Experimental Fluid Mechanics R.J. Adrian · M. Gharib · W. Merzkirch D. Rockwell · J.H. Whitelaw
T. Liu J.P. Sullivan
...
121 downloads
1696 Views
7MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Experimental Fluid Mechanics R.J. Adrian · M. Gharib · W. Merzkirch D. Rockwell · J.H. Whitelaw
T. Liu J.P. Sullivan
Pressure and Temperature Sensitive Paints
Tianshu Liu NASA Langley Research Center MS 493, Hampton, VA 23681-0001 USA Prof. John P. Sullivan Purdue University School of Aeronautics and Astronautics 315 N. Grant St. Grissom Hall West Lafayette, IN 47907-2023 USA
ISBN 3-540-22241-3
Springer Berlin Heidelberg New York
Library of Congress Control Number: 2004109333 This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilm or in other ways, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9, 1965, in its current version, and permission for use must always be obtained from Springer-Verlag. Violations are liable to prosecution under German Copyright Law. Springer is a part of Springer Science+Business Media springeronline.com
c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2005 Printed in Germany The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Typesetting: Data conversion by the authors. Final processing by PTP-Berlin Protago-TeX-Production GmbH, Germany Cover-Design: design & production GmbH, Heidelberg Printed on acid-free paper 61/3020Yu - 5 4 3 2 1 0
Series Editors Prof. R.J. Adrian University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign Dept. of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics 216 Talbot Laboratory 104 South Wright Street Urbana, IL 61801 USA Prof. M. Gharib California Institute of Technology Graduate Aeronautical Laboratories 1200 E. California Blvd. MC 205-45 Pasadena, CA 91125 USA Prof. Dr. W. Merzkirch Universit¨ at Essen Lehrstuhl f¨ ur Str¨ omungslehre Sch¨ utzenbahn 70 45141 Essen Germany Prof. Dr. D. Rockwell Lehigh University Dept. of Mechanical Engineering and Mechanics Packard Lab. 19 Memorial Drive West Bethlehem, PA 18015-3085 USA Prof. J.H. Whitelaw Imperial College Dept. of Mechanical Engineering Exhibition Road London SW7 2BX UK
Preface
The aim of this book is to provide a systematic description of pressure and temperature sensitive paints (PSP and TSP) developed since the 1980s for aerodynamics/fluid mechanics and heat transfer experiments. PSP is the first global optical technique that is able to give non-contact, quantitative surface pressure visualization for complex aerodynamic flows and provide tremendous information on flow structures that cannot be easily obtained using conventional pressure sensors. TSP is a valuable addition to other global temperature measurement techniques such as thermographic phosphors, thermochromic liquid crystals and infrared thermography. This book mainly covers research made in the United States, Japan, Germany, France, Great Britain and Canada. Excellent work on PSP in Russia has been described in the book “Luminescent Pressure Sensors in Aerodynamic Experiments” by V. E. Mosharov, V. N. Radchenko and S. D. Fonov of the Central Aerohydrodynamic Institute (TsAGI). We are truly grateful to our colleagues in the field of PSP and TSP for kindly providing their paper drafts, offering comments, and allowing us to use their published results. Without their helps, this book cannot be completed. Especially, we would like to thank the following individuals and organizations: T. Amer, K. Asai, J. H. Bell, T. J. Bencic, O. C. Brown, G. Buck, A. W. Burner, S. Burns, B. Campbell, B. F. Carroll, L. N. Cattafesta, J. Crafton, R. C. Crites, G. Dale, R. H. Engler, R. G. Erausquin, W. Goad, L. G. Goss, J. W. Gregory, M. Gounterman, M. Guille, M. Hamner, J. M. Holmes, C. Y. Huang, J. P. Hubner, J. Ingram, H. Ji, R. Johnston, J. D. Jordan, M. Kameda, M. Kammeyer, J. T. Kegelman, N. Lachendro, J. Lepicovsky, Y. Le Sant, X. Lu, Y. Mebarki, R. D. Mehta, K. Nakakita, C. Obara, D. M. Oglesby, T. G. Popernack, W. M. Ruyten, H. Sakaue, E. T. Schairer, K. S. Schanze, M. E. Sellers, Y. Shimbo, K. Teduka, S. D. Torgerson, B. T. Upchurch, A. N. Watkins. NASA, ONR, AFOSR, Boeing, Raytheon, Japanese NAL.
Table of Contents
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Introduction .................................................................................................... 1 1.1. Pressure Sensitive Paint ....................................................................... 2 1.2. Temperature Sensitive Paint ................................................................ 8 1.3. Historical Remarks ............................................................................ 11 Basic Photophysics....................................................................................... 15 2.1. Kinetics of Luminescence.................................................................. 15 2.2. Models for Conventional Pressure Sensitive Paint ............................ 18 2.3. Models for Porous Pressure Sensitive Paint ...................................... 24 2.3.1. Collision-Controlled Model .................................................... 26 2.3.2. Adsorption-Controlled Model................................................. 27 2.4. Thermal Quenching ........................................................................... 31 Physical Properties of Paints ........................................................................ 33 3.1. Calibration ......................................................................................... 33 3.2. Typical Pressure Sensitive Paints ...................................................... 34 3.3. Typical Temperature Sensitive Paints................................................ 45 3.4. Cryogenic Paints................................................................................ 50 3.5. Multi-Luminophore Paints................................................................. 54 3.6. ‘Ideal’ Pressure Sensitive Paint ......................................................... 56 3.7. Desirable Properties of Paints............................................................ 58 Radiative Energy Transport and Intensity-Based Methods .......................... 61 4.1. Radiometric Notation......................................................................... 61 4.2. Excitation Light ................................................................................. 62 4.3. Luminescent Emission and Photodetector Response......................... 65 4.4. Intensity-Based Measurement Systems ............................................. 69 4.4.1. CCD Camera System .............................................................. 70 4.4.2. Laser Scanning System ........................................................... 74 4.5. Basic Data Processing........................................................................ 75 Image and Data Analysis Techniques........................................................... 81 5.1. Geometric Calibration of Camera...................................................... 82 5.1.1. Collinearity Equations............................................................. 82 5.1.2. Direct Linear Transformation ................................................. 85 5.1.3. Optimization Method .............................................................. 87 5.2. Radiometric Calibration of Camera ................................................... 92 5.3. Correction for Self-Illumination ........................................................ 95 5.4. Image Registration........................................................................... 102 5.5. Conversion to Pressure .................................................................... 105 5.6. Pressure Correction for Extrapolation to Low-Speed Data.............. 107 5.7. Generation of Deformed Surface Grid............................................. 112
X
6.
7.
8.
Table of Contents
Lifetime-Based Methods ............................................................................ 115 6.1. Response of Luminescence to Time-Varying Excitation Light ....... 116 6.1.1. First-Order Model ................................................................. 116 6.1.2. Higher-Order Model ............................................................. 118 6.2. Lifetime Measurement Techniques.................................................. 118 6.2.1. Pulse Method ........................................................................ 118 6.2.2. Phase Method........................................................................ 119 6.2.3. Amplitude Demodulation Method ........................................ 121 6.2.4. Gated Intensity Ratio Method ............................................... 123 6.3. Fluorescence Lifetime Imaging ....................................................... 128 6.3.1. Intensified CCD Camera ....................................................... 128 6.3.2. Internally Gated CCD Camera .............................................. 130 6.4. Lifetime Experiments ...................................................................... 131 Uncertainty ................................................................................................. 137 7.1. Pressure Uncertainty of Intensity-Based Methods........................... 137 7.1.1. System Modeling .................................................................. 137 7.1.2. Error Propagation, Sensitivity and Total Uncertainty ........... 138 7.1.3. Photodetector Noise and Limiting Pressure Resolution........ 141 7.1.4. Errors Induced by Model Deformation ................................. 144 7.1.5. Temperature Effect ............................................................... 145 7.1.6. Calibration Errors.................................................................. 145 7.1.7. Temporal Variations in Luminescence and Illumination ...... 146 7.1.8. Spectral Variability and Filter Leakage ................................ 146 7.1.9. Pressure Mapping Errors....................................................... 146 7.1.10. Paint Intrusiveness ................................................................ 147 7.1.11. Other Error Sources and Limitations .................................... 148 7.1.12. Allowable Upper Bounds of Elemental Errors...................... 149 7.1.13. Uncertainties of Integrated Forces and Moments.................. 150 7.2. Pressure Uncertainty Analysis for Subsonic Airfoil Flows ............. 151 7.3. In-Situ Calibration Uncertainty ....................................................... 156 7.3.1. Experiments .......................................................................... 156 7.3.2. Simulation ............................................................................. 159 7.4. Pressure Uncertainty of Lifetime-Based Methods ........................... 163 7.4.1. Phase Method........................................................................ 163 7.4.2. Amplitude Demodulation Method ........................................ 164 7.4.3. Gated Intensity Ratio Method ............................................... 166 7.5. Uncertainty of Temperature Sensitive Paint .................................... 169 7.5.1. Error Propagation and Limiting Temperature Resolution..... 169 7.5.2. Elemental Error Sources ....................................................... 170 Time Response ........................................................................................... 175 8.1. Time Response of Conventional Pressure Sensitive Paint............... 175 8.1.1. Solutions of Diffusion Equation............................................ 175 8.1.2. Pressure Response and Optimum Thickness......................... 178 8.2. Time Response of Porous Pressure Sensitive Paint ......................... 182 8.2.1. Deviation from the Square-Law............................................ 182 8.2.2. Effective Diffusivity ............................................................. 183 8.2.3. Diffusion Timescale.............................................................. 186
Table of Contents
XI
8.3. 8.4.
Measurements of Pressure Time Response...................................... 187 Time Response of Temperature Sensitive Paint .............................. 194 8.4.1. Pulse Laser Heating on Thin Metal Film .............................. 195 8.4.2. Step-Like Jet Impingement Cooling ..................................... 198 9. Applications of Pressure Sensitive Paint .................................................... 201 9.1. Low-Speed Flows ............................................................................ 201 9.1.1. Airfoil Flows ......................................................................... 201 9.1.2. Delta Wings, Swept Wings and Car Models......................... 207 9.1.3. Impingement Jet.................................................................... 214 9.2. Subsonic, Transonic and Supersonic Wind Tunnels........................ 215 9.2.1. Aircraft Model in Transonic Flow ........................................ 215 9.2.2. Supercritical Wing at Cruising Speed ................................... 221 9.2.3. Transonic Wing-Body Model ............................................... 223 9.2.4. Laser Scanning Pressure Measurement on Transonic Wing . 225 9.2.5. Boundary Layer Control in Supersonic Inlets....................... 226 9.3. Hypersonic and Shock Wind Tunnels.............................................. 230 9.3.1. Expansion and Compression Corners ................................... 230 9.3.2. Moving Shock Impinging to Cylinder Normal to Wall......... 236 9.4. Cryogenic Wind Tunnels ................................................................. 237 9.5. Rotating Machinery ......................................................................... 242 9.5.1. Laser Scanning Measurements.............................................. 242 9.5.2. CCD Camera Measurements................................................. 247 9.6. Impinging Jets.................................................................................. 249 9.7. Flight Tests ...................................................................................... 256 9.8. Micronozzle ..................................................................................... 260 10. Applications of Temperature Sensitive Paint ............................................. 263 10.1. Hypersonic Flows .......................................................................... 263 10.2. Boundary-Layer Transition Detection ........................................... 270 10.3. Impinging Jet Heat Transfer .......................................................... 275 10.4. Shock/Boundary-Layer Interaction ................................................ 280 10.5. Laser Spot Heating and Heat Transfer Measurements ................... 282 10.6. Hot-Film Surface Temperature in Shear Flow ............................... 289 References .................................................................................................. 293 Appendix A. Calibration Apparatus ........................................................... 313 Appendix B. Recipes of Typical Pressure and Temperature Sensitive Paints................................................. 317 Appendix C. Vendors ................................................................................. 319 Color Plates ................................................................................................ 321 Index........................................................................................................... 327
1. Introduction
Quantitative measurements of surface pressure and temperature in wind tunnel and flight testing are essential to understanding of the aerodynamic performance and heat transfer characteristics of flight vehicles. Pressure data are required to determine the distribution of aerodynamic loads for the design of a flight vehicle, while temperature data are used to estimate heat transfer on the surface of the vehicle. Pressure and temperature measurements provide critical information on important flow phenomena such as shock, flow separation and boundary-layer transition. In addition, accurate pressure and temperature data play a key role in validation and verification of computational fluid dynamics (CFD) codes. Traditionally, surface pressure is measured by utilizing a pressure tap or orifice at a location of interest connected through a small tube to a pressure transducer (Barlow et al. 1999). Hundreds of pressure taps are needed to obtain an acceptable pressure field on a complex aircraft model. Manufacturing, tubing and preparing such a model for wind tunnel testing is very labor-intensive and costly. For thin models such as supersonic transports, military aircraft and small fan blades, installation of a large number of pressure taps is impossible. Furthermore, pressure measurements at discrete taps ultimately limit the spatial resolution of measurements such that some details of a complex flow field cannot be revealed. Similarly, a surface temperature field is traditionally measured using temperature sensors such as thermocouples and resistance thermometers distributed at discrete locations (Moffat 1990). Since the 1980s, new optical sensors for measuring surface pressure and temperature have been developed based on the quenching mechanisms of luminescence. These luminescent molecule sensors are called pressure sensitive paint (PSP) and temperature sensitive paint (TSP). Compared with conventional techniques, they offer a unique capability for non-contact, full-field measurements of surface pressure and temperature on a complex aerodynamic model with a much higher spatial resolution and a lower cost. Therefore, they provide a powerful tool for experimental aerodynamicists to gain a deeper understanding of rich physical phenomena in complex flows around flight vehicles. Both PSP and TSP use luminescent molecules as probes that are incorporated into a suitable polymer coating on an aerodynamic model surface. In general, the luminophore and polymer binder in PSP and TSP can be dissolved in a solvent; the resulting paint can be applied to a surface using a sprayer or brush. After the solvent evaporates, a solid polymer coating in which the luminescent molecules are immobilized remains on the surface. When a light of a proper wavelength illuminates the paint, the luminescent molecules are excited and the luminescent
2
1. Introduction
light of a longer wavelength is emitted from the excited molecules. Figure 1.1 shows a schematic of a generic luminescent paint layer emitting radiation under excitation by an incident light. Detector (CCD, PMT, PD)
Excitation light (UV, laser, LED)
Optical Filter
Calibrated output for pressure & temperature
Emission
Luminescent molecule Binder (polymer, porous solid)
Fig. 1.1. Schematic of a luminescent paint (PSP or TSP) on a surface
The luminescent emission from a paint layer can be affected by certain physical processes. The main photophysical process in PSP is oxygen quenching that causes a decrease of the luminescent intensity as the partial pressure of oxygen or air pressure increases. The polymer binder for PSP is oxygen permeable, which allows oxygen molecules to interact with the luminescent molecules in the binder. For certain fast-responding PSP, a mixture of the luminophore and solvent is directly applied to a porous solid surface. In fact, PSP is an oxygen-sensitive sensor. By contrast, the major mechanism in TSP is thermal quenching that reduces the luminescent intensity as temperature increases. TSP is not sensitive to air pressure since the polymer binder used for TSP is oxygen impermeable, while due to the thermal quenching PSP is intrinsically temperature-sensitive. After PSP and TSP are appropriately calibrated, pressure and temperature can be remotely measured by detecting the luminescent emission. PSP and TSP are companion techniques because they not only utilize luminescent molecules as probes, but also use the same measurement systems and similar data processing methods.
1.1. Pressure Sensitive Paint The basic concepts of pressure sensitive paint (PSP) are simple. After a photon of radiation with a certain frequency is absorbed to excite the luminophore from the ground electronic state to the excited electronic state, the excited electron returns
1.1. Pressure Sensitive Paint
3
to the unexcited ground state through radiative and radiationless processes. The radiative emission is called luminescence (a general term for both fluorescence and phosphorescence). The excited state can be deactivated by interaction of the excited luminophore molecules with oxygen molecules in a radiationless process; that is, oxygen molecules quench the luminescent emission. According to Henry’s law, the concentration of oxygen in a PSP polymer is proportional to the partial pressure of oxygen in gas above the polymer. For air, pressure is proportional to the oxygen partial pressure. So, for higher air pressure, more oxygen molecules exist in the PSP layer and as a result more luminescent molecules are quenched. Hence, the luminescent intensity is a decreasing function of air pressure. The relationship between the luminescent intensity and oxygen concentration can be described by the Stern-Volmer relation. For experimental aerodynamicists, a convenient form of the Stern-Volmer relation between the luminescent intensity I and air pressure p is
I ref I
= A+ B
p p ref
,
(1.1)
where I ref and p ref are the luminescent intensity and air pressure at a reference condition, respectively. The Stern-Volmer coefficients A and B, which are temperature-dependent due to the thermal quenching, are experimentally determined by calibration. Theoretically speaking, the intensity ratio I ref / I can eliminate the effects of non-uniform illumination, uneven coating and nonhomogenous luminophore concentration in PSP. In typical tests in a wind tunnel, I ref is taken when the tunnel is turned off and hence it is often called the wind-off intensity (or image); likewise, I is called the wind-on intensity (or image). Figures 1.2 and 1.3 show, respectively, the luminescent intensity as a function of pressure at the ambient temperature and the corresponding Stern-Volmer plots for three PSPs: Ru(ph2-phen) in GE RTV 118, Pyrene in GE RTV 118 and PtOEP in GP 197. A measurement system for PSP or TSP is generally composed of paint, illumination light, photodetector, and data acquisition/processing unit. Figure 1.4 shows a generic CCD camera system for both PSP and TSP. Many light sources are available for illuminating PSP/TSP, including lasers, ultraviolet (UV) lamps, xenon lamps, and light-emitting-diode (LED) arrays. Scientific-grade chargecoupled device (CCD) cameras are often used as detectors because of their good linear response, high dynamic range and low noise. Other commonly-used photodetectors are photomultiplier tubes (PMT) and photodiodes (PD). A generic laser-scanning system, as shown in Fig. 1.5, typically uses a laser with a computer-controlled scanning mirror as an illumination source and a PMT as a detector along with a lock-in amplifier for both intensity and phase measurements. Optical filters are used in both systems to separate the luminescent emission from the excitation light.
4
1. Introduction
7 Ru(ph2-phen) in GE RTV 118 Pyrene in GE RTV 118 PtOEP in GP 197
6 5
I/Iref
4 3 2 1 0 0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
p/pref Fig. 1.2. The luminescent intensity as a function of pressure for three PSPs at the ambient temperature, where pref is the ambient pressure and Iref is the luminescence intensity at the ambient conditions. 1.0
0.8
Iref/I
0.6
0.4
Ru(ph2-phen) in GE RTV 118
0.2
Pyrene in GE RTV 118 PtOEP in GP 197
0.0 0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
p/pref Fig. 1.3. The Stern-Volmer plots for three PSPs at the ambient temperature, where pref is the ambient pressure and Iref is the luminescence intensity at the ambient conditions.
1.1. Pressure Sensitive Paint
5
Fig. 1.4. Generic CCD camera system for PSP and TSP
Once PSP is calibrated, in principle, pressure can be directly calculated from the luminescent intensity using the Stern-Volmer relation. Nevertheless, practical data processing is more elaborate in order to suppress the error sources and improve the measurement accuracy of PSP. For an intensity-based CCD camera system, the wind-on image often does not align with the wind-off reference image due to aeroelastic deformation of a model in wind tunnel testing. Therefore, the image registration technique must be used to re-align the wind-on image to the wind-off image before taking a ratio between those images. Also, since the SternVolmer coefficients A and B are temperature-dependent, temperature correction is certainly required since the temperature effect of PSP is the most dominant error source in PSP measurements. In wind tunnel testing, the temperature effect of PSP is to a great extent compensated by the in-situ calibration procedure that directly correlates the luminescent intensity to pressure tap data obtained at welldistributed locations on a model during tests. To further reduce the measurement uncertainty, additional data processing procedures are applied, including image
6
1. Introduction
summation, dark-current correction, flat-field correction, illumination compensation, and self-illumination correction. After a pressure image is obtained, to make pressure data more useful to aircraft design engineers, data in the image plane should be mapped onto a model surface grid in the 3D object space. Therefore, geometric camera calibration and image resection are necessary to establish the relationship between the image plane and the 3D object space. Besides the intensity-ratio method for a single-luminophore PSP, lifetime measurement systems and multi-luminophore PSP systems have also been developed. Theoretically speaking, the luminescent lifetime is independent of the luminophore concentration, illumination level and coating thickness. Hence, the lifetime method does not require the reference intensity (or image) and it is ideally immune from the troublesome ratioing process in the intensity-ratio method for a deformed model. Similarly, one of the purposes of developing the multipleluminophore PSP system is to eliminate the need of the wind-off reference image and reduce the error associated with model deformation. Another goal of using the multiple-luminophore PSP system is to compensate the temperature effect of PSP.
Computer
Laser Modulator
Lock-in Amplifier
PMT
2D Scanner
Laser Beam
Luminescence
Painted Model
Fig. 1.5. Generic laser scanning lifetime system for PSP and TSP
1.1. Pressure Sensitive Paint
7
Most PSP measurements have been conducted in high subsonic, transonic and supersonic flows on various aerodynamic models in both large production wind tunnels and small research wind tunnels. PSP is particularly effective in a range of Mach numbers from 0.3 to 3.0. Figure 1.6 shows a typical PSP-derived pressure field on the F-16C model at Mach 0.9 and the angle-of-attack of 4 degrees, which was obtained by Sellers and his colleagues (Sellers 1998a, 1998b, 2000; Sellers and Brill 1994) at the Arnold Engineering Development Center (AEDC). For PSP measurements in large wind tunnels, the accuracy of PSP is typically 0.02-0.03 in the pressure coefficient, while in well-controlled experiments the absolute pressure accuracy of 1 mbar (0.0145 psi) can be achieved. In short-duration hypersonic tunnels (Mach 6-10), measurements require very fast time response of PSP and minimization of the temperature effect of PSP. Binder-free, porous anodized aluminum (AA) PSP has been used in hypersonic flows and rotating machinery since it has a very short response time of 30–100 µs in comparison with a timescale of about 0.5 s for a conventional polymer-based PSP. Furthermore, because AA-PSP is a part of an aluminum model, an increase of the surface temperature in a short duration is relatively small due to the high thermal conductivity of aluminum. Since a porous PSP usually exhibits the pressure sensitivity at cryogenic temperatures, AA-PSP and polymerbased porous PSP have been used for pressure measurements in cryogenic wind tunnels where the oxygen concentration is extremely low and the total temperature is as low as 90 K.
Fig. 1.6. PSP image for the F-16C model at Mach 0.9 and the angle-of-attack of 4 degrees. From Sellers (2000)
8
1. Introduction
PSP measurements in low-speed flows are difficult since a very small change in pressure must be resolved and the major error sources must be minimized to obtain acceptable quantitative pressure results. Some low-speed PSP measurements were conducted on delta wings where upper surface pressure exhibited a relatively large change induced by the leading-edge vortices. In addition, experiments were conducted on airfoils, car models and impinging jets at speeds as low as 20 m/s. The pressure resolution of PSP in low-speed flows is ultimately limited by the photon shot noise of a CCD camera. Instead of pushing PSP instrumentation to the limit in low-speed flows, the pressure-correction method was proposed to recover the incompressible pressure coefficient from PSP results obtained in subsonic flows at suitably higher Mach numbers by removing the compressibility effect. Since PSP is a non-contact technique, it is particularly suitable to pressure measurements on high-speed rotating blades in rotating machinery where conventional techniques are difficult to use. Both CCD camera and laser scanning systems have been used for PSP measurements on rotating blades in turbine engines and helicopters. Impinging jets were used in some studies as a canonical flow for testing the performance of PSP systems. Flight test is a challenging area where PSP has showed its advantages as a non-contact, optical pressure measurement technique. The pressure distributions on wings and parts of aircrafts have been measured using film-based camera systems in early in-flight experiments and a laser scanning system in recent flight tests.
1.2. Temperature Sensitive Paint Temperature sensitive paint (TSP) is a polymer-based paint in which the temperature-sensitive luminescent molecules are immobilized. The quantum efficiency of luminescence decreases with increasing temperature; this effect associated with temperature is thermal quenching that serves as the major working mechanism for TSP. Over a certain temperature range, a relation between the luminescent intensity I and absolute temperature T can be written in the Arrhenius form
ln
E §1 I( T ) 1 = nr ¨ − ¨ I ( Tref ) R © T Tref
· ¸, ¸ ¹
(1.2)
where Enr is the activation energy for the non-radiative process, R is the universal gas constant, and Tref is a reference temperature in Kelvin. Figures 1.7 and 1.8 show, respectively, the temperature dependencies of the luminescent intensity and the Arrhenius plots for three TSPs: Ru(bpy) in Shellac, Rodamine-B in dope and EuTTA in dope. The procedure for applying TSP to a surface is basically the same as that for PSP. Not only does TSP use the same measurement systems shown in Figs. 1.4 and 1.5, but also most data processing methods for TSP are similar to those for PSP. Ideally, TSP can be used in tandem with PSP to correct
1.2. Temperature Sensitive Paint
9
the temperature effect of PSP and simultaneously obtain the temperature and pressure distributions. Compared to conventional temperature sensors, TSP is a global measurement technique that is able to obtain the surface temperature distribution with reasonable accuracy at a much higher spatial resolution. o A family of TSPs has been developed, covering a temperature range of –196 C o o to 200 C. The accuracy of TSP is typically 0.2-0.8 C. TSP has been used in various aerodynamic experiments to measure the temperature and heat transfer distributions. In hypersonic wind tunnel tests, TSP not only visualized flow transition patterns, but also provided quantitative heat transfer data calculated based on quasi-steady and transient heat transfer models. Figure 1.9 shows a windward-side heat transfer image of the lower half of the waverider model at Mach 10 at 0.57 s after the wind tunnel started to run (Liu et al. 1995b), where the 2 gray intensity bar denotes heat flux in kW/m . TSP is an effective technique for visualizing boundary-layer transition from laminar to turbulent flow. Due to a significant difference in convection heat transfer between the laminar and turbulent flow regimes, TSP can visualize a surface temperature change across the transition line. In low-speed wind tunnel tests, a model is typically heated or cooled to increase the temperature difference. However, in high-speed flows, friction heating often produces a sufficient temperature difference for TSP transition visualization. Cryogenic TSPs have been used to detect boundary-layer transition on airfoils in cryogenic wind tunnels over a range of the total temperatures from 90 K to 150 K. Complemented with other techniques, TSP has been used to study the relationship between heat transfer and flow structures in an acoustically excited impinging jet. The mapping capability of TSP allows quantitative visualization of the impingement heat transfer fields controlled (enhanced or suppressed) by acoustical excitation. The heat transfer fields in complex separated flows induced by shock/boundary-layer interactions have also been studied using TSP. A novel heat transfer measurement technique has been developed, which combines a laser scanning TSP and a laser spot heating units into a single non-intrusive system. An infrared laser was used to generate local heat flux and convection heat transfer was determined based on a transient heat transfer model from the surface temperature response measured using TSP. This system was applied to quantitative heat transfer measurements in complex flows on a 75-degree swept delta wing and around an intersection of a strut and a wall. Through an optical magnification system, TSP can achieve a very high spatial resolution over the surface of a small object like MEMS devices. TSP has been used to measure the surface temperature field of a miniature flush-mounted hotfilm sensor in a flat-plate turbulent boundary layer.
1. Introduction
1.5
EuTTA-dope
I(T)/I(Tr)
Ru(bpy)-Shellac
1.0
0.5 Rhodamine-B-dope
0.0 0
20
40
60
80
T (deg. C)
Fig. 1.7. Temperature dependencies of the luminescent intensity for three TSPs
0.5 0.0
ln[I(T)/I(Tr)]
10
Ru(bpy)-Shellac
-0.5 -1.0
Rodamine-B-dope
-1.5 EuTTA-dope
-2.0 -2.5 -0.6
-0.4
-0.2 3
0.0 -1
(1/T - 1/Tr )10 ( K )
Fig. 1.8. The Arrhenius plots for three TSPs
0.2
1.3. Historical Remarks
11
Fig. 1.9. Heat transfer image obtained using TSP on the windward side of the waverider at Mach 10. From Liu et al. (1995b)
1.3. Historical Remarks The working principles of PSP are based on the oxygen quenching of luminescence that was first discovered by H. Kautsky and H. Hirsch (1935). The quenching effect of luminescence by oxygen was used to detect small quantities of oxygen in medical applications (Gewehr and Delpy 1993) and analytical chemistry (Lakowicz 1991, 1999) before experimental aerodynamicists realized its utility as an optical sensor for measuring air pressure on a surface. J. Peterson and V. Fitzgerald (1980) demonstrated a surface flow visualization technique based on the oxygen quenching of dye fluorescence and revealed the possibility of using oxygen sensors for surface pressure measurements. Pioneering studies of applying oxygen sensors to aerodynamic experiments were initiated independently by scientists at the Central Aero-Hydrodynamic Institute (TsAGI) in Russia and the University of Washington in collaboration with the Boeing Company and the NASA Ames Research Center in the United States. The conceptual transformation from oxygen concentration measurement to surface pressure measurement was really a critical step for aerodynamic applications of PSP, signifying a paradigm shift from conventional point-based pressure measurement to global pressure mapping. G. Pervushin and L. Nevsky (1981) of TsAGI, inspired by the work of I. Zakharov et al. (1964, 1974) on oxygen measurement, suggested the use of the oxygen quenching phenomenon for pressure measurements in aerodynamic experiments. The first PSP measurements at TsAGI were conducted at Mach 3 on a sphere, a half-cone and a flat plate with an upright block that were coated with a long-lifetime luminescent paint excited by a flash lamp. Their PSP was acriflavine or beta-aminoanthraquinone in a matrix consisting of silichrome, starch, sugar and polyvinylpyrrolidone. A photographic film camera was used for imaging the luminescent intensity field. The results obtained in these tests were in reasonable agreement with the known theoretical solution and pressure tap data (Ardasheva et al. 1982, 1985). Another TsAGI group consisting of A. Orlov, V.
12
1. Introduction
Mosharov, S. Fonov and V. Radchenko started their research in 1983 to improve the accuracy of PSP by measuring the lifetime (the decay time). In their first tests on a cone-cylinder model at Mach 2.5 and 3.0, they used a photomultiplier tube as a detector and a pulsed Argon laser mechanically scanned over a surface to excite a newly developed PSP (Radchenko 1985). Unfortunately, they found that the lifetime measurements suffered from very strong temperature sensitivity (about o 7%/ C) and a very long lifetime (about several minuets) of their first PSP. As a result, their effort has been exclusively focused on the development of intensitybased techniques since 1985. At TsAGI, a number of proprietary PSP formulations have been developed and applied to various subsonic, transonic, supersonic, shock, dynamic tunnels, and rotating machinery (Bukov et al. 1992, 1993; Troyanovsky et al. 1993; Mosharov et al. 1997). The imaging devices used at TsAGI covered a range of photographic film cameras, TV cameras, scientific grade CCD cameras and photomultiplier tubes with laser scanning systems. In the later 1980s, TsAGI marketed its PSP technology through the Italian firm INTECO and issued a one-page advertisement in the magazine ‘Aviation Week & Space Technology’ in February 12, 1990. Interestingly, scientists in the Western World were not aware of Russia’s work on PSP until reading the advertisement. Then, TsAGI’s PSP system was demonstrated in several wind tunnel tests at the Boeing Company in 1990 and Deutsche Forschungsanstalt fur Luft- und Raumfahrt (DLR) in Germany in 1991, which attracted widespread attention of researchers in the aerospace community (Volan and Alati 1991). PSP was independently developed by a group of chemists led by M. Gouterman and J. Callis at the University of Washington (UW) in the late 1980s (Gouterman et al. 1990; Kavandi et al. 1990). The chemists at UW were initially interested in use of porphyrin compounds as an oxygen sensor for biomedical applications. After stimulating discussions with experimental aerodynamicists J. Crowder of the Boeing Company and B. McLachlan of NASA Ames, Gouterman and Callis understood the important implication of oxygen sensors in aerodynamic testing and started to develop a luminescent coating applied to surface for pressure measurements. Their classical PSP used platinum-octaethylporphorin (PtOEP) as a luminescent probe molecule in a proprietary commercial polymer mixture called GP-197 made by the Genesee Company. In 1989, using PtOEP in GP-197, M. Gouterman and J. Kavandi conducted PSP measurements on a NACA 0012 airfoil model (3-in chord and 9-in span) in the 25×25 cm wind tunnel at NASA Ames Fluid Dynamics Laboratory. The model was spray coated with a commercial white epoxy Krylon base-coat and then sprayed with PtOEP in GP-197. An UV lamp was used for excitation, and an analog camera interfaced to an IBM-AT computer with an 8-bit frame grabber for image acquisition. The model was set at o the angle-of-attack of 5 and the Mach numbers ranged from 0.3 to 0.66. Their data showed very favorable agreement with pressure tap data, clearly indicating the formation of a shock on the upper surface of the model as the Mach number increases (Kavandi et al. 1990; McLachlan et al. 1993a). More importantly, this work established the basic procedures for intensity-based PSP measurements such as image ratioing and in-situ calibration. Following the tests at NASA Ames, Kavandi demonstrated the same PSP system in the Boeing Transonic Wind
1.3. Historical Remarks
13
Tunnel on various commercial airplane models, which was briefly discussed by Crowder (1990). Several proprietary paint formulations have been developed at UW, and successfully applied to wind tunnel testing at the Boeing Company and NASA Ames (McLachlan et al. 1993a, 1993b, 1995; McLachlan and Bell 1995; Bell and McLachlan 1993, 1996; Gouterman 1997). Excellent work on PSP was also made at the former McDonnell Douglas (MD, now the Boeing Company at St. Louis) (Morris et al. 1993a, 1993b; Morris 1995; Morris and Donovan 1994; Donovan et al. 1993; Dowgwillo et al. 1994, 1996; Crites 1993; Crites and Benne 1995). MD PSPs were mainly based on Ruthenium compounds that were successfully used in subsonic, transonic and supersonic flows for a generic wing-body model, a full-span ramp, F-15 model, and a converging-diverging nozzle. Other major PSP research groups in the United States include NASA Langley, NASA Glenn, Arnold Engineering Development Center (AEDC), United States Air Force Wright-Patterson Laboratory, Purdue University, and University of Florida. European researchers in DLR (Germany), British Aerospace (BAe, UK), British Defense Evaluation and Research Agency (DERA, UK), and Office National d’Etudes et de Recherches Aerospatiales (ONERA, France) have been active in the field of PSP (Engler et al. 1991, 1992; Engler and Klein 1997a, 1997b; Engler 1995; Davies et al. 1995; Lyonnet et al. 1997). In Japan, the National Aerospace Laboratory (NAL), in collaboration with Purdue and a number of Japanese universities, developed cryogenic and fastresponding PSPs (Asai 1999; Asai et al. 2001, 2003). More and more research institutions all over the world are becoming interested in developing PSP technology because of its obvious advantages over conventional techniques. Brown (2000) gave a historical review with personal notes and recollections from some pioneers on early PSP development. Before the advent of polymer-based luminescent TSPs, thermographic phosphors and thermochromic liquid crystals have been used for measuring the surface temperature distributions in heat transfer and aerothermodynamic experiments. Thermographic phosphors are usually applied to a surface in the form of insoluble powder or crystal in contrast to polymer-based luminescent TSPs although both techniques utilize the temperature dependence of luminescence. A family of thermographic phosphors can cover a temperature range from room temperature (293 K) to 1600 K, which overlaps with the temperature range of polymer-based TSPs from cryogenic temperature (about 100 K) to 423 K. In this sense, thermographic phosphors and polymer-based luminescent TSPs are complementary to cover a broader range from cryogenic to high temperatures. L. Bradley (1953) explored aerodynamic application of thermographic phosphors mixed with binders and ceramic materials to measure surface temperature. Then, thermographic phosphors were used for temperature measurements in high-speed wind tunnels (Czysz and Dixon 1969; Buck 1988, 1989, 1991; Merski 1998, 1999), gas turbine engines (Noel et al. 1985, 1986, 1987; Tobin et al. 1990; Alaruri et al. 1995), and fiber-optic thermometry systems (Wickersheim and Sun 1985). Allison and Gillies (1997) gave a comprehensive review on thermographic phosphors. Thermochromic liquid crystals applied to a black surface selectively reflect light and hue varies depending on the temperature
14
1. Introduction
of the surface, which allows measurement of the surface temperature in a o relatively narrow range from 25 to 45 C. After E. Klein (1968) used liquid crystals in aerodynamic testing, this technique for global temperature measurement has been used in turbine machinery (Jones and Hippensteele 1988; Hippensteele and Russell 1988; Ireland and Jones 1986), hypersonic tunnels (Babinsky and Edwards 1996), and turbulent flows (Smith et al. 2000). Polymer-based TSPs are relatively new compared to thermographic phosphors and thermochromic liquid crystals. P. Kolodner and A. Tyson (1982, 1983a, 1983b) of the Bell Laboratory used a Europium-based TSP in a polymer binder to measure the surface temperature distribution of an operating integrated circuit. A family of TSPs have been developed at Purdue University and used in low-speed, supersonic and hypersonic aerodynamic experiments (Campbell et al. 1992, 1994; Campbell 1994; Liu et al. 1992b, 1994a, 1994b, 1995a, 1995b, 1996, 1997a, o 1997b). Two typical TSPs are EuTTA in model airplane dope (-20 to 100 C) and o o Ru(bpy) in Shellac (0 to 90 C). Several cryogenic TSPs (-175 to 0 C) were first discovered at Purdue University (Campbell et al. 1994) and used for transition detection in cryogenic flows (Asai et al. 1997c; Popernack et al. 1997). Further development of cryogenic TSPs was made at Purdue (Eransquin 1998a, 1998b), NAL in Japan (Asai et al. 1997c; Asai and Sullivan 1998) and NASA Langley. TSP formulations were also studied at the University of Washington (Gallery 1993) and one of the paints was used for boundary-layer transition detection at NASA Ames (McLachlan et al. 1993b). PSP and TSP have become an active and growing interdisciplinary research area, offering the promise of quantitative pressure and temperature mapping on the one hand and giving new technical challenges on the other hand. Useful reviews were given by Crites (1993), McLachlan and Bell (1995a), Crites and Benne (1995), Liu et al. (1997b), Mosharov et al. (1997), Bell et al. (2001), and Sullivan (2001). This book provides a systematic and detailed description of all the technical aspects of PSP and TSP, including basic photophysics, paint formulations and their physical properties, radiative energy transport, measurement methods and systems, uncertainty, time response, image and data analysis techniques, and various applications in aerodynamics and fluid mechanics.
