PRISONER OF HISTORY
This page intentionally left blank
PRISONER OF HISTORY Aspasia of Miletus and Her Biographical Tradition
Madeleine M. Henry
New York Oxford OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS 1995
Oxford University Press Oxford New York Athens Auckland Bangkok Bombay Calcutta Cape Town Dar es Salaam Delhi Florence Hong Kong Istanbul Karachi Kuala Lumpur Madras Madrid Melbourne Mexico City Nairobi Paris Singapore Taipei Tokyo Toronto and associated companies in Berlin Ibadan
Copyright © 1995 by Madeleine M. Henry Published by Oxford University Press, Inc., 198 Madison Avenue, New York, New York 10016-43 14 Oxford is a registered trademark of Oxford University Press All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior permission of Oxford University Press. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Henry, Madeleine Mary. 1949Prisoner of history : Aspasia of Miletus and her biographical tradition / Madeleine M. Henry. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-19-508712-7 1. Aspasia. 2. Pericles, 499-429 B.C. 3. Mistresses—Greece—Athens—Biography. 4. Women in politics—Greece—Athens—Biography. 5. Greece—History— Athenian supremacy, 479-431 B.C. I. Title. DF228.A8H46 1995 938'.504'092—dc20 [B] 94-1250
98765432 Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper
Contents
Introduction, 3 1. Aspasia in Greek History, 9 2. The Story Told by Comedy, 19 3. Aspasia and the Socratic Tradition, 29 4. The Sargasso Sea: Aspasia and the Discourse on Prostitutes in the Hellenistic, Roman, and Late Antique Periods, 57 5. Aspasia in the Postclassical West, 83 Afterword, 127 Notes, 131 Bibliography, 177 Index, 195
Acknowledgments
People and institutions have helped Aspasia and me on our journey. Iowa State University gave me a job, several research grants, and a faculty improvement leave, during which much of the work was done. Colleagues in the Department of Foreign Languages and Literatures and in the Classical Studies and Women's Studies Programs offered moral and practical support, and friends in Classical Studies in the United States, Canada, and England sustained me. This work owes more than I can ever say to the sisterhood I have found in the Women's Classical Caucus and to Jim Ruebel's encouragement and collegiality. Special thanks to my friends Achilles Avraamides, John Cunnally, Marie Lathers, Deepa Majumdar, Frank Mariner, Suzanne Mills, Brian LeMay, David Roochnik, and Linda Rutland Gillison, to Jeff Rusten and Philip Stadter, who read the manuscript for Oxford University Press, and to OUP's copyeditor, Lisa Tippett.
PRISONER OF HISTORY
This page intentionally left blank
Introduction
Aspasia of Miletus, a key figure in the intellectual history of fifthcentury Athens, is without question the most important woman of that era. Aspasia left no written works of her own, was lampooned in comedy, and was an important figure in Greek philosophical dialogue—all things she shares with Socrates, a better known and more revered icon, and whose teacher she is said to have been. Aspasia's reputation as teacher has repeatedly been connected with her sexual reputation as a courtesan and the mistress of the statesman Pericles. The historical possibilities for her life and the ebb and surge of her biographical tradition have never before been seriously and comprehensively examined; they are the subject of my study. It is time to remember Aspasia's place in the history of women and of feminist epistemology. During her own lifetime, Aspasia was a notorious woman, one of the few who apparently contradicted the statement, attributed to Pericles, that it is better for women not to be mentioned.1 She has been mentioned in comedy, philosophy, historiography, and art. She has been identified as Pericles' political advisor, as an original "liberated woman," as a philosopher, and as a prototype of the grand horizontal. I hope here to suggest ways in which ancient sources and modern interpreters have constructed her life, and how the possibilities that existed for her life have been misunderstood. Biographical anecdotes that arose in antiquity about Aspasia are wildly colorful, almost completely unverifiable, and still alive and well in the twentieth century. It is arduous but necessary to investigate that tradition from its inception during her own lifetime until the present. The 3
4
Prisoner of History
continued fascination exerted by classical Athens, so near to us and yet so far from us, demands a full treatment of the bios of its most famous woman. 2 Feminist scholarship must be used together with traditional philological methods if we are to see in what ways Aspasia's bios began and has continued to grow, and in what ways it has done her wrong. In Writing a Woman's Life, Carolyn Heilbrun states that women in the West have historically been deprived of the narratives, texts, plots, or examples with which to assume power over their lives. This assertion of the political power of narrative presumes that the forms, structures, and contents of biography, autobiography, and historiography have heretofore supplied insufficient, inaccurate, defective narratives—ones that at best cannot tell the truth of women's lives and at worst create perniciously misleading and stifling narrative plots.3 Furthermore, the very formation of canonical features for biography and biographical tradition has been until recently a process engaged in for the most part by male scholars about male subjects: Aspasia's biographical tradition, although rich, diverges remarkably in its manifestations from those features traditionally considered canonical.4 The paucity of evidence, together with the problems involved in studying the lack of symmetry between men's and women's lives in classical antiquity, has tended to prevent us from considering either that women can legitimately be seen as creative participants in Western intellectual tradition or that they are the proper objects of scholarly inquiry. A standard study of Greek biography categorically, if unintentionally, denies Aspasia a biography: "An account of the life of a man from birth to death is what I call biography."5 This definition of biography merely embellishes the declaration of the great classicist Ulrich von WilamowitzMoellendorff, who declared that Aspasia's life and intellect—and questions about either—have no place in history; we have not come very far.6 The persistence of Aspasia's bios and, in fact, its expansion in the last two centuries suggest that we desperately need to understand both what Aspasia may have been and what she has come to represent. The task is formidable for several reasons. First, the period during which Aspasia lived is one for which there is much conjecture and little good contemporary evidence. At times, it seems that the amount of scholarship produced on a given historical question is inversely proportional to the amount and quality of evidence available. Those who study the lives and biographical traditions of men such as Pericles, Themistocles, or Plato, and of Aspasia face like obstacles, for in each instance it
Introduction
5
is necessary to sift, order, and evaluate evidence of a bewildering quantity, quality, kind, and date (not to mention datability). In order to establish the life events for the greatest figures of classical Athenian history within even a tentative chronology, historians leap perilously among the ice floes of contemporary inscriptions, forward to Plutarch and back to fourth-century revisionist historiographers, only to advance again to papyrus fragments and Byzantine lexica. Over this set of problems lies the "problem" of Aspasia's gender. The male writers of Greco-Roman antiquity perceived, identified, evaluated, and described their female and male subjects very differently. The first consequence of this fact is that far less information has been recorded about women relative to the amount we have about men. Male historians generally did not mention women at all. For example, warfare, a favorite topic of historiographers, affected women in grave ways, but its effect on them is recorded only very indirectly in any sources.7 Even a woman warrior such as Artemisia, who by male standards played an important role in the Persian Wars, is described differently by Herodotus than are Persian men.8 To discern and analyze the gross and fine asymmetries between women's and men's material lives and between their presumed moral and intellectual capacities—and the representation of these in discourse across time and space—is an essential part of feminist critical practice and must supplement traditional philological methods. To classify and evaluate the numerous biographical anecdotes related of Aspasia in exactly the same manner as has been done, for example, for those of Plato, would be a mistake even if it were possible. Because women and men led asymmetrical lives in fifth-century Athens, evidence itself is not "the same" evidence, but different inasmuch as it is informed by a differently gendered relationship for the female object of the male writer's scrutiny. Because of Aspasia's longstanding reputation as teacher, companion to Pericles, and member of an intellectual elite, it has been customary to place her, and then leave her, among other members, all men, of that alleged coterie—Anaxagoras, Phidias, and the scientists and sophists.9 But it is also necessary in the most fundamental sense to consider the ways in which her biographical tradition portrays her as a woman. For example, Aspasia and Pericles are often criticized in comedy and sometimes are mentioned together; it would be erroneous in the extreme, however, to imagine that each is criticized for analogous reasons. It is imperative rather to compare her with other members of the gender class
6
Prisoner of History
"woman" and weigh her representation as a concubine, prostitute, and mother in Old Comedy against the representation of other such women in that genre. This having been done, Aspasia can be seen to participate in a discourse in which men do not. Note that Old Comedy does not celebrate any women thinkers, and that the charge of effeminacy, with strong negative connotations, is leveled against poets. Autonomous "femaleness" and femininity are not revered in Old Comedy. It is likewise perilous to situate Aspasia with Socrates just by denning each as a radical outsider teacher. Like Socrates, Aspasia was criticized in comedy, enjoyed a reputation as a sophistic philosopher, and was an important figure in fourth-century philosophical dialogue. Yet history has largely considered only Plato and other men to be philosophers; women philosophers are footnotes, freaks, groupies, and martyrs—anything and everything but philosophers. It is necessary to explore Aspasia's singular place in the Socratic dialogues and to ask why and with what effect Plato makes Aspasia the only woman outside of Diotima who speaks in any of his works.10 To free Aspasia from the prison of history, we must try to shed any prior notions about what a biography—the writing of a life, the writing of a woman's life—is or must be. First, I suggest the range of historical possibilities for Aspasia's life; these differ substantially from the descriptions and references found in Attic comedy, the only sources contemporary with that life. After identifying the characteristics of her biographical tradition in its first centuries, before Plutarch distilled it into the form that would influence its major reappearances after the end of Greco-Roman antiquity, I trace the evolution of her bios from late antiquity to the present. Next to Sappho's and Cleopatra's, Aspasia's is the longest and richest female biographical tradition to come down to us from the Greco-Roman past. That past has had much to do with current constructions of gender roles and the ways in which women participate, or do not, in intellectual discourse in the West. It is entirely possible that the sexualization of Aspasia's intellect, a key facet of her bios, has negatively affected the development of feminist consciousness. The process of retrieving and reinterpreting the varied aspects of her biographical tradition may help us retrieve earlier moments in the development of feminist consciousness. Perhaps no one will be entirely sympathetic to my treatment of this subject; any topic that is manifested over such a long expanse of time
Introduction
1
and moves among such disparate texts is bound to be unevenly developed by its first investigator. I hope that the reader's dissatisfaction will be born of the recognition that Aspasia and her bios are important and worth much further study. I consider it a positive consequence to have provoked such dissatisfaction.
This page intentionally left blank
1 Aspasia in Greek History
Our ignorance of Aspasia's life course is emblematic of our ignorance of the lives of all women in fifth-century Hellas. This only seems so shocking and our curiosity so keenly and urgently justified because Aspasia's reputation has thrown her into high relief. In fact, however, we are even more ignorant of other women—nameless persons whose lives may have been quite similar to hers. To ask questions about Aspasia's life is to ask questions about half of humanity. One may assume that her early life began typically, that is to say, inauspiciously, and that we must seek its broadest outlines not in the atypical but in the normative bounds. It would be necessary to do this even should it ever become demonstrable that every scurrilous anecdote about Aspasia had a factual basis. We must learn to forget Aspasia's reputation. It is treacherous but obligatory to begin with the most concentrated and connected account of Aspasia's life, that found in chapters 24 and 32 of Plutarch's Life of Pericles. Feminist historians have problematized the authority of male biographers, and classicists painstakingly have dissected out the layers of sources in this imperial author's discussion of Pericles and his associates nearly seven hundred years after the fact. Within Plutarch's brief account, we find scraps of information that may have originated during Aspasia's own lifetime. According to Plutarch, Aspasia came from Miletus, a wealthy city on the coast of Asia Minor, and her father's name was Axiochus.' She had a union with Pericles some time after his divorce from his wife, and she is usually assumed to have given birth to the bastard, Pericles junior. Aspasia is also said to have "married" the Athenian politician Lysides 9
10
Prisoner of History
and to have borne him a son.2 Fifth-century comedy calls her both a concubine and a whore; Plutarch reports that she modeled herself on Thargelia, the Ionian courtesan who attempted to capture the affections of the most powerful men of the day and to influence them politically, but there is no conclusive contemporary evidence. Comedy provides the only fifth-century evidence that she influenced Pericles' political policies.3 In fact, no fifth-century evidence exists for any substantial part of Aspasia's life. It is possible to map only the barest possibilities for that life: to ascertain the approximate date of her birth, her places of residence, the duration and nature of her sexual relationships, the number and birth dates of her children, and the date of her death, are all hazardous endeavors. Additionally, and most importantly, there is no good evidence for her inner or intellectual life. Against the colorful reportage may be set something less sensational, something more documentary. An early fourth-century B.C. Attic gravestone bears the names of persons who were probably Aspasia's collateral descendants. As Oswyn Murray said of ancient historians, "When we do come across evidence, we refuse to believe it, or deny that it is history."4 The possibilities created by the names of the dead allow the hypothesis, suggested by Peter J. Bicknell, that Aspasia was born any time after 470 B.C., that she came to Athens around 450 B.C. as a fatherless refugee of marriageable or nearly marriageable age, and that she was related by her sister's marriage to the Athenian Alcibiades, grandfather of the notorious Alcibiades.5 The elder Alcibiades, ostracized from Athens in 460, may have spent his exile in Miletus. Bicknell proposes that there he met a daughter of Axiochus and by her had two sons, Axiochus (born ca. 458 B.C.) and Aspasios (born ca. 456 B.C.). Aspasia would have been the younger sister of this Milesian wife. Miletus' history was turbulent in the archaic and classical periods. By the 460s, it was a member of the Delian League, a defensive alliance wherein Athens came to assume an increasingly dominant position and to which allied cities contributed ships or tribute in return for protection against Persians and pirates. Around 457/6 there was stasis (factional unrest) in Miletus, possibly caused by oligarchic revolutionaries who did not want to pay tribute, and the city temporarily defected from the league. The oligarchs, hitherto supported by Athens, exiled their opponents to the surrounding communities of Leros and Teichioussa, and others that continued to pay tribute. In the summer of 452, Athens retook Miletus, banned the oligarchs, and reinstated their opponents. It
Aspasia in Greek History
11
is impossible to know what part Axiochus or Alcibiades played in all this, but it is tempting to conjecture that Axiochus was dead and/or his household in disarray by the time Alcibiades' ostracism expired in 450 and he returned to Athens, accompanied by his wife, children, and young sister-in-law.6 The inscription on the grave stele allows the following reconstruction: Alcibiades' son Axiochus is the grandfather of the Aischines named on the stele as the father of the Aspasios commemorated on the stone. Both Axiochoi are identified as demesmen of Skambonidai, and on the stele are mentioned not only Axiochus' wife Eukleia, but also their children, Aischines, Sostrate, and Aspasia. Because sons were commonly named for grandfathers, and because the names Axiochus and Aspasios are themselves rare—in fact, unattested in Attica before the early fourth century—Bicknell's suggestion is plausible. The association within one family of the names Axiochus and Aspasios, of which Aspasia is the feminine form, is also significant. Furthermore, the stele was found in Athens' port city, Piraeus, which was home to many families of foreign origin. Although she may now be tentatively identified as the dependent relation of an Athenian aristocrat, Aspasia was also and unquestionably a resident alien, a metic. If she did in fact arrive in Athens in 450, she would have come at a time when the status of non-Athenian women had recently been radically circumscribed. The question of her status as a metic must now be taken up. The attempt to intelligently assess what it may have meant to be an aristocratic female metic in mid-fifth-century Athens, however difficult it is to make this assessment, will in turn help identify the biases present both in contemporary comic remarks on Aspasia 's life and also in later sources. These sources, because they viewed the fifth century through the lens of subsequent historical and literary developments, have provided their own additional distortions. Recent studies of the ideology of metic status conclude that the concept of the metic was bound up with the concept of citizen; to discuss citizenship is to discuss both its content and its extent. The content and nature of Attic citizenship were not static; they were constantly evolving. Pericles' famous law on citizenship, passed in 451/450, is landmark evidence of this dynamic process. The law seems to have restricted citizenship to persons who had two Athenian parents; but the terminology of the law, the definitions of those terms, the reason(s) that brought the law into being, precisely how citizenship was defined before
12
Prisoner of History
and after the passage of the law, and other restrictions on citizenship, remain somewhat unclear. Nor is it yet entirely clear how the category citizen applied to women versus men; as Cynthia Patterson has shown, major differences obtained for female citizens versus male citizens.7 Pericles' citizenship law was probably passed in response to a substantial and ' 'unnatural" increase in the population of Attica in the years following the Persian Wars of 490-479. This increase was caused by the heavy enrollment into denies and phratries of resident aliens—metics. In his treatise on the subject, David Whitehead translates the term literally as "home-changers."8 Before 490, there is ample evidence that aristocrats, for whom the most evidence survives, commonly married "out"; the illustrious Themistocles, Cleisthenes, Cimon, and Miltiades all had foreign mothers. Before Pericles' law, marriages with such women were probably considered fully valid, and any offspring were given full citizenship rights. Certainly these men's mixed parentage hardly compromised their ability to have political careers, although Pericles is said to have reproached Cimon's sons for having a foreign mother.9 A substantial metic population was assimilating into the Attic body politic by mid-century. The Athens to which Aspasia removed was a city that formerly had been hospitable to metics and in which, until shortly before she arrived, she would have had every expectation of living out a normal woman's life—that is, of marrying and of bearing her husband legitimate sons, sons with political prospects like those of Themistocles and Cimon. It is even possible that Alcibiades and his extended family returned to Athens without knowing that the law had passed; this law, which Patterson has demonstrated was not retroactive, would not have affected Alcibiades' two sons, Aspasios and Axiochus. The Peiraeus grave stele identifies Aspasios, son of Aischines, as a demesman; therefore, he was a citizen.10 Our few sources for the study of the extent and content of metic status in the mid-fifth century are almost completely silent on the subject of women metics.'' Nevertheless, it can be said with confidence that metic status was in general characterized by many liabilities: metics were subject to special taxes, they could not participate politically or own land in Attica, and they were excluded from membership in deme and phratry. And, although the citizenship law of 451/450 fell into abeyance during the Peloponnesian War, it was reenacted in 403/402, a clear indication that the division Athens made between citizen and metic was considered important and worth maintaining. A final proof of the impor-
Aspasia in Greek History
13
tance of boundary maintenance between citizenship and metic status is the fact that enslavement was the penalty for those who falsely represented themselves as citizens.12 The questions of how Pericles and Aspasia met, and how and why they had an apparently lengthy liaison, are vexing ones. If, as is generally assumed, Aspasia was the mother of the bastard, Pericles junior, the union must have commenced before 440, the latest possible birth date for the younger Pericles. If so, this child would have been a little boy in the early years after the passage of his father's citizenship law, and he would have been considered to be of marriageable age by around 420. No ancient sources confirm that Pericles junior was the son of Pericles and Aspasia; it has merely been traditional to assume (as did Demeas regarding Chrysis and the baby in Menander's comedy Samia) that she was the child's mother.13 Pericles had two legitimate sons; therefore, union with a metic woman cannot have been motivated solely by the desire for offspring. Despite the later romantic tradition that has made Pericles absolutely besotted with Aspasia, practical considerations may well have played some part in his liaison with her. It is commonly believed that Pericles made political capital off his ex-wife's remarriage, a practice not uncommon for a man of his class; it is not unreasonable to suspect that his association with Aspasia brought with it some political advantage as well.14 But the tradition does speak of Pericles' love for Aspasia, and the question of its nature haunts us still. If, as the tradition suggests, she was highly intelligent, the love of a powerful and wealthy man could have protected and nurtured her, allowing her to develop her mind in ways not open to other women who lacked either her wisdom or the materially and emotionally supportive environment provided by such a love. In discussing the importance of a supportive environment for the intellectual development of both sexes, Gerda Lerner points out that highly intelligent women have benefited from nurturant and mutually respectful relationships with spouses or partners. But, as she states, "such heterosexual, mutually supportive relationships, while they do occur, are rare in the historical record."15 Because law now deprived Aspasia of the ability to enter a fully valid Athenian marriage, one must ask what kind of union, in the legal exterior sense, she and Pericles had. Metic women seem to have been subject to kyrieia (guardianship) just as citizen women were; presumably Aspasia's kyrios (guardian) would have tried to marry her to another
14
Prisoner of History
metic or possibly place her in pallakia (concubinage) with an actual citizen. Raphael Sealey has recently suggested that pallakia was being institutionalized in the fifth century, and that citizens too poor to provide a dowry as well as well-born metics placed their daughters in a quasimarital "pallakia with stipulations," a status created with "a fully explicit contract." This situation, it is hypothesized, would have guaranteed the bride some security and recourse, though her children would not have been considered legitimate. Even if this were the case, Patterson has shown that a pallake (concubine) was severely disadvantaged by convention and the law. Furthermore, because the citizenship law's negative impact would not have been felt immediately by large numbers of families after its passage, it seems rather unlikely that fathers at this point in time would have hatched an entirely formed concept and practice for pallakia with stipulations and impossible to know under what precise circumstances Aspasia came to be Pericles' sexual property, beloved or otherwise. It was, as David Schaps observed, inevitable for women to wed, and if Aspasia were a dependent relation, it would have been even more in her guardian's interest to get her off his hands at the earliest possible age.16 The tightening of requirements for citizenship was accompanied by the constriction of definitions of legitimacy and the kinds of partnerships that could produce legitimate offspring; the nature of the parents' partnership, as well as their own civic status or lack thereof, determined the status of their children. It is possible that children born of any union other than one between two citizens could be termed nothoi (bastards), though it is most likely that the term was mainly applied to the issue of unions between persons who were not equal.17 Pericles' citizenship law had as an inevitable consequence the elevation of the status of engyetic (formal dowered) marriage between two citizens and a concomitant decline in the status of concubinage, secondary and servile as this had always been. And, because the primary purpose of heterosexual cohabitation was to produce legitimate heirs, the status of nothoi must also have declined in the course of the fifth century.18 S. C. Humphreys maintains that nothoi with foreign mothers were at an even greater disadvantage than were those with two domestic parents; she offers as an example the mixed fortunes of Pericles junior's coeval, Antisthenes the Socratic, another nothos with a foreign mother. Sons of foreign women might also lack the benefits customarily available from avuncular relationships.19 Despite the disadvantages of pallakia for both the woman
Aspasia in Greek History
15
and her offspring, Aspasia's best option as a metic in Athens after 451/450 could have been to become thepallake of a well-born Athenian, and this in fact seems to have been her fate. Cratinus' definition of Aspasia as a pallake in his comedy Cheirons (discussed in the next chapter) probably reflects her true status. The prospects for any children whom Aspasia might have borne to Pericles were indeed mixed. No daughters are attested for either party. This silence is itself unremarkable, inasmuch as daughters tended to be mentioned only with regard to their parentage, husbands, or children. If, in fact, Aspasia ever bore a daughter, she might have been exposed or removed in some other manner; if she lived to adulthood, she might have been consigned quietly to pallakia or married to another metic.20 Evidence suggests, but does not prove, that Pericles junior was Aspasia's son or at least the son of a free woman. Perhaps the increasingly negative remarks found in comedy about Pericles junior reflect a diminishing status for all nothoi in the late fifth century, as well as the disappearance of protection upon the death of his father; perhaps they are purely personal attacks indicating the son's perceived failure to measure up to his illustrious parent. His unhappy fate as one of the generals condemned and executed after the battle of Arginusae surely was not affected by his parentage. (Comedy is discussed in the next chapter; the comic tag Nothippos probably reflects the inferior status of this group.)21 So much for the possibilities of offspring of Aspasia. I turn now to Aspasia's years with Pericles, the terminus for which relationship has traditionally been set with the latter's death in 429. References made by comic writers to their relationship are impossible to put into an exact sequence, but they do suggest a period of some eleven to thirteen years—that is, from the Samian War to 430 B.C.—in which she was publicly recognized as Pericles' mate. Later tradition has dwelt on Aspasia's intellectual acumen, her political influence upon Pericles, and his love for her, but no evidence established as contemporary illuminates these possibilities. Plutarch mentions one more specific incident regarding Aspasia's life. The comic poet Hermippus supposedly prosecuted her on the charge of asebeia (impiety). Scholarly opinion is divided as to whether the suit actually took place or whether, like Philocleon's prosecution of the cheese-pilfering dog Labes in Aristophanes' Wasps, it was a purely imaginary trial, conducted on the comic stage and later insinuated into the historical record. The exact nature of the prosecution and the precise
16
Prisoner of History
meaning of asebeia are also hotly debated. It is most likely that if Aspasia was literally tried in court, it was in order to discredit Pericles. Belief is based on the notion that Aspasia's influence upon Pericles and/ or others was, or was perceived to be, of an actionable nature, and that Pericles was attached enough to Aspasia to defend her, as Plutarch reports, with a singular display of public weeping. As an analysis of comedy will show, this trial was most probably a dramatic fantasy.22 The rapidity with which Aspasia apparently entered a union with Lysicles after Pericles' death invites several explanations. First, her relationship with Pericles may have terminated some time before his death; the alliance with Lysicles might have been far from hasty. Pericles could have tired of her, for comedy reports other sexual interests besides Aspasia.23 Widows, and presumably relict concubines, were "remarried" as soon as possible; thus, if Aspasia's union with Pericles lasted until the latter's death, her subsequent union with Lysicles might have been entirely proper.24 It is also possible that the continued presence of Pericles' "relict" was a liability to his remaining family, particularly in the gloomy days of plague-ridden Athens. Thucydides tersely and movingly tells of the plague's effects on the city's social fabric, and Xenophon shows how quickly and devastatingly female dependents in an aristocratic household could become a financial liability during hard times (see Thuc. 2.47-2.54; Xen. Mem. 2.7; Dem. 57.45). Pericles lost most of his relatives to the plague (Plut. Per. 36); presumably, the surviving females would have been more dependent than ever before. The orators paint a portrait of close and affectionate relations between Athenian mothers and their sons, but this may reflect ideals rather than realities. Aspasia and Pericles junior were no ordinary dyad: the mother may have been an embarrassment to her son, so recently and extraordinarily franchised. As a nothos, Pericles junior was exempted from the legal requirement of supporting his parents in their old age. A son whose irregular parentage would dog him most of his life and who was only adopted after his legitimate stepbrothers had died might have found it politic to settle his mother elsewhere.25 Perhaps there was a positive side to Aspasia's alleged union in middle age with the sheepdealer Lysicles. He was a prominent politician and she might have been able to enhance his political fortunes. How this union came about, if it did, is open to question. There is some evidence that a lone woman could occasionally act on her own behalf, as Me-
Aspasia in Greek History
17
nander says, "heautes kyria" ("as her own kyrios"; Men. Pk. 497); Aspasia may have chosen Lysicles herself. If the citizenship law was in effect at the time of this union, it cannot be entirely correct to term her union with Lysicles a marriage, as late commentators describe it. In any event, Lysicles' death in 428 cuts off our possibility for knowing anything about this union,26 if it was in fact historical. A portrait herm found in Italy in 1777 and inscribed at the base ACIIACIA may have been copied from her grave (Figure 1.1). A rather solemn female head with the melon coiffure is depicted on this 1.7meter-high monument. Although there is no ancient testimony for portraits of Aspasia, the eyes and hair can be traced to fifth-century types, as Gisela Richter argues in making her case for the statue's authenticity. More puzzling to Richter is the fact that Aspasia was rendered as a "simple, expressionless woman" who nonetheless had "a certain beauty." Indeed, no physical description of Aspasia has survived, and she may have been quite ordinary in appearance. Richter, assuming (as had Wilamowitz) that Aspasia "geistig etwas mehr bedeutete," suggests that "Aspasia's extraordinary attraction lay in her animated expression, which the sculptor of the herm was not able to convey." If the herm was copied from an actual grave stele, however, this alone could explain the solemnity of the head's expression, for late fifth-century funerary art depicted the deceased with serene solemnity. Additionally, those who set up her monument may have been attempting to counter such labels as the Cratinan pallaken kynopida (dog-eyed concubine) and the Eupolidean/wrae (whore; literally, "buyable woman"). A "simple, expressionless woman" would have been the family grave's quiet answer to such insults. The possibility that her kin needed to make such a visual statement underscores again the impropriety of naming Aspasia a "female Socrates"; his portraiture is rich in Silenus and sage types. The pensive and virginal maiden of the stele denies the literary reputation of the woman to whom Socrates brought people for instruction, who kept a brothel, instigated wars, and taught rhetoric to Socrates and Pericles. In her study of the Severe Style, Ridgway provides a different interpretation, defining it as a classicizing portrait of a type called "Aspasia/Sosandra." The original, of which many copies besides this herm are known, was Calamis the Elder's fifth-century statue of Aphrodite Sosandra, dedicated by Callias on the Acropolis.27 Although Diodorus of Athens may have seen her grave and noted it in his treatise on funeral monuments, we do not know when or where Aspasia died.28
18
Prisoner of History
Figure 1.1. Marble portrait herm, Aspasia. Vatican Museums inv. 272. Courtesy Vatican Museums.
