Radiation Mechanics PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE
This page intentionally left blank
Radiation Mechanics PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE
ESAM M. A. HUSSEIN Department of Mechanical Engineering University of New Brunswick Fredericton, N.B. Canada
Amsterdam • Boston • Heidelberg • London • New York • Oxford Paris • San Diego • San Francisco • Singapore • Sydney • Tokyo
Elsevier The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington, Oxford OX5 1GB, UK Radarweg 29, PO Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands First edition 2007 Copyright © 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior written permission of the publisher Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Science & Technology Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone (+44) (0) 1865 843830; fax (+44) (0) 1865 853333; email:
[email protected]. Alternatively you can submit your request online by visiting the Elsevier web site at http://elsevier.com/locate/permissions, and selecting Obtaining permission to use Elsevier material Notice No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress For information on all Elsevier publications visit our web site at books.elsevier.com Typeset by Charon Tec Ltd (A Macmillan Company), Chennai, India www.charontec.com Printed and bound in Great Britain 07 08 09 10 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 ISBN: 978-0-0804-5053-7
To my two Amina’s: Mother and Daughter Dedicated in memory of: Uncle Ahmed Sabry Abdel-Ghaffar Uncle Mohammad Ali Abu-Hussein
This page intentionally left blank
CONTENTS
Preface List of Algorithms
xi xv
1. Mechanisms
1
1.1 1.2
1.3
1.4
1.5
1.6
1.7
1.8
Introduction Radiation 1.2.1 Neutral particles 1.2.2 Charged particles 1.2.3 Photons Wave–Particle Duality 1.3.1 Corpuscular nature of waves 1.3.2 Wave nature of particles 1.3.3 Uncertainty principle Nuclear/Atomic Fields 1.4.1 Potential field 1.4.2 Nuclear strong-force field 1.4.3 Nuclear weak-force field 1.4.4 Electromagnetic field 1.4.5 Quantum states Atom and Nucleus 1.5.1 Atomic structure 1.5.2 Nuclear structure Nuclear Decay 1.6.1 Kinetics 1.6.2 Statistics 1.6.3 Alpha decay 1.6.4 Beta decay 1.6.5 Gamma decay 1.6.6 Internal conversion 1.6.7 Spontaneous fission 1.6.8 Decay by neutron or proton emission Reactions and Interactions 1.7.1 Interaction with atomic electrons 1.7.2 Interaction with electric field of atom 1.7.3 Nuclear interactions Macroscopic Field 1.8.1 Transport space 1.8.2 Particle density and flux
1 3 3 5 5 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 14 16 19 19 20 26 27 28 29 32 36 37 38 39 40 40 45 46 53 54 55 vii
viii
Contents
1.9
1.8.3 Atomic/nuclear density 1.8.4 Interaction rate Problems
2. Collision Kinematics 2.1 2.2 2.3
2.4
2.5
2.6 2.7
2.8
2.9
Overview Center-of-Mass System Relativity 2.3.1 Special theory of relativity 2.3.2 Center of relativistic mass 2.3.3 Lorentz transformation of momentum and energy Conservation Laws 2.4.1 Stoichiometric conservation 2.4.2 Intrinsic conservation 2.4.3 Kinematical conservation Einsteinian Kinematics 2.5.1 Two-body kinematics 2.5.2 Analysis using invariants 2.5.3 Non-elastic interactions 2.5.4 Non-relativistic approximation Newtonian Kinematics Specific Interactions 2.7.1 Elastic scattering 2.7.2 Inelastic scattering 2.7.3 Non-elastic collisions Electromagnetic Interactions 2.8.1 Coulomb scattering 2.8.2 Radiative collisions 2.8.3 Diffraction Problems
3. Cross Sections 3.1 3.2
3.3
Introduction Nuclear Cross-Section Models 3.2.1 Optical model 3.2.2 Compound nucleus 3.2.3 Continuum theory 3.2.4 Evaporation 3.2.5 Stripping 3.2.6 Photonuclear reactions 3.2.7 Nucleonic collisions Neutron Cross Sections 3.3.1 Elastic scattering 3.3.2 Inelastic scattering
57 58 60
67 67 68 74 74 78 79 80 81 81 82 83 83 93 98 103 104 108 109 114 116 123 123 133 144 146
153 153 156 156 162 165 165 166 166 168 168 169 172
ix
Contents
3.4
3.5
3.6
3.7
3.8
3.3.3 Radiative capture 3.3.4 Fission 3.3.5 Charged-particle production 3.3.6 Energy and angular distribution 3.3.7 Thermal neutrons Electrodynamics 3.4.1 Quantum electrodynamics 3.4.2 Feynman diagrams Photon Cross Sections 3.5.1 Thomson scattering 3.5.2 Compton scattering 3.5.3 Rayleigh scattering 3.5.4 Diffraction 3.5.5 Photoelectric effect 3.5.6 Pair production 3.5.7 Triplet production 3.5.8 Delbruck scattering Charged-Particle Cross Sections 3.6.1 Coulomb scattering 3.6.2 Rutherford scattering 3.6.3 Mott scattering 3.6.4 Bremsstrahlung 3.6.5 Moller scattering 3.6.6 Bhabha scattering 3.6.7 Pair annihilation Data Libraries and Processing 3.7.1 Libraries 3.7.2 Processing and manipulation 3.7.3 Compound and mixture cross sections Problems
4. Transport 4.1
4.2
Boltzmann Transport Equation 4.1.1 Basics 4.1.2 Transport in void 4.1.3 Divergence law 4.1.4 Attenuation law 4.1.5 Point kernel 4.1.6 Diffusion theory 4.1.7 Adjoint transport equation Modal Solution Methods 4.2.1 P 1 approximation 4.2.2 Diffusion equation 4.2.3 Numerical solution and computer codes
173 174 174 175 179 183 183 189 194 195 197 203 204 205 208 213 213 215 215 217 219 220 224 226 227 229 229 232 237 238
247 247 247 251 252 254 255 256 257 259 262 264 266
x
Contents
4.3
4.4
4.5
4.6
Nodal Solution Methods 4.3.1 Discretization of directions: discrete ordinates 4.3.2 Discretization of time, energy, and space 4.3.3 Multigroup approximation 4.3.4 Discretization of transport equation 4.3.5 Curved geometries 4.3.6 Source term 4.3.7 Solution of S n equations 4.3.8 Computer codes Stochastic Methods 4.4.1 Introduction 4.4.2 Random variables and statistical basis 4.4.3 Abstract analysis 4.4.4 Random numbers 4.4.5 Random number generation 4.4.6 Sampling 4.4.7 Particle transport 4.4.8 Example 4.4.9 Computer codes Transport of Charged Particles 4.5.1 Special features 4.5.2 Stopping power and range 4.5.3 Transport Problems
266 267 270 273 273 275 278 279 283 284 284 285 286 292 292 293 296 302 305 306 306 307 307 308
Bibliography Constants and Units
311 315
Useful Web Sites Glossary Index
319 321 323
PREFACE
The word “radiation’’ refers to electromagnetic waves (at various frequencies), atomic emissions (X-rays), or nuclear decay and reaction products (alpha and beta particles, gamma rays, neutrons, positrons, etc.). Conventional optical principles are used to describe the behavior of electromagnetic radiation in the form of visible light, while the concepts of radiative heat transfer are utilized when dealing with thermal (infrared) radiation. These relatively simplistic principles along with the more elegant analysis of electromagnetic radiation using the Maxwell equations are appropriate when a large number of photons are involved, and wave characteristics are the norm. At very high frequencies (in the range of Xand γ-rays), electromagnetic radiation exhibits corpuscular properties, and conventional particle mechanics (conservation of energy and momentum) become directly applicable. The transport, as a collective, of these particle-like photons is governed by the Boltzmann transport equation. Similarly neutral radiation particles (neutrons) abide by conservation laws and the transport equation. However, when characterizing the dynamics of neutron interactions with the nucleus, wave (quantum) mechanics is utilized. At low energy, neutrons exhibit wave properties, and the wave nature of radiation still prevails. Particles carrying an electric charge (such as alpha and beta particles, or protons) are affected by the Coulomb forces of the atom and its nucleus as they traverse matter, and as such do not penetrate deep into matter. They can, however, trigger the generation of a chain of electrons in the form of a “shower’’ that can propagate further into matter. Electrons, being light in mass, can acquire a speed that approaches the speed of light, then relativistic effects become pronounced and must be taken into account. It is obvious from the above preamble that the mechanics of atomic/nuclear radiation involves many physical effects. At the time of writing this book and to the author’s knowledge, there was no single textbook that covers all these aspects. While a classical book such as that of Evans [1] covers the basic interactions and mechanisms, it does not tackle the transport theory and in essence considers a single interaction of a radiation entity with matter at a time. On the other hand, a book on transport theory, such as that of Davison [2], concerns itself with the mathematical aspects of the transport theory. Applied textbooks, such as those concerned with reactor theory [3, 4], radiation detection and measurement [5, 6], radiation shielding [7, 8], or radiation-based devices [9], tend to focus on the aspects that specifically relate to the subject of interest. Students of the field formulate an overall understanding of radiation behavior from individual subjects, ranging from basic nuclear physics and quantum mechanics to radiation transport theory and computations. This work integrates these aspects of radiation behavior in a single treatise under the framework of “radiation mechanics’’, in the same manner all aspects of fluid flow are covered under the subject of “fluid xi
xii
Preface
mechanics’’, and stress analysis is addressed under “solid mechanics’’ or “mechanics of materials’’. Mechanics is the science of studying energy and forces, and their effects on matter. It involves (1) mechanisms, (2) kinematics, (3) cross sections, and (4) transport. Mechanisms describe how various types of radiation interact with different targets (atoms and nuclei). Kinematics studies particle motion via conservation of energy and momentum, albeit taking into account energy stored within the target, along with any relativistic effects which become pronounced at high particle speeds. Therefore, kinematics determines the energy and direction of radiation following a certain interaction. A reaction cross section is a measure of the probability of occurrence of a certain interaction, at given kinematic (energy and direction) attributes. Interaction cross sections are determined by the interaction “amplitudes’’, as dictated by the “potential field’’ of the target and its effect on the incoming radiation. Quantum mechanics provides a mathematical framework for obtaining these amplitudes, the square of which (properly normalized) defines a cross section. The transport (spread and distribution of radiation from one location to another and its evolution with time) is determined by bookkeeping principles via the particle transport theory. The book addresses the above four aspects of radiation mechanics in four separate chapters. The first two chapters can be covered in a one-semester course, and the latter two chapters in a subsequent semester. However, students with some background in modern and nuclear physics can skip Chapter 1, and each of the other three chapters can be presented in any order, since they are reasonably independent of each other. At the end of each chapter a set of problems is presented to further assist students in understanding the underlying concepts. Use of computations and Internet resources1 are included in the problems as much as possible. Instructors can approach the author at
[email protected] for a copy of the solutions manual for the problems in this book. In order to enable the reader to navigate through this book, one interaction at a time,Table 1 below provides a summary of all the relevant interactions and refers to the pages in this book where they are defined, their kinematics are addressed, and their cross sections are presented. This book was written using LATEX, based on MiKTEXplatform, with WinTEX XP as the interfacing editor. Special thanks to Mr. John T. Bowles for proof reading the text of the four chapters of the book. Esam Hussein Fredericton, N.B. Canada December, 2006
1
Uniform resource locators (URL’S) in this book refer to web sites that were active at the time of finalizing this work. Such web sites may change location and content, or disappear altogether. Readers are advised to do an Internet search under the relevant topic, if a URL ceases to be accessible.
xiii
Preface
Table 1 List of radiation interactions: numbers indicate the page number in which a particular aspect of an interaction is addressed
Interaction
Mechanism
Kinematics
Anomalous scattering
Cross section 196
Bremsstrahlung
46
136
220
Cerenkov radiation
45
141
Compton scattering
42
112
197
Delbruck scattering
53
143
213
Diffraction
43
144
183, 204
Elastic scattering: • Anomalous • Bhabha • Coulomb • Moller • Mott • Neutron/nuclear • Potential • Rayleigh • Rutherford • Thomson
43 43, 48 43 43, 49 47 47 42 49 43, 49
113 123, 129 113 113 109 140 131 139
196 226 215 224 219,225 156,169 159 203 217 195
Fission
51
122
174
Inelastic Scattering: • Compton • Coulomb • Neutron/nuclear • Thermal neutron
42 44 50 179
112 132 114 179
197 215 172, 180 179
Pair production
45, 53
118
208
Photoabsorption (Photoelectric effect)
41
117
205
Positron annihilation
44
116
227
Potential scattering
47
Production (nuclear): • Charged particle • Neutron
52 52
159 119 120
174, 179 177 (Continued )
xiv
Preface
Table 1
(Cont.)
Interaction
Mechanism
Kinematics
Cross section
Radiative capture
51
119
173, 178
Rayleigh scattering
42
140
203
Resonance scattering
49
Spallation
51
Thomson scattering
43, 49
139
Transition radiation
46
143
Triplet production
42
118
169
195
213
LIST OF ALGORITHMS
• •
Relativistic kinematics of a two-body interaction: 2(1,3)4 Invariant-based kinematics of a two-body interaction: 2(1,3)4
92 96
This page intentionally left blank
C H A P T E R
O N E
Mechanisms
Contents 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9
Introduction Radiation Wave–Particle Duality Nuclear/Atomic Fields Atom and Nucleus Nuclear Decay Reactions and Interactions Macroscopic Field Problems
1 3 7 11 19 26 40 53 60
1.1 Introduction Mechanics is the study of forces and energy and their effect on matter, it is also the study of mechanisms. Radiation mechanics then involves: 1. Understanding the mechanisms via which radiation interacts with a target atom/nucleus and how the target reacts. 2. Studying the kinematics of an interaction via the conservation of momentum and energy. 3. Determining the probability of interaction of a certain radiation entity, having a certain energy with a particular atom/nucleus (cross sections). 4. Modeling the transport of a flux of these entities into a medium. Figure 1.1 illustrates these concepts schematically for a scattering mechanism. In the Figure, a particle (or an equivalent wave packet) approaches the nuclear field, and its associated electric (Coulomb) field. These fields change the particle’s energy and direction, i.e. the particle is scattered. The energy of the emerging particle is determined by the kinematics of scattering. The probability that the particle will emerge in any specific direction is dictated by the potential field of the target nucleus and its effect on the incoming particle. This particle will continue to move in the medium causing different types of interactions with many target nuclei, until it is absorbed or escapes from the domain of interest. The Radiation Mechanics: Principles & Practice ISBN-13: 978-0-08-045053-7
© 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1
2
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
E(ϑ) Mechanism (scattering) E0
Particle (wave packet)
ϑ
Nuclear field
Kinematics: E(ϑ)
Coulomb field
Excited state Potential field Ground state
Transport
Figure 1.1 A schematic view of the mechanics of a radiation interaction: a scattering mechanism, the kinematics of which determines the outgoing energy, E(ϑ), based on the incoming energy, E0 , and the angle of scattering, ϑ; while the potential field governs the probability of scattering by ϑ to E(ϑ). A sequence of scattering events results in the transport of many particles in a medium of many atoms/nuclei.
collective movement of these particles in a medium is called particle transport. In Fig. 1.1, the particle could have been replaced with a photon and the target with an atom, or even a single atomic electron, and the same three aspects of particle mechanics will still emerge. These aspects are discussed in this book. Chapter 2 deals with interaction kinematics. The cross sections of interactions are discussed in Chapter 3. The particle transport process is analyzed in Chapter 4. In this chapter, the basic mechanisms affecting the behavior of each type of radiation addressed in this book are examined. The chapter begins by introducing the various forms of radiation, and identifying the ones that evince corpuscular (that of a minute particle) properties, which are the main subject of this book. Since nuclear/atomic radiation can assume both wave and particle characteristics, the concept of wave–particle duality is introduced. The information given in this chapter is quite basic and can be found in more detail in nuclear and atomic physics textbooks such as those of [1, 10–16]. The natural atomic/nuclear fields involved in the formation of the atom and its nucleus, to which radiation particles
3
1.2 Radiation
are exposed, are then reviewed, followed by an examination of the structure of the atom and the nucleus, and the nuclear decay processes. The types of interactions radiation can encounter upon approaching these fields are subsequently classified. After studying individual radiation particles and the individual target atoms/nuclei they interact with, we take a macroscopic point-of-view by involving many radiation particles with a medium containing many atoms/nuclei. This defines the space within which radiation transport takes place. Note that this book is not concerned with high-energy particle physics, a field that deals with studying the fundamental constituents of matter, though some of the concepts introduced are suited for use with high-energy particles.
1.2 Radiation This book deals with three types of radiation as outlined in Table 1.1.
1.2.1 Neutral particles A particle by definition carries a mass. Einstein (1905), through the special theory of relativity, introduced an energy term corresponding to the mass, m0 , of a particle when it is at rest; (see Section 2.3), the so-called rest-mass energy: Rest-mass energy = m0 c 2
(fundamental equation)
(1.1)
where c is the speed of light. This is a fundamental relationship, not derivable from other relations, just like Newton’s laws of motion. A number of these fundamental relationships will be identified throughout this chapter. The introduction of the rest-mass energy enables the accommodation of changes within the target atom and nucleus that involve changes in mass and energy.
Neutrinos and antineutrinos The neutral particle of interest in this book is the neutron. There is, however, another elementary particle called the neutrino, which is discussed here because Table 1.1 Types of nuclear/atomic radiation
Radiation
Rest mass
Electric charge
Neutral particles
>0
=0
Neutrinos (ν), neutrons (n)
Charged particles
>0
=0
Beta electrons (β− ), beta positrons (β+ ), alpha (α), protons (p), ions
Photons
=0
=0
X-rays, gamma-rays (γ)
4
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
of the role it plays in the β-decay process. A neutrino (referred to as ν) has very little mass (less then a few eV rest-mass energy)1 , if any, and is not affected much by the strong nuclear forces (see Section 1.4). As such, neutrinos are highly penetrating as they interact weakly with matter. It is, therefore, difficult to detect neutrinos, or harness their use in practical applications. A neutrino serves to conserve momentum and energy in decay processes involving the emission of positive (positron, β+ ) or negative (electron, β− ) beta rays. These nuclear decay processes, unlike those of gamma decay, exhibit a continuous, rather than a discrete, energy distribution, although both decay processes are associated with discrete transitions in energy from one nuclear state to another. The neutrino shares a portion of the released energy with the emitted beta particle, causing the energy distribution to be continuous, as that portion can vary from nothing to the entire decay energy. The conservation of momentum in the β-decay process requires also the emission of a neutrino at 180◦ from the emitted β-particle. The neutrino associated with β− decay is known as an antineutrino, while that associated with β+ decay is called a neutrino. In fact the antineutrino is the antimatter counterpart of the neutrino, in the sense that the particles annihilate each other if they ever coexist at the same location and the same time. The spin of a neutrino is opposite its linear momentum, i.e. it follows the orientation of the fingers of the left hand when wrapped around the vector of the linear momentum with the thumb pointing along the direction of the linear momentum. On the other hand, the spin of the antineutrino is “right-handed’’.
Neutrons The neutron is an elementary particle with a mass, mn , of about 1.675 × 10−27 kg or 1.0087 u, where u is the atomic mass unit2 , and an equivalent rest-mass energy, mn c 2 = 939.6 MeV (≈1 GeV). A free neutron has a half-life of about 615 s, as it decays by emitting a β− particle and an antineutrino, and in the process transmutes itself into a proton. Therefore, neutrons do not naturally exist, but are produced as a result of other nuclear interactions, nuclear decay, or fission. Because of its neutral charge, a neutron easily reaches the nucleus, without being obstructed by electric forces. Neutron reactions are, therefore, interactions with the nucleus, rather than with atomic electrons. Though the neutron has no electrical charge, it has an intrinsic angular momentum and a magnetic moment. These minute magnetic properties are due to the electric charge of the three fundamental moving particles (quarks), from which the neutron is assumed to be constituted. The neutron is composed of two down quarks and one up quark. An up (U) quark has a charge of 23 e and a down (D) quark has a − 13 e charge, where e is the electronic charge (see Glossary for the definition of quarks). At very low energy (in the meV range), neutrons exhibit strong wave characteristics that are employed in 1 eV
is unit of energy (see Glossary at the end of the book) conventionally used in radiation mechanics to reflect the small amount of energy carried by radiation entities (1 eV = 1.602 × 10−19 J). 2 1 u = 1 th of the mass of 12 C ≡ 931.494 MeV in rest-mass energy. 12
5
1.2 Radiation
studying the crystal structure of matter. These neutrons are known as “cold neutrons’’, to distinguish them from the “thermal’’ neutrons, which have an energy corresponding to the temperature of the medium in which they propagate (see Section 3.3.7).
1.2.2 Charged particles The term charged particles refers to electrons (e− ), positrons (e+ ), protons (p), and the positive ions of any atom, including that of the 4 He atom which is known as the alpha (α) particle. The electric charge of each particle is defined in terms of the charge of one electron (e); a fundamental constant called the elementary charge (1 e = 1.602 × 10−19 C). Charged particles are classified as light particles (electrons, positrons) and heavy particles (protons, α particles, and other ions). The Glossary at the end of this book gives the charge and mass of common charged particles. When these particles move at a speed much larger than the velocities of thermal motion, they are referred to as “swift’’ particles. These swift particles are those of interest in this book.
1.2.3 Photons A photon is a quantum of electromagnetic energy. It can be thought of as a packet of waves consolidating together within a confined space as shown in Fig. 1.2. This packet of energy has no mass, no electric charge, and an indefinitely long lifetime, but it exhibits the characteristics of a discrete particle. The energy of a photon, E, is related to the frequency, ν, of its electromagnetic wave by the Planck constant, h (= 4.135667 × 10−15 eV/s), so that: E = hν
(fundamental equation)
(1.2)
The photons we are interested in here are those that have sufficient energy to change the physical status of an atom, say by exciting its electrons or ionizing it by stripping one of its electrons. The electron-binding energy of the tightest bound electron (those in the shell closest to the nucleus, K shell) is in the range
Figure 1.2 A wave packet formed by waves consolidating together within a confined space.
6
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
Table 1.2 Wavelength, frequency, and photon energy of various forms of electromagnetic radiation
Radiation
Wavelength (m)
Frequency (Hz)
Energy (eV)
ULFa
108
3 × 100
10−14
ELFb
107
3 × 101
10−13
VFc
106
3 × 102
10−12
Communicationsd
105
3 × 103
10−11
Microwave
10−2
3 × 1010
10−4
Infrared
10−3
3 × 1011
10−3
Visible light
7.6 × 10−7
4 × 1014
1.63
Ultraviolet
3.8 × 10−7
8 × 1014
3.26
Soft X-ray
10−8
3 × 1016
102
Hard X-raye
10−10
3 × 1018
104
Gamma-raye
10−12
3 × 1020
106
a
Ultra low frequency. Extremely low frequency. Voice (telephone) frequency. d Includes VLF (very low frequency) waves, used for instance in submarine communications, radio waves, and the UHF (ultra high frequency) waves of TV channels. e X- and γ-rays are distinguished by their origin; the former from electronic effects while the latter is due to nuclear excitation. The given range is only indicative, as the two types of radiation overlap in range. b c
from 13.6 eV (for H) to 121.76 eV (for Pu)3 . Therefore, our interest here is in electromagnetic radiation with an energy in the tens of eVs, so that they can reach the bound electron in the inner electronic shells. Obviously, for photons to affect the nucleus, they must have much higher energy to overcome the barrier of atomic electrons. As Table 1.2 shows, only radiation in the upper range of the ultraviolet (UV) waves and above has sufficient energy to affect bound atomic electrons. However, given the relatively long wavelength of ultraviolet radiation and soft (low energy) X-rays (10−8 to 10−10 m), in comparison to the size of the atom (about 10−11 m), UV and soft X-ray photons tend to behave more like waves than particles when encountering the atom. With this wave behavior, no energy is deposited within the atom and the waves are reflected, refracted, diffracted, or Doppler shifted in 3 See
http://www.webelements.com/webelements/elements/text/periodic-table/bind.html for the electron-binding energies of atomic shells in various elements, which reports a maximum value of 115.606 keV for U, and http://www.csrri.iit.edu/periodic-table.html which includes information on the energy edges for X-ray emission up to Pu.
7
1.3 Wave–Particle Duality
a manner similar to an optical wave. However, in the smaller wavelength of soft X-rays, the radiation wavelength becomes comparable in value to the spacing distance between atoms. Therefore, soft X-rays can provide useful information on lattice structures from the diffraction patterns of incident waves. This raises, however, the question of whether photons are particles or waves (see Section 1.3).
X- and γ-rays X-rays are the photons produced electronically, by fast electrons bombarding an electron-rich target. X-ray generators can be common X-ray tubes or powerful electron accelerators (linear accelerators (linacs) or synchrotrons). Gamma (γ) rays are the photons emitted during the decay of a radioactive material. Since an electron bombarding a target slows down gradually, it emits a continuous spectrum extending in energy from an energy equal to the energy of the incident electron to zero energy. X-rays have, therefore, a continuous energy distribution. γ-ray photons have, on the other hand, discrete energies, as they correspond to certain transitions between the excitation levels of a nucleus.
1.3 Wave–Particle Duality Before discussing the concept of wave–particle duality, let us examine the general characteristics of waves and particles, and the concept of duality.
Waves A wave is characterized by a frequency, ν, and a wavelength, λ, related such that: c = νλ
(fundamental equation)
(1.3)
where c is the speed of the wave, which is equal to the speed of light in the case of electromagnetic radiation. A wave propagates and exists in all locations and at all times. For instance a sine wave is expressed by the function A sin(ωt + kx), where A is the amplitude of the wave, k = 2π λ is its wave number, and ω = 2πν, is its angular velocity. This wave repeats itself every 2π within a period of T = 2π ν . A more complex waveform can be constructed by a linear summation of sine waves, with different frequencies. When two waves interact, they can interfere with each other constructively (increasing the resultant amplitude) or destructively. A wave can also change its amplitude when encountering a change in the medium in which it propagates, and it can be phase-shifted (its period displaced) in the process. Subsequently, the phenomena of reflection, refraction, diffraction, and Doppler shifting are observed with waves.
8
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
Particles Unlike a wave, a particle is a consolidated discrete uniform entity with an energy concentrated within a well-defined finite and confined space with definite boundaries.Therefore, a particle exists at a specific location at a certain time, and can only move to a new position in space under the external influence of a force or a potential field. Hence, a particle, unlike a wave, can change its speed, and consequently can be accelerated or decelerated. When a particle collides with another particle, the interaction between the two is governed by the principles of conservation of momentum and energy.
Duality Duality of wave and particle means that an entity can possess the quality or state of having corpuscular or wave properties. This has been observed, for instance, in the case of light photons which at the frequency range of ultraviolet radiation or higher can behave as particles that collide with atomic electrons and liberate them. Then an electric current can be driven by applying an external voltage, as in the case of photocells. On the other hand, particles such as electrons are known to produce diffraction patterns in a grating, similar to those observed with light. In fact, electron microscopes work on the premise that electrons function as waves providing a resolution on the order of their wave length, 10−12 m or less; a resolution much better than that the 10−6 m, or so, of an optical microscope. In order to be able to express the corpuscular behavior of electromagnetic waves and the wave behavior of particles, the concept of wave–particle duality was devised.
1.3.1 Corpuscular nature of waves The concept of a wave exhibiting particle behavior is better explained by the expanded definition of energy, E, to include the rest-mass energy of Eq. (1.1), so that: E = T + m0 c 2
(1.4)
where T refers to the kinetic energy. This expression accommodates a particle with zero mass. A zero-mass particle can be used to express the corpuscular properties of a wave. This “particle’’ is called a photon, and it has only a kinetic energy equal, according to Eq. (1.2), to: T = E = hν =
hc λ
(1.5)
While this takes care of the energy of the photon, we must also give that photon a momentum, p, so that it can possess all the attributes of a particle. Since this photon “particle’’ has no mass, we cannot use the classical definition of moment as mass × velocity. We can rely instead on the relativistic definition of momentum,
9
1.3 Wave–Particle Duality
discussed in Section 2.3, pc =
E 2 − (m0 c 2 )2
(1.6)
For a photon: E hν h = = (1.7) c νλ λ Equations (1.5) and (1.7) give an electromagnetic wave kinetic energy and momentum values, which in turn enable us to use the laws of conservation of energy and momentum of particles. Note that the momentum is a vector with a direction corresponding to the direction of wave propagation. p=
1.3.2 Wave nature of particles In order for a particle to behave like a wave, it needs to have a frequency, ν, and a wavelength, λ, so that νλ = v, where v is the particle’s velocity. One must also accommodate the fact that while a wave tends to extend across the entire space, as in the case of a sine wave, a particle is concentrated within a small region in space. This confinement of space can be accommodated using the fact that waves interfere constructively and destructively, and that interference can be formed such that the waves combine into a packet (or a beat, as it is called in the case of sound waves), as shown in Fig. 1.2; see also Problem 1.2 and the Wave Packet Explorer: http://phys.educ.ksu.edu/vqm/html/wpe.html on the Internet. We will demonstrate this by simply taking two sinusoidal waves, sin(k − k)x and sin(k + k)x, propagating in the x direction with wave numbers k − k and k + k, respectively. The combination of these two waves gives: sin(k − k)x + sin(k + k)x = 2 sin(kx) cos( k x)
(1.8)
It is obvious that the combined wave has a wave number equal to the average of the two waves, and consequently oscillates at the average of the two frequencies, 2πν since k = 2π λ = v . The cosine term in the combined wave can be seen as a gradual modulator of the amplitude of the sine wave, which initially strengthens the combined wave, but tends to destroy it as the two combined waves become completely out of phase. The result is that the energy of the two waves is consolidated into a “beat’’ within a distance of about x. Note that the two combined waves will again become in phase, and the beat will periodically re-emerge. If a wide range of wave numbers is taken, the quality (concentration) of the beat is improved, and its length, x, is reduced. In the limit, when a continuous distribution of waves of various values of k, spread over a range, k, are combined, one obtains a wave packet similar to that shown in Fig. 1.2, and the combined waves will never become in phase again since they have many different values of k. That is, the wave packet will not be repeated and will be confined within a distance of x, so that x k ∼ 1. Now, we have a localized wave packet that resembles a particle in its confinement to a finite space. What remains is to relate the kinetic energy and momentum of the particle to its wave packet. Before we do this, it
10
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
should be kept in mind that the above argument can be repeated for a wave propagating in time (using waves of the form: sin ωt), resulting in the confinement of the wave packet within a time interval, t ω ∼ 1. We can link the mass and velocity of a particle to the wavelength, λ, and the corresponding wave number, k, of the associated wave, using de Broglie’s relationship (L. de Broglie, 1924) of duality between particle and wave: λ=
2π h = k p
(fundamental equation)
(1.9)
where p is the momentum of the particle. Note that this relationship is identical to that of Eq. (1.2) for photons, though the latter was derived for photons (zero mass), and that Eq. (1.9) cannot be derived from Eq. (1.6) due to the non-zero particle mass, m0 . As such Eq. (1.9) is another fundamental relationship. Similarly, the energy of the particle, E, can be related to the frequency of its associated wave using Eq. (1.2): hv E = hν = (1.10) λ
1.3.3 Uncertainty principle There is a problem with using a single wave number, and frequency, as Eqs (1.9) and (1.10) indicate, while using a wave packet to resemble a particle. A wave packet, as indicated earlier, is the result of the combination of many waves of various wave numbers within k around k; while the above-mentioned equations designate one value of k; a particle can have only one momentum, p, at a given point in space. This dilemma is resolved by the Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle, which states that a particle’s momentum is uncertain until it is measured. This is a logical statement, as it says one cannot know the value of the momentum or any other physical property until one measures it. The uncertainty principle has profound implications. It enables a wave packet to possess the many values of k needed for its formation, while only a single value of k, hence a single value for p, can be measured. This is because the measurement process is an intrusive process that requires some perturbation of the physical property of the particle in order to measure its attributes. For instance, in order to measure the position of a particle such as an electron, one can send a high-energy photon (say an X-ray) and observe its reflection. This X-ray wave will, however, give energy to the electron and in effect change its momentum. On the other hand, if we send a low-energy photon (e.g. a light wave) to precisely measure the momentum, one would get a fuzzy picture of the particle and its position becomes more uncertain. Therefore, in order to know exactly the value of x, one cannot determine the value of k (the range of the wave numbers forming the wave packet), or equivalently the particle’s momentum. The opposite is also true, to measure k, the value of x will be uncertain. This effect is already demonstrated by the fact that x k ∼ 1. 2π From Eq. (1.9), k = 2πp h , hence k = h p. The uncertainty (or indeterminacy)
11
1.4 Nuclear/Atomic Fields
principle (W. Heisenberg, 1927) states that:
x p ≥
h 2π
(1.11)
h is often referred to as . Note that the above inequality The quantity 2π confines the precision with which a quantity can be measured along with its complementary variable4 . Another form of this principle is:
t E ≥
(1.12)
The above form of Heisenberg’s principle indicates that certainty in time comes at the expense of uncertainty in energy, and vice versa. The small value of makes this principle practically irrelevant when dealing with large objects. Given the above discussion one may ask the questions: Is a diffracted neutron a wave? Is a scattered photon imparting kinetic energy to an electron a particle? The concept of wave–particle duality answers these questions by the fact that all radiation entities (particles or photons) evince at times wave-like characteristics and at other times corpuscular behavior. In other words, these entities appear to us, the observers, as particles in some interactions and as waves in others. The wave nature of particles is used to explain the interaction probabilities as discussed in Chapter 3. The term particle is, therefore, often used metaphorically to refer to all subatomic entities.
1.4 Nuclear/Atomic Fields There are four basic natural forces: (1) the force of gravity, (2) electromagnetic forces (3) the strong nuclear force, and (4) the weak nuclear force. Since the particles we deal with here are minute, the effect of gravity is negligible, hence the use of the term corpuscular properties. The other forces create potential fields that can affect approaching nuclear particles. A natural potential field is seen as an interaction between two entities mediated by some exchange particle. For the field of gravity, the exchange particle is thought to be yet undetectable virtual particle with zero mass called the “graviton’’. Photons are the particles mediating the electromagnetic field. The strong nuclear forces are mediated by unstable nuclear particles called pions (a type of mesons; see Glossary), with an energy of 135 MeV, while intermediate vector bosons of energy of about 80 GeV mediate the weak nuclear forces. The intermediate vector bosons are particles that exist for an extremely short period of 4 If the uncertainties x and p are taken as the standard deviation (±σ) of the position and momentum measurements, h respectively, then x p = 4π . In Eq. (1.11) the uncertainty is taken to be the smallest range in a normal distribution that contains 50% of the observed values (i.e. between ±0.67σ). The ratio between the certainty levels should be 0.672 = 0.45, but a value of 0.5 is tolerated by the inequality.
12
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
time to facilitate an interaction. They erupt from the vacuum momentarily, borrowing energy which is paid back upon their annihilation. The mean lifetime of these exchange particles is limited by the uncertainty principle, the inequality of (1.12), with E equal to the exchanged energy. Taking the speed of light as the ultimate speed of these exchange particles, one can determine the range of each of these natural forces. It can be easily shown that the range, R, is given by: R=
c 0.2 × 10−12 (MeVm) ≈ mc 2 mc 2
(1.13)
where mc 2 is the rest-mass energy of the exchange particle. Since the exchange forces in the gravitational and electromagnetic forces have a zero mass, the range of these forces is infinite. For the strong nuclear force, the range is about 10−15 m (1 fm) (equal to the diameter of a medium-size nucleus), while that of the weak force is 10−18 m (1 am).
1.4.1 Potential field The potential energy, V (r), between two entities separated by a distance, r, from any of these four natural forces can, in general, be expressed as: V (r) = ∓A2
exp (−r) r
(1.14)
where the negative value signifies a potential well (producing a force of attraction) while the positive sign indicates a repulsion force, A2 is the strength of the interaction, called the coupling constant, r refers to the distance from the center of the field, and m is the mass of the mediating particle. Table 1.3 gives A2 values for the various forces between two protons. A dimensionless fine structure constant5 can be used to define the inherent strength of a field. For the strong nuclear force, the fine structure constant is equal to about unity, while that for the weak fore is in the range from 10−6 to 10−7 . For the electromagnetic forces, the A2 1 , with A2em being fine structure constant is denoted by α, given by α = emc = 137 the coupling constant. For gravity, a fine structure constant can be defined in a A2
manner analogous to α as cg ≈ 5.9 × 10−39 , where A2g is the coupling constant for gravity between two protons. It is obvious that for radiation particles such as protons, the effect of gravity is so weak in comparison to the effect of the other three forces that it is ignored. Therefore, only the other fields are discussed in associated with the potential energy some details below. Note that the force, F, is determined by V = ∇ · F. 5 The
value of the fine structure constant is not directly related to any obvious physical effect, but is observed when examining finer detail of the physical process involved.
13
1.4 Nuclear/Atomic Fields
Table 1.3 Strength and range of natural fields between two protons∗
∗
Field
Exchange particle (mc2 )
Coupling constant, A2 (eV m)
Range (m)
Fine structure constant
Gravity
Graviton (0)
1.17 × 10−45
∞
Electromagnetic
Photon (0)
1.44 × 10−09
∞
5.9 × 10−39 1 137
Strong nuclear
Pion (135 MeV)
1.56 × 10−08
1.5 × 10−15
1
Weak nuclear
Intermediate vector Boson (91 GeV)
2.01 × 10−12
2 × 10−18
3 × 10−7
Guide to Nuclear Wallchart, Chapter 4, Four Fundamental Interactions, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, 2000: http://www.lbl.gov/abc/wallchart/chapters/04/0.html, accessed October, 2004.
Pion
Nucleon
Nucleon
Figure 1.3 A schematic of the nuclear strong force.
