Postwestern Cultures
Postwestern Horizons gener al editor William R. Handley University of Southern California series...
68 downloads
1422 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Postwestern Cultures
Postwestern Horizons gener al editor William R. Handley University of Southern California series editors José Aranda Rice University Melody Graulich Utah State University Thomas King University of Guelph Rachel Lee University of California, Los Angeles Nathaniel Lewis Saint Michael’s College Stephen Tatum University of Utah
Postwestern
Cultures Literature, Theory, Space
Edited by Susan Kollin
UNIVERSIT Y OF NEBR ASK A PRESS LINCOLN AND LONDON
Publication of this book was assisted by a grant from Montana State University. © 2007 by the Board of Regents of the University of Nebraska All rights reserved Manufactured in the United States of America ∞ Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Postwestern cultures: literature, theory, space / edited by Susan Kollin. p. cm.—(Postwestern horizons) Includes bibliographical references. isbn 978-0-8032-1114-8 (cloth: alk. paper) isbn 978-0-8032-6044-3 (pbk.: alk. paper) 1. American literature—West (U.S.)— History and criticism. 2. American literature—History and criticism. 3. West (U.S.)—In literature. 4. Popular culture in literature. 5. Ecology in literature. 6. Homosexuality in literature. 7. Multiculturalism in literature. I. Kollin, Susan. ps271.p57 2007 810.9⬘978 2 22 2007011384 Set in Quadraat by Bob Reitz. Designed by R. W. Boeche.
Contents Acknowledgments
vii
Introduction: Postwestern Studies, Dead or Alive ix Susan Kollin Part 1: Newer New Wests 1. Spectrality and the Postregional Interface 3 Stephen Tatum 2. Everyday Regionalisms in Contemporary Critical Practice Krista Comer 3. Critical Regionalism, Thirdspace, and John Brinckerhoff Jackson’s Western Cultural Landscapes Neil Campbell 4. Architecture and the Virtual West in William Gibson’s San Francisco 82 Michael Beehler Part 2: Nature and Culture 5. What’s Authentic about Western Literature? And, More to the Point, What’s Literary? 97 Lee Clark Mitchell 6. Some Questions about Sexless Nature Writing David Oates
115
30
59
7. Backpacking and the Ultralight Solution Capper Nichols 8. Survival, Alaska Style Susan Kollin
127
143
Part 3: Contested Wests 9. Scheduling Idealism in Laramie, Wyoming Beth Loffreda
159
10. Frontier Mythology, Children’s Literature, and Japanese American Incarceration 172 John Streamas 11. I’m Just a Lonesome Korean Cowgirl; or, Adoption and National Identity 186 Melody Graulich 12. Cultivating Otowi Bridge Audrey Goodman
206
13. The Romance of Ranching; or, Selling Place-Based Fantasies in and of the West 223 Nancy Cook References
245
Contributors 265
Acknowledgments Over the years I have been fortunate to discuss postwestern studies with a number of colleagues; thanks especially to Robert Bennett, Rachel Bryson, Nancy Cook, Melody Graulich, Capper Nichols, and Steve Tatum for keeping me on track. For their financial and emotional support of this book I am grateful to Sara Jayne Steen, former Dean of the College of Letters and Science at Montana State University; and Michael Beehler, former Chair of the English Department. A Research Enhancement Award from Montana State University’s College of Letters and Science and a Scholarship and Creativity Award from the Office of the Vice Provost for Research also enabled me to finish this project. I am likewise indebted to Michael Becker, computer guru and patient proofreader, who played a key role in making sure the manuscript was completed on time; and to Jonathan Lawrence for his care and attention during the copyediting process. Ladette Randolph, my editor at the University of Nebraska Press, has been great to work with and always “gets it.” My appreciation to her for her endless humor, patience, and wisdom in the production of this book. In his pedagogy, parenting, and professional life, my philosopher/film scholar husband, Dan Flory, has been doing his best to help usher in the post-patriarchy. I could not have finished this project without his support and willingness to discuss western film and culture at all hours of the day and night. With much gratitude, I dedicate this book to him.
Introduction Postwestern Studies, Dead or Alive susan kollin
The region seems to be an indestructible entity that transcends and survives history to remain everlastingly the same. . . . [I]f regionalism is the nostalgia for a past state, it is also the certainty of the survival of that past. . . . The past becomes a place . . . that we can bring back, ideally, in our understandable present as a moral prescription. Roberto Dainotto, “‘All the Regions Do Smilingly Revolt’: The Literature of Place and Region” Artists and critics must find a way to care about both the distant and the local—to analyze regional communities without losing sight of the larger global community that requires and enables the production of regions. Hsuan L. Hsu, “Literature and Regional Production”
In May 2006 at a press conference with British prime minister Tony Blair, President George W. Bush offered a surprising confession to news reporters when he admitted his political mistake in using “tough talk” shortly after 9/11. At issue for the president was his choice of language, particularly the western vernacular of bounty hunting epitomized by that “old poster out West,” which he recalled in outlining his plans for capturing Osama bin Laden “dead or alive.” “I learned some lessons about expressing myself,” the president explained, especially about the need to adopt a more “sophisticated manner” in his speeches on terrorism.1 For those of us studying and teaching
x
|
susan kollin
in the field of western American culture, the president’s unexpected attention to the power of words—to the political consequences of rhetoric and imagery—reminds us of precisely what is at stake in our intellectual labors. What does it mean for critical regional studies when the popular idioms that have often defined the American West in narrowly conceived ways are called into question in such a public manner? Is it a sign of our postwestern moment that the president himself sees the limits of frontier discourses and recognizes the urgency of reframing his political language? Many of us remember how the president’s earlier post-9/11 speeches set off a maelstrom of national and international criticism that blasted America’s new “Lone Ranger foreign policy,” its “cowboy diplomacy,” and the administration’s reliance on Old West–style “frontier justice.” As part of the political fallout, student antiwar demonstrators carried signs reminding the president, “It’s the Middle East, not the Wild West.”2 Yet if social commentators, international political leaders, and antiwar protesters were outraged at the rhetorical framing of U.S. foreign policy in the post-9/11 period, in many ways the administration’s use of Wild West imagery should have come as no surprise. Campaigning for the nation’s highest office both times as an earthy, no-nonsense Texas rancher, the president traded on some of the most enduring images of American national identity. Indeed, the allure of the Old West with its promises of personal freedom and collective renewal has proven to be a central means for political self-fashioning for a long line of U.S. presidents. For scholars in the field, such uses of western American imagery in political discourse are a powerful reminder of how particular images and sentiments associated with the West move well beyond the confines of regional boundaries to provide explanatory power for the nation as a whole. Such moments remind us how important it is to continue carefully assessing and evaluating the political burdens placed on western spaces in national discourse. The field of critical regional studies offers important tools for examining the deployment of such regional imagery, and in doing so it insists that we remain aware of how the spatial meanings and identi-
Introduction |
ties surrounding regions may indeed be powerful constructs that are not in any way self-evident or predetermined. Cultural critic Hsuan L. Hsu, for instance, calls for a fluid and flexible understanding of regions, suggesting that they “may administer or fix social and economic relations in a given area, but they are themselves produced or transformed in relation to—and often in the service of—larger dominant spaces.”3 National and transnational concerns always inflect the meanings regions are given and the uses to which they are put. Hsu thus argues for an understanding of regions as both “productive” and “continually produced,” not bounded eternally to a set geography, but “dynamic and flexible . . . neither isolated nor fixed . . . their constitutive and necessary interactions with other scales suggest that space, in its various and contradictory relations, can be as dialectical as time.”4 This collection of new essays on postwestern cultures likewise insists that we understand the region not as a closed or bounded space but as a continually changing and evolving entity in both content and form. The larger aim of this study is to examine a particularly contested space—the American West—and the highly charged and continually shifting meanings that have become associated with it. To say that the West is a multiply inflected terrain whose identity is always in flux and revision is to recognize that the political uses of western American iconography discussed above do not lay claim to all the possible meanings associated with the region. Indeed, the essays in this collection testify otherwise by examining a wide range of regional practices and forms of signification and by drawing on a variety of critical approaches, including global studies, feminist theory, cultural studies, environmental criticism, cultural geography, queer studies, and critical race theory. As an emerging critical approach, postwestern studies work against a narrowly conceived regionalism, one that restricts western cultures of the past and present to some predetermined entity with static borders and boundaries. Postwestern studies instead involve a critical reassessment of those very restrictions, whether they be theoretical, geographical, or political. In working against totalizing approaches
xi
xii
|
susan kollin
that posit “one West, one frontier, or one borderland,” critic Blake Allmendinger explains: All of us recognize a West whose history is represented by certain dates and hard facts; whose literary history is embodied by a canon of literature; whose images are communally recognized, shared, and experienced; whose geographic identity is sketched as a series of immobile boundary lines. But at the same time, each of us makes up the West for ourselves. We interpret historical facts, individually experience works of fiction and film, and transgress those seemingly immobile boundary lines in peculiar, often quite profound ways. . . . Today, although the West may be settled, its meanings and boundaries remain unfixed and unsealed.5 As Allmendinger points out, while past approaches and previous concepts of the West continue to circulate and inform the present, new understandings and experiences are currently reshaping cultural production in the region. Postwestern studies date back at least to the early 1970s before the postmodern turn in the humanities, when scholars such as Philip French called attention to a number of new films that were critically restructuring the Western. For French, these “post-western” Westerns marked a decided shift in the genre’s usual sentiments and allegiances. Influenced by the social movements of the 1960s and 1970s, the new crop of movies tended to locate in the genre’s “all-American” figures “some less attractive traits: patriotism masking xenophobia, ignorance masquerading as intuitive common-sense, mindless aggression concealed beneath virility, arrogance disguised as style.”6 What French saw as “post-western” Westerns were texts that developed new interpretations of the West’s past and that provided viewers different viewpoints and loyalties from the usual fare. In the 1990s Frieda Knobloch offered another take on postwestern studies, calling for scholarship that could be “mobilize[d] . . . not only in the service of a ‘new western history,’ but more importantly in the service of—in anticipation of—a postwestern history.” For Kno-
Introduction |
bloch, the promise of postwestern studies carried great potential and possibility but had not yet been fully realized as a lived experience. Indeed, for Knobloch, the term postwestern, “as in ‘United States out of North America,’” functioned as a “particularly succinct indigenist, anti-imperialist, and antistatist demand, for which no ‘West’ as such, cultural or geographical, exists.”7 By arguing that a postwestern condition is still being anticipated rather than realized, Knobloch calls attention to the greater difficulties involved in “posting” the West. Much of this problem stems from how, in dominant national discourse, the American West has been imagined and celebrated largely for its status as “pre”—for its position as a pre-lapsarian, pre-social, and pre-modern space. To some extent, this thinking has spilled over into studies of the American West, so that like the very spaces of an idealized western geography, some literary and cultural scholarship about the region has adopted a pre- or even anti-theoretical stance, as if regional studies could offer a similar retreat or refuge from a dehumanizing culture, whether it be modernism, industrialism, or the domain of critical theory in the contemporary academy.8 The heated debates that have ensued among western literary scholars and the history crowd, to give just one instance, indicate that Knobloch’s anticipation of a postwestern scholarship in the academy is still more a dream than a reality.9 It is important to remember, too, that such a realization will necessarily result in quite diverse and varied responses. As geographer Trevor Barnes has noted in another context, “no single body of ‘post’prefixed approaches” exists in the academy today, and “significant dissimilarities and disagreements” continue to divide critics. Nevertheless, “‘post’-prefixed” scholarship as a whole tends to be motivated by a common concern, namely, a “desire to interrupt the Enlightenment project in various ways and to strive toward an alternative.” Overwhelmingly, such scholarship rejects rationalist responses that seek to impose order on a world that “eschew[s] both closure and regimented structure.”10 In this vein, Stephen Tatum describes the emergence of what he calls “postfrontier horizons,” a new critical landscape in literary and cultural studies. For Tatum, postfrontier
xiii
xiv
|
susan kollin
scholarship examines “subaltern voices and alternate histories, and like its New Western History counterparts, has contested Turner’s frontier thesis and its key term.” Tatum goes on to explain how this scholarship avoids the closure and rigid structure that Turner offered and instead explores “how places or region need to be regarded not only as geopolitical and geological territories or physical landscapes, but also as sites produced by the circulation of peoples, of technologies and commodities, and of cultural artifacts, including of course images, stories, and myths. So instead of Turner’s concept of the westward-moving frontier as a line of demarcation conceptually grounded by East/West and savage/civilized binaries, contemporary critics are more likely to view the frontier as an intercultural contact zone.”11 When President Bush outlined his plans for national security in the post–9/11 period using unmistakable codes of the Old West revenge tale, he did so with the assumption that Americans and the rest of the world knew the conventions and plot turns of the region’s master narrative—the upstanding cowboy saving the frontier community from savagery and lawlessness in order to ensure a future of freedom. The international response that followed the press conference, however, indicated not just a widespread familiarity with the Wild West narrative but a vocal and passionate rejection of its terms. With its black-and-white certainty of right and wrong, the Old West morality conjured up by the administration’s statements and actions held little currency or explanatory capital for many of the world’s citizens. Even as this discourse was widely rejected, however, some observers noted that popular national sentiment following 9/11 may have helped spark a new cycle of the Western, following an era in which the form seemed to be undergoing a revisionist turn. bbc reporter Ryan Dilley, for instance, remarked about how tempting it is to look at the nation’s efforts at self-reflection following 9/11 to explain the “flurry” of new Westerns. “Could it be that America at war (and at odds with many former allies) is looking back to its heroic wild west past for inspiration and comfort?” he asked.12 Other writers made
Introduction |
similar observations, noting that producers may be capitalizing on the frontier fascination of the current administration by providing new “tough-talking Westerns.” As one insider explained, “the timing is really good for shows that take on right and wrong and kick some bad-guy butt.”13 While it may be too early to predict what will happen with the Western in the near future, one television show, hbo’s Deadwood series, has already staked out a position in this terrain. Rather than endorsing the current administration’s view of the nation’s western past, Deadwood offers a critical take on what that world allegedly offered. Choosing a politically loaded historical moment—the summer months of 1876 shortly following Custer’s defeat at the Battle of Little Bighorn—Deadwood interrogates western regional sensibility during a time of crisis in American confidence. There are no clear-cut heroes in this show; instead, we are given what Philip French defined as a “post-western” Western. For French, such films operated as thinly veiled allegories about the nation as a whole, which in Deadwood appear as the Euro-American settlers understand their presence in the region to be an encroachment on Indian land and a direct violation of the Laramie Treaty. Drawing on elements of the classic mining tale with settlers in and around Deadwood prospecting for gold in the Black Hills, the show adopts a kind of New West sensibility concerning hyperdevelopment, as the struggle to rid the frontier of all impediments to economic enterprise becomes a central theme of the series.14 The two main saloonkeepers, for instance, do the dirty business of fighting off competition for their establishments’ customers, prostitutes, and growing drug trade. Among the show’s characters, multicultural awareness appears in chronic short supply as various ethnic slurs are regularly exchanged between the townspeople. The show also features other less-than-desirable characters, including doped-up poker players, a glassy-eyed minister, a serial killer who murders prostitutes, and a sadistic businessman who will do anything to stay top dog. Although the language in the show may commit many of Mark Twain’s literary offenses, and the profanities used by the characters
xv
xvi
|
susan kollin
may not achieve historical accuracy, Deadwood’s scriptwriters offer other lessons by staging connections between our current political era and the historical moment in which the show is set. Here we are given battles over gold instead of oil, and broken Indian treaties in the place of un violations. We are shown a muzzled press, religious fundamentalism, rampant capitalism, and the social and environmental costs of hyperdevelopment. Another text that has recently deployed regional imagery—but again for a different purpose—is Khaled Hosseini’s best-selling novel, The Kite Runner, which tells the story of a young man’s coming-of-age in Afghanistan, his turbulent friendship with another Afghani boy, and his later exile in California. At one point the narrator comments on the cultural capital accrued in owning American jeans or “cowboy pants” that signified wealth in Afghanistan.15 The two boys watch The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly at a local theater, a film that eventually unseats The Magnificent Seven as their favorite Western. The narrator’s friend, Hassan, is later thrilled to receive a leather cowboy hat, a replica of the one Clint Eastwood wore in the spaghetti Westerns.16 At another point, Amir recalls his childhood in Kabul: We saw our first Western together, Rio Bravo with John Wayne, at the Cinema Park, across the street from my favorite bookstore. I remember begging Baba to take us to Iran so we could meet John Wayne. Baba burst out in gales of his deep-throated laughter—a sound not unlike a truck engine revving up—and, when he could talk again, explained to us the concept of voice dubbing. Hassan and I were stunned. Dazed. John Wayne didn’t really speak Farsi and he wasn’t Iranian! He was American, just like the friendly, longhaired men and women we always saw hanging around in Kabul, dressed in their tattered, brightly colored shirts. We saw Rio Bravo three times, but we saw our favorite Western, The Magnificent Seven, thirteen times. With each viewing, we cried at the end when the Mexican kids buried Charles Bronson— who, as it turned out, wasn’t Iranian either.17
Introduction |
Referenced here is a spaghetti Western made by Italian film director Sergio Leone, who based his own character on a figure from a Japanese samurai film. The novel also features young filmgoers in Kabul mistaking the famous cowboy actor John Wayne as an Iranian hero, thus providing us with a glimpse of the complexities involved in transnational rearticulations of the American West. Just as novelists, filmmakers, and political speechwriters do not deploy the western American past for the same purposes, so scholars have recognized the varied cultural work performed by western regionalism. As some critics have warned, regionalism has the potential to offer an acritical turn to the past, a retreat from modernity and multiculturalism, which thus calls for a rigorous examination of its failure to decenter national metanarratives. As Hsu explains, “For readers, tourists, and politicians alike, the region often serves as a focus of nostalgia and a privileged site of geographical feeling. Both the architects of gated suburban communities and progressive cultural critics represent the local as the scale of familiarity, loyalty, and authentic experience, in contrast with the merely imagined community of the nation and the passionless economic space of globalization.”18 Hsu goes on to argue, however, that regionalism should be assessed not solely as a nostalgic response to nationalism but also as an effect and product of that very nationalism, indeed, as being constituted by but likewise producing the larger national and global spaces in which it dwells. Hsu explains: “The relation between literature and regional production involves not only the production of literature about regions but also the ways in which literary works produce, reimagine, and actively restructure regional identities in the minds and hearts of their readers; moreover, this latter process of regional transformation always occurs in relation to larger-scale phenomena such as migrant flows, transportational networks, and international commerce.”19 A study of western regionalism ultimately requires us to travel critically in many directions, between past and present and between regions and nations. Such travels move us back and forth in time and between the local and the global, providing us with a view that is akin to what Tom Lutz describes as the “cosmopolitan
xvii
xviii
|
susan kollin
vistas” of critical regionalism. As Lutz explains, in combining local and global concerns, “a central issue [of regionalism] has been the relation of different groups to ongoing technological, economic, and social change, or, in other words, the relation of the region to the rest of the world.”20 Of course, too, there is much more to western American studies than the popular Western. As the contributors to this volume clearly indicate, cultural production about the West includes many other stories about and experiences in the region that also need to be engaged. Thus, the authors in this collection address a number of topics, from gender and power in the youth subculture of surfing to the cultural production of Gen X and cyberpunk writers, from the uses of frontier rhetoric in narratives about Japanese American internment camps to the emerging agricultural tourism in the New West, from the consumer culture of nature advocacy to the formation of regional identities in the context of transnational adoption, from examinations of vernacular or abandoned western landscapes through the theories of geographer J. B. Jackson to the problems of defining what’s “real” about western American literature, and from the cultures of silence in Laramie following Matt Shepard’s murder to the promises and possibilities of queering western nature writing. Ultimately, the essays collected here offer a complicated reassessment of cultural production throughout the region. In doing so, the contributors aim to realize a postwestern critical sensibility that opens up potential lines of inquiry and expands the western archive to include new voices and experiences that have not received adequate scholarly attention. Notes 1. For an astute commentary on the speech see Philip Gourevitch’s “Comment: Just Watching” in New Yorker, June 12, 2006, 49–50. For a transcript of the news conference, see the National Public Radio website at http://www.npr .org/templates/story/story/php/storyID=5433122 (accessed June 26, 2006). 2. See, e.g., Tom Barry, “Frontier Justice: From tr to Bush,” Counterpunch, November 15, 2002, 1; and “Students Cut Class to Protest War,” CBS News Online, March 5, 2003, http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2003/03/05/iraq/ main542856.shtml (accessed August 9, 2006).
Introduction |
3. Hsu, “Literature and Regional Production,” 38. 4. Hsu, “Literature and Regional Production,” 37–38. 5. Allmendinger and Matsumoto, introduction, 2–4. 6. French, Westerns, 142. 7. Knobloch, Cultures of Wilderness, ix. 8. I borrow here from Dana Phillips, whose remarks about ecocriticism apply to certain instances of western American criticism; see his Truth of Ecology, 4. 9. Forrest G. Robinson offers various insights about these debates, particularly concerning the theoretical divides that separate literary critics and new western historians. See “Clio Bereft of Calliope” and “We Should Talk.” 10. Barnes, Logics of Dislocation, 8–9, v. 11. Tatum, “Postfrontier Horizons,” 460–61. 12. Ryan Dilley, “Is It High Noon for the Western?” BBC News Online, September 25, 2003, http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk–news/magazine/3132746. stm (accessed August 9, 2006). 13. Paul Bedard with Betsy Streisand and Richard J. Newman, “‘West Wing’ into ‘Gunsmoke,’” U.S. News and World Report, 131, no. 14 (2001): 4. See also Walter Metz, “‘Mother Needs You’: Kevin Costner’s Open Range and the Melodramatics of the American Western,” forthcoming in A Family Affair, ed. Murray Pomerance (London: Wallflower Press). 14. See French’s discussion of McCabe and Mrs. Miller for various influences on Deadwood (Westerns, 161). 15. Hosseini, The Kite Runner, 69. 16. Hosseini, The Kite Runner, 44. 17. Hosseini, The Kite Runner, 26. 18. Hsu, “Literature and Regional Production,” 36. 19. Hsu, “Literature and Regional Production,” 36–37. 20. T. Lutz, Cosmopolitan Vistas, 15.
