Polymer Spectroscopy Edited by
ALLAN H. FAWCETT The Queens University of Belfast, Belfast, Northern Ireland, UK
JOHN W...
164 downloads
1747 Views
17MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Polymer Spectroscopy Edited by
ALLAN H. FAWCETT The Queens University of Belfast, Belfast, Northern Ireland, UK
JOHN WILEY & SONS Chichester • New York • Brisbane • Toronto • Singapore
Copyright © 1996 by John Wiley & Sons Ltd, Baffins Lane, Chichester, West Sussex PO19 IUD, England National International
01243779777 (+44) 1243 779777
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced by any means, or transmitted, or translated into a machine language without the written permission of the publisher. Other Wiley Editorial Offices John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 605 Third Avenue, New York, NY 10158-0012, USA Jacaranda Wiley Ltd, 33 Park Road, Milton, Queensland 4064, Australia John Wiley & Sons (Canada) Ltd, 22 Worcester Road, Rexdale, Ontario M9W ILl, Canada John Wiley & Sons (SEA) Pte Ltd, 37 Jalan Pemimpin #05-04, Block B, Union Industrial Building, Singapore 2057
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBNO 471960292 Typeset in 10/12pt Times by Thomson Press (India) Ltd, New Delhi Printed and bound by Antony Rowe Ltd, Eastbourne This book is printed on acid-free paper responsibly manufactured from sustainable forestation, for which at least two trees are planted for each one used for paper production.
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS
Gordon G. Cameron Department of Chemistry, University of Aberdeen, Meeston Walk, Old Aberdeen AB92UE, Scotland, UK Michelle Carey Department of Chemistry, Imperial College of Science, Technology and Medicine, South Kensington, London SWl'2AY, UK Trudy G. Carswell Chemistry Department, University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD 4072, Australia Francesco Ciardelli Dipartimento di Chimica e Chimica Industriale, Universita of Pisa, Via Risorgimento 35, 56126 Pisa, Italy Iain G. Davidson Department of Chemistry, University of Aberdeen, Meeston Walk, Old Aberdeen AB9 2UE, Scotland, UK Christine Duch Chemistry Department, University of Wales, Swansea, Singleton Park, Swansea SA2 8PP, Wales, UK Allan H. Fawcett School of Chemistry, The Queen's University of Belfast, Belfast BT95AG, Northern Ireland, UK Adriano Fissi, CNR Institute of Biophysics, University of Pisa, Via Risorgimento 35,56126 Pisa, Italy Jerome Fournier Chemistry Department, University of Wales, Swansea, Singleton Park, Swansea SA2 8PP, Wales, UK R. Wayne Garrett Chemistry Department, University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD 4072, Australia J. G. Hamilton School of Chemistry, The Queens University of Belfast, Belfast BT95AG, Northern Ireland, UK
Robin K. Harris Department of Chemistry, University of Durham, Science Laboratories, South Road, Durham DHl 3LE, UK James R. Hayden Chemistry Department, University of Wales, Swansea, Singleton Park, Swansea SA28PP,Wales,UK Patrick J. Hendra Department of Chemistry, University of Southampton, Highfield, Southampton SO95NH, UK Ian R. Herbert Department of Chemistry, University of Durham, Science Laboratories, South Road, Durham DHl 3LE, UK David J. T. Hill Chemistry Department, University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD 4072, Australia Oliver W. Howarth Centre for Nuclear Magnetic Resonance, Department of Chemistry, University of Warwick, Coventry CV4IAL, UK Roger N. Ibbett Department of Chemistry, University of Durham, Science Laboratories, South Road, Durham DHl 3LE, UK Jack L. Koenig Department of Macromolecular Science, Case Western Reserve University, 10900 Euclid Avenue, Cleveland, OH 44106-7202, USA
W.F.Maddams, Department of Chemistry, University of Southampton, Highfield, Southampton SO95NH,UK James H. O'Donnell Chemistry Department, University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD 4072, Australia (Deceased) David Phillips Department of Chemistry, Imperial College of Science, Technology and Medicine, South Kensington, London SW72AY, UK Osvaldo Pieroni Dipartimento di Chimica e Chimica Industriale, and CNR, Institute of Biophysics, Universita di Pisa, Via Risorgimemto 35, 56126 Pisa, Italy Peter J. Pomery Chemistry Department, University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD 4072, Australia
Adrian R. Rennie Polymers and Colloids Group, Cavendish Laboratory, University of Cambridge, Madingley Road, Cambridge CB3 OHE, UK R. W. Richards Department of Chemistry, University of Durham, Durham DHl 3LE, UK J. J. Rooney School of Chemistry, The Queen's University of Belfast, Belfast BT9 5AG, Northern Ireland, UK
H.W.Spiess Max-Planck-Institute Germany
fur Polymerforschung, Postfach 3148, D-55021 Mainz,
Alan E. Tonelli Fiber and Polymer Science Program, College of Textiles, North Carolina State University, PO Box 8301, Raleigh, NC 27695-8301, USA Graham Williams Chemistry Department, University of Wales, Swansea, Singleton Park, Swansea SA2 8PP, Wales, UK Mark A. Whiskens Department of Chemistry, University of Durham, Science Laboratories, South Road, Durham DHl 3LE, UK Catherine L. Winzor Chemistry of Department University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD 4072, Australia Robert J. Young Manchester Materials Science Centre, University of Manchester, Grosvenor Street, Manchester Ml 7HS, UK
Contents
List of Contributors .............................................................
xiii
Introduction to Polymer Spectroscopy ..........................
1
1. NMR Characterisation of Macromolecules in Solution .......................................................................
7
1.1
Introduction ...................................................................
7
1.2
Branched Molecules: Polyethylene and a Polyester System ..........................................................
9
1.3
The Microstructure of Linear Chains ............................
15
1.4
The Participation of a Charge-Transfer Complex in a Free Radical Polymerization Reaction ......................
22
1.5
The Polymerization of Dienes ......................................
25
1.6
Ring-Opening-Metathesis Polymerizations ..................
30
1.6.1
Stereoselectivity in ROMP .........................
32
1.6.2
Distribution of trans Double Bonds in High cis Poly(Norbornene) .........................
36
1.6.3
Regioselectivity in ROMP ..........................
41
1.6.4
Direct Observation of Tacticity ...................
45
References ...................................................................
52
2. Conformation: the Connection between the NMR Spectra and the Microstructures of Polymers .........
55
1.7
2.1 2.2
Introduction ................................................................... 13
Substituent Effects on C Chemical Shifts .................. This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
55 56
v
vi
Contents 2.3 2.4
2.5
γ-Gauche Effect Method of Predicting NMR Chemical Shifts .............................................................
60
Applications of γ-Gauche Effect Analysis of Polymer Microstructures ...............................................
64
2.4.1
Polypropylene (PP) ....................................
64
2.4.2
Propylene-Vinyl Chloride Copolymers (P-VC) ........................................................
67
2.4.3
Poly(Propylene Oxide) (PPO) ....................
68
2.4.4
Poly(Vinylidene Fluoride) (PVF2) ................
81
NMR Spectroscopy as a Means to Probe Polymer Conformations ..............................................................
84
2.5.1
Styrene-Methyl Methacrylate Copolymers (S-MM) ...................................
84
Ethylene-Vinyl Acetate (E-VAc) Copolymers ................................................
88
NMR Observation of Rigid Polymer Conformations ..............................................................
92
References ...................................................................
93
3. ‘Model-Free’ RIS Statistical Weight Parameters from 13C NMR Data .....................................................
97
2.5.2 2.6 2.7
3.1
Introduction ...................................................................
3.2
Methods ........................................................................ 100
3.3
Some Calculation Details ............................................. 101
3.4
Individual Polymers ...................................................... 102
3.5
The Calculated RIS Parameters .................................. 109
3.6
β-Gauche Effects .......................................................... 111
3.7
Coupling Constants ...................................................... 111
3.8
Characteristic Ratios .................................................... 113
3.9
Conclusions .................................................................. 114 This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
97
Contents
vii
3.10
Acknowledgement ........................................................ 115
3.11
References ................................................................... 115
4. NMR Studies of Solid Polymers ................................ 117 4.1
Introduction ................................................................... 117
4.2
The Techniques ............................................................ 118
4.3
High-Resolution Carbon-13 NMR of Polymers ............ 121
4.4
Proton Spin Relaxation ................................................. 125
4.5
Discrimination in Carbon-13 Spectra ........................... 128
4.6
Spectra of Abundant Spins ........................................... 131
4.7
Conclusion .................................................................... 132
4.8
Acknowledgements ...................................................... 132
4.9
References ................................................................... 133
5. Multidimensional Solid-State NMR of Polymers ...... 135 5.1
Introduction ................................................................... 135
5.2
Multidimensional Solid-State NMR Spectra ................. 137
5.3
Examples ...................................................................... 138 5.3.1
Increase of Spectral Resolution ................. 138
5.3.2
Separated Local Field NMR ....................... 140
5.3.3
Wideline Separation Experiments .............. 141
5.3.4
2D and 3D Exchange NMR ........................ 142
5.3.5
Chain Alignment from 2D and 3D NMR ...... 144
5.3.6
Domain Sizes from Spin Diffusion Experiments ............................................... 146
5.3.7
Spatially Resolved Solid State NMR .......... 146
5.4
Conclusion .................................................................... 148
5.5
Acknowledgements ...................................................... 149
5.6
References ................................................................... 149 This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
viii
Contents
6. NMR Imaging of Polymers ......................................... 151 6.1
6.2
Introduction ................................................................... 151 6.1.1
Basis of NMR Imaging ............................... 151
6.1.2
Relaxation Parameters in NMR Imaging .... 153
6.1.3
Resolution in NMR Imaging ....................... 155
6.1.4
Utility of NMRI ............................................ 155
6.1.5
Image Processing ...................................... 156
Advanced Imaging Techniques .................................... 156 6.2.1
6.3
Chemical Shift Imaging .............................. 156
Applications of NMRI to Polymers ................................ 159 6.3.1
Detection of Voids in Composites .............. 159
6.3.2
Detection of Nonuniform Dispersion of Filler ........................................................... 161
6.3.3
NMRI of Physical Aging ............................. 161
6.3.4
NMRI Studies of Diffusion in Polymers ...... 162
6.3.5
Desorption of Liquids from Polymers ......... 165
6.3.6
Multicomponent Diffusion as Studied by NMRI ......................................................... 167
6.3.7
Absorption-Desorption Cycling of Liquids in Polymers .................................... 169
6.4
Acknowledgements ...................................................... 171
6.5
References ................................................................... 171
7. Fourier Transform Infrared and Raman Spectroscopies in the Study of Polymer Orientation .................................................................. 173 7.1
Introduction ................................................................... 173 7.1.1
The Basis of Orientation Measurements by Infrared Spectroscopy ........................... 174
This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
Contents 7.1.2 7.2
7.3
ix
The Basis of Orientation Measurements by Raman Spectroscopy ............................ 176
........................................................................................ 177 7.2.1
Experimental Techniques on Static Samples ..................................................... 177
7.2.2
Infrared Spectroscopic Studies on Oriented Polymers ..................................... 180
7.2.3
Raman Spectroscopic Studies on Oriented Polymers ..................................... 182
Time Resolved Measurements .................................... 185 7.3.1
The Response of a Viscoelastic System to Sinusoidal Stress ................................... 185
7.3.2
Experimental .............................................. 187
7.3.3
Some Examples of Dynamic Linear Dichroic Infrared Studies ............................ 192
7.4
Elastomers Under Stress ............................................. 198
7.5
Conclusion .................................................................... 200
7.6
References ................................................................... 201
8. Deformation Studies of Polymers using Raman Spectroscopy ............................................................. 203 8.1
8.2
8.3
Introduction ................................................................... 203 8.1.1
Polydiacetylene Single Crystals ................. 204
8.1.2
Extension of the Technique to Other Materials .................................................... 206
High-Performance Polymer Fibres ............................... 206 8.2.1
Aromatic Polyamide Fibres ........................ 206
8.2.2
Polyethylene Fibres ................................... 210
Isotropic Polymers ........................................................ 214 8.3.1
Urethane-Diacetylene Copolymers ............ 214
This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
x
Contents 8.3.2 8.4
Deformation Studies .................................. 217
Composites ................................................................... 221 8.4.1
Single-Fibre Composites ............................ 221
8.4.2
Interfacial Micromechanics ......................... 224
8.5
Conclusions .................................................................. 227
8.6
Acknowledgements ...................................................... 228
8.7
References ................................................................... 228
9. Spin-Label Studies of Heterogeneous Polymer Systems ...................................................................... 231 9.1
Introduction ................................................................... 231 9.1.1
9.2
Synthesis of Spin Labels ............................ 232
Theoretical Background ............................................... 235 9.2.1
9.2.2
Correlation Times ...................................... 235 9.2.1.1
Fast Motion ................................... 239
9.2.1.2
Slow Motion ................................... 240
The Glass Transition and T50G ................... 240
9.3
Heterogeneous Systems .............................................. 242
9.4
Polymer Blends ............................................................. 245
9.5
References ................................................................... 251
10. The Use of ESR Spectroscopy for Studying Polymerization and Polymer Degradation Reactions .................................................................... 253 10.1
Introduction ................................................................... 253
10.2
Experimental ................................................................. 254
10.3
Results and Discussion ................................................ 255 10.3.1 Free Radical Polymerization ...................... 255 10.3.1.1 Identification of the Radicals in the ESR Spectrum ........................ 255
This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
Contents
xi
10.3.1.2 Measurement of Radical Concentration ................................ 256 10.3.1.3 Monomer Concentration during Polymerization ............................... 256 10.3.1.4 Radical Concentration during Polymerization ............................... 257 10.3.1.5 Correction for Changing Sensitivity of the Spectrometer ..... 259 10.3.1.6 Kinetic Analysis ............................. 260 10.3.1.7 Crosslinking Methacrylate Monomers ..................................... 261 10.3.2 Polymer Degradation by High-Energy Radiation ................................................... 263 10.3.2.1 Poly(Methyl Methacrylate) ............. 263 10.3.2.2 Polystyrene ................................... 267 10.3.2.3 Random Copolymers of Methyl Methacrylate and Styrene ............. 268 10.3.2.4 ESR and the Mechanism of Radiolysis ...................................... 269 10.4
Conclusions .................................................................. 273
10.5
Acknowledgements ...................................................... 273
10.6
References ................................................................... 273
11. Dynamics of Bulk Polymers and Polymerizing Systems as Studied Using Dielectric Relaxation Spectroscopy ............................................................. 275 11.1
Introduction ................................................................... 275
11.2
Amorphous Polymers: Phenomenological and Molecular Aspects ........................................................ 276
11.3
Crystalline Polymers ..................................................... 280
This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
xii
Contents 11.4
Liquid Crystalline (LC) Polymers .................................. 282
11.5
Real-Time Studies of Chemical and Physical Changes ....................................................................... 288
11.6
Conclusions and Future Prospects .............................. 293
11.7
Acknowledgements ...................................................... 294
11.8
References ................................................................... 294
12. Light Scattering from Polymer Systems .................. 297 12.1
Introduction ................................................................... 297
12.2
Small Angle Light Scattering (SALS) ........................... 298 12.2.1 Semi-Crystalline Polymers ......................... 298 12.2.2 Phase-Separating Polymer Mixtures .......... 305
12.3
Quasi-Elastic Light Scattering (QELS) ......................... 309 12.3.1 Dilute Polymer Solutions ............................ 309 12.3.2 Gels ........................................................... 311 12.3.3 Semi-Dilute Solutions and Trapped Chains ....................................................... 313 12.3.4 Surface Quasi-Elastic Light Scattering (SQELS) .................................................... 316
12.4
Conclusions .................................................................. 321
12.5
References ................................................................... 321
13. Neutron Scattering from Polymers ........................... 325 13.1
Introduction ................................................................... 325
13.2
The Principles of Neutron Scattering ........................... 325
13.3
Neutron Experiments .................................................... 329 13.3.1 Studies of Polymer Dimensions: Small Angle Scattering ........................................ 330 13.3.2 Polymers at Surfaces-Reflection ................ 333
This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
Contents
xiii
13.3.3 Polymer Dynamics-Quasi-Elastic Scattering .................................................. 334 13.4
Some Examples of Recent Progress ........................... 336 13.4.1 Studies of Copolymers ............................... 336 13.4.2 Adsorption at Surfaces ............................... 339 13.4.3 Kinetics and Polymer Motion ...................... 341
13.5
Final Remarks ............................................................... 342
13.6
References ................................................................... 342
14. Optical Activity and the Structure of Macromolecules ......................................................... 347 14.1
Introduction ................................................................... 347 14.1.1 Origin of Optical Activity in Macromolecules ......................................... 347 14.1.2 Objective .................................................... 350
14.2
Chiroptical Properties of Photochromic Polypeptides ................................................................. 351 14.2.1 Polypeptides Photoresponsive to UV Light ........................................................... 351 14.2.1.1 Azobenzene-Containing Polypeptides .................................. 351 14.2.1.2 Light-Induced Conformational Changes ........................................ 352 14.2.1.3 Photosimulated AggregationDisaggregation Effects .................. 355 14.2.2 Photomodulation of Polypeptide Conformation by Sunlight ........................... 357 14.2.2.1 Spiropyran-Containing Polypeptides .................................. 357
This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
xiv
Contents 14.2.2.2 Photomodulation of Conformation ................................. 360 14.2.2.3 Photoinduced Variations of Viscosity ........................................ 366 14.3
References ................................................................... 367
15. Polymer Luminescence and Photophysics ............. 369 15.1
Introduction ................................................................... 369
15.2
Probes of Order in Polymers ........................................ 370
15.3
Probes of Sub-Group Motions ...................................... 372
15.4
Photochemistry in Polymers ......................................... 372
15.5
Excimer-Forming Polymers .......................................... 374
15.6
Dynamics of Luminescence ......................................... 376
15.7
Fluorescence Decay in Vinyl Aromatic Polymers ........ 377 15.7.1 Diffusional Models ..................................... 379 15.7.1.1 Random Walk Migration, Evenly Spaced Chromophores ................. 380 15.7.1.2 Random Water, Random Distribution Chromophores ........... 380 15.7.1.3 Multiple Trap Energies .................. 381 15.7.1.4 Reversible Excimer Formation ...... 381 15.7.1.5 Diffusion of Energy and Chromophore ................................ 381 15.7.1.6 Fluorescence Anisotrophy Measurements .............................. 385
15.8
Conclusion .................................................................... 387
15.9
Acknowledgements ...................................................... 388
15.10 References ................................................................... 388
Index .................................................................................. 391 This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
INTRODUCTION TO POLYMER SPECTROSCOPY A. H. FAWCETT
The Queen's University of Belfast
Historically there was a difficulty in dealing with macromolecules that was simply the realisation of their large size; the organic chemist's early painstaking methodology for isolating, studying and recognising the readily obtained small natural product molecule did not lend itself to the examination of many natural macromolecules such as cellulose and rubber. Such chemists, used to identifying their substances by the melting point complemented by similar studies on the derivatives and then the slow construction of the molecule by use of a developing repertoire of piecemeal reactions, were slow to accept how readily high polymers might be man-made by a simple but powerful repetitive process. Ancient practices and evolving technology might utilise materials such as wood, leather, silk and cotton, but the true macromolecular nature of these materials was not appreciated until about 60 years ago, and methods for exploring the large molecule and the development of appropriate concepts for a proper scientific enquiry took time to evolve. Spectroscopy has played a role in this process, light scattering in particular being used to show how high molecular weights might be, and NMR spectroscopy latterly being used to identify polymer structures. Now spectroscopy is at the heart of modern developments within polymer science, being used not only to characterise the microstructure of the chains, but also to monitor their dynamics, so important in determining the physical properties of interest to the materials scientist and engineer, and to explore the interesting properties that are being introduced in the search for special effects to be used in devices. Two developments have given us insight into polymers at the molecular level, the first being the spectroscopic techniques for recognising molecular components and the manner in which they are linked together, which is the topic of the first part of this book. Of course, the analytical problem of recognising a particular polymer is less severe to the man who chose the monomer and the polymerisation process (and any plasticiser or stabiliser) than it is to a would-be emulator, but the proper description of the microstructure of a macromolecule is as essential to the developmental chemist (Chapter 1) as it is to his competitor. For this purpose, NMR spectroscopy has now overtaken IR spectroscopy as the Polymer Spectroscopy. Edited by Allan H. Fawcett © 1996 John Wiley & Sons Ltd
analytical tool in general use. A second advance, much associated with Flory, was the development of statistical mechanical methods. These have provided insight into the equilibrium configurations of the isolated polymer chain and the manner in which modest thermal energies develop elaborate configurations within the backbones and any side chains, so that the calculations of the mean values of such quantities as dipole moment and end-to-end distance are complex, yet focus upon such readily visualised ideas as the potential surface for the conformations of each pair of adjacent bonds. NMR spectroscopic quantities such as chemical shift and coupling constant may be considered in just these terms, as Tonelli has described for us (Chapter 2). One has only to reflect on a subject area such as liquid crystals, where so often the description is formulated by the physicist in terms of unit cell properties, to realise how much closer workers with polymers routinely think in terms of molecular structure, and are able to link a certain molecular feature to an interesting property. Configurational elaborations are the prime characteristic of molecules rendered extremely long by the repetitive enchainment of a small number of simple residues: Ciardelli et al. describe the manner in whch stimuli such as light may induce changes in the structure of pendent groups and so in polymer-solvent interactions that are amplified by the connectivity of the system to cause profound changes in the equilibrium statistics of the single chain, and hence in its solution properties. Indeed, a group of chains may so be led to associate reversibly (Chapter 14). The manner in which light interacts with chromophores in bulk polymers, located either within the standard residues or merely within minor components such as end groups, is the subject of Phillips and Carey's contribution (Chapter 15). There are two interrelated factors to be disentangled—the manner in which light is absorbed, whether it is retained or migrates, and how the energy is eventually used, together with the dynamics of the moieties involved in this process. Excimer formation, luminescence, fluorescence and other photophysics processes are all subject to such factors as spacing constraints and the timescales of segmental motions, which in the bulk are not merely the property of a single molecule. Although the physical chemistry of the chain isolated in solution is well understood, the question of its performance within the bulk has thus become the subject of much study. Rapid movement between adjacent conformations ceases below the glass transition of an amorphous polymer, and in the crystalline state packing effects become significant and restrict configurations to a very few. The question of the location of the backbone is readily tackled: spectroscopic techniques for studying the configurations of the polymer in amorphous and crystalline phases within the bulk are well established; neutron scattering is a prime, if expensive, tool for the determination of molecular dimensions and for the study of dynamics (in a quasielastic scattering mode) and is now being developed as a method for studying surface structures (Chapter 13). The contrast is obtained by use of perdeuterated molecules. Light scattering is a more familiar
tool for investigating polymers; the method was introduced originally by such luminaries as Debye, and has developed, with the availability of lasers, in the quasielastic mode, not just for chains isolated in solution but also for gels, when various modes of motion may be inferred from treatments of the fluctuations of the intensity of the light scattered. The technique is now applied to studying phase separating mixtures and events within polymers upon surfaces (Chapter 12). Richards also covers the small angle light scattering method as used to investigate semi-crystalline polymers. IR and Raman spectroscopy characterise the high frequency vibrations of the skeleton and pendent atoms of the macromolecule, and so immediately tell us what groups are present; they have a useful analytical capacity to distinguish, for example, a poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) from a PVC or a polyolefin. Vibration modes extend over several simple oscillators (such as bonds and bond angles); in the crystalline state they reflect the arrangement adopted within the unit cell, from which IR bands and Raman shifts follow conventional symmetryrelated selection rules. They may be used to measure crystallinity, as such. In the amorphous state conformational elaborations are not averaged out on the timescale of the vibration. Observed bands are thus composite and relatively broad, and although they may indicate whether in a rubber a double bond is cis or trans, and may measure the presence of methyl groups in low density polyethylene, band frequencies are not as sensitive as solution NMR spectroscopy to microstructure details extending over several residues. The fine structure observed in the shifts of linear polymers is itself a topic of careful consideration, as Tonelli and Howarth et al. have described (Chapters 2 and 3). The conformational origin within vinyl polymers of the patterns displayed in 13 C shifts is now well established, and provides the best source of information on tacticity and residue sequence, so that one might attempt to discriminate between mechanisms for propagation, such as those of the Bernoullian and Markov type, those involving charge-transfer complexes, and mechanisms involving catalysts derived from metal complexes (Chapter 1). Once one has evidence on the reaction mechanism, one may proceed to the design of new and better catalysts. Like vibration spectroscopy, NMR in the solid state, made feasible by the cross polarisation-magic angle spinning dipole decoupling method, is similarly rather insensitive to microstructural issues within the crystalline and amorphous states, but interesting results may be obtained when carefully chosen systems are compared: Harris presents the cases of the 4/1 helix of syndiotactic polypropylene and the 3/1 helix of isotactic polypropylene, the former clearly displaying sensitivity to the helix structure through the gamma-gauche effect so that internal and external methylenes are distinguished, and the latter displaying some sensitivity to the helix sense of the neighbouring chains (Chapter 4). The solid state NMR method is capable also of sensing inhomogeneities such as arise from microcrystals within a homopolymer such as polyethylene, and within blends of two different and only partly compatible polymers (Chapters 4 and 5), an area
that is similarly tractable by modern two-dimensional methods that are being developed within IR spectroscopy (Chapter 7). Both chemical shift and IR vibration frequency of one chain are sensitive to the nature of the neighbouring chains, particularly if an interaction such as a hydrogen bond is possible. The timescale of magnetic polarisation decay is capable of being linked to the size of the inhomogeneities. Mobility as measured by proton or carbon NMR relaxation times is a property of matter, including polymeric materials and any permeated liquid, that may be sensed by a scanning technique and displayed in an image form, usually in two dimensions. Koenig surveys for us the various applications he has made, the images providing an interesting comparison with the more conventional light and electron microscope viewing methods (Chapter 6). Vibration spectroscopy is sensitive, as Hendra and Maddams describe (Chapter 7), to such factors as anisotropy within such samples as uniaxially drawn rods and biaxially drawn films, allowing their properties to be optimised from an understanding of the molecular process. Such well established use of IR spectroscopy is now being succeeded by dynamic dichroic methods, to reveal how the backbones and side chains separately respond to imposed cyclic stresses. This provides a fascinating account of the manner in which different modes of motion come into play. A development of Raman spectroscopy described by Young is the response of certain vibrations in the spectrum to a progressive strain imposed upon the material, a technique that may exploit recent instrumental developments such as charge coupled device cameras and the confocal Raman microscope (Chapter 8). For a composite material, the technique allows us to answer a question such as the manner of the distribution of strain along a polyaramid fibre within a matrix that initially bears the imposed stress; the particular interest is the length of fibre required to take up the strain. The timescale of the response of a polymer to a stimulus ranges from the high frequencies of IR radiation through to the low frequencies or long time scales of diffusion of the whole molecule by the reptation mechanism, a process that is amenable to study by dielectric relaxation spectroscopy, as in studies on cispolyisoprene by Adachi. The dielectric response is present only from polar units, and is governed by the location of the dipoles, whether within side chains or backbones, in the geometry of the dipole itself and the geometry and flexibility of the neighbouring segments. For the chain in solution, simple and satisfactory accounts are available in these terms, and only in special cases do the dipoles themselves mutually organise to control the response. For the bulk material, whether in crystalline, amorphous or liquid crystalline form, cooperations between chains may be significant. For example, the alpha relaxation of crystalline polyethylene is a progression of a kink in one chain within a crystalline region, as computer simulations have modelled: it is the linear all-trans neighbours that define the tube within which the single chain performs (Chapter 11). Distributions of correlation times may be extremely wide in an amorphous material, but how
much this derives from variations in local conformations and orientations of the dipole within the chain in question, and how much from intra-chain influences (which may themselves have a response) is, as they say, a very good question! The same issues arise when studying the dynamic mechanical behaviour of polymers, a method closer to the concerns of the polymer engineers. Perhaps the developing power of NMR spectroscopy to measure correlation functions and the magnitude of the orientational jump and to identify the pathways of the motion will help provide an answer to these questions (Chapter 5). As Spiess describes, the NMR method might measure the angle of displacement, as well as its frequency, for poly(oxymethylene), displaying helical jump dynamics. Two-dimensional and three-dimensional experiments are now being performed to measure motions and to determine order within oriented solids (Chapter 5). The use of a paramagnetic probe coupled with electron spin resonance (ESR) monitoring provides information, within the timescale range of 10"3 s to 10"7 s, of a complementary nature, for by sensing the mode of rotation of the radical within the polymeric matrix, it measures the behaviour of the "holes", the packets of free volume, that facilitate the movements of the chains and play a vital role in the glass transition, Tg, phenomena. Locating the radical on the chain or at its end allows one to sense the extra degree of freedom at a polymer chain end (Chapter 9). The ESR technique in this book is applied to a second issue, monitoring the radicals actually responsible for a polymerisation of pure monomer plus a certain amount of crosslinker, the interest lying in the changes that take place to create a new regime when the gel effect operates, during which termination reactions are much retarded by the immobilisation of the radicals, as they are also in the final period, when the development of a glass is the cause of onset of a third regime (Chapter 10). O'Donnell's work monitors the radicals by ESR and the unreacted groups by near-IR spectroscopy, to reveal new insight into the kinetics during these periods. This study of the chemistry of free radical polymerisation is succeeded by a discussion of an equally important topic, as far as industrial use is concerned, the detailed chemistry of degradation by ionising radiation of polystyrene and poly(methyl methacrylate): following such training, O'Donnell's previous students helped develop microlithography. This book records the principal lectures given at a Conference in Grasmere organised by the Macro Group. The proceedings of two of the previous conferences with this subject area and sponsorship have also been published [1, 2] and provide a useful indication of the developments that have occurred over recent years in the practice and value of polymer spectroscopy.
REFERENCES [1] KJ. Ivin (Ed.), Structural Studies of Macromolecules by Spectroscopic Methods, John Wiley & Sons, London, 1976. [2] A.H. Fawcett, Br. Polym. /., 1987,219,97 and following papers.
