Quantum Mechanics for Mathematicians Leon A. Takhtajan
Graduate Studies in Mathematics Volume 95
American Mathematical Society Providence, Rhode Island
Editorial Board David Cox (Chair) Steven G. Krantz Rafe Mazzeo Martin Scharlemann 2000 Mathematics Subject Classification. Primary 81-01.
For additional information and updates on this book, visit
www.ams.org/bookpages/gsm-95
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Takhtadzhian, L. A. (Leon Armenovich) Quantum mechanics for mathematicians / Leon A. Takhtajan.
p. cm. - (Graduate studies in mathematics ; v. 95) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-8218-4630-8 (alk. paper)
1. Quantum theory. QC174.12.T343
2. Mathematical physics.
I. Title.
2008
530.12-dc22
2008013072
Copying and reprinting. Individual readers of this publication, and nonprofit libraries acting for them, are permitted to make fair use of the material, such as to copy a chapter for use in teaching or research. Permission is granted to quote brief passages from this publication in reviews, provided the customary acknowledgment of the source is given. Republication, systematic copying, or multiple reproduction of any material in this publication is permitted only under license from the American Mathematical Society. Requests for such permission should be addressed to the Acquisitions Department, American Mathematical Society, 201 Charles Street, Providence, Rhode Island 02904-2294, USA. Requests can also be made by e-mail to reprint -permission@ams. org. © 2008 by the American Mathematical Society. All rights reserved. The American Mathematical Society retains all rights except those granted to the United States Government. Printed in the United States of America.
® The paper used in this book is acid-free and falls within the guidelines established to ensure permanence and durability. Visit the AMS home page at http: //ww. ams. org/ 10987654321 131211100908
To my teacher Ludwig Dmitrievich Faddeev with admiration and gratitude.
Contents
Preface
Part 1. Foundations Chapter 1. Classical Mechanics §1. Lagrangian Mechanics 1.1. Generalized coordinates 1.2. The principle of the least action 1.3. Examples of Lagrangian systems 1.4. Symmetries and Noether's theorem 1.5. One-dimensional motion 1.6. The motion in a central field and the Kepler problem 1.7. Legendre transform §2. Hamiltonian Mechanics 2.1. Hamilton's equations 2.2. The action functional in the phase space 2.3. The action as a function of coordinates 2.4. Classical observables and Poisson bracket 2.5. Canonical transformations and generating functions 2.6. Symplectic manifolds 2.7. Poisson manifolds 2.8. Hamilton's and Liouville's representations §3. Notes and references Chapter 2.
Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics §1. Observables, states, and dynamics 1.1. Mathematical formulation
63 65 66
vii
Contents
viii
1.2. 1.3.
§2. 2.1. 2.2. 2.3. 2.4. 2.5. 2.6. 2.7. §3.
3.1. 3.2. 3.3. 3.4.
3.5.
§4.
Heisenberg's uncertainty relations Dynamics Quantization Heisenberg commutation relations Coordinate and momentum representations Free quantum particle Examples of quantum systems Old quantum mechanics Harmonic oscillator Holomorphic representation and Wick symbols Weyl relations Stone-von Neumann theorem Invariant formulation Weyl quantization The *-product Deformation quantization Notes and references
Chapter 3. Schrodinger Equation §1. General properties 1.1. Self-adjointness 1.2. Characterization of the spectrum 1.3. The virial theorem §2. One-dimensional Schrodinger equation 2.1. Jost functions and transition coefficients 2.2. Eigenfunction expansion 2.3. S-matrix and scattering theory 2.4. Other boundary conditions §3. Angular momentum and SO(3) 3.1. Angular momentum operators 3.2. Representation theory of SO(3) §4. Two-body problem 4.1. Separation of the center of mass 4.2. Three-dimensional scattering theory 4.3. Particle in a central potential §5. Hydrogen atom and SO(4) 5.1. Discrete spectrum 5.2. Continuous spectrum 5.3. Hidden SO(4) symmetry §6. Semi-classical asymptotics - I 6.1. Time-dependent asymptotics
74 75
79
80 86 93 98 102 103 111
118 119 125
128 136 139 146 149 149 150 152 154 155 155
163
170 177 180 180 182 185 185 186
188 193 193
197 199
205
206
Contents
6.2. 6.3. §7.
ix
Time independent asymptotics Bohr-Wilson-Sommerfeld quantization rules Notes and references
Chapter 4.
Spin and Identical Particles
§1.
Spin
1.1. 1.2.
Spin operators Spin and representation theory of SU(2) Charged spin particle in the magnetic field Pauli Hamiltonian Particle in a uniform magnetic field System of identical particles The symmetrization postulate Young diagrams and representation theory of SymN Schur-Weyl duality and symmetry of the wave functions Notes and references
§2.
2.1. 2.2. §3.
3.1. 3.2. 3.3. §4.
209 212 213
217 217 217 218 221 221 223
224 225 229 232 234
Part 2. Functional Methods and Supersymmetry Chapter 5. Path Integral Formulation of Quantum Mechanics §1. Feynman path integral 1.1. The fundamental solution of the Schrodinger equation 1.2. Feynman path integral in the phase space 1.3. Feynman path integral in the configuration space 1.4. Several degrees of freedom §2. Symbols of the evolution operator and path integrals 2.1. The pq-symbol 2.2. The qp-symbol 2.3. The Weyl symbol 2.4. The Wick symbol §3. Feynman path integral for the harmonic oscillator 3.1. Gaussian integration 3.2. Propagator of the harmonic oscillator 3.3. Mehler identity §4. Gaussian path integrals 4.1. Gaussian path integral for a free particle 4.2. Gaussian path integral for the harmonic oscillator §5. Regularized determinants of differential operators 5.1. Dirichlet boundary conditions 5.2. Periodic boundary conditions 5.3. First order differential operators
239
239 239 242 245 247 249 249 250 251 252
255 255 257 259 260 261 264 268 268 274 278
Contents
x
§6.
6.1. 6.2. §7.
Semi-classical asymptotics - II Using the Feynman path integral Rigorous derivation Notes and references
280 281 282 285
Chapter 6. Integration in Functional Spaces §1. Gaussian measures 1.1. Finite-dimensional case 1.2. Infinite-dimensional case §2. Wiener measure and Wiener integral 2.1. Definition of the Wiener measure 2.2. Conditional Wiener measure and Feynman-Kac formula 2.3. Relation between Wiener and Feynman integrals §3. Gaussian Wiener integrals 3.1. Dirichlet boundary conditions 3.2. Periodic boundary conditions §4. Notes and references
289
Chapter 7. Fermion Systems §1. Canonical anticommutation relations 1.1. Motivation 1.2. Clifford algebras §2. Grassmann algebras 2.1. Realization of canonical anticommutation relations 2.2. Differential forms 2.3. Berezin integral §3. Graded linear algebra 3.1. Graded vector spaces and superalgebras 3.2. Examples of superalgebras 3.3. Supertrace and Berezinian §4. Path integrals for anticommuting variables 4.1. Wick and matrix symbols 4.2. Path integral for the evolution operator 4.3. Gaussian path integrals over Grassmann variables §5. Notes and references
307
Chapter 8. Supersymmetry §1. Supermanifolds §2. Equivariant cohomology and localization 2.1. Finite-dimensional case 2.2. Infinite-dimensional case
289 289 291 293 293 296 299 301 301 302
305
307 307 311
314 315 317 319
324 324 326 328 330 330 335 338 340 343 343 345 345 349
Contents
Classical mechanics on supermanifolds Functions with anticommuting values Classical systems §4. Supersymmetry 4.1. Total angular momentum 4.2. Supersymmetry transformation 4.3. Supersymmetric particle on a Riemannian manifold §5. Quantum mechanics on supermanifolds §6. Atiyah-Singer index formula §7. Notes and references
xi
§3.
354
3.1. 3.2.
354 356 359 359 360 362
364 369 370
Bibliography
373
Index
383
Preface
This book is based on graduate courses taught by the author over the last fourteen years in the mathematics department of Stony Brook University. The goal of these courses was to introduce second year graduate students with no prior knowledge of physics to the basic concepts and methods of quantum mechanics. For the last 50 years quantum physics has been a driving force behind many dramatic achievements in mathematics, similar to the role played by classical physics in the seventeenth to nineteenth centuries. Classical physics, especially classical mechanics, was an integral part of mathematical education up to the early twentieth century, with lecture courses given by Hilbert and Poincare. Surprisingly, quantum physics, especially quantum mechanics, with its intrinsic beauty and connections with many branches of mathematics, has never been a part of a graduate mathematics curriculum. This course was developed to partially fill this gap and to make quantum mechanics accessible to graduate students and research mathematicians. L.D. Faddeev was the first to develop a course in quantum mechanics for undergraduate students specializing in mathematics. From 1968 to 1973 he regularly lectured in the mathematics department of St. Petersburg State University in St. Petersburg, Russial, and the author enjoyed the opportunity to take his course. The notes for this book emerged from an attempt to create a similar course for graduate students, which uses more sophisticated mathematics and covers a larger variety of topics, including the Feynman path integral approach to quantum mechanics.
'At that time in Leningrad, Soviet Union.
xiii
xiv
Preface
There are many excellent physics textbooks on quantum mechanics, starting with the classic texts by P.A.M. Dirac [Dir47], L.D. Landau and E.M. Lifshitz [LL58], and V.A. Fock [Foc78], to the encyclopedic treatise by A. Messiah [Mes99], the recent popular textbook by J.J. Sakurai [Sak94], and many others. From a mathematics perspective, there are classic monographs by J. von Neumann [vN96] and by H. Weyl [Wey50], as well as a more recent book by G.W. Mackey [Mac04], which deal with the basic mathematical formalism and logical foundations of the theory. There is also a monumental project [DEF+99], created with the purpose of introducing graduate students and research mathematicians to the realm of quantum fields and strings, both from a mathematics and a physics perspective. Though it contains a very detailed exposition of classical mechanics, classical field theory, and supersymmetry, oriented at the mathematical audience, quantum mechanics is discussed only briefly (with the exception of L.D. Faddeev's elegant introduction to quantum mechanics in [Fad99]). Excellent lecture notes for undergraduate students by L.D. Faddeev and O.A. Yakubovskii [FY80] seems to be the only book on quantum mechanics completely accessible to mathematicians2. Recent books by S.J. Gustafson and I.M. Sigal [GS03] and by F. Strocchi [Str05] are also oriented at math-
ematicians. The latter is a short introductory course, while the former is more an intermediate level monograph on quantum theory rather than a textbook on quantum mechanics. There are also many specialized books on different parts of quantum mechanics, like scattering theory, the Schrodinger operator, C*-algebras and foundations, etc. The present book gives a comprehensive treatment of quantum mechanics from a mathematics perspective and covers such topics as mathematical foundations, quantization, the Schrodinger equation, the Feynman path in-
tegral and functional methods, and supersymmetry. It can be used as a one-year graduate course, or as two one-semester courses: the introductory course based on the material in Part 1, and a more advanced course based on Part 2. Part 1 of the book, which consists of Chapters 1-4, can be considered as an expanded version of [FY80]. It uses more advanced mathematics than [FY80], and contains rigorous proofs of all main results, including the celebrated Stone-von Neumann theorem. It should be accessible to a second-year graduate student. As in [FY80], we adopt the approach, which goes back to Dirac and was further developed by Faddeev, that classical mechanics and quantum mechanics are just two different realizations of the fundamental
mathematical structure of a physical theory that uses the notions of observables, states, measurement, and the time evolution - dynamics. Part 2, which consists of Chapters 5-8, deals with functional methods in quantum 2The English translation will appear in the AMS "The Student Mathematical Library" series.
Preface
xv
mechanics, and goes beyond the material in [FY80]. Exposition there is less detailed and requires certain mathematical sophistication. Though our presentation freely uses all the necessary tools of modern
mathematics, it follows the spirit and tradition of the classical texts and monographs mentioned above. In this sense it can be considered "neoclassical" (as compared with a more abstract approach in [DF99a]). Each chapter in the book concludes with a special Notes and references section, which provides references to the necessary mathematics background and physics sources. A courageous reader can actually learn the relevant mathematics by studying the main text and consulting these references, and with enough sophistication, could "translate" corresponding parts in physics textbooks into the mathematics language. For the physics students, the book presents an opportunity to become familiar with the mathematical foundations and methods of quantum mechanics on a "case by case" basis. It is worth mentioning that development of many mathematics disciplines has been stimulated by quantum mechanics. There are several ways to study the material in this book. A casual reader can study the main text in a cursory manner, and ignore numerous remarks and problems, located at the end of the sections. This would be sufficient to obtain basic minimal knowledge of quantum mechanics. A determined
reader is supposed to fill in the details of the computations in the main text (a pencil and paper are required), which is the only way to master the material, and to attempt to solve the basic problems3. Finally, a truly devoted reader should try to solve all the problems (probably consulting the corresponding references at the end of each section) and to follow up on the remarks, which may often be linked to other topics not covered in the main text.
The author would like to thank the students in his courses for their comments on the draft of the lecture notes. He is especially grateful to his colleagues Peter Kulish and Lee-Peng Teo for the careful reading of the manuscript. The work on the book was partially supported by the NSF grants DMS-0204628 and DMS-0705263. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this book are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation.
3We leave it to the reader to decide which problems are basic and which are advanced.
Part 1
Foundations
Chapter 1
Classical Mechanics
We assume that the reader is familiar with the basic notions from the theory of smooth (that is, C°) manifolds and recall here the standard notation. Unless it is stated explicitly otherwise, all maps are assumed to be smooth and all functions are assumed to be smooth and real-valued. Local coordinates q = (q', , qn) on a smooth n-dimensional manifold M at a point q E M are Cartesian coordinates on cp(U) C 1R' , where (U, cp) is a coordinate chart on M centered at q E U. For f : U --> R' we denote (f o cp-1)(q1, ... , q'n) by f (q), and we let
of aq
of of (ag1,..., aqn
stand for the gradient of a function f at a point q E Rn with Cartesian coordinates (q1, ... , qn). We denote by n
A'(M) = (@Ak(M) k=°
the graded algebra of smooth differential forms on M with respect to the wedge product, and by d the de Rham differential - a graded derivation of A' (M) of degree 1 such that df is a differential of a function f E A° (M) = C°(M). Let Vect(M) be the Lie algebra of smooth vector fields on M with the Lie bracket [ , ], given by a commutator of vector fields. For X E Vect(M)
we denote by LX and ix, respectively, the Lie derivative along X and the inner product with X. The Lie derivative is a degree 0 derivation of A'(M) which commutes with d and satisfies Lx (f) = X (f) for f E A°(M), and the inner product is a degree -1 derivation of A'(M) satisfying ix(f) = 0 3
1. Classical Mechanics
4
and ix(df) = X (f) for f E ,A°(M). They satisfy Cartan formulas Lx = ix o d + d o ix = (d + ix)2,
i[x,y]=Lxoiy-iyoLx. For a smooth mapping of manifolds f : M , N we denote by f* : TM TN and f* : T*N -* T*M, respectively, the induced mappings on tangent and cotangent bundles. Other notations, including those traditional for classical mechanics, will be introduced in the main text.
1. Lagrangian Mechanics 1.1. Generalized coordinates. Classical mechanics describes systems of finitely many interacting particles'. A system is called closed if its particles do not interact with the outside material bodies. The position of a system
in space is specified by positions of its particles and defines a point in a smooth, finite-dimensional manifold M, the configuration space of a system. Coordinates on M are called generalized coordinates of a system, and the dimension n = dim M is called the number of degrees of freedom2.
The state of a system at any instant of time is described by a point q E M and by a tangent vector v E TqM at this point. The basic principle of classical mechanics is the Newton-Laplace determinacy principle which asserts that a state of a system at a given instant completely determines
its motion at all times t (in the future and in the past). The motion is described by the classical trajectory - a path -y(t) in the configuration space M. In generalized coordinates 'y(t) _ (q' (t), ... , qn(t)), and corresponding derivatives 4Z = dq are called generalized velocities. The Newton-Laplace
principle is a fundamental experimental fact confirmed by our perception d2q of everyday experiences. It implies that generalized accelerations dt2 are uniquely defined by generalized coordinates qz and generalized velocities
4i, so that classical trajectories satisfy a system of second order ordinary differential equations, called equations of motion. In the next section we formulate the most general principle governing the motion of mechanical systems.
1.2. The principle of the least action. A Lagrangian system on a configuration space M is defined by a smooth, real-valued function L on TM x R
- the direct product of a tangent bundle TM of M and the time axis3 called the Lagrangian function (or simply, Lagrangian). The motion of a 'A particle is a material body whose dimensions may be neglected in describing its motion. 2Systems with infinitely many degrees of freedom are described by classical field theory. 31t follows from the Newton-Laplace principle that L could depend only on generalized coordinates and velocities, and on time.
1. Lagrangian Mechanics
5
Lagrangian system (M, L) is described by the principle of the least action in the configuration space (or Hamilton's principle), formulated as follows. Let P(M)go,to = {'Y : [to, ti] -' M, -y (to) = qo, ry(t1) = qi}
be the space of smooth parametrized paths in M connecting points qo and ql. The path space P(M) = P(M)go;to is an infinite-dimensional real Frechet manifold, and the tangent space T.yP(M) to P(M) at 'y E P(M) consists of all smooth vector fields along the path ry in M which vanish at the endpoints qo and ql. A smooth path IF in P(M), passing through 'y E P(M), is called a variation with fixed ends of the path y(t) in M. A variation F is a family 'E(t) = F(t, E) of paths in M given by a smooth map F : [to, tl] x [-EO, EO] -4 M
such that F(t, 0) = ry(t) for to < t < tl and F(to, E) = qo, F(tl, E) = ql for -eO < E < co. The tangent vector &ry =
8F 8E
E T,P(M) E=O
corresponding to a variation 7,(t) is traditionally called an infinitesimal variation. Explicitly, 5'(t) = F*(aE)(t, 0) E Ty(t)M, where
to < t < t1,
is a tangent vector to the interval [-EO, EO] at 0. Finally, a tangential
lift of a path ry [to, tl] --+ M is the path ry' : [to, ti] -> TM defined by ry'(t) = 'y*(') E Ty(t) M, to < t < t1, where at is a tangent vector to [to, tl] at t. In other words, 'y'(t) is the velocity vector of a path -y(t) at time t. :
Definition. The action functional S : P(M) --> ll of a Lagrangian system (M, L) is defined by tl
S(ry) = J L(7 (t), t) dt. I,
Principle of the Least Action (Hamilton's principle). A path ry E PM describes the motion of a Lagrangian system (M, L) between the position qo E M at time to and the position ql E M at time tl if and only if it is a critical point of the action functional S, d dE E=0
s(ryE) = 0
for all variations ryy(t) of -y(t) with fixed ends.
The critical points of the action functional are called extremals and the principle of the least action states that a Lagrangian system (M, L)
1. Classical Mechanics
6
moves along the extremals4. The extremals are characterized by equations of motion - a system of second order differential equations in local coordinates on TM. The equations of motion have the most elegant form for the following choice of local coordinates on TM.
Definition. Let (U, cp) be a coordinate chart on M with local coordinates q = (ql,... , qn). Coordinates I
n
I
on a chart TU on TM, where v = (v', ... , vn) are coordinates in the fiber corresponding to the basis 0 , ... , 11qn for TqM, are called standard coorOq1
Standard coordinates are Cartesian coordinates on co (TU) C TR' Rn X Rn and have the property that for (q, v) E TU and f E C°°(U),
i=1
aqZ
=vOf aq
Let (U, cp) and (U', cp') be coordinate charts on M with the transition functions F = (Fl, ... , Fn) = cp' o cp-I : cp(U n U') -> cp'(U n U'), and let (q, v) and (q', v'), respectively, be the standard coordinates on TU and TU'. We
have q' = F(q) and v' = F. (q) v, where F. (q)
aF 1i
In
(q) y
is a matrix-
..' ij=1 aqj valued function on cp(U n U'). Thus "vertical" coordinates v = (v',. .. , v") in the fibers of TM -> M transform like components of a tangent vector on M under the change of coordinates on M. The tangential lift 'y'(t) of a path -y(t) in M in standard coordinates on TU is (q(t), 4(t)) = (q'(t), ... , qn(t), 41(t), ... , 4n(t)), where the dot stands for the time derivative, so that
L(ry'(t), t) = L(q(t), 4(t), t).
Following a centuries long tradition 5, we will usually denote standard coordinates by (q, 4) _ (q1, ... , qn, 41, ... , 4n),
where the dot does not stand for the time derivative. Since we only consider paths in TM that are tangential lifts of paths in M, there will be no confusions. 4The principle of the least action does not state that an extremal connecting points qo and ql is a minimum of S, nor that such an extremal is unique. It also does not state that any two points can be connected by an extremal. 5Used in all texts on classical mechanics and theoretical physics. 6We reserve the notation (q(t), v(t)) for general paths in TM.
1. Lagrangian Mechanics
7
Theorem 1.1. The equations of motion of a Lagrangian system (M, L) in standard coordinates on TM are given by the Euler-Lagrange equations aq (q(t), (t), t)
td
-d
(q (t), 4(t), t)) = 0.
Proof. Suppose first that an extremal 'y(t) lies in a coordinate chart U of M. Then a simple computation in standard coordinates, using integration by parts, gives e=o
d
dEo f L(q(t,),(t,e),t)dt o
L i=1 n n i=1
ti to
f
tl
o
(5qi+.±i'\dt Ri '94i d 1L )oqidt+ n 8L 5q (aqi - d aq i=1 a4i q 8L
tl a
to
The second sum in the last line vanishes due to the property Sgi(to) _ bgi(ti) = 0, i = 1, ... , n. The first sum is zero for arbitrary smooth functions oqi on the interval [to, t1] which vanish at the endpoints. This implies that for each term in the sum the integrand is identically zero, aqi
(q (t), 4(t), t)
- dt (4j(q(t),4(t),t)) = 0,
i = 1, ... , n.
Since the restriction of an extremal of the action functional S to a coordinate chart on M is again an extremal, each extremal in standard coordinates on TM satisfies Euler-Lagrange equations.
Remark. In calculus of variations, the directional derivative of a functional
S with respect to a tangent vector V E TyP(M) - the Gato derivative is defined by 6VS =
d S(ye), A e=o
where ye is a path in P(M) with a tangent vector V at yo = y. The result of the above computation (when y lies in a coordinate chart U C M) can be written as d c7L tl 8L CVs a4i) (q (t), 4(t), t)vi(t)dt aqi - d = fto tl (1.1)
=
8L
f (8q
I 8L dt
a4) (q (t), 4(t), t)v(t)dt.
1. Classical Mechanics
8
n
v2 (t) a is a vector field along the path y in M. Formula
Here V (t) _
Q ii
i=1
(1.1) is called the formula for the first variation of the action with fixed ends. The principle of the least action is a statement that 5vS(y) = 0 for all V E T.yP(M).
Remark. It is also convenient to consider a space P(M) = {y : [to, ti] --> M} of all smooth parametrized paths in M. The tangent space T.,P to P(M) at y E P(M) is the space of all smooth vector fields along the path y in M (no condition at the endpoints). The computation in the proof of Theorem 1.1 yields the following formula for the first variation of the action with free ends: (1.2)
bvS =
tl (OL
Jto
d aL
aq - dt aq)
v dt +
-Lv aq
tl to
Problem 1.1. Show that the action functional is given by the evaluation of the 1-form Ldt on TM x R over the 1-chain ' on TM x R, S('7) =
,
where y = {(ry'(t), t); to < t < tl } and Ldt (w, cat) = cL(q, v), w E T(q,v)TM, c E R.
Problem 1.2. Let f E Cm(M). Show that Lagrangian systems (M, L) and (M, L+df) (where df is a fibre-wise linear function on TM) have the same equations of motion.
Problem 1.3. Give examples of Lagrangian systems such that an extremal connecting two given points (i) is not a local minimum; (ii) is not unique; (iii) does not exist.
Problem 1.4. For ry an extremal of the action functional S, the second variation of S is defined by 2
az
v S( IE1,62), V1 V2S = ae1ae2 61=62=
where '761,62 is a smooth two-parameter family of paths in M such that the paths '761,0 and-Y0,62 in P(M) at the point ryo,o = 'y E P(M) have tangent vectors Vl and V2, respectively. For a Lagrangian system (M, L) find the second variation of S and verify that for given Vl and V2 it does not depend on the choice of y61,62
1.3. Examples of Lagrangian systems. To describe a mechanical phenomena it is necessary to choose a frame of reference. The properties of the space-time where the motion takes place depend on this choice. The space-time is characterized by the following postulates7. 7Strictly speaking, these postulates are valid only in the non-relativistic limit of special relativity, when the speed of light in the vacuum is assumed to be infinite.
1. Lagrangian Mechanics
9
Newtonian Space-Time. The space is a three-dimensional affine Eucli-
dean space P. A choice of the origin 0 E E3 - a reference point
-
establishes the isomorphism E3 1R3, where the vector space I[83 carries the Euclidean inner product and has a fixed orientation. The time is onedimensional - a time axis 1[8 - and the space-time is a direct product E3 xR. An inertial reference frame is a coordinate system with respect to the origin 0 E E3, initial time to, and an orthonormal basis in 1R3. In an inertial frame the space is homogeneous and isotropic and the time is homogeneous. The laws of motion are invariant with respect to the transformations
ro E 1[83 and g is an orthogonal linear transformation in J3. The time in classical mechanics is absolute.
The Galilean group is the group of all affine transformations of E3 x JR which preserve time intervals and which for every t E 1[8 are isometries in E3. Every Galilean transformation is a composition of rotation, space-time translation, and a transformation
r --* r + vt,
t --* t,
where v E 1[83. Any two inertial frames are related by a Galilean transformation.
Galileo's Relativity Principle. The laws of motion are invariant with respect to the Galilean group. These postulates impose restrictions on Lagrangians of mechanical sys-
tems. Thus it follows from the first postulate that the Lagrangian L of a closed system does not explicitly depend on time. Physical systems are described by special Lagrangians, in agreement with the experimental facts about the motion of material bodies. Example 1.1 (Free particle). The configuration space for a free particle is M = 1R3, and it can be deduced from Galileo's relativity principle that the Lagrangian for a free particle is
L = zmr2. Here m > 0s is the mass of a particle and r2 = 1i 12 is the length square of the velocity vector T E TrJR3 _ R3. Euler-Lagrange equations give Newton's law of inertia,
r=0. 8Otherwise the action functional is not bounded from below.
1. Classical Mechanics
10
Example 1.2 (Interacting particles). A closed system of N interacting particles in 1R3 with masses ml, ... , MN is described by a configuration space
M=R 3N = R3 X ... X IR3 N
with a position vector r = (r1, ... , rN), where ra E R3 is the position vector of the a-th particle, a = 1, ... , N. It is found that the Lagrangian is given by N
L a=1
2ma1
where
- V (r) = T - V, N
T2mara a=1
is called kinetic energy of a system and V (r) is potential energy. The EulerLagrange equations give Newton's equations
mara = Fa, where
F.
aV 01ra
is the force on the a-th particle, a = 1, ... , N. Forces of this form are called conservative. It follows from homogeneity of space that potential energy V (r) of a closed system of N interacting particles with conservative forces depends only on relative positions of the particles, which leads to the equation N
EFa=O. a=1
In particular, for a closed system of two particles F1 + F2 = 0, which is the equality of action and reaction forces, also called Newton's third law. The potential energy of a closed system with only pair-wise interaction between the particles has the form V(r) = E Vab(ra - rb). 1
It follows from the isotropy of space that V (r) depends only on relative distances between the particles, so that the Lagrangian of a closed system of N particles with pair-wise interaction has the form N
L=
2mara a=1
Y, 1
Vab(Ira - rb)
1. Lagrangian Mechanics
11
If the potential energy V (r) is a homogeneous function of degree p, V (\r) = .XPV (r), then the average values T and V of kinetic energy and potential energy over a closed trajectory are related by the virial theorem 2T = pV.
(1.3)
Indeed, let r(t) be a periodic trajectory with period r > 0, i.e., r(0) = r(T), T(0) = r(r). Using integration by parts, Newton's equations, and Euler's homogeneous function theorem, we get N
rN
a=1
Jo a=1
-T 2T = Jrnaia2dt= TE o
mararadt
N
=
T
JTadt_-PV. a 0
a=1
Example 1.3 (Universal gravitation). According to Newton's law of gravitation, the potential energy of the gravitational force between two particles with masses ma and Mb is amrb
V (ra - rb) = -G
,
Ira
where G is the gravitational constant. The configuration space of N particles with gravitational interaction is
M={(r1i...,rN) ER3N:ra54 rbfor a
b, a,b=1,...,N}.
Example 1.4 (Particle in an external potential field). Here M = R3 and
L = 1mr2 - V(r, t), where potential energy can explicitly depend on time. Equations of motion are Newton's equations 09V mr=F =-ar.
If V = V(Irl) is a function only of the distance Irl, the potential field is called central.
Example 1.5 (Charged particle in electromagnetic fields). Consider a particle of charge e and mass m in 1183 moving in a time-independent electromag-
netic field with scalar and vector potentials W(r) and A(r) = (A, (r), A2(r), A3(r)). The Lagrangian has the form
9This is a non-relativistic limit of an example in classical electrodynamics.
1. Classical Mechanics
12
where c is the speed of light. The Euler-Lagrange equations give Newton's equations with the Lorentz force,
mr=e(E+cxB), c where x is the cross-product of vectors in R3, and
E=-9r
and B=curlA
are electric and magnetic1o fields, respectively.
Example 1.6 (Small oscillations). Consider a particle of mass m with n degrees of freedom moving in a potential field V(q), and suppose that potential energy U has a minimum at q = 0. Expanding V (q) in Taylor series around 0 and keeping only quadratic terms, one obtains a Lagrangian system which describes small oscillations from equilibrium. Explicitly,
L = 2mg2 - Vo(q), where Vo is a positive-definite quadratic form on Rn given by n
2
q
Vo(q) = 2
gj(0)gZqi.
Z,.9=1
Since every quadratic form can be diagonalized by an orthogonal transformation, we can assume from the very beginning that coordinates q = (ql, ... , qn) are chosen so that Vo(q) is diagonal and n
(1.4)
L = 2m(92 -
wi (qZ)2)+
i=1
where wl, ... , wn > 0. Such coordinates q are called normal coordinates. In normal coordinates Euler-Lagrange equations take the form
i = 1, ... , n,
qZ + wi qZ = 0,
and describe n decoupled (i.e., non-interacting) harmonic oscillators with frequencies W1, ... , wn.
Example 1.7 (Free particle on a Riemannian manifold). Let (M, ds2) be a Riemannian manifold with the Riemannian metric ds2. In local coordinates x 11 ...,Xn on M, ds2 = g,
(x)dxµdx",
where following tradition we assume the summation over repeated indices. The Lagrangian of a free particle on M is
L(v) = 2(v,v) = loNotation B = rot A is also used.
aIIvII2, v E TM,
1. Lagrangian Mechanics
13
where ( , ) stands for the inner product in fibers of TM given by the Riemannian metric. The corresponding functional tl
s(Y) = 2
to
/ ti
III (t) I2dt = 2 J
tp
is called the action functional in Riemannian geometry. The Euler-Lagrange equations are xµx,\
gµvxµ
xµxa
+ axe
2 axv and after multiplying by the inverse metric tensor g°' and summation over v they take the form where a
agµa
1 Qa
rµv = 2g
agva
agµv
axv + axµ axe are Christoffel's symbols. The Euler-Lagrange equations of a free particle moving on a Riemannian manifold are geodesic equations. C
Let V be the Levi-Civita connection - the metric connection in the tangent bundle TM - and let V be a covariant derivative with respect to the vector field l; E Vect(M). Explicitly,
(i(V o), = axv + I Var1\ Fi
v,
where
t; = l;µ(x) aµ, 77 _ 77µ(i) a
For a path 7(t) = (xµ(t)) denote by V.y a covariant derivative along ry, d
(O771)1(t) =
dtt)
where
17 =
77µ(t)aaµ
is a vector field along 'y. Formula (1.1) can now be written in an invariant form Pti
6S = - 1
(Vy,', 6-1) dt,
tp
which is known as the formula for the first variation of the action in Riemannian geometry.
Example 1.8 (The rigid body). The configuration space of a rigid body in R3 with a fixed point is a Lie group G = SO(3) of orientation preserving orthogonal linear transformations in 1[83. Every left-invariant Riemannian metric (,) on G defines a Lagrangian L : TG -> R by L(v) = 1(v, v),
v E TG.
According to the previous example, equations of motion of a rigid body are geodesic equations on G with respect to the Riemannian metric ( , ). Let g = so(3) be the Lie algebra of G. A velocity vector g E TgG defines the angular velocity of the body by Sl = (Lg-1),g e g, where Lg : G --> G are
1. Classical Mechanics
14
left translations on G. In terms of angular velocity, the Lagrangian takes the form L = 1(1,12)e,
where ( , )e is an inner product on g = TeG given by the Riemannian metric (, ). The Lie algebra g - the Lie algebra of 3 x 3 skew-symmetric matrices has the invariant inner product (u, v)o = - 2 Tr uv (the Killing form), so that (52, 51)e = (A S2, Il)o for some symmetric linear operator A : g - g which is positive-definite with respect to the Killing form. Such a linear operator A
is called the inertia tensor of the body. The principal axes of inertia of the body are orthonormal eigenvectors el, e2, e3 of A; corresponding eigenvalues
11,12,13 are called the principal moments of inertia. Setting S1 = 12lel + 122e2 + S23e311, we get
L=
2(I1S2i+I2Q2+I3E23).
In this parametrization, the Euler-Lagrange equations become Euler's equations I101 = (12 - 13)112123,
12112=(I3-Il)111113, 1303 = (Il - I2)121S12.
Euler's equations describe the rotation of a free rigid body around a fixed point. In the system of coordinates with axes which are the principal axes of inertia, principal moments of inertia of the body are Il, 12, 13. Problem 1.5. Determine the motion of a charged particle in a constant uniform magnetic field. Show that if the initial velocity v3 = 0 in the z-axis (taken in the cmvt direction of the field, B = (0, 0, B)), the trajectories are circles of radii r = eB in a plane perpendicular to the field (the xy-plane), where vt = vi -+v22 is the initial velocity in the xy-plane. The centers (xo, yo) of circles are given by cmvl cmv2 xo = eB + x, yo = - eB + y, where (x, y) are points on a circle of radius r.
Problem 1.6. Show that the Euler-Lagrange equations for the Lagrangian L(v) _ JvJJ, v E TM, coincide with the geodesic equations written with respect to a constant multiple of the natural parameter.
Problem 1.7. Prove that for a particle in a potential field, discussed in Example 1.4, the second variation of the action functional, defined in Problem 1.4, is given by
62S =
1 J(b1r)62rdt,
Jto
11This establishes the Lie algebra isomorphism g ^_ R3, where the Lie bracket in 1R3 is given by the cross-product.
1. Lagrangian Mechanics
w here 6 1r, 6 2r E Ty PR3 , - y
15
z
= r( t ) i s th e c l assi ca l t raject ory, , T = - matt I
{332(r(t))}3
8T
( t) ,
,,a,b=1 a-on vector fields linear differential operator J, acting along y, is called the Jacobi I is the 3 x 3 identity matrix, and
(t)
.
A second-order
operator.