xix
1 Newer New Wests
1. Spectrality and the Postregional Interface stephen tatum
From media, entertainment, and telecommunications to artificial life, neuroscience, and electronic money, virtual technologies are transforming what was once called “reality.” At the precise moment that critical analysis is imperative, interpretive strategies that have proved extremely effective for the past several decades no longer seem adequate. Mark C. Taylor, Hiding Susan said that the unifying theme amid all this Gappiness is, of course, the computer spreadsheet and the bar-coded inventory. “A jaded cosmopolite in the Upper West Side buys an Armpit, Nebraska-style worker’s shirt (in ‘oatmeal’) and Gap computers” (doubtless buried deep within a deactivated norad command center somewhere in the Rockies) “instantaneously spew out the message to Asian garment manufacturers, ‘Armpit worker shirts are hot.’ Likewise, an agrarian soul out there in Armpit, pining away for a touch of life away from the silo, buys an oxford cloth button-down shirt at the local Gap, and computerized Gap-funded looms in Asia retool for the preppie revival.” Douglas Coupland, Microserfs Globalization and the (Post)Region For the past decade cultural critics in a variety of academic disciplines and fields have been identifying and theorizing about the several economic and social trends associated with a globalizing world-system’s restructuring of the economic landscape. Predominant in this
4
|
stephen tatum
discourse about globalization and its multinational corporate diffusion of urban-industrial capitalism across the various geopolitical boundaries associated with states, regions, and nations are tropes of flow, circulation, and migration. On one level, such tropes discursively highlight the rather intensified, speeded-up movement of investment capital and commodities, of information and technology, of images, and, of course, of animal and human populations in the global economy that—as the above quote from Douglas Coupland’s novel Microserfs suggests—binds together the fates of individuals in Asia, New York City, and Armpit, Nebraska. On another level, however, certain theorists deploy the tropes of flow, circulation, and migration not only to describe a major trend associated with globalization but also to diagnose a major consequence of globalization’s economic restructuring of the landscape. As a result of new information technologies, the breakdown of trade barriers, and the disciplining of labor unions through the outsourcing of manufacturing jobs in a networked global economy, there results—to quote Manuel Castells—“the separation between functional flows and historically determined places as two disjointed spheres of the human experience. People live in places, power rules through flows.”1 Keeping in mind this theorized disjuncture between the space of flows and the space of lived places, we can think of the global, macroeconomic forces striving to integrate industrial production, commercial trade, and financial investment with new technological paradigms as overlaying or doubling and, as Castells for one argues, even “ruling,” which is to say redrawing and determining the contour lines of the local, the regional, and even the national maps. Consider, for instance, the mob of Hereford- and Angus-cross steers and feeder cows on the ground in the feedlot at Wilderado, a few miles west of Amarillo, Texas, on I-40. Born, weaned, and for a time raised on ranches in west Texas, the Oklahoma panhandle, eastern New Mexico, and southeastern Colorado, such cattle are trucked to Wilderado to be fattened for an eventual sale at auction and then a trip to the slaughterhouse. When the wind is from the west, as it often is on the Texas high plains, the stench of the cattle’s urine and excrement,
Spectrality and the Postregional Interface |
this matter mounded into artificial hills in the open space between the feeding troughs, is highly noticeable to the east, drifting past the “Cadillac Ranch” earth sculpture and on through Amarillo neighborhoods. Still, as is the case with other feedlots (and slaughterhouses) across the high plains, the feeder cattle on the ground at Wilderado represent but a subset of an intricate, integrated global system of beef production, marketing, and distribution. This system is enabled by certain trade agreements (gatt, nafta), by the flexibility of transnational capital, and by the mobility of the largely immigrant labor force staffing the feedlots and packing plants and trucking companies typically owned by multinational agribusiness corporations. It is a system whose feedlots and slaughterhouses are typically located in close proximity not only to supplies of grain but also to the interstate highway system that enables the cattle to be trucked efficiently from ranch, to feedlot, to slaughterhouse, and then to retail stores and to coastal ports for the export market. It is a system enabled by container shipping technology at these distant ports to which the highways lead, and it is an integrated system in that the same container shipping and interstate transportation corridors can be and are used to import as well as to export frozen beef. In short, there is the actual steer living on the ground and gorging on the hormone-laced feed at this place called Wilderado, and there is this actual steer’s spectral or virtual double, the “world steer,” an entirely fictive but nevertheless real bovine creature produced by the flow of the global commodity futures market—an abstract creature, in short, whose shifting exchange value overdetermines the actual steers and feeder cows on the ground and fouling the space of local places in, say, Texas, Nebraska, Australia, and Argentina. It is precisely because the flows of technology, capital, and animal and human bodies coalesce to produce such abstract economic phenomena as “the world steer” that, some critics conclude, the hegemony of the nation-state has been and is being severely challenged in a globalizing world-system. As Arif Dirlik argues, for example, “the new pathways for the development of capital cut across
5
6
|
stephen tatum
national boundaries and intrude on national economic sovereignty, which renders irrelevant the notion of a national market or a national economic unit and undermines national sovereignty from within by fragmenting the national economy.”2 Indeed, “the new pathways for the development of capital” existing today suggest to Edward Soja that “in many ways the most interesting developments arising from globalization and postfordist economic restructuring can be found in the ‘in-between’ spaces, the new geographies of power emerging between the national and global and the national and local scales.” On the one hand, Soja notes, one of “the new geographies of power” exists between the national and global scale in the form of such “supra-state regionalisms” as the European Union; on the other hand, between the national and local economic scales there is a new geography of power associated with what he calls “city-region states” like Los Angeles, Chicago, or Atlanta.3 Given “the new pathways for the development of capital” and the “new geographies of power” associated with globalization, the challenge for critical cultural studies becomes identifying and theorizing newer critical paradigms that will improve our understanding of the relationship between the “new geographies” created by the spaces of transnational flows and local or regional cultural economies. In short, we need to cultivate “postnational and transnational ways of knowing,” new interpretive strategies for being in a world where various, disjunctive flows increasingly overdetermine and shape lives and the imaginations of those living in specific places.4 It logically follows that efforts by critics to identify the relevant topics, methods, and theoretical perspectives for a properly “postnational” or “transnational” American cultural studies ought to be extended as well to the regional or local scale of critical analysis—regardless of whether that scale be conceived, to use Soja’s terminology, as transnationalism from above (supra-state regionalism) or transnationalism from below (city-state regionalism). Whether or not one specifically chooses to examine, say, the emergence of the spectral “world steer” that supersedes steers who live in actual places, or the abstract economic calculus of “labor units” that supersedes those
Spectrality and the Postregional Interface | 7
laboring bodies in local fields and factories, or the global dissemination of a western American regional imaginary through the film, television, and tourist industries—regardless of the specific focus or example, at some juncture the critic would do well to consider a series of larger questions. In the context of the social, political, economic, and cultural transformations wrought by the now-dominant globalizing world-system, for example, what are the consequences for critical thinking of the concept of the regional (or the local)? If, as Soja argues, it is possible for a regional cultural economy to continue to exist amid the circuits of global capital, what are its emergent features? What major themes, forms, images, and rhetorical figures begin to define an emergent, postregional cultural style? In what ways might this emergent cultural style or structure of sensibility and sentiment register, diagnose, and perhaps even critique globalization’s restructuring of the economic landscape into a space of flows? Such questions gain a certain urgency at the beginning of a new millennium precisely because various economists, sociologists, political scientists, and cultural geographers have been stressing since the mid-1990s how the regional and the local are, at bottom, entwined with, if not even produced by, the diverse economic, political, and social forces of globalization. “What does seem clear,” Mike Featherstone argues, “is that it is not helpful to regard the global and local as dichotomies separated in space and time; rather, it would seem that the processes of globalization and localization are inextricably bound together in the current phase.”5 From this dialectical perspective, the neologism “glocalization,” as well as my example of the “world steer” that haunts the steers on the ground around the world, illustrates how the global is always being localized and the local is always being globalized. With Featherstone’s comment in mind, however, there is a twofold point to make here. First, we need to recognize how the spaces created by various global flows effectively collapse the older binaries of global/local or center/periphery so that the geopolitical American West with its particular history, climate, and physical topography is not, cannot be, and should not be regarded, much less celebrated, as a secure refuge or enclave both
8
|
stephen tatum
immune from and oppositional to the general impact of globalization. Second, “glocalization” not only connotes a process whereby global, macroeconomic forces insinuate themselves into and “shape” specific local geographies. It also suggests the alternative position that regional, geographically differentiated market production and consumption can insinuate themselves into and shape a global economy’s space of flows. In 1983 the architect and theorist Kenneth Frampton called for a “critical regionalism” whose prevailing aesthetic in the built environment and whose cultural productions would oppose what he viewed as the globalizing world-system’s increasing homogenization and abstraction of lived space—a process, as the narrator in Coupland’s novel Microserfs notes, orchestrated by such corporate giants as Gap, Nike, Microsoft, Disney, and McDonald’s.6 However, given the apparent “triumph” of globalization’s restructuring of the landscape since Frampton’s groundbreaking essay appeared, it would seem fair to ask now whether such an alternative or oppositional “critical regionalism” has emerged, or indeed even can emerge and gain purchase. Perhaps, in other words, multinational corporate capitalism’s intensified marketing of cultural difference—what Dirlik calls the corporate “guerilla marketing” of local difference—in its relentless search for superprofits means that the regional and local cultural productions are, inevitably, complicit with globalization rather than providing evidence, say, of an alternative or oppositional “critical regionalism” or “critical localism” advocated by Frampton.7 If so, then the critical question and task, to quote Masao Miyoshi, becomes “how then to balance the transnationalization of economy and politics with the survival of local culture and history—without mummifying them with tourism and in museums.”8 Now, this framing question not only follows on the undeniable evidence of a hypermobile, global capital’s cannibalizing of local or regional “difference” through tourism and museums and historical theme parks, much less through its print and visual media discourse about “authentic” local or regional cuisines and folkways. The global economy is bound up with and indeed exploits the regional and local
Spectrality and the Postregional Interface |
cultural economy in at least three other ways. For one thing, as critics like Soja and Arjun Appadurai stress, the “regional,” conceptually speaking, must be understood now less as a specific geographical locale or empirical reality. That is, the “regional” in an emergent global economy of flows should be regarded more as a liminal, discursive terrain, a cultural imaginary produced at the point where the circulation of media imagery, the movement of transnational capital, and the voluntary or forced migrations of peoples intersect with a particular geographic locale. To use Appadurai’s terminology, the regional or local gets produced by the disjunctive, varied flow of transnational capital investment, this creating a particular “finanscape”; of human populations (tourists, immigrants, refugees, exiles, guest workers) migrating to particular lived places organized by the flows of capital investment, this flow creating a place’s distinctive “ethnoscape”; and of imagery about a place circulated by an integrated global media (film, television, and the internet), thus creating a distinctive “mediascape.”9 The intersection of these building blocks with a particular geographical locale, Appadurai theorizes, produces an “imagined world,” or what we might call a particular “regional imaginary.” With Appadurai’s theoretical framework, at least two points need to be made as we consider the impact of global flows on the regional cultural economy. One is that at any given moment in any given place multiple imagined worlds will coexist. Like the relationship between actual cattle on the ground and the fictive, marketplace creation called the “world steer,” the signifier “Wyoming” overlays the geopolitical boundaries of the state with, for instance, the state tourism board’s circulation of an extant Old West cowboy culture’s iconography (as part of its promotion of the dude ranch and ski industries); the aesthetic-recreational landscape of the Grand Teton and Yellowstone national parks; and the contemporary “finanscape” largely dominated by the shift of capital and people away from rural towns, farms, and ranches and toward the detritus of businesses and related industries that service the open-pit coal mines and Wyoming oil patch. The second point is that if we think of the region as a discursive, imagined construct produced by disjunctive flows, then neither the multiple
9
10
|
stephen tatum
regional imaginaries nor their audiences are bound to specific times and spaces. Because “people, machinery, money, images, and ideas now follow increasingly nonisomorphic paths,” it is no longer feasible to demand a one-to-one, or isomorphic, relation between a local or regional culture and a particular topography.10 Moreover, precisely because the various flows of capital, technology, imagery, and peoples in the global economy are disjunctive, regions and localities effectively are pitted against each other in the global economic competition for investments, jobs, and tourist dollars. Thus, as Soja notes in Postmodern Geographies, the global economy promotes uneven regional development not only between regions (e.g., Sun Belt versus Rust Belt in the United States) but also within regions. The 2000 U.S. Census, for instance, revealed the profound economic gap between those western states geared to newer hightech economies (California, Washington) and those still wedded to an older “finanscape” based on ranching and the extraction of timber, coal, oil, and natural gas (Wyoming, Montana). Finally, amid all the interdisciplinary discourse about how globalization triggers capital flight, plant closures, and the outsourcing of jobs, as well as the disciplining of labor unions through the development of labor-saving technologies, Soja further shows how the global economy’s uneven regional development produces new territorial divisions of labor and labor markets. In the American West, deindustrialization in the form of plant and mine and sawmill closures and capital flight, accompanied by selective, local reindustrialization based on new information technologies, have fostered, among other things, an increasing polarization of occupations and classes. Such economic restructuring of the regional landscape is registered materially in the spatial divide between, for example, suburban or edge city research campuses or parks with skilled, highly educated workers who perform computer, biotech, and medical research and development, and the so-called unskilled, “surplus” labor force composed largely of legal (and illegal) immigrants and minority, working-class women who staff a minimum-wage “service” economy primarily in the downtown hotel and entertainment zones.11
Spectrality and the Postregional Interface |
To summarize to this point: the contemporary restructuring of the economic, sociocultural, and political landscape by a global economy is evident in the hypermobility of capital across geopolitical boundaries, by uneven regional development both above and below the national scale, and by emerging spatial divisions of labor which themselves register an increasing polarization of occupations and classes. As a result of these trends, theorists like Soja and Appadurai claim that the “regional” or “local” scale has become fully rearticulated with rather than against transnational economic (and political) developments. From the perspective of disciplines like sociology, political economy, and geography, then, the regional or the local now connotes less a specific locale and political unit and more a postindustrial nodal point where the global flows of capital, commodities, peoples, and images intersect. Conceptually speaking, in other words, in the increasingly postindustrial environment governed by global flows of data, electronic technologies, and imagery, regional and local cultural economies have become “deterritorialized,” unmoored from specific physical sites. To put the transformation we are living through another way: at the end of the nineteenth century and the beginning of the twentieth, when local color or “western” regional cultural productions emerged in the context of industrialization, a center-periphery model for the most part theoretically grounded the regional concept. This model essentially juxtaposed a metropolitan industrial and commercial center or core against an agricultural and resource-supply periphery (i.e., the region). In this model, which basically represents a form of the nation-state’s internal colonialism, the American West served as an agrarian subsidy zone, a source of raw materials and mineral wealth, and a reservoir of cheap labor. To be sure, in some respects the contemporary American West still supplies agricultural products, raw materials, and labor to metropolitan centers. Even so, the major trends associated with the development and expansion of a global economy of flows—particularly the rearticulation of the region with transnational markets and the deindustrialization of the older metropolitan core back east—trouble this center-periphery model, includ-
11
12
|
stephen tatum
ing its cultural corollary, the one-to-one relation between place and culture. Now, the center-periphery model associated with the era of colonialism and industrialization is homologous with the architecture of Fordist assembly-line production: centralized authority, hierarchical organization, and serial production and distribution. By contrast, the architecture of our contemporary postindustrial technoculture increasingly centered on data networks, electronic technologies, and robotic logic is largely decentralized, laterally organized, and proceeds by parallel rather than serial processing and distribution.12 Think here of workplace environments with several networked computer servers rather than a central mainframe computer; think here of robots on production lines independently controlled by microchip processors wired to personal computers; and, to shift from organizational architecture to workforce demographics, think here of how the new professional managerial class members laboring in the advanced technological infrastructure at Silicon Valley and other research parks located in close proximity to major research universities in the urban West do not inhabit specific, local places so much as they “belong to a cross-border culture in many ways embedded in a global network of local places—particularly international financial centers among which people, information, and capital circulate regularly.”13 “A global network of local places”: instead of being identified by means of a specific physical topography, or solely as a resource subsidy zone for a metropolitan center, the regional and local in a globalizing world-system should be regarded both as (1) a discursive site, an imagined world produced by the conjunction of mediascapes, ethnoscapes, and the migrations and territorial divisions of labor; and as (2) a network of strategic, interurban commercial and financial centers whose networks of power deterritorialize traditional local, national, and regional spaces. From this perspective, western American regionalism has been superseded by a “postregional” and largely postindustrial global economy whose nodal points on a networked grid are Houston, Denver, Salt Lake City, Phoenix, Seattle, the San Francisco Bay area, Mexico City, and Los Angeles. These “city-regions,”
Spectrality and the Postregional Interface |
to use Soja’s term, are not only linked with each other as nodal points on a grid of flows (e.g., the tourist grid linking Los Angeles with Las Vegas and the Zion, Bryce Canyon, and Grand Canyon National Park circuit) but are also linked with the current capitals of the main trading blocs in the global economy: New York, London, Hong Kong, and Tokyo. The technological developments driving the postindustrial environment and the disarticulation of the regional concept from the space of places were from the beginning, and are now, associated with the military, aerospace, and entertainment industries in the American West. Virtual-reality machines such as head-mounted displays and flight simulators emerged from nasa’s Ames Research Center for advanced supercomputing in Mountain View, California. The secretive “Skunk Works” advanced development program of Lockheed Martin pioneered the Stealth fighter jets and bombers that were produced and tested in Palmdale, California. The advanced digital effects technology associated with cinema and computer gaming, as well as the animatronics associated with theme parks and the entertainment industry in California and Nevada, have been and are being developed by the West’s networked “city-regions.” My point here is not to argue for the American West’s importance over other regions’ research and development sites but rather to suggest that the electronic and transportation networks, the virtual technologies, and the flow of images from the entertainment industry sector compose a postregional grid networking Palmdale with Area 51 in Nevada; the Bay Area’s Pixar and Industrial Light and Magic with southern California’s Walt Disney Corporation; and Hollywood with the Las Vegas (and Reno) gaming and entertainment industry. From this perspective, in the postregional American West, the flows of capital, technology, people, and imagery all come together at a nodal point called “Las Vegas.” Indeed, as a character in Coupland’s Microserfs speculates, casino-hotels like the mgm Grand in Las Vegas, whose “theme” basically deploys Hollywood’s Wizard of Oz fantasy to tourists and convention-goers, epitomize “the Detroit of the postindustrial economy.”14 Whether or not one focuses on the entertainment, recreational, and transportation grid that effectively
13
14
|
stephen tatum
carves out a postregional space of flows linking Los Angeles and Las Vegas, though, the crucial point to emphasize is this: the conceptual transformation of the traditional geopolitical space of the regional into a “global network of local places” highlights how we need to rethink (and reorganize) the “spatial hierarchies that are usually taken as given, such as local < national < global.”15 With all the global flows of people, images, technology, and capital coming together in local places like Las Vegas, the spatial hierarchies need to be reframed this way: local/regional > national > global. Or, to paraphrase Robert Venturi and Denis Scott Brown, there are things we can still learn from Las Vegas. Spectrality and the Postregional West There was mist floating on the ground above the soccer fields outside the central buildings. I thought about the email and Bill and all of that, and I had this weird feeling—of how the presence of Bill floats about the Campus, semi-visible, at all times, kind of like the dead grandfather in the Family Circus cartoons. Bill is a moral force, a spectral force, a force that shapes, a force that molds. A force with thick, thick glasses. Douglas Coupland, Microserfs As Gayatri Spivak has argued in an essay focusing in part on the economic fate of subaltern working women in the developing world’s southern regions, it is not the terrain of the much-discussed postmodern metropolis celebrated by such theorists as Fredric Jameson but rather the rural “where changes seen upon urban-built space are the most visible.”16 Indeed, she suggests, “it is entirely possible that the real terrain of globalization is the spectralization of the so-called rural.” The “so-called rural” variously connotes what Spivak identifies throughout the essay as the terrain of the local, the regional, the aboriginal or indigene, and the ecological. All these synonyms for the “rural” are as relevant to the “real terrain” of the American West, with its maquiladores and factory farms and tribal lands and toxic landscapes and suburban edge cities, as they are to, say, the “real terrain” of
Spectrality and the Postregional Interface |
Bangladesh or Indonesia in the so-called developing world’s densely populated Southern Hemisphere. The other key word in her comment, “spectralization,” represents her shorthand way of describing globalization’s transformation of this “so-called rural”—“so-called” here because that very transformation has eroded the boundary between the global metropolis and the rural or local region. By using the term “spectralization” Spivak also wants to stress an intensified process of abstraction, the dematerialization of peoples and things that operates across the restructured landscape of multinational corporate capitalism. For in a globalizing world-system, she notes, the world’s banks and investment houses relentlessly transform actual, laboring bodies in the “so-called rural” zones of production into the abstract, more spectral realm of so-called “labor power” or “labor units.” Furthermore, with the term “spectralization,” Spivak is interested in how actual physical topographies are transformed into virtual or simulated landscapes of grids and points, of circuits and networks through which capital, laboring bodies, images, and commodities flow. So, for example, a geopolitical region’s distinctive topography might get “spectralized” as simulated maps identifying a network of electronic battlefields or power-line transmission grids, banking and investment routes, air travel and highway transportation hubs and nodes, illegal drug manufacturing and distribution/ consumption points. And finally, “spectralization” for Spivak additionally connotes both the familiar Marxian concern about the transfer of use value into exchange value and the pulsing, ghostly flow of immaterial capital and intellectual property through the electronic portals of a “postindustrial economy’s” satellite, digital, and computer technologies. I refer to Spivak’s essay for two reasons: first, it implicitly suggests yet another way to consider the identity and the place of the (post)regional in the emergent postindustrial economy; and second, it introduces both a theme (the process of abstraction or “spectralization”) and a trope or image (the spectral) that defines one major contour line identifying the intersection of an emergent “postregional” literary and cultural imaginary with the global economy of flows.
