Professional Education Using E-Simulations: Benefits of Blended Learning Design Dale Holt Deakin University, Australia Stephen Segrave Deakin University, Australia Jacob L. Cybulski Deakin University, Australia
Senior Editorial Director: Director of Book Publications: Editorial Director: Acquisitions Editor: Development Editor: Production Editor: Typesetters: Print Coordinator: Cover Design:
Kristin Klinger Julia Mosemann Lindsay Johnston Erika Carter Michael Killian Sean Woznicki Jennifer Romanchak, Lisandro Gonzalez Jamie Snavely Nick Newcomer
Published in the United States of America by Business Science Reference (an imprint of IGI Global) 701 E. Chocolate Avenue Hershey PA 17033 Tel: 717-533-8845 Fax: 717-533-8661 E-mail:
[email protected] Web site: http://www.igi-global.com Copyright © 2012 by IGI Global. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored or distributed in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, without written permission from the publisher. Product or company names used in this set are for identification purposes only. Inclusion of the names of the products or companies does not indicate a claim of ownership by IGI Global of the trademark or registered trademark.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Professional education using e-simulations: benefits of blended learning design / Dale Holt, Stephen Segrave and Jacob L. Cybulski, editors. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. Summary: “This book disseminates current research and best practice for diffusion of e-Simulations in professional education, providing both theoretical frameworks and case-based evidence to assist the target readership to build their own capacity for developing and/or using e-Simulations”--Provided by publisher. ISBN 978-1-61350-189-4 (hardcover) -- ISBN 978-1-61350-190-0 (ebook) -- ISBN 978-1-61350-191-7 (print & perpetual access) 1. Professional education--Computer-assisted instruction. 2. Blended learning. I. Holt, Dale, 1957- II. Segrave, Stephen, 1954- III. Cybulski, Jacob L., 1958LC1059.P755 2012 371.33’4--dc22 2011009282
British Cataloguing in Publication Data A Cataloguing in Publication record for this book is available from the British Library. All work contributed to this book is new, previously-unpublished material. The views expressed in this book are those of the authors, but not necessarily of the publisher.
Editorial Advisory Board Malcolm Brown, EDUCAUSE Learning Initiative, USA Brian Corbitt, RMIT University, Australia John Hedberg, Millennium Innovations & Macquarie University, Australia Mike Keppell, Charles Sturt University & ASCILITE, Australia Jan H. G. Klabbers, International Simulation and Gaming Association, The Netherlands Piet Kommers, University of Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands Michelle Lamberson, University of British Columbia, Canada Elyssebeth Leigh, University of Technology, Sydney, Australia Som Naidu, Charles Sturt University, Australia Rod Sims, University of New England, Australia Christine Spratt, Northern Melbourne Institute of TAFE, Australia
List of Reviewers Colin Mason, Deakin University, Australia Lemai Nguyen, Deakin University, Australia Charlotte Brack, Monash University, Australia Ben Bradley, Charles Sturt University, Australia Alastair Reed, Northern Melbourne Institute of TAFE, Australia
Table of Contents
Foreword..............................................................................................................................................viii Preface..................................................................................................................................................... x Acknowledgment...............................................................................................................................xviii Chapter 1 E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments................................. 1 Dale Holt, Deakin University, Australia Stephen Segrave, Deakin University, Australia Jacob Cybulski, Deakin University, Australia Section 1 Theorising the Nature of Design for Authentic Learning and E-Simulations Chapter 2 Reappraising Design Practice................................................................................................................ 25 Roderick C. Sims, University of New England, Australia Chapter 3 Real Experiences with Virtual Worlds................................................................................................... 41 Andrew Cram, Macquarie University, Australia John G. Hedberg, Macquarie University, Australia Chapter 4 Design of an Authentic E-Learning Environment................................................................................. 57 Theo J. Bastiaens, Fernuniversität in Hagen, Germany
Section 2 E-Simulation Learning Designs in Action Chapter 5 E-Simulations for the Purpose of Training Forensic (Investigative) Interviewers................................ 71 Belinda Guadagno, Deakin University, Australia Martine Powell, Deakin University, Australia Chapter 6 Professional Midwifery Education: Blended Teaching and Learning Approaches............................... 87 Diane Phillips, Deakin University, Australia Chapter 7 Evaluating the Impact of a Virtual Emergency Room Simulation for Learning................................. 100 Luke Rogers, University of Ballarat, Australia Charlynn Miller, University of Ballarat, Australia Sally Firmin, University of Ballarat, Australia Chapter 8 Designing Simulations for Professional Skill Development in Distance Education: A Holistic Approach for Blended Learning.......................................................................................................... 121 Deborah Murdoch, Charles Sturt University, Australia Chris Bushell, Charles Sturt University, Australia Stephanie Johnson, Charles Sturt University, Australia Chapter 9 Simulating Difficult Nurse Patient Relationships: Meeting the Online Continuing Professional Development Needs of Clinical Nurses with Low Cost Multimedia E-Simulations........................... 141 Peter Kandlbinder, University of Technology Sydney, Australia Scott Brunero, Prince of Wales Hospital, Australia Chapter 10 Blended Learning Designs Facilitated by New Media Technologies Including E-Simulations for Pharmacy and Other Health Sciences.................................................................................................. 157 Gregory Duncan, Monash University, Australia Ian Larson, Monash University, Australia Chapter 11 Integrating E-Simulations in Teaching Business Information Systems............................................... 174 Jacob Cybulski, Deakin University, Australia Lemai Nguyen, Deakin University, Australia
Chapter 12 Developing Professional Competence in Project Management Using E-Simulation on Campus....... 198 Ian Searle, RMIT University, Australia Hossein Zadeh, RMIT University, Australia Chapter 13 Using E-Simulations in Retail Sales Training: Benefits of Blended Learning Design........................ 215 Virpi Slotte, AAC Global, Finland Anne Herbert, Aalto Universtiy School of Economics, Finland Chapter 14 The SUPL Approach: A Conceptual Framework for the Design of 3D E-Simulations Based on Gaming Technology within a Problem-Based Learning Pedagogy..................................... 233 Michael Garrett, Edith Cowan University, Australia Mark McMahon, Edith Cowan University, Australia Chapter 15 Media Effects: E-Simulations and Authentic “Blended” Learning..................................................... 255 Kristin Demetrious, Deakin University, Australia Chapter 16 Through the Looking Glass: Immersive Interfaces for Participant Engagement in Blended E-Learning Environments................................................................................................. 271 Janette Grenfell, Deakin University, Australia Ian Warren, Deakin University, Australia Section 3 Developing Knowledge and Building Capacities for E-Simulations Chapter 17 A Framework for Designing Mainstream Educational E-Simulations................................................ 293 Jacob Cybulski, Deakin University, Australia Chapter 18 Supporting the Design of Interactive Scenarios in a University Environment: Techniques, Issues and Constraints...................................................................................................... 316 T. M. Stewart, Massey University, New Zealand Chapter 19 Scenario-Based Learning: Experiences in the Development and Application of a Generic Teaching Software Tool................................................................................................... 346 Audrey Jinks, The University of Queensland, Australia Geoff Norton, The University of Queensland, Australia Matt Taylor, The University of Queensland, Australia Terry Stewart, Massey University, New Zealand
Chapter 20 Future Developments in E-Simulations for Learning Soft Skills in the Health Professions............... 370 Piet Kommers, University of Twente, The Netherlands Chapter 21 The Challenge of Investigating the Value of E-Simulations in Blended Learning Environments: A Case for Design-Based Research.............................................................. 394 Stephen Segrave, Deakin University, Australia Mary Rice, Educational Consultant, Australia Afterword............................................................................................................................................ 415 About the Contributors..................................................................................................................... 423 Index.................................................................................................................................................... 431
viii
Foreword
The success of any media depends on the ease of cutting and pasting. How easily can your work borrow from my work? First, there is the raison d’être. Does it make sense for someone to create a type of experience and does it make sense for a group to consume it? This was initially true of so much we take for granted today. The case had to be made, often by courageous fanatics, for plays, opera, novels, and Facebook. As a result of preceding work, Stephen Spielberg did not have to say, “Wouldn’t it be great if a lot of people would pay to sit in a dark room looking at moving pictures and sound?” Then, media expands when techniques and processes are shared. Professionals need to know about the successful practices of the people who came before us. For example, over the years, various innovators have developed and refined such scaffolding as chapters in books, laugh tracks in sitcoms, and titles and credits for movies. Finally, there comes the democratising inflection point in the success of media when actual raw content can be swapped around. Today for example, almost anyone can use a word processor to cut and paste text and photographs and formatting. Lawyers use boilerplate passages all of the time. Meanwhile a high schooler may use a pop-music track for laying out a music video, while an amateur movie director may use footage from another movie to work out pacing issues. Which brings us to e-simulations, and the book you have in front of you. There is the very burning question, where are we now? First, there is the good news. Because of the work of the fanatics who came before us, we know that simulations are necessary for the effectiveness of eLearning (and therefore distance learning), and increasingly all education. We have crossed that threshold, even if some haven’t noticed it yet. The methodology to support the most life-and-death applications of education, necessarily driving competence, conviction, and comfort in students aiming to be doctors and pilots, have long demanded and evolved the use of sims. But now almost all new programs in any discipline are employing e-simulations at different levels of sophistication. But the bad news is that we aren’t yet at the moment that you can cut and paste from someone else’s work. The creation of e-simulations has not been democratised. We can’t easily play around with someone else’s sim. We can’t make a few changes, and then a few more, until we have something of our own. There is no multi-genre sim equivalent of a word processor. This places us right in the middle. Leading professionals are, well, leading. They are pioneering new approaches, almost inevitably the hard way. And it is up to the rest of us members of the education field to learn everything we can from them. We must absorb techniques and research and genuine lessons. It is too hard and inefficient to start from scratch each time, and it is irresponsible to ignore progress all together.
ix
And that’s where Holt’s, Segrave’s, and Cybulski’s “Professional Education Using e-Simulations: Benefits of Blended Learning Design” comes in. This book is state of the art. And I don’t mean Star Trek style holodecks (which are coming) or Matrix style knowledge-downloads (good luck with that). Rather, this is where the pioneers of the industry really are. The papers gathered here honestly and thoroughly show today’s risk taking, brainstorming, and realistic compromises. Here are the processes that others will be following shortly, and likely the techniques that will get formalised in the authoring tools of the future. There is a final and critically important best practice to consider, however. We focus on the roles and scale of the individual and design teams. Their actions are critical and are the foundation of the value delivered. But the more strategic and thus perhaps even more important process to emulate is Deakin University’s approach to the sim space. We are at a time when there are three major innovations shaping higher ed.: Virtual/non-face-to-face engagement, social networking, and sims. But as powerful as the first two innovations are, they are akin to retail organisations outsourcing the manufacturing process offshore, or newspapers replacing staff reporters with AP or other centralised news feeds. These approaches are useful in the short term to scale up and boost the bottom line. But if the two are the sole foci, they also lead to non-differentiation and even disintermediation in the long term. It may well be that the hard, innovative work of sim design, construction, and deployment remains the area of highest, real, and even differentiating value. This means that other universities have a choice. They can follow this strategic path to higher value today, or risk irrelevance within the decade. Clark Aldrich Clark Aldrich Designs, USA
Clark Aldrich is a global education thought leader, labeled a guru by Fortune Magazine. As well as being an award-winning analyst and speaker, Clark Aldrich has designed simulations that have been patent winning, generated millions in revenues, are market leaders in their categories, have been rigorously proven to drive long term desired changes in behavior, and have been translated and deployed in dozens of countries and languages. Aldrich is also the author of five books, including his new book Unschooling Rules. Clark Aldrich founded and serves as the Managing Partner of Clark Aldrich Designs, which works with corporate, military, government, and academic organizations balancing both board-level and hands-on work. Aldrich’s work has been featured in hundreds of sources, including CBS, ABC, The New York Times, Wall Street Journal, CNN, NPR, CNET, Business 2.0, BusinessWeek, U.S. News and World Reports. Previously, Aldrich was the founder and former director of research for Gartner’s e-learning coverage. He graduated from Brown University with a degree in Cognitive Science, and earlier in his career worked on special projects for Xerox’ executive team.
x
Preface
The genesis of this project lies in the Editors leading a major national Australian project, ‘Building academic staff capacity for using e-Simulations in professional education for experience transfer’, over the period 2008-2010 funded under the Australian Learning and Teaching Council (ALTC) Competitive Grants Scheme. Certain chapters in this book reflect developments undertaken through this national project. The Editors would like to give due acknowledgement to the ALTC and the Australian Department of Education, Employment and Workplace Relations (DEEWR) in providing the opportunity to undertake this project which in turn provided the stimulus to make contact with other people actively involved in developing and using e-simulations in higher education and the workplace for educating the professions, and the training of other related occupations. These contacts were located across Australia and other parts of the world; the interests in e-simulations covered both 2D and 3D immersive environments for education and training. Our investigations have revealed a major gap and therefore opportunity to foreground the use and value of these types of e-simulations in the interrelated fields of online, distance and flexible education. We have, however, chosen to situate e-simulation developments squarely in the domain of blended learning theorising and action, as it is currently receiving much attention in both so-called traditional on-campus institutions and more flexibly-based distance education providers. Increasingly, tertiary institutions seem to be evolving both sets of characteristics coalescing around commitments to blended aspects of both organisational worlds. Moreover, we are focusing primarily on the deployment of e-simulations in contributing to the education of the professions and by extension the training of other workplace occupations. A striking theme in the book is how a range of disciplines across a variety of institutions conceptualise their learning designs for local blended learning environments, and have built the necessary capacities for developing and delivering their own e-simulation frameworks. The use of digital, Webbased simulations for education and training in the professions is a significant, emerging technology innovation requiring immediate attention. A convergence of new educational needs, theories of learning and role-based simulation technologies, point to the educators’ readiness for e-simulations as a serious teaching endeavour. As modern e-simulations aim at integration into blended learning environments, they promote rich experiential, constructivist learning. As such they are and will continue to rapidly gain mainstream acceptance. This book contains a broad range of theoretical perspectives on, and practical illustrations of, the field of e-simulations for educating the professions in blended learning environments. Readers will see authors articulate various views on the nature of professions and professionalism, the nature and roles that various types of e-simulations play in contributing to developing an array of professional capabilities, and various viewpoints on how e-simulations as an integral component of blended learning envi-
xi
ronments can be conceived, enacted, evaluated and researched. A broad range of professions and allied occupational groupings are considered through the chapters in this book covering: the Health professions (nursing, midwifery, psychology, occupational therapy, pharmacy, forensic interviewing, counselling, medicine); the Business and Law professions (business studies, project management, business Information Systems, financial planning, law, ethics); Arts professions (criminology, public relations, police studies, journalism); the Education profession; the Engineering and Science professions (environmental sciences, veterinary science, agriculture); the Social and Behavioural Science professions; and Workplace training (sales, mining fire evacuation). Moreover, a special contribution to the book is an emphasis on effective leadership and management to ensure e-simulations can be developed and sustained as a key strategy in institutions’ online teaching and learning plans. Of overriding importance though is the focus on effective learning designs of both e-simulations and the overall learning environments in which simulations are embedded. These learning designs are highly contingent on context, the student audience and an organisation’s technical capabilities. This demands that academic teachers play the defining role in shaping the designs and operation of their e-simulations in their learning environments for the benefit of their students’ learning. Let us step back for a moment from this book and its contents and briefly chart the evolutionary course of e-simulations. For more than 50 years researchers have reported the benefits of simulations, but leaders with a long history of publishing and practice in the field, such as Dr. Jan Klabbers (General secretary of the International Simulation and Gaming Association from 1976 to 2004), Dr. Hugh Cannon (Dean of Fellows, Association for Business Simulation and Experiential Learning) and more recently innovators such as Clark Aldrich (co-founder of SimuLearn, independent consultant and practitioner working on educational simulations for professional skills training) recount that designing and researching simulations remains a problem, in part because ‘scientific’ methods rely on shared understandings, terminology and classification when dealing with simulation concepts, principles, rules, theories and models. Such understandings are struggling to keep pace with the advancing technologies and the reflexive practices of teachers. This situation will only become more problematic with the advent of networked and mobile simulations and games. In respect to the explosion of technologies for educational purposes, while the 1990s was the decade of the ‘e’ in eLearning and other ‘e’ activities, the past decade has seen the emergence of the ‘i’ with many products made famous by Apple Pty. Ltd. - iPod, iTunes, iPhone and iPad. For digital simulations the ‘eSim’ term has persisted and has not been critiqued here. It could be suggested that the ‘e’ denoting ‘electronic’, might carry more appropriate connotations along the lines of experiential, emotional and engaging. These terms are at the heart of many of the chapters in the book. As indicated, the field of simulations and games is represented by a diverse literature continuing to struggle with terminology, ontology, typology, and taxonomy. Narrowing the field to digital simulations, ‘e-simulations’ (Web-based, digital simulations) used in the service of education, hardly simplifies the challenge of identifying and organising their characteristics and attributes in a taxonomy. One way of describing e-simulations is through a typology that foregrounds the characteristics or traits they have in common. The book advocates a typology based on e-simulations used in blended learning designs in the service of higher education in the professions. It also advocates a design-based research (DBR) approach to progressing e-simulations agendas and programs. A DBR approach is illuminative of relations in the whole rather than just focusing on classifying the parts, is consistent with a constructivist epistemology, celebrates cases rather than categories, foregrounds themes rather than hierarchies of atomistic elements, and is synthetic and emergent rather than analytic and reductive.
xii
When defining simulations, it is important to distinguish between form and function. To illustrate; while games often ‘simulate’ a system of relationships and events found in real or imagined settings, in the process of modelling these, games exhibit characteristics and attributes (e.g. winning) that nongame simulations may not. Clearly, many simulations do not function as games, but it is not unusual for goal-based, role-based simulations to contain attributes of games (e.g. rules, chance and feedback); in fact it can be argued that it is important to retain such characteristics. Equally importantly is the need to grapple with the territory which is defined as blended learning. We can see it simply at one level as the fusion of both physical and virtual environments in ways which contribute to quality learning experiences and outcomes, and which usually embody a mix of learning methods. As Littlejohn and Pegler (2007) suggest, blended learning is as much an old as it is a new phenomenon, but it is being strongly invigorated by the affordances of the new digital and online technologies: Blended is an art that has been practised by inspirational teachers for centuries. It centres on the integration of different types of resources and activities within a range of learning environments where learners can interact and build ideas. Over the past few decades, blended learning has extended learning methodologies, opening up opportunities for open and distance learning as well as challenging more traditional methods. Most recently the term ‘blend’ has been attached to e-learning, and this blending of e-learning with traditional methods is attracting the interest of many teachers in further and higher education. This contrasts with the relatively poor take-up of predominantly or exclusively e-learning methods, particularly where e-learning has been expected to offer an unproblematic cost-saving replication of traditional teaching methods. (p.1) Beyond its relatively simple and straightforward definition, the book aims to probe and deepen understanding of blended learning as the artfulness of the intentionality (wilfulness) of designing nuanced conceptualisations of comprehensively integrated learning environments. This sees teachers as agents working in reflexive ways, performing the art of influencing the way the learning environment functions. This perhaps represents a more mature notion than a simplistic description of blending being a fusion of online, face-to-face and other methods of learning. In this book, we explicitly pay homage to the pioneers of educational simulation and their efforts to theorise the field of simulations and games; and to those who have conceptualised the field of blended learning illustrating it with a rich range of cases in action. Their work is cited through the book. We aim though to bring the message of the value of e-simulations into the realm of the practising teacher who wishes to make a difference to the learning of their students, and yet who may not wish to engage directly, and contribute actively to the body of relevant knowledge, or, indeed, wish to master complex technologies in creating valuable learning resources. They need to see approaches that work, which can be done within reasonable timeframes and with reasonable resources, and which fit with their educational values, beliefs and practices. They need to see evidence of an effective student learning experience. They need fundamentally to have an astute sense of the changing demands of professional practice, and the appropriate combination of means to prepare and enhance their students’ capacities as competent and ethical professionals in times of rapid and unpredictable change. Many of these potential users do not have the time to be taken away from their ongoing academic and training worlds to engage with grander forms of theorising and elaborate processes of design and development. We see progress as much in terms of the expansion of practical developments of high utility as we do in the refinement of theoretical frames of reference.
xiii
Thus, the target readership audience is framed by the book’s aim to develop the capacities for educational institutions to design, develop, implement, evaluate and research the impacts of e-simulations as an integral part of their educational strategies. Hence, the book has the following range of key audiences: academic teachers who wish to adopt value adding e-learning strategies to enhance the education of their students in professional fields and disciplines offered in a range of different contexts; instructional designers who wish to learn new methodologies for the cost-effective development of e-simulations; media producers interested in the skills and technologies involved in developing and delivering various types of role-based e-simulations; institutional leaders and managers wishing to make sound investments in learning, teaching and technologies; evaluators and researchers wishing to assess the impact on learning and teaching of e-simulations; professional bodies and industry experts wishing to see e-learning technologies applied in ways which will better prepare students for professional practice; and professional and corporate trainers wishing to use e-Simulation as a major method for the ongoing training and development of employees. The book begins by setting the scene for the development of e-simulations for educating the professions in blended learning environments in Chapter 1. Holt, Segrave and Cybulski chart the field covering changing needs and circumstances, and relevant learning theories and definitions of e-simulations and blended learning. The chapter highlights a way of framing the alignment of design elements when designing for the e-simulation learning experience in a blended learning environment. Chapters 2-4 in Section 1: Theorising the Nature of Design for Authentic Learning and E-Simulations, provide various theoretical underpinnings and consequent practical illustrative advice on designing digitally-supported authentic learning and e-simulation environments. Rod Sims in Chapter 2 draws on a life-time of instructional design experience and scholarship in conceiving a design model more attuned to the affordances of progressive pedagogy and digital media. The chapter presents an enhanced version of Proactive Design for Learning (PD4L) and applies it to the design of a fictitious e-simulation relating to the global financial crisis. Chapter 3 by Andrew Cram and John Hedberg extends the design challenge into three-dimensional virtual worlds for learning. The chapter also identifies a range of narrative types and supportive modifiers which can be deployed in designing virtual worlds. Underlying the chapter is social constructivism as a strong point of theorising about the design and operation of these worlds for student learning. Specifically, four representation opportunities for simulation designers are examined, namely; space, time, place and avatars Theo Bastiaens in Chapter 4 sets out another instructional design model based on cognitive learning theory and used in responding to life-long learning needs, namely: the Four-Component Instructional Design Model (4C/ID model). The model demands attention to learning tasks, supportive information, just-in-time information and part-task practice. The application of this model relates to teacher educators and their development needs in using interactive whiteboards in classroom teaching. The section exemplifies the diversity of theorising on approaches to designing authentic and e-simulation environments in the contexts of educating the professions and workforce training needs. Two approaches in Section 1 are strongly shaped by pre-existing theories of learning, while the other is strongly grounded in extensive instructional design practice. Such approaches and models require further practical application and testing of their efficacy in various simulated environments. There is strength in their versatility of use, and yet careful thought needs to be given to the application of any instructional design model when considering the development of simulations, both virtual and as played out in physical settings, and in their design into more broadly conceived blended learning environments drawing on other pedagogies and media.