Problem 1.8. Find normal coordinates and frequencies for the Lagrangian system considered in Example 1.6 with Vo(q) = 2a2
1(qi+l-qi)2, where qfl+l = q1.
Problem 1.9. Prove that the second variation of the action functional in Riemannian geometry is given by
tl (J(Jl'Y), 62y)dt.
62S = it o
Here 61'Y, 62y E .,PM, J = -V7 - R('y, )'y is the Jacobi operator, and R is a curvature operator - a fibre-wise linear mapping R : TM ® TM -> End(TM) of vector bundles, defined by R(e,g) = V,70£ - VCV,7 + V[C,,7] : TM -> TM, where , g E Vect(M). Problem 1.10. Choosing the principal axes of inertia as a/ basis in 1R3, show
that the Lie algebra isomorphism g - ]R3 is given by g D ( n3
02
03 -sly 01
I
F-+
o
A, 02, 1l3) E R3.
Problem 1.11. Show that for every symmetric A E End g there exists a symmetric 3 x 3 matrix A such that A SZ = Al + QA, and find A for diagonal A.
Problem 1.12. Derive Euler's equations for a rigid body. (Hint: Use that L = -2 Tr ASZ2, where 1 = g-1g and 6 = -g-16g 1 + g-16g, and obtain the EulerLagrange equations in the matrix form Al + IA = A12 - 12A.)
1.4. Symmetries and Noether's theorem. To describe the motion of a mechanical system one needs to solve the corresponding Euler-Lagrange
equations - a system of second order ordinary differential equations for the generalized coordinates. This could be a very difficult problem. Therefore of particular interest are those functions of generalized coordinates and velocities which remain constant during the motion.
Definition. A smooth function I : TM -> R is called the integral of motion (first integral, or conservation law) for a Lagrangian system (M, L) if
dtI(ry
(t)) = 0
for all extremals -y of the action functional.
Definition. The energy of a Lagrangian system (M, L) is a function E on TM x R defined in standard coordinates on TM by n
E(q, 4, t) _ 8=1
4 8q (q, 4, t) - L(q, 4, t).
1. Classical Mechanics
16
Lemma 1.1. The energy E = q
aL aq
- L is a well-defined function on TM x
Proof. Let (U, cp) and (U', cp') be coordinate charts on M with the transition functions F = (F1, ... , Fn) = cp' o cp-1 : cp(U fl U') -+ c "(U n U'). Corre-
sponding standard coordinates (q, q) and (q', q') are related by q' = F(q)
and q' = F,(q)q (see Section 1.2). We have dq' = F*(q)dq and dq' _ G(q, q)dq + F, (q)dq (for some matrix-valued function G(q, q)), so that
aLdq'+aLdq'+atdt
dL = =
(IL
aL
aq,F*(q) + aq,G(q, q)J dq +
F.(q)dq + at dt
= aq dq + aq dq + at dt. Thus under a change of coordinates
aq F. (q) = a4
and
aL aL q aq, = qaq ,
so that E is a well-defined function on TM.
Corollary 1.2. Under a change of local coordinates on M, components of
aq (q, q, t) =
(aq , ... , aq ) transform like components of a 1-form on M.
Proposition 1.1 (Conservation of energy). The energy of a closed system is an integral of motion.
Proof. For an extremal 'y set E(t) = E(y(t)). We have, according to the Euler-Lagrange equations,
dE
d
dt
dt
aL aL.. q q + aq '94 d
aL aq q ,
aL ., aq q
aL
at
=(d(4)-aQ)q- at =-a.
Since for a closed system at = 0, the energy is conserved. Conservation of energy for a closed mechanical system is a fundamental law of physics which follows from the homogeneity of time. For a general closed system of N interacting particles considered in Example 1.2, N
N
E=>mara-L=EZmara+V(r). a=1
a=1
1. Lagrangian Mechanics
17
In other words, the total energy E = T + V is a sum of the kinetic energy and the potential energy.
Definition. A Lagrangian L : TM --+ R is invariant with respect to the diffeomorphism g : M --> M if L(g,(v)) = L(v) for all v E TM. The diffeomorphism g is called the symmetry of a closed Lagrangian system (M, L). A Lie group G is the symmetry group of (M, L) (group of continuous symmetries) if there is a left G-action on M such that for every g c G the mapping
Mix
Continuous symmetries give rise to conservation laws.
Theorem 1.3 (Noether). Suppose that a Lagrangian L : TM -* IR is invariant under a one-parameter group {gs}SER of difeomorphisms of M. Then the Lagrangian system (M, L) admits an integral of motion I, given in standard coordinates on TM by
I (q, q) i=1
where X = i=1
aq (q, 4)
(d9()
aL 8=0
ad
a,
a2(q) a9 is the vector field on M associated with the flow gs ii
The integral of motion I is called the Noether integral. Proof. It follows from Corollary 1.2 that I is a well-defined function on TM. Now differentiating L((gs),(ry'(t))) = L(ry'(t)) with respect to s at s = 0 and using the Euler-Lagrange equations we get d aL aL da aL . = d aL 0 = aL aqa +aqa a+ dt dt ad aqa ad dt
where a(t) = (a1(ry(t)), ... , an(y(t))).
Remark. A vector field X on M is called an infinitesimal symmetry if the corresponding local flow gs of X (defined for each s e IR on some U, C M)
is a symmetry: L o (g3), = L on Us. Every vector field X on M lifts to a vector field X' on TM, defined by a local flow on TM induced from the corresponding local flow on M. In standard coordinates on TM, and X' _ (q) aqi Qi i=1 i,j=1 It is easy to verify that X is an infinitesimal symmetry if and only if (1.5)
X=
a' (q)
i=1
dL(X') = 0 on TM, which in standard coordinates has the form (1.6) i=1
i,j=1
(q) aq = 0.
1. Classical Mechanics
18
Remark. Noether's theorem generalizes to time-dependent Lagrangians L : TM x 1[8 -> R. Namely, on the extended configuration space M1 = M X IR define a time-independent Lagrangian Ll by
L1(4,r,4,T) = L q, --,T
T,
where (q, T) are local coordinates on M1 and (q, T, 4, T) are standard coordinates on TM1. The Noether integral Il for a closed system (Mi, L1) defines an integral of motion I for a system (M, L) by the formula
I(4,4,t) = I,(4,t,4,1). When the Lagrangian L does not depend on time, L1 is invariant with respect to the one-parameter group of translations r '--> r + s, and the Noether integral Il = L, gives I = -E. ai-
Noether's theorem can be generalized as follows.
Proposition 1.2. Suppose that for the Lagrangian L : TM -+ IR there exist a vector field X on M and a function K on TM such that for every path ry in M,
Then n
I=
n 7-
(q, 4) - K(4, 4)
a2(4) i=1
is an integral of motion for the Lagrangian system (M, L). Proof. Using Euler-Lagrange equations, we have along the extremal ry, d dt
aL
a'a 4
=
aL a4
a+
aL. dK a4 a = dt
Example 1.9 (Conservation of momentum). Let M = V be a vector space, and suppose that a Lagrangian L is invariant with respect to a one-parameter group g. (q) = q + sv, v E V. According to Noether's theorem, n
aL I=Evza qi
i
=1
is an integral of motion. Now let (M, L) be a closed Lagrangian system of N interacting particles considered in Example 1.2. We have M = V = If83`v, and the Lagrangian L is invariant under simultaneous translation of
1. Lagrangian Mechanics
19
coordinates Ta = (ra, r2, r3) of all particles by the same vector c E R3. Thus v = (c, ... , c) E R3N and for every c = (cI, c2, c3) E ]f83, N &3L
I = Y (cl ara + c2 ara + c3
= c1P1 } c2P2 + c3P3
a
is an integral of motion. The integrals of motion P1, P2, P3 define the vector N
P=far ER (or rather a vector in the dual space to 1R3), called the momentum of the system. Explicitly, N
P = E mO'a, a=1
so that the total momentum of a closed system is the sum of momenta of individual particles. Conservation of momentum is a fundamental physical law which reflects the homogeneity of space. 8L Traditionally, pi = are called generalized moments corresponding to aqi
generalized coordinates qt, and Fz = aL are called generalized forces. In q these notations, the Euler-Lagrange equations have the same form
15 =F as Newton's equations in Cartesian coordinates. Conservation of momentum implies Newton's third law.
Example 1.10 (Conservation of angular momentum). Let M = V be a vector space with Euclidean inner product. Let G = SO(V) be the connected
Lie group of automorphisms of V preserving the inner product, and let g = .so (V) be the Lie algebra of G. Suppose that a Lagrangian L is invariant with respect to the action of a one-parameter subgroup g, (q) = esx q of G
on V, where x E g and ex is the exponential map. According to Noether's theorem, n
(x q)'
I
aL aqi
i=1
is an integral of motion. Now let (M, L) be a closed Lagrangian system of N interacting particles considered in Example 1.2. We have M = V = R3N, and the Lagrangian L is invariant under a simultaneous rotation of coordinates Ta of all particles by the same orthogonal transformation in 1[83.
1. Classical Mechanics
20
Thus x = (u, ... , u) E so(3) ® .
.
and for every u E so (3),
.ED
N
I _- 1NC(u
ra,)
1 9L
+ (u Ta)
Owl
a=1
2 aL ara2
+ (u ra)
3 aL ar3 /
is an integral of motion. Let u (= u1X11 + u2X2 + u3X3, where X, = 0
]I83 coris the basis in so (3) 01 -01 0' \-0 0 0 I , X3 J o responding to the rotations about the vectors e1i e2, e3 of the standard orC 0
0 01 , X2
thonormal basis in 1E83 (see Problem 1.10). We get
I = u1M1 + u2M2 + u3M3,
where M = (MI, M2, M3) E 1[83 (or rather a vector in the dual space to so(3)) is given by N
MEra X a Q. a=1
The vector M is called the angular momentum of the system. Explicitly, N
M = E ra X maTa, a=1
so that the total angular momentum of a closed system is the sum of angular momenta of individual particles. Conservation of angular momentum is a fundamental physical law which reflects the isotropy of space. Problem 1.13. Find how total momentum and total angular momentum transform under the Galilean transformations.
1.5. One-dimensional motion. The motion of systems with one degree of freedom is called one-dimensional. In terms of a Cartesian coordinate x on M = 1[8 the Lagrangian takes the form
L=
V(x).
The conservation of energy
E = 2m±2+V(x) allows us to solve the equation of motion in a closed form by separation of variables. We have
so that t=
rTrn 22
dx
E - V (X)
1. Lagrangian Mechanics
21
The inverse function x(t) is a general solution of Newton's equation dV
mx = d--x
with two arbitrary constants, the energy E and the constant of integration. Since kinetic energy is non-negative, for a given value of E the actual motion takes place in the region of 118 where V (x) < E. The points where V (x) = E are called turning points. The motion which is confined between two turning points is called finite. The finite motion is periodic - the particle oscillates between the turning points fxl and x2 with the period
T (E) = 2m
dx
J
X2
E-V(x)
If the region V(x) < E is unbounded, then the motion is called infinite and the particle eventually goes to infinity. The regions where V (x) > E are forbidden.
On the phase plane with coordinates (x, y) Newton's equation reduces to the first order system dV mx=y, y=-dx
Trajectories correspond to the phase curves (x(t), y(t)), which lie on the level sets
y
2m
+ V (x) = E
of the energy function. The points (xo, 0), where xo is a critical point of the potential energy V (x), correspond to the equilibrium solutions. The local
minima correspond to the stable solutions and local maxima correspond to the unstable solutions. For the values of E which do not correspond to the equilibrium solutions the level sets are smooth curves. These curves are closed if the motion is finite. The simplest non-trivial one-dimensional system, besides the free particle, is the harmonic oscillator with V(x) = 2kx2 (k > 0), considered in Example 1.6. The general solution of the equation of motion is
x(t) = Acos(wt + a), where A is the amplitude, w = V
m
is the frequency, and a is the phase 2
. The energy is E _ of a simple harmonic motion with the period T = 12 mw2A2 and the motion is finite with the same period T for E > 0.
Problem 1.14. Show that for V(x) = -x4 there are phase curves which do not exist for all times. Prove that if V (x) > 0 for all x, then all phase curves exist for all times.
1. Classical Mechanics
22
Problem 1.15. The simple pendulum is a Lagrangian system with M = S1 = R/27rZ and L = 10' + cos 0. Find the period T of the pendulum as a function of the amplitude of the oscillations. Problem 1.16. Suppose that the potential energy V (x) is even, V (O) = 0, and V (x) is a one-to-one monotonically increasing function for x > 0. Prove that the inverse function x(V) and the period T(E) are related by the Abel transform V dV 1 T(E)dE T(E) = 2 2m E dx and x(V) = dV E _-V 27r 2m Jo V-E
1.6. The motion in a central field and the Kepler problem. The motion of a system of two interacting particles - the two-body problem - can also be solved completely. Namely, in this case (see Example 1.2) M=R 6 and
L=
m12
i
+
!!& - V(lrl - r2l)2
Introducing on R6 new coordinates
r=rl-r2 and
R=mlrl+m2r2
M1 + m2
we get
L = z'nR2+ 2µ''2 -V(Irl), where m = m1 +m2 is the total mass and p = mlm2 is the reduced mass m1+m2 of a two-body system. The Lagrangian L depends only on the velocity R of the center of mass and not on its position R. A generalized coordinate with this property is called cyclic. It follows from the Euler-Lagrange equations that generalized momentum corresponding to the cyclic coordinate is conserved. In our case it is a total momentum of the system,
P = aR = mR, so that the center of mass R moves uniformly. Thus in the frame of reference
where R = 0, the two-body problem reduces to the problem of a single particle of mass p in the external central field V (I r l) . In spherical coordinates in 1183,
x = r sin l9 cos cp, y = r sin O sin W, z = r cos O,
where 0 < 19 < 7r, 0 < W < 2ir, its Lagrangian takes the form L = 2µ(T2 + r2i92 + r2 sine2,0 cp2) - V(r).
It follows from the conservation of angular momentum M = pr X r that during motion the position vector r lies in the plane P orthogonal to M in 1[83. Introducing polar coordinates (r, x) in the plane P we get X2 = 192 + sin219 cp2, so that
L = 1µ(T2 + r2X2) - V (r).
1. Lagrangian Mechanics
23
The coordinate X is cyclic and its generalized momentum pr2i coincides with IMI if X > 0 and with -IM I if < 0. Denoting this quantity by M, we get the equation (1.7)
µr 2X = M,
which is equivalent to Kepler's second law12. Using (1.7) we get for the total energy 2
(1.8)
E = 1µ(r2 + r2X2) + V (r) =
2µr2 + V (r) + 2r2
µ Thus the radial motion reduces to a one-dimensional motion on the half-line r > 0 with the effective potential energy M2
Veff (r) = V (r) + 2µr2
where the second term is called the centrifugal energy. As in the previous section, the solution is given by dr
µ
t =
(1.9)
2
E - Veff(r)
It follows from (1.7) that the angle X is a monotonic function of t, given by another quadrature M dr (1.10)
X
2µ
r2 E - Veff(r)'
yielding an equation of the trajectory in polar coordinates.
The set Veff (r) < E is a union of annuli 0 < rmin, < r < rmax < oo, and the motion is finite if 0 < rmin < r < rmax < oo. Though for a finite motion r(t) oscillates between rmin, and rmax, corresponding trajectories are
not necessarily closed. The necessary and sufficient condition for a finite motion to have a closed trajectory is that the angle
M
rmax
OX V "Y"
min
dr
r2 E - Yef f (r)
is commensurable with 2-7r, i.e., AX = 2-7rm for some m, n E Z. If the angle n
AX is not commensurable with 27r, the orbit is everywhere dense in the annulus rmin < r < rmax. If lim Veff (r) = lim V (r) = V < 00, r-oo roo
the motion is infinite for E > V - the particle goes to oo with finite velocity
(E - V). 12It is the statement that sectorial velocity of a particle in a central field is constant.
1. Classical Mechanics
24
A very important special case is when
V(r) = -a. r It describes Newton's gravitational attraction (a > 0) and Coulomb electrostatic interaction (either attractive or repulsive). First consider the case when a > 0 - Kepler's problem. The effective potential energy is
a
M2
Veff (r) = - r + 2µr2 and has the global minimum a2µ
__
2M2
VO
at r° =
M2
The motion is infinite for E > 0 and is finite for V° < E < 0. The explicit form of trajectories can be determined by an elementary
aµ
.
integration in (1.10), which gives
M M r
To + C. 2µ(E - V°) Choosing a constant of integration C = 0 and introducing notation
X = COS1
p=r° and e= we get the equation of the orbit (trajectory) p
(1.11)
= l+ecosX.
This is the equation of a conic section with one focus at the origin. Quantity
2p is called the latus rectum of the orbit, and e is called the eccentricity. The choice C = 0 is such that the point with X = 0 is the point nearest to the origin (called the perihelion). When V° < E < 0, the eccentricity e < 1 so that the orbit is the ellipse13 with the major and minor semi-axes _ p IMI (1.12) a= p _ a 1 - e2
Correspondingly, rmzn = orbit is given by
- 2JEJ'
1
+ e,
b-
rmax
1 - e2
p
=1
T = era N
2_1L I EI
e, and the period T of elliptic
f -a 2IEI3,
The last formula is Kepler's third law. When E > 0, the eccentricity e > 1
and the motion is infinite - the orbit is a hyperbola with the origin as 13The statement that planets have elliptic orbits with a focus at the Sun is Kepler's first law.
1. Lagrangian Mechanics
25
internal focus. When E = 0, the eccentricity e = 1 - the particle starts from rest at oc and the orbit is a parabola. For the repulsive case a < 0 the effective potential energy Ve f f (r) is always positive and decreases monotonically from oo to 0. The motion is always infinite and the trajectories are hyperbolas (parabola if E = 0)
r
=-1+ecosX
with
p=-M2 and e= ap
2EM2
1+
µa2
Kepler's problem is very special: for every a c 1l the Lagrangian system on 1[83 with
L= µT2+-ar
(1.13)
2
has three extra integrals of motion W1, W2, W3 in addition to the components of the angular momentum M. The corresponding vector W = (Wi, W2, W3), called the Laplace-Runge-Lenz vector, is given by
W
(1.14)
M or =rx--. r
Indeed, using equations of motion yr =
lar momentum M = pr x r, we get
- a3r and conservation of the angu-
W =µr X (r xr)- arr
r3
= (µr r)r - (µT r)T - ar + a( T3r)r r
=0.
Using µ(r x M) r = M2 and the identity (a X b)2 = a2 b2 - (a b)2, we get (1.15)
W2 = a2 + 2M2E µ
where
E=P2p2-ar is the energy corresponding to the Lagrangian (1.13). The fact that all orbits are conic sections follows from this extra symmetry of Kepler's problem. Problem 1.17. Prove all the statements made in this section.
1. Classical Mechanics
26
Problem 1.18. Show that if lim V, f(r)
r-+0
then there are orbits with r,,,,i,,, = 0 - "fall" of the particle to the center.
Problem 1.19. Prove that all finite trajectories in the central field are closed only when
a>0. V(r)=kr2, k>0, and V(r)=-a, r Problem 1.20. Find parametric equations for orbits in Kepler's problem.
Problem 1.21. Prove that the Laplace-Runge-Lenz vector W points in the direction of the major axis of the orbit and that W J = ae, where e is the eccentricity of the orbit.
Problem 1.22. Using the conservation of the Laplace-Runge-Lenz vector, prove that trajectories in Kepler's problem with E < 0 are ellipses. (Hint: Evaluate W r and use the result of the previous problem.)
1.7. Legendre transform. The equations of motion of a Lagrangian system (M, L) in standard coordinates associated with a coordinate chart U C M are the Euler-Lagrange equations. In expanded form, they are given by the following system of second order ordinary differential equations:
aq (q, 9) = dt
_
,IL
(aq
a2L (5Vq;
a2L
+ agag; (q, 4) 4j
i = 1, ... , n.
;_ In order for this system to be solvable for the highest derivatives for all initial conditions in TU, the symmetric n x n matrix 2
HL (q, q) = f aQ qj (q,
l'
1 i7'
=1
should be invertible on TU.
Definition. A Lagrangian system (M, L) is called non-degenerate if for every coordinate chart U on M the matrix HL(q, q) is invertible on TU.
Remark. Note that the n x n matrix HL is a Hessian of the Lagrangian function L for vertical directions on TM. Under the change of standard coordinates q' = F(q) and q' = F (q)v (see Section 1.2) it has the transformation law HL (q, 4) = F. (q)T HL (q', 4')F'* (q),
where F, (q)T is the transposed matrix, so that the condition det HL does not depend on the choice of standard coordinates.
0
1. Lagrangian Mechanics
27
For an invariant formulation, consider the 1-form BL, defined in standard coordinates associated with a coordinate chart U C M by n
OL _
. 8L dqi
L.ai i=1
q
= aL a q d4
It follows from Corollary 1.2 that 9L is a well-defined 1-form on TM.
Lemma 1.2. A Lagrangian system (M, L) is non-degenerate if and only if the 2-form dOL on TM is non-degenerate.
Proof. In standard coordinates, d6L =
E
/ as
2
C
2
aq7
dq' A dqi + as aqj dq3 A dq2 J
,
and it is easy to see, by considering the 2n-form dBL = dBL A .
A dOL, n
that the 2-form dOL is non-degenerate if and only if the matrix HL is nondegenerate.
Remark. Using the 1-form BL, the Noether integral I in Theorem 1.3 can be written as (1.16)
I = iX1 (BL),
where X' is a lift to TM of a vector field X on M given by (1.5). It also immediately follows from (1.6) that if X is an infinitesimal symmetry, then (1.17)
GX' (6L) = 0.
Definition. Let (U, cp) be a coordinate chart on M. Coordinates (p,q) = (pl,...,pn,gl,...,g)
on the chart T* U _ R x U on the cotangent bundle T* M are called standard coordinates14 if for (p, q) E T*U and f E Coo (U) aa4 pi(df) =
,
i = 1,...,n.
Equivalently, standard coordinates on T*U are uniquely characterized by the condition that p = ( p 1 , . . . , pn) are coordinates in the fiber corresponding
to the basis dql, ... , dqn for T9 M, dual to the basis - , ... , aqn for TqM. o9ql
14Following tradition, the first n coordinates parametrize the fiber of T*U and the last n coordinates parametrize the base.
1. Classical Mechanics
28
Definition. The 1-form 0 on T*M, defined in standard coordinates by n
0 = E pidgz = pdq, is called Liouville's canonical 1-form. Corollary 1.2 shows that 0 is a well-defined 1-form on T*M. Clearly, the 1-form 0 also admits an invariant definition 0(u) = p(7r*(u)),
where
u c T(p,q)T*M,
and 7r : T*M -p M is the canonical projection.
Definition. A fibre-wise mapping TL : TM -> T*M is called a Legendre transform associated with the Lagrangian L if eL = TL(e).
In standard coordinates the Legendre transform is given by TL(q, 4) _ (p, q),
where p = aq (q, 4)
The mapping TL is a local diffeomorphism if and only if the Lagrangian L is non-degenerate.
Definition. Suppose that the Legendre transform TL : TM -i T*M is a diffeomorphism. The Hamiltonian function H : T*M -+ R, associated with the Lagrangian L : TM - R, is defined by aL
HoTL=EL=4aq
L.
In standard coordinates, H(p, q) _ (p4 - L(q, 4))I aL , P-- Tqr
where q is a function of p and q defined by the equation p =
8L
a4
(q, q)
through the implicit function theorem. The cotangent bundle T*M is called the phase space of the Lagrangian system (M, L). It turns out that on the phase space the equations of motion take a very simple and symmetric form.
Theorem 1.4. Suppose that the Legendre transform TL : TM --* T*M is a diffeomorphism. Then the Euler-Lagrange equations in standard coordinates on TM, d 8L aL
dt8cji - a- =0, i = 1,...,n,
1. Lagrangian Mechanics
29
are equivalent to the following system of first order differential equations in standard coordinates on T*M:
pi= -
a
aH
OH
4
api
,
i = 1,...,n.
Proof. We have
dH =
=
dP +
OH
dq
(Pd+qdP_-_-dq___dcfl q a4
aL P_- Tqr
aL (qdP_-dq) Thus under the Legendre transform,
4=
d49L_r7L_ aH
OH
and T = dt a4
19P
aq
aq
Corresponding first order differential equations on T*M are called Hamilton's equations (canonical equations).
Corollary 1.5. The Hamiltonian H is constant on the solutions of Hamilton's equations.
Proof. For H(t) = H(p(t), q(t)) we have dH dt
_ aH
aH
.
aH aH
.
aq 4+ aP P
49q aP
aH aH .9p aq
0.
El
For the Lagrangian z
L=m2 -V(r)=T-V,
rElE83,
of a particle of mass m in a potential field V (r), considered in Example 1.4, we have
P=
OL Or
= mr.
Thus the Legendre transform TL : T1f 3 -> T*I1 3 is a global diffeomorphism, linear on the fibers, and
H(P,r)= (PT-L)1;._p =
2m+V(r)=T+V.
1. Classical Mechanics
30
Hamilton's equations
r= OH ap
p
m'
aH
aV
p=-ar =-ar
are equivalent to Newton's equations with the force F = -
ar
For the Lagrangian system describing small oscillators, considered in Example 1.6, we have p = m4, and using normal coordinates we get n
2
H(p, 4) = (p4 - L(4, 4))14=y = 2- + Vo(4) = 2m
(p2 + m2 > wi (qi)2) i=1
Similarly, for the system of N interacting particles, considered in Example 1.2, we have p = (pl, ... , PN), where aL Pa =
ar a
a = 1, ... , N.
= mara,
T*IR3N is a global diffeomorphism,
The Legendre transform TL : TR3N linear on the fibers, and
N
2
H (p, r) = (pr - L) 1._ Q = E pa + V (r) = T + V. r,n
a=1 2ma
In particular, for a closed system with pair-wise interaction, N
2
pa Vab(ra - rb) 2m a + a=1 1
H(p, r)
In general, consider the Lagrangian n
2aij(4)4x4j - V(q), q c Rn
L= i,j=1
where A(q) = {aij (q) }i j=1 is a symmetric n x n matrix. We have n aL Ai = z = E aij(4)4', a4.
i = 1,...,n,
j=1
and the Legendre transform is a global diffeomorphism, linear on the fibers, if and only if the matrix A(q) is non-degenerate for all q E R'. In this case, n
H(p,4)= (p4-L(4,4))l r_aL = Tqr
2aij (4)7i1j+V(4), i,j=1
where {aij (q)}ij=1 = A-1(q) is the inverse matrix.
2. Hamiltonian Mechanics
31
Problem 1.23 (Second tangent bundle). Let it : TM -> M be the canonical projection and let Tv(TM) be the vertical tangent bundle of TM along the fibers of it - the kernel of the bundle mapping -7r* : T(TM) --> TM. Prove that there is a natural bundle isomorphism i : TM ^ TV (TM).
Problem 1.24 (Invariant definition of the 1-form BL). Show that OL(v) _ dL((i o 7r*)v), where v E T(TM).
Problem 1.25. Give an invariant proof of (1.17). Problem 1.26. Prove that the path y(t) in M is a trajectory for the Lagrangian system (M, L) if and only if i_y,(t) (dOL) +dEL(y'(t)) = 0,
where y'(t) is the velocity vector of the path 'y'(t) in TM.
Problem 1.27. Show that for a charged particle in an electromagnetic field, considered in Example 1.5,
H(p, r)2m= -(- c
p = m + eA and c
eA)z
+ ep(r).
Problem 1.28. Suppose that for a Lagrangian system ([8L, L) the Legendre transform TL is a diffeomorphism and let H be the corresponding Hamiltonian. Prove that for fixed q and q the function pq - H(p, q) has a single critical point aL at p = . aq Problem 1.29. Give an example of a non-degenerate Lagrangian system (M, L) such that the Legendre transform TL : TM -+ T*M is one-to-one but not onto.
2. Hamiltonian Mechanics 2.1. Hamilton's equations. With every function H : T*M -> I[8 on the phase space T*M there are associated Hamilton's equations - a first-order system of ordinary differential equations, which in the standard coordinates on T*U has the form OH
p=-aq,
(2.1)
aH q= ap.
The corresponding vector field XH on T*U, XH
aHa - i-1
\ app aqx
aHa
aHaaHa _
a4Z
gives rise to a well-defined vector field XH on T*M, called the Hamiltonian
vector field. Suppose now that the vector field XH on T*M is complete, i.e., its integral curves exist for all times. The corresponding one-parameter group {gt}tEu of diffeomorphisms of T*M generated by XH is called the Hamiltonian phase flow. It is defined by gt(p, q) = (p(t), q(t)), where p(t), q(t) is a solution of Hamilton's equations satisfying p(O) = p, q(0) = q.
1. Classical Mechanics
32
Liouville's canonical 1-form 0 on T*M defines a 2-form w = dB. In standard coordinates on T*M it is given by n
i=1
and is a non-degenerate 2-form. The form w is called the canonical symplectic form on T*M. The symplectic form w defines an isomorphism J : T*(T*M) --> T(T*M) between tangent and cotangent bundles to T*M. For every (p, q) E T*M the linear mapping J-1 T(r q)T*M -> Tar 9)T*M is :
given by w(u1i U2)
= J-1(u2)(u1),
U1, u2 E
T(r,q)T*M.
The mapping J induces the isomorphism between the infinite-dimensional vector spaces Al(T*M) and Vect(T*M), which is linear over C°°(T*M). If 19 is a 1-form on T*M, then the corresponding vector field J(19) on T*M satisfies w(X, J(19)) = 19(X),
X E Vect(T*M),
and J-1(X) = -ixw. In particular, in standard coordinates,
J(dp) = aq and J(dq)
49 p19p,
so that XH = J(dH). Theorem 2.1. The Hamiltonian phase flow on T*M preserves the canonical symplectic form. Proof. We need to prove that (gt)*w = w. Since gt is a one-parameter group of diffeomorphisms, it is sufficient to show that d 1
4+
(gt)*w 1t=o = GXHW = 0,
where Lx, is the Lie derivative along the vector field XH. Since for every vector field X,
Gx(df) = d(X(f)), we compute GxH (dpi) = -d I
q
and GxH (dq2) = d
(P )
so that n
(GxH (dpi) A dqZ + dpi A Lx, (dqZ))
GxHw = i=1
E \-d(a4) AdgZ+dpiAd (ap )) Z-1
-d(dH)=0.
El
2. Hamiltonian Mechanics
33
Corollary 2.2. Lx,, (0) = d(-H+0(XH)), where 0 is Liouville's canonical 1 -form.
The canonical symplectic form w on T*M defines the volume form wn n!
_
1
n!
A w on T*M, called Liouville's volume form.
wA
n
Corollary 2.3 (Liouville's theorem). The Hamiltonian phase flow on T*M preserves Liouville's volume form.
The restriction of the symplectic form w on T*M to the configuration space M is 0. Generalizing this property, we get the following notion.
Definition. A submanifold . of the phase space T*M is called a Lagrangian submanifold if dim P = dim M and wl2 = 0. It follows from Theorem 2.1 that the image of a Lagrangian submanifold under the Hamiltonian phase flow is a Lagrangian submanifold. Problem 2.1. Verify that XH is a well-defined vector field on T*M.
Problem 2.2. Show that if all level sets of the Hamiltonian H are compact submanifolds of T*M, then the Hamiltonian vector field XH is complete.
Problem 2.3. Let 7r : T*M -* M be the canonical projection, and let . be a Lagrangian submanifold. Show that if the mapping 7rl, : Y -> M is a diffeomorphism, then 2 is a graph of a smooth function on M. Give examples when for some t > 0 the corresponding projection of gt (2) onto M is no longer a diffeomorphism.
2.2. The action functional in the phase space. With every function H on the phase space T*M there is an associated 1-form
0 - Hdt = pdq - Hdt on the extended phase space T*M x R, called the Poincare-Cartan form. Let y : [to, t1] -> T*M be a smooth parametrized path in T*M such that 7r(y(to)) = qo and ir(y(tl)) = q1, where 7r : T*M , M is the canonical projection. By definition, the lift of a path y to the extended phase space T*M x R is a path o, [to, t1] -+ T*M x IR given by o,(t) = (y(t), t), and a path a in T*M x IR is called an admissible path if it is a lift of a path y in :
T*M. The space of admissible paths in T*M x R is denoted by P(T*M)Qo,to.
A variation of an admissible path a is a smooth family of admissible paths o"E, where E E [-Eo, Eo] and ao = a, and the corresponding infinitesimal variation is SQ =
aE
Lo
E TcTP(T*M)9o,to
(cf. Section 1.2). The principle of the least action in the phase space is the following statement.
1. Classical Mechanics
34
Theorem 2.4 (Poincare). The admissible path a in T*M x R is an extremal for the action functional
S(a) = f (pdq - Hdt) = Q
f
tl
(pq - H)dt
tp
if and only if it is a lift of a path y(t) = (p(t), q(t)) in T*M, where p(t) and q(t) satisfy canonical Hamilton's equations 25=
aH
ag,
aH
q=Opp.
Proof. As in the proof of Theorem 1.1, for an admissible family aE(t) _ (p(t, s), q(t, e), t) we compute using integration by parts, d de E=o
S(0E) _
f tl (4' Jpi - pi6q ' - aHi 6q
n
J
i=1
ag
to
aH
Spi
1
dt
api
n
tl
+
pi cSqiI to i=1
Since 6q(to) = Sq(t1) = 0, the path a is critical if and only if p(t) and q(t) satisfy canonical Hamilton's equations (2.1).
Remark. For a Lagrangian system (M, L), every path y(t) = (q(t)) in the configuration space M connecting points qo and q1 defines an admissible path 5'(t) = (p(t), q(t), t) in the phase space T*M by setting p = aL. If the q Legendre transform TL : TM -> T*M is a diffeomorphism, then ti
,
S(Y) = it (pq - H)dt = f to to
t)dt.
to
Thus the principle of the least action in a configuration space - Hamilton's principle - follows from the principle of the least action in a phase space. In fact, in this case the two principles are equivalent (see Problem 1.28). From Corollary 1.5 we immediately get the following result.
Corollary 2.5. Solutions of canonical Hamilton's equations lying on the hypersurface H(p, q) = E are extremals of the functional fa pdq in the class of admissible paths a lying on this hypersurface.
Corollary 2.6 (Maupertuis' principle). The trajectory y = (q(-r)) of a closed Lagrangian system (M, L) connecting points qo and q, and having energy E is the extremal of the functional pdq y
IL (q (-r), 4(T))4(r)dr
rya4
2. Hamiltonian Mechanics
35
on the space of all paths in the configuration space M connecting points qo and ql and parametrized such that H( (T),q(r)) = E. The functional
So(y) =
fpdq
is called the abbreviated action15
Proof. Every path y = q(7-), parametrized such that H(aq, q) = E, lifts to an admissible path a = (OL (r), q(T), r), a < -r < b, lying on the hypersurface
H(p, q) = E. Problem 2.4 (Jacobi). On a Riemannian manifold (M, ds2) consider a Lagrangian system with L(q, v) = 11 v11 2 - V(q). Let E > V(q) for all q E M. Show z that the trajectories of a closed Lagrangian system (M, L) with total energy E are geodesics for the Riemannian metric d§2 = (E - V(q))ds2 on M.
