Professional Learning as Relational Practice
Jenny Reeves
Professional Learning as Relational Practice
123
Dr. Jenny Reeves University of Stirling Stirling Inst. Education Stirling United Kingdom FK9 4LA
[email protected]
ISBN 978-90-481-8738-6 e-ISBN 978-90-481-8739-3 DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-8739-3 Springer Dordrecht Heidelberg London New York Library of Congress Control Number: 2010921590 © Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010 No part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, microfilming recording or otherwise, without written permission from the Publisher, with the exception of any material supplied specificall for the purpose of being entered and executed on a computer system, for exclusive use by the purchaser of the work. Printed on acid-free paper Springer is part of Springer Science+Business Media (www.springer.com)
Preface
For many years, I have been engaged in the professional education of experienced teachers, working with them to try and change practice for the better in schools on courses with a substantive element of practice-based learning in their design. I have been impressed by what many of the teachers have achieved in their classrooms and as leaders and managers in their schools. However, over time, the results have often been disappointing in terms of sustaining new ways of working. When searching the literature to try to gain a better understanding of what changing practice entails what I have read has often seemed at odds with my observations. Texts either were exhortatory, promoting approaches to changing practice that were essentially rational, staged and planned, or provided accounts that were interesting in relation to certain aspects of professional learning but, nevertheless, somehow incomplete. What I was experiencing were processes that were, in contrast, frequently messy, surprising, complicated and contested. It is this gap, between accounts and experiences of practice-based learning, which this book sets out to explore, the gap between the experience of an interactive, dynamic, and socially contextualised process and descriptions that are often individualistic, overly linear and largely context-free. My claim is that this difference between ‘theory’ and ‘practice’ is both conceptual and methodological in that a restrictive and narrow framing of professional learning is both the corollary and the outcome of modes of enquiry that, in their turn, concentrate on a limited selection of data in exploring such learning. In order to counteract this problem, I have adopted a relational approach to describing practice-based professional development, which includes the use of graphical means for representing the material spaces and interactions produced by the activity. Drawing provides a means of representing the varied movements, relationships and interactions of people and things occurring in the course of learning processes that tend to get lost in words. By building a picture of the ephemeral spaces and connections that educating activities produce, mapping relational space allows for a more holistic overview of what is happening during processes of professional change. Given that we are witnessing a transformation in the form and structures of professional work through developments such as enquiry-based practice and transdisciplinary approaches to service provision, there is an urgent need for those of us involved in the fiel of professional education to develop a more robust v
vi
Preface
understanding of the dynamics of changing professional practice. This has to be based on a more inclusive approach to the analysis of the processes involved across the varied and interrelated contexts in which they occur. Thus the central claim of this book is that our capacity to understand the development of professional knowledge and practice is both transformed and enhanced by examining the events that are implicated in processes of professional learning. Event analysis allows us to map the learning spaces created by educating processes and track the movement of people and ideas between them. Mapping relational space provides a new way of undertaking qualitative and quantitative research into activity systems, including investigating knowledge exchange and creation in the networked contexts that we all inhabit in our professional lives. The chapters in this book draw on empirical work much of which has already been published as journal articles. The initial investigation of the Scottish Qualificatio for Headship (SQH) programme was reported in Reeves & Forde, 2004 and in Reeves et al., 2005. In 2003, I was part of a team that secured a commission to work with a local authority’s education department to support and evaluate the implementation of an organisational learning strategy. In tracking the inception of this initiative and the early stages of its implementation, we had access to many of the key events during which new ideas and practices in relation to school improvement were debated and framed. In trying to preserve the complex interconnections within this series of events, I began to develop event and content analysis as a means of deriving a visual representation of activity (Reeves & Boreham, 2006). In the interim, the continuing professional development team at Stirling University introduced a new practice-based master’s programme, Professional Enquiry in Education (2001), aimed at teachers interested in qualifying as chartered teachers (CT). Building on what we had learned from the SQH, the team designed this course to support collaborative learning; we also increased the level and rhythm of interaction between activity at the university and activities in the participants’ schools. Over the next 4 years, further investigations into participating teachers’ experiences of this CT programme, and of our own practice, formed the basis of a series of seminars that opened up other aspects of investigation into practice-based learning and its interconnections with the wider fiel of educating (Reeves & I’Anson, 2006; Reeves, 2007; Reeves & Fox, 2008).
Acknowledgements
I would like to thank colleagues who have been engaged in the conversations, debates and activities centred on the work of the Western SQH Consortium and the Partnership for Professional Enquiry that led to the thesis outlined in this book, including all those who have allowed access to their work and their thoughts in the course of various research studies. In particular, I have to thank those I have worked with as co-authors on the various papers that form the basis of this present text and members of the Professional Development team at the University of Stirling who pioneered putting many of these ideas into practice.
vii
Contents
1 Adopting a New Approach to Professional Learning . . . . . . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Looking at Professional Learning from a Relational Perspective Delineating Educating Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Plan of the Book . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Part I: Mapping the Relational Spaces of Educating . . . . . . . . Part II: Exploring Professional Learning as Relational Practice . . Part III: Tracking Knowledge Creation and Exchange . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
1 1 1 4 6 7 8 9
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
13 13 13 17 19 19 20 22 23 24 25 30 32
3 The Field of Educating: Tracking Relations and Relays . . . . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Educating as a Field of Activity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A Typology for Educating Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . An Order of Discourse . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Making Sense of Organisational Learning . . . . . . . . . . . . . Surfacing Pedagogies, Relays and Discursive Struggle . . . . . . . Representing Relays and Networks: Building a Relational Map . Pedagogic Strategy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
33 33 34 35 39 42 48 48 51
Part I
Mapping the Relational Spaces of Educating
2 Describing Educating Systems . . . . . . . . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . What Is the Scottish Qualificatio for Headship? The Parameters of Educating Systems . . . . Developing a Descriptive Framework . . . . . . Five Criteria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mediated Learning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Situated Learning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Activity Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Actor Network Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . Mapping Techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
ix
x
Contents
Discursive Struggle . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Making Learning Spaces Visible . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Relational Space . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Forms of Spatiality . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Assembling the Tool Set for Durational Mapping . . . . . . Event Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Participation: People . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Participation: Artefacts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Spaces and Flows . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Spatial Patterning of Interaction on the SQH Programme Mapping the System as Time and Space . . . . . . . . . . The Durational Representation of the SQH . . . . . . . . Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Applications of Mapping Relational Space . . . . . . . . . . Using Mapping for Investigation and Design . . . . . . . Effects of Hybridity in Educating Systems . . . . . . . . . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Summary Part I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Part II
54 55
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
57 57 58 58 60 60 62 64 65 67 67 68 73 74 74 77 81 81
Professional Learning as Relational Practice
5 Changing Self: Interactions of Space and Identity . . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Practice-Based Learning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Professional Practice . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Implications for Professional Learning . . . . . . . . . Learning During Practice-Based Programmes . . . . . Tracking Discursive Change in Reflect ve Commentaries Annette . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jean . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Dynamics of the Learning Process . . . . . . . . . . In-Built Contingency . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Enacted Social Space . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Imagined Social Space . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Outcomes of Interaction: The Creation of Third Space Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
85 85 86 86 87 89 91 92 96 98 98 100 102 103 106
6 Pedagogy: Creating a Hub in a Field of Relays Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pedagogy and Purpose . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A Psychological Approach . . . . . . . . . . . A Sociological Perspective . . . . . . . . . . . Agency and Intentionality . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
107 107 107 108 110 112
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
Contents
xi
Pedagogy on the Chartered Teacher Programme: Section 1 The Intentions of Educators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Relay 1: Shaping the Learner – Being Postgraduate . . . . Relay 2: Shaping the Learner – Being a Chartered Teacher Relay 3: Disciplinary Governance . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pedagogy on the Chartered Teacher Programme: Section 2 The Actions of Educators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Collaborative Learning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Reflect ve Practice . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pedagogic Practices – Relaying Agency . . . . . . . . . . . Creating the Activity Set . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mixing Theoretical and Practical Knowledge . . . . . . . Creating and Rebundling Connections . . . . . . . . . . . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
113 115 116 120
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
121 124 125 127 128 129 130 132
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
133 133 134 134 138 141 142 144 145 146 147 147 149 151 152
8 Knowledge Creation: The Reflex vity of Hybrid Systems . . . . . . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Knowledge and Activity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Refl xivity and Reflectio . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Knowledge Creation and the CT Programme . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Outcomes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Stage 1: Multiplicity – Performing the CT Programme as a Networked System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Stage 2: The System in Action – Knowledge Exchange and Creation Characteristics of a Hybrid System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Knowledge Exchange and Creation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Forms of Forgetting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Network Effects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
157 157 157 160 162 166
. . . . . . .
166 169 172 172 174 174 176
7 Constructing Knowledge and Agency . . . . . . . . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Teacher Professionalism and Chartered Teachers . . . . Contradictory Conceptions of Professionalism . . . The Construction of Reflect ve Reports . . . . . . . . . Using Sources External to the School Community . . Using Sources Internal to the School Community . . Rhetorical Devices and the Making of ‘War’ Machines Re-contextualising and Creating Knowledge . . . . Displaying Expertise . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ‘Proven’ Experience . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Shaped Experience . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Power to Influenc Others . . . . . . . . . . . . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Summary Part II . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Part III Tracking Knowledge Creation and Exchange
xii
9 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Describing Educating as Relational Practice Substantive Issues in Professional Learning Implications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Contents
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
179 179 181 184
References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
187
Author Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
197
Subject Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
201
Chapter 1
Adopting a New Approach to Professional Learning
Introduction Whilst it sometimes seems that every book on education starts with the claim that everything is changing there is an opposite refrain, particularly with regard to professional practice in the public services. This is to the effect that some practices show a remarkable resilience despite repeated efforts to alter them. In this respect the ‘incapacity’ of public education services to respond appropriately to the needs of pupils, of hospitals to care for their patients and of social services to protect the vulnerable is an ongoing source of complaint. Continuing professional development (CPD) is seen as one of the answers to these problems. In education, there is a widespread belief amongst policy makers that the reform of classroom practice will come about through engaging teachers in CPD based on sound evidence of how pupils learn best. The problem with this solution is that much of this evidence has been around for some time and has already constituted the basis for various efforts at reform, many of which have come and gone whilst leaving remarkably little trace of their passage. For example, initiatives based on constructivist approaches to teaching and learning introduced in the UK in the 1970s and 1980s (Stenhouse, 1975; Brandes & Ginnis, 1986; Driver & Oldham, 1986) failed to become an integral part of classroom practice. These have been revisited in more recent national projects such as those associated with the implementation of formative assessment (Black, 2003) once again with a mixed prognosis for success (Priestly & Sime, 2005)
Looking at Professional Learning from a Relational Perspective The predominant approach to the professional development of teachers has been both individualistic and transmissive. Generally courses and programmes are still based on the assumption that teachers need to be told about and trial new teaching techniques during workshop-based courses which they can then implement with pupils. There has been a realisation in some quarters that there is also a need for support when it comes to transposing skills and knowledge from workshops to classrooms (Joyce & Showers, 1988). Over the years such support has been provided by allying professional and school development in the use of action learning cycles J. Reeves, Professional Learning as Relational Practice, C Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010 DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-8739-3_1,
1
2
1 Adopting a New Approach to Professional Learning
(Hopkins et al., 1994), through coaching (Lieberman, 1986), and through the use of collaborative action research networks (Campbell et al., 2004), as means of overcoming barriers to integrating new teaching approaches into classroom and school routines. Nevertheless, the problem remains that professional development often does not work very well, or rather it may work for a while, but its effects are not sustained (Eraut, 2004). In a sense this is the reiteration of an old and familiar problem, that of knowledge transfer or the lack of effective means by which new forms of practice can be transposed across different contexts. The question this raises is whether or not there is an issue with the way that we think about professional learning. The reason for asking this question is not simply to try and resolve a technical problem regarding the effica y of professional development but also provoked by what teachers say about their learning. A group of us from the universities of Stirling and Glasgow undertook a 2-year investigation into the effects that the Scottish Qualificatio for Headship (SQH) course had on 40 of the candidates who completed it in 2000. This was a postgraduate programme that combined taught and work-based learning modules as part of enabling students to address an occupational standard. Participants communicated a sense of being between different social worlds, relationships and languages as they moved from the taught to the work-based elements of the course and back. They associated these movements with personal change and professional growth and also with political and ideational work in their schools to gain and maintain opportunities to alter practice. Whilst we knew that this programme was a hybrid, combining elements of a traditional postgraduate taught course with practice-based learning in schools, we had not paid much heed to the effects that this mixing of pedagogic strategies would have on participants. The evidence from this study drew our attention to the importance of perceptions of difference in this particular educative process and how difference was experienced as a direct outcome of the interaction between the various learning spaces that the SQH programme created. These teachers did not construe their learning as the simple acquisition and application of knowledge and skills but as a far more complex process embedded in changes to their relationships with people and things, their professional identities, their knowledge and their capacity for action. They were pointing to who they were and who they had become through the experience of the programme. In other words they represented their learning as a complex interactional and relational process that was contextually grounded. This led to thinking that, in investigating professional learning, one of the problems may be the convention, at least in the UK, of thinking about education, including teacher education, in terms of teaching and learning. This framing of practice has become leached of meaning over time with teaching increasingly being treated as a largely technical matter of exercising an efficien means to achieve learning, which has been reduced to the achievement of ‘outcomes’ in a neat lock-step trajectory punctuated by assessment. Between the two poles, teaching and learning, the complex interactions of persons and things over time have tended to get lost, and with it the notion of educating as a process of shaping and forming persons. This fundamental purpose of pedagogy, that people should change and become
Introduction
3
different as a result of education, has been pushed into the background despite the increasing dominance of standards and arrays of outcomes that seek to specify what persons should be like. For this reason, I have chosen to use the term educating when referring to programmes of professional development as a more ‘honest’ concept, because it admits of intentions on the part of educators to shape the character and practice of those who are being educated. The explicit inclusion of educative purpose also factors issues of power into the interrelationship of those who ‘deliver’ professional development, as teacher educators, and those engaged in it, as participants. Within this definition I am including as educators and educating all forms of initiatives, such as school improvement, where one group is attempting to mould the behaviour of another. Educating is a more holistic term not only politically but also because it involves teachers and learners in a single process that they perform together, emphasising that, even though the power balance is traditionally very one-sided, this is a joint activity. In its non-transitive form, as in educating oneself, it also allows for the extension of intentionality, in terms of becoming different, as a desire of the learner. Spatially too, on practice-based programmes, it directs consideration to the whole of the educating activity across the different contexts in which it takes place. Educating may still be occurring without the embodied presence of a teacher. In the case of experienced practitioners, educating activity on practice-based courses concerns both what happens in schools as learning contexts for teachers and what happens in the spaces where they meet with tutors, coaches and trainers. Such an examination across contexts foregrounds the nature of the interactions between the two. Confinin the description of teaching and learning to a largely technical level has also helped to isolate this interactive process from the matrix of relations in which it is embedded. A technicist interpretation tends to hide from view the ways of seeing, and being in the world, that these external connections bring to the conduct of educating. It helps to make what happens between educators and practitioners on a professional development course appear to occur in a separate world, sealed off from other aspects of their professional lives. For example, when recounting narratives of movement between spaces the SQH participants also personifie things, like the Standard for Headship (SOEID, 1998b) and the programme itself, as ‘making’ them act in certain ways. The attribution of agency to things was intriguing because of the clear connections this had to the political aspects of changing practice that figure prominently in their accounts. More importantly, it pointed to the interpenetration of the educating process through its external relations, in this case by a particular discourse as a way of framing and understanding what school leadership and management was and how it ought to be conducted. The inclusion of these external relations impinges on the key characteristic of educating which is its role in sense making since it is directed to the acquisition, development and creation of knowledge on the part of learners. Again, an inclusive relational approach to investigating professional learning has a much wider scope than enquiring into specifi learning outcomes for individual practitioners because it is concerned with how both professional educators and practitioners make sense of their professional worlds and of themselves and others within them. There is a claim
4
1 Adopting a New Approach to Professional Learning
here that knowledge and skills that are transformational of practice are not separable from the professional identities of the persons who acquire and use them. A relational approach to educating raises questions about what those acting as educators are making of the process they are engaged in: What kind of persons and knowledge are they seeking to produce and how does their professional practice link to these purposes? Lastly, in the feedback from the research, our students were alerting us to the materiality of educating, to how the educating process was experienced as a series of lived events. This drew attention to the nature of educating as a performance, as a process of co-production, something that the educators and learners make in the course of their joint activity. On this account professional change was something that was constructed in the spaces that educating created in time. It implied that a spatiotemporal approach was needed to describe what professional learning entailed. The students’ responses pushed us back to basics in our enquiry about learning, to asking simple empirical questions like what is happening here, who and what is involved in this activity, what are people doing, what are they making and using, where and how are they moving over time. Summarising the argument so far, the aspiring headteachers’ responses to questions about the nature of their learning indicated that there was a need to think about their experiences very differently from the way we had done in the past. It involved a change to conceiving learning as a matter of relations between spaces over time people and things being and becoming power and agency discourse and identity Whilst this did not suggest an easy answer to the question of why changing practice was so difficul to sustain, it did begin to indicate that looking at professional learning in a more inclusive and holistic fashion might well be fruitful for developing a greater understanding of the problem.
Delineating Educating Systems However, adopting a relational approach to investigating educating as a practice is problematic. If the aim of enquiry is to achieve a holistic and inclusive description of activity, then the outcome of the endeavour is necessarily complex and complexity is difficul to describe. The narrative forms we tend to use in qualitative research to delineate processes are not very satisfactory in this regard; they are well suited to tracking the trajectory of a single, common ‘entity’ or for expressing one viewpoint in relation to a process but much less effective for dealing with many trajectories, or considering the interactions of equally valid, but differing viewpoints i.e. holding in
Introduction
5
mind a number of perspectives. Dealing with relationality and multiplicity is diff cult both linguistically and conceptually; on the other hand, not dealing with these factors seriously limits our view of complex social activities such as educating. Another corollary of taking a relational view of activity is that it involves looking at networks which are, by their nature, extensive. Therefore, one needs some means of setting limits to the object of one’s enquiries if the latter are to be feasible. I have chosen to use the notion of an educating system where what define such a system is the educational object of the activity. On these grounds an educating system is made up of all those activities that form part of pursuing an educational object. Thus the SQH is an educating system that encompasses all those activities that go to make up the process of enabling teachers to be recognised as having achieved the Standard for Headship in Scotland. Equally, this definitio could be applied to other forms of professional development. For example, one could defin an action research project that seeks to develop practitioners’ knowledge through involving them as lead researchers working with university staff to share and publish knowledge generated as a result of collaborative classroom enquiries as an educating system. Here the educator function would largely rest with the funders (central government and local authorities) and their agents (university staff). In both cases the educational object determines the limits of the system as encompassing all those activities that actors would acknowledge as playing a part in its pursuit. There is a caveat here, since what comprises a system varies according to the differing points of view of the actors involved, their experiences of the activity will always be partial and dependent on their particular role, a caveat which applies equally to anyone acting as a researcher. These kinds of systems are open systems that interact with their environment so that, whilst it is possible to defin their boundaries in terms of the object of activity, each of them has connections with other systems as part of the matrix of relations in which it is embedded. Thus a relational view also requires that we have a way of tracking the network of connections between systems, paying regard to the external relations a system has as well as to the internal connections that characterise its operation. It is on these grounds that developing a visual mode of representation for activity has such an appeal because complex relational information is far more easily conveyed in an image than it is in words. Any such representation also needs to have a temporal dimension since learning and change take place over time. Over the last 9 years I have been trying to make sense of these issues by tracking what happened, as my colleagues and I engaged in educating experienced practitioners. During this time I gradually developed and refine methods for describing the complex interrelationships that these enquiries revealed. In so doing I have become increasingly literal, pedantic and inclusive with regard to material evidence. Rather than cutting out data as irrelevant or ignoring seemingly petty details, I have tried to retain it all and stay with the material complexities of the processes I have been investigating. Rather than dissecting information into separate categories, I have tried to fin ways of preserving its interrelationships. Part of the answer to making sense of all this material was to focus on events and how these and their relations could be define and ‘measured’. Issues of time and space were key to achieving
6
1 Adopting a New Approach to Professional Learning
this objective. The challenge has been to describe the activity systems that are performed by these events in a way that locates the resultant systems materially in time and space, is ‘true’ to their embodied and dynamic nature and retains the interrelationships between their components and their connections to related activity systems. In following the object of my enquiries I have come to realise that what I have been looking at are essentially networked systems of activity that are themselves embedded in a complex matrix of networked systems. Exploring relational space reveals a frequently disregarded world that is fascinating in its complexity and dynamism. It also highlights the simplification and exclusions we maintain in order to make sense of our daily lives. In that regard, the series of studies that this book relates will hopefully offer new and interesting ways of both perceiving the activity of educating and thinking about pedagogic issues. There is, of course, an inherent fault in this enterprise since any framing necessarily places restrictions on the data available and, in that sense, misrepresents the interrelationships that occur in practice. Nevertheless, given the marked exclusions of traditional framings of activity, an approach that enables the dynamics of educating to be described with greater plausibility is worth pursuing. Current ways of representing educating limit our capacity both to explore practice and to consider forms and pedagogies that may be better suited to our needs.
The Plan of the Book In writing the book I have tried to overtake two main objectives: • to outline a methodology for investigating the activity of educating in practicebased systems whose object is to bring about professional learning; and • to describe processes in which professional learning occurs in relational terms, in that sense to reconceptualise how professional learning may be described and understood as both process and practice. To meet these two goals the book is divided into three parts. Part I largely concentrates on methodological issues and how the spatio-temporal nature of changing practice, as professional learning, may be represented and investigated without losing sight of its dynamic and relational nature. In so doing it seeks a new way of describing the operation of networked systems. Part II explores what a relational and spatial approach to describing educating reveals about the interface between professional practitioners, their educators and their joint activity. It examines the interrelations between the different spaces created by practice-based professional development programmes emphasising the lived and embodied quality of educating practices. In so doing, it demonstrates the kinds of substantive issues in relation to professional learning that the techniques outlined in Part I can be used to explore.
Part I: Mapping the Relational Spaces of Educating
7
Part III concentrates on issues of knowledge creation and exchange in the networked systems created by the implementation of hybrid pedagogies and the implications this has for professional learning at a collective level and in particular the role of higher education in this field Within this structure, each chapter starts by outlining the background to a particular theme, which leads into a case study section chosen to illustrate it. This is followed by a discussion as to the significanc of the evidence and what it contributes to furthering our understanding of the theme. Because the book is about the relational aspects of activity, the case study sections are quite complex and lengthy and the maps that accompany the text are also quite complicated. There is an inescapable dilemma here since the rationale for the methodology on which the book is based is the preservation and inclusion of data rather than its simplifica tion through selection. I have tried to ease the burden on the reader by setting out the aspects of the case that are particularly germane to the argument at the beginning of each of the case study sections and by building up the maps in Part I step by step in order to clarify the protocols that are being used in their composition. For many readers the maps will not be critical to their understanding of the argument but for those interested in investigating practices in relational terms or designing systems to promote learning they do provide productive new tools for analysis.
Part I: Mapping the Relational Spaces of Educating The key features that are characteristic of networked educating systems are set out in Chapter 2, which establishes a set of criteria for developing a suitable array of tools for their analysis. It looks at various socio-cultural approaches to changing practice and developing knowledge; situated learning, activity theory and actor network theory, and provides an assessment of their strengths and weaknesses as orientations for exploring relational processes. Different techniques for mapping various aspects of social interaction are also discussed. The chapter ends by setting out the approach that is adopted in this book and how it both draws upon and extends previous work on the examination and description of activity systems. Chapter 3 seeks to locate practice-based educating systems, such as that described in Chapter 2, in the wider fiel of educational activity. Distinctions are made between educating systems on the basis of their pedagogic strategies resulting in a fourfold typology: socialising, schooling, developmental and contagious systems. The f rst two are characterised as assimilative pedagogic strategies, since learners enter the educators’ domain of practice, whereas the last two are characterised as invasive strategies, with the educators entering and attempting to disrupt practice in the learners’ territory. This typology is linked to an order of discourse, which provides the background to a case study that tracks the progress of a developmental educating initiative in a local authority. The case is used to generate a relational map for the implementation of the initiative, which provides a graphic illustration of the discursive connections that fuelled the conceptual and political work required to secure an initial commitment to the implementation of change in this particular case.
8
1 Adopting a New Approach to Professional Learning
The representation of relational space as the ephemeral, but nevertheless material and embodied, space produced by the performance of an activity is the subject of Chapter 4. It explains the key elements of event analysis and how this, linked to discursive analysis of the content of activity, provides the basis for durational mapping. These techniques are then applied to generate durational maps of two different versions of the SQH programme. Comparing the two maps illustrates the spatial differences between schooling and hybrid (schooling and developmental) educating systems. The comparison of the maps focuses attention on certain features of design in educating systems including spatiality, movement, rhythm and sequence and how these features relate to resourcing and knowledge exchange. It also demonstrates that such comparisons can be both qualitative and quantitative opening up the possibility of framing a number of new questions about educating activities for empirical investigation.