1 NMR CHARACTERISATION OF MACROMOLECULES IN SOLUTION A. H. FAWCETT, J. G. HAMILTON AND J. J. ROONEY School of Chemistry, The Queens University of Belfast, Belfast BT9 5AG, Northern Ireland, UK
1.1 INTRODUCTION The NMR method of studying the microstructure of macromolecules is the most effective available, provided that the materials can be obtained in solution. The method is now routinely employed to characterise and to identify the structures present in polymers, both those in common use and those created by the chemist when working with new monomers or new catalyst systems [1-6]. Derivatives of polymers and reactions on polymers are similarly accessible to study. The NMR parameter that is sensitive to these structural issues is the chemical shift, commonly measured in ppm from an internal reference. It senses readily information on the framework of the polymer—its connectivity—by providing information on the number and type of atoms linked to each particular nucleus, and also senses such factors as the relative chirality of pairs of such centres and cis/trans isomerism within double bonds. The nucleus most often employed for both man-made and natural macromolecules is 13C, despite its being rather dilute (only 1% of the carbons). This is because in the spectrum the dispersion of shifts is particularly large; much detail or fine structure is generally encountered that is directly related to the polymer structure itself, and signal intensity is rarely a problem with modern high field instruments. Many other NMR-active nuclei such as 19 F and 31 P may be used too when they are present in the macromolecule. Proton NMR spectra are complicated by the presence of coupling effects between the spins of the protons if, as is usual, the protons are present on directly bonded carbon atoms. In certain cases these coupling effects are of extreme value: as Bovey showed for poly(methyl methacrylate) [2,7], the tacticity of the polymers may be identified directly, and the value of vicinal coupling constants provides information on the conformational properties of the bond [5,8]. However, frequently, as for example with polyolefins, they conceal the shift effects associated with the microstructure Polymer Spectroscopy. Edited by Allan H. Fawcett © 1996 John Wiley & Sons Ltd
by creating a multiplicity of splittings, a complicating factor which may be relieved only by the use of a substantial proportion of selective deuteration, as has been demonstrated for polypropylene [9,10]. We may note two rather special cases of proton NMR spectra: for highly syndiotactic polystyrene the methylene protons, being equivalent, have a simple three line 1:2:1 pattern that derives from the coupling effect of the two flanking methine protons [ H ] . The highly isotactic polymer has a slightly more complex but still recognisable spectrum [12]. Features in the spectrum of the atactic polymer are quite unrecognisable, as proton coupling effects intermingle with chirality effects, coupled with substantial chemical shift anisotropy from the phenyl ring [13]: each main chain carbon bears at least one proton, a situation that is unfortunately more usual. We are familiar with only one case, involving the furfurol oligomer bis(5-furfuryl-2-furylmethane), in which the methylene protons are more sensitive to position than is the carbon of the same group; this is probably because the central methylene protons sample the anisotropic shielding cone of the furan rings in a manner different from that for the protons of the flanking methylene groups, but the carbons, being in the plane of the rings, experience a constant effect [14]. During the last 25 years the development of the NMR method, firstly in terms of the power of the magnet employed and secondly by turning to computer-based operating systems, has often been stimulated, if not driven, by the need to understand polymer microstructure. In 1971 the chemical companies Dow, ICI and Du Pont themselves commissioned new magnets that increased the magnetic field beyond 5 T in order to pursue their studies of polymers so vital to their business. This magnetic field, equivalent to more than 200 MHz in terms of the proton resonance frequency, was achieved by employing superconducting windings at cryogenic temperatures [15]. The stronger the magnetic field, the greater the sensitivity and the dispersion of shifts (and the closer the proton spectra come to being first order). Initially man-made polymers were the subjects of study, but more recently biological polymers have been the targets. The last ten years has seen field strengths in common use rise to 11.74 T (equivalent to 500MHz for protons and 125.7 MHz for carbons) by the adoption of superconducting magnets, and similar technical improvements associated with versatile signal transmitter and receiver coil design have also come into common practice. Indeed, 17.5 T instruments have recently been announced. Just as important as these developments in magnet design has been the introduction of pulsed Fourier transform methods, for these permit the performance of new types of experiment by the computerised systems that control the production, acquisition and processing of the experimental data. New pulse sequences increasingly made available by instrument manufacturers within their software suites permit the routine performance of these new experiments: an early example is the distortionless enhancement polarisation transfer, or DEPT, experiment to identify the number of protons attached to a carbon by controlling the final
proton pulse flip angle [16]. A later example is provided by 2-D and 3-D experiments, the introduction of which has made the connectivity of the carbon and protons much clearer [17,18], has much reduced the problem of distinguishing coupling effects from shift effects by providing extra dimensions for displaying the NMR signal, and has even provided an extra structure-discriminating route [19-22]. One development that exploits the storage of data on the computer base for subsequent processing can be optimised for a particular purpose, such as resolution enhancement using the Lorentz-Gaussian transformation technique, in which the free induction decay data is multiplied by the product of a Lorentzian and a Gaussian weighting function prior to the Fourier transformation [23]. Similarly, the computer base has been used for some time to control measurements within the time domain and to provide values for such parameters as T1, the spin-lattice relaxation time, which is sensitive to the motions of the chains, such as those of polysulphones, whose dynamic response is dispersed on opposite sides of the Larmor frequency when made from 1-olefins and 2-olefins [24]. The nuclear Overhauser enhancement (NOE effect) is also sensitive to the motions of the polymer chains, and good practice, when careful quantitative measurements of 13 C signals are required, is to use instrument settings that eliminate the NOE [25], so preventing it from enhancing the signals of certain carbons relative to those of others.
1.2 BRANCHED MOLECULES: POLYETHYLENE AND A POLYESTER SYSTEM We choose to start our discussion of the 13 C chemical shift effects in macromolecules with a mention of the substitution parameter schemes such as those of Grant and Paul [26], which were introduced into polymer spectroscopy by Bovey at an earlier conference in the series [I]. The rule that a carbon's chemical shift increases by a fairly constant increment when a covalently attached hydrogen atom is replaced by a methyl group, the alpha effect, has proved of value when spectral assignments are made. Similar parameters associated with substitution at progressively more remote sites, the beta, gamma and even delta effects, have been established and found to diminish in magnitude (alpha = 11 to 2.5 ppm, beta = 9 to 7ppm, gamma= —2.5ppm, delta = O to 0.5ppm). Although quite precise values are often given [2,3], the values of these parameters are sensitive to the exact structure of the site of supposed structural change, and the best practice utilises model compounds close to the target structures, as in Randal's studies on the side chains of polyethylene [27-29]. A development of this substitution approach, which is appropriate to molecules containing heteroatoms, is to study the effect on chemical shifts of replacing a —CH 2 — group with another atom or group. This has been used to predict shifts in molecules and polymers containing
Figure 1.1 100 MHz 13C NMR spectrum of a high density polyethylene sample in solution at 125 0C. The spectrum shows peaks from end groups (E) and methyl, ethyl and butyl side chains. The sample had been irradiated at 423 K with 300 KGy of gamma rays [32] and shows minor features near 29,32 and 41 ppm from the H structures thus formed —O—, —NH— and —SO 2 — groups, the electronegativity of these groups causing in general a down-field effect. Thus, the shifts of polymers containing heteroatoms may also be predicted from first principles, for assignment purposes, if the shift of the corresponding hydrocarbon is known [30]. For the high density polyethylene spectrum of Figure 1.1, the main feature is the intense signal at 30 ppm from the long runs of methylene units. The shifts of the end groups (marked E 1 , E 2 , E 3 as we move inwards from the methyl signal) are the next feature, but a number of resonances from side chains are present. The methyl group of a butyl side chain coincides with E 1 , but the second methylene group, E 2 , is distinguished at % 23.4 ppm. The methyl groups of a small proportion of ethyl side chains (Etx) and methyl side chains (Me1) are also seen at 20 and 11 ppm respectively. The main chain carbons at the root of and next to the branches are also seen, the assignments for those next to the butyl unit being shown in the first part of Scheme 1. Methyl and ethyl side chains are probably derived from traces of propene and but-1-ene within the ethylene feedstock. The features from these are clear, but are in very small proportions compared with the end group signals for this linear polyethylene.
-CH2-CH2-CH-CH2-CH2CH 2 -CH 2 -CH 2 -CH 3 Bu3 Bu2 Buj Butyl side chains to polyethylene —CH2-CH2-CH-CH2-CH2-CH2-CH2-CH-CH2-CH2H crosslinks
— CH2-CH2-CH-CH2-CH2CH2-CH2-CH2Y links / long branches (1)
Scheme 1 Elementary structure in polyethylenes.
Application to the field of low density polyethylenes was prompted by the need to understand the high proportion of carbons in the form of methyl groups (perhaps as much as 8%), an early result from the IR spectra. The studies led to the recognition of an elaborate branched structure, for the production of which the mechanism of Roedel, backbiting by the propagating radical, was introduced. The normal process produces butyl side chains as a result of a cyclic transition state of five carbons-I-one hydrogen for the intramolecular hydrogen atom abstraction. Ethyl side chains (Et) may have formed by two consecutive backbitings. Randal has characterised low density polyethylene and related copolymers by carbon-13 NMR spectroscopy: complex dendritic structures are revealed by the analysis [30]. Long side chains form also by intermolecular abstractions of hydrogen atoms—chain transfer to polymer. A study of linear low density polymers, the side chains of which, as they derive from a 1-olefin component of known structure and occurrence, are well-defined, allowed the derivation of substitution parameters appropriate to the polyethylene problem itself, gave much security to this approach [27,28], and so led to the full assignment of the methylene carbon shifts dispersed on each side of the main signal at 30.0 ppm from the long runs of methylene groups. More assignments subtle were also found, such as a distinction between the methyl groups at the end of butyl side chains (14.21 ppm) and those at the ends of longer chains (14.01 ppm) [29]. Besides the use of substitution parameters, assignments were also made using special spectrometer settings: APT (attached proton test) and DEPT techniques allow the direct recognition of quaternary carbons, of methylenes and of methyls and methines together [30]. A coherent view of the complex dendritic structure of free radically-produced low density polyethylene is now available. The usual microstructural features of high density polyethylene, alkyl side chains, have also been observed in ultra high molecular weight polyethylene, but in much smaller proportions [31].
A related study has been the elucidation of the crosslink structures induced within polyethylene by high energy radiation. The secondary carbon radicals thus produced by C—H bond scission may diffuse by hydrogen atom abstraction. They have been shown to combine in pairs to form H type junctions, and to create Y type junctions by reactions with the vinyl end groups of the chains and with primary carbon radicals produced by main chain scission. In each case the shifts characteristic of the new structure were identified [32]. The shifts of the H junctions are distinct, being 41.1, 31.9 and 28.7 ppm respectively at the (CH) junction and the first and second linked carbons, as is shown in Scheme 1, but the shifts of the Y junctions coincide with those at the roots of long branches, and their formation is recognised only when a careful comparison has been made of the areas of these shifts before and after irradiation. In a similar area, that of the characterisation of branched and network polyesters from difunctional acids and tri- or tetra-functional alcohols, in systems that were first used about 150 years ago when there was no understanding of their polymeric nature, our studies have found a similar sensitivity in the NMR spectrum [33] within the 55-75 ppm region, where the carbons of the alcohol and ester functions are found; see Scheme 2. The shifts of the carbons of glycerol [33] or erythritol [34] during the progressive conversion of alcohol functions to ester groups by a reaction with succinic anhydride change after each step by a few ppm in a manner that is readily recognised, for the sequence in time and symmetry of substitution of the molecules that form reflects the greater reactivity of the primary alcohol sites. Thus, replacing the —O—H group of an alcohol with an O—H
i
I CH2-CH-CH2-O-H O-SA-OH O—H III CH 2 -CH-CH 2 O—SA-OH O—SA-OH
II CH 2 -CH-CH 2 -O-H O-H O-SA-OH O—H IV CH 2 -CH-CH 2 -O-SA-OH O—SA-OH
O—SA-OH V CH 2 -CH-CH 2 -O-SA-OH
l O — S A - OH Scheme 2 Primary oligomers of glycerol and succinic acid
—O—succinate has at the first, second and third carbons alpha, beta and gamma effects of respectively +2.6, —3.1 and — 0.4 ppm [33]. (These alpha, beta and gamma parameters correspond to the beta, gamma and delta parameters of Grant and Paul [26] because of the intervening oxygen atom.) If the second site of the succinic acid residue subsequently forms an ester, the shifts of the previously linked glycerol residue appear in slightly different places. Thus, a glycerol residue linked 1, 3 within a chain has different shifts from one linked 1, 3 at the end of a chain and from the oligomeric 1,3-discuccinate (III). We have introduced the term III" for such a chain-extending unit and III' for a unit at the end of a branch, the number of primes indicating how many of the second, and more remote, acid groups have reacted. The shifts of the glyceryl residues of the oligomers of Scheme 2 thus provide good guides to the shifts of glyceryl residues at branch points (V), in chain extenders (III and IV) and at chain ends (I and II) in the highly branched or fractal polymers that may be made, thus allowing the assignments of Figure 1.2. The trisuccinate oligomer V can be readily obtained in pure form [33], unlike the other oligomers. It may be polymerised in a single process by heating in a vacuum, where succinic acid is first lost as the anhydride to the vapour phase, and the vacated alcohol site (in a III or IV type residue, for which evidence is present in Figure 1.3) then forms an ester with an acid group of another oligomer. The consequence of this development of linkages is seen in the shifts of each carbon of the glycerol residue, where extra fine structure develops as the molecule evolves towards a dendritic or fractal structure. The initial molecule is a heptamer (XV of Scheme 3 [33]), but others emerge. The shifts are sensitive not only to whether the link at the remote site has formed an ester, but also (in the case of the central carbon) to whether that site was a primary or a secondary alcohol. The shifts of the network node are sensitive to the structure of the immediately
Figure 1.2 13C NMR spectrum at 126 MHz of the mixture of oligomers formed by the reaction of glycerol with succinic anhydride [33]. Only the region of the glycerol residue shifts is shown. The oligomers are identified in Scheme 2; G refers to glycerol
Figure 1.3 13C NMR spectrum at 126MHz of the mixture of oligomers formed by heating oligomer V in a vacuum at 1800C. Parts (a) and (c) for 40 min, part (b) for 20 min, part (d) for 60 min. The labels refer to Scheme 3. The region of the glycerol residue shifts is shown in (a), and for the higher resolution plots (b-d) only the signal from the central methine carbon. The resolution of the latter parts was obtained with zero line broadening. Reproduced with permission from [33] adjacent nodes when the link is succinic acid, but not if glutaric acid is used, for the extra methylene group renders the linkage too remote. In Figure 1.3 the shifts at three early stages may be seen, as the molecules evolve towards a polymeric form of III: peaks z and y 3 we assign to the shifts of the primary and secondary glycerol carbons when the primary carbon is linked to another glycerol residue; peaks yx and y 2 come from a secondary carbon of a glycerol which is linked through a succinic acid residue to respectively a primary and a secondary site of a glycerol residue, as shown in Scheme 3. These distinctions in the fine structure are relatively minor, are best observed with a high field system [33], and assist in the development of the chemistry of the formation of fractal polyesters. Novel liquid crystalline forms, for example, have been produced using such means, the
XV [V'- S A - VT 3 y3 z yi 1 H—O—SA-O—CH 2 -CH-CH 2 -O—SA-O—CH-(—CH 2 -O-SA-OH) 2
XVI
O—SA-OH 3 y3 z H-O-SA-O-CH2-CH-CH2-O-SA
[V-SA-V"- SA-Vl
I HO—SA-O
I O Y2 CH-CH 2 -O-SA-OH zCH2 O
H-O-SA-O-CH 2 -CH-CH 2 -O-SA HO—SA-O
xvn
[V 1 -SA-V] 3 k c* 2 1 H—O—SA-O—CH 2 -CH-CH 2 -O—SA-O—CH-(—CH 2 -O-SA-OH) 2 O—H Scheme 3 Some higher oligomers of glycerol and succinic acid; the numbers are those of ref. [33] mesogenic units being present as pendent groups demonstrably in full complement upon what was a poly(erythntolfractal glutarate [ O — H ] 2 backbone [34].
13 THE MICROSTRUCTURE OF LINEAR CHAINS The first microstructural issue of linear homopolymer chains that we examine is tacticity, which we illustrate with spectra from two systems from our own work: the poly(alkyl cyanoacrylates) [ - C H 2 - C ( C N ) C O O R - ] , which constitute a vinylidene system the spectra of which are shown in Figure 1.4, and the polyalkene sulphides and sulphones: [—CH 2 —CHR—S—] and [—CH 2 — CHR—SO 2 —], spectra of which are shown in Figure 1.5. We show meso or m dyad structures of two of these polymers in Scheme 4. Note how the two chiral centres of the first polymer appear to be equivalent, but for the second polymer the equivalence is less immediately evident, for the residues contain three bonds
Figure 1.4 NMR spectra of poly(ethyl cyanoacrylate) samples. Part (a) has the main chain methylene proton signals at 400 MHz of samples prepared in acetone with sparteine as initiator (A2) and in THF with cinchonidine as initiator (A5). Part (b) shows the 13C spectrum of the side chain methylene carbons of the samples A2 and A5, with triad and pentad assignments [38] (a) C N H CN I I I —C—C—C— C O H CO I (b) I OEf ; OEt
H CH2-CH3 I I -SO2-CH2-C-SO2-CH2-C-SO2CH2-CH3 H
Scheme 4 Meso structures of poly(ethyl cyanoacrylate) and poly(but-l-ene sulphone). The projections have the backbones in a planar ziz-zag, and show the chain from above and in successive residues a particular atom is in turn in the "up" and the "down" position. Triad, tetrad, pentad and longer sequences may be obtained by the successive inclusion of extra residues and may be recognised by NMR. The stereochemical structure of these longer sequences are described in terms of the m or r relationships of the successive pairs of chiral centres [2,3]. In the case
ppm
ppm
Figure 1.5 13C NMR spectra of the backbone methylene carbons of (a) a tactic poly(but-l-ene sulphide), (b) of the tactic poly(but-l-ene sulphone) made from it by oxidation, and (c) of an atactic polysulphone. The dispersion of shifts of the sulphone polymer is greater because of the gamma-gfaucfie effect of the oxygens. The small peak at 6 = 49.2 ppm is from H — H sequence.
of the first polymer the residues, as they have just two backbone carbons, are sensitive to influences equally from each direction along the chain, and mr and rm heterotactic sequences are identical as far as the signals from carbons at or pendent to the central chiral centre are concerned. At high resolution the influence of the next two chiral centres may be expressed, so we may be able to distinguish the rmrr and mmrr pentads. For the polysulphides and polysulphones the residues have three components, so that the influence upon chemical shifts of one residue that derives from the chiral centres of the two neighbouring residues is diflferent, and depends upon the direction: thus, an mr sequence will not for symmetry reasons have the same shifts as an rm sequence. (The mechanism that generates shift multiplicity depends upon fine differences in bond rotation populations for different chiral sequences that are coupled to the gamma-^auc/ie interactions, as Tonelli describes elsewhere [8]). As in the related olefin oxide and styrene oxide polymers [34,35], the residues of the polysulphide predominantly orientate in only one direction, so that head to head junctions are also encountered, and provide minor features in the spectrum, as we indicate in Figure 1.5. This type of enchainment has been termed positional isomerism, orienticity [3] or regioselectivity, the last term being used below for ring-opening metathesis polymerisation (ROMP) systems. Another consequence of the presence of three distinct groups in each residue of the linear backbone is the possibility of optical activity, a property that independently permits recognition of isotacticity [37]. We first discuss the spectra of poly(ethyl cyanoacrylate), proton spectra being shown in Figure 1.4(a) and the corresponding 13 C spectra in Figure 1.4(b) [38]. We use the classical route, first used by Bovey and Tiers for poly(methylmethacrylate) [2,7], PMMA, for determining the type of tacticity that predominates. They recognised the four-line pattern of an AB quartet in the 60 MHz spectrum of a predominantly isotactic polymer in the signal from the main chain methylene protons within a meso dyad—this was distinctly different from the single line from the methylene protons of a racemic dyad that was found in a polymer produced by a different mechanism (the absence of an effect from the coupling constant deriving from the equivalence of the two protons). For our assignment two polymers were available, poly(ethyl cyanoacrylate)s that had been made in different solvents and with different chiral initiators for the anionic polymerization process (it transpired that the solvent was the important factor). In contrast to the case with PMMA, an AB quartet was not immediately apparent in the proton NMR spectrum, and a pair of clear lines (a and b in Figure 1.4(a)) considered for part of such a system was found to be unsuitable: the splitting between the lines was not —14 Hz (the value of a geminal coupling) nor were there signals nearby at that splitting. Moreover, their relative intensities changed in a simple manner with the value of the tacticity parameter deduced from the 13 C NMR spectrum. They were thus assigned to rrr and rrm fine structure, and these assignments were confirmed by checking their relative
intensities with values predicted with the aid of a single (Bernoullian) tacticity parameter obtained from the side chain methylene carbon spectrum. Discrepancies between the Bernoullian and the experimental intensities were of the order of 2% within both proton and carbon spectra. The direct recognition of an AB quartet in spectra such as those of Figure 1.4(a) was prevented by partial overlap of m dyad signals dispersed by tetrad effects and a coincidence with the remaining r-centred tetrad, as a two-dimensional experiment has subsequently made clear [39]. The main components of the AB structure lie near 2.6 and 2.8 ppm. In the carbon spectrum pentad effects were resolved within the rr-centred triad of the side chain methylene carbons (Figure 1.4(b)). The two peaks of the mr-centred triad may be assigned as indicated in the figure to mrmm and (mrmr + rrmm) sequences, of expected relative intensities of 0.100 and 0.096 respectively of A2; the remaining sequence rrmr, of Bernoullian intensity 0.02, is apparently not resolved in the signal. This set of pentads may be more readily recognised on the basis of more clearly different line intensities in the spectrum of A5. They and the other peaks were assigned, once the chains were recognised as being predominantly isotactic, on the manner in which their intensities varied with the value of P1-, a practice which is widely adopted when samples of different tacticities are available. In the case of polyacrylonitrile [—CH 2 —CH(CN)—], which gives an atactic polymer when the free radical reaction is performed in solution, enhancement of the tacticity to Pf values as high as 0.70-0.87 has been provided by performing a polymerisation when the monomers were constrained, or lined up, within a urea canal complex. This allows the development within the 13 C NMR spectrum of intense peaks from certain heptads [12], the emphasis providing clear indication of the origin of the signals from sequences of high isotactic content. The fine structure of the 13 C NMR signals from the methyl groups of polypropylene displays pentad and partial heptad fine structure, for the assignment of which a number of methods were adopted, depending mainly upon the availability of polymers of known tacticity, as their crystal structures had previously been determined, but also using 13C-labelled model compounds of known stereo sequence content [40]. Highly isotactic polystyrene has been produced using a titanium trichloride-derived catalyst [41]. Once such a material is available the spectra may give an insight into the manner in which the process behaves: a catalyst for isotactic polypropylene sometimes allows errors in stereochemistry, but these are immediately corrected, as the presence of mrrm but not mrmm pentads testifies [2]. Such interesting evidence on the manner in which a catalyst functions helps us to understand the mechanism; we conclude this review with an account of such effects discovered in our studies of ring-opening metathesis polymerisation, or ROMP, which likewise use metal-centred catalysts. The Bernoullian nature of the free radical or ionic propagation in a polymer may be ascertained from the relative intensities of the rr, mr -I- rm, and mm components of the triad fine structure, as in our studies of the side chain
methylene group in poly(ethyl cyanoacrylate)s. Provided that each new chiral centre forms in a manner that depends only upon the type of the previous chiral centre, so that only one statistical parameter is involved for dyad occurrences, the weights of the triads are respectively [2,3] (1 - F1)2,2P1(I - P1) and (P,)2. Using in turn (from left to right) the first two areas, the second two, and then the first and third of each part of Figure 1.4(b), we solve for P1 to obtain 0.63,0.72 and 0.68 for sample A2, values which are hardly significantly different from each other; and for sample A5 we have correspondingly 0.52, 0.60 and 0.56, which are close. A test for Markov behaviour is provided by the relationships involving two parameters [2, 3]: JV/m) = « = (nn)/(2(m)) = (mr)/(2(mm) + (mr)) and P(m/r) = w = (rm)/(2(r)) = (mr)/(2(rr) + (mr)), where P(r/m) is the probability that an r dyad will follow an m dyad. Markov behaviour has u + w < 1.00. For the cyanoacrylate spectra of Figure 1.4(b) the values of u and w are respectively 0.28 and 0.66 for polymer A2 and 0.46 and 0.54 for polymer A5, indicating that both polymerisations are close to Bernoullian. Sample A2, which deviates more from the ideal was made using as initiator sparteine. As this compound is a dinitrogen base, it may enhance the formation of a complex between the oppositely charged initiator and the propagating ends of the chain in a zwitterion. A clear case of Markov behaviour is given below. The statistical index P = 4IS/H2 = (4(mm)(rr)/(mr)2] has been used to characterise the isotactic acrylonitrile polymers prepared within the canal complexes [12]. Two distinct mechanisms were identified from the dependence of this index upon the isotactic content, a much stronger dependence being found for the polymers produced at low temperatures after irradiation than for those produced during irradiation at a moderately low temperature, for which canal coherence might have been upset by the evolution of heat and the irradiation itself. The second aspect of linear polymers from our own field may be considered as a whole, for polysulphones may be obtained by oxidation of polysulphides as well as by the free radical copolymerisation of SO 2 with an olefin. Indeed, this chemical change is beneficial to the spectroscopy, for fine structure develops as a result of oxidation, as may be seen in Figure 1.5, where the shifts, each at 500 MHz, of the methylene carbons of an isotactic polysulphide and the polysulphone prepared from it are displayed in parts (a) and (b) respectively. As discussed elsewhere [2, 5, 8], fine structure may be the consequence of gamma-grawc/ie interactions weighted according to the occupancy of the intervening bond conformational states. In this case the fine structure undoubtedly develops a larger dispersion and becomes more sensitive to the stereochemistry because we have introduced oxygens gamma with respect to each main chain carbon; such oxygens may cause a shift effect as large as — 9.4 ppm, the particular value
depending upon the conformation adopted by the intervening C—S bond [30,42]. Poly(l-olefin sulphone)s have been found to be atactic when made from the monomers by the free radical reaction; when first observed the backbone carbons showed incipient or clear triad fine structure [41,42]. The first carbon of the side chain displays dyad stereochemical sensitivity at low resolution, the upfield half of the signal being assigned to an m dyad when a comparison was made with an isotactic poly(propylene sulphone) made by oxidising an isotactic polysulphide [41]. The poly(but-l-ene sulphone)s prepared by free radical means showed similar spectra of the main chain methine when examined at high field (Figure 1.5(c)), showing clearly mm, mr + rm, and rr triads, as labelled by comparison with the other spectrum, that of the optically active polymer prepared from a polysulphide. The test on the Markov nature finds M = 0.51 (±0.01) and w = 0.480 (±0.005), giving u + w = 0.99 (±0.01), so the free radical polymerisation process was clearly Bernoullian. For the polymer prepared by oxidation of the polysulphide the parameters are w = 0.25 (±0.01) and w = 0.51 (±0.01), giving M + W = 0.76 (±0.02) and indicating the Markov nature of the polymerisation process the polysulphide precursor had experienced. (From the spectrum of the polysulphide itself we were able to obtain only one parameter, P1 = 0.66, a number very close to w/(u + w) = 0.67, as expected.) It may well be that the polysulphide formation was not Bernoullian, for the catalyst used was an optically active zinc-centred species that favoured the R enantiomer of the sulphide, and the monomer itself contained an excess of the S enantiomer [44]. A second feature in the spectrum reflecting the polysulphide formation mechanism is the presence of three minor features near 49.2 ppm in Figure 1.5(b) that we associate with head to head structures. During propagation, the sulphide anion at the end of the chain may occasionally attack the methine carbon site as well as the methylene carbon site in the monomer, and this remains when the polysulphone is prepared. We note that the heterotactic triads signal of Figure 1.5(c) has more than three components, consistent with the mr and the rm heterotactic sequences being distinguishable; as the relative intensities of the four not quite resolved lines for the atactic polymer of Figure 1.5(c) are roughly in the proportion of 1:2:3:2, and the four heterotactic-centred sequences mmrm, mmrr, rrmm and rrmr would be expected to have similar proportions (as Pr = P1n) = 0.5), one of these pentads must be sensitive to an extra chiral centre. Our most recent work in this area has shown that tactic main chains may be obtained in a free radical reaction if the 1-olefin bears a chiral centre of a particular type (K 6r S) at the site next to the olefin group: the carbon NMR spectrum then displays from each atom within or close to the backbone widely spaced pairs of peaks, the relative intensity within each pair being 6:4 or 7:3. This reflects within a residue a preferred relationship of the two chiral centres [45], the one initially present within the olefin and the second created by the addition reaction.
1.4 THE PARTICIPATION OF A CHARGE-TRANSFER COMPLEX IN A FREE RADICAL POLYMERIZATION REACTION A long-standing issue in the formation of alternating copolymers, such as are found when electron-rich and electron-deficient monomers polymerise by free radical means, has been the question of the role of the charge-transfer complex in the polymerisation mechanism. For poly(olefin sulphone) feeds, many experimental techniques have demonstrated that the complex is present, but is the complex incidental or is it the reacting species? One possibility is that each type of radical may react only with the other type of monomer; a second is that the charge-transfer adduct itself is the only reacting species [46]. In Scheme 5 below these two possibilities are shown respectively as the vertical (c + d) and the horizontal (a) propagation reaction paths. The rate-determining step for polymerisation is apparently the reaction of an electron-deficient radical, presumably a sulphonyl radical, with an electron-rich monomer, presumably either an olefin (d) or the olefin part of a charge-transfer complex (a), for substitution to the olefin group enhances the rate. AU the reactions are written as reversible in Scheme 5: there is a wealth of experimental evidence in support of this, for example, the olefins are known to isomerise at temperatures above and below the ceiling temperature for polymer formation, and the ESR spectrum of the radicals present indicates that this may be both C-based and S-based. P-SO2-C-C* SO2
JcSo 2
P-SO/ + C=C - = - P-SO2-C-C-SO* e dC=C
P-SO2-C-C" Scheme 5 The free radical formation of poly(but-2-ene sulphone) through chargetransfer complex reaction (horizontal route) or successive monomer addition (descending route) If the precise alternation in the chain residues is the only criterion, there is no way of distinguishing between the two mechanisms. However, the stereochemistry of the but-2-ene sulphone residues and their relationship to the cis or trans nature of the olefin does provide a guide [43,46]. Broadly speaking, two methyl shifts are encountered: at high temperatures, whichever olefin is used, there is a single shift at « 9 ppm, but at low temperatures, if the trans but not the cis olefin
Figure 1.6 13C NMR spectra at 101 MHz of the methyl groups of s/B three samples of poly(but-2-ene sulphone) recorded in DMSO-J6 at 70 0C. The samples SCH/7, U27 and U23 were prepared at - 95 0C, - 63 0C and - 84 0C respectively, the last from the cis olefin and the first two from the trans olefin. Lowering the temperature has increased the intensity of the signal at 13 ppm from the meso residues obtained from the trans olefin, but the signal from the polymer made from the cis olefin at an intermediate temperature shows a much greater proportion of the racemic residues, with their methyl shift at 9 ppm [46]
is used, there is a new peak at 13ppm; see Figure 1.6 for three examples. The assignment of the order of the methyl carbon shifts to meso or to racemic but-2-ene residues is not straightforward; since a gamma-gauche effect from the oxygen atom of the sulphone group (9.4 ppm) may well be larger than the gamma-gauche effect from a methyl group (6.4 ppm), the shift distinction may be associated with the conformations of the C—S bonds, rather than with that of the C—C bond as we first assumed [42]. We now make the assignment of the meso and racemic structures on the basis of the similarity of the order of the shifts in the polymers to models of known structure. The molecule alpha-2,3-bis(isopropylsulphonyl) butane has the structure shown in Figure 1.7(a), according to X-ray measurements, making it the centrosymmetric meso form [46]. The central unit corresponds exactly to a residue of a poly(but-2-ene sulphone) chain that is flanked by structures corresponding to a little over half the alkane component of the next residue. The carbon shift of the central methyls is at 13.7 ppm, compared with 10.0 ppm for the corresponding shift in the racemic molecule, shift differences that are found in the polymers, too. (The IR spectra show similar correspondences [46]). The fact that at low temperatures the trans olefin converts to polymer with partial retention of the configuration of the two prochiral centres
T/C
Figure 1.7 (a) The model bis(isopropylsulphonyl) butane in the crystal [46], showing its centrosymmetry and meso characteristic of the central portion; (b) plots of meso residue content against temperature of preparation for the series of poly(but-2-ene sulphone)s prepared from cis and trans olefin, curves (i) and (ii) respectively. That there are two distinct curves indicates that the charge-transfer complex is a significant reacting species. The solid symbols record the results from the spectra of Figure 1.6
on the olefin-CT complex and that the cis olefin converts similarly suggests that the reaction does proceed along path a of Scheme 5 at these low temperatures, when large proportions of the charge-transfer complex are present. At the higher temperatures the polymer and the monomer structures are not related, both yielding mainly racemic residues, consistent with alkyl radicals being present long enough during the polymerisation for radical inversions to eliminate the memory of the initial structure. Chain microstructure therefore indicates that the complex is a reacting species at low temperatures. We cannot tell whether the complex exclusively reacts, and the sulphonyl radical partly dissociates (path b), or whether paths a and c are alternatives, a being becoming favoured as the temperature is lowered, to some extent reflecting the greater stability of the charge-transfer complex. The rise in meso content when cis olefin is the precursor probably indicates that path c is used even at low temperatures, and that then the radical intermediate favours less a mode of reaction that yields the racemic type of product.