2.3. The action as a function of coordinates. Consider a non-degenerate Lagrangian system (M, L) and denote by y(t; qo, vo) the solution of Euler-Lagrange equations
aL _0 dt o94 aq with the initial conditions y(to) = qo E M and '(to) = vo E Tg0M. Suppose that there exist a neighborhood V0 C Tv0M of vo and ti > to such that for all v E V0 the extremals y(t; qo, v), which start at time to at qo, do not intersect in the extended configuration space M x 118 for times to < t < t1. Such extremals are said to form a central field which includes the
daL
-
extremal -yo (t) = -y (t; qo, vo). The existence of the central field of extremals is
equivalent to the condition that for every to < t < tl there is a neighborhood Ut C M of yo (t) E M such that the mapping (2.2)
V0 E) v !--) q(t)
_ -y(t; qo, v) E Ut
is a diffeomorphism. Basic theorems in the theory of ordinary differential equations guarantee that for tl sufficiently close to to every extremal y(t) for to < t < tl can be included into the central field. In standard coordinates the mapping (2.2) is given by q --> q(t) = y(t; qo, q). For the central field of extremals y(t; qo, q), to < t < t1, we define the action as a function of coordinates and time (or, classical action) by S(q, t; qo, to) =
f L(ry (r))dr, to
15The accurate formulation of Maupertuis' principle is due to Euler and Lagrange.
1. Classical Mechanics
36
where y(r) is the extremal from the central field that connects qo and q. For given qo and to, the classical action is defined for t E (to, ti) and q E Uto
S(q, t; qo, to) = So(q, t; qo, to) - E(t
- to),
where So is the abbreviated action from the previous section.
Theorem 2.7. The differential of the classical action S(q, t) with fixed initial point is given by
dS = pdq - Hdt, where p = aq (q, q) and H = pq - L(q, q) are determined by the velocity q of the extremal y(T) at time t.
Proof. Let qE be a path in M passing through q at E = 0 with the tangent vector v E TqM _- Rn, and for E small enough let y,(-r) be the family of extremals from the central field satisfying ye(to) = qo and yy(t) = qE. For the infinitesimal variation 6y we have &y(to) = 0 and 6y(t) = v, and for fixed t we get from the formula for variation with the free ends (1.2) that
dS(v) =
V.
This shows that as = p. Setting q(t) = y(t), we obtain q
as
d
dt S(q(t), t) = aq q
so that
as
+ at
L,
S=L-pq=-H.
El
Corollary 2.8. The classical action satisfies the following nonlinear partial differential equation (2.4)
11
at +H I aq,q) q
= 0.
This equation is called the Hamilton-Jacobi equation. Hamilton's equations (2.1) can be used for solving the Cauchy problem
S(q,t)jt=o = s(q), s E C°°(M), for Hamilton-Jacobi equation (2.4) by the method of characteristics. Namely assume the existence of the Hamiltonian phase flow gt on T*M and consider the Lagrangian submanifold (2.5)
(p,q)ET*M:p=asq)
2. Hamiltonian Mechanics
37
a graph of the 1-form ds on M - a section of the cotangent bundle 7r T*M -+ M. The mapping it is one-to-one and for sufficiently small t the restriction of the projection 7r to the Lagrangian submanifold 2t = gt(-2) remains to be one-to-one. In other words, there is tl > 0 such that for all 0 < t < ti the mapping 7rt = 7r o gt o (7r1.)-' : M --* M is a diffeomorphism, and the extremals ry(r, qo, qo) in the extended configuration space M x ][8,
where qo = aH (po, qo) and (po, qo) E 2, do not intersect. Such extremals are called the characteristics of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation.
Proposition 2.1. For 0 < t < tl the solution S(q, t) to the Cauchy problem (2.4)-(2.5) is given by t
S(q, t) = s(qo) + f
L(-'(T))dr. 0
Here -y(T) is the characteristic with y(t) = q and with the starting point qo = -y(0) which is uniquely determined by q.
Proof. As in the proof of Theorem 2.7 we use formula (1.2), where now depends on q, and obtain
8S
as
aqo
aq (g) = aqo (qo) aq + since aqo(qo) = po =
aL(go,
d dts(q(t),
8L
(q, q) 494
a 8L
qo (qo, qo)
qo
aqo
aq = p,
qo) Setting q(t) = 7(t) we get
t) = asq + at = L(q, q),
so that as
and S satisfies the Hamilton-Jacobi equation. We can also consider the action S(q, t; qo, to) as a function of both variables q and qo. The analog of Theorem 2.7 is the following statement.
Proposition 2.2. The differential of the classical action as a function of initial and final points is given by
dS = pdq - podqo - H(p, q)dt + H(po, go)dto. Problem 2.5. Prove that the solution to the Cauchy problem for the HamiltonJacobi equation is unique.
1. Classical Mechanics
38
2.4. Classical observables and Poisson bracket. Smooth real-valued functions on the phase space T*M are called classical observables. The vector
space C°°(T*M) is an IR-algebra - an associative algebra over R with a unit given by the constant function 1, and with a multiplication given by the point-wise product of functions. The commutative algebra CO°(T*M) is called the algebra of classical observables. Assuming that the Hamiltonian
phase flow gt exists for all times, the time evolution of every observable f E C°°(T*M) is given by ft(p, q) = f (gt(p, q)) = f (p(t), q(t)), (p, q) E TM. Equivalently, the time evolution is described by the differential equation dft
dfs+t
at
ds
n
_
__
d(ft o gs) as
8=o
(aH aft
= XH(ft)
LO
aHaft _ OH aft aqi apz)
ap i aqi
ap aq
aHaft aq ap
called Hamilton's equation for classical observables. Setting (2.6)
{f, g} = X f(g)
= of aQ - a4 ap,
f, g c C°°(T*M),
we can rewrite Hamilton's equation in the concise form
d = {H, f },
(2.7)
where it is understood that (2.7) is a differential equation for a family of functions ft on T*M with the initial condition ft(p, q)It=o = f (p, q). The properties of the bilinear mapping {
,
} : C°°(T*M) x C00(T*M) ---> C°°(T*M)
are summarized below.
Theorem 2.9. The mapping {
,
} satisfies the following properties.
(i) (Relation with the symplectic form) { f, g} = w(J(df), J(dg)) = w(X f, Xg). (ii) (Skew-symmetry)
{ f, g} = -{g, f }. (iii) (Leibniz rule) { f g, h} = f {g, h} + g{ f, h}.
(iv) (Jacobi identity)
{f, {g,h}}+{g,{h, f}}+{h,{f,g}} = 0 for all f,g,h E C°°(T*M).
2. Hamiltonian Mechanics
39
Proof. Property (i) immediately follows from the definitions of w and J in Section 2.1. Properties (ii)-(iii) are obvious. The Jacobi identity could be verified by a direct computation using (2.6), or by the following elegant argument. Observe that { f, g} is a bilinear form in the first partial derivatives of f and g, and every term in the left-hand side of the Jacobi identity is a linear homogenous function of second partial derivatives of f, g, and h. Now the only terms in the Jacobi identity which could actually contain second partial derivatives of a function h are the following:
{f, {g, h}} + {g, {h, f }} = (XfXg - XgXf)(h). However, this expression does not contain second partial derivatives of h since it is a commutator of two differential operators of the first order which is again a differential operator of the first order! The observable { f, g} is called the canonical Poisson bracket of the observables f and g. The Poisson bracket map { , } : C°°(T*M) xCO°(T*M) -* CO0(T*M) turns the algebra of classical observables C°°(T*M) into a Lie algebra with a Lie bracket given by the Poisson bracket. It has an important
property that the Lie bracket is a bi-derivation with respect to the multiplication in C°°(T*M). The algebra of classical observables CO°(T*M) is an example of the Poisson algebra - a commutative algebra over 118 carrying a structure of a Lie algebra with the property that the Lie bracket is a derivation with respect to the algebra product. In Lagrangian mechanics, a function I on TM is an integral of motion for the Lagrangian system (M, L) if it is constant along the trajectories. In Hamiltonian mechanics, an observable I - a function on the phase space T*M - is called an integral of motion (first integral) for Hamilton's equations (2.1) if it is constant along the Hamiltonian phase flow. According to (2.7), this is equivalent to the condition
{H,I}=0. It is said that the observables H and I are in involution (Poisson commute).
2.5. Canonical transformations and generating functions. Definition. A diffeomorphism g of the phase space T*M is called a canonical transformation, if it preserves the canonical symplectic form w on T*M, i.e., g*(w) = w. By Theorem 2.1, the Hamiltonian phase flow gt is a oneparameter group of canonical transformations.
Proposition 2.3. Canonical transformations preserve Hamilton's equations.
1. Classical Mechanics
40
Proof. From g*(w) = w it follows that the mapping J : T*(T*M) T(T*M) satisfies
g*oJog* =J.
(2.8)
Indeed, for all X, Y E Vect(M) we have16
w(X,Y) = 9*(w)(X,Y) = w(9*(X), 9*(Y)) o g, so that for every 1-form i9 on M,
w(X, J(g*(t9))) = 9*(,O)(X) ='d(9*(X)) 09 = w(9*(X), 49)) 09, which gives g*(J(g*(29))) = J(i9). Using (2.8), we get
9*(XH) = 9*(J(dH)) = J((9*)-1(dH)) = XK, where K = H o g-1. Thus the canonical transformation g maps trajectories of the Hamiltonian vector field XH into the trajectories of the Hamiltonian vector field XK.
Remark. In classical terms, Proposition 2.3 means that canonical Hamilton's equations
p=-
aH
a
(p, q)
in new coordinates (P, Q) = g(p, q) continue to have the canonical form
-aQ(P,Q), Q = aP(P,Q) with the old Hamiltonian function K(P, Q) = H(p, q). Consider now the classical case M = R'. For a canonical transformation
(P, Q) = g(p, q) set P = P(p, q) and Q = Q(p, q). Since dP A dQ = dp A dq on T*M -_ I[82n, the 1-form pdq - PdQ - the difference between the canonical Liouville 1-form and its pullback by the mapping g - is closed.
From the Poincare lemma it follows that there exists a function F(p, q) on 1R2 such that (2.9)
pdq - PdQ = dF(p, q).
Now assume that at some point (p0, qo) the n x n matrix
aP
8P{ l In
ap p
apj
5
i,7=1
is non-degenerate. By the inverse function theorem, there exists a neighborhood U of (po, qo) in R2, for which the functions P, q are coordinate functions. The function S(P, q) = F(p, q) + PQ 16 Since
g is a diffeomorphism, g.X is a well-defined vector field on M.
2. Hamiltonian Mechanics
41
is called a generating function of the canonical transformation g in U. It follows from (2.9) that in new coordinates P, q on U,
p= aq(P,q) and Q= aS(P,q) The converse statement below easily follows from the implicit function theorem.
Proposition 2.4. Let S(P, q) be a function in some neighborhood U of a point (Po, qo) E R2n such that the n x n matrix
a2 S
a2S
3Paq (Po, qo)
aPZaqj
n
(PO, qo) JZ =1
is non-degenerate. Then S is a generating function of a local (i.e., defined in some neighborhood of (Po, qo) in R2"`) canonical transformation.
Suppose there is a canonical transformation (P, Q) = g(p, q) such that H(p, q) = K(P) for some function K. Then in the new coordinates Hamilton's equations take the form
P=O, O =
(2.10)
and are trivially integrated:
P(t) = P(0), Q(t) = Q(0) + t aK (P(0)). OP is non-degenerate, the generating function Assuming that the matrix p S(P, q) satisfies the differential equation
H (9q (P, q), q) = K(P),
(2.11)
where after the differentiation one should substitute q = q(P, Q), defined by the canonical transformation g-1. The differential equation (2.11) for fixed P, as it follows from (2.3), coincides with the Hamilton-Jacobi equation for
the abbreviated action So = S - Et where E = K(P), H(
So (P, q), q) = E.
Theorem 2.10 (Jacobi). Suppose that there is a function S(P, q) which depends on n parameters P = (Pl, ... , P, ), satisfies the Hamilton-Jacobi equation (2.11) for some function K(P), and has the property that the n x n a2
matrix DPaq is non-degenerate. Then Hamilton's equations aH aH
P=-, q=-p 09q
1. Classical Mechanics
42
can be solved explicitly, and the functions P(p, q) = (Pi(p, q), ... , Pn(p, q)), defined by the equations p =
Proof. Set p =
as (P, q), are integrals of motion in involution.
49S
as
(P, q) and Q = (P, q). By the inverse function theorem, g(p, q) = (P, Q) is a local canonical transformation with the generating function S. It follows from (2.11) that H(p(P, Q), q(P, Q)) = K(P), so that Hamilton's equations take the form (2.10). Since w = dP A dQ, integrals of motion Pl (p, q), ... , P, (p, q) are in involution. The solution of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation satisfying conditions in Theorem 2.10 is called the complete integral. At first glance it seems that solving the Hamilton-Jacobi equation, which is a nonlinear partial differential equation, is a more difficult problem then solving Hamilton's equations, which is a system of ordinary differential equations. It is quite remarkable that for many problems of classical mechanics one can find the complete integral of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation by the method of separation of variables. By Theorem 2.10, this solves the corresponding Hamilton's equations. Problem 2.6. Find the generating function for the identity transformation P = p, Q = q.
Problem 2.7. Prove Proposition 2.4.
Problem 2.8. Suppose that the canonical transformation g(p, q) = (P, Q) is such that locally (Q, q) can be considered as new coordinates (canonical transfor-
mations with this property are called free). Prove that Si (Q, q) = F(p, q), also called a generating function, satisfies
aSl and P= aQ aq Problem 2.9. Find the complete integral for the case of a particle in R3 moving -as,
in a central field.
2.6. Symplectic manifolds. The notion of a symplectic manifold is a generalization of the example of a cotangent bundle T*M.
Definition. A non-degenerate, closed 2-form w on a manifold .4' is called a symplectic form, and the pair (.4', w) is called a symplectic manifold. Since a symplectic form w is non-degenerate, a symplectic manifold .elf is necessarily even-dimensional, dim W = 2n. The nowhere vanishing 2n-form
wn defines a canonical orientation on 4', and as in the case .elf = T*M, w" - is called Liouville's volume form. We also have the general notion of a n!
Lagrangian submanifold.
2. Hamiltonian Mechanics
43
Definition. A submanifold 4° of a symplectic manifold (.ill, w) is called a Lagrangian submanifold, if dim P = 2 dim .ill and the restriction of the symplectic form w to 2 is 0. Symplectic manifolds form a category. A morphism between (4'i,wl) and (4'2i w2), also called a symplectomorphism, is a mapping f :.ills - _&2 such that wl = f *(W2)- When .%' = .i&2 and wl = w2, the notion of a symplectomorphism generalizes the notion of a canonical transformation. The direct product of symplectic manifolds (-&l, wl) and (A, W2) is a symplectic manifold (A x .112, 7r1* (wl) + 7r2 (W2)),
where 7rl and 7r2 are, respectively, projections of
x .iW2 onto the first and
second factors in the Cartesian product. Besides cotangent bundles, another important class of symplectic manifolds is given by Kahler manifolds17. Recall that a complex manifold .ill is a Kahler manifold if it carries the Hermitian metric whose imaginary part is a closed (1, 1)-form. In local complex coordinates z = (zl, ... , z") on .ill the Hermitian metric is written as n
h = E h«Q(z,z)dz« ® dzQ. «,Q=1
Correspondingly,
g = Re h = 2 E h«Q(z, z) (dz« (D dzQ + dzQ ®dz«) is the Riemannian metric on .ill and n
w=- Im h= 2 E h«Q(z, z)dz« n d? «,R=1
is the symplectic form on .ill (considered as a 2n-dimensional real manifold). The simplest compact Kahler manifold is CP1 - S2 with the symplectic form given by the area 2-form of the Hermitian metric of Gaussian curvature
1 - the round metric on the 2-sphere. In terms of the local coordinate z associated with the stereographic projection CP1
w=2i
C U {oo},
dzAdz (1+1x12)2
Similarly, the natural symplectic form on the complex projective space CPn is the symplectic form of the Fubini-Study metric. By pull-back, it defines symplectic forms on complex projective varieties. "Needless to say, not every symplectic manifold admits a complex structure, not to mention a Kahler structure.
1. Classical Mechanics
44
The simplest non-compact Kahler manifold is the n-dimensional complex vector space Cn with the standard Hermitian metric. In complex coordinates z = (zl, ... , zn) on Cn it is given by n
h=dz®dz=1: dz"®dz". In terms of real coordinates (x, y) = (xi, .. , xn, yl, .. , yn) on R2n ,,, Cn, where z = x + iy, the corresponding symplectic form w = - Im h has the canonical form n
w= dzAdxdx"ndy"=dxndy. "=1
This example naturally leads to the following definition.
Definition. A symplectic vector space is a pair (V, w), where V is a vector space over ]I8 and w is a non-degenerate, skew-symmetric bilinear form on V.
It follows from basic linear algebra that every symplectic vector space
V has a symplectic basis - a basis ell ... , en, fl, ... , fn of V, where 2n = dim V, such that
w(e',e1)=w(fi,fj)=0 and w(e',fj)=bj, i,j=1,...,n. In coordinates (p, q) = (pl, ... , pn, ql, ... , qn) corresponding to this basis, V
1[82n and
n
w=dpAdq=>dpindgi. i=1
Thus every symplectic vector space is isomorphic to a direct product of the phase planes R2 with the canonical symplectic form dp A dq. Introducing
complex coordinates z = p + iq, we get the isomorphism V - Cn, so that every symplectic vector space admits a Kahler structure. It is a basic fact of symplectic geometry that every symplectic manifold is locally isomorphic to a symplectic vector space. Theorem 2.11 (Darboux' theorem). Let (dI, w) be a 2n-dimensional symplectic manifold. For every point x E .ill there is a neighborhood U of x with local coordinates (p, q) _ (pt, ... , pn, ql,... , qn) such that on U n
w=dpAdqdpiAdgi. i=1
Coordinates p, q are called canonical coordinates (Darboux coordinates).
The proof proceeds by induction on n with the two main steps stated as Problems 2.13 and 2.14.
45
2. Hamiltonian Mechanics
A non-degenerate 2-form w for every x E .ill defines an isomorphism
J : T*4' - Tx-& by w(ul,u2) = J-'(U2) (ul), ul,u2 E TT-&. Explicitly, for every X E Vect(-&) and 19 E A'(4') we have w(X, J(1))) = 19(X)
and
J-1(X) = -ix(w)
(cf. Section 2.1). In local coordinates x = (xl, ... , x2n) for the coordinate chart (U, cp) on .ill, the 2-form w is given by 2n
w=
1 1: wij (x) dxi A dxj, 2
i,j=1
where {wij (x) }? 7=1 is a non-degenerate, skew-symmetric matrix-valued funcwe have tion on cp(U). Denoting the inverse matrix by a
2n
J(dxz) j=1
wZ' (x) 8xj'
i = 1, ... , 2n.
Definition. A Hamiltonian system is a pair consisting of a symplectic manifold (.ill, w), called a phase space, and a smooth real-valued function H on .ill, called a Hamiltonian. The motion of points on the phase space is described by the vector field
XH = J(dH), called a Hamiltonian vector field.
The trajectories of a Hamiltonian system ((.ill, w), H) are the integral curves of a Hamiltonian vector field XH on W. In canonical coordinates (p, q) they are described by the canonical Hamilton's equations (2.1), 8H OH
p=--) q=q= ap. 49q
Suppose now that the Hamiltonian vector field XH on 4' is complete. The Hamiltonian phase flow on .ill associated with a Hamiltonian H is a oneparameter group {gt}tEIR of diffeomorphisms of ill generated by XH. The following statement generalizes Theorem 2.1. Theorem 2.12. The Hamiltonian phase flow preserves the symplectic form.
Proof. It is sufficient to show that LXHW = 0. Using Cartan's formula
Lx=ixod+doix and dw = 0, we get for every X E Vect (-&)I
Lxw = (do ix) (w).
1. Classical Mechanics
46
Since iX(w)(Y) = w(X,Y), we have for X = XH and every Y E Vect(.') that ZXH (w) (Y) = w(J(dH), Y) = -dH(Y). Thus ixH(w) = -dH, and the statement follows from d2 = 0.
Corollary 2.13. A vector field X on .ill is a Hamiltonian vector field if and only if the 1-form ix(w) is exact.
Definition. A vector field X on a symplectic manifold (.ill, w) is called a symplectic vector field if the 1-form ix (w) is closed, which is equivalent to
YXw=0. The commutative algebra C'(,&), with a multiplication given by the point-wise product of functions, is called the algebra of classical observables.
Assuming that the Hamiltonian phase flow gt exists for all times, the time evolution of every observable f c C'(,&) is given by
ft(x) = f (gt(x)), x E and is described by the differential equation dit dt = XH(ft)
- Hamilton's equation for classical observables. Hamilton's equations for observables on ill have the same form as Hamilton's equations on .ill = T*M, considered in Section 2.3. Since XH(f) = df (XH) = W(XH, J(df)) = W(XH, Xf), we have the following.
Definition. A Poisson bracket on the algebra C°° (.ill) of classical servables on a symplectic manifold (.ill, w) is a bilinear mapping C°° (.ill) x C°° (.ill) , C'(-4,v), defined by
{f,g} = w(Xf,X9),
.f,g E C°°()
Now Hamilton's equation takes the concise form (2.12)
dt = {H, f
understood as a differential equation for a family of functions ft on .ill with the initial condition ftlt=o = f. In local coordinates x _ (x', ... , x2n ) on
41,
2n
Wij (X)
r7.f (X) 099(x)
i,.7=1
Theorem 2.14. The Poisson bracket { , } on a symplectic manifold (4', w) is skew-symmetric and satisfies Leibniz rule and the Jacobi identity.
2. Hamiltonian Mechanics
47
Proof. The first two properties are obvious. It follows from the definition of a Poisson bracket and the formula [X f, Xg] (h) = (XgX f - X fX9) (h) = {g, { f, h}} - {f, {g, h}}
that the Jacobi identity is equivalent to the property (2.13)
[Xf, X9] = Let X and Y be symplectic vector fields. Using Cartan's formulas we get X{f,g}.
i[X,Y](w) = Lx(iy(w))
- iy(Lx (w))
= d(ix o iy(w)) + ixd(iy(w)) = d(w(Y,X)) = iz(w), where Z is a Hamiltonian vector field corresponding to w(X, Y) E COO (,W). Since the 2-form w is non-degenerate, this implies [X, Y] = Z, so that setting X = X f, Y = Xg and using { f, g} = w(X f, Xg), we get (2.13).
From (2.13) we immediately get the following result.
Corollary 2.15. The subspace Ham(4') of Hamiltonian vector fields on .ill is a Lie subalgebra of Vect(4'). The mapping C°°(4') -> Ham(-&), given by f " X f, is a Lie algebra homomorphism with the kernel consisting of locally constant functions on W. As in the case .elf = T*M (see Section 2.4), an observable I - a function on the phase space .elf - is called an integral of motion (first integral) for the Hamiltonian system ((.elf, w), H) if it is constant along the Hamiltonian phase flow. According to (2.12), this is equivalent to the condition (2.14)
{H, I} = 0.
It is said that the observables H and I are in involution (Poisson commute). From the Jacobi identity for the Poisson bracket we get the following result.
Corollary 2.16 (Poisson's theorem). The Poisson bracket of two integrals of motion is an integral of motion.
Proof. If {H, Ii} = {H, 12} = 0, then {H, {Il, I2}} = {{H, Ill, 12} -If H,I2}, Il} = 0. It follows from Poisson's theorem that integrals of motion form a Lie algebra and, by (2.13), corresponding Hamiltonian vector fields form a Lie
subalgebra in Vect(4'). Since {I, H} = dH(XI) = 0, the vector fields XI are tangent to submanifolds dIE = {x E l' : H(x) = E} - the level sets of the Hamiltonian H. This defines a Lie algebra of integrals of motion for the Hamiltonian system ((.4', w), H) at the level set .AWE.
1. Classical Mechanics
48
Let G be a finite-dimensional Lie group that acts on a connected symplectic manifold (4', w) by symplectomorphisms. The Lie algebra g of G acts on 4' by vector fields
Xg(f)(x) = ds and the linear mapping g
s=o
f
x),
1; H X E Vect(4') is a homomorphism of Lie
algebras, X,7] = X [C,n],
, 77 E g
The G-action is called a Hamiltonian action if XX are Hamiltonian vector fields, i.e., for every l; E g there is 'I E C°°(4'), defined up to an additive constant, such that XX = XDE = It is called a Poisson action if there is a choice of functions 4)6 such that the linear mapping 4) : g -+ C°°(,d') is a homomorphism of Lie algebras, (2.15)
,77E9.
Definition. A Lie group G is a symmetry group of the Hamiltonian system w), H) if there is a Hamiltonian action of G on .W such that
H(g x) = H(x),
g E G, x E -W.
Theorem 2.17 (Noether theorem with symmetries). If G is a symmetry group of the Hamiltonian system
w), H), then the functions E g, are the integrals of motion. If the action of G is Poisson, the integrals of
motion satisfy (2.15).
Proof. By definition of the Hamiltonian action, for every l; E g, 0 = XX(H) = X4)£ (H) _
H}.
Corollary 2.18. Let (M, L) be a Lagrangian system such that the Legendre transform TL : TM -- T*M is a diffeomorphism. Then if a Lie group G
is a symmetry of (M, L), then G is a symmetry group of the corresponding Hamiltonian system ((T*M, w), H = EL o TL 1), and the corresponding G-
action on T*M is Poisson. In particular, 4) = -IC o TL 1, where II are Noether integrals of motion for the one-parameter subgroups of G generated by l; E g.
Proof. Let X be the vector field associated with the one-parameter subgroup of diffeomorphisms of M, used in Theorem 1.3, and let X' be its lift to TM. We have18 (2.16)
X = -(TL)*(X'),
18The negative sign reflects the difference in definitions of X and XE.
2. Hamiltonian Mechanics
49
and it follows from (1.16) that c = ix{ (0) = 9(XX), where 0 is the canonical Liouville 1-form on T*M. From Cartan's formula and (1.17) we get
d-tC = d(ix, (6)) = -ix£ (d0) + Cxe (0) _ -ix{ (w),
so that
-J(ix{(w)) = XX, and the G-action is Hamiltonian. Using (1.17) and another Cartan's formula, we obtain i[xe,x, ] (0) = Lx£ (ix,, (0)) + ix,, (Lxc (0))
{44, D'}. = Example 2.1. The Lagrangian L = Zmr2 - V(r)
E
for a particle in R3 moving in a central field (see Section 1.6) is invariant with respect to the action of the group SO(3) of orthogonal transformations of the Euclidean space R3. Let U1, U2, U3 be a basis for the Lie algebra so(3)
corresponding to the rotations with the axes given by the vectors of the standard basis el, e2, e3 for 1R3 (see Example 1.10 in Section 1.4). These generators satisfy the commutation relations [ui, ujI = Eijkuk,
where i, j, k = 1, 2, 3, and Eijk is a totally anti-symmetric tensor, E123 = 1. Corresponding Noether integrals of motion are given by -Du; = -Mi, where
M1 = (r x P)1 = r2p3 - r3p2, M2 = (r x P)2 = r3p1 - rlp3,
M3 = (r x p)3 = r1p2 - r2p1
are components of the angular momentum vector M = r x p. (Here it is convenient to lower the indices of the coordinates ri by the Euclidean metric
on l3.) For the Hamiltonian 2
H = 2m +
V (r)
we have
{H,Mi}=0. According to Theorem 2.17 and Corollary 2.18, Poisson brackets of the components of the angular momentum satisfy
{Mi, Mj} = -EijkMk, which is also easy to verify directly using (2.6),
{f,g}(p,r) =
of ag
of ag
a-ar arap
1. Classical Mechanics
50
Example 2.2 (Kepler's problem). For every a E ll the Lagrangian system on JR3 with
a L= ZmrZ+ r
has three extra integrals of motion - the components Wl, W2, W3 of the Laplace-Runge-Lenz vector, given by
W=Pm
xM-ar
r
(see Section 1.6). Using Poisson brackets from the previous example, together with {ri, M;} = -Eijkrk and {pi, M;} = -eijkpk, we get by a straightforward computation, 2H EijkMk, {Wi, Mj} = -eijkWk and {Wi, Wj} = m
2_
where H = 2m -
r
is the Hamiltonian of Kepler's problem.
The Hamiltonian system ((.ill, w), H), dim.iW = 2n, is called completely
integrable if it has n independent integrals of motion Fl = H,. .. , Fn in involution. The former condition means that dFi(x),... dF,(x) E T,*.ill are linearly independent for almost all x c .ill. Hamiltonian systems with ,
one degree of freedom such that dH has only finitely many zeros are completely integrable. Complete separation of variables in the Hamilton-Jacobi equation (see Section 2.5) provides other examples of completely integrable Hamiltonian systems. Let ((.ill, w), H) be a completely integrable Hamiltonian system. Sup-
pose that the level set Of = {x E .ill : Fl(x) = fl,... , F,,,(x) = fTh} is compact and tangent vectors JdFI, .
. . , JdFT,, are linearly independent for all x E .ill f. Then by the Liouville-Arnold theorem, in a neighborhood of .ill f
there exist so-called action-angle variables: coordinates I = (I,, . , E lR = (R>0)n and cp = (vi, ... , Wn) E T n= (lR/27rZ)n such that w = dlndcp and H = H(11,. .. , In). According to Hamilton's equations, . .
4=0 and
cpi = wi =
-H, i = 1, ... , n, Z
so that action variables are constants, and angle variables change uniformly, cpi (t) = cpi (0) + wit, i = 1, ... , n. The classical motion is almost-periodic with the frequencies wl, ... , wn. Problem 2.10. Show that a symplectic manifold (.ill, w) admits an almost complex structure: a bundle map : Till --p Tdi such that J2 = -id. Problem 2.11. Give an example of a symplectic manifold which admits a complex structure but not a Kahler structure.
2. Hamiltonian Mechanics
51
Problem 2.12 (Coadjont orbits). Let G be a finite-dimensional Lie group, let g be its Lie algebra, and let g* be the dual vector space to g. For u E g* let .ill = 0", be the orbit of u under the coadjoint action of G on g*. Show that the formula w(ul, u2) = u([xl, x2]), where ul = ad*xl(u),u2 = ad*x2(u) E 0,,, and ad* stands for the coadjoint action of a Lie algebra 9 on g*, gives rise to a well-defined 2-form on .ill, which is closed and non-degenerate. (The 2-form w is called the Kirillov-Kostant symplectic form.)
Problem 2.13. Let (.ill, w) be a symplectic manifold. For x c .ill choose a function ql on .ill such that ql (x) = 0 and dq' does not vanish at x, and set X = -Xq1. Show that there is a neighborhood U of x E -0 and a function pi on U such that X (ql) = 1 on U, and there exist coordinates pl, q1, z1,. .. , z2n-2 on U such that X= apl and Y = Xr1 = aql . Problem 2.14. Continuing Problem 2.13, show that the 2-form w - dpl A dql on U depends only on coordinates z1, ... , z2''-2 and is non-degenerate. Problem 2.15. Do the computation in Example 2.2 and show that the Lie algebra of the integrals M1, M2, M3, W1, W2, W3 in Kepler's problem at H(p, r) = E is isomorphic to the Lie algebra so(4), if E < 0, to the Euclidean Lie algebra e(3), if E = 0, and to the Lie algebra so(1, 3), if E > 0.
Problem 2.16. Find the action-angle variables for a particle with one degree of freedom, when the potential V (x) is a convex function on R satisfying
V (x)
= oo. (Hint: Define I = , pdx, where integration goes over the closed orbit with H(p, x) = E.)
Problem 2.17. Show that a Hamiltonian system describing a particle in R3 moving in a central field is completely integrable, and find the action-angle variables.
Problem 2.18 (Symplectic quotients). For a Poisson action of a Lie group G on a symplectic manifold (.ill, w), define the moment map P P(x)(0 = N (X),
9* by
E 9, x E mil,
where 9 is the Lie algebra of G. For every p E g* such that a stabilizer Gr of p acts freely and properly on 4',, = P-1(p) (such p is called the regular value of the moment map), the quotient Mp = Gr\-Wp is called a reduced phase space. Show that Mp is a symplectic manifold with the symplectic form uniquely characterized
by the condition that its pull-back to Ap coincides with the restriction to .Z, of the symplectic form w.
2.7. Poisson manifolds. The notion of a Poisson manifold generalizes the notion of a symplectic manifold. Definition. A Poisson manifold is a manifold structure - a skew-symmetric bilinear mapping {
,
equipped with a Poisson
} : C'(,&) x C'(,&) -> C'(-&)
which satisfies the Leibniz rule and Jacobi identity.
1. Classical Mechanics
52
Equivalently, .ill is a Poisson manifold if the algebra A = C°° (.ill) of classical observables is a Poisson algebra - a Lie algebra such that the Lie bracket is a bi-derivation with respect to the multiplication in A (a pointwise product of functions). It follows from the derivation property that in local coordinates x = (x', ... , xN) on .ill, the Poisson bracket has the form N
af* ag(x) {f, 9}x_ E 77(x) i' axi axj i,j=1
The 2-tensor rlii (x), called a Poisson tensor, defines a global section g of the vector bundle Tall A Tall over W. The evolution of classical observables on a Poisson manifold is given by Hamilton's equations, which have the same form as (2.12), dt
XH(f) = {H, f}.
The phase flow gt for a complete Hamiltonian vector field XH = {H, defines the evolution operator Ut : A -+ A by
}
Ut(f)(x) = f(gt(x)), f E A.
Theorem 2.19. Suppose that every Hamiltonian vector field on a Poisson manifold (.ill, { }) is complete. Then for every H E A, the corresponding evolution operator Ut is an automorphism of the Poisson algebra A, i.e., ,
Ut({ f, g}) = {Ut(f ), Ut(g)}
(2.17)
for all f, g E A.
Conversely, if a skew-symmetric bilinear mapping { , } : C°°(-,ll) x C°D(4') -+ Coo (-4K) is such that XH = {H, } are complete vector fields for all H E A, and corresponding evolution operators Ut satisfy (2.17), then (.ill, { , }) is a Poisson manifold.
Proof. Let ft = Ut(f), gt = Ut(g), and19 ht = Ut({ f, g}). By definition, dt If (.ill, {
{ft, gt} = {{H, ft}, gt} + { ft, {H, gt}} ,
and
d tt
= {H, ht}.
}) is a Poisson manifold, then it follows from the Jacobi identity
that {{H, ft}, gt} + I ft, {H, gt}} = {H, { ft, gt}}, so that ht and I ft, gt} satisfy the same differential equation (2.12). Since these functions coincide at t = 0, (2.17) follows from the uniqueness theorem for the ordinary differential equations. Conversely, we get the Jacobi identity for the functions f, g, and H by differentiating (2.17) with respect to t at t = 0. 19Here gt is not the phase flow!
2. Hamiltonian Mechanics
53
Corollary 2.20. A global section 77 of T.' A T.' is a Poisson tensor if and only if L x1r7 = 0
for all f E A.
Definition. The center of a Poisson algebra A is
Z(A)={f EA:{f,g}=0 for all gEA}. A Poisson manifold (4', { }) is called non-degenerate if the center of a Poisson algebra of classical observables A = C°° (4') consists only of locally constant functions (Z(A) = R for connected 4'). ,
Equivalently, a Poisson manifold (.ill, { , }) is non-degenerate if the Poisson tensor i is non-degenerate everywhere on .ill, so that .,d' is necessarily
an even-dimensional manifold. A non-degenerate Poisson tensor for every xE
defines an isomorphism J : TT .,dl --> Tx.idl by
'J(ul, u2) = u2(J(ul)), u1i u2 E T*.'dl. In local coordinates x = (xl, ... , xN) for the coordinate chart (U, cp) on we have N
J(dxz)
71
j=1
(x) 8
xj,
i = 1, ... , N.