Part II: Exploring Professional Learning as Relational Practice Evidence of ‘discursive’ change in the texts produced by students on a practicebased postgraduate programme and its link to new experiences engendered by undertaking collaborative projects in the work setting forms the subject of Chapter 5. This chapter explores the interaction of ideas, identity and professional action that is provoked by having to bridge the intersection of two social spaces: the space created in the educators’ territory (the cohort learning space) and that of the participant’s work setting. Bridging the two can lead to the creation of third space as a space of interference between different forms of activity where professional practice may be changed. The chapter explores the issues that arise between the learning of the individual and the groups they interact with, pointing to the political, as well as the conceptual work embedded in processes of developing practice. Continuing the examination of the interface between educators, students and educating activity, Chapter 6 concentrates on the other half of the student/educator dyad. It examines two major themes: issues of intentionality and agency on the part of educators and issues of pedagogy, exploring the way in which the educating process is structured and managed by educators. It illustrates how educators can create and use social space by looking at how taught sessions are structured and ‘performed’ with a focus on the way in which professional practitioners’ perceptions and practice may be shaped by the use of various pedagogic devices. Chapter 7 explores the use that the students make of the resources provided by practice-based learning programmes. As in Chapter 5, a key theme is how knowledge is constructed, but this time the focus is on its rhetorical function. The case study looks at how the students make use of the more traditional resources that a schooling system provides (access to reading, discussions, ‘researcher’ and ‘scholar’ roles and written composition). The nature of the knowledge they develop and its power to influenc the behaviour of others is seen by the students as crucial in enabling them to sustain personal growth as well as to secure the involvement
Part III: Tracking Knowledge Creation and Exchange
9
of others in collaborative action. It is argued that the mixing of spaces and texts in students’ narrative accounts enables them to build a basis to figh for and win the space to change their own and others’ practice.
Part III: Tracking Knowledge Creation and Exchange The creation and transformation of knowledge in the process of educating within the system at a more holistic level is the subject of Chapter 8. It argues that hybrid educating systems have considerable productive potential because of their in-built refl xivity. Durational mapping of the system created by the chartered teacher programme, focusing on the activity of the tutors, is used to illustrate the complexity of the spatial structures involved and their fecundity in terms of generating new knowledge. The implications of hybridity for the promotion of professional learning and the creation and exchange of knowledge across the wider fiel of professional practice are explored. Chapter 9 draws the whole together and considers some of the issues that viewing learning as a relational practice raises for those working in professional contexts, particularly as educators of experienced professionals in higher education.
Part I
Mapping the Relational Spaces of Educating
Introduction to Part I The purpose of the firs part of this book is to lay out a set of tools that may be used for the analysis and representation of social activity as dynamic, material performances involving people, things and actions. It is based on the search for a means of coming to grips with a set of related problems: • understanding the lived materiality of professional learning as practice; • findin a means of creating a processual understanding of educating as action over time; • investigating the productivity (of particular cases) of educating activity in the making of patterns of connecting and interfering spaces; and • maintaining as integrative a positioning as possible in trying to describe the relationalities of such practices. It does so by examining the operation of educating systems. The approach aimed at affecting the practice of established practitioners. The three chapters in Part I outline a spatio-temporal approach to the analysis of practice-based educating systems. The approach concentrates on the relational aspects of their operation, including both their internal and their external connections as parts of networked field of activity. The systems that are examined are an organisational learning initiative in a local authority’s education service and a postgraduate programme for aspiring head teachers (SQH). The latter was implemented in two forms, one of which, known as the standard route, used a substantial element of work-based learning, whilst the other, the accelerated route, accredited prior experiential learning. In examining the textual data generated by these educating systems, discourse and event analysis are used to draw up relational and durational maps of activity as a means of representing the complexities of these systems’ functioning over time. Whilst the maps are presented in this book as part of case study narratives, in the course of an empirical enquiry they are a primary means of analysing and synthesising data in spatio-temporal terms. Methodologically, durational map making occurs as an analytical process; the map that results is therefore the analysis rather than, as it occurs here, an illustration of a narrative.
Chapter 2
Describing Educating Systems
Introduction In order to provide an overview of the kind of educating systems that I have been seeking to investigate and describe, this firs chapter begins by delineating the activities and interrelations involved in the performance of a particular course. This is a programme for aspiring headteachers, which was introduced in Scotland in 1998. The description of this particular educating system illustrates the key dimensions that need to be incorporated into any tool set that would allow for mapping the dynamic interrelations that the performance of this programme gives rise to. Subsequently, these dimensions are used to generate criteria for evaluating what kind of investigational tools are required for achieving a relational view of this type of activity. The second half of the chapter explores various approaches to investigating social activity, using the criteria that were generated in the f rst exercise. This serves to identify some of the ideas that relate to the analytic methods that will be developed in Part I and also, where some of the more obvious gaps lie in the description and representation of dynamic systems and the development and use of knowledge as part of educating. The chapter concludes by summarising the approach I intend to adopt in order to develop a more relational view of educating systems that seek to support professional development of teachers.
What Is the Scottish Qualificatio for Headship? Picking up on the issues that were outlined in the introductory chapter I am going to begin by trying to illustrate what I mean by an educating system in order to show, if we focus on a particular purpose, or object, for educating this allows us to delineate the extent of the activity and therefore to get an idea of the parameters that apply in attempting to describe it. I shall start by posing a single question: What is the Scottish Qualificatio for Headship? A question to which I shall give a number of seemingly disparate answers, each of which is empirically defensible, to illustrate the kind of complexities that the book sets out to explore. J. Reeves, Professional Learning as Relational Practice, C Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010 DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-8739-3_2,
13
14
2
Describing Educating Systems
Answer 1: It is an activity that enables teachers to gain a qualification In 1998 a new programme was introduced in Scotland to ensure that teachers were prepared for taking on the role of headteacher in Scottish schools. The Scottish Qualificatio for Headship (SQH) was a course of leadership and management development that was introduced, and sponsored, by the Scottish Offic Education and Industry Department (SOEID). It is a practice-based learning programme designed to enable participants to demonstrate competence against an occupational standard, The Standard for Headship in Scotland (SOEID, 1998b). The production of national programme guidelines and an insistence on joint institutional governance led to the formation of three consortia, consisting of universities and local authorities. These were authorised by SOEID to deliver the programme that takes just over 2 years to complete. Successful candidates gain the professional award (SQH) and a postgraduate diploma, and this is the object of the activity. Answer 2: It is a set of ideas embedded in a form of language. The SQH activity has a particular jargon that is embedded in the artefacts that are central to its pursuit as well as to the speech of those who are involved in it. In the Standard for Headship in Scotland the words ‘leadership’ and ‘participative management’ are central to describing the function of headteachers. Verbs and verbal phrases such as ‘negotiate’, ‘agree and implement’, ‘monitor and evaluate’, ‘plan, develop and review’ and, of course, ‘manage’ are used to describe the actions that headteachers should be able to demonstrate. Drawing on a slightly different discourse the terms ‘critical reflection and ‘professional values’ are also prominent in the course materials. At a more mundane level tutors and co-ordinators refer to ‘P&Cs’ (portfolios and commentaries), and to ‘candidates’ or ‘SQHers’ as terms used for students on the programme. The function of this language is to provide a basis for joint sense making, sharing knowledge and the legitimation of the SQH activity. It serves to include ‘those in the know’ about the SQH as well as to exclude those who are not part of the system. It is a parochial and local way of making sense of the activity and its object of preparing candidates to undertake the role of headteacher. On the other hand, much of the SQH’s conceptual tool kit is derived from discourses that are characteristic of a much wider fiel of activity. Key managerialist assumptions are embedded in the Standard, the base text for designing the programme and assessing the outcomes of the candidates’ engagement. Whilst these assumptions have been translated into a formulation which is peculiar to the SQH, they nevertheless ensure that it has much in common with similar activities elsewhere. For example, in its origins and purposes, the SQH shares a great deal with its counterpart, the National Professional Qualificatio for Headship, which was introduced into England and Wales in 1996. The SQH is linked ideationally to a general trend in the UK in the second half of the 1990s to place increasing emphasis on professional standards and continuing professional development (CPD) as the means of improving public service delivery. This trend, in its turn, is an identifiabl stage in a much longer project, dating from the late 1970s, to import the discourse and practice of managers and management into the public sector in both the UK
What Is the Scottish Qualificatio for Headship?
15
and a number of other countries as a means of controlling costs and improving efficien y and effectiveness (Clarke & Newman, 1997). Thus sense making on the SQH is linked to frames of reference that operate across a much wider fiel of activity. Answer 3: It is structures located within and across organisations. The introduction of the SQH led to the formation of a number of new structures: three regional consortia located in the north, west and east of the country consisting of partnerships of universities with local authorities, validated work-based postgraduate programmes in the six universities involved, the appointment or assignation of the role of SQH co-ordinator to people in 32 local authorities, likewise roles of SQH course director and tutor in the participating universities and the identificatio of school staff as SQH candidates. Cohorts were formed annually to work with tutors, and network groups were set up within the local authorities. Field assessors were appointed and trained to undertake assessment and school visits. In schools, working parties were formed to carry forward the improvement projects that it was agreed SQH participants would lead and manage as part of the programme. An annual ceremony was instituted when certificates awarding the Scottish Qualificatio for Headship, were presented to successful candidates by a Minister for Education. A National SQH Consortia Group was formed to enable the three consortia to exchange ideas and co-ordinate developments. Besides these new structures dedicated to the SQH activity, the programme connects into others that are not dedicated to it, for example, structures for the validation and accreditation of courses in universities and human resource and financia management departments in local authorities. These structures are located both within and across the boundaries of a large number of organisations, and the nature and ‘closeness’ of the relationships between them varies. Whilst a number reflec the hierarchical organisation of educational services, within the activity itself, they are not part of a fi ed hierarchy. Power and control are distributed across the SQH structures and their directionality within the activity system is not clearly established. Answer 4: It is an interaction of people and things in various events. The local authority co-ordinators are involved in the selection and funding of candidates on the basis of a central allocation of grant from the Scottish Executive. In liaison with the university/universities within their local consortium, a calendar is agreed, and cohort groups are formed for the delivery of the taught part of the programme. The candidates’ headteachers are given training to act as supporter/mentors for candidates in their schools. Co-ordinators set up series of network meetings for their candidates. Later fiel assessors are appointed to assess the work of candidates. All these activities entail a number of events during which members of the various groups – candidates, local authority co-ordinators, headteacher supporters, course directors, tutors and fiel assessors – interact in pursuance of the SQH activity. Members of each of these groups share a particular and identifiabl role that they enact in relation to the SQH.
16
2
Describing Educating Systems
There are a number of things: books, forms, portfolios of evidence, reflect ve commentaries, articles, plans, websites, etc. which are inextricably part of the activity. Many exercise a form of agency within the SQH. The Standard is particularly powerful in this regard since it is fundamental to the way in which the programme is conceived and delivered (Reeves et al., 1998). It is used by candidates to argue for permission to undertake certain actions in their schools, or excuse such actions, on the grounds that the Standard ‘makes you’ (Reeves et al., 2003b:64). Other key artefacts are the Programme Guidelines, which lay out the curricular framework and the criteria for assessment; Unit Descriptors which specify the assignments which participants are required to complete; and the Guide to Assessment which forms the basis of the work of tutor and fiel assessors. These texts constitute the standard operating procedures of the programme and are therefore a material part of many SQH events. In addition, there are texts which are less central to the activity but nevertheless form part of the toolkit such as the core literature used on the various modules and the development plans produced in the candidates’ schools. SQH events consist of taught days for candidates, network meetings, school working party meetings, school visits by fiel assessors, online workshops, etc. These events take place at particular times, in particular places, involving particular people. Many of these people move from one type of event to another and back again, i.e. they participate in the activity in a number of different social spaces. For example a candidate may move from being involved in a taught day of workshops and discussions at the university with fellow candidates to a meeting of a school working party which is analysing the results of a pupil survey as part of a workbased project for the programme before going on to his/her next taught day. Both these types of events are provoked by/implicated in the SQH activity. A local authority co-ordinator may participate in a day of interviewing prospective candidates and later be involved in a meeting of their local consortium’s management committee. Field assessors move from being involved in training at a central location to assessing portfolios and commentaries in their own homes to making school visits and then meeting up centrally for moderation. All these events make up the variety of social spaces that are created in the pursuit of the SQH activity. Answer 5: It is a lived experience. It has a life – its own history. For the people involved in the activity it is a part of their life. It becomes an element in their professional identity. People enter the social spaces the SQH creates and inhabit them for a period. For example, there is a social space created for each cohort that is largely occupied by a group of students and their tutor. This space is both material and virtual for the whole of the time that the particular cohort is engaged in the SQH programme. As candidates, teachers are involved in this space until they graduate although some retain a connection through continuing to network informally with members of their cohort after completing the programme. Some may become reconnected with the SQH through gaining a headship and becoming a supporter or a fiel assessor. For other actors, such as tutors and local authority co-ordinators, the occupation of SQH spaces is more likely to be a significan element of their experience for a longer period of time. The nature of the spaces
What Is the Scottish Qualificatio for Headship?
17
that people occupy varies according to both their role and the particular contextual factors that affect it. Thus the activity is experienced in a variety of different ways by a range of differently situated actors. Its continuity is maintained despite a constant entering and exiting of people and their to-ing and fro-ing between different SQH spaces whilst they are engaged in the activity. Similarly its artefacts move between spaces whilst being subject to continual re-interpretation and modification The activity’s continuance is embedded in a set of identifiabl spatial practices and relations constituting a temporal, physical, ongoing structuration that is the SQH programme’s spatio-temporal ‘signature’. Answer 6: It is a system and a network. Once we begin to consider this particular practice-based learning course as a whole it makes sense to begin to describe it as a system, that is, as a whole made up of interrelated parts, since it is a complex set of interactions of people and things over time. As a system, the functions of the whole reside in the dynamic relationships between the parts, and, as Ackoff reminds us, there are added layers of complexity since A system, viewed structurally, is a divisible whole; but viewed functionally it is an indivisible whole in the sense that some of its essential properties are lost in taking it apart. The parts of a system may themselves be systems and every part of a system may be part of a larger system. . . . System performance depends critically on how the parts f t and work together, not merely on how well each performs independently; it depends on interactions rather than actions. (1980:27)
However, because the SQH has a sense making, semiotic function, it may also be conceived as a communication network, define by Monge and Contractor as ‘the patterns of contact that are created by the f ow of messages among communicators through time and space’ (2003:3). In this sense, pathways of communication are established by the activity that is governed by relatively predictable and stable relationships between the communicants, although the movements of information through a combination of people and things have a variety of levels of intensity and vary in their patterning in time in relation to some of the sub-activities. For example, assessment generates its own particular trajectories within the system at particular times within the year as the programme is performed.
The Parameters of Educating Systems This description of the SQH shows how complex an educating system is once you begin to explore its ramification in practice. The problem is therefore to develop a set of tools which enable a description of such a system, and others like it, that (a) plausibly preserves the complexity of what has been described and, in particular, a sense of the relations and movement between social spaces;
18
2
Describing Educating Systems
(b) is sufficientl fl xible to represent the differences between different educating systems without being unwieldy; and (c) provides a workable basis for reflectin upon and reviewing educating activities. What I propose to do in Part I of this book is to develop an array of tools for describing such systems that will meet these criteria. In order to do so it must be able to address the parameters identifie by the answers to the question: What is the Scottish Qualificatio for Headship? It must account for practice-based educating systems as the following: 1. Activities that have particular objects. A characteristic of an activity is that it has an object or goal, and it is the actions of the people who seek to achieve this object that delineate the nature of the activity. 2. Frameworks for sense making. Each educating system will have its own set of values embodied in its object and practices. This will be encoded into a local discourse used by members of the system to defin identities, for example, the respective roles and behaviour of educators and learners, the ways in which they should interact and what learners should be like when they exit the process. The discourse used by those engaged in the activity is also the basis for making sense of their actions and their object. It provides, through various pedagogic and associated artefacts, a system for the exchange, production and usage of knowledge. 3. Sets of connected spaces and structures within and across organisations. Although an activity system may be confine within a particular organisation or a particular grouping it often runs across such boundaries. Where such a system is bounded within a single organisation or community, it will still be composed of subsets, at the very least, in the case of educating systems, of educators and learners. Additionally those who engage in a particular educating system will also engage in other activities, which may or may not have a bearing on the educating system. Because educating systems often prepare people to enter other activity systems, for example, architects to enter the fiel of building and construction, they are, by their nature, likely to be permeable and permeating. 4. Patterns of interaction of people and things in events. Activities are carried out as events that form the basis of fixin when and where the actions that tend towards attaining the object take place. At these events, people interact with others to take action and with things (artefacts) that enable them to carry out those actions. 5. Lived experience in the patterning of space/time. Educating is a material activity that happens in time and space. For those involved, educating is bound up with their identities and the narrative of their own lives. It is experienced as an inhabited set of events not as an abstract category. It has a strong affective component. The experiences of the participants get built into the culture of the system and live on in its discursive practices. This
Developing a Descriptive Framework
19
material quality is preserved through the spatial practices by which the activity is maintained as a form or pattern of interrelationships. 6. Networked elements in wider systems of sense making. In a sense the sixth answer entails all the previous answers since systems and networks are characterised as complex, interacting, communicating parts. We are, however, talking here of human systems/networks which crucially involve sense making for those who are engaged in them. This means we are looking at changes in knowledge usage and production that is not necessarily the case for purely mechanical or biological systems.
Developing a Descriptive Framework Five Criteria Rather than returning to f rst principles I am going to proceed with my argument on the basis of a number of assumptions about the activity of educating: • fi st, that educating is a social activity and therefore concerned with the operation of collectives in, and across, spaces of interaction; • second, that educating is about interactions and relations between individuals, collectives and things (materials, locations, processes). • third, that educating is about making meaning and the exchange, creation, and use of knowledge; • fourth, that educating is centrally concerned with change and therefore it is a spatio-temporal process; and • fift , that educating is bound up with issues of power both within educating systems and the local field of practice to which they are attached. This view of educating distances my descriptive task from the usual body of learning theory that centres on individuals since it places an emphasis on the activity of collectives at different social sites. Using these f ve assumptions as criteria for developing a relevant analytic framework indicates that theoretical approaches based on social constructivism are most likely to have a bearing on my problem, since they seek to address the learning of collectives and of individuals as members of social groupings and, stemming from a rather different tradition, theories of organisational learning. Social constructivism, drawing on Marxist theory, has produced various offspring such as activity theory, situated learning and, following a slightly different trajectory into the fiel of semiotics and discourse analysis, actor network theory. Organisational learning theory, given its historical relationship to an individualistic psychology, has generally proved to be less well suited to my purposes, although it is increasingly being influence by socio-cultural approaches that give it greater relevance. There are also very clear links to systems theory and its
20
2
Describing Educating Systems
concern with relationality. However, the most immediate initial link through a concern for the interconnections between people, artefacts and action lies with mediated learning.
Mediated Learning Within the Marxist tradition Vygotsky’s work forms the foundation for social constructivist approaches to education. He proposed that human learning at the higher levels of cognitive functioning is mediated through language and signs and therefore based upon our social relationships. Every function in the child’s cultural development appears twice: first on the social level; and later, on the individual level; f rst between people (interpsychological) and then inside the child (intrapsychological). This applies equally to voluntary attention, logical memory, and the formation of concepts. All the higher functions originate as actual relations between human individuals. (1978:57)
Vygotsky claimed that the cognitive capacities of children were constructed in interaction with the material world through the mediation offered by their teachers (1978), see Fig. 2.1. He placed a clear focus on the teacher and society as the force behind education using mediational means, of which the chief was language, to shape the understanding and conduct of learners. He pointed to an essentially dialogic process between the learner, the sense making tools made available to her and the material world as the basis for development (Daniels, 2001:64). The purpose of schooling he saw as promoting the development of higher mental functioning, or what he termed the internalisation of scientific as opposed to everyday, concepts on the part of children and young people. Thus he privileged socialisation, as the mediation of culture by adults to children, as the primary medium of human learning in contrast to constructivist researchers such as Piaget who emphasised the importance of the child’s direct interaction with the material world as the basis for the development of mental functions.
Fig. 2.1 Vygotsky’s triangle
Developing a Descriptive Framework
21
Leont’ev (1978) applied Vygotsky’s psychological insights to human activity at a more general level. Translating the social mediation of meaning to contexts of collective action he emphasised the role of activity in shaping the culture and consciousness of its participants, including their identities. He saw social action as a series of activity systems that are formed as a result of people engaging in collaborative action to pursue an overarching purpose (object) using tools (meditational means) that are adapted to its achievement. Within these systems there is a differential engagement of participants (subjects) who take on a variety of roles (division of labour) that are construed as contributing towards the fulfilmen of the object. The power of this formulation lies in foregrounding practice as the site of learning and alerting us to the way in which different forms of activity produce different constructions of conduct and knowledge embedded in the use of different arrays of artefacts or tools. There is a similarity here with Dewey’s (1973) pragmatic formulation of learning through enquiry and reflectio on experience, learning by doing, but a greater privileging of the concept of person-with-tool as agent. The discursive, semiotic nature of human activity identifie by Vygotsky and Leont’ev was extrapolated by Bakhtin’s work on the functions of language (1981). This provides a broader framework for the dialectics at play in the development of practice by emphasising the complex layerings of language and social groupings within any given society. According to this analysis, whilst people in France may generally speak French, within this broad language ‘community’ there are innumerable variants, or social languages, which are distinctive to the activity of different groupings. These groups use their own form of ‘jargon’ as the basis of interaction, and each of these dialects, or discourses, carries with it a particular view of the world. Thus Bakhtin points to a discursive multiplicity, associating different language forms and culture with variations in human practice. Furthermore, each of us may participate in a variety of such groupings, thus adopting a number of different identities, some of which may be based upon irreconcilable views of the world. Bakhtin claims that so long as we compartmentalise our lives according to these different activities this ‘multi-lingualism’ causes us no problems. However, if these discourses and activities are mixed together for some reason, they can open up a clash of ideas and practices, which force us to either reach a new accommodation between contesting positions or refute one or the other. Bakhtin gives the example of a peasant who prayed to God in one language ( . . .) sang songs in another, spoke to his family in a third, and, when he began to dictate petitions to the local authorities through a scribe, he tried speaking yet a fourth (. . .) As soon as a critical interanimation of languages began to occur in the consciousness of our peasant, as soon as it became clear that these were not only various different languages but even internally variegated languages, that the ideological systems and approaches to the world that were indissolubly connected to these languages contradicted each other and could in no way live in peace and quiet with each other – then the inviolability and predetermined quality of these languages came to an end, and the necessity of actively choosing one’s orientation among them began. (ibid:295/6)
22
2
Describing Educating Systems
The Russian tradition of socio-cultural theory has informed three contemporary schools of thought concerned with the examination of practice as the location of learning, or coming to know: situated learning, activity theory and actor network theory each of which has built upon Vygotsky’s basic triad of persons, meditational means and object-related action (Fig. 2.1).
Situated Learning Situated learning has been largely elaborated and popularised by Wenger, based upon the outcomes of research into various forms of apprenticeship undertaken in the 1980s (Lave, 1988; Lave & Wenger, 1991). For Lave and Wenger learning and competence are part of activity not some form of portable, abstracted knowledge internalised in individual minds. Rather knowledge as capability is manifest in collaborative action where understanding and experience are in constant interaction and mutually constitute each other in a given collective or community of practice. Wenger’s (1998) major concern has been to provide a description of how these communities of practice function. His attention, given his interest in socialisation, continues to be based on the experiences of newcomers entering and achieving recognition as a member of a community of practice. In this sense, his model is innately conservative, since it functions to ensure the replication and reproduction of practice by individuals rather than to accommodate change on the part of the collective. Although Wenger argues for the essential instability of practice claiming that the twin processes of participation and reification which underpin the making of meaning through activity, can somehow be sufficientl disturbed to bring about change, he provides very little in terms of evidence as to why and how this actually happens. However, the claim that since practice has to be continually reproduced it is open to variation is not sufficien to ensure that significan alterations are likely to occur. Social selection, within its own context, is nearly as efficien at weeding out unwanted variations as natural selection (Strauss, 1997). Wenger is relatively uninterested in the purpose of activity or the content of action. Indeed, in some ways he writes of communities of practice as almost utopian ends in themselves (1998:134) perhaps because his empirical focus has largely been on learning in either traditional or informal exemplars of collectives. Communities of practice by his account therefore function as relatively isolated and autonomous entities. Wenger’s lack of attention to the role of tools leads him to disregard ties to institutions and organisations, and because these constraints are not in view, he overplays the capacity of such collectives to operate as sites for new learning. Additionally, since situated learning centres around initiation, movement with regard to knowledge is limited. Trajectories apply largely to individuals either coming to know by acquiring the competences of the collective, or losing these competences, and hence are define either as a movement from periphery to centrality in terms of communal practice or vice versa. Of the three approaches examined here, Wenger’s emphasis on identity change as a central measure of the learning of subjects is both important and something
Developing a Descriptive Framework
23
that the other two schools tend to ignore. He also points to the place of affective elements in processes of being and becoming within social settings. However, consistent with the boundedness of his conception of community, he seems to provide a relatively simple account of identity. The notion that one’s work identity is unitary and omnipresent is questionable and again part and parcel of reifying a community of practice as a largely self-directed and self-contained enterprise. For much the same reason, he pays little account to the division of labour since what distinguishes between individuals is their level of engagement in a community rather than the nature of that engagement; in that sense communities of practice are exclusionary of difference. This leads him to an essentially politically quiescent account of learning which is perhaps what makes the theory so very attractive in managerial circles.
