Quantum Theory at the Crossroads
arXiv:quant-ph/0609184v1 24 Sep 2006
Re onsidering the 1927 Solvay Conferen e
Guido ...
36 downloads
1576 Views
3MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Quantum Theory at the Crossroads
arXiv:quant-ph/0609184v1 24 Sep 2006
Re onsidering the 1927 Solvay Conferen e
Guido Ba
iagaluppi Antony Valentini
Cambridge University Press
ISBN: 9780521814218
To the memory of James T. Cushing
Contents
Prefa e Abbreviations Typographi onventions Note on the bibliography Permissions and opyright noti es
1
2
page vii xiii xiv xiv xiv
Part IPerspe tives on the 1927 Solvay onferen e Histori al introdu tion
1.1 Ernest Solvay and the Institute of Physi s 1.2 War and international relations 1.3 S ienti planning and ba kground 1.4 Further details of planning 1.5 The Solvay meeting 1.6 The editing of the pro eedings 1.7 Con lusion Ar hival notes
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
2.1 2.2
2.3
2.4 2.5
Ba kground A new approa h to parti le dynami s: 192324 2.2.1 First papers on pilot-wave theory (1923) 2.2.2 Thesis (1924) 2.2.3 Opti al interferen e fringes: November 1924 Towards a omplete pilot-wave dynami s: 192527 2.3.1 `Stru ture': Journal de Physique, May 1927 2.3.2 Signi an e of de Broglie's `Stru ture' paper 1927 Solvay report: the new dynami s of quanta Signi an e of de Broglie's work from 1923 to 1927 ii
1 3 3 6 10 16 20 22 24 26 30 30 37 38 43 54 57 61 72 75 84
Contents Ar hival notes
iii 88
3
89 3.1 Summary of Born and Heisenberg's report 90 3.2 Writing of the report 93 3.3 Formalism 94 3.3.1 Before matrix me hani s 94 3.3.2 Matrix me hani s 96 3.3.3 Formal extensions of matrix me hani s 100 3.4 Interpretation 102 3.4.1 Matrix me hani s, Born and Wiener 103 3.4.2 Born and Jordan on guiding elds, Bohr on ollisions105 3.4.3 Born's ollision papers 107 3.4.4 Heisenberg on energy u tuations 109 3.4.5 Transformation theory 111 3.4.6 Development of the `statisti al view' in the report115 3.4.7 Justi ation and overall on lusions 119 Ar hival notes 122
4
S hrödinger's wave me hani s
151
5
From matrix me hani s to quantum me hani s
4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6
Planning of S hrödinger's report Summary of the report Parti les as wave pa kets The problem of radiation S hrödinger and de Broglie The oni t with matrix me hani s 4.6.1 Early days 4.6.2 From Muni h to Copenhagen 4.6.3 Continuity and dis ontinuity Ar hival notes
123 124 126 128 133 137 139 140 142 146 150
Part IIQuantum foundations and the 1927 Solvay onferen e Quantum theory and the measurement problem 5.1 5.2
153 What is quantum theory? 153 The measurement problem today 155 5.2.1 A fundamental ambiguity 155 5.2.2 Measurement as a physi al pro ess: quantum theory `without observers'157 5.2.3 Quantum osmology 162 5.2.4 The measurement problem in `statisti al' interpretations of ψ 164
iv
6
Contents
Interferen e, superposition, and wave pa ket ollapse 168 6.1
6.2 6.3 6.4
7
8
9
10
11
12
Probability and interferen e 168 6.1.1 Interferen e in de Broglie's pilot-wave theory 169 6.1.2 Interferen e in the `quantum me hani s' of Born and Heisenberg172 Ma ros opi superposition: Born's dis ussion of the loud hamber177 6.2.1 Quantum me hani s without wave pa ket ollapse?178 Dira and Heisenberg: interferen e, state redu tion, and delayed hoi e182 Further remarks on Born and Heisenberg's quantum me hani s190
Lo ality and in ompleteness
194 194 198 202
Time, determinism, and the spa etime framework
204 204 209 213
7.1 7.2 7.3
8.1 8.2 8.3
Einstein's 1927 argument for in ompleteness A pre ursor: Einstein at Salzburg in 1909 More on nonlo ality and relativity Time in quantum theory Determinism and probability Visualisability and the spa etime framework
Guiding elds in 3-spa e
9.1 9.2
218 Einstein's early attempts to formulate a dynami al theory of light quanta218 The failure of energy-momentum onservation 221
S attering and measurement in de Broglie's pilot-wave theory 227
10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4
S attering in pilot-wave theory 228 Elasti and inelasti s attering: Born and Brillouin, Pauli and de Broglie232 Quantum measurement in pilot-wave theory 244 Re oil of a single photon: Kramers and de Broglie 246
Pilot-wave theory in retrospe t
248 250 258 259 265
Beyond the Bohr-Einstein debate
268 269 272
11.1 11.2 11.3 11.4
Histori al mis on eptions Why was de Broglie's theory reje ted? Einstein's alternative pilot-wave theory (May 1927) Obje tions: in 1927 and today
12.1 The standard histori al a
ount 12.2 Towards a histori al revision
Part IIIThe pro eedings of the 1927 Solvay onferen e
277 H. A. Lorentz † Fifth physi s onferen e
279 281
Contents
v
The intensity of X-ray ree tion (W. L. Bragg )
283 The lassi al treatment of X-ray dira tion phenomena 283 History of the use of quantitative methods 285 Results of quantitative analysis 289 292 Interpretation of measurements of F Examples of analysis 295 The me hanism of X-ray s attering 303 The analysis of atomi stru ture by X-ray intensity measurements308 The refra tion of X-rays 312 Referen es 316 Dis ussion of Mr Bragg's report 318 Notes to the translation 327
Disagreements between experiment and the ele tromagneti theory of radiation (A. H. Compton ) Introdu tion The problem of the ether The emission of radiation The photoele tri ee t Phenomena asso iated with the s attering of X-rays Intera tions between radiation and single ele trons Reliability of experimental eviden e Summary Dis ussion of Mr Compton's report Notes to the translation
329 332 333 335 342 348 352 354 356 372
The new dynami s of quanta (L. de Broglie )
374 I. Prin ipal points of view 374 382 II. Probable meaning of the ontinuous waves Ψ III. Experiments showing preliminary dire t eviden e for the new Dynami s of the ele tron390 Bibliography 397 Dis ussion of Mr de Broglie's report 399 Notes to the translation 407
Quantum me hani s (M. Born and W. Heisenberg )
408 Introdu tion 408 I. The mathemati al methods of quantum me hani s 410 II. Physi al interpretation 420 III. Formulation of the prin iples and delimitation of their s ope429 IV. Appli ations of quantum me hani s 434 Con lusion 437 Bibliography 438 Dis ussion of Messrs Born and Heisenberg's report 442
vi
Contents Notes to the translation
Wave me hani s (E. S hrödinger )
445
Introdu tion I. Multi-dimensional theory II. Four-dimensional theory III. The many-ele tron problem Dis ussion of Mr S hrödinger's report Notes to the translation
448 448 449 458 462 469 475
General dis ussion of the new ideas presented
477 477 498 501 521 525
Causality, determinism, probability Photons Photons and ele trons Notes to the translation Bibliography
Prefa e
And they said one to another: Go to, let us build us a tower, whose top may rea h unto heaven; and let us make us a name. And the Lord said: Go to, let us go down, and there onfound their language, that they may not understand one another's spee h. Genesis 11: 37
Anyone who has taken part in a debate on the interpretation of quantum theory will re ognise how tting is the above quotation from the book of Genesis, a
ording to whi h the builders of the Tower of Babel found that they ould no longer understand one another's spee h. For when it omes to the interpretation of quantum theory, even the most lear-thinking and apable physi ists are often unable to understand ea h other. This state of aairs dates ba k to the genesis of quantum theory itself. In O tober 1927, during the `general dis ussion' that took pla e in Brussels at the end of the fth Solvay onferen e, Paul Ehrenfest wrote the above lines on the bla kboard. As Langevin later remarked, the Solvay meeting in 1927 was the onferen e where `the onfusion of ideas rea hed its peak'. Ehrenfest's per eptive gesture aptured the essen e of a situation that has persisted for three-quarters of a entury. A
ording to widespread histori al folklore, the deep dieren es of opinion among the leading physi ists of the day led to intense debates, whi h were satisfa torily resolved by Bohr and Heisenberg around the time of the 1927 Solvay meeting. But in fa t, at the end of 1927, a signi ant number of the main parti ipants (in parti ular de Broglie, Einstein, and S hrödinger) remained un onvin ed, and the deep dieren es of opinion were never really resolved. The interpretation of quantum theory seems as highly ontroversial vii
viii
Prefa e
today as it was in 1927. There has also been riti ism on the part of historians as well as physi ists of the ta ti s used by Bohr and others to propagate their views in the late 1920s, and a realisation that alternative ideas may have been dismissed or unfairly disparaged. For many physi ists, a sense of unease lingers over the whole subje t. Might it be that things are not as lear- ut as Bohr and Heisenberg would have us believe? Might it be that their opponents had something important to say after all? Be ause today there is no longer an established interpretation of quantum me hani s, we feel it is important to go ba k to the sour es and re-evaluate them. In this spirit, we oer the reader a return to a time just before the Copenhagen interpretation was widely a
epted, when the best physi ists of the day gathered to dis uss a range of views, on erning many topi s of interest today (measurement, determinism, nonlo ality, subje tivity, interferen e, and so on), and when three distin t theories de Broglie's pilot-wave theory, Born and Heisenberg's quantum me hani s, and S hrödinger's wave me hani s were presented and dis ussed on an equal footing. * Sin e the 1930s, and espe ially sin e the Se ond World War, it has been ommon to dismiss questions about the interpretation of quantum theory as `metaphysi al' or `just philosophi al'. It will be lear from the lively and wide-ranging dis ussions of 1927 that at that time, for the most distinguished physi ists of the day, the issues were de idedly physi al : Is the ele tron a point parti le with a ontinuous traje tory (de Broglie), or a wave pa ket (S hrödinger), or neither (Born and Heisenberg)? Do quantum out omes o
ur when nature makes a hoi e (Dira ), or when an observer de ides to re ord them (Heisenberg)? Is the nonlo ality of quantum theory ompatible with relativity (Einstein)? Can a theory with traje tories a
ount for the re oil of a single photon on a mirror (Kramers, de Broglie)? Is indeterminism a fundamental limitation, or merely the out ome of oarse-graining over something deeper and deterministi (Lorentz)? After 1927, the Copenhagen interpretation be ame rmly established. Rival views were marginalised, in parti ular those represented by de Broglie, S hrödinger and Einstein, even though these s ientists were responsible for many of the major developments in quantum physi s itself. (This marginalisation is apparent in most histori al a
ounts written throughout the twentieth entury.) From the very beginning,
Prefa e
ix
however, there were some notes of aution: for example, when Bohr's landmark paper of 1928 (the English version of his famous Como le ture) was published in Nature, an editorial prefa e expressed dissatisfa tion with the `somewhat vague statisti al des ription' and ended with the hope that this would not be the `last word on the subje t'. And there were a few outstanding alarm bells, in parti ular the famous paper by Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen in 1935, and the important papers by S hrödinger (in the same year) on the at paradox and on entanglement. But on the whole, the questioning eased in all but a few orners. A general opinion arose that the questions had been essentially settled, and that a satisfa tory point of view had been arrived at, prin ipally through the work of Bohr and Heisenberg. For subsequent generations of physi ists, `shut up and al ulate' emerged as the working rule among the vast majority. Despite this atmosphere, the questioning never ompletely died out, and some very signi ant work was published, for example by Bohm in 1952, Everett in 1957, and Bell in 1964 and 1966. But attitudes hanged very slowly. Younger physi ists were strongly dis ouraged from pursuing su h questions. Those who persisted generally had di ult areers, and mu h of the areful thinking about quantum foundations was relegated to departments of philosophy. Nevertheless, the losing de ade of the twentieth entury saw a resurgen e of interest in the foundations of quantum theory. At the time of writing, a range of alternatives (su h as hidden variables, many worlds,
ollapse models, among others) are being a tively pursued, and the Copenhagen interpretation an no longer laim to be the dominant or `orthodox' interpretation. The modern reader familiar with urrent debates and positions in quantum foundations will re ognise many of the standard points of view in the dis ussions reprodu ed here, though expressed with a remarkable
on ision and larity. This provides a wel ome ontrast with the generally poor level of debate today: as the distinguished osmologist Dennis S iama was fond of pointing out, when it omes to the interpretation of quantum theory `the standard of argument suddenly drops to zero'. We hope that the publi ation of this book will ontribute to a revival of sharp and informed debate about the meaning of quantum theory. * Remarkably, the pro eedings of the fth Solvay onferen e have not re eived the attention they deserve, neither from physi ists nor from
x
Prefa e
historians, and the literature ontains numerous major misunderstandings about what took pla e there. The fth Solvay onferen e is usually remembered for the lash that took pla e between Einstein and Bohr over the un ertainty relations. It is remarkable, then, to nd that not a word of these dis ussions appears in the published pro eedings. It is known that Einstein and Bohr engaged in vigorous informal dis ussions, but in the formal debates re orded in the pro eedings they were relatively silent. Bohr did
ontribute to the general dis ussion, but this material was not published. Instead, at Bohr's request, it was repla ed by a translation of the German version of his Como le ture, whi h appeared in Naturwissens haften in 1928. (We do not reprodu e this well-known paper here.) The appending of this translation to the published pro eedings may be the ause of the
ommon misunderstanding that Bohr gave a report at the onferen e: in fa t, he did not. Born and Heisenberg present a number of unfamiliar viewpoints on erning, among other things, the nature of the wave fun tion and the role of time and of probability in quantum theory. Parti ularly surprising is the seeming absen e of a ollapse postulate in their formulation, and the apparently phenomenologi al status of the time-dependent S hrödinger equation. Born and Heisenberg's `quantum me hani s' seems remarkably dierent from quantum me hani s (in the Dira -von Neumann formulation) as we know it today. De Broglie's pilot-wave theory was the subje t of extensive and varied dis ussions. This is rather startling in view of the laim in Max Jammer's lassi histori al study The Philosophy of Quantum Me hani s that de Broglie's theory `was hardly dis ussed at all' and that `the only serious rea tion ame from Pauli' (Jammer 1974, pp. 11011). Jammer's view is typi al even today. But in the published pro eedings, at the end of de Broglie's report there are 9 pages of dis ussion devoted to de Broglie's theory, and of the 42 pages of general dis ussion, 15 ontain dis ussion of de Broglie's theory, with serious rea tions and omments
oming not only from Pauli but also from Born, Brillouin, Einstein, Kramers, Lorentz, S hrödinger and others. Even the well-known ex hange between Pauli and de Broglie has been widely misunderstood. Finally, another surprise is that in his report de Broglie proposed the many-body pilot-wave dynami s for a system of parti les, with the total
onguration guided by a wave in onguration spa e, and not just (as is generally believed) the one-body theory in 3-spa e. De Broglie's theory is essentially the same as that developed by Bohm in 1952, the only
Prefa e
xi
dieren e being that de Broglie's dynami s (like the form of pilot-wave theory popularised by Bell) is formulated in terms of velo ity rather than a
eleration. * This work is a translation of and ommentary on the pro eedings of the fth Solvay onferen e of 1927, whi h were published in Fren h in 1928 under the title Éle trons et Photons. We have not attempted to give an exhaustive histori al analysis of the fth Solvay onferen e. Rather, our main aims have been to present the material in a manner a
essible to the general physi ist, and to situate the pro eedings in the ontext of urrent resear h in quantum foundations. We hope that the book will ontribute to stimulating and reviving serious debate about quantum foundations in the wider physi s
ommunity, and that making the pro eedings available in English will en ourage historians and philosophers to re onsider their signi an e. Part I begins with a histori al introdu tion and provides essays on the three main theories presented at the onferen e (pilot-wave theory, quantum me hani s, wave me hani s). The le tures and dis ussions that took pla e at the fth Solvay onferen e ontain an extensive range of material that is relevant to urrent resear h in the foundations of quantum theory. In Part II, after a brief review of the status of quantum foundations today, we summarise what seem to us to be the highlights of the onferen e, from the point of view of urrent debates about the meaning of quantum theory. Part III of the book onsists of translations of the reports, of the dis ussions following them, and of the general dis ussion. Wherever possible, the original (in parti ular English or German) texts have been used. We have ta itly orre ted minor mistakes in pun tuation and spelling, and we have uniformised the style of equations, referen es and footnotes. (Unless otherwise spe ied, all translations of quotations are ours.) Part I (ex ept for hapter 2) and the reports by Compton, by Born and Heisenberg and by S hrödinger, are prin ipally the work of Guido Ba
iagaluppi. Chapter 2, Part II, and the reports by Bragg and by de Broglie and the general dis ussion in Part III, are prin ipally the work of Antony Valentini. Chapters 2, 10 and 11 are based on a seminar, `The early history of Louis de Broglie's pilot-wave dynami s', given by Antony Valentini at the University of Notre Dame in September 1997, at a onferen e in honour of the sixtieth birthday of the late James T. Cushing.
xii
Prefa e *
To James T. Cushing, physi ist, philosopher, historian and gentleman, we both owe a spe ial and heartfelt thanks. It was he who brought us together on this proje t, and to him we are indebted for his en ouragement and, above all, his example. This book is dedi ated to his memory. Guido Ba
iagaluppi wishes to express his thanks to the Humboldt Foundation, whi h supported the bulk of his work in the form of an Alexander von Humboldt Fors hungsstipendium, and to his hosts in Germany, Carsten Held and the Philosophis hes Seminar I, University of Freiburg, and Harald Atmanspa her and the Institut für Grenzgebiete der Psy hologie und Psy hohygiene, Freiburg, as well as to Ja ques Dubu s and the Institut d'Histoire et de Philosophie des S ien es et des Te hniques (CNRS, Paris 1, ENS) for support during the nal phase. He also wishes to thank Didier Devriese of the Université Libre de Bruxelles, who is in harge of the ar hives of the Instituts Internationaux de Physique et de Chimie Solvay, Université Libre de Bruxelles, for his kindness and availability, and Brigitte Parakenings (formerly Uhlemann) and her sta at the Philosophis hes Ar hiv of the University of Konstanz, for the ontinuous assistan e with the Ar hive for the History of Quantum Physi s. Finally, he should wish to thank Je Barrett for suggesting this proje t to him in Utre ht one day ba k in 1996, as well as Mark van Atten, Jennifer Bailey, Olivier Darrigol, Feli ity Pors, Gregor S hiemann and many others for dis ussions, suggestions,
orresponden e, referen es and other help. Antony Valentini began studying these fas inating pro eedings while holding a postdo toral position at the University of Rome `La Sapienza' (199496), and is grateful to Mar ello Cini, Bruno Bertotti and Dennis S iama for their support and en ouragement during that period. For support in re ent years, he is grateful to Perimeter Institute, and wishes to express a spe ial thanks to Howard Burton, Lu ien Hardy and Lee Smolin. We are both grateful to Tamsin van Essen at Cambridge University Press for her support and en ouragement during most of the gestation of this book, and to Augustus College for support during the nal stages of this work. Guido Ba
iagaluppi Antony Valentini
Lake Maggiore, August 2006
Abbreviations
xiii
Abbreviations AEA: Albert Einstein Ar hives, Jewish National and University Library, Hebrew University of Jerusalem. AHQP: Ar hive for the History of Quantum Physi s. AHQP-BSC: Bohr S ienti Corresponden e, mi rolmed from the Niels Bohr Arkiv, Copenhagen. AHQP-BMSS: Bohr S ienti Manus ripts, mi rolmed from the Niels Bohr Arkiv, Copenhagen. AHQP-EHR: Ehrenfest olle tion, mi rolmed from the Rijksmuseum voor de Ges hiedenis van de Natuurwetens happen en van de Geneeskunde `Museum Boerhaave', Leiden. AHQP-LTZ: Lorentz olle tion, mi rolmed from the Algemeen Rijksar hief, Den Haag. AHQP-RDN: Ri hardson Colle tion, mi rolmed from the Harry Ransom Humanities Resear h Center, University of Texas at Austin. AHQP-OHI: Oral history interview trans ripts. IIPCS: Ar hives of the Instituts Internationaux de Physique et de Chimie Solvay, Université Libre de Bruxelles. Ann. d. Phys. or Ann. der Phys.: Annalen der Physik. Bayr. Akad. d. Wiss. Math. phys. Kl.: Sitzungsberi hte der Mathematis h-Physikalis hen Klasse der Königli h-Bayeris hen Akademie der Wissens haften (Mün hen). Berl. Ber.: Sitzungsberi hte der Preussis hen Akademie der Wissens haften (Berlin). A ad. Roy. Belg. or Bull. A . R. Belg. or Bull. A . roy. de Belgique or Bull. A . roy. Belgique or Bull. A . roy. Belg. or Bull. A . R. Belg., Cl. des S ien es: Bulletin de l'A adémie Royale des S ien es, des Lettres et des Beaux-arts de Belgique. Classe des S ien es. Bull. Natl. Res. Coun.: Bulletin of the National Resear h Coun il (U.S.). Comm. Fenn.: Commentationes Physi o-mathemati ae, So ietas S ientiarum Fenni a. C. R. or C. R. A ad. S . or Comptes Rendus A ad. S i. Paris: Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séan es de l'A adémie des S ien es (Paris). Gött. Na hr.: Na hri hten der Akademie der Wissens haften in Göttingen. II, Mathematis h-Physikalis he Klasse. J. de Phys. or Jour. de Phys. or Journ. Physique or Journ. d. Phys.: Journal de Physique (until 1919), then Journal de Physique et le Radium. Jour. Frank. Inst.: Journal of the Franklin Institute.
xiv
Permissions and opyright noti es
Lin ei Rend.: Rendi onti Lin ei. Man hester Memoirs: Man hester Literary and Philosophi al So iety, Memoirs and Pro eedings. Math. Ann. or Mathem. Ann.: Mathematis he Annalen. Naturw. or Naturwiss. or Naturwissens h. or Naturwissens haften: Die Naturwissens haften. Nat. A ad. S i. Pro . or Pro . Nat. A ad. S i. or Pro . Nat. A ad.: Pro eedings of the National A ademy of S ien es (U.S.). Phil. Mag.: Philosophi al Magazine. Phil. Trans. or Phil. Trans. Roy. So .: Philosophi al Transa tions of the Royal So iety of London. Phys. Rev.: Physi al Review. Phys. Zeits. or Phys. Zeits h. or Physik. Zts.: Physikalis he Zeits hrift. Pro . Camb. Phil. So . or Pro . Cambr. Phil. So . or Pro . Cambridge Phil. So .: Pro eedings of the Cambridge Philosophi al So iety. Pro . Phys. So .: Pro eedings of the Physi al So iety of London. Pro . Roy. So . or Roy. So . Pro .: Pro eedings of the Royal So iety of London. Upsala Univ. Årsskr.: Uppsala Universitets Årsskrift. Z. f. Phys. or Zts. f. Phys. or Zeit. f. Phys. or Zeits. f. Phys. or Zeits h. f. Phys. or Zeits hr. f. Phys.: Zeits hrift für Physik.
Typographi onventions The following onventions have been used. Square bra kets [ ℄ denote editorial amendments or (in the translations) original wordings. Curly bra kets { } denote additions (in original types ripts or manus ripts). Angle bra kets < > denote an ellations (in original types ripts or manus ripts).
Note on the bibliography The referen es ited in Parts I and II, and in the endnotes and editorial footnotes to Part III, are listed in our bibliography. The referen es
ited in the original Solvay volume are found in the translation of the pro eedings in Part III.
Permissions and opyright noti es
Part I Perspe tives on the 1927 Solvay onferen e
1 Histori al introdu tion
Quantum re on iliation very [added, deleted℄ unpleasant [deleted℄ tenden y [deleted℄ retrograde [deleted℄ questionable [added, deleted℄ idea [deleted℄ ippant [deleted℄ title leads to misunderstanding. Ehrenfest, on the onferen e plans
1
The onferen e was surely the most interesting s ienti
onferen e I have taken part in so far. 2 Heisenberg, upon re eipt of the onferen e photograph
The early Solvay onferen es were remarkable o
asions, made possible by the generosity of Belgian industrialist Ernest Solvay and, with the ex eption of the rst onferen e in 1912, planned and organised by the indefatigable Hendrik Antoon Lorentz. In this hapter, we shall rst sket h the beginnings of the Solvay onferen es, Lorentz's involvement and the situation in the years leading up to 1927 (se tions 1.1 and 1.2). Then we shall des ribe spe i ally the planning of the fth Solvay onferen e, both in its s ienti aspe ts (se tion 1.3) and in its more pra ti al aspe ts (se tion 1.4). Se tion 1.5 presents the day-by-day progress of the onferen e as far as it an be re onstru ted from the sour es, while se tion 1.6 follows the making of the volume of pro eedings, whi h is the main sour e of original material from the fth Solvay onferen e and forms Part III of this book.
1.1 Ernest Solvay and the Institute of Physi s Ernest Solvay had an extensive re ord of supporting s ienti , edu ational and so ial initiatives, as Lorentz emphasises in a two-page 3
4
Histori al introdu tion
do ument written in September 1914, during the rst months of the rst world war:3 I feel bound to say some words in these days about one of Belgium's noblest
itizens, one of the men whom I admire and honour most highly. Mr Ernest Solvay .... is the founder of one of the most ourishing industries of the world, the soda manufa ture based on the pro ess invented by him and now spread over Belgium, Fran e, England, Germany, Russia and the United States. ....
The fortune won by an a tivity of half a entury has been largely used
by Mr Solvay for the publi benet.
In the rm onvi tion that a better
understanding of the laws of nature and of human so iety will prove one of the most powerful means for promoting the happiness of mankind, he has in many ways and on a large s ale en ouraged and supported s ienti resear h and tea hing.
Part of this a tivity was entred around the proje t of the Cité S ientique, a series of institutes in Brussels founded and endowed by Ernest Solvay and by his brother Alfred Solvay, whi h ulminated in the founding of the Institutes of Physi s and of Chemistry in 1912 and 1913.a This proje t had originally developed through the han e en ounter between Ernest Solvay and Paul Héger, physi ian and professor of physiology at the Université Libre de Bruxelles (ULB), and involved a ollaboration between Solvay, the ULB and the ity of Brussels. In June 1892, it was agreed that Solvay would onstru t and equip two Institutes of Physiology on land owned by the ity in the Par Léopold in Brussels.b There soon followed in 189394 an Institute for Hygiene, Ba teriology and Therapy, funded mainly by Alfred Solvay, and a S hool of Politi al and So ial S ien es, founded by Ernest Solvay in 1894, whi h moved to the Cité S ientique in 1901, and to whi h a S hool of Commer e was added in 1904. The idea for what be ame known as the rst Solvay onferen e in physi s goes ba k to Wilhelm Nernst and Max Plan k,c who around 1910
onsidered that the urrent problems in the theory of radiation and in the theory of spe i heats had be ome so serious that an international meeting (indeed a ` oun il') should be onvened in order to attempt to resolve the situation. The further en ounter between Nernst and Solvay provided the material opportunity for the meeting, and by July 1910, a The following material on the Cité S ientique is drawn mainly from Despy-Meyer and Devriese (1997). b One was to be ome property of the ity and given in use to the ULB, while the other was to be leased for thirty years to and run by Solvay himself.
In the rest of this and in part of the following se tions, we draw on an unpublished
ompilation of the ontents of the Solvay ar hives by J. Pelseneer.4
1.1 Ernest Solvay and the Institute of Physi s
5
Nernst was sending Solvay the detailed proposals. He had also se ured the ollaboration of Lorentz (who was eventually asked to preside), of Knudsen and naturally of Plan k, who wrote: .... anything that may happen in this dire tion will ex ite my greatest interest and .... I promise already my parti ipation in any su h endeavour. For I an say without exaggeration that in fa t for the past 10 years nothing in physi s has so ontinuously stimulated, ex ited and irritated me as mu h as these a quanta of a tion.
Lorentz set up a ommittee to onsider questions relating to the new experimental resear h that had been deemed ne essary during the
onferen e (whi h took pla e between 30 O tober and 3 November 1911). This ommittee in luded Marie Curie, Brillouin, Warburg, Kamerlingh Onnes, Nernst, Rutherford and Knudsen. Lorentz in turn was asked to be the president. Further, at the end of the onferen e, Solvay proposed to Lorentz the idea of a s ienti foundation. Lorentz's reply to Solvay's proposals, of 4 January 1912, in ludes extremely detailed suggestions on the fun tions and stru ture of the foundation, all of whi h were put into pra ti e and whi h an be summarised as follows.6 The foundation would be devoted prin ipally to physi s and physi al
hemistry, as well as to questions relating to physi s from other s ien es. It would provide international support to resear hers (`a Rutherford, a Lenard, a Weiss') in the form of money or loan of s ienti instruments, and it would provide s holarships for young Belgian s ientists (both men and women) to work in the best laboratories or universities, mostly abroad. The question of a link between the foundation and the `Conseil de physique' was left open, but Lorentz suggested to provide meeting fa ilities if Solvay wished to link the two. Lorentz suggested instituting an administrative board ( onsisting of a Solvay family member or appointee, an appointee of the King, and a member of the Belgian s ienti establishment) and a s ienti ommittee (whi h ould initially be the one he had formed during the rst Solvay onferen e). Finally, Lorentz suggested housing the foundation in an annex of one of the existing institutes in the Cité Universitaire. During January, Solvay sent Paul Héger to Leiden to work with Lorentz on the statutes of the foundation, whi h Lorentz sent to Solvay on 2 February. Solvay approved them with hardly any modi ations (only su h as were required by the Belgian legislation of the time). The a Exquisite ending in the original: `.... dass mi h seit 10 Jahren im Grunde ni hts in der Physik so ununterbro hen an-, er-, und aufregt wie diese Wirkungsquanten'.5
6
Histori al introdu tion
foundation, or rather the `Solvay International Institute of Physi s', was o ially established on 1 May 1912, whi h predates by several years the establishment of the omparable Belgian state institutions (Fondation Universitaire: 1920; Fonds National de la Re her he S ientique: 1928). In this onne tion, Lorentz hoped `that governments would understand more and more the importan e of s ienti resear h and that in the long run one will arrive at a satisfa tory organisation, independent of the individual eorts of private persons',7 a sentiment e hoed by Solvay himself.a The institute, whi h Solvay had endowed for thirty years, ould soon boast of remarkable a tivity in supporting s ienti resear h. The numerous re ipients of subsidies granted during the rst two years until the rst world war in luded Lebedew's laboratory, von Laue, Sommerfeld, Fran k and Hertz, W. L. Bragg (who was later to be ome president of the s ienti ommittee), Stark, and Wien. In 1913, an Institute of Chemistry followed suit, organised along similar lines to the Institute of Physi s.
1.2 War and international relations The rst meeting of the s ienti ommittee, for the planning of the se ond Solvay onferen e, took pla e on 30 September and 1 O tober 1912. The onferen e was held the following year, but the a tivities of the institute were soon disrupted by the start of the rst world war, in parti ular the German invasion of Belgium. Immediate pra ti al disruption in luded the fear of requisitions, the di ulty of ommuni ation between the international membership of the s ienti ommittee and, with regard to the publi ation of the pro eedings of the se ond Solvay onferen e, the impossibility of sending Lorentz the proofs for orre tion and the eventual prospe t of German
ensorship.a The war, however, had longer-term negative impli ations for international intelle tual ooperation. In O tober 1914, a group of 93 representatives of German s ien e and ulture signed the manifesto `An die a `Mr Solvay also thinks that it is the role of the state to subsidise and organise s ienti institutions, and he hopes that in thirty years the state will fulll this duty better than it does today.'8 a The pro eedings of the rst Solvay onferen e had had both a Fren h and a German edition. Those of the se ond Solvay onferen e were printed in three languages in 1915, but never published in this form and later mostly destroyed. Only under the hanged onditions after the war, in 1921, were the pro eedings published in a Fren h translation ( arried out, as on later o
asions, by J.-É. Vers haelt).
1.2 War and international relations
7
Kulturwelt!', denying German responsibilities in the war.a Among the signatories were both Nernst and Plan k. This manifesto was partly responsible for the very strong hostility of Fren h and Belgian s ientists and institutions towards renewal of s ienti relations with Germany after the war. No Germans or Austrians were invited to the third Solvay onferen e of 1921. The only ex eption (whi h remained problemati until the last minute) was Ehrenfest, who was Austrian, but who had remained in Leiden throughout the war as Lorentz's su
essor. Similarly, no Germans parti ipated in the fourth Solvay onferen e of 1924. Fren h and Belgian armies had o
upied the Ruhr in January 1923, and the international situation was parti ularly tense. Einstein had (temporarily) resigned from the League of Nations' Committee on Intelle tual Cooperation, and wrote to Lorentz that he would not parti ipate in the Solvay onferen e be ause of the ex lusion of the German s ientists, and that he should please make sure that no invitation was sent.9 Bohr also de lined to parti ipate in the onferen e apparently be ause of the ontinued ex lusion of German s ientists (Moore 1989, p. 157). S hrödinger, however, who was Austrian and working in Switzerland, was invited.a Einstein had distinguished himself by assuming a pa ist position during the war.b Lorentz was pointing out Einstein's ex eptional ase to Solvay already in January 1919: However, in talking about the Germans, we must not lose sight of the fa t that they ome in all kinds of nuan es. A man like Einstein, the great and profound physi ist, is not `German' in the sense one often atta hes to the word today; his judgement on the events of the past years will not dier at all from 11 yours or mine.
a The main laims of the manifesto were: `.... It is not true that Germany is the
ause of this war. .... It is not true that we have wantonly [freventli h℄ infringed the neutrality of Belgium. .... It is not true that the life and property of a single Belgian itizen has been tou hed by our soldiers, ex ept when utter self-defen e required it. .... It is not true that our troops have raged brutally against Leuven. .... It is not true that our ondu t of war disregards the laws of international right. .... It is not true that the struggle against our so- alled militarism is not a struggle against our ulture ....' (translated from Böhme 1975, pp. 479). a Van Aubel (a member of the s ienti ommittee) obje ted strongly in 1923 to the possibility of Einstein being invited to the fourth Solvay onferen e, and resigned when it was de ided to invite him. It appears he was onvin ed to remain on the
ommittee.10 b For instan e, Einstein was one of only four signatories of the ounter-manifesto `Aufruf an die Europäer' (Ni olai 1917). Note also that Einstein had renoun ed his German itizenship and had be ome a Swiss itizen in 1901, although there was some un ertainty about his itizenship when he was awarded the Nobel prize (Pais 1982, pp. 45 and 5034).
8
Histori al introdu tion
In the meantime, after the treaty of Lo arno of 1925, Germany was going to join the League of Nations, but the details of the negotiations were problemati .a As early as February 1926, one nds mention of the prospe t of renewed in lusion of German s ientists at the Solvay
onferen es.13 In the same month, Kamerlingh Onnes died, and at the next meeting of the s ienti ommittee, in early April (at whi h the fth Solvay onferen e was planned), it was de ided to propose both to invite Einstein to repla e Onnes and to in lude again the German s ientists. On 1 April, Charles Lefébure, then se retary of the administrative
ommission, wrote to ommission members Armand Solvay and Jules Bordet,a enquiring about the admissibility of `moderate gures like Einstein, Plan kb and others'16 (Bordet telegraphed ba k: `Germany will soon be League of Nations therefore no obje tion'17 ). On 2 April, Lorentz himself had a long interview with the King, who gave his approval. Thus, nally, Lorentz wrote to Einstein on 6 April, informing him of the unanimous de ision by the members of the ommittee present at the meeting,c as well as of the whole administrative ommission, to invite him to su
eed Kamerlingh Onnes. The Solvay onferen es were to readmit Germans, and if Einstein were a member of the ommittee, Lorentz hoped this would en ourage the German s ientists to a
ept the invitation.18 Einstein was favourably impressed by the positive Belgian attitude and glad to a
ept under the altered onditions.19 Lorentz pro eeded to invite the German s ientists, `not be ause there should be su h a great haste in the thing, rather to show the Germans as soon a Lorentz to Einstein on 14 Mar h 1926: `Things are bad with the League of Nations; if only one ould yet nd a way out until the day after tomorrow'.12 Negotiations provisionally broke down on 17 Mar h, but Germany eventually joined the League in September 1926. a Lefébure was the appointee of the Solvay family to the administrative ommission, and as su h su
eeded Eugène Tassel, who had died in O tober 1922 and had been a long-standing ollaborator of Ernest Solvay sin e 1886. Armand Solvay was the son of Ernest Solvay, who had died on 26 May 1922. Bordet was the royal appointee to the ommission, and had just been appointed in February 1926, following the death of Paul Héger.14 b A
ording to Lorentz, Plan k had always been helpful to him when he had tried to intervene with the German authorities during the war. Further, Plan k had somewhat qualied his position with regard to the Kulturwelt manifesto in an open letter, whi h he asked Lorentz to publish in the Dut h newspapers in 1916. On the other hand, he expli itly ruled out a publi disavowal of the manifesto in De ember 1923.15
Listed as Marie Curie, Langevin, Ri hardson, Guye and Knudsen (with two members absent, W. H. Bragg and Van Aubel).
1.2 War and international relations
9
as possible our good will',20 and sent the informal invitations to Born, Heisenberg and Plan k (as well as to Bohr) in or around June 1926.21 As late as O tober 1927, however, the issue was still a sensitive one. Van Aubel (who had not been present at the April 1926 meeting of the s ienti ommittee) replied in the negative to the o ial invitation to the onferen e.a Furthermore, it was proposed to release the list of parti ipants to the press only after the onferen e to avoid publi demonstrations. Lorentz travelled in person to Brussels on 17 O tober to dis uss the matter.23 Lorentz's own position during and immediately after the war, as a physi ist from one of the neutral ountries, had possibly been rather deli ate. In the text on Ernest Solvay from whi h we have quoted at the beginning of this hapter, for instan e, he appears to be defending the impartiality of the poli ies of the Institute of Physi s in the years leading up to the war. Lorentz started working for some form of re on iliation as soon as the war was over, writing as follows to Solvay in January 1919: All things onsidered, I think I must propose to you not to ex lude formally the Germans, that is, not to lose the door on them forever. I hope that it may be open for a new generation, and even that maybe, in the ourse of the years, one may admit those of today's s holars who one an believe regret sin erely and honestly the events that have taken pla e. Thus German s ien e will be 24 able to regain the pla e that, despite everything, it deserves for its past.
It should be noted that Lorentz was not only the s ienti organiser of the Solvay institute and the Solvay onferen es, but also a prime mover behind eorts towards international intelle tual ooperation, through his heavy involvement with the Conseil International de Re her hes, as well as with the League of Nations' Committee on Intelle tual Cooperation, of whi h he was a member from 1923 and president from 1925.b Lorentz's gure and ontributions to the Solvay onferen es are movingly re alled by Marie Curie in her obituary of Lorentz in the pro eedings of the fth Solvay onferen e (whi h opens Part III of this volume). a Lefébure's omment was: `be ause there are Germans! Then why does he stay in the Institute of Physi s?'22 b The Conseil International de Re her hes (founded in 1919) has today be ome the International Coun il for S ien e (ICSU). The Committee on Intelle tual Cooperation (founded in 1922) and the related International Institute of Intelle tual Cooperation (inaugurated in Paris in 1926) were the forerunners of UNESCO.25
10
Histori al introdu tion
1.3 S ienti planning and ba kground What was at issue in the remark that heads this hapter,a s ribbled by Ehrenfest in the margin of a letter from Lorentz, was the proposed topi for the fth Solvay onferen e, namely `the oni t and the possible re on iliation between the lassi al theories and the theory of quanta'.26 Ehrenfest found the phrasing obje tionable in that it en ouraged one to `swindle away the fruitful and suggestive harshness of the oni t by most slimy un lear thinking, quite in analogy with what happened also even after 1900 with the me hani al ether theories of the Maxwell equations', pointing out that `Bohr feels even more strongly than me against this slogan [S hlagwort℄, pre isely be ause he takes it so parti ularly to heart to nd the foundations of the future theory'.27 Lorentz took Ehrenfest's suggestion into a
ount, and dropped the referen e to re on iliation both from the title and from later des riptions of the fo us of the meeting.a The meeting of the s ienti ommittee for the planning of the fth Solvay onferen e took pla e in Brussels on 1 and 2 April 1926. Lorentz reported a few days later to Einstein: As the topi for 1927 we have hosen `The quantum theory and the lassi al theories of radiation', and we hope to have the following reports or le tures:
1 2 3
W. L. Bragg. New tests of the lassi al theory. A. H. Compton. Compton ee t and its onsequen es. C. T. R. Wilson. Observations on photoele trons and ollision ele trons by
the ondensation method.
4 5
L. de Broglie. Interferen e and light quanta. (short note):
Kramers.
Theory of Slater-Bohr-Kramers and analogous
theories.
6
Einstein. New derivations of Plan k's law and appli ations of statisti s to
quanta.
7
Heisenberg. 29 theory.
Adaptation of the foundations of dynami s to the quantum
Another report, by the ommittee's se retary Vers haelt,30 adds, on erning point 5 : `(at least, if Mr Kramers judges that it is still useful)'; a In the original: `Quantenverzoening <{zeer} antipathik<e>> <{bedenkelijk<e>}> [?℄ titel wekt misverstand'. Many thanks to Mark van Atten for help with this passage. a To Bohr in June 1926: `.... the oni t between the lassi al theories and the quantum theory .... '; to S hrödinger in January 1927: ` .... the ontrast between the urrent and the earlier on eptions [Auassungen℄ and the attempts at development of a new me hani s'.28
1.3 S ienti planning and ba kground
11
it further lists a few alternative speakers: Compton or Debye for 2 , Einstein or Ehrenfest for 6 , and Heisenberg or S hrödinger for 7.a Thus, the fth Solvay onferen e, as originally planned, was to fo us mainly on the theory of radiation and on light quanta, in luding only one report on the new quantum theory of matter. The shift in fo us between 1926 and 1927 was learly due to major theoreti al advan es (for example by S hrödinger and Dira ) and new experimental results (su h as the Davisson-Germer experiments), and it an be partly followed as the planning of the onferen e progressed. S hrödinger's wave me hani s was one of the major theoreti al developments of the year 1926. Einstein, who had been alerted to S hrödinger's rst paper by Plan k ( f. Przibram 1967, p. 23), suggested to Lorentz that S hrödinger should talk at the onferen e instead of himself, on the basis of his new `theory of quantum states', whi h he des ribed as a development of genius of de Broglie's ideas.31 While it is un lear whether Lorentz knew of S hrödinger's papers by the time of the April meeting,a S hrödinger was listed a week later as a possible substitute for Heisenberg, and Lorentz himself was assuring Einstein at the end of April that S hrödinger was already being onsidered, spe ially as a substitute for the report on the new foundations of dynami s rather than for the report on quantum statisti s.b Lorentz losely followed the development of wave me hani s, indeed
ontributing some essential ritique in his orresponden e with S hrödinger from this period, for the most part translated in Przibram (1967) (see hapter 4, espe ially se tions 4.3 and 4.4, for some more details on this orresponden e). Lorentz also gave a number of olloquia and le tures on wave me hani s (and on matrix me hani s) in the period leading up to the Solvay onferen e, in Leiden, Itha a and Pasadena.32 In Pasadena he also had the opportunity of dis ussing with S hrödinger the possibility that S hrödinger may also give a report at the onferen e, as in fa t he did.c S hrödinger's wave me hani s had also made a great impression on Einstein, although he repeatedly expressed his unease to Lorentz at the use of wave fun tions on onguration spa e (`obs ure',34 `harsh',35 a `Mysterium'36 ), and again during the general dis ussion (p. 488). a For details of the other parti ipants, see the next se tion. a Cf. se tion 4.1. b Note that S hrödinger (1926a) had written on `Einstein's gas theory' in a paper that is an immediate pre ursor to his series of papers on quantisation.
Lorentz was at Cornell from September to De ember 1926, then in Pasadena until Mar h 1927.33 On S hrödinger's Ameri an voyage, see Moore (1989, pp. 23033).
12
Histori al introdu tion
One sees Lorentz's involvement with the re ent developments also in his orresponden e with Ehrenfest. In parti ular, Lorentz appears to have been stru k by Dira 's ontributions to quantum me hani s.a In June 1927, Lorentz invited Dira to spend the following a ademi year in Leiden ,38 and asked Born and Heisenberg to in lude a dis ussion of Dira 's work in their report.39 Finally, in late August, Lorentz de ided that Dira , and also Pauli, ought to be invited to the onferen e, for indeed: Sin e last year, quantum me hani s, whi h will be our topi , has developed with an unexpe ted rapidity, and some physi ists who were formerly in the se ond tier have made extremely notable ontributions.
For this reason I
would be very keen to invite also Mr Dira of Cambridge and Mr Pauli of Copenhagen. .... Their ollaboration would be very useful to us .... I need not
onsult the s ienti ommittee be ause Mr Dira and Mr Pauli were both on 40
a list that we had drawn up last year .... .
Lorentz invited Pauli on 5 September 1927 (Pauli 1979, pp. 4089) and Dira sometime before 13 September 1927.41 On the experimental side, some of the main a hievements of 1927 were the experiments on matter waves. While originally de Broglie was listed to give a report on light quanta, the work he presented was about both light quanta and material parti les (indeed, ele trons and photons!), and Lorentz asked him expli itly to in lude some dis ussion of the re ent experiments speaking in favour of the notion of matter waves, spe i ally dis ussing Elsasser's (1925) proposals, and the experimental work of Dymond (1927) and of Davisson and Germer (1927).42 Thus, in the nal programme of the onferen e, we nd three reports on the foundations of a new me hani s, by de Broglie, Heisenberg (together with Born) and S hrödinger. The talks given by Bragg and Compton, instead, ree t at least in part the initial orientation of the onferen e. Here is how Compton presents the division of labour (p. 329): Professor W. L. Bragg has just dis ussed a whole series of radiation phenomena in whi h the ele tromagneti theory is onrmed.
....
I have been left the
task of pleading the opposing ause to that of the ele tromagneti theory of radiation, seen from the experimental viewpoint.
Bragg fo usses in parti ular on the te hnique of X-ray analysis, as the `most dire t way of analysing atomi and mole ular stru ture' (p. 284), a This orresponden e in ludes for instan e a 15-page ommentary by Lorentz on Dira (1927a).37
1.3 S ienti planning and ba kground
13
the development of whi h, as he had mentioned to Lorentz, was the `line in whi h [he had℄ been espe ially interested'.43 This in ludes in parti ular the investigation of the ele troni harge distribution. At Lorentz's request, he had also in luded a dis ussion of the refra tion of X-rays (se tion 8 of his report), whi h is dire tly relevant to the dis ussion after Compton's report.44 As des ribed by Lorentz in June 1927, Bragg was to report `on phenomena that still somehow allow a
lassi al des ription'.45 A few more aspe ts of Bragg's report are of immediate relevan e for the rest of the onferen e, espe ially to the dis ussion of S hrödinger's interpretation of the wave fun tion in terms of an ele tri harge density (pp. 307, 312, se tion 4.4), and so are some of the issues taken up further in the dis ussion (Hartree approximation, problems with waves in three dimensions), but it is fair to say that the report provides a rather distant ba kground for what followed it. Compton's talk overs the topi s of points 2 and 3 listed above. The expli it fo us of his report is the three-way omparison between the photon hypothesis, the Bohr-Kramers-Slater (BKS) theory of radiation, and the lassi al theory of radiation. Note, however, that Compton introdu es many of the topi s of later dis ussions. For instan e, he dis usses the problem of how to explain atomi radiation (se tion on `The emission of radiation', p. 333), whi h is inexpli able from the point of view of the lassi al theory, given that the `orbital frequen ies' in the atom do not orrespond to the emission frequen ies. This problem was one of S hrödinger's main on erns and one of the main points of oni t between S hrödinger and, for instan e, Heisenberg (see in parti ular the dis ussion after S hrödinger's report and, below, se tions 4.4 and 4.6). Compton's dis ussion of the photon hypothesis relates to the question of `guiding elds' (pp. 331 and 354) and of the lo alisation of parti les or energy quanta within a wave (pp. 339 and 348). These in turn are losely
onne ted with some of de Broglie's and Einstein's ideas (see below
hapter 7, espe ially se tion 7.2, and hapter 9 ), and with de Broglie's report on pilot-wave theory and Einstein's remark about lo ality in the general dis ussion (p. 488). Bohr had been a noted s epti of the photon hypothesis, and in 1924 Bohr, Kramers and Slater had developed a theory that was able to maintain a wave pi ture of radiation, by introdu ing a des ription of the atom based on `virtual os illators' with frequen ies equal to the frequen ies of emission (Bohr, Kramers and Slater 1924a,b).a A stationary state of a As Darrigol (1992, p. 257) emphasises, while the free virtual elds obey the
14
Histori al introdu tion
an atom, say the nth, is asso iated with a state of ex itation of the os illators with frequen ies orresponding to transitions from the energy En . Su h os illators produ e a lassi al radiation eld (a `virtual' one), whi h in turn determines the probabilities for spontaneous emission in the atom, that is, for the emission of energy from the atom and the jump to a stationary state of lower energy. The virtual eld of one atom also intera ts with the virtual os illators in other atoms (whi h in turn produ e se ondary virtual radiation) and inuen es the probabilities for indu ed emission and absorption in the other atoms. While the theory provides a me hanism for radiation onsistent with the pi ture of stationary states ( f. Compton's remarks, p. 335), it violates energy and momentum onservation for single events, in that an emission in one atom is not onne ted dire tly to an absorption in another atom, but only indire tly through the virtual radiation eld. Energy and momentum onservation hold only at a statisti al level. The BKS proposal was short-lived, be ause the Bothe-Geiger and Compton-Simon experiments established the onservation laws for individual pro esses (as explained in detail by Compton in his report, pp. 350 .). Thus, at the time of the planning of the fth Solvay onferen e, the experimental eviden e had ruled out the BKS theory (hen e the above remark: `if Mr Kramers judges that it is still useful').a The short note 5, indeed, dropped out of the programme altogether.b The des ription of the intera tion between matter and radiation, in parti ular the Compton ee t, ontinued to be a problem for Bohr, and
ontributed to the development of his views on wave-parti le dualism and
omplementarity. In his ontribution to the dis ussion after Compton's report (p. 360, the longest of his published ontributions in the Solvay volumea ), Bohr sket hes the motivations behind the BKS theory, the Maxwell equations, i.e. an be onsidered to be lassi al, the virtual os illators and the intera tion between the elds and the os illators are non- lassi al in several respe ts. a Bothe and Geiger had been working on their experiments sin e June 1924 (Bothe and Geiger 1924), and provisional results were being debated by the turn of the year. For two diering views on the signi an e of these results for instan e see Einstein to Lorentz, 16 De ember 1924 (the same letter in whi h he wrote to Lorentz about de Broglie's results)46 and the ex hange of letters between Born and Bohr in January 1925 (Bohr 1984, pp. 3026). By April 1925, Bothe and Geiger had lear- ut results against the BKS theory (Bothe and Geiger 1925a,b; see also the letters between Geiger and Bohr in Bohr 1984, pp. 3524). b On the BKS theory and related matters, see also hapter 3 (espe ially se tions 3.3.1 and 3.4.2), hapter 9, Darrigol (1992, hapter 9), the ex ellent introdu tion by Stolzenburg to Part I of Bohr (1984) and Mehra and Re henberg (1982, se tion V.2). a See below for the fate of his ontribution to the general dis ussion.
1.3 S ienti planning and ba kground
15
on lusions to be drawn from the Bothe-Geiger and Compton-Simon experiments and the further development of his views. Lorentz, in his report of the meeting to Einstein had mentioned `SlaterBohr-Kramers and analogous theories'. This may refer to the further developments (independent of the validity of the BKS theory) that led in parti ular to Kramer's (1924) dispersion theory (and from there towards matrix me hani s), or to Slater's original ideas, whi h were roughly along the lines of guiding elds for the photons (even though the photons were dropped from the nal BKS proposal).a Note that Einstein at this time was also thinking about guiding elds (in three dimensions). Pais (1982, pp. 44041) writes that, a
ording to Wigner, Einstein did not publish these ideas be ause they also led to problems with the onservation laws.b Einstein was asked by Lorentz to ontribute a report on `New derivations of Plan k's law and appli ations of statisti s to quanta' (point 6 ),
learly referring to the work by Bose (1924) on Plan k's law, hampioned by Einstein and applied by him to the theory of the ideal gas (Einstein 1924, 1925a,b). The se ond of these papers is also where Einstein famously endorses de Broglie's idea of matter waves. Einstein thought that his work on the subje t was already too well-known, but he a
epted after Lorentz repeated his invitation.47 On 17 June 1927, however, at about the time when Lorentz was sending detailed requests to the speakers, Einstein informed him in the following terms that he would not, after all, present a report: I re all having ommitted myself to you to give a report on quantum statisti s at the Solvay onferen e. After mu h ree tion ba k and forth, I ome to the
onvi tion that I am not ompetent [to give℄ su h a report in a way that really
orresponds to the state of things. The reason is that I have not been able to parti ipate as intensively in the modern development of quantum theory as would be ne essary for this purpose. This is in part be ause I have on the whole too little re eptive talent for fully following the stormy developments, in part also be ause I do not approve of the purely statisti al way of thinking on whi h the new theories are founded .... Up until now, I kept hoping to be able to ontribute something of value in Brussels; I have now given up that hope. I beg you not to be angry with me be ause of that; I did not take this lightly but tried with all my strength .... (Quoted in Pais 1982, pp. 4312)
Einstein's withdrawal may be related to the following ir umstan es. On a Cf. Slater (1924) and Mehra and Re henberg (1982, pp. 5436). See also Pauli's remark during the dis ussion of de Broglie's report (p. 401). b Cf. Einstein's ontribution to the general dis ussion (p. 486) and the dis ussion below in hapter 9.