xiv
Chapters 5-16 in Section 2: E-Simulation Learning Designs in Action, present various e-simulation designs in action serving the needs of learners in a number of disciplines and professional fields. Each one provides insight into the design rationale, the use of the e-simulation in blended learning settings, and the evaluation of impacts on the student learning experience. The reader’s attention is drawn to two fundamental considerations shaping these designs in action. First is how the e-simulation is conceived to address the development of desired capabilities or competencies of the profession in question. These rationales increasingly need to take account of growing pressures on teaching and physical resources, and greater demands from a range of parties on acceptable professional standards. The second consideration is how the contribution of the e-simulation is defined in relation to other aspects of the blended learning environment. The former provides a range of e-simulation design actions from the development of well specified professional attributes (as usually defined by externally accrediting professional bodies) to those which help critique and open up new domains of professional capability in the fields in question. The latter consideration opens up various permutations and combinations of pedagogy, media and assessment incorporating e-simulations in complex, holistically conceived learning environments. The studies of designs in action illuminate the highly contingent and creative task of designing and successfully delivering e-simulations. Their resonance (relevance and value) is to be judged primarily by the reader in relation to their own commitments, challenges and contexts of use. Chapters 5-10 cover broadly the health-case, health science and pharmacy professions. The feature of Chapter 5 by Belinda Guadagno and Martine Powell is the strong disciplinary-based research underpinning more effective forms of forensic interviewing as encapsulated in their e-simulation aimed at developing such communicative skills in the demanding and highly sensitive area relating to the potential sexual abuse of a child. Diane Phillips examines the value of an e-simulation in the preparation of mid-wives as used in diverse blended learning regional and rural settings. The skills developed respond to external accreditation requirements of the relevant professional body. In Chapter 7, Rogers, Miller and Firmin move the focus of nursing education into the three-dimensional environment of Second Life with their well designed and evaluated virtual emergency room simulation. The authors locate the benefits of their simulation within a broader examination of the worth of simulations and educational technologies within nursing education. Working in an institution with a strong profile in online, distance and professional education, Murdoch, Bushell and Johnson focus on the design of simulations in mental health and policing using a disciplined approach to their planning and delivery in Chapter 8. The Analysis, Design, Development, Implementation and Evaluation (ADDIE) approach to instructional design, and the constructive alignment framework and SOLO (Structure of the Observed Learning Outcome) taxonomy, were used to ensure the most cost-effective development of the e-simulations as integrated into the relevant curricula and assessment. The theme of developing low-cost multimedia simulations for dealing with difficult nurse-patient relationships and in doing so adopting a user-centred design approach is taken up by Peter Kandlbinder and Scott Brunero in Chapter 9. The authoring of this chapter represents a strong working relationship between the academic designer and the hospital-based professional practitioner. This type of partnership highlights the need for e-simulations to be well grounded in significant concerns of professional practice. Finally, in this cluster of chapters, Gregory Duncan and Ian Larson use a Pedagogy>Space>Technology framework to present their cases of differently conceived e-simulations in pharmacy and other health sciences. They articulate strong background factors and drivers shaping the need to consider different types of e-simulations both from the vantage point of pressures in educating the professions in higher education, and from the perspective of the changing and ever-increasing
xv
expectations of the profession. Fittingly, the chapter concludes with a proposed inter-professional esimulation learning environment for medical and pharmacy students. The possibility of inter-disciplinary teams designing inter-professional e-simulations in contributing to broader experiences in educating the professions is seen as an emerging field of great potential, and is returned to in the Afterword. Chapters 11-14 cover the business Information System and project management, and customer and mine evacuation training domains. They fall generally in the area of business, management and Information Technology. Jacob Cybulski and Lemai Nguyen begin the discussion with Chapter 11 which looks at the highly strategic and targeted use of e-simulation in a very large, complex unit in first year business Information Systems. The development and deployment of the e-simulation was part of a major renewal of the entire subject, and one which is taught over campuses, regions and different modes of study (onand off-campus) and to students of enormous diversity. Once again the e-simulation was underpinned by an astute and reasonable understanding of professional practice requirements at the first year level. More profoundly, the e-simulation and its deployment required the honest acknowledgement and critical dismantlement of ‘educational dogmas’ in order to achieve evaluated benefits. The authors remind us that e-simulations require a far broader and deeper critical re-examination of curricular, pedagogical and assessment concerns to achieve full student learning value. Moreover, the blends of media and technologies are more sophisticated and subtle than a simple substitution of one method or technology for another. Ian Searle and Hossein Zadeh take us into the use of e-simulation in a quite different type of blended learning environment with a predominately single on-campus learning experience. The authors methodically work through the professional competence requirements of the field of project management as related to managing business Information Systems projects. The project management methodologies of relevant professional associations are articulated as necessary background to their e-simulation. The feature though is the way in which the whole subject is taught through a simulation with its blending of resources and activities located in virtual and physical worlds. In Chapter 13, Virpi Slotte and Anne Herbert shift the focus into workplace-based learning in organisational contexts relating to retail sales training. In the e-simulation training programs developed the blend focuses on socially situated interaction in the workplace with the simulation itself. This blended approach had a deliberate and well researched instructional design. Chapter 14 by Michael Garrett and Mark McMahon takes us further into the world of both workplace learning and the benefits of learning in three-dimensional e-simulations. Their work is informed by the design of 3D e-simulations based on gaming technology and within a problem-based learning pedagogy. The simulation is based on the design of an occupational health and safety training platform, the Fires in Underground Mines Evacuation Simulator (FUMES). The environment developed and evaluated showcases the affordances of 3D technology for the type of learning required. Chapters 15 and 16 deal with the fields of public relations (one of the media communication professions) and art education. These design cases in Chapter 16 augment the teacher education cases used as illustrative examples in chapters 3 and 4. In Chapter 15, Kristin Demetrious engages critically with the current state of public relations as a professional occupation. This critical re-engagement of the field in turn leads to a re-conceptualisation of the PR curriculum and the novel design intent of the e-simulation scenarios developed. While other design cases in action draw on generally accepted views held by both teachers and their professional associations on what constitutes good professional practice, Demetrious challenges us and her colleagues to rethink both the domains of ethical and constructive PR practice, and the requisite capabilities to excel in such domains. Such a fundamental critique and repositioning sees e-simulations blended into radically new curricula and pedagogies. Jenny Grenfell and Ian Warren
xvi
also adopt a more far-reaching conceptualisation of operating within and across virtual 3D and physical worlds in support again of inter-professional learning in art education and another area of public relations. Their work highlights the mutually beneficial immersion and active participation of teachers and students, or teachers and students as co-learners and co-producers of digital resources in such virtual worlds. This design case in action reveals a richness of learning and complexity of learning environments as to challenge us to think yet again about the blends of learning that might be imagined in shaping the future education of the professions as learning community. Further cases relating to the sciences and other professional fields are illustrated in chapters 18 and 19, while chapter 20 focuses on general e-simulation systems development as related to medical and allied health-care professions. The final chapter 21 on design-based research cites as examples developments from psychology, journalism, law, accounting and financial planning. While section 2 highlights cases of e-simulations in depth, clearly other chapters in section 1 and 3, respectively, use further illustrative examples from other professional fields to build the overall view on the breadth and diversity of e-simulation developments. E-simulations will continue to contribute to online learning and teaching the world over. What is at stake is the quality and scope of e-simulation developments, i.e. realising the potential of the strong alignments between simulation, as worthy pedagogy, and their electronic construction and delivery, as a worthy and substantial contribution to blended learning for educating the professions. Five chapters in Section 3: Developing Knowledge and Building Capacities for E-Simulations, are devoted to examining various aspects of developing knowledge and building capacities for e-simulations. Chapter 17 by Jacob Cybulski begins this investigation by identifying the key elements that need to be considered in delivering a successful e-simulation program for mainstreaming purposes. The elements are drawn together into a framework covering scope, experience, mechanics and deployment. These elements encompass more than the educational rationale and local requirements. The successful mainstreaming of e-simulations is an educational, technical and organisational challenge which needs a well and comprehensively conceived basis for success. One such element in achieving mainstreaming of e-simulations is to adopt a wellinformed approach to their conception and story boarding, and then to their effective deployment. These matters are considered in detail in Chapter 18 by Terry Stewart, who introduces a particular authoring tool which has been developed to facilitate the development process, with extensive illustrations. The mechanics and functioning of this tool is further examined in chapter 19 by Jinks, Norton, Taylor and Stewart, with additional illustrative and showcase examples. Compellingly, this tool has been jointly developed by universities in New Zealand and Australia, and used in the United Kingdom. These crossinstitutional, cross-country collaborative endeavours reveal the potential of expanding knowledge and capacity for greater and better action. In Chapter 20, Piet Kommers maps out the components for developing a major research-driven system for e-simulations for developing soft skills in the medical and health-care professions. The scope of this research and development initiative is based on projects funded by the European Union (EU) including contributions from several countries in the region. Finally, Stephen Segrave and Mary Rice in Chapter 21 propose the case for design-based research in progressing e-simulation enhancements over time, and as evidenced by the use of this approach in one major institutional context. Design-based research can involve and meet the needs of various stakeholders by focusing on the value of e-simulations, and as embedded in various blended learning environments, and their development as a strategic agenda of action. The institutional setting presented reveals the potential for strong internal organisational partner-
xvii
ing as a basis for national inter-institutional partnering to build and share knowledge in the service of enhancing the profile of e-simulations in the world of blended learning for professional and workplace education. Stephen Segrave concludes the book in an Afterword exploring developments in e-simulations for educating the professions in blended learning settings in prospect. The best prospects will see more complex and sophisticated settings for the blended design and use of e-simulations, accompanied by more inter-disciplinary, inter-institutional and inter-regional collaborations. Dale Holt Deakin University, Australia Stephen Segrave Deakin University, Australia Jacob L. Cybulski Deakin University, Australia
REFERENCES Littlejohn, A., & Pegler, C. (2007). Preparing for blended e-learning. London, UK: Routledge.1
xviii
Acknowledgment
Support for this publication has been provided by the Australian Learning and Teaching Council Ltd, an initiative of the Australian Government Department of Education, Employment and Workplace Relations. The views expressed in this publication do not necessarily reflect the views of the Australian Learning and Teaching Council. Dale Holt Deakin University, Australia Stephen Segrave Deakin University, Australia Jacob L. Cybulski Deakin University, Australia
1
Chapter 1
E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments Dale Holt Deakin University, Australia Stephen Segrave Deakin University, Australia Jacob Cybulski Deakin University, Australia
ABSTRACT This chapter introduces digital, role-based simulations as an emerging and powerful educational approach for the professions and for broader workforce development purposes. It is acknowledged that simulations used for education, professional development, and training, have a long history of development and use. The focus is on digital simulations (e-simulations) situated in blended learning environments and the improved affordances of the newer digital media used via the web to enhance the value of their contribution to learning and teaching in professional and vocationally-oriented fields. This is an area which has received less attention in the whole “e-learning” literature compared with the voluminous body of knowledge and practice on computer-mediated communication, online community building, social networking, and various forms of online (usually automated) assessment. A framework of blended e-simulation design is outlined. The chapter concludes by examining what the future might hold for simulations in further and higher education, and ongoing work-based learning.
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-61350-189-4.ch001
Copyright © 2012, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments
INTRODUCTION The cornerstone of frameworks for providing open, distance and flexible education, is associated with online and recent pervasive technologies. Advances in networked media technologies drive new forms of blended learning and teaching practices. There is an extraordinary volume and richness of literature relating to educational technologies emanating from, and applying to, these various intersecting fields of educational and training practice. From this publisher’s more recent series alone, online education can be seen as being informed by the rich heritage of adult learning theories and practices (Kidd, 2010; Kidd & Keengwe, 2010), while information and communication technologies (ICT) are foregrounded in developments in blended learning practices (Stacey & Gerbic, 2009), to include ICT support for evidence-based assessment practices (Spratt & Lajbcygier, 2009). While these publications draw on contributors from across the world and from an enormous variety of national and institutional settings, the totality of reported works represents only a small amount of the large body of literature relating to research, scholarship, practice, and policy making surrounding educational technologies globally. The world of educational technologies is rapidly expanding, and its boundaries are dynamic to continually include new stakeholders, to span novel problems, and to embrace new scope and concerns. For the new researcher, practitioner and policy maker, it must seem like a bewilderingly complex and confusing world to navigate and achieve well evidenced outcomes. While acknowledging the broad sweep of the literature, our concern in this book is to focus on one area of online education, which offers great potential for enhancing teaching and learning experiences in contemporary settings. More specifically, we examine the design, implementation, and evaluation of e-simulations to enhance the education of those in professional and vocational fields. This chapter maps some of the key territory for the 2
development and use of e-simulations, including their theoretical foundations, nature, characteristics and benefits. We highlight the value of centring role-based e-simulations in the blended design of contemporary learning environments. The field of e-simulations has its own diversity of perspectives and practices. These are acknowledged and explained throughout this publication. However, we see e-simulations as a reasonably well-defined and understandable educational technology that can add significant value to mature and nuanced blended learning designs and, ultimately, students’ learning experiences.
THE CHANGING CONTEXTS OF HIGHER EDUCATION AND TRAINING In the 21st century, higher education must meet a number of new (and continuing) challenges. External pressures have forced institutions to focus strongly on vocational courses at the expense of more scholarly classical studies. Reduced finances available from governments have led to the constant need to find alternative funding arrangements. Extra demands are placed on academic staff to do more with less in respect to their teaching and research. The nature of student cohorts has changed quite considerably, with respect to diversity in ability, cultural background, learning preferences, technology experience, levels of motivation, and the time they are able or willing to spend on their study (Biggs, 2003). The following are typical observations made by teachers of the newer generation of students: • • • • •
They have less time for everything. They pay less attention (often to authority). They demonstrate less persistence and endurance. They see less need for deep knowledge. They have somewhat less fear of failure and are open to pursuing alternatives and new options.
E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments
•
• •
They see their new wealth as buying results and act like pragmatic customers or consumers of (educational) services. They undertake a critical rating of benefit for the effort they expend. They consistently value friends and networks.
What implications do such observations have for fostering student learning? In relation to higher education, Oblinger and Oblinger (2005) discussed the needs and characteristics of the ‘Net generation’ (or Generation Y, those born on or after 1982) and highlighted their learning preferences as including: •
•
•
•
A desire to be strongly team and peer-topeer based, that is, they seek out help from their friends and gravitate towards team approaches; A demand for engagement and experience, that is, they like to learn by discovery and doing things; A strong preference for visual and kinesthetic, that is, they are visual communicators and like to be physically immersed in their work; and A desire to learn things that matter, that is, they switch off quickly from things that don’t interest them and that don’t seem relevant to their world.
What clues do these observations give us about designing and operating contemporary blended teaching and learning environments? If, as Oblinger and Oblinger (2005) argue, the Net generation wish learning experiences to be digital (while still valuing highly effective forms of interpersonal, face-to-face communication), connected, experiential, immediate, and socially based, what are the implications for the appropriate development and use of technologies in higher education?
A further challenge for higher education has been the advent of sophisticated e-teaching that has seen a range of new technologies available for new educational designs and new performances of teaching. It has become such a firmly entrenched element in many higher education courses that online environments are used in some form or another across almost all institutions, and in almost all discipline areas. Through a process of gradual development over several years, institutions have been implementing various types of digital environments that provide access to study materials and resources, and facilitate electronic communications. Concurrent with this shift has been greater emphases on the need for more effective teaching approaches to cater for the various ways students learn, and the various preferences they have for bringing about their own learning in respect to both content and media. For decades, much university teaching has been based on “transmission” models in which academics had the discipline knowledge and were responsible for imparting or transmitting it to their students using various teaching methods, some of which involved various media technologies. With the expansion of more powerful technologies over the years, and more particularly the use of knowledge creation and collaboration tools for online learning, the expectation was that teaching and learning processes could be transformed. Digital multi-media and communication technologies have the potential to bring to life much of the abstract learning in university contexts. It was thought that online communities of inquiry would lead to more academic learning. However, as Garrison and Anderson (2003) argue, these advances have not led most students “to approach learning in a critical manner and process information in a deep and meaningful way” (p.5). Indeed, a number of authors have argued (Aldrich, 2009; Laurillard, 2003; Ramsden, 2003) that in spite of new technologies, recognisable linear transmission models still comprise the dominant teaching paradigm in many courses that include online learning, because
3
E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments
of the tendency to simply move existing courses online rather than reconceptualise the design of teaching, learning, and assessment to maximise the potential offered by networked, digital technologies. (See, for example, Biggs, 2003; Garrison & Anderson, 2003; Laurillard, 2003.) These same authors advocate change, using approaches that apply research evidence to teaching practices, that is, “evidence based teaching”. In particular, because teaching is personal, Biggs (2003, pp.5-7) argues for the use of a “scholarship of teaching” brought about through reflection on teaching actions in a particular context. This need for change has prompted a great deal of rethinking about university approaches to teaching and learning with technology, and has led to the publication of a number of seminal texts that argue the case for change and provide suitable frameworks or blueprints for doing so. (See Bates & Poole, 2003; Biggs, 2003; Garrison & Anderson, 2003; Jonassen, Peck, & Wilson, 1999; Laurillard, 2003; Ramsden, 2003.) These texts and other key papers present a clear consensus about what constitutes effective teaching and learning with technology. We argue that e-simulations are best understood as one constructive response to the challenges outlined above. They can be well grounded both theoretically and practically. Broadly conceived, they represent a valuable and potentially transformative field contributing to the education of professionals, with the capacity to enact more valuable forms of online learning environments.
THEORETICAL UNDERPINNINGS IN TEACHING AND LEARNING Nature of Knowledge Whether articulated or not, all teaching reflects some particular theory of the nature of knowledge in a specific field, and how students may learn and use that knowledge. Bates and Poole (2003,
4
p.27) note that the predominant epistemologies in higher education today are objectivism and constructivism. Objectivists believe there exists a set of objective facts that have been discovered over the years, and that the truth and meaning of these facts “exists outside the human mind”. This claim has led to the predominant transmission approach in higher education, wherein the process of effectively transmitting knowledge becomes the central goal of teaching. On the other hand, constructivists argue that knowledge is socially constructed by individual learners as they experience the world. There is no objective truth to be discovered, only conventions, which themselves have been constructed and agreed upon by people over time. Jonassen, Peck and Wilson (1999, p.3) contend, “individuals make sense of their world by constructing their own representations or models of their experiences”. Therefore, there are multiple perspectives about phenomena in the world. These authors argue that “knowledge is embedded in activity” and “anchored in the context in which the activity takes place” (p.3). They also emphasise the importance of meaning making in the knowledge-building process and suggest that meaning making comes about when there is “a dissonance between what is known and what is observed in the world” (p.5). Vygotsky (1978) argued that learning is, first and foremost, a social collaborative activity, and that is where meaning is built. With respect to this, Jonassen, Peck and Wilson (1999) note that contrary to opinion, not all knowledge constructed by individuals is valid. It has to be viable, that is, make sense in terms of the evidence, community standards, and mores. In describing the nature of academic learning, Laurillard (2003) argues that university teaching is more than imparting decontextualised or abstract knowledge, and even more than creating opportunities for situated cognition, whereby students learn as they engage in activities that occur in natural environments. For Laurillard, academic learning “represents a second-order experience of
E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments
the world”. It is “known through exposition, argument, interpretation” and “through reflection on experience” (p.21), the type of goal-based, mediated experience provided through e-simulations. It includes the learning of precepts or general rules, as well as the learning of percepts developed as a consequence of perception. Therefore, “teaching is essentially a rhetorical activity” that seeks “to persuade students to change the way they experience the world through an understanding of the insights of others” (p.23). She believes students need to learn the agreed conventions in a discipline through a process of mediation.
The Acquisition of Knowledge The question of how students learn has long been of interest to academics. Ramsden (2003) points out that approaches to learning vary from one person to another so there is no one right way to affect learning. Yet, in examining the essential differences between school learning and university learning, Laurillard (2003) suggests while course descriptions are content driven, and while academic teachers are purportedly more interested in the way students handle knowledge than in the acquisition of knowledge, lectures, textbooks and other “linear” methods are still prevalent in academic settings. This doesn’t take into account the nature of knowledge or the variety of ways in which students learn. From the constructivist perspective, Jonassen, Peck, and Wilson (1999), discussed five interdependent attributes they believe are necessary for meaningful learning. For them, learning must be: •
•
Active. Learners “interact with their environment, manipulate objects in that environment”, observe the effects of their interventions, and construct their own interpretations of what has occurred (p.8). Constructive. “Learners must reflect on their activities and observations to learn the lessons that their activity has to teach”
•
•
•
(p.9). The relationship between the active and constructive attributes is “symbiotic”, for they each rely on the other to bring about meaning. Intentional. Students “think and learn more when they are fulfilling an intention”. Having goals and articulating those intentions “are essential for meaningful learning” (p.9). Authentic. Learning must reflect the complexity of the real world. The meaning of particular ideas depends on the contexts in which they occur, so to simplify and remove knowledge from its authentic context is to distort meaning. Cooperative. Humans live and work in knowledge-building communities where problems are solved and tasks are completed through collaboration and conversation. This process involves social negotiation to reach common understandings and attain goals, and learners come to appreciate multiple viewpoints and multiple ways of solving problems.
Biggs (2003), Garrison and Anderson (2003), and Laurillard (2003) all describe surface-level and deep-level approaches to processing and understanding new knowledge, These were first identified by Marton and Saljo (1976). A surface approach (in the case of reading a text) refers to skimming the surface of the text and remembering a series of “disjointed facts” rather than truly understanding the point being made. Laurillard (2003) refers to this as an “atomistic” approach that distorts the original structure, and therefore distorts meaning. It arises when low-level cognitive activities are used and the learner just wants to complete the task as quickly as possible. Deep learning involves an understanding of the bigger picture by going below the surface of the text and making sense of (constructing the meaning from) what the author is saying. Laurillard (2003) sees this as a “holistic” approach that preserves the
5
E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments
original structure and meaning. Biggs (2003, p.12) notes these terms “describe ways of learning”, not “characteristics of students”. He suggests the goal of university teaching is to use activities and assessment approaches that encourage deep learning. Biggs (2003) concerns himself with the way students learn, and promotes the premise that it’s what the student does that matters. This is based on Marton’s (1981) notion of “phenomenography”, which contends it is the student perspective that determines what is learned, not the teacher’s intentions. Therefore, Biggs (2003, p.12) suggests, “teaching is a matter of changing the learner’s perspective, the way the learner sees the world”. Laurillard (2003, p.70) explains its empirical base is derived “from discovery rather than hypothesis testing”, so it is the nature of the action between learner and subject matter that is of interest, rather than what the teacher does to the learner. From the ontological standpoint, Biggs (2003) considers phenomenography to be consistent with, (though not the same as), a constructivist view of learning. This has led Biggs (2003) to argue that the most appropriate way of helping students construct learning is by “aligning teaching”. He refers to this as “constructive alignment”, whereby all the components in the learning environment are closely aligned. Apart from learners and teachers, these include: • • • • •
The curriculum we teach. The methods we use to teach. The assessment procedures and the methods for reporting results. The climate we create in our interactions with students. The institutional climate, the rules and procedures we have to follow (p.26).
Biggs (2003) says the notion of constructive alignment brings together a constructivist view of learning, and an “aligned design for teaching” (p.27). This means students do the work, while the teacher “acts as broker between the student
6
and a learning environment that supports learning activities” (p.27). In considering how students learn, Laurillard (2003) acknowledges “it is not easy to penetrate the private world of someone coming to an understanding of an idea” (p.41). She discussed “mathemagenic” activities, defined as “activities that give birth to learning” (p.41). These include: apprehending the “structure of discourse” to discern the coherent meaning; interpreting the “forms of representation” of the discourse; acting on and manipulating “descriptions of the world” to give rise to further descriptions; using both intrinsic and extrinsic feedback to adjust actions and descriptions; and reflecting on the cycle that relates feedback to the purpose of the discourse (pp.60-61). Reflection on action is an important element for deep learning. These ideas are consistent with constructivism and underpin the theoretical frameworks and design approaches used in e-simulations and games. There are clear congruencies between the attributes discussed by Jonassen, Peck and Wilson (1999), Bigg’s (2003) constructive alignment, the notions of student-centred mathemagenic activities, and approaches that encourage deep learning. They point to a particular way of conceiving teaching that is most likely to result in desired learning. Focusing on the future of simulations in adult (and by implication professional) education shaped more by constructivism, Magee (2006) critiques the objectivist approach by stating: The knowledge economy that is currently evolving requires an understanding of more than just how to produce information. It also requires workers to comprehend how to filter it, find meaning in it and then finally apply it in an ambiguous and ever-changing environment. One consequence of the more traditional educational approaches has been the neglect of the development of judgment skills, critical thinking skills, and creativity in adult learners. All of these skills will be necessary in order to succeed in the knowledge economy. (p.2)
E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments
E-simulations excel in addressing these skills in ways that often retain key complexities from real life.
Authentic Assessment of Learning In higher education recently, authentic assessment has been discussed in the context of broadening assessment approaches in ways that ensure they are aligned with expected learning outcomes. The emphasis on higher order “workplace competencies” in the training sector also reflects this. As will become evident from the following discussion, technology, and simulations in particular, can provide powerful mechanisms for designing and implementing authentic assessment. Much of the literature on authenticity relates to the nature of particular tasks, whether or not they are used for formal assessment purposes. Consistent with ideas on the nature of authenticity espoused by Herrington, Oliver and Reeves (2003), Gulikers, Bastiaens, and Kirschner (2004, p.69) acknowledge there are differences of opinion about what constitutes authenticity because of varying emphases on task and context as opposed to performance. They distinguish between authentic and performance assessment by arguing “every authentic assessment is performance, but not vice versa” (p.69). They further contend that the degree of fidelity of the task and the conditions under which performance takes place, is greater in authentic assessment than in performance assessment. Therefore, they define authentic assessment as: an assessment requiring students to use the same competencies, or combinations of knowledge, skills, and attitudes that they need to apply in the criterion situation in professional life” (Gulikers et al., 2004, p.69). Khaira and Yambo (2005) concur with this, arguing that authentic tasks should be real-life tasks with multiple solutions for learners. Similarly, Jonassen, Peck and Wilson (1999) say environments should be created that “present learners with problems that are naturally complex and embedded in a real world context” (p.229). The
tasks should also require higher-order thinking. Mueller (2006) suggests the rationale for using authentic assessment usually springs from the idea that graduates should be capable of performing the tasks they encounter after they graduate, therefore their assessment should replicate real world challenges. Clearly, authentic assessment has to do with students demonstrating they know a body of knowledge, have developed a set of skills, can apply them in a ‘real-life’ situation, and can solve real-life problems. Role-playing e-simulations are an obvious method for inviting learners to demonstrate their level of mastery of integrated knowledge and skills through authentic assessment requiring performance.