Activity Theory Building on the earlier work of Leont’ev (1978), Engestrom and his followers have retained the distinction between subject and object, stating of the latter: The object is a heterogeneous and internally contradictory, yet enduring, constantly reproduced purpose of a collective activity system that motivates and define the horizon of possible goals and actions. (Engestrom et al., 2003:307)
In these terms, the exploration of collective learning and knowledge creation lies in following what happens to the object during activity. Engestrom continues to assert the Marxist case that it is contradictions and anomalies that occur within an activity system that lead to disturbance and result in learning as part of ‘the expansion of the meaning of the object’ (Engestrom, 2001:136, 1999). Expansive learning is therefore an internal process. The explanation that contradictions arise naturally over time in a closed system is fairly unconvincing. It has echoes in much of the literature on organisational learning where change supposedly originates when organisational members confront and work on problems and in so doing create new practices (Senge, 1990; Fullan & Steigelbauer, 1991). Based on the pragmatics of learning through enquiry, models such as Lewin’s action research cycle (1952) and its various adaptations have been developed as the basis for managing organisational development. However, the attribution of change to people’s response to ‘problems’ is as unconvincing as the notion of contradictions. People in their habitual practice tend not to fin and respond to problems if they can possibly help it (Mintzberg, 1994). Since the capacity to operate in social settings crucially depends upon one’s ability to predict and understand the behaviour of others and to reciprocate within the same norms change is generally resisted as a threat to the capacity for collaborative action. The power of social conformity is well attested by research in the fiel of psychology (Strauss, 1997; Baron & Kerr, 2003). As with situated learning, the problem of accounting for changes in practice as an outcome of collective learning lies in delineating ‘tight’ boundaries for an activity system. This is the case even though the scale here is
24
2
Describing Educating Systems
very different from that of situational learning, since systems in activity theory are conceived as operating across a whole fiel of activity on ‘an historical’ timescale. In contrast to this theoretical position, the empirical work of activity theorists indicates that interference and difference are more characteristic of knowledge creation and development than internal contradictions in relation to collectives. More recently Engestrom et al. (2003) have proposed that interactions between activity systems should become the basic unit of analysis using the notion of boundary crossing and boundary objects developed by symbolic interactionists (Strauss, 1997) to describe the meeting of social worlds as a source of change. Adopting an approach called Developmental Work Research, activity theorists have taken to provoking expansive learning through their own interventions. On the basis of research-informed workshops, largely undertaken in multi-professional settings (Daniels et al., 2007), there has been an increasing emphasis in their writing on the role of ‘boundary objects’ as purposes that potentially form a basis for bridging across different activities to form hybrid systems (Pirkkalainen & Kaatrakoski, 2007). There is a puzzle here, since the original conceptualisation of an activity system was on such a grand scale, as to what an activity system constitutes in terms of scale of operation. Additionally the researchers’ accounts of their interventions demonstrate the role of difference in provoking change and learning, but this has not lead to them to paying much attention to roles and identities, that is, to the division of labour which was an essential element in Leont’ev’s original conception. Interestingly, they have investigated identity in terms of the ‘object’, in this case in the form of the trajectory of a patient within the care system, but they have not applied the same attention to the actors or subjects of the activity. In many ways there seems to be growing gap between their theoretical tools and their accounts of their empirical work where the former fail to account for the complexity and dynamism of sense making that is often amply illustrated in the latter.
Actor Network Theory Actor network theory (ANT) emphasises the role of discourses, incorporated as people, texts, tools and venues, in the formation and transformation of knowledge. This is both a strength and a weakness. It is very helpful in directing attention to the material evidence of ideational connections and relationships, and the complex entwinings of concepts, people, actions and things. Through attention to the movement and transformation of data it also surfaces the politics of changing practice and knowledge creation. However, it is unhelpful in that, by making ‘a whole’ of actants, both human and non-human, and a network it tends to obviate any need for further investigation as to the relations between the components of these entities. Indeed, because of a radical concern not to essentialise entities, researchers such as Latour actively discourage any such endeavour. There is therefore a tendency, recognised by its proponents, for the notion of an actor network to become something so all-encompassing that it loses descriptive value. In addition, by tracking meanings
Developing a Descriptive Framework
25
that are transformed and changed over time, dynamics tend to be limited to a single spatial trajectory, where the key is the transposition of a singularity, whether as concept or thing. Law (1999) recognises these dilemmas and the need to look at issues of form, in terms of the topology of actor networks, as a way forward. ANT is in many ways the most promising approach of the three for my purposes because it focuses on movement in space and time. By following people and artefacts and tracking action through and across different social spaces researchers in the fiel of science studies have developed a convincing account of how knowledge is made. Their picture of the transposition and development of knowledge is messier and more contingent than that offered by situated learning. They also bear witness to the multiple and often contested nature of identities and their inseparability from artefacts and performance. The notion of the actant/actor as a compound of person and tools is particularly useful as it points to the connection between the multiple identities held by persons and the phenomenon of the continual hybridisation of tools and practices that is so characteristic of our current experience (Giddens, 1991). The concept of an actant lends support to Bakhtin’s proposition of multiple social languages. Through a strict attention to materiality and the use of discursive analysis ANT researchers follow the process of mobilising knowledge, examining the material transformations that information goes through in the course of its transposition from location to location (Latour, 1987, 1999). This reinforces the notion of the interaction and interpenetration of competing discourses and groupings as an engine for changes in knowledge and practice that matches rather better with the messy characteristics of the process than does the notion of contradictions. It also provides some explanation of the kind of phenomena Engestrom et al. (2003) are exploring when they look at points of interaction between different activity systems where their account bears witness to the variety of interpretations of reality revealed in these encounters. Similarly Mol makes the claim that ANT has reshaped ontology ‘by underlining that the reality we live in is one performed by a variety of practices’ (1999:74). However, actor network theorists’ emphasis on change and mobility tends to push the influenc of structure into the background in many of their accounts although this is not always the case (De Laet, 2000). Indeed Latour has claimed (2005) that studies should be confine to exploring the new and emergent rather than focusing upon established forms of practice on the grounds that sociologists have been too ready to identify ‘structures’ in the past without having done the necessary empirical work on which to base these categorisations.
Mapping Techniques Whilst the Russo-European tradition provides a number of useful ways of meeting the f rst, second and fift of the criteria on our list, there are resources to be drawn upon from other disciplines that are helpful in addressing our third and fourth criteria and in providing additional clues to meeting the first These resources relate to the exploration of spatiality, relationality and sense making, all three of which are linked through the application of mapping techniques. Cartography is used to
26
2
Describing Educating Systems
represent relations of place in space; graphing is used to explore networked relations and discourse analysis; and semiotics use mapping to track relations between ideas in the formation of frames of meaning. Spatiality Notions of spatiality are critical to the endeavour to create a means of describing educating systems. Space can be conceived in a number of ways: as place, for instance, a classroom; as temporal as in, ‘I have a space in my diary for - -’; or, combining both, as a material space of interaction involving both people and things (Goffman, 1959, 1974; Nespor, 1994; Massey, 2005). It is this latter sense of space where location and time are linked to the idea of social action that particularly concerns me in this book. As such social space is something made in performance since time and space (location) are inseparable elements of movement and activity. These spaces are embodied and material in that they are both ‘peopled’ and ‘thinged’ since they involve the use of linguistic and other, more obviously material, tools. Such spaces are also material in time, in that activity has both a duration and a location, although the use of electronic media stretches the meaning of these terms. In such a contextualised or lived space a person acts in conjunction with others who also act in that space. For instance, the classroom (as place) is a context that, in part, constitutes the space where teachers and pupils enact school teaching and learning on the basis of a set of norms and values that shape the way of doing educating that governs their interactions. Because this type of space is a product of performance it is open to change since its ‘maintenance’ depends upon repetitions that are subject to contingencies (Deleuze, 1994; Bergson, 2002). For instance, in our example, on each occasion when the teacher and the pupils meet in the classroom for the time allotted by the timetable they re-perform the space of teaching and learning. Necessarily, however, this can never be done exactly as it was before or exactly as it may be done in the future. The class activity creates a repetitive spatial patterning opening up when members of this particular activity set are together and closing again when they disperse. In such patterned spaces, created by repeated interactions, there will be a tendency to normalise behaviour so that those using the space create a predictable environment. In our example, this adherence to a set of norms is not only constantly policed within the class group but also enforced by practices emanating from other locations within the wider activity system. For instance, the working of the school’s disciplinary procedures would be one of the interpenetrating technologies in this case. Because social space is created through the enaction, or putting into practice, of a particular discourse requiring obedience to certain rules of proper behaviour and practice, it is also inextricably linked with identity. Social spaces are locations where identity is formed and maintained, for instance, in our example as ‘school teacher’ and as ‘pupil’. As we have already noted a person’s identity, in the social constructivist tradition derived from symbolic interactionism, is the result of negotiation between the individual and the collective in such a space of interaction (Berger & Luckman, 1967; Gergen, 1989; Jenkins, 1996). The notion of a social space as
Developing a Descriptive Framework
27
governed by a particular discourse plainly links with Bakhtin’s ideas concerning heteroglossia as the capacity each of us has to use a variety of social languages or discourses. These discursive variants can therefore provide textual markers of change and movement as persons travel between social locations using different textual tools or languages as part of their everyday lives, for example, as someone moves between spaces where she is a teacher, a football player and a sister. Each of these three identities entails the enaction of different aspects of the person accompanied by different arrays of artefacts, shaped in order to meet the accountabilities, norms and expectations attached to the different social spaces to which they relate. This relationship between activity and social space raises the possibility of mapping activity as space thereby affording a means of visualising the relations between spaces produced by different activities and, if time can be factored into the mapping, of studying the changing patterns, or structurations and forms, that are produced by practices. Relationality There is branch of study, based on tracking relations between pairs of entities and of representing these mathematically, known as graph theory. Nodes or entities in a particular collection can be discriminated one from another on the basis of: • the number, directionality and nature of their ties; • whether or not they are directly linked to each other; and • their closeness or distance from each other in the particular array, or network, that constitutes the object of study. These relationships can also be represented graphically (visually). Graph theory has obvious applications in the fiel of communications, and it has also been used for the analysis of social networks (Scott, 2000; Carrington et al., 2005), although its application in social studies has, until recently, been relatively limited except in the fiel of information technology where it has increasingly been used to explore features of web-based networks (Muller et al., 2008). Mapping networks provides a visual means of tracking the various pathways by which organisations and people are connected and hence of evidencing of lines of influenc that fl w across them. For example, it has been used in exploring relational bases for the power of key families such as the Medici in fifteenth-centur Florence (Padgett & Ansell, 1993) and as a way of examining the rise to power of the Solidarity Movement in Poland (Osa, 2003). Visual graphing can be seen as one way of realising Latour’s (2005) metaphor of ‘flattenin out’ the social to preserve the track of relationalities across sites and times. An insistence on two-dimensionality, by pedantically exposing the material workings of relations between contexts of activity, would, he argues, discourage sociologists from making facile assumptions about social structures. However, similar objections apply to the use of graphing to explore social networks with Mische (2003) claiming that the types of relations used, such as
28
2
Describing Educating Systems
membership of organisations, fail to get to grips with exactly what ‘membership’ signifie in terms of practice. As a result, she claims that presumptions are made about influenc and affiliatio that go well beyond what the data can support. Recent studies of the Web touch on other aspects of network formation which tend to be elided in this form of analysis. They attest to the importance of the affective dimension in the structuration of networks, networks thrive only in the light of the actions, strategies and perceptions of individuals embedded in them. (. . .) Social drives, desires, interests and attitudes are fundamental aspects of how links are made. (Shadbolt & Berner-Lee, 2008:62)
Nevertheless the notion of a visual representation of synchronous relations within networked systems is helpful as a means of exposing the connections and relays between entities and systems. Bearing in mind Mische’s and Latour’s criticisms this needs to be done with careful attention to the empirical content and material occurrence of these relations. Sense Making Unravelling the nature of relations in practice is essential to describing educating systems in spatio-temporal terms. Since making sense of the world is at the heart of learning, it follows that tracking this process is critical in any attempt to provide a description of educating. In order to do this, it is necessary to pay due attention to the ‘content’ of activity, to what it consumes, uses and produces in ideational terms. Central to this is attention to discourses as characterised by particular patternings of concepts that are used within given forms of practice (Phillips & Jorgenson, 2002). Most of the evidence for discursive patterns, or articulations, of ideas is textual. By analysing the type of discourse used in texts associated with an activity and its constituent conceptual articulations, we can gauge whether and how frames of meaning travel between spaces and how they are preserved, developed or lost in the course of activity. In so doing, careful attention to the relations between texts is critical – who quotes what, cites what, or borrows what, provides a set of markers for changes in sense making. How authors, as writers and speakers, construct their frames of reference provides evidence for the type of knowledge being used and created in the course of action. For instance, Wodak’s (2000) study of decision making in relation to European Union employment policy demonstrates how such pasting and cutting in the making of a text reflect activity as members of a working group negotiate and compromise in order to reach agreement. Equally we need to know how these texts are used in activity, what their different genres signify and perform and how they both provoke and are involved in action. Potter and Wetherall cite a study that demonstrated how scientists used markedly different, and contradictory, discourses to describe their activities according to context: In the formal paper experimental results suggest a model – in the interview the central idea of the model becomes a dramatic revelation. Moreover, the results described as doing the suggesting in the paper are described in the interview as being produced from the intuitively formulated model. (1987:148)
Developing a Descriptive Framework
29
Thus according to one genre of report, science progresses from the empirical to the abstract and imagined, whereas, in another form, the account is quite the opposite, and it is imagination that provokes the empirical enquiry, the purpose of which is to demonstrate that a particular hunch is true. This emphasises the complexity of the discursive issues involved in looking at text and the importance of understanding its relation to its audience. Practices are institutionalised, and memorised, often in a textual form, in routines and procedures. March’s work on organisational intelligence shows that most organisations function on the basis of behaviours that are legitimated by becoming encoded in established procedures. organizations are seen as learning by encoding inferences from history that guide behaviour. The generic term routines includes forms, rules, procedures, conventions, strategies and technologies around which organisations are constructed and through which they operate. (1999:76)
Such artefacts not only encode learning which has already occurred but may also carry the power to provoke further learning since they provide the means whereby ideas are made mobile and usable across space and time (Giddens, 1990). For instance, a notable feature of the pedagogy of New Public Management has been the introduction of artefacts such as occupational standards, targets and performance indicators, allied to processes of assessment, as instruments for altering the practice of public service professionals (Mahony & Hextall, 2000). Changes in the nature and content of such artefacts therefore provide indications of changes in practice in collectives. Recent work on organisational learning emphasises that whilst some sort of shock to the system is a feature of change, events in themselves, even if they are problematic, are unlikely to bring about learning unless they are accompanied by theorisation that simplifie and distils proposed new practices and legitimises their effects: The importance of theorisation is likely to be especially acute in mature or highly structured settings (for instance, highly professional settings), where the boundaries of occupational communities and the templates of appropriate organisational forms are well established and structured. (Greenwood et al., 2002:61)
Greenwood et al.’s observations mark a recognition of the political and conceptual work involved in changing practice considerations of which have been notable in their absence from standard texts on organisational learning and change. This form of work is generated by the inherent conservatism of social interaction that requires that we continually account for ourselves as behaving in conformity with established norms and beliefs (Weick, 1995; Edwards, 1997). For instance Dunne notes that ‘discursive articulation is a pervasive requirement of practice which gets particularly sharp when we are looking at change’ (2005:370). Increased theorisation is symptomatic of the intensificatio of accounting practices that occurs when alterations in activity are attempted. Changes in practice require us to engage in argumentation, demonstration and justificatio to explain ourselves and establish a
30
2
Describing Educating Systems
warrant for our new behaviours that will maintain our credit in the eyes of our fellows. There is thus a strong political element involved in practitioner learning which is detectable textually in increases in rhetorical activity. On this basis, the tools of discourse analysis, in particular tools for tracking intertextuality, are essential for understanding the content of activity and the dynamic of the relations between actors, social spaces and networked systems.
Discussion All three of the schools of thought that relate most closely to the problem of describing the dynamic relational systems that I wish to tackle retain the Vygotskian triad in that the phenomena they are interested in are the relations between people, things and action in, and over, time. All are concerned with learning and change and social spaces of one form or another. Returning to my f ve criteria, it seems to me that what is required is some way of looking at action over time and across locations that stays with ANT’s commitment to attending to the materiality of activity as a productive approach to de-constructing the commonplace and the complex. ANT’s other major strength is its capacity to identify and track connections across spaces and structures through paying attention to the way in which knowledge is transformed and re-contextualised, i.e. by attending to the content of action and emphasising the importance of tools. In so doing, it provides a means of tackling problems of scale by radically localising them. ANT’s commitment to materiality helps here in that researchers adopting this approach emphasise that one is essentially bound to looking locally. Even at the level of a global organisation practice is ‘localised’ in particular sets of events, involving particular people and things in particular places at particular times (De Laet, 2000). In that sense, Latour’s geographical notion of a fla landscape also aligns with the work on social networks, communications networks and social movements (Scott, 2000; Monge & Contractor, 2003; Diani & McAdam, 2003; Carrington et al., 2005). Localism touches on the problem of scale and the common practice of assuming that accumulations of power are a phenomenon of the macro as opposed to the micro level of social activity. Power and influence in ANTic terms, is not a matter of bigger, more inclusive structures containing smaller ones, but one of relationality. Conceptually this is a significan move in that it requires a much more sceptical attitude to the notion of boundaries and boundedness; indeed, it opens up commonsense notions of concrete structures with fi ed territorialities to question. In so doing, it does not fi comfortably with conventional hierarchical means of ordering descriptions – given the caveat that this does not by any means justify discounting the place of hierarchy in discourses of practice. Haraway’s (1991) insistence on privileging situativity in accounts is crucial in this regard in that if we are looking at complex relationships in a matrix of networks of dynamic systems, then describing where we are looking from, as researchers, should be attempted as accurately as possible because our positioning affects what we see.
Discussion
31
One of the problems with ANT arises from its strength, which is that in ‘following the actors’ in pursuit of new knowledge it tends to present a unidirectional trajectory that is without repetitions, whereas many connections in the course of practice are multi-directional and spatially repetitive. Latour recognises this is the case but nevertheless believes researchers should confin themselves to the new and emergent in order to avoid the essentialising effects of looking at established systems, i.e. that the idea of organisations attaches to assumptions that obscure how organising is done (Law, 1994). Activity theory is more relevant in this regard because it centres on the operation of systems and therefore accommodates the notion of repetition and collaborative action around the pursuit of an object. The incorporation of the idea of contestation in the formulation of boundary objects at the point of interference between activity systems allows for a more obviously political account of learning and change processes. The notion of interference also provides a means of exploring the politics of change – in that sense it would combine very fruitfully with ANT’s attention to tracking connectivity and the dissolution of boundaries. Situated learning offers a certain antidote to ANT’s attention to the new and emergent and brings into play, in the emphasis on identity, greater attention to the affective aspects of practice-focused learning. One of the major difficultie with all three positions is that none of them have developed effective means of representation for the relations that they implicate in learning processes. Having asserted the importance of action over time and its location none of the three schools has devised a way of describing this other than in the form of narratives, which, as a genre, set their own, marked, restrictions on the description of data. The other major gap lies in the conception of the subject. Although Leontev’s definitio of activity depended on the analysis of the division of labour in the pursuit of an object by a group of people, all of the approaches I have examined tend to assume a basic homogeneity in participation at the level of collectivities involved in collaborative action. Again, ANT accounts are best at surfacing the political undercurrents of change but do not really provide a way of getting to grips with issues of identity, and the narrative form of the trajectory is quite limiting in this regard. Nespor tackles the issue to an extent in considering students as key actants in his book Knowledge in Motion (1994), but again this consists of a comparison of single-track trajectories within traditional subject-based undergraduate courses. Action that generates a multiplicity of actants that pursue varied trajectories is not easily accommodated within a narrative form. Activity theorists are very good at pointing to the multiplicity inherent in the objects of activity but tend to overlook the very similar issues that apply to subjects, those who are involved in pursuing the activity. Without some representation of space and time much of this is lost from view. In that sense, I agree with Law’s definitio of activity as mess (2004), although I suspect that what we are looking at are the endless variations in form that can be achieved through relatively simple means, i.e. that an infinit variety of networked systems are all the outcomes of relations between people and things in time and space and that the crucible for the formation and repetition of these relationalities are events.
32
2
Describing Educating Systems
I am going to pick my way through this set of problems by adopting the terms ‘system’ and ‘network’, meaning by the former repeating patterns of activity in an identifiabl locale that result from the pursuit of a particular object and by the latter arrays of systems that are connected together. These are merely working definition because I am not concerning myself, at this stage, as to whether what counts as a network and what counts as a system is a matter of scale. Indeed, the quote from Ackoff indicates the position I tend to favour, that there are: systems; of systems; of systems. However, I need these words because I am not going to ‘follow actors’ across a fiel of activity but rather to attempt to describe localised activities. Thus I shall not try to track all the connections between the activities that are the object of my studies and the hubs and nodes within the fiel to which they are attached. I am going to stay much more in one place revealing, as far as I can, given this localised approach, where those connections lie and the effects they have on the educating systems that are the focus of my attention.
Conclusion Scoping the parameters for the development of an adequate apparatus for the analysis and representation of educating systems shows that there is a tantalising mix of congruence and heterogeneity in terms of theoretical models and methods for investigating and describing social practices. The discussion has revealed some useful starting points for meeting the criteria that were identifie as critical to developing a more inclusive framework for description. Summarising where we have got in regard to the list, the f rst, second, third and fift of our original criteria have been addressed to a varying extent through the use of some of the theoretical resources that we have examined. However, we are still relatively poorly equipped to meet the terms of the fourth criterion. The latter part of the discussion has centred on ways of describing change processes in spatial and visual terms that go beyond the limitations of narrative as a representational format. This leaves us with the question of whether it is possible, through adopting a spatio-temporal approach, to derive a better means of exploring the dynamic aspects of systems and of representing their functioning as non-replicating ‘repetitions’. Both of these goals relate to the ability to investigate the production of space in the performance of educating. This is essentially a structural issue but not, perhaps, in the way we normally frame social structures. It would be an attempt to look at processes of structuration as performance, i.e. to focus on ephemeral spaces that come and go and change with activity. Successfully adopting this approach would also enable us to cast light on the contentious question of agency in relation to educating and to investigate the relationships between individuals and collectivities in changing practice and associated processes of knowledge creation and exchange in a new way.