1.4.2 Nuclear strong-force field This field exists between the nucleons (protons and neutrons) of the nucleus, and produces a force stronger than the Coulomb repulsion force between protons. The field has, however, a very short range (about 10−15 mm), and as such affects only particles approaching a nucleus. The strong nuclear force is what keeps the nucleons together. The strong nuclear force is created by the exchange of a meson (pion) between two nucleons, as schematically shown in Fig. 1.3. This field can affect an incoming radiation particle as long as the particle can reach within the range of the field around the nucleus. The neutron is the particle with greatest ability to reach the nucleus within the range of this field, since being a neutral particle it is not affected by the electromagnetic force created by the protons of the atom. The very short range of this potential has the effect that a nucleon inside the nucleus is primarily affected by its immediate neighbor. In essence, every nucleon inside a nucleus is subjected to the same field strength, and subsequently the field of the strong nuclear force can be represented by a flat potential well. The short range of the strong nuclear forces tends also to produce a uniform distribution of nuclear matter inside the nucleus, and as such the volume of a nucleus (which defines the width of its potential field) is proportional to the number of nucleons in the nucleus, i.e. its mass number (A). Subsequently, the radius, R, of a nucleus
14
Chapter 1 Mechanisms 1
is proportional to A 3 , or: 1
R = R0 A 3
(1.15)
where R0 = 1.2−15 m = 1.2 fm. This assumption of uniform distribution of nuclear matter leads to a nuclear density of 2.3 × 1017 kg/m3 .
1.4.3 Nuclear weak-force field The weak nuclear force is mediated by the exchange of massive fundamental particles known as the intermediate vector bosons (fundamental particles of a rest-mass energy greater than 80 GeV). Their range, according to Eq. (1.13), is on the order of 10−18 m (about 0.1% of the diameter of a proton). The weak nuclear force, as the name implies, is more feeble than that of the strong force. These weak forces are responsible for the decay of free neutrons and for beta decay; both involve the emergence of neutrinos and electrons or positrons.
1.4.4 Electromagnetic field The electromagnetic (EM) force is a force between two charged bodies (Coulomb force), or a force induced on a moving electrically charged body by a magnetic field. Magnetic and electric forces are the result of the exchange of a quanta of EM energy (photons), i.e. a photon mediates the exchanged force. The quantum approach to the electromagnetic force is dealt with in quantum electrodynamics (as discussed in Section 3.4). Since photons can travel indefinitely, the EM force has an infinite range, but its magnitude decreases with the inverse of the square of the distance between the affected bodies. At the atomic/nuclear level, the EM 2 1 force is weaker than the strong nuclear force by a factor of 4πεe 0 c = 137 , which is the fine structure constant, with ε0 being the electric permittivity of free space (= 8.85 × 10−12 F/m (or C2 /J m)).
Electric field The Coulomb force between atomic electrons is the dominant force in atomic and molecular structures, since these electrons are too far from the nucleus to be affected by the strong and weak nuclear forces. Magnetic effects provide refinements that are detectable only at high-resolution measurements, or under the influence of very strong magnetic fields (as is the case in magnetic resonance imaging, MRI). The Coulomb (electric) potential energy, V (r), between charged particles, having charges of ze and Ze, where e is the electronic charge and z and Z refer to the atomic number of the particles, is expressed as: V (r) = ∓
1 Zze 2 4πε0 r
(1.16)
15
1.4 Nuclear/Atomic Fields
where r is the distance of approach between the two particles, and the ∓ sign signifies an attraction (−) or repulsion (+), depending, respectively, on whether the electric charges have a different or same charge sign.
Magnetic field defined by the force, F, on a moving The magnetic field is a directional vector, B, charge in accordance to Lorentz’s law as:
F = eZ( v × B)
(1.17)
where eZ is a charge equal to that of Z electrons, v is the velocity of the charge Recall and the operator × is the cross product between the two vectors, v and B. that the direction of the force is given by the right-hand rule. The units of the are N s/(C m), or N/(A m), or simply Tesla (T). The effect of magnetic field, B, the magnetic field is combined with that of other fields by vectorially combining the forces resulting from each field. The potential energy of the magnetic field is ; a vector quantity of the current, i, defined by the magnetic dipole moment, M in a loop (coil) times the loop’s area, A, in the direction perpendicular to the = iAˆn, nˆ is the unit vector current’s loop in the right-hand rule direction, i.e. M normal to the loop’s plane (see Fig. 1.4). The magnetic potential energy, Vm (r, ϕ), is expressed by the dot product: (r) · B Vm (r, ϑ) = −M
(1.18)
where r is the loop’s radius, ϑ is the angle between the plane of the loop and the i.e. cos ϑ = nˆ · nˆ B where nˆ B is the unit vector in the direction of B. direction of B, Equation (1.18) shows that when M is aligned with B, the potential energy is low and B are opposite to each other. The est (most negative), but is highest when M difference between the highest and lowest potential energies is 2|M ||B|, where |·| designates magnitude. These relationships have relevance when dealing with the magnetic dipoles of electrons orbiting an atom, and with the intrinsic magnetic moment associated with the spin of the electron and nucleus. The magnetic e moment of an electron is given by μB = 2m , where e and me are, respectively, e the charge and mass of the electron. This is a fundamental constant known as nˆ
M = iAnˆ
A = Area of loop i
Figure 1.4
, produced by a current, i, in a loop of area, A. Magnetic moment, M
16
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
e the Bohr magneton and is equal to 5.788 × 10−5 eV/T6 . The quantity μB = 2m , p where mp is the mass of the proton, is another physical constant known as the nuclear magneton, = 3.152 × 10−8 eV/T. The magnetic moment of the proton is equal to 2.793μN , while that of the neutron is −1.913μN (with the negative sign indicating that the spin of the neutron is in opposite direction to that of the proton). The fact that the magnitudes of the magnetic moments of the neutron and the proton are greater than μN , and that the neutron (a neutral particle) has a magnetic moment, suggest a more complex internal structure than a mere single entity. In fact, the proton consists of two up quarks and one down quark, while the neutron is composed of two down quarks and one up quark (see Glossary for the definition of quarks).
1.4.5 Quantum states The effect of the atomic and nuclear fields can be studied by both classical continuum mechanics and quantum mechanics. The latter deals probabilistically with the wave nature of particles, while classical mechanics addresses the corpuscular nature of matter. Quantum mechanics is fundamental to the understanding of the atom and its nucleus, and the interaction of radiation with matter. A brief conceptual introduction is given here. As discussed in Section 1.3, a particle of mass m moving with a momentum p has associated with it a wave packet of wavelength λ = hp . Let us indicate this wave by the function ( r , t); a function of the position of the particle in space, r , and the time, t. The intensity of a wave is proportional to the square of its amplitudes. As such, ||2 is indicative of the density of a particle at a given point in space and time. In other words, ||2 dV is the probability of finding ∞ a particle within a volume dV at a certain point in time. Consequently, −∞ ||2 dV = 1. In essence, ||2 is a probability density function. In order to determine one must have a basic wave equation to solve. This equation is the Schrödinger equation: i
∂ 2 = − ∇ 2 + V (r) ∂t 2m
(fundamental equation)
(1.19)
for a particle of mass m approaching a field V (r), where r is the radial distance from the field’s center.This is a fundamental equation (like Newton’s laws, it needs no proof, but its consequences are supported by physical observations). Note that in the above equation, the potential is assumed to be a function of position only, as normally is the case with nuclear fields. For the function to be physically meaningful, the function itself and its derivatives must be finite, continuous and single valued at all points in space, and it must vanish at infinity. It should be measured value of the magnetic moment of an electron is equal to −1.00116μB (see http://physics. nist.gov/cuu/Constants/index.html), under “electron magnetic moment to Bohr magneton ratio’’ for the precise value.
6 The
17
1.4 Nuclear/Atomic Fields
kept in mind that the function represents a single particle, not the statistical distribution of particles. However, it is possible for this wave to interfere with itself, since the wave exists at all times and at all points in space. Note that for a free particle, the potential is zero, i.e. V (r) = 0, but when a particle approaches an atom or a nucleus V (r) assumes one or more of the potential field values described in Section 1.4.
Quantum numbers The solution of the wave equation is more readily obtained in the spherical spatial coordinates (r, ϑ, ϕ) using the method of separation of variables. This method of solution necessitates equating the separated functions to constants (to a total of three constants), since they are independent of each other. Each of these independent equations can then be solved separately. The physical acceptability of the solutions, according to the above-mentioned restrictions on , necessitates that the three constants assume certain values, known as the quantum numbers. The three quantum numbers are designated as n, l, and m and are such that: n = 1, 2, 3, . . .
(1.20)
l = 0, 1, 2, . . . , (n − 2), (n − 1)
(1.21)
m = −l, (−l + 1), (−l + 2), . . . , −1, 0, 1, 2, . . . , (l − 1), l
(1.22)
The quantum number n is known as the principal quantum number and determines √ the particle’s energy, E, while l specifies the angular momentum = l(l + 1) and m is the magnetic quantum number, as it controls the energy split when a particle is placed in a magnetic field (the Zeeman effect). The angular momentum number, l, is specified by a certain letter, according to spectroscopy terminology as shown in Table 1.4. In addition to the above quantum numbers, a spin quantum number, s, is added to take into account that a particle rotates around an axis√ passing through itself.The angular momentum associated with this spin is equal to s(s + 1), with s assuming two possible values, ±s, corresponding to the two possible directions of rotation. Note that the proton, neutron, neutrino, and electron all have a spin of s = 12 , while an α particle has no spin and a photon has a spin of s = 1. Particles of half-integer spin are called fermions, while those with an integer spin are known as bosons. A quantum state is defined by a unique set of numbers. The concept of quantum states is not unique to atomic and nuclear states. For example, the harmonic analysis of a vibrating string or the conduction of heat under certain Table 1.4 Terminology for the angular momentum quantum number l
l
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
…
s
p
d
f
g
h
i
…
18
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
boundary conditions, dictate a set of finite convergent series of sine and cosine functions (Fourier series), comprising a series of “quantum’’ frequencies, whose magnitudes are integer multiples of the fundamental frequency.
Pauli exclusion principle The Pauli exclusion principle stipulates that no two particles of half-integer spin (fermions) can occupy the same quantum state. Let us consider two identical particles 1 and 2 with wave functions 1 and 2 occupying two quantum states, i and j (with i and j being sets of two quantum numbers identifying the two states). The wave function of the system could then be ij = 1 (i)2 ( j). Since the two particles are identical, the same system can be arrived at if particle 1 occupies state j and particle 2 in state i, resulting in another system wave function ji = 1 ( j)2 (i). That is, the same system is represented by two different wave functions, and , producing two different physical properties, which is physically unreasonable. However, a linear combination of ij and ji leads to a system wave function: = 12 [ij − ji ] = 12 [1 (i)2 (j) − 1 ( j)2 (i)]. A weight of 12 is used for normalization, and equal weights are employed, since the two particles are identical. The negative sign is used here so that if the two states i and j are identical, then the system’s wave function will be zero and the system cannot exist. That is, for the combined system of the two particles to coexist, the two identical particles must be in different quantum states, i.e. with different quantum numbers. If the two identical particles interchange their quantum states, ij must be equal to −ji , which leads to = ij = −ji . A system of particles whose wave function flips sign if any of two identical particles in the system interchange positions is said to follow the Fermi–Dirac (anti-symmetric) statistics, or simply Fermi statistics, and the particles are called fermions. A system in which the interchange of the quantum states of two identical particles leaves the system’s wave function unaffected follows the symmetric Bose–Einstein statistics. Particles that follow this statistics are called bosons. Fermons (such as electrons, protons, neutrons, and neutrinos), which have half-integer spin, abide by the Pauli exclusion principle, while bosons (alpha particles and photons, with integer spin) do not. That is, more than one boson can occupy the same quantum state. The ability of bosons to occupy the same quantum state, hence energy state, can lead to concentration, or condensation, of bosons. However, for this to be possible, the bosons must be identical and their waves must overlap and exist at high concentration. This is achievable in electromagnetic radiation as in the case of laser cohesiveness and blackbody radiation, otherwise such conditions are very difficult to attain and occur only at extremely low temperatures7 . Note that Fermi–Dirac statistics is 7 The
phenomenon of superfluidity (zero viscosity) of helium cooled to 2.17 K can be explained by Bose–Einstein statistics. Superfluidity is caused by the condensation of many atoms to the lowest possible energy. The same condensation effect is behind superconductivity, where it is theorized that pairs of electrons coupled by lattice interactions behave like bosons and condensate into a state of zero electrical resistance. Ultra-cold atoms also follow Bose–Einstein statistics and can condensate.
1.5 Atom and Nucleus
19
used to describe the physical properties of metal, such as electrical conductivity, paramagnetism, thermal conductivity, etc.
Parity Another useful and important concept that arises from quantum mechanisms is that of parity, denoted by (upper case“pi’’).The wave function, ( r ), describing a particular system, e.g. an atom or a nucleus, may or may not change its parity, when r reverses direction to − r . If ( r ) = −(− r ), the system is said to have an “odd’’ or a negative parity, = −1. On the other hand, if ( r ) = (− r ), the wave function has an “even’’ or a positive parity, = +1. The concept of parity has no analogous formulation in classical mechanics, but can be viewed as a property that describes the reflection of a particle along a plane passing through its origin, and whether it maintains its as is (even parity), or alters its sign (odd parity). Parity is conserved, like energy and momentum, in processes involving strong nuclear forces and electromagnetic interactions, as long as the system remains isolated from external effects. The parity of a particle is determined by its orbital angular momentum and is equal to (−1)l , i.e. = +1 if l is even and = −1 for odd values of l. As such, the parity is a quantum number. The parity of an electron is considered to be even, and the same applies to the proton, neutron, and neutrino. The wave function of a system consisting of a number of particles, e.g. an atom or a nucleus, is the product of the wave functions of the individual particles, i.e. = 1 2 . . . N = N i=1 i , for a system of N particles. Therefore, the parity of depends on the parity of individual wave functions, and = 1 2 . . . N = N i=1 i . In defining a quantum state, the parity is given as a superscript of the total angular momentum of the system, i.e. J , with J= (l + s)i where i refers to particle i in the system, and = −1 or +1. Nuclides with even number of protons and neutrons have an even parity, since nucleons pair with each other (a neutron with a neutron and a proton with a proton). When two nucleons pair to produce a net angular momentum of zero, their energy is lowered and as such nucleons occupying the ground state in an even–even nucleus have a zero spin. For a nucleus of an odd mass number, one nucleon would remain unpaired, and the spin and parity of that nucleon (called the valence nucleon) determines the spin and parity of the nucleus.The parity and spin of a nucleus with an odd number of neutrons and an odd number of protons is determined by the two (one proton and one neutron) unpaired valence nucleons.
1.5 Atom and Nucleus 1.5.1 Atomic structure An atom consists of a nucleus surrounded with Z electrons, where Z is the atomic number. The chemical name of the element defines Z, since each element has a
20
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
unique value of Z; Z = 1 for hydrogen (H) and Z = 2 for helium (He), etc. These Z electrons rotate around the nucleus in orbits or shells, called Bohr orbits, of definite energies. Each shell is defined by the principal quantum number n which determines its energy; with n = 1 corresponding to the inner most orbit (K shell), n = 2 to the next orbit (M shell), etc. For the hydrogen atom, the energy of level n, E n , can be explicitly expressed by the equation: En =
Ry n2
(1.23)
where Ry is known as the Rydberg8 energy and is equal to 13.61 eV.The angular √ momentum of the orbiting electron is l(l + 1), where the angular quantum number, l, is such that 0 ≤ l ≤ n − 1. The magnetic quantum number, m, takes an integer value from −l to l, including zero, and defines the components of the angular momentum in a certain direction (observed under the application of an external magnetic field). The electron also has two spin states that produce a nonorbiting angular momentum, designated by the spin quantum number: s = + 12 and − 12 . The electrons are distributed in each orbit according to these quantum numbers, such that they obey the Pauli exclusion principle (see Section 1.4.5). Table 1.5 shows the quantum numbers for the first two energy states. Electrons are filled in the order shown in the table. Atoms whose shells are completely filled, such as helium in the K shell and neon in the L shell, are chemically inert as they have a stable (fully occupied) orbit arrangement that does not need additional electrons. On the other hand, elements with incomplete shells are chemically active. Elements which have one electron in a shell (such as lithium in the L shell) or need an electron to fill the shell (as in the case of fluorine with a missing electron in the L shell) are the most chemically reactive; they can easily either lose the lone electron in the shell or acquire an electron from any other element to fill up the shell. The two angular moment numbers, l and s, are combined into a single quantum number j that defines the total angular momentum such that j = l + s = l ± 12 . The designation nsj defines an electron with a principal quantum number n, l = 0 (for s) and j = 12 , i.e. s = j − l. A 2p 1 is one for which 2
n = 2, l = 1, and s = 12 − 1 = − 12 ; there are three electrons with this designation depending on whether m = −1, m = 0, or m = +1. The designation nf 7 indicates that shell n for l = 3 contains seven electrons.
1.5.2 Nuclear structure The nucleus contains Z protons (same number as the atomic electrons), and A − Z neutrons, with A being the number of nucleons (protons and neutrons), known 8 Rydberg
(1889) obtained empirically a constant, R∞ , while arriving at a formula to determine the wavelength of the optical spectra of elements. This constant was shown later by Bohr’s (1913) model of the hydrogen atom to be equal 4 ee to R∞ = cε2m(4π = 1.097 × 107 m−1 . The constant Ry is the constant that defines the energy level of the spectral )3 line. Therefore, Ry = R∞ hc.
21
1.5 Atom and Nucleus
Table 1.5
Order
Quantum numbers for the first two energy states (K and L shells)
n
l
m
s
K shell 1st
1
0
0
+ 12
2nd
1
0
0
− 12
L shell 3rd
2
0
0
+ 12
4th
2
0
0
− 12
5th
2
1
−1
+ 12
6th
2
1
0
+ 12
7th
2
1
+1
+ 12
8th
2
1
−1
− 12
9th
2
1
0
− 12
10th
2
1
+1
− 12
as the mass number. The nucleus is designated by A Z X , where X is the name of the element; or simply A X , since for each element X , there is a unique value of Z. For example 1 H, 2 H, and 3 H indicate three forms (called isotopes9 ) of hydrogen, with A = 1, 2, and 3, respectively (2 H is also known as deuterium (D) and 3 H as tritium (T)). In all cases, it is necessary that (A − Z) ≥ Z for a nucleus to be stable. For A ≤ 40, Z and A − Z are nearly equal for stable nuclides10 , but heavier nuclides have (A − Z) > Z, since more neutrons are needed to provide nuclear forces that can overcome the increasing repulsive Coulomb force caused by the elevated nuclear charge.
Mass defect 1 The mass of a nuclide is typically given in atomic mass units (u), 1 u = 12 th of the 12 mass of C ≡ 931.493 MeV in rest-mass energy. In all cases, the mass of a nuclide, M , is less than the sum of the mass of its individual nucleons and electrons (the mass of the electrons is so small, compared to that of a nucleon, and is normally nuclides of the same A are called isobars, while those with the same number of neutrons (A − Z) are known as isotones. 10 An atom identified by its nuclear constituents is called a nuclide. 9 Two
22
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
neglected). That is, M = Zmp + (A − Z)mn − M
(1.24)
Mc = Zmp c + (A − Z)mn c − B
(1.25)
2
2
2
where mp is the mass of a proton and mn is that of a neutron, the difference,
M , is called the mass defect, as it reflects the deficiency in mass between the mass of the individual constitutes of the nucleus and its collective mass. The energy corresponding to M , according to Eq. (1.1), is B = Mc 2 , and is called the binding energy. This is the energy associated with the work done by the nuclear forces between nucleons, and it is the energy that would be released if an atom were formed from its constituents11 . Any two particles that are no longer free create a negative potential field, i.e. energy that can be released if the two particles become free. In the nucleus, therefore, the depth of the potential field shown in Fig. 1.1 is equal to −B. As in all natural systems, stability favors the lowest possible potential energy. Therefore, nuclear decay and energy-producing (exoergic or exothermic) nuclear interactions generally move toward a state of lower energy, i.e. the final state of the process will have more binding energy than the initial state, with some exceptions. If the binding energy of the products in a nuclear reaction is lower than that of the reactants, the reaction is only possible if an external additional energy is added to the initial state to make up for the difference; the reaction is then called an endoergic (or endothermic) reaction.
Binding energy The binding energy is indicative of how strong the nucleus is bound. This binding effect is due to the strong nuclear forces between neighboring nucleons (both neutrons and protons). However, this force is subdued by a number of factors. First, the nuclear force of nucleons near the surface of the nucleus is less than that for those in its interior, due to the lower number of neighboring nucleons at the surface. Second, the longer range Coulomb forces between protons act against the short range nuclear force of attraction. Third, an odd number of protons or neutrons tends to weaken the nuclear bond than an even number of either, since the last odd number nucleon does not share its energy state with any other nucleon and as such occupies a higher-energy state. Fifth, nature favors an equal number of protons and neutrons to minimize the total energy of the nucleus (according to Pauli exclusion principle which applies to protons and neutrons, separately). The only factor that can enhance the bonding caused by the nuclear factors is the third factor in reverse, i.e., when an even number of neutrons and protons are present. These trends combined tend to favor an increasing neutron/proton ratio for high mass number nuclides, and equal number of protons and neutrons for light nuclides. Too many neutrons or protons can cause the binding energy to be negative, and the nucleus to become unstable. 11 A
stable nucleus has a higher binding energy than a less stable one, in the same manner the ashes of a burned matter are more strongly bound than the original matter to the extent that no more energy can be extracted from the ashes.
23
1.5 Atom and Nucleus
Nuclear shell model B The binding energy per nucleons, A (see Problem 1.13), generally increases with the mass number, A, until it reaches a maximum value of about 9 MeV in the region of A = 60. It then decreases slowly with A for heavier elements. This decrease is indicative of the fact that heavy nucleons are less tightly bound, due to the increasing effect of the Coulomb force between protons. This general trend is not, however, smooth, but is interrupted by sharp spikes for elements having Z or A − Z equal to 2, 8, 20, 28, 50, 82, and 126. These numbers of protons or neutrons are known as the magic numbers, as they provide the most stable nuclear configuration; analogous to an inert atom which has its atomic shells filled. This observation leads to the establishment of the nuclear shell model, in which the nucleons in the nucleus, like the electrons in the atom, are arranged in discrete energy levels in accordance to their quantum numbers and the Pauli exclusion principle. Unlike the atom, there is no principal quantum number that determines the energy level in the nucleus, rather those levels are determined by the angular momentum quantum number, l. The other significant quantum numbers are the spin number, s = ± 12 , the total angular momentum, j = l + s = l ± 12 , the magnetic angular momentum, m (= −l, −l + 1, . . . , l − 1, l) and the magnetic total angular momentum, mj (= −j, −j + 1, . . . , j − 1, j). The energy levels are determined by the l and j values. The label (2g 7 )8 designates the second energy level for l = 4 2
(for g), with a total angular momentum j of 72 , i.e. with a spin quantum number s = j − l = − 12 , and a room for (2j + 1 = 8) nucleons (8 multiplicity states) each with a different value of mj .The nuclear shell structure is shown inTable 1.5. Note that because of the Coulomb force, the proton energy levels differ from those of the neutron, but the sequence of the energy levels in the nucleus is hardly affected (Fig. 1.5). The highest level in the nucleus occupied by a nucleon is called the Fermi level, and the energy, EF corresponding to this level is the Fermi energy. The energy required to remove a nucleon from the Fermi level is equal to the binding energy of a nucleon to the nucleus, about EAB , where EB is the binding energy and A is the mass number. The value of EAB is about 7–9 MeV. Therefore, the Fermi level lies at about 7–9 MeV below the zero potential energy level (level after which the Coulomb field arises, shown in Fig. 1.1 by the horizontal solid line.) The value of EF for a nucleus of a mass number A and an atomic number Z can be estimated as [17]: 2 Z 3 EF (protons) = 53 MeV A 2 A−Z 3 EF (neutrons) = 53 MeV A
(1.26) (1.27)
24
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
Energy level
Quantum state
Cumulative number of nuclides
(2g7)8 2
4 1g (2p9)10 2
3 2p
50 (Closed shell)
(2p1
40
2
38
)6
(1f5
2
3 1f
)2 )4
(2p3
32
2
(1f7)8
28 (Closed shell)
2
2 2s 2 1d
(1d3)4 2
(2s1)2 2
)6
(1d5
2
(1p1)2 1 1p
20 (Closed shell) 16 14 8 (Closed shell)
2
)4
(1p3
6
2
0 1s
)2
(1s1
2 (Closed shell)
2
Figure 1.5 A schematic of lower-energy levels and quantum states (magic numbers correspond to closed shells). For a complete set, see [12].
The average energy of a nucleon in any of the available energy states is about 0.6 EF . For nuclides of ZA = 0.5, EF ≈ 33 MeV for both protons and neutrons, and the average energy is about 20 MeV. Then the ground state is about 8 MeV below EF , i.e. at about 40 MeV below the zero potential level. Equations (1.26) and (1.27) show that for hydrogen, as one would expect, EF (neutron) = 0. For a heavy nucleus rich in neutrons, EF (neutron) > EF (proton), due to the fact that the highest-filled proton level is at a lower energy since there are more neutrons than protons, hence the additional energy levels for neutrons.
Nuclear excitation state In a given nuclide, the lowest possible energy levels are filled first. Note that the energy level for the l − 12 states is lower than that for the l + 12 states. A nucleon moving to an unfilled state brings the nucleus to an excited state. There are specific excitation levels for each nuclide, in the same manner there are specific electron orbits for an atom. These excitation levels are available on the Internet (NuDat 2.0: http://www.nndc.bnl.gov/nudat2/). Figures 1.6 and 1.7 show for the sake of demonstration the excitation levels for a light isotope, 12 C, and a heavy one, 235 U, respectively (note the difference in scale). Nucleons in excited states will
25
1.5 Atom and Nucleus
12C
Level energy (MeV)
↑ etc.
16.11 15.11 14.08 12.71 11.16 9.64 7.65 4.44
0.00
Figure 1.6
Ground level
Excitation levels in
12 C.
Level energy (keV)
↑ etc.
235U
1028.00 927.21 826.64 680.11 518.10 307.18 148.38 44.92 0.00
Figure 1.7
Excitation levels in
Ground level 238 U.
decay eventually to more stable states. It is obviously easier (takes less energy) to excite a nucleus to its first excitation level above the ground level.
Nuclear collective models Nuclear transitions, particularly in heavy nuclides, can involve nucleons moving collectively to higher excited states. This “collective’’ transition resembles the movement of a drop of liquid (in which molecules move together). Therefore, this model of the nucleus is also known as the liquid drop model, and is used to describe the process of nuclear fission, in which a heavy nucleus divides into two smaller nuclides; a drastic change from the more common nuclear excitation to
26
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
higher energy levels. Using this model, if a nucleus were spherical in shape, its 1 1 radius R would be proportional to A 3 , where A is the mass number, or R = R0A 3 with R0 = 1.2 fm; as indicated by Eq. (1.15). This liquid drop model is also known as the vibrational model, as it assumes that the liquid drop nucleus oscillates between oblate and prolate shapes, due to the competition between the collective Coulomb force amongst protons and the attraction force of the nucleons on the surface of the nucleus (the “surface tension’’). These vibrations affect the excitation energy state of the nucleus. A characteristic quantum number, K , is introduced to describe the projection of the total angular momentum of the nucleus, J , on its symmetry axis. The balance between these two collective forces can break spontaneously in some nuclides, as liquid droplets tend to do, causing spontaneous fission. A gentle prodding of the liquid drop can also cause it to break up. In the same manner, a slow (thermal) neutron can cause the fission of a heavy nucleus. However, when the surface tension force is strong, more energy would be required to destroy the droplet, as such fast-neutron fission can also take place. Nevertheless, this collective action of the nucleons occurs only in certain nuclides, those with many nucleons occupying shells far away from closed shells (i.e. with number of neutrons and protons far removed from the magic number). Such nucleons tend to act as a group. Isotopes of uranium and plutonium fit this pattern, as well as 252 Cf (a common source of neutrons). The Fermi gas model of the nucleus assumes that nucleons are not as tightly bound to each other as in the liquid drop model, but they are always in motion in a manner similar to the molecules of a gas. The gas model describes the ground state, which has the minimum energy, much like a gas in a state of equilibrium. The model considers two gases, a proton gas and a neutron gas, with both having an equal tendency to occupy the lowest possible energy level. However, due to the repulsive force between protons, the lowest energy of the proton gas is slightly higher than that of the neutron gas, which explains why for heavy nuclides, where the electric repulsion between the protons is strong, there are more neutrons to achieve a stable (minimum energy) state. In lighter nuclides, the ground energy for both the ground states of the protons and neutrons are not very different from each other, and the number of neutrons and that of protons tend to be equal.
1.6 Nuclear Decay The stability of a nucleus is not absolute, and can be disrupted by the addition of external energy as in the case of nuclear interactions, or by spontaneous radioactive disintegration as a nucleus decays in attempt to reach a more stable state. This can involve the release of alpha or beta particles, γ radiation, and some other particles, as explained in the following sections. We begin, however, with an overall (macroscopic) analysis of the decay process.
27
1.6 Nuclear Decay
1.6.1 Kinetics Consider a radioactive material containing N0 nuclei at time t = 0. Let λ be the probability per unit time that this material will decay, one way or another.The probability that the material will not decay within a short time interval t is then q = 1 − λ t. That is, qN0 nuclei will remain without decay after t, q2 N0 after 2 t, and so on. Therefore, within n sequential time intervals, adding up to a total time period, t, the number of nuclei remaining without decay in the nth time interval, N (t), is then N (n t) = N (t) = qn N0 . As t → 0, n → ∞, one has12 : t n N n n = lim q = lim (1 − λ t) = lim 1 − λ n→∞ n→∞ n→∞ N0 n = e−λt = exp(−λt)
(1.28)
This is the exponential law of decay, and λ is the decay constant of the considered nuclide. The rate of decay (or disintegration) is called the activity, A: dN = Nλ (1.29) A= dt The activity is expressed in becquerels (Bq), disintegration per second13 . The half-time, t 1 , is the time it takes a material to lose by decay half of its 2
original quantity, i.e. the time at which t1 = 2
N N0
= 12 . It can be easily shown that:
ln 2 0.693 = λ λ
(1.30)
If a nuclide decays by more than one mode, a partial half-life, τ 1 , for the ith type of 2 decay (or a particular transition with the same type of decay), which has a decay constant λi , is defined as: t1 ln 2 τ1 = = 2 (1.31) 2 λi fi where fi is the ratio of the partial to the total decay constant, called the branching ratio. The partial half-life is the half-life if the material were to decay exclusively by the prescribed mode of decay. The daughter in a decay process may also be radioactive. Then, the rate of accumulation of a daughter nuclei is equal to its rate of production minus its rate of decay, i.e.: dNd = λp Np − λd Nd = λp Np (0) exp(−λp t) − λd Nd dt
b 1 + ab a = e. 13 The old unit is called Curie (Ci), 1 Ci = 3.7 × 1010 Bq = 37 GBq. 12 lim
b a →∞
(1.32)
28
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
where p refers to the parent nuclide and d to the daughter nuclide. The solution of Eq. (1.32) is: λp Np (0) Nd (t) = Nd (0) − exp(−λd t) λd − λp +
λp Np (0) exp(−λp t) λd − λp
(1.33)
d When λp < λd , i.e. the parent had a longer half-life, N Np will reach a constant value with time; the parent and daughter are then in a state of transient equilibrium. If λp << λd , so that the decay of the parent during the accumulation of the daughter nuclei is negligible, Nd will eventually approach a saturation value, establishing a state of secular equilibrium. There are a number of long decay sequences involving many progenies; those of 232Th, 235 U, 238 U, and 241 Pu, known, respectively, as the thorium, actinium, uranium, and neptunium decay series. An interactive demonstration of these decay series can be found on the Internet (e.g. Natural Radioactive Series: http://www.eserc.stonybrook.edu/ProjectJava/Radiation/).
1.6.2 Statistics The decay process is a discrete process in the sense that it involves the decay of one nucleus at a time. Such discrete events are statistically governed by the binomial distribution. Let N be the population from which n decay events occur within a time interval t. Within this period, t, the probability that no decay takes place, q, is exp(−λt), as evident from Eq. (1.28). Then the probability that decay occurs is p = 1 − exp(−λ t). This is while according to the binomial distribution, the probability P(n) of n decay events is: N! pn qN −n n!(N − n)! N! [1 − exp(−λ t)]n [exp(−λ t)]N −n = n!(N − n)!
P(n, t) =
(1.34)
The mean of this distribution is n¯ = Np = N [1 − exp(−λ t)], which is the average number of particles emitted within t. When λ t << 1 (or equivalently, when the observation time is much less than the half-life), then n << N , and one can take the limit N → ∞ of the distribution (1.34) as a reasonable representation of the decay statistics. Then: P(n, t) =
(λ t)n exp(−λ t) n!
(1.35)
This is the Poisson distribution, which has a mean equal to n¯ = λt (corresponding to Np in the binomial distribution) and a variance, σ 2 , equal to its mean, that is
29
1.6 Nuclear Decay
σ 2 = n¯ . Although, N is not infinity, it is quite large compared to the number of decays observed within a certain time period, and the Poisson distribution is used to statistically analyze radioactive decay. Another interesting feature of Poisson distribution is that it is also a special case of the normal (Gaussian) distribution, when n is sufficiently large (> 20 or so). Then: (¯n − n)2 P(n) = √ exp − 2¯n 2πn¯ 1
(1.36)
The use of the normal distribution facilitates the definition of confidence intervals, one can state that 50% of the measurements lie between m ± 0.67 σ, 68% within m ± σ, 95% within m + 2 σ, etc. It should be noted though while the Poisson distribution is a distribution of discrete events, the normal distribution is a continuous distribution.
1.6.3 Alpha decay The decay of a nucleus by the emission of an α particle requires firstly that two protons and two neutrons combine within the nucleus, and secondly the formed positively charged particle overcomes the Coulomb barrier in the field of the nucleus (about 20 MeV for a typical heavy nucleus). For an α particle (a 4 He nucleus) to form within a nucleus, the nucleus must be rich in both neutrons and protons. Therefore, α decay occurs in nuclides heavier than lead (possible for A ≥ 150 and is the dominant decay mode for A ≥ 210, where A is the mass number). In such a heavy nuclide, many nucleons can exist far away from the closed nuclear shell, with some freedom to collectively combine with each other. The formation of an α particle is favored over the formation of the lighter 2 H nucleus, since the binding energy of 4 He is much higher than that for 2 H (28 MeV compared to only 2 MeV); since the most stable forms have the highest binding energy per nucleon. Also, the probability of α particle formation in a nuclide with even number of nucleons is higher than in those containing odd numbers of nucleons, resulting in a lower decay rate for the latter. An α particle formed in the negative portion of the nuclear potential field, i.e. below the energy level at which the Coulomb field begins to appear (see Fig. 1.1), cannot leave the nucleus. However, an α particle in a positive energy state can “tunnel’’ through the Coulomb barrier. This is possible as an α particle can possess wave properties; a portion of the wave incident on the inside of the Coulomb barrier can be transmitted through to the outside of the barrier, while the remaining portion is reflected back. That is, there is a finite probability that an α particle can exist outside the Coulomb barrier; hence a finite probability exists for α emission out of the nucleus. The α decay of a parent nuclide X with a mass number A and an atomic A−4 number Z, designated here as A Z X, to a daughter nuclide Z−2Y, can leave the latter
30
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
in an excited state. The decay process can then be expressed in two stages as: A ZX A−4 ∗ Z−2 Y
→ →
A−4 ∗ 4 Z−2Y + 2 α + Eα A−4 Z−2Y + Eγ
whereY∗ indicates the excited state of the product nucleus (if any, see below), Eα is the kinetic energy carried by the α particle and the recoil nucleus, and Eγ is the energy of the γ radiation resulting from de-excitation. The binding energy for this combined decay process is such that: [Zmp + (A − Z)mn ]c 2 − B1 = [(Z − 2)mp + (A − Z − 2)mn ]c 2 − B2 + [(2mp + 2mn )c 2 ] − Bα + Eα + Eγ Qα = Eα + Eγ = Bα + (B2 − B1 )
(1.37)
where mp and mn are, respectively, the mass of a proton and a neutron, and B1 and B2 refer to the binding energy of the original and product nuclei, respectively. The energy corresponding to the difference in mass between the parent nucleus and the decay products (daughter nucleus and the α particle), which is equal to the value of Eα + Eγ , is called the Q-value of the decay. The high binding energy of α particles, about 28 MeV, makes α decay an exoergic process in many nuclides, since the energy consumed in removing the particle from the nucleus is so small. Therefore, this decay can take place spontaneously, without leaving the nucleus in an excited state, i.e. with Eγ = 0. Alpha decay also lowers the Coulomb energy of the daughter nucleus (by removing two protons), while not having much effect on the binding energy per nucleon. Therefore, the daughter nucleus tends to be more stable than the parent nucleus. Note that all α particles emitted from a certain nuclide have the same kinetic energy, since the change in binding energy is always the same.
Alpha transitions The conservation of the total angular momentum and parity restricts the energy levels from which α decay can occur. A parent nucleus with a total angular momentum given by Jp decays to a daughter of a total angular momentum determined by Jd such that the total angular momentum of the α particle, jα , is the vector difference between the angular momentum of the initial and final states; i.e. Jα = | Jp − Jd |. The latter vector difference can have any absolute value from | Jp − Jd | to | Jp + Jd |, depending on the relative orientation of Jp and Jd . Since the α particle has zero spin, its total angular momentum jα is equal to its angular momentum lα (recall that j = l + s). Therefore, conservation of total angular momentum for α decay requires that: | Jp − Jd | ≤ lα ≤ | Jp + Jd |. The parity of an α particle is equal to (−1)l , since its spin is zero. Conservation of parity dictates that Jp p = (−1)l Jdd . If for example the parent is 0+ , i.e. has an
31
1.6 Nuclear Decay
even parity with Jp = 0, then the daughter should be such that Jd is equal to 0+ for l = 0; 1− for l = 1; 2+ for l = 2, and so on; all other transitions are forbidden. Alpha decay tends to leave the daughter in the ground state, so that the α particle carries a maximum amount of energy. For nuclides with even number of neutrons and protons, the spin of the ground state is zero, consequently α decay tends also to result in a daughter in a zero-spin ground state. However, in nuclides with an even mass number, the daughter nucleus can be left in an excited state (though close to the ground state) following α decay. This leads to the emission of α particles with different distinct energies depending on the level of excitation of the product nucleus. Such energy variation is known as the fine structure of the α particle energy spectrum.