2 The Story Told by Comedy
Attic comedy, a genre full of commentary about politics, provides the only known contemporary evidence for Aspasia's life. Old Comedy, as this earliest attested phase of Greek comedy is known, is paramount to Aspasia's biographical tradition: though frequently surreal and fantastic, it was nonetheless treated as a historical source by later ancient historians such as Duris and Plutarch. Comedy is also the premier nexus of discourses on sexuality, power, and intellect in the fifth century, discourses to which Aspasia is crucial. Unfortunately, only eleven of Aristophanes' plays have survived intact, and the fragmentary remains of the rest of Old Comedy are exceedingly difficult to date. To correlate undated and/or undatable fragments by their references to the supposed life events of public figures is nearly impossible, for oftentimes these references constitute the only surviving mention of said event. It is easier, therefore, to discuss the treatment of Aspasia in Old Comedy on a playwright-by-playwright basis, beginning with the best-known authors and those whose references to Aspasia are the most significant. Although Attic comedy made Aspasia a public figure, it treats her very differently than it does men. For example, Aspasia, unlike many Athenian men (Solon, Miltiades, Pericles, Socrates et al.) was apparently never put on stage in propria persona. Furthermore, comic allusions to Aspasia are invariably sexual, sexualized, and sexualizing; well-known males receive a broader spectrum of comment than she does. Pericles' sexual integrity was attacked by the poets, but so were his oratorical skills, physical appearance, and political views. The latter attributes could be mentioned without reference to his sexuality.1 19
20
Prisoner of History
Cratinus Cratinus can be considered the founder of political comedy as we know it. His work, rife with topicality and inventive invective, set the tone for subsequent comic treatments of both Pericles and Aspasia. Aristophanes, Cratinus' rival and younger contemporary, was probably more in his elder's debt than we can know. 2 Cratinus is known to have attacked Aspasia in only one play, the Cheirons (frags. 246-268 K-A). The dating of the comedy is problematic; it has been assigned both to the very late 440s—when Pericles became the most powerful man in Athens after the ostracism in 443 of Thucydides, son of Melesias—as well as to around 430, near the beginning of the Peloponnesian War. In either case, this golden age nostalgia drama invidiously contrasts the corrupt life of the time of its writing with the sweet simplicity of the past, and reflects anxieties about Pericles' power and hostility to Aspasia. The violent language Cratinus uses of Aspasia and Pericles certainly represents a strong reaction to some aspect of Pericles' regime.3 Golden age comedies were characterized either by a total absence of women or by a purely subordinate position for them as providers of sexual gratification. The Cheirons is full of epic language and parodies of that language.4 Solon was brought back from the dead as a reminder of the "happy" past and pointed out the populace's moral failures; interestingly, fourthcentury comedy would credit Solon with having founded statesubsidized brothels.5 Salient to the present discussion are Cheirons frag. 258 and 259 K-A, considered on the grounds of meter and sense to be part of theparabasis, that part of the comedy wherein the chorus often spoke the poet's mind and delivered advice to the city. Thus, the lines are attributable to a group, not to a character, and need not have referred to any event or events within the play. Perhaps neither Pericles nor Aspasia appeared on stage in this play, because their mention here was probably part of the chorus' recitation of events that had brought Athens to her present parlous condition.6 Stasis and elderborn Time, mating with one another birthed a very great tyrant whom the gods call "head-gatherer." (258 K-A) Shameless Lust bears him Hera-Aspasia, a dog-eyed concubine (259 K-A)
The Story Told by Comedy
21
Long-standing instability in the state, that is, Chronos (time) and Stasis (civic strife), have bred a monster in the form of Pericles, who is parodied by reference to his large head (cf. the common Homeric epithet "Cloud-Gatherer," used for Zeus). The abuse of Pericles, both anatomical and political, is combined neatly in his identification as the despotic offspring of abstract personifications. Stasis, the feminine abstraction identified as Pericles' mother, is semantically associated in fifth-century historiography and tragedy with women and anandreia (unmanliness).7 The gods deflate Pericles with an undignified mock-epic epithet. Next, katapygosyne ("shameless lust") bore him the dog-eyed concubine Hera-Aspasia. Aspasia is given an actual Homeric tag, but it is not a complimentary one, for it associates her with both the shrewish Hera and the ruinous Pandora. Hephaestus calls his mother "dog-eyed" (//. 18.396); Hesiod's Pandora has a dog's mind and a thief's character (Works and Days 67). Katapygosyne, which really cannot be translated, is a highly abusive word probably coined by Cratinus; it refers not only to the general notion of shameless lust but also to "pathic" practice; Aspasia seems to be the first and only female to be associated with the noun abstract of the word, an association that makes her even more monstrous.8 By identifying Aspasia as apallake, Cratinus suggests not only that she lacks the right to rule with her "Zeus," but also that she is unable to properly transmit his legacy. I believe that the reference pointedly marks the actual type of "marriage" Aspasia had with Pericles and comments on its legally and socially inferior nature; concubinage was, as has been shown, a union whose issue could not claim a place in the polis or the family.9 The Cheirons is paradigmatic of Old Comedy's critique of women vis-a-vis political power. According to this critique, women could not govern the polis; their attempts to do so, especially as would be seen in Arisophanes' Lysistrata and Ecclesiazusae, must always be considered an inversion and mockery of the norm; the possibility of their doing so, even when represented as fantasy, indicates a severe crisis in the polis. The importance to this theme of politicians' association with women of ill repute cannot be stressed enough; Aristophanes would make "loose women" the symbols of destruction, death, and intellectual and literary corruption. Cheirons frag. 258-259 K-A demonstrates that there was no natural place for women in the state, that they were believed to serve their lovers rather than the state, and that they could neither inherit nor transmit their lovers' political capital.10
22
Prisoner of History
It would be wonderful to have other Cratinan invective against Aspasia, but nothing conclusive survives. His mythological burlesque Dionysalexandros may revile Pericles, who is likened to both Paris and Dionysus, for having started a war. All that can be said is that the play shows that a politician's irregular sexual behavior has political consequences. If Pericles was Paris, Aspasia might have been seen as Helen— sexually alluring and the cause of a great war. The report that Eupolis, Cratinus' younger contemporary, and occasional plagiarist, called Aspasia "Helen" (Prospaltians 267 K-A) may mean that Eupolis copied or modified a Cratinan epithet.11 Cratinus' Nemesis alludes not only to the Trojan War and to Helen, but also to Pericles' dominance in Athens (118 K-A, assuming that the mention of Zeus refers to Pericles), and it is generally thought that Pericles appeared on stage as a character. The fact that Leda is told to incubate her egg (115 K-A) opens the possibility that Aspasia was also put on stage. The Nemesis may implicate Pericles in the outbreak of the Peloponnesian War. But ever since Kaibel, the difficulties of locating Aspasia within the plot have been abundantly apparent. Nemesis herself has been seen as Aspasia and Helen as Pericles junior; the egg has been seen as the Megarian decree or even as the war itself. It can only be said that the political result of bad politics was probably represented comedically as a monstrous birth.12 Without more fragments, it is impossible to say more about this play. If indeed the Nemesis likens Pericles to Zeus, some common threads can be seen in that play and the Cheirons and Dionysalexandros: Cratinus represents Pericles as a man whose irregular domestic life produces "unnatural" results—either tyranny and a concubine co-tyrant (as in the Cheirons), a war (as in the Dionysalexandros), or an improperly engendered egg that may represent war or its prelude (as in the Nemesis). In Cheirons and Dionysalexandros, the playwright stresses the political consequence of the statesman's irregular behavior; in Cheirons and Nemesis, the political result of bad politics is itself represented as a monstrous birth.13
Eupolis Eupolis, a younger contemporary of Aristophanes and Cratinus, mentions Aspasia by name in three comedies and probably alludes to her in a fourth.14 Aspasia is mentioned in his first play, the wartime Prospal-
The Story Told by Comedy
23
tians, as "Helen." But all that can be said of this is that Helen and Aspasia were both accused of sexual impropriety and were alleged to have started wars.15 The plot of the Philoi, which was produced just a few years later at the 424/423 B.C. Dionysia, is also obscure, nor can the one fragment, in which Aspasia is called Omphale tyrannon or Omphaletyrannon, be integrated with the rest of the play. Omphale sexually dominated Heracles, whose earlier cultural image as harddrinking beast master and womanizer was now being sanitized and assimilated to an icon of temperate masculine virtue.16 The play also seems to have had pederastic and sympotic themes, and reviled Rhodia, wife of the Athenian Lykon.17 The Marikas has attracted much critical attention though little is known of its plot. Produced at the festival of the Lenaia in 421, it vanquished the first version of Aristophanes' Clouds. In the second, surviving version of the Clouds, Aristophanes accuses Eupolis of having plagiarized parts of the Marikas play from his own Knights (Clouds 553-555). In the Marikas, the politician Hyperbolus was satirized as the barbarian slave whose name gives the play its title; the chorus was a double one. That there was considerable topical humor is evident from the mentions of the Spartans, Cleon, and Nicias.18 All the more frustrating, then, is the poor preservation of fragment 192, in which "the bastard," Aspasia, and Paralus are all mentioned in the space of three lines (lines 166-169).19 Little can be gained from this except to note that Paralus, and probably Pericles' other legitimate son, Xanthippus, are both named along with Pericles junior, who is perhaps called Aspasia's bastard here. The mention of all of Pericles' sons and identification of one of them as a bastard borne by Aspasia is the third time Aspasia is insulted by name in the comic fragments.20 She was probably singled out for the sake of criticizing the nothos, Pericles junior; at the time of the Marikas' composition, Paralus and Xanthippus would have been dead nearly a decade and the nothos would have been about twenty years old. Why any of them is remarked on here cannot be ascertained, but the comic poets commonly insulted politicians by referring unflatteringly to their mothers. Although Eupolis' exploitation of the mother-son relationship is not unique, he may have been the first to mention Aspasia's motherhood on the stage.21 Eupolis' last play, the Demes (411 B.C.), is, like Aristophanes' more famous Frogs, a catabatic quest for civic salvation. In it Solon, Mil-
24
Prisoner of History
tiades, Aristides, and Pericles are brought back from the dead in order to advise the city, although it is difficult to say more than this about the plot. Aspasia and Pericles junior are mentioned, and Pericles' plaintive query, "And is my nothos alive?" (110 K-A) shows that Pericles himself was a speaking character. The mention here of the bastard and of Pericles' head elsewhere in the Demes (115 K-A) were very old jokes by now; probably these threadbare jests facilitated the recognition of Pericles, who had now been dead for more than fifteen years. The reply to Pericles' question—that the nothos was indeed alive but ashamed of having a porne for a mother (110 K-A)—suggests that after Pericles' death, Aspasia was mentioned with increasing harshness. In the earlier Prospaltians and Philoi, Eupolis had referred to her in mythological travesty and also made references to her sexual allure; he identified her as the mother of a bastard in his mid-career play, Marikas, and called her an outright whore in a play from his later years, Demes, which last reference is the final certain one to her in Old Comedy. The label was resoundingly negative and referred only to her inferior sexual status. The general view of Pericles in this play was probably positive, judging from its fulsome praise of his oratory.22
Hermippus Hermippus was less important in his own day and to posterity than were Cratinus, Eupolis, and Aristophanes, but he merits special attention in the development of Aspasia's bios; according to Plutarch, it was he who prosecuted Aspasia for asebeia (Plut. Per. 32.1).23 He also is said to have accused Aspasia of ensnaring free women for Pericles to dally with (Plut. Per. 32.1), a charge also leveled, without a named accuser, against Phidias (Plut. Per. 13.14). Again, the questions of the historicity of these charges, of whether or not Hermippus prosecuted Aspasia in a fantasy trial on stage or in his actual right as a citizen, cannot be decided conclusively. Certainly a good many accusations against Pericles are those of sexual and political impropriety; accusations of sexual excess, in which Pericles' associates were said to have pimped citizen women for him, may have inspired Aristophanes, and later, Eupolis, to call Aspasia a whore and to imply that she kept other women. These allegations attributed to Pericles a personal behavior somewhat counter to the purpose and spirit of his own citizenship law, and if true, intimated that
The Story Told by Comedy
25
in the matter of sexual appetite, Pericles, like other popular politicians late and soon, felt himself above or beyond the law. Hermippus' dialogue could be markedly abusive: in the Artopolides (Breadsellers), someone addresses a woman as ' 'O sapra, kaipasiporne, kai kapraina'' ("O decayed one, and all-whore, and she-goat").24
Aristophanes Aristophanes (457/445-385 B.C.) offers especially rich ground for an investigation of Aspasia's bios, even though he mentioned Aspasia only once in his extant oeuvre (Acharnians, produced at the Lenaia in 425 B.C.). Because eleven of his plays do survive whole, it is possible to discuss Aristophanes' thematic and symbolic uses and definitions of women and gender, to speculate upon the poet's views concerning the relationship of women to the state, and lastly, to discuss his use of female characters as part of the opsis (visual aspect) of Old Comedy. In the reference to Aspasia and in references to other women, we are able also to see the contexts in which real females, as particularities, were used dramatically. Thus the Acharnians, in which the protagonist, Dikaeopolis, concludes a private peace with the Spartans and vanquishes those who would continue to make war, is vital for helping us see in what ways the comic Aspasia, mentioned elsewhere in fragments bereft of a context, might have functioned in those other plays.25 Aristophanes' Acharnians contains a significant reference to Aspasia. Dikaeopolis tells the chorus and audience about the causes of the war: Men from our side—I'm not saying the polis—remember this, I'm not saying the polis, but worthless pipsqueaks, phonies, dishonorable counterfeits, halfbreeds, began to denounce Megara's little cloaks. And if anybody saw a gourd or a hare or a piglet or a garlic or some rocksalt— these were "Megarian" and sold off that same day! Still, this was a minor matter, and not unexpected. But, then some young drunks went to Megara and stole the whore Simaitha. Well, the Megarians were driven crazy by this insult and stole in return two whores from Aspasia. From this began the Great War in all Hellas—from three cock-sucking sluts. (Ach. 516-539)
This little passage has given rise to the immense problem of whether or not the theft was historical. In addition the literary problem of this passage's relationship to the beginning of Herodotus' History, which it
26
Prisoner of History
probably parodies, is not insignificant. Opinions range from Walter Ameling's and Donald Kagan's views that the reference to Aspasia's whores is pure fantasy and a comic topos to a nearly literal "if there's smoke" view. David Sansone's well-argued position that the passage indeed parodies Hdt. 1.1-4 need not vitiate more literal interpretations. Douglas MacDowell suggests that Pericles did have nonpolitical reasons, perhaps even connected with Aspasia, for enacting the Megarian embargo. He argues cogently for a political interpretation of the play that identifies Dikaeopolis' aims with the audience's own and that makes a serious bid for peace, but fails to convincingly show what the nature of Pericles' and/or Aspasia's animus against the Megarians might have been.26 This is no place to settle the problems regarding the Megarian decree. One can but observe that Aspasia's alleged responsibility for the outbreak of the Peloponnesian War sounds suspiciously like the charge attributed to Duris that she was responsible for the Samian War.27 I believe that the accusation is fictional and groundless. Cratinus had already given Aspasia a vicious genealogy, making her a monstrous, illegitimate, shameless, and tyrannical partner for Pericles; he had also associated her with Paris/Pericles, a warmonger, and had identified her with the temptresses Omphale and Helen. Hermippus had called her a procuress and impious. Thus, she had already been attacked—with Pericles—as an abuser of power and in ways that impugned her sexuality and in language that was also couched in parody. Therefore, in a period when it was popular to parody Herodotus, it would have been easy for Aristophanes to weave into his tale of the abduction of women the additional insult that Aspasia was a fellatrix and a procuress. Aristophanes' definition of the activities that led up to the outbreak of war as the deeds of laikastriai (fellatrices) was an extremely coarse and insulting one.28 Aspasia is implicitly a whore and explicitly a fellatrix, a laikastria. Placed finally and emphatically in the period, the word laikastriai situated Aspasia, and by association, Pericles, in disreputable company. As a way of describing her putative association with Athenian politics, it was an insult as grave as any hurled at other public figures in comedy. For Aspasia to be mentioned as a pimp, a fellatrix, and precipitator of a disastrous war was humorous only in the bleakest possible sense. Once she is defined as the keeper of whores, Aspasia is a woman near the center of government who controls men's access to women and whose displeasure could bring on war; at the end of the play,
The Story Told by Comedy
27
order is restored, and Dikaeopolis revels with two whores (Ach. lines 1199 to the end).29 Similarly, Aristophanes' Peace (421) represents Peace both metaphorically as the resumption of men's unlimited access to food and sexual relations, and concretely as a lovely and penetrable virgin. In that play, wherein women are never a threat and seem to be present only to be penetrated by males, Aristophanes again mentioned Pericles, the beginning of the war, and the Megarian decree, but he did not mention Aspasia.30 Aristophanes' abuse of Aspasia in the Acharnians accords with his abuse elsewhere of the female sexual partners of other male politicians. It is possible to compare the treatment Aspasia is given in the first extant play with that of other women associated with politicians in other, complete Aristophanic plays, and to speculate on the function that other references performed in plays now fragmentary fulfilled. Paphlagon, in the Knights (424 B.C.), prays to Athena to confirm that he—after Lysicles and the prostitutes Kynna and Salabaccho—has been the "best man'' and has given the greatest benefit to the demos (Kn. 763-766; note that Kynna and Salabaccho are masculinized here). Lysicles, supposedly Aspasia's mate after the death of Pericles, is here also associated with whores. But the parabasis of Wasps (422 B.C.) and its nearverbatim repetition in Peace, demonstrate the most compelling association of politicians with prostitutes. The chorus defend Aristophanes to the audience: Nor, when he began to produce plays, did he attack men, but rather, with the anger of Heracles, he beset the greatest targets: immediately he screwed up his courage against the jagged-toothed Cleon, from whose eyes beams the looks of Kynna the whore, and whose head is encircled with the tongues of one hundred sycophants, deadly torrents of voice, the stench of a seal, the unwashed testicles of a Lamia, and the asshole of a camel. (1029-1035)
The playwright has attacked not ordinary men (1029) but the greatest of them, the jagged-toothed monster (teras), Cleon. Particularly odd here is the assignment of testicles to the traditionally female monster, Lamia, but here, as in other comic slurs, bad politics is rendered visible as an ugly, misshapen hybrid. Aristophanes' monster elaborately recapitulates Cratinus' genealogy for the "headgatherer" and his tyrannous concubine. Further evidence for this comedic association can be found in the earlier statement by the poet Callias (in his Pedetai) that Aspasia
28
Prisoner of History
taught Pericles how to speak. That statement is the antecedent for Aristophanes' claims that Cleon sees with Kynna's eyes: just so, Pericles speaks with Aspasia's tongue.31 That politicians and prostitutes are interchangeable is also implicit in a statement in Aristophanes' Thesmophoriazousae (411 B.C.), wherein the chorus declares that Cleophon is no worse than Salabaccho (line 805). The image of Aspasia concocted by comedy retains its potency. So great has been its power that it may now seem heterodox to claim that Aspasia, perhaps a mere war refugee placed in concubinage with an important politician, was unable to avoid colliding with Greek comedy's misogynist scenario and being recast as a pome and procuress. This scenario could not have told the truth about her even if it wanted to. The absence of good historical evidence to the contrary leaves this investigator with the indelible impression, exaggerated as I suspect it to be, of a prostitute near the inner circle of power. The power of comedy to construct Aspasia can be seen in the next stage of her bios, when philosophical dialogue, indebted to both tragedy and comedy, further developed the image of an erotically alluring and intellectually formidable woman among men.
3 Aspasia and the Socratic Tradition
The decline of Athens after the end of the Peloponnesian War would see the demise of tragedy as a viable art form and the movement of comedy from its major bases of surrealism and sexualized political invective to a greater focus on domestic drama and mythological travesty. The nascent form of philosophical dialogue adopted motifs from both tragedy and comedy in its use of historical and mythological characters to articulate and argue its own generic points of view. Many such dialogues were set in the heyday of Athens' greatness; therefore, some of the same individuals who were historical actors and comic butts in the fifth century reappeared as participants in philosophical discourse. The Socratic dialogues of the fourth century, the next locus of Aspasia's bios, took up the comic claim that Pericles spoke with Aspasia's tongue. The function of female characters in Greek drama has been thoroughly, though certainly not definitively, discussed by many scholars; but study of the function of female characters in philosophical discourse and the intersection of these characters with philosophical definitions of femaleness and femininity is rather new terrain. In the fourth century, Aspasia's biographical tradition becomes centrally entwined with these dialogic discussions of politics, sexuality, and gender, and it may be central to them. These conversations have a particularly Athenian cast, however, in that philosophical discourse almost exclusively represents male discussants engaged in an examination of the good life as lived in a community dominated by men. Perhaps philosophical discourse's long neglect of feminist concerns is due both to philosophy's self-validating claim to objectivity, which functions as a 29
30
Prisoner of History
protective bubble, and also to the Western philosophical establishment's traditional restriction to men of its practice, teaching, and self-analysis.1 These new dimensions of Aspasia's biographical tradition maintain the earlier concerns found in comedy and the historical record about the relationship of gender and sexuality to citizenship, civic participation, and moral health. The contribution that philosophical discourse makes to Aspasia's bios elevates these concerns only to dismiss them. In comedy, Aspasia had been used to discredit the historical actor Pericles; in some of the Socratica (in particular, Plato's Menexenus) Aspasia remains a site for the reinscription of Athenian history. It can even be said that she is a phallic woman.2 The use of Aspasia's name, the creation of a persona or personae for her in this very masculinist discourse, and the representations of her speech all require special attention. Aspasia does not appear in any dialogue as a character in her own right, although two dialogues bore her name. The important exception, however, is Plato's Menexenus. It is made up almost entirely of a speech recited by Socrates but which Aspasia allegedly taught him. It is necessary to ask what kind of personae were constructed for Aspasia and what functions the personae performed in each dialogue, and to ascertain the metaphorical dimensions of the speech "she" was given. The language of sexual reproduction and of feminine and masculine social roles looms large in these dialogues. Because the Socratic contributors to Aspasia's bios were reacting largely to ideas first put forth in Old Comedy, it is possible to discuss their treatment of her thematically, rather than chronologically; the latter approach is, in any case, not totally possible.3 The contributions of philosophical dialogue to Aspasia's biographical tradition can be schematized into two components: a negative developmental strand, represented by Antisthenes and Plato, and a positive one, with Aeschines of Sphettos and Xenophon as its representatives. The negative aspects of the tradition resemble the invective already seen in comedy.