2. Basic Photophysics
2.1. Kinetics of Luminescence Pressure sensitive paint (PSP) and temperature sensitive paint (TSP) are, respectively, based on the oxygen and thermal quenching processes of luminescence which are reversible processes in molecular photoluminescence. The general principles of luminescence are described in detail by Rebek (1987), Becker (1969) and Parker (1968). The different energy levels and photophysical processes of luminescence for a simple luminophore can be clearly described by the Jablonski energy-level diagram shown in Fig. 2.1. The lowest horizontal line represents the ground-state energy of the molecule, which is normally a singlet state denoted by S0. The upper lines are energy levels for the vibrational states of excited electronic states. The successive excited singlet and triplet states are denoted by S1 and S2, and T1, respectively. As is normally the case, the energy of the first excited triplet state T1 is lower than the energy of the corresponding singlet state S1. A photon of radiation is absorbed to excite the luminophore from the ground electronic state to excited electronic states ( S 0 → S 1 and S 0 → S 2 ). The excitation process is symbolically expressed as S 0 + !ν → S 1 , where ! is the Plank constant and ν is the frequency of the excitation light. Each electronic state has different vibrational states, and each vibrational state has different rotational states. The excited electron returns to the unexcited ground state by a combination of radiative and radiationless processes. Emission occurs through the radiative processes called luminescence. The radiation transition from the lowest excited singlet state to the ground state is called fluorescence, which is expressed as S 1 → S 0 + !ν f . Fluorescence is a spin-allowed radiative transition between two states of the same multiplicity. The radiative transition from the triplet state to the ground state is called phosphorescence ( T1 → S 0 + !ν p ), which is a spinforbidden radiative transition between two states of different multiplicity. The lowest excited triplet state, T1, is formed through a radiationless transition from S1 by intersystem crossing ( S 1 → T1 ). Since phosphorescence is a forbidden transition, the phosphorescent lifetime is typically longer than the fluorescent lifetime. Luminescence is a general term for both fluorescence and phosphorescence.
16
2. Basic Photophysics
Singlet Excited States Internal Conversion
Triplet Excited State
Vibrational Relaxation
S2
Interstystem Crossing S1
Energy
T1
Adsorption
Fluorescence
Internal and External Conversion
Phosphorescence
So Ground State Vibrational Relaxation
Fig. 2.1. Jablonsky energy-level diagram
Radiationless deactivation processes mainly include internal conversion (IC), intersystem crossing (ISC) and external conversion (EC). The internal conversion (IC) is a spin-allowed radiationless transition between two states of the same multiplicity ( S 2 → S 1 , S 1 → S 0 ). Typically, this process is expressed as
S 1 → S 0 + ∆ , where ∆ denotes heat released. IC appears to be particularly efficient when two electronic energy levels are sufficiently close. The intersystem crossing (ISC) is a spin-forbidden radiationless transition between two states of the different multiplicity, which are expressed as S 1 → T1 + ∆ and T1 → S 0 + ∆ . Phosphorescence depends to a large extent on the population of the triplet state ( T1 ) from the excited singlet state ( S 1 ) by the intersystem crossing. In addition, deactivation of an excited electronic state may involve interaction and energy transfer between the excited molecules and the environment like solutes, which are called external conversion (EC). The excited singlet and triplet states can be deactivated by interaction of the excited molecules with the components of a system. These bimolecular processes are quenching processes, including collisional quenching (diffusion or nondiffusion controlled), concentration quenching, oxygen quenching, and energy transfer quenching. The oxygen quenching of luminescence is the major photophysical mechanism for PSP. Due to the oxygen quenching, air pressure on
2.1. Kinetics of Luminescence
17
an aerodynamic model surface is related to the luminescent intensity by the SternVolmer equation that will be further discussed. The quantum efficiency of luminescence in most molecules decreases with increasing temperature because the increased frequency of collisions at elevated temperatures improves the possibility for deactivation by the external conversion. This effect associated with temperature is the thermal quenching, which is the major photophysical mechanism for TSP. The population of the excited singlet states ( S 1 ) and triplet states ( T1 ) at any given time depends on the competition among different photophysical processes listed in Table 2.1. The singlet state population [ S 1 ] and triplet state population
[ T1 ] are described by the following first-order kinetic model d [ S1 ] = I a − ( k f + k ic + k isc( s1 −t1 ) + k q( s ) [ Q ])[ S 1 ] dt d [ T1 ] = k isc ( s1 −t1 ) [ S 1 ] − ( k p + k isc( t1 − s0 ) + k q( t ) [ Q ])[ T1 ] dt
,
(2.1)
where I a is the light absorption rate of generating the excited singlet states, [ Q ] is the population of the quencher Q, k f and k p are, respectively, the rate constants for fluorescence and phosphorescence, k isc( s1 −t1 ) and k isc( t1 − s0 ) are, respectively, the rate constants for the intersystem crossings S 1 → T1 and
T1 → S 0 , k ic is the rate constant for the internal conversion, and k q( s ) and k q( t ) are the rate constants for the quenching in the singlet states and triplet states, respectively. The light absorption rate I a = k s 1 [ S 0 ] is proportional to the population [ S 0 ] in the ground state and the rate constant of excitation k s 1 . After a pulse excitation, the times required for the populations in the excited singlet state and triplet state to decay to 1/e of the initial value are, respectively,
τ f = 1 / ( k f + k ic + k isc( s1 −t1 ) + k q ( s ) [ Q ])
τ p = 1 / ( k p + k isc( t1 − s0 ) + k q( t ) [ Q ]) .
(2.2)
The time constants τ f and τ p are defined as the fluorescent and phosphorescent lifetimes, respectively. Usually, the lifetime of a specific photophysical process is defined as the reciprocal of the corresponding rate constant. Typical values of the lifetimes for different photophysical processes are listed in Table 2.1. When the intersystem crossing from T1 back to S 1 ( T1 → S 1 + ∆ ) is included in the kinetic model, extra terms k isc ( t1 − s1 ) [ T1 ]
and − k isc( t1 − s1 ) [ T1 ]
should be added,
respectively, to the right-hand sides of Eq. (2.1) for [ S 1 ] and [ T1 ] , where
k isc( t1 − s1 ) is the rate constant for the intersystem crossing T1 → S 1 . In this case,
18
2. Basic Photophysics
the kinetic model becomes a coupled system of equations (Mosharov et al. 1997; Bell et al. 2001). Since S 1 is a higher energy state than T1 , this intersystem crossing is thermally activated and therefore the rate constant for the process T1 → S 1 is temperature-dependent. Table 2.1. Photophysical processes involving electronically excited states Step
Process
Rate
Lifetime (s)
Excitation
S 0 + !ν → S 1
k s1 [ S0 ]
10 −15
Fluorescence (F)
S 1 → S 0 + !ν f
k f [ S1 ]
10 −11 − 10 −6
Internal Conversion (IC)
S1 → S 0 + ∆
k ic [ S 1 ]
10 −14 − 10 −11
Intersystem Crossing (ISC)
S 1 → T1 + ∆
k isc( s1 −t1 ) [ S 1 ]
10 −11 − 10 −8
Phosphorescence (P)
T1 → S 0 + !ν p
k p [ T1 ]
10 −3 − 10 2
Intersystem Crossing (ISC)
T1 → S 0 + ∆
k isc( t1 − s0 ) [ T1 ]
2.2. Models for Conventional Pressure Sensitive Paint From a standpoint of engineering application, it is unnecessary to analyze all the intermediate photophysical processes and their interactions. Therefore, a lumped model for luminescence (fluorescence and phosphorescence) is given here by considering the main processes: excitation, luminescent radiation, non-radiative deactivation, and quenching. The luminophore is excited by a photon from a ground state L0 to an excited state L* , i.e., L0 + !ν → L* . The excited state L* returns to the ground state L0 by either a radiative process (emission) or a radiationless process (deactivation). In the radiative process, the luminescent kr emission releases energy of !ν l , that is L* ⎯⎯→ L0 + !ν l , where k r is the rate constant for the radiation process and ν l is the frequency of the luminescent emission. In the deactivation process, L* returns to L0 by releasing heat, which k nr is expressed as L* ⎯⎯ ⎯→ L0 + ∆ , where k nr is the rate constant for the combined effect of all the non-radiative processes. If temperature around a luminophore molecule increases, the deactivation rate increases, reducing the radiative process from L* . Thus, the rate constant k nr for the non-radiative processes is temperature-dependent. The quenching process by a quencher Q is expressed as kq L* + Q ⎯⎯→ L0 + Q* , where k q is the rate constant of the quenching process
2.2. Models for Conventional Pressure Sensitive Paint
19
and Q* denotes the excited quencher. The molecular oxygen O2 in the ground state is an efficient quencher for both the excited singlet and triplet states. The molecular oxygen is excited to O2* once it quenches luminescence, i.e.,
L* + O2 → L0 + O2* . By combining the rates of emission, deactivation and quenching processes, the rate of change of the population of the excited state [ L* ] is given by the first-order equation d [ L* ] = I a − ( k r + k nr + k q [ Q ])[ L* ] . dt
(2.3)
The rate of excitation is I a = k s 1 [ L0 ] , where [ L0 ] is the population in the ground state and k s 1 is the rate constant for excitation.
At a steady state
d [ L* ] / dt = 0 , without quenching ( [ Q ] = 0 ), we have * I a = ( k r + k nr )[ L ] .
(2.4)
The amount of luminophore molecules in a given excited state is described by the quantum yield of luminescence defined by
Φ=
rate of luminescence . rate of excitation
(2.5)
The quantum yield Φ for the luminescent emission from L* with the quencher Q is expressed by [ *] I kr , (2.6) Φ = kr L = = k r + k nr + k q [ Q ] I a Ia where I is the luminescent intensity. The quantum yield without quenching is
[ *] Φ0 = k r L = Ia
I kr = 0 k r + k nr I a
,
(2.7)
where I 0 is the luminescent intensity without quenching. Dividing Φ 0 by Φ , we obtain the well-known Stern-Volmer relation
Φ0 I 0 kq = = 1+ [ Q ] = 1 + k qτ 0 [ Q ] , I Φ k r + k nr where τ 0 = 1 /( k r + k nr ) is the luminescent lifetime without quenching. luminescent lifetime with the quencher is
τ =
1 + + k r k nr k q [ Q ]
.
(2.8) The
(2.9)
20
2. Basic Photophysics
Thus, Eq. (2.8) can be written as
Φ0 / Φ = τ 0 / τ .
(2.10)
When the quencher is oxygen, the Stern-Volmer equation is
I0 τ 0 = = 1 + k qτ 0 [ O2 ] . τ I
(2.11)
In general, the rate constants k nr and k q for the non-radiative and quenching processes are temperature-dependent. The temperature dependency of k nr can be decomposed into a temperature-independent term and a temperature-dependent term modeled by the Arrhenius relation (Bennett and McCartin 1966; Song and Fayer 1991), i.e., E nr ), (2.12) k nr = k nr 0 + k nr 1 exp( − RT where k nr 0 = k nr ( T = 0 ) and k nr 1 are the rate constants for the temperatureindependent and temperature-dependent processes, respectively, Enr is the activation energy for the non-radiative process, R is the universal gas constant, and T is the absolute temperature in Kelvin. The temperature dependency of the rate constant k q for the quenching process is related to oxygen diffusion in a homogenous polymer layer used for a conventional PSP. According to the Smoluchowski relation, the rate constant k q for the oxygen quenching can be described by k q = 4π R AB N 0 D (2.13) where R AB is an interaction distance between the luminophore and oxygen molecules, and N 0 is the Avogadro's number. The diffusivity D has the temperature dependency modeled by the Arrhenius relation D = D0 exp( −
ED ), RT
(2.14)
where E D is the activation energy for the oxygen diffusion process. Therefore, from Eq. (2.9), the reciprocal of the luminescent lifetime is
1
τ
= k r + k nr 0 + k nr 1 exp( −
E nr E ) + 4πR AB N 0 D0 exp( − D ) [ O2 ] polymer RT RT
(2.15)
According to Henry's law, the oxygen population [ O2 ] polymer in a polymer binder is proportional to the partial pressure of oxygen pO2 or air pressure p , i.e.,
[ O2 ] polymer = S pO2 = S φ O2 p
(2.16)
2.2. Models for Conventional Pressure Sensitive Paint
21
where S is the oxygen solubility in a polymer binder layer and φ O2 is the mole fraction of oxygen in the testing gas. The mole fraction of oxygen φ O2 is 21% in the atmosphere, but it varies depending on testing facilities. For example, φ O2 is -4 only a few ppm (1ppm = 10 %) in a cryogenic wind tunnel where the working gas is nitrogen. Defining the permeability P0 = SD0 , from Eq. (2.15), we have
1
τ
= ka + K p ,
(2.17)
where the coefficients k a and K are defined as
k a = k r + k nr 0 + k nr 1 exp( −
E E nr ) and K = 4πR AB N 0 P0 exp( − D )φ O2 . (2.18) RT RT
In aerodynamic applications, it is difficult to obtain the zero-oxygen condition since the working gas in most wind tunnels is air containing 21% oxygen. Thus, instead of using the zero-oxygen condition, we usually utilize the zero-speed (wind-off) condition as a reference. Taking a luminescent intensity ratio between the wind-off and wind-on conditions, we obtain the Stern-Volmer equation suitable to aerodynamic applications
I ref I
=
τ ref p . = A polymer ( T ) + B polymer ( T ) τ p ref
(2.19)
The Stern-Volmer coefficients in Eq. (2.19) are
A polymer = A polymer ,ref
K ka , and B polymer = B polymer , ref , k aref K ref
(2.20)
where the reference coefficients are defined as
A polymer , ref =
1 + K ref
p ref 1 and B polymer , ref = . p ref / k aref k aref / K ref + p ref
(2.21)
The subscript ‘polymer’ specifically denotes a conventional polymer-based PSP; it will be seen that porous PSPs have somewhat different forms of the SternVolmer coefficients. Eq. (2.19) indicates that a ratio between the luminescent intensities in the wind-on and wind-off conditions is required to determine air pressure. This intensity-ratio method is commonly employed in PSP and TSP measurements. Using the expressions for k a and K , we can write A polymer and B polymer as a function of temperature ª 1 + ξ exp( − E nr RT ) º » A polymer = A polymer , ref « «¬ 1 + ξ exp( − E nr R T ref ) »¼
22
2. Basic Photophysics
ª E D B polymer = B polymer , ref exp «− «¬ R T ref
·º § Tref ¨ − 1¸ » , ¸» ¨ T ¹¼ ©
(2.22)
where the factor ξ is defined as ξ = k nr 1 /( k r + k nr 0 ) . For ( T − Tref ) / Tref << 1 , the linearized expressions for A polymer and B polymer are
ª E nr A polymer = A polymer , ref «1 + η R T ref «¬ ª ED B polymer = B polymer , ref «1 + R T ref «¬
§ T − Tref ¨ ¨ T ref ©
§ T − Tref ¨ ¨ T ref ©
·º ¸» ¸» ¹¼
·º ¸» , ¸» ¹¼
(2.23)
where the factor η is
η=
ξ exp( − E nr RTref ) . 1 + ξ exp( − E nr R T ref )
(2.24)
Clearly, the Stern-Volmer coefficients A polymer and B polymer satisfy the following constraint A polymer ( Tref ) + B polymer ( Tref ) = 1 . (2.25) Eq. (2.23) indicates that the Stern-Volmer coefficient B polymer depends on the activity energy E D for the oxygen diffusion process; this implies that the temperature sensitivity of PSP is mainly related to the oxygen diffusion. Indeed, experiments conducted by Gewehr and Delpy (1993) and Schanze et al. (1997) for two different oxygen sensors showed that the temperature dependency of the oxygen diffusivity in a polymer dominated the temperature effect of PSP. This finding has an important implication in the design of low-temperature-sensitive PSP formulations; the low-temperature-sensitive PSP should have a polymer binder with the low activation energy for oxygen diffusion. In another special case where E D ≈ E nr and η ≈ 1 over a certain range of temperature, the coefficients A polymer ( T ) and B polymer ( T ) have the same temperature dependency; thus a ratio between A polymer ( T ) and B polymer ( T ) becomes temperature independent. PSP satisfying the above conditions is so-called ‘ideal’ PSP (see Section 3.6). This paint is advantageous for correcting the temperature effect since the Stern-Volmer relation becomes temperature independent when the intensity ratio scaled by a single temperature-dependent factor is used as a similarity variable. In many PSP measurements, the linear Stern-Volmer relation Eq. (2.19) is sufficiently accurate in a certain range of pressure. However, over an extended range of the partial pressure of oxygen or air pressure, the non-linear Stern-
2.2. Models for Conventional Pressure Sensitive Paint
23
Volmer behavior becomes appreciable for microheterogeneous PSPs (Carraway et al. 1991a; Xu et al. 1994; Hartmann et al. 1995). The main physical mechanisms behind the non-linear Stern-Volmer characteristics are associated with microheterogeneity of the environment of a probe molecule and deviation from Henry’s law. Solid-state matrices like polymers may provide numerous different kinds of environments for a probe molecule, resulting in the non-exponential decay or multiple-exponential decay of luminescence. In some cases, a double exponential model is sufficient for the decay; thus the oxygen quenching of luminescence in microheterogeneous systems is described by a two-component model −1
º I0 ª f 01 f 02 =« + » , I ¬ 1 + K SV 1 [ O 2 ] 1 + K SV 2 [ O 2 ] ¼ where
f 01 and
(2.26)
f 02 are the fractional intensity contributions of the two
components in the absence of oxygen ( f 01 + f 02 = 1 ), K SV 1 and K SV 2 are the Stern-Volmer constants of the two components. Furthermore, for the probe molecule incorporated into a polymer, dual sorption mechanisms are considered and thus the oxygen concentration is related to the applied partial pressure by adsorption isotherm. These mechanisms are responsible for a slight deviation of the actual concentration from that given by Henry’s law. The analytical form of dual sorption in a polymer is obtained by adding the Langmuir isotherm to Henry’s law, i.e., b pO2 , (2.27) [ O2 ] polymer = S pO2 + C’ 1 + b pO2 where C’ is the Langmuir gas capacity due to adsorption and b is the Langumir affinity coefficient. Based on the dual sorption model Eq. (2.27), Hubner and Carroll (1997) suggested an extended form of the Stern-Volmer relation
I ref I
= A+ B
D ( p / p ref ) p +C . p ref 1 + D ( p / p ref )
(2.28)
Eq. (2.28) was able to give a good fit to experimental data for some PSPs. From a standpoint of aerodynamic applications, an empirical form of the non-linear SternVolmer relation is usually given by a polynomial 2
§ p · p ¸ +. = A( T ) + B( T ) + C( T ) ¨ ¨ p ref ¸ I p ref © ¹
I ref
(2.29)
24
2. Basic Photophysics
2.3. Models for Porous Pressure Sensitive Paint In the preceding section, the photophysical models for a conventional polymer PSP are discussed. Nevertheless, according to the work of Sakaue (1999), the photophysical models for a porous PSP or open PSP system are different. In general, pores in a porous PSP are macroscopic, which are much larger than the size of an oxygen molecule. Figure 2.2 shows schematically a comparison of a conventional polymer PSP with a porous PSP. In a conventional polymer PSP, as shown in Fig. 2.2(a), the oxygen molecules in the working gas permeate into a polymer binder layer and quench the luminescence. In contrast, as illustrated in Fig. 2.2(b), a porous PSP has a much larger open surface to which the luminophore molecules are directly applied; the oxygen molecules can directly quench the luminescence without having to permeate into a binder layer. Therefore, the use of a porous material as a binder for PSP offers two advantages. First, a porous PSP can achieve a very fast time response (in the order of microseconds) for unsteady PSP measurements; secondly, it makes PSP measurements possible at cryogenic temperatures at which oxygen diffusion is prevented through a conventional homogeneous polymer. Oxygen Molecules
Oxygen Permeation Incident Light
Luminescence Polymer Layer
(a)
Luminophore
Model
Incident Light
Luminescence Oxygen Molecules
Porous Material Surface
(b)
Luminophore
Model Surface
Oxygen Quenching
Fig. 2.2. Schematic of (a) conventional polymer PSP and (b) porous PSP. From Sakaue (1999)
2.3. Models for Porous Pressure Sensitive Paint
25
The oxygen quenching process in a porous PSP is different from that in a conventional polymer PSP. Figures 2.3(a) and (b) illustrate two scenarios of the oxygen quenching in a porous PSP; in both cases, a luminophore molecule is adsorbed on a porous surface opened to the working gas. In Fig. 2.3(a), a gaseous oxygen molecule collides to a luminophore molecule, resulting in the oxygen quenching; in this case, the oxygen quenching process is controlled by a collision between the gaseous oxygen molecule and luminophore molecule adsorbed on the surface. In other case, as illustrated in Fig. 2.3(b), an adsorbed oxygen molecule can cause quenching by diffusing to a luminophore molecule and hence the oxygen quenching process is related to adsorption and diffusion of the oxygen molecule into the luminophore molecule. Wolfgang and Gafney (1983) studied the oxygen quenching of tris(2,2'-bipyridyl)ruthenium (Ru(bpy)) on a porous Vycor glass and reported that Ru(bpy) was quenched by either a gaseous oxygen molecule colliding to the adsorbed Ru(bpy) or an adsorbed oxygen molecule.
gaseous oxygen
adsorbed oxygen
collision porous surface
porous surface
surface diffusion
oxygen quenching (b): Adsorption Controlled Model quencher: adsorbed oxygen process: adsorption/surface diffusion
luminophore
(a): Collision Controlled Model quencher: gaseous oxygen process: collision
Fig. 2.3. Oxygen quenching mechanisms for porous PSP: (a) Collision controlled model; (b) Adsorption controlled model. From Sakaue (1999)
Two photophysical models were developed by Sakaue (1999) to describe the oxygen quenching on a porous surface by considering the Eley-Rideal (ER) mechanism and Langmuir-Hinshelwood (LH) mechanism. The ER mechanism is a target annihilation reaction between a gaseous oxygen molecule and an adsorbed luminophore molecule; it is a collision-controlled reaction (Samuel et al. 1992). The LH mechanism, which is adsorption/surface-diffusion-controlled, is a reaction between an adsorbed oxygen molecule and an adsorbed luminophore molecule (Hinshelwood 1940). Samuel et al. (1992) studied the oxygen quenching of Ru(bpy) on a porous silica surface over a temperature range of 88-353 K and reported that at low temperatures the oxygen quenching was diffusion-controlled (the LH type). As temperature increased, the reaction remained the LH type in nature, but it was increasingly influenced by the target annihilation reaction (the
26
2. Basic Photophysics
ER type). At higher temperatures, the reaction was no longer the LH type, which was dominated by the ER type reaction. In these cases, the rate constant kq for the oxygen quenching and the oxygen concentration [O2] were described in a different manner from that for a conventional polymer binder. 2.3.1. Collision-Controlled Model When the rate constant kq for the oxygen quenching and the oxygen concentration [O2] are considered in a collision-controlled reaction, the Stern-Volmer relation is called the collision-controlled model to distinguish from the diffusion-controlled relation (or adsorption-controlled model). The rate of collision of the oxygen * molecules on a porous surface is [ O2 ] c* / 4 , where c is the average speed of the molecules. According to the theory of ideal gas, one knows
[ O2 ] =
N 0 pO2 RT
and c* =
8RT
(2.30)
π Mm
where pO2 is the partial pressure of oxygen, T is the absolute temperature in Kelvin, Mm is the molar mass, R is the universal gas constant, and N0 is the Avogadro's number. The rate of the oxygen quenching is modeled by a product of an effective contact area σeff and the collision rate
k q [ O2 ] =
σ eff [ O2 ] c * 4
=
σ eff N 0 p O2 2π M m RT
=
σ eff N 0 φ O2 p 2π M m RT
.
(2.31)
Hence, the rate of the oxygen quenching is proportional to the partial pressure of oxygen or air pressure, but is inversely proportional to the square root of temperature. The Stern-Volmer relation for the luminescent lifetime then becomes σ eff N 0 φ O2 1 = ka + p (2.32) τ 2π M m RT For aerodynamic applications, the Stern-Volmer relation for the collisioncontrolled quenching process can be written as
p I ref = Acollision ( T ) + B collision ( T ) . I p ref
(2.33)
In Eq. (2.33), the Stern-Volmer coefficients are
Acollision = Acollision, ref
T ref k a and B , collision = B collision ,ref T k aref
(2.34)
2.3. Models for Porous Pressure Sensitive Paint
27
where the coefficients at the reference conditions are defined as
Acollision , ref = 1 /( 1 + ζ ) , B collision , ref = ζ /( 1 + ζ ) ,
ζ =
σ eff N 0φ O2 p ref k aref
2π M m R Tref
.
(2.35)
Although Eq. (2.33) has the same form as that for a conventional polymer binder, the Stern-Volmer coefficients Acollision and Bcollision have different physical meanings. The coefficient Bcollision has weaker temperature dependency that is inversely proportional to the square root of temperature. In contrast, the temperature dependency of Acollision has the same form as that for a conventional polymer binder; linearization of Eq. (2.34) at T = Tref leads to ª E nr Acollision = Acollision , ref «1 + R T ref «¬
§ T − Tref ¨ ¨ T ref ©
·º ¸» . ¸» ¹¼
(2.36)
2.3.2. Adsorption-Controlled Model Besides the collision-controlled quenching, an adsorbed oxygen molecule on a porous surface can also quench the luminescence; if this is the dominant mechanism, the oxygen quenching is controlled by adsorption and surface diffusion of the adsorbed oxygen on the porous surface. The oxygen concentration on a porous surface, [O2]ads, can be described by the fractional coverage of oxygen on the porous surface
θ=
[ O2 ] ads [ O2 ] adsM
,
(2.37)
where [O2]adsM is the maximum oxygen concentration on the porous surface. The Stern-Volmer equation is then written as
I0 = 1 + τ k q 0 [ O2 ] adsM θ , I
(2.38)
and accordingly the convenient form of the Stern-Volmer relation for aerodynamic applications is θ I ref = A( T ) + B( T ) , (2.39) I θ ref where
A=
k q [ O2 ] adsM θ ref ka and B = . k a + k qref [ O2 ] adsM θ ref k a + k qref [ O2 ] adsM θ ref
(2.40)
28
2. Basic Photophysics
The rate constant kq for the oxygen quenching, which is surface-diffusioncontrolled, can be described by (Freeman and Doll 1983) 0 k q = 2πR AB λ B D = k q exp( − E sdiff / RT ) ,
(2.41)
where RAB is the relative distance between an adsorbed oxygen and an adsorbed luminophore, and D is the diffusivity and the parameter λΒ is a ratio of the modified first-order and second-order Bessel functions of the second kind. Basically, kq is temperature-dependent due to the Arrhenius relation D = D0 exp( − E sdiff / RT ) . To describe θ, either the Langmuir isotherm or the Freundlich isotherm can be used (Carraway et al. 1991b). The Langmuir isotherm relates θ to the partial pressure of oxygen pO2 in the working gas by
θ=
b p O2 1 + b p O2
.
(2.42)
The factor b in Eq. (2.42) is a function of temperature (Butt 1980)
σ eff
b= kd
2π M m RT
exp( − E ads / RT ) = b0
exp( − E ads / RT ) T
,
(2.43)
where kd is the desorption rate constant per unit surface area and Eads is the heat of adsorption. Since the oxygen concentration is [ O2 ] = b pO2 , Eq. (2.38) becomes
b pO2 1 + bref pO2 ref I ref = ALangmuir + B Langmuir 1 + b p O2 I bref pO2 ref
.
(2.44)
Eq. (2.44) is the adsorption-controlled model derived from the Langmuir isotherm; for [ O2 ] = b pO2 << [ O2 ] adsM , it can be approximated by
pO2 I ref = ALangmuir ( T ) + B Langmuir ( T ) pO2 ref I
,
(2.45)
.
(2.46)
where the Stern-Volmer coefficients are
ALangmuir =
B Langmuir =
ka + [ O k a k qref 2 ] adsM b ref p O2 ref k q [ O2 ] adsM b pO2 ref k a + k qref [ O2 ] adsM bref pO2 ref
The coefficient ALangmuir has the same temperature dependency as that for a conventional polymer PSP and that in the collision-controlled model, i.e.,
2.3. Models for Porous Pressure Sensitive Paint
ALangmuir = ALangmuir , ref
ka k aref
,
29
(2.47)
and the linearized form for ALangmuir is
ª E nr ALangmuir = ALangmuir , ref «1 + R T ref «¬
§ T − T ref ¨ ¨ T ref ©
·º ¸» . ¸» ¹¼
(2.48)
Hence, Eq. (2.48) indicates that ALangmuir is related to the temperature dependency of the non-radiative processes of the luminophore. On the other hand, BLangmuir has the following temperature dependency ª − E l § T ref ·º kq b T ref ¨ ¸» , (2.49) exp « = B Langmuir , ref − 1 B Langmuir = B Langmuir , ref ¨ ¸ T k qref b ref «¬ R T ref © T ¹»¼ where E l = E sdiff + E ads . Rewriting Eq. (2.49) in an exponential form yields
ª El B Langmuir = B Langmuir , ref exp «− «¬ R T ref
· 1 § T ref § T ref ¨¨ − 1¸¸ + ln¨¨ ¹ 2 © T © T
·º ¸¸» , ¹»¼
(2.50)
and furthermore, linearization of Eq. (2.50) at T = Tref gives
ª EL B Langmuir = B Langmuir , ref «1 + R T ref «¬
§ T − T ref ¨ ¨ T ref ©
·º ¸» , ¸» ¹¼
(2.51)
where E L = El − R Tref / 2 = E sdiff + E ads − R Tref / 2 . Clearly, the temperature dependency of the coefficient BLangmuir, Eq. (2.51), is associated with both surface diffusion and adsorption; but it has the similar form to Eq. (2.23) for a conventional polymer layer. The reference Stern-Volmer coefficients ALangmuir , ref and B Langmuir , ref
(their lengthy expressions are not given here) satisfy the
constraint ALangmuir , ref + B Langmuir , ref = 1 . The Freundlich isotherm can serve as another model for surface adsorption
θ = bF ( p O2 )γ
(2.52)
where the coefficient and exponent are
bF =
b0 T
γ
exp( − E ads / RT ) and γ =
RT E adsM
.
(2.53)
The exponent γ is an empirical parameter that is temperature-dependent. For a known γref at a known reference temperature Tref, EadsM is given by
30
2. Basic Photophysics
E adsM =
R T ref
.
γ ref
(2.54)
Substituting Eqs. (2.52), (2.53) and (2.54) into Eq. (2.39), we obtain the non-linear Stern-Volmer equation
§ pO I ref 2 = AFreundlich ( T ) + B Freundlich ( T ) ¨ ¨ p O ref I © 2
· ¸ ¸ ¹
γ
(2.55)
where
AFreundlich =
B Freundlich =
ka γ ref
k a + k qref [ O2 ] absM b Fref ( pO2 ref ) k q [ O2 ] absM b F ( pO2 ref )
γ ref γ ref
k a + k qref [ O2 ] absM b Fref ( pO2 ref )
.
(2.56)
The coefficient AFreundlich has the same temperature dependency as that in other models ka , (2.57) AFreundlich = AFreundlich , ref k aref and the linearized form for AFreundlich is
ª E nr AFreundlich = AFreundlich , ref «1 + R T ref «¬
§ T − T ref ¨ ¨ T ref ©
·º ¸» . ¸» ¹¼
(2.58)
.
(2.59)
The coefficient BFreundlich has the temperature dependency
B Freundlich = B Freundlich , ref
γ k q b F ( pO2 ref ) γ ref
k qref b Fref ( pO2 ref )
Substituting Eqs. (2.41) and (2.53) into (2.59) yields
B Freundlich = B Freundlich , ref
( T ref ) Tγ
( p O2 ref )γ
γ ref
( pO2 ref )
γ ref
ª −Ef exp « «¬ R T ref
§ T ref ·º ¨ ¸» , − 1 ¨ T ¸ © ¹ »¼
(2.60)
where E f = E sdiff + E ads . When an approximation γref ≈ γ is used for a small temperature change, the expression for B Freundlich becomes
B Freundlich
§ T ref = B Freundlich , ref ¨¨ © T
· ¸ ¸ ¹
γ ref
ª −Ef exp « ¬« R T ref
§ T ref ·º ¨ ¸ ¨ T − 1¸ » , © ¹»¼
(2.61)
2.4. Thermal Quenching
31
which is similar to BLangmuir. After rewriting all the terms in Eq. (2.61) in an exponential form, linearization at T = Tref yields ª EF B Freundlich = B Freundlich , ref «1 + R T ref «¬
§ T − Tref ¨ ¨ T ref ©
·º ¸» , ¸» ¹¼
(2.62)
where
E F = − E sdiff − E ads + γ ref R T ref
ª §p «ln¨ O2 ref « ¨¨ T ref «¬ ©
· ¸− ¸¸ ¹
º 1» . 2» »¼
(2.63)
Similar to the Langmuir-type model, the coefficient BFreundlich has the temperature dependency associated with surface diffusion and adsorption. However, the photophysical model Eq. (2.55) describes the non-linear behavior of the SternVolmer plot for a porous PSP.
2.4. Thermal Quenching For TSP where the paint layer is not oxygen-permeable such that no oxygen quenching occurs, from Eq. (2.8), the quantum yield of luminescence is simply given by kr I Φ = . (2.64) = Ia k r + k rn The temperature dependency of the non-radiative processes k nr can be decomposed into a temperature-independent term and a temperature-dependent term modeled by the Arrhenius relation (Bennett and McCartin 1966; Song and Fayer 1991; Schanze et al. 1997) E nr ), (2.65) k nr = k nr 0 + k nr 1 exp( − RT where k nr 0 = k nr ( T = 0 ) and k nr 1 are the rate constants for the temperatureindependent and temperature-dependent processes, respectively, Enr is the activation energy for the non-radiative process, R is the universal gas constant, and T is the absolute temperature in Kelvin. From Eqs. (2.64) and (2.65), we have ln
I ( T )[ I ( 0 ) − I ( Tref )] I ( Tref )[ I ( 0 ) − I ( T )]
=
E nr R
§1 ¨ − 1 ¨ T Tref ©
· ¸, ¸ ¹
(2.66)
where I ( 0 ) = I ( T = 0 ) is the luminescent intensity at the absolute zero temperature.