Hindrance factor The half-life for α decay, t 1 α , is empirically related to the Q-value of the α decay, 2 Qα , by the Keller–Munzel relationship14 : 2 Z 3 +b (1.38) −Z log 10 t 1 α = a √ 2 Qα with Qα in MeV, and a and b are best-fit constants for t 1 (in seconds): 2
Z
A−Z
a
b
Even
Even
1.61
−20.261
Even
Odd
1.65
20.238
Odd
Even
1.66
20.726
Odd
Odd
1.77
20.657
It is obvious that the lowest half-life, hence highest rate of decay, is achieved in even–even nuclides. The α decay of such a nuclide is a transition to another even–even nuclide. Since the total angular momentum for even–even nuclide is zero, and their parity is even, the ground state to ground state (gs–gs) α transitions are 0+ → 0+ transitions. The half-life of this type of decay can be theoretically calculated using the so-called “one-body’’ model of α particles, which assumes that the α particle is pre-formed (as one body) within the nucleus before penetrating the Coulomb potential barrier by the tunneling effect. In this model, the probability of decay (i.e. release of the pre-formed α particle) in the nucleus depends on the probability of the particle hitting the Coulomb barrier times 14 K.
H. Keller and H. Munzel. Shell effect and α-decay probability, Zeitschrift fur Physik, Vol. 255, 1972, pp. 419–424.
32
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
the probability of penetrating the barrier. The ratio between the measured partial half-life of a particular transition and that calculated using the one-particle model for an even–even nuclei at the energy of α decay is known as the hindrance factor (HF).
1.6.4 Beta decay Beta decay involves the conversion of a neutron to a proton, or a proton to a neutron, i.e. the transformation of a nucleus to an isobar (as the mass number does not change). This conversion process is not surprising given the fact that protons and neutrons are both nucleons that abide by the same set of quantum numbers, and as such are subject to transformation from one state to another within the nucleus. The result of this conversion process is that the neutron-to-proton ratio changes; increasing in a neutron-rich nucleus and decreasing in a proton-rich nucleus. This mode of interaction occurs in the majority of unstable nuclides, and can take one of the three forms: β− decay, β+ decay, and the capture of an atomic electron.
β− decay The conversion of a neutron to a proton requires the release of an electron (a β− particle) for charge balance, such that: 1 0n
→11 p +−10 e + 00 ν¯ + Eβ + Eν¯
where ν¯ refers to an antineutrino and Eβ and Eν¯ are the kinetic energies of the emitted electron (β− particle) and antineutrino (¯ν). The presence of the almost massless neutrino is required to satisfy momentum conservation, as well as to meet the experimentally observed variation in the energy spectrum of the emitted β− particle, which varies from zero to a maximum energy, Eβmax . The neutron, the proton, and the electron are all fermions with a spin number of 12 . Therefore, without the neutrino, the spin (hence angular momentum) will not be conserved. It is also necessary to balance the lepton number15 . Therefore, an antineutrino (not a neutrino) is assigned to this decay process. The β− decay of a parent nuclide A Z X may leave the nucleus in an excited ∗ . Therefore, this combined decay process is expressed as: Y state, A Z−1 A ZX
A ∗ →Z+1 Y +−10 e + 00 ν¯ + Eβmax
A ∗ Z+1Y 15 A
A →Z+1 Y + Eγ
lepton is particle that is not involved in the strong nuclear forces, but participates in the weak ones (see Glossary). A lepton number of 1 is assigned to both the electron and the neutrino and −1 is associated with both the antineutrino and the positron.
33
1.6 Nuclear Decay
where Eγ is the energy of γ radiation. In terms of binding energy for the final state, after de-excitation, [Zmp + (A − Z)mn ]c 2 − B1 = [(Z + 1)mp + (A − Z − 1)mn ]c 2 −B2 + me c 2 + Eβmax + Eγ Qβ− = Eβmax + Eγ = (B2 − B1 ) + (mn − mp − me )c 2
(1.39)
where mp , mn , and me are, respectively, the mass of a proton, a neutron, and an electron, c is the speed of light, and B1 and B2 refer to the binding energy of the original and product nuclei, respectively. Note that (mn − mp − me )c 2 ≈ 782 keV. Equation (1.39) indicates that a β− decay processes in which Eβmax + Eγ < 782 keV ≈ (mn − mp − me )c 2 has to involve a decrease in binding energy (contrary to the general trend of increasing binding energy encountered in most decay processes). Note that if the product nucleus after β− decay is in the ground state, Eγ will be equal to zero.
β+ decay The β− decay process is anticipated, and encountered in the disintegration of natural nuclides, as they all have a neutron-to-proton ratio greater than one in order for them to exist in stable states. Since the neutron is heavier than the proton, it is also natural to expect that a neutron would shed some mass to reach a lower and more stable energy state. In fact, a free neutron would eventually decay to a proton. On the other hand, the proton is lighter than the neutron, and is a stable free particle. Therefore, for the positron emission process: [E] + 11 p →10 n + 01 e + 00 ν + Eβ + Eν to take place, where ν designates a neutrino, the proton has to acquire some energy, [E], from another nucleon in the nucleus. This decay occurs in artificially produced proton-rich isotopes, such as 13 N and 15 O, which has proton-to-neutron ratios of, respectively, 76 and 87 . Like in β− decay, the neutrino is emitted to conserve linear and angular momentum and the lepton number, which also explains the observed energy distribution of the emitted positron. The β+ decay of a parent nuclide A Z X is such that: A ZX
A ∗ →Z−1 Y + 01 e + 00 ν + Eβmax
A ∗ Z−1Y
A →Z−1 Y + Eγ
34
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
Naturally, if after β+ decay the nucleus is not excited, Eγ will be equal to zero. Then, [Zmp + (A − Z)mn ]c 2 − B1 = [(Z − 1)mp + (A − Z + 1)mn ]c 2 − B2 + me c 2 + Eβmax + Eγ Qβ+ = Eβmax + Eγ = (B2 − B1 ) − (mn − mp + me )c 2
(1.40)
With (mn − mp + me )c 2 ≈ 1.804 MeV, β+ decay requires the product nucleus to have a binding energy higher than that of the product nucleus by more than 1.8 MeV. The positron generated in this reaction will travel through the sea of electrons surrounding the nucleus and will combine with one of these electrons causing their mutual annihilation and the production of two photons, each of energy of me c 2 = 511 keV, emitted in opposite directions to conserve linear momentum. This positron annihilation process is the essence of the positron emission tomography (PET) technique used in medical imaging.
Electron capture A proton can also be converted to a neutron by capturing an electron from the atomic electrons nearby, e.g. from the K shell. In this manner, there is no need for a proton to acquire energy from within the nucleus, hence no positron emission. The electron capture (EC) process (also referred to as ε decay) is such that: 0 1 1 p +−1 e
→10 n +00 ν + Eν
where Eν is the kinetic energy carried by the neutrino and the nucleus as it recoils (the latter is a negligible quantity). The emission of the neutrino is again essential, to conserve momentum, as the nucleus recoils and compensates for the addition of an electron of a lepton number of 1 to the parent nucleus. Electron capture creates a vacancy in the affected electron shell, which is subsequently filled by an electron from a higher shell. This causes the emission of X-rays and electrons characteristic of the product nucleus, called Auger electrons. Mass– energy balance alone is not sufficient to produce the above interactions, since mp + me < mn . Additional energy has, therefore, to be acquired from the nucleus, by the change in the binding energy. The nuclear binding energy for a parent A ZX A Y, is as follows: nucleus decaying by electron capture to a daughter nucleus, Z−1 [Zmp + (A − Z)mn ]c 2 − B1 + me c 2
= (Z − 1)mp + (A − Z + 1)mn c 2 − B2 + Eν Eν = (B2 − B1 ) + (mn − mp − me )c 2
(1.41)
The energy of binding the atomic electron is not included here, since it is not part of the nucleus, and is at any rate quite small compared to the binding energy
1.6 Nuclear Decay
35
of a nucleon in the nucleus. The available decay energy (i.e. the energy aside from the change in binding energy) is similar in value to that of Eq. (1.39) for β− decay. However, by comparison to Eq. (1.40), the decay energy available for EC is 1.022 MeV (= 2me c 2 ) lower than that for positron decay.Therefore, if the available decay energy is less than 2me c 2 , positron emission is impossible and a nucleus can decrease its number of protons by EC. Of course, if the available energy is higher than 2me c 2 , both β+ decay and EC can take place. For example, 22 Na decays 9% of the time by EC (Auger electrons) and 91% by positron emission, while in heavy elements EC is highly favored over positron emission; e.g. 100% of the decay of 125 I to 125Te and 207 Bi to 207 Pb is by EC. Since electron capture produces the same change in the nucleus as a positron emission, decay information for these two types of decay are often included together. Decay information is available on the Internet (NuDat 2.0: http://www.nndc.bnl.gov/nudat2).
Beta transitions The emitted beta particle and neutrino each have a spin of ± 21 , which can combine vectorially parallel to each other resulting in a net spin S = ±1, or anti-parallel with a net spin S = 0. Therefore, nuclides most readily decay when | Jp − Jd | = 1 or 0, and their is no change in parity between the parent and daughter nuclei, where Jp and Jd refer to the total angular momentum of the parent and daughter nuclei, respectively. Nuclear transitions associated with beta decays are called allowed transitions. Decay with | Jp − Jd | = 1 is known as Gamow–Teller transitions, while those with | Jp − Jd | are called Fermi transitions. The probability of emission depends on the value of | Jp − Jd |, being highest when | Jp − Jd | = 0. The probability of beta emission is expressed through a function known as the comparative half-life or ft value, where t is the half-life of the decaying nucleus, and f is a function of the atomic number of the decaying nucleus and the decay energy, Eβ + Eν . The log ft values are reported in the Isotope Explorer: http://ie.lbl.gov/ensdf/ under tables. The smallest ft values are those of mirror nuclides, i.e. those whose number of neutrons and protons are interchangeable, 23 23 25 25 e.g. (n,p), (31 H, 32 He), (178 O, 17 9 F), (11 F, 12 Mg), and (12 Mg, 13Al). Nuclear transitions leading to beta decay are classified according to | Jp − Jd |, and the value of log ft as: superallowed, allowed first forbidden, second forbidden, and so on. Superallowed transitions occur when both the parent and daughter have the same total angular momentum parity, i.e. Jp − Jd = 0 and p = d . Conservation of parity is not necessary in beta decay, since it involves the weak nuclear forces. These superallowed transitions are typically those of light elements, and include the decay of a free neutron. A transition with Jp − Jd = ±1, with the parent and the daughter having the same parity, is called an allowed transition, as it still has a high probability of emission, but is more likely than the superallowed transition as the electron carries a higher angular momentum. Transitions with larger values of | Jp − Jd | have much lower emission rates, since this implies that the emitted electron carries a large momentum which is quite unlikely given the small
36
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
mass of the electron in comparison to the nucleus. Such forbidden transitions are transitions in which the parent and the daughter nuclei may not have the same parity. An nth transition is such that | Jp − Jd | = n, n + 1 and p d = (−1)n . The only exception to this rule is that of the first forbidden state, in which parent and daughter have different parties, | Jp − Jd | = 0, 1, or 2. Note that the above rules for | Jp − Jd | apply to the three forms of beta decay (β− , β+ , and ε), since they pertain to the state of the isomers before (parent) and after (daughter) beta decay. Since the values of | Jp − Jd | overlap different degrees of forbiddenness, the value log ft determines whether a certain decay process belongs to a particular class, the lower log ft the lower is the degree of forbiddenness. Transitions in which |Lp − Ld | > | Jp − Jd |, where L is the angular momentum (excluding spin of the nucleus) are called l forbidden. In a deformed (non-spherical nucleus), if |Kp − Kd | > | Jp − Jd |, the transition is called K -forbidden, where K is a quantum number that describes the deformation (from spherical symmetry) of a nucleus (see Section 1.5.2). There is a very small probability that a nucleus can decay to a stable state by emitting two beta particles simultaneously. This double-beta decay process is quite rare.
1.6.5 Gamma decay Gamma (γ) decay is caused by the de-excitation of the nucleus, either to the ground state or to another exited state. The γ-ray energy can be as small as a few keV (e.g. 38.9 keV for 172W γ decay) or as high as a few MeV (e.g. 4.443 MeV for 11 Be γ decay). If the excited state has a measurable lifetime, the nuclide is in a metastable state, called an isomeric state and is identified by adding the letter m after its mass number, e.g. 99m Tc emits 142.7 keV γ (used as a radiopharmaceutical in medical nuclear imaging). The decay process is then referred to as an isomeric transition (IT). As indicated above, γ decay can accompany other types of radiation decay which leaves the nucleus in an excited state. To conserve momentum, the emitting nucleus recoils, gaining kinetic energy, but this energy is so low that it is negligible. Therefore, the energy of the emitted γ-rays is slightly lower than the difference in energy between the initial and final states.
Gamma transitions The energy of an emitted γ-ray, Eγ , is equal to the difference between the initial and final states of the isomers, Ei − Ef , i.e.: Eγ = hν = Ei − Ef
(1.42)
where ν is the frequency of the γ-ray and h is Planck’s constant. This transition is accompanied by a change in the total angular momentum and parity, i.e. from J i to J f and from i to f . The γ photon acquires an angular momentum defined
37
1.6 Nuclear Decay
by the quantum number ł, which is such that | Ji − Jf | ≤ l ≤ | Ji + Jf |, due to the vector nature of J i and J f . However, transitions take the lowest change in angular momentum, as such l = | Ji − Jf |. Gamma nuclear transitions are classified according to the value of | Ji − Jf |, and whether i is equal to f or not. If i = f , an odd value for | Ji − Jf | refers to a magnetic multipole transition, M| Ji − Jf | , and an even value results in electric multipole transition, E| Ji −Jf | ; the opposite is true for f = |i . The degree of multiplicity of a pole is given by 2l , with l = 1 resulting in a dipole, l = 2, a quadruple, l = 3 an octupole, and so on. That is: |Ji − Jf |
1
2
3
4
...
Parity
i = f
i = f
i = f
i = f
...
Electric
E1
E2
E3
E4
...
Parity
i = f
i = f
i = f
i = f
...
Magnetic
M1
M2
M3
M4
...
The terminology “electric’’ and “magnetic’’ describes the type of electromagnetic field associated with radiation16 . Favored transitions have a small | Ji − Jf | and high transition energy, while all other transitions are either unfavorable or do not occur. Energy levels close to the ground state tend to have the same parity as the ground state, and such transitions from those states to the ground state or in between themselves are the M1 or E2 transitions. Often though mixed M1 /E2 transitions are observed, due to the enhancement of E2 caused by the deformed (non-spherical) shape of the nucleus. Note that | Ji − Jf | = 0 is not permitted, since a released photon requires an angular momentum of 1. However, nuclear vibrations (see the collective model of the nucleus in Section 1.5.2), can transfer energy to a surrounding atomic electron, even at | Ji − Jf | = 0, ejecting it from the atom. This is the process of internal conversion described below.
1.6.6 Internal conversion The excitation energy of a nucleus can be transferred into an orbital electron. This can be thought of as a “shivering’’ nucleus affecting the electrons surrounding it. As indicated above this process can take place without change in the total angular momentum of the nucleus. An affected atomic electron will in turn be liberated, carrying an energy equal to the nuclear transition energy minus the electron’s binding energy. If the same transition energy can be released as a γ-ray, then both processes can take place at the same time. The ratio between the two processes is 16 Electric
fields are produced by oscillating charges, while magnetic ones are due to oscillating currents.
38
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
called the conversion coefficient, α, defined as: α=
Number of internal conversion decays Number of γ-ray decays
(1.43)
Since the ejected electrons can arise from any electron orbit, an orbit-specific conversion coefficient can be defined, then α = αK + αL + αM , . . . , where the subscript refers to the shell from which the electron is emitted. The electron with the highest energy will then be emitted from the outer atomic shell, which has the lowest binding energy, while the K shell gives rise to the lowest electron energy. Most internal conversion takes place at the K shell, and the value of α tends to increase with increasing atomic number and decreasing nuclear excitation energy. A vacancy left in an outer shell by internal conversion (IC) is subsequently filled with an electron from an outer shell. This is either followed by the release of Auger electrons or characteristic X-rays, in a manner similar to the electron capture process of beta decay.
1.6.7 Spontaneous fission According to the liquid drop model of the nucleus, indicated in Section 1.5.2, a gentle perturbation of a large nucleus should split it into two small droplets, causing division or fission. One could argue that superheavy nuclides do not exist because of the instability against spontaneous fission. This instability is caused by the large repulsive force between the protons in heavy nuclei, which drives the droplet to a non-spherical shape that is vulnerable to division, but is tampered by the binding energy stabilizing effect associated with the shell structure of the nucleus. The latter effect, in many cases, stabilizes most heavy nuclides against spontaneous fission. Fission is resisted by a potential barrier of about 5–8 MeV for nuclides of mass number from 232 to 242. If a nucleus is excited to an energy equal or above this barrier energy it will undergo fission, most likely before it releases its excitation energy by γ emission. Nuclides at the ground state can still undergo spontaneous fission by tunneling through the fission barrier, in a manner similar to α decay. Therefore, nuclides that undergo spontaneous fission are also α emitters. Some of the nuclides that exhibit spontaneous fission with significant intensity are: 248 Cm, 252 Cf, and 254 Cf. Californium-252 is a common isotropic source of neutrons. Other less significant spontaneous fission occurs in 208 Po, 231Th, 235 U, 238 U, 239 Pu, 240 Pu, 250 Cm, 252 Fm, 254 Fm, 256 Fm, and 258 Fm. The fission process of a heavy nucleus results in the release of ν neutrons (0 ≤ ν ≤ ∼6 or so, with an average value, ν¯ , of about 2.5) and two medium-size nuclides, with mass numbers in the range of 70–160. This process for a nucleus A Z X can be represented as: A ZX
1 →A Z1 X1
+
A2 Z2 X2
+ ν01 n + γ
with
A1 + A2 + ν = A Z1 + Z2 = Z
39
1.6 Nuclear Decay
The γ-rays released simultaneously as the nucleus divides, is called prompt γ-rays A2 1 and can have an energy up to 8 MeV. The fission products, A Z1 X1 and Z2 X2 , are typically left in an excited state and emit γ-rays within less that 1 ms of their formation. Since fission takes place in heavy nuclei that are neutron rich, the fission products are also neutron rich, and as such decay by a series of β− emissions to reduce their proton-to-neutron ratio. Such β− decays typically leave the nucleus in an excited state and is usually accompanied by γ decay. Some of the nuclides created by fission also decay by neutron emission, producing the so-called delayed neutrons to distinguish them from the prompt neutrons produced during the fission process17 . The emitted neutrons acquire a kinetic energy over a wide energy range, up to about 14 MeV. The energy distribution of the neutrons is typically expressed by the Watt distribution18 : N (E)dE = a exp(−E) sinh
√ bE dE neutrons/MeV
(1.44)
where N (E)dE is the number of neutrons per fission emitted with an energy between E and E + dE, and a and b are nuclide-dependent constants. The average kinetic energy of a fission neutron is about 2 MeV, though the most probable energy is about one-third the average value.
1.6.8 Decay by neutron or proton emission Since the nucleus is composed of protons and neutrons, one might expect that decay by neutron or proton emission would be quite common. However, this type of decay is forbidden by energy conservation, that is the binding energy of the product nucleus of this type of decay would be less than that of the parent nucleus. Therefore, such decay requires the addition of energy to the parent nucleus, to enable one or more of its nucleons to overcome the potential barrier and leave the nucleus. This requirement prevents the decay of natural nuclides by this type of emission. However, decay by proton and neutron emission is observed in the isomeric decay of excited nuclides, typically following a β decay. For example, after the β+ decay of 111Te, the daughter 111 Sb decays by proton emission to 110 Sn, while the 87 Kr isomer, resulting from the β− decay of 87 Br (about 2% of the time), decays to 86 Kr by neutron emission. These processes are known as betadelayed proton or neutron emissions. Note also that these beta-delayed decays can release α particles, and other types of particles. The metastable isomer 53m Co emits (1.5% of the time) a proton directly (without prior beta decay), decaying to 52 Fe. Some other heavy nuclei also exhibit proton decay from the ground state, such as 147Tm and 151 Lu. When proton emission takes place, it must tunnel 17 Delayed
neutrons are relied upon to control the fission process in nuclear reactors, by ensuring that a reactor does not become critical without their contribution. 18 B. E.Watt. Energy spectrum of neutrons from thermal fission of U235 , Physical Review, Vol. 87, 1952, pp. 1037–1041.
40
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
through the Coulomb potential barrier, unless it has an energy greater than that of the barrier.
1.7 Reactions and Interactions When a radiation particle approaches an atom/nucleus it can be affected by the associated fields in a number of ways. It is then said that the particle has “interacted’’. The target atom/nucleus, on the other hand, may suffer some change, i.e. “react’’, or be left unaffected, or so barley affected that the reaction is inconsequential. Due to the short range of nuclear forces, interactions with the nucleus are quite different in nature from those with the atom as a whole, or with its individual atomic electrons. Therefore, these two types of interactions are discussed separately in the ensuing sections. One can classify these interactions using both the corpuscular nature and the wave nature of radiation, or based on the nature of the affecting atomic/nuclear field. However, it is more practical to classify these interactions by the effect the fields have on the incident radiation. Most textbooks address all aspects of one interaction at a time; presenting the mechanism of an interaction then directly examining its kinematics and the probability of its encounter, all at once. This book takes a broader perspective, given the fact that most of these interactions can be described by generalized kinematics and interaction mechanics. Therefore, in this section a compilation of all possible reactions are presented, while the kinematics of all interaction are discussed in Chapter 2 and the probability of interaction are introduced in Chapter 3. In each of these Chapters, a generalized analysis is first presented, and is subsequently applied to specific interactions. This gives the reader a broader view and avoids the need to consider one interaction in isolation of others. Readers interested in one type of interaction can consult either the Index at the end of the book or Table 1 in the Preface. Some simplified schematic diagrams, using obvious notations, are presented below to facilitate understanding of some interaction mechanisms. Note that the symbol γ is used to represent an X-ray or a γ-ray photon.
1.7.1 Interaction with atomic electrons The first target a radiation particle encounters is the atomic electrons, which affect the incoming radiation by virtue of their charge and the associated electromagnetic field. Neutrons are obviously not affected by the electrons as they have no charge. On the other hand, both photons and charged particles are strongly influenced by the atomic electrons. The mechanisms affecting both types of radiation are quite different, since photons carry no charge. Figure 1.8 provides a general classification of the interactions of photons and charged particles with one or more of the atomic electrons. The interactions of each of these two types of radiation are discussed below.
41
1.7 Reactions and Interactions
Photon
Charged particle ±
Absorption
Photoelectric effect, triplet production
Atomic electron(s)
Compton Incoherent scattering Rayleigh, Thomson Coherent
Figure 1.8
Coulomb, Moller, Bhabha
Elastic scattering
Soft, hard Neutralization, Annihilation
Inelastic scattering
Absorption
Interactions with atomic electron(s) for photons and charged particles.
Photon–electron interactions Photoabsorption Photon absorption by an atomic electron occurs in the photoelectric effect process, in which the photon loses its entire energy to an atomic electron which is in turn e− liberated from the atom. This process requires the incident Atomic electron photon to have an energy greater than the binding energy of an orbital electron. For X- and γ-ray photons of sufficient energy, photoelectric absorption is most likely to be caused γ by the most tightly bound electrons, i.e. those of the K shell, because the concentration of electrons is highest in this shell. Note that the photoelectric effect cannot occur if the electron is unbound, as it will not be possible to conserve both energy and momentum. The reaction is also favored at low photon energy and for atoms with a large atomic number, where there are many electron shells for the incoming photon to interact with, and to match in energy. The incident photon is completely absorbed in this process and the electron is released carrying a kinetic energy equal to that of the incident photon minus its binding energy. Although, the atom recoils in this process to conserve momentum, the kinetic energy it carries is negligible. The released electron leaves behind a vacancy in the inner orbit it occupied. This vacancy is subsequently filled by an electron from a shell with a lower binding energy (an outer orbit, e.g. from an L to a K shell). The difference between the two binding energies of the electron filling the vacancy is released in the form of an X-ray photon, known as fluorescent radiation. Alternatively, the energy may lead to the ejection from the atom of another orbital electron, called the Auger electron. This electron in turn leaves a vacancy and the process of emission of X-ray photons or Auger electrons is repeated, and so on. In atoms with high atomic number, X-ray emission is usually favored over the releases of Auger electrons, and the opposite is true for light elements. In essence, while in the photoelectric effect the original photon is absorbed, other photons (X-rays) and electrons (the first liberated electron and any Auger electrons) are released.
42
Triplet production In the electric field of the electron, a photon of an energy greater than four times the rest mass of the electron (4 × 0.511 = 2.044 MeV) can disappear and be replaced by a positron–electron pair.The target electron also recoils, and because of its small mass it can acquire a significant amount of energy. One then observes three particles (two electrons and a positron) replacing the absorbed photon.
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
e− e−
e+
Atomic electron γ E > 2.044 MeV
Compton (incoherent) scattering A more likely scenario is that the incident photon gives some of its γ energy to an atomic electron, while remaining as a e− photon with a reduced energy. In essence, the inciAtomic electron dent photon acts like a “particle’’ colliding with a γ “free’’ (and at rest) electron. The electron is considered here to be free, since this process, which is called E > Be Compton scattering, occurs at a photon energy much higher than the binding energy, Be , of atomic electrons, to the extent that the electron is considered to be practically “unbound’’. This is an interaction in which the photon loses energy and changes direction, but the total energy and momentum of the two colliding particles is conserved. The interaction is considered to be an incoherent scattering, since the photon possesses in this process corpuscular properties, rather than coherent wave properties. However, Compton scattering is an elastic process, as far as the interacting photon and electron are concerned. From the atom’s point of view, this is an inelastic scattering, because the atom loses an electron and can become ionized, or at least excited. Following the reaction, recoil electrons are transported through matter and interact as charged particles, and ultimately dissipate their energy as heat before coming to rest. Note that inverse Compton scattering can also take place, that is a high-energy free electron can scatter with a photon of lower energy. This interaction is important in astrophysics. Rayleigh (coherent) scattering This is an interaction with bound atomic electrons (as a collective) in a coherent fashion, in the sense that photons behave as waves and interact elastically, because the nature of the atom is not altered19 . The entire atom recoils to conserve momentum. As a result, the deflected photon emerges with an energy almost equal to the incident energy, and the photon scatters by a very small angle. The practical impact of this interaction is a slight change in angle in the forward direction, with almost no reduction in energy. 19 The
γ
Atom γ
classical definition of Rayleigh scattering is the scattering of electromagnetic waves by particles smaller in size than the wavelength. The scattering of such waves with particles larger in size than the wavelength is called Mie scattering.
43
1.7 Reactions and Interactions
Diffraction When the radiation wavelength is about equal in value to inter-atomic spacing (lattice pitch in crystallized structures), wave interference effects produce a diffraction pattern (fringes), due to the coherence between incident and reflected waves at some discrete directions. The structure and identity of the crystal can be deduced from these patterns. The same effect can also be used to study chemical bonds and biological structures, that exhibit regular patterns of atomic arrangements. Both low energy X-rays and cold neutrons produce this effect. At this range of wavelength and higher, X-rays and cold neutrons also exhibit other optical properties such as reflection, refraction, and polarization. Thomson electron scattering This is a coherent, hence elastic, interaction of a photon with a single unbound electron. As such, the photon energy does not change, but the photon can scatter in any direction (forward and backward). This reaction is, however, not as probable as Rayleigh scattering, and the latter itself has generally a low probability in comparison to other interactions.
γ γ
Atomic electron
Charged-particle interactions with atomic electron Elastic scattering A charged particle can be deflected by the Coulomb forces of the atomic electrons in such a way that energy and momentum are conserved. Heavy charged particles are hardly affected by electrons because of the greatness of their mass relative to that of the electron. Elastic scattering of charged particles with the atom as a whole is in effect a scattering by the positive electric charge of the nucleus screened by the negative charge of the atomic electrons. The reaction is an elastic one when the atomic electrons do not receive any excitation energy in the process. When the incident particles are electrons or positrons, they can interact elastically with individual atomic electrons by, respectively, repulsive or attractive Coulomb forces. If the Atomic incident particle is an electron, the projectile electron and the target become identical and interference between the waves describing their interaction affects their behavior. The interaction is then called Mott scattering between Moller Bhabha identical particles20 . When the energy loss per collision for the incident particle is >0.255 MeV, electron–electron scattering is called Moller scattering, while the positron–electron interaction is known as Bhabha 20 The
Coulomb elastic scattering of an electron by the atomic nucleus, when dealt with using quantum mechanics, is also called Mott scattering.
44
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
scattering. Obviously, for an electron (or a positron) to lose energy > 0.255 MeV (half its rest-mass energy), it must possess a high velocity; which necessitates the relativistic treatment of Moller (and Bhabha) scattering. Inelastic scattering The predominant interaction of charged particles with atomic electrons is an inelastic one, in which Atomic the atomic electrons receive energy that electrons exceeds their binding energy. The target atom then becomes excited, or even ionized if an atomic electron leaves the nucleus and Repulsion Attraction becomes unbound. Given the small mass of the electron, the kinetic energy received by an ejected electron in the ionization process can be quite large. These swift electrons are called delta (δ) rays, and their energy can be sufficiently high to cause further (secondary) ionization before they lose their entire energy and are subsequently re-absorbed in the atom. When the amount of energy transferred to the atomic electron is small, on the order of its excitation or ionization energy, the interaction is called a “soft collision’’. Obviously, the interaction is a “hard collision’’ if the energy transferred to the electron is such that the effect of its binding energy is negligible, so that the atomic electron involved in the collision can be considered to be initially free. Absorption As charged particles slow-down they may have sufficient energy to break chemical bonds, but they also dissipate their kinetic energy in the form of heat until they reach a state of thermal equilibrium within the medium. A positively heavy charged particle eventually captures an electron and becomes neutral. Then, its effect on the atom is considerably reduced. In solids, the absorption of a charged particle can lead to lattice defects, when atoms are displaced from their lattice. An electron can be captured by an atom ionized in a previous interaction, changing it from an ion to a neutral atom, or it can attach itself to a neutral atom creating a negative ion. These neutralized atoms will also attain an equilibrium condition. Atomic shells act, therefore, as donors of electrons to positively charged particles, or as receptors of electrons, in effect absorbing these particles. Positron annihilation As a positron comes to rest, it is absorbed by a free or loosely bound atomic electron, in a process known as annihilation, in which the two particles mutually self-destruct. Their rest mass is then converted into two photons each possessing an energy of 511 keV (equivalent to the rest mass of an electron or a positron). To conserve momentum these two photons are emitted in two opposite directions.
γ
Nucleus
45
1.7 Reactions and Interactions
Photon
Charged particle ±
Absorption
Figure 1.9 particles.
Pair production
Electric field of atom/nucleus
Cerenkov, bremsstrahlung
Radiative collisions
Interactions with the electric atomic/nuclear field for photons and charged
1.7.2 Interaction with electric field of atom The electric field created by the charge and motion of atomic electrons and the nucleus and its nucleons provides an environment that enables some interactions to take place. These interactions are outlined in Fig. 1.9 and introduced above.
Photon interactions Pair production This is an absorption process in which a photon disintegrates into an electron and a positron. e− e+ For this reaction to take place the energy of the photon Atom has to be greater than the rest-mass energy of the pair nucleus γ produced, i.e. 2 × 0.511 = 1.022 MeV. Photon energy in excess of this rest-mass energy is shared as kinetic E > 1.022 MeV energy between the electron and the positron. Obviously this pair has to have some kinetic energy, otherwise the two particles will recombine. Simultaneous conservation of momentum and energy requires the presence of a third body/field, which in this case is the atomic electron or the nucleus, that recoils to conserve momentum. Pair production in the field of the atomic electrons is much less significant than that within the field of the nucleus. In the electron field, the target electron recoils with significant momentum, due to its small mass, and the process is referred to as triplet production (see Section 1.7.1).
Charged-particle interactions Cerenkov radiation When a charged particle moves in a medium at a speed greater than the phase velocity of light in this medium21 , the electric field of the particle is subjected to a strong perturbation. If v < nc , the perturbation is cancelled by destructive wave interferences in all directions. However, if v > nc , the waves constructively interfere,
γ ± n<1 c > n
phase velocity of light in a medium is equal to nc , where c is the speed of light in vacuum and n is the medium’s optical index of refraction.
21 The
46
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
producing an optical “shock wave’’ (in the same manner a supersonic jet generates very intense waves: the Mach waves). The result is the emission of electromagnetic radiation in the visible range called the Cerenkov radiation. This phenomenon is typically observed with electrons as they can easily acquire speeds larger than the speed of light in the medium. Transition radiation When a high-energy charged particle crosses a boundary between two media of different dielectric permittivity, hence different atomic structure, a sudden change in the rate of energy loss occurs. This mismatch results in an acceleration or deceleration of the charged particle, and is compensated by the emission of X-rays, called the X-ray transition radiation.
γ
Bremsstrahlung When a free electron approaches the positively charged nucleus, it experiences an attraction force that deflects its electron and causes the electron to accelerate. This sudden acceleration causes the emission of a pulse of radiation in the form of a photon. This in turn causes the electron to lose kinetic energy, and it slows down. The emitted radiation is, therefore, called the braking or impulse radiation, and more commonly the bremsstrahlung22 .The bremsstrahlung produced by electrons in the field of the nucleus of heavy elements is the main source of photons in X-ray tubes. The acceleration of a positron in the field of a free electron also produces bremsstrahlung. However, the bremsstrahlung emitted as a result of acceleration of an electron in the field of another electron (by the repulsion force), tends to be weak, since the bremsstrahlung electric fields of the incident electron and the target electron are out of phase with each other, resulting in a destructive interference. This interaction, in the field of the nucleus, is quite pronounced in electrons, much more than heavy charged particles, because of the small mass of the electron, which makes it quite susceptible to accelerating and deceleration. This effect is, therefore, negligible for all heavy charged particles. However, when a charged particle collides with a free electron, that electron can itself produce its own bremsstrahlung.
1.7.3 Nuclear interactions Notation Nuclear interactions/reactions are defined by the notation a X(z, y)b Y, where z designates the projectile radiation particle, a X refers to a target nucleus of element X which has a mass number a, and b Y is the residual nucleus of mass number b, left after the interaction. Since the number of nucleons in this interaction must be conserved, the mass number of all involved radiation particles must also be conserved. In addition, the charge must be conserved. For example, 1 H(n,n)1 H 22 Bremsstrahlung
is German, from “bremse’’ (brake) and “strahlung’’ (radiation).
1.7 Reactions and Interactions
47
is an interaction where the neutron simply scatters without affecting the target nucleus; hydrogen with mass number 1 in this case. Therefore, the latter reaction is simply referred to as 1 H(n,n). Also in the reaction 56 Fe(n,n )56 Fe∗ , the target element stays the same (iron with mass number 56) but is in an excited state (indicated by ∗) after emitting a neutron. Since the emitted neutron may not necessarily be the same as the incident neutron, it is designated as n . The same reaction can be expressed as 56 Fe(n,nγ), since the excited nucleus subsequently releases immediately the excitation energy in the form of a γ-ray. It is then understood that the outgoing neutron is not necessarily the incident neutron (from a practical point of view, the two are indistinguishable), and that the nucleus did not elementally change, and it has been in an excited state. A third example is 10 B(n,α)7 Li; note the conservation of the mass number with an α particle having a mass number of 4. The last example also implicitly conserves the number of protons via the explicit designation of the elements and particles (5 + 0 = 2 + 3). Nuclear interactions involve not only neutrons, but also photons and charged particles that have sufficient energy to overcome the atomic electric field in order to reach the nucleus. The following are other observed interactions, aside from elastic and inelastic scattering: (n,γ), (n,p), (n,2n), (γ,n), (γ,p), (p,α), (p,d), (p,n), (p,γ), (d,α), (d,p), (d,n), (d,2n), (n,α), (α,p), and (α,n). The discussion below considers a general incident particle, z.
Reaction types When a radiation particle approaches a nucleus it is affected by its strong forces and its electric field. However, in many cases a simple collision between two solid particles occurs, resulting in the so-called “hard-ball’’ collisions. If the incident particle succeeds in penetrating the nucleus, the target nucleus can be viewed as a “soft ball’’. A more formal way of describing these reactions is by referring to them as elastic and non-elastic, since in the hard-ball collision the target nucleus returns to its original state after the interaction, while some “deformation’’ takes place in the case of soft-ball interactions. In other words, the nucleus acquires some internal energy in the case of non-elastic scattering. With the incident radiation being inside the potential well of the target nucleus, a “compound nucleus’’ is formed, typically in an excited state. If this new excited state is stable, the nucleus can remain in this state indefinitely. In many cases though, the excited state is metastable and the compound nucleus attempts to reach a more stable state by emitting gamma rays, neutrons, charged particles, or a combination of thereof. If the de-excitation is not immediate, i.e. prompt, subsequent de-excitation becomes in effect a nuclear decay process (see Section 1.6). Figure 1.10 provides a flowchart of various possible nuclear interactions, a brief description of each interaction is given below.