15
16
|
stephen tatum
More specifically, by combining Spivak’s location of the “real terrain” of globalization in the “so-called rural” with Appadurai’s stress on the disjunctive global flows of images, peoples, and capital, I want to suggest that any emergent “postregional” western American culture ought to be thought of as a spectral, rather deterritorialized space imaginatively located somewhere “in between” a specific geographic reality, the residual traces of the visual images and written narratives associated with the mythic Wild West, and the emergent regional imaginaries associated with both the new “wired,” technoculture West and that of “Greater Mexico.”17 In addition, again following the leads of Spivak’s and Soja’s arguments, I want to stress how the discursive terrain of this deterritorialized, postregional cultural imaginary materializes as a particular type of interface between distinctive geographical realities, finanscapes, and emergent types and divisions of labor. Thus, as the “non-isomorphic paths” or flows of people, machinery, capital, and images overrun or surpass geopolitical boundaries, we should be alert to how postregional cultural economies of representation are bound up with the way embodied “laboring populations” are brought “into the lower-class sectors and spaces of relatively wealthy societies” that traffic in information and investment capital.18 Given the matrix of economics, labor and class relations, and migratory labor populations in the contemporary American West, it seems to me entirely plausible for Susan Kollin, for example, to suggest that “discussions about the western range and struggles for Indian sovereignty and land rights will be concerns that shape the region for a long time ahead,” and furthermore, that “these [political, economic, and legal] debates and issues will remain themes that structure the next generation of western American literature for some time to come.”19 Whether or not Kollin’s prediction about the future shape of western American literature is on target, a regional cultural imaginary preoccupied with “the western range” and the fate of its mining and pastoral industries in relation to American Indian tribal sovereignty claims might well inflect the “spectral” along the lines of laid out by James Welch’s Winter in the Blood or filmmaker Jim
Spectrality and the Postregional Interface |
Jarmusch’s Dead Man: as a ceaseless haunting of the present by the contagious residue of a violent past. What interests me here, however, is how on the scale of the “so-called rural”—“the real terrain of globalization,” as Spivak insists—there has been and is another class or territorial division of labor that warrants critical concern. It is a type of labor that indexes the new global capitalism, and one whose territorial division or class stratification bears precisely on how certain embodied workers are brought into and positioned in relatively wealthy societies. It is, furthermore, an emergent type of labor whose particular inflection of the trope of the spectral offers still another set of themes, images, and characters potentially defining an emergent “postregional” western American literature “for some time to come.” If one defines the (post)region in a globalizing world-system through the particular way flowing “laboring populations” interface with “the spaces of relatively wealthy societies,” then clearly the new territorial divisions of labor associated with the contemporary American West’s commercial sectors, tourist and entertainment zones, university research parks, and corporate campuses suggest another key interface to analyze. I am referring here to that omnipresent contemporary interface between embodied human (and animal) subjects and computer and digital technology and robotic logic. In the new postindustrial environment governed by electronic technology and data networks, in other words, the key interface requiring innovative interpretive strategies is that of a prosthesis between humans and technology or machines. And though ghosts or Navajo skinwalkers may well haunt technological prosthesis and cybernetics in our contemporary moment, this particular interface manifests spectrality as a theme, metaphor, and principle through the flickering images and languages pulsing on the surfaces of the electronic screens, monitors, and displays of computers, on cellular devices, and other miniaturized technologies and programmed machines and virtual environments powered by electricity generated from coal or water in the West. We might call this interface produced by “spectralization” the emergent dream of “becoming electronic,” one which of course
17
18
|
stephen tatum
starkly contrasts to the perennial western American cultural dream of becoming “authentic” by reverting to the aboriginal or the animal primitive or the ecological or natural. This kind of “spectralization,” grounded by its human-machine interface and its attendant dream of becoming electronic, is manifested in or by, to make a short list for starters, the artificial limbs and organs and the cloning experiments developed in the postindustrial economy’s western biotech and medical research labs; by the computer-generated simulations of weather patterns and traffic patterns and even of nuclear accidents at test sites in the West; by the electronic tracking devices and surveillance cameras and satellites developed for parolees, and illegal immigrants, and endangered animals across the geopolitical West; by the robots on the floors of the region’s manufacturing sector; and by the animatronics and computer-simulated effects in the entertainment sectors located largely, though not exclusively, in California and Nevada. With this kind of interface (human-machine) and this version of the spectral (visual displays on screens and monitors) in mind, perhaps the forensic lab detailed in the television series C.S.I.: Crime Scene Investigation (set in Las Vegas) or the computerized slot machines in Indian country and Nevada casinos that return to gamblers paper receipts or coupons (instead of actual coins) most compellingly illustrate how Spivak’s “spectralization of the so-called rural” has begun to saturate the postregional American West’s cultural economy.20 The Electronic Geography of Hope Karla lost it and started to cry, and then, well, I started to cry. And then Dad, and then, well, everybody, and at the center of it all was Mom, part woman/part machine, emanating blue Macintosh light. Douglas Coupland, Microserfs I am suggesting, then, that one way of understanding the ongoing, global economic restructuring of capital and the cultural economy is through what Spivak calls “spectralization,” and furthermore, that this economic process of “spectralization” in a global postindustrial
Spectrality and the Postregional Interface |
economy of flows manifests itself in at least two ways: first, in changing conceptualizations of the regional cultural economy (the deterritorialized, discursive space of “postregional” imagined worlds); and second, by such tropes in this emergent regional cultural imaginary as the interface and the spectral, these emerging as theme, image, and metaphor in recent literature, film and television, and music productions using the physical settings, history, and cultural iconography associated with the American West. To begin to illustrate how the intersection of emergent types and divisions of labor, technological prosthesis, and the trope of spectrality define an emergent postregional western American cultural imaginary, I want here to explore the concluding scenes of Vancouver writer and artist Douglas Coupland’s 1995 novel Microserfs. Coupland’s novel treats the shifting career fortunes and personal lives of a group of Generation X computer programmers whose lives, for the most part, move between their work, their homes or apartments, and their local Costco store, and whose computer programmer jobs, in the overall course of the narrative, compel them to migrate from Microsoft in the Seattle area to a startup software company named Oop! in California’s Silicon Valley. The narration proceeds as a series of fragmented journal entries by a character named Daniel Underwood, a self-confessed “hair-trigger geek” who is haunted by memories of his dead brother Jed and who begins writing late at night “to try to see patterns in [his] life”—to try to understand what root problem occasions both his insomnia and his career and relationship anxieties, “and then, hopefully, [to] solve it.”21 Set in the environs of three of the American West’s “city-regions,” its postmodern aesthetic saturated with popular culture trivia, brand names, and the idioms of advertising, and thematically concerned with such issues as the human-machine interface in the computer age, Microserfs both thematically and formally indexes the various economic, social, and cultural forces reshaping the regional landscape. Near the novel’s conclusion, in a chapter titled “Transhumanity”—a neologism that itself gestures toward Coupland’s interface that troubles the human/machine binary—the Oop! gang of com-
19
20
|
stephen tatum
puter programmers and software designers, all clad in their “Riot Nerd” gear, travel to Las Vegas to market their fledgling startup company and its new software product at the annual Consumer Electronics Show.22 Their abiding hope is that their combined efforts at the convention will attract new investors to help launch their software design into production and retail sales, and, as a result, help them realize their collective ambition to rise from the status of laboring “microserf ” to the rather exalted status of “Cyberlord” (personified in the novel by “Bill,” a character Coupland bases on Bill Gates, real-life chairman of the Microsoft Corporation). As their crucial Las Vegas working adventure unfolds, Underwood at one point describes a satellite video transmission of uber-Cyberlord Bill’s facial image to the various television screens and computer monitors set up throughout a cavernous Las Vegas convention center filled with software designers, computer technicians, graphic artists, journalists, and retail salespersons. Seeing Bill’s face, framed with thick glasses, and hearing Bill’s voice launching some new software product by means of a video transmission from an undisclosed remote location off the convention premises, Underwood observes how everyone is “riveted” to Bill’s virtual image, “not listening to what he’s saying but instead trying to figure out what was his . . . secret.”23 What Underwood for one has already figured out is this: Bill’s ultimate “secret,” and the source of his power, is that his face “shows nothing.” Not “nothing” in the sense of James Bond’s charismatic “coolness,” but rather “nothing” as in the expression of a “nothingness,” which is “maybe the core of the nerd dream: the core of power and money that lies at the center of the storm of technology, that doesn’t have to express emotion or charisma, because emotion can’t be converted into lines of code.”24 Though brief, this moment near the novel’s end is worth extended critical attention. For one thing, there is its setting in Las Vegas, whose casino-hotels and entertainment and tourism industry represent “the Detroit of the postindustrial economy.” For another thing, there is in this vignette the predominance of the video image itself— in this instance a simulated image of a blank, expressionless face projected onto television screens and computer monitors through-
Spectrality and the Postregional Interface | 21
out the convention space. Not just any face, of course, but the face of “the Bill,” one whose overall blank “nothing” gaze at the video camera represents, to Underwood’s eyes, the panoptic, mesmerizing “spectral force” of this reigning, postindustrial Wizard of Oz.25 Third, Underwood’s figurative language to describe Bill’s on-screen virtual image is also quite revealing. For to get at the “secret” of the Bill’s projected image, and more particularly the “secret” of his blank or “nothing” face, Underwood resorts to a familiar analogy drawn from the natural world: as if the Bill were himself like a hurricane-force wind, his face and blank look constitute the “eye” at the center of “the storm of technology.” Taken together, the image of video technology and surveillance, the transformation of a human face into a simulacra of low-affect blankness, and the metaphorical transposition of nature into technology through the “eye of the storm” trope concisely illustrate one version of what Spivak calls the “spectralization” associated with the new global capitalism. These various elements also condense both the spatial logic and the utopian dream attendant upon becoming electronic through technological prosthesis. Like the mise-en-scène of the television show C.S.I., the prevalence of video screens and computer monitors and cameras both inside and outside the Las Vegas convention center marks, on one level, the ubiquitous, invisible, and dominant presence of technology in a surveillance culture. But there is more to be noticed here, for the narrator-character Underwood’s metaphorical substitution of technology and the ubiquitous video image for nature’s eye of the hurricane also exemplifies what art critic Jeremy Gilbert-Rolfe has called contemporary capitalism’s “posthuman technological sublime.”26 As Gilbert-Rolfe argues, in its properly “posthuman” form such characteristic features of the sublime mode as limitlessness and inscrutability are now “found not in the presence of the forest but in the presentness simulated by the computer, not in the temporality of nature but in the simultaneity of the electronic.”27 As illustrated by Underwood’s interpretation of the Bill’s blank, “nothing” expression as embodying the “core of the nerd dream,” the contemporary posthuman techno-sublime “does not seek to overcome the body by
22
|
stephen tatum
simulating the natural. . . . [It] seeks instead to obviate the body. Or to redefine it as a face attached to a [electronic] pulse” (emphasis added).28 An image of a human body first reduced to a face and then further reduced to an “eye” whose gaze is enabled by an electronic pulse, Bill’s inscrutable spectral image manifests the techno-sublime’s utopian dream in which the organic becomes the modular and interchangeable and limitlessly reproduced image. In Microserfs this utopian dream associated with contemporary technoculture capitalism is manifested not only by the Bill’s virtual image but also by the novel’s allusions to other examples of modular, interchangeable, and homogeneous things and spaces: Legos, highway engineering design books, Gap clothing, farm-raised catfish, and the “clean rooms” of research and production labs. On still another level, Underwood’s interpretation of the “nothing” or the “nothingness” communicated by the Bill’s televised image interestingly redefines the idea of blankness itself. That is, in traditional terms an expressionless, blank facial expression might be thought of as signifying potentiality—as representing an absence in the present that, in due course, will become transformed into a presence, as is the case, for example, with a blank, primed canvas that, traditionally speaking, signifies an artist’s future activity of concealing the blank canvas with a brush loaded with pigment. However, the blankness Underwood attributes to Bill’s compelling spectral image represents, by contrast, an active signifier already signifying activity in the presentness of the present. As suggested by Gilbert-Rolfe’s contrast between “the temporality of nature” and “the simultaneity of the electronic,” advanced communication technologies enable the instantaneous or simultaneous circuit of both transmission and reception of the image. Unlike the blankness of the primed canvas, a blankness implying both temporal duration and spatial depth, the immediate transmission and reception of Bill’s virtual image transforms his blank “face” into the charged, virtual interface between Bill’s image and the viewers’ faces “riveted” to the surface of the screen. If we further consider how Bill’s “nothing,” blank expression on the surface of the screen is not only hypervisible but also hypermobile
Spectrality and the Postregional Interface | 23
(infinitely reproducible, limited only by the number of monitors available to display it), then we can also understand how Underwood’s narration of this scene establishes a semantic link between “the spectral force” of Bill’s expressionless neutrality and, in the novel’s larger narrative, the analogous, generic blankness associated with the lines of computer “language” and the universal bar code (undoubtedly the most visible modular and interchangeable units in the globalizing world-system today). Through such semantic and imagistic links, in short, the novel imagines the contemporary techno-sublime’s version of spectrality as a condition of the “blank” face/interface. This “blank” face/interface is not only transparently mobile (as are lines of computer code or universal bar codes) but also (like the theory of Legos referenced throughout the novel) essentially placeless or context-free—an idealized, homogeneous space analogous to that of the identical “clean rooms” where silicon computer chips are produced around the world. And in the end, if not from the beginning, it is this very hypermobility—the intensified and instantaneous flow of forms of capital and images and peoples across various geopolitical borders—that constitutes the working dream of what theorists variously call a post-Fordist or postindustrial restructuring spawned by the new global capitalism. (And as anyone who has ever tried to cash a check or use an atm machine or get a credit report knows, capital’s enhanced flexibility and hypermobility is enabled by its “spectralization,” its transformation into and instantaneous electronic transmission as an immaterial, virtual reality that can haunt real terrains in the form of refusal of credit, or identity theft, or accounting fraud.) All told, then, amid its postmodernist aesthetic experimentation and its familiar plot of career ambition and of both love and family lost and then found, Microserfs remaps the American West as a postregional, consumer electronic interface where certain residual cultural factors (traditional sexual roles, Generation X and other subcultural idioms, nostalgia for spirituality), dominant cultural factors (lifestyles based on consumption patterns; television and motion picture viewing; shopping mall experiences; computer and video technology), and emergent cultural factors (computer interface with
24
|
stephen tatum
consumers; robotics) commingle on the spectral surface of video displays and computer monitors. Furthermore, amid the triangular movement of the novel’s main characters between the Seattle area, California’s Silicon Valley, and the Las Vegas consumer electronics show, Microserfs registers through its setting, plot threads, characters, images, and themes both the uneven regional development and the emergent spatial divisions of labor following on (high) technocapitalism’s restructuring of the American West as a deterritorialized space of cultural imagery and information flows “attached to an electronic pulse.” Though the novel grounds its rather traditional official bildungsroman plot on the narrator-character Underwood’s family romance and developing intimacy with a fellow microserf named Karla, this plot is haunted both by the specter of his brother’s death and by his primal anxieties about proletarianization. And this latter anxiety, elaborated on one register by the fate of Underwood’s father, fired from his job because he did not survive the new “storm of technology,” leavens the novel’s playful linguistic surface and subtly discloses how both the Oop! research and software development and the dominant class culture of leisure and consumption spectacularly centered in Las Vegas are underwritten by the tourist and convention economy serviced by low-skilled, low-wage earners drawn largely from “Greater Mexico.” Through the themes and formal features of Coupland’s novel, then, we can begin to understand how postmodern and postindustrial regions in general, and the American West in particular, are not and cannot be enclaves insulated or isolated from the “spectralization” associated with new global capitalism. Indeed, this novel’s investment in spectrality as image (video projections on screens and monitors), metaphor (machines and minds haunted by ghosts), and theme (the interface of humans and machines; the moral and ethical meanings of technological prosthesis) offers compelling evidence for how “spectralization” in the cultural sphere parallels the “spectralization of the rural” that Spivak has defined as the engine driving globalization in the economic sphere.29 But what ultimately interests me about Microserfs in this context is how Coupland’s creative vision
Spectrality and the Postregional Interface | 25
of “postregional spectrality” centers, at the end, on a technological prosthesis between human consciousness and a computer’s subconscious “ghost in the machine” that crosses the “frontier between words and skin; speech and flesh.”30 In Coupland’s vision, Siegfried and Roy’s particular combination of science, animatronics, and plastic surgery ultimately does not realize the emergent posthuman techno-sublime in the new “wired” West symbolized by Las Vegas. Rather, it is embodied by Underwood’s librarian mother, who—in the wake of a stroke that afflicts her while Underwood attends the Las Vegas electronics show—eventually regains her “voice,” and hence her subjectivity, when the leader of the Oop! software team hooks her up to a Macintosh computer so that her fingers are connected to a keypad, so a circuit is completed between her brain’s neurons and the machine’s silicon processor on the surface of a screen: “Mom, part woman/part machine, emanating blue Macintosh light.”31 The regional paradigm associated with an industrial mode of production in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century was primarily bound up, as Bill Brown has argued in A Sense of Things, with material artifacts—material “things.” Regional and local color literary production, museum curatorial practice, and anthropological endeavors all essentially promoted what Brown calls a “poetics of attachment,” which is to say a kind of synecdochal magic where part-objects (e.g., Navajo rugs) were construed as expressing the “whole” of a culture. Whether one considers the fetishization of tools, manner of dress, dialect speech, and foodways in fictions or museum displays of that era, things were effectively (re)vitalized by being viewed through visual and verbal tableaux of people engaged in occupational tasks. As I mentioned above, because in this older industrial paradigm a metropolitan, industrial, and commercial center is juxtaposed to the geographical region as peripheral subsidy zone or resource for raw materials and reservoir of cheap labor, regionalism and “local color” primarily was rooted in resistance to the homogenizing of cultural traditions and the triumph of abstract space in a modernizing industrial society. In the older regional cultural economy, it presumably became important to possess material objects, to see and hold the
26
|
stephen tatum
traces or record of the past, as if the point of a Jim Burden palpating the rusted remnant of a conquistadore’s spur in Willa Cather’s My Ántonia was literally to possess a repudiated or repressed or forgotten past through a material presence that would promote an affective experience legitimating or authenticating one’s reality and real life in an increasingly weightless present. But approximately a century after the moment of Austin, Wister, Remington, and Roosevelt, in the postindustrial mode of global techno-capitalism, the “rural” or the local and regional become “socalled,” in Spivak’s words. “So-called” because the local and regional exist now as a mutable, discursive constructions or cultural imaginaries; “so-called” also because the local and regional cultural economies are entirely saturated by capital, technology, peoples, and the inventory of imagery circulating throughout a globalized world. As the final scenes in Microserfs disclose, one result of the disarticulation and reorganization of the regional cultural economy from specific places is that things themselves have become “spectralized.” So the Bill’s human presence gets reconfigured as a spectral “face attached to an electronic pulse”; so Daniel Underwood’s “Mom” emerges from her stroke as a hand attached to a computer keyboard, a “part woman/part machine” cyborg whose visual display’s pulsing blue text dissolves the oppositions between human and machine, inside and outside, mind and body, and virtual and real. On the last page of Microserfs the presiding image is of Underwood and his girlfriend, his parents, and the rest of the Oop! gang sitting or lying around a swimming pool in the dark night, their handheld flashlights and portable lasers shining, “cutting the weather, extending ourselves into the sky, into the end of the universe with precision technology running so fine.”32 Whereas Jean Baudrillard once upon a time theorized robotic humans so entranced by and with technology that culture became defined as hypervisible and hyperabundant communication without community, Coupland’s utopian dream of becoming electronic dramatizes an alternative postregional and posthuman “geography of hope” in the American West (to use Wallace Stegner’s famous phrase). On the one hand, Coupland’s electronic
Spectrality and the Postregional Interface | 27
“geography of hope,” primarily through its scattered intertextual allusions to “frontier” myths and imagery, discloses how the “city-regions” of the postindustrial American West are fully interdependent with the flows of a deterritorialized, global economy. And yet on the other hand, in contrast to the Bill’s “nothing” face, the Oop! gang— through its dialogues about whether (or how) machines have souls; its fumbling attempts at intimacy; its critique of Legos—seeks to cultivate sensory experiences and meaningful affective relations within an increasingly programmed everyday drift. As the final scene of the novel suggests, the Oop! gang gathered around the swimming pool under a dark western sky and “extending [themselves] into the sky, into the end of the universe,” their flashlight beams representing a kind of miniaturized version of the Luxor casino’s vertical white light, projects not only an embodied sense of being together but a momentary realization of the hope that through technological interfaces one can become “transhuman,” can “extend” oneself literally as well as imaginatively beyond the constraints of class, sex, gender, race, and ethnicity. In Coupland’s vision, in other words, social restoration and spiritual renewal in a “global network of local places” starts with altering human consciousness—starts with an emergent occupational neo-tribe interfacing with the electronic frontier.33 Notes 1. Castells, The Informational City, 349. 2. Dirlik, “The Global in the Local,” 31. 3. Soja, Postmetropolis, 205, 208. 4. The phrase “postnational and transnational ways of knowing” is from Lipsitz, American Studies in a Moment of Danger, 301. For more on the calls for and examples of newer critical paradigms in American cultural studies, see Rowe, The New American Studies; and Pease and Wiegman, The Futures of American Studies. 5. Featherstone, “Localism, Globalism, and Cultural Identity,” 47. 6. Frampton, “Towards a Critical Regionalism.” 7. “Critical localism” is Arif Dirlik’s term for “the local as a site of resistance and liberation,” not a “localism” that is exploited by global capital. “The Global in the Local,” 38–42.
28
|
stephen tatum
8. Miyoshi, “A Borderless World?” 95. 9. Appadurai, Modernity at Large, 33–35. 10. Appadurai, Modernity at Large, 37. 11. Soja, Postmodern Geographies, esp. chap. 7 (pp. 157–89). Also useful is Storper, The Regional World. 12. I am indebted to Mark C. Taylor’s Hiding (293–305) for this contrast between the organized architectures of a center-periphery and contemporary technoculture model. 13. Sassen, “Spatialities and Temporalities,” 226. 14. Coupland, Microserfs, 337. 15. Sassen, “Spatialities and Temporalities,” 226. 16. Spivak, “From Haverstock Hill Flat,” 29. 17. The phrase “Greater Mexico” comes from Limón, American Encounters, 3. It is Limón’s term for an imagined community of Mexicans and people of Mexican descent existing “beyond Laredo and from either side [of the border], with all their commonalities and differences.” Both the regional imaginary of the “wired,” high-technoculture West and that of “Greater Mexico” illustrate how the flows of people, technology, capital, and images erode geopolitical boundaries and the isomorphic concept of culture and place. 18. Appadurai, Modernity at Large, 37. 19. Kollin, “Wister and the ‘New West,’” 252. 20. In this context we could also consider such texts as the 2004 Disneyproduced film Hidalgo, which features, near its end, the appearance in the Arabian desert of the ghosts of an Indian family massacred at Wounded Knee; director Ron Howard’s The Missing (2004), his remake of the classic 1956 John Ford film The Searchers, in which kidnappers are led by an Indian “witch” with supernatural powers; or Sherman Alexie’s 1996 novel Indian Killer, which explores issues of cross-cultural adoption, tribal extinction and survival, and the politics of identity in a narrative focusing on a mysterious serial killer who haunts the Seattle area. 21. Coupland, Microserfs, 4, 5. 22. Coupland, Microserfs, 338. 23. Coupland, Microserfs, 355. 24. Coupland, Microserfs, 355. 25. Coupland, Microserfs, 3. 26. Gilbert-Rolfe, Beauty and the Contemporary Sublime, 118. 27. Gilbert-Rolfe, Beauty and the Contemporary Sublime, 80. 28. Gilbert-Rolfe, Beauty and the Contemporary Sublime, 113.
Spectrality and the Postregional Interface | 29
29. In addition to Coupland’s trademark popular-culture allusions (including the use of brand-name products), the novel’s many references to games and its plot’s overall stress on the competition for investments, hightech employees, and ownership of intellectual property indirectly register another contemporary sociocultural and economic context. This is the rise to the foreground in the commercial sector of so-called game theory and strategic analysis, as exemplified by such books as Michael Porter’s Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analyzing Industries and Competitors (New York: Free Press, 1980). 30. Coupland, Microserfs, 364. 31. Coupland, Microserfs, 369. 32. Coupland, Microserfs, 371. 33. See Featherstone, “Localism, Globalism, and Cultural Identity,” 66–67, for more on the emergence of postmodern neo-tribalism and its ambivalent relationship to global marketing.
2. Everyday Regionalisms in Contemporary Critical Practice krista comer
At issue here is the circulation of images of westernness in various global consumer marketplaces—in particular, images of surfer “girls” that include women. The case is for a gender-inflected critical practice able to accommodate new global performances of the western local. I am aiming for a demonstration of one kind of new critical regionalism, one discussion of “postwests” or (in Mike Davis fashion) future Wests already certainly here. I proceed in this way to recognize how older western social identities (like the mountain man/pioneer/ cowboy) take on new meanings (i.e., surfers/surfer girls) alongside the emergence of new forms of identity, sociality, commerce, and politics. To make clear the multiple genealogies underwriting this kind of project and a postwestern critical enterprise more generally, I lay out in an extended introduction what I see as the two overlapping traditions informing a volume of collected essays such as this one—the New Western History (and the dialogue of western literature and critics with it) as well as the “spatial turn” in critical theory. Ultimately, I urge western studies to embrace expansive, flexible interdisciplinary methodologies, since the kinds of western meaningmaking processes occurring today in so many parts of the world will entirely exceed processes conventionally delimited by “the literary.” I also advocate serious and respectful attention to young peoples’ commercial cultures, since within them so many newcomers come into regular contact with the everyday regionalisms they understand to be western. In the early 1990s, before the stock market soared or the implications of the fall of the Berlin Wall became clearer—that is, before
Regionalisms in Contemporary Practice | 31
the undeniable arrival of “the global” in all facets of daily American life—the New Western History was at the height of its popular visibility. As a discourse of national reckoning with a less-than-triumphal or mythic western past, the New Western History found a ready public. Sign-in books at the 1991 watershed Smithsonian exhibit The West as America indicated that museum visitors approved the language of “conquest” to describe this past by a ratio of two to one, a shift in public consciousness surprisingly in time with New Western History’s civil-rights-inspired political values.1 Western literary texts—by writers from Ivan Doig to Maxine Hong Kingston to Leslie Marmon Silko to Rudolfo Anaya—participated notably in this popular reassessment of the western past. Indeed, historians often found themselves featured in mass media alongside writers, together representing something like a “New West.” In the shadow of this media-showered public history project, mentioned on nobody’s A-list of “people to consult,” the so-called New Western Criticism came to be. Critics put themselves repeatedly into conversation with historians about the literary West and its centuryand-a-half commentary on the matter of conquest, arguing that the two fields had much common cause to make.2 But the effort across disciplines was usually one-sided.3 As the 1990s stretched on, the arrival of the global became ever more explicit and everyday. Academic as well as popular history and literary discussions in the United States moved self-consciously away from “the national” as the challenge of thinking both postnationally and transnationally (two ways to conceive of the global) took center stage. For lots of reasons, among them the changing status of “the national,” the New Western History faded from public prominence, as did luminary western writers themselves. Not so, however, with western literary studies. Belatedly, and thanks in part to the New Western History’s and western writers’ successes at producing “the American West” as a viable public intellectual project for the late 1980s and early 1990s, the New Western Criticism found newly receptive audiences, among scholars if not the general public. Prominent and promising scholars in the field were for the first time featured in the Chronicle of Higher Education; review es-
32
|
krista comer
says about the field were commissioned (Forrest Robinson for American Literary History, Stephen Tatum for Modern Fiction Studies).4 The field could be said to be flourishing. Evidence of this growing, transformed field is to be found in many sources: a new presence of West-related criticism in national scholarly journals;5 in the publication of various critical books that in topic and method or execution suggest a paradigm shift in the field at large;6 by the fact that we “inside” the field now speak with some confidence to those “outside” the field of a “New Western Criticism” or even, perhaps most interestingly, of “critical regionalism.”7 The present volume of essays obviously aims to explicate and advance the last goal in particular. As an epistemological project, western critical regionalism has partially recuperated “the regional” as not inevitably productive of conservative nationalisms, masculine or white authority, or essentialist/authentic definitions of place (all of these features of midcentury regionalisms). If, since the founding of western literary criticism in the mid-1960s, its strengths have included its deep historicism, its confrontation with high and low cultural divides, its wrestling with western masculinity, and its identification of region and space as categories of analysis able to intrude in novel ways upon operations of power, more recently, and rapidly, the field’s center has shifted. Today, gender and racial difference motivate some of the field’s most innovative rearticulations. Theoretical inquiry is sustained more systematically, cutting across well-known topics like popular culture and the West’s relationship to it, like the relationship between regionalism and nationalism but now including postnationalism, like the status of historical narrative and the intimacies between “the literary” and “the historical.” Critics show a much more sophisticated sense of what Nat Lewis (following Baudrillard) calls western literature’s role in the production of the real, the authentic.8 We may even have been freed to focus at last on “the literary,” if by that is meant freedom in critical practice to release the literary West from the hold of the “real” historical West, and therefore to enter discussions of representation. The field’s current struggles have to do with the partiality of the
Regionalisms in Contemporary Practice | 33
recuperation successes, and here let us take the Western Literature Association (wla) as a loose “real time” or “live” barometer of the field on the ground. Explicitly I mean that, in this matter of recuperation, the performance of new social relationships and understandings between people (not just the production of improved ideas) is very much part of the recuperative equation—having the potential to inspire or disappoint larger social engagement. In terms of nonwhite ethnic studies, in my view wla is best at borderlands studies. It is most challenged (as is the American Studies Association and U.S. academia at large) when it comes to Native American studies and the explosive challenges posed by its epistemologies, multilingualism, its relationship to nationalism and definitions of modernity. Related to the challenge of the indigenous is that posed by Asian/Pacific Islander studies and people, as my own recent work on global surf culture has taught me. That last social geography is not yet much on the map of university-based western critical imaginations. Finally, feminist western literary and cultural studies remains in its infancy, in spite of key inspirational texts in the field and the leadership of wla by feminist scholars. This state of affairs was brought clearly home in the processes that saw to publication the two review essays I mentioned earlier (those commissioned by Modern Fiction Studies and American Literary History). Editors of each journal, apparently on the alert to a new critical trend and wishing to showcase it, forwarded to reviewers texts demonstrative of either the most stereotypical sense of the West, such as “frontier” texts, or texts exclusively by male scholars and often about masculinity.9 Fortunately, in both cases, reviewers wrote capaciously grounded field surveys. Still, concern is warranted about how the New Western Criticism and its evolution will be represented, especially how feminist genealogies will figure as acknowledged resources for rethinking western cultural landscapes, especially when it comes to masculinity. Critics need to actively educate nonspecialists about what might seem less obvious genealogies forwarding this new West. Without that kind of careful, principled record keeping, the risk of replicating a mythic white-male center runs strong.
