Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 70
POISONING AND PROMOTION IN CATALYSIS BASED ON SURFACE SCIENCE CONCEPTS AND EXPERIMENTS
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis AdvisoryEditors: B. Delmon and J.T. Yates Vol. 70
POISONING AND PROMOTION INCATALYSIS BASEDON SURFACE SCIENCE CONCEPTS AND EXPERIMENTS
M.P. Kiskinova Institute of General and Inorganic Chemistry, Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, Sofia 1040, Bulgaria
and
Sincrotrone Trieste, Padriciano 99, 34072 Trieste, Italy
ELSEVIER
Amsterdam
- Oxford - NewYork - Tokyo
1992
ELSEVIER SCIENCE PUBLISHERS B.V. Sara Burgerhartstraat 25 P.O. Box 211,1000AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands Distributors for the United States and Canada:
ELSEVIER SCIENCE PUBLISHING COMPANY, INC. 655 Avenue of the Americas NewYork, NY 10010, USA
ISBN: 0-444-86947-6
0 Elsevier Science Publishers B.V., 1992. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the Publisher, Elsevier Science Publishers B.V./Academic Publishing Division, P.O. Box330,1000 AH Amsterdam, The Netherlands. Special regulations for readers in the USA - This publication has been registered with the Copyright Clearance Center Inc. (CCC), Salem, Massachusetts. Information can be obtained from the CCC about conditions under which photocopies of parts of this publication may be made in the USA. All other copyright questions, including photocopying outside of the USA, should be referred to the Publisher. No responsibility is assumed by the Publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Although all advertising material is expected to conform to ethical (medical) standards, inclusion in this publication does not constitute a guarantee or endorsement of the quality or value of such product or of the claims made of it by its manufacturer. This book is printed on acid-free paper. Printed in The Netherlands
PREFACE
Extensive work on surface research during the past two decades, occasioned by the development of various powerful surface-sensitive techniques, has resulted in a much-improved fundamental understanding of surface phenomena. Valuable information, concerning catalytic processes on metal surfaces, was derived from experimental data thus obtained. Such information concerns the characterization, on atomic as well as molecular scale, of the following surface factors: electronic structure, position and order of atoms and chemical composition of the catalysts. It also concerns the composition, structure and properties of the adsorbed layers, and lastly, the factors responsible for changes in catalytic activity and selectivity. In this book, an attempt is made to summarise current information which contributes t o the fundamental understanding of the effect of additives, some of which act as promotors, others as poisons, in a number of important catalytic reactions. A description of single- and double-component systems has been obtained by using surface-sensitive techniques, particularly suited for this purpose. For the benefit of the reader, a short summary of the main surface science techniques used in the studies considered in this book has been given in Chapter 2. Three general and interrelated topics are reviewed. The first concerns the interaction of electronegative (Cl, S, Se, C, N , 0, P) and electropositive (alkali metals) atoms with metal surfaces (Chapter 4). The second topic covers the chemisorptive properties of metal surfaces modified by varying amounts of additives with respect to different reactants ( CO, NO, N2, 02,Ha, C 0 2 , NH3, H 2 0 , and hydrocarbons) (Chapters 5 & 6). In particular, the adsorption kinetics and energetics and the electronic, structural and reactive properties of the coadsorbate systems are considered, whereby particular attention is given to recent surface science studies with well-characterized, single crystal metal surfaces. In these chapters, special attention is paid to showing the contribution of different factors (the nature and adsorption state of the modifier and the coadsorbed molecule, the structure of the adsorbed layer, the type of interactions in the mixed overlayers, etc.) t o the modifier effects. In the discussion of the third topic, model studies of several important catalytic reactions (Fischer - Tropsch synthesis, ammonia synthesis, GO oxidation, water-gas shift synthesis) on modified metal surfaces (Chapter 8) are considered. Emphasis is placed on the correlations between the chemisorptive properties of the modified surfaces and the observed changes in their catalytic activity and selectivity. Included in this discussion is the question to what V
Vi
Prefeace
extent various factors contribute t o the promoting or poisoning effect in the model experiments and how this affects actual catalytic operations. There is a chapter on the theoretical approaches to the definition of modifier effects also. I would like t o thank a number of people who worked with me on this subject. I am grateful to Prof. J.T. Yates, Prof. D.W. Goodman and Dr. A. Szabo with whom I had the pleasure to work on joint projects and thereby discuss many aspects of the poison phenomenon. I greatly appreciate the joint work, valuable discussions and constant exchange of scientific information and with Prof. H. Bonze1 and Dr. G. Pirug, that helped me to deepen my knowledge in the field of alkali-modified surfaces. Special thanks are due to my colleagues in the Institute of General and Inorganic Chemistry, Prof. L. Dr. M. Tikhov and Dr. G. Rangelov for their enthusiasm and Surnev, dedication to our joint research on alkali modification effects and for their helpful comments on the subject. I acknowledge the financial support of part of my research by the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation (Germany) and the Eastern Europe Program of NSF (USA). Maya P. Kiskinova
CONTENTS
PREFACE Chapter 1. INTRODUCTION Chapter 2. SURFACE SCIENCE METHODS 2.1. DYNAMICAL METHODS 5 2.1.1. Thermal Desorption 5 2.1.2. Molecular Beam Technique 6 2.1.3. Electron and Photon Stimulated Desorption 7 2.1.4. Secondary Ion Mass Spectrometry 8 2.2. STATIC METHODS 8 2.2.1. Low Energy Electron Diffraction 8 2.2.2. Work Function Measurements 9 2.2.3. Emission Spectroscopies 10 2.2.4. Absoption Spectroscopies 12 References 13
Chapter 3 EXPERIMENTAL APPROACH
15
References 18
Chapter 4 INTERACTION OF ATOMIC ADSORBATES, ACTING AS PROMOTERS OR POISONS, WITH SINGLE CRYSTAL SURFACES 4.1. ELECTROPOSITIVE ADDITIVES: ALKALI METALS 19 4.1.1. Surface Order and Surface Concentration 19 4.1.2. Nature of the Adsorption Bond 28 4.1.3. Summary for AlkalilMetal Adsorption Systems 39 4.1.4. Alkali Adsorption on Semiconductor Surfaces 40 4.2. ELECTRONEGATIVE ADDITIVES 41 4.2.1. Surface Structure, Site Occupation and Bond Lengths 41 4.2.2. Strength and Nature of the Surface Bonding 52 4.2.3. Conclusive Remarks 61 References 62
vii
19
...
Vlll
Con tents
Chapter 5 ADSORPTION O F GASES ON SURFACES MODIFIED BY ELECTRONEGATIVE ADDITIVES
5.1. CARBON MONOXIDE 69 5.1.1. General Remarks for CO Adsorption on Clean Metal Surfaces 69 5.1.2. Modifier Effect on the CO Adsorption Energy and on the Surface Adsorptive Capacity 72 5.1.3. Modifier Effect on the CO Adsorption Kinetics 80 5.1.4. Modifier Effect on the CO Adsorption Site Occupation 85 5.1.5. Surface Order in Mixed Overlayers 87 5.1.6. Modifier Effect on the CO Mobility and Bonding Orientation 92 5.1.7. Effect of the Substrate Surface Orientation on the Range and Strength of the Modifier Effect 94 5.1.8. Modifier Effect on the Electronic Structure of the Adsorbed CO Molecule 94 5.1.9. Modifier Effect on CO Dissociative Adsorption 96 5.1.10. Influence of the Chemical State of the'Modifier on the Strength of Poisoning 101 5.1.11. Conclusive Remarks 102 5.2. NITRIC OXIDE 104 5.2.1. General Remarks for NO Adsorption on Clean Metal Surfaces 104 5.2.2. Modifier Effect on the NO Molecular Adsorption 107 5.2.3. Surface Order in Mixed Overlayers 115 5.2.4. Modifier Effect on the NO Dissociative Adsorption 118 5.2.5. Differences in the Effect of Oxygen on the Adsorptive Properties and Reactivity of Pt(ll1) with Respect to CO and NO 120 5.2.6. Differences in the Effects of the NO Dissociation Products 0 and N on the Reactivity of Pt(ll1) and Rh(ll1) Surfaces with Respect to CO Oxidation and NO Reduction 123 5.3. NITROGEN AND OXYGEN 124 5.3.1. General Remarks for N2 Adsorption on Transition Metal Surfaces 124 5.3.2. Modifier Effect on the N 2 Molecular and Dissociative Adsorption 126 5.3.3. Modifier Effect on the 0 2 Adsorption 127 5.4. HYDROGEN 128 5.4.1. Hydrogen Dissociative Adsorption on Modified Surfaces: Adsorption Kinetics, Energetics and Capacity for Adsorption 129 5.4.2. Modifier Effect on the Surface Diffusion of Hydrogen Adatoms 133
69
Contents
ix
5.5. WATER 135 5.6. ORGANIC COMPOUNDS 139 5.6.1. Interaction of Hydrocarbons with Modified Metal Surfaces 140 5.6.2. Effect of S and C on the Interaction of Thiophene with Transition Metal Surfaces 147 5.6.3. Interaction of Alcohols, Aldehydes etc. with Modified Metal Surfaces 150 5.7. CONCLUSIVE REMARKS: THE POISONING EFFECT DESCRIBED WITHIN THE FRAMEWORK OF THE POSSIBLE INTERACTIONS IN THE COADSORBED LAYER 155 References 161 C h a p t e r 6 ADSORPTION OF GASES O N SURFACES MODIFIED BY ALKALI METALS 6.1. CARBON MONOXIDE 169 6.1.1. Alkali Effect on the Kinetics and Energetics of CO Molecular Adsorption 169 6.1.2. Alkali Effect on the Vibrational Properties of the Coadsorbed CO Molecules 178 6.1.3. Surface Order in Mixed Overlayers 183 6.1.4. Alkali Effect on the Electronic Structure of the Coadsorbed CO Molecules 186 6.1.5. Alkali Effect on the CO Bonding Orientation and the C0 Bond Length 198 6.1.6. Conclusive Remarks about the Behaviour of Mixed Alkali-CO Overlayers 200 6.1.7. Alkali Effect on the CO Dissociative Adsorption 203 6.2. CARBON DIOXIDE 208 6.2.1. Alkali Effect on the CO Adsorption Rate, the Surface Adsorptive Capacity and the Stability of the COa Adspecies 209 6.2.2. Alkali Induced Dissociation of COYand Secondarv Reactions in the Mixed Overlayer 212 6.3. NITRIC OXIDE 215 6.3.1. Alkali Effect on the NO Molecular Adsorption 215 6.3.2. Alkali Promoted Dissociation of NO and Secondary Reactions in the Mixed Overlayer 219 6.4. OXYGEN 227 6.4.1. Alkali Effect on the 0 2 Dissociative Adsorption: Adsorption Kinetics and Adsorptive Capacity of the Modified Surface 228
169
Con tents
X
6.4.2. Mutually Induced Stabilization of the Coadsorbed Oxygen and Alkali Species 233 6.4.3. 0 - Alkali Interactions in Mixed Overlayers 238 6.5. WATER 245 6.5.1. Alkali Effect on the H20 Molecular Adsorption 246 6.5.2. Alkali Induced Dissociation of H 2 0 and Stabilization of the Dissociation Products 247 6.6. HYDROGEN 251 6.6.1. Alkali Effect on the H2 Dissociative Adsorption and Saturation Hydrogen Coverage 252 6.6.2. Alkali Effect on the Adsorption State of the Hydrogen Adatoms 253 6.7. NITROGEN 256 6.7.1. Alkali Effect on the N2 Molecular Adsorption Kinetics and N2 Molecular Adsorption State 256 6.7.2. Alkali Promoted N2 Dissociative Adsorption 258 6.8. ORGANIC COMPOUNDS 261 6.8.1. Interaction of Unsaturated Hydrocarbons with Alkali Modified Metal Surfaces 261 6.8.2. Interaction of Alcohols with Alkali Modified Metal Surfaces 264 6.8.3. Conclusive Remarks 266 6.9. AMMONIA 267 6.10. ALKALI MODIFICATION EFFECTS AND FACTORS DETERMINING THE TYPE OF THE INTERACTIONS I N THE MIXED LAYERS 268 6.10.1. Mechanism of the Alkali Stabilization Effect on the Molecular Adsorption State of Acceptor-like Coadsorbates 269 6.10.2. Alkali Effect on the Adsorption Kinetics and Energetics 272 6.10.3. Alkali Effect on the Dissociation Propensity 274 6.10.4. Formation of Compound-like Species in the Mixed Overlayers 275 6.10.5. Conclusive Remarks 276 References 276 Chapter 7 THEORETICAL APPROACHES TO THE DESCRIPTION OF THE MODIFIER EFFECTS 7.1. PROMOTING EFFECT OF ALKALI METAL ADDITIVES 285 7.1.1. Theoretical Models for Alkali Adsorption on Metal Surfaces 285
285
Con ten t s
xi
7.1.2. Theoretical Models for the Alkali Effect on Coadsorbed Molecules 291 7.2. THEORETICAL MODELS FOR THE POISONING EFFECT OF THE ELECTRONEGATIVE ADDITIVES 298 References 306 Chapter 8 MODEL STUDIES O F SURFACE REACTIONS ON MODIFIED SURFACES
309
8.1. METHANATION AND FISCHER - TROPSCH SYNTHESES 310 8.1.1. Effect of Electronegative Additives on the Catalytic Activity and Reactivity 311 8.1.2. Alkali Promoters in Catalysts for CO Hydrogenation 317 8.1.3. Conclusive Remarks 320 8.2. CO OXIDATION: EFFECT OF ELECTRONEGATIVE ADDITIVES 321 8.3. REACTION OF NO AND CO: EFFECT OF S 324
8.4. WATER-GAS SHIFT REACTION 326 8.4.1. Effect of S on the Rate of the Water-Gas Shift Reaction 326 8.4.2. Effect of Cs on the Rate of the Water-Gas Shift Synthesis 327 8.5. AMMONIA SYNTHESIS: K PROMOTION EFFECT 329 8.6. CHEMICAL STATE OF THE ALKALI ADDITIVES UNDER THE REACTION CONDITIONS 331 8.7. CONCLUSIVE REMARKS: CORRELATIONS BETWEEN THE ADSORPTIVE AND THE CATALYTIC ACTIVITY AND SELECTIVITY 332 References 335 INDEX
337
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Chapter 1
INTRODUCTION
The importance of heterogeneous catalysis in modern industry motivated the great interest towards experimental and theoretical studies of gas - solid surface interactions. The phenomenon catalysis is a complex system of various processes. These concerns adsorption, desorption, surface and subsurface diffusion, interactions between chemisorbed atoms, molecules, and molecular fragments. Changes in the surface structure and properties induced by temperature, reactants, products, intermediates and desired or undesired additives are also concerned. Because of the complex nature of the catalytic reactions, many factors should be considered in order to explain the mechanism of each process and its relation t o the main characteristics describing the catalytic reactions: catalytic activity and catalytic selectivity. Catalytic activity is usually expressed by the rate of the desired catalytic reaction, e.g. the number of converted molecules per active site per second, or the number of product molecules per surface substrate atom per second (turnover number). The catalytic selectivity is a characteristic related to the fact that i n most cases, the catalytic reactions take place either successively ( A -kBl L Ck- D )
k3
and/or simultaneously (A
+)
in steps
where only one product of the i-th reaction step is the desired one. Consequently, the selectivity of the catalyst is defined as the fraction of reactant molecules converted to the desired product and is expressed by the ratio It is obvious that changes in selectivity are not always k,(desired)/ accompanied by changes in activity, because the total number of converted reactant molecules might not have changed. In the conventional methods for examining catalysis on an actual scale usually industrial processes are simulated, whereby the same form of supported or non-supported catalysts is used. They involve measurements of the reaction kinetics at various temperatures and partial pressures of the reagents, whereby identification of the rate-limiting step and its activation energy are aimed a t . In some cases the identity of the interacting species may be found by means of vibrational (infrared) spectroscopy. Information on the structure and properties of the catalyst, such as state of dispersion (size of crystallites or clusters), number of active sites and defeck, interatomic distances and coordination number of the catalyst clusters, is usually obtained by means of
CH,.
1
2
Chapter 1.
electron microscopy, X-ray scattering, X-ray absorption spectroscopy and adsorption studies. The usual correlations that come out of systematic studies of different reactions over a series of catalyst,s, concern the relationship between catalytic activity and selectivity for given types of reactions and some of the catalyst properties. By properties is meant the number of active sites, the heats of adsorption of the reactants or products, the position in the periodic table, and the prevailing structure of the micro - crystallites etc. However, the macroscopic reaction rate and product distribution, determined by conventional methods, does not provide a precise description of the single surface processes and the properties of the catalyst surface and surface overlayer on an atomic and molecular level. In order to obtain more accurate information, one should isolate single processes concerned with the catalytic reaction taking place on a well defined surface. This became possible after the development of precise physical methods for the characterization of the structure and chemical state of the solid surfaces and chemisorbed molecules, atoms and radicals. In order to simplify the systems and show the influence of the surface structure and composition on catalytic activity, model studies are usually carried out with single-crystal samples. This ensures investigation of the various steps of the catalytic reaction on well defined surfaces, the structure and composition of which can be changed in a controllable way. Since most of the surface science techniques work under ultra- high vacuum, the experimental conditions in the same chamber are most suitable for studies of chemisorbed, static layers. The sensitivity of most surface techniques enable studies of the interaction of isolated molecules or atoms with the surface, and the induced changes in the adsorbat,e and substrate surface structure and properties. Kinetic studies require a second reaction chamber where the chemical reaction can be carried out at elevated pressures with pure reactants. The connection with the surface analyses chamber ensures precise control of the catalyst surface before and after the reaction. New surface science techniques, applicable to cases inaccessible by the conventional methods, can give information on:
(1) the atomic and electronic structure of the surface, and the changes in this structure induced by the presence of adsorbates;
(2) the identity of the adsorbed molecules, atoms and molecular fragments and the perturbations in their electronic structure as a result of adsorption forces;
(3) the structure of the adsorbate layers, tqhecoordination of the adsorption sites, and the vibrational and energetic properties of the adsorbed species at different concentrations of the adsorbates; (4) the relation between the surface structure and composition and adsorp-
tive and catalytic properties by studying different single crystal surfaces and the introduction of defects (step, kinks, terraces) or foreign atoms with a known concentration, and
(5) the mechanism of the single processes involved in the catalytic reaction.