16
Histori al introdu tion
5 May 1927, during a meeting of the Prussian A ademy of S ien es in Berlin, Einstein had read a paper on the question: `Does S hrödinger's wave me hani s determine the motion of a system ompletely or only in the sense of statisti s?'48 As dis ussed in detail by Belousek (1996), the paper attempts to dene deterministi parti le motions from S hrödinger's wave fun tions, but was also suddenly withdrawn on 21 May.a The plans for the talks were nalised by Lorentz around June 1927. An extra t from his letter to S hrödinger on the subje t reads as follows: [W℄e hope to have the following reports [Referate℄ (I give them in the order in whi h we might dis uss them): 1. From Mr W. L. Bragg on phenomena that still somehow allow a lassi al des ription (reexion of X-rays by rystals, dira tion and total ree tion of X-rays). 2. From Mr Compton on the ee t dis overed by him and what relates to it. 3. From Mr de Broglie on his theory. I am asking him also to take into a
ount the appli ation of his ideas to free ele trons (Elsasser, quantum me hani s of free ele trons; Dymond, Davisson and Germer, s attering of ele trons). 4. From Dr Heisenberg
or
Prof. Born (the hoi e is left to them) on matrix
me hani s, in luding Dira 's theory. 5. Your report [on wave me hani s℄. Maybe another one or two short ommuni ations [Beri hte℄ on spe ial topi s 50 will be added.
This was, indeed, the nal programme of the onferen e, with Born and Heisenberg de iding to ontribute a joint report.a
1.4 Further details of planning In 192627 the s ienti ommittee and the administrative ommission of the Solvay institute were omposed as follows. a The news of Einstein's ommuni ation prompted an ex hange of letters between Heisenberg and Einstein, of whi h Heisenberg's letters, of 19 May and 10 June, survive.49 The se ond of these is parti ularly interesting, be ause Heisenberg presents in some detail his view of theories that in lude parti le traje tories. Both Einstein's hidden-variables proposal and Heisenberg's rea tion will be des ribed in se tion 11.3. a See se tion 3.2. Note that, as we shall see below, while Bohr ontributed signi antly to the general dis ussion and reported the views he had developed in Como (Bohr 1949, p. 216, 1985, pp. 357), he was unable to prepare an edited version of his omments in time and therefore suggested that a translation of his Como le ture, in the version for Naturwissens haften (Bohr 1928), be in luded in the volume instead. This has given rise to a ommon belief that Bohr gave a report on a par with the other reports, and that the general dis ussion at the onferen e was the dis ussion following it. See for instan e Mehra (1975, p. 152), and Mehra and Re henberg (2000, pp. 246 and 249), who appear further to believe that Bohr did not parti ipate in the o ial dis ussion.
1.4 Further details of planning
17
S ienti ommittee: Lorentz (Leiden) as president, Knudsen (Copenhagen) as se retary, W. H. Bragg (until May 1927, London),a Marie Curie (Paris), Einstein (sin e April 1926, Berlin), Charles-Eugène Guye (Geneva),b Langevin (Paris), Ri hardson (London), Edm. van Aubel (Gent). Administrative ommission: Armand Solvay, Jules Bordet (ULB), Mauri e Bourquin (ULB), Émile Henriot (ULB); the administrative se retary sin e 1922, and thus main orrespondent of Lorentz and others, was Charles Lefébure. The se retary of the meeting was Jules-Émile. Vers haelt (Gent), who had a ted as se retary sin e the third Solvay onferen e.52 The rst provisional list of possible parti ipants (in addition to Ehrenfest) appears in Lorentz's letter to Ehrenfest of 29 Mar h 1926: Einstein, Bohr, Kramers, Born, Heisenberg (Jordan surely more mathemati ian), Pauli, Ladenburg (?), Slater, the young Bragg (be ause of the ` orresponden e' to the lassi al theory that his work has often resulted in), J. J. Thomson, another one or two Englishmen (Darwin?
Fowler?), Léon
Brillouin (do not know whether he has worked on this, he has also already been there a number of times),
Louis
de Broglie (light quanta), one or two
who have on erned themselves with dira tion of X-rays (Bergen Davis?, 53 Compton, Debye, Dira (?)).
Lorentz asked for further suggestions and omments, whi h Ehrenfest sent in a letter dated `Leiden 30 Mar h 1926. Late at night': Langevin, Fowler, Dira , J. Fran[ ℄k (already for the experiments he devised by Hanle on the destru tion of resonan e polarisation through Larmor rotation a and for the work he proposed by Hund on the Ramsauer ee t undisturbed passage of slow ele trons through atoms and so on), Fermi (for interesting
ontinuation of the experiments by Hanle), Oseen (possibly a wrong attempt at explanation of needle radiation and as sharpwitted riti ), S hrödinger (was perhaps the rst to give quantum interpretation of the Doppler ee t, thus
lose to Compton ee t), Bothe (for Bothe-Geiger experiment on orrelation of Compton quantum and ele tron, whi h destroys Bohr-Slater theory, altogether a ne brain!) (Bothe should be onsidered perhaps
before S hrödinger),
Darwin, Smekal (is indeed a very deserving onnoisseur of quantum nesses, only he writes so
frightfully
mu h).
Léon Brillouin has published something re ently on matrix physi s, but I 54 have not read it yet.
a W. H. Bragg resigned due to over ommitment and was later repla ed by Cabrera (Madrid).51 b In 1909 the university of Geneva onferred on Einstein his rst honorary degree. A
ording to Pais (1982, p. 152), this was probably due to Guye. Coin identally, Ernest Solvay was honoured at the same time. a For more on the spe ial interest of the Ramsauer ee t, see se tion 3.4.2 below.
18
Histori al introdu tion
At the April meeting (as listed in the report by Vers haelt55 ) it was then de ided to invite: Bohr, Kramers, Ehrenfest, two among Born, Heisenberg and Pauli, Plan k, Fowler, W. L. Bragg, C. T. R. Wilson, L. de Broglie, L. Brillouin, Deslandres, Compton, S hrödinger and Debye. Possible substitutes were listed as: M. de Broglie or Thibaud for Bragg, Dira for Brillouin, Fabry for Deslandres, Kapitza for Wilson, Darwin or Dira for Fowler, Bergen Davis for Compton, and Thirring for S hrödinger.a The members of the s ienti ommitee would all take part ex o io, and invitations would be sent to the professors of physi s at ULB, that is, to Pi
ard, Henriot and De Donder57 (the latter apparently somewhat to Lefébure's hagrin, who, just before the
onferen e started, felt obliged to remind Lorentz that De Donder was `a paradoxi al mind, loud [en ombrant℄ and always ready to seize the word, often with great maladroitness'58 ). Both the number of a tual parti ipants and of observers was to be kept limited,59 partly explaining why it was thought that one should invite only two among Born, Heisenberg and Pauli. The hoi e initially fell on Born and Heisenberg (although Fran k was also onsidered as an alternative).60 Eventually, as noted above, Pauli was also in luded, as was Dira .61 Lorentz was also keen to invite Millikan and possibly Hall , when he heard that Millikan would be in Europe anyway for the Como meeting (Einstein and Ri hardson agreed).62 However, nothing
ame of this plan. When Einstein eventually withdrew as a speaker, he suggested Fermi or Langevin as possible substitutes (Pais 1982, p. 432). For a while it was not lear whether Langevin (who was anyway a member of the s ienti
ommittee) would be able to ome, sin e he was in Argentina over the summer and due to go on to Pasadena from there. Ehrenfest suggested F. Perrin instead, in rather admiring tones. Langevin was needed in Paris in O tober, however, and was able to ome to the onferen e.63 Finally, the week before the onferen e started, Lorentz extended the invitation to Irving Langmuir,64 who would happen to be in Brussels at the time of the onferen e.a Lorentz sent most of the informal invitations around January 1927.65 In May 1927, he sent to Lefébure the list of all the people he had `provisionally invited',66 in luding all the members of the s ienti ommittee and the prospe tive invitees as listed above by Vers haelt (that is, a A few days later, Guye suggested also Auger as a possible substitute for Wilson.56 a To Langmuir we owe a fas inating `home movie' of the onferen e; see the report in the AIP Bulletin of Physi s News, number 724 (2005).
1.4 Further details of planning
19
as yet without Pauli and Dira ). All had already replied and a
epted, ex ept Deslandres (who eventually replied mu h later de lining the invitation67 ). Around early July, Lorentz invited the physi ists from the university,68 and presumably sent a new invitation to W. H. Bragg, who thanked him but de lined.69 Formal letters of onrmation were sent out by Lefébure shortly before the onferen e.70 Around June 1927, Lorentz wrote to the planned speakers inviting them in the name of the s ienti ommittee to ontribute written reports, to rea h him preferably by 1 September. The general guidelines were: to fo us on one's own work, without mathemati al details, but rather so that `the prin iples are highlighted as learly as possible, and the open questions as well as the onne tions [Zusammenhänge℄ and
ontrasts are laried'. The material in the reports did not have to be unpublished, and a bibliography would be wel ome.71 Compton wrote that he would aim to deliver his manus ipt by 20 August, de Broglie easily before the end of August, Bragg, as well as Born and Heisenberg, by 1 September, and S hrödinger presumably only in the se ond half of September.72 (For further details of the orresponden e between some of the authors and Lorentz, see the relevant hapters below.) The written reports were to be sent to all parti ipants in advan e of the onferen e.a De Broglie's, whi h had been written dire tly in Fren h, was sent by Lorentz to the publishers, Gauthier-Villars in Paris, before he left for the Como meeting. They hoped to send 35 proofs to Lorentz by the end of September. In the meantime, Vers haelt and Lorentz's son had the remaining reports mimeographed by the `Holland Typing O e' in Amsterdam, and Vers haelt with the help of a student added in the formulas by hand, managing to mail on time to the parti ipants at least Compton's and Born and Heisenberg's reports, if not all of them.74 Lorentz had further written to all speakers (ex ept Compton) to ask them to bring reprints of their papers.75 Late during planning, a slight problem emerged, namely an unfortunate overlap of the Brussels onferen e with the festivities for the
entenary of Fresnel in Paris, to be o ially opened Thursday 27 O tober. Lorentz informed Lefébure of the lash writing from Naples after the Como meeting: neither the date of the onferen e ould be hanged nor that of the Fresnel elebrations, whi h had been xed by the Fren h President. The problem was ompounded by the fa t that de Broglie had a Mimeographed opies of Bragg's, Born and Heisenberg's and S hrödinger's reports are to be found in the Ri hardson Colle tion, Harry Ransom Humanities Resear h Center, University of Texas at Austin.73
20
Histori al introdu tion
a
epted to give a le ture to the So iété de Physique on the o
asion.a Lorentz suggested the ompromise solution of a general invitation to attend the elebrations. Those who wished to parti ipate ould travel to Paris on 27 O tober, returning to Brussels the next day, when sessions would be resumed in the afternoon. This was the solution that was indeed adopted.77
1.5 The Solvay meeting The fth Solvay onferen e took pla e from 24 to 29 O tober 1927 in Brussels. As on previous o
asions, the parti ipants stayed at the Htel Britannique, where a dinner invitation from Armand Solvay awaited them.78 Other meals were going to be taken at the institute, whi h was housed in the building of the Institute of Physiology in the Par Léopold;
atering for 5055 people had been arranged.79 The parti ipants were guests of the administrative ommission and all travel expenses within Europe were met.80 From the evening of 23 O tober onwards, three seats were reserved in a box at the Théatre de la Monnaie.81 The rst session of the onferen e started at 10:00 on Monday 24 O tober. A tentative re onstru tion of the s hedule of the onferen e is as follows.82 We assume that the talks were given in the order they were des ribed in the plans and printed in the volume, and that the re eption by the university on the Tuesday ontinued throughout the morning. It is lear that the general dis ussion extended over at least two days, from the fa t that Dira in his main ontribution (p. 491) refers expli itly to Bohr's omments of the day before.a • Monday 24 O tober, morning: W. L. Bragg's report, followed by dis ussion. • Monday 24 O tober, afternoon: A. H. Compton's report, followed by dis ussion. a In Lorentz's letter, the date of de Broglie's le ture is mentioned as 28 O tober, but the o ial invitations state that it was Zeeman who le tured then, and de Broglie the next evening, after the end of the Solvay onferen e. A report on de Broglie's le ture, whi h was entitled `Fresnel's ÷uvre and the urrent development of physi s', was published by Guye in the Journal de Genève of 16 and 18 April 1928.76 a In a letter to Vers haelt, Kramers refers to `the general dis ussion of Thursday', but that in fa t was the day of the Fresnel elebrations in Paris. The photograph of Lorentz in luded in the volume, a
ording to the aption, was also taken on that day. Sin e the elebrations opened only at 8:30pm, it is on eivable that there was a rst dis ussion session on Thursday morning. Pelseneer states, however, that sessions were suspended for the whole day.83
1.5 The Solvay meeting
21
• Tuesday 25 O tober, starting 9:00 a.m.: re eption oered by the ULB.
• Tuesday 25 O tober, afternoon: L. de Broglie's report, followed by dis ussion. • Wednesday 26 O tober, morning: M. Born and W. Heisenberg's report, followed by dis ussion. • Wednesday 26 O tober, afternoon: E. S hrödinger's report, followed by dis ussion. • Thursday 27 O tober, all day: travel to Paris and entenary of Fresnel.a • Friday 28 O tober, morning: return to Brussels.
• Friday 28 O tober, afternoon: general dis ussion.
• Saturday 29 O tober, morning: general dis ussion,b followed by lun h with the King and Queen of the Belgians. • Saturday 29 O tober, evening: dinner oered by Armand Solvay.
The languages used were presumably English, German and Fren h. S hrödinger had volunteered to give his talk in English,c while Born had suggested that he and Heisenberg ould provide additional explanations in English (while he thought that neither of them knew Fren h).86 The phrasing used by Born referred to who should `explain orally the ontents of the report', suggesting that the speakers did not present the exa t or full text of the reports as printed. Multipli ity of languages had long been a hara teristi of the Solvay
onferen es. A well-known letter by Ehrenfest87 tells us of `[p℄oor Lorentz as interpreter between the British and the Fren h who were absolutely unable to understand ea h other. Summarising Bohr. And Bohr responding with polite despair' (as quoted in Bohr 1985, p. 38).d On the last day of the onferen e, Ehrenfest went to the bla kboard and evoked the image of the tower of Babel (presumably in a more a Most of the parti ipants at the Solvay onferen e, with the ex eption of Knudsen, Dira , Ehrenfest, Plan k, S hrödinger, Henriot, Pi
ard and Herzen, travelled to Paris to attend the inauguration of the elebrations, in the grand amphithéatre of the Sorbonne.84 b The nal session of the onferen e also in luded a homage to Ernest Solvay's widow.85
Note that S hrödinger was uent in English from hildhood, his mother and aunts being half-English (Moore 1989, hapter 1). d Both W. H. Bragg and Plan k deplored in letters to Lorentz that they were very poor linguists. Indeed, in a letter explaining in more detail why he would not parti ipate in the onferen e, W. H. Bragg wrote: `I nd it impossible to follow the dis ussions even though you so often try to make it easy for us', and Plan k was in doubt about oming, parti ularly be ause of the language di ulties.88
22
Histori al introdu tion
metaphori al sense than the mere multipli ity of spoken languages), writing: And they said one to another: .... Go to, let us build us .... a tower, whose top may rea h unto heaven; and
let us make us a name ....
And the Lord said: ....
Go to, let us go down, and there onfound their language, that they may not understand one another's spee h. (Genesis 11: 37, reported by Pelseneer, his a emphasis )
Informal dis ussions at the onferen e must have been plentiful, but information about them has to be gathered from other sour es. Famously, Einstein and Bohr engaged in dis ussions that were des ribed in detail in later re olle tions by Bohr (1949), and vividly re alled by Ehrenfest within days of the onferen e in the well-known letter quoted above (see also hapter 12). Little known, if at all, is another referen e by Ehrenfest to the dis ussions between Bohr and Einstein, whi h appears to relate more dire tly to the issues raised by Einstein in the general dis ussion: Bohr had given a very pretty argument in a onversation with Einstein, that one ould not hope ever to master many-parti le problems with threedimensional S hrödinger ma hinery. (more or less!!!!!!):
He said something like the following
a wave pa ket an never simultaneously determine EX-
ACTLY the position and the velo ity of a parti le. Thus if one has for instan e TWO parti les, then they annot possibly be represented in
three-dimensional
spa e su h that one an simultaneously represent exa tly their kineti energy and the potential energy OF THEIR INTERACTION. Therefore......... (What omes after this therefore I already annot reprodu e properly.) In the multidimensional representation instead the potential energy of the intera tion appears totally sharp in the relevant oe ients of the wave equation and one 90 does [?℄ not get to see the kineti energy at all.
1.6 The editing of the pro eedings The editing of the pro eedings of the fth Solvay onferen e was largely
arried out by Vers haelt, who reported regularly to Lorentz and to Lefébure. During the last months of 1927 Lorentz was busy writing up the le ture he had given at the Como meeting in September.91 He then died suddenly on 4 February, before the editing work was omplete. The translation of the reports into Fren h was arried out after the
onferen e, ex ept for de Broglie's report whi h, as mentioned, was a This may have been Ehrenfest's own emphasis. Note that, if not ne essarily present at the sessions, Pelseneer had some onne tion with the onferen e, having taken Lorentz's photograph reprodu ed in the pro eedings.89
1.6 The editing of the pro eedings
23
written dire tly in Fren h. From Vers haelt's letters we gather that by 6 January 1928 all the reports had been translated, Bragg's and Compton's had been sent to the publishers, and Born and Heisenberg's and S hrödinger's were to be sent on that day or the next. Several proofs were ba k by the beginning of Mar h.92 Lorentz had envisaged preparing with Vers haelt an edited version of the dis ussions from notes taken during the onferen e, and sending the edited version to the speakers at proof stage.a In fa t, stenographed notes appear to have been taken, typed up and sent to the speakers, who for the most part used them to prepare drafts of their ontributions. From these, Vers haelt then edited the nal version, with some help from Kramers (who spe i ally ompleted two of Lorentz's
ontributions).93 A opy of the galley proofs of the general dis ussion, dated 1 June 1928, survives in the Bohr ar hives in Copenhagen,94 and in ludes some ontributions that appear to have been still largely unedited at that time.b By January, the editing of the dis ussions was pro eeding well, and at the beginning of Mar h it was almost ompleted. Some ontributions, however, were still missing, most notably Bohr's. The notes sent by Vers haelt had many gaps; Bohr wanted Kramers's advi e and help with the dis ussion ontributions, and travelled to Utre ht for this purpose at the beginning of Mar h.95 At the end of Mar h, Kramers sent Vers haelt the edited version of Bohr's ontributions to the dis ussion after Compton's report (pp. 360 and 370) and after Born and Heisenberg's report (p. 444), remarking that these were all of Bohr's ontributions to the dis ussions during the rst three days of the
onferen e.c In ontrast, material on Bohr's ontributions to the general dis ussion survives only in the form of notes in the Bohr ar hives.d (Some notes by Ri hardson also relate to Bohr's ontributions.97 ) A translation of version of the Como le ture for Naturwissens haften (Bohr 1928) was in luded instead, reprinted on a par with the other reports, and a
ompanied by the following footnote (p. 215 of the published pro eedings): a A
ording to D. Devriese, urator of the IIPCS ar hives, the original notes have not survived. b We have reprodu ed some of this material in the endnotes to the general dis ussion.
Note that Bohr also asked some brief questions after S hrödinger's report (p. 469). Kramers further writes that Bohr suggested to `omit the whole nal Born-Heisenberg dis ussion (Nr. 1823) and equally Fowler's remark 9'. Again, thanks to Mark van Atten for help with this letter.96 d This material is not mi rolmed in AHQP. See also Bohr (1985, pp. 357, 100 and 4789).
24
Histori al introdu tion
This arti le, whi h is the translation of a note published very re ently in
Naturwissens haften,
vol. 16, 1928, p. 245, has been added at the author's
request to repla e the exposition of his ideas that he gave in the ourse of the following general dis ussion. It is essentially the reprodu tion of a talk on the
urrent state of quantum theory that was given in Como on 16 September 1927, on the o
asion of the jubilee festivities in honour of Volta.
The last remaining material was sent to Gauthier-Villars sometime in September 1928, and the volume was nally published in early De ember of that year.98
1.7 Con lusion The fth Solvay onferen e was by any standards an important and memorable event. On this point all parti ipants presumably agreed, as shown by numerous letters, su h as Ehrenfest's letter quoted above (reprodu ed in Bohr 1985), Heisenberg's letter to Lefébure at the head of this hapter, or various other letters of thanks addressed to the organisers after the onferen e:99 I would like to take this opportunity of thanking you for your kind hospitality, and telling you how mu h I enjoyed this parti ular Conferen e. I think it has been the most memorable one whi h I have attended for the subje t whi h was dis ussed was of su h vital interest and I learned so mu h. (W. L. Bragg to Armand Solvay, 3 November 1927) It was the most stimulating s ienti meeting I have ever taken part in. (Max Born to Charles Lefébure, 8 November 1927)
Per eptions of the signi an e of the onferen e diered from ea h other, however. In the o ial history, the fth Solvay onferen e went down (perhaps together with the Como meeting) as the o
asion on whi h the interpretational issues were nally laried. This was presumably a genuine sentiment on the part of Bohr, Heisenberg and the other physi ists of the Copenhagen-Göttingen s hool. We nd it expli itly as early as 1929: In relating the development of the quantum theory, one must in parti ular not forget the dis ussions at the Solvay onferen e in Brussels in 1927, haired by Lorentz.
Through the possibility of ex hange [Ausspra he℄ between the
representatives of dierent lines of resear h, this onferen e has ontributed extraordinarily to the lari ation of the physi al foundations of the quantum theory; it forms so to speak the outward ompletion of the quantum theory .... . (Heisenberg 1929, p. 495)
1.7 Con lusion
25
On the other hand, the onferen e was also des ribed (by Langevin) as the one where `the onfusion of ideas rea hed its peak'.100 From a distan e of almost 80 years, the beginnings of a more dispassionate evaluation should be possible. In the following hapters, we shall revisit the fth Solvay onferen e, fo ussing in parti ular on the ba kground and ontributions relating to the three main `lines of resear h' into quantum theory represented there: de Broglie's pilot-wave theory, Born and Heisenberg's quantum me hani s and S hrödinger's wave me hani s.
26
Notes to pp. 39
Ar hival notes 1 Handwritten remark (by Ehrenfest) in the margin of Lorentz to Ehrenfest, 29 Mar h 1926, AHQP-EHR-23 (in Dut h). 2 Heisenberg to Lefébure, 19 De ember [1927℄, IIPCS 2685 (in German). 3 AHQP-LTZ-12, talk X 23, `Ernest Solvay', dated 28 September 1914 (in English). Cf. also the Fren h version of the same, X 10. (The two pages of the latter are in separate pla es on the mi rolm.)
Historique des Instituts Internationaux de Physique et de Chimie Solvay depuis leur fondation jusqu'à la deuxième guerre mondiale,
4 Pelseneer, J.,
[1962℄, 103 pp., AHQP-58, se tion 1 (hereafter referred to simply as `Pelseneer'). 5 Plan k to Nernst, 11 June 1910, Pelseneer, p. 7 (in German). 6 Lorentz to Solvay, 4 January 1912, Pelseneer, pp. 2026 (in Fren h). See also the reply, Solvay to Lorentz, 10 January 1912, AHQP-LTZ-12 (in Fren h). 7 Lorentz to Solvay, 6 Mar h 1912, Pelseneer, p. 27 (in Fren h). 8 Héger to Lorentz, 16 February 1912, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in Fren h). 9 Einstein to Lorentz, 16 August 1923, AHQP-LTZ-7 (in German). 10 Van Aubel to Lorentz, 16 April, 16 May and 19 July 1923, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in Fren h). 11 Lorentz to Solvay, 10 January 1919, Pelseneer, p. 37 (in Fren h). 12 Lorentz to Einstein, 14 Mar h 1926, AHQP-86 (in German). 13 Lefébure to Lorentz, 12 February 1926, AHQP-LTZ-12 (in Fren h). 14 Cf. Lefébure to Lorentz, 12 February 1926, AHQP-LTZ-12 (in Fren h). 15 Letter by Lorentz, 7 January 1919, Pelseneer, pp. 356 (in Fren h), two letters from Plan k to Lorentz, 1915, AHQP-LTZ-12 (in German), Plan k to Lorentz, Mar h 1916, Pelseneer, pp. 345 (in German), and Plan k to Lorentz, 5 De ember 1923, AHQP-LTZ-9 (in German). 16 From Lefébure [possibly a opy for Lorentz℄, 1 April 1926, AHQP-LTZ-12 (in Fren h). Obituary of Tassel,
L'Éventail,
15 O tober 1922,
AHQP-LTZ-13 (in Fren h). 17 Cf. Lefébure to Lorentz, 6 April 1926, AHQP-LTZ-12 (in Fren h). 18 Lorentz to Einstein, 6 April 1926, AHQP-86 (in German). 19 Einstein to Lorentz, 14 April 1926 and 1 May 1927, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in German). 20 Lorentz to Einstein, 28 April 1926, AHQP-86 (in German). 21 Compare the invitation of Lorentz to Bohr, 7 June 1926, AHQP-BSC-13 (in English), and the replies of Bohr to Lorentz, 24 June 1926, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in English), Plan k to Lorentz, 13 June 1926, AHQP-LTZ-8 (in German), Born to Lorentz, 19 June 1926, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in German), and Heisenberg to Lorentz, 4 July 1926, AHQP-LTZ-12 (in German). 22 Van Aubel to Lefébure, 6 O tober 1927, IIPCS 2545 (in Fren h), with Lefébure's handwritten omment. 23 Lefébure to Lorentz, 14 O tober 1927, IIPCS 2534, and 15 O tober 1927, IIPCS 2536, telegramme Lorentz to Lefébure, 15 O tober 1927, IIPCS 2535, and Lefébure to the King, 19 O tober 1927, IIPCS 2622 (all in Fren h). 24 Lorentz to Solvay, 10 January 1919, Pelseneer, p. 37 (in Fren h). 25 There is a large amount of relevant orresponden e in AHQP-LTZ.
Notes to pp. 918
27
26 Lorentz to Ehrenfest, 29 Mar h 1926, AHQP-EHR-23 (in Dut h), with Ehrenfest's handwritten omments. 27 Ehrenfest to Lorentz, 30 Mar h 1926, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in German). 28 Lorentz to Bohr, 7 June 1926, AHQP-BSC-13, se tion 3 (in English), Lorentz to S hrödinger, 21 January 1927, AHQP-41, se tion 9 (in German). 29 Lorentz to Einstein, 6 April 1926, AHQP-86 (in German and Fren h). 30 Vers haelt to Lefébure, 8 April 1926, IIPCS 2573 (in Fren h). 31 Einstein to Lorentz, 12 April 1926, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in German). 32 See for instan e the atalogue of Lorentz's manus ripts in AHQP-LTZ-11. 33 See also Lorentz to S hrödinger, 21 January and 17 June 1927, AHQP-41, se tion 9 (in German). 34 Einstein to Lorentz, 1 May 1926, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in German). 35 Einstein to Lorentz, 22 June 1926, AHQP-LTZ-8 (in German). 36 Einstein to Lorentz, 16 February 1927, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in German). 37 En losed with Lorentz to Ehrenfest, 3 June [1927, erroneously amended to 1925℄, AHQP-EHR-23 (in Dut h). 38 Lorentz to Dira , 9 June 1927, AHQP-LTZ-8 (in English). 39 Cf. Born to Lorentz, 23 June 1927, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in German). 40 Lorentz to Lefébure, 27 August 1927, IIPCS 2532A/B (in Fren h). [There appears to be a further item also numbered 2532.℄ 41 Dira to Lorentz, 13 September 1927, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in English). 42 Cf. de Broglie to Lorentz, 22 June 1927, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in Fren h), and Ehrenfest to Lorentz, 14 June 1927, AHQP-EHR-23 (in Dut h and German). 43 W. L. Bragg to Lorentz, 7 February 1927, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in English). 44 Cf. also W. L. Bragg to Lorentz, 27 June 1927, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in English). 45 Lorentz to S hrödinger, 17 June 1927, AHQP-41, se tion 9 (in German). 46 Einstein to Lorentz, 16 De ember 1924, AHQP-LTZ-7 (in German). 47 Einstein to Lorentz, 12 April 1926, AHQP-LTZ-11, Lorentz to Einstein, 28 April 1926, AHQP-86, and Einstein to Lorentz, 1 May 1926, AHQP-LTZ-11 (all in German). 48 `Bestimmt S hrödingers Wellenme hanik die Bewegung eines Systems vollständig oder nur im Sinne der Statistik?', AEA 2-100.00 (in German), available on-line at http://www.alberteinstein.info/db/ViewDetails.do?Do umentID=34338 . 49 Heisenberg to Einstein, 19 May 1927, AEA 12-173.00, and 10 June 1927, AEA 12-174.00 (both in German). 50 Lorentz to S hrödinger, 17 June 1927, AHQP-41, se tion 9 (in German). 51 W. H. Bragg to Lorentz, 11 May 1927, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in English). 52 Tassel to Vers haelt, 24 February 1921, AHQP-LTZ-13 (in Fren h). 53 Lorentz to Ehrenfest, 29 Mar h 1926, AHQP-EHR-23 (in Dut h). 54 Ehrenfest to Lorentz, 30 Mar h 1926, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in German). 55 Vers haelt to Lefébure, 8 April 1926, IIPCS 2573 (in Fren h). 56 Guye to Lorentz, 14 April 1926, AHQP-LTZ-8 (in Fren h). 57 Cf. for instan e Lorentz to S hrödinger, 21 January 1927, AHQP-41, se tion 9 (in German). 58 Lefébure to Lorentz, 22 O tober 1927, AHQP-LTZ-12 (in Fren h). 59 Lorentz to Einstein, 28 April 1926, AHQP-86 (in German), Lorentz to Lefébure, 9 O tober 1927, IIPCS, 2530A/B (in Fren h).
28
Notes to pp. 1819
60 Lorentz to Einstein, 28 April 1926, AHQP-86 (in German), Einstein to Lorentz, 1 May 1926, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in German). 61 For the latter, f. also Brillouin to Lorentz, 20 August 1927, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in Fren h). 62 Lorentz to Einstein, 30 January 1927, AHQP-86 (in German), Einstein to Lorentz, 16 February 1927, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in German), Ri hardson to Lorentz, 19 February 1927, AHQP-LTZ-12 (in English). 63 Brillouin to Lorentz, 20 August 1927, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in Fren h), Ehrenfest to Lorentz 18 August 1927, AHQP-EHR-23 (in German). 64 Telegramme Lorentz to Lefébure, 19 O tober 1927, IIPCS 2541 (in Fren h), with Lefébure's note: `Oui'. 65 Lorentz to Brillouin, 15 De ember 1926, AHQP-LTZ-12 (in Fren h), Lorentz to Ehrenfest, 18 January 1927, AHQP-EHR-23 (in Dut h), Lorentz to S hrödinger, 21 January 1927, AHQP-41, se tion 9 (in German); ompare various other replies to Lorentz's invitation, in AHQP-LTZ-11, AHQP-LTZ-12 and AHQP-LTZ-13: Brillouin, 8 January 1927 (in Fren h), de Broglie, 8 January 1927 (in Fren h), W. L. Bragg, 7 February 1927 (in English), Wilson, 11 February 1927 (in English), Kramers, 14 February 1927 (in German), Debye, 24 February 1927 (in Dut h), Compton, 3 April 1927 (in English) [late be ause he had been away for two months `in the Orient'℄. 66 Lorentz to Lefébure, 21 May 1927, IIPCS 2521A (in Fren h). 67 Deslandres to Lorentz, 19 July 1927, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in Fren h). 68 See the letters of a
eptan e to Lorentz: De Donder, 8 July 1927, AHQP-LTZ-11, Henriot, 10 July 1927, AHQP-LTZ-12, Pi
ard, 2 O tober 1927, AHQP-LTZ-12 (all in Fren h). 69 W. H. Bragg to Lorentz, 12 and 17 July 1927, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in English). 70 Copies in AHQP-LTZ-12 and IIPCS 2543. Various replies: IIPCS 254451, 25536, 2558, 25603. 71 Cf. Lorentz to S hrödinger, 17 June 1927, AHQP-41, se tion 9 (in German). 72 Compare the answers by Bragg, 27 June 1927, and by Compton, 7 July 1927, both AHQP-LTZ-11 (in English), and the detailed ones by de Broglie, 27 June 1927, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in Fren h) and by Born, 23 June 1927, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in German); also S hrödinger to Lorentz, 23 June 1927, AHQP-LTZ-13 (original with S hrödinger's orre tions), and AHQP-41 se tion 9 ( arbon opy) (in German). 73 Mi rolmed in AHQP-RDN, do uments M-0059 (Bragg, atalogued as `unidentied author'), M-0309 (Born and Heisenberg, with seven pages of notes by Ri hardson) and M-1354 (S hrödinger). 74 See in parti ular the already quoted Lorentz to Lefébure, 27 August 1927, IIPCS 2532A/B (in Fren h), as well as Lorentz to Lefébure, 23 September 1927, IIPCS 2523A/B, and 4 O tober 1927, IIPCS 2528 (both in Fren h), Gauthiers-Villars to Lefébure, 16 September 1927, IIPCS 2755 (in Fren h), Vers haelt to Lorentz, 6 O tober 1927, AHQP-LTZ-13 (in Dut h), de Broglie to Lorentz, 29 August 1927, AHQP-LTZ-8, and 11 O tober 1927, AHQP-LTZ-11 (both in Fren h), and Vers haelt to Lefébure, 15 O tober 1927, IIPCS 2756 (in Fren h). 75 Lorentz to Ehrenfest, 13 O tober 1927, AHQP-EHR-23 (in Dut h). See also Born to Lorentz, 11 O tober 1927 AHQP-LTZ-11 (in German), de
Notes to pp. 1924
29
Broglie to Lorentz, 11 O tober 1927, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in Fren h), Plan k to Lefébure, 17 O tober 1927, IIPCS 2558, and Ri hardson to Lefébure, IIPCS 2561. 76 `Une rise dans la physique moderne I & II', IIPCS 275051 (in Fren h). 77 Lorentz to Lefébure, 29 September 1927, IIPCS 2523A/B, Brillouin to Lorentz, 11 O tober 1927, AHQP-LTZ-11, Fondation Solvay to Lefébure, IIPCS 2582. Invitation: IIPCS 2615 and 2619, AHPQ-LTZ-8. Replies: IIPCS 2617 and 2618. (All do uments in Fren h.) 78 IIPCS 2530A/B, 2537. 79 IIPCS 2533, 2586A/B/C/D/E (the proposed menus from the Taverne Royale), 2587A/B. 80 Lorentz to S hrödinger, 21 January 1927, AHQP-41, se tion 9 (in German). 81 IIPCS 2340. 82 For the time and pla e of the rst session, see IIPCS 2523A/B. For the re eption at ULB, see IIPCS 2540 and 2629. There is a seating plan for the lun h with the royal ouple, IIPCS 2627. For the dinner with Armand Solvay, see IIPCS 2533, 2624 and 2625. See also Pelseneer, pp. 4950. 83 See Kramers to Vers haelt, 23 Mar h 1928, AHQP-28 (in Dut h), and Pelseneer, p. 50. 84 IIPCS 2621. 85 See AHQP-LTZ-12 (draft), and presumably IIPCS 2667. 86 S hrödinger to Lorentz, 23 June 1927, AHQP-LTZ-13 and AHQP-41, se tion 9 (in German), Lorentz to S hrödinger, 8 July 1927, AHPQ-41, se tion 9 (in German), Born to Lorentz, 23 June 1927, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in German). 87 Ehrenfest to Goudsmit, Uhlenbe k and Dieke, 3 November 1927, AHQP-61 (in German). 88 W. H. Bragg to Lorentz, 17 July [1927℄, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in English), Plan k to Lorentz, 2 February 1927, AHQP-LTZ-8 (in German). 89 See Pelseneer, pp. 5051. 90 Ehrenfest to Kramers, 6 November 1927, AHQP-9, se tion 10 (in German). The words `bekommt man' [?℄ are very faint. 91 Lorentz to Lefébure, 30 De ember 1927, IIPCS 2670A/B (in Fren h). 92 Vers haelt to Lefébure, 6 January 1928, IIPCS 2609, 2 Mar h 1928, IIPCS 2610 (both in Fren h). 93 Lefébure to Lorentz, [after 27 August 1927℄, IIPCS 2524 (in Fren h), Bohr to Kramers, 17 February 1928, AHQP-BSC-13 (in Danish), Brillouin to Lorentz, 31 De ember 1927, AHQP-LTZ-8 (in Fren h), and Kramers to Vers haelt, 28 Mar h 1928, AHQP-28, se tion 4 (in Dut h). 94 Mi rolmed in AHQP-BMSS-11, se tion 5. 95 Bohr to Kramers, 17 and 27 February 1928, AHQP-BSC-13 (both in Danish). 96 Kramers to Vers haelt, 28 Mar h 1928, AHQP-28, se tion 4 (in Dut h). 97 In luded with the opy of Born and Heisenberg's report in AHQP-RDN, do ument M-0309. 98 Gauthier-Villars to Vers haelt, 6 De ember 1928, IIPCS 2762 (in Fren h), and Vers haelt to Lefébure, 11 [De ember℄ 1928, IIPCS 2761 (in Fren h). 99 IIPCS 2671 (in English), IIPCS 2672 (in German). 100 Quoted in Pelseneer, p. 50.
2 De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
2.1 Ba kground At a time when no single known fa t supported this theory, Louis de Broglie asserted that a stream of ele trons whi h passed through a very small hole in an opaque s reen must exhibit the same phenomena as a light ray under the same onditions. Prof. C. W. Oseen, Chairman of the Nobel Committee for Physi s, presentation spee h, 12 De ember 1929 (Oseen 1999)
In September 1923, Prin e Louis de Brogliea made one of the most astonishing predi tions in the history of theoreti al physi s: that material bodies would exhibit the wave-like phenomena of dira tion and interferen e upon passing through su iently narrow slits. Like Einstein's predi tion of the dee tion of light by the sun, whi h was based on a reinterpretation of gravitational for e in terms of geometry, de Broglie's predi tion of the dee tion of ele tron paths by narrow slits was made on the basis of a fundamental reappraisal of the nature of for es and of dynami s. De Broglie had proposed that Newton's rst law of motion be abandoned, and repla ed by a new postulate, a
ording to whi h a freely moving body follows a traje tory that is orthogonal to the surfa es of equal phase of an asso iated guiding wave. The resulting `de Broglian dynami s' or pilot-wave theory as de Broglie later alled it was a new approa h to the theory of motion, as radi al as Einstein's interpretation a The de Broglies had ome to Fran e from Italy in the seventeenth entury, the original name `Broglia' eventually being hanged to de Broglie. On his father's side, de Broglie's an estors in luded dukes, prin es, ambassadors, and marshals of Fran e. Nye (1997) onsiders the oni t between de Broglie's pursuit of s ien e and the expe tations of his aristo rati family. For a biography of de Broglie, see Lo hak (1992).
30
2.1 Ba kground
31
of the traje tories of falling bodies as geodesi s of a urved spa etime, and as far-rea hing in its impli ations. In 1929 de Broglie re eived the Nobel Prize, `for his dis overy of the wave nature of ele trons'. Strangely enough, however, even though de Broglie's predi tion was
onrmed experimentally a few years later, for most of the twentieth
entury single-parti le dira tion and interferen e were routinely ited as eviden e against de Broglie's ideas: even today, some textbooks on quantum me hani s assert that su h interferen e demonstrates that parti le traje tories annot exist in the quantum domain (see se tion 6.1). It is as if the dee tion of light by the sun had ome to be widely regarded as eviden e against Einstein's general theory of relativity. This remarkable misunderstanding illustrates the extent to whi h de Broglie's work in the 1920s has been underestimated, misrepresented, and indeed largely ignored, not only by physi ists but also by historians. De Broglie's PhD thesis of 1924 is of ourse re ognised as a landmark in the history of quantum theory. But what is usually remembered about that thesis is the proposed extension of Einstein's wave-parti le duality from light to matter, with the formulas E = hν and p = h/λ (relating energy and momentum to frequen y and wavelength) being applied to ele trons or `matter waves'. Usually, little attention is paid to the fa t that a entral theme of de Broglie's thesis was the onstru tion of a new form of dynami s, in whi h lassi al (Newtonian or Einsteinian) laws are abandoned, and repla ed by new laws a
ording to whi h parti le velo ities are determined by guiding waves, in a spe i manner that unies the variational prin iples of Maupertuis and Fermat. Nor, indeed, have historians paid mu h attention to de Broglie's later and more
omplete form of pilot-wave dynami s, whi h he arrived at in a paper published in May 1927 in Journal de Physique, and whi h he then presented in O tober 1927 at the fth Solvay onferen e. Unlike the other main ontributors to quantum theory, de Broglie worked in relative isolation, having little onta t with the prin ipal resear h entres in Berlin, Copenhagen, Göttingen, Cambridge and Muni h. While Bohr, Heisenberg, Born, S hrödinger, Pauli and others visited ea h other frequently and orresponded regularly, de Broglie worked essentially alone in Paris.a In Fran e at the time, while pure a In his typed `Replies to Mr Kuhn's questions' in the Ar hive for the History of Quantum Physi s,1 de Broglie writes (p. 7): `Between 1919 and 1928, I worked very mu h in isolation ' (emphasis in the original). Regarding his Ph.D. thesis de Broglie re alled (p. 9): `I worked very mu h alone and almost without any ex hange of ideas'.
32
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
mathemati s was well represented, there was very little a tivity in theoreti al physi s. In addition, after the rst world war, s ienti relations with Germany and Austria were interrupted.a All this seems to have suited de Broglie's rather solitary temperament. De Broglie's isolation, and the fa t that Fran e was outside the mainstream of theoreti al physi s, may a
ount in part for why so mu h of de Broglie's work went relatively unnoti ed at the time, and has remained largely ignored even to the present day. For some seventy years, the physi s ommunity tended to believe either that `hidden-variables' theories like de Broglie's were impossible, or that su h theories had been disproven experimentally. The situation
hanged onsiderably in the 1990s, with the publi ation of textbooks presenting quantum me hani s in the pilot-wave formulation (Bohm and Hiley 1993; Holland 1993). Pilot-wave theory as originated by de Broglie in 1927, and elaborated by Bohm 25 years later (Bohm 1952a,b) is now a
epted as an alternative (if little used) formulation of quantum theory. Fo ussing for simpli ity on the nonrelativisti quantum theory of a system of N (spinless) parti les with 3-ve tor positions xi (i = 1, 2, ..., N ), it is now generally agreed that, with appropriate initial onditions, quantum physi s may be a
ounted for by the deterministi dynami s dened by two dierential equations, the S hrödinger equation N
i~
∂Ψ X ~2 2 − ∇ Ψ+VΨ = ∂t 2mi i i=1
(1)
for a `pilot wave' Ψ(x1 , x2 , ..., xN , t) in onguration spa e, and the de Broglie guidan e equation mi
dxi = ∇i S dt
(2)
for parti le traje tories xi (t), where the phase S(x1 , x2 , ..., xN , t) is lo ally dened by S = ~ Im ln Ψ (so that Ψ = |Ψ| e(i/~)S ). This, as we shall see, is how de Broglie presented his dynami s in 1927. Bohm's presentation of 1952 was somewhat dierent. If one takes the time derivative of (2), then using (1) one obtains Newton's law of motion for a
eleration mi x ¨i = −∇i (V + Q) ,
(3)
a For more details on de Broglie's situation in Fran e at the time, see Mehra and Re henberg (1982a, pp. 57884).
2.1 Ba kground
33
where Q≡−
X ℏ2 ∇2 |Ψ| i 2m |Ψ| i i
(4)
is the `quantum potential'. Bohm regarded (3) as the law of motion, with (2) added as a onstraint on the initial momenta, a onstraint that Bohm thought ould be relaxed (see se tion 11.1). For de Broglie, in ontrast, the law of motion (2) for velo ity had a fundamental status, and for him represented the uni ation of the prin iples of Maupertuis and Fermat. One should then distinguish between de Broglie's rst-order (velo itybased) dynami s of 1927, and Bohm's se ond-order (a
eleration-based) dynami s of 1952. In this hapter, we shall be on erned with the histori al origins of de Broglie's 1927 dynami s dened by (1) and (2). Some authors have referred to this dynami s as `Bohmian me hani s'. Su h terminology is misleading: it disregards de Broglie's priority, and misses de Broglie's physi al motivations for re asting dynami s in terms of velo ity; it also misrepresents Bohm's 1952 formulation, whi h was based on (1) and (3). These and other histori al mis on eptions on erning de Broglie-Bohm theory will be addressed in se tion 11.1. The two equations (1), (2) dene a deterministi (de Broglian or pilotwave) dynami s for a single multiparti le system: given an initial wave fun tion Ψ(x1 , x2 , ..., xN , 0) at t = 0, (1) determines Ψ(x1 , x2 , ..., xN , t) at all times t; and given an initial onguration (x1 (0), x2 (0), ..., xN (0)), (2) then determines the traje tory (x1 (t), x2 (t), ..., xN (t)). For an ensemble of systems with the same initial wave fun tion Ψ(x1 , x2 , ..., xN , 0), and with initial ongurations (x1 (0), x2 (0), ..., xN (0)) distributed a
ording to the Born rule 2
P (x1 , x2 , ..., xN , 0) = |Ψ(x1 , x2 , ..., xN , 0)| ,
(5)
the statisti al distribution of out omes of quantum measurements will agree with the predi tions of standard quantum theory. This is shown by treating the measuring apparatus, together with the system being measured, as a single multiparti le system obeying de Broglian dynami s, so that (x1 , x2 , ..., xN ) denes the `pointer position' of the apparatus as well as the onguration of the measured system. Given the initial
ondition (5) for any multiparti le system, the statisti al distribution of parti le positions at later times will also agree with the Born rule 2 P = |Ψ| . Thus, the statisti al distribution of pointer positions in any experiment will agree with the predi tions of quantum theory, yielding
34
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
the orre t statisti al distribution of out omes for standard quantum measurements. In his 1927 Solvay report, de Broglie gave some simple appli ations of pilot-wave theory, with the assumed initial ondition (5). He applied the theory to single-photon interferen e, to atomi transitions, and to the s attering (or dira tion) of ele trons by a rystal latti e. But a detailed demonstration of equivalen e to quantum theory, and in parti ular a pilot-wave a
ount of the general quantum theory of measurement, was not provided until the work of Bohm in 1952. How did de Broglie ome to propose this theory in 1927? In this
hapter, we tra e de Broglie's work in this dire tion, from his early work leading to his do toral thesis of 1924 (de Broglie 1924e, 1925), to his ru ial paper of 1927 published in Journal de Physique (de Broglie 1927b), and ulminating in his presentation of pilot-wave theory at the fth Solvay onferen e. We examine in detail how de Broglie arrived at this new form of parti le dynami s, and what his attitude towards it was. Later, in hapter 10, we shall onsider some of the dis ussions of de Broglie's theory that took pla e at the onferen e, in parti ular the famous (and widely misunderstood) lash between de Broglie and Pauli. De Broglie's dynami s has the striking feature that ele trons and photons are regarded as both parti les and waves. Like many s ienti ideas, this mingling of parti le-like and wave-like aspe ts had pre ursors. In Newton's Opti ks (rst published in 1704), both wave-like and parti lelike properties are attributed to light. Newton's so- alled ` orpus ular' theory was formulated on the basis of extensive and detailed experiments ( arried out by Grimaldi, Hooke, and Newton himself) involving what we would now all interferen e and dira tion. A
ording to Newton, light orpus les or light `Rays' as he alled thema generate `Waves of Vibrations' in an `Aethereal Medium', mu h as a stone thrown into water generates water waves (Newton 1730; reprint, pp. 3479). In addition, Newton supposed that the waves in turn ae t the motion of the orpus les, whi h `may be alternately a
elerated and retarded by the Vibrations' (p. 348). In parti ular, Newton thought that the ee t of the medium on the motion of the orpus les was responsible for the phenomena of interferen e and dira tion. He writes, for example (p. 350): And doth not the gradual ondensation of this Medium extend to some dis-
a The opening denition of the Opti ks denes `Rays' of light as `its least Parts'.
2.1 Ba kground
35
tan e from the Bodies, and thereby ause the Inexions of the Rays of Light, whi h pass by the edges of dense Bodies, at some distan e from the Bodies?
Newton understood that, for dira tion to o
ur, the motion of the light
orpus les would have to be ae ted at a distan e by the dira ting body `Do not Bodies a t upon Light at a distan e, and by their a tion bend its Rays .... ?' (p. 339) and his proposed me hanism involved waves in an inhomogeneous ether. Further, a
ording to Newton, to a
ount for the oloured fringes that had been observed by Grimaldi in the dira tion of white light by opaque bodies, the orpus les would have to exe ute an os illatory motion `like that of an Eel' (p. 339): Are not the Rays of Light in passing by the edges and sides of Bodies, bent several times ba kwards and forwards, with a motion like that of an Eel? And do not the three Fringes of olour'd Light above-mention'd arise from three su h bendings?
For Newton, of ourse, su h non-re tilinear motion ould be aused only by a for e emanating from the dira ting body. It is interesting to note that, in the general dis ussion at the fth Solvay onferen e (p. 510), de Broglie ommented on this very point, with referen e to the `emission' (or orpus ular) theory, and pointed out that if pilot-wave dynami s were written in terms of a
eleration (as done later by Bohm) then just su h for es appeared: In the orpus ular on eption of light, the existen e of dira tion phenomena o
uring at the edge of a s reen requires us to assume that, in this ase, the traje tory of the photons is urved. The supporters of the emission theory said that the edge of the s reen exerts a for e on the orpus le. Now, if in the new me hani s as I develop it, one writes the Lagrange equations for the photon, one sees appear on the right-hand side of these equations a term .... [that℄ .... represents a sort of for e of a new kind, whi h exists only .... where there is interferen e. It is this for e that will urve the traje tory of the photon when its wave
ψ
is dira ted by the edge of a s reen.
The striking similarity between Newton's qualitative ideas and pilotwave theory has also been noted by Berry, who remarks that during interferen e or dira tion the de Broglie-Bohm traje tories indeed `wriggle like an eel' (Berry 1997, p. 42), in some sense vindi ating Newton. A mathemati al pre ursor to de Broglian dynami s is found in the early nineteenth entury, in Hamilton's formulation of geometri al opti s and parti le me hani s. As de Broglie points out in his Solvay report (pp. 377 and 383), Hamilton's theory is in fa t the short-wavelength limit of pilot-wave dynami s: for in that limit, the phase of the wave fun tion
36
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
obeys the Hamilton-Ja obi equation, and de Broglie's traje tories redu e to those of lassi al me hani s. A physi al theory of light as both parti les and waves in ee t a revival of Newton's views emerged again with Einstein in 1905. It is less well known that, after 1905, Einstein tried to onstru t theories of lo alised light quanta oupled to ve tor elds in 3-spa e. As we shall see in hapter 9, Einstein's ideas in this vein show some resemblan e to de Broglie's but also dier from them. It should also be mentioned that, in the autumn of 1923 (the same year in whi h de Broglie rst elaborated his ideas), Slater tried to develop a theory in whi h the motion of photons was guided by the ele tromagneti eld. It appears that Slater rst attempted to onstru t a deterministi theory, but had trouble dening an appropriate velo ity ve tor; he then
ame to the on lusion that photons and the ele tromagneti eld were related only statisti ally, with the photon probability density being given by the intensity of the eld. After dis ussing his ideas with Bohr and Kramers in 1924, the photons were removed from the theory, apparently against Slater's wishes (Mehra and Re henberg 1982a, pp. 5426). Note that, while de Broglie applied his theory to photons, he made it lear (for example in the general dis ussion, p. 509) that in his theory the guiding `ψ -wave' was distin t from the ele tromagneti eld. In the ase of light, then, the idea of ombining both parti le-like and wave-like aspe ts was an old one, going ba k indeed to Newton. In the
ase of ordinary matter, however, de Broglie seems to have been the rst to develop a physi al theory of this form. It is sometimes laimed that, for the ase of ele trons, ideas similar to de Broglie's were put forward by Madelung in 1926. What Madelung proposed, however, was to regard an ele tron with mass m and wave fun tion ψ not as a pointlike parti le within the wave, but as a ontinuous uid spread over spa e with mass density m |ψ|2 (Madelung 1926a,b). In this `hydrodynami al' interpretation, mathemati ally the uid velo ity
oin ides with de Broglie's velo ity eld; but physi ally, Madelung's theory seems more akin to S hrödinger's theory than to de Broglie's. Finally, before we examine de Broglie's work, we note what appears to be a re urring histori al opposition to dualisti physi al theories
ontaining both waves and parti les. In 180103, Thomas Young, who by his own a
ount regarded his theory as a development of Newton's ideas,a removed the orpus les from Newton's theory and produ ed a purely una See, for example, Bernard Cohen's prefa e to Newton's Opti ks (1730, reprint).