34
|
krista comer
Taking our struggles as growing pains rather than failures, our ongoing large disjunctions across the field’s various constituencies have to do (for me) with how it is that critics aim to conceptualize “place,” what knowledges we understand ourselves to be producing and for whom, and with what kinds of political and social effects. How do we talk about “place” when, as Ursula Heise recently remarked, the vocabularies of “‘authentic belonging,’ the ‘spirit of place,’ ‘rootedness,’ and ‘dwelling’” have been persuasively criticized for their essentialist assumptions, their potential politics of exclusion, and their neglect of the mobility of the local?10 At the same time, again drawing on Heise, critical rhetorics much celebrated during the 1990s—nomadology, hybridity, migration, exile, border crossing, traveling cultures—have also been critiqued extensively and persuasively. So how do we talk about “place” now? What methods of scholarly practice will critics ultimately stand behind from our various institutional locations of the future? Questions such as these clearly locate the field debates and theoretical impulse of the New Western Criticism within the broader “spatial turn” in critical theory, a trend emerging across the humanities and social sciences since the late 1970s. Various new spatial keywords— ”regionalism,” “regionalization,” “territorial complexes,” “deterritorialized publics,” “borderlands,” “glocalisms,” “the transregional”— have come to the fore of critical theory because they seem especially well suited to an analysis of present-day global economic restructuring. They map, according to Christopher Connery, “the materiality of new capitalist spaces,” and insist (in Arjun Appadurai’s formulation) on more process-based geographies than aggregate-trait geographies—a reworking of the Eurocentric social geography of area studies toward postcolonial remappings of the global political.11 Attention to regional (versus exclusively nation-based) political economy is one of the more novel ways to theorize new economic structures of production, labor, global migration, and culture. In one of the first usages of the rhetoric of “critical” regionalism, geographer Edward Soja sees its analytic powers as able to “synthesize the urban and global.”12 But any number of thinkers—from sociology, anthropol-
Regionalisms in Contemporary Practice | 35
ogy, global studies, critical Asian studies, urban studies—might be brought to bear to answer this challenge of reconceptualizing “the local” or “place” and then working, through it, to formulate theories of newer global communities and relations (and vice versa).13 A revamped “regional” perspective might be understood, then, to underwrite American studies in its postnational or critical American studies phase. Critical western regionalism would seem to offer fresh and untapped thinking for contemporary academic discourse about how to theorize place, space, subjectivity, and transregional social formations. Two crucial influences have carried a revamped western regionalism to the fore. The first, the New Western History, is obviously if sometimes contentiously acknowledged, and the dialogue between western criticism and history is direct, if one-way. But most of us (including myself ) seem just now to be “catching up” to the location of our own work in the larger spatial turn in critical theory, an unawareness no doubt owing to a similar delayed recognition of the importance of these topics to the larger field of American studies, which as an organization, in its 2005 annual meeting, finally put the American Studies Association in explicit conversation with “Space and Place in American Cultures.” As I see it, if the New Western History has been one “local” (meaning quasi-national) discursive context facilitating the emergence of the New Western Criticism, another more internationally driven and cross-disciplinary (but not history-based) resource comes out of critical genealogies making up the spatial turn. Critical western regionalism, in this guise, speaks through a changed vocabulary or countervocabulary of westernness; its keywords are “borders,” “the urban,” “postmodernity,” “migration,” “indigeneity,” “mestizaje,” “globalization,” “desire,” “women” (though not usually feminism), “the simulacra,” “the global/local.” Surfing Transregional Circuits of the New World Order I’m not sure whether I speak to the choir when I assert that the dominant cultural work of western narratives today, both in the U.S. and global marketplace, is to exploit ideas about and images of the Amer-
36
|
krista comer
ican West in order to sell products and political positions. That is, what we might presently want to call “regional identity” more than ever travels the circuits of global capitalism, suggesting to viewers and to consumers of durable and nondurable goods that however diffuse it might be, they are engaged in the production of some kind of “western meaning.” The products might include obvious ones like trucks or cigarettes or less obvious structures of feeling attached to them like “the authentic” or, the historical staple of Westerns, “the masculine real.” Signs of “western” might also carry the power of state sponsorship—as in the case of President Bush’s retreats to Crawford Ranch, invocation of the mythical line at the Alamo to separate cowards from heroes in the war on terror, and the posting of Old West–style “Wanted” lists after 9/11. The concern here is how we map these circuits of meaning, chart their political implications. How do we make sense of what Matt Herman wonderfully calls “everyday regionalisms,” the structures of feeling and doing that get articulated through the performance of regional vernaculars?14 How are we to understand, in Lawrence Buell’s terms, “complex forms of affiliation involving identification with particular places that at the same time generate and authorize a translocal, transregional, transnational sense of collective belonging and purpose”?15 In the case of the Bush example, nineteenth-century meanings of righteous western expansion have been reinvigorated and put in the service of current political agendas. These redeployments of western iconography and popular memory have displaced “the West” of the New Western History, permitting multiple current wars to be waged in defense of the values of “Western civilization.” Surfing, I submit, is very much in play in this historical moment as both a western American and a global signifying system. For instance, I would notice how familiar a western profile the surfer cuts across many media. Think about classic “Old Western” visual themes like that of the lone male and white figure framed against a redemptive/unpeopled (read depopulated) western landscape. It can be pioneer surveying open land, cowboy riding into the cinematic distance, proud Marlboro man atop his horse, or solitary surfer against sea-
Regionalisms in Contemporary Practice | 37
scape at sunset. These are related visual economies, mutually constitutive. Surfers are the most recent enactments of an older, familiar western cast of characters—whether mountain man, gold miner, settler, cowboy-rancher. (I will deal shortly with the legacy for surfer girls of the settler woman.) As visuals, most of these have traveled the world for nearly two hundred years, producing profit and various knowledges about the American, the real, the Other, the masculine, the sublime, the bohemian, the “edge.” The implicit plot formula rehearsed by this older figure is what is important, and the fact that surfers as contemporary heroes at the same time tell a new twenty-firstcentury tale. This tale, I believe, charts a critical (if ambivalent) response to current ideologies of consumerism. It forwards a renovated form of white masculinity that the subculture of surfing has been fine-tuning since the late 1950s. It privileges forms of rigorous global outdoor sport/pleasure, like surfing, as collective performances of a new kind of transnational politics. Surf culture is very Green these days (and global in its Greenness), very intergenerational. It is also, especially in commercial culture, “girl friendly.” I’m suggesting that new social formations of global westernness are under construction. In Appadurian terms, they constitute imaginative “staging grounds for action, and not only for escape.”16 As discourse about both the American West and Western civilization, I would put surfing in some kind of complicated cosmopolitan and secular contest with Bush’s Christian cowboy diplomacies. With regard to racial formation, the subculture’s renovation of white masculinity has sent surfers in global pursuit of “the perfect wave” for half a century, establishing an international or diasporic surfing public along the way, and with it, many a postcolonial conundrum. These, again, to critics of the West, should be partly familiar dilemmas. The white western protagonist often simultaneously co-opts features of indigeneity (he “goes native”) even as he bordercrosses as critique of normative wasp discourse. He comes to compromise the very thing/person/image he admired and needed in order to formulate different visions of manhood. Surfing’s love affair with Hawaiian native manhood and islander “Aloha” spirit (and women)
38
|
krista comer
is no exception; neither is surf culture’s (and southern California’s) unconscious claim upon Greater Mexico and its structures of everyday feeling and doing. Any “new” or critical regionalism will not forget to ask after the implications of these last points for the traditional West’s “others.” By the same token, I would not dismiss as simple appropriation these border-crossing efforts; it makes no sense to condemn people for the contradictions they face even while the responses they chart in efforts to address contradiction must be held to account. The fact remains that surfers in the postwar (post-1945) period have been in search of much more than perfect waves; they have been after fundamentally better ways of everyday living, including living more interracial and flexibly masculine lives. The double duty that surfers perform in contemporary culture— invoking a familiar iconographic past in order to comment and intervene on a changed present—is nowhere more tangible than in the figure of the surfer girl. Her high-profile presence in global surf discourse suggests that older formulas are being updated and made relevant not only to an age of cyberspace and global economic restructuring but to girl power in all its implications. If the trope of singular figure in contest with the depopulated wild is one we might read as typically productive of individualist, imperial, masculinist national subjectivity, now put in place instead the figure of the youthful female surfer. Her appearance as the subject, not object, of these masculinist visual economies suggests that even wilderness (“extreme”) landscapes—the ultimate proving ground of the national masculine past—are open to young female navigation. Heir not only to the pioneer/cowboy’s rugged individualism but to the pioneer woman’s/cowgirl’s scrappy toughness, the girl who can surf knows historic opportunity when she sees it and takes pride in being no man’s fragile flower. As I have archived in the book project from which this essay draws, images of surfer girls in American popular culture since the mid-1990s have gone from occasional and exotic visual anomalies to being mainstay representational figures of global twenty-first-century womanhood. That is, approximately in the same period when the New Western History faded from public view and President Bush’s
Regionalisms in Contemporary Practice | 39
version of the West ascended to national prominence, a competing vision of the West—embodied by the surfer and surfer girl and underwritten by a notoriously antiauthoritarian subculture—massively proliferated. The clear-eyed, super-fit, level-headed female surfer stood as poster child for all that young women might become in the twenty-first century. If it were not for the fact that metaphors of surfing circulate today in cultural contexts that have nothing to do with sand and swells and seagulls, the story of surfing would begin and end relatively locally. But such is not the case. Since the end of the cold war, the values and language associated with surf culture have articulated some of the most consequential changes in global economic and social life. Most far-reachingly, people all over the world now “surf ” the internet: we don’t swim it, fly it, or use some other verb to express the “doing” of it. “Surfing” has emerged as the metaphor of choice to describe users’ experiences of new world-transforming media.17 Like most master metaphors, this one has been normalized, come to seem natural, nearly overnight. To interrupt the normalization process, I ask why the metaphor of “surfing the web” caught on in so many languages during the 1990s, instead of some alternative metaphor. What is it about surfing, surf culture and history, that captured that decade’s popular imagination and collective longings? And what does any of this have to do with actual women surfers, representations of surfer girls, or girl power? As a topic for critical regionalism, I think it is fairly clear that there would be no glamour or cultural power to rhetorics of “surfing” without all the simultaneous western regional meanings that have attached to it in the United States and the historical ability of “America’s West” to signal a global colonial discourse about Western civilization. Surfing’s global status as metaphor depends upon a renewable western (including Californian) regional identity. I have taken up the vexed status of California and its western credentials elsewhere, and I wish to reiterate that in that debate I come out on the side of California as very much part of the West. From the early gold strikes to the post-1945 period, it is hard to imagine a migration destination more indicative of western allure than California,
40
|
krista comer
and after the first Gidget movie appeared in 1958, one more associated with landscapes of idealized youth, “all-American kids,” and fresh starts: that is, the West again as America. The Beach Blanket movies (set in motion by Gidget) and the furious cinematic response of the subculture to Hollywood’s popularized versions of surfing produced a rich supply of postwar western/Californian heroes and anti-heroes, often blending “the Californian” with “the Hawaiian.” Although subcultural production of manhood in particular differed from Hollywood formulas, both visualized the surfer girl—perhaps most memorably in the person of blond, perky Sandra Dee, the original Gidget. My point here is that this surfer girl, this “California girl” of Beach Boys fame, herself became eventually available as a vaguely western icon, traveling the world with a certain reputation. Underneath the sun-touched streaky-blond California “look,” she remains a rough-and-tumble cowgirl, able to do what it takes in masculinist cultural landscapes—this time not the range or ranch but the lineup offshore where surfers wait for waves. Keeping in mind the image of the California girl and representations of “liberated femininity” in global consumer culture and girlpower target markets, I want to move this discussion to a new form of fashion advertising recently birthed by surf-industry heavyweight Quiksilver Corporation. In 2003, Quiksilver began to promote its girl’s wear logo (Roxy Girl) through corporate-hired literature. In terms of the political economy producing this literary product, consider that Quiksilver has, since 1986, been trading on the New York Stock Exchange to the tune of an average $600 million annual gross sales. Around the world Quiksilver exercises an immeasurable influence on surf culture, competitive surfing events, and the style of surfing, not to mention various local non-U.S. economies that gear up for the infusion of U.S. dollars these events import. The female logo, Roxy, since it has little appreciable competition, to an even greater degree influences women’s surfing. In addition to manufacturing surf apparel and accessories, Roxy underwrites major amateur as well as professional women’s surfing events around the world, and Roxy’s own “team riders” are none other than the world’s best female
Regionalisms in Contemporary Practice | 41
surfers, most notably five-time world champion Lisa Anderson, sixtime champion Layne Beachley, as well as younger up-and-coming champions like Chelsea Georgeson and Sofia Mulanovich.18 (All of these young women but Mulanovich have the “Cali girl” look, even if Beachley and Georgeson are Australians.) Since surfing has usually had something of a bad-boy image and parents of teenage girls flee from anything predatory when it comes to their daughters, Quiksilver hit upon the idea to expand its market share by revising the Roxy Girl image so it might suggest “nice sporty girls who also read.” In October 2003 the first novel in a new series for young adult females debuted under the name Luna Bay: A Roxy Girl Series, with the Roxy pro rider Veronica Kay (the quintessential California girl) shown surfing on the novel’s cover. Subsequent novels generally featured a good read about surfer-related themes while displaying the Roxy logo on bookjacket covers and offering Roxy clothing products and other prizes (one was surf sessions with the pros) as part of contests the publisher (HarperEntertainment) ran.19 Like most advertising campaigns it was a short-lived phenomenon, but over about eighteen months a half dozen novels were distributed while several others were in press, and on the Roxy website one could find a book club, just above a link entitled “be a model!”20 Site visitors could join the book clubs or discuss books, and a Roxy editor responded to girls’ comments. Discussions always included the girls’ hometowns, which showed a remarkable internationalism: Australia, Puerto Rice, England, Fiji, South Africa, Japan, as well as less predictable parts of the United States (Midwest, New Jersey). Marketing ploy or not, these global addresses are not random. The international women’s surfing pro tour (sponsored, remember, by Roxy) stops in surfing communities in all of the non-U.S. nations but England. Indeed, these pro-tour events and local surf communities make up some of the transregional hot spots or Appadurian “finanscapes” of global surfing economies. In terms of the novels’ story lines, each one takes up the newest adventure in the lives of five best girlfriends who also are competitive surfers. They live in a fictional beachside town in southern Cali-
42
|
krista comer
fornia, somewhere (I would put it) between Los Angeles and San Diego. The girlfriends themselves represent classic types of surfers: hard-core short-board “shredders,” big-wave surfers, longboarders, soul surfers, and one, the central protagonist, who combines these types. Importantly, the social base of their friendships is a small business—a surf shop run by the central protagonist’s parents. So readers’ introductions into the everyday structure of surfers’ lives come at least as much through water scenes as through “hip commerce”: the cool surf shop, where the girls are employed as camp counselors for summer surf camps. The economy of contemporary surf culture—its local shops, instructional camps, international competitive circuit, product-endorsement opportunities for celebrity/competitive surfers, provision of “desirable” modeling work for young women (modeling their sport, not their bodies)—mediates young women’s relationships to surfing, to one another, to adult authority and institutions, and to globalization, since the business of surfing in this series clearly is global. Significantly, the series features the presence of a three-time world champion as the mother of the central protagonist, a kind of second-wave (blond though graying) feminist role model for all the young women in her social orbit, and in whose footsteps the daughter tries, with a great deal of anxiety, to walk. Though again short-lived, the series captured many of the defining tensions in girls’ surf culture at the beginning of the twenty-first century. Consider, for example, the series’ generational profile and its address to a global youth market. Luna Bay is aimed at nine- to twelveyear-olds, and while promotional materials note the series’ “surfer themes,” the overarching thematics of the texts have to do with their sense of issues current to Generation Y (born between 1980 and 2000) as they intersect with very generalized “surfer girl” challenges.21 In an age of popular moral panics in the United States about self-loathing “Ophelias” and competitive “queen bees”—panics largely about U.S. Gen Y female youth—this new Roxy girl is one whose mental health is stable, guaranteed by sports activities.22 None of these Roxy girls are “mean girls.” They back one another when the going gets tough, and they bring each other back to sisterly sanity when anyone
Regionalisms in Contemporary Practice | 43
gets too boy-distracted. While protagonists sometimes enjoy the encouragement of male peers, if they do not, the new surfer girl “rips” (surfs aggressively) anyway, cheered on by her girlfriends. For her, no surf spot is too heavy, no hard-core male locals scene too hostile. All the while the new surfer girl respects her femininity—she does not denounce “girl-ness,” insisting it be valued, taken seriously. She is not a “tomboy”; she does not secretly wish to have been born a boy. In keeping with so much Gen Y discourse about body issues, the body coding of this new surfer girl is both conventionally idealized and a critique of sexist body prescriptions. A central textual drama is girls’ navigation of beauty culture such that they are not inevitably reinscribed by it in ways that dramatize internalized sexism. Girls are fit, strong; they feel good about their strength and what it permits them to do in the water. At the same time, the cultural imperative of “athletic hetero-sexy” keeps them ever anxious that their shoulders, stomachs, legs, hair, and so forth will mark them as too athletic, too this or not enough that. In the characters’ relationships to food, readers have some feeling for the middle-class health norms governing the series. At the same time, for example, one character’s glee about airplane food demonstrates the novelty for her of a first experience aboard any airplane, a glee revelatory of lower-than-middle-class roots. In an effort to narrativize the very mixed-class makeup and complicated class allegiances of surf communities globally, the series tries to break through the numbness of much young-adult literature to the topic of class. The inscription of racial coding upon bodies is also in keeping with typical Gen Y visual economies: these are tales that represent bonds between often mixed-race young women. The series’ central protagonist is blond, and through blondness readers understand that she is white. Her name, Luna, is given by her parents for its Spanish meaning and to link her to the place they live, Luna Bay (a Spanish place-name). Two others of the crew also are white, Rae and Cricket. Another of the surfer girls, Kanani, is mixed race by birth, Hawaiian and white. She is adopted however, and her adoptive parents are white. Isobel is dark haired, and somewhat clichéd Spanish dialogue
44
|
krista comer
illustrates and celebrates “Hispanic family values,” setting her up as Mexican American. But racial difference (versus something like “cultural difference”) is not finally defined as topical. Navigating the sexism of the larger cultural moment unites these girls. To fight it, they band together. There is no suggestion that race would meaningfully divide them. What is youthfully feminist about these tales is the bravado that animates girl culture, its willingness to identify as well as resist overt sexism, and to show girl-gang loyalty in the face of pressures for young women to destructively compete with one another. The Luna Bay series, then, is in broad dialogue with popular culture’s representation of Gen Y girls and their gangs and crews. Consider, for instance, the Hollywood blockbuster film Blue Crush (and the cinema of girl power underwriting it)23 and two reality tv shows, wb’s Boarding House and mtv’s Surf Girls. For well over a decade, feminist images and rhetorics have been incorporated into the ideological center of consumer culture and its dialogue with female purchasing power. Girls’ principal schooling in “feminist ideals” often comes directly and exclusively through promotional materials surrounding teen market products. Male-female power struggles figure explicitly in Luna Bay, and girls note it as such and battle it as such. Although the word “sexism” never appears, these girls are not its innocent or complicit victims. Insofar as racial diversity is the norm of most popular youth Gen Y story lines, and “cross-cultural respect” is the constant and given narrative informing “diversity” in mainstream U.S. popular youth culture, we might say that notions of tolerance have been aggressively incorporated into youth markets. White-nonwhite tensions simply do not figure in Luna Bay. The reason they do not, I would argue, has to do with the fact that “race” does not figure, as a word or concept. Moments of “difference,” even as they are explicitly encoded upon girls’ bodies as racial (blond hair; thick, dark hair), always get read as “cultural.” Not surprisingly, then, there is no sense that there ever was or could presently be something like white advantage. (Silences such as this one make it more possible to overlook the fact that the blond
Regionalisms in Contemporary Practice | 45
people of the text own the surf shop and center the dramatic and economic structure of the tales. I will say more about such silences in my conclusion.) Border crossing and “mixedness” is at the center of this female narrative, suggesting that some new white racial formation is being staged. California as a region seems a “natural” site for the demographics (white/Mexican/Asian/Pacific Islander) generating this structure of feeling; one then projected globally through the California girl. The parent company of Roxy, Quiksilver, represents to potential investors its corporate strength in exactly these teen markets, quoting on its website the impressive fact that the teenage market has over $200 billion of discretionary spending power each year in the United States alone! Girl “power” in this vein has very much to do with purchasing power, across race. At the same time, “tolerance” has never been so lucrative, or so necessary to continued profitability. A number of coming-of-age stories are working in this series—that of second- and third-wave feminism, of Gen Y American girls, of girlfriendly surf culture as a liberalized or updated version of masculinist surf history. There is also the coming-of-age of the discursive formation of “surfing the web,” whose rhetorics and cultural logics are a preferred way of understanding first worlders’ sense of the new world order. In terms of theorizing these very contemporary comingof-age narratives, I would locate them in the context of a formal convention—the bildungsroman of the late eighteenth century and early nineteenth century—which played a specific historical role: that of representing and narrativizing a nascent capitalist modernity. As Franco Moretti argues, such a task was accomplished by inventing “youth” as a modern social location capable of articulating tensions between more “traditional” social contracts and the individualism that modernity occasioned.24 These tensions of course are clearly, if not exclusively, male-biased and Eurocentric, meaning the social compact has always constrained women’s individual liberties far more than it has men’s, and “maturity,” as Rosemary George shows, often means coming home to Westernized conclusions and geographies.25 In terms of gender life cycle, the apprenticeship or bildungsroman plot traditionally assumes its protagonist’s ultimate claims upon a skill or trade, and especially a
46
|
krista comer
modern, western, social location, in excess of marriage and/or parenthood. Travel abroad—to the colonies perhaps—and sexual initiation aid the journey—for men. By contrast, women’s unchaperoned travel or sexual experience destroys successful resolution: female major life “choice” is that of partner and/or motherhood.26 But clearly, the women’s liberation movement in the United States has altered all of these foregone conclusions, and the biographies and coming-of-age stories of contemporary surfers suggest that the (male) life-cycle options of the classic bildungsroman might now be open to women. Such is the implicit claim made by the Roxy Girl series. We have in them a credible support network for female comingof-age—a female world-champ mentor, a group of accomplished and motivating peers, injunction to travel and (with definite constraints) gain sexual knowledge, and a larger global context (that of a transnational surf economy) approving their efforts. Still, if possibilities have opened for female development, the series simultaneously reads as a contemporary version of the older tradition of what Nancy Armstrong calls the conduct book.27 It is clear what “good girls” ought to do as they negotiate this demanding moment in global female history: they should compete, achieve, support one another in similar goals, take care with their appearance (but not somehow too much care), and marry. They should enact “cultural sensitivity,” since so many people will be racially mixed. In other words, that which is required now, for successful contemporary girlhood, is somehow implicitly gender-liberated and racially (“culturally”) tolerant. Girls will not merely hope for female public accomplishment in addition to fulfilling the role of wife (and eventually mother) in family life; these roles are new social mandates. As Nancy Armstrong argues, courtesy literature is implicated, along with the novel, in the feminization of culture beginning in the late eighteenth century and constitutive of the making of the middle class. It is my sense that echoes of this history operate now as a global consumer middle class is being formed. If in the nineteenth century bourgeois “civilized” womankind was under intense construction, in this moment bourgeois American girlhood is under construction.