Chapter 3
The Field of Educating: Tracking Relations and Relays
Introduction This chapter is about the f rst stage of mapping networked activity systems, relational mapping, which is a means of representing the relations, transmission points and relays that run between and across educating systems. I want to begin to develop the tool set for mapping by positioning the operation of local educating systems within the wider context of educating as a fiel of activity. There are therefore two main objectives for the chapter: f rst, to provide some delineation of the types of systems involved in educating activity and second, to begin the process of building representations of the operation of networked systems within this particular field The chapter begins by exploring some of the general features of educating and the relationship this activity has to various discourses that are characteristic of educational contexts. In so doing, it identifie four broad categories of educating systems that use socialising, schooling and developmental and contagious pedagogic strategies to shape the behaviour of learners. The f rst two strategies are characterised as assimilative, since learners are taken into the space of their educators, whilst the two latter strategies are characterised as invasive, in that the educators move into the learners’ territory. The case study that forms the background for extending this discussion is about the introduction of an organisational learning strategy into a local authority’s education service. The account begins the analytical task by looking at how two particular local educating systems sought to establish frameworks for sense making that would alter the practice of teachers in schools and how these systems were materially connected to one another in contestation over practice. The case illustrates the conceptual and political work that was involved in attempting to shape practice through the use of an invasive, developmental strategy on the part of the local authority’s senior management team. Last, the discursive analysis of the case study data is used to derive a horizontal section or a relational map through this local network. A map that shows some of the key discursive relays and relations between the activity systems that were germane to the progress of educating at this particular location. The relational map is based on the use of a number of conventions that will be built upon and refine in the next chapter as a way of mapping educating activity over time. J. Reeves, Professional Learning as Relational Practice, C Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010 DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-8739-3_3,
33
34
3 The Field of Educating: Tracking Relations and Relays
Educating as a Field of Activity It may seem odd to choose the word ‘educating’ to describe the practice of those systems with which I am concerned when ‘learning’ is the term in common use. However, I believe it is necessary to make a distinction between learning and educating. There is an intentionality about the process of educating which is lacking in the notion of learning. Educating brings the dimension of power into the discussion, which is critical to describing most people’s experience of formal, and informal, learning − educating is something that is done unto people, as well as with them. Whilst an educating system shares with a learning system processes of knowledge usage and creation on the part of those involved in it, educating as a practice is concerned with altering those who become educated. In educating systems, certain organisations, groups and individuals deliberately set about changing the behaviour and attitudes of other individuals, groups and organisations. Educators seek to affect learners’ sense of themselves and the world around them in ways that they, the educators, regard as valuable. Thus, educating, as an activity, involves an intention to transform, shape and convert in line with certain values, which is not a necessary aspect of the broader phenomenon of learning; this does not, of course, preclude an educating system, or those involved in it, from learning. On these grounds, apparently open statements such as ‘enabling every child to achieve his or her potential’ rest upon often unquestioned assumptions about how ‘enabling’, ‘female/male’ ‘child’ as ‘learner’, ‘achievement’ and ‘potential’ are to be performed in practice. Thus the use of the term educating exposes the role of educators to scrutiny, whereas the use of the term learning tends to hide the role of these actors from view. The business of educating has grown exponentially in the last 50 years. Within the fiel (Bourdieu, 1977), there is some commonality in the nature of the activity, in the roles and relationships between people and in the use and form of the artefacts which are part of it though nothing is fi ed or uniform. What can be specifie is that there are educators who generally conceive themselves to have knowledge and skills that those to whom they relate as learners lack. The object of the educators is to transmit, transfer and support the acquisition of this knowledge and skill by the learners. As an outcome of educating, the expectation is that the learners will change, and they will acquire the relevant knowledge and skill and become more competent. There is thus a common narrative for learners of engaging with the activity and ‘graduating’ from it as ‘transformed’ persons. A time of entry, a duration of engagement and a time of exit characterise the experience of being educated. Often this progression is marked symbolically as in ceremonies of initiation and certification This common educational narrative relates to another feature of educating which is that the to-be-educated must move, or be moved, from a space of familiarity into a new space, a space of educating, one where they do not know initially how to conduct themselves. Given this narrative of formation and associated processes of movement and becoming, educating also carries a high affective charge. The educators seek to make the goal of educating desirable for the learners, something that will tempt them to
Educating as a Field of Activity
35
move into the activity and participate fully once they have done so within the terms of the discourse that the activity promotes. However, since the to-be-educated are not always fully persuaded of this, coercive strategies are also commonly employed by educators to achieve their ends. Students undergoing compulsory education or workers being pressured to adopt new working practices may be unconvinced about the desirability of becoming educated, giving rise to conflic and friction. There is a ‘painful’ feature that is a characteristic of all forms of educating, since they are processes aimed at the change and transformation of someone’s, or some group’s, practice; they are also about the elimination of previous practice. Educating therefore entails, to a varying extent, the dissolution, as well as the creation of forms of activity, for those who are positioned as learners (Fullan & Steigelbauer, 1991). It exerts pressure and excites resistance both because it can be construed as a repudiation of a former self and because doing and being what you know how to do and be often feels less risky and uncomfortable than learning how to do and be something different. This has to be balanced against the excitement of learning and the desire to grow and change. Where educating is perceived as an imposition, those who are subject to the activity will attempt to resist or subvert the intentions of the educators. The impulse to become educated is thus a mixture of necessity, or pressure to change, and desire as in the pursuit of a vision of a better future to be secured through becoming educated. There are innumerable systems and subsystems within the fiel of educating where people and things are variously positioned. An activist who believes that global warming must be controlled may not see attempting to persuade people on the street to change their behaviour as part of the activity of educating. A plasterer working with a new labourer may not defin herself as involved in the business of educating when showing the recruit how the plaster mix should look and feel, whereas, under other circumstances, this activity might be formalised as education through a recognised apprenticeship linked to attendance at college. For others their engagement in the fiel is more clear-cut. A lecturer in a university is well aware that she is employed to teach other people, designated as students, in an institution whose core business is education. Thus the educator side of a system may appear to be relatively simple and informal or it may clearly be formalised as part of an elaborate technology involving national, or even international, organisations specialising in functions such as assessment and the specificatio of curricula.
A Typology for Educating Systems Educating can be characterised by a number of types of systems. In the f rst instance, human beings are inducted into social practice by their parents and/or other adult carers. The pedagogic strategies of socialising are both ancient and familiar in the form of mentoring and apprenticeship practices, such as those that were central to the operation of craft guilds in medieval Europe. The socialisation process is at the centre of Lave and Wenger’s description of situated learning (1991) and Vygotsky’s
36
3 The Field of Educating: Tracking Relations and Relays
notion of mediation (1978). Essentially learning takes place through the progressive engagement of the learner in the practice of the educating group accompanied by a movement of the person being educated from the periphery as apprentice towards greater centrality in the community of practice as master. Nowadays such learning has been technicised in many organisations through the adoption of formal managerial procedures: job descriptions, standards, performance reviews and the setting of targets where line managers progressively seek to induct organisational members through various ‘stages in their career’ within organisations. This latter strategy represents the use of a mix of socialising and developmental strategies together marking the extension of the period in which organisational members are classed as to-be-educated beyond initial induction. A second category of educating system is that created by organisations and collectives whose business it is to provide education for large groups of people or even whole sectors of a population. A schooling organisation such as a university sets out to educate people, through a knowledge system divided into subjects, to engage with a wide range of activities such as engineering, fin arts, biological sciences, media studies and business management. Religious, military and state institutions have been the major sponsors of this category of organisation. Nurseries, schools, universities and colleges require the attendance of people on their own premises, in the case of children and young people often compulsorily, in order to educate them. For school pupils and undergraduates, the educating process is popularly predicated on preparing them to handle the transition to adult worker and citizen based upon the acquisition of systematised bodies of knowledge. More recently continuing professional development, now characterised as an aspect of lifelong learning, is intended to transform an adult’s practice and either send them back whence they came as a more effective practitioner or enable them to change their occupation. Even in the case of e-learning and distance learning students still enter a space that is constructed by their educators. Besides a state’s designated education services, other public services may also carry out schooling functions. For instance, a health service may have specialists engaged in rehabilitation, occupational or cognitive behaviour therapy. In addition to the provision of education as a state-sponsored public service, there are companies and independent organisations which specialise in providing training, counselling and consultancy as well as divisions or groups within organisations whose purpose is to educate other organisational members in-house. A third type of educating system, popularised in the latter half of the twentieth century, sets out to manage change and bring about improvements in practice through the use of pedagogies such as performance indicators, target setting, strategic planning, action research, reflect ve practice, change agency, and consultancy. Here the emphasis is on re-structuring the activity spaces that people currently perform, or occupy, rather than taking them out of their usual environment and placing them in educating spaces that are new to them – although this too may be part of an overall plan for improvement. Often characterised as a strategy adopted by those at the top of an organisational hierarchy to transform the practice of organisational members lower down the pecking order, this form of educating system is
Educating as a Field of Activity
37
associated with managerialism and carries labels such as ‘scientifi management’, ‘organisational learning’ in ‘the learning organisation’, or ‘total quality management’. It also permeates the fiel of international economic and social development where, in developing countries, groups characterised as less skilled, knowledgeable and capable are to be assisted to improve their practice through the educational actions and technologies of those with greater technical ‘expertise’ and ‘competence’ (Parfitt 2002; Satterthwaite, 2003). Because developmentalism, linked to therapy, is based on the idea of improvement, it often has moral overtones, and responsibility is easily projected onto the learners, encapsulated in the notion of self-actualisation (Rose, 1991). Change management strategies have proved to be very popular with politicians as means that promise effective control over processes of reform, whilst avoiding the dangers of contestation or, worse still, revolution. Incremental or continuous improvement is seen as an evolutionary strategy that circumvents crises. Nevertheless resistance to this type of invasive educational strategy that tries to alter the operation of an already established activity can be both strong and persistent (Elmore, 2000). The fourth category of educating system is the political or social movement that seeks to recruit and educate people to a particular view of the world and social practice. Here, the driving purpose is very clearly one of ‘doing the right thing’ even though this may appear relatively superficial such as adopting a particular style such as ‘punk’. A more typical example is provided by organisations and groups campaigning on ecological issues that may mount conferences, run courses and, through campaigning on the streets, seek to educate others into joining and/or promoting their cause. Recently those concerned with promoting sustainable improvement in developing countries have seen indigenous social movements as the only viable and ethical vehicle for changing practice, marking a transition from the change management approach to a contagion approach in this field Social movements are often more clearly identifiabl as ‘war machines’ attracting hostility from established groups in that members of such movements have the clear intention of altering the future by breaking with current practice at an institutional level, and they are openly political in their intent. They also generally work outside, or across, established organisational boundaries. In summary, we are looking at the following broad typology in terms of strategies for educating: • socialising systems which operate within a fiel of practice and are basically conservative in that their purpose is to reproduce practice; • schooling systems where persons are removed to an institution which specialises in educating usually on the basis of formalised divisions of knowledge. These can be both conservative in preparing people to enter established field of activity or roles in life (Bernstein, 1996; OECD, 2007) or innovatory in sponsoring new forms of activity; • developmental systems which operate within a fiel of practice and attempt to change the behaviour of established practitioners. Generally this type of system is
38
3 The Field of Educating: Tracking Relations and Relays
about a top-down attempt at hegemonic change and functions within established institutional structures; and • contagious systems such as social/political movements which try to bring about hegemonic change from outside or across established structures. These systems are generally at the more creative and innovative end of the continuum. These variations in pedagogic strategy and form result in variations in the movements of learners: from outsider to insider positions in socialising systems; from one social space to another in schooling systems, being put into new spaces of interaction that are inserted into existing collectivities in developmental systems or being induced to both enter and create new spaces of interaction through contagious systems. Furthermore, these systems vary in their boundedness – some overlap and interfere with other types of systems in the fiel or with similar systems engaged in other field of activity; some systems are largely ‘contained’ within organisations or particular communities of practice and others run across and between organisational and communal boundaries. They vary in size and extent both spatially and temporally. What distinguishes one from the other can be determined in terms of time, people, artefacts, events, actions and location. These same parameters apply even where this location is virtual, as in systems that employ e-learning strategies. Types of systems can also be deliberately mixed by educators as, for example, in the use of contagious, socialising and schooling strategies by political movements or they may mix and interfere with each other as demonstrated by the growth of the resistance movement in South African schools during apartheid. Many educating systems have a close discursive relationship to other activity field that they serve to feed with suitably educated persons. This is very obviously the case with socialising and schooling systems, which are also largely predicated on influencin individuals. In contrast, the second two types of educating systems are targeted at groups of people and aim to transform established practices rather than reproduce them. Contestation and political activity are therefore likely to be more overt and endemic in the case of developmental and contagious systems because the power balance between the educators and those to be educated is often less unequal than is generally the case in the firs two types of system. Thus, in political terms there are basically two variants here: assimilative systems, where the to-be-educated are taken into the milieu of the educators and are thus relatively powerless and individualised as in socialising and schooling models. The basic objective in these systems is to maintain and sustain practices by inducting newcomers. invasive systems where the educators enter the territory of the to-be-educated who are therefore relatively powerful and already collectivised. Thus the base condition for developmental or contagious systems is the need to disrupt previous socialisations and practices, the opposite of the conditions that generally apply in the case of socialising and schooling systems.
Educating as a Field of Activity
39
An Order of Discourse Each type, and sub-type, of system is based upon a number of identifiabl assumptions about learning, the relationships that ought to prevail between learners and educators and the value and nature of what is to be learned. For any given system, this is embedded in a local discourse, as a framework for sense making which positions the various actors involved, assigning meaning and value to particular identities, purposes and actions. These local discourses in their turn draw upon more widely distributed forms of sense making current in the fiel of educating activity. Thus, the following discourses are likely candidates for widespread usage across the field There is an element of matching here between the discourses and the typology of systems outlined under the previous heading, which is, of course, exactly what one would expect given the link between discourse and action: • a nurturing, therapeutic discourse – of care, growth, educator responsibility and commitment, ethical engagement, disciplinary in terms of developing right thinking and behaviour for the good of the (young) person. • an academic discourse – making sense through a system of subject disciplines, a language for assessment and testing, the use of academic genres, expertise, scholarship and professionalism. • a managerial discourse – of improvement and reform, standards, objectives, targets, outcomes, audit and evaluation, projects and interventions. • a political discourse – of empowerment, legitimation, morality, argumentation and activism. Any description of a discourse tends to be broad-based and somewhat fuzzy, but the four categories above bear some resemblance to the list that Edwards et al. (2005:29) use to describe the ‘tribes’ of adult educators and to Bottery’s (1990) categorisation of purposes in compulsory education as child-centred development, cultural transmission, national economic productivity and social reconstruction. Discourses, as ways of making meaning are fundamentally material. They exist only in so far as they are uttered, actioned and textualised, in things, people, time and space. However, although discourses are not entities that ‘inhabit’ a parallel non-material sphere, they may be characterised as sets of ideas that stand in a particular relation to one another, along the lines of the collections of ideas that I have used in the bullet points above. On these grounds it is possible to make an analytical separation between discursive practices, as ideational relations, embedded in ways of uttering that play an active role in creating and changing our world. This can be done through analysing the material entities and relations such linguistic practices bring into being. Such a separation of ideas and actions is helpful in exploring relations, since there is a need to pay close attention to both the material form and the ideational content of a relation in order to understand what it signifie in practice. Thus, in order to make the link between content and process, discourses will largely be treated in this book as textual, as accounts of the world distinct from the totality of the fiel of activity that they create, maintain and change. Talking
40
3 The Field of Educating: Tracking Relations and Relays
of a discourse, such as managerialism, is therefore a convenient way of summing up a number of related material practices and also of identifying, through pattern matching with a characteristic articulation, or relation between key ideas or elements (Laclau & Mouffe, 2001), when and how practices at a particular location are changing. Change may therefore be identifie through noting how such discursive patterns are altering over time and across locations. Chouliaraki and Fairclough’s (1999: 114) notion that there is an identifiabl order of discourses associated with any given fiel of activity is useful and ties in with the relationship proposed above between the types of educating and types of discourse. Indeed, it follows logically from the analytical split made in this paragraph – that a fiel of activity and its related imaginaries, or its order of discourse, are roughly coterminous. The word ‘roughly’ is used because discourses are promiscuous and prone to invade other subfield of activity, as in the case of lifelong learning as a hybrid mix of the nurturing and the managerial forms of discourse in the guise of self-actualisation. Each of these discourses, in turn, may be used in slightly different ways and in different mixes within particular systems so that there are identifiabl local ‘dialects’. In this sense, Potter and Wetherall’s (1987) notion of a local discourse as having an interpretive repertoire which draws upon resources provided by a number of more ‘universal’ discourses is helpful. Returning to our original example, an analysis of textual productions of participants in the SQH activity would reveal elements of all four of the discourses listed above although the nurturing/managerial hybrid would probably predominate. Theoretically, there is a contrast between those who represent discourses as all-powerful, unitary interpretations of the world and those who see them as multiple and contradictory, providing opportunities for collectivities to compose their own mixes and dialects according to local circumstances. Although I favour the second interpretation, the influenc of more generally dominant discourses on local practice should not be underrated. Within each activity system there will be an intimate relationship between the discursive practices characteristic of the actants and the performance of the activity, i.e. the two are inextricably linked. To depict the dynamics of networked systems local discourses need to be examined in terms of their content, function, and their material means of movement within the system. Common ideational patterns in the fiel of educating and the various systems within it are invested physically in the artefacts used and formed during the course of educating. Again, such artefacts may be in common use across a significan number of educating systems of a particular type or across a number of types. For instance, certain scientifi texts or instruments might be used across parts of the schooling system, such as colleges and universities, and also as part of induction into practice in various workplaces. In this way, artefacts have an important role in networking and connecting systems within the fiel both as part of shaping local systems and as an accessible resource for creating ideational coherence. Pedagogical techniques are also artefacts that can be used to defin differences and commonalities between systems as Nespor (2003) does in examining the effects of different subjects’ pedagogical strategies in a university setting.
Educating as a Field of Activity
41
The analysis of textual artefacts allows us to trace knowledge creation and usage. It can also provide evidence of the use of power and the nature of contestation in changing practice. Tracking the movement of ideas and concepts through the use of language and other signs provides a means of identifying the evolution of new discourses/practices and the decline of established frameworks of meaning (Jones, 2002). The identificatio and analysis of what Laclau (2007) has called floatin or empty signifie s is helpful in this regard. These are signs that can be invested with different meanings by different discourses and are therefore useful markers of consensus or contestation. A classic example of this in the fiel of CPD is ‘professionalism’ (Reeves et al., 2008), a word that can mean very different things according to the particular discursive form or dialect being used by particular actors either collectively or individually. In sum, educating covers a vast fiel of interconnecting sites of activity, and whilst there are identifiabl discourses that clearly relate to the structuration of these interactions, none can claim a total dominance across all aspects of the field It follows that the analysis of discourse is one way of exploring connections and influences This opening discussion has necessarily been rather abstract. Following Latour’s advice, it is important to relate these ideas to the empirical level, bearing in mind that discourse analysis, which relies solely on text and does not relate this to bodies and action, provides an incomplete picture of practice. The case study that follows moves us on to this concrete level. It illustrates how local educating systems may be variously linked to discourses circulating in the fiel and hence how such systems may reflec the ideational differences between them. In this instance, we are looking at the interface between two developmental, or invasive, educating systems, drawing, respectively, on hard and soft dialects of managerialism (Trow, 1994), both of which embedded a different understanding of processes of school improvement. The two systems were a nationally established quality assurance system for the schools’ sector in Scotland that had been developed over more than a decade and an organisational learning strategy adopted much more recently by a local authority’s education department. The former can be characterised as an example of the hard version of a managerialist discourse with its emphasis on compliance with a centrally determined agenda for school improvement driven by targets, standards, performance criteria, etc. The latter initiative aligned with the softer version of managerialism that advocates the pursuit of an agenda for improvement that is locally derived to address issues judged by the school community to present the greatest potential for improving the school’s effectiveness. In terms of educating to change practice the case study illustrates the following: • the role of difference in provoking a contestation of ideas; • the conceptual and political work involved changing practice and how the local activity reflect wider discursive struggles in the field • hybridisation, the putting together and making of things and local discourses out of diverse elements.
42
3 The Field of Educating: Tracking Relations and Relays
Making Sense of Organisational Learning In July 2002, a team from the University of Stirling suggested to the director of education in Craigton, a local authority in Scotland’s central belt, that adopting an organisational learning strategy would assist the council’s education service to meet two interlinked challenges (Reeves & Boreham, 2006; Boreham & Reeves, 2008). Like all other authorities in Scotland, Craigton was implementing a major restructuring of its teaching force as an outcome of the McCrone Agreement (2001). The second challenge was pressure from the Scottish Executive to raise attainment and achievement, particularly within the secondary sector. Craigton’s senior management team favoured the use of the McCrone Report’s approach to school improvement, underlining the collective responsibility of staff in a problem-solving approach to raising achievement that concentrated attention on pupils’ learning. This married well with an organisational learning approach emphasising the flattenin of management hierarchies, teamwork and engagement in action enquiry for improvement under the aegis of a shared vision for the future. This is a familiar set of concepts relating to a strand of the managerial discourse that has become dominant in the public services in the UK over the last 20 years or so. After some discussion, and a visit to a company that claimed to have become a learning organisation, the authority’s senior management team decided to adopt such a strategy and entitled it: Succeeding Together. Succeeding Together aims to increase individual staff and school capability to significantl raise the levels of pupil achievement in relation to Education’s National Priorities. (Craigton Council, 2004)
Thus the object of this new strategy was school improvement, a goal that the Council had already been pursuing through its quality assurance procedures. Succeeding Together therefore marked a change in direction towards achieving this goal. In outline, the strategy involved the following: (a) Building a shared vision of how the education service could improve outcomes for all pupils; (b) Replacing the existing approach to school development planning based on centrally established priorities with an approach based on teacher-led action enquiries focused on identifying and overcoming barriers to pupil learning; (c) Setting up networks to provide staff from across the authority with opportunities to meet regularly to share ideas and experience; (d) Supporting teachers’ capacity for practitioner research by devoting a large part of the department’s CPD programme to Succeeding Together; (e) Revising the Authority’s practices and procedures to support changes in practice resulting from the action enquiries and networking; and (f) Evaluating the strategy formatively and continuously to develop more effective learning structures within the authority.