3 When trying t o describe the mechanism of surface reactions, one should take into account that, for reactions to proceed, including intermediate steps, there must be specific surface sites with specific properties. That is why any changes in the catalyst surface structure and composition might affect the catalytic activity and selectivity. By introducing foreign species, one can modify the properties of the catalyst surface reversibly or irreversibly. The additives may alter the geometrical structure and the chemical state of the surface. This may affect certain reactions. When these effects add to catalytic activity and/ or selectivity, the additivies are called promoters. When these effects detract from the catalytic act,ivity or cause undesired changes of the selectivity, the additives are called inhibitors (when the process is reversible) or poisons (when the process is irreversible). The promoters are generally introduced deliberately during the preparation of the catalyst in order to improve its properties. The catalytic poisons are different in origin. They can be (i) impurities, introduced during the catalyst preparation, which segregate on the surface and occupy certain active sites; (ii) impurities in the reactants or some of the reaction participants. Whether a species acts as a poison or as a promoter depends exclusively on the kind of the catalytic reaction concerned. Since most of the metal-catalyzed reactions, which will be considered in the present manuscript, require cheniisorption and/or dissociation of reactants with electron acceptor behaviour (CO, NO, 0 2 , N z , etc.), one should expect that elements which are electronegative in respect of the metal catalyst, should act as poisons and vice versa. Following this conventional definition, the terms electronegative and electropositive additives will be used hereafter. Over the past decade a great number of surface science studies have been dedicated t o coadsorption experiments on single crystal metal surfaces modified by foreign atoms. These model experiments play a significant role in understanding the contribution of various factors to the poisoning and promotion phenomena. The purpose of this monograph is to summarize what has recently been achieved by surface science model studies (on single crystal surfaces with controlled amounts of modifiers and coadsorbates) in developing a consistent picture of the mechanism of poisoning and promotion effects. The main scientific issues which will be considered are related to:
(1) the influence of additives on the chemisorptive properties of the substrate with respect to molecular and dissociative adsorption; (2) the contribution of different factors, such as atomic size, electronegativity, adsorption state, surface order, and surface concentratmionof the additive, on the direction and the strength of the modifying effects;
(3) the nature of the modifier - coadsorbate interactions, and (4) the relationship between the modified chemisorptive properties and the observed changes in the cat,alytic activity and selectivity of some catalytic systems.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Chapter 2
SURFACE SCIENCE METHODS
Since a great number of books has already appeared, giving detailed descriptions of the surface science methods (e.g. refs. [I, 2]), a brief classification and a description of the most common techniques will suffice. 2.1
DYNAMIC METHODS
The techniques used, when applying these methods, cause the adsorbed molecules, atoms or radicals to be desorbed from the surface and analyzed in the gas phase. A mass-spectrometer is normally used as the gas analyzer. The desorption of the surface species can be achieved in various ways, e.g. by means of a programmed increase of the substrate surface temperature or by irradiation of the surface layer by electrons, photons, atoms or ions. 2.1.1
Thermal Desorption
This widely used method is based on measuring the flux of the desorbing species for a given adsorption system [3-81. The desorption is induced by heating the sample using an adequate temperature ramp (temperatureprogrammed desorption, TPD) [3-71, or pulse laser beam (laser-induced desorption, LID) [8]. The desorption flux is usually recorded and analyzed by a mass spectrometer. For a linear temperature ramp the desorption rate can be described by the relationship:
dN - V dP S _ dt - w[dt+l/p]l where N is the adsorbate surface concentration in molecules per cm ', P is the pressure change induced by the desorbing particles, S is the pumping rate of the system in 1 per sec, A is the adsorbent surface in cm 2 , V is the volume of the system and Tg is the temperature in the gas phase. With S >> V as the limit and a slow heating rate ( d T / d t ) the desorption rate ( d N / d t ) becomes proportional to the pressure changes induced by the desorbing particles. Taking into account that the modern experimental chambers are characterized by V 5 20 1, and S > 400 I.sec-', aiid d T / d t is usually less than 20' sec-l, 5
Chapter 2.
6
the mathematical description of the T P D spectra obtained is simplified considerably. Thus the traces of the T P D spectra usually reflect the desorption rate directly from the i-th adsorption state, as described by the Polanyi Wigner equation [9, 101:
where ni is the order of desorption, E, is the activation energy of desorption, v, is the frequency factor and N , is the surface concentration for the i-th adsorption state. Thus, in the case of E,, n, and v, independent of the adsorbate surface concentration the relation between the desorption parameters and the experimental thermal desorption curves for n, = 1 can be described by [4]:
Ei RT
- = In
(y) vi.T .
3.46,
(3)
where p = dT/dt, and Tpd is the temperature at the maximum of the corresponding T P D peak. For ni = 2, the relation can be given by [4]:
where Nio is the initial coverage. In actual fact, the desorption parameters can be independent of coverage only with the limits of very low coverages. This calls for full analyses of the complex T P D spectra obtained at moderate and high coverages [5, 9-11]. The T P D method is rather popular because it is relatively cheap and can be applied to many adsorption systems. The T P D data provide information about the adsorbate surface coverage (the area under the T P D spectra is directly proportional to the adsorbate surface concentration), the existence of different adsorption states (an appearance of several TPD peaks), the adsorption and desorption kinetic parameters, the existence of different adsorption states at different adsorbate coverages (from the changes in the shape of the T P D spectra), the interactions between the adsorbed species, the phase transitions in the adsorbate layer, etc. In order to obtain reliable information, it is necessary to avoid side effects, such as recording desorption from the sample supports, a temperature gradient across the crystal, possible laser-induced damage t o the surface, etc. [6,7]. When interpreting the data, especially the multi - peak T D spectra, care must be taken, because in some cases the temperature rise might cause interconversion between the adsorption states. Consequently, the different peaks in the T P D spectra do not necessarily reflect a coexistence of different adsorption st,at,es at the given adsorption temperature. 2.1.2
Molecular Beam Technique
Rapid progress has been made recently with molecular beam experiments because they represent a good approach to the heterogeneously catalyzed surface
2.1. Dynamic Methods
7
reactions [12-141. In these experiments, the sample or t h e detectors (or both) can be moved so that the molecular beams of the molecules, atoms or fragments under study can be directed and reflected elastically or inelastically by the substrate surface a t different angles. This ensures variation of the angle of incidence of the molecular beam, an independent change of the gas and surface temperature, and allows direct analysis of the reaction products by means of a mass spectrometer. The use of a mass spectrometer as an analyzer and lock-in phase sensitive detection restricts the measurements only to the primary reaction products of interest. Furthermore, by using a modulated molecular beam and by first analyzing the phase shift between the input and output signal, it is possible to obtain information about the residence time of the adsorbing species at different substrate temperatures and to deduce the adsorption/desorption parameters and the mechanism of the surface processes. 2.1.3
Electron and Photon Stimulated Desorption (ESD and PSD) and Electron Stimulated Desorption - Angular Distribution (ESDAD)
This method is based on analyses of the particles (ions and neutrals) desorbed as a result of electronic excitations of the adsorbed surface species, induced by electron or photon irradiation 11, 15-17]. A variety of molecular and fragment ions and neutrals ( either in ground or in electronically excited states) have been detected from the adsorbed overlayers as electron (photon)-stimulated products. Two mechanisms are proposed for explaining the electron- stimulated desorption. According to the first mechanism (known as Menzel, Gonier and Redhead model) [15, IS], the first step of electronic excitation is a FrankCondon transition from a ground to nonbonding (repulsive) state. This primary excitation can be followed by different events leading either to quenching of the excitation (by delocalization and trapping of the particles in an attractive potential well) or t o the removal of the excited particle from the surface (by transfer of the electronic energy to a nuclear motion as a result of the electronic rearrangements). On it,s way away, the excited particle may be transferred to another repulsive potential curve which determines the nature of the detected products (positive or negat>iveions or neutrals). In this model, the total desorption cross section is usually given by the relationship: u = u,.P,
where u, is the excitation cross section for the gas phase and P is the escape probability. P depends on the shape of the repulsive potential curve which determines the kinetic energy of the desorbing particle and the lifetime of the excited state a t the surface. According t o the second model suggested by Knotek and Feibelman [17], the primary excitation is a core excitation that decays by an interatomic Auger transition. As a result of this Auger decay, the ion which was negatively charged originally, loses electrons and becomes positively charged. This leads to the desorption of positive ions due to the inversion of the Madelung
8
Chapter 2.
potential. This model is primarily applicable to systems with an ionic bond at the highest valence state. As was mentioned above, while the desorbing particles are leaving the surface, they can undergo different transitions leading to the recapture or a change in the charged state. What happens very much depends on the environment of the adsorbed particles. Depending on the type of the excitation process involved, the cross section of the different ESD products can vary substantially with the changes of the adsorption state and the adsorbate coverage. These variations provide inherent information on the nature of surface - adsorbate interactions and bonding and the changes induced by changes in coverage or modifications of the surface. It is assumed that the directions of the desorbing beams are exclusively determined by the bond orientation of the initial state which allows the angular distribution measurements of the species desorbing by electron or photon stimulation, as developed by using the ESDAD method [18-21). A movable mass - spectrometer [20], a phosphorus screen [I91 or a resistive anode [21] can be used as detector for the ESDAD patterns of the excit,ed ESD products. The uniqueness of the ESDAD method is that i t is passing on information about single species on the surface. It does not require long-range ordering but azimuthal ordering for abnormal directions. This method turns out to be a sensitive probe, concerning the chemisorption bond angles, the site location, the amplitudes of the soft bending molecular vibrations parallel to the surface and their dependence on temperature, coverage and surface composition.
2.1.4
Secondary Ion Mass Spectrometry (SIMS)
This method is based on mass analysis of the species sputtered from the surface as a result of bombardment with highly energetic particles, usually Ar ions with energies in the keV range [I, 221. The emission of the surface particles is induced by energy transfer from the impact ions to the substrate lattice atoms or to the adsorbates. The mass analysis of the sputtered particles contains information about the surface composition. It also provides information on the local structure using the kind of the fragments monitored by the mass spectrometer and the angular dependence of the ion emission as a fingerprint. Depending on the density of the incident-beam current (ranging from 1 nA cm-2 t o 1 mA emd2), this technique can be used for accurate surface and bulk analysis, which provides information on a depth scale.
2.2
STATIC METHODS
These methods involve analyses of the stationary adsorbed phase by means of various spectroscopies based on the interaction of electroils and photons with the surface layer.
2.2.1
Low Energy Electron Diffraction (LEED)
This method is based on recording and doing spatial analysis of the elastically back scattered low energy (15-350 eV) primary electrons from the surface [l, 2, 23, 241. According t o the Lue de Broglie equation [l],which describes the
2.2. Static Methods
9
interference phenomena in electrons scattered by a crystal, the pronounced maxima in the angular distribution of the back scattered electrons displayed on the detector (phosphorus screen or resistive anode) reflect the periodicity of the surface and the possible variations as a result of reconstruction or formation of ordered adsorbate superstructures. In the case of a two - dimensional lattice consisting of parallel rows of atoms in the directions [k,h] and interatomic distances dk,h the Lue de Broglie equation becomes:
where A is the wave length, 90 the angle of the primary electron beam, andps the angle of the reflected electrons. Usually in the LEED systems, ‘po is 0’. Thus the diffraction pattern reflects the periodicity on the surface and the changes induced by the increase of coverage, introduction of coadsorbates, reconstruction of the substrate surface etc. The main driving force for obtaining ordered adsorbate structures on a single cryst,al substrate is determined by the type of adsorbate - substrate and adsorbate - adsorbate interactions. Complete structural analysis of the LEED patterns is possible applying the kinematic theory and measuring the intensity of the diffracted beam as a function of the direction and energy of the primary electron beam [23,24]. This ensures determination of the site location of surface species within the unit cell, and the corresponding adsorbate - adsorbate distances and adsorbate - substrate bond lengths. 2.2.2
W o r k Function Measurements
The change of the work function upon structural and/or composition changes on the surface provides valuable information on the electrostatic potential of the surface which affects its reactivity [25]. Work function is usually described by the relationship: 4 = A4 - m / e , (7) where A@ represents the electrostatic potential of the surface double layer and xel the chemical potential of the electron in the bulk. Since the chemical potential is a bulk property and is not much affected by modification of the surface, it is the change of the double layer that generally determines the work function changes that are observed. The surface potential in the adsorption systems arises because of the presence of dipoles. The potential difference on the two sides of the dipole layer is given by the equation:
Ad = 4 ~ , u N ,
(8)
where N and p are the concentration of the dipoles and the dipole moment of each species on the layer. When the concentration of the surface dipoles increases, the depolarization effects should be ascribed to dipole-dipole interactions. In this case, the surface potential can be expressed by the following equation: 4?rp0N A$ = (9) 1 +9a”
10
Chapter 2.
where LY is the polarizability of the adsorbed species and po is the initial dipole moment. The absolute values of the work function can be determined by three methods only: thermo-ionic, field emission methods and a He1 ultraviolet photoemission method [25, 271. Since usually the relative change of the surface potential, Ad, is the only important factor, many other methods can be used, such as a vibrating capacitor, a diode (retarding potential) method, a secondary electron method (cut-off of the low energy secondary electrons created by electron or photon irradiation on the surface), etc. [25]. It should be pointed out that, together with information about the sign and strength of the surface dipoles, some of the informat,ion on the uniformity of the surface layer is obtained by using these methods, e.g. by the diode method [26, 271. In mixed overlayers the coexistence of patches of different work functions, compositions and structures on the surface (which is difficult to detect with other methods) can be established. 2.2.3
Emission Spectroscopies
Depending on the kind of emission which is recorded and used for characterization of the overlayer, the emission spectroscopies can be classified into two general groups: A. Electron emission spectroscopies. These involve spectroscopies based on measurements of the intensities and the kinetic energies of the electrons emitted from various electron levels of the matter under investigation. Depending on the primary irradiation that causes the electron emission, these spectroscopies can be divided as follows: (a) Spectroscopies in which the primary irradiation is performed by electrons. The Auger Electron Spectroscopy (AES) falls in this category [1,2]. This is the most widely used technique for the quantitative and qualitative analysis of surface layers. The principle of the method is based on detection and analysis of the energy distribution of the Auger electrons ejected from the surface as a result of excitation induced by irradiation with electrons of primary energy (typically between 1500-5000 eV). The energies of the secondary Auger electrons is determined by the following relationship:
where E,, Ey and E , are the binding energies of the three electron levels involved in the Auger process, E, is the correction for relaxation of the levels as a result of changes in the amounts of the charges, caused by the creation of a core hole, and e4sp is the work function of the spectrometer. It is obvious from eq.(lO) that the kinetic energy of the emitted Auger electron is independent of the primary excitation energy. Information derived from the energy position, intensity and shape of the Auger spectra has been successfully used for the determination of surface concentration and changes in the chemical state of the adsorbate and substrake. The surface sensitivity of AES depends on the primary excitation energy and the energy of the given Auger transition. Usually, Auger electrons with a low kinetic energy are operative at valence electron levels and are much more sensitive to the interactions in the overlayer and changes in the chemical d a t e of the interacting species.
2.2. Static Methods
11
(b) Photoelectron spectroscopies, where the primary irradiation is electromagnetic (photons). In this class are: X-ray excited Auger electron spectroscopy (XAES), X-ray photo-electron spectroscopy (XPS), ultraviolet electron spectroscopy (UPS), extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS) etc. [1,2]. The XPS and UPS methods are based on detection of the kinetic energies, &n, of the photoelectrons ejected from discrete electron levels of the adsorbate or substrate as a result of irradiation by a monochromatic photon beam with an energy hv. When using the relationship:
one can determine the binding energy in electron level 12, E g , with respect to the vacuum level. XPS and UPS differ in the energy of the primary excitation beam. Usually, the irradiation sources for XPS give beams with energies by 150-8000 eV. XPS is most appropriate for the determination of the electron states in the core levels. The information originating from the XPS spectra includes data. on : the m t u r e of adsorbates a.nd suhstmtes, the surface concentration (which is directly proportional t.0 the int,ensity of the photoelectrons emitted from tlie deep core levels), the chmiges i n chemical state of the surface species (from the energy shifts), tlie coordination of the adsorbed molecules etc. The energy of tlie primary photon beam for UPS is less than 100 eV (usually 10-45 eV). The information based on UPS concerns mainly the valence electron states, binding energies of the molecular orbitals, and the changes induced by interactions on the surface. As has been mentioned in subsection 2.2.2., t8he UPS method can also be applied for work function measurements [I]. The EXAFS method is based 011 the fact, that the photoelectrons a,re emitted as a result of X-ray a.bsorption hack scattered off neighboring atoms. This results in interference between the outgoing and back - scattered photoelectron waves. This interference process produces a,n oscillatory modulation in the X-ray absorption spectrum within the energy range beyond the absorption threshold. Analyses of this oscilhtory fraction in the X-ray absorption spectrum provide information on the local structure around the absorbing species. The advantage of this met,Iiod is that, contrary to the diffraction methods (such as LEED and X-ray diffraction), it does not require a longrange periodicity. (c) Spectroscopies where the primary irra.diation is performed by noble gas ions and metastable atoms with low kinetic energies. To this class belong the metastable quenching spectroscopy (MQS) or penning ionization electron spectroscopy (PIES) [l]. This method is b a e d on t,he fact that the interaction of noble gas ions or excited neutrals with a surface layer forces neutralization accompanied by a.n electron emission. Depending on t,he deexitation mechanism, the resulting electron energy spectra. conbain information on t.he energy position of the molecu1a.r orbitals, the electron levels near t,he Fermi level etc. B. Photoemission spectroscopies. These a.re the spect,roscopies based on measurements of tlie intensities and the energies of the electroma.gnetic radiation emitted as a result of the interaction of slow electrons with the surface layer. In this class a.re the appearance potential spectroscopy (APS) [l]and the inverse photoemission spectroscopy (IPS) [1,28].
12
Chapter 2.
The APS method is based on measuring the X-ray intensity emitted from the surface irradiated with electrons, on which , in the background, which is steadily gaining in strength, a characteristic emission is superimposed. The latter appears when the primary beam energy equals the threshhold energy of excitation of an electron from a core level to an unfilled state above the Fermi level. APS spectra contain information about the core level binding energies and the density of unfilled states above the Fermi level. IPS is based on a process which is to photoemission, i.e. a radiative deexcitation of electrons. Thus, the energy distribution of the emitted photons reflects the electron density of the unoccupied stat,es of the adsorbate and substrate. It should be pointed out that the photoemission spectroscopies provide information about the empty electron density of states above the Fermi level and the unoccupied adsorbate electron orbitals, whereas the electron emission spectroscopies carry information exclusively on the occupied electronic states of the substrate and the occupied molecular or atomic orbitals of the adsorbates. 2.2.4
Absorption Spectroscopies
The absorption spectroscopies are based on monitoring of the energy spectra of the inelastically back-scattered primary electrons (electron loss spectroscopies) or reflected electromagnetic radiation (infrared spectroscopy - IR). A. Electron loss spectroscopy. Depending on the characteristic energy losses two categories of electron loss spectroscopies are distinguished on the basis of the energy of the primary electron beam: (a) Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy (EELS), where the primary electron energies are of the order of 100 eV. The characteristic energy spectra are a result of energy losses caused by the induction of interband and intraband transitions, plasmon and core level electron excitations in the surface layers and one electron transitions in molecules, atoms or molecular fragments present on the surface. These losses are usually observed in the 1-50 eV range and the energies of the loss peaks are determined by the separation of the two electron levels involved in the induced electron transition or the excitation energy for the plasma oscillations. (b) High Resolution Electron Energy Loss spectroscopy (HREELS), where the primary energy is of the order of a few eV and the electron losses are caused by excitations of the vibrational modes (phonons) at the surface or in the adsorbed species. These losses are nearly of the order of 100 meV. HREELS has been successfully applied in studies of interfacial properties of thin films, and bonding configurations of adsorbed species. Information obtained by HREELS regarding the vibrations excited in the adsorbed molecular species is very similar to that offered by infrared spectroscopy, where the same excitations are induced by electromagnetic irradiation.