2.2 A new approa h to parti le dynami s: 192324
37
dulatory a
ount of light. In 1905, Einstein's dualist view of light was not taken seriously, and did not win widespread support until the dis overy of the Compton ee t in 1923. In 1924, Bohr and Kramers, who regarded the Bohr-Kramers-Slater theory as a development of Slater's original idea, insisted on removing the photons from Slater's theory of radiation.a And in 1926, S hrödinger, who regarded his work as a development of de Broglie's ideas, removed the traje tories from de Broglie's theory and produ ed a purely undulatory `wave me hani s'.b
2.2 A new approa h to parti le dynami s: 192324 In this se tion we show how de Broglie took his rst steps towards a new form of dynami s.a His aim was to explain the quantum phenomena known at the time in parti ular the Bohr-Sommerfeld quantisation of atomi energy levels, and the apparently dual nature of radiation by unifying the physi s of parti les with the physi s of waves. To a
omplish this, de Broglie began by extending Einstein's wave-parti le duality for light to all material bodies, by introdu ing a `phase wave' a
ompanying every material parti le. Then, inspired by the opti alme hani al analogy,b de Broglie proposed that Newton's rst law of motion should be abandoned, and repla ed by a new prin iple that unied Maupertuis' variational prin iple for me hani s with Fermat's variational prin iple for opti s. The result was a new form of dynami s in whi h the velo ity v of a parti le is determined by the gradient of the phase φ of an a
ompanying wave in ontrast with lassi al me hani s, where a
elerations are determined by for es. (Note that de Broglie's phase φ has a sign opposite to the phase S as we would normally dene it now.) This new approa h to dynami s enabled de Broglie to obtain a wavelike explanation for the quantisation of atomi energy levels, to explain the observed interferen e of single photons, and to predi t for the rst time the new and unexpe ted phenomenon of the dira tion and interferen e of ele trons. a In 1925, Born and Jordan attempted to restore the photons, proposing a sto hasti theory reminis ent of Slater's original ideas; it appears that they were dissuaded from publi ation by Bohr. See Darrigol (1992, p. 253) and se tion 3.4.2. b Cf. se tion 4.5. a An insightful and general a
ount of de Broglie's early work, up to 1924, has been given by Darrigol (1993). b Possibly, de Broglie was also inuen ed by the philosopher Henri Bergson's writings
on erning time, ontinuity and motion (Feuer 1974, pp. 20614); though this is denied by Lo hak (1992).
38
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
As we shall see, the theory proposed by de Broglie in 192324 was, in fa t, a simple form of pilot-wave dynami s, for the spe ial ase of independent parti les guided by waves in 3-spa e, and without a spe i wave equation.
2.2.1 First papers on pilot-wave theory (1923) De Broglie's earliest experien e of physi s was losely tied to experiment. During the rst world war he worked on wireless telegraphy, and after the war his rst papers on erned X-ray spe tros opy. In 1922 he published a paper treating bla kbody radiation as a gas of light quanta (de Broglie 1922). In this paper, de Broglie made the unusual assumption that photons had a very small but non-zero rest mass m0 . He was therefore now applying Einstein's relations E = hν and p = h/λ (relating energy and momentum to frequen y and wavelength) to massive parti les, even if these were still only photons. It seems that de Broglie made the assumption m0 6= 0 so that light quanta ould be treated in the same way as ordinary material parti les. It appears that this paper was the seed from whi h de Broglie's subsequent work grew.a A
ording to de Broglie's later re olle tions (L. de Broglie, AHQP interview, 7 January 1963, p. 1),2 his rst ideas on erning a pilot-wave theory of massive parti les arose as follows. During onversations on the subje t of X-rays with his older brother Mauri e de Broglie,b he be ame onvin ed that X-rays were both parti les and waves. Then, in the summer of 1923, de Broglie had the idea of extending this duality to ordinary matter, in parti ular to ele trons. He was drawn in this dire tion by onsideration of the opti al-me hani al analogy; further, the presen e of whole numbers in quantisation onditions suggested to him that waves must be involved. This last motivation was re alled by de Broglie (1999) in his Nobel le ture of 1929: .... the determination of the stable motions of the ele trons in the atom involves whole numbers, and so far the only phenomena in whi h whole numbers were involved in physi s were those of interferen e and of eigenvibrations. That
a In a olle tion of papers by de Broglie and Brillouin, published in 1928, a footnote added to de Broglie's 1922 paper on bla kbody radiation and light quanta remarks: `This paper .... was the origin of the ideas of the author on wave me hani s' (de Broglie and Brillouin 1928, p. 1). b Mauri e, the sixth du de Broglie, was a distinguished experimental physi ist, having done important work on the photoele tri ee t with X-rays experiments that were arried out in his private laboratory in Paris.
2.2 A new approa h to parti le dynami s: 192324
39
suggested the idea to me that ele trons themselves ould not be represented as simple orpus les either, but that a periodi ity had also to be assigned to them too.
De Broglie rst presented his new ideas in three notes published (in Fren h) in the Comptes Rendus of the A ademy of S ien es in Paris (de Broglie 1923a,b, ), and also in two papers published in English one in Nature (de Broglie 1923d), the other in the Philosophi al Magazine (de Broglie 1924a).a The ideas in these papers formed the basis for de Broglie's do toral thesis. The paper in the Philosophi al Magazine reads, in fa t, like a summary of mu h of the material in the thesis. Sin e the thesis provides a more systemati presentation, we shall give a detailed summary of it in the next subse tion; here, we give only a brief a
ount of the earlier papers, ex ept for the ru ial se ond paper, whose on eptual ontent warrants more detailed ommentary.b The rst ommuni ation (de Broglie 1923a), entitled `Waves and quanta', proposes that an `internal periodi phenomenon' should be asso iated with any massive parti le (in luding light quanta). In the rest frame of a parti le with rest mass m0 , the periodi phenomenon is assumed to have a frequen y ν0 = m0 c2 /h. In a frame where the parti le has uniform velo ity p v , de Broglie onsiders the two frequen ies ν and ν1 , where 2 ν = ν0 / 1 − v 2 /c2 is the frequen y p ν = mc /h asso iated p with the 2 2 relativisti mass in rease m = m0 / 1 − v /c and ν1 = ν0 1 − v 2 /c2 is the time-dilated frequen y. De Broglie shows that, be ause ν1 = ν(1− v 2 /c2 ), a ` titious' wave of frequen y ν and phase velo ity vph = c2 /v (propagating in the same dire tion as the parti le) will remain in phase with the internal os illation of frequen y ν1 . De Broglie then onsiders an atomi ele tron moving uniformly on a ir ular orbit. He proposes that orbits are stable only if the titious wave remains in phase with the internal os illation of the ele tron. From this ondition, de Broglie derives the Bohr-Sommerfeld quantisation ondition. The se ond ommuni ation (de Broglie 1923b), entitled `Light quanta, dira tion and interferen e', has a more on eptual tone. De Broglie begins by re alling his previous result, that a moving body must be asso iated with `a non-material sinusoidal wave'. He adds that the parti le velo ity v is equal to the group velo ity of the wave, whi h de Broglie here alls `the phase wave' be ause its phase at the lo ation of the a It seems possible that Comptes Rendus was not widely read by physi ists outside Fran e, but this ertainly was not true of Nature or the Philosophi al Magazine. b We do not always keep to de Broglie's original notation.
40
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
parti le is equal to the phase of the internal os illation of the parti le. De Broglie then goes on to make some very signi ant observations about dira tion and the nature of the new dynami s that he is proposing. De Broglie asserts that dira tion phenomena prove that light quanta
annot always propagate in a straight line, even in what would normally be alled empty spa e. He draws the bold on lusion that Newton's rst law of motion (the `prin iple of inertia') must be abandoned (p. 549): The light quanta [atomes de lumière℄ whose existen e we assume do not always propagate in a straight line, as proved by the phenomena of dira tion. It then seems
ne essary
to modify the prin iple of inertia.
De Broglie then suggests repla ing Newton's rst law with a new postulate (p. 549): We propose to adopt the following postulate as the basis of the dynami s of the free material point: `At ea h point of its traje tory, a free moving body follows in a uniform motion the
ray
of its phase wave, that is (in an isotropi
medium), the normal to the surfa es of equal phase'.
The dira tion of light quanta is then explained sin e, as de Broglie notes, `if the moving body must pass through an opening whose dimensions are small ompared to the wavelength of the phase wave, in general its traje tory will urve like the ray of the dira ted wave'. In retrospe t, de Broglie's postulate for free parti les may be seen as a simplied form of the law of motion of what we now know as pilot-wave dynami s ex ept for the statement that the motion along a ray be `uniform' (that is, have onstant speed), whi h in pilot-wave theory is true only in spe ial ases.a De Broglie notes that his postulate respe ts
onservation of energy but not of momentum. And indeed, in pilot-wave theory the momentum of a `free' parti le is generally not onserved: in ee t (from the standpoint of Bohm's Newtonian formulation), the pilot wave or quantum potential a ts like an `external sour e' of momentum (and in general of energy too).b The abandonment of something as a From Bohm's se ond-order equation (3) applied to a single parti le, for timeindependent V it follows that d( 12 mv2 + V + Q)/dt = ∂Q/∂t (the usual energy
onservation formula with a time-dependent ontribution Q to the potential). In free spa e (V = 0), the speed v is onstant if and only if dQ/dt = ∂Q/∂t or v · ∇Q = 0 (so that the `quantum for e' does no work), whi h is true only in spe ial ases. b Again from (3), in free spa e the rate of hange of momentum p = mv (where v = ∇S/m) is dp/dt = −∇Q, whi h is generally non-zero. Further, in general (3) implies d( 21 mv2 + V )/dt = −v · ∇Q, so that the standard ( lassi al) expression for energy is onserved if and only if v · ∇Q = 0. If, on the other hand, one denes 1 mv2 + V + Q as the `energy', it will be onserved if and only if ∂Q/∂t = 0, whi h 2
2.2 A new approa h to parti le dynami s: 192324
41
elementary as momentum onservation is ertainly a radi al step by any standards. On the other hand, if one is willing as de Broglie was to propose a fundamentally new approa h to the theory of motion, then the loss of lassi al onservation laws is not surprising, as these are really properties of lassi al equations of motion. De Broglie then makes a remarkable predi tion, that any moving body (not just light quanta) an undergo dira tion: .... any moving body ould in ertain ases be dira ted. A stream of ele trons passing through a small enough opening will show dira tion phenomena. It is in this dire tion that one should perhaps look for experimental onrmation of our ideas.
Next, de Broglie puts his proposals in a general on eptual and histori al perspe tive. Con erning the role of the phase wave, he writes (p. 549): We therefore on eive of the phase wave as guiding the movements of energy, and this is what an allow the synthesis of waves and quanta.
Here, for the rst time, de Broglie hara terises the phase wave as a `guiding' wave. De Broglie then remarks that, histori ally speaking, the theory of waves `went too far' by denying the dis ontinuous stru ture of radiation and `not far enough' by not playing a role in dynami s. For de Broglie, his proposal has a lear histori al signi an e (p. 549, itali s in the original): The new dynami s of the free material point is to the old dynami s (in luding that of Einstein) what wave opti s is to geometri al opti s. Upon ree tion one will see that the proposed synthesis appears as the logi al ulmination of the omparative development of dynami s and of opti s sin e the seventeenth
entury.
In the se ond part of this note, de Broglie onsiders the explanation of opti al interferen e fringes. He assumes that the probability for an atom to absorb or emit a light quantum is determined by `the resultant of one of the ve tors of the phase waves rossing ea h other there [se roisant sur lui℄' (pp. 54950). In Young's interferen e experiment, the light quanta passing through the two holes are dira ted, and the probability of them being dete ted behind the s reen will vary from point to point, depending on the `state of interferen e' of the phase waves. De Broglie is true only for spe ial ases (in parti ular for stationary states, sin e for these |Ψ| is time-independent).
42
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
on ludes that there will be bright and dark fringes as predi ted by the wave theories, no matter how feeble the in ident light. This approa h to opti al interferen e in whi h interfering phase waves determine the probability for intera tion between photons and the atoms in the dete tion apparatus is elaborated in de Broglie's thesis (see below). Soon after ompleting his thesis (apparently), de Broglie abandoned this idea in favour of a simpler approa h, in whi h the interfering phase waves determine the number density of photon traje tories (see se tion 2.2.3). In de Broglie's third ommuni ation (de Broglie 1923 ), entitled `Quanta, the kineti theory of gases and Fermat's prin iple', part 1 onsiders the statisti al treatment of a gas of parti les a
ompanied by phase waves. De Broglie makes the following assumption: The state of the gas will then be stable only if the waves orresponding to all of the atoms form a system of stationary waves.
In other words, de Broglie onsiders the stationary modes, or standing waves, asso iated with a given spatial volume. He assumes that ea h mode ` an transport zero, one, two or several atoms', with probabilities determined by the Boltzmann fa tor.a A
ording to de Broglie, for a gas of nonrelativisti atoms his method yields the Maxwell distribution, while for a gas of photons it yields the Plan k distribution.b In part 2 of the same note, de Broglie shows how his new dynami al postulate amounts to a uni ation of Maupertuis' prin iple of least a tion with Fermat's prin iple of least time in opti s. Let us re all that, in the me hani al prin iple of Maupertuis for parti le traje tories, Z b δ mv · dx = 0 , (6) a
the ondition of stationarity determines the parti le paths. (In (6) the energy is xed on the varied paths; at the end points, ∆x = 0 but ∆t need not be zero.) While in the opti al prin iple of Fermat for light rays, Z b δ dφ = 0 , (7) a
the stationary line integral for the phase hange the stationary `opti al a As remarked by Pais (1982, pp. 4356), in this paper de Broglie `evaluated independently of Bose (and published before him) the density of radiation states in terms of parti le (photon) language'. b As shown by Darrigol (1993), de Broglie made some errors in his appli ation of the methods of statisti al me hani s.
2.2 A new approa h to parti le dynami s: 192324
43
path length' provides a ondition that determines the path of a ray
onne ting two points, in spa e (for the time-independent ase) or in spa etime. Now, a
ording to de Broglie's basi postulate: `The rays of the phase waves oin ide with the dynami ally possible traje tories' (p. 632). The rays are des ribed by Fermat's prin iple (for the ase of a dispersive medium), whi h de Broglie shows oin ides with Maupertuis' prin iple, as follows: writing the element of phase hange as dφ = 2πνdl/vph, where dl is an element of path and vph = c2 /v is the phase velo ity, and using the relation ν = E/h = mc2 /h, the element of phase
hange may be rewritten as (2π/h)mvdl, so that (7) oin ides with (6). As de Broglie puts it (p. 632): In this way the fundamental link that unites the two great prin iples of geometri al opti s and of dynami s is brought fully to light.
De Broglie remarks that some of the dynami ally possible traje tories will be `in resonan e with the phase wave', and that these orrespond to R Bohr's stable orbits, for whi h νdl/vph is a whole number. Soon afterwards, de Broglie introdu es a ovariant 4-ve tor formulation of his basi dynami al postulate (de Broglie 1924a,b). He denes n), where n ˆ is a unit ve tor in the a 4-ve tor wµ = (ν/c, −(ν/vph )ˆ dire tion of a ray of the phase wave, and assumes it to be related to the energy-momentum 4-ve tor pµ = (E/c, −p) by pµ = hwµ . De Broglie notes that the identity of the prin iples of Maupertuis and Fermat then follows immediately. We shall dis uss this in more detail in the next subse tion.
2.2.2 Thesis (1924) He has lifted a orner of the great veil. Einstein, ommenting on de Broglie's thesis
a
De Broglie's do toral thesis (de Broglie 1924e) was mostly based on the above papers. It seems to have been ompleted in the summer of 1924, and was defended at the Sorbonne in November. The thesis was published early in 1925 in the Annales de Physique (de Broglie 1925).b a Letter to Langevin, 16 De ember 1924 (quoted in Darrigol 1993, p. 355). b An English translation of extra ts from de Broglie's thesis appears in Ludwig (1968). A omplete translation has been done by A. F. Kra klauer ( urrently online at http://www.ensmp.fr/ab/LDB-oeuvres/De_Broglie_Kra klauer.htm ). All translations here are ours.
44
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
When writing his thesis, de Broglie was well aware that his theory had gaps. As he put it (p. 30):a .... the main aim of the present thesis is to present a more omplete a
ount of the new ideas that we have proposed, of the su
esses to whi h they have led, and also of the many gaps they ontain.
De Broglie begins his thesis with a histori al introdu tion. Newtonian me hani s, he notes, was eventually formulated in terms of the prin iple of least a tion, whi h was rst given by Maupertuis and then later in another form by Hamilton. As for the s ien e of light and opti s, the laws of geometri al opti s were eventually summarised by Fermat in terms of a prin iple whose form is reminis ent of the prin iple of least a tion. Newton tried to explain some of the phenomena of wave opti s in terms of his orpus ular theory, but the work of Young and Fresnel led to the rise of the wave theory of light, in parti ular the su
essful wave explanation of the re tilinear propagation of light (whi h had been so lear in the orpus ular or `emission' theory). On this, de Broglie
omments (p. 25): When two theories, based on ideas that seem entirely dierent, a
ount for the same experimental fa t with equal elegan e, one an always wonder if the opposition between the two points of view is truly real and is not due solely to an inadequa y of our eorts at synthesis.
This remark is, of ourse, a hint that the aim of the thesis is to ee t just su h a synthesis. De Broglie then turns to the rise of ele trodynami s, relativity, and the theory of energy quanta. He notes that Einstein's theory of the photoele tri ee t amounts to a revival of Newton's orpus ular theory. De Broglie then sket hes Bohr's 1913 theory of the atom, and goes on to point out that observations of the photoele tri ee t for X- and γ -rays seem to onrm the orpus ular hara ter of radiation. At the same time, the wave aspe t ontinues to be onrmed by the observed interferen e and dira tion of X-rays. Finally, de Broglie notes the very re ent orpus ular interpretation of Compton s attering. De Broglie on ludes his histori al introdu tion with a mention of his own re ent work (p. 30): ....
the moment seemed to have arrived to make an eort towards unifying
the orpus ular and wave points of view and to go a bit more deeply into the true meaning of the quanta. That is what we have done re ently ....
a Here and below, page referen es for de Broglie's thesis orrespond to the published version in Annales de Physique (de Broglie 1925).
2.2 A new approa h to parti le dynami s: 192324
45
De Broglie learly regarded his own work as a synthesis of earlier theories of dynami s and opti s, a synthesis in reasingly for ed upon us by a
umulating experimental eviden e. Chapter 1 of the thesis is entitled `The phase wave'. De Broglie begins by re alling the equivalen e of mass and energy implied by the theory of relativity. Turning to the problem of quanta, he remarks (pp. 323): It seems to us that the fundamental idea of the quantum theory is the impossibility of onsidering an isolated quantity of energy without asso iating a
ertain frequen y with it. This onne tion is expressed by what I shall all the quantum relation:
energy = h × frequency where
h
is Plan k's onstant.
To make sense of the quantum relation, de Broglie proposes that (p. 33) .... to ea h energy fragment of proper mass phenomenon of frequen y
ν0
m0
there is atta hed a periodi
su h that one has:
hν0 = m0 c2 ν0
being measured, of ourse, in the system tied to the energy fragment.
De Broglie asks if the periodi phenomenon must be assumed to be lo alised inside the energy fragment. He asserts that this is not at all ne essary, and that it will be seen to be `without doubt spread over an extensive region of spa e' (p. 34). De Broglie goes on to onsider p the apparent ontradi tion between the 2 ν = mc /h = ν / 1 − v 2 /c2 and the time-dilated frequen y frequen y 0 p 2 2 ν1 = ν0 1 − v /c . He proposes that the ontradi tion is resolved by the following `theorem of phase harmony' (p. 35): in a frame where the moving body has velo ity v , the periodi phenomenon tied to the moving body and with frequen y ν1 is always in phase with a wave of frequen y ν propagating in the same dire tion as the moving body with phase velo ity vph = c2 /v . This is shown by applying the Lorentz transformation to a rest-frame wave sin (ν0 t0 ), yielding a wave h i p sin ν0 t − vx/c2 / 1 − v 2 /c2 (8) p of frequen y ν = ν0 / 1 − v 2 /c2 and phase velo ity c2 /v . Regarding the nature of this wave de Broglie says that, be ause its velo ity is greater than c, it annot be a wave transporting energy: rather, `it represents the spatial distribution of the phases of a phenomenon; it is a phase wave ' (p. 36). De Broglie shows that the group velo ity of the phase
46
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
wave is equal to the velo ity of the parti le. In the nal se tion of
hapter 1 (`The phase wave in spa etime'), he dis usses the appearan e of surfa es of onstant phase for dierently moving observers, from a spa etime perspe tive. Chapter 2 is entitled `Maupertuis' prin iple and Fermat's prin iple'. The aim is to generalise the results of the rst hapter to non-uniform, non-re tilinear motion. In the introdu tion to hapter 2 de Broglie writes (p. 45): Guided by the idea of a deep unity between the prin iple of least a tion and that of Fermat, from the beginning of my investigations on this subje t I was led to
assume
that, for a given value of the total energy of the moving body
and therefore of the frequen y of its phase wave, the dynami ally possible traje tories of the one oin ided with the possible rays of the other.
De Broglie dis usses the prin iple of least a tion, in the dierent forms given by Hamilton and by Maupertuis, and also for relativisti parti les in an external ele tromagneti eld. He writes Hamilton's prin iple as Z Q pµ dxµ = 0 δ (9) P
(µ = 0, 1, 2, 3, with dx0 = cdt), where P , Q are points in spa etime and pµ is the anoni al energy-momentum 4-ve tor, and notes that if p0 is
onstant the prin iple be omes Z B δ pi dxi = 0 (10) A
(i = 1, 2, 3), where A, B are the orresponding points in spa e that is, Hamilton's prin iple redu es to Maupertuis' prin iple. De Broglie then dis usses wave propagation and Fermat's prin iple from a spa etime perspe tive. He onsiders a sinusoidal fun tion sin φ, where the phase φ has a spa etime-dependent dierential dφ, and writes the variational prin iple for the ray in spa etime in the Hamiltonian form Z Q δ (11) dφ = 0 . P
De Broglie then introdu es a 4-ve tor eld wµ on spa etime, dened by dφ = 2πwµ dxµ ,
(12)
where the wµ are generally fun tions on spa etime. (Of ourse, this implies that 2πwµ = ∂µ φ, though de Broglie does not write this expli itly.) De Broglie also notes that dφ = 2π(νdt − (ν/vph )dl) and
2.2 A new approa h to parti le dynami s: 192324
47
wµ = (ν/c, −(ν/vph )ˆ n), where n ˆ is a unit ve tor in the dire tion of propagation; and that if ν is onstant, the prin iple in the Hamiltonian form Z Q δ wµ dxµ = 0 (13) P
redu es to the prin iple in the Maupertuisian form Z B wi dxi = 0 , δ
(14)
A
or
δ
Z
B A
ν dl = 0 , vph
(15)
whi h is Fermat's prin iple. De Broglie then dis usses an `extension of the quantum relation' (that is, an extension of E = hν ). He states that the two 4-ve tors pµ and wµ play perfe tly symmetri al roles in the motion of a parti le and in the propagation of a wave. Writing the `quantum relation' E = hν as w0 = h1 p0 , de Broglie proposes the generalisation wµ =
1 pµ , h
(16)
so that dφ = 2πwµ dxµ =
2π pµ dxµ . h
Fermat's prin iple then be omes Z B pi dxi = 0 , δ
(17)
(18)
A
whi h is the same as Maupertuis' prin iple. Thus, de Broglie arrives at the following statement (p. 56): Fermat's prin iple applied to the phase wave is identi al to Maupertuis' prin iple applied to the moving body; the dynami ally possible traje tories of the moving body are identi al to the possible rays of the wave.
He adds that (p. 56): We think that this idea of a deep relationship between the two great prin iples of Geometri al Opti s and Dynami s ould be a valuable guide in realising the synthesis of waves and quanta.
48
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
De Broglie then dis usses some parti ular ases: the free parti le, a parti le in an ele trostati eld, and a parti le in a general ele tromagneti eld. He al ulates the phase velo ity, whi h depends on the ele tromagneti potentials. He notes that the propagation of a phase wave in an external eld depends on the harge and mass of the moving body. And he shows that the group velo ity along a ray is still equal to the velo ity of the moving body. For the ase of an ele tron of harge e and velo ity v in an ele trostati potential ϕ, de Broglie writes down the following expressions for the frequen y ν and phase velo ity vph of the phase wave (p. 57): ν = (mc2 + eϕ)/h , vph = (mc2 + eϕ)/mv (19) p (where again m = m0 / 1 − v 2 /c2 ). He shows that vph may be rewritten as the free value c2 /v multiplied by a fa tor hν/(hν − eϕ) that depends on the potential ϕ. The expressions (19) formed the starting point for S hrödinger's work on the wave equation for de Broglie's phase waves (as re onstru ted by Mehra and Re henberg (1987, pp. 4235), see se tion 2.3). While de Broglie does not expli itly say so in his thesis, note that from the denition (12) of wµ , the generalised quantum relation (16) may be written in the form pµ = ℏ∂µ φ .
(20)
This is what we would now all a relativisti guidan e equation, giving the velo ity of a parti le in terms of the gradient of the phase of a pilot wave (where here de Broglie denes the phase φ to be dimensionless). In other words, the extended quantum relation is a rst-order equation of motion. In the presen e of an ele tromagneti eld, the anoni al momentum pµ ontains the 4-ve tor potential. For a free parti le, with pµ = (E/c, −p), the guidan e equation has omponents ˙ p = −ℏ∇φ , E = ℏφ,
where the spatial omponents may also be written as m0 v mv = p = −ℏ∇φ . 1 − v 2 /c2
(21)
(22)
For a plane wave of phase φ = ωt − k · x, we have E = ℏω, p = ℏk .
(23)
Thus, de Broglie's uni ation of the prin iples of Maupertuis and
2.2 A new approa h to parti le dynami s: 192324
49
Fermat amounts to a new dynami al law, (16) or (20), in whi h the phase of a guiding wave determines the parti le velo ity. This new law of motion is the essen e of de Broglie's new, rst-order dynami s. Chapter 3 of de Broglie's thesis is entitled `The quantum onditions for the stability of orbits'. De Broglie reviews Bohr's ondition for ir ular orbits, a
ording to whi h the angular R 2πmomentum of the ele tron must be a multiple of ℏ, or equivalently 0 pθ dθ = Hnh (pθ onjugate to θ). He also reviews Sommerfeld's generalisation, H P3 pi dqi = ni h (integral ni ) and Einstein's invariant formulation i=1 pi dqi = nh (integral n). De Broglie then provides an explanation for Einstein's ondition. The traje tory of the moving body oin ides with one of the rays of its phase wave, and the phase wave moves along the traje tory with a onstant frequen y (be ause the total energy is onstant) and with a variable speed whose value has been al ulated. To have a stable orbit, laims de Broglie, the length l of the orbit must be in `resonan e' with the wave: thus l = nλ in the ase of onstant wavelength, and H (ν/vph )dl = n (n integral) generally. De Broglie notes that this is pre isely the integral appearing in Fermat's prin iple, whi h has been shown to be equal to the integral giving the Maupertuisian a tion divided by h. The resonan e ondition is then identi al to the required stability
ondition. For the simple ase of ir ular orbits in the Bohr atom de Broglie shows, using H vph = νλ and h/λ = m0 v , that the resonan e
ondition be omes m0 vdl = nh or m0 ωR2 = nℏ (with v = ωR), as originally given by Bohr.a (Note that the simple argument ommonly found in textbooks, about the tting of whole numbers of wavelengths along a Bohr orbit, originates in this work of de Broglie's.) De Broglie thought that his explanation of the stability or quantisation
onditions onstituted important eviden e for his ideas. As he puts it (p. 65): This beautiful result, whose demonstration is so immediate when one has a
epted the ideas of the pre eding hapter, is the best justi ation we an give for our way of atta king the problem of quanta.
Certainly, de Broglie had a hieved a on rete realisation of his initial intuition that quantisation onditions for atomi energy levels ould arise from the properties of waves. In his hapter 4, de Broglie onsiders the two-body problem, in para De Broglie also laims to generalise his results from losed orbits to quasi-periodi (or multi-periodi ) motion: however, as shown by Darrigol (1993), de Broglie's derivation is faulty.
50
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
ti ular the hydrogen atom. He expresses on ern over how to dene the proper masses, taking into a
ount the intera tion energy. He dis usses the quantisation onditions for hydrogen from a two-body point of view: he has two phase waves, one for the ele tron and one for the nu leus. The subje t of hapter 5 is light quanta. De Broglie suggests that the
lassi al (ele tromagneti ) wave distribution in spa e is some sort of time average over the true distribution of phase waves. His light quantum is assigned a very small proper mass: the velo ity v of the quantum, and the phase velo ity c2 /v of the a
ompanying phase wave, are then both very lose to c. De Broglie points out that radiation is sometimes observed to violate re tilinear propagation: a light wave striking the edge of a s reen dira ts into the geometri al shadow, and rays passing lose to the s reen deviate from a straight line. De Broglie notes the two histori al explanations for this phenomenon on the one hand the explanation for dira tion given by the wave theory, and on the other the explanation given by Newton in his emission theory: `Newton assumed [the existen e of℄ a for e exerted by the edge of the s reen on the orpus le' (p. 80). De Broglie asserts that he an now give a unied explanation for dira tion, by abandoning Newton's rst law of motion (p. 80): .... the ray of the wave would urve as predi ted by the theory of waves, and the moving body, for whi h the prin iple of inertia would no longer be valid, would suer the same deviation as the ray with whi h its motion is bound up [solidaire℄ ....
De Broglie's words here deserve emphasis. As is also very lear in his se ond paper of the pre eding year (see se tion 2.2.1), de Broglie regards his explanation of parti le dira tion as based on a new form of dynami s in whi h Newton's rst law the prin iple that a free body will always move uniformly in a straight line is abandoned. At the same time, de Broglie re ognises that one an always adopt a lassi al-me hani al viewpoint if one wishes (pp. 8081): .... perhaps one ould say that the wall exerts a for e on it [the moving body℄ if one takes the urvature of the traje tory as a riterion for the existen e of a for e.
Here, de Broglie re ognises that one may still think in Newtonian terms, if one ontinues to identify a
eleration as indi ative of the presen e of a for e. Similarly, as we shall see, in 1927 de Broglie notes that his pilotwave dynami s may if one wishes be written in Newtonian form with a quantum potential. But de Broglie's preferred approa h, throughout his
2.2 A new approa h to parti le dynami s: 192324
51
work in the period 192327, is to abandon Newton's rst law and base his dynami s on velo ity rather than on a
eleration. After onsidering the Doppler ee t, ree tion by a moving mirror, and radiation pressure, all from a photon viewpoint, de Broglie turns to the phenomena of wave opti s, noting that (p. 86): The stumbling blo k of the theory of light quanta is the explanation of the phenomena that onstitute wave opti s.
Here it be omes apparent that, despite his understanding of how nonre tilinear parti le traje tories arise during dira tion and interferen e, de Broglie is not sure of the details of how to explain the observed bright and dark fringes in dira tion and interferen e experiments with light. In parti ular, de Broglie did not have a pre ise theory of the assumed statisti al relationship between his phase waves and the ele tromagneti eld. Even so, he went on to make what he alled `vague suggestions' (p. 87) towards a detailed theory of opti al interferen e. De Broglie's idea was that the phase waves would determine the probability for the light quanta to intera t with the atoms onstituting the equipment used to observe the radiation, in su h a way as to a
ount for the observed fringes (p. 88): .... the probability of rea tions between atoms of matter and atoms of light is at ea h point tied to the resultant (or rather to the mean value of this) of one of the ve tors hara terising the phase wave; where this resultant vanishes the light is undete table; there is interferen e. One then on eives that an atom of light traversing a region where the phase waves interfere will be able to be absorbed by matter at ertain points and not at others. This is the still very qualitative prin iple of an explanation of interferen e .... .
As we shall see in the next se tion, after ompleting his thesis de Broglie arrived at a simpler explanation of opti al interferen e fringes. The nal se tion of hapter 5 onsiders the explanation of Bohr's frequen y ondition hν = E1 − E2 for the light emitted by an atomi transition from energy state E1 to energy state E2 . De Broglie derives this from the assumption that ea h transition involves the emission of a single light quantum of energy E = hν (together with the assumption of energy onservation). De Broglie's hapter 6 dis usses the s attering of X- and γ -rays. In his hapter 7, de Broglie turns to statisti al me hani s, and shows how the on ept of statisti al equilibrium is to be modied in the presen e of phase waves. If ea h parti le or atom in a gas is a
ompanied by a phase wave, then a box of gas will be ` riss- rossed in all dire tions'
52
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
(p. 110) by the waves. De Broglie nds it natural to assume that the only stable phase waves in the box will be those that form stationary or standing waves, and that only these will be relevant to thermodynami equilibrium. He illustrates his idea with a simple example of mole ules moving in one dimension, onned to an interval of length l. In the nonrelativisti limit, ea h phase wave has a wavelength λ = h/m0 v and the `resonan e ondition' is l = nλ with n integral. Writing v0 = h/m0 l, one then has v = nv0 . As de Broglie notes (p. 112): `The speed will then be able to take only values equal to integer multiples of v0 '. (This is, of
ourse, the well-known quantisation of momentum for parti les onned to a box.) De Broglie then argues that a velo ity element δv orresponds to a number δn = (m0 l/h)δv of states of a mole ule ( ompatible with the existen e of stationary phase waves), so that an element m0 δxδv of phase spa e volume orresponds to a number m0 δxδv/h of possible states. Generalising to three dimensions, de Broglie is led to take the element of phase spa e volume divided by h3 as the measure of the number of possible states of a mole ule, as assumed by Plan k. De Broglie then turns to the photon gas, for whi h he obtains Wien's law. He laims that, in order to get the Plan k law, the following further hypothesis is required (p. 116): If two or several atoms [of light℄ have phase waves that are exa tly superposed, of whi h one an therefore say that they are transported by the same wave, their motions an no longer be onsidered as entirely independent and these atoms an no longer be treated as separate units in al ulating the probabilities.
In de Broglie's approa h, the stationary phase waves play the role of the elementary obje ts of statisti al me hani s. De Broglie denes stationary waves as a superposition of two waves of the form i i x x sin h sin h and , (24) 2π νt + + φ0 2π νt − + φ0 cos cos λ λ
where φ0 an take any value from 0 to 1 and ν takes one of the allowed values. Ea h elementary wave an arry any number 0, 1, 2, ... of atoms, and the probability of arrying n atoms is given by the Boltzmann fa tor e−nhν/kT . Applying this method to a gas of light quanta, de Broglie
laims to derive the Plan k distribution.a De Broglie's thesis ends with a summary and on lusions (pp. 1258). The seeds of the problem of quanta have been shown, he laims, to be a Again, as shown by Darrigol (1993), de Broglie's appli ation of statisti al me hani s ontains some errors.
2.2 A new approa h to parti le dynami s: 192324
53
ontained in the histori al `parallelism of the orpus ular and wave-like
on eptions of radiation'. He has postulated a periodi phenomenon asso iated with ea h energy fragment, and shown how relativity requires us to asso iate a phase wave with every uniformly moving body. For the ase of non-uniform motion, Maupertuis' prin iple and Fermat's prin iple ` ould well be two aspe ts of a single law', and this new approa h to dynami s led to an extension of the quantum relation, giving the speed of a phase wave in an ele tromagneti eld. The most important onsequen e is the interpretation of the quantum onditions for atomi orbits in terms of a resonan e of the phase wave along the traje tories: `this is the rst physi ally plausible explanation proposed for the Bohr-Sommerfeld stability onditions'. A `qualitative theory of interferen e' has been suggested. The phase wave has been introdu ed into statisti al me hani s, yielding a derivation of Plan k's phase volume element, and of the bla kbody spe trum. De Broglie has, he laims, perhaps ontributed to a uni ation of the opposing on eptions of waves and parti les, in whi h the dynami s of the material point is understood in terms of wave propagation. He adds that the ideas need further development: rst of all, a new ele tromagneti theory is required, that takes into a
ount the dis ontinuous stru ture of radiation and the physi al nature of phase waves, with Maxwell's theory emerging as a statisti al approximation. The nal paragraph of de Broglie's thesis emphasises the in ompleteness of his theory at the time: I have deliberately left rather vague the denition of the phase wave, and of the periodi phenomenon of whi h it must in some sense be the translation, as well as that of the light quantum. The present theory should therefore be
onsidered as one whose physi al ontent is not entirely spe ied, rather than as a onsistent and denitively onstituted do trine.
As de Broglie's on luding paragraph makes lear, his theory of 1924 was rather abstra t. There was no spe ied basis for the phase waves (they were ertainly not regarded as `material' waves); nor was any parti ular wave equation suggested. It should also be noted that at this time de Broglie's waves were real-valued fun tions of spa e and time, of the form ∝ sin(ωt − k · x), with a real os illating amplitude. They were not omplex waves ∝ ei(k·x−ωt) of uniform amplitude. Thus, de Broglie's `phase waves' had an os illating amplitude as well as a phase. (De Broglie seems to have alled them `phase waves' only be ause of his theorem of phase harmony.) Note also that, in his treatment of parti les
54
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
in a box, de Broglie superposes waves propagating in opposite dire tions, yielding stationary waves whose amplitudes os illate in time. In his thesis de Broglie does not expli itly dis uss dira tion or interferen e experiments with ele trons, even though in his se ond ommuni ation of 1923 (de Broglie 1923b) he had suggested ele tron dira tion as an experimental test. A
ording to de Broglie's later re olle tions (L. de Broglie, AHQP Interview, 7 January 1963, p. 6),3 at his thesis defen e on 25 November 1924: Mr Jean Perrin, who haired the ommittee, asked me if my ideas ould lead to experimental onrmation. I replied that yes they ould, and I mentioned the dira tion of ele trons by rystals. Soon afterwards, I advised Mr Dauvillier .... to try the experiment, but, absorbed by other resear h, he did not do it. I do not know if he believed, or if he said to himself that it was perhaps very un ertain, that he was going to go to a lot of trouble for nothing it's possible. .... But the following year it was dis overed in Ameri a by Davisson and Germer.
2.2.3 Opti al interferen e fringes: November 1924 On 17 November 1924, just a few days before de Broglie defended his thesis, a further ommuni ation of de Broglie's was presented to the A ademy of S ien es: entitled `On the dynami s of the light quantum and interferen e', and published in the Comptes Rendus, this short note gave a new and improved a
ount of opti al interferen e in terms of light quanta (de Broglie 1924d). De Broglie began his note by re alling his unsatisfa tory dis ussion of opti al interferen e in his re ent work on the quantum theory (p. 1039): .... I had not rea hed a truly satisfying explanation for the phenomena of wave opti s whi h, in prin iple, all ome down to interferen e. I limited myself to putting forward a ertain onne tion between the state of interferen e of the waves and the probability for the absorption of light quanta by matter. This viewpoint now seems to me a bit arti ial and I tend towards adopting another, more in harmony with the broad outlines of my theory itself.
As we have seen, in his thesis de Broglie was unsure about how to a
ount for the bright and dark fringes observed in opti al interferen e experiments. He did not have a theory of the ele tromagneti eld, whi h he assumed emerged as some sort of average over his phase waves. To a
ount for opti al fringes, he had suggested that the phase waves somehow determined the probability for intera tions between photons and the atoms in the apparatus. Now, after ompleting his thesis, he
2.2 A new approa h to parti le dynami s: 192324
55
felt he had a better explanation, that was based purely on the spatial distribution of the photon traje tories. De Broglie's note ontinues by outlining his `new dynami s', in whi h the energy-momentum 4-ve tor of every material point is proportional to the ` hara teristi ' 4-ve tor of an asso iated wave, even when the wave undergoes interferen e or dira tion. He then gives his new view of interferen e fringes (p. 1040): The rays predi ted by the wave theories would then be in every ase the possible traje tories of the quantum. In the phenomena of interferen e, the rays be ome on entrated in those regions alled `bright fringes' and be ome diluted in those regions alled `dark fringes'.
In my rst explanation of
interferen e, the dark fringes were dark be ause the a tion of fragments of light on matter was zero there; in my urrent explanation, these fringes are dark be ause the number of quanta passing through them is small or zero.
Here, then, de Broglie explains bright and dark fringes simply in terms of a high or low density of photon traje tories in the orresponding regions. When de Broglie speaks of the traje tories being on entrated and diluted in regions of bright and dark fringes respe tively, he presumably had in mind that the number density of parti les in an interferen e zone should be proportional to the lassi al wave intensity, though he does not say this expli itly. We an dis ern the essen e of the more pre ise and omplete explanation of opti al interferen e given by de Broglie three years later in his Solvay report: there, de Broglie has the same photon traje tories, with a number density spe ied as proportional to the amplitude-squared of the guiding wave (see pp. 384 f., and our dis ussion in se tion 6.1.1). In his note of November 1924, de Broglie goes on to illustrate his proposal for the ase of Young's interferen e experiment with two pinholes a ting as point sour es. De Broglie ites the well-known fa ts that in this ase the surfa es of equal phase are ellipsoids with the pinholes as fo i, and that the rays (whi h are normal to the ellipsoidal surfa es) are on entrated on hyperboloids of onstru tive interferen e where the
lassi al intensity has maxima. He then notes (p. 1040): Let let
r1 and r2 be the distan es from a point in spa e ψ be the fun tion 12 (r1 + r2 ), whi h is onstant on
to the two holes and ea h surfa e of equal
phase. One easily shows that the phase velo ity of the waves along a ray is equal to the value it would have in the ase of free propagation divided by the derivative of
ψ
taken along the ray; as for the speed of the quantum, it will
be equal to the speed of free motion multiplied by the same derivative.
De Broglie gives no further details, but these are easily re onstru ted.
56
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
For an in ident beam of wavelength λ = 2π/k , ea h pinhole a ts as a sour e of a spheri al wave of wavelength λ, yielding a resultant wave proportional to the real part of ei(kr1 −ωt) ei(kr2 −ωt) + . r1 r2
(25)
If the pinholes have a separation d, then at large distan es (r1 , r2 >> d) from the s reen the resultant wave may be approximated as ei(kr−ωt) kd 2 (26) cos θ r 2 where θ is the (small) angular deviation from the normal to the s reen. The amplitude shows the well-known interferen e pattern. As for the phase φ = kr − ωt, with r = 12 (r1 + r2 ), the surfa es of equal phase are indeed the well-known ellipsoids. Further, the phase velo ity is given by vph =
|∂φ/∂t| ω 1 c = = , |∇φ| k |∇r| |∇r|
(27)
while de Broglie's parti le velo ity given by (22) has magnitude v=
ℏ |∇φ| k ℏ |∇φ| = = c2 |∇r| = c |∇r| 2 m (ℏω/c ) ω
(28)
(where m is the relativisti photon mass), in agreement with de Broglie's assertions. At the end of his note, de Broglie omments that this method may be applied to the study of s attering. In November 1924, then, de Broglie understood how interfering phase waves would ae t photon traje tories, ausing them to bun h together in regions oin iding with the observed bright fringes. Note that in this paper de Broglie treats his phase waves as if they were a dire t representation of the ele tromagneti eld. In his dis ussion of Young's interferen e experiment, he has phase waves emerging from the two holes and interfering, and he identies the interferen e fringes of his phase waves with opti al interferen e fringes. However, he seems quite aware that this is a simpli ation,a remarking that `the whole theory will be ome truly lear only if one manages to dene the stru ture of the light wave'. De Broglie is still not sure about the pre ise relationship between his phase waves and light waves, a situation that persists even until the a De Broglie may have thought of this as analogous to s alar wave opti s, whi h predi ts the orre t opti al interferen e fringes by treating the ele tromagneti eld simply as a s alar wave.
2.3 Towards a omplete pilot-wave dynami s: 192527
57
fth Solvay onferen e: there, while he gives (pp. 384 f.) a pre ise a
ount of opti al interferen e in his report, he points out (p. 509) that the onne tion between his guiding wave and the ele tromagneti eld is still unknown.
2.3 Towards a omplete pilot-wave dynami s: 192527 On 16 De ember 1924, Einstein wrote to Lorentz:a A younger brother of the de Broglie known to us [Mauri e de Broglie℄ has made a very interesting attempt to interpret the Bohr-Sommerfeld quantization rules (Paris Dissertation, 1924).
I believe that it is the rst feeble ray of light
to illuminate this, the worst of our physi al riddles.
I have also dis overed
something that supports his onstru tion.
What Einstein had dis overed, in support of de Broglie's ideas, appeared in the se ond of his famous papers on the quantum theory of the ideal gas (Einstein 1925a). Einstein showed that the u tuations asso iated with the new Bose-Einstein statisti s ontained two distin t terms that
ould be interpreted as parti le-like and wave-like ontributions just as Einstein had shown, many years earlier, for bla kbody radiation. Einstein argued that the wave-like ontribution should be interpreted in terms of de Broglie's matter waves, and he ited de Broglie's thesis. It was largely through this paper by Einstein that de Broglie's work be ame known outside Fran e. In the same paper, Einstein suggested that a mole ular beam would undergo dira tion through a su iently small aperture. De Broglie had already made a similar suggestion for ele trons, in his se ond ommuni ation to the Comptes Rendus (de Broglie 1923b). Even so, in their report at the fth Solvay onferen e, Born and Heisenberg state that in his gas theory paper Einstein `dedu ed from de Broglie's daring theory the possibility of dira tion of material parti les' (p. 426), giving the in orre t impression that Einstein had been the rst to see this onsequen e of de Broglie's theory. It seems likely that Born and Heisenberg did not noti e de Broglie's early papers in the Comptes Rendus. In 1925 Elsasser a student of Born's in Göttingen read de Broglie's thesis. Like most others outside Fran e, Elsasser had heard about de Broglie's thesis through Einstein's gas theory papers. Elsasser suspe ted that two observed experimental anomalies ould be explained a Quoted in Mehra and Re henberg (1982a, p. 604).
58
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
by de Broglie's new dynami s. First, the Ramsauer ee t the surprisingly large mean free path of low-velo ity ele trons in gases whi h Elsasser thought ould be explained by ele tron interferen e. Se ond, the intensity maxima observed by Davisson and Kunsman at ertain angles of ree tion of ele trons from metal surfa es, whi h had been assumed to be aused by atomi shell stru ture, and whi h Elsasser thought were
aused by ele tron dira tion. Elsasser published a short note sket hing these ideas in Die Naturwissens haften (Elsasser 1925). Elsasser then tried to design an experiment to test the ideas further, with low-velo ity ele trons, but never arried it out. A
ording to Heisenberg's later re olle tion, Elsasser's supervisor Born was s epti al about the reality of matter waves, be ause they seemed in oni t with the observed parti le tra ks in loud hambers.a On 3 November 1925, S hrödinger wrote to Einstein: `A few days ago I read with the greatest interest the ingenious thesis of Louis de Broglie .... '.a S hrödinger too had be ome interested in de Broglie's thesis by reading Einstein's gas theory papers, and he set about trying to nd the wave equation for de Broglie's phase waves. As we have seen (se tion 2.2.2), in his thesis de Broglie had shown that, in an ele trostati potential ϕ, the phase wave of an ele tron of harge e and velo ity v would have (see equation (19)) frequen y ν = p (mc2 + V )/h and phase 2 velo ity vph = (mc + V )/mv , where m = m0 / 1 − v 2 /c2 and V = eϕ is the potential energy. These expressions for ν and vph , given by de Broglie, formed the starting point for S hrödinger's work on the wave equation. S hrödinger took de Broglie's formulas for ν and vph and applied them to the hydrogen atom, with a Coulomb eld ϕ = −e/r.b Using the formula for ν to eliminate v , S hrödinger rewrote the expression for the phase velo ity vph purely in terms of the frequen y ν and the ele tronproton distan e r: vph =
hν q m0 c
1 (hν/m0
c2
− V /m0
2 c2 )
(29) −1
a For this and further details on erning Elsasser, see Mehra and Re henberg (1982a, pp. 6247). See also the dis ussion in se tion 3.4.2. a Quoted in Mehra and Re henberg (1987, p. 412). b Here we follow the analysis by Mehra and Re henberg (1987, pp. 4235) of what they all S hrödinger's `earliest preserved [unpublished℄ manus ript on wave me hani s'. Similar reasoning is found in a letter from Pauli to Jordan of 12 April 1926 (Pauli 1979, pp. 31520).
2.3 Towards a omplete pilot-wave dynami s: 192527
59
(where V = −e2 /r). Then, writing de Broglie's phase wave as ψ = ψ(x, t), he took the equation for ψ to be the usual wave equation ∇2 ψ =
1 ∂2ψ 2 ∂t2 vph
(30)
with phase velo ity vph . Assuming ψ to have a time dependen e ∝ e−2πiνt , S hrödinger then obtained the time-independent equation ∇2 ψ = −
4π 2 ν 2 ψ 2 vph
(31)
with vph given by (29). This was S hrödinger's original (relativisti ) equation for the energy states of the hydrogen atom. As is well known, S hrödinger found that the energy levels predi ted by (31) that is, the eigenvalues hν disagreed with experiment. He then adopted a nonrelativisti approximation, and found that this yielded the orre t energy levels for the low-energy limit. It is in fa t straightforward to obtain the orre t nonrelativisti limit. Writing E = hν − m0 c2 , in the low-energy limit |E| /m0 c2 << 1 and |V | /m0 c2 << 1, we have ν2 2m0 2 = h2 (E − V ) , vph
(32)
so that (31) redu es to what we now know as the nonrelativisti timeindependent S hrödinger equation for a single parti le in a potential V : −
ℏ2 2 ∇ ψ + V ψ = Eψ . 2m0
(33)
Histori ally speaking, then, S hrödinger's original equation (31) for stationary states amounted to a mathemati al trans ription into the language of the standard wave equation (30) of de Broglie's expressions for the frequen y and phase velo ity of an ele tron wave. By studying the eigenvalue problem of this equation in its nonrelativisti form (33), S hrödinger was able to show that the eigenvalues agreed remarkably well with the observed features of the hydrogen spe trum. Thus, by adopting the formalism of a wave equation, S hrödinger transformed de Broglie's elementary derivation of the quantisation of energy levels into a rigorous and powerful te hnique. The time-dependent S hrödinger equation iℏ
ℏ2 2 ∂ψ ∇ ψ+Vψ , =− ∂t 2m0
(34)
60
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
with a single time derivative, was eventually obtained by S hrödinger in his fourth paper on wave me hani s, ompleted in June 1926 (S hrödinger 1926g). The path taken by S hrödinger in these four published papers was rather tortuous. In the fourth paper, he a tually began by
onsidering a wave equation that was of se ond order in time and of fourth order in the spatial derivatives. However, he eventually settled on (34), deriving it by the following argument: for a wave with time dependen e ∝ e−(i/ℏ)Et , one may write the term Eψ in (33) as iℏ∂ψ/∂t and thus obtain (34), whi h must be valid for any E and therefore for any ψ that an be expanded as a Fourier time series.a The pri e paid for having an equation that was of only rst order in time was that ψ had to be omplex. In retrospe t, the time-dependent S hrödinger equation for a free parti le ((34) with V = 0) may be immediately derived as the simplest wave equation obeyed by a omplex plane wave ei(k·x−ωt) with the nonrelativisti dispersion relation ℏω = (ℏk)2 /2m (that is, E = p2 /2m
ombined with de Broglie's relations E = ℏω and p = ℏk ). This derivation is, in fa t, often found in textbooks. Not only did S hrödinger adopt de Broglie's idea that quantised energy levels ould be explained in terms of waves, he also took up de Broglie's
onvi tion that lassi al me hani s was merely the short-wavelength limit of a broader theory. Thus in his se ond paper on wave me hani s S hrödinger (1926 , p. 497) wrote: Maybe our lassi al me hani s is the
omplete
analogue of geometri al opti s
and as su h is wrong, not in agreement with reality; it fails as soon as the radii of urvature and the dimensions of the traje tory are no longer large
ompared to a ertain wavelength, whi h has a real meaning in the q -spa e. a Then one has to look for an `undulatory me hani s' and the most natural path towards this is surely the wave-theoreti al elaboration of the Hamiltonian pi ture.
S hrödinger used the opti al-me hani al analogy as a guide in the onstru tion of wave equations for atomi systems, parti ularly in his se ond paper. S hrödinger tended to think of the opti al-me hani al analogy in a A tually, S hrödinger onsidered the time dependen e ∝ e±(i/ℏ)Et , so that Eψ = ±iℏ∂ψ/∂t, leading to two possible wave equations diering by the sign of i. He wrote: `We shall require that the omplex wave fun tion ψ satisfy one of these two equations. Sin e at the same time the omplex onjugate fun tion ψ¯ satises the other equation, one may onsider the real part of ψ as a real wave fun tion (if one needs it)' (S hrödinger 1926g, p. 112, original itali s). a Here S hrödinger adds a footnote: `Cf. also A. Einstein, Berl. Ber., pp. 9 . (1925)'.
2.3 Towards a omplete pilot-wave dynami s: 192527
61
terms of the Hamilton-Ja obi equation and the equation of geometri al opti s, whereas de Broglie tended to think of it in terms of the prin iples of Maupertuis and Fermat. These are of ourse two dierent ways of drawing the same analogy. While S hrödinger took up and developed many of de Broglie's ideas, he did not a
ept de Broglie's view that the parti le was lo alised within an extended wave. In ee t, S hrödinger removed the parti le traje tories from de Broglie's theory, and worked only with the extended (non-singular) waves. (For a detailed dis ussion of S hrödinger's work, see hapter 4.) In the period 192526, then, many of the ideas in de Broglie's thesis were taken up and developed by other workers, espe ially S hrödinger. But what of de Broglie himself? Unlike in his earlier work, during this period de Broglie onsidered spe i equations for his waves. Like S hrödinger, he took standard relativisti wave equations as his starting point. Unlike S hrödinger, however, de Broglie was guided by the following two ideas. First, that parti les are really small singular regions, of very large wave amplitude, within an extended wave. Se ond, that the motion of the parti les or singularities must in some sense satisfy the
ondition (35)
Maupertuis ≡ Fermat ,
so as to bring about a synthesis of the dynami s of parti les with the theory of waves, along the lines already sket hed in de Broglie's thesis. This work ame to a head in a remarkable paper published in May 1927, to whi h we now turn.