Poisson manifolds form a category. A morphism between (.Wl, { , }1) and (4'2i { , }2) is a mapping cp : dll -+ .WW2 of smooth manifolds such that If ocp,gocp}1 ={f,g}2ocp for all }1) and (%'2i { , }2) is a A direct product of Poisson manifolds x _,dl2i { , }) defined by the property that natural Poisson manifold projection maps 7r1 : d' x .,t2 -> W1 and 7r2 : W1 x 4'2 -> 4'2 are Poisson mappings. For f E C' (,W1 x .WW2) and (x1i x2) E .idle x .WW2 denote,
respectively, by fx) and f (2) restrictions of f to .4' x {x2} and {xl} x dle. Then for f, g E coo (.'1 x dl2),
{f,g}(xl,x2) = {f(l),9x2) }1(x1) + Non-degenerate Poisson manifolds form a subcategory of the category Poisson manifolds.
Theorem 2.21. The category of symplectic manifolds is (anti-) isomorphic to the category of non-degenerate Poisson manifolds.
Proof. According to Theorem 2.14, every symplectic manifold carries a Poisson structure. Its non-degeneracy follows from the non-degeneracy of a symplectic form. Conversely, let (.', { , }) be a non-degenerate Poisson manifold. Define the 2-form w on 4' by w(X,Y) = J-1(Y)(X), X,Y E Vect(4'),
1. Classical Mechanics
54
where the isomorphism J : T*4 -- T4' is defined by the Poisson tensor g. In local coordinates x = (x1, ... , xN) on .ill,
w-- 1:
qij(x)dxindxj,
1
where {?7ij(x)}N-1 is the inverse matrix to {qij(x)}N=1. The 2-form w is skew-symmetric and non-degenerate. For every f E A let Xf = { f, } be the corresponding vector field on 4'. The Jacobi identity for the Poisson bracket { } is equivalent to GXfr7 = 0 for every f E A, so that ,
GXfw0. Since X f = Jdf , we have w (X, Jdf) = df (X) for every X E Vect (.ill ), so that W (Xf, X9) _ {f, g}.
By Cartan's formula,
(Cxw(Y, Z) - £yw(X, Z) + Czw(X,Y)
dw(X, Y, Z) = 3
_W ([X, Y], Z) + w([X, Z], Y) - w([Y, Z], X)) , where X, Y, Z E Vect(4'). Now setting
X = Xf, Y = Xg, Z = Xh, we get
dw(X f, Xg, Xh) = 3 (w(Xh, [Xf, X9]) + w(Xf, [Xg, Xh]) + w(X9, [Xh, Xf])) (w(Xh, X{f,9}) +W(X f, X{g,h}) + w(X9, X{h,f}))
= 3 ({h, { f, g}} + If, {g, h}} + {g, {h, f}}) = 0.
The exact 1-forms df, f E A, generate the vector space of 1-forms A' (4') as a module over A, so that Hamiltonian vector fields X f = Jdf generate the vector space Vect(-,W) as a module over A. Thus dw = 0 and (.ill, w) is a symplectic manifold associated with the Poisson manifold (.ill, { , }). It follows from the definitions that Poisson mappings of non-degenerate Poisson manifolds correspond to symplectomorphisms of associated symplectic manifolds.
Remark. One can also prove this theorem by a straightforward computation in local coordinates x = (x1, ... , xN) on W. Just observe that the condition 077ij(x)
ax'
+
ar7j1(x)
axi
+ arlli(x) = 0, axj
which is a coordinate form of dw = 0, follows from the condition agkl(x) N i, a77 ik(x) ij k, E 77 ii axe + rl (x) axe + rl (x) a_li(x) 0, axe )
/
2. Hamiltonian Mechanics
55
which is a coordinate form of the Jacobi identity, by multiplying it three times by the inverse matrix rlij (x) using
E (iP(X)ariPk(x) +
azp(xj X)77pk(x))
= o.
P
Remark. Let . il l ' = T*lR" with the Poisson bracket { , } given by the canon-
ical symplectic form w = d p A dq, where (p, q) = ( P I ,- .. , pn, q1, ... , qn) are coordinate functions on T*lIkn. The non-degeneracy of the Poisson manifold (T*lRn, {
,
}) can be formulated as the property that the only observable
f E C°°(T*ll8n) satisfying {f,pl}=...={f,p}=0,
{f,ql}=...={f,qn}=0
is f (p, q) = const. Problem 2.19 (Dual space to a Lie algebra). Let g be a finite-dimensional Lie algebra with a Lie bracket [
,
], and let g* be its dual space. For f,g E CO°(g*)
define
{f, g}(u) = u ([df, dg]) , where u E g* and Tug* - g. Prove that { , } is a Poisson bracket. (It was introduced by Sophus Lie and is called a linear, or Lie-Poisson bracket.) Show that this bracket is degenerate and determine the center of A = C°°(g*).
Problem 2.20. A Poisson bracket { , } on .ill restricts to a Poisson bracket { ,
}o
on a submanifold N if the inclusion z :.ifs -+ .ill is a Poisson mapping. Show that the Lie-Poisson bracket on g* restricts to a non-degenerate Poisson bracket on a coadjoint orbit, associated with the Kirillov-Kostant symplectic form.
Problem 2.21 (Lie-Poisson groups). A finite-dimensional Lie group is called a Lie-Poisson group if it has a structure of a Poisson manifold (G, 1, }) such that the group multiplication G x G ---* G is a Poisson mapping, where G x G is a direct product of Poisson manifolds, Using a basis a1, ... , an of left-invariant vector fields on G corresponding to a basis x1, ... , xn of the Lie algebra g, the Poisson bracket { , } can be written as n
{f1,f2}(9) =
77ij(9)19ifl19jf2,
i,j=1
where the 2-tensor 77ij (g) defines a mapping 7) : G -> A2g by r7(g) = E2 j=177ij (g)xi®
xj. Show that the bracket { , } equips G with a Lie-Poisson structure if and only if the following conditions are satisfied: (i) for all g E G, n
0'(9) _ E (77zi(9)aWk(9) +77j1(9)a177'i(9)
+77'1(9)a171zj(9))
1=1
n
+ E (ciprlp3 (9)77'1(9) + Cj'prlpk (9)7721(9) + c1r7'i
(9)771(9))
= 0,
1,p=1
where [xi, xj] _ Ek=1 c xk; (ii) the mapping 77 is a group 1-cocycle with the adjoint action on A2g, i.e., 77(9192) = Ad-192 77(91) + 77(92), 91,92 E G.
1. Classical Mechanics
56
Problem 2.22. Show that the second condition in the previous problem trivially holds when rl is a coboundary, 77(g) = for some r = Ei j-1 rijxi®xj E A2 g, and then the first` condition is satisfied if and only if the element S (r) = [r12, r13 + 7'23 + [r13, r23] E A3g
is invariant under the adjoint action of g on A3g. Here r12 = Ei j=1 rUxi 0 xj ®1,
r13 = i j=1 rijxi 0 1 ® xj, and r23 = Ei j_1 rij 1 ® xi 0 xj are corresponding elements in the universal enveloping algebra Ug of a Lie algebra g. In particular, G is a Lie-Poisson group if f (r) = 0, which is called the classical Yang-Baxter equation.
Problem 2.23. Suppose that r = En=1 rijxi ®xj E A2g is such that the matrix {rij } is non-degenerate, and let {rij } be the inverse matrix. Show that r satisfies the classical Yang-Baxter equation if and only if the map c : A20 -* C, defined by c(x, y) = Ei j=1 rijuivj, where x = T= 1 u'xi, y = j= 17Jixi, is a non-degenerate Lie algebra 2-cocycle, i.e., it satisfies c(x, [y, z]) + c(z, [x, y]) + c(y, [z, x]) = 0,
x, y, z E g.
2.8. Hamilton's and Liouville's representations. To complete the formulation of classical mechanics, we need to describe the process of measurement. In physics, by a measurement of a classical system one understands the result of a physical experiment which gives numerical values for classical observables. The experiment consists of creating certain conditions for the system, and it is always assumed that these conditions can be repeated over
and over. The conditions of the experiment define a state of the system if repeating these conditions results in probability distributions for the values of all observables of the system. Mathematically, a state p on the algebra A = C'(-&) of classical observables on the phase space .ill is the assignment
A 9 f ~' µ'f c 9(R), where 41(R) is a set of probability measures on IR - Borel measures on IR such that the total measure of JR is 1. For every Borel subset E C_ JR the
quantity 0 < p f (E) < 1 is a probability that in the state p the value of the observable f belongs to E. By definition, the expectation value of an observable f in the state y is given by the Lebesgue-Stieltjes integral Eµ(f) =
foo
Adpf(A),
where pf(A) = p f ((-oo, A)) is a distribution function of the measure dµ f. The correspondence f f--> p f should satisfy the following natural properties. 1 Eµ (f) < oo for f E Ao - the subalgebra of bounded observables. S2. Eµ(1) = 1, where 1 is the unit in A.
S 1.
2. Hamiltonian Mechanics
57
S3. For alla,bERand f,gEA, Eµ.(a f + bg) = aEN,(f) + bEµ(g),
if both Ep(f) and E, (g) exist. S4. If f1 = cp o f2 with smooth cp : 1R -> I[8, then for every Borel subset
EC
R
=µfz(w-1(E)) It follows from property S4 and the definition of the Lebesgue-Stieltjes integral that
f
(2.18)
p (A)dpf(A) 00
In particular, E1, (f 2) > 0 for all f E A, so that the states define normalized, positive, linear functionals on the subalgebra Ao. Assuming that the functional E. extends to the space of bounded, pieceand satisfies (2.18) for measurable functions wise continuous functions on cp, one can recover the distribution function from the expectation values by the formula µf (A) = EM(e(A - f)), where 9(x) is the Heavyside step function, B(x) _
J1, x > 0,
10, x<0.
Indeed, let X be the characteristic function of the interval (-oo, A) C R. Using (2.18) and the definition of the Lebesgue-Stieltjes integral we get 00
Eµ(9(A
- f)) = f 00 X(s)dµf(s) = pf((-oo, A)) = µf (A)
Every probability measure dy on .ill defines the state on A by assigning20
to every observable f a probability measure p f = f, (µ) on 1[8 - a pushforward of the measure dp on .ill by the mapping f :.ill -* R. It is defined by p f (E) = p(f -1(E)) for every Borel subset E C I[8, and has the distribution function µf (A) =
µ(f-1(-o0, A)) =
f
dµ,
oa(f)
where .illa(f) _ {x E -0 : f (x) < Al. It follows from the Pubini theorem that (2.19)
Ej,(f) = fooc'oAdµ f(A) =
J
f dµ.
20There should be no confusion in denoting the state and the measure by µ.
1. Classical Mechanics
58
It turns out that probability measures on .ill are essentially the only examples of states. Namely, for a locally compact topological space 4' the Riesz-Markov theorem asserts that for every positive, linear functional 1 on the space Cc (,W) of continuous functions on 4' with compact support, there is a unique regular Borel measure d p on ' such that .
l(f)=J fdp
for all f ECc (.').
This leads to the following definition of states in classical mechanics.
Definition. The set of states S for a Hamiltonian system with the phase space W is the convex set .9'(.') of all probability measures on W. The states corresponding to Dirac measures da supported at points x E .ill are called pure states, and the phase space W is also called the space of states21. All other states are called mixed states. A process of measurement in classical mechanics is the correspondence AXS
(f, µ) - µf = f. (p) E -41 (R),
which to every observable f E A and state µ E S assigns a probability measure p f on R - a push-forward of the measure d,a on .ill by f. For every Borel subset E C I[8 the quantity 0 < pf(E) < 1 is the probability that for a system in the state p the result of a measurement of the observable f is in the set E. The expectation value of an observable f in a state t is given by (2.19).
In physics, pure states are characterized by having the property that a measurement of every observable always gives a well-defined result. Mathematically this can be expressed as follows. Let 01µ(f)
= EN, ((f
- E. (f))2) = Eµ(f2) - Eµ(f)2 > 0
be the variance of the observable f in the state p. Lemma 2.1. Pure states are the only states in which every observable has zero variance.
Proof. It follows from the Cauchy-Bunyakovski-Schwarz inequality that ( f ) = 0 if only if f is constant on the support of a probability measure 0 12 dii.
In particular, a mixture of pure states dµ., and dpy, x, y E ill, is a mixed state with
dµdµy+(1-a)dµy, 0
so that a 2(f) > 0 for every observable f such that f (x) jk f (y). 21The space of pure states, to be precise.
2. Hamiltonian Mechanics
59
For a system consisting of few interacting particles (say, a motion of planets in celestial mechanics) it is possible to measure all coordinates and momenta, so one considers only pure states. Mixed states necessarily appear for macroscopic systems, when it is impossible to measure all coordinates and Remark. As a topological space, the space of states .ill can be reconstructed from the algebra A of classical observables. Namely, suppose for simplicity momenta22.
that .ill is compact. Then the C-algebra C = C(all) of complex-valued continuous functions on .ill - the completion of the complexification of the JR-algebra A of classical observables with respect to the sup-norm is a commutative cC*-algebra. This means that C(all) is a Banach space with respect to the norm II f II = supXE ' I f (x) 1, has a C-algebra structure (associative algebra over C with a unit) given by the point-wise product of functions such that I f g I I< I I f I I I I9I I, and has a complex anti-linear antiinvolution: a map * : C -f C given by the complex conjugation f * (x) = f (x) 112 and satisfying I If - f* I I = I I f . Then the Gelfand-Naimark theorem asserts that every commutative C*-algebra C is isomorphic to the algebra C(all) of I
continuous functions on its spectrum - the set of maximal ideals of C - a compact topological space with the topology induced by the weak topology on C*, the dual space of C.
We conclude our exposition of classical mechanics by presenting two equivalent ways of describing the dynamics - the time evolution of a Hamiltonian system ((.ill, { , }), H) with the algebra of observables A = Coo (-W) and the set of states S = 9(%'). In addition, we assume that the Hamiltonian phase flow gt exists for all times, and that the phase space .ill carries a volume form dx invariant under the phase flow23.
Hamilton's Description of Dynamics. States do not depend on time, and time evolution of observables is given by Hamilton's equations of motion,
dt = 0, µ E S, and
t
= {H, f }, f c A.
The expectation value of an observable f in the state µ at time t is given by EM (ft)
where p(x) =
= le f ° gt dµ = f f(gt(x))p(x)dx,
is the Radon-Nikodim derivative. In particular, the expec-
tation value of f in the pure state da corresponding to the point x E .ill dx is f (gt(x)). Hamilton's picture is commonly used for mechanical systems consisting of few interacting particles. 22 Typically, a macroscopic system consists of N - 1023 molecules. Macroscopic systems are studied in classical statistical mechanics. 23It is Liouville's volume form when the Poisson structure on ..W is non-degenerate.
1. Classical Mechanics
60
Liouville's Description of Dynamics. The observables do not depend on time 0,
f E A,
dt and states dp(x) = p(x)dx satisfy Liouville's equation
dtp = -{H, p}, p(x)dx E S. Here the Radon-Nikodim derivative p(x) = LA and Liouville's equation are understood in the distributional sense. The expectation value of an observ-
able f in the state p at time t is given by Eµt(f) =
Jf(x)p(gt(x))dx.
Liouville's picture, where states are described by the distribution functions p(x) - positive distributions on ill corresponding to probability measures p(x)dx - is commonly used in statistical mechanics. The equality
Ep(ft)=Eµt(f) for all f EA, pES, which follows from the invariance of the volume form dx and the change of variables, expresses the equivalence between Liouville's and Hamilton's descriptions of the dynamics.
3. Notes and references Classical references are the textbooks [Arn89] and [LL76], which are written, respectively, from mathematics and physics perspectives. The elegance of [LL76] is supplemented by the attention to detail in [Go180], another physics classic. A brief overview of Hamiltonian formalism necessary for quantum mechanics can be found in [FY80]. The treatise [AM78] and the encyclopaedia surveys [AG90], [AKN97] provide a comprehensive exposition of classical mechanics, including the history of
the subject, and the references to classical works and recent contributions. The textbook [Ste83], monographs [DFN84], [DFN85], and lecture notes [Bry95] contain all the necessary material from differential geometry and the theory of Lie groups, as well as references to other sources. In addition, the lectures [God69] also provide an introduction to differential geometry and classical mechanics. In particular, [God69] and [Bry95] discuss the role the second tangent bundle plays in Lagrangian mechanics (see also the monograph [Y173] and [Cra83]). For a brief review of integration theory, including the Riesz-Markov theorem, see [RS80]; for the proof of the Gelfand-Naimark theorem and more details on C*-algebras, see [Str05] and references therein.
Our exposition follows the traditional outline in [LL76] and [Arn89], which starts with the Lagrangian formalism and introduces Hamiltonian formalism through
3. Notes and references
61
the Legendre transform. As in [Arn89], we made special emphasis on precise mathematical formulations. Having graduate students and research mathematicians as a main audience, we have the advantage to use freely the calculus of differential forms and vector fields on smooth manifolds. This differs from the presentation in [Arn89], which is oriented at undergraduate students and needs to introduce this material in the main text. Since the goal of this chapter was to present only those basics of classical mechanics which are fundamental for the formulation of quan-
tum mechanics, we have omitted many important topics, including mechanicalgeometrical optics analogy, theory of oscillations, rotation of a rigid body, perturbation theory, etc. The interested reader can find this material in [LL76] and [Arn89] and in the above-mentioned monographs. Completely integrable Hamiltonian systems were also only briefly mentioned at the end of Section 2.6. We refer the reader to [AKN97] and references therein for a comprehensive exposition, and to the monograph [FT07] for the so-called Lax pair method in the theory of integrable systems, especially for the case of infinitely many degrees of freedom.
In Section 2.7, following [FY80], [DFN84], [DFN85], we discussed Poisson manifolds and Poisson algebras. These notions, usually not emphasized in standard exposition of classical mechanics, are fundamental for understanding the meaning of quantization - a passage from classical mechanics to quantum mechanics. We also have included in Sections 1.6 and 2.7 the treatment of the Laplace-Runge-Lenz vector, whose components are extra integrals of motions for the Kepler Though briefly mentioned in [LL76], the Laplace-Runge-Lenz vector does not actually appear in many textbooks, with the exception of [Go180] and [DFN84]. In Section 2.7, following [FY80], we also included Theorem 2.19, which clarifies the meaning of the Jacobi identity, and presented Hamilton's and Liouville's descriptions of the dynamics. problem24.
Most of the problems in this chapter are fairly standard and are taken from various sources, mainly from [Arn89], [LL76], [Bry95], [DFN84], and [DFN85]. Other problems indicate interesting relations with representation theory and symplectic geometry. Thus Problems 2.12 and 2.20 introduce the reader to the orbit method [Kir04], and Problem 2.18 - to the method of symplectic reduction (see [Arn89], [Bry95] and references therein). Problems 2.21- 2.23 introduce the reader to the theory of Lie-Poisson groups (see [Dri86], [Dri87], [STS85], and [Tak90] for an elementary exposition).
24We will see in Chapter 3 that these extra integrals are responsible for the hidden SO(4) symmetry of the hydrogen atom.
Chapter 2
Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
We recall the standard notation and basic facts from the theory of selfadjoint operators on Hilbert spaces. Let J-Y be a separable Hilbert space with an inner product ( , ), which is complex-linear with respect to the first argument, and let A be a linear operator in de with the domain D(A) C 3 - a linear subset of 3l°. An operator A is called closed if its graph I'(A) = {(cp, Acp) E 3l° x 3' : cp E D(A)} is a closed subspace in 3 ° x 3e. If the
domain of A is denser in 3Y, i.e., D(A) = 3l°, the domain D(A*) of the adjoint operator A* consists of cp E 3l° such that there is i E 3° with the property that (A,O, cp) = (0, 77) for all 0 E D(A), and the operator A* is defined by A*cp = rl. An operator A is called symmetric if (AV), cp) = (0, Ap)
for all cp, 0 E D(A).
By definition, the regular set of a closed operator A with a dense domain D(A) is the set p(A) = {A E C I A-AI : D(A)
is a bijection with a bounded inverse21,
and for A E p(A), the bounded operator RA(A) = (A - AI)-1 is called the resolvent of A at A. The regular set p(A) C C is open and its complement Q(A) = C \ p(A) is the spectrum of A. The subset up(A) of Q(A) consisting of eigenvalues of A of finite multiplicity is called the point spectrum. l We consider only linear operators with dense domains. 2By the closed graph theorem, the last condition is redundant. 63
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
64
An operator A is self-adjoint (or Hermitian) if A = A*. Equivalently, A is symmetric and D(A) = D(A*), and for such operators Q(A) C IR. A symmetric operator A is called essentially self-adjoint if its closure A = A** is self-adjoint. For a symmetric operator A the following conditions are equivalent:
(i) A is essentially self-adjoint. (ii) Ker(A* + ii) = Ker(A* - ii) = {0}.
(iii) Im(A + ii) = Im(A - ii) = 341. A symmetric operator A with D(A) = -he is bounded and self-adjoint. An operator A is positive3 if (Acp, cp) > 0 for all 0 E D(A), which we denote by A > 0. Positive operators satisfy the Cauchy-Bunyakovski-Schwarz inequality (0.1)
(Acp,)I2 < (Acp,
for all cp, V)E D(A).
In particular, (Acp, cp) = 0 implies that Acp = 0. Every bounded positive operator is self-adjoint4. We denote by .(3 °) the (C*-algebra of bounded linear operators on 3l° with the operator norm II and with the antiinvolution * given by the operator adjoint. Operator A E is called compact if it maps bounded sets in 3Y into pre-compact sets5. The vector space of compact operators on 3° is a closed two-sided ideals of the cC*-algebra .(3l°). An operator A E `'(3 °) is of trace class if 11
cc
IIAII1=Eµn(A)
where µn(A) are singular values of A: µn(A) = An(A) > 0, where An(A) are eigenvalues of A*A. Equivalently, an operator A E 2(dY) is of trace class if and only if for every orthonormal basis {en}'=1 for 3C° 00
1: 1 (Aen, en) I < 00. -n=1
Since a permutation of an orthonormal basis is again an orthonormal basis, this condition can be replaced by 00
>(Aen, en) <
00
n=1 3Non-negative, to be precise. 4This is true only for complex Hilbert spaces. 5The sets with compact closure. 'Ideal `'(AY) is the only closed two-sided ideal of 2(At°).
1. Observables, states, and dynamics
65
for every orthonormal basis {en}'1 for J. The trace of a trace class operator A is defined by 00
Tr A = E (Aen, en), n=1
and does not depend on the choice of an orthonormal basis {en}O°_1 for °. A positive operator A E .(3f°) is of trace class if cc
E (Aen, en) < 00 n=1
for some orthonormal basis {en}°°_1 for 3e°. The space 91 of trace class operators in 3e is a Banach algebra with the norm IIAII1 = Tr A*A, and is a two-sided ideal (von Neumann-Schatten ideal) in the C*-algebra The property
Tr AB = Tr BA for all A E 91i B E 2(3e) is called the cyclic property of the trace. If A E 91, the mapping 1A(B) TrAB, B E .(Jye), is a continuous linear functional on 2(34°), so that - the dual Banach space to P(3"). However, 91 0 91 C and the mapping A --, 1A is an isomorphism but rather 91 = of Banach spaces. Similarly, the mapping B H lB gives an isomorphism P(3l°) = Y1 . An operator A E P(3b°) is called a Hilbert-Schmidt operator if AA* E 5°1. Equivalently, an operator A E `P(3e) is a Hilbert-Schmidt operator if and only if for some orthonormal basis {en}°_1 for 3l° IIAen112
n=1
The vector space 92 of Hilbert-Schmidt operators in 3l° is a Hilbert space with the inner product (A, B)2 = Tr AB*. The Hilbert-Schmidt space 92 is also a two-sided ideal in the C*-algebra P(3°).
1. Observables, states, and dynamics Quantum mechanics studies the microworld - the physical laws at an atomic scale - that cannot be adequately described by classical mechanics. The properties of the microworld are so different from our everyday experiences that it is no surprise that its laws seem to contradict the common sense. Thus classical mechanics and classical electrodynamics cannot explain the stability of atoms and molecules. Neither can these theories reconcile different properties of light, its wave-like behavior in interference and diffraction phenomena, and its particle-like behavior in photo-electric emission and scattering by free photons. The fundamental difference between
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
66
the microworld and the perceived world around us is that in the microworld
every experiment results in interaction with the system and thus disturbs its properties, whereas in classical physics it is always assumed that one can neglect the disturbances the measurement brings upon a system. This imposes a limitation on our powers of observation and leads to a conclusion that there exist observables which cannot be measured simultaneously. We will not discuss here these and other basic experimental facts, referring the interested reader to physics textbooks. Nor will we follow the historic path of the theory. Instead, we show how to formulate quantum mechanics using the general notions of states, observables, and time evolution, described in Section 2.8 in Chapter 1. There we have seen that commutativity of the algebra of observables A results in its realization as an algebra of functions on the topological space - the space of states - and thus brings us to the realm of classical mechanics. Therefore in order to get a realization of observables and states which is different from classical mechanics, we
must assume that the C*-algebra associated with observables is no longer commutative. A fundamental example of a non-commutative C*-algebra is given by the algebra of all bounded operators on a complex Hilbert space, and it turns out that it is this algebra which plays a fundamental role in quantum mechanics! Here we formulate the basic principles of quantum mechanics using precise mathematical language. At this point it should be noted that one can not verify directly the principles lying at the foundation of quantum mechanics. Nevertheless, the validity of quantum mechanics, whenever it is applicable, is continuously being confirmed by numerous experimental facts which perfectly agree with the predictions of the theory7.
1.1. Mathematical formulation. The following axioms constitute the basis of quantum mechanics.
Al. With every quantum system there is associated an infinite-dimensional separable complex Hilbert space J -Y, in physics terminology called the space of states8. The Hilbert space of a composite quantum system is a tensor product of Hilbert spaces of component systems.
A2. The set of observables W of a quantum system with the Hilbert space 3' consists of all self-adjoint operators on A°. The subset .moo = Wn_O(. ) of bounded observables is a vector space over IR.
A3. The set of states .7 of a quantum system with a Hilbert space -ye, consists of all positive (and hence self-adjoint) trace class operators M with 7This refers to non-relativistic phenomena at the atomic scale. 8The space of pure states, to be precise.
1. Observables, states, and dynamics
67
Tr M = 1. Pure states are projection operators onto one-dimensional subFor 0 E ", JJV)JI = 1, the corresponding projection onto CV) spaces of is denoted by P,1,. All other states are called mixed states9. .
A4. A process of measurement is the correspondence
.dx9'
(A,M)'-*hAE.9'(l ),
which to every observable A E W and state M E 9' assigns a probability measure uA on R. For every Borel subset E C_ R, the quantity 0 < µA (E) < 1
is the probability that for a quantum system in the state M the result of a measurement of the observable A belongs to E. The expectation value (the mean-value) of the observable A E Wfoo in the state M E 9' is
(AIM) =
AdµA(A),
where PA(A) = PA((-oo, A)) is a distribution function for the probability measure µA.
The set of states 9' is a convex set. According to the Hilbert-Schmidt theorem on the canonical decomposition for compact self-adjoint operators, (finite or for every M E 9' there exists an orthonormal set {,0n}' 1 in infinite, in the latter case N = oo) such that N
N
n=1
n=1
M=EanPOn and TrM=Ean=1, where an > 0 are non-zero eigenvalues of M. Thus every mixed state is a convex linear combination of pure states. The following result characterizes the pure states.
Lemma 1.1. A state M E 9' is a pure state if and only if it cannot be represented as a non-trivial convex linear combination in Y.
Proof. Suppose that
P,+,=aM1+(1-a)M2i 0
so that (M1cp,cp) = 0 for all cp E Yel and by (0.1) we get M1 is self-adjoint, it leaves the complementary subspace CV) invariant, and from TrM1 = 1 it follows that M1 = P.p. Therefore, M1 = M2 = P.1. 9In physics terminology, the operator M is called the density operator.
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
68
Explicit construction of the correspondence d x 9 -+ ,9'(1l) is based on the general spectral theorem of von Neumann, which emphasizes the fundamental role the self-adjoint operators play in quantum mechanics.
Definition. A projection-valued measure on R is a mapping P : R(R) P(3l°) of the o-algebra .(R) of Borel subsets of R into the algebra of bounded operators on 3l°, satisfying the following properties.
PM1. For every Borel subset E C R, P(E) is an orthogonal projection, i.e., P(E) = P(E)2 and P(E) = P(E)*. PM2. P(O) = 0, P(R) = I, the identity operator on . PM3. For every disjoint union of Borel subsets, n
00
E _ JJ En,
P(E) = l
n=1
P(Ei) i=1
in the strong topology on Y(3l°).
Remark. Similarly, a projection-valued measure on W is a mapping P M(IEBn) -4 9(. ), satisfying the same properties PM1-PM3. It follows from PM1-PM3 that P(El)P(E2) = P(El n E2) for all El, E2 E .9(R).
(1.2)
With every projection-valued measure P on R we associate a projectionvalued function P(A) = P((-00, A)), called the projection-valued resolution of the identity. It is characterized by the following properties.
PD1. P(A)P(p) = P(min{A,p}).
PD2. lim P(A) = 0, lim P(A) = I. a-00
A- -0o
PD3. lim P(p) = P(A). µ
For every cp c . Ye' the resolution of the identity P(A) defines a distribution function (P(A)cp, cp) of the bounded measure on R (probability measure when 11coll = 1). By the polarization identity (P(A)P, &) =1 {(P(A)(W + VG), cp + ) - (P(A)(w - V)), W -
+ i(P(A)(W + iV)), W + iV)) - i(P(A)(w - i';),W - io)},
1. Observables, states, and dynamics
69
so that (P(A)cp, 0) corresponds to a complex measure on R - a complex linear combination of measures.
A measurable function f on R is said to be finite almost everywhere (a.e.) with respect to the projection-valued measure P if it is finite a.e. with respect to all measures (PO, 0), E 34. For separable <3 9 a theorem of von Neumann states that for every projection-valued measure P there exists cp E A° such that a function f is finite a.e. with respect to P if and only if it is finite a.e. with respect to the measure (Pcp, cp).
The next statement is the celebrated general spectral theorem of von Neumann.
Theorem 1.1 (J. von Neumann). For every self-adjoint operator A on the Hilbert space -he there exists a unique projection-valued resolution of the identity P(A), satisfying the following properties. (i)
D(A) =
E
:
j
A2d(P(A)cp, cp) < oo 0"
and for every cp E D(A) 00
Acp =
AdP(A)cp,
J
defined as a limit of Riemann-Stieltjes sums in the strong topology on J -Y. The support of the corresponding projection-valued measure P coincides with the spectrum of the operator A: A E o-(A) if and only if PA ((A - E, A + E)) 0 for all E > 0. (ii) For every continuous function f on R, f (A) is a linear operator on with a dense domain D(f (A)) = S P E A ° :
l
If J-00
d efined for cp ED (f (A)) as f (A)SP =
f
00 f (A)dP(A)00
and understood as in part (i). The operator f (A) satisfies f (A)* = I (A),
where f is the complex conjugate function to f, and the operator f (A) is bounded if and only if the function f is bounded on Q(A). For bounded on o,(A) continuous functions f and g,
f
foo00f (A)g(A)dP(A)cp,
cp E .31°.
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
70
(iii) For every measurable function f on I[8, finite a. e. with respect to the projection-valued measure P, f (A) is a linear operator on defined as in (ii), where the integral for f (A)cp is now understood in the weak sense: for cp c D(f (A)) and every E 3e, .
f
(f (A)SP,
00
f
- a Lebesgue-Stieltjes integral with respect to a complex measure. The correspondence f --> f (A) satisfies the same properties as in (ii), where the integrals are understood in the weak sense. (iv) A bounded operator B commutes with A, that is, B(D(A)) C D(A) and AB = BA on D(A), if and only if it commutes with P(A) for all A and, therefore, B commutes with every operator f (A). (v) For every projection-valued resolution of identity P(\) the operator
A on f, defined as in part (i), is self-adjoint. Using the spectral theorem, the correspondence (A, M) --> AA, postulated in A4, can be explicitly described as follows. A5. The probability measure µA on I[8, which defines the correspondence d x 9' -> 9(1R), is given by the Born-von Neumann formula
,uA(E) = Tr PA(E)M, E E .V(R),
(1.3)
where PA is a projection-valued measure on R associated with the self-adjoint operator A.
Remark. The probability measure µA on R can be considered as a "quantum push-forward" of the state M by the observable A (cf. the discussion in Section 2.8 in Chapter 1). From the Hilbert-Schmidt decomposition (1.1) we get N
N
N
hA(E) = E an(PA(E)On, bn) = E an IIPA(E)On1I2 _< E an = 1, n=1
n=1
n=1
so that indeed 0 < µA(E) < 1. Denote by hA(A) the distribution function of the probability measure AA, AA (A) = (PA(A)V, 0) for M = P.O.
Proposition 1.1. Suppose that an observable A E d and a state M E 5° are such that (AIM) < oo and Im M C D(A). Then AM E 9i and (AIM) = Tr AM.
In particular, if M = P.,, and V E D(A), then
(AIM) = (A', b)
and
(A2I M) = IIA'
II2.
1. Observables, states, and dynamics
71
Proof. Let {e,,,}°_1 be an orthonormal basis for 3e. Since
µA (E) = Tr PA(E)M = E(PA(E)Men, en), n=1
we get for every E E .4(R), 0" An (E), 1:
AWE)
n=1
where An are finite measures on 1l defined by An (E) = (PA(E)Men, en). Since
ffduA
=EffdAn
n-1
for every function f integrable with respect to the measure µA, it follows from the spectral theorem that 00
00
>(AMen, en) =
00
E
Adµn(A) =
n=1 -oo
n=1
J
AdµA(A) < oo. 00
Thus AM E 9l and (AIM) = TrAM. In particular, when M = PV, and
0ED(A), (AIM) = f Ad(PA(A)0, V) = (Am, 0). Finally, from the spectral theorem and the change of variables formula we 00 get 00
IIA')II2 = f A2d(PA(A)0, ')) = f Ad(PA2 (A),O, 0) = (A2I M). o
Corollary 1.2. If (AIM), (A2IM) < oc, then AM E 9'1 and (AIM) _ Tr AM.
Proof. Since
f A2dµn(A) < 17 A2dµA(A) = (A2I M) < 00, 00
00
we get that en E D(AM), and the result follows from the proof of Proposition 1.1.
Remark. It is convenient to approximate an unbounded self-adjoint operator A by bounded operators An = fn(A), where fn = X[-n,n] - a characteristic function of the interval [-n, n]. Assuming that (AIM) exists, we have
:=
(AIM) = f:AdA
f n-. _n n
lim
Ad/A(A) = lim (AnI M). n-cc
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
72
Definition. Self-adjoint operators A and B commute if the corresponding projection-valued measures PA and PB commute, PA(El)PB(E2) = PB(E2)PA(EI)
for all
E1iE2 E .R(1R).