1.5 THE POLYMERISATION OF DIENES The manner in which dienes become entrained within polymer chains depends upon a number of factors, such as the type of mechanism (free radical, ionic or coordination), the nature of the diene itself, and whether other monomers are involved. If one double bond reacts, a chiral centre is formed and the polymers may be tactic, if 1,4-addition (or 4,1-addition) takes place the main chain incorporates a double bond whose cis or trans nature may be important in determining properties such as the glass transition temperature, and the reaction of a second double bond can cause crosslinks. The case of polychloroprene has been described by Ebdon [47], where proton shifts are sufficient to detect head to tail (2.35 ppm), head to head (2.5 ppm) and tail to tail (2.2 ppm) enchainments of this unsymmetrical monomer [47]. For poly(butadiene)s, sequence triads involving three different types of residue—cis and trans 1,4-residues within the main chain and 1,2-residues involving pendent vinyl groups—may be distinguished even with a 270 MHz spectrometer in the region of the spectrum between 127 and 133 ppm, where are found the resonances of the 1,4-residues (see Table 1.1 and Figure 1.8). The assignments were obtained using a number of polymers of distinctly different but recognisable microstructure. When the spectrum is obtained under conditions that avoid NOE enhancement of signal intensity, and long delays between pulses reduce systematic errors in signal proportions, from this region and that of the pendent vinyl groups (at 114 and 143 ppm) compositions accurate to better than 1% may be claimed [25]. In this study of polybutadiene rubbers, when three different methods were compared, it was found that the microstructures as determined by the Raman and 13 C NMR methods
Table 1.1 Triad sequences within the main chain olefinic region of the carbon-13 NMR spectrum of poly(butadiene)s [25]. Reproduced from [25] with kind permission from Elsevier Science Ltd., The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidiington OX5 IGB, UK Carbon Atom Peak No. Triad assignment Shift (ppm) -C=C*I vtv 13L8 2 ctv, ttv 131.4 3 we 130.7 4 ctv, ttv 130.6 5 ccv, tcv 130.2 6 ctc,ctt 130.2 7 vcc, vet 130.1 8 ttc, ttt 130.1 —*C=C— 9 ctv, ttv 129.9 10 ccc, tec 129.7 11 cct, tct 129.5 12 ctv, ttv 129.3 13 vtc 128.5 14 vtt 128.4 15 vtc 128.2 16 vcc 128.1 17 vet 127.9 18 vcv 127.8 *Note: v = vinyl, c =* cis, t = trans.
were in good agreement but that the IR method was much less consistent [25], as peaks were not very distinct and extinction coefficients were too variable. We illustrate the reactions of dienes by our studies on furans as monomers in free radical copolymerisations with acrylonitrile (AN), work undertaken to develop the polymer chemistry of materials that may be obtained from renewable resources. We have found that a variety of structures may be entrained within a polyacrylonitrile chain; to some extent their proportions depend upon the presence and the nature of substituents at the position alpha to the furan ring [48-50]. Only furan, the least aromatic of the heterocycles, seems to behave in this way. The five-membered furan ring remains intact. The differentiation of structures of types I and II was performed on the basis of the shifts of model compounds obtained by reacting furan and methylfuran with the 2-cyanopropyl radicals from decomposing 2,2'-azobis(isobutyronitrile), AIBN. The carbon shifts of the polymer residues were consistent with attack at the alpha or C 2 position of furan and at the C 5 position of methylfuran by the acrylonitrile radical. The furan radical that forms then propagates in the manner of a diene either through the more remote alpha position or through the adjacent beta position. A minor proportion of I residues from methylfuran in which the polymer AN radical had attached to the C 2 were also detected from the appearance of minor shifts at 130 ppm (see Figure 1.9) from the beta carbons,
Figure 1.8 13 C NMR spectrum of an anionically prepared polybutadiene at 25 0 C in CDCl 3 at 60 MHz. The labels correspond to the peak numbers and triad sequences of Table 1.1. In this study [25] extreme care was taken in obtaining quantitative information: avoidance of the nuclear overhauser enhancement was achieved by decoupling only during the signal acquisition; pulse angle 90°, 40000 scans, 33 s pulse delay. Reproduced from [25] with kind permission from Elsevier Science Ltd., The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington OX5 IGB, UK shifts that reflect the different arrangement in this residue of the methyl and nearest nitrile groups. The appearance at this place of the olefinic shifts is readily rationalised in terms of a beta effect of 3.7 ppm and a gamma effect from the nitrile group of —5.5 ppm. Other peaks were found in both proton and 13C spectra in the region below the shifts from the acrylonitrile residues, and other possible structures were sought,
i
H
in
iv
v
vi
Scheme 6 The structures of five residues derived from furan in acrylonitrile (AN) copoiymers, and the methylfuran radical
Figure 1.9 13C NMR spectra of the low field region of (a) a dimethylfuran copolymer, (b) a methylfuran copolymer, and (c) a furan copolymer. Assignments of the nitrile carbon of the AN residues, of the olefinic carbons of the furan residues and of the bridgehead and other carbons next to an oxygen are indicated but a certain proof of a third type of structure was more elusive. The characteristic feature was a proton shift at « 3.9 ppm [49], a position appropriate to a proton on an ether carbon, and olefinic protons were thought to be lacking. We present a relevant set of reactions in Scheme 7. It was eventually recognised [49] that the addition of an excess of the furan monomer, which promoted II-AN-furan sequences, had the effect of reducing the proportion of the unknown furan residue, presumably by preventing the participation of the II structures in a second reaction (d) to give a structure of type III. Once ~ II-AN-AN' radicals were reduced in proportion by this means, the signals from the II structures became clearly enhanced in the spectrum, as route (a) was then taken. This
Scheme 7 Possible reactions of a II structure in a second manner during the acrylonitrile copolymerisation [49] revealed the origin of the previously obscure third structure. A proof of the entrainment of AN-furan Diels-Alder products was made by observation of the shifts of the residues formed by a direct copolymerisation involving an endo adduct of furan and a mixture of endo and exo adducts: the carbon and the proton spectra together indicated that both adducts can become entrained within an acrylonitrile chain [48] to yield a structure of type IV, with carbon shifts at 80ppm from the bridgehead sites and corresponding proton shifts at about 4.7 ppm. A careful inspection of the region near 130 ppm in the spectrum of each polymer (Figure 1.9) reveals that each carbon of the I residues has two shifts, a feature that we attributed to the influence of the chirality of the nearest —CHCN— chiral centre. No feature that we could associate with the cis or trans junctions to the ring were identified, although for the I residues, if not the II residues, the structural variation seemed possible. Inspection of the spectra at a higher field strength found a further set of peaks whose intensities increased as the furan content rose from « 5 to 25% of the residues. This was attributed to a small sequence effect. In an effort to clarify the sequence fine structure, both of the various furan residues and of the acrylonitrile residue signals un-field, we added Lewis acids in the hope of causing alternation of the residues by enhancing the electron deficiency of the acrylonitrile radical through a coordination to the nitrile group. When the polymerisation was performed in the presence of a mild Lewis acid such
as ZnCl2, it was found instead that, although the yields were enhanced by an order of magnitude, the furan proportion was increased only a little, but the pattern of the predominant II structures became modified considerably [50]. For the 2-methylfuran systems, the shift of the 5-proton was diminished relative to the shifts of the other furan protons. The search for their new position in the spectrum, to provide structural evidence for the effect of the Lewis acid upon the reaction mode, was performed with deuterium NMR spectroscopy, the methylfuran monomer having been deuterated at the single alpha position. In reactions leaving a furan ring from radicals of structure V at the end of chains, the deuteriums were found to have transferred from the furan radical to the Lewis acid-activated monomer (creating D—CH 2 —CHCN ~ , shift at 1.5 ppm) and to acrylonitrile radicals (creating ~CH 2 —CHDCN, 2.2 ppm). This latter group was also identified at 14.3 ppm in the 13 C NMR spectrum, where it was particularly prominent if an independent source of hydrogen atoms, in the form of a chain-transfer agent, had been added [48]. Despite the transfer reaction and the disproportionation promoted by the Lewis acids, processes which would be expected to lower molecular weights, yields of the free radical reaction were greatly enhanced and gels were produced, presumably through a crosslinking second reaction of II residues, and the proton NMR signals consequently became broader [50]. Isotopic enhancement may be also illustrated by Bevington et al.'s exploration of the use of the*3C-enriched free radical initiators l,l'-azobis(phenylethane) and AIBN in preparing butadiene polymers [51] and the use of dimethyl 2,2'azobis(isobutyrate) to initiate the polymerisations of styrene, acrylonitrile, methyl methacrylate and methyl acrylate [52]. The signals from the ends are thus rendered more intense, and become observable in a standard 13 C NMR spectrum, where they display information on the manner in which the initiator radicals have attacked the first monomer to become incorporated at the start of the polymer chain: one can thus compare initial and mean tacticities. In a further use of isotope enrichment, Moad and Willing found that selective 13 C enrichment of one monomer together with carbon-13-proton correlation NMR spectroscopy allowed the separation of tacticity and sequence effects; they used this approach for studying copolymers of butyl methacrylate with methyl methacrylate [53].
1.6 RING-OPENING-METATHESIS POLYMERISATIONS Polymers formed by the ring-opening metathesis polymerisation (ROMP) reaction [54] exhibit a wide variety of microstructures which may be evaluated by specctroscopic techniques. The first ROMP polymers were analysed by IR spectroscopy [55], but that can only determine the absolute stereochemistry of
the double bonds in the polmer, and provides no information on the sequences in which such microstructural variations might occur. This limitation is largely overcome by 13 C NMR spectroscopy, where sensitivity to change in substitution and stereochemistry up to six carbon atoms remote from the particular carbon under observation is regularly seen [54], In the remaining part of this article we deal almost exclusively with polymers formed from the bicyclic olefins norbornene, norbornadiene and their derivatives, but will also discuss some work with oxygen-containing analogues, thus providing a comprehensive range of different microstructural types. These monomers have a substantial ring strain, so they are good candidates for ROMP.
P * polymer chain
Scheme 8 The ROMP reaction of Scheme 8 is catalysed by metallacarbenes [54] that have been formed from a wide variety of transition metal salts, often but not exclusively in the presence of an organometallic co-catalyst in systems similar to the industrially important Ziegler-Natta catalysts. In addition, there are now many examples of metathesis of both cyclic and acyclic olefins using well-defined metal carbene complexes [56]. In the former systems, which are considered here, the metallacarbene catalyst is formed from the various catalyst components and is very active, the concentration of active sites being extremely low but each site having a very high turnover number [57]. As a result, observation of the working catalyst by any spectroscopic or other means is not possible. We view the polymers, with their different microstructural features, as a "tape recording" of events at the catalyst site which may be "read" through the medium of 1 3 C NMR spectroscopy. For highly strained monomers these events are the primary ones up to high conversion. One may, by careful choice of monomer, study the potential of different catalysts to behave in a stereoselective or regioselective manner. Thus, with a symmetrical monomer such as norbornene [58], norbornadiene [59] or their 5,6 [60] or 7-substituted derivatives [61,62] we have obtained polymers with a variety of cis main chain double bond contents and distributions. In a number of the 7-substituted examples, fine structure on certain 13 C NMR resonances is observed which is attributable to tacticity effects. Conversely, one may use the unsymmetrical monomers such as 1-substituted derivatives [63] and delineate the propensity of the different catalysts to regioselectivity, which manifests itself as head-tail bias in the polymer.
In the case of these substituted derivatives, the polymers formed with most catalyst systems exhibit fine structure in the spectra due to each of the possible microstructural variations, leading to very complex spectra. We have made very extensive use of chain transfer to acyclic olefin to obtain lower molecular weights, and consequent line narrowing in the spectra of the polymers, to optimise resolution. Also, certain of the catalysts at our disposal may behave in a very stereospecific and regiospecific manner, allowing one to pinpoint certain lines in more complex spectra. These techniques, combined with the excellent resolving power and sensitivity of modern high field NMR instruments, have allowed complete and unambiguous assignment of most spectra.
1.6.1 STEREOSELECTIVITYINROMP There are two basic types of stereoselectivity observed in the ROMP of cyclic olefins, both of which may be observed in the 13 C NMR spectra of the polymers. The double bonds which form part of the main chain may be either cis or trans, and in the case of the prochiral monomers norbornene, norbornadiene, their symmetrically substituted derivatives and their chiral unsymmetrically substituted derivatives the residues may be enchained in such a way as to yield tactic or, more commonly, atactic polymers [54]. A representation of atactic poly(norbornene) is shown in Scheme 9, where cis and trans double bonds are associated with r or m dyad units respectively.
Scheme 9 Thus polymers with a given cis double bond content may be prepared with an appropriate catalyst, as is shown in Table 1.2. Resonances from the various olefinic and cyclopentane ring carbon atoms are observed and fine structure due to the effect of two or three neighbouring double bonds is resolved, Figure 1.10. One of the earliest observations to be made from these spectra was that the relative line intensities of the various cc, ct, tt and tc (etc.) resonances indicated that the distribution of cis and trans double bonds was non-random, and that there was an increasing tendency towards a blocky cis distribution as the cis double bond content of the polymer increased [58]. An explanation was suggested, based upon chain propagation involving different metallacarbenes which had been distinguished in terms of the stereochemistry of the last-formed double
Table 1.2
Fraction of cis double bonds in ring-opened polymers of norbornene, norbornadiene and derivatives obtained with different catalysts Catalyst
Monomer
RuCl3
MoCl 5 /Bu 4 Sn
OsCl3
WCl6/Me4Sn
ReCl5
Ref.
0.05
-
0.50
0.55
1.00
[54]
0.00
-
0.15
0.55
0.95
[61]
0.10
-
-
0.55
0.95
[60]
0.37
0.90
0.51
0.82
[59]
0.20
0.97
0.42
1.00
-
0.36
0.73
1.00
[66]
0.10
-
0.39
-
1.00
[66]
0.00
0.31
0.10
0.75
1.00
[63]
0.05
0.11
0.30
0.70
1.00
[65]
- [62]
bonds. In essence this theory emphasised the importance of steric effects at the catalyst site. Blocks of cis double bonds are obtained by propagation through a species P c (see Scheme 10) where the last-formed double bond is cis and where the next monomer unit reacts with the metallacarbene while the previously
Figure 1.10 * 3C NMR spectrum of poly(norbornene) with %60% cis, randomly distributed, main chain bonds
Scheme 10 formed cis double bond is still in the coordination sphere of the metal. The steric constraint thus imposed aligns the incoming monomer unit in a cis orientation, leading to the formation of another cis double bond. The kinetically distinct Pt species is believed to be too bulky sterically to be a chain carrier at all, and it relaxes to a species P in which the last-formed double bond has left the coordination sphere of the metal; the monomer has then the opportunity to react in either a cis or a trans orientation, with the trans orientation preferred on steric grounds. This phenomenon is also observed in the case of the stereospecific metathesis of acyclic olefins [68], where, in the pre-equilibrium stage of the reaction, cis products are often formed from cis substrates and trans from trans. Inspection of Table 1.2 shows that the cis content of polymers formed from bidentate chelating olefins is significantly higher than that observed with the mono-olefin analogue. The highly stereospecific and rather unreactive RuCl3 catalyst exhibits extreme behaviour, as it is highly trans-directing with norbornene, and incidentally with many other mono-olefin derivatives, but highly cis directing when using endodicyclopentadiene as monomer [66]. It is significant that the catalytically active residual solution from RuCl3/endo-dicyclopentadiene polymerisation also produces high cis polymers with norbornene derivatives, and that exo-dicyclopentadiene gives the "normal" high trans polymer. The link between steric crowding of the catalyst site and cis stereospecificity is therefore well established, both by ourselves [66] and by others [69].
1.6.2 DISTRIBUTION OF trans DOUBLE BONDS IN HIGH cis POLY(NORBORNENE) The NMR spectra of both the cyclopentane ring and the olefinic carbon atoms in poly(norbornene) are sensitive to the stereochemistry of the neighbouring double bonds and, as seen above, this leads to cc/ct; tt/tc doublets for the cyclopentane ring carbon atoms. There is, however, the possibility of quartet fine structure for both cis and trans olefinic carbon resonances, owing to the inequivalence of the carbon atoms in a given double bond [64], as in Scheme 11. CH=CH
m t/c
uc * crt
Cft
c/c
Scheme 11 In the spectrum of a poly(norbornene) of intermediate cis content, Figure 1.10, this fine structure is well resolved for the cis resonance, but overlapp of the etc and the ttt components occurs in the trans resonance. In high cis polymer two different types of non-random trans double bond distribution have been observed. Figure 1.11 shows the spectra of two polymers, one prepared using ReCl5, Figure 1.1 l(a), and the other using OsCl3, Figure 1.1 l(b) in the presence of benzoquinone, another chelating ligand which imposes a high a s directive effect [7O]. In these high cis polymers one would expect, statistically, that trans double bonds would almost always be flanked by cis double bonds, leading to high tc/tt ratios for the cyclopentane ring carbon atoms and a strong etc signal for the olefinic trans resonance. In fact, inspection of Figure l.ll(a) shows that the reverse is the case for the ReCl5-catalysed polymer; here the various ct and tt lines are of approximately equal intensity, and the centre component of the trans olefinic resonance which arises from isolated trans, etc, or blocks of trans, ttt, has become only a shoulder on the ttc line. This means that trans double bonds tend to occur in pairs in these predominantly cis chains. Mechanistically, this can be seen as a chain error repair process, where the aberrant formation of the first trans double bond is corrected by the formation of a second before resumption of cis double bond formation. An analogous phenomenon has been observed in the largely isotactic polymerisation of certain alpha-olefins [2], where 13 C NMR spectroscopy has shown that the small proportions of syndiotactic (r) junctions that occur are found in pairs, as evidenced by the relatively intense rmmr and mmrr pentad signals. Here the catalyst site, which normally selects the same prochiral face of the monomer in each cycle, occasionally reacts at the other face, leading to an aberrant r junction. Choice of the original prochiral face in the next
catalytic cycle results in the continuous formation of isotactic polymer: this mechanism is marked by the presence of pairs of syndiotactic (r) junctions. Alternatively the catalyst, having chosen a different prochiral face, continues to do so. The result is the formation of a polymer containing isotactic blocks joined by single syndiotactic (r) junctions, i.e. the initial error is propagated, and is visible in the 13 C NMR spectrum as the occurrence of mrmm and mmrm pentads. Here again an analogous situation exists in some ROMP's of norbornene and derivatives, and is seen in the polymerisation of norbornene using the benzoquinonemodified OsCl3 catalyst, Figure 1.1 l(b). In this case, and in contrast to the ReCl5 polymer of Figure 1.1 l(a), the various tt lines are three to four times as intense as the tc lines, with a concomitant increase in the intensity of what must be the ttt component over the ttc and ctt lines in the olefinic trans resonance. This indicates that the small percentage of trans double bonds occur in tn blocks (n > 2). The same phenomenon is observed in polymers formed from 1-methylnorbornene [63], Figure 1.12. At the cis junction in these high cis polymers, monomer addition occurs in a head-tail manner (see below) but the small proportion of trans junctions shows no bias. However, it may be clearly seen that in the polymer formed using the WCl 6 /Me 4 Sn catalyst, Figure 1.12(a), trans double bonds tend to occur in pairs, as evidenced by the low intensity ttt/ctc signals, whereas in the polymers formed from the OsCl3 catalyst, Figure 1.12(b), there is a tendency to form blocks. If there is propagation through metallacarbenes of octahedral symmetry with a vacant alternating ligand position such as described above, these species may be chiral, with the formation of tactic polymer. Furthermore, cis double bond formation will be associated with syndiotactic junctions and trans double bonds with isotactic junctions, as in Scheme 12. If, however, the catalyst site is achiral, or
Scheme 12 chiral but undergoing racemisation faster that propagation, then atactic polymer will result, and r or m dyads may be associated with either cis or trans double bond [67]. Initially (see below) with poly(norbornene) no fine structure was observed, which could be attributed to this tacticity effect, but it was realised that polymerisation using one enantiomeric form of a chiral norbornene derivative (Scheme 13) would translate the tacticity effect into a bias toward head-head (HH) and tail-tail (TT) addition for syndiotactic polymers, and head-tail (HT) addition for isotactic polymers [65].
fa)
ppm
(b)
ppm Figure 1.11 13C NMR spectra of high cis poly(norbornene): (a) 90% cis prepared using ReCl5 catalyst, and (b) 93% cis prepared using a modified OsCl3 catalyst
ROMP
Scheme 13
(a)
(b) 13
Figure 1.12 Olefinic region of the C NMR spectrum of poly(l-methylnorboraene) formed with (a) the WCi 6 /Me 4 Sn catalyst and (b) the OsCl 3 catalyst: (a) Reproduced by permission of Huthig & Wepf Verlag from [63]
This analysis was made possible because the chemical shifts of the various olefinic carbon double bonds in these unsymmetrically substituted norbornene derivatives are very sensitive to whether they are in an HH, TT or HT/TH unit, as can be seen for the case of poly(l-methylnorbornene) [63] in Figure 1.12. It was therefore possible to examine a range of metathesis catalysts for their ability to produce tactic polymers. In fact, a range of tacticities was observed, with extremes in behaviour being represented by the ReCl5 catalyst, which produced an all-ds syndiotactic polymer [65] and the W(mesityl) (CO)3 catalyst, which produced a high trans isotactic polymer [71].
1.6.3 REGIOSELECTIVITY IN R O M P The above method of tacticity determination depends upon there being no regioselectivity, i.e. no bias towards HT or HH/TT addition in the polymerisation of the racemate, and in fact this is the case with 5-substituted norbornene derivatives. Placement of a methyl substituent on the double bond results in complete regioselectivity [72], but much more interesting is the case where an alkyl group is in the bridgehead position, as in poly(l-alkylnorbornene) [63, 73]. These monomers exhibit a strong catalyst- and substitutent-dependent selectivity, which again may be observed in the 13 C NMR spectra of the polymer, Figure 1.13. For example, high trans polymer may be prepared using either RuCl3 or OsCl3 as catalyst, but whereas the RuCl3 catalyst is non-regioselective the OsCl3 catalyst exhibits a strong bias towards the HT addition of monomer (Figure 1.12(a)). This effect may be explained in terms of different polarities of the respective [ M t ] - = C + C ^ pi-bonds as they engage the monomer double bond, Scheme 8, in a [2 + 2] cycloaddition reaction which is the initial step of the ROMP reaction [74,75]. As expected, steric effects are also important, and the more bulky ethyl substituent induces a HT bias in the polymer formed using the RuCl3 catalyst [73] and enhances the HT bias in the OsCl3 case [70][73], Figure 1.13(b). In this context a particularly interesting and unique example of the alternating copolymerisation of enantiomers was demonstrated in the polymerisation of 1methylnorbornene with the ReCl5 catalyst [63,75]. The analysis relied on the fact that the hydrogenated forms of these polymers (but see more recent work, p. 52), unlike their unsaturated precursors, exhibited fine structure due to the presence of ring dyad units of different tacticities. This catalyst gave a poly(l-methylnorbornene) which on 13 C NMR analysis, Figure 1.14, was shown to be all-cis and all HT, in contrast to the OsCl3 catalyst, which produced an all-trans and all HT polymer, Figure 1.13. Both polymers were hydrogenated, and it was found that whereas in the OsCl 3 case one line exhibited doublet fine structure, which must be due to the m/r effects, the ReCl5 polymer gave only the down-field line, indicating that the polymer was tactic. The
Figure 1.13 Olefinic region from the 13C NMR spectrum of all-trans polymer formed from various 1-alkylnorbornenes with different catalyst systems, (a) Reproduced by permission of the Society of Chemical Industry, London, from Br. Polym. J., 1984,16,2; (b) Reproduced by permission of the Society of Chemical Industry, London, from [73]
ppm 13
Figure 1.14 Olefinic region of the C NMR spectrum of poly(l-methylnorbornene) formed using a ReCl5 catalyst; the polymer is all HT all-cis and syndiotactic (compare Figure 1.12 (a) andd (b)). Reproduced by permission of the Society of Chemical Industry, London, from Br. Polym. J., 1984,16, 2
fact that it was syndiotactic was shown by using the OsCl3 catalyst to polymerise optically resolved monomer, which must result in an isotactic all-trans polymer. The 13 C NMR spectrum of the hydrogenated product gave only the up-field line of the original m/r pair, thereby proving the syndiotactic nature of the poly(lmethylnorbornene) prepared using the ReCl5 catalyst. Such a polymer can only form at a catalyst site which alternates in chirality in each catalytic cycle, and thus is required to choose alternate enantiomeric forms of the monomer in successive catalytic cycles. An alternating copolymer of enantiomers was thereby formed. It was therefore highly significant that, in this context, we were unable to form ring-opened polymer from optically resolved monomers with the ReCl5 catalyst. Here again we may draw parallels with Ziegler-Natta polymerisations, Scheme 14. In the syndiotactic polymerisation of propylene [76] the catalyst is
Scheme 14
selecting a different prochiral face of a monomer (which exists in only one molecular form). In the case of the 1-methylnorbornene monomer, Scheme 15, reaction is restricted to one face (exo) of the molecule [61], but two chiral forms are available. In each case the polymer is H-T biased, and the catalyst site alternates in chirality in each catalytic cycle.
Scheme 15
Scheme 16
13
C NMR studies of the ROMP of certain 7-substituted norbornadiene derivatives provided a remarkable example of a substituent-dependent regioselectivity, Scheme 16. 7-methylnorbornadiene [62] and 7-f-butoxynorbornadiene [77] were polymerised using a range of catalysts; whereas the 7-Me derivative behaved in the expected manner with almost exclusive attack at the anti face of the molecule (13C NMR spectra of the polymers are discussed below), catalyst attack occurred with almost equal facility at both syn and anti faces in the 7-r-butoxy derivative. In this reaction it is envisaged that the lone pair of electrons on the 7-oxy substituent interacts with the electrons of the syn double bond, and the normal [2 + 2] cycloaddition, which occurs on anti attack, becomes a facile pseudo [3 + 2] cycloaddition, overcoming the apparent steric crowding at the syn face [62]. 1.6.4 DIRECT OBSERVATION O F TACTICITY 13
C NMR spectra of polymers formed when there is unsymmetric substitution in the norbornene monomer, as shown above, have been very useful in demonstrating the regioselectivity of various catalyst systems. In addition, these substituents are responsible for a decrease in the conformational mobility of the polymer chain, and consequently fine structure which may be due to tacticity is resolved in certain cases. The situation is complicated, however, by the possibility that such splittings may be due to longer range HT effects when HT, HH and TT sequences are present in the polymer chain. Positioning the substituent at C 7 retains the chain stiffening effect without splittings due to a regio effect; the observed fine structure may then be attributed to tacticity effects, especially in high cis or high trans polymers where remote c and t effects do not interfere. These 7-substituted derivatives are also important because much of the above mechanistic interpretation depends upon the assumption that attack on the norbornene molecule occurs at the exo face. The result of ring-opening polymerisation of mixtures of syn- and anft'-7-methylnorbornene [61] shows that this assumption is valid. Thus, only poly(«nr/-7-methylnorbornene) was obtained from the polymerisation of syn/anti mixtures, although a small proportion of syn isomer was incorporated in some cases. With particularly active catalysts the syn isomer could be homopolymerised. More recently, and in relation to the regioselectivity studies discussed above, 7-methylnorbornadiene was prepared and polymerised [62]. The importance of these polymers (for NMR analysis) lies in the excellent resolution of the 13 C NMR spectra which may be achieved and the fact that ring tacticity may be observed directly in addition to cis/trans ratios and distribution. For example, the spectrum of the high trans polymer of anft'-7-methylnorbornene, Figure 1.15(b), which is atactic, showing sensitivity to m/r dyads, may be compared with its tactic high cis analogue, Figure 1.15(a). The syndiotactic nature of this latter polymer is inferred from the known behaviour of the ReCl5 catalyst discussed earlier. Other catalyst systems produce a variety of microstruc-
(a)
ppm
(b)
ppm
Figure 1.15 * 3C NMR spectra of poly(anft'-7-methylnorbornene): (a) syndiotactic all-cis polymer prepared using the ReCl5 catalyst; (b) atactic all-trans polymer prepared using the RuCl5 catalyst. Reproduced by kind permission of Elsevier Science Publishers from [61]
(a)
ppm
(b)
ppm 13
Figure 1.16 C NMR spectra of poly(anfi-7-methylnorbornene): (a) an intermediate cis-tactic polymer prepared using the W(mesit) (CO) 3 /EtAlCI 2 catalyst system, and (b) an atactic polymer of similar cis content prepared using the WCl 6 /Bu 4 Sn catalyst system. Reproduced by kind permission of Elsevier Science Publishers from [61]
ture types, and it is interesting that one can subtly change the behaviour of, for example, a W-based catalyst by changing the oxidation state and ligation. The W(mesityl) (CO)3 complex and the WVI hexachloride catalyst both produce polymers of intermediate and similar cis double bond content, Figure 1.16(a) and (b) respectively, but in the former case cis double bonds are associated solely with r dyads and trans with m, whereas in the latter case cis or trans double bonds may be associated with m or r dyads [61]. In keeping with the general principle that polymerisation of monomers that have a pair of double bonds capable of chelation at the catalyst site leads to the formation of high cis polymer [66], polymers formed from 7-methylnorbornadiene were generally high cis. Resolution of the various microstructural features is also observed in the* 3 C spectra of these polymers, but paradoxically it is in the C 7 , tt line, Figure 1.17 (which shows no fine structure in the 7methylnorbornene case), which is clearly resolved here; exactly the opposite situation holds for the C7, cc line. One can therefore estimate cis content, blockiness and tacticity of the various double bond dyads from this resonance alone, which may be checked for consistency by reference to the fine structure of other resonances in the spectrum.
Figure 1.17 The C 7 resonance in the 13C NMR spectrum of poly(7-methylnorbornadiene) prepared using the WCl6/Me4Sn catalyst system. Reproduced by permission of Huthig & Wepf Verlag from [62]
(a)
ppm
Figure 1.18 125 MHz 13C NMR spectrum of (a) poly(l-methylnorbornene), all cis, all HT, atactic, prepared using a tungsten carbene complex, (b) the same polymer prepared using the ReCl5 catalyst
An important consequence of the foregoing discussion is that it is impossible to predict which resonance will be split by any of the possible microstructural features, and one must therefore be careful not to assume that a polymer is, for example, tactic simply because no fine structure is resolved. Also, spectra of polymers taken on modern high field instruments (125 MHz for 13C) may show up fine structure not resolved on lower field instruments. A most apposite example of this was observed recently in the * 3 C NMR spectroscopy of polymers formed from 1-methylnorbornene using a tungsten alkylidene complex [78]. A spectrum was taken initially at 62.5 MHz and fine structure was not observed. The polymer was high cis, all HT, assumed to be syndiotactic and thought initially to be another example of the alternating copolymerisation of enantiomers described in detail above. However, on obtaining the spectrum at high field (125 MHz, Figure 1.18(a), each line exhibited considerable fine structure, showing that the polymer was in fact only partially syndiotactic [79]. In contrast, it was gratifying to observe that the alternating copolymer of enantiomers formed from this monomer using the ReCl2 catalyst, Figure 1.14, when re-examined at 125 MHz), Figure 1.18(b), had a spectrum almost devoid of fine structure, thereby demonstrating its tactic nature and allowing the assignment of some of the lines in the more complex spectrum of the atactic polymer.