Making Sense of Organisational Learning
43
In preparing the narrative that follows the development of Succeeding Together was traced through the construction and use of three key artefacts, The Project Proposal; The Policy Statement; and The Guide to the Implementation of Succeeding Together. These particular texts provoked and shaped interaction in pursuit of the strategy in the course of a series of events. Data, in the form of fiel notes and documents used and developed in the course of these events, gave those of us in the university team an evidential base for examining changes in sense making. For example, there were nine drafts of The Guide to the Implementation of Succeeding Together all of which had the common objective of enabling action enquiries to take place in schools. Since the nine versions of this artefact arose from the interactions of particular groups in particular events, it was possible to track changes in the content and authorship of this text as it was constructed. In describing the process of putting Succeeding Together into practice, the term activity set is used for delineating the participation of people as members of groups and teams define by their role or, rather, the particular object which it was their task to pursue within Craigton’s education service. Stage 1 Justifying action through appealing to beliefs and values After agreeing the Project Proposal there was a series of meetings between the university research team and Craigton’s senior management teams (SMT) in the summer of 2003 that began with the aim of planning a way forward for achieving the four objectives outlined in that text but quickly centred on one of these: The f rst objective will be to develop a shared vision of Craigton’s future position – A management group should meet to work out an initial outline of the shared vision, oversee the development of the Quality Indicators and work out a strategy for the adoption of the vision by the whole education service. (Project Proposal, May 2003)
Discussions focused on the simplificatio and clarificatio of the central notion of organisational learning through agreeing a name for the strategy, preparing a draft policy statement and designing a bookmark for distribution to all employees stating Succeeding Together’s aim, objectives and performance indicators. During this series of meetings the senior management team held two seminars under the title Fit for Purpose? In this, Succeeding Together was discussed with education service managers and headteachers. Feedback from these groups resulted in various changes to the text of the draft policy document – the definitio of the organisation became more holistic; there was an acknowledgement that everyone would be called upon to change their practice (not just staff in schools); a commitment was made to simplifying and streamlining school development planning; and the need to strengthen communication was recognised. The political task of convincing everyone in the service of the worth of the strategy was central to these discussions. The somewhat bald statements about the aims of organisational learning in the Project Proposal stand in contrast to the more rhetorically aligned text produced for launching the strategy. The aim of this programme is to increase Craigton Council’s capacity to significantl raise the level of pupil achievement across the service, in relation to the National Priorities. This will take place against the background of the implementation of the McCrone agreement,
44
3 The Field of Educating: Tracking Relations and Relays which is putting in place a new framework which promotes professionalism and define revised staff ng structures. (Project Proposal, May 2003) The aim of Succeeding Together is to increase individual staff and school capacity to significantl raise the levels of pupil achievement in relation to the National Priorities. Specificall the project aims to improve attainment and achievement for all our pupils by engaging everyone in action research focused on this objective and by sharing and implementing what we learn. The following improvement outcomes have therefore been identified • improving attainment and achievement for every pupil • engaging everyone in evidence-based improvement • sharing and implementing what we learn (. . .) The principles and working parameters of the project will support the new McCrone organisational and staffin structure and will facilitate new and more productive ways of working. Succeeding Together will reinstate the professionalism of teachers and ensure that all understand how they contribute to overall organisational goals. (Policy Statement September 2003)
The composition of the draft policy was used to marshal arguments from external sources for adopting the approach and countering contrary opinions. The branding and packaging of the strategy visually (logos and banners) and symbolically was seen as vitally important. Staging the launch event and deciding who would attend, who would speak and in what order was done with an eye to investing the strategy with legitimacy. This phase was characterised by justification which Weick (1995) identifie as one of the processes that characterises the enaction of new practice in organisations. How the vision was to be shared also formed an important part of this debate. Reliance on the normal system of face-to-face communication with headteachers and the accompanying distribution of documents was agreed to be inadequate. The artefacts produced in September reflecte the conceptualisation of a shared vision as one communicated directly and personally by the leadership of the organisation to all staff. ‘Sharing a vision’ was conceived as the transmission of a message from the top down. By sending a letter and bookmark to every employee and then visiting every establishment to talk about Succeeding Together (an activity nicknamed The Road Show) the Craigton SMT sought to demonstrate the importance that its members attached to this change in strategy. This series of events illustrates a process of assimilation, re-alignment and hybridisation of discourses and ideas at a local level. The work with Craigton’s SMT led to a re-working of the language in the Project Proposal which largely ‘belonged’ to the university team, drawing on an academic dialect and the genre of research proposals. In its place, the Policy Statement used a discourse that reflecte common usage within the authority. This, in its turn, related to that of national educational policy texts. The policy statement and the other artefacts produced for the launch of Succeeding Together, including the event itself, were rhetorically aligned towards a new audience. Their function was to justify the SMT’s decision to the chief executive, local councillors, headteachers and HMIE. They consisted of arguments and devices linking action to incontrovertible beliefs and values as part of attempting to impose a particular sense and meaning on the SMT’s decisions and
Making Sense of Organisational Learning
45
actions. Discursively these products were not ‘pure’, since they carried a mix of concepts in a discourse that was a hybridisation of the academic, the nurturing, the political and the managerial. This stage marked both an assemblage of power, in terms of putting together a collection of warrants, and its exercise by, and through, the senior management team in the marshalling and use of resources, in particular the application of money, time and labour in creating space for the initiative, symbolising its legitimacy and authority, publishing and communicating this throughout the service and investing in the process of implementation. Stage 2 Arguing about what actions beliefs and values entail The series of events that shaped the Guide began with a seminar for the central education services team in October 2003. This was followed by the cluster representatives’ seminar (CRS), which ran over a period of 6 months from November 2003 until May 2004. This was conducted by the university team and was attended by three headteachers from each of the 11 clusters of schools in the authority. Each of these clusters consisted of a secondary school and a number of associated primary schools in its local geographical area. Representatives of Craigton’s educational psychological service, the manager of continuing professional development for teachers and a representative, in its latter stages several representatives, of the quality development officers team also attended. A central issue in conducting these two seminars was communication. The mode of interaction within the authority had more commonly been top-down than interactive. In pedagogical terms, there was therefore a need to create conditions for dialogue if a suitable ethos for organisational learning was to be established. With the Fit for Purpose seminars, the senior management team had signalled a change to a more open relationship that had been welcomed. The cluster representatives’ seminar was predicated on eliciting participants’ views and concerns and addressing these in developing the Guide. Members of the cluster representatives’ seminar could see that changes were made to the text in the light of their feedback. Over time, the ethos of the seminar developed from a somewhat wary ‘them-and-us’ atmosphere at the firs meeting to one in which there was a sense of being engaged in joint problem solving. There was an interesting set of tensions in terms of identity because participants were oscillating between being a member of a temporary new group, charged with overtaking a particular goal, and being a member of their normal role or activity set. As the purpose of the seminar series was to produce guidance for schools on implementing action enquiries the interactions that took place within it were representative of the second of Weick’s (1995) forms of sense making during the enaction of change, i.e. arguing from beliefs and values to what these mean in terms of practice. As his use of the word ‘argue’ signifies this is often a more contested process than justifying actions. Whatever the declared intention of the seminar, the debate ranged far more widely than the concept of action enquiry itself. The major concern of participants was to address authority-wide issues such as central services’ practice in relation to planning; CPD provision; communication; and finall the role of the educational psychologists. The most immediate and pressing of these issues was
46
3 The Field of Educating: Tracking Relations and Relays
the need to clarify the relationships between the national priorities for education, school improvement planning and action enquiry. To achieve this, it was necessary to reconcile two processes, the Succeeding Together strategy and the framework for quality assurance devised by HMIE and promoted by the Scottish Executive. Both the Succeeding Together improvement plan and school development plans required by the quality assurance process shared the same conceptual origin in an organisational learning framework. However, over the years, the latter had been invaded and colonised by a more centralised and bureaucratic approach to improvement. Guidelines for school development plans laid a heavy emphasis on compliance with detailed quality indicators and nationally determined priorities (HMIE, 2002). The counter argument to the university team’s proposal that action enquiry represented a departure from current practice was presented by the quality development officers whose role was quality assurance. Their version of the Guide represented improvement planning as just a matter of simplifying current development plans. Development planning is a well established process in Craigton’s schools. However, in many cases it has become too unwieldy and diff cult to manage – Each school will be expected to produce a whole school Improvement Plan. Schools may select their own format, for example those who have found the PCPlan format useful [school improvement planning software] may wish to continue using this provided they select limited priorities and outcomes which meet their specifi improvement needs. (QDO draft Guide, February 2004)
In reply, and after a number of contacts and negotiations, the version of The Guide presented to the seminar group in February argued that putting the focus on pupil learning entailed delegating greater responsibility to schools and teachers to decide on the content and order of development priorities. Instead of schools being told what priorities and activities they should be pursuing each will, working with its own school community, identify a focus for improvement in the quality of its students’ learning. The focus will be based on an enquiry into underachievement and where and how barriers to learning are being experienced by students. Focusing on this area staff will then carry out collaborative action enquiries in the form of projects to develop creative and reliable ways of improving students’ performance. There should be no more than three projects per school. (CRS draft Guide, February 2004)
Thus action enquiry and improvement planning were welded together to present a coherent justificatio for the adoption of action enquiry. This draft was agreed to constitute a workable set of procedures by those attending the February meeting of the seminar. Thereafter, people rapidly moved to action with a Headteachers’ Improvement Planning Seminar, a Succeeding Together in-service day in all schools and the production of school improvement plans all taking place between March and June 2004. This succession, in the struggle to form a new activity set, clearly related to accounts of the development of boundary objects and boundary crossing alluded to by other writers (Haraway, 1991; Borum, 2004; Engestrom et al., 2003). The progression through this series of texts in terms of authorship is significant. The firs of the published texts, Succeeding Together: Draft Tool Kit for Action Inquiry in September 2003, largely contained text devised by the university
Making Sense of Organisational Learning
47
team together with some material jointly authored with Craigton’s senior managers. In contrast, the fina February draft contained text from the following groups: headteachers, quality development officers the CPD manager and the educational psychologists as well as ourselves and Craigton’s SMT. In Fairclough’s terms (2003) this constituted an acceptable re-contextalisation of the discourse or what Latour (1999) refers to as a ‘transformation’ that marks the successful movement of an actor/actant from one space to another. Here, a ‘text’ also served as a space for action, as a site for the expansion in the number of its authors and also for their interaction as co-authors. In so doing, it accumulated further power in terms of warrant and, in the nature of the compromise it represented, of resourcing by enabling the infiltratio of the action enquiry process into those structures and resources already in place to support school development planning. What happened in the space created in the CRS could be characterised as a contest between two dialects of managerialism: hard managerialism with its emphasis on audit, quantifiabl outcomes and tight control by a strategic centre was running up against soft managerialism, with its emphasis on the involvement and participation of shop floo workers in improvement processes and decision making. The QDOs, with close links to HMIE, were imbued with the discourse and ideas of the ‘hard’ camp, whilst the university team, as disruptive outsiders, were basing their proposals on the ‘soft’ discourse. However, the nature of the contestation and negotiation over the Guide was much more complex than a straightforward battle of ideas between these two activity sets. Within the two seminar spaces that centred on the production of the Guide there was a number of groups, or activity sets, with different interests, different reactions and different desires in terms of shaping the initiative. Many of the headteachers were findin development planning oppressive and unsatisfactory and were inclined to prefer the notion of greater autonomy for schools and teachers. This fitte with the discourse of a ‘new’ professionalism of McCrone and was implied in the concept of action enquiry. On the other hand the headteachers were also anxious about the reaction of HMIE to such a change in practice fearing they might be castigated in inspection reports for not covering every priority prescribed nationally. The quality development officers team had been specificall formed to ensure, under the terms of the 2000 Education Act, that the authority complied with the model of quality assurance that statutory engagement in Improvement Planning required. Their work centred on the use of standard operating procedures published by HMI in the form of Quality Management in Education (2000a), which covered quality assurance in local authorities and How Good is Our School? (HMI, 1996; HMIE, 2002) which performed the same function in schools. Their power derived from their close connection with HMIE. What was at stake for them was a substantive change in their practice and a threat to their current relationship with headteachers. The HMIE were ‘ghostly’ participants since, without being bodily present, their existence had a strong influenc on the conduct of the seminar. At this time, developments at national policy level had resulted in HMIE talking about taking a less
48
3 The Field of Educating: Tracking Relations and Relays
prescriptive approach to school inspection (HMIE, 2003) and allowing schools greater autonomy which favoured the adoption of the new proposals. However, many headteachers retained a certain scepticism about whether such a change in practice would be implemented. The educational psychology team placed a high value on research as an outcome of their academic training. The opportunity to work with schools on action enquiries aimed at identifying and removing barriers to learning was something that they regarded as better use of their expertise than being limited to assessing the learning needs of individual pupils. They were therefore in tune with the university team’s perspective and were delighted at the prospect of the introduction of the initiative. The university team were promoting a strategy that was in line with the development of a ‘softer’ tone in relation to school management and governance represented by the McCrone Report and changing discourses in the fiel of school improvement. We came from an academic setting where notions of evidence-based practice, action research and criticality were valued and we also had a contract with the authority to introduce a change in approach. Within this mix of motives and interests the Guide, as both artefact and boundary object, developed as a negotiated text (Wodak, 2000; Cooren, 2004) that eventually satisfie the various groups involved in the seminars sufficientl to serve as an agreed basis for action, which does not mean that it was sufficien to secure the continuation of the practice in the longer term. This negotiation was not simply a micro-political struggle based on the differing interests of the groups involved. It was also a conceptual process, as the CRS participants tried to make sense of what organisational learning might mean in practice. The Guide, whatever its limitations, was a creative invention of the group in a new space where people were unsure about the rules of the game, since its conduct was untypical of ‘normal’ practice in the authority. In political terms, what the seminar produced was a re-contextualisation of organisational learning at the ‘boundary’ between the SMT, the university team, the QDOs, the educational psychologists and the headteachers that balanced possible risk against possible benefi for the headteachers who were by far the largest group of participants. This allowed them to align themselves with the SMT without feeling they ran too great a risk in relation to Quality Assurance.
Surfacing Pedagogies, Relays and Discursive Struggle Representing Relays and Networks: Building a Relational Map In this section, I am going to go through some of the key connections that are pertinent to the case study, whilst at the same time building a way of representing these relations graphically in the form of a map. I shall do this by introducing the various elements in the mapping process in a series of steps Figs. 3.1 (1)–(3). The relational
Surfacing Pedagogies, Relays and Discursive Struggle
49
map that results, Figure 3.1 Significan Relays in the Introduction of Succeeding Together, represents a network of relays in a particular locality, Craigton, within the general matrix of networked systems within the field In the Craigton study, we have an example of ‘competition’ between two educating systems at the point at which they interfere with each other’s operation. There was a relatively ‘established’ quality assurance system, the Quality Initiative (HMI, 2000b), implemented through the Scottish Executive that was seeking to change and improve practice in schools, i.e. it was an educating system which fell within the typology identifie as a developmental strategy. It was challenged, in Craigton’s education department, by Succeeding Together, the title given to an emerging educating system, based on a different developmental strategy for school improvement. These two local systems shared a number of basic conceptual tools, so they can be categorised as being part of an overarching managerial discourse, but they entailed different forms of practice so they constituted competing discourses under the managerialist umbrella. Furthermore they resonated and interacted with other discourses differently. Soft managerialism’s links to reflect ve practice and action research form a bridge into a dominant professional/academic discourse in teacher education in Scotland. Equally, hard managerialism has a symbiotic relationship with some of the values and worldview of bureau-professionalism, which had traditionally been the dominant mode of operation in the public services in the UK (Clarke & Newman, 1997). In the Craigton case, in reaction to the disturbance caused by the introduction of Succeeding Together, members of the different activity sets at local level tended to align themselves slightly differently with different elements of this complex mix. Figure 3.1 (1) attempts to designate key elements of this background. The central shaded oval is where the specifi local connections in the Craigton case are going to be mapped. ‘Surrounding’ this area is a huge terra incognita of connections that
Fig. 3.1 (1) Building a relational map 1
50
3 The Field of Educating: Tracking Relations and Relays
stretch out globally and which cannot possibly be either known or charted. However, in Craigton’s case, we were able to demonstrate general connections through discursive analysis with two different dialects of the discourse of managerialism: the hard and soft versions. The labels in the area surrounding the central shaded oval indicate that these are the relevant elements in the field s order of discourse that apply to the local relays that are going to be mapped in the central oval. In Fig. 3.1 (2) the relay that was crucial to the instigation of Succeeding Together is mapped. There are two key activity sets involved, shown as labelled white ovals, these are Craigton’s senior management team and the university team. There are three transmission points in this relay:
Fig. 3.1 (2) Building a relational map 2
(i) Craigton’s SMT was engaged in translating or re-contextualising the McCrone Agreement for operation within the authority’s schools; (ii) The University team are looking to conduct research into organisational learning so have re-contextualised this to appeal to the SMT in their approach to the authority; (iii) The two groups worked together on the Project Proposal, which was an artefact that amalgamated ideas from organisational learning and from the McCrone report in the form of project plan for Succeeding Together. Thus this bit of the map represents the three-point relay that allowed the entry of the ‘new’ developmental system into the education department. Relays consist of series of transmission or translation activities where contents of action and artefacts are reformulated or re-contextualised in some way as they ‘move’ from space to space. Such transmission points are characterised by links between people (represented as activity sets) and key artefacts that they either use or make and use in
Surfacing Pedagogies, Relays and Discursive Struggle
51
action (represented as shaded rectangles). The connections between people and artefacts within the relays are shown as white rounded lines. The artefacts are textually connected one to the other by quotation, ‘plagiarism’ and/or reference, and these connections are shown as bold black lines. A relay is define as a connected set of re-contextualising operations (transmission points) on the basis of the identifiabl discursive links between the points – in this case through a series of texts. The territory that Succeeding Together entered was already occupied by an established system concerned with training people to comply with centralised prescriptions for quality assurance. This was conveyed through a line of artefacts that shared the pattern of ideas associated with hard managerialism. Here, key activity sets were the schools’s inspectorate, the quality development officer and the headteachers as those charged with operationalising quality assurance. Figure 3.1 (3) shows the key relays for this activity in Craigton.
Fig. 3.1 (3) Building a relational map 3
Pedagogic Strategy The Craigton case provides an illustration of how the initiation of a developmental educating strategy • involved the importation of new ideas into an organisation through contact with new people and new artefacts; • provoked sense making within the organisation as part of the educative process and the re-contextualisation of ‘old’ and ‘new’ ideas in the making of new artefacts;
52
3 The Field of Educating: Tracking Relations and Relays
• led to changes in alignment of the various groups of the ‘to-be-educated’ according to their positioning both ideationally and practically within the organisation and in connection with the wider systems of which the organisation was a part. • required the exercise of power through the mobilisation of resources on the part of the instigators, Craigton Council Education Department’s senior management team, and provoked ‘opposition’, particularly in the more overt resistance of the QDO team. • ‘Invaded’ School Improvement Plans and interfered with the terms of QDOs’ relationships with schools in requiring that these texts meet certain criteria laid down in the Guide and in putting headteachers together to share their plans with each other. The case also illustrated how Succeeding Together relied on the creation of new spaces for the to-be-educated that was achieved through the use of various pedagogic devices: • the design and enaction of ‘new’, non-routine types of events such as the Fit for Purpose and the Cluster Representatives’ Seminars, the Launch of Succeeding Together and the presentations to all members of staff in the Road Show; and • the production and use of new artefacts at these events such as the Policy Statement, the Succeeding Together bookmark and banners and the Guide to Implementing Succeeding Together. The process occurred within a complex matrix of connections between actors/artefacts with systems that had already been established, and these had a direct bearing on the processes of justificatio and argumentation that led to the re-contextualisation of new ideas about practice into an actionable form. These new spaces contrasted with those being produced by the quality assurance system that relied heavily on creating spaces based on assessment activities. This was achieved by incorporating the use of HGIOS as the key artefact for enacting auditing, improvement planning and reporting with the publication of school inspections as a strongly coercive strategy in its armoury (SG, 2007). An important characteristic of new spaces made through the activity of ‘improvement’ or ‘development’ is that they disrupt practice by juxtaposing different ways of acting and therefore surfacing a contestation between the past and the future that has to be resolved by the groups involved. Figure 3.1, the completed map, shows the relays that resulted as an outcome of this pedagogic activity in 2004. The ‘new’ system (Succeeding Together) and its originating artefact, the Project Proposal, spawned a number of new artefacts which wrested resources away from the former School Development Plans and diverted them to the Succeeding Together Improvement Plans (disconnection of relays, shown by dotted lines, on the left-hand side and re-connection shown just to the right of centre). However, this did not mark a complete break from the QA system of ties, merely a slight ‘re-bundling’ of the relays. The Local Authority Improvement Plan was also adjusted with the Road Show, The Guide and the Policy
Surfacing Pedagogies, Relays and Discursive Struggle
53
Key to Figure 3.1 The key artefacts are represented as dark shaded rectangles and the direct connections between them (actual textual transpositions) are represented by thick black connecting lines. The broken black line indicates connections and artefacts being superceded. HGIOS = How Good is Our School? (HMI, 1996; HMIE, 2002) Ed. Act 2000 = Standards in Scotland’s Schools etc Act (SE, 2000a) McCrone Report = A Teaching Profession for the 21st Century (SE, 2000b) Succeeding T. Improvement Plans = Succeeding Together Improvement Plans The key groups involved in the process are represented by white rounded shapes and their connections by white connecting lines. Council Ed. SMT = Craigton Council’s Directorate of Education QDOs = Craigton Council’s Quality Development Off cers EPs = Education Psychologists Fig. 3.1 Significan relays in the introduction of succeeding together
Statement (not shown) serving to instantiate the compromises and bridges between the two systems made by the various activity sets involved in their composition during the process of implementation (educating). Figure 3.1 begins the process of developing graphical means of representing certain aspects of educating systems. Drawing attention to how groups of people are attached to, or use, particular artefacts, and the practice they instantiate has value of alerting would-be educators in organisational settings to the prior relations that may be disrupted by their activities. It alerts would-be educators to the need to understand the implications this has for those whose practice they are endeavouring to influence
54
3 The Field of Educating: Tracking Relations and Relays
What such relational mapping shows is that concentrating on educating activity in a local system does not preclude a recognition of the globalised context in which such systems operate. The content of the events making up the case study have been used to surface the connections between local discourses formed for the purpose of educating in a particular context and the more immediate relays for the entry and maintenance of varying discursive traits at a particular site of activity. The attempt to introject a new educating system within a network of systems (Craigton’s education service), through the interference of a third network of systems, the university, sets up a complicated chain of interactions which is both about political negotiation between different interests and a conceptual/intellectual/ideological exercise involving the invention of a local discourse for changing forms of practice. The thesis being put forward here is that systems are always connected to a much wider fiel of activity and that these connections are material and embodied. They are also extensive because each connection is connected again, and again, through a series of ‘local’ relays. Even within the same educating system, in this case Craigton Council’s education service, there were a number of different groups involved in the activity that constituted the service. Each of these groups was differently connected to different artefactual/discursive lines of fl w. All of these could potentially be traced in the same way across space and time, as various ANT studies have demonstrated. One of the real limitations on tracking and understanding connectivity is the sheer bulk of the data generated in networked systems and the labour involved in collecting and analysing it. Referring back to one of the problems identifie in Chapter 2, analysing activity, according to both persons and artefacts, and identifying their discursive connections provides a basis for surfacing and representing the relays of knowledge and power in an educating system. It can therefore overcome, to a significan extent, Mische’s criticism of the use of graphing to explore social networks by giving much greater weight to the content of activity in determining what the relations in a given network signify for participants.
Discursive Struggle On the basis of the connections illustrated in Fig. 3.1, one would speculate that Succeeding Together is highly unlikely to succeed. The ‘opposing’ quality assurance system is much more powerfully embedded through statutory regulation, the process of central inspection, the publication of inspection reports and the inclusion of local authority quality development officer in HMIE training and inspections. Thus the formal power legitimating operating procedures on the left-hand side of the picture far outweighs the forces on the right. There are however opposing forces, sets of resistances (Gunter & Butt, 2007) indicated by the development of elaborated forms of paper practice in response to Quality Initiative procedures, rather than changes in teaching practice, the publication of critiques by educationalists, the capacity of teachers to resist change in their classrooms, and in the conservatism of pupils
Conclusion
55
and parents, etc. The penetration of the ‘soft’ discourse at policy level has become greater over the last few years, particularly along a thread running from Scotland’s National Debate on Education through to the latest pronouncements on curricular policy (SE, 2004). There is evidence of the creation of a new blend of ideological alliances that could improve the chances of ‘softism’, at least in terms of granting a greater degree of local autonomy and diminishing the emphasis on quality control. Although, having said this, the dominance of target setting shows no sign of weakening (OECD, 2007). Thus the contest for hegemony between the two managerial dialects continues at policy level and reverberates through local networks.
Conclusion A discursive analysis of events and artefacts shows the workings of the new educating system, Succeeding Together, as Craigton’s senior managers resourced and introduced new spaces of interaction and enrolled external educators, ourselves, to help theorise and enable the translation of knowledge and practices that were new to the authority into a form in which they could be enacted. At a given locality, relational mapping enables us to look differently at the fiel of activity. It takes us back to Ackoff’s observation (1980) about how systems are relationally bound to one another, although his notion of a ‘whole’ needs to be treated with caution. Connectivity challenges our notion of boundaries and concepts like ‘inside’ and ‘outside’. As a form of representation, a synchronous, relational mapping of activity, showing a horizontal section through a networked activity system, privileges connections, interferences, pluralities and permeabilities. Tracking the performance of the developmental educating system, Succeeding Together demonstrated the complexity and ambiguity of people’s positioning as they were caught in a complex web of contestations between various discourses that were mixing and hybridising together in different ways. This is an effect that is exacerbated under pressure from invasive pedagogies, which provoke the need for ‘rationalisation’ in order for those concerned to negotiate a way between different practices. Indeed, the solution that was reached in the space created by the Cluster Representatives’ Seminar illustrated what Rose refers to as a ‘contingent lash up’ (1999:276), the putting of sets of contents and practices that are not really compatible but are made workable in one way or another, sometimes as much because of their inconsistencies as despite them. This raises an important point. Mapping transmission points in relays may tend to convey that these faithfully pass on ‘the intentions’ of the originators of the chain. This is far from the case – relays mark linked transmission points of re-contextualisation and translation where the sense of a discourse can, and very often is, wittingly or unwittingly sabotaged. Transmission points in a relay often mark boundaries between systems and sub-systems and are therefore possible sites for refl xivity and change. Returning to the original question about professional learning and changing practice what the case illustrates is that this occurs within local field where practice is already anchored in a matrix of connections. These connections relate to the variety
56
3 The Field of Educating: Tracking Relations and Relays
of roles of those involved and their earlier socialisations and allegiances, including networks of governance and disciplinarity. Whilst the evidence is derived from the context of the authority rather than to that of the schools, the implication is that the latter will be subject to similar relational influence and contestations and that the introduction of new practices in schools is therefore likely to engender similar struggles over their legitimacy.
Chapter 4
Making Learning Spaces Visible
Introduction This chapter uses the concept of the event as a key analytic category for developing a way of representing the social spaces made by educating. Events are central to looking more closely at the interactions of people and things in activity. They provide the basis for exploring the forms, or patterns, that networked activity systems make over time, opening up to examination the social spaces that are produced by educating and the effects their production has on those who participate in their creation. The combination of event analysis and the discursive analysis of the content of activity is used to draw up durational maps that show the forms and relational patterning of the spaces created by educating systems over time. Visual illustrations such as these have advantages in representing relationality, for, as Kress et al. (2001) have pointed out, the use of written text tends to confin our descriptions of activity to a temporal rather than a spatial dimension and, I would add, often to grossly oversimplify the former as well. The use of a visual mode of representation allows us to surface relations and patternings of spaces that tend to get lost in textual descriptions. Maps enable us to do and see things in relation to one another offering, in Kress et al.’s terms, affordances that other modes of description do not. The chapter begins by discussing the theoretical underpinnings of the approach. Then, building on the discursive analyses that were used to generate the relational mapping of relays in Chapter 2, the various elements that go to make up event analysis and the relations between these elements are more clearly described. Event analysis is then applied, in the case study section, to mapping the relational spaces created by the two variants of the Scottish Qualificatio for Headship programme that ran from 1998 to 2005, the standard and the accelerated routes. A durational map of the standard route of the SQH programme, which is an example of an educating system that uses a hybrid design, combining a schooling and a developmental pedagogic strategy, showed that the movements associated with educating in this system created a distinctive patterning of spaces over time. This is compared with the pattern of another version of the programme to show how the technique can be used as a basis for both designing and investigating the properties of educating
J. Reeves, Professional Learning as Relational Practice, C Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010 DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-8739-3_4,
57
58
4 Making Learning Spaces Visible
systems. The patterns that educating systems make, it is argued, have important implications for learning and change. This leads to a discussion of the spatial effects of hybrid systems and how the interferences between spaces that they set up creates ‘third space’ (Gutierrez et al., 1995) as locations between established practices that offer the possibility of changing collective and individual behaviours and inventing new forms of interaction.