The following results, which follow from the spectral theorem, are very useful in applications.
Proposition 1.2. The following statements are equivalent. (i) Self-adjoint operators A and B commute. (ii) For all A, tt E C, Im A, Im y 0, RA(A)RI,,(B) = R, (B)Ra(A).
(iii) For all u, v E
R
eiuAeivB
=
eivBeiuA
(iv) For all u E ]R, the operators eiuA and B commute.
Slightly abusing notation10, we will often write [A, B] = AB - BA = 0 for commuting self-adjoint operators A and B.
Proposition 1.3. Let A = {&..., An} be a finite set of self-adjoint, pairwise commuting operators on 0. There exists a unique projection-valued measure PA on the Borel subsets of ]l8n having the following properties.
(i) For every E = El x
x En E .V(R'),
PA(E) = PA,(Ei) ... PA. (En). (ii) In the strong operator topology, Ak = JRn AkdPA,
k = 1, ... , n,
where .k is the k-th coordinate function on Rn, Ak(xl, ... , x,)
_
xk.
(iii) For every measurable function f on R', finite a. e. with respect to the projection-valued measure PA, f (Al, ... , An) is a linear operator on .3° defined by
f(Al,...,An) = f fdPA, n where the integral is understood in the weak operator topology. The
correspondence f H f (&..., An) satisfies the same properties as in part (ii) of the spectral theorem. loIn general, for unbounded self-adjoint operators A and B the commutator [A, B] = AB-BA is not necessarily closed, i.e., it could be defined only for cp = 0.
1. Observables, states, and dynamics
73
The support of the projection-valued measure PA on R' is called the joint spectrum of the commutative family A = {Al, ... , An}.
Remark. According to von Neumann's theorem on a generating operator, for every commutative family A of self-adjoint operators (not necessarily finite) on a separable Hilbert space .39 there is a generating operator - a self-adjoint operator R on 3' Isuch that all operators in A are functions of R.
It seems natural that simultaneous measurement of a finite set of observables A = {Al, . . . , An} in the state M E 9 should be described by the probability measure AA on 1R' given by the following generalization of the Born-von Neumann formula: (1.4) AA(E) = Tr(PA1(El) ... PAn (En)
M), E = El x ... x En E 9(R').
However, formula (1.4) defines a probability measure on Rn if and only if PA, (El) ... PAn (En) defines a projection-valued measure on R'n. Since a
product of orthogonal projections is an orthogonal projection only when the
projection operators commute, we conclude that the operators Al,... , An should form a commutative family. This agrees with the requirement that simultaneous measurement of several observables should be independent of
the order of the measurements of individual observables. We summarize these arguments as the following axiom.
A6. A finite set of observables A = {Al, ... , An} can be measured simultaneously (simultaneously measured observables) if and only if they form a commutative family. Simultaneous measurement of the commutative family A C W in the state M E 9 is described by the probability measure AA on R given by
AA (E) = Tr PA(E)M, E E 9(Rn), where PA is the projection-valued measure from Proposition 1.3. Explicitly,
x En E P(1Rn). For evPA(E) = PA, (El) ... PA,. (En) for E = El x ery Borel subset E C_ I[8n the quantity 0 < AA(E) < 1 is the probability that for a quantum system in the state M the result of the simultaneous measurement of observables Al, ... , An belongs to E. The axioms Al-A6 are known as Dirac-von Neumann axioms. Problem 1.1. Prove property (1.2). Problem 1.2. Prove that the state M is a pure state if and only if Tr M2 = 1. Problem 1.3. Prove that the Born-von Neumann formula (1.3) defines a probability measure on R, i.e., AA is a a-additive function on .
1(]E8).
Problem 1.4. Prove all the remaining statements in this section.
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
74
1.2. Heisenberg's uncertainty relations. The variance of the observable A in the state M, which measures the mean deviation of A from its expectation value, is defined by
-
AM(A) = ((A - (AI M)I)2I M) = (A2I M) (Al M)2 > 0, provided the expectation values (A2I M) and (AIM) exist. It follows from Proposition 1.1 that for M = P,,, where 0 E D(A), oM(A) = II (A
- (Al M)I)
II2 = IIA'II2 - (AV), 2/1)2.
Lemma 1.2. For A E d and M E .' the variance am (A) = 0 if and only if Im M is an eigenspace for the operator A with the eigenvalue a = (AIM) . In particular, if M = PO, then is an eigenvector of A, AV) = a2/1.
Proof. It follows from the spectral theorem that am (A) =
(A - a)2dpA(A), foo
so that o-M (A) = 0 if and only if the probability measure µA is supported at the point a E I[8, i.e., ILA({a}) = 1. Since µA({a}) = Tr PA({a})M and Tr M = 1, we conclude that this is equivalent to Im M being an invariant subspace for PA({a}), and it follows from the spectral theorem that Im M is an eigenspace for A with the eigenvalue a. Now we formulate generalized Heisenberg's uncertainty relations.
Proposition 1.4 (H. Weyl). Let A, B E .s5( and let M = P,,, be the pure state such that 2/) E D(A) f1 D(B) and Ag', B2/1 E D(A) fl D(B). Then O'M(A)cyL(B) ? ' (i[A, B] I M)2_
The same inequality holds for all M E 9', where by definition (i[A, B] I M) _ limn-,, (i [An, Bn] I M) .
Proof. Let M = Pp. Since [A - (AI M)I, B - (BIM)I] = [A, B], it is sufficient to prove the inequality (A2 I M) (B2 I M) ? 4 (i [A, B] I M) 2.
We have for all a E IR, II (A + iaB),0II2 = a2(B2b, B2b) - ia(A2/1, B2/1) + ia(B2/), A2/1) + (A2/), A2/1)
= a2(B22/1, 0) + a(i[A, B]Vb, 0) + so that necessarily 4(A22/), 0)(B22/J, 0) > (i[A, B]2/), 2/1)2.
(A20, 0) > 0,
1. Observables, states, and dynamics
75
The same argument works for the mixed states. Since 2 2 2 2 um (A)am(B) = lim QM(An)QM(Bn)
n-*oo
(see the remark in the previous section), it is sufficient to prove the inequality
for bounded A and B. Then using the cyclic property of the trace we have for all a E R,
0
so that 4Tr A2MTrB2M > Tr(i[A, BI M)2. Heisenberg's uncertainty relations provide a quantitative expression of the fact that even in a pure state non-commuting observables cannot be measured simultaneously. This shows a fundamental difference between the process of measurement in classical mechanics and in quantum mechanics.
1.3. Dynamics. The set .d of quantum observables does not form an algebra with respect to an operator product". Nevertheless, a real vector space .do of bounded observables has a Lie algebra structure with the Lie bracket
i[A, B] = i(AB - BA),
A, B E do.
Remark. In fact, the (C*-algebra of bounded operators on 7P has a structure of a complex Lie algebra with the Lie bracket given by a commutator [A, B] = AB - BA. It satisfies the Leibniz rule [AB, C] = A[B, C] + [A, C]B,
so that the Lie bracket is a derivation of the (C*-algebra Y(-°). In analogy with classical mechanics, we postulate that the time evolution of a quantum system with the space of states J-Y is completely determined by a special observable H E d, called a Hamiltonian operator (Hamiltonian for brevity). As in classical mechanics, the Lie algebra structure on do leads to corresponding quantum equations of motion. Specifically, the analog of Hamilton's picture in classical mechanics (see Section 2.8 in Chapter 1) is the Heisenberg picture in quantum mechanics, where the states do not depend on time
dM dt
=0, MEY,
11The product of two non-commuting self-adjoint operators is not self-adjoint.
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
76
and bounded observables satisfy the Heisenberg equation of motion
d = {H, A}, ,
(1.5)
A E srdo,
where
{, }n= [,
(1.6)
I
is the quantum bracket - the h-dependent Lie bracket on moo. The positive number h, called the Planck constant, is one of the fundamental constants in
physics12.
The Heisenberg equation (1.5) is well defined when H E d0. Indeed, let U(t) be a strongly continuous one-parameter group of unitary operators associated with a bounded self-adjoint operator H, (1.7)
U(t) = e_Ktx,
t E R.
It satisfies the differential equation
ihd
HU(t) = U(t)H, dtt) = so that the solution A(t) of the Heisenberg equation of motion with the initial condition A(O) = A E .do is given by (1.8)
(1.9)
A(t) = U(t)-'AU(t).
In general, a strongly one-parameter group of unitary operators (1.7), associated with a self-adjoint operator H, satisfies differential equation (1.8) only on D(H) in a strong sense, that is, applied to cp E D(H). The quantum dynamics is defined by the same formula (1.9), and in this sense all quantum observables satisfy the Heisenberg equation of motion (1.5). The evolution operator Ut : d -+ d is defined by Ut(A) = A(t) = U(t)-1AU(t), and is an automorphism of the Lie algebra do of bounded observables. This is a quantum analog of the statement that the evolution operator in classical mechanics is an automorphism of the Poisson algebra of classical observables (see Theorem 2.19 in Section 2.7 of Chapter 1). By Stone's theorem, every strongly-continuous one-parameter group of unitary operators13 U(t) is of the form (1.7), where
D(H)=(coE3°:li
oU(tt-Icp
exists
and Hcp=ihli
oU(tt-IMP
The domain D(H) of the self-adjoint operator H, called the infinitesimal generator of U(t), is an invariant linear subspace for all operators U(t). 12The Planck constant has a physical dimension of the action (energy x time). Its value h = 1.054 x 10-27 erg x sec, which is determined from the experiment, manifests that quantum mechanics is a microscopic theory. 13According to a theorem of von Neumann, on a separable Hilbert space every weakly measurable one-parameter group of unitary operators is strongly continuous.
1. Observables, states, and dynamics
77
We summarize the presented arguments as the following axiom.
A7 (Heisenberg's Picture). The dynamics of a quantum system is described by the strongly continuous one-parameter group U(t) of unitary operators. Quantum states do not depend on time, 9 D M --p M(t) = M E 9, and time dependence of quantum observables is given by the evolution operator Ut,
./ E) A H A(t) = Ut(A) = U(t)-1AU(t) E W. Infinitesimally, the evolution of quantum observables is described by the Heisenberg equation of motion (1.5), where the Hamiltonian operator H is the infinitesimal generator of U(t). The analog of Liouville's picture in classical mechanics (see Section 2.8
in Chapter 1) is Schrodinger's picture in quantum mechanics, defined as follows.
A8 (Schrodinger's Picture). The dynamics of a quantum system is described by the strongly continuous one-parameter group U(t) of unitary operators. Quantum observables do not depend on time, d 3 A H A(t) _ A E d, and time dependence of states is given by the inverse of the evolution operator Ut 1 = U_t, (1.10)
9 M --> M(t) = U_t(M) = U(t)MU(t)-1 E Y.
Infinitesimally, the evolution of quantum states is described by the Schrodinger equation of motion (1.11)
ddt
= -{H, M}h, M E 9,
where the Hamiltonian operator H is the infinitesimal generator of U(t). Proposition 1.5. Heisenberg and Schrodinger descriptions of dynamics are equivalent.
Proof. Let AA(t) and (µt)A be, respectively, probability measures on ]l8 asso-
ciated with (A(t), M) E d x 9 and (A, M(t)) E W x 9 according to A3-A4, where A(t) = Ut(A) and M(t) = U_t(M). We need to show that /A(t) = (,at)A It follows from the spectral theorem that PA(t) = U(t)-1PAU(t), so that using the Born-von Neumann formula (1.3) and the cyclic property of the trace, we get for E E M(R), Tr(U(t)-1PA(E)U(t)M) /A(t)(E) = Tr PA(t) (E)M = Tr(PA(E)U(t)MU(t)-1) = Tr PA(E)M(t) = = (µt)A(E).
Corollary 1.3. (A(t)IM) = (AIM(t)). In analogy with classical mechanics (see Section 1.4 of Chapter 1), we have the following definition.
78
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
Definition. An observable A E W is a quantum integral of motion (or a constant of motion) for a quantum system with the Hamiltonian H if in Heisenberg's picture dA(t) dt
0
It follows from Proposition 1.2 that A E W is an integral of motion if and only if it commutes with the Hamiltonian H, so that, in agreement with (1.5),
{H,A}n,=0. This is a quantum analog of the Poisson commutativity property, given by formula (2.14) in Section 2.6 of Chapter 1.
It follows from (1.11) that the time evolution of a pure state M = Pp is given by M(t) = P,p(t), where O(t) = U(t)z/'. Since D(H) is invariant under U(t), the vector '(t) = U(t)V) satisfies the time-dependent Schrodinger equation (1.12)
ih dt = HV
with the initial condition V)(0) =,O.
Definition. A state M E 9 is called stationary for a quantum system with Hamiltonian H if in Schrodinger's picture dM(t) 0 dt
The state M is stationary if and only if [M, U(t)] = 0 for all t, and by Proposition 1.2 this is equivalent to {H, M}n, = 0,
in agreement with (1.11). The following simple result is fundamental.
Lemma 1.3. The pure state M = P is stationary if and only if Eli is an eigenvector for H, HO = AV),
and in this case 0(t) = e-hatO.
Proof. It follows from U(t)P, = POU(t) that '% is a common eigenvector for unitary operators U(t) for all t, U(t)O = c(t)o, c(t)j = 1. Since U(t) is a strongly continuous one-parameter group of unitary operators, the continuous function c(t) = (U(t),O,0) satisfies the equation c(tl + t2) = c(tl)c(t2) for all tl, t2 E I[8, so that c(t) = e- h At for some A E R. Thus by Stone's theorem 'O E D(H) and H = Ai'.
2. Quantization
79
In physics terminology, the eigenvectors of H are called bound states. The corresponding eigenvalues are called energy levels and are usually denoted by
E. The eigenvalue equation Ho = E0 is called the stationary Schrodinger equation.
Problem 1.5. Show that if an observable A is such that for every state M the expectation value (AIM(t)) does not depend on t, then A is a quantum integral of motion. (This is the definition of integrals of motion in the Schrodinger picture.)
Problem 1.6. Show that a solution of the initial value problem for the timedependent Schrodinger equation (1.12) is given by
where P(a) is the resolution of identity for the Hamiltonian H.
fsss,
Problem 1.7. Let D be a linear subspace of .3t°, consisting of Gdrding vectors 00
Of =
f E 9(R), 0 E 3L°,
00
where 9(R) is the Schwartz space of rapidly decreasing functions on R. Prove that D is dense in .3 ° and is invariant for U(t) and for the Hamiltonian H. (Hint: Show
that U(t)Of = Of, E D, where ft(s) = f (s - t), and deduce HO f = 4Of,.)
2. Quantization To study the quantum system one needs to describe its Hilbert space of states Jye and the Hamiltonian H - a self-adjoint operator in ° which defines the evolution of a system. When the quantum system has a classical analog, the procedure of constructing the corresponding Hilbert space and the Hamiltonian H is called quantization.
Definition. Quantization of a classical system HH) with the Hamiltonian function14 He is a one-to-one mapping Qr, : A -> .d from the set of classical observables A = Coo (4') to the set W of quantum observables - the set of self-adjoint operators on a Hilbert space The map Qr, depends on the parameter h > 0, and its restriction to the subspace of bounded classical observables A0 is a linear mapping to the subspace do of bounded quantum observables, which satisfies the properties
lim 2 Q_ 1(Qn(f1)Qh(f2) + Qh(f2)Qh(fl)) = flf2 and
li o Qh1({Qn(fl), Qn(f2)}n,) = {fl, f2}
for all
fl, f2 E Ao.
14Notation He is used to distinguish the Hamiltonian function in classical mechanics from the Hamiltonian operator H in quantum mechanics.
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
80
The latter property is the celebrated correspondence principle of Niels Bohr. In particular, HH --> Qh(Hc) = H - the Hamiltonian operator for a quantum system.
Remark. In physics literature the correspondence principle is often stated in the form
as h,0. Quantum mechanics is different from classical mechanics, so that the correspondence f F-> Qh(f) cannot be an isomorphism between the Lie algebras of bounded classical and quantum observables with respect to classical and quantum brackets. It becomes an isomorphism only in the limit h -> 0 when, according to the correspondence principle, quantum mechanics turns into classical mechanics. Since quantum mechanics provides a more accurate and refined description than classical mechanics, quantization of a classical system may not be unique.
Definition. Two quantizations Q(1) and Q(2) of a given classical system }), Hc) are said to be equivalent if there exists a linear mapping IZ/h : A -> A such that Q(2) = Q(1) o Oh, and lim % = id. h--+O
For many "real world" quantum systems - the systems describing actual physical phenomena - the corresponding Hamiltonian H does not depend on a choice of equivalent quantization, and is uniquely determined by the classical Hamiltonian function Hc.
2.1. Heisenberg commutation relations. The simplest classical system with one degree of freedom is described by the phase space ER2 with coordinates p, q and the Poisson bracket { , }, associated with the canonical symplectic form w = dp A dq. In particular, the Poisson bracket between classical observables p and q - momentum and coordinate of a particle has the following simple form:
-
{p,q} = 1.
(2.1)
-
It is another postulate of quantum mechanics that under quantization classical observables p and q correspond to quantum observables P and Q self-adjoint operators on a Hilbert space _°, satisfying the following properties.
CR1. There is a dense linear subset D c -e' such that P : D -> D and
Q:D-->D. CR2. For all z/i E D,
(PQ - QP)' = -iho.
2. Quantization
81
which commutes with P and Q is CR3. Every bounded operator on a multiple of the identity operator I.
Property CR2 is called the Heisenberg commutation relation for one degree of freedom. In terms of the quantum bracket (1.6) it takes the form {P, Q}n, = I,
(2.2)
which is exactly the same as the Poisson bracket (2.1). Property CR3 is a quantum analog of the classical property that the Poisson manifold }) is non-degenerate: every function which Poisson commutes with p and q is a constant (see the last remark in Section 2.7 of Chapter 1). The operators P and Q are called, respectively, the momentum operator and the coordinate operator. The correspondence p H P, q --* Q with P and Q satisfying CR1-CR3 is the cornerstone for the quantization of classical systems. The validity of (2.2), as well as of quantum mechanics as a whole, is confirmed by the agreement of the theory with numerous experiments. (R2, {
,
Remark. It is tempting to extend the correspondence p H P, q --+ Q to all observables by defining the mapping f (p, q) '--> f (P, Q). However, this approach to quantization is rather naive: operators P and Q satisfy (2.2) and do not commute, so that one needs to understand how f (P, Q) - a "function of non-commuting variables" - is actually defined. We will address this problem of the ordering of non-commuting operators P and Q in Section 3.3.
It follows from Heisenberg's uncertainty relations (see Proposition 1.4), that for any pure state M = PO with E D, QM(P)QM(Q) >
2
This is a fundamental result saying that it is impossible to measure the coordinate and the momentum of a quantum particle simultaneously: the more accurate the measurement of one quantity is, the less accurate the value of the other is. It is often said that a quantum particle has no observed path, so that "quantum motion" differs dramatically from the motion in classical mechanics. It is now straightforward to consider a classical system with n degrees of freedom, described by the phase space IR2, with coordinates p = (pi, ... , per,)
and q = (q1, ... , qfl), and the Poisson bracket {
,
}, associated with the
canonical symplectic form w = dp A dq. The Poisson brackets between clas-
sical observables p and q - momenta and coordinates of a particle - have the form (2.3)
IN, P11 = 0,
{qk,q'1=0,
{pk,g1} = ok,
k,l = 1,...,n.
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
82
Corresponding momenta and coordinate operators P = (Pi, ... , P,,,) and Q = (Q1 Qfl) are self-adjoint operators that have a common invariant dense linear subset D C , and on D satisfy the following commutation relations: (2.4)
{Pk, Pj} h = 0,
{Qk, QI}n, = 0,
{Pk, Ql}n, = 5LI,
k, l = 1, ... , n.
These relations are called Heisenberg commutation relations for n degrees of
freedom. The analog of CR3 is the property that every bounded operator on ) ° which commutes with all operators P and Q is a multiple of the identity operator I. The fundamental algebraic structure associated with Heisenberg commutation relations is the so-called Heisenberg algebra. Definition. The Heisenberg algebra fl,,, with n degrees of freedom is a Lie algebra with the generators e1, ... , e', fl, ... , f, c and the relations (2.5)
[ek, c]
= 0,
[fk, c] = 0,
[eke fl]
_
8 c,
k, l = 1, ... , n.
The invariant definition is the following. Let (V, w) be a 2n-dimensional symplectic vector space considered as an abelian Lie algebra, and let g be a one-dimensional central extension of V by a Lie algebra 2-cocycle given by the bilinear form w. This means that there is an exact sequence of vector spaces
0->][8->g->V--+ O,
(2.6)
and the Lie bracket in g is defined by [x, y] = w(x, y)c,
(2.7)
where t, y are the images in V of elements x, y E g, and c is the image of 1 under the embedding JR --> g, called the central element of g. A choice of a symplectic basis e1, ... , e', fl, . , f,, for V (see Section 2.6 of Chapter 1) establishes the isomorphism g ^_, Ij,,, and relations (2.5) are obtained from the Lie bracket (2.7). By Ado's theorem, the Heisenberg algebra C ,, is isomorphic to a Lie subalgebra of a matrix algebra over R. Explicitly, it is realized as a nilpotent subalgebra of the Lie algebra of (n + 2) x (n + 2) matrices with the elements n
(2.8)
E(u k fk + vkek ) + ac =
0
u1
u2
0
0
0
0
vl
0
0
0
0
V2
0
0
0
...
0
vn,
0
0
0
...
0
0
k=1
2. Quantization
83
Remark. The faithful representation 4, -` g1n+2, given by (2.8), is clearly reducible: the subspace V = {x _ (X1, ... , xn+2) E R'+2 : Xn+2 = 0} is an invariant subspace for C .,,, with the central element c acting by zero. However,
this representation is not decomposable: the vector space Rn+2 cannot be written as a direct sum of V and a one-dimensional invariant subspace for [a. This explains why the central element c is not represented by a diagonal matrix with the first n + 1 zeros, but rather has a special form given by (2.8).
Analytically, Heisenberg commutation relations (2.5) correspond to an irreducible unitary representation of the Heisenberg Lie algebra [in. Recall that a unitary representation p of ,,, in the Hilbert space -ye is the linear mapping p : [in -+ id - the space of skew-Hermitian operators in 3O such that all self-adjoint operators ip(x), x E 0, have a common invariant dense linear subset D C JV' and satisfy
-
P([x, y])cP = (p(x)p(y) - P(y)P(x))cP,
x, y E [in, cP E D.
Formally applying Schur's lemma we say that the representation p is irreducible if every bounded operator which commutes with all operators ip(x) is a multiple of the identity operator I. Then Heisenberg commutation relations (2.5) define an irreducible unitary representation p of the Heisenberg Lie algebra [n in the Hilbert space -he by setting (2.9)
P(.fk) = -iPk,
P(ek) _ -iQk,
k = 1, ... , n,
p(c)=-W.
Since the operators Pk and Qk are necessarily unbounded (see Problem 2.1), the condition PkPicp = PlPkcp for all cp E D
does not necessarily imply (see Problem 2.2) that self-adjoint operators Pk and PI commute in the sense of the definition in Section 1.1. To avoid such "pathological" representations, we will assume that p is an integrable representation, i.e., it can be integrated (in a precise sense specified below)
to an irreducible unitary representation of the Heisenberg group Hn - a connected, simply-connected Lie group with the Lie algebra [in. Explicitly, the Heisenberg group is a unipotent subgroup of the Lie algebra SL(n + 2, 1l) with the elements
g=
u1
u2
...
un
a
0
1
0
...
0
v1
0
0
1
...
0
V2
0
0
0
...
1
v",
0
0
0
...
0
1
1
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
84
The exponential map exp : Cl,, -> Hn is onto, and the Heisenberg group H,,, is generated by two n-parameter abelian subgroups
exp uX = exp
(u1dfk) 1:
,
exp vY = exp
(k=1
(vke*) E
,
U' V E R,
(k=1
and a one-parameter center exp ac, which satisfy the relations n
(2.10)
exp uX exp vY = exp(-uvc) exp vY exp uX,
uv = > ukvk. k=0
Indeed, it follows from (2.5) that [uX, vY] = -uvc is a central element, so that using the Baker-Campbell-Hausdorff formula we obtain
exp uX exp vY = exp(- uvc) exp(uX + vY), 2 exp vY exp uX = exp(2uvc) exp(uX + vY). In the matrix realization, the exponential map is given by the matrix expo-
nential and we get e'X = I + uX, e"Y = I + vY, and eac = I + ac, where I is the (n + 2) x (n + 2) identity matrix. Let R be an irreducible unitary representation of the Heisenberg group Hn in the Hilbert space JV' - a strongly continuous group homomorphism R : Hn -> 0II (.3f'), where G& (JV) is the group of unitary operators in ,3°. By Schur's lemma, R(eap) = e-iaaI, A E R. Suppose now that A = h, and define
two strongly continuous n-parameter abelian groups of unitary operators
U(u) = R(exp uX ), V(v) = R(exp vY),
u, v E 1W .
Then it follows from (2.10) that unitary operators U(u) and V(v) satisfy commutation relations U(u)V(v) = eih""V (v)U(u),
(2.11)
called Weyl relations. Let P = (P1,.. . , Pn) and Q = (Q1, ... , Qn) be, respectively, infinitesimal generators of the subgroups U(u) and V (v), given by the Stone theorem, Pk = i
au
and Qk = i u=o
aV(v) ,
avk
k = 1, ... , n.
v=0
Taking the second partial derivatives of Weyl relations (2.11) at the origin u = v = 0 and using the solution of Problem 1.7 in the previous section, we easily obtain the following result. Lemma 2.1. Let R : Hn -> GIl (3 °) be an irreducible unitary representation of the Heisenberg group Hn in .3 such that R(eap) = e-ifial, and let P = (Pi,. _., Pn) and Q = (Q1, ... , Qn) be, respectively, infinitesimal generators of the strongly continuous n-parameter abelian subgroups U(u) and V(v).
2. Quantization
85
Then formulas (2.9) define an irreducible unitary representation p of the Heisenberg algebra Cln, in 3l°.
The representation p in Lemma 2.1 is called the differential of a represen-
tation R, and is denoted by dR. The irreducible unitary representation p of C n is called integrable if p = dR for some irreducible unitary representation R of Hn.
Remark. Not every irreducible unitary representation of the Heisenberg algebra is integrable, so that Weyl relations cannot be obtained from the Heisenberg commutation relations. However, the following heuristic argument (which ignores the subtleties of dealing with unbounded operators) is commonly used in physics textbooks. Consider the case of one degree of freedom and start with {P, Q}n = I. Since the quantum bracket satisfies the Leibniz rule we have, for a "suitable" function f,
if (P), Q}h = f'(P) In particular, choosing f (P) = e-i"P = U(u), we obtain
U(u)Q - QU(u) = huU(u) or U(u)QU(u)-1 = Q + hul. This implies, for a "suitable" function g,
U(u)g(Q) = g(Q + hul)U(u), and setting g(Q) = e-ivQ = V(v), we get the Weyl relation. We will prove in Section 3.1 that all integrable irreducible unitary representations of the Heisenberg algebra CJ,,, with the same action of the central element c are unitarily equivalent. This justifies the following mathemati-
cal formulation of the Heisenberg commutation relations for n degrees of freedom.
A9 (Heisenberg's Commutation Relations). Momenta and coordinate operators P = (P1i ... , Pte,) and Q = (Q1, ... , Q') for a quantum particle with n degrees of freedom are defined by formulas (2.9), where p is an integrable irreducible unitary representation of the Heisenberg algebra Clv,
with the property p(c) _ -ihl. Problem 2.1. Prove that there are no bounded operators on the Hilbert space 3l° satisfying [A, B] = I.
Problem 2.2. Give an example of self-adjoint operators A and B which have a common invariant dense linear subset D C ° such that ABcp = BAcp for all cp E D, but e'A and eiB do not commute.
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
86
Problem 2.3. Prove Lemma 2.1. (Hint: As in Problem 1.7, let D be the linear set of Garding vectors
Of =
Ln
f (u, v)U(u)V (v)') d"ud"e,
f E Y(R2"'), V) E JY,
where .9(R2i) is the Schwartz space of rapidly decreasing functions on R2n.)
2.2. Coordinate and momentum representations. We start with the case of one degree of freedom and consider two natural realizations of the Heisenberg commutation relation. They are defined by the property that one of the self-adjoint operators P and Q is "diagonal" (i.e., is a multiplication by a function operator in the corresponding Hilbert space). In the coordinate representation, ' = L2 (R, dq) is the L2-space on the configuration space R with the coordinate q, which is a Lagrangian subspace of 1R2 defined by the equation p = 0. Set
D(Q)={ l
E -V':
f
0
(q)I2dq
and for cp c D(Q) define the operator Q as a "multiplication by q operator", (QW) (q) = qW (q), q E IR,
justifying the name coordinate representation. The coordinate operator Q is obviously self-adjoint and its projection-valued measure is given by (2.12)
(P(E)cp)(q) = XE(q)co(q),
where XE is the characteristic function of a Borel subset E C R. Therefore
suppP=IRandor(Q)= R. Recall that a self-adjoint operator A has an absolutely continuous spectrum if for every V) E , II = 1, the probability measure v.0, II
v,,,(E) = (PA(E) b,,b),
E E .8(1R),
is absolutely continuous with respect to the Lebesgue measure on R. Lemma 2.2. The coordinate operator Q has an absolutely continuous spectrum IR, and every bounded operator B which commutes with Q is a function of Q, B = f (Q) with f c L°O(R).
Proof. It follows from (2.12) that v1,(E) = fE kb(q)I2dq, which proves the first statement. Now a bounded operator B on 3° commutes with Q if and only if BP(E) = P(E)B for all E E _4(R), and using (2.12) we get (2.13)
B(XEV) = XEB(@p)
Choosing in (2.13) E = El and cp = XE2, where El and E2 have finite Lebesgue measure, we obtain B(XE1 - XE2) = B(XE1nE2) = XE1B(XE2) = XE2B(XEl),
2. Quantization
87
so that denoting fE = B(XE) we get supp fE C E, and fElIE1nE2 = fE2IE1nE2
for all El, E2 E M(R) with finite Lebesgue measure. Thus there exists a measurable function f on I[8 such that f I E = ME for every E E .(I[8) with finite Lebesgue measure. The linear subspace spanned by all XE E L2(IR) is dense in L2 (I[8) and the operator B is continuous, so that we get
(Bc)(q) = f (q)cp(q)
for all cp E L2(IR).
Since B is a bounded operator, f E L°° (R) and I I B I I =
11f
El
Remark. By the Schwartz kernel theorem, the operator B can be represented by an integral operator with a distributional kernel K(q, q'). Then the commutativity BQ = QB implies that, in the distributional sense,
(q-4)K(q,4) = 0, so that K is "proportional" to the Dirac delta-function, i.e.,
K(q, q') = f (q)6(q - q'), with some f c L°°(R). This argument is usually given in the physics textbooks.
Remark. The operator Q has no eigenvectors - the eigenvalue equation has no solutions in L2(J). However, in the distributional sense, this equation for every A E JR has a unique (up to a constant factor) solution cpa (q) = S(q - A), and these "generalized eigenfunctions", also called eigenfunctions
of the continuous spectrum, combine to a Schwarz kernel of the identity operator I on L2(J). This reflects the fact that operator Q is diagonal in the coordinate representation. Remark. Normalization of the eigenfunctions of the continuous spectrum V, \(q) can be also determined by the condition that for every A E JR the function A
IDa (q)
= fAO Pr (q) dµ,
-Da E L2 (IR),
s atisfies
(2.14)
l
1
Here ao E I[8 is fixed and does not enter (2.14). Indeed, in our case (ba = X(ao,A) - the characteristic function of the interval (Ao, A) - so that II IDa+o-
4aII2=o.
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
88
For a pure state M = P1,, 11011 = 1, the corresponding probability measure pQ on II8 is given by
/Q(E) = vO(E) = JE IO(q)I2dq,
E E -4(R).
Physically, this is interpreted that in the state P,,, with the "wave function"
'(q), the probability of finding a quantum particle between q and q + dq is Iz0(q)I2dq. In other words, the modulus square of a wave function is the probability distribution for the coordinate of a quantum particle. The corresponding momentum operator P is given by a differential operator
hd
i dq
with D(P) = W1,2 (R) - the Sobolev space of absolutely continuous functions f on R such that f and its derivative f' (defined a.e.) are in L2(IR). The operator P is self-adjoint and it is straightforward to verify that on D = CC(l[8), the space of smooth functions on R with compact support,
QP - PQ=intl. Remark. The operator P on .° has no eigenvectors - the eigenvalue equation
Pcp=p(p, pEl[8, has a solution
cp(q) = const x eh' which does not belong to L2 (R). We will see later that the family of normalized eigenfunctions of the continuous spectrum 1
=pq
combines to a Schwartz kernel of the inverse h-dependent Fourier transform
operator, which diagonalizes the momentum operator P. In the distributional sense, f00
op(q)Wp,(q)dq = 6(p
- p').
Remark. As for the case of the coordinate operator, the normalization of the eigenfunctions of the continuous spectrum cpp(q) of the momentum operator can be determined from the condition (2.14). Indeed,
p(q) =
fPcekdk o
so that 4(bp+o (q)
=
\ (e*'' - e*Th1) i
/l
Aq ehi (p+ 1 o)9 sin - -Dp (q) = 2ch q 2h 2
2. Quantization
89
Using the elementary integral, we obtain 0II(Dr+o(q)
so that c =
-
-(Pp(q) 112
=
2c2h ccf
sin q q2
dq = 27rc2h,
1
Proposition 2.1. The coordinate representation defines an irreducible, unitary, integrable representation of the Heisenberg algebra.
Proof. To show that the coordinate representation is integrable, let U(u) = e-iup and V (v) = e-ivQ be the corresponding one-parameter groups of unitary operators. Clearly, (V(v)cp)&(q) = e-ivgcp(q) and it easily follows from the Stone theorem (or by the definition of a derivative) that (U(u)cp)(q) = cp(q - hu), so that unitary operators U(u) and V (v) satisfy the Weyl relation (2.11). Such a realization of the Weyl relation is called the Schrodinger representation.
To prove that the coordinate representation is irreducible, let B be a bounded operator commuting with P and Q. By Lemma 2.2, T = f (Q) for some f E L°°(R). Now commutativity between T and P implies that
TU(u) = U(u)T for all u which is equivalent to f (q - hu) = f (q) for all q, u E R, so that f = const a.e. on R.