DEFINING E-SIMULATIONS What is a Simulation? Simulations have become commonly used tools in contemporary society, e.g. in studying natural phenomena, physical processes, in engineering design, or in media production, to name just a few. Many are now computer-based and networked to take advantage of the sophisticated tools available in online environments (Klein & Herskovitcz, 2005). In higher education, e-simulations are increasingly being used for teaching and learning purposes. As Aldrich (2003, p. 8) points out, in fields such as medicine, nursing, pilot, or military training, simulation use is critical for practising skills before being required to do the real thing. The simulations by their very nature are complex and people from different professions and technology backgrounds define them quite differently. The general Wikipedia definition is: “Simulation is the imitation of some real thing, state of affairs, or process. The act of simulating something generally entails representing certain key characteristics or behaviours of a selected physical or abstract system”. In more simple terms, Prensky (2004, p. 1) suggests “simulation
7
E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments
is, by definition, pretending. All simulations are tools that give you ersatz (as opposed to real) experience”. Aldrich (2004, p.52) says simulations “model reality”, and more specifically, “they can rigorously but selectively represent objects or situations” as well as “user interactions”. Prensky (2004, p.2) stressed, “The one universal truth about any simulation is that at its centre lies a model”, and they are often, though not always, computation models. Feinstein and Parks (2002) note simulations duplicate the characteristics of “a real business or management system through an iconic or symbolic model”, and “can be further defined by describing its underlying model as a discrete event, a continuous event, or a combined event” (p.397). Aldrich (2009, p.52) further refined his descriptions of the concept, structure, and function of simulations, saying they not only “capture and model some part of reality and the role of someone in it”, but the elements in simulations “describe what actions are available, how the actions influence relevant systems, (and) how those systems produce feedback and results”. Further, he proposes four major “knowledge constructs” that he calls simulation “sweet spots” emerging from experiencing simulations: situational awareness, dead reckoning, understanding of actions and awareness of patterns. Some aspects of what is at work in simulations appear to be well understood. These definitions suggest the key characteristics of a simulation are that it is based on a model, it represents some aspect of reality without itself being real, and it involves inputs, manipulations, and resultant outputs depending on its purpose. Notwithstanding these commonalities, Jones (1998, p.1) contends “definitions restricted to systems, rules, imitations, payoffs, and representations are inappropriate and inadequate in the field of interactive events…because they ignore human behaviour” and “fail to distinguish between the real and the fake”. For him, the main criterion for defining a simulation is “human behaviour—what actually happens’ (p.1). To support his argument,
8
he claims that, for example, no definition of a game includes a duty to win, and yet, without that element he suggests it is not a game. He argues further, “if everyone in an event referred to it as a game, but behaved as if it were a simulation, then it would be a simulation, not a game” (p.4). Brozik and Zapalska (2002) tend to use the terms “simulation” and “games” interchangeably. They believe the combination of “simulation to represent elements of reality and gaming to stimulate interaction” can bring about “powerful learning constructs” (p.7) and provide a strong rationale and purpose for using simulations in education. As far as educational simulations are concerned, there is an added dimension. Aldrich (2004b) argues a simulation should only be regarded as educational when it has specific learning elements in it that expose the learner to essential concepts relating to the environment being simulated. Similarly, Hertel and Millis (2002) note educational simulations usually “place students in true-to-life roles”, but in line with Aldrich, they also acknowledged that while the “simulated activities are ‘real world’, modifications occur for learning purposes” (p.16). Importantly, educational simulations are generally goal-based scenarios (Schank, 1997) and help learners to focus on particular elements in systems or situations that occur in the real environments they model. Aldrich (2004a) identified six criteria that are critical in educational simulations. Three describe content elements, “linear, systems, and cyclical”, and three describe delivery elements, “simulation, game, and pedagogy” (p.1). In elaborating on these elements, Aldrich (2004a) suggested linear content involves sequencing, or step-by-step procedures; systems content includes “the components of the system and how those components impact each other” (p. 1); and cyclical content relates to “activities that can be infinitely combined to create an outcome” (p. 2). In respect to delivery, he believes simulation elements “enable discovery, experimentation, concrete examples, practice, and active construction” of the three content elements
E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments
(p.6). Game elements can “increase the enjoyment” of, and engagement with, the experience, which means learners give more of their time and attention, resulting in increased learning. On the other hand, too many game elements “distracts from, or waters down, the learning” (p.7). Pedagogical elements help to focus students’ attention on how to be productive, though too many of those elements can leave learners feeling as though they are using an instruction manual or “mindlessly following directions” (p.8). Aldrich (2004a) claims it is only through attending to all six elements that we obtain results that actually change people. In further describing the nature of simulations, Prensky (2004, p.9) identified the connections between the model and the users as being the “inputs”, information incorporated into the model, and the “outputs” or feedback from the model. Both inputs and outputs of simulations vary “along a continuum from abstraction to realism”, although he suggests educational simulations are more likely to have realistic outputs presented in “life-like conditions” (p.9). In relation to this, he raises the issue of fidelity, which is important in simulations for learning in the professions. Fidelity pertains not only to inputs and outputs but also to the simulation model. Stoffregen, Bardy, Smart, and Pagulayan (2003) say the essence of simulation fidelity has to do with whether adaptive behaviours can be executed or not, and if so, on the basis of what information. In considering the concept of presence in simulations, Stoffregen et al. (2003) distinguish between realism and reality by equating the “perception of realism with perceptions of the simulation, and perceptions of reality with perception of that which is simulated” (p.121). The critical question posed by Prensky (2004, p.9) is: “How close to life does the simulation have to be to do its job?” He suggested the higher the fidelity, the higher the cost of producing the simulation, so the degree of fidelity required for success should correlate closely with its purpose. In learning or training for the professions, he suggests fidelity
requirements “are more complicated and varied” (p.10), therefore low fidelity simulation should be used “for learning concepts”, and “higher fidelity simulation for learning about things” (p.10). Aldrich (2004b, p.102) contends simulations will become increasingly realistic but “will never perfectly replicate reality”. Indeed, he believes the environments provided by simulations may be better for learning than real-life situations because they can remove distractions and focus attention on essential concepts associated with the teaching and learning goals. Due to the complexity of simulations, Aldrich (2004b, p.14) suggested the only way to understand them is “to become familiar with today’s computer games because they introduce many of the structures, standards and techniques built into simulations today”.
What is an E-Simulation? Our focus is on e-simulations used for education in the professions and enacted in blended learning designs; that is, digital simulations integrated with various other media on digital networks and in the physical environment. Students can experience e-simulations via a web browser for use in any location, including by individuals studying at a distance and by groups of students studying together on-campus. In many cases, the students are invited to adopt a character role in a scenario that has been designed with specific educational goals and detailed objectives in mind to support the unit of study as a whole. In broad terms, these e-simulations tend to be: • • • • •
Single-person (student); Role-based (participant immersion); Goal-based scenarios, used in Blended learning designs, that are Assessment driven.
While advocating the use of learning designs that carefully integrate digital simulations as a form of e-learning in blended learning environments,
9
E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments
one should not underestimate the role of the Web platform as a “network”. Mobilising the power of networks (physical and digital), will see the emergence of new networked e-simulations that “time-shift” and “place-shift” in conjunction with peers and other communities aspiring to develop new skills in professional practice. E-simulations are not a singular and static concept. Design-based research struggles (as other research approaches do) to investigate and explain the emerging expressions of e-simulations.
•
•
Purposes of Digital Simulations Klabbers (2003; 2009) distinguished between two closely connected design levels: design-inthe-large (DIL) and design-in-the-small (DIS). Approaches to these and linkages between the two make any such design effort a “science of design” in Klabbers’ view. DIL refers to the design of “courses of action aimed at changing existing systems into preferred ones” while DIS is design of an artifact—a simulation for example. It is argued that educational and training systems need to be innovative, yet relevant and responsive to the changing needs of students, staff, and professional bodies. Such systems need further development, as a DIL challenge, and, with this goal in mind, e-simulations represent at least one constructive response, with each such e-simulation representing a DIS addressing the following needs. •
10
Need for work-related events in a range of professions: e.g., by providing digitally simulated experiential learning activities. Professional education and provision of internships that place students in real work environments have often been problematic due mainly to logistics of placement, availability of appropriate businesses or practices, the demands it places on busy professionals, and variability in the quality of the experience provided for students.
•
•
Need for authentic, engaging learning experiences that motivate students: e.g., create an enhanced method for moving students to action in completing written tasks requiring high-level cognitive processing of complex, integrated, professional problems. Such challenges will inevitably require students to draw on multiple information sources in a scenario that requires professional judgement. Need for flexibility for equity groups: e.g., equity of experience for off-campus and remote students with activities that they otherwise would not have, and equity of access for people with disabilities. Need for contemporary, valid, workrelated assessment practices: e.g., students have expressed the need for assessment that is relevant to the work they will be required to perform in their chosen profession. Need to link students with the professions and industry in ways that are not place specific (or parochial): e.g., internships may have required students to be physically present in a workplace. While e-simulations do not take the place of realtime work placements, they can augment such experiences by providing opportunities for familiarisation and practice before confronting the risks in real workplaces.
SITUATING E-SIMULATIONS IN E-LEARNING AND BLENDED LEARNING Distance education has a long history of rationally selecting and integrating elements of analogue media and, over time, integrating such elements with emerging digital media and, more recently, a growing number of networked or e-learning technologies. Frameworks for making media choices have been researched and reported by distance education theorists and scholars (see
E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments
Bates, 2005; Laurillard, 2003), with a trailing history of attention to “media classification and selection” models and algorithms stretching back to the 1950’s in the literature of “instructional systems design” and “educational technology”. Concurrently, the best classroom-based educators have long used a variety of approaches and techniques to stimulate student learning, incorporating a variety of media to achieve their purposes. One could ask the question posed by Jay Cross in the Foreword to Bonk and Graham’s (2006) “Handbook of Blended Learning”, about why the need for treatment of blended learning, when he could not envisage a situation where unblended learning would ever occur (xvii). So why would any educator ever not blend? Blended is a transitory term. In time it will join programmed instruction and transactional analysis in the dustbin of has-beens. In the meantime, blended is a stepping-stone on the way to the future. It reminds us to look at learning challenges from any directions. It makes computer-only training look ridiculous. It drives us to pick the right tools to get the job done (Jay Cross in Bonk & Graham, 2006, p. xxiii).
The Meaning of Blended Learning As mentioned earlier, for the purposes of simplicity and clarity, we have adopted the definition of blended learning enunciated by Graham (2006). Blended learning systems combine face-to-face instruction with computer-mediated instruction. The working definition...reflects the idea that BL is the combination of instruction from two historically separate models of teaching and learning: traditional face-to-face learning systems and distributed learning systems. It also emphasises the central role of computer-based technologies in blended learning. (p.5)
We broadly agree with Graham’s (2006, pp.810) list of purported benefits of blended learning encompassing the improvement of pedagogy, increased access and flexibility, and increased cost-effectiveness, while Garrison and Vaughan (2008, p.4) observe, “The need to provide more engaged learning experiences is at the core of the interest in blended learning”. Garrison and Vaughan (2008, pp.4-5) further argue that “the time has come to reject the dualistic thinking that seems to demand choosing between conventional face-to-face and online learning, a dualism that is no longer tenable, theoretically or practically”. Indeed, communication and knowledge media already permeate contemporary, physical learning environments. New forms of engagement are required. In relation to Graham’s (2006, p.13) three general categories of blends—enabling, enhancing and transforming—we see e-simulations serving purposes in all three, yet with the potential to create transforming potential by “for example, a change from a model where learners are just receivers of information to a model where learners actively construct knowledge through dynamic interactions. These types of blends enable intellectual activity that was not practically possible without the technology” (p.13). The relationships between face-to-face and elearning modes are a pivotal area of investigation, and one where blended learning design solutions will be highly contextualised. The goal is to adopt “a new educational paradigm that integrates the strengths of face-to-face and online learning. Blended learning—a design approach whereby both face-to-face and online learning are made better by the presence of the other—offers the possibility of recapturing the traditional values of higher education, while meeting the demands and needs of the twenty-first century” (Garrison & Vaughan, 2008, p.5). In presenting a Student Survey Questionnaire (See chapter 11, Appendix A) for blended learning, Garrison and Vaughan (2008, p.193) illuminate how student perceptions
11
E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments
of the strength and value of relationships between classroom and online learning can be conceived and evaluated in four significant degrees from more to less positive where: • • • •
Online and in-class work enhanced each other; Online and in-class work were relevant to each other; The connection between the two was not always clear; and There was little or no connection between the two.
These degrees of integration and value are given more precise formulation in the “blended learning design alignment” template introduced below for use with e-simulations. It provides equal emphasis on activities occurring within the simulation and those occurring outside, with congruency required between the two domains of activity.
proaches provide instructors with many affordances and opportunities for creating engaging and supportive settings. …It is the capability of blended learning to draw the maximum benefit from the technology affordances while retaining the best features of face-to-face teaching that make it ideal for supporting authentic activities within larger learning designs. (p.505) An important stance taken in the conceptualisation, design, and use of e-simulations relates to how they are situated in blended learning. For e-simulations, this means the simulation has been created for use in a teaching and learning context involving a range of other critical activities in the wider learning environment. For example: •
• •
The Meaning of E-Simulations in Blended Learning
•
In relation to the explosion in e-learning developments and possibilities globally, “more educators and trainers need to understand what they can accomplish in these environments. They are seeking guidance, stories, and examples of what works or might work” (Bonk, 2009, p.112). This observation has particular significance in examining the e-simulations in blended learning settings. As e-simulation emerges strongly, it deserves greater prominence in research and practice. This book provides frameworks and cases documenting claims about what works in e-learning and blended learning settings. Oliver, Herrington and Reeves (2006) note:
•
Blended learning appears to offer strong supports for instructors looking to create learning settings based on authentic tasks. Blended learning ap-
12
•
•
Classroom introduction to the simulation involving orientation to the task (especially if it involves assessment). Practice on the task in a group. Rationale for the challenges in the simulation. Explanations of independent/individual learning applications such as for preparation for internships or exams. Debriefings and feedback about the roles and tasks undertaken by the student in the simulation. Collaborative work and discussions between students who have used the simulation. Individual feedback on any assessable component in the simulation.
The variety of teachers’ educational intentions in using simulations is evident, for example, in the timing of their use during the teaching period. This reflects the “embedded” and “contextual” nature of usage in the curriculum and assessment of units. Further indications of ways to respond to the contextual demands of using e-simulations in educational institutions are as follows:
E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments
•
•
•
•
•
Via a combination of delivery and support platforms: Stand-alone using CD only; combination of CD and a simulation website; combination of CD, simulation website and learning management system (LMS); combination of CD, simulation website and social software environment. (Each depends on student access to broadband Internet.) For different student groups: Pre-service undergraduate students; internship preparation by students; in-service and preservice postgraduate students; mid-career employees; workplace trainees. In different physical locations: At home; at work; in student residences; in student computer labs on-campus. In different human relationships: Alone unsupervised by teachers; with fellow students unsupervised by teachers; with fellow students in tutorials/computer-laboratories supervised by teachers; with work colleagues in the workplace. In relation to actual workplace learning: In preparation for workplace learning; as a partial substitute for workplace learning; as a full substitute for workplace learning; as a form of reinforcement after workplace learning.
These provide a snapshot of conservative settings and needs to which e-simulations respond.
A TYPOLOGY FOR DESIGNING E-SIMULATIONS Our attempt to classify e-simulations for educating the professions is strongly guided by the following observation of Jones (1998), a creator and researcher of simulations and games for more than thirty years:
My concern about categories is not about semantics. It is not about words as such, it is about behavior. In interactive events, behavior should determine the category. If everyone in an event referred to it as a game but behaved as if it were a simulation, then it would be a simulation, not a game. The actions, skills, motives, thoughts, and emotions are what matter in determining categories of human behavior. It is important, particularly for professionals, to describe clearly and/or define carefully what they are trying to communicate. In any field involving behavior, descriptions and examples are safer than definitions. Clear categories are important. (pp.316-317) With this in mind, we propose a “typology” of e-simulations determined by design variables that exert an impact on learner experience and behaviour inside and outside the e-simulation; that is, the teacher/designer’s intentions for using the e-simulation in a blended learning environment. The e-simulation types vary in their individual experience design including the students’ experience more broadly of a congruent blend in a unit of study, where e-learning is expressed in a blended learning design. The range of e-simulations reported in this book varies in ways associated with the fidelity of the screen representations and modes of interactivity simulating human interaction. These and other design elements determine the “representational validity” (Feinstein & Cannon, 2002) of the e-simulation. Representational Validity is evident when the simulation of a chosen phenomenon in professional practice is seen as a valid representation of the phenomenon for the defined educational purposes; valid in its concepts and constructs rather than being a high fidelity replica of reality. This contrasts with the validity of the e-simulation’s learning design, or “educational validity” when considered in the context of the overall educational goals, objectives, and strategies used in a unit of study. Educational validity is evident when the students’ experience of learning and
13
E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments
assessment inside and outside the e-simulation is seen to be in valid alignment; that is, supporting the defined educational purposes (Feinstein & Cannon, 2002, pp.432-434). This involves attending to the constructive alignments in the blended learning design for the unit as a whole. For the e-simulation to achieve satisfactory educational validity (Feinstein & Cannon, 2002), it must contribute to the constructive alignments. The constructive alignment of design elements, both inside and outside an e-simulation is a core feature of the type of e-simulation designed for blended learning (See Table 3).
Figure 1. Closed cycle of alignments
Constructive Alignment of Design Elements for E-Simulations In considering the constructive alignment of design elements for e-simulations, we draw on the aforementioned work of Biggs (2003) relating to acquisition of knowledge. His work suggests e-simulations ought to represent a commitment to constructive alignment of key elements in an educational design. Table 1 demonstrates the key design alignments we propose, while Figure 1 shows five resulting segments as a closed cycle of alignments. Segment (v) in the closed cycle represents the domain containing both assessment and evaluation. It aims to provide evidence of the extent to which the e-simulation delivers on its promise to develop in the learner expected forms of integrated professional capability (outcomes evaluations). Assessment (A) of this form of student
learning reflects a stage on the road to integrated expertise in professional practice that the profession and employers need (N): graduate attributes. To achieve this, e-simulations should have both representational and educational validity. These are two key goals when completing an effective e-simulation “learning design” that properly integrates an e-simulation into the intended design of broader learning environments and learning experiences. The alignment of representational and educational validities ensures congruency of the academic goals with the professional capability of the employee. Representational Validity is present when the chosen real-world phenomenon, as simulated, is seen as a valid representation (of concepts and constructs) for the defined educational purposes (see Figure 2). This means the e-simulation facili-
Table 1. Alignment of elements in an educational design i
Profession/discipline Needs with the Curriculum goals;
N&C
ii
The Curriculum with “kinds” of Learning (categories of learned capabilities);
C&L
iii
Kinds of Learning withTeaching strategies (kinds of teaching);
L&T
iv
Teaching strategies (and all of the above) with the Assessment strategies (methods of measuring the learning for which evidence is provided);
T&A
v
Assessment (evidence of learning) with the identified Needs of the profession/discipline.
A&N
14
E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments
tates the “transfer” of professional experience in the real world, to the student learning experiences in a university setting, (i.e., transfer from the profession to the: Curriculum, Teaching, Learning and Assessment in the unit as shown in segments i-iv in Figure 1). To achieve the desired level of representational validity of the professional practice, four clusters of complexity in the practice need to be addressed. They are central to the design of a simulated professional experience with representational validity and are detailed in Table 3. Educational Validity is present when students’ learning experiences via e-simulation in the educational setting encourage the appropriate ‘transfer’ of learned professional experience and capabilities to the real world (see Figure 3). This is to ensure that graduates’ achievements transfer from the university program to the profession/employer as shown in segment v, Figure 1. When designing an e-simulation to achieve the desired level of ‘educational validity’; meeting the requirements for a constructivist, active, participative and socially situated learning environment, the four clusters of engagement shown in Figure 3 need to be addressed. The clusters are valuable points of connection between the student and other learners, their teachers or practitioners. They are essential in any design of a simulated professional experience
with educational validity. These four clusters of “intentional activities” designed by teachers typify the designs of e-simulations. Table 2 provides examples for each cluster. These four clusters of activity typically occur both inside and outside the e-simulation to a large extent. This reflects the manner in which they are embedded in a blended learning design rather than taking an “off-the-shelf” commercial simulation.
Addressing E-Simulations in Blended Learning Environments It is important that the achievement of “blended learning environments” is the result of proactive–reflexive design of teaching by the teacher as “agent for learning”. It is therefore essential that the enacted educational design is learner– centred, that is, the ultimate learner performance in the learning events (both inside and outside the e-simulations) remains the responsibility of the learner. Only the learner can truly choose to engage and participate actively in any learning environment, playing their role, making use of the learning resources and the learning interactions. Only the learner can choose to engage, perform, and achieve the praxis that is possible. So while the teacher is the agent of learning, ultimate power for learning resides with the student. There is concern about potential imbalances in this
Table 2. Examples of “intentional activities” designed by teachers Intentional elements in the design:
Examples:
Participation in learning and practice of situated capabilities
Role-play on interviewing skills inside and outside the e-simulation.
Teacher guidance and feedback
Light interventions by the teacher during the role experience, in order to guide and provide evaluative feedback inside and outside the e-simulation.
Connections with significant others in “blended learning” contexts
Embedding the individual role experience from the e-simulation into the social contexts of the unit (course), such as online discussion spaces provided in a Learning Management System or social software.
Formative and summative assessment
Using the e-simulation for formative practice and assessment with a small weighting for the final grade in the unit (course).
15
E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments
Figure 2. Elements of “representational validity” designed by the teacher for students to experience as valid phenomena selected from the professional workplace
relationship, particularly in light of heightened emphasis on individual learner experiences in the educational environment. The teacher as broker, orchestrator, and agent is critical for the success of e-simulations in a blended learning environment. Therefore, when considering the total learning design of any e-simulation, attention should be given to the design of relevant experiences outside as well as inside the e-simulation. Quality blended learning designs rate highly in regard to “conceptual validity” and “construct validity”, being educationally mature designs to achieve the intended learning outcomes. The previous clusters in representational validity and educational validity converge in the conceptualisation in Figure 4
of what constitutes the students’ blended learning experiences inside and outside the e-simulation. Achieving quality, blended learning using esimulations occurs by aligning the representational and educational validity clusters of design elements that reflect the teacher’s educational intentions. The roles of students and teachers, as they actively engage with each other, and the resources and tasks in stories and scenarios, comprise the blended learning environment of a contemporary e-simulation. The quality of this experience of relationships seriously influences the quality of the learning.
Figure 3. Elements of “educational validity” designed by the teacher for students to experience as valid experiences aligned to support the defined educational purposes.
16
E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments
Table 3. Alignment of design elements when designing for the student experience in a blended learning environment Designing for the Student Experience in a Blended Learning Environment Title of the e-simulation: Name of the teacher/designers: Elements
Description / Example
Learner profile
Key characteristics and attributes of learners that impact on the design of the e-simulation in the blended learning approach. E.g. maturity, experience, course level, study mode, cohort size.
Teacher’s main aim
This is a ‘high level’ statement of the teacher’s intentions or purposes in creating the esimulation as a treatment for educating in specific areas of a specific profession (teacher’s perspective).
Teaching goals and strategy
This is a “second order” statement of the teacher’s intentions. It points to the expectations the teacher has for the student’s final learning outcome and indicates the key strategy/method for reaching it.
Blended Learning architecture(Preordinate design structure)
This is a “high level” description of the main elements in the designed (pre-planned) methods for achieving the blended learning. This includes elements in the digital e-simulation that link with other virtual/online elements as much as with those in the physical classroom, home, or workplace environments.
Teaching strategies for using the esimulation in the curriculum
The ultimate “performance” of teaching as a reflexive, interactive process may be promoted in the pre-planned design and use of the e-simulation. For example, are there unresolved professional issues and practices that the e-simulation raises for varied treatments when teaching?
Role(s) assumed by students
This may be more than first expected. Consider the student’s roles both inside and outside the e-simulation. Some e-simulations allow students to play different roles.
Key objectives for the learners
Highlight the most important learned capabilities in the profession that students learn from the e-simulation, either alone or in conjunction with other elements of the blended design.
Challenge / Difficulty
Highlight the selected elements from the real world that are being set as a “challenge” in the simulation. The type of challenge/difficulty portrays how well the e-simulation meets the demands that occur at the intersection of representational validity and educational validity of the e-simulation.
Methods and Sequences
INSIDE the e-simulation
OUTSIDE the e-simulation
Invitationto engage
In what way, in the e-simulation, do users receive a motivational welcome and invitation to engage in the experiences offered?
Through what other means do students receive an invitation and rationale for participating in the approaches and activities both in the e-simulation and what surrounds it?
Briefing(on roles and purposes)
State where and how this occurs in the sequence of e-simulation screens.
State if and how this occurs before the esimulation via other means online or in class.
Supportfrom teacher (assistance, guidance and feedback)
List key screens or interaction events that support the student learning in the e-simulation. It may be important for these to be absent on occasions. Note the approach/timing.
State if this occurs before/during/after the esimulation via other means online or in class. Only mention the key strategy for supporting students individually and/or as a group.
Resources/tools(for taking action simulated, virtual and real)
Identify the means by which students do the productive work; the active, participative “learning” work for which the e-simulation provides the experiential framework.
Identify any other means online or in class, by which students receive the resources/tool for enacting the role in a productive manner for practice/assessment.
Tasks(work actively completed by students)
State task(s) completed in the e-simulation, whether assessed or not. Include key elements of a task that might occur during the esimulation, with other elements done before, during, or after the e-simulation using another method outside the e-simulation. Emphasise tasks completed, not activities that support the scenario experience.
A major task in a unit that is connected with the work completed in the e-simulation. It is often formally assessed and results in a mark that contributes to an overall grade for the unit. Describe any tasks outside the esimulation that represent a “blended approach to the assessment”.
continued on following page
17
E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments
Table 3. Continued Designing for the Student Experience in a Blended Learning Environment Time(structure and pressure)
Indicate key methods for creating structured/ pressured time on e-simulation users. Is time clocked and reported to the user? Do users control e-simulation time structure and pace?
Name relevant elements or tools in the broader e-learning environment or the physical environment that may determine the timing of exposure to all or parts of the e-simulation.
Reflection(individual/group)
Indicate opportunities for students to reflect on the meaning of the experience and their performance, prompted or otherwise.
Indicate planned opportunities for reflecting and discussing progress with learning.
Debriefing
When/how do students receive feedback on the meaning of the e-simulation experience and their performance?
When/how do students receive analytical and explanatory feedback individually and as a class/group as needed?
Results(Formative/ summative assessment by the teacher/assessor)
Does the e-simulation facilitate assessable work generated by the student? Does it involve minor formative results or a major learning result to be assessed?
Does the e-simulation contribute to a more substantial piece of assessable work external to the e-simulation?
Unit Outcomes(measured by the teacher/evaluator)
What evidence would you seek outside the e-simulation and perhaps outside the unit, that professional performances learned using the e-simulation contribute to graduate attributes transferable to (or transferred to) actual professional practice, therefore addressing needs of the profession?
Figure 4. Five spheres that affect the learning relationships both inside and outside the e-simulation
18
E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments
Figure 5. Example of students’ experiences inside the e-simulation
Student Experience Inside the E-Simulation Several factors play key roles in the successful performance of any educational e-simulation. Some examples of these are shown in Figure 5. Each element represented in Figure 5 is present in the structure and functions of an educational e-simulation. Indeed, most play key roles in a wide range of educational designs. They are detailed in the Design Table (see Table 3). When conceptualising the meaning and use of an esimulation for education in the professions, the significance of blended learning means every student (regardless of their location) will have specific learning needs associated with the embedding of the e-simulation as a congruent part of the outside learning environment. The Design Table (see Table 3) details elements integral to the learner experience both inside and outside the e-simulation. They include “engagement” methods and sequences such as the • • • •
Invitation to engage; Briefing (on roles and purposes); Support from teacher (assistance, guidance and feedback); Resources/tools (for taking action simulated, virtual and real);
• • • • •
Tasks (work actively completed by students); Time (structure and pressure); Reflection (individual/group); Debriefing; and Results (Formative/ summative assessment by the teacher/assessor).
Profiles of e-simulations developed by teacherdesigners using the Design Table (See Table 3) assist in creating a congruent, blended learning environment incorporating the e-simulation. The goal is to address the needs of students and the professions in developing the capabilities inherent in complex professional expertise. (See Figure 1, The N-C-L-T-A Cycle.) To achieve congruent, integrated learning designs using e-simulations of the kind advocated in this typology and prompted by Table 3, other design expertise is necessary such as scenario design, interface design, interaction design and experience design. Approaches to each of these design imperatives determine simulation characteristics, such as fidelity and the various domains of validity (e.g., face validity, content validity, construct validity, and educational validity). Considerable expertise infuses digital e-simulations and this is extended when learning design necessarily includes their use in blended learning environments.
19
E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments
FUTURE OF E-SIMULATIONS In recent years, authentic learning, participatory learning, experiential learning, and immersive learning have been keywords in contemporary educational practice. Media artifacts described as simulations and games are being re-examined for their potential for mainstream education and training as a result of the massive convergence of media, and information and communication technologies to the digital platform. Furthermore, digital simulations and games are being used in conjunction with networked computer devices and central databases in order to create educational artifacts and integrated teaching and learning environments that: •
•
•
Customise learning experiences: adaptations allowing teachers to meet broadly anticipated curriculum, teaching and learning needs and purposes; Personalise learning experiences: adaptations to meet certain personal preferences when interacting with an educational artifact or environment; the manner in which a learning resource/environment presents itself and addresses the learner; and Individualise learning experiences: adaptations to the behaviour and content of a learning resource/environment based on students taking greater control to meet their own learning needs.