Antisthenes Antisthenes (fl. ca. 445 B.C.-360 B.C.), a fascinating and curious figure, was the only follower of Socrates who did not become part of the Socratic diaspora. In the turmoil that followed the end of the Peloponne-
Aspasia and the Socratic Tradition
31
sian War, it was probably "unimportance rather than acceptability" that helped him avoid Socrates' fate.4 Like Pericles junior, he was a nothos with a foreign mother. If nothoi did form a sociocultural subset, then Antisthenes and Pericles junior probably knew each other. Disfranchised from birth by the law of 451/450 B.C., Antisthenes may have become an Athenian citizen through his own efforts and those of Callias.5 H. D. Rankin recently speculated that "we may ask whether Antisthenes' ridicule of Pericles and Alcibiades was not to some extent nourished by his annoyance at the privileges granted to their family in the matter of citizenship." Rankin saw personal jealousy as the motivation for Antisthenes' "ferocious attacks" against Xanthippus and Paralus in his Aspasia. Rankin believes an additional factor in this dislike of Pericles and his family was Socrates' own anti-Periclean bent as evidenced in Plato's Gorgias and Protagoras.6 This somewhat tenuous evidence for Antisthenes' thought can be bolstered by such sayings attributed to Antisthenes as the claim that one should esteem an honest man above a kinsman (D.L. 6.12) and that nobility belongs to the virtuous (D.L. 6.10-11). Antisthenes composed ten volumes of works. Some are apparently philosophical dialogues titled with the names of historical personages; the Aspasia and the Cyrus, or, On Kingship are the only known works in volume 5. He is considered to be a founder of the Cynics, perhaps because of his presence at the Kynosarges gymnasium (a meeting place for nothoi) and also because of his bitter outlook.7 Apparently devoted to robust hardihood, Antisthenes disregarded feminine beauty and luxury. He was particularly interested in the pursuit of arete (virtue), which he stated was the same for women and men.8 Antisthenes made light of the Athenian claim to autochthony, a predominant theme of Plato's Menexenus, by stating that locusts and snails could also be called children of Attic soil and that he himself wouldn't have behaved so courageously at the battle of Tanagra had his parents both been Athenian (D.L. 6.1).9 Unfortunately, we lack any record of Antisthenean attacks on Pericles junior, whose extraordinary enfranchisement would have created an obvious target. In his Aspasia, however, Antisthenes roundly abuses other members of Pericles' family. The date of the Aspasia is not known, but it is generally thought to have preceded Aeschines' dialogue of the same name.10 Little can be said about the focus of the dialogue and to what extent Aspasia's own character was discussed, although it is
32
Prisoner of History
universally accepted that she was unfavorably represented—as Ehlers puts it, to Antisthenes, Aspasia was the very embodiment of pleasure, of hedone. All of the fragments relevant to Aspasia refer to her sexuality and/or relationship with Pericles.11 The fragments show a definite continuity with comedic invective. Xanthippus and Paralus are both accused of' 'homosexuality of a squalid kind," as Rankin says; one son is accused of living with a male prostitute of the lowest sort; the other, of a long-term liaison with the vulgarian Euphemus (frag. 34 Caizzi = Ath. 5.220d). If Halperin is correct to claim that the "democratic body" was figured as the body of a male citizen, then this species of insult is peculiarly appropriate. It attacks the sexuality and thereby the integrity of Pericles' male kin. Pericles is also here accused of having had sexual relations with Cimon's sister, Elpinike. Furthermore, Antisthenes attacked Alcibiades in his book on Cyrus (frag. 29a Caizzi = Ath. 5.220c) for having had intercourse, Persian fashion, with his mother and sister.12 Other remnants of Antisthenes' thought suggest how and/or why he treated Aspasia so unfavorably. As Rankin says, much of the evidence for Antisthenes' thought is gleaned from "interesting traces in the surviving fragments." He extolled autarkeia (self-sufficiency), and Pericles' excessive love for Aspasia would have demonstrated the statesman's failure to practice this prized virtue. Antisthenes was no moral relativist (frags. 22, 23, 72, 73 Caizzi) and thus may have opposed the inherently relativistic view, attributed to Aspasia by Aeschines and Xenophon, that erotic experience with another person could lead one to arete. Additionally, Antisthenes might have been unable to accept active female subjectivity of the kind that Aeschines and Xenophon would positively attribute to Aspasia and with which comedy had negatively endowed her. In his Choice of Heracles, in a manner similar to Prodicus', he represented the feminized abstractions Arete and Kakia (virtue and vice) as the objects of man's quests. There was no female subject.13
Plato Plato (427-347 B.C.) has dominated the other Socratics, and the fact that his Menexenus is the only one of three ancient dialogues concerned with Aspasia to survive in its entirety has skewed our understanding of her position in philosophical dialogue in ways that are difficult to appreciate
Aspasia and the Socratic Tradition
33
and describe. That Aspasia is the only provably historical woman to be accorded a speech in his entire corpus is significant and should be considered carefully; with the voice Plato gives her, Aspasia discredits her claims to advise the polis. His position on "the woman question" is far from settled, sometimes being claimed as a protofeminist position and at other times considered as wholly masculinist. If Plato knew Aspasia personally, it was when he was in his youth and she was in her middle or old age.14 His Menexenus, an early dialogue set in 386 B.C., features Socrates and the young Menexenus, who is evidently from a family of politicians (Menex. 234a4-234b2).15 In the opening frame (234al-236d3), the pair meet, and Menexenus tells the older man that the Boule has decided to choose a speaker to deliver an epitaphios, an oration performed in honor of the Athenian war dead (234b4—7). When Menexenus doubts that anyone could compose such a speech on short notice, Socrates remarks that Aspasia has recently recited to him just such a speech (235c6236cl). Of course, the younger man is gratefully willing to hear what she taught him, and Socrates recites the sample oration (236d4249c8).16 Aspasia's speech consists of both the epitaphios proper and a speech within a speech (246dl-248d6) wherein she tells the audience what the war dead advise their survivors to do and to feel. A second conversational interchange (249dl-e7) between Socrates and Menexenus provides the closing frame; the latter expresses gratitude and amazement, and Socrates promises to impart other political speeches (politikoi logof) that Aspasia has also recited to him. The Menexenus has been called a spurious dialogue, a genuine work of Plato that was an ironic joke, an exhortation to philosophy, and a completely serious praise of Athens—a true epitaphios—played straight.17 The present consensus is that although a genuine work of Plato, the Menexenus is nevertheless an ironic critique of the epitaphios and its objects of praise; but the target(s) of the critique and the manner(s) in which Plato effects the critique are much debated. In her brilliant study of the funeral oration, Nicole Loraux names the Menexenus as an important expression of Plato's political thought and as a pastiche more real than the speeches it mocks; the pastiche is both the most powerful of the political orations and an exorcism thereof—a kind of pharmakon. In parodying such epitaphian topoi as autochthony, the definition of who is an Athenian, and the transcendence of parenthood by the city, Plato exposes the hollowness of the epitaphian ideality.18
34
Prisoner of History
Despite her careful and brilliant explication, Loraux, like other commentators, stops short of considering the most significant question: Why is Aspasia made the author of the speech? In containing Aspasia within Socrates, Loraux not only fails to deal with Aspasia herself, but also replicates the Platonic strategies she so illuminatingly dissects: "Against the funeral oration, Plato sets up Socrates . . . " We may compare Bloedow's discussion of "Aspasia, who is of course identifiable with Perikles . . ."'9 Clearly, substitution, interchange, and interchangeability are important thematic and compositional facets of this dialogue. But we must take the observation further. If Plato sets up Aspasia to substitute for someone or something, what does this mean? How does he do this and what are its implications, particularly the implications of the fact that such a lengthy speech is attributed to the woman? It is necessary to analyze the importance of the fact that Aspasia is the speaker. What does it mean for this particular woman to author, and through Socrates to deliver, that particular politikos logos that articulates Athens' selfimage? Besides examining the essential question of how Aspasia functions in this dialogue, we must also pay careful attention to the relationship between certain themes in Old Comedy and certain themes of this epitaphios.20 The Menexenus displays many affinities with comedy and history. Ostensibly historical and "about history," it, as an epitaphios, shares some elements with comedy, in that the performance of the funeral oration occurred during a festival, or perhaps better, an antifestival.21 Making Aspasia author of this speech helped Plato underscore his critique of epitaphian topoi; he exploits not only her actual status as a foreigner, but also her location within Old comedy as a whore and a monstrous producer of the illegitimate. It is important to note that the comedic definition of Aspasia as a porne had rendered her an interchangeable commodity, a particular characteristic that highlights the general theme of interchangeability so important in the Menexenus.22 The term porne, which comedy had applied to Aspasia and to her alleged employees or slaves, literally made her a "buyable woman"; the prostitute, unlike a legitimate wife, was owed no obligation and could be interchanged with other women. Nor could she produce legitimate children. In view of Plato's disapproving presentation of the epitaphios as made up of words or mythologems that are interchangeable in respect to who speaks them (236c5-7, 249dl2-e2), about whom or what they are spoken (235d3-6), and the occasions on which they are spoken (e.g.,
Aspasia and the Socratic Tradition
35
Aspasia as synkollosa, "gluing together"; see 236b6), Plato's use of Aspasia as speaker, Aspasia who had been defined in the earlier public discourse of comedy as ultimately interchangeable and commodified, is a brilliant reversal that itself proves the interchangeability of one epitaphios with another and thus the genre's ultimate absurdity. The sign is proliferated until its literal meaning is lost; until it becomes utterly arbitrary.23 For an occasion that celebrates andreia (manly courage), Plato supplies the words of a woman, not a man; of a foreigner, not a citizen; of a whore, not a wife; of the parent of a bastard, not a citizen; of Aspasia. Surely the references to Aspasia's interchangeability with other speakers, which are made both before and after Socrates recites her speech (236c5-7, 249dl2-e2), emphasize that the choice of speaker ultimately does not matter. Surely Menexenus' declaration that Socrates makes Aspasia makaria (blessed) if she, a woman, can compose such speeches suggests that ability to give a politikos logos need not be accompanied by the manly courage so lauded in the epitaphios.24 Aspasia herself has made many of the nobles into speakers, and Pericles is but one of them (235e3-7). To call Pericles but one of the speakers instructed by Aspasia damages prior eulogizing of his singular oratorical skill. This tutelage is well known to Menexenus (235e8) even though Socrates has not yet named Aspasia (235e4, "there being a teacher"). Aspasia made speakers of many men. The fact that one is named, and that this one is a man with whom she had a sexual relationship, delicately suggests that she had sexual relationships with the others as well and that they all speak with words she taught them. The propensity of politicians to speak with the mouths of whores and to see with their eyes is a well-known charge of comedy; one need only recall the association of Cleon with Kynna (Wasps 1015-1035 and Peace 739759), and Callias' statement, in the Pedetai, that Aspasia taught Pericles to speak (*21 K-A). Significantly, a scholion to Menexenus 235e is the sole source for this last citation. Plato alludes to Aspasia's comic reputation as a whore in several comments, which include Menexenus' ambiguous "I've met her many times and know what she's like" (249d8-9). He knows what she's like, but what she's like is not specified—it does not need to be.25 We know everything, and nothing, about Aspasia. The implication of this "not telling" is that the male audience does not need to be told. Aspasia is her reputation, and her reputation is what men say it is. The real woman is
36
Prisoner of History
encapsulated within her reputation just as the dead are enclosed within their own reputations (doxa) and fame (eukleia) (247a6-7). Aspasia herself had alluded to future encounters with the youth of Athens as "whenever I encounter any of you " (246b7-cl); the verb for encounter, entynchanein, is a euphemism for sexual intercourse.26 She also refers to her past encounters with their progonoi (forefathers) in the context of reporting what these fathers would like said (246c2-4); she has heard them speak (246c4-6), and having associated with the fathers, knows what would please them. This all suggests scenarios wherein the fathers have conversed with Aspasia—conversations that she will communicate to their descendants. Socrates speaks for her; if Menexenus doesn't give him away, he will recite additional politikoi logoi that Aspasia taught him (249e3-5). What binds these men, then, is the ideality that they share through association with a foreign woman who is, by means of both the conversational aspect and the delicately submerged sexual aspect, "known" to them all. Thus, thepolitikos logos has a sexual tinge, and Athenian men are united with one another and with this logos by means of their association with a foreign woman. Aspasia and the speech she delivers unite the citizens of Athens across generations. Loraux discusses the importance to this epitaphios of the silenced but everpresent Other, which she identifies as the noncitizens. The presence of the foreign Other at the recitation of the epitaphios (Menex. 235b2-8) was "necessary to the city only so that the latter could admire itself in others' eyes.'' The late fifth and early fourth centuries witnessed zealous enforcement of the citizenship law, and the political climate of the early fourth century was therefore likely to have engendered scrutiny of the civic status of those connected with the production of the epitaphios.27 Another important source of civic anxiety and concern was boundary maintenance between citizen and noncitizen. A conservative trend after 403/402 is evidenced in legislation which required the legitimacy of war orphans for the purpose of allotting state subsidies and additionally demanded that public figures be legitimate. The reenactment of Pericles' citizenship law in 403/402 disfranchised some men and precluded the naturalization of others.28 Loraux posits that "the most general propensity of an ideological discourse is to conceal the internal divisions of a society . . ." and finds it significant that metics and slaves were ignored. To note merely that all women except Amazons were excluded, however, again avoids the question of why Aspasia, a metic and the mother of a bastard, authors this discourse.29
Aspasia and the Socratic Tradition
37
It seems more to the point to observe that women not only make up an essential component of the Other, but that the Other is here in fact, figured as a woman who speaks in order to define the civic Self. A real woman is erased and a constructed woman, "known" to us all but not described, speaks in her place. The Other's presence at such a central point in the composition and delivery of the epitaphios is a way of making absence present and presence, that is, relevance and validity, absent.30 Paradoxically, the quintessential outsider, Aspasia, delivers consolation and hope to the insiders. The epitaphios situates the listener in the Nesoi Makaron, the Isles of the Blessed (235c4), by letting Aspasia traverse the boundaries between the living and the dead and between insider and outsider; she takes her audience with her into "no place." Socrates puts it contrariwise when he states that these speakers can make you believe anything (especially at 234cl-235c5), as does Menexenus when he remarks that Aspasia is makaria (blessed) if she can deliver such a speech.31 That both Aspasia and Socrates must have been dead at the date of this dialogue is, of course, one of its often-noted paradoxes and one that cloaks the speech in falsity and hollowness. Socrates' confession that he feels he has been in the Islands of the Blessed when he has listened to an epitaphios (235c4), and the likelihood that Aspasia as well as he was dead at the dramatic date of the dialogue, additionally contribute to this sense of absence and "dead-ness." He describes his prospective recitation of Aspasia's speech with the verb ekpherein (236c4), a word that can mean to deliver or publish, but whose older and more literal meaning is to carry out, as of a corpse (cf. ekphora).32 To listen to this praise of the dead and to adhere to the precepts of the politikos logos requires the listener to deny the actual bodily death of the warriors. Plato's Socrates denies death by brilliantly evoking a trance, a deathlike state, in which his instructress claims that the dead achieve a new birth. Plato additionally brings about this trance by making Aspasia herself metonymize motherhood within earth and women within men, and by making her contain men themselves within the polis.33 Therefore, far from agreeing with Loraux that in the Menexenus the polis "seems to transcend the distinction between male and female," I believe that Plato reconstructs human parenthood by deemphasizing human motherhood.34 To make his case for autochthony and to deemphasize human motherhood, Plato uses a constructed woman, an Aspasia who equals her reputation, a woman whose own motherhood was,
38
Prisoner of History
according to public discourse, problematic for herself, her child, and the state. The Menexenus makes death the central fact of the warriors' existence. The dead are particularly praised because they are autochthones, born of a true mother (Earth) and living in their own land (237b2-c4). They were not migrants, nor were they reared by a metruia (a stepmother), but by their own mother, who has once more received them. This carefully worded "logic" defines the mother as the one who has received the dead and shares with Aeschylus' definition of parenthood in the Eumenides the suppression of human women's real roles.35 Motherhood is the particular property of ge (Earth), as seen in the use of the participle tekouses (having borne, 237c2), and it is most just to praise this mother (237c3). The part of ge that makes up Attica differs from the rest of Earth. The rest of Earth, "the whole earth," produced monsters—a process Aspasia describes in words not used exclusively or particularly of human parturition: he pasa ge anedidou kai ephye ("the whole earth gave forth and grew," 237d3—4). In contrast, she says of the Athenian portion of Earth, he hemetera . . . egennesen ("our [part of Earth] bore," 237d5-6); the verb (egennesen) immediately evokes the birth of human beings. That Earth nourished our ancestors and the ancestors' ancestors proves that she bore us (237el-5). This sentence and the next would seem to characterize the earth as female and maternal. Earth bears and, like a woman, provides suitable nourishment (237e3). Yet Plato unsexes Earth, even as he calls her "mother," by subsuming the planet in the category of "things that bring forth" through the use of the neuter participle to tekon (that which bears, 237e2-3).36 But the next part of Aspasia's speech is truly extraordinary. In its maternity, Earth is not like a human mother, but rather the other way around: ou gar ge gynaika memimetai kuesei kai gennesei, alia gyne gen ("For Earth does not imitate a woman in respect to conception and birth, but rather woman imitates Earth") (238a4-5). This speech act metonymizes women's abilities within Earth's ability. Aspasia's next claim, that humans, having been endowed by their uniqueness with the tools of learning, enjoy a special nourishment, again denies the physicality of human existence: "government is the nourishment of humans" (238cl). Other poleis, like other parts of Earth mentioned earlier, have populations of diverse origins, a heterogeneity that predisposes them to
Aspasia and the Socratic Tradition
39
having anomalous constitutions (particularly tyrannies and oligarchies, 238e3^4). This statement is truly ironic because at the end of the Peloponnesian War it was Athens that was beset by tyranny, oligarchy, and stasis. Athenians differ from other people because they are the children of one mother, and all are brothers (238e5-239al). There has been a unity of government since the beginning, and this is due to the citizens' equal birth (238el). Next, Aspasia gives a brief account of some aspects of Athens' mythical-historical past. She privileges the Marathonomachoi, the men who fought at Marathon, by stating that these men are not just the fathers of Athenians' bodies but also of their freedom (240d7-e3). This double paternity of the Marathonomachoi renders bodies and freedom parallel, just as Aspasia had made government and human sustenance parallel. She makes the men and their corporeal legacy of sons no longer wholly literal, just as she makes the spiritual legacy of freedom no longer wholly metaphorical. After reducing the Sicilian disaster to mere misfortune (edystychesan, "they suffered misfortune," 243a5), Aspasia declares that the Athenians were defeated only by themselves and that the ensuing stasis was mild because the Athenians are related to each other (243d7-244b3); this statement is acceptable because of Athens' superiority. As Loraux remarks, civil war becomes a fraternity.37 In a reprise of the language used to describe the wreck of the Sicilian campaign, Aspasia says the internal disarray at the end of the Peloponnesian War was caused not by echthra (enmity) but by dystychia (misfortune, 244a7-bl). Plato repeatedly injects sexually charged language into situations that are not necessarily sexual. In contrast to other poleis with inhabitants who were meixobarbaroi (245d4—5) Athens' status as homophylon ("one race," 244a2) allows its people to mix with each other again (synemeixan, 243e5). More use of this language also occurs when Athens is praised to a fault for being too kind (244el-245c6); the Athenians are too kind because they are "not mixed with barbarians" (amigeis barbaron, 245dl-2) and "we dwell unmixed with barbarians" (ou meixobarbaroi oikoumen, 245d4-5).38 Any pretense on the part of this speech and its speaker to render an objective account of the last one hundred years of Athenian history, including any claim to having analyzed the etiology of key events, is vitiated by the collapsing of categories in this account. Aspasia is herself
40
Prisoner of History
a collapsed category, who both suppresses the more unpleasant facts of Athens' military defeats and stasis and was herself accused in comedy of having helped to cause war.39 In her speech within a speech, Aspasia reports the exhortations of the dead ancestors, particularly stressing the importance of eukleia and doxa, together with that of arete (247a4-b7); it is unmitigated sophistry to ally virtue with its mere reputation. And, in a supremely anti-Socratic move, the war dead, speaking through Aspasia, declare that the life of one who has shamed his forebears—not the unexamined life—is abioton ("not worth living," 246d6). The fallen warriors encourage their own fathers and mothers to bear the loss lightly (247c5-7; cf. 248b4-6); fathers are fit parents if they manfully bear the loss of their sons (247d7e5). Care for the departed warriors' wives and young children is entrusted to surviving children (248c5-dl); care of the fathers and sons of the dead, however, is entrusted to the polis (248d2-5). In a renewed erasure of women from the process of human reproduction, it is now the city that shall rear the war orphans and that will be both a son and heir to the dead, as well as a guardian to the elders, always caring for them (249a3-c3). The polis now occupies all the important roles, those of guardian, son, heir, and father (esp. at249b3-c3). This "second birth," out of the polis, is a theme developed pointedly by Plato in the Laws (11.926d8ff). Only by dying in war can the male citizen be valorized and reborn.40 And Plato, who makes Aspasia speak through Socrates, constructed a world that consists only of Athenian men and the city. Plato's Aspasia is a free-floating phallic signifier who anticipates the construction of Diotima as a kind of Robot-Maria in the perfect male world of his Symposium. Diotima's speech, with its affirmation that males alone matter, is only credible in a thought-world awash in the autochtonous fantasy established here in the Menexenus. The character of Diotima is not a stand-in for the historical Aspasia; rather, Plato constructed both females in order to validate what Katz calls the "dream of a world without women."41
Aeschines of Sphettos Aeschines of Sphettos (fl. 4th c. B.C.), Plato's contemporary, seems to have been the first ancient writer to create an Aspasia in whom eras and
Aspasia and the Socratic Tradition
41
the search for arete are fused, and the first to have mentioned her in a positive light. To reconstruct his lost dialogue, Aspasia, from its refractions into various facets by later sources is a literary-historical problem of great magnitude. Aeschines' own bios (D.L. 2.60-64) is interesting and suggests conflict, real or imaginary, between himself and Plato. According to tradition, Plato resented and snubbed Aeschines, who, like Plato, had spent time at the Syracusan court (D.L. 2.60-62). It was additionally claimed that Xanthippe presented Socratic dialogues to Aeschines as a token of gratitude after Socrates' death, and that Aeschines passed these off as his own. This tradition of friendship between the great man's widow and his disciple makes Aeschines' relationship to Socrates and his family the opposite of Plato's portrayal of a Socrates emotionally estranged, and with good reason, from the doltish Xanthippe. Not altogether popular in his own day, Aeschines was the target of a hostile speech by Lysias, who called him a swindler, a deadbeat, and an adulterer who corrupted the wife of the perfume-seller Hermaeus.42 Although Aeschines has been overshadowed by Plato, his work enjoyed a time of high regard from the first century B.C. through the second century A.D., from which most citations of his Aspasia come. The dialogue, perhaps written as a reaction to Antisthenes' negative portrayal, has been persuasively reconstructed by Ehlers. As in the other Socratica in which her speech is reported, Aspasia herself does not appear; here, as in the Menexenus, she is quoted by Socrates. For the first and perhaps the only time in classical antiquity, the thought of "Aspasia" stands on its own—her speech is reported by a man, to be sure, but it is reported for its own sake and not primarily to attack or support a man. In fact, Aeschines may be said to have attempted to create a female subject.43 Aeschines' portrait of Aspasia seems to have differed radically from that seen in comedy, which had concentrated on her relationship with Pericles and on her motherhood. He may have transformed these negative treatments in a positive manner, making Aspasia independent of, if not actually in charge of, her lover(s). Ehlers believes that Aspasia was a hetaira (courtesan) in real life and was so represented in this dialogue, but that Aeschines muted the negative aspects of this status. I am not certain that it is possible for Aspasia to have been vividly or explicitly represented as a hetaira. If, as seems the case, Aeschines' dialogue purported that the wives of respectable men associated with
42
Prisoner of History
her, it is unlikely that Aspasia could have been represented as a courtesan.44 The Aspasia was composed between 393 and 384 B.C., but its dramatic date is between 420 and 410 B.C. In the dialogue, Socrates converses with the wealthy Callias, who has asked him to recommend a teacher for his son. Socrates recommends Aspasia, for she had taught him. Aeschines' departure from standard characterizations is evident in his treatments of both Aspasia and Callias. In comedy and in Plato's work, Callias' character exemplifies the sad fact that expensive instruction does not necessarily bring wisdom; here, however, Aeschines apparently presents Callias' quest for instruction for his son without irony. It must also be noted that the dramatic date of the dialogue makes Aspasia not an attractive young woman but an older one, whose erotic life was presumably over.45 At first, Socrates' recommendation would have seemed ironic, and Callias probably asks Socrates for Aspasia's qualifications. Socrates may have begun by citing other women who taught men or behaved in "masculine" ways. Rhodogyne, queen of Persia, was Amazonian and adept at politics. Nothing, not even her beauty—which Philostratus would later contrast with her bellicosity— got in the way of Rhodogyne's political duties. Ehlers states that Rhodogyne, representing a "negative Haltung zum Eros," was contrasted with Aspasia. The Ionian courtesan Thargelia was cited as another exceptional woman; Thargelia had evidently earned political influence over her male lover(s) by giving wise counsel. Both Rhodogyne and Thargelia functioned in the political realm but with important differences: Rhodogyne was motivated by love of her own land and by her inherited position, whereas Thargelia had moved from Ionia to Macedon as an independent agent. It is significant that although all three women were exceptional, none was a copy of the other; neither Rhodogyne nor Thargelia was directly compared with Aspasia, nor did the dialogue aim to demonstrate "the intellectual and moral capacities of women as a gender.' '46 Aspasia was the next exceptional woman to be named. It is quite possible that Aeschines presented Aspasia as a medial figure between the Amazonian Rhodogyne and the hypersexual Thargelia. Nowhere in any fragments ever assigned to this dialogue did Aeschines clearly indicate that Aspasia was a hetaira. Her valence is more that of the partner and wise woman than the enchantress. In diaeretic fashion, Socrates cited as examples two men who had profited from her teaching—their eminence would have flattered Callias. Far from being the focus of this
Aspasia and the Socratic Tradition
43
section of the dialogue, Pericles is used here as an example of Aspasia's skill as teacher. The story of Pericles' loss of composure at her trial may have indicated his political dependence on her as well as his devotion to her. Plut. Per. 24.5, possibly derived from Aeschines, suggests that both Pericles and Socrates were drawn to Aspasia because she was sophe (wise) and politike (politically astute). Ehlers believes that Aeschines recounted specific instances of Aspasia's actual influence over Pericles. One such example would have been her teaching of rhetoric to Pericles: he was clearly a star pupil.47 Oddly, Aspasia's relationship with Lysicles would have been more important to this dialogue than was her relationship with Pericles. Lysicles, an important Athenian politician of the 420s, is connected with Aspasia here for the first time in the datable testimonia; he was mentioned in this dialogue as even better evidence than Pericles of Aspasia's expertise. If she could make a success out of a mediocre man, then she was truly gifted.48 This dialogue probably did not mention that Aspasia bore Lysicles a son named Poristes ("provider/supplier"); the name is extraordinary, and Aspasia was probably too old to have borne Lysicles a child if their liaison began only after Pericles' death. It is likely that the word poristes was used of Aspasia herself in the dialogue and that something like tes rhetorikes ("of rhetorical skill") fell out of the text.49 After Aspasia's skill as a teacher of rhetoric was established, it remained to establish her usefulness as a teacher for Callias' son. Ehlers, who believes that Aspasia began her adult life as an actual hetaira, also seems to believe that Callias meant his son to receive both erotic and rhetorical instruction. The image of an older man sending his son to a woman for both is unprecedented; nonetheless, if we deny or cast doubt upon the possibility that Aspasia really was a hetaira, then we must explain what other kind of instruction she might provide a young man. It need not be necessary to assume that Aspasia's role was that of involved erotic pedagogue; in fact, nothing in her bios says she ever loved any man. The example of Xenophon and his wife, instructed by Aspasia, seems to have been adduced to show Aspasia's skill as a rhetorician, not as a lover. In fact, Cicero and Quintilian, who preserved this fragment, each cited it as an example of particularly fine argumentation. But it is clear that Aeschines' Aspasia here connects eros and arete. For example, as in Aeschines of Sphettos' dialogue, Socrates shows that Aspasia spoke with Xenophon's wife and Xenophon himself:
44
Prisoner of History "Tell me, please, wife of Xenophon, if your neighbor had a better piece of gold jewelry than you, would you prefer hers or your own?" "Hers," said the wife. "So—if she should have a dress or other feminine ornament more expensive than what you have, would you prefer hers or yours?" "Hers, naturally," said the wife. "So now: what if that woman had a better husband than you? Would you prefer hers or your own?" Here the woman blushed. Aspasia, however, began to interrogate Xenophon himself, (frag. 31 Dittmar = Cic. Inv. Rhet. 1.31.51 ff.)