Regionalisms in Contemporary Practice | 47
The terms of “successful” girlhood are prescriptively professionalist, and it is understood that competitive professionalism, not some dialogue with feminism, facilitates liberated femininity. It is far less clear what factors are to underwrite tolerance, beyond the fact that blurred boundaries between the “us” and the “them” have made “pure” racial categories an increasingly dated racial formation. The Roxy Girl texts, like surfer-girl discourse more generally, are part of an attempt to manage this new icon. The genealogy of such an icon’s evolution and circulation, I am suggesting, is one approach to a new critical regionalism. Before I turn to the essay’s final section, let me make my challenges to critical regionalism more explicit. As some readers may anticipate, I would situate my discussion of global girl power within a larger impulse to clarify what Signs recently called (in a special issue devoted to the topic) the “gender of globalization.”28 Gender has too rarely been an important analytic of the “big books” on globalization (Harvey, Soja, Appadurai, Jameson), prompting much feminist puzzlement and dissent. Carla Freeman asks why—when feminism so persuasively demonstrates the centrality of gender to all networks of production, consumption, and distribution—we get so much gender-neutral macroanalysis of the structure and history of new economic forms alongside microanalyses of women’s “fit” into them as (supposedly) gender-free workers or nationals.29 That is, if university feminism has been thoroughly changed by critical regionalisms of the postcolonial variety (i.e., Said, Spivak, Mohanty), has critical regionalism been transformed by feminism? Clearly, for me the answer is “not really.” Can anyone imagine a “serious” project that puts girl power and discourses of play at the center of global studies or contemporary world history? The skepticisms facing such a project are very revealing, and it is to them and it that I now turn. Legacies of Endless Summer One of the more interesting facets of the girl-power phenomenon is its availability to females who are no longer girls—that is, to mature women, usually baby boomers. As a final gesture toward postwest-
48
|
krista comer
ern critical horizons and methods, I report briefly on ethnographic work I have done in Sayulita, a fishing village on the Pacific coastline of Mexico, about forty-five minutes north of Puerto Vallarta by car. I went to Sayulita to study a women’s surf camp, Las Olas, which advertises itself as a “reverse finishing school” that makes “girls out of women.” In what ways, I wondered, is such a reversal appealing? I also wanted to assess female surf culture’s embrace of the discourse of “the surfari,” since the number of women making global surf treks has, until recently, been very small and the increase owes in part to female-only surf expeditions and the new girl-friendly face of contemporary surfing businesses. The goal took on a different urgency after terrorist attacks by Al Queda in Bali, in October 2003, targeted a nightclub very well known on the international professional surfing circuit to be a surfers’ hangout. Of the nearly two hundred people who died in Bali (346 wounded), many were there for surf holiday. The ethnographic thesis is that surf tourism for women (in the instance of Sayulita, mainly U.S. white women) is a case study in international and postnational female subject formation. Surfing international waters, and servicing those who do so, is one way some women as laborers and consumers articulate what it means to occupy the world as global citizens. I understand the “surfer as tourist” as a complicated phenomenon, since surfers, whether at their home breaks or away, are as much “toured upon” as those who tour, meaning that surfers are always a form of spectacle, a situation triply true for female surfers. So I am working from a model of tourism that does not castigate tourists themselves but rather examines that middle ground where local and global touristic forces come together.30 I am interested in the fact that global citizenry seems to be realized for the consumers through the categories of “play,” “travel,” and “the female body” as they come in contact with both surfing men, local “others,” and the world’s oceans. I have been tracking the role of play in the history of contemporary U.S. women’s liberation in particular, asking, are certain forms of intense play/sport, like surfing, implicitly politicizing or consciousness-changing activities? Since second-wave American feminism in-
Regionalisms in Contemporary Practice | 49
herits from both wasp and U.S. leftist cultures an aversion to this kind of “frivolity,” and since younger women’s tendency toward play today often is met with bitter second-wave disappointment, I am all the more interested in the relationship of American second wavers to the concept and activity of play, and I am also challenged as I try to make sense of groups of women for whom women’s liberation means something about the female body’s ability to play hard, play rough, to play for keeps, as though one’s life depends on it. I have been repeatedly challenged by skeptical colleagues about whether or not this kind of broadly understood athleticism can be considered feminist. What shall we understand from this persistent line of questioning? Shall it be determined in advance what counts as feminist? These questions bring us back to the problems of defining “the political” that underlie, I believe, so much dismissal of subcultural and countercultural movements as protopolitical, too personal and not enough political, nostalgic, and so forth. The local population of Sayulita is about three thousand (nonresident population today about two thousand). Sayulita is a town whose character, local economy, and real property ownership profile has thoroughly shifted in the last fifteen years, but especially the last five, by the appearance of tourists and tourist dollars, both coming mainly from the United States. To the extent that there is any money in Sayulita today, it comes no longer from family fishing economies but from service businesses related to tourism and nonresidents—food, lodging, curios, and sport activities. Surfing is the principal tourist attraction, since Suyalita’s natural resources include a pretty consistent reef break. It supports beginners—the current cash cow of the surf industry—at the same time the town itself is simple enough that more seasoned surfers, who like their travels rustic, make the trek as lesson givers, sports experts, water professionals, surf-shop staff, tourists (including surfing parents on holiday with their surfing children), and, of course, more capitalized business owners, like the snowboarder-turned-surfer who founded Las Olas, Bev Sanders. Hers is the principal surf business in town. In the context of surf camps currently in international opera-
50
|
krista comer
tion—upwards of one thousand across the globe—Las Olas is more the norm than the exception in its overall philosophy of surfing and its understanding of gender relations. To the degree that these surf camps overtly theorize the status of women, and the women’s camps and businesses often do, they do so in classic (meaning essentialist) ecofeminist terms. Women are “instinctive caretakers,” the mission statement of Las Olas asserts. “Empower us and the whole world benefits.” The strategy or path to empowerment lies in play and the link between girlhood and play. “Our strength can be discovered by the little girl inside who just loves to play in the waves.” By providing an opportunity for women to develop a “friendship with the ocean,” Las Olas hopes to facilitate a new connection to the waves and to foster a sense of the ocean as “a living breathing thing.” Taking her lead from the third-wave ecofeminist Julia Butterfly Hill, a recurrent visitor to Las Olas, Sanders sees human connection to the natural world as a precursor to environmentalist activism. That relationship, she believes, “enables women to speak up for what we believe in, the rights of our families and communities, or on behalf of an abused ocean or forest.” Sanders’s ecofeminist successes in her hometown of Benicia, above San Francisco, suggest the political efficacy (especially in U.S. contexts) of her mission statement. The footprint she leaves in Mexico is a more complicated matter. Ethnographic work with the “older women” of the camp (over forty-five) suggests that their play, inside and out of the surf, is in very interesting dialogue with contemporary discourses about girl power. The first camp I visited included a group of some twenty-five campers, about a dozen of whom were women from the Bay Area who call themselves “the Hot Flashes.” These women play sports together at home, support one another’s families (most are parents, and many are single parents), and traveled to Sayulita in honor of one woman’s fiftieth birthday. It was their occupancy of public space that I found most notable, for their group behavior had the unselfconscious effect of taking over and dominating local restaurants, the beach break, and the camp culture in general. In their unselfconsciousness they acted very often like U.S. teenage girls. Through performances like public
Regionalisms in Contemporary Practice |
loud singing mini-skits (“California Girls” a song of choice), done in costume, or parodies in nightclubs of sexualized dancing, these women used their voices and their bodies (and most of them were large) to engage in outrageous violations of decorous female public behavior. They reported it all to be in the name of play, of having fun. In many ways the Hot Flashes embodied the freedom that Bev Sanders imagines girls possess. As a group they became fine examples of reverse finishing school experience, taking for themselves the prerogatives that usually fall to men in public spaces, and in so doing, opening up a much larger space for the whole group of women surfers to play and be powerful as girls/women. As a critical perspective from which to enter discussions of globalization and transregionalisms, how are we to analyze this kind of “girl culture”? From a female surf history perspective, one of the things going on at Las Olas is the meeting up, on Mexican soil, of various newcomers to surfing. These are typically U.S. beginners who, in Mexico, encounter for the first time representatives from much older and established northern as well as southern California surfing communities. The representatives of these developed communities are quite aware that if people travel to Sayulita to learn to surf today, seasoned surfers have been trekking south of the border since the 1950s: to Baja or San Felipe, and then later to Puerto Escondido (also known as “the Mexican Pipeline”). What ultimately is being passed on at a surf camp like Las Olas, and in most surf camps, is not just surf skill (how to paddle and stand up) but a sense of the geographical imagination and history of surf culture, and at Las Olas, female surf culture. Experienced surfers (including the teachers of Las Olas) have been schooled over the course of their subcultural lives in what we might call the ethos of Endless Summer (1966), the subculture’s first and still premier canonical film. Endless Summer represents the initial attempt to visualize the global by what turned out to be a very influential group of young southern California white surfers—the first to represent the culture to itself as subculture. The film crystallized in people’s minds a very specific structure of feeling having to do with surfing, music, and certain “California-ish” cultural and social mores—and
51
52
|
krista comer
then it transferred that “California feeling” to a series of related global places that eventually cohered in the 1970s and 1980s into a global surfing circuit and public culture. (These places would count among them the international surf spots noted in the Luna Bay series.) As scholars across the humanities and social sciences now routinely assert, globalization always works from some “home” or local place. For American surfers “home” has most often meant not only a home break where one surfs as a local, but simultaneously “inside” of the subculture’s movies, magazines, and more recently, videos. If surfing is a water sport or activity, and hence produces “place connections” to specific surf breaks, surf culture is always also a “lifestyle,” relying upon onshore community and infrastructure. Hence connections to surf breaks translate into specific kinds of connections to the towns, cities, or ecosystems in which surf breaks are located. The process of place-affinity I am working with, then, is quite local at the same time the “local” occurs across quasi-organized larger global and transregional networks that (in the case of surfing) are economic, military, cultural, technological, gendered, generational, and touristic. While space does not permit me to fully unpack this claim, the argument has to do with the international landscapes on which California surfers historically enacted new forms of white Protestant masculinity—landscapes both imaginative and real. The best known of these of course is Hawaii and its Aloha spirit, central both to Endless Summer and to surf culture’s evolving global imagination and political unconscious. “California-ish” structures of feeling seemed relatively compatible with the non-urgent or decelerated everyday pace associated with Hawaii, and Polynesia more generally. But how did California itself get associated with decelerations or “relaxed lifestyle” except through the fact of its earlier Califorñio identity and history? Known for grand fiestas, outdoor sport and play, generosity of friendship, the culture of the colonial Mexican/Califorñio elite informs the core of that California-ish structure of feeling so dear to and palpable in Endless Summer (and seemingly so endangered by postwar California crowding, migration, suburban sprawl). And yet also so invisible and overlooked: Mexico never appears in Endless Summer.
Regionalisms in Contemporary Practice |
What I would like to do toward a conclusion is to return to the Las Olas example and think about the kinds of geographical imaginations and histories of surf culture being taught and enacted there. I am interested in the political implications of place claims and the impact of surf culture upon various specific “homes” it has claimed over the last fifty years. What kinds of new social or imaginative formations (again invoking Appadurai) are to be found in subcultures that articulate global circulation through colonial rhetorics like “surfari”? How do such formations evidence “globalization from below”? What does it mean to put female actors deliberately at the center of our discussion alongside the broader question of the gender of globalization? In their travels in and out of Mexican spaces, women tourists and surf trainers are active U.S. citizens (presenting passports, trading U.S. dollars) at the same time they are participating in a much older regional imaginary that longtime Californians know intimately if unconsciously: that implied by “Greater Mexico.” They have a feeling for a different way of conceiving this region, not as one defined by geopolitical boundaries like the border, but as one unified by both surf breaks and longer-standing cultural, regional, and linguistic continuities. While an argument of this kind about contemporary tourist travel and play must foreground the class and racial and national privileges assumed by outrageous behaviors in foreign contexts, I want to insist that other cultural transactions are also happening—ones in which the status of whiteness, a reckoning with whiteness and its histories, is always part of what is being dramatized and negotiated. If Mexico as a cultural geography is “foreign,” it is also “home,” not only to Californians, but especially to California surfers—and this is an important point given that the history of surfing usually comes so undiluted from Hawaii. Transnational travels between a set of related places—today between Sayulita, Santa Cruz, San Francisco, and points south like San Diego—invoke “other” prior regional and cultural and racial memories: that of the California that was and remains Mexico. That of the Mexico that was and remains Native America. At the heart of most “local” or regional cultural geographies is border
53
54
|
krista comer
crossing and its histories. In the famous formulation of James Clifford, there are no “roots” without “routes.” I am still figuring out and therefore have not emphasized here the complicated implications of this kind of travel for Mexican nationals, especially the townswomen, whose social mobility is relatively more constrained. Certainly, there is everything to be said about the long history of colonial contact that peoples of the Mexican coast know well, and which predates by centuries the arrival of surfing in Sayulita and certainly shapes the reception of it. Given the primitivist discourse that hangs over a place like Sayulita, it is important to go on record that the tradition of “natives” watching “us” is hardly innocent of history. In recent times, local women have been witness, over the seven years Las Olas has been operative, to probably fifteen hundred to two thousand mostly American white women, up and down the streets of Sayulita. How do they understand females who travel without children or men, who bear muscles in tank tops as they move these heavy longboards atop their heads, who are comparatively rich and middle-age? Who, indeed, is the “postnational subject” of this critical regionalist ethnography, and what “related series of places” might the townswomen identify as meaningful to them? These questions guide the final research currently under way for the larger book project. Here I wish to return to my claim that today American girlhood is under intense scrutiny and construction, and surf discourse, including surf camps like Las Olas, is part of an effort to maneuver this new iconic figure. Although the figure varies (sometimes Polynesian, sometimes South American, sometimes dark-haired American), the backbone figure is the blond California girl. The Beach Boys song now surfs global circuits and has become a sustaining mythos of commercial culture. To the forces that can manage “her” will go considerable spoils—particularly if she performs well in nondomestic markets. Increasingly, the surfer girl’s emotional profile and body image is one of the more often exported figures of normative young American femininity—poised to become a significant new player in a global marketplace selling gender identities and ideals in a relent-
Regionalisms in Contemporary Practice |
less bid for new buyers and larger market share. As a figure for the world’s women to emulate and for the world’s men to desire, this ideal should not be dismissed as a form of “cultural lite,” because that is exactly how the politics operating through her will fail to attract and sustain critical attention. If she is an ideal in dominant visual economies, she is also a figure who will discipline women whose bodies and social values are far afield from the norms seemingly signaled through her, whether they be normative body type, age, race, or worker (professional) status, and that body’s coding of other social categories like secularity/religiosity, sexuality, maternity, national identity, and language. The genealogy of such an icon and its circulation, I have suggested, is one approach to a new critical regionalism, necessarily requiring a larger set of theoretical tools and methods than those devoted exclusively to textuality. The places and local sites it will study will be likely linked in new and novel ways. The explicit or implicit appearance in this essay of women on the ground in various parts of the world—whether Japanese girls reading Roxy Girl novels in English, to middle-age women activist/business owners like Bev Saunders of Las Olas/Benicia, to garment workers who make Roxy T-shirts, to pro surfers, to “Hot Flash” women on holiday, to the women servicing surf destinations around the globe—is the consequence of a more varied set of research tools. The everyday regionalisms they enact and reproduce are keys to the largest metanarratives governing this moment in global history: stories about the West and the rest, new technology and (one way to think about surfing) new diasporas of connection—through oceanic sport—for women. The international perspective on labor relations between consumers and workers brings into final focus my earlier observation that, in the Luna Bay series, it is white surfers, or blond California girls, at the center of surf culture’s political and cultural economy. Regarding the series’ multicultural dealings in “diversity,” I will note in conclusion that one historically underrepresented U.S. minority is absent from its California landscapes: African Americans. Were they more present in surf culture (as black surfers are, for example, in the new
55
56
|
krista comer
South Africa), it would be much harder to stage this racial discourse with no explicit reference to race. Generally, people can think of little else in regard to anyone of African origin. The point is that the “Mexican/Californian/Hawaiian” transregional racial nexus—embodied in surfers and in the California girl—is apparently a much easier one to quiet or assimilate on the topic of race. Such quieting might encourage readers to overlook the fact that Luna’s family owns the surf shop that is the structural center of this surfing world—putting the blond mother/daughter pair, two generations of California girls, at the center of this mixed-race frame. It is noteworthy that an identical racial palette (blond star with supporting cast of Latina/Hawaiian characters) can be found in Blue Crush. How much has changed, in the western drama, if white people still occupy the role of center, and mixed-race people provide “alternative” racial landscapes while also bringing up the supporting-cast rear? I wish to close in the heart of postcolonial conundrum, since the above final questions locate even the most ecofriendly, “girl-friendly,” or racially integrated surf industries precisely there. Having said that, I would not end on a note of resignation. There is no heavy sigh here at the phrase “postcolonial conundrum.” It is the hopefulness of surf subculture more generally that I would deploy as a strategic politic for the present, the investment in living alternative lives hopefully, yes as critique, but not stuck in the idiom of critique. Some might call this a gesture of nostalgia, or maybe a reinscription of imperial landscapes of western optimism, but I don’t see it that way. While all of the worries about “appropriation” and so forth absolutely apply to the kind of arguments I am making about alternative whitenesses, I nonetheless claim in this project that the countercultural experiences and knowledges that surf history generally authorized articulated the hopes that white Protestants in particular might commit themselves to lives not so identified with “productivity” and “respectability” (including professional success). California, as regional and social space, somehow stages these hopes. Thus it is possible to hold simultaneously true that surfing is a global public culture dedicated to cosmopolitan bor-
Regionalisms in Contemporary Practice |
der crossing, Green globalism, and alternative whitenesses even as it is true that blond imagery and real-time middle-age American and Australian men control the subcultural narrative and its considerable profits. Still, the subculture was founded on ambivalences about white masculinity as expressed through principles of outrage at colonial, racial injury and alliance with the Hawaiian native peoples. The communal pleasure ethics that surfing performed for them remain important present-day guides to how and why to revolutionize the overloaded Protestant work ethics that over-drive first-world lives, communities, and relations to nonhuman nature. Notes I wish to acknowledge George Lipsitz for his very generous bibliographic advice as well as his thoughtful response to an earlier version of this essay. 1. Santigian, “Revisions and Resistance.” 2. The most notable example is F. G. Robinson, New Western History. 3. An exception is Matsumoto and Blake Allmendinger, Over the Edge. 4. F. G. Robinson, “We Should Talk”; Tatum, “Postfrontier Horizons.” 5. Elliot, “Coyote Comes to Norton”; LeMenager, “Trading Stories”; Allmendinger, “The Plow and the Pen”; R. M. Irwin, “Ramona and Postnationalist American Studies”; Gonzales, “The Warp of Whiteness”; and Villa and Sánchez, “Los Angeles and the Future of Urban Cities.” 6. Comer, Landscapes of the New West; Allen, Blood Narrative; Handley, Marriage, Violence, and the Nation; Handley and Lewis, True West; Kollin, Nature’s State; Goodman, Translating Southwestern Landscapes. 7. Davis, City of Quartz; Limón, American Encounters; Saldívar, Border Matters; Lowe, Immigrant Acts. 8. Lewis, Unsettling the Literary West. 9. The texts to which I refer are Handley’s Marriage, Violence, and the Nation and Johnson’s Black Masculinity and the Frontier Myth. On no grounds do I wish to object to these texts; indeed, Handley’s book is very important to my sense of theorizing historical narrative. 10. Ursula Heise, e-mail to author, November 14, 2005. 11. Connery, “The Oceanic Feeling,” 286; Appadurai, “Grassroots Globalization,” 7. 12. Soja quoted in Connery, “The Oceanic Feeling,” 286.
57
58
|
krista comer
13. Appadurai, Modernity at Large; R. Wilson and Dissanayake, Global/Local; Canclini, Hybrid Cultures; Jameson and Miyoshi, Cultures of Globalization; Kaplan, Questions of Travel. 14. Herman, “Literature, Growth, and Criticism,” 67. 15. Lawrence Buell, e-mail to author, January 18, 2005. Also see L. Buell, Future of Environmental Criticism. 16. Appadurai, Modernity at Large, 7. 17. I am grateful to P. David Marshall for this language, which I first heard in Brisbane, Queensland, Australia, at the 2000 meeting of the Australian Cultural Studies Association. 18. Roxy’s home page can be found at http://www.usa.quiksilver.com. 19. Bettijane Levine, “Riding Wave of Fashion-Fiction Marketing,” Houston Chronicle, April 22, 2003, 3e. 20. The novels are Lantz, Luna Bay #1, Luna Bay #2, Luna Bay #3, Luna Bay #4, Luna Bay #5, Luna Bay #6; and Dubowski, Luna Bay #7. 21. Of course, all of these generational formulations are potentially facile demarcations, as demographers should readily admit. The better discussions of their explanatory usefulness, to my mind, can be found in Howe and Strauss, 13th Gen; Acland, “Fresh Contacts”; and Austin and Willard, introduction. 22. Key popular texts contributing to the moral panic include the following: on the discourse about “Ophelia,” Pipher, Reviving Ophelia; on girls and body issues, Brumburg, The Body Project; and on “mean girls” and female competition, Wiseman, Queen Bees and Wannabes. 23. For an extended discussion see Comer, “Wanting to Be Lisa,” 252. 24. Moretti, Way of the World. 25. George, “But That Was in Another Country.” 26. Fraiman, Unbecoming Women. 27. See Fraiman, Unbecoming Women, 14. 28. Signs: Journal of Women and Culture in Society 26 (2001). 29. Freeman, “Is Local: Global as Feminine: Masculine?” 30. See Wrobel, Seeing and Being Seen.
3. Critical Regionalism, Thirdspace, and John Brinckerhoff Jackson’s Western Cultural Landscapes neil campbell
The best place to find new landscapes is in the West. John Brinckerhoff Jackson, Discovering the Vernacular Landscape The thirst of the American tourist for Romance is insatiable, and the West is where he prefers to look for it. John Brinckerhoff Jackson, Landscape in Sight There’s nothing more unsettling than the continual movement of something that seems fixed. Gilles Deleuze, Negotiations
Near the end of Postmodern Geographies (1989), Edward Soja argues for the benefits of “critical regional studies” as an approach to the changing relations among the urban, the national, and the global, claiming it operates with openness, flexibility, and an “inclination to try new combinations of ideas rather than fall back to old categorical dualities.”1 In the final two chapters of that book he develops a “critical regional” approach to the analysis of Los Angeles that he later extended in both Thirdspace (1996) and Postmetropolis (2000). My purpose in this essay is to examine how Soja’s theory of “thirdspace” might help to uncover the critical regionalist credentials of an earlier, largely unrecognized figure, John Brinckerhoff Jackson. The concept of
60
|
neil campbell
“thirdspace” has different histories, but it is most notably explicated in Thirdspace: Journeys to Los Angeles and Other Real and Imagined Places, where Soja traces the term’s various uses across cultural and social studies.2 His aim is to make the reader “think differently about the meanings and significances of space and those related concepts . . . place, location, locality, landscape, environment, home, city, region, territory, and geography.”3 This is, and always has been, a central concern of western studies, too—rethinking western “spatiality” as nature and human nature in interaction and dialogue—always a complex, “real-and-imagined” spatiality, as Soja is quick to remind us. The American West as “region” and “idea” is heavily weighted with myth, national narrative, and cultural legacy and is without doubt the most real and imagined of American and global spaces. Thirdspace is a means of rethinking space in a transdisciplinary manner, demonstrating “a growing awareness of the simultaneity and interwoven complexity of the social, the historical, and the spatial, their inseparability and interdependence.”4 Soja’s “radical postmodernism” rejects the “either/or choice” perspective and recognizes instead a “both/and also logic” encouraging new combinations alongside the mixing and hybridizing of thought and idea. It becomes an “invitation to enter a space of extraordinary openness, a place of critical exchange where the geographical imagination can be expanded to encompass a multiplicity of perspectives” (emphasis added).5 Thus the “spatial imaginary” (such as that of the West) is opened up by this process of “critical exchange” and interrogation, unfixed from its binary position, such as East/West, real/imagined, or old/new, through the intervention of a third perspective “interjecting an-Other set of choices” blurring such distinctions.6 Soja calls this “critical thirding” whereby the two original positions are not dismissed but subjected to a creative and critical process of restructuring that allows for a more sensitive and complicated understanding of “expanded” space. Hence the assumed binary that “firstspace” is real, as in the material culture of the roadscape, and that “secondspace” is imagined, as in the creative responses to that roadscape in film or literature, is interrupted, “restructured” by the concept of a
John Brinckerhoff Jackson’s Landscapes |
“thirdspace” that is both real and imagined, deliberately moving between the two. Our experience of space, as in the American West, is a combination and mixture of these effects, an elaborate and perpetual “crossing” between. Borrowing heavily from Henri Lefebvre’s The Production of Space (1974) and Michel Foucault’s “Of Other Spaces” (1985–86), Soja is concerned with what he terms a “trialectics”—perceived, conceived, and lived space—which equates to spatial practice (the material expression of social relations within a space—a motel lobby, for example, where multiple activities might occur and interact—business, social, sexual); representations of space (conceptual abstractions that inform the configurations of space, such as geometry or the grid); and representational space (as imagined).7 For Lefebvre such divisions were not separable, but rather an “interweaving incantation” through which to comprehend the complex “uses” of space and to recognize their overlapping status.8 It was a spatial response to the “late 1960s,” according to Soja, as people searched for alternative models for understanding society and saw spatial interaction as a relatively unexamined concept. Precisely because of this attention to multiplicity, to “other” spaces, and to their complex interrelations, thirdspace has also emerged as a concept useful to postcolonial critics like Homi Bhabha, seeking a means to express hybridity as a process of identity and nation formation.9 In his 1990 interview “The Third Space,” for example, Bhabha speaks of hybridity as “the third space which enables other positions to emerge . . . [it] displaces the histories that constitute it, and sets up new structures of authority, new political initiatives, which are inadequately understood through received wisdom.” Importantly for Bhabha, such hybridity “bears the traces of those feelings and practices which inform it, just like a translation,” and give rise to “a new area of negotiation of meaning and representation.”10 Such definitions view cultural space as dynamic, a complex mix of traces, translations, and negotiations that resists any simplistic conceptualization of how we relate to, organize, imagine, and use space. Out of these clusters of ideas and possibilities Soja formed his concept of thirdspace.