For | I ( T ) − I ( Tref ) | / I ( 0 ) << 1 and I ( T )I ( Tref ) /[ I ( 0 )] 2 << 1
32
2. Basic Photophysics
over a certain temperature range, a relation between the luminescent intensity and temperature can be approximately written in the Arrhenius form ln
E §1 I( T ) 1 = nr ¨ − I ( Tref ) R ¨© T Tref
· ¸. ¸ ¹
(2.67)
Theoretically speaking, the Arrhenius plot of ln[ I ( T ) / I ( Tref )] versus 1/T gives a straight line of the slope Enr/R. Experimental results indeed indicate that the simple Arrhenius relation Eq. (2.67) is able to fit data over a certain temperature range. However, for some TSPs, experimental data may not fully obey the simple Arrhenius relation over a wider range of temperature. Thus, as an alternative, an empirical functional relation between the luminescent intensity and temperature is I( T ) = f ( T / Tref ) , (2.68) I ( Tref ) where f ( T / Tref ) could be a polynomial, exponential or other function to fit experimental data over a working temperature range. Either Eq. (2.67) or Eq. (2.68) can serve as an operational form of the calibration relation for TSP in practical applications.
3. Physical Properties of Paints
3.1. Calibration In order to quantitatively measure air pressure with PSP, the relationship between the luminescence signal (intensity, lifetime or phase) and air pressure should be experimentally determined by calibration. Apparatus for calibration of PSP over a temperature range of 90-423 K are described in Appendix A. A generic calibration set-up consists of a pressure chamber, excitation light source and photodetector. A PSP sample is placed in the pressure chamber where pressure can be adjusted from vacuum to high pressures. The surface temperature of the PSP sample is controlled using a heating/cooling device and measured using a temperature sensor. The PSP sample is excited by an illumination source (e.g. UV lamp, LED array or laser) through a window of the pressure chamber. The luminescent emission from the paint sample, after filtered by a band-pass optical filter, is measured using a photodetector (e.g. photodiode, PMT or CCD camera), and the photodetector output is acquired with a PC over a range of pressures and temperatures. Therefore, the correspondence between the luminescence signal and pressure, which is usually described by the Stern-Volmer equation, is established over a range of temperatures. Typical calibration results for a number of PSP formulations based on Platinum Porphrins, Ruthenium complexes and Perlene/Pyrene are given in the following sections. The calibration set-up for PSP can be used for TSP calibration when the surface temperature of a paint sample varies while pressure in the chamber is kept constant. Calibration data for TSP are typically presented as an Arrhenius plot over a certain temperature range; typical calibration results for TSP formulations are given in Sections 3.3 and 3.4. The most common calibrations for PSP and TSP are based on measurements of the luminescent intensity as a function of pressure and/or temperature. As discussed before, however, the luminescent lifetime (or phase) is also a function of pressure and/or temperature. In a lifetime calibration apparatus, a pulsed (or modulated) excitation light source is used, and after an exciting pulse light ceases the exponential decay of the luminescent intensity is measured using a fastresponding photodetector and recorded with a PC or an oscilloscope. The luminescent lifetime can be determined by fitting data with a single exponential function or multiple-exponential function for certain paints over a range of pressures and temperatures. Early instrument for measuring the luminescent
34
3. Physical Properties of Paints
lifetime was described by Brody (1957) and Bennett (1960), and the current state of luminescent lifetime measurement systems in photochemistry and medical applications was comprehensively reviewed by Lakowicz (1991, 1999). The Stern-Volmer relations between the lifetime and oxygen partial pressure (or concentration) for oxygen sensitive luminescent materials were determined by Gewehr and Delpy (1993), Gord et al. (1995), Sacksteder et al. (1993), Xu et al. (1994), and Papkovsky (1995). Lifetime calibration results for TSPs and thermographic phosphors were also reported by Sholes and Small (1980), Grattan et al. (1987), Bugos (1989), Noel et al. (1985), and Lakowicz (1999). A more detailed discussion on the lifetime and phase methods is given in Chapter 6.
3.2. Typical Pressure Sensitive Paints A typical PSP is prepared by dissolving a luminescent dye and a polymer binder in a solvent; the order of mixing the components and the relative concentration of the components may change the characteristics of the paint. Chlorinated organic solvents such as dichloromethane and trichloroethane have been used for making PSP. The selection of a polymer binder for PSP is important, which should be based on a balanced consideration of its oxygen permeability, temperature effect, humidity effect, adhesion, mechanical stability, photodegradation, and other required properties. Silicone rubbers, GP-197, silica gel and sol-gel-derived coatings have been used as binders for PSPs and oxygen sensors (Wan 1993; Gallery 1993; Xu et al. 1994; MacCraith et al. 1995; Jordan et al. 1999a, 1999b). Other polymers and porous materials that are potentially useful for PSP can be found in the literature of polymers (Krevelen 1976; Mulder 1991; Fried 1995; Robinson and Perlmutter 1994). The permeability, solubility and diffusion coefficients of a polymer binder are related to the pressure sensitivity and time response of PSP. Furthermore, the behavior of PSP depends on interaction between a probe molecule and its surrounding polymer. The microenvironment of the probe molecule in the polymer binder can significantly affect the luminescence and quenching behavior (Hartmann et al. 1995; Meier et al. 1995; Xu et al. 1994; Lu and Winnik 2001; Lu et al. 2001). Also, it was observed that a basecoat might affect the behavior of PSP (Coyle et al. 1995). A useful review on quenching of luminescence by oxygen in polymer films was given by Lu and Winnik (2000), stressing on luminescent materials and polymers. Table 3.1 lists some PSP formulations along with their spectroscopic properties and the Stern-Volmer coefficients. In Table 3.1, the Stern-Volmer coefficients A( T ) and B( T ) are the coefficients in the linear relation
I ref / I = A( T ) + B( T ) p / pref at the room temperature of about 20 C, where the o
reference pressure p ref is the ambient pressure of 1 atm. For certain PSPs that do not completely obey the linear Stern-Volmer relation, the coefficients A( T ) and
B( T ) are estimated by fitting data over a finite linear range. The results are collected from the theses and papers by Wan (1993), Burns (1995), Baron et al.
3.2. Typical Pressure Sensitive Paints
35
(1993), Kavandi et al. (1990), and McLachlan et al. (1993a, 1995), which documented the absorption spectra, emission spectra, and Stern-Volmer plots of oxygen-sensing luminophores and supporting polymer matrices. Table 3.1 also include a number of proprietary PSPs developed by TsAGI (Troyanovsky et al. 1993; Bukov et al. 1993), the former McDonnell Douglas (now Boeing at St. Louis) (Morris et al. 1993a, 1993b; Morris 1995), the University of Washington/NASA Ames (McLachlan and Bell 1995) and NASA Langley (Oglesby and Jordan 2000). Some PSP formulations of the former McDonnell Douglas have been patented (Schwab and Levy 1994). Generally speaking, a good PSP has the Stern-Volmer coefficient B( T ) larger than 0.5, indicating acceptable pressure sensitivity for quantitative measurements (Oglesby et al. 1995a). Table 3.1. Pressure sensitive paints Luminophore
Binder
Excitation Emission Stern-Volmer wavelength wavelength coefficients (nm) (nm) A B
H2TSPP H2(Me2N)TFPP H2TCPP H2TNMPP H2TTMAPP Perylene dibutyrate Perylene dye PtTFPP
silica gel silica gel silica gel silica gel silica gel silica gel silica gel silica gel DuPont Chrom. Polystyrene FEM
400 400 410 420 410 457 480, 530 390
PtTFPP PtTFPP PtOEP Pyrene Ru(bpy) Ru(ph2-phen) [Ru(ph2-phen)3] 2+
FIB GP-197 silica gel GE RTV 118 silica gel silica gel GE RTV118 GP-134/silica
650, 709 650 709 661, 714 653, 710 520 550, 570 650
390
650
390 366, 543
650 650
360-390 337, 457 337, 457
470 600 600
337
620
NASA-Ames PSP McDonnell Douglas PSP TsAGI LPSL2
blue 320-350
425-550
0.58 0.43 0.40 0.43 0.40 0.33 0.47 0.27 0.50 0.29 0.17
0.42 0.56 0.61 0.60 0.60 0.67 0.53 0.72 0.52 0.69 0.83
0.13 0.32 0.12 0.12 0.33 0.17 0.27 0.22
0.87 0.70 0.88 0.88 0.68 0.84 0.75 0.78
0.38
0.62
0.18
0.82
0.25
0.75
Lifetime Temp. at room coeff. temp. (%/0C) (micro s) ~0 ~0 0.013 50
4.5 0.35 -2.1 -1.8 -4.3 -1.4
50
-1.0 -1.7 -~0
3 4.7 0.3
-1.3 -0.78 -1.5
-0.3
Reference
Purchase source
Wan (1993) Wan (1993) Wan (1993) Wan (1993) Wan (1993) Burns (1995) Wan (1993) Wan (1993), Burns (1995)
Porphyrin Porphyrin Porphyrin Aldrich Aldrich Pylam Aldrich Porphyrin
Burns (1995)
NASA Langley ISSI Porphyrin
Burns (1995) Burns (1995)
Aldrich GFS Chem.
Xu et al. (1994) McLachlan and Bell (1995) Dowgwillo et al. (1994) Bukov et al. (1993)
NASA Ames McDonnell Douglas TsAGI
Three families of luminescent dyes, Platinum Porphyrins, Ruthenium Polypyridyls and Pyrene derivatives, have been commonly used for making PSP. Recipes of three PSP formulations are given in Appendix B. The Platinum Porphyrin compounds, which can be excited by either an UV light or a green light, emit red luminescence. They are very sensitive to oxygen, but they often have a long lifetime and low luminescent intensity at the atmospheric pressure. The Ruthenium compounds also emit red luminescence when excited by either an UV light or a blue light. They are very photo-stable, but are difficult to incorporate into polymer systems. The Pyrene derivatives, which are UV excited, emit blue
36
3. Physical Properties of Paints
luminescence. The Pyrene derivatives have weak temperature sensitivity; however, they suffer from photodegradation and sublimation. Figure 3.1 shows the chemical structure, and absorption and emission spectra for platinum meso-tetra(pentafluorophenyl)porphine (PtTFPP). Figures 3.2 and 3.3 show the Stern-Volmer plots and temperature dependencies for two PtTFPP PSP formulations: PtTFPP in the FIB polymer (poly-heptafluoro-n-butyl methacrylate-co-hexafluorisopropyl methacrylate) developed by the University of Washington (Gouterman and Carlson 1999) and PtTFPP in the FEM polymer (poly-tifluoro-ethylmethacrylate-co-isobutylmethacrylate) developed by NASA Langley (Oglesby and Jordan 2000). In these figures, the lower temperature sensitivity of PSP at vacuum represents the intrinsic temperature dependency of the luminophore, while the higher temperature sensitivity of PSP at the atmospheric pressure indicates an additional temperature effect on the oxygen diffusion in the polymer. F
F F
F
F
F
F
F N
F N F
Pt
F N F
N
F
F F F
(a)
F
F F
F
(b) Fig. 3.1. (a) Chemical structure of PtTFPP, (b) absorption and emission spectra of PtTFPP. From Puklin et al. (2000)
3.2. Typical Pressure Sensitive Paints
37
1 .4 1 .3
2 4 .4 o 3 4 .7 o 4 5 .7 o 5 5 .3 o
1 .2 1 .1 1 .0
C C C C
I
ref
/I
0 .9 0 .8 0 .7 0 .6 0 .5 0 .4
I ref = I a t 1 4 . 7 0 p si a a i r a t 2 4 . 4 o C
0 .3 0 .2 0 .1 0 .0 0 .0
0 .1
0 .2
0 .3
0 .4
0 .5
0 .6
0 .7
0.8
0 .9
1.0
1 .1
P /P r e f
(a)
Relative Emission Intensity
1 .0 -0.46%/ o C
vacuum 0 .9
-1.00%/ o C
0 .8
1 atm
0 .7 20
30
40
T e m p e ra tu re ( o C )
50
60
(b) Fig. 3.2. (a) The Stern-Volmer plots, and (b) temperature dependency for PtTFPP in the FIB Polymer. From Oglesby and Jordan (2000)
38
3. Physical Properties of Paints 1 .5 1 .4
25.1o 35.6o 45.5o 55.6o
1 .3 1 .2 1 .1
C C C C
1 .0
Iref /I
0 .9 0 .8 0 .7 0 .6 0 .5 0 .4
I r e f = I a t 1 4 . 7 0 p si a a i r a t 2 5 . 1 o C
0 .3 0 .2 0 .1 0 .0 0.0
0 .1
0.2
0 .3
0 .4
0 .5
0 .6
0 .7
0 .8
0.9
1 .0
1 .1
P /P r e f
(a) 1.0
Relative Emission Intensity
vacuum -0.64%/o C
0.9 1 atm
0.8 -1.4%/o C
0.7 20
30
40
50
Temperature (o C )
(b) Fig. 3.3. (a) The Stern-Volmer plots, and (b) temperature dependency for PtTFPP in the FEM polymer (NASA Langley). From Oglesby and Jordan (2000)
3.2. Typical Pressure Sensitive Paints
39
2.2
85
FIB FEM SOLGEL UNICOAT PAR
2.0
80
1.8
75 ST (%/deg)
SP (%/bar)
1.6
70 65
1.4 1.2 1.0
60
FIB FEM SOLGEL UNICOAT PAR
55
0.8 0.6 0.4
50 10
15
20
25 T (deg. C)
30
35
40
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
p/pref
Fig. 3.4. Pressure sensitivity (SP) and temperature sensitivity (ST) for PtTFPP in five different polymer binders, where Pref = 1 bar and Tref = 10°C. From Mebarki and Le Sant (2001)
In order to examine the effect of a polymer binder on the properties of PSP, Mebarki and Le Sant (2001) calibrated five PSP formulations that used the same porphyrin molecule, PtTFPP, with different polymer binders. Two formulations, the PAR PSP from the Institute for Aerospace Research (IAR) of NRC in Canada (Mebarki 2000) and the FEM PSP from NASA Langley (Oglesby and Upchurch 1999), are not commercially available. Other paints, the FIB PSP originally developed by the University of Washington (Gouterman and Carlson 1999), solgel PSP (Jordan et al. 1999a, 1999b) and the Uni-Coat PSP (Mebarki 2000), were commercially produced by Innovative Scientific Solutions Inc. (ISSI). Except for the Uni-Coat PSP that did not require a primer layer, the commercial FIB and solgel PSP formulations were supplied with their respective primers. To simplify the application procedures and solve adhesion problems, the FIB active layer was applied on the top of the Tristar (DHMS C4.01TY3) white epoxy primer that was also used as a screen layer for both the FEM PSP and PAR PSP. It was found that the primer had no effect on the pressure or temperature sensitivity of the active layer. However, the polymer binder (or permeable matrix) in which the porphyrin molecule was immobilized affected both the pressure and temperature sensitivities of the paint. To evaluate the performance of PSP, the pressure sensitivity and temperature sensitivity are defined as SP = ∆( I ref / I ) / ∆P (in % per bar) and
ST = −∆( I / I ref ) / ∆T (in % per degree), respectively. The pressure sensitivity was calculated in a pressure range of 0.15-2 bars and the temperature sensitivity was determined in a temperature range of 10-35°C. Figure 3.4 shows the pressure sensitivity SP as a function of temperature and the temperature sensitivity ST as a function of pressure. The pressure sensitivity SP varied from 55% to nearly
40
3. Physical Properties of Paints
80% per bar, depending on the polymer binder used and temperature as well. The FIB PSP formulation had nearly constant pressure sensitivity over a temperature range of 10-40°C. The Uni-Coat and sol-gel PSP formulations had a similar linear dependency of the pressure sensitivity SP on temperature; the temperature sensitivity ST ranges from 0.6% to 1.6% per degree. The temperature sensitivity was somewhat affected by pressure for all the PSP formulations except the FIB PSP. The FIB PSP also has the lowest temperature sensitivity among them. Figure 3.5 shows the chemical structure, and absorption and emission spectra of Bathophen Ruthenium Chloride (Ru(ph2-phen) or Ru(dpp)). Ruthenium-based oxygen sensors have been studied extensively by analytical chemists (Bacon and Demas 1987; Carraway et al. 1991a, 1991b; Sacksteder et al. 1993; Xu et al. 1994; Klimant and Wolfbeis 1995). The Ruthenium-based PSP formulations have been developed and used for wind tunnel testing by the former McDonnell Douglas (now Boeing at St. Louis) (Schwab and Levy 1994). Figure 3.6 shows the SternVolmer plots for Ru(dpp) in GE RTV 118 added with silica gel particles at different temperatures; Figure 3.7 shows the luminescent lifetime as a function of o pressure for Ru(dpp) in GE RTV 118 at 22 C.
N
N
Ru2+ N
N N
N
Intensity (arbitrary units)
(a)
Absorption
200
300
400
Luminescence
500
600
700
800
900
Wavelength (nm)
(b) Fig. 3.5. (a) Chemical structure, and (b) Absorption and emission spectra of Ru(ph2-phen) or Ru(dpp)
3.2. Typical Pressure Sensitive Paints
41
1.0 243K 253K 258K 263K 268K 273K 283K 293K linear fit
0.9
0.8
Iref/I
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3 0.0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1.0
P/Pref
Fig. 3.6. The Stern-Volmer plots for Ru(ph2-phen) or Ru(dpp) in GE RTV 110 added with silica gel particles, where the reference pressure pref is 14.5 psi and reference temperature is 293 K. From Lachendro (2000) 1.4
5 Ru(ph2-phen) in GE RTV 118
4
1.2
3
0.8 0.6
2
τref/τ
Lifetime τ (µs)
1.0
0.4
τ τref/τ
1
0.2
0
0.0 0
200
400
600
800
P (mmHg)
Fig. 3.7. Lifetime-pressure relation for Ru(ph2-phen) in GE RTV 118 at 22 C, where τref is the lifetime at the ambient pressure (1 atm). From Liu et al. (1997b) o
Figure 3.8 shows the chemical structure and absorption and emission spectra of Pyrene. The Pyrene-based PSP formulations were developed by TsAGI/OPTROD in Russia (Fonov et al. 1998). One of them was the binary paint (B1 PSP) in which a pressure-insensitive reference component was added to correct the excitation light variations on a surface in performing a ratio between the wind-on and wind-off images. Figure 3.9 shows the Stern-Volmer plots at different temperatures for Pyrene complex in GE RTV 118. Obviously, this Pyrene-based
42
3. Physical Properties of Paints o
PSP exhibits weak temperature dependency over a temperature range of 17-40 C. Note that Perylene and its derivatives like Green Gold (perylene dibutylate) were also used as a luminescent dye for PSP. Besides TsAGI, ONERA in France and DLR in Germany developed Pyrene-based PSP formulations as well (Engler et al. 2001a). The PyGd PSP formulation developed by ONERA contained Pyrene as a pressure-sensitive dye and a gadolinium oxysulfide as a reference component. Figure 3.10 shows the emission spectrum of the PyGd PSP excited at 325 nm. The two components in the paint absorbed an ultraviolet excitation light and emitted at sufficiently different wavelengths such that the emissions from the two components can be separated using optical filters. Figure 3.11 shows the SternVolmer plots at the ambient temperature for three Pyrene-based PSP formulations: PyGd, B1 and PdGd. Because the temperature sensitivity of the reference component was similar to that of the Pyrene dye in the PyGd PSP, the temperature effect can be compensated by taking a ratio between the luminescent intensities from the pressure-sensitive component (Pyrene) and reference component. As a result, the PyGd PSP displayed very low temperature sensitivity of 0.05%/K. A number of ‘Göttingen Dyes’ (GD) were developed by DLR and the University of Göttingen, and three stable Pyrene-based paints, GD145, GD146 and GD147, were tested in wind tunnels (Engler and Klein 1997b). Figure 3.12 shows the pressure sensitivities of the Göttingen PSP formulations. A shortcoming of Pyrene-based paints is that sublimation may occur when temperature is greater o than 40 C.
(a)
Emission
(b) Wavelength (nm)
Fig. 3.8. (a) Chemical structure of Pyrene, and (b) absorption and emission spectra of Pyrene. From Mebarki (2001)
3.2. Typical Pressure Sensitive Paints
43
intensity (A.U)
Fig. 3.9. The Stern-Volmer plots for Pyrene in GE RTV 118, where the excitation source is filtered at 334±5 nm and the luminescent emission is filtered at >450 nm. The reference conditions are Tref = 17°C and Pref = 1bar. Sublimation of Pyrene occurs initially at 40°C, o resulting in an intensity decrease and thus a different curve at 50 C. From Mebarki (2001)
vacuum
Pref=1bar
300
400
500
600 λ (nm)
Fig. 3.10. Emission spectra of a binary Pyrene-based PSP (PyGd) at 1 bar and vacuum. From Engler et al. (2001a)
44
3. Physical Properties of Paints 1.02 1 0.98
Iref/I
0.96 0.94 0.92 0.9 PyGd
0.88
PdGd 0.86 0.84 0.82
B1 0.84
0.86
0.88
0.9
0.92
0.94
0.96
0.98
1
1.02
P/Pref
Fig. 3.11. The Stern-Volmer plots for three Pyrene-based PSP formulations (PyGd, PdGd, and B1) used at ONERA. From Engler et al. (2001a)
Fig. 3.12. The Stern-Volmer plots for the Göttingen Pyrene-based PSP formulations (GD 145, GD 146, and GD 147). From Engler et al. (2001a)
3.3. Typical Temperature Sensitive Paints
45
3.3. Typical Temperature Sensitive Paints Like PSP, TSP is prepared by dissolving a luminescent dye and a binder in a solvent. Many commercially available resins and epoxies can serve as polymer binders for TSP if they are not oxygen permeable and do not degrade the activity of the probe luminophore molecule. Table 3.2 lists some TSP formulations as well as the spectroscopic properties, temperature sensitivities and useful temperature measurement ranges. Data are collected from Campbell (1993) and Gallery (1993) and other sources. For a comparison between different TSP formulations, the maximum logarithmic slope max{ d [ln( I / I ref )] / dT } is used as an indicator of the temperature sensitivity for TSP over a certain temperature range, where I ref is the reference luminescence intensity. Here, the logarithmic slope is used since it is independent of the reference intensity that is different in various sources. Two proprietary TSP formulations and two high-temperature thermographic phosphors are also included in Table 3.2 for comparison. Figure 3.13 shows typical temperature dependencies of the luminescent intensity for a number of TSP formulations. Some of them have been used to measure the temperature and heat transfer fields in various applications (Kolodner and Tyson 1982, 1983a, 1983b; Romano et al. 1989; Campbell et al. 1993, 1994; Liu et al. 1995a, 1995b, 1996; Hamner et al. 1994; Asai et al. 1996, 1997c). Table 3.2. Temperature sensitive paints Luminophore
Binder
Coumanin CuOEP
PMMA GP-197
EuTTA Perylene Perylenedicarboximide Pyronin B Pyronin Y Rhodamine B Ru(bpy) Ru(bpy)/Zeolite
Dope Dope PMMA PMMA Dope Dope Shellac Poly Vinyl Alcohol GP-197 Poly Vinyl Alcohol
Ru(trpy) Ru(trpy)/Zeolite La2O2S:Eu Y 2O3:Eu NASA-Ames (Univ. of Washington) TSP McDonnell Douglas TSP
Excitation Emission Useful wavelength wavelength temperature (nm) (nm) range (degree C) UV 20 to 100 480-515 -180 to 20
Max. log slope (%/0C) -0.4 -2.9
Lifetime at room temp. (micro s)
350 330-450 480-515 460-580 460-580 460-590 320, 452 320, 452
-3.9 -1.9 -0.7 -4.6 -5.5 -1.8 -0.93 -4.1
500 0.005
550-590 588 588
-20 to 80 0 to 100 50 to 100 50 to 100 0 to 100 0 to 80 0 to 90 -20 to 80
310, 475 310, 475
620 620
-170 to -50 -1.34 -180 to 80 -1.8
337 266
537 611
100 to 200 -3.5 510 to 1000 -1.88
612 430-580
UV 340-500
>500
0 to 50
-3.9
-5 to 90
-2.7
0.004 5
Reference
Purchase source
Campbell (1993) Campbell et al. (1994) Liu (1996) Campbell (1994) Campbell (1993) Campbell (1993) Campbell (1993) Sullivan (1991) Liu (1996) Campbell et al. (1994)
Purdue Purdue
Campbell (1993) Campbell et al. (1994) 100 1400
Noel et al. (1985) Alaruri et al. (1995) McLachlan et al (1993b) Cattafesta and Moore (1995)
Kodak Aldrich Aldrich Aldrich Aldrich Aldrich GFS Chem. GFS Chem. Purdue Purdue Allison Eng. Univ. of Washington McDonnell Douglas
46
3. Physical Properties of Paints 1.2 1.0
I/Iref
0.8 8
5
0.6
7 6
0.4
4
0.2 1
2
3
0.0 -150
-100
-50
0
50
100
150
T (deg. C)
Fig. 3.13. Temperature dependencies of the luminescence intensity for TSP formulations: (1) Ru(trpy) in Ethanol/Methanol, (2) Ru(trpy)(phtrpy) in GP-197, (3) Ru(VH127) in GP197, (4) Ru(trpy) in DuPont ChromaClear, (5) Ru(trpy)/Zeolite in GP-197, (6) EuTTA in dope, (7) Ru(bpy) in DuPont ChromaClear, (8) Perylenedicarboximide in Sucrose o Octaacetate. (Tref = -150 C). From Liu et al. (1997b)
Two typical TSP formulations are Ru(bpy) in an automobile clear coat (DuPont ChromaClear) binder and EuTTA in model airplane dope (see Appendix B); both are easy to prepare and use. Figure 3.14(a) shows the chemical structure of tris(2,2’-bipyridyl) ruthenium or Ru(bpy) and Figure 3.14(b) shows the absorption and emission spectra of Ru(bpy) that are similar to those of Ru(dpp) for PSP. Ru(bpy) can be excited by a UV lamp, nitrogen laser, argon laser, doubled YAG laser or blue LED array. Since the Stokes shift is large (the emission peak at about 620 nm), the excitation light can be easily separated from the luminescent emission using an optical filter. An automobile urethane clear coat, which is usually used as a top coat on most automobiles, is used as a polymer binder for Ru(bpy); particularly, DuPont ChromaClear 7500S is used, but other brands should work as well. The advantage of this binder is that it is oxygen impermeable, readily available, and easy to spray although some pressure sensitivity was observed at very high pressures and temperatures. Figure 3.13 shows the temperature dependency of the luminescent intensity for Ru(bpy) in DuPont ChromaClear along with other TSP formulations. Ru(bpy) can also mixed with a Shellac binder; the Ru(bpy)-Shellac TSP is similar to Ru(bpy) in DuPont ChromaClear in terms of the temperature sensitivity. It is also easy to apply. Figures 3.15 and 3.16 show, respectively, the Arrhenius plot and lifetime for the Ru(bpy)-Shellac TSP compared with the EuTTA-dope TSP.
3.3. Typical Temperature Sensitive Paints
N
N N
2+
N
Ru N
47
N
Intensity (arb. units)
(a)
Absorption
200
300
(b)
400
Emission
500
600
700
800
900
Wavelength (nm)
Fig. 3.14. (a) Chemical structure of Ru(bpy), and (b) absorption and emission spectra of Ru(bpy) 1
ln[I(T)/I(Tref)]
0
-1
-2
EuTTA-dope Ru(bpy)-Shellac
-3 -0.8
-0.6
-0.4
-0.2
0.0 3
0.2
0.4
-1
(1/T - 1/Tref)10 (K )
Fig. 3.15. The Arrhenius plots for two TSP formulations: EuTTA-dope TSP and Ru(bpy)Shellac TSP, where Tref = 293 K. From Liu et al. (1997b)
3. Physical Properties of Paints
Lifetime of Ru(bpy)-Shellac (µs)
7
2.5 Ru(bpy)-Shellac EuTTA-dope
6
2.0
5 1.5
4 1.0
3
0.5
2 1
Lifetime of EuTTA-dope (ms)
48
0.0
0
20
40
60
80
Temperature (degree C)
Fig. 3.16. Lifetime-temperature relations for two Ru(bpy)-Shellac TSP and EuTTA-dope TSP. From Liu et al. (1997b) S O F F
O
F
F
F
F
Eu O
O
O
S F
Intensity (arb. units)
(a)
O
Absorption
300
(b)
F F
350
400
450
S
Emission
500
550
600
650
700
Wavelength (nm)
Fig. 3.17. (a) Chemical structure of EuTTA, (b) absorption and emission spectra of EuTTA
3.3. Typical Temperature Sensitive Paints
49
Another good TSP is based on Europium (III) Thenoyltrifluoroacetonate or EuTTA whose structure and the absorption and emission spectra are shown in Fig. 3.17. Obviously, a UV lamp or a nitrogen laser can be used for excitation. EuTTA has a high quantum yield and a large Stokes shift (the emission peak at about 620 nm). The binder used with this luminphore is a clear model airplane dope that, like DuPont ChromaClear and Shellac, is readily available, easy to spray, and oxygen impermeable. Figures 3.15 and 3.16 show, respectively, the Arrhenius plot and lifetime for the EuTTA-dope TSP along with those for the Ru(bpy)-Shellac TSP. Thermographic phosphors and thermochromic liquid crystals are also temperature sensitive coatings for measuring the surface temperature distributions. Similar to polymer-based TSPs, thermographic phosphors utilize the thermal quenching of the luminescent emission from ceramic materials that are doped or activated with rare-earth elements (Allison and Gillies 1997). However, they are usually in the form of insoluble powders or crystals in contrast to a polymer-based TSP where luminescent molecules are immobilized in a polymer matrix. The luminescent intensity (or lifetime) of thermographic phosphor and polymer-based TSP follows the same functional relation I ∝ [ 1 + a0 exp( − a1 / T )] −1 . Figure 3.18 shows the measurement envelops of thermographic phosphors and polymerbased luminescent TSPs. A family of thermographic phosphors can cover a temperature range of 273-1600 K, which overlaps with the temperature range of the polymer-based TSP family from 90 to 423 K. Hence, a combination of thermographic phosphors and polymer-based luminescent TSPs can cover a very broad range from cryogenic to high temperatures. The measurement systems (intensity- and lifetime-based systems) for thermographic phosphors are essentially the same as those for polymer-based luminescent TSPs. The emission spectrum of certain phosphor has multiple distinct lines that have very different temperature sensitivities. Thus, an emission-intensity ratio between the temperature-sensitive and -insensitive lines can eliminate the effect of nonuniform illumination on a surface. Note that certain emission lines of certain phosphors are also temperature sensitive in cryogenic conditions. Thermochromic liquid crystals selectively reflect light depending on the surface temperature, and hence the dominant wavelength or hue of the reflected light varies monotonically o with temperature over a relatively narrow temperature range of about 32-42 C (Smith et al. 2000). For comparison, Figure 3.18 plots the normalized hue of a typical thermochromic liquid crystal as a function of temperature; the temperature sensitivity of the thermochromic liquid crystal is high over a narrow temperature range.
50
3. Physical Properties of Paints
Normalized Luminescent Intensity or Hue
1.4 Measurement Envelop of TSPs Measurement Envelop of Phosphors Typical Calibration Curve for Liquid Crystal
1.2 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0
0
200
400
600
800 1000 1200 Temperature (Kelvin)
1400
1600
1800
Fig. 3.18. Measurement envelops for polymer-based TSPs and thermographic phosphors along with a typical normalized calibration curve of thermochromic liquid crystal
3.4. Cryogenic Paints A challenging problem is application of PSP in cryogenic wind tunnels like the NASA Langley National Transonic Facility (NTF) and European Transonic Wind Tunnel Facility (ETW). Porous materials were usually used as binders for PSP at cryogenic temperatures. Porous material has a large exposure surface area where the probe luminophore can be directly applied and luminescence can be directly quenched by oxygen. The use of porous materials as binders allows PSP measurements at cryogenic temperatures and achieves fast time response as well (in the order of microseconds). Various porous materials were investigated as binders for PSP, including a thin layer chromatography (TLC) plate (Baron et al. 1993), hydrothermal coating (Bacsa and Gratzel 1996), sol-gel (MacCraith et al. 1995; Jordan et al. 1999a, 1999b), tape-casting (Scroggin 1999), anodized aluminum (Asai 1997a), anodized titanium and porous paper filter (Erausquin 1998; Erauquin et al. 1998). Aluminum can be anodized to create a thin aluminum oxide layer on the surface through an electrochemical process. Anodized aluminum (AA) is highly porous with 10-100 nm micropores uniformly distributed on the surface. AA-PSP is made by adsorbing the luminophore into the pores on the AA surface (Asai 1997a). Figure 3.19 shows the Stern-Volmer plot for an AA-PSP, Ru(dpp) on anodized aluminum, compared with a conventional polymer-based PSP (Ru(dpp) in RTV) at cryogenic temperatures. This AA-PSP still exhibits good sensitivity to oxygen even at 100 K, whereas the conventional PSP loses its sensitivity to oxygen at 150 K. Upchurch et al. (1998) and Asai et al. (2000, 2002) developed a polymer-based cryogenic PSP that used highly porous Poly(TMSP) as a binder.
3.4. Cryogenic Paints
51
To compare the two cryogenic PSP formulations, Figure 3.20 shows the SternVolmer plots for the Poly(TMSP)-based PSP and AA-PSP that use Ru(dpp) as a luminescent dye; both PSPs exhibit the non-linear behavior in the Stern-Volmer plot. 2.0
AA-PSP (pO ref=14Pa, T=100K) 2
Iref/I
1.5
1.0
0.5
conventional PSP (pO ref=14Pa, T=150K) 2
0.0 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
p /p O2
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
O2ref
Fig. 3.19. The Stern-Volmer plots for a porous AA-PSP and a conventional PSP with silicone rubber as a binder at cryogenic temperatures. Both PSP formulations uses Ru(ph2phen) as a probe luminophore. From Sakaue (1999)
1.0 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0.0
É ÑÉÑÉ ÑÉ É É Ñ T=100K ÉÉ Ñ É ÉÉ Ñ ÉÉ Ñ É ÉÉ ÑÑ ÉÉ Ñ Ñ ÉÉ ÑÑÑ É ÑÑÑ É ÑÑ Ñ poly(TMSP) Ñ ÉÑÑ É anodized É ÑÑ 0
200 400 600 800 1000 oxygen concentration, ppm
Fig. 3.20. Comparison of Poly(TMSP) PSP with anodized aluminum (AA) PSP at 100 K, where excitation is at 400±50 nm and emission is at 650±50 nm. From Asai et al. (2000)
A family of the luminescent molecules Ru(trpy) (see Fig. 3.21 for the chemical structure) has been studied for making cryogenic TSP formulations since it is found that these compounds are temperature sensitive at cryogenic temperatures (Campbell 1994; Erausquin 1998; Iijima et al. 2003). They have very intense emission at low temperatures, but they are nearly fully quenched at the room temperature. The absorption and emission spectra of the family of Ru(trpy) are
52
3. Physical Properties of Paints
very similar to those of Ru(dpp) and Ru(bpy). The Ru(trpy) compounds, which can be excited by either a UV light or blue light, emit red luminescence. Various [Ru(trpy)2] molecules with different ligands were synthesized (Erausquin 1998). The dynamics of the metal-to-ligand bond, as well as the electron donating or accepting characteristics of the ligand, has a significant effect on the temperature sensitivity of a luminescent molecule. Thus, this would enable synthesis of a molecule specifically designed to respond with high sensitivity over a certain range of cryogenic temperatures. DuPont ChromaClear (CC) is selected as a binder for cryogenic TSP due to its low oxygen diffusivity and good surface adhesion at cryogenic temperatures (Erausquin 1998). Figure 3.22 shows a comparison of several synthesized [Ru(trpy)2] compounds in the polymers CC and GP-197. In general, interaction between a polymer binder and a luminescent molecule can affect the mobility of the metal-to-ligand bonds, changing the temperature dependency of the paint. Figure 3.23 shows the temperature dependencies for [Ru(trpy)(phtrpy)](PF6)2 in two different polymer binders CC and GP-197. Other Ruthenium compounds have a good response at cryogenic temperatures as well, as shown in Table 3.3 that summarizes the temperature sensitivities and useful temperature ranges for cryogenic TSP formulations calibrated by Erausquin (1998).