This dialectical strategy, which we have come to call Socratic, moves the discussants up along a set of not-quite-parallel alternatives—from choosing the best property to selecting the best spouse—and is basic to Greek thought; to ask whether one prefers the better or the worse alternative forces the respondent to declare that one wants the better. Aspasia interrogates not only the wife, but the husband as well. She eventually reminds both that in order to have the best spouse, one must be the best spouse.50 The rest of the conversation must have taken place between Xenophon and Aspasia, because the wife aporetically blushes and falls silent (cf. PL Euthydemus 275-277). In it, Aspasia declares that each partner in a marriage should become the best person possible so that each spouse's wish to have the best possible partner might be fulfilled. Significantly, virtue is sought in reference to another human being; eros is the locus of mutual commitment. Moreover, a woman and a man are together considered worthy of this joint pursuit. Each is one another's love object at the same time that they are themselves acting subjects. That Aspasia's bios speaks of Pericles' devotion to Aspasia and never the reverse problematizes Ehlers' contentions that Aspasia knew of eros' power through direct experience and that this experience was the foundation of her work and her success. Aspasia's advice to the wife of Xenophon does not "transcend" anything, nor does it suggest that one should or can run through a variety of mates in the search for an appropriate partner: her advice is contextually limited and must be followed over a long span of time. Because of the contextual limits of her prescription, one might label Aeschines' Aspasia as a relativist. The erotic path to virtue that Aspasia recommends is not abstract, theoretical, or sublimated, as it would be in Plato's Symposium; instead, it is specific and paved with earthly experience. Moreover, both women and men are
Aspasia and the Socratic Tradition
45
granted an equal stake and responsibility in this partnership. Each is the subject of her or his own quest, even while functioning as the object of the other's. The humble materiality of the oikos and its mortal constitutors and continuants is starkly contrasted to the glittering wordplay that excises mortality and materiality in Plato's Menexenus. This fragment may represent a particular moment in the history of consciousness, namely, an early attempt to create a female subject.51 It is most significant that Aeschines set his dialogue in a time when Aspasia would have been an older woman, perhaps a graus (crone); she could have been figured as one who is liminally or symbolically/ anagogically erotic, rather than as participatively or actively so. This liminal eroticism is also a chief ingredient in Plato's representation of Socrates. The fact of Aspasia's old age balances whatever emphasis Aeschines might have placed on her erotic history. She is a crosser of boundaries, a woman who has had marriage-like relationships, but not marriages, with leaders of the polis and who advises husbands and wives to seek and to be the best possible spouse. It is entirely possible to consider the wisewoman as a credible instructress for the young man without making her carry an active erotic charge; for example, she might have been showing the son how to choose and educate a wife (see the discussion of Xenophon's Oeconomicus, in the next section). Aspasia shows the path to others; her participation as a sort of philosophic sex therapist (as twentieth-century sexology would have her be), is not required. Aeschines might well have identified Aspasia as apromnestris ("matchmaker") in this dialogue and meant it in a literal sense. That function of matchmaker resembles those functions Plato's and Xenophon's Socrates assigns himself—which he would describe literally and metaphorically as pander, fellow hunter, matchmaker, and midwife.52
Xenophon Xenophon (ca. 430-356 B.C.) carries significant portions of Aspasia's bios in his Socratica, the Memorabilia and the Oeconomicus; the two passages in which she is mentioned are both thought to have derived from Aeschines' Aspasia. Scholars devoted to the Quellenforschung of Aeschines' dialogue have not paid much attention to Xenophon's own use of Aspasia.53 Several other sections of the Memorabilia, of the Oeconomicus, and
46
Prisoner of History
of Xenophon's Symposium touch upon Aspasia's biographical tradition. As is conventional, Aspasia neither appears as a character nor speaks directly. But Socrates presents her as an authority and as a friend whom he has frequently visited; she is evidently truthful, intelligent, and trustworthy. Socrates' offer, in the Oeconomicus, to introduce Aspasia to Critoboulus so that she might tell him about the proper training of spouses is comparable to the situation in Plato's Menexenus, where Socrates also promises to take his interlocutor to hear Aspasia, and to the situation in Aeschines' Aspasia, where Socrates recommends that Callias engage Aspasia to teach his son. In the Oeconomicus and the Memorabilia, Xenophon evokes a woman whose life and thought were neither dependent on nor mediated by her sexual relationship with Pericles. She is presented as an authority on male-female relationships, but Xenophon's Aspasia is neither power hungry nor exclusively sexual. Whereas Plato presents Aspasia ironically as an analyst and practitioner of a bankrupt rhetoric, a rhetoric that creates a temporary illusion, a seeming death, a meaningless logos void of ergon, Xenophon makes Aspasia's ability to detect truth and falsehood in the reports of matchmakers a positive thing. Moreover, her reputed ability to educate spouses, taken with her advice that marriages be made honestly, shows her to be interested in helping create ethical and lasting partnerships. Unlike the temporary illusion produced by residence in epitaphian ou-topia, the deceit or openness of the matchmaker and the suitability of a spouse will be endured for many years by husband and wife alike; as Aspasia says, deceived parties will hate both each other and the matchmaker (Mem. 2.6.36). Aspasia, like the Muses, knows lies and truth: Xenophon's Aspasia knows, speaks, and advocates the private truth proper to courtship and marriage, not the glittering public lies of the epitaphios. Nevertheless, Xenophon's Aspasia scarcely transcends her position as secondary to the interests and requirements of men's discourse; Xenophon merely deploys "Aspasian" ideas in a new way, showing us a Socrates who appropriates attributes of the woman and of femininity to his own ends.
The Memorabilia The Memorabilia, or more properly, the Apomnemoneumata, recollects brief conversations between Socrates and various persons. The reference
Aspasia and the Socratic Tradition
47
to Aspasia as one who understands the duties of the matchmaker is found in its second book, wherein Socrates and the young Critoboulus converse about the proper way to estimate the quality of worthwhile philoi ("friends," or male lovers). A close reading of this section shows how Aspasia, whose bios had never before associated her with male courtship, comes to be cited as a helpful authority in that endeavor.54 At the beginning of this discussion (Mem. 2.6.1), the language is nonsexual. One should carefully consider the prior behavior of a prospective "friend"; his treatment of his old friends can be compared with his treatment of his animals says Socrates (2.6.7). The pursuit of friends can be likened to a hunt (2.6.8; the term is qualified by Socrates at 2.6.9-10). An element of enchantment, resembling the Sirens' song to Odysseus, enters the search (2.6.11); the image of beautiful women is used at this point to exemplify the dangers of sexual allure. When Critoboulus asks if Socrates knows any other spells, the latter replies, "No, but I've heard that Pericles knew many, and using them on the city made it love him" (2.6.13). The politician's relationship to the city is described as lover-like, Pericles' charming language is assimilated into the charm of courtship, and male courtship imagery describes other pursuits.55 Next, Socrates, expatiates on how "noble friendship" helps the man of public life (2.6.21-27); the language is not yet sexually charged, but suddenly Socrates slips seamlessly into the theme of erotic pursuit (2.6.28-29). He once again mentions the Sirens' song as an inducement to erotic friendship, and men, transsexed, are now the Sirens (2.6.31). The feminized city, which consists of autochthonous men, "feels" a human emotion. The kind of friends Critoboulus wishes to attract is once more made clear; they are lovers, and the pursuit of lovers is again a hunt (2.6.2728; cf. 2.6.8-10). The usual terminology of erastesi'eromenos (active lover/passive beloved) is absent here, although sexual intimacy is clearly the object (e.g., see 2.6.6) and Xenophon straightforwardly employs the literal terminology in the Symposium. Socrates now offers to assist Critoboulus by informing any would-be friend that Critoboulus admires him, naming himself an adept at the hunt, a syntheros (' 'fellow hunter," 2.6.36; cf. Ar. Plut. 157). He is a third party who will help Critoboulus in courting.56 The possible means of winning a friend have now been established: these consist of charms, spells, honest praise, and the help of a fellow
48
Prisoner of History
hunter. It is at this point that Critoboulus suggests that Socrates need not scruple in his reports to prospective lovers. Of course, Socrates declines to lie about something so important; Aspasia, who recommends veracity to matchmakers, is associated here with an open and truthful logos, one whose original audience was heterosexual: CRITOBOULUS: "Why then . . . do you tell me this,
as if it weren't in your power to say whatever you want about me?" SOCRATES: "Not at all, as I once heard Aspasia say; for she said that the best matchmakers are skilled at bringing people into a marriage alliance when the good things they say are true, and that she did not want to praise lying matchmakers. For the deceived parties hate both each other and the matchmaker. I am convinced that this is correct . . . " (Mem. 2.6.36).57
Previously, Xenophon's Socrates had carefully blurred the boundary between heterosexual and homosexual pursuits, so that by the time Aspasia's advice is slipped in, its original context is lost and it appears to be perfectly appropriate to the occasion. Although the Platonic Socrates calls himself a midwife of ideas and arrogates to himself the role of matchmaker, the Xenophontic Socrates does not go so far here as to appropriate a role culturally defined as feminine. He nonetheless makes two significant analogies: one between the processes of men-only courtship and heterosexual courtship, and the other between the roles of fellow hunter and matchmaker. Socrates' reiteration of Aspasia's advice makes this clear: "Now, Critoboulus, how then do you think I'll be more helpful to you—by praising you falsely, or by persuading you to try to be a good man?" (2.6.S7).58 The episode closes on a sexually neutral note (2.6.37-39), but some of the same elements of sexual pursuit resonate markedly in the Theodote episode in the third book. For that reason, and because Theodote has sometimes (and wrongly) been assumed to be a substitute for Aspasia, it is necessary to discuss this section. "Once upon a time in Athens there was a beautiful woman whose name was Theodote" (3.11.1). Clearly a courtesan, and perhaps the daughter of one, Theodote readily associates with anyone who persuades her (3.11.1-4). The language used to describe the situation is sexually neutral, but the content is explicit, as was not the case in Mem. 2.6, discussed previously. Theodote has allowed her portrait to be
Aspasia and the Socratic Tradition
49
painted, and Socrates leads a group to view her indescribable beauty. Because she earns her considerable living from any friend who wishes to treat her well (3.11.4), it behooves Theodote to become an expert at the "hunt." Socrates duly advises her to devise a means to "hunt" "friends" (philous theraseiri), that is, paying lovers, likening her body to the hunting nets and suggesting that someone act as her hound (3.11.7-10). Her body is only a means for Theodote to achieve her end; it is an end for the lovers, however. Thus, she is both subject and object of the erotic quest, and by helping her hunt, Socrates becomes Theodote's co-subject. He urges the honest pursuit of honest lovers, and advises Theodote to use titillation judiciously (3.11.10-14). Socrates' advice to pursue lovers honestly echoes his earlier repetition of Aspasia's opinion that matchmakers must be honest. But, in a strategy similar to that which he employed in Mem. 2.6.36, Socrates here too redirects that "Aspasian" advice to his own ends, and it is not merely by omitting Aspasia's name and the marital context. Convinced, Theodote asks Socrates if he will be her synthemtes ton philon, her "fellow hunter of friends" (3.11.15). This request, if granted, would make Socrates' relationship with Theodote parallel to his relationship to Critoboulus. They banter—he will come to her if she persuades him, but she must discover how to persuade him (3.11.15). Socrates finally evades the issue by saying that friends of both sexes flock to him and take up much of his free time. The women come in order to learn philters and spells; the men flock to him because Socrates lures them with philters, spells, and magical devices (3.11.16-17). The section ends as Socrates promises to receive Theodote in the absence of a philotera (a "woman more loved," or "a dearer friend" 3.11.18). Thus, in the Memorabilia, Socrates speaks with words of seduction and magic of both male and female followers, as he adapts Aspasia's advice to the contexts of both homosexual and heterosexual courtship.59 Not only is Aspasia not mentioned in the Theodote passage, she could have had no part in it. Ehlers rightly sees that the themes of Socrates' conversation with Theodote correspond in many ways to those of his earlier conversation with Critoboulus, but I disagree with her analysis of what this correspondence is. Ehlers believes that Theodote represents Aspasia and that such a substitution spared Aspasia the negative connotations of being represented as the hetaira that Ehlers thinks she actually was. According to this logic, Xenophon wanted to portray Socrates as having learned of eras' power from Aspasia but without naming her as a
50
Prisoner of History
hetaira and thereby reinforcing that role's many negative connotations. If the real Aspasia had been Socrates' teacher, how can "Theodote/ Aspasia" be Socrates' pupil? Theodote simply cannot be Aspasia in disguise, for the roles of pupil and teacher are reversed here. Aeschines' Aspasia is a master teacher who uses no helpers of any kind, whereas Theodote is cast in the role of someone who needs Socrates' help. Theodote stands, then, in the same relation to Socrates as had Critoboulus in 2.6—she needs lovers and she needs help to find them.60 I suggest a different line of thought: Aeschines' Aspasia had observed that heterosexual eros could be a path to arete and had demonstrated that within marriage such a possibility was manifested in each spouse's wish and attempt to be the other's best possible mate. Xenophon uses this advice, initially generated by Aeschines' Aspasia, by citing Aspasia's remark about honest matchmaking in his Memorabilia. He first uses that remark explicitly to make Socrates advocate honesty in homoerotic courtship and then uses it implicitly to make Socrates encourage the hetaira to pursue clients honestly. In each context. Xenophon's Socrates also employs the concept of fellow hunter, a concept somewhat analogous to that of matchmaker, and thereby creates for himself a role as co-subject (but significantly, not as co-object).61
The Oeconomicus The implications of "Aspasia's" advice for marital partners reach fullest exposition in Oeconomicus. This famous discussion between Socrates and Critoboulus about household management and husbandry contains Xenophon's second reference to Aspasia and further extends the notion of honest marital courtship. Socrates lengthily recounts a conversation he once had with the exemplary Ischomachus (Oec. 7-21), whom he offers to Critoboulus as an example of one who has learned what is worth learning about having a good marriage. Aspasia's ideas seem to have borne fruit for Ischomachus and his wife. Critoboulus and Socrates discuss the trainability of animals and humans; if a sheep fares poorly, the shepherd is blamed; if ahorse, the rider; if a wife, the husband (3.11; cf. Mem. 2.6.7 on a man's relations with his animals). It is particularly important to have a good wife; to her a man entrusts his most serious business, even though men take mere ignorant girls as wives (3.12-14). Critoboulus asks and Socrates answers obliquely (3.14):
Aspasia and the Socratic Tradition
51
CRITOBOULUS: "What then of the husbands who have, as you say, good wives? Did the husbands themselves educate their wives?" SOCRATES: "There's nothing like close examination. I'll introduce you to Aspasia, who will explain everything to you more knowledgeably than I can."
Socrates does not say that Aspasia will show him how to train a wife, but rather that she will "explain everything." This implies not only that the procedure is more than just an indoctrination of the woman by the man, but also that he, Socrates, has listened to her and therefore knows what it is she will explain. In other words, Socrates' remark implies the existence of a prior context, a wider scenario. Ischomachus establishes that complementary gender roles are essential (7.3-4). In response to Socrates' question about how the wife was trained (7.4—7) Ischomachus states that he first prayed that he might really teach and his wife really learn what was best for them both and that his wife prayed as well for the same thing (7.7-8). Ischomachus told his wife that he and her parents chose her as his mate in the belief that their partnership would be the best; this recalls Aspasia's statement to Xenophon's own wife that spouses should try to be the best for one another. Each partner brings to the union the desire to be the best possible partner, the potential to bear children, and property (7.11-13). Property is to be held in common, and the better partner is the one who has made the better contribution (7.13). This evokes the conversation reported between Aspasia and Xenophon and his wife, but here more detail and examples are given. Each partner should act in order that the property be as sound as possible and that it grow by fair and just means (7.15); the wife's role in this endeavor is to have children (7.17-19) and to take care of the house and its attendant work (7.20-22), things women are better equipped to do (7.22). But in other ways, namely, mneme (memory) and epimeleia (care), both are equals, as well as in respect to to enkrates de einai (self-control, 7.26-27). The lack of completely symmetrical capabilities between the sexes (7.28) makes each the more useful to the other. The groom concurs with his bride's insight that servants who are well cared for will repay that care with greater loyalty (7.37-38). That each partner should/ought to try to be as good as possible is again stressed; the pleasantest thing of all is for the wife to be better than the husband and to
52
Prisoner of History
make him her servant (7.42). Together, the pair arrange their household belongings in orderly fashion (8-9), and the wife acts as a magistrate (9.14).62 Just as Aspasia had earlier prescribed mutual honesty in courtship and marriage (Mem. 2.6.26), Ischomachus identifies particular mental and moral qualities as the equal province of both sexes. The main part of Ischomachus' argument to his wife recommends that partners in a marriage be honest—they must not conceal, boast, or exaggerate (see especially 10.3). Ischomachus calls cosmetics a form of deceit; a mark of his wife's merit is her willingness to give up cosmetics at her husband's request (10.1-9).63 Ischomachus is clearly an elaborated illustration of the kind of marital happiness that comes about when partners are honest with each other. He is the ideal husband of the marriage Aspasia sketches in her advice to Xenophon and his wife. Xenophon's Socrates uses the Aeschinean Aspasia 's advice on marital courtship in two dialogues: he plays the role of honest matchmaker (cum fellow hunter) in the Memorabilia and discusses a successful marriage that seems to have been brought about and continued according to "Aspasian" principles in the Oeconomicus. The "Aspasian" concept of matchmaking is likened to hunting and hunting to procuring in the Memorabilia; as I will discuss next, in the Symposium, Socrates uses the image of procurer to describe his own role as a liminal, erotic facilitator of male love. Possibly, Socrates found the matchmaker image and took it from "Aspasia" as a way of redefining and refining his own role. Socrates' use of the literal and metaphoric functions of mastropos (pimp), syntheros (fellow hunter), andpromnestris (matchmaker) in Xenophon, and of midwife in Plato, indicates a progressive refinement of Socrates' apparent self-concept (or the development of same by his biographical tradition).64 Socrates' tendency to attribute words to Aspasia, to speak "her" words in dialogue, must also be part of this process. Before I leave the Socratica behind, it is necessary to take a look at Xenophon's Symposium.
The Symposium Xenophon's Symposium presents an earthier and more robust Socrates than does Plato's homonymous dialogue. Even here, however, Socrates is becoming a liminally erotic figure. He participates in other men's courtships by assuming the role of advisor; he is married but not mar-
Aspasia and the Socratic Tradition
53
ried, loved but not in love.65 Xenophon's humorous representation of Socrates makes the philosopher evasive rather than lofty. Socrates advises Lycon that his son Autolycus should seek out the most suitable man to show him a life of virtue. When asked by the general company how one might find such a teacher, Socrates uses the arrival of a dancing girl to demur (2.6-8). Her proficiency as a dancer leads Socrates to observe that women's nature is not inferior to men's (except in gnome, intelligence, and ischys, strength), and that men can teach their wives whatever they wish them to know (2.8-9), a comment that anticipates the more sophisticated treatment of marital relations present in the Oeconomicus. Socrates next evades the question as to why he does not teach Xanthippe (2.9-10). His own relationship with his wife is stunningly unlike that of Ischomachus and his wife (see especially Symp. 2.9-10).66 It can even be said that Socrates' relation to Xanthippe as he himself describes it is almost as far as one can get from the pictures of the ideal marriage in the Memorabilia and Oeconomicus. Socrates' refusal to follow his own advice—that men can teach their wives anything—maintains his superiority or transcendent nature even as it exposes him. Socrates sets the course of the evening's conversation by calling on each person to disclose what he thinks is his most valuable knowledge (3.3). Socrates claims pride in his knowledge of mastropeia (procuring, 3.10). Despite the group's ridicule, Socrates claims that he could earn considerable money by pursuing such a techne (skill). The topic of Socrates qua procurer is left behind as other symposiasts declare pride in jesting, or in the father-son relationship, or in the goodness and power of friends (3.11-3.14). Next, each man attempts to prove that his source of pride is worthy of that pride. At last, Socrates explains his pride in his adoxos techne, his disreputable skill (4.56). Beginning with a functionbased definition, he establishes that the function of an excellent procurer is to make whoever employs him, man or woman, attractive to all comers (4.57). By establishing the individual's power to convey multiple impressions, Socrates shows that the external aspects of attractiveness are multivalenced and malleable. Arguing on the "more is better" principle, Socrates next obtains the group's agreement that the better procurer is one who can make a person attractive not just to one person, but to many—in fact, to the whole polls (4.58-60). The advantages of this activity are quite plain: ' 'For the man who is able to recognize those who can benefit one another and who is able to make them desirous of
54
Prisoner of History
one another, that man, I think, could also make cities be friendly and could arrange appropriate marriages; he would be a very valuable friend and ally to acquire, for both states and private parties" (4.64). As was the case in comedy and as would be the case in the Memorabilia, the political world is eroticized. Subsequently, Socrates directs the conversation to a discussion of eros. Antisthenes calls him a "procurer of yourself," mastropos sautou (8.5). Socrates wittily dismisses him (8.6) and moves to a discussion of the right sort of love objects (8.6-8.8). His remark that mutual admiration spurs lovers on to ever greater virtue (8.17-18) resonates with the Aeschinean Aspasia's doctrine of eros as a path to arete. The element of commitment is important: Socrates notes that a man who is only physically in love is like someone who has rented a farm, but one who loves spiritually is like one who owns the farm (8.25). Socrates additionally demonstrates to Callias that one who wishes to benefit his beloved must practice virtue: "But the greatest good that comes to him who wishes to have a friend in his lover, is that he himself needs to practice arete habitually" (8.27). This statement recalls the Aeschinean Aspasia's dictum that husband and wife must be the best for each other. At dialogue's end, the married members of the party set off for home in order to enjoy their own wives. The married Socrates, however, is not among this number; he joins others on a walk (9.7). Socrates' liminality is maintained. Married but not married, using the lowly language of pimping in the service of "noble friendship," he remains with his male companions.