To summarize, the coordinate representation is characterized by the property that the coordinate operator Q is a multiplication by q operator and the momentum operator P is a differentiation operator,
Q=q and P= hd i dq Similarly, momentum representation is defined by the property that the momentum operator P is a multiplication by p operator. Namely let .) = L2(R, dp) be the Hilbert L2-space on the "momentum space" R with the coordinate p, which is a Lagrangian subspace of R2 defined by the equation q = 0. The coordinate and momentum operators are given by
ihd and P=p, p
and satisfy the Heisenberg commutation relation. As the coordinate representation, the momentum representation is an irreducible, unitary, integrable representation of the Heisenberg algebra. In the momentum representation,
the modulus square of the wave function '(p) of a pure state M = P101
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
90
JIV511 = 1, is the probability distribution for the momentum of the quantum particle, i.e., the probability that a quantum particle has momentum between p and p + dp is 1,0 (p) I2dp. Let -Q'h : L' (R) ---> L2 (1E8) be the h-dependent Fourier transform operator,
defined by
O(p) =
727h
fe
*Pgco(q)dq
00 = lim,,,_ Here the integral is understood as the limit cp
cp,,, in the strong
topology on L2 (I[8), where 0 "( p ) =
1
27rfit
J
e-fiP'co(q)dq n
By Plancherel's theorem, 9%' is a unitary operator on L2(1[8), 'Vhlo%h =
I,
and
Q=.FhQJFW1, so that coordinate and momentum representations are unitarily equivalent. In particular, since the operator P is obviously self-adjoint, this immediately shows that the operator P is self-adjoint. For n degrees of freedom, the coordinate representation is defined by setting = L2(R , dq), where d'q = dql .. dq' is the Lebesgue measure
on R', and Q=q=(4,...,g
),
h a = (h a P=iaq
ha)
ia--,...,iagn
.
Here 1I8n is the configuration space with coordinates q - a Lagrangian subspace of R2" defined by the equations p = 0. The coordinate and momenta operators are self-adjoint and satisfy Heisenberg commutation relations. Projection-valued measures for the operators Qk are given by (Pk(E)W)(q) = Xakl(El(q)W (q),
where E E M(R) and'\k : ]I8n --+ 1[8 is a canonical projection onto the k-th component, k = 1,. .. , n. Correspondingly, the projection-valued measure P for the commutative family Q = (Q1, ... , Qn) (see Proposition 1.3) is defined on the Borel subsets E C 1[8n by (P(E)cp)(q) = XE(q)W(q)The family Q has absolutely continuous joint spectrum IRn. Coordinate operators Q1,. .. , Qn form a complete system of commuting
observables. This means, by definition, that none of these operators is a function of the other operators, and that every bounded operator commuting with Q1, ... , Qn is a function of Q1, ... , Qn, i.e., is a multiplication by f (q)
2. Quantization
91
operator for some f E L°°(W ). The proof repeats verbatim the proof of Lemma 2.2. For a pure state M = P.,, 11011 = 1, the modulus square IV)(q) 1 2 of the wave function is the density of a joint distribution function µQ for the
commutative family Q, i.e., the probability of finding a quantum particle in a Borel subset E C Rn is given by
pQ(E) = E The coordinate representation defines an irreducible, unitary, integrable representation of the Heisenberg algebra C I. Indeed, n-parameter groups of unitary operators U(u) = e-iup and V (v) = e-"Q are given by I')(q)12d"q.
(U(u)W)(q) = cp(q - hu),
(V (v)W)(q) =
and satisfy Weyl relations (2.11). The same argument as in the proof of Proposition 2.1 shows that this representation of the Heisenberg group H,,, called the Schrodinger representation for n degrees of freedom, is irreducible.
= L2(W , dnp), where dnp =
In the momentum representation, dpl
. dpi, is the Lebesgue measure on IRn, and
a
i h ap
=
(
'9pi
ih-,...,ih---apn
P =p =
,
j
(pi,...,pn)
Here Rn is the momentum space with coordinates p - a Lagrangian subspace of R2n defined by the equations q = 0. The coordinate and momentum representations are unitarily equivalent by the Fourier transform. As in the case n = 1, the Fourier transform L2 (Rn) -p L2 (W) is a unitary operator defined by O(p)
=(2-7rh)-n/2
= 351h(co)(p)
=N
f
e-*Pqco(q)dnq n
m(27rh)-n/2
f
e-
q,
q l
where the limit is understood in the strong topology on L2(Rn). As in the case n = 1, we have Qk = -qnQk9h 1,
Pk = 9hPk9h 1,
k - 1, ... , n.
In particular, since operators P1, ... , Pn are obviously self-adjoint, this immediately shows that P1i . , Pn are also self-adjoint. .
.
by a ket vector Remark. Following Dirac, physicists denote a vector E Je is a complex antiI0, a vector cp E 3l2* in the dual space to * ( linear isomorphism) by a bra vector (WI, and their inner product by (W10). In standard mathematics notation, (0, W) _ (W 10)
and
(AO, p) _ (API A10),
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
92
where A is a linear operator. From a physics point of view, Dirac's notation is intuitive and convenient for working with coordinate and momentum representations. Denoting by Iq) = 5(q-q') and Ip) = (2irh)-n/2e*1I the set of generalized common eigenfunctions for the operators Q and P, respectively, we formally get QIq) = q1q), Plp) = pip), where operators Q act on q', and
(qlV)) = f n8(q - q') V) (9 (27th)-n/2
(pl'b) =
)dq' _
(q),
fRn e-fil (q)dq = 'gy(p),
as well as (qlq') = 8(q - q'), (plp') = b(p - p'). Though in our exposition
we are not using Dirac's notation, these formulas would help the interested reader "translate" the notation used in physics textbooks to standard mathematics notation. Remark. We will show in Section 3.2 that every Lagrangian subspace of the symplectic vector space 1R2n with the canonical symplectic form w = dp A dq gives rise to an integrable, unitary, irreducible representation of the Heisenberg algebra 1)rj. This is the simplest example of the real polarization, which for a given symplectic manifold (.ill, w) is defined as an integrable distriof Lagrangian subspaces Y of tangent spaces T 4'. The bution notion of a polarization plays a fundamental role in geometric quantization:
it allows us to construct (under certain conditions) the Hilbert space of In the linear states associated with the classical phase space case .ill = 1[82n every Lagrangian subspace 2 in 1[82n gives rise to a real polarization by using the identification TXIR2n - R2n. In particular, for the coordinate representation, 2 is given by the equation q = 0, and for the
momentum representation - by the equation p = 0. The corresponding Hilbert -he space consists of functions on R2n which are constant along the fibers of the polarization. Problem 2.4. Give an example of a non-integrable representation of the Heisenberg algebra.
Problem 2.5. Prove that there exists cp E J-Y = L2 (IR, dq) such that the vectors P(E)cp, E E _4(R), where P is a projection-valued measure for the coordinate operator Q, are dense in
.
Problem 2.6. Find the generating operator for the commutative family Q = (Q1
Qn). Does it have a physical interpretation?
Problem 2.7. Find the projection-valued measure for the commutative family P = (P1, ... , P") in the coordinate representation.
2. Quantization
93
2.3. Free quantum particle. A free classical particle with one degree of freedom is described by the phase space R2 with coordinates p, q and the Poisson bracket (2.1), and by the Hamiltonian function 2
(2.15)
Hc (p, q)
= 2m The Hamiltonian operator of a free quantum particle with one degree of freedom is P2
H°=2m, and in coordinate representation is given by h2 d2 H0
2m dq2
It is a self-adjoint operator on dF = L2(R, dq) with D(Ho) = W2,2(R) the Sobolev space of functions in L2(IR), whose generalized first and second derivatives are in L2(1I ). The operator Ho is positive with absolutely continuous spectrum [0, CO) of multiplicity two. Indeed, let Sjo = L2 (R>o, C2; da) be the Hilbert space of C2-valued measurable functions T on the semi-line IR>o = (0, oo), which are square-integrable with respect to the measure do, (A) = V 2A dA, S70 = {w(A)
= (01(A))
:11`1'112
= f (Ik1(A)I2 + 102(A)12)da(A) < oo
It follows from the unitarity of the Fourier transform that the operator Gllo:L2(IEB,dq)->bo, 2mA) do( )(A)_`F(A)_ ( z (-( 2mA) )
is unitary, OZ/o OZ/o = I and OZ/OOlo = Io, where I and Io are, respectively,
identity operators in J e and Sjo. The operator 4/0 establishes the isomorphism L2 (IEB, dq) _- Sjo, and since in the momentum representation H° is a multiplication by 2-1mp2 operator, the operator 910H0IZIo 1 is a multiplication by A operator in Sjo.
Remark. The Hamiltonian operator Ho has no eigenvectors - the eigenvalue equation
Hob=AO has no solutions in L2 (R). However, for every A = 2L k2 > 0 this differential equation has two linear independent bounded solutions k
e±R kq
k > 0.
In the distributional sense, these eigenfunctions of the continuous spectrum combine to a Schwartz kernel of the unitary operator OZ/0, which establishes
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
94
the isomorphism between .3° = L2 (IR, dq) and the Hilbert space Sjo, where Ho acts as a multiplication by A operator. The normalization of the eigenfunctions of the continuous spectrum is also determined by the condition (2.14):
0
lim
1
J,
JiM 1,
A-0
q, k+A -
0
k-)) -01
k where A'kk)(q) = fko
The Cauchy problem for the Schrodinger equation for a free particle,
ihd
(2.16)
V)(0) = 0, dtt) HoO(t), is easily solved by the Fourier transform. Indeed, in the momentum representation it takes the form ine
a( p, t) =
p2
2mV (p, t),
at
0(p, 0) = 0(p),
so that t) = e gy(p) In the coordinate representation, the solution of (2.16) is given by (2.17)
''(q, t) =
1
2,rrx
J
t)dp =
1
27rh
J
where
X(p,q,t)
p2 pq =- 2m + t
Formula (2.17) describes the motion of a quantum particle, and admits the following physical interpretation. Let initial condition '0 in (2.16) be such that its Fourier transform O = .Fh(o) is a smooth function supported in a neighborhood Uo of po E I[8 \ {0}, 0 V Uo, and
f
1. 00
Such states are called "wave packets". Then for every compact subset E C IR we have (2.18)
Since
lim
f
Jtj-oo E
IV) (q, t)I2dq = 0.
00
f I')(q,t)12dq=1 for all t, it follows from (2.18) that the particle leaves every compact subset of IR as Itl --> oo and the quantum motion is infinite. To prove (2.18), observe
that the function X(p, q, t) - the "phase" in integral representation (2.17)
2. Quantization
95
> C > 0 for all p E Uo, q E E and large
has the property that
enough ItI. Integrating by parts we get
'(q,t) =
1
I
ehx(P,q,t)t.(p)dp
27rt 1 ,
o
/f a
it / 27r
Uo
gy(p)
efix(p,e,t)tdp,
ax P,q,t
8p
ap
so that uniformly on E, ''l'(q, t) = O(Itl-1)
as
Itl -+ oo.
By repeated integration by parts, we obtain that for every n E N, uniformly on E, '
(q, t) = O(I tl -n),
so that '(q,t) = O(ItI-O°). To describe the motion of a free quantum particle in unbounded regions,
we use the stationary phase method. In its simplest form it is stated as follows.
The Method of Stationary Phase. Let f,g E C°°(IR), where f is realvalued and g has compact support, and suppose that f has a single nondegenerate critical point xo, i.e., f'(xo) = 0 and f"(xo) j4 0. Then
2
eiNf(x)g(x)dx
FOO
l
2
Nf(x0)+ 4
O
1\Njf"(xo)1
N
asN -+oo. Applying the stationary phase method to the integral representation (2.17) (and setting N = t), we find that the critical point of X(p, q, t) is PO = M1 with X"(po) = -,1-,.,,
0, and
q2 j
(q, t) = r!t (m e
+ O(t-1)
=')o(q,t)+O(t-1)
as
t---,oo.
a domain where the probability of finding a particle is asymptotically different from zero. At large t the points in this domain move with constant velocities v = k, p c Uo. In this sense, the classical relation p = my remains valid in the quantum picture. Moreover, the asymptotic wave function z'o satisfies Thus as t --+ oo, the wave function V) (q, t) is supported on
/'
t)I2dq =
" ()2dq = 1,
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
96
and, therefore, describes the asymptotic probability distribution. Similarly, setting N = -It1, we can describe the behavior of the wave function 0(q, t)
ast --> -oo. Remark. We have limjtj_oo 0(t) = 0 in the weak topology on 3V. Indeed, ° we get by Parseval's identity for the Fourier integrals,
for every co E
(
f
(t), ) =
&2 7t
oo
dp, cc
and the integral goes to zero as tI --+ oo by the Riemann-Lebesgue lemma.
A free classical particle with n degrees of freedom is described by the phase space R2n with coordinates p = (p1, ... , pn) and q = (ql, ... , qn), the Poisson bracket (2.3), and the Hamiltonian function Hc(p, q) = p2 2m
= 1 (pI2 + ... + pn). 2 2m
The Hamiltonian operator of a free quantum particle with n degrees of freedom is
p2 H°
1
2
2m(P1
2m
2 +...+Pn),
and in the coordinate representation is
where
A __ -
( , ) 2 + ... +
2
( 11 )
-
(, aqn
2
)
is the Laplace operator15 in the Cartesian coordinates on W'. The Hamiltonian Ho is a self-adjoint operator on A° = L2(W1, dnq) with D(Ho) _ W2'2(Rn) - the Sobolev space on R n. In the momentum representation, 2
Ho
2m
- a multiplication by a function operator on 3C° = L2(Rn, dnp). The operator Ho is positive with absolutely continuous spectrum [0, oo) of infinite multiplicity. Namely, let Sn-1 = In E Rn : n2 = 1} be the (n-1)dimensional unit sphere in W , let do be the measure on Sn-1 induced by the Lebesgue measure on 1[8n, and let
If :Sn-1-+ C
:
IIfII
_In_1If(n)I2dn
15It is the negative of the Laplace-Beltrami operator of the standard Euclidean metric on Rn.
2. Quantization
97
Let s')on) = L2(IR>o, 4; dan) be the Hilbert space of 1)-valued measurable
functions16 ' on R>o = (0, oo), square-integrable on R>o with respect to the measure dan(A) = (2mA) 2 2a, 1j0(n)
= {w
II,QII2
: IEB>o
dan(,\) < oo}
=
When n = 1, fjo1) = Sjo - the corresponding Hilbert space for one degree of freedom. The operator 0&0 : L2(IEBn, dnq) --+ Sjon),
%(O)(A) ='y(A),
IF(A)(n) = ( 2mAn),
is unitary and establishes the isomorphism L2(IIBn, dnq) - .fjon). In the momentum representation Ho is a multiplication by 2,m p2 operator, so that the operator G1loH0OIlo 1 is a multiplication by A operator in Sjon)
Remark. As in the case n = 1, the Hamiltonian operator Ho has no eigenvectors - the eigenvalue equation
Ho' =AO has no solutions in L2(li n). However, for every A > 0 this differential equation has infinitely many linearly independent bounded solutions efi 2rnAnq ,
(q) = (27rh)
parametrized by the unit sphere Sn-1. These solutions do not belong to L2(IIBn), but in the distributional sense they combine to a Schwartz kernel of the unitary operator °Ilo, which establishes the isomorphism between .3 ° = L2(l[8n, dnq) and the Hilbert space ion), where Ho acts as a multiplication by A operator.
As in the case n = 1, the Schrodinger equation for free particle, i ,d
HoO(t), dtt) is solved by the Fourier transform
(q, t) _
(2-7rh)-n/2
0(0) _ 0,
f eR (Pnn
For a wave packet, an initial condition 0 such that its Fourier transform _ gr,( ) is a smooth function supported on a neighborhood Uo of po E Rn \ {0} such that 0 Uo and fRn
I Yi(p) I2dnp = 1,
16That is, for every f E h the function (f, W) is measurable on 1R>o.
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
98
the quantum particle leaves every compact subset of R' and the motion is infinite. Asymptotically as ItI --p oo, the wave function &(q, t) is different from 0 only when q = Rt, P E Uo. Problem 2.8. Find the asymptotic wave function for a free quantum particle with n degrees of freedom.
2.4. Examples of quantum systems. Here we describe quantum systems that correspond to the classical Lagrangian systems introduced in Section 1.3 of Chapter 1. In Hamiltonian formulation, the phase space of these systems, except for the last example, is a symplectic vector space 1182n with canonical coordinates p, q and symplectic form w = dp A dq.
Example 2.1 (Newtonian particle). According to Section 1.7 in Chapter 1, a classical particle in Rn moving in a potential field V (q) is described by the Hamiltonian function 2
Hc(p,q)=
m+V(q)
Assume that the Hamiltonian operator for the quantum system is given by 2
H=2m+V, with some operator V, so that coordinate and momenta operators satisfy Heisenberg equations of motion (2.19)
P = {H, P}n,, Q = {H, Q},.
To determine V, we require that the classical relation q = E between the
m velocity and the momentum of a particle is preserved under the quantization, i.e.,
Q_P M
Since {P2, Q}h, = 2P, it follows from (2.19) that this condition is equivalent to
[V, Qk] = 0,
k = 1, ... , n.
It follows from Section 2.2 that V is a function of commuting operators
Ql,...
, Qom,, and the natural choice17 is V = V (Q). Thus the Hamiltonian operator of a Newtonian particle is
H
_ P2
2m + V (Q),
17Confirmed by the agreement of the theory with the experiments.
2. Quantization
99
in agreement with H = HC(P, Q)18. In coordinate representation the Hamiltonian is the Schrodinger operator 2
(2.20)
H = --A + V(q)
with the real-valued potential V (q).
Remark. The sum of two unbounded, self-adjoint operators is not necessarily self-adjoint, and one needs to describe admissible potentials V(q) for which H is a self-adjoint operator on L2(Rn, dnq). If the potential V(q) is a real-valued, locally integrable function on R', then the differential operator (2.20) defines a symmetric operator H with the domain Cp (Rn) - twice continuously differentiable functions on 1EBn with compact support. Potentials for which the symmetric operator H has no self-adjoint extensions are obviously non-physical. It may also happen that H has several self-adjoint extensions19. These extensions are specified by some boundary conditions at infinity and there are no physical principles distinguishing between them. The only physical case is when the symmetric operator H admits a unique self-adjoint extension, that is, when H is essentially self-adjoint. In Chapter 3 we present necessary conditions for the essential self-adjointness. Here we only mention the von Neumann criterion that if A is a closed operator and D(A) = °, then H = A*A is a positive self-adjoint operator.
Example 2.2 (Interacting quantum particles). In Lagrangian formalism, a closed classical system of N interacting particles on 1R3 was described in Example 1.2 in Section 1.3 of Chapter 1. In Hamiltonian formalism, it is described by the canonical coordinates r = (ri,... , TN), the canonical momenta p = (pi, ... , PN), Ta,, pa E 1R3, and by the Hamiltonian function (2.21)
2a +V(T),
Hc(p,T) =
a
a=1
where ma is the mass of the a-th particle, a = 1, ... , N (see Section 1.7 in Chapter 1). The corresponding Hamiltonian operator H in the coordinate representation has the form N (2.22)
H=
2
- E Zm Da + V(T). a=1
a
In particular, when
V(Ta -Tb),
V(T) = 1
181n the special case H,(p, q) = f (p) + g(q) the problem of the ordering of non-commuting operators P and Q does not arise. 19This is the case when the defect indices of H are equal and are non-zero.
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
100
the Schrodinger operator (2.22) describes the N-body problem in quantum mechanics. The fundamental quantum system is the complex atom, formed by a nucleus of charge Ne and mass M, and by N electrons of charge -e and mass m. Denoting by R E R3 the position of the nucleus, and by r1, . , rN the positions of the electrons and assuming that the interaction is given by the Coulomb attraction, we get for the Hamiltonian function (2.21) . .
N P'2
P2 2M
a=1
Net
N
2m
FR
a=1
e2
ral
1
where P is the canonical momentum of the nucleus. The corresponding Schrodinger operator H in the coordinate representation has the form20
H= -- A2
2M
N
N
2
2m
-
a-E
Ne 2
+
e2
IR - ral 1
a=1
consists of a single proton21, the Hamiltonian is h2
h2
e2
H 2MAp 2mAe lrp - r el' where rp is the position of the proton and re is the position of the electron. As the first approximation, the proton can be considered as infinitely heavy, so that the hydrogen atom is described by an electron in an attrac-
tive Coulomb field -e2/Irl, where now r = re - rp. The corresponding Hamiltonian operator takes the form e2
h2
H = -ZA - Irl.
(2.23)
We will solve the Schrodinger equation with this Hamiltonian H and determine its energy levels in Section 5.1 of Chapter 3.
Example 2.3 (Charged particle in an electromagnetic field). A classical particle of charge e and mass m moving in the time-independent electromagnetic field with scalar and vector potentials W(r) and A(r), r E ]R3, is described by the Hamiltonian function Hc(p, r)
2m p
e
l
cAl +
(see Problem 1.27 in Section 1.7 of Chapter 1). The corresponding classical velocity vector v = {HH, r} is given by e v=p--A, c 20Ignoring the fact that electron has spin, see Chapter 4. 21In the case of hydrogen-1 or protium; it includes one or more neutrons for deuterium, tritium, and other isotopes.
2. Quantization
101
and its components v = (v1, V2, v3) have non-vanishing Poisson brackets: {v1, v2}
_ -m2cB3,
{v2, v3}
_ -m2CB1,
{v3, v1} _ -m2cB2,
where B = (B17 B2, B3) are components of the magnetic field B = curl A. The Hamiltonian operator of a quantum particle is
H=
(2.24)
2m
(P eA)
2
+ ecp(r)
- the Schrodinger operator of a charged particle in an electromagnetic field. The corresponding quantum velocity vector V = {H, Q}h, is given by the same formula as in the classical case,
V=P-eA, c and its components V = (VI, V2, V3) have non-vanishing quantum brackets: {Vi, V2}h
-4-B3,
{V2, V3}n _ -m2cB1,
{V3,
V1},_ -mzcB2
Thus in the presence of a magnetic field the three components of a quantum velocity operator no longer commute and cannot be measured simultaneously.
Example 2.4 (Free quantum particle on a Riemannian manifold). The phase space of a classical particle of mass m = 1 moving on a Riemannian manifold (M, g) is the cotangent bundle T*M, and the corresponding Hamiltonian function is given by Hr (p, x)
2g"' (x)p,p,, where gµv(x) is the inverse of the metric tensor 9,,(x), and 1
n)
are standard coordinates on T*M (see Section 1.7 of Chapter 1). The Hilbert
space of the quantum system is 3° = L2(M, dµ), where dp = g(x)dnx, g(x) = det(g,,v(x)), is the measure associated with the density of the Riemannian metric (Riemannian volume form if M is oriented). When canonical coordinates (p, x) are only locally defined on T*M, it is not possible to con-
struct corresponding operators P and Q. Still, one can always define the Hamiltonian operator by 2
(2.25)
H=
O9,
where Ag = -
(V'')
x aµ is the Laplace-Beltrami operator of the Riemannian metric g on M. Note that in this case there is a non-trivial problem of the ordering of noncommuting operators in the quantization of Hc(p, x), which arises if in a 1
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
102
coordinate chart on M one replaces canonical coordinates p and x by P and Q. The formula O9
-gµv*axaaxv
shows that local expressions defined by (2.26)
Hc(P, Q) = z (gµv(Q)P,Pu + ingµ°(Q)F
(Q) Pv)
combine to a well-defined self-adjoint operator H on ° given by (2.25). Thus even when M = 1<8n and canonical coordinates (p, x) are globally defined on T* R', the correct formula for He (P, Q) - the one which extends to general Riemannian manifolds - is given by (2.26), where the second term represents the "quantum correction" to the naive expression gAv(Q)P,PP.
2.5. Old quantum mechanics. The formulation of quantum mechanics presented here goes back to 1925-1927, and is due to Heisenberg, Schrodinger, Born, Jordan, and Dirac. It replaced the old quantum theory, proposed in 1913 by Bohr, which was based on Rutherford's planetary model of the atom. In the old theory, the energy levels of a one-dimensional quantum system correspond to the closed orbits of the associated classical Hamiltonian system which satisfy the Bohr- Wilson-Sommerfeld quantization rule (BWS rule)
i pdq = 27rh(n + 2 ), where n is a non-negative integer, and integration goes over the closed orbit in the phase space 1182. Bohr-Wilson-Sommerfeld quantization rules also apply to completely integrable Hamiltonian systems with several degrees of freedom (see Section 2.6 of Chapter 1). Namely, let F1 = H..... FN be N independent integrals of motion in involution. The BWS quantization rules are
i pdq = 2rrh(n.y + 4 ind ry),
where integration goes over all 1-cycles -y in the Lagrangian submanifold E,F2(p,q) = E2,...,FN(p,q) = EN}, A = {(p,q) E 1182' : and ind -y E Z is the so-called Maslov index of a cycle 'y in A. In the onedimensional case the closed orbit is topologically a circle and its Maslov index is 2. It will be shown in Section 6.3 of Chapter 3 that, in general, BohrWilson-Sommerfeld quantization rules only give asymptotics of the energy levels as h -> 0. However, for integrable systems with extra symmetry, such as the harmonic oscillator and the Kepler problem, the BWS quantization rules determine the energy levels exactly. We will show this in the next section for the harmonic oscillator, and in Section 5.1 of Chapter 3 - for the Kepler problem.
2. Quantization
103
2.6. Harmonic oscillator. The simplest classical system with one degree of freedom, besides the free particle, is the harmonic oscillator. It is described by the phase space 1[82 with the canonical coordinates p, q, and the Hamiltonian function mw2g2
p2
(2.27)
Hc(p, q) = 2m + 2 (see Sections 1.5 and 1.7 in Chapter 1). Hamilton's equations
p=
p} = -mw2q,
q = {Hc, q} = m
with the initial conditions po, qo are readily solved, (2.28)
p(t) = po cos wt - mwgo sin wt,
(2.29)
q(t) = qo coswt +
1 mw
po sin wt,
and describe the harmonic motion. As in Section 2.6 of Chapter 1, it is convenient to introduce complex coordinates on the phase space on IE82 - C, (2.30)
Z=
1
2w
(wq + ip)
1
z=
,
2w
(wq - ip) .
We have (2.31)
{ z,
.
Hc(z, z) = mwIz12,
}=---,
so that Hamilton's equations decouple,
z = {H, z} _ -iwz,
z = {H z} = iwz,
and are trivially solved, ei`''tzo.
z(t) = e-iwtzo,
(2.32)
Here
zo =
1
2w (wqo + ipo)
1
zo =
,
ipo) 2w (wqo -
For the quantum system, the corresponding Hamiltonian operator is
H
_
P2 mw2Q2 2 2m +
and in the coordinate representation operator with a quadratic potential, h2 d2 H
.
= L2 (d8, dq) it is a Schrodinger mw2g2
+ 2 The quantum harmonic oscillator is the simplest non-trivial quantum sys2m dq2
tem, besides the free particle, whose Schrodinger equation can be solved explicitly. It appears in all problems involving quantized oscillations, namely in molecular and crystalline vibrations. The exact solution of the harmonic
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
104
oscillator, described below, has remarkable22 algebraic and analytic properties. Temporarily set m = 1 and consider the operators 1
a=
(2.33)
2wx (wQ +
iP), a* =
2wlx (wQ - iP) ,
which are quantum analogs of complex coordinates (2.30). The operators a and a* are defined on W1"2(R) n W1>2(R), where W1°2(R) = g(W1'2(1[8)),
and it is easy to show that a* is the adjoint operator to a and a** = a, so that a is a closed operator. From the Heisenberg commutation relation (2.2) we get the canonical commutation relation [a, a*] = I
(2.34)
on W2'2(R) n
W-2,2
as*
=
(I[8). Indeed,
P2 +W 2Q2 2wh
+
P2 + w2Q2 iw [P' Q] = 2wh 2wh
1
+ 2I,
and
a*a
P2 + w2Q2 2wh
P2 + w2Q2 iw [P ' Q] = 2wh 2wh
1
2,I
so that (2.34) holds on W2,2 (R) n W2,2(R), where W2,2(IR) = F (W2,2(R)), and
H = wh (a*a + 2I) = wh (aa* - 2I) . In particular, it follows from the von Neumann criterion that the Hamiltonian operator H is self-adjoint. The operators a, a* and N = a*a satisfy the commutation relations (2.35)
[N, a] = -a,
[N, a*] = a*,
[a, a*] = I.
These commutation relations correspond to the irreducible unitary representation of a four-dimensional solvable Lie algebra Cl associated with the Heisenberg algebra 1) = C 1, introduced in Section 2.1. Namely, fl is a Lie algebra with the generators e, f, h, and c, where e, f, c satisfy the relations of the Heisenberg algebra C , and [h, e] = - f ,
[h, f ] = w2 e,
[h, c] = 0.
The irreducible integrable representation p of the Heisenberg algebra 1) (see (2.9) in Section 2.1) extends to a unitary representation of the Lie algebra 22The algebraic structure of the exact solution of the harmonic oscillator plays a fundamental role in quantum electrodynamics and in quantum field theory in general.
2. Quantization
105
I by setting
P(h) = -iwN =
2Q2
P2
+
2
Z
I.
Remark. In invariant terms, the Lie algebra 6 is a one-dimensional right extension of the Heisenberg algebra Cl,
R->0. a derivation
It is defined by the Cl-valued Lie algebra 1-cocycle r E Zl of 1), given on generators by
r(e) = f,
r(f) = -wee, r(c) = 0.
Explicitly, if h E 6 is such that h = 1 E R under the projection Cl -+ R, then Cl, we identifying elements in Cl with their images under the embedding Cl have
[x + ah, y + Oh] = [x, y] - ar(y) + ,Qr(y),
x, y E 11.
It is due to this Lie-algebraic structure of commutation relations (2.35) that Heisenberg equations of motion for the harmonic oscillator can be solved exactly. Namely, we have
it = {H, a}h, = -iwa,
so that
a(t) = e-zwtao,
a* = {H, a*}fi, = iwa*,
a*(t) = eiwta*
Comparing with (2.32) we see that solutions of classical and quantum equations of motion for the harmonic oscillator have the same form!
Next, using commutation relations (2.35) and positivity of the operator N, we will solve the eigenvalue problem for the Hamiltonian H of the harmonic oscillator explicitly by finding its energy levels and corresponding eigenvectors. We will prove that the eigenvectors form a complete system
of vectors in, so that the spectrum of the Hamiltonian H is the point spectrum. This is a quantum mechanical analog of the fact that classical motion of the harmonic oscillator is always finite.
The algebraic part of the exact solution is the following fundamental result.
Proposition 2.2. Suppose that there exists a non-zero 0 E D(an)fD((a*)"), n = 1, 2, ... , such that
HV=A
.
Then the following statements hold.
(i) There exists ''o E Y, Ik'oII = 1, such that HV)o = 2hw'o.
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
106
(ii) The vectors On = (any Oo E A9,
n = 0,1, 2, ... ,
are orthonormal eigenvectors for H with the eigenvalues hw(n+2),
Hzbn=hw(n+2)0n. (iii) Restriction of the operator H to the Hilbert space A 'o - a closed subspace of -if, spanned by the orthonormal set {On}°O o - is essentially self-adjoint.
Proof. Rewriting commutation relations (2.35) as
Na = a(N - I) and Na* = a*(N + I), and putting A = hw (µ + 2) , we get for all n > 0,
Nanz/) = (p - n)an0 and N(a*)no = (p + n)(a*)no. Since N > _ 0 on D(N), it follows from the first equation in (2.36) that there /, = 0. Setting ibo = ano exists no > 0 such that an0' 0 but an0+1Y' (2.36)
Ilan°
we get (2.37)
Since H = hw(N +
II
a0o = 0 and Noo = 0. this proves part (i). To prove part (ii), we use 2I),
commutation relations (2.38)
[a, (a*)n] =
n(a*)n-1,
which follow from (2.34) and the Leibniz rule. Using//''(2.37)-(2.38), we get
a*On = n + 1 ,bn+1 ,
(2.39)
aOn = Vn On-1,
so that IIknII2
=
VIn
(a*On-1, On) =
1 (On-1,a' n) = IIVn-1112 = ... = IIbolI2 =1.
From the second equation in (2.36) it follows that NOn = nOn, so 0n are normalized eigenvectors of H with the eigenvalues hw(n+ The eigenvectors On are orthogonal since the corresponding eigenvalues are distinct and the operator H is symmetric. Finally, part (iii) immediately follows from the 2).
fact that, according to part (ii), the subspaces Im (H + iI) Imo are dense in _0, which is the criterion of essential self-ad ointness. El Remark. Since the coordinate representation of the Heisenberg commutation relations is irreducible, it is tempting to conclude, using Proposition 2.2, that A'o =. Namely, it follows from the construction that the linear span of vectors On - a dense subspace of A'O - is invariant for the operators P and Q. However, this does not immediately imply that the projection
2. Quantization
107
operator 110 onto the subspace dY0 commutes with self-adjoint operators P and Q in the sense of the definition in Section 1.1. Using the coordinate representation, we can immediately show the exis-
tence of the vector ')o in Proposition 2.2, and prove that . = °. Indeed, equation aV)0 = 0 becomes a first order linear differential equation (hdq+wql V0=0,
so that
w _92
4
Vo(q)
e
and IIbo112
=
V
7rh
f
00
e W92dq
= 1.
The vector V)o is called the ground state for the harmonic oscillator. Correspondingly, the eigenfunctions
=(1L (wq -2whdg
n(q)=
11
are of the form P(q)e, where 42 Pn(q) are polynomials of degree n. The following result guarantees that the functions {V)n}°O_o form an orthonormal basis in L2(R, dq). gne_g2,
Lemma 2.3. The functions
n = 0, 1, 2, ... , are complete in L2 (IR, dq).
Proof. Let f c L2 (R, dq) is such that
I-: f (q)gne-42dq = 0,
n = 0, 1, 2, ... .
The integral
F(z) =
f
f 00
(q)e,q,-42dq
is absolutely convergent for all z E C and, therefore, defines an entire function. We have F(n) (0) = in
f
00 00
f
(q)gne-42dq
= 0,
n = 0, 1, 2, ... , (q)e-42
so that F(z) = 0 for all z E C. This implies the function g(q) = f E L1(IR) nL2(IR) satisfies .F (g) = 0, where is the "ordinary" (h = 1) Fourier transform. Thus we conclude that g = 0.
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
108
The polynomials Pn are expressed through classical Hermite-Tchebyscheff polynomials Hn, defined by dn a-q2 dqn
HH,(q) = (-1)'e42
n=0,1,2,....
Namely, using the identity e2
-(
dgna-e2
[,-e2
dqd
Q11a-92I n
q -
q2
d
_ (-1)n q - dq we obtain ,,/'
1
Wn (q) rowwr_l
2nnf
e
W 92 - 2W
Hn
e
2
(q).
We summarize the obtained results as follows.
Theorem 2.1. The Hamiltonian H
_
h2 d2
mw2g2
+ 2 of the quantum harmonic oscillator with one degree of freedom is a selfadjoint operator on d° = L2(IR, dq) with the domain D(H) = W2,2([8) n 2m dq2
W2'2(R). The operator H has pure point spectrum n = 0, 1, 2, ... ,
IIZ/Jn = AnOn,
with the eigenvalues An = hw(n+ Corresponding eigenfunctions Wn form an orthonormal basis for 3P and are given by 2).
(2.40)
'/' Y n (q) =
1
Fa7r
2nn!
e
q
2
mw 11
Hn (v1 h qJ
where Hn (q) are classical Hermite-Tchebyscheff polynomials.
Proof. Consider the operator H defined on the Schwartz space 9'(R) of rapidly decreasing functions. Since the operator H is symmetric and has a complete system of eigenvectors in Y(IR), the subspaces Im(H±iI) are dense
in -3'P, so that H is essentially self-adjoint. The proof that its self-adjoint closure (which we continue to denote by H) has the domain W2'2([8) n W2'2(R) is left to the reader.