2.3.1 `Stru ture': Journal de Physique, May 1927 In the last number of the Journal de Physique, a paper by de Broglie has appeared .... de Broglie attempts here to re on ile the full determinism of physi al pro esses with the dualism between waves and orpus les .... even if this paper by de Broglie is o the mark (and I hope that a tually), still it is very ri h in ideas and very sharp, and on a mu h higher level than the hildish papers by S hrödinger, who even today still thinks he may .... abolish material points. Pauli, letter to Bohr, 6 August 1927 (Pauli 1979, pp. 4045)
What we now know as pilot-wave theory rst appears in a paper by de
62
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
Broglie (1927b) entitled `Wave me hani s and the atomi stru ture of matter and of radiation', whi h was published in Journal de Physique in May 1927, and whi h we shall dis uss in detail in this se tion.a We shall refer to this ru ial paper as `Stru ture' for short. In `Stru ture', de Broglie presents a theory of parti les as moving singularities. It is argued, on the basis of ertain assumptions, that the equations of what we now all pilot-wave dynami s will emerge from this theory. At the end of the paper de Broglie proposes, as a provisional theory, simply taking the equations of pilot-wave dynami s as given, without trying to derive them from something deeper. It is this last, provisional theory that de Broglie presents a few months later at the fth Solvay onferen e. For histori al ompleteness we should point out that, a
ording to a footnote to the introdu tion, `Stru ture' was `the development of two notes' published earlier in Comptes Rendus (de Broglie 1926, 1927a). The rst, of 28 August 1926, onsiders a model of photons as moving singularities: arguments are given (similar to those found in `Stru ture') leading to the usual velo ity formula, and to the on lusion that the probability density of photons is proportional to the lassi al wave intensity. The se ond note, of 31 January 1927, sket hes analogous ideas for material bodies in an external potential, with the probability density now proportional to the amplitude-squared of the wave fun tion. Unlike `Stru ture', neither of these notes ontains the suggestion that pilot-wave theory may be adopted as a provisional view. We now turn to a detailed analysis of de Broglie's `Stru ture' paper. De Broglie rst onsiders a `material point of proper mass m0 ' moving in free spa e with a onstant velo ity v and represented by a wave u(x, t) satisfying what we would now all the Klein-Gordon equation ∇2 u −
1 ∂2u 4π 2 ν02 = u, 2 2 c ∂t c2
(36)
with ν0 = m0 c2 /h. De Broglie onsiders solutions of the form u(x, t) = f (x − vt) cos
2π φ(x, t) , h
(37)
where the amplitude f is singular at the lo ation x = vt of the moving a Again, we do not always follow de Broglie's notation. Note also that de Broglie moves ba k and forth between solutions of the form f cos φ and solutions `written in omplex form' f eiφ .
2.3 Towards a omplete pilot-wave dynami s: 192527
63
body and the phasea hν0 v · x φ(x, t) = p t− 2 c 1 − v 2 /c2
(38)
is equal to the lassi al Hamiltonian a tion of the parti le. A single parti le is represented by a wave (37), where the moving singularity has velo ity v and the phase φ(x, t) is extended over all spa e. De Broglie then onsiders an ensemble (or ` loud') of similar free parti les with no mutual intera tion, all having the same velo ity v, and with singular amplitudes f entred at dierent points in spa e. A
ording to de Broglie, this ensemble of moving singularities may be represented by a ontinuous solution of the same wave equation (36), of the form 2π Ψ(x, t) = a cos φ(x, t) , (39) h where a is a onstant and φ is given by (38). This ontinuous solution is said to ` orrespond to' the singular solution (37). (De Broglie points out that the ontinuous solutions Ψ are the same as those onsidered by S hrödinger.) The number density of parti les in the ensemble is taken to have a
onstant value ρ, whi h may be written as ρ = Ka2
(40)
for some onstant K . Thus, de Broglie notes, (39) gives the `distribution of phases in the loud of points' as well as the `density of the loud'; and for a single parti le with known velo ity and unknown position, a2 d3 x will measure the probability for the parti le to be in a volume element d3 x. Having dis ussed the free parti le, de Broglie moves on to the ase of a single parti le in a stati external potential V (x). The wave u `written in omplex form' now satises what we would all the Klein-Gordon equation in an external potentiala V2 2i ∂u 1 1 ∂2u 2 2 2 (41) − 2 m0 c − 2 u = 0 . ∇ u − 2 2 + 2V c ∂t ℏc ∂t ℏ c De Broglie assumes that the parti le begins in free spa e, represented by a singular wave (37), and then enters a region where V 6= 0, into whi h a For simpli ity we ignore an arbitrary onstant in the phase, whi h was in luded by de Broglie. a This follows from (36) by the substitution iℏ∂/∂t → iℏ∂/∂t + V .
64
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
the free solution (37) must be extended. De Broglie writes (37) `in
omplex form', substitutes into (41), and takes the real and imaginary parts, yielding two oupled partial dierential equations for f and φ. Writing φ(x, t) = Et − φ1 (x)
(42)
(where E = hν is onstant), one of the said partial dierential equations be omes f 1 ℏ2 (43) = (∇φ1 )2 − 2 (E − V )2 + m20 c2 f c (where ≡ ∇2 − (1/c2 )∂ 2 /∂t2 ). De Broglie notes that if the left-hand side is negligible, (43) redu es to the `Ja obi equation' for relativisti dynami s in a stati potential, so that φ1 redu es to the `Ja obi fun tion'. Deviations from lassi al me hani s o
ur, de Broglie notes, when f is non-zero. De Broglie now remarks that, in the lassi al limit, the velo ity of the parti le has the same dire tion as the ve tor ∇φ1 ; he then expli itly assumes that this is still true in the general ase. Here, the identity (35) of the prin iples of Maupertuis and Fermat is being invoked. With this assumption, de Broglie shows that the singularity must have velo ity v=
c2 ∇φ1 , E−V
(44)
and he adds that in the nonrelativisti approximation, E − V ≈ m0 c2 , so that 1 ∇φ1 . v= (45) m0 De Broglie remarks that, in the lassi al approximation, φ1 be omes the `Ja obi fun tion' and that (44) agrees with the relativisti relation between velo ity and momentum. He adds (p. 230): The aim of the pre eding arguments is to make it plausible that the relation [(44)℄ is stri tly valid in the new me hani s.
The importan e of the relation (44) for de Broglie is, of ourse, that it embodies the identity of the prin iples of Maupertuis and Fermat. As in the free ase, de Broglie then goes on to onsider an ensemble of su h parti les, with ea h parti le represented by a moving singularity. He assumes that the phase fun tion φ1 is the same for all the parti les, whose velo ities are then given by (44). The (time-independent) parti le
2.3 Towards a omplete pilot-wave dynami s: 192527
65
density ρ(x) must then satisfy the ontinuity equation (46)
∇ · (ρv) = 0 .
On e again, de Broglie introdu es a representation of the ensemble by a ontinuous solution of (41). In the presen e of the potential V , the solution is taken to have the form 2π ′ 1 ′ Ψ(x, t) = a(x) cos (47) φ (x, t) = a(x) cos 2π νt − φ1 (x) . h h Again, writing Ψ `in omplex form', substituting into (41) and taking real and imaginary parts, de Broglie obtains two oupled partial dierential equations, now in a and φ′1 . One of these reads ℏ2
∇2 a 1 2 = (∇φ′1 ) − 2 (E − V )2 + m20 c2 . a c
(48)
In this ase de Broglie notes that if the left-hand side is negligible, (48) redu es to the equation of geometri al opti s asso iated with the wave equation (41). Comparing (43) and (48), de Broglie notes that when the left-hand sides are negligible, one re overs both lassi al me hani s (for a moving singularity) and geometri al opti s (for a ontinuous wave). In this limit, the fun tions φ1 and φ′1 are identi al, being both equal to the `Ja obi fun tion'. At this point de Broglie makes a ru ial assumption. He proposes to assume, as a hypothesis, that φ1 and φ′1 are always equal, regardless of any approximation (p. 2312): We now make the essential hypothesis that
φ1
and
φ′1
are still identi al when
[the left-hand sides of (43) and (48)℄ an no longer be negle ted. Obviously, this requires that one have:
f ∇2 a = . a f We shall refer to this postulate by the name of `prin iple of the double solution', be ause it implies the existen e of two sinusoidal solutions of equation [(41)℄ having the same phase fa tor, the one onsisting of a point-like singularity and the other having, on the ontrary, a ontinuous amplitude.
This hypothesis expresses, in a more on rete form, de Broglie's earlier idea of `phase harmony' between the internal os illation of a parti le and the os illation of an a
ompanying extended wave: the ondition that φ1 and φ′1 should oin ide amounts to a phase harmony between the
66
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
singular u-wave representing the point-like parti le and the ontinuous Ψ-wave. Given this ondition, de Broglie dedu es that the ratio ρ/a2 (E − V ) is
onstant along the parti le traje tories. Sin e ea h parti le is assumed to begin in free spa e, where V = 0 and (a
ording to (40)) ρ = Ka2 , de Broglie dedu es that in general V (x) , ρ(x) = Ka2 (x) 1 − (49) E where K is a onstant. The ontinuous wave then gives the ensemble density at ea h point. In the nonrelativisti approximation, this be omes ρ(x) = Ka2 (x) .
(50)
De Broglie notes that ea h possible initial position for the parti le gives rise to a possible traje tory, and that an ensemble of initial positions gives rise to an ensemble of motions. Again, de Broglie takes ρ(x)d3 x as the probability for a single parti le to be in a volume element d3 x. This probability is, as he notes, given in terms of Ψ by (49) or (50). De Broglie adds that Ψ also determines the traje tories (p. 232): The form of the traje tories is moreover equally determined by knowledge of the ontinuous wave, sin e these traje tories are orthogonal to the surfa es of equal phase.
Here we see the rst suggestion that Ψ itself may be regarded as determining the traje tories, an idea that de Broglie proposes more fully at the end of the paper. After sket hing how the above ould be used to al ulate probabilities for ele tron s attering o a xed potential, de Broglie goes on to generalise his results to the ase of a parti le of harge e in a time-dependent ele tromagneti eld (V(x, t), A(x, t)). He writes down the orresponding Klein-Gordon equation, and on e again onsiders solutions of the form (37) with a moving singularity, following the same pro edure as before. Be ause of the time-dependen e of the potentials, φ no longer takes the form (42). Instead of (44), the velo ity of the singularity is now found to be ∇φ + ec A , v = −c2 (51) φ˙ − eV or, in the nonrelativisti approximation, e 1 ∇φ + A . v=− m0 c
(52)
2.3 Towards a omplete pilot-wave dynami s: 192527
67
On e again, de Broglie then onsiders an ensemble of su h moving singularities, with the same phase fun tion φ(x, t). The density ρ(x, t) now obeys a ontinuity equation ∂ρ (53) + ∇ · (ρv) = 0 , ∂t with velo ity eld v given by (51). Again, de Broglie pro eeds to represent the motion of the ensemble by means of a ontinuous solution Ψ of the wave equation, this time of the form 2π ′ φ (x, t) , (54) h with a time-dependent amplitude and a phase no longer linear in t. And again, de Broglie assumes the prin iple of the double solution, that the phase fun tions φ(x, t) and φ′ (x, t) are the same. From this, de Broglie ˙ is onstant along parti le traje tories. dedu es that the ratio ρ/a2 (φ−eV) Using on e more the expression ρ = Ka2 for free spa e, where V = 0 and φ˙ = E0 , de Broglie argues that in general K 2 a (x, t) φ˙ − eV = K ′ a2 φ˙ − eV , ρ(x, t) = (55) E0 Ψ(x, t) = a(x, t) cos
and that in the nonrelativisti limit ρ is still proportional to a2 . As before, the ensemble may be regarded as omposed of all the possible positions of a single parti le, of whi h only the initial velo ity is known, and the probability that the parti le is in the volume element d3 x at time t is equal to ρ(x, t)d3 x and is given in terms of Ψ by (55). De Broglie now shows how the above results for the motion of a parti le in a potential V = eV (ignoring for simpli ity the ve tor potential A) may be obtained from lassi al me hani s, with a Lagrangian of the standard form p L = −M0 c2 1 − v 2 /c2 − V , (56) by assuming that the parti le has a variable proper mass r ℏ2 a M0 (x, t) = m20 − 2 (57) , c a where a is the amplitude of the ontinuous Ψ wave. Further, he onsiders this point of view in the nonrelativisti limit. Writing M0 (x, t) = m0 + ε(x, t) with ε small, the Lagrangian takes the approximate form 1 L = −m0 c2 + m0 v 2 − εc2 − V . 2 As de Broglie remarks (p. 237):
(58)
68
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
Everything then takes pla e as if there existed, in addition to εc2 .
V,
a potential
energy term
This extra term oin ides, of ourse, with Bohm's quantum potential Q (equation (4)), sin e to lowest order εc2 = −
ℏ2 a ¨ ℏ2 ∇2 a ℏ2 a =− + 2 2m0 a 2m0 a 2m0 c a
(59)
and the se ond term is negligible in the nonrelativisti limit (c → ∞). As we have already repeatedly remarked, for de Broglie the guidan e equation v ∝ ∇φ for velo ity is the fundamental equation of motion, expressing as it does the identity of the prin iples of Maupertuis and Fermat. Even so, de Broglie points out that one an write the dynami s of the parti le in lassi al (Newtonian or Einsteinian) terms, provided one in ludes a variable proper mass or, in the nonrelativisti limit, an additional quantum potential. It is this latter, Newtonian formulation that Bohm proposes in 1952. De Broglie now turns to the ase of a many-body system, onsisting of N parti les with proper masses m1 , m2 , ..., mN . In the nonrelativisti approximation, if the system has total (Newtonian) energy E and potential energy V (x1 , ..., xN ), then following S hrödinger one may onsider the propagation of a wave u in the 3N -dimensional onguration spa e, satisfying the wave equation N X i=1
−
ℏ2 2 ∇ u + V u = Eu 2mi i
(60)
(the time-independent S hrödinger equation). De Broglie remarks that this seems natural, be ause (60) is the obvious generalisation of the one-body S hrödinger equation, whi h follows from the nonrelativisti limit of de Broglie's wave equation (41). However, de Broglie riti ises S hrödinger's interpretation, a
ording to whi h a parti le is identied with an extended, non-singular wave pa ket, having no pre ise position or traje tory. De Broglie obje ts that, without well-dened parti le positions, the oordinates x1 , ..., xN used to onstru t the onguration spa e would have no meaning. Further, de Broglie asserts that onguration spa e is `purely abstra t', and that a wave propagating in this spa e annot be a physi al wave: instead, the physi al pi ture of the system must involve N waves propagating in 3-spa e. `What then', asks de Broglie (p. 238), `is the true meaning of the S hrödinger equation?' To answer this question, de Broglie onsiders,
2.3 Towards a omplete pilot-wave dynami s: 192527
69
for simpli ity, the ase of two parti les, whi h for him are singularities of a wave-like phenomenon in 3-spa e. Negle ting the ve tor potential, the two singular waves u1 (x, t) and u2 (x, t) satisfy the oupled equations 2i V2 ∂u1 1 u1 + 2 V1 − 2 m21 c2 − 12 u1 = 0 , ℏc ∂t ℏ c (61) 2i V2 ∂u2 1 u2 + 2 V2 − 2 m22 c2 − 22 u2 = 0 , ℏc ∂t ℏ c with potentials V1 = V (|x − x2 |)
, V2 = V (|x − x1 |) ,
(62)
where x1 , x2 are the positions of the two parti les (or singularities). The propagation of ea h wave then depends, through V , on the position of the singularity in the other wave. De Broglie is now fa ed with the formidable problem of solving the simultaneous partial dierential equations (61), in order to obtain the motions of the two singularities. Not surprisingly, de Broglie does not attempt to arry through su h a solution. Instead he notes that, in
lassi al me hani s in the nonrelativisti limit, it is possible to nd a `Ja obi fun tion' φ(x1 , x2 ) for the two-parti le system, su h that the parti le momenta are given by m1 v1 = −∇1 φ ,
m2 v2 = −∇2 φ .
(63)
De Broglie then asks (p. 238): `Can the new me hani s .... dene su h a fun tion φ?' De Broglie is asking whether, if one ould solve the oupled equations (61), the resulting motions of the singularities would (in the nonrelativisti limit) satisfy the guidan e equations (63) for some fun tion φ(x1 , x2 ). He then asserts, on the basis of an in orre t argument (to whi h we shall return in a moment), that this will indeed be the ase. Having on luded that a fun tion φ(x1 , x2 ) generating the motions of the singularities will in fa t exist, he goes on to identify φ(x1 , x2 ) with the phase of a ontinuous solution Ψ(x1 , x2 , t) of the S hrödinger equation (60) for the two-parti le system. While de Broglie does not say so expli itly, in ee t he assumes that there exists a ontinuous solution of (60) whose phase oin ides with the fun tion φ(x1 , x2 ) that generates the motions of the singularities via (63). This seems to be de Broglie's answer to the question he raises, as to the `true meaning' of the S hrödinger equation: solving the S hrödinger equation (60) in onguration spa e provides
70
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
an ee tive means of obtaining the motions of the singularities without having to solve the oupled partial dierential equations (61) in 3-spa e. De Broglie's in orre t argument for the existen e of an appropriate fun tion φ, derived from the equations (61), pro eeds as follows. He rst imagines that the motion of singularity 2 is already known, so that the problem of motion for singularity 1 redu es to a ase that has already been dis ussed, of a single parti le in a given time-dependent potential. For this ase, it has already been shown that the ensemble of possible traje tories may be represented by a ontinuous wave a1 (x, t)e(i/ℏ)φ1 (x,t) .
(64)
Further, as was shown earlier, the equations of motion for the parti le may be written in Lagrangian form with an additional potential ε1 (x1 , t)c2 . Similarly, onsidering the motion of singularity 1 as known, the motion of singularity 2 an be des ribed by a Lagrangian with an additional potential ε2 (x2 , t)c2 . The two sets of ( lassi al) equations of motion an be derived from a single Lagrangian, de Broglie argues, only if ε1 and ε2 redu e to a single fun tion ε(|x1 − x2 |) of the interparti le separation. `If we assume this', says de Broglie, the total Lagrangian for the system will be L=
1 1 m1 v12 + m2 v22 − V (|x1 − x2 |) − ε(|x1 − x2 |)c2 , 2 2
(65)
and one will be able to dedu e, in the usual fashion, the existen e of a fun tion φ(x1 , x2 ) satisfying the equations (63). It is not entirely lear from the text if de Broglie is really onvin ed that ε1 and ε2 will indeed redu e to a single fun tion ε(|x1 − x2 |). With hindsight one sees, in fa t, that this will not usually be the ase. For it amounts to requiring that the quantum potential Q(x1 , x2 ) for two parti les should take the form Q(x1 , x2 ) = Q(|x1 − x2 |), whi h is generally false.a After giving his in orre t argument for the existen e of φ, de Broglie points out that, sin e the parti les have denite traje tories, it is meaningful to onsider their six-dimensional onguration spa e, and to represent the two parti les by a single point in this spa e, with velo ity
omponents given by (63). If the initial velo ity omponents are given, but the initial positions of the two parti les are not, one may onsider an ensemble of representative points (x1 , x2 ), whose density ρ(x1 , x2 ) in a One might also question the meaning of de Broglie's wave fun tion (64) for parti le 1, in the ontext of a system of two intera ting parti les, whi h must have an entangled wave fun tion Ψ(x1 , x2 , t).
2.3 Towards a omplete pilot-wave dynami s: 192527
71
onguration spa e satises the ontinuity equation, ∇ · (ρv) = 0 ,
(66)
where v is the (six-dimensional) velo ity eld given by (63). De Broglie then onsiders, as we have said, a ontinuous solution of the S hrödinger equation (60), of the form Ψ(x1 , x2 , t) = A(x1 , x2 )e(i/ℏ)φ ,
(67)
with the ta it assumption that the phase φ is the same fun tion φ whose existen e has been (apparently) established by the above (in orre t) argument. He then shows, from (60), that A2 satises the ongurationspa e ontinuity equation (66). De Broglie on ludes that A2 d3 x1 d3 x2 is the probability for the representative point (x1 , x2 ) to be present in a volume element d3 x1 d3 x2 of onguration spa e. Here, then, de Broglie has arrived at a higher-dimensional analogue of his previous results: the wave fun tion Ψ in onguration spa e determines the ensemble probability density through its amplitude, as well as the motion of a single system through its phase. De Broglie ends this se tion by remarking that it seems di ult to nd an equation playing a role similar to (60) outside of the nonrelativisti approximation, and that Fermi's al ulation on erning the s attering of ele trons by a rotator may be regarded as illustrating the above. From the point of view of the history of pilot-wave theory, the most important se tion of de Broglie's paper now follows. Entitled `The pilot wave' (`L'onde pilote'), it begins by re alling the results obtained in the
ase of a single parti le in a time-dependent potential, whi h de Broglie states may be summarised by `the two fundamental formulas' (51) and (55) for the parti le velo ity and probability density respe tively. De Broglie notes that he arrived at the velo ity formula (51) by invoking the prin iple of the double solution a prin iple that is valid in free spa e but whi h `remains a hypothesis in the general ase' (p. 241). At this point, de Broglie makes a remarkable suggestion: that instead of trying to derive the velo ity eld (51) from an underlying theory, one
ould simply take it as a postulate, and regard Ψ as a physi ally-real `pilot wave' guiding the motion of the parti le. To quote de Broglie (p. 241): But if one does not wish to invoke the prin iple of the double solution, it is a
eptable to adopt the following point of view:
one will assume the
existen e, as distin t realities, of the material point and of the ontinuous wave represented by the fun tion
Ψ,
and one will take it as a postulate that
72
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
the motion of the point is determined as a fun tion of the phase of the wave by the equation [(51)℄. One then on eives the ontinuous wave as guiding the motion of the parti le. It is a pilot wave.
This is the rst appearan e in the literature of what we now know as pilot-wave or de Broglian dynami s (albeit stated expli itly for only a single parti le). The pilot wave Ψ satisfying the S hrödinger equation, and the material point, are regarded as `distin t realities', with the former guiding the motion of the latter a
ording to the velo ity law (51). De Broglie made it lear, however, that he thought su h a dynami s
ould be only provisional (p. 241): By thus taking [(51)℄ as a postulate, one avoids having to justify it by the prin iple of the double solution; but this an only be, I believe, a provisional attitude. No doubt one will indeed have to
rein orporate
the parti le into the
wave-like phenomenon, and one will probably be led ba k to ideas analogous to those that have been developed above.
As we shall dis uss in the next se tion, de Broglie's proposal of pilotwave theory as a provisional measure has striking analogues in the early history of Newtonian gravity and of Maxwellian ele tromagneti theory. De Broglie goes on to point out two important appli ations of the formulas (51) and (55). First, applying the theory to light, a
ording to (55) `the density of the photons is proportional to the square of the amplitude' of the guiding wave Ψ, yielding agreement with the predi tions of wave opti s. Se ond, an ensemble of hydrogen atoms with a denite state Ψ will have a mean ele troni harge density proportional 2 to |Ψ| , as assumed by S hrödinger. De Broglie's `Stru ture' paper ends with some remarks on the pressure exerted by parti les on a wall (for example of a box of gas). He notes that a
ording to (51), be ause of the interferen e between the in ident and ree ted waves, the parti les will not a tually strike the wall, raising the question of how the pressure is produ ed. De Broglie laims that the pressure omes from stresses in the interferen e zone, as appear in an expression obtained by S hrödinger (1927 ) for the stress-energy tensor asso iated with the wave Ψ.
2.3.2 Signi an e of de Broglie's `Stru ture' paper The ex eptional quality of de Broglie's `Stru ture' paper in Journal de Physique was noted by Pauli, in a letter to Bohr dated 6 August
2.3 Towards a omplete pilot-wave dynami s: 192527
73
1927, already quoted as the epigraph to the last subse tion: `.... it is very ri h in ideas and very sharp, and on a mu h higher level than the hildish papers by S hrödinger ....' (Pauli 1979, pp. 4045). In the same letter, Pauli suggested that Bohr would have to refer to de Broglie's paper in his Como le ture (in whi h Bohr developed the idea of omplementarity between waves and parti les); and in fa t, in what was to remain an unpublished version of the Como le ture, Bohr did take an expli it stand against de Broglie's ideas (Bohr 1985, pp. 8998). Bohr hara terised de Broglie's work as attempting `to re on ile the two apparently ontradi tory sides of the phenomena by regarding the individual parti les or light quanta as singularities in the wave eld'; further, Bohr suggested that de Broglie's view rested upon `the on epts of lassi al physi s' and was therefore not `suited to help us over the fundamental di ulties' (Bohr 1985, p. 92). On the whole, though, this paper by de Broglie has been essentially ignored, by both physi ists and historians. De Broglie's `Stru ture' paper may be summed up as follows. De Broglie has a model of parti les as singularities of 3-spa e waves ui , in whi h the motion of the individual parti les, as well as the ensemble distribution of the parti les, are determined by a ontinuous wave fun tion Ψ. (We emphasise that de Broglie has both the wave fun tion Ψ and the singular u-waves.) The result is a rst-order theory of motion, based on the velo ity law mi vi = ∇i φ, in whi h the prin iples of Maupertuis and Fermat are unied. Then, at the end of the paper, de Broglie re ognises that his singularity model of parti les an be dropped, and that the results he has obtained the formulas for velo ity and probability density in terms of Ψ an be simply postulated, yielding pilot-wave theory as a provisional measure. A few months later, in O tober 1927, de Broglie presented this pilotwave theory at the fth Solvay onferen e, for a nonrelativisti system of N parti les guided by a wave fun tion Ψ in onguration spa e. Before dis ussing de Broglie's Solvay report, however, it is worth pausing to
onsider the role played by the `Stru ture' paper in de Broglie's thinking. From a histori al point of view, the signi an e of de Broglie's `Stru ture' paper inevitably depends on the signi an e one as ribes to the provisional pilot-wave theory arrived at in that paper. Given what we know today that pilot-wave theory provides a onsistent a
ount of quantum phenomena de Broglie's `Stru ture' paper now seems
onsiderably more signi ant than it has seemed in the past. From the point of view of pilot-wave theory as we know it today, the
74
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
singular u-waves played a similar role for de Broglie as the material ether did for Maxwell in ele tromagneti theory. In both ases, there was a on eptual s aolding that was used to build a new theory, and that ould be dropped on e the results had been arrived at. De Broglie re ognised at the end of his paper that, if one took pilot-wave dynami s as a provisional theory, then the s aolding he had used to onstru t this theory ould be dropped. At the same time, de Broglie insisted that taking su h a step was indeed only provisional, and that an underlying theory was still needed, probably along the lines he had been pursuing. Similar situations have arisen before in the history of s ien e. Abstra ting away the details of a model based on an older theory sometimes results in a new theory in its own right, involving new on epts, where, however, the author regards the new theory as only a provisional measure, and expe ts that the model based on the older theory will eventually provide a proper basis for the provisional theory. Thus, for example, Newton tried to explain gravitation on the basis of a tion by onta t, involving a material medium lling spa e the same `Aethereal Medium', in fa t, as he thought responsible for the interferen e and dira tion of light (Newton 1730; reprint, pp. 35053). Newton regarded his theory of gravitation, with a tion at a distan e, as merely a provisional and phenomenologi al theory, that would later nd an explanation in terms of ontiguous a tion. Eventually, however, the on ept of `gravitational a tion at a distan e' be ame widely a
epted in its own right (though it was later to be overthrown, of ourse, by general relativity). Similarly, Maxwell used me hani al models of an ether to develop his theory of the ele tromagneti eld. Maxwell himself may or may not have re ognised that this s aolding ould be dropped (Hendry 1986). But ertainly, many of his immediate followers did not: they regarded working only with Maxwell's equations as provisional and phenomenologi al, pending the development of an underlying me hani al model of an ether. Again, the on ept of `ele tromagneti eld' eventually be ame widely a
epted as a physi al entity in its own right. In the ase of de Broglie in 1927, in his `Stru ture' paper (and subsequently at the fth Solvay onferen e), he arrived at the new on ept of `pilot wave in onguration spa e', an entirely new kind of physi al entity that, a
ording to de Broglie's (provisional) theory, guides the motion of material systems.
2.4 1927 Solvay report: the new dynami s of quanta
75
2.4 1927 Solvay report: the new dynami s of quanta We now turn to a (brief) summary of and ommentary on de Broglie's report at the fth Solvay onferen e.a As we have noted, the theory presented in this report is pilot-wave theory as we know it today, for a nonrelativisti many-body system, with a guiding wave in onguration spa e that determines the parti le velo ities a
ording to de Broglie's basi law of motion. De Broglie's ideas about parti les as singularities of 3-spa e waves are mentioned only briey. The theory de Broglie presents in Brussels in O tober 1927 is, indeed, just the provisional theory he proposed a few months earlier at the end of his `Stru ture' paper (though now expli itly applied to many-body systems as well). De Broglie begins part I of his report by reviewing the results obtained in his do toral thesis. The energy E and momentum p of a parti le are determined by the phase φ of an asso iated wave:a E = ∂φ/∂t ,
p = −∇φ .
(68)
(These are the relativisti guidan e equations of de Broglie's early pilotwave theory of 192324.) It follows that, as de Broglie remarks, `the prin iples of least a tion and of Fermat are identi al' (p. 376). Quantisation onditions appear in a natural way, and there are far-rea hing impli ations for statisti al me hani s. De Broglie ends the review of his early work with some general remarks. He points out (p. 377) that he `has always assumed that the material point o
upies a well-dened position in spa e', and he asserts that as a result the wave amplitude must be singular, or take very large values in a small region, somewhere within the extended wave. Signi antly, de Broglie adds: `But, in fa t, the form of the amplitude plays no role in the results reviewed above'. This seems to be a rst hint that the a tual results, su h as (68), do not depend on the details of any underlying model of the parti les as moving singularities. De Broglie then outlines the work of S hrödinger. He notes that S hrödinger's wave equation is onstru ted in order that the phase φ of the wave fun tion 2π Ψ = a cos (69) φ h be a solution of the Hamilton-Ja obi equation in the geometri al-opti s limit. He points out that S hrödinger identies parti les with lo alised a Again, our notation sometimes departs from de Broglie's. a Again, de Broglie's phase φ has a sign opposite to the phase S as we would normally dene it now.
76
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
wave pa kets instead of with a small on entration within an extended wave, and that for a many-body system S hrödinger has a wave Ψ propagating in onguration spa e. For both the one-body and many-body
ases, de Broglie writes down the time-independent S hrödinger equation only, with a stati potential energy fun tion. As we shall see, de Broglie in fa t onsiders non-stationary wave fun tions as well. For the one-body
ase, de Broglie also writes down a relativisti , and time-dependent, equation what we now know as the Klein-Gordon equation in an external ele tromagneti eld. De Broglie then raises two on eptual di ulties with S hrödinger's work (similar in spirit to the obje tions he raises in `Stru ture'): (1) He questions how one an meaningfully onstru t a onguration spa e without a real onguration, asserting that it `seems a little paradoxi al to onstru t a onguration spa e with the oordinates of points that do not exist' (p. 380). (2) He laims that the physi al meaning of the wave Ψ annot be ompared with that of an ordinary wave in 3-spa e, be ause the number of dimensions of the abstra t spa e on whi h Ψ is dened is determined by the number of degrees of freedom of the system. (This se ond point seems indeed a very ee tive way to make lear that Ψ is quite dierent from a onventional wave or eld on 3-spa e.) Part I of the report ends with some remarks on Born's statisti al interpretation, whi h de Broglie asserts is analogous to his own. In part II of his report, de Broglie presents his own interpretation of the wave fun tion. Pilot-wave theory is learly formulated, rst for a single parti le, and then for a system of N parti les. Several appli ations are outlined. It is interesting to see how de Broglie motivates his theory and ompares it with the ontenders. De Broglie begins by asking what the relationship is between parti les and the wave Ψ. He rst onsiders a single relativisti parti le in an external ele tromagneti eld with potentials (V , A). De Broglie notes that, in the lassi al limit, the phase φ of Ψ obeys the Hamilton-Ja obi equation, and the velo ity of the parti le is given by v = −c2
∇φ + ec A φ˙ − eV
(70)
(the same formula (51) dis ussed in `Stru ture'). De Broglie then proposes that this velo ity formula is valid even outside the lassi al limit (p. 383, itali s in the original): We propose to assume by indu tion that this formula is still valid when the old Me hani s is no longer su ient, that is to say when [φ℄ is no longer a solution
2.4 1927 Solvay report: the new dynami s of quanta
77
of the Ja obi equation. If one a
epts this hypothesis, whi h appears justied by its onsequen es, the formula [(70)℄ ompletely determines the motion of the orpus le
as soon as one is given its position at an initial instant.
In
other words, the fun tion [φ℄, just like the Ja obi fun tion of whi h it is the generalisation, determines a whole lass of motions, and to know whi h of these motions is a tually des ribed it su es to know the initial position.
We emphasise that there is no appeal to singular u-waves anywhere in de Broglie's report. No use is made of the prin iple of the double solution. As he had suggested at the end of his `Stru ture' paper a few months earlier, de Broglie simply postulates the basi equations of pilot-wave dynami s, without trying to derive them from anything else. To motivate the guidan e equation, de Broglie simply generalises the lassi al Hamilton-Ja obi velo ity formula to the non- lassi al domain: he assumes `by indu tion' that the formula holds even outside the
lassi al limit. And de Broglie is quite expli it that he is proposing a rst-order theory of motion, based on velo ities: given the wave fun tion, the initial position alone determines the traje tory. So far, then, for a single parti le de Broglie has a (relativisti ) wave fun tion Ψ = a cos 2π h φ whose phase φ determines the parti le velo ity by the guidan e equation (70). De Broglie now goes on to point out that, for an ensemble of parti les guided by the velo ity eld (70), the distribution Ka2 φ˙ − eV (71)
is preserved in time (that is, equivariant). He on ludes that, if the initial position of the parti le is ignored, then the probability for the parti le to be present (at time t) in a spatial volume dτ is πdτ = Ka2 φ˙ − eV dτ . (72)
(This is the same probability formula (55) arrived at in `Stru ture'.) De Broglie's expression `probabilité de présen e' makes it lear that we have to do with a probability for the ele tron being somewhere, and not merely with a probability for an experimenter nding the ele tron somewhere f. Bell (1990, p. 29). De Broglie simply assumes that the equivariant distribution is the orre t probability measure for a parti le of unknown position. In fa t, this distribution is only an equilibrium distribution, analogous to thermal equilibrium in lassi al statisti al me hani s (see se tion 8.2). De Broglie sums up his results so far (p. 383):
78
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
In brief, in our hypotheses, ea h wave
Ψ
determines a ` lass of motions', and
ea h one of these motions is governed by equation [(70)℄ when one knows the initial position of the orpus le. If one ignores this initial position, the formula [(72)℄ gives the probability for the presen e of the orpus le in the element of volume
dτ
at the instant
t.
Ψ then appears probability wave.
The wave
(Führungsfeld of Mr Born) and a
as both a
pilot wave
There are, de Broglie adds, no grounds for abandoning determinism, and in this his theory diers from that of Born. De Broglie adds that, in the nonrelativisti approximation (where φ˙ − eV ≈ m0 c2 ), the guidan e and probability formulas (70) and (72) redu e to 1 e v=− (73) ∇φ + A m0 c and
π = const · a2 .
(74)
These are the standard pilot-wave equations for a single parti le (in an external ele tromagneti eld). De Broglie then remarks on how the above formulas may be applied to the s attering of a single parti le by a xed potential. The ensemble of in ident parti les may be represented by a plane wave with a uniform probability distribution. Upon entering a region of non-zero eld, the behaviour of the wave fun tion may be al ulated using Born's perturbation theory (for example, for the Rutherford s attering of an ele tron by an atomi nu leus). De Broglie draws an analogy between the s attering of the wave fun tion Ψ and the lassi al s attering of light by a refra ting medium. As in his `Stru ture' paper, de Broglie remarks in passing that, for a relativisti parti le governed by the guidan e equation (70), one may write down the equations of lassi al dynami s with a variable rest mass M0 given by equation (57). As we have already noted, in the nonrelativisti approximation this yields an additional potential energy term, whi h is pre isely Bohm's `quantum potential'. And, on e again, we emphasise that for de Broglie the equation v ∝ ∇φ for velo ity is the fundamental equation of motion, expressing the identity of the prin iples of Maupertuis and Fermat: de Broglie merely points out that, if one wishes, the dynami s an be written in lassi al terms (as Bohm did in 1952). De Broglie then turns to the interpretation of interferen e and dira tion, for the ase of photons. Here, the guiding wave Ψ is similar to
2.4 1927 Solvay report: the new dynami s of quanta
79
but not the same as a light wave.a De Broglie onsiders s attering by xed obsta les, in whi h ase the guiding wave may be taken to have a
onstant frequen y ν . The relativisti equations (70), (72) then be ome v=−
c2 ∇φ, hν
(75)
π = const · a2 .
De Broglie points out that the se ond equation predi ts the well-known interferen e and dira tion patterns. He argues that the results will be the same, whether the experiment is done with an intense beam over a short time or with a feeble beam over a long time. De Broglie remarks, as he did at the end of `Stru ture', on the stresses appearing in S hrödinger's expression for the stress-energy tensor of the wave Ψ. A
ording to de Broglie, these stresses provide an explanation for the pressure exerted by light ree ting on a mirror despite the fa t that, a
ording to (70), the photons never a tually strike the surfa e of the mirror (as shown expli itly by Brillouin in the dis ussion after de Broglie's report). De Broglie then turns to the generalisation of the above dynami s to a (nonrelativisti ) many-body system. Remarkably, many historians and ommentators have not noti ed this proposal by de Broglie of a many-body dynami s in onguration spa e, a proposal that is usually attributed to Bohm ( f. se tion 11.1.) De Broglie begins by pointing out how the two di ulties he has raised against S hrödinger's wave me hani s might be solved. First, if a real onguration exists at all times, one an meaningfully onstru t the
onguration spa e. As for the se ond di ulty, regarding the meaning of a wave in the abstra t onguration spa e, de Broglie makes the following preliminary remark (p. 386): It appears to us ertain that if one wants to of a system of
N
in spa e, ea h of the
N −1
physi ally
represent the evolution
orpus les, one must onsider the propagation of
N
N
waves
propagations being determined by the a tion of the
orpus les onne ted to the other waves.
This seems a lear referen e to the theory of intera ting singular u-waves dis ussed a few months earlier in de Broglie's `Stru ture' paper.a (The a De Broglie did not identify the photoni pilot wave with the ele tromagneti eld. In the general dis ussion, on p. 509, de Broglie expli itly states that in his theory the wave Ψ for the ase of photons is distin t from the ele tromagneti eld. a It might be thought that here de Broglie has in mind the fa t that N moving parti les may be asso iated with N velo ity elds in 3-spa e, whi h may be asso iated with N (non-singular) guiding waves in 3-spa e. From a pilot-wave perspe tive, su h N guiding waves may be identied with the N ` onditional' wave
80
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
propagation of ea h wave must depend on the motion of the other N − 1 parti les, of ourse, in order to a
ount for intera tions between the parti les.) As we saw above (se tion 2.3.1), in `Stru ture' de Broglie expli itly onsidered the ase of two parti les, whi h were represented by two singular waves u1 (x, t) and u2 (x, t) satisfying a pair of oupled partial dierential equations (61), where the equation for ea h wave
ontained a potential depending on the position of the singularity in the other wave. Instead of trying to solve the equations, de Broglie assumed that the resulting velo ities of the moving singularities ould be written as the gradient of a fun tion φ(x1 , x2 ), whi h ould be identied with the phase of a solution Ψ(x1 , x2 , t) of the (time-independent) S hrödinger equation. In `Stru ture', then, the wave fun tion in onguration spa e appeared as an ee tive des ription of the motions of the parti les (or singularities). An e ho of this view is dis ernible in the Solvay report, whi h ontinues with the following justi ation for introdu ing a guiding wave in onguration spa e (p. 386): Nevertheless, if one fo usses one's attention only on the orpus les, one an represent their states by a point in onguration spa e, and one an try to relate the motion of this representative point to the propagation of a titious wave
Ψ
in onguration spa e.
De Broglie seems to be saying that, if one is on erned only with a su
in t mathemati al a
ount of parti le motion (as opposed to a physi al representation), then this an be obtained by introdu ing a guiding wave in onguration spa e. Certainly, the dynami s is mu h simpler with a single, autonomous wave Ψ in onguration spa e. As in his `Stru ture' paper, this seems to be de Broglie's explanation for S hrödinger's otherwise mysterious onguration-spa e wave. When de Broglie states that the wave Ψ is ` titious', he presumably means that it has only mathemati al, and not physi al, signi an e.a It provides a onvenient mathemati al a
ount of parti le motion, pending fun tions ψi (xi , t) ≡ Ψ(X1 , X2 , ..., xi , ..., XN , t), where xi (i = 1, 2, ..., N ) ranges over all positions in 3-spa e and Xj is the a tual position of the j th parti le. Ea h ψi (xi , t) denes a wave in 3-spa e that determines the velo ity of the ith parti le (through the gradient of its phase); and ea h ψi (xi , t) depends on the positions of the other N − 1 parti les. However, given the ontext (in parti ular the re ent publi ation of `Stru ture'), it seems lear that here de Broglie's N waves are the singular u-waves of his double-solution theory. a This is somewhat in ontrast with de Broglie's introdu tion of the pilot wave at the end of `Stru ture', where he refers to the parti le and the guiding wave as `distin t realities'. However, there de Broglie expli itly proposed pilot-wave theory for a single parti le only, and it is likely that while he was omfortable with the idea of a physi ally real pilot wave in 3-spa e (for the one-body ase), he ould not regard a pilot wave in onguration spa e as having more than mathemati al signi an e.
2.4 1927 Solvay report: the new dynami s of quanta
81
a full physi al des ription by a more detailed theory. As we dis ussed in se tion 2.3.2, the provisional introdu tion of a `mathemati al' des ription, pending the development of a proper `physi al' model, has distinguished pre edents in the history of Newtonian gravity and Maxwellian ele trodynami s. Having motivated the introdu tion of a guiding wave Ψ in onguration spa e, de Broglie suggests (p. 386) that Ψ ....
plays for the representative point of the system in onguration spa e
the same role of pilot wave and of probability wave that the wave
Ψ
plays in
ordinary spa e in the ase of a single material point.
Thus, in the nonrelativisti approximation, de Broglie onsiders N parti les with positions x1 , x2 , ..., xN . He states that the wave Ψ determines the velo ity of the representative point in onguration spa e by the formula 1 vk = − (76) ∇k φ mk (where mk is the mass of the k th parti le). As in the ase of a single parti le, notes de Broglie, the probability for the system to be present in a volume element dτ of onguration spa e is πdτ = const · a2 dτ .
(77)
These are the standard pilot-wave equations for a many-body system, repla ing the single-parti le formulas (73) and (74). De Broglie remarks that (77) seems to agree with Born's results for ele tron s attering by an atom and with Fermi's for s attering by a rotator. Finally, at the end of his se tion on the many-body ase, de Broglie notes that it seems di ult to onstru t a wave Ψ that an generate the motion of a relativisti many-body system (in ontrast with the relativisti one-body ase), a point that de Broglie had already noted in `Stru ture'. From the very beginning, then, it was re ognised that it would be di ult to formulate a fundamentally Lorentz-invariant pilotwave theory for a many-body system, a situation that persists to this day. Thus, in his report at the fth Solvay onferen e, de Broglie arrived at pilot-wave theory for a many-body system, with a guiding wave in
onguration spa e. Judging by de Broglie's omments about a physi al representation requiring N waves in 3-spa e, and his hara terisation of Ψ as a ` titious' wave, it seems lear that he still regarded his new
82
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
dynami s as an ee tive, mathemati al theory only (just as he had a few months earlier in his `Stru ture' paper). De Broglie's report then moves on to sket h some appli ations to atomi theory. For stationary states of hydrogen, de Broglie notes that the ele tron motion is ir ular, ex ept in the ase of magneti quantum number m = 0 for whi h the ele tron is at rest. (Note that de Broglie expresses no on ern that the ele tron is predi ted to be motionless in the ground state of hydrogen. This result may seem puzzling lassi ally, just as Bohr's quantised atomi orbits seem puzzling lassi ally: but both are natural onsequen es of de Broglie's non- lassi al dynami s.) De Broglie also points out that one an al ulate the ele tron velo ity during an atomi transition i → j , so that su h transitions an be visualised. In this example, de Broglie's guiding wave is a solution of the time-dependent S hrödinger equation, with a time-dependent amplitude as well as phase. (The atomi wave fun tion is taken to have the form Ψ = ci Ψi + cj Ψj , where Ψi , Ψj are eigenfun tions orresponding to the atomi states i, j , and ci , cj are fun tions of time.) Clearly, then, de Broglie applied his pilot-wave dynami s not just to stationary states, but to quite general wave fun tions as he had also done (in the ase of a single parti le) in `Stru ture'. De Broglie then outlines how, in his theory, one an obtain expressions for the mean harge and urrent density for an ensemble of atoms. These expressions are the same as those used by S hrödinger and others. De Broglie remarks that, `denoting by Ψ the wave written in omplex form, and by [Ψ∗ ℄ the onjugate fun tion', in the nonrelativisti limit the
harge density is proportional to |Ψ|2 : the ele tri dipole moment then
ontains the orre t transition frequen ies. By using these expressions as sour es in Maxwell's equations, says de Broglie, one an orre tly predi t the mean energy radiated by an atom. This is just semi lassi al radiation theory, whi h is still widely used today in quantum opti s.a Part II of de Broglie's report ends with some general remarks. First and foremost, de Broglie makes it lear that he regards pilot-wave theory as only provisional (p. 390): So far we have onsidered the orpus les as `exterior' to the wave motion being only determined by the propagation of the wave.
Ψ,
their
This is, no
doubt, only a provisional point of view: a true theory of the atomi stru ture of matter and radiation should, it seems to us,
in orporate
the orpus les in
the wave phenomenon by onsidering singular solutions of the wave equations.
a Cf. se tion 4.4.
2.4 1927 Solvay report: the new dynami s of quanta
83
De Broglie goes on to suggest that in a deeper theory one ould `show that there exists a orresponden e between the singular waves and the waves Ψ, su h that the motion of the singularities is onne ted to the propagation of the waves Ψ', just as he had suggested in `Stru ture'. Part II ends by noting the in omplete state of the theory with respe t to the ele tromagneti eld and ele tron spin. De Broglie's nal part III ontains a lengthy dis ussion and review of re ent experiments involving the dira tion, interferen e and s attering of ele trons (as had been requested by Lorentz4 ). He regards the results as eviden e for his `new Dynami s'. For the ase of the dira tion of ele trons by a rystal latti e, de Broglie points out that the s attered wave fun tion Ψ has maxima in ertain dire tions, and notes that a
ording to his theory the ele trons should be preferentially s attered in these dire tions (p. 392): Be ause of the role of pilot wave played by the wave
Ψ,
one must then observe
a sele tive s attering of the ele trons in these dire tions.
What de Broglie is (briey) des ribing here is the separation of the in ident wave fun tion Ψ into distin t (non-overlapping) emerging beams, with ea h outgoing ele tron o
upying one beam, and with an ensemble of ele trons being distributed among the emerging beams a
ording to the Born rule. This is relevant to a proper understanding of the de Broglie-Pauli en ounter, dis ussed in se tion 10.2. Con erning the s attering maxima observed re ently by Davisson and Germer, for ele trons in ident on a rystal, de Broglie remarks (p. 395): There is dire t numeri al onrmation of the formulas of the new Dynami s .... .
De Broglie also dis usses the inelasti s attering of ele trons by atoms. A
ording to Born's al ulations, one should observe maxima and minima in the angular dependen e of the dierential s attering ross se tion. A
ording to de Broglie, it is premature to speak of an agreement with experiment. The results of Dymond, for the inelasti s attering of ele trons by helium atoms, do however show maxima in the ross se tion, in qualitative agreement with the predi tions. De Broglie makes it quite
lear that, at the time, theory was far behind experiment. The dis ussion following de Broglie's report was extensive, detailed, and varied. A number of parti ipants raised queries, and de Broglie replied to most of them. Some of this dis ussion will be onsidered in
84
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
detail in hapters 10 and 11. Here, we limit ourselves to a brief summary of the questions raised. Lorentz asked how, in the simple pilot-wave theory of 1924, de Broglie derived quantisation onditions for the ase of multiperiodi atomi orbits. Born questioned the validity of de Broglie's guidan e equation for an elasti ollision, while Pauli suggested that the key idea behind de Broglie's theory was the asso iation of parti le traje tories with a lo ally
onserved urrent. S hrödinger raised the question of an alternative velo ity eld dierent from that assumed by de Broglie, while Kramers raised the question of how the Maxwell energy-momentum tensor ould arise from independently moving photons. Lorentz, Ehrenfest and S hrödinger asked about the properties of ele tron orbits in hydrogen. Brillouin dis ussed at length the simple example of a photon olliding with a mirror: in his Fig. 2, the in ident and emergent photon traje tories are lo ated inside pa kets of limited extent (a point relevant for the de Broglie-Pauli en ounter in the general dis ussion). Finally, Lorentz
onsidered, in lassi al Maxwell theory, the near-eld attra tive stress between two prisms, and laimed that this `negative pressure' ould not be produ ed by the motion of orpus les (photons).
2.5 Signi an e of de Broglie's work from 1923 to 1927 In his papers and thesis of 192324, de Broglie proposed a simple form of a new, non- lassi al dynami s of parti les with velo ities determined by the phase gradient of abstra t waves in 3-spa e. De Broglie onstru ted the dynami s in su h a way as to unify the me hani al prin iple of Maupertuis with the opti al prin iple of Fermat. He showed that it gave an a
ount of some simple quantum phenomena, in luding single-parti le interferen e and quantised atomi energy levels. As we have seen, the s ope and ambition of de Broglie's do toral thesis went far beyond a mere extension of the relations E = hν , p = h/λ from photons to other parti les. Yet, the thesis is usually remembered solely for this idea. The depth and inner logi of de Broglie's thinking is not usually appre iated, neither by physi ists nor by historians. An ex eption is Darrigol (1993), who on this very point writes (pp. 3034): For one who only knows of de Broglie's relation
λ = h/p,
two explanations
of his originality oer themselves. The rst has him as a lu ky dreamer who hit upon a great idea amidst a foolish play with analogies and formulas. The se ond has him a providential deep thinker, who dedu ed unsuspe ted onne tions by rationally ombining distant on epts. The rst explanation is the
2.5 Signi an e of de Broglie's work from 1923 to 1927
85
most popular, though rarely expressed in print. .... The se ond explanation of Louis de Broglie's originality, though also extreme, is ertainly loser to the truth. Anyone who has read de Broglie's thesis annot help admiring the unity and inner onsisten y of his views, the inspired use of general prin iples, and a ne essary reserve.
In 1926, starting from de Broglie's expressions for the frequen y and phase velo ity of an ele tron wave in an external potential, S hrödinger found the (nonrelativisti ) wave equation for de Broglie's waves. It was de Broglie's work, beginning in 1923, that initiated the notion of a wave fun tion for material parti les. And it was de Broglie's view of the signi an e of the opti al-me hani al analogy, and of the role waves
ould play in bringing about the existen e of integer-valued quantum numbers, that formed the basis for S hrödinger's development of the wave equation and the asso iated eigenvalue problem. In 1927, de Broglie proposed what we now know as pilot-wave or de Broglian dynami s for a many-body system, with a guiding wave in
onguration spa e. De Broglie regarded this theory as provisional: he thought it should emerge as an ee tive theory, from a more fundamental theory in whi h parti les are represented by singularities of 3-spa e waves. Even so, he did propose the theory, in the rst-order form most
ommonly used today. Further, as we have seen, de Broglie's view of the pilot wave as merely phenomenologi al is strikingly reminis ent of (for example) late-nineteenth- entury views of the ele tromagneti eld. In retrospe t, one may regard de Broglie as having unwittingly arrived at a new and fundamental on ept, that of a pilot wave in onguration spa e. De Broglie was unable to show that his new dynami s a
ounted for all quantum phenomena. In parti ular, as we shall dis uss in hapters 10 and 11, de Broglie did not understand how to des ribe the pro ess of measurement of arbitrary quantum observables in pilot-wave theory: as shown in detail by Bohm in 1952, this requires an appli ation of de Broglie's dynami s to the measuring devi e itself. De Broglie did, however, possess the fundamental dynami s in omplete form. Furthermore, de Broglie did understand how his theory a
ounted for single-parti le interferen e, for the dire ted s attering asso iated with rystal dira tion, and for ele tron s attering by atoms (for the latter, see se tion 10.2). Clearly, in 1927, many appli ations of pilot-wave theory remained to be developed; just as, indeed, many appli ations of quantum theory in luding the general quantum theory of measurement remained to be developed and laried.