References
13
B. Infrared reflection absorption spectroscopy [29]. The advantage of this vibrational spectroscopy is the higher resolution than that of HREELS and the absence of possible electron beam effects. Recently, it is widely applied for the determination of the bonding mode orientation of adsorbed molecules and interactional effects between adsorbed species. It is worth mentioning here that the vibrational spectroscopies are directly related t o the fact that any adsorbate on the surface is vibrating. The possible vibrational modes are determined by the symmetry of the adsorbed species. The symmetry depends on the number of the substrate atoms participating in the formation of the adsorption bond. The possible adsorption sites on single crystal surfaces are determined by the crystallographic orientation of the surface plane. For example, for a fcc (111) surface there are one-, two- and three-fold adsorption sites, depending on the number of the nearest substrate surface atoms.
REFERENCES G . Ertl and J. Kiippers, Low Energy Electrons and Surface Chemistry, 2nd ed. (Verlag Cheniie, Weinheim, 1986) D. P. Woodruff and T. C. Delchar, Cambridge Solid State Sciences Series, eds. R. Cahn, E. Davies and I. Ward (Cambridge, 1986) G. Erlich, J. AppJ. Phys. 32 (1961) 4; Adv. Catalysis 14 (1963) 255 P. A. Redhead, Vacuum 12 (1962) 203 L. D. Schmidt, Catalysis Rev.-Sci. Eng. 9 (1974) 115 L. P. Levine, J. F. Ready and E. Bernalg, J . appl. Phys. 38 (1967) 531; 1EE J . Quantum Electron. QE-4 (1968) 18 [71 D. Menzel, in: Chemistry and Physics of Solid Surfaces, eds. R. Vanselow and R. Rowe (Springer Series in Chemical Physics, 1981) p.389 J. T. Yates, in: Experimental Methods of Experimental Physics vol.22, ed. R. L. Park (Academic Press, 1985) p.425 D. A . King, Surface Sci. 47 (1975) 384 E. G. Seebauer, A. C. F. Kong and L. D. Schmidt, Surface Sci. 193 (1988) 417
J. B. Miller, H. R. Siddiqui, S. M. Gates, J. N. Russel Jr., J . T. Yates Jr., J. C. Tully and M. J. Cardillo, J . Chem. Phys. 87 (1987) 6725 P. M. Merrill, Cat. Rev. 4 (1970) 115 M. P. D’Evelyn and R. J. Madix, Surface Sci.Reports 3 (1983) 413 J. A. Barker and D. J. Auerbach, Surface Sci. Reports 4 (1984) 1 D. Menzel and R. Gomer, J . Chem. Phys. 41 (1964) 3311 P. A. Redhead, Can. J . Phys. 42 (1964) 886 M. L. Knotec and P. J. Feibelman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 40 (1978) 904 J. J. Czyzewsky, T. E. Madey and 3. T. Yates Jr., Phys. rev. Lett. 32 (1974) 777
T. E. Madey, D. L. Doering, E. Bertel and R. Stockbauer, Ultramicroscopy I1 (1983) 187 and references therein D. Menzel, Nucl. Instr. and Methods in: Physics Research, Vol. B13 (1986) 50
M. Alvey, M. J. Dresser and J. T. Yates Jr., Phys. Rev. Lett. 56 (1986) 367 A. Benninghoven, J . Phys. 230 (1970) 403; Surface Sci. 57 (1975) 596
14
Chapter 2
[23]
J. B. Pendry, Low Energy Electron Diffraction eds. G. M. Conn and I<. R.
[24]
M. A. Van Hove and S. Y. Tong, Surface Crystallography by LEED,(Springer
[25]
J. Holzl, F. Schulte in: Solid Surface Physics , vo1.85 of Springer Tracts in
[26] [27] [28] [29]
Modern Physics (Springer, Berlin, 1979) p.85 A. G. Knapp, Surface Sci. 34 (1973) 289 I. I. Ionov, Soviet Phys. Tech. Phys. 43 (1973) 159 V. Dose, Surface Sci. Reports, 3 (1985) 337 and the references therein F. M. Hoffmann, Surface Sci. Reports 3 (1983) 107
Coleman (Academic Press, London, 1974) Berlin, 1979)
Chapter 3
EXPERIMENTAL APPROACH
A scheme of an experimental system for adsorption and reaction model studies is shown in figs. 3.1. and 3.2. The ultra-high vacuum (UHV) conditions with a base pressure less than P a can be achieved by using a combination of diffusion, turbo-molecular, ion-sorption and titanium sublimation pumps. The composition of the residual gases is checked by a mass-spectrometer and, depending on the type of the pumps used it consists of varying amounts of Ha, COz, CO, CH4, HzO and Ar. In addition to the mass-spectrometer the UHV analysis chamber is equipped with several other surface analytical facilities, the use of which depends on the objectives of the study.
7
C MA
Fig. 3.1. A scheme of a typical UHV experimental chamber equipped with selected surface sensitive techniques.
The usual experimental approa,ch of model surface science studies is by first obtaining substrate surfaces that a.re not contaminated by undesired atoms.
15
16
Chapter 3.
The cleaning procedure depends on the nature of the substrate. Several different kinds of treatment may be necessary, such as annealing, ion bombardment with high energy noble gas (Ar) ions, which remove the dirty surface layers; or chemical types of treatment, such as oxidation/reduction reactions. When a single crystal is used as a model catalyst, it should necessarily be accurately oriented and polished before insertion into the experimental chamber. After cleaning, the substrate surface is characterized with respect to structure and composition. The structure of the single crystal surface is usually determined by using the LEED method. The cleanliness is verified by means of XPS and AES. A well-ordered surface should show distinct reflections, which should characterize the corresponding crystallographic plane. A surface which does not show traces of contaminants, may be considered 'clean', i.e. free from foreign atoms. The criterion for accepting the cleanliness of the surface lies in the sensitivity limits of the AES or XPS method used, which will be of the order of 0.01 part of the monolayer (ML).
Analysis and Surface Preparrlioa Cbanber
Fig. 3.2. A combined system consisting of high pressure reaction and UHV analysis chambers, allowing translation of the crystal.
The amount of foreign particles on the surface is usually expressed by the ratio of the number of foreign particles per number of substrate surface atoms, taking the absolute number of the substrate surface atoms as one monolayer (ML). Another way of expressing this is the number of foreign particles per cm2. These two ways of expressing the foreign particles coverage differ by the factor of the number of the substrate atoms per cm2. In some cases, when the absolute coverage is unknown, the unit-fractional coverage is used.
17 I t is related to the maximum adsorbate coverage achieved under the actual experimental conditions. The calibration of the absolute adsorbate coverage is easiest when the adsorbate layer forms ordered superstructures. In the other cases relative methods can be applied, e.g. comparison of the intensities of TPD, XPS or AES spectra for a given adlayer with those corresponding to adsorbate layers with a known concentration. A controllable introduction of the modifiers can be performed in several ways. Alkali metals which are very frequently used as promoters in several important catalytic processes, are deposited in situ onto the clean substrate surface. Various alkali metal sources have been used, such as ion exchanged zeolites [l],alloys, consisting of a high percentage of a desired alkali metal [a], or compound dispensers (SAES getters: a mixture of alkali metal chromate and a Zr-A1 alloy which acts as a reducing agent) [3]. The principle which applies t o all sources is, after sufficient (several hours) outgassing under UHV conditions at appropriate temperatures, a flux consisting of pure alkali atoms and/or ions is obtained. The production of this flux requires relatively high temperatures (> 800 I<). The actual formation temperature of an alkali flux depends on the type of the source and the alkali metal present. The sources are designed in a way such, that the alkali flux can be directed and deposited onto the sample. Usually, after the outgassing procedure, the sources are calibrated for different working temperatures. This ensures a rough estimation of the conditions (evaporation at a given temperature) necessary to achieve the desired alkali coverage. Another procedure for the introduction of a modifier is to adsorb a gas which contains the modifier [4]. The adsorbed species, after appropriate heat treatments, dissociate on the surface and the undesired components are desorbed, whereas t,he modifier remains bonded to the surface. In this way, many modifiers, behaving as poisons in many catalytic reactions, are deposited on the surface of the model catalysts. For example, S is introduced by adsorbing H2S, P by PH3, Se by H2Se, Te by H2Te, C by CzH4 or CzH4, N by N2H4. In all these cases, after dissociation, H can be removed by desorption at elevated temperatures. Sometimes it is possible to introduce the modifier directly by dissociative adsorptioii, e.g.S by Sz, C1 by Cl2, 0 by 0 2 etc. The cleanliness and the concentration of the modifier overlayer can be determined by a variety of surface sensitive techniques, described in Chapter 2. Normally the following methods are applied: AES (where the intensity of the modifier’s most intensive Auger transition is measured), XPS (where the intensity of a chosen intensive core level peak of the modifier is measured), T P D (where the modifier can be desorbed at elevated temperatures, e.g. alkali metals). The calibration of the modifier AES or XPS signals to absolute coverages might be performed in several ways, e.g. by mass-spectrometric measurements of the undesired species resulting from dissociation which desorb upon heating (H in the case of H2S, HzSe, HzTe, PH3, NzH4, C2H2, and C2H4), direct thermal desorption of the modifier, when possible ( 0 2 , Cl2, N 2 , and alkali metals), radiotracer measurements, LEED, when the modifier forms ordered overlayer structures, etc. The uniformity and ordering of the modifier overlayer can be determined by scanning AES, LEED, and EXAFS. Furthermore, the modified surface can be characterized by the techniques available
Chapter 3.
18
in the chamber in order t o gain information about the nature of the surface UPS, TPD), the adsorption site (e.g. EXAFS, HREELS), the perturbations induced in the geometric structure of the substrate surface (e.g. LEED, EXAFS), the changes in electronic structures of the substrate and adsorbate as a result of the adsorption bond formation (e.g. XPS, UPS, MQS), etc. The next step, after modifying the substrate with a desired amount of an additive, is the adsorption studies. The modified surface is exposed to a gas (reactant or product of a certain catalytic reaction) whose interaction with the surface is of interest. In order to have a basis for comparison, these coadsorption experiments are usually preceded by the characterization of the gas - clean surface interactions. The adsorption experiments on modified surfaces include measurements a t various modifier and coadsorbate concentrations. This ensures a description of the coverage effects on the surface chemisorptive properties and on the strength of the modifier - coadsorbate interactions. The available experimental techniques are applied in order to show up all the aspects of the modifier effects on the chemisorptive properties of the surface. All experiments described above are designed so as to simplify the systems in order to obtain reliable information about each step involved in the complex catalytic processes. The conditions in these model adsorption experiments (specimens, pressures and environment) are far from the real technological conditions. More realistic conditions are created by using a second reactor chamber, in series with the first one. The model experiment is carried out in the first UHV chamber, kinetic stmudiesat elevated pressures in the second. Usually, this second chamber is equipped with a chromatograph or mass spectrometer for measuring the reaction rate [5-71. The advantage of these double chamber systems is that they ensure thorough characterization of the catalyst surface structure, composition, and chemisorptive properties before and after the reaction. As will be illustrated in the forthcoming sections, this combination enables precise studies of the effect of various modifiers with different surface concentrations and surface orders on the catalyst reactivity and selectivity. - modifier bonding (e.g. WF, LEED, SEXAFS, angle resolved
REFERENCES [l] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7]
R. E. Weber and L. F. Cordes, Rev. Sci. I m t r . 37 (1966) 112 G. Broden and H . P. Bonzel, Surface Sci. 84 (1979) 106 SAES Getters S.p.A. Via Gallarate 215 Milano, Italy M. Kiskinova, Surface Sci. Reports 8 (1988) 359 G. A. Somorjai, Catalysis Rev.-Sci. Eng. 18 (1978) 173 H. P. Bonzel, G. Broden and H. J. Krebs, Appl. Surface Sci. 16 (1983) 373 D. W. Goodman, J . Vac. Sci. TechnoJ. 2 (1984) 873
Chapter 4
INTERACTION OF ATOMIC ADSORBATES, ACTING AS PROMOTERS O R POISONS WITH SINGLE CRYSTAL METAL SURFACES
4.1 E L E C T R O P O S I T I V E ADDITIVES: A L K A L I M E T A L S Among the most important additives used to promote a desired function of metal and metal oxide catalysts are alkali metals. They can be present at the surface in different manners ranging from sub monolayer quantities to surface or bulk compound. Originally, alkali metal salts were used in the manufacture of iron catalysts for ammonia synthesis [l]. Now alkali promoters are used in a number of catalytic reactions, e.g. Haber - Bosch (ammonia) synthesis, Fischer - Tropsch (hydrocarbon) synthesis, alcohol synthesis, water-gas shift reaction, etc. [2-41. Alkali metals are strongly electropositive elements with low ionization potentials (5.39, 5.14, 4.34, 4.18 and 3.89 eV for Li, Na, K, Rb and Cs, respectively). The first studies of alkali metals adsorption on transition metal surfaces were reported in 1920’s. A drastic lowering of the work fuiiction induced by the presence of alkali metals was established [5, 61. Since then a great number of studies have been dedicated to understanding the physics and chemistry of alkali metal adsorption on metal or semiconductor surfaces. 4.1.1
Surface Order and Surface Concentration of Alkali 0verlayers
A. Ordering and structural transformations of the alkali overlayers. When alkali metal is adsorbed on a single crystal metal surface, depending on the adlayer surface concentration and the adsorption temperature, two dimensionally commensurate and incommensurate ordered structures can be formed [7-161. At low temperatures a series of ordered structures are observed in the different alkali adsorpt>ionsystems [7]. Selected phase diagrams for N a on Ru(0001) [22] and Cs on Rh(100) [8, 121 are shown in figs. 4.1-4.3. It is obvious that, because of the significant changes in the adsorption state and
19
20
Chapter 4.
the surface diffusion rate of the alkali metals, the adsorption temperature at which ordered alkali structures exist, increases with increasing surface density of the adatoms. That is why in most cases where alkali adsorption is studied at room temperature, ordered overlayer structures are formed only a t coverages near saturation of the first overlayer. The formation of ordered structures is determined by the balance between the adatom - adatom interactions and the periodic surface potential contour. The relative magnitude of these forces determines whether the overlayer order will be commensurate (in-registry with substrate geometric structure) or incommensurate (out-of registry with the substrate geometric structure).
O
.
0.2
0.3
0.L
0.5
J
Na Coverage Fig. 4.1. A phase diagram for Na on Ru(0001). ‘Split ( f i x &)R30 epitaxy phase. ‘TR’ means transition region (from ref.[22]).
is a rotational
At low coverages the repulsive dipole-dipole interactions between the alkali adspecies are dominating. This leads to the stabilization of a structure with the largest possible distance between the adspecies. The adsorption sites are determined by the surface potential contour and in most cases these are the sites with the highest surface atoms coordination number (e.g. three-fold hollow sites on fcc (111) and hpc (0001) planes, or four-fold sites on fcc (loo), fcc (110) and bcc (100)).The mean mutual distance decreases with increasing surface density which also leads to occupation of less favourable adsorption sites. This subject will be discussed in greater detail in Subsection 4.1.2. Table 4.1. summarizes several selected data on the alkali induced superstructures observed on different substrate crystallographic planes at room temperature. Typical of the closed packed fcc(lll) , hpc(0001) and bcc(ll0)
4.1. Electropositive Additives: Alkali Metals
21
planes is the formation of hexagonal super-structures.
Fig. 4.2. Model structures for the different phases of Na on Ru(0001). Open circles represent Na atoms in symmetric sites. Hatched circles are Na atoms in asymmetric sites (from ref.[22])
Obeying the requirement about a minimum energy of the system, in some cases the highest coordinated sites are abandoned in order to form a structure where the repulsion between the species is the weakest. Examples of surface orders where various structures appear as a result of the phase tran-
22
Chapter 4.
i
CslRh (1001 LATTICE GAS
(333
t
5) K
- 300Y
0, L
3
c
e 200-
(155
OI
g :
e!
(145 t 5 ) . ..... ... .
loo-"
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.L
05
Cs Coverage
"r.1 o=f I3.21-ZCS
Fig. 4.3. Phase diagram, schematic LEED pattern and real space models for Cs on Rh(100) with increasing Cs coverage (from ref. [8])
4.1. Electropositive Additives: Alkali Metals
23
sitions with increasing alkali coverage are shown in figs. 4.2. and 4.3. Phase transitions leading to the conversion from commensurate to incommensurate superstructures are likely at high alkali coverages. Table 4.1. Ordered Superstructures and the Corresponding Alkali Coverages, @ A M , (in ML - adatoms per substrate surface atom) for Several Single Crystal Metal Planes a t T = 290 K. In brackets the surface atomic density in atoms.cm-' for each surface plane is given.
SURFACE fcc Ni(100) (1.6 x Na/Ni(100)
OAM
0 0.25 0.5 I
STRUCTURE 1x1 P(2 x 2 ) c(2 x 2 ) P(2 x 2 ) hexagonal-incommensurate hexagonal-incommensurate 1x1 disordered & x &)R30° 1 x 1 1 / 3 x 1/3 &)R30° (& x &)R30° 1x1 incommensurate in [1210] c(2 x 2) incommensurate in [310] c(2 x 2 ) incommensurate in mi01
(Ax
In their thorough studies on the structures of alkali metal overlayers and the driving forces of the surface phase transitions, Naumovets et a1 [9, 14, 161 have shown that even at temperatures as low as 100 I< the surface mobility of the alkali metals is very high so that the format>ionof ordered structures is not hindered kinetically. The general trend in the changes of the diffusion coefficient is a decrease with increasing coverages but, as is illustrated in fig. 4.4., this decrease is rather nonmonotonous and correlates with the structural changes occurring in the overlayer. An important conclusion from the alkali diffusion studies is that despite the alkali coverage and the crystallographic orientation, the diffusion coefficient and the type of the ordered structures are strongly dependent on the nature of the substrate. For example, for the same crystallographic planes with almost identical lattice constants, such as M o ( l l 0 ) and W(110), the phase diagrams and the surface diffusion rates for Li differ substantially [16]. This fact demonstrates the importance of the electronic surface structure in the formation of ordered overlayers.
24
Chapter 4.