1.7 REFERENCES [1] F.A. Bovey, high resolution carbon-13 studies of polymer structures, in K J . Ivin (Ed.), Structural Studies of Macromolecules by Spectroscopic Methods, John Wiley & Sons, London, 1976. [2] F.A. Bovey, Chain Structure and Conformation of Macromolecules, Academic Press, London, 1982. [3] J.L. Koenig, Chemical Microstructure of Polymer Chains, John Wiley & Sons, Chichester, 1980. [4] J.L. Koenig, Spectroscopy of Polymers, ACS Professional Reference Book, American Chemical Society, Washington, 1992. [5] A.E. Tonelli, NMR Spectroscopy and Polymer Microstructure, VCH Publishers, Berlin, 1989. [6] A.H. Fawcett, Synthetic macromolecules, p. 333 in G. Webb (Ed.), Special Periodical Report on Nuclear Magnetic Resonance, The Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, 1993. [7] F.A. Bovey and J. Tiers, J. Polym. Sci., 1960, 44,173. [8] A.E. Tonelli, Chapter 2, p. 55, in this book. [9] F. Heatley and A. Zambelli, Macromolecules, 1969,2,618. [10] A. Zambelli and A. Segre, J. Polym. ScL, B, 1968, 6,473. [11] N. Ishihara, T. Seimiya, M. Kuramoto and M. Uoi, Macromolecules, 1986,19,2464. [12] M. Minagawa, H. Yamada, K. Yamaguchi and F. Yoshi, Macromolecules, 1992,25, 503. [13] A.M. Aerdts, J.W. de Haan and A.L. German, Macromolecules, 1993, 26, 1965. [14] A.H. Fawcett and W. Ddamda, MakromoL Chem., 1982,183, 2799.
[15] J.K. Becconsall, P.A. Curnuck and M.C Mclvor, Appl. Spectrosc, 1971,4, 307. [16] D.T. Pegg, D.M. Doddrell and M.R. Bendall, J. Chem. Phys., 1982,77, 2745. [17] R.E. Emst, G. Bodenhausen and A. Waokaun, Principles of Nuclear Magnetic Resonance, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1987. [18] H. Friebolin, Basic One- and Two-Dimensional NMR Spectroscopy, VCH, New York
and Weinheim, 1991. [19] F.C. Schilling, F. A. Bovey, M. D. Bruch and S. A. Kozlowski, Macromolecules, 1985, 18,1418. [20] P.A. Mirau and F.A. Bovey, Macromolecules, 1986,19, 210. [21] JJ. Kotyk, P.A. Berger and E.E. Remsen, Macromolecules, 1990, 23, 5167. [22] G.R. Quinting and R. Cai, Macromolecules, 1994,27,6301. [23] A.G. Ferrige and J.C. Lindon, J. Magn. Reson,, 1978, 31, 337. [24] A.H. Fawcett, S. Fee and L.C. Waring, Polymer, 1983,4,1571. [25] J.A. Frankland, H.G.M. Edwards, A.F. Johnston, LR. Lewis and S. Poshyachinda, Specirochim. Ada, Part A, 1991,47A, 1511.
[26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] [37] [38] [39] [40] [41] [42] [43] [44] [45] [46] [47]
D.M. Grant and E.G. Paul, J. Am. Chem. Soc,, 1964,86, 2984. J.C. Randal, J. Polym. ScL, Polym. Phys. Ed., 1973,11, 275. J.C. Randal (Ed.), NMR and Macromolecules, ACS Symp. Ser., No. 247,1984, 256. J.C. Randal, CJ. Ruff and M. Keltermans, Reel Trav. Chim. Pays-Bos, 1991,110,543. A.H. Fawcett, KJ. Ivin and C. Stewart, Org. Magn. Reson., 1978, 11, 360, and references cited therein. A. Kaji, Y. Akitomo and M. Murano, J. Polym. Set, Part A: Polym. Chem., 1991,29, 1987. Q. Zhu, F. Horii and R. Kitamaru, J. Polym. ScL, Part A: Polym. Chem., 1990, 28, 2741. A.H. Fawcett, M. Hania, K.-W. Lo and A. Patty, J. Polym. ScL, Part A: Polym. Chem., 1994,32, 815. A.H. Fawcett and M. Hania, unpublished results. F. Heatley, Y.Z. Luo, J.F. Ding, R.H. Mobbs and C. Booth, Macromolecules, 1989, 21, 2713. F. Heatley, G.E. Yu, M.D. Draper and C. Booth, Eur. Polym. J., 1991, 27,471. F. Ciardelli, O. Pierone and A. Fissi, Chapter 14, p. 347 of this book. A.H. Fawcett, J. Guthrie, M.S. Otterbum and D.Y.S. Szeto, J. Polym. ScL, Polym. Lett., 1988,26,459. A.H. Fawcett, D.Y.S. Szeto and D. Pepper, in preparation. A. Zambelli, P. Locatelli, G. Bajo and F.A. Bovey, Macromolecules, 1975,8,687. R. Mani and CM. Burns, Macromolecules, 1991, 24, 5476. A.H. Fawcett, F. Heatley, KJ. Ivin, CD. Stewart and P. Watt, Macromolecules, 1977,10, 765. R.H. Cole, P.W. Winsor, A.H. Fawcett and S. Fee, Macromolecules, 1987, 20,157. N. Spasky and P. Sigwalt, Bull. Soc. Chim. Fr., 1967,4617. A.H. Fawcett and R.K. Malcolm, Polym. Int., 1994,35,41. S.A. Chambers, A.H. Fawcett, J.F. Malone and S. Fee, Macromolecules, 1990, 23, 2757. J.R. Ebdon, The characterization of diene polymers by high resolution proton magnetic resonance, in K. J. Ivin (Ed.), Structural Studies of Macromolecules by
Spectroscopic Methods, John Wiley & Sons, London, 1976, p. 241. [48] C-W. Chau, A.H. Fawcett, J.N. Mulemwa and C-E. Tan, Polymer, 1992, 193, 257. [49] A.H. Fawcett, J.N. Mulemwa and C-E. Tan, Polym. Commun., 1984,25, 300.
[50] C-W. Chau, A.H. Fawcett, J.N. Mulemwa, L.-W. Poom, A. Surgenor and C-E. Tan, Makromol. Chem., 1992,193, 257.
[51] J.C Bevington, D.A. Cywar, T.N. Huckerby, R.A. Lyons, E. Senogles and D. A. Tirrell, Eur. Polym. J., 1991,27, 603. [52] J.C. Bevington, R.A. Lyons and E. Senogles, Eur. Polym. J., 1992, 28,283. [53] G. Moad and R.I. Willing, Polym. J., 1991,23,1401. [54] KJ. Ivin, Olefin Metathesis, Academic Press, London, 1983. [55] W.L. Truett, D.R. Johnson, LM. Robinson and B. A. Montague, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 1960,82, 2337. [56] J.H. Oskam and R.R. Schrock, J. Am. Chem. Soc,1993,115,11831. [57] KJ. Ivin, B.S.R. Reddy and JJ. Rooney, J. Chem. Soc, Chem. Commun., 1981,1062. [58] KJ. Ivin, D.T. Laverty and JJ. Rooney, Makromol. Chem., 1977,178,1545. [59] B. Bell, J.G. Hamilton, O.N.D. Mackay and JJ. Rooney, J. MoI. CataL, 1992,77,61. [60] R.M.E. Greene, KJ. Ivin, G.M. McCann and JJ. Rooney, Makromol. Chem., 1987, 185,1993. [61] J.G. Hamilton, KJ. Ivin and JJ. Rooney, J. MoI. CataL, 1985,28, 255. [62] J.G. Hamilton, JJ. Rooney and D.G. Snowden, Makromol. Chem., 1993,194, 2907. [63] J.G. Hamilton, KJ. Ivin, G.M. McCann and JJ. Rooney, Makromol. Chem., 1985, 186,1477. [64] R.M.E. Greene, J.G. Hamilton, KJ. Ivin and JJ. Rooney, Makromol. Chem., 1986, 187, 619. [65] H.T. Ho, KJ. Ivin and JJ. Rooney, J. MoI. CataL, 1982,15, 245. [66] J.G. Hamilton, KJ. Ivin and JJ. Rooney, J. MoI. CataL, 1986,36,115. [67] KJ. Ivin, D.T. Laverty, J.H. O'Donnell and JJ. Rooney, Makromol. Chem., 1979, 180,1989. [68] J.G. Hamilton, KJ. Ivin, G.M. McCann and JJ. Rooney, J. Chem. Soc, Chem. Commun., 1984, 1379. [69] D.L. Barnes, N.W. Eilerts, J.A. Heppert, W.H. Huang and M.D. Morton, Polyhedron, 1994,13,1267. [70] J.G. Hamilton and JJ. Rooney, ubpublished results. [71] G.I. Devine, H.T. Ho, KJ. Ivin, M.A. Mohammed and JJ. Rooney, J. Chem. Soc, Chem. Commun., 1982, 1229.
[72] TJ. Katz, SJ. Lee and M.A. Shippey, J. MoI. CataL, 1980,8,219. [73] J.G. Hamilton, KJ. Ivin and JJ. Rooney, Br. Polym. J., 1988, 20,91. [74] H.T. Ho, B.S.R. Reddy and JJ. Rooney, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 1, 1982, 78, 3307. [75] J. G. Hamilton, K. J. Ivin, J. J. Rooney and L. C. Waring, J. Chem. Soc, Chem. Commun., 1983, 159. [76] J. Boor, Ziegler Natta Catalysts and Polymerization, Academic Press, New York, 1979. [77] J.G. Hamilton and JJ. Rooney, J. Chem. Soc, Chem. Commun., 1992, 370. [78] J.-L. Couturier, C. Paillet, M. Leconte, J.-M. Basset and K. Weiss, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. EngL, 1992,31, 628. [79] J.-M. Basset, J.G. Hamilton, M. Leconte and JJ. Rooney, ubpublished results.
2
CONFORMATIONITHE
CONNECTION BETWEEN THE NMR SPECTRA AND THE MICROSTRUCTURES OF POLYMERS A. E. TONELLI Fiber + Polymer Science Program, College of Textiles, North Carolina State University, PO Box 8301, Raleigh, NC 27695-8301, USA
2.1 INTRODUCTION The resonance or Larmor frequency of a spin-1/2 nucleus is highly sensitive to the local molecular environment in which it resides. When placed in a strong, static magnetic field H 0 of several tesla, the cloud of electrons about the nucleus produces orbital currents resulting in the creation of small local magnetic fields, which are proportional to H 0 , but are opposite in direction. These local induced magnetic fields effectively screen or shield the nucleus from H 0 and result in the nucleus experiencing a net local magnetic field Hloc = H 0 (1 — a), where a is the screening constant, a is highly sensitive to chemical structure, i.e., the numbers and types of atoms and groups of atoms attached to or near the observed nucleus. It is the dependence of a upon molecular structure that lies at the heart of NMR's utility as a probe of molecular structure. Any structural feature that alters the electronic environment around a nucleus will affect its screening constant o and lead to an alteration in its resonance frequency or chemical shift 8. Consequently, to predict the chemical shift of, say, a 13 C nucleus in a particular molecular environment, the electronic wave function of the molecular system in the presence of the strong applied field H 0 must be known. For this reason it has been extremely difficult to make a priori predictions of the resonance frequencies or chemical shifts of spin-1/2 nuclei [1-4]. If, for example, we wish to calculate the relative chemical shifts of the 13 C nuclei in methane and methyl fluoride, we must be able to determine accurately the electronic wave functions of both molecules in the presence of Ho; Polymer Spectroscopy. Edited by Allan H. Fawcett © 1996 John Wiley & Sons Ltd
To date it has not been possible to make accurate predictions of the chemical shifts observed for spin-1/2 nuclei, even when applying the most sophisticated ab initio quantum mechanical methods. Instead, the empirically observed effects of substituents and local conformation have been used to correlate chemical shifts (usually 13C) with the microstructures of molecules, including polymers [5].
2.2 SUBSTITUENT EFFECTS ON 13C CHEMICAL SHIFTS Substituent effect rules useful in predicting the 13C chemical shifts observed in the 13 C NMR spectra of paraffinic hydrocarbons have been derived [6-9]. 13 C chemical shifts are ordered in terms of the effects produced by substituents attached to the observed carbon at the a, /?, and y positions. Some of the data used to establish these rules are reproduced in Tables 2.1-2.3, where it is apparent that each carbon substituent added a and/or j? to the observed carbon C° deshields it by ^ 9 ppm. On the other hand, each carbon y-substituent results in shielding of % 2 ppm of the observed carbon. Using these substituent rules makes it possible to assign the 13 C NMR spectra of paraffinic hydrocarbons, including their highly branched members. Table 2.1 a-substituent effect on ^13C [10]
a-effect, ppm
(a)
0
CH 3 -^H
(b)
0
CH 3 -I- 01 CH 3
5.9
8.0
/CH3 CH I *[
16.1
10.2
25.2
9.1
279
27
0
(C)
"21
/CH 3
°CH-f-aCH3 (d)
Xa
CH3
/CH3
° c 4; cH3 (e)
XT01CHs >CH 3
Table 2.2
0-substituent effect on S* 3 C [ 10] <513C from TMS, ppm
(a)
5.9
(b)
15.6
^-effect, ppm
9.7
8.7
(C)
24.3
7.2
(d) 31.5
Table 2.3 y-substituent effect on <5*3C [10] <513C from TMS, ppm
y-effect, ppm
(a)
15.6
(b)
13.2
-2.4
(C)
11.5
-1.7
(d)
8.7
-2.8
(e)
25.0
(0
22.6
(g)
20.7
(h)
18.8
-2.4
-1.9
-1.9
H-T
H-H:T-T
Figure 2.1
Possible regiosequences of monomer units in P P Table 2.4 Value OfS13C observed in the speatra of H - T [13] and H - H : T - T [14] PPs <5 13 Cvs.TMS, fl ppm Carbon CH CH 2 CH 3
H-Tb
H-Hc
T-T c
28^5 46.0 20.5
37X) 15.0
31.3
"All S13C values are averaged over the different stereosequences [14]. ''Schilling and Tonelli [ H ] . c M611eretal. [12].
We may understand why the 13C nuclei in head-to-tail (H-T) polypropylene (PP) (see Figure 2.1) resonate in the order CH2, CH, CH 3 from low to high ISeId (see Table 2.4) in terms of their a-, /?-, and y-substituent effects. Methine carbons have two additional a- (4- 18ppm) and two additional y-substituents (—4ppm) compared with methyl carbons and should resonate 18 — 4=14 ppm downfield. Methylene carbons have two additional p- ( + 18ppm), one fewer a- (-9ppm), and two fewer y-substituents (+ 4 ppm) compared with the methine carbons, and should resonate 18-9 + 4 = 13 ppm further downfield. Suppose that PP possesses head-to-head (H-H) and tail-to-tail (T-T) units in addition to the predominant H-T enchainment of monomer units. As seen in Figure 2.1, the H-H methine carbons have an additional /?- ( + 9 ppm) and two fewer y-substituents (+ 4 ppm) than H-T methine carbons, and should resonate 9-1-4=13 ppm downfield from their H-T counterparts. T-T methylene carbons have one fewer y8-( — 9 ppm) and two more y-substituents (—4 ppm) than the H-T methylene carbons, and should move — 9—4 = —13 ppm upfield from the H-T methylene resonances. H-H methyls should resonance - 2 ppm upfield from the H-T methyls, because they have a single additional y-substituent. Note in
ISOTACTIC
ATACTIC
SYNDIOTACTIC
ppm vs. TMS
Figure 2.2 25MHz PP [13]
13
CNMR spectra of (a) isotactic, (b) atactic, and (c) syndiotactic
Table 2.4 that all these expectations are borne out in the 13 C NMR spectra of H-T PP [11] and H-HiT-T PP [12], and are consistent with the a-, j?-, and y-substituent effects on 13 C chemical shifts derived from paraffins. However, it is clear from the 13 C NMR spectra of three PP samples presented in Figure 2.2 [13] that the multiple resonances appearing in the spectrum of atactic-PP(b), which are well known to be produced by different stereosequences [11], cannot be explained by the usual a-, /?-, and y-substituent effects. Each methyl carbon in PP has one a-, two /?-, and two y-substituents, each methine carbon has two a-, two /?-, and four y-substituents, and each methylene carbon has two a-, four /?- and two y-substituents independent of stereosequence. Some factor other than numbers and types of a-, /J-, and y-substituents, and which depends on PP stereosequence, must be responsible for the multiplicity of
resonances observed in the atactic PP spectrum. As we shall shortly see, that other factor is the stereosequence-dependent local conformation of the PP chain [11,13,14].
23 y-GA UCHE EFFECT METHOD OF PREDICTING NMR CHEMICAL SHIFTS We have mentioned that y-substituents in paraffinic hydrocarbons shield carbon nuclei relative to unsubstituted carbons. In Figure 2.3 it is apparent that the observed carbon C° and its y-substituent CY can alter their mutual arrangement (distance and orientation) via rotation about the central of the three bonds which separate them. Note that the distance between C° and Cy (do_y) is reduced from 4 to 3 A on changing their arrangement from trans to gauche. Grant and Cheney [15] first suggested a conformational origin for the y-substituent effect on S* 3 C. Polarization of the C°-H and C7-H bonds as a result of their compression by proton-proton (o-y) repulsion was suggested as the source of y-gauche shielding. More recently, Li and Chesnut [16] have suggested that the shielding y-effects correlate with attractive van der Waals forces and not repulsive steric interactions, though they still suggest that the gauche arrangement of the observed carbon and its y-substituent is required for shielding. Seidman and Machiel [17] concluded, based on semiempirical and ab inito quantum mechanical calculations, that the y-substituent effect is conformational
Figure 2.3 Newman projctions of an n-alkane chain in the (a) trans (<£ = 0°) and gauche ( = 120°) conformations
in origin, but is not exclusively attributable to the proximity of the interacting C° and (7 groups. Most recently, Barfield and Yamamura [4] concluded that nuclear shielding of the methyl carbons in n-butane is dominated by changes in the paramagnetic contributions for the C 1 —C 2 and C 1 —H bonds, rather than the steric compression of C 1 —H bonds produced by the crowding of terminal methyl groups in the gauche conformation. Though its fundamental origins remain uncertain, the y-substituent effect on (513C values has a conformational sensitivity and, as we will shortly demonstrate, is potentially useful in characterizing both the conformations and the microstructures of polymers. For a carbon nucleus to be shielded by a y-substituent we have suggested that they must be in a gauche arrangement (see Figure 2.3). This suggestion is supported by comparing the <513C values observed for the methyl carbons in n-alkanes. The methyl carbons in n-butane and higher n-alkanes have a single y-substituent, whereas the methyl carbons in n-propane have no y-substituents, but the same number and kinds of a- and jS-substituents as the higher n-alkanes. In their crystals the n-alkanes adopt the extended, all-trans conformation, where both methyl carbons are trans to their y-substituents. If the y-substituents are trans to the methyl carbons in the higher solid n-alkanes, then we would expect (513CH3 (solid C n H 2n+2 , n ^ 4) = (513CH3 (liquid n-propane). VanderHart [18] has observed the methyl carbons in the solid n-alkanes with n — 19,20,23, or 32 to resonate between 15 and 16ppm (relative to TMS), while the methyl carbon in liquid n-propane resonates at 15.6ppm. [19] On the other hand, in the liquid state, the methyl carbons in the higher n-alkanes (n ^ 4) resonate upfield at 13.2-14.1 ppm. [19] Of course in the liquid state the C—C bonds in n-alkanes possess a significant gauche content, and this results in the shielding of <513CH3 for n-butane and the higher n-alkanes compared to that observed for the methyl carbons in n-propane or the higher solid n-alkanes in the all-trans conformation. If we know how much gauche character Pg is possessed by the central bond between C° and X y [ C ° — C ^ - C - X 7 ] , then we can estimate the shielding produced by Xy, yc x, when in a gauche arrangement with C°. This procedure is illustrated in Figure 2.4, where the gauche shielding effects of the y-substituents C, OH, and Cl are derived. As an example, when the shielding produced at the methyl carbon in n-butane by the other methyl group (its y-substituent), i.e., A(5 13 CH 3 = <513CH3 (n-butane)-(5 13 CH 3 (n-propane)= 1 3 . 2 - 1 5 . 6 = - 2 . 4 ppm, is divided by the gauche character of the intervening bond, P9 = 0.46: yc,c = A(513CH3/P^= -2.4/0.46= - 5 . 2 ppm. When this procedure is applied to n-butane, 1-propanol, and 1-chloropropane, the following y-gauche shielding effects are derived: yc c = — 5.2 ppm, 7C,OH = —7.2 ppm, and yCtC1= —6.8 ppm. We now see that the shielding at a carbon nucleus produced by a y-substituent in a gauche arrangement can be comparable in magnitude ( - 5 to - 7 ppm) to the deshielding ( + 9 ppm) caused
CH3-CH2-CH2-CHj % gauche = 46 Xc-c "^i
»-5.2ppm
CH 3 -CH 2 -CH 2 -OH 7 % gauche = 74
t - o = ~-M= -?-2ppm CH3-CH2-CH2-C*7 % gauche s 60.0 y
c - a = ^
^ - 6 . 8 ppm
Figure 2.4 Derivation of the y-gauche shielding produced by the y-substituents C, OH, and Cl (see text) by the more proximal a and /? substituents. More important, however, is the conformational dependence of the y-substituent effect on 13 CNMR chemical shifts. Any variation in the microstructure of a molecule which affects its local conformation can be expected to be reflected in its S13C values via the y-gauche effect. Let us complete our discussion of the conformational connection between the microstructures and NMR spectra of polymers, which is provided by the conformationally sensitive y-gauche effect, by considering the nonequivalent S13C values for the isopropyl methyl carbons in several branched alkanes [8,20, 21] as presented in Table 2.5. Even though the isopropyl methyl carbons in each alkane have the same a-, /?-, and y-substituents, we note in column 2 that the observed nonequivalence progressively decreases as the number of carbons separating the terminal isopropyl group from the asymmetric center is increased. This behavior can be understood [22] if we focus on the source of the nonequivalent <513C values observed for the isopropyl methyl carbons in 2,4dimethylhexane (2,4-DMH). In Figure 2.5 we have illustrated the possible staggered conformations about the C 2 - C 3 backbone bond in 2,4-DMH, since these determine whether or not the isopropyl methyl carbons Csc, C bb are y-gauche to the asymmetric carbon C 4 . From the probabilities of finding bond C2-C3 in the trans (t), gauche + (g 4-), and
13
Table 2.5 Nonequivalent
C NMR chemical shifts for the isopropyl methyl carbons in branched alkanes A<5, ppm Alkane Obsd.0 Calcd.
C C I I C—C—C—C—C—C C C I I C
C
I
I
C—C—C—C—C—C—C—C C C I
1.0 (1,9,1.1,0.9)*
1.6,1.1,0.9
0.1
0.04
I
c—c—c—c—c—c—c—c—c
o.o
o.o
" Observed between ambient temperature and 480C. (Kroschwitz et al. [20], Lindeman and Adams [8]; Carman et al. [21]. •Observed at - 1 2 0 , 25, and 90 0C (Tonelli et al. [22].
Figure. 2.5 (a) 2,4-DMH in the all-trans conformation; (b) Newman projections illustrating rotational states about the C2-C3 backbone bond of 2,4-DMH [22] gauche — (g - ) rotational states (Pn Pg+,Pg_), we obtain Pt + P9+, P9 + + P9 _ as the probabilities for gauche arrangements between Csc and Cbb, respectively, and their y-substituent C 4 . Bond rotation probabilities are obtained from the conformational model developed by Mark [23] for ethylene-propylene copolymers:
Pt = 0.38, Pg+ = 0.0 and Pg_ = 0.61. Thus, C 4 is y-gauche to Csc with probability 0.39 and to C bb with probability 0.62. We expect the nonequivalence between Csc and Cbb to be AS13C = (0.39 -0.62) x y c c = - 0.23( - 5.2 ppm) =1.1 ppm, where we have adopted the value yCtC = — 5.2 ppm derived from n-butane. The observed nonequivalence (1.0-1.1 ppm) is in close agreement with the value expected from the y-gauche conformational calculation. The temperature dependence of the observed magnetic nonequivalence is also successfully reproduced by the y-gauche effect calculations, leaving little doubt that its origin is the conformationally sensitive y-gauche effect. From the Newman projections in Figure 2.5 it might be expected that the t and g — conformations would be equally populated. However, it is well known [24] that rotational state probabilities for the backbone bonds in linear chain molecules depend on the conformations, or rotational states, of neighboring bonds. The asymmetric center at C 4 generates intramolecular interactions which depend simultaneously on (f> and neighboring bond rotations (see Figure 2.5(a)), which render Px^ Pg_. The values of Pt and P9_ approach each other as the asymmetric center is further removed from the terminal isopropyl group, leading to a reduction in the expected nonequivalence of the isopropyl methyl carbons. This expectation is borne out in Table 2.5, where it is both observed and predicted that the magnetic nonequialence of isopropyl methyl carbons vanishes once they are separated by more than four carbons from the asymmetric center. It is apparent from this example that the microstructural sensitivity of 13 C NMR chemical shifts can have a conformational origin. <513C depends on the local magnetic field, which is influenced by the local conformation in the vicinity of the resonating carbon nucleus. The local conformation is determined by the neighboring microstructure. Hence, the microstructural sensitivity of 1 3 C NMR has its basis in the dependence of the local conformation on microstructure microstructure -> conformation -* H loc -+(513C The shielding of 13 C nuclei by y-substituents in a gauche arrangement (ygauche effect) enables us to both complete and simplify the conformational connection between the microstructures and NMR spectra of polymers. y-gauche effect
microstructure
c l 3
-,
•
2.4. APPLICATIONSOF y - GA UCHE EFFECT ANALYSIS OF POLYMER MICROSTRUCTURES 2.4.1 POLYPROPYLENE(PP) We are now in a position to understand the stereosequence sensitivity of the 613C values observed [11] for atactic PP (see Figure 2.2(b)). When the methyl carbon
ppm vs. TMS 13
Figure 2.6 (a) C NMR spectrum at 90.52 MHz of the methyl carbon region in atactic PP in 20% w/v n-heptane solution at 67 0C. (b) Simulated spectrum obtained from calculated chemical shifts, as represented by the line spectrum below, assuming Lorentzian peaks <0.1 ppm in width at half height [13] region of this spectrum is expanded [13] we see in Figure 2.6(a) that over 20 resonances are observed. Because there are 10 and 36 distinct pentad and heptad stereosequences [25], the 1 3 CNMR spectrum of atactic PP shows sensitivity to heptad stereosequences in the methyl region. An atactic PP heptad is illustrated in Figure 2.7 along with Newman projections detailing the y-gauche interactions involving the methyl group. It is clear that in the t and g~ backbone conformations the methyl group is gauche to its y-substituents, the backbone methine carbons (a). To predict the 13C chemical shifts expected for the methyl carbons in atactic PP we simply have to calculate the trans/gauche probabilities for these backbone bonds in each of the 36 heptad stereosequences. When this is carried
Figure 2.7 (a) Conformations of a four carbon fragment of a PP chain; (b) heptad of PP; observed methyl is marked by asterisk out with the Suter-Flory [26] RIS (rotational isomeric state) model for PP, and the resultant probabilities of finding CH 3 in a gauche arrangement with its y-substituents Ca are multiplied by the shielding produced by this arrangement (y CH3Ca = — 5ppm), we obtain [13] the predicted methyl 13 C chemical shifts presented in the form of a stick spectrum at the bottom of Figure 2.6(b). Because the y-gauche effect method of calculating 13 C chemical shifts only leads to the prediction of stereosequence-dependent relative chemical shifts, we are free in the comparison with observed spectra to translate the calculated shifts to obtain the best agreement with the observed (513Cs. This has been done in Figure 2.6, where the agreement between the observed and calculated methly <513C values has been used to make the stereosequence assignments indicated there. The y-gauche effect method of assigning resonances in the methyl region of the 13 C NMR spectrum of atactic PP to heptad stereosequences has been achieved without recourse to the study of PP model compounds or stereoregular PP's (see Figure 2.2(a) and (c)) and without assuming a particular statistical model to describe the frequencies or populations of stereosequences produced during polymerization. By achieving agreement between the observed 13 C chemical shifts and those predicted by the y-gauche effect method, we have not only determined the microstructure (stereosequence) of this polymer, but in addition we have
stringently tested its conformational characteristics as embodied in the RIS model. Clearly then, it is possible to use 13 C NMR spectroscopy to test or derive the conformational characteristics of vinyl polymers by comparison of observed 13 C NMR spectra with the 5 13 Cs calculated via the y-gauche effect method. This approach has been pursued with success to test the local conformational characteristics of several vinyl polymers [13, 27, 28] and provides the basis for the discussion presented in the subsequent chapter of this volume. Having established the assignment of resonances observed in the methyl region of the 13 C NMR spectrum of atactic PP to the appropriate heptad stereosequences, one might ask what use can be made of this detailed configurational information. Through an analysis of the intensities of the observed resonances we may learn if any simple statistical model, such as Bernoullian or Markovian statistics, can describe the polymerization of atactic PP. In Figure 2.6 we compare the observed and simulated 13 C NMR spectra of the methyl region of atactic PP. The simulated spectrum was obtained [13] by assuming Lorentzian peaks of < 0.1 ppm width at half height for each of the 36 heptad chemical shifts calculated by the y-gauche effect method. The relative intensities or heights of these heptad peaks were then adjusted to obtain the best simulation of the observed spectrum. The comparison presented in Figure 2.6 makes it apparent that we have been able successfully to simulate the methyl region of the 13 C NMR spectrum of atactic PP based on our ability to calculate and assign all of the heptad stereosequence resonances. Thus, from this successful simulation we know how much of each heptad stereosequence is present in our atactic PP sample. When we compare these heptad stereosequence populations with those predicted by simple statistical models, we are able to conclude that our atactic PP sample cannot be described by any simple statistical polymerization model, such as Bernoullian or first-order Markovian. It has been subsequently shown by Inoue et al. [29] that a two site model of Ziegler-Natta polymerization of propylene [30] adequately describes the distribution of stereosequences observed in atactic PP. At one of the catalyst sites the monomer addition obeys Bernoullian statistics, and at the other site a predominance of monomer units is added in only one of the two possible configurations (R, S or d, /). As we can see, the y-gauche effect prediction of 13 C NMR chemical shifts in vinyl polymers permits assignment of their 13 C NMR spectra, provides an opportunity to test or derive an RIS model description of their conformational characteristics, and may also permit a test of their polymerization statistics. 2.4.2 PROPYLENE-VINYL CHLORIDE COPOLYMERS (P-VC) Although propylene (P) does not homopolymerize under free-radical initiation [31], it can be incorporated to a minor degree in a copolymerization with vinyl
chloride (VC) leading to P-VC copolymers with up to 15mol% P units. The combination of low P content and the inability of P to homopolymerize under these conditions results in P-VC copolymers where all P units are isolated by long uninterrupted runs of VC units. Consequently, we may study the stereochemistry of the comonomer sequences containing the isolated P units, i.e., .. V C - V C - V C - V C - V C - V C - P — V C - V C - V C - V C - V C - V C . . . , and compare them with the stereosequences found in the two homopolymers PP and PVC. The methyl carbon regions of the 1 3 CNMR spectra of two PP samples are compared with the methyl carbon region observed in the P—VC copolymer [32] in Figure 2.8. The PP sample A in (a) is a typical commercial atactic material [11], and the PP sample B in (b) is a heptane-soluble fraction of a research-grade material [33]. The stick spectrum in (b) was calculated as just described; the y-gauche effect13C chemical shifts calculated for the methyl carbons in the P-VC copolymer (c) were obtained by employing Mark's [34] RIS conformational model of P-VC copolymers. Comparison of the methyl resonances in P-VC and PP reveals a decreased sensitivity to stereosequence for the P-VC copolymer. The methyl carbon resonances in P-VC are sensitive to pentad stereosequences, whereas in PP heptad sensitivity is observed. In Table 2.6 the 13 C chemical shifts calculated for the methyl carbons in several heptad stereosequences of P-VC and PP are compared. As observed, the methyl carbon chemical shifts calculated for P-VC are sensitive to pentads, but PP methyl carbons show significant heptad sensitivity. This difference in stereosequence sensitivity between the methyl carbons in P-VC and PP is directly attributable to differences in their conformational behavior as embodied in their RIS models. Local bond conformations reflect pentad sensitivity in P-VC and heptad dependence in PP. In addition, note that the overall spreads in methyl carbon chemical shifts observed in P-VC and PP are 2.7 and 2.0 ppm, respectively, with the P-VC methyl carbons resonating about 1 ppm upfield from those in PP. These observations are also reproduced by the calculated chemical shifts, which employ the same y-effect (yCH3,cH = — 5 ppm) and further indicate differences in the conformational behavior between P-VC copolymer [34] and PP homopolymer [26].