Beyond what are narrowly understood to be “simulations”, Bonk (2009, p.8) identifies “Alternative Reality Learning” as one of the 10 major technological trends which is opening the world to a revolution in education. Commenting on the benefits of this technological trend, Bonk (2009) observes: It seems that everyone wants a dose of reality these days. We all crave to experience or do the real thing rather than listen to someone tell us about
20
the supposed real thing. Most people realize that they perform best when learning by doping in the real world. Whenever possible and available, they want to do it now – not some time much later. And, of course, it must be fun. What’s more, millions of people are willing to take on a different persona, sometimes multiple ones, in order to experience alternative versions of reality that are different from what they tend to experience each day. (p.27) New digital tools and approaches such as “augmented reality” and “trans-media” narratives, are challenging our concepts of blending in alternative reality experiences. Designs that blend for teaching and learning for the professions will increasingly use powerful virtual reality via e-simulations, because they support active experiences for deep learning. The emerging designs and benefits of e-simulations in the service of teaching and learning, clearly build upon a long history of simulations and games, yet Bonk (2009) adds a note of caution: The degree of authenticity and believability keeps growing in online scenarios, simulations and virtual worlds. We are entering a time that continues to push the envelope of what is possible. But these same envelopes have been pushed before. Will this lead to higher levels of expertise in shorter bursts? Will simulations or alternative worlds created in one culture be readily transferred to another? How authentic must a virtual world be for educational payoff of some kind? And just who will determine the payoff? (p.290) For education in the professions to benefit from rapidly changing technology developments, significant, new organisational and staff capacitybuilding initiatives are required nationally and internationally. Future potential will only be realised through proactive leadership in the strategic and operational spheres of organisations in the education sector. Simulation technologies will continue to advance, with richer and smarter im-
E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments
mersive experiences provided for learners through synthetic characters and environments. Currently, educational institutions, for example, lag well behind breaking technology developments in the commercial world, and arguably, well behind contemporary game theories in the service of learning. Moreover, with the extended opportunities provided by networked simulations, educational institutions will be challenged to examine their development and use on mobile devices. Various capacities will be required within, and possibly shared between, institutions to deliver fully on e-simulations’ potentials. Institutions’ resources are limited and there are many competing claims on budgets for various sorts of teaching and learning developments in general, and educational technology systems and applications in particular. E-simulations will need to compete for institutional attention and prove they can be delivered cost-effectively and make a real difference to the quality of the student learning experience. We believe this can occur.
CONCLUSION In this chapter we have identified the central concerns of e-simulations for the education of students in professional and vocational fields. Various aspects of e-simulations, as valued and high potential educational technologies, have been canvassed, including what they are, what they can do, and how they can be integrated effectively into blended learning environments. We emphasise that pure educational value may not be enough to enable the uptake of this type of technology unless supported by appropriate organisational capacities and effective strategic and operational leadership. Quality educational technology must be matched by quality institutional leadership. This is the case for all novel and emerging educational technologies which hold promise for contemporary educational systems.
REFERENCES Aldrich, C. (2003). A field guide to educational simulations. American Society for Training and Development (ASTD). Retrieved from http:// www.simulearn.net/pdf/astd.pdf ] Aldrich, C. (2004a). Six criteria of an educational simulation. Learning circuits, 2003. Retrieved from http://www.learningcircuits.org/NR/rdonlyres/F2ED000A-7A59-4108-A6CB-1BE4F4CC1CA5/4719/clark_e2.pdf Aldrich, C. (2004b). Simulations and the future of e-learning: An innovative (and perhaps revolutionary) approach to e-learning. San Francisco, CA: Pfeiffer, (an imprint of Wiley). Aldrich, C. (2009). The complete guide to simulations and serious games: How the most valuable content will be created in the age beyond Gutenberg to Google. San Francisco, CA: Pfeiffer (an imprint of Wiley). Bates, A. W. (2005). Technology, e-learning, and distance education. New York, NY: Routledge Falmer. Bates, A. W., & Poole, G. (2003). Effective teaching with technology in higher education: Foundations for success. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. Biggs, J. (2003). Teaching for quality learning at university: What the student does (2nd ed.). Berkshire, UK: Society for Research into Higher Education: Open University Press. Biggs, J. B. (1987). Student approaches to learning and studying. Hawthorn, Victoria: Australian Council for Educational Research. Bonk, C. J. (2009). The world is open: How Web technology is revolutionizing education. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. Bonk, C. J., & Graham, C. R. (Eds.). (2006). The handbook of blended learning: Global perspectives, local designs. San Francisco, CA: Pfeiffer.
21
E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments
Brozik, D., & Zapalska, A. (2005). Developing simulations and games: Serious play. In S. Narasimhan & R. Teach (Eds.), Paper presented at the 36th Annual Conference of the International Simulation and Gaming Association (ISAGA), Atlanta, GA, USA. Feinstein,A. H., & Cannon, H. M. (2002). Constructs of simulation evaluation. Simulation & Gaming, 33(4), 425–440. doi:10.1177/1046878102238606 Feinstein, A. H., & Parks, S. J. (2002). The use of simulation in hospitality as an analytic tool and instructional system: A review of the literature. Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research (Washington, D.C.), 26(4), 396–421. doi:10.1177/109634802237486 Garrison, D. R., & Anderson, T. (2003). [st century: A framework for research and practice. London, UK: RoutledgeFalmer.]. E-learning, 21. Garrison, D. R., & Vaughan, N. D. (2008). Blended learning in higher education: Framework, principles, and guidelines. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. Graham, C. R. (2006). Blended learning systems: Definition, current trends, and future directions. In Bonk, C. J., & Graham, C. R. (Eds.), The handbook of blended learning: Global perspectives, local designs (pp. 3–21). San Francisco, CA: Pfeiffer. Gulikers, J., Bastiaens, T., & Kirschner, P. (2004). A five-dimensional framework for authentic assessment. Educational Technology Research and Development, 52(3), 67–85. doi:10.1007/ BF02504676 Herrington, J., Oliver, R., & Reeves, T. C. (2003). Patterns of engagement in authentic online learning environments. Australian Journal of Educational Technology, 19(1), 59–71. Hertel, J. P., & Millis, B. J. (2002). Why simulations further educational goals. Using simulations to promote learning in higher education: An introduction. Stylus Publishing.
22
Jonassen, D. H., Peck, K. L., & Wilson, B. G. (1999). Learning with technology: A constructivist perspective. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey: Prentice Hall. Jones, K. (1998). What are we talking about? Simulation & Gaming, 29(3), 314–317. doi:10.1177/1046878198293006 Kidd, T. T. (Ed.). (2010). Online education and adult learning: New frontiers for teaching practices. Hershey, PA: IGI Global. Kidd, T. T., & Keengwe, J. (Eds.). (2010). Adult learning in the digital age: Perspectives on online technologies and outcomes. Hershey, PA: IGI Global. Klabbers, J. H. G. (2003). Simulation and gaming: Introduction to the art and science of design. [Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.]. Simulation & Gaming, 34(4), 448–494. doi:10.1177/1046878103258195 Klabbers, J. H. G. (2009). The magic circle: Principles of gaming & simulation (3rd and revised ed.). Rotterdam, The Netherlands: Sense Publishers. Klein, E. E., & Herskovitz, P. J. (2005). Philosophical foundations of computer simulation validation. [Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.]. Simulation & Gaming, 36(3), 303–329. doi:10.1177/1046878104273437 Laurillard, D. (2003). Rethinking university teaching: A conversational framework for the effective use of learning technologies (2nd ed.). London, UK: RoutledgeFalmer. Magee, M. (2006). State of the field review: Simulation in education (final report). Retrieved from http://www.ccl-cca.ca/NR/rdonlyres/C8CB4C08F7D3-4915–BDAA-C41250A43516/0/SFRSimulationinEducationJul06REV.pdf] Marton, F. (1981). Phenomenography: Describing conceptions of the world around us. Instructional Science, 10, 177–200. doi:10.1007/BF00132516
E-Simulations for Educating the Professions in Blended Learning Environments
Marton, F., & Saljo, R. (1976). On qualitative differences in learning, 1: Outcome and process. The British Journal of Educational Psychology, 46, 4–11. doi:10.1111/j.2044-8279.1976.tb02980.x Mueller, J. (2006). Authentic assessment toolbox. Retrieved from http://jonathan.mueller.faculty. noctrl.edu/toolbox/whatisit.htm#looklike Oblinger, D., & Oblinger, J. (2005). Is it age or IT: First steps toward understanding the Net Generation. In Educating the Net Generation, EDUCAUSE e-book. Retrieved from http://net. educause.edu/ir/library/pdf/pub7101b.pdf Oliver, R., Herrington, J., & Reeves, T. C. (2006). Creating authentic learning environments through blended learning approaches. In Bonk, C. J., & Graham, C. R. (Eds.), The handbook of blended learning: Global perspectives, local designs (pp. 502–515). San Francisco, CA: Pfeiffer. Prensky, M. (2004). Interactive pretending: An overview of simulation. Retrieved from http:// www.marcprensky.com/writing/Prensky-Interactive_Pretending.pdf
Ramsden, P. (2003). Learning to teach in higher education (2nd ed.). London, UK: RoutledgeFalmer. Spratt, C., & Lajbcygier, P. (Eds.). (2009). ELearning technologies and evidence-based assessment approaches. Hershey, PA: IGI Global. doi:10.4018/978-1-60566-410-1 Stacey, E., & Gerbic, P. (Eds.). (2009). Effective blended learning practices: Evidence-based perspectives in ICT-facilitated education. Hershey, PA: IGI Global. doi:10.4018/978-1-60566-296-1 Stoffregen, T., Bardy, B., Smart, L. J., & Pagulayan, R. (2003). On the nature and evaluation of fidelity in virtual environments. In Hettinger, L. J., & Haas, M. W. (Eds.), Virtual and adaptive environments: Applications, implications, and human performance issues (pp. 111–128). New York, NY: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. doi:10.1201/9781410608888.ch6 Vygotsky, L. (1978). Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes. Boston, MA: Harvard University Press. Wikipedia. (n.d.). Simulation. Retrieved from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ Simulation.
23
Section 1
Theorising the Nature of Design for Authentic Learning and E-Simulations
25
Chapter 2
Reappraising Design Practice Roderick C. Sims University of New England, Australia
ABSTRACT Since the emergence of computer-based applications to support teaching and learning in the early 1970s, the practices of those responsible for the design and development of those applications have received considerable attention. The underpinning tradition for those designers and developers has been the practice of Instructional Design, a series of guiding principles to define and create artefacts and/or strategies to facilitate learning. However, as computer technology has evolved over the past 40 years, the successful application of that technology to education and training has not been consistently achieved. It is therefore timely to revisit and reappraise design practices to assess the alignment of these ‘traditional’ approaches with contemporary technology and pedagogy. This chapter argues that to design and develop learning and teaching environments that support an emergent, learner-centred pedagogy, especially in terms of the role and value of simulations, requires an alternative design mindset. To this end, the chapter elaborates an enhanced version of Proactive Design for Learning (PD4L) and its application to e-simulations as a set of principles that enable technology and pedagogy to align, through the synergy of both the attributes of networked, online technology and contemporary approaches to learning. By applying PD4L in association with an outcomes-based ethos, more effective learning through e-simulations will emerge.
INTRODUCTION Underlying the arguments presented in this chapter is a philosophical perspective that the traditions of Instructional Design, while well-established and researched (Reigeluth & Carr-Chellman, 2009), do not effectively or consistently align with either the expectations of the contemporary learner or the attri-
butes of online teaching and learning environments, such as interaction, collaboration, communication and content creation. Consequently practitioners (designers, developers) require re-conceptualised tools, processes and practices to effectively create the motivating and engaging learning experiences demanded and expected by learners. Rather than taking a ‘rear-view mirror’ approach to inform de
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-61350-189-4.ch002
Copyright © 2012, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Reappraising Design Practice
sign practice, this chapter presents a perspective on the thinking designers, developers, teachers, and learners need to adopt: philosophically, pedagogically, and practically. For the purposes of this discussion and from the human perspective, the term design denotes the analysis, discussion, and effort put into both the conceptualisation and production of educational resources. From the technology perspective, the term e-learning is used to represent the range of options available for implementing computer-based technologies into environments where the focus is on learning through interaction, collaboration, and knowledge construction. And given the focus of this publication, the term blended is used to represent those educational contexts that embrace a combination of delivery and access options. However, blended, in the current environment, is more complex than a case of “face-to-face and online”; rather blended can also refer to a combination of access, resources, and strategies that enable a coherent learning experience from a diverse and distributed student cohort. To provide a context for the arguments presented, the chapter initially reflects on the design traditions that have influenced the field of computers, teaching, and learning. While the term e-learning is currently well established in the educational discourse, its predecessors (computerbased learning, hypermedia, multimedia) and its probable successors remain subject to the work of designers, and the pedagogies that inform and influence their work. Given these traditions, the following section presents a case for what is termed emergent design, a set of inter-related principles that are contextualised within the Proactive Design for Learning (PD4L) model. Using this set of guiding principles, the third section of the chapter explores the value of applying outcomesbased strategies, in combination with PD4L, to maximise the effectiveness of e-simulations. Through a synthesis of these ideas, the chapter presents a framework for successful e-learning and e-simulations within blended teaching and learning environments. 26
DESIGN TRADITIONS In 1976, when I first encountered the possibility of using computers in a teaching and learning context, the relationship was crystal clear. The designer would use fundamental computer programming structures (variables, loops, conditions, indexes, arrays) to create applications that would be accessed by the learner, and which would allow that learner to interact based on the instructions within the program code. The applications which emerged in those early days of our field were pedagogically sound, graphically accurate, and enabled complex interaction between the learner and the subject matter. The design principles supporting the development of these computer-based learning tools were predicated on the fundamental principles of Instructional Design (O’Neil, 1979) and design strategies for specific applications, such as the simulation, were given explicit treatment (e.g. Alessi & Trollip, 1985). In addition, the competencies required to successfully undertake a development project were embedded in a subject-matter expert, an instructional designer, and a programmer. The design, development, and implementation of computer-based resources and environments aimed to enhance and/or facilitate the teaching and learning process were not only the result of pedagogical competencies, but also those associated with software development and the human-computer interface. Over the past 35 years, while there have been many instances of excellent e-learning productions, there has been a trend to leave the creation of e-learning resources and environments to groups who manifest only a subset of these competencies; for example, the independent subject-matter expert or a content specialist supported by an educational developer, but without a background in computer programming and operations. As a result, many resources which have been developed lack the depth and complexity which program code enables. At the same time, especially in today’s higher education institutions, the learning management systems deployed allow participants to access a range of
Reappraising Design Practice
tools, such as threaded discussions, blogs, wikis, chat-rooms, assessments and assignments. In some cases these are supplemented with audio-visual resources such as podcasts and lecture slides. Together these tools allow participants to engage in mediated, asynchronous discussions, synchronous collaborations, self-assessment, and review. However, rarely do these environments evidence the additional computational power available to support participant interactions with content – adapted to the context and situation of individual learners. As a result, current online learning environments have lost, to a large extent, the very affordances that enable them to function comprehensively in a teaching and learning role.
Instructional Design Instructional Design is not a single approach to conceptualising, creating and implementing learning resources, but rather a strategy founded on a range of different theoretical frameworks that allow flexibility and choice for the designer (Reigeluth & Carr-Chelmann, 2009). At the very core of Instructional Design is the ADDIE structure, that the process of designing and developing educational resources which follow an iterative and recursive sequence of Analysis (A), Design (D), Development (D), Implementation (I) and Evaluation (E). But it is not so much the process or sequence that is problematic, but its interpretation and application. Despite a range of models that have attempted to enhance the basic principles or understanding of ADDIE (e.g. R2D2 from Willis, 1995), the outputs from the practice of “instructional design” are often manifested as quality representations of subject matter without the additional alignment to assessment, learning activities, and learning outcomes. Consequently, there is a lack of continuity between what online environments should do and how they are being implemented. The design of e-learning must take into account not only the essential components of instructional design and the associated learning theories, but also the
complexity of attributes and functionality the current technology enables. Rather than the design process being the “problem”, it is more the case that we have forgotten how to effectively enable the interaction, engagement, and motivation that is the foundation of digital learning technology.
Advocating Change Given this background, and argument that alternative models are required for contemporary learning environments, it is important to reflect on the most effective and efficient processes that will enable the implementation of meaningful computer-mediated environments. One of the key areas that I have worked in, and continue to challenge, is the notion of instructional design. The more time I spend in the field, the more I find competing drivers challenging and confronting the traditions. There are well-established instructional design theories and models which assume that without formal design processes in place learning cannot be effective and efficient (for example, Gagne, 1985; Merrill, 1994; Regeluth & Carr-Chellman, 2009). However, the reality for many educators and institutions is that the course designs resulting from such formal processes are content-focused, unfriendly to the learner, and manifest an information transmission approach, where little regard is paid to the appearance or usability of the resources provided to students. For this discussion, the emphasis is on the design of learning environments and artefacts that align with the generation and construction of knowledge rather than its presentation. There are however perspectives other than those embedded in instructional design which present the relationships between knowing, learning and teaching, and the implications for design, quite differently. As an example, Davis, Sumara, and Luce-Kapler (2008, p. 7) contend that “humans are not self-contained, insulated, or isolated beings, but are situated in grander social, cultural, and ecological systems” which 27
Reappraising Design Practice
contrasts the more rigid tenets of Instructional Design which focus on classifying those about to be instructed. Education and training need not be seen as learning environments about certain topics, but “in terms of the individual-and-thecollective and the biological-and-the-cultural” (Davis et al, 2008, p. 13). Concepts such as these not only use a different language to that of the Instructional Design tradition, but also present a far greater inter- and intra-relationship between teacher, learner, and knowledge, which align far more with the affordances (such as interaction, collaboration, and connection) of the online milieu (Siemens, 2004). Working towards the success of e-learning means adopting mind-sets and vocabulary that are consistent with the technology being applied, as more recently highlighted by Webb (2009) who identified components such as scalable metaforums, guild formats, cloud services, and co-agent agency as essential for educational design. The rise of the networked and co-constructed internet has changed the very world in which education and training will take place, and new models are therefore required to enable effective design in these “new worlds”.
Embracing Simulation An alternative can be seen in the re-construction of designer competencies and in the empowerment of the student. The designer’s role can no longer be one of “instructional designer” and all the traditions and processes that entails, but one of enabler, defining spaces in which students and teachers can explore the origins of their field, the currency of their field, and the myriad of futures open to that field. This is the space where emergent design and emergent outcomes become critical. No longer can designers focus on students achieving pre-defined, textbook-based objectives but rather create activities where the available resources are employed for the analysis of the present and the
28
results of that interactional analysis targeted to predict and prepare for the future. In the context of this book, these ideas are closely linked to the importance of simulated environments as that “enabling space”. However these ideas are not without their critics; “who would want their brain surgeon trained by a computer”? Such responses however miss the point, and do not reflect the realities or expectations held within our field. I would never claim that a computer could independently, even with today’s capabilities, teach a surgeon or pilot to perform competently and consistently. However, when used appropriately, and in combination with other educational strategies, computer-based applications should be playing a significant role in these and all other educational endeavours, subject of course to the economic capabilities of the delivery context. Designers need to be open to opportunities which enable learning to emerge from the known. The simulator allows a surgeon, a pilot, or a manager to work through situations of varying complexity and fidelity to achieve competence and experience, and that of course is critical for accreditation of that competence and their ongoing work to heal, to fly, or to supervise. However, a simulator (which is controlled by a set of computer instructions), can also be set up to allow experimentation and testing. What if the surgeon wants to explore a different sequence in the operating procedure based on insights gained over years of real-life experiences? What if the pilot wants to test different ways to resolve an engine failure based on flying experience and intuition? What if the manager has ideas to improve productivity that is not “by the book”? Where are the environments to test these hypotheses, if not the simulator? It is the simulator that can provide that vehicle for exploration and testing. To ‘boldly go to new places’ without risk, but with the potential through communication and collaboration to emerge with new concepts, processes or procedures.
Reappraising Design Practice
Embracing this approach also requires a rethinking of student capabilities. I continually read that students entering university need and want to be just given the facts to complete the assessments. But these are the same students who can vote, drive, drink and travel independently. Why then are they portrayed as being incapable of independent thought? Students have intelligent, active minds that we are engaging with – and a shift is required in what it means to be in a learning institution and what learning actually means. Learning is not necessarily best represented by an examination mark, but rather by curiosity and the pursuit of knowledge. And while the use of games and simulations has been part of the e-learning discourse, the implementation has been varied, despite the growth of complex simulations and gaming community (Webb & Sims, 2006).
A Personal Experience The driver for these ideas came in the early 1990s, when I was asked to develop a computer-based training package on a corporate email system and which resulted in changes to my philosophy towards the design of educational artefacts. The first shift was a realisation that the printed reference materials for the product (available as a manual) bore no relationship to its operation or functionality. For example, to determine how to send an email meant turning to three or four sections of the manual. The second shift was that if I approached the original brief literally, which was to produce an “Introduction to Email” training course, then it would need to reflect the respective chapters of the manual. Curiously little has changed. Recently, when I reviewed the manual for a sophisticated copier/ scanner, the focus was on what the machine did, not how to use it. The initial pages revealed the various displays, but not how to copy a page. And this design is sadly reflected in many of the e-learning applications in place today; they are more about the subject matter (the copier or email system) and
not what the user is meant to do with that subject matter. Such mismatches between content and application may well be the very reason that many students become disengaged with their learning, not because of different learning preferences but because the material lacks meaning and relevance. From that initial experience with the email manual, where the underlying purpose was to encourage employees to use the system, an outcomes-based, functional approach was adopted whereby employees worked through a simulated sequence of activities (receiving mail, replying to mail, sending mail with attachments) under a revised course title “Have You Read Your Mail Today?” This project resulted in the creation of a time-based simulation of working with email, and from this design experience I have since applied an outcomes-based approach to both my writing and practice as a designer, especially in the field of online teaching and learning. Such potential of the simulation for learning has long been recognised in the application of computers to education, especially as an application for e-learning. Alessi and Trollip (1985, p. 161) noted that the “simulation is a powerful technique that teaches about some aspect of the world by imitating or replicating it. Students are not only motivated by simulations but also learn by interacting with them”. More recently, Allen (2007, p. xii) proclaimed that “simulations, gaming, and scenario-based e-learning courses are the most powerful learning experiences... designing this level of e-learning solutions requires a combination of well-educated and experienced e-learning designers”. However, there are less enthusiastic responses to the use of simulations, such as Clark and Mayer (2007) who articulate a different set of principles for simulation design and implementation from those proposed by Alessi and Trollip (1985) some 20 years earlier. According to Alessi and Trollip (1985, 2001) simulations can be either about something (physical or iterative simulations) or how to do something (procedural or situational simulations). This compares to Clark and Mayer’s
29
Reappraising Design Practice
(2007, p. 350) determination that simulations are either operational (teaching procedural skills) or conceptual (“learning domain-specific strategic knowledge and skills”). However, what seems more important is the actual perspective of the designer, given the current complexity of both social and educational communications. Underpinning the frameworks posed by Clark and Mayer (2007) is a perspective that the simulation will be undertaken and then an assessment provided to confirm learning; however, as will be argued later in the chapter, the simulation itself can also act as the assessment, with completion of the simulated activities or processes being a demonstration of learning. Rather than it being a simulation to teach, it becomes a simulation to enable learning. While beyond the scope of this chapter, these latter comments reinforce the importance of the philosophical and epistemological views of the designer; in brief, the arguments proposed in this chapter align with rationalism (the mind activity constructs knowledge) and interpretivism (reality is assumed to be constructed by the knower) and the accompanying socio-constructivist learning theories (Driscoll, 2005, p. 12).
Emergent Design For those involved in the design and development of online resources and environments for teaching and learning, an extensive variety of models and processes have been proposed, and guide those efforts, ranging from the conservative (Merrill, 1994) to the practical (Alessi & Trollip, 1985; 2001; Jonassen, 1988) to the pragmatic (Clark & Mayer, 2008; Rothwell & Kazanas, 2008) to the contentious (Allen, 2007). Allen’s (2007) admonition (and the subtitle of his text) is to “forget what you know about instructional design and do something different”, and his background is similar to my own, both having early experience with the PLATO computer-based training system. It is from these original foundations and ongoing interactions as a developer,
30
teacher, and writer that the concept of Proactive Design for Learning (PD4L) emerged, integrating earlier work in the evaluation of online learning environments (Proactive Evaluation, Sims, Dobbs, & Hand, 2002), as well as strategies to effectively align online development with the iterative and continual improvement process associated with practice in higher education (Three Phase Design, Sims & Jones, 2003). An initial version of Proactive Design for Learning was presented by Sims (2009) and the enhancements elaborated in this chapter not only reflect revisions to better position the model within the contemporary educational climate but also provides an important design ethos for the focus of this text, e-simulations within blended learning environments. The purpose of PD4L is to provide the designer with an integrated framework of guidelines and principles that go beyond the prescriptive traditions of instructional design while enabling quality of engagement, effectiveness of learning and efficiencies in development. The overall Proactive Design for Learning model (PD4L) is represented in Figure 1, where the central three-phased development paradigm is supported by six essential factors that contribute to the creation of online learning events. To provide a context for PD4L, a hypothetical simulation will be discussed such that the enhancements to the original model can be elaborated through their specific relationship to the creation of e-simulations.
A SIMULATION SCENARIO The preceding discussion has suggested that the simulation is a key model for enhancing learning and that the traditional instructional design methods may not align with the potential of esimulations, where collaboration and interaction between participants in a simulation becomes a significant design variable. For example, and based on encounters I have experienced with teachers, if we were to take the recent global financial
Reappraising Design Practice
Figure 1. The enhanced Proactive Design for Learning (PD4L) model
emergent outcomes. The example also enables the essential elements of a blended environment to be utilised – virtual communications and presence, computer-based tools, real-time data access such as RSS feeds as well as the opportunity for participants to meet face-to-face. In the following elaboration of the PD4L components, their relationship to the design and development of this second emergent simulation is provided, referred to as the GFC Simulation.