61
62
|
neil campbell
Although the American West is an immensely complicated and multiple cultural space, it has too often been defined by similar binary and reductionist thinking, expressing the region uncritically as myth and reality, true and false, utopia and dystopia, rural and urban, when, in fact, it has always existed as a blurred, contested zone: both region and more than region, as imagined dreamspace as well as real, material space. Western studies have long sought to challenge such binary approaches by questioning defining texts like Frederick Jackson Turner’s frontier thesis, or by taking popular culture seriously, or by exploring the “hidden histories” of race and gender and engaging with the complexities of border studies. Without doubt Soja’s thirdspace helps us to theorize these developments, linking western studies with many key movements in critical, cultural studies, but also, and in some ways even more importantly, linking these concepts back to earlier American predecessors. In his history of thirdspace, Soja fails to look closer to home and to go back beyond the “late 1960s” to the work of another cultural geographer, John Brinckerhoff Jackson, who, although born in France in 1909 and influenced by French geographers Deffontaines, de la Blache, Demangeon, and le Lannou, was an American who lived and worked for much of his life in the American West—in New Mexico and California, specifically.11 By working with and through critical regionalism and the concept of thirdspace, I would like to reassess Jackson’s significance to western studies in three ways: as a trailblazer of new thinking and transdisciplinary approaches, whose definition of culture opened up academic thought and practice before British cultural studies;12 as a writer whose work within (primarily) western cultural geography prefigures the more fashionable theoretical ideas made famous in Soja’s book;13 and as a self-professed “outsider” whose perspectives provide an important approach to those interested in a more globalized and transnational concept of western studies for the twenty-first century. Jackson was a deliberately provocative and opinionated man whose essays range in tone from questioning and confrontational to ironic and intentionally obscure. In 1951, in his first editorial for his journal
John Brinckerhoff Jackson’s Landscapes |
Landscape, he wrote, “Beyond the last street light, out where the familiar asphalt ends, a whole country waits to be discovered. . . . A rich and beautiful book is always open before us. We have but to learn to read it.”14 His attentiveness to local, everyday detail and his unwillingness to engage in academic jargon might make his work unfashionable today, but it should in no way detract from its significance and value. Jackson always understood that space was ideological and that in analyzing its uses, meanings, and designs one could understand the wider political climate of the age. Through the semiotics of the highway, the small town, the trailer park, and overlooked everyday events, Jackson began to construct a very different and revealing commentary on America, and most often on the American New West, focusing upon a vernacular landscape defined as “temporary, utilitarian, unorthodox” with no desire to “express universal principles,” but rather as “contingent; it responds to environmental influences— social as well as natural—and alters as those influences alter.”15 His work engages constantly in a Soja-like “restructuring” of established thought and principle, “interjecting” some “Other” into fixed, universalized, and “binary” landscapes, and above all, I would suggest, through launching revisionist approaches to definitions of the American West from “outside” perspectives. This vernacular landscape of “in-between” (between official, established, and recognized spaces) is, in part, a practical exploration of thirdspace—or what he himself termed “Landscape Three”—as we shall see later. By deliberately selecting “spaces that have no documentation,” Jackson undertook a radical approach to cultural analysis that contrasted established, official, and dominant geographical views with the “other spaces of a humbler, less permanent, less conspicuous sort,” or what he also called “minor and local episodes.”16 Jackson excavated a secret history of the West from the 1950s onward, looking at the overlooked, while New Western History only began to adopt some of these approaches for its own purposes in the late 1980s.17 Donald Worster has defined New Western History as putting the West “back into the world community, with no illusions of moral uniqueness,” and “restor[ing] to memory all those unsmiling
63
64
|
neil campbell
aspects that Turner wanted to leave out . . . a history beyond myth.”18 Indeed, just as New Western History took the Turner thesis as its starting point for a revision of a more subtle and complex reading of the West, Jackson looked beyond and behind the simplified overlays of cultural landscape, like the grid system, to produce a richer and fuller comprehension of western space. To this end, his invocation of the “minor and local” relates his project in some respects with that of Deleuze and Guattari, who defined “minor literature” as “deterritorializing” because it used its language to displace or question dominant, normalized, and official “territory.” Their spatial, geopolitical metaphors lend themselves to parallels with the scope and purpose of Jackson’s efforts to rethink how cultural landscapes are perceived and used in the contemporary world. Inside the dominant “language” of landscape studies (in Jackson’s case), with its attention to officially sanctioned spaces, high architecture, and universal aesthetic determinants, there exists another “minor” (or local, regional, vernacular) language “within the heart of what is called great (or established) literature” that is articulated through “[w]riting like a dog digging a hole, a rat digging its burrow . . . finding . . . his own patois, his own third world, his own desert” in opposition to the dominant/official language that, sounding rather like the rhetoric of westward expansionism, colonizes a territory “along river valleys or train tracks; it spreads like a patch of oil.”19 In his most repeated example, Deleuze cites Proust, who believed that writers “invent a new language within language, a foreign language, as it were. They bring to light new grammatical or syntactic powers. They force language outside its customary furrows, they make it delirious.”20 This “other,” foreign language (which is always more than mere words) “communicates with its own outside” and so gets “beyond” all the “furrows” of accepted and “taken-for-granted” cultural frameworks, becoming “the outside of language.”21 Jackson, as the upper-class, European-educated American whose ideas seem to “shadow” the fashionable worlds of the academy, saw himself as a kind of outsider, as Grady Clay has written: “Buried as he forced himself to become in his Western-Pioneer-Frontier explorations, he
John Brinckerhoff Jackson’s Landscapes |
seemed always to carry with him the judgemental baggage of the Outsider.”22 From the “outside” of accepted academic frameworks, traditions, and language, Jackson created his own “minor” literature of cultural landscape studies, a story from below, from the roadside, from the small town and urban center that assembled an alternative iconography of the West resembling Deleuze and Guattari’s, one that “brings together extracts . . . presents samples from all ages, all lands, and all nations . . . a collection of heterogeneous parts: an infinite patchwork, or an endless wall of dry stones (a cemented wall, or pieces of a puzzle, would reconstitute a totality). The world as a sampling: the samples (‘specimens’) are singularities, remarkable and nontotalizable parts extracted from a series of ordinary parts.”23 Here is a “proto-postmodern” vision of the West as a complex network of “sampled” cultures, forms, and ideas without the imposed metanarratives of the frontier, Anglo-Saxon authority, nationhood, or the geographical grid, a vision at whose heart lie “singularities” and “minor scenes . . . more important than any consideration of the whole.”24 Thus Jackson’s writing on roadscapes—that is, the highway and all the spaces and activities on either side of the road—celebrates, in language reminiscent of postmodernism, its singular and transient styles as “conspicuous . . . exotic . . . lavish . . . [with] an indiscriminate borrowing and imitating” understanding its “festive purpose” to intervene and unsettle the conformist strictures of overblown modernism.25 Similarly, predating Foucault’s work of the 1970s on alternative histories and “subjugated knowledges,” Jackson’s new geohistory is precisely “a complex system of distinct and multiple elements, unable to be mastered by the powers of synthesis,” consciously working at the margins of accepted practice, giving voice to everyday artifacts and the structures of a dynamic and changing social landscape with “a history of its own.”26 Jackson defined his methodology as seeing “out of the corner of my eye” to record a mobile and evolutionary world to set against the “forces of stability” that constituted what he terms the rigidified “political landscape” epitomized ultimately by the trope of the grid.27 Jackson’s work, however, sees beyond the grid, “burrows”
65
66
|
neil campbell
below its dominant patterns of control and regulation, confronting readers with alternative, contradictory, and challenging perspectives; to borrow an image from one of his own essays, his work navigates a kind of “stranger’s path” into unexpected, unrecorded spaces “beneath the surface,” bringing in “new life” through being in “touch with the outside world.”28 The significance of the Jeffersonian grid system of land division and surveying that still dominates the structure and organization of the American West cannot be underestimated in Jackson’s work. Like Wilbur Zelinsky, Jackson reacted to its “remorseless rectangularity” as a material manifestation of spatial discipline and territorial control, and as a metaphorical conceptualization of a particular way of thinking within boundaries.29 Jackson’s work opposes and challenges such impositions, seeing the grid as “too rigid,” “a web of inefficient, arbitrary boundary lines which handicap social or economic action” and “strangle” and “impoverish” the lives of those contained and defined by it.30 Here was, according to Jackson, an organizing principle whose deadly grip became, ironically, even the norm for cemetery design.31 For Jackson, the grid’s effects are as much political and ideological as geographical, “imprinted at the moment of conception on every American child” and constructing a spatial, national narrative: “It is this grid, not the eagle or the stars and stripes, which is our true national emblem,” representing an “over-powering,” “all-pervading sameness,” and “ignoring all inherent differences.”32 It was an apparently innocent method of land division that Jackson defined ideologically as a metaphor for territoriality, social control, imaginative reduction, and standardization.33 One of Jackson’s students, John Stilgoe, wrote in 1982 that “the grid objectified national, not regional order,”34 an order that Jackson defined in terms redolent of Foucault and Deleuze and Guattari: “we had to discipline those meandering, unpredictable roads and paths and alleys and trails which had proliferated since the beginning of history and which, like a web of roots [rhizomes?], always threatened to heave up and ruin even the most carefully planned landscape of spaces.” The “anarchic instinct” (that Jackson celebrated) opposed the dominant
John Brinckerhoff Jackson’s Landscapes |
spatial narrative epitomized by the grid’s “disciplining” of the land with “monotony,” a process Jackson recognized mirrored in America’s cold-war cultural politics, itself threatening a more mobile, differentiated, and democratic national identity.35 In Deleuze and Guattari’s A Thousand Plateaus, published in French in 1980 (the same year Jackson published The Necessity for Ruins), they distinguish between “smooth space” and “striated space,” with the former defined as “vectorial, projective, or topological . . . occupied without being counted” and the latter as state space “counted in order to be occupied.” The striated state space is “gridded,” and movement within it confined and limited by preset patterns, whereas “smooth space” is nomadic and open-ended, rich with connections and offshoots that intervene and traverse controlled spaces.36 Very much in the spirit of postwar radicalism, Jackson’s critique of a gridded western landscape, or “territorial space,” rapidly emerging in the Sun Belt was linked to a rampant Taylorism/Fordism in which industrialization was defined by “standardization . . . training, supervision, and production planning,” and whose “production” of spatial values translated into a wider ideological framework that Jackson saw mapped most clearly (and also potentially countered) in the West.37 To counter such “official” (gridded/striated) space, Jackson reinscribes it with the unrecorded and the overlooked vernacular, with “in between” thirdspaces—truck stops, highway strips, and trailer parks—that bring into the grid those excluded, hybrid elements to “reframe” or break out from its “inflexibility,” altering perceptions by acknowledging the “imperceptible” and challenging the logic of regular, “linear” landscapes with irregular, “folded” spaces of “affect” and “sensation” (to borrow terms from Deleuze). For example, in “The Accessible Landscape” Jackson discusses the parking lot as a “beautiful and exciting” “transitional zone” existing between privatized and public space, providing a “vernacular impulse toward accessibility and freedom of movement.” It was functional, versatile, and represented “a new ordering of [common] space” that brought “classes together” outside of their increasingly “defensible private territories” and presented a “more immediate relationship between various ele-
67
68
|
neil campbell
ments in our society: consumer and producer, public and private, the street and the dwelling.”38 Like Deleuze, who wrote his book on the baroque in 1988, Jackson often commented on his admiration for baroque forms over modernist geometry and shared some of his fascination with its “folds”: “the Baroque trait twists and turns its folds, pushing them to infinity, fold over fold, one upon the other,” wrote Deleuze.39 Jackson’s recognition of the “real vitality” of roadside architecture in the West, “creating a dream environment” out of extravagant forms of lights and signs, is compared to the baroque and its “capacity to transform.”40 As John Rajchman puts it: “Rather the fold creates a different kind of ‘flow’—the flow of an energy that the bounded spaces [like the grid] seems to be impeding, that is spilling over into its surroundings, interrupting the calm narrative of its context and so opening new readings in it.”41 Jackson’s “interruptive” mappings of “baroque” western spaces transform perceptions of “normal,” accepted landscapes and interfere with the “calm narratives” of official history and the boosterist myth-making of State space that he termed in 1954 “the old reliable line of goods.”42 As Kathleen Stewart puts it, such “cultural productions that constitute an ‘America’ of sorts are frozen into essentialized ‘objects’ with fixed identities; a prefab landscape of abstract ‘values’ puts an end to the story of ‘America’ before it begins.” Stewart’s book (about southwestern West Virginia) uses an approach similar to that of Jackson’s work (although she does not refer to Jackson at all) by claiming a new narrative space, another thirdspace—“a space on the side of the road” (her book’s title)—through which to create “the site of an opening or reopening into the story of America.” As in Jackson’s work, this is her “reframing” process, her assault on the material and metaphorical “grid” that contains the stories to be told and the representations to be projected onto the national “screen” in order to refigure space as open, dynamic, and “becoming” rather than fixed and closed.43 Her concerns, like Jackson’s, are to explore “minoritized spaces” and provide “a kind of back talk to ‘America’s’ mythic claims to realism, progress, and order” and to demonstrate and use “a gap in the order of myth itself.”44
John Brinckerhoff Jackson’s Landscapes |
Some thirty years before postcolonial critic Homi Bhabha’s work on thirdspace as hybridity, Jackson recognized the hybrid potentiality (or “anarchic instinct”) of the haphazard evolution of roadside spaces intervening in the dominant gridded forms, the “essential” metanarratives of the West, and with it recognized the need for a “critical thirding” to unsettle such dominant spatial imaginary. As Bhabha put it, with particular parallels to the significance of the West within the American cultural imagination, “Such an intervention quite properly challenges our sense of the historical identity of culture as a homogenizing, unifying force, authenticated by the originary Past, kept alive in the national tradition of the People.”45 In a 1980 essay, “Learning about Landscapes,” Jackson argues against seeing landscapes as essential, a habit too common to the western tradition, refusing to see them “as profound expressions of ethnic or racial traits. . . [which] created a special breed of men and women with common psychological and physical characteristics . . . rooted in the land . . . [and providing] a cultural heritage that must at all costs be preserved intact.”46 Such a narrow and simplistic link between roots, land, and national identity reminded Jackson of the fascist ideology he had experienced during World War II, with its call to an “ancestral landscape” which he felt “did enormous damage.”47 In breaking this link between rootedness and exceptionalist, imperial identity, Jackson asserted instead a new multilayered, folded landscape (and identity) of mobility, ambivalence, and hybridity—a complex thirdspace constantly capable of appropriating, translating, recombining, and creating things anew “in-between” fixed states. Prefiguring postcolonial and poststructuralist theories of Deleuze and Guattari, Clifford, Bhabha, Gilroy, Hall, Massey, Urry, and others concerned with rethinking identity and place as formed as much by “routes” of mobility as by settlement and rootedness, Jackson sought the “balance between the forces of stability and those of mobility,” between roots and routes (or striated space and smooth space).48 In this he was an early example of a critical regionalist, a term first coined by Lefaivre and Tzonis in 1981, later made famous by Kenneth Frampton in 1986, and invoked, as we have seen, by Soja in 1989. Its
69
70
|
neil campbell
stated purpose was to “reframe regionalism” in order to break down this sentimental, nostalgic vision and to reassert its more radical potential.49 To do this, Lefaivre and Tzonis, in their 2003 book Critical Regionalism, invoke Americans Lewis Mumford and John Brinckerhoff Jackson, whose writings they claim “value the singular” and aim “at sustaining diversity while benefiting from universality.”50 Jackson had first read and been influenced by Mumford around 1928 at the University of Wisconsin, and Mumford later contributed to Landscape magazine. Like Jackson, he critiqued the International Style of architecture, preferring “regional” alternatives from the San Francisco Bay Region School of Architecture, praising their “from the ground up” approach rather than an elitist “top-down,” imposed one. One phrase in particular suggests a strong link to Jackson, as Mumford attacked the gridlike hold of modernism, with its regularized patterns and “striated space,” and praised instead reframed regionalism’s ability to “liberate us from the tyranny of the rectangular form.”51 Traditional regionalism, however, was for both writers a “blind reaction” to modernism and technology, an “aversion from what is” rather than “an impulse toward what may be,” and they felt the need to be critical of both, preferring instead an “infused [regionalism] with a notion of relativity,” regarding it as “engagement with the global, universalizing world rather than by an attitude of resistance,” becoming “a constant process of negotiation between the local and the global on the many different issues that traditionally made up regionalism.”52 Mumford’s preference is for reciprocity, seeing culture as a contact zone, where the “regional” “has contributed something of value to the universal movement . . . without forfeiting its . . . characteristics [and] can absorb something in return . . . a continuous give and take.”53 Ultimately, Mumford saw regionalism as critically engaged with the wider world: [E]very regional culture necessarily has a universal side to it. It is steadily open to influences that come from other parts of the world, and from other cultures, separated from the local region in space or time or both together. It would be use-
John Brinckerhoff Jackson’s Landscapes | 71
ful if we formed the habit of never using the word regional without mentally adding to it the idea of the universal—remembering the constant contact and interchange between the local scene and the wide world that lies beyond it. To make the best use of local resources, we must often seek help from people or ideas or technical methods that originate elsewhere. . . . As with a human being, every culture must both be itself and transcend itself; it must make most of its limitations and must pass beyond them; it must be open to fresh experience and yet it must maintain its integrity. (emphasis added)54 Thus, more than forty years before Mary Louise Pratt, Mumford articulated regions as complex contact zones whose many overlapping elements were all to be considered as crucial to the dynamic formations of multicultural space and place like that he envisioned for Honolulu: “a significant experiment in the hybridization of cultures which perhaps will mark the future of human society; it is a miniature experimental station.”55 Lefaivre argues that Mumford’s preferred approach, like Jackson’s in my analysis, is one of “engagement and inbetweening,” bringing together ideas from “inside” and “outside” traditions and styles in negotiated dialogue to create a “multi-dimensional, multifunctional, interdisciplinary approach . . . involving identity, sustainability, memory, community in a globalizing, post-colonial and fragmented world” better suited to the postwar experience.56 Jackson too argued against space as “monofunctional” in houses as well as in society as a whole, preferring shared uses that defined space through “use” rather than absolute and regulated function.57 Jackson wrote, “the values we stress are stability and permanence and the putting down of roots and holding on,” but there is another “tradition of mobility and short-term occupancy” that is equally powerful, particularly in the West. Between extreme opposite positions—of “roots” and “routes”—Jackson sought out an alternative space of “constant contact and interchange between the local scene and the wide world,” or what he called his “Landscape Three,” created in dialogue with earlier versions of a static, rooted community
72
|
neil campbell
(“homogenous and dedicated to a single purpose”) and a vernacular, local one (“mixing all kinds of spaces and uses together”).58 Like Mumford (and Deleuze and Guattari), Jackson knew that “the two spaces in fact exist only in mixture: smooth space is constantly being translated, transversed into a striated space; striated space is constantly being reversed, returned to a smooth space.”59 Jackson saw a “danger” in “having two distinct sublandscapes, one dedicated to stability and place, the other dedicated to mobility,” for as I have argued throughout, he saw the necessity of both folded into the creation of “living, pulsating, infinitely complicated organisms which man has made over and over again.”60 Rather than a simple regionalism “clinging to obsolete forms and attitude” as a denial of process and history, Jackson’s New West had to be a reframed, critical regionalism, a third landscape “creating a new nature, a new beauty” out of the hybridized, diasporic space of crossing between the two, where there exists, according to Victor Burgin, a third space, “neither within nor without; it was an experience of being between the two, a ‘between’ formed only in the simultaneous presence of the two.”61 This “space between,” echoing Stewart’s “space on the side of the road,” was most evident for Jackson in western roadscapes where messy contradictions—what he called “ambidexterity”—combined private and public, work and play, in a carnival of creativity and contact that expressed a hybrid spatiality mirroring his own hope for an America of “shared interests and mutual help” with an infinite capacity for regenerative energy and for “a new kind of history, a new, more responsive social order, and ultimately a new landscape.”62 Against the increasing standardization, corporatization, and McDonaldization of the highway “strip”—“being conveyed through a complex, well-ordered, admirable world” at “uniform speed”—Jackson held on to the “immense potential” and “vitality” of a “mixed public” interacting in transient, heteroglossic, “new centers of sociability”: “a jumbled reminder of all current enthusiasms—atomic energy, space travel, Acapulco, folk singing, computers, Danish contemporary, health foods, hot-rod racing, and so on.”63 This hybrid roadscape was a powerful agent in Jackson’s new sense of, and hope
John Brinckerhoff Jackson’s Landscapes | 73
for, (western) cultural identity, for it “prescribes no traditional behavior,” but along with the automobile, suggested a potential, if utopian, diasporic “meeting place” of “almost complete freedom” where the New West’s “self-definition” is as plural as its varied landforms and where his twin enemies of “exclusiveness” and the “overemphasis on competition and control” might be held at bay.64 This is a mobile thirdspace (or what Deleuze calls “becoming”) confronting the essentialist tendencies of a rooted sense of place where “land was the object men could best use in their search for identity” with an “existential” perspective “without absolutes, without prototypes, devoted to change and mobility.” As early as 1957, Jackson’s work is scattered with words like “exchange,” “trans-shipment,” and “contact,” emphasizing the West as a potential space of interaction and encounter where the “uniformity of taste and income and interests” is countered by “this ceaseless influx of new wants, new ideas, new manners, new strength.” Jackson’s vernacular, unofficial, anarchic roadscapes, studied in their pre-corporatized variety, test and expand the monotonous grid (and its inherent ideology), spilling out in real and imagined directions denying notions of metanarratival discipline and control favoring “fragments of the whole—studies of micro-ecosystems, isolated structures and spaces of little significance.”65 These are deeply political ideas about class, control, and social organization sited in the various struggles over the use and representation of land.66 Jackson wrote that by “political” he meant “those spaces and structures [like the grid] designed to impose or preserve a unity and order on the land, or in keeping with a long-range, large-scale plan” (emphasis added).67 His work continually argues against such essentialist absolutism in favor of what Michel de Certeau would later call “making do” or practice—that is, how people use and affect space.68 In “The House in the Vernacular Landscape” (1990), Jackson asserted that vernacular space “has no inherent [fixed] identity, it is simply defined by the way it is used,” as distinct from “the middleclass or established concept,” in which “each space is unique and can in fact affect the activity taking place within it.”69 Jackson contrasted
74
|
neil campbell