Elastic and ground-state scattering Potential scattering When a radiation particle encounters a potential field and does not affect it, or if the effect is so negligible to be observable, the interaction
48
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
Total (z,total)
Ground state reaction (2) (z,z0)
Inelastic scattering (4,102–107) (z,z)
Excited state reaction (3) (z,non-elastic)
Absorption (27) (z,abs)
Fission (18) (z,fission)
Electric field interactions (517)
Production of neutrons (16,17,37) (z,kn)
Disappearance (101) (z,disap)
Production of neutrons and charged particles (11, 22–37,41–45) (z,jnjq)
Radiative capture (102) (n,γ) Production of charged particles (103–117) (n,jq)
Figure 1.10 Types of nuclear interactions for a radiation particle z, where j, j are integers ≥1, and k is also an integer ≥1 expect for z = n where k ≥ 2, q designates a charged particle different from z (if z was charged), and the numbers in parenthesis are the ENDF MT numbers described in Table 3.2.
would simply be between the solid matter of the proPlane wave jectile and target. This occurs, for instance, when a (scattered particle) neutron collides with a nucleus without penetrating Nucleus it. The process then resembles a “hard-ball’’ collision, and its kinematics can be described by conventional Plane wave conservations laws of momentum and energy. When (incident particle) the radiation particle is viewed as a plane wave, the wave will be reflected on the solid surface of the field (i.e. that of the target it represents). The scattering is then called potential scattering. In effect, the incident particle is deflected by the short-range strong nuclear forces as it approaches the nucleus, without touching the nucleus. No compound nucleus is formed in this process. Coulomb elastic scattering Charged particles can scatter elastically by the force between the electric fields of an incident particle and a target nucleus. Direct collision, or contact, between the incident particle and the nucleus is, therefore,
1.7 Reactions and Interactions
49
not necessary. In this type of collision, the charged particle Nucleus is deflected without exciting the nucleus and without being accompanied with the release of electromagnetic radiation. The incident particle loses only the kinetic energy needed for conservation of momentum. The scattering of slow charged Repulsive particles by heavy nuclei is called Rutherford scattering 23 . In quantum mechanics, the elastic scattering of an electron with Nucleus the Coulomb field of the nucleus is called Mott scattering. When the incident particles and the target are identical, e.g. a proAttractive ton on a hydrogen nucleus, the incident and target particles, become indistinguishable, and quantum treatment of the scattering between the two particles requires accounting for the interference between their waves. The interaction is then known as Mott scattering between identical particles. Thomson nucleus scattering Thomson scattering refers to the scattering of electromagnetic radiation by a charged particle. The nucleus being a charged particle subjects incident photons to this type of elastic (coherent) scattering. This scattering combines coherently with Rayleigh scattering, and its effect is quite small due to the large mass of the nucleus. Resonance scattering Elastic scattering can also take place by the formation of a compound nucleus, Nucleus with the subsequent re-emergence of a particle of the same type as the incident particle (no other Target Compound Residual types of radiation is emitted). That is, the total kinetic energy of the incident particle and the nucleus are conserved, and the nucleus stays at its ground state. This is known as compound elastic scattering or resonance elastic scattering, since this process favors particles with energies that resonate with (match) one of the energy levels in the nucleus. At high particle energy, where the energy levels are so close that they appear to be continuous, all particle energies become susceptible to this type of scattering, which can then be called smooth or unresolved resonance scattering; with the word “unresolved’’ reflecting the fact that the resonance levels are no longer distinguishable. Since in this scattering process the target nucleus remains in its original state, without experiencing any nuclear excitation, the reaction is designated as (z, z0 ) or simply (z, z), where z refers to the incident particle and z0 signifies that the target nucleus remains in the ground state after the particle z re-emerges. Resonance (resolved or unresolved) neutron elastic scattering occurs with all nuclei, since there is no Coulomb barrier it is easier for the compound nucleus to emit a neutron than to 23 Rutherford
scattering, in general, is the scattering of heavy charged particles under the Coulomb field of the nucleus. Therefore, the term is also used to describe high-energy distant collisions in which direct contact between the interacting particles does not take place.
50
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
emit a charged particle. Moreover, γ emission is a slow process, in comparison to the emission of particles, and as such the latter usually takes precedence over the emission of γ radiation. In practice, all above elastic scattering processes amount to the same effect: conservation of both the total kinetic energy and momentum of the colliding bodies, with the target nucleus staying at its ground state. In most cases, the energy of the radiation particle is much higher than the energy of the target nucleus, and the target can be considered in practice to be stationary (i.e. at rest). In effect, a target nucleus possesses the thermal energy of its atom, which typically results in very small vibration (kinetic) energy, in the meV range (see Section 3.3.7). The target nucleus then receives some kinetic energy, which causes it to “recoil’’. Inelastic scattering In this process, a particle of the γ Nucleus same type as the incident particle re-emerges. Since in practice the same type of particle reappears, the process is considered a scattering process in which Target Compound Residual the particle changes both its direction and energy. This process involves the formation of a compound nucleus, which immediately releases a particle of the same type as the incident particle leaving a nucleus in the excited state. The resulting nucleus is referred to as the residual nucleus to distinguish it from the original target nucleus. This nucleus in turn releases its excitation energy in the form of a γ-ray with an energy that depends on the excitation level from which the nucleus is de-excited. The reaction is designated as (z,zi ) to indicate that the residual nucleus is left in the ith state, or (z,z ) or (z,zγ) when all the excited states are considered. The set of nuclear levels, including the ground state, is referred to as the exit channels. Note that the γ radiation emitted in this reaction is due to the de-excitation of the residual nucleus, unlike the radiation capture gammas which are a direct product of the interaction. Therefore, the incident particle must have sufficient energy to bring the nucleus to its first excitation state, unlike radiative capture which can take place even at very low particle energy. The minimum energy required for inelastic scattering is called the threshold energy, and it is on the order of a few MeV for light nuclei, but is only around 100 keV or less for heavy nuclei. This reaction is commonly observed with fast neutrons, as in the case of the 12 C(n,n )12 C∗ and the 238 U(n,n )238 U∗ reactions, requiring, respectively, threshold energies of 4.8 MeV and 45 keV24 .This reaction also occurs when a charged particle passes sufficiently close to the nucleus to be influenced by the nuclear forces, and transfers a sufficient amount of its kinetic energy to the nucleus to bring it to an excited state. The charged particle also changes its direction of motion. Whether the incident particle is neutral or 24 The
threshold energy is greater than the energy of the first excitation level for reasons explained in Section 2.7.2, Eq. (2.148).
51
1.7 Reactions and Interactions
charged, the total kinetic energy of the interaction is not conserved, since the energy associated with nuclear excitation comes at the expense of the kinetic energy of the incident particle. Non-elastic reactions If the target atom/nucleus is viewed as a “soft ball’’, then an incoming radiation particle can penetrate it, and in essence provide it with some additional “internal’’ energy. This in effect causes the particle to “fall ’’ into the potential well, increasing its energy. The target nucleus becomes excited, a state that is not sustainable, since stability is durable only at the ground state (i.e. at minimum potential energy). Then, a number of processes can take place as discussed below. γ γ Nucleus
Absorption Fission or spallation
Radiative Charged- Neutron capture particle production production
Absorption An incident particle can be absorbed by the nucleus in a non-elastic interaction. While such absorption leads to the disappearance of the incident radiation, it also adds energy into the potential field that can destabilize the nucleus. In some heavy nuclides, such as those of uranium and plutonium, an absorbed neutron can deposit sufficient energy to break up the nucleus into smaller nuclides, causing a fission process that is also accompanied by the release of a few neutrons. Highly energetic25 charged particles can also shatter nuclides with intermediate mass leading to the emission of several particles, in a process known as spallation. In fission and in spallation, a few more particles of the same type as the original incident radiation re-emerge, leading in effect to “apparent’’ multiplication of radiation. Radiative capture Radiation absorption is often accompanied by the release of γ radiation, hence the process is called radiative capture and denoted by (z,γ). The emission of γ-rays is not accompanied by particle emission, and is a direct result of the interaction, unlike that associated with inelastic-scattering γ-ray which is produced as the compound nucleus decays. The captured incident radiation, in effect, becomes bound to the target nucleus, forming a new nuclide. 25 In
the domain of high-energy physics: 10 MeV to the GeV range.
52
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
The γ-ray is released as a result of the excess binding energy. However, the newly formed nuclide may itself be radioactive, and decays and releases radiation. Examples of radiative-capture reactions include 1 H(n,γ)2 H, 238 U(n,γ)239 U∗ , and 12 C(p,γ)13 N∗ . The asterisk (∗) in these reactions indicate that the product residual is unstable and will subsequently decay; by β− in the case of 235 U to 239 Np (which also decays to 239 Pu after another β− emission) and by β+ emission in the case of 13 N to 13 C. Notice that neutron capture results in the production of an isotope of the same element as that of the target nucleus, while the absorption of a charged particle gives rise to a new element. Charged-particle production Here reactions that produce a charged particle different from the incident particle are considered. If upon the absorption of an incident particle the release of γ-ray energy does not result in a stable nucleus, charged particles (one or more) can be ejected. When an incident particle enters a nucleus, it can be captured in one of the excitation levels of the nucleus.Whenever the excitation energy is larger than the binding energy of a proton, plus the energy required to overcome the Coulomb barrier, a proton is emitted from the nucleus. If more than one excited state is created by the incident particle, a group of particles can be emitted, usually accompanied by γ radiation that brings the residual nucleus to the ground state. If the energy of the incident particle is very high, it can directly knock out individual nucleons from the nucleus. A third charged-particle mechanism is called stripping, in which multi-nucleon incident particles, particularly deuterons, are broken up by the nuclear forces as they approach the nucleus. In the case of the deuteron, it splits into a neutron and a proton. The neutron, being neutral, is easily absorbed by the nucleus, while the proton is repelled by the Coulomb field of the nucleus and appears as an ejected particle. That is, in (d,p) reactions, the emerging proton does not arise from the target nucleus, but only appears to. The reverse of this stripping process occurs in the proton–deuteron, (p,d), and proton–triton, (p,t) reactions, where the incident particle acquires a nucleon or more, rather than losing one. When several particles are emitted, the reaction is called “spallation’’. Examples of charged particle producing reactions include: 3 He(n,p)3 H, 26 Mg(γ,p)25 Na∗ , 10 B(n,α)7 Li, 16 O(n,p)16 N, 63 Cu(p,n)63 Zn, 209 Bi(d,p)210 Bi∗ , and 27Al(α,p)30 Si. Neutron production This reaction does not include fission, which is considered as part of the neutron absorption process, since it can take place at low particle (neutron) energy. It does not include the (n,n) and (n,n ) reactions, which are not obviously production reactions. A charged particle or a photon can release a neutron, from a compound nucleus or by direct interaction, when they have an energy larger than the neutron’s binding energy in the nucleus. Examples of these (z,n) reactions, with z = n, include: 2 H(γ,n)1 H , 9 Be(γ,n)8 Be, 2 H(d,n)3 He, and 3 H(d,n)4 He. At high incident-particle energy, the probability of emitting a nucleon from the compound nucleus, or by direct interaction, decreases; otherwise this single nucleon will carry an excessively large energy.Therefore, the probability
1.8 Macroscopic Field
53
of emitting two nucleons begins to increase as the probability of ejecting a single nucleon decreases. At even higher energy, the release of two nucleons decreases, as the emission probability of three nucleon increases, and so on. The emission of a neutron is favored over the release of a charged particle, since there is no Coulomb field to overcome; and the reactions (z,2n), and (z,3n) are usually more probable (but not always) than the emission of charged particles (alone or in combination of one neutron or more). In either case, the incident particle must have an energy greater than the threshold energy required to liberate each of the emitted particles. As such, these reactions appear at high incident energy. For example, the reaction 209 Bi(α,2n)211At requires α particles with more than 21.1 MeV, while the 209 Bi(α,3n)210At reaction becomes possible at an energy of almost 30 MeV. Simultaneous production of neutrons and charged particles In some cases, combinations of neutrons and charged particles are ejected from the compound nucleus, or as a result of a direct interaction, though neutron production is favored over the generation of charged particles. This typically happens when a nucleus with more dense energy levels is produced. For example, the reaction 63 Cu(p,pn)62 Cu is more likely than the 63 Cu(p,2n)62 Zn reaction.
Electric field interactions Pair production The production of a positron and an electron resulting from the disintegration of a photon of energy greater than the combined rest mass of this pair of charged particles (2 × 0.511 MeV) is in effect a photon absorption process. This interaction, known as pair production, requires the presence of an external charged particle, which recoils to enable the simultaneous conservation of momentum and energy. Therefore, it also occurs in the presence of the field of a nucleus, as well as in the field of atomic electrons. However, pair production in the field of the nucleus is much more likely than that with the field of the atomic electrons. Delbruck scattering This is an elastic scattering caused by the potential electric field of the nucleus. Although the photon has no charge, it is affected by the electric field of the nucleus, if it is viewed as consisting of a “virtual’’ electron– positron pair. This charge pair is then scattered in the Coulomb field of the nucleus, and the two virtual particles recombine to form a photon of the same energy as that of the original photon. The only observed change is then a change in angle. As such, this interaction is often thought of as a coherent scattering. Its effect is, however, very small, and is hardly detectable.
1.8 Macroscopic Field So far we have considered a single projectile (a neutron, a photon, or a charged particle), a single target (an atomic electron, an atom, or a nucleus), and
54
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
the interaction between one projectile and one target. In reality these radiation projectiles travel in a flux of many entities, and they can encounter an enormous number of targets as they travel through a medium. One, therefore, must take a macroscopic view of radiation and the medium it interacts within, while accommodating the microscopic “one-projectile on one-target’’ mechanisms. These aspects are considered here, after examining the nature of the space within which radiation travels.
1.8.1 Transport space As explained in Section 1.4, targets with which radiation interacts are presented directly by the atom or the nucleus or the electric field associated with them. These effects are only felt by a projectile, if it passes in the proximity of a target, since the range of nuclear forces is limited while the Coulomb force decreases rapidly with distance, as explained in Section 1.4. However, the targets occupy only a small fraction of the available space, as demonstrated below. While charged particles are continuously affected by surrounding electromagnetic fields, a neutral particle can travel some distance before encountering a target to interact with. A neutral projectile may also miss a target altogether. This affects the interaction rate as discussed in Section 1.8.4. We begin, however, by examining the space occupied by atoms in a medium.
Sparseness As shown in Section 1.4, following Eq. (1.15), the mass density of the matter from which the nucleus is made is equal to 2.3 × 1017 kg/m3 . This is obviously an extremely high density compared to the material density normally observed26 . This analysis is indicative of the fact that the nuclei are widely distributed over the volume and the space in between them is vacant. Even for the most dense material, the nuclei occupy about 10−14 of the total volume. The space that the atomic electrons occupy is quite small, because of their very small mass. However, the electrons are spread around the nucleus over a larger distance. For example, the radius of the smallest atom, hydrogen, as given by Bohr constant, is 5.29 × 10−11 m, compared to a nucleus radius of 1.25 × 10−15 m, according to Eq. (1.15). For a heavy element like iron, the ionic and atomic radii27 are 6.45 × 10−11 and 1.72 × 10−10 m, respectively, compared with the nucleus’s 3.7 × 10−15 m.Taking the atomic radius and assuming that each atoms is a cube of width twice the atomic radius and a weight of Au, the density of iron (A = 56) can be shown to be about 2284 kg/m3 . This is still lower than the nominal density of iron, which shows that there is some overlapping between atoms. However, using the covalent radius of 1.17 × 10−11 m, one arrives at a density of 7255 kg/m3 , which is closer to the nominal density. 26 The
most dense elements are osium and iridium, with a densities of 22,610 and 22,650 kg/m3 , respectively. ionic radius is the radius in a crystal where the ions are packed together so that their outermost electronic orbits are in contact with each other, while the atomic radius is half the distance between two adjacent atoms in a crystal.
27 The
1.8 Macroscopic Field
55
Penetrability A fundamental difference between the transport medium of radiation and that of classical continuum mechanics (e.g. fluid mechanics) is that radiation transport is not hindered by boundaries or interfaces. That is, fluids are governed by the principle of impenetrability, which causes them to form interfaces between each other and prevents them from penetrating solid barriers. Radiation particles do not respect such barriers or interfaces. Consequently, radiation does not form clouds, droplets, clusters, or the likes. The implication of this penetrability of radiation is that while a fluid can be confined to a certain direction of flow, radiation can move in all directions. The result is that radiation has a full velocity directional distribution. Therefore, radiation intensity can change with the magnitude of its velocity (or energy) and with direction. Therefore, the transport space for radiation has the velocity vector, v , as an independent variable, much like the position vector, r and time, t. That is, the transport phase space is a seven-dimensional space: three for position, (x, y, z in cartesian coordinates), one for the magnitude of velocity (|v|) or equivalently energy (E), two for the direction of motion (), and one for time (t).
1.8.2 Particle density and flux In order to examine the transport of many particles at a time, one must consider the particle density, that is the number of particles per unit phase-space element in the transport space. Given that the transport space is a seven-dimensional space, then an element in this space is given by dV dE d dt, where dV is an infinitesimal spatial volume, dE an infinitesimal energy interval, d an infinitesimal solid angle, and dt an infinitesimal time interval. We speak then of t)dV dE d as being the number of particles per unit time within dV n( r , E, , with an energy in the interval dE around E, and with a direction in d around Then, n( r , E, , t) is the particle density function, or simply the particle density. . However, the particle flux is more commonly used and is introduced below. The concept of flux is a simple one, but it can be misunderstood. In general, flux is the rate of fluid, particle, or energy, flow through a surface, and the flux density is simply the flux per unit area. This conventional definition of flux is suitable in directionally well-defined flows, such as a fluid in a pipe, particles in a chute, or the lines of a magnetic field, where a surface area can be designated at a direction normal to the flow direction. Radiation particles tend to move in all directions, making it difficult to define a particular orientation for the particles or the surface. However, the dimensions of flux density is the number of flowing entities per unit area per unit time. The same dimensions can be arrived at if we consider the number length per unit volume per unit time, where the number length is the summation of the track-lengths of all particles passing through the unit volume, as schematically shown in Fig. 1.11. This definition better suits radiation particles as it removes any directional dependence, while maintaining the concept of flux as pertaining to flow. The higher the flux, the more the
56
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
li f= i
∑ li V
per unit time
li = length of radiation track i within volume V
Figure 1.11 A schematic showing the definition of flux.
density of the tracks crossing the volume, the more particles are passing through the volume. The flux density, φ (called simply flux), is then related to the particle density, n(v), for particles moving at a certain velocity, v, by the relationship: li li per unit time v φ(v) = per unit time = = V V V Total number of particles of speed v × v = n(v)v (1.45) φ(v) = V where the notations are as shown in Fig. 1.11, and v in the parentheses indicates that the associated quantity is defined for particles moving at a velocity v. For photons, v = c, where c is the speed of light; then φ = nc. However, this definition of flux does not take into consideration the directionality of the flowing particle. the flux of particles of energy E A better definition is then given by φ(E; ), moving in the direction .This definition accommodates both photons and other charged particles, by considering energy, rather than velocity, while accounting only for one direction (yet not focusing on a particular surface area).The following relationships can then be established between the flux, φ, and the particle density, n, starting from the most basic definition of the angular flux density (also called t), i.e. the flux in a given direction for particles with a pointance), φ( r , E, , certain energy E at given instant in time, t: t) = vn( r , E, , t) φ( r , E, , t)d φ( r , E, t) = φ( r , E, ,
(1.46) (1.47)
4π
t) = φ( r , ,
t)dE φ( r , E, ,
(1.48)
φ( r , E, t)dE
(1.49)
φ( r , E, t)dt
(1.50)
φ( r , t) = φ( r , E) =
57
1.8 Macroscopic Field
where r designates some point in the space at a distance and location defined by the vector r . The flux integrated over time, φ( r , E), is known as the particle fluence, or simply fluence; also called irradiation, irradiance, or exposure. The above definitions of flux enable one to specify the flux at any level of detail over the basic seven coordinates of the transport space. The particle current density, or simply current, J , is given by the relationship: t) = v n( r , E, , t) J ( r , E, , vn( r , E, , t) = φ( r , E, , t) =
(1.51)
Therefore, the current is the directed flow of particles in a given direction , and like flux it can be integrated over energy and time. The current density, J , can be used as a measure of the number of particles crossing a surface in a given direction, by simply projecting the vector J on the desired direction across the surface. Current, therefore, includes directional characteristics, while the flux, φ, is simply a scalar quantity.
1.8.3 Atomic/nuclear density In order to account for the presence of many atoms/nuclei in a medium, one must determine the atomic density, that is the number of atoms per unit volume, N , which is simply expressed as: N =
ρ Mass of material per unit volume (density) = Mass of a single atom Au
(1.52)
where ρ is the material density (mass per unit volume) and Au is the mass of an atom of mass number A, with u being the atomic mass unit (= 1.6605 × 10−27 kg). Equation (1.52) is often expressed as N = Aρ A0 , with ρ in g/cm3 and A0 being Avogadro’s number (= 0.6022 × 1024 g/mol). For a mixture of density ρm , the density of each element in the mixture, wρm , should be used, with w being the weight fraction of the element in the matrix. For a compound of a molecular weight, M , one calculates the number of molecules per unit volume, Nm , as: Nm =
Mass of material per unit volume (density) ρ = Mass of a single molecule Mu
(1.53)
Then one can determine the atomic density for a particular element in the molecule from chemical composition. For example, H2 O has two hydrogen atoms and one oxygen atom, as such the atomic density of H in H2 O is equal to 2Nm and that of O is Nm , where Nm is calculated using Eq. (1.53) at the proper water density and with M = 2 × 1 + 1 × 16 = 18.
58
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
1.8.4 Interaction rate The introduction of the particle flux density along with the atomic density enables direct evaluation of the interaction rate, R, per unit volume. The number of interactions a particle i encounters has to be proportional to the distance, li , it travels within a volume V , the longer the distance the higher the number of interactions. More interactions will also occur if there are more targets, i.e. more atoms or more nuclei per unit volume, N . In addition, the higher the probability of interaction, σ, of each particle with each target, the larger is the interaction probability. Therefore, in an infinitesimal volume, V , the interaction rate per unit time per unit volume for all particles can be expressed as: d R=N dt
i li σ
V
=N
i vi σ
V
(1.54)
where vi is the velocity of particle i. For particles of the same velocity, v, or energy, E, Eq. (1.54) can be expressed as: R(E) = N σ(E)nv(E) = N σ(E)φ(v)
(1.55)
where n(E) is the number of particles per unit volume that have a velocity v, or energy E, and use was made of Eq. (1.45) to introduce the flux, φ(v). Matching the dimensions in the two sides of Eq. (1.55) dictates that σ(E) has dimensions of area in order for R to be the number of interactions per unit volume per unit time. Recalling that σ designates the interaction probability of one radiation particle with one target, it is referred to as the microscopic cross section. In essence, σ represents the area projected by the target to the incoming projectile. Therefore, one would expect its value to be on the same order of magnitude as the crosssection area of the target, which for a nucleus, using Eq. (1.15), is on the order of 10−28 m2 , or so. Therefore, the microscopic cross section is reported in the unit of barn (b), with 1 b = 10−28 m2 = 10−24 cm2 . The value of σ depends on the nature of the target, as well as on the type of incident radiation and its energy and the nature of the interaction. In case of scattering, there is dependence on the angle of scattering. Cross-section libraries report these values, which are either measured or calculated using quantum mechanics (as discussed in Chapter 3).
Macroscopic cross section The quantity: = Nσ
(1.56)
represents the overall target area projected by all nuclei in a unit volume, and as such is called the macroscopic cross section. From Eq. (1.56), it is evident that the macroscopic cross section is the summation of the microscopic cross sections
59
1.8 Macroscopic Field
of all targets per unit volume. Therefore, for a mixture, one can write: (mixture) = αi i
(1.57)
i
where αi is the volume fraction occupied by species i and i is its total cross section. Note that wi = ρρi αi , where wi is the weight fraction and ρi is the density of the material of component i, and ρ is the mixture’s density. The macroscopic cross section of a compound can be calculated from the microscopic cross sections, σi s, of its elements as: (compound) = Ni σi (1.58) i
where Ni is the target density of element i, which for atoms and nuclei is: Ni = wi
ρ Ai u
(1.59)
where Ai is the mass number of element i. Combining the above two equations gives: ρ (compound) = σi = wi wi i (1.60) Ai u i i where i is the macroscopic cross section of element i, if it had the density of the compound. As evident from Eq. (1.56), the macroscopic cross section has dimensions of inverse distance. It can, therefore, be thought of as the probability of interaction per unit distance, in the same manner the decay constant λ (which has dimensions of inverse time) was shown in Section 1.6 to be the probability of decay per unit time. Therefore, the same probabilistic arguments used to derive the exponential law of decay can be used to derive the exponential law of attenuation (reduction in radiation intensity), so that: I = I0 exp(−x)
(1.61)
where I0 is the intensity of a narrow beam of radiation incident on material of thickness x, and I is the intensity of the radiation that succeeds in penetrating the material. The use of a narrow beam is necessary here due to the one-dimensionality of the relationship (only in x), which excludes any radiation transport in other directions; a process conceivable only in narrow beams. Nevertheless, this attenuation law elucidates the physical meaning of as an attenuation coefficient. The value ρ is customarily reported for photons, as it provides a density-independent parameter, and is referred to as the mass attenuation coefficient. The one-dimensionality of the attenuation law makes it possible to describe the movement of particles in one specific direction, along some distance x, by exponential attenuation. Then one can state that the probability a
60
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
radiation particle traveling a distance x without interacting then interacting at a distance between x and x + dx is: p(x)dx = exp(−t x)t dx
(1.62)
where the exponential term is the survival probability to x and dx is the interaction probability within dx. Using the above equation, the mean distance of travel, or the mean-free-path (mfp), that is the average distance a radiation particle will travel between interactions, is given by: ∞ ∞ 1 mfp = xp(x)dx = xexp(−x)dx = (1.63) 0 0 This gives the macroscopic cross section another useful meaning as the reciprocal of the mean-free-path. In other words, within a distance x, a radiation particle x = x interactions. That is, can also be viewed as on average will encounter mfp the average number of interactions per unit length. The distance 1 is also called the relaxation distance, since according to Eq. (1.61), 1 is the distance required to attenuate a beam of radiation to 1e (= 0.3679) of its initial value.
1.9 Problems Section 1.3 1.1 Using Eq. (1.6), show that for a particle of v << c, the kinetic energy is given by the classical expression: 12 m0 v 2 . 1.2 Consider a light wave of wavelength λ = 5 × 10−7 m. 1. Plot this wave over a distance in the interval: [−5λ, +5λ], at a certain time. 2. Replot the above wave combined with a wave of a wave number of 1.1k, where k is the wave number of the original wave. 3. Combine the two waves with a third wave of wavenumber of 1.2k, and replot the combined wave. 4. Add an additional wave with a wave number of 1.3k to the above three waves and plot the combined wave. 5. Comment on the development of a wave packet as these waves are combined. 1.3 A 6.6 kg bowling ball moving at a speed of 10 m/s. 1. Calculate the width of the slit through which this ball can diffract. 2. If the slit width is 250 mm, what will be the particle speed necessary for the bowling ball to exhibit diffraction? Comment on your answers.
61
1.9 Problems
1.4 The kinetic energy of a particle is T = 12 mv 2 , while that of its associated wave is T = hν. The momentum of the particle is p = mv and that of the associated 1
mv 2
h 2 1 wave is p = λh . The speed of the wave is c = λν = mv h = 2 v. This wave speed seems to be only half that of the particle it is associated with. If this is the case, the particle and its associated wave would not stay together. What is wrong with this analysis? Propose an alternative analysis that ensures that the particle and its associated wave have the same speed. 1.5 If the two sinusoidal waves sin[(k − k)x − (ω − ω)t] and sin[(k + k)x − (ω + ω)t] are combined, show that the shape they form has a velocity of w
k . Using the argument that when a group of continuous waves are combined, the velocity of the wave packet would be w
k , show that the velocity of the wave packet will be identical to the particle it is associated with. 1.6 A group of waves of wavelengths around λ + δλ are grouped into a wave packet to resemble a particle of velocity v. Show that the velocity of the wave packet is equal to that of the particle. du , where λ is the Hint:The group velocity, w, of waves is given by w = u −λ dλ wavelength of an individual wave and u is the velocity of that wave (called the phase velocity) = νu , with ν being the frequency of the individual wave. 1.7 A ball with a mass of 0.10 kg is approaching a player at a speed of 45 ± 1 m/s. What is the uncertainty in determining its position at a given instant. Comment on the results.
Section 1.4 1.8 Using the uncertainty principle determine the range of each of the four natural forces. 1.9 Prove that the quantity: r0 =
μ0 e 2 4πme
(1.64)
has dimensions of meters and determine its value, where μ0 is the vacuum permeability, me is the rest mass of the electron and e is its charge. The above quantity is called the classical radius of the electron. Rewrite the above expression in terms of the permittivity in vacuum, ε0 , and elaborate on the 2 physical meaning of 4πεe 0 r0 . 1.10 For an electron evolving around a nucleus, assuming a circular orbit, show that the electron’s magnetic moment Mm = − 2me e ωr , where ωr is the angular moment of the electron, e its charge and me its mass. 1.11 Show that if the sum of the quantum angular momentum, l, for a system of particles is a positive number, the system has an even parity, and if the sum is an odd number, the system has an odd parity.
62
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
1.12 Two particles, a and b, occupy any of two states. Distribute these two particles according to classical statistics (Maxwell–Boltzmann), Bose–Einstein statistics, and Fermi–Dirac statistics. Explain your logic. Hint: in the latter two distributions, the two particles are considered to be indistinguishable from each other.
Section 1.5 1.13 The binding energy, B(Z, A), can be represented as a function of the atomic number, Z, and the mass number, A, by the expression: B(Z, A) = a1 A − a2 A 3 − a3 Z(Z − 1)A− 3 − a4 (2Z − A)2 A−1 2
1
+ a5 A− 4 3
(1.65)
where the a’s are constants that can be obtained by best curve fitting of the above expression to actual binding energy data. 1. Explain the physical basis behind each term. 2. Calculate the binding energy for the following nuclides: 4 He (4.0026032), 6 Li (6.0151223), 8 Be (8.0053051), 12 C (12), 16 O (15.9949146), 20 Ne (19.9924402), 28 Si (27.9769265), 40 Ca (39.9625912), 58 Ni (57.9353479), 56 Fe (55.9349421), 100 Zr (99.9177617), 116 Sn (115.9017441), 208 Pb (207.9766359), and 209 Bi (208.9803832), using both Eqs (1.65) and (1.25), and compare the results. The numbers in parenthesis are the atomic masses, with mp = 1.00727647u, mn = 1.008665012u and u = 931.4943 MeV. Use the following values for the constants (all in MeV)28 : a1 = 15.5 a2 = 16.8 a3 = 0.72 a4 = 23, 34 even N and even Z 0 for odd N or odd Z a5 = −34 odd N and odd Z 3. Identify the nuclide(s) with the maximum binding energy. 4. Plot the binding energy per nucleon using the results obtained above, and compare the two curves.
Section 1.6 1.14 1. Use Poisson distribution to determine the expected (average) number of decays within a time interval t. nxn exp (−x) = x. Hint: ∞ n=0 n! 28 The semi-empirical mass formula (SEMF) Isobar mass chains (http://www.pp.rhul.ac.uk/ptd/TEACHING/PH2510/
nuclear-2-d.pdf).
63
1.9 Problems
2. What is the probability of a nucleus surviving a time t then decaying within t + t? 3. What is the mean-life time of a radionuclide that has a decay constant λ? 4. Can equilibrium conditions be reached when a parent nuclide decays to a daughter of about the same half-life? 1.15 Show that for α decay to take place the condition below must be satisfied: B1 B2 B2 1 Bα A1 − A2 − < (1.66) A1 − A2 A1 4 A2
1.16 1.17 1.18 1.19
1.20
where B refers to the binding energy, A to the mass number, and the subscript 1, 2 and α to the parent and daughter nuclei, and the α particle, respectively. Comment on the value of the change in the binding energy per nucleon, and whether α decay leads to a more stable nucleus. Using Eq. (1.65) show that nuclides of mass number greater than about 150 are all energetically unstable against α decay. α Are any of the following parity transitions of decay possible: (1) 1+ → 0+ , α + α − (2) 2− → 0+ , (3) 52 → 52 ? Express the binding energy conditions of β− , β+ and electron capture decay, i.e. Eqs (1.39)–(1.41) in terms of the atomic masses of the original and product nuclei. Comment on the results. The nuclide 64 Cu has all the three beta decay modes. Using the Isotope Explorer: http://ie.lbl.gov/ensdf/, identify these modes and for each mode report (1) the change in total angular momentum, (2) the change in parity, (3) the relative emission intensity, (4) the half-life, (5) the decay energy, and (6) the ft value. Comments on the relationship between these four properties of emission. Using the Isotope Explorer: http://ie.lbl.gov/ensdf/, under Level Table and the appropriate decay table, classify the following beta decay processes. Use the following log ft values as a guide: Superallowed 3.2–3.8, Allowed 3.5– 7.5, First-Forbidden 6–9, Second-Forbidden 10–13, Third-Forbidden 14– 20, Fourth-Forbidden ≈ 23. Recall that there are parity change conditions associated with each category. 1
n → H 3 H → He 6 He → Li 7 Be → Li
13
N→C
36
Cl → Ar
40
37
Rb → Sr
89
139
14
Ba → La
C→N
14
O→N
K → Ca
60
C→Y
115
141
17
F→O
11
C→B
35
S → Cl
Co → Ni
75
Ge → As
In → Sn
137
Cs → Ba
87
Kr → Rb
Ce → Pr
1.21 Examine the beta transitions for 65 Ni → Ga for the change in the angular momentum quantum number l, and identify which one can be classified as l forbidden. (Use the Isotope Explorer: http://ie.lbl.gov/ensdf/).
64
Chapter 1 Mechanisms
1.22 Using the Isotope Explorer: http://ie.lbl.gov/ensdf/, examine and comment on the decay of 129Te to the ground state, in terms of the change in total angular momentum, parity, transition type (electric or magnetic multipole), internal conversion ratio (α), and isomeric transitions. 1.23 NuDat (http://www.nndc.bnl.gov/nudat2/) reports two modes for the decay of 252 Cf: 3.1% by spontaneous fission and 96.9% by α decay, both at a half-life of 2.645 y. If 252 Cf were to decay by spontaneous fission only, what would be its half-life? In other words, what is the partial half-life for 252 Cf decay by spontaneous fission? 1.24 Identify five delayed-beta neutron emissions (βn) and five delayed-beta proton (βp) emissions, with at least one example for ε-delayed decay. Comment on the trend. Hint: use NuDat: http://www.nndc.bnl.gov/nudat2/
Section 1.8 1.25 Consider water at the normal density of 1000 kg/m3 : 1. Calculate the number of molecules of H2 O in 1 m3 . 2. Assuming a spherical nucleus, calculate the total condensed volume and mass occupied by the nuclei of one H2 O molecule. Assume a condensed nuclear density of 2 × 1017 kg/m3 . From this, determine the packing factor of H2 O nuclei. 3. Assuming a mean radius of a water molecule, or in other words, the mean separation distance between the O and H atoms in the H O H atomic bond (van der Waal’s radius) to be 1.41 × 10−10 m, calculate the total condensed volume occupied by the H2 O molecules in 1 m3 . From this, determine the packing factor of H2 O molecules. 4. Calculate the maximum number of molecules that can be packed in a 1 m3 (i.e. at 100% packing factor). 5. Comment on the above volume-based results. 1.26 Particle flux can be defined as the number of particles per unit area per unit time, or as the number of particles that enter a sphere of unit cross-sectional area. Relate these definitions to the definition of flux density as the number of track lengths per unit volume. 1.27 The following cross sections are symbolically given: Radiation
Target
Interaction
Cross section
γ
Electron
Compton
σe
γ
Atom
Photoelectric
σpe
Neutron
Nucleus
Absorption
σa
Neutron
Molecule Thermal scattering
σs
65
1.9 Problems
Using these symbols, write expressions for the macroscopic cross sections for H2 O. 1.28 Consider that the microscopic cross section can be viewed as the area projected by the atom to an incoming beam of radiation, the probability that radiation will interact with the atoms in a layer of thickness x normal to the incident beam can be expressed as29 : p =
Area projected by atoms in layer Area of layer normal to incident beam
=
Area projected by one atom × number of atoms Area of layer normal to incident beam
=
σt × NA x = N σt x = t x A
(1.67)
where σt and t are the microscopic and macroscopic cross sections, respectively, A is the area of the layer, and N is the number of atoms per unit volume in the layer. The probability of radiation leaving the layer without interaction is then: q = 1 − p = 1 − t x
(1.68)
1. If n layers are staggered against each other, each of thickness x containing the same material, show that the flux leaving the nth layer, φn , is given by: φn = qn φ0
(1.69)
where φn is the flux of the incident beam. 2. As x → 0, n → ∞, shows that: φ = φ0 exp[−t x]
(1.70)
where φ is the flux incident on a layer of thickness x. Hint :
lim
n→∞
1+
a ab =e b
(1.71)
1.29 Prove that the mean-free-path is equal to the reciprocal of the linear attenuation coefficient. Explain why this relationship is valid only for radiation that can travel some distance without suffering any interactions with matter.
29 Problem
attributed to P. J. Arsenault.
This page intentionally left blank
C H A P T E R
TW O
Collision Kinematics
Contents 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9
Overview Center-of-Mass System Relativity Conservation Laws Einsteinian Kinematics Newtonian Kinematics Specific Interactions Electromagnetic Interactions Problems
67 68 74 80 83 104 108 123 146
2.1 Overview Kinematics is the study of motion of a system of bodies without directly considering the forces or potential fields affecting the motion. In other words, kinematics examines how the momentum and energy are shared among interacting bodies. Many of the interactions discussed in Chapter 1 are two-body interactions, in the sense that they involve two interacting entities: a projectile on a target. One important implication of two-body interactions is that there is a single plane that contains the two interacting particles. As such, there will be no momentum component off the plane of interaction. Therefore, the two bodies emerging from the interaction must be also on the same plane. Two-body interactions are, therefore, two-dimensional. In addition, with only two bodies, one can easily define a center-of-mass around which the incident and emerging particles will revolve. The center-of-mass is such that the total moment of the mass (mass × distance from the center-of-mass) is zero. Consequently, the center-ofmass is also such that the total momentum (mass × velocity) is also equal to zero. This facilitates considerably the performance of momentum balance. As such, kinematic analysis is performed in the center-of-mass. In Section 2.2, we discuss the relationship between the center-of-mass frame of reference and the laboratory frame of reference (in which observations are recorded). In addition to conserving Radiation Mechanics: Principles & Practice ISBN-13: 978-0-08-045053-7
© 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
67
68
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
energy and momentum, interactions must also abide by some stoichiometric and intrinsic conservation principles which are summarized in Section 2.4. When dealing with radiation particles, the small size of the particle can lead to magnitudes of velocities close to the speed of light. Photons always move at the speed light. These high speeds introduce special relativistic effects that must be taken into consideration. Therefore, the special theory of relativity is reviewed in Section 2.3, with particular attention to its impact on the conservation of energy and momentum. Of course, there are many instances in which relativistic effects are not important. Nevertheless, the use of relativistic kinematic analysis will lead to results that are valid both at high and low speeds. In essence, classical kinematics is a special case (a first order approximation) of relativistic mechanics, as demonstrated by some examples in this chapter. A detailed mathematical analysis of relativistic particle kinematics is given in [18]. Relativistic kinematics, often referred to as Einsteinian kinematics, is discussed in Section 2.5, while the non-relativistic classical Newtonian kinematics is addressed in Section 2.6. In Section 2.7, the kinematic analysis is applied to those interactions discussed in Chapter 1 that are not affected by electromagnetic fields. In most cases, the kinematics of radiation interactions concerns itself with the interaction of one projectile with a single target, unlike in the interaction of the molecules of a gas where the collective movement of the gas is considered. Gas dynamics necessitates an overall analysis of the motion of gas molecules, since these molecules interact with each other. In the case of radiation, the field density is generally quite low and interaction amongst radiation particles is quite improbable, and is simply ignored. Therefore, radiation interactions are considered as a one-on-one (projectile on a target) process, in which the incoming radiation imparts energy to the target, while not receiving energy from it. However, when radiation particles are in thermal equilibrium with the atoms of the medium, particles can gain energy from the target atoms; a process that is quite analogous with that of gases. However, the collective moment of radiation particles is dealt with in a probabilistic manner, as discussed in Section 3.3.7 for the thermal equilibrium of neutrons. As Chapter 1 showed, there are some radiation interactions that are governed by electromagnetic wave behavior, rather than by the corpuscular nature of radiation. The kinematics of these wave interactions are discussed in Section 2.8.