Remark. The energy levels of the harmonic oscillator can be also obtained from the Bohr-Wilson-Sommerfeld quantization rule. Indeed, the corresponding classical orbit with the energy E is an ellipse in the phase plane
2. Quantization
109
given by the equations q(t) =A cos(wt+ a), p(t) = -mwAsin(wt+a), where E = 2mw2A2 (see Section 1.5 in Chapter 1). Thus pdq = J J dp A dq = irmwA2 =
27E, W
and the BWS quantization rule gives the energy levels En = hw(n + ). 2
Remark. Since the energy levels of the Hamiltonian H are equidistant by hw, the quantum harmonic oscillator describes the system of identical "quanta" with the energy hw. The ground state 10) = zbo, in Dirac's notation,
is the vacuum state with no quanta present and with the vacuum energy hw, and the states In) = V),,, consist of n quanta with the energy hw (n + 2) According to (2.39), the operator a* adds one quantum to the state In) and is called a creation operator, and the operator a destroys one quantum in the state In) and is called an annihilation operator. .
An example of the harmonic oscillator illustrates the dramatic difference between the motion in quantum mechanics and in classical mechanics. The
classical motion in the potential field V(q) = 2mw2g2 is finite: a particle with energy E moves in the region IwqI whereas there is always a non-zero probability of finding a quantum particle outside the classical m region. Thus for the ground state energy E = hw this probability is 2
IV)o(q)I2dq =
f
J
2
e-_2dx _ 0.1572992070.
1
The classical harmonic oscillator with n degrees of freedom is described by the phase space R2n with the canonical coordinates p, q, and the Hamiltonian function 2 n mW2 2
H,; (p,q)=2m+j
2i
j=1
where wl, ... , wn > 0 (see Sections 1.3 and 1.7 in Chapter 1).
The corresponding Hamiltonian operator is
H
_ 2m P2
n mw2 Q +E j=1
and in the coordinate representation 31° = L2(W , dnq) is a Schrodinger operator with quadratic potential, mwj H=-- L H> j 2
n
j=1
2 2
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
110
The Hamiltonian H is a self-adjoint operator with D(H) = W2'2(PI) n W2°2(118') and a pure point spectrum. The corresponding eigenfunctions Ybk(q) = 4'k, (q1) ... Vk (qn),
where k = (k1, ... , kn) and ' 'kj (qj) are eigenfunctions (2.40) with w = wj, form an orthonormal basis for L2(118', dnq). The corresponding energy levels are given by Ak = hwl (kl + 2) + . + hwn(k,, + 2)
The spectrum of H is simple if and only if hwl, ... , hwn are linearly independent over Z. The highest degeneracy case is w1 = = wn = w, when the multiplicity of the eigenvalue n
Ak=hWE(kj+z) j=1
is the partition function p(k) - the number of representations of the integer I k I = k1 + + kn as a sum of n non-negative integers. Setting m = 1 and introducing the operators23
(2.41) aj=
w
(wQj+iPj), aj*_
w
(wQj-iPj), j=1,...,n,
we get canonical commutation relations for creation and annihilation operators for n degrees of freedom, [aj, at ] = 0, [aj, of ] = 63iI, j, l = 1, ... , n, which generalize relation (2.34) for the one degree of freedom. The operators aj, a and Nj = aj* aj, j = 1, . . . , n, satisfy commutation relations (2.42)
[aj, at] = 0,
(2.43)
[Ni, at] = -bjtat,
j,1 = 1, ... , n.
[Ni, ai ] = 6jtat ,
In particular, the operator n
n
N=> Nj=1: a*aj j=1
j=1
satisfies
[N, aj] = -aj,
[N,
aj,
j = 1, ... , n,
and H=hw(N+ZI). Commutation relations (2.42) and (2.43) correspond to the irreducible unitary representation of the solvable Lie algebra In with 3n + 1 generators ej, fj, hj, and c, where ej, fj, c satisfy the relations in the Heisenberg algebra Cln, and
[hj, et] = -ajift,
[hj, ft] = ojtwl et,
[hj, c] = 0,
j, l = 1, ... , n.
23Here, using the standard Euclidean metric on Rn, we lowered the indices for Q-7.
2. Quantization
111
Problem 2.9. Show that (HIM) >
2hw for every M E .9, where H is the
Hamiltonian of the harmonic oscillator with one degree of freedom.
Problem 2.10. Let q(t) = Acos(wt + a) be the classical trajectory of the harmonic oscillator with m = 1 and the energy E = 2w2A2, and let µ,, be the probability measure on R supported at the point q(t). Show that the convex linear combination of the measures µ,,, 0 < a < 27r, is the probability measure on R with the distribution function µ(q) = e AZ-qa where O(q) is the Heavyside step 7r Az-qa function.
Problem 2.11. Show that when n -* oo and h -* 0 such that hiw(n+2) = 2w2A2 remains fixed, the envelope of the distribution function Yn (q) 12 on the interval ql < A coincides with the classical distribution function p(q) from the previous problem. (Hint: Prove the integral representation a
e q Hn(q) =
2"+1
°O
fe
2
' yn cos(2gy - 2nir)dy7
o
and derive the asymptotic formula On (q) =
1
cos{
, A2 _ g2
W
(A2 sin-1
2h
q
A
+q
A2
_q2 - 2 A2zr) +0(1) }
when h-*0andh(n+2)=2wA2, Iql
Problem 2.13 (The N-representation theorem). Let ip E 9(R). Show that the L2-convergent expansion 0 = E°° o cnz/in, where cn = *On), converges in .9(R). (Hint: Use NZ)n = n0n.)
Problem 2.14. Show that the operators Eij = a1 aj, i, j = 1,.. , n, satisfy the .
commutation relations of the Lie algebra sl(n, C).
2.7. Holomorphic representation and Wick symbols. Let e2
=
C = {Cn}°°=o
:
IICI12 =
00
Icn12 < 00
n=0
be the Hilbert £2-space. The choice of an orthonormal basis {On}'=0 for L2(R, dq), given by the eigenfunctions (2.40) of the Schrodinger operator for the harmonic oscillator, establishes the Hilbert space isomorphism L2(R, dq) - P2 L 7
W L2(R, dq)
V) = E CnOn I
.'
C = {Cn}
n=0
where
Cn = (0, On) f_(q)n(q)dg7
0 E £2,
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
112
since the functions 0,,, are real-valued. Using (2.39) we get CO
a*0 =
00
cn,a*on =
n=0
n V+ l cn0n+i =
00
n=0
V fn cn-14bni
O E D(a*),
n=1
and 00
aO_EGna0n=EY'LCHOW-1= n=0
so that in
f2
n+lcn+1On5
OED(a),
n=0
n=1
creation and annihilation operators a* and a are represented
by the following semi-infinite matrices: 0
a=
0
v
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
"2-
0
... ...
0
,
0
0
0
V/-1
0
0
0
0
V2_
0
0
a*=
0
0
0f0
As a result,
N = a*a =
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
2
0
0
0
0
3
so that the Hamiltonian of the harmonic oscillator is represented by a diagonal matrix,
H=hw(N+2)=diag{2hw,2fiw,2
,...}.
This representation of the Heisenberg commutation relations is called the representation by occupation numbers, and has the property that in this representation the Hamiltonian H of the harmonic operator is diagonal. Another representation where H is diagonal is constructed as follows. Let be the space of entire functions f (z) with the inner product
if f
(2.44)
(z)9(z)e-IZ12d2z,
(f, 9) = ir
where d2 z = 2 dz A dz is the Lebesgue measure on C
R2. It is easy to check
that -9 is a Hilbert space with the orthonormal basis zn
fn(z) =
n=0,1,2,....
The correspondence 00
P2 3 c = {cn}°O_0 '--* f (z)
cnfn(z) E n=0
2. Quantization
113
establishes the Hilbert space isomorphism f2 - 9. The realization of a Hilbert space 3l° as the Hilbert space 9 of entire functions is called a holomorphic representation. In the holomorphic representation,
a*=z,
a=d
,
H=hw
and
(zdz+2/l,
and it is very easy to show that a* is the adjoint operator to a. The mapping 00
00
cnfn(z) E
CnWn F--> P z) _
n=0
n=0
establishes the isomorphism between the coordinate and holomorphic representations. It follows from the formula for the generating function for Hermite-Tchebyscheff polynomials, n
°O
e29z-Z2
Hn(q) n! = n=0
that the corresponding unitary operator U :
-Ye
-- 9 is an integral operator
with the kernel (2.45)
U(z,q)
00 = Jiiiie2ht12-( a e _ On(q)fn(z)
Z)2
n=0
Another useful realization is a representation in the Hilbert space anti-holomorphic functions f (z) on C with the inner product (f, g) = 7r
of
I f(z)9(z)e-IZ12d2z,
given by
a =z,
d
a
dz. Remark. Holomorphic and anti-holomorphic representations correspond to different choices of a complex polarization of the symplectic manifold R2. By definition, a complex polarization of a symplectic manifold (4', w) is
an integrable distribution on .0 of complex Lagrangian subspaces of the complexified vector spaces TT.1 OR C. As the notion of real polarization, the notion of complex polarization plays a fundamental role in geometric quantization. In particular, holomorphic representation corresponds to the complex Lagrangian subspace in TXIR2 OR C C2 given by the equation z = 0, where z and z are complex coordinates on C2. (Note that here z is not a complex conjugate to z!) The equation 2 = 0 defines a complex Lagrangian subspace which corresponds to the anti-holomorphic representation.
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
114
The anti-holomorphic representation is used to introduce the so-called Wick symbols of the operators. Namely, let A be an operator in -9 which is a polynomial with constant coefficients in creation and annihilation operators a* and a. Using the commutation relation (2.34), we can move all operators
a* to the left of the operators a, and represent A in the Wick normal form as follows:
A=
(2.46)
Ai,(a*)la'm.
a,m
By definition, the Wick symbol A(z, z) of the operator A is (2.47)
A(z, z)
_ 1:
Atn,&lz"`.
I'm
It is a restriction of a polynomial A(v, z) in variables v and z to v = z. In order to define Wick symbols of bounded operators in we consider the family of coherent states (or Poisson vectors) 4)T, E .9, v E C, defined by
z E C.
evz,
They satisfy the properties and f (v) = (f, 4v),
a-1)v = v)v
(2.48)
f E -9, v E C.
Indeed, the first property is trivial, whereas the "reproducing property" immediately follows from the formula cc
(2.49)
-10v(2) = 1: f. (v) in (2), n=0
where fn (z) = fn (z), n = 0, 1, 2, ... , is the orthonormal basis for We also have (2.50)
(.f' g) _
f(f,v)(g,v)e_12d2v.
Now for the operator A in the Wick normal form (2.46) we get, using the first property in (2.48), (A(Dz,
Atm,(am
E Aj,,,,((a*)lamcz, 1,m
1,m
= A(v, z)(-Pz, 4)v)
Therefore, A(v,
z)
(-z, -v)) (
- e-vz(A4)z, 4)z),
since by the reproducing property, (-Dz, (Pv) = Oz(v) = evz
'z, Av)
2. Quantization
115
Definition. The Wick symbol A(z, z) of a bounded operator A in the Hilbert space _9 is a restriction to v = z of an entire function A(v, z) in variables v and z, defined by A(v, z) = e-vz(A-Dz, 4Dv)
In the next theorem, we summarize the properties of the Wick symbols.
Theorem 2.2. Wick symbols of the bounded operators on _9 have the following properties.
(i) If A(2, z) is the Wick symbol of an operator A, then for the Wick symbol of the operator A* we have A* (z, z) = A(2, z) and A* (v, z) = A(z, v).
(ii) For f E 19,
f A(z, v)f
(Af) (z) _
(v)e-v(v-z)d2v.
(iii) A real-analytic function A(z, z) is a Wick symbol of a bounded operator A in if and only if it is a restriction to v = z of an entire function A(v, z) in variables v and z with the property that for every f E the integral in part (ii) is absolutely convergent and defines a function in 11. (iv) If Al (z, z) and A2 (Z, z) are the Wick symbols of operators Al and A2, then the Wick symbol of the operator A = A1A2 is given by A(z, z) =
z)e-(v-z)(v-z)d2v.
1 f Al (z, v)A2(v,
Proof. We have A*(v, z) = e-vz(A*-D,z, -Dv)
= e-vz
(cz, ADv) = e-vz(ADv, 4Dz)
= A(z, v),
which proves (i). To prove (ii), we use the reproducing property to get
(Af)(z) = (Af, ,D.) = (f, A*4)z) _
ff(ti)(A*z)(ti)e_H2d2v. 7r
1C
Using the reproducing property once again we have (A*,Dz)(v) = (A' 4)Z)
A*(v,
evzA(z, v),
which proves (ii). Property (iii) follows from the definition and the uniform
boundness principle, which is needed to show that the operator A on 1J'
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
116
defined by the integral in (ii), is bounded. We leave the standard details to the reader. To prove (iv), by using (2.50) and (i) we get A(z, z) = e-1Z1' (AlA2'Dz,'Dz) = e-jzI2(A2'Dz, Ai45z)
=1 1 7r
(A24)zI ov)(Ai0z+
frc
0')e-(JVJ2+Iz12)d2v
A1(z, v)A2(v, z)e- (v-(v-z) d2v.
I
Remark. Properties (i) and (iv) remain valid for the polynomials in a* and a - operators of the form (2.46).
A matrix symbol A(z, z) of a bounded operator A in the Hilbert space is a restriction to v = 2 of an entire function A(v, z) in variables v and z, defined by the following absolutely convergent series: A(v, Z)
(2.51)
=m,n=0 E (Al., fn)fn(v)fm(z) C'O
The matrix and Wick symbols are related as follows.
Lemma 2.4. For a bounded operator A in the Hilbert space -9, A(v, z) = evzA(v, z).
Proof. Using (2.49) we get A(v, z)
_
I
cc
E fn(v)fm(z) f C(Afm)(n)fn(v)e-,wJ2d2u - m,n=O
=1
f
(A-Dz, 4)v) = evzA(v, z).
Changing the order of summation and integration is justified by the absolute convergence.
Corollary 2.3. If A1(2, z) and A2(2, z) are matrix symbols of operators Al and A2, then the matrix symbol of the operator A = AlA2 is given by A(z, z)
_
f
Al(z, v)A2(v, z)e-IV12d2v.
Proof. The proof immediately follows from part (iv) of Theorem 2.2 and Lemma 2.4.
It is straightforward to generalize these constructions to n degrees of freedom. The Hilbert space 1n defining the holomorphic representation is
2. Quantization
117
the space of entire functions f (z) of n complex variables z = (z1, ... , zn) with the inner product (f, 9) = 71
ff
(z)9(z)e-IZ12d2nz
n
d2zn is the Lebesgue measure
+ z2 and d2nz = d2z1 where Iz12 = zi + on Cn - 1[82n. The functions z1M1
...znmn
m1i...,mn=0,1,2,...,
M1... Mn!
fTn.(z)=
< oo,
where m = (ml, ... , Mn) is a multi-index, form an orthonormal basis for -9n. Corresponding creation and annihilation operators are given by a
a3 = z3,
3
azj
of anti-holomorphic functions f (z) on Cn is defined The Hilbert space by the inner product (2.52)
,71
(f, 9) =
f fn(z)9(z)e-I z,2d2nz < 00,
and the creation and annihilation operators are given by
a , 8z;
7=1,...,n.
The coherent states are -D"(z) = e"z, where vz = vi2i +
+ vnzn, and
satisfy the reproducing property f (v)
fE
_ (f,
0
v E Cn.
The Wick symbol A(z, z) of a bounded operator A on _1Pn is defined as
a restriction to v = z of an entire function A(v, z) of 2n variables v = (vl, ... , vn) and z = (zl, ... , zn), given by A(v, z) = e-"z(At 4v). 7
We have
(Af) (z) _
7rn
'n A(z, v)f
(v)e-v(v-z)d2nv,
f E _pn,
and the Wick symbol A(z, z) of the operator A = A1A2 is given by
A(z, z) =
1
7fn
v)A2(v, f A1(. n ,
z)e-("-:)(v-z)d2nv,
where A, (2, z) and A2 (z, z) are the Wick symbols of the operators Al and A2.
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
118
The matrix symbol A(z, z) of a bounded operator A on ! is defined as a restriction to v = z of an entire function A(v, z) of 2n variables v = (v1,. .. , vn,) and z = (z1, ... , zn), given by the absolutely convergent series 00
A(v, z) = E (Afk, fm.)fn.(v)fk(z), k,m=o
where k = (ki, ... , k,,), m = (ml, ... , Mn) are multi-indices, and f,,,, (z) fm(z). The matrix and Wick symbols of a bounded operator A are related by
A(v, z) = e"zA(v, z).
Remark. The anti-holomorphic representation is very useful in quantum mechanics and especially in quantum field theory, where it is called holomorphic representation (with respect to the variables z). Slightly abusing terminology, in Part 2 we will also call it holomorphic representation. Problem 2.15. Find an explicit formula for the unitary operator establishing the Hilbert space isomorphism
= L2(R", d'nq).
Problem 2.16. Prove that for the bounded operator A the functions A(v, z) and A(v, z) are entire functions of 2n variables.
Problem 2.17. Let A be a trace class operator on
with the Wick symbol
A(z, z). Prove that
TA= it1
A(z, z)e_IZ12d2"z. cn
Problem 2.18. Show that the Wick symbol A(z, z) of the product A = Al ... Al is given by A(z, z)
_
f
c
At (z, zl-1) ... A, (21, z) exp {
k-i
zk (zk_ - zk) }d2zi
... d2zl-1,
where zo = z, = z, zi = z, and Ak(z, z) are the Wick symbols of the operators Ak.
3. Weyl relations Let R be an irreducible unitary representation of the Heisenberg group Hn in Hilbert space A'. It follows from Schur's lemma that R(ea0) = e' I for some
h E IR, where I is the identity operator on A'. If fi, = 0, the n-parameter abelian groups of unitary operators U(u) = R(eux) and V(v) = R(e"') commute, so using Schur's lemma once again we conclude that there exist p, q E Rn such that U(u) = e-iupI and V W = e-z"qI. Therefore, in this case the irreducible representation R is one-dimensional and is parametrized by a vector (p, q) E R2n. When h # 0, unitary operators U(u) and V (v) satisfy the Weyl relations (3.1)
U(u)V(v) = eihUVV(v)U(u),
3. Weyl relations
119
which admit the Schrodinger representation, introduced in Section 2.2. It turns out that every unitary irreducible representation of the Heisenberg group H,,, is unitarily equivalent either to a one-dimensional representation with parameters (p, q) E 1R2,, or to the Schrodinger representation with some h # 0. The physically meaningful case corresponds to h > 0, and
representation with -h is given by the operators U-1(u) = U(-u) and V(v).
3.1. Stone-von Neumann theorem. Here we prove the following fundamental result.
Theorem 3.1 (Stone-von Neumann theorem). Every irreducible unitary representation of the Weyl relations for n degrees of freedom,
U(u)V(v) = e2h""V(v)U(u), is unitarily equivalent to the Schrodinger representation.
Proof. It is sufficient to consider n = 1, the general case n > 1 is treated similarly. Set S(u, v) = e-tfi2 v U(U)V(V).
The unitary operator S(u, v) satisfies
S(u, V)* = S(-u, -v),
(3.2)
and it follows from the Weyl relation that S(ul, vl)S(u2, v2) = e 2 (v1v2-u2v1)S(u1 + u2, vl + v2). Define a linear map W : L1(1R2) -fR2 > .('), called the Weyl transform, by (3.3)
f (u, v)S(u, v)dudv.
W (f) = 2
Here the integral is,/1 understood in the weak sense: for every 01, 02 E 3e, (W
02) =
27f
f
2
f (u, v)(s(u, 001, b2)dudv.
The integral is absolutely convergent for all 01, 02 E °, and defines a bounded operator W (f) satisfying IIW(f)I1 <
111f11L1.
The Weyl transform has the following properties.
WT1. For f E Ll(1R2),
W(f)* = W(f*), where
f * (u, v) = f (-u, -v).
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
120
WT2. For f E L'(R2), S(ul, vl)W (f)S(u2, v2) = W(A), where
, v = e 2 {(ul-u2)v-(vl-v2)u+u1v2-u2V1} u- U1 - U2, v- VI - V2).
A,
WT3. Ker W = {0}. WT4. For fl, f2 E L1(II82),
W(fl)W(h) = W (h *h f2), where ?,(UV,-u'v)f1(u
(fl *h f2) (U, v) = 217r 2 e 2
- u', v - v')f2(u', v') du'dv'.
The first two properties follow from the definition and (3.2) and (3.3). To prove WT3, suppose that W (f) = 0. Then for every 01, i' E ' and all u', v' e we have 0 = (W (f)S(u , v')01, S(u , v')02)
= 2 12
eih(uv'-u'v) f(u,
v)(S(u, v)V)1, b2)dudv.
Therefore f (u, v) (S(u, v)'01 i 02) = 0 a.e. on R2, so that f = 0.
To prove WT4, we compute
(W (f1)W (f2)1, 02) = (W (f2)'1, W (fl)*2)
= =
1
27r
11 2
f2(u2, v2)(S(u2, v2)V,1, W (fl)* 2)du2dv2
1
27r
2
f2(u2, v2) (W (fl)S(u2, v2) Y'1, 02)du2dv2
1
(2,7r )2
fRI f
fl(ul - u2, vl - V2)f2(u2, v2) 2
e2(ulv2-u2v1)(S(u1) vl)'1,'42)duldvldu2dv2
=
1f
(fl*hf2)(u,v)(S(u,v) 1,y "/'2)dudv. 22
We have fl *r, f2 E L1(R2), and it follows from the associativity of the operator product and property WT3 that the linear mapping *r,: L'(R 2) x L'(R2) -* L'(R 2) defines a new associative product on L'(R2), fl *h (f2 *h f3) = (fl *h f2) *h f3
for all
fl, f2, f3 E L1(IR2).
When h = 0, the product *h becomes the usual convolution product on Ll (1[82).
3. Weyl relations
121
For every non-zero 0 E 3l° denote by
.
the closed subspace of 3t°
spanned by the vectors S(u, v) & for all u, v E R. The subspace 3l,, is invari-
ant for all operators U(u) and V(v). Since the representation of the Weyl relation is irreducible, 3l°O = 3e. There is a vector ''o E 3l° for which all inner products of the generating can be explicitly computed. Namely, let vectors S(u, v)V)o of
fo(u, v) =
he-4(,2+v2)
and set WO = W(fo). Then WO* = WO and W0S(u, v)Wo = e- 4 (u2+772) Wo.
In particular, Wo = Wo, so that Wo is an orthogonal projection. Indeed, using WT4, we have W0S(u, v)Wo = W YO *h Jo),
where
U,v') = ea (7lv'-7l'77) fo(u - u,v' - v). By "completing the square" we obtain .
(f0 *h fo)(u', v') =
he-4(u2+v2+ur2+v'2)I(u
,
v'),
where
I(u v') =
h
e 2
Shifting contours of integration to Im u" = -v - v', Im v" = u + u' and = u" - u - u' + iv + iv', i = v" - v - v' - iu - iu', we get
substituting
I(u',v') = 2 f2
1.
Now leto = Im Wo - a non-zero closed subspace of 3i° by property WT3. For every '01i 02 E JWO we have Wool = 01, W002 = 02, and (S(ul, vl)Y'1, S(u2, v2)b2) = (S(ul, vl)Wob1, S(u2, v2)Wo,0//,,2)
= (W0S(-u2, -v2)S(u1, vl)Wo4'1, '2)
=e
a2 (U1v2-U2v1)
e2
=e
2
(WOS(ul - U2, vl - v2)
(u1772-u2v1)-4{(711-712)2+(771-772)2}(Wo (711772-U2V1)-4{(711-712)2+(771-772)2} (y '/'
1, 4'2)
1, 02).
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
122
is one-dimensional. Indeed, for every This implies that the subspace such that (01,02) = 0, we have that the corresponding 01,02 E spaces for every non-zero V), and IP2 are orthogonal. Since -Y, = at least one of the vectors 01, 02 is 0. Let Jyeo = C'o, IIOo II = 1, and set
0a,0 = S(a,,Q)0o, cY, Q E R. The closure of the linear span of the vectors for all a,,3 E IR is 3l°. We have
;
,`Py,b) = e 2
and
S(u, v)Y'a,Q = e 2
(uQ-va)
`Ya+u,Q+v.
Next we consider the Schrodinger representation of the Weyl relation in L2(R, dq):
(U(u)W)(q) = W (q - hu),
(V(v)W)(q) = -ivgW(q), e22 vv-ZVqW(q -
(S(u,
hu).
For the corresponding operaf tor Wo we have (WOW) (q)
=
2
e-4(u2+v2)e2uv-iv( W(q - hu)dudv
h /oo e4{v,2+(v-'q)2}cp(q - hu)du
J
7r
_
00
1
e-A (g2+q'2)W(Q oo
)dq ,
so that Wo is a projection onto the one-dimensional subspace of L2(R, dq) spanned by the Gaussian exponential WO(q) = 'e-Zhg2, IIWoII = 1. Let Wa,p = S(a, 3)oo
Since the Schrodinger representation is irreducible, the closed subspace spanned by the functions cpa p for all a,,3 E R is the whole Hilbert space L2(R, dq). (This also follows from the completeness of Hermite-Tchebyscheff functions, )2 sin ce We h ave e
(wa,p,( and
e2(ab-Qy)-a11 {(a-y)2+(Q-a)2}
3. Weyl relations
For J
123
define
cVba,,O, E
n
eiai,O, E L2(R, dq). i=1
Since inner products between the vectors 0a,Q coincide with the inner products between the vectors cps Q, /we have 112
I
-
IIV)112
yI so that ' is a well-defined unitary operator between the subspaces spanned by the vectors {' a,Q}a,RE[P and f cOa,Q}a,QER. Thus '& extends to the unitary operator 1W : -+ L2 (R, dq) and
VS(a,,3) = S(a,,3)Q( for all a,,3 E R. Lemma 2.1 in Section 2.1 is now an easy corollary of the Stone-von Neumann theorem.
Corollary 3.2. The self-adjoint generators P = (Pi,. .. , Pn) and Q = (Q1,. .. , Qn) of the n-parameter abelian groups of unitary operators U(u) and V(v) satisfy Heisenberg commutation relations. Proof. It follows from the Stone theorem that in the Schrodinger representation the generators P and Q are momenta and coordinate operators.
Remark. For n degrees of freedom
S(u,v) = e
z2
u"U(u)V (v) = e- 2 uve-iuPe-ivQ
and formally using the Baker-Campbell-Hausdorff formula, we get
S(u, v) = e-i(uP+v41).
(3.4)
Thus the Weyl transform
W (f) =
1
(27r)n
f2n
f (u, v)e-i(uP+"Q)dnu dnv
can be considered as a non-commutative Fourier transform - an operatorvalued generalization of the "ordinary" Fourier transform f (P, q) = (27r)n
fen f (u, v)e-i(uP+vq)dnu dn'v.
Remark. The Stone-von Neumann theorem is a very strong result. In particular, it implies that creation and annihilation operators for n degrees of freedom,
a=
(Q + iP),
a* = 4 (Q - iP),
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
124
where P and Q are the corresponding generators24 satisfying Heisenberg commutation relations, are unitarily equivalent to the corresponding operators in the Schrodinger representation. Thus there always exists a ground state - a vector V50 E A, annihilated by the operators a = (al, ... , a"). The corresponding statement no longer holds for quantum systems with infinitely many degrees of freedom, described by quantum field theory, where one needs to postulate the existence of the ground state (the "physical vacuum"). The Weyl transform in the Schrodinger representation 3° = L2(W1, dnq) can be described explicitly as a bounded operator with an integral kernel. Namely,
(S(u, v)1')(q) = e z uv-iv4',(q
(3.5)
- Btu),
V E L2(IR", dnq),
and for 01, 02 E L2 (1R", dnq) and f c Ll(IE82n) n L2(II82") we have (W (f ) 01, V)2) = (21f)n f2n f (u, v) (S(u, v)Wl, V)2)dnu dnv 1
f
(JRn e 2
(2ir)"
=
uv-ivs f (u, v)'Vl (q - nu)' 2
f (f
Rn
]]fin
K(q,
(q)
dnq) du dnv
q'),Ol(4 )dnq') V)2(q)d"q,
where (3.6)
K(q, q')
_
(2
h)"
f
Ln
,
f(
v)e-2 (9+q')vdnv.
The interchange of the order of integrations is justified by the Fubini theorem. Thus W (f) is an integral operator with the integral kernel K(q, q'),
(W (f )')) (q) = fn K(q, By the Plancherel theorem,
J
I K(q,
q')12dnq dnq'
)dnq',
=f 2n
' E L2 (fin, dnq)
lf(u, v)12dnu dnv,
so that W (f) is a Hilbert-Schmidt operator on. The linear subspace L1(R2") n L2(R2n) is dense in L2(II82") and the Weyl transform extends to the isometry W : L2(R2") -> 92, where 92 is the Hilbert space of HilbertSchmidt operators on ° = L2(IR", dnq). Since every Hilbert-Schmidt operator on is a bounded operator with the integral kernel in L2(1R2n), the mapping W is onto. Thus we have proved the following result. 24Here it is convenient to lower the indices by the Euclidean metric on IR" and use Q = (Qi,
. .
, Qn).
3. Weyl relations
125
Lemma 3.1. The Weyl transform W defines the isomorphism L2(lR2n) ,,,
Problem 3.1. Let P = (P1,.. . , Pn) and Q = (Q1i ... , Q.) be self-adjoint operators25 on .3° satisfying Heisenberg commutation relations (2.4) on some dense
domain D in 3l°, and such that the symmetric operator H = Ek_1(Pk + Q2 ),
defined on D, is essentially self-adjoint. Also suppose that every bounded operator which commutes with P and Q is a multiple of the identity operator in -Y. Prove
that P and Q are unitarily equivalent to momenta and coordinate operators in the Schrodinger representation. (Hint: By the Stone-von Neumann theorem, it is sufficient to show that P and Q define an integrable representation of the Heisenberg algebra. One can also prove this result directly by using commutation relations between the operators H, a*, a and the arguments in Section 2.6. This would give another proof of the Stone-von Neumann theorem.)
Problem 3.2. Prove formula (3.4).
3.2. Invariant formulation. Here we present a coordinate-free description of the Schrodinger representation. Let (V, w) be a finite-dimensional
symplectic vector space, dim V = 2n. Recall that (see Section 2.1) the Heisenberg algebra g = g(V) is a one-dimensional central extension of the abelian Lie algebra V by the skew-symmetric bilinear form w. As a vector space,
g = V ®Rc, with the Lie bracket [u + ac, v + /3c] = w(u, v)c,
u, v E V, a, ,3 E R.
Every Lagrangian subspace t of V defines an abelian subalgebra f ® R c of g. A Lagrangian subspace .£' is complementary to £ in V if £ ® £' = V. A choice of the complementary Lagrangian subspace e' to £ establishes the isomorphism g/(e (D Rc) ,., t'.
The Heisenberg group C = G(V) is a connected and simply-connected Lie group with the Lie algebra g. By the exponential map, G ^_ V ® R c as a manifold, with the group law exp(vi + alc) exp(v2 + a2c) = exp(vi + v2 + (al + a2 + Zw(vl, v2))c),
where v1i V2 E V, al, a2 E R. A choice of the symplectic basis for V establishes the isomorphism G(V) -_ Hn with the matrix Heisenberg group defined in Section 2.1. The volume form d2nv A dc, where d2nv E A2nV* is a volume form on V and V* is the dual vector space to V, defines a bi-invariant Haar measure on G. Every Lagrangian subspace t defines an 25See previous footnote.
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
126
abelian subgroup L = exp( ®1l c) of G, and a choice of the complementary Lagrangian subspace £' establishes the isomorphism G/L _- Q'.
(3.7)
The isomorphism A2nV* - Ant* A Ant'* gives rise to the volume form d'v' on 2' and defines a measure dg on the homogeneous space GIL. The measure dg is invariant under the left G-action and does not depend on the choice of P'
For a given h E R, the function X : L -> C, X(exp(v + ac)) = eZ
v c V, a E I[8,
defines a one-dimensional unitary character of L, X(1112) = X(11)X(12),
11, 12 E L.
Definition. The Schrodinger representation Se of the Heisenberg group G(V), associated with a Lagrangian subspace £ of V, is a representation of G induced by the one-dimensional representation X of the corresponding abelian Lie group L, St = IndL X. By definition of the induced representation, the Hilbert space d6f of the representation Se consists of measurable functions f : G --+ C satisfying the property f (gl) = X(1)-1f (g),
g E G, 1 E L,
and such that I
I f III = f IL
If (g) I2dg < oc.
Corresponding unitary operators Se(g), g E G, are defined by the left translations, g c G. (St (g)f) (g') = f (g-1g'), f E In particular, ,
(Se(exp ac) f)(g) = f (exp(-ac)g) = f (g exp(-ac)) = eZ f (g),
so that St(exp ac) = ei I, where I is the identity operator on For every Lagrangian subspace f of V, the representation St is unitarily .
equivalent to the Schrodinger representation. This can be explicitly shown as follows. By (3.7), a choice of a complementary Lagrangian subspace f' gives rise to the unique decomposition g = exp v' exp(v + ac), and for f E Jyee we get
f (g) = f (exp v' exp(v + ac)) = e-Z f (exp v'),
v E f, v' E 2', a E R.
3. Weyl relations
127
Thus every f E Jhet is completely determined by its restriction to exp f' ^_ P',
-- L2 (f', d'v'), defined by
and the mapping G&I :
Glle(f) (v') = f (exp iv'),
v' E P',
is the isomorphism of Hilbert spaces. For the corresponding representation Se = G1leSeGlle 1 in L2 (f', d'v') we have
(Sj(eXpv)')(v') = ez"(v,v'),O(vl),
(Se(eXpu)V)(v')
=O(v'-hu),
v E .£, v' E f',
u', v' E P'.
Let e1, ... , eu, fl, ... , f, be the symplectic basis for V such that
f=RelED ...®Re' and and let (p, q) _ (p1, ... , p,,, q1, ... , ql) be the corresponding coordinates in V (see Section 2.6 in Chapter 1). Then L2(P', d"v') :-- L2(R72, d7q) and
St(exp uX) = U(u)
and Se(exp vY) = V (v),
uk fk, vY = Ek-1 vkek, and U(u) = e-'U,p, V (v) _ e-z"4 are, respectively, n-parameter groups of unitary operators correspond-
where uX =
ing to momenta and coordinate operators P and Q. The mapping *h - the new associative product on L1 (R272) introduced in
the last section - can also be described in invariant terms. Let Bh = G/Fh be the quotient group, where rh = {exp(2- c) E G I n c Z} is a discrete central subgroup in G, and let db = d2"v A d*a be the left-invariant Haar measure on Bh, where d*a is the normalized Haar measure on the circle
R/ 7G. The Banach space L1(Bh, db) has an algebra structure with respect to the convolution: P1(b1)P2(bi 1b)dbl,
(W1 *Bn W2) (b) =
fBn
W1, W2 E L1(Bh,db).