the growing tendency toward corporatized, “planned, specialized organization” defined by “inertia” and its inclination toward the “sterilizing of our roadsides” and the containment of both individual and community, with his preference for “fluid, undifferentiated spaces” and renewed, dynamic public spaces through which alternative values could be expressed and exchanged in an atmosphere of “gaiety and brilliance” in a “community where the streets are still common property, still part of the living space of every citizen.”70 Unsurprisingly, Jackson’s ideal example of a kind of hybrid, democratic thirdspace was a western one—Santa Fe in 1954—“gregarious . . . hostile to . . . regulation” and full of “color and vitality.” Such utopian spaces, Jackson believed, opposed the sterility of the grid and of more “regulated” communities and landscapes and made possible forms of “transitional,” mobile space: an “existential landscape, without absolutes, without prototypes, devoted to change and mobility and the free confrontation of men.” In this vein, Jackson described landscape as a growing, evolving language with “obscure and undecipherable origins . . . the slow creation of all elements in society . . . clinging to obsolescent forms, inventing new ones . . . the field of perpetual conflict and compromise between what is established by authority and what the vernacular insists upon preferring.”71 Always ahead of his time, Jackson understood the global and the transnational relations inherent in the West, writing, for example, in 1954 of how the “Great social and economic forces, as remote in origin and as irresistible as the wind that blows incessantly from the west, helped form the human landscape of the region.” This desire to bring the Outside into the frame, in every sense, locates Jackson’s work as both critical regionalist and decidedly “post-Western,” seeing the “shared [third] spaces” of the region as constructed by a set of complex discourses interrelated with global, transnational issues and representations.72 His work is not, to borrow a phrase from Deleuze and Guattari, about “the revival of regionalisms,” for how would that “serve a worldwide, transnational technocracy”? For a minor language and literature must “travel,” become “vehicular,” as they put it, and follow “creative lines of escape.” The “regionalizing
John Brinckerhoff Jackson’s Landscapes | 75
or ghettoizing” of a minor language has a limited political purpose, as in the tradition of the “local” within the American West, since it should always relate, at some level, with the global. The goal is, as Deleuze and Guattari put it, “to make use of the polylingualism of one’s own language, to make a minor or intensive use of it, to oppose the oppressed quality of this language to its oppressive quality.” Hence, the minoritarian (or regionalist-vernacular) impulse in this sense opposes reductionism or the “one single dream” and its “state . . . official language” that “masters the signifier” and instead “create[s] the opposite dream . . . a becoming-minor.”73 This vital process of turning the “inside” and the “local” outward is not nationally defined but rather transnational in the same way that the West is not only consumed and produced by westerners but a globalized “language” whose “polylingualism” extends outside the United States through its various rhizomatic sproutings in other places and cultures. Thus the rupturing minor language of a “critical regionalist” like Jackson is always, by implication, transnational, intervening in the closed “single dream” of a particular, nostalgic, or official version of the West, like the mythic landscapes of Ansel Adams (“That school of ‘timeless’ photography”), interrogating and opening it up in new and challenging ways.74 This “method of the rhizome,” as Deleuze and Guattari term it, acts by “decentering [language] onto other dimensions and other registers” so as to keep it open, with “the idea perhaps com[ing] first from outside” as a kind of “stammering”: “To be a foreigner, but in one’s own tongue, not only when speaking in a language other than one’s own. To be bilingual, multilingual, but in one and the same language, without even a dialect or patois. To be a bastard, a half-breed.” Jackson’s “stammering” cultural geography disrupts the accepted norms of critical “language” about landscape, “illegitimizing” the official, sanctioned stories and myths, “uprooting them from their state as constants” providing the “cutting edge of deterritorialization,” pushing language “toward the limit of its elements, forms, or notions, toward a near side or a beyond of language.”75 Few, other than Jackson, would, for example, define parking lots and used-car
76
|
neil campbell
lots as a “delight and inspiration,” offering forms of “variety . . . essential to our well-being” and integral to the productive undoing of established landscapes.76 In deliberately and consistently unsettling normalized thinking and countering it with an askance view of cultural landscape, Jackson always looked “beyond” a defined West, both as local, vernacular culture and as national narrative, seeing its place within a wider transnational economy and increasingly global world system. Denise Scott Brown, whose work with Robert Venturi was directly and dramatically influenced by Jackson, certainly recognized this, believing that “cross-cultural crossfires” in his work were not to be “solved” but “lived with,” “using its tension to foster creativity. . . . This . . . is what Brinck did. The skewed view—the view from the marginal position—can produce useful insights and an unusual vision.”77 Jackson’s influence is clear in Scott Brown and Venturi’s Learning from Las Vegas, a work that takes seriously a western vernacular landscape and its relations with wider economic and cultural forces. From Jackson’s “stammering” or “skewed” cultural architecture of the New West we follow the “stranger’s path” finding new ways of looking at accepted narratives, spatial or otherwise, differently, to question and challenge received wisdom, and to disrupt overly rigid systems of order (the inflexible grid). The “practice of outside” cultivated by Jackson is a tool (as I argue elsewhere)78 to get at the inside and alter it, to open up the discursive West and look into its spaces differently, enabling reflexiveness, greater understanding of its relationships to others, and its role— both real and imagined—within a wider global community. The grid, in other words, spills out further than the West, further than America. In rethinking this “architecture” one might pay more attention, as Jackson did, to the “in-between space” (thirdspace) as a mobile space of contact, translation, and negotiation in order to, as Bhabha put it, “open the way to conceptualizing an international culture, based not on the exoticism of multiculturalism or the diversity of cultures, but on the inscription and articulation of culture’s hybridity.”79 In his early rejection of essentialism and rooted identity, and in his insistent
John Brinckerhoff Jackson’s Landscapes | 77
excavation of the mobile, the marginalized, and the everyday, Jackson demonstrated a refreshingly open and outward-looking perspective that folded the regional West into a globalizing outside space. For living is, ultimately, he wrote, “a dialog, not a monolog. . . . Existence means shared existence. We are all increasingly dependent on the presence of our fellow men—not necessarily on their approval.”80 It is only in mapping and “exploring this Third Space,” as Bhabha says, and as Jackson’s work consistently shows in his rethinking of western cultural landscapes, that “we may elude the politics of polarity and emerge as others of our selves.”81 In one startling description based on Jackson’s favorite pastime of motorbiking, he conveys an ideal, experiential relationship that tells us much, finally, about his critical method and its aim of transformation: “In short, the traditional perspective, the traditional way of seeing and experiencing the world is abandoned; in its stead we become active participants, the shifting focus of a moving, abstract world; our nerves and muscles are all of them brought into play. To the perceptive individual, there can be an almost mystical quality to the experience; his identity seems for the moment to be transmuted.”82 Notes 1. Soja, Postmodern Geographies, 189. 2. Soja spells the concept as one word, “thirdspace,” and I will follow this convention. However, other critics, such as Homi Bhabha, use “third space,” and I have used this only when quoting Bhabha directly. 3. Soja, Thirdspace, 1. 4. Soja, Thirdspace, 3 5. Soja, Thirdspace, 5. 6. Soja, Thirdspace, 5. 7. I am grateful to Victor Burgin’s In/Different Spaces, 26–28, for a discussion of Lefebvre’s and Soja’s work. 8. Quoted in Soja, Thirdspace, 10. 9. Soja also discusses the work of bell hooks; see Thirdspace, 12–13. 10. Bhabha, “Interview with Homi Bhabha,” 211. 11. A key figure here is Paul Vidal de la Blache (1845–1918), who founded Annales de Geographie and was committed to intensive regional geography,
78
|
neil campbell
believing that the physical environment and human activity were intimately connected and that one should study the “genre de vie” (a way of living) in all its elements. Such thinking was immensely influential on Jackson. 12. Richard Hoggart’s The Use of Literacy (1957) and Raymond Williams’s Culture and Society (1958) are seen as British cultural studies’ inaugural texts, but Jackson’s journal Landscape was launched in 1951. However, Jackson’s work responded to earlier European work in France in the 1930s and later via the British Independent Group (itself responding to U.S. popular culture). These circuits of exchange and influence are vital to understanding Jackson and his inevitable resistance to any essentialist label. He studies America— the West—but without an inwardness. 13. For example, Jackson wrote specifically on Santa Fe, New Mexico, Optimo City (an invented western space), Chihuahua, and many other western landscapes. 14. Quoted in Wilson and Groth, Everyday America, 9. 15. Jackson, Landscape in Sight, 246. 16. Jackson, Discovering the Vernacular Landscape, xi; Jackson, Landscape in Sight, 160. 17. Jackson was known both to the “founder” of New Western History, Patricia Nelson Limerick, and to her architect-husband, Jeffrey, and both have written about him. Patricia Limerick refers to Jackson as a “personal trainer, who takes us through calisthenics that trick us into revealing unexpected reservoirs of stamina and agility and who gives us a chance to rethink the rules of the game” (quoted in Wilson and Groth, Everyday America, 36). 18. Worster, Under Western Skies, 12. 19. Deleuze and Guattari, Kafka, 18; Deleuze and Guattari, A Thousand Plateaus, 7. Of course, the word vernacular carries with it the sense of a language that is native and local, but like Deleuze and Guattari’s concept of the “minor,” Jackson’s use of the vernacular is wider and more complex. 20. Deleuze, Essays Critical and Clinical, lv. 21. Deleuze, Essays Critical and Clinical, lv. 22. Clay, “From Crossing the American Grain,” 19. 23. Deleuze, Essays Critical and Clinical, 57. 24. Deleuze, Essays Critical and Clinical, 57. 25. Jackson, Landscapes, 68. 26. Foucault, Language, Counter-Memory, Practice, 161; Jackson, Discovering the Vernacular Landscape, 85. Jackson had read Foucault, quoting him, for example, in The Necessity for Ruins, 5–6.
John Brinckerhoff Jackson’s Landscapes | 79
27. Jackson, Discovering the Vernacular Landscape, xiii, x. 28. Jackson, Landscape in Sight, 26; Jackson, Discovering the Vernacular Landscape, 141. 29. Zelinsky cited in Van Noy, Surveying the Interior, 15. Jackson discusses territoriality at some length in “The Accessible Landscape” (Landscape in Sight, 69–71). 30. Jackson, Landscapes, 142. 31. Jackson, Landscape in Sight, 167. 32. Jackson, A Sense of Time, 153, 154. 33. I have assembled an array of ideas about the grid from many different sources all relevant to this discussion. See, for example, Van Noy, Surveying the Interior; and Fox, who calls the grid “the national nervous system” (The Void, the Grid and the Sign, 95). Fox refers to Jackson’s work in his book (see 128–29). The notion of the grid is a theme I develop at length in the longer book from which this section comes (The Rhizomatic West, forthcoming from the University of Nebraska Press). 34. Stilgoe quoted in Van Noy, Surveying the Interior, 16. 35. Jackson, A Sense of Time, 6, 4, 6. As I argued in “‘Much Unseen Is Also Here,’” Jackson’s work has to be seen as related to the Beat and counterculture of the 1950s and 1960s, particularly their questioning of the centripetal forces of consensus, suburbia, consumerism, and containment. 36. Deleuze and Guattari, A Thousand Plateaus, 361–62, xiii. 37. Jackson, Discovering the Vernacular Landscape, 67, 119; Jackson, Landscape in Sight, 260, 263–64. See Antonio Gramsci’s work on Fordism and hegemony in Selections from the Prison Notebooks. 38. Jackson, Landscape in Sight, 73–77. 39. See Jackson, Landscape in Sight, xiv. Another connection from Jackson to Robert Venturi and Denise Scott Brown is through a shared interest in the baroque (see Venturi, Complexity and Contradiction, 13). Deleuze, The Fold, 3. 40. Jackson, Landscapes, 66. 41. Rajchman, Constructions, 26. 42. Jackson, Landscape in Sight, 352. 43. Stewart, Side of the Road, 3. Again the idea of “becoming” is borrowed from Deleuze and Guattari. 44. Stewart, Side of the Road, 3. 45. Bhabha, Location of Culture, 37. 46. Jackson, The Necessity for Ruins, 11. 47. Jackson, The Necessity for Ruins, 11.
80
|
neil campbell
48. Jackson, Discovering the Vernacular Landscape, xii. 49. Tzonis and Lefaivre, “The Grid and the Pathway”; Lefaivre and Tzonis, Critical Regionalism, 19; Frampton, “Towards a Critical Regionalism.” 50. Lefaivre and Tzonis, Critical Regionalism, 20. 51. Lefaivre and Tzonis, “Lewis Mumford’s Regionalism,” 3. 52. Lefaivre and Tzonis, Critical Regionalism, 34; Lefaivre and Tzonis, “Lewis Mumford’s Regionalism,” 2. 53. Mumford, Roots of Contemporary American Architecture, xi. 54. Quoted in Lefaivre and Tzonis, Critical Regionalism, 39. 55. Mumford quoted in Lefaivre and Tzonis, Critical Regionalism, 39. Mary Louise Pratt, in Imperial Eyes, defined the concept of “contact zones.” 56. Lefaivre and Tzonis, Critical Regionalism, 39. 57. Jackson, Discovering the Vernacular Landscape, 64–65. 58. Jackson, Landscape in Sight, 223; Jackson, Discovering the Vernacular Landscape, 152–55. 59. Deleuze and Guattari, A Thousand Plateaus, 474. 60. Jackson, Landscape in Sight, 291. 61. Jackson, Discovering the Vernacular Landscape, 154, 155; Burgin, In/Different Spaces, 185. 62. Jackson, Landscapes, 58; Groth and Bressi, Understanding Ordinary Landscapes, 153; Jackson, Discovering the Vernacular Landscape, 157. 63. Jackson, Landscape in Sight, 207–8; Jackson, Landscapes, 149, 149–50. In this respect Jackson has something in common with Paul Virilio’s exploration of how speed and acceleration in the modern world rob humanity of its contacts with life. 64. Jackson, Landscapes, 149–50; Jackson, Landscape in Sight, 77. 65. Jackson, Landscapes, 150, 9; Jackson, Landscape in Sight, 23–27, 69. Susan Naremore Maher’s article “Deep Mapping the Great Plains” was a provocative source for some of these ideas. William Least Heat-Moon, whom Maher discusses, mentions Jackson some seven times in his “From the Commonplace Book” section of PrairyErth. 66. Jackson is often criticized as nonpolitical (see Walker, “Unseen and Disbelieved”). Although I would agree that he does not consider issues of race and gender in the manner of recent cultural studies, he is very aware, as I argue here, of the presence of class, political control, and forms of spatial “apartheid.” Jackson is not, as Walker states, “too respectful” (172), but he is more observant and astute in his ideological analysis than is often credited. His recognition of poverty as a major factor in spatiality is an important
John Brinckerhoff Jackson’s Landscapes |
breakthrough (see “To Pity the Plumage”) and ties his ideas in with those of Michael Harrington (see Campbell, “‘Much Unseen Is Also Here’”). 67. Jackson, Discovering the Vernacular Landscape, 150. 68. Certeau, Practice of Everyday Life. 69. Jackson, “House in the Vernacular Landscape,” 368. 70. Jackson, Landscapes, 72, 138, 143; Jackson, “House in the Vernacular Landscape,” 368; Jackson, Landscapes, 72, 111. Again I see Jackson as working ahead of urbanist Mike Davis, whose work on public space can be seen prefigured in many of these essays and ideas. 71. Jackson, Landscapes, 111, 9; Jackson, Discovering the Vernacular Landscape, 148. 72. Jackson, Landscape in Sight, 162, 77. 73. Deleuze and Guattari, Kafka, 24, 25, 26, 27. 74. Jackson’s own photography reveals a man recording vernacular, hybrid western space in a similar way to the work of the New Topographics exhibition of 1975 (I examine this in the forthcoming book The Rhizomatic West). Jackson, A Sense of Time, 180. 75. Deleuze and Guattari, A Thousand Plateaus, 8, 98. 76. Jackson, Landscape in Sight, 69. 77. Brown, “Learning from Brinck,” 56. 78. The “practice of outside” and many of the ideas sketched in this essay are discussed at length in my forthcoming book The Rhizomatic West (University of Nebraska Press) and linked to “associated” western outsiders such as Robert Frank, Reyner Banham, and Sergio Leone and theorized via Bakhtin, Deleuze and Guattari, and Elizabeth Grosz. 79. Bhabha, Location of Culture, 38. 80. Jackson, Landscapes, 147. 81. Bhabha, Location of Culture, 38–39. 82. Jackson, Landscape in Sight, 205.
81
4. Architecture and the Virtual West in William Gibson’s San Francisco michael beehler
Yamazaki stared at Transamerica’s upright thorn, bandaged with the brace they’d applied after the Little Grande [earthquake]. . . . Modernity was ending. Here, on the bridge, it long since had. William Gibson, Virtual Light
Modernity is on its last legs in the New West of 2005 San Francisco and Los Angeles—or at least that’s the way it is envisioned by William Gibson in Virtual Light, the first of his “bridge trilogy” series of nearfuture novels (the last two being Idoru and All Tomorrow’s Parties). In Gibson’s postwestern future there are many casualties of the earthquakes that have devastated both Tokyo and San Francisco, not the least of which is that jewel of architectural modernism, the Transamerica Pyramid, the “upright thorn” that Berry Rydell, the novel’s main character, describes as the “big spiky” thing that is “more modern” than any other San Francisco building.1 The Little Grande earthquake dealt it a serious blow, and it’s now held up only by a prosthetic appendage, a “truss-thing” or “brace” that keeps it from falling down.2 This pyramid-with-a-crutch is an apt image of the closure of modernism’s architectural and cultural project as it plays itself out in the postdisaster, cyberpunk West figured by Virtual Light, which builds on the questions of virtuality and futurity only hinted at in its title. These questions are as old as the pyramids or, at least, as old as the gridded abstractions that have historically dominated Western spatial thinking, abstractions reified in the prosthetically assisted
Architecture and the Virtual West |
pyramid of modernism. Speaking about Hegel, architectural theorist Bernard Tschumi notes that, for the old philosopher (we might ask, was he ever lame? did he ever need crutches?), the pyramid was the “ultimate model of reason.”3 So it is only fitting that Gibson’s novel takes the spatial embodiment of Hegel’s precious architectural figure as its own model of modernity on its last legs. Tschumi goes on to point out that, with Hegel’s bracing assistance, the architect has been historically understood as “the person who conceives the form of the building without manipulating materials himself,” and so architecture comes to understand itself as a “cosa mentale . . . the forms conceived by the architect ensur[ing] the domination of the idea over matter.”4 Fittingly, the West Coast is the locale for Gibson’s exploration of the last gasps of this domination. The logic of the pyramid, the logic that now needs all the help it can get just to remain standing, is the modernist logic in which reason, form, abstraction, and mental constructs are seen as dominating over the material physicality or the spatial praxes architects associate with a building’s unprogrammable use. It is also the historical logic in which the West has been conceptualized and, consequently, programmed and managed. But “modernity,” Gibson writes, “was ending,” and his novel traces the trajectory of modernity’s sun as it sets both in the West as a spatial location and on the West as a cosa mentale.5 But this modernity is not going down without a fight. The whole cultural background against which the novel’s plot moves—involving stolen virtual-reality glasses, the raging aids epidemic ended only by the blood of a prostitute, and a real estate scheme to regrid post–Little Grande San Francisco into a totally programmed, corporatized space (the city as complete cosa mentale or “total story,” as Neil Campbell puts it)—is filled with reactionary, prosthetic protective devices, making the environment of both SoCal and NoCal (now two separate states) look like a last-ditch anti-matter, anti-social, and anti-body project.6 From the ubiquitous anti-viroid face masks worn by nearly everyone and the nanotech contraceptive device worn by the lawyer Karen Mendelsohn, to the gated communities and “stealth houses” (expensive houses that protect themselves by being “dug in
83
84
|
michael beehler
beneath something that looked almost, but not quite, like a bombedout drycleaning plant”), 2005 California is a paranoid environment whose primary goal is self-protection via the control of every spatial, bodily border and every digital interface.7 Gibson acknowledges that his vision of a fortress California comes from the “Fortress L.A.” chapter of Mike Davis’s City of Quartz, in which Davis reads the public, built environment of Los Angeles as being literally “turned inside out, in the service of ‘security’ and profit.”8 And given the current battles over immigration being played out in the West by such vigilante and fence-building groups as the Orange County Republican Party and the Minutemen, Virtual Light’s paranoid future West turns out to be scarily prescient (a recent op-ed by Gustavo Arellano in the Los Angeles Times notes that “Orange County is the Mexican-bashing capital of the United States”).9 Gibson’s decrepit pyramid is the architectural apotheosis of this contemporary white (and particularly southern Californian and southwestern) anxiety about the undocumented immigrant and the unprogrammable other, and of its ever more desperately protectionist political prosthetics. That’s why the “virtual light” (vl) glasses whose theft moves the novel’s plot are the ideal figure of modernism’s fantasy of a dematerialized western reality programmed by the dominating idea, for nothing is more a cosa mentale than the virtual-reality images produced by these glasses. Bypassing the interface of the eye itself, vl glasses “work on [the] optic nerves direct[ly],” allowing the wearer to experience a digitally conceived and ultimately controllable world.10 It is only appropriate that the first use of these glasses in the novel is for viewing pornography—a dematerialized experience that does without the dangerous messiness of the body—and that the story’s complications are set up by a courier who, carrying two sets of vl glasses—one for his own pleasure and one showing the gridded, corporatized future of a rebuilt San Francisco-to-come—has the ones with the building project stolen by the bike courier Chevette Washington. The significance of this confusion of glasses is clear: safe sex can be had via the cosa mentale of virtual light, and a safe future can be guaranteed by the completion of a real estate project (a kind of
Architecture and the Virtual West |
Manifest Destiny for developers) that programs the West Coast into the abstract image of a corporate ideal, which is pornographic in its own way. Each gives us a vision of the modernist project in full flower, as each ensures—or at least embodies the modernist wish for—the domination of the idea over matter, or of the surveyor’s grid over the space of the West. The developer’s scheme represented in the vl glasses involves the construction of megastructures in downtown San Francisco, buildings “bigger than anything, a stone regular grid of them, marching in from the hills. Each one maybe four blocks at the base, rising straight and featureless,” all under the watchful eye of the ironically named Sunflower Corporation.11 “They’re going to rebuild San Francisco,” the glasses courier explains. “From the ground up, basically. Like they’re doing to Tokyo. They’ll start by layering a grid of seventeen complexes into the existing infrastructure. Eighty-story office/residential, retail/residence in the base.”12 The goal here is the development of a totally planned future built environment for San Francisco, one with no lines of flight, no risk, and no “slack,” and one in which every interface between buildings and the people who inhabit them is completely programmed and managed. These buildings are designed to be absolutely “self-sufficient,” and because they will “eat their own sewage,” like the pornographic vl glasses they too reflect the modernist anti-matter and white, western anti-immigrant fantasy of the impermeable border.13 The whole project, in fact, models this fantasy, because the glasses that bear this image of a totally designed future are a key component in the scheme to make some people really rich: if they can see this future, they will know what San Francisco properties to buy in advance of the rebuilding. For the developers who share in the pornography of this visionary corporate future, the real San Francisco of matter (buildings, dirt, bodies, etc.) dematerializes into the capitalist abstraction of real estate and its future into a totally programmed, anticorporeal corporatization of reality: into, that is to say, a virtual future. Thus the scheme is particularly well named. Labeled the Sunflower Project, it recalls Ginsberg’s romantic nostalgia for a nature lost among the locomotive debris of a 1950s San Francisco,
85
86
|
michael beehler
and promises an ironic reflowering of the post-quake city with shiteating buildings that, like flowers, seem to grow themselves. But beneath its romantic trope, the Sunflower Project is in fact the corporate redeployment of the heliotropic fantasy in which the idea, the cosa mentale that is the Platonic (or, additionally, the Hegelian) sun, obliterates every living space that stands in its path, including—and especially— any future that doesn’t get with the program. Philosopher and architectural theorist Elizabeth Grosz has explored this fantasy and the virtual reality (vr) technologies that are its expression. In Architecture from the Outside, she explains the gendered appeal of vr’s anticorporeal, heliotropic fantasies. “vr,” she notes in a chapter on “Lived Spatiality,” “promises fulfillment of the age-old (male) fantasy of disembodied self-containment . . . [and] autogenesis.”14 As I have already suggested, Gibson’s shit-eating buildings are the architectural exemplars of this male fantasy—one with clear ties to western myths of independence and radical individualism—but what is even more significant about Grosz’s argument is the way in which she, like Gibson with his vl glasses, associates vr with a kind of pornography of mastery and control. What vr offers, she writes, is the “fantasy of a 1960s style polysexuality, with none of the nasty consequences: a high without drugs or the hangover, sex without pregnancy or disease, pleasure without the body. This,” she concludes, “is the fantasy only of a male body, the anticipation of pleasure or sex that is so corporeally self-distancing that mastery over distance itself becomes the turn-on.”15 In every way, then, the virtual, as deployed in the fantasies of vr and vl, displaces and replaces the real in an act of power that overpowers every other reality, including the otherness of female and, even, male corporeality, and hence it functions as a modernist instrument of domination par excellence. And in Virtual Light, it is an other West as the site of the future itself—the other San Francisco that stands as a spatial and architectural invitation to the unprogrammable or unanticipatable to-come, and that invites the future per se—that is threatened by the dematerializing, virtual fantasies of the Sunflower Corporation, which promise a final mastery over both the temporality and the corporeality of San Francisco’s physical body.