86
De Broglie's pilot-wave theory
In retrospe t, de Broglian dynami s seems as radi al as and indeed somewhat reminis ent of Einstein's theory of gravity. A
ording to Einstein, there is no gravitational for e, and a freely falling body follows the straightest path in a urved spa etime. A
ording to de Broglie, a massive body undergoing dira tion and following a urvilinear path is not a ted upon by a Newtonian for e: it is following the ray of a guiding wave. De Broglie's abandonment of Newton's rst law of motion in 1923, and the adoption of a dynami s based on velo ity rather than a
eleration, amounts to a far-rea hing departure from lassi al me hani s and (arguably) from lassi al kinemati s too with impli ations for the stru ture of spa etime that have perhaps not been understood (Valentini 1997). Certainly, the extent to whi h de Broglie's dynami s departs from
lassi al ideas was unfortunately obs ured by Bohm's presentation of it, in 1952, in terms of a
eleration and a pseudo-Newtonian quantum potential, a formulation that today seems arti ial and inelegant ompared with de Broglie's (mu h as the rewriting of general relativity as a eld theory on at spa etime seems unnatural and hardly illuminating). The fundamentally se ond-order nature of lassi al physi s is today embodied in the formalism of Hamiltonian dynami s in phase spa e. In ontrast, de Broglie's rst-order approa h to the theory of motion seems more naturally ast in terms of a dynami s in onguration spa e. Regardless of how one may wish to interpret it, by any standards de Broglie's work from 1923 to 1927 shows a remarkable progression of thought, beginning from early intuitions and simple models of the relationship between parti les and waves, and ending (with S hrödinger's help) with a omplete and new form of dynami s for nonrelativisti systems a deterministi dynami s that was later shown by Bohm to be empiri ally equivalent to quantum theory (given a Born-rule distribution of initial parti le positions). The inner logi of de Broglie's work in this period, his drive to unite the physi s of parti les with the physi s of waves by unifying the prin iples of Maupertuis and Fermat, his wave-like explanation for quantised energy levels, his predi tion of ele tron dira tion, his explanation for single-parti le interferen e, his attempts to onstru t a eld-theoreti al pi ture of parti les as moving singularities, and his eventual proposal of pilot-wave dynami s as a provisional theory all this ompels admiration, all the more for being largely unknown and unappre iated. Today, pilot-wave theory is often hara terised as simply adding parti le traje tories to the S hrödinger equation. An understanding of de Broglie's thought from 1923 to 1927, and of the role it played in
2.5 Signi an e of de Broglie's work from 1923 to 1927
87
S hrödinger's work, shows the gross ina
ura y of this hara terisation: after all, it was a tually S hrödinger who removed the traje tories from de Broglie's theory ( f. se tion 11.1). It is di ult to avoid the on lusion that de Broglie's stature as a major ontributor to quantum theory has suered unduly from the ir umstan e that, for most of the twentieth entury, the theory proposed by him was in orre tly regarded as untenable or in onsistent with experiment. Regardless of whether or not de Broglie's pilot-wave theory is loser to the truth than other interpretations, the fa t that it is a onsistent and viable approa h to quantum physi s whi h has no measurement problem, whi h shows that obje tivity and determinism are not in ompatible with quantum physi s, and whi h stimulated Bell to develop his famous inequalities ne essarily entails a reappraisal of de Broglie's pla e in the history of twentieth- entury physi s.
88
Notes to pp. 3183
Ar hival notes 1 AHQP-OHI, Louis de Broglie, `Replies to Mr Kuhn's questions'. 2 AHQP-OHI, Louis de Broglie, session 1 (tape 43a), 7 January 1963, Paris; 0.75 h, in Fren h, 13 pp.; by T. S. Kuhn, T. Kahan and A. George.
3
Ibid.
4 Cf. de Broglie to Lorentz, 27 June 1927, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in Fren h).
3 From matrix me hani s to quantum me hani s
The report by Born and Heisenberg on `quantum me hani s' may seem surprisingly di ult to the modern reader. This is partly be ause Born and Heisenberg are des ribing various stages of development of the theory that are quite dierent from today's quantum me hani s. Among these, it should be noted in parti ular that the theory developed by Heisenberg, Born and Jordan in the years 192526 and known today as matrix me hani s (Heisenberg 1925b [1℄, Born and Jordan 1925 [2℄, Born, Heisenberg and Jordan 1926 [4℄)a diers from standard quantum me hani s in several important respe ts. At the same time, the interpretation of the theory (the topi of se tion II of the report) also appears to have undergone important modi ations, in parti ular regarding the notion of the state of a system. Initially, Born and Heisenberg insist on the notion that a system is always in a stationary state (performing quantum jumps between dierent stationary states). Then the notion of the wave fun tion is introdu ed and related to probabilities for the stationary states. At a later stage probabilisti notions (in parti ular, what one now alls transition probabilities) are extended to arbitrary observables, but it remains somewhat un lear whether the wave fun tion itself should be regarded as a fundamental entity or merely as an ee tive one. This may ree t the dierent routes followed by Born and by Heisenberg in the development of their ideas. The ommon position presented by Born and Heisenberg emphasises the probabilisti aspe t of the theory as fundamental, and the on lusion of the report expresses strong onden e in the resulting pi ture. The two main se tions of this hapter, se tion 3.3 and se tion 3.4, will be devoted, respe tively, to providing more details on the various a Throughout this hapter, numbers in square bra kets refer to entries in the original bibliography at the end of Born and Heisenberg's report.
89
90
From matrix to quantum me hani s
stages of development of the theory, and to disentangling various threads of interpretation that appear to be present in Born and Heisenberg's report. Before that, we provide a summary (se tion 3.1) and a few remarks on the authorship and writing of the various se tions of the report (se tion 3.2).
3.1 Summary of Born and Heisenberg's report Born and Heisenberg's report has four se tions (together with an introdu tion and on lusion): I on formalism, II on interpretation, III on axiomati formulations and on un ertainty, and IV on appli ations. The formalism that is des ribed is initially that of matrix me hani s, whi h is then extended beyond the original framework (among other things, in order to make the onne tion with S hrödinger's wave me hani s). Then, further developments of matrix me hani s are sket hed. These allow one to in orporate a `statisti al' interpretation. After a brief dis ussion of Jordan's (1927b, [39℄) axiomati formulation, the un ertainty relations are used to justify the statisti al element of the interpretation. A few appli ations of spe ial interest and some brief nal remarks on lude the report. As we dis uss below, Born drafted se tions I and II, and Heisenberg drafted the introdu tion, se tions III and IV and the on lusion. Born and Heisenberg's introdu tion stresses the ontinuity of quantum me hani s with the old quantum theory of Plan k, Einstein and Bohr, and tou hes briey on su h themes as dis ontinuity, observability in prin iple, `Ans hauli hkeit' (for whi h see se tion 4.6 below) and the statisti al element in quantum me hani s. Se tion I, `The mathemati al methods of quantum me hani s', rst sket hes matrix me hani s roughly as developed in the `three-man paper' by Born, Heisenberg and Jordan (1926 [4℄): the basi framework of position and momentum matri es and of the anoni al equations, the perturbation theory, and the onne tion with the theory of quadrati forms (the latter leading to both dis rete and ontinuous spe tra).a Next, Born and Heisenberg des ribe two generalisations of matrix me hani s: Dira 's (1926a [7℄) q-number theory and what they refer to as Born and Wiener's (1926a [21℄, 1926b) operator al ulus. As a a Note that Born and Heisenberg use the term `quantum me hani s' to refer also to matrix me hani s, in keeping with the terminology of the original papers. See also Mehra and Re henberg (1982 , fn. 72 on pp. 612). Heisenberg expresses his dislike for the term `matrix physi s' in Heisenberg to Pauli, 16 November 1925 (Pauli, 1979, pp. 2556).
3.1 Summary of Born and Heisenberg's report
91
matter of fa t, they already sket h von Neumann's representation of physi al quantities by operators in Hilbert spa e. This is identied as a mathemati ally rigorous version of the transformation theory of Dira (1927a [38℄) and Jordan (1927b, [39℄).a Born and Heisenberg note that, if one takes as the Hilbert spa e the appropriate fun tion spa e, the problem of diagonalising the Hamiltonian operator leads to the timeindependent S hrödinger equation. Thus, in this (formal) sense, the S hrödinger theory is a spe ial ase of the operator version of quantum me hani s. The eigenfun tions of the Hamiltonian an be asso iated with the unitary transformation that diagonalises it. Matrix me hani s, too, is a spe ial ase of this more general formalism, if one takes the (dis rete) energy eigenstates as the basis for the matrix representation. Se tion II on `Physi al interpretation' is probably the most striking. It begins by stating that matrix me hani s des ribes neither the a tual state of a system, nor when hanges in the a tual state take pla e, suggesting that this is related to the idea that matrix me hani s des ribes only losed systems. In order to obtain some des ription of
hange, one must onsider open systems. Two methods for doing this are introdu ed. First of all, following Heisenberg (1926b [35℄) and Jordan (1927a [36℄), one an onsider the matrix me hani al des ription of two oupled systems that are in resonan e. One an show that the resulting des ription an be interpreted in terms of quantum jumps between the energy levels of the two systems, with an expli it expression for the transition probabilities. The se ond method uses the generalised formalism of se tion I, in whi h time dependen e an be introdu ed expli itly via the time-dependent S hrödinger equation. Again, expressions an be found that an be interpreted as transition probabilities, and similarly the squared modulus of the wave fun tion's oe ients in the energy basis is interpreted as the probability for the o
urren e of the orresponding stationary state. Born and Heisenberg introdu e the notion of interferen e of probabilities. Only at this stage are experiments mentioned as playing a on eptually ru ial role, namely in an argument why su h interferen e `does not represent a ontradi tion with the rules of the probability al ulus' (p. 425). Interferen e is then related to the wave theory of de Broglie and S hrödinger, and the interpretation of a See below, se tions 3.3.3 and 3.4.1, for some dis ussion of Born and Wiener's work, and se tion 3.4.5 for the transformation theory (mainly Dira 's). Note that von Neumann had published a series of papers on the Hilbert-spa e formulation of quantum me hani s before his well-known treatise of 1932. It is to two of these that Born and Heisenberg refer, Hilbert, von Neumann and Nordheim (1928 [41℄, submitted April 1927) and von Neumann (1927 [42℄).
92
From matrix to quantum me hani s
the squared modulus of the wave fun tion as a probability density for position is introdu ed. Born and Heisenberg also dene the `relative' (i.e. onditional) position density given an energy value, as the squared modulus of the amplitude of a stationary state. Finally, in the ontext of Dira 's and Jordan's transformation theory, the notions of transition probability (for a single quantity) and of onditional probability (for a pair of quantities) are generalised to arbitrary physi al quantities. Se tion III opens with a on ise exposition of Jordan's (1927b, [39℄) axioms for quantum me hani s, whi h take the notion of probability amplitude as primary. Born and Heisenberg point out some formal drawba ks, su h as the use of δ -fun tions and the presen e of unobservable phases in the probability amplitudes. They note that su h drawba ks have been over ome by the formulation of von Neumann (whi h they do not go on to dis uss further). Born and Heisenberg then pro eed to dis uss in parti ular whether the statisti al element in the theory an be re on iled with ma ros opi determinism. To this ee t they rst justify the ne essity of using probabilisti notions by appeal to the notion of un ertainty (dis ussed using the example of dira tion of light by a single slit); then they point out that, while for instan e in ases of dira tion the laws of propagation of the probabilities in quantum me hani s are very dierent from the lassi al evolution of a probability density, there are ases where the two oin ide to a very good approximation; they write that this justies the lassi al treatment of α- and β -parti les in a
loud hamber. Se tion IV dis usses briey some appli ations, hosen for their ` lose relation to questions of prin iple' (p. 434). Mostly, these appli ations highlight the importan e of the generalised formalism (introdu ed in se tion I), by going beyond matrix me hani s proper or wave me hani s proper. The rst example is that of spin, whi h, requiring nite matri es, is taken to be a problemati on ept for wave me hani s (but not for matrix me hani s). The main example is given by the dis ussion of identi al parti les, the Pauli prin iple and quantum statisti s. Born and Heisenberg note that the hoi e of whether the wave fun tion should be symmetri or antisymmetri appears to be arbitrary. They note, moreover, that the appropriate hoi e arises naturally if one quantises the normal modes of a bla k body, leading to Bose-Einstein statisti s, or, if one adopts Jordan's (1927d [54℄) quantisation pro edure, to FermiDira statisti s.a Finally, Born and Heisenberg omment on Dira 's a The general dis ussion returns to these issues in more detail; see for instan e Dira 's riti al remarks on Jordan's pro edure, p. 502.
3.2 Writing of the report
93
quantum ele trodynami s (Dira 1927b, [51,52℄), noting in parti ular that it yields the transition probabilities for spontaneous emission. The on lusion dis usses quantum me hani s as a ` losed theory' (see se tion 3.4.7 below) and addresses the question of whether indeterminism in quantum me hani s is fundamental. In parti ular, Born and Heisenberg state that the assumption of indeterminism agrees with experien e and that the treatment of ele trodynami s will not modify this state of aairs. They on lude by noting that the existing problems
on ern rather the development of a fully relativisti theory of quantum ele trodynami s, but that there is progress also in this dire tion. The dis ussion is omparatively brief. Dira des ribes the analogy between the matrix method and the Hamilton-Ja obi theory. Then Lorentz makes a few remarks, in parti ular emphasising that the freedom to hoose the phases in the matri es q and p, (2) and (5) below, is not limited to a dierent hoi e of the time origin, a possibility already noted by Heisenberg (1925b [1℄), but extends to arbitrary phase fa tors of the form ei(δm −δn ) , as noted by Born and Jordan (1925 [2℄).a A
ording to Lorentz, this fa t suggests that the `true os illators' are asso iated with the dierent stationary states rather than with the spe tral frequen ies.1 The last few and brief ontributions address the question of the phases.b
3.2 Writing of the report The respe tive ontributions by Born and by Heisenberg to the report be ome lear from their orresponden e with Lorentz. As mentioned in
hapter 1, Lorentz had originally planned to have a report on quantum me hani s from either Born or Heisenberg, leaving to them the hoi e of who was to write it. In reply, Born and Heisenberg suggested that they would provide a joint report.2 Heisenberg was going to visit Born in Göttingen in early July 1927, on whi h o
asion they would de ide on the stru ture of the report and divide up the work, planning to meet again in August to nish it. The report (as requested by Lorentz) would in lude the results by Dira , who was in Göttingen at the time.c As a This orresponds of ourse to the hoi e of a phase fa tor for ea h energy state. b As mentioned in footnote on p. 23, Bohr suggested to omit this entire dis ussion from the published pro eedings.
Dira was in Göttingen from February 1927 to the end of June, after having spent September to February in Copenhagen. Dira 's paper on transformation theory (1927a [38℄) and his paper on emission and absorption (Dira 1927b [51℄) were written in Copenhagen, while the paper on dispersion (Dira 1927 [52℄) was written in Göttingen. Compare Kragh (1990, h. 2. pp. 37 .).
94
From matrix to quantum me hani s
Born explains, the report would `above all emphasise the viewpoints that are presumably taken less into a
ount by S hrödinger, namely the statisti al on eption of quantum me hani s'. Either author, or both, ould orally present the report at the onferen e (Heisenberg, in a parallel letter, suggested that Born should be the appropriate hoi e, sin e he was the senior s ientist3 ); Born and Heisenberg ould also give additional explanations in English. Born did not speak Fren h, nor (Born thought) did Heisenberg. In a later letter,4 Born reports that Heisenberg had sent him at the end of July the draft of introdu tion, on lusion and se tions III and IV, upon whi h Born had written se tions I and II, reworked Heisenberg's draft, and sent everything ba k to Heisenberg. Heisenberg in turn had made some further small hanges. Due to illness and a small operation, Born had been unable to go to Muni h in mid-August, so that he had not seen the hanges. He trusted, however, that he would agree with the details of Heisenberg's nal version.a Born also mentions that Heisenberg and himself would like to go through the text again, at least at proof stage.b The presentation would be split between Born (introdu tion and se tions I and II) and Heisenberg (se tions III and IV and on lusion). Born on ludes with the following words: `It would be parti ularly important for us to ome to an agreement with S hrödinger regarding the physi al interpretation of the quantum formalisms'.
3.3 Formalism
3.3.1 Before matrix me hani s In the old Bohr-Sommerfeld theory, ele tron orbits are des ribed as
lassi al Kepler orbits subje t to additional onstraints (the `quantum
onditions'), yielding dis rete stationary states. Su h a pro edure, in Born and Heisenberg's introdu tion, is riti ised as arti ial.c An atom is assumed to `jump' between its various stationary states, and energy dieren es between stationary states are related to the spe tral frequen ies via Bohr's frequen y ondition. Spe tral frequen ies and a Heisenberg had sent the nal text to Lorentz on 24 August.5 b The published version and the types ript show only minor dis repan ies, and many of these are learly mistakes in the published version (detailed in our endnotes to the report). This and the fa t that Born and Heisenberg appear not to have spoken Fren h suggests that there was in fa t no proofreading on their part.
The remark is rather brief, but note that Born and Heisenberg seem to onsider the introdu tion of photons into the lassi al ele tromagneti theory (a orpus ular dis ontinuity) to be as arti ial as the introdu tion of dis rete stationary states into lassi al me hani s.
3.3 Formalism
95
orbital frequen ies, however, appear to be quite unrelated. This is the
ru ial `radiation problem' of the old quantum theory (see also below, se tion 4.4). The BKS theory of radiationa in ludes a rather dierent pi ture of the atom, and arguably provides a solution to the radiation problem just mentioned. In the BKS theory, one asso iates to ea h atom a set of `virtual' os illators, with frequen ies equal to the spe tral frequen ies. Spe i ally, when the atom is in the stationary state n, the os illators that are ex ited are those with frequen ies orresponding to transitions from the energy En to both lower and higher energy levels. These os illators produ e a virtual radiation eld, whi h propagates ( lassi ally) a
ording to Maxwell's equations and intera ts (non- lassi ally) with the virtual os illators, in parti ular inuen ing the probabilities for indu ed emission and absorption in other atoms and determining the probabilities for spontaneous emission in the atom itself. The a tual emission or absorption of energy is asso iated with the orresponding transition between stationary states. Note that an emission in one atom is not onne ted dire tly to an absorption in another, so that energy and momentum are onserved only statisti ally. Several important results derived by developing orresponden e arguments into translation rules from lassi al to quantum expressions were formulated within the ontext of the BKS theory, in parti ular Kramers' (1924) dispersion theory. Other examples were Born's (1924) perturbation formula, Kramers and Heisenberg's (1925) joint paper on dispersion and Heisenberg's (1925a) paper on polarisation of uores en e radiation.b The same arguments also led to a natural reformulation of the quantum onditions independent of the old ` lassi al models' (Kuhn 1925, Thomas 1925). As rst argued by Pauli (1925), su h results were entirely independent of the presumed me hanism of radiation.c Indeed, after the demise of the BKS theory following the experimental veri ation of the onservation laws in the Bothe-Geiger experiments, these results and the orresponding te hniques of symboli translation formed the basis for Heisenberg's formulation of matrix me hani s in his famous paper of 1925 (Heisenberg 1925b [1℄). Heisenberg's stroke of genius was to give up altogether the kinemati al des ription in terms of spatial oordinates, while retaining the lassi al form of the equations a See also the des ription in se tion 1.3. b See Darrigol (1992, pp. 22446) and Mehra and Re henberg (1982b, se tions III.4 and III.5).
Cf. Darrigol (1992, pp. 2445). Cf. also Jordan (1927e [63℄), among others.
96
From matrix to quantum me hani s
of motion, to be solved under suitably reformulated quantum onditions (those of Kuhn and Thomas). While Heisenberg had dropped both the me hanism of radiation and the older ele troni orbits, there were points of ontinuity with the BKS theory and with the old quantum theory; in parti ular, as we shall see, the new variables were at least formally related to the virtual os illators, and the pi ture of quantum jumps was retained, at least for the time being.
3.3.2 Matrix me hani s Heisenberg's original paper is rather dierent from the more denitive presentations of matrix me hani s: the equations are given in Newtonian (not Hamiltonian) form, energy onservation is not established to all orders, and, as is well known, Heisenberg at rst had not re ognised that his theory used the mathemati al ma hinery of matri es. Like Born and Heisenberg in their report, we shall a
ordingly follow in this se tion mainly the papers by Born and Jordan (1925 [2℄) and Born, Heisenberg and Jordan (1926 [4℄), as well as the book by Born (1926d,e [58℄), supplementing the report with more details when useful. Kinemati ally, the des ription of `motion' in matrix me hani s generalises that given by the set of the omponents of a lassi al Fourier series, qn e2πinνt
(1)
(and thus generalises the idea of a periodi motion). As frequen ies, one
hooses, instead of ν(n) = nν , the transition frequen ies of the system under onsideration, whi h are required to obey Ritz's ombination prin iple, νij = Ti − Tj (relating the frequen ies to the spe tros opi terms Ti = Ei /h, or, in Born and Heisenberg's notation, Ti = Wi /h). The omponents thus dened form a doubly innite array: q11 e2πiν11 t q12 e2πiν12 t . . . 2πiν21 t q22 e2πiν22 t . . . q = q21 e (2) . .. .. .. . . .
From the ombination prin iple for the νij , it follows that νij = −νji . Further, it is required of the (generally omplex) amplitudes that ∗ qji = qij ,
(3)
by analogy with a lassi al Fourier series, so that the array is in fa t a Hermitian matrix.
3.3 Formalism
97
In modern notation, the above matrix onsists of the elements of the position observable (in Heisenberg pi ture) in the energy basis. For a
losed system with Hamiltonian H , these indeed take the form hEi | Q(t) |Ej i = hEi | e(i/~)Ht Q(0)e−(i/~)Ht |Ej i = hEi | Q(0) |Ej i e(i/~)(Ei −Ej )t .
(4)
Along with the position matrix q , one onsiders also a momentum matrix: p11 e2πiν11 t p12 e2πiν12 t . . . 2πiν21 t p22 e2πiν22 t . . . p = p21 e (5) , .. .. .. . . .
as well as all other matrix quantities that an be obtained as fun tions of q and p, dened as polynomials or as power series (leaving aside questions of onvergen e). Again from the ombination prin iple, it follows that under multipli ation of two su h matri es, one obtains another matrix of the same form (i.e. with the same time-dependent phases). Thus one justies taking these two-dimensional arrays as matri es. The most general physi al quantity in matrix me hani s is a matrix whose elements (in modern terminology) are the elements of an arbitrary Heisenbergpi ture observable in the energy basis. The values of these matri es (in parti ular the amplitudes qij and the frequen ies νij ) will have to be determined by solving the equations of motion under some suitable quantum onditions. Spe i ally, the equations of motion are postulated to be the analogues of the lassi al Hamiltonian equations: dq ∂H = , dt ∂p
dp ∂H =− , dt ∂q
(6)
where H is a suitable matrix fun tion of q and p. The quantum onditions are formulated as pq − qp =
h ·1 , 2πi
(7)
where 1 is the identity matrix. In the limit of large quantum numbers, (7) orresponds to the `old' quantum onditions. Of ourse, dierentiation with respe t to t and with respe t to matrix arguments need to be suitably dened. The former is dened elementwise as (8) f˙ij = 2πiνij fij ,
98
From matrix to quantum me hani s
whi h an be written equivalently as 2πi f˙ = (9) (W f − f W ) , h where W is the diagonal matrix with Wij = Wi δij . Dierentiation with respe t to matrix arguments is dened (in slightly modernised form) as f (x + α1) − f (x) df (10) = lim , dx α→0 α where the limit is also understood elementwise.a On e the pre eding s heme has been set up, the next question is how to go about solving the equations of motion. First, for the spe ial ase of dierentiation with respe t to q or p, one shows that f q − qf =
h ∂f 2πi ∂p
(11)
pf − f p =
h ∂f 2πi ∂q
(12)
and
(by indu tion on the form of f and using (7)). From this and from (9), one an easily show that the equations of motion are equivalent to W q − qW = Hq − qH
(13)
W p − pW = Hp − pH .
(14)
and Thus, W − H ommutes with both q and p, and therefore also with H . It follows that W H − HW = 0 ,
(15)
H˙ = 0 ,
(16)
whi h by (9) means that that is, energy is onserved. In the non-degenerate ase, it follows that H is a diagonal matrix. Denoting its diagonal terms by Hi , (13) yields further the Bohr frequen y ondition, Hi − Hj = Wi − Wj = hνij ,
(17)
and xing an arbitrary onstant one an set H = W . The above proof shows also that onversely, (16), (17) and the ommutation relations a This denition was agreed upon after some debate. See Mehra and Re henberg (1982 , pp. 6971 and 97100).
3.3 Formalism
99
imply the equations of motion. Therefore, the problem of solving the equations of motion essentially redu es to that of diagonalising the energy matrix. This dis ussion leads also to the notion of a ` anoni al transformation' (a transformation that leaves the equations of motion invariant) as a transformation that preserves the ommutation relations. Obviously any transformation of the form Q = SqS −1 ,
P = SpS −1
(18)
(with S invertible) will be su h a transformation, and it was onje tured that these were the most general anoni al transformations. At this stage, S is required only to be invertible; indeed, the notion of unitarity has not been introdu ed yet. If H is a suitably symmetrised fun tion of q and p, however, it will also be a Hermitian matrix, and the problem of diagonalising it an be solved using the theory of quadrati forms of innitely many variables (assuming that the theory as known at the time extends also to unbounded quadrati forms). In parti ular, it will be possible to diagonalise H using a unitary S , whi h also guarantees that the new oordinates Q and P will be Hermitian. What does su h a solution to the equations of motion yield? In the rst pla e, one obtains the values of the frequen ies νij and of the energies Wi (along with the values of other onserved quantities). In the se ond pla e, based on orresponden e arguments, one an identify the diagonal elements of a matrix with `time average' in the respe tive stationary states,a and relate the squared amplitudes |qij |2 to the intensities of spontaneous emission, or equivalently to the orresponding transition probabilities between stationary states.b This, however, is not an argument based on rst prin iples. Indeed, as Born and Heisenberg repeatedly stress, matrix me hani s in the above form des ribes a losed,
onservative system, in whi h no hange should take pla e. As Born and Heisenberg note in se tion II, a tual transfer of energy is to be expe ted only when the atom is oupled to some other system, spe i ally the radiation eld. Born and Jordan's paper (1925 [2℄) and Born, Heisenberg and Jordan's paper (1926 [4℄) in lude a rst attempt at treating the radiation eld quantum me hani ally and at justifying the assumed interpretation of the squared amplitudes. A satisfa tory treatment of a The on ept of `time averages' an also be thought of as related to the BKS theory, as remarked by Heisenberg himself in a letter to Einstein of February 1926.6 b The determination of intensities had been a pressing problem sin e the work by Born (1924) and the `Utre ht observations' referred to in the report (p. 412). See Darrigol (1992, pp. 2345).
100
From matrix to quantum me hani s
spontaneous radiation was later given by Dira (1927b [51℄), as also mentioned in the report.a In the third pla e, by setting up relations between the amplitudes qij and the matrix elements of other onserved quantities su h as angular momentum, one is able to identify whi h transitions are possible between states with the orresponding quantum numbers (derivation of `sele tion rules'). Expe tation values, other than in the form of time averages for the stationary states, are la king. It should be lear that matrix me hani s in its histori al formulation is not to be identied with today's quantum me hani s in the Heisenberg pi ture. The matri es allowed as solutions in matrix me hani s are basis-dependent. Moreover, quite apart from the fa t that solutions to the equations of motion are hard to nd,a the results obtained are relatively modest. In parti ular, there are no general expe tation values for physi al quantities. In dis ussing both the mathemati al formalism and the physi al interpretation, Born and Heisenberg suggest that the original matrix theory is inadequate and in need of extension.
3.3.3 Formal extensions of matrix me hani s As presented in the report, the hief formal rather than interpretational di ulty for matrix me hani s is the failure to des ribe aperiodi quantities. As we have seen, the matri es were understood as a generalisation of lassi al Fourier series. Stri tly speaking, if one follows this analogy, a periodi quantity is represented by a dis rete (if doubly innite) matrix, and one an envisage representing aperiodi quantities by ontinuous matri es analogously to the representation of lassi al quantities by Fourier integrals. Indeed, already Heisenberg (1925b [1℄) points out that his quadrati arrays would have in general both a periodi part (dis rete) and an aperiodi part ( ontinuous). The onne tion between matri es and quadrati forms showed in fa t that matri es in general had also a ontinous spe trum (if the theory extended to the unbounded ase). Still, ontinuous matri es are unwieldy, and in ertain ases the matrix elements (whi h are always evaluated in the energy basis) will be ome singular, as when trying to des ribe a free parti le. (This is not at all surprising, onsidering that also in the lassi al analogy the Fourier integral of the fun tion at + b fails to onverge.) a Note that by this time Dira (1927a [38℄) had already introdu ed a probabilisti interpretation based on the transformation theory. a In parti ular, one was unable to introdu e a tion-angle variables to solve the Hamiltonian equations as in lassi al me hani s; f. Born and Heisenberg's remarks on `aperiodi motions'.
3.3 Formalism
101
This problem was addressed by generalising the notion of a matrix to that of a q-number (Dira 1926a [7℄) and to that of an operator (Born and Wiener 1926a [21℄, 1926b). Dira 's q-numbers are abstra t obje ts that are assumed to form a non ommutative algebra, while Born and Wiener's operators are hara terised not by their elements in some basis, but by their a tion on a spa e of fun tions. In both approa hes, one an deal with aperiodi quantities and quantities with a singular matrix representation. Born and Wiener's approa h is the lesser-known of the two, and shall therefore be briey sket hed.a The operators in question are linear operators a ting on a spa e of fun tions x(t) (whi h are not given any spe i physi al interpretation). These fun tions are understood as generalising the fun tions having the form x(t) =
∞ X
xn e
2πi h Wn t
.
(19)
n=1
That is, they generalise the fun tions that an be written in a Fourier-like series with frequen ies equal to the spe tral frequen ies. Therefore, the operators generalise the matri es that a t on innite-dimensional ve tors indexed by the energy values, i.e. they generalise the matri es in the energy basis. By using these operators, Born and Wiener free themselves from the need to operate with the matrix elements, and they are able to solve the equations of motion expli itly for systems more general than those treated in matrix me hani s until then. Their main example is the (aperiodi ) one-dimensional free parti le. Instead of presenting this formalism, however, in the report Born and Heisenberg present dire tly von Neumann's formalism of operators on Hilbert spa e (evidently but ta itly onsidering Born and Wiener's formalism as its natural pre ursor). They note that in this formalism it is possible to onsider matri es in arbitrary, even ontinuous bases, and they use this fa t to make the onne tion with S hrödinger's theory. In parti ular, they point out that solving the (time-independent) S hrödinger equation is equivalent to diagonalising the Hamiltonian quadrati form, in the sense that the set of S hrödinger eigenfun tions ϕ(q, W ) (wave fun tions in q indexed by W ) yields the transformation matrix S from the position basis to the energy basis. Thus one an use the familiar methods of partial dierential equations to diagonalise H .b a Born and Wiener published two very similar papers on their operator theory, one in German, referred to in the report (1926a [21℄), and one in English (1926b). b Cf. below, se tion 3.4.5. The onne tion between matrix and wave me hani s was
102
From matrix to quantum me hani s
Despite providing very useful formal extensions of matrix me hani s, the q-numbers and the operators (at least as presented in se tion I of the report) do not provide further insights into the physi al interpretation of the theory. In the following se tion II, on `Physi al interpretation', Born and Heisenberg dis uss the problem of des ribing a tual states and pro esses in matrix me hani s, suitably extended, and the surprising rami ations of this problem.
3.4 Interpretation Born and Heisenberg's se tion II begins with the following statement (p. 420): The most noti eable defe t of the original matrix me hani s onsists in the fa t that at rst it appears to give information not about a tual phenomena, but rather only about possible states and pro esses. It allows one to al ulate the possible stationary states of a system; further it makes a statement about the nature of the harmoni os illation that an manifest itself as a light wave in a quantum jump. But it says nothing about when a given state is present, or when a hange is to be expe ted.
The reason for this is lear:
matrix
me hani s deals only with losed periodi systems, and in these there are indeed no hanges. In order to have true pro esses, as long as one remains in the domain of matrix me hani s, one must dire t one's attention to a
part
of
the system; this is no longer losed and enters into intera tion with the rest of the system. The question is what matrix me hani s an tell us about this.
(This is again one of the se tions originally drafted by Born.) As raised here, the question to be addressed is how to in orporate into matrix me hani s the (a tual) state of a system, and the time development of su h a state. The dis ussion given in the report may give rise to some onfusion, be ause it arguably ontains at least two, if not three, disparate approa hes to what is a state in quantum me hani s. The rst, ree ted in the above quotation, is the idea that a state of a system is always a stationary state, whi h stems from Bohr's quantum theory and whi h appears to have lived on through the BKS phase until well into the development of matrix me hani s, indeed at least as late as Heisenberg's dis overed independently by S hrödinger (1926d), E kart (1926 [22℄) and Pauli (Pauli to Jordan, 12 April 1926, in Pauli 1979, pp. 31520). For a des ription of the various ontributions, in luding the work of Lan zos (1926 [23℄), see Mehra and Re henberg (1987, pp. 63684). Muller (1997) argues that matrix me hani s and wave me hani s, as formulated and understood at the time, were nevertheless inequivalent theories. For on rete examples in whi h the two theories were indeed
onsidered to yield dierent predi tions, see below p. 143 (in luding the footnote) and the dis ussion on p. 470.
3.4 Interpretation
103
paper on resonan e (Heisenberg 1926b [35℄). The se ond is the idea that the state of a system is given by its wave fun tion, but it is bound up with the question of whether the latter should be seen as a `spread-out' entity, a `guiding eld', a `statisti al state' or something else.a Born's papers on ollisions (Born 1926a,b [30℄) an be said to ontain elements of both these approa hes. Yet a third approa h may well be present in the report, an approa h in whi h the notion of state would be purely an ee tive one. Some pronoun ements by Heisenberg, in orresponden e and in the un ertainty paper (Heisenberg 1927 [46℄), may support this further (tentative) suggestion. It seems to us that Born and Heisenberg's statements be ome learer if one is aware of the dierent ba kgrounds to their dis ussion. A
ordingly, we shall dis uss in turn, briey, various developments that appear to have fed into their on eption of quantum me hani s, in parti ular previous work by Born and Wiener on generalising matrix me hani s (se tion 3.4.1), by Born on guiding elds (se tion 3.4.2), by Bohr as well as famously by Born on ollision pro esses (again se tion 3.4.2 and se tion 3.4.3), by Heisenberg on atoms in resonan e (se tion 3.4.4) and by Dira on the transformation theory (se tion 3.4.5). We shall then dis uss the treatment of interpretational issues given in the report in se tions 3.4.6 and 3.4.7. The latter in ludes some brief omments on the notion of a ` losed theory', whi h is prominent in some of Heisenberg's later writings (e.g. Heisenberg 1948), and whi h appears to be used here for the rst time. We do not laim to have settled the interpretational issues, and will return to several of them in Part II. Overall, the `physi al interpretation' of the report requires areful reading and assessment.
3.4.1 Matrix me hani s, Born and Wiener As we have seen, in the old quantum theory the only states allowed for atomi systems are stationary states, understood in terms of lassi al orbits subje t to the quantum onditions of Bohr and Sommerfeld. The same is true in the BKS theory, where stationary states be ome more abstra t and are represented by the olle tion of virtual os illators orresponding to the transitions of the atom from a given energy level. In both theories, dis ontinuous transitions between the stationary states, so- alled quantum jumps, are assumed to o
ur. Although in today's quantum theory one usually still talks about dis ontinuous transitions, a Cf. the next hapter.
104
From matrix to quantum me hani s
these are asso iated with the ollapse postulate and with the on ept of a measurement. The states performing these transitions are not ne essarily stationary states, i.e. eigenstates of energy (whether one des ribes them dynami ally in the S hrödinger pi ture or stati ally in the Heisenberg pi ture). This modern notion of state is strikingly absent also in matrix me hani s, as we have seen it formulated in the original papers. Indeed, the interpretation of the theory is still ostensibly in terms of stationary states and quantum jumps, but the formalism itself ontains only matri es, whi h an at most be seen as a olle tive representation of all stationary states, in the following sense. The matrix (2) in orporates the os illations orresponding to all possible transitions of the system. Ea h matrix element is formally analogous to a virtual os illator with frequen y νij = (Ei − Ej )/h ( orresponding to an atomi transition Ei → Ej ). Therefore, ea h row (or olumn) ontains all the frequen ies
orresponding to the transitions from (or to) a given energy level, mu h like a stationary state in the BKS theory. As in the above quotation, the matrix an thus be seen as the olle tive representation of all the stationary states of a losed system.a This analysis is further supported by examining Born and Wiener's work, in whi h the pi ture of stationary states as the rows of the position matrix (now the position operator) be omes even more expli it. While the fun tions x(t) remain uninterpreted, Born and Wiener appear to asso iate the `rows' or, rather, the ` olumns' of their operators with (stationary) states of motion. This is lear from the following. Born and Wiener introdu e a notion of ` olumn sum', that is, a generalisation of the sum of the elements in the olumn of a matrix. In dis ussing their main example, the free parti le, they then show that, for the position operator, this generalised olumn sum q(t, W ) takes the form s 2W + F (W ) , q(t, W ) = t (20) µ where µ is the mass of the parti le and F (W ) is a omplex-valued expression independent of t. They expli itly draw the on lusion that at least the real part of the generalised olumn sum represents a lassi al inertial motion with the energy W . a A somewhat similar idea appears to be expressed by Dira at the beginning of the dis ussion after the report (p. 442), where he emphasises the parallel between matrix me hani s and lassi al Hamiton-Ja obi theory, with the latter also des ribing not single traje tories but whole families of traje tories.
3.4 Interpretation
105
Note that this indi ates not only that Born and Wiener asso iate the state of a system with a olumn of the position operator. It also suggests that, in their view, at least a limited spatio-temporal pi ture of parti le traje tories in the absen e of intera tions is possible (analogously to the earlier limited use of spatio-temporal pi tures in des ribing atomi states in the absen e of transitions).
3.4.2 Born and Jordan on guiding elds, Bohr on ollisions The early history of the guiding eld idea, in onne tion with Einstein and with the BKS theory (in the ase of photons), and in onne tion with de Broglie (in the ase of both photons and material parti les), is dis ussed mainly in hapters 9 and 2, respe tively. Slater's original intention was in fa t to have the virtual elds to be guiding elds for the photons, whi h were to arry energy and momentum, but this aspe t was not in orporated in the BKS theory. However, after this theory was reje ted pre isely be ause of the results on energy and momentum
onservation in individual pro esses (detailed, for instan e, in Compton's report), Slater's original idea was eetingly revived. On 24 April 1925, after learning from Fran k that Bohr had in fa t given up the BKS theory, Born sent Bohr the des ription of su h a proposal (whi h, as he wrote, he had been working on for some weeks with Jordan). A manus ript by Born and Jordan followed, entitled `Zur Strahlungstheorie', whi h is found today in the Bohr ar hives. a The proposal ombines the BKS idea of emission of waves while the atom is in a stationary state with the emission of a light quantum during an instantaneous quantum jump, in order to give a spa etime pi ture of radiation. The light quantum thus follows the rear end of the wave. It
an be s attered or absorbed by other atoms (both pro esses depending on the dipole moment of the appropriate virtual os illators in the atoms), in the latter ase leaving a `dead' wave that has no further physi al ee ts. Born and Jordan had applied this pi ture with some su
ess to a few simple examples, and were intending to publish the idea in Naturwissens haften, provided Bohr or Kramers did not nd fault with it (Bohr 1984, pp. 845 and 30810). Bohr replied on 1 May, after re eipt of both the letter and the manus ript,
riti ising the proposal, on the grounds, rst, that the proposed me hanism did not guarantee that the traje tories of the light quanta would a Cf. Darrigol (1992, p. 253). We are espe ially grateful to Olivier Darrigol for helpful orresponden e on this matter.
106
From matrix to quantum me hani s
oin ide with the propagation of the wave, and se ond, that the ross se tion for the absorption ought to be a onstant in order for the parti le number density to be proportional to the intensity of the wave. Bohr reiterated the beliefs he had expressed to Fran k: that the oupling between state transitions in dierent atoms ex luded a des ription that used ans hauli h pi tures, and that he suspe ted the same on lusion to be likely in the ase of ollision phenomena (Bohr 1984, pp. 85 and 31011).a Bohr's work on ollisions, to whi h he alluded here, was an extension of the BKS idea of merely statisti al onservation laws (Bohr 1925).a The idea, as paraphrased by Born, was `to regard the eld of the parti le passing by in the same way as the eld of a light wave; thus, it only produ es a probability for the absorption of energy, and this [absorption℄ only o
urs when the ollision lasts su iently long (the parti le passes slowly)' (Born to Bohr, 15 January 1925, quoted in Bohr 1984, p. 73).b However, the Ramsauer ee t the anomalously low ross se tion of atoms of ertain gases for slow ele trons ould not be a
ommodated in Bohr's s heme. Bohr therefore was developing doubts about statisti al onservation laws (and further, about the feasibility altogether of a spa etime pi ture of ollisionsc ), even as he was submitting his paper on ollisions,d that is, even before the results of the Bothe-Geiger experiments were onrmed in April 1925. Bohr's paper was published only after Bohr in luded an addendum in July 1925, whi h draws the
onsequen es from both the Bothe-Geiger experiments and the di ulties with the Ramsauer ee t. In the same month of July, an explanation a See Bohr to Fran k, 21 April 1925, in Bohr (1984, pp. 35051). a Cf. also Darrigol (1992, pp. 24951) and pp. 8993 in Stolzenburg's introdu tion to Part I of Bohr (1984). b Another olourful paraphrase is in Bohr to Fran k, 30 Mar h 1925: `If two atoms have the possibility of settling their mutual a
ount, it is, of ourse, simplest that they do so. However, when the invoi es annot be submitted simultaneously, they must be satised with a running a
ount' (quoted in Bohr 1984, p. 74).
One of the most striking expressions of this is a passage in Bohr to Heisenberg, 18 April 1925: `Stimulated espe ially by talks with Pauli, I am for ing myself these days with all my strength to familiarise myself with the mysti ism of nature and am attempting to prepare myself for all eventualities, indeed even for the assumption of a oupling of quantum pro esses in separated atoms. However, the osts of this assumption are so great that they annot be estimated within the ordinary spa etime des ription' (Bohr 1984, pp. 36061). For other qualms about su h `quantum nonlo ality', f. also Jordan's habilitation le ture (1927f [62℄), in whi h Jordan onsiders the idea of mi ros opi indeterminism to be omprehensible only if the elementary random events are independent. (This le ture was translated into English by Oppenheimer and published in Nature as Jordan (1927g).) d The paper was re eived by Zeits hrift für Physik on 30 Mar h 1925; on that very day Bohr was expressing his doubts in a letter to Fran k (Bohr 1984, pp. 34850).
3.4 Interpretation
107
for the Ramsauer ee t was suggested by Elsasser (1925) in Göttingen, on the basis of de Broglie's matter waves.
3.4.3 Born's ollision papers The above provides a useful ba kdrop for dis ussing Born's own work on ollisions (Born 1926a,b [30℄),a whi h treats ollision problems on the basis of S hrödinger's wave me hani s.b This work also ree ts the idea that the states of a system are stationary states undergoing transitions. Indeed, Born presents the problem as that of in luding in matrix me hani s a des ription of the transitions between stationary states. The ase of ollisions, say between an atom and an ele tron, is hosen as the simplest for treating this problem (while still leading to interesting predi tions), be ause it is natural to expe t that in this ase the ombined system is asymptoti ally in a stationary state for the atom and a state of uniform translational motion for the ele tron. (Note that this is onne ted to the treatment of the free parti le by Born and Wiener.) If one an manage to des ribe the asymptoti behaviour of the ombined system mathemati ally, this will give on rete indi ations as to the transitions between the initial and nal asymptoti states. Born managed to nd the solution spe i ally by wave me hani al methods.c Note that Born onsiders two on eptually distin t obje ts, the wave fun tion on the one hand and the stationary states of the atom and the ele tron on the other, the onne tion between them being that the wave fun tion denes a probability distribution over the stationary states. (Note also that he reserves the word `state' only for the stationary states.) Born solves by perturbation methods the time-independent S hrödinger equation for the ombined system of atom and ele tron under the ondition that asymptoti ally for z → ∞, the solution has the form 2π ψn (q)e λ z (a produ t of the n-th eigenstate of the atom with a plane wave oming from the z -dire tion), with energy τ . Born's solution has a For a modern dis ussion of ollisions, f. se tion 10.1. b The Ramsauer ee t, however, is ex luded from Born's dis ussion (1926b [30℄, footnote on p. 824). A few passages might be seen to refer to Born's ex hange with Bohr, in parti ular the remark that, at the pri e of dropping ausality, the usual spa etime pi ture an be maintained (1926b [30℄, p. 826).
Cf. Born to S hrödinger, 16 May 1927: `the simple possibility of treating with it aperiodi pro esses ( ollisions) made me rst believe that your on eption was superior' (quoted in Mehra and Re henberg 2000, p. 135).
108
From matrix to quantum me hani s
the form: XZ m
τ
αx+βy+γz>0
Φτnm (α, β, γ)ψm (q)eknm (αx+βy+γz+δ) dω ,
(21)
τ equals where the energy orresponding to the wave number knm τ Enm = hνnm + τ ,
(22)
the νnm being the transition frequen ies of the atom. The omponents of the superposition an thus be asso iated with various, generally inelasti , ollisions in whi h energy is onserved, and Born interprets |Φλnm (α, β, γ)|2 as the probability for the atom to be in the stationary state m and the ele tron to be s attered in the dire tion (α, β, γ).a But now, ru ially, sin e the initial wave fun tion orresponds to a fully determined stationary state and inertial motion, this probability is also the probability for a quantum jump from the given initial state to the given nal state, i.e. a transition probability. This idea is linked to that of a guiding eld. The link is made expli itly at the beginning of Born's se ond paper (whi h in ludes the details of the derivation and some quantitative predi tions). While Born judges that in the ontext of opti s one ought to wait until the development of a proper quantum ele trodynami s, in the ontext of the quantum me hani s of material parti les the guiding eld idea an be applied already, using the de Broglie-S hrödinger waves as guiding elds. The traje tories of material parti les, however, are determined by the guiding eld merely probabilisti ally (1926b [30℄, pp. 8034). In his
on lusion, Born regards the pi ture of the guiding eld as fundamentally indeterministi . A deterministi ompletion, if possible, would not have any pra ti al use. Born also expresses the hope that the `laws of motion for light quanta' will nd a similar treatment to the one given for ele trons, and refers to the di ulties `so far' of pursuing a guiding eld approa h in opti s (pp. 8267).b a A statisti al interpretation for the modulus squared of the oe ients of the wave fun tion in the energy basis was introdu ed also by Dira (1926 [37℄), at the same time as and presumably independently of Born ( f. Darrigol 1992, p. 333). Note further that, even though it may be tempting to assume that ea h traje tory pro eeds from the s attering entre, stri tly speaking to ea h stationary state of the free parti le orresponds a whole family of inertial traje tories. (Similarly, in the ase treated by Born and Wiener, ea h generalised olumn sum asso iated with a stationary state orresponds to two dierent inertial traje tories, depending on the sign of the square root in (20).) b Born's views on quantum me hani s from this period are also presented in Born (1927), an expanded version (published Mar h 1927) of a talk given by Born in August 1926.
3.4 Interpretation
109
3.4.4 Heisenberg on energy u tuations As dis ussed in the next hapter, Heisenberg in parti ular among matrix physi ists was opposed to S hrödinger's attempt to re ast and reinterpret quantum theory on the basis of ontinuous wave fun tions. S hrödinger's wave fun tions were meant from the start as des riptions of individual states of a physi al system. Even though in general they are abstra t fun tions (on onguration spa e), they an provide a pi ture of Bohr's stationary states. Furthermore, the solution of the timedependent S hrödinger equation appears to provide a generalisation of the state of a system as it evolves in time. Heisenberg appears to have been disturbed initially also by Born's use of S hrödinger's theory in the treatment of ollisions, an attitude ree ted in parti ular in his orresponden e with Pauli.a In this onne tion, the fa t that Pauli in his letter of 19 O tober (Pauli 1979, pp. 3409) was in ee t able to sket h how one ould reinterpret Born's results in terms of matrix elements, must have been of parti ular signi an e: `Your al ulations have given me again great hope, be ause they show that Born's somewhat dogmati viewpoint of the probability waves is only one of many possible s hemes'.b A few days later, Heisenberg sent Pauli the manus ript of his paper on u tuation phenomena (Heisenberg 1926b [35℄), in whi h he developed
onsiderations similar to Pauli's in the ontext of a hara teristi example, that of two atoms in resonan e. By fo ussing on the subsystems of a losed system, Heisenberg was able to derive expressions for (transition) probabilities within matrix me hani s proper, without having to introdu e the wave fun tion as an external aid. A very similar result was derived at the same time by Jordan (1927 [36℄), using two systems with a single energy dieren e in ommon. We shall now sket h Heisenberg's reasoning. We adapt the presentation of the argument given by Heisenberg in The Physi al Prin iples of the Quantum Theory (Heisenberg 1930b, pp. 1427),c whi h is more general than the one given in the paper and learer than the one given in Born and Heisenberg's report. Take two systems, 1 and 2, that are in resonan e. Consider, to begin with, that the frequen y of the transition n1 → m1 in system a `One senten e [of Born's paper℄ reminded me vividly of a hapter in the Christian
reed: An ele tron is a plane wave... ' (Heisenberg to Pauli 28 July 1926, in Pauli 1979, p. 338, original emphasis). b Heisenberg to Pauli, 28 O tober 1926, in Pauli (1979, p. 350).
This very remarkable book is an expanded English edition of Heisenberg (1930a).
110
From matrix to quantum me hani s
1 orresponds to exa tly one transition frequen y in system 2, say ν (1) (n1 m1 ) = ν (2) (n2 m2 ) .
(23)
If the systems are un oupled, the ombined system has the degenerate eigenvalue of energy (2) (1) Wn(1) + Wm = Wm + Wn(2) . 1 2 1 2
(24)
If we ouple weakly the two systems, the degenera y will be lifted. Let us label the new eigenstates of the ombined system by a and b. We
an now onsider the matrix S that transforms the basis of eigenstates of energy of the oupled system to the (produ t) basis of eigenstates of energy of the un oupled systems. In parti ular we an onsider the submatrix Sn1 m2 ,a Sn1 m2 ,b . (25) Sn2 m1 ,a Sn2 m1 ,b Choose one of the stationary states of the ombined system, say a. If the ombined system is in the state a, what an one say about the energy of the subsystems, for instan e H (1) ? Heisenberg's answer, in the terminology and notation of his book (1930b), is that in the state a, the time average of H (1) (whi h is no longer a diagonal matrix, thus no longer time-independent), or of any fun tion f (H (1) ), is (1) f (H (1) ) = f (Wn(1) )|Sn1 m2 ,a |2 + f (Wm )|Sm1 n2 ,a |2 . 1 1
(26)
Sin e f is arbitrary, Heisenberg on ludes that |Sn1 m2 ,a |2 is the probability that the state n1 has remained the same (and the state m2 has remained the same), and |Sm1 n2 ,a |2 is the probability that the state n1 has jumped to the state m1 (and m2 has jumped to n2 ). The asso iated transfer of energy between the systems appears to be instantaneous, in that a quantum jump in one system (from a higher to a lower energy level) is a
ompanied by a orresponding jump in the other system (from a lower to a higher energy level). The paper merely mentions, without elaborating further, that a light quantum (or better a `sound quantum') is ex hanged over and over again between the two systems. The pi ture thus avoids the non- onservation of energy of the BKS theory, at the pri e of what appears to be an expli it orrelation at a distan e. In modern terms, Heisenberg has al ulated the expe tation value of
3.4 Interpretation
111
the observable f (H (1) ) ⊗ 1 in the state a: ha|f (H (1) ) ⊗ 1|ai =
ha |n1 m2 ihn1 m2 | f (H (1) ) ⊗ 1 |n1 m2 ihn1 m2 | ai+
ha |m1 n2 ihm1 n2 | f (H (1) ) ⊗ 1 |m1 n2 ihm1 n2 | ai = hn1 |f (H
(1)
hm1 |f (H
(27)
2
)|n1 i|hn1 m2 |ai| +
(1)
)|m1 i|hm1 n2 |ai|2 .
Note, however, that rather than fo ussing on the idea that |Sn1 m2 ,a |2 = |hn1 m2 |ai|2
(28)
is a onditional probability (in fa t what we would today all a transition probability), Heisenberg is still fo ussing on the transitions between the stationary states of the subsystems, as in Born's work on ollisions.
3.4.5 Transformation theory Less than three weeks after ompleting his draft on u tuation phenomena, we nd Heisenberg reporting to Pauli about Dira 's transformation theory, whi h generalises pre isely the formal expression of a onditional probability given by Heisenberg in terms of the transformation matrix: `Here [in Copenhagen℄ we have also been thinking more about the question of the meaning of the transformation fun tion S and Dira has a hieved an extraordinarily broad generalisation of this assumption from my note on u tuations' (Pauli 1979, p. 357, original emphasis). Dira indeed presents his results in his paper, signi antly titled `The physi al interpretation of quantum dynami s' (1927a [38℄), as a generalisation of Heisenberg's approa h. The main goal of the paper is the following.a Take any pair of onjugate matrix quantities ξ and η , and any ` onstant of integration' g(ξ, η).b Given a value of ξ as a -number, nd the fra tion of η -spa e for whi h g lies between any two numeri al values. If η is assumed to be distributed uniformly,c this result will yield the frequen y of the given values of g in an ensemble of systems. a In our presentation we shall partly follow the analysis by Darrigol (1992, pp. 33745). b This term is meant to in lude any value of a dynami al quantity at a spe ied time t = t0 (Dira 1927 [38℄, p. 623, footnote).
This assumption may sound strange, espe ially sin e ξ is assumed to have a denite value and ξ and η are anoni ally onjugate. Cf. however Dira 's remarks on interpretation below.