Conclusion Even though the chronological problems of the Socratica are knotty, it is nonetheless possible to identify among them thematic relationships relevant to the development of Aspasia's bios. The figure of the mastropos as Xenophon's sympotic Socrates uses it is first on a metaphorical continuum of pimp to fellow hunter to matchmaker; Socrates refines the figure of mastropos into that of the syntheros and yet further, by using Aeschines' contribution to Aspasia's biographical tradition, into that of the promnestris. It would remain for Plato to carry the idea on, to show Socrates not only as a matchmaker for men who love other men, but also as a midwife for men who birth ideas. One must neither consider this as
Aspasia and the Socratic Tradition
55
a logical and linear progression of ideas nor use this set of metaphors in order to set the various dialogues into a chronological order. But it is important to reestablish "Aspasian" discourse as a missing link in both the history of female subjectivity and the discourse on erotic pedagogy, a discourse largely attributed only to Socrates. The figure of the mastropos is vivid and crude. It acknowledges the malleability of the lover-employer from subject into object, as the mastropos re-presents that employer in the most favorable, but not necessarily the most truthful, light. It is the literal image of a disreputable skill (adoxos techne), and it is multivalent, for one can even pimp oneself, as Xenophon's sympotic Antisthenes avers. The figure of syntheros, as found in the Memorabilia, is far more complex; it is a metaphor. Discussion of the "hunt" mixes metaphor and literality, for one can describe the reports disseminated to the beloved in literal terms or one can discuss the lover's blandishments metaphorically as "hounds" and "nets." The notion of mutuality is more prominent and that of malleability is less prominent; the roles of hunter and fellow hunter are presented as the shared pursuit of an end that only one will enjoy. Yet despite its wondrous complexity, the metaphor of syntheros is sterile and unsatisfying: a successful hunt kills or paralyzes the quarry, nourishing the hunter but not creating anything new. The image of the promnestris is the most idealized. Aeschines' Aspasia spoke literally of actual promnestreis, for she was discussing an actual female social role. This role, discussed substantively and positively in the Oeconomicus, becomes metaphorical when applied to homoerotic courtship in the Memorabilia. The role of promnestris is both productive even as it is played on the borderland; the matchmaker, usually a crone, played a vital part in perpetuating a productive and tranquil household. The role of the matchmaker, as used metaphorically by Xenophon's Socrates of male love in the Memorabilia, overcomes the barrenness of the role of syntheros and transcends the playful naughtiness of the mastropos without relinquishing the latter's liminality. The use by Xenophon's Socrates of the image of promnestris in the Memorabilia, and the concomitant elision of the matchmaker's duties into the process of male courtship, anticipates the Platonic Socrates' conflation of the image of matchmaker with that of midwife in his discussion of the birth of ideas in the Theaetetus (150a). The appropriation of "Aspasian" language during this process supports duBois' contention that a philosophical language was developing in the fourth
56
Prisoner of History
century that arrogated women's experiences and occupations to the philosophical search for a masculine source for the good. It is possible that some aspects of this language began with '' Aspasia." If so, it is less correct to call Aspasia a "female Socrates" and to speak of Aeschines' dialogue as a "pre-Platonic" discourse on eros than it is to call the Socrates of Plato's Symposium a "male Aspasia" and to speak of his Symposium a s ' 'post-'Aspasian'." It is Plato who takes from women the capacity for intellectual and biological creativity. For a moment, philosophical discourse allowed a woman to advocate that women and men, connected by eros, search together for the good. But that incredible moment was not to last, and the dominant portrait of Aspasia that antiquity would hand the West was that of Pericles' "intellectual girlfriend."67
4 The Sargasso Sea: Aspasia and the Discourse on Prostitutes in the Hellenistic, Roman, and Late Antique Periods
Although Aspasia's bios would surface spectacularly in Plutarch's Life of Pericles, it is not possible to limn her biographical tradition clearly from the mid-fourth century B.C. onward. Aspasia is mentioned but cursorily in a few complete texts, and we cannot hope to fully understand how she was treated in the many fragmentary works that mention her. Cicero and Quintilian took her seriously as a logician, and Plutarch thought it worth reporting elements of her life relevant to Pericles. For others, Aspasia not only dominated Pericles, but was also the lovelorn Socrates' "agony aunt." There is much here for the student of high culture to disdain, but the persistence of treatments of Aspasia along the entire continuum of texts, patchy though these be, testifies to her power as an icon in this period of cultural ferment, fusion, and eclecticism. With few exceptions, most citations of Aspasia float in a Sargasso Sea of protoprosopography, subhistory, and subbiography; most of these anecdotes are found in the works of Greek, not Roman, authors. The interest many of these works display in exceptional women (mostly prostitutes), suggests the development of a "protopornography," or a discourse on prostitutes, that is remarkably consistent across texts and through the centuries. It would be improper to try to classify and discuss 57
58
Prisoner of History
these works genetically; we must speak more of general themes than of genres, schools, or locales. Precisely because Aspasia was becoming important as a cultural icon, treatments of her do appear in diverse texts; these texts mostly share the assumption that she was a hetaira.1 Extensive literary treatment of prostitutes began in the fourth century B.C., which has been called the ancient world's "golden age of the hetaira." Pornography—"writing about prostitutes"—in the strictest sense had itself begun during Aspasia's own lifetime, but there is no evidence that anyone wrote treatises on prostitutes in the fourth century.2 Aspasia, never typical, fits uneasily into the developing discourse on prostitutes; this discourse uses sensational and historical or quasihistorical anecdotes about individual women. Anecdotes of this sort, which had made their first appearances in comedy, now appear in historiography, miscellany, prosopography, poetry, and philosophical dialogue.
The Discourse on Prostitutes in Greek Literature: Genesis and Characteristics Two of the earliest contributors to the discourse on prostitutes were the brothers Lynceus and Duris of Samos. In addition to an unknown number of comedies, Deipnetikai Epistolai ("Dinner Letters"), Opsonitike Techne ("The Caterer's Art"), and a treatise on Menander, Lynceus wrote an Apomnemoneumata (or Apophthegmata, "Memorabilia"), which contained quasi-historical anecdotes about his contemporaries and predecessors; some of these were witty prostitutes. Aspasia does not appear in any surviving fragments of Lynceus, but it is important to note that he was interested in the literary treatments of historical prostitutes, scholarship on comedy, comedy itself, and historical anecdote; all of these are locales within which Aspasia's biographical tradition develops in the postclassical period. Duris was probably the first to allege that Aspasia was implicated in Athens' involvement in the conflict between Samos and Miletus.3 Lynceus was a source for Machon of Sicyon, who worked at Alexandria in the mid-third century B.C. He displayed a similar range of interests, particularly in his use of witty prostitutes who philosophize and banter in his Chreiai ("Bright Sayings"; see esp. frags. 12 and 15 Gow), a work composed in metrical form, perhaps in order to help
The Sargasso Sea
59
would-be symposium raconteurs memorize desired stories.4 Matro of Pitane, a parodist of the fourth century B.C., also contributed to the discourse on prostitutes in his bizarre Homeric cento Deipnon Attikon ("Attic Dinner'') by giving food a feminized sexuality and by representing prostitutes and their customers prominently in the poem. Prostitutes thus were entering discourses they never had before. Duris inserted anecdotes about Aspasia into historiography, his brother composed (pseudo)historical memoirs in which prostitutes participated as characters, and Matro pornographized Homer.5 The interest in prostitutes is seen across a cultural continuum. The second-century author Hegesander of Delphi wrote a Hypomnemata ("Commentaries"), and perhaps a treatise, on the malice of Plato; the former work concerned kings, parasites, courtesans, philosophers, and other types, and may have been divided into books according to topic. He mentions prostitutes in fragments of chreiai he attributes to the prostitute Metaneira, when he states that Sophocles lived with a hetaira in his old age and made her his kleronomos (heiress), and in information about a religious festival. Hegesander wrote prostitutes into all sorts of texts; his work discussed prostitutes' wit, their rapacious readiness to attach themselves to wealthy old men, and a religious festival with the name of Hetairideia.6 Nor did philosophical discourse after Plato abandon its interest in Aspasia. A polemic by Heraclides Ponticus, Peri Hedones ("On Pleasure"), was written in a comedic style and may have been composed in dialogue form; unfortunately, no hint as to speakers or identities is preserved. Possibly Heraclides, who was a pupil of Plato and was later associated with Aristotle, discussed the dichotomy, Prodicus-wise, between pleasure and duty, himself opposing pleasure. Fragment 55 states an opinion of pleasure and luxury that other fragments refute: namely, the ability to live luxuriously is a mark of peoples at the height of their power. Most of the fragments demonstrate the madness that characterizes extremes of pleasure and luxury; the Samians lost their city after living in excessive luxury (frag. 57); Callias, who lived off his inheritance of Persian gold, died with only an elderly foreign woman by his side (frag. 58). In addition, love of comfort is found in tandem with fear of danger (frag. 60) and extreme love of comfort can lead to madness and self-mutilation (frag. 61). Pericles dismissed his wife from his house, opting for a life of pleasure, and lived with the Megarian [sic] courtesan Aspasia, on whom he squandered much of his property (frag.
60
Prisoner of History
59 = Ath. 12.533d). The dependence of such comment on comedy is obvious.7 Pericles' relationship with Aspasia is made antithetical to his married life; the explicit opposition of mistress to wife had heretofore been absent and is found here in an anecdote whose erroneous assertion about Aspasia's background probably comes from Aristophanes' Acharnians. Aspasia is warmonger and dominatrix, instrument and symbol of Pericles' and Athens' tryphe (excessive luxury); she becomes part of a moralizing tale about a man who leaves his wife for a prostitute. Interestingly, Aspasia and the foreign graidion (little old lady) who attended Callias' deathbed are the only women mentioned in the remains of this treatise; both the notorious courtesan and the anonymous crone represent the social isolation and bad end to which each man comes. The Peripatetic Clearchus of Soli emulated Aristotle's learnedness, but his sensationalism sets him apart from the Stagirite. Although his reputation languishes today, he was admired and used by other ancient writers. Clearchus' Erotika, a work of two or more books, treats aphrodisia (sexual relations) of various types, the deeper meanings of courtship rituals, and the excesses to which lovers' passions drive them. It also mentions literary accounts of love affairs. The category of lovers' excesses is pertinent to this discussion; Clearchus mentioned Cleisophus of Selymbria, who tailed to copulate with a statue but succeeded with a scrap of meat (frag. 26); animals who fall in love with human beings (frags. 27 and 28); Gyges, who erected a monument to his dead mistress (frag. 29); Pericles, who threw all Hellas into turmoil for Aspasia's sake (frag. 30); and Eriphanis, the lovelorn poet who was even joined in mourning by animals (frag. 32).8 To situate Pericles and Aspasia in this company of freaks exceeds even Heraclides, but both authors' anecdotes participate in an identical economy, traceable to fifth-century comedy. In the work by Heraclides, Pericles' relationship with Aspasia reveals the politician's lack of control as an individual and family man and his enslavement to pleasure in the forms of a beautiful woman and expenditure of money. Clearchus made the cause more specific and its effect more wide-ranging: because of an erotic passion, Pericles throws into turmoil not just his household and his property (ousia, in Heraclides), but all of Greece. Aspasia becomes a perverse example of the personal as political. The end of the fourth century saw the beginnings of literary and historical scholarship on comedy, which is the other main locus besides philosophical dialogue of Aspasia's bios. In addition to the famous lost
The Sargasso Sea
61
second book of Aristotle's Poetics and Lynceus' treatise on Menander, the fourth century also saw the appearance of Theophrastus' Peri Komoidias (' 'On Comedy"), as well as his famous Peri Charakteron (' 'On Characters"). The fact that exceptional women, usually prostitutes, are found in many different genres is not insignificant. The scholar Satyrus, whose works have received mixed reviews across the ages, exemplifies some of the tendencies that contributed to the nascent discourse on prostitutes.9 In his Peri Charakteron ("On Characters'') Satyrus decried prodigals who enjoy courtesans rather than the wholesome company of male friends (FHG frag. 20); association with courtesans is equated with reckless disregard for one's financial future, a sentiment as old as Alcaeus and as new as New Comedy. A second and more significant passage from Satyrus' Bioi has the courtesan Glykera telling a philosopher that it doesn't matter whether one is corrupted by him or her: "Stilpo, we're both equally guilty. For people say you corrupt those who meet you by teaching them no-account eristic sophistics—and they say I do the same thing teaching them erotics! So, it doesn't matter to men who are ruined and doing badly whether they live with a philosopher or a hetaira" (FHG 3.164, frag. 19 = Ath. 13.584a4-9). Equally pernicious are a philosopher's time and a prostitute's, a philosopher's conversation and a prostitute's. The affinities between Satyrus, comic invective, and the earlier construction of Aspasia's speech in the Menexenus are obvious. It is also important to note the scandalous anecdotes contributed by Idomeneus of Lampsacus to the discourse on prostitutes. Named by Plutarch in his Pericles and elsewhere—only to be discredited—and not mentioning Aspasia in any fragment yet identified, Idomeneus nonetheless contributed with his story that Themistocles yoked prostitutes to a chariot and drove them; this anecdote resembles a passage in Matro's DeipnonAttikon, which describes a man entering a symposium driving a chariot drawn by prostitutes. Possibly Idomeneus wrote about Aspasia in his Peri ton Sokratikon ("On the Socratics"), but no fragments survive.10
The (Pseudo)Scholarly Discourse on Prostitutes In the third century B.C., the center of scholarship gravitated from Athens to Alexandria. The first datable evidence of treatises specifically devoted to prostitutes comes in the works attributed to Aristophanes of
62
Prisoner of History
Byzantium (ca. 275-180 B.C.), a prodigious and prolific scholar who studied with Machon and became head of the Mouseion (Library) in Alexandria around 194 B.C. Several titles suggest that Aristophanes took a particular interest in drama: Peri Komoidias ("On Comedy"), Lexis Komike ("Comic Diction"), PeriProsopon ("On Masks"); and a work that may be more prosopographical than literary, Peri ton Athenesin Hetairidon ("On Athenian Courtesans"). This treatise apparently contained information about 135 hetairai, but only its title remains (Ath. 13.567a). Aspasia may have been mentioned therein.11 The several Peri Hetairon treatises, of which Aristophanes' is the first, may have been a subset of those more general works known as Komoidoumenoi, "Persons Mentioned in Comedy." Whatever the true nature of the "On Courtesans" treatise, Aristophanes was followed in the endeavor by his pupil Callistratus in a work mentioned only once in the available sources: " 'Alexander razed , but Phryne put it back up,' as Callistratus recounts in his Peri Hetairon" (FGrH frag. 1 = Ath. 13.591d3-6). The fragment's content and tone can be compared with Old Comedy's likening of politicians' activities to those of prostitutes. The fragment concerning Phryne is found in a section of Athenaeus which also has sources taken from various comic playwrights and scholars of comedy.12 Aristarchus, Aristophanes' more famous pupil, succeeded him as head of the Library and produced a student of his own, Ammonius grammaticus, who also wrote both a Komoidoumenoi and a Peri Hetairon. In the infamous thirteenth book of Athenaeus, in which prostitutes are discussed, the symposiast Cynulcus chides Myrtilus for carrying around Peri Hetairon treatises and hanging about wineshops with prostitutes the day long (FGrH frag. 350 Tl = Ath. 13.567a).13 Another of Aristarchus' pupils, Apollodorus of Athens, left Alexandria for Pergamum around 146 and moved to Athens around 133. In addition to historiographical, philological, and sympotic works, he also wrote a Peri Hetairon treatise that apparently surpassed Aristophanes of Byzantium's list of 135 hetairai in its length. Apollodorus claimed that Aristophanes had omitted a number of women. This claim suggests that in the late Hellenistic age such treatises had a well-established place in the scholarly world; they were known as a separate kind of treatise and were subject to legitimate correction by "authorities," just as were other works on tamer subjects. The surviving fragments of Apollodorus' Peri Hetairon list prostitutes' names, nicknames, parentage, and chil-
The Sargasso Sea
63
dren, and attempt to identify individual women who bore the same name.14 Two more authors of Peri Hetairon treatises in Greek are attested; both display the preoccupations already discussed. Antiphanes the Younger, Apollodorus' approximate contemporary in the second century B.C., wrote a Peri Hetairon treatise whose few fragments also recount nicknames and family histories. Gorgias of Athens, a grammarian of the late first or early second century A.D. , is also credited with such a treatise, which apparently contained information about prostitutes' relations with politicians. Gorgias' approximate coeval, the Roman Suetonius, is credited with a treatise on prostitutes, but nothing is known of its contents or manner of treatment.15 It is possible that the Peri Hetairon treatises began as, and remained, a specialized outgrowth of the Komoidoumenoi treatises, that is, a form of prosopography. Nevertheless, it must be remembered that although historical prostitutes were mentioned in factual texts such as the orators, in quasi-factual texts such as the Socratica and memorabilia, and in purely fictional texts such as the plays of New Comedy, they are constructed in similar ways across these discourses. That very phenomenon argues for a nascent pornography. It is necessary to resist an essentialist discussion of "the prostitute in" various cultural productions, as if she simply exists in the manner in which these texts describe her; from the fourth century B.C. on, the world of Greek thought was constructing ' 'the prostitute.'' The nature of that stereotype, as it developed, has been much obscured by the loss of the texts where the development was taking place, and it has been additionally obscured by scholars' inability to see its existence. Prostitutes are everywhere and nowhere in these protopornographic texts. For example, the tale that the orator Hypereides saved the hetaira Phryne in court sounds suspiciously like a doublet of the story that Aspasia was saved by Pericles; each story, however, is enrolled as historical evidence to verify the other.16 By the time of Plutarch's Life of Pericles, the discourse on prostitutes was attaining a certain generic quality, though it was visible across various genres and most visible in the existence of a separate set of treatises about whores. The meager remains of this pornography suggest that its authors tended to mesh their construction of fictitious prostitutes with reportage about historical women and that they were interested in prostitutes' nicknames, witticisms, idiosyncrasies, families, and sexual partners. There is a tendency to show prostitutes' domination over their
64
Prisoner of History
"clients," but there also exists an underside that shows the women's essential helplessness. Aspasia does not much participate in this discourse; however, given the lack of sources, I cannot claim that she doesn't appear at all. 17
Lipstick Traces: Debased Socratic Erotics in the Hellenistic Period The erotic Socrates and his Milesian teacher continue on in Hellenistic literature. In his Leontion, three campy books of elegy named for and dedicated to his mistress, Hermesianax of Colophon concocted a puerile assertion that Socrates loved Aspasia. The Leontion recounts great loves of the literary and mythical past. A lengthy fragment of the third book, preserved in Athenaeus, tells of the pangs of desire and devotion experienced by Orpheus, Musaeus, Hesiod, Homer, Mimnermus, and others, for Argiope, Antiope, and other women. Leontion is assured that not even philosophers escape the madness of eros. After mentioning Pythagoras' love for Theano, Socrates' love for Aspasia, and Aristippus' love for Lais, the fragment breaks off: "And how powerfully did the angry Cypris heat up Socrates, the man Apollo had declared to be outstanding in wisdom! From his deep soul, he executed lighter labours when he frequented Aspasia's house; nor did he find his way, though he had discovered numerous paths of logic" (frag. 7 CA, lines 90-94 = Ath. 13.599a6-b3). Hermesianax has turned the high respect for Aspasia exhibited by Aeschines' and Xenophon's Socrates into an adolescent crush.18 At about the same time, Herodicus of Babylon ("the Cratetean"), who was fiercely funny and vehemently anti-Platonic, invented a piece of advice Aspasia supposedly gave to Socrates about winning the love of Alcibiades. A contemporary of Ammonius grammaticus, Herodicus wrote not only the Pros ton Philosokraten ("Against the Socratophile"), but also a Komoidoumenoi and a Symmikta Hypomnemata. Herodicus apparently suggested that Plato exaggerated Socrates' martial valor, that his chronology was faulty, and that he concealed Socrates' love for Alcibiades.19 The relevant passage from the Pros ton Philosokraten is found in the Deipnosophistae in a passage wherein the host, Larensis, vilifies Plato, Socrates, and others. Larensis quotes Herodicus as citing a poem that
The Sargasso Sea
65
Socrates' teacher, Aspasia, presents to him; cognizant of the philosopher's passion, she urges him to press his suit. Herodicus also calls Aspasia Socrates' erotodidaskalos (teacher of erotics; Dueling frag. 4 = Ath. 5.219d5). Duering believes that Herodicus himself authored the poem ascribed to Aspasia. Ouk clothes me ("you haven't escaped my notice")—line 1 of the poem—suggests that Socrates has been trying to keep his passion for Alcibiades secret but that Aspasia has found him out, which suggestion contradicts Plato's image of the detached philosopher in the Symposium. Aspasia calls Socrates' and Alcibiades' emotions pathos and Socrates' desire paidika (lines 1, 3, 8); both men's feelings are called philia (line 9). These are conventional and almost homely words to describe emotional and sexual longing, rather than lofty words evoking the search for the good. The Cratetean implodes Plato's sublimative and sublime Socrates by making Aspasia invoke the earthier, nontranscendent erotic Socrates of Xenophon and by using language that recalls the imagery of the hunt (cf. chapter 3): the word thereuetai (frag. 4 Duering = Ath. 5.219d7) and the Hellenistic adjective tithason ("tractable," relating to the domestication of the wild—line 3 of the poem = Ath. 5.219e6), are associated with the complex of words related to the hunt (found in Xen. Mem. and Symp.). Socrates has burst into tears in front of Aspasia, who calls him "dear Socrates" (line 11), a form of address that clearly challenges the image of the highly controlled Platonic Socrates who marries a difficult woman just to prove he can meet the challenge.20 As had been the case in "serious" Socratic dialogues, here Socrates reports speech attributed to Aspasia. Aspasia herself does not speak but speaks through Herodicus/Socrates and invalidates a man. Herodicus' outburst may reflect hostility both to the growth of philosophical schools in the Hellenistic period and to women's participation (albeit limited) therein. His practice of discrediting Socrates through the philosopher Plato also recalls the earlier practice of discrediting politicians by associating them with whores; his treatment also resonates with more contemporary treatments such as those of Hermesianax, who had shown the philosophers Socrates, Pythagoras, and Aristippus to be in erotic thrall to women. Hellenistic literati, like men of the classical period, still continued to discredit other men by alleging that they were advised by whores; the most lasting stigma, however, affected not the men, but any woman who pretended to participate in the life of the mind.