Architecture and the Virtual West |
This threat to the other West of the ( future as) other is for Gibson the legacy of modernity in the West. But the body—and, oddly enough, a specifically unprotected and diseased body—turns out to be the only thing that can save a humanity savaged by the aids epidemic (“You still don’t remember,” the sage Skinner tells the Japanese chronicler Yamazaki, “what it felt like, watching them [bodies] pile up like that”).16 One of the subplots of Virtual Light involves James Delmore Shapely, a thirty-one-year-old prostitute who “had been hiv-positive for twelve years” but whose strain of the virus was nonpathogenic.17 Once this fact becomes known to the aids industry “in the early months of the new century,” researcher Dr. Kim Kutnik gets Shapely released from prison, initiates a project to inject Shapely’s blood into terminally ill aids patients, and, startlingly, uncovers “clinical data suggesting that unprotected sex with Shapely had apparently reversed the symptoms of several of her [Kutnik’s] patients.”18 The result, of course, is that Shapely, the “illiterate prostitute,” becomes the “splendid source” whose blood, eucharistically distributed and shared out (“that piece of him in everybody now”), rescues humanity from this decimating plague.19 The male, modernist fantasy of an idealized, perfectly protected self-containment—a racist and secure-the-borders-at-all-costs dream if there ever was one—is thus perforated by the needles bearing Shapely’s blood, for it is only through the risk of opening itself to the blood of an other—first through a sexual contact without any prosthetics of protection and then through the injections themselves—that humanity is rescued, that the “course of darkness is reversed,” and that, in fact, the future has a chance at all.20 None of this happens, however, without the armed resistance of the purists, the anti-body protectionists figured here by “fundamentalist Christians” violently opposed to such an apparently defiling eucharist.21 A group of seven “armed fundamentalists, members of a white racist sect,” finally murders Shapely at the Salt Lake City airport, only to be caught and put into prison, where, ironically, two of their members die of aids while “steadfastly refusing the viral strain patented in Shapely’s name.”22 In this counterstory to both today’s Minutemen and the novel’s Sunflower Project, then, it is the unprotected body laid open
87
88
|
michael beehler
to its outside, exposed to what comes to it from beyond its own skin, that lives on only by risking contamination with an other’s blood. Recounting Shapely’s story, the novel rejects the fantastic vr cul-de-sac of individual and national autonomy and self-containment: the closed circle in which one eats one’s own shit. This corporeal paradigm of the open interface—what Jean-Luc Nancy might call le partage des corps, or the ex-scripted corpus—finds its built analog in Virtual Light’s other key architectural figure: the Oakland Bay Bridge, which stands in sharp contrast to the prosthetically supported pyramid and to its decrepit modernist fantasy. Gibson emphasizes that, on the post-quake bridge, modernity had ended, its anti-matter program overwhelmed by “another reality, intent upon its own agenda.”23 For although the bridge still stands—it survived the Little Grande relatively intact—its “steel bones [and] stranded tendons” now form the webwork supporting a kind of thirdspace, a guerrilla architecture of ad hoc structures built “piecemeal, to no set plan, employing every imaginable technique and material.” No programming organizes this “amorphous,” parasitic, and “startlingly organic . . . secondary construction,” this “accretion of dreams” made up of “tattoo parlors, dimly lit stalls stacked with decaying magazines, sellers of fireworks, of cut bait, betting shops, sushi bars, unlicensed pawnbrokers, herbalists, barbers, bars.”24 Instead of the glistening, coherently abstract forms of the modernist pyramid, there is, on the bridge, a “patchwork carnival of scavenged surfaces,” a “formless mass of stuff” culled from other building projects and put to uses for which it was never intended, uses neither foreseen nor managed by any architectural program.25 Neil Campbell has associated the bridge with Foucault’s definition of “heterotopia,” arguing that its “ramshackle, free-form democracy has all the characteristics of a vision of the urban New West as potential heterotopic space,” and indeed that seems to be the case, since no cosa mentale, no “underlying structure,” dominates this other West of the ( future as) other that is the bridge’s bricolage-space, which grows not according to some corporate or vr plan but only through a random but highly energetic and productive sort of accretion and use.26
Architecture and the Virtual West |
The bridge, then, unlike either the pyramid or the Sunflower megastructures, exposes itself to the indefiniteness of an unanticipatable future, an in-coming other for which it makes (a) space but which it does not program. “Things accumulated there,” Yamazaki observes, “around some armature of original purpose, until a point of crisis had been attained and a new program had emerged. But what was that program?” he asks (a question the novel leaves suspended; hanging, as it were, in midair).27 The bridge retains its definitive, modernist program but lives on beyond its limits in a carnivalizing excess of labyrinthine, secondary structures that simply attach themselves to it, as though it were some kind of magnetic attractor welcoming this undesigned stuff that just happens. For Tschumi, this paradox of definite program plus undefinable excess, of the “Pyramid of concepts and the Labyrinth of [sensual, lived] experience, of immaterial architecture as a concept [vr or space] and of material architecture as a presence [event or, as Tschumi likes to say, ‘violence’],” constitutes the very nature of architecture itself and is the source of its double pleasure, a hybrid space we can also associate with the postwestern critical regionalism of a Soja or a Campbell.28 Unlike the vr pornography of a masturbatory modernist architecture, architecture in this double sense—involving both “mental constructs and sensuality,” blueprinted space and unpredictable event—is for Tschumi the “ultimate erotic object, because an architectural act, brought to the level of excess” and taking place at the “possible/impossible junction of concepts and experience,” is the “only way to reveal both the traces of history and its own immediate experiential truth.” The bridge’s secondary structures are the built forms of this erotic “pleasure of excess,” a pleasure embodied here by a suspension bridge that suspends the future as virtual reality by maintaining the irreducible suspense of an always in-coming futurity.29 Taking a cue from Hart Crane’s Brooklyn Bridge, Gibson’s Bay Bridge is a poetic object that sings “when the wind’s just right” and that hums “like a muffled harp” in whose song Yamazaki hears “some message of vast, obscure”—and, ultimately, undefinable— “moment,” a song that marks this site’s open readiness for whatever
89
90
|
michael beehler
is coming, a song addressed to the future as a kind of promissory note.30 Thus the bridge is a specifically chor-al site. Like the “event of architecture” Edward Casey describes in The Fate of Place, the bridge “gives place (donne lieu), gives room for things to happen,”31 just like the chora of the Timaeus, which, in Derrida’s reading, is Plato’s figure for “place as interval,” a place that takes place in “the very excess of spac-ing out,” or “by the very promise of giving place” to what will take place by coming to it from some unprogrammable future.32 The sun of modernity sets on the far side of this choral bridge, on which lies the promise of a new and suspended western spatiality, an other spatiality of the ( future) other. Tschumi has himself sought to build such a choral site, not in the American West of San Francisco but on “125 acres of industrial land in northeastern Paris.”33 His Parc de la Villette, variously described as an “avant garde Disney Land,” an exemplar of “deconstructive” architecture, and an “Urban Park for the 21st Century,” is made up of “35 red folies, sport and recreation areas, playgrounds, a science and technology museum, and a music center.”34 Tschumi overtly associates the Parc with a kind of madness, a figure he derives from Maurice Blanchot: a madness that “serves as a constant point of reference . . . because it appears to illustrate a characteristic situation at the end of the twentieth century—that of disjunctions and dissociations between use, form, and social values.”35 Also figured by the other spatiality of Gibson’s bridge, this mad (or erotic) disjunction between form and function, between architecture as defined space and architecture as unprogrammable event, is not necessarily a negative situation. Tschumi envisions his park, and especially its thirty-five red folies, in exactly the same terms as Gibson sees the Bay Bridge: as a kind of welcoming accumulator for or invitation to what will happen in and on it; to, that is to say, happenstance itself, or to the event-ful-ness that constitutes architecture per se. “The aim,” he writes, “is to free the built folie from its historical connotations and to place it on a broader and more abstract plane, as an autonomous object that, in the future [emphasis added], will be able to receive new meanings.”36 Rejecting the “ideological a priori of the masterplans of the past”—masterplans that,
1. Folie r4 from Event-Cities 2 by Bernard Tschumi. Folies are like mirrors: you project your own fantasies on them. © 2000 by MIT Press.
in Gibson’s novel, are reiterated as the virtual future imaged by the vl glasses—Tschumi’s folies, like the Bay Bridge, serve as anchoring “points of intensity” for future events, places of “new investment” where “the grafts of transference can take hold”: places that, through their disjunctive force or their “programmatic instability,” promise themselves to future uses and make places for those unspecified uses to take place and attach themselves (see fig. 1).37 The madness of this “transgressive architecture” thus lies in its uselessness to any present program, a uselessness that constitutes its perpetual promise to the future.38 And this uselessness fits precisely Tschumi’s characterization of architecture’s survivability: “Architecture seems to survive only when it saves its nature by negating the form that society expects of it . . . there has never been any reason to doubt the necessity of architecture, for the necessity of architecture is its non-necessity. It is useless, but radically so.”39 Radically transgressive because radically useless, radically useless because perpetually promised to the future, the Bay Bridge and the Parc take place as architecture because they are both a little mad about what remains, indefinitely, to come. They embody what we might well call an architecture a folie and, more accurately for Gibson, a specifically
92
|
michael beehler
new western spatiality that, by suspending the purposefulness of the abstract program and the determining grid, lives on in suspense. In Virtual Light this mad promise goes by the name “Thomasson,” the term Yamazaki uses to characterize the Bay Bridge, San Francisco, and the new urban West, and, finally, America itself. As Yamazaki explains it (and Gibson is here citing a real historical event), “Thomasson” was first coined by Japanese “writer and artisan Gempei Akasegawa” in an effort to “describe certain useless and inexplicable moments, pointless yet curiously artlike features of the urban landscape.”40 For reasons that are murky but certainly provocative, Akasegawa uses the name of Gary Thomasson to mark these useless but intensely promising moments and artifacts. According to Yamazaki, “Thomasson was an American baseball player, very handsome, very powerful. He went to the Yomiyuri Giants in 1982, for a large sum of money. Then it was discovered he could not hit the ball.”41 (In fact, Thomasson’s overall batting average in nine seasons in Major League Baseball was a mediocre .249.) When Yamazaki looks at the Bay Bridge—at its disjunctive “magic” and its mad “singularity”—he sees that, “in all the world, surely, there was no more magnificent Thomasson.”42 Yamazaki never saw Tschumi’s folies, but it seems clear that they too are exemplary Thomassons. Like the Bay Bridge, the folies’ mad promise “undoes the pretensions of the systematic and the total,” and as such it functions as the “ultimate explosion of permanent presence.”43 And, finally, this promise functions as an intense irruption of an other virtuality, which this architecture a folie solicits not as the preprogramming of every future by the fantasies of vr but as the mad excess— the unprogrammable futurity—of the present itself. This is the idea of virtuality Grosz opposes to the seductions of virtual reality, and one she believes has much to offer an architectural profession limited by its own pyramidal project or by its modernist dreams of domination. “What,” she asks, does the thought of “virtuality, rather than virtual reality, offer to architecture?” Her answer illuminates both Gibson’s bridge and Tschumi’s Parc, for according to Grosz, virtuality offers “The idea of an indeterminate, unspecified future, open-endedness,
Architecture and the Virtual West |
the preeminence of futurity over the present and the past, the promise not of simulation . . . but of (temporal) displacement, not simply deferral but endless openness.”44 Virtuality thus “resides in the real (as the oxymoron ‘virtual reality’ implies)” almost like the saving impurity of Shapely’s nonpathogenic virus resides in the bodies of Virtual Light: as, that is, the excess in corporeal reality that enables it to sur-vive or keep living to the extent that it transgresses itself, such that it remains disjunctively “open to the future, open to potentialities other than those now actualized.” This is Gibson’s virtual West, his counterstory to the dominating, modernist fantasies of virtual reality and the abstract grid. It is for Grosz only by virtue of this virtual excess in the real, this real excess of virtuality, that the real has a chance to “expand itself,” to live on beyond itself, in different ways, in the future, and so she concludes that “the virtual poses no threat to the real because it is a mode of production and enhancement of the real: an augmentation, a supplementation, and a transformation of the real by and through its negotiation with virtuality.”45 Gibson certainly never read Grosz—and Tschumi built his Parc long before Architecture from the Outside was published—but the Bay Bridge’s other spatiality and the Parc’s architecture a folie invite the chance of a “new West” and of an other future—of, that is to say, a virtual West as the ( future) other, or as the other(‘s) future—by closing the programmed fantasies of virtual reality and by opening the unspecified reality of virtuality. Notes 1. Gibson, Virtual Light, 115. 2. Gibson, Virtual Light, 115, 144. 3. Tschumi, Architecture and Disjunction, 38. 4. Tschumi, Architecture and Disjunction, 38. 5. Gibson, Virtual Light, 97. 6. Campbell, Cultures of the American New West, 160. 7. Gibson, Virtual Light, 14. 8. Davis, City of Quartz, 240. 9. Gustavo Arellano, “O.C. Can You Say . . . ‘anti-Mexican’?” Los Angeles Times, May 8, 2006. 10. Gibson, Virtual Light, 122.
93
94
|
michael beehler
11. Gibson, Virtual Light, 144. 12. Gibson, Virtual Light, 250–51. 13. Gibson, Virtual Light, 251. 14. Grosz, Architecture from the Outside, 42, 43. 15. Grosz, Architecture from the Outside, 46. 16. Gibson, Virtual Light, 259. 17. Gibson, Virtual Light, 207. 18. Gibson, Virtual Light, 209. 19. Gibson, Virtual Light, 258, 259. 20. Gibson, Virtual Light, 323. 21. Gibson, Virtual Light, 209. 22. Gibson, Virtual Light, 323. 23. Gibson, Virtual Light, 62. 24. Gibson, Virtual Light, 62–63. 25. Gibson, Virtual Light, 63, 178. 26. Campbell, Cultures of the American New West, 161; Gibson, Virtual Light, 126. 27. Gibson, Virtual Light, 64. 28. Tschumi, Architecture and Disjunction, 47. 29. Tschumi, Architecture and Disjunction, 71. 30. Gibson, Virtual Light, 44, 159. 31. Casey, The Fate of Place, 313. 32. Derrida and Eisenman, Choral Works, 108; Casey, The Fate of Place, 320. 33. McGill School of Architecture, http://www.arch.mcgill.ca/prof.mellin/ arch671/winter2000/sdarali/precedents/villette.htm. 34. Deconstructive Architecture, http://www.pixcentrix.co.uk/pomo/arch/ arch.htm; Tschumi, Event-Cities 2, 053; Parc de la Villette, http://www.archidose.org/Feb99/020199.htm. 35. Tschumi, Architecture, 175. 36. Tschumi, Architecture, 174. 37. Tschumi, Event-Cities 2, 053; Tschumi, Architecture, 178, 179, 203. 38. Tschumi, Event-Cities 2, 063. 39. Tschumi, Architecture, 46. 40. Gibson, Virtual Light, 64. 41. Gibson, Virtual Light, 64. 42. Gibson, Virtual Light, 63. 43. Casey, The Fate of Place, 316, 317. 44. Grosz, Architecture from the Outside, 88. 45. Grosz, Architecture from the Outside, 90.
2 Nature and d Culture
5. What’s Authentic about Western Literature? And, More to the Point, What’s Literary? lee clark mitchell
Outsider status has long been a vexed issue in western American studies, and not simply because of churning demographics out West, where, as Nancy Cook observes, “authenticity continues to be claimed to assert ‘insider’ status for ‘outsiders’ and to keep newer ‘outsiders’ at bay or powerless.”1 The issue has less to do with priority of arrival than with standards of judgment and thus (among other things) with the kind of literature people value. This literary effect is clearest with the genre most characteristically regional, cowboy Westerns, which share with other popular genres (spy thrillers, detective novels) a deep investment in assumed authenticity, requiring footnotes be strung around like barbed wire to verify unlikely locales, outrageous garb, and improbable activities all within the realm of the actual, the authentic. Ever since James Fenimore Cooper, writers have duly obliged. The phony allure of such assumed historical authenticity has been exposed by a handful of masterful Westerns, even as they celebrate that allure’s venerable hold on tradition—a legacy of faux authenticity that often trumps history itself (or as Maxwell Scott exhorts in John Ford’s The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance, “Print the legend!”).2 Ford’s films in fact offer the perfect example, created by the son of Cape Elizabeth, Maine, just as do the western stories of Stephen Crane, hailing from Port Jervis, New Jersey. Given two such accomplished non-western artists of the West, one wonders why the West still demands literary authenticity so much more stridently than either the South or the North. After all, southerners once held fiercely to a plantation myth, even though that belief did not directly affect resident literary judgments. Northerners
98
|
lee clark mitchell
once endorsed the ideal of a melting-pot nation, though that is only a marginal theme in northern fiction. Why does the West continue to cherish authenticity as an essential standard in judging texts, fictional and otherwise, as if one needed to earn a readership with truth, achieve literary authority with accuracy, and merit by birth the right to authenticity? Moreover, as the reference to Cooper suggests, this is hardly a recent phenomenon, even if the New Western History has lent it luster by self-consciously demolishing myths in order to clear the historical landscape for more “authentic” experiences actually lived by westerners. In the effort to weaken the iron grip of Frederick Jackson Turner, the trio of Patricia Limerick, Richard White, and Donald Worster have resorted to a customary tactic among historians who want to dislodge one of their own: rejecting Turner’s account as history, praising it instead as literature. Yet at a moment when literature professors as well have tried ignoring Turner, it is surprising to see how deeply in his shadow we continue to lie. For central to his thesis is an authenticity of frontier experience that transforms one into a genuine American, by which he means “westerner.” And it is that alleged standard that continues to shape our judgment of literary texts, requiring them to be historically accurate, written by those in the know. It’s time to break the stranglehold historians have placed on western literature, if only to recover certain distinct literary pleasures. That is the goal of a recent collection of essays edited by William Handley and Nathaniel Lewis, True West: Authenticity and the American West, which offers a twin-barreled assault on historical “truth” and “authenticity,” implicitly taking to task such esteemed critics as Wallace Stegner, Ivan Doig, and William Kittredge in order to reveal them as better imaginative writers than their own critical perspective allows. What unites these younger scholars is the idea that regional literature need not be constrained by provincial considerations, either of history or of place. For when authenticity trumps verbal play, when it discounts narrative ploys and literary delight itself, then literature as literature fails. And the converse only confirms the point: that when western literature becomes more remarkable as literature, claims
What’s Authentic about Western Literature? |
of regional authenticity fall by the boards (not as incorrect, but as largely irrelevant). Still, such claims continue, nowhere more forcefully than in the Montana novelist Ralph Beer’s creed that a writer must be rooted in a particular place: “You’d better know the place, and you’d better know the people who live there, and you’d better have some commitment to that place and those people or else what you write is not going to bear up under time or scrutiny. It will ultimately be rejected not only by the people who inhabit that place but by other wise readers as well.”3 Beer’s demand for firsthand knowledge effectively outlaws the writerly imagination that would talk the talk without the proverbial, prerequisite walk. This demand is meant understandably as a rebuke to that long line of eastern writers who have successfully imposed their myth of the West onto a landscape never seen. Yet it sounds uncomfortably like the prologue to Huckleberry Finn, where Mark Twain promises to prosecute, banish, and shoot any reader of a certain critical bent. Perhaps all regionalism encourages this bent, though the West’s colorful landscapes and diverse peoples only exacerbate the situation, with literature and by extension painting, sculpture, and other representational arts necessarily parasitic on what they represent. Because the region always exceeds its representations, we are invariably caught “between the aspiring text and the more perfect form of the West itself,” as Nathaniel Lewis observes; it is a competition that cannot be won, since “the reality is always thought to be more stunning than the painting or book, than memory or anticipation.”4 When authenticity is the gold standard, then literature as literature becomes absorbed by other disciplines: geography, say, or history, or sociology. And even those who agree that much western literature is neither authentic nor well written (popular Westerns, say) cannot ensure that good writing will emerge by simply excluding the inauthentic. Still, that is often the pressure even native western authors feel—to return to the actual, the physical, the lived experience—since as Nancy Cook once again observes, “Many contemporary western writers are judged less by their imaginations than by their ability to be lyrically
99
100
|
lee clark mitchell
descriptive. We still seem to want our western writers to be native informants.”5 That desire is what makes the adjective “realistic” such a ubiquitous sales pitch in Amazon.com’s list of encomiums. So strong is the pressure for regional writing to embrace landscapes, beautiful or sublime, that we can be nonplussed by a writer who simply defies the convention. Richard Ford was once asked whether landscape “contribute[s], in any way, to human action”—a question Turner took for granted, of course, as have many regional writers, western and non-western. “Well, I suppose it does, in one way or another,” Ford slyly riposted. “If it’s cold where you live, then you tend to stay in a lot and get cabin fever. . . . But I think, more commonly that we say it contributes in our attempts to explain our lives to ourselves: why this happened, why we feel this way, why we’re having this problem. The drama is in us, not the mountain range to the west of here. I think landscape is inert, and that we attribute to it qualities, strengths that we say affect our lives. If our explanations persuade us and others, then the relationship to landscape which we’ve advanced becomes true.” Ford’s point is that landscape descriptions are tautological, invoked to confirm qualities we have already attributed to them (think for starters of the melodramatic nineteenth-century landscape paintings of Albert Bierstadt and Frederick Edwin Church). In the effort to break the tautology, Ford denies any imputed value to nature at all, either grandeur or menace: “what I want to do is write something new and not sentimental, something that owes itself more to the imagination than to a responsibility to a place.” It’s not that he denies the promise of lyric description, but that too often that promise is unredeemed: “So these guys who look at the mountains and want to write descriptions of the mountains, what I think is: Hell, go to the mountains! Forget about writing pictures of them. If you want to write pictures of them, make it interesting word for word. . . . That’s why I don’t have a lot of word-pictures in my stories. I don’t have the patience to write them.”6 It’s worth recalling that Ford is a southerner, whose temporary residence in Montana hardly confirmed the authenticity of his vision. And though Stegner would probably have agreed with Ford’s point,
What’s Authentic about Western Literature? |
it is interesting that as a westerner Stegner lined up with Beer in affirming regional writers’ need to be deeply rooted. In 1987, shortly after Ford’s story collection appeared, Stegner made a pointed dismissal of it in those terms: “There have been a lot of migrants. What’s his name—I can’t remember any names this morning—Rock Springs. He paid no attention to the local history or geography. He had gold mines outside of Rock Springs, Wyoming, and things like that. He didn’t give a damn—after all Keats said Cortez. The locals who do give a damn about history and geography and want it straight thought he was a kind of carpetbagger writing southern stories about Montana.”7 Here the authenticity issue achieves an inadvertent clarity, since Stegner starts with censure of Ford for certain alleged geographic blunders, only to end by comparing his efforts with Keats’s first great sonnet: “Or like stout Cortez when with eagle eyes / He star’d at the Pacific—and all his men / Look’d at each other with a wild surmise— / Silent, upon a peak in Darien.” Keats’s mistaking Cortez for Balboa hardly diminishes these closing lines, a conclusion Stegner seems to intend as a surprisingly generous gesture to Ford. After all, the animadverting “locals” alluded to by Stegner comprise only a tiny fraction of even western readers, as Stegner well knew, who are substantially more urban than those in the East. In short, despite Stegner’s aversion to textual errors, cunning inauthenticity always trumps flat-footed truth. By the same token, notwithstanding Ford’s distaste for word pictures, it’s worth holding onto the possibility of landscape description. The most cogent reminder of this lies in the paired epigraphs to a Loren Estleman Western: the first, Mark Twain’s “No weather will be found in this book. This is an attempt to pull a book through without weather”; the second, Hemingway’s “Remember to get the weather in your god damned book—weather is very important.”8 These mutually exclusive injunctions for and against the Weather Channel register a healthily broad range of novelistic agendas. But keep in mind that even when weather is included, it’s always fictional weather, storms brewed out of verbal cold fronts, halcyon days concocted from a narrative brew, and not some meteorological log for a real locale. It’s part of a mise-en-
101
102
|
lee clark mitchell
scène in which, as Ivan Doig so memorably subtitled his memoir, the landscape displays configurations “of a western mind.”9 Documentary realism offers a misleading standard for judging anything other than straightforward chronicle. Literary truth is not geographic truth, after all, but serves a larger metonymic, often psychological role. And the sense of place we cherish in fiction thus offers more than mere lyrical delight in landscape. Take one of my favorite fictional places, Tom Outland’s discovery of Mesa Verde. Willa Cather’s prose evokes a landscape of “silence and stillness and repose,” but even more compellingly it embodies youthful fervor in intellectual horizons expanded, a stunning revelation of what life might be because of what it once was.10 Or take Stegner’s account of coming-of-age in the Saskatchewan prairies of Wolf Willow, which conjures out of the land’s desolate beauty the lineaments of his developing western ethos, his acquired sense of personal restraint and poeticism in a land so spare and open that it always “mark[s] the sparrow’s fall.”11 In neither of these instances do we fidget over authorial authenticity—after all, Cather the southwestern tourist does just fine. What compels us primarily in both is the artist’s inimitable skill at taking native materials and transforming them, without necessarily having lived within them. Yet my mention of Stegner’s affection for the landscape of childhood prompts the question of another kind of authenticity: the nostalgia for a historical past always supplanted by transformations that have made one into a writer capable of experiencing, and representing, that nostalgia. Turner pronounced the frontier’s significance as primarily its passing, a theme reiterated in accounts that tout western history as measure of all that is lost. Yet if cowboy Westerns flagrantly evoke this nostalgia for a simple mythic past, the irony is that those who dismiss the genre as inauthentic rely on the selfsame vision of an irreclaimable world. The argument is simply that that lost world must be recalled more accurately, more authentically, by those who remember. “Looking backward is one of our main hobbies here in the American West, as we age,” Kittredge has proclaimed.12 Underlying this admission is the belief that credible narratives can
What’s Authentic about Western Literature? |
only be written by those