112
From matrix to quantum me hani s
Equivalently, we an state Dira 's goal as that of nding the expe tation value (or more pre isely, the η -average) of any xed-time observable g , given a ertain value of ξ . The main part of the paper is devoted to developing a `transformation theory' that will allow Dira to write the quantity g not in the usual energy representation but in an arbitrary ξ -representation. Dira then suggests taking the η -averaged value of g , for ξ taking the -number value ξ ′ , as given by the diagonal element gξ′ ξ′ of g in this representation. This is in fa t a natural if `extremely broad' generalisation, to an arbitrary pair of onjugate quantities (ξ, η), of the assumption that the diagonal elements of a matrix in the energy representation (su h as Heisenberg's f (H (1) ) from the previous se tion) are time averages, although the justi ation Dira gives for this assumption is merely that `the diagonal elements .... ertainly would [determine the average values℄ in the limiting ase of large quantum numbers' (Dira 1927 [38℄, p. 637). Dira writes the elements of a general transformation matrix between two omplete sets of variables ξ and α (whether dis rete or ontinuous) as (ξ ′ /α′ ) (what we would now write hξ ′ |α′ i), so that the matrix elements transform as Z gξ′ ξ′′ = (ξ ′ /α′ )gα′ α′′ (α′′ /ξ ′′ )dα′ dα′′ (29) (Dira 's notation is meant to in lude the possibility of dis rete sums). His main analyti tool is the manipulation of δ -fun tions and their derivatives. Dira shows in parti ular that for the quantity ξ itself, ξξ′ ξ′′ = ξ ′ δ(ξ ′ − ξ ′′ ) ,
(30)
and that for the quantity η anoni ally onjugate to ξ , ηξ′ ξ′′ = −i~δ ′ (ξ ′ − ξ ′′ ) .
(31)
In a mixed representation, one has ξξ′ α′ = ξ ′ (ξ ′ /α′ ) ,
(32)
and ηξ′ α′ = −i~
∂ ′ ′ (ξ /α ) , ∂ξ ′
(33)
from whi h follows ∂ gξ′ α′ = g ξ, −i~ ′ (ξ ′ /α′ ) ∂ξ
for arbitrary g = g(ξ, η).
(34)
3.4 Interpretation
113
Choosing α su h that g is diagonal in the α-representation, one has gξ′ α′ = gα′ (ξ ′ /α′ ) ,
(35)
where the gα′ are the eigenvalues of g . Therefore, (34) be omes a dierential equation for the (ξ ′ /α′ ) (seen as fun tions of ξ ′ ), whi h generalises the time-independent S hrödinger equation.a On e this equation is solved, one ould obtain the desired gξ′ ξ′ from the gξ′ α′ by the appropriate transformation. The way Dira states his nal result, however, is by onsidering the matrix δ(g − g ′ ). The numeri al fun tion δ(g − g ′ ), when integrated, Z b δ(g − g ′ )dg ′ , (36) a
yields the hara teristi fun tion of the set a < g < b. Therefore, in Dira 's proposed interpretation, the diagonal elements of the orresponding matrix in the ξ -representation yield, for ea h value ξ = ξ ′ , the fra tion of the η -spa e for whi h a < g < b. That is, if η is assumed to be distributed uniformly, these diagonal elements yield the onditional probability for a < g < b given ξ = ξ ′ . Thus, the diagonal elements of the matrix δ(g − g ′ ) yield the orresponding onditional probability density for g given ξ = ξ ′ . But now, e.g. sin e for any fun tion f (g) one has Z f (g)ξ′ ξ′′ = (ξ ′ /g ′′ )f (g ′′ )(g ′′ /ξ ′′ )dg ′′ , (37) one has in parti ular Z δ(g − g ′ )ξ′ ξ′ = (ξ ′ /g ′′ )δ(g ′′ − g ′ )(g ′′ /ξ ′ )dg ′′ = (ξ ′ /g ′ )(g ′ /ξ ′ ) .
(38)
Therefore, the onditional probability density for g given ξ = ξ ′ is equal to |(g ′ /ξ ′ )|2 , a result that Dira illustrates by dis ussing Heisenberg's example of transition probabilities in resonant atoms and Born's ollision problem. In parallel with Dira 's development of transformation theory, Jordan (1927b, [39℄) also arrived at a similar theory, following on dire tly from his paper on quantum jumps (1927a [36℄) and from his earlier work on anoni al transformations (1926a,b), to whi h Dira also makes an expli it onne tion. Although Born and Heisenberg state in the report (p. 430) that the two methods are equivalent, Darrigol (1992, pp. 3434) a Dira also gives a generalisation of the time-dependent S hrödinger equation.
114
From matrix to quantum me hani s
points to some subtle dieren es, whi h are also related to Dira 's riti ism in the general dis ussion of Jordan's introdu tion of anti ommuting elds (p. 502). Dira also notes that his theory generalises the work by Lan zos (1926 [23℄). The development of transformation theory from the idea of anoni al transformations led further towards the realisation that quantum me hani al operators a t on a Hilbert spa e and that the natural transformations are in fa t unitary.a Dira on ludes his paper with an intriguing suggestion of .... a point of view for regarding quantum phenomena rather dierent from the usual ones. One an suppose that the initial state of a system determines denitely the state of the system at any subsequent time.
If, however, one
des ribes the state of the system at an arbitrary time by giving numeri al values to the o-ordinates and momenta, then one annot a tually set up a one-one orresponden e between the values of these o-ordinates and momenta initially and their values at a subsequent time. All the same one an obtain a good deal of information (of the nature of averages) about the values at the subsequent time onsidered as fun tions of the initial values. The notion of probabilities does not enter into the ultimate des ription of me hani al pro esses: only when one is given some information that involves a probability (e.g., that all points in
η -spa e
are equally probable for representing the
system) an one dedu e results that involve probabilities. (Dira 1927a [38℄, p. 641)
Here Dira does not impute indeterminism to nature itself (the matrix equations are after all deterministi ), but instead apparently identies the sour e of the statisti al element in the hoi e of probabilisti initial data.a A
ording to Heisenberg, however, and despite the generality of the results and the `extraordinary progress' obtained (Pauli 1979, p. 358), Dira 's transformation theory did not resolve the question of the meaning of quantum me hani s. As Darrigol (1992, p. 344) emphasises, there is no notion of state ve tor in Dira 's paper (the well-known bras and kets do not appear yet). C-number values, and probability distribua See La ki (2004), who gives details also of London's (1926a,b) ontributions to this development. Note also the onne tion between transformation theory and the work on the `equivalen e' between matrix me hani s and wave me hani s. a This should be ompared to the general dis ussion, in whi h Dira (a) talks of `an irrevo able hoi e of nature' (p. 495) in relation to the out omes of an experiment, (b) uses expli itly (perhaps for the rst time) the notion of the state ve tor, when he arms that `[a℄
ording to quantum me hani s the state of the world at any time is des ribable by a wave fun tion ψ, whi h normally varies a
ording to a ausal law, so that its initial value determines its value at any later time' (p. 495), and in whi h ( ) he des ribes the initial data taken for quantum me hani al al ulations as des ribing `a ts of freewill', namely `the disturban es that an experimenter applies to a system to observe it' (p. 494); see also se tion 8.2.
3.4 Interpretation
115
tions over -number values, now refer to arbitrary quantities or pairs of quantities. As Heisenberg wrote: `there are too many -numbers in all our utteran es used to des ribe a fa t' (Pauli 1979, p. 359). Cru ially, however, the energy variable and the stationary states no longer played a privileged role.
3.4.6 Development of the `statisti al view' in the report In the report, Born and Heisenberg appear to understand Born's ollision papers (1926a,b [30℄) on the one hand and the papers by Heisenberg (1926b [35℄) and Jordan (1927a [36℄) on the other broadly in the same way, as seeking to obtain `information .... about a tual phenomena', by `dire t[ing℄ one's attention to a part of the system' (p. 420 of the report). And indeed, by onsidering oupled systems all of these papers manage to derive quantitative expressions for the probabilities of quantum jumps between energy eigenstates. Heisenberg's setting is the one hosen in the report, and sin e Heisenberg's treatment of intera ting systems does not use the formalism of wave me hani s, this hoi e may be intended to make the point that matrix me hani s an indeed a
ount for time-dependent phenomena without the aid of wave me hani s. The form of Heisenberg's result (26) as given in the report is in terms of the expe ted deviation of the value of energy from a given initial value, for instan e n1 :a δfn1 =f (H (1) ) − f (Wn(1) )= 1
{f (Wn(1) ) − f (Wn(1) )}|Sn1 m2 ,a |2 + 1 1 (1) {f (Wm ) 1
−
f (Wn(1) )}|Sm1 n2 ,a |2 1
(39)
.
If we write Φn1 m1 for the probability of the transition n1 → m1 in system 1, this be omes equation (20) of the report, ex ept that Born and Heisenberg label the matrix elements Sn1 m2 ,a and Sm1 n2 ,a , respe tively, by the transitions n1 m2 → n1 m2 and n1 m2 → m1 n2 , that is, as Sn1 m2 ,n1 m2 and Sn1 m2 ,m1 n2 , omitting referen e to the state a.b One further dieren e between our des ription above and the one given in the report is that Born and Heisenberg are treating the ase in whi h the transition n1 → m1 in system 1 may resonate with more than one a Note that |Sn1 m2 ,a |2 + |Sm1 n2 ,a |2 = 1, be ause a is normalised. b In Heisenberg's paper, the matrix (25) orresponds to a 45-degree rotation, so the probabilities are independent of the hoi e of a or b.
116
From matrix to quantum me hani s
transition in system 2. In this ase, the total transition probability Φn1 m1 is no longer equal to |Sn1 m2 ,m1 n2 |2 but to X |Sn1 m2 ,m1 n2 |2 . Φn1 m1 = (40) m2 n2
Thus we also have equation (21) of the report. It is only after this matrix me hani al dis ussion that Born and Heisenberg introdu e the time-dependent S hrödinger equation, as a more ` onvenient' formalism for `thinking of the system under onsideration as oupled to another one and negle ting the rea tion on the latter' (p. 423). This suggests that Born and Heisenberg may onsider the timedependent S hrödinger equation only as an ee tive des ription. This impression is reinfor ed by omparing with Heisenberg's book (1930b, pp. 14850) where, after the above derivation, Heisenberg ontinues with a more general derivation of time-dependent probabilities, whi h he then relates to the usual time-dependent S hrödinger equation. Nevertheless, Born and Heisenberg use the wave fun tion throughout the ensuing dis ussion of probabilities, noting that this formalism `leads to a further development of the statisti al view', by whi h they mean in parti ular the idea of interferen e of probabilities.a First of all Born and Heisenberg relate the wave fun tion to probabilities. They take the time-dependent transformation matrix S(t) given by the unitary evolution. For the oe ients of the wave fun tion in the energy basis one has (equation (25) in the report): X cn (t) = (41) Snm (t)cm (0) . m
If now all cm (0) ex ept one (say, ck (0)) are zero, from the assumption that a system is always in a stationary state it is natural to on lude that the |Snk (t)|2 are the probabilities for transitions to the respe tive energy states (`transition probabilties'), and the |cn (t)|2 are the resulting probabilities for the stationary states (`state probabilities'). In support of this interpretation (whi h is the same as in Born's ollision papers), the report quotes in parti ular Born's paper on the adiabati prin iple (1926 [34℄), that is, Born's proof that in the adiabati ase the transition probabilities between dierent states tend to zero, in a
ordan e with Ehrenfest's (1917) prin iple.b a On these matters f. also se tion 8.1. b Ehrenfest had the idea that sin e quantised variables annot hange by arbitrarily small amounts, they should remain onstant under adiabati perturbations. This
3.4 Interpretation
117
Then Born and Heisenberg ome to dis ussing interferen e.a This is also the rst time in the presentation of the physi al interpretation of the theory that measurements enter the pi ture. Born and Heisenberg note that if ck is not the only non-zero oe ient at t = 0, then (41) does not imply X |cn (t)|2 = (42) |Snm (t)|2 |cm (0)|2 , m
but that instead one has
|cn (t)|2 = |
X
Snm (t)cm (0)|2 .
(43)
m
The passage immediately following this is both remarkable and, in our opinion, very signi ant (p. 425):a it should be noted that this `interferen e' does not represent a ontradi tion with the rules of the probability al ulus, that is, with the assumption that 2 the |Snk | are quite usual probabilities. In fa t, the omposition rule [(42)℄
follows from the on ept of probability for the problem treated here when and |cn |2 of the atoms in
only when the relative number, that is, the probability the state phases
n,
γn
has been
established
beforehand
experimentally.
In this ase the
are unknown in prin iple, so that [(43)℄ then naturally goes over to
[(42)℄ .... .
(The passage ends with a referen e to Heisenberg's un ertainty paper.) How do Born and Heisenberg propose to resolve this apparent ontradi tion? It would make sense to say that the |Snk (t)|2 annot be taken in general as probabilities for quantum jumps, be ause the derivation of |Snk (t)|2 as a transition probability works only in a spe ial ase (that is, presumably, if the energy at t = 0 has in fa t been measured). On this reading, there might on eivably exist some quite dierent transition led him to formulate the prin iple stating that the lassi al variables to be quantised are the adiabati invariants of the system. Cf. Born (1969, pp. 113 .). a Born and Heisenberg give redit to Pauli for the notion of interferen e of probabilities (p. 424). Note that Pauli ontributed signi antly to the development of the `statisti al view', albeit mainly in orresponden e and dis ussion. Contrary to what is ommonly assumed, the idea of a probability density for position is not ontained in Born's ollision papers, but appears in fa t in Pauli's letter to Heisenberg of 19 O tober 1926 (Pauli 1979, p. 3409), together with the idea of the orresponding momentum density, and in print in a footnote of Pauli's paper on gas degenera y and paramagnetism (1927 [44℄). (See also Heisenberg to Pauli, 28 O tober 1926, in Pauli 1979, pp. 34052.) Jordan (1927b [39℄), in his se ond paper on the transformation theory, even gives redit to Pauli for the introdu tion of arbitrary transition probabilities and amplitudes. a For further dis ussion, see se tion 6.1.2.
118
From matrix to quantum me hani s
probabilities, whi h lie outside the s ope of quantum me hani s and are presumbly of no pra ti al value (like a deterministi ompletion in the
ase of ollision pro esses).a However, this reading does not seem to t what Born and Heisenberg a tually say. Their suggestion seems to be that the |Snk (t)|2 are indeed always transition probabilities, but that the |cn |2 are not always state probabilities: the |cn |2 will be state probabilities if and only if the energies have been measured (non-sele tively). This seems analogous to Heisenberg's (1927 [46℄, p. 197) idea in the un ertainty paper that the `law of ausality' is inappli able be ause it is impossible in prin iple to know the present with su ient a
ura y (i.e. the ante edent of the law of ausality fails).a Born and Heisenberg swiftly move on to generalising the dis ussion to the ase of arbitrary observables, on the basis of Dira 's and Jordan's transformation theory (Dira 1927a [38℄, Jordan 1927b, [39℄). They introdu e the interpretation of |ϕ|2 as a position density, and onsider in parti ular the density |ϕ(q ′ , W ′ )|2 dened by the stationary state ϕ(q ′ , W ′ ) with the energy W ′ , or in modern notation, |ϕ(q ′ , W ′ )|2 = |ϕW ′ (q ′ )|2 = |hq ′ |W ′ i|2 .
(44)
This is immediately generalised to arbitrary pairs of observables q and Q with values q ′ and Q′ : |ϕ(q ′ , Q′ )|2 = |hq ′ |Q′ i|2 .
(45)
Born and Heisenberg all this a `relative state probability', reserving the term `transition probability' for the ase of a single observable evolving in time (or depending on some external parameter), always with the proviso that in general one should expe t interferen e of the orresponding `transition amplitudes'. Note that the physi al interpretation of this generalisation makes sense only if one takes over from the above the idea that probabilities su h as a That su h probabilities an be dened (albeit non-uniquely), leading to well-dened sto hasti pro esses for the quantum jumps, was shown expli itly by Bell (1984). a It appears not to be well known that the last 20 pages of the original types ript of Heisenberg's un ertainty paper are ontained in AHQP, mis atalogued as an 'in omplete and unpublished paper (pp. 12-31)' by Kramers.7 The types ript
ontains slight textual variants (as ompared with the published version) and manus ript orre tions in what appears to be Heisenberg's hand, but does not in lude the famous addendum in proof in response to Bohr's riti ism ( f. p. 146 below). On Heisenberg's treatment of the `law of ausality', see also Beller (1999, pp. 11013).
3.4 Interpretation
119
|ϕ|2 are well-dened only upon measurement, or more pre isely, that a tual frequen ies upon measurement will be given by the expression |ϕ|2 . Born and Heisenberg's terminology, however, is somewhat ambiguous.a A major on eptual shift appears to be taking pla e, whi h may be easy to miss. Do quantum jumps still o
ur whenever two systems intera t, or do they now o
ur only between measurements? Indeed, are systems always in stationary states, as has been expli itly assumed until now, or only when the energy is measured? Heisenberg's un ertainty paper (on pp. 1901), as well as the orresponden e with Pauli (Heisenberg to Pauli, 23 February 1927, in Pauli 1979, pp. 37682) both mention expli itly the loss of a privileged status for stationary states. It seems that, even though we are not expli itly told so, the pi ture of quantum jumps (that is, of probabilisti transitions between possessed values of energy) is shifting to that of probabilisti transitions from one measurement to the next. The idea that frequen ies are well-dened only upon measurement appears to play the same role as von Neumann's proje tion postulate. As dis ussed in more detail in hapter 6, however, it is far from lear whether that is what Born and Heisenberg have in mind. A similar notion is introdu ed in Heisenberg's un ertainty paper (1927 [46℄, p. 186), but again in terms that are `somewhat mysti al' (Pauli to Bohr, 17 O tober 1927, in Pauli 1979, p. 411). It appears expli itly in the pro eedings only in the general dis ussion, in Born's main ontribution (p. 483) and in the intriguing ex hange between Dira and Heisenberg (pp. 493 .). In hapter 6 and se tion 8.1, we shall return to Born and Heisenberg's view of interferen e and to the question of whether, a
ording to them, the ollapse of the wave fun tion and the time-dependent S hrödinger evolution are at all fundamental pro esses.
3.4.7 Justi ation and overall on lusions The following se tion III (drafted by Heisenberg) presents Jordan's axiomati formulation of quantum me hani s (Jordan 1927b, [39℄),a and justies the ne essity of a statisti al view in the ontext of Heisenberg's notion of un ertainty (Heisenberg 1927 [46℄). Born and Heisenberg a In one paragraph they refer to `the probability that for given energy W ′ the
oordinate q ′ is in some given element dq ′ ', whereas in the next they refer to `the probability, given q ′ , to nd the value of Q′ in dQ′ ' (p. 427; itali s added). a This formulation, whi h is how Jordan presents his transformation theory, was expli itly intended as a generalisation of the formalisms of matrix me hani s, wave me hani s, q-number theory and of Born and Wiener's original operator formalism.
120
From matrix to quantum me hani s
argue as follows. Even in lassi al me hani s, if ertain quantities (for instan e the phases of the motion) were known only with a ertain impre ision, the future evolution of the system would be only statisti ally
onstrained. Now, the un ertainty relations prevent one from determining the values of all physi al quantities, providing a fundamental limit of pre ision. In addition, quantum me hani s pres ibes dierent laws for the time evolution of the statisti al onstraints. Impre ise initial
onditions an be des ribed by hoosing ertain `probability fun tions' (this is the losest Born and Heisenberg ome to dis ussing the `redu tion of the wave pa ket' as presented in the un ertainty paper), and `the quantum me hani al laws determine the hange (wave-like propagation) of these probability fun tions' (p. 432). Born and Heisenberg laim that dis ussion of the ases in whi h these laws oin ide to a very good approximation with the lassi al evolution of a probability density justies the lassi al treatment of α- and β -parti le traje tories in a
loud hamber.a They thus maintain that the statisti al element in the theory an be re on iled with ma ros opi determinism.b Se tion III arguably addresses the dual task set in the introdu tion of ensuring that quantum me hani s is ` onsistent in itself' and of showing that quantum me hani s an be taken to `predi t unambiguously the results for all experiments on eivable in its domain' (p. 409). This task appears to be related to two on eptual desiderata, that the theory be intuitive (ans hauli h) and losed (abges hlossen). These are tou hed upon briey in the report, espe ially in the introdu tion and on lusion, but are important both in the debate with S hrödinger (see se tion 4.6) and in some of Heisenberg's later writings (in parti ular, Heisenberg 1948). The report appears to be the rst instan e in whi h Heisenberg uses the on ept of a losed theory.a a Born and Heisenberg's remarks about dierent laws of propagation of the probabilities may refer to the onditions under whi h (43) redu es to (42), whi h would arguably be an early example of de oheren e onsiderations. However, the remark is too brief, and Born and Heisenberg may be merely omparing the spreading of the quantum probabilities with that of a Liouville distribution. For a modern treatment of the latter omparison, see Ballentine (2003). b For further dis ussion of these issues see se tions 6.2.1 and 6.4. a Compare also S heibe (1993) on the on ept of losed theories in Heisenberg's thought. The origin of this on ept has also been tra ed to two earlier papers (Heisenberg 1926a [28℄ and 1926 [60℄); see for instan e Chevalley (1988). However, in the rst paper there is no mention of losed theories, only of losed systems of terms (symmetri and antisymmetri ), a point also repeated in the se ond paper. In the latter, Heisenberg mentions the need to introdu e equations for the matrix variables in order to obtain a ` losed theory', but this does not seem to be the same use of the term as in the report. We wish to thank also Gregor S hiemann for orresponden e and referen es on this topi .
3.4 Interpretation
121
As dened in the report, a losed theory is one that has a hieved a denitive form, and is no longer liable to modi ation, either in its mathemati al formulation or in its physi al meaning. This is made more pre ise in later presentations (e.g. Heisenberg 1948), in whi h Heisenberg in ludes the appli ability of the on epts of a theory in the analysis. All
losed theories possess a spe i domain of appli ation, within whi h they are and will always remain orre t. Indeed, their on epts always remain part of the s ienti language and are onstitutive of our physi al understanding of the world. In the report, quantum me hani s (without the in lusion of ele trodynami s) is indeed taken to be a losed theory,a so that dierent assumptions about the physi al meaning of quantum me hani s (su h as S hrödinger's idea of taking |ϕ|2 to be a harge densityb ), would lead to ontradi tions with experien e. Thus, the report ends on a note of utmost onden e.
a Heisenberg (1948) lists Newtonian me hani s, Maxwellian ele trodynami s and spe ial-relativisti physi s, thermodynami s, and nonrelativisti quantum me hani s as the four main examples of su h theories. b Des ribed in more detail in se tion 4.4.
122
Notes to pp. 93118
Ar hival notes 1 Cf. also Lorentz to Ehrenfest, 4 July 1927, AHQP-EHR-23 (in Dut h). 2 This and the following remarks are based on Born to Lorentz, 23 June 1927, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in German). 3 Heisenberg to Lorentz, 23 June 1927, AHQP-LTZ-12 (in German). 4 Born to Lorentz, 29 August 1927, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in German). 5 Heisenberg to Lorentz, 24 August 1927, AHQP-LTZ-12 (in German). 6 Heisenberg to Einstein, 18 February 1926, AEA 12-172.00 (in German). 7 AHQP-28 (H. A. Kramers, notes and drafts 192652), se tion 6.
4 S hrödinger's wave me hani s
S hrödinger's work on wave me hani s in 1926 appears to have been driven by the idea that one ould give a purely wave-theoreti al des ription of matter. Key elements in this pi ture were the idea of parti les as wave pa kets (se tion 4.3) and the possible impli ations for the problem of radiation (se tion 4.4). This pure wave theory, in ontrast to de Broglie's work, did away with the idea of point parti les altogether (se tion 4.5). The main oni t, however, was between S hrödinger and the proponents of quantum me hani s (se tion 4.6), both in its form at the time of S hrödinger's papers and in its further developments as sket hed in the previous hapter. For referen e, we provide a brief hronology of S hrödinger's writings relating to wave me hani s up to the Solvay onferen e: • Paper on Einstein's gas theory, submitted 15 De ember 1925, published 1 Mar h 1926 (S hrödinger 1926a). • First paper on quantisation, submitted 27 January 1926, addendum in proof 28 February 1926, published 13 Mar h 1926 (S hrödinger 1926b). • Se ond paper on quantisation, submitted 23 February 1926, published 6 April 1926 (S hrödinger 1926 ). • Paper on the relation between wave and matrix me hani s (`equivalen e paper'), submitted 18 Mar h 1926, published 4 May 1926 (S hrödinger 1926d). • Paper on mi ro- and ma rome hani s ( oherent states for the harmoni os illator), published 9 July 1926 (S hrödinger 1926e). • Third paper on quantisation, submitted 10 May 1926, published 13 July 1926 (S hrödinger 1926f).
123
124
S hrödinger's wave me hani s
• Fourth paper on quantisation, submitted 21 June 1926, published 5 September 1926 (S hrödinger 1926g). • Review paper in English for the Physi al Review, submitted 3 September 1926, published De ember 1926 (S hrödinger 1926h). • Prefa e to the rst edition of Abhandlungen zur Wellenme hanik, dated November 1926 (S hrödinger 1926i). • Paper on the Compton ee t in wave me hani s, submitted 30 November 1926, published 10 January 1927 (S hrödinger 1927a). • Paper on the energy-momentum tensor, submitted 10 De ember 1926, published 10 January 1927 (S hrödinger 1927b). • Paper on energy ex hange in wave me hani s, submitted 10 June 1927, published 9 August 1927 (S hrödinger 1927 ).
We shall now dis uss the above points in turn, after a brief dis ussion of the planning of S hrödinger's report for the onferen e (se tion 4.1) and a summary of the report itself (se tion 4.2).
4.1 Planning of S hrödinger's report As reported in hapter 1, the s ienti ommittee of the Solvay institute met in Brussels on 1 and 2 April 1926 to plan the fth Solvay onferen e. Lorentz had asked Ehrenfest to suggest some further names of possible parti ipants, and it is in Ehrenfest's letter of 30 Mar h1 that S hrödinger's name is rst mentioned in onne tion with the onferen e.a On this o
asion, Ehrenfest suggested S hrödinger on the basis of a paper in whi h S hrödinger proposed an expression for the broadening of spe tral lines due to the Doppler ee t, and whi h applied the onservation laws to phenomena involving single light quanta (S hrödinger 1922).b Evidently, neither Lorentz nor Ehrenfest were yet aware of S hrödinger's work on wave me hani s. In the meantime, S hrödinger sent to Lorentz the proof sheets of his rst two papers on quantisation, also on 30 Mar h,2 thus initiating his well-known orresponden e with Lorentz on wave me hani s.c a S hrödinger had already been a parti ipant in the fourth Solvay onferen e, though not a speaker; f. Moore (1989, pp. 1578). b As S hrödinger points out, the al ulated broadening of the spe tral lines is small
ompared to that expe ted on the basis of the thermal agitation of the radiating gas, otherwise the ee t ould be used as a test of the light quantum hypothesis.
Most of this orresponden e is translated in Przibram (1967). In the letter of 30 Mar h, not in luded there, S hrödinger suggests reading the se ond paper on quantisation before the rst, whi h should be seen rather an as example of an appli ation. Also, he writes that the variational prin iple of the rst paper is
4.1 Planning of S hrödinger's report
125
A
ordingly, already in a report of 8 April 1926 to the administrative
ommission,3 S hrödinger is listed as a possible substitute for Heisenberg for a le ture on the `adaptation of the foundations of dynami s to the quantum theory'. (It is unlikely, however, that the papers rea hed Lorentz before the meeting in Brussels.a ) In January 1927 then, as most of the other parti ipants, S hrödinger was invited to the fth Solvay
onferen e.5 A few weeks later, S hrödinger had the opportunity to dis uss personally with Lorentz the plans for the report `under the beautiful palms of Pasadena', as he re alls in a letter of June 1927. In the same letter, we nd a useful sket h of the theme and fo us of S hrödinger's report; we also gather that S hrödinger was wary of the potential for a onfrontation in Brussels:6 ....
I nurtured the quiet hope you would yet return to your rst plan and
entrust only Messrs [d℄e Broglie and Heisenberg with reports on the new me hani s. But now you have de ided otherwise and I will of ourse happily perform my duty. Yet I fear that the `matri ians' (as Mr Ehrenfest used to say) will feel disadvantaged. Should it ome to dierent views, whi h might after all urge on the ommittee the wish to limit the reports to two, you know, dear Professor, that I shall always happily remit my harge into your hands.
A
ording to S hrödinger's sket h, the report is to stress points of prin iple, rather than the (by then many) appli ations of the theory. First of all, one has to distinguish learly between two wave-me hani al theories: a theory of waves in spa e and time (whi h however runs into di ulties espe ially with the many-ele tron problem), and the highly su
essful theory of waves in onguration spa e (whi h however is not relativisti ). A di ulty of prin iple to be dis ussed in the ontext of the spa etime theory is the possibility of developing an intera ting theory, whi h seems to require distinguishing between the elds generated by dierent parti les, and whether this an be done in a sensible way, or perhaps be avoided.a In the ontext of the onguration-spa e theory, the main question is how to interpret the wave fun tion. S hrödinger given a sensible formulation only in the addendum in proof. Finally, he mentions the paper on Einstein's gas theory in the Physikalis he Zeits hrift (1926a) as a kind of preparatory work. Note that Lorentz on 27 May thanks S hrödinger for the proof sheets of three papers rather than the two mentioned in S hrödinger's letter. This third paper is learly the equivalen e paper (1926d), and was presumably sent separately ( f. Przibram 1967, pp. 43 and 556). a Lorentz had written to Ehrenfest on 29 Mar h from Paris, where he had another meeting, and appears to have travelled to Brussels dire tly from there.4 a Cf. p. 461 of the report.
126
S hrödinger's wave me hani s
mentions the widespread view that the wave des ribes only ensembles, as well as his own `preferred interpretation as a real des ription of the individual system, whi h thereby be omes a kind of mollus '. In the letter (but not in the report), he is expli it about some of his misgivings about the ensemble view (as well as about the di ulties with his own preferred understanding, namely the `failure of the ele trons to stay together and similar'). Indeed, he points out that the S hrödinger equation is time-symmetri (if one in ludes omplex onjugation), while experien e tea hes us that the statisti al behaviour of ensembles annot be des ribed time-symmetri ally. Also, insisten e on a statisti al interpretation leads to `mysti al' al ulations with amplitudes and thus to problems with the laws of probability.7
4.2 Summary of the report The eventual form of S hrödinger's report follows roughly the sket h given above, with an introdu tion, followed by three main se tions, respe tively on the onguration-spa e theory, on the spa etime theory and on the many-ele tron problem. Introdu tion. S hrödinger draws the distin tion between the spa etime theory (four-dimensional) and the onguration-spa e theory (multidimensional). He states that the use of onguration spa e is a mathemati al way for des ribing what are in fa t events in spa e and time. However, it is the multi-dimensional theory that is the most su
essful and has proved to be a powerful analyti tool in relation to Heisenberg and Born's matrix me hani s. The multi-dimensional point of view has not been re on iled yet with the four-dimensional one.a I. Multi-dimensional theory. S hrödinger sket hes a derivation of his time-independent wave equation, noting that it reprodu es or improves on the results of Bohr's quantum theory. He also notes that the stationary states allow one to al ulate the transition probabilities en ountered in matrix me hani s. If one wishes to onsistently develop a formalism in whi h there are only dis ontinuous transitions, he suggests one should take seriously the idea that the transitions do not o
ur against a ontinuous time ba kground; the appearen e of a a As be omes lear in the dis ussion, S hrödinger thinks that the multi-dimensional theory may prove indispensable, so that one should a
ept the notion of a ψfun tion on onguration spa e and try instead to understand its physi al meaning in terms of its manifestation in spa e and time. (See the dis ussion in se tion 4.4 below.)
4.2 Summary of the report
127
ontinuous time parameter would be purely statisti al, so to speak.a As an alternative, he suggests interpreting the time-independent equation as arising from a time-dependent one from whi h the time variable is eliminated by assuming a stationary solution. He thus arrives to the des ription of a quantum system in terms of a time-dependent wave fun tion on onguration spa e. He then asks what the meaning of this wave fun tion is: `how does the system des ribed by it really look like in three dimensions?' (p. 454, S hrödinger's emphasis). He briey mentions the view that the ψ -fun tion des ribes an ensemble of systems, whi h Born and Heisenberg are going to dis uss. S hrödinger instead nds it useful (if perhaps `a bit naive') to imagine an individual system as ontinuously lling the whole of spa e somehow weighted by |ψ|2 (as he further laries in the dis ussion). S hrödinger then arefully spells out that the spatial density resulting from the onguration spa e density is not a lassi al harge density, in the sense that the a tion on the parti les by external elds and the intera tion between the parti les are already des ribed by the potentials in the wave equation, and that it is in onsistent to assume that this spatial density is also a ted upon in the manner of a lassi al harge density. Instead, it is possible to interpret it as a harge density (with some quali ations, some of whi h are spelled out only in the dis ussion) for the purpose of al ulating the ( lassi al) radiation eld, thus yielding a partial vindi ation of the idea of spatial densities. This, however, must be an approximation, sin e the observation of su h emitted radiation is itself an intera tion between the emitting atom and some other absorbing atom or mole ule, to be des ribed again by the appropriate potentials in the wave equation. II. Four-dimensional theory. S hrödinger shows that the time-dependent wave equation for a single parti le is a nonrelativisti approximation (with subtra tion of a rest frequen y) to the wave equation for the de Broglie phase wave of the parti le. The latter an be made manifestly relativisti by in luding ve tor potentials. (In modern terminology, this is the Klein-Gordon equation.) If one ouples the Maxwell eld to it, the same spatial densities dis ussed in se tion I appear as harge (and
urrent) densities. However, in the appli ation to the ele tron in the hydrogen atom, it be omes apparent that adding the self-eld of the ele tron to the (external) eld of the nu leus yields the wrong results.a Thus S hrödinger argues that if one hopes to develop a spa etime theory of intera ting parti les, it will be ne essary to onsider not just the a Cf. the dis ussion in h. 8.1. a Cf. S hrödinger (1927b), as mentioned in se tion 4.6 below.
128
S hrödinger's wave me hani s
overall eld generated by the parti les, but to distinguish between the (spatially overlapping) elds generated by ea h individual parti le, ea h eld a ting only on the other parti les of the system. Finally, he notes that the Klein-Gordon equation needs to be modied in order to des ribe spin ee ts, and that it may be possible to do so by onsidering a ve torial instead of a s alar ψ . III. The many-ele tron problem. S hrödinger returns to the multidimensional theory and its treatment, by approximation, of the manyele tron atom. His interest in this spe i example relates to the question of whether this multi-dimensional system an be understood in spa etime terms. The treatment rst negle ts the intera tion potentials between the ele trons, and as a rst approximation takes produ ts ψk1 . . . ψkn of the single-ele tron wave fun tions as solutions. One then expands the solution of the full equation in terms of the produ t wave fun tions. The time-dependent oe ients ak1 ...kn (t) in this expansion
an then be al ulated approximately if the intera tion between the ele trons is small. S hrödinger shows that before any approximation the oe ients in the equations for the ak1 ...kn (t) depend only on potentials al ulated from the spatial harge densities asso iated with the ψki . Thus, although the solution to the full equation is a fun tion on
onguration spa e, it is determined by purely spatial harge densities. A
ording to S hrödinger, this reinfor es the hope of providing a spatial interpretation of the wave fun tion. A sket h of the approximation method on ludes this se tion and the report.
4.3 Parti les as wave pa kets The idea of parti les as wave pa kets is ru ial to the development of S hrödinger's ideas and appears to provide one of the main motivations, at least initially, behind the idea of a des ription of matter purely in terms of waves. S hrödinger's earliest spe ulation about wave pa kets (for both material parti les and light quanta) is found in his paper on Einstein's gas statisti s (1926a), in se tion 5, `On the possibility of representing mole ules or light quanta through interferen e of phase waves'. As he explains, S hrödinger nds it un anny that in de Broglie's theory one should onsider the phase waves of the orpus les to be plane waves, sin e it is lear that by appropriate superposition of dierent plane waves one
an onstru t a `signal', whi h following Debye (1909) and von Laue
4.3 Parti les as wave pa kets
129
(1914, se tion 2) an be onstrained to a small spatial volume. He then
ontinues: On the other hand, it is of ourse
not
to be a hieved by the lassi al wave
laws, that the onstru ted `model of a light quantum' whi h by the way extends indeed for stays together.
many
wavelengths in every dire tion also
permanently
Rather, it spreads itself out [zerstreut si h℄ over ever larger
volumes after passing through a fo al point. If one ould avoid this last on lusion by a quantum theoreti al modi ation of the lassi al wave laws, then a way to deliveran e from the light quantum dilemma would appear to be paved [angebahnt℄. (1926a, p. 101)
Wave pa kets are rst dis ussed at length in the se ond paper on quantisation (1926 ): after des ribing the opti al-me hani al analogy, S hrödinger dis usses how one an onstru t wave pa kets (using the analogues of the opti al onstru tions by Debye and von Laue), and then shows that the entroid of su h a wave pa ket follows the lassi al equations of motion. S hrödinger onje tures that material points are in fa t des ribed by wave pa kets of small dimensions. He notes also that, for systems moving along very small orbits, the pa ket will be spread out, so that the idea of the traje tory or of the position of the ele tron inside the atom loses its meaning. In fa t, the main problem that S hrödinger was to fa e with regard to wave pa kets turned out to be that spreading of wave pa kets is a mu h more generi feature than he imagined at rst. As mentioned, S hrödinger sent to Lorentz the proofs of his rst two papers on quantisation (1926b, ) on 30 Mar h 1926. In his reply, among many other things, Lorentz dis ussed expli itly the idea of wave pa kets, indeed doubting that they would stay together (Przibram 1967, pp. 478).a S hrödinger ommented on this both in his reply of 6 June (Przibram 1967, pp. 5566) and in an earlier letter of 31 May to Plan k (Przibram 1967, pp. 811). In the latter, he admits that there will always exist spread-out states, be ause of linearity, but still hopes it will be possible to onstru t pa kets that stay together for hydrogen orbits of high quantum number. As he notes in the reply to Lorentz, this would imply that there is no general identi ation between hydrogen eigenstates and Bohr orbits, sin e a Bohr orbit of high quantum number would be represented by a wave pa ket rather than a stationary wave. a As Lorentz remarks, the alternative would be `to dissolve the ele tron ompletely .... and to repla e it by a system of waves' (p. 48), whi h, however, would make it di ult to understand phenomena su h as the photoele tri ee t. The latter was in fa t one of the riti isms levelled at S hrödinger's theory by Heisenberg (see below, se tion 4.6).
130
S hrödinger's wave me hani s
(For an ele tron in a hydrogen orbit of low quantum number, S hrödinger did not envisage an orbiting pa ket but indeed a spread-out ele tron.) With the reply to Lorentz, S hrödinger further sent his paper on mi roand ma rome hani s (1926e), in whi h he showed that for the harmoni os illator, wave pa kets do stay together. He hoped that the result would generalise to all quasi-periodi motions (admitting that maybe there would be `dissolution' for a free ele tron). However, on 19 June Lorentz sent S hrödinger a al ulation showing that wave pa kets on a high hydrogen orbit would indeed spread out ( f. Przibram 1967, pp. 6971, where the details of the al ulation, however, are omitted). The relevan e of high hydrogen orbits is, of ourse, the role they play in Bohr's orresponden e prin iple. The fa t that wave pa kets along su h orbits do not stay together was thus a blow for any hopes S hrödinger might have had of explaining the transition from mi ro- to ma rome hani s along the lines of the orresponden e prin iple. A further blow to the idea of wave pa kets must have ome with Born's papers on ollision theory during the summer of 1926 (Born 1926a,b; f. se tion 3.4.3 above). In the equivalen e paper, S hrödinger had in luded a remark about s attering, for whi h, he wrote, it is `indeed ne essary to understand learly the ontinuous transition between the ma ros opi ans hauli h me hani s and the mi rome hani s of the atom' (1926d, p. 753; see below, se tion 4.6, for the notion of Ans hauli hkeit). Given that at the time S hrödinger thought that ele trons on high quantum orbits should be des ribed by wave pa kets, this remark may indi ate that S hrödinger also thought that s attering should involve a dee tion of wave pa kets, whi h would move asymptoti ally in straight lines.a Born's work on ollisions in the summer of 1926 made essential use of wave me hani s, but suggested a very dierent pi ture of s attering. Born expli itly understood his work as providing an alternative interpretation both to his earlier views on matrix me hani s and to S hrödinger's views. In turn, S hrödinger appeared to be s epti al of Born's suggestions, writing on 25 August to Wilhelm Wien: Zeits h. f. Phys. I know more or waves must be stri tly ausally determined through eld laws, the wavefun tions on the other hand have only the meaning of probabilities for the a tual motions of light- or material-parti les. I believe
From an oprint of Born's last work in the less how he thinks of things: the
that Born thereby overlooks that ....
it would depend on the taste of the
a If thus was indeed S hrödinger's intuition, it may seem quite remarkable. On the other hand, so is the fa t that S hrödinger does not seem to dis uss dira tion of material parti les, whi h seems equally problemati for the idea of wave pa kets.
4.3 Parti les as wave pa kets
131
observer whi h he now wishes to regard as real, the parti le or the guiding eld. (Quoted in Moore 1989, p. 225)
A few days later, S hrödinger submitted a review paper on `undulatory me hani s' to the Physi al Review (1926h). In it, he qualied rather strongly the idea that `material points onsist of, or are nothing but, wave systems' (p. 1049). Indeed, he ontinued (pp. 104950): This extreme on eption may be wrong, indeed it does not oer as yet the slightest explanation of why su h wave-systems seem to be realized in nature as orrespond to mass-points of denite mass and harge.
....
a thorough
orrelation of all features of physi al phenomena an probably be aorded only by a harmonious union of these two extremes.
During the general dis ussion at the Solvay onferen e, S hrödinger summarised the situation with the following words (this volume, p. 519): The original pi ture was this, that what moves is in reality not a point but a domain of ex itation of nite dimensions ....
.
One has sin e found that
the naive identi ation of an ele tron, moving on a ma ros opi orbit, with a wave pa ket en ounters di ulties and so annot be a
epted to the letter. The main di ulty is this, that with ertainty the wave pa ket spreads in all dire tions when it strikes an obsta le, an atom for example.
We know
today, from the interferen e experiments with athode rays by Davisson and Germer, that this is part of the truth, while on the other hand the Wilson
loud hamber experiments have shown that there must be something that
ontinues to des ribe a well-dened traje tory after the ollision with the obsta le. I regard the ompromise proposed from dierent sides, whi h onsists of assuming a ombination of waves and point ele trons, as simply a provisional manner of resolving the di ulty.
The problem of the relation between mi ro- and ma rophysi s is onne ted of ourse to the linearity of the wave equation, whi h appears to lead dire tly to highly non lassi al states (witness S hrödinger's famous ` at' example, S hrödinger 1935).a One might ask whether S hrödinger himself onsidered the idea of a nonlinear wave equation. In this
onne tion, a few remarks by S hrödinger may be worth investigating further. One expli it, if early, referen e to nonlinearity is ontained in the letter of 31 May to Plan k, where, after noti ing that linearity for es the existen e of non- lassi al states, S hrödinger indeed spe ulates that the equations might be only approximately linear (Przibram 1967, p. 10). In the orresponden e with Lorentz, the question of nonlinearity arises a Note, on the other hand, that S hulman (1997) shows there are ` lassi al' solutions to the linear equation in quite realisti models of oupling between mi ro- and ma rosystems (measurements), provided one requires them to satify appropriate boundary onditions at both the initial and the nal time.
132
S hrödinger's wave me hani s
in other ontexts. In the ontext of the problem of radiation, it appears at rst to be ne essary for ombination tones to arise (pp. 4950). In the
ontext of radiation rea tion, S hrödinger writes that the ex hange with Lorentz has onvin ed him of the ne essity of nonlinear terms (p. 62). In print, S hrödinger mentioned the possibility of a nonlinear term in order to in lude radiaton rea tion in his fourth paper on quantisation (1926g, p. 130).a Finally, a few years later, in his se ond paper on entanglement (1936, pp. 4512), S hrödinger mentioned the possibility of spontaneous de ay of entanglement at spatial separation, whi h would have meant a yet untested violation of the S hrödinger equation. Modern ollapse theories, su h as those by Ghirardi, Rimini and Weber (1986) or by Pearle (1976, 1979, 1989), modify the S hrödinger equation sto hasti ally, in a way that su
essfully ountera ts spreading with in reasing s ale of the system. S hrödinger's strategy based on wave pa kets thus appears to be viable at least if one a
epts sto hasti modi ations to S hrödinger's equation (as S hrödinger was not ne essarily likely to do). Note that while ru ial, the failure of the straightforward idea of wave pa kets for representing the ma ros opi , or lassi al, regime of the theory is distin t from the question of whether S hrödinger's wave pi ture ould adequately des ribe what appeared to be other examples or lear indi ations of parti ulate or `dis ontinuous' behaviour, su h as en ountered in the photoele tri ee t. This question was parti ularly important in the dialogue with Heisenberg and Bohr (se tion 4.6). We shall also see that S hrödinger ontinued to explore how ontinuous waves might provide des riptions of apparently parti ulate or dis ontinuous quantum phenomena, su h as the Compton ee t, quantum jumps, bla kbody radiation and even the photoele tri ee t (se tion 4.6.3). a An expli it proposal for in luding radiation rea tion through a nonlinear term is due to Fermi (1927). Classi ally, if one in ludes radiation rea tion, one has the third-order nonrelativisti Abraham-Lorentz equation ...
x ¨ − τ x = F/m ,
(1)
where F is the externally applied for e and τ = (2/3)e2 /mc3 (e is the ele tron
harge, m is the mass). Fermi (1927) proposed modifying the S hrödinger equation as follows: i
3 ∂Ψ ˆ − mτ Ψx· d = HΨ ∂t dt3
Z
d3 x′ Ψ∗ x′ Ψ . 3
(2)
d That is, he added an extra `potential' −mτ x· dt 3 hxi. Rederiving the Ehrenfest theorem, one nds that hxi then obeys the above Abraham-Lorentz equation.
4.4 The problem of radiation
133
4.4 The problem of radiation In Bohr's theory of the atom, the frequen y of emitted light orresponded not to the frequen y of os illation of an ele tron on a Bohr orbit, but to the term dieren e between two Bohr orbits. No known me hanism
ould explain the dieren e between the frequen y of os illation and the frequen y of emission. Bohr's theory simply postulated quantum jumps Ei → Ej between the stationary states of energy Ei and Ej , a
ompanied by emission (or absorption) of light of the orresponding E −E frequen y νij = i h j . In this respe t, the Bohr-Kramers-Slater (BKS) theory had the advantage of postulating a olle tion of virtual os illators with the observed frequen ies. This was also, in a sense, that aspe t of the BKS theory that survived into Heisenberg's matrix me hani s.a The idea that wave me hani s ould provide a ontinuous des ription of the radiation pro ess (as opposed to the pi ture of quantum jumps) appears to have been also one of the main bones of ontention between S hrödinger and the Copenhagen-Göttingen physi ists. As S hrödinger wrote to Lorentz on 6 June 1926: The frequen y dis repan y in the Bohr model, on the other hand, seems to me, (and has indeed seemed to me sin e 1914), to be something so
monstrous,
that I should like to hara terize the ex itation of light in this way as really a almost in on eivable. (Przibram 1967, p. 61)
The rea tion by S hrödinger to the BKS theory instead was quite enthusiasti . In part, S hrödinger was well predisposed towards the possibility that energy and momentum onservation be only statisti ally valid.b In part (as argued by de Regt, 1997), this was pre isely be ause the BKS theory provided a me hanism for radiation, in fa t a very ans hauli h me hanism, albeit `virtual'. S hrödinger published a paper on the BKS theory, ontaining an estimate of its energy u tuations (1924b).c In 1926, with the development of wave me hani s, S hrödinger saw a new possibility of on eiving a me hanism for radiation: the superposia See above se tion 1.3 (p. 13) and hapter 3, espe ially se tion 3.3.1. a The emphasis here is strong, but f. the ontext of this passage in S hrödinger's letter. b Cf. S hrödinger to Pauli, 8 November 1922, in Pauli (1979, pp. 6971). The idea of abandoning exa t onservation laws seems to be derived from S hrödinger's tea her Exner (ibid., and Moore 1989, pp. 1524). S hrödinger publi ly stated this view and allegian e in his inaugural le ture at the University of Züri h (9 De ember 1922), published as S hrödinger (1929a).
Cf. Darrigol (1992, pp. 2478) on the problem of the indenite growth of the energy u tuations with time (as raised in parti ular by Einstein). A
ording to S hrödinger, an isolated system would behave in this way, but the problem would disappear for a system oupled to an innite thermal bath.
134
S hrödinger's wave me hani s
tion of two waves would involve two frequen ies, and emitted radiation
ould be understood as some kind of `dieren e tone'. In his rst paper on quantisation (1926b), S hrödinger states that this pi ture would be `mu h more pleasing [um vieles sympathis her℄' than the one of quantum jumps (p. 375), but the idea is rather sket hy: S hrödinger spe ulates that the energies of the dierent eigenstates all share a large onstant term, and that if the square of the frequen y is proportional to mc2 + E , then the frequen y dieren es (and therefore the beat frequen ies) are approximately given by the hydrogen term dieren es. The se ond paper (1926 ) refers to radiation only in passing. Commenting on these papers in his letter to S hrödinger of 27 May, Lorentz pointed out that while beats would arise if the time-dependent wave equation (whi h S hrödinger did not have yet) were linear, they would still not produ e radiation by any known me hanism. Combination tones would arise if the wave equation were nonlinear (Przibram 1967, pp. 4950). As be omes lear in the following letters between S hrödinger and Lorentz, on e the harge density of a parti le is asso iated with a quadrati fun tion of ψ , su h as |ψ|2 , `dieren e tones' in the os illating harge density arise regardless of whether the wave equation is linear or nonlinear. This idea is still the basis of today's semi lassi al radiation theory (often used in quantum opti s), that is, the determination of lassi al ele tromagneti radiation from the urrent asso iated with a harge density proportional to |ψ|2 (for a non-stationary ψ ).a S hrödinger arrived at this result through his work onne ting wave me hani s and matrix me hani s (his `equivalen e paper', 1926d). In fa t, S hrödinger showed how to express the elements of Heisenberg's matri es wave me hani ally, in parti ular the elements of the dipole moment matrix, whi h (by orresponden e arguments) were interpreted as proportional to the radiation intensities. S hrödinger now suggested it might be possible `to give an extraordinarily ans hauli h interpretation of the intensity and polarisation of radiation' (1926d, p. 755), by dening an appropriate
harge density in terms of ψ . In this paper, he suggested as yet, for a ∗ single ele tron, to use (the real part of) the quadrati fun tion ψ ∂ψ ∂t . The third paper on quantisation (1926f) is on erned with perturbation theory and its appli ation to the Stark ee t, but S hrödinger notes in an addendum in proof (footnote on p. 476) that the orre t a This method is tou hed on previously. Pauli uses it (for the ase of one parti le) in al ulating the s attered radiation in the Compton ee t during the dis ussion after Compton's talk (p. 365).
4.4 The problem of radiation
135
harge density is given by |ψ|2 . In the letter to Lorentz of 6 June 1926, he explains in detail how this gives rise to a sensible notion of harge density also for several parti les, ea h ontribution being obtained by integrating over the other parti les (Przibram 1967, p. 56). This idea is then used and dis ussed in print (as a `heuristi hypothesis') in the fourth paper on quantisation (1926g, p. 118, S hrödinger's itali s), where the wave fun tion is also expli itly interpreted in terms of a superposition of all lassi alR ongurations of a system weighted by |ψ|2 , and the time
onstan y of |ψ|2 is derived (pp. 1356).a This is also the pi ture of the wave fun tion given by S hrödinger in the Solvay report (pp. 454 .). S hrödinger dis reetly skips dis ussing the view of the wave fun tion as des ribing only an ensemble. S hrödinger's on ern in interpreting the wave fun tion is to understand its manifestation in spa etime. This on ern also motivates S hrödinger's dis ussion of the many-ele tron atoma , where he stresses that the spatial
harge distributions of the single (non-intera ting) ele trons already determine the wave fun tion of the intera ting ele trons. In the report, S hrödinger starts by rephrasing the question of the meaning of the wave fun tion as that of how a system des ribed by a ertain (multi-parti le) wave fun tion looks like in three dimensions. He des ribes this as taking all possible ongurations of the lassi al system simultaneously and weighting them a
ording to |ψ|2 . To this pi ture of the system as a `snapshot' (as he alls it in the report) or as a `mollus ' (as he had written to Lorentz) S hrödinger then asso iates the
orresponding ele tri harge density in 3-spa e. He is areful to state, however, that this is not an ele tri harge in the usual sense. For one thing, the ele tromagneti eld does not exert for es on it. While this
harge does des ribe the sour es of the eld in the semi- lassi al theory, this oupling of the eld to the harges is des ribed as `provisional', rst, be ause of the problem of radiation rea tion (whi h is not taken into a
ount in the S hrödinger equation), and se ond, be ause within a
losed system it is in onsistent to model the intera tion between dierent
harged parti les using the semi- lassi al eld. In parti ular, the observation of emitted radiation is in prin iple again a quantum me hani al intera tion, and should be des ribed by orresponding potentials in the equation for the total system. a The latter question had also been raised by Lorentz (Przibram 1967, p. 71) and answered in S hrödinger's next letter, not in luded in Przibram's olle tion.8 a Previously unpublished but deriving from methods used in S hrödinger's paper on energy ex hange (1927 ).