Relational Space Forms of Spatiality It is important, before going on to describe the basis of the mapping process in detail, to articulate the spatial relations that underpin this form of analysis, which relies upon positing three different ‘forms’ of spatiality. A relatively simple spatial typology is given by Harvey (2006:121) whose interpretation of Lefebvre’s earlier analysis results in a similar tri-partite division of forms. The f rst of these that he describes relates to spatial practice as being carried out in measurable space. This is a form of space that is directly apparent to our senses, a space of bodies, things and distances that both Lefebvre (1991) and Harvey label as ‘absolute’, being, in conceptual terms, fi ed and unchanging. The second form that Harvey identifie is relative space, which varies according to the viewpoint of the observer and the relations being observed; he provides the example of the space of transport relations in a particular location. Unlike absolute space, relative space is a spatio-temporal conception where the relationship between objects depends upon the frame of reference of the observer. The third form is representational space, which is also in Harvey’s formulation, spatio-temporal and concerns the cultural and affective ‘entities’ that attach to spatial elements and objects but which, in themselves, are immeasurable. They have an objective effect in the world, but this, according to Harvey, is not materially identifiabl in either absolute or relative space. In a sense, I am disagreeing with this position and asserting that combining analyses relating to material and, what I am calling, imaginary space does allow for surfacing the objective effects of the relationship between ideas and material activity in what I have called relational space. The argument being as follows: Locating activity in people, things, and their interactions in places and over time relates to the firs spatial form, which I shall call material space. This is measured through the use of event analysis where activity is treated as a series of interactions, or events, that relate to the pursuance of a particular object or purpose. This provides material grounds for identifying an activity system. Events, as social interactions, are locatable in time and place and have identifiabl participants undertaking concrete actions. However this is not sufficien to achieve our purposes. We need a way of identifying which events form part of an activity system, how these events are differentiated within the system, and the basis on which actants and artefacts move between them.
Relational Space
59
For this, we need to refer to a second type of ‘space’ that is immaterial – an imaginary space of ideas, purposes, desires etc. where these symbolic ‘entities’ relate to one another in articulations that give them meaning. I am referring here to the discursive plane that relates to an activity, or rather to the ideational basis upon which the activity is made meaningful to those who enact it. This space cannot be ‘mapped’ in the sense that it has no material existence. However, it may be materially evidenced through the discursive analysis of the tools and texts that are used and produced in action in any given activity system. Thus, although immaterial, imaginary space has objective effects in a third form of space. This I shall call relational space, an ephemeral space that is produced through the interaction between material and imaginary space in the performance of an activity. In a sense this connection between material and imaginary space has already been made in definin an activity system on the basis of its object, since an object, or purpose, is an ideational entity. Durational mapping is a way of surfacing relational space because it marries the material entities involved in social events with the discursive content of action to defin what goes to make up activity as movement and change over time. Whilst activity may have permanent outcomes and effects in material space, it is ephemeral as performance. You might make an analogy here with a traditional seaside resort, which often has an eerie quality in the winter, because, as a space it is about ‘being at the seaside’ but that activity only happens in the summer. In this sense, the resort loses much of its meaning when it is not being performed by people, dogs, icecreams, spades, umbrellas and sandcastles. Yet these latter come and go and ‘make the space’ in time. Relational space is mapped by using discursive analysis to identify what material interactions, as events, go to make up the performance of an activity system. It enables the mapping of duration, sequence and fl ws within a system. Table 4.1 sets out these different forms of space and their relation in the analysis. For our purposes, event analysis, with its concern for the answers to the questions of who, where, with what and when, provides information that is framed in terms of the material space created by activity. It relates to commonsense perceptions of what may be measured in relation to the functioning of an educating system. The second strand of analysis, the discursive and intertextual exploration of the content and process of educating, provides the basis for identifying the symbolic qualities Table 4.1 Forms of space Space Material space Relational space
Type of analysis
Event analysis Durational/relational mapping Imaginary ‘space’ Discursive and intertextual analysis
Subject matter Bodies, things, places and times. Activity, participation, duration, sequence and fl ws Objects (purposes), ideas, articulations or patterns of connections between ideas and desires.
60
4 Making Learning Spaces Visible
that can be attached to the simple entities identifie in material space. It allows for the definitio of viewpoint and the surfacing of relations, for deciding which events and which participants are to be considered as the focus of attention and for delineating how they interact and interconnect in the activity of educating. Thus the set of analytic tools I am about to outline offers a way of representing how space is constantly being produced as an outcome of events. The relational spaces I am looking at are continually opening up and disappearing. Whilst they are linked to organising, they are not commensurate with organisations because the relational spaces represented by durational mapping are essentially the product of activity and vary in form according to time and viewpoint. Before going into the details of constructing durational maps it is worth outlining the relationship between durational mapping, which is the subject of this chapter, and the relational mapping that was introduced in Chapter 3. The best way to represent the activity systems that we are concerned with would be to map them in three dimensions. This is because they change over time as evolving patterns of activity. The spaces created in their performance can best be imagined as constantly changing volumes define in terms of the duration of events. The connections from space to space similarly occur at and over particular times so would also be more accurately represented in three dimensions. However, the limits of two-dimensional drawings can be circumvented to some extent by providing images of both horizontal and vertical sections through networked systems, i.e. by using both relational and durational mapping to delineate them.
Assembling the Tool Set for Durational Mapping In the last chapter, we began the task of building a representational framework by looking at means of tracking connections between systems through attention to the discursive content of activity and textual artefacts. This provided a basis for representing connections and tracking lines of power and influenc between systems but took us no further in looking at spatio-temporal issues other than as an element in narrative description. A key to making progress is focusing analysis on events. The analysis of events is critical to representing practice because doing so privileges the temporal and the locational elements of social action. Events allow a concentration on the processual aspects of educating (Van de Ven & Poole, 2005) rather than the ‘what’ and ‘why’ of education as an abstract entity. Foucault (1980:114) provides a strong justificatio for the analysis of events, claiming that it is in paying attention to the concrete minutiae of how things are done that we may escape the assumptions imposed upon us by the powerful institutions in which we are enmeshed.
Event Analysis Events, for our purposes, may be define as forms of social interaction involving two or more people (and things), which are understood by those involved to be
Assembling the Tool Set for Durational Mapping
61
part of a particular process of educating. Such events are therefore incidents within ongoing joint activity and entail interacting in any form that is recognisable as part of an ongoing pedagogic purpose. Thus the events I am concerned with are the products of deliberative, or planned, action. I am not interested in events that are unplanned – although that does not mean that the unplanned does not happen in the events that I am interested in. Focusing on planned events means that I am not concerned with the kind of events that are subject to quantitative techniques, such as event history analysis (Marsden, 2005), which is based upon the point in time when a particular event occurs, for example, when someone catches an illness in epidemiological studies. By definin events as planned social interactions in the course of a particular activity, it follows that there are several parameters that can be used to delineate them. An event of this nature not only occurs at a point in time but also has a duration; thus it may be located both within a sequence and its ‘volume’ or ‘size’, in durational terms may be compared with that of other events. In pursuit of an activity, there may well be several series of different types of events, and time can also serve as a medium for exploring the connections between one type of event and another within a sequence. Events also take place at locations, whether in material or virtual space, and they have participants as both the people and the things that are engaged in the particular interactions that occur during them. On this basis, the events that are part of the performance of a particular activity system may be define by who, and what, participates in them, where they occur and what takes place during them. All events are unique in that they can never be exactly replicated, but many are repetitive because they are scheduled, planned and/or otherwise part of a cycle associated with a form of activity. In sum, we may defin events by affixin the following: Place in time (sequence) Duration Location Participants – people Participants – tools in the form of language, procedures, equipment, etc. Action It is worth contrasting this listing of elements in events as concrete occurrences with the representations of events in text by comparing the above with a similar list drawn up by Fairclough (2003:135), where he makes separate categories for language, means and techniques of interaction all of which are classed as tools or artefacts in my list in order to avoid equating discursive elements with text alone. In a similar fashion, I have subsumed another of his categories, social relations as part of the analysis of action and participation. Furthermore, institutional forms are excluded as entities from my list because I am making the assumption that systemic forms and relations may emerge from events in repetition but cannot be determined as entities beforehand. Whilst Fairclough includes times and places in his list, he does not identify duration as a measure. I have also used the term location rather
62
4 Making Learning Spaces Visible
than place because I want to include virtual as well as physical interactions, and location seems to be a rather ‘freer’ term. In the following sections, I shall consider each of these elements in turn and how they may be represented.
Participation: People Of course, definin these elements is not as simple as it seems for there remain a number of representational difficultie not the least of which is deciding what constitutes participation. This is in part because we come back to the problem about the relationships between individuals, as particular and unique bodies, and groups as forms of association that are not merely the sum of a number of individuals but serve as the basis for the sharing of a common discourse and positioning in relation to an activity. Thus, the question is, in considering participation in events, should the emphasis lie with identity as a composite phenomenon of engagement in activity or with persons treated as individuals? This dilemma has already been encountered in the Craigton case, where whilst each quality development office was different from her fellows, nevertheless, as a member of a working team, she shared a culture, a set experiences and a ‘worldview’ with her colleagues in respect of her working role. This positioning necessarily had an influenc on her actions and the particular sense she made of the initiative Succeeding Together. The assumption is that we usually act as a representative of the groups we are involved in when we are in a role, i.e. we adopt an identity that has a strong collective element to it rather than one which is individuated and independent of group norms and practices. Thus, when we were talking about those events in Craigton that related to composing The Guide, people tended to represent the views and position of their particular group because they held an allegiance with their normal professional role, whilst they were in the process of negotiating a way to implement the new initiative. The evidence from a number of sources is that people carry many identities in their everyday life that relate to the different activities in which they are involved (Woodward, 2002). The management of this multiplicity of roles in Western cultures is usually achieved by compartmentalisation on the part of the person concerned so that his or her various identities are kept apart (Goffman, 1959; Berger & Luckman, 1967; Edwards, 1997). For instance, conventionally, we tend to keep our private life separate from our working life, and the two spheres are only likely to ‘interfere’ or ‘spill into’ one another when there is a major crisis in either one. In another sense, our identities are not entirely portable anyway since a person does not, and often cannot, take the same artefactual array from one space to another. Someone could, for example, wear her swimming gear in a lecture theatre but this would be regarded as eccentric and inappropriate in this context, whereas on the beach or at a swimming pool it would form part of an accepted array of artefacts. Thus the ‘intentional’ tone of compartmentalisation is a bit misleading – leaving an identity ‘behind’ when you move to a different activity is, in many ways, a physical necessity rather than a matter of choice. In terms of social activities, identities are thus a
Assembling the Tool Set for Durational Mapping
63
mixture of persons and things in settings associated with similar mixes of persons and things rather than something that applies to individuals unencumbered with the discursive trappings that are considered proper to the practice they are engaged in. For the purposes of analysing educating events, this means that it is legitimate to consider the roles that participants hold that are likely to be pertinent in exploring the particular educating process one is concerned with. Activity Sets One way of examining what happens across interconnected social spaces is to use the notion of activity sets. The concept of ‘sets’, with their property of permeability, allows for interference and interaction as well as issues of separation and difference. Activity sets provide a means of paying attention to micro-political themes, such as those that arose in the case of Craigton, whilst avoiding the problem of using a ‘strong’ version for collective boundaries. Activity sets can be define as consisting of groups of people who commonly interact together in pursuit of an activity. An activity set has a number of broad characteristics: It centres around the pursuit of a particular object or activity; It has its own discourse and artefacts that are shared and used by set members; It embodies a particular point of view and hence a set of values; Membership is acknowledged by the people involved and forms an element, however minor, in definin their identities; • It is permeable so that members of the set also belong to other sets; • It exercises means for inclusion and exclusion in terms of membership. • • • •
If we apply these criteria to organisations, it is clear that they too could be define as activity sets although the opposite is not the case, i.e. not all activity sets are organisations. This definitio is still problematic in that whether or not persons can be counted as members of an activity set is sometimes difficul to determine, particularly at the stage where an activity set is either forming or disintegrating. For instance, you might have a group of public service professionals that come together to devise a coordinated service plan for their area. However, the group never really unites behind this purpose because participants act in alignment with their particular specialities as social workers, medical practitioners and educationalists. The question then is whether or not this group constitutes an activity set. It could be argued that it is not a legitimate set in the sense that the declared object is not really pursued – but it might also be argued that it does constitute a set in so far as all the participants recognise and agree that the group exists to defend and maintain traditional professional boundaries, even if this purpose is not made overt for political reasons. This kind of phenomena is particularly likely to occur with ‘invasive’ forms of educating that mix developmental and contagious pedagogic strategies. In the case of socialisation and formal models of schooling, issues of interference between roles are less
64
4 Making Learning Spaces Visible
likely to occur so that singular forms of identificatio are more likely to apply or to be taken to do so (Bernstein, 1996). However, despite these ambiguities, the notion of an activity set as a basis for analysis retains a useful function as a means for surfacing the influenc of the various collectivities that people are party to. Just asking the question about whether or not an activity set exists helps to direct attention to the over-layering and interference of identities in educating activities.
Participation: Artefacts We also need to consider the things which are implicated in the activities which help to create these spaces, i.e. artefacts. According to Leont’ev (1978), a major part of the knowledge and expertise of a work group is embodied in its artefacts, which are significan constituents of its culture. These are the tools that set members use in pursuing their object; they are therefore part of the collective activity of the set members. We are back here to the notion of actants, mixes of people and things that exert power through action because they do work of some sort in terms of applying energy, time and material to achieve the production of an effect or some particular thing. For ANT theorists, artefacts are seen as exerting agency independently of persons. For instance, a key artefact for the SQH programme is the Standard for Headship that lays out a framework for practice and carries with it the authority of the national government. It also accrues authority from the governance of the course itself, because local authorities, as well as universities, are involved in delivering the programme. Whilst accepting the considerable effects that artefacts can produce, these happen in relation to action that also involves persons, so I am inclined to disagree with the ANTic position that they have ‘agency’ of themselves, separable from their embroilment with people. Artefactual Arrays Like people, in general artefacts do not exist in activity as single entities; they are usually associated with activities in complex and characteristic arrays. For instance in teaching and learning at a university there are specialist locations – lecture theatres, libraries and classrooms that contain equipment for the projection of presentations, etc., where students and teachers use particular textual and material artefacts. Pedagogic procedures and genres of communication within the ‘teaching and learning’ setting also constitute part of this collection as do assessment criteria and assignments. It is this whole array of devices, and the relations between them and the humans involved, which is implicated in educating. As with their human co-actors, the role of artefacts and their participation in action can be problematic. For instance, adaptations to a document may be made as a result of a meeting. Whilst the basis for change was determined in the meeting, the change was actually made later in a satellite event in which a person interacted with a text and altered it along the lines agreed by the group. Should this be treated
Assembling the Tool Set for Durational Mapping
65
as a separate event or do we subsume changing the text as an action ‘within’ the firs event?
Spaces and Flows The major assumption I am going to make here is that events create social spaces that are definabl by the use of the criteria that were listed for events and that these spaces are measurable in terms of points in time and duration. These measures, along with location, can be used to map a representation of social space. Putting this more formally, activity can be conceived as constituted by those events during which an object is pursued by an activity set (or a mixture of sets) performed as spaces, located in both time and place. In this respect, locations are occluded in a similar way to that of persons, i.e. just as I am referring to members of activity sets rather than individuals I am not pointing to events occurring in room 2B but to location as a typology such as classrooms or laboratories, etc. A second assumption I am making is that when more than one event takes place in relation to a particular object of activity and involves the same activity set(s) and the same array of artefacts, then the space created by the activity may be represented as additive of those events. On this basis, some events open singular social spaces since the particular group/s interact to pursue a particular activity just the once; whilst other events are spatially additive, the same activity sets interact in a succession of events in pursuit of the same object, resulting in a continuation of that particular social space. Social spaces can be mapped on the basis of the following: • • • •
points in time; duration (either as a singular event or as sums of like events); purpose/activity (location as a particular space); and connections (movement of persons plus things between spaces).
Thus in the Craigton Council case the cluster representatives’ seminar took place as four separate events between November 2003 and May 2004, but the same activity sets participated in all four of these events, and action during them centred around the composition of The Guide to implementing the organisational learning initiative. On this basis, these four events could be treated as additive and creating one type of space. Depending on the scale of representation, the four spaces can either be shown graphically as four separate occasions occurring at times t1 to t4 of duration d1 to d4 that are joined by a f ow of people and things from one to the other or summed as one space of duration D spanning time t1 to t4 . In the latter case, D is equal to the durations of all four meetings, i.e. D = (d1 at time t1 ) + (d2 at time t2 ) + (d3 at time t3 ) + (d4 at time t4 ). There are therefore decisions to be made about divisions into events – does a week’s residential course count as one event over 1 week or as a series of events. This depends upon the level of detail that one is seeking to illustrate. Whether or not to illustrate particular aspects and levels of detail within a
66
4 Making Learning Spaces Visible
system depends upon the focus of a particular study and the boundaries set for data collection. Within a given activity system there may be a number of networked spaces. Returning to the case of the standard route version of the SQH programme, there are two spaces for learning, one involves candidates as students in a teaching space with a tutor, whilst the other (which is a multiple of the number of schools the candidates in a given cohort group work in) involves candidates working with groups of colleagues in their respective schools to overtake action-learning projects. There is also a space for governance where the local authority co-ordinators and tutors from the universities come together to manage the programme, and yet another space is created by the business of assessment. All these spaces link together and each is produced as a part of the performance of the SQH activity. To complete the picture of the educating process, we also need to follow the lines of connectivity by which ideas/knowledge move physically from one interactive space to another along with members of activity sets and/or in the artefacts carried by them. This movement needs to include the f ow of people and artefacts from event to event in the same space and the movement of people and artefacts from one space to another. Movement here is not simply a matter of material relocation but is about the ‘actant’, as person plus artefact(s), acting in the space to which they have moved, i.e. the definitio of movement entails the performance of a particular actant in both spaces. This is to distinguish a connection or relation from purely locational changes, for example, when a person changes out of her work clothes and goes swimming, there is no appreciable action that is provoked by her moving between her working space and her recreational space. In terms of activity there is therefore no relation or connection between the two spaces since she changes identity as she moves from one to the other. The greatest interference occurs when an identity is retained and transported. An activity set flo occurs where members of one or more activity sets, as actants, move from one interactive space to another at a point in time. An artefact flo occurs where an artefact, or parts of it, ‘move’ from one interactive space to another, and it is used in both spaces, i.e. because it forms part of an actant. The actant, of which the artefact is part, may remain the same in both the spaces or may change. For example, the SQH portfolios (artefacts) are used in one space by the candidates as a tool for assembling school-generated data (portfolio + candidate) and in another space by tutors and fiel assessors to assess candidates’ competence (portfolio + assessor). The artefact acts in both spaces but is not attached to the same type of person as it travels. All fl ws can potentially be tracked in terms of the time of their occurrence, activity set membership, artefacts and the interactive spaces constituted by events. In making these categorisations and determining relationalities, it is important to note that the discursive ‘content’ of artefacts, actants and activity is critical in determining which are the relevant events, activity sets, artefacts and actions that
The Spatial Patterning of Interaction on the SQH Programme
67
are the focus of study and in determining their relations. Thus, although we are mapping material relations, their form and nature always reflect the influenc of an imaginary plane of articulations, or relations, between ideas. The case study section that follows illustrates the following: • how you can make durational maps; • how durational maps privilege features of educating which are not brought into focus in other forms of representation; • how durational and relational mapping can be used to compare the design and functioning of different educating systems.
The Spatial Patterning of Interaction on the SQH Programme The SQH programme was delivered in two forms up until 2005. These were the standard route, which depended upon the participants undertaking practice-based learning projects in schools, and the accelerated route, which was developed to meet the needs of experienced senior managers, and substituted the accreditation of prior learning for the projects undertaken by participants on the standard route. In this section, durational maps of both the standard and the accelerated route programmes are provided and explained to show how the various concepts we have already discussed can be converted into a visual form. The reason for comparing these two routes is because they represent different types of educating systems. The standard route is essentially a hybrid system in that two of the four units that make up the programme are traditional taught units based on a fairly standard form of university teaching, following an assimilative, schooling model of educational practice, whereas the two work-based units occur in participants’ schools on the basis of practice prescribed by a standard and are therefore more typical of an invasive, developmental pedagogy.
Mapping the System as Time and Space The SQH will be mapped as a system by concentrating on the interface between the students and the programme. It is important to be specifi in this regard, because, as we shall see later, where you are in the system alters the shape, or rather the ‘view’ that you have of it. The discussion will apply the criteria that have been described in the introduction and show both how these relate to the empirical data and how the various entities provide the basis for mapping the SQH activity in durational terms. In contrast to the relational mapping that we used in Fig. 3.1, which did not map activity over time but rather cut a horizontal slice through the system to illustrate relays running across it, on this occasion the cut through the system is ‘vertical’, providing an asynchronous view that reveals the patterning of space that the activity makes as time passes.
68
4 Making Learning Spaces Visible
The Durational Representation of the SQH The f rst stage in building the durational map is shown in Fig. 4.1 (1). Only one axis is fi ed in this form of mapping and it is shown on the right-hand side as a timescale running from the top of the figur towards the base. In this case, it is calibrated as 6 monthly semesters. It covers a period of just over 2 years which is the time it takes most SQH candidates to complete the programme as part-time students. On the left-hand side, the events that comprise the taught parts of the programme are shown as the cohort-learning space. In this space, the two taught units, Units 1 and 4 opened up 4 day long durations at the beginning and end of the programme with a period of 2 days in the middle for Unit 3 preparation. The smaller durations in this space mark when network meetings or tutorials took place. These spaces are
Fig. 4.1 (1) Building a durational map 1
The Spatial Patterning of Interaction on the SQH Programme
69
linked together because they all involved teaching, interaction of the same activity sets (tutors and SQH candidates) and a common set of artefacts, procedures and types of location. Figure 4.1 (2) completes the representation of the SQH learning spaces by placing the durations of school-based learning activities in a space to the right of the figure This shows that the bulk of activity in this learning space took place during Units 2 and 3 when the candidates were leading and managing their school-based learning projects. The smaller durations in this space were created by planning and assessment activities associated with the programme. The size of this space is in the nature of an approximation because the duration of activity obviously would have differed between candidates. For instance, some of them would have been engaged in larger and more complex projects than others. Again, all the activities in this space involved the same activity sets (candidates, their school colleagues and pupils), and they centred around school-improvement projects. Fig. 4.1 (2) Building a durational map 2
The next, Figure 4.1 (3) adds in the f ows that occurred between the cohortlearning space and the school-learning space. On Unit 1, candidates were asked to bring materials from their schools, in the form of policies and plans, for discussion in the cohort-learning space. For the second part of the Unit, each of them was required to carry out an investigation within his/her own schools. The outcomes of these activities were then discussed with their peers in the cohort in preparation for writing
70
4 Making Learning Spaces Visible
Fig. 4.1 (3) Building a durational map 3
up a situational analysis of the school’s functioning as part of the assignment for Unit 1, which included a proposal for the Unit 2 project. During Units 2 and 3, the candidates met regularly with their peers in the cohort to discuss how their projects were going and what they were learning from them. Thus, the fl ws represent the movement across the spaces of texts (both oral and written), procedures, etc. and persons (the candidates). Flows indicate an importation/exportation of artefacts and people acting together in both spaces, i.e. as actants. Figure 4.1 (4) shows the key artefacts involved in the programme and the way in which they were interconnected with the spaces. The key texts for both learning spaces are shown at the top right-hand of the figure and they were the Standard for Headship, the Programme Handbook which specifie the principles behind the course, the content, learning experiences and assessment procedures for each of the modules, etc. and the academic and policy texts that were selected as appropriate learning materials. In between the two main learning spaces lay the assignments which linked the two spaces in a sequence of preparation and planning for action in school followed by reporting and reflectin on that action. Each planning assignment set up the basis for discussions in the cohort-learning space that took place at regular network and tutorial meetings during the course of the practice-based modules Units 2 and 3. Within the school-learning space, the inclusion of the SQH candidate’s project in the SIP or school-improvement plan was critical to enabling them to access the resources and legitimation they required from their headteachers and colleagues to carry out their projects
The Spatial Patterning of Interaction on the SQH Programme
71
Fig. 4.1 (4) Building a durational map 4
Finally, all this information is presented on the map as shown in the completed version of Fig. 4.1. The conventions that applied in building this particular representation apply in the case of all the durational maps used in this book. Obviously, things like the timescale and the particular viewpoint of a system that such a map shows can vary. Thinking back to the description of the SQH that was given in Chapter 2 makes it clear that Fig. 4.1 represents only a small part of the whole even though it is at the heart of the SQH activity. To get a sense of the level of variation that occurs according to viewpoint you can compare the durational maps in Figs. 6.3, 7.1 and 8.1, which all present different views of a similar practice-based educating system, the Chartered Teacher Programme. To illustrate how student experience may vary according to the design of a programme, a second durational map, Fig. 4.2, of student experience on the accelerated route to the SQH is included here. This version of the programme was developed to allow experienced senior managers to make a claim against the Standard for Headship based on their previous work; therefore it did not require students to undertake projects in school. As a result, the bulk of the space opened up by this activity was in the cohort-learning space, the taught element being much the same as that on the standard route. The accelerated route programme did not open up any substantive space in participants’ schools. It was also shorter by 1 year than the standard route.