A Context for the PD4L Components
crisis, a teacher may determine that students should understand (learn?) that Model X is the preferred approach to maintaining future global financial security and consequently implements a simulation that is predicated on presentation of existing facts, choices that are predetermined, and prescriptive of a desired outcome (Model X), and which is based on external, historical (text-book) knowledge. An alternative approach, and one which aligns with the PD4L strategy, is where a teacher presents students with a set of known variables, factors, and tools and then creates an environment where those tools/variables/factors can be explored and tested in such a way that students propose one or more models that would maintain future global financial security. While the outcome in both cases is a model, in this second option the outcome is emergent, generational, and dependent on the interactions between and knowledge of the individual participants. Such an environment is then more than simulating certain economic conditions to test outcomes; rather the environment embraces and integrates simulation with interaction to allow
With any educational resource, it is essential to focus on initially building a functional rather than an elaborate product; the former is more likely to result in learning, the latter in short-term impressions. In developing the Three-Phase Design process (represented in Figure 2), Sims and Jones (2003) argued that function is more important than form, especially in the early stages of development, and that a resource which works educationally can be implemented functionally. For example, a black and white line drawing might effectively represent a landscape just as well as an illustrious oil painting. As course participants (designers, teachers, learners) work through a resource (such as a simulation or game), observations of their interactions coupled with evaluative feedback can be used to enhance the original functional structure. This approach is consistent with the observations of both Koehler and Mishra (2004) and Mishra, Koehler and Kereluik (2009) who advocate “teacher-as-designer” frameworks. In terms of the GFC Simulation, the initial structure might limit the number of variables and tools and focus on collaborative interactions to enable emergent outcomes, and then use observations of those interactions to identify appropriate enhancements, such as economic modelling tools. Over the longer term, major enhancements become less significant and the simulation enters a maintenance phase, although open to integrating
31
Reappraising Design Practice
Figure 2. Three-Phase Design, the core of PD4L
new paradigms of learning. The maintain process continues until the resource either becomes redundant; for example, in this case financial conditions might change so radically that any emergent model ceases to have relevance to the real world. Aligned with the three-phase process are a set of theoretical positions which are represented through the primary outcomes that reflect the application of interconnecting learning theories (as represented in Figure 3). The first outcome is connection, not only in terms of the connectivist approach to learning (Siemens, 2004) and the importance of learning through social interaction (Vygotsky, 1978), but also in terms of learning being meaningful (Ausubel, 1968), and connections being made both internally with a course of study and to the broader, external environment. Utilising these theoretical foundations, in conjunction with a contextual or situated cognition perspective (Clancey, 1997), and more recent interpretations such as authentic learning (Herrington, Reeves, & Oliver, 2007), provides the foundation for establishing teaching and learning environments where relevant, meaningful knowl-
32
edge is constructed by the participants and which can then be internalised by individual learners. In the case of the GFC Simulation, each of the theoretical constructs represented in Figure 3 become integral to the creation of the space into which the participants interact. Through interacting within that space through available information, experimentation, and communica-
Figure 3. Learning theories informing PD4L
Reappraising Design Practice
tions, learners will (ideally) construct knowledge, understanding, and subsequent skills and abilities. A strong theoretical foundation, in conjunction with explicit design strategies, ensures the integrity of the online teaching and learning environment. Underpinning this theoretical element are the proactive approaches initially proposed by Sims et al. (2002) and which aim to capture the essential features of e-simulation environments, such as the networking and cloud elements proposed by Webb (2009). Identifying factors such as the strategic intent of the unit—the need, the participants, the outcomes—will enable the creation of optimal teaching strategies, associated learning activities (including assessment) and the context in which those activities will take place to ensure the outcomes are met (as discussed later in this chapter). Through this approach, participants take responsibility for accessing and identifying relevant content, and teachers provide the strategies and/or resources by which learners will make sense of that content. Because the underpinning technology is computer-based, a third element the designer must address is the interface; today’s learning management systems have clear but relatively inflexible interfaces, and therefore designs have to be created which give participants an impression they are “part of an overarching narrative where each task they complete is related to working through that narrative sequence” (Sims, 2009, p. 388). Understanding the informing learning theories and accepted principles of design for computerbased environments provides the framework for applying the other components of PD4L to the design of e-learning resources. Proactive Design for Learning (PD4L) is predicated on a team-based approach, focusing on the importance of a collaborative ethos between the key stakeholders and the way that their interactions can establish and maintain a shared vision and understanding of the overall design process and outcome (as represented in Figure 4). Thus there is a blurring between the design of an educational resource, its delivery and its subsequent enhancement.
By focusing on the roles of those who will participate in the process, and in recognition of Laurel (1993) who elaborated on the concept of computers as theatre, the model sees the collaboration and vision being enabled and maintained by writers, builders, actors, and viewers. The writers (educational developers, instructional designers) need input from the actors (teachers, learners) who will provide insights as to key subject-matter, learning outcomes, and learner expectations. Once a script (specification) has been created, it is then up to the builders (graphic designers, web-developers, programmers, network specialists) who will create the vision for the viewers (the administrators, community, and government, as well as the actors, writers and builders) to evaluate how that vision was achieved. Through a combination of three-phased driven development initiatives, a strong theoretical framework, and collaboration focusing on continuous improvement, the emergence of a community of practice (Wenger, 1998) would establish an environment where all stakeholders actively contribute and participate. This opens up the potential for simulations to embrace virtual worlds Figure 4. Players in the design performance
33
Reappraising Design Practice
such as Second Life where interaction between participants is as much part of the simulated experiences as the resources within those virtual worlds. Applying these concepts to the GFC Simulation means that the simulation is under constant scrutiny. The initial design aimed to allow participants to collaborate and interact in such a way that models that might ensure financial security would emerge. With any educational resource, it is only through evaluation of that resource in operation that its functionality can be determined, and this component of PD4L emphasises the importance of a continuous interplay between design and delivery. Throughout this chapter, and the PD4L model itself, is a plea for designers to embrace the enabling factors of e-learning and e-simulation (interactions, collaboration, connection, networking), and to ensure those factors are not lost through application of traditional design models, which have traditions in teaching and learning that pre-date digital technology. The importance of innovation is therefore critical, in that it can result in new concepts and paradigms for the way education is designed, developed, and accessed. For example, a common tradition in the distance education institution is the preparation of extensive printed books of readings and unit guides through which the individual learner works, and responds by submitting assessments and undertaking examinations. These learners often study independently, only meeting other students if there is a residential, intensive set of activities, and workshops. Modifying this delivery model to reduce (physically and visually) the content and rather privilege learning activities over content, will provide an environment where students can experience deeper and more contextual learning interactions. By reflecting on the three factors of innovation identified in Figure 5, news ways of thinking can be established. The first of these factors, research, refers to the crucial step of knowing what other
34
research is reporting – and the conflicts and debates resulting from those findings. The second is challenge, which encourages designers to examine structural and operational parameters within the institution to assess ways in which they may be enhancing or inhibiting innovation. The third factor involves hypothesising, testing, and assessing the value and potential usability of different options. Being open to change, and willing to test ideas and explore new avenues of experiencing the teaching-learning dynamic creates an ethos of research and exploration and, potentially, excitement at discovering new or different means to achieve learning outcomes. An approach to enabling outcomes, even unpredictable outcomes, is through emergence, a concept that Johnson (2001) suggests is what happens when the whole is smarter than the sum of its parts, and occurs from the bottom-up of an environment without any explicit control (see Figure 6 for a representation of the key components of this concept). Applied to the GFC Simulation, emergence is based on a strategy that the very interactions between participants will result in the generation or emergence of knowledge, in this Figure 5. PD4L as an enabler of new ideas
Reappraising Design Practice
case models to ensure financial stability. Rather than assume that existing models are correct, the process of interaction and connection may generate alternative models or confirm existing models. However, the overall process and design strategies are quite different from those that look to ‘teach the model’. If this simulation were extrapolated to a virtual world, the subject-matter would then become part of that world, while encounters between learners and the resultant interactions within that world enable the potential emergence of new understandings about that world. No longer is the teacher or the textbook the knowledge source, but rather that source is the world (virtual and physical) in which we live. In the e-learning environment where collaboration and communities of practice are considered desirable because of the social learning outcomes, emergence has particular relevance because it allows the designer to focus on the participants being able to take advantage of the dynamic nature of the environment through contributing content and knowledge based on prior-experience, rather than relying on teacher-prescribed materials (Irlbeck et al, 2006).
Sims (2009) indicated that empowering students to challenge and question existing theories and principles was an essential component of PD4L and so it remains, with designers who may have aligned with a traditional approach needing to focus more on designing for others to use. The e-learning milieu is complex, flexible, organic, and dynamic; designing and creating contexts from which different perspectives on the subject matter can emerge provides a more engaging experience for learners, especially if they have the opportunity to encounter informal participants in the formal delivery of a unit of study. The discussion of the preceding PD4L components has emphasised the importance of the interaction among participants, as well as with other content resources, and is important to warrant a specific discussion. The reason for this is that it is crucial to discuss, “what makes a learning experience interactive?” The designer has a responsibility to show what learning activities and teaching strategies are active at any point in a course, with each purposeful and directed towards completion of the overall learning outcomes. To create content-based applications means creating interactions where the learner must apply their
Figure 6. Components of an emergent design
35
Reappraising Design Practice
knowledge to progress (Allen, 2007; Clark & Mayer, 2008). However, I have tested a number of self-paced courses where a learner could gain “mastery” by closing their eyes and pressing the Enter key repeatedly. As illustrated in Figure 7, to be relevant an interaction must provide each participant with a context and a domain of knowledge in which to engage in some cognitive activity, such as adjusting variables (experimenting), testing assumptions (hypothesising), introducing content (modifying), constructing solutions (manipulating), or situating the learning within their own experience and environment (contextualising). Interaction is about doing, being actively engaged with either unit participants or unit content, not just on occasion but throughout the whole educational experience. A mantra used to reinforce the importance of interaction is “learners as producers, not consumers; learners as creators, not watchers”. Thus with the GFC Simulation, participants would be producing and creating models, testing those models using economic modelling tools and collaborating with peers on the outcomes of that modelling. Making education relevant for the individual learner has been a quest for computer-based applications, through strategies such as individualisation (addressing the learner by name) or adaptation (changing material based on individual performance). In light of this, the initial PD4L model identified personalisation as a key component; that is, ensuring factors of relevance to the individual learner (such as culture, context, or learning preferences) are catered for in the design process. However, on reflection, it is more appropriate to examine this in terms of contextual factors, through adopting a problembased foundation to the learning environment, as represented in Figure 8. Through this strategy, and especially with respect to the creation of simulations, the focus is on the learners being able to process and interpret the course content (subject matter) within their own personal context; their culture, their
36
Figure 7. Interaction, the key to success
global needs, their situation, the need for authenticity, the ability to experience, and through that the achievement of personal outcomes. Thus the role of the designer shifts from assessing the characteristics of the learner (such as through the traditional target audience analysis) to focusing on creating an environment where the learner is
Figure 8. Making learning relevant
Reappraising Design Practice
able to apply individual traits such as their prior knowledge, specific context and situation, preferred learning style, cultural framework, and media preferences. So it is not a case of “how do I design for a learner with characteristic X?” but rather “how do I design an environment such that learners with any characteristic can make the encounters contextual and meaningful”? When considered in terms of the GFC Simulation, the design would assume that models may emerge that had relevance in different financial environments. For example, many institutions cater for diverse student cohorts from many parts of the world; rather than requiring each of those students to study just one model, the designer is obliged (based on this analysis) to allow and encourage the focus (modelling financial market security) to be applied both globally and locally. Will a model that appears successful in China be applicable in India and Australia?
PD4L FOR DESIGN PRACTICE As has been discussed, Proactive Design for Learning (PD4L) is an integrated set of concepts and ideas, built on a specific three-phased design approach, that identifies the key factors which should be considered by designers of e-learning applications. In the following section, the implementation of a proactive design approach is discussed in terms of the importance of addressing outcomes as the driver of learning design, especially in the area of simulation. Ultimately for the designer the question becomes “so what do I do when asked to design a unit of study”? Based on the premises of PD4L, for a unit that requires both formative and summative assessment and examination, the process represented in Figure 9 has proved successful. The first step in the process is to establish the desired learning outcomes for the unit, which can be expressed as statements of what the student will be able to do/apply on completion of the unit
Figure 9. An outcomes-based design process
and within their own context and perspective. Often outcomes are expressed as very specific learning objectives, such as “Given two sides of a triangle, calculate the length of the third side”, or much broader achievements such as “Understanding of the Australian Constitution”. An outcomes-based design approach places the focus on a student’s ability (for example) to explain, debate, or apply the key subject-related principles within a specific context. In the case of the GFC Simulation, the participating students would be expected to have prior knowledge of economic modelling and apply that knowledge to the emergence of new or adapted economic models. The second step places the designer’s attention on assessment, with each outcome then used to determine the nature of the assessment items. For example, given the current situation in Australian politics, an outcome of “Explain the role of the Australian Constitution on the resolution of a hung parliament”, a corresponding assessment might be “Taking on the role of an advocate for change, argue a case for applying specific principles of the Australian Constitution to resolve a hung parliament”.
37
Reappraising Design Practice
Once the assessment items have been derived from the outcomes, the focus shifts to both the teacher and student roles within the unit of study. From the teacher’s perspective, the designer must determine what the teacher will do to introduce and engage students with subject-matter and to align and link each of these strategies to one or more outcomes and associated assessments. For example, a strategy given the above outcome and assessment might be a series of debates between students on constitutional/election issues. From the student’s perspective, the debates (in this case) become the activities in which they participate in order to have sufficient information to complete the assessment, in order to achieve all or part of an outcome. The crux of this design process is that, within a unit of study, every element of the subject matter, every student activity, and every underlying strategy are tied to an outcome/assessment pairing.
A Model for Simulation Design When this design strategy is applied to a simulation environment, there are different dynamics at play which require a change to the components and representation of the O-A-S-A model (Figure 9). With the simulation, the importance of the outcome remains: what should the student be able to do once the simulation task has been completed? However, unlike the previous model where the outcome was directly linked to an assessment, for the simulation, the key is to link the outcome to the strategy or category—physical, procedural, situational or process-driven (Alessi & Trollip, 1985)—such as a problem-solving simulation. Given the strategy, a series of inter-related and decision-based problems might be presented to the student, expressed both practically and contextually. Conceptually, the student will encounter these problems or decisions as they progress through the simulation. As represented in Figure 10, the most important aspect of the simulation is resolution, whether successful or unsuccessful. Unlike the
38
broader outcomes-based model, where assessment was seen as related to, but independent from, the strategy and activity, in this model there is no identifiable assessment. Instead, to be able to solve the problem or choose a decision in itself are manifestations of knowledge application and thus completion or resolution of the simulation is acknowledgement of success, and of learning. In the case of the GFC Simulation, the identification, explanation and justification of a model, created through simulation, would acknowledge the learning that had taken place.
CONCLUSION Theory, context, interaction, innovation, collaboration, and emergence are the major components of the Proactive Design for Learning (PD4L) model elaborated in this chapter. From both an historical and experience-based perspective, it has been argued that the paradigms associated with traditional instructional design practices are inconsistent with the affordances of e-learning, and that new approaches to design, which challenge those traditions, are critical for e-learning Figure 10. The simulation structure
Reappraising Design Practice
success. Employing emergent design practice, through the use of strategies embedded within a Proactive Design for Learning (PD4L) model and employing an outcome-strategy-resolution design framework not only integrate the affordances of e-learning but also maximise the potential for learner engagement and interaction. And it is through the simulation that these elements can best be achieved; environments where the learner is active, experimentation and problem-solving are the drivers, and learning is a manifestation of knowledge application and emergent outcomes.
REFERENCES Alessi, S. M., & Trollip, S. R. (1985). Computerbased instruction: Methods and development. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall. Alessi, S. M., & Trollip, S. R. (2001). Multimedia for learning: Methods and development (3rd ed.). Boston, MA: Allyn and Bacon. Allen, M. (2007). Designing successful e-learning: Forget what you know about instructional design and do something different. San Francisco, CA: Pfeiffer. Ausubel, D. P. (1968). Educational psychology: A cognitive view. New York, NY: Hoilt, Rinehart & Winston. Clancey, W. J. (1997). Situated cognition: On human knowledge and computer representations. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press. Clark, R. M., & Mayer, R. E. (2008). E-learning and the science of instruction: Proven guidelines for consumers and designers of multimedia learning (2nd ed.). San Francisco, CA: Pfeiffer. Davis, B., Sumara, D., & Luce-Kapler, R. (2008). Engaging minds: Changing teaching in complex times (2nd ed.). New York, NY: Routledge.
Driscoll, M. P. (2005). Psychology of learning for instruction (3rd ed.). Boston, MA: Pearson. Gagne, R. M. (1985). The conditions of learning and theory of instruction. New York, NY: Holt, Rinehart & Winston. Herrington, J., Reeves, T. C., & Oliver, R. (2007). Realism and online authentic learning. Journal of Computing in Higher Education, 19(1), 65–84. doi:10.1007/BF03033421 Irlbeck, S., Kays, E., Jones, D., & Sims, R. (2006). The pheonix rising: Emergent models of instructional design. Distance Education, 27(2). doi:10.1080/01587910600789514 Johnson, C. (2001). Emergence: The connected lives of ants, brains, cities, and software. ISBN13: 9780684868752 Jonassen, D. H. (Ed.). (1988). Instructional designs for microcomputer courseware. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum. Koehler, M. J., & Mishra, P. (2004). Learning course design by design. Distance Education Report, 8(18), 8. Laurel, B. (1993). Computers as theatre. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley. Merrill, M. D. (1994). Instruction design theory. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Educational Technology Publications. Mishra, P., Koehler, M. J., & Kereluik, K. (2009). The song remains the same: Looking back to the future of educational technology. TechTrends, 53(5), 48–53. doi:10.1007/s11528-009-0325-3 O’Neil, H. F. (Ed.). (1979). Procedures for instructional systems development. New York, NY: Academic Press. Reigeluth, C. M., & Carr-Chellman, A. A. (Eds.). (2009). Instruction-design theories and models: Building a comon knowledge base (Vol. III). New York, NY: Routledge.
39
Reappraising Design Practice
Rothwell, W. J., & Kazanas, H. C. (2008). Mastering the instructional design process: A systematic approach. San Francisco, CA: Pfeiffer. Siemens, G. (2004). Connectivism: A learning theory for the digital age. Retrieved from http:// www.elearnspace.org/Articles/connectivism.htm. Sims, R. (2009). From three-phase to proactive learning design: Creating effective online teaching and learning environments. In Willis, J. (Ed.), Constructivist Instructional Design (C-ID): Foundations, models, and practical examples (pp. 379–391). Information Age. Sims, R., Dobbs, G., & Hand, T. (2002). Enhancing quality in online learning: Scaffolding design and planning through proactive evaluation. Distance Education, 23(2), 135–148. doi:10.1080/0158791022000009169 Sims, R., & Jones, D. (2003). Where practice informs theory: Reshaping instructional design for academic communities of practice in online teaching and learning. Information Technology. Education et Sociétés, 4(1), 3–20. Vygotsky, L. S. (1978). Mind and society: The development of higher mental processes. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
40
Webb, R., & Sims, R. (2006). Online gaming and online gaming communities: 10 reasons why they matter, In A. Treloar & A. Ellis (Eds.), Making a difference with Web technologies. Proceedings of AusWeb06, the 12th Australian World Wide Web Conference. Noosa Heads, QLD: Southern Cross University. Retrieved from http://ausweb.scu.edu. au/aw06/papers/refereed/webb/index.html Webb, R. L. (2009). The online game modding community: A connectivist instructional design for online learning? PhD Dissertation, Capella Univeristy, Minneapolis, MN. Retrieved from http://proquest.umi.com.library.capella.edu/pqd web?did=1663053261&sid=2&Fmt=2&clientI d=62763&RQT=309&VName=PQD Wenger, E. (1998). Communities of practice: Learning as a social system. Retrieved from http://www.co-i-l.com/coil/knowledge-garden/ cop/lss.shtml Willis, J. (1995). A recursive, reflective instructional design model based on constructivistinterpretist theory. Educational Technology, 35(6), 5–23.
41
Chapter 3
Real Experiences with Virtual Worlds Andrew Cram Macquarie University, Australia John G. Hedberg Macquarie University, Australia
ABSTRACT The virtual world provides a useful experimental space in which learners can experience the design parameters of a real world task. The importance of the simulated space is that it enables the learner to explore their solution to a design task. This chapter explores some educational opportunities offered by virtual world simulations, and presents a conceptual framework to guide their design and implementation. The framework is illustrated by exploring three contrasting simulation examples. In particular, the examples explain how simulations within virtual worlds can be linked to real world performances and provide an efficient way of developing difficult concepts. The examples outline different types of simulations: an exploratory simulation for learning socio-scientific inquiry; a role play simulation involving an ethically toned situation; and a design simulation in which learners test and refine their ideas for subsequent creation using concrete materials.
SIMULATIONS AND VIRTUAL WORLDS The virtual learning is out of this world. It gives you a totally different view of education. (Learner, Student-Constructed Artwork simulation) Virtual worlds offer unique opportunities for educational simulations. As users control an animated character (avatar) within a threedimensional environment, virtual worlds offer
a space in which a range of social phenomena may be simulated within a variety of conceptual contexts. Virtual worlds are essentially places to blend learners’ understandings of the real world with challenging and exploratory simulations. The blend ensures learners can explore concepts and ideas in safe and scaffolded learning contexts that in turn, provide experiences to inform everyday practice.
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-61350-189-4.ch003
Copyright © 2012, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Real Experiences with Virtual Worlds
Simulations have been described as “a simplified and contrived situation that contains enough verisimilitude, or illusion of reality, to induce real world-like responses by those participating in the exercise” (Keys & Wolfe, 1990, p. 308). An important learning goal of virtual world simulations is to provide learners with an experience that can be transferred to activities that occur outside that simulation. Another potential goal is to engage the learner in verisimilar assessment, in which the learner’s responses within the simulation are as close as possible to responses to decisions in everyday contexts. Thus the virtual world enables observation and evaluation of a learner’s response in terms of actions and choices made during the exercise, which otherwise may be difficult to assess. Real-world contexts require flexible, nonlinear narratives with uncertain outcomes. Virtual worlds can require learners to make choices through active decision making, and provide a diverse set of opportunities for engagement, with different parts of the context being simulated. The verisimilitude of the simulation will partly determine how closely the learning experience within the simulation generates a similar experience outside the simulation. Within an educational simulation, verisimilitude facilitates transfer of understandings constructed within the simulation to the achievement of goals and resolution of problems outside the simulation, and impacts both the choice of representation and how learners interact with objects. Several researchers have assisted designers by describing how the affordances of virtual worlds can be used to benefit learners. These include: extended or rich interactions, visualisation and contextualisation, authentic content and culture, identity play, immersion, simulation, community presence, content production (Warburton, 2009) and spatial knowledge representation, experiential learning, engagement, contextual learning, and collaborative learning (Dalgarno & Lee, 2010).
42
In a similar fashion, Bell, Kanar, and Kozlowski (2008, p. 9) describe how certain features (relating to content, immersion, interactivity and communication) of technology-based simulations produce potential learning benefits including the enablement of emotional arousal, knowledge integration, real-time interactions, and use of characters and agents. While these authors have given us a solid basis for the design of simulations that will help mimic real-world learning activities, this chapter seeks to extend understanding of those activities to include not only the features and affordances of the technology but also to suggest strategies that will help learners meaningfully interpret the objects and events in the simulated world. Further we explore some modifications of each element that will modulate and improve learners’ transfer of their experiences into real world contexts (Figure 1). Representational opportunities are enabled by virtual worlds beyond those available within traditional representations such as text, images, and digital movies. These representational opportunities utilise the relatively high degree of representational fidelity offered by virtual worlds, (for a list of the characteristics that determine representational fidelity of virtual worlds, see Dalgarno & Lee, 2010). Schultze, Hiltz, Nardi, Rennecker, and Stucky (2008) argue that the key affordances of virtual worlds relate to presence, placement, perspective, and place. In essence, these describe how learners can experience spatial, cultural, and interpersonal relationships within virtual worlds. Additionally, virtual worlds support changes over time, or temporal relationships. Underlying these is a set of four representation (see Table 1) opportunities that may be utilised by simulation designers. Strategies for meaningful interpretations are ways of structuring activities and choices within the world that enable users to progress through the world and interact with it. The strategies make
Real Experiences with Virtual Worlds
Figure 1. Conceptualising options for a virtual world simulation
use of the representational opportunities listed above, as well as interactional opportunities between the user, the virtual world, and other users. Dalgarno and Lee (2010) have described four characteristics of virtual worlds that afford learner interaction: embodied actions including view control, navigation, and object manipulation; embodied verbal and non-verbal communication; control of environmental attributes and behaviour; and construction of objects and scripting of object behaviours. Learners will actively utilise these characteristics in their engagements with a dynamic virtual world. It is the role of designers to create the learner activities in ways that assist learners to make meaningful interpretations of their experiences and that guide the learners towards the learning outcomes. The narrative strategies in Table 2 may be intertwined to struc-
ture the learning trajectory with one or more present in the same simulation. Supportive modifiers (Table 3) can be applied to combinations of the elements in Table 2 to modulate the learning trajectory of users as they progress through the e-simulation. Varying the modifiers allows educators to provide appropriate guidance and support for individual learners. Learner experience is modulated by the choices made within three areas of design options: representational opportunities, strategies for meaningful interpretations, and supportive modifiers. A successful outcome is achieved when the elements of space, time, place, and user representation are combined with strategies that in effect define the types of possible interactions available to the user.
Table 1. The four representation opportunities that may be utilised by simulation designers Space
Relationships between points and the reasons why they are linked or related. A three dimensional environment may be designed with certain physical relationships between objects and data within that environment.
Time
The space represented within a 3D virtual environment may be transformed over time, to simulate physical relationships in four dimensions. Multiple perspectives of a representation can be obtained through different viewpoints in time and space.
Place
An area in space that has cultural and other meaningful attributes that situate the thinking and action. This may be useful to represent specific cultural and historical aspects, or situate rare or potentially dangerous activities.
Avatars and representations of users
Each user can be represented by an animated character, through which embodied actions such as traversing through space and non-verbal communication may be performed. Having avatars within a place allows the enactment of complex social practices, such as ceremonies and protests, which involve culturally influenced relationships between the position and appearance of objects, the environment and the avatars (Taylor, 2002).