66
Prisoner of History
The Wise Woman Aspasia does not fit into just one category of the class "woman" in the Hellenistic and Roman periods. Although her biographical tradition occasionally enrolls her in the pornographic discourse on prostitutes, it more frequently sets her apart. This reflex, which pulls her into or pushes her out of the company of whores, has confined until the present. In the surviving "serious" literature of the early Roman period, the habit of extracting Aspasia from the company of hetairai and relocating her in the company of wise women begins with Didymus. He, Cicero, and Quintilian all treated her with reverence, the Greek as a wise woman and the Romans as an exponent of rhetorical logic; these were the parts of her tradition Christian writers invoked on the few occasions Aspasia appeared in postpagan works. Curiously, Aspasia did not much interest Roman writers, perhaps because there were many powerful and sexually alluring Roman women and perhaps because Athens and her empire did not particularly fascinate the Romans. Of all the Imperial writers, Lucian the satirist concentrated most mockingly on the scurrilous elements of her tradition; but only Plutarch attempted to account for the contradictions in her bios. His willingness to remain in a state of aporia about Aspasia was in fact remarkable. The polymath Didymus Chalcenteros (" Brass Guts," from his ability to work hard), whose copious syntheses of earlier scholarship have been variously evaluated, wrote a Lexis Komike ("Comic Diction") and a Symposiaka or Symmeikta ("Sympotic Matters'V'Miscellanea"). The latter work contained a long passage on exceptional women from myth and history, including a sanitized Aspasia. (Didymus speculated elsewhere whether Sappho was a whore.) These discussions are interesting because they bring to the fore and make problematical the sexuality of women thought to be intellectually formidable: Aspasia's sexuality, like that of other women philosophers, is noticeably downplayed, whereas Sappho's is turned into a question mark. Didymus mentioned, but did not discuss, Aspasia's reputation in comedy; he set that reputation conspicuously apart from those accomplishments that he considers worth delineating: "And (as for) Aspasia the Milesian, concerning whom the comic poets also have recounted many things: Socrates derived an enjoyment of philosophy from her, and Pericles rhetoric" (frag. 7 Schmidt). The other women noted in this fragment, namely, Theano the Pythagorean and Arete, wife of Aristippus, are outstanding in respect to their intellect, love of family, and/or feminine virtue.21
The Sargasso Sea
67
Two Roman rhetorical works cited the Aeschinean Aspasia's famous conversation with Xenophon and his wife as a good example of inductio. Cicero defined inductio as the practice of getting one's interlocutor to agree with undisputed facts and then getting the interlocutor to assent to a doubtful proposition that resembles the earlier one. Quintilian stated that inductio was to arrive at a conclusion from the given problem's resemblance to points raised previously.22 Cicero notes that this kind of argumentation was favored by Socrates and also points out the strategic nature of the device: Hoc modo sermonis plurimum Socrates usus est propterea quod nihil ipse afferre ad persuadendum volebat, sed ex eo quod sibi ille dederat quicum disputabat, aliquid conficere malebat, quod ille ex eo quod iam concessisset necessario approbate deberet: "Socrates made great use of this style of conversation, because he didn't want to do any persuading himself. He preferred instead to make a result from the material that the interlocutor had given him, which result the interlocutor had necessarily to approve as following from what he had already conceded." (Inv. Rhet. 1.31.53)
Not unexpectedly, Cicero submerges the content of the original discussion—marital conduct—and the gender of the primary discussant, Aspasia, in favor of highlighting the rhetorical method and motive. It is interesting to note, however, that Cicero also attributed to Socrates the predominant usage of this method, ascribing to him a motive that touches on his liminality (as discussed earlier in chapter 3). Aspasia, her advice, and her own liminality are downplayed, whereas Socrates' use of this method and his own liminality are emphasized. Quintilian follows Cicero in highlighting Socrates' use of the method even as he disparages Cicero's separation of collatio ("comparison") from exemplum ("example," Inst. 5.11.2-3). Quintilian quotes less of the passage than did Cicero; he provides only Aspasia's conversation with the wife, omitting her discussion with the husband. Aspasia thus is not shown advising both sexes, but only another woman.23
Plutarch's Life of Pericles Plutarch (ca. 50-120 A.D.) is perhaps the most important single source in antiquity for Aspasia's biographical tradition. His importance as a biographer and source of social history are unquestioned; his work has pro-
68
Prisoner of History
roundly influenced the structure and content of biography in the West and its perceived relation to history. Plutarch's remarks about Aspasia both distill the most salient features of earlier treatments and, by virtue of their own preservation within his privileged corpus of biographical and moralizing writings, have become the source upon which most modern treatments depend. His willingness to take Aspasia seriously as a historical actor is remarkable. It is necessary to study Plutarch's two chapters on Aspasia in his Life of Pericles within the environment of Plutarch's own aims, oeuvre, and methods rather than to extract and treat them as a freestanding paradigm for the ambitious courtesan of later European cultural history. Current views of Plutarch consider that his purpose in writing the Lives was moral rather than historical, in that it aimed to show philosophy in action to his educated audience, and that Plutarch himself believed philosophical training the sine qua non for a life of action. Plutarch's Pericles can be considered a good example of philosophy in action. Plutarch was interested in the morally suasive power of biography and history and disparaged kakoethia (malignity) in such writing, most vividly expressing his views in the famous work best known by its Latin title De malignitate Herodoti ("On the Malignity of Herodotus"—De mal. Hdt.). His critique of Herodotus lists several ways in which a historical narrative can be malicious: if a narrative uses harsh or unkind words when these are avoidable: if the writer includes irrelevant failures and omits good deeds; if the writer presents the less plausible of conflicting reports; and if the writer attributes a discreditable motive when the facts are not in dispute, for example, that Pericles started the Peloponnesian war because of Aspasia or Phidias or that Thebe assassinated Alexander out of emotion rather than hatred of tyranny. I can add to these criteria Plutarch's observation elsewhere that events could also be distorted by contemporary observers for personal reasons (Per. 13.16), an important consideration when looking at his account of slanders against Aspasia.24 The fact that Plutarch devoted as much space as he did to Aspasia and provided so much information about her suggests that he considered her important for her own sake as well as for her association with charges that Pericles was tyrannical and had begun two wars for base motives. It is necessary, however, to look at what Plutarch said about her in the context of his entire Life of Pericles.25 Plutarch introduces Pericles as a subject whose study demonstrates the value of contemplating the actions
The Sargasso Sea
69
of good men; he includes those qualities shared by Pericles and his parallel biographand Fabius Maximus (1-2.5). Pericles' lineage and physical appearance are mentioned, as well as his teachers—Damon, who trained him for political contests in the same manner as an athlete was trained, and Zeno, who was skilled in cross-examination. Pericles derived his greatest benefit from Anaxagoras, and Plutarch summarizes his teaching in this work, providing as examples Pericles' calm charity to an abusive citizen and Anaxagoras' own dispassionate analysis of the significance of the one-horned ram (3-6). (Plutarch points out later that Pericles did not learn thrift from Anaxagoras, 16.7) The narration of Pericles' unfolding political career proceeds despite the lack of strict chronology and the absence of evidence for a prior biographical tradition; Plutarch fades in and out from general to highly specific statements, and acknowledges the dearth of primary evidence other than decrees (7-8).26 In addition to Aspasia, Elpinike is mentioned—she is reported to have had political dealings with Pericles, possibly engineering the recall of her brother Cimon and on another occasion entreating Pericles not to prosecute Cimon severely (10.5-6). Elpinike is sexualized by the report that Pericles gently rebuked her for attempting to charm him, but the allegation that Elpinike had obtained Cimon's recall by having sex with Pericles (Ath. 13.589e8-f2) is not repeated here. Thucydides, the son of Melesias, is Pericles' next political rival (1114), and Pericles' building program, a means by which he enabled the demos to enjoy Athens' wealth, occasions the mention of Phidias. Pericles' enemies assail the building program, likening it to a falsely preening woman (hosper alazona gynaika, 12.2). Pericles himself does not respond in kind to this sexually charged language; instead, he dryly explains his policy on the building and its expenditures (12.3-4). Phidias' position of responsibility and close friendship with Pericles are given as the reasons he was slandered; in fact, he is actually accused of having pimped free women for Pericles: " brought Phidias envy and Pericles slander, from the rumor that Phidias pimped free Athenian women for Pericles when they came to see his work in progress" (13.15).27 In the earlier part of this entire description, Pericles' enemies had characterized the city as a preening impostor woman; here, the chief beautifier of the city pimps for the head of state. The comic poets take up the tale (13.15), making the slander more specific by charging that Pericles had corrupted the wife of another strategos (elected general)
70
Prisoner of History
and that one Pyrilampus had given peacocks to several other female conquests of Pericles. The most damning charge Plutarch reports is that of Stesimbrotus, who accuses Pericles of corrupting his own daughterin-law. That Plutarch disbelieves these charges is apparent in the words he uses to report them: phthonon, blasphemian (envy and slander, 13.15, 13.16); the accusers are men of riotous and improvident ways (satyrikous tois biois), and Stesimbrotus' story is a dreadful and abominable impiety (deinon asebema kai mysodes). Thus, Plutarch deflects charges of Pericles' sexual impropriety by accusing the accusers of equal or worse misbehavior. Once Pericles has consolidated his rule, a string of adulatory metaphors describes how he governs—he is the city's doctor and teacher, and favors using a rein and a rudder to guide the people (14—16). His fiscal honesty is emphasized, as well as his immediate family's resentment of his household economies (15.3,16.4—5), a trait that Anaxagoras bears with somewhat more humor (16.8-9). Plutarch stresses the grandeur of Pericles' vision (17.4, on the Congress decree; cf. 21.1), as well as his reluctance to waste Athenian lives in connection with the revolt of Euboea and the Spartan invasion (18, 21-23). Prudence, foresight, and the conservation of Athenian lives are the hallmarks of Pericles' policy, things to which his deathbed utterance will allude. The expedition to Samos and Aspasia's putative role in it occasion Plutarch's discussion of Aspasia, managed in a brief transition (24.1-2). Plutarch's first and longest discussion of her (24.2-11; 25.1) bears careful reading. In it, Plutarch assembles much reportage but endorses almost none of it. The only things in the bios that he seemed to believe were her birthplace and her father's name: "It is agreed (homologeitai) that she was a Milesian and the daughter of Axiochus" (24.3). He immediately balances this assertion by not agreeing that Aspasia arrived in Athens as a new Thargelia: "But they say" (phasi d' . . . , 24.3). It is surprising that some modern historiographers are so certain about Aspasia's life because Plutarch, the source most often followed, expressed anything but certainty about it. His first words to describe his aim are highly tentative: entauth' an eie kairos diaporesai malista peri tes anthropou ("Perhaps it would be timely to raise the question about this individual here," 24.2). As Philip Stadter aptly translates, diaporesai means "to raise the question about"; the verb indicates doubt and questioning. Plutarch was willing enough to report what others said
The Sargasso Sea
71
about her, but he specifically located this reportage within the web of conjecture. Even when reporting what others have written about Aspasia, Plutarch casts doubt upon the information, allowing only "this much of historia'' (24.7) in the Menexenus' report, namely, that Aspasia had the reputation of discussing rhetoric with many Athenians. As for her supposed maternity, Plutarch notes that "Apparently (dokei) Pericles had a bastard by her," specifying that Eupolis made (pepoiekeri) Pericles the character ask about his bastard (24.10). He also reports as conjectural both her alleged role in the beginning of the Samian War (dokei, 24.2) and her emulation of Thargelia (24.3). Likewise disclaimed are the statements that Pericles kissed her when he came and went ("as they say," has phasi, 24.9) and that Pericles sought her because she was wise and politic (sophe kai politike, 24.5, reported with "they say," legousi).2S Use of the phrase "they say" also appears to disclaim the report that Socrates and company visited Aspasia, even though her occupation was not at all nice. Plutarch's conclusion to this chapter, with its brief remarks upon the concubine of Cyrus, sometimes called "Aspasia II" (24.11-12), forms a logical if somewhat unexpected end. He had introduced Aspasia of Miletus with the pointedly neutral he anthropos ("this individual") and noted that it would be apanthropon ("misanthropic") not to mention her namesake. The fame and character of the Milesian ("Aspasia I"), who allegedly held men in thrall (echeirosato) and occasioned philosophers neither a bad nor a short logos (24.2), explain why Cyrus renamed his favorite concubine for her. The life of Thargelia, the Milesian's supposed model, also comes into play. For Thargelia, "they say" (phasi d', 24.3), turned Hellenes to the Persian cause; Aspasia I, the object of Pericles' erotic love, reportedly urged him to make war on her homeland's enemy, and finally, Aspasia II gained influence at the Persian court due to the fortunes of war.29 But despite (or perhaps because of) all these data and all these sources, Aspasia remains a mystery. First, Plutarch qualifies most of the information. She is not described physically, although the early mention of Thargelia's beauty (24.4) may suggest that Aspasia too was lovely.30 Plutarch neither answers all the questions his account raised, nor explicitly solves its inconsistencies. He twice mentions the hostile tradition that Aspasia was the alleged instigator of the Samian War (24.1-2,
72
Prisoner of History
25.1); Plutarch, however, consistently defends Pericles' prosecution of the war and squelches Duris' stories about its atrocities (28.2-3), noting that neither Ephorus nor Thucydides recounts these details and concluding that Samos, a grave threat to Athens, carne close to wresting naval supremacy from her (28.8). I find Plutarch's failure to refute the specific charges against Aspasia to be telling: he believed that they were so ridiculous as to require no response and furthermore subtly suggested that Samos needed to be dealt with firmly. In another work, Plutarch mentions this very charge against Aspasia as the kind of statement characteristic of a writer who was dysmenes and kakoethes (De mat. Hdt. 855F-856A). Evidence of careful source criticism can be seen in Plutarch's use of qualifiers such as "on the one hand some say." Stadter believes that "Plutarch clearly accepts the notion that Aspasia supported herself by running a brothel." Because Plutarch's reference to her occupation occurs within a clause that begins "and some say, on the one hand, that . . . ," it does not follow that Plutarch himself believed Aspasia kept a brothel. In fact, Plutarch concedes belief in only one aspect of Aspasia's personality, namely, that Pericles was erotically devoted to her. The evidence for this is that after Pericles' amicable divorce, he "cherished extraordinarily" (esterxe diapherontos, 24.89).31 The next mention of Aspasia comes after Plutarch has provided more information about Pericles' life. After concluding his account of the Samian War and recounting Elpinike's rebuke to Pericles, Plutarch goes on to a discussion of the onset of the Peloponnesian War (29-32). Despite diplomatic efforts to rescind the Megarian decree—a move that Plutarch believed could have helped avoid the war (29.7-8), tensions mounted. Megara denied responsibility for an Athenian messenger's death, blaming Pericles and Aspasia in what Plutarch calls "notorious and vulgar little verses" (periboetois, demodesi, 30.4). These verses are, in fact, the famous lines from Aristophanes' Acharnians. Again, Plutarch's opinion is noncommittal, and he notes "ten men oun archen hopos eschen ou radian gnonai" ("but as far as how it began, it isn't easy to know," 31.1). Plutarch then discusses the persecution of Pericles' associates. The account of Phidias' trial and imprisonment (31.25) precedes and dwarfs the account of the persecutions of Aspasia and Anaxagoras (32). Just as Phidias earlier had been accused of pimping free women for Pericles, so too is Aspasia now accused (32.1). After a
The Sargasso Sea
73
brief mention of Aspasia's prosecution, Plutarch continues with discussion of Anaxagoras and of Pericles' expenditures (32.2—4) before returning to her acquittal, a decision reached, "as Aeschines says," by Pericles' crying and begging (32.5); the language used resembles that found in the report that Aspasia had begged for war against Samos (24.1-2), a report that Plutarch disqualified. Plutarch completes this portion of the Life by noting to d'alethes addon ("the truth is unclear," 32.6) in regard to Pericles' protection of Phidias and the civic wrath he had incurred. Plutarch opened and concluded this part of the Life with expressions of skepticism.32 A "ring" can be seen, enclosed in doubt: 31.1 "it is not easy to know" 31.2-5 Phidias 32.1-2 Aspasia, Anaxagoras 32.3-4 trial proceedings 32.5 Aspasia, Anaxagoras 32.6 Phidias; "the truth is unclear" The next section contains an account of ineffective Spartan attempts to revive interest in the legend of the curse upon the Alcmaeonids and an account of the Spartan invasion (33.1-6). Of all the comic choruses that attacked Pericles, Plutarch singles out Hermippus' verses, which called Pericles "king of the satyrs" (33.7-8, discussed in chapter 2). As the Life of Pericles continues, the plague malignly robs Pericles of the opportunity for success; the leader is further savaged by the demos, who attack him as one attacks a father or doctor (34.4-5). The final expedition's aim is to heal (iasthai, 35.1), but Pericles is stripped of his strategia and fined (35.4). Nor can Pericles find peace at home. Xanthippus ridicules Pericles (36.4), and Stesimbrotus is reported to have alleged that Xanthippus himself spread slander about Pericles and his daughter-in-law (36.6). Xanthippus dies of the plague unreconciled with his father, and Pericles loses his sister and many other relatives and friends (36.6-7). Plutarch declares that Pericles retained his composure until his son Paralus was laid out, only then bursting into violent tears, a thing that he had never done before (36.9). The assertion that Pericles wept like this but once may have been another way of undermining the veracity of the account of Pericles' tears at Aspasia's trial. When recalled to his strategia, Pericles returns without enthusiasm (37.1), but nonetheless has the presence of mind to ask for a personal
74
Prisoner of History
exemption to the law about nothoi, lest his own name and family die out. The nothos is enrolled in the phratry, and Pericles gives him his own name (37.5). Curiously, the man who best led Athens is portrayed as an outsider; estranged from his family, he entrusts his household accounts to a slave (16.6). Not content to remain with his legitimate wife and rarely in attendance at family functions, he has a deep friendship (philia) with Phidias (13.14) and an erotic love (erotike agapesis) for a foreign woman whom he cherishes extraordinarily (24.7-8).33 Uncritical readings of these sections of Plutarch's Life of Pericles have helped define Aspasia as the planful courtesan who starts wars and holds a great statesman in thrall. I believe that Plutarch considered Aspasia's nature to have been unknowable—that even though such a characterization had been suggested by earlier (unreliable) sources, her nature was by now indefinable. The effect of Plutarch's mention of so many of these sources, even though he seems to have done so only to discount or cast doubt upon them, nonetheless makes Aspasia the archetype of the sexually alluring and politically influential courtesan. The importance of such a construction cannot be stressed enough. To continue to construct Aspasia as a powerful prostitute, and to not read the ancient sources critically and historicize them as necessary, is to nativize two beliefs: first, that an intellectual woman's importance and influence are ultimately traceable to her manipulation of her own sexuality, and second, that intellectual women do not act autonomously, but rather upon and through men. As we shall see, uncritical readings of Plutarch, whose works were influential in the European Renaissance, helped foster the image of Aspasia that is still favored.
The End of the Pagan Tradition Thanks to Plutarch, we have an integrated summation of views about Aspasia. Other Greek intellectuals also mentioned her, but they refracted the wholistic Plutarchan view, using bits and pieces of her bios for purposes ranging from edification and rhetorical persuasion to sheer amusement. Yet, the presence of Aspasia across various discourses in the high and late Empire attests to her ability to function as a revenant of Socrates, Pericles, and the heyday of Athens.34 The sophist Maximus of Tyre (ca. 125-185) claimed to be a follower of Plato and, in his orations, eulogized Socrates. In a passage derivative
The Sargasso Sea
75
of the Socratica, Maximus identifies Socrates as foremost of the philosophers who exhorted in common talk rather then enigmatically:' 'We hear you <, Socrates,> many times affirming that you honor episteme more than anything, and recommending one teacher to one youth, and another to another—for example, even exhorting Callias to send his son to Aspasia the Milesian: a man to a woman! You yourself, an elderly man, frequent her company. Nor does she suffice as your teacher, but you glean for yourself erotics from Diotima, music from Konnos, poetics from Euenos, farming from Ischomachus, and geometry from Theodorus" (Oral. 38.4.b-d; cf. 24.4). This scrap is important because it indicates the syncretistic practice of sophists such as Maximus; he cobbled together his Socrates from portrayals in Plato, Aeschines, and Xenophon. Nor did Maximus care particularly about Aspasia, Diotima, or any woman's intellectual capabilities; they, and male teachers, are mentioned as purveyors of knowledge and skill to Socrates and his followers.35 Lucian of Samosata, Maximus of Tyre's more famous contemporary, used Aspasia with great facility in several of his satirical and epideictic works. In some respects, Lucian reprised all the previous treatments of Aspasia, but because he presents Aspasia both seriously and, as was more often the case, humorously, it is impossible to speculate on his actual view of her. In his Imagines, a woman's portrait is planned and discussed in a dialogue between Lykinos and Polystratos. They decide that earlier women shall be models for this portrait: Aspasia, Theano the Pythagorean, Sappho, and Diotima reflect the subject's intellect. Polystratos additionally invokes the virtuous Theano, wife of Antenor; Arete and her daughter, Nausicaa; and Penelope: Next, her wisdom and understanding (sophia and synesis) must be represented. We shall need many examples there, mostly ancient ones, and one Ionic like herself. Aeschines the friend of Socrates and Socrates himself represented her, both of them exceedingly true craftsmen because they worked with eros. That example is the famous Aspasia of Miletus, with whom the most wonderful Olympian <sc. Pericles> lived. Putting before us no mean image of understanding, let us bring to bear as much as she had of experience in affairs, acumen in politics, and quickness of wit, and with accurate measurement transfer it all to our own portrait. (Imagines 17)
This praise of Aspasia and other women recalls Didymus' list of exemplary women; like that list, it does not sexualize her.36
76
Prisoner of History
Lucian, however, was equally capable of exploiting the more risque aspects of Aspasia's biographical tradition. In his satirical work Okypous ("Swiftfoot"), he made the title character the son of Podaleirius and Astasia ("Gout" and "Inability to Stand"), names that resemble Pericles' and Aspasia's and that may parodize Cratinan coinage. He represented Aspasia as a hetaira in The Dream or The Cock, wherein the cock discusses his prior incarnations as both Pythagoras and Aspasia: as Aspasia, he lived with Pericles, bore children, spun yarn, and "was a woman, hetaira-fashion" (The Dream 19); the cock was later incarnated as the cynic Crates. The straight man, Micyllus, exclaims, "By the Dioskouroi, what an unlikelihood—from a courtesan to a philosopher!" (The Dream 20). The underside of this joke, of course, is the by now familiar notion that philosophy and prostitution are similar practices. In The Eunuch, a eunuch tries to demonstrate that his kind should not be excluded from the practice of philosophy; he suggests that if Aspasia, Thargelia, Diotima, and the eunuch Favorinus have participated in philosophy, he also should be permitted to engage in it (Eun. 7). The passage exploits Aspasia's reputation as a women philosopher even while it renders "the female philosopher" categorically abnormal; the dialogue humorously reveals philosophy's masculinist bias. A mixed acknowledgment of Aspasia's possible influence upon Socrates is given in The Dance, wherein one character notes in the same sentence that the philosopher did not spurn the opportunity to learn even insignificant things (ta mikra, 25) from flute girls but also listened to serious matters from Aspasia; she is described with Herodotus' periphrastic euphemism, "hetaira gyne" ("companion female"), someone from whom Socrates could learn "something serious" ("spoudaion ti").37 Fictional and embellished historical letters also used Aspasia. Alciphron's Letters of Courtesans present fictional and historical courtesans' correspondence; letter 7 suggests the general association of philosophers with prostitutes. Thais complains to Euthydemus that he has no time for her now that he has taken up philosophy (letter 7.1-2). She compares herself to philosophers by reminding the youth that his own teacher is mad for her, and that sophists do not differ from hetairai (7.2, 7.4), particularly in their shared love of gain (to labein, 7.4). The hetaira, however, is the better in that she does not incite her students to meddle in politics (7.6); as Thais says, "We don't teach young men any worse than they do. Decide, if you like, between Aspasia the hetaira and Socrates the sophist, and consider which of them did a better job
The Sargasso Sea
77
. You will see that Pericles was her pupil and Critias his!" (7.6-7) This second- or third-century remark derives from comedy and Socratica. Similarly derivative of the classical period, the sophist Philostratus' Seventy-third Letter to Julia Domna, the learned Roman empress, remarks on the classical sophists' influence and includes Aspasia in their number. He claimed that Plato himself emulated the literary forms of the sophists and that numerous Greeks emulated Gorgias. These include Critias, Thucydides, Aeschines of Sphettos, and Aspasia the Milesian, who "is said to have sharpened Pericles' tongue to imitate Gorgias." The final pagan writer of this time to mention Aspasia is a senator from Constantinople, Themistius, a pagan apologist and ideologue. One of the last great sophists, Themistius mentioned Aspasia in his twentysixth Oration, wherein he defended himself against those who criticized him for openly discussing philosophy. Themistius averred that philosophy, like other arts, should be permitted an open forum and that Plato and Socrates thought philosophy could improve men. In an attempt to show that philosophy should be practiced as a living art, Themistius claimed that one should not praise only Aspasia, Pericles, and those of Anaxagoras' generation. Thus, Aspasia and Pericles are associated together as representatives of a classical past, a past whose best traditions should not be allowed to fossilize.38 Aspasia's sexuality functions as a liability in this derivative pagan literature; when she is praised, her sexual reputation is rarely mentioned. Christian writers also briefly made use of her; in the end, however, they seemed to be unable to overlook Aspasia's allegedly illicit sexual behavior—or possibly her sex itself—and, as will be shown in the next section, she disappeared from the literature.
The Christian Point of View By the middle of the second century, Christianity constituted what George Kennedy calls "a serious intellectual influence of international dimensions," creatively transforming pagan classical tradition.39 Perhaps because Aspasia's dubious sexual reputation was so inextricably bound up with her intellectual one, early Christian writers did not incorporate her into their views of the classical past; when she was mentioned, her reputed sexual life was excised. Clement, Synesius, and
78
Prisoner of History
Theodoret all sanitized her; Tertullian and Salvianus, obsessed with whores, did not mention her at all. Clement of Alexandria, born in Athens around 150 to pagan parents, subsequently converted, obtained an education at Alexandria, and succeeded his teacher, Pantaenus, as head of the catechistic school there. He fled Alexandria during Lucius Septimius Severus' persecutions of 202 and died about ten years later. Clement referred once to Aspasia in his Stromateis ("Miscellanies"), a work heavily indebted to Didymus that attempts to demonstrate Christianity's superiority to paganism. In it, Clement discusses the virtues of women such as Judith, Esther, Susanna, and Moses' sister, Miriam (Strom. 118.1-119.3); he then recounted exemplary women of the pagan world by inserting a passage from Didymus' Symposiaka (discussed in an earlier section of this chapter), which detailed the loyalty and virtue of Greek women, including Aspasia. Of Aspasia, Clement observes only that she came from Miletus and that Socrates and Pericles learned philosophy and rhetoric, respectively, from her (122.3). Clement went on to discuss Sarah, and noted that Hebrew princesses and Nausicaa both virtuously performed homely tasks (Strom. 123.1). Thus, Aspasia became one of many chaste and exemplary women in a context that did not mention her sexual reputation. This type of material is interesting because it prefigures the discussion of "women worthies" in the Middle Ages and Renaissance, and the pictorial tradition of representing heroic women in Renaissance and later art.40 The Christian neo-Platonist Synesius of Cyrene, a pupil of Hypatia, the female philosopher, defended "Aspasian" erotics in a limited sense. In his Dion, which attacked the decline of humanism, Synesius notes that Socrates assigned an epitaphios to Aspasia, whose company he frequented for the sake of learning ta erotika. Synesius observes that if one considered Aspasia's and Socrates' erotics, one would understand the relationship of that erotics to philosophy. Punning on aspasios' meaning of "pleasing" or "welcoming," Synesius notes that the cognizant individual would recognize philosophy as a good, and welcome and praise it (Dion 59A). Concerned with the Greek world's lapse into barbarism, Synesius enlists Socrates and, briefly, Aspasia in his cause. Aware of Aspasia's reputation, Synesius nonetheless does not specifically refer to it in this treatise.41 Like Clement of Alexandria, to whom he was indebted, Theodoret, bishop of Cyrrhus in Syria, contrasted paganism invidiously to Chris-
The Sargasso Sea
79
tianity. His Hellenikon Therapeutike Pathematon ("Cure for Greek Maladies") contrasted the two religious systems, and in it he mentioned Aspasia once. After stating that the greatest Greek philosophers, such as Pherecydes, Pythagoras, Thales, Solon, and Plato learned from the East and Egypt, sparing no effort to find enlightenment in all possible quarters (1.12-16), Theodoret remarks that Socrates, that best of philosophers, did not consider it unworthy to learn something from women, for he did not blush to call himself the student of Diotima, and frequented Aspasia as well (1.17). Theodoret goes on to say that the Greeks learned much from the barbarians; as does Lucian in The Dance, he identifies Aspasia as a somewhat unsuitable but not entirely unworthy source of knowledge.42 Two churchmen who did not mention Aspasia nonetheless suggest through indirection why Aspasia—neither a martyr nor a penitent Magdalene—was too problematic to be useful to any Christian argument that pagan evidence might bolster. Tertullian, active in Carthage in the late second century, interpreted Christian teachings in a highly ascetic manner and was an extreme advocate of female modesty. Preoccupied with the dangers of sexual depravity, Tertullian was distressed that Carthaginians let matrons and whores dress alike (Apol. 6.3), and he noted that Cato and Socrates shared their wives with others: leno est philosophus et censor ("The philosopher and the censor are each a pimp," Apol. 39.13). Tertullian also stated that Socrates should be considered a whoremaster for having suggested that wives be held in common. The only woman identified as a prostitute who is praised by Tertullian in his fulminous Apologeticum was Leaina, mistress of the tyrannicides, in a chapter that decried the fact that pagan martyrs mostly died in ways that glorified only the individual (Apol. 50.8).43 Salvianus, bishop of Marseilles in the later fifth century, was a close follower of Tertullian and reflected the elder churchman in his statements that Socrates and other ancients pimped their own wives (de Gubernitate Dei, "On God's Governance," 7.101-103); of Socrates, Salvianus says lupanar fecit e mundo ("he made a brothel of the world," 7.103).44 Lexicographers and encyclopedists from the second through tenth centuries A.D. preserved scraps of information that add little to the picture of Aspasia's biographical tradition sketched by earlier sources; one constant in this information is her connection with Pericles. Most probably because her dubious sexual reputation was an integral part of her biographical tradition, because Socrates—her supposed pupil—was
80
Prisoner of History
himself problematic for some Christians, and simply because she was a woman, Aspasia was not able to take a place among pagans adopted by Christian writers as positive exempla. Aspasia and her bios faded out of both Western and Byzantine sources.45
A Pictorial Tradition? The attempt to find a pictorial tradition for Aspasia parallel to her appearance in literary texts in the Hellenistic, Roman, and Late Antique periods is unsatisfying. Some representations have been identified as being of Aspasia; the correctness of these identifications, impossible to prove, is almost less important than the fact that they seek to locate Aspasia with Socrates in symposiac or festive contexts. The Vatican portrait herm discussed in chapter 1, may date from the Roman period.46 Two terra-cotta reliefs survive, one Hellenistic and one Roman. On them are a seated woman (on the left), holding a wreath, a winged figure (in the center), and a man facing the woman (on the right). These reliefs, apparently molded from the same original, were manufactured as ornaments. The earlier relief, dated to the third to second centuries B.C. , was originally part of the handle attachment of two silvered terra-cotta pails and is now in the Museo Nazionale in Naples. Various identities have been suggested: Diotima or Aspasia or Aphrodite have been put forth for the woman, the winged figure is agreed to be Eros, and the male has been identified either as Socrates or more generally as a teacher. The second relief, dated to the Roman period, was discovered in Pompeii in 1882 on a bronze relief attached to a chest; it too is now housed at the Museo Nazionale in Naples. Karl Schefold identifies the seated female as a hetaira.47 A Roman sarcophagus—discovered in the eighteenth century and now located in the Louvre—has on it a woman and Socrates conversing under an archway. The woman has been identified as Aspasia or a Muse; because Socrates is readily recognizable, art historians have been eager to name his female companion as well.48 Bone carvings that were used as furniture ornaments are also said to have portrayed Aspasia. A pair of Alexandrian carvings of the third to fourth centuries A.D., now in the Boston Museum of Fine Arts, shows a Silenus-type Socrates and a woman (Aspasia?) holding a wreath in her right hand. It has been sug-
The Sargasso Sea
81
gested that there were statuary pairs of Socrates and Aspasia in basilicas and libraries during the Roman period; other than the works noted here, which are only tentatively identified, there is no evidence. Again, the persistent tendency to locate Aspasia in men's company can be seen.49 In the Hellenistic, Roman, and Late Antique periods, written texts persistently grouped Aspasia with a man, be it Pericles or Socrates, or both. Art historians have continued to situate Aspasia with men as well. It would be left to the modern period to give Aspasia an individual identity of the complexity approaching that which she possessed in Aeschines' lost dialogue.