2.2 Center-of-Mass System Definition In the ordinary laboratory frame of reference, events of an interaction are described from the point of view of an external observer. When the observer is located at the center-of-mass of the two interacting bodies, the interaction can be described from the view point of an “internal’’ observer. The relationship between the two
69
2.2 Center-of-Mass System
is governed by a transformation between the two frames of reference. In a static system of multiple bodies, the center-of-mass measured from some reference point is such that: mi ri r0 = (2.1) mi where r0 is the distance of the center-of-mass from the point of origin, ri is the distance of a body of mass mi from the origin. In a dynamic system, we differentiate with respect to time to arrive at: dri mi dt dr0 mi vi v0 = = = mi mi dt
(2.2)
where v0 is the velocity of the center-of-mass (also called the center of momentum) system with respect to the lab system where the point of origin is located. The velocity vector vi of body i is along ri , and is considered to be positive if the particle is moving away from the point of origin of the lab system. Transformation between the center-of-mass frame of reference (C ) and the laboratory frame of reference (L) is then done using the relationship: v = v − v0
(2.3)
where v and v are velocity vectors in C and L, respectively. In the analysis below, the magnitude of a vector is designated by simply dropping off the vector notation. Note that the vectorial relationship of Eq. (2.3), applied to a certain particle, enables relating the angles of scattering in L and in C to each other using the law of sines on the triangle formed by this vector equation; i.e.: sin(ϑ − ϑ) sin(π − ϑ ) sin ϑ = = v v0 v
(2.4)
where the angles are as designated in Fig. 2.1.
υ
ϑ
υ ϑ
υ0
Figure 2.1 Velocity diagram relating C to L, where v is the velocity of a particle in L, v is its velocity in C and v 0 is the velocity of C itself.
70
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
ϑ4
m2, υ2
m2, υ2 ϑ4
ϑ3
m3, υ3
m4, υ4
m4, υ4 m3, υ3 ϑ3
C
m1, υ1
m1, υ1 L (Point of origin) Laboratory frame of reference (L)
Center-of-mass frame of reference (C)
Figure 2.2 Two particles approaching each other in the laboratory and the center-of-mass frames of reference.
Before an interaction Figure 2.2 schematically shows the relationship between C and L for the twobody interaction of a projectile 1 of mass m1 colliding with a target with mass m2 , resulting in the emergence of a particle 3 with mass m3 and particle 4 with mass m4 . Of course, if the reaction is an elastic one, then m1 = m3 and m2 = m4 . If a photon is emitted, m3 has to be replaced by an energy term, as will be shown in Section 2.3. If the initial particle velocities are, respectively, v1 and v2 , at some point in time, the definition of C requires that: m1 v1 − m2 v2 = (m1 + m2 )v0
(2.5)
which is equivalent to equating the rate of moment of the two masses dx0 dx2 1 (m1 dx dt + m2 dt ) to that of the center-of-mass ((m1 + m2 ) dt ) around a point of origin located somewhere along the line connecting the two particles, where dx2 1 x refers to distance from the origin in L. Note that if v1 = − dx dt , then v2 = − dt , since if particle 1 is moving away from the origin, particle 2 will be moving toward it, and vice versa. m1 (v1 − v0 ) − m2 (v2 + v0 ) = 0 (2.6) Since v0 is a vector along the direction of the incident particle (i.e. opposite to that of the target), the velocities of the projectile and the target in C are: v 1 = v1 − v0 v 2
= v2 − v0
v1 = v1 − v0 v2
= −(v2 + v0 )
(2.7) (2.8)
Therefore, Eq. (2.6) becomes: m1 v1 + m2 v2 = 0
(2.9)
71
2.2 Center-of-Mass System
The same relationship can be arrived at by equating the rate of moment of the dx1 dx2 two masses dt + dt around the center-of-mass to zero, where x refers to distance of particle from C , keeping in mind that both particles are moving in opposite directions toward C and x1 and x2 are opposite in sign. The important implication of Eq. (2.9) is that the total momentum in C is equal to zero. Comparing Eqs (2.5) to (2.9), one notices that in the latter equation the right-hand side is zero, and in determining the center-of-mass the momenta are added. These are due to the fact that the observer is at C (hence the zero value), and the projectile and target are moving toward C (hence the addition of momentum).
Reduced mass From Eq. (2.5): v1 m1 v1 − m2 v2 v2 v0 = = μ1,2 − m1 + m 2 m2 m1 where: μ1,2 =
m1 m2 m1 + m2
(2.10)
(2.11)
is known as the reduced mass. Note that if m2 >> m1 , μ1,2 ≈ m1 , and v0 ≈ v2 , i.e. C coincides with m2 as one would expect. Equation (2.10) can be expressed as: v0 v1 v2 = − μ1,2 m2 m1
(2.12)
Let us now consider the momentum of the reduced mass obtained by multiplying μ1,2 by the relative velocity, vr , of particle 1 with respect to the target 2, where vr = v1 − v2 . Then, vr = v1 − (−v2 ) = v1 + v2 ; with a negative sign associated with v2 because it is opposite to v1 . Using Eq. (2.12), it can then be shown that: ⎧ m1 v1 m1 v0 ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨ μ1,2 v1 + m2 − μ1,2 = (v1 − v0 )m1 = v1 m1 μ1,2 vr = μ1,2 (v1 +v2 ) = ⎪ m2 v0 m2 v2 ⎪ ⎪ + + v2 = (v2 + v0 )m2 = −v2 m2 ⎩ μ1,2 μ1,2 m1 (2.13) The above equation shows that the momentum of the reduced mass in terms of the relative velocity is equal to the momentum of the projectile or the target in C .That is, with the reduced mass and the relative velocity, one can easily determine the momentum of the projectile and the target, which arises of the fact that the total momentum in C is zero. In other words, one can reduce the two-body system to a single-body equivalent system of a mass equal to the reduced mass and a velocity
72
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
equal to the relative velocity. The latter velocity, vr , has the same value in both systems, since the relative velocity is not affected by the transformation from one frame of reference to another. That is: vr = v1 − v2 = v1 − v2
vr = v1 + v2 = v1 − v2
(2.14)
In turn, the momentum μ1,2 vr has the same value in either system, which is a useful tool for relating the two frames of references to each other.
After the interaction Let us now turn our attention to the emerging particles 3 and 4 in the C system. The center-of-mass of the emerging particle must be on the line joining the two particles, which necessitates that: m3 v3 + m4 v4 = 0
(2.15)
since the velocity of the center-of-mass is zero in C . This also shows that the total momentum remains zero in C after the interaction. Analogous to Eq. (2.13), one can state that: μ3,4 (v3 + v4 ) = v3 m3 = −v4 m2 (2.16) m4 . If the interaction is an elastic scattering, μ1,2 = μ3,4 , and the where μ3,4 = mm33+m 4 equivalent one-body system maintains the same momentum. Since the relative velocity does not change with system transformation, v3 + v4 = v1 + v2 . Then using Eq. (2.16), it becomes possible to determine both v3 and v4 in terms of v1 − v2 , for elastic scattering. The next step is to transform these values back to L. Let, as shown in Fig. 2.2, ϑ3 be the angle between the directions of particles 1 and 3 in L, and ϑ3 be the corresponding angle in C . Then one can project back v3 to v3 by adding to the former vectorially the velocity of C , as Eq. (2.3) indicates. That is, v3 = v3 + v0 (2.17) The velocity vectors can be expressed as:
v3 = v3 (cos ϑ3ˆi + sin ϑ3ˆj )
(2.18)
v 3 = v3 (cos ϑ3 ˆi + sin ϑ3 ˆj )
(2.19)
v0 = v0ˆi + 0ˆj
(2.20)
where ˆi and ˆj are, respectively, unit vectors in the direction cosines of the initial direction of incidence of particle 1 and the axis normal to it. Applying the above to Eq. (2.17) and equating the ˆi and ˆj components leads to: v3 cos ϑ3 = v3 cos ϑ3 + v0
(2.21)
v3 sin ϑ3 =
(2.22)
v3 sin ϑ3
73
2.2 Center-of-Mass System
Combining the above equations gives: tan ϑ3 =
sin ϑ3 cos ϑ3 +
(2.23)
v0 v3
With v3 known from Eq. (2.16) and with v0 determined by Eq. (2.10), the relationship between ϑ3 and ϑ3 is established by Eq. (2.23). That is, if one of those angles is known, the other is determined. Then, one can evaluate v3 using Eq. (2.22). The velocity, v4 , can then be also determined using Eq. (2.16).
Angular momentum and moment of inertia Another interesting kinematic quantity that maintains the same value in L and C is the angular momentum, J , around the center-of-mass. The angular momentum of a particle of mass m around a point is a vector product J = r × p, where r is the vector connecting the particle to the point and p is the linear momentum. The magnitude of J is | J | = mvr sin ψ, where ψ is the angle between r and v .Therefore, for the configuration of Fig. 2.3, the total angular momentum of particles 1 and 2 around C is: x | J | = [m1 (v1 − v0 )r1 + m2 (v2 + v0 )r2 ] r1 + r2 x = [m1 v1 r1 − m2 v2 r2 ] = μ1,2 vr x = μ1,2 (v1 + v2 )x (2.24) r1 + r 2 where use was made of Eq. (2.13).This shows that | J| stays the same in both frames of reference, which is expected, since they all differ by the translational velocity, v0 , that plays no part in the angular momentum.The distance x is known as the impact parameter, and is zero if the two particles are approaching each other head on. m1, z 1e
υ1 r1
r2
x
C
υ2
m2, z 2e
Figure 2.3 A schematic showing parameters for calculating the angular momentum around C.
74
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
The moment of inertia, I , around C for the configuration of Fig. 2.3 is given by: I = m1 r12 + m2 r22 = μ1,2 (r1 + r1 )2 =
m12 2 m2 r1 = 2 r22 μ1,2 μ1,2
(2.25)
where use is made of the definition of C which is such that m1 r1 = m2 r2 = μ1,2 (r1 + r2 ).
2.3 Relativity 2.3.1 Special theory of relativity The theory of relativity deals with the viewing of events by observers moving at different speeds. Its effect is quite significant for particles moving at speeds approaching the speed of light. This can happen for example to electrons, that easily acquire high speeds at low kinetic energy because of their very small mass. The special theory of relativity deals with systems at rest or those moving at a constant speed (without acceleration, i.e. not subjected to field effects). Therefore, this theory, first formulated by Einstein (1905), is quite relevant when dealing with radiation kinematics. The theory considers coordinate systems that are in uniform rectilinear translational motion relative to each other, and assumes in these systems that: 1. Physical laws maintain the same mathematical form. 2. The speed of light, c, is constant, and is independent of the motion of the source of light (or electromagnetic radiation). We will apply first the classical Galilean transformation, named x3 x 3 after Galileo (1564–1642), betυ0 ween two coordinate systems K (x1 , x2 , x3 ) and K (x1 , x2 , x3 ), with the latter moving at a conx2 x2 stant speed v0 in the direction of x3 of the K system. Such frames of reference are called inertial frames, x1 x 1 since they move at a constant speed in straight lines with respect to each other and are non-accelerating. We assume that at time t = t = 0, the systems coincided. We are using here subscripts to denote the spatial coordinates, rather than the traditional x, y, z notation, since the theory of relativity requires the expansion of this three-dimensional space to a four-dimensional space. For the same reason, time is given different notations in the two coordinate systems.
75
2.3 Relativity
Galilean transformation Consider the emission of a pulse of light at the origin of the two systems at time t = t = 0, i.e. when the systems coincide with each other. Since light travels at the speed of light, c, and behaves as a wave, at time, t, the observer in the K system will see a spherical wavefront of radius ct, which is mathematically describable by the equations x21 + x22 + x23 = (ct)2 (2.26) The observer in K would express the spherical wavefront of radiation by: 2 2 2 x2 1 + x2 + x3 = (ct )
(2.27)
Using the classical Galilean transformation between the coordinates of the two systems: x1 = x1 x2 = x2 x3 = x3 − v0 t t = t (2.28) in Eq. (2.27), one gets x21 + x22 + x23 = (ct )2 − v02 t 2 + 2v0 t. This implies that the wavefront moves at a speed different from the speed of light, which is an obvious violation of physical laws. Therefore, to accept that Galilean transformation is to admit that either the speed of light depends on the frame of reference (a violation of the first postulate of the theory of relativity), or that the mathematical law that describes the waveform is system-dependent (a contravention of the second postulate); accepting either would violate physical evidence.
Lorentz transformation The above difficulty with the Galilean transformation is resolved by considering √ a fourth imaginary independent coordinate: x4 = ict, x4 = ict , where i = −1. The wavefront in the two systems is then described by: x21 + x22 + x23 + x24 = 0 x2 1
+ x2 2
+ x2 3
+ x2 4
(2.29)
=0
(2.30)
The Galilean transformation needs then to be expanded, and modified, to accommodate the fourth variable. This is achieved by Lorentz (1895) via the transformation: x1 = x1
x2 = x2
x1 = x1
= x2
x2
x3 = γ(x3 − βct) x3
=
γ(x3
+ βct)
x4 = γ(x4 − iβx3 )
(2.31)
x4 =
(2.32)
γ(x4
+ iβx3 )
where β = vc0 and γ = √
1 . With this transformation, the waveform maintains 1 − β2 the same spherical shape and the same speed of propagation in both the K and K
frames of reference. This transformation makes time, t, an independent variable, orthogonal to the other three spatial independent variables (x1 , x2 , x3 ). This introduces difficulties in defining velocity (and other time-dependent variables
76
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
such as momentum and force), since one cannot differentiate two independent variables (e.g. space with respect to time) to obtain a dependent variable (like velocity). Therefore, a new time-like variable is introduced to define momentum, which replaces velocity as the main fundamental variable.
Proper time Let us consider the rotation (rather than the translation as considered above) of coordinate systems with a common origin. In an ordinary transformation, such rotation leaves the Euclidean distance r 2 = x21 + x22 + x23 unchanged, i.e. invariant. Similarly, the rotation of the four-dimensional space (often called the space–time continuum, or Minkowski space, named after Minkowski (1908) who first introduced the concept of space–time) should have s2 = x21 + x22 + x23 + x24 invariant. Since x4 is imaginary, one would expect s to be imaginary, so let us set s = icτ, in analogy with x4 = ict, where τ is an invariant (since c is constant) with the units of time. Since t is now an independent variable, τ is a dependent time-like variable, called the “proper time’’. Then: r2 s2 = r 2 − c 2 t 2 = −c 2 τ 2 τ 2 = t 2 − 2 (2.33) c The metric s2 in Eq. (2.33) does not have to be a positive quantity, since r 2 can be less that c 2 t 2 . In fact, in the above analysis for the light pulse, s2 = 0, hence τ = 0. Events with τ = 0 (s2 = 0) are said to have a “light-like’’ separation from the origin of the space–time continuum. When τ is imaginary (s2 > 0) events have a “space-like’’ separation, as the spatial distance, r, dominates. A real value of τ refers to events in which time is dominant, s2 < 0, which are said to have a time-like separation. In the latter separation, τ can be positive (forward) or negative (backward).
Four-vector momentum The proper time enables the definition of four components of velocity (U1 , U2 , U3 , U4 ) and momentum (P1 , P2 , P3 , P4 ) in the four-dimensional space (x1 , x2 , x3 , x4 ) as follows1 : dx1 dx1 dt = = γ x˙3 dτ dt dτ dx2 dt dx2 = U2 = = γ x˙2 dτ dt dτ dx3 dt dx3 = = γ x˙3 U3 = dτ dt dτ dt = iγc U4 = ic dτ
U1 =
1
t dτ = = dt τ
1 r2 1− 2 2 t c
=
1 v2 1− 2 c
=
1 1 − β2
= γ.
P1 = γm0 x˙1 P2 = γm0 x˙2 (2.34) P3 = γm0 x˙3 P4 = iγm0 c
77
2.3 Relativity
v β = , v is the ordinary three-vector velocity, and m0 is c the “rest’’ (at zero speed) mass of the body for which the momentum is evaluated. The introduced fourth momentum, P4 , has a physical significance that can be demonstrated by considering the low-speed case, v << c, where relativistic effects can be neglected. Then, the Taylor series expansion2 of γ is: 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 = 1 + β + β + β + ··· (2.35) γ= 2 8 16 1 − β2 where γ = √
1 , with 1 − β2
Then, at v << c, Eq. (2.34) becomes: 1 1 v 2 (2.36) P4 = im0 c 1 + β2 = im0 c 1 + 2 2 c i The second term in the left-hand side is times the well-known non-relativistic c c kinetic energy, 12 m0 v 2 . Analogously, P4 is an energy term, called the total energy, i E, defined such that: E=
cP4 = γm0 c 2 i
(2.37)
Total energy The term m0 c 2 in Eq. (2.37), is called self-energy, rest-mass energy, or simply restenergy. Equation (2.37) indicates that the total energy is greater than the rest energy. Since so far we considered free bodies, the difference between E and m0 c 2 has to be attributed to the kinetic energy, T . That is, E = m0 c 2 + T
(2.38)
Therefore, the total energy consists of an intrinsic constant component, m0 c 2 , and a variable component acquired by motion, T , as was already shown by Eq. (1.4). Using the Taylor series expansion of for γ, given by Eq. (2.35), then: 3 4 5 6 2 1 2 β + β + β + ··· (2.39) T = m0 c 2 8 16 which shows that the conventional expression of T = 12 m0 v 2 is only valid when v << c. The total energy, E, can also be expressed in terms of a “relativistic mass’’, m, so that: m0 (2.40) E = mc 2 m = 1 − β2 2 Taylor
series expansion: f (x) = f (0) +
∞ xn ∂n f (x)|x=0 . n=1 n! ∂xn
78
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
With this definition of E, the four-vector momentum of Eq. (2.34) becomes: P1 = mx˙1
P2 = mx˙2
P3 = mx˙3
P4 = imc
(2.41)
Momentum The ordinary momentum, p, is equal to p = mv = mβc, with v being the ordinary three-vector velocity. Then from the definition of m in Eq. (2.40) one gets: m2 =
m02 1−
p2 m2 c 2
(2.42)
which leads to: (pc)2 = (mc 2 )2 − (m0 c 2 )2 = E 2 − (m0 c 2 )2
(2.43)
With E = T + m0 c 2 , then: p2 c 2 = T 2 + 2m0 c 2 T
(2.44)
The above equation demonstrates that when the rest-mass energy is zero, as in the case of photons, p = Tc and from Eq. (2.38), T = E. Then, p = Tc , which is the same as given in Eq. (1.7). One final useful expression for the total energy is obtained by replacing T in Eq. (2.44) by E − m0 c 2 , leading to: E 2 = p2 c 2 + (m0 c 2 )2
(2.45)
2.3.2 Center of relativistic mass With the relativistic mass defined by Eq. (2.40) as mc 2 , one must revisit the concept of the center-of-mass described in Section 2.2 for the rest mass. The center for relativistic mass is referred to here by C r to distinguish it from the center of rest mass (C ).The relationship between the C r frame of reference and that of laboratory (L) system can be established using Lorentz transformation with the system K given a relative velocity β0 in the x1 axis of the K system. Then, the K system corresponds with the C r system, while that of K coincides with the L system. By using the ordinary velocity, we can restrict the transformation to the three spatial coordinates. Then differentiating the spatial coordinates in Eqs (2.31) and (2.32) with respect to t and multiplying each side by the relativistic mass m, one obtains: β0 p1 = p1 p2 = p2 p3 = γ0 p3 − E (2.46) c β0 (2.47) p1 = p1 p2 = p2 p3 = γ0 p3 + E c where γ0 = √
1 1 − β02
and use is made of the fact that E = mc 2 , with the linear
momentum evaluated using the relativistic mass, m. The value of β0 is obtained
79
2.3 Relativity
using of the fact that the total momentum in C r is always zero. Applying this fact to the interacting bodies and transforming the momentum in C r back to the L system using Eq. (2.46), for the problem described in Fig. 2.2, one has: p1 + p2 = 0 β0 β0 p1 − E1 + γ0 p2 − E2 = 0 c c p1 + p2 p 1 + p2 β0 = = c E1 + E2 m1 c 2 + m2 c 2
γ0
(2.48)
where 1 and 2 refer here to the projectile and the target, respectively. Notice here that attention is not given to assigning a negative value for p2 or p2 although both oppose p1 and p2 , respectively, to avoid assigning a wrong sign for energy in the transformation. The direction of the momentum should be accounted for at the very end of the analysis. Comparing Eqs (2.48) to (2.10), one can see that the relativistic mass simply replaces the rest mass in determining the speed of the center-of-mass system. While it is not possible to create a simple velocity diagram for C r , analogous to that of Fig. 2.1 for C , interaction kinematics can be formulated vectorially as shown in Section 2.5.
2.3.3 Lorentz transformation of momentum and energy Lorentz transformation, thought applied above to the space–time fourcomponent vector: ( r , ict), can also be applied to the four-component momentum-energy vector: ( p, iE), with x1 ≡ cp1 , x2 ≡ cp2 , x3 ≡ cp3 , and x4 ≡ iE; with p1 , p2 , and p3 being the three orthogonal components of p, and c is introduced for consistency of units. Guided by Eq. (2.31), momentum and energy can be transformed between the two frames of references K and K moving with a velocity v0 (=β0 c) in the direction of p3 , as follows: cp sin ϑ cos ϕ = cp1 sin ϑ cos ϕ cp cos ϑ = γ0 (cp cos ϑ − β0 E)
cp sin ϑ sin ϕ = cp sin ϑ sin ϕ E = γ0 (E − β0 cp cos ϑ)
where ϑ and φ are the polar and azimuthal angles of the vector p, shown in Fig. 2.4, and the primed values are the corresponding ones, in the K system. Equivalently, one can write: ϕ = ϕ cp cos ϑ = γ0 (cp cos ϑ − β0 E)
p sin ϑ = p sin ϑ E = γ0 (E − β0 cp cos ϑ)
(2.49)
The reverse transformation, from K to K , is simply performed by replacing β0 with −β0 . This facilities greatly the transformation of momentum and energy between the two frames of reference, particularly when K is taken as the L system, and K is considered to be the center-of-mass system for the relativistic mass (C r ), then v0 = βc. For the two-body problem of Fig. 2.2, β0 can be calculated using
80
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
x3
cp cos ϑ
cp
υ ϑ β0 = c0
x2
cp sin ϑ sin ϕ
ϕ x1
Figure 2.4
cp sin ϑ cos ϕ
Polar (ϑ) and azimuthal (ϕ) angles of a momentum vector cp .
Eq. (2.48), which can also be arrived at by setting the total momentum for particles 1 and 2 in C r (K ) equal to zero and transforming it back to L(K ) using Eq. (2.49); keeping in mind that ϑ1 = ϑ1 = 0 and ϑ2 = ϑ2 = −π, while the momentum of one particle is opposite in direction to that of the other. That is, cp1 + cp2 = 0 = (cp1 − β0 E1 ) + (cp2 − β0 E2 )
2.4 Conservation Laws Interaction kinematics is concerned with the laws of conservation of momentum and energy. However, interactions also adhere to some other conservation principles, in addition to the kinematical ones. We will classify these other principles as stoichiometric and intrinsic. Stoichiometric conservation is an elemental balance that assures equality of charge and nucleons between the reactants and the products. Intrinsic balance determines the internal state of the products, i.e. whether they are in stable or excited states and what quantum numbers define these states. Both stoichiometric and intrinsic conservation affect the kinematics of interaction as they determine consecutively the mass and charge of the reaction products and the amount of internal energy stored, which affects in turn the momentum and energy of the reaction products. These conservation laws are presented here. Let us consider the generic reaction between a projectile X1 and a target nucleus X2 that results in the emission of a particle X3 and a product nuclide X4 : A1 Z1X1
2 +A Z2X2 →
A3 Z3X3
4 +A Z4X4
(2.50)
where the subscripts and the superscripts designate, respectively, the atomic and mass numbers.
81
2.4 Conservation Laws
2.4.1 Stoichiometric conservation Charge Z1 + Z2 = Z3 + Z4 , total electric charge is conserved, i.e.
Z = constant.
Lepton number A lepton is a particle not affected by the strong nuclear forces, but is only subjected to the weak forces. As such, electrons and neutrinos are leptons. A lepton number of 1 is assigned to both the electron and the neutrino and −1 to the antineutrino and the positron. Conservation of the lepton number is useful in studying interactions, and decay processes, in which β particles (positive or negative) are produced. This conservation principle is also useful in high-energy physics.
Mass number A1 + A2 = A1 + A4 , number of nucleons is conserved, i.e.
A = constant.
Baryon number A general form for the conservation of the mass number is the conservation of the baryon number. A baryon is any particle that consists of three quarks, such as the proton and neutron. A baryon number B = 1 is assigned to each baryon, subsequently a quark has a baryon number of 13 . Conservation of the baryon number, B = constant, is particularly useful when dealing with high-energy physics reactions.
Statistics
As a consequence of A = constant, if A is odd, it stays odd and the interaction is governed by Fermi–Dirac statistics, while if A is even, Bose–Einstein statistics prevails throughout the interaction. See Section 1.4 for the definition of each type of statistics.
2.4.2 Intrinsic conservation Angular momentum The total angular momentum number is defined by the quantum number J and is conserved vectorially, i.e. J1 + J2 = J3 + J4 . The reactants can have a combined magnitude of the total angular momentum that vary in magnitude from | J1 − J2 | to | J1 + J2 |, depending on the relative orientation of J1 and J2 . Similarly the products have angular momentum values from | J3 − J4 | to | J3 + J4 |.
82
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
Conservation of the total angular momentum restricts the values of J for the interaction products within the same range of the reactants.
Parity
Conservation of parity, , requires that 1 2 = 3 4 , i.e. = constant.That is, if the combined parity of the reactants is even, that of the products must stay even, and if the former is odd the latter is also odd. This adds further restrictions on the angular quantum numbers (the l quantum number) of the products, in addition to that imposed by the conservation of the total angular momentum J .
Isospin Although conservation of nucleons (Baryon number) is essential, its satisfaction does not assure that a certain excited state resulting from an interaction, or even the interaction itself, is allowed.This is because, while the proton and the neutron have nearly the same mass, and as such are subjected to almost the same strong nuclear field (which does not depend on the charge), they are still two separate entities, distinguished by a hypothetical spin number, analogous to the intrinsic spin, called the isobaric spin, or simply the isospin. It is set equal to + 12 for the proton and − 12 for the neutron. Interactions that result in excited states which do not conserve isospin are forbidden, even if such states conserve angular momentum and parity. This conservation principle can explain why some excited states are not observed, and in high-energy physics why some interactions are not possible.
2.4.3 Kinematical conservation Linear momentum The total linear momentum of the products must be equal to the total linear momentum of the reactants. Note that the linear moment (called simply momentum) is a vector quantity and is conserved at any direction. In the center-of-mass system (see Section 2.2), the total momentum is always zero, before and after the interaction, in any direction. This fact facilitates greatly the application of momentum conservation.
Total energy Neither kinetic energy nor mass are conserved on their own in radiation interactions, the conservation is that of the total energy (kinetic energy + rest-mass energy) (see Eq. (2.38)).The following section provides a detailed analysis of kinematic conservation of momentum and energy for interactions that are assumed to abide by the stoichiometric and intrinsic conservation laws given above. If the latter laws are not adhered to, the interaction would not take place and the application of kinematic analysis becomes meaningless.
83
2.5 Einsteinian Kinematics
2.5 Einsteinian Kinematics 2.5.1 Two-body kinematics Relativistic mechanics is applied here to a general two-body interaction. The analysis below is an extension of that given in [19, Section I.B.]. Consider the interaction 2(1,3)4, shown in Fig. 2.5, which involves a projectile of mass M1 and kinetic energy T1 bombarding a stationary target of mass M2 at rest, i.e. with a zero kinetic energy, T2 = 0. Let the emerging particle have a mass M3 and kinetic energy T3 and the residual target having a mass M4 and a kinetic energy T4 . In all cases, it is referred to the rest mass. In relativistic mechanics, the state of a body is defined by (E, P ), where E is its total energy and P is its momentum. These state variables are shown in Fig. 2.5 for a two-body interaction, identified for each body by the appropriate subscript.
Notation In order to facilitate analysis, we use here units of energy for both mass and momentum, by multiplying the former by c 2 and the latter by c and we use upper-case letters for both. Table 2.1 relates the notation of this section to the conventional one. Let us define the angles ϑj and ϕj as, respectively, the polar and azimuthal angles a body j ( j = 1–4) makes with the incident direction of particle 1 in L (i.e. ϑ1 = ϑ1 = 0), with ϑj and ϕj being the corresponding angles in C r . Since body 2 is stationary, then also ϑ2 = ϑ2 = 0.
Kinematical conservation in C r To take advantage of the fact that total momentum in the relativistic center-of-mass frame of reference (C r ) is zero, momentum and energy balance is performed in C r , E4, P4
E2, P2
E3, P3 ϑ4 ϑ3
ϑ3
E2, P2
E 3, P 3
ϑ4
b0 E 4, P 4 L
E1, P1
Cr
E1, P1
Figure 2.5 A schematic of a two-body interaction in the lab (L) and relativistic center-of-mass (C r ) frames of reference, with the state of each body defined by the total energy E and the linear momentum, P.
84
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
Table 2.1
Notation used in analysis
Notation Variable Conventional
Relativistic
Velocity
v
β = vc
Rest mass
m0
M = m0 c 2
Momentum
p = mv = m0 γv
P = pc = M βγ
Momentum vector
p = m v = m0 γ v
P = M γ β
Total energy
E = T + m0 c 2
E =T +M
Relationships
p2 c 2 = T 2 + 2m0 c 2 T
P 2 = T 2 + 2MT
E 2 = (pc)2 + (m0 c 2 )2
E2 = P 2 + M 2
v 1 v . T = kinetic energy; both M and P are in units of energy; c = speed of light; β = ; β = ; γ = c c 1 − β2
and the results are then transformed back to the laboratory frame of reference (L). The speed of C r with respect to L is obtained using Eq. (2.48), which ensures that the total momentum in C r is always zero. After employing the notation of Table 2.1 and assigning P2 = 0 and E2 = M2 , one obtains: β0 =
P1 E1 + M2
(2.51)
Conservation of momentum and energy requires that: i
P i =
P f
and
f
i
Ei =
Ef
(2.52)
f
where i and f refer to the initial and final states, respectively. Applying these conservations laws in C r results in the following. Momentum in direction of projectile in C r
P1 cos ϑ1 + P2 cos ϑ2 = P3 cos ϑ3 + P4 cos ϑ4 = 0
(2.53)
Momentum in direction ⊥ to projectile in C r Since in C r the total momentum is zero, the initial and final particles can assume any azimuthal direction. Therefore,
85
2.5 Einsteinian Kinematics
two orthogonal directions in the azimuthal planes are considered in this analysis, so that: P3 sin ϑ3 cos ϕ3 + P4 sin ϑ4 cos ϕ4 = 0 (2.54) P3 sin ϑ3 sin ϕ3 + P4 sin ϑ4 sin ϕ4 = 0 Total energy
E = E1 + E2 = E3 + E4
(2.55)
where E is the total energy of C r . Angles of Scattering in C r The two equations of (2.54) lead to:
tan ϕ3 = tan ϕ4 The above equation is satisfied when: |ϕ3 − ϕ4 | = π
(2.56)
which again describes the physical fact that the momentum vectors of particles 3 and 4 lie in a plane in C r , as is the case in L. Therefore, P3 sin ϑ3 = P4 sin ϑ4 . Equation (2.53) gives: P3 cos ϑ3 = −P4 cos ϑ4 , and as such tan ϑ3 = −tan ϑ4 . Therefore, ϑ4 = π − ϑ3 (2.57) This shows that particles 3 and 4 emerge in opposite directions in C r , as expected. Substituting Eq. (2.57) in Eq. (2.53) gives: P3 = P4 = P
(2.58)
Energy and momentum in C r Using E 2 = P 2 + M 2 along with Eq. (2.58) results in:
E32 = E42 + M32 − M42
(2.59)
2
Adding E3 + 2E3 E4 to both sides of the above equation, then, 2E3 (E3 + E4 ) = (E3 + E4 )2 + M32 − M42 1 [(E + E4 )2 + M32 − M42 ] E3 = 2(E3 + E4 ) 3 Consequently, E3 =
E 2 + M32 − M42 κ = 2E 2E
(2.60)
where, κ = (E3 + E4 )2 + M32 − M42 = E 2 + M32 − M42
(2.61)
86
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
The momentum of particle 3 is equal to that of particle 4, as Eq. (2.58) shows,
and their value is obtained using P3 = E32 − M32 :
P =
P3
=
P4
=
κ2 − M32 4E 2
(2.62)
The total energy of particle 4 is obtained from Eq. (2.55) as: E4 = E − E3 = E −
κ 2E 2 − κ κ = = 2E 2E 2E
(2.63)
where, κ = E 2 − (M32 − M42 )
(2.64)
Once the total energy of the two bodies (the value of E according to Eq. (2.55)) is determined, the energy and momentum of particles 3 and 4 become known. Their angles of scattering, ϑ3 and ϑ4 , can be determined from Eqs (2.53) and (2.57). Note that any two azimuthal angles ϕ3 and ϕ4 will satisfy momentum balance provided that |ϕ3 − ϕ4 | = π, as Eq. (2.56) indicates. In relation to incident particle in L In order to able to transform the results obtained above in C r back to L, we recall that C r is by definition moving in the direction of the incident particle, particle 1, and that ϑ1 = 0, P2 = T2 = 0. The velocity of C r is given by Eq. (2.48), which with the notation of Table 2.1 becomes (after setting E2 = T2 + M2 = M2 and P2 = 0):
β0 =
P1 E1 + M2
(2.65)
Therefore, β0 is the ratio between the system’s momentum and energy in L. Then, γ02 =
1 1 (E1 + M2 )2 = = 2 2 2 P1 1 − β0 M1 + 2M2 E1 + M22 1 − (E1 +M 2 ) 2
where use is made of E12 = P12 + M12 . Therefore, γ0 = where:
E1 + M2 E
(2.66)
E = M12 + 2M2 E1 + M22
which is shown in Eq. (2.69) below as being the system’s energy in C r . As such, γ0 is the ratio between the energy of the incident particles in L and the C r energy.
87
2.5 Einsteinian Kinematics
Now we can transform the energy balance equation of (2.55) to L using the Lorentz transformation of momentum and energy, Eq. (2.49) adjusted for the notation of Table 2.1, to obtain: E1 + E2 = γ0 [(E1 − β0 P1 ) + (M2 )] E3
+ E4
= γ0 [(E3 − β0 P3 cos ϑ3 ) + (E4 − β0 P4 cos ϑ3 )]
(2.67) (2.68)
Then using Eqs (2.55), (2.65), and (2.66) along with P12 = E12 − M12 , one gets: E3 + E4 = E1 + E2 = γ0 [E1 − β0 P1 + M2 ] P12 E1 + M2 E1 + M2 − = E E1 + M2 1 = [M12 + 2E1 M2 + M22 ] = M12 + 2M2 E1 + M22 E Therefore, E3 + E4 = M12 + 2M2 E1 + M22 = E1 + E2 = E
(2.69)
since E = E3 + E4 = E1 + E2 , as defined by Eq. (2.55). The energy E is the total energy of the reactant particles 1 and 2, made available for the creation of the product √ particles 3 and 4. At very high energy, i.e. when E >> M1 , M2 , one has E ≈ 2M2 E1 . Then, a high incident energy E1 in L does not produce a high C r energy that can be used to supply particles 3 and 4 with high energy if the target particle 3 is at rest, due to the damping by the relatively smaller M2 value. In order to generate sufficient energy to produce new particles in high-energy studies, the use of fixed targets is avoided, instead intersecting, or colliding, particle beams are utilized. This has led into the concept of “colliders’’, which serve to maximize the energy available in C r , E , hence facilitating the creation of new particles with rest-mass energies much higher than the reactant particles. Now with E known in terms of the properties of the incident particles, all parameters in C r are fully determined. Transformation to L The transformation of Eq. (2.49), adjusted for the notation of Table 2.1, gives: E3 = γ0 (E3 − β0 P3 cos ϑ3 ) (2.70) Given that E3 is now known, from Eq. (2.60), and keeping in mind that E32 = P32 + M32 , Eq. (2.70) becomes a quadratic equation that can be solved for the value of P3 , then for E3 . The possibility of having two values for E3 and P3 indicates that there are two possibilities for the angle ϑ , as discussed below. Reverse transformation L → C r Applying the transformation of Eq. (2.49) in reverse, with β0 replaced with −β0 , to particle 3, one obtains:
ϕ3 = ϕ3
(2.71)
88
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
P3 sin ϑ3 = P sin ϑ3
(2.72)
P3 cos ϑ3 = γ0 (P3 cos ϑ3 + β0 E3 )
(2.73)
E3 = γ0 (E3 + β0 P cos ϑ3 )
(2.74)
Equations (2.72) and (2.73) give: γ0 tan ϑ3 =
β3 sin ϑ3 β0 + β3 cos ϑ3
(2.75)
where: β3 =
P E3
(2.76)
Possible angles of scattering Equation (2.75) indicates that there can be restrictions on the range of values the angle ϑ3 can assume, depending on whether it is less than, greater than, or equal to β0 . These restrictions, or lack of, can be illustrated by vectorially combining β 0 and β 3 to yield a vector that defines the angle ϑ3 , or precisely the angle ϑ = tan−1 (γ0 tan ϑ3 ), with this angle being the angle the combined vector β 0 + β 3 makes with β 0 . The resulting vector diagrams are shown in Fig. (2.6), which indicates that Eq. (2.75) can be satisfied by two possible values of ϑ3 . These two possibilities are designated by the points 1 and 2 on the circle representing all possible values β3 for a determined (by the energy and momentum of the incident particle) value of β0 . The various possibilities are discussed below. When β3 < β0 , as Fig. 2.6 shows, the vector β 0 + β 3 produces two possible points 1 and 2 at the same angle ϑ. Therefore, for the same angle, ϑ3 , in L, there are two values of β3 , hence two possible energies. This is the so-called doubleenergy domain. Note however, in this domain, there is a maximum value of for ϑ3 , the value at which β 0 + β 3 becomes tangential to the circle. The corresponding maximum value of ϑ3 is such that: tan ϑ3 |max =
β π < 3 2 γ0 β02 − β32
(2.77)
When β3 > β0 , Eq. (2.77) indicates that there is no real-value for ϑ3 |max , i.e. there is no maximum, and therefore ϑ3 can assume any value within its range. Then the combination vector β 0 + β 3 produces two values for β3 , hence two values of ϑ3 which differ from each other by π. Accordingly two values of ϑ3 are possible.