Fig. 4.4. Plots of lg D versus Li coverage on W(Ol1) at different temperatures:(l) 130 K; (2) 175 K; (3) 200 K; (4) 225 I< (from ref. [9])
Consequently, the numerous structural data on the alkali metal-met,al systems provide evidence of the major factors contributing to the formation of ordered alkali metal structures are the adsorption temperature, the actual alkali coverage (which will be shown further on determines the changes in the strength of the adsorption bond and the dipole-dipole interactions) and the geometric and electronic structure of the surface. At low alkali coverages, the surface overlayer is built by positively charged species and the surface - adparticles bond is characterized by a large dipole moment, p. In these layers, the dipole-dipole repulsions are with an energy [17]:
These repulsions appear t o be the major interaction force. Because of the significance of these repulsive forces under the usual conditions of the catalytic reactions (room or elevated temperatures) alkali metals are uniformly distributed on the surface at low sub monolayer coverages and no ordered structures are observed. In addition to these dominating dipole-dipole interactions indirect interactions occurring via substrat,e exist as well. They are characterized by an energy term [18]:
u, s C O S ( 2 k F l . ) / d ,
(2)
where r l " ~is the magnitude of the Fermi momentum, and t varies from 1 to 5 depending on the shape of the Fermi surface in the considered direction. These
4 . 1 . Electropositive Additives: Alkali Metals
25
interactions are propagated through the electron and phonons and have an oscillating and anisotropic character. A recent opinion is that the substrate mediated interactions can superimpose with the dipole-dipole ones [15]. The resulting potential energy-oscillating contour seems to play an important role in the determination of the most favourable surface order at a given coverage. This explains, t o a certain extent, the dependence of the alkali metal surface order on the substrate nature and the crystallographic orientation. The influence of the crystallographic plane anisotropy on the rate of the surface diffusion of the adsorbate and the strength of the surface mediated interaction forces is the reason for the difference in stability of the ordered alkali superstructures on the different crystallographic planes. A typical example in this respect is the comparison of the hehaviour of alkali adsorbed on closedpacked ‘isotropic’ surfaces (e.g. fcc(ll1) and ( l o o ) , hpc(0001), bcc(ll(i), etc.) and open ‘anisotropic’ surfaces (e.g. fcc(llO), hpc(lOiO), bcc(ll2), etc.) [7]. The latter consist of closed-packed rows of atoms in one of the crystallographic directions spaced by troughs. Because the lateral interactions between the adsorbed species on these surfaces with anisotropic potential relief are also anisotropic, this usually leads to stabilization of ordered structures at higher temperatures and lower coverages. Because of the preference of the adsorption sites in the troughs, the saturated first layer on these surfaces tend to conform with the substrate by the formation of an incommensurate structure with alkali adspecies compressed in rows along the troughs (fig. 4 . 5 . ) .
Fig. 4.5. Model of surface structures of alkalis on fcc(llO), hpc(lOT0) and bcc(ll2)
A transition from commensurate alkali surface phases to incommensurate ones occurs at higher coverages where the dipole-dipole interactions are weakened as a result of depolarization effects due to the elect
26
Chapter 4.
transitions in the alkali layers is the necessity to balance the lateral interactions by shifting the adatoms to less favourable adsorption sites. The saturated first alkali layer consists of adspecies with negligible polarization. With a few exceptions, the saturated first alkali layer is characterized by the formation of hexagonal lattices. The shortest distance between the adjoining adatoms of the saturated first layer is often less than that corresponding to the alkali bulk lattice constant. This compression is generally higher for the 4 % for Na [8, 131. larger alkali atoms, e.g. up to 24 % for Cs but only This compression is observed for both commensurate and incommensurate structures. In recent theoretical considerations, the assumption is made that the contraction of the alkali layer is related to the formation of 2 D electron bands and polarization of alkali semi-core levels, i.e direct adatom-adatom interactions become important. These compression effects as well as other properties of the first alkali overlayer indicate that its properties are affected significantly by the substrate. The influence of the substrate nature on the alkali adatom surface order is clearly demonstrated when comparing the ordering tendencies in the alkali/transition metal and alkali/free electron metal systems [7-10, 19, 201. In the first case the electrostatic repulsion remains predominant throughout the monolayer growth, whereas in the second case 2D condensation readily occurs even at low alkali coverages above a certain adsorption temperature ( w 300 K) [19, 201. This tendency of clustering indicates t,hat the electrostatic interactions between the alkali adatoms on free electron metals can be easily overcome by cohesive interactions due to the overlaps of the wave functions between neighbouring adspecies. These results indicate that the horizontal corrugation of the surface potential relief is weaker in the case of the free electron metals. As will be discussed in the forthcoming subsections, besides the reduced barrier for surface diffusion, the enhanced tendency to clustering correlates with the measured smaller effective charge (dipole moment) and adsorption binding energy for alkali adspecies on electron free metals. Here, it is worth mentioning that the absence of a surface order and the strong trend to the formation of clusters characterize alkali-layer growth on alkali oxide (a-alumina) surfaces [19]. The tendency towards formation of ordered alkali overlayers at certain coverages is very helpful for the calibration of the absolute alkali coverage. According to the proposed structural models, the corresponding coverages at first layer saturation are determined exclusively by the size of the adatom and the crystallographic orientation of the surface.. For example, for fcc (111) planes of P t , Pd, Ni etc., the saturation coverage for ( f i x &)R30 structure of Cs and K is 0.33, whereas for the incoherent hexagonal structure of N a it is 0.5 [7]. Building alkali metal multilayers is possible when the substrate temperature is lower than the temperatures at which alkali metals sublimate. Condensation of the alkali metal in the second layer can still be accompanied by the formation of ordered structures, whereas further multilayer growth usually does not occur in an ordered epitaxial way [21-241. Since alkali multilayers already behave as pure alkali metals, they will not be considered in this review.
-
4.1. Electropositive Additives: Alkali Metals
27
."p.
0.1 0.2 UESIUM COVERAtE IHL)
0.3
Fig. 4.6. The variation of integrated intensity of selected half order beams from Cs induced (1 x 2)-MR structures of Ag (110) (full line) and Pd (110) (dashed line) (from ref. [61]).
B. Alkali induced surface reconstruction. Up to here only cases when alkali adspecies form various overlayer superstructures (in registry or not with the surface lattice) without affecting the original surface structure of the substrate have been considered. This is however not the case with all substrates. Depending on the nature of the substrate and the crystallographic plane, alkali metal adsorption also causes structural modification of the surface. These effects are very important with respect to the description of the induced changes in the properties of the substrate in the presence of modifiers. Recently a number of studies have shown that (110) faces of several fcc d-band metals (Ag, Pd, Cu, Ni) suffer a reconstruction in the presence of adsorbed alkali metals [7, 24-26]. This reconstruction requires some activation energy so that, at low adsorption temperatures (- 100 K), alkali adsorption leads t o the formation of different phases with increasing coverage without any modification of the (1 x 1) unreconstructed substrate. The onset of the alkali induced (1 x 1) to (1 x 2) reconstruction of the above-mentioned fcc(ll0) metals can be observed at different temperatures determined by the actual
28
Chapter 4.
alkali coverage. The missing-row model (every second (110) closed packed atomic row is missing) has been accepted for explaining the substrate surface atomic arrangement after the reconstruction [27-291. A rather interesting fact is that the reconstruction induced by the alkali metal is favoured only over a limited range of alkali surface concentrations, which are substrate dependent (see fig. 4.6). A restoration of the initial (1 x 1) substrate structure takes place at high alkali coverages. It has also been established that, for the same substrate, the critical coverages required to drive the reconstruction increases in the sequence Cs, K, N a [25, 301, i.e. the larger alkali atoms are more active. Another finding is that only fcc metals with partly-filled or filled d bands show a trend to reconstruction, whereas other similar two-dimensionally channeled surfaces such as hpc (1010) Ru or Co are stable in the presence of alkali metal. The ease of reconstruction of the above mentioned (110) faces can be ascribed to the small energy difference of the (1x 1) and (1x 2) unit cell, so that slight perturbations induced by the presence of an adsorbate can cause the reconstruction [24]. The transition from (1 x 1) to (1 x 2) surface structure is found to be an activated process, associated with a surface diffusion process of the surface atoms and adspecies. As a result of this surface diffusion, islands of (1 x 2) reconstruction are formed which grow in size within the corresponding alkali coverage range. Several explanations of the driving force of the alkali induced reconstruction are proposed. They account on effects due to the perturbations in the substrate surface electronic structure as a result of the the formation of the alkali - surface adsorption bond and/or variations of the dependence of the alkali - surface binding energy on the surface structure with increasing alkali coverage [25, 261. Another possible effect of the alkali adsorbates on the substrate surface structure is alkali induced stabilization of the reconstruction of a clean surface or lifting of the original reconstruction at certain alkali coverages. An example for the first case is the system Cs/W( 100) where the clean substrate exhibits a zig-zag chain reconstruction which is stabilized by the presence of Cs [8, 31, 321. An example for the second case is the K/Ag(llO) 2 x 1 system where at high K coverages the original 2 x 1 reconstruction is lifted [33].
4.1.2
Nature of the Alkali Adsorption Bond
A. Alkali induced work function changes. The first attempt to -1iaracterize the interaction of the adsorbed alkali atoms with the substrate surface and within the adsorbate overlayer are linked to measurements of the work function changes in alkali/transition metal systems [2G]. The characteristic work function changes during alkali metal adsorption on transition metal surfaces (A4 vs BAM) are illustrated in fig. 4.7. [34]. The A d ( 0 A M ) curves exhibit a strong initial decrease to a minimum followed by a rise to a near bulk alkali metal work function value at completion of the first overlayer. This shape of the A + ( e A M ) plots for transition metal surfaces is independent of temperature up to adsorption temperatures below the onset of desorption of the first alkali layer (- 300-350 I< depending on the type of the alkali metal). The initial slope of the &(eAM) plot can be used for the evaluation of the initial dipole moment due to the adsorbed alkali species.
4.1. Electropositive Additives: Alkali Metals
29
0 1 - K/Ru100011 2 - Cs/Ru(0001) 3 - K/Ruf IOiO) 4 - Cs/RullOiO)
-1 2
-
- -24
% I
8
a
-3 5
- 4 81
0
15
3 Alkali coverage
4.5 (X
6
75
lO''at/cm')
Fig. 4.7. W F changes, I, as a function of I< and Cs coverages for Ru(0001) (1 & 2) and for Ru(1070) (3 & 4) (from ref.[34])
Selected data of the calculated initial dipole moments, pol and the maximum work function changes, Aq5,,,, for several substrates and alkalis are given in Table 4.2. A full set of the available work function data for alkalifmetal adsorption systems can be found in refs. [26] and [36]. Assuming that in the case of alkali adatoms, (because of the large polarization) the measured work function changes are determined exclusively by the external electrostatic dipole moment, one can evaluate roughly the effective positive charge on the adsorbed alkali atom at a zero coverage using the simple relationship: cloy. d , (3) where d is the dipole length and y is the electronic charge. Usually d is determined on the basis of the substrate lattice constant, the ionic alkali radii and the assumption about occupation of the highest coordinated adsorption state at low alkali coverages. Thus, for N a , K and Cs on Ni(100) the following values were estimated q = 0.41,0.58,0.78 e- [35], respectively, for Na, I<, Cs on Ru(0001) q = 0.44,0.67 and 0.82 e- [44], respectively, and for I< on Pt(ll1) - q = 0.86 e-. The important piece of information carried by these approximate estimations is that even within the limits of very low coverages the alkali adatoms are not fully ionized. The general trend i n all work function data is that the induced dipole moment and the absolut,e values of A&,,, increase with decreasing ionization potential of the alkali metal. Besides, the po and q5,,
30
Chapter 4.
Table 4.2. Initial dipole moments, 2p0, maximal work function changes, A&,,, and initial heats of adsorptions, A H o , for adsorption of Na, K and Cs on different substrates.
SURFACE
2po(D)
AHo (kJ/mole)
6.8
242
3.2
13.5 21.0 7.8 14.2 20.4 5.8
295 325 258 297 322 255
3.4 3.6 3.5 3.9 4.1 3.15
10.2 14.6 10.5
275 305
3.4 3.6 3.7
A&,,,
(eV)
('#'abs)
Na/Ni(100) (5.2) K/Ni(100) Cs/Ni(100) Na/Ru( 000 1) I
18.8 3.2
-
-
180
4.6 2.0
(4.5) I
values depend on the substrate: they are larger for surface faces characterized by a higher clean surface work function. These large work function changes, observed upon alkali adsorption, are first explained assuming that the adsorption state of the alkali species is ionic [5]. According to the first theoretical considerations [45] it is assumed that at low alkali coverages, as a result of electron transfer t o the substrate, the valence ns-electron levels of the single alkali adatom are broadened in resonances and shifted above the Fermi level. T h e energy and width of this resonance varies with increasing alkali coverage because of the depolarization field of the surrounding ad-dipoles. As will be discussed in more details later, the experimental results exclude the existence of completely ionized alkali adatoms, i.e. within the framework of the valence resonance model one should take into account that even at the lowest coverages the low energy tail of the resonance extends below the Fermi level. That
4.1. Electropositive Additives: Alkali Metals
80
31
7
I . ,
b
1 No
2 K 3 cs
8
Fig. 4.8. (a) The changes of the alkali adatom dipole moments as a function of the alkali coverage; (b) The coverage dependence of the alkali desorption energies for Na, K and Cs adsorbed on Ru (0001) (ref.[37])
is why it is appropriate to introduce the term degree of ionicity of the alkali substrate adsorption bond. It accounts for changes in the contribution of the ionic component of bonding with increasing alkali coverage. The changes in the dipole moments due to the adsorbed alkalis estimated on the basis of the A4 vs OAM plots axe shown in fig. 4.8a. They can be satisfactorily fitted to eq. (9) in Chapter 2., which accounts for the induced decrease of the dipole moment with decreasing effective distances between the ad-dipoles as a result of strong depolarization effects. It is logical to expect that the strong repulsive interactions and the high mobility of the alkali adatoms will favour uniform distribution on the surface at room temperature at low coverages. For flat surface planes this assumption is confirmed by both LEED (see the phase digrams in figs. 4.1-4.3.). and WF studies; the shape of the I-V characteristics is uniform. For corrugated surface planes (e.g. Ru(1010)) both LEED and WF data (appearance of a shoulder in the I-V curves in fig. 4.9.) indicate a coexistence of islands of different surface superstructures (ordered and disordered alkali phase) [34, -
32
Chapter 4.
41, 431. The analysis of the evolution of the shape and the position of the retarding potential curves suggests development of small ordered domains and fairly inhomogeneous distribution of the alkali adatoms on the remaining surface. This result about a possible inhomogeneous distribution of the alkali adatoms is important because it explains why the absolute work function changes depend in some cases on the experimental method used for measuring the work function. This result for homogeneity of the alkali layers on flat and corrugated transition metal surfaces can be related t o the real catalysts which exhibit an anisotropic surface structure. It implies that, because of the possible uneven distribution of the promoter, the rate of the catalytic reaction might vary along the surface.
0
2
r,
2
6
Voltage lev1
Fig. 4.9. Normalized retarding potential curves for increasing coverages of (a) K on Ru(0001) with 8K: 1 - 0, 2 - 0.03, 3 - 0.07, 4 - 0.36; (b) K on Ru(lOT0) with OK: 1 - 0, 2 - 0.03, 3 - 0.13, 4 - 0.20, 5 - 0.35, 6 - 0.66. (from ref. [34])
For electron-free metal surfaces, the alkali induced work function changes are temperature dependent. They show the typical patterns observed on transition metals only for low adsorption temperatures [20] (see fig. 4.10.), whereas at room temperature above a critical (relatively low) alkali coverage the Aqj(0AM) dependence becomes linear. As is noted in Subsection 4.1.1., this temperature effect on the surface potential versus the alkali coverage dependence is due to the induced 2D condensation of the alkali adspecies above critical surface coverages. As is obvious from the data in Table 4.2., the initial dipole moment due to the same alkali is smaller for an electron free
4.1. Electropositive Additives: Alkali Metals
I
I
0
.
1
1
1
. 2 1 A Jodlum Cmvamge 0..
I
I
d
1
33
1 2
Fig. 4.10. K induced work function changes for adsorption at 100 K (open circles) and after annealing to 350 K or upon K adsorption at 350 K (open triangles) on A1 single crystals (from ref.[19])
substrate. This implies a lower degree of ionicity of the alkali - free electron metal bond compared t o the alkali - transition one. B. Spectroscopy data and their relevance to the charge redistribution as a result of alkali adsorption. The change in magnitude of the effective charge associated with the alkali species (assumed to be a measure of the contribution of the ionic component to the alkali - surface bonding) was confirmed by a couple of spectroscopic data. Photoelectron spectroscopy data demonstrate a shift of the core levels of the alkali metal adatoms to lower binding energies due to the depolarization effects with increasing alkali coverage. Depending on the type of the alkali and the substrate, the absolute value of this energy shift is in the range 0.3-0.8 eV [21, 26, 461. The direction of the alkali core level binding energy shift is in general agreement with the decreased charge transfer after the increase in alkali coverage. The increase in population of the alkali valence ns levels gives an intra atomic repulsion which pushes the core level electron energy to lower energies. It should be taken into account that the measured magnitude of this shift is affected by
34
Chapter 4.
initial and final state effects due t o the changes in relaxation. These many body effects are more likely the reason for the existing variations in the alkali core level shifts for some alkali/metal systems. For example, the Cs 5p energy for Cs/W(OOl) remains constant [47], whereas for Cs/Mo(001) even a higher energy shift of the Cs 5p core levels is observed with increasing Cs coverage
WI. More uniform are the
data on the core level shifts obtained by EELS, where the energy loss for excitations from ( n - 1)p to empty ns valence levels are measured because these intra atomic excitations should be less affected by the many-body effects. For all studied alkali/metal systems, the core level loss spectra exhibit an initial energy decrease up to coverages corresponding to the minimum of the A4(0,,) plot and levels off with further increase of the alkali coverage [26, 37, 48-51]. It should be pointed out that the absolute values of these energy shifts are much larger than the ones observed for the 1.5 eV for N a 2 p 3 s , core level shifts by photoelectron spectroscopy, e.g. 2.1 eV for K 4 p 5 s and 2.5 eV for Cs adlayers on Ru(0001) [36]. From the relation between these energy loss shifts and the charging state of the adatom, Anderson and Jostell [35]estimated that even a t very low coverages the positive charge on the adsorbed alkali atom is less than unity. The core level binding energies characteristic of the first alkali overlayer remain lower (- 1 eV) than that of a bulk like multilayer alkali film. Since this binding energy difference is mainly due to initial state effects, this indicates that the properties of the first alkali adlayer should be different from that of an alkali bulk film. Direct information about the position and the occupancy of the alkali adatoms valence resonances is obtained by metastable quenching spectroscopy (MQS) [52,53], UPS [54,55] and electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS) [26]. MQS data showed the existence of alkali induced peaks associated with ns valence states even at the lowest alkali coverages. This result, together with the EELS data where one electron ns-np transitions are also detected at low alkali coverages, indicate that alkali metal adatoms should be considered as polarized rather than ionized. The coverage dependent change in electronic structure of the adsorbed alkali species involving a decrease of the polarization is evidenced by all spectroscopic data under consideration. At higher alkali coverages when a dense metal-like layer is built, the linear dependence between the MQS alkali 11s iiiteiisity and the alkali coverage is violated and the signal becomes narrow [52]. The UPS spectra s h o w a rise of narrow ns-derived peaks near the Fermi level, whereas the one electron ns-np loss peaks shifting initially to smaller energies change their character and transform into collective plasmon excitations in the metal-like overlayer
-
WI.