2.4.3
P O L Y ( P R O P Y L E N E OXIDE) (PPO)
r°i (CH3CHCH2) Propylene oxide exists in both R and S optical forms owing to its asymmetric methine carbon. If during polymerization only one of the C—O bonds in the cyclic monomer is cleaved, then it is possible to generate four different
ppm vs. (CH^) 4 Si
Figure 2.8 (a) Methyl carbon region of the 50 MHz 13C NMR spectrum of PP sample A; (b) methyl carbon region of the 50 MHz 13C NMR spectrum of PP sample B with stick spectrum of 13C chemical shifts calculated for the methyl carbons in atactic PP; (c) P-methyl carbon region of the 50MHz 13 CNMR spectrum of P-VC copolymer with stick spectrum of 13C chemical shifts calculated for the methyl carbons in P-VC
Table 2.6 13C NMR chemical shifts calculated for the methyl carbons in several heptad stereosequences of P-VC and PP* A<5,* ppm Heptad r(rmrm)r m(rmrm)r r(rmrm)m m(rmrm)m r(mrrm)r m(mrrm)r m(mrrm)m
P-VC 0 -0.01 -0.01 -0.03 0 -0.04 -0.07
PP 0 -0.07 -0.05 -0.10 0 -0.07 -0.12
Tonelli and Schilling [32]. *A<5 is the difference in chemical shift among the various heptads containing the same central pentad stereo sequence. VCH?CH = - 5 ppm was used for both PP and P-VC.
ISOTACTIC, RRR OR SSS
SYNDIOTACTIC, RSR OR SRS
HETEROTACTIC-1 RRSORSSR
HETEROTACTIC-2 SRR OR RSS
stereochemical triads in the regioregular head-to-tail (H-T) PPO polymer. These H-T triads are presented below in planar zigzag projection. If, however, during the ring-opening polymerization [35, 36] both C—O bonds in propylene oxide are subject to cleavage, then, in addition to the H-T PPO triads above, three additional structural triads or regiosequences are possible for PPO. These are illustrated here for the all-/* regioisomers, where H-T, H-H, T-T, and T-H refer to the directions of neighboring monomers, and where H is the methine end and T is the methylene end of the monomer unit. Each CH3 H
H
HCH3H
/VxVV\ H
H H ^CH3 H3C
H
(T-H: T-T) CH3 H
CH 3 HH
AWV\ H
JCH3
HH H (T-T: H-H)
HH
H
CH 3 HH
HH
HCH 3 .H CH3
H
H
(H-H: T-H) of these regioirregular triads, with H-H and T-T additions, can be further subdivided on stereochemical grounds, as was done above for the regioregular H-T triads. Thus, when both regiosequence and stereosequence are considered, 16 unique structural triads can potentially exist in PPO. It is worth mentioning that, independent of regiosequence (H-T, H-H, T-T), an m-diad consists of RR or SS neighboring units, whereas an r-diad consists of RS or SR neighboring units. However, the methyl groups in a H-T m-diad are on opposite sides of the planar zigzag projection, while in H-H and T-T diads they are on the same side. The methyl groups in r-diads are on the same side of the backbone when the diad is H-T, but on opposite sides in both the H-H and T-T r-diads. This is a direct consequence of the number of bonds separating asymmetric centers in H-T (three bonds) and in H-H or T-T (two or four bonds) regiosequences. Because the PPO repeat untit contains three protons (two methylene and one methine) whose resonances overlap extensively, it has not been possible to use
1
H NMR spectroscopy [37-42], even at 500 MHz, to determine the microstructure of PPO. Deuteration at the methine carbon simplifies the 1 H NMR spectra of PPO [38-41], and two-dimensional 1 H NMR spectroscopy [42] also leads to greater separation of the overlapping proton resonances. However, even the application of these special synthetic and spectroscopic techniques has not been completely successful in establishing the microstructures present in PPO. Carbon-13 NMR generally offers the potential for greater spectroscopic resolution than 1 HNMR and might be expected to be better suited for the analysis of PPO microstructure [43-47]. This expectation is realized for regioregular (all H-T) PPO, where CH and CH 2 carbon resonances are separated by 2 ppm, and permits the unambiguous assignment [45] of PPO stereosequences. However, as we will demonstrate here, the methine and methylene carbon resonances in regioirregular (H-T, H-H, T-T) PPO do overlap [48]. The methine and methylene carbons in PPO have the same numbers and types of a and p substituents (CH -• two a-C, one a-O one /?-C, and one /?-O; CH 2 -+ one a-C, one a-O, two /J-C, and one /J-O) independent of whether or not they are part of H-T, H-H, or T-T units (see the triad representations above). Because the deshielding of a carbon nucleus produced by a- and /?-carbon substituents is very similar ( « + 9 ppm), the relativex 3 C chemical shifts of both CH and CH 2 carbons in PPO should depend solely on their y-gauche interactions. In regioregular PPO the H-T methine carbons have two y-substituents (two CH) and the methylene carbons three y-substituents (two CH 2 , one CH3). We therefore expect, as is observed [45], that the methylene carbons will resonate upfield ( « — 2 ppm) from the methine carbons. In regioirregular PPO the H-H methine carbons have three y-substituents (two CH 2 and one CH 3 , or one CH, one CH2, and one CH3), as do the H-T methylene carbons, and the T-T methylene carbons have two ysubstituents (two CH, or one CH and one CH2), like the H-T methine carbons. We therefore expect the H-H methine and H-T methylene carbon resonances and the T-T methylene and H-T methine resonances to overlap, based on their having the same numbers and types of a-, /?-, and y-substituents. In earlier studies of PPO using 13 C NMR [45], confusion developed in assigning resonances to carbons of the H-H:T-T defects that result from the catalyst occasionally cleaving the CH—O linkage instead of the CH 2 —O bond when opening the propylene oxide ring. The possible mixing of overlapping methine and methylene carbon resonances was not considered. Additionally, spectral analysis of lowermolecular-weight samples must take into account the contributions of carbon nuclei in the chain-end structures. Our approach [48] in analyzing the 13 CNMR spectra of PPO was first to define the type of carbon represented by each resonance, i.e., methine, methylene, or methyl. Application of the DEPT and INEPT pulse editing techniques [49] permitted achievement of this objective. Second, by analysis of PPO samples differing in molecular weight we were able to assign those resonances belonging to end-group carbons. The third and final step in the analysis was to assign the
H-H and T-T defect resonances using the y-gauche effect method to calculate (513C values. The carbon nuclei in PPO are shielded by carbon and oxygen y-substituents. From 13 CNMR studies of alkanes and their oxygenated derivatives [19], y c c = —4 to — 5ppm and yc,o = —6 to — 8ppm seem likely for the shieldings produced by C and O y-substituents when in a gauche arrangement with carbon nuclei in PPO. The numbers of such y-gauche arrangements were determined from the bond conformation probabilities calculated for PPO with the RIS model developed by Abe etal. [5O]. This conformational description developed for regioregular (H-T) PPO was modified [48] so as to permit the calculation of bond conformation probabilities in the H-H and T-T portions of PPO as well. Effects of both regiosequence and stereosequence were explicitly considered when calculating relative 13C NMR chemical shifts in PPO via the y-gauche effect method. The results of these calculations for the carbon nuclei in the H-H and T-T defect structures of PPO are presented in Table 2.7. Note the significant differences between the <513C values predicted for the regular H-T and defect H-H and T-T carbons. 13 CNMR spectra of PPO 4000 (M = 4000) and isotactic PPO (M = 14 500) are presented in Figure 2.9. All three carbon types display chemical shift sensitivity to the stereochemistry of the polymer chain. The assignment of resonances to the regioregular portions of PPO (see Table 2.8) is made by comparison of the two spectra, and agrees with earlier work [44,45]. In contrast to 13 C NMR observations for most vinyl polymers, the observed sensitivity of the PPO carbon chemical shifts to stereochemistry is very small. The total spread of S13C is only 0.12, 0.20, and 0.25 ppm for the methyl, methine, and methylene carbons, respectively. This can be contrasted to atactic PP [11], where the range of chemical shifts due to stereosequences is 2.0, 0.5, and 2.0 ppm for the same carbon types. The reduced sensitivity in PPO reflects the presence of three bonds between chiral centers in contrast to the two bonds in vinyl polymers. The limited chemical shift sensitivity is predicted by the RIS model for PPO [50]. On the basis of y-gauche shielding interactions, a spread of H-T chemical shifts of % 0.5 ppm is predicted for each of the three carbon types. The DEPT technique [49, 51] permits spectral editing in such a manner that spectra containing only a specific carbon type can be produced. In Figure 2.10 we show results of DEPT measurements on atactic PPO 4000 for the methine and methylene carbons only. At the vertical gain used in acquiring these spectra the H-T resonances are off scale, and we are observing the resonances of the defect H-H and T-T structures as well as the chain-end carbons. In (a), all CH and CH2 resonances are observed, whereas in (b) and (c) only the CH and the CH2 resonances, respectively, are observed. The most striking feature of these DEPT editing spectra is the observation that there are clearly methine carbon resonances in the upfield region previously thought to contain exclusively methylene resonances, and there also are methylene resonances in the downfield portion of
Table 2.7 Calculated 1 CH3
I
-CH
2
1
13
2 a
CH3 b
I
-CH-O-CH
1
C NMR chemical shifts for poly(propylene oxide) [48] at 23 0 C
2
I
2
3 CH3 3 Diad
Carbon
a
CH 3 I 2 2 2 2 3 3 4 4 5 CH 2 I 2 2 2 2 3 3 4 4 5 CH 1 2 2 2 2 3 3 4 4 5
m r m r m
b
3
2
4
4
2
-CH-O--
5
5
a
C
d
r r m m r m
m m r r m r -
m m r m r
l
-O-CH-CH-O-CH
m r m m m r r m
5 CH 3
d
I
-CH-O-CH-CH
2
4 CH 3
c
r r m
m m r r m r r m m
Chem. shift, PPmb 0.00 0.45 0.49 0.75 0.79 0.53 0.82 0.02 0.04 0.00 0.00 -0.15 -0.19 + 0.20 + 0.25 + 4.40 + 4.73 + 4.75 + 4.78 0.00 0.00 -4.49 -4.45 -4.49 -4.45 -4.48 -4.48 -0.25 -0.27 0.00 + + + + + + + +
"The dash (-) indicates either m or r diad placement. T h e + and - indicate downfield and upfield shifts, respectively, relative to the position of the 1 or 5 (H-T) carbons.
the spectra previously thought to contain only methine resonances. [These observations are confirmed by INEPT spectra (not shown) [48] in which methylene resonances can be observed with negative intensity but methine signals appear as positive peaks.] Certain H-H: T-T and/or end-group resonances at % 73.5 and 75.6 ppm can only be observed in the edited spectra, as they are completely obscured by the H - T peaks in a normal FT spectrum.The
ppm vs. TMS 13
Figure 2.9 50.31 MHz CNMR spectra of (a) atactic PPO 4000, and (b) isotactic PPO, observed [48] at 23 0C in C6D6. see Table 2.8 comparison of resonances in the three spectra of Figure 2.10 permits us to identify each resonance as to carbon type, methine or methylene. To assign resonances produced by various end-groups we compare the spectra observed for PPO 4000 (DP = 69) and PPO1000 (DP = 17) as presented in Figure 2.11. Results of a DEPT measurement on PPO 1000 agree with those for PPO 4000 in establishing the carbon type represented by each resonance. AU of the visible resonances in Figure 2.11 (a), other than the labeled H-T peaks, can be attributed to the end-groups, because the number of such groups is about 3 times that of the H-H: T-T defects in the low-molecular-weight PPO 1000. All of the
Table 2,8 * 3C NMR chemical shifts and relaxation data [48] for headto-tail carbons in poly(propylene oxide) at 230C Chem. shift,a T1, Carbon Resonance ppm s type Stereosequence "1 75J5 078 CH mm 2 75.64 0.80 CH mr + rm 3 75.50 0.81 CH rr 4 73.78 0.51 CH2 m 5 73.54 0.50 CH2 r 6 73.47 0.50 CH2 r 7 17.79 1.03 CH 3 rm,mr,rr 8 17.71 1.03 CH 3 mm,rm, mr, rr 9 75.73 CH mm 10 73.77 CH2 m 11 17.72 CH 3 mm -Figure 2.9.
CH 2 and CH end-group resonances occur in the H - T methine region between 75.0 and 76.5 ppm. DEPT spectra of PPO 1000 (not shown) [48] indicate that no end-group CH resonances are hidden by the H-T methylene resonance at 73.5 ppm. Comparison of DEPT spectra permits the specific assignment of end-group methine (1) and methylene (2) resonances. Note in Figure 2.1 l(a) the end-group methylene resonances at «75.6 ppm, which add to the complexity of the H - T CH region. Comparison of the spectra in Figure 2.11 permits the identification of end-group resonances in PPO 4000 and, by elimination, those resonances that are crosshatched must result from carbons in the H-HrT-T structures. These H-H: T-T peaks are identified as to carbon type from the DEPT spectra in Figure 2.10. A summary of the methine and methylene carbon resonances and their assignment to H-H:T-T defects or end groups appears in Table 2.9. The methyl regions of both atactic PPO samples are displayed in Figure 2.12. Resonances attributable to methyl carbons in or adjacent to an end-group can be assigned by comparison of (a) and (b), where it can be seen that all H-H: T-T defect resonances occur downfield from the H-T peaks. A summary of the methyl carbon data is given in Table 2.10. In order to make the assignments of the carbon nuclei in the H-H: T-T structures, a comparison was made between the experimental chemical shift data (Figures 2.10 and 2.11 and Tables 2.9 and 2.10) and the relative chemical shifts for each carbon type resulting from the y-gauche effect calculations (Table 2.7). The calculated data indicate a lack of sensitivity for all carbons to the nature of the stereochemistry across the T-T portion of the chain (diad c in Table 2.7). In addition, for the H - H methyl and methylene carbons 2 and 3, diad b strongly affects their chemical shifts, but diad a has a much smaller influence. The H - H
ppm vs. TMS
Figure 2.10 Methine and methylene (a), methine only (b), and methylene only (c) 50.31 MHz*3C NMR DEPT spectra of atactic PPO 4000 observed [48] at 23 0C in C6D6
methine carbons, however, are expected to show only a very minor stereochemical dependence. Using the calculated shift data of Table 2.7, it is possible to make the specific assignments given in Tables 2.9 and 2.10. The H-H methine carbons 2 and 3 are predicted to be significantly upfield of the H-T CH resonances (at « 72.8-73.8 ppm) and are observed most clearly in the DEPT editing spectrum (Figure 2.10 (b)). Methine carbon 4 cannot be resolved from the H-T CH resonances. For the CH 2 carbons (Figure 2.10 (a)) the group of resonances slightly downfield of the H-T methylene resonances is assigned to carbon 2, while the methylene resonances (3, 4, 6, 7) shifted downfield into the H-T CH region are assigned to carbons 3 and 4. Despite differences in the magnitudes of calculated and observed shifts for the H-H: T-T vs, H-T methine and methylene carbons
ppm vs. TMS
Figure 2.11 50.31 MHz 13CNMR spectra of (a) atactic PPO 1000, and (b) atactic PPO 4000 observed [48] at 23 0C in C6D6 (1 indicates methine and 2 indicates methylene.) The crosshatched resonances result from the H-HiT-T structure (see below), the predicted direction of relative y-gauche shielding for each carbon permits a consistent set of assignments as given in Table 2.9. These results illustrate the difficulties faced by early workers in assigning the 13 C NMR spectrum of PPO. At first glance one is tempted simply to divide the 73-76 ppm region into two parts, methine and methylene. However, a careful interpretation of the chemical shift effects produced by the H-HiT-T structures shows that a large number of the methine and methylene resonances should overlap, and that the identity of carbon types can be ascertained only by DEPT or INEPT editing experiments [51]. In addition, the comparison of PPO samples differing in molecular weight is necessary to identify the chain-end carbon resonances. The differences in the magnitudes of the S13C values observed and calculated for methine and methylene carbons in the H-HiT-T and H-T PPO structures may stem from the slightly different /J-substituents [19] present in each of these structural environments. The methine and methylene carbons in both H-T and H-HiT-T structures are P to oxygen ( C H - C H 2 - O and C H 2 - C H - O ) , and the methylene carbons are /? to methyl carbons (CH 2 —CH—CH 3 ). However,
Table 2.9 13C NMR chemical shift assignments and relaxation data [48] for the methine and methylene carbons of atactic PPO 4000 at 230C Chem. shift," T\, Resonance ppm Assignment* s I 76J6 —CHE 0.93 2 76.29 —CHE 0.80 3 76.26 -CH23,4 0.80 4 76.21 -CH23,4 0.77 5 76.10 -CH2E 1.19 6 75.98 -CH23,4 0.56 7 75.88 -CH23,4 0.59 8 75.24 —CHE 0.82 9 75.13 -CHE 0.81 10 75.08 -CH-,-CH2E 0.81 II 75.02 -CH2E 0.90 12 74.96 -CHE 1.08 13 74.91 -CHE 1.18 14 74.46 -CH22 1.04 15 74.26 -CH22 0.50 16 74.02 -CH22 0.51 17 73.82 —CH2,3 18 72.97 -CH2,3 0.61 19 72.93 -CH2,3 0.64 20 72.87 —CH2,3 0.68 21 72.06 -CH2E 2.16 22 72.03 -CH2E 2.16 23 73.30 -CH2,3 24 75.65 -CH2E 25 75.57 -CH2E •Figure 2.10. *E indicates chain end structure; 2,3,4 indicate H-H: T-T defect structure (see Table 2.7).
the H-T methine and H-HrT-T methylene carbons are /J to methylene carbons ( C H - O - C H 2 and C H 2 - O - C H 2 ) , whereas H-T methylene and H-HrT-T methine carbons are p to methine carbons (CH 2 —O—CH and CH—O—CH) (See Table 2.7). On the other hand, H-HrT-T and H-T methyl carbons have precisely the same a- and 0-substituents. The fact that the calculated and observed <513C values agree so closely for the methyl carbons (see below) lends support to the suggestion that slightly different /?-substituents for H-T and H-HrT-T methine and methylene carbons may be the source of the disparity between the magnitudes of their measured and calculated <513Cs. The methyl carbon resonances of the H-HrT-T structures are assigned in Table 2.10. Both the calculated magnitudes and the directions of the methyl resonances relative to H-T resonances agree with the observed results (Figure 2.12(a)). The three defect resonances (peaks 4, 5, 6) are assigned to carbons
ppm vs. TMS
Figure 2.12 Methyl region of the 50.31 MHz 13CNMR spectra of (a) atactic PPO 4000, and (b) atactic PPO 1000 observed [48] at 23 0C in C6D6. See Table 2.10 2 and 3 (Table 2.7). Because of the predicted overlap resulting from stereosequences, we cannot make further specific assignments in this region of the PPO spectrum. Note that in Tables 2.8-2.10 values of the spin-lattice relaxation time T1 are presented for each resonance. These were determined by the inversion recovery method and were utilized to insure that quantitative spectra were obtained. From the methyl carbon data (Figure 2.12(a)) we are able to estimate that PPO 4000 contains 2.2% inverted, or defect, H-HrT-T units and has a number-average molcecular weight Mn = 5400, or DP = 93, based on the end-group resonance intensities. This may be compared with Mv = 4000, or DP = 69, provided by the manufacturer and based on KOH hydroxyl number. With the aid of multiple-pulse editing techniques (DEPT, INEPT) and the y-gauche effect calculations of relative 13 CNMR chemical shifts, we [48] have
Table 2.10 * 3C NMR chemical shift assignments and relaxation data [48] for the methyl carbons of atacticPPO4000at23°C Resonance "1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Chem. shift,0 ppm Assignment* 19.27 E 19.24 E 18.99 E 18.74 2,3 18.51 2,3 18.38 2,3 17.29 E 19.31 E 19.26 E 19.02 E 17.31 E
T19 s 1.65 1.65 1.80 0.99 0.96 0.92 1.09
•Figure 2.12. *E indicates chain end structure; 2, 3, indicate H - H . T - T defect structure (see Table 2.9).
assigned the 1 3 CNMR spectrum of PPO, including the determination of carbon resonances resulting from chain-end structures. Analysis of the expected differences between the y-gauche interactions of the methine and methylene carbons in H-T and H-H:T-T PPO structures indicated that H - H i T - T methine resonances should overlap with the H-T methylene signals and the H - H i T - T methylene and H-T methine peaks should also overlap. It was this analysis that prompted our reinvestigation and assignment of the 1 3 C NMR spectrum of PPO. From these assignments it was possible to determine quantitatively the number of H-HiT-T defects incorporated in PPO through occasional ring opening of propylene oxide monomer at the CH—O bond. In addition, identification of chain-end structures permitted an estimate of the number-average molecular weight, and (though not discussed here) determination of specific terminal structures also provided insight concerning the polymerization mechanism of PPO.
2.4.4 POLY(VINYLIDENE F L U O R I D E ) (PVF 2 ) With the application of a triple-resonance scheme [52], which simultaneously broad-band decouples both proton and fluorine nuclei while observing carbon nuclei, it was possible to obtain 1 3 CNMR spectra of fluoropolymers that were free of both 1 3 C - 1 H and 1 3 C - 1 9 F J-couplings. As an example, the triple resonance 13 C NMR spectrum of poly(vinylidene fluoride) (PVF 2 ) was successfully interpreted with y-gauche effects of ycc = — 2 ppm and yCF = — 2 to
—4ppm, and an estimate of 3.2% was made for the content of H-HrT-T defect structures shown below -CF 2 -^ CH2-*-CF2-^ CH2-*- CH2-CF2 J- CH2 -*-CH2 -^CF2 -*- CH2 -^CF2 -^CH 2 Having successfully analyzed [53] the 13 C NMR spectrum OfPVF2 containing a small number of inverted units [3.2% of H-H: T-T monomer additions as observed by integration of detect (H-HrT-T) and normal (H-T) resonances], we now attempt to assign and analyze the 1 9 FNMR spectrum of the same PVF 2 sample. The 1 9 FNMR spectrum of PVF 2 measured at 84.6 MHz is presented in Figure 2.13(a). Three small resonances appear 3.2, 22.0, and 24.0 ppm upfield
<X> p p m Figure 2.13 Observed and calculated [54] 19 F NMR spectra of PVF 2 : (a) measured at 84.6MHz; (b) measured at 188.2 MHz; (c) calculated. Vertical expansion in (a) is x 8, in (b) x 40.
from the main H-T fluorine resonance at 91.9 ppm (relative to CFCl3) and are attributed to the fluorine nuclei belonging to H-H: T-T inverted units [55,56]. We may write expressions for the relative 1 9 FNMR chemical shifts SF of the H-T and H-H: T-T fluorines in terms of their y-gauche effects (y FF and yFC) and the bond rotation probabilities (P) which determine the frequencies of y-gauche interactions: 5JT = (I+P t )y F ,c SF = (1 + 0.5 Pt,d + 0.5 Pt>e)yF,c + (1.5 - 0.5 Pt,c)yF,F, S¥ = (1 + 0.5 Pue + 0.5 Puf)yFtC + (1.5 - 0.5 P J y F i F , <5£ = (l+O.5P t , h + O.5P u )y F , c .
(1) (2) (3) (4)
Comparison of Equations' (1) and (4) reveals that <5F~T an 8F are most similar. Thus, SF — SF~T = 3.2 ppm, which leads directly to <5Fc = +30 ppm (shielding). By elimination, \SF — S¥\ = 2 ppm, which yields <5FF = +15 ppm. Substitution of <5FF = 15 ppm and <5FC = 3Oppm into Equations (1-4) leads to calculated SF values shown as sticks in (c) of Figure 2.13, and which compare well with the observed spectrum in (a) recorded at low field strength. At 188MHz four additional defect resonances (1, 5, 6, and 7) appear in the 19 FNMR spectrum OfPVF2 [see (b) in Figure 2.13]. Ferguson and Brame [57] also observed these additional defect peaks and tentatively assigned them to defect structures drawn in Figure 2.13(b) based on a-, /?-, and y-substituent effects derived from the CF 2 resonances observed in various saturated, partially fluorinated linear alkanes. In addition to SF~T, 8F, SF, and 8F, 19 F chemical shifts were also calculated for the defect fluorines 1,5,6, and 7. 19 F y-effects (yF,CH2; 7F,CF2^ anc * yFF) were least-squares fitted to produce the best agreement between observed and calculated <5F values [see (b) and (c) of Figure 2.13]. Best agreement was achieved for yFfCH2 = yF,CF2 = )V,c = 25-30 ppm and yF F = 1 5 ppm, confirming the assignments proposed by Ferguson and Brame [57] and the y-effects derived from the more prominent defect resonances 2, 3, and 4 observed at lower field strength. Measurement of the intensities of the defect resonances and comparison with the total intensity of all observable resonances yields an estimate of 3.4% defect H-H:T-T addition in this sample of PVF 2 . This compares well with the 3.2% defect estimate described earlier using the 13 CNMR analysis. The 1 9 FNMR spectra of poly(vinyl fluoride), poly(fluoromethylene), and poly(trifluoroethylene) were also successfully interpreted [54] with very similar y-gauche effects (y F F =15ppm and y F C = 25-30 ppm), leading to a detailed accounting of their stereo- and regiosequences. In addition to eliminating the need for triple resonance observation [52] of 13 C NMR spectra, 1 9 F NMR spectra of fluoropolymers [54] are much more sensitive to their microstructures, because the conformationally sensitive y-gauche shield-
ings of their 19 F nuclei are nearly an order of magnitude greater than the shieldings observed for their 13 C nuclei. Clearly 1 9 FNMR provides a vastly superior means for characterizing the microstructures of fluoropolymers compared with 13 CNMR observations.
2.5 NMR SPECTROSCOPY AS A MEANS TO PROBE POLYMER CONFORMATIONS 2.5.1 STYRENE-METHYLMETHACRYLATE COPOLYMERS (S-MM) The advent of two-dimensional NMR techniques [58-61] has resulted in a rebirth of 1 HNMR as a means of studying molecular structure. Extensive Jcoupling of protons, which unduly complicates one-dimensional 1 HNMR spectra, is used to advantage in 2D 1 HNMR to map the connectivity of molecules. Those protons that are scalar J-coupled, and therefore interact between the 90°r.f. pulses, evidence cross peaks in a 2D 1H COSY (correlated spectroscopy) spectrum. If an additional 90°r.f. pulse is inserted between the two 90°r.f. pulses of the 2D 1 H COSY experiment, then the correlating influence or interaction between proton spins which results in cross peaks is their direct, through space, dipolar coupling or NOE (nuclear Overhauser effect). This 2D technique is referred to as NOESY and permits a mapping of all proton spins in the sample which are closer than « 4 A. Let us illustrate how the 2D 1 HNMR technique NOESY, i.e., NOE correlated spectroscopy, can be applied to regularly alternating styrene-methyl methacrylate (S-MM) copolymer to learn about its conformational characteristics. The methylene region of the 500MHz 2D NOESY spectrum of the regularly alternating S-MM copolymer is presented in Figure 2.14. The stippled cross peaks correspond to the intermethylene interactions occurring in the S-centered co-hetero S-MM triad seen below: CO-HETERO
These intermethylene N O t cross peaks appear to fall into three categories based
ppm fromTMS ppm from TMS F
2
Figure 2.14 Expansion of the phase-sensitive proton NOESY spectrum at 500 MHz and 800C, showing only the methylene region [62]. Geminal interactions are indicated by crosshatched cross peaks, and intermethylene interactions by stippled cross peaks. The designations S, M, and W refer to the strengths (cross peak volumes) of the intermethylene proton interactions on their intensities: one strong (S), H^-H1; two medium (M), H e -H^ and Ht-Ht'; and one weak (W), H e -H( etc. corresponding to short, medium, and longer interproton distances, respectively (see Heffner et al. [62] for details of the proton peak assignments). By combining portions of the conformational descriptions derived for styrene, methyl acrylate, and methyl methacrylate homopolymers [63-66], Koinuma et al. [67] developed an RIS model for the 1:1 alternating S-MM copolymer. When this RIS model is utilized to calculate the conformation probabilities for the bond pair flanking the styrene methine carbon in the co-hetero S-MM triad illustrated above, it is possible to calculate [62] the average intermethylene
proton distances corresponding to the four cross peaks in Figure 2.14. This procedure is illustrated in Figure 2.15 and Table 2.11. The only three conformations allowed for the co-hetero S-MM triad are drawn in Figure 2.15 along with the probability calculated for each. The intermethylene proton distances rHH calculated for the same S-MM triad are listed for each conformation in Table 2.11. When these rHH values are raised to the — 6 power and averaged over the three possible conformers shown in Figure 2.15 according to the calculated probabili-
FRACTlON
Figure 2.15 Ball-and-stick models of the styrene-centered MM-S-MM co-hetero triad, showing the tt, tg +, and g-t conformations, with 20° deviations from exact staggering [62]
Table 2.11 Intermethylene H-H distances (rHH) calculated [62] for the co-hetero styrene-centered triad (see Figure 2.15) r
HH> A
i>i t,t(-20°,20°) t,g+(-20°,100°) g-,t(-100°,20°) <0 lf *2> <l92>
He-Ht> 189 3.74 3.74 0.0010(0.0027)"
He-He, Ho 2.63 3.68 0.0016' (0.0016)*
Ht-Ht, Ho 3.68 2.63 0.0016(0.0020)*
H e -H t 220 2.59 2.59 0.0063fl (0.0030)*
a
r~£ averaged over all three (^1, ^ 2 ) conformations. *Same as above, except 0 , , ^ 2 = 0, ± 120° in the ^g* states (Heffner et al. [62]).
ties also listed there, the entries in the next-to-last row of Table 2.11 are obtained. These values should be proportional to the strengths of the intermethylene proton-proton cross peaks seen in Figure 2.14, and this is indeed the case. The agreement between the predicted and the observed pattern of NOESY cross peaks for the co-hetero triad of 1:1 alternating S-MM copolymer confirms the validity of the Koinuma et al. [67] conformational model. It is particularly noteworthy that this agreement requires the assumption of «20° displacements from the perfectly staggered rotational states as predicted for the backbone bonds in polystyrene by Yoon et al. [63] (see the Newman projections below). As an example, in the t, t conformation (see Figure 2.15), 0, # 2 = — 20°, 20° because this produces relief from steric interactions of the phenyl ring and the methyl methacrylate C^ as seen in the following Newman projections:
If perfectly staggered states t(0°), g ± (+120°) are assigned in the calculation of intermethylene proton-proton distances, then the results in the bottom row of Table 2.11 are obtained, i.e., all interactions (<**„„» are approximately the same. It is apparent from Figure 2.14 that this is not the case. More recently Mirau et al. [68] have derived intermethylene proton-proton distances rHH directly from the NOESY spectra of 1:1 alternating S-MM. A comparison was made with the distances rHH of Table 2.11 after conformationally averaging according to the Koinuma et al. [67] RIS model. Reasonable agreement was obtained, as indicated by the following observed and (calculated) conformer populations: t, t = 0.58 + 0.05 (0.53), t,g + = 0.24 ± 0.05 (0.20), and g - , t = 0.18 ± 0.05 (0.27). In addition, it was found that an 11° displacement from
perfectly staggered rotational states produced rHH values in closest agreement with those obtained from NOESY cross peak intensities, adding further support to the Koinuma et al. [67] RIS model, which assumed 20° displacements. This ID NOESY 1 HNMR study of 1:1 alternating S-MM copolymer marked the first attempt to derive the conformational characteristics of a flexible polymer in solution through a direct measurement of conformationally averaged interproton distances.