N
N N
Ru
N
Fig. 3.21. Chemical structure of Ru(trpy)
I(T) / Iref(T)
1.6 1.4
[Ru(trpy)2] in CC [Ru(trpy)(phtrpy)](PF6)2
1.2
[Ru(ppd-trpy)2](TFPB)2 in CC
1.0
[Ru(trpy)(VH-127)](PF6)2 in GP-197
0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0
-200
-150
-100
-50
0
50
Temperature (oC)
Fig. 3.22. Comparison of Ru(trpy)-based cryogenic TSP formulations, where CC denotes DuPont ChromaClear. From Erausquin (1998)
3.4. Cryogenic Paints
53
1.6 GP-197 Chromaclear
1.4
I(T) / Iref(T)
1.2 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 -200
-150
-100
-50
0
50
Temperature (oC)
Fig. 3.23. Temperature calibration for cryogenic TSPs: [Ru(trpy)(phtrpy)](PF6)2 in GP-197 and DuPont ChromaClear. From Erausquin (1998) Table 3.3. Cryogenic temperature sensitive paints
Paint [Rh(bzq)2Cl]2 in CC
Useful temp.
Temp. sensi. coeff.
range ( C)
∆(I/Iref)/∆T
-175 to -130
-0.0191
o
[Rh(bzq)2(phen)](PF6) in CC
-100 to –50
-0.0107
[Ru(trpy)] in CC
-175 to –85
-0.0112
[Ru(trpy)(4'-C6F5-trpy)](NO3)2 in CC
-175 to –50
-0.0081
[Ru(trpy)(4'-Cl-trpy)](Cl2) in CC
-175 to –50
-0.0106
[Ru(trpy)(4'-NC-trpy)](NO3)2 in CC
-150 to –50
-0.0078
[Ru(phtrpy)(Cltrpy)](NO3)2 in CC
-175 to –50
-0.0093
[Ru(trpy)(4'-TfO-trpy)](NO3)2 in CC
-175 to –50
-0.0101
[Ru(trpy)(MeStrpy)](NO3)2 in CC
-175 to –75
-0.0105
[Ru(trpy)(phtrpy)](PF6)2 in GP-197
-175 to –50
-0.0114
[Ru(trpy)(phtrpy)](PF6)2 in CC
-150 to –100
-0.0142
[Ru(trpy)(ppd-trpy)](TFPB)2 in CC
-175 to –50
-0.0097
[Ru(trpy)(phyphen)](TFPB)2 in CC
-175 to –50
-0.0090
[Ru(trpy)(SO2Me-trpy)](PF6)2 in CC
-175 to –75
-0.0104
[Ru(trpy2)](TFPB)2 in CC
-170 to –75
-0.0114
[Ru(ppd-trpy)2](TFPB)2 in CC
-175 to –75
-0.0149
[Ru(trpy)(Vh127)](PF6)2 in GP-197
-175 to –75
-0.0154
54
3. Physical Properties of Paints
3.5. Multiple-Luminophore Paints The intensity-based method for PSP and TSP requires a ratio between the wind-on and wind-off images of a painted model. When a model moves in a nonhomogenous illumination filed during a test, the image-ratio method inevitably causes inaccuracy in determining pressure and temperature. A multipleluminophore paint is designed to eliminate the need for a wind-off reference image. Generally, a two-luminophore PSP consists of a pressure-sensitive luminophore and a pressure-insensitive reference luminophore; similarly, a twoluminophore TSP combines a temperature-sensitive luminophore with a temperature-insensitive reference luminophore. The probe and reference luminophores can be excited by the same illumination light. Ideally, there is no overlap between the emission spectra of the probe and reference luminophores such that the luminescent emissions from the two components can be completely separated using optical filters. Theoretically, a ratio I λ1 / I λ2 between the probe and reference images could able to eliminate the effects of spatial non-uniform illumination, paint thickness and luminophore concentration, where I λ1 and I λ2 are the luminescent intensities at the emission wavelengths λ1 and λ 2 , respectively. However, McLean (1998) pointed out that since two luminophores cannot be perfectly mixed, the simple two-color intensity ratio I λ1 / I λ2 cannot completely compensate the effect of non-homogenous dye concentration. In this case, a ratio of ratios ( I λ1 / I λ2 ) /( I λ1 / I λ2 )0 should be used to correct the effects of non-homogenous dye concentration and paint thickness variation, where the subscript 0 denotes the wind-off condition. Besides the above combinations of luminophores, a temperature-sensitive luminophore, which cannot be quenched by oxygen, can be combined with an oxygen-sensitive luminophore. This two-luminophore temperature/pressure paint can be used for correcting the temperature effect of PSP. In particular, when the temperature dependencies of the two luminophores are close, a two-color intensity ratio between the two luminophores exhibits a very weak temperature dependency (Engler et al. 2001a). Figure 3.24 shows a ratio of ratios of a two-luminophore PSP (PtTFPP in FIB with a proprietary reference luminophore) as a function of pressure at different temperatures (Crafton et al. 2002). Clearly, the data at different temperatures overlap, and a ratio of ratios of this PSP is almost o Furthermore, a multipletemperature insensitive in a range of 5-45 C. luminophore PSP can be developed to correct the temperature effect as well as the effect of non-uniform illumination simultaneously.
3.5. Multiple-Luminophore Paints
55
1.5
Ro/R
1.2 0.9
5C 15 C 25 C 35 C 45 C
0.6 0.3 0 0
0.3
0.6
0.9
1.2
1.5
P/Po
Fig. 3.24. Ratio of ratios of a two-luminophore PSP (PtTFPP in FIB with a reference luminophore) as a function of pressure at different temperatures, where R = I λ1 / I λ2 and
R0 = ( I λ1 / I λ2 )0 are the two-color intensity ratios between the probe and reference luminophores at the run and reference conditions, respectively. From Crafton et al. (2002)
Oglesby et al. (1995b) used PtOEP or PtTFPP as a pressure probe luminophore and Fluorol Green Gold 084 (3,9-perylenedicarboxylic acid, bis(2methylpropyl)ester) as a reference luminophore in the GP-197 polymer. Harris and Gouterman (1995, 1998) used PtTFPP as a pressure-sensitive luminophore 2+ and incorporated a solid-state phosphor BaMg2Al16O27:Eu (BaMgAl) as a reference luminophore in an Acrylic copolymer. Since BaMgAl is insoluble, the reference luminophore was not uniformly distributed and therefore the paint suffers from the effect of the uneven layer thickness. TsAGI/OPTROD developed the proprietary two-luminophore PSP formulations, LPS B1 and LPS B12 (Bukov, et al. 1997; Lyonnet, et al. 1997). Three pressure sensitive paints with an internal temperature sensitive luminophore were also tested by Oglesby et al. (1996), where EuTTA, MgOEP and Ru(bpy) were used as temperature-sensitive reference luminophores. Hradil et al. (2002) used Ru(dpp) as a pressure probe molecule and manganese-activated magnesium fluorogermanate (MFG) as a thermographic phosphor. The preliminary results showed that two-luminophore PSPs indeed enabled point-by-point correction for the temperature effect of PSP. Buck (1988, 1989, 1991) used a blue-green Radelin thermographic phosphor for aerothermodynamic testing that intrinsically exhibited two narrow-band emission peaks at 450 nm and 520 nm. It was found that a ratio of the blue to green emission intensity was a function of temperature, but independent of the UV illumination intensity. Another two-color phosphor system used a green-red mixture of rare-earth and Radelin phosphors for a broader range of temperatures. Buck (1988, 1989) gives a detailed description of the multiple-color phosphor thermography system developed at NASA Langley.
56
3. Physical Properties of Paints
3.6. ‘Ideal’ Pressure Sensitive Paint A perfect PSP should be completely temperature independent. According to Eq. (2.23), a temperature insensitive PSP should have such small activity energy E D for the oxygen diffusion process that the Stern-Volmer coefficient B polymer is a weak function of temperature over a certain range of temperature. However, since the excited-state decay rates of a luminophore are intrinsically temperature dependent, it is unlikely to develop an absolutely temperature-insensitive PSP whose the Stern-Volmer coefficients A polymer and B polymer are constants. Instead, researchers seek a so-called ‘ideal’ PSP exhibiting invariant temperature dependency at different pressures over a certain range of temperatures (Puklin et al. 1998; Coyle et al. 1999; Bencic 1999; Ji et al. 2000). Note that the term ‘ideal PSP’ does not accurately describe the invariant property of this special paint. Nevertheless, since this term has been used in the PSP community, we adopt it here and discuss its true meaning below. Consider the Stern-Volmer relation in the following form
I0(T ) = 1 + K SV ( T ) p , I ( p ,T )
(3.1)
where I 0 ( T ) = I ( p = 0 ,T ) is the luminescent intensity at zero pressure (vacuum) and K SV ( T ) is related to the coefficients A polymer ( T ) and B polymer ( T ) by
K SV ( T ) = [ B polymer ( T ) / A polymer ( T )] / p ref .
(3.2)
If the coefficients A polymer ( T ) and B polymer ( T ) have the same temperature dependency, the Stern-Volmer coefficient K SV ( T ) becomes temperature independent. According to Eq. (2.23), this situation may occur under the conditions E D ≈ E nr and η ≈ 1 over a certain range of temperatures. Therefore, for an ‘ideal’ PSP, the Stern-Volmer coefficient K SV ( T ) in Eq. (3.1), rather than the coefficients A polymer ( T ) and B polymer ( T ) , is temperature independent. Consequently, the Stern-Volmer relation in the form for aerodynamic application can be written as I ref p , (3.3) = A polymer , ref + B polymer , ref g( T ) p ref I where the function g ( T ) is defined as
ª ED g ( T ) = «1 + R T ref «¬
§ T − Tref ¨ ¨ T ref ©
·º ¸» ¸» ¹¼
−1
ª E nr = «1 + R T ref «¬
§ T − Tref ¨ ¨ T ref ©
·º ¸» ¸» ¹¼
−1
(3.4)
3.6. ‘Ideal’ Pressure Sensitive Paint
57
and the coefficients A polymer , ref and B polymer , ref are temperature independent given the reference conditions. For an ‘ideal’ PSP, the Stern-Volmer relation Eq. (3.3) enjoys such similarity that it is invariant at different temperatures for the variable g( T )I ref / I . The temperature effect of PSP is concentrated in a single scaling factor g ( T ) ; this similarity simplifies the temperature correction procedure for PSP. Ji et al. (2000) developed a bichromophic molecule Ru-Pyrene for an ‘ideal’ PSP, which, as shown in Fig. 3.25, consisted of a covalently linked assembly of a Ruthenium (II) polypyridyl complex and Pyrene. They also synthesized the MPP acrylate polymer binder for Ru-Pyrene. Figure 3.26(a) shows the Stern-Volmer plots for the Ru-pyrene/MPP PSP at pressures ranging from 0.005 to 1 atm and o temperatures from 25 to 55 C. The Stern-Volmer plots at different temperatures are collapsed onto a single curve. Figure 3.26(b) illustrates the temperature dependency of the Ru-Pyrene/MPP PSP at 0.005, 0.14, 0.55 and 1 atm, indicating that the temperature dependency of this PSP is independent of pressure.
Fig. 3.25. Chemical structure of Ru-pyrene. From Ji et al. (2000)
Fig. 3.26. (a) The Stern-Volmer plots for Ru-pyrene/MPP PSP at eight pressures ranging o from 0.005 to 1 atm and four temperatures from 25 to 55 C; (b) the temperature dependency of Ru-pyrene/MPP PSP at pressures of 0.005, 0.14, 0.55 and 1 atm. From Ji et al. (2000)
58
3. Physical Properties of Paints
3.7. Desirable Properties of Paints As pointed out before, PSP or TSP is prepared by dissolving a luminescent dye and a polymer binder in a solvent solution; the resulting mixture is then applied on a surface by spraying, brushing or dipping. After the solvent evaporates, a thin coating of the paint remains on the surface, in which the luminescent molecules are immobilized in the polymer matrix. The polymer binder is an important ingredient of the paint adhering to the surface of interest. In some cases, the polymer matrix is only a passive anchor; in other cases, the polymer may significantly affect the photophysical behavior of the paint through complicated interaction between the luminescent molecule and the macromolecule of the polymer. Since how the polymer affects the photophysical processes in the paint is not well understood, it is basically a trial and error process to find an optimal combination of a luminophore and a polymer. A good paint (PSP or TSP) for aerodynamic applications should have certain required physical and chemical properties. The following discussion is focused on the required properties of PSP while some requirements are generally applicable to TSP. A general strategy for the development of improved PSP formulations was proposed by Benne et al. (2002).
Pressure Response The Stern-Volmer coefficients of PSP should be chosen to match the pressure range on a tested article and the performance requirements of a photodetector (e.g. CCD camera) used in particular measurements. A large Stern-Volmer coefficient B( T ) generally indicates a good pressure response. However, for aerodynamic experiments at high pressures, a large Stern-Volmer coefficient B( T ) of PSP may cause unwanted severe oxygen quenching in the ambient reference conditions, considerably reducing the luminescent emission from the paint and therefore the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of a photodetector.
Luminescent Output The luminescent emission of a luminophore is characterized by the quantum yield (or efficiency); it is generally desirable to have as high a luminescent output as possible to maximize the SNR of a photodetector. The luminescent intensity is proportional to the concentration of the probe molecules over a certain range. However, it cannot be increased indefinitely by increasing the dye concentration; if the concentration is too high, self-quenching of luminescence occurs. Similarly, the luminescent intensity is no longer linearly proportional to the excitation light intensity at a very high excitation level, and eventually it saturates when the excitation light intensity increases further. Paint Stability Ideally, the luminescent intensity of PSP should not change with time under excitation. Usually, the luminescent intensity decreases with time due to photodegradation of a luminophore (Egami and Asai 2002). A decrease in the luminescent intensity could also be due to the presence of certain chemicals other than oxygen that can quench the luminescence. The polymer binder undergoes
3.7. Desirable Properties of Paints
59
aging, which can change its characteristics with respect to the oxygen solubility and diffusivity. As a result, the Stern-Volmer coefficients of PSP may be altered.
Response Time The response time of PSP is mainly determined by oxygen diffusion through a paint layer when the luminescent lifetime is much shorter than the diffusion timescale. The high porosity of the paint will increase the time response. The need for fast time response depends on a particular application; a short response time of PSP is required for unsteady aerodynamic measurements. For steady-state measurements, however, the use of a fast-responding PSP does not necessarily offer an advantage. For a highly oxygen-permeable PSP with a short response time, the Stern-Volmer coefficient B( T ) is usually large, and thus weak luminescence of PSP in the ambient conditions may lead to a low SNR. Temperature Sensitivity A good PSP should have a weak temperature effect. The temperature sensitivity arises from two sources: the intrinsic temperature dependency of a luminophore and the temperature dependency of the solubility and diffusivity of oxygen in a polymer matrix. The latter is a major contributor to the temperature sensitivity of PSP. Physical Characteristics The physical properties of a polymer binder, such as adhesion, hardness, coating smoothness and thickness, should be considered prior to a test. Adhesion should be strong enough to sustain skin friction on a surface particularly in high-speed flows, which is related to surface tension, solvent softening and chemical bonding. Hardness primarily depends on the type of polymers, the molecular weight and the degree of cross-linking. For example, silicone rubbers (or RTVs) are generally soft, whereas Acrylates and methacrylates are generally hard. Smoothness depends primarily on paint itself and application techniques; for most paints uniform leveling of the paint is essential to a smooth finish. The coating thickness is very dependent on application techniques for both the basecoat and PSP topcoat. It is generally desirable to minimize the coating roughness and thickness to avoid any effect on the aerodynamic characteristics of a model. Typically, the maximum rms roughness of a coating should be less than 0.25 µm, and the coating thickness ranges from 20 to 40 µm. Chemical Characteristics Toxicity of paint is a major concern of safety; toxic solvents such as chlorinated solvents should be avoided. Painter must be protected against contact with paint spray through the use of fresh air breathing equipment and adequate ventilation. The paint must be easily sprayed, leveled, and cured to give the specified physical characteristics of coating under different environmental conditions in wind tunnels. The solvent evaporation rate must be controlled under different conditions of temperature and humidity. Since the wind tunnel time is expensive, application of the paint should be as fast as possible. The curing temperature must o be reasonable (less than 100 C); if the curing temperature is too high, it is difficult to achieve uniform curing over different metal materials. In addition, paint removal and reapplication on a model is a practical issue in wind tunnel testing.
60
3. Physical Properties of Paints
Some paints, particularly those designed for good and robust adhesion, are difficult to remove and generally require an aggressive paint stripper like methylene chloride. This introduces problems with toxicity and insuring adequate ventilation.
4. Radiative Energy Transport and Intensity-Based Methods
4.1. Radiometric Notation Luminescent radiation from a luminescent paint (PSP or TSP) on a surface involves two major transport processes of radiative energy. The first process is absorption of an excitation light through a paint layer and the second process is luminescent radiation that is an absorbing-emitting process in the paint layer. These processes can be described by the transport equations of radiative energy (Modest 1993; Pomraning 1973). The luminescent intensity emitted from a paint layer in plane geometry can be analytically determined by solving the transport equations. Thus, the corresponding photodetector output can be derived for an analysis of measurement system performance and uncertainty. Before doing a detailed analysis, it is necessary to discuss the radiometric notation. In the literature of PSP and TSP, the term ‘luminescent intensity’ or ‘fluorescent intensity’, which is usually denoted by the capital English letter ‘I’, has been widely used. In a strict radiometric sense, the luminescent intensity I is the luminescent radiance defined as the radiant energy flux (power) per unit solid angle and per unit projected area of an elemental surface of PSP or TSP (units: -2 -1 -1 -2 -1 watt-m -sr or J-s -m -sr ). Z Incident light
θ
Emission
Y
φ
X
Fig. 4.1. Incident excitation light and luminescent emission in a local polar coordinate system
62
4. Radiative Energy Transport and Intensity-Based Methods
The radiance is a function of both position and direction, which is graphically represented by a cone of a solid angle element in radiometry as shown in Fig. 4.1. The direction of the radiance (incident or emitting radiance) is given by the polar angle ș (measured from the surface normal) and the azimuthal angle φ (measured between an arbitrary axis on the surface and the elemental solid angle on the surface) in a local coordinate system. In radiometry, the radiance is conventionally denoted by the captical English letter ‘L’. The term ‘intensity’ is sometimes confusing because its definition is different in a number of different -1 disciplines. In radiometry, the radiant intensity (units: watt-sr ), denoted by the letter ‘I’, is the radiant flux per unit solid angle, which is different from the radiance (McCluney 1994; Wolfe 1998). However, in the literature of radiative heat transfer, the radiative intensity, denoted by the same letter ‘I’, is essentially equivalent to the radiance in radiometry (Modest 1993). In order to avoid confusion in notation, we specifically define the luminescent intensity ‘I’ as the luminescent radiance from PSP or TSP, which is consistent with the notation and terminology commonly used in the literature of PSP and TSP. In a general case, we still use the traditional radiometric notation ‘L’ to denote the radiance in other radiometric measurements and modeling. The spectral radiance such as I Ȝ and
L Ȝ at a wavelength λ (units: watt-m -sr -nm ) is usually denoted by a subscript -2
-1
-1
λ ; the radiance I (or L) is the integration of the spectral radiance I Ȝ (or L Ȝ ) over a certain range of the radiation wavelengths. Since the radiation from a luminescent molecule is isotropic, a plausible assumption is that the luminescent radiance from PSP or TSP is independent of the azimuthal angle φ . Under this assumption, an analysis of transport of the luminescent radiative energy in PSP or TSP is considerably simplified. The following analysis is given for PSP, but it is also valid for TSP that is treated as a special case of PSP when the oxygen quenching vanishes.
4.2. Excitation Light We consider a PSP layer with a thickness h on a wall, as shown in Fig. 4.2. Suppose that PSP is not a scattering medium and scattering exists only at the wall surface. When an incident excitation light beam with a wavelength λ1 enters the layer, without scattering and other sources for the excitation energy, the incident light is attenuated due to absorption through the PSP medium. In plane geometry where the luminescent intensity (radiance) is independent of the azimuthal angle, the intensity of the incident excitation light with λ1 can be described by
µ
d I Ȝ−1 dz
+ ȕ Ȝ1 I Ȝ−1 = 0 ,
(4.1)
4.2. Excitation Light
63
where I Ȝ−1 is the incident excitation light intensity, µ = cos ș is the cosine of the polar angle ș , and ȕ Ȝ 1 is the extinction coefficient of the PSP medium for the incident excitation light with λ1.
The extinction coefficient ȕ Ȝ1 = İ Ȝ1 c is a
product of the molar absorptivity İ Ȝ1 and luminescent molecule concentration c . Again, note that the spectral intensity is defined as radiative energy transferred per -2 unit time, solid angle, spectral variable and area normal to the ray (units: watt-m -1 -1 sr -nm ). The superscript ‘-‘ in I Ȝ−1 indicates the negative direction in which the light enters the layer. The incident angle ș ranges from ʌ / 2 to 3 ʌ /2 ( −1 ≤ µ ≤ 0 ) (see Fig. 4.2). Incident excitation light q 0
Luminescence
Z
θ
Air PSP
h
+
Ιλ2
+
Ιλ 2 θ
θ
−
Ιλ 2
−
Ιλ1
+
Ιλ1
θ
O
Wall Reflected/scattered luminescent light
Reflected/scattered excitation light
Fig. 4.2. Radiative energy transports in a luminescent paint layer
For the collimated excitation light, the boundary value for Eq. (4.1) is the component penetrating into the PSP layer,
I Ȝ−1 (z = h) = ( 1 − ȡ Ȝap1 ) q0 E Ȝ 1 (Ȝ 1 ) į(µ − µ ex ) ,
(4.2)
where q0 and E Ȝ 1 (Ȝ 1 ) are the radiative flux and spectrum of the incident excitation light, respectively, ȡ Ȝap1 is the reflectivity of the air-PSP interface, µex is the cosine of the incident angle of the excitation light, and į(µ ) is the Dirac-delta function. The solution to Eq. (4.1) is
I Ȝ−1 = ( 1 − ȡ Ȝap1 ) q0 E Ȝ 1 (Ȝ 1 ) į(µ − µex ) exp [( ȕ Ȝ 1 / µ)(h − z)] . ( −1 ≤ µ ≤ 0 )
(4.3)
This relation describes a decay of the incident excitation light intensity through the layer. The incident excitation light flux at the wall integrated over the ranges of ș from either ʌ to ʌ / 2 or ʌ to 3 ʌ /2 is
64
4. Radiative Energy Transport and Intensity-Based Methods
q Ȝ−1 ( z = 0 ) = −
³
0 −1
I Ȝ−1 (z = 0) µ dµ ≅ C d ( 1 − ȡ Ȝap1 ) q 0 E Ȝ 1 (Ȝ 1 ),
(4.4)
where C d is the coefficient representing the directional effect of the excitation light, that is, C d = − µ ex exp( ȕ Ȝ 1 h / µ ex ) . ( −1 ≤ µ ex ≤ 0 ) (4.5) When the incident excitation light impinges on the wall, the light reflects and re-enters into the layer. Without a scattering source inside PSP, the intensity of the reflected and scattered light from the wall is described by
µ
d I Ȝ+1 dz
+ ȕ Ȝ1 I Ȝ+1 = 0 ,
(4.6)
where I Ȝ+1 is the excitation light intensity in the positive direction emanating from the wall. As shown in Fig. 4.2, the range of µ is 0 ≤ µ ≤ 1 ( 0 ≤ ș ≤ ʌ /2 and −ʌ / 2 ≤ ș ≤ 0 ) for the outgoing reflected and scattered excitation light. The superscript ‘+’ indicates the outgoing direction from the wall. For the wall that reflects diffusely, the boundary condition for Eq. (4.6) is
I Ȝ+1 (z = 0) = ȡ Ȝwp1 q Ȝ−1 ( z = 0 ) = C d ȡ Ȝwp1 ( 1 − ȡ Ȝap1 ) q0 E Ȝ 1 (Ȝ 1 ),
(4.7)
where ȡ Ȝwp1 is the reflectivity of the wall-PSP interface for the excitation light. The solution to Eq. (4.6) is (0 ≤ µ ≤ 1 )
I Ȝ+1 = C d ȡ Ȝwp1 ( 1 − ȡ Ȝap1 ) q0 E Ȝ 1 (Ȝ 1 ) exp ( − ȕ Ȝ 1 z / µ).
(4.8)
At a point inside the PSP layer, the net excitation light flux is contributed by the incident and scattering light rays from all the possible directions. The net flux is calculated by adding the incident flux (integrated over ș = ʌ to ʌ /2 and
ș = ʌ to 3ʌ /2 ) and scattering flux (integrated over ș = 0 to − ʌ /2 ). Hence, the net excitation light flux is ( q Ȝ 1 )net = − 2
³
0 −1
I Ȝ−1 µ dµ − 2
³
0 1
ș = 0 to ʌ /2
I Ȝ+1 µ dµ
and
(4.9)
≅ C d ( 1 − ȡ ) q0 E Ȝ 1 (Ȝ 1 )[ exp ( − ȕ Ȝ 1 z /µex ) + ȡ exp ( −3 ȕ Ȝ 1 z / 2)] . ap Ȝ1
wp Ȝ1
Note that the derivation of Eq. (4.9) uses an approximation of the exponential integral of third order, E 3 (x) ≅ (1/2) exp ( −3 x / 2) .
4.3. Luminescent Emission and Photodetector Response
65
4.3. Luminescent Emission and Photodetector Response After the luminescent molecules in PSP absorb the energy from the excitation light with a wavelength λ1, they emit luminescence with a longer wavelength λ2 due to the Stokes shift. Luminescent radiative transfer in PSP is an absorbingemitting process; the luminescent light rays from the luminescent molecules radiate in both the inward and outward directions. For the luminescent emission toward the wall, the luminescent intensity I Ȝ−2 can be described by
µ
d I Ȝ−2 dz
+ ȕ Ȝ2 I Ȝ−2 = S Ȝ2 (z) ,
( −1 ≤ µ ≤ 0 )
(4.10)
where S Ȝ2 (z) is the luminescent source term and the extinction coefficient
ȕ Ȝ2 = İ Ȝ2 c is a product of the molar absorptivity İ Ȝ2 and luminescent molecule concentration c .
S Ȝ2 (z) is assumed to be
The luminescent source term
proportional to the extinction coefficient for the excitation light, the quantum yield, and the net excitation light flux filtered over a spectral range of absorption. Therefore, a model for the luminescent source term is expressed as
S Ȝ 2 (z) = Φ ( p, T ) E Ȝ 2 ( Ȝ 2 )
³
∞ 0
(q Ȝ 1 )net ȕ Ȝ 1 Ft 1 ( Ȝ 1 ) dȜ 1 ,
(4.11)
where Φ ( p, T ) is the luminescent quantum yield that depends on air pressure (p) and temperature (T), E Ȝ 2 (Ȝ 2 ) is the luminescent emission spectrum, and
Ft 1 ( Ȝ1 ) is a filter function describing the optical filter used to insure the excitation light within the absorption spectrum of the luminescent molecules. With the boundary condition I Ȝ−2 (z = h) = 0 , the solution to Eq. (4.10) is § ȕȜ2 z · 1 ª ¸ « I Ȝ−2 = exp ¨ − ¨ µ ¸µ« © ¹ ¬
³
z 0
§ ȕȜ2 z · ¸ dz − S Ȝ2 ( z ) exp ¨ ¨ µ ¸ © ¹
³
h 0
§ ȕȜ2 z · ¸ dz S Ȝ2 ( z ) exp ¨ ¨ µ ¸ © ¹
( −1 ≤ µ ≤ 0 )
º ». » ¼
(4.12)
The incoming luminescent flux toward the wall at the surface (integrated over ș = ʌ to ʌ /2 and ș = ʌ to 3ʌ /2 ) is
q Ȝ−2 ( z = 0 ) = − 2 where
³
0 −1
I Ȝ−2 (z = 0) µ dµ ,
(4.13)
66
4. Radiative Energy Transport and Intensity-Based Methods
I Ȝ−2 ( z = 0 ) = −
1 µ
³
h 0
S Ȝ2 ( z ) exp (
ȕȜ2 z µ
)dz .
We consider the luminescent emission in the outward direction and assume that the scattering occurs only at the wall. The outgoing luminescent intensity I Ȝ+2 can be described by
µ
d I Ȝ+2 dz
+ ȕ Ȝ2 I Ȝ+2 = S Ȝ2 (z) .
(0 ≤ µ ≤ 1)
(4.14)
Similar to the boundary condition for the scattering excitation light, a fraction of the incoming luminescent flux q Ȝ− 2 ( z = 0 ) is reflected diffusely from the wall. Thus, the boundary condition for Eq. (4.14) is
I Ȝ+2 (z = 0) = ȡ Ȝwp2 q Ȝ−2 ( z = 0 ) = − 2 ȡ Ȝwp2
³
0 −1
I Ȝ−2 (z = 0) µ dµ ,
(4.15)
where ȡ Ȝwp2 is the reflectivity of the wall-PSP interface for the luminescent light. The solution to Eq. (4.14) with the boundary condition Eq. (4.15) is
§ ȕȜ2 z · ª 1 ¸« I Ȝ+2 = exp ¨ − ¨ µ ¸«µ ¹¬ ©
³
º § ȕȜ2 z · ¸ dz + I + ( z = 0 )» . S Ȝ2 ( z ) exp¨ Ȝ2 ¨ µ ¸ 0 » ¹ © ¼ z
( −1 ≤ µ ≤ 0 )
(4.16)
At this stage, the outgoing luminescent intensity I Ȝ+2 can be readily calculated by substituting the source term Eq. (4.11) into Eq. (4.16). In general, I Ȝ+2 has a nonlinear distribution across the PSP layer, which is composed of the exponentials of ȕ Ȝ 1 z and ȕ Ȝ2 z . For simplicity of algebra, we consider an asymptotic but important case ʊ an optically thin PSP layer. When the PSP layer is optically thin ( ȕ Ȝ 1 h , ȕ Ȝ 2 h , ȕ Ȝ 1 z and ȕ Ȝ2 z <<1), the asymptotic expression for I Ȝ+2 is simply
I Ȝ+2 ( z ) = Φ ( p, T ) q0 E Ȝ 2 (Ȝ 2 )K 1 (ȕ Ȝ 1 / µ)( z + 2 ȡ Ȝwp2 h µ) , ( −1 ≤ µ ≤ 0 ) where
K 1 = ȕ Ȝ−11
³
∞ 0
ȕ Ȝ 1 E Ȝ 1 (Ȝ 1 ) C d ( 1 − ȡ Ȝap1 )( 1 + ȡ Ȝwp1 )Ft 1 ( Ȝ1 ) dȜ1 .
(4.17)
4.3. Luminescent Emission and Photodetector Response
67
Eq. (4.17) indicates that for an optically thin PSP layer the outgoing luminescent intensity is proportional to the extinction coefficient (a product of the molar absorptivity and luminescent molecule concentration), paint layer thickness, quantum yield of the luminescent molecules, and incident excitation light flux. The term K 1 represents the combined effect of the optical filter, excitation light scattering and direction of the incident excitation light. The outgoing luminescent intensity averaged over the layer is
< I Ȝ+2 > = h −1
³
h 0
I Ȝ+2 (z) dz = h Φ ( p, T ) q0 E Ȝ 2 (Ȝ 2 )K 1 (ȕ Ȝ 1 / µ) M(µ ),
(4.18)
where M ( µ ) = 0.5 + 2 ȡ Ȝwp2 µ. The outgoing luminescent energy flow rate Q Ȝ+2 (radiant flux) on an area element A s of the PSP paint surface collected by a detector is
Q Ȝ+2 = A s
³
ȍ
< I Ȝ+2 > cos ș dȍ = ȕ Ȝ 1 h Φ ( p, T ) q0 E Ȝ 2 (Ȝ 2 ) K 1 < M > A s ȍ
, (4.19)
where Q Ȝ+2 is equivalent to the spectral radiant flux in radiometry (watt-nm ), ȍ -1
is a collecting solid angle of the detector, and the extinction coefficient ȕ Ȝ1 = İ Ȝ1 c is a product of the molar absorptivity İ Ȝ1 and luminescent molecule concentration c . The coefficient < M > represents the effect of reflection and scattering of the luminescent light at the wall, which is defined as
< M > = ȍ −1
³
ȍ
M(µ ) dȍ = 0.5 + ȡ Ȝwp2 ( µ1 + µ 2 ) ,
where µ1 = cos ș1 and µ 2 = cos ș 2 are the cosines of two polar angles in the solid angle ȍ . Imaging system aperture area, A0 = ʌ D2 /4
Source area
Image of source area AI
As
R1
R2
Fig. 4.3. Schematic of an imaging system
68
4. Radiative Energy Transport and Intensity-Based Methods
The response of a photodetector to the luminescent emission can be derived based on a model of an optical system (Holst 1998). Consider an optical system located at a distance R1 from a luminescent source area, as shown in Fig. 4.3. The collecting solid angle with which the lens is seen from the source can be approximated by ȍ ≈ A 0 / R12 , where A0 = ʌ D 2 /4 is the imaging system entrance aperture area, and D is the effective diameter of the aperture. Using Eq. (4.19) and additional relations A s / R12 = A I / R22 and 1 / R1 + 1 / R2 = 1 / fl , we obtain the radiative energy flux onto the detector (QȜ 2 )det =
ʌ AI Top Tatm ȕ Ȝ h Φ ( p, T ) q0 E Ȝ 2 (Ȝ 2 ) K 1 < M > , 4 F 2 (1 + M op )2 1
(4.20)
where F = fl / D is the f-number, M op = R2 / R1 is the optical magnification, fl is the system’s effective focal length, AI is the image area, and Top and Tatm are the system’s optical transmittance and atmospheric transmittance, respectively. The output of the detector is
V =G
³
∞
0
Rq (Ȝ 2 ) (Q Ȝ 2 )det Ft 2 ( Ȝ2 )dȜ2 ,
(4.21)
where Rq (Ȝ 2 ) is the detector’s quantum efficiency, G is the system’s gain, and
Ft 2 ( Ȝ2 ) is a filter function describing the optical filter for the luminescent emission. The dimension of V/G is [V/G] = J/s. Substitution of Eq. (4.20) into Eq. (4.21) yields V =G
AI ʌ ȕ Ȝ h Φ ( p, T ) q0 K 1 K 2 , 4 F 2 (1 + M op ) 2 1
(4.22)
where
K2 =
³
∞
0
Top Tatm E Ȝ 2 (Ȝ 2 )< M > Rq (Ȝ 2 ) Ft 2 ( Ȝ2 )dȜ2 .
The term K 2 represents the combined effect of the optical filter, luminescent light scattering, and system response to the luminescent light. The above analysis is made based on an assumption that the radiation source is on the optical axis. In general, the off-axis effect is taken into account by multiplying a factor cos 4 θ p in the right-hand side of Eq. (4.22), where θ p is the angle between the optical axis and light ray through the optical center (McCluney 1994). Eq. (4.19) gives the directional dependency of the luminescent radiant flux
Q Ȝ+2 ∝ 1 + 2 ρ λwp2 [cos( θ − ∆θ / 2 ) + cos( θ + ∆θ / 2 )] ,
(4.23)
4.4. Intensity-Based Measurement Systems
69
where ∆θ = θ 2 − θ 1 is the difference between two polar angles in the solid angle ȍ . Clearly, the luminescent radiant flux contains a constant irradiance term and a Lambertian term that is proportional to the cosine of the polar angle θ . Le Sant (2001b) measured the directional dependency of the luminescent emission of the OPTROD’s B1 PSP composed of a derived Pyrene dye and a reference component. Figure 4.4 shows the normalized luminescent intensity as a function of the viewing polar angle for the B1 paint and the B1 paint with talc compared with the theoretical distribution Eq. (4.23) with ρ λwp2 = 0.5 and ∆θ = 4 degrees. The experimental directional dependency remains nearly constant for both paints o until the viewing polar angle is larger than 60 . The theoretical distribution for a non-scattering paint fails to predict the flatness of the experimental directional distributions of the luminescent emission. This is because the simplified theoretical analysis does not consider scattering particles (e.g. talc and solid reference component particles) re-directing and re-distributing both the excitation light and luminescent light inside the paints. A more complete analysis of the radiative energy transport in a luminescent paint with scattering particles requires a numerical solution of an integro-differential equation (Modest 1993).