136
S hrödinger's wave me hani s
The above pi ture of the wave fun tion and the question of regarding S hrödinger's formal harge density as a sour e of lassi al ele tromagneti radiation evidently raised many questions. (S hrödinger introdu es the dis ussion after his report by the remark: `It would seem that my des ription in terms of a snapshot was not very fortunate, sin e it has been misunderstood', p. 469.) It also eli ited the most dis ussion following S hrödinger's report.a A di ulty that is spelled out only in the dis ussion ( ontributions by Bohr and by S hrödinger, p. 469), is that using S hrödinger's dipole moment (equation (13) in S hrödinger's talk) to al ulate the radiation does not dire tly yield the orre t intensities. As pointed out in the P talk, if one evaluates the dipole moment for Ra superposition k ck ψk , one obtains terms ontaining the integrals −e qψk ψl∗ dτ . These are the matrix elements of the dipole moment matrix in matrix me hani s, and they an be used within ertain limits to al ulate the emitted radiation (in parti ular, as S hrödinger points out, vanishing of the integral implies vanishing of the orresponding spe tral line). However, these integrals appear with the oe ients ck c∗l , whereas both a
ording to Bohr's old quantum theory and to experiment, the intensity of radiation should not depend on the oe ient of the `nal state', say ψl . Thus, the use of (13) as a lassi al dipole moment in the al ulation of emitted radiation does not in general yield the orre t intensities. Bohr also drew attention to the fa t that by the time of the Solvay
onferen e, Dira (1927b, ) had already published his treatment of the intera tion of the (S hrödinger) ele tron with the quantised ele tromagneti eld. S hrödinger replied that he was aware of Dira 's work, but had the same misgivings with q-numbers as he had with matri es: the la k of `physi al meaning', without whi h he thought the further development of a relativisti theory would be di ult.a a The rest of the dis ussion in ludes a few te hni al questions and omments ( ontributions by Fowler and De Donder, Born's report on some numeri al work on perturbation theory), and some dis ussion of the `three-dimensionality' of the many-ele tron atom. Further dis ussion of the meaning of S hrödinger's harge densities (and of the meaning of the S hrödinger wave in the ontext of the transformation theory of matrix me hani s) took pla e in the general dis ussion, espe ially in ontributions by Dira and by Kramers (pp. 492 and 496). a Note that in his treatment of the emission of radiation in The Physi al Prin iples of the Quantum Theory (Heisenberg 1930b, pp. 824), Heisenberg seems to follow and expand on the dis ussion of S hrödinger's report. Indeed, Heisenberg rst des ribes two related methods for al ulating the radiation, based respe tively on
al ulating the matrix element of the dipole moment of the atom (justied via the
orresponden e prin iple), and on al ulating the dipole moment of S hrödinger's `virtual harges' (as he alls them). He then explains pre isely the di ulty with
4.5 S hrödinger and de Broglie
137
If the interpretation of the wave fun tion as a harge density raises problems of prin iple (as Born and Heisenberg also stress in their report, p. 437), what is the point of suggesting su h an interpretation? One possible way of understanding S hrödinger's intentions is to say that he is proposing an ans hauli h image of the wave fun tion in terms of the spatial density it denes, without in general spe ifying the dynami al role played by this density. Under ertain ir umstan es, then, this spatial density takes on the dynami al role of a harge density, in parti ular as a sour e of radiation. This point of view does not resolve the other problems onne ted with the wave on eption of matter (spreading of the wave pa ket, S hrödinger's at, mi ro-ma ro question), but it oers a platform from whi h to work towards their possible resolution. This of ourse may be an overinterpretation of S hrödinger's position, but it ts approximately with later developments that take S hrödinger's wave
on eption seriously, e.g. Bell's (1990) idea of |ψ|2 as `density of stu' (in onguration spa e).
4.5 S hrödinger and de Broglie Thus opens S hrödinger's review paper on wave me hani s for the Physi al Review (1926h, p. 1049, referen es omitted): The theory whi h is reported in the following pages is based on the very interesting and fundamental resear hes of L. de Broglie on what he alled `phase waves' (`ondes de phase') and thought to be asso iated with the motion a of material points, espe ially with the motion of an ele tron or [photon℄. The point of view taken here, whi h was rst published in a series of German papers, is rather that material points onsist of, or are nothing but, wavesystems.
This passage both illustrates the well-known fa t that S hrödinger arrived at his wave me hani s by developing further the ideas of de Broglie starting with his paper on gas statisti s (S hrödinger 1926a) and emphasises the main on eptual dieren e between de Broglie's and S hrödinger's approa hes. While some details of the relation between S hrödinger's and de Broglie's work are dis ussed in se tion 2.3, in this se tion we wish to raise the question of why S hrödinger should have developed su h a dierent the latter dis ussed here by Bohr and S hrödinger, and goes on to sket h (a variant of) Dira 's treatment of the problem. a The text here reads `proton', whi h is very likely a misprint, sin e de Broglie's work indeed fo ussed on ele trons and photons.
138
S hrödinger's wave me hani s
pi ture of wave me hani s. Indeed, although S hrödinger quotes de Broglie as the redis overer of Hamilton's opti al-me hani al analogy (1926h, footnote 3 on p. 1052), the two authors apply the analogy in opposite dire tions: de Broglie treats even the photon as a material parti le with a traje tory, while S hrödinger treats even the ele tron as a pure wave.a As S hrödinger writes in his rst paper on quantisation, it was in parti ular `ree tion on the spatial distribution' of de Broglie's phase waves that gave the impulse for the development of his own theory of wave me hani s (1926b, p. 372). We gain some insight as to what this refers to from a letter from S hrödinger to Landé of 16 November 1925: I have tried in vain to make for myself a pi ture of the phase wave of the ele tron in the Kepler orbit. Closely neighbouring Kepler ellipses are onsidered as `rays'. This, however, gives horrible ` austi s' or the like for the wave fronts. (Quoted in Moore 1989, p. 192)
Thus, one reason for S hrödinger to abandon the idea of traje tories in favour of the pure wave theory might have been that well-behaved traje tories seemed to be in ompatible with well-behaved waves. And indeed, in his presentations of the opti al-me hani al analogy, S hrödinger states that outside of the geometri limit the notion of `ray' be omes meaningless (1926b, pp. 495 and 507, 1926h, pp. 10523). This also seems to be at issue in the ex hange between S hrödinger and Lorentz during the dis ussion of de Broglie's report, where S hrödinger points out that in ases of degenera y, any arbitrary linear ombination of solutions is allowed, and de Broglie's theory would predi t very ompli ated orbits (p. 402). There are other aspe ts that ould on eivably provide further reasons for S hrödinger's denite abandoning of the traje tories. One possibility is that S hrödinger pi ked up from de Broglie spe i ally the idea of parti les as singularities of the wave,a and was happy to relax it to the a As is lear from de Broglie's thesis and as mentioned by de Broglie himself in his report (p. 377), de Broglie had always assumed the pi ture of traje tories. The above quotation in any ase makes it lear that this was S hrödinger's own reading of de Broglie. Already as early as January 1926, S hrödinger writes in his gas theory paper about `the de Broglie-Einstein undulatory theory of orpus les in motion, a
ording to whi h the latter are no more than a kind of foam rest [S hammkaum℄ on the wave radiation that onstitutes the world ba kground [Weltgrund℄' (1926a, p. 95). Other indi ations that this was well-known are Lorentz's omments to S hrödinger on the onstru tion of ele tron orbits in his letter of 19 June 1926 oming ` lose to de Broglie's arguments' (Przibram 1967, p. 74) and Pauli's referen e to Einstein's and de Broglie's `moving point masses' in his letter to Jordan of 12 April 1926 (Pauli 1979, p. 316). a Cf. S hrödinger (1926a, p. 99): `The universal radiation, as signals or perhaps singularities of whi h the parti les are meant to o
ur, is thus something quite
4.6 The oni t with matrix me hani s
139
idea of wave pa kets. Indeed, as we have seen above, S hrödinger pla ed great emphasis on the notion of a wave pa ket, and if it had been an adequate notion, there would have been no need for a separate notion of a orpus le in order to explain the parti ulate aspe ts of matter. We have also seen that S hrödinger was a utely aware of the radiation problem, namely of the dis repan y between the orbital frequen y of the ele tron and the frequen y of the emitted radiation. While de Broglie in his thesis was able to derive the Bohr orbits from wave onsiderations, this would in no way seem to alleviate the problem: the frequen y of revolution of the ele tron in de Broglie's theory was the same as in the Bohr model, and would lead to the wrong frequen y of radiation if the ele tron was treated as a lassi al sour e. (In the ase of degenera y noted above, the situation would be even more ompli ated.)a Finally, S hrödinger appeared to be riti al of proposals ombining waves and parti les, for instan e as appeared to be done by Born in his
ollision papers (see se tion 4.3 above). Su h misgivings ould easily have applied also to de Broglie's theory.
4.6 The oni t with matrix me hani s In the early dis ussions on the meaning of quantum theory, the notion of `Ans hauli hkeit' resurfa es time and again. The verb `ans hauen' means `to look at', and `ans hauli h', whi h means ` lear', `vivid' or `intuitive', has visual onnotations that the English word `intuitive' la ks. Ans hauli hkeit of a physi al theory is thus a quality of ready
omprehensibility that may (but need notb ) in lude a strong omponent of literal pi turability. For S hrödinger, at any rate, it seems that the possibility of grasping a theory through some kind of spatio-temporal intuition was a key omponent of physi al understanding.c It is lear, however, that the oni t between wave me hani s and matrix or quantum me hani s was not, or not only, a philosophi al issue, say about the validity of the on epts of spa etime and ausality,d and a b
d
essentially more ompli ated than for instan e the wave radiation of Maxwell's theory .... ' Note, however, that de Broglie (1924 ) had dis ussed the solution of this problem in the orresponden e limit (i.e. for the ase of high quantum numbers). Cf. below Heisenberg's use of the term in the un ertainty paper. A good dis ussion of the role the notion of Ans hauli hkeit played for S hrödinger is given by de Regt (1997, 2001), who argues that S hrödinger's requirement of Ans hauli hkeit is derived indire tly from Boltzmann, and is essentially a methodologi al requirement (as opposed to being a ommitment to realism
f. also the introdu tion by Bitbol in S hrödinger 1995, p. 4 fn. 10). Note that Kant's on eption of spa e and time is formulated in terms of what he
140
S hrödinger's wave me hani s
that, in the minds of the parties involved, these issues were onne ted with spe i ally s ienti questions.a The list of these questions is extensive. In his `equivalen e' paper (1926d), S hrödinger states that mathemati al equivalen e is not the same as physi al equivalen e, in the sense that two theories an oer quite dierent possibilities for generalisation and further development.a He thinks of two problems in parti ular: rst, the problem of s attering (as mentioned in se tion 4.3 above), se ond, the problem of radiation (dis ussed in se tion 4.4), in onne tion with whi h he then des ribes the idea of the vibrating harge density. The radiation problem in turn links to further issues at the heart of the debate with Heisenberg and Bohr in parti ular, on whether there are quantum jumps or whether the pro ess of radiation and the atomi transitions an be des ribed as
ontinuous pro esses in spa e and time. In a sense, neither the issue of s attering nor that of radiation resolved the debate in favour of either theory: both theories were modied or reinterpreted in the ourse of these developments, even though the result (statisti al interpretation, Copenhagen interpretation) was not to S hrödinger's taste. We shall now follow how the oni t evolved, from the beginnings to the time of the Solvay onferen e, sin e both sides developed onsiderably during the ru ial period between S hrödinger's rst papers and the onferen e.
4.6.1 Early days At the time of S hrödinger's rst two papers on quantisation, as we have seen in the previous hapter, matrix me hani s was a theory that reje ted the notion of ele tron orbits, indeed the very possibility of a spa etime des ription, substituting the lassi al kinemati al quantities with matrix quantities; but it kept the postulate of stationary states and of quantum jumps between these states. Matrix me hani s did not des ribe the stationary states individually, only olle tively, and allowed one to al ulate only transition probabilities for the jumps. S hrödinger's rst paper on quantisation (1926b) ontains only a few
omments on the possible ontinuous pi ture of atomi transitions, as
alls the `Ans hauungsformen' (the `forms of intuition'), so that the dis ussion has indeed strong philosophi al overtones. a This point has been re ently argued also by Perovi (2006). a Similarly, in the dis ussion after his own report, S hrödinger insists that nding a physi al interpretation of the theory is `indispensable for the further development of the theory' (p. 473).
4.6 The oni t with matrix me hani s
141
opposed to quantum jumps. (But of ourse, at this stage, he has very little to say about the problem of radiation, in parti ular nothing about intensities.) The rst time he omments expli itly on the dieren es between wave me hani s and quantum me hani s is in his se ond paper. There he writes that wave me hani s oers a way to interpret the onvi tion, more and more oming to the fore today, that should deny real signi an e to the
se ond:
phase
rst:
one
of the ele tron motions in the atom;
that one may not even laim that the ele tron at a ertain time is
on one parti ular of the quantum traje tories distinguished by the quantum onditions; third: the true laws of quantum me hani s onsist not in denite pres riptions for the individual traje tory, rather these true laws lo ated
relate through equations the elements of the whole manifold of traje tories of a system through, so that apparently a ertain intera tion between the dierent traje tories obtains. (1926 , pp. 508)
As S hrödinger pro eeds to say, these laims are in ontradi tion with the ideas of ele tron position and ele tron orbit, but should not be taken as for ing a omplete surrender of spatio-temporal ideas. At the time, the mathemati al relation between wave me hani s and matrix me hani s was not yet laried, but S hrödinger hopes there would be a well-dened mathemati al relation between the two, whi h ould then
omplement ea h other. A
ording to S hrödinger, Heisenberg's theory yields the line intensities, his own oers the possibility of bridging the mi ro-ma ro gap.a Personally, he nds the on eption of emitted frequen ies as `beats' parti ularly attra tive and believes it will provide an ans hauli h understanding of the intensity formulas (1926 , pp. 51314). Within weeks, the relation between the two theories was laried independently by S hrödinger (1926d), by E kart (1926) and by Pauli, in his remarkable letter to Jordan of 12 April 1926 (Pauli 1979, pp. 31520). This is one of the rst do umented rea tions to S hrödinger's new work from a physi ist of the Copenhagen-Göttingen s hool.b In it, Pauli emphasises in fa t that in S hrödinger's theory there are no ele tron orbits, sin e traje tories are a on ept belonging to the geometri limit of the theory. Pauli seems to say that insofar as S hrödinger provides a a S hrödinger's olle ted works (1984) reprodu e this and other papers from Erwin and Anny S hrödinger's own opy of the se ond edition of Abhandlungen zur Wellenme hanik (S hrödinger 1928). In this opy of the book, the passage about the mi ro-ma ro bridge is underlined. b Ehrenfest informed Lorentz of the `equivalen e' result (and of Klein's (1926) theory) on 5 May 1926, when Kramers reported them in the olloquium at Leiden. Ehrenfest also mentioned the relation of this result to Lan zos's (1927) work.9 As noted above (footnote on p. 125), by 27 May Lorentz had re eived a opy of the paper dire tly from S hrödinger.
142
S hrödinger's wave me hani s
des ription of individual stationary states, his theory is not in oni t with matrix me hani s, sin e it also does not ontain the on ept of ele tron orbits.a The tone of S hrödinger's remarks and of the omments they eli it
hanges with the equivalen e paper. In a mu h-quoted footnote, S hrödinger says he had known of Heisenberg's theory but was `s ared away, not to say repelled', by the ompli ated algebrai methods and the la k of Ans hauli hkeit (1926d, p. 735). On 8 June 1926, Heisenberg sends Pauli an equally notorious (but often mis-quoted) omment: The more I ree t on the physi al part of S hrödinger's theory, the more disgusting [abs heuli h℄ I nd it. Imagine the rotating ele tron, whose harge is distributed over the whole spa e with its axis in a fourth and fth dimension.
What S hrödinger writes of the Ans hauli hkeit of his theory would [be ℄
an appropriate...
s ar ely
in other words I nd it poppy o k [Mist℄. (Pauli 1979,
p. 328)
It seems lear that, a
ording to Heisenberg, it is S hrödinger's laim of Ans hauli hkeit for his theory that is ludi rous, presumably partly be ause of the spread-out ele tron and partly be ause the waves are in
onguration spa e.a
4.6.2 From Muni h to Copenhagen In the summer of 1926, S hrödinger gave a series of talks on wave me hani s in various German universities, in parti ular, on 21 and 23 July, he talked in Muni h at the invitation of Sommerfeld and of Wien.b The des ription of a me hanism for radiation eli ited enthusiasti omments by Wien, but riti ism from Sommerfeld and from Heisenberg. The dis ussion was apparently heated, and eventually identied a ru ial a Pauli knew very early about S hrödinger's paper, having been informed by Sommerfeld, to whom at S hrödinger's request a opy of the paper had been forwarded by Wien, the editor of Annalen der Physik ( f. Pauli 1979, pp. 278 and 293). Pauli's analysis in the letter of 12 April appears to be based only on S hrödinger's rst paper on quantisation, although at least the o ial publi ation date of the se ond paper was 6 April 1926. See also the letters between Pauli and S hrödinger reprodu ed in Pauli (1979). a Alternatively, with a `fourth and fth dimension', Heisenberg might on eivably be referring to Klein's ve-dimensional extension of S hrödinger's equation (Klein 1926). As one example, here is how Moore (1989, p. 221) quotes the passage: `The more I think of the physi al part of the S hrödinger theory, the more abominable I nd it. What S hrödinger writes about Ans hauli hkeit makes s ar ely any sense, in other words I think it is bullshit [Mist℄'. b Here we follow mainly the a
ount given by Heisenberg (1946).
4.6 The oni t with matrix me hani s
143
experiment that would de ide between the idea of the ontinuous me hanism of radiation envisaged in wave me hani s and the idea of quantum jumps. This was in oherent s attering, i.e. the Raman ee t (at that time neither observed nor thus named). A
ording to the quantum predi tion (Smekal 1923, Kramers and Heisenberg 1925), in oherent s attering would exist also for atoms in the ground state, be ause the atom ould be ex ited by the in ident light. A
ording to S hrödinger instead, the ee t was due to indu ed vibrations for the ase in whi h at least two atomi frequen ies were already present, and so would not o
ur in the ground state.a Apparently, Sommerfeld and Heisenberg were `prepared to enter a bet for its existen e, while the experimental physi ists were against it and S hrödinger took a more wait-and-see attitude' (Heisenberg 1946, p. 5). In a letter to Pauli of 28 July, Heisenberg gives other spe i riti isms of S hrödinger, for throwing overboard `everything quantum theoreti al: namely photoele tri ee t, Fran k ollisions, Stern-Gerla h ee t et .' (Pauli 1979, p. 338). As a matter of fa t, in the letter to Wien of 25 August 1926, quoted above (se tion 4.3), S hrödinger admitted that he had great on eptual di ulties with the photoele tri ee t (but see below the dis ussion of S hrödinger, 1929b). Heisenberg further mentioned to Pauli that, together with S hrödinger and Wien, he had dis ussed Wien's experiments on the de ay of lumines en e (Wien 1923,
h. XX). This was another point where S hrödinger thought wave me hani s proved superior to matrix me hani s, and Heisenberg en ouraged Pauli to al ulate and publish the damping oe ients for the hydrogen spe trum.a Heisenberg mentions similar riti isms in his talk on `Quantum me hani s', given at the 89th meeting of German S ientists and Physi ians in Düsseldorf on 23 September 1926 and published in the issue of 5 November of Naturwissens haften (Heisenberg 1926 ). This talk ould be seen as a publi response to the laims that the return to a ` ontinuum theory' was possible. In it, Heisenberg addresses in parti ular the problem of Ans hauli hkeit: a
ording to Heisenberg, the usual notions a Note the implied inequivalen e of wave and matrix me hani s (despite the re ent `equivalen e proofs'). Another su h possibility of experimental inequivalen e is mentioned in the dis ussion after S hrödinger's report, with regard to the quadrupole radiation of the atom (p. 470). Cf. also Muller (1997) on the inequivalen e of the two theories. a Cf. Born and Heisenberg's report (pp. 434 and 436), where spin is onsidered to be problemati for wave me hani s, and where it is expli itly stated that Dira (1927 ) provides an explanation for the de ay experiments.
144
S hrödinger's wave me hani s
of spa e and time, and in parti ular their appli ation to physi s with the idea that spa e and matter are in prin iple ontinuously divisible, turn out to be mistaken, rst of all due to the Unans hauli hkeit of the orpus ular nature of matter, then through the theoreti al and experimental
onsiderations leading to the idea of stationary states and quantum jumps (Bohr, Fran k-Hertz, Stern-Gerla h), and nally through onsideration of radiation phenomena (Plan k's radiation formula, Einstein's light quantum, the Compton ee t and the Bothe-Geiger experiments). This issue, it is laimed, also relates losely to the question of the degree of `reality' to be as ribed to material parti les or light quanta. Quantum me hani s in its development had thus rst of all to free itself from notions of Ans hauli hkeit, in order to set up a new kind of kinemati s and me hani s. In dis ussing the wave theory, Heisenberg onsiders rst de Broglie and Einstein as having developed wave-parti le dualism for matter and having suggested the possibility of interferen e for an ensemble [S har℄ of parti les. He then explains that S hrödinger found a dierential equation for the matter waves that reprodu es the eigenvalue problem of quantum (i.e. matrix) me hani s. However, a
ording to Heisenberg, the S hrödinger theory fails to provide the link with de Broglie's ideas, that is, it fails to provide the analogy with light waves in ordinary spa e, be ause of the need to onsider waves in onguration spa e; the latter therefore have only a formal signi an e. Heisenberg refers to the laim that on the basis of S hrödinger's theory one may be able to return to `a purely ontinuous des ription of the quantum theoreti al phenomena', and ontinues (Heisenberg 1926 , p. 992): In developing onsequently this point of view one leaves in fa t the ground of de Broglie's theory, thus of Q.M. and indeed of all quantum theory and arrives in my opinion at a omplete ontradi tion with experien e (law of bla kbody radiation; dispersion theory). This route is thus not viable. The a tual reality of the de Broglie waves lies rather in the interferen e phenomena mentioned above, whi h defy any interpretation on the basis of lassi al on epts. The extraordinary physi al signi an e of S hrödinger's results lies in the realisation that an ans hauli h interpretation of the quantum me hani al formulas
ontains both typi al features of a orpus ular theory and typi al features of a wave theory.
After dis ussing quantum statisti s (`whi h in any ase represents a very bizarre further limiting of the reality of the orpus les', p. 992), Heisenberg on ludes (p. 994): In our ans hauli h interpretation of the physi al pro esses and mathemati al formulas there is a dualism between wave theory and orpus ular theory su h
4.6 The oni t with matrix me hani s
145
that many phenomena are des ribed most naturally by a wave theory of light as well as of matter, in parti ular interferen e and dira tion phenomena, while other phenomena in turn an be interpreted only on the basis of the
orpus ular theory. .... The ontradi tions of the ans hauli h interpretations of dierent phenomena ontained in the urrent s heme are ompletely unsatisfa tory. For a ontradi tion-free ans hauli h interpretation of the experiments, whi h in themselves are indeed ontradi tion-free, some essential trait in our pi ture of the stru ture of matter is urrently still missing.
After the summer, S hrödinger visited Copenhagen for an intense round of dis ussions. A
ording to Heisenberg's re onstru tion in Der Teil und das Ganze (Heisenberg 1969), S hrödinger argued with Bohr pre isely about the ne essity of nding a me hanism for radiation, while Bohr insisted that quantum jumps were ne essary for the derivation of Plan k's radiation law, as well as being dire tly observable in experiments. Heisenberg (1946, p. 6) states that the dis ussion ended with the re ognition `that an interpretation of wave me hani s without quantum jumps was impossible and that the mentioned ru ial experiment [i.e. the Raman ee t℄ in any ase would turn out in favour of the quantum jumps'.a S hrödinger in turn admitted his di ulties. In a letter to Wien of 21 O tober 1926 (quoted in Pauli 1979, p. 339), he wrote: `It is quite
ertain that the position of ans hauli h images, whi h de Broglie and I take, has not nearly been developed far enough to a
ount even just for the most important fa ts. And it is downright probable that here and there a wrong path has been taken that needs to be abandoned'. And,
ommenting in his prefa e (dated November 1926) to the rst edition of Abhandlungen zur Wellenme hanik (1926i) on the fa t that the papers were being reprinted un hanged, he invoked `the impossibility at the
urrent stage of giving an essentially more satisfa tory or even denitive new presentation'. In the meantime, both Bohr and Heisenberg were working to nd their own satisfa tory interpretation of the theory.b In parti ular as regards Heisenberg, the orresponden e with Pauli is very telling.c First of all one nds the dis ussion of Born's ollision papers (Born 1926a,b), whi h led to Heisenberg's paper on u tuation phenomena (Heisenberg 1926b). a The well-known quotation `If this damned quantum jumping is indeed to stay, then I regret having worked on this subje t at all' is reported both in Heisenberg (1946) and Heisenberg (1969). b See also se tion 3.4 above.
As noted in Pauli (1979, p. 339 and fn. 3 on p. 340), however, most of Pauli's letters to Heisenberg from this period appear to have been destroyed in the war.
146
S hrödinger's wave me hani s
As already mentioned in se tion 3.4.5, Heisenberg then reports to Pauli about Dira 's transformation theory (Dira 1927a), whi h, however, is seen only as an extraordinary formal development. The next letters from Heisenberg to Pauli are from February 1927 and in lude on 23 February the sket h of the ideas of the un ertainty paper (Pauli 1979, pp. 37681). This, as was Bohr's simultaneous development of the idea of
omplementarity, was meant to provide the ans hauli h pi ture that was still missing. Indeed, in the un ertainty paper, Heisenberg (1927, p. 172) formulates Ans hauli hkeit as the possibility of arriving at qualitative predi tions in simple ases together with formal onsisten y. With the formulation and appli ation of the un ertainty relations, he was then satised to have found su h an interpretation. In a sense, however, the un ertainty paper was also the end of the original notion of `quantum jumps' as transitions between stationary states of a system. Indeed, as had to be the ase given the generalisation of transition probabilities to arbitrary pairs of observables (and as was implied in the Heisenberg-Pauli orresponden e), the privileged role of stationary states had to give way. It is somewhat ironi that Heisenberg was to give up quantum jumps only a few months after the dis ussions with S hrödinger in Copenhagen; nevertheless, quantum me hani s thus wedded to probabilisti transitions between measurements was just as dis ontinuous as the pi ture of quantum jumps between stationary states that it repla ed, and, for S hrödinger, it was equally unsatisfa tory. Note that, for Bohr at least, wave aspe ts played a ru ial role in the resulting `Copenhagen' interpretation. Yet, just as in the ase of Born's (1926a,b) use of wave me hani s in the dis ussion of ollisions (see se tion 3.4.4), Heisenberg appears to have been onvin ed that the apparent wave aspe ts ould be interpreted entirely in matrix terms. This dieren e of opinion was ree ted in the sometimes tense dis ussions between Heisenberg and Bohr at the time, in parti ular on the topi of Heisenberg's treatment of the γ -ray mi ros ope in the un ertainty paper and the orresponding addendum in proof.a
4.6.3 Continuity and dis ontinuity Between late 1926 and the time of the Solvay onferen e, S hrödinger
ontinued to work along lines that brought out the attra tive features and sometimes the limitations of the wave pi ture. In late 1926 and a For more on this issue, see Beller (1999, pp. 714 and 13841) and Camilleri (2006). For Heisenberg's way out of the di ulty, see Heisenberg (1929, pp. 4945).
4.6 The oni t with matrix me hani s
147
early 1927, S hrödinger fo ussed on the `four-dimensional' theory, with his papers on the Compton ee t (1927a), and on the energy-momentum tensor (1927b), while he returned to the `many-dimensional' theory shortly before the Solvay onferen e, with his work on energy ex hange (1927 ) and the treatment of the many-ele tron atom presented in his report. The Compton ee t is of ourse a paradigmati example of a `dis ontinuous' phenomenon, but S hrödinger (1927a) gives it a wave me hani al treatment, by analogy with the lassi al ase of ree tion of a light wave when it en ounters a sound wave (Brillouin 1922).a As he remarks in the paper, and as remarked in the dis ussion after Compton's report, this treatment relies on the onsideration of stationary waves and does not dire tly des ribe an individual Compton ollision.b The paper on the energy-momentum tensor (1927b), following Gordon (1926), takes the Lagrangian approa h to deriving the Klein-Gordon equation, and varies also the ele tromagneti potentials, thus deriving the Maxwell equations as well. S hrödinger then onsiders in parti ular the energy-momentum tensor of the ombined Maxwell and KleinGordon elds. As he remarks (S hrödinger 1928, p. x), this is a beautiful formal development of the theory, but it heightens starkly the di ulties with the four-dimensional view, sin e one annot insert the ele tromagneti potentials thus obtained ba k into the Klein-Gordon equation. For instan e, in luding the self-eld of the ele tron in the treatment of the hydrogen atom would yield the wrong results, as S hrödinger also mentions in se tion II of his report. In this onne tion, S hrödinger states that: `The ex hange of energy and momentum between the ele tromagneti eld and matter does not in reality take pla e in a ontinuous way, as the [given℄ eldlike expression suggests' (1927b, p. 271).c A
ording to Heisenberg (1929), the further development of the four-dimensional theory was indeed purely formal, but provided a basis for the later development of quantum eld theory.d a S hrödinger had given a derivation of Brillouin's result by assuming that energy and momentum were ex hanged in the form of quanta (1924a). In the paper on the Compton ee t he now omments on how, in a sense, he is reversing his own earlier reasoning. b See in parti ular the remarks by Pauli (p. 364) and the dis ussion following S hrödinger's ontribution (p. 370). Cf. also the losing paragraph of Pauli's letter to S hrödinger of 12 De ember 1927 (Pauli 1979, p. 366).
See again the ex hange of letters between Pauli and S hrödinger in De ember 1926 (Pauli 1979, pp. 3648). d Heisenberg (1930b) in orporates into his view of quantum theory both the multi-dimensional theory and the four-dimensional theory of S hrödinger's report.
148
S hrödinger's wave me hani s
The paper on energy ex hange (1927 ), S hrödinger's last paper before the Solvay onferen e, marks an attempt to meet the riti ism that wave me hani s annot a
ount for ru ial phenomena involving `quantum jumps'. Following Dira (1926 ), S hrödinger sket hes the method of the variation of onstants, whi h he is to use also in the dis ussion of the many-ele tron atom in his Solvay report. He then applies it to the system of two atoms in resonan e dis ussed by Heisenberg (1926b) (and by Jordan (1927a)). As dis ussed in se tion 3.4, Heisenberg uses this example to show how in matrix me hani s one an indeed des ribe
hange starting from rst prin iples, in parti ular how one an determine the probabilities for quantum jumps. Now S hrödinger turns the tables around and argues that the treatment of atoms in resonan e using wave me hani s shows how one an eliminate quantum jumps from the pi ture. He argues that the two atoms ex hange energies as if they were ex hanging denite quanta. Indeed, he goes further and suggests that the idea of quantised energy itself should be reinterpreted in terms of wave frequen y,a and that resonan e phenomena are indeed the key to the `quantum postulates'. S hrödinger then pro eeds to formulate statisti al onsiderations about the distributions of the amplitudes of the two systems in resonan e, leading to the idea of the squares of the amplitudes as measures of the strength of ex itation of an eigenvalue. He then returns to resonan e onsiderations in the ase of a system
oupled to a heat bath, whi h he onsiders would su e in prin iple for the derivation of Plan k's radiation formula and of all the results of the `old quantum statisti s'. In the aftermath of the Solvay onferen e, although in pla es one nds S hrödinger at least temporarily espousing views mu h loser to those of the Copenhagen-Göttingen s hool ( f. Moore 1989, pp. 25051), S hrödinger ontinued to explore the possibilities of the wave pi ture.a The following is a telling example. In a short paper in Naturwissens haften, S hrödinger (1929b) proposes to illustrate `how the quantum theory in its newest phase again makes use of ontinuous spa etime fun tions, The latter is interpreted as a lassi al wave theory of matter that forms the ba kground for a se ond quantisation, and in ludes the ba krea tion of the self-eld via in lusion in the potential ( f. also above, fn. on p. 132). a S hrödinger had expressed the idea of energy as frequen y already in his letter to Wien of 25 August 1926: `What we all the energy of an individual ele tron is its frequen y. Basi ally it does not move with a ertain speed be ause it has re eived a ertain shove, but be ause a dispersion law holds for the waves of whi h it
onsists, as a onsequen e of whi h a wave pa ket of this frequen y has exa tly this speed of propagation' (as quoted in Moore 1989, p. 225). a Cf. also Bitbol's introdu tion in S hrödinger (1995), p. 5.
4.6 The oni t with matrix me hani s
149
indeed of properties of their form, to des ribe the state and behaviour of a system ....' (p. 487). S hrödinger quotes the example of how photo hemi al and photoele tri phenomena depend on the form of an impinging wave (i.e. on its Fourier de omposition), rather than on lo al properties of the wave at the point where it impinges on the relevant system. He argues that a ontinuous pi ture an be retained, but introdu es the idea (whi h, as he remarks, generalises without dif ulty to the ase of many-parti le wave fun tions) that the ru ial properties of wave fun tions are in fa t properties pertaining to the entire wave. S hrödinger may thus have been the rst to introdu e the idea of nonlo alisable properties, as part of the pri e to pay in order to pursue a wave pi ture of matter.
150
Notes to pp. 124141
Ar hival notes 1 Ehrenfest to Lorentz, 30 Mar h 1926, AHQP-LTZ-11 (in German). 2 S hrödinger to Lorentz, 30 Mar h 1926, AHQP-LTZ-8 (in German). 3 Vers haelt to Lefébure, 8 April 1926, IIPCS 2573 (in Fren h). 4 Lorentz to Einstein, 6 April 1926, AHQP-86 (in German). 5 Lorentz to S hrödinger, 21 January 1927, AHQP-41, se tion 9 (in German). 6 S hrödinger to Lorentz, 23 June 1927, AHQP-LTZ-13 (original with S hrödinger's orre tions) and AHQP-41, se tion 9 ( arbon opy) (in German). 7 See also S hrödinger to Lorentz, 16 July 1927, AHQP-LTZ-13 (in German). 8 S hrödinger to Lorentz, 23 June 1926, AHQP-LTZ-8 (in German). 9 Ehrenfest to Lorentz, 5 May 1926, AHQP-EHR-23 (in German).
Part II Quantum foundations and the 1927 Solvay
onferen e
5 Quantum theory and the measurement problem
5.1 What is quantum theory? For mu h of the twentieth entury, it was widely believed that the interpretation of quantum theory had been essentially settled by Bohr and Heisenberg in 1927. But not only were the `dissenters' of 1927 in parti ular de Broglie, Einstein, and S hrödinger un onvin ed at the time: similar dissenting points of view are not un ommon even today. What Popper alled `the s hism in physi s' (Popper 1982) never really healed. Soon after 1927 it be ame standard to assert that matters of interpretation had been dealt with, but the sense of puzzlement and paradox surrounding quantum theory never disappeared. As the entury wore on, many of the on erns and alternative viewpoints expressed in 1927 slowly but surely revived. In 1952, Bohm revived and extended de Broglie's theory (Bohm 1952a,b), and in 1993 the de Broglie-Bohm theory nally re eived textbook treatment as an alternative formulation of quantum theory (Bohm and Hiley 1993; Holland 1993). In 1957, Everett (1957) revived S hrödinger's view that the wave fun tion, and the wave fun tion alone, is real (albeit in a very novel sense), and the resulting `Everett' or `many-worlds' interpretation (DeWitt and Graham 1973) gradually won widespread support, espe ially among physi ists interested in quantum gravity and quantum
osmology. Theories even loser to S hrödinger's ideas ollapse theories, with ma ros opi obje ts regarded as wave pa kets whose spreading is prevented by sto hasti ollapse were developed from the 1970s onwards (Pearle 1976, 1979; Ghirardi, Rimini and Weber 1986). As for Einstein's on erns in 1927 about the nonlo ality of quantum theory (see hapter 7), re-expressed in the famous EPR paper of 1935, matters
ame to a head in 1964 with the publi ation of Bell's theorem (Bell 153
154
Quantum theory and the measurement problem
1964). In the losing de ades of the twentieth entury, after many stringent experimental tests showed that Bell's inequality was violated by entangled quantum states, nonlo ality ame to be widely regarded as a entral fa t of the quantum world. Other on erns, voi ed by S hrödinger just a few years after the fth Solvay onferen e, also eventually played a entral role after de ades of obs urity. S hrödinger's ` at paradox' of 1935 ame to dominate dis ussions about the meaning of quantum theory. And the pe uliar `entanglement' that S hrödinger had highlighted as a key dieren e between lassi al and quantum physi s (S hrödinger 1935) eventually found its pla e as a entral on ept in quantum information theory: as well as being a matter of `philosophi al' on ern, entanglement ame to be seen as a physi al resour e to be exploited for te hnologi al purposes, and as a entral feature of quantum physi s that had been strangely under-appre iated for most of the twentieth entury. The interpretation of quantum theory is probably as ontroversial now as it ever has been. Many workers now re ognise that standard quantum theory entred as it is around the notion of `measurement' requires a lassi al ba kground ( ontaining ma ros opi measuring devi es), whi h an never be sharply dened, and whi h in prin iple does not even exist. Even so, the operational approa h to the interpretation of quantum physi s is still being pursued by some, in terms of new axioms that onstrain the stru ture of quantum theory (Hardy 2001, 2002; Clifton, Bub and Halvorson 2003). On the other hand, those who do regard the ba kground problem as ru ial tend to assert that everything in the universe mi ros opi systems, ma ros opi equipment, and even human experimenters should in prin iple be des ribed in a unied manner, and that `measurement' pro esses must be regarded as physi al pro esses like any other. Approa hes of this type in lude: the Everett interpretation (Everett 1957), whi h is being subje ted to in reasing s rutiny at a foundational level (Saunders 1995, 1998; Deuts h 1999; Walla e 2003a,b); the pilot-wave theory of de Broglie and Bohm (de Broglie 1928; Bohm 1952a,b; Bohm and Hiley 1993; Holland 1993), whi h is being pursued and developed more than ever before (Cushing, Fine and Goldstein 1996; Pearle and Valentini 2006; Valentini 2007);
ollapse models (Pearle 1976, 1979, 1989; Ghirardi, Rimini and Weber 1986), whi h are being subje ted to ever more stringent experimental tests (Pearle and Valentini 2006); and theories of ` onsistent' or `de oherent' histories (Griths 1984, 2002; Gell-Mann and Hartle 1990; Hartle 1995; Omnès 1992, 1994).
5.2 The measurement problem today
155
Today, it is simply untenable to regard the views of Bohr and Heisenberg (whi h in any ase diered onsiderably from ea h other) as in any sense standard or anoni al. The meaning of quantum theory is today an open question, arguably as mu h as it was in O tober 1927.
5.2 The measurement problem today The problem of measurement and the observer is the problem of where the measurement begins and ends, and where the observer begins and ends. .... I think, that when you analyse this language that the physi ists have fallen into, that physi s is about the results of observations you nd that on analysis it evaporates, and nothing very lear is being said. J. S. Bell (1986, p. 48)
The re urring puzzlement over the meaning of quantum theory often
entres around a group of related on eptual questions that usually ome under the general heading of the `measurement problem'.
5.2.1 A fundamental ambiguity As normally presented in textbooks, quantum theory des ribes experiments in a way that is ertainly pra ti ally su
essful, but seemingly fundamentally ill-dened. For it is usually impli itly or expli itly assumed that there is a lear boundary between mi ros opi quantum systems and ma ros opi lassi al apparatus, or that there is a lear dividing line between `mi ros opi indeniteness' and the denite states of our lassi al ma ros opi realm. Yet, su h distin tions defy sharp and pre ise formulation. That quantum theory is therefore fundamentally ambiguous was argued with parti ular larity by Bell. For example (Bell 1986, p. 54): The formulations of quantum me hani s that you nd in the books involve dividing the world into an observer and an observed, and you are not told where that division omes on whi h side of my spe ta les it omes, for example or at whi h end of my opti nerve.
The problem being pointed to here is the la k of a pre ise boundary between the quantum system and the rest of the world (in luding the apparatus and the experimenter). A losely-related aspe t of the `measurement problem' is the need to explain what happens to the denite states of the everyday ma ros opi
156
Quantum theory and the measurement problem
domain as one goes to smaller s ales. Where does ma ros opi deniteness give way to mi ros opi indeniteness? Does the transition o
ur somewhere between pollen grains and ma romole ules, and if so, where? On whi h side of the line is a virus? Nor an quantum `indeniteness' or `fuzziness' be easily onned to the atomi level. For ma ros opi obje ts are made of atoms, and so inevitably one is led to doubt whether ro ks, trees, or even the Moon, have denite ma ros opi states, espe ially when observers are not present. And this in the fa e of remarkable developments in twentieth- entury astrophysi s and osmology, whi h have tra ed the origins of stars, galaxies, helium and the other elements, to times long before human observers existed. The notion of a `real state of aairs' is familiar from everyday experien e: for example, the lo ation and number of ma ros opi bodies in a laboratory. S ien e has shown that there is more to the real state of things than is immediately obvious (for example, the ele tromagneti eld). Further, it has been shown that the hara ter of the real state of things hanges with s ale: on large s ales we nd planets, stars and galaxies, while on small s ales we nd pollen grains, viruses, mole ules, and atoms. Nevertheless, at least outside of the quantum domain, the notion of `real state' remains. The ambiguity emphasised by Bell onsists of the la k of a sharp boundary between the ` lassi al' domain, in whi h `real state' is a valid on ept, and the `quantum domain', in whi h `real state' is not a valid on ept. Despite de ades of eort, this ambiguity remains unresolved within standard textbook quantum theory, and many riti s have been led to argue that the notion of real state should be extended, in some appropriate way, into the quantum domain. Thus, for example, Bell (1987, pp. 2930): Theoreti al physi ists live in a lassi al world, looking out into a quantumme hani al world. The latter we des ribe only subje tively, in terms of pro edures and results in our lassi al domain.
This subje tive des ription is
ee ted by means of quantum-me hani al state fun tions
ψ
world of ourse is des ribed quite dire tly `as it is'.
.... . The lassi al ....
Now nobody
knows just where the boundary between the lassi al and quantum domain is situated. ....
A possibility is that we nd exa tly where the boundary lies.
More plausible to me is that we will nd that there is no boundary. It is hard for me to envisage intelligible dis ourse about a world with no lassi al part no base of given events .... to be orrelated. On the other hand, it is easy to imagine that the lassi al domain ould be extended to over the whole.
5.2 The measurement problem today
157
While Bell goes on to argue in favour of adding extra (`hidden') parameters to the quantum formalism, for our purposes the key point being made here is the need to extend the notion of real state into the mi ros opi domain. This might indeed be a hieved by introdu ing hidden variables, or by other means (for example, the Everett approa h). Whatever form the theory may take, the real ma ros opi states onsidered in the rest of s ien e should be part of a unied des ription of mi ros opi and ma ros opi phenomena what Bell (1987, p. 30)
alled `a homogeneous a
ount of the world'. There are in fa t, as we have mentioned, several well-developed proposals for su h a unied or homogeneous (or `realist') a
ount of the world: the pilot-wave theory of de Broglie (1928) and Bohm (1952a,b); theories of dynami al wave-fun tion ollapse (Pearle 1976, 1979, 1989; Ghirardi, Rimini and Weber 1986); and the many-worlds interpretation of Everett (1957). The available proposals that have broad s ope assume that the wave fun tion is a real obje t that is part of the stru ture of an individual system. At the time of writing, it is not known if realist theories may be onstru ted without this feature.a
5.2.2 Measurement as a physi al pro ess: quantum theory `without observers' Another losely-related aspe t of the measurement problem is the question of how quantum theory may be applied to the pro ess of measurement itself. For it seems ines apable that it should be possible (in prin iple) to treat apparatus and observers as physi al systems, and to dis uss the pro ess of measurement in purely quantum-theoreti al terms. However, attempts to do so are notoriously ontroversial and apt to result in paradox and onfusion. For example, in the paradox of `Wigner's friend' (Wigner 1961), an experimenter A (Wigner) possesses a box ontaining an experimenter B (his friend) and a mi ros opi system S. Suppose S is initially in, for example, a superposition of energy states 1 |ψ0 i = √ (|E1 i + |E2 i) 2 a For example, a ording to the sto hasti hidden-variables theory of Fényes (1952) and Nelson (1966), the wave fun tion merely provides an emergent des ription of probabilities. However, despite appearan es, it seems that for te hni al reasons this theory is awed and does not really reprodu e quantum theory: the S hrödinger equation is obtained only for ex eptional (nodeless) wave fun tions (Wallstrom 1994; Pearle and Valentini 2006).
158
Quantum theory and the measurement problem
and that the whole box is initially in a state |Ψ0 i = |B0 i⊗|ψ0 i (idealising B as initially in a pure state |B0 i). Let B perform an ideal energy measurement on S. If A does not arry out any measurement, then from the point of view of A the quantum state of the whole box evolves ontinuously (a
ording to the S hrödinger equation) into a superposition of states 1 |Ψ(t)i = √ (|B1 i ⊗ |E1 i + |B2 i ⊗ |E2 i) (1) 2 (where |Bi i is a state su h that B has found the energy value Ei ). Now, if A wished to, ould he (in prin iple) at later times, by appropriate experiments on the whole box, observe interferen e ee ts involving both bran hes of the superposition in (1)? If so, ould this be onsistent with the point of view of B, a
ording to whi h the energy measurement had a denite result? One may well question whether the above s enario is realisti , even in prin iple (given the resour es in our universe). For example, one might question whether a box ontaining a human observer ould ever be su iently isolated for environmental de oheren e to be negligible. However, if the above `experimenter B' were repla ed by an automati devi e or ma hine, the s enario may indeed be ome realisti , depending on the possibility of isolating the box to su ient a
ura y.a Most s ientists agree that ma ros opi equipment is subje t to the laws of physi s, just like any other system, and that it should be possible to des ribe the operation of su h equipment purely in terms of the most fundamental theory available. There is somewhat less onsensus over the status of human experimenters as physi al systems. Some physi ists have suggested, in the ontext of quantum physi s, that human beings
annot be treated as just another physi al system, and that human
ons iousness plays a spe ial role. For example, Wigner (1961) on luded from his paradox that `the being with a ons iousness must have a dierent role in quantum me hani s than the inanimate measuring devi e', and that for a system ontaining a ons ious observer `the quantum me hani al equations of motion annot be linear'. Wigner's on lusion, that living beings violate quantum laws, seems in reasingly in redible given the impressive progress made in human biology and neuros ien e, in whi h the human organism in luding the brain is treated as (ultimately) a omplex ele tro- hemi al sysa It is perhaps worth remarking that, even if de oheren e has a role to play here, one has to realise what the problem is in order to understand whether and how de oheren e might ontribute to a solution ( f. Ba
iagaluppi 2005).
5.2 The measurement problem today
159
tem. There is no eviden e that human beings are able to violate, for example, the laws of gravity, or of thermodynami s, or basi prin iples of hemistry, and the on lusion that human beings in parti ular should be outside the domain of quantum laws seems di ult to a
ept. An alternative on lusion, of ourse, is that something is missing from orthodox quantum theory. Assuming, then, that human experimenters and their equipment may in prin iple be regarded as physi al systems subje t to the usual laws, their intera tion with mi rosystems ought to be analysable, and the pro ess of measurement ought to be treatable as a physi al pro ess like any other. One an then ask if, over an ensemble of similar experiments, it would be possible in prin iple for the external experimenter A to observe (at the statisti al level) interferen e ee ts asso iated with both terms in (1). To deny this possibility would be to laim (with Wigner) that a box ontaining a human being violates the laws of quantum theory. To a
ept the possibility would seem to imply that, at time t before experimenter A makes a measurement, there was (at least a
ording to A) no matter of fa t about the result of B's observation, notwithstanding the expli it supposition that B had indeed arried out an observation by time t. It is sometimes said that Wigner's paradox may be evaded by noting that, if the external experimenter A a tually performs an experiment on the whole box that reveals interferen e between the two bran hes of (1), then this operation will destroy the memory the internal experimenter B had of obtaining a parti ular result, so that there is no ontradi tion. But this misses the point. For while it is true that B will then not have any memory of having obtained a parti ular experimental result, the
ontradi tion remains with there being a purported matter of fa t (at time t) as to the result of B's observation, regardless of whether or not B has subsequently forgotten it. (Note that in this dis ussion we are talking about matters of fa t, not for mi rosystems, but for ma ros opi experimental results.) Let us examine the reasoning behind Wigner's paradox more losely. We take it that experimenter B agreed beforehand to enter the box and perform an energy measurement on the mi ros opi system S; and that it was further agreed that after su ient time had elapsed for B to perform the measurement, A would de ide whether or not to arry out an experiment showing interferen e between the two bran hes of (1). Considering an ensemble of similar experiments, the paradox onsists of
160
Quantum theory and the measurement problem
a ontradi tion between the following statements on erning the physi al state of B just before A de ides what to do: (I) There is no denite state of B, be ause A an if he wishes perform measurements showing the presen e of interferen e between dierent states of B. (II) There is a denite state of B, be ause B is a human experimenter like any other, and be ause instead of testing for interferen e A an simply ask B what he saw. The argument in (I) is the familiar one from standard quantum theory, applied to the unusual ase of a box ontaining an experimenter. The argument in (II) is unusual: it requires omment and elaboration. Be ause B is a human experimenter like any other, we are driven to onsider the theoreti al possibility that, in the distant future, some `super-experimenter' ould de ide to perform an interferen e experiment on a `box' ontaining us and our equipment. What would happen to our
urrent (ma ros opi ally-re orded) experimental fa ts on erning for example the out ome of a spin measurement performed in the laboratory? To be sure, our re ords of these experiments ould one day be erased, but it would be illogi al to suppose that the fa t of these experiments having been arried out (with denite results) ould ever be hanged. Unless we a
ept (II), we are in danger of en ountering the paradox that fa ts about what we have done in the laboratory today might later turn out not to be fa ts. Further support for (II) omes from Wigner's original argument, whi h
entred around the assumed reality of other minds. (Wigner did not regard solipsism as worthy of serious onsideration.) From this assumption Wigner inferred that, whatever the ir umstan es, if one asks a `friend' what he saw, the answer given by the friend must have been, as Wigner put it, `already de ided in his mind, before I asked him'. But then, if A de ides not to perform an interferen e experiment on the box, and simply asks B what he saw, A is obliged to take B's answer as indi ative of the state of B's mind before A asked the question indeed, before A de ided on whether or not to perform an interferen e experiment. For Wigner, a superposition of the form (1) is una
eptable for a system
ontaining a human experimenter or `friend', be ause it implies that the friend `was in a state of suspended animation before he answered my question'. As Wigner presented it, the argument is based on the assumption that
5.2 The measurement problem today
161
a ons ious being will always have a denite state of ons iousness. In orthodox quantum theory, of ourse, one might dismiss as `meaningless' the question of whether the friend's ons iousness ontained one impression or the other (B1 or B2 ) before he was asked. However, as Wigner put it, `to deny the existen e of the ons iousness of a friend to this extent is surely an unnatural attitude, approa hing solipsism'. Finally, on the topi of Wigner's paradox, it is important to emphasise the distin tion between `matters of fa t' on the one hand, and `memories' (true or false) on the other a distin tion that is omparable to the distin tion between fa ts and opinions, or between truth and belief, or between reality and appearan e, distin tions that form part and par el of the s ienti method. Thus, again, while an experimenter's memory of having obtained a ertain result might be erased in the future, the fa t that he on e obtained a ertain result will ne essarily remain a fa t: to assert otherwise would be a logi al ontradi tion. A further, more subtle motivation for treating measurement as a physi al pro ess omes from onsidering the very nature of `measurement'. As is well known to philosophers, and to experimental physi ists, the pro ess of measurement is `theory-laden'. That is, in order to know how to
arry out a measurement orre tly, or how to design a spe i measuring apparatus orre tly, some prior body of theory is required: in parti ular, one needs some understanding of how the equipment fun tions, and how it intera ts with the system being examined. For this reason, it is di ult to see how the pro ess of quantum measurement an be properly understood, without some prior body of theory that des ribes the equipment itself and its intera tion with the `system'. And sin e the equipment usually belongs to the denite ma ros opi realm, and the `system' often does not, a proper understanding seems to require a `homogeneous a
ount of the world' as dis ussed above, that is, a theory in whi h an obje tive a
ount is provided not only of the ma ros opi apparatus, but also of the mi rosystem and its intera tion with the apparatus. A ommon on lusion, then, is that a oherent a
ount of quantum measurement requires that quantum theory be somehow extended from a theory of mi rosystems to a universal physi al theory with an unbounded domain of appli ation, with our everyday ma ros opi realism being somehow extended to the mi ros opi level. Given su h a well-dened and universal physi al theory, whose subje t matter onsists of the real states of the world as a whole, it would be possible in prin iple to use the theory to analyse the pro ess of measurement as a physi al pro ess like
162
Quantum theory and the measurement problem
any other (just as, for example, lassi al ele trodynami s may be used to analyse the pro ess involving for es exerted by magneti elds by whi h an ammeter measures an ele tri urrent). Thus, for example, pilot-wave theory, or the Everett interpretation, or
ollapse models, may be applied to situations where a quantum measurement is taking pla e. If the theory provides an unambiguous a
ount of obje tive pro esses in general, it will provide an unambiguous a
ount of the quantum measurement pro ess in parti ular. The result is a quantum theory `without observers', in the sense that observers are physi al systems obeying the same laws as all other systems, and do not have to be added to the theory as extra-physi al elements. Con lusions as to what is a tually happening during quantum measurements will, of ourse, depend on the details of the theory. For example, onsider again Wigner's s enario above. In the Everett interpretation, B's observation within the box has two results, and there is no ontradi tion if the external experimenter A subsequently observes interferen e between them. In de Broglie-Bohm theory, B's observation has only one result sele ted by the a tual onguration, but even so the empty wave pa ket still exists in onguration spa e, and an in prin iple re-overlap with (and hen e interfere with) the o
upied pa ket if appropriate Hamiltonians are applied.