2.5.2 ETHYLENE-VINYL ACETATE (E-VAc) COPOLYMERS Recently, a conformational description (RIS model) has been developed for ethylene-vinyl acetate (E-VAc) copolymers [69] by merging the RIS model descriptions of the constituent homopolymers [70, 71]. Unfortunately no measurements of microstructurally and conformationally sensitive properties have been reported for these copolymers. Traditional global measures of polymer conformation, such as mean-square end-to-end distances and dipole moments, are not yet available for E-VAc copolymers. However, the 1 3 CNMR spectra of a complete series of atactic E-VAc copolymers have been assigned [72-74]. Through comparison of ^ 13 C values calculated [28] via the y-gauche effect method to those previously observed and assigned in E-VAc 13 C NMR spectra, we may evaluate the ability of the RIS model derived for E-VAc copolymers to describe the microstructural sensitivity of the local copolymer conformation, thereby providing an alternate means for testing its validity. Wu and Ovenall [72,73] assigned the low field (22.6 MHz for 13C)13C NMR spectra of E-VAc copolymers by comparison with the 1 3 CNMR spectra recorded for the E-VAc model compounds presented below.
Later Sung and Noggle [74], employing higher field observations (62.9 MHz for 13C) and using paramagnetic shift reagents, corrected some of the earlier assignments made by Wu et al. [72,73]. Even so, they were not able conclusively to discriminate between the assignment of resonances belonging to the methine carbons in the mrmr, rrrr, and mrrm stereosequence pentads of atactic PVAc. We calculated [28] the S13Cs expected for the methylene and methine carbons in the complete series of E-VAc copolymers using ycc = — 3 ppm and 7c,o — — 5 ppm and the RIS model recently developed for these copolymers [69]. Figure 2.16 presents a schematic comparison of methine carbon 5 13 C values observed and calculated for E-VAc copolymers. A similar comparison of E-VAc methylene carbon <513C values is displayed in Figure 2.17. Whereas the chemical shifts calculated for the methine carbons in E-VAc copolymers only reflect differences in the numbers and kinds (ycc and yco) of magnetic shieldings produced by their microstructurally sensitive gauche arrangements with C and O y-substituents (see Figure 2.16), the methylene carbon chemical shifts (see Figure 2.17) reflect in addition different numbers of P-OAc substituents. Wu et al. [72, 73] found /J-OAc = + 5 ppm from their model compound studies, and this value was employed in the calculation of E-VAc methylene carbon chemical shifts. Note the close agreement between <513Cs observed and calculated for the backbone carbon nuclei in E-VAc copolymers. This provides strong support for the efficacy of the RIS model [69] recently developed for these copolymers. In addition, <513Cs calculated for the backbone carbon nuclei in atactic PVAc using
Observed
Calculated
Figure 2.16
Comparison of observed [74] and calculated [28] 13C chemical shifts for the methine carbons in E-VAc copolymers
Observed
Calculated
Figure 2.17
Comparison of observed [74] and calculated [28] 13C chemical shifts for the methylene carbons in E-VAc copolymers
the homopolymer RIS model [71] and the same y-gauche effects employed for E-VAc copolymers generally agree with those appearing in the observed spectrum [74]. This agreement permitted a conclusive assignment of those methine carbon resonances belonging to the mrmr, rrrr, and mrrm pentad stereosequences which Sung and Noggle [74] had been unable to assign unambiguously. In Chapter 3 Howarth et al. describe an extension of the approach employed above to actually derive the conformational descriptions (RIS models) of polymers by comparison of 13 C chemical shifts calculated via the y-gauche effect method with their observed 1 3 CNMR spectra, followed by iterative adjustment of the RIS models until they yield calculated <513Cs in agreement with observed values.
2.6 NMR OBSERVATION OF RIGID POLYMER CONFORMATIONS Although we have dealt exclusively with the analysis of polymer microstructures and conformations by comparison of chemical shifts (<513C, <519F) calculated via the y-gauche effect method and 1 H- 1 H distances, averaged over all conformations available to them, with their observed solution spectra, high resolution, solid state NMR observations can also probe rigidly fixed polymer conformations. It has been demonstrated [75,76] that the 13 C chemical shifts observed in CPMAS/DD 1 3 CNMR spectra of solid polymers are also sensitive to the local rigid conformations of their constituent chains. This has been demonstrated in several instances for crystalline polymers able to crystallize in two or more polymorphs which are distinguishable for the different conformations adopted by their polymer chains. As an example, syndiotactic polystyrene (s-PS) [76] can be crystallized in two conformationally distinct polymorphs, form I, with all-trans, planar zig-zag chains, and form II, where the chains adopt the helical... ttggttgg... conformation, very similar to that observed [77] in syndiotactic polypropylene (s-PP) crystals. CPMAS/DD 1 3 CNMR spectra of both s-PS polymorphs are shown in Figure 2.18. Note in the form II spectrum (b) that two methylene carbon resonances appear at 49.1 and 38.1 ppm (vs. TMS). As half the methylene carbons in form II s-PS are trans to both of their y-substituents(CH's), while the other half are gauche to both of theirs, it is not surprising that two methylene carbon resonances separated by » 2 x ycc (11 ppm) are observed. Identical behavior is observed [78] for s-PP, which also crystallizes in the ...ttggttgg... helical conformation. All the methylene carbons in the all-trans form I crystalline chains are trans to their y-substituents, consistent with the single CH2 resonance observed for this polymorph at 48.4 ppm, which is virtually coincident with that half of the methylene carbons in form II crystals (49.1 ppm) that are also not shielded by their y-substituents.
ppm 13
Figure 2.18 CPM AS/DD C NMR spectra [76] of form I (a) and form II (b) s-PS. The form II sample of (b) was obtained by absorption of dichloromethane into an amorphous, melt-quenched film of s-PS This and many other examples [75, 76, 78] clearly demonstrate the utility of high resolution NMR as a probe of polymer chain conformations as they occur in rigid, solid samples.
2.7 REFERENCES [1] R. Ditchfield, Nucl. Magn. Reson., 1976,5, 1. [2] P.V. Schastnev and A.A. Cheremisin, J. Struct. Chem., 1982, 23,440.
[3] D.B. Chesnut, in G. A. Webb (Ed.), Annual Reports on NMR Spectroscopy, Academic Press, New York, 1989, Vol. 21, p. 51. [4] M. Barfield and S.H. Yamamura, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 1990,112,4747. [5] H. Duddeck, in E.L. EHeI, S.H. Wilen and N.L. Allinger (Eds.) Topics in Stereochemistry, Wiley-Interscience, New York, 1986, Vol. 16, p. 219. [6] H. Spiesecke and W.G. Schneider, J. Chem. Phys., 1961,35, 722. [7] D.M. Grant and E.G. Paul, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 1964, 86, 2984. [8] L.P. Lindeman and J.W. Adams, Anal. Chem., 1971,43,1245. [9] D.E. Dorman, R.E. Carhart and J.D. Roberts, cited in Ref. [10]. [10] F.A. Bovey, in E.B. Mano (Ed.), Proceedings of the International Symposium on
[11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33]
Macromolecules, Rio de Janeiro, July 26-31,1974, Elsevier, New York, 1974, p. 169. F.C. Schilling and A.E. Tonelli, Macromolecules, 1980,13, 270. M. Moller, W. Ritter and H.-J. Cantow, Polym. Bull., 1981, 4, 609. A.E. Tonelli and F.C. Schilling, Ace. Chem. Res., 1981,14, 233. A.E. Tonelli, NMR Spectroscopy and Polymer Microstructure: The Conformationa Connection, VCH, New York, 1989. D.M. Grant and B.V. Cheney, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 1967,89, 5315. S. Li and D.B. Chesnut, Magn. Reson. Chem., 1985, 23,625. K. Seidman and G.E. Maciel, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 1977,99, 659. D.L. VanderHart, J. Magn. Reson., 1981,44,117. J.B. Stochers, Carbon-13 NMR Spectroscopy, Academic Press, New York, 1972, Chap. 3. J.L Kroschwitz, M. Winokur, HJ. Reid and J.D. Roberts, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 1969,91, 5927. CJ. Carman, A.R. Tarpley, Jr. and J.H. Goldstein, Macromolecules, 1973,6, 719. A.E. Tonelli, F.C. Schilling and F.A. Bovey, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 1984,106,1157. J.E. Mark, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 57, 2541. PJ. Flory, Statistical Mechanics of Chain Molecules, Wiley-Interscience, New York, 1969. H.L. Frisch, CL. Mallows and F.A. Bovey, J. Chem. Phys., 1966, 45, 1565. U.W. Suter and PJ. Flory, Macromolecules, 1975,8, 765. A.E. Tonelli, Macromolecules, 1978,11, 565,634; 1979,12, 255; 1985,18, 1086. E. Tart, G. Wood, D. Wernsman, U. Sangwatanaroj, C. Howe, Q. Zhou, S. Zhang and A.E. Tonelli, Macromolecules, 1993,26,4283. Y. Inoue, Y. Itabashi, R. Chujo and Y. Doi, Polymer, 1984; 25, 1640. V.A. Zakharov, G.P. Bukatov and Y.I. Yermakov, Adv. Polym. Sci., 1983,51, 61. R.D. Deanin, SPE J., 1967,23, 59. A.E. Tonelli and F.C. Schilling, Macromolecules, 1984,17,1946. D.L. Plazek and DJ. Plazek, Macromolecules, 1983,16,1469.
[34] J.E. Mark, J. Polym. Sci., Polym. Phys. Ed., 1973,11, 1375.
[35] [36] [37] [38] [39] [40] [41] [42] [43] [44] [45]
CC. Price and M. Osgun, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 1956,78, 4787. CC. Price, R. Spectro and A. Tunolo, J. Polym. ScL, Part A-I, 1967, 5,407. K.C. Ramey and N.D. Field, Polym. Lett., 1964, 2, 461. H. Tani, N. Oguni and S. Watanabe, Polym. Lett., 1968,6, 577. T. Hirano, P.H. Khanh and T. Tsurata, Makromoi Chem., 1972,153, 331. N. Oguni, S. Maeda and H. Tani, Macromolecules, 1973, 6,459. N. Oguni, S. Watanabe, M. Maki and H. Tani, Macromolecules, 1973,6, 195. M.D. Bruch, F.A. Bovey, R.E. Cais and J.H. Noggle, Macromolecules, 1985,18,1253. J. Schaefer, Macromolecules, 1969, 2, 533. N. Oguni, K. Lee and H. Tani, Macromolecules, 1972, 5, 819. N. Oguni, S. Shinohara and K. Lee, Polym. J. (Tokyo), 1979,11, 755.
[46] [47] [48] [49] [50] [51] [52] [53] [54] [55] [56] [57] [58] [59] [60] [61] [62] [63] [64] [65] [66] [67] [68] [69] [70] [71] [72] [73] [74] [75] [76] [77] [78]
W. Lapeyre, H. Cheradame, N. Spassky and P. Sigwalt, J. Chim. Phys., 1973,70,838. T. Uryu, H. Shimazu and K. Matsuzuki, Polym. Lett., 1973,11, 275. F C Schilling and A.E. Tonelli, Macromolecules, 1986,19,1337. A.E. Derome, Modern NMR Techniques for Chemistry Research, Pergamon, New York, 1987, Chap. 4. A. Abe, T. Hirano and T. Tsurata, Macromolecules, 1979,12,1092. CJ. Turner, Prog. Nucl. Magn. Reson. Spectrosc, 1984,16, 27. F.C. Schilling, J. Magn. Reson., 1982,47, 61. A.E. Tonelli, F.C. Schilling and R.E. Cais, Macromolecules, 1981,14, 560. A.E. Tonelli, F.C. Schilling and R.E. Cais, Macromolecules, 1982,15, 849. CW. Wilson, III, J. Polyn. ScL, Part AA, 1963,1305. CW. Wilson, III and E.R. Santee, Jr., J. Polym. ScL, Part C, 1965,8,97. R.C. Ferguson and E.G. Brame, Jr., J. Phys. Chem., 1979,83,1397. A. Bax, Two-Dimensional Nuclear Magnetic Resonance in Liquids, Delft University Press, Delft, Reidel, Amsterdam, 1982. K. Wuthrich, NMR of Proteins and Nucleic Acids, Wiley, New York, 1986. A. Bax and L. Lerner, Science, 1986, 232,1960. F.A. Bovey and P.A. Mirau, Ace. Chem. Res., 1988, 21, 37. S.A. Heffner, F.A. Bovey, L.A. Verge, P.A. Mirau and A.E. Tonelli, Macromolecules, 1986,19,1628. D.Y. Yoon, P.R. Sundarajan and PJ. FLory, Macromolecules, 1975,8, 776. D.Y. Yoon, U.W. Suter, P.R. Sundarajan and PJ. Flory, Macromolecules, 1975,8, 784. P.R. Sundararajan and PJ. Flory, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 1974,96, 5025. P.R. Sundararajan and PJ. Flory, J. Polym. ScL, Polym. Lett. Ed., 1977,15, 699. H. Koinuma, T. Tanabe and H. Hirai, Makromol. Chem., 1980,181, 383. P.A. Mirau, F.A. Bovey, A.E. Tonelli and S.A. Heffner, Macromolecules, 1987, 20, 1701. T.D. Rathke, M.W. Frey, D. Guthrie, R. Graham, W. Simendinger, B.-C. Wang, T. Shepard, R. Jones and A.E. Tonelli, Comp. Polym. ScL, 1993,3,61 A. Abe, R.L. Jernigan and PJ. Flory, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 1966,88,631. P.R. Sundararajan, Macromolecules, 1978,11, 256. T.K. Wu, J. Polym. ScL, Part A-2,1970,8,167. T.K. Wu and D.W. Ovenall, Macromolecules, 1974,7,776. H.N. Sung and J.H. Noggle, J. Polym. ScL, Polym. Phys. Ed., 1981,19,1593. See Chapter 11 in Ref. [14] and references cited there. M.A. Gomez and A.E. Tonelli, Macromolecules, 1990, 23, 3385; 1991,24, 3533. G. Natta, I. Pasquon, P. Corradini, M. Peraldo, M. Pegoraro and A. Zambelli, Atti Accad. Naz. Lincei, Cl. ScL Fis., Mat. Nat., Rend., 1960,28, 539. A. Bunn, E.A. Cudby, R.K. Harris, KJ. Packer and B. Say, J. Chem. Soc, Chem. Commun., 1981,15.
3 'MODEL-FREE' RIS STATISTICAL WEIGHT PARAMETERS FROM 13 C NMR DATA O. W. HOWARTH, R. N. IBBETT, L R. HERBERT and M. A. WHISKENS Centre for Nuclear Magnetic Resonance, Department of Chemistry, University of Warwick, Coventry CV4 IAL, UK
3.1 INTRODUCTION This chapter describes some new attempts to exploit the rich source of conformational data that is potentially available from the dependence of 13C NMR shifts upon the local tactic sequence in a substituted carbon-based polymer. The main link between shift and conformation is the gamma-gauc/ie effect. This is widely used in the interpretation of 13C chemical shifts in many types of compound. It was initially identified from the classic work by Dalling and Grant [1], and by others [2], on the 13C shifts of hydrocarbons, and especially of methylcyclohexanes, in which specific local conformations could be frozen out by either chemical or physical means. If a molecule contains any partial carbon chain C1-C2-C3-C4, and if Cl and C4 are mutually y-gauche, thus making the C1,2-C3,4 dihedral angle approximately ± 60°, then both C1 and C4 experience an additional shielding, i.e. lowering of <5C, of %5ppm (see Figure 3.1). Similar shifts are observed when CA is replaced by a wide range of groups [3]. The shift effects of different groups do not vary in any obvious way with polarity. Indeed, the shifts that arise from, e.g., hydroxyl substituents may be somewhat smaller than average. However, they do seem to bear some relationship to the bulk of the substituent, and indeed they are often interpreted in terms of steric compression. Various more serious attempts have been made to explain the y-gauche effect by MO computations. The most recent are those of Barfield and Yamamura [4], using an ab initio method with a double-C basis set. Although this level of computation is a little less than that required to give the best available absolute shieldings, it reproduces very adequately a wide range of steric shifts in hydrocarbons (i.e. those dependent solely upon variations in stereochemistry) and also Polymer Spectroscopy. Edited by Allan H. Fawcett © 1996 John Wiley & Sons Ltd
Y - gauche interaction (two of the four present) syn - axial interaction
"P - gaucheT shifts possible at these atoms, because of the A C y - gauche interaction
Figure 3.1 Illustration of stereochemical relationships. In this rotational state, A and B are both y-gauche to the next-nearest non-methylene carbon, and the two A groups are syn-axial to each other, as are the two B groups supports the intuitive assumption that y-gauche contributions to the shift of a given carbon from more than one source are additive. It also draws attention to several other potential steric contributions to carbon shifts, including those that arise from quite modest deviations from dihedral angles of ± 60°. These will be discussed in a later section. Shifts that arise from the y-gauche relationship may be readily computed for polymers, provided that the appropriate RIS (rotational isomeric state) probability parameters [5] are known from calculations of the potential energy surface of the macromolecule. The basic procedure is to start with an estimate, e.g. from molecular modelling calculations, of the free energies and bond angles of the various energy minima found upon rotation of the two (usually) C—C bonds in both the meso (m) and the racemic (r) dyad units of the polymer chain. Neighbouring dyads are then permitted to alter these free energies through the steric restrictions, such as the 1,5 pentane effect, that must apply to the dyad joins. Although these effects extend in theory to an infinite succession of next-neighbours, the calculated sequence dependence of shifts is usually small beyond the heptad/hexad level, at most. Thus one obtains an estimate of the true probabilities for occupation of any dyad in any steric sequence. It is then simple to explore the effects of conformation upon the observed chemical shifts, using, e.g., the y-gauche shift model. Such calculations are described in detail by Tonelli in Chapter 2. They work spectacularly well for polypropylene, with a model having five rotameric states per chain bond. However, Tonelli has pointed out additional factors that must be included when other polymers are considered. One is that the methylene shifts in,
e.g., monohalo vinyl polymers, unlike the methine shifts, show some dependence upon solvent [6]. Another is that no conceivable RIS parameters can explain the rather large steric shifts that distinguish isotactic from syndiotactic poly(methyl methacrylate), either in the solution state or, even more so, in the solid state [T]. These can be up to lOppm in magnitude. A further conceptual challenge arises intuitively. It is reasonable that the shifts at a given sidechain carbon should depend not only upon the proximity of y-gauche atoms, but also upon the identity of the atom or group which will necessarily be syn-axial to it, i.e. its even closer neighbour, in any vinyl polymer. This relationship is illustrated in Figure 3.1. There is also a practical consideration. RIS parameters are not at all easy to calculate in many cases, particularly for disubstituted vinyl polymers. In vinyl polymers with main chain methine groups, a few of the dyad rotamers will often have lower energies than the others, because they place both of the methine protons approximately syn-axial to some other group or chain portion, and thus minimise steric repulsions. However, this is not possible in disubstituted polymers, and indeed even the gauche and trans RIS states themselves are likely to offer poor approximations to the real bond torsional angles. There is also some concern that the contributions of minor conformers may be underestimated if the model assumes unrealistically rigid elements. Furthermore, some polymers have shift patterns for every carbon that depend noticeably upon solvent. Such variations lie beyond the reach of conventional RIS calculations, although they must obviously bear witness to interesting conformational changes caused by the influence of the solvent on the potential energy surface of the macromolecule. The present work is an attempt to address the above challenges by turning the methodology around. Might it prove possible to obtain reasonable RIS statistical weight parameters, of use to other modellers, by treating the carbon shifts as given data and the RIS parameters as variables? Complete sets of such sequencedependent shifts have been fairly reliably assigned at the tetrad/pentad level for many mono- and disubstituted vinyl polymers, and in some cases the spin-spin coupling constants are also available as further constraints on any model. The obvious attraction of this approach is that the RIS variables may be overdetermined. Suppose that one allows only three rotameric states per chain bond, and treats any possible sidechain rotamers as having a constant average contribution. Even if the probability of each dyad rotamer is allowed to vary independently, after due regard for symmetry, there are only 10 undetermined probability ratios in a vinyl polymer. (Note that the ratio of the m- to the r-dyad probabilities is not significant in the present context). To these 10 must be added a single variable, such as the g*g*/g~g~ elements of Flory's Un, matrix [8], which controls the extent by which 1,5 syn-axial chain segments are forbidden. This extent may not be 100% after allowance for minor distortions of the intervening torsional angles, especially when the substituent groups are small, and even more so if they are capable of favourable interactions such as hydrogen bonding. To determine these
11 variables we typically have some 16-30 different steric shifts, or even more if the assignment can be made at the hexad/heptad level. Thus the quality as well as the existence of any shift fit might be used to assess the reliability of the calculation.
3.2 METHODS The first problem that arises with this approach is that the y-gauche contributions from many groups are not known accurately. Some may be estimated from the shifts of molecules is known conformations, e.g. substituted cyclohexanes, but others remain to be established. An underlying principle of the present study is that all such parameters be fixed for a given group, even if it appears in several different polymers. Another principle is that all the carbon resonance patterns of a given polymer must be fitted simultaneously. Indeed, as a further simplification, we specify that the shift effects depend only on the substituent, and not on the type of carbon (e.g. C, CH, CH 2 , CH 3 , CO, CN) under observation. Fortunately, the numerical value of most shift parameters does not in practice greatly affect the resulting RIS weightings, within a reasonable range. It is the shift patterns which dominate the calculation. The second problem is to meet the challenge of polymers such as poly(methyl methacrylate), which fit poorly to any scheme based simply on y-gauche contributions to the methyl shift. Our proposal is that, for such groups, the y-gauche contributions should be subdivided into three separate syn-axial contributions from the appropriate groups S to the carbon under observation. Thus, an a-methyl group in poly(methyl methacrylate) may be y-gauche to the next-nearest unprotonated carbon, but then it must also be sjw-axial either to another a-methyl or to a carboxymethyl group or to the chain methylene in the next dyad. These three will not necessarily cause the same shielding at the original methyl, although their average shielding effect should not very greatly from a typical value of, say, 5 ppm. One should note in this context that a hydrogen atom may be an active substituent, because the shifting unit is in fact both the syn-axial H and also the gauche C, even though we refer to the shielding parameter for brevity as being simply 'syn-axiaF. Indeed, one may not even assume that H necessarily imposes a smaller 'syn-axiaF shielding than any other group. We show below that this model is capable of allowing surprisingly large methyl shifts. The next problem arises from Tonelli's observation that some methylene shifts depend noticeably upon solvent. If these changes are not matched by corresponding changes in other shift patterns, then they cannot be explained by RIS weightings alone. Tonelli and Schilling have suggested [6] that they may arise from differential solvation of m- and r-dyads, which should affect methylene shifts much more that others. We accept this suggestion by creating one more adjustable parameter, a variable, solvent-induced shift difference between m- and
r-methylenes. In most cases this turns out to be small, but even so it turns out in general to give noticeably improved fits. Finally, one must decide on the size of the RIS dyad matrices. In this respect, the present work is not altogether 'model-free'. The main problem is that each gauche state, and perhaps also the trans state, probably exists with two variants [5], so as to ease the concomitant syw-axial repulsions. In cases where detailed calculations have been made [9], these variants typically shift the chain dihedral angle from ± 60° to ± 50° and to ± 70°, with unequal weightings and with a very low or non-existent intervening energy barrier. It would probably be ideal to use a generalised 6 x 6 state model in order to allow for this. However, this would generate an unacceptable number of variables. Instead, we have chosen a simple 3 x 3 state model. This implies the assumption that the probabilities of each nearby pair of rotational states may reasonably be represented by their sum, and thus that the shift contributions from each state are comparable. Barfield and Yamamura [4] have indeed shown that the y-gauche effect varies monotonically with dihedral angle in an approximately sinusoidal manner, so that the shift contributions from the ±50° and from the ±70° angles should be not too different. Although the resulting, simplified RIS parameters will be more artificial, they should retain their usefulness for most calculations simply because of their derivation from experimental data.
3.3 SOMECALCULATIONDETAILS A spreadsheet calculation (using Microsoft Excel version 3.0) was written to convert the 3 x 3 m- and dyad probability matrices into predicted steric shifts, by the usual methods of matrix multiplication, to find overall conformational probabilities. Although the final calculations were only carried out at the tetrad/pentad level, the calculations assumed further, flanking m-dyads in each case in order to give more realistic weightings. The linking U i r matrix was assumed to have one freely variable component, g*g+/g~g~, with the other elements being fixed at unity. This has the effect of permitting all dyad joins equally, except for those which result in syw-axial chain segments. The latter are suppressed in proportion to the variable component. In fact, none of the fitted values of g*g+/g~g~ exceeds the necessary bounds of zero to approximately unity. As described above, a further shift variable was then introduced, to give the same shift increment to each r-methylene resonance. These increments were never large, and typically were less than ±0.4ppm. The resulting shift patterns were compared with the experimental data, which are described in detail below, and the squared shift differences were summed. In some cases one resonance of a polymer shows little spread of shifts, and so cannot be reliably assigned, and here the calculated shifts were constrained within limits set by the overall
linewidth of the data, without regard to their detailed assignment. Such data are represented in the appropriate figures by single, broad Lorentzian peaks. The sums of squared differences were then minimized with respect to the above variables. Minimisation was carried out by the Newton-Raphson method using Microsoft Solver version 3.0. It was almost invariably well-behaved, and for each polymer it converged to give essentially the same results from a wide range of starting parameters. Various calculational refinements were also tested in the hope of improved fits, but, interestingly, they had little extra success. These included attempts to reduce the g~g+/g*g~ elements in U n , to values below unity. This gave good results only with polystyrene. The calculations also permit an estimate of the reliability of individual parameters. In some cases, the data closely defined all the parameters. In others, a few parameters, noted below, rose to unreasonably high values in the final fits, such as y-gauche shifts > lOppm. However, these could be reduced in all cases to reasonable values without a loss of fitting accuracy greater than the experimental errors of shift measurement. The RIS elements were not permitted to become negative. Apart from this, the calculations were deliberately kept as simple as possible, because of the aim of practical usefulness to modellers.
3.4 INDIVIDUALPOLYMERS The method was first tested on polypropylene, because the shifts for this polymer are reliably known as is its accessibility to shift calculations. Furthermore, both the methyl and the chain methylene groups have been shown to give (and receive) y-gauche shifts of close to —5.0 ppm [9]. This usefully reduced the number of variables in the calculation, though in fact little change was observed even if they were allowed to float. The resulting fits, using our simplified 3 x 3 RIS approximation, were not quite as good as those obtained by Schilling and Tonelli [9], especially in that they slightly underestimated the shift contributions from the more distant chain groups. However, the fit was still very good, as is shown in Table 3.1. The syn-axial shift from H was initially permitted to float, but in a variety of calculations it always came close to —4.0 ppm, and so it was fixed thereafter at this value. The next polymer to be tested was poly(acrylonitrile), which is readily available with minor known variations of tacticity within the approximately atactic range. Full shift data for this have not been published and are therefore presented in Table 3.2, using both dimethyl sulphoxide-d6 (DMSO) and waterd 2 /Na + [SCN] " solvents. Our assignment, based on integration rather than peak height and using several minor variations in tacticity, reverses a previous assignment [10] for the CN mrrm and rrrr resonances. The differential effects of distant groups are small and so the assignments are straightforward, except for the unresolvable methylene resonances. Each set of RIS calculations led to a CN
Table 3.1
Relative
13
C shifts in polypropylene
CH^ mmmm mmmr rmmr mmrm rmrm mmrr rmrr mrrm mrrr rrrr
CH^ 0
obs.
calc.
1.99 1.73 1.46 1.10 0.81 1.27 0.96 0 0.27 0.49
1.94 1.72 1.50 1.10 0.84 1.25 1.00 0 0.23 0.43
mmm mmr rmr mrm mrr rr
CH
obs.
calc.
0.79 1.35 2.07 0 0.88 1.81
0.81 1.37 2.03 0 0.93 1.81
mmmm mmmr rmmr mmrm rmrm mrnrr rmrr mrrrn mrrr rrrr
obs.
calc.
0.50 0.45 0.40 0.17 0.14 0.28 0.23 0 0.04 0.08
0.51 0.51 0.51 0.22 0.23 0.25 0.26 0 0.03 0.05
'y-gauche/d sjw-axial parameters: CH 2 , CH 3 - 5.0ppm, (C)H -4.0ppm. RMS error 0.039 ppm.