This page intentionally left blank
5 Aspasia in the Postclassical West
The Middle Ages, the Renaissance, and the Baroque Periods The Greek East and the Latin West both figured women as sinful vessels. As Greek sources and the knowledge of Greek disappeared from the West, most information about Aspasia was lost. The Middle Ages, which has recently been identified as the time when feminist consciousness first germinated, saw women speaking and thinking in a Christian context, whether as mystics inspired by God, or as authorized to speak and think through their own motherhood. The Christian environment of that time would appear to have been an unpromising one for the development of Aspasia's bios.' Aspasia enters the modern period with Heloise's laudatory reference in her first letter to Peter Abelard. Heloise's tragic affair with Abelard has been greatly romanticized; the existence and afterlife of the lovers' correspondence has invested their relationship with a larger-than-life dimension fueled more by her passionate declarations than by Peter's chilly, reasoned replies. Heloise (ca. 1100-1164) is the first woman known to have considered Aspasia as an authority and example for the way she wanted to live her own life.2 Heloise's first letter to Abelard responds to his Historia Calamitatum, a melodramatic autobiographical piece in which he tells of his education, his pride in his erudition, and his affair with Heloise and its unhappy outcome. Berating his lust not only for Heloise but also for whores (Hist. Cal. pp. 70-71, lines 252-279 Monfrin), Abelard spoke 83
84
Prisoner of History
of regret and chastened pride, and frequently referred to Scripture. In contrast, Heloise's salutation reidentifies her without shame. "To her master, nay father; to her husband, nay brother; his handmaid, nay daughter; his spouse, nay sister; to Abelard, Heloise" (p. Ill, lines 2-4 Monfrin). She refers less frequently in this first letter to Christian or scriptural authority than to Greco-Roman texts, and thereby locates herself in an otherworld, or perhaps between the two worlds. In declaring her unbounded love for Abelard, Heloise states that God knows she would follow him to the Vulcania loca (" Vulcanian places,' ' p . 117, line 247 Monfrin), a locale far off the Christian map. Heloise also avoids placement within conventional categories for women by boldly claiming membership in the category of concubine or whore: ' 'And if the name of 'wife' seems holier and more valid, to me the word 'friendship' has always been a sweeter thing—or, if you weren't ashamed, the name of 'concubine' or even 'whore' (scorti)" (p. 114, lines 147-151 Monfrin). Heloise uses a pagan woman's authority to try to persuade Abelard that their love is good: As the inductio peformed by the philosopher (philosophe) Aspasia with Xenophon and his wife in the work of Aeschines Socraticus plainly convinces us. When the aforesaid philosopher <sc., Aspasia> had advanced this argument for their reconciliation, she ended it in this way: "For when you have cultivated this [idea], that there is not a better man nor a happier woman in all the land, then you will always desire that which you think the best; you to be the husband of the best possible wife, and she to be wedded to the most excellent husband." This opinion is surely blessed, and more than philosophical, for it speaks wisdom itself rather than of philosophy, (p. 11, lines 167-178 Monfrin)3 Heloise's statements that the label of Abelard's meretrix would be dearer and more dignified than even that of Augustus' empress (p. 114, lines 157-161 Monfrin), as well as her numerous arguments against the belief that mere marriage guarantees love, show a continued identification with the pagan. Additionally, this refusal to endorse indicates a thoughtful adoption of the "Aspasian" ideals that entail mutual commitment rather than belief in the promise that some particular emotional status will be granted with the assumption of a social role. Heloise's citation of Aspasia as an authority also suggests that for Heloise there existed at least the possibility of a woman-centered consciousness. Whereas pagan and Christian writers gave short shrift to Aspasia's participation in either side of the great debate over the value of pagan
Aspasia in the Postclassical West
85
culture, Heloise unregenerately claimed not only pagan values, but also a woman's values alongside other, more orthodox classical authorities. In his own letters, Abelard suffocated these values under a Christian blanket. Heloise probably knew of Aeschines' Aspasia only through Cicero's De Inventione Rhetorica, which was canonical in medieval Europe, and Cicero did not name Aspasia as a courtesan. Therefore, Heloise's admiration for Aspasian thought and her embrace of the title "concubine or even whore" are not necessarily connected. Although the chaste and queenly Philosophia of Boethius had attacked his interest in secular literature by calling the Muses of such works poisonous and sterile, theatrical little harlots, Heloise not only praised the role of the meretrix but also asserted that Aspasia's advice transcended philosophy.4 Peggy Kamuf perceptively interprets Heloise's refusal to "convert" to the nunlike status of Christ's bride, and her attempt to remain Abelard's lover, as important moments in the history of consciousness; she calls Heloise's insistence on the erotic an attempt to destabilize the hierarchical and sublimated oppositions that Abelard had forced upon her.5 Heloise's adoption of Aspasia as a model, and her comment that Aspasia transcends philosophy, are additional components of this moment and deserve more emphasis. In fact, Heloise persistently identifies herself as an outsider in the world Abelard and others would have had her inhabit, claiming the right to seek wisdom in her own way and to her own ends, but not as a penitent Magdalene. Abelard's reply to this first letter ignores most of what she said, asserting that he hadn't written because he didn't think she really needed him (65 Moncrieff), thus denying the existence, let alone the legitimacy, of Heloise's desire. References to the husband and wife relationship abound (68-69 Moncrieff); such references effectively obliterate his lover's claims by ignoring her remarkable salutation and her claim to the title of meretrix. Abelard overloads his letter with the very definition Heloise had refused. Furthermore, his first letter is rife with scriptural references, in contrast to Heloise's many references to pagan sources. Heloise's second letter laments her lot and that of her sister nuns, as well as Abelard's mutilation. Blaming marriage for their misfortunes, she declares that in fornication they were happy (78 Moncrieff). But here she begins to capitulate to him by fighting on his ground; the numerous pagan authorities of her first letter yield here to Christian references. The "honorary Christian," Seneca, is her only pagan
86
Prisoner of History
citation. Nonetheless, Heloise reasserts her desire for Abelard and states that she desired to please him rather than God (82 Moncrieff). This desire to please an individual mortal rather than an unseen transcendent Being is a logical extension of Aspasia's highly contextual and personal advice.6 Abelard's insistence in his second letter to Heloise that she sublimate her desire by accepting her state as the bride of Christ, referring all to Heaven and denying earthly pleasures, can be read as a refusal of Aspasia's message, as can his claim that his castration is the greater punishment (103-104 Moncrieff). According to this calculus, women are inferior to men because they cannot suffer as greatly as men can; Aspasia's message, however, implies equal capabilities between the sexes. In her third and final letter, Heloise directs her attention away from their relationship and asks for a discussion of the origin of nuns and for a rule that would suit women (109-110 Moncrieff). One may surmise that Heloise abandoned trying to convince Abelard of anything and accepted her new role. This was not without having suggested that, on the most basic of levels, men do not understand women (112 Moncrieff). Heloise notes that Benedict's prescription for monks' clothing would not suit nuns, who menstruate and therefore need different garments. Unable to realize her ambition to be Abelard's meretrix, Heloise was forced to adopt the role of a bride of Christ. It proved impossible for her to live an "Aspasian" life with him because the participation of both parties was required; furthermore, the Aspasian path is empirical and earthly, not contemplative or sublimated, as Peter had demanded. Heloise's thwarted desire is poignant because she aspired to be something that her model would neither have sought nor gloried in. Furthermore, the nun's burning passion for the charismatic and unavailable Abelard finds no counterpart in the fuller biographical tradition, unknown to Heloise, which made Pericles the devoted if not besotted lover of an ambitious courtesan. Heloise's devotion to Peter survives in what Michele Le Doeuff calls the "Heloise complex."7 Thus, Heloise made a flawed and unsuccessful attempt to own and name her sexual desires. This assertion preceded the traditional beginnings of modern Western feminism; the historian Joan Kelly has located these beginnings in the life and work of Christine de Pizan (ca. 1363-ca. 1431). Kelly points out the radical force of Pizan's assertion, in The Book of the City of Ladies, that valid self-knowledge is possible for
Aspasia in the Postclassical West
87
women without men's intervention. The general, theoretical, and historically based defense of women begun by Pizan would be supplemented by experientially based definitions and defenses of and by women, which oftentimes took the form of catalogues of virtuous women from throughout Western history. As most of these rehabilitative lists were based on biblical and Roman sources, Aspasia appeared relatively late, after Plutarch's Lives became available in Latin and vernacular languages. Cicero's and Quintilian's mentions of her did not record any display of virtue suitable for inclusion in such catalogues. Once Plutarch was available in translation, Aspasia entered, in the company of Pericles, naturally.8 The catalogue was a Greco-Roman form much used by medieval and Renaissance writers, but it was only one of the many ways in which the Renaissance brought to life historical persons of the ancient world. Another interesting manifestation of the age's love of the classical was the collection, display, and publication of antique coins—a visual analogue to the literary catalogue. This phenomenon helped feed into another, namely, the publication of the immensely popular "medallion books," which provided engravings of actual coins or, in many cases, imaginary coin-type portraits of exemplary historical figures, and was enriched with brief biographical sketches. Aspasia appeared in at least three such books, complete with imaginary portrait and brief biographical sketch. The immensely popular Promptuarium Iconum of Guillaume Rouille, first published in Lyon in 1553 and subsequently translated from Latin into French, Italian, and Spanish, was a kind of illustrated "Who's Who'' of the most renowned individuals from the beginning of the world until the time of the work's publication. Rouille placed Aspasia next to Pericles; he gave Plutarch's Pericles as his sole source for Aspasia, whom he discussed in seven lines. Rouille noted her amatory alliance with Pericles and Pericles' singular love and affection for her. He also reported the allegation that she persuaded Pericles to go to war against Samos and stated that Pericles formed his liaison with Aspasia after an amicable divorce from his wife. Pericles, described in eighteen lines, is also given a portrait. Rouille cited Plutarch, Thucydides, Xenophon, and Erasmus as his sources for Pericles. The two lovers face each other on the page; Aspasia is not seen outside of the company of Pericles (Figure 5.1). Everything that is said about Aspasia in the biographical
88
Prisoner of History
Figure 5.1. Woodcuts of imaginary coin portraits of Aspasia and Pericles. Guillaume de Rouille, Promptuarium Inconum (Lyons: Rouille, 1553) vol. 1, p. 119.
sketch concerns her relationship to Pericles; she, however, is not mentioned at all in the sketch about him. Rouille indeed used Plutarch but in a highly selective manner.9 Just a century later, angry because such catalogue authors as Boccaccio had omitted many examples of women's intellect, the Venetian feminist Arcangela Tarabotti composed a passionate tract, La semplicitd ingannata, o tirannia paterna (1654), which filled many gaps in the conventional lists. She asked why they did not mention Aspasia, the teacher of Pericles, and noted other women commonly omitted from the lists.10 Tarabotti's near-contemporary, the French savant Gilles de Menage (1613-1692), published the influential Historia Mulierum Philosopharum (History of Women Philosophers). This work possibly was inspired by Menage's acquaintance with the salons of such intellectual women as Madame de Scudery and his friendship with an editor and translator of the classics, Anne Lefebvre Dacier, whom he addressed as "feminarum doctissima" in the book's dedication to her. It may also have been modeled on work of the ancient biographer of the philosophers, Diogenes Laertius, about whom Menage had already written. His history of women philosophers was first published in Latin in 1690 in Lyons but did not appear in French until an abridgement was issued in 1758. In this work, Menage defined women as philosophers if they were called a philosopher, learned, or wise by an ancient source; if they were the relative, friend, or disciple of some known philosopher; or if they had done something that could be called philosophical. By using these
Aspasia in the Postclassical West
89
criteria, Menage assembled sixty-five women philosophers from antiquity to his own day.11 Aspasia appeared in his first chapter on philosophers of no definite sect, in the company of some eighteen other women, including Diotima, Julia Domna, St. Catherine, AnnaComnena, and Heloise. Menage carefully assembled the major sources. He states as fact that the Milesian's father was Axiochus, that she taught rhetoric to Pericles and rhetoric and philosophy to Socrates, and that she was the mistress of Pericles and later his wife. He evidently believed that Pericles married her after she was captured by the Athenians and that the marriage provoked the Samian and the Peloponnesian wars; all other information is qualified. He also relates that Aspasia was depicted in the medallion books of Bellorio and Canini. The original gem was in the possession of a lady called Felicia Rondanina. This antique jasper stone is described as being labelled Aspasou (possibly, as Menage pointed out, an incorrect genitive form for the formation Aspaso); Menage described the engraving as of a beautiful long-haired woman, armed with a helmet and shield. And indeed, Canini's portrait of Aspasia is just so. On the lady's helmet is painted a four-horse chariot, and above the chariot, Pegasus and the Sphinx, a fantastic iconography that cannot possibly have come from classical antiquity (Figure 5.2). Interestingly, however, Aspasia's martial reputation, as seen on the stone, comprised a large part of what Menage endorsed in his own presentation of the information about her.12
The Eighteenth Century Her presence in medallion books, in Tarabotti's defense of women, and in the influential Historia Mulierum Philosopharum would have made Aspasia known (if not well known) to literate Europeans interested in women's history. Dictionaries and encyclopedias also mentioned her; these were heavily dependent on Plutarch, with "spice" from Athenaeus. Jean Leconte de Bievre, following Plutarch's mention of the two Aspasias, published his credulous Histoire des deuxAspasies in 1736.13 The "other" Aspasia is, of course, Cyrus' mistress of the same name. Leconte did nothing to unite his treatment of these women except to note in his introduction that important women deserve treatment equal to men's at the hands of historians. The work is essentially bipartite, with ninety-two pages devoted to the Milesian and forty-seven to the other
90
Prisoner of History
Figure 5.2. Engraved gemstone portrait of Aspasia. Giovanni Angelo Canini. Iconografia doe Desegni d'Imagini de Famosissimi Monarchi, Regi, Filosofi, Poeti ed Ordtori dell'Antichita (Rome: Lazari, 1669) p. 121.
Aspasia; each section has a separate contents and an index. Credulous of Plutarch, Leconte considered Aspasia to have imitated Thargelia—a femme galante—to have gotten an Ionian education in rhetoric and science, and to have had an ability to teach, expressed as 'Tart de bien dire, de gagner les coeurs, de persuader, de gouverner les esprits." Pericles was said to have fallen in love with his teacher in a way that resonated with other romanticized pairs such as Heloise and Abelard: "Rarement une belle femme orne 1'esprit par ses instructions, sans
Aspasia in the Postclassical West
91
toucher le coeur par ses graces . . . 1'Amour se joignit aux Muses pour former leur union." Leconte states as fact not only that Pericles married Aspasia, but also that Pericles junior was the pair's natural child. The next known representation of Aspasia was the amazing feminist vision rendered by the young portraitist, Marie-Genevieve Bouliar. In the frightening and heady years of the French Revolution in which women themselves participated and during which laws were passed on their behalf, Bouliar (1763-1825) painted Aspasie, her only surviving classical subject painting, in 1794. Exhibited at the Salon of 1795, it garnered a Prix d'Encouragement. Born in Paris, Bouliar was educated by Joseph Siffred Duplessis (1725-1802), one of the period's most celebrated portraitists, whose unconventional positioning of his subjects suggested their individuality. Bouliar exhibited at the Salons from 1791 until 1817, with interruptions from 1802 to 1808 and 1808 to 1817. Her father may have been the Parisian engraver Jacques Bouliard, who also exhibited at the Salon of 1791. If this is so, Bouliar's early life followed the pattern often seen among female artists: the artistic gift was manifested and nurtured by the family, particularly by the father. The few known facts of her life suggest a pattern counter to the norm of marriage and motherhood: Bouliar, who seems never to have married and to have died at the home of friends, had a productive span of more than two dozen years and apparently made most of her living as a portraitist.14 Bouliar, like many other female artists, was primarily a portraitist. Her Aspasie, although a departure from her usual fare of living subjects, was also a portrait. This was fitting, inasmuch as Aspasia' reported life events did not lend themselves to scenes of vivid emotion or violent action as did those of other popular classical and/or biblical subjects. Nor was Aspasia a known or popular female subject, as she did not belong to the categories of femmes fortes or of Weibermacht. For the female artist, moreover, any depiction of Aspasia, given her troubling sexual reputation, would have been problematic. Bouliar's choice of this subject, therefore, even in an age that had many female classical subjects, is important and suggests that the artist felt strongly about it. In her study of the Baroque painter Artemisia Gentileschi, Mary Garrard notes the attraction of heroic women subjects for women painters in her observation that Gentileschi needed "to identify personally with her characters in order to bring them to life." Many heroic women subjects, as well as the women who painted them, were outsiders; Aspasia was a
92
Prisoner of History
quintessential outsider. It is impossible to know Bouliar's self-concept and whether she thought of herself as an outsider, let alone what of herself she put into the Aspasie, but the painter seems to have had a deep sympathy for her subject and to have given much thought to the representation of her.15 The Aspasie, the first known representation of Aspasia by a woman artist, was called "the masterpiece of her small surviving oeuvre" by art historian Linda Sutherland Harris (Figure 5.3). The painting was exhib-
Figure 5.3. Oil painting, Aspasie. Marie-Genevieve Bouliar, 1795. Courtesy Musee d'Arras (France).
Aspasia in the Postclassical West
93
ited at the Musee Napoleon (Louvre), decorated Fontainbleau from 1837 to 1875, and in 1876 was given by the state to the museum at Arras, its present home. In it, Aspasia is shown seated in a dimly lit, arched interior that contains a table with flowers at her left and a bust of Pericles in the background. She rests her left hand on the table and in that hand holds an unwrapped scroll lettered in Greek. In her right hand she holds a mirror into which she gazes. Her legs are open and the feet, not seen because the painting terminates in the middle of her calves, would have been crossed at the ankles. Aspasia wears a heavy overdrape and a diaphanous undertunic, which has slipped off her right shoulder and bares the right breast. The woman is brightly illuminated, as are the surface of the table, the scroll, the flowers, and the back of the mirror, from a light source in front of her.16 Francoise Maison's 1972 Arras catalogue entry identifies the importance of Plutarch's Pericles to contemporary understanding of Aspasia's milieu, and, in its analysis of the painting, notes iconographic correspondences with other French paintings. The Harris and Nochlin catalogue commentary also reads the painting with Plutarch. The bared breast is considered to be a reference to Aspasia's erotic nature, a nature, moreover, that called into question her intellectualism. Nochlin and Harris consider her solitude a momentary one in which she perhaps awaits Pericles or Socrates; they suggest that the portrait constitutes "a gentle plea, couched in the most respectable of artistic language, for the equality of women."17 It is possible to grant Aspasia more subjectivity than this by reading the painting in concert with developments in European feminism, as well as with iconographic conventions and with Plutarch himself. First, I note her gaze into the mirror. Harris, following tradition, called this pose a reference to Aspasia's putative erotic beauty; tradition might indeed class this painting among the numerous Venuses at the toilette. But Aspasia is hardly at her toilette: cosmetics are absent, and in her other hand she holds a Greek text rather than a comb or hair ornament. Nor does she look at the viewer, as do many of the pornographic pictures of women who primp or invite the voyeur's gaze in the most unlikely situations. One can recall the advice of Christine de Pizan's divine instructress: look in the mirror to find yourself, and don't listen to men.18 It is at least as likely that Bouliar chose to show Aspasia looking into the mirror in order to better know herself in accord with the Greek
94
Prisoner of History
maxim, gnothi sauton ("know thyself")- The iconography of the mirror as a mirror of the soul was well established by Bouliar's day, and Socrates was painted holding up a mirror to his students. Garrard notes that women artists in particular used the mirror as a symbol of selfknowledge. Who better to hold up a mirror than Socrates' own teacher? The image suggests that Aspasia is practicing a technique that she would later pass on to Socrates. Her response to her image is one of thoughtful engagement; she does not smile coquettishly or narcissistically. In her left hand Aspasia holds a Greek text, which indicates produced knowledge—the eternal textual' 'product,'' and in her right hand the mirror— the path to self-knowledge. Self-knowledge is a dynamic process that occurs only at those moments when we seek it. Aspasia holds the scroll but looks in the mirror; this suggests that the self-knowledge that is produced by introspection is primary and that the textual product is incidental. Like Socrates, Aspasia left no written work.19 Aspasia's clothing and the positioning of her body are also noteworthy. It is true that bared breasts can signify the erotic, but one bared breast is Amazonian, suggestive of the self-sufficient and forceful woman. One recalls Plutarch's reports that Aspasia urged Pericles to practice an aggressive foreign policy, and that seventeenth-century medallion portraits emphasized the Minerval aspect of Aspasia. Additionally, tradition has it that Pericles defended his beloved by begging and weeping. No ancient source says that Aspasia loved Pericles or anyone else. Bouliar's Aspasia, self-confident and at ease, does not appear to be eagerly awaiting a male visitor. Her relaxed lower limbs suggest a state of comfort. Aspasia sits as men do, with her legs casually apart and with no attention drawn to her genital area. In the background is the bust of Pericles, not Pericles himself or any suggestion of his literal presence in her life. Bouliar placed his image in the dark, as she positioned the living Aspasia in the light. The bust, like the globe, functions as furniture, indicating, perhaps, Aspasia's interests and concerns (or the bios' reportage of these). Certainly Pericles' statue does not have the function of a guardian angel. In fact, Bouliar avoided representing the dominatrix suggested by ancient comedy, the elegant saloniere her own day imagined Aspasia to have been, or the winsome creature that Victorian novels would produce. Aspasia does not exist here in relation to some Other. She is not the signifier or phallic woman but is herself the significant, shown in the dynamic process of fulfilling Pizan's instructor's advice. Bouliar, like Christine de Pizan and Arte-
Aspasia in the Postclassical West
95
misia Gentileschi, transformed those intellectual and allegorical traditions that had rendered the female "signifier rather than the significant."20 Bouliar also alluded to the negative aspects of Aspasia's bios. The cut or potted flowers on the table and the garland draped over the back of her chair give an ambivalent cast. Do these flowers, removed from their natural environment to be cut and shaped, suggest that Aspasia's life was also fashioned by desires not her own, that it was cultivated rather than allowed to proceed freely—that it was in a sense unnatural? If the painting has not been cut down, Bouliar has literally cut off Aspasia's feet, thereby immobilizing her in a darkened room. By showing Aspasia as a young woman, did Bouliar imply that her mature years would have been less happy? The cut flowers and the single figure, apparently content to be alone, might also suggest an unrealized potential, which sometimes occurs when a talented individual lacks true peers, becoming what Mary Daly calls "a cognitive minority of one."21
Aspasia on the Continent, in England, and in the New World in the Nineteenth Century Three years after Bouliar's Aspasie was exhibited, Nicholas-Andre Monsiau located her once again in the company of men in his 1798 painting Aspasie s'entretenant avec Alciblades et Socrate. He engulfed her with men in his Aspasie s'entretenant avec les hommes les plus illustres d'Athenes, which he created for the Salon of 1806 (Figure 5.4). The painting illustrated the then-popular notion that Aspasia held salons. This work, now at the Musee de Chambery, depicts Aspasia holding court with ten men and is a counterpart to Monsiau's 1802 Salon offering, Moliere lisant son Tartufe chez Ninon de I'Enclos. Monsiau's contemporary, the intellectual saloniere Madame de Stael, claimed as fact the notion that Aspasia held salons. Later nineteenthcentury cultural historians elaborated on this notion. Louis Aime Victor Becq de Fouquieres (1831-1887) ably surveyed the ancient sources, including the portrait herm and possibly the Renaissance engraved gem; he provided a highly laudatory view of Aspasia. He believed that Aspasia never was a prostitute and that her reputation as one was a hostile development of comedy. Becq de Fouquieres was well acquainted with European studies of Aspasia and other learned woman. He treated Peri-
96
Prisoner of History
Figure 5.4. Oil painting, Aspasie s'entretenant avec les hommes les plus illustres d'Athenes. Nicolas-Andre Monsiau, 1806. Musee de Chambery inv. D.83.1.1 Courtesy Musee de Chambery (depot du Louvre).