-
-
IPS is used as a probe of the behaviour of the unoccupied alkali adatom states just above the Fermi level, i.e. the n p states which participate as final states in one electron ns-np intra atomic transitions. The general trend in the energy position of these empty states up to moderate alkali coverages (shown in fig. 4.11) [26] is in quantitative agreement with the EELS data which predict a larger downward shift of the unoccupied valence states than is the case of the occupied states [26].
4 . 1 . Electropositive Additives: Alkali Metals
35
-HIAg(111)
(IPS) WCu(100) (EELS and A@ )
Fig. 4.11. The energy position of the I< 4p,-derived state for I
All spectroscopic data together with the observed work function changes are a strong confirmative indication that the adsorption state of the alkali adatoms changes significantly with increasing alkali coverage. On the basis of the data summarized above one should distinguish between the low coverage adsorption state when the alkali - surface bonding is strongly polarized (which is associated with a larger contribution of the ionic component t o the bonding) and to a much less polarized metal-like bonding at saturation of the first overlayer. The transformation (according to the data) from a ‘strongly polarized’ to a ‘metallic’ state is not abrupt, which means that the contribution of the ionic component gradually decreases in the intermediate coverage region.
36
Chapter 4
Since all transition metals exhibit the same type of Aq5(0,,) plots, it can be generalized that for the same substrate crystallographic plane the ionic contribution at low alkali coverages increases with decreasing ionization potential of the alkali adatom. Judging from the initial dipole moments and the tendency for 2D condensation, the contribution of the ionic component (degree of polarization) for the same substrate is smaller in the case of free electron substrates. C. Strength of the alkali adsorption bond at various alkali coverages. The coverage-induced changes in the character of the alkali - surface bonding affect strongly the adsorption binding energy and the alkali - surface bond lengths. This is very well illustrated by the thermal desorption alkali spectra for different alkali coverages shown in fig. 4.12.and the E d vs AM plot in fig. 4.8.(b), obtained on the basis of the TPD data. Since for an non activated adsorption process as is the case of alkali adsorption on metal surfaces, the desorption energy, Ed, is equal to the heats of adsorption, AH, the Ed data can be used as a measure of the adsorption bond strength.
Fig. 4.12. I< TPD spectra for various I< coverages on Ru(0001) (from ref. [44])
As can be judged from the data in fig. 4.8(b)., the variations in the alkali adsorption binding energy are rather large. The absolute changes with the built of the first alkali become larger with decreasing ionization potential of the alkali metal. The same trend is exhibited by the values of the initial heats of adsorption. As can be seen in fig. 4.8(b). and table 4.2. the absolute values
4.1. Electropositive Additives: Alkali Metals
37
of the initial heats of adsorption, A H A ~correlate , with that of the initial dipole moment, PO. Since PO relates to the contribution of the ionic component to the adsorption bond, this means that the latter plays an important role at low alkali coverages. Its contribution is dampened with increasing alkali coverage leading to the observed significant weakening of the adsorption bond. However, the adsorption energy measured on completion of the first alkali Layer remains higher than that corresponding to the sublimation energy of the bulk material. This supports the spectroscopic results that within the first layer the alkali ns-valence electrons remain involved in bond formation with the substrate surface. The variation of the nature of the alkali - surface bonding associated with the transition from a ‘polarized’ to a ‘metallic’ state affects also the bond lengths. As has been shown by recent SEXAFS studies of the system Cs/Ag(lll), the bond length increases from 3.2 to 3.5 A a s a result of weakening of the adsorption bond [58]. Although the trend in the coverage induced changes of the strength of the alkali adsorption bond is the same for all alkali - metal systems, there is a difference in the absolute values of the initial heats of adsorption for transition and free electron metals. The smaller alkali adsorption energies for free electron metals correlate well with the measured lower initial dipole moments. This result leads to different theoretical approaches to the description of the properties of alkali adlayers on metals. All recent realistic models exclude the existence of completely ionized adparticles whose valence electrons are delocalized into the substrate metal. An appropriate theoretical approach (using the simple jellium model) of alkali adsorption on free electron met,als ( A l , Cu) w a s first proposed by N.Lang et al. [59,60]. Further verifications, done by many other authors, can be found in refs. [61-661. Within the limit of low alkali coverages the electron-density contours corresponding to chemisorption of one adatom on a high-density jellium substrate indicate that the adatom electron density is displaced from the vacuum to the interface side. As a result, the corresponding ns-valence resonance of the alkali adatom becomes almost empty, which is interpreted as a charge transfer t o the substrate and the formation of an ionic type bonding at very low coverages. Recent theoretical studies of alkali adsorption on Al(001) [64] exclude charge transfer to the substrate. They describe the bonding and the observed coverage effects by assuming hybridization of adatom and substrate surface states and variation of polarization with increasing alkali coverage. For the case of a transition metal substrate which surface electronic structure is more corrugated because of the spilled out d-like states, the alkali adsorption bond is described by E. Wimmer et al.as a polarized covalent one [65, 661. The formation of this bond involves mainly alkali ns-valence states and s , d-like surface states of the substrate (Mo or W). This theoretical covalent bond model suggests a smooth variation of electronic features with increasing alkali coverage. Irrespective of the coverage, the alkali adatoms preserve partial occupation of the ns-derived states with a tendency towards increased polarization per adatom at lower coverages. It is worth pointing out that within the framework of both theoretical approaches one can explain
38
Chapter 4
satisfactorily most of the experimental results. D. Range of the alkali induced charge redistribution within the surface layer (local work function)”Obviously, the formation of an alkali adsorption bond and the induced changes in the electrostatic potential cause a charge redistribution within a certain surface region. Since these are the major alkali induced modification effects on the substrate surface, it is of great importance to know the lateral range of this effect. The theoretical models generally suggest a rather localized character of the alkali - surface bonding and the charge redistribution. The lateral range of perturbation of the substrate surface electronic structure due to the adsorption of an alkali atom or the so called ‘local work function’ has been recently probed by photoemission studies of noble gas adsorption on alkali modified metal single crystals [67-691. These studies are based on the simple principle that the noble gas (Xe) core level binding energies with respect to the vacuum level, EB(V)are independent of the substrate because of the weak Xe/metal interaction and the large size of the Xe adatom. Taking into account that EB(V)is a sum of two quantities: EB(v)= EB(F) 4,’ (4) (where EB(F)is the core binding energy with respect to the Fermi level and 4sis the local surface potential of the adsorption site) it becomes obvious that any changes in +s will cause changes in EB(F).This picture of a floating potential well of the adsorbed noble gases with the vacuum level has been also predicted theoretically in the calculations of Lang et a1 [70] for adsorption of a single Xe atom on a jellium surface. Thus. the difference in the,measured by photoelectron spectroscopy, E g ( F ) levels for Xe(5p,12) has been successfully used for the determination of the work function difference between the surface regions of affected and nonaffected by [67]. Fig. 4.13. presents the structure of a Xe-K coadsorbed layer for Ru(0001) covered with small amounts of K and a set of photoemission Xe(5p3/2,1/2) spectra. These results indicate that the state in which Xe next to I< is populated first, followed by occupation of the surface site next-nearest to an alkali adatom. According to the measured Xe 5p binding energies, one can draw the conclusion that the local electrostatic potential of the ‘promoted’ state next to K is much lower than that of the next nearest state. For K on Ru, the local work function decrease confined within -8 A around the K adatom is found t o be of the order of 0.5 eV, whereas beyond this sphere of 8 A, the so called long range work function is considerably smaller - 0.08 eV. This determination of the alkali-induced local work function changes on an almost atomic scale is an important finding for further coadsorption studies. Obviously, the introduction of an alkali modifier onto the metal-catalyst surface induces a significant non uniformity of the surface with respect to the spatial charge distribution. This implies that the strength of the promoting effect on the coadsorbed reagents or reaction products will differ significantly when changing the alkali - coadsorbate separation in the overlayer.
+
- -
4.1. Electropositive Additives: Alkali Metals
39
XelKI
Fig. 4.13. Structural model for Xe adsorbed on a 0.05 K/ Ru(0001) surface and the Xe ( 5 ~ ~ / ~ , , photoemission /2) spectra for increasing Xe coverages on O.OSK/ Ru(0001) (from re€. [67])
4.1.3
Summary for Alkali/Metal Adsorption Systems
The most important results contributing to the description of the behaviour of alkali atoms adsorbed on metals can be summarized as follows: 1. The interaction of alkali metals with both transition and free electron metals show the same general features: a strong initial work function decrease t o a minimum followed by a rise to a value close to the corresponding alkali bulk value on completion of the first overlayer;
coverage governed significant changes in the charge of the alkali adatoms due t o depolarizatioii taking place with decreasing separation between the alkali adatoin dipoles; a significant decrease of the alkali adsorption energy with increasing alkali coverage within the first layer; formation of ordered superstructures favoured at higher alkali coverages when the repulsive dipole-dipole forces are reduced; a gradual reduction of the contribution of the ionic component to the alkali adsorption bond, reflected by an increase of the occupancy in the alkali ns-valence levels with increasing alkali coverage
40
Chapter 4 and the formation of a 2D ns-band with a nearly free electron gas on completion of the first layer.
2. The ionicity and the strength of the alkali adatom - substrate bond depend on three major factors: the kind of alkali (its size and ionization potential), the nature of the substrate, and the actual alkali coverage. For the same alkali coverages they are larger for alkalis with a higher atomic number and for transition metal surfaces.
3. The kind of change of the adsorpt,ion state which is a function of coverage. It is characterised by ‘a strongly polarised’ bonding at low coverages and moves t o a ‘metallic’-like bonding at high coverages. This change in the bonding character is accompanied by an increase of the alkali surface bond length. 4. The lateral range of the alkali induced charge redistribution within the surface is rather short. The strong local changes are confined within the next nearest adsorption sites so that at sufficiently low alkali coverages one can distinguish between strongly ‘promoted’ and almost unaffected sites beyond a certain distance from the alkali adatom.
4.1.4 Alkali Adsorption on Semiconductor Surfaces Finally, some information is given on the behaviour of the alkali/semiconductor adsorption systems. The author believes that this will be useful t o the reader who wishes to evaluate the influence of the substrate surface electronic structure on the nature of the adsorption bond. Most of the semiconductor surfaces are characterized by active surface dangling bonds directed outwards and a bulk band gap. This suggests the important role of the hybridization between the adatom and the substrate surface states during the formation of the adsorption bond. It should be pointed out that besides the fundamental interest, the alkali adatoms can serve as promoters for the oxidising and nitriding semiconductor surfaces [71-741 . When describing the alkali - semiconductor systems a great deal effort has gone into the question whether the alkali adatom is bound in an ionic or in a covalent manner. The experimental data show similar work function changes as in the case of alkali - transition metal systems with exceptions of several systems where distinct minima in the work function curves are lacking [75]. Some differences were also observed in the EELS spectra where the 2D ns-band collective excitations did not appear on the completion of the first overlayer [76]. The photoelectron studies also support the views that there is a lack of metallization in some systems on completion of the first alkali overlayer [77]. On the other hand, the MQS data indicate that similarly to the case of the metal substrates, Cs 6s-derived levels exist at all Cs coverages with an abrupt increase in their charge density above a certain critical Cs coverage [78]. The alkali adsorption bond for most of the semiconductors is found t o be of the same strength as that measured for transition metals, but it depends t o a minor extent on alkali coverage [7G, 791. This seems unexpected because
4.2. Elect ronega t i ve Ad di t i ves
41
the depolarization effects with increasing alkali coverage should be larger for semiconductor substrates where the screening is much less effective than in the case of metals. A plausible explanation of the behaviour of alkali - semiconductor systems is that for substrates with active surface states projected outside the surface, a central role in the formation of the alkali - surface bond is played by the hybridization between these active surface states and the alkali valence states. The adatom dipole moment is interpreted as a result of polarization of the covalent bond [80]. This model of alkali - semiconductor bonding is very similar t o the strong polarized covalent bonding proposed by E.Wimmer et al.for alkali - W (Mo) [65, 661. Indeed, these transition metals also possess spill out d-like surface states. However, because of the more active dangling bonds of the semiconductor surfaces the coverage induced weakening of the alkali - semiconductor bond is smaller, which explains why in most cases no metallization is achieved on completion of the first layer. 4.2
ELECTRONEGATIVE ADDITIVES
The quantitative interpretation of the extent, strength and nature of the deactivation effects induced by the presence of electronegative additives, requires a fundamental knowledge of the structure and bonding of the additives on the catalyst surface. This knowledge is necessary in order to explain the contribution of the so called geometric (e.g. site blocking) and electronic (redistribution of the valence electron charge density of the adsorbate and substrate atoms) factors t o the observed changes in the reactivity of the surface. 4.2.1
Surface Structures, Site Occupation and Bond Lengths
Structural information regarding the geometry of the adsorbed layers of electronegative additives has been obtained already on various single crystal metal surfaces [7]. A variety of techniques, such as the LEED analysis, ion scattering, ARUPS, SEXAFS, SEELFS (surface estended energy loss structure) and HREELS, have provided accurate information on the coverage dependence of the adsorbate surface order, the adsorption sites, the adsorbate - substrate atom bond lengths and the adsorbate-induced reconstruction of the substrate surface. It is well known that the trend towards surface ordering depends on the types of interactions between the species on the surface. As will be discussed in the forthcoming subsection, in most cases the electronegative atomic adsorption is characterized by the formation of rather strong bonds of a covalent type. A. Ordering of the electronegative additives at various coverages. Since sulphur and other chalcogens are the most common poisons in real catalysis, recently many papers have appeared dealing with the crystallographic structure of the cheinisorbed states of these atoms on different transition metal single-crystal surfaces. Selected data concerning the observed S structures, site occupations and the measured bond lengths, L , on different crystallographic planes of several metals which are important in catalysis, are given in table 4.3. For most of the systems considered in table 4.3. the bond
42
Chapter 4
Fig. 4.14. LEED and TPD data from Pt (111) saturated with HzSe and subsequently annealed (from ref.[113])
lengths are for S coverages where S is in an adsorbed state residing in the highest coordination sites on the surface. The data in Table 4.3. [81-1111 show that for unreconstructed fcc ( l l l ) , (100) and (110), bcc(ll0) and (loo), the p(2 x 2) overlayer superstructure is formed a t an S coverage of 0.25. It should be pointed out that usually p(2 x 2) patterns appear at sulphur coverages far below 0.25. This indicates that S tends to form long-range ordered islands so that the substrate surface at 0s < 0.25 should be regarded as a mixture of p(2 x 2) S islands and S-free regions. As the coverage increases, these islands grow and form either larger domains if they are in-phase, or domain boundaries if they are out of-phase. As reported recently [112], in such a domain structure of a sulphur p(2 x 2) overlayer on Cu( loo), the local geometric structures of the S adsorption sites within the p(2 x 2) domains and at the domain boundaries are different. This is ascribed to different substrate surface reconstructions at the domain boundaries and the domains. Such nonuniformity of the modified surface might introduce certain difficulties in obtaining a clear picture of the modifier effects on the reagent gas adsorption at lower modifier coverages. With increasing S coverage beyond 0.25, a mixture of p(2 x 2) and c(2 x 2) or x &)R30° patterns exist till completion of the final c(2 x 2) order at Bs = 0.5 for the fcc(lOO), bcc(100) and fcc(ll0) planes, x 6 ) R 3 0 ° order at 0s = 0.33 for the f c G l l l ) or hpc(OOO1) and the (fi
(a
43
4.2. Electronegative Additives
Table 4.3. Sulfur Surface Structures, Adsorption Sites and Adsorption Bond Lengths ( L ) on Some Transition Metal Single Crystal Planes. In brackets the bond lengths of some bulk sulfides are given for the sake of comparison. ~
L
(A)
METAL
OVERLAYER ORDER
ADSORPTION SITE
Ni(ll1) [82-871 Pd(ll1) ~8,891 Rh( 111) [go, 911 Pt(ll1) [92-941 Ir(ll1) 1951 Ni( 100) [96, 971 Pd(100) ~981 Rh(100) [99, loo] P t ( 100) p o l , 1021 Fe( 100) ~091 Ni(ll0) [103,104] Rh( 110) [99, loo] Pt(ll0) [105-1071 Fe( 110) [lo81 NisFe(ll0) [110,111]
p(2 x 2) -+ ( A x &)R3Oo -+ 5& x 2 +8fix 2 p(2 x 2) x &)R30° -+ hexagonal ( & x &)R3Oo p(2 x 2) 4 hexagonal p(2 x 2) + x &)R3Oo --+ hexagonal p(2 x 2) -+ ( A x fi)R30°
three-fold four-fold three-fold
2.20 (NiS-2.39) 2.22
t hree-fold three-fold
2.18 (RhzS3-2.37) 2.28
t hree-fold
2.28
- (4 -
(a
p(2 x 2)
+
c(2 x 2)
four-fold
2.23
p(2 x 2)
-*
c(2 x 2)
four-fold
2.35
c(2 x 2)
four-fold
2.30
p(5 x 20) -* p(2 x 2) -* c(2 x 2) p(2 x 2) -t c(2 x 2)
four-fold four-fold
2.34 2.30
p(2 x 2)
c(2 x 2)
four-fold
2.31
c(2 x 2)
four-fold
2.39
c(2 x 2)
four-fold
-
p(2 x 2) c(2 x 2) c ( n x 1) p(2 x 2) -* c(2 x 2) P(2 x 3)
four-fold
-
four-fold
-
p(2 x 2)
p(2 x 2) p(2 x 2)
-
+
-
44
Chapter 4
planes. For the c(2 x 2) superstructure on fcc(100) and (110), bcc(100) etc. planes and the (4x &)R3O0 superstructure on f cc(lll) , hpc (OOOl), and other planes, all substrate surface atoms become directly coordinated to the modifier adatom. As will be shown in the forthcoming sections, the modifier structures at higher modifier coverages are usually associated with a complete deactivation of the surface. The same p(2 x 2), c(2 x 2) or ( Ax &)R30° ordered structures are formed in the case of the ot,her chalcogen atoms (Se and Te), C1, I, etc. [7]. In many cases, the maximum adatom coverages achieved exceed those corresponding to c(2 x 2) or ( f ix &)R3Oo orders, which are accompanied by the development of new LEED patterns. An example of the evolution of the LEED patterns upon increasing the Se coverage on P t ( l l 1 ) is given in fig. 4.14. [113]. Parallel LEED and T P D measurements have shown that the reverse conversion from the (4 x 4) to (& x &)R30° order occurs readily in the temperature range 800-900 K when part of Se desorbs. The data in fig. 4.14.,together with the AES calibration data indicate, that in the case of Se the maximum Se coverage achieved upon HzSe dissociative adsorption and the subsequent removal of hydrogen by desorption exceeds 0.5 (corresponding t o the (4 x 4) order). A hexagonal compact structure can be achieved at higher chalcogen coverages [loll. As will be discussed below, in most cases sulphur coverages exceeding 0.33 on fcc( 111) planes cause the development of complicated LEED patterns associated with an induced substrate surface reconstruction. Up t o coverages of 0.25, the same ordered p(2 x 2) structure is observed for the other smaller sized electronegative additives, such as C, N and 0 [7]. With these small adatoms the picture is more complicated at coverages exceeding 0.25 because of the induced substrate surface reconstruction. This will be discussed later. In the cases where no reconstruction or compound formation takes place, these adat,oms form the same ordered structures at higher coverages as summarized in table 4.3. For systems with a lack of reconstruction, the general trend to occupation of the highest coordination adsorpt.ion sites (C3,, and Cq, for single crystal planes considered in table 4.3.) is fulfilled for most of the systems under consideration [7, 1141. Exceptions to this rule occur usually in cases where the adatoms induce reconstruction of the substrate surface or the adatom surface interactions lead to the formation of a bulk compound. Fig.4.15. shows schemes of the location of the electronegative adatoms in the highest coordination (fourfold and threefold sites) on different crystallographic planes. There are some exceptions to this general trend usually with open crystallographic planes or originally reconstructed surfaces which exhibit rather large surface lattice constants. Such examples are the systems S/Re(1010) [115],and S/Ir(llO)-1 x 2 [llG]. Dynamical LEED studies of these systems have shown that the S adatom occupies three-fold sites between the surface and second substrate layer. This adatom location reduces the distance to the two closer ridge substrate atom supposing stronger interaction for the three-fold site. As can be seen in fig. 4.15., the number of the substrate atoms coordinated to the electronegative adatoms depends on the crystallographic
4.2. EIectronega t ive Addi tives
a
45
b
Fig. 4.15. Location of the adatom on different crystallographic single crystal planes: (a) three-fold site on fcc(ll1) and hpc(0001); (b) four-fold site on fcc(100); (c) fourfold, short-bridge and long bridge sites on fcc( 110); (d) four-fold and three-fold sites on bcc(ll0); (f) four-fold site on bcc(100).