Normalized Luminescent Intensity
1.2
1.0
0.8
0.6
Theory B1 PSP without talc B1 PSP with talc
0.4
0.2 -100
-80
-60
-40
-20
0
20
40
60
80
100
Polar Angle (degree)
Fig. 4.4. Directional dependency of the luminescent emission from the B1 paint and B1 paint with talc, compared with the theoretical directional distribution for a non-scattering paint. Experimental data for the B1 paints are from Le Sant (2001b)
4.4. Intensity-Based Measurement Systems The photodetector output V responding to the luminescent emission, Eq. (4.22), is re-written as V = Ȇ c Ȇ f ȕ Ȝ1 h q0 Φ ( p, T ) . (4.24)
70
4. Radiative Energy Transport and Intensity-Based Methods
The parameters Ȇ c and Ȇ f
are Ȇ c = ( ʌ / 4) G AI [ F 2 (1 + M op ) 2 ] −1 and
Ȇ f = K 1 K 2 , which are related to the imaging system (camera) performance and filter parameters, respectively. The quantum yield Φ ( p, T ) is described by
Φ ( p,T) = k r /( k r + k nr + k q S φO2 p ) , where kr is the radiative rate constant, knr is the radiationless deactivation rate constant, kq is the quenching rate constant, p is air pressure, S is the solubility of oxygen, and φ O2 is the volume fraction of oxygen in air. In PSP applications, the intensity-ratio method is commonly used to eliminate the effects of spatial variations in illumination, paint thickness, and molecule concentration. Without any model deformation, air pressure p is related to a ratio between the wind-off and wind-on outputs by the Stern-Volmer relation
Vref V
= A( T ) + B( T )
p . p ref
(4.25)
The essential elements of a measurement system for PSP and TSP include illumination sources, optical filters, photodetectors and data acquisition/processing units. In terms of the detectors and illumination sources used, measurement systems can be generally categorized into CCD camera system and laser scanning system with a single-sensor detector. Since each system has advantages over the other, researchers can choose one most suitable to meet the requirements for their specific experiments.
4.4.1. CCD Camera System A CCD camera system is most commonly used for PSP and TSP measurements in wind tunnel tests. Figure 1.4 shows a schematic of a CCD camera system. The luminescent paint (PSP or TSP) is applied to a model surface, which is excited to luminesce by an illumination source such as UV lamp, LED array or laser. The luminescent emission is filtered optically to eliminate the illuminating light before projecting onto a CCD sensor. Images (wind-on and wind-off images) are digitized and transferred to a computer for data processing. In order to correct the dark current in a CCD camera, a dark current image is acquired when no light is incident on the camera. A ratio between the wind-on and wind-off images is taken after the dark current image is subtracted from both images, resulting in a luminescent intensity ratio image. Then, using the calibration relation for the paint, the distribution of the surface pressure or temperature is computed from the intensity ratio image. Scientific grade cooled CCD digital cameras are ideal imaging sensors for PSP and TSP, which can provide a high intensity resolution (12 to 16 bits) and high spatial resolution (typically 512×512, 1024×1024, up to 2048×2048 pixels). Because a scientific grade CCD camera exhibits a good linear response and a high signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) up to 60 dB, it is particularly suitable to quantitative measurement of the luminescent emission (LaBelle and Garvey 1995). The major
4.4. Intensity-Based Measurement Systems
71
disadvantages of a scientific grade CCD camera are its high cost and a very slow frame rate. Less expensive consumer grade CCD video cameras were used in early PSP and TSP measurements (Kavandi et al. 1990; Engler et al. 1991; McLachlan et al. 1992); the intensity resolution of a CCD video camera is typically 8 bits with a conventional frame grabber. When there is a large pressure variation over a model surface, a consumer grade video CCD camera can be used as an alternative to give acceptable quantitative results after the camera is carefully calibrated to correct the non-linearity of the radiometric response function of the camera (see Chapter 5). The low SNR of a video camera can be improved by averaging a sequence of images to reduce the random noise. In addition, film-based camera systems were occasionally used in special PSP measurements like flight tests (Abbitt et al. 1996). The performance of a CCD array is characterized by the responsivity, charge well capacity and noise. From these quantities, the minimum signal, maximum signal, signal-to-noise ratio and dynamic range can be estimated (Holst 1998; Janesick 1995). These performance parameters are critical for quantitative radiometric measurements of the luminescent emission, which can be estimated based on the camera model and noise models (Holst 1998). Here, the most relevant concepts are briefly discussed. The responsivity, the efficiency of generating electrons by a photon, is determined by the spectral quantum efficiency Rq ( λ ) of a detector. The full-well capacity specifies the number of photoelectrons that a pixel can hold before charge begins to spill out, thus reducing the response linearity. The maximum signal is proportional to the fullwell capacity. Normally, the well size is approximately proportional to the pixel size. Therefore, in a fixed CCD area, increasing the effective pixel size to enhance the SNR may reduce the spatial resolution. The dynamic range, defined as the maximum signal (or the full-well capacity) divided by the rms readout noise (or noise floor), loosely describes the camera’s ability to measure both low and high light levels. The minimum signal is limited by the camera noises, including the photon shot noise, dark current, reset noise, amplifier noise, quantization noise, and fixed pattern noise. The photon shot noise is associated with the discrete nature of photoelectrons obeying the Poisson statistics in which the variance is equal to the mean. The dark current is due to thermally generated electrons, which can be reduced to a very low level by cooling a CCD device. The reset noise is associated with resetting the sense node capacitor that is temperature-dependent. The amplifier noise contains two components: 1/f noise and white noise; the array manufacturer usually provides this value and calls it the readout noise, noise equivalent electrons, or noise floor. By careful optimization of the camera electronics, the readout noise or noise floor can be reduced to as low as 4-6 electrons. The quantization noise results from the analog-to-digital conversion. The fixed pattern noise (the pixel-to-pixel variation) is due to differences in pixel responsivity, which is called the scene noise, pixel noise, or pixel nonuniformity as well.
72
4. Radiative Energy Transport and Intensity-Based Methods
Noise Electrons (rms)
10000
Total Noise
1000
100 Noise Floor 10
Fixed Pattern Noise Photon Shot Noise
1 10
100
1000
10000
100000
Photoelectrons
Fig. 4.5. Noise curves of CCD for the noise floor = 50e and non-uniformity U = 0.25%
Although various noise sources exist, for many applications, it is sufficient to consider the photon shot noise, noise floor, and fixed pattern noise due to pixel nonuniformity. Thus, according to the Poisson statistics, the total system noise < nsys > is given by 2 < nsys > = < nshot > + < n 2floor > + < n 2pattern > = n pe + < n 2floor > + ( Un pe )2
, (4.26)
2 > , < n 2floor > and < n 2pattern > are the variances of the photon shot where < nshot
noise, noise floor and pattern noise, respectively, n pe is the number of collected photoelectrons, and U is the pixel nonuniformity. Accordingly, the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) is
SNR = n pe / n pe + < n 2floor > + ( Un pe ) 2
.
(4.27)
Figure 4.5 shows the total noise, photon shot noise, noise floor (readout noise), and fixed pattern noise of a CCD as a function of the number of photoelectrons for < n 2floor > 1 / 2 = 50e and U = 0.25%. For a very low photon flux, the noise floor dominates. As the incident light flux increases, the photon shot noise dominates. At a very high level of the incident light flux, the noise may be dominated by the fixed pattern noise. When the photon shot noise dominates, the SNR asymptotically approaches to
SNR = n pe , and the dynamic range is
( n pe )max / < n floor > , where ( n pe )max is the full-well capacity. The dark current only affects those applications where the SNR is low. In most applications of PSP
4.4. Intensity-Based Measurement Systems
73
and TSP, the pressure and temperature resolutions are limited by the photon shot noise. Table 4.1, which is adapted from Crites (1993), lists the performance parameters of some CCD sensors. Table 4.1. Characteristics of CCD Sensors CCD
TH7883PM
TH7895B
TH896A
TK512CB
TK1024F
Pixel array
384×586
512×512
1024×1024
512×512
1024×1024
1024×1024
Full well (e)
180000
290000
350000
700000
450000
256000
o
TK1024B
Temperature ( C)
-45
-45
-40
-40
-40
-40
Dark current (e)
8
8
25
4
3
6
Readout Noise (e)
12
6
6
10
9
9
Quantum efficiency
40%
40%
40%
80%
35%
80%
Peak wavelength (nm)
700
670
670
650
670
650
The selection of an appropriate illumination source depends on the absorption spectrum of a luminescent paint and optical access of a specific facility. An illumination source must provide a sufficiently large number of photons in the wavelength band of absorption without saturating the luminescence and causing serious photodegradation. It is desirable for a source to generate a reasonably uniform illumination field over a surface such that the measurement uncertainty associated with model deformation can be reduced. A continuous illumination source should be stable and a flash source should be repeatable. A variety of illumination sources are commercially available. Pulsed and continuous-wave lasers with fiber-optic delivery systems were used in wind tunnel tests (Morris et al. 1993a, 1993b; Crites 1993; Bukov et al. 1992; Volan and Alati. 1991; Engler et al. 1991, 1992; Lyonnet et al. 1997). Lasers have obvious advantages in terms of providing narrow band intense illumination. Very stable blue LED arrays were developed for illuminating paints (Dale et al. 1999). LED arrays are attractive as an illumination source since they are light in weight and they produce little heat; they can be suitably distributed to form a fairly uniform illumination field. In addition, they can be easily controlled to generate either continuous or modulated illumination. Other light sources reported in the literature of PSP and TSP include xenon arc lamps with blue filters (McLachlan et al. 1993a), incandescent tungsten/halogen lamps with blue filters (Morris et al. 1993a; Dowgwillo et al. 1994) and fluorescent UV lamps (Liu et al. 1995a, 1995b). The spectral characteristics of illumination sources can be found in The Photonics Design and Applications Handbook (1999). Crites (1993) discussed some available light sources from a viewpoint of PSP application. Optical filters are used to separate the luminescent emission from the excitation light, or separate the luminescent emissions from different luminophores. There are two kinds of filters: interference filters and color glass filters. Interference filters select a band of light through a process of constructive and destructive interference. They consist of a substrate onto which chemical layers are vacuum deposited in such a fashion that the transmission of certain wavelengths is
74
4. Radiative Energy Transport and Intensity-Based Methods
enhanced, while other wavelengths are either reflected or absorbed. Band-pass interference filters only transmit light in a spectral band; the peak wavelength and spectral width can be tightly controlled. Edge interference filters only transmit light above (long pass) or below (short pass) a certain wavelength. Color glass filters are used for applications that do not need precise control over wavelengths and transmission intensities. The ratio of transmission to blocking is a key filter characteristic. All filters are sensitive to the angle of incidence of the incoming light. For interference filters, the peak transmission wavelength decreases as the angle of incidence deviates from the normal, while the bandwidth and transmission characteristics generally remain unchanged. For color glass filters, an increase of the incident angle increases the transmission path, reducing the transmission efficiency. 4.4.2. Laser Scanning System A generic laser scanning system for PSP and TSP is shown in Fig. 1.5. A lowpower laser beam is focused to a small point and scanned over a model surface using a computer-controlled mirror to excite the paint on a model. The luminescent emission is detected using a low-noise photodetector (e.g. PMT); the photodetector signal is digitized with a high-resolution A/D converter in a PC and processed to calculate pressure or temperature based on the calibration relation for the paint. When the laser beam is modulated, a lock-in amplifier can be used to reduce the noise. Furthermore, the phase angle between the modulated excitation light and responding luminescence can be obtained using a lock-in amplifier for phase-based PSP and TSP measurements. The laser can be scanned continuously or in steps; it is synchronized to data acquisition such that the position of the laser spot on the model is known. In order to compensate for a laser power drift, the laser power variation is monitored using a photodiode. The laser scanning systems for PSP and TSP measurements were discussed by Hamner et al. (1994), Burns (1995), Torgerson et al (1996), and Torgerson (1997). Compared to a CCD camera system, a laser scanning system offers certain advantages. Since a low-noise PMT is used to measure the luminescent emission, before an analog output from the PMT is digitized, standard SNR enhancement techniques are available to improve the measurement accuracy. Amplification and band-limited filtering can be used to improve the SNR. The signal is then digitized with a high-resolution A/D converter (12 to 24 bits). Additional noise reduction can be accomplished using a lock-in amplifier when the laser beam is modulated. The laser scanning system is able to provide uniform illumination over a surface by scanning a single laser spot. The laser power is easily monitored and correction for the laser power drift can be made for each measurement point. The laser scanning system can be used for PSP and TSP measurements in a facility where optical access is so limited that a CCD camera system is difficult to use.
4.5. Basic Data Processing
75
4.5. Basic Data Processing The most basic processing procedure in the intensity-based method for PSP and TSP is taking a ratio between the wind-on image and the wind-off reference image to correct the effects of non-homogenous illumination, uneven paint thickness and non-uniform luminophore concentration. However, this ratioing procedure is complicated by model deformation induced by aerodynamic loads, which results in misalignment between the wind-on and wind-off images. Therefore, additional correction procedures are required to eliminate (or reduce) the error sources associated with model deformation, the temperature effect of PSP, selfillumination, and camera noises (dark current and fixed pattern noise). Figure 4.6 shows a generic data processing flowchart for intensity-based measurements of PSP and TSP with a CCD camera. A laser scanning system has similar data processing procedures for intensity-based measurements. The windon and wind-off images are acquired using a CCD camera. Usually, a sequence of acquired images is averaged to reduce the random noise like the photon shot noise. The dark current image and ambient lighting image are subtracted from data images to eliminate the dark current noise of the CCD camera and the contribution from the ambient light. The dark current image is usually acquired when the camera shutter is closed. In a wind tunnel environment, there is always weak ambient light that may cause a bias error in data images. The ambient lighting image is acquired when the shutter is open while all controllable light sources are turned off. The integration time for the dark current image and ambient lighting image should be the same as that for data images. The data images are then divided by the flat-field image to correct the fixed pattern noise. At a very high signal level, this correction is necessary since the fixed pattern noise may surpass the photon shot noise. Ideally, the flat-field image is acquired from a uniformly illuminated scene. A simple but less accurate approach is use of several diffuse scattering glasses mounted in the front of the lens of the camera to generate an approximately uniform illumination field. When a uniform illumination field cannot be achieved, a more complex noise-model-based approach can be used to obtain the fixed pattern noise field for a CCD camera (Healey and Kondepudy 1994). Normally, a scientific grade CCD camera has a good linear response of the camera output to the incident irradiance of light. However, conventional CCD video cameras often exhibit a non-linear response to the incident light intensity; in this case, a video camera should be radiometrically calibrated to correct the non-linearity. A simple but useful radiometric camera calibration technique is described in Chapter 5.
76
4. Radiative Energy Transport and Intensity-Based Methods
Wind-On Image
Wind-Off Image
Correction for Dark Current, Ambient Light & Fixed Pattern Noise
Correction for Non-Linearity of Response of Detector Registered & Corrected Wind-On Image
Corrected Wind-Off Image
Image Registration
Ratio Image
Self-Illumination Correction
PSP/TSP Image
PSP/TSP Calibration
PSP/TSP Data on 3D Grid
Image Resection
Forces & Moments/Heat Transfer
Fig. 4.6. Generic data processing flowchart for intensity-based PSP and TSP measurements
In this stage, even though the noise-corrected wind-on and wind-off images are obtained, we cannot yet calculate a ratio of the wind-off image over the wind-on image, Vref / V , for conversion to a pressure or temperature image. This is because the wind-on image may not align with the wind-off image due to model deformation produced by aerodynamic loads. A ratio between those non-aligned images can lead to a considerable error in calculation of pressure or temperature using a calibration relation. Also, some distinct flow features such as shock, boundary layer transition and flow separation could be smeared. In order to correct the non-alignment problem, the image registration technique should be used to match the wind-on image to the wind-off image (Bell and McLachlan 1993, 1996; Donovan et al. 1993). The image registration technique is based on a mathematical transformation ( x' , y' ) ( x , y ) , which empirically maps the deformed wind-on image coordinate ( x' , y' ) onto the reference wind-off image coordinate ( x , y ) . For a small deformation, an image registration transformation is well described by polynomials m
m
( x, y ) = (
¦
i , j =0
aij x' i y' j ,
¦ b x' ij
i
y' j ) .
(4.28)
i , j =0
Geometrically, the constant terms, linear terms, non-linear terms in Eq. (4.28) represent translation, rotation and scaling, and higher-order deformation of a
4.5. Basic Data Processing
77
model in the image plane, respectively. In measurements of PSP and TSP, black fiducial targets are placed in the locations on a model where deformation is appreciable. The displacement of these marks in the image plane represents perspective projection of real model deformation in the 3D object space. From the corresponding centroids of the targets in the wind-on and wind-off images, the polynomial coefficients aij and bij in Eq. (4.28) can be determined using least-squares method. More targets will increase the statistical redundancy and improve the precision of least-squares estimation. For most wind tunnel tests, a second-order polynomial transformation (m = 2) is found to be sufficient. As a pure geometric correction method, however, the image registration technique fails to take into account a variation in illumination level on a model due to model movement in a non-homogenous illumination field. An estimate of this error requires the knowledge of the illumination field and the movement of the model relative to the light sources. Bell and McLachlan (1993, 1996) gave an analysis on this error in a simplified circumstance and found that this error was small if the illumination light field was nearly homogenous and model movement was small. Experiments showed that the image registration technique considerably improved the quality of PSP and TSP images (McLachlan and Bell 1995). Weaver et al. (1999) utilized spatial anomalies (dots formed from aerosol mists in spraying) in a basecoat and calculated a pixel shift vector field of a model using a spatial correlation technique similar to that used in particle image velocimetry (PIV). Based on the shift vector field, the wind-on image was registered. Le Sant et al. (1997) described an automatic scheme for target recognition and image alignment. A detailed discussion on the image registration technique is given in Chapter 5. After a ratio of the wind-off image over the registered wind-on image is taken, a pressure or temperature image can be obtained using the calibration relation (the Stern-Volmer relation for PSP or the Arrhenius relation for TSP). Compared to relatively straightforward conversion of an intensity ratio image to a temperature image, conversion to a pressure image is more difficult since the intensity ratio image of PSP is a function of not only pressure, but also temperature. The temperature effect of PSP often has a dominant contribution to the total uncertainty of PSP measurements if it is not corrected. When the Stern-Volmer coefficients A( T ) and B( T ) are determined in a priori laboratory PSP calibration and the temperature field on the surface are known, the pressure field can be, in principle, calculated from a ratio image. The need of temperature correction provoked the development of multiple-luminophore PSP and tandem use of PSP with TSP. The surface temperature distribution can be measured using TSP and infrared (IR) cameras. Also, the temperature field can be given by theoretical and numerical solutions to the motion and energy equations of flows. Unfortunately, experiments have shown that the use of a priori laboratory PSP calibration with a correction for the temperature effect still leads to a systematic error in the derived pressure distribution due to certain uncontrollable factors in wind tunnel environment. To correct this systematic error, pressure tap data at a number of locations are used to correlate the intensity ratio values to the pressure tap data; this procedure is referred to as in-situ calibration of PSP. In the worst
78
4. Radiative Energy Transport and Intensity-Based Methods
case where A( T ) and B( T ) are not known and the surface temperature field is not given, in-situ calibration is still able to give a pressure field. However, the accuracy of interpretation of PSP data between the pressure taps is not guaranteed especially when the gradients of the pressure and temperature fields between the taps are large. Obviously, the selection of the locations of the pressure taps is critical to assure the accuracy of in-situ calibration. The pressure tap data at the discrete locations for in-situ calibration should reasonably cover the pressure distribution on the surface. The in-situ calibration uncertainty of PSP is discussed in Chapter 7. PSP and TSP data in images have to be mapped onto a surface grid of a model in the 3D object space since the pressure and temperature fields on the surface grid are more useful for engineers and researchers. Further, this mapping is necessary for extraction of aerodynamic loads and heat transfer and for comparison with CFD results. In the literature of PSP and TSP, this mapping procedure is often called image resection. Note that the meaning of resection in the PSP and TSP literature is somewhat broader and looser than the strict one in photogrammetry. From the standpoint of photogrammetry, a key of this procedure is geometric camera calibration by solving the perspective collinearity equations to determine the camera interior and exterior orientation parameters, and lens distortion parameters. Once these parameters in the collinearity equations relating the 3D object space to the image plane are known, PSP and TSP data in images can be mapped onto a given surface grid in the 3D object space. A detailed discussion on analytical photogrammetric techniques is given in Chapter 5. In most PSP and TSP measurements conducted so far, data in images are mapped onto a rigid CFD or CAD surface grid of a model. However, when a model experiences a significant aeroelastic deformation in wind tunnel tests, mapping onto a rigid grid misrepresents the true pressure and temperature fields. Therefore, a deformed surface grid of a model should be generated for PSP and TSP mapping. Liu et al. (1999) discussed generation of a deformed surface grid based on videogrammetric model deformation measurements conducted along with PSP/TSP measurements (see Chapter 5). Finally, the integrated aerodynamic forces and moments can be calculated from the pressure distribution on the surface. For example, the lift is given by FL = ¦ p i ( n • l L ∆S )i , where n is the
unit normal vector of a panel on the surface, ∆S is the area of the panel, and l L is the unit vector of the lift. Similarly, the integrated quantities of heat transfer can be obtained from the surface temperature fields based on appropriate heat transfer models. The self-illumination correction is implemented after the luminescent intensity data are mapped on a surface grid in the 3D object space. The socalled self-illumination is a phenomenon that the luminescent emission from one part of a model surface illuminates another surface, thus increasing the observed luminescent intensity of the receiving surface and producing an additional error in calculation of pressure and temperature. This distorting effect often occurs on the surfaces of neighboring components such as wind/body junctures and concave surfaces. The self-illumination depends on the surface geometry, the luminescent field, and the reflecting properties of a paint layer. Assuming that a
4.5. Basic Data Processing
79
paint surface is Lambertian, Ruyten (1997a, 1997b, 2001a) developed an analytical model and a numerical scheme for correcting the self-illumination effect. The self-illumination correction scheme is discussed in Chapter 5. One of the original purposes of developing two-luminophore PSPs is to simplify the data processing for PSP. The dependency of a two-color intensity ratio I λ1 / I λ2 on pressure p and temperature T is generally expressed as
I λ1 / I λ2 = f ( p , T ) , where I λ1 and I λ2 are the luminescent intensities at the emission wavelengths λ1 and λ 2 , respectively. Ideally, a two-color intensity ratio can eliminate the effect of spatially non-uniform illumination on a surface. However, since two luminophores cannot be perfectly mixed, the simple twocolor intensity ratio I λ1 / I λ2 cannot completely compensate the effect of nonhomogenous dye concentration. In this case, a ratio of ratios ( I λ1 / I λ2 ) /( I λ1 / I λ2 )0 should be used to correct the effects of non-homogenous dye concentration and paint thickness variation, where the subscript 0 denotes the wind-off condition (McLean 1998). Since the wind-off images are required, the ratio-of-ratios method still needs image registration. The ratio-of-ratios approach was also applied to non-pressure-sensitive reference targets to compensate the effect of non-homogenous illumination on a moving model (Subramanian et al. 2002).
5. Image and Data Analysis Techniques
This Chapter describes image and data analysis techniques used in various processing steps for PSP and TSP. For quantitative PSP and TSP measurements, cameras should be geometrically calibrated to establish the accurate relationship between the image plane and the 3D object space and map data in images onto a surface grid in the object space. Analytical camera calibration techniques, especially the Direct Linear Transformation (DLT) and the optimization calibration method, are discussed. Since PSP and TSP are based on radiometric measurements, an ideal camera should have a linear response to the luminescent radiance. For a camera having a non-linear response, radiometric camera calibration is required to determine the radiometric response function of the camera for correcting the image intensity before taking a ratio between the wind-on and wind-off images. A simple but effective technique is described here for radiometric camera calibration. The self-illumination of PSP and TSP may cause a significant error near a conjuncture of surfaces when a strong exchange of the radiative energy occurs between neighboring surfaces. The numerical methods for correcting the selfillumination are generally described and the errors associated with the selfillumination are estimated for a typical case. The self-illumination correction is usually made on a surface grid in the object space since it highly depends on the surface geometry. A standard procedure in the intensity-based method for PSP and TSP is to take a ratio between the wind-on and wind-off images to eliminate the effects of non-homogenous illumination intensity, dye concentration, and paint thickness. However, since a model deforms due to aerodynamic loads, the wind-on image does not align with the wind-off image. The image registration technique based on a mathematical transformation between the wind-on and wind-off images is described to re-align these images. A crucial step for PSP is to accurately convert the luminescent intensity to pressure; cautious use of the calibration relations with a correction of the temperature effect of PSP is discussed. PSP measurements in low-speed flows are particularly difficult since a very small pressure change has to be sufficiently resolved by PSP. The pressure-correction method is described as an alternative to extrapolate the incompressible pressure coefficient from PSP measurements at suitably higher Mach numbers by removing the compressibility effect. The final processing step for PSP and TSP is to map results in images onto a model surface grid in the object space. When a model has a large deformation produced by aerodynamic loads, a deformed surface grid should be generated for more accurate PSP and TSP mapping. A methodology for generating a deformed wing grid is proposed based on
82
5. Image and Data Analysis Techniques
videogrammetric aeroelastic deformation simultaneously with PSP and TSP measurements.
measurements
conducted
5.1. Geometric Calibration of Camera
5.1.1. Collinearity Equations After the results of pressure and temperature are extracted from images of PSP and TSP, it is necessary to map the data onto a surface grid in the 3D object space (or physical space) to make the results more useful for design engineers and researchers. The collinearity equations in photogrammetry provide the perspective relationship between the 3D coordinates in the object space and corresponding 2D coordinates in the image plane (Wong 1980; McGlone 1989; Mikhail et al. 2001; Cooper and Robson 2001; Liu 2002). A key problem in quantitative image-based measurements is camera calibration to determine the camera interior and exterior orientation parameters, and lens distortion parameters in the collinearity equations. Simpler resection methods have often been used in PSP and TSP systems to determine the camera exterior orientation parameters under an assumption that the interior orientation and lens distortion parameters are known (Donovan et al. 1993; Le Sant and Merienne 1995). The standard Direct Linear Transformation (DLT) was also used to obtain the interior orientation parameters in addition to the exterior orientation parameters (Bell and McLachlan 1993, 1996). An optimization method for comprehensive camera calibration was developed by Liu et al. (2000), which can determine the exterior orientation, interior orientation and lens distortion parameters (as well as the pixel aspect ratio of a CCD array) from a single image of a 3D target field. The optimization method, combined with the DLT, allows automatic camera calibration without an initial guess of the orientation parameters; this feature particularly facilitates PSP and TSP measurements in wind tunnels. Besides the DLT, a closed-form resection solution given by Zeng and Wang (1992) is also useful for initial estimation of the exterior orientation parameters of a camera based on three known targets. Figure 5.1 illustrates the perspective relationship between the 3D coordinates ( X, Y, Z ) in the object space and the corresponding 2D coordinates (x, y) in the image plane. The lens of a camera is modeled by a single point known as the perspective center, the location of which in the object space is ( X c ,Yc ,Z c ) . Likewise, the orientation of the camera is characterized by three Euler orientation angles. The orientation angles and location of the perspective center are referred to in photogrammetry as the exterior orientation parameters. On the other hand, the relationship between the perspective center and the image coordinate system is defined by the camera interior orientation parameters, namely, the camera principal distance c and the photogrammetric principal-point location ( x p ,y p ) .
5.1. Geometric Calibration of Camera
83
The principal distance, which equals the camera focal length for a camera focused at infinity, is the perpendicular distance from the perspective center to the image plane, whereas the photogrammetric principal-point is where a perpendicular line from the perspective center intersects the image plane. Due to lens distortion, however, perturbation to the imaging process leads to departure from collinearity that can be represented by the shifts dx and dy of the image point from its ‘ideal’ position on the image plane. The shifts dx and dy are modeled and characterized by the lens distortion parameters. Z
Y Object point
X
O Object space
y Perturbed image point
Model
Perspective center c
dy
Principal point
dx yp
x
xp Ideal image point Image plane
Fig. 5.1. Camera imaging process and the interior orientation parameters
The perspective relationship is described by the collinearity equations
x − x p + d x =− c
m11 ( X − X c ) + m12 ( Y − Yc ) + m13 ( Z − Z c ) U = −c W m31 ( X − X c ) + m32 ( Y − Yc ) + m33 ( Z − Z c )
, y − y p + d y =− c
(5.1)
m21 ( X − X c ) + m22 ( Y − Yc ) + m23 ( Z − Z c ) V = −c W m31 ( X − X c ) + m32 ( Y − Yc ) + m33 ( Z − Z c )
where mij (i, j = 1, 2, 3) are the elements of the rotation matrix that are functions of the Euler orientation angles ( ω ,φ ,κ ) ,
84
5. Image and Data Analysis Techniques
m11 = cos φ cos κ m12 = sin ω sin φ cos κ + cos ω sin κ m13 = − cos ω sin φ cos κ + sin ω sin κ m21 = − cos φ sin κ m22 = − sin ω sin φ sin κ + cos ω cos κ
(5.2)
m23 = cos ω sin φ sin κ + sin ω cos κ m31 = sin φ m32 = − sin ω cos φ m33 = cos ω cos φ . The orientation angles ( ω ,φ ,κ ) are essentially the pitch, yaw, and roll angles of a camera in an established coordinate system. The terms dx and dy are the image coordinate shifts induced by lens distortion, which can be modeled by a sum of the radial distortion and decentering distortion (Fraser 1992; Fryer1989)
d x=d xr + d xd and d y =d y r + d y d ,
(5.3)
where
d x r = K 1 ( x' − x p ) r 2 + K 2 ( x' − x p ) r 4 , d y r = K 1 ( y' − y p ) r 2 + K 2 ( y' − y p ) r 4 , d x d = P1 [ r 2 + 2( x' − x p ) 2 ] + 2 P2 ( x' − x p )( y' − y p ) ,
(5.4)
d y d = P2 [ r 2 + 2( y' − y p ) 2 ] + 2 P1 ( x' − x p )( y' − y p ) , r 2 = ( x' − x p ) 2 + ( y' − y p )2 . Here, K1 and K2 are the radial distortion parameters, P1 and P2 are the decentering distortion parameters, and x’ and y’ are the undistorted coordinates in the image plane. When lens distortion is small, the unknown undistorted coordinates can be approximated by the known distorted coordinates, i.e., x' ≈ x and y' ≈ y . For large lens distortion, an iterative procedure can be employed to determine the appropriate undistorted coordinates to improve the accuracy of estimation. The following iterative relations can be used: ( x' )0 = x and ( y' )0 = y ,
( x' )k +1 = x + d x [( x' ) k ,( y' )k ] and ( y' )k +1 = y + d y [( x' ) k ,( y' ) k ] , where the superscripted iteration index is k = 0 , 1, 2 . The collinearity equations Eq. (5.1) contain a set of the camera parameters to be determined by camera calibration; the parameter sets ( ω ,φ ,κ , X c ,Yc , Z c ) , (c, x p , y p ) , and (K 1 , K 2 , P1 , P2 ) in Eq. (5.1) are the exterior orientation, interior orientation, and lens distortion parameters of a camera, respectively. Analytical camera calibration techniques have been used to solve the collinearity equations
5.1. Geometric Calibration of Camera
85
with the lens distortion model for the camera exterior and interior parameters (Rüther 1989; Tsai 1987). Since Eq. (5.1) is non-linear, iterative methods of leastsquares estimation have been used as a standard technique for the solution of the collinearity equations in photogrammetry (Wong 1980; McGlone 1989). However, direct recovery of the interior orientation parameters is often impeded by inversion of a nearly singular normal-equation-matrix in least-squares estimation. The singularity of the normal-equation-matrix mainly results from strong correlation between the exterior and interior orientation parameters. In order to reduce the correlation between these parameters and enhance the determinability of (c, x p , y p ) , Fraser (1992) suggested the use of multiple camera stations, varying image scales, different camera roll angles and a well-distributed target field in three dimensions. These schemes for selecting suitable calibration geometry improve the properties of the normal equation matrix. In general, iterative least-squares methods require a good initial guess to obtain a convergent solution. Mathematically, the singularity problem can be treated using the singular value decomposition that produces the best solution in a least-squares sense. Also, the Levenberg-Marquardt method can stay away to some extent from zero pivots (Marquardt 1963). Nevertheless, multiple-station, multiple-image methods for camera calibration are not easy to use in a wind tunnel environment where only a limited number of windows are available for cameras and the positions of cameras are fixed. Thus, it is highly desirable for PSP and TSP to have a single-image, easy-to-use calibration method devoid of the singularity problem and an initial guess. In the computer vision community, Tsai’s two-step method is particularly popular. Instead of directly solving the standard collinearity equations Eq. (5.1), Tsai (1987) used a radial alignment constraint to obtain a linear least-squares solution for a subset of the calibration parameters, whereas the rest of the parameters including the radial distortion parameter are estimated by an iterative scheme. Tsai’s method is fast, but less accurate than the standard photogrammetric methods. In addition, the radial alignment constraint prevents this method from incorporating a more general model of lens distortion. Here, we first discuss the DLT that can automatically provide initial values of the camera parameters and then describe an optimization method for more comprehensive calibration of a camera. 5.1.2. Direct Linear Transformation The Direct Linear Transformation (DLT), originally proposed by Abdel-Aziz and Karara (1971), can be very useful to determine approximate values of the camera parameters. Rearranging the terms in the collinearity equations leads to the DLT equations L1 X + L2 Y + L3 Z + L4 − ( x+ d x )( L9 X + L10 Y + L11 Z + 1 ) = 0 . (5.5) L5 X + L6 Y + L7 Z + L8 − ( y + d y )( L9 X + L10 Y + L11 Z + 1 ) = 0
86
5. Image and Data Analysis Techniques
The DLT parameters L1 , L11 are related to the camera exterior and interior orientation parameters ( ω ,φ ,κ , X c ,Yc , Z c ) and (c, x p , y p ) (McGlone 1989). Unlike the standard collinearity equations Eq. (5.1), Eq. (5.5) is linear for the DLT parameters when the lens distortion terms dx and dy are neglected. In fact, the DLT is a linear treatment of what is essentially a non-linear problem at the cost of introducing two additional parameters. The matrix form of the linear DLT L = ( L1 , L11 )T , equations for M targets is B L = C , where
C = ( x1 , y1 , x M , y M )T , and B is the 2M×11 configuration matrix that can be directly obtained from Eq. (5.5). A least-squares solution for L is formally given by L = (B T B) −1 B T C without using an initial guess. The camera parameters can be extracted from the DLT parameters from the following expressions
x p = ( L1 L9 + L2 L10 + L3 L11 )L2 , y p = ( L5 L9 + L6 L10 + L7 L11 )L2 , c = ( L21 + L22 + L23 )L2 − x 2p
,
φ = sin −1 ( L9 L ) , ω = tan −1 ( − L10 / L11 ) , κ = cos −1 ( m11 / cos( φ )) , m11 = L( x p L9 − L1 ) / c , L = − ( L29 + L210 + L211 )−1 / 2 ,
§ Xc · § L1 ¨ ¸ ¨ ¨ Yc ¸ = − ¨ L5 ¨ ¸ ¨ © Zc ¹ © L9
L2 L6 L10
L3 · § L4 · ¸¨ ¸ L7 ¸ ¨ L8 ¸ . ¸¨ ¸ L11 ¹ © 1 ¹
Because of its simplicity, the DLT is widely used in both non-topographic photogrammetry and computer vision. When dx and dy cannot be ignored, however, iterative solution methods are still needed and the DLT loses its simplicity. In general, the DLT can be used to obtain fairly good values of the exterior orientation parameter and the principal distance, although it gives a poor estimate for the principal-point location (x p ,y p ) (Cattafesta and Moore 1996). Therefore, the DLT is valuable since it can provide initial approximations for more accurate methods like the optimization method discussed below for comprehensive camera calibration.