cles' and Aspasia's union as a kind of precursor to the modern egalitarian marriage. Becq de Fouquieres considered this union to be as close to legal marriage as the citizenship law allowed, and he suggested that Aspasia, the first saloniere in history, exercised a moral influence over the women brought to her salon. In Becq de Fouquieres' view, the kernel of Aspasia's message appears to have been that women should have freedom of choice in love.22 Even as Becq de Fouquieres was giving this positive interpretation, however, Jean-Leon Gerome had been pornographizing Aspasia. His important 1861 Salon painting Socrates Seeking Alcibiades in the House of Aspasia shows her just before or after fellating Alcibiades. Although the influence of Plutarch seems to have dominated narratives about Aspasia in prose and on canvas, a significant Continental extension of her bios was developed along Platonic lines in the work of the great Italian poet and essayist, Giacomo Leopardi (1798-1837). Leopardi's classical education, the pain of his unrequited loves, and the emotional damage wrought by his own physical deformities and debilitating illnesses informed his "Aspasia cycle" of five poems, com-
Aspasia in the Postclassical West
97
posed in Naples between 1831 and 1835. So named because Aspasia is the addressee of the last poem and the poetic referent in the first four to Leopardi's beloved, Fanny Targioni-Tozzetti, the cycle is a RomanticPlatonic meditation on love and death.23 The poems begin with Leopardi's first-person meditation on the twin natures of love and death in Amore e morte. Death is love's companion and twin, a beautiful maiden who nullifies the sad; love, on the other hand, empowers us to act. But even as we fall in love, we see that death will be our release from love. This first poem ends with a prayer that fate give the bold either love or death. The persona asks for death, which is more constant than love. The poem's classical superscription, Menander's "Whom the gods love die young," anticipates this wish. The next poem, Consalvo, is a narration of the death of Consalvo, who lies alone, wishing for just a kiss from his unreciprocating but beloved Elvira. She obliges; once kissed, the transfigured man can die happy. Elvira's momentary gift of earthly love effects Consalvo's liberation, which is identified with death. Here, the lover's wish of the first poem is fulfilled, but at one remove, because the story is told in the third person, not by a first-person narrator. Leopardi returned to first-person narration in // pensiero dominante, investing love, "the dominating thought," with all that is restful and productive. This thought evokes for the traveler verdant fields beside which all else is valueless, sterile, and banal. Because of this thought, the persona can laugh at death and transcend his own time, this eta superba. In naming the dominating thought as the only passion that dwells in the human heart, Leopardi evokes Plato's Symposium and its privileging of eros; moreover, in asserting that the thought makes one forget the truth, Leopardi acknowledges that humans become enraptured by the love object's mere physical beauty. His only real description of the dominant thought identifies it as a dream, a divine error. Like Plato, Leopardi revealed the illusory nature of that which humans hold most dear. At the poem's end, Leopardi conflates the love object with the dominating thought; thus, in mingling the human and divine, the real and ideal, he shows the point at which the lover ignorantly and passionately confounds the two. The mood of A se stesso is gloomy. Rather than addressing an idea, talking about personified abstractions, or narrating a moment in another lover's progress, Leopardi appears to be speaking frankly to himself. In this poem, Leopardi acknowledges that the illusion he thought eternal was dead and advises himself to scorn everything, including the brute
98
Prisoner of History
power that amuses itself with our woe. The only possibility is to survive with dignity. The final poem, Aspasia, an address to his lost beloved, magnificently synthesizes the themes of the first four poems. Leopardi twice addressed his lost love as Aspasia (lines 2 and 63). The richest in classical allusions of the cycle, Aspasia also locates the title character in the past, in the land of the dead. Leopardi, having triumphed over his passion, produced his text to show that the mortal woman who inspired him has literally died and that, on the other hand, his illusion has lived on. (Note that in Consalvo the mortal woman lives, the lover dies, and the idea is left hanging.) He acknowledged her divine beauty: her form was angelic, she transfigured his world, she represented nature and the fecundity of motherhood. Aspasia reveals unknown Elysiums—even Heaven, the ultimate transcendence, is multiplied. Here, Leopardi acknowledged that the lover's mind begets the idea of eros, and that even as he embraces the mortal woman, he really embraces the idea, whose divine form he first apprehended in Fanny/Aspasia. Because the mortal is a mere avenue to this idea. Leopardi can think about Fanny/Aspasia now. She comes and goes in his thoughts come cara larva, like a beloved ghost. Thus, we can read the Aspasia cycle not only with the Symposium, but also with the Menexenus, where a dead woman inspires the living. Leopardi transcended his human disappointment by rewriting the narrative of his unrequited love. He kept the joy of having loved but also gained freedom from servitude. He took revenge and comfort in being able to lie smiling at the sea and stars. The real woman is dead, and here, even more than in the fourth poem, the lover can truly speak a se stesso, to himself. Fittingly, the poet called the mortal avenue to these insights "Aspasia," who became through Plato's Menexenus a floating signifier and, through later ages' conflation with Diotima, an erotic guide. By figuring the seeker of this enlightened solitude as a man and the avenue to it as a woman, Leopardi achieved for Aspasia a universal/ archetypal status as das Ewigweibliche, a status she would occupy in several nineteenth- and twentieth-century novels. Victorian classicism purified Aspasia, making her consort to the great man and desexing her; historiography, painting, and the novel all produced similar views. Growing interest in "the woman question" in Europe and the United States in the nineteenth century also occasioned references to and treatments of Aspasia. Walter Savage Landor (1775— 1864), whose work is little read today, spent much of his later life in
Aspasia in the Postclassical West
99
Italy. The conservative Landor had popular success with his epistolary novel, Pericles and Aspasia, which he was inspired to write at the beginning of 1835 and which first appeared in 1836. He considered his sources to be Bayle, Menage, Thucydides, and Plutarch, being happy to let little more impede his own creative view of fifth-century Athens.24 This novel, the first full fictional treatment of Aspasia's relationship with Pericles, is made up of 237 numbered letters between Pericles and Aspasia, and other real or invented personages. Aspasia's correspondence with her fictional friend, Cleone (who conveniently resides in faroff Miletus and is thus unable to be an on-hand companion or ally) provides the narrative structure.25 Aspasia somehow makes her way from Miletus to Athens and primly lodges with a widowed kinswoman (letters 1,2). On her first day there, she dons male attire and attends a performance at the festival of Dionysus; overcome with excitement, she faints and is succored by attendants of Pericles (letters 4-6). Like some Victorian swain, Pericles soon visits her and asks permission to call (letter 10). Love follows soon after (letters 11, 13, 14, 15). The particulars of the relationship are not clear. That they have married is not manifest until letter 162, when Aspasia, telling Cleone of her trial for impiety, states that at the trial Pericles referred to her as his wife. Not until letter 185 is a reference made to their child, when Aspasia writes to Cleone of Pericles' desire that "our son" grow up in Athens; removed to Thessaly, she takes comfort in "little Pericles" (letter 192). Anachronistically, Pericles informs Aspasia that he had revoked the "odious" citizenship law (letter 198), thus allowing Pericles junior to continue on with the family, well before the deaths of Xanthippus and Paralus (narrated in letter 234).26 The marriage most often referred to is Pericles' marriage to power; Aspasia timidly protests this time-consuming commitment, but to no avail (letters 105,106). Like Abelard before him, Pericles often declines to answer his lover's requests (e.g., letters 61 and 63; 163 and 164; 173, 174, 185; in letter 111 he even refuses to give Aspasia copies of his speeches). But she does not seem to mind this apparent neglect, assuring him that "I shall love you even more than I do, if you will love yourself more than me" (letter 70). Landor takes away from Aspasia most claims made for her independence of thought or her influence on Pericles. Aspasia denies that she has retouched any of Pericles' orations (letter 50), and Anaxagoras
100
Prisoner of History
praises Aspasia for having taken Pericles' advice to read history rather than philosophy (letter 134). Aspasia even recounts Pericles' severe criticism of her own summary of Roman history (letter 137). As for Aspasia's reputed eloquence, she does mount her own defence at the trial, but Pericles finishes the job for her (letters 161, 162). Thus the rescued one can say, "I was forgotten . . . the danger, the insult, seemed his" (letter 163). Moreover, many of Aspasia's letters to Cleone simply transcribe Pericles' own opinions and speeches; her letters become a vehicle for replicating his ideas, not her own. When Cleone asks Aspasia for a panegyric on women poets, Aspasia declines and asks Pericles his opinion (letters 36, 37). Nor does she seem to have any part in the Samian War, remarking to Cleone after its end that it is enough that her Pericles is safe at home: "Not a word has he spoken, not a question have I asked him about the odious war of Samos" (letter 120). This Victorian writer inverted the ancient formula by which Pericles spoke with Aspasia's tongue instead of making her speak with his. The Aspasia who emerges admires restraint, disapproves of Sappho's passions, and lauds Euripides' and Sophocles' self-control (letter 48). She does not attempt to advise Pericles about foreign policy, though she states that war is barbaric (letter 112). Landor dispelled rumors that she was a madam by having her recount her efforts to win honest suitors for two Milesian girls, which sincere and innocuous effort is twisted by Dracontides into the malicious rumor that she pimped for Pericles (letters 55-59). Obedient to Pericles, she entertains an elderly woman at his request (letter 102); he permits her to go visiting, tells her how to behave (letters 23, 24), and advises her to change the air (letter 31). She writes a little; Landor ascribed to her a comic epigram (letter 78), a poem to her nurse and a piece on youth and age (letter 107), and a paean to Miletus (letter 140), all of which are transcribed in letters to Cleone. So far as we can tell, Pericles knows nothing of these productions. Aspasia's masterpiece is three fragments of a tragedy about the house of Atreus (letters 225, 227, 229). Cleone urges her to complete the play (letter 228) but Aspasia is diffident: "Tragedy is quite above me" she pleads (letter 225), adding in her last installment that she dislikes any manual activity, be it sewing or writing (letter 229)—this Aspasia doesn't know the difference between the two.27 Lander's Aspasia is a perfect "angel in the house," a docile wife and mother, a reflector of Pericles' glory whose life is not worth narrating after Pericles' death. The novel ends when Aspasia, removed from the
Aspasia in the Postclassical West
101
dangers of war, is informed by Alcibiades of Pericles' and Cleone's deaths (letters 236 and 237, respectively). Eliza Lynn Linton, the formidable antifeminist novelist and essayist, was in her twenties when her second historical novel, Amymone: A Romance of the Days of Pericles, appeared in 1848. Dedicated to her father and praised lavishly by Savage Landor, the novel launched Linton on a long and successful career. In her preface, Linton announced that in Aspasia's character she tried "to embody what I believe to be the practical truths of human life'' (p. v); "I have but clothed in Grecian form the spirit of modern England; speaking, under local names, of questions which interest universal man" (pp. v, vi). This genteel and philosophical purpose is effected in about 1,200 pages of rotten-ripe ecphraseis, poison, torture, disguise, and treachery that surpassed the penny dreadfuls of that time.28 The tale told is of the beautiful and treacherous me tic Amymone, recently disfranchised by Pericles' citizenship law, which Linton obviously considered to have been retroactive. Married to a handsome but weak-willed metic, Methion, Amymone schemes and claws her way into the inner circle of Athenian high society by forging a new will in which Methion's pros tales (citizen sponsor), Crethon, leaves everything to Methion, whereupon Crethon is murdered. Cleon waits in the wings to blackmail her into committing even worse acts while he simultaneously works to discredit Pericles and his friends. Rather than show compassion for Amymone's plight as a metic, Linton dwells instead on Amymone's failure to accept her status, and on her fierce, ungovernable passions, her ability to sexually dominate men, and her unwomanly ability to resort to violence. Amymone visits a witch, horridly loathes the husband who must be her master (1.240), and is described as a Clytemnestran wife (1.304 and 3.17). When finally trapped, after having "laboured ceaselessly to obtain an influence counter to Aspasia's, which should destroy and annul her work" (2.68), and after having attended the Olympian games disguised as a Phrygian boy (3.193), Amymone, and her husband, stand trial for their crimes. He cravenly is willing to live on as a public slave (3.348), but Amymone murders her own child in the courtroom and then kills herself on the last page of the novel (3.348). Aspasia, whose arrival and presence in Athens is never explained, lives with Pericles in wedded harmony (1.56); their household, simple and unadorned, is "the very Erechtheion of the social life of Athens"
102
Prisoner of History
(1.48). At home, the married pair assure one another of their mutual devotion (1.58-64). Aspasia would be Pericles' slave, his helot (1.62). In an early scene, Aspasia and Pericles talk of their love for one another, but Pericles then speaks alone of philosophy with Socrates (1.48-70). Pericles is the center of a formidable intellectual circle: "And that beautiful Ionian woman sat among them, like the queen of all" (1.75). Aspasia and Pericles ("that republican monarch" 1.87) alike dream of a day when the people shall rule supreme and, as Aspasia says to herself, "And then, men will understand other than conventional virtues . . . then I, Aspasia, now named Hetaira, because endowed with an Hetaira's education, shall be called virtuous, and beyond my age. . . . To live a matron's seeming, and to play a harlot's games, Athens winks at that! To love in pure, chaste wedlock of soul, but to despise the formal customs, that is to be an Hetaira, abandoned, shameless, and undone" (1.91). Linton noted that whereas hetairai are self-confident, educated, and friends to men, wives are mere housekeepers (1.113). Aspasia and Amymone are contrasted with each other in several encounters, the most notable of which (1.77-105) shows that Aspasia was branded with the name of courtesan, because she had learnt those arts of education which had hitherto been reserved for this class; because she had endeavoured to rescue philosophy, learning, and art, from the purposes of seduction, to which alone they were applied; because she strove to establish the truth of an equal law between the sexes; an equal though a diverse; and threw off many of the conventional restraints of her time; because she did all this, the chaste matrons of the violet city shrieked out against her; and men, more narrow, mean, and bigoted, repeated the slanderous lie, till after ages caught the echo, and Aspasia's name lies still deep-stained with a calumnious infamy. (2.79) Aspasia tells Amymone that love is the most necessary part of a marriage (2.88-89). This conversation, which Amymone reports to Hermippus, becomes the basis for his accusation of impiety, despite Aspasia's own declaration to another woman: "Loving, chaste, obedient, and true, all this let womanhood remain; but with these virtues let her have a wider education and a higher moral position" (2.103). In accord with Aspasia's wish that womanhood remain obedient, she avers to Pericles that "an Attic birth could not have given me more than my present greatest privilege,—the privilege of loving thee" (2.254), and severs her innocent friendship with a young girl because the girl's suitor disapproves (3.98-130).
Aspasia in the Postclassical West
103
Amidst increasing public censure of Aspasia, Lysicles becomes her ally at a Dionysiac festival during which Hermippus publicly calls her a hetaira (2.130-132), a nice touch that allowed Linton to forecast Lysicles' supposed protection of her after the death of Pericles. Hermippus' formal charge of impiety will not come for another half-dozen years, in the mid-430s B.C. (3.274), as part of a concerted campaign against Pericles by assorted demagogues. Amymone is allowed to testify against Aspasia in Linton's fantastic version of the trial (3.277). But Pericles' celebrated tears finally sway the crowd (3.282-283). The fact that the novel ends with the death of Amymone, soon after Aspasia's acquittal on the impiety charge, shows the extent to which Linton was eager to figure the ambitious woman as an evil foil. The dark, Medea-like Amymone (3.331) takes the fall for ambitious women. Because Aspasia seemingly achieves her own security with love, beauty, brains, and luck, she has no cause to worry. Linton never showed Aspasia in any genuine predicament or seriously dissatisfied with her lot or those of other women, and even foreshadowed the protection she would receive from Lysicles after Pericles' death. She conveniently made Xanthippus and Paralus exceedingly unlikable sons. Linton took the tradition of a colorful, scandalous, unconventional female genius and, like Savage Landor, domesticated her into "the angel in the house." Sir Lawrence Alma-Tadema (1836-1912), a major interpreter of the Victorian vision of the ancient world, also protected Aspasia by positioning her chastely in men's space as a reflector and admirer of men's projects in his 1868 painting, Phidias and the Frieze of the Parthenon (Figure 5.5). Alma-Tadema's strain of classicism is characterized by his fusion of classicizing idealism with the minuteness of detail typical of genre painting; additionally, he displayed a strong interest in ecphrasis or, as Richard Jenkyns calls it, a "pull toward literary or anecdotal content."29 The painting synthesizes certain aspects of Plutarch's descriptions of Pericles' associates and the Parthenon project. Noted figures of the day pay homage to Art, a projection back into antiquity of the homage paid in London by Britons when the Elgin Marbles were first displayed. A heroic Phidias shows the Parthenon frieze, in progress, to Pericles, Aspasia, and three other men. All but one man (possibly Alcibiades, who eyes another man) gaze reverently at the sculptures. Aspasia is somewhat concealed from view. She is heavily robed; one may glimpse
104
Prisoner of History
Figure 5.5. Oil painting, Phidias and the Frieze of the Parthenon, Athens. Lawrence Alma-Tadema, 1868. City Museum of Birmingham inv. 118.23. Courtesy of the Birmingham Museum and Art Gallery.
her black and white spotted underdress, and she wears a saffron outer dress, a possible reference to her reputation as a courtesan. But her hair is mostly covered and suggests a matron's coiffure.30 Heavy and dark, this Aspasia hardly recalls Landor's sprightly woman or Linton's queenly one, and she certainly is totally unlike Bouliar's version. This may be the only one of Alma-Tadema's classical subject paintings in which he gave a woman a positive rendition "in a position of power and authority," as Joseph Kestner puts it, and made Aspasia "the virtuous mistress of Pericles." Certainly, Aspasia is more positively portrayed than is Alma-Tadema's scheming Julia Domna in the 1907 Caracalla and Geta, and she is more reverently attentive to the display of men's labor than either the lolling Lesbia in his 1865 At Lesbia's or the indolent woman who is sharply contrasted to rapt male listeners in his 1885 A Reading from Homer. Alma-Tadema often showed women in pairs, or as Kestner puts it, as "dangerous doubles," "anti-intellectuals," and "in a state of idleness and torpor." According to tradition, Aspasia, had no female peers; here, Alma-Tadema did not
Aspasia in the Postclassical West
105
emphasize her singularity as had Bouliar. Instead, he enveloped her and her reaction to Phidias' workmanship in a man's space. Ultimately, Alma-Tadema's Aspasia fulfills the aim of Linton's Aspasia, that is, to give women the intellectual training to make them fit companions for men. In like fashion his Sappho, in the 1881 Sappho and Alcaeus, is subordinated, along with her "school," to Alcaeus; she and her girls are Alcaeus' audience, not his peers. Eliza Lynn Linton, who had made Amymone a frightening monster, would continue to inveigh against "wild women" even as Alma-Tadema showed tamed, exemplary women on some canvases and dangerous sensual ones elsewhere.31 At around the same time, an American writer, C. Holland, published Aspasia, an obscure quasi-autobiographical novel that made interesting use of parts of Aspasia's identity. It may be the first treatment of Aspasia in the New World and the first fictional treatment that made Aspasia the sole narrator.32 Aspasia Horton, the devout protagonist, decides her life's destiny at the age of 12: "I then and there resolved that I would be a woman in the broadest sense of the term" (p. 7). She begins to realize her destiny at a young ladies' seminary, where she uses her prodigious memory to learn Latin, Greek, and geology, and also debates her teachers and fellows about Christian theology. She is outstandingly rational: although Aspasia meets her future husband, Morgan Goodspeed, during adolescence, she resolves to heed her late mother and not marry until having completed her education (p. 74). Aspasia is far more reasonable than her romantic and impetuous suitor (pp. 76-77). After the vicissitudes of earning a poor living for herself and her children while Morgan grapples with the evils of drink, Aspasia at length has the satisfaction of seeing her husband repent, sober up, and prosper. After his edifying death, the wealthy widow can "bestow my charities with a liberal hand" (p. 186). She feeds and houses the poor and distributes religious reading materials. Aspasia Horton Goodspeed attempts to synthesize and live the precepts of Jesus Christ and the Greek philosophers, among whom she sees no great difference (p. 41). At the end of the book, she fuses the moral teachings of Greek philosophy and the Presbyterian catechism (chapter 17, p. 187 ff.) For this latter-day Aspasia, particular obligations grow from our natures, one of which is that we must live out the implications of the fact that "there is no such thing as sex in souls or spirits" (pp. 189-190). Holland focused on the spiritual and intellectual development of the heroine and her use of those strengths to overcome all obstacles. Her
106
Prisoner of History
"Aspasia" is a seminary-educated, Christian lady bountiful who survives adversity to find material and spiritual wealth. From the Milesian's bios, Holland took her learning, her rhetorical skill, and the probability that she outlived her mate, and rewarded this literary creation more handsomely than her namesake ever was. Aspasia Goodspeed is never insulted publicly, she has a proper marriage, and as we read the memoirs of her late middle age, we are given the satisfaction of knowing what happens to her. Holland's transformation of Aspasia into a positive role model for contemporary American women was undoubtedly not embraced by all nineteenth-century proponents of women's education. Margaret Fuller's contemporary, Caroline Dall, could refer contemptuously to Ischomachus as running off to "the saloon of Aspasia." Nonetheless, the protagonist's unusual determination to prosecute her life's course, and her contention that education was woman's right, harmonizes with the tenets of nineteenth-century American feminism.33 Aspasia Horton Goodspeed, a rather tame protofeminist, was no match for the most glamorous fictional Aspasia of the century. The Austrian classicist Rupert Hammerling (pseudonym Robert Hamerling, 1830-1889), whose historical novels and poetry are today mostly forgotten, wrote a blockbuster Aspasia in 1876. This lavish and lengthy work was in print for about 50 years and inspired a play and musical composition. Hamerling's sympathetic portrait of Aspasia credited her with far more subjectivity and activism than had any prior construction of her biographical tradition, even as it omitted some inconvenient details that did not mesh with his idealizing project.34 Hamerling created an imperial fantasy in his violet Athens, a place where the common man discourses learnedly in the agora about the most complex political and philosophical issues. Aspasia is singular; she is no ordinary woman but a queen bee with no real understanding of the problems of women as a gender class. As Euripides says, Aspasia is a woman but women are not Aspasias (2.60). Not only is Aspasia singular among women, she is represented as almost divine, for Phidias' and Pericles' first glimpse of her is treated as a kind of epiphany: "There are looks, words, which fall like the kindling lightning into a human soul. Pericles had been touched by such a word, such a glance . . . the might of the glance darted through him with a sweet fire, from whose glow he emerged more transformed than he was aware!" (1.32). Pericles, Aspasia, Sophocles, and the latter's mistress are "as gay as Olym-
Aspasia in the Postclassical West
107
plan gods" (1.171); Socrates, whose philosophical progress will be directed by his pure love for Aspasia, first hears the voice of his daimon when first he beholds Aspasia (1.184); and, according to this work, Sophocles writes the eros chorus of Antigone for Aspasia (1.162). Most significantly for our understanding of Aspasia, Hamerling has made her a meteoric register of the Zeitgeist. The rise and decline of her love affair with Pericles coincides with the acme and decay of Athenian brilliance; she inspires the building program and even awakens Socrates' daimon. Pericles admits that she has composed most of his speeches (2.40). Hamerling's Aspasia is orphaned in Miletus and reared by a philosophical old gentleman. After her benefactor's death, she moves to Attica. Misunderstood by the Megarians, she is "rescued" by the subsequently lecherous Hipponicus, and eventually finds refuge with a friend of her mother (1.123). Her only actual lover is Pericles. Aspasia's basic philosophy, as she expounds it at the Athenian equivalent of a gallery showing, is simple: beauty is the highest good and now is the time to beautify Athens (1.31-32; cf. 1.37 and 2, chap. 7). Beauty is superior to mere goodness, Aspasia tells Socrates; Socrates recognizes this and wishes he were handsome rather than wise (1.156). "Only in the garb of beauty will wisdom conquer all hearts," says Aspasia (2.22). Another indication of Aspasia's exceptional nature is the fact that Hamerling dresses her in men's clothing so that she can move about Athens as a Spartan youth (1.109 et passim), a necessity Pericles permits her (1.111) but from which he vows to free her (1.337). Aspasia thinks women should be permitted to act on the stage (1.222-223, 226), and Sophocles lets her play Eurydice in the Antigone (1.217-244), an action that discomfits Pericles. Aspasia is incensed at the treatment of Athenian women but also blames them for not knowing how to please men and keep their love (1.138-139). In an extraordinary scene, Aspasia, in men's attire, calls on Pericles' unlettered wife (here named Telesippe) and her "masculine" companion Elpinike. Ironically, these unbeautiful women penetrate her disguise more quickly than do the men with whom she more frequently associates (1.135).35 Elpinike and Telesippe, however, plot against Aspasia, as do Diopeithes and Lampon, the representatives of superstition (1.87-116; 2.28-52). In a stunning moment, Aspasia declares warfare against prejudice and on behalf of women (2.26-27) and
108
Prisoner of History
asks women at the Thesmophoria to unite in support of women's rights that they might exert equal power in the world. Elpinike's faction defeats this bold move (2.52-78, esp. pp. 76-78). Eventually, Pericles divorces Telesippe, whose grief at the termination of her marriage and the loss of her sons Hamerling deprecates (2.36). Not long after the outbreak of the Samian War, and after a burst of passionate love letters, Aspasia joins Pericles in Ionia, where they wed (1.301-323; 2.25-26). Their marriage is to be a new sort, based on mutual love and honesty, for Aspasia had told Pericles that if she could, she would be neither hetaira nor wife (1.324—325). Despite persistent rumors that Aspasia is a second Thargelia, she seems more interested in Pericles' heart and women's rights than in exercising political power by sexually dominating her lover (2.40-41). In addition to her failed attempt to galvanize women at the Thesmophoria, Aspasia founds a short-lived school for young ladies, which is attended by her two orphaned nieces and an Arcadian girl: She did not wish to train hetaerae, but champions and allies, adapted by their intellect and beauty to gain influence as she herself had done. The school she established should keep alive what she transmitted, and diffuse it to wider circles. . . . Her pupils, like their mistress might obtain for husbands powerful and influential men, who would strengthen Pericles' authority and oppose the efforts of his enemies. (2.182-183; see also 2.28-78 and 200-201, and esp. chap. 7, pp. 200-201)
Like Landor before him, Hammerling rewrote the Megarian crisis; now its impetus is the abduction of Aspasia's nieces, performed in retaliation for Alcibiades' prankish abduction of a Megarian maiden (2.171-201, chap. 7). This slight incident provokes the high-level Megarian crisis of Greek history and occasions Hermippus' prosecution of Aspasia for impiety. In its call for a reinstatement of the death penalty (2.216-217), Hermippus' charge prefigures the charge against Socrates. Pericles defends Aspasia as her husband and sponsor; his tears, and his claim that she is responsible for his good deeds and that to condemn her is to condemn him (2.232-23