89
2.5 Einsteinian Kinematics
1
1
β3
1
β3
β3
β0
β0
β0 2 β3
β3
β0
2 β0
2 β3 β0
Figure 2.6 A vector diagram showing the possible combinations of β0 and β3 , marked angles show limits of ϑ3 .
When β3 = β0 , the first solution is such that: sin ϑ3 γ0 (1 + cos ϑ3 ) 1 1 − cos2 ϑ3 1 − cos ϑ3 = = γ0 (1 + cos ϑ3 )2 γ02 (1 + cos ϑ3 )
tan ϑ3 =
(2.78)
The second solution for ϑ (point 2 in the corresponding graph in Fig. 2.6) corresponds to ϑ3 = π, which according to Eq. (2.75), produces a value in L for ϑ3 = π2 . The momentum in direction of particle 1 in L is such that: P1 = P3 cos ϑ3 + P4 cos ϑ4
(2.79)
Then, at ϑ3 = π2 , P4 cos ϑ4 = P1 . Since the momentum is zero in L in the direction normal to that of the incident particle, a particle emerging in that direction must have a zero momentum. That is, P3 = 0 when ϑ3 = π2 . The momentum in the direction normal that of particle 1 is such that: P3 sin ϑ3 − P4 sin ϑ4 = 0
(2.80)
Therefore, with ϑ3 = π2 , and P3 = 0, P4 sin ϑ4 = 0, ϑ4 = 0, and P4 = P1 .
Q-value and excitation energy The Q-value, Q, of an interaction is defined as: Q = (M1 + M2 ) − (M3 + M4 ) = (T3 + T4 ) − (T1 + T2 ) = (T3 + T4) − (T1 + T2) (2.81) The proof that Q is the difference between the total kinetic energy of the products and the reactants, in either C r or L, is straightforward, since M is an invariant and
90
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
M = E − T = E − T . In other words, Q has the same value in C r and in L. In elastic scattering, Q = 0. A positive Q-value indicates that the reaction releases energy, since the total mass of the products is less than that of the reactants, with the difference transformed to energy. When Q is negative, the reaction is endoergeic and some minimum energy must be supplied in order for the reaction to take place; then [−Q] is referred to as the excitation energy of the reaction, or separation energy of the interaction. We will use the square brackets around Q to indicate the excitation or separation energy, and simply Q to refer to the Q-value. This minimum energy is referred to as the threshold energy, and is introduced below.
Forward threshold energy If the Q-value given by Eq. (2.81) is negative, the reaction in endoergeic, and T1 must exceed a threshold value, Tf , called the forward threshold energy. For the reaction to occur, the total kinetic energy of the product particles in C r must be nonnegative, or equivalently: E = E3 + E4 ≥ M3 + M4 . Then, E 2 = κ − M32 + M42 > (M3 + M4 )2 , or equivalently κ > 2M3 (M3 + M4 ). For particle 3 to emerge, M3 has to be greater than zero, i.e. κ > 0 is required for the two-body reaction to take place. An equivalent expression in terms of the Q-value, or the excitation energy, [−Q], is obtained using Eqs (2.69) and (2.81): E 2 = (M12 + M22 + 2M2 E1 ) ≥ (M3 + M4 )2
M12 + M22 + 2M2 T1 + 2M1 M2 ≥ (M3 + M4 )2 M1 1 Q (M3 + M4 )2 − (M1 + M2 )2 = [−Q] 1 + T1 ≥ − 2M2 M2 2M2 Therefore, Tf is given by: 1 M1 Q 2 2 [(M3 + M4 ) − (M1 + M2 ) ] = [−Q] 1 + − Tf = 2M2 M2 2M2
(2.82)
At T1 = Tf , E3 + E4 = M3 + M4 . Then, with M3 = 0 and M4 = 0, particles 3 and 4 have no kinetic energy in C r , hence in L they will both move together with the same velocity.
Back threshold energy At the scattering angle for particle 3 of ϑ3 = π2 , the corresponding kinetic energy of particle 1, T1 , is known as the back threshold energy, since then particle 3 cannot emerge at an angle greater than π2 , when β3 ≤ β0 . With ϑ3 = π2 , E3 = M3 , and E42 = P42 + M42 = P12 + M42 = T12 + 2T1 M1 + M42 , since P3 = 0, P4 sin ϑ4 = 0, ϑ4 = 0 and P4 = P1 . Therefore, from the conservation of energy in L: E1 + M2 = M3 + E4
(2.83)
2.5 Einsteinian Kinematics
91
one obtains: (E1 + M2 − M3 )2 = E42 = T12 + 2T1 M1 + M42 2(M1 + M2 − M3 )T1 + (M1 + M2 − M3 )2 = 2T1 M1 + M42 2T1 (M2 − M3 ) + (M1 + M2 − M3 )2 − M42 = 0 T1 = −
(M1 + M2 − M3 )2 − M42 2(M2 − M3 )
T1 = −
(M1 + M2 − M3 − M4 )(M1 + M2 − M3 + M4 ) 2(M2 − M3 )
T1 = −
Q(M1 + M2 − M3 + M4 + Q − Q) 2(M2 − M3 )
T1 = −
Q[2M1 + 2(M2 − M3 ) − Q] 2(M2 − M3 )
Since for β0 ≥ β3 , the maximum allowed angle for ϑ3 is π2 , the above value for T1 is the back threshold energy, because particle 3 cannot scatter by an angle greater than π2 . This threshold value is expressed as: (M1 + M2 − M3 )2 − M42 Q M1 Tb = − − = [−Q] 1 + 2(M2 − M3 ) M2 − M3 2(M2 − M3 ) (2.84)
Reaction possibilities The forward and back threshold values, Eqs (2.82) and (2.84), respectively, define the threshold energies of the 2(1,3)4 reaction, so that if: T1 < Tf : reaction is energetically forbidden. Tf < T1 < Tb : ϑ3 < π2 and two distinct energies are observed at the same angle ϑ3 , corresponding to the two signs of the quadratic solution of Eq. (2.70). T1 > Tb : the energy of particle 3 is determined by Eq. (2.70), with the positive sign of its quadratic solution corresponding to ϑ3 < π2 , and the negative sign to ϑ3 > π2 . For elastic scattering, Q = 0, and the threshold energies are zero. The two energies of the quadratic solution of Eq. (2.70) correspond then to forward scattering ϑ3 < π2 , and backscattering ϑ3 > π2 .
Algorithm 1 Given all the rest masses and T1 , one can find T3 at all angles in C r , with 1 ≤ cos ϑ3 ≤ 1, using Algorithm 1. Then the corresponding values at the permissible range in L can be determined.
92
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
Algorithm 1
Relativistic kinematics of a two-body interaction: 2(1,3)4
Require: Mi ≥ 0, where i = 1–4 Require: T1 > 0 Require: P2 = 0 Ensure: Ei ≥ Mi , where i = 3, 4 Ensure: Ei ≥ Mi , where i = 3, 4 Ensure: P3 = P4 Ensure: −1 ≤ cos ϑi ≤ 1, where i = 3, 4 Ensure: −1 ≤ cos ϑi ≤ 1, where i = 3, 4 1: E1 = T1 + M1 E2 = M2 P1 = T12 + 2T1 M1 P2 = 0 2: E 2 = M12 + 2M2 E1 + M22
3: E3 =
E 2 + M32 − M42 2E
4: P3 =
E 2 − M32 + M42 2E
E4 =
E32 − M32
P4 =
E42 − M42
5: Transfer back to L: β0 =
P1 E1 + M2
E1 + M2 E
γ0 =
6: for all ϑ3 such that −1 ≤ cos ϑ3 ≤ 1 do 7: E3 = γ0 [E3 + β0 P3 cos ϑ3 ] 8: P3 =
E4 = γ0 [E4 + β0 P4 cos(ϑ3 + π)]
E32 − M32
P4 =
E42 − M42
9: cos ϑ3 = 10: end for
γ0 [P3 cos ϑ3 + β0 E3 ] P3
cos ϑ4 =
γ0 [P4 cos (ϑ3 + π) + β0 E4 ] P4
93
2.5 Einsteinian Kinematics
2.5.2 Analysis using invariants Kinematical analysis can be considerably simplified using the concept of invariants3 . An invariant quantity maintains the same value in all frames of reference, but is not conserved. For instance, mass is an invariant, but is not conserved. In geometry, the square of the Euclidean distance ( r 2 ) is an invariant, and we have shown in Section 2.3, that the proper time (τ 2 ) in the space–time domain and the rest-mass energy in the four-dimensional space of mass and energy are invariants. The invariants are most readily defined if the following four-component energy–momentum vectors are introduced: ⎧ ⎪ ⎨
⎫ E ⎪ ⎬ P sin ϑ cos ϕ μ P = ⎪ ⎩ P sin ϑ sin ϕ ⎪ ⎭ P cos ϑ
⎧ ⎪ ⎨
⎫ E ⎪ ⎬ −P sin ϑ cos ϕ Pμ = ⎪ ⎩ −P sin ϑ sin ϕ ⎪ ⎭ −P cos ϑ
(2.85)
where the superscript μ is used to indicate the so-called contravariant components of the vector, while the subscript μ designates the covariant vector. Now the scalar (inner product) of the two vectors gives the value of: P 2 = (P μ ){Pμ } = E 2 − P 2 = M 2
(2.86)
where the parentheses indicate the transpose of the vector. This is an invariant, known as the Lorentz invariant. Note that this invariant is equal to zero when dealing with photons, since a photon has a zero rest mass. For the 2(1, 3)4 interaction, 16 invariants can be defined in principle, relating a particle to itself and to the three other particles. The four self-to-self invariants replicate the Lorentz invariant of Eq. (2.86) for each particle, and hence relate a particle’s energy to its momentum. The invariants are commutive, i.e. the invariant relating particle i to particle j is the same as that relating the latter particle to the former. Therefore, there are only six particle-to-particle invariants. Since the reactant particles 1 and 2 are independent from each other, one can only speak of their total energy–momentum vector, which provides the invariant s1,2 . Conservation of energy and momentum necessitates that s1,2 = s3,4 , i.e. the values of P μ and Pμ before and after the interaction must be equal. Therefore, μ
μ
μ
μ
P1 + P2 = P3 + P4
Pμ1 + Pμ2 = Pμ3 + Pμ4 μ
μ
μ
μ
s1,2 = (P1 + P2 ){Pμ1 + Pμ2 } = s3,4 = (P3 + P4 ){Pμ3 + Pμ4 } = s
3 In
this analysis, use was made of the lecture notes of W. von Schlippe, Relativistic kinematics of particle interactions, posted on http://www.phys.spbu.ru/Library/Lectures/Stud/Schlippe/Data/Kin_Rel/kin_rel.pdf, March 2002.
94
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
This s invariant in L and C r (recall that two-body interactions are coplanar, i.e. all have the same azimuthal angle ϕ) can be expressed as: s = s1,2 = (E1 + E2 )2 − P12 − P22 − 2P1 P2 cos(ϑ2 − ϑ1 ) = s3,4 = (E3 + E4 )2 − P32 − P42 − 2P3 P4 cos(ϑ4 − ϑ3 ) = (E1 + E2 )2 − P12 − P22 − 2P1 P2 cos(ϑ2 − ϑ1 ) = s1,2 = (E3 + E4 )2 − P32 − P42 − 2P3 P4 cos(ϑ4 − ϑ3 ) = s3,4
(2.87)
Since in C r the total momentum is equal to naught, P1 = −P2 , ϑ2 − ϑ1 = π, P3 = −P4 , ϑ4 − ϑ3 = −π, then s = (E1 + E2 )2 = (E3 + E4 )2 . That is, s = E 2 , where E is the energy of C r ; same as Eq. (2.55). The threshold energy for an interaction can be directly obtained by equating s1,2 to s3,4 in L, with particles 3 and 4 having no momentum.This leads directly to: Q2 (M3 + M4 )2 − (M12 + M22 ) M1 Ef = + = M1 − Q 1 + (2.88) 2M2 M2 2M2 with Ef being the threshold energy when particle 2 is at rest. Obviously when M1 = M3 and M2 = M4 , i.e. in the case of elastic scattering, Ef = M1 , i.e. Tf = Ef − M1 = 0. Another set of invariants can be established by relating a reactant particle to a product particle. Since the change in momentum and energy between a pair of particles in the interaction must be taken up by the other pair in this two-body interaction, one obtains: μ
μ
μ
μ
P1 − P3 = P2 − P4
t1,3 =
μ (P1
Pμ1 − Pμ3 μ − P3 ){Pμ1 − Pμ3 }
= Pμ2 − Pμ4 μ
μ
= t2,4 = (P2 − P4 ){Pμ2 − Pμ4 } = t
(2.89)
and μ
μ
μ
μ
P1 − P4 = P2 − P3
u1,4 =
μ (P1
Pμ1 − Pμ4 μ − P4 ){Pμ1 − Pμ3 }
= Pμ2 − Pμ3 μ
μ
= u2,3 = (P2 − P3 ){Pμ2 − Pμ4 } = u
(2.90)
The invariants of Eqs (2.89) and (2.90) can be expressed in L and C r as: t = t1,3 = (E1 − E3 )2 − P12 − P32 + 2P1 P3 cos(ϑ3 − ϑ1 ) = t2,4 = (E2 − E4 )2 − P22 − P42 + 2P2 P4 cos(ϑ4 − ϑ2 ) = (E1 − E3 )2 − P12 − P32 + 2P1 P3 cos(ϑ3 − ϑ1 ) = t1,3 = (E2 − E4 )2 − P22 − P42 + 2P2 P4 cos(ϑ4 − ϑ2 ) = t2,4
(2.91)
95
2.5 Einsteinian Kinematics
and u = u1,4 = (E1 − E4 )2 − P12 − P42 + 2P1 P4 cos(ϑ4 − ϑ1 ) = u2,3 = (E2 − E3 )2 − P22 − P32 + 2P2 P3 cos(ϑ3 − ϑ2 ) = u1,4 = (E1 − E4 )2 − P12 − P42 + 2P1 P4 cos(ϑ4 − ϑ1 ) = u2,3 = (E2 − E3 )2 − P22 − P32 + 2P2 P3 cos(ϑ3 − ϑ2 )
(2.92)
The invariants of Eqs (2.87), (2.91) and (2.92) for this two-body interaction are named after Mandelstam (1958) who originally introduced them. They always add to a constant, such that: s + t + u = M12 + M22 + M32 + M42
(2.93)
Therefore, only two of the invariants are independent. These variables facilitate relating the momentum and energy of interacting particles. For instances, in L where θ1 = 0, P2 = 0, and E2 = M2 , the invariant t gives: (E1 − E3 )2 − P12 − P32 + 2P1 P3 cos ϑ3 = (M2 − E4 )2 − P42 Total energy conservation requires E1 + M2 = E3 + E4 , then eliminating E4 from the above equation and making use of the fact that M 2 = E 2 − P 2 results in: M12 + M32 − 2(E1 E3 − P1 P3 cos ϑ3 ) = M42 − M22 − 2M2 (E1 − E3 )
(2.94)
From this equation one can directly determine the E and P of the outgoing particle 3 in terms of the incoming particle 1, without having to perform vectorial momentum balance or transformation from one frame reference to another.
Algorithm 2 Algorithm 2 gives a summary of equations that can be used to determine the energies and momenta of all particles in a two-body interaction, given E1 and P1 . Calculations should be carried over a range of cos ϑ3 values within [−1, 1] in C r , from which the range at various scattering angles, cos ϑ3 , in L can be found.
96
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
Algorithm 2
Invariant-based kinematics of a two-body interaction: 2(1,3)4
Require: Mi ≥ 0, where i = 1–4 Require: T1 > 0 Require: P2 = 0 Ensure: Ei ≥ Mi , where i = 3, 4 Ensure: Ei ≥ Mi , where i = 3, 4 Ensure: −1 ≤ cos ϑi ≤ 1, where i = 3, 4 Ensure: −1 ≤ cos ϑi ≤ 1, where i = 3, 4 1: s = M12 + M22 + 2M2 (T1 + M1 ) 2: In C r : E1 =
s + M12 − M22 √ 2 s
E2 =
s + M22 − M12 √ 2 s
s + M32 − M42 s + M42 − M32 E4 = √ √ 2 s 2 s 1 P1 = P2 = √ [s − (M1 − M2 )2 ][s − (M1 + M2 )2 ] 2 s 1 P3 = P4 = √ [s − (M3 − M4 )2 ][s − (M3 + M4 )2 ] 2 s E3 =
3: for all ϑ3 such that −1 ≤ cos ϑ3 ≤ 1 do 4: t = M12 + M32 − 2(E1 E3 − P1 P3 cos θ3 ) u = M12 + M42 − 2(E1 E4 − P1 P4 cos θ4 ) 5: In L: E1 =
s − M12 − M22 2M2
E2 = M2
−u + M22 + M32 −t + M22 + M42 E4 = 2M2 2M2 1 P3 = [−u + (M2 − M3 )2 ][−u + (M2 + M3 )2 ] 2M2 1 [−u + (M2 − M4 )2 ][−u + (M2 − M4 )2 ] P4 = 2M2
E3 =
cos ϑ3 = 6: end for
t − M12 − M32 + 2E1 E3 2P1 P3
cos ϑ4 =
u − M12 − M42 + 2E1 E4 2P1 P4
97
2.5 Einsteinian Kinematics
A useful relationship between the energy and momentum of particle 3, as well as its scattering angle, can be obtained from the t invariant as: 2P1 P3 cos ϑ3 = [M42 − M12 − M22 − M32 − 2M2 E1 ] + 2(E1 + M2 )E3 = [M42 − M32 − s] + 2(E1 + M2 )E3
(2.95)
Isolating E3 on one side of the equation, squaring both sides, and substituting E32 = P32 + M32 , one obtains a quadratic equation of the form: aP32 + bP3 + c = 0 a = 4[(E1 + M2 )2 − P12 cos2 ϑ3 ] = 4(s + P12 sin2 ϑ3 ) b = −4(s + M32 − M42 )P1 cos ϑ3 c = 4M32 (E1 + M2 )2 − (s + M32 − M42 )2 b2 − 4ac = 16(E1 + M2 )2 {[s − (M3 − M4 )2 ][s − (M3 + M4 )2 ] − 4M32 P12 sin2 ϑ3 } = 64(E1 + M2 )2 {sP32 − M32 P12 sin2 ϑ3 } The solution of the above quadratic equation leads to:
P3 =
(s + M32 − M42 )P1 cos ϑ3 ± 2(E1 + M2 ) sP32 − M32 P12 sin2 ϑ3 2(s + P12 sin2 ϑ3 )
(2.96)
A physically acceptable solution requires that sP32 ≥ M32 P12 sin ϑ32 . If angles of ϑ3 are permitted, but only the solution with the positive sign is acceptable, since P3 being the magnitude of the momentum should 2 2 2 be positive. Onthe other hand, if sP3 < M3 P1 , then there is a maximum angle √ sP32 > M32 P12 , all
sP
ϑ3 |max = sin−1 M3 P31 . Then for each value of ϑ3 > ϑ3 |max , there are two values for P3 , and consequently two values for P4 , corresponding to the two signs of Eq. (2.96). Note that a similar expression can be obtained for P4 by exchanging the subscripts 3 and 4. For non-elastic scattering, one can incorporate the Q-value of the reaction with the help of Eq. (2.88), to obtain: s + M32 − M42 = 2[M2 (E1 − Ef ) + M3 (M1 + M2 − Q)]
= 2[M2 T1 + (Q + M3 )(M1 + M2 ) − M3 Q] − Q 2 (2.97)
98
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
2.5.3 Non-elastic interactions Interactions in which the product particles are not identical to the reactant particles can be analyzed either through an intermediary composite particle (or a compound nucleus) which subsequently decays, or as a direct interaction. In the latter case, if it is a two-body interaction, the analysis presented in the preceding sections can be directly applied. If more than two particles emerge, one can focus on observing the behavior of one particle and lump the attributes of all other product particles into one entity, to create an equivalent two-body interaction. This so-called inclusive collision is discussed below, followed by the analysis of the kinematics of the creation of the composite particle, and its decay to two or more particles. We will be using the notation of Table 2.1, unless otherwise mentioned.
Inclusive collisions Let us consider the interaction 2(1,3)4, . . . n, in which n − 2 particles are created (3–n), but our interest is in observing only a certain particle, which we will consider to be particle 3. For this interaction, the invariant s of Eq. (2.87) is such that: s = (M1 + M2 )2 + 2M2 T1 = (E3 + E4 + · · · + En )2 ≥ (M3 + M4 + · · · + Mn )2 (2.98) with the inequality made possible, since E ≥ M . From the above one can stipulate that the threshold total and kinetic energy for this interaction are: Ef =
(M3 + M4 + · · · + Mn )2 − (M12 + M22 ) 2M2
Tf = Ef − M1 =
(M3 + M4 + · · · + Mn )2 − (M1 + M2 )2 2M2
(2.99) (2.100)
Obviously if particle 1 carries only this threshold energy, all the created particles will have no kinetic energy in C r (except of course if a particle is massless, e.g. a photon). Therefore, more kinetic energy than Tf is needed for the created massive particles to emerge and be observed in L as individual distinguishable particles; otherwise they will appear as a single entity with a zero velocity. In order to determine the momentum and energy of one of the emerging particles, one can create the equivalent two-body inclusive collision: 2(1,3)b, where all particles 4–n are presented by one state, b, with a mass Mb = M4 + M5 + · · · + Mn . The two-body kinematics of Section 2.5 can then be applied. The process can be repeated for other particles, by lumping all particles other than the one of interest into one equivalent entity.
99
2.5 Einsteinian Kinematics
Formation of composite particle The energy of projectile particle, 1, and the target, 2, can be combined to form a composite particle a. Considering the target to be at rest, one can state that: E = (M1 + M2 )2 + 2M2 T1 = Ta + Ma (2.101) where use was made of Eq. (2.69). Even if particle a does not acquire any kinetic energy, some kinetic energy must be supplied, in this case by particles 1, in order for the reaction to take place. From Eq. (2.101), with Ta = 0, the threshold energy, Tf , is then: Ma2 − (M1 + M2 )2 M1 Q = [−Q] 1 + − (2.102) Tf = 2M2 M2 2M2 where use was made of Eq. (2.82) to arrive at the right-hand side of the equation. It is, therefore, obvious that non-elastic collisions require Ma > M1 + M2 , since an equal value will occur only if Q = 0, at which point no excitation of particle a takes place. This interaction can also be analyzed in L: E1 + M2 = Ea P1 = Pa Momentum balance forces particle a to move in the same direction as particle 1, since the momentum in any other direction is zero, and there is only one particle remaining after the interaction.
Two-body decay A composite particle, a, formed by the interaction of particles 1 and 2, can carry some kinetic energy, if T1 > Tf , with particle 2 being at rest and Tf given by Eq. (2.102). If this composite particle further decays, to say particles 3 and 4, it will then decay “on the fly’’. Let the total energy of the composite particle a be Ea (=E3 + E4 ) and its momentum, P a , along a direction defined by an angle, ϑa , with respect to particle 1, in the plane of particles, 1, 2, and a. Particle a must also be coplanar with the decay particles 3 and 4. Conservation of momentum in the azimuthal direction between the initial particles 1 and 2 and the final particles 3 and 4, requires that the four particles, along with the intermediate particle a, be coplanar. The invariant s of Eq. (2.87) becomes s = Ma2 , since there is no second reactant body along with a. With C r now coinciding with particle a, E3 + E4 = Ma , and s = E32 + E42 + 2E3 E4 , which after eliminating E4 and using E32 = P32 + M32 gives: 1 2 P = [Ma − (M3 − M4 )2 ][Ma2 − (M3 + M4 )2 ] (2.103) 2Ma
100
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
From Eq. (2.96): P3 =
(Ma2 + M32 − M42 )Pa cos ϑ3a ± 2Ea Ma2 P 2 − M32 Pa2 sin2 ϑ3a 2(Ma2 + Pa2 sin2 ϑ3a )
(2.104)
2 . If A physically acceptable solution requires that Ma2 P 2 ≥ M32 Pa2 sin ϑ3a 2 2 2 2 Ma P > M3 Pa , all angles of ϑ3a are satisfied, but only the solution with the positive sign is acceptable, since P3 being the magnitude of the momentum should be 2 2 2 2 positive. On the other hand, if Ma P < M3 Pa , then there is a maximum
Ma P angle ϑ3a |max = sin−1 M . Then for each value of ϑ3a > ϑ3a |max , there are 3 Pa two values for P3 , and consequently two values for P4 , each corresponding to the two signs of Eq. (2.104). Note that:
P4 = P32 + Pa2 − 2Pa P3 cos ϑ3a as can be easily shown by combining the two momentum balance equations in the direction of flight and perpendicular to it: Pa = P3 cos ϑ3a + P4 sin ϑ4a 0 = P3 sin ϑ3a + P4 sin ϑ4a If the composite particle a does not acquire in L any kinetic energy from particles 1 and 2, i.e. when only the threshold energy for the formation of the composite particle is supplied, then particle a coincides with C r of particles 3 and 4, and with Pa = 0 and Ea = Ma , Eq. (2.104) becomes P3 = P , and using Eq. (2.103): P3 = P4 = P =
1 2 [Ma − (M3 − M4 )2 ][Ma2 − (M3 + M4 )2 ] 2Ma
(2.105)
where use was made of Eq. (2.103), and only the positive square roots are accepted in order to produce realistic momentum values. It is obvious from Eq. (2.105) that the momenta of particles 3 and 4 have a fixed value determined by the masses of particles a, 3, and 4, and the excitation energy of the reaction. If Ma = M3 + M4 , particles 3 and 4 will have no momentum and would not be observed in L as moving particles. When particle a is at rest, Eq. (2.105), unlike Eq. (2.104), does not show any angular dependence. Therefore, there is no preferred direction for the emergence of particles 3 and 4, i.e. their angular distribution is isotropic. However, since the momentum of the parent particle a is assumed to be zero in L, particles 3 and 4 must emerge in L at two opposite directions, i.e. back-to-back.
2.5 Einsteinian Kinematics
101
Radiative capture If one particle, say, 3, is massless, e.g. a photon, then the other particle 4, is such that M4 = M1 + M2 , as happens in radiative capture, then (keeping in mind that Q = M1 + M2 − Ma , and the value of Q is the same in both L and C r ), Eq. (2.103) gives: P3 |M3 =0
=
E3 |M3 =0
1 Q 2 2 = [M − M4 ] = [−Q] 1 + 2Ma a 2(M1 + M2 − Q) (2.106)
If particle a is at rest, then Eq. (2.105) gives also the same above values for P3 |M3 =0 = E3 |M3 =0 in L. When Q << M1 + M2 , one gets P3 |M3 =0 = E3 |M3 =0 = [−Q], i.e. the excitation energy of the reaction. Note that this excitation energy may not be released immediately, but may keep the composite particle in an excited quantum state for delayed decay by γ emission. The excitation energy may also be transformed into rotational energy of the composite particle. Further decay If following radiative capture, the residual particle, particle 4 in the above discussion, further disintegrates to say particles 5 and 6, the two-body particle decay process can proceed as above with Ma replaced with Ma − E3 |M3 =0 , i.e. the C r energy is reduced by E3 |M3 =0 . Alternatively, one can consider the combined radiative capture decay and the two-body decay of particle a as a three-body decay process, as discussed below.
Three-body decay While the approach of inclusive collisions discussed above enables one to observe one product particle at a time, by creating a two-body equivalent collision process, it is often useful to examine more than one product particle simultaneously to determine the kinematical limits imposed by the presence of more than two product particles. Let us again examine the decay of a composite particle a, formed by particles 1 and 2, that subsequently decays to particles 3, 4, and 5. We will start the analysis in the C r frame of particle a (called here C r:a ), designated by the primed variables. Transformation back to the L frame can be done using the invariants P1 Ea or by Lorentz transformation with β0 = M and γ0 = M , where the variables are 1 a for particle a in L. We also perform the analysis in C r ’s for the particle pairs (3,4), (4,5) and (3,5), called here C r:3,4 , C r:4,5 , and C r:3,5 , with their variables designated with superscripts, ◦, •, and , respectively. In these so-called Jackson frames, the concerned particles have an equal momentum values and move in opposite directions. The use of these frames enables one to determine the kinematic limits of the invariants.
102
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
We will consider here the following set of invariants, expressed in C r:a : s = sa = Ma2 s3 = sa3 = (Ma − E3 )2 − P32 = Ma2 + M32 − 2Ma E3 = s45 = (E4 + E5 )2 − P42 − P52 + 2P4 P5 cos(ϑ4 + ϑ5 ) s4 = sa4 = (Ma − E4 )2 − P42 = Ma2 + M42 − 2Ma E4 = s35 = (E3 + E5 )2 − P32 − P52 + 2P3 P5 cos(ϑ3 + ϑ5 ) s5 = sa5 = (Ma − E5 )2 − P52 = Ma2 + M52 − 2Ma E5 = s34 = (E3 + E4 )2 − P32 − P42 + 2P3 P4 cos(ϑ3 + ϑ4 ) These invariants guarantee that energy and momentum are conserved, though the sa invariant here is trivial as it has no kinematical content. It is easy to show that s3 + s3 + s5 = Ma2 + M32 + M42 + M52 . Therefore, only two of these invariants are sufficient to fully determine the behavior of the interaction. The upper bound of s3 occurs when E3 = 0, as obvious from the definition of sa3 . An analogous situation exists for s4 and s5 . Therefore, s3 ≤ (Ma − M3 )2
s4 ≤ (Ma − M4 )2
s5 ≤ (Ma − M5 )2
(2.107)
The invariants evaluated in C r:4,5 , C r:3,5 , and C r:3,4 are: s3 = (E4• + E5• )2
s4 = (E3 + E5 )2
s5 = (E3◦ + E4◦ )2
Obviously the lower limit for the value of these invariants occurs when the total energy of the relevant particles is equal to their rest-mass energy: s3 ≥ (M4 + M5 )2
s4 ≥ (M3 + M5 )2
s5 ≤ (M3 + M4 )2
(2.108)
Equations (2.107) and (2.108) define the bounds the values of the invariants are confined within. However, not all possible values are attainable, as shown below. Consider C r:4,5 , at which P4• = P5• , and Pa• = P1• . Then: s3 = (Ea• − E3• )2 =
2 Ma2 + Pa•2 − M32 + P3•2
1 [s3 − (Ma − M3 )2 ][s3 − (Ma + M3 )2 ] 4s3 2 M42 + P4•2 + M52 + P5•2 s3 = (E4• + E5• )2 =
P3•2 =
P4•2 = P5•2 =
1 [s3 − (M4 − M5 )2 ][s3 − (M4 + M5 )2 ] 4s3
103
2.5 Einsteinian Kinematics
where the obtained momenta are direct solutions of their preceding equations. Then: 1 E3• = √ (s − s3 − M32 ) 2 s3 1 E4• = √ (s3 + M42 − M52 ) 2 s3 1 E5• = √ (s3 + M52 − M42 ) 2 s3 The invariant s3 evaluated in C r:3,4 does not show any angular dependence. We need to consider another invariant to complete the kinematic description of particles 4 and 5. Consider s4 : s4 = s35 = M32 + M52 + 2[E3• E5• − P3• P5• cos(ϑ3• + ϑ5• )] A fixed value for s3 sets fixed values for P3• , P4• , and P5• as shown above. Then s2 depends only on ϑ3• + ϑ5• , i.e. the angle between particles 4 and 5 in C r:3,4 . This in turn sets an upper bound (s4↑ ) and a lower bound (s4↓ ) on the value of s2 , since the cosine of an angle is limited within the interval [−1, 1]. Therefore, s4↓ = M32 + M52 + 2(E3• E5• − P3• P5• ) ≤ s4 ≤ M32 + M52 + 2(E3• E5• + P3• P5• ) = s4↑ (2.109) At another value of s3 , one would obtain another pair of limits on s4 , and so on. Covering all possible values of s3 within its limits, one obtains the domain of the range of the allowed values of s3 and s4 enclosed with the so-called Dalitz plot, as schematically shown in Fig. 2.7. Let us consider the special case where one of the particles is massless, say particle 3 is a photon, i.e. M3 = 0. Then (M4 + M5 )2 ≤ s3 ≤ Ma2 , and M 2 − (M + M )2
s3 = Ma2 − 2Ma P3 . Therefore, P3 ≤ a 2M4 a 5 , whose magnitude is identical to that obtained using two-body kinematics, Eq. (2.106), if particles 4 and 5 are lumped into a single equivalent particle. This shows that the concept of inclusive scattering is sufficient to determine the kinematic attributes of a certain particle. Therefore, in the case of multibody decay, one can either reduce the system to the equivalent of a two-particle decay or a three-particle decay, with the latter used if the interest is to observe simultaneously two particles.
2.5.4 Non-relativistic approximation When the energy of the projectile particle is much less than its rest-mass energy, i.e. T << M , it is reasonable then to set P 2 ≈ 2MT . By eliminating ϑ4 from the two momentum equations in L, Eqs (2.79) and (2.80), substituting all the P 2
104
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
S4 (Ma M4)2 S4
↓
S4↓ (M3 M5)2
(M4 M5)2
S3 (Ma M3)2
Figure 2.7 A representative Dalitz plot for three-body decay of permitted values of invariants.
terms by the corresponding 2MT terms, and then using the energy equation in the L, Eq. (2.81), one obtains the following non-relativistic value of T3 : 2 M1 M3 T1 2ϑ +η ± cos (2.110) cos ϑ T3 ≈ 3 3 (M3 + M4 )2 where:
M1 + M2 M4 Q M4 Q M3 + M4 M4 − M1 + ≈ M4 − M1 + η= M1 M3 T1 M1 M3 T1 (2.111)
The approximation in the above value is valid when the Q-value is less than the Q << 1. Note that when M4 is comparable rest masses of all particles involved, i.e. M to M1 in value, the above approximation is not a very good one as the value of Q becomes dominant, which violates the condition under which the equation was arrived at. The relationship of Eq. (2.110) could have been also obtained from classical conservation of momentum and energy, without considering the rest-mass energy, as discussed in Section 2.6 below. Similar approximations can be obtained for the other kinematic parameters.
2.6 Newtonian Kinematics In interactions involving mass-carrying projectiles, where the speed of the interacting bodies is well below the speed of light, the use of classical Newtonian kinematics is usually adequate. Although one can arrive at the results of this
105
2.6 Newtonian Kinematics
m2, υ2 m4, υ4
m3, υ3
m3, υ3
ϑ3
ϑ4 ϑ3
ϑ4
m2, υ2 m4, υ4
υ0
L
m1, υ1
C
m1, υ1
Figure 2.8 A schematic of a two-body interaction in the lab (L) and the center-ofmass (C) frames of reference, with the state of each body defined by the mass, m, and velocity v.