5.1. Geometric Calibration of Camera
87
5.1.3. Optimization Method In order to develop a simple and robust method for comprehensive camera calibration, the singularity problem must be dealt with to solve the collinearity equations. Liu et al. (2000) proposed an optimization method based on the following insight. Strong correlation between the interior and exterior orientation parameters leads to the singularity of the normal-equation-matrix in least-squares estimation for a complete set of the camera parameters. Therefore, to eliminate the singularity, least-squares estimation is used for the exterior orientation parameters only, while the interior orientation and lens distortion parameters are calculated separately using an optimization scheme. This optimization method contains two separate, but interacting procedures: resection for the exterior orientation parameters and optimization for the interior orientation and lens distortion parameters. When the image coordinates (x, y) are given in pixels, we express the collinearity equations Eq. (5.1) as
f 1 = S h x n − x p + d x + cU / W = 0 f 2 = S v y n − y p + d y + cV / W = 0
,
(5.6)
where Sh and Sv are the horizontal and vertical pixel spacings (mm/pixel) of a CCD array, respectively. In general, the vertical pixel spacing is fixed and known for a CCD camera, but the effective horizontal spacing may be variable. Thus, an additional parameter, the pixel-spacing-aspect-ratio S h / S v , is introduced. We define Ȇ ex = ( Ȧ, ij, ț, X c , Yc , Z c )T for the exterior orientation parameters and
Ȇ in = (c, x p , y p , K 1 , K 2 , P1 , P2 , S h / S v )T for the interior orientation and lens distortion parameters in addition to the pixel-spacing-aspect-ratio. For given values of Ȇ in , and a set of known points (targets) pn =(x n ,y n )T and Pn =(X n ,Yn ,Z n )T , a solution for Ȇ ex in Eq. (5.6) can be found using an iterative least-squares method, referred to as resection in photogrammetry. The linearized collinearity equations for targets (n = 1, 2, , M) are written as V = ǹ ( ǻȆ ex ) − l , where ǻȆ ex is the correction term for the exterior orientation parameters, V is the 2M×1 residual vector, A is the 2M×6 configuration matrix, and l is the 2M×1 observation vector. The configuration matrix A and observation vector l in the linearized collinearity equations are § (∂ f 1 / ∂ Ȇ ex )1 · § ( f 1 )1 · ¸ ¨ ¸ ¨ ¨ (∂ f 2 / ∂ Ȇ ex )1 ¸ ¨ ( f 2 )1 ¸ ¸ ¨ ¸ ¨ (5.7) A=¨ ¸ and l = − ¨ ¸ , ¨ (∂ f 1 / ∂ Ȇ ex ) ¸ ¨ ( f 1 )M ¸ M ¸ ¨ ¸ ¨ ¨( f2 ) ¸ ¨ (∂ f 2 / ∂ Ȇ ex ) ¸ M ¹ M ¹ © ©
88
5. Image and Data Analysis Techniques
where
the
operator
∂ /∂ Ȇ ex
is
defined
as
( ∂ /∂ Ȧ,∂ /∂ ij,∂ /∂ ț, ∂ /∂ X c , ∂ /∂Yc , ∂ /∂ Z c ) and the subscript denotes a target. The components of the vectors ∂ f 1 / ∂ Ȇ ex and ∂ f 2 / ∂ Ȇ ex are
∂ f1 c U = { m12 ( Z − Z c ) − m13 ( Y − Yc ) − [ m32 ( Z − Z c ) − m33 ( Y − Yc )]} , ∂Ȧ W W ∂ f1 c U = [ −cos ț W − (cos ț U − sin ț V)] , ∂ij W W ∂ f 1 cV = W ∂ț
,
∂ f1 U c = ( −m11 + m31 ) , ∂Xc W W ∂ f1 c U = ( −m12 + m32 ) , ∂Yc W W ∂ f1 c U = ( −m13 + m33 ) , ∂Zc W W ∂ f2 c V = { m22 ( Z − Z c ) − m23 ( Y − Yc ) − [ m32 ( Z − Z c ) − m33 ( Y − Yc )]} , ∂Ȧ W W ∂ f2 c V = [sin ț W − (cos ț U − sin ț V)] , ∂ij W W ∂ f2 cU =− W ∂ț
,
∂ f2 c V = ( −m 21 + m31 ) , ∂Xc W W ∂ f2 c V = ( −m22 + m32 ) , ∂Yc W W ∂ f2 c V = ( −m23 + m33 ) . ∂Zc W W A least-squares solution to minimize the residuals V for the correction term is ǻȆ ex =(AT A) −1 AT l . In general, the 6 × 6 normal-equation-matrix ( AT A ) can be inverted without any singularity problem since the interior orientation and lens
5.1. Geometric Calibration of Camera
89
distortion parameters are not included in least-squares estimation. To obtain such Ȇ ex that the correction term ǻȆ ex becomes zero, the Newton-Raphson iterative method is used for solving the non-linear equation (AT A) −1 AT l = 0 for Ȇ ex . This approach converges over a considerable range of the initial values of Ȇ ex . Therefore, for given Ȇ in , the corresponding exterior orientation parameter Ȇ ex can be obtained, which are symbolically expressed as Ȇ ex = RESECTION( Ȇ in ) . At this stage, the exterior orientation parameters Ȇ ex are not necessarily correct unless the given interior orientation and lens distortion parameters Ȇ in are accurate. Obviously, an extra condition is needed to obtain correct Ȇ in and the determination of Ȇ in is coupled with the resection for Ȇ ex . An optimization scheme to obtain the correct Ȇ in is described as follows. We notice that the correct values of Ȇ in are intrinsic constants for a camera/lens system, and they are independent of the target locations p n = (x n ,y n )T in the image plane and Pn = (X n ,Yn ,Z n )T in the object space. Mathematically, Ȇ in is an invariant under a transformation ( p n ,Pn ) ( p m ,Pm ) ( m≠n ). Therefore, for the correct values of Ȇ in , the parameters (c, x p , y p ) are invariant under the transformation ( p n ,Pn ) ( p m ,Pm ) ( m≠n ). In other words, for the correct values of Ȇ in , the standard deviation of (c, x p , y p ) calculated over all the targets from the collinearity equations should be zero, i.e., M
std(x p ) = [ ¦ ( x p − < x p > ) 2 /( M − 1 ) ] 1/2 = 0 , where std denotes the standard n =1
deviation and < > denotes the mean value. Furthermore, since std ( x p ) ≥ 0 is always valid, the correct Ȇ in must correspond to the global minimum point of the function std ( x p ) . Hence, the determination of the correct Ȇ in becomes an optimization problem to seek such values of Ȇ in that the objective function
std ( x p ) is minimized, i.e., std ( x p ) → min . To solve this multiple-dimensional optimization problem, the sequential golden section search technique is used because of its robustness and simplicity. Since (c, x p , y p ) are estimated from Eq. (5.1) for given Ȇ ex , the optimization scheme for Ȇ in is coupled with the resection scheme for Ȇ ex . Other appropriate objective functions can also be used; an obvious choice is the root-mean-square (rms) deviation of the calculated object space coordinates of all the targets from the measured ones. In fact, it is found that std ( x p ) or std ( y p ) is equivalent to this rms deviation in the optimization problem. The quantities std ( x p ) and std ( y p ) for optimization have a simple topological structure near the global minimum point, exhibiting a single ‘valley’ structure in the parametric space (Liu et al. 2000). Generally, the topological
90
5. Image and Data Analysis Techniques
structure of std ( x p ) or std ( y p ) depends on three-dimensionality of a target field; stronger three-dimensionality of the target field produces a steeper ‘valley’ in topology, leading to faster convergence. The topological structure of std ( x p ) or std ( y p ) can also be affected by random disturbances on the targets. Larger noise in images leads to a slower convergence rate and produces a larger error in optimization computations. Although the simple ‘valley’ topological structure allows convergence of optimization computation over a considerable range of the initial values, appropriate initial values are still required to obtain a converged solution. The DLT can provide such initial values for the exterior orientation parameters ( Ȧ, ij, ț , X c , Yc , Z c ) and the principal distance c . Combined with the DLT, the optimization method allows rapid and comprehensive automatic camera calibration to obtain a total of 14 camera parameters from a single image without requiring a guess of the initial values.
Fig. 5.2. Step target plate for camera calibration
The optimization method was used for calibrating a Hitachi CCD camera with a Sony zoom lens (12.5 to 75 mm focal length) and an 8 mm Cosmicar television. As shown in Fig. 5.2, a three-step target plate with a 2-in step height provided a 3D target field for camera calibration, on which 54 circular retro-reflective targets of a 0.5-in diameter spaced out 2 inches apart are placed. Figure 5.3 shows the principal distance given by the optimization method versus zoom setting for the Sony zoom lens. Figures 5.4 and 5.5 show, respectively, the principal-point location and radial distortion coefficient K1 as a function of the principal distance for the Sony zoom lens. The results given by the optimization method are in reasonable agreement with measurements for the same lens using optical equipment in laboratory (Burner 1995). The optimization method was also used to calibrate the same Hitachi CCD camera with an 8 mm Cosmicar television lens. Table 5.1 lists the calibration results given by the optimization method compared well with those obtained using optical equipment. In order to determine accurately the interior orientation parameters, a target field should fill up an image for camera calibration. In large wind tunnels, however, a camera is often located far from a model such that the target field looks small in the image plane. In this case, a two-step approach is suggested that determines the interior and exterior orientation parameters separately. First, placing a target plate near a camera to produce a sufficiently large target field in the image plane, we can determine accurately the interior orientation parameters
5.1. Geometric Calibration of Camera
91
using the optimization method. Next, assuming that the determined interior orientation parameters are fixed for locked camera setting, we obtain the exterior orientation parameters using a resection scheme from the target field in a given wind-tunnel coordinate system. 90
Principal distance c (mm)
80
Optimization algorithm Linear fit
70 60 50 40 30 20 10 10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Zoom setting (mm)
Fig. 5.3. Principal distance vs. zoom setting for a Sony zoom lens. From Liu et al. (2000) 2 Optimization algorithm
xp or yp (mm)
Laser illumination technique
1
yp 0
xp -1 10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
c (mm)
Fig. 5.4. Principal-point location as a function of the principal distance for a Sony zoom lens connected to a Hitachi camera. From Liu et al. (2000)
92
5. Image and Data Analysis Techniques 0.0010 Optimization algorithm Burner (1995)
0.0005
K1 (mm-2)
0.0000
-0.0005
-0.0010
-0.0015
-0.0020 10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
c (mm)
Fig. 5.5. The radial distortion coefficient as a function of the principal distance for a Sony zoom lens connected to a Hitachi camera. From Liu et al. (2000)
Table 5.1. Calibration for Hitachi CCD camera with 8 mm Cosmicar TV lens Interior orientation
c (mm) xp (mm)
yp (mm)
Sh /Sv
K1 (mm-2)
K2 (mm-4)
Optimization
8.133
0.2014
0.99238
0.0026
3.3×10
Optical techniques
8.137
-0.156 -0.168
0.2010
0.99244
0.0027
-5
-5
4.5×10
P1 (mm-1)
P2 (mm-1)
1.8×10
-4
3×10
1.7×10
-4
-5
7×10-5
5.2. Radiometric Calibration of Camera Since PSP and TSP are based on radiometric measurements, a CCD camera used for measurements should have a good linear response of the electrical output to the scene radiance. However, there are many stages of image acquisition that may introduce non-linearity; for example, video cameras often include some form of ‘gamma’ mapping. When the radiometric response function of a camera is known, the non-linearity can be corrected. Here, a simple algorithm is described to determine the radiometric response function of a camera from a scene image taken in different exposures. First, we define I ( x ) as a linear radiometric response to the scene radiance and m [ I ( x )] as the measurement of I ( x ) by camera electronic circuitry that may produce a non-linear electrical output. Actually, the measurement m [ I ( x )] is the brightness or gray level of an image, where x is the image coordinates. The non-dimensional response function relating I ( x ) to m [ I ( x )] is defined by
5.2. Radiometric Calibration of Camera
I ( x ) / I max = f [ ξ ( x )] ,
93
(5.8)
where ξ ( x ) = m[ I ( x )] / m( I max ) is the non-dimensional measurement of I ( x ) normalized by the maximum value and I max corresponds to the maximum
radiance in the scene. Recovery of f (ξ ) is the task of the radiometric calibration of a camera. Two images of a scene are taken in two different exposures. According to the camera formula (Holst 1998), I ( x ) is proportional to the integration time t INT and inversely proportional to the square of the f-number F. Thus, we have the following functional equation for f (ξ ) ,
f (ξ 1 ) / f ( ξ 2 ) = R12 ,
(5.9)
where the subscripts 1 and 2 denote the image 1 and image 2, and the factor R12 is defined as I ( t / F 2 )1 . (5.10) R12 = max 2 INT I max 1 ( t INT / F 2 )2 Since m( I max ) corresponds to I max , the boundary condition for
f (ξ = 1) = 1 . We assume that f (ξ ) can be expanded as f (ξ ) =
f (ξ ) is
N
¦ c φ (ξ ) , n
(5.11)
n
n =0
where the base functions φ n ( ξ ) are the Chebyshev functions although other orthogonal functions and non-orthogonal functions like polynomials can also be used. Substitution of Eq. (5.11) to Eq. (5.9) leads to the following equations for the coefficients c n N
¦ c [φ ( ξ n
n
1
) − R12 φ n ( ξ 2 )] = 0 ,
n =0 N
¦ c φ (1) = 1 .
(5.12)
n n
n =0
For selected M pixels in a scene image, Eq. (5.12) constitutes a system of M+1 equations for the N+1 unknowns c n ( M ≥ N ). For a given R12 , a least-squares solution for c n can be found. In practice, since the factor R12 is not exactly known a priori, we use an approximate value of R12
R12 ≈
m( I max 2 ) ( t INT / F 2 )1 m( I max 1 ) ( t INT / F 2 )2
.
An iteration scheme can be used to give an improved value of R12 . Figure 5.6 shows two images taken by a Cannon digital still camera (EOS D30) at two
94
5. Image and Data Analysis Techniques
different f-numbers of F = 4.0 and F = 5.6, where Ansel Adams’ photograph of Mirror Lake of Yosemite was used as a test scene providing a broad range of the gray levels for radiometric calibration. Figure 5.7 shows the radiometric response function of the camera retrieved from the two images, where six terms of the Chebyshev functions in Eq. (5.11) were used. The response function of the Cannon digital still camera exhibits a non-linear behavior; it is also different for the red, green and blue (RGB) color channels.
(a)
(b)
Fig. 5.6. Two images of Mirror Lake of Yosemite (Ansel Adams 1935) taken by a Cannon digital still camera (EOS D30) at different F-numbers (a) F = 4.0 and (b) F = 5.6 for radiometric calibration of the camera
Camera Response Function, I/Imax
1.0
R G B
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0 0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
m(I)/m(Imax)
Fig. 5.7. Response functions of a Cannon digital still camera (EOS D30) for the R, G, and B color channels obtained from radiometric calibration
5.3. Correction for Self-Illumination
95
5.3. Correction for Self-Illumination The self-illumination of PSP and TSP results from the luminescent contribution to a point on a surface from all visible neighboring points; it becomes appreciable near a conjuncture of two surfaces and on a concave surface (Ruyten 1997a, 1997b, 2001a; Ruyten and Fisher 2001; Le Sant 2001b). Although the selfillumination can be to certain extent suppressed by taking a ratio between a windon image and a wind-off image, it cannot be eliminated without considering an exchange of the radiative energy between neighboring surfaces, which may produce an error in data reduction of PSP and TSP. Therefore, we need to know how much the radiative energy leaves from an area element and travels toward another element. The geometric relations for this inter-surface process are known as view factors, configuration factors, shape factors, or angle factors (Modest 1993). We consider diffuse surfaces that absorb and emit diffusely, and also reflect the radiative energy diffusely. The view factor dFdA i − dA j between two infinitesimal surface elements dAi and dA j , as shown in Fig. 5.8, is defined as a ratio between the diffuse energy leaving dAi directly toward and intercepted by
dA j and the total diffuse energy leaving dAi , which is expressed as dFdA i − dA j =
cos θ i cos θ j
π | X ij |
2
dA j =
( ni • X ij )( n j • X ij )
π | X ij |4
dA j ,
(5.13)
where n i (or n j ) is the unit normal vector of dAi (or dA j ), X ij is the position vector directing from dAi toward dA j , and θ i (or θ j ) is the angle between the position vector X ij and the normal n i (or n j ). The view factors leaving dAi directly toward the total surface A j or leaving A j toward dAi , or leaving A j toward Ai can be similarly defined by integrating dFdA i − dA j (Modest 1993). The law of reciprocity dAi dFdA i −dA j = dA j dFdA j −dA i is valid for these view factors. The view factor is a function of the geometric parameters. Methods for evaluating the view factors were discussed by Modest (1993) and a large collection of the view factors for simple geometric configurations was complied by Howell (1982). For partially specular surfaces, the determination of the view factors is more complicated since the bidirectional reflectance distribution function (BRDF) of the paint must be known (Nicodemus et al. 1977; Asmail 1991).
96
5. Image and Data Analysis Techniques
Xj nj
θj dAj
Xij
ni θi
Xi
dAi
Fig. 5.8. Radiative exchange between two surface elements
The self-illumination correction is applied to an image intensity (or brightness intensity) field denoted by I in this sub-section after it is mapped onto a model surface grid in the object space. Because the image intensity is proportional to the luminescent energy flow rate, the image intensity I i at an area element dAi is a sum of the local intrinsic intensity I i( 0 ) and an integration of the contributions from all the neighboring elements, i.e., N
I i = I i( 0 ) + ρ λwp2
¦I j =1
j
dFdA j − dAi dA j
,
(5.14)
where ρ λwp2 is the reflectivity of the wall-paint interface at the luminescent wavelength. In simulations, given a set of the intrinsic intensities I i( 0 ) , the image intensity I i affected by the self-illumination can be obtained using a simple iteration scheme N
I i( n+1 ) = I i( 0 ) + ρ λwp2
¦I j =1
(n) j
dFdA j −dA i dA j
.
(5.15)
The more efficient Gauss-Seidel iteration scheme was used by Ruyten and Fisher (2001). In measurements, since the image intensity I i is known in PSP and TSP images, an explicit relation is used to correct the self-illumination and recover the intrinsic intensity I i( 0 ) , i.e., N
I i( 0 ) = I i − ρ λwp2
¦I j =1
j
dFdA j −dA i dA j
.
(5.16)
5.3. Correction for Self-Illumination
97
The steps for correcting the self-illumination are: (1) measuring the reflectivity ρ λwp2 ; (2) defining a surface grid consisting of N surface elements dAi ; (3) evaluating the view factors dFdA j −dA i ; (4) mapping the image intensity I i onto the surface grid; (5) calculating the intrinsic (corrected) intensity I i( 0 ) using Eq. (5.16); and (6) calculating a ratio of the intrinsic (self-illumination-corrected) intensities and converting it to pressure or temperature. Ruyten and Fisher (2001) conducted a numerical simulation of correcting the self-illumination for a PSP test of the Alpha jet and found that the error associated with the self-illumination in PSP measurements could reach several percents of actual pressure.
plate 2
plate 1 dA1
α
Fig. 5.9. Wedge-shaped conjunction of two plates
Here, we consider a simple but representative geometric configuration, a wedge-shaped conjunction of two infinitely large plates, as shown in Fig. 5.9; this case allows an analytical estimate of the error induced by the self-illumination. The image intensity at a location on the plate 1 is
I 1 = I 1( 0 ) + ρ λwp2
³I
2
dFdA2 −dA1 dA2 .
(5.17)
plate 2
Assuming that the image intensity at the plate 2 is homogenous, by integrating the view factor for this configuration (Modest 1993), we obtain the image intensity at the plate1 affected by the plate 2
I 1 ≈ I 1( 0 ) + ε 1 I 2 ,
(5.18)
where the parameter ε 1 = ρ λwp2 ( 1 + cos α ) / 2 represents the combined effect of the angle α between the plates and reflectivity. Clearly, the self-illumination decreases from the maximum value at α = 0 o to zero at α = 180 o . A reciprocal relation gives the image intensity at the plate 2
98
5. Image and Data Analysis Techniques
I 2 ≈ I 2( 0 ) + ε 1 I 1 .
(5.19)
When the parameter ε 1 is small, the image intensity ratio at the plate 1 is 0) I 1 ref / I 1 ≈ ( I 1( ref / I 1( 0 ) ) ( 1 + ε 1 ε 2 ) .
(5.20)
0) − I 2( 0 ) / I 1( 0 ) reflects the difference of the relative The parameter ε 2 = I 2( 0ref) / I 1( ref influence of the plate 2 on the pate 1 between the wind-off reference and wind-on conditions. Using the Stern-Volmer relation for PSP, we obtain an estimate for the pressure error associated with the self-illumination for the wedge configuration
§ A p( 0 ) | p − p( 0 ) | ≈ ε1 | ε 2 | ¨ + (0 ) (0 ) ¨ B p ref p ref ©
· ¸, ¸ ¹
(5.21)
(0 ) where A and B are the Stern-Volmer coefficients, and p ( 0 ) and p ref are, respectively, the intrinsic PSP-derived pressures in the wind-on and wind-off reference conditions that are not affected by the self-illumination. Similarly, using the Arrhenius relation for TSP, we have an estimate for the temperature error associated with the self-illumination for the wedge configuration
|T − T (0 ) | R ≈ ε1 | ε2 | E nr T (0 )
,
(5.22)
where R is the universal gas constant, E nr is the activity energy of TSP, and
T ( 0 ) is the intrinsic TSP-derived temperature that is not affected by the selfillumination. The above discussion is based on an assumption that the luminescent paint surface is a diffuse surface or Lambertian surface. Nevertheless, a real paint surface is neither Lambertian nor specular. To characterize reflection on a general surface, the bidirectional reflectance distribution function (BRDF) was introduced by Nicodemus et al. (1977). As shown in Fig. 5.10, the incident radiance is generally a function of the incident direction defined by the incident polar angle and azimuthal angle ( θ i ,φ i ) , i.e., Li = Li ( θ i ,φ i ) .
(5.23)
The reflection radiance Lr ( θ i ,φ i ;θ r ,φ r ) is quantitatively characterized by the BRDF
f r ( θ i ,φ i ;θ r ,φ r ) = dLr ( θ i ,φ i ;θ r ,φ r ) / dEi ( θ i ,φ i ) .
(5.24)
where ( θ r ,φ r ) defines the direction of reflection and the infinitesimal incident irradiance dE i ( θ i ,φ i ) over a solid angle element dω i is
5.3. Correction for Self-Illumination
dEi ( θ i ,φ i ) = Li ( θ i ,φ i ) cosθ i dω i .
99
(5.25)
-1
The BRDF has a unit of steradian . Here, the conventional radiometric notations L and E are used for radiance and irradiance, which are also applicable to the luminescent emission. The BRDF depends on a surface roughness distribution. For a perfectly diffuse surface where the reflection radiance is isotropic, i.e., Lr = const . , the BRDF is
f r = 1 / π (Horn and Sjoberg 1979). For a general surface, the BRDF can be derived based on either the wave equation for electromagnetic waves or geometrical optics models (Beckmann and Spizzichino 1963; Torrance and Sparrow 1967; Nayar et al. 1991). Asmail (1991) gave a bibliographical review on the BRDF. From a viewpoint of application, empirical expressions for the scattered radiance from a rough surface are very useful due to their simplicity (Cook and Torrance 1981; Haussecker 1999). An empirical model for a single light source is Lr ( X ) = ρ a E a ( X ) + ρ d Els ( X )( N T Ls ) + ρ s Els ( X ) p( R T V ) ,
(5.26)
where the first, second and third terms are, respectively, the contributions from the ambient reflection, diffuse reflection, and specular reflection. In Eq. (5.26), ρ a ,
ρ d , and ρ s , are the empirical reflection coefficients for the ambient reflection, diffuse reflection, and specular reflection. As shown in Fig. 5.10, the vectors N , Ls , R , and V are, respectively, the unit normal vector of a surface, the unit vector directing the light source from the surface, the unit main directional vector of the specular reflection, and the unit viewing vector. E a ( X ) and Els ( X ) are the irradiances for the ambient environment and light sources, respectively. The function p( R T V ) is the directional distribution of the specular reflection, describing the spreading of scattered light. Phong (1975) gave a power function p( R T V ) = ( R T V )n . In general, the main directional vector of the specular reflection, R , is a function of the incident direction of light − Ls . Although there are certain theories for predicting the specular direction R (Torrance and Sparrow 1967), R is not known for a general surface. The unknowns in Eq. (5.26), such as R , the reflection coefficients, and the parameters in p( R T V ) , have to be determined experimentally by calibration. Le Sant (2001b) measured the BRDF for the B1 PSP paint with talc using a BRDF calibration rig. As illustrated in Fig. 5.11, the BRDF calibration rig included a lamp for illumination and a spectrometer to measure the reflected light from a sample. The lamp emitted white light, enabling the calibration of the o o BRDF in the visible range; the lamp moved from 0 at the vertical position to 60 . o o The zenith (or polar) angle of the spectrometer moved from 0 to 60 and the o o o azimuth angle moved from 0 to 180 , where 180 was in the opposite direction of the emission. Figure 5.12 shows the measured BRDF for the B1 paint, which was nearly Lambertian when the zenith (or polar) angle of illumination was 10°, while specular reflection occurred when the zenith angle increased further. The
100
5. Image and Data Analysis Techniques
maximum value was always achieved in the specular direction. The low value obtained at the azimuth angle of 0° was incorrect since the spectrometer was in the front of the lamp and thus the PSP sample was no longer illuminated. The measured BRDF showed a superposition of diffuse reflection and specular reflection. A specular peak was observed at the zenith angle of 60° as well as a secondary peak at the azimuth angle of 90°. The value of the diffuse reflection factor depended on the zenith angle of illumination. Le Sant (2001b) was able achieve a good fit to the measured BRDF using the modified Phong model (Phong 1975), as shown in Fig. 5.13, and the modeled BRDF captured the main features of the measured BRDF except the secondary specular peaks.
LI
θE
V
N
R
θH
φH
Fig. 5.10. Vectors of incident, reflecting, and viewing directions zenith (spectrometer) zenith (illumination)
0°
180° 90°
90°
azimuth 0°
Fig. 5.11. The zenith (or polar) and azimuth angles in the BRDF calibration rig. From Le Sant (2001b)
5.3. Correction for Self-Illumination BRDF
BRDF
0.4
0.4
0.2
0.2
0.2
0.1
0.1
0.1 60
0
60
0
180
zenith
20
zenith
20
azimuth
zenith
80
20
0
0
40
0.6
50
0.4
60
0.4
0.2
0.2
60
0
0.1 60
0
180
10
180
40
160 140
zenith
zenith
azimuth
10
40
160
azimuth
80
10
40 20
20 0
0
0
azimuth
60
40
20
120 100
20
80 60
140
30
120 100
20
180
40
160 140
30
120 100 80
0
50
50
60
0.4
0.3
0.1
50
20
0.5
0.3
0.1 60
BRDF 0.5
0.3
30
0
0.6
BRDF 0.5
40
azimuth
40 20 0
0.6
0
80 60
10
40 20 0
BRDF
zenith
120 100
azimuth
60 10
40
160 140
30
120 100
20 0
180
40
160 140
30
80 60
10
180
40
160 140 120 100
0
50
50
50
30
0.4
0.3
0.3
0.3
40
0.5
30
0.5
20
0.5
60
0.6
0.6
0.6
BRDF
10
101
0
0
Fig. 5.12. The measured BRDF of the B1 paint at the illumination zenith angles of 10, 20, 30, 40, 50 and 60 degrees. From Le Sant (2001b)
BRDF
BRDF
10
20
0.5
0.4
30
0.5
0.4
0.2
0.1
0.1 60
0
60
0
180
zenith
80
20
zenith
80
0.4
0 180 160 140
30
120 100
20
80 60
10
azimuth
0.2
0.1 60
0
50 180
40
160
0.1 60
0
50 180
40
160
140
30
zenith
120 100
20
80 60
10
40
40 20
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.2
40
60
0.4
0.5
0.3
0.1
50
0.6
BRDF 0.5
0.3
60
0
0.6
50
0.5
azimuth
40 20 0
BRDF
40
0
80 60
10
0
0.6
0
20
40 20 0
0
BRDF
zenith
120 100
azimuth
60 10
40 20 0
160 140
30
120 100
azimuth
60 10
180
40
160 140
30
120 100
20
180
40
160 140
30
0
50
50
50 40
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.2
0.1
zenith
0.5
0.3
0.3
60
0.6
0.6
0.6
BRDF
140
30
zenith
120 100
20
80
azimuth
60 10
0
azimuth
40
20 0
20 0
0
Fig. 5.13. The modeled BRDF of the B1 paint at the illumination zenith angles of 10, 20, 30, 40, 50 and 60 degrees using the modified Phong model. From Le Sant (2001b)
Le Sant (2001b) also studied the self-illumination in a corner to validate a correction algorithm. The corner was painted with a Pyrene-based paint providing an image significantly affected by the self-illumination near the junction of the two plates, as shown in Fig. 5.14. Then, the left plate was covered with a black sheet, removing the effect of the self-illumination on the right plate, as shown in
102
5. Image and Data Analysis Techniques
the right image in Fig. 5.14. Figure 5.15 shows results before and after correcting the self-illumination based on the diffuse surface model and the Phong model. The self-illumination correction was effective; the self-illumination effect was reduced to 15% from about 40% near the junction. This paint behaved mostly like a diffuse paint such that the Phong model did not exhibit a significant improvement. Although the Phong model might improve the accuracy of correction for a surface with strong specular reflection, the computation time for the Phong model was much longer than that for the diffuse surface model.
Fig. 5.14. Self-illumination in a corner coated with PSP. From Le Sant (2001b) 0.16
with SI effect
0.15 0.14 0.13
diffuse model
0.12 0.11
Phong model
0.10 0
10
20
30
without SI 40 X (mm) 50
Fig. 5.15. Self-illumination correction using the diffuse and Phong models. From Le Sant (2001b)
5.4. Image Registration The intensity-based method for PSP and TSP requires a ratio between the wind-on and wind-off images of a painted model. Since a model deforms due to aerodynamic loads, the wind-on image does not align with the wind-off image; therefore these images have to be re-aligned before taking a ratio between the images. The image registration technique, developed by Bell and McLachlan (1993, 1996) and Donovan et al. (1993), is based on an ad-hoc transformation that
5.4. Image Registration
103
maps the deformed wind-on image coordinates ( xon , yon ) onto the reference wind-off image coordinates ( xoff , yoff ) . In order to register the images, some black fiducial targets are placed on a model. When the correspondence between the targets in the wind-off and wind-on images is established, a transformation between the wind-off and wind-on image coordinates of the targets can be expressed as x off = aij φ i ( x on )φ j ( y on ) . (5.27) y off = bij φ i ( xon )φ j ( y on )
¦ ¦
The base functions φ i ( ξ ) are either the orthogonal functions like the Chebyshev functions or the non-orthogonal power functions φ i ( x ) = x i used by Bell and McLachlan (1993, 1996) and Donovan et al. (1993). Given the image coordinates of the targets placed on a model, the unknown coefficients aij and bij can be determined using least-squares method to match the targets between the wind-on and wind-off images. For image warping, one can also use a 2D perspective transform (Jähne 1999)
x off =
a 11 x on + a 12 y on + a 13 a 31 x on + a 32 y on + 1
. (5.28) a 21 x on + a 22 y on + a 23 y off = a 31 x on + a 32 y on + 1 Although the perspective transform is non-linear, it can be reduced to a linear transform using the homogeneous coordinates. The perspective transform is collinear that maps a line into another line and a rectangle into a quadrilateral. Therefore, Eq. (5.28) is more restricted than Eq. (5.27) for PSP and TSP applications. Before the image registration technique is applied, the targets must be identified and their centroid locations in images must be determined. The target centroid ( xc , y c ) is defined as
¦¦ x I ( x , y ) / ¦¦ I ( x , y ) , = ¦¦ y I ( x , y ) / ¦¦ I ( x , y )
xc =
i
i
i
i
i
yc
i
i
i
i
i
(5.29)
where I ( xi , y i ) is the gray level on an image. When a target contains only a few pixels and the target contrast is not high, the centroid calculation using the definition Eq. (5.29) may not be accurate. Another method for determining the target location is to maximize the correlation between a template f ( x , y ) and the target scene I ( x , y ) (Rosenfeld and Kak 1982). The correlation coefficient C fI is defined as
104
5. Image and Data Analysis Techniques
C fI =
³³ f ( x + x , y + y )I ( x , y )dxdy ³³ f ( x , y )dxdy ³³ I ( x , y )dxdy 0
2
0
.
(5.30)
2
For the continuous functions f ( x , y ) and I ( x , y ) , one can determine the location
( x0 , y0 ) of the target by maximizing C fI . However, it is found that for small targets in images, sub-pixel misalignment between the template and the scene can significantly reduce the value of C fI even when the scene contains a perfect replica of the template. To enhance the robustness of a localization scheme, Ruyten (2001b) proposed an augmented template f ( x , y ) = f 0 ( x , y ) + f x ∆ x + f y ∆ y , where f 0 ( x , y ) represented a conventional template and f x and f y are the partial derivatives of f ( x , y ) . The additional shift parameters ( ∆ x , ∆ y ) allowed more robust and accurate determination of the target locations. In PSP and TSP measurements, operators can manually select the targets and determine the correspondence between the wind-off and wind-on images. However, PSP and TSP measurements with multiple cameras in production wind tunnels may produce hundreds or thousands of images in a given test; thus, image registration becomes very labor-intensive and time-consuming. It is non-trivial to automatically establish the point-correspondence between images taken by cameras at different viewing angles and positions. This problem is generally related to the epipolar geometry in which a point on an image corresponds to a line on another image (Faugeras 1993). Ruyten (1999) discussed the methodologies for automatic image registration including searching targets, labeling targets and rejecting false targets. Unlike ad-hoc techniques, the searching technique based on photogrammetric mapping is more rigorous. Once cameras are calibrated and the position and attitude of a tested model are approximately given by other techniques (such as accelerators and videogrammetric techniques), the targets in the images can be found using photogrammetric mapping from the 3D object space to the image plane (see Section 5.1). The aforementioned methods of using a single transformation for the whole image is a global approach for image registration. A local approach proposed by Shanmugasundaram and Samareh-Abolhassani (1995) divides an image domain into triangles connecting a set of targets based on the Delaunay triangulation (de Berg et al. 1998). For a triangle defined by the vertex vectors R1 , R2 and R2 , a point in the plane of the triangle can be described by a vector u1 R1 + u 2 R2 + u 3 R3 , where (u 1 , u 2 , u 3 ) are referred to as the parametric (barocentric) coordinates and a constraint u1 + u 2 + u 3 = 1 is imposed. When a wind-on pixel is identified inside a triangle and its parametric coordinates is given, the corresponding wind-off pixel can be determined by using the same parametric coordinates in the vertex vectors of the corresponding triangle in the wind-off image. Finally, the image intensity at that pixel is mapped from the wind-on
5.5. Conversion to Pressure
105
image to the wind-off image. This approach is basically a linear interpolation assuming that the relative position of a point inside a triangle to the vertices is invariant under a transformation from the wind-on image to the wind-off image. Weaver et al. (1999) proposed a so-called Quantum Pixel Energy Distribution (QPED) algorithm that utilizes local surface features to calculate a pixel shift vector using a spatial correlation method. The local surface features could be targets, pressure taps, and dots formed from aerosol mists in spraying on a basecoat. Similar to particle image velocimetry (PIV), the QPED algorithm can give a field of the displacement vectors when the registration marks or features are dense enough. Based on the shift vector field, the wind-on image can be registered. Although the QPED algorithm is computationally intensive, it can provide the local displacement vectors at certain locations to complement the global image registration techniques. A comparative study of different image registration techniques was made by Venkatakrishnan (2003).
5.5. Conversion to Pressure In PSP measurements, conversion of the luminescent intensity to pressure is complicated by the temperature effect of PSP especially when the surface temperature distribution is not known. Empirically, a priori calibration relation between air pressure and the relative luminescent intensity is expressed by a polynomial 2
I ref § I ref · p ¸ . = C1 ( T ) + C2 ( T ) + C3 ( T ) ¨¨ ¸ I pref © I ¹
(5.31)
The experimentally determined coefficients C1 , C2 and C3 in Eq. (5.31) can be expressed as a polynomial function of temperature. If a distribution of the surface temperature is not given and the thermal conditions in a priori laboratory calibrations are different from those in wind tunnel tests, a priori relation Eq. (5.31) cannot be directly applied to conversion to pressure. To deal with this problem, a short-cut approach is in-situ PSP calibration that directly correlates the luminescent intensity to pressure data from taps distributed on a model surface. In this case, the constant coefficients C1 , C2 and C3 in Eq. (5.31) are determined using least-squares method to achieve the best fit to the pressure tap data over a certain range of pressures. Through in-situ calibration, the effect of a non-uniform surface temperature distribution is actually absorbed into a precision error of leastsquares estimation. When the temperature effect of PSP overwhelms a change of the luminescent intensity produced by pressure, in-situ calibration has a large precision error. In addition, when the pressure tap data do not cover the full range of pressure on a surface, in-situ PSP conversion may lead to a large bias error in data extrapolation outside the calibration range of pressures.