orientation and the actual adsorption site. This determines the importance of the adatom surface structure in explaining the differences of the niodification effect on different substrate crystallographic planes. It is related to the fact that the substrate atoins directly coordinated to the modifier are most strongly affected. Depending on the actual substrate surface orientation, the lattice constant, and the atomic radii of the electronegative modifier, the adatoms located in the hollows of the surface are also more or less closely coordinated to the substrate atoms of the second layer . Thus, considering the local bonding geometry in determining of the total number of the substrate atoms coordinated to the adatom, the subsurface substrate atoms should also be involved in some cases. The actual location of the electronegative adatoms in the highest coordinated adsorption sites is not always centered in the hollow. Recently a
46
Chapter 4
thorough LEED analysis of the S/Mo(100) system [117] has shown a lateral displacement of the S adatoms towards the bridge sites in the 10 surface direction. This leads t o differences in the bond lengths between the S adatom and the top Mo atoms involved in the bonding: 2.33 and 2.58 A, respectively ( S - second layer Mo atom distance for the laterally displaced S atoms was found to be 2.57 A). Comparing these values for length with that corresponding to the centered hollow location of S (2.4681 to the top and 2.5781 t o the second Mo layers) it can be seen that, as a result of the lateral displacement, S becomes more closely attached to two Mo surface atoms. Undoubtedly, this will affect the strength of the S adsorption bond. The data in Table 4.3. indicate that the adatom - surface atom bond lengths tend to increase for higher adatom coordination numbers. Consequently, the dependence of the adsorption bond length on the coordination number is similar to that of the compound bulk bonds vs. the coordination number [118]. The measured adatom - substrate surface atom bond lengths are in most cases shorter than the corresponding Me - X bond lengths in the bulk compounds. As discussed in refs. [153] and [154], this implies a lower degree of ionicity between the substrate atoms and the modifier and stronger bonding compared to the corresponding bulk compound. In many cases the measured bond lengths for unreconstructed p(2 x 2) and c(2 x 2) structures show a negligible difference. This indicates that the adatom - adatom interactions are weak compared to the surface - modifier bonding. The location and the adatom - surface atoms bond lengths determine the distances between the modifier and the surface plane and between the modifier and the subsurface atoms. These characteristics are very important in describing the extent of the modifier effects, as will be discussed later. B. Electronegative adatom induced surface reconstruction.The changes in electronic structure of the substrate atoms involved in the strong interactions with the electronegative adatoms are expected to affect not only the nearest surface atoms but, in many cases, lead to a reconstruction of the substrate surface, extending typically over 2-3 atomic layers. The phenomenon of adsorbate induced surface reconstruction is very important especially with regard t o catalytic reactions which are sensitive to surface structure. The adsorbate induced reconstruction is coverage dependent and occurs most readily on more open crystallographic planes. At high adatom coverages, usually exceeding 0.33 for fcc (111) and hpc (0001) planes and 0.25-0.5 for fcc (100) and (110) planes, most of the transition metals used as catalysts (Ni, Fe, Mo, Cu, Pd, etc) undergo reconstruction and in some cases even a bulk compound is formed. Less severe cases of reconstruction are an adatom-induced expansion of the top substrate surface layer or a lateral displacement of the surface atoms as well as some changes of the position of the substrate atoms in the second layer. In the latter case the adatoms usually preserve the highest coordinated adsorption sites. As an example for such systems may be mentioned the 10 % expansion of the Ni(ll0) surface layer induced by c(2 x 2) S in a fourfold site [104], the buckling of the second layer of the Ni(100) crystal as a result of an interaction with oxygen in a fourfold site [121], the lateral displacement of
4 . 2 . Electronegati ve Ad& tives
47
I0011
Fig. 4.1G. Surface top and side views of oxygen adsorbed on Cu(llO)-2xl as deduced from SEXAFS data. Oxygen is adsorbed above the surface in the longbridge site with the surface reconstruction according to the missing row model (from ref.[126]).
the Ru top atoms coordinated with 0 and the buckling of the first and second layers for the p(2 x 2)O and three-domains p(2 x 1 ) 0 with an oxygen adatom in a threefold site on Ru(0001) [122], etc. It should be emphasised that the most recent LEED intensity analysis data show that strongly-bound atomic adsorbates can induce reconstruction even of the closed-packed surfaces at low adsorbate coverages as in the case of O/Ru(OOOl) [122]. More severe reconstruction of the single crystal surfaces is usually associated with missing of surface atomic rows or reorientation of t81iesubstrate surface atoms maintaining a new geometry. An example of the first case is the oxygen-induced (2 x 1) reconstruction of Cu(llO), where oxygen occupies lower symmetry long bridge sites lying 0.23 A above the top substrate layers (bond lengths top Cu-0 = 1.82 A, second Cu-0 = 1.98 A), as illustrated in fig. 4.16 [123-1261. In the second case the reconstruction is usually associated with the appearance of a variety of complicated LEED patterns. Examples
Chapter 4
48
of such systems are S / N i ( l l I ) [82, 83, 871, O/Cu(111) [161], S/Fe(llO) and (100) [108, 1091, C, N/Ni(100) [128-1321, O/Pd(100) [133], S/Pt(100) [134], etc.
Fig. 4.17. Structural pseudo - c(2 x 2)s - Ni(100) model corresponding to a x 2)s structure on a reconstructed N i ( l l 1 ) surface (from ref. [87])
(5a
Fig.4.17. presents the suggested new surface order induced on Ni(ll1) by S which satisfactorily explains the (5&x 2) and (8&x 2) LEED patterns[87] observed at 0s > 0.33. The reconstructed surface layer consists of domains of a distorted c(2 x 2)s - Ni(100) surface. The measured nearest top N i - S bond length (2.22 is the same as the one measured for the real c(2 x 2)s - Ni(100). It is smaller than that corresponding to the bulk compounds NiS (2.38 k) and Ni3S2 (2.28 A). This result excludes sulfide formation on the Ni(ll1) surface even for these high S coverages. A similar rearrangement, i.e. formation of rotational domains of distorted c(2 x 2)O - Cu( 100) has been suggested for explaining the complicated LEED patterns at high oxygen coverages on C u ( l l 1 ) [127]. Typical electronegative adatoms which usually induce a surface reconstruction are also C and N . C or N adsorbed on a Ni(100) surface at coverages exceeding 0.25 induce reconstruction leading to a ( 2 x 2)p4g structure [1281321. It has been supposed that this reconstruction involves rotation of the four nearest N i surface atoms, as is illustrated in fig. 4.18. Recent SEXAFS [129, 1311 and SEELFS [132] analyses favour a. fourfold hollow site in the rotated square as an adsorption site for the modifier adatom. Comparison of the behaviour of the 0, N and C/Ni(100) systems [131] have shown that the adsorbate induced (2 x 2)p4g reconstruction is not observed in the case of oxygen where 0 adsorbs in the fourfold site on the unreconstruct,ed surface. The measured modifier to the nearest neighbour top Ni distances are : 0 Ni = 1.97 N - Ni = 1.89 and C - Ni = 1.82 A. The short C - Ni bond indicates that the carbon adatom is located in the same plane or even
A)
A,
A,
4.2. Elect ronega t ive Additives
49
Fig. 4.18. Model proposed by LEED analysis for C(N) induced reconstruction of Ni(100) leading to ( 2 x 2)p4g structure. The arrows indicate t,he lateral distortion of the top Ni layer atoms (large circles) and the small circles represent the adatoms in the four-fold hollow sites (from ref.[132]).
slightly below the top Ni layer, whereas N and 0 are 0.11 and 0.88a above the top layer, respectively. On the basis of a similar cOmparison concerning the trend of the adsorbate-induced reconstruction for various systemsjt has been shown that, for the same substrate and crystallographic orientation, this trend depends on the adsorption bonding strength As has been shown in the theoretical treatment in ref.[135], in this case the electronic structure (filling of the valence levels) of the modifier is of main importance. Reconstruction of the substrate surface induced by the adsorption of electronegative modifiers appears to be a general phenomenon. It occurs usually above critical adatom coverages and occurs, in some cases, at elevated temperatures only. The tendency t o reconstruction is strongly dependent not only on the nature of the modifier and the substrate but also on the substrate surface orientation. The reconstruction can lead to the appearance of new active adsorption sites and/or elimination of others. Closer behaviour to real catalysis (where the catalyst is a polycrystalline sample or a highly-dispersed metal surface) is exhibited by the stepped metal surfaces. These surfaces reconstruct more readily a t lower adatom coverages. For example, no reconstruction has been observed with Pt(ll1) in the presence of S up to sulphur coverages of 0.33, while S adsorption of a stepped
50
Chapter 4
Pt(S) - [6(111)x(lOO) surface induces Pt(S) - [12(111) x2(100)] and Pt(S) - [6s(lll)xn(100)] reconstructions [136]. It has also been found that S occupies preferentially the step edges which are expected to be the most active adsorption sites. Here it is worth noting that the impurities such as 0, S, N , C , C1, etc., always occupy preferentially the defect sites, such as steps, grain boundaries etc., irrespective of whether they are introduced on the surface by adsorption or segregate from the bulk [137]. A similar stronger tendency towards reconstruction in the presence of S is observed for a stepped Cu(ll0) [138] surface compared to the behaviour of the flat Cu surface [139]. With increasing S coverage on stepped Cu(llO), a great number of complicated LEED structures are detected [137]. They indicate that the substrate surface undergoes a complex 2D and 3D faceting which is governed by the sulphur surface concentration. Stronger interactions between Ni and C or S have also been reported for stepped Ni surfaces, when faceting of the surface covered by C or S adsorbates is detected even at low modifier coverages [140]. More complicated is the characterization of the electronegative modifier structure on the single crystal alloy surfaces. This is due to the fact that the composition of the alloy surface is strongly dependent on the presence of impurities. Also the affinity of the different constituents of the alloys towards the adsorbate is different and one should expect preferential bonding to one of the elements. As an example, the surface composition and structure of S overlayers on two faces of a Ni3Fe alloy are shown in table 4.3 [110]. Comparison with the behaviour of the S/Ni and SfFe systems shows that the same surface order is observed only for the S/Ni( 100) and S/Fe( 100) systems. However, for the alloy surfaces, the highest coordinated adsorption site remains the most favoured one as an adsorption site. Another very important result for the S/NiFe alloy systems is the S-induced change in the surface composition at elevated temperatures as illustrated in fig 4.19. [110]. This temperature dependent surface composition of the sulphur covered alloy is explained by the preferential S - Fe interactions. The trend for the surface composition to be restored above a certain temperature is due to the tendency to disorder which is outweighing the tendency towards iron - sulphur bonding. C. Compound formation between the adatoin and the substrate or formation of a separate modifier phase.The most severe modification of the substrate surface occurs with the formation of two- or three-dimensional compounds as a result of interaction with the electronegative modifier. Usually this happens at elevated temperatures and high modifier coverages when compressed overlayers are formed. Typical examples of a compound formation are: (i) the formation of a surface oxide phase and growth of a bulk oxide above critical oxygen coverages on Ni [141, 1421, Cu [143], M o [144, 1451, Fe [146, 1471, and Ir [148, 1491, single crystal surfaces; (ii) the formation of a sulfide surface phase on Fe [lo$, 1501 and Mo [151, 1521 single crystals; (iii) the formation of metal carbides on W [153-1551, Mo [156, 1571, etc. In most cases the formation of a surface or bulk compound is also accompanied by the formation of ordered structures as monitored by LEED. A good example for such a system is the carbonization of W(100) [154]. For this system the LEED patterns show a sequential appearance of c(2 x 2)C, (1310)C, (6 x l)C and (5 x l)C structures [154, 1551. The final two structures which are a culmina-
4.2. Elec tronega ti ve A ddjti ves
51
Fig. 4.19. N i and Fe atomic fractions i n the first and the second planes versus temperature for S/NijFe(lll) (from ref.[llO])
tion of the substrate carbonization, appear only at adsorption temperatures N 1500 K when the surface reconstructs in such a manner that the carbon atoms are residing in interstitial positions between the first two layers of tungsten atoms. This atomic order of the substrate and the modifier is very similar to the layered structure of W2C. It is clear that in the case of surface or bulk compound formation the chemical properties of the substrate will match those of the new material, as for instance has been shown in refs. [158, 1591: the carbonization of some transition metals results in a material with catalytic behaviour similar to that of noble metals. Obviously, the formation of a n oxide phase will cause the properties of the metal catalyst to be converted t o those of the metal oxide, etc. The tendency towards compound formation with the same electronegative modifier under the same reaction conditions depends on the nature of the substrate metal. For example, when comparing the single crystal closely packed metal surfaces of Ni, P d and P t , which are from the same row of the periodic table, it transpires that the possibility of reconstruction and/or compound formation decreases in the sequence Ni, Pd, P t , i. e. going down the column. The Ni lattice can be disturbed by sulphur at elevated temperatures [107, 1611, it also forms a relatively stable surface carbide [162], and is rather easily oxidized [142, 143, 1611. The P t lattice is not penetrated by sulphur [91, 921, and no carbide formation or oxidation takes place under UHV conditions [158, 1601, whereas Pd exhibits intermediate behaviour [89, 134, 1581.
52
Chapter 4
Another possibility of a structural order of some electronegative additives on metal surfaces is that observed on phosphorus covered single crystal surfaces. The reports on the behaviour of the P/ Ni(100) [162], P/Rh(100) [163], and P/Pt(lll) [164] systems do not give unambiguous identification of the P structure and site occupation. It has been supposed that phosphorus either tends t o form istands of a P phase, or the isolated P adatoms may react to form a variety of compounds with the substrate surface atoms. A field emission study [165] has shown that, as a result of interaction with phosphorus, changes in the surface orientation of Pt take place and compound clusters are formed. The stoichiometry of the proposed Me,P, compounds depends on the P concentration and the substrate temperature. The lack of order in the phosphorus adsorption layers causes difficulties in determining the absolute phosphorus coverage and, as can be demonstrated in the forthcoming sections, it has a significant bearing on the strength of the phosphorus modification effects. It should also be mentioned here that, in the case of C, one should distinguish between the two possible surface states of carbon. The first state, i.e. the so called ‘carbidic’ carbon is the one considered above in describing the formation of differently ordered structures due to adsorption and/or carboninduced surface reconstruction. The ’carbidic’ carbon atoms are highly coordinated on the substrate surface and, in the cases of induced reconstruction, they may well occupy the interstices between the first and second layers as well. The second surface form of carbon is the so called ‘graphitic’ form. The formation of a basal layer of graphite is preceded by the growth of islands of a graphite phase in which the location of the carbon atoms cannot be specified [166, 1681. An important conclusion regarding the structural behaviour of the electronegative additives is that, except in some cases, they show a strong tendency towards the formation of ordered structures and towards the occupation of the highest coordinated surface states with submonolayer coverages. This assist an explaining the contribution of the geometric factor to the adatom modification effects, especially for low modifier coverages when, in most cases, the strongly bound additives do not cause substantial reconstruction of the substrate surface. 4.2.2
Strength and Nature of the Surface Bonding
A. Strength of the adsorption bond of the electronegative additives The strength of the substrate - adsorbate bonding is an important characteristic because it determines the stability of the ”poisons” on the surface. Various methods have been applied t o the evaluation of the metal-electronegative modifier bonding energy, EM-x. The choice of the method depends on the stability of the modifier adatom on the surface, i.e. on whether it can be removed from the surface by desorption a t elevated temperatures, or not. The determination of EM-x by direct thermal programmed associative desorption is possible in the case of less strongly bound additives, e.g. O?/P t, O?/Ru, Oz/Pd, NZ/Pt, S/Pt, etc. which have no strong tendency to compound formation. For all these cases the adsorption is a nonactivated process so that
4.2. Electronega tive Additives
53
the desorption energy measured from the T P D spectra can be directly related t o EM-Xaccording to the well known relationship :
where AH is the activation energy of desorption and D x , is the dissociation energy of the molecule X2 in the gas phase. Another method for evaluating of the E M - X values is based on the adsorption isobars or isosteres, for the case that the modifier is deposited on the surface by gas adsorption, e.g. HzS, H2Se, PH3, H2C2, etc. This method uses the Clausius - Clapeiron relationship for determining the heats of adsorption, A U.
d l-n P -
dl/T
AH --
R
The third method for direct evaluation of E M - X is the Born - Haber cycle, using adequate XPS data. Table 4.4. presents selected EM-^ values for the adsorption state of several 0.25). The covalent radii, of the most common poisons (for a coverage T , , the Pauling electronegativity, x, and the energies of the corresponding stoichiometric bulk compounds are given in brackets. The EM-^ values show that the affinity of most catalyst surfaces to these modifiers is very high and rather stable layers are formed. That is why it is impossible to avoid poisoning, because the temperatures at which the catalytic reactions usually take place are far below the temperatures required for the poison desorption in the cases when no compound formation or subsurface diffusion take place. However, as outlined in the previous subsection, a variety of secondary processes, such as temperature-driven adatom bulk diffusion/surface segregation, reconstruction and compound formation, are likely to happen at elevated temperatures. The selected data in Table 4.4. lead to the following two important coilclusions:
-
(i) comparison of the measured EM-Xvalues with the corresponding bond strengths of the bulk metal compounds shows that the adsorbed electronegative additives layers on the metal are more stable [118], as has already been predicted earlier by the measured shorter M - X bond lengths;
(ii) the measured EM-x values show a good correlat,ion with the observed tendency towards a substrate surface reconstruction and compound formation in the presence of the electronegative additives, e.g. for the same modifier reconstruction and compound formation occurs more readily on Fe than on Pt, while for the same substrate - C is the more active element.