Table 3.2
Observed
13
C shifts/ppm for poly(acrylonitrile)
CN mmmm mmmr nnmr mmrm rmrm mmrr rmrr mrrm mrrr rrrr
cii
DMSO
water/NaSCN
119.73 119.66 119.59 119.36° 119.29 119.45 119.36 119.00° 119.09° 119.18
122.8 122.7 122.5 122.4 122.3 122.5 122.4 122.0 122.1 122.2
DMSO mm mr rr
26.50 27.04 27.47
water/NaSCN 29.40 29.77 29.85
CH 2 «32.6 «34.3 both almost unresolved
"Some further fine structure is visible.
and syn-axial S shift parameter of —2.84 ppm. The fits are fairly good, although they underrepresent the fine structure in the CN region. The favoured conformations are in reasonable agreement with those deduced by Ganster and Lochmann [11] for 2,4-dicyanopentane in vacuo. Similar calculations were then performed for poly(vinyl alcohol). They are shown as sticks, below the aqueous spectrum, in Figure 3.2. Here the sample is complicated by incomplete removal of acetate groups. However, the removal was >90%, and so the dominant peaks in the spectrum are those of fully hydrolysed regions. The effects of distant groups were once again small. The assignments in DMSO are published [12]: those in water were assigned largely by analogy, although the methylene data were sufficiently different to require some confirmation via homo- and heteronuclear shift correlation experiments. The calculated
CH
CH2
Figure 3.2 100.6MHz 13C(1H) NMR spectrum of poly(vinyl alcohol); CH and CH2 regions. Calculated shifts (with atactic weightings) are shown as sticks below, in the same order of assignment
RIS parameters (Table 3.3) show that H-bonding, even in water, is sufficient to overcome some of the steric repulsions, including those associated with the 1,5 pentane effect, between 5yw-axial chain segments. One possible flaw in the poly(vinyl alcohol) calculations is that the shifts might also be directly and differentially affected by H-bonding. However, an independent study of saccharides in water and in DMSO indicates that this is probably not so. Another interesting feature is that, when the rotamers that were calculated to be dominant were reset to be totally dominant, then the CH shift pattern was
Table 3.3 T polypropylene m-dyad r-dyad poly(acrylonitrile) in DMSO m-dyad r-dyad poly(acrylonitrile) in water m-dyad/NaSCN r-dyad poly(vinyl alcohol) in water m-dyad r-dyad poly(vinyl alcohol) in DMSO m-dyad r-dyad polystyrene m-dyad r-dyad poly(methylacrylonitrile) m-dyad r-dyad poly(methyl methacrylate) m-dyad r-dyad poly(vinyl chloride) m-dyad r-dyad a
Calculated RIS statistical weight parameters"
*v
tg'lg't
tg+fg+t
0
0 0
1 0
0 0.08
0 0
0 0.94
0.08
0 0
1 0
0 0.41
1.79 0.51
0 1.04
0 1
0 0
1 0
0 0.12
0.65 0.51
0 0.96
0.40
-0.01
1 0.22
0 1
0 0
0.40 1.55
0 0
7.51 0.93
0.78
+ 0.32
0 1
0 0
0.69 2.71
0 0
0.23 0
0.75
-0.06
0.18 0
0 0
1 0
0.01 0
0 0
0 2.91
0*
-0.77
0.01
1 0
0.28 0.36
0.39 1.26
0 0
0 0
0.07
-0.22
0.31 0
0 0
-0.19
0.35
0 0
0.00
0.02 0.41 0
1 0
0.37 0.16
0 0
0 0.87
0.00
+ 1.12
9 9
<5(CH2)/ppm
391K 0.22
+ 0.07
373 K 0.41
+ 0.20
300K
295 K
295 K
363 K
363 K
300K 1.01 393 K 0.04 1
g* and g defined as in Flory [5]. g~g+/g+g~ links across the chiral carbons were also completely forbidden in this case.
b
g g+/g+g
tt
essentially magnified by a factor of « 3 . It then fitted quite well with the solid-state data of Terao et al. [13], who obtain a CH shift spread of « 1 0 ppm. Tonelli (Chapter 2) has interpreted solid-state polypropylene shifts in a similar way, based on structures deduced by Bunn et al. [14]. Poly(acrylonrtrile) in DMSO
Poly(acrylonitrile) in water/NaSCN
Poly(vinyl alcohol) in water
Poly(vlnyl alcohol) In DMSO
Figure 3 3 {Continued)
Polypropylene
Polystyrene
Poly(methyiacrylonrtrlle)
Poly(methyl methacrylate)
Figure 3.3 (a),(b) Upper traces: 13 C( 1 H) NMR spectra for eight different polymer solutions, calculated at the tetrad/pentad level. Lower traces: observed shifts, simplified to the same level, and further, to broad Lorentzian peaks of representative width, if overlaps prevent assignment. The numbers are shifts in ppm
The shift parameter for OH did not converge well, however, perhaps because of the unusual number of accessible conformations and the presence of only two types of carbon atom. Values ranging from O to — 5ppm gave acceptable predictions of the observed shifts. To resolve this problem, we instead used an independent and strongly convergent value of — 3.5 ppm, obtained from an extensive study of hexopyranose sugars of known conformation in both water and DMSO [15]. This value is lower than that for H, which may help to explain the otherwise curious observations by Stothers and coworkers [16, 17] on s>w-axial shifts in sterols and related compounds. The other monosubstituted vinyl polymer to be studied in detail was polystyrene. Its spectrum is made complex in the methylene region by large shift influences at the hexad/heptad level. These probably arise from the anisotropic bulk of the phenyl rings. Our calculations are certainly naive in ignoring this anisotropy. The methylene region may speculatively be divided into four broad subsections, approximate assignments of which were checked by the classical area method. Our assignments confirm those of Sato etal. [18]. The unprotonated phenyl carbon shifts are more easily assigned by the same method. The shift calculations were only successful if all gg links across the chiral carbons were fully disallowed. They then gave a broadly reasonable but less than perfect fit. Although this restrictive possibility was also investigated for other polymers, it only gave useful results in this case. The phenyl shift constant converged well, to —4.58 ppm. The next polymer, poly(methylacrylonitrile), presented a more severe test in that there were no remaining variable shift parameters, and also one further resonance region to be fitted. An initial assignment was made following Inoue et al. [19], but with a spectrum taken at higher frequency, and with the methylene sub-areas rechecked. The fit is encouraging although not perfect. Finally, it proved possible to obtain an acceptable fit for poly(methyl methacrylate) using a carbomethoxy shift parameter of —9.50 ppm. This shift was not very well defined by the data, although it must certainly be large. (When it was permitted to float freely in the minimisation, it drifted upward to ^ — 14 ppm, but with only a very minor resulting improvement in the least-squares fit.) If the conformations that we calculate to have highest probability are instead set to be dominant, then the syndiotactic chain becomes all-trans, as observed in the solid state by Speracek et al. [20], and a 4-8.14 ppm shift increment is predicted on going from the syndiotactic to the isotactic polymer. The experimental figure is between + 6.0 and + 8.45 ppm. The fits are all presented in diagrammatic form in Figure 3.3(a) and (b). Calculated relative shifts are plotted upright, with a standard Lorentzian lineshape and with intensities that assume a strictly atactic sample. The vertically inverted plots are idealisations of the experimental spectra. Broad Lorentzian bands are used to depict the extent of any overlapped and hence unassigned resonances. The order of assignment of the resolved peaks, calculated and
observed, is the same in every case expect for the fine structure in the COOMe and CH 3 (mr) resonances of poly(methyl methacrylate). The same fits could not be approximated for any of the polymers by any alternative and significantly different set of minimised RIS parameters. Fits (not shown) have also been successfully generated for poly(vinyl chloride). In this case the experimental steric shifts for both carbon types varied by % 2 ppm. The worst methylene fitting error was 0.11 ppm. The Cl shift parameter minimised to —4.01 ppm, and the mmethylene shift factor was unusually large, at 1.12 ppm.
3-5 THE CALCULATED RIS PARAMETERS The complete set of calculated RIS parameters is presented in Table 3.3, and some of the conformations that are calculated to be dominant are depicted in Figure 3.4. Those for polypropylene confirm the simple predictions that the dominant conformations are the four where no carbon is syn-axial to any other carbon, and that the methylene groups have a very similar bulk to the methyls. However, those for poly(acrylonitrile) deviate markedly from this. Although it remains true that the CN groups, like the methyls in polypropylene, resist being mutually syw-axial, this may be seen from simple modelling to result from unfavourable dipolar alignment rather than from steric interactions. Also, the possibility exists that some other mutual orientations of CN groups may be sufficiently favoured, for the same reason, to override concomitant but less favourable steric interactions, e.g. between CN and the chain methylenes. Such dipolar interactions are very hard to model independently because of the difficulty of defining the local dielectric medium. It is interesting to note that, in the unusually polar solvent D 2 O/Na + [SCN]", the RIS term tt(m) is decreased yet further with respect to that in DMSO solvent. This term involves syw-axial CN groups. Evidently their polar repulsion is increased by the very polar solvent, perhaps because the cations polarise the CN groups further while being sterically unable to interpose themselves. The opposite behaviour is evident in poly(vinyl alcohol). The m-dyad shows a marked preference for the tt and g~g~ conformations (see Figure 3.4) over the more normal tg* and g+t. The tt and g~g" conformations both involve closeness of the OH groups, created presumably by H-bonding, and sufficient to overcome steric repulsions in the latter case. The same pattern holds for the r-dyad. The tg ~ and g~ t conformations are now the ones with syn-axial hydroxyls, and these are again favoured along with the unexpected g~g~ conformer, possibly in a rather distorted form so as to permit another H-bond. The only big effect of changing the solvent from DMSO to water is a large increase in the g+g+(m) term. Perhaps water is able to enhance the intramolecular H-bonding that is sterically possible from this conformation.
poly(acrylonitrile) r-diad, tt rotamer
poly(acrylonitrile) m-diad, tg* rotamer
poly(vinyl alcohol) m-diad. tt rotamer
poly(vinyl alcohol) r-diad, tg rotamer
poly(acrylonitrile)
poly(methyl methacrylate)
m-diad. gg* rotamer
m-diad. tt rotamer
Figure 3.4 Some typical dominant dyad conformations
The calculations for polystyrene are discussed above, and should be regarded with caution. They do, however, yield sensible RIS parameters, which are like those for polypropylene, except for larger repulsions between phenyl and H than between methyl and H. In contrast, poly(vinyl chloride) is intermediate between polystyrene and polypropylene, although in this case a tendency is also evident for neighbouring C-Cl bonds to lie approximately antiparallel, perhaps for dipolar reasons.
The parameters for poly(methylacrylonitrile) are less easy to anticipate, because most conformations will involve either steric or dipolar repulsions. The most likely conformations will be g+f(m), tg+(m), tt(r) and g+g+(r), because these alone allow the CN groups to lie syw-axial to other groups, and not to themselves. The CN group has less steric bulk than, say, methyl. The calculations bear out this prediction, although they do to some extent also permit one conformer, g ~g ~(m), in which neighbouring CN groups are syn-axial. Not surprisingly, for the reasons discussed above, the fit for poly(methyl methacrylate) has the biggest error sum of the present series. Nevertheless, the fit is acceptable given the approximations, which in this case include ignoring the carboxymethyl orientations. Once again, there is a preference for the four conformers as above, because the carboxymethyl group also has a low steric bulk in some orientations. However, the fit also shows a marginal preference for the tt state in the m dyad, consistently with the solid-state data noted above [20]. This will no doubt be made possible by a favourable mutual orientation of the carbonyl dipoles.
3.6
'P-GAUCHE9EFFECTS
The experimental evidence for y-gauche shifts [3] may also point to concomitant shifts of the two carbons that connect the y-gauche groups, as marked in Figure 3.1. These 'fi-gauche' shifts seem to be of the same sign as the y-gauche ones, but of approximately half the magnitude. Unfortunately, because they are smaller, they are less easy to quantify. We have experimented with the inclusion of ft-gauche shifts in our model, with values half those for the corresponding y-gauche shifts. They do not affect the qualitative conclusions above for any polymer, and the fits are generally a little less satisfactory in each case. Thus, although such shifts probably do occur, it is not necessary to include them at the present level of approximation.
3.7 COUPLING CONSTANTS In principle, it is also possible to use interpf oton coupling data in monovinyl polymers to assess the conformational equilibria. For such calculations one needs not only the weightings for the conformations but also their torsional angles, and a reasonable estimate of the appropriate Karplus relationship [21] between the HCCH dihedral angle and the corresponding coupling. In practice, it is not easy to separate the peak splittings due to couplings from those arising from tacticity. In some cases, and for some components, the separation can be achieved by a 2D ./-resolved spectrum [22]. In favourable case this procedure may also provide an assignment, because the methylene protons in an r-dyad will be at least approxi-
CH
CH2
ppm 1
Figure 3.5 Partial 2D ./-resolved H NMR spectrum of poly(acrylonitrile) in DMSOd6. The multiplets are effectively rotated into the vertical dimension. The large peak at 3.06 ppm arises from water, and the uneven ridge marked x is partly an artefact
Table 3.4 Coupling constants 3 polypropylene J(obs)/Hz 7.0 and 6.5 (m) 3 J(calc)/Hz 7.34 and 7.25 (m) 3 poly(acrylonitrile) in DMSO J(obs)/Hz 8.4 and 6.0 (m) V(calc)/Hz 8.16 and 5.85 (m)
7.0 (r) 7.13 (r) 7.5 (r) 7.32 (r)
mately isochronic. Figure 3.5 shows an example of such data for poly(acrylonitrile) in DMSO. The couplings are compared with calculated values in Table 3.4, along with those for polypropylene, which have been deduced from the spectra of oligomers. However, the calculated values are not very sensitive to conformation, and their absolute values depend on what allowance one makes for libration within each RI state when setting the t and g couplings for individual vicinal proton pairs. The present study uses 12.0 Hz (t) and 2.0 Hz (#, polypropylene) or 4.0Hz (g, poly(acrylonitrile)).
3.8 CHARACTERISTICRATIOS One may in principle check RIS calculations [5] by the measurement of characteristic ratios 0 /n/ 2 , particularly as a function of tacticity. However, such correlations present several problems. The published experimental data are limited in extent and show significant scatter. Also, the calculations require a good estimate of the chain torsion angles in each conformer. Nevertheless, some comparisons are possible, because in vacuo modelling calculations are likely to give reasonably accurate torsion angles even when their predictions of energy are suspect. We have used our RIS data together with published torsion angles to calculate the characteristic ratios for polypropylene at various temperatures in the solution state. Table 3.5 shows that they agree well with the experimental data [23]. Earlier calculations tended to fit poorly at the extremes of tacticity, perhaps because they underestimated the contribution of minor conformations. The calculations were performed using the Biosym RIS package, with a 200-unit chain and randomised tacticity.
Table 3.5 syndiotactic atactic isotactic
Characteristic ratios for polypropylene
Calculated ratio
Observed ratio
Earlier estimates
7.6(320K) 5.4(435K) 6.3(305K) 5.3 (420 K) 5.4(400K)
6.7(318K) 5.4(426K) 6.5(307K) 5.0(456 K) 5.9(398K)
11.0(413K) 5.5(415K) 4.2 (413 K)
syndiotactic
atactic
isotactic
Figure 3.6 Observed (squares) and calculated (lines) characteristic ratios for poly(methyl methacrylate) at 333 K, plotted as a function of tacticity. The lines are based on RI states with chain dihedral angles of (upper line) 10,20,100,115, - 1 0 0 and -115°, (central, broken line) 10,20,100,125, - 1 0 0 and -125°, (lower, hatched line) 15,20,100,110, - 1 0 0 and-110°
Calculations were also performed for poly(methyl methacrylate). These were more complex, because modelling shows each RI state to be markedly doubled because of syw-axial interactions. Also, the calculated torsion angles were less reliable than above. We approached this problem by dividing each RI state into torsionally close pairs in the calculation, and assuming equal probabilities for each member of a pair. In particular, this permitted some twist in a chain dominated by tt states. Calculations are presented in Figure 3.6 for three reasonable choices of torsional angle sets. The comparison with experiment [24] is encouraging. However, characteristic ratios alone are not a sensitive test of RIS weightings, for many combinations of weightings will give similar results.
3,9 CONCLUSIONS Although there is no guarantee that our simple model will be capable of predicting the shifts observed for any given polymer, the present fits are encouraging. They were undertaken, in part, to assess the validity of the y-gauche shift model. It is likely that ab initio calculations will soon be able to refine this model. Indeed, the work of Barfield and Yamamura [4] suggests that unusual shifts may arise in rather specific conformations over a narrow range of torsion angles. These may help to explain the rather unexpected shifts sometimes observed in the solid state, but they are less likely to be a problem in the more widely averaged local environments of the fluid state. One may therefore
reasonably propose that the present model generates relative RIS parameters for the fluid state that are of genuine predictive value.
3.10 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT We thank Dr. CJ. Samuel for many helpful discussions.
3.11 REFERENCES [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24]
D. Dalling and D.M. Grant, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 1967,89, 6612. D.M. Grant and B.V. Cheyney, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 1967,89,5315. H.-J. Schneider and V. Hoppen, J. Org. Chem., 1978,43, 3866. M. Barfield and S.H. Yamamura, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 1990,112,4747. PJ. Flory, Macromolecules, 1974, 7, 381. A.E. Tonelli and F.C. Schilling, Ace Chem. Res., 1981,14, 235. A.E. Tonelli, Macromolecules, 1991, 24, 3065. PJ. Flory, P.R. Sundararajan and L.C. DeBoIt, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 1974,96, 5015. F.C. Schilling and A.E. Tonelli, Macromolecules, 1980,13, 270. J. Schaefer, Macromolecules, 1971,4,105. J. Ganster and J.R. Lochmann, Polymer, 1990,31,1159. T.K. Wu and M.L. Sheer, Macromolecules, 1977,10, 529. T. Terao, S. Maeda and A. Saika, Macromolecules, 1983,16,1535. A. Bunn, E.A. Cudby, R.K. Harris, KJ. Packer and BJ. Say, J. Chem. Soc,Chem. Commun., 1981,15. P. Hobley and O.W. Howarth, to be published. W.A. Ayer, L.M. Browne, S. Fung and J.B. Stothers, Can. J. Chem., 1976,54, 3272. S.H. Grover, J.P. Guthrie, J.B. Stothers and CT. Tan, J. Magn. Reson., 1973,10,227. H. Sato, Y. Tanaka and K. Hatada, Makromol. Chem. Rapid. Commun., 1982,3,19. Y. Inoue, K. Koyama, R. Chujo and A. Nishioka, Makromol. Chem., 1974,175,277. J. Spevacek, B. Schneider and J. Straka, Macromolecules, 1990, 23, 3042. J. Kowalewski, Prog. NMR Spectrosc, 1977,11,1. W.P. Aue, E. Bartholdi and R.R. Ernst, J. Chem. Phys., 1976,65,4226. W.W. Suter and PJ. Flory, Macromolecules, 1975,8, 765. P.R. Sundararajan, Macromolecules, 1986,19, 415.
4
NMRSTUDIESOFSOLID POLYMERS R. K. HARRIS Department of Chemistry and IRC in Polymer Science and Technology, University of Durham, South Road, Durham DHl 3LE, UK
4.1 INTRODUCTION It is the intention in this chapter to present an overview of some major aspects of NMR studies of solid polymers and to give some examples of applications. It will also provide the background to the more sophisticated multi-dimensional solidstate NMR techniques discussed in Chapter 5. NMR studies of solids can be generally grouped into three types: (a) broadline spectra; (b) relaxation times; and (c) high-resolution spectra. Of course, spin-spin (transverse) relaxation directly affects the observed signal (free induction decay) from pulsed NMR operation, which is Fourier transformed to yield the spectrum, so that the three areas are not totally distinct. This article will address all three aspects but will only relate to 1H, 19 F and 13C NMR. In particular, there will be no discussion of 2H spectra of polymers, important though that topic is. In suitable circumstances other spin- \ nuclei such as 15N, 29 Si and 3 1 P can be relevant, and they will behave much like 13C. Following the discovery of the NMR phenomenon in 1945 by two groups of physicists [1,2] NMR was applied to a wide range of systems, both solids and solutions. However, it rapidly became obvious that solution-state NMR was exceptionally useful to chemists because the high resolution achieved (with linewidths for 1 H less than 1 Hz) allowed small but important effects (i.e. chemical shifts and splittings due to coupling constants) to be observed. Solid-state NMR became for a while the esoteric preserve of a few hardy physicists and physical chemists. This situation became even more apparent after the introduction of the Fourier transform principle made high-quality 13C spectra obtainable. The reason for the relative neglect of solid-state NMR in the period 1955-1975 is apparent from Figure 4.1. Although it is clear that there is some useful information [3] (as the stereoregularity affects the spectrum), the resonances are % 50 kHz in width, with no fine structure. AU information on chemical shifts and coupling constants appears to be lost. The reason for such a disappointing Polymer Spectroscopy. Edited by Allan H. Fawcett © 1996 John Wiley & Sons Ltd
Figure 4.1 200MHz proton NMR spectrum of solid isotactic polypropene: A, high stereoregularity sample; B, low stereoregularity sample situation is that all NMR interaction of importance (especially shielding, dipolar coupling and indirect coupling) depend on the orientation of the local nuclear environment in the applied magnetic field B 0 . In mobile isotropic liquids or solutions the effects are averaged. The average dipolar coupling is zero, so it is eliminated from solution-state spectra; each active nucleus has an intrinsic shielding constant and each nuclear pair a single coupling constant. In solids, there is usually relatively little motion. Moreover, most samples (except single crystals) have a complete range of molecular orientations in the magnetic field. Both these factors lead to substantial line-broadening.
4.2 THE TECHNIQUES Fortunately, a series of techniques can be used to overcome the problems. The most ubiquitous is magic-angle spinning (M AS) [4], which consists of rotating the sample rapidly about an axis making an angle of 54.7° to B 0 (Figure 4.2). In principle this removes all the relevant anisotropies in most circumstances, yielding spectra comparable with those of solutions. Unfortunately, it is not normally possible to spin fast enough (up to 50OkHz would be required for extreme cases such as protons in rigid CH 2 groups). Additional techniques are therefore required. For the observation of dilute spins (such as 13C) in the presence of abundant spins (such as 1H), high-power heteronuclear decoupling (HPHD) is necessary. Combined with MAS, this yields 13 C spectra with linewidths as low as a few Hz in favourable cases (but at least an order of magnitude larger for polymers). However, HPHD is not applicable to the direct
Figure 4,2 The arrangement for magic-angle spinning (diagrammatic)
Figure 4.3 The WAHUHA pulse sequence [5] used for homonuclear decoupling in solids. AU pulse angles are 90°. The r.f. phases are indicated above them. The middle four pulses illustrated form the repeat unit of the sequence, s marks a sampling point observation of abundant spins. Special pulse sequences, using phase-alternated 90° pulses interspersed with single-point measurements, are used instead. Figure 4.3 shows the repeat unit of the simplest such sequence [5], known as WAHUHA. When a suitable sequence is combined with MAS at modest speeds («5kHz), anisotropic effects are removed. This combination of techniques is known as CRAMPS (combined rotation and multiple pulse spectroscopy) [6]. Multiple-pulse techniques of the WAHUHA type are also of value for proton homonuclear dipolar decoupling in experiments where other nuclei, such as 13 C, are observed under either static or MAS conditions. An additional problem, especially for dilute spin- \ nuclei, is that relaxation times in solids can be very long. Consequently normal pulse Fourier transform NMR, which requires delays between pulses of about five times T1, becomes very inefficient. However, a clever double-resonance pulse regime [7] known as cross-polarisation (CP) overcomes this difficulty; see Figure 4.4. During the contact time, magnetisation flows from protons to carbons provided that the radiofrequency powers are matched, enhancing the signal by a factor of « 4 and allowing repetition times to depend on T1 (1H) rather than T1 (13C), the former being generally substantially shorter than the latter. The first example of the CP/HPHD/MAS combination of techniques [8] sparked an explosion of research activity, and polymer chemistry has been one of the principal beneficiaries. Figure 4.5 shows the influence of the HPHD and MAS techniques in securing
Figure 4.4 The cross-polarisation pulse sequence. The contact time (CT) is of the order of ms. DC designates decouple
Figure 4.5 Cross-polarised 75 MHz 13 C spectra of solid poly(methyl methacrylate): A, static, coupled; B, static, proton-decoupled; C, with MAS, coupled; D, with MAS, protondecoupled
Figure 4.6 22.6 MHz 13C CP/HPHD/MAS spectrum of bisphenol-A diglycidyl ether, I. The spinning sidebands of the aromatic peaks are shaded line-narrowing and hence high resolution. The final linewidths are affected by a number of factors, but for polymers a major effect is the range of environments frequently encountered for a given carbon atom when amorphous components are present. Magic-angle spinning, to be fully effective, must be greater than the static bandwidth of the spectrum—in practice for 13 C under HPHD this means the shielding anisotropy. Otherwise additional peaks, known as spinning sidebands, appear in the spectra as satellites around the isotropic resonances, as shown in Figure 4.6 for the monomer I. For many purposes, these are a nuisance, but in fact they contain extra information (on the tensor nature of shielding) and they can be used to extract such data. In other circumstances, spinning sidebands can be used to obtain dipolar coupling constants and thence internuclear distances [9].
4.3 HIGH-RESOLUTION CARBON-13 NMR OF POLYMERS The CP/HPHD/M AS suite of techniques is ideal for the observation of 13 C spectra, which can then be used in the way traditional for solution-state NMR, i.e. to determine chemical structure. However, for solids the local environment of a chemical group is usually rigid, and this introduces further considerations that affect isotropic chemical shifts. These matters relate to crystallography (where appropriate) or, more generally, to molecular packing. The emphasis may be
Figure 4.7 A, 22.6MHz 13C CP/HPHD/M AS spectrum of syndiotactic polypropene [10]; B, projection of the helical chain in the crystal structure of syndiotactic polypropene [12]
Figure 4.8 A, 22.6 MHz *3C CP/HPHD/MAS spectrum of isotactic polypropene [H]; B, projection of the crystal structure for the a form of isotactic polypropene [13]. The central pair of chains have oppositely handed helices
either intramolecular or intermolecular. A well-attested example is polypropene. Figures 4.7 and 4.8 show 13 C spectra [10,11] and structural arrangements [12, 13] for the syndiotactic and isotactic forms respectively. The doubling of the CH 2 signal for the former can be readily seen to be a consequence of the curious helical nature of the chains, which leaves all the CH carbons in equivalent positions but results in two different types of CH 2 carbons—an intramolecular effect. The spectrum for isotactic polypropene, on the other hand, shows small, apparently 2:1 splittings of both CH 2 and CH 3 carbon signals. These can be attributed to the pairing of the polymer chains in the crystalline domains—an mtermolecular effect. Such spectra can be used to examine the effects at the molecular level of polymer processing. Thus, Figure 4.9 shows part of the spectra [14] of annealed and quenched forms of a block copolymer of nylon-6 and a polyether-containing polyesteramide (H) with n « 9 . The linking unit R is phenylene, and O — O represents a polyether component with both ethene oxide and propene oxide
II units. Only aliphatic nylon signals are shown in Figure 4.9, with the carbonnumbering scheme given in III. It is clear that the annealed material gives a much simpler spectrum than the quenched one. AU the resonances in the former can be attributed to the a-crystalline form, whereas additional peaks from both ycrystalline and amorphous forms appear in the latter.
III 13
Similarly C NMR can be used to study polymer degradation. Figure 4.10(A) shows part of the spectrum [15] of a complex cross-linked system containing blocks of a random copolymer of styrene, methyl methacrylate and maleic anhydride, together with cross-linking blocks formed from a polyester-tipped with a /?-hydroxyamine (IV). Figure 4.1OB is of the polymer degraded under moist conditions. Comparison of the spectra shows that there is substantial loss of all
IV
Figure 4.9 Resolution-enhanced 50.3 MHz 13C CP/HPHD/MAS spectra of a nylon6/20% (polyether/polyesteramide) (II) copolymer (CH2 nylon signals only) [14]; A, annealed sample; B, quenched sample
Figure 4.10 50.3 MHz 13 C CP/HPHD/MAS spectra of a cross-linked copolymer (see the text) [15]. A, as synthesized; B, after degradation. The asterisks indicate methylene signals of the polyester moiety
polyester CH2 signals, indicating complete excision of polyester chains (with or without internal break-up) and therefore showing that hydrolysis occurs at the hydroxyamine ends.
4.4 PROTON SPIN RELAXATION For heterogeneous materials, 13 C CPMAS spectra cannot be properly understood without a knowledge of proton relaxation times, which are also of intrinsic importance because of their relation to mobility at the molecular level and to domain structure. Three types of relaxation that need to be considered are: • Spin-lattice (longitudinal) relaxation This refers to magnetisation parallel to B 0 , is characterised by a time T1, involves spin energy, requires motion at the resonance frequency (i.e. hundreds of MHz) and is relatively easily averaged by spin diffusion. • Spin-lattice relaxation in the rotationframe This refers to magnetisation along the radiofrequency magnetic field JJ1, is characterised by a time T1 p, requires motion at a frequency related to the strength of B1 (i.e. tens of kHz) and is somewhat more difficult to average by spin diffusion than T1. • Spin-spin (transverse) relaxation This refers to magnetisation perpendicular to B 0 (in the absence of B1), involves spin phase-coherence (entropy), requires only very low-frequency motion, is not averaged by spin diffusion, and is directly related to the NMR signal (free induction decay). Whereas T1 and T1p are normally exponential or multi-exponential, transverse relaxation for solids takes a more complicated mathematical form (see below), the relevant time constant usually being given the symbol T2. For relatively rigid solid polymers, T1, T l p and T2 are normally of the order of s, ms and /is respectively. Since relaxation times are related to mobility, temperature and phase strongly influence the observed values. The phenomenon of spin diffusion mentioned above is a crucial ingredient of relaxation phenomena in heterogeneous systems such as polymers. It describes transfer of spin polarisation through space without atomic movement, and is caused by the pairwise "flip-flop" term of the dipolar interaction (see Figure 4.11), which itself depends on the inverse cube power of internuclear distances. It is efficient only in homonuclear situations, when little or no energy is required, and thus is particularly important for abundant spins such as 1H. It will cause averaging of some relaxation characteristics between domains in solid polymers when the sizes are small. For lamellar morphology the factor L2DTT is involved, where L = lamellar semi-thickness, D = spin diffusion coefficient and Tx is the relevant relaxation time. Averaging of relaxation occurs when L 2 « DTx. This occurs for domain sizes much less than a few tens of A for T1 p , or much less than a few hundreds of A for T1. Information on spin diffusion can be obtained in principle by the Goldman-Shen pulse
Figure 4.11 Spin diffusion by the flip-flop process (diagrammatic). Letters a-d represent successive situations, with e and f indicating later cases
A
B prep
evol
det
Figure 4.12 The Goldman-Shen pulse sequence [16] for the study of spin diffusion: A, short mixing time; B, long mixing time. All pulse angles are 90°. The r.f. phases are indicated above the pulses. The signal after the initial 90° pulse shows both rapidly relaxing and slowly relaxing components. The terms prep, evol and det refer to the preparation, evolution and detection periods respectively
sequence [16] (Figure 4.12) which prepares the magnetisation of a system of two domains, A and B say, such that the one with a short T2 (A, say) is zeroed. Then the remaining magnetisation is put back into the z direction, where it can equilibrate with B by spin diffusion during an evolution (mixing) time, after which the system is monitored. Unfortunately, quantitative interpretation of the results is complicated by spin-lattice relaxation during the mixing time.
InS
t/ms Figure 4.13 Experimental (300 MHz) and computer-simulated plots [17] for T1p of PVC. The y axis is the natural logarithm of the normalised signal height following spin-locking for a time t. The deviation from the upper straight line is plotted at the bottom left to give the short-time component
Frequently polymer heterogeneity can be monitored by measurement of Tlp. Figure 4.13 shows experimental and computer-fitted plots [17] of spin-lattice relaxation in the rotating frame for a sample of PVC. The decay curve can be satisfactorily fitted by two exponentials, giving 72% with T1p = 8.8 ms and 28% with T l p = 1.5 ms. Whereas this properly indicates heterogeneity, showing that there are more-ordered and less-ordered domains which are greater than a few tens of A, the effect of spin diffusion is to give the data a mixed character, meaning that neither the proportions nor the times are necessarily the intrinsic values of the different domains. In principle, free induction decays (and/or the spectra produced therefrom) should give better information on domain structure. In several ways it makes more sense to analyse the free induction decays directly, rather than the transformed spectra. However, there is no universally accepted algorithm for such analysis, which is not surprising given the complexity of the situation for polymeric systems. We have adopted a mix of three mathematical functions: • Exponential (Lorentzian): S(t) = exp( — t/T2). This is well justified for highly mobile regions. • Weibullian [18]: S(t) = exp[—(r/r 2 H with 1 < n ^ 2. Although this function has no particular justification in theory, it has the merit of varying with the exponent from pure Lorentzian (n = 1) to pure Gaussian (n = 2). • Abragamian: S(f) = exp[ —(£/T2)2] (sin 2nbt)/2nbt. Such a function was proposed by Abragam [19] as an approximation of the CaF 2 1 9 F decay. It
signal
signal
A
B
t/ms
t/ms
Figure 4.14 60 MHz free induction decays for: A, nylon-6; and B, copolymer of nylon-6 and 20% polyether/polyesteramide II (see the text) [14]. The ordinate is signal intensity on an arbitrary scale Table 4.1
Free induction decay analysis of samples of nylon-6 and its copolymer containing 20% of the unit II Nylon-6 Population/%
Copolymer Time/us
Population/%
Exponential 5 64 22 Abragamian 95 18° 78 a The value of b is 21000 and 20000 for the nylon-6 and copolymer respectively.