Newtonian analysis as an approximation of relativistic kinematics, as was done at the end of Section 2.5, analysis using classical dynamics is presented here as it is commonly applied. The presented analysis is based on that given in [19, Section I.B]. We will resort back to the conventional notation for energy T = 12 mv 2 and the momentum being equal to m v , where m here refers to the rest mass and v to velocity. Therefore, the kinematic state of a particle is fully determined by m and v . In the laboratory frame-of-reference, the following conservation equations apply for the 2(1,3)4 interaction of Fig. 2.8: m1 v1 = m3 v3 cos ϑ3 + m4 v4 cos ϑ4
(2.112)
0 = m3 v3 sin ϑ3 − m4 v4 sin ϑ4
(2.113)
1 1 1 m1 v12 = m3 v32 + m4 v42 − Q 2 2 2 Eliminating ϑ4 and v4 from the above equations leads to: 1 m1 m3 T1 ± η + cos2 ϑ3 cos ϑ T3 = m3 v32 = 3 2 (m3 + m4 )2 where:
m3 + m4 m4 Q η= m4 − m1 + (m1 m3 ) T1
(2.114)
2
(2.115)
(2.116)
Equation (2.115) is identical to the non-relativistic approximation, Eq. (2.110). The threshold limits Tf and Tb are obtained similar to the relativistic analysis of Section 2.5 by considering the problem in the center-of-mass system (C ), in which the total system momentum is zero (see Section 2.2). But due to the discrepancy in the total mass between in the initial state with a rest mass m1 + m2
106
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
and the final state with m3 + m4 , finding a C that accommodates both states is not possible, since there are two centers of mass, one before the interaction takes f place, v0i , and the other after the interaction, v0 . Note that in elastic scattering, m1 + m2 = m3 + m4 and this discrepancy does not exist. With the two velocities f v0i and v0 taken in the direction of particle 1, their values are: v0i = f
v0 =
m1 v1 m1 + m 2
(2.117)
m3 v3 cos ϑ3 + m4 v4 cos ϑ4 m1 v1 = m3 + m 4 m3 + m 4
(2.118)
f
where use was made of Eq. (2.112). However, v0i ≈ v0 when: i f v0 − v0 ≈ 0 1 1 = m1 v1 − m1 + m2 m3 + m4 m1 + m2 Qv0i i = = v0 1 − m3 + m4 (m3 + m4 )c 2 f Qv0 f m3 + m4 = v0 − 1 = m1 + m2 (m1 + m2 )c 2 f
Therefore, for the difference between v0i and v0 to be small, |Q| << (m1 + m2 )c 2 ≈ f (m3 + m4 )c 2 . Then, a velocity v0 ≈ v0i ≈ v0 can be taken for C so that: v0 =
m1 v1 m1 v1 m1 v1 ≈ ≈√ m1 + m 2 m3 + m4 (m1 + m2 )(m3 + m4 )
(2.119)
Conservation of momentum and energy in the zero-total-momentum, C , gives: m1 v 1 + m2 v 2 = m3 v 3 + m4 v 4 = 0 (2.120) T1 + T2 = T3 + T4 − Q Equation (2.120) with T = 12 mv 2 along with Eq. (2.119) leads to: v 1 = v 2 and v 3 = v 4 m12 v12 = m22 v22 and m32 v32 = m42 v42 m1 T1 = m2 T2 and m3 T3 = m4 T4 m1 m3 T1 and T4 = T T2 = m2 m4 3
(2.121)
107
2.6 Newtonian Kinematics
Note also that with: 1 1 m22 T1 T1 = m1 v1 2 = m1 (v1 − v0 )2 = 2 2 (m1 + m2 )2 which in Eq. (2.121) leads to: T3
m2 T1 m4 = +Q m3 + m 4 m1 + m 2
(2.122)
The value of T1 corresponding to T3 = 0 leads to the forward threshold that makes the reaction possible: Tf = [−Q]
m1 + m2 m2
(2.123)
The condition for |v3 | < v0 leads to the second threshold, Tb , since according to Eq. (2.3) |v | ≥ v0 : v3 2 = v32 + v02 − 2v3 v0 cos ϑ3
(2.124)
Therefore, the condition for v3 < v0 is cos ϑ3 > 2vv30 ≥ 0. If the condition is satisfied, particle 3 cannot emerge at an angle greater than π2 . The T1 energy corresponding to the v3 < v0 condition, Tb , is such that: m3 v32 = m3 v02 T3 =
(m1 v1 )2 1 m3 2 (m1 + m2 )(m3 + m4 ) m2 m3 m1 Tb m4 Tb +Q = m3 + m 4 m1 + m2 (m1 + m2 )(m3 + m4 )
where use was made of Eqs (2.119) and (2.122). The above leads to: Tb = −
m2 m4 Tf m4 (m1 + m2 )[−Q] = m4 m2 − m1 m3 m2 m4 − m1 m3
(2.125)
It can be easily shown that the total kinetic energy in C is: T1 + T2 =
1 m1 m2 2 1 v = μ1,2 v12 2 m1 + m 2 1 2
(2.126)
where μ1,2 is the reduced mass of particles 1 and 2. By analogy one can state that: T3 + T4 =
1 m3 m4 2 1 m1 m2 2 v¯ ≈ v¯ 2 m3 + m 3 2 m1 + m 2
(2.127)
108
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
with the value of v¯ obtained from the non-relativistic conservation of energy, T1 + T2 = T3 + T4 − Q, so that: 1 m1 m2 2 1 m1 m2 2 v = v¯ − Q 2 m1 + m 2 1 2 m1 + m2
(2.128)
One can then define a mass m¯ 2 such that: m¯ 2 = m2
v¯ v1
(2.129)
This can be seen as the modified mass of particle 2 that will make the interaction equivalent to elastic scattering. Eq. (2.129) in Eq. (2.128) gives: Q (m1 + m2 ) 2 2 (2.130) m¯ 2 = m2 1 + T1 m2 Then Eq. (2.122) can be rewritten as: T3 =
m¯ 22 m2 m4 T1 (m1 + m2 )(m3 + m4 ) m22
(2.131)
Using the vector velocity relationship of Eq. (2.3), one has: v32 = v32 + v02 − 2v3 v0 cos (π − ϑ3 ) 1 T3 = T3 + m3 v02 + v3 m3 v0 cos ϑ3 2 1 m1 v1 m12 v12 T3 = T3 + m3 + 2T3 m3 cos ϑ3 2 (m1 + m2 )2 (m1 + m2 )
(2.132)
where use is made of Eq. (2.119). Now with aid of Eq. (2.122) one obtains: T3 =
T1 (m1 + m2 )(m3 + m4 ) ! " m¯ 22 m3 + m4 m¯ 2 m1 m2 m3 m4 (m3 + m4 ) × m2 m4 2 + m1 m3 +2 cos ϑ3 m1 + m2 m2 m1 + m2 m2 (2.133)
2.7 Specific Interactions We will apply the relationships developed in Sections 2.5 and 2.6 to the various two-body interactions described in Section 1.7. We will use Algorithms 1
109
2.7 Specific Interactions
and 2 for relativistic analysis, and Eq. (2.133) for the Newtonian analysis. For neutrons, Newtonian kinematics is usually sufficient, since in most situations the speed of a neutron does not approach that of the speed of light. Nevertheless, it is a good practice to employ relativistic kinematics, as it will lead to the same results as those of classical kinematics while conserving both mass and kinetic energy via the use of the total energy.
2.7.1 Elastic scattering In elastic scattering, one has the two body interaction 2(1,1)2, i.e. the projectile and the observed particles, 1 and 3 have the same rest mass, and the target is not altered. Therefore, M1 = M3 , M2 = M4 . Then, the Mandelstam variables, Eqs (2.87)–(2.92), add to the constant value s + t + u = 2(M12 + M22 ) (see Eq. (2.93)). Momentum conservation in C r requires that P1 = P2 and P3 = P4 = P , ϑ2 = ϑ1 + π and ϑ4 = π − ϑ3 . Therefore, the s invariant of Eq. (2.87) applied in C r with E = M + P , results in P12 = P32 and P22 = P42 . Consequently, E3 = E1 and E4 = E3 . Then, with ϑ1 = 0 as reference, the t invariant of Eq. (2.91) is: t = t13 = −2P 2 (1 − cos ϑ3 ) = t24 = 2M2 (M2 − E4 ) = −2M2 T4
(2.134)
Therefore, 0 ≤ −t ≤ 4P 2 , which bounds the values of t. As such, in elastic scattering, t is always negative, except at cos ϑ3 = 0, where it is zero. The relationship between E3 and E1 as a function of ϑ3 can be directly obtained by solving Eq. (2.94) after substituting P32 = E32 − M32 . The result is a quadratic equation that will produce two values, one corresponding to ϑ3 and the other to ϑ3 + π.
Neutron elastic scattering Relativistic Using the notation of Table 2.1, with the neutron being particle 1 and the nucleus is the target, elastic scattering requires: M3 = M1 and M2 = M4 , i.e. M1 + M2 = M3 + M4 , and as such Q = 0. For simplification, we will express all masses in terms of the mass of the neutron, setting M1 = M3 = 1 and M2 = M4 = A, where A is the mass number of the target nucleus (which when multiplied by the neutron’s rest-mass energy gives the mass of the target nucleus, assuming that the neutron and the proton are equal in mass). Now we will follow the procedure of Algorithm 1 and supplementary relationships from Section 2.5: P1 = T12 + 2T1
E 2 = (1 + A)2 + 2AT1
κ = E 2 + 1 − A2 = 2[(1 + A) + AT1 ] The minimum value of κ occurs when A = 1 (with hydrogen being the smallest target nucleus). Therefore, κ|min = 2(2 + T1 ) > 0, even for T1 = 0.
110
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
The energy of particle 3 in C r is then: κ (1 + A) + AT1 = 2E (1 + A)2 + 2AT1 The minimum value of E3 at A = 1 is E3 |min = 1 + T21 ≥ 1. Therefore, the condition E3 > M3 is always satisfied in this interaction, except when T1 = 0, then T3 = 0. Now, we can proceed with the analysis to obtain: T12 + 2T1 P = P3 = E32 − M32 = A (1 + A)2 + 2AT1 T12 + 2T1 P β3 = = A (2.135) E3 (1 + A) + AT1 T12 + 2T1 P1 = β0 = E1 + M2 (1 + A) + T1 E3 =
1 (1 + A) + T1 γ0 = = (1 + A)2 + 2AT1 1 − β02 A A(1 + A)2 + 2AT1 sin ϑ3 β3 sin ϑ3 = tan ϑ3 = γ0 (β0 + β3 cos ϑ3 ) [(1 + A) + AT1 ] + A[A(1 + A) + T1 ] cos ϑ3 E3 = γ0 (E3 + β0 P3 cos ϑ3 ) (1 + A)2 (1 + T1 ) + AT12 + AT1 (2 + T1 ) cos ϑ3 (1 + A)2 + 2AT1
(1 + A2 ) + AT1 + A(2 + T1 ) cos ϑ3 T3 = E3 − M3 = T1 (1 + A)2 + 2AT1 =
(2.136)
Note that β3 > β0 when A2 > 1. Then, there are always two possible values for ϑ3 , as Fig. 2.6 shows, i.e. for all target nuclides except for hydrogen (A = 1). For the latter case, β3 = β0 , and one of the values of ϑ3 is equal to π. The minimum possible value for T3 is when cos ϑ3 = −1 for A = 1, i.e. T1 |min = 0. That is, T3 and accordingly E3 are never less than zero, as physically expected. With T3 determined, then P3 and cos ϑ3 can be evaluated. Recall thought that all the above values are determined in units of the neutron’s rest mass. In elastic scattering (Q = 0), the back and forward threshold energies are Tb = 0 and Tf = 0, as Eqs (2.84) and (2.82), respectively, show. Therefore, the
111
2.7 Specific Interactions
elastic scattering interaction is always possible and there are no restrictions on the value that ϑ3 can assume. However, when A = 1, i.e. when a neutron elastically scatters by a hydrogen nucleus (a proton), T3 = 12 T1 [1 + cos ϑ3 ]. Consequently, T3 = 0, when cos ϑ3 = −1. Also, for A = 1, β0 = β3 . Therefore, tan ϑ3 = ∞, i.e. the maximum angle of scattering of a neutron with a proton in L is ϑ3 = π2 , at which angle the neutron loses all its energy. Backscattering of neutrons with protons, in a single collision, is, therefore, forbidden. Non-relativistic approximation When T3 << 1, the non-relativistic approximation of Eq. (2.136) leads to:
T3 =
T1 [(1 + A2 ) + 2A cos ϑ3 ] (1 + A2 )
(2.137)
In practice, the above expression is quite valid for neutron scattering, since the rest-mass energy of a neutron is about 1 GeV, while the maximum kinetic energy observed of neutrons produced in reactors or by neutron generators is about 15 MeV. Therefore, the assumption T1 << M1 is easily satisfied. Newtonian Resorting to Newtonian kinematics, Eq. (2.133), when applied to elastic scattering, i.e. with m1 = m3 , m¯ 2 = m2 = m4 and A = mm12 , leads to:
T3 =
T1 [A2 + 1 ± 2A cos ϑ3 ] (1 + A)2
(2.138)
This equation is identical to Eq. (2.137), except for the ±sign, with the positive sign corresponding to ϑ3 < π2 , and the negative sign to ϑ3 > π2 . Another useful formulation found in nuclear engineering textbooks, such as [20], is: T3 =
T1 [(1 + α) ± (1 − α) cos ϑ3 ] 2
(2.139)
2 where α = A−1 A+1 . This equation, and its counterparts, show that the minimum energy a neutron can carry after a single collision is αT1 , and a neutron can lose its energy in a single collision only if α = 0 (A = 1), i.e. when colliding with a proton (a hydrogen nucleus). The total energy of the particles in C must remain equal to that of C , i.e., according to Eq. (2.126), 1 m1 m2 2 1 1 v1 = m3 v32 + m4 v42 2 m1 + m 2 2 2 2 Given that m1 = m3 , m2 = m4 , A = m m1 , and that momentum balance in C requires that m3 v3 = m4 v4 , and with the aid of Eqs (2.23) and (2.10), one can show that
112
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
the angle ϑ (in C ) and ϑ in (L) are related by the relationship: cos ϑ3 =
A cos ϑ3 + 1 A2 + 1 + 2A cos ϑ3
One can also show that: 1 cos ϑ32 − 1 + cos ϑ3 cos ϑ32 − 1 + A2 cos ϑ3 = A
(2.140)
(2.141)
Equations (2.138) and (2.141) can be combined into the following single equation: ! "2 cos ϑ3 ± cos2 ϑ3 + A2 − 1 (2.142) T3 = T1 (A + 1) It is interesting to notice that when A = 1, one of the solutions always result in T3 = 0, indicating that no scattering angle, ϑ3 , is allowed to be greater than π 2 , when a neutron is elastically scattered by a proton, as indicated earlier when discussing the forward threshold energy.
Compton scattering In the two-body interaction 2(1,3)4, if M1 = M3 = 0 and M2 = M4 = Me , where Me is the rest mass of the electron, then one has Compton scattering: e− + γ → e− + γ. From the kinematics point of view, this is an elastic scattering, since the reactants and the products are identical. However, as far as the atom is concerned, its electronic structure is altered by this interaction. Since we are concerned here with kinematics, this interaction is classified as two-body elastic scattering. Traditionally, Compton scattering kinematics are arrived at using conservation of momentum and energy. We will use here the invariants as they are quite convenient. We have for the t invariant: t = t13 = −2E1 E3 (1 − cos ϑ3 ) = t24 = 2Me2 − 2Me E4 Conservation of energy in L requires E1 + Me = E3 + E4 , since in Compton scattering the target electron is assumed to be at rest and free. Therefore, it is straightforward to show that: E3 = P3 =
E1 Me Me + E1 (1 − cos ϑ3 )
(2.143)
which is identical to the well-known Compton scattering relationship (keeping in mind that P3 = E3 = T3 ). It is obvious that a photon cannot lose all its energy 1 Me in one collision with an electron, since E3 |min = MEe + 2E1 . The reader can easily
113
2.7 Specific Interactions
show that in C r (where the total momentum is zero), there is no change in electron energy or momentum before and after scattering. In other words, no matter what the angle of scattering is, the energy and momentum of the two bodies remain constant. As such, one can conclude that Compton scattering in C r is isotropic. 2 2 It interesting to note that for Compton √ scattering, s ≥ Me , t ≤ 0; u ≤ Me , and 4 su ≥ Me . That is, the energy of C r (= s) is greater than the electron’s rest-mass energy of 511 keV. Note that, since photons move at the speed of light, classical treatment is not applicable.
Moller and Bhabha scattering Moller scattering is the e− + e− → e− + e− interaction, while Bhabha scattering is e+ + e− → e+ + e− . Both cases lead to the two-body elastic interaction 2(1,3)4 which has M1 = M2 = M3 = M4 = Me . In both interactions, the target particle is an electron at rest. To determine the angle in L at which particle 3, i.e. the scattered electron/positron, emerges at a certain magnitude of energy, E3 (hence momentum, P3 = E32 − Me2 ), one can make use of the t invariant: t = t13 = 2Me2 − 2E1 E3 + 2P1 P3 cos ϑ3 = t24 = 2Me2 − 2Me E4 = 2Me2 − 2Me (E1 + Me − E3 ) = −2Me (E1 − E3 ) Therefore, E3 (E1 + Me ) − Me2 − Me E1 (2.144) P1 P3 where use was made of the conservation of energy, E1 + M2 = E3 + E4 . Similarly for the u invariant: cos ϑ3 =
u = u14 = 2Me2 − 2E1 E4 + 2P1 P4 cos ϑ4 = u23 = 2Me2 − 2Me E3 = 2Me2 − 2Me (E1 + Me − E4 ) = −2Me (E1 − E4 ) Hence, for a given E4 , and subsequently P4 , particle 4 will emerge at the angle determined by: cos ϑ4 =
E4 (E1 + Me ) − Me2 − Me E1 P1 P4
(2.145)
Both these interactions require that s ≥ 4Me2 , a C r energy greater than twice the electron’s rest-mass energy. Also not that t ≤ 0 and u ≤ 0 in these interactions.
Mott scattering This is the interaction of a light charged particle, typically an electron, with the atomic nucleus. It then reasonable in a 2(1,3)4 interaction to assume that
114
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
M2 >> M1 , E1 , P1 . The interaction can then be seen to take place in L and the recoil of the target is negligible. In this elastic scattering, M1 = M3 and M2 = M4 . Then the change in the electron momentum is quite small and the momentum transfer can be determined by: |P3 − P1 |2 = t13 = −P12 − P32 + 2P1 P3 cos ϑ3 ≈ −2P 2 (1 − cos ϑ3 ) = −4P 2 sin2
ϑ3 2
(2.146)
2.7.2 Inelastic scattering Neutron inelastic scattering Relativistic This (n,n γ) interaction is a two-body interaction of a neutron with a target nucleus that leads to three products: a neutron, a photon, and a recoiled (and may be excited) nucleus. The interaction is also endoergeic, i.e. it has a negative Q-value, and as such can only take place if the incident neutron has an energy greater than the magnitude of the Q-value. On the other hand, the mass of the reactants and the products does not change, i.e. M1 = M3 , and M2 = M4 in a 2(1,3)4 interaction, when the neutron is the observed particle (particle of interest). Then according to Eq. (2.81), Q = 0, if calculated as the difference in rest-mass energy, which contradicts the fact that Q is negative in this interaction. In order to overcome this difficulty, we will assume that a fictitious rest-mass energy of [−Q] is added to the target, so that M4 = M2 + [−Q], where [−Q] is the internal (excitation) energy absorbed by the target nucleus. We will then let M4 decay on the fly to a photon and a nucleus of mass M2 . Let us first consider the kinematics of the emerging neutron. Threshold energy With M1 = M3 = Mn , where Mn is the rest-mass energy of the neutron, then according to Eq. (2.88) the threshold energy for this interaction is:
1 [(Mn + M2 + [−Q])2 − (Mn2 + M22 )] 2M2 Mn [−Q] + = Mn + [−Q] 1 + M2 2M2 1 Mn [−Q] ≈ [−Q] 1 + + Tf = [−Q] 1 + M2 2M2 A Ef =
(2.147) (2.148)
2 where A = M Mn . Since Q is negative in this interaction, Tf has to be slightly greater than [−Q]. As indicated in Section 1.7.3, the threshold energy is on the order of a few MeV for light nuclei and only 100s of keV for heavy nuclei. Therefore, Q is on the order of magnitude of Tf and much smaller than M2 (which is in the GeV range); hence the approximation in Eq. (2.148).
115
2.7 Specific Interactions
Neutron energy Now with E1 > Ef , we can follow either Algorithm 1 or 2 to determine the kinematic properties of the emerging neutron. It is obvious that, unlike in elastic scattering in C r , E3 = E1 and P3 = P1 , since M4 = M2 . Gamma energy Let particle 4, with M4 = M2 + [−Q], decays to a massless photon such that M5 = 0, a residual nucleus with M6 = M2 . Then in the C r of 4, Eq. (2.103) gives:
Pγ = P = Eγ =
1 2M4 − [−Q] [M42 − M22 ] = [−Q] ≈ [−Q] 2M4 2M4
(2.149)
Using Eq. (2.104), one can determine that the photon’s momentum in L is: Pγ =
M4 [−Q](P4 cos ϑγ4 + E4 ) [M42 − M22 ](P4 cos ϑγ4 + E4 ) = 2 2 2 2(M4 + P4 sin ϑγ4 ) (M42 + P42 sin2 ϑγ4 )
(2.150)
where ϑγ4 is the angle the emitted photon makes with the direction of particle 4. Given that P is typically in the MeV range and the rest-mass energies are on the order of GeVs, one can state that: Pγ ≈
M4 [−Q] = [−Q] M4
(2.151)
Consequently Eγ = [−Q] is also a very good approximation for the photon energy; recall that Eγ2 = Pγ2 . In this approximation, Pγ has no angular dependence, hence its emission can be assumed to be isotropic. The momentum of the residual particle is then: [M42 + M22 ]P4 cos ϑ64 ± 2E4 M42 P 2 − M22 P42 sin2 ϑr4 (2.152) P6 = 2(M42 + P42 sin2 ϑr4 ) Newtonian As shown in Section 2.6, an inelastic scattering can be made equivalent to an elastic one, by adopting a “hard’’ mass for the target nucleus, using 2 ¯ m¯2 Eq. (2.130). In this equation setting, A = m m1 , and A = m1 , one obtains:
[−Q] (1 + A) ¯ 2 = A2 1 − A T1 A
(2.153)
keeping in mind that Q is negative. Now, applying Eq. (2.133), with m1 = m3 , m2 = m4 , the kinetic energy of the inelastically scattered neutron emerging at angle of ϑ3 with respect to the incident neutron in C is given by: T3 =
T1 ¯ 2 + 1 + 2A ¯ cos ϑ3 ] [A (1 + A)2
(2.154)
116
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
¯
¯ and v1 by A+1 v1 in Eq. (2.138) leads also to Eq. (2.154). This Replacing A by A A+1 reflects in essence that the incident neutron appears to the modified “hardened’’ ¯ nucleus to be approaching by a reduced velocity of A+1 A+1 v1 .The angles of scattering in L and C are related in analogy with Eqs (2.140) and (2.141) by: cos ϑ3 =
¯ cos ϑ3 + 1 A
¯ 2 + 1 + 2A ¯ cos ϑ3 A 2 ¯ ¯2 A cos ϑ3 = cos ϑ3 − 1 + cos ϑ3 cos ϑ32 − 1 + A
(2.155)
(2.156)
2.7.3 Non-elastic collisions Positron annihilation This interaction kinematically is an inelastic scattering, since the product particles are different from the reactant particles. As a two-body 2(1,3)4 interaction, the reaction e+ + e− → γ + γ, has M1 = M2 = Me and M3 = M4 = 0. Due to the involvement of photons, Newtonian kinematics are not suited here.The invariants in this interaction are such that s ≥ 4Me2 , t ≤ Me2 , u ≤ Me2 .The C r energy, E , is such that E > 2M42 , i.e. ≥ 1.022 MeV. Assuming that the electron is the target and is at rest, then the angle in L at which one of the photons emerges with a certain energy is such that: t = t13 = Me2 − 2E1 E3 + 2P1 P3 cos ϑ3 = t24 = Me2 − 2Me E4 = −2Me (E1 − E3 ) − Me2 where use is made of the fact that E4 = E1 + Me − E3 . Then, taking advantage of the fact that E3 = P3 , E3 = P3 =
Me2 + Me E1 E1 + Me − P1 cos ϑ3
(2.157)
Similar use of the u invariant produces the energy and momentum of the other photon: E4 = P4 =
Me2 + Me E1 E1 + Me − P1 cos ϑ4
(2.158)
If the positron has a zero momentum, or more practically if its kinetic energy is much less than Me = 0.511 MeV,then one can set E1 = M1 . Equations (2.157) and (2.157) show clearly that E3 = E4 = P3 = P4 , when E1 = M1 . Angular dependence then disappears from the expressions for the t and u invariants in L. However, the s invariant when E1 = M1 is s = 4Me2 = 2Me2 − 2Me2 cos(ϑ4 − ϑ3 ). That is, ϑ4 − ϑ3 = π, indicating that the two photons emerge at two opposite angles.
2.7 Specific Interactions
117
Since then photon energy is not angular dependent, photon emission is isotropic and photons are emitted at any two opposite directions. Note that this is the essence of positron emission tomography (known as PET), which measures the coincident emission of 511 keV photons to determine the location of a positron source that causes annihilation as the positron comes to rest in the surrounding medium.
Photoelectric absorption Kinematic analysis of the photoelectric effect is not quite straightforward because it involves a bound electron as a target, but the atom as a whole recoils. The photoelectric effect cannot take place in free space, in the absence of the atom. On the other hand, one cannot precisely define the target of the interaction, and has to rely on the probabilistic arguments of quantum mechanics (see Section 3.5.5). Nevertheless, one can represent the photoelectric effect by the two-body interaction 2(1,3)4, with M1 = 0, the product particle is an electron, M3 = Me , and M4 = M2 − Me + Be , i.e. the target loses an electron in the process and gains some excitation energy, Be . Then the threshold energy for the interaction, according to Eq. (2.88) is: (M2 + Be )2 − M22 B2 = Be + e ≈ Be (2.159) 2M2 2M2 The approximation is made possible by the fact that Be , the electron’s binding energy, is at most in the keV range, while the mass of an atom is at least in the GeV range. It is also reasonable to assume that M2 and M4 are much larger than both Me and E1 . Given this, it is also reasonable to assume that C r coincides with L. Since photoelectric absorption takes place only in the field of the atom, it is not unreasonable to reduce the C r energy by the mass of the target atom, M4 , which includes the atomic field potential, Be . The remaining energy is then assumed by the electron. Therefore, √ E3 ≈ E3 = s − M4 ≈ M2 + E1 − (M2 − Me + Be ) = E1 − Be + Me (2.160) √ E1 . Keeping in mind that E3 = where s = M22 + 2M2 E1 and s ≈ M2 1 + M 2 M3 + T3 = Me + M3 , the above is the well-known Einstein’s (1905) photoelectric equation4 , in which Be is called the work function and is equal to the binding energy of the atomic electron liberated in the interaction (typically a K-shell electron). Note that under this approximation, E4 = M4 + Be , i.e. the momentum given to the residual atom is Be . The momentum of the electron is then: Ef =
P32 = (E1 − Be + Me )2 − Me2 = E12 + 2Me E1 + Be2 − 2Be (Me + E1 ) (2.161) Given that Be << Me , since the maximum value of Be is for the K shell is at most on the order of 100 keV (see Section 1.2.3) Me = 511 keV, then P3 > P1 (=E1 ). 4 1921
Nobel Prize in physics.
118
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
When E1 >> Be , then P32 = E12 + 2Me E1 , and the momentum given to the recoil atom can be neglected.The momentum balance (P3 sin ϑ3 = P4 sin ϑ4 ) shows that as P4 → 0, sin ϑ3 → 0 and the electron will tend to emerge in the same direction as the incident photon, i.e. with a small scattering angle. Then the residual atom will recoil backwards, since ϑ3 + ϑ4 = 0 given that C r and L almost coincide. When E1 , on the other hand, is close in value to Be , the momentum of the electron becomes almost zero, and ϑ4 → 0. Then, the electron and the residual atom travel in opposite directions, i.e. ϑ3 → π at low energies. As Section 3.5.5, Eq. (3.166) shows, at low photon energy electron emission tends to be in a direction normal to that of the incident photon.
Pair and triplet production This interaction occurs only in the presence of the electric field of an atom or an electron. It can be considered as a three-body interaction: 2(1,3 and 5)4, with M1 = 0, M2 = M4 = M and M3 = M5 = Me , where M is the mass of the target and Me is that of an electron or a positron. However, for the purpose of finding the threshold energy we will combine particles 3 and 5 into one particle of mass equal to 2Me . Then according to Eq. (2.88): Ef =
(2Me + M2 )2 − M22 2Me (Me + M2 ) = 2M2 M2
(2.162)
For pair production in the field of the atom, M2 >> Me , and Ef = 2Me = 1.022 MeV. On the other hand for pair production in the field of the electron, M2 = Me , and Ef = 4M4 = 2.044 MeV.The latter process is the triplet production process, since the target electron also acquires a considerable momentum. Now to examine the kinematical behavior of one of the particles (say the positron) let us consider the two-body inclusive scattering that lumps the other particle, (the electron) into one equivalent particle, i.e. M4 = M2 + Me , with M3 = Me . Given that M1 = 0, one can employ either schemes ofAlgorithms 1 or 2. Since the positron and the electron have an identical mass, once the energy of one particle (the positron) is determined, the energy of the other (the electron) is obtained from energy conservation, such that Eγ = E− + E+ , where the subscripts γ, e−, and e+ are used to refer, respectively, to photon, electron, and positron. The same algorithms can be used to determine the polar angle of scattering for the other particle.
Absorption When the incident particle is absorbed in the target, one can assume in the 2(1,3)4 interaction that E3 = 0, i.e. M3 = P3 = 0. The target 4 then must recoil in the same direction as the incident particle, since there is no momentum in any other direction. With the target being at rest, the s invariant dictates that s = M42 . This in turn results in P4 = 0. Now with ϑ4 = 0, P4 can be shown,
2.7 Specific Interactions
119
using an equation analogous to Eq. (2.96), to be equal to P1 . Notice also that E42 = P42 + M42 is consistent with the conservation of energy, E4 = E1 + M2 , when P4 = P1 and M42 = s = M12 + 2M2 E1 + M22 . Since E1 ≥ M1 , then M4 ≥ M1 + M2 . The threshold energy for this interaction, according to Eq. (2.88), is Ef = E1 . If the formed particle is not stable or quantum-mechanically allowable, as it is mostly the case, since M4 is not likely to correspond to a stable particle, then M4 is simply a compound nucleus that is most likely to decay by the emission of a photon or a charged particle. However, at Ef = E1 = 0, a particle may be formed with a mass M4 = M1 + M2 , which is the case with the absorption of thermal neutrons that have practically a zero energy.
Neutron radiative capture Let us consider the two-body interaction 2(1,3)4, in which particle 1 is a neutron with M1 = Mn , a photon is emitted, M3 = 0, and the target nucleus increased in mass by Mn , i.e. M4 = M2 + Mn . Then according to Algorithm 2: 4sP32 = (s − M4 )2 . The momentum of the emitted γ-ray, according to Eq. (2.96) is: P1 cos ϑγ + (E1 + M2 ) (2.163) Pγ = (s − M42 ) 2(s + P12 sin2 ϑ3 ) In the common case of thermal-neutron absorption, T1 = P1 ≈ 0, and Pγ = Eγ is given by: Q 2 (M1 + M2 ) =Q 1− ≈Q (2.164) Pγ = Eγ = (s − M4 ) 2s 2(M1 + M2 ) Obviously this is an exoergeic interaction in which Q is positive. The lack of dependence of Pγ on the angle of emission indicates that the interaction is isotropic. The approximation is enabled by the fact that Q << M1 , since M1 is about 1 GeV. Indeed, T1 << E1 , since neutron energy does not exceed 20 MeV in practice, and the above approximation is valid for neutron radiative capture at any energy.
Particle emission and transmutation Nuclear interactions involving charged particles result in the transmutation of the nucleus, while those involving neutron emission produce isotopic transformation. In either case, the general kinematics of the interaction is the same. We will consider here, as examples, a number of common interactions.
Alpha particle production Consider the interaction: 10 B(n,α)7 Li. This interaction is used for detecting thermal neutrons. It has two Q-values: 2.792 MeV when 7 Li is left in the ground state,
120
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
and 2.310 MeV when it is an excited state, with the latter condition much more likely. Since the Q-value is positive, the threshold energy is negative, as Eq. (2.88) indicates. That is, this interaction can take place at any energy. The kinematics of this interaction at any incident neutron energy can be evaluated using Algorithms 1 or 2 for the analogous 2(1,3)4 interaction. We will consider here, however, the case of thermal neutrons, i.e. at T1 = P1 ≈ 0. Using Algorithm 2, along with Eq. (2.96) and the definition of Q in Eq. (2.81), one has: ! " 1 M3 − M4 2 2 2 P3 = P3 = Q(M1 + M2 + M3 + M4 ) 1 − (2.165) 4 M1 + M2 M3 M4 2 2 With M M1 = 10, M1 = 4, M1 = 7, then P3 = 5.09M1 Q. The lack of angular dependence of P3 , is indicative of the isotropy of the emerging particles. For Q = 2.31 MeV, assuming M1 = 1 GeV, P32 = 11.76 × 103 MeV2 , T3 = E3 − M3 = 1.47 MeV. Similarly, T4 = 0.84 MeV. Notice that T3 + T4 = Q, as would be expected in this case, since the incident particle is assumed to have no kinetic energy. The reader can repeat these calculations using more accurate values for mass, and should arrive at a very similar result.
Proton production The interaction 3 He(n,p)3 H is also used in neutron detection, and has a Q-value of 0.764 MeV.The interaction is useful for detecting both slow and fast neutrons, it is most sensitive to the former. However, since the neutron energy does not exceed in practice 20 MeV, and the neutron’s rest-mass energy is about 1 GeV, T1 << M1 , one can set E1 = M1 , when describing this interaction by the 2(1,3)4 twoM3 M4 2 body kinematics. Now consider, M M1 = 3, M1 = 1, M1 = 3, then using Eq. (2.165), P32 = 1.5M1 Q. With Q = 0.764 MeV, and M1 = 1 GeV, P32 = 1.15 × 103 MeV2 , T3 = 0.57 MeV. Similarly, T4 = 0.19 MeV. These values are very close to those obtained with more exact mass values and satisfy the relation: T3 + T4 = Q, as expected.
Neutron production Neutron generators exploit the interactions 2 H(2 H,n)3 He and 3 H(2 H,n)4 He, with the aid of accelerated deuteron beams in the energy range of 100–300 keV. Since the energy of the incident particles are quite small compared to their rest masses, a quick estimate of the momentum of the emitted neutrons can be obtained with the aid of Eq. (2.165). For the 2 H(2 H,n)3 He reaction, the Q-value is 3.26 MeV, which leads to a value of P32 = 4.89 × 103 MeV2 , assuming a 1 GeV neutron mass, which in turn gives a neutron kinetic energy of about 2.4 MeV. For the 3 H(2 H,n)4 He reaction, the Q-value is 17.6 MeV, leading to a neutron kinetic energy of 14 MeV. In both cases, the incident particle energy is much
121
2.7 Specific Interactions
smaller than the Q-value of the interaction, the energy of the produced neutron stays at about the same energy at all angles. Photoneutron production Let us now consider a photoneutron interaction such as 2 H(γ,n)1 H (encountered in CANDU reactors, which utilize heavy water as a moderator), or the 9 Be(γ,n)8 Be reaction. The former reaction has a negative Qvalue of Q = −2.226 MeV, while the latter’s has Q = −1.666 MeV.With M1 = 0, T1 = E1 , Eq. (2.97) gives:
s + M32 − M42 = 2[M2 E1 + (Q + M3 )M2 − M3 Q] − Q 2
(2.166)
Equation (2.96) then gives the neutron’s momentum at various angles. Note that, since the incident photon has no mass, no further approximations are useful, in terms of neglecting some terms in the equations of the relativistic Algorithms 1 and 2. However, one may use Newtonian kinematics to obtain an approximate solution. This can be achieved by setting the speed, v0 of C equal to mp12 ; notice the change to lower-case variables which indicates the use of classical mechanics. 4 Now, with m1 = 0, T3 can be expressed using Eq. (2.122) as: T3 = m3m+m (T1 +Q). 4 Since Q is quite small, then according to Eq. (2.130), one can set m¯2 = m2 , and m2 , = m3 + m4 , with p1 replacing m1 v1 in Eq. (2.132) with the above value for T3 , one obtains: T3 =
=
m4 1 m3 p12 (T1 + Q) + m3 + m4 2 (m3 + m4 )2 √ p1 2m4 m3 (m3 + m4 )(T1 + Q) + cos ϑ3 2 (m3 + m4 ) M4 1 M3 E12 (E1 + Q) + M3 + M4 2 (M3 + M4 )2 √ E1 2M4 M3 (M3 + M4 )(E1 + Q) + cos ϑ3 (M3 + M4 )2
(2.167)
The second term in the right-hand side of the above equation is usually neglected, when E1 is much less than M3 or M4 , which is commonly the case. Then Eq. (2.167) becomes identical to that reported for instance in [5], except for the use of the Ls angle, ϑ3 , instead of the C s angle, ϑ3 . However, according to T 2M
1 3 → 0. Given that T1 is Eq. (2.23) ϑ3 = ϑ3 , when vv0 → 0, i.e. when 2(T1 +Q)M 2 M4 3 usually in the MeV range, and same is Q, while the rest masses are in the GeV order of magnitude, this condition is typically satisfied, unless T1 is very close to |Q| in value but then the probability of this interaction becomes quite small.
122
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
Fission This is a drastic and catastrophic interaction, as far as the target nucleus is concerned. Nevertheless, we will use kinematical principles to demonstrate some of its features. Let us consider the specific example of the fission of a 235 U nucleus by a thermal neutron to one of its typical fragments, 95 Sr and 139 Xe. Balance of nucleons necessitates that two neutrons be emitted as well. Let us attempt to determine the energy of one of these neutrons using the concept of inclusive collisions, that is lumping all the other products into one mass, M4 , such that M4 = 235 M3 , with M1 = M3 being the neutron’s rest-mass energy, and M2 = 235 M1 , being the mass of the target nucleus. Since the incident neutron energy is essentially zero, one may use Eq. (2.165) to determine the neutron energy, assuming an approximate Q-value of 200 MeV. This will lead to T3 = 182 MeV, with M1 = 1000 MeV, which is obviously an excessively high energy that is not observed in practice. The mistake that was made in the analysis just presented is that the neutron is treated as a direct product of fission. Neutron production is an after-effect of fission emitted promptly by the fission fragments. Therefore, the energy of the emitted neutrons depends on the excitation energy levels of the emitting nucleus, and can vary widely, with a most probable energy of 0.72 MeV for the fission of 235 U. In addition, some heavier fission fragments may also promptly emit more than one neutron, leading to on average the emission of 2.5 neutrons per 235 U fission. The other forms of energy released in fission, γ and β radiation and neutrinos, are also the result of the decay of fission fragments. Nevertheless, applying the kinematics of Eq. (2.165) to the emission of the above fission products, with M3 referring to 96 Sr and M4 to 140 Xe as the precursors for the emitted neutrons, the obtained kinetic energies for these nuclei are respectively, about 119 and 81 MeV; which are reasonable approximations for the kinetic energy of the fission fragments.
Spallation The spallation process involves the collision of a high energy (typically a proton in the GeV range) light particle with a heavy target, shattering the latter into many small particles and leaving behind a lighter remnant nucleus. Therefore, relativistic kinematics must be applied. The kinematics of spallation is typically divided into two separate steps. In the first step, the energy of the projectile is distributed by collisions among the many nucleons of the target nucleus. This process is known as the intra nuclear cascade, and can result in the emission of some nucleons. The target nucleus is left in an excited state and decays by emitting many low energy charged particles and neutrons; in some cases fission takes place.The de-excitation process is often referred to as “evaporation’’. The kinematics of the intra nuclear cascade process is quite complex as it involves the transport of nucleons via many collisions within the confined potential well of the nucleus. A simplified approach is provided by the abrasion–ablation model5 . In this model, it is assumed that the 5 J.
J. Gaimard and K. H. Schmidt, A reexamination of the abrasion–ablation model for the description of the nuclear fragmentation reaction. Nuclear Physics,Vol. A 531, 1991, pp. 709–745.
2.8 Electromagnetic Interactions
123
projectile strips off a portion of the target (abrasion), leaving the rest of the target as an unaffected (“unheated’’) spectator. The “hot’’ sheared-off portion (called the fireball region) decays by the release of nucleons and bigger fragments, while the remaining portion of the target acquires an additional surface area. The additional surface area, accordingly introduces an excitation energy as the nucleons near the new surface lose their neighbors, see the section on Binding energy (page 22). The subsequent decay (ablation) of the remnant nucleus gives rise to the emission of another set of nucleons and fragments. Experimentally, spallation is studied using reverse kinematics; a process in which the target and projectile are reversed, with heavy ions beams ( ≈ 1 GeV) used to bombard a target of a liquid hydrogen (protons).Then the product particles emerge in the forward direction, due to the forward momentum of the incident ion beam. It becomes then practical to detect the emitted charged particles, by directing them using magnets toward certain detectors.