B. Charge transfer involved in the formation of the adsorption bond (work f unc ti on changes).The forma.tion of the adatom - surfa.ce adsorption bond involves energetica,lly and symmetrically appropriate adsorbate
Chapter 4
54
Table 4.1. Adsorption bond strength, EM-^ in kJ/mole, for several adatom transition metal systems. For the sake of comparison the bond strength in NiS is given at the end of the table
METAL
Fe( 110) Ru(001) Rh( 111) Ir( 11 1) Pd( 111) Pt(ll1) Ni( 11 1) Ni(100) NiS
MODIFIER ( r c in
A; X )
S
C
N
(1.02; 2.5)
(0.77; 2.5)
(0.75; 3.0)
733 [169] 603 [169]
585 [175]
330 [go] -
290 [lo71 425 [lo"] 411 [157] 682 11741 360
-
635 489 569 633 555
[169] [169] [169] [169] [174]
-
530 545 530 564 490
[I711 [177] [178] [176] [179]
0 (0.73; 3.5) 530 445 725 389 367 352 543
[I691 [170] [173] [171] [171] [I721 [169]
and substrate electronic states. In order to obtain a more complete description of the properties of the modified surface, it is important to establish the perturbations of the surface electronic structure induced by the presence of adatoms on the surface. The first attempts to characterize the changes in surface electronic structure are the measurements of the adatom induced changes in the work function, A@, assuming a direct relationship between the dipole moment, m,estimated from the A@ value (see eq.(8) in Chapter 2.) and the amount of charge transfer between the adatom and the surface. According to the relationship rn = dq, where q is the charge transfer per atom and d is the dipole length (the component of the bond length perpendicular to the surface), one can estimate q for all adsorbate systems where the adsorption site and the adsorption bond lengths, 1, are known. Usually, for most of the common 'poisons' such as S, Se, P, and C, the measured work function changes upon adsorption are rather small (0.1-0.5 e V ) . This determines rather low q values. The sign of the work function changes is usually positive, which would indicate a charge transfer towards the electronegative additive adatom, but there are cases where the adsorption of the modifier induces a negative work function change. Some selected work function data for S adsorption on several transition metal single crystal surfaces may be considered. It so happens that on N i ( l l 1 ) [185], Ni(100) [180], Mo(100) [181] and Ru(0001) [182], S adsorption induces an increase of the work function in the range 0.14.5 eV for a monolayer coverage ( c(2 x 2)s for fcc (100) and bcc(100) surfaces and (6 x &)R30° for fcc(ll1) and hpc(OOO1) surfaces). On the contrary, S adsorption on Pt(100), P t ( l l 1 ) [134, 1831 and P d ( l l 1 ) [89] leads to negative work function changes. An example of A$vs. sulphur coverage dependence for positive and negative work function changes is shown
4.2. Elec tronega ti ve Additives
55
in fig. 4.20. [184]. From the data in fig. 4.20. one can evaluate that the charge transfer per S adatom can be evaluated within the limits of very low adsorbate coverages:- -0.04 e- for S/Ni(100) and +0.02 e- for S / P t ( l l l ) . Negative work function changes were measured also for other electronegative additives, e.g. C1 on W(110) I1851 and W(211) [36], N on W(100) [186], I on W(100) [36], Te on Ni(100) [84], etc.
-
0.4 0*3 3 0.2 QI u 3 0.1 “ 0
- 0.1
- O o2I
\9,
- O 3 Pt(l11)
Fig. 4.20. Work function changes induced by S adsorption on Ni(100) and Pt(l11) surfaces (from ref. [187])
The work function results indicate that the formation of a strong adsorption bond between most of the electronegative modifiers and the substrate involves a negligible charge movement in the Z direction to tthe adatom, and in some cases the charge movement seems to be even towards the substrate. Since all electronegative modifiers under consideration are expected to behave as electron accepter an explanation of the measured positive work function changes in some adsorption systems can be based on the fact that there are two contributions to the measured work function changes upon adsorption: the external electrostatic dipole moment, (determined by d and q ) and the internal polarization dipole moment, A@,,,, (determined by the interactions of the adspecies with the hybridized substrate surface d - p orbitals) [188, 1891. The adsorbate induced surface dipole A$’,nt is always negative in sign and its magnitude depends on the nature of the adsorbate and substrate and on the surface crystallographic orientat,ion. That is why, in the case of adsorbates where the adsorption bond formation involves a small charge trans-
56
Chapter 4
fer in the Z direction, the conventional arguments relating the sign and the magnitude of the experimentally measured work function to the electrostatic dipole moment only is not valid because the contribution of A@,nt(although small) should be also taken into account. This might lead to work function changes with a negative sign even for some acceptor adatoms. C . N a t u r e of the e le c t rone ga t ive adatom adsorption bond.The main conclusion from the relatively small and sometimes negligible charge transfer t o the electronegative adspecies, discussed above, is that the character of the Me - X adsorption bond is largely covalent. This is consistent with the theoretical predictions of Citrin [119] for the small percentage of ionicity of the bonding of the adatoms under consideration on the single metal surfaces, especially for additives such as S, Se, C, and Te, which are less electronegative. In order to qualify the degree of covalency or ionicity, Citrin used the simplest approach of comparison of the calculated covalent single bond lengths in a bulk-like system with measured adsorption bond lengths. The bond length of the covalent single bond was calculated using the simple relationship: RMex(calculated) = f M e -!- fx - C(&e
-xx),
(7)
where T M and ~ r x are the single bond covalent radii of the metal and the additive taken from ref. [118], X M and ~ X x are the corresponding Pauling electronegativities, and c is an empirical coefficient. The basic idea is that, comparing the calculated values of the single covalent bond, with the experimentally measured adsorption bond lengths, L , from the deviation one can judge the degree of the ionicity of the corresponding adsorption bond. L larger than RMex(calc.) suggests a relatively more pronounced ionic character, and vice versa. Although, as pointed o u t in ref. [llg], these simplified calculations are not strictly quantitative. This approach gives an idea about the trends in the character of the adsorption bonding. On the basis of the = D differences, the following trends are found. For adsorbate L systems where the modifiers have close covalent radii but different Pauling electronegativities the deviation D confirms the expected correlation of an increase of the ionicity of the bonding with increasing Pauling electronegativity. A convincing example is the comparison of the estimated D values for the following adsorption systems: (i) O/Ni(100) --Xo = 3.5, TO = 0.73, D = +0.12; N/Ni(100) -XN = 3.0, f N = 0.75, D = 0.00; C/Ni(100) - & = 2.5, f c = 0.77, D = -0.13; (ii) I/Cu(lOO) -XI = 2.5, q = 1.33, D = +0.08; Te/Cu(lOO) r ~ =, 1.37, D = -0.03;
-XTe
= 2.1,
(iii) I / C u ( l l l ) - D = +0.05, T e / C u ( l l l ) - D = +0.04. The results for modifier/Cu systems also show further that the degree of ionicity for the same adatom and substrate is dependent on the crystallographic orientation of the substrate. This reflects the dependence of L on the adsorption site first-neighbour coordination number, discussed in Subsection 4.2.1. An apparent trend is, that the ionicity increases with the coordination number (bond length). For the case of Te, it should be remembered that the Te
4.2. Elec tronega tive Additives
57
adsorption site on C u ( l l 1 ) is a six-fold one and the Te - nearest Cu bond lengths are 2.62 and 2.69 for Cu(100) and C u ( l l l ) , respectively [190]. The general trend of a larger coordination number (or L ) and a higher degree of ionicity is also evident in the case of S/Ni(100) ( D = -0.5), S/Ni(111) (D = -0.08), O/Ni(100) (D = +0.12), O / N i ( l l l ) ( D = +0.06), etc. [119]. This correlation between the coordination number and the ionicity of bonding is the same as that observed for bulk compounds [118].This is not surprising, taking into account the fact that the strength of the electronegative adatoms adsorption bonds is comparable with or even higher than the typical chemical bonds. When the trend for adatoms with t8hesame Pauling electronegativity but different adatom covalent radii is compared, it becomes obvious that the adatom dimensions should also be taken into account (the bond ionicity increases with adatom size). An example of the influence of the adatom dimensions of electronegative additives with the same Pauling electronegativity is the larger ‘covalency’ of the C adsorption bond (D = -0.13, PC = 0.77 [135]) on Ni(100), compared with that of S ( D = -0.05, T S = 1.04 [191]) and I (D= +0.21, 7-1 = 1.33 [192]) adsorbed on the same surface. A quantitative picture of the relative contribution of the Pauling electronegativity and the size of the adatoms to the nature (‘ionicity’ or ‘covalency’) of the adsorption bond is very difficult to make because as was stressed above, this simplified approach is rather empirical and outlines only the general trend, including any deviations. D. Bonding chemistry. For a thorough quantitative description of the nature of the adsorption bond of electronegat,ive additives, a detailed picture of the local electronic structure of the different adsorption sites as to directions, symmetries and energies of the hybridized occupied and unoccupied metal orbitals on the surface. The latter contribute to the formation of the adsorption bond. They determine the most favourable location where the appropriate modifier adatom electronic valence states will overlap with those of the substrate atoms. For the electronegative adatoms under consideration, it can be assumed that their highest lying p-electronic valence states will participate in the formation of the adsorption bond. The degree of coupling with the substrate electronic states depends on the energy, symmetry and occupied position of the modifier p-states: e.g. C has two partly filled p , and py atomic orbitals and one empty p r orbital; N has three partly-filled p orbitals, and 0 has one completely filled p , and two partly filled p , and p , orbitals. As discussed above, this results in significant differences in the nature of chemisorption on the same Ni( 100) surface. One of the most appropriate techniques used for determining the nature of the chemical bond of the adsorbed species, i.e. how the adatoms are bound t o the surface, is angle-resolved photoemission. It gives reliable information about the degree of involvement of the different modifier and substrate electronic valence states in the bonding when the adatoms form well ordered layers. As an example for a precise ARUPS characterization of chalcogen adsorption is the study of p(2 x 2), c(2 x 2) and (&x &)R30° sulphur overlayers on Ni(100) [193] and Ni(ll1) [194], respectively. As a result of the interaction of the S 3p,, 3py and 3p, levels with the appropriate symmetric Ni states
58
Chapter 4
(S being in a fourfold adsorption site), two types of molecular orbitals can be formed: a single orbital with a1 symmetry, involving S p , atomic orbital, and two doubly degenera.t.e orbitals with e symmetry involving the p , and p , atomic orbitals. In the real adsorbate syst,ems with ordered S overlayers, two dimensional band is formed due t o additional interactions, either direct or via the substrate between the S porbitals. Fig. 4.21. presents the experimental normal emission ARUPS spectra for ppolarized light at two angles of incidence. It is obvious that the energy positions of the 0.1 state built by the S 3 p , orbital and the e state composed by the S p , and p , orbitals depend on the S covera.ge. The binding energies of the al and e level are 4.2 and 4.9 eV, respectively, for p(2 x 2)S, whereas for c(2 x 2) s the a1 and e states reverse in binding energy, a,1 moving to a higher binding energy of 5.9 eV and e moving slightly to a lower binding energy of 4.4 eV. In addition, the changes in the and e binding energies wit11 increasing S coverage a.re a.ccompanied by changes in the width of the states: for the a.1 state the width increa,ses from 1.0 eV for p(2 x 2 ) s to 2.1 eV for c(2 x 2)S, whereas for the e st,at.e the width decreases from 2.1 to 1.4 eV, respectively. Although the deta.iled description of these observations can not be based on initial stmateeffects only, they contain important informa.tion on the relative contribution which the S 3p,, 3p, and 3 p , levels render towards the formatmionof the adsorption bond for two S structures formed a t va.rious S covemges. The data in fig. 4.21 indica.te that for higher S coverages, the contribution of the p , - Ni interaction becomes stronger, whereas a t p(2 x 2)s (qs = 0.25) the S p , and p , orbitals are more strongly involved in the formation of the a.dsorption bond. In addition, with increasing S coverage (from the p(2 x 2 ) s to the c(2 x 2)s overlayer), the S p bands dispersion increases. This suggests an enhmced interaction between the S p states within the c(2 x 2)s layer as a result of the decreased S - S separation at higher S covemges [193]. In the case of larger cha.lcogen a.dditives (Se and Te), the same trend in the p , and p,, derived states a,nd in the p band dispersion is observed with increasing adatom covera.ge on Ni(100), i.e energy inversion of the p , and p,, states and an increase in dispersion (see table 111. in ref. [195]). The case of 0 is the only one for which, the energy posit#ionof the p , level is alwa.ys below the p,, levels. Although it, goes from the p(2 x 2) to the c(2 x 2) coverage, the p z level is subjected to a stronger upwa.rd energy shift which approaches the p,, level. Obviously, these differences in the modifier plevels energy positions reflect their different overlap with the hybridized substra,te surface electronic states. It should be pointed out tha.t, 011 the basis of compa.rison between the p orbital energies of the free chalcogens and the values measured on the chalcogen adatom, one can get an idea of the ionicity of the adsorption bond. It has been found that, as predict,ed from t
-
-
-
4.2. Electronega ti ve Add; tives
59
INITIAL ENERGY ( e V )
Fig. 4.21. Normal emission spectra for S/Ni(100) for p-polarized light at two angles of incidence. The a1 state is built by the S p z orbital and the ‘e’ state is composed by the S p , and S p , levels (from ref.[193]) of oxygen adsorption on several inetal substrates, Doyen et alhave calculated that the charge transfer is of the order of 5 % [196].
The same tendency of an upward shift (a decrease of the binding energy) has been observed for the core levels of the modifier adatoms under consideration [197-1991. However, since the orbital binding energies derived from the photoelectron spectra depend not only on the initial state effects (chemical and electrostatic shifts) but also on the final state relaxation or screening effects (which are unique for each adsorption system), a quantitative conclusion regarding the variations in ionicity of the adsorption bond of different modifiers cannot be made on the basis of the UPS data alone. Up t o this point, the filled valence states of the adatoms which are located below the Fermi level were considered. For transition metals characterized by a high density of d-states at the Fermi level, the unoccupied antibonding modifier pderived states can not be detected by UPS because they lie above the Fermi level. Certain information on the enhancement of the local density of unfilled valence band states located above the Fermi level has been found for C, N , 0 and S adsorbed on Ni, Cr, and Ti, using the X-ray appearance method [199] and inverse photoemission [200]. Existence of antibonding p derived levels below the Fermi level has been detected by UPS for substrates (e.g. Cu) where the filled d-band lies below the Fermi level [196, 2011. In these cases the emission associated with the antibonding p levels has been detected a t energies below the Fermi level. The experimental evidence of the presence of bonding and antibonding electron states indicates that the formation of the
Chapter 4 adsorption bond should be described as a localized phenomenon in terms of a ‘surface molecule’. This means that the chemisorption bond energy depends on the efficiency of the overlap between the modifier and substrate surface atom orbitals. Thus, the measured energy level shifts of the orbitals involved in the formation of the chemisorption bond and the energy separation (gap) between the resulting bonding and antibonding states can be successfully correlated with the measured magnitudes of the modifier’s adsorption bond strengths. Thus far the only energy changes looked at were those electronic levels of the electronegative adatoms which, as a result of the adsorption bond formation, concerned both, occupied and unoccupied electronic states of the substrate surface. Undoubtedly, the substrate nature is another important factor in the strength and the nature of the surface - modifier bonding. Of interest are the atomic radii and the electronegativity of the substrate atoms as well as the surface geometric and electronic structure. The possible modifier induced perturbations in geometric structure of the surface have already been considered in the previous subsection. They are always accompanied by significant changes in the electronic structure of the substrate surface, due to the strong coupling of the additive adatoms with the surface atoms involved in the formation of the adsorption bond. These changes of the electron density distribution in the surface valence band are reflected by the energy shifts in both the occupied and unoccupied electronic states. In general, the local density of states near the Fermi level is supposed to be an important property of the catalyst surface because it determines the number of electronic states that can be excited from an occupied to an unoccupied state at the lowest energy cost. In most cases these are the states involved in the interaction with the reagents. Consequently the introduction of a modifier will affect the ability of the surface to respond to external perturbations [l89]. The magnitude of the adatom-induced alterations of the electron distribution at/or near the surface depends on the nature and strength of the chemical bond. The current ARUPS and IPE data have shown that all electronegative adatoms considered in the present review cause a suppression of the substrate surface emission from the valence d-band near the Fermi level and the appearance of new features in the near region below the Fermi level. Most often these features are attributed to an emission from chemically shifted d-states of the substrate atoms directly involved in the adsorption bond [191, 192 195, 197-199, 202-2051. Thus, the significant changes in the energy region of the Ni d band observed in the angle-resolved photoemission spectra when S is adsorbed, indicate a considerable involvement of the localized surface Ni 3d electron states in the adsorption bond [193]. However, as outlined in ref. [195], the intensity changes in the substrate d-band region are not related in any direct manner to the actual charge redistribution on the surface atoms. This means that the relative weight of the valence d-states and the delocalized s-valence states contributions to the interactions with the electronegative additives cannot be qualified on the basis of the presently available experimental data. The main conclusion that can be made on the basis of the available experimental and theoretical data is, that the strongest charge perturbations
4.2. Elec tronega t i ve Additives
61
as a result of the adsorption bond formation, are localized within the first substrate plane. It has been shown that the increased bonding charge in the adatom/surface interface is counteracted by a charge depletion below the surface top layer resulting in a change of the Me - Me spacing between the first and the second layer. Indeed, as was discussed in the previous Subsection, in many adsorption systems, an expansion in the substrate lattice has been observed. The changes in valence electron distribution of the substrate surface atoms also lead t o changes in the surface atom core level electron states. In the case of adsorbates with electron acceptor behaviour, an increase of the core level binding energy (downward shift) of the substrate atoms should be expected if the formation of the adsorption bond involves a substantial charge transfer to the adatom . Some authors [205] have tried to correlate the measured surface Mo 3 d 5 / , core level shifts, A E , induced by adsorption of different electronegative additives (O,C, and B) to the Pauling electronegativity difference, AX, between the modifier and the substrate metal. For the three chosen additives - 0, C and B. which are characterized by different electronegativities ( 3 . 5 , 2.5 and 2.0, resp.), but with closely covalent radii (0.73, 0.77 and 0.8, resp.), the authors have established a linear dependence between the measured DE values and the corresponding k values [205]. It has been shown that the adsorption of B, C and 0 causes the following increase of the surface 3d core level binding energy: AS, = +0.1 eV, A& = +0.2 eV and Eo = +0.4 eV. The trend in the A E values indicates that going from B to 0, the surface atoms become more electron deficient due to an increase of the adsorption bond ionicity. More significant surface core level shifts have been detected when, as a result of the surface - modifier interactions, a new chemical compound is formed. This is attributed to the fact that the true stoichiometric compounds usually have more ionic bonds [118]. 4.2.3
Conclusive Remarks
The most import,ant data reviewed in this subsection show that, in order to explain the poisoning action of the electronegative additives under consideration, the contribution of the following three main fact,ors should be taken into account for any particular system:
1. The number of substrate atoms involved in direct interactions with the modifier adatom. This depends on the structural order of the modifier overlayers on the surface and determines the blocking effect of the poisons. 2. The actual changes in electronic structure of the substrate atoms induced by the adsorption bond formation. The magnitude of these changes depend on the nature and strength of the adsorption bond, which is of a covalent type for most of the electronegative additives under consideration.