Time/us 367 18fl
represents a rectangular distribution of Gaussians, and its value lies partly in the fact that it can yield a small oscillation such as is to be expected when there are relatively isolated spin pairs such as CH 2 groups. Figure 4.14 shows free induction decays [14] for nylon-6 and the copolymer containing 20% of the unit II. A small initial oscillation is apparent in each case, and the long-time component in Figure 4.14B is obvious. Table 4.1 shows the results of the analysis. The small amount of the exponential for pure nylon-6 probably relates to additives in the commercial sample. The time constants of the two domains are an order of magnitude different, showing the considerable degree of motional heterogeneity. The proportion of the copolymer which decays slowly clearly reflects the content of II. Of course, for more complete information, other NMR experiments, both 1 H and 13 C, must be performed and the results collated. For copolymer systems deuterated in one component, the phase boundaries can be probed by attempting to cross-polarise from the protons in the second component.
4.5 DISCRIMINATION IN CARBON-13 SPECTRA Proton relaxation data allow the NMR spectroscopist both to interpret 13 C CPMAS spectra and to devise discriminating experiments [20]. One such
lo
9ioS
A
l
B
°9ioS
CT/ms
CT/ms Figure 4.15. Cross-polarisation dynamics for 50.3 MHz 13C spectra of a copolymer of nylon-6 and 40% polyether/polyesteramide (see the text) [14]; variation of peak height S with contact time CT: A, nylon-6-carbons (diamonds indicate the C4/C5 peak, squares are for C2, and circles are for Cl, see III); B, polyether carbons (the symbols are for the peaks at the following chemical shifts: triangles 18.2 ppm, circles 75.8 ppm, squares 73.9 ppm, diamonds 71.2 ppm). S is expressed relative to the peak height of the most intense signal, extrapolated to zero CT. A theoretical curve is shown for Cl in A experiment is variation of the contact time. During the contact time of the CP process, transfer of polarisation will reach a maximum because of the competing effects of creating equilibrium between the 1 H and 13 C spin baths and the loss of proton magnetisation to the "lattice" by spin-lattice relaxation in the rotating frame. When there are domains differing substantially in T 1 ^ 1 H), the optimum contact time for each domain will also differ. Indeed, it is possible to measure (at considerable cost of spectrometer time) values of T 1 ^ 1 H) selectively for different 13 C peaks by variation of the contact time, as shown [14] in Figure 4.15. In the case illustrated, long contact times will clearly favour the polyether carbons. In
A
B
Figure 4.16 Discrimination by contact time for PVC plasticised by 180pph of di-2ethylhexyl phthalate [17]. 300 MHz*3C CP/HPHD/M AS spectra: A, contact time 200 /is; B, contact time 5 ms. The broad peaks arise from PVC and the sharp ones from the plasticiser
such circumstances quantitative measurement of relative signal intensities can be obtained only by extrapolation of the decay curves under long contact to their intercepts at zero contact time. Figure 4.16 shows discriminating spectra for a different polymer situation: PVC plasticised by di-2-ethylhexyl phthalate [17]. The PVC itself is mostly rigid, cross-polarises efficiently but has a short associated T1^(1H). Hence a short contact time reveals PVC peaks strongly. The plasticiser, on the other hand, is mostly very mobile, cross-polarises badly but is influenced by a long T1^1H). It therefore gives intense peaks only at long contact times. A second discriminating pair of experiments consists of comparing a CP/HPHD/MAS spectrum with one obtained without cross-polarisation (sometimes referred to as single-pulse excitation, SPE). Whereas the former depends on proton relaxation, the latter is affected only by carbon relaxation. SPE spectra are likely to be strongly influenced by carbon peaks with short T1(13C), usually in relatively mobile parts of the sample, or, if recycle delays between pulses are long, by all the carbons. Figure 4.17 gives an example [14] for the nylon-6 copolymer containing 20% of II. Whereas the CP spectrum shows mostly signals from crystalline nylon domains, the SPE spectrum is dominated by peaks from the polyether moieties and from amorphous esteramide or nylon regions. SPE spectra can yield quantitative relative intensities of signals if recycle delays are long enough. However, nuclear Overhauser effects can cause complications if the duty cycle of the decoupler is significant.
A
B
Figure 4.17 200 MHz * 3 C MAS spectra of a copolymer of nylon-6 and 20% polyether/ polyester-amide II (see the text) [14]: A, SPE/HPHD mode with recycle delay 5 s; B, CP/HPHD mode with contact time 1 ms and recycle delay 2 s. The broad peaks in A arise from amorphous esteramide or nylon groups. The sharp peaks in A are from PEO or PPO groups
4.6 SPECTRA OF ABUNDANT SPINS As indicated earlier, for direct observation of 1H or 19 F spectra of solids with high resolution, it is necessary to use the CRAMP pair of techniques [6]. As yet these have been underused in polymer NMR, partly because they are more demanding of the instrument electronics than CPMAS operation and partly because residual linewidths, which are frequently several hundred Hz, give only moderate resolution for 1 H, which has a relatively small chemical shift range. However, CRAMPS is excellent for detecting strong hydrogen bonding, which gives proton signals in the S = 10-20 region where there are seldom any other peaks. Moreover, the potential for CRAMPS with 1 9 F for polymers is high, as the shift range is large. Figure 4.18 gives a simple example [21], showing how information on chain^ends can be readily derived. The figure also illustrates the appearance of spinning sidebands. Comparison of Figures 4.18A and B indicates the way in which increasing rotational speed causes sidebands to move out from the centrebands and to weaken. This allows the centrebands to be obtained unambiguously.
A
B
C
Figure 4.18 188.3MHz 1 9 F CRAMP spectra of PTFE samples [21]: A and B, shortchain polymer (^C 2 0 F 4 2 ); C, long-chain polymer. The spinning speeds were A 2.6 kHz; B 5.1 kHz, and C 2.5 kHz. The arrows in B indicate signals from chain ends. The asterisks denote spinning sidebands
47 CONCLUSION The scope for application of NMR to solid polymers is very wide. Information on chemical microstructure, micromorphology and molecular-level dynamics is available. It is important to undertake studies comprehensively using both 13 C and 1 H nuclei, with measurements of both spectra and relaxation times. Various experiments are available for the selective examination of heterogeneous systems. More sophisticated methods are also feasible, as is discussed in Chapter 5
4.8 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I am grateful to colleagues whose results are mentioned in this article and whose names are given in the references. I particularly thank S. Friebel, S-W. Tsui and
A.F. Johnson for the collaboration in hitherto-unpublished work, resulting in Figures 4.9,4.14,4.15 and 4.17.1 also thank the UK S.E.R.C. for financial support under grants GR/E 91110 and GR/H 30175 and for allocations of time on the Solid-state NMR Service sited at Durham.
4.9 REFERENCES [1] E.M. Purcell, H.C. Torrey and R.V. Pound, Phys. Rev., 1946,69, 37. [2] F. Bloch, W.W. Hansen and M.E. Packard, Phys. Rev., 1946,69,127. [3] P.W.R. Smith, Ph.D. Thesis, University of East Anglia, 1986. See also IJ. Colquhoun and KJ. Packer, Br. Polym. J., 1987,19,151. [4] For a review, see E.R. Andrew, Int. Rev. Phys. Chem., 1981,1,195. [5] J.S. Waugh, L.M. Huber and U. Haeberlen, Phys. Rev. Lett., 1968,20,180. [6] L.M. Ryan, R.E. Taylor, AJ. Paff and B.C. Gerstein, J. Chem. Phys., 1980, 72, 508. [7] A. Pines, M.G. Gibby and J.S. Waugh, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59, 569. [8] J. Schaefer and E.O. Stejskal, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 1976,98,1031. [9] J. Schaefer, E.O. Stejskal, R.A. McKay and W.T. Dixon, Macromolecules, 1984,17, 1479. [10] A. Bunn, M.E.A. Cudby, R.K. Harris, KJ. Packer and BJ. Say, J. Chem. Soc, Chem. Commun., 1981, 15. [11] A. Bunn, M.E.A. Cudby, R.K. Harris, KJ. Packer and BJ. Say, Polymer, 1982, 23, 694. [12] P. Corradini, G. Natta, P. Ganis and P.A. Temussi, / . Polym. Sci. C, 1967,16,2477. [13] G. Natta and P. Corradini, Nuovo Cim., 1960,15 (Suppl), 40. [14] S. Friebel, R.K. Harris, S.-W. Tsui and A.F. Johnson, ubpublished work. [15] A. Findlay, Ph.D. Thesis, University of Durham, 1991. [16] M. Goldman and L. Shen, Phys. Rev., 1966,144, 321. [17] M.I.B. Tavares, R.K. Harris and E.E.C. Monteiro, unpublished work. [18] S. Kaufman and DJ. Bunger, J. Magn. Reson., 1970,3, 218. [19] A. Abragam, Principles of Nuclear Magnetism, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1961, p. 120. [20] R.S. Aujla, R.K. Harris, KJ. Packer, M. Parameswaran and BJ. Say, Polym. Bull., 1982,8, 253. [21] R.K. Harris and P. Jackson, Chem. Rev., 1991,91,1427.
5
MULTIDIMENSIONAL SOLID-STATE NMR OF POLYMERS H. W. SPIESS Max-Planck-Institut fur Polymerforschung, Postfach 3148, D-55021 Mainz, Germany
5.1 INTRODUCTION One of the key goals of materials science is the establishment of structureproperty relationships in order to improve known properties and to permit the design of new materials. This holds in particular for synthetic polymers, whose properties depend on both the molecular structure and the organization of the macromolecules in the solid state: their phase structure, morphology, molecular order and their molecular dynamics [1, 2]. Both macroscopic and microscopic parameters are influenced by the processing that follows the chemical synthesis. This calls for powerful analytical tools that can probe these aspects in the material as it is used predominantly in the solid state. The structural aspects are studied mostly by scattering techniques or by microscopy. Information about dynamic aspects is deduced mainly from scattering or relaxation experiments [3]. Among these nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) [4,5] is well established for the structural characterization of liquids or compounds in solution, but much less so for solids [6, 7]. Indeed, NMR offers numerous ways to study dynamic aspects over a large range of characteristic rates. The main advantage of NMR is its unprecedented selectivity. It is thus desirable to develop this technique for studying the structure and dynamics of solid polymers [8]. However, owing to the presence of angular-dependent anisotropic interactions, the spectral resolution of solid-state NMR spectra is orders of magnitude lower than that of high resolution NMR in liquids. Important improvements were achieved in the 1970's by combining high-speed mechanical rotation of the sample with ingenious manipulations of the nuclear spins, such as multiple-pulse irradiation, highpower decoupling and cross polarization [9]. Moreover, two-dimensional (and higher) NMR techniques have been introduced that offer fundamental advantages [10]. First, as in liquids, the introduction of a new frequency dimension provides a means of increasing the spectral resolution. Even more important, Polymer Spectroscopy. Edited by Allan H. Fawcett © 19% John Wiley & Sons Ltd
multidimensional spectroscopy also provides routes to new information that is unavailable from one-dimensional spectra even in the limit of high resolution. Experiments can be designed which correlate different spin interactions providing different structural information, or relate various states taken up by the molecular unit during different time periods by exchange, and in this way to probe dynamic processes in real time. Progress in multidimensional solid-state NMR has been hampered by experimental and conceptual difficulties, but these are now overcome [11-14]. This chapter briefly outlines some of the main concepts and illustrates the information available from multidimensional solid-state NMR spectra concerning polymer structure and dynamics through experimental examples selected from the author's laboratory. Polymer dynamics is of central interest in our studies. Of the great variety of molecular motions possible in polymers (e.g., translations, rotation, vibrations), rotations have the most pronounced effects of NMR lineshapes and relaxation parameters.Thus, multidimensional NMR provides essentially unique information about rotational motions. Their timescales may be followed in real time over many orders of magnitude, covering in particular that regime of slow motions which govern the mechanical properties of polymers. Moreover, the higher-order correlation functions provided by multidimensional NMR yield previously inaccessible model-independent information about the geometry of rotational motions, the orientational memory of molecular units involved in complex dynamics, and the nature of nonexponential relaxation in disordered systems. When the information has been collected for a variety of polymers, it should eventually lead to a better understanding of their mechanical and rheological behavior, which is of interest not only for conventional but also for new advanced polymeric materials. Two other aspects are particularly important for establishing structureproperty relationships for polymer materials, namely chain alignment in partially ordered systems and domain sizes in heterogeneous polymer materials. The orientation of macromolecular units is used to improve the properties of polymers for such diverse applications as high-tensile-strength fibres and nonlinear optical materials for information technology. Advanced polymer materials almost inevitably consist of more than one component, which often leads to phase separation. Careful design of the molar ratios as well as the size, composition and morphology of the different phases offers a means to control the mechanical, electrical and optical properties. Small domains that extend over only a few nanometers, and also interfacial regions between the different phases, are particularly difficult to characterize. Major advances have been achieved in these areas by introducing the concepts of multidimensional spectroscopy. The new solidstate NMR techniques nicely supplement well-established scattering and microscopic methods, as we demonstrate by various experimental examples and by explicit comparison.
5.2 MULTIDIMENSIONALSOLID-STATE NMR SPECTRA Solid-state NMR exploits anisotropic, angular-dependent interactions of nuclear spins with their surroundings [4, 5], in particular magnetic dipole-dipole coupling of nuclei among themselves. This leads to broad NMR lines covering « 5 0 kHz for 1 H - 1 H homonuclear coupling and « 2 5 kHz for 1 H- 1 3 C heteronuclear coupling. The anisotropy of the chemical shift results in powder patterns ocvering « 1 5 kHz at a field strength of 7 T. In addition to these magnetic interactions, nuclei with spin / > 1/2 can also have electric quadrupole moments, and are subject to quadrupole coupling to the electric field gradient at the nuclear site. For 2 H ( / = 1) in C- 2 H bonds this leads to spectral splittings of «250 kHz. Since C-H bonds are common in polymers, 2 H labeling is particularly useful. If one of the above mentioned couplings dominates, either because of its strength, or because the others have been suppressed by decoupling, the angular dependence of the NMR frequency in high magnetic fields is alike for all couplings, and is given by: a) = coL + ±A(3cos2O-
I - rjsin20cos2(t))
(1)
Here coL is the Larmor frequency, A describes the strength of the anisotropic coupling: i.e. the anisotropic chemical shift or x3 C - l H dipole-dipole coupling for 13 C and the quadrupole coupling for 2 H, and rj is the asymmetry parameter describing the deviation of the anisotropic coupling from axial symmetry (O ^ Y] ^ 1). The angles 0, are the polar angles of the magnetic field B 0 in the the principal axes system of the coupling tensor. This in turn is often simply related to the molecular geometry; i.e. the unique axis being along a bond direction, e.g. dipole-dipole coupling: 1 3 C- 1 H bond, quadrupole coupling: C- 2 H bond, or perpendicular to an sp 2 plane as for 13 C chemical shift tensors in aromatic rings etc. Depending on the total spin involved, signals described by Equation (1) and their mirror images with respect to coL may be superimposed, and in powder samples the spectra for all orientations are added to yield the powder lineshape (e.g., the Pake pattern for 2 H with spin / = 1). Details of the experiments designed to record multidimensional NMR spectra are not given here, as ample literature exists on the subject [10-13] and an extended monograph is available [14]. However, basis knowledge of solid-state NMR, as in Chapter 4, and of the concept of two-dimensional (2D) Fourier spectroscopy, is needed to read this chapter. A 2D NMR spectrum is generated by recording a two-dimensional data set following pulsed irradiation as a function of two time variables, as shown schematically in Figure 5.1, and subsequent double Fourier transformation. The development of the nuclear spin system in the evolution period with incremented time tx at the beginning of the pulse sequence provides the basis for the first frequency dimension Co1. The NMR signal is detected in the detection period with time 12 at the end of the pulse sequence,
preparation
evolution
mixing
detection
Figure 5.1 Time scheme of two-dimensional NMR [11] providing the basis for the second frequency dimension co2. In the exchange experiments described here, a variable mixing period of duration tm, during which dynamic processes can take place, is inserted between evolution and detection. The concept of 2D spectroscopy is readily extended to three and higher dimensions by inserting additional evolution and mixing times.
5.3 EXAMPLES 5.3.1 INCREASE OF SPECTRAL RESOLUTION Let us first consider experiments which increase the spectral resolution of solid state NMR spectra in order to characterize polymer structure in terms of chemical moieties on the basis of isotropic chemical shifts. This represents the most important feature of standard NMR techniques, and makes up one or two dimensions of many multidimensional experiments in which the chemical structure is correlated with other molecular properties such as mobility or order. In the solid state, the tensorial nature of the chemical shift makes the NMR frequency also depend on the orientation of the molecular unit under study with respect to the applied magnetic field of the NMR spectrometer, cf. Equation (1). Since the orientational dependence of the NMR frequency is comparable with or even larger than the variation of the isotropic chemical shifts of different structural units, the powder patterns resulting from the anisotropic chemical shifts overlap severely in all but the simplest polymer structures. Thus, in many cases a quantitative analysis is virtually impossible. The effect of the anisotropy can be removed by rapidly spinning the sample about an axis inclined at the "magic angle" of 54.7° (magic angle spinning, MAS). However, this is accompanied by a loss of the information about the molecular orientation, which is the basis of structural and dynamic information typical of the solid state. Thus, experiments are desired that retain this information without sacrificing spectral resolution. For moderate spinning speeds in the range of a few kHz, the anisotropic chemical shift is not "spun out", but leads to sideband patterns, from which the anisotropies can be retrieved [15, 16]. However, in complex polymer structures
Figure 5.2 Separation of isotropic and anisotropic chemical shifts: (a) 13C MAS spectrum of an ether sulfone oligomer showing severe overlap of sidebands; (b) 2D 13C sideband MAS spectrum of the same compound showing resolved sidebands [18]
the sideband patterns overlap heavily and hamper a quantitative analysis. By ingenious spin manipulations through multiple-pulse sequences, these sideband patterns can be removed from the spectrum in one dimension and retained in the other [17, 18]. As shown in Figure 5.2, the crowded sideband patterns of amorphous polymers can be nicely resolved in a second frequency dimension and can then be exploited to provide structural and dynamic information.
5.3.2 SEPARATED LOCAL FIELD N M R The dipole-dipole coupling, for instance between 1H and 13 C, or 1 H and 15 N, provides valuable structural information. As the C-H bond lengths are known, the measurements of dipolar splittings can be interpreted in terms of angles between individual bonds and the applied magnetic fields. For proteins, measurements of N - H bond lengths are of considerable interest, as they vary due to hydrogen bonding and therefore contain important structural information. In order to be useful, however, the dipolar patterns have to be separated according to the chemically distinct sites in a molecule or monomer unit as identified by their 13 C or 1 5 N chemical shits. As the dipolar couplings correspond to local fields, such experiments are often named "separated local field" (SLF) experiments [19]. Different schemes have been developed based on sample spinning [20, 21]. If the polymer contains only carbons with a common chemical shift, static techniques can be used [10]. As an example, Figure 5.3(a) displays the 13 C
Figure 53 Separated local field spectroscopy correlating heteronuclear dipoledipole coupling with chemical shifts: (a) ID * 3 Q 1 H spectrum of highly oriented poly(oxymethylene) (POM) with its order axis inclined at 30° with respect to the magnetic field [22]; (b) orientation of chemical shift tensor deduced from this spectrum (principal axes marked by
chemical ShIfV13C-1H dipolar powder pattern for oriented poly(oxymethylene) (POM) [22]. From a quantitative analysis of such patterns, bond lengths and bond angles can be determined, as well as the orientations of the principal axes of the chemical-shift tensor in relation to structural units such as CH 2 groups, Figure 5.3(b). Such information is needed for a quantitative analysis of other experiments exploiting anisotropic chemical shifts.
5.3.3 WIDELINE SEPARATION EXPERIMENTS Multidimensional NMR provides especially interesting information about polymer dynamics. A long-standing method for qualitative characterization of molecular mobility is 1 H wideline NMR spectroscopy. There, large-amplitude motions are detected through the reduction of the dipolar line width. However, ID proton lineshapes leave many questions open, as they typically represent superpositions of broad and narrow lines, and their relation to different structural units is often not obvious. In a straightforward combination of 1 H wideline NMR, cross polarization (CP) and 13 C MAS spectroscopy in a 2D experiment [23], it is possible to separate the dipolar patterns for the different structural units (Wideline SEparation, WISE). This is demonstrated in Figure 5.4, where a WISE
Figure 5.4 2D WISE NMR specrating 1 H wideline spectra for different structural units according to their 13C chemical shifts: (a) conventional 1 H wideline spectrum of a blend of poly(styrene) (PS) and poly(vinylmethylether) (PVME); (b) 2D 1H 13C WISE NMR spectrum indicating different mobilities of the two components [23]
NMR spectrum of a 50:50 wt% blend of poly(styrene) (PS) and poly(vinylmethylether) (PVME) is presented. The 1 H wideline spectrum, Figure 5.4(a), consists of a rather featureless superposition of Components with different dipolar linewidths, which are nicely separated in the second frequency dimension (Figure 5.4(b)) and related to structural units according to their 13 C chemical shifts. Substantial motional heterogeneities, PVME being more mobile (narrower 1 H lines) than PS, are detected despite the fact that the spectrum is recorded about 60 K above the caloric glass transition of this blend, which appears homogeneous by most classical techniques. Such information about the mobility of the different structural units is highly valuable for many practical applications.
5.3.4 2 D and 3D EXCHANGE N M R For a thorough understanding of the chain motions in polymers, qualitative information provided by 1H wideline spectra is not sufficient. In order to relate chain motions to the structure of the polymer itself or to the packing of the macromolecular chains, one requires knowledge about the geometry of the motion, for example, the angles about which a molecular unit rotates during individual motional steps. This information, which is hard to get otherwise, is indeed provided by 2D exchange NMR as applied to rotational motions [12-14]. In simple cases this technique yields elliptical ridge patterns from which the angle about which the molecules have rotated can be directly read off with a ruler [24]. As a specific example, Figure 5.5(a) displays such a 2 H 2D exchange spectrum for poly(vinylidene fluoride) (PVF2), a polymer of considerable technological interest because of its electrical properties. The geometric information from 2D NMR, together with knowledge of the dipole moment change generated by the motion, allowed us to identify the conformational change tgtg«—> gtgt of a chain defect as being responsible for the mechanical and dielectric relaxation in the crystalline regions of this polymer [25]. In a series of papers [26], 2D exchange NMR was applied to study the chain motion of amorphous polymers above their glass transition. For complex motions, even the information accessible by 2D techniques is not sufficient for an adequate description of the motional mechanisms involved in chain dynamics. This is due to the fact that in 2D NMR the orientation of molecules is measured only twice, in the evolution and in the detection periods. Therefore, no information is provided about the trajectory a molecular unit follows when rotating from one orientation to another. In order to distinguish different mechanisms one has to determine the molecular orientation at least three times. This is achieved in 3D exchange NMR. In a 3D exchange spectrum, as displayed in Figure 5.5(b) for natural abundance 13 C in semicrystalline poly(oxymethylene) (POM), different pathways pursued by the molecule lead to different exchange signals, which can therefore be clearly distinguished. From
Figure 5.5 Multidimensional exchange NMR spectra elucidating slow molecular motions: (a) 2D 2H NMR spectrum of crystalline poly(vinylidene fluoride) reflecting chain motions through defect diffusion [25]; (b) 3D 13C exchange spectrum of oriented poly(oxymethylene) reflecting helical jumps in the crystalline regions [14]
analysis of such 3D spectra for different semicrystalline polymers, which pack in helical conformations, helical jump motions have been identified in which the chain units rotate to neighboring positions and translate by one repeat unit [14]. This process can eventually lead to chain diffusion between crystalline and amorphous regions with pronounced effects on the long-term mechanical properties [27].
5.3.5 CHAIN A L I G N M E N T FROM 2D A N D 3D NMR Structural characterization of polymers often requires the determination of the alignment of macromolecular chains. Orientation in polymers is often induced by the production process and has strong effects on product properties. Through the angular-dependent NMR interactions, orientation is amenable to measurement in NMR experiments. In contrast to most classical techniques, the order of both crystalline and amorphous components can be studied. For 2 H- or 13C-enriched samples, one-dimensional experiments are sufficient to obtain orientation distributions in terms of a single angle [28]. In order to reconstruct two-dimensional orientation distributions, or to resolve overlapping patterns in natural-abundance 13 C spectra, multidimensional spectra are required. Two examples are presented in Figure 5.6. Both involve 3D spectra of 13 C in natural abundance. In the case of a biaxially drawn film of poly(ethylene terephthalate) (PET), the orientational distribution was mapped out by flipping the sample between different orientations with respect to the magnetic field (Direction Exchange with Correlation for Orientation Distribution Evaluation and Reconstruction, DECODER) [29]. The NMR signals of the different structural units of PET are completely resolved in the 3D cube and their orientation distributions are thus separately determined [30]. The chain axes are confined to the film plane (full-width-at-half-maximum,fwhm, of 15°), whereas the in-plane distribution is much broader (fwhm approx. 90°). The planes containing the phenylene rings and the carboxyl group are oriented preferentially parallel to the plane of the film (fwhm of 55°). In the case of a liquid-crystalline side-group polymer (Figure 5.6(b)), the extension to a third dimension is performed in order to achieve the necessary spectral resolution [31]. Rotor-synchronized MAS is applied to map out the degree of molecular order along Ox. The sidebands are separated by their order along o2 (see Figure 5.2), and the chemical structure is probed via the isotropic chemical shift along o3. Each dot in the 3D spectrum represents a single sideband of a carbon position in the repeat unit with resolved 13 C chemical shift in the MAS spectrum. This allows the molecular order of relatively complex polymers to be analyzed quantitatively even for liquid-crystalline polymers, where different moieties of the repeat unit exhibit substantially different degrees of alignment [32]. The specific example studied here is a frozen smectic polyacrylate with a phenylbenzoate mesogenic side group and a spacer of six methylene
Figure 5.6 3D NMR spectra for determining molecular order: (a) 3D 13C DECODER NMR spectrum of biaxially drawn polyethylene terephthalate) [30]; (b) 3D 13C MAS spectrum of a liquid-crystalline side-group polymer [31]
units. The 3D MAS NMR spectrum not only reveals a pronounced order gradient from the aligned mesogen to the disordered polymer chain, it also shows that the acrylic carbonyl group exhibits a much higher order than the hydrocarbon units of the main chain. Because of its selectivity, high resolution solid-state NMR is able to reveal that the carbon-carbon bond which links the acrylic carbonyl to the main chain plays a crucial role in the decoupling of the ordered side groups from the polymer chain [31]. 5.3.6 D O M A I N SIZES FROM SPIN D I F F U S I O N EXPERIMENTS In heterogeneous polymers, domain sizes, or structures on the scale of up to a few hundred nanometers, can be investigated. In NMR the proximity of molecular units is probed by spin diffusion [4,14], which is most effective among protons. Thus, NMR is particularly suited for characterizing small domains, nanoheterogeneities or concentration fluctuations on length scales of a few nm, where other methods often fail owing to liminations in resolution or contrast. An advanced approach exploiting 1 H spin diffusion with highly sensitive 13 C detection has been introduced recently [33, 34]. As a particularly clear-cut case, this technique has been applied to a series of symmetric diblock copolymers of PS and poly(methyl methacrylate), PMMA [34]. In Figure 5.7(a) the increase of the carbon signals of the phenyl ring in the PS block after selection of the PMMA block is plotted against the spin diffusion time for various block lengths. The equal lengths of both blocks in the symmetric copolymers ensures a lamellar structure which makes the quantitative analysis of the data easy. PMMA and PS are known to be immiscible. The spin diffusion data yield domain sizes which are consistent with the scaling law M n 0 66 , where Mn denotes the molar mass of the blocks, as predicted theoretically [35]. For comparison, a statistical copolymer, in which no phase separation is possible, and a blend of both homopolymers were included in the data set. The close agreement between experimental intensities and the time dependence calculated from the diffusion equation is apparent in Figure 5.7(b) and demonstrates that domain sizes between 0.5 and 100 nm can be determined quantitatively. This technique has already been applied to a number of homogeneous and heterogeneous polymer systems, in particular to block copolymers containing both mobile and rigid components affording detection of heterogeneities on a scale as small as 2 nm in systems that exhibit a single Tg in differential scanning calorimetry [36]. 5.3.7 SPATIALLY RESOLVED SOLID STATE NMR Eventually one would like to obtain the information about molecular structure and dynamics accessible by solid-state NMR not just for the sample as a whole
(PMMA)
(PMMA)
ppm
signal intensity PS
toilms]
t m 1/2 [ms"*]
Figure 5.7 Spin diffusion as a tool for determining domain sizes in heterogeneous polymers [34]: (a) 13C MAS spectra of the symmetrical diblock copolymer PS-b-PMMA as a function of the diffusion time tm after selection of proton magnetization of the methoxy group in PMMA; (b) signal intensity of the phenyl carbons in PS as function of tm for different molecular weights. The numbers indicate domain sizes obtained from the fit
Figure 5.8 (a) Spatially resolved 2D 13 C spectrum of an injection-molded drawn tensile bar of syndiotactic poly(propylene); (b) geometry of sample [37]
but with spatial resolution. For instance, one would like to distinguish the molecular parameters in regions close to the surface from those in the bulk. In fact, by applying pulsed magnetic field gradients, the concepts of multidimensional NMR can also be used to generate a spatial dimension in 2D spectra through Fourier imaging [10]; see also Chapter 6. As a first example, a spatially resolved 13 C NMR spectrum of a drawn poly(propylene) sample is displayed in Figure 5.8 [37]. It reflects differences of density and chain alignment between skin and core due to the processing of the material, and demonstrates that spectroscopic solid-state NMR imaging is indeed possible. This exciting field is still in its infancy and considerable progress is expected in the near future, as indicated in a recent book on the subject [38] which is based on lectures at an international conference.
5.4 CONCLUSION As these examples indicate, a wealth of information about polymer structure and dynamics is available through advanced multidimensional solid-state NMR techniques. Profound correlations between macroscopic and molecular behavior
are emerging from such studies. Examples are helical jumps or defect diffusion in crystallites, specific local motions in amorphous polymers and conformational transitions coupled to relaxations of larger chain units in highly viscous polymer melts. Such information has already been used successfully in the design of polymers with improved properties. Thus, it can be anticipated that the importance of multidimensional solid-state NMR as an advanced tool of polymer spectroscopy will increase substantially in the future.
5.5 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS It is a pleasure to thank my coworkers engaged in the work described here: Drs. B. Bliimich, B. Chmelka, J. Clauss, S. Feaux de Lacroix, E. Gunther, D. Schaefer, JJ. Titmann, M. Wilhelm and, in particular, Dr. K. Schmidt-Rohr.
5.6 REFERENCES [1] PJ. Flory, Principles of Polymer Chemistry, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, 1953. [2] J.I. Kroschwitz (Ed.), Concise Encyclopedia of Polymer Science and Technology, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1990. [3] N.G. McCrum, B.E. Read and G. Williams, Anelastic and Dielectric Effects in Polymeric Solids, Dover Publishing, New York, 1967. [4] A. Abragam, The Principles of Nuclear Magnetism, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1961. [5] CP. Slichter, Principles of Magnetic Resonance, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1980. [6] F.A. Bovey,