72
4 Making Learning Spaces Visible
Key to Figures 4.1 and 4.2 Rectangular boxes and f ow lines outlined in black delineate the artefactual system, whilst rounded white shapes and fl w lines represent activity set interactions and f ows. • The space on the left, labelled the Cohort-Learning Space (CLS), is where three activity sets interact (the students, the tutors and the local co-ordinators) • The space on the right, labelled the School-Learning Space (SLS), represents the interactions occurring between the students (as members of the SQH cohort) and the school activity set, i.e. activity in school that comes about as a direct result of the student’s involvement in the SQH programme. • On the far right-hand side, there is a timeline calibrated in 6 monthly semesters. Fig. 4.1 Durational map of the spaces created by the performance of the SQH programme standard route
Summary
73
Fig. 4.2 Durational map of the spaces created by the performance of the SQH programme accelerated route
It is important to note that timescale and point of view are indissolubly linked. In this chapter, we have been looking at the SQH system from the point of view of the candidates. They enter and progress through the system only once; thus their timescale, in this case, is either one and a half or two and a half years of parttime engagement. If we mapped the same part of the system (the learning spaces) from the tutors’ point of view, then they would have experienced the cohort-learning space as a series of repetitions with similar but different groups of students stretching over a timescale of as many years as they were engaged with the programme, i.e. there would be a repeating pattern of cohort-learning spaces over time rather than a single representation of this space, as shown in Fig. 4.1. In addition, as the school-learning spaces are not locations in which the tutors act, these spaces would be ‘missing’ from any durational map representing their particular viewpoint (see Fig. 8.1).
Summary What I have tried to do in this case study section is to show that by conceiving an educating system as a patterning of interaction over time it is possible to begin to look at what was happening during an educating process rather differently from
74
4 Making Learning Spaces Visible
the way we would normally do. Mapping the activity at the interface between the learner and the programme provides a way of surfacing the spatial patterning of the programme highlighting the rhythms of interaction, stages in activity, frequencies and location of action and the points when key artefacts were produced. These are all elements of an educating system which can be varied by design, i.e. mapping provides a means of thinking rather differently about what an educating system is and how it may be performed.
Applications of Mapping Relational Space Using Mapping for Investigation and Design Durational mapping provides a useful way of comparing the two programme routes within the SQH system (Figs. 4.1 and 4.2). On both routes the bulk of the input in terms of teaching and texts (activity in the cohort-learning space) is much the same. The major contrast between the two figures aside from the overall duration of the programmes, is that whilst the standard route opened up an SQH activity space within the candidates’ schools, the accelerated route did no such thing. It did not interfere artefactually in the candidates’ school spaces since there was no connection with schools’ improvement plans. The Portfolio Plan on the accelerated route largely entailed going back through file of past events and making decisions about what evidence to present from what had already been done. It did not involve entering into any discussions with anyone in the school about action for the future. Comparing Figs. 4.1 and 4.2 also shows the difference between an educational design that is a hybrid between ‘schooling’ and ‘developmental’ forms of pedagogy and one that is purely of the ‘schooling’ kind. This is because the SQH standard route employed an invasive strategy, since it used collaborative action-learning projects as a means of inserting itself into school-improvement plans. It thereby appropriated resources and legitimacy for action within the candidates’ schools. The pattern of the accelerated route, which has now been discontinued, was much nearer to that of a traditional programme employing a schooling strategy. On this route, the bulk of the action took place in the cohort-learning space, i.e. candidates were not engaged by the programme in any learning activities within their schools. The standard route was a mixture of a schooling strategy – removing participants to a new space (the cohort-learning space) – and a developmental strategy (intrusion into the school through creating a school-learning space for trialling changes in leadership and management practice). We can explore these issues further by comparing relational maps of the learning spaces created by the two programmes as shown in Fig. 4.3. If we look at a ‘synchronous’ slice through the standard route system, then the cohort-learning space for each particular grouping relates to as many schoollearning spaces as there are students. For instance, in Fig. 4.3 for a cohort of 10
Applications of Mapping Relational Space
75
Key to Figure 4.3 Octagons represent spaces. Flows of persons are represented as rounded, white lines. Artefactual f ows as black lines Fig. 4.3 Comparing the learning spaces created by the standard and the accelerated routes of the SQH programme
students, there will be 10 different school-learning spaces and what happens in each one of these spaces will vary. In some schools, the students’ projects will open up relatively large spaces as a product of SQH activity, whilst in others there may be much less engagement. Nevertheless, because the two forms of learning space are connected, in that candidates had to bring things from their school spaces (evidence of action, analyses of data, records of observations, etc.) into the cohort-learning space and, vice versa, take things from the cohort-learning space (the Standard, various tools for evaluation, principles, theoretical tools and procedures) and use them in the school-learning space, the programme sets up a series of interferences. The candidates were required to move as ‘actants’ between the two spaces. The compartmentalisation of identities as learners and as staff members on their part became problematic under these circumstances. An added pressure was the need for their headteachers’ and the local authority co-ordinators’ sponsorship and the knowing engagement of the members of their project groups in their work-based learning. This made their participation in the programme very public within their
76
4 Making Learning Spaces Visible
work settings. For those on the accelerated route, these pressures, arising from the mixing of two different identities, as a learner on the SQH and as a member of the school management team, were largely absent and candidates could easily preserve their learning activity as something separate from their normal working life. The spatial design also affected the resources available for learning. Here I am referring to the potential within a cohort for mixing the range of experiences open to the group using case-driven teaching techniques. The potential for generating a much closer relationship between theory and practice in a hybrid programme is therefore much greater as a result of the design. Texts and ideas can be transported outward into the workplace to be involved in enaction and thereby become part of experience and then returned to the cohort space for critique and analysis. Knowledge generated in the school-learning space can provide the basis for theorisation and further knowledge creation in the cohort-learning space. These differences in the experiences of candidates on the different routes raise questions about the effects and implications that hybrid forms have for both the nature of the learning that occurs in their performance and the development of pedagogical practices that are relevant and effective in supporting practitioners’ learning. Mapping the spatial practice of the accelerated route and the standard route shows that these two, supposedly equivalent forms of educating, are in fact very different from the candidates’ point of view. Interestingly, the impression amongst the local co-ordinators and tutors in their own evaluations was that the accelerated route was having little effect on practice. This was confirme by an independent evaluation commissioned by the Scottish Executive that was published in 2003. The report was based on a national survey of headteachers who had had candidates on the programme in their schools and of the candidates who had successfully completed the programme and nine case studies. The outcomes indicated that the programme, in the standard form, was having an impact on practice: Many (candidates) were also aware of the effects of their interventions on the wider professional culture of the school. Indeed there were several accounts from colleagues of how they had been inspired to greater efforts in their own work through the leadership provided by the SQH candidate. So the programme not only provided candidates with insight and personal development, it actually lead to significan developments in schools. (Menter et al., 2005:18)
However, the evaluation team found no such positive evidence of impact in the case of the accelerated route – ‘there is some evidence that the accelerated route is not functioning as a development programme for the candidate nor is it having a significan impact on the candidates’ schools.’ (Menter et al., 2003:3) An obvious question to ask on the basis of this comparison is what difference do variations in spatial practices make when it comes to students’ learning. Are certain spatial practices more or less effective in enabling experienced practitioners to change the way they work? The evidence from the participants, which we will examine in Part II, and from the Scottish Executive’s evaluation of the SQH suggests that they were an important variable in this case.
Applications of Mapping Relational Space
77
Mapping has the capacity to allow for both qualitative and quantitative comparisons of systems. It can be used to track how systems change over time as, for instance, in comparing the initial stages of the introduction of Craigton’s organisational learning structure with later stages to see how, and if, it appeared in the schools and what sense was made of it in these contexts – which groups were actually involved and affected by the changes. It can also be used to compare different points of view, for instance the mapping of the Chartered Teacher programme from the students’ point of view in Fig. 7.1 is very different from the map of the system from the tutors’ viewpoint Fig. 8.1. We used our investigations into the patterning of the SQH to inform both the design of the Chartered Teacher programme, see Figs. 6.3 and 7.1 and the revised SQH programme in 2005. On both, the patterning of the design was changed in order to increase the interaction between school- and cohort-learning spaces, and we altered our pedagogy and the tools we used in order to make much better use of the resources that this mixing made available. We were thus able to place far greater emphasis on the co-production of knowledge and understanding about professional practice and its development.
Effects of Hybridity in Educating Systems Hybridity and Spatial Interference I want to explore the effects of the mixing and interference of relational spaces that were alluded to in the case study section a little further, particularly with reference to effects of hybridity which is a major theme in Part II. Similar issues regarding the interference caused by the ‘marriage’ of different forms of practice arose when we examined the Craigton case, and again these occasions led to contestation that signalled learning and change. Thus the indications are that this phenomenon was centrally implicated in processes of altering practice in both these cases. However, whilst both cases gave rise to spaces of interference, this was largely attributable to the use of an invasive, developmental pedagogic strategy. Having said this, interference is just that, so that when we are talking here about practice-based programmes that employ a mixture of schooling and developmental strategies the effect is to open up two different spaces to each other, i.e. influenc is reciprocal, not one way, and what is quite likely to be produced is a real hybrid, i.e. something which resembles neither parent. Thus hybrids are liable to have consequences which no one really foresees at their inception; they display some of the ‘emergent’ properties that are a feature of complex dynamic systems. In enrolling on the SQH programme, we can think of any standard route participant as being involved in three spaces of activity that had a significan bearing on her professional practice. All three involved different mixes and interactions of people and things. The f rst of these spaces was created by the participant’s work community and the assumptions, values and role definition that governed the activities of its members.
78
4 Making Learning Spaces Visible
It was within this milieu that, as an established teacher, she had already developed a professional identity. The second space was created by the SQH programme and typifie in the cohort learning space. It was here that the particular values and purposes of the programme were enacted and established, largely by the tutors and the local authority coordinators. Here the participant was positioned as a learner and as an aspirant to headship, sponsored by her local authority and her headteacher. The SQH also created a third space, most forcibly during Units 2 and 3, this was the school learning space where the participant had to lead and manage two collaborative projects involving her colleagues. These projects provided the means whereby she was to demonstrate her competence against the Standard for Headship, an artefact that carried the weight of a nationally approved and applied definitio of ‘headteacherliness’. On the standard route a candidate was placed in the position of bridging the gap between the f rst and the second spaces described above, as did the projects that she led and managed. The projects were essential pedagogic artefacts in the activity since they were prescribed as the basis of demonstrating competence. They served to set up interferences between the participant’s identity as a learner on the SQH and her identity as a staff member in her school. These two spaces, that of normal school activity, and that of the SQH cohort-learning space, were likely to be based upon sufficientl different beliefs and values to cause some discomfort for most SQH candidates, leading, in a few cases, to a level of open contention in their school setting. Of the 40 SQH candidates whose work we examined, 29 made direct reference to micro-political dilemmas affecting project implementation, for example, In some respects I felt I was trying to work in two directions. I wanted the staff to see I was sympathetic to their problems in developing writing. I also wanted to show the headteacher I could take the staff with me and get positive results and feedback by the way I interacted with the staff. . . (Reeves et al., 2003b:62)
The evidence suggested that it was through interaction with both people and artefacts that conceptual/perceptual disturbance occurred, and the opportunity for change was effected. By ‘making’ candidates change the way things were done in school and ‘making’ headteachers and others give ‘permission’ for them to undertake these changes, the SQH programme substantially altered the parameters of professional development at the postgraduate level. By the same token, it also invaded and disturbed practices within the universities where the accreditation of work-based learning and the use of portfolios were new forms of pedagogic activity. Besides what happened to persons, there was a concomitant mixing and interaction between artefacts belonging in the f rst space, such as the school’s development plan, proceedings of working parties and groups, data on pupils’ learning and artefacts belonging to the second space, such as the Standard, assignments and
Applications of Mapping Relational Space
79
assessment criteria, and concepts derived from theoretical texts on school leadership and management. This mixing occurred in new texts composed by the students, in the form of project plans, and portfolios and commentaries produced as part of practice-based learning. In this sense, an artefactual third space was created alongside the embodied third space in schools engendered by the activity of the students’ project groups. For example, the project plans submitted for assessment at the end of Unit 1 of the programme opened up interaction between candidates and their headteachers because they had to be signed as an agreed plan. Similarly, the portfolios submitted at the end of Unit 2 were required to demonstrate the use of a collaborative approach to leadership and management and therefore contain evidence of the activities of both candidates and their colleagues (see Fig. 4.2). It was thus new combinations of people and artefacts that opened up and made third space possible. Looking back to Chapter 3, we can see the same sort of effects in the Craigton case where, for instance, Succeeeding Together provided a third space for the educational psychologists to move from a f rst space they found unsatisfactory to a second space which better represented their aspirations to contribute to the development of teaching practice on the basis of their expertise in learning. For the quality development officer the effect was the opposite, the third space of Succeeding Together represented the possible loss of a firs space that they wished to retain, their imagined future space in this instance being largely negative and therefore one to be avoided.
Characteristics of Third Space Couching what happened in more abstract terms, the notion of competing activity sets based upon different points of view expressed in different forms of discourse and material practice gives us a new tool for investigating what is changing for whom and how in a particular case. The progress the ‘new’ practice is making can be tracked by investigating how those involved are making up their minds both as individuals and as collectivities about what practice ‘should’ be. Such an analysis helps to reveal how change on the part of one or more individuals in an activity set is fundamentally a political issue involving contestation over the nature of practice and hence associated issues of practitioner identity. This phenomenon applies whether the change agents are already part of an established activity set or pushy intruders into an established system. Since it occurs in a social context, such a change requires others to allow space for the new practice to be enacted, which, of course, they may choose not to do. However, if the new practice is allowed to occur, these others also need to grant it a degree of acceptance and validation to enable it to be sustained. Thus changing practice always represents a challenge to the status quo and involves argument, questioning and debate about why the new way is desirable and/or should be considered as proper conduct. Even when arguments are not openly surfaced between set members, those sponsoring the change have to engage in this dialectic
80
4 Making Learning Spaces Visible
internally. This view of the change/learning process runs somewhat counter to the managerialist portrayal of changing practice as a largely uncontroversial technical matter. The language of shared culture, ownership and empowerment papers over the conceptual, emotional and practical difficultie that people frequently experience on the ground (Dadds, 1994). The study of the SQH indicates that the intersection of activity sets creates ‘new’, more fluid third spaces (Soja, 1989, 1996), where changes may occur. The intersection between two different activities brings both forms of practice into question and challenges those who occupy this third space to negotiate a new way of behaving that overcomes the problem created by the overlapping of spatial boundaries. Strauss claims that ‘Innovation, in fact, rests upon ambiguous, confused, not wholly define situations. Out of ambiguity arises challenge and the discovery of new values.’ (1997:28). These spaces may be engendered in a variety of ways. In change management systems, ‘third spaces’ may be deliberately created through organisational re-structuring. For example, in Scotland the New Community Schools’ initiative (SOEID, 1998a) brought professionals into interaction in new groupings dictated by structural changes in service delivery. New forms of interaction were engineered between social work, health and school education in the hopes of changing the practice of these services. However, using re-structuring as a pedagogic device for change is liable to fail because people simply seek to make sense of the new arrangements within their previous framework of meaning. Even with a deliberate attempt at re-educating, change in multi-professional contexts is hard to achieve because of the plurality of tightly compartmentalised professional positions (Engestrom et al., 2003; Borum, 2004). Thus productivity of third spaces as locations for learning and the invention and emergence of new practices have to be set against the basic logic of spatial production. This latter depends upon the power to marshal resources and determine the object, norms and values relating to a given activity, driven by a desire for predictability and control. Third space is relatively easily achieved where the object is shaping an individual’s practice. Bringing about a change that constitutes a third space for her as she attempts to come to terms with a new behaviour may have little effect on the collectivity in which she is involved. It is much harder to achieve or maintain an opening when the aim is to alter collective practice, where opposition to the enquiry posed by difference is liable to be much greater. Appropriating room for change within the complex web of relations that go to make up practice is not easily achieved. Even the simplifie analysis I have conducted here, by limiting attention to only one part of the activity that makes up the SQH system, already illustrates Lefebvre’s claim, The hypercomplexity of social space should now be apparent, embracing as it does individual entities and peculiarities, relatively fi ed points, movements, and f ows and waves – some interpenetrating, others in conflic and so on. The principle of the interpenetration and superimposition of social spaces has one very helpful result, for it means each fragment of space subjected to analysis masks not just one social relationship but a host of them that analysis can potentially disclose. (1991: 88)
Summary Part I
81
Conclusion This chapter has demonstrated the means whereby ephemeral space, as the product of the performance of an activity system, can be represented visually. Such durational mapping draws attention to features of educating that often pass unnoticed such as the following: Spatialities – the types and relations of spaces involved in the system Movement of things and people including ideas Rhythm and pacing of events Sequencing Connections and relations In so doing, durational mapping opens up a whole new set of questions that can be applied in the qualitative and quantitative investigation and comparison of educating systems. Equally, the technique has value in structuring and designing means of promoting and supporting professional learning. By demonstrating how systems are interlinked in practice-based learning, the mapping of activity enables us to consider the constraints and possibilities that apply to strategies for promoting professional development in a more comprehensive and less atomised fashion than is often the case. Being aware of the relational dimensions of activity allows us to factor them into the design of new or revised systems. The maps allow us to compare and contrast the way activity is patterned in particular systems and therefore to begin to think about what we do as educators, or as those being educated, in a rather different way. It helps us to think about the resources made available for learning, the range of interactions that a given system is bringing about, their balance, sequence and rhythm all of which are aspects of educating that are probably more important than we normally give them credit for.
Summary Part I This completes the outline of the particular array of tools for analysis that has been developed for exploring the relational spaces of educating systems and the connections and interactions that they can give rise to. Event analysis relies on the examination of texts at an ethnomethodological level of detail over time, since the task is not to fi meaning and relations at a given ‘point’ but to track changes in both as processes that unfold in the performance of collaborative activity. The resulting relational and durational maps capture some aspects of the movements, connections and patterns produced by these activity systems in performance. As Part II will demonstrate, they help to surface the social dynamics that link issues of identity, power, agency and risk to the development of practice and the construction of knowledge.
82
4 Making Learning Spaces Visible
Such mapping can serve to challenge some of our everyday assumptions. It demonstrates that spaces of activity in a system are experienced quite differently according to the form of participation of the various actants involved. In observational terms, whilst it may be evidenced that a viewpoint is broadly shared by members of a particular activity set nevertheless what is assumed to be a commonality of experience may vary significantl in how it is sensed from that of members of another set – even where the latter supposedly participate in the ‘same’ events. Relational analyses can help to bring these differences and pluralities of focus to our attention. Furthermore, the conception of boundaries and associated notions of what is internal and external to ‘an’ activity system are increasingly problematicised in the exploration of the data generated by the cases that are examined in the next three chapters. Looking at activity in relational terms implies a radical re-working of our view of structures.
Part II
Professional Learning as Relational Practice
Introduction to Part II The next three chapters take a much closer look at the interface between the to-be-educated, the educators and various forms of action that educating may take. Part II illustrates the substantive issues that the methods described in Part I can be used to interrogate. It does so by moving to a detailed examination of what happened in the three learning spaces created by the performance of two postgraduate professional development programmes: the standard route programme for the SQH and a similar practice-based masters programme for aspiring chartered teachers (CTs). Chapter 5 looks at students’ reports of their experiences in the school-learning space, the third space that was created by undertaking practice-based learning projects in their schools. Chapter 6 looks at the activity of the tutors in the cohortlearning space, on the CT programme, in particular at what informed and shaped their pedagogy and how they set about instantiating the key knowledge, skills and concepts that were ‘agreed’ to underpin accomplished teaching. Finally, Chapter 7 looks at what students composed and made for, and of, themselves in their individual-learning spaces from the resources that they accessed in the cohort and the school-learning spaces. Part II builds up a picture of professional learning that is multi-faceted and part of changing relations and relays in a process which is both heavily controlled and highly contingent. The hybrid pedagogy used by the programmes that are examined here opened up new space-to-space interactions that provoked knowledge creation through the mixing of difference. It illustrates how this led to the amplificatio of both refl xivity and power in the form of labour and the application of resources. These local systems served as hubs for the re-direction and creation of new transmission points and relays, forming, un-bundling and re-bundling relations and connections as part of the performance of educating activity.
Chapter 5
Changing Self: Interactions of Space and Identity
Introduction This firs chapter explores what educating felt like for the students and how they made sense of their experiences. It concentrates on the interface between the individual practitioners and their accounts of enacting practice-based learning activities, i.e. at the point where they were trying to introduce practice that was new to them in their schools. It explores what happened in the school learning spaces created by a hybrid pedagogic system. The chapter starts by considering the nature of teachers’ professional practice and its relationship to what we know about effective professional development. This provides a context for the case study section, which focuses on the students’ experiences of practice-based learning on the standard route of the SQH programme. For this purpose, the accounts submitted by students at the end of Units 2 and 3 (see Fig. 4.1) were compared. These were the narratives constructed by the students about their experiences of leading and managing projects in their schools. Their comments in interviews held after they had completed the programme supplement this material. Both these forms of accounts related directly to the candidates’ attempts to bridge the model of practice promulgated on the taught part of the course into their work setting. Essentially the case study section explores the experience of third space, of being held betwixt and between two different discursive spaces, and the consequences this has for changing practice. The fina section explores what this evidence tells us about the learning process at this particular site and what it adds to the description of professional learning that was outlined at the beginning of the chapter. It summarises the insights into the learning process that are highlighted by the use of relational space as an analytic tool.
J. Reeves, Professional Learning as Relational Practice, C Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010 DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-8739-3_5,
85
86
5 Changing Self: Interactions of Space and Identity
Practice-Based Learning Professional Practice Going back to firs principles, professional action is based on a claim to specialist knowledge and the capacity to exercise that knowledge to the benefi of clients/students/patients. Underlying this definitio is an assumption of agency, where the work of professionals affects the lives of others, making a positive difference to their circumstances, i.e. professionals take action in pursuance of what are agreed to be societal goods in their particular field There is a measure of consensus in the literature that professional action draws upon a complex mix of ‘knowledges’ that have been variously described by different writers (Schon, 1983; Eraut, 1994; Flyvbjerg, 2001). Underlying most of these descriptions is a twofold distinction between propositional or theoretical knowledge and know-how, labelled as procedural or practical knowledge. This theory/practice divide was built into a traditional career pathway of initial training at a university or college followed by a form of practicum for qualificatio and entry into a profession. It is now both structurally and conceptually unhelpful. Whatever the professional activity there will be some mixing of ‘procedural’ and ‘propositional’ knowledge in its execution since every practitioner must incorporate within her practice artefacts, in the form of conceptual frameworks, procedures or materials that owe their origin to both sources (Gibbons et al., 1994; Spillane & Sherer, 2004; Schwandt, 2005). It is therefore perhaps more fruitful to see practice as permeated by theory and theory as permeated by practice in professional fields It is this ‘mixture’ of knowledges that constitutes the resource that a professional relies upon in carrying out her work. Although a professional lays claim to the capacity to make appropriate judgements according to unique circumstances much professional work is essentially repetitive. Thus, in many instances, for an experienced professional, the exercise of knowledge results in routines. These take the form of standard f ows of action that have become largely automatic. These routines, given their relative complexity, may take several years to establish. Since many practitioners have to exercise judgement in contexts where decisions have to be taken very rapidly, there is little time to engage in deliberation (Brown & McIntyre, 1993). Some time may be available pre-action (planning) or post-action (evaluation), but this is likely to be scarce in pressured environments such as schools and hospitals. Hence, once practitioners have established reasonably effective routines, they are discouraged from changing them by the level of disruption and investment required to do so (Huberman, 2001). The difficult of changing practice is indicated by studies of the impact of professional development on teaching such as Joyce and Showers’ work (1988) where they found that incorporating new forms of pedagogy into teachers’ repertoires often required extensive support that was sustained across different contexts and included feedback and discussion whilst they introduced new practice in their classrooms. Motivation that supports persistence in pursuing an alteration in practice is thus critical. Change needs to accord with the ‘self’ of the person, and with her desire for agency (Hargreaves & Goodson, 1996; Day et al., 2007). This is because altering
Practice-Based Learning
87
her practice in any substantive fashion also alters her professional identity to some extent. For example, a teacher changing her habitual questioning technique from closed to open questions needs to change her understanding of her role from one of testing for retention to one of encouraging the development of her students’ thinking. In that sense, she needs to change her mind about what it is to be a good teacher. This in turn alters the balance of relations between her and her pupils challenging previously held norms about legitimate classroom practices. Thus, returning to the earlier point about theory and practice, it is important that new practices are justifiabl in the eyes of teachers and that they are supported by evidence of effica y in terms of their educational value, i.e. that there is a clear case for having a positive impact on learning and relations in school settings. Of course what constitutes educational value is open to interpretation. The judgements an individual teacher makes about attempts at change are often likely to be informed by the immediate behavioural feedback from pupils and significantl mediated by emotions and, in the UK system, by pressure to raise attainment (James & Pedder, 2006; Leat & Higgins, 2002). These kinds of warrants are a means of overriding some of the political difficultie which inevitably arise during the course of implementation. Additionally, because of the emotional aspects of changing practice, collaboration which provides access to professional dialogue and discussion, as in the form of coaching and mentoring, may provide the personal support a practitioner needs during a period of change (Lieberman & Miller, 1999).