5.2.3 Quantum osmology Further losely-related questions, again broadly under the heading of the `measurement problem', on ern the des ription of the distant past before human beings and other life forms evolved on Earth, and indeed the des ription of the universe as a whole in epo hs before life existed. While the basi theoreti al foundations of big-bang osmology had already been laid by 1927 (through the work of Friedmann and Lemaître), at that time any suggestion of the need to provide a quantum-theoreti al a
ount of the early universe ould easily have been dismissed as being of no pra ti al or experimental import. By the 1980s, however, with the development of inationary osmology (Guth 1981), the theoreti al question be ame a pra ti al one, with observational impli ations. A
ording to our urrent understanding, the small non-uniformities of temperature observed in the osmi mi rowave ba kground originated from lassi al density perturbations in the early (and approximately homogenous) universe (Padmanabhan 1993). And a
ording to inationary theory, those early lassi al density perturbations originated from
5.2 The measurement problem today
163
quantum u tuations at even earlier times (Liddle and Lyth 2000). Here we have an example of a osmologi al theory in whi h a `quantum-to lassi al transition' o
urred long before life (or even galaxies) developed, and whose details have left an imprint on the sky that an be measured today. This is the measurement problem on a osmi s ale (Kiefer, Polarski and Starobinsky 1998; Perez, Sahlmann and Sudarsky 2006; Valentini 2006). But the tension between `Copenhagen' quantum theory and the requirements of osmology was felt long before osmology matured as an experimental s ien e. Thus, for example, in his pioneering work in the 1960s on quantum gravity, when it ame to applying the theory to a
losed universe DeWitt wrote (DeWitt 1967, p. 1131): The Copenhagen view depends on the assumed
a priori
existen e of a lassi al
level to whi h all questions of observation may ultimately be referred. Here, however, the whole universe is the obje t of inspe tion; there is no lassi al vantage point, and hen e the interpretation question must be re-argued from the beginning.
DeWitt went on to argue (pp. 11402) that, in the absen e of a lassi al level, the Everett interpretation should be adopted. A
ording to DeWitt (p. 1141): Everett's view of the world is a very natural one to adopt in the quantum theory of gravity, where one is a
ustomed to speak without embarrassment of the `wave fun tion of the universe'.
While DeWitt expresses a preferen e for the Everett interpretation, for our purposes the entral point being made is that, if the whole universe is treated as a quantum obje t, with no denite ( lassi al) ba kground `to whi h all questions of observation may ultimately be referred', then the physi s be omes unintelligible unless some form of real state (or ontology) is as ribed to the quantum obje t. The Everett interpretation provides one way, among others, to do this.a Everett himself, in 1957, had already ited the quantum theory of
osmology as one of his main motivations for going beyond what he alled the ` onventional or external observation formulation of quantum me hani s' (Everett 1957, p. 454). Everett's general motivation was the need to des ribe the quantum physi s internal to an isolated system, in a Everett's original formulation was of ourse open to a number of riti isms, in parti ular on erning the notion of `world' and the idea of probability. Su h riti isms are arguably being met only through more re ent developments (Saunders 1995, 1998; Deuts h 1999; Walla e 2003a,b).
164
Quantum theory and the measurement problem
parti ular one ontaining observers. A losed universe was a spe ial ase of su h a system, and one that arguably would have to be onsidered as the s ien e of osmology progressed (as has indeed proved to be the
ase). Thus Everett wrote (p. 455): How is one to apply the onventional formulation of quantum me hani s to the spa e-time geometry itself ?
The issue be omes espe ially a ute in the
ase of a losed universe. There is no pla e to stand outside the system to observe it. There is nothing outside it to produ e transitions from one state to another. .... No way is evident to apply the onventional formulation of quantum me hani s to a system that is not subje t to
external
observation.
The whole interpretive s heme of that formalism rests upon the notion of external observation.
The probabilities of the various possible out omes of
the observation are pres ribed ex lusively by Pro ess 1 [dis ontinuous wave fun tion ollapse℄.
In more re ent years, similar on erns have motivated the development of a `generalised quantum me hani s' based on ` onsistent' or `de oherent' histories (Griths 1984, 2002; Gell-Mann and Hartle 1990; Hartle 1995; Omnès 1992, 1994), an approa h that is also supposed to provide a quantum theory `without observers', and without a presumed lassi al ba kground, so as to be appli able to quantum osmology.
5.2.4 The measurement problem in `statisti al' interpretations of ψ The measurement problem is often posed simply as the problem of how to interpret a ma ros opi superposition of quantum states, su h as (pure) states of S hrödinger's at. This way of posing the measurement problem
an be misleading, however, as it usually rests on the impli it assumption (or suggestion) that the quantum wave fun tion ψ is a real physi al obje t identiable as a omplete des ription of an individual system. It might be that ψ is indeed a real obje t, but not a omplete des ription (as in pilot-wave theory). Or, ψ might not be a real obje t at all. Here we fo us on the latter possibility. The quantum wave fun tion ψ might be merely a mathemati al tool for al ulating and predi ting the measured frequen ies of out omes over an ensemble of similar experiments. In whi h ase, it would be immediately wrong to interpret a mathemati al superposition of terms in ψ as somehow orresponding to a physi al superposition of real states for individual systems, and the `measurement problem' in the limited sense just mentioned would be a pseudo-problem. This `statisti al in-
5.2 The measurement problem today
165
terpretation' of quantum theory has been hampioned in parti ular by Ballentine (1970). However, even in the statisti al interpretation, the `measurement problem' in the more general sense remains. For quantum theory is then an in omplete theory that refers only to ensembles, and simply does not fully des ribe individual quantum systems or their relation to real, individual ma ros opi states. The statisti al interpretation gives no a
ount of what happens, for example, when an individual ele tron is being measured: it talks only about the distribution of (ma ros opi allyregistered) measurement out omes over an ensemble of similar experiments. Nor does the statisti al interpretation provide any sharp delineation of the boundary between `ma ros opi ' obje ts with an individual (non-ensemble) des ription and `mi ros opi ' obje ts with no su h des ription.a In the statisti al interpretation, then, a solution of the measurement problem in the general sense will require the development of a omplete des ription of individual systems. This was Einstein's point of view (Einstein 1949, pp. 6712): The attempt to on eive the quantum-theoreti al des ription as the omplete des ription of the individual systems leads to unnatural theoreti al interpretations, whi h be ome immediately unne essary if one a
epts the interpretation that the des ription refers to ensembles of systems and not to individual systems. .... [I℄t appears unavoidable to look elsewhere for a omplete des ription of the individual system .... .
Einstein was arguably the founder of the statisti al interpretation.b It should be noted, however, that while Einstein's on lusion about the nature of ψ might turn out to be orre t, what seems to have been his main argument for this on lusion now appears to be wrong, in that it was based on what now appears to be a false premise the assumption of lo ality. For example, in a letter to his friend Mi hele Besso, dated 8 O tober 1952, Einstein argued that the `quantum state' ψ ould not be a omplete hara terisation of the `real state' of an individual system, on the following grounds: A system
S2 ,
S12 ,
with known fun tion
whi h at time
t
ψ12 ,
is omposed of subsystems
S1
and
are far away from ea h other. If one makes a ` omplete'
a There are dierent ways of onsidering a `statisti al' interpretation, depending on one's point of view on erning the nature of probability. In any ase, the `measurement problem' in the general sense still stands. b Cf. Ballentine (1972).
166
Quantum theory and the measurement problem
S1 , this an be done in dierent ways .... . From the meaand the ψ -fun tion ψ12 , one an determine .... the ψ -fun tion ψ2 of the se ond system. This will take on dierent forms, a
ording to the kind of measurement applied to S1 .
measurement on surement result
But this is in ontradi tion with assumption (1) [that the quantum state
hara terises the real state ompletely℄, Then in fa t the measurement on
S2 ,
S1
if one ex ludes a tion at a distan e.
an have no inuen e on the real state of
and therefore a
ording to (1) an have also no inuen e on the quantum
state of
S2
des ribed by
ψ2 .
(Einstein and Besso 1972, pp. 4878, emphasis
in the original)
Einstein's argument hinges on the fa t that, in a lo al physi s, the measurement made on S1 an have no ee t on the real state of S2 .a With the development of Bell's theorem, however, it seems to be beyond reasonable doubt that quantum physi s is not lo al (if one assumes the absen e of ba kwards ausation or of many worlds). For if lo ality is assumed, one may use the EPR argument to infer determinism for the out omes of quantum measurements at widely-separated wings of an entangled state.b Following further reasoning by Bell (1964), one may then show that any lo al and deterministi ompletion of quantum theory annot reprodu e quantum orrelations for all measurements on entangled states. Therefore, lo ality ontradi ts quantum theory.c Be ause the premise of Einstein's argument ontradi ts quantum theory, the argument annot be used to infer anything about quantum theory or about the nature of ψ . Thus, Einstein's argument does not establish the `statisti al' or `ensemble' nature of ψ .d a The notion of lo ality that Einstein uses here is, to be pre ise, a ombination of the prin iples of `separability' (that widely-separated systems have lo ally-dened real states) and of `no a tion at a distan e'. Cf. Howard (1990). b `It is important to note that .... determinism .... in the EPR argument .... is not assumed but inferred [from lo ality℄. .... It is remarkably di ult to get this point a ross, that determinism is not a presupposition of the analysis' (Bell 1987, p. 143, itali s in the original).
See, however, Fine (1999) for a dissenting view. d Einstein's argument above has re ently been revived by Fu hs (2002) (who is, however, not expli it about the ompleteness or in ompleteness of quantum theory). Fu hs states (p. 9) that Einstein `was the rst person to say in absolutely unambiguous terms why the quantum state should be viewed as information .... . His argument was simply that a quantum-state assignment for a system an be for ed to go one way or the other by intera ting with a part of the world that should have no ausal onne tion with the system of interest'. Fu hs then quotes at length (p. 10) the above letter by Einstein. Later in the same paper, Fu hs writes (p. 39): `Re all what I viewed to be the most powerful argument for the quantum state's subje tivity the Einsteinian argument of [the above letter℄. Sin e [for entangled systems℄ we an toggle the quantum state from a distan e, it must not be something sitting over there, but rather something sitting over here: It an only be our information about the far-away system'. Again, the premise
5.2 The measurement problem today
167
of this Einsteinian argument lo ality is nowadays no longer reasonable (as of
ourse it was in 1952), and so the argument annot be used to infer the subje tive or epistemi nature of the quantum state.
6 Interferen e, superposition, and wave pa ket ollapse
6.1 Probability and interferen e A
ording to Feynman (1965, hap. 1, p. 1), single-parti le interferen e is `the only mystery' of quantum theory. Feynman onsidered an experiment in whi h parti les are red, one at a time, towards a s reen with two holes labelled 1 and 2. With both holes open, the distribution P12 of parti les at the ba kstop displays an os illatory pattern of bright and dark fringes. If P1 is the distribution with only hole 1 open, and P2 is the distribution with only hole 2 open, then experimentally it is found that P12 6= P1 + P2 . A
ording to the argument given by Feynman (as well as by many other authors), this result is inexpli able by ` lassi al' reasoning. By his presentation of the two-slit experiment (as well as by his development of the path-integral formulation of quantum theory), Feynman popularised the idea that the usual probability al ulus breaks down in the presen e of quantum interferen e, where it is probability amplitudes (and not probabilities themselves) that are to be added. As pointed out by Koopman (1955), and by Ballentine (1986), this argument is mistaken: the probability distributions at the ba kstop P12 , P1 and P2 are onditional probabilities with three distin t onditions (both slits open, one or other slit losed), and probability al ulus does not imply any relationship between these. Feynman's argument notwithstanding, standard probability al ulus is perfe tly onsistent with the two-slit experiment. In his inuential le tures on physi s, as well as asserting the breakdown of probability al ulus, Feynman laimed that no theory with parti le traje tories ould explain the two-slit experiment. This laim 168
6.1 Probability and interferen e
169
is still found in many textbooks.a From a histori al point of view, it is remarkable indeed that single-parti le interferen e ame to be widely regarded as in onsistent with any theory ontaining parti le traje tories: for as we have seen in hapter 2, in the ase of ele trons this phenomenon was in fa t rst predi ted (by de Broglie) on the basis of pre isely su h a theory. As we shall now dis uss, in his report at the fth Solvay onferen e de Broglie gave a lear and simple explanation for single-parti le interferen e on the basis of his pilot-wave theory; and the extensive dis ussions at the onferen e ontain no sign of any obje tion to the onsisten y of de Broglie's position on this point. As for S hrödinger's theory of wave me hani s, in whi h parti les were supposed to be onstru ted out of lo alised wave pa kets, in retrospe t it is di ult to see how single-parti le interferen e ould have been a
ounted for. It is then perhaps not surprising that, in Brussels in 1927, no spe i dis ussion of interferen e appears in S hrödinger's
ontributions. Born and Heisenberg, on the other hand, do dis uss interferen e in their report, from the point of view of their `quantum me hani s'. And, they do onsider the question of the appli ability of probability al ulus. The views they present are, interestingly enough, rather dierent from the views usually asso iated with quantum me hani s today. In parti ular, as we shall see below, a
ording to Born and Heisenberg there was (in a very spe i sense) no oni t between quantum interferen e and the ordinary probability al ulus. Interferen e was also onsidered in the general dis ussion, in parti ular by Dira and Heisenberg: this latter material will be dis ussed later, in se tion 6.3.
6.1.1 Interferen e in de Broglie's pilot-wave theory At the fth Solvay onferen e, the subje t of interferen e was addressed from a pilot-wave perspe tive by de Broglie in his report. In his se tion 5, `The interpretation of interferen e', de Broglie onsidered interferen e experiments with light of a given frequen y ν . For a guiding wave Ψ a For example, Shankar (1994) dis usses the two-slit experiment at length in his
hapter 3, and laims (p. 111) that the observed single-photon interferen e pattern ` ompletely rules out the possibility that photons move in well-dened traje tories'. Further, a
ording to Shankar (p. 112): `It is now widely a
epted that all parti les are des ribed by probability amplitudes ψ(x), and that the assumption that they move in denite traje tories is ruled out by experiment'.
170
Interferen e, superposition, and ollapse
of phase φ and amplitude a, de Broglie took the photon velo ity to be c2 given by v = − hν ∇φ, while the probability distribution was taken to be π = const·a2 . As de Broglie had pointed out, the latter distribution is preserved over time by the assumed motion of the photons. Therefore, the usual interferen e and dira tion patterns follow immediately. To quote de Broglie (p. 385): the bright and dark fringes predi ted by the new theory will oin ide with those predi ted by the old [that is, by lassi al wave opti s℄.
De Broglie also pointed out that his theory gave the orre t bright and dark fringes for photon interferen e experiments, regardless of whether the experiments were performed with an intense or a very feeble sour e. As he put it (p. 385): one an do an experiment of short duration with intense irradiation, or an experiment of long duration with feeble irradiation .... if the light quanta do not a t on ea h other the statisti al result must evidently be the same.
De Broglie's dis ussion here addresses pre isely the supposed di ulty highlighted mu h later by Feynman. It is noteworthy that a lear and simple answer to what Feynman thought was `the only mystery' of quantum me hani s was published as long ago as the 1920s. Even so, for the rest of the twentieth entury, the two-slit experiment was widely ited as proof of the non-existen e of parti le traje tories in the quantum domain. Su h traje tories were thought to imply the relation P12 = P1 + P2 , whi h is violated by experiment. As Feynman (1965, hap. 1, p. 6) put it, on the basis of this argument it should `undoubtedly' be on luded that: `It is not true that the ele trons go either through hole 1 or hole 2'. Feynman also suggested that, by 1965, there had been a long history of failures to explain interferen e in terms of traje tories: Many ideas have been on o ted to try to explain the urve for
P12
[that
is, the interferen e pattern℄ in terms of individual ele trons going around in
ompli ated ways through the holes. None of them has su
eeded. (Feynman 1965, hap. 1, p. 6)
Yet, de Broglie's onstru tion is so simple as to be almost trivial: the 2 quantum probability density |ψ| for parti le position obeys a ontinuity equation, with a lo al probability urrent; if the traje tories follow the ow lines of the quantum urrent then, by onstru tion, an in ident 2 distribution |ψ0 | of parti les will ne essarily evolve into a distribution
6.1 Probability and interferen e
171
2
|ψ| at the ba kstop with interferen e or dira tion, as the ase may be, depending on the potential in whi h the wave ψ evolves. Not only did Feynman laim, wrongly, that no one had ever su
eeded in explaining interferen e in terms of traje tories; he also gave an argument to the ee t that any su h explanation was impossible: Suppose we were to assume that inside the ele tron there is some kind of ma hinery that determines where it is going to end up. That ma hine must
also
determine whi h hole it is going to go through on its way. But .... what
is inside the ele tron should not be dependent .... upon whether we open or
lose one of the holes. So if an ele tron, before it starts, has already made up its mind (a) whi h hole it is going to use, and (b) where it is going to land, we should nd
P1
for those ele trons that have hosen hole 1,
P2
that have hosen hole 2,
and ne essarily
through the two holes.
There seems to be no way around this.
the sum
P1 + P2
for those
for those that arrive (Feynman
1965, hap. 1, p. 10)
Feynman's argument assumes that the motion of the ele tron is unae ted by opening or losing one of the holes. This assumption is violated in pilot-wave theory, where the form of the guiding wave behind the two-slit s reen does depend on whether or not both slits are open. A similar assumption is made in the dis ussion of the two-slit experiment by Heisenberg (1962), in hapter III of his book Physi s and Philosophy. Heisenberg onsiders single photons in ident on a s reen with two small holes and a photographi plate on the far side, and gives the familiar argument that the existen e of parti le traje tories implies the non-interfering result P1 + P2 . As Heisenberg puts it: If [a single photon℄ goes through the rst hole and is s attered there, its probability for being absorbed at a ertain point of the photographi plate
annot depend upon whether the se ond hole is losed or open. (Heisenberg 1962)
This assertion is denied by pilot-wave theory, whi h provides a simple
ounterexample to Heisenberg's on lusion that `the statement that any light quantum must have gone either through the rst or through the se ond hole is problemati and leads to ontradi tions'. Finally, we note that interferen e was also onsidered by Brillouin (pp. 402 .) in the dis ussion following de Broglie's report, for the ase of photons ree ted by a mirror. Brillouin drew a gure (p. 404), with a sket h of a photon traje tory passing through an interferen e region. To our knowledge, plots of traje tories in ases of interferen e did not appear again in the literature until the pioneering numeri al work by Philippidis, Dewdney and Hiley (1979).
172
Interferen e, superposition, and ollapse
6.1.2 Interferen e in the `quantum me hani s' of Born and Heisenberg The subje t of interferen e was onsidered by Born and Heisenberg, in their report on quantum me hani s (pp. 424 f.), for the ase of an atom initially in a superposition X |ψ(0)i = (1) cn (0) |ni n
of energy states |ni, with oe ients cn (0) = |cn (0)| eiγn and eigenvalues En . The S hrödinger equation implies a time evolution X cn (t) = (2) Snm (t)cm (0) m
with (in modern notation) Snm (t) = hn| U (t, 0) |mi, where U (t, 0) is the evolution operator. In the spe ial ase where cm (0) = δmk for some k , we 2 2 2 have |cn (t)| = |Snk (t)| , and Born and Heisenberg interpret |Snk (t)| as a transition probability. They also draw the on lusion that `the |cn (t)|2 must be the state probabilities' (p. 424). Born and Heisenberg seem to adopt a statisti al interpretation, a
ording to whi h the system is always in a denite energy state, with 2 jump probabilities |Snk (t)| and o
upation (or `state') probabilities 2 |cn (t)| ( f. se tion 3.4.6). This is stated quite expli itly (p. 423): From the point of view of Bohr's theory a system an always be in only
one
quantum state. .... A
ording to Bohr's prin iples it makes no sense to say a system is simultaneously in several states. The only possible interpretation seems to be statisti al: the superposition of several eigensolutions expresses that through the perturbation the initial state an go over to any other quantum state .... .
Note that this is quite dierent from present-day quantum me hani s, in whi h a system des ribed by the superposition (1) would not normally be regarded as always o
upying only one energy state. At the same time, Born and Heisenberg re ognise a di ulty (p. 424): Here, however, one runs into a di ulty of prin iple that is of great importan e, as soon as one starts from an initial state for whi h not all the
cn (0)
ex ept one vanish.
The di ulty, of ourse, is that for an initial superposition the nal probability distribution is given by X 2 |cn (t)|2 = (3) Snm (t)cm (0) m
6.1 Probability and interferen e
173
|cn (t)|2 =
(4)
as opposed to X m
|Snm (t)|2 |cm (0)|2
whi h, as Born and Heisenberg remark, `one might suppose from the usual probability al ulus'. (In standard probability al ulus, of ourse, (4) expresses |cn (t)|2 as a sum over onditional transition probabilities 2 2 |Snm (t)| weighted by the initial population probabilities |cm (0)| .) While Born and Heisenberg refer to (3) as the `theorem of the interferen e of probabilities', they make the remarkable assertion that there is in fa t no ontradi tion with the usual rules of probability al ulus, and 2 that the |Snm | may still be regarded as ordinary probabilities. Further, and equally remarkably, it is laimed that in any ase where the state probabilities |cn |2 are experimentally established, the presen e of the unknown phases γn makes the interfering expression (3) redu e to the non-interfering expression (4) (p. 425): .... it should be noted that this `interferen e' does not represent a ontradi tion with the rules of the probability al ulus, that is, with the assumption that 2 the |Snk | are quite usual probabilities. In fa t, .... [(4)℄ follows from the
on ept of probability .... when and only when the relative number, that is, the |cn |2 of the atoms in the state n, has been established beforehand
probability
experimentally.
In this ase the phases
γn
are unknown in prin iple, so that
[(3)℄ then naturally goes over to [(4)℄.... .
Here, Born and Heisenberg refer to Heisenberg's (re ently-published) un ertainty paper, whi h ontains a similar laim. There, Heisenberg
onsiders a Stern-Gerla h atomi beam passing through two su
essive regions of eld inhomogeneous in the dire tion of the beam (so as to indu e transitions between energy states without separating the beam into omponents). If the input beam is in a denite energy state then the beam emerging from the rst region will be in a superposition. The probability distribution for energy emerging from the se ond region will then ontain interferen e as in (3), where the `initial' superposition (1) is now the state emerging from the rst region. Heisenberg asserts that, if the energy of an atom is a tually measured between the two regions, then be ause of the resulting perturbation `the phase of the atom hanges by amounts that are in prin iple un ontrollable' (Heisenberg 1927, pp. 183 4), and averaging over the unknown phases in the nal superposition yields a non-interfering result. The same example, with the same phase randomisation argument, is also given by Heisenberg (1930b) in his book The Physi al Prin iples
174
Interferen e, superposition, and ollapse
of the Quantum Theory ( hapter IV, se tion 2), whi h was based on le tures delivered at Chi ago in 1929. Heisenberg asserts (p. 60) that an energy measurement for an atom in the intermediate region `will ne essarily alter the phase of the de Broglie wave of the atom in state m by an unknown amount of order of magnitude one', so that in applying the (analogue of the) interfering expression (3) ea h term in the sum `must thus be multiplied by the arbitrary fa tor exp (iϕm ) and then averaged over all values of ϕm '. From a modern perspe tive, this argument seems strange and unfamiliar, and indeed quite wrong. However, the argument makes rather more sense, if one re ognises that the `quantum me hani s' des ribed by Born and Heisenberg is not quantum me hani s as we usually know it today. In parti ular, the theory as they present it appears to ontain no notion of wave pa ket ollapse (or state ve tor redu tion). The argument given by Born and Heisenberg amounts to saying, in modern language, that if the energies of an atomi population have a tually been measured, then one will have a mixture of states of the superposed form (1), with randomly-distributed phases γn . Su h a mixture is indeed statisti ally equivalent to a mixture of energy states |ni with weights |cn (0)|2 , be ause the density operators are the same: ! X Y 1 Z |cn (0)| |cm (0)| ei(γn −γm ) |ni hm| = dγk 2π n,m k X 2 |cn (0)| |ni hn| . (5) n
However, from a modern point of view, if one did measure the atomi energies and nd the value En with frequen y pn , the resulting total ensemble would naturally be represented by a density operator ρ = P n pn |ni hn|, and there would seem to be no parti ular reason to rewrite this in terms of the alternative de omposition on the left-hand side of (5) (with |cn (0)|2 = pn and random phases eiγn ); though of ourse one ould if one wished to. What is more, an a tual in onsisten y would appear if having measured the atomi energies one sele ted a parti ular atom that was found to have energy Em : a subsequent and immediate energy measurement for this parti ular atom should again yield the result Em with ertainty, as is onsistent with the usual representation of the atom by the state |mi, and this ertainty would be in onsistent with what appears to be (at least in ee t) the proposed representation of the atom P by a state n |cn (0)| eiγn |ni with randomised phases γn . Indeed, for any
6.1 Probability and interferen e
175
subensemble omposed of the latter states, all the energy values present in the sum will be possible out omes of subsequent and immediate energy measurements.a This in onsisten y arises, however, if one applies the modern notion of state ve tor ollapse a notion that, upon lose examination, appears to be quite absent from the theory presented by Born and Heisenberg. Instead of applying the usual ollapse rule, Born and Heisenberg seem to interpret the quantities |Snm |2 as `quite usual' transition probabilities in all ir umstan es, even in the presen e of interferen e. On this view, then, an atom that has been found to have energy Em an be represented P by a state n |cn (0)| eiγn |ni with randomised phases γn , and the probability of obtaining a value En in an immediately su
essive measurement is given not by |cn (0)|2 (as would follow from the usual ollapse rule) 2 but by the transition probability |Snm | where the latter does indeed approa h δnm as the time interval between the two energy measurements tends to zero, so that the above ontradi tion does not in fa t arise. Considering now the whole atomi ensemble, if the energies of the atoms have indeed been measured, then using the |Snm |2 as transition 2 probabilities and the |cm (0)| as population probabilities, appli ation of the probability al ulus gives the non-interfering result (4). As noted by Born and Heisenberg, on their view exa tly the same result is obtained from the `interfering' expression (3), with random phases γm appearing in the oe ients cm (0) = |cm (0)| eiγm . If instead the atomi energies have not been measured, then, a
ording to Born and Heisenberg, the phases γm have not been randomised and the expression (3) does show interferen e, in ontradi tion with the noninterfering expression (4). How do Born and Heisenberg re on ile the breakdown of (4) with their laim that the ordinary probability al ulus still holds, with the |Snm |2 being quite ordinary probabilities? The answer seems to be that, if the energies have not been measured, then the population probabilities |cm (0)|2 are in some sense ill-dened, so that the usual probability formula (4) simply annot be applied: `[(4)℄ follows from the on ept of probability .... when and only when .... the probability |cn |2 .... has been established beforehand experimentally'. Born and Heisenberg seem to take an `operational' view of the populaa Of ourse, if we do not subdivide the atomi ensemble on the basis of the measured energies, the total ensemble will be a mixture with density operator P 2 n |cn (0)|P|ni hn| and will indeed be indistinguishable from the proposed mixture iγn |ni with randomly-distributed phases. of states But there is n |cn (0)| e nothing to prevent an experimenter from sele ting atoms a
ording to their measured energies.
176
Interferen e, superposition, and ollapse
tion probabilities, in the sense that these are to be regarded as meaningful only when dire tly measured. And the ited argument in Heisenberg's un ertainty paper suggests that it is operationally impossible to have simultaneously well-dened phase relations and population probabilities in the same experiment. This impossibility was presumably regarded as
omparable to the (operational) impossibility of having simultaneously a well-dened position and momentum for a parti le. What seems to be at work here, then, is some form of un ertainty relation (or omplementarity) between population probabilities and phases: measurement of the former makes the latter ill-dened, and vi e versa. Interferen e requires denite phase relationships, whi h pre lude a well-dened population probability, so that the ordinary probability al ulus annot be applied.a If instead the population probability has a tually been measured, then the phases are indenite and averaging over them washes out any interferen e. The resulting viewpoint is ertainly remarkable. A
ording to Born 2 and Heisenberg, in the presen e of interferen e, the quantities |Snm |
ontinue to be quite ordinary (transition) probabilities, while the quanti2 ties |cm (0)| annot be regarded as population probabilities rendering the formula (4) inappli able. On this view, ordinary probability al ulus is not violated; it is simply wrong to assert that the |cm (0)|2 represent state probabilities in an interfering ase. One may well obje t to this point of view on the grounds that, even without measuring the energies, for a given preparation of the state (1) the oe ients cm (0) and hen e the values of |cm (0)|2 will be known (up to an overall phase). However, presumably, Born and Heisenberg would have had to assert that while the |cm (0)|2 always exist as mathemati al quantities, they annot be properly interpreted as population probabilities unless the energies have been measured dire tly. From a modern perspe tive, Born and Heisenberg's treatment of interferen e is surprising: in modern quantum me hani s, of ourse, in ases where interferen e o
urs the quantities |Snm |2 would not normally be interpreted as `quite usual' transition probabilities; while in ases where interferen e does not o
ur, the non-interfering result (4) (as applied a There is an analogy here with Heisenberg's view of ausality, expressed in his un ertainty paper, a
ording to whi h ausality annot be applied be ause its premiss is generally false: `.... in the sharp formulation of the law of ausality, If we know the present exa tly, we an al ulate the future, it is not the onsequent that is wrong, but the ante edent. We annot in prin iple get to know the present in all [its℄ determining data' (Heisenberg 1927, p. 197).
6.2 Ma ros opi superposition: Born's dis ussion of the loud hamber 177 here) would not normally be regarded as arising from the interfering result (3) through a pro ess of phase randomisation.
6.2 Ma ros opi superposition: Born's dis ussion of the loud
hamber Quantum theory is normally understood to allow the `superposition of distin t physi al states'. However, while `superposition' is well-dened as a mathemati al term, it is hard to make sense of when applied to physi al states that is, when the omponents in a superposition are regarded as simultaneous physi al attributes of a single system. The need to understand su h `physi al superposition' seems parti ularly a ute when it is onsidered at the ma ros opi level. The di ulty here is losely related to the question of wave pa ket ollapse: how is a mathemati al superposition of ma ros opi ally-distin t states related to the denite ma ros opi states seen in the laboratory? The Wilson loud hamber, as used to observe the tra ks of α-parti les, was dis ussed at length by Born in the general dis ussion. The loud
hamber illustrates the measurement problem rather well, and is a good example of how mi ros opi superpositions an be ome transferred to the ma ros opi domain. It also illustrates how extending the formal quantum des ription to the environment does not by itself alleviate the measurement problem (despite many laims to the ontrary, for example Zurek (1991)).a Remarkably, as we shall see, Born asserts that wave pa ket ollapse is not required to dis uss the loud hamber. The me hanism of the loud hamber is well known. The α-parti les pass through a supersaturated vapour. The passage of the parti les
auses ionisation, and the vapour ondenses around the ions, resulting in the formation of tiny droplets. The droplets s atter light, making the parti le tra ks visible. If the emission of an α-parti le is undire ted, so that the emitted wave fun tion is approximately spheri al, how does one a
ount for the approximately straight parti le tra k revealed by the loud hamber? In the general dis ussion, Born attributes this question to Einstein, and asserts that to answer it (p. 483) ....
one must appeal to the notion of `redu tion of the probability pa ket'
developed by Heisenberg.
a For a summary of riti isms of environmental de oheren e as a solution to the measurement problem, see Ba
iagaluppi (2005).
178
Interferen e, superposition, and ollapse
This notion appears in Heisenberg's un ertainty paper, whi h had been published in May of 1927. In se tion 3, entitled `The transition from mi ro- to ma rome hani s', Heisenberg had des ribed how a lassi al ele tron orbit ` omes into being' through repeated observation of the ele tron position, using light of wavelength λ. A
ording to Heisenberg, the result of ea h observation an be hara terised by a probability pa ket of width λ, where the pa ket spreads freely until the next observation: `Every determination of position redu es therefore the wave pa ket ba k to its original size λ' (Heisenberg 1927, p. 186). In the ase of the loud hamber, the ollapse of the wave pa ket is applied repeatedly to the α-parti le alone. Upon produ ing visible ionisation, the wave pa ket of the α-parti le ollapses, and then starts to spread again, until further visible ionisation is produ ed, whereupon
ollapse o
urs again, and so on. The probability for the resulting `traje tory' is on entrated along straight lines, a
ounting for the observed tra k in the loud hamber. As Born puts it (p. 483): The des ription of the emission by a spheri al wave is valid only for as long as one does not observe ionisation; as soon as su h ionisation is shown by the appearan e of loud droplets, in order to des ribe what happens afterwards one must `redu e' the wave pa ket in the immediate vi inity of the drops. One thus obtains a wave pa ket in the form of a ray, whi h orresponds to the
orpus ular hara ter of the phenomenon.
Here, the loud hamber itself the ionisation, and the formation of droplets from the vapour is treated as if it were an external ` lassi al apparatus': only the α-parti le appears in the wave fun tion.
6.2.1 Quantum me hani s without wave pa ket ollapse? Born goes on to onsider if wave pa ket redu tion an be avoided by treating the atoms of the loud hamber, along with the α-parti le, as a single system des ribed by quantum theory, a suggestion that he attributes to Pauli (p. 483): Mr Pauli has asked me if it is not possible to des ribe the pro ess without the redu tion of wave pa kets, by resorting to a multi-dimensional spa e, whose number of dimensions is three times the number of all the parti les present .... . This is in fa t possible .... but this does not lead us further as regards the fundamental questions.
Remarkably, Born laims that a treatment without redu tion is `in fa t' possible, and goes on to illustrate how, in his opinion, this an be
6.2 Ma ros opi superposition
179
done. As we shall see, Born seems to make use of a ` lassi al' probability redu tion only, without any redu tion for the onguration-spa e wave pa ket. As for Born's referen e to Pauli, around the time of the Solvay onferen e Pauli believed that wave pa ket redu tion was needed only for des ribing subsystems. This is lear from a letter he wrote to Bohr, on 17 O tober 1927 (one week before the Solvay meeting began), in whi h Pauli omments on wave pa ket redu tion (Pauli 1979, p. 411): This is pre isely a point that was not quite satisfa tory in Heisenberg [that is, in the un ertainty paper℄; there the `redu tion of the pa kets' seemed a bit mysti al. Now however, it is to be stressed that at rst su h redu tions are not ne essary if one
in ludes
in the system all means of measurement. But
in order to des ribe observational results theoreti ally at all, one has to ask what one an say about just a
part
of the whole system. And then from the
omplete solution one sees immediately that, in many ases (of ourse not always), leaving out the means of observation an be formally repla ed by su h redu tions.
Thus, at that time, Pauli thought that the redu tion was a formality asso iated with an ee tive des ription of subsystems alone, and that if the apparatus were in luded in the system then redu tion would not be needed at all. Born, then, presents a multi-dimensional treatment, in whi h atoms in the loud hamber are des ribed by quantum theory on the same footing as the α-parti le. Born onsiders the simple ase of a model loud
hamber onsisting of just two atoms in one spatial dimension. There are two ases, one with both atoms on the same side of the origin (where the α-parti le is emitted), and the other with the atoms on opposite sides of the origin. The two `tubes' in Born's diagram (see his gure) represent, for the two ases, the time development of the total (lo alised) pa ket in 3-dimensional onguration spa e. The oordinate x0 of the α-parti le is perpendi ular to the page, while x1 , x2 are the oordinates of the two atoms. In ase I, the initial state is lo alised at x0 = 0, x1 , x2 > 0; in ase II it is lo alised at x0 = 0, x1 > 0, x2 < 0. Ea h initial pa ket separates into two pa kets moving in opposite dire tions along the x0 -axis. In the rst ase the two ollisions (indi ated by kinks in the traje tory of the pa keta ) take pla e on the same side of the origin; in the se ond ase they take pla e on opposite sides. Note that, in both ases, both bran hes of a Note that the motion o
urs in one spatial dimension; a kink in the ongurationspa e traje tory shows that the orresponding atom has undergone a small spatial displa ement.
180
Interferen e, superposition, and ollapse
the wave pa ket moving in opposite dire tions are shown; that is, the omplete (`un ollapsed') pa kets are shown in the gure. Born remarks (p. 486) that: To the `redu tion' of the wave pa ket orresponds the hoi e of one of the two dire tions of propagation
+x0 , −x0 ,
whi h one must take as soon as it is
established that one of the two points 1 and 2 is hit, that is to say, that the traje tory of the pa ket has re eived a kink.
Here Born seems to be saying that, instead of redu tion, what takes pla e is a hoi e of dire tion of propagation. But propagation of what? Born presumably does not mean a hoi e of dire tion of propagation of the wave pa ket, for that would amount to wave pa ket redu tion, whi h Born at the outset has laimed is unne essary in a multi-dimensional treatment. (And indeed, his gure shows the wave pa ket propagating in both dire tions.) Instead, Born seems to be referring to a hoi e in the dire tion of propagation of the system (whi h we would represent by a point in onguration spa e). The wave pa ket spreads in both dire tions, and determines the probabilities for the dierent possible motions of the system. On e the dire tion of motion of the system is established, by the o
urren e of ollisions, an ordinary (` lassi al') redu tion of the probability distribution o
urs while the wave pa ket itself is un hanged. In other words, the probabilities are updated but the wave pa ket does not ollapse. This, at least, appears to be Born's point of view. This may seem a pe uliar interpretation ordinary probabilisti
ollapse without wave pa ket ollapse but it is perhaps related to the intuitive thinking behind Born's famous ollision papers of the previous year (Born 1926a,b) (papers in whi h probabilities for results of
ollisions were identied with squares of s attering amplitudes for the wave fun tiona ). Born drew an analogy with Einstein's notion of a `ghost eld' that determines probabilities for photons (see hapter 9). As Born put it: In this, I start from a remark by Einstein on the relationship between the wave eld and light quanta; he said, for instan e, that the waves are there only to show the orpus ular light quanta the way, and in this sense he talked of a `ghost eld'.
This determines the probability for a light quantum, the
arrier of energy and momentum, to take a parti ular path; the eld itself, however, possesses no energy and no momentum.
....
analogy between the light quantum and the ele tron ....
Given the perfe t one will think of
formulating the laws of motion of ele trons in a similar way.
a Cf. the dis ussion in se tion 3.4.3.
And here it
6.2 Ma ros opi superposition
181
is natural to onsider the de Broglie-S hrödinger waves as the `ghost eld', or better, `guiding eld' .... [whi h℄ propagates a
ording to the S hrödinger equation.
Momentum and energy, however, are transferred as if orpus les
(ele trons) were a tually ying around. The traje tories of these orpus les are determined only insofar as they are onstrained by the onservation of energy and momentum; furthermore, only a probability for taking a ertain path is determined by the distribution of values of the fun tion
ψ.
(Born
1926b, pp. 8034)
Here, Born seems to be suggesting that there are sto hasti traje tories for ele trons, with probabilities for paths determined by the wave fun tion ψ . It is not lear, though, whether the ψ eld is to be regarded as a physi al eld asso iated with individual systems (as the ele tromagneti eld usually is), or whether it is to be regarded merely as relating to an ensemble. If the former, then it might make sense to apply ollapse to the probabilities without applying ollapse to ψ itself. For example, this ould happen in a sto hasti version of de Broglie-Bohm theory: ψ
ould be a physi al eld evolving at all times by the S hrödinger equation (hen e never ollapsing), and instead of generating deterministi parti le traje tories (as in standard de Broglie-Bohm theory) ψ ould generate probabilisti motions only. Further eviden e that Born was indeed thinking along su h lines omes from an unpublished manus ript by Born and Jordan, written in 1925, in whi h they propose a sto hasti theory of photon traje tories with probabilities determined by the ele tromagneti eld (as originally envisaged by Slater) see Darrigol (1992, p. 253) and se tion 3.4.2.a Thus, in his dis ussion of the loud hamber, when Born spoke of `the
hoi e of one of the two dire tions of propagation', he may indeed have been referring to the possible dire tions of propagation of the system
onguration, with the ψ eld remaining in a superposition. On this reading, wave pa ket redu tion for the α-parti le would be only an ee tive des ription, whi h properly orresponds to the bran hing of the total wave fun tion together with a random hoi e of traje tory (in multi-dimensional onguration spa e). Unfortunately, however, Born's intentions are not entirely lear: whether this really is what Born had in mind, in 1926 or 1927, is di ult to say. Certainly, in the general a In this onne tion it is interesting to note the following passage from Born's book Atomi Physi s (Born 1969), whi h was rst published in German in 1933: `A me hani al pro ess is therefore a
ompanied by a wave pro ess, the guiding wave, des ribed by S hrödinger's equation, the signi an e of whi h is that it gives the probability of a denite ourse of the me hani al pro ess'. Born's referen e to the wave fun tion as `the guiding wave' shows the lingering inuen e of the ideas that had inspired him in 1926.
182
Interferen e, superposition, and ollapse
dis ussion at the fth Solvay onferen e, Born did maintain that ψ does not really ollapse (in this multi-dimensional treatment), so it is di ult to see how he ould have thought that ψ gave merely a probability distribution over an ensemble. The laim that the wave fun tion ψ does not ollapse is also found, in ee t, in se tion II of the report that Born and Heisenberg gave on quantum me hani s. As we saw in se tion 6.1.2, in their dis ussion of interferen e, an energy measurement is taken to indu e a randomisation of the phases appearing in a superposition of energy states, instead of the usual ollapse to an energy eigenstate. In their example, after an energy measurement all of the omponents of the superposition are still present, and the phase relations between them are randomised. In Born's example of the loud hamber, it seems that, here too, all of the omponents of the wave fun tion are still present at the end of a measurement. Nothing is said, however, about the relative phases of the
omponents, and we do not know whether or not Born had in mind a similar phase randomisation in this ase also.
6.3 Dira and Heisenberg: interferen e, state redu tion, and delayed hoi e Another striking feature of quantum theory, as normally understood, is `interferen e between alternative histories'. Like superposition, interferen e is mathemati ally well-dened but its physi al meaning is ambiguous, and it has long been onsidered one of the main mysteries of quantum theory (as we saw in se tion 6.1). The question of when interferen e an or annot take pla e is intimately bound up with the measurement problem, in parti ular, with the question of when or how denite out omes emerge from quantum experiments, and with the question of the boundary between the quantum and lassi al domains. In modern times, one of the most puzzling aspe ts of interferen e was emphasised by Wheeler (1978). In his `delayed- hoi e' experiment, it appears that the existen e or non-existen e of interfering histories in the past is determined by an experimental hoi e made in the present. One version of Wheeler's experiment a `delayed- hoi e double-slit experiment' with single photons is shown in Fig. 6.1. A single photon is in ident on a s reen with two slits. The waves emerging from the slits are fo ussed (by o- entred lenses) so as to ross ea h other as shown. The insertion of a photographi plate in the interferen e region would seem (from the interferen e pattern) to imply the past existen e of
6.3 Dira and Heisenberg
183
Fig. 6.1. Delayed- hoi e double-slit experiment.
interfering traje tories passing through both slits. On the other hand, if no su h plate is inserted, then a dete tion at P or P seems to imply that the parti le passed through the bottom or top slit respe tively.a Sin e the plate ould have been inserted long after the photon ompleted most of its journey (or journeys), it appears that an experimental hoi e now
an ae t whether or not there was a denite photon path in the past. A similar point arose in 1927 in the general dis ussion. Dira expounded his view that quantum out omes o
ur when nature makes a hoi e. Heisenberg replied that this ould not be, be ause of the possibility of observing interferen e later on by hoosing an appropriate experimental arrangement, leading Heisenberg to on lude that out omes o
ur when a hoi e is made (or brought about) not by nature but by the observer. Heisenberg's view here bears some resemblan e to Wheeler's. Dira , in
ontrast, seems to say on the one hand that sto hasti ollapse of the wave pa ket o
urs for mi ros opi systems, while on the other hand a This inferen e is ommonly made, usually without expli it justi ation. Some authors appeal to onservation of momentum for a free parti le, but it is not lear how su h an argument ould be made pre ise after all there are no parti le traje tories in standard quantum theory. In de Broglie-Bohm theory, the inferen e is a tually wrong: parti les dete ted at P or P ome from the top or bottom slits respe tively (Bell 1980; Bell 1987, hap. 14).
184
Interferen e, superposition, and ollapse
that if the experiment is hosen so as to allow interferen e then su h
ollapse is postponed. Here is how Dira expresses it (p. 495): A
ording to quantum me hani s the state of the world at any time is des ribable by a wave fun tion
ψ,
whi h normally varies a
ording to a ausal law,
so that its initial value determines its value at any later time. It may however happen that at a ertain time
t1 , ψ ψ=
an be expanded in the form
X
cn ψn ,
n
where the
ψn 's
are wave fun tions of su h a nature that they annot interfere
with one another at any time subsequent to
t1 .
If su h is the ase, then the
world at times later than t1 will be des ribed not by The parti ular
ψn
ψ
but by one of the
ψn 's.
that it shall be must be regarded as hosen by nature.
Note rst of all that Dira regards ψ as des ribing the state `of the world' presumably the whole world. Then, in ir umstan es where ψ may be expanded in terms of non-interfering states ψn , the world is subsequently des ribed by one of the ψn (the hoi e being made by nature, the probability for ψn being |cn |2 ). Dira does not elaborate on pre isely when or why a de omposition into non-interfering states should exist, nor does he address the question of whether su h a de omposition is likely to be unique. Su h questions, of ourse, go to the heart of the measurement problem, and are lively topi s of urrent resear h. It is interesting that, in Dira 's view (apparently), there are ir umstan es in whi h interferen e is ompletely and irreversibly destroyed. For him, the parti ular ψn results from (p. 495): an irrevo able hoi e of nature, whi h must ae t the whole of the future
ourse of events.
It seems that a
ording to Dira , on e nature makes a hoi e of one bran h, interferen e with the other bran hes is impossible for the whole of the future. A denite ollapse has o
urred, after whi h interferen e between the alternative out omes is no longer possible, even in prin iple. This view learly violates the S hrödinger equation as applied to the whole world: as Dira states, the wave fun tion ψ of the world `normally' evolves a
ording to a ausal law, but not always. But Dira goes further, and re ognises that there are ir umstan es where the hoi e made by nature annot have o
urred at the point where it might have been expe ted. Dira onsiders the spe i example of the s attering of an ele tron. He rst notes that, after the s attering, one must take the wave fun tion to be not the whole s attered wave
6.3 Dira and Heisenberg
185
but a pa ket moving in a spe i dire tion (that is, one of the ψn ). He
laims (p. 495) that one ould infer that nature had hosen this spe i dire tion: From the results of an experiment, by tra ing ba k a hain of ausally onne ted events one ould determine in whi h dire tion the ele tron was s attered and one would thus infer that nature had hosen this dire tion.
This is illustrated in Fig. 6.2(a). If the ele tron is dete ted at P, for example, one may arguably infer a orresponding hoi e of dire tion at the time of s attering. (Note that Figs. 6.2(a)( ) are ours.) On the other hand, Dira goes on to make the following observation (p. 495): If, now, one arranged a mirror to ree t the ele tron wave s attered in one dire tion
d1
so as to make it interfere with the ele tron wave s attered in
another dire tion
d2 ,
one would not be able to distinguish between the ase
when the ele tron is s attered in the dire tion the dire tion
d1
and ree ted ba k into
d2 .
d2
and when it is s attered in
One would then not be able to
tra e ba k the hain of ausal events so far, and one would not be able to say that nature had hosen a dire tion as soon as the ollision o
urred, but only [that℄ at a later time nature hose where the ele tron should appear.
Dira 's modied s enario is sket hed in Fig. 6.2(b). The presen e of the mirror leads to interferen e, at Q, between parts of the ele tron wave s attered in dierent dire tions d1 , d2 . And Dira 's interpretation is that this interferen e is intimately related to the fa t that an experimenter observing the outgoing ele tron in a dire tion d2 `would not be able to distinguish between the ase when the ele tron is s attered in the dire tion d2 and when it is s attered in the dire tion d1 and ree ted ba k into d2 '. The experimenter would not be able to `tra e ba k the
hain of ausal events' to the point where he ould say that `nature had
hosen a dire tion as soon as the ollision o
urred'. For Dira , in this
ase, nature did not make a hoi e at the time of the ollision, and only later nature ` hose where the ele tron should appear'. What Dira des ribes here is pre isely the viewpoint popularised by Feynman in his famous le tures (Feynman 1965), a
ording to whi h if a pro ess o
urs by dierent routes that are subsequently indistinguishable (in the sense that afterwards an experimenter is in prin iple unable to tell whi h route was taken) then the probability amplitudes for the dierent routes are to be added; whereas if the dierent routes are subsequently distinguishable in prin iple, then the probabilities are to be added.a a Note that Feynman's path-integral formulation of quantum theory developed in
186
Interferen e, superposition, and ollapse
Fig. 6.2. Re onstru tion of s attering s enarios dis ussed by Dira (Figs. (a), (b)) and Heisenberg (Fig. ( )).
Dira 's presentation of the s attering experiment with the mirror ends with the statement (p. 496): The interferen e between the
ψn 's
ompels nature to postpone her hoi e.
his PhD thesis and elsewhere (Feynman 1942, 1948) was anti ipated by Dira (1933). Feynman's thesis and Dira 's paper are reprinted in Brown (2005).
6.3 Dira and Heisenberg
187
In his manus ript, a an elled version of the senten e begins with `Thus a possibility of interferen e between .... ', while another an elled version begins as `Thus the existen e of .... ' (itali s added). Possibly, Dira hesitated here be ause he saw that the mirror ould be added by the experimenter after the s attering had taken pla e, leading to di ulties with his view that without the mirror nature makes a hoi e at the time of s attering. For if, in the absen e of the mirror, nature indeed makes a hoi e at the time of s attering, how ould this hoi e be undone by subsequent addition of the mirror? Whether Dira really foresaw this di ulty is hard to say. In any ase, pre isely this point was made by Heisenberg, and Dira 's hesitation here ertainly ree ts a deep di ulty that lies at the heart of the measurement problem. Heisenberg makes his point with disarming simpli ity (p. 497): I do not agree with Mr Dira when he says that, in the des ribed experiment, nature makes a hoi e.
Even if you pla e yourself very far away from your
s attering material, and if you measure after a very long time, you are able to obtain interferen e by taking two mirrors. If nature had made a hoi e, it would be di ult to imagine how the interferen e is produ ed.
What Heisenberg had in mind seems to have been something like the set-up shown in Fig. 6.2( ), where a pair of mirrors is pla ed far away from the s attering region, ausing dierent parts of the s attered wave to re-overlap and interfere at R. A
ording to Dira 's a
ount, in the absen e of any mirrors (Fig. 6.2(a)), upon dete tion of the parti le one might say that nature hose a spe i dire tion at the time of s attering. Heisenberg points out that, by pla ing mirrors far away (and removing the dete tors at P and P), interferen e may be observed a long time after the s attering took pla e. While Heisenberg does not mention it expli itly, in this example the
hoi e between `whi h-way information' on the one hand, or interfering paths on the other, may be made long after the parti le has ompleted most of its journey (or journeys), just as in Wheeler's delayed- hoi e experiment. Dira 's set-up with no mirrors at all provides whi h-way information, sin e dete tion of the parti le at a point far away may be interpreted as providing information on the dire tion hosen at the time of s attering (Fig. 6.2(a)). Heisenberg's modi ation, with the two mirrors, demonstrates interferen e between alternative paths starting from the s attering region (Fig. 6.2( )). Unlike Wheeler, however, Heisenberg does not expli itly emphasise that the hoi e of whether or not to add the mirrors ould be made at the last moment, long after the s attering
188
Interferen e, superposition, and ollapse
takes pla e. On the other hand, Heisenberg does emphasise that the measurement with the mirrors ould be done `very far away' and `after a very long time', and notes the ontradi tion with nature having made a hoi e at the time of s attering. Thus, Heisenberg's remarks arguably
ontain the essen e of Wheeler's delayed- hoi e experiment. Heisenberg goes on to say (p. 497) that, instead of nature making a
hoi e, I should rather say, as I did in my last paper, that the
observer himself
makes
the hoi e, be ause it is only at the moment where the observation is made that the ` hoi e' has be ome a physi al reality and that the phase relationship in the waves, the power of interferen e, is destroyed.
From the hronology of Heisenberg's publi ations, here he must be referring to his un ertainty paper (published in May 1927), in whi h he writes that `all per eiving is a hoi e from a plenitude of possibilities' (Heisenberg 1927, p. 197). Heisenberg's statement above that the observer `makes' the hoi e seems to be meant in the sense of the observer `bringing about' the hoi e. Thus it would seem that, for Heisenberg, a denite out ome o
urs and there is no longer any possibility of interferen e only when an experimenter makes an observation. Similar views have been expressed by Wheeler (1986). One may, however, obje t to this viewpoint, on the grounds that there is no reason in prin iple why a more advan ed being ould not observe interferen e between the alternative states of the dete tor registering interferen e, or, between the alternative states of the human observer wat hing the dete tor. (Cf. the dis ussion of Wigner's paradox in se tion 5.2.2.) After all, the dete tor is ertainly just another physi al system, built out of atoms. And as far as we an tell, human observers
an likewise be treated as physi al systems built out of atoms. To say that `the power of interferen e' is `destroyed' when and only when a human observer intervenes is to make a remarkable assertion to the ee t that human beings, unlike any other physi al systems, have spe ial properties by virtue of whi h they annot be treated by ordinary physi al laws but generate deviations from those laws. As we have already mentioned, there is no eviden e that human beings are able to violate, for example, the laws of gravity or of thermodynami s, and it would be remarkable if they were indeed able to violate the laws of quantum physi s. It is interesting to note that, while for Heisenberg the human observer seems to play a ru ial role at the end of a quantum experiment, for
6.3 Further remarks on Born and Heisenberg
189
Dira the human observer and his `freewill' seems to play a ru ial role at the beginning, in the preparation stage. For as Dira puts it (p. 494, Dira 's itali s):