106
5. Image and Data Analysis Techniques
A hybrid method between in-situ and a priori methods is the so-called K-fit method originally suggested by M. Morris and recapitulated by Woodmansee and Dutton (1998). Eq. (5.31) is re-written as 2 ª § I off · § I off · º p ¸ + C3 ( T ) ¨ K I ¸ », = K P «C1 ( T ) + C2 ( T )¨¨ K I ¨ « poff I ¸¹ I ¸¹ » © © ¬ ¼
(5.32)
where I off = I ( poff ,Toff ) is the luminescent intensity in the wind-off conditions, and K I = I ref / I off and K P = pref / poff are called the K-factors. The reference conditions under which a priori calibration is made in a laboratory are generally different from the wind-off conditions in a wind tunnel. While the factor K P = pref / poff is known, the factor K I = I ref / I off is generally not known and has to be determined since illumination conditions and photodetectors used in laboratory may be different from those in wind tunnel. Given the coefficients C1 ,
C2 and C3 at a known temperature on an isothermal surface, K I can be determined using a single data point from pressure taps. When the surface temperature data near a number of pressure taps are provided by other techniques like TSP and IR camera, a more accurate value of K I can be obtained using leastsquares method with larger statistical redundancy. In the worst case where the surface temperature distribution is totally unknown, assuming an average temperature over the surface, we still able to estimate K I by fitting the pressure tap data. Similar to in-situ calibration, the effect of a non-uniform temperature distribution is absorbed into a precision error of least-squares estimation for K I . Bencic (1999) used a similarity variable of the luminescent intensity to scale the temperature effect of certain PSP
I ref I
= g( T ) corr
I ref I
,
(5.33)
where g( T ) was a function of temperature to be determined by a priori calibration. Under this similarity transformation, the calibration curves for the paint at different temperatures collapsed onto a single curve with the temperatureindependent coefficients, i.e.,
I ref p = C1 + C2 I pref
corr
§ I ref + C3 ¨ ¨ I ©
2
· ¸ . ¸ corr ¹
(5.34)
In this case, instead of using a 2D calibration surface in the parametric space, only a single one-parameter relation Eq. (5.34) was used to convert the luminescent intensity ratio to pressure. Bencic (1999) found that this similarity was valid for a
5.6. Pressure Correction for Extrapolation to Low-Speed Data
107
Ruthenium-based PSP used at NASA Glenn. In fact, as pointed out in Section 3.6, this similarity is a property of the so-called ‘ideal’ PSP that obeys the following relations (Puklin et al. 1998; Coyle et al. 1999)
I ( p,T ) / I ( p,Tref ) = g( T ) , I ref ( pref ,Tref ) I ( p,Tref )
= g( T )
I ref ( pref ,Tref ) I ( p,T )
.
(5.35)
Puklin et al. (1998) found that PtTFPP in FIB polymer was an ‘ideal’ PSP over a certain range of temperatures. Note that this similarity (or invariance) is not the universal property of a general PSP.
5.6. Pressure Correction for Extrapolation to Low-Speed Data PSP is particularly effective in high subsonic, transonic and supersonic flow regimes. However, in low-speed flows where the Mach number is typically less than 0.3, PSP measurement is a challenging problem since a very small pressure change may not be sufficiently resolved by PSP. The major error sources, notably the temperature effect, image misalignment and CCD camera noise, must be minimized to obtain acceptable quantitative pressure results at low speeds. The resolution of PSP measurements is eventually limited by the photon shot noise of a CCD camera. Liu (2003) proposed a pressure-correction method as an alterative to extrapolate low-speed pressure data without directly attacking the intrinsic difficulty of PSP instrumentation for low-speed flows. This method is able to obtain the incompressible pressure coefficient from PSP measurements at suitably higher Mach numbers (typically Mach 0.3-0.6) by removing the compressibility effect. It is noticed that there is a significant difference between the responses of the absolute pressure p and the pressure coefficient C p to the freestream Mach number M ∞ .
The sensitivity of C p to the Mach number for M ∞2 << 1 is
estimated by
M ∞ dC p (5.36) ≈ M ∞2 . C p dM ∞ In contrast, the sensitivity of pressure to the Mach number is approximately M∞ d( p − p∞ ) S p − p∞ = ≈ 2. (5.37) ( p − p ∞ ) dM ∞ SC p =
For
M ∞2 << 1 ,
SC p
is much smaller than
S p − p∞ ; for
M ∞ = 0.3
and
dM ∞ / M ∞ = 10% , the relative change of the absolute pressure difference is d ( p − p∞ ) /( p − p∞ ) ≈ 20% , while the relative change of C p is only
108
5. Image and Data Analysis Techniques
dC p / C p ≈ 0.9% .
Clearly, PSP can take the advantage of the relative
insensitivity of C p to the Mach number to obtain the approximate incompressible pressure coefficient distribution at suitably higher Mach numbers. Furthermore, the compressibility effect can be corrected using the pressure-correction methods. Historically, the pressure-correction formulas were derived in order to extrapolate the pressure coefficient in subsonic compressible flows from the incompressible flow theory and low-speed pressure measurements. In contrast, for PSP applications, the pressure-correction formulas are used to transform the compressible C p to the corresponding incompressible C pinc . The theoretical foundation for pressure correction in 2D potential flows is well established. The linearized theory for subsonic compressible flows gives the Prandtl-Glauert rule (Anderson 1990)
C p = C pinc / 1 − M ∞2 . (5.38) The use of a hodograph solution of the non-linear potential equation gives the Karman-Tsien rule (Anderson 1990) C pinc Cp = . (5.39) § ·C 2 M pinc ¨ ¸ ∞ 1 − M ∞2 + ¨ ¨ 1 + 1 − M ∞2 ¸¸ 2 © ¹ For PSP measurements on 2D airfoils at suitably high Mach numbers, both the Prandtl-Glauert rule and Karman-Tsien rule can be used to recover the incompressible pressure coefficient. Bell and Hand (1998) used the PrandtlGlauert rule for the purpose of improving the image ratioing procedure of PSP to obtain a pseudo wind-off pressure coefficient at a suitably low velocity. For complex 3D viscous flows such as separated flows, however, a general pressurecorrection method is required. Liu (2003) developed an iterative pressure-correction method for 3D flows. For M ∞2 << 1 , a pressure field can be generally expressed as a power series of M ∞2 . The pressure-correction formula for a general surface Z = S ( X ,Y ) has a functional form composed of an incompressible term and a compressible correction term C p ≈ C pinc + M ∞2 F [ X ,Y , S ( X ,Y )] . (5.40) Eq. (5.40) is valid for not only potential flows, but also complex viscous flows over a 3D body. Because C pinc = C pinc [ X ,Y , S ( X ,Y )] is a function of X and Y, we can, in principle, eliminate X in the correction function F [ X ,Y , S ( X ,Y )] by using C pinc and Y. Therefore, since the correction function F [ X ,Y , S ( X ,Y )] is not specified yet, the equivalent form to Eq. (5.40) is C p ≈ C pinc + M ∞2 F ( C pinc ,Y ) . (5.41) Eq. (5.41) indicates that the pressure correction in 3D flows depends on not only C pinc , but also one space coordinate Y. Note that the functional form of Eq. (5.41) remains valid after the coordinate Y is switched to another coordinate X. When
5.6. Pressure Correction for Extrapolation to Low-Speed Data
109
C p does not change along the coordinate Y, Eq. (5.41) is naturally reduced to the method for 2D and axisymmetrical flows. polynomial function, Eq. (5.41) becomes
By writing F ( C pinc ,Y ) as a
N
¦ a (Y )C
C p ≈ C pinc + M ∞2
n
n pinc
.
(5.42)
n =0
When the distributions of C p and C pinc are known along an intersection between the plane Y = const . and the surface Z = S ( X ,Y ) , the coefficients a n ( Y ) can be determined using least-squares method. In wind tunnel measurements, pressure tap data in subsonic flow and the corresponding low-speed flow can be used to establish the relationship between C p and C pinc . However, this approach is not convenient for PSP measurements in wind tunnels since extra pressure tap data are required. Here, an iterative method is proposed to recover C pinc from C p data at two different subsonic Mach numbers M ∞1 and M ∞ 2 . The biggest advantage of this method is that C pinc can be directly obtained from two PSP images taken at
M ∞1 and M ∞ 2 without use of additional pressure tap data. Denote C p 1 and C p 2 as the pressure coefficients at M ∞1 and M ∞ 2 , respectively, and assume M ∞1 < M ∞ 2 . Given the distributions of C p 1 and C p 2 along an intersection between the plane Y = const . and surface Z = S ( X ,Y ) , we need to solve the following equations to recover C pinc and a n ( Y ) N
C p1 ≈ C pinc + M ∞2 1
¦ a ( Y )C n
n pinc
n =0 N
C p 2 ≈ C pinc + M ∞2 2
¦ a ( Y )C n
n pinc
.
(5.43)
n =0
An iteration scheme for solving Eq. (5.43) is described below. (1) Give the initial distribution C pinc( k ) = C p1 (k = 0) as a function of X along an intersection between Y = const . and Z = S ( X ,Y ) in the object space (a row or column in the image plane). Here, k is the iteration index number; (2) Determine the coefficients a n( k ) ( Y ) ( n = 0 ,1 N ) in the polynomial from a system of equations
( C p 2 − C pinc( k ) ) / M ∞2 2 =
N
n ¦ a n( k ) ( Y ) C pinc (k )
using
least-squares
n =0
method; (3) Substitute a n ( Y ) into C pinc( k +1 ) ≈ C p1 − M ∞2 1
N
n ¦ a n( k ) ( Y ) C pinc (k )
to
n =0
obtain the corrected value C pinc( k +1 ) ; (4) Go back to Step (2), replace C pinc( k ) by the corrected value
C pinc( k +1 )
and iterate until the converged results
110
5. Image and Data Analysis Techniques
C pinc = Lim C pinc( k ) and a n ( Y ) = Lim a n( k ) ( Y ) ( n = 0 ,1 N ) are obtained; (5) k →∞
k →∞
Output the final C pinc = C pinc [ X ,Y , S ( X ,Y )] and a n ( Y ) . After processing for a large set of intersections, we can recover the distribution of C pinc on the whole surface. Unlike the classical pressure-correction formulas for 2D flows, this iterative method is a non-local approach that has to be done along an intersection. The selection of the order N of the polynomial in Eq. (5.43) depends on the complexity of the Mach number effect on the pressure distribution along the intersection. For 2D flows and near-2D flows, N = 2 is sufficient; for more complex flows, the order of the polynomial could be higher. The number of available data points on an intersection eventually limits the order of the polynomial. For PSP, data processing is typically done in the image plane rather than in the object space. Therefore, for convenience, the pressure-correction method should be used in the image plane. The aforementioned analysis is made in an arbitrary object-space coordinate system ( X ,Y , Z ) or a general non-orthogonal curvilinear coordinate system on a surface. Since there is a one-to-one projection mapping between the image plane ( x , y ) and the surface Z = S ( X ,Y ) , the iterative pressure correction method can be directly applied to rows or columns in PSP images. There are limitation conditions for application of the iterative pressurecorrection method (actually for any pressure-correction method). First, the two Mach numbers M ∞1 and M ∞ 2 should be lower than the critical Mach number at which flow becomes sonic at certain point on a surface. Secondly, the pressurecorrection method relies on an assumption that the pressure distribution does not have a drastic change due to the Reynolds number effect as the Mach number increases from M ∞ = 0 to M ∞1 and M ∞ 2 . When the Reynolds number effect on pressure overwhelms the effect of the Mach number, the pressure-correction method cannot produce correct results because the flow pattern has been qualitatively changed. This situation may happen on a high-lift model under certain testing conditions in certain flow separation regions that are particularly sensitive to the Reynolds number effect. Fortunately, there is a large class of flows in which the Reynolds number does not significantly affect the surface pressure distribution, such as attached flows and certain separated flows whose separation and re-attachment lines are fixed. For these flows, the pressurecorrection method is applicable. The iterative pressure-correction method was validated for flows over a circular cylinder, sphere, prolate spheroid, transonic body and delta wing (Liu 2003). Figure 5.16 shows the incompressible C pinc distribution on a circular cylinder recovered by the iterative pressure-correction method along with the results obtained using the Prandtl-Glauert rule and Karman-Tsien rule. The iterative method produced excellent recovery of C pinc given by the incompressible solution of potential flow over a cylinder (Lighthill 1954). The Karman-Tsien rule also gave a good correction while the Prandtl-Glauert rule was not accurate in the low-
5.6. Pressure Correction for Extrapolation to Low-Speed Data
111
pressure region C p = [ −3,−2 ] . The iterative method used the C p distributions at
M ∞1 = 0.4 and M ∞ 2 = 0.6 . The order of polynomial was N = 2 and the solution for C pinc converged after 10 iterations. Both the Karman-Tsien rule and PrandtlGlauert rule used C p at M ∞ = 0.4 to recover C pinc . Figure 5.17 shows the pressure correction for a prolate spheroid of a fineness ratio of 6 at the angle of o attack of 5.6 and zero ellipsoidal coordinate (Matthews 1953). The iterative method used C p data at M ∞1 = 0.6 and M ∞ 2 = 0.8 . Even though these Mach numbers are quite high, the iterative method still produced good results since the Mach numbers were less than the critical Mach number of 0.904 in this case. To examine the capability of the iterative pressure-correction method for complex vortical separated flows, it was also used to recover C pinc on the upper surface of o
a 65 delta wing; the recovered C pinc distributions showed a correct trend as the Mach number increases. 2 Cpinc, Iterative method Cpinc, Karman-Tsien Cpinc, Prandtl-Glauert Incompressible solution
1
0
Cp
-1
-2
-3 Mach 0.4 -4
Mach 0.6
Cylinder
-5 0
1
2
3
theta (radian)
Fig. 5.16. Pressure correction for a circular cylinder to recover the incompressible pressure coefficient. From Liu (2003)
112
5. Image and Data Analysis Techniques 0.4
Prolate spheroid of fineness ratio 6
0.3
Cpinc, Iterative method Mach 0.0 Mach 0.6 Mach 0.8
Cp
0.2
0.1
AoA = 5.6 deg omega = 0 deg
0.0
-0.1
-0.2 0
10
20
30
40
50
Percent distance from nose
Fig. 5.17. Pressure correction for a prolate spheroid to recover the incompressible pressure coefficient. From Liu (2003)
5.7. Generation of Deformed Surface Grid For a more accurate representation of data, PSP and TSP results in images should be mapped onto a deformed surface grid of a model rather than a rigid surface grid when the model undergoes a large deformation in wind tunnel tests. Aeroelastic deformation data for a model can be obtained using videogrammetric model deformation (VMD) measurement technique (Burner and Liu 2001). Hence, PSP and TSP systems should be integrated with a VMD system for fusion of pressure and temperature data with deformation data (Bell and Burner 1998; Liu et al. 1999). There are two approaches for integration of PSP/TSP with VMD. The first approach uses PSP/TSP simultaneously with VMD as a separate and independent system, while VMD, that is operated under the PSP/TSP lighting and surface conditions, provides deformation data for generating a deformed surface grid. The advantage of this approach is that the structure of a PSP/TSP system is not changed and PSP/TSP operation suffers no interference from VMD operation in large production wind tunnels. In contrast, the second approach uses the same camera for both PSP/TSP and VMD measurements at the same time; VMD software is integrated as an additional part of the PSP/TSP software package. Instead of a nearly normal view of a camera for pure PSP/TSP application, the combined system requires an oblique viewing angle of a camera to achieve good position sensitivity for VMD measurements. Usually, VMD gives wing deformation characterized by the twist and bending of a wing. When the local translation and twist are measured by VMD at different spanwise locations of a wing, a transformation of translation and rotation can be used to generate a deformed surface grid of the wing. At a spanwise location Y,
5.7. Generation of Deformed Surface Grid
113
the deformed coordinate ( X ' ,Y ' , Z' ) on a wing surface grid is locally related to the non-deformed grid coordinate ( X ,Y , Z ) by
§ X' · § X · § T ( Y )· ¸ ¨ ¸ = R( Y )¨ ¸ + ¨ x ¨ Z' ¸ ¨ Z ¸ ¨ T ( Y )¸ . © ¹ © ¹ © z ¹
(5.44)
The translation vector at a spanwise location Y of the wing is (Tx , Tz ) and the rotational matrix is sin ștwist · § cos ștwist ¸, (5.45) R(Y) = ¨¨ ¸ © − sin ș twist cos ș twist ¹ where the twist ș twist is a function of the spanwise location Y. When the bending relative to the wingspan is small, the spanwise location does not change much, i.e., Y ' ≈ Y , and the wing airfoil section remains the same. For illustration, we consider a fictional wing with a NACA0012 airfoil section and assume that the spanwise distributions of twist and bending are given by ștwist = − 5(Y/b)3 ,
Tz = 0.08 b (Y/b)3 and Tx = 0 , where b is the semi-span of the wing. Figure 5.18 shows a deformed surface grid generated using a transformation of translation and rotation.
Fig. 5.18. Generation of a deformed surface grid of a wing based on videogrammetric deformation measurements. From Liu et al. (1999)
6. Lifetime-Based Methods
Compared with the widely used intensity-based method, the greatest advantage of the lifetime-based method is that a relation between the luminescent lifetime and pressure is not dependent on the illumination intensity. Therefore, the problem associated with non-uniform illumination in the intensity-based method becomes essentially irrelevant to the lifetime method. Theoretically speaking, lifetime measurement is also insensitive to luminophore concentration, paint thickness, photodegradation and paint contamination; thus a wind-off reference intensity image (or signal) is not required and the troubles associated with model deformation do not exist. The lifetime method for PSP and TSP can be applied to both a laser scanning system and an imaging system. Davies et al. (1995) developed a pulsed laser scanning system to directly determine the luminescent lifetime and used it to measure the pressure distributions on a cylinder in subsonic flows and on a wedge at Mach 2. Torgerson et al. (1996) developed a portable, modulated, two-dimensional laser scanning system that can simultaneously measure both the luminescent intensity and phase angle; this system was used to measure the surface pressure distributions in a low-speed impinging jet and on an airfoil in transonic flow. The system was further refined by Lachendro et al. (1998) and used to measure the pressure distributions on a wing of a Beechjet in flight tests. A fluorescent lifetime imaging (FLIM) system for PSP and TSP has become promising as solid-state imaging technology makes a rapid advance. The FLIM system, originally proposed by biochemists for oxygen detection in a small area (Szmacinski and Lakowicz 1995; Hartmann and Ziegler 1996), was used for PSP measurements in wind tunnels at DERA (Holmes 1998). DERA’s FLIM system comprised a phase-sensitive camera, modulated blue LED array, associated control hardware and computer. This Chapter discusses the response of the luminescent emission to a time-varying excitation light and describes the luminescent lifetime measurement techniques, including the pulse method, phase method, amplitude demodulation method and gated intensity ratio method. Although the discussion is focused on PSP, these techniques are generally applicable to TSP as well. Measurement uncertainty of the lifetime methods is discussed in Chapter 7. Similar analyses of the lifetime-based techniques were given by Goss et al. (2000) and Bell (2001).
116
6. Lifetime-Based Methods
6.1. Response of Luminescence to Time-Varying Excitation Light
6.1.1. First-Order Model The lifetime method for PSP and TSP is based on the response of luminescence to a time-varying excitation light. The response of the luminescent emission I from a paint to an excitation light E(t) can be described as a first-order system
dI / d t = − I / IJ + E( t) , where IJ is the luminescent lifetime. solution to Eq. (6.1) is
I (t) =
³
t 0
(6.1)
With the initial condition I(0) = 0 , a
exp[ − ( t − u ) / IJ ] E( u ) du .
(6.2)
For a pulse light E(t) = Am į(t) , the luminescent response is simply an exponential decay I (t) = Am exp( − t / IJ ) . (6.3) We consider a general periodic excitation light that is expressed as a Fourier series
§a E(t) = Am ¨ 0 + ¨ 2 ©
∞
¦[a n =1
n
· cos(n Ȧt ) + bn sin(n Ȧ t ) ] ¸ , ¸ ¹
(6.4)
where Ȧ = 2ʌ f is the circular frequency of the excitation light. Substitution of Eq. (6.4) into Eq. (6.2) yields the luminescent response after a short transient process ∞ § a a n cos(n Ȧt − ijn ) + bn sin(n Ȧ t − ijn ) ·¸ I (t) = Am IJ ¨¨ 0 + (6.5) ¸¸ . 2 2 2 ¨ 2 + n =1 1 n Ȧ IJ © ¹
¦
Here, the phase angles ijn are related to the luminescent lifetime by
tan ijn = n Ȧ IJ .
(6.6)
In the simplest case where the sinusoidally modulated excitation light is E(t) = Am [ 1 + H sin( Ȧ t )] , the luminescent response Eq. (6.5) is reduced to
I (t) = Am IJ [ 1 + H M eff sin(Ȧt − ij) ] ,
(6.7)
6.1. Response of Luminescence to Time-Varying Excitation Light
117
where M eff = (1 + IJ 2 Ȧ 2 ) −1 / 2 is the effective amplitude modulation index, Am is the amplitude, and H is the modulation depth. The phase angle ij is related to the luminescent lifetime simply by
tan ij = Ȧ IJ .
(6.8)
Other waveforms of the excitation light include square and triangle. Figure 6.1 shows the luminescent response to typical periodic excitations with the square, sine and triangle waveforms for the non-dimensional lifetime of Ȧ IJ = ʌ /10 . 2 .5
E x c ita tio n L ig h t
Intensity
2 .0
L u m in e s c e n c e
1 .5
1 .0
0 .5
0 .0 0
2
4
6
8
10
12
10
12
10
12
ω t (ra d ia n )
(a) Square waveform 4 .0
E x c ita tio n L ig h t
3 .5
L u m in e s c e n c e
Intensity
3 .0 2 .5 2 .0 1 .5 1 .0 0 .5 0
2
4
6
8
ω t ( r a d ia n )
(b) Sine waveform 5
E x c ita tio n L ig h t
Intensity
4
L u m in e s c e n c e
3
2
1
0
0
2
4
6
8
ω t (ra d ia n )
(c) Triangle waveform Fig. 6.1. Response of luminescence to time-varying excitations of the square, sine and triangle waveforms for Ȧ IJ = ʌ /10
118
6. Lifetime-Based Methods
6.1.2. Higher-Order Model In a micro-heterogeneous polymer matrix, the multiple-exponential luminescent emission decay can be observed in contrast to the single-exponential decay in a homogeneous medium (Carraway et al. 1991a; Sacksteder et al. 1993; Xu et al. 1994). This is associated with the fact that the host matrix has domains that vary with respect to their interaction with the luminescent probe molecules; as a result, the excited molecules decay at different rates, depending on their environments. Consider a paint system consisting of a number of independently emitting species with different single-exponential lifetimes IJ i ( i = 1, 2, 3, ) and relative contributions. The multiple-exponential luminescent decay is described as I (t) = Į i exp( − t / IJ i ) , (6.9)
¦
where Į i is the weighting constant for the ith component. The luminescent lifetime of each component obeys the Stern-Volmer relation IJ 0 i / IJ i = 1 + K SV i p , (6.10) where K SV i is the Stern-Volmer coefficient for the ith component. Hence, a higher-order model is needed to describe the luminescent response of an inhomogeneous PSP to a time-varying excitation light. We consider a third-order model a 0 d 3 I / dt 3 + a 1 d 2 I / dt 2 + a 2 dI / dt + a 3 I = E( t ) . (6.11) With the initial conditions I ( 0 ) = I' ( 0 ) = I' ' ( 0 ) = 0 , a solution for (6.11) is
I (t) =
³
3
t
E( u ) 0
¦ Į exp[ − ( t − u ) / IJ i
i
] du .
(6.12)
i =1
The lifetimes IJ i are related to the weighting constants Į i through the roots of the characteristic equation a 0 s 3 + a 1 s 2 + a 2 s + a 3 = 0 . The weighted mean lifetime is usually expressed as < IJ > = ¦ Į i IJ i / ¦ Į i . A general model for the nonexponential decay of luminescence was discussed by Ruyten (2004) and Ruyten and Sellers (2004) considering the continuous decay rate spectrum and excitation response function.
6.2. Lifetime Measurement Techniques
6.2.1. Pulse Method Our goal is to measure the luminescent lifetime and to determine air pressure through the Stern-Volmer relation. A variety of methods can be used to extract the lifetime from the luminescent response to a time-varying excitation light. The pulse method is the most direct method widely used in photochemistry (Lakowicz
6.2. Lifetime Measurement Techniques
119
1991, 1999). After PSP is excited by a pulsed illumination light, the luminescent decay is measured using a fast-responding photodetector and acquired using a PC or an oscilloscope. The lifetime is calculated by fitting the time-resolved data with a single exponential function or a multiple-exponential function. This direct time-domain approach was used by Davies et al. (1995) for lifetime measurements of PSP. For certain PSP with multiple distinct lifetimes, the pulse method allows simultaneous determination of pressure and temperature if the lifetimes have sufficiently different Stern-Volmer coefficients as a function of temperature. In this case, given the lifetimes ( IJ i ), a system of equations for pressure and temperature are IJ i ref p = Ai ( T ) + Bi ( T ) , ( i = 1, 2, N , N ≥ 2 ) (6.13) IJi p ref In principle, unknown pressure and temperature can be simultaneously determined by solving Eq. (6.13). 6.2.2. Phase Method The phase method is a frequency-domain technique that detects a phase shift of the luminescent signal with respect to the modulated excitation light (Torgerson et al. 1996; Torgerson 1997). Figure 6.2 shows the working principle of the phase method with a lock-in amplifier. For the sinusoidal excitation light E(t) = Am [ 1 + H sin( Ȧ t )] , the corresponding modulated luminescent signal from a photodetector is mixed with the in-phase and quadrature reference signals, i.e., sin( Ȧ t ) and cos( Ȧ t ) . Next, the use of a low-pass filter generates the DC components Vc = − Am IJ H M eff sin (ij ) and Vs = Am IJ H M eff cos (ij ) , which are related to the phase angle ij between the luminescent emission and excitation light. A ratio between these filtered signals yields a quantity tan ij = Ȧ IJ = − Vc / Vs that is uniquely related to the lifetime for a fixed modulation frequency. Therefore, pressure is given by § · −1 ¨ Ȧ IJ 0 ¸ p = K SV (6.14) ¨ tan ij − 1¸ . © ¹ The sensitivity of the phase angle ij to pressure is defined as dϕ ∂τ ω Sp = . (6.15) = 2 dp 1 + ( ωτ ) ∂p The optimal modulation frequency to achieve the maximum sensitivity S p is (6.16) ȦIJ = 1 . It must be noted that the maximum sensitivity to pressure does not tell the whole story if the noise is not taken into account. Besides good sensitivity to pressure, the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) should be also considered in order to select the optimal modulation frequency. At a higher frequency, the modulation amplitude
120
6. Lifetime-Based Methods
and DC components from PSP decrease, resulting in a lower SNR. Figure 6.3 is a Bode plot showing the response of a typical PSP, PtTFPP in polymer/ceramic composite, to the modulation frequency; the behavior of this PSP is very close to the first-order system. E(t) = A m [ 1 + H sin( Ȧ t )]
PSP
I (t) = A m IJ [ 1 + H M
cos( Ȧt)
Mixer
eff
sin( Ȧ t − ij) ]
Low-Pass Filter
V c = − Am IJ H M
sin( Ȧt)
Mixer
Low-Pass Filter
eff
sin( ij )
V s = Am IJ H M
eff
cos( ij )
Divider
tan( ij ) = Ȧ IJ = − V c / V s
Fig. 6.2. Block diagram of the phase method
3 0 -3 -6 -9 0.07psi 2.32psi 5.37psi 8.49psi 11.42psi 14.68psi
dB
-12 -15 -18 -21
3rd Order Fit
-24 -27 -30 -33 102
103
104
105
Freqeuncy(Hz)
Fig. 6.3. The Bode plot of PSP (PtTFPP in polymer/ceramic composite) at –30°C. From Lachendro (2000)
6.2. Lifetime Measurement Techniques
121
6.2.3. Amplitude Demodulation Method The amplitude demodulation method was used for fluorescent lifetime measurements of tagged biological specimens in a flow cytometer (Deka et al. 1994). For the sinusoidally modulated excitation light, the luminescent response is given by Eq. (6.7) and the effective amplitude modulation index is M eff = (1 + IJ 2 Ȧ 2 ) −1 / 2 . Clearly, for a fixed modulation frequency, the lifetime can be obtained from measurement of the effective modulation index. Combination of the Stern-Volmer relation Eq. (6.10) with M eff = (1 + IJ 2 Ȧ 2 ) −1 / 2 yields an expression for pressure as a function of the effective amplitude modulation index M eff
§ · ¸ 1 ¨ Ȧ IJ 0 M eff p= −1¸ . (6.17) ¨ 2 K SV ¨ 1 − M ¸ eff © ¹ To measure the effective amplitude modulation index M eff , Deka et al. (1994) used the following expression I ( t ) − I min ( t min ) , (5.18) M eff = H −1 max max I max ( t max ) + I min ( t min ) where t max and t min were the times at which the modulated oscillating luminescent signal went through the maximum intensity I max ( t max ) and minimum intensity
I min ( t min ) , respectively. Here, as illustrated in Fig. 6.4, a simpler scheme is proposed to determine M eff by calculating the time-averaged quantities of the modulated luminescent signal. Define the time-averaged oscillating luminescent signal 1 T < I > = Lim I ( t ) dt . (6.19) T →∞ 2T −T The mean and standard deviation of the luminescent intensity I(t) are
³
< I > = Am IJ and std ( I ) = < ( I − < I > )2 > 1 / 2 = Am IJ H M eff / 2 . Therefore, taking a ratio between these quantities, we obtain a simple formula for the effective amplitude modulation index M eff = (1 + IJ 2 Ȧ 2 ) −1 / 2 std ( I ) < E > std ( I ) . (6.20) = std ( E ) < I > It is emphasized that Eq. (6.20) is valid only for the sinusoidally modulated excitation light E(t) = Am [ 1 + H sin( Ȧ t )] . Instrumentation for utilizing this methodology is particularly simple since only the mean and standard deviation of the sinusoidal luminescent intensity and excitation light intensity are required. The optimal modulation frequency can be obtained by maximizing the sensitivity of M eff to pressure M eff = 2 H −1
122
6. Lifetime-Based Methods
2 Ȧ2 IJ ∂τ . 2 2 3/2 dp (1 + Ȧ IJ ) ∂p The optimal modulation frequency for the maximum sensitivity is Sp =
d ( M eff )
=
(6.21)
(Ȧ IJ)op = ( 1 + 7 ) / 3 ≈ 1.215 .
(6.22)
For a typical PSP, Ru(dpp) in GE RTV 118, having the lifetime IJ = 4.7 µs at the ambient conditions, the optimal modulation frequency is 41 kHz. Figure 6.5 shows the effective amplitude modulation index M eff as a function of the relative pressure p/p ref at different sinusoidal modulation frequencies for this PSP having Clearly, the selection of the the lifetime IJ = IJ ref / ( 0.17 + 0.84 p/p ref ) . modulation frequency affects the performance of the system.
E(t) = A m [ 1 + H sin( Ȧ t )]
PSP
I (t) = A m IJ [ 1 + H M eff sin( Ȧ t − ij) ]
std ( I ) = 2 A m IJ H M eff
< I > = Am IJ
Divider
M eff = ( 1 + IJ 2 Ȧ 2 )−1 / 2 =
2 H −1 std ( I ) / < I >
Fig. 6.4. Block diagram of the amplitude demodulation method
6.2. Lifetime Measurement Techniques
123
1.2
Modulation frequency = 5 kHz 1.0
24 kHz
Meff
0.8
0.6
50 kHz
0.4
100 kHz
0.2
0.0 0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
P/Pref
Fig. 6.5. The effective amplitude modulation index M eff as a function of relative pressure o
at different sinusoidal modulation frequencies for Ru(dpp) in GE RTV 118 for T = 20 C and pref = 1 atm
6.2.4. Gated Intensity Ratio Method The gated intensity ratio method, as illustrated in Fig. 6.6, gates the modulated luminescent signal by applying two gain functions over two different intervals, i.e.,
I1 =
³
I ( t ) G1 ( t ) dt and I 2 =
∆ T1
³
I ( t ) G 2 ( t ) dt ,
∆ T2
(6.23)
where the gain functions G1 ( t ) and G2 ( t ) are certain time-varying functions. A ratio between the gated intensity integrals, I 2 / I 1 , is a function of the luminescent lifetime for given modulation parameters. In the simplest case, the gain function is a top-hat function or a square function where G1 ( t ) = G2 ( t ) = 1 in the time intervals ǻ T1 and ǻ T2 and G1 ( t ) = G2 ( t ) = 0 elsewhere.
In this case, the
square waveform of G1 ( t ) and G2 ( t ) serves as an ‘on-off’ gating function. The functional form for the excitation light and gain function can be selected to meet the requirements for a specific test. Common combinations are a pulse excitation with a square gain function (pulse-square), a sine-waveform excitation with a square gain function (sine-square), a square-waveform excitation with a square gain function (square-square), and a sine-waveform excitation with a sinewaveform gain function (sine-sine) (Goss et al. 2000).
124
6. Lifetime-Based Methods
E(t, r )
PSP
I (t, r )
I2 =
³
∆ T2
I1 =
I ( t , r ) G 2 ( t ) dt
³
∆ T1
I ( t , r ) G 1 ( t ) dt
Divider
I 2 /I 1 = F ( IJ )
Fig. 6.6. Block diagram of the gated intensity method
The modulated luminescent intensity is integrated over a gate time interval from 0 to 1/2f (0 to π in Ȧ t ) and over a gate time interval from 1/2f to 1/f (π to
2π in Ȧ t ) relative to a modulated excitation light. For the Fourier-series-form of the modulated excitation light Eq. (6.4), a ratio between the two integrals is I 2 /I 1 =
³
1/f
³
I dt 1/2f
1/2f 0
Idt =
ʌ − D( ωτ ) , ʌ + D( ωτ )
(6.24)
where
D(Ȧ IJ) =
2 a0
∞
[1 + ( −1) n +1 ] (a n n Ȧ IJ + bn ) n( 1 + n 2Ȧ2 IJ 2 )
¦ n =1
.
Obviously, the ratio I 2 / I 1 is only a function of the non-dimensional lifetime Ȧ IJ and therefore is related to pressure when the modulation frequency is fixed. In particular, the gated intensity ratio for the sinusoidally modulated excitation light E(t) = Am [ 1 + H sin( Ȧ t )] has a simple form
I 2 /I 1 =
³
1/f
I dt 1/2f
³
1/2f 0
Idt =
ʌ (1 + Ȧ 2 IJ 2 ) − 2 H ʌ (1 + Ȧ 2 IJ 2 ) + 2 H
.
(6.25)
6.2. Lifetime Measurement Techniques
125
Figure 6.7 shows the gated intensity ratio I 2 / I 1 as a function of the nondimensional lifetime Ȧ IJ for the excitation light with the square, triangle, sine and cosine waveforms. Although the lifetime is always positive, Figure 6.7 plots the ratio I 2 / I 1 over a range of −6 ≤ Ȧ IJ ≤ 6 to exhibit the global behavior of I 2 / I 1 as a function of Ȧ IJ . The behavior of I 2 / I 1 depends on the waveform of the modulated excitation light. Figure 6.8 shows the gated intensity ratio I 2 / I 1 as a function of the relative pressure p/p ref at different modulation frequencies for a typical PSP, Ru(dpp) in GE RTV 118, when the sinusoidal excitation light has the modulation depth of H = 1.
2.4
triangle wave 2.0
cosine wave sine wave
I2/I1
1.6
1.2
0.8
0.4
square wave 0.0 -6
-5
-4
-3
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
ωτ (radian)
Fig. 6.7. The gated intensity ratio as a function of the non-dimensional luminescent lifetime
1.2 Modulation frequency = 200 kHz
1.0
100 kHz
I2/I1
0.8
0.6
50 kHz
0.4
25 kHz
0.2
5 kHz
0.0 0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
P/Pref
Fig. 6.8. The gated intensity ratio as a function of pressure at different modulation o frequencies for Ru(dpp) in GE RTV 118 (T = 20 C and Pref = 1 atm) when the modulated excitation is sinusoidal
126
6. Lifetime-Based Methods
For the sinusoidal excitation light, the non-dimensional modulation frequency and modulation depth can be selected to achieve the greatest sensitivity of the gated intensity ratio to pressure defined as
Sp =
d ( I 2 /I 1 ) 8ʌ Ȧ 2 IJ H ∂τ = dp [ʌ (1 + Ȧ 2 IJ 2 ) + 2 H] 2 ∂p
.
(6.26)
The optimal modulation frequency for the maximum sensitivity is
(Ȧ IJ)op =
3 ≈ 1.732 .