The correspondence L1(V, d2'nv) D f (v) - cp(exp(v + ac)) = e-'r« f (v) E L1(Bh, db)
defines the inclusion map L1(V, d2uv) -+ L1(Bh, db), and the image of L1(V, d2"v) is a subalgebra of L1(Bh, db) under the convolution. We have for f1, f2 E L1(V, d2nv),
(cp1 *B,, cp2)(expv) = f cpl(exp(u + ac))cp2(exp(-u - ac) expv)d2Tvd*a h
fv cpl(expu)cp2(exp(v - u) exp(-2w(u, = f fl(u)f2(v - u) e IF` =
(u,v)d2nv
V
(fl *h f2) (V),
vEV
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
128
Problem 3.3. Prove that the Weyl transform is the restriction to L' (V, d2'ly) of the mapping L1(Bh, db) E) cp ,-i fBh cp (b)S1(b)db E
Problem 3.4. Let t1 e2, B3 be Lagrangian subspaces of V. Define the triple i
Maslov index r(f1i e2, P3) as a signature of the quadratic form Q on fl ® f2 ® e3, defined by Q(x1, x2, x3) = w(x1, x2) + w(x2, x3) + w(x3, xl)
For Lagrangian subspaces L1, f2 of V let 9e2,tl be the unitary operator establishing the Hilbert space isomorphism -Vtl ^ 'e12 and intertwining representations S11 and
St,, e2,tl S11 (9) = Set (9)` 'e2,t1 ,
Prove that t1 ,t3 F13 ,12' 'e2,11 =
g E G.
e-7riT(e1,12,e3)Ii, where I1
is the identity operator
in -Yt,.
Problem 3.5. Let Sp(V) be the symplectic group of (V, w) - the subgroup of GL(V), preserving the symplectic form w. The group Sp(V) acts as a group of automorphisms of the Heisenberg group G by the formula h exp(v + ac) _ exp(h v + ac), h E Sp(V), v E V. Let R be an irreducible unitary representation of G in the Hilbert space A. Show that there exist unitary operators U(h), defined up to multiplication by complex numbers of modulus 1, such that U(h)R(g)U(h)-1
= R(h g), h E Sp(V), g E G,
and that U defines a projective unitary representation of Sp(V) in .3t°, called the Shale- Weil representation. Find a realization of the Hilbert space _-Y such that the 2-cocycle of the Shale-Weil representation is explicitly computed in terms of the Maslov index.
3.3. Weyl quantization. The Weyl transform, introduced in Section 3.1, defines a quantization of classical systems associated with the phase space IE82, with coordinates p = (pr,. .. ,per,), q = (q',. .. , q,), and the Poisson bracket { , } associated with the canonical symplectic form w = dp A dq. Let
-1 : 9(R2n) _V( ye), where W is the Weyl transform and 9-1 is the inverse Fourier transform, be the linear mapping of the Schwartz space 9(1R2,) of complex-valued 4)=Wo
functions of rapid decay on R2n into the Banach space of bounded operators Y(.310) on . = L2(ll? , d,q). It is given explicitly by the integral
4)(f) =
(2), i fR1n f (u, v)S(u, v)d,u d,v,
understood as a limit of Riemann sums in the uniform topology on where
f(u, v) _
-1(f)(u, v) =
(27,)n I22 f (p, q)e2(uP+vg)dpdnq,
3. Weyl relations
129
and S(u, v) = e- 2 "'U(u)V(v). It follows from (3.6) that (D (f) is an integral operator: for every 'c% E L2 (R', dnq),
(,D (f)V))(q) = fRn K(q, q')')(4 )dnq', w here
K(9' q')
f (4
n
Q' he
v)e-ZV(q+q')dnv
J (2 Since the Schwartz space is self-dual with respect to the Fourier transform, K E 92(Rn x Rn) C L2(lR x l8n), so that 4)(f) is a Hilbert-Schmidt operator.
Using the property S(u, v)* = S(-u, -v) we get 4)(f)*
so that classical observables - real-valued functions on ]R 2n, correspond to
quantum observables - self-adjoint operators in °. It follows from the property WT3 in Section 3.1 that the mapping 4D is injective; its image Im 4D and the inverse mapping 4D-1 are explicitly described as follows.
Proposition 3.1. The subspace Im 4D C 2( °) consists of operators B E Sol such that corresponding functions g(u, v) = hn Tr(B S(u, v)-1) belong to the Schwartz class 9(182n); in this case W(g) = B. The inverse mapping (D-1 = 9 o W-1 is given by the Weyl's inversion formula Au, v) = hn Tr((D (f)S(u, v)-1),
f E Y(I[82n).
Proof. First consider the case n = 1. Let
H=
P2 + Q2 2
be the Hamiltonian of the harmonic oscillator with m = 1 and w = 1. According to Theorem 2.1, the operator H has a complete orthonormal system of real-valued eigenfunctions On(q), given by Hermite-Tchebyscheff functions, with the eigenvalues h(n + ), so that the inverse operator H-1 E 2 92. The operator is an integral operator with the kernel 2 (-h2 '9 + q 2)K(q, q'), which is a Schwartz class function on 1R2, so that H-D(f) E 92. The operator 4)(f) = H-1H-:D(f )
is a product of Hilbert-Schmidt operators and, therefore, is of trace class. Using the orthonormal basis {Y,bn(q)}°_o for .3° = L2(R), we get (3.8)
K(q,Q) = E Gmn m,n=O
)n(q),m(q1),
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
130
where
c.,, = f
K(q, Q)In(g)Im(4 )dgdq', 2
and the series (3.8) converges in
L2(R2).
Since K E 9'(R2), it follows from
the N-representation theorem (see Problem 2.13) that this series is also convergent in the 9(lR2) topology. It is this fact which allows us to set q' = q in (3.8) and to get the expansion 00
K(q,q) = E cmnV)n(q) m(q), m,n=O
which converges in .(R). Thus we obtain
0
Tr-P (f)
(f)4'n,'Yn) = EGnn = n=0
n=0
FOO
K(q,q)dq,
where the interchange of orders of summation and integration is legitimate. The general case n > 1 is similar. We consider the operator
H=
P2 + Q2 2
and use the fact that operators Hn4(f) and H-n are Hilbert-Schmidt. To prove the formula
Tr 4) (f) = j nK(q, q)dnq, we expand the kernel K(q, q') using the orthonormal basis {0k(q)} i0 for L2(Rn), where
k = (k1, ... , kn) From the explicit form of the kernel K we get O/C (q) _ Okl (ql) ... Wkn (qn),
(3.9)
Tr 4) (f)
(2 h)n f,. JRn f (0,
v)e-ivgdv dnq = h-n f(0,
0),
which gives the inversion formula for u = v = 0. To get the inversion formula for all u, v E W1, it is sufficient to apply (3.9) to the function fuv = 9(fu,z1), where
fu,v(u', v') = f (u + u', v + v') e 2
("'U-u'v),
and to use S(u, v)-1 = S(u, v)* = S(-u, -v) and the property WT2 in Section 3.1,
W(f)S(-U, -v) = W (fu""). To complete the proof, we need to show that Im 4 consists of all B E 91 with the property that the function g(u, v) = hn Tr(B S(u, v)-1) belongs to the Schwartz class. By the inversion formula,
g(u, v) =
hn
Tr(4> (f) S(u, v)-1),
3. Weyl relations
131
where f = 9(g), so it is sufficient to prove that if Tr(B S(u, v)-1) = 0 for all u, v c Rn, then B = 0. Indeed, multiplying by f (u, v) and integrating, we get
TrBW(f)* = 0 for all f E Y(lf 2n). Since Schwartz class functions are dense in L2(ll 2n), by Lemma 3.1 we get Tr BB* = 0 and, therefore, B = 0.
Corollary 3.3. Tr .1, (f)
(G7fh)n
L2n f (p7 q)dnp dnq
Remark. By the Schwartz kernel theorem, the operator S(u, v) is an integral operator with the distributional kernel e2v'v-zvg6(q-q'-hu)
so that ) n 6(u)6(v).
Tr S(u, v) = 1 Thus, as is customary in physics texts,
fn
f(u,v)6(u)S(v)dnudv=l2-n.f(0,0).
Let Ao = 5(lR2n, 1[8) C A be the subalgebra of classical observables on R2n of rapid decay, and let .slo = d f1 Y(n) be the space of bounded quantum observables.
Proposition 3.2. The mapping AO E) f H O(f) E sj is a quantization, i.e., it satisfies l
0
20-1
(O(f1)O(f2) + O(f2)O(f1)) = f1f2
and the correspondence principle hlim
-1 ({4)(fl), 4)(f2)}h) = {fl, f2},
fl, f2 E A0,
where
(fl), "D (f2)}h = i ["D(f1), 4)(f2)]
and
afl af2
5fl af2
{fl,f2}= Op aq - aq Op
are, respectively, the quantum bracket and the Poisson bracket.
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
132
Proof. In terms of the product *h introduced in Section 3.1 we have 'D -1(D(f1)(D (f2)) =
(fl
.
and it follows from the property WT4 that -1(-T,(fl)4)(f2))(p, q) =
(3.10)
e
(27r)2n
1'2n I 2n fl(ul, v1)f2(U2, v2)
2 (ulv2-u2vl)-i(ul+u2)P-i(vl+v2)gdnuldnu2dnvld"412.
Using the expansion e
in ulv2-u2v1)
=1+
2 (ulv2 - u2v1) + O(h2(u1v2 - u2v1)2)
as h - 0, and the basic properties of the Fourier transform,
(uf(u,v)) = iof (P,q) and 9(vf(u,v)) = iaq(p,q), we get from (3.10) that as h --+ 0, (fl) -(D (f2)) (p, q)
_ (flf2)(p, q) -
2{fl, f2}(p, q) + 0(h2).
Using skew-symmetry of the Poisson bracket completes the proof.
The quantization associated with the mapping 4) = Wow-1 is called the Weyl quantization. The correspondence f --* (D(f) can be easily extended to the vector space L1(R2n) - the image of Ll (1R2n) under the Fourier transform, which is a subspace of C(1[82n). More generally, for f E 5o(IE82n)'
- the space of tempered distributions on j2n - the corresponding kernel (3.11)
(2 1)n.n f (p, q2q )e*P(q-q')dnp,
K(q, q') =
considered as a tempered distribution on W x Rn, is a Schwartz kernel of the linear operator 1'(f) : 9(1[8n) -> y(1f8n)'.
In particular, the constant function f = 1 corresponds to the identity operator I with K(q, q') = b(q - q'). In terms of the kernel K(q, q') the Weyl inversion formula takes the form (3.12)
f (p, q) =
f
K(q - 2v, q + 2v)e*Pdnv.
The distribution f (p, q) defined by (3.12) is called the Weyl symbol of the operator in L2(1Rn, dnq) with the Schwartz kernel K(q, q'). Examples below describe classes of distributions f such that the operators -(D(f) are essentially self-adjoint unbounded operators on the domain 9(1Rn) c L2(ln, dnq)
3. Weyl relations
133
Example 3.1. Let f = f (q) E LP(IR') for some 1 < p < oo, or let f be a polynomially bounded function as IqJ -p oo. In the distributional sense,
f (u, v) = (2x),"26(u)f (v) so that
K(q, q') _
(h 2W)n
f
)f (v)e 2v(q+q')d'Lv
6(
n
_ 6(q - q')f(
) = f (q)6(q - q'). Thus the operator (P (f) is a multiplication by f (q) operator on L2(W ). In particular, coordinates q in classical mechanics correspond to coordinate
operators Q in quantum mechanics. Similarly, if f = f (p), then -ID(f) = f (P). In particular, momenta p in classical mechanics correspond to the momenta operators P in quantum mechanics.
Example 3.2. Let 2
He = 2 + V (q) be the Hamiltonian function in classical mechanics. Then H = 4'(H) is the corresponding Hamiltonian operator in quantum mechanics, 2
H = 2m + V (Q). In Chapter 3 we give necessary conditions for the operator H to be essentially self-adjoint.
Example 3.3. Here we find f E 9(ll 2n)' such that IP(.f)_P10
- a pure state P,L,, where 0 E L2(IIBn), 11011 = 1. The projection P,P is an integral operator with the kernel',(q)i(q'), and we get from (3.11),
(2 1) n flan f(p, Introducing q+ = f (2n,
,
1+q)ehP(q-9')dnp ='b(q)b(q')
2(q + q'), q_ = 2(q - q'), we obtain
v) _ hn
n
q-)e"q+dnq+,
V,(q- +
or
f (u, v) = n f nO(q + 2 hu)b(q - 2hu)ezvgdnq. Assuming that / does not depend on h, we get in accordance with Corollary 3.3,
P(u, v) = lim
1
(2 1i)n f (u' v)
(27r)n
J. I ')(q)
I2ezvgd'Lv.
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
134
Thus in the classical limit h -> 0 the pure state Pp in quantum mechanics becomes a mixed state in classical mechanics, given by a probability measure dp = p(p, q)dnp dnq on R2n with the density p(p, q) = 6(p) IV)(q)
I2.
It describes a classical particle at rest (p = 0) with the distribution of coordinates given by the probability measure IO(q) I2dnq on R'. When O(q) _ eh"°gcp(q), where cp(q) does not depend on h, the corresponding density is p(p, q) = 8(p - po) I W (q) I2.
Remark. The Weyl quantization can be considered as a way of defining a function f (P, Q) of non-commuting operators P = (P1, ... , Pn) and Q = (Q1 Qn) by setting
f(P,Q) = .1)(f) In particular, if f (p, q) = g(p) + h(q), then f (P, Q) = g(P) + h(Q).
For f (p, q) = pq = pi q' +
+ pngn we get, using (3.11), PQ+QP
f(P,Q) =
2
This shows that the Weyl quantization symmetrizes products of the noncommuting factors P and Q. In general, let f be a polynomial function,
f (p, q) _ E cap paq",
(3.13)
IaI,IQI
where for the multi-indices a = (al, ... , an) and Q = (01,
pa = pil
pnn
and dal =
= (gl)Q1 ...
qQ
101 = 31 +
.
.
. ,
On),
(gn)An,
+ Nn. Using (3.11), we get the
following formula (3.14)
4D(f)
=
E
caQ Sym(P0QQ)
al,101
Here Sym(PaQQ) is a symmetric product, defined by (3.15)
(uP + vQ)k = IaI+Ial=k
kt uavA Sym(PaQA), a!Q!
where up
and a! = 01! ... an!,
/3! = 01! ...On!.
3. Weyl relations
135
Remark. In addition to the Weyl quantization 4), consider also the mappings 4)1 : 9(R2"') -p '(.9 ') and Y(R2,) defined by 4) 1
(f)
(27r)n
Ln f (
u, v ) e 2 '"p(u, v )d'' u d v
and
uvS(u v)d"udnv,
4)2(f) = (2ir)n f2n f (u,v)e 2 where f = Y-1(f) is the inverse Fourier transform. Though 4)1 and 'D2 no longer map AO into the real vector space sa/o of bounded quantum observables, they satisfy all the properties in Proposition 3.2. It follows from (3.5) that for f E 9(R2"') the operators 41)1(f) and 4)2(f) are integral operators with the integral kernels
Kl(q, q') =
1 (27rh)n
][gn
f (p, q')e'P(q-I )dnp
and
K2 (q, q)
(27r1t)n
fRn f (P,
q)ehP(9-4')P,
respectively. As in the case of the Weyl quantization, these formulas extend the mappings f H (D 1(f) and f H 4D2 (f) of the space .(IE82n)' of tempered distributions on 1R2"'. In particular, if f (p, q) is a polynomial function (3.13), then (3.16)
(1(f) _
caQ PaQQ IaI,IQI
and (3.17)
ca,Q Qopa.
(D2 (f) _ Ia1,1Q1
Therefore the mapping f --* 4)1(f) is called the pq-quantization, and the mapping f - 42 (f) - the qp-quantization. Corresponding inversion formulas are (3.18)
f (p, q) = f Ki (q - v, q)eKi dnv n
and (3.19)
f (p, q) = f K2(q, q + v) eh 'dnv. n
The distribution f (p, q) defined by (3.18) is called the pq-symbol of an operator with the Schwartz kernel K1(q, q'), and the distribution f (p, q) defined by (3.19) - the qp-symbol of an operator with the Schwartz kernel K2 (q, q'). The qp-symbols are commonly used in the theory of pseudodifferential operators. It follows from (3.18) and (3.19) that if f (p, q) is a pq-symbol of the operator (D1(f ), then f (p, q) is a qp-symbol of the adjoint operator 41(f)*.
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
136
Problem 3.6. Prove formula (3.14). Problem 3.7. Prove formulas (3.16)-(3.17). Problem 3.8. Prove that Weyl, pq, and qp-quantizations are equivalent. (Hint: Find the relations between Weyl, pq, and qp-symbols of a given operator.)
3.4. The *-product. The Weyl quantization 4): Y(lR2n) --i 2'(m), studied in the previous section, defines a new bilinear operation *h : Y(1[82n) x 9(R2n) --) Y(R2n)
on 9'(R2,) by the formula 11 *h 12 =-1(W(f1)W(.f2)) This operation is called the *-product26. According to (3.10), (3.20)
(11 *h f2)(P, q) =
(2,,)2n
fR2n fR2n 11(ul, v1)12(u2, V2)
e I-A
u2dnt 1d 412.
a
The *-product on 9(1i82n) has the following properties.
1. Associativity:
11*h(12*h13) = (11*hf2)*hf3 2. Semi-classical limit:
(11 *h f2)(p, q) _ (flf2)(P, q) - 2 {11,12}(p, q) + O(h2) as h --> 0. 3. Property of the unit:
1*h1=1*h1, where 1 is a function which identically equals 1 on 4. The cyclic trace property:
II82n.
T (fl *h 12) = T (f2 *h 11),
where the (C-linear map T :.So(R2n) -> C is defined by T (1) = (27rfit)n L2Th f (P, q)dnp dnq.
Property 1 follows from the corresponding property for the product *h (see Section 3.1), property 2 follows from Proposition 3.2, and properties 3 and 4 directly follow from the definition (3.20). The complex vector space Y (R2n) (@ C 1 with the bilinear operation *h is an associative algebra over C with unit 1 and the cyclic trace T, satisfying the correspondence principle,
0;(11*h12 -12*h11) _ {fl,f2}. 26A1so called Moyal product in physics.
3. Weyl relations
137
Consider the tensor product of Hilbert spaces L2(l2n) 0 ... L2(R2n x R2n L2(R2n)
and define the unitary operator U1 on L2(If82n) ® L2(lR2n) by
Ul = e
(5®
t2
P
9
where
a 9q =
a ap
a
n
a
apk
It follows from the theory of Fourier transform that for fl, f2 E Y(][82n),
I
(Ul(fl 0 f2)) (pl,gl,p2,g2)
I
fl(ul,vl)f2(U2,v2)
(27r)2n 2n .2n e2U1V2-iu1P1-iu2P2-iv1gi-iv2g2dn'u dnul 1
2
dnv1 dnv 2
Similarly, defining the unitary operator U2 on L2(Il 2n) 0 L2(R2n) by
2 s(& Tp-)
U2= we get
(271r)2n
(U2(fl (9 f2)) (pi, gj,P2, g2)
L2n f 2n fi(u1, vl)f2(u2, V2) -
`2U2vi-iu1P1-iU2P2-ivigi-v2g2dnu 1 dnul2 dn'v1 d''V 2
Finally, define the unitary operator Un, on L2(R2n) ® L2(R2n) by
a_a
a
ifi
a
Un, = UiU2 1 = e 2 (Tpag 8qTp and denote by m : 92(I[82n) ® 9(II82n) -> So(IE82n) the point-wise product of functions, (m (fl ® f2)) (p, q) = fi(p, q)f2(P, q). Then the *-product can be written in the following concise form: (3.21)
f1*n.f2=(roUn)(fi®f2).
In analogy with the Poisson bracket {
,
} on IE82n associated with the
canonical symplectic form w = dp A dq,
{fl, f2} =
Oh aft _ aft aft ,9p aq
aq ap
we introduce the notation
{®}=
a
a aq
a aq
a
a2
-
a2
ap
apl,Q2 agl ape Then it follows from the theory of Fourier transform that formula (3.21) for ,9p
the *-product can be rewritten as (3.22)
(fl *, f2)(p, q) = (e{
fi(pi, gl)f2(p2, q2)) P1=P2=P q1=q2=q
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
138
Thus we have shown that on 9'(R2,) the *-product can be equivalently defined by (3.20), or by (3.21) and (3.22). The latter representation has the advantage that the formal expansion of the exponential e- 2 { ® } into the
power series gives the asymptotic expansion of the *-product as h -> 0.
,
Namely, define the bidifferential operators
byBk=mo{
Bk : Y(R2,) ® 9(R 2n) }k fork land B0 =rn.
y(J2n)
Lemma 3.2. For every fl, f2 E y7(l[82n) and 1 E N there is C > 0 such that for all p,gEll82n I
(fl *n f2) (p, q) - E ( _i4) 2kk! Bk(fl, f2) (p, q)
Ch1+1
as
h -, 0.
k=0
Succinctly, (3.23)
f2) (p, q) + 0(h°°). (fl *n f2) (p, q) = E ( 2kh)kBk(fl, k! k=0
Proof. Expanding the exponential function e 2 (ulV2-'L2V1) into the power series and repeating the proof of Proposition 3.2 gives the result. Finally, we get another integral representation for the *-product. Applying the Fourier inversion formula to the integral over d,uld,vl in (3.20), we get (fl *h f2) (A q)
2v2, q + 2u2)f2(u27 v2)
L. .fl(p
(21f)n
e-iu2p-iv2gdnu2dnv 2 1
(271
fR2n
fl(p
][P2n
2v2,q+ 2U2)f2(p2,g2)
e-iu2p-iV2q+iu2p2+iv2g2dp2d
and changing variables pi = p (fl *ri, f2) (p, q) _
g2du2dv2,
- 2 v2, ql = q + 2 u2, we obtain 2
h
2
f f 2n
2n
e!s (plq-pql+glp2-g2p1+pq2-p2q)
fl(pl, gl)f2(p2, q2) -
pl gldnp2
q2
Let A be a Euclidean triangle (a 2-simplex) in the phase space ll 2, with the vertices (p, q), (pl, ql), and (p2i Q2). It is easy to see that/
plq-pql+glp2-g2pl+pq2-p2q=2J
0 w,
3. Weyl relations
139
which is twice the symplectic area of A - the sum of oriented areas of the (pn, qn) Thus we projections of A onto two-dimensional planes (pi, q'), have the final formula ,
(3.24)
f
2 f f1(p1, qi) f2(p2, q2) e4if rt o'd pidngidnp2d q2,
(fi *nz f2) (p, q) =
(-7r h)2-
which is a composition formula for the Weyl symbols.
Remark. It is instructive to compare formulas (3.23) and (3.24). The latter formula represents the *-product on 9(1R2,) as an absolutely convergent integral, and is equivalent to the Weyl quantization. The former formula is an asymptotic expansion of the *-product as h -> 0, and does not capture all properties of the Weyl quantization. In general, the power series in (3.23) diverges; for polynomial functions this series becomes a finite sum and gives a formula for the *-product of polynomials. Problem 3.9 (Composition formula for pq-symbols). Let fl (p, q) and f2 (p, q) be, respectively, the pq-symbols of the operators 4P1(f i) and 4P1(f2 ). Show that the pq-symbol of the operator (D1(f1)01(f2) is given by f (p, q)
(27rh)n
q)e*(P-Pi)(q-gi)dpllql
zn fl (p, gl)f2(pl,
(Hint: Use the formula for (m o U1) (fi 0 f2).)
Problem 3.10 (Composition formula for qp-symbols). Let fl(p, q) and f2(p, q) be, respectively, the qp-symbols of the operators 42(fl) and (D2 (f2). Show that the qp-symbol of the operator 'D2(f1)4D2(f2) is given by I
(p, 9) - (27rtt)' 2n Ii (pl,
ql)e R(P-P1)(q-qi) d"`pld"`q1.
(Hint: Use the formula for (m o U2 2) (fl 0 f2).)
Problem 3.11. Using (3.24) prove that the *-product is associative.
Problem 3.12. For classical observable f (p, q) define the *-exponential (the analog of the evolution operator) by
exp*f =1: -n n-o
f*hf*h...*hf. n
Compute exp*(-itHH), where H, (p, q) is the Hamiltonian function (2.27) of the harmonic oscillator.
3.5. Deformation quantization. Here we consider the quantization procedure from a formal algebraic point of view as the deformation theory of associative algebras. Let A be a C-algebra (or an associative algebra with unit over a field k of characteristic zero) with a bilinear multiplication map
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
140
mo : A ®c A -> A, which we will abbreviate as a b = mo(a, b). Denote by C[[t]] the ring of formal power series in t with coefficients in C, (C[1t]1 _ E ante : a, E C n=0 CO
and let
At=C[[t]]®cA be the C[[t]]-algebra of formal power series in t with coefficients in A. The multiplication in At is a C[[t]]-bilinear extension of the multiplication in A, which we continue to denote by mo. The algebra At is Z-graded, 00 At = ®An,
n=o
where An = tnA, so that Am Am C Am+n.
Definition. A formal deformation of a (C-algebra A with a multiplication mo is an associative algebra At over the ring C[[t]] with a C[[t]]-bilinear multiplication map mt : A®®c[[t]] At -> At such that 00
mt(a, b) = a b + E tmmn (a, b) n=1
for all a, b E A, where mn : A ®c A -> A are bilinear mappings. It follows from C[[t]]-bilinearity of mt that the associativity condition is equivalent to mt(mt(a, b), c) = mt(a, mt(b, c))
(3.25)
for all a, b, c E A.
Definition. Two formal deformations mt and rnt of a C-algebra A are equivalent if there is a C[[t]]-linear mapping Ft : At -> At such that
(i) for every a E A,
Ft(a) = a +
tnfn(a), n=1
where fn : A --> A are linear mappings; (ii) for all a, b E A, Ft(mt(a, b)) = mt (Ft (a), Ft (b)).
The bilinear maps mn satisfy infinitely many relations which are obtained by expanding (3.25) into formal power series in t. The first two of them, arising from comparing the coefficients at t and t2, are
am1(b,c)-m1(ab,c)+m1(a,bc)-m1(a,b)c=0,
3. Weyl relations
141
and
a m2 (b, c) - m2 (a b, c) + m2 (a, b c) - m2 (a, b) c = ml (ml (a, b), c) - m1 (a, ml (b, c)). In general
+mn(a,b c) -mn(a,b) - c n-1
=
1: (mj(mn-j(a, b), c) - mj(a, mn-j(b, c))). j=1
The main tool for understanding these equations and studying the deformation theory of associative algebras is the Hochschild cohomology. Namely, let M be an A-bimodule, i.e., a left and right module for the C-algebra A.
Definition. The Hochschild cochain complex C'(A, M) of a C-algebra A with coefficients in A-bimodule M is defined by the cochains C' (A, M) = Homc(A®', M), i.e., n-linear maps f (al, ... , an) on A with values in M, and the differential do : C' (A, M) --i C'n+1(A M), (dnf)(al, a2i ... , an+l) = al - f (a2, ... , an+1) n
+
E(-1)jf (al, ... , aj-l,aj - aj+1, aj+2 ... , an+1) j=1
n+1
We have d2 = 0, i.e., do+1 o do = 0, and the cohomology H' (A, M) of the complex (C'(A, M), d), Hn (A, M) = ker do / Im do-1,
is called the Hochschild cohomology of the algebra A with coefficients in the A-bimodule M. In the deformation theory of associative algebras we have the simplest
non-trivial case M = A with the left and right A-actions given by the multiplication map. The associativity equation (3.25) can be written as (d2m1)(a, b, c) = 0, n-1
(d2mn)(a, b, c) = E (mj(mn_j(a, b), c) - mj(a, mn_j(b, c)))
,
a, b, c E A.
j=l
It is quite remarkable that the Hochschild cochain complex C' (A, A) carries an additional structure of a graded Lie algebra, which plays a fundamental
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
142
role in studying the associativity equation (3.25). Namely, for f E Cm(A, A) and g E C1(A, A) let
(f o g)(al,... am+n-1) ,
M-1
E(-1)3f(al,...,aj,9(aj+l,...,aj+n),aj+n+1, ...,am+n-1),
j=o
and define g-(-1)(m-l)(n-1)g of [f, 9]G = f o The linear mapping [ , ]G : Cm (A, A) X Cn(A, A) ---* (Cm+n-1(A, A) satisfies [f 9]G = _(_1)(m-l)(n-l)[g f]G, and is called the Gerstenhaber Considering the restriction of a multiplication mt to A®c A as formal power series in t with coefficients in C' (A, A) and using the Gerstenhaber bracket, we can rewrite (3.25) in the succinct form: bracket27.
[mt, mt]G = 0.
(3.26)
Let A be a commutative C-algebra, and let At be a formal deformation of A. Define the bilinear map { } : A ®c A --> A by ,
(3.27)
{a, b} = ml (a, b) - ml (b, a),
a, b E A.
Lemma 3.3. A formal deformation At of a commutative C-algebra A equips A with a Poisson algebra structure with the bracket { , I.
Proof. Consider the equation dµ1 (a, b, c) = 0. Subtracting from it the equation with a and c interchanged, and using the commutativity of A, we obtain
{a, b c}=a {b,c}-c {a, b}. Interchanging b and c, we get
and interchanging further a and c, we obtain
{a,b}-b {c, a}.
{a c,b} - {c,
Adding the first and third equations and subtracting the second equation gives
so that the skew-symmetric cochain { } E C2 (A, A) satisfies the Leibniz rule. To prove the Jacobi identity, observe that mt(a, b) - mt(b, a) (3.28) {a, b} = mod tAt. ,
t
27Together with the cup product of cochains, the Gerstenhaber bracket equips C' (A, A) with the structure of a Gerstenhaber algebra.
3. Weyl relations
143
Using associativity condition (3.25) (associativity modulo t2 At is sufficient) we get
{{a, b}, c} + {{c, a}, b} + {{b, c}, a} = t2 ((mt(mt(a, b) - mt(b, a)), c) -mt(c, mt(a, b) - mt(b, a)) + mt(mt(c, a) - mt(a, c), b) -mt(b, mt(c, a) - mt(a, c)) + mt(mt(b, c) - mt(c, b), a) -mt(a, mt(b, c) - mt(c, b))) mod tAt = 0.
This result motivates the following definition.
Definition. A deformation quantization of a Poisson algebra (A, { , }) with the commutative product mo : A ®c A -* A is a formal deformation At of an algebra A such that the multiplication map mt satisfies (3.28).
By Lemma 3.3, every formal deformation At of a commutative algebra A is a deformation quantization of the Poisson algebra (A, { , }) with the Poisson bracket given by (3.27). According to Lemma 3.2, a deformation quantization of the Poisson algebra (97(R27`), { , }), where the Poisson bracket is associated with the canonical symplectic form w = dp A dq, is the algebra 9(R2") [[t]], where t = -ih and h is considered as a formal parameter, and the multiplication map is given by the *-product. The following statement is a formal algebraic analog of the representation (3.22) for the *-product.
Theorem 3.4 (Universal deformation). Let A be a commutative C-algebra with the multiplication map mo, and let cpl and cp2 be two commuting derivations of A, i.e., linear maps cpl, cp2 : A ---p A satisfying Leibniz rule and (P1 o 02 = P2 0'1 Then
{a, b} = cp1(a) cp2 (b) - cp2 (a) cp1(b),
a, b E A,
defines a Poisson bracket on A, and the formula
mt=mooet',
4 =cp1®cp2,
called the universal deformation formula, gives a deformation quantization of the Poisson algebra (A, { , }).
Proof. The Jacobi identity for the bracket { } follows from the commutativity of the derivations cpl and cp2. To show that At is a deformation quantization of the Poisson algebra (A, { , }), we need to verify the associativity condition (3.25) for the map mt. Let A : A -> A ®c A be the ,
coproduct map,
0(a)=a®1+1®a, aEA.
2. Basic Principles of Quantum Mechanics
144
It extends to a C-linear mapping from Homc(A, A) to Homc(A®2, A®2), which we continue to denote by A, and A(cp) = cp ®id + id ®cp,
cp E Homc (A, A).
To prove (3.25), we observe that the Leibniz rule and the binomial formula yield the following identity for a derivation cp of A: etc o mo = mo o etA('O).
Using commutativity of cpl and cp2i we obtain c)) = mo(eto(a ® mo(et '(b ® c)))) mt(a, mt(b,
= (moo (id®mo))(et(id®0)(D)etid®(D(a ® b 0 c)) = (moo
(id®mo))(et(id®0)(4D)+t id (&4) (a
0 b 0 c)),
where (id ®0)((D) = 01 ®0002) E A®3. Similarly, mt(mt(a, b), c) = (mo o (mo 0 id))(et(o®id)(4))+t4)®id(a ® b ® c)),
where
A(co1)®cp2 E A®3. Since moo (id(&mo) =moo (mooid),
the associativity of the multiplication mt is equivalent to (A ® id) (-(D) + 4, ® id = (id ®0) (4)) + id ®4-,
which is obviously satisfied since
= W1 ®cp2.
In general, 2n pair-wise commuting derivations cpi on a commutative algebra A define a Poisson bracket on A, n
{a, b} = 1: (cpi(a) - Vi+n(b) - Bpi+n(a) . oi(b)), i=1
and deformation quantization of the corresponding Poisson algebra (A, { , }) is given by the universal deformation formula
mt = mo o et
n
i=1(Wi®Wi+n-'Pi+n®Wi
A deformation quantization of a Poisson manifold (4', { }) (see Section 2.7 in Chapter 1) is, by definition, a deformation quantization of the ,
corresponding Poisson algebra of classical observables (C°°(.1'ff), { , }) with
the property that the linear maps mn, n > 1, are bidifferential operators28. The formal power series expansion (3.22) of the *-product is a deformation quantization of the Poisson manifold (R2n, { , }), where the Poisson bracket corresponding to the canonical symplectic form w = dp A dq. 28This property ensures that the unit in Poisson algebra is preserved under the deformation.
3. Weyl relations
145
Problem 3.13. Show that C' (A, A) is a graded Lie algebra with respect to the Gerstenhaber bracket, i.e., that [ , ]c satisfies the graded Jacobi identity (-1)(n-1)(P-1)
(-1)(--1)(P-1)[f, [g, h]] +
[h, [f, g]] +
(-1)(m-1)(n-1) [g, [h, f]]
=0
for all f E Ct'(A,A),g E CT(A,A),h E C1(A,A).
Problem 3.14. Verify that do f = [1' mo]c, where f E C't (A, A) and do is the Hochschild differential.
Problem 3.15. Show that deformation quantizations associated with Weyl, pq, and qp-quantizations are equivalent. (In fact, all deformation quantizations of the canonical Poisson manifold (R In, {
,
}) are equivalent.)
Problem 3.16. Let g be a finite-dimensional Lie algebra with a basis x1i ... , xn, and let g* be its dual space equipped with the Lie-Poisson bracket {
,
} (see Problem
2.20 in Section 2.7 of Chapter 1). For u E g* and x = E 1 ixi, y = E 1 i xi E g let
eu(i logetsetl-x-y)
_
a,,,3 (u, t)070, a,A
where
(S1)a ...
i 70 = (ij1)0.... (gn)Rn, be the formal group law -
the "Baker-Campbell-Hausdorff series". Show that the product
mt(fl,f2) =
a.0(u,t)Dafl(u)D1 f2(u),
f1, f2 E Co"(9*),
a'O
J where for a multi-index a = (al, ... , an) and f E C' (9*), DO, f = a° aul...au°n gives a deformation quantization of the Poisson manifold (g*, {
,
}).
Problem 3.17. Let (G, { }) be a Lie-Poisson group, where q(g) = ,
and non-degenerate r satisfies the classical Yang-Baxter equation (see Problems 2.21