Implications for Professional Learning What this discussion indicates is that professional practice is systemic at the level of the individual practitioner in that it includes affective, cognitive, behavioural and material aspects in an indivisible mix and that all these parameters are affected as part of professional growth. Evidence for this complex emerges from the results of reviews conducted by Cordingley et al. (2003, 2005) of studies that they judged to have established a link between collaborative continuing professional development and impact on students’ learning. In describing the effects on teachers of engagement in professional development cited in these studies, the review team identifie the following: • • • • • •
greater confidence enhanced beliefs about self-effica y in regard to students’ learning enthusiasm for collaborative working development of knowledge, understanding and skills in a curricular area changes in teacher beliefs access to suitable resources
However, this analysis at an individual level needs to be extrapolated further. For instance, the teacher’s working context includes her pupils and her colleagues
88
5 Changing Self: Interactions of Space and Identity
all of whom – teacher, pupils and colleagues – are bound into ways of conducting educational activity which are largely customary and habitual at that particular site. Classroom discourse is a particularly powerful anchoring feature of practice as is shown by the continued persistence of the teacher-dominated initiation–response– feedback (IRF) pattern of communication to which teachers, and indeed pupils, are habituated (Skidmore, 2006). These customary routines will be inscribed in the artefacts that the practitioner and those she works with use in any given setting. Any change undertaken by an individual teacher disrupts practice on the part of others by altering her relationships with them and the procedures and materials that they use in common. For instance, if the teacher switches from the IRF form of communication to a more open and exploratory questioning technique, then it changes her relationship with the pupils and requires them to begin to alter their behaviour and contribute to the lesson in a different way. What is being asserted here is that practice is relational, and therefore opportunities for professional growth need to be contextualised within the social spaces in which practice normally occurs. The practitioner is part of a collaborative activity system. Change on her part, because it disrupts the practice of others, is therefore likely to be resisted. She will have to justify any alterations she makes not only to herself but also to others in order to engage them in the process of change. Establishing links to this kind of wider contextual framing, empirical studies carried out by researchers across a number of field indicate the importance of socio-cultural factors in either blocking or supporting learning on the part of practitioners (Hargreaves, 1994; Davis & Sumara, 2001). An account of one of the initiatives that met the ‘test’ of an instantiated change in teaching technique that led to significan gains in student achievement bears witness to the complexity of the process. Adey et al. (2004), recounting their experience of changing practices in science teaching, cite three key dimensions for securing effective change. These are as follows: f rst, the nature of the innovation and how convincingly it can be argued and understood as being of educational value; second, elements in the provision of professional development such as longevity, intensity, access to coaching and reflectio and third, the nature of the environment in which the change is engendered including levels of collegiality, the attitudes of the senior management, opportunities provided for the personal engagement of teachers and teacher turnover. The implication of the model of practice that has been outlined here is that professional development that leads to a transformation in practice is about adapting complexes involving, broadly, contemporaneous changes: (a) At an individual practitioner level of beliefs and values (knowledge); self-concept and identity; relationships; artefacts (including conceptual frameworks, procedures, materials and equipment); and skills.
Practice-Based Learning
89
(b) And, by implication, the same ‘complex’ needs to undergo some alteration on behalf of the others she works with in her context of practice: students, parents and colleagues. One way of thinking about this, although it is too mechanistic and bounded, is to conceive of the practitioner as an interactional system of person, tools and relations who is operating within the bounds of another interactional system, consisting of those she works with and their tools and relations. One of the outcomes of this framing for considering the effects of professional development is that it is not possible to establish simple relationships between inputs to individual teachers, changes in their practice and outcomes for their pupils, i.e. to use a model of cause and effect and generalisability that traditionally underpins scientifi method. Thus, there is no sense in the search to test the effect of, for example, altering teachers’ approaches to questioning, because a change in questioning will be ‘contaminated’ by all the other changes which have to take place in order for a teacher’s questioning to change. Whilst it still makes sense to look at whether professional growth, define in terms of the complexes outlined above, is associated with positive effects on desired student experiences and outcomes, it does not make sense to attribute this to a technique. For instance, whilst agreeing with Adey et al. (2004) that there is a degree of predictability in matters of practice, I do not believe that controlled experiments are possible whereby the only variable is ‘a single change in teacher behaviour’ and indeed they later point out the considerable f aws in this argument themselves. On the same grounds, the belief that the adoption of a new practice is simply a matter of changing a practitioner’s knowledge and/or skills is equally unrealistic.
Learning During Practice-Based Programmes The particular focus for investigation in this chapter are the reported effects of SQH candidates’ experiences of carrying out action-learning projects aimed at achieving improvements in their practice within their workplaces. In the case of these experienced practitioners following this particular practice-based professional learning programme there will already be established ways of performing organisational improvement in their establishments. The requirement placed upon them by the design of the course, to collaborate with their colleagues in undertaking a joint improvement project, ostensibly involves the pursuit of the same object. It therefore has the potential to cause interference. At the same time, such projects also have the object of enabling participants to demonstrate competences and achieve a qualification There are therefore two potential forms of disturbance to the status quo within participants’ work settings that may be brought about by these projects: (a) that caused by participants engaging in a form of practice which is new for them, i.e. changing their personal positioning and professional identities; and
90
5 Changing Self: Interactions of Space and Identity
(b) that caused by participants engaging groups of people in improvement practices which differ from those which are normally employed in their schools. Obviously, it might be the case that the practice advocated on the programme is entirely congruent with that usually adopted in the workplace so that the only disturbance caused by bridging the two spaces would be of type (a). However, where the practice prevailing in the organisation is not entirely congruent with that advocated on the programme, the potential interference is of both type (a) and type (b). In this sense, practice-based learning, which is sponsored by agencies external to the learners’ organisations, can be construed as an invasive strategy likely to arouse resistance. Accounts of Practice On the standard route of the SQH programme each student submitted a reflect ve commentary and a portfolio of evidence at the end of Units 2 and 3 for assessment purposes, i.e. almost a year apart. Before looking at an analysis of these texts, it is important to consider the functions they served. Given that the commentaries refer to specifi actions carried out as part of a programme, they are stories about a sequence of events. They therefore relate to a much wider genre of ‘accounts’ and ‘narratives’ where authors present themselves and their actions to audiences. Each commentary is about the depiction of a ‘self’ of the author that is judged to be compatible with the kind of practitioner delineated by the Standard for Headship. This public presentation of self in the guise of a worthy aspirant to headship is at the heart of the task of students’ authorship at the end of Units 2 and 3. In these texts, students are expected to reflec critically on their own actions, thereby opening themselves, and their colleagues, up for scrutiny by a number of audiences: themselves, the university tutors and the fiel assessors who will visit the school to talk to colleagues about the projects they have carried out. Such public learning exerts its own particular pressures from fears of loss of face (Weick, 1995). On the other side of the equation constructing the commentaries and portfolios is seen by course designers and tutors as the medium for displaying valued knowledge and understanding. Over the last decade or so, largely under the influenc of Schon’s thesis in The Reflectiv Practitioner (1983), reflect ve accounts of practice have become a recognised genre for assessment in teacher education. In the context of postgraduate courses for teachers, writing which demonstrates applied knowledge and understanding is now privileged. Critically reflect ve accounts of practice, incorporating material drawn from experience and analysed in relation to theoretical concepts, constitute a common form of assignment for assessment purposes. As mechanisms for undertaking ‘self-work’, the reflect ve commentaries produced on the SQH programme are distinctive because students are required to position themselves in relation to a particular occupational standard. They must make claims that demonstrate their compliance with the characteristics and conduct that the Standard for Headship (SOEID, 1998b; SE, 2005) enumerates. The writers of these commentaries are directly implicated in the composition and authoring
Tracking Discursive Change in Reflect ve Commentaries
91
of a professional self in a public arena according to criteria set by the Scottish Government. Their texts, as artefacts for assessment, are therefore invested with a high degree of both personal and professional risk. Criteria for assessment prescribe that the commentaries must display evidence of the following: • critical engagement with academic texts; and • reflectio on professional action in the workplace. The uniqueness of each of these accounts comes from the contextualisation of the particular actions of a particular person, in a particular place, at a particular time and in conjunction with particular others. The accompanying portfolio is expected to provide evidence of actions and outcomes in the work setting that ‘confirms the account given in the commentary and the author’s claims to competence against the standard. These portfolios, as the outcome of work undertaken in the school, are public documents within the school since the evidence that they contain is derived from the work of a candidate’s colleagues and pupils. In seeking to enact new practice the case study illustrates the following effects reported by students: • the lived and embodied nature of the knowledge they are creating; • the affective, imaginative, social and political elements involved in sense making and the development of practice; and • the contingent and situated nature of the learning process.
Tracking Discursive Change in Reflect ve Commentaries This section draws upon a comparison of the reflect ve commentaries produced by SQH candidates during Year 1 and Year 2 of the standard route programme in order to explore any changes in discursive practice that they exhibit. The analysis centres on how the students used key elements of the SQH discourse and the linkages they made in their texts between these concepts and their own experiences. The research group looked at the work of 40 students who completed the course in 2001. Their reflect ve commentaries were examined on a case-by-case basis to explore how each person’s writing about leadership and management had changed over the 2 years. All of those in the sample were also interviewed about their experiences and what they felt they had learned in the course. The Year 1 commentaries were based on the school projects the candidates undertook during Unit 2 whilst the Year 2 commentaries related to their experiences of undertaking their Unit 3 projects. Of this original sample, nine students, three representing those who seemed to have substantively changed their discourse, three who gave some evidence of change, and three who did not appear to have changed were chosen as subjects for a more detailed analysis (Reeves et al., 2005). The connections between each person’s claims to
92
5 Changing Self: Interactions of Space and Identity
learning and the circumstances to which he or she attributed this learning were the focus of these nine mini-case studies. One way of construing the learning task that faced candidates on the SQH is to see it as being about the acquisition of a discourse of school leadership and management and the ability to enact this successfully in the workplace. Hence, the learning process encompasses changes in action and performance on the part of candidates in their schools. This entailed a re-negotiation and re-definitio of their professional selves to a greater or a lesser extent, depending on their initial positioning and the nature of what they sought to achieve. In the reflect ve commentaries, candidates were expected to account for themselves in terms of the model of school leadership and management embedded in the text of the Standard for Headship (SfH), i.e. to conform to a particular type of discourse (Burroughs, 2001; Chappell et al., 2003). They were required to demonstrate a mastery of the ‘proper’ language that, in its turn, reflecte the orthodoxies of its time. Key words and concepts such as Vision, leadership, direction and values. Participative and consultative approaches to decision making. Partnership, teams and culture. are very familiar and widely used in both policy documents and the literature on school leadership and management (Schein, 1992). Since this form of discourse was mediated to, and used by, all SQH candidates on the programme, one way of distinguishing between individuals is to compare the use they made of these terms. Two cases have been selected, respectively, identifie as the accounts of Annette and Jean. Whilst these two people are superficiall similar, an examination of their commentaries shows that their accounts of experience were very different. Both Annette and Jean were from the primary sector, both were members of the senior management teams in their respective schools, and both declared from Year 1 that they wanted to introduce more participative forms of leadership and management into their school settings.
Annette Annette worked in a primary school in an inner city area. A preliminary analysis of her commentaries placed her in the group of those whose texts showed clear development in terms of their articulation of the SQH discourse and their capacity to reflec upon leadership and management practice within its framing. Her project in Year 1 (Y1) centred on homework whilst in Year 2 (Y2) she concentrated on the introduction of measures to raise achievement. Discursive Changes The school already had a homework policy, but there were problems with its implementation:
Tracking Discursive Change in Reflect ve Commentaries
93
Although there was an existing policy, the interpretation of the policy by staff was very varied and the quantity and quality of homework had to be addressed. (Y1)
Annette’s account started from the premise that plans and policies were insufficien to ensure implementation. She presents herself as identifying the adoption of participatory management as the answer to this problem and believed this would entail a change in the staff’s conception of their professionalism although she did not articulate the problem in precisely these terms: I wanted everyone on the staff, and not exclusively the working group, to feel they had a stake and say in the change of policy that would be taking place. This required cultural transformation to ensure that the whole staff had the ability and the confidenc to make choices, to solve problems and to be fully involved in implementing, monitoring and evaluating the homework plan. (Y1)
However, her view of participation had its limits and inconsistencies, some of which she shares with the reader. Although she knew a participative approach entailed relinquishing the power over decision making she was, as her text makes clear, decidedly in charge of the project: The fact there was consultation and then a tight structure may appear to lead to conflic or tension. The plan does not allow for autonomy. This was a deliberate decision. Although much of the change is the responsibility of the teacher the task of monitoring, on which the success of the plan depends, is my responsibility. . . . Through the project I now understand that previous initiatives I have been involved in have failed because of lack of monitoring. (Y1)
Reflectin on the outcomes of her Year 1 project Annette presents herself as advancing a number of reasons as to why her approach to generating cultural change had been less effective than she had hoped. Writing a year later she identifie f ve key strategies that she had resolved to use in Year 2 to improve the impact of her new project: (a) There should be a large working party – to ensure that all staff are welcome and able to join in shaping the policy; (b) I should rely on the staff more and take a back seat. I should act as co-ordinator and organiser but let the tasks be completed by others. (c) The staff should be given the responsibility of monitoring and evaluating aspects of the policy so that they have a long-lasting investment in its success. (Y1) (d) Communication should be face-to-face and frequent. Written communication should not be used as the main medium of contact with others. (e) Parents should be included in the development of the policy. (Y2)
In her Year 2 commentary, Annette begins to use the concept of empowerment. Although she made it clear that staff, pupils and parents could and should shape the development, influencin operations and contributing to the implementation process, she did not believe they should determine strategy. The need for shared and enacted responsibility was her preferred argument in this second text:
94
5 Changing Self: Interactions of Space and Identity The school has to move forward and empower the staff to participate in change. Empowering the staff will encompass giving them the understanding of why change is necessary, motivating them to participate and giving them the skills necessary to make a valuable contribution to the change. – The staff have been saturated by change, which has not always been long lasting or effective. I have to address the needs of the staff as active participants in change. (Y2) Engaging the staff was done through the working group meetings and the constant consultation with all staff members. By delegating much of the responsibility to staff the project has been a huge success. (Y2)
By the end of Year 2, Annette had made links in her account between the goals of participation, as she define it, and the conditions and processes for establishing it that showed greater consistency and helped to make a more convincing link with practice than that evidenced in Year 1. In the second year account, by distinguishing between empowerment and participation, she gained the means to examine how capability could be developed to foster participation, something that she could not do as well when the two concepts were conflated Situational Factors In her second text, Annette presents an assessment of the school’s functioning that was marked by a split between a very experienced staff, disillusioned by externally driven change, and a management team that endeavoured to ensure the school complied with national and local authority priorities: There has been a strong belief from the management team that there was no time to involve staff and that management would save staff the trouble of working on something they could do for them. The SMT also believed that staff were not interested in participating in change and would prefer not to be involved in the formulation of new policies. (Y2)
She balanced this account of the management team’s view of the staff by delineating an equally negative view of the former on the part of the latter as the basis for explaining how her role developed. Annette claimed in her Year 1 commentary that she believed in the improvement agenda from the beginning of the course, and she took on the task of enacting a new model of school leadership with enthusiasm: I was excited and challenged by the project from the beginning. I had my own ideas about the way teaching and learning and people should be managed which were in conflic with many of the values of my school. I was already convinced that by setting up a more democratic culture, focusing on relationships, empowering the staff and using my interpersonal and intellectual abilities, I could develop a home work plan which would lead to long lasting improvement in teaching and learning and raise levels of attainment. (Y1)
This passage was illustrative of how Annette demonstrated her commitment to the image of leadership she saw the SQH as promoting. In this text, she espoused a mission to alter the culture in her school, which she identifie as the prime stumbling block to improvement. In Year 2, she writes that the choice of a change in management style was straightforward, but there are elements in both her commentaries and her interview that indicate that moving away from a previous mind set
Tracking Discursive Change in Reflect ve Commentaries
95
took time. Clearly she was not always as critical of the old management style as she had become: The SQH allowed me to do things differently because my headteacher allowed me to do my project my way. Sometimes in the past you managed things and they were very much influence by the person above you. (Interview)
By the end of Year 2, Annette had achieved a better articulation of participation, and her text asserts the need to involve everyone including the headteacher, who was a marginal figur in the Year 1 account: The cultural change I was looking for would not happen without management backing. – This was perhaps one of the most challenging aspects of the project. – . Both the headteacher and the staff were looking for a commitment from each other before they would make a commitment. This problem could not be solved quickly or easily. As small but significan changes occurred I informed both parties in an informal way until both were convinced of each other’s commitment and shared aims and values. (Y2)
According to her account, Annette’s favoured concept of participation challenged prevailing norms and values held by both the staff and the management team. Through the structure offered by the SQH she desired, and took, the chance to be different driven by the following: (a) her fir belief in the project of school improvement; and (b) enough initial success with her firs project to maintain and strengthen her belief that she could achieve cultural change. In her commentaries, Annette gives evidence that she managed to win a viable space for change on several grounds. Her own desire to be successful led her to gain a mastery over the SQH discourse through her reading and to focus on the outcomes of her project and the actions of others, all of which of which helped her in retaining her own commitment and adapting her practice. However, despite her enthusiasm for the key ideas of participation and empowerment, it was clear that these did not make the same sense to start with as they did by the end of Year 2. She provides a story of how she shaped her approach on the basis of her perception of her situation. She attributed subsequent adjustments in her behaviour and thinking as arising directly out of people’s reactions to her actions. She also says that this meant she had to reject her previous ‘knowledge’ about the staff and the senior management team. In Year 2, she re-aligned her account of their interaction, i.e. deconstructed her previous formulation for action and re-wrote it within the frame of the dominant discourse promulgated by the SQH programme. This was necessary because, if the staff were as recalcitrant and incapable as she had formerly cast them, how would she have been able to account for their reform. She presented herself as successfully implicating others in new practice, with both the staff and the headteacher successively altering their behaviours to enable her interventions to be carried out with a degree of success.
96
5 Changing Self: Interactions of Space and Identity
Jean Jean worked as a deputy headteacher in a large primary school in a rural community. She was one of the candidates who showed little evidence of development as a result of the initial analysis of her commentaries. In the f rst year, she focused on the improvement of writing after having to defer her preferred project, ICT development, until Year 2. Discursive Changes In her Year 1 commentary, Jean conveyed the impression that she was very selffocused. In listing her purposes in developing writing she included the following: This area was of particular importance to myself, – because I wanted to prove to myself that I had the courage and determination to carry out the work and produce something concrete and useful at the end of the work. (Y1)
The frequent statements Jean made about displaying ‘leadership’ are such that readers perhaps interpreted them otherwise than was intended, that is, as indicating a concern with establishing credibility and taking on the demeanours that would achieve this. Jean stated the need for collegial leadership a number of times in the text. However, within her listing of desirable leadership attributes there was an inherent tension with this concept, for instance, ‘establishing authority’ and ‘preserving distance’ were not easily reconciled with the demand to ‘be collegial’ and ‘to be open and approachable’. These inconsistencies are evident in the following excerpt: As I have previously stated I believe that it is important to take the staff ‘with you’ whenever it is possible. It is sometimes equally important being prepared to be ‘forceful’ when it is needed. It is the role of members of the SMT to make decisions within the school. This is a major part of the job remit and it is an area that the other members of staff expect you to do – even though they realise there will be times when you make decisions they disagree with. (Y1)
The text affords little evidence of reflectio on her experience, for instance, there was nothing offered up in her account about making changes in her approach for the future. In the Year 2 text, these discontinuities were not resolved. There was some change in that there was less emphasis on demeanour and more on expertise as the basis for establishing credibility. There was also a slightly more ‘peopled’ quality to the text; the staff figure more in the leadership formulation although there were hints that Jean’s expectations of them were fairly low given the need for the school leader to ‘deflec pressure’, ‘hold things together’ and ‘get them to follow’. There was a certain defensiveness about some of her statements implying that collegiality provided a means of sharing aggravations: The headteacher needs to be at the forefront leading the school, providing a vision for everyone associated with the school while at the same time giving the staff the chance to
Tracking Discursive Change in Reflect ve Commentaries
97
take on some of the burden and take developments forward in an effective and meaningful way. (Y2)
There was no demonstrable linking of the concept of collegial leadership with principles for action nor was any tangible evidence offered in the text about developing the means of achieving a collegial approach. The rather restrictive nature of her formulation of these concepts showed in her summary of what she felt she had achieved: I feel that my ability to think strategically has been developed and can be shown through: The development of a three year budget; The project plan that allows for the pace of staff development to determine the pace at which advances are made; The realisation that I must take staff with me, and to do this it requires we work at their pace; Looking for different ways to go about developing ICT within the school e.g. audit, working group, inset days and twilight courses. (Y2)
Collegial leadership never appeared to signify more than a tactical stance in Jean’s texts. It was not associated with wider concepts such as professionalism or developing capability. Both of her commentaries showed greater concern with establishing personal credibility than they did with an exploration of the practice of collaboration. Situational Factors These were the formulations of an experienced deputy head who had been in the post for a number of years although the worries over management style are usually characteristic of new managers (Fisher, 1996). However, these preoccupations made more sense when we took account of her view of herself as introducing a new style of management and, coincidentally, setting up grounds for ‘failure’: The head works in a more ‘formal’ style as described by Bush in . . . I believe this method of producing policies does not encourage staff to put them into practice in the same way they would if they had been more involved in their development. I knew this would be an area that was going to be diff cult for me to work round without creating an awkward working atmosphere for myself. (Y1:5)
Despite having been deputy head for some time her Year 1 project was the firs occasion on which she had been given a project to lead and manage. Whilst she claimed that she had vindicated her approach in Year 1, in her interview at the end of Year 2, she expressed doubts that the new style would be adopted. A certain lack of confidenc ran throughout both commentaries and the interview. She appeared to have found it difficul to function as she would have wished and not simply because of difficultie with the headteacher: Yes that is right – and it (a collegial approach) would be with anything I am doing in the future – but not necessarily if it is being led by other members of the management. One of the goals I was trying to get across was to show that collegiality does work and while I have shown that it does it will not necessarily be adopted in other areas – that is one
98
5 Changing Self: Interactions of Space and Identity of the difficultie you come up against. I am only a small cog amongst many other cogs. (Interview1 )
There were indications in the interview that showed Jean as someone who had never felt fully socialised into the management role. A sense of being set apart from the other staff was something she said she still found difficult and this may well have been compounded by her own ambivalence about the managerial values enacted in the school. Knowing about these situational factors, one might begin to interpret some of the characteristics of the candidate’s discursive framework as the manifestation of the equivocal position in which she found herself between the model being promulgated by the SQH and the actualities of her work situation. Under these circumstances, it is unsurprising if her schema for leadership was contradictory and unconvincing. Whilst Jean was ‘successful’ in gaining a space from her headteacher to lead two projects, this position was not clearly legitimated in the eyes of her colleagues. She did not appear to command the same degree of personal influenc as Annette. In part, this may have been due to not having worked in quite the same way to develop her own level of expertise, since her command of the discourse remained somewhat tenuous. Whatever the reasons, probably a mixture of personal and contextual factors, Jean was left with little space in which to bring about change. In terms of enacting new practices she was far less successful by her own account than Annette. In trying to retain her aspirations and avoid de-constructing current practice Jean appeared to compromise both her position and her espoused conceptual framework as she tried to reconcile her relationship to the ideas prevailing on the SQH and those prevailing in her school.
The Dynamics of the Learning Process In-Built Contingency Of the nine SQH candidates whose work we looked at in detail, seven overtly referred to experiencing some political tension as a result of being engaged on the SQH, and there is evidence in their accounts of how these tensions influence perception. There were only two in the sample who made no mention of politics, neither of whom showed any evidence of conceptual change which f ts with Fullan’s argument that if there is no loss or disruption there is no change (1991:32). In Jean’s case, it could be argued that her worries about credibility indicated that she had difficultie with enacting the role of leader and manager. This interpretation was given added weight by her perception of prevailing attitudes and practices in her school. The lack of evidence for discursive change in her texts may have been materially affected by her unsuccessful political struggles at work. Even where a 1 Italics
are my insertion.
The Dynamics of the Learning Process
99
candidate was more successful in securing a space to be different, their ideas were nevertheless coloured by the politics of the school. Our knowledge of Annette’s circumstances alerts us to the basis for the counter voice to her refrain of participation and empowerment that remains detectable even in her second commentary. Over the course of the programme Annette reformulates both the knowledge she presents of the ‘reality’ of a ‘more democratic culture’ and her view of herself and the significan others, headteacher and staff, in her school context. Her narrative is about successfully authoring what was a future, or imagined space of interaction, over the two projects and about a re-consideration and reformulation of her past to accommodate this new account. In many ways Jean does not become ‘educated’ by the SQH system. She find the means of avoiding open contestation with current practice within her establishment and takes on neither the discourse nor the practice that the SQH supports. Wrestling with notions of collegial leadership under a headteacher whose style she perceived as autocratic showed inherent tensions and inconsistencies in her articulation of leadership that were not resolved over the 2 years of the programme. Once she had completed the course, one would speculate that her position in the school would be pretty much indistinguishable from that which she held before she started. Annette, by contrast, claimed to bring about change