43
Real Experiences with Virtual Worlds
Table 2. Exploratory narratives
Simulated contexts may offer different forms of interactions with different informational content, and these may also vary over time. Learners are generally given tasks that guide their trajectory through the exploratory narrative. Exploratory narratives are to some extent non-linear, in that students have some flexibility to actively select the context and interaction with which they will engage. The Quest Atlantis Taiga Park simulation described in the first case below is an example of an exploratory narrative.
Role play narratives
Users assume roles, take positions and perspectives, and interpret the situations they encounter from a particular point of view. These may be used to provide learners with opportunities to practice skills and to provide experiences that highlight particular aspects of the learning outcomes for later reflection. The Ethical Dilemma simulation described in the second case below is an example of a role play narrative.
Design narratives
Learners use the simulation to design an artefact. Learners are required to make decisions about how to meaningfully engage with, and organise, the representational opportunities offered by the virtual world to achieve their design goals. The Student-Constructed Artworks simulation described in the third case below is an example of a design narrative.
Table 3. Types of goal
Changes to the goal can refocus the range of options to include multiple solutions, one “correct” solution, or a solution dependent on personal values and interests. Other factors also define the forms of assessment used to evaluate learner performance and structure the feedback. Goal variations will have a significant impact on the meanings that the learner draws from their experience. Simulations that guide learners through a single trajectory may be useful for assisting the learners to a specific understanding of a concept or skill (such as microworlds). However, virtual worlds may also support flexible, non-linear and even student-constructed trajectories. These have the potential to assist learners to construct deep, personally meaningful understandings of how the concepts and skills can be used to achieve goals.
Game elements
These build extrinsic motivational goals, by rewarding certain forms of activity to encourage particular learner behaviour. Common game elements include points, awards, and special bonuses. Task- or quest-based approaches provide students with specific sequences of goals, and assign rewards for learners who satisfactorily complete those goals.
Scaffolding
Suggesting processes or specific information provides learners with a conceptual framework that offers a structure for the learners’ understandings and actions. Scaffolding can be embedded within the simulation or delivered by a facilitator through other means. In Quest Atlantis Taiga Park, for example, learners are supported by their classroom teacher as well as scaffolding that is embedded within the simulation (Hickey, Ingram-Goble, & Jameson, 2009).
Collaborative options
Suggest the importance of other users and their skill sets or interests to jointly achieve a goal. Collaboration may occur through the virtual world, be mediated by another communication technology, or be face-to-face.
Expectations of user contribution
In many contexts, users might have extensive control over interactions, construction, and design of the elements that lead to an end goal, in others users are constrained by the simulation designer’s or teacher’s expectations manifest in the interaction options with objects, contexts and other users. The type of rule set used to govern interactions within the simulation has a significant impact on opportunities for user contribution. Algorithmic rule sets constrain users to the activities and interactions that are defined within the algorithm. The consequences of each of the learner’s actions are also pre-determined. In contrast, a choreographic rule set provides a loose structure for the learner’s activity (for example by defining learners’ roles), while providing greater flexibility for each learner to explore their own trajectory through the simulation. A simulation might combine algorithms with choreography to pre-determine some of the situations, interactions, data and roles, while still enabling learners to design and add some or all of these elements. Allowing learners to design elements of the simulation provides further opportunities to form meaningful interpretations compared with simulations that are completely pre-determined, despite being more cognitively demanding.
44
Real Experiences with Virtual Worlds
CASE EXAMPLES The conceptualisation of the virtual world experience and its influence on the real world outcome for each learner is demonstrated in three cases that follow. The range of learner ages within the cases highlight that professional skill development can be applied to school children as well as in higher education and beyond. With appropriate adjustment of the supportive modifiers, the simulation techniques used in the cases would be equally applicable for educating professionals in higher education in a range of disciplines. University educators of trainee school teachers will find particular significance in the first and third cases as demonstrations of how these environments may be implemented by the trainee teachers within their future classrooms. Each example presents an overview of the virtual world simulation, followed by a discussion and analysis of the particular simulation based on the conceptual framework of Figure 1. The discussion includes both a description of the design elements of the simulation, and the transfer of engagement from the virtual world simulations to real world tasks. The contrasting examples demonstrate the
three narrative techniques available for simulation designers using virtual worlds.
Case 1: Quest Atlantis — Taiga Park Environment Quest Atlantis is a collection of educational virtual worlds in which younger learners (9-16 years) explore the worlds and complete quests to assist a fictional race of beings, the Atlantians (Quest Atlantis, 2010). The learners have opportunities to achieve a diverse set of learning outcomes, in domains such as science, literature, environmental studies, and mathematics. Guided by the quests and supported by their classroom teachers, the learners participate in activities within the virtual worlds that provide experience of what it is like to conduct meaningful inquiries in that particular domain, providing a context for the development of vocabulary, skills, and understandings. This case focuses on one virtual world in Quest Atlantis: Taiga Park. The Quest Atlantis Taiga Park environment simulation (Figure 2) involves an exploratory narrative, in which students collect and use information throughout the virtual world to help
Table 4. Learning outcomes
Are dependent on the learners’ ability to meaningfully interpret the experience within the simulation to achieve goals and resolve challenges. Users learn and solve problems by reflecting on their previous embodied experiences, while using the resources that are situated within their current experienced context (Brown, Collins, & Duguid, 1989; Gee, 2003; Lave, 1993). Within the situated learning perspective, users accumulate experiences and come to recognise and understand the value of conceptual and physical tools for the achievement of goals (Barab, Zuiker et al., 2007; Gee, 2003). Learning is not simply about better articulation of concepts and their interrelationships (although it is one possible outcome); it is more about being able to successfully engage in practices in order to achieve meaningful goals (Lave, 1993).
Identity formation
Occurs through the goals formed and choices made by a learner. It relates both to the simulation design as well as the context-of-use (for example, part of a course). Some simulations aim for learners to take on specific identities. For example, in both Quest Atlantis and River City, students are encouraged to take on identities as scientists involved in significant research (Barab, Zuiker et al,, 2007; Dede, Nelson, Ketelhut, Clarke, & Bowman, 2004). To succeed in these virtual worlds, learners need to think and act like scientists – analysing data, forming hypotheses, and conducting experiments.
Motivation and engagement
Influences the extent to which learners focus their efforts towards the intended goals or problems within the simulation. This motivation can be encouraged through extrinsic, game-like rewards. Intrinsic motivation, through meaningful learning experiences, customisable avatars, and opportunities for free play also plays a significant role (Barab, Dodge, Thomas, Jackson, & Tuzun, 2007; Clarke & Dede, 2005). Another important factor is to provide an appropriate level of scaffolding so that learners will see the challenges as difficult but achievable.
45
Real Experiences with Virtual Worlds
compose responses to a series of quests (Hickey, Ingram-Goble, & Jameson, 2009). Over a 15-hour curriculum blended with classroom discussions and activities, learners are required to develop and evaluate hypotheses, consider alternative reasons, make recommendations, and observe consequences. The learning activities, or quests, in Taiga Park form a socio-scientific investigation aiming to
resolve a problem relating to declining fish numbers; the fishing company is threatening to move their operations from the park, in which case the park would lose a vital source of revenue. The Taiga Park simulation involves four quests for learners (Barab, Sadler, Heiselt, Hickey, & Zuiker, 2007; Hickey, Ingram-Goble, & Jameson, 2009). Quest 1 involves learners defining the problem by interviewing characters with different perspec-
Figure 2. Quest Atlantis Taiga Park simulation description
46
Real Experiences with Virtual Worlds
tives on the problem. In Quest 2, learners collect and analyse data to develop a hypothesis, and Quest 3 has learners proposing a resolution that implicates one of the stakeholders. Quest 4 starts by showing learners the consequences of a nonconsensual solution (the closure of the park), then requires learners to propose an alternate solution that considered all stakeholders. At the end of Quest 4, learners are again shown the future so that they can see the more beneficial consequences of the consensual solution.
Learner Experience Many research studies have reported learners’ experiences within Quest Atlantis, and Taiga Park in particular. Several iterations of evaluation and design refinements of Taiga Park have been completed. These modifications lead to significant changes in learner experience, and highlight the options available for educators to modify virtual world simulations. The analysis discussed below focuses on modifying the simulation, rather than the classroom teachers’ practice, to maximise the portability of the simulation for use in other classrooms. Nonetheless, the classroom teachers played an important role in blending students’ learning through the simulation with classroom discussions and activities. One evaluation, reported by Barab and his colleagues (Barab, Zuiker et al., 2007), indicated that the learners tended to overly simplify the situation when initially defining the problem, and many were not successfully enlisting the intended concepts to meaningfully interpret the context. In response to the first issue (a tendency to oversimplify the problem), additional narrative complexity was created, along with scaffolds within the narrative that suggested that multiple stakeholders were contributing to the problem. The second issue identified in the evaluation (insufficient enlistment of the intended concepts to meaningfully interpret the context) led to several refinements to the simulation. The underlying rule
set driving the narrative was modified to require more choices by learners. This created additional points in the narrative at which the learners needed to make intentional decisions in order to progress, guiding the learners towards a meaningful interpretation of the context. Additional game elements were embedded into the simulation, aiming to motivate learners to engage with the context by allowing them to uncover “mystery” files and unlock simulation functionalities which would allow the use of new tools. Finally, new scenarios were added to the simulation, to provide learners with opportunities to generalise and abstract the intended conceptual understandings (for example, an optional activity which posed a challenge for learners that involved a separate context rather than taking place within Taiga Park). It was argued that students engaging with the concepts in other scenarios would more successfully employ the concepts to respond to challenges in Taiga Park context as well as other scenarios. Learners using the refined Taiga Park simulation were indeed able to successfully enlist the intended concepts to make meaningful interpretations, and also to generalise these interpretations to successfully resolve challenges in other contexts. The study reports that on randomly selected standardised test items linked to the intended curriculum learning outcomes, the class’s mean score was significantly better on the post test (Barab, Zuiker et al., 2007). The test items differed in both context and content representation between the scenarios, demonstrating the learners’ ability to transfer their meaningful interpretations from Quest Atlantis to other contexts. In a subsequent evaluation (Hickey, IngramGoble, & Jameson, 2009), efforts were made to improve learners engagement with the formative feedback provided for learners’ submissions to Quest 2 (selected for its crucial role in the learning trajectory). It was noticed that many learners were not making significant improvements to their quest resubmissions. To provide additional scaffolding, a formative feedback proforma was
47
Real Experiences with Virtual Worlds
developed for the class teacher (who marked the Quest submissions) to customise for each learner. Part of this proforma was an instruction for the learner to go and talk to the Lab Technician within the simulation. The rule set for the Lab Technician was expanded, giving learners the option of intentionally accessing additional information that elaborated the formative feedback. The additional formative feedback assisted learners; however the gains were limited because relatively few learners were intentionally accessing all of the additional information available. In response, the design team considered adding game elements to provide extrinsic motivators for learners to engage with the formative feedback. This highlights how the supportive modifiers combine to influence learner
Figure 3. Ethical Dilemma simulation description
48
experiences; in this case, changes are required to both the scaffolding and game elements within the simulation, to motivate learners to engage with the additional supports and improve their learning outcomes.
Case 2: Ethical Dilemma Simulation The Ethical Dilemma simulation (Figure 3) places learners within a situation in which they are required to respond to a problem involving ethical concerns. The learner takes on the role of an Operational Health and Safety (OH&S) manager within a manufacturing company and, as the role-play unfolds, a problem develops as to whether to initiate the temporary closure of the
Real Experiences with Virtual Worlds
plant for a safety audit. This would help improve the safety conditions for the employees, but would also place most employees on half pay for the duration of the safety audit. The objective of this simulation is to conduct verisimilar assessment of each learner’s response to this situation. The simulation has been designed to provide an experience that is as close as possible to a potential real-world ethical dilemma for an OH&S manager. This would allow the learner to discover and reflect on how they would respond in this scenario, as well as present an observable action response for assessment. This simulation differs from Quest Atlantis Taiga Park by having a much more loosely defined rule set (in this case, a choreographed role play script) to define interactional possibilities between the learner and other people in the simulation. In the Ethical Dilemma simulation, learners’ choices may lead to encountering different sets of events and information, while in Quest Atlantis Taiga Park, learners progress through a pre-defined set of events and gain access to similar information. Some aspects of the Ethical Dilemma simulation are intended to be invariant across learners to ensure that each learner is required to consider the implications of a safety audit, however flexibility is also desired so that each learner may interpret and respond to the situation employing their personal ethical values. The Ethical Dilemma simulation involves the learner interacting with two actors, who assume the roles of Operations Manager (Sarah) and one of the Directors (Tim) of the same company. The scenario is designed to be approximately 20 minutes in length. The simulation takes place in a four level office building, surrounded by a landscaped outdoor area. The learner travels through different locations within the building, with each location offering different information and interactional possibilities. Learners may interact with the actors through voice chat, as well as non-verbal communication through relative positioning of the avatar within the office space,
and use of gestures such as waving. Voice chat allows a greater feeling of social presence within the world (Sallnäs, 2002), facilitating a greater degree of natural communication between the learner and the actors.
Learner Experience A research study involving 9 volunteer learners has been conducted on the Ethical Dilemma simulation. The learners were experienced workers, who had varying experience and confidence with virtual worlds and problem solving. Each of the learners went through a one-hour group training session, consisting of three group activities designed to allow the learners to practice the skills that would be required in the scenario. A background information sheet was provided prior to the start of the scenario, to orient the learner with the role and context. A debrief session was conducted with each learner after participation within the simulation. The scenario provided learners with an opportunity to assume the identity of an OH&S manager. After an initial orientation and discussion of the facility’s recent history and the safety initiatives planned for the near future, the learner is informed of an accident that has just occurred and has injured four employees. The news of the accident turns attention to the implications of a safety audit, and specifically, how to inform the Director of the incident. Finally, the learner has a meeting with the Director and either may or may not inform him of the incident. Figure 4 depicts the intended pathways for learners within the simulation. Figure 5 summarises each learners’ trajectory through the Ethical Dilemma simulation, from the scenario orientation to the final meeting with the Director. Each learner had a similar trajectory while progressing through the orientation, discussing the current situation, and during the event of the accident. After this, the learners’ trajectories could be differentiated according to
49
Real Experiences with Virtual Worlds
Figure 4. Intended pathways for the Ethical Dilemma simulation
perceived ethical considerations, decisions, and actions within the final meeting with the Director. When reflecting after the scenario, all learners could perceive ethical issues within their experience, and five of the learners perceived two or more ethical issues. Two of the ethical considerations that were experienced, but were not intended within the scenario design, are the potential implications to the company’s public perception and job retention and the need for transparency with the Director. For the simulation to be considered a success, the learners need to have acted in response to the ethical dilemma, and be able to reflect and share their thoughts and feelings about that experience. By their response, the participants indicate several outcomes: first, the issues within the situation were considered by the participant to be ethically meaningful; second, enacting a response to the ethical dilemma illustrates a specific stance towards those ethical issues, and this stance can inform their self-reflection or assessment. 50
Six of the learners were sensitive to the ethical considerations while participating in the scenario, and used these considerations to guide their response to the situation. These learners were able to reflect on and share how they responded to an ethically toned situation. The other three learners did not enact a response to an ethical dilemma. One was overwhelmed by the amount of information within the simulation, and did not recognise the ethical issues until reflecting after the scenario. Of the remaining two learners, one proceeded to the meeting without making a choice of whether she would inform the Director immediately or not, while the other leaner did not feel any responsibility regarding the safety audit and did not consider the decision meaningful. These learners were able to reflect on the existence of ethical issues within their experience, but had not yet been required to make a decision that indicated a particular stance on the issues. The learners were also able to interpret their experiences in terms of emotions and feeling.
Real Experiences with Virtual Worlds
Figure 5. Actual pathways taken in the Ethical Dilemma simulation
For example, one learner was nervous about the meeting with the Director, as she had decided not to tell him about the incident and was unsure of how the other actor would react. Two other learners felt emotionally blackmailed by one of the actors, and felt resentment towards that actor. These experiences confirm the need for appropriate debriefing at the end of this type of scenario. The simulation provided a situation that facilitated differentiation between learners on the basis of the ethical considerations they perceived within the scenario. For the six learners who perceived and responded to an ethical dilemma within the scenario, the simulation also provided an opportunity to observe how these learners may respond
to a similar ethical dilemma within an everyday situation. When blended with other learning opportunities within a professional learning context, this simulation would provide learners with a comparable experience, in which their individual perceptions and responses could be discussed and contrasted. The simulation also facilitates self, peer, and teacher assessment of the learner’s responses to a situation that is a relatively rare occurrence in everyday activity.
51
Real Experiences with Virtual Worlds
Case 3: StudentConstructed Artworks The Student-Constructed Artworks simulation (Figure 6) provides learners with a supportive environment to develop understandings of spatial awareness, and then model their ideas for a site-specific artwork. The virtual world includes replications of the physical spaces in which the site-specific artworks would be eventually constructed, and thus enables learners to test and refine their ideas in a space that is verisimilar to the physical location. Through this process, the learners experience what it is like to be an artist,
and gain a vocabulary, conceptual understandings, and skills that can assist their artistic efforts. Learners start by completing three developmental activities within the virtual world. Activities 1 and 2 are aimed at orienting learners within the virtual environment while cultivating skills in using the virtual world construction tools. Activity 3 introduces learners to concepts of spatial awareness, encouraging learners to consider how to use different forms to generate relationships between an artwork (positive space) and the surrounding space (negative space). The fourth activity is more blended, with students initially conducting a photographic survey
Figure 6. Student Constructed Artworks simulation description
52
Real Experiences with Virtual Worlds
Figure 7. One student’s sculpture design idea in Activity 2
of the physical design site, developing initial ideas within their Visual Arts Process Diary, testing and refining their ideas within the virtual world simulation space, and finally physically constructing their artworks within the installation site. The final artwork may be constructed in groups of 2-4. In this case, students individually test and refine their ideas within the simulation, then as a group integrate these ideas into the final physical artwork.
Learner Experience
Figure 8. The virtual world space for Activity 3
Figure 9. One student’s design response to Activity 3
An evaluation of the Student-Constructed Artwork simulation has been completed with 15 Year 9 students over 10 weeks. All learners successfully completed the activities, and participated in the construction of a group artwork at a selected site within their school. The simulation both supported the learners’ development of spatial awareness and provided an efficient tool to model design ideas. Although the first two activities were intended as opportunities for students to develop virtual object construction skills, the representation of learners as avatars within the virtual world prompted consideration of the relationship of person and artwork. For example, when designing the sculpture in Activity 2, one student noted that “avatars can fly through” a hole in the middle of the sculpture (Figure 7). In Activity 3, students had an opportunity to focus on the development of their spatial awareness. Each student was given an identical virtual space (Figure 8), which contained relatively basic spatial elements. Figure 9 shows one learner’s design, demonstrating an effective resolution of the design space through use of lines, colours, and repetition. Figure 9 shows one student’s design process in Activity 4 – from initial idea, to virtual model, to physical construction within the actual site within the school. The progression of the idea can be seen through the different design forms. Initially, the idea is represented using a black and white sketch. Even at this early design stage, the
53
Real Experiences with Virtual Worlds
learner is approaching the artwork design as an artist would, considering both the audience and the environment. Audience participation is to be encouraged by allowing viewers to add new pieces of origami to the artwork. The environment is considered by using the coloured paper to contrast with the colour of the tree. Based on the initial design idea, the learner was able to explore different ways that this idea may be executed by modelling the idea within the virtual world. After completing their virtual models, the learners worked in groups of 2-4 to construct the physical site-specific artworks. In the example shown in Figure 10, the physical construction of the artwork is very similar to the virtual model, with some additional elements that were drawn from models of the other learners. Not all learners were able to contribute their virtual model ideas to the final physical artwork. Some of the learners’ virtual models could not be physically constructed, partly because the learners were not aware of which physical materials would be available to construct their models. The virtual world construction tools were particularly suited to allowing learners to efficiently test and refine their artwork ideas. The learners reported that modelling and refining their ideas within the virtual world assisted them to improve their artworks, by identifying the forms, colours and feel of the artwork that would work within that space. Through this process, the learners came to appreciate how to apply spatial awareness to develop site-specific artworks. Students were highly motivated throughout the study. When asked, the students reported the sources of their motivation as learning about artworks and mastering virtual construction skills, avatar customisation, play and exploration of the space and technological capabilities, the opportunity for creativity, and socialisation.
54
Figure 10. One student’s process for artwork design in Activity 4. Clockwise from top left: initial sketch of idea, virtual model of idea, physical artwork at night, physical artwork during the day.
CONCLUSION The design framework and its use in the development of virtual world contexts has shown that it is possible to ensure that simulations in a virtual world can be constructed to generate real world learning outcomes. In comparison to many learning designs, the effective employment of the virtual world can scaffold the skill set of the learners to create differential performance in complex real world scenarios. The cases chosen each contained very open elements that required learners to progress through judgment and intentional choices, thus facilitating higher order learning outcomes. The cases also illustrate that creative outcomes are achievable in scientific problem-solving, the assessment of ethical decision-making actions and in the use of the space to develop not only a creative product but more importantly an understanding of the artistic object and the participant.
Real Experiences with Virtual Worlds
In each example, the links between the virtual experience and the user’s ability to apply the learning outcomes in the real world have shown it is possible to employ the concept of cross functional teams and negotiated tasks within a virtual context that can transfer into a real world scenario. These examples, from both well designed research studies and smaller case studies, all point to valuable outcomes for learning how complex tasks can be undertaken in the real world. This in itself contributes to a literature that is limited at this point. Thus the cases illustrate some of the possible uses of a simulation that is flexible and dynamically responds to the vagaries of real people making choices. The exploratory narrative of Taiga Park provides a simulation of an ecological domain in which real data processing and real scientific understanding are required to find a solution. Learners gain understandings of scientific concepts and their relationships, as well as the process of scientific inquiry. The choice of the Ethical Dilemma case was to illustrate the beginning of possible assessment approaches for the attitudinal objectives often omitted in testing as they are rather poorly tested with traditional paper and pencil. It can provide a context that is closer to the real world and yet still remains very open-ended as the number of different responses and learning trajectories illustrate. The point being made is that in the effort to attain authentic learning environments, the particular strength of virtual worlds is that they can support real-world transfer through the use of verisimilar assessment activities. In particular, they enable less scripted scenarios while generating real emotions about the relationship between the learner and the other people within the situation. The virtual world mediates learner interactions, but there are some limitations on the interactions that are supported. For example, there are limits to social cues, especially physiological cues being noticed by roughly rendered avatars.
The Student Constructed Artworks simulation supports planning in a simulated site that mimics the real world but enables the user to construct and explore a variety of design responses more efficiently than concrete materials would allow. Although the time to learn the tools might take a while, the gains in design refinement, once mastered, still resulted in more exploration than other learners using real world models. The dimensionality and the ability to squeeze through gaps in the sculpture were unexpected gains for the students’ development of spatial awareness. The cases and discussion demonstrate some opportunities to blend virtual worlds with other technologies and face-to-face learning. Explorations of further opportunities for blending are currently underway in several research sites. Overall, the challenge is always the alignment of learning outcomes to activities that can be supported by virtual worlds; secondary challenges include supporting students to master the construction tools in reasonable time, as well as providing sufficient support to allow students to manage the complexity involved in designing and constructing solutions to problems. Most important, ongoing tweaking of the activity structures ensures transfer of skills and knowledge utilised in the virtual world to applications within the “real” world.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT The authors would like to thank the team from the Macquarie ICT Innovations Centre who contributed to the thinking in this chapter, Katy Lumkin, Janette Eade, Roger Buck and Deborah Evans. The assistance and suggestions provided by Dr. Maree Gosper, Dr. Geoff Dick, and the review team were also greatly appreciated.
55
Real Experiences with Virtual Worlds
REFERENCES Barab, S., Dodge, T., Thomas, M., Jackson, C., & Tuzun, H. (2007). Our designs and the social agendas they carry. Journal of the Learning Sciences, 16(2), 263–305. doi:10.1080/10508400701193713 Barab, S., Zuiker, S., Warren, S., Hickey, D., Ingram-Goble, A., Kwon, E.-J., & Herring, S. C. (2007). Situationally embodied curriculum: Relating formalisms and contexts. Science Education, 91(5), 750–782. doi:10.1002/sce.20217 Barab, S. A., Sadler, T. D., Heiselt, C., Hickey, D., & Zuiker, S. (2007). Relating narrative, inquiry, and inscriptions: Supporting consequential play. Journal of Science Education and Technology, 16(1), 59–82. doi:10.1007/s10956-006-9033-3 Bell, B. S., Kanar, A. M., & Kozlowski, S. W. J. (2008). Current issues and future directions in simulation-based training. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University, School of Industrial and Labor Relations, Centre for Advanced Human Resource Studies (CAHRS). Brown, J. S., Collins, A., & Duguid, P. (1989). Situated cognition and the culture of learning. Educational Researcher, 18(1), 32–42. Clarke, J., & Dede, C. (2005). Making learning meaningful: An exploratory study of using MultiUser Virtual Environments (MUVEs) in middle school science. Paper presented at the American Educational Research Association, Montreal, Canada. Dalgarno, B., & Lee, M. J. W. (2010). What are the learning affordances of 3D virtual environments? British Journal of Educational Technology, 41(1), 10–32. doi:10.1111/j.1467-8535.2009.01038.x Dede, C., Nelson, B., Ketelhut, D. J., Clarke, J., & Bowman, C. (2004). Design-based research strategies for studying situated learning in a multiuser virtual environment. Paper presented at the International Conference on Learning Sciences, Mahweh, New Jersey. 56
Gee, J. P. (2003). What video games have to teach us about learning and literacy. New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan. Hickey, D. T., Ingram-Goble, A. A., & Jameson, E. M. (2009). Designing assessments and assessing designs in virtual educational environments. Journal of Science Education and Technology, 18(2), 187–208. doi:10.1007/s10956-008-9143-1 Keys, B., & Wolfe, J. (1990). The role of management games and simulations in education and research. Journal of Management, 16(2), 307. doi:10.1177/014920639001600205 Lave, J. (1993). The practice of learning. In Chaiklin, S., & Lave, J. (Eds.), Understanding practice: Perspectives on activity and context (pp. 3–32). New York, NY: Cambridge University Press. doi:10.1017/CBO9780511625510.002 Quest Atlantis. (2010). Quest Atlantis. Retrieved from http://atlantis.crlt.indiana.edu/ Sallnäs, E. L. (2002). Collaboration in multi-modal virtual worlds: Comparing touch, text, voice, and video. In Schroeder, R. (Ed.), The social life of avatars: Presence and interaction in shared virtual environments (pp. 172–187). London, UK: Springer-Verlag London Limited. Schultze, U., Hiltz, S. R., Nardi, B., Rennecker, J., & Stucky, S. (2008). Using synthetic worlds for work and learning. Communications of the Association for Information Systems, 22, 351–370. Taylor, T. L. (2002). Living digitally: Embodiment in virtual worlds. In Schroeder, R. (Ed.), The social life of avatars: Presence and interaction in shared virtual environments (pp. 40–62). London, UK: Springer-Verlag London Limited. Warburton, S. (2009). Second Life in higher education: Assessing the potential for and the barriers to deploying virtual worlds in learning and teaching. British Journal of Educational Technology, 40(3), 414–426. doi:10.1111/j.1467-8535.2009.00952.x
57
Chapter 4
Design of an Authentic E-Learning Environment Theo J. Bastiaens Fernuniversität in Hagen, Germany
ABSTRACT The increasing necessity of a lifelong learning attitude has its influence on the ageing population in Western societies. Employees nowadays cannot rely on their skills once learned in school. Most, also older, employees have to keep up by learning new insights, new skills, and new knowledge. A lot of money is invested in training and further education. New technology can play an important role here. This chapter will give an insight into the development of an authentic multimedia learning environment to support lifelong learners. More specifically, it has been developed in order to improve learning materials in terms of giving the right amount of scaffolding at the time when it is needed to increase the motivation and the performance of the (older) learner. A design that adapts cognitive load theory to minimise cognitive overload was embedded in an authentic context that, as a result, provided a fruitful basis for authentic and simulated learning environments addressing both younger and older adults.