(6.27)
For Ru(dpp) in GE RTV 118 that has the lifetime of 4.7 µs at the ambient conditions, the optimal modulation frequency is 59 kHz. The appropriate modulation depth H can also be selected according to certain criteria for a balance between the pressure sensitivity and SNR. It is noted that the off-phase intensity I 2 = ( Am IJ / 2 f )[ 1 − ( 2 H / ʌ )(1 + Ȧ 2 IJ 2 )−1 ] decreases as H increases and the normalized off-phase intensity at the optimal modulation frequency is I 2 /(I 2 )H =0 = 1 − H / 2ʌ . Since the SNR is proportional to
[ I 2 /(I 2 )H =0 ] 1 / 2 = ( 1 − H / 2π )1 / 2 , the SNR is a decreasing function of H in a range of 0 ≤ H ≤ 1 . On the other hand, the normalized sensitivity S p at the optimal modulation frequency, which is proportional to H / ( 2π + H ) 2 , is an increasing function of H in a range of 0 ≤ H ≤ 1 . Therefore, the appropriate modulation depth H of about 0.5 is chosen to achieve both a high SNR and good pressure sensitivity. The gated intensity integrals I1 and I2 are taken over the intervals from 0 to 1/2f (0 to π in Ȧ t ) and 1/2f to 1/f (π to 2π in Ȧ t ). The time variable t in these integrals is relative to the modulated excitation light. The integration is carried out immediately after the measurement system receives a trigger signal that is synchronized with the modulated excitation light. The trigger signal can be provided by a photodiode sensing the excitation light or a driver for the modulator. In practice, however, the trigger signal may have a time delay relative to the excitation light. The time delay, although small, may significantly alter the relation between I 2 / I 1 and pressure especially when the modulation frequency is high. For the sinusoidally modulated excitation light E(t) = Am [ 1 + H sin( Ȧ t )] , if the trigger signal has a time delay ǻt , the gated intensity ratio is
I 2 /I 1 =
³
1/f + ǻt 1/2f + ǻt
I dt
³
1/2f + ǻt ǻt
Idt =
ʌ − 2 H cos(ij ) cos( ij − Ȧ ǻt) ʌ + 2 H cos(ij ) cos( ij − Ȧ ǻt)
,
(6.28)
where cos( ij) = 1 / 1 + ( Ȧ IJ)2 . For a typical PSP, Ru(dpp) in GE RTV 118, Figure 6.9 shows the relation between I 2 / I 1 and p/p ref for different phase shifts Ȧ ǻt , where the sinusoidal modulation frequency is 25 kHz and the modulation depth is H = 1. It is clear that the behavior of the relation is significantly affected
6.2. Lifetime Measurement Techniques
127
by the phase shifts Ȧ ǻt and the curve is even no longer monotonous when the phase shift is large. The similar change also occurs for the excitation light having other waveforms like the square waveform. This change due to the trigger signal delay was observed in experiments. 0.9 ω∆t = π/2
0.8 0.7
I2/I1
0.6 0.5 π/3 0.4 π/4 0.3
0
0.2 0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
P/Pref
Fig. 6.9. The gated intensity ratio I 2 / I 1 as a function of p/p ref at different phase shifts
Ȧ ǻt for Ru(dpp) in GE RTV 118 (T = 20oC and Pref = 1 atm), where the sinusoidal modulation frequency is 25 kHz and the modulation depth H is one
Furthermore, the gated intensity ratio method can be applied to the pulse excitation light; in this case, the luminescent intensity signal is I (t) = Am exp( − t / IJ ) . For two gating intervals [ t 0 , t 1 ] and [ t 2 , t 3 ] where
t 3 > t 2 > t 1 > t 0 is assumed, the gated intensity ratio is I 2 /I 1 =
³
t3 t2
I dt
³
t1 t0
Idt =
exp( − t 3 / IJ ) − exp( − t 2 / IJ ) . exp( − t 1 / IJ ) − exp( − t 0 / IJ )
(6.29)
For the given gating intervals, the ratio I 2 / I 1 is only related to the lifetime. This integration approach was used as an alternative to the time-resolved pulse approach, which was called the time-resolved multiple-gate method by Goss et al. (2000). Bell (2001) discussed an optimization problem of the gating parameters ( t 0 , t1 , t 2 , t 3 ) to achieve the maximum sensitivity in an ICCD camera system. In a limiting but representative case where the time t g divides the two gating intervals [ 0 , t g ] and [ t g , ∞ ] ( t 0 = 0 , t 3 → ∞ , t 1 = t 2 = t g ), we have
I 2 /I 1 =
exp( − t g / IJ ) 1 − exp( − t g / IJ )
.
(6.30)
128
6. Lifetime-Based Methods
Although the above methods utilize two gating intervals, three gating intervals can be similarly used and therefore two gated intensity ratios like I 1 / I 2 and I 1 / I 3 can be obtained. If the two gated intensity ratios have sufficiently different dependencies to pressure and temperature for certain PSP, the surface pressure and temperature distributions can be determined simultaneously from the gated intensity ratio images.
6.3. Fluorescence Lifetime Imaging
6.3.1. Intensified CCD Camera The structure of an intensified CCD (ICCD) system is illustrated in Fig. 6.10. After being impacted by a photon, the photocathode creates photoelectrons that are amplified by the micro channel plate (MCP); the amplified electrons are converted back into photons by a phosphor screen. These photons are relayed to a CCD by either a fiber-optic bundle or a relay lens; the CCD creates the photoelectrons that are measured. The biggest advantage of ICCD is its ability of gating that allows the luminescent lifetime imaging over a painted area. Electronic shutter action can be produced by pulsing the MCP voltage and the gain can be modulated by simply changing the voltage on the intensifier. Figure 6.11 illustrates the luminescent lifetime imaging method with an ICCD. Photo Cathode
Micro Channel Plate
A
Phosphor Screen
Fiber-Optic Taper
CCD
A
A
Fig. 6.10. Structure of ICCD and multiple photon-electron conversions in ICCD
< I > =
I (t, r )
Image Intensifier
I(t, r ) G (t)
1 T
INT
³
T INT
I ( t , r ) G ( t ) dt
0
CCD
G (t)
Fig. 6.11. Diagram of lifetime imaging with ICCD for modulated illumination
6.3. Fluorescence Lifetime Imaging
129
For the pulse excitation light, the gain function is typically a top-hat function or a square function. The luminescent signal is gated in two different intervals during an exponential decay of luminescence and the gated intensity ratio is related to the luminescent lifetime by Eq. (6.29). This approach was employed for PSP measurements by Goss et al. (2000), Bencic (2001), Bell (2001), Baker (2001), and Mitsuo et al. (2002). Another approach uses the sinusoidal excitation light combined with either the square gain function (Holmes 1998) or sinusoidal gain function (Lakowicz and Berndt 1991). Consider the sinusoidally modulated excitation light E(t) = Am [ 1 + H sin( Ȧ t )] and the corresponding luminescent signal from PSP is I (t) = Am IJ [ 1 + H M eff sin(Ȧt − ij) ] , where the effective amplitude modulation index is M eff = (1 + IJ 2 Ȧ 2 ) −1 / 2 = cos( ij ) . When the gain function has a square-waveform, the gated intensity ratio is given by Eq. (6.25). Instead of using the square function, Lakowicz and Berndt (1991) adopted the sinusoidal gain function for modulating the intensifier. When the MCP is sinusoidally modulated, the gain function of the detector is G(t) = G0 [ 1 + m D sin(Ȧt − ș D ) ] , where G0 is the intensifier gain without applying a modulating signal, m D is the gain modulation depth, and ș D is the detector phase angle relative to the modulated illumination light. The CCD collecting photons over an integration time actually serves as an integrator; thus, the signal output from the CCD is represented by a time-averaged intensity over an integration time TINT
=
1 TINT
³
TINT 0
I ( t , r ) G( t ) dt = Am IJ G0 [ 1 + 0.5 M eff m D cos( ij − ș D ) ] . (6.31)
To extract the phase angle or lifetime from the CCD output < I > , several values of < I > are obtained by changing the detector phase angle ș D . Therefore, a system of equations is given for eliminating Am and G0 . These equations can be solved using least-squares method to determine the phase angle ij that is related to the luminescent lifetime τ. In the simplest case where only two different detector phase angles ș D1 and ș D2 are chosen, a ratio between the two timeaveraged intensities at ș D1 and ș D2 is
< I > ( șD 2 ) / < I > ( șD1 ) =
1 + 0.5 m D cos( ij ) cos( ij − ș D 2 ) . 1 + 0.5 mD cos( ij ) cos( ij − ș D 1 )
(6.32)
Once the parameters m D , ș D1 , and ș D2 are given, the ratio in Eq. (6.32) is only related to the phase angle ij . Lakowicz and Berndt (1991) used three different detector phase angles to recover the luminescent lifetime. One shortcoming of the intensifier CCD camera is that the SNR may be reduced due to quantum losses and additive noise in the multiple-step photon-electron transfer processes.
130
6. Lifetime-Based Methods
6.3.2. Internally Gated CCD Camera An internally gated CCD camera is promising for luminescent lifetime imaging. Fisher et al. (1999) developed a phase-sensitive CCD camera system for twodimensional imaging of concentrations of radical species in reacting flows such as turbulent flames. They modified a commercial scientific-grade CCD camera to perform phase-sensitive imaging as well as to reduce the level of integrated background light. In fact, this internally gated CCD camera has the capability to selectively integrate the time-varying luminescent intensity either in-phase or outof-phase with respect to the modulated excitation light. A ratio between the outof-phase and in-phase images is related to the luminescent lifetime, and thus a pressure field can be obtained from a luminescent lifetime image. Modern CCD cameras available for industrial machine vision or scientific uses possess many of the features required to construct a phase-sensitive imaging system. Most notably, the feature commonly referred to as ‘electronic shuttering’ can be suitably modified to serve phase sensitive imaging or lifetime imaging. The CCD array architecture employed by cameras capable of performing electronic shuttering is referred to as an interline transfer array shown in Fig. 6.12. It consists of photodiodes separated by vertical transfer registers that are covered by an opaque metal shield that prevents direct entry of photoelectrons. Charge accumulated in the photosensors can be transferred either to the vertical registers or discarded in the substrate by supplying a high voltage to the Read Out Gate (ROG) or the Over Flow Drain (OFD) respectively. In order to perform phase-sensitive imaging, charge shifting and storage in the CCD must be synchronized with the light-source modulation signal. This requires appropriate modification of the camera controller logic, and of the camera head circuitry and logic. Based on the modulation waveform, a suitable control signal will be generated, which raises the ROG voltage and lowers the OFD voltage during the in-phase half of the cycle. The in-phase luminescent signal is thus integrated into the vertical register. In the out-of-phase half of the modulation cycle, the ROG and OFD voltages are reversed, thus dumping the out-of-phase light into the substrate. This process is repeated for a number of cycles until the full-well capacity of the vertical registers is utilized to maximize the SNR. Finally, after the desired integration time (or the number of cycles) the accumulated charge in the vertical registers can be read out through the horizontal register using conventional frame transfer techniques. The out-of-phase image o can be similarly obtained, the only difference being the introduction of a 180 phase lag between the modulation signal and the control signal described above. As pointed out before, a ratio between the out-of-phase and in-phase intensity images, I 2 /I 1 , is a function of the phase angle or the luminescent lifetime; therefore, a pressure field can be obtained from the luminescent lifetime image.
6.4. Lifetime Experiments
131
Fig. 6.12. Interline transfer CCD architecture and charge flow
6.4. Lifetime Experiments Lachendro (2000) used a set-up shown in Fig. A2 in Appendix A for phase calibration of PSP and TSP formulations at temperatures lower than –30°C, which was capable of holding pressures down to 0.03 psi. In order to make phase calibrations, LED arrays were used as a modulated excitation source; a blue LED array was used for Ruthenium-based complexes and a green LED array for Porphyrin-based luminophores. Each array consisted of seven LEDs arranged in a hexagonal formation for more uniform illumination. The light from an LED array was passed through an appropriate interference filter to eliminate unwanted emission. A function generator was used to directly power and modulate the arrays; the TTL signal from the function generator was used as an external reference for a lock-in amplifier. After passing through a focusing lens, the luminescent response of PSP (or TSP) was detected using a PMT fitted with an interference filter centered at 620 nm and then was sampled by the lock-in amplifier. A PC was used to acquire calibration data from the lock-in amplifier. Figures 6.13-6.15 show phase calibration results for three PSP formulations: Ru(dpp) in a silicone polymer with silica gel, PtTFPP in a silicone polymer with silica gel, and PtTFPP in a porous polymer/ceramic(Al2O3) composite tape casting. Figures 6.16-6.18 show phase calibration results for three TSP formulations: PtTFPP, Ru(trpy)(C6F5-trpy)(NO3)2, and Ru(bipy)2(p-bipy)2 in DuPont ChromaClear.
132
6. Lifetime-Based Methods
0 -5
Phase Shift (Degrees)
-10 -15 -20
-30οC -20οC -15οC -10οC -5οC 0οC 10οC 20οC 3rd Order
-25 -30 -35 -40 -45 -50 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10 11
12 13
14
15
Pressure (psia)
Fig. 6.13. Phase calibration for PSP, Ru(dpp) in RTV 110 with Silica Gel. Lachendro (2000)
From
0 -2
Phase Shift (Degrees)
-4 -6 -8 -10
-30οC -18οC -3οC 10οC 20οC 5th Order Fit
-12 -14 -16 -18 -20 -22 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10 11
12
13 14 15
Pressure(psia)
Fig. 6.14. Phase calibration for PSP, PtTFPP in RTV 110 with Silica Gel. From Lachendro (2000)
6.4. Lifetime Experiments
4
-50οC -45οC -40οC -35οC -30οC -25οC -20οC ο -15 C -10οC -5οC 0οC 5οC 10οC 15οC 20οC 25οC
0 -4 Phase Shift (Degrees)
133
-8 -12 -16 -20 -24 -28 -32 -36 -40 -44 0
1
2
3
4
5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Pressure (psia)
Fig. 6.15. Phase calibrations for PSP, PtTFPP in a porous polymer/ceramic(Al2O3) composite tape casting. From Lachendro (2000)
0 -1 Phase Shift (degrees)
-2 -3 -4 -5 -6 -7 -8 -9 -10 -50 -45 -40 -35 -30 -25 -20 -15 -10 -5 Temperature (οC)
0
5
10 15 20
Fig. 6.16. Phase calibration for TSP, PtTFPP in DuPont ChromaClear. From Lachendro (2000)
134
6. Lifetime-Based Methods 0 -2 Phase Shift (degrees)
-4 -6 -8 -10 -12 -14 -16 -18 -20 -50 -45 -40 -35 -30 -25 -20 -15 -10 -5
0
5
10 15 20
ο
Temperature ( C)
Fig. 6.17. Phase calibration for TSP, Ru(trpy)(C6F5-trpy)(NO3)2 in DuPont ChromaClear. From Lachendro (2000)
2 0 Phase Shift (degrees)
-2 -4 -6 -8 -10 -12 -14 -16 -18 -50 -45 -40 -35 -30 -25 -20 -15 -10 -5
0
5 10 15 20 25
Temperature (oC)
Fig. 6.18. Phase calibration for TSP, Ru(bipy)2(p-bipy)2 in DuPont ChromaClear. From Lachendro (2000)
Goss et al. (2000) evaluated the lifetime techniques based on several different modulation/gating combinations such as the time-resolved multiple-gate method for the pulse excitation, sine-square method, and square-square method. The detectors used were ICCD, phase-sensitive interline-transfer CCD, and back-lit CCD with a liquid-crystal shutter. A xenon strobe light and a Nd:YAG laser were
6.4. Lifetime Experiments
135
used as a pulse light source, while a LED array was used for the sinusoidal and square-wave excitation. PSP tested was PtTFPP in a sol-gel binder. The gated intensity ratio was measured as a function of pressure using the detectors with different gating strategies. They found that the time-resolved multiple-gate method had greater sensitivity to pressure than other lifetime methods and the intensity-based (or radiometric) method. The square-square method had the second best sensitivity to pressure. Figure 6.19 shows calibration results of the gated intensity ratio for that PSP obtained with the ICCD employing the timeresolved multiple-gate method and square-square method. One of the problems with the ICCD was a high noise level of the system; the rms variation of the gated intensity ratio was as high as 3-5% even after binning. 1.8 1.6
Multiple-Gate Method Square-Square Method
Gated Intensity Ratio
1.4
PtTFPP-sol-gel PSP
1.2 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 0
20
40
60
80
100
Pressure (kPa)
Fig. 6.19. Calibration of the gated intensity ratio for PtTFPP-sol-gel PSP with ICCD using the time-resolved multiple-gate method and square-square method. From Goss et al. (2000)
Bell (2001) studied the time-resolved multiple-gate method for the pulse excitation to optimize the gating parameters. He found that the gated intensity ratio was not constant over a PSP-coated surface even at constant pressure and temperature, and the variation was 0.5-3% depending on homogeneity of the paint. This indicated that the lifetime was different at different locations even when pressure and temperature are uniformly invariant over a surface. Earlier, in laser-scanning PSP measurements, Torgerson et al. (1996) observed a variation of o about 0.5 in the phase angle (related to the lifetime) across a measurement domain in the flow-off case where pressure and temperature were constant. Similar to Bell’s observation on the gated intensity ratio, the spatial phase pattern was repeatable, dependent on the location. Hartmann et al. (1995) also observed similar results and attributed this phenomenon to microheterogeneity of the polymer environment. The small lifetime or phase variation may not significantly affect PSP measurements at higher Mach numbers, whereas it can introduce a
136
6. Lifetime-Based Methods
considerable error in low-speed PSP measurements. To correct this intrinsic spatial variation of the lifetime, Torgerson et al. (1996) and Bell (2001) used raw lifetime or phase distributions in the flow-off conditions as a reference, and took a ratio between the wind-on and reference lifetime images (signals). Unfortunately, this correction method defeats to certain degree the original purpose of using the lifetime method to eliminate the wind-off reference. Bencic (2001) compared the lifetime method with the intensity-based method for PSP measurements at high viewing polar angles and in a shadowed region, and found that the lifetime-based measurements achieved better results in these cases. Mitsuo et al. (2002) studied the luminescent decay of a PtTFPP-based PSP using a streak camera and found that the multiple-exponential decay of the paint was sensitively dependent on pressure and temperature. This characteristic allowed simultaneous determination of pressure and temperature from three gated intensities obtained by an ICCD camera since two ratios between the three gated intensities had sufficiently different dependencies on pressure and temperature. They selected the first and third gating intervals ǻ T1 = 0 − 0.8 µs and
ǻ T3 = 30 − 82.8 µs. The gated intensity I 1 in ǻ T1 was almost independent from both pressure and temperature, whereas the gated intensity I 3 in ǻ T3 was very sensitive to pressure and temperature. The second gating interval ǻ T2 = 12 − 19.4 µs was chosen based on minimization of the pressure error due to a small pertubation of the intensity ratio signal. Their calibration experiments showed that pressure could be well described by polynomials of the gated intensity ratios I 1 / I 2 and I 1 / I 3 with the temperature-dependent coefficients. Using the calibration relations, they were able to obtain simultaneously the surface pressure and temperature fields in a sonic impinging jet from the two gated intensity ratio images. Recent tests by Watkins et al. (2003) used a new internally gated interline transfer CCD camera to alleviate noise sources associated with ICCD.
7. Uncertainty
7.1. Pressure Uncertainty of Intensity-Based Methods
7.1.1. System Modeling Uncertainty analysis is highly desirable in order to establish PSP as a quantitative measurement technique. Based on the Stern-Volmer equation, Sajben (1993) investigated error sources contributing to the uncertainty of PSP, and found that the uncertainty strongly depended on flow conditions and the surface temperature significantly affected the final measurement results. Oglesby et al. (1995a) presented an analysis of an intrinsic limit of the Stern-Volmer relation to the achievable sensitivity and accuracy. Mendoza (1997a, 1997b) studied CCD camera noise and its effect on PSP measurements and suggested the limiting Mach number for quantitative PSP measurements. From a standpoint of system modeling, Liu et al. (2001a) gave a general and comprehensive uncertainty analysis for PSP. The following uncertainty analysis focuses on the intensity-ratio method widely used in PSP measurements. From Eq. (4.24), air pressure p can be generally expressed in terms of the system’s outputs and other variables Vref ( t, x ) p ref A(T) p ref p = U1 − . (7.1) V( t' , x' ) B(T) B(T) The factor U1 in Eq. (7.1) is
U1 =
Ȇ c Ȇ f h( x' ) c( x' ) q0 ( t' , X' ) , Ȇ c ref Ȇ f ref href ( x ) c ref ( x ) q0 ref ( t, X )
where x = (x, y)T and x' = (x' , y' )T are the coordinates in the wind-off and windon images, respectively, X = (X, Y, Z)T and X' = (X' ,Y' , Z' )T are the object space coordinates in the wind-off and wind-on cases, respectively, and t and t’ are the instants at which the wind-off and wind-on images are taken, respectively. Here, the paint thickness h and dye concentration c are expressed as a function of the image coordinate x rather than the object space coordinate X since the image
138
7. Uncertainty
registration error is more easily treated in the image plane. In fact, x and X are related through the perspective transformation (the collinearity equations). In order to separate complicated coupling between the temporal and spatial variations of these variables, some terms in Eq. (7.1) can be further decomposed when a small model deformation and a short time interval are considered. The wind-on image coordinates can be expressed as a superposition of the wind-off image coordinates and an image displacement vector ǻx , i.e., x' = x + ǻx . Similarly, the temporal decomposition is t' = t + ǻt , where ǻt is a time interval between the instants at which the wind-off and wind-on images are taken. If ǻx and ǻt are small, a ratio between the wind-off and wind-on images can be separated into two factors, Vref ( t, x )/V( t' , x' ) ≈ Dt (ǻt ) D x (ǻx )Vref ( t, x )/V( t, x ) , where
the
factors
Dt ( ǻt ) = 1 − ( ∂V / ∂ t )( ǻt)/V
and
D x (ǻx ) = 1 − ( ∇V ) • ( ǻx ) /V represent the effects of the temporal and spatial changes of the luminescent intensity, respectively. The temporal change of the luminescent intensity is mainly caused by photodegradation and sedimentation of dusts and oil droplets on a surface. The spatial intensity change is due to model deformation generated by aerodynamic loads. In the same fashion, the excitation q0 ( t' , X' )/q0 ref ( t, X ) ≈ light flux can be decomposed into Dq0 (ǻt ) q0 ( t, X' )/q0 ref ( t, X ) ,
where
the
factor
Dq0 ( ǻt ) = 1 + ( ∂ q0 / ∂ t )( ǻt) / q0 ref represents the temporal variation in the excitation light flux. The use of the above estimates yields the generalized Stern-Volmer relation Vref ( t, x ) p ref A(T) p ref − , (7.2) p = U2 V( t, x ) B(T) B(T) where U 2 = Dt (ǻt ) D x (ǻx ) Dq0 (ǻt )
Ȇ c Ȇ f h( x' ) c( x' ) q0 ( t, X' ) . Ȇ c ref Ȇ f ref href ( x ) c ref ( x ) q0 ref ( t, X )
Without any model motion ( x' = x and X' = X ) and temporal illumination fluctuation, the factor U2 is unity and then Eq. (7.2) recovers the generic SternVolmer relation. Eq. (7.2) is a general relation that includes the effects of model deformation, spectral variability, and temporal variations in both illumination and luminescence, which allows a more complete uncertainty analysis and a clearer understanding of how these variables contribute the total uncertainty in PSP measurements. 7.1.2. Error Propagation, Sensitivity and Total Uncertainty According to the general uncertainty analysis formalism (Ronen 1988; Bevington and Robinson 1992), the total uncertainty of pressure p is described by the error propagation equation
7.1. Pressure Uncertainty of Intensity-Based Methods M [ var( ȗ i ) var( ȗ j )] 1/2 var (p) = S S ȡ i j ij p2 ȗ iȗ j i, j = 1
¦
where between
ȡi j = cov( ȗ i ȗ j )/[ var( ȗ i ) var( ȗ j )] 1/2 the
variables
ȗi
and
,
139
(7.3)
is the correlation coefficient
ȗj,
var (ȗ i ) = < ǻȗ i > 2
and
cov (ȗ i ȗ j ) = < ǻȗ i ǻȗ j > are the variance and covariance, respectively, and the notation < > denotes the statistical ensemble average. Here, the variables {ȗ i , i = 1 M} denote a set of the parameters Dt (ǻt ) , D x (ǻx ) , Dq0 (ǻt ) , V , Vref , Ȇ c /Ȇ c ref , Ȇ f /Ȇ f ref , h / href , c / c ref , q0 /q0 ref , p ref , T , A, and B in Eq. (7.2). The sensitivity coefficients S i are defined as S i = ( ȗ i /p )( ∂ p / ∂ ȗ i ) . Eq. (7.3) becomes particularly simple when the cross-correlation coefficients between the variables vanish ( ȡi j = 0 , i ≠ j ). Table 7.1 lists the sensitivity coefficients, the elemental errors and their physical origins. Many sensitivity coefficients are proportional to a factor ϕ = 1 + [A(T) /B(T)] / (p / p ref ) . For Bath Ruth + silica-gel in GE RTV 118, Figure 7.1 shows the factor 1 + [A(T) /B(T)] / (p / p ref ) as a function of p / p ref for different temperatures, which is only slightly changed by temperature. The temperature sensitivity coefficient is S T = −T [B' (T) + A' (T) p ref /p]/ B ( T ) , where the prime denotes differentiation respect with temperature. Figure 7.2 shows the absolute value of S T as a function of p / p ref at different temperatures. After the elemental errors in Table 7.1 are evaluated, the total uncertainty in pressure can be readily calculated using Eq. (7.3). The major elemental error sources are discussed below.
140
7. Uncertainty
Table 7.1. Sensitivity coefficients, elemental errors, and total uncertainty of PSP Variable
Sensi. Coef.
ȗi
Elemental Variance
Physical Origin
var( ȗ i )
Si
1
D t (ǻt )
ij
[( ∂V / ∂ t )( ǻt)/V ] 2
2
D x (ǻx )
ij
[ (∂V/∂x ) ı x2 + (∂V /∂ y ) ı 2y ] V − 2
3
D q0 (ǻt )
[( ∂ q 0 / ∂ t )( ǻt)/q 0 ref ] 2
4 5 6
Vref V Ȇ c /Ȇ c ref
7
Ȇ f /Ȇ f ref
8
h / href
ij ij -ij ij ij ij
9
c / c ref
ij
−2 [ (∂ c /∂ x ) ı x2 + (∂ c /∂ y ) ı 2y ] c ref
10 q 0 /q 0 ref
ij
( q0 ref )−2 ( ∇q0 ) • ( ǻX )
11
1
var( p)
p ref
12 T 13 A 14 B 15 Pressure
mapping
2
2
Temporal variation in luminescence due to photodegradation and surface contamination Image registration errors for correcting luminescence variation due to model motion Temporal variation in illumination Photodetector noise
V ref G ! Ȟ B d
Photodetector noise
V G !Ȟ Bd
[ R2 /(R1 + R2 )] (ǻR1 /R1 ) 2
2
var(Ȇ f /Ȇ f ref ) −2 [ (∂ h /∂ x ) ı x2 + (∂ h /∂ y ) ı 2y ] href 2
2
2
2
2
ST
var( T) 1 − ij var( A) -1 var( B) 1 (∂ p/∂x )2 ı x2 + (∂p /∂y )2 ı 2y and ( ∇ p )surf • ( ǻX )surf
2
Change in camera performance parameters due to model motion Illumination spectral variability and filter spectral leakage Image registration errors for correcting thickness variation due to model motion Image registration errors for correcting concentration variation due to model motion Illumination variation on model surface due to model motion Error in measurement of reference pressure Temperature effect of PSP Paint calibration error Paint calibration error Errors in camera calibration and pressure mapping on a surface of a presumed rigid body M
Total Uncertainty in Pressure
var (p)/ p 2 =
¦S
2 i
var( ȗ i )/ ȗ i
2
i =1
Note: (1) ı x and ı y are the standard deviations of least-squares estimation in the image registration or camera calibration. (2) The factors for the sensitivity coefficient are defined as ij = 1 + [ A( T ) / B( T )]( p ref / p ) and S T = − [ T / B ( T )] [B' (T) + A' (T)(p ref / p ) ] .
7.1. Pressure Uncertainty of Intensity-Based Methods
141
3.0 T = 293 K T = 313 K T = 333 K
1 + (A(T)/B(T))(Pref/P)
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5 0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
2.0
P/Pref
Fig. 7.1. The sensitivity factor 1 + [A(T) /B(T)] / (p / p ref ) as a function of p / p ref at different temperatures for Bath Ruth + silica-gel in GE RTV 118. From Liu et al. (2001a) 10 9
T = 293 K T = 313 K T = 333 K
|(dP/dT)(T/P)|
8 7 6 5 4 3 2 0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
2.0
P/Pref
Fig. 7.2. The temperature sensitivity coefficient as a function of p / p ref at different temperatures for Bath Ruth + silica-gel in GE RTV 118. From Liu et al. (2001a)
7.1.3. Photodetector Noise and Limiting Pressure Resolution The uncertainties in the outputs V and Vref from a photodetector (e.g. camera) are contributed from a number of noise sources in the detector such as the photon shot noise, dark current shot noise, amplifier noise, quantization noise, and pattern
142
7. Uncertainty
noise. When the dark current and pattern noise are subtracted and the noise floor is negligible, the detector is photon-shot-noise-limited. In this case, the signal-tonoise ratio (SNR) of the detector is SNR = ( V / G ! ȞBd )1 / 2 , where ! is the Planck’s constant, ν is the frequency, Bd is the electrical bandwidth of the detection electronics, G is the system’s gain, and V is the detector output. The uncertainties in the outputs are expressed by the variances var(V) = V G ! Ȟ Bd and
var(Vref ) = Vref G ! Ȟ Bd . In the photon-shot-noise-limited case in which the error propagation equation contains only two terms related to V and Vref , the pressure uncertainty is ǻ p §¨ G Bd ! Ȟ ·¸ = ¨ V ref ¸ p ¹ ©
1/ 2
ª A( T ) p ref «1 + B( T ) p «¬
ºª p º » » «1 + A( T ) + B( T ) p ref »¼ »¼ ¬«
1/ 2
,
(7.4)
which holds for both CCD cameras and non-imaging detectors. For a CCD camera, the first factor in the right-hand side of Eq. (7.4) can be simply expressed by the total number of photoelectrons collected over the integration time ( ∝ 1 / Bd ), n pe = V /( G ! ȞBd ) . When the full-well capacity of the CCD camera is achieved, we obtain the minimum pressure difference that PSP can measure from a single frame of image
( ǻp)min 1 = p (n pe ref )max
ª p º A(T) p ref º ª » «1 + » «1 + A(T) + B(T) p ref »¼ B(T) p »¼ ¬« ¬«
1/2
,
(7.5)
where (n pe ref )max is the full-well capacity of the camera in reference conditions. When N images are averaged, the limiting pressure difference (7.5) is further 1/2 reduced by a factor N . Eq. (7.5) provides an estimate for the noise-equivalent pressure resolution for a CCD camera. When (n pe ref )max is 500,000 electrons for a CCD camera and Bath Ruth + silica-gel in GE RTV 118 is used, the minimum pressure uncertainty ( ǻp)min / p is shown in Fig. 7.3 as a function of p / p ref for different temperatures, indicating that an increased temperature degrades the limiting pressure resolution.
Figure 7.4 shows
(n pe ref )max ( ǻp)min / p
as a
function of p / p ref for different values of the Stern-Volmer coefficient B(T) . Clearly, a larger B(T) leads to a smaller limiting pressure uncertainty ( ǻp)min / p . Figure 7.5 shows
(n pe ref )max ( ǻp)min / p
as a function of the Stern-Volmer
coefficient B(T) for different values of p / p ref . There is no optimal value of B in this case.
Minimum pressure uncertainty (%)
7.1. Pressure Uncertainty of Intensity-Based Methods
143
0.40
0.36
0.32 T = 333 K T = 313 K
0.28 T = 293 K 0.24
0.20 0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
2.0
P/Pref
Fig. 7.3. The minimum pressure uncertainty ( ǻp)min / p as a function of p / p ref at different temperatures for Bath Ruth + silica-gel in GE RTV 118. From Liu et al. (2001a)
7
(∆P)min/P [(npe ref)max]
1/2
6
5 B = 0.5 4 0.6 3
0.7 0.8
2
0.9
1 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
P/Pref
Fig. 7.4. The normalized minimum pressure uncertainty
(n pe ref )max ( ǻp)min / p as a
function of p / p ref for different values of the Stern-Volmer coefficient B(T) . From Liu et al. (2001a)
144
7. Uncertainty
20 P/Pref = 0.2
(∆P)min/P [(npe ref)max]
1/2
0.5 15
1.0
1.5
10
2.0 5
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
B
Fig. 7.5. The normalized minimum pressure uncertainty
(n pe ref )max ( ǻp)min / p as a
function of the Stern-Volmer coefficient B for different values of p / p ref . From Liu et al. (2001a)
7.1.4. Errors Induced by Model Deformation Model deformation generated by aerodynamic loads causes a displacement ǻx = x' − x of the wind-on image relative to the wind-off image. This displacement leads to the deviations of the quantities D x (ǻx ) , h / href , c / c ref , and q0 /q0 ref in Eq. (7.2) from unity because the distributions of the luminescent intensity, paint thickness, dye concentration and illumination level are not spatially homogeneous on a surface. After the image registration technique is applied to re-align the wind-on and wind-off images, the estimated variances of these quantities are var[Dx (ǻx )] ≈ W ( V ) / V 2 , var( h / href ) ≈ W ( h ) /( href )2 , and
var( c / c ref ) ≈ W ( c ) /( c ref ) 2 .
The
operator
W( • )
is defined
as
W( • ) = (∂ /∂ x ) ı + (∂ /∂ y ) ı , where ı x and ı y are the standard deviations of least-squares estimation for image registration. The uncertainty in q0 ( X )/q0 ref ( X' ) is caused by a change in the illumination intensity on a model surface after the model moves with respect to the light sources. When a point on the model surface travels along the displacement vector ǻX = X' − X in the object space, the variance of q0 /q0 ref is estimated by 2
2 x
2
2 y
2
var[q0 ( X ) / q0 ref ( X' )] ≈ ( q0 ref )−2 ( ∇q0 ) • ( ǻX ) . Consider a point light source
7.1. Pressure Uncertainty of Intensity-Based Methods
with unit strength that has a light flux distribution q0 ( X − X s ) = X − X s
145 −n
,
where n is an exponent (normally n = 2) and X − X s is the distance between the point X on the model surface and the light source location X s . Thus, the variance of q0 /q0 ref for a single point light source is var[q0 ( X ) / q0 ref ( X' )]
= n2 X − X s
−4
2
( X − X s ) • ( ǻX ) .
The variance for multiple point light
sources can be obtained based on the principle of superposition. In addition, model deformation leads to a small change in the distance between the model surface and the camera lens. The uncertainty in the camera performance parameters due to this change is var(Ȇ c /Ȇ c ref ) ≈ [ R2 /(R1 + R2 )] 2 (ǻR1 /R1 )2 , where R1 is the distance between the lens and model surface and R2 is the distance between the lens and sensor. For R1 >> R2 , this error is very small.
7.1.5. Temperature Effect Since the luminescent intensity of PSP is intrinsically temperature-dependent, a temperature change on a model during a wind tunnel run results in a significant bias error in PSP measurements if the temperature effect is not corrected. In addition, temperature influences the total uncertainty of PSP measurements through the sensitivity coefficients of the variables in the error propagation equation. Hence, the surface temperature on a model must be known in order to correct the temperature effect of PSP. In general, the surface temperature distribution can be measured experimentally using TSP or IR camera and determined numerically by solving the motion and energy equations of flows coupled with the heat conduction equation for a model. For a compressible boundary layer on an adiabatic wall, the adiabatic wall temperature Taw can be estimated using a simple relation Taw / T0 = [ 1 + r( γ - 1)M 2 / 2 ] [ 1 + ( γ - 1)M 2 / 2 ] −1 , where r is the recovery factor for the boundary layer, T0 is the total temperature, M is the local Mach number, and γ is the specific heat ratio.
7.1.6. Calibration Errors The uncertainties in determining the Stern-Volmer coefficients A(T) and B(T) are calibration errors. In a priori PSP calibration in a pressure chamber, the uncertainty is represented by the standard deviation of data collected in replication tests. Because tests in a pressure chamber are well controlled, a priori calibration results usually show a small precision error. However, a significant bias error is found when a priori calibration results are directly used for data reduction in wind tunnel tests due to unknown