2.8 Electromagnetic Interactions Electromagnetism affects radiation interactions in a number of ways. First, charged particles in motion (projectiles) produce electromagnetic fields. Targets (atomic electrons, nuclei) also produce their own electric fields. Moreover, photons possess the characteristics of electromagnetic waves that can be affected and affect charged particles as targets. Complete analysis using electromagnetic theory is beyond the scope of this book, but it is dealt with in electrodynamics textbooks such as that of [21]. However, simplified analysis is given here to provide a basic appreciation of the fundamentals.
2.8.1 Coulomb scattering Classical elastic Coulomb scattering The presence of the electrostatic field of atomic electrons produces a repulsive or an attractive effect, depending on the electric charge of the incident particle. This prevents the incident particle from having a “head-on’’ collision, with the target nucleus, and keeps the two particles at some distance apart. On the other hand, an incident particle traveling at the proximity of the target can feel its presence. The latter effect is particularly important given the very long (essentially infinite) range of the Coulomb field. In practice, however, there is some distance, beyond which the mutual effect of the Coulomb force between the two particles is negligible. Within the field of impact, the incident particle will be accelerated by the repulsion or attraction force, hence gain energy and momentum. Some energy will also be transferred to the target and the direction of the incident particle will change. Our interest here is, therefore, to determine this deflection (or scattering) angle and the amount of energy lost by the incident particle, hence that gained by the
124
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
m2, z2
R C
χ
r
m1, z1 b
Figure 2.9 A schematic showing two charged particles approaching each other.
target. Guided by Appendix B of [1], we will determine this angle in C , where the total momentum is zero, by finding the trajectory of a charged particle, of mass m1 and charge ±z1 e, as it approaches a target of mass m2 and charge ±z2 e, where e is the electronic charge, and the ± sign indicates that the charge can be positive or negative. We will consider as usual the target particle to be initially at rest. Figure 2.9 shows a schematic of an incident particle approaching a target at an impact distance b, with distance r + R between them. In the absence of the electrostatic field between the projectile and the target, the projectile would bypass the target at the distance, b. As the field becomes effective, the incident particle 1 will tend to be repulsed or attracted to the target, depending on whether the charges are alike or are opposite. The incident particle will then follow a curved trajectory that we will describe in terms of polar coordinates (r, χ) with the origin at the center of mass, C , of the two particles. Then r will be the distance from the position of particle 1 to C , and χ being some angle measured with respected to an arbitrary axis. Now in C , we can define the following radial and tangential components of the instantaneous velocity, u, and acceleration, a, for particle 1: 2 d2 r dχ ar = 2 − r dt dt dχ 1 d 2 dχ uχ = r aχ = r dt r dt dt dr ur = dt
(2.168)
(2.169)
The instantaneous velocity under the influence of the Coulomb forces is designated here by u, in order to distinguish it from the velocity v away from the field effect. Since there is no force in the tangential directions, aχ = 0, and subsequently r 2 dχ dt = constant. The value of this constant can be obtained by taking advantage of the fact that dχ dt is the angular velocity around C of the line connecting the two particles. The angular velocity times the moment of inertia is equal to the angular
125
2.8 Electromagnetic Interactions
momentum. Therefore, using Eqs (2.24) and (2.25) with v2 = 0, since the target is assumed to be initially at rest, one has: dχ m12 2 r = μ12 v1 b dt μ12 r2
μ2 dχ = 12 v1 b = B dt m12
(2.170)
where μ12 is the reduced mass of particles 1 and 2, and B is a constant at a given impact parameter (distance) b and incident particle velocities v1 in L. The radial acceleration, ar , is related to the Coulomb force by: ±z1 z2 e 2 μ12 2 ±z1 z2 e 2 m1 ar = = 4πε0 (r 2 + R 2 ) 4πε0 r 2 m1 ±z1 z2 e 2 μ212 1 ±A ar = = 2 (2.171) 2 4πε0 m1 r r where ε0 is the permittivity of free space ( ≈ 8.85 × 0−12 C2 /Jm), A is a constant for a given projectile and target, and use was made of the fact that the definition of C is such that m1 r = μ12 (r + R). The sign of A is positive if the two charges are of the same type, indicating a repulsive force, and is negative in the case of attraction, i.e. opposite charges. Now, making use of Eq. (2.170): dr dr dχ dr B = = dt dχ dt dχ r 2 d2 r B 2 d2 r B d2 r dχ = = dt 2 r 2 dχ2 dt dχ2 r 4 which from the definition of ar , Eq. (2.168), and its value (2.171) leads to: 1 d2 r ±A 1 − = 2 2 2 r dχ r B
(2.172)
This differential equation has the solution6 : r=
B2 A FB 2 A
cos χ − 1
(2.173)
dr 1 dy d2 r 1 d2 1 is used to obtain a directly solvable equation: =− 2 , = = y dχ y dχ dχ2 dχ2 y 1 d2 y d2 y ∓A ∓A − 2 , so that: + y = 2 . This differential equation has the solution: y = 2 + F cos (χ − χ0 ), with y dχ2 dχ2 B B F and χ0 being constants of integration. Measuring the angle χ from a direction away from the vertex for an attractive force and toward the vertex for a repulsive force, one can set χ0 = 0 as the initial value of χ (see Fig. 2.11). 1 Transforming back with y = , leads to Eq. (2.173). r
6 The
transformation r =
126
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
where F is a constant of integration, which we will determine below by energy conservation. Equation (2.173) is an equation of a hyperbola. Recall that a hyperbola is the locus of points whose distances from two fixed points (foci) have a constant difference, and in polar coordinates (r, χ) with the origin at a focus, the general form of its equation is: r=
±a(2 − 1) ( cos χ − 1)
(2.174)
with the negative sign for the origin of coordinates at the focus enclosed by the two branches of the hyperbola and the positive sign for the origin outside the conic surface of the hyperbola, 2a is the distance between the two vertices of the hyperbola; see Fig. 2.10, and (called the eccentricity) is the ratio of the distance between the two foci and the two vertices. Therefore, by setting 2 AB 2 = FB A and a = F 2 B 4 −A2 in Eq. (2.174), one obtains the hyperbolic equation of (2.174). When A is positive, i.e. when the force is repulsive, C is a focal point outside the conic section of the hyperbola, while when A is negative (attractive force) C is within the conic section. That is, one branch of the hyperbola will be followed, depending on the nature of the electrostatic force. The two situations are illustrated in Fig. 2.11. Note that in the case of repulsion, r is smallest when
a a
a a
r χ (0,0)
Figure 2.10 A general shape of a hyperbola, with 2a being the distance between its foci. C*
C
χ
a '
' a
a q C
χ
Attractive
q C* Repulsive
Figure 2.11 Hyperbolic orbits for a repulsive Coulomb field (right-hand side) and attractive field (left-hand side) in C.
127
2.8 Electromagnetic Interactions
cos χ = 1; therefore, χ is measured in a direction toward the vertex, while in the case of attraction χ is measured in a direction away from the vertex, since r is minimum at cos χ = −1. Let us determine the integration constant, F. With the equation for r now determined, we can combine the radial and polar components of the instantaneous velocity, u1 of Eq. (2.168)7 , to obtain: u12 = F 2 B 2 sin2 χ +
B2 r2
(2.175)
This enables determining the instantaneous kinetic energy of particle 1, which when added to the potential energy, should be equal to the initial kinetic energy of particle 1. The instantaneous kinetic energy in C is given by: 1 m1 1 2 1 1 2 2 2 T = m1 u1 + mu2 = μ12 (u1 + u2 ) = m1 u1 (2.176) 2 2 2 2 μ12 where u2 is the instantaneous velocity of the target particle in C . The potential 2 2 2e 1 z2 e μ12 energy is 4πεz10z(r+R) = z4πε . Adding this potential energy to T , one obtains 0 r m1 the total instantaneous energy, which must be equal to the initial kinetic energy. Therefore, 1 m1 z1 z2 e 2 μ12 1 2 m1 u1 + = μ12 v12 (2.177) 2 μ12 4πε0 r m1 2 Now using Eqs (2.175) and (2.173), for u1 and r, respectively, one obtains: F = 2
v1 μ12 B m1
2
+
A B2
2 (2.178)
With F known, using Eqs (2.170) and (2.171) for B and A, respectively, one obtains an expression for the two parameters controlling the hyperbola: 2 2 4πε μ v b μ12 b 0 12 1 2 = 1 + v1 = 1+ a = b⊥ (2.179) 2 z1 z2 e b⊥ m1 The parameter b⊥ in Eq. (2.179) is such that: b⊥ = 7 Use
is made of Eq. (2.170) and
|z1 z2 e 2 | 1 4πε0 μ12 v12
dr dy 1 ∓A dr = , y = = 2 + F cos χ. dχ dy dχ r B
(2.180)
128
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
Note that the eccentricity is the same for attractive and repulsive forces, for the same magnitude of particle charge, and ≥ 1 always, which excludes the possibility of an elliptical projectile. The eccentricity is also related to the value of χ at r = ∞, χ∞ , by cos χ∞ = 1, according to Eq. (2.174). In turn, 2χ∞ = π − ϑ . Therefore, the angle of deflection of the incident particle in C , which is also the angle between the asymptotes of the hyperbola, is such that: sin
ϑ1 1 = 2
tan
ϑ1 b⊥ = 2 b
(2.181)
Therefore, it is now possible to determine the angle of deflection ϑ1 in C , and subsequently the corresponding energy in L, using Eqs (2.179) and (2.181). From Eq. (2.179), one can see that at ϑ1 = π2 , b⊥ = b, i.e. b⊥ is the impact parameter at which the scattering angle in C is π2 . The parameter 2b⊥ is called the collision diameter, since at the impact distance corresponding to this diameter the incoming particle is deflected by 90◦ in C . The minimum separation between the projectile and the target occurs, as indicated by Eq. (2.174) and Fig. 2.11, at r = a( ± 1), depending on whether the force between the particles is repulsive (+) or attractive (−ve). Since the definition of C requires rm1 = Rm2 = (r + R)μ12 , the minimum separation distance between the two particles can be expressed as: m1 m1 2 + b2 r|min = a( ± 1) = ±b⊥ + b⊥ (r + R)|min = μ12 μ12 # $ 1 = ±b⊥ +1 (2.182) ϑ sin 23 where use was made of Eqs (2.179) and (2.181). The above equation shows that the collision diameter, 2b⊥ , is the closest permissible distance of approach in a head-on collision (ϑ3 = π) in a repulsive field, i.e. when b = 0 between the interacting particles. In an attractive field, the closest distance of approach in a head-on collision is zero, as Eq. (2.182) shows, then the short-range nuclear forces can cause further effects, such as annihilation. One last quantity we will determine here is the energy of the recoiled target, since it is the energy lost by the incident particle in an interaction. Taking advantage of the fact that when the target’s velocity is zero, one has: v 2 = − v0 , as Eq. (2.8) shows. Since the magnitude of velocities does not change in C by elastic scattering, then v4 = v 2 = v0 , where v4 is the velocity of the target in C after collision. Then as the target scatters by an angle ϑ4 in C , the triangle of the vector diagram of Fig. 2.1 applied after collision to particle 2 becomes isosceles, leading to ϑ4 = 2ϑ4 . Since in C (see Fig. 2.2) ϑ3 + ϑ4 = π, then 2 v4 = π − ϑ3 . The triangle of Fig. 2.9 with v4 = v0 also gives ϑ v42 = 2v02 (1 − cos ϑ4 ) = 2v02 (1 − cos ϑ3 ) = 4v02 sin2 23 . The kinetic energy of the
129
2.8 Electromagnetic Interactions
target particle after collision in L is T4 = 12 m2 v42 . Now with Eqs (2.10), (2.179), and (2.181), one obtains: 2 2μ212 v12 b⊥ 2 = T4 = 2 2 m2 b + b⊥ m2 v12
z1 z2 e 2 4πε0
2
1 2 = 2 2 b + b⊥ m2 v12
z1 z2 e 2 4πε0
2
sin2
ϑ3 2
2 b⊥
(2.183) Note that the amount of energy transferred to the target is inversely proportional to its mass. Therefore, energy loss by Coulomb elastic scattering is predominant in the interaction of charged particles with light particles, mainly electrons. The kinetic energy of the incident particle after collision is T3 = T1 − T4 , where T1 is the initial kinetic energy. Interactions in which the energy transfer is large are referred to as hard collisions, while those soft collisions involve a small energy transfer. The maximum energy transfer occurs when b = 0, i.e. at ϑ3 = π. On the other hand, at very large values of b, the amount of energy transfer becomes quite small, and T4 becomes inversely proportional to b2 . Then the scattering angle also becomes small as Eq. (2.181) indicates. It it is, therefore, customarily to set a limit, bmax , on the value of b. In the case of an atomic electron being the target, bmax is chosen as the value at which the energy transfer is about equal to the binding energy, since then the interaction ceases in effect to be an elastic scattering. In scattering with heavy charged particles, even though the energy loss is not great, as Eq. (2.183) indicates, the projectile particle can experience considerable deflection, as is the case with Rutherford scattering. It is also straightforward to show, using Eq. (2.183), that upon head-on collision (b = 0) in a repulsive field z1 z2 e 2 the closest distance of approach occurs when: 4πε = 12 μ12 v12 , i.e., when the 0 (2b⊥ ) Coulomb field’s potential energy balances with the total kinetic energy of the particles in C (see Eq. (2.126)).
Relativistic elastic Coulomb scattering At high velocities, the eccentricity of the incident particle trajectory, Eq. (2.179), is quite high and the angle of scattering, given by Eq. (2.181), is quite small. Therefore, relativistic elastic scattering is extremely fowardly directed that a straight-line trajectory can be assumed. Then the target hardly recoils, and one can assume that it remains at rest. Due to the small angle of scattering, one can also assume that the change in the magnitude of the momentum of the incident particle is quite small. Then, one √can consider the change, qc, in the momentum of the projectile to be equal to −t13 , where t13 is the t invariant. Therefore, using the notation of Table 2.1, one obtains: q2 c 2 = −t13 = −[(E1 − E3 )2 − P12 − P32 + 2P1 P3 cos θ3 ] ≈ 4P22 sin2
θ3 2 (2.184)
130
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
where we assumed √ E1 ≈ E3 , and P1 ≈ P3 . The equivalent classical momentum transfer is equal to 2m2 T4 , where T4 is the kinetic energy transfer given by Eq. (2.183), since in the case under consideration the target does not significantly move. Comparing 2m2 T4 of Eq. (2.183) to q2 from Eq. (2.184), one has: P1 =
z1 z2 e 2 c z1 z2 e 2 1 z1 z2 e 2 M1 γ = = 4πε0 b⊥ v1 4πε0 b⊥ β 4πε0 b⊥ P1
P12 =
z1 z2 e 2 M1 γ 4πε0 b⊥
(2.185)
where M1 γ is the total energy (excluding potential energy) (see Table 2.1). Note ϑ that, since the momentum hardly changes, ϑ3 = π − ϑ3 , hence sin ϑ23 = sin 23 . Using Eq. (2.183), one can determine b⊥ , half the collision diameter, as: b⊥ =
z1 z2 e 2 E1 4πε0 P12
(2.186)
Therefore, for a given kinetic energy of the projectile, T1 , one can determine the collision diameter, 2b⊥ , since E1 = M1 + T1 and P12 = T12 + 2T1 M2 . Since the target hardly moves, the scattering angle of the projectile in C r and the corresponding one in L are about equal. Moreover, for the small angle of deflection, which occurs in this type of interaction, tan ϑ ≈ ϑ. Then, in analogy with Eq. (2.181), the small deflection angle of the projectile in L for a given impact parameter, b, can be estimated as: ϑ1 = 2
z1 z2 e 2 E1 4πε0 b P12
(2.187)
Since the energy transfer in this interaction is small, one can equate it to the momentum transfer, qc, determined by Eq. (2.184). That is, T4 = qc. The above analysis is obviously simplified, but enables direct use of the relativistic relationships, when needed.
Quantum effects As Eq. (2.24) indicates, the value of the impact parameter, b, can be determined from the angular momentum, J , around the center-of-mass of the projectile and the target, since J = mv1 b. The angular momentum can be written in units of h ( = 2π ), where h is the Planck constant, so that J = l , with l being a scaling factor. Classically, there are no restrictions on the value of l. However, the uncertainty principle imposes some constraints on the value of l, since the uncertainty in determining the position of a particle, hence the uncertainty in b, is such that b p ≈ , where p is the particle’s momentum. Therefore, there is
131
2.8 Electromagnetic Interactions
a minimum value of b for a given momentum such that: bq = p , below which the quantum mechanical effects must be taken into consideration. Therefore, the classical analysis which neglects quantum effects is valid when: c e2 z1 z2 e 2 c b⊥ ≈ = z1 z2 = z1 z2 α > 1 bq 4πε0 v1 4πε0 c v1 v1
(2.188)
2
1 where use was made of Eq. (2.180), and α = 4πεe 0 c ≈ 137 is known as the fine structure constant, for the obvious reason that it determines the level at which fine (quantum mechanical) details are relevant. If the condition of Eq. (2.188) is not satisfied, the impact parameter, b, would not have a definite value, since the uncertainty in it would be large. The condition of Eq. (2.188) is easily satisfied when the particles are slow and heavy (large charge). Then the collision diameter, 2b⊥ , is much greater than the radius of a particle, as is the case with Rutherford scattering.
Rutherford scattering As indicated in Section 1.7.3, Rutherford scattering is the scattering of charged particles by heavy nuclei. Under these conditions, the collision diameter, 2b⊥ , is considerably larger than the radius of the target nucleus. The nuclear potential of the target does not then affect the interaction, neither do the electrons surrounding the nucleus. The charge distribution of the interacting particles do not overlap in this interaction. Therefore, Rutherford scattering is a Coulomb scattering for which classical analysis is applicable. Then, the energy loss is not great, but considerable deflection takes place. At the high speeds encountered in accelerators, Rutherford scattering is also used to describe distant nuclear collisions that do not involve direct contact. The interaction is then a small-angle scattering, for which relativistic treatment can be applied.
Electron scattering For incident electrons to be scattered by a nucleus, they must have sufficient energy to overcome the repulsive electrostatic potential of the atomic electrons. That is, the impact parameter of the projectile electron needs to be less than the size of the atom as defined by its orbiting electrons. Electrons subjected to Coulomb scattering by the nucleus experience a large scattering angle, while hardly losing any kinetic energy. This is evident from the fact that the reduced mass, μ12 , of the electron and any nucleus is quite small (about equal to the mass of the electron). Therefore, as Eq. (2.179) indicates, ≈ 1, and in turn the scattering angle in C is ϑ3 ≈ π, as Eq. (2.181) shows. Given the small mass of the electron compared to that of the nucleus, the C system coincides with L; consequently the scattering angles in L, ϑ3 , is also approximately equal to π. Therefore, the interaction is a backscattering process. The energy acquired by the target, according to Eq. (2.183), is quite small, given the large mass of the
132
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
nucleus. The target hardly gains energy and the incident electrons in turn retain their kinetic energy in spite of the large deflection angle. At high velocities, one needs not only to consider the relativistic effects but also the fact that, as Eq. (2.180) indicates, b⊥ decreases with increased projectile velocity. If the velocity is sufficiently high that b⊥ is comparable or lower than the size of the nucleus, the effect of nuclear forces must be taken into account and a nuclear interaction can take place. The electron energy needed for nuclear effects to take place is on the Ze 2 order of 4πε , where Z is the atomic number of the nucleus and R0 is its radius 0 R0 −15 (on order 10 m). This energy is about 1.44Z MeV, which is a considerable energy for a high Z target.
Scattering by atomic electrons Heavy charged particles are hardly affected by the atomic electrons. They do not lose much energy nor they change direction significantly. As in the case of the scattering of an electron by the nucleus, the reduced mass is quite small, b⊥ as Eq. (2.180) shows is large, and the scattering angle in C according to Eq. (2.181) is ϑ3 ≈ π. However, in this case, C coincides with the incident particle. Then according to Eq. (2.4), the scattering angle in L, ϑ3 ≈ 0. Therefore, for all practical purposes, the Coulomb scattering of heavy charged particles can be neglected, as it does not noticeably affect the incident particles. However, the energy gained by the target electrons is quite significant, due to their small mass, as Eq. (2.183) shows.Therefore, heavy charged particles in their wake cause significant ionization of the target atoms. On the other hand, light charge particles, like electrons, are affected considerably by the target electrons. If the energy transferred to the atomic electrons is sufficiently larger than their binding energy, the interaction can be considered as an elastic one. Then, the collision kinematics of Section 2.8.1 can be applied, provided that the incident particle’s energy is not so large that the particle comes close to, or penetrates, the nucleus. In the case of electron–electron scattering, one cannot distinguish between the scattered electron and the recoiled one. Nevertheless, it can be easily shown, using the kinematics of Coulomb scattering for any two particles of equal mass and charge, that the energy of one of the emerging ϑ
electrons is such that T3,4 = T1 cos2 23,4 , where 1 refers to the incident electron and 3 and 4 to the emerging electrons. Due to the equal mass of the interacting particles, the angle of scattering in C , ϑ = 2ϑ, where ϑ is the scattering angle in L. Note that if the energy transfer is greater than 255.5 keV, i.e. greater than half the rest-mass energy of the electron, the electron–electron elastic scattering becomes a Moller scattering and must be treated relativistically.
Soft collisions When the energy transferred by a charged particle is comparable to the binding energy of its target, the reaction becomes an inelastic one, as far as reaction
133
2.8 Electromagnetic Interactions
kinematics is concerned. Soft collisions, which do not impart much energy, are typically encountered when swift charged particles approach a target at a large impact parameter, resulting in small scattering angles. The trajectory of the incident particle can then be approximated as a straight line, rather than a hyperbola, as is the case in elastic scattering. The amount of energy transfer, i.e. the kinetic energy of the target particle then becomes: 2 2μ212 v12 b⊥ 2 T4 = = 2 m2 b m2 v12 b2
z1 z2 e 2 4πε0
2 (2.189)
This was obtained from Eq. (2.183) by setting b >> b⊥ , and using Eq. (2.180).
2.8.2 Radiative collisions An electric charge ze, at position r0 , creates an electric potential, φ( r ), at all positions, r , around it, such that8 : ze φ( r ) = 4πε0
δ[ r − r0 ] 3 d r | r − r |
(2.190)
where δ[ r − r0 ] is the Dirac delta function, which is zero everywhere except at r = r0 . A moving charged particle changes its position continuously, i.e. r0 becomes a function of time. The electric field produced becomes then time-varying and can be expressed as: ze φ( r , t) = 4πε0
δ[ r − r0 (t )] 3 d r | r − r |
(2.191)
r − r c
(2.192)
The time t is such that: t = t −
where t is the time it takes for the effect of a charge at r to reach a point a r , with the electromagnetic effect traveling at the speed of light, c. This time is called the retarded time, as the influence of the charge is delayed by the time it takes to propagate its effect. A moving charge also creates a current, which in turn 8 The
, is such that E = ∇φ, where ∇ is a vector gradient operator. Coulomb’s law for electrostatics: electric field, E ρe , where ρe is the electric charge per unit volume (Coulomb/m3 ). ε0
= ∇ ·E
134
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
, the potential of which is expressed as9 : introduces a magnetic field, B μ ze r , t) = 0 A( 4π
v1 δ[ r − r0 (t )] 3 d r | r − r |
(2.193)
where μ0 = 4π × 10−7 Henry/m is the permeability of free space, v1 = ∂r∂t0 , is the speed of the moving charged particle (ε0 μ0 c 2 = 1). Expression (2.191) and (2.193) are known as the Liénard (1898) – Wiechert (1990) potentials of a moving point charge [22]. These two equations are evaluated at the retarded time, t . Therefore, the integration of these two equations requires relating r to those at r , but also t to t . The latter times can be related to each other using Eq. (2.192) as: dt v1 · ( r − r ) = 1 − dt c| r − r |
(2.194)
Given that | r − r | = c(t − t ), then t is also a function of position, which leads to: r − r ∇t = − r − r ) c 1 − v1c| ·r( − r |
(2.195)
=∇ ×A and E = −∇φ − ∂A , along Now using the electromagnetic equations: B ∂t with Eqs (2.191), (2.193)–(2.195), one obtains [22]: ⎧ ⎫ 2
⎪ ⎪ v R R ⎨ 1 + (1 − 2 ) R − v1 ] ⎬ − v1 × R [ a × R ze c c c = E (2.196) 3 ⎪ 4πε0 c 2 ⎪ R ⎩ ⎭ R − v1 · c
= {R} ˆ × B
E c
(2.197)
= r − r , where {. . .} indicates that the enclosed function is evaluated at t , R R = |R|, i.e. the distance between the charge and the point at which the fields 9B =∇
i.e. the magnetic field is the curl of the vector potential A. Ampere’s law: ∇ × B = μ0 J , where i is the × A, electric current density (Coulomb/(s m2 )).
135
2.8 Electromagnetic Interactions
R and a = ∂ v1 is the are estimated at this time, Rˆ = R , is a unit vector along R, ∂t particle’s acceleration10 . The electromagnetic energy per unit volume (energy density) is given by: 1 B2 2 B 2 μ0 + ε0 E , while E × μ0 is the energy flux density (across a surface). The latter quantity is also known as Poynting vector. The Poynting vector of the fields of Eqs (2.196) and (2.197) is [23]:
× E
1 B × ({R} ˆ ×E ) = E μ0 μ0 c 1 ˆ − (E · {R}) ˆ E ] [E2 {R} = μ0 c 1 ˆ [E2 {R}] = μ0 c
(2.198)
is normal to R, ˆ so that scalar product where use was made of the fact that E · Rˆ = 0. E The electromagnetic field of Eqs (2.196) and (2.197) contains two components: (1) an acceleration-proportional field which decreases with R1 at large distance, and (2) a velocity-proportional field which decreases with R12 and is equal to the electrostatic field at zero velocity. The velocity-dependent field has a Poynting vector, as Eq. (2.198) shows, that decreases with R14 , and as such when integrating over the area of a spherical surface its power decreases with 1 , vanishing quickly with increasing distance. Therefore, the field created by the R2 velocity-dependent term is often referred to as the near field. The acceleration It is also the dominant field is such that its E and B components are normal to R. term at large distance and is the term that accounts for radiation emission by moving charged particles. The Poynting vector of the acceleration field, according to Eq. (2.198), decreases with R12 , which upon integration with a spherical surface area gives a constant total energy. Therefore, the radiation term gives a finite total power even at infinity in vacuum. It is, therefore, referred to as the radiation field, and it affirms the fact that a charged particle radiates (literally sends out energy) only upon acceleration (a particle cannot radiate if moving at a uniform speed in vacuum). Equation (2.198) indicates that the radiation energy propagates in the direction Therefore, radiation energy crosses a spherical surfaces normal R at a rate of R. E2 (energy per unit area per unit time) of μ0 c . The radiation rate per unit solid angle is
R 2 E2 μ0 c , since
the solid angle is the area divided by R 2 . Since E for the radiation v2
in the above discussion the appearance of the term 1 − c 21 and the retarded time, which also appeared when discussing the Lorentz transform and the special theory of relativity in Section 2.3. The electromagnetic theory led, therefore, to the theory of relativity. In fact the Maxwell’s equations of electromagnetism and the associated equations discussed here are already fully relativistic, and there is no need for relativistic corrections.
10 Notice
136
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
term of Eq. (2.196) is inversely proportional to R, the energy rate per unit solid angle is independent of R, and is given by [22]: v1 B dPwr 2 ˆ · × = {R } 1 − {R} E d c μ0 ⎡
ˆ · a a · v1 {R} c ⎢ = ⎣ 3 + 2 4 2 3 16π ε0 c ˆ · v1 ˆ · v1 1 − {R} 1 − {R} c c ⎤
2 v2 ˆ 1 − c 21 {R} · a ⎥ − 5 ⎦ ˆ · v1 1 − {R} c z2 e 2
a2
(2.199)
where Pwr is the power (energyper unit time) and is the solid angle. Note that n ˆ · v1 in the denominators of the terms in Eq. (2.199), we have the term 1 − {R} c with n = 3, 4, or 5. This term, therefore, influences greatly the angular distribution ˆ · v1 = −β cos ϑ, where ϑ is the angle between of the emitted radiation. Since {R} c ˆ v1 → 0. Then, according to and v1 , with β = v1 , when v1 → c, one has: 1 − {R}· R c c Eq. (2.199), the amount of radiation in the direction along the particle’s velocity (forward direction) is greatly enhanced; a phenomenon known as the relativistic headlight effect. Integration over the solid angle gives [23]: Pwr =
z2 e 2 2γ 4 2 a − ( a · v1 )2 3 4πε0 3c
(2.200)
v2 where γ1 = 1 − c 21 · Note here that regardless of relativistic considerations, a charge cannot be accelerated to a velocity equal to c, because then γ → ∞, and an infinite amount of radiation would be emitted; which is impossible. Equation (2.200) is presented in terms of the time, t, which is the time at the point where the field is determined. The power in terms of the time at the particle, t , is useful when one is interested in determining the energy emission rate per unit volume at the particle, so that it can be added to that of other particles in the volume. This power at t can be obtained by multiplying the power at t by dtdt of Eq. (2.194).
Bremsstrahlung As a charged particle of charge z1 e approaches a target (atomic electron or a nucleus) of charge z2 e, the Coulomb field between the two, E, subjects the
137
2.8 Electromagnetic Interactions
hν
b
b
z1e
z1e z2e
Figure 2.12 A schematic representation of bremsstrahlung.
projectile to an acceleration, a, given by [23]: a =
E z1 z2 e 2 1 = m1 4πε0 r 2 m1 γ
(2.201)
where r is the distance between the two charges, assuming the target is at rest and ignoring its recoil, and m1 γ is the relativistic mass of the projectile. This acceleration lasts for a short period of time; approximately the time the projectile takes to travel a distance b, where b is the impact parameter. We will assume that the curvature of the projectile’s trajectory during this impulse is small, i.e. the deflection angle is small, and the projectile during acceleration is simply a straight line, as schematically shown in Fig. 2.12. The acceleration can be seen as an impulse, since the acceleration is only significant during that short time period; otherwise the acceleration is negligible when the projectile and the target are far apart. On average, the impulse is perpendicular to the projectile velocity. Let us take the impulse period as being equal to t = vb1 , where b is the impact parameter. In other words, we are assuming that the projectile is repelled, or attracted, by the target over a straight-line distance equivalent to the impact parameter, and beyond that distance the effect of the acceleration becomes negligible. We will also assume that the impulse is in a direction perpendicular to the trajectory of the projectile during the acceleration period, as it tends to throw the particle off its path. Then z12 e 2 2a2 γ 4 according to Eq. (2.200): Pwr = 4πε 3 . Multiplying this power by t gives us 0 3c an approximate estimate of the energy emitted during this impulse. Therefore, using Eq. (2.201) with r = b, one estimates the emitted energy, W , as [23]: z2 e 2 2γ 4 W = 1 4πε0 3c 3
z1 z2 e 2 1 4πε0 b2 m1 γ
2
b z4 z2 e 6 2γ 2 1 = 1 2 3 3 2 3 v1 (4πε0 ) 3c m1 v1 b
(2.202)
This interaction is referred to as a radiative collision, as radiation is emitted in the process. As Eq. (2.202) shows, since W is proportional to z22 , an electron as a target (z2 = 1) is much less effective than a nucleus (z2 = Z, where Z is the atomic number), particularly at high Z values. Eq. (2.202) also demonstrates that, at the same
138
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
velocity, electrons emit much more radiation than protons, with the same target, even though they have the same absolute charge value, because of the inverses proportionality with m2 .Therefore, in general, bremsstrahlung is usually neglected in the case of heavy charged particles in the field of other heavy charged particles. However, when a heavy charged particle is accelerated by a free (unbound) electron, the recoil electron experiences acceleration and emits radiation at an energy given also by Eq. (2.202), with z1 replacing z2 , and vice versa, and the mass of the projectile, m1 , replaced by the mass of the target electron. Note that an electron incident on an atom emits radiation by its acceleration by the electrostatic field of the nucleus not by atomic electrons.This is because the incident electron and a target electron would accelerate each other by an equal amount, as Eq. (2.201) shows, but at opposite directions. That is, their electric fields are equal and opposite and produce radiation waves in the far field of bremsstrahlung that are out of phase by an angle π, and in turn cancel each other. However, the motion of the projectile (assuming the target is initially at rest), can cause this phase shift to deviate from the π value. But, as long as this deviation remains small (much smaller than the wavelength of either waves), the electric fields produced by the two electrons will tend to cancel each other. The shift in position of the incident electron during 2π 1 the time of acceleration causes a phase change of at most c t = 2πv cb . Therefore, as long as v1 << c, the two emitted waves would stay at a phase difference of almost π and would tend to cancel each other. At high (relativistic) speeds, the phase difference considerably deviates from π and electron–electron bremsstrahlung becomes relevant. It should be kept in mind that the radiation waves produced in electron–positron bremsstrahlung do not cancel each other out. The bremsstrahlung electromagnetic energy is emitted in the form of a photon, 1 the energy (hence frequency) varies over a frequency range of approximately t , so that: 2 2 dW z12 e 2 2γ 4 z1 z2 e 2 1 b z14 z22 e 6 2γ 2 1 ≈ W t = = dν 4πε0 3c 3 4πε0 b2 m1 γ v1 (4πε0 )3 3c 3 m12 v¯12 b2 (2.203) The average velocity, v¯1 , is used here to account for the energy and momentum carried by the emitted photon, which changes the velocity of the incident particle. Equation (2.203) indicates that for a single particle collision at a certain incident particle energy (hence velocity) and impact parameter, the energy distribution has approximately a uniform spectrum up to the maximum frequency. In order for a photon to be emitted at an energy of hν, the kinetic energy of the incident particle should have a value greater than hν. Therefore, for a given photon frequency, ν, t = 1ν = vb1 , which gives the maximum impact parameter for the impulse producing this photon. The emitted photon carries some momentum, changing in the process the kinetic energy of the incident particle. Therefore, the emitted energy comes at the expense of reduced kinetic energy, causing the particle to suddenly slow down.
139
2.8 Electromagnetic Interactions
It should be kept in mind that the above analysis is approximate, guided by [22] and [23], and is limited to particle speeds much less than c, i.e. for γ ≈ 1. Electrons and positrons, being light particles, can acquire easily relativistic speeds. Then the emitted bremsstrahlung photons can have an energy comparable in value to the rest-mass energy of the electron, and one must deal with the total relativistic energy of the incident electron, not only its kinetic energy. Such analysis is facilitated by considering the electromagnetic field as consisting of “virtual photons’’ which scatter with the incoming electron (i.e. the reverse of Compton scattering). These virtual photons facilitate the energy and momentum transfer process. Bremsstrahlung is then viewed as a scattering process between an electron, or a positron, and a virtual photon, creating a free photon (bremsstrahlung) and a recoil electron, see section 3.4 which deals with quantum electrodynamics. The word “quantum’’ reflects the use of plane waves representing the photons, and the fact that a photon itself is a quantum of energy. The use of quantum mechanics enables the calculation of a wave amplitude for each interaction, the square of which, with proper normalization, determines the interaction probability; see Chapter 3. Therefore, the probability distribution (spectrum) of the bremsstrahlung photons are determined by quantum electrodynamics (see Section 3.6.4). It is worth noting that in spite of these relativistic effects, the flatness of the energy distribution of Eq. (2.203) stays largely valid. Note also that the maximum possible photon energy in relativistic analysis is E = m1 c 2 + T1 , where T1 is the particle’s kinetic energy.
Thomson scattering The scattering of a photon by a free electron is a form of radiative collisions, in which the electron is subjected to the electromagnetic field of the incident photon. In this process, the target electron is accelerated, and begins to oscillate at the same frequency as that of the incident electromagnetic wave. This oscillation produces in turn an oscillating electric field that gives rise to a “retarded’’ (delayed) wave of the same frequency as that of the oscillation. In essence, if the target electron is initially at rest, then the scattered photon would retain its energy. The initial movement of the electron, if present, will cause a Doppler shift between the incident photon and the electron, as well as between the scattered radiation and the observer (due to the motion of the emitter). The result is a scattering frequency determined by: ν3 = ν1 +
1 (k3 − k 1 ) · v3 2π
(2.204)
where the subscripts 1, 2, and 3 designate, respectively, the incident radiation, the target electrons and the scattered radiation, and k is the wave vector of a wave of ˆ a wave number of 2πν c in the direction defined by the unit vector k. The above analysis is applicable to atomic electrons as long as their binding energy is much less than the incident photon energy, so that the electrons can be considered to
140
Chapter 2 Collision Kinematics
be free. It also ignores the change in the momentum of the incident photon and the target electron. This electromagnetic wave analysis also fails at high photon energy, approaching that of the rest-mass energy of the electron, 511 keV, not only because of the large momentum acquired by the target electron, compared to its rest-mass energy, but also because of the quantum nature of the photons (being packets of energy with particle-like behavior). Then, Compton scattering kinematics (see Section 2.7.1), must be applied. Returning to Thomson scattering and viewing the interaction as in effect a Coulomb scattering of the target electron in the electromagnetic field of the incident electron, and assuming non-relativistic conditions, the emitted power (by the electron) per unit solid angle according to Eq. (2.199) is: dPwr e2 = a2 sin2 ψ = d 16π2 ε20 c 3
e2 4πε0 me c 2
2 ε0 cE2 sin2 ψ = re2 si sin2 ψ (2.205)
where the angle ψ here is the angle between the direction of the emitted radiation and the direction of acceleration, and the electron’s acceleration, a, is expressed , with me being the mass of the electron. in terms of the electric field as a = mee E 2
The parameter re2 = 4πεe0 me c 2 is a constant (=2.82 fm), known as the classical electron radius, and si is the magnitude of the Poynting vector, i.e. the instantaneous power per unit area of the incident wave, si = ε0 cE2 . Thomson scattering of photons can also occur with the nucleus. The power emitted per solid angle by the target nucleus can be obtained using Eq. (2.205) by replacing the electron charge, e, by the charge of the nucleus, Ze, and the electron mass by the mass of the nucleus. Obviously, because of the large mass of t