INTRODUCTION In the beginning of the new technology era, faith was put in the fact that only the use of new technology could genuinely improve learners’ motivation, learning approach, and their learning results. The educational technology community DOI: 10.4018/978-1-61350-189-4.ch004
learned the lesson the hard way, that the mere usage of new technology alone would not improve anything. New technology can be seen as just another medium that can be used, as one can also use a teacher, books, or other educational media. From the author’s point of view, it is of foremost importance that new technology is embedded in a systematic instructional design that makes sense. However, there are many instructional design (ID)
Copyright © 2012, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Design of an Authentic E-Learning Environment
models from which to choose. Some ID models are grounded in learning psychology fundamentals like behaviorism or cognitivism. Others are more prescriptive like, for example, the ADDIE (Analysis, Design, Development, Implementation, Evaluation) model. Another category is the phenomenological ID model which takes, for example, situated learning theory or the theory of andragogy as its starting point. In general, all ID models try to translate theoretical assumptions to practical and applicable steps to be taken when developing learning situations, learning materials, or new technologies. The only dilemma and question to be resolved is which ID model to adopt? This is of great importance in designing digitally-supported, authentic, and simulated learning environments for adult and lifelong learning. In the project reported in this chapter, the question was answered by combining ground rules from different theories. That combination finally led to one ID model (The Four-Component Instructional Design Model) that fitted very well with the particular requirements of the project, and also has applicability to undertaking other authentic e-learning designs.
THEORETICAL PERSPECTIVES FROM ADULT AND LIFELONG LEARNING In the project featured in this chapter, a multimedia environment for older learners was developed. Knowles (1975) developed a theory of andragogy to understand and support adult learning. It emphasises that adults are self-directed and do expect to take responsibility for their decisions. Moreover, the theory of self-regulated learning emphasises that students are more effective when they take a purposeful role in their own learning. Multimedia learning environments should therefore not only state why learners need to learn the content, and how the knowledge will be immediately applicable, but these environments should also facilitate a self directed learning process in 58
which the learner can utilise his/her life experience (Knowles, 1975). On the other hand, with age comes the tendency to become less explorative but to turn into a more hands-on, more reflective, and observant learner instead. Minimal guidance, and the very often used discovery learning where learners must construct essential information, might therefore be challenging. As learning research, in general, reveals the importance of providing learners with an authentic context to support learning, and andragogy finds this especially poignant, the concept of situated learning can be considered as a possible framework. Collins, Brown, and Newman (1989) developed the theory of situated learning to increase the knowledge transfer from classroom instruction to real-life applications (Park & Hannafin, 1993; Young, 1993). Taking further findings of research on lifelong learning into account, for example, that adults prefer learning materials that relate to their pre-existing knowledge and experiences, therefore makes it even more plausible that adult learners prefer authentic tasks above conventional ones. So, a possible ID framework has to offer learners a structure where they can direct their own learning and apply their learning strategies to move at their own pace through the materials.
DESIGNING AUTHENTIC LEARNING ENVIRONMENTS In integrating the theory of situated learning, Herrington and Oliver (2000) suggest nine design recommendations for authentic learning environments: • • • • •
Provide authentic contexts that reflect the way the knowledge will be used in real life. Provide authentic activities. Provide access to expert performances and the modelling of processes. Provide multiple roles and perspectives. Support collaborative construction of knowledge.
Design of an Authentic E-Learning Environment
• • •
•
Promote reflection to enable abstractions to be formed. Promote articulation to enable tacit knowledge to be made explicit. Provide coaching by the teacher at critical times, and scaffolding and fading of teacher support. Provide for integrated assessment of learning within the tasks.
As mentioned before, an authentic learning environment provides a context that reflects the way knowledge and skills will be used in real life. This includes a physical or virtual environment that resembles the real world, with real-world complexity and limitations, and provides options and possibilities that are also present in real life (Herrington & Oliver, 2000). An authentic environment is not the same as an authentic task, which resembles a task performed in a non-educational setting and requires students to apply a broad range of knowledge and skills (Roth, 1995). Authentic environments provide a realistic context for authentic learning tasks. In Europe in the last decade, the emphasis in education has changed from focusing on the memorisation of knowledge, to the development of an integrative whole of knowledge, skills and attitudes. This integration of three key values in education is often referred to as the development of a competency (Stoof, Martens, van Merriënboer, & Bastiaens, 2002).The function of both an authentic learning environment and an authentic learning task is to show students relevance and stimulate them to develop those competencies that are relevant for their future professional and/or daily life (Gulikers, Bastiaens, & Martens, 2005). For example, students need to be able to handle problems that they will be confronted with in the workplace. Companies often argue that students know a lot of “facts” but are not competent to solve a real world problem (Bastiaens & Martens, 2000). It is contended that they are simply not trained to do so in school. On the other hand, in schools, and even more at universities, students
complain that they cannot see the relevance of a certain subject that is taught. It seems as if the kind of learning that occurs in schools does not fit with what companies call ‘competent’ employees. Authentic learning is thought to provide an answer to these complaints. For that, we need to provide students with an authentic learning task in an authentic learning environment. It is almost impossible to separate these two. Some authors as Petraglia (1998) and Uhlenbeck (2002) argue that it is impossible to provide students with an authentic task without providing an authentic context. In this project we developed a multimedia environment in which students worked on authentic tasks in a simulated authentic environment. To summarise, it was determined that our multimedia learning environment should be characterised by real world relevance where learning is embedded in social practice. The tasks should be authentic and have a diversity of possible outcomes, and there should be authentic assessment that is seamlessly integrated with these tasks. In the multimedia learning environment opportunities for students to examine content and tasks from a variety of perspectives and to collaborate, articulate, and reflect on their knowledge should be provided. Herrington and Oliver’s (2000) nine aspects are conceived as a guideline for the design of multimedia-based environments that incorporate the characteristics of authentic learning. However, the nine aspects proposed raise the need for a systematic design model to accommodate complex learning.
THE FOUR-COMPONENT INSTRUCTIONAL DESIGN MODEL Modern instructional design models assume that realistic and rich learning tasks are the driving force for learning (Merril, 2002). Well-designed learning tasks stimulate learners to integrate and coordinate required skills, knowledge, and attitudes. This finally leads to a rich knowledge base 59
Design of an Authentic E-Learning Environment
that allows for transfer to daily life and future work settings (van Merriënboer, Bastiaens, & Hoogveld, 2004). These developments put forward the need for a design model to accommodate complex learning (van Merriënboer, Clark, & de Croock, 2002). However, such design methodologies or models are rare, so designers often have to fall back on their own ideas and intuition, thereby often neglecting systematic analysis, design and evaluation (van Merriënboer & Martens, 2002). Moreover, constructivist learning approaches almost always have an implicit or explicit combination of both cognitive and motivational effects through the learning materials. This makes it even more complicated to design constructivist learning environments and to predict and understand their effects. The Four-Component Instructional Design Model (4C/ID) of van Merriënboer (1997) offers design guidelines in response to this challenge. It supports the development of complex tasks for learning that are often used in higher education. The model distinguishes between non-recurrent aspects of learning and performance, which differ from problem to problem situation, and recurrent aspects, which are identical from one problem situation to another. The model in general exists in four interrelated blueprint components. The backbone of the model is formed by learning tasks which are defined as concrete, authentic, and meaningful whole task experiences. They are sequenced in simple-to-complex task classes. Ideally, they confront learners with all aspects of a professional competency. The second component is called supportive information. This is information that is supportive to the learning and performance of non-recurrent aspects of learning tasks, (e.g. problem solving and reasoning), within the same task class. It helps to develop mental models and cognitive strategies. Just-in-time information is the third component and is a prerequisite to the learning and performance of recurrent aspects of learning tasks. It is relevant to the performance of routine
60
aspects of the learning tasks. In general, these are small information units and presented to learners just-in-time while working on the learning tasks. The last component is called part task practice. These are in fact additional exercises for recurrent aspects of learning tasks for which a very high level of automation is required after instruction. Figure 1 provides a schematic overview of the four components: (1) learning tasks, organised in task classes and with scaffolding within each task class, (2) supportive information, (3) just-in-time (JIT) information, and (4) part-task practice. The sequence of learning tasks, represented as circles, serves as a backbone. Equivalent learning tasks belong to the same task class (the dotted rectangles around the set of learning tasks in Figure 1). The equivalency means that they can be performed on the basis of the same body of knowledge. Each new task class is more difficult than the previous task class. Learners receive a great deal of guidance and support for their work on the first learning tasks in a task class. This guidance and support decreases in a process of ‘scaffolding’ as learners acquire more expertise. In Figure 1, this is indicated by the filled circles. The last learning task in a task class is empty, meaning that the learners work without any support on this final learning task. Often this last task is also used as a test task for the assessment of learners’ performance. The supportive information (presented as Lshaped light grey shapes in Figure 1 for each individual task class) is the information that is often referred to as ‘the theory’ allowing learners to do things that they could not do before. Supportive information describes: •
Mental models of how the learning domain is organised while answering the questions ‘What is this?’(conceptual model), ‘How is this constructed?’(structural model) and ‘How does this work?’(causal model). The supportive information also gives concrete examples and case studies;
Design of an Authentic E-Learning Environment
Figure 1. A schematic overview of the four components of the Instructional Design Model Note: Adapted from van Merriënboer, Bastiaens, & Hoogveld (2004), p.15.
•
•
cognitive strategies of how to approach a problem in a learning domain. After a description of successive phases in a problem solving process and the rules of thumb that may be helpful to complete each of the phases; again examples may be shown of an expert thinking aloud while problem solving; and cognitive feedback that is given on the quality of the task performance while working on the learning tasks.
The just-in-time (JIT) information is represented by dark grey rectangles, with upward pointing arrows indicating that just-in-time information is explicitly coupled to separate learning tasks. This information is preferably presented exactly when learners need to perform particular recurrent aspects of learning tasks. It removes the need for memorisation beforehand.
Part task practice is indicated in Figure 1 by small series of circles representing practice items. Part task practice is only necessary if the learning tasks do not provide enough repetition to reach the required level of automation. The main goal of the 4C/ID model is to support and enable educational developers to construct learning materials for complex tasks that are in line with cognitive load theory, implying that the complexity of these materials do not overwhelm the student. However, there are also motivational claims (Bastiaens & Martens, 2005). It is presumed that the structure of the 4C/ID model, especially the different sequencing principles (simple to complex, high level of support to no support) and the difference between supportive and just-in-time information will have positive effects on learning and motivation. “It is clearly impossible to use highly complex learning tasks from the start of a course or training program because this would yield excessive cognitive load for the learners,
61
Design of an Authentic E-Learning Environment
with negative effects on learning, performance and motivation” (Sweller, van Merriënboer, & Paas, 1998, p. 260). Thus, an important aim is to construct learning materials in such a way that they do not increase cognitive load (Paas, 1992). Next to this, learning tasks are defined as realistic and authentic situations and problems which are derived from professional practice (Janssen & van Merriënboer, 2002). Four C/ID’s whole task practice offers “nontrivial, realistic, and increasingly more authentic tasks” (van Merriënboer, Clark, & de Croock, 2002, p. 58). These tasks are expected to be more stimulating and challenging for learners. Instructional design models such as the 4C/ ID model of van Merriënboer (1997) are increasingly popular for the development of learning environments for complex learning. 4C/ID is based on the tradition of situated learning and has been acknowledged as one of the most effective instructional design models for e-learning environments. The model fitted our ambition to develop an authentic learning environment for the project reported below. It gives structure and guidance in the development of authentic learning tasks and authentic learning environments in general.
THE “INTERACTIVE WHITEBOARDS – AUTHENTIC LEARNING” PROJECT Since the 4C/ID model is acknowledged as one of the most effective instructional design models (Merrill, Barclay, & Schaak, 2008) a complete multimedia learning environment was developed applying this methodology. The multimedia environment provides a possibility for (future) teachers and educational staff to learn how to use an interactive whiteboard, and how to develop teaching materials for it. In fact, the multimedia learning environment provides training for our adult students, studying mostly part time while in existing employment and who are approaching the end of their bachelor’s degree at our distance teaching
62
university. Their bachelor’s degree prepares them for practical work as an educational technologist in schools and educational institutes. These adult students are used to self-regulated learning and have clear expectations in the sense that the time they invest in further education should benefit them in the work they are already doing. These students at least do have a clear goal about how they want to use the new knowledge they acquire to further their careers, as nearly all of them already have clear ideas about the requirements of working life. Thus there is a specific need for the learning materials to be authentic for this group of adult learners. For example, badly drawn metaphors depicting working situations would not be sufficient for this user group. Other expectations involve the need for materials to have a clear structure, as this homogeneous group of adult learners has a common background in higher education and also prior working experience. The clear structure and choice of support needed during the work on the learning tasks allows learners to choose freely the topics they need and to focus on, or skip exercises and topics that they have already mastered. While the content area for the development of the learning environment according to the ID model is not critical, the 4C/ID model has been proven to be particularly appropriate for our content area of learning to apply a tool, i.e. interactive whiteboards. The lack of training in the use of interactive whiteboards for teachers was obvious as the technology was still in its infancy at the beginning of this project (Beauchamp & Parkinson, 2005; Cogill, 2006). Our project idea of encouraging the use of interactive whiteboards through the development of a rich multimedia environment seemed perfect. The seamless integration of multimedia into the learning environment enables learners to familiarise themselves first with the topic through worked examples and case studies, and then to develop a mental model. After the development of these understandings, students can get proactive in working with simulated exercises, both at a technical level (concerning the
Design of an Authentic E-Learning Environment
software) as well as involving the behavioural modelling of the expert. Students finally work towards the integration of their new knowledge into their real world experiences, (in this case the integration of an interactive whiteboard in their own classroom situations). The four interrelated blueprint components of the 4CID model were used, detailed and worked out in designing the authentic multimedia environment with its simulated exercises.
Learning Tasks The backbone of the model are the learning tasks which are concrete, authentic, and meaningful whole task experiences that confront learners with all aspects of a certain task and deal with all aspects of a professional competency. In our multimedia environment defined as authentic, whole-task experiences, which include worked examples in the form of case studies, were provided. Learning tasks come in a specific order that is based on the scaffolding principle. For example, learners get a first learning task in which a video of an experienced teacher using the whiteboard
in a classroom is shown. This expert performance has to be observed, (see an example of this represented in Figure 2). This worked out example generates the first mental model for the learner of what constitutes effective practice. The second learning task can be an imitation problem in which an example is shown that the learner consequently has to imitate in a different context. The third learning task can finally be a conventional problem in which the learners have to perform the task or solve the problem themselves. In our example, we first made a mind map of an expert teacher using an interactive whiteboard in actually undertaking their work in a real classroom. We analysed how the expert develops their lessons and prepares themselves while also video recording the actual classroom usage of the interactive whiteboard. The authentic learning tasks constructed deal with the development, preparation, and usage of the interactive whiteboard in a classroom. In the design process, we gathered detailed input from actual teaching experts in an actual job situation (as the 4CID model suggests).
Figure 2. Case study in Module 1
63
Design of an Authentic E-Learning Environment
Supportive Information The second component is called supportive information. This is (theoretical) information that is supportive to the learning and performance of nonrecurrent aspects of learning tasks (e.g. problem solving and reasoning). Supportive information helps to develop mental models and cognitive strategies. Supportive information is necessary for the non-recurrent aspects in the multimedia environment and is provided in the form of classroom videos and audio files containing the “theory”. The multimedia learning environment therefore offers a mix containing video and audio resources as well as more traditional online texts. The learner can get more fundamental information about the situation or problem from these resources. Supportive information is valid and pinpointed to all the learning tasks in the one module.
Just-In-Time Information Just-in-time information is the third component and is prerequisite to the learning and performance of recurrent aspects of learning tasks, meaning that it is relevant to the performance of routine aspects of the learning tasks. In general these are small information units and presented to learners, just-in-time, while working on the learning tasks. The multimedia learning environment offers help sites, glossaries, and Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs). We also use software examples and hands on software exercises to promote the necessary technical skills needed to use interactive whiteboards. But equally as important as the technical knowhow are the pedagogical context and the didactical strategies to apply when using the interactive whiteboard. As situated learning research has shown, case studies especially have the ability to introduce the learner to a certain situation or context and to show them how to reflect on the case situation from various perspectives. This multimedia learning environment integrates a wide range of case studies reflecting various
64
perspectives from experienced teachers who have used interactive whiteboards for several years to those who are less experienced and represent a novice point of view. Just-in-time information is available at the right moment of need to solve practical routine problems, for example, in providing short information on how to take certain procedural steps in the software. Just-in-time information is connected to each individual student’s authentic learning task.
Part-Task Practice Part-task practice for the automation of some recurrent tasks in form of additional exercises. These are in fact additional exercises for recurrent aspects of learning tasks for which a very high level of automation is required after instruction (van Merriënboer, 1997). These exercises were not required in our multimedia environment, so we did not develop part-task practice tasks. The learning materials in our multimedia environment are organised into four modules that build upon each other with increasing complexity (as depicted in Figure 1). Learners encounter authentic and complex problems in the learning environment in the same way teachers would in classroom situations except that they have the scaffolding support they need in place such as the supportive information and the just-in-time information. The learning environment is web based and was developed with Adobe Flash and a MySQL Database. It has been created to run on all standard browsers and is available for participants on the university website.
RESEARCH QUESTIONS The main research questions of this study are twofold. The first question is whether learning in an authentic learning environment influences student performance, and especially whether there is any difference between younger students (under 25, the
Design of an Authentic E-Learning Environment
so called network generation) and the older more experienced adult learners. The second question is whether learning in an authentic environment influences student experiences with the learning environment and whether that experience makes the transfer of what is learned easier to their daily practice. Moreover, we are also interested in the intrinsic motivation of students and the experience of reality as a result of the learning environment within which they work. We hold the hypothesis that the authentic learning environment will result in higher intrinsic motivation and an experience of increased connection to reality, simply because the authentic environment is a more realistic simulation of reality. In our research design, we rank the participants on age, experience, and background. In the environment, we have built in three questionnaires (pretest, during and posttest). During a one year period, participants are free to register and work/ learn in the online environment. In comparable designs with online questionnaires we have collected data from up to 15 000 people (Deimann & Bastiaens, 2010).
DISCUSSION This chapter deals with three central challenges: how best to support adult learners with their specific learning in multimedia learning environments; how to use the increasingly popular concept of situated learning in the instructional design process; and finding an appropriate instructional design model for the development of suitable learning tasks and environments. Lifelong learning and the growing use of new technology provide interesting challenges for instructional designers. Difficulties in learning can be caused when adult learners cannot anticipate what to expect in terms of how the learning materials interrelate with each other or with existing knowledge (Botwinick, 1978).
The aforementioned learning environment based on the 4C/ID model shows how learning materials can be developed to ensure that adult learners can benefit from contextualised learning in terms of motivation and performance (Martens, Gulikers, & Bastiaens, 2004).The sequencing from simple to complex modules and the separation of recurrent and non-recurrent information provides the right amount of scaffolding when it is needed. Though the need for student-centred, problembased learning environments has been recognised, the difficulties in implementing those affect most higher learning institutions. The aforementioned characteristics of situated learning in general and more specifically the 4C/ID model can be implemented in the real world, in classroom situations, in e-learning environments, and all variations of blended learning. Apart from the methodology, they can be applied to practically any discipline. Gulikers, Bastiaens, and Martens (2005) completed a comparable study that provided insight into the effects of an authentic electronic learning environment on student performance and experiences. At that time, it was expected that learning in an authentic learning environment resulted in higher performance. The results of that study showed, contrary to what was expected, that students who worked in an authentic environment did not perform better than students who worked in a less authentic environment. Moreover, the reported experiences with the learning environment did not differ between both groups. It was concluded that the main reason for that outcome could have been that students in the non-authentic condition were possibly distracted because this condition contained less (irrelevant) information and fewer multimedia features. Students in the authentic condition were, in that study, confronted with much more choice of options and a lot to see and hear because of all of the multimedia features that were used. Consequently, because the students were distracted during their learning, they did not perform better.
65
Design of an Authentic E-Learning Environment
However, we believe that times have now changed; students are more used to working and learning online with multimedia. We have also changed our concept and view about authentic learning. In this new study we made some radical changes. Most importantly, now we more clearly structure the authentic learning experience that we develop. Although it is authentic, it is still all about learning. In our earlier projects, we probably focused more on constructivism and the high fidelity of the multimedia environment, (meaning that it had to be as close as possible to a real-life experience), than on the fact that we are still designing for a learning situation. The experience of the FernUniversität in Hagen with teaching undergraduate and graduate students in a blended learning approach using authentic learning materials has shown in the past that, the more authentic the tasks are, the more students generally get engaged within the learning process and are able to retain that knowledge. However, experience has also shown that students might be overwhelmed with self-regulated learning especially with little prior experience. For that reason the 4C/ID model was chosen because the combination of authentic learning with a good instructional format based on cognitive load theory can be seen as a solid basis for the development of learning materials.
CONCLUSION In this chapter we have described the benefits of authentic learning and a possible approach to create these kinds of learning experiences through the use of an instructional design model. Learners have to solve problems and create a result (mostly a product) themselves. However, authentic learning should not be seen as the ultimate constructivist approach. Too often, educators abuse the term authentic learning or constructivism for situations in which learners are struggling with a learning task, completely left alone and, for example, revert
66
to only googling for solutions. That has nothing to do with authentic learning or constructivism. We still think that guidance, structure, and good examples are very important for learners. As we learned the hard way, high fidelity is not of primary importance. It is expected that students benefit both from authentic tasks and well structured supportive learning materials and flexible scaffolding. Further research and an empirical study needs to be undertaken to prove these claims.
REFERENCES Bastiaens, T. J., & Martens, R. L. (2000). Conditions for Web-based learning with real events. In Abbey, B. (Ed.), Instructional and cognitive impacts of Web-based education (pp. 1–31). Hershey, PA: Idea Group Publishing. doi:10.4018/9781878289599.ch001 Bastiaens, T. J., & Martens, R. L. (2005). Motivational effects of learning with complex tasks. Paper presented at the European Association for Research on Learning and Instruction (EARLI) Conference 2005, Nicosia, Cyprus. Beauchamp, G., & Parkinson, J. (2005). Beyond the ‘wow’ factor: Developing interactivity with the interactive whiteboard. The School Science Review, 86(316), 97–103. Botwinick, J. (1978). Aging and behavior. New York, NY: Springer. Cogill, J. (2006). Pedagogy, models of teacher knowledge, and use of the interactive whiteboard. Education Today, 56(3), 6–13. Collins, A., Brown, J. S., & Newman, S. E. (1989). Cognitive apprenticeship: Teaching the crafts of reading, writing, and mathematics. In Resnick, L. B. (Ed.), Knowing, learning and instruction: Essays in honour of Robert Glaser (pp. 453–494). Hillsdale, NJ: LEA.
Design of an Authentic E-Learning Environment
Deimann, M., & Bastiaens, T. J. (2010). The role of volition in distance education: An exploration of its capacities. International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning, 11(1), 1–16. Gulikers, J. T. M., Bastiaens, T. J., & Martens, R. L. (2005). The surplus value of an authentic learning environment. Computers in Human Behavior, 21(3), 509–521. doi:10.1016/j.chb.2004.10.028 Herrington, J., & Oliver, R. (2000). An instructional design framework for authentic learning environments. Educational Technology Research and Development, 48(3), 23–48. doi:10.1007/ BF02319856 Janssen, A. M. B., & van Merriënboer, J. J. G. (2002). Innovatief onderwijs ontwerpen. Via leertaken naar complexe vaardigheden [Designing innovative education: from learning tasks to complex tasks]. Groningen: Wolters-Noordhoff. Knowles, M. (1975). Self-directed learning. Chicago, IL: Follet. Martens, R. L., Gulikers, J., & Bastiaens, T. (2004). The impact of intrinsic motivation on e-learning in authentic computer tasks. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 20, 368–376. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2729.2004.00096.x Merrill, M. D. (2002). First principles of instruction. Educational Technology Research and Development, 50(3), 43–59. doi:10.1007/BF02505024 Merrill, M. D., Barclay, M., & Schaak, A. V. (2008). Prescriptive principles for instructional design. In Spector, J. M., Merrill, M. D., van Merriënboer, J., & Driscoll, M. P. (Eds.), Handbook of research on educational communications and technology (pp. 173–184). New York, NY: Taylor & Francis Group.
Paas, F. (1992). Training strategies for attaining transfer of problem-solving skill in statistics: A cognitive-load approach. Journal of Educational Psychology, 84, 429–434. doi:10.1037/00220663.84.4.429 Park, I., & Hannafin, M. J. (1993). Empiricallybased guidelines for the design of interactive multimedia. Educational Technology Research and Development, 41(3), 63–85. doi:10.1007/ BF02297358 Petraglia, J. (1998). Reality by design. The rhetoric and technology of authenticity in education. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum. Roth, W. M. (1995). Authentic school science: Knowledge and learning in open-inquiry science laboratories. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Kluwer Academic Press. Stoof, A., Martens, R. L., van Merriënboer, J. J. G., & Bastiaens, T. J. (2002). The boundary approach of competence: A constructivist aid for understanding and using the concept of competence. Human Resource Development Review, 1, 345–365. doi:10.1177/1534484302013005 Sweller, J., van Merriënboer, J., & Paas, F. (1998). Cognitive architecture and instructional design. Educational Psychology Review, 10, 251–296. doi:10.1023/A:1022193728205 Uhlenbeck, A. (2002). The development of an assessment procedure for beginning teachers of English as a foreign language. Doctoral dissertation, University of Leiden, The Netherlands. Van Merriënboer, J. J. G. (1997). Training complex cognitive skills: A four-component instructional design model for technical training. Englewood Cliffs, N. J.: Educational Technology Publications.
67
Design of an Authentic E-Learning Environment
Van Merriënboer, J. J. G., Bastiaens, T., & Hoogveld, A. (2004). Instructional design for integrated e-learning. In Jochems, W., Van Merriënboer, J. J. G., & Koper, R. (Eds.), Integrated e-learning: Implications for pedagogy, technology & organisation (pp. 13–24). London, UK: Routledge Falmer. Van Merriënboer, J. J. G., Clark, R., & de Croock, M. (2002). Blueprints for complex learning: The 4C/ID-Model. Educational Technology Research and Development, 50, 39–64. doi:10.1007/ BF02504993 Van Merriënboer, J. J. G., & Martens, R. L. (2002). Computer-based tools for instructional design. [Special Issue]. Educational Technology Research and Development, 50. Young, M. F. (1993). Instructional design for situated learning. Educational Technology Research and Development, 41(1), 43–58. doi:10.1007/ BF02297091
Chaffin, A. J., & Harlow, S. D. (2005). Cognitive learning applied to older adult learners and technology. Educational Gerontology, 31, 301–329. doi:10.1080/03601270590916803 Clark, R. C., & Mayer, R. E. (2003). E-Learning and the science of instruction: Proven guidelines for consumers and designers of multimedia. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass/Pfeiffer. Gerven, P. W. M. v., Paas, F., Merriënboer, J. J. G. v., Hendriks, M., & Schmidt, H. G. (2003). The efficiency of multimedia learning into old age. The British Journal of Educational Psychology, 73, 489–505. doi:10.1348/000709903322591208 Gulikers, J. T. M., Bastiaens, T. J., & Kirschner, P. A. (2004). A Five-Dimensional Framework for Authentic Assessment. ETR&D, 52(3), 67–87. doi:10.1007/BF02504676
ADDITIONAL READING
Gulikers, J. T. M., Bastiaens, T. J., Kirschner, P. A., & Kester, L. (2006). Relations between student perceptions of assessment authenticity, study approaches and learning outcome. Studies in Educational Evaluation, 32, 381–400. doi:10.1016/j. stueduc.2006.10.003
Bastiaens, T., Boon, J., & Martens, R. (2004). Evaluating integrated e-learning. In Jochems, W., Merriënboer, J. v., & Koper, R. (Eds.), Integrated E-learning. Implications for Pedagogy, Technology & Organisation (pp. 187–199). London: Routledge Falmer.
Gulikers, J. T. M., Bastiaens, Th. J., Kirschners, P. A., & Kester, L. (2008). Authenticity is in the eye of the beholder: student and teacher perception of assessment authenticity. Journal of Vocational Education and Training, 60(4), 401–412. doi:10.1080/13636820802591830
Bastiaens, Th., & De Croock, M. (2005). Instructieontwerp voor effectieve taakuitvoering: in 10 stappen naar complex leren. Persoon en Gemeenschap, 57(3), pp 169-180.
Herrington, A., & Herrington, J. (2006). Authentic learning environments in higher education. Hershey, PA: Information Science Publishing.
Brünken, R., Plass, J. L., & Leutner, D. (2003). Direct measurement of cognitive load in multimedia learning. Educational Psychologist, 38(1), 53–61. doi:10.1207/S15326985EP3801_7
68
Herrington, J., Oliver, R., & Reeves, T. C. (2003). Patterns of engagement in authentic online learning environments. Australian Journal of Educational Technology, 19(1), 59–71.
Design of an Authentic E-Learning Environment
Jonassen, D. H. (2006). A constructivist’s perspective on functional contextualism. Educational Technology Research and Development, 54(1), 43–47. doi:10.1007/s11423-006-6493-3 Kalyuga, S. (2007). Enhancing instructional efficiency of interactive e-learning environments: A cognitive load perspective. Educational Psychology Review, 19, 387–399. doi:10.1007/ s10648-007-9051-6 Martens, R. L., Gulikers, J., & Bastiaens, T. (2004). The impact of intrinsic motivation on e-learning in authentic computer tasks. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 20, 368–376. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2729.2004.00096.x
Paas, F., Renkl, A., & Sweller, J. (2004). Cognitive load theory: Instructional implications of the interaction between information structures and cognitive architecture. Instructional Science, 32, 1–8. doi:10.1023/B:TRUC.0000021806.17516. d0 Petraglia, J. (1998). Reality by design: The rhetoric and technology of authenticity in education. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum. Pintrich, P. R. (2004). A conceptual framework for assessing motivation and self-regulated learning in college students. Educational Psychology Review, 16(4), 285–407.
Mayer, R. E., & Moreno, R. (2003). Nine ways to reduce cognitive load in multimedia learning. Educational Psychologist, 38(1), 43–52. doi:10.1207/S15326985EP3801_6
Reigeluth, C. M., & An, Y.-J. (2006). Functional contextualism: An ideal framework for theory in instructional design and technology. Educational Technology Research and Development, 54(1), 49–53. doi:10.1007/s11423-006-6494-2
Merriënboer, J. J. G. v., & Kirschner, P. A. (2007). Ten steps to complex learning: A systematic approach to Four-Component Instructional Design. Mahwah, New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Reiser, R. A., & Dempsey, J. V. (Eds.). (2007). Trends and issues in instructional design and technology (2nd ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Merrill Prentice Hall.
Merriënboer, J. J. G. v., & Stoyanov, S. (2008). Learners in a changing learning landscape: Reflections from an instructional design perspective. In Visser, J., & Visser-Valfrey, M. (Eds.), Learners in a changing learning landscape: Reflections from a dialogue on new roles and expectations (pp. 69–90). Berlin, Germany: Springer.
Scheiter, K., Gerjets, P., Vollmann, B., & Catrambone, R. (2009). The impact of learner characteristics on information utilisation strategies, cognitive load experienced, and performance in hypermedia learning. Learning and Instruction, 19(5), 387–401. doi:10.1016/j.learninstruc.2009.02.004
Moreno, R., & Mayer, R. (2007). Interactive multimodal learning environments. Educational Psychology Review, 19, 309–326. doi:10.1007/ s10648-007-9047-2 Paas, F., & Kester, L. (2006). Learner and information characteristics in the design of powerful learning environments. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 20, 281–285. doi:10.1002/acp.1244
Sweller, J., Merrienboer, J. J. G. v., & Paas, F. G. W. C. (1998). Cognitive architecture and instructional design. Educational Psychology Review, 10(3). doi:10.1023/A:1022193728205 Young, M. F. (1993). Instructional design for situated learning. Educational Technology Research and Development, 41(1), 43–58. doi:10.1007/ BF02297091
69
Section 2
E-Simulation Learning Designs in Action
71
Chapter 5
E-Simulations for the Purpose of Training Forensic (Investigative) Interviewers Belinda Guadagno Deakin University, Australia Martine Powell Deakin University, Australia
ABSTRACT One of the most critical issues facing investigative organisations is how best to administer effective practice opportunities in investigative interviewing on a global scale. Interviewer evaluation research across the world has highlighted inadequacies in the adherence to and maintenance of best-practice interview approaches, and insufficient opportunities for practice and feedback are the major reasons attributed by experts for poor interviewer competency. “Unreal Interviewing: Virtual Forensic Interviewing of a Child” (an e-simulation created at Deakin University, Australia) was developed as a way to ‘expand the reach’ of trainers in the investigative interviewing area. The simulation enables trainers to provide ongoing professional development for forensic interviewers in dispersed work environments, without the financial burden on organisations of extracting large numbers of professionals from the workplace to the classroom. This chapter provides readers with: an overview of the key stages involved in the development of Unreal Interviewing and the education and technical decisions that needed to be made; and a review of the application of “Unreal Interviewing” in the training and continuing professional development of trainees in their workplace. DOI: 10.4018/978-1-61350-189-4.ch005
Copyright © 2012, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
E-Simulations for the Purpose of Training Forensic (Investigative) Interviewers
INTRODUCTION Whenever there is an allegation of abuse (or other crime) perpetrated against, or in the presence of, a child, the child witness will typically engage in an investigative interview with a professional working in the forensic field. Although investigative interviews may vary in purpose, scope, and content, the common objective of all investigative interviews is to elicit an accurate, complete, and detailed account of the incident in question (Powell, 2009). Eliciting an accurate and detailed account of an event (such as abuse) from a child is a complex process that involves several skills and competencies which have been well articulated in the literature. Overall, experts agree that the most critical skill is the ability to maintain the use of non-leading, open-ended questions; such questions elicit elaborate responses but do not dictate or suggest what information is required (e.g., “I wasn’t there when that happened. Start at the beginning and tell me everything that happened”, “What else happened?”, “And then what happened?”; Powell & Snow, 2007). Open-ended questions are essential because they maximise the accuracy of the child’s account of the event and minimise the opportunity for confusion, contamination and/or misunderstandings between the child and the interviewer (Powell, Fisher, & Wright, 2005). An open-ended questioning style is also critical to tasks such as the development of rapport (Roberts, Lamb, & Sternberg, 1999; Sternberg et al., 1997) and the elicitation of a clear disclosure of abuse and temporal attributes (Orbach & Lamb, 2007; Powell & Snow, 2007). Further, open-ended questions elicit the most coherent and credible statements from child witnesses (Feltis, Powell, Snow, & Hughes-Scholes, 2010; Guadagno, Powell, & Wright, 2006). Experts in investigative interviewing are also in agreement about what is generally needed to promote the use of open-ended questions. As with most practical skills (see Ericsson, 2004;
72
Ericsson, Krampe, & Tesch-Romer, 1993), regular practice in the use of open-ended questions and expert feedback is critical. The impact of practice and feedback has been indicated in studies showing better use of open-ended questions among interviewers who received these elements on an ongoing basis (i.e., after the initial training program ceased) compared to those who did not (Lamb, Sternberg, Orbach, Herskowitz, et al, 2002; Powell, Fisher, & Hughes-Scholes, 2008a, 2008b). However, research in relation to interviewer training is still in its infancy and further research is needed to define the relative effectiveness of the various training elements as well as the precise way in which feedback and practice exercises should be delivered. The importance of, and urgent need for, further guidance in this area is heightened by the finding that most investigative interviewers have tremendous difficulty maintaining open-ended questions with children. Most of the prior evaluation research in the U.K., U.S., and Australia has revealed rates of open-ended questions of approximately 25%; research has shown that this low rate would be minimising the chance of successful prosecution (Pipe, Orbach, Lamb, Abbott, & Stewart, 2008). The major reason attributed to this poor performance is insufficient opportunity (within police and human service organisations) to practise skills on an ongoing basis, and a lack of appropriate monitoring and supervision of performance (Aarons, Powell, & Browne, 2004; Davies, Wilson, Mitchell, & Milsom, 1995; Lamb, Sternberg, Orbach, Espin, & Mitchell, 2002; Lamb, Sternberg, Orbach, Herskowitz et al., 2002; Schollum, Westera, Grantham, & Chartres, 2006; Wright, Guadagno, & Powell, 2009). Learning the precise skill of maintaining open-ended questions can be conceptualised as involving several discrete sub-skills. These include: knowing what an open-ended question is, and why it is important; recognising various types of open-ended questions; choosing the most effective open-ended question at the appropriate
E-Simulations for the Purpose of Training Forensic (Investigative) Interviewers
point in the interview; and being able to vocalise the right open-ended question. In this chapter we describe and evaluate the use of an e-simulation specifically designed to facilitate the development of the third skill relating to the choice of appropriate open-ended questions. As far as we are aware, “Unreal Interviewing” is the first interactive e-simulation developed to assist professionals in learning how to interview a child. It was developed as a way to “expand the reach” of trainers in the investigative interviewing area, allowing training to occur in dispersed work environments without the financial burden on organisations of extracting large numbers of professionals from the workplace to the classroom. Specifically, “Unreal Interviewing” encourages trainee interviewers to take an active role in initiating practice in the selection of open-ended questions and monitoring of their performance in their own time and space (without the cost associated with other training programs that include a live practice and feedback component). “Unreal Interviewing” was created to selectively simulate professional practice, rather than to create a richly complex, immersive environment. In this sense, it is best described as an experiential simulation, as denoted by the inclusion of two features of this type of digital simulation. These features are: a live actor (rather than animated computer characters or simple case-study text) who is rendered in the simulation as a video character; and a trainee engaging in the simulation participates in a timed interview with a virtual child (and receives expert feedback about his/her performance) that generally unfolds in real-time. “Unreal Interviewing” allows trainees to participate in the interview by influencing the scenario through their question selections, analysing the resultant information, and making professional decisions along the way. Creation of a simulated interview of this type was a costly and complex process involving many steps. Specifically, its development required consideration of its use and consideration of the
training literature on investigative interviewing, creative scenario design, attention to detail of simulated characters and their behaviour, involvement in graphic and multimedia design, as well as extensive testing and evaluation of simulation scripts and their deployment in the teaching context. The purpose of this chapter is to provide readers with an overview of what was involved in each of these stages and a justification for the decisions that needed to be made. First, we provide a description of “Unreal Interviewing” and each stage of its development. Second, we review preliminary qualitative feedback about the exercise from trainee investigative interviewers who used the e-simulation as part of a training course.
DEVELOPING “UNREAL INTERVIEWING” In “Unreal Interviewing”, trainees interview a virtual five-year-old child (named Theresa) about suspected sexual abuse by choosing the most appropriate questions to ask from a list of question options provided in the simulation. Development of the simulation involved several discrete stages: preparing question-and-answer scripts for multiple logical paths through the interview; selecting actors to represent the child interviewee (Theresa); structuring the user’s interview experience and designing the simulation interfaces; and finally developing the technical architecture of “Unreal Interviewing”. Each stage is now discussed separately in turn.
Stage 1: Preparing Scripts for Multiple Logical Paths Through the Interview As previously mentioned, the simulation allows trainees to interview a virtual child (Theresa) about her experience of abuse by choosing the best questions to ask from a list of question options provided. At each step in the interview, trainees
73
E-Simulations for the Purpose of Training Forensic (Investigative) Interviewers
are provided with four questions to choose from. Once trainees select one of the four question options, they receive a response from the child and four further question options, from which they are to select their next question. There are a total of 226 question options included in the simulation. Each question selection made by the trainee determines the path of the interview, and trainees receive immediate expert feedback about their selections. Two educators (both expert trainers and researchers in the area of child witness interviewing) prepared the question-and-answer scripts, the logic of the multiple paths through the interview, and the coding of those paths in XML. This was done with the help of a software programmer. The programmer requested a diagrammatic representation of the question-and-answer structures, starting initially with one section/path of
Figure 1. Summary of complex question structure
74
the interview (with the idea that the many sections/paths would interconnect). However, the educators were not sure that this diagram would be helpful as there was such a complicated web between questions. Ultimately, an Excel sheet was employed to plot every question and answer included in the simulation (along with their respective identification number/code). The process involved the educators writing four questions and responses on a three-by-four meter sheet of paper. For each response, they wrote another four questions until they had completed the scenario (i.e., when a disclosure of the abusive act had been elicited and all of the question-andanswer pathways had been brought together and ended on the same question). Figure 1 provides a summary of the complex question structure employed in “Unreal Interviewing”.
E-Simulations for the Purpose of Training Forensic (Investigative) Interviewers
For each of the four question options, there was always one question that was the ‘best’ question (i.e., most open-ended) to ask next. Openended (desirable) questions were rewarded with relevant (abuse-related) information, and specific questions (less desirable questions) were discouraged (i.e., they elicited brief responses), consistent with the literature on best-practice guidelines and formative assessment. Prior research shows that reinforcement of appropriate questions is critical for the effectiveness of practical training exercises (Irons, 2007; Powell et al., 2008a). Once completed on the three-by-four meter sheet of paper, every question and answer was entered into a Word document and evaluative feedback was written by the educators for each question choice. Feedback on trainee question choice was considered a critical component of the simulation (Irons, 2007). Once finalised, all questions, answers, and feedback were edited by the expert trainer in forensic interviewing. Finally, all question-and-answer pathways were checked to ensure they functioned correctly (i.e., all ended on the same question and made logical sense). The software developer created the XML structure (the code and content that ran the e-simulation), and the question-and-answer pathways were again checked for accuracy, this time by running simulated interviews in a nomedia mode.
Stage 2: Selecting the Actors to Represent the Child To simulate an interview with a child witness, the producers agreed that it demanded a video recording of an actor playing the role of the child interviewee (Theresa). However, a script dealing with child sexual abuse presents clear legal and ethical reasons for not using a five-year-old girl actor. Various options, such as using the image and voice of an adult playing the role, were rejected. Rather, it was decided that the simulation should
have a seemingly “live” video nature so as to allow trainees greater emotional engagement with the simulation (Salmon, 2003). The development team favoured the use of a real child, however, Theresa had to be represented in a semi-realistic manner. A real child actor was recorded answering general questions about herself (but not related to the topic) while seated on a chair in the video studio. The child was lit with back lighting to give the appearance of legitimately hiding the child’s identity. The “real” simulation child responses were recorded in an audio studio with an adult actor, selected because of her child-like voice, and special post-production processing treatments using ProTools (a professional audio engineering software program by Digidesign) were used to manipulate the adult actor’s voice to sound even more like that of a child. This processed voice recording was used to replace the child’s actual voice. Thus, the sometimes sexually explicit answers apparently given by the child in the simulation were actually provided by an adult female actor whose voice mimicked that of a five-year-old child via voice enhancement to the audio postproduction. There was a real need to be able to control the voice nuances in the questions asked by the adult interviewer and the answers seemingly given by the child. To achieve excellent modelling of the question asking, one of the educators (an expert forensic interviewer of children) asked the questions rather than an actor. However, using an actor for the child’s voice enabled clear studio direction (by the same expert in forensic interviewing) about how the answers should be approached and how they should sound. Quite some care was taken to refine the scripted answers in the studio to achieve the best delivery, something that is difficult to script in academic isolation. In addition, the video of the child was timed and looped to substantially reduce the file-size of the video content, thereby reducing the computer demands of the simulation and making it more readily accessible by trainees who may have computers with low specifications. The size and
75
E-Simulations for the Purpose of Training Forensic (Investigative) Interviewers
framing of the video image of the child were also discussed in design meetings. It was decided not to crop the ‘kicking’ legs of the child so as to retain natural body language, rather than representing the child in a closer shot. The use of a wide-angle shot, along with the backlit image of the child, further enhanced the appearance of natural audiolip synchronisation. The scenario achieves significant emotional engagement by trainees in part due to the seemingly ‘live’ nature of the simulated child interacting with trainees. This approach delivered a believable character, helping to encourage learners to give themselves over to the scenario with that classic “willing suspension of disbelief for the moment” famously attributed to Samuel Taylor Coleridge (1817/1854, p.365).
Stage 3: Structuring the Interview Experience and Designing the “Unreal Interviewing” Interfaces The expert interview trainers/educators and software programmers worked collaboratively in structuring the “Unreal Interviewing” interview experience. All agreed that: trainees must receive a clear introduction to the task and detailed instructions about their role in the simulation; and that the simulation should unfold in a way that is reminiscent of the interviews encountered by investigative interviewers in the workplace. “Unreal Interviewing” was developed to include the following: •
•
•
76
A “welcome interface” where users are introduced to the tool and the reasons for its development, and are offered instructions about its use. A “login interface” so that use of the simulation could be tracked and retained in a database for performance evaluation and research purposes. A briefing about the child interviewee (Theresa) and the nature of her experi-
•
•
ence of abuse, not unlike the background information about a case that investigative interviewers receive in the field, prior to interviewing a child witness. The ability for users to customise their learning experience by, for example, modifying whether evaluative feedback on question choices is offered during the interview experience (immediately after each question has been selected), or whether it is delayed until the conclusion of the interview. An invitation for users to provide an email address, to which a rich text file of their interview transcript (including their chosen questions, child responses and evaluation feedback) can be forwarded at the end of their simulation experience.
While “Unreal Interviewing” contains the expected briefing before the interview experience, it was decided that a postuse debriefing would be best provided online in discussion forums associated with the e-simulation, rather than embedded within the simulation. Table 1 provides a description and visual representation of each of the various screen interfaces that users encounter as they navigate the “Unreal Interviewing” simulation. There was no precedent for representing the physical characteristics of a ‘typical’ interview room for a child interview. Rooms and interview formats vary across states and investigative organisations in Australia, so the virtual room included in the various “Unreal Interviewing” interfaces was evaluated by police colleagues. The “Unreal Interviewing” interface, during the interview phase of the simulation, displays five information panes as shown in Figure 2. A clock is located in the top left-hand pane, while the top right-hand pane provides the interview room scenario (where Theresa is shown sitting on a chair in a virtual room via a blue screen montage). Immediately below the interview room scenario are the question options (questions are always
E-Simulations for the Purpose of Training Forensic (Investigative) Interviewers
Table 1. Description and visual representation of screen interfaces No.
Sequence
Description
01
Run the simulation launcher
Opening the.exe file loads the Sumulation Launcher which if clicked will confirm launching Flash simulation software
02
Splash screen
The splash screen presents the title of the program, Unreal Interviewing
03
Welcome screen
This screen displays a welcome video to Unreal Interviewing. The welcome is made by an expert trainer in forensic interviewing. The educators decided to deliver the welcome and instruction in both video and text form. Video was included to enhance engagement with the simulation and to ensure that personal communication with users and clear instructions were offered
04
Log-in screen
Users log-in to this first scenario, Forensic Interviewing of a Child, by providing a Username and Password. If the user does not login, then the trainee’s use of the simulation offline cannot be tracked and retained in the database.
05
Introduction screen
An introduction to this forensic interview of the five-year-old-girl, Theresa, is offered by an expert trainer and a background briefing about Theresa and the general situation regarding her family and friends is provided. This is very specific briefing information that could be easily edited, if desired. Care is taken to not provide in the simulation what can be provided another way outside the simulation. Instructions in text can be read carefully by users and considered, rather than only listening to transient audio if presented that way.
06
User Options
Optional setting for the receipt of a transcript of the interview and exaluative feedbnack on question choices are offered. Useres can select to (i) display the transcript of the interview in real-time, and/or (ii) display as text an evaluation of the question choices made in the interview. All expert feedback to users is contained in the simulation. Users have the option of viewing the feedback during or at the end of each session. Evaluation responses can be retained by users along with a record of the interview (i.e., the interview transcript).
07
Clock
The interview is timed and, if the user is logged in, events are tracked time-stamped and are retained in the database.
08
Interview Questions
Interview questions are displayed as text in groups of four and the user is required to select one by clicking on the respective button. Once selected, the question is spoken by a voice on behalf of the interviewer.
continued on following page
77
E-Simulations for the Purpose of Training Forensic (Investigative) Interviewers
Table 1. Continued No.
Sequence
Description
09
End the interview
Regardless of whether the user reaches a point of disclosure about the abusive event, they can exit the interview (at which time a record of the interview, as a rich text file, is email to the user). This record of the interview includes the chosen questions, the answers given and the evaluative feedback.
10
Credit sequence and Exit.
The user is thanked for using Unreal Interviewing and the people involved in the conception and creation of the simulation are acknowledged in the credits (along with the copyright details).
Figure 2. Five information panes of “unreal Interviewing” interface
78
E-Simulations for the Purpose of Training Forensic (Investigative) Interviewers
released in sets of four with a fifth question, the exit option, always reading “That’s all the questions I have to ask you today. Thank you very much for coming and talking to me”). The bottom left- and right-hand corners of the interface display the record of the interview transcript and the question evaluations, (feedback on the quality of the user’s question choice), respectively. Importantly, the size and placement of the panes on the computer screen are a customisation choice; these are just a few of the optional panes in a live simulation design.
Stage 4: Developing the Technical Architecture of “Unreal Interviewing” Four separate technical modules, in combination, comprise the underlying simulation architecture that presents “Unreal Interviewing”:
The Screen Presentation of all Simulation Components Adobe Flash® is the proprietary software that runs “Unreal Interviewing”. The production team decided to use this software because it is found on most computers. Using this software ensured greater access among potential trainees (particularly those living/working in rural areas).
The Authored Scenario as a Script of Speech with Interaction Commands The actual scripted words and the code for enacting the simulation behaviour is delivered to the “state” logic controller in the form of XML script. Computer instructions as “ActionScript” and XML scripting are used to enable the simulation architecture to present the required behaviours of objects (e.g., the child) and the simulated events over time, in a series of “states” in the system that respond to the trainee-user interactions.
The ‘Controller’ of Responses made to Trainee Interaction (Client-Side Actions) In most cases, it is the non-linear progress through the simulated reality that is enacted by the “state” logic controller.
The Database Services (Server-Side Actions) Simulation settings prescribed by the trainer/administrator, or optional settings by the trainee, can be managed and/or tracked by the database. Key purposes for the data in the database are for trainee assessment, evaluation of the simulation, and for research (with the permission of the trainees). A significant benefit of this architecture is that it is modular and manages reusable media elements, allowing significant customisation and editing. When managed by a database, such alterations can be executed on the fly. This can be seen at work in “Unreal Interviewing” where optional modular components (such as the panes for the transcript, clock, and feedback on the question choices) are used and placed where they are in relation to the panes for the interview scenario and the sets of four questions.
EVALUATING “UNREAL INTERVIEWING”: PRELIMINARY RESEARCH “Unreal Interviewing” was developed for use in a range of distance education contexts. To date, the e-simulation has been used by a variety of professionals. These include 72 trainee investigative interviewers (police and child protection officers, psychologists) enrolled in a distance education course aimed at improving their skills in interviewing, 29 social work students completing undergraduate study, and 17 primary school teachers who are mandated under state legislation to notify police and child protection authorities
79
E-Simulations for the Purpose of Training Forensic (Investigative) Interviewers
where they suspect a child is, or may be, at risk of being, abused. All professionals used “Unreal Interviewing” as part of their broader training in the child abuse investigation area. This training