3. The Pauling electronegativity and the adatom size of the modifier which are the major factors determining the degree of ionicity of the adsorption
Chapter 4
62
bond. T h e s e factors a r e i m p o r t a n t for explaining the differences i n the severity (range) of the poisoning effect of different modifiers.
REFERENCES
PI
D R P 249.447 submitted 9 January 1910 by C. Bosch, A. Mittasch, G . Stern and H. Wiff, Basf Lunwigshafen W. D. Mross, Catal. Rev.-Sci. Eng. 25 (1983) 591 A. Nielsen, Catal. Rev.-Sci. Eng. 23 (1981) 17 D. W. Goodman, Acc. Chem. Rev. bf. 17 (1984) 194 I. Langmuir and K.H.I
E. Bauer in: Chemical Physics of Solid Surfaces and Heterogeneous Catalysis vo1.3, eds. D. King and D. P. Woodruff (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1984) p.1 G. Pirug and H. P. Bonzel, Surface Sci. 194 (1988) 159 K. Heinz, G. Besold and K. Mtller, in: Physics of Solid Surfaces, ed. J. Koukal (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1988) p.191 R. D. Gerlach and T. N. Rhodin, Surface Sci. 17 (1969) 32; ibid. 19 (1970) 403 ~141 A. G. Naumovets and J. S. Vedula, Surface Sci. Reports 4 (1984) 365 1151 A. G. Naumovets, Contemporary Physics, Vo1.30 (1989) 187; Sov. Scz. Rev. A , 5 (1984) 443 Yu. S. Vedula, A. G. Naumovets and V. V. Poplavski, Fiz. Tverdogo Tela 30 (1988) 2116 (Russ.) T. L. Einstein, J. A. Hertz and J . R. Schriefer in: Theory of Chemisorption, ed. J. R. Smith (Springer, Berlin, 1980) 183 J. M. Koesterlitz in: Phase Transitions in Surface Films, eds. J. R. Pash and J. Rivalds (Plenum Press, New York, 1980) 193 J. Paul, J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A5 (1987) 664 T. Agura, H. Tochihara and Y. Murata, Surface Sci. 175 (1986) L725 G. Pirug, A. Winkler and H. P. Bonzel, Surface Sci. 163 (1985) 153 P. L. Doering and S. Semancik, Surface Sci. 129 (1983) 177 T. K. Sham, M.-L. Shek, G.-Q Xu and J . Hrbek, J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A7 (1989) 2191
R. J. Behm, in: Physics and Chemistry of Alkali Metal Adsorption, eds. H. Bonzel, A. M. Bradshaw and G. Ertl (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1989) p.111 and the references therein
References
63
C. J. Barnes, M. Lindroos, D. J. Holmes and D. A. King, in: Physics and Chemistry of Alkali Metal Adsorption, eds. H. Bonzel, A. M. Bradshaw and G. Ertl (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1989) p.129 and the references therein T.Agura and Yo.Murata, Progress in Surface Science vo1.31 (1989) p.61 W. Moritz and D. Wolf, Surface Sci. 18 (1979) L29; ibgd. 163 (1985) LG55 C. M. Chan, M. A. Van Hive, M. A. Weinberg and E. D. Williams, Surface Sci. 91 (1980) 440 E. Sowa, M. A. Van Hove and D. L. Adams, Surface Sci. 199 (1988) 174 B. E. Hayden, I<. C . Prince, P. J. Davie, G. Paolucci and A. M. Bradshaw, Solid S t a t e Cornmun. 48 (1985) 325 C. A. Papageorgopoulos and J. M. Chen, Surface Sci. 39 (1973) 283 I. K. Robinson, M. S. Altmann and P. J. Estrup in: Structure of Surfaces, eds. J. F. Van der Veen and M. A. Van Hove (Springer,Berlin, 1988) p.137 G. R. Behm, G. Ertl, D. I<. Flynn, I<. D. Jannison and P. A. Thiel, Phys. Rev. B 36 (1987) 9267 Sv. Surnev and M. Kiskinova, A p p l . Phys. A 46 (1988) 323 S. Andersson and U. Jostell, Surface Sci. 46 (1974) 625; Far. Disc. Chem. Soc. GO (1975) 255
J . Holzl, F. Schulte in: Solid Surface Physics, Springer Tracts in Modern Physics (Springer, Berlin, 1979) p.85 G. Rangelov and L. Surnev, Surface Sci. 185 (1987) 457 R. A. d e Paola, J. Hrbek and F. M. Hoffman, J . Chem. Phys. 82 (1985) 2484 K. Markert and I<. Wandelt, Surface Sci. 159 (1985) 24 J. Hrbek, Surface Sci. 164 (1985) 139 M. Kiskinova, Surface Sci. 182 (1987) 150 K. Harrison, R. M. Lambert and P. H. Prince, Surface Sci. 176 (1986) 530 M. Kiskinova and M. Tikhov, Surface Sci. 104 (1988) 379 G.Rangelov, Ph. D.Thesis, Sofia, 1987 R. W . Gurney, Phys. Rev. 47 (1935) 479 J . J . Weimer and E. Umbach, Phys. Rev. B 30 (1984) 4863 P. Soukiassian, R. Riwan, J. Lecant, E. Wimmer, S. R. Chabb and H. 3 . Freeman, Phys. Rev. B 31 (1985) 4911 L. Surnev, M. Kiskinova and G. Bliznakov, Solid S t a t e Commun. 37 (1981) 87
S. A. Lindren and L. Walden, Solid State Commun. 25 (1978) 13; Phys. Rev. B 22 (1980) 5967; in: Physrcs and Chemistry of Alkali Metal Adsorptton, eds. H. Bonzel, A. M. Bradshaw and G. Ertl (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1989) p.101 and the references therein L. Surnev, G. Rangelov, E. Bertel and F. P. Netzer, Surface Sci. 184 (1987) 10
L. Surnev and G. Rangelov, Solid S t a t e Comrnun. 54 (1985) 783 J . Ktppers, in: Physics and Chemistry of Alkali MetaJ Adsorption, eds. H. Bonzel, A. M. Bradshaw and G. Ertl (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1989) p.45 and the references therein J. Lee, C. Hanrahan, J. Arias, F. Bozso, R. M. Martin and H. Matiu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 54 (1985) 611
64
Chapter 4 H. Horn, J. Somers, Th. Lindner and A. M. Bradshaw, in: Physics and Chemistry of Alkali Metal Adsorption, eds. H. Bonzel, A. M. Bradshaw and G. Ertl (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1989) p.55 and the references therein
L. Wallden, Phys. Rev. Lett. 54 (1985) 943 E. Bertel, W. Jacob and V. Dose, Phys. Rev. B 36 (1987) 2421 D. Heskett, I<.-H. Frank, E. E. Koch and H.-J. Freund, Phys. Rev. B 36 (1987) 1276
G.M. Lamble, R. S. Brooks, D. A. King and D. Norman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 61 (1988) 1112 N. D. Lang and A. R. Williams, Phys. Rev. B 18 (1978) 616 N. D. Lang, in: Physics and Chemistry of Alkali Metal Adsorption, eds. H. Bonzel, A. M. Bradshaw and G. Ertl (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1989) p.11 and the references therein J. P. Muskat and D. M. Newns, Progress in Surface Sci. 9 (1978) 1 J. W. Gadzuk, J. I<. Hartman and T. N . Rhodin, Phys. Rev. B 4 (1971) 241 D. Drakova, G. Doyen and R. Hubner, J. Chem. Phys. 89 (1988) 1725 H. Ishida and I<. Terakura, Phys. Rev. B 38 (1988) 5752 E. Wimmer, A. J. Freeman, M. Weinert, H. Krakauer, J. R. Hiskes and A. M. Karo, Phys. Rev. Lett. 48 (1982) 1128 S. R. Chubb, E. Wimmer, A. J. Freeman, J . R. Hiskes and A. M. Karo, Phys. Rev. B 36 (1987) 4112 K. Wandelt, in: Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, Vol. 32, ed. P. Wissmann (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1987) p.280 ; in: Physics and Chemistry of Alkali Metal Adsorption, eds. H. Bonzel, A. M. Bradshaw and G. Ertl (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1989) p.25 and the references therein K. Jacobi and H. Rotermund, Surface Sci. 116 (1982) 435 D. R. Mullins, J. M. White and H. S. Luftman, Surface Sci. 167 (1986) 39 N. D. Lang and A. R. Williams, Phys. Rev. B 25 (1982) 2940 L. Surnev, in: Physics and Chemistry of Alkali Metal Adsorption, eds. H. Bonzel, A. M. Bradshaw and G. Ertl (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1989) p.173 R. Miranda, in: Physics and Chemistry of Alkali Metal Adsorption, eds. H. Bonzel, A. M. Bradshaw and G. Ertl (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1989) p.425 and the references therein [731 P. Soukiassian and H. J. Starnberg, in: Physics and Chemistry of Alkali Metal Adsorption, eds. H. Bonzel, A. M. Bradshaw and G. Ertl (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1989) p.449 and the references therein M. Prietsch, C. Laubschat, M. Domke and G. Kaindl, in: Physjcs and Cbemistry of Alkali Metal Adsorption, eds. H. Bonzel, A. M. Bradshaw and G. Ertl (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1989) p.469 and the references therein D. Heskett, T. Maeda Wong, A. J. Smith and W. R. Graham, N. J. DiNardo and E. W. Plummer, J. Vac. Sci. Techno]. B 7 (1989) 915 M. Tikhov, G. Rangelov and L. Surnev, Surface Sci. 231 (1990) 280 Y.Etna, I<. Kinoshita, S. Suzuki and S. Kono, Phys. Rev. B 36 (1987) 9801; ibid. 39 (1989) 1125 S. Nishigaki, N. Oishi, S. Matzuda, N . Kawanishi and T. Sasaki, Phys. Rev. B 39 (1989) 8048 M. Kamaratos and C. A. Papageorgopoulos, Surface Sci 219 (1989) 317 H.Ishida and I<. Terakura, Phys. Rev. I3 40 (1989) 11519
References
65
Y. Etna, K. Kinoshita, S. Suzuki and S. Kono, Phys. Rev. B 39 (1989) 1125 T. Edmonds, J. J . McCaroll and P. C. Pitkethly, J . Vacuum Sci. Technol. 8 (1971) 68
J. E. Demuth, D. W. Jepsen and P. Markus, Phys. Rev. Lett. 32 (1974) 1182 T.W. Capehart and T. N. Rhodin, J . Vacuum Sci. Technol. 6 (1979) 594 T. W. Capehart, C. W. Seabury, G. W. Graham and T . N . Rhodin, Surface Sci. 120 (1982) L441 E. Erley and H. Wagner, J. Catalysis 53 (1978) 283 J. Kitajima, T. Yokoyama, T. Ohta, M. Funalashi, N. I
J. S. Foord and A. E. Reynolds, Surface Sci. 164 (1985) 640 Y.Bertier, M. Perdereau and J. Oudar, Surface Sci. 36 (1973) 125 I<. Hayek, H. Glassl, A. Gutmann, H. Leonhard, M. Prutton. S. P. Tear and M. R. Welton-Cook, Surface Sci. 152/153 (1985) 419 R. J. Koestner, M. Salmeron, E. B I
C. M. Chan and W. H. Weinbeig, J . Cbem. Pltys. 71 (1979) 3998 P. M. Marcus, J . E. Demutli and D. W. Jepsen, Surface Sci. 53 (19’75) 501 J. Stohr, R. Jaeger and S. Brennan, Surface Sci. 117 (1983) 503 W. Berndt, R. Hora and M. Scheffler, Surface Sci. 117 (1982) 188 S. Hengrasmee, P. R. Watson, D. C. Frost and I<. A. R. Mitchell, Surface Sci. 87 (1979) L249 K. A. R. Mitchell, Surface Sci. 100 (1980) 225 T.E. Fischer and S. R. Kelemen, Surface Sci. 69 (1977) 1 W. Heegemann, I<. H. Meister, E. Bechtold and R. Hayek, Surface Sci. 49 (1975) 161
I<. A . R. Mitchell, Surface Sci. 92 (1980) 79
D. R. Warburton, G . Thornton, D. Norman, C. H. Richardson, R. Mcgrath and F. Sette, Surface Sci. 189/90 (1987) 485
H. P. Bonze1 and R. Ku, J. Cbem. Phys. 58 (1973) 4617 Y. Berthier, J. Oudar and M. Huber, Surface Sci. 65 (1977) 361 J. Oudar, Catalysis Rev. Sci. Eng. 22 (1980) 171
S. R. Kelemen and A . Kalder, J. Chem. Phys. 75 (1981) 1530 H. D. Shih, F. Joaa, D. W. Jepsen and P. M. Marcus, Phys. Rev. Lett. 46 (1981) 731
P. Marcus, A. Teissier and J . Oudar, Surface Sci. 129 (1983) 432 P. Marcus and J. Oudar, Physical Chemistry of the Solid State, Applications to Metals and their Compounds, ed. P. Lacombe (Elsevier, 1984) p.29 [112] Y . Ma, R. Rudolf, E. E. Chaban, C. T. Chen, G. Meigs and F. Sette, Phys. Rev. D (1990) in press M. Kiskinova, A. Szabo and J . T. Yates, Surface Sci. 226 (1990) 237 J. M. MacLaren, J. B. Pendry, J . P. Roils, D. I<. Saldin, G. A . Somorjai, M. A . Van Hove and D. D. Vvedensky A Handbook of Surface Structure (D.
.
Riedel Publishing Conipany) 1988
66
Chapter 4
D. G. Kelly, A. J. Gellman, M. Salmeron, G. A. Somorjai, V. Maurice, M. Huber and J. Oudar, Surface Sci. 2 0 4 (1988) 1 [116] C.-M. Chan and M. A. Van Hove, Surface Sci. 183 (1987) 303 [117] D. G. Kelly, R. F. Lin, M. A. Van Hove and G . A. Somorjai, Surface Sci. [115]
224 (1989) 97 [118] L. Pauling, The Chemical Bond, 4th ed. Cornell University Press, Ithaca, N.Y., 1966 P. N. Citrin, Surface Sci. 184 (1987) 109 [119] C. H. Bartholomew, P. I(. Agrawal and J. R. Katzer, in: Advances in Catal[120] ysis, ~01.31,p.135 [121] W. Oed, H. Lindner, U. Starke, H. Heinz, K. Muller and J. B. Pendry, Surface Sci. 2 2 4 (1989) 179 [122] M. Lindvoos, H. Pfnur, G. Held and D. Menzel, Surface Sci. 2 2 2 (1989) 451 I1231 G. Ertl and J. Kuppers, Surface Sci. 24 (1975) 104 [124] H. Niehus and G. Comsa, Surface Sci. 140 (1984) 18 [125] M. Bader, A. Pushman, S. Ocal and J. Hasse, Phys. Rev. Lett. 57 (1986) 3273
A. W. Robinson, J. S. Somers, D. E. Ricken, A. M. Bradsliaw, A . L. Kilcoyne and D. P. Woodruff, Surface Sci. 227 (1990) 337 [127] R. W. Judd, P. Hollins and J . Pritchard, Surface Sci. 171 (1986) 643 [128] J. H. Onufrenko, D. P. Woodruff and B. H. Holland, Surface Sci. 81 (1979)
[126]
357 [lag]
M. Bader, C. Ocal, B. Hillert, J. Haase and A. M. Bradshaw, Phys. Rev. B
[130] [131]
35 (1987) 5900 W. Daum, S. Lehwald and H. Ibach, Surface Sci. 178 (1986) 528 D. Avranitis, K. Baberschke, L. Wenzel and N. Dobler, Phys. Rev. Lett. 57
(1986) 3175 [132] E. Atkei, U. Bardi, M. Maglietta, G. Rovida, M. Tokkini and E. Zamazzi, Surface Sci. 2 1 1 / 2 1 2 (1989) 93 [133] T. W. Orent and S. D. Bader, Surface Sci. 115 (1982) 323 [134] H. Gutleben and E. Bechtold, Surface Sci. 191 (1987) 157 [135] J. E. Muller, M. Wittig and H. Ibach, Phys. Rev. Lett. 5 6 (1986) 1583 [136] A.-M. Lanzilloto and S. L. Bernasek, J. Chem. Phys. 84 (1986) 3553 [137] H. J. Grabke, W. Paulitschke and S. R. Srinivasan, Reactivity of Solids, ed.
[138] [139] [140] [141] [142] [143] [144] [145] [146]
by J. Wood, 0. Lindquist, S. Helgesson and N. Vannerberg (Plenum N.Y. 1977), p.55 J. C. Bouliard and M. P. Sotto, Surface Sci. 1 8 2 (1987) 200; ibid. 195 (1988) 255; ibid. 2 1 7 (1989) 38 V. Maurice, J. Oudar and M. Huber, Surface Sci. 187 (1987) 312 H. V. Thapliyal and J . Blakeley, J. Vacuum Sci. TechnoJ. 15 (1978) 600 P. H. Holloway and J. B. Hudson, Surface Sci. 43 (1974) 123; ibid. 141 C. R. Brundle and A. F. Carley, Chem. Phys. Lett. 31 (1975) 425 C. Benndorf, A. Hohlfeld, C. Nobl and F. Thieme, in: Proc. ICSS-4 & ECOSS-3, Cannes, 1980 (Suppl. Le Vide No 201 (1980) p.363 C. R. Brundle, Surface Sci. 48 (1975) 99 E. Bauer and H. Poppa, Surface Sci. 88 (1979) 31 J. M. Van Zoest, J. M. Fluit, T. J. Vink and B. A. Van Hassel, Surface Sci. 182 (1987) 179
References
67
[147] K. Ueda and R. Shimizu, Surface Sci. 43 (1974) 77 [148] H. Conrad, J. Kuppers, F. Nitschke and A . Plagge, Surface Sci. 69 (1977) 668 [149] V. P. Ivanov, G. I<. Boreskov, V. I. Savchenko, W. F. Egelhoff Jr., and W. H. Winberg, J. Catalysis 48 (1977) 269 K. 0. Legg, F. Jona, D. W. Jepsen and P. M. Marcus, Surface Sci. 66 (1977) I1501 25 [151] T. Kikuchi and I<. Ishizuka, J. Res. Inst. Catal. Hokkaido Univ. 26 (1978) 7 11521 J. Oudar Conf. Catal. Deactivat. Poison., Lowrence Berkeley Lab., Berkeley May 24-26, 1978 M. Boudart and D. F. Ollis, Surface Sci. 23 (1970) 330 J. B. Benziger, E. KO and R. Madix, J. Cat. 54 (1978) 41 D.R. Mullins and S. H. Overburg, Surface Sci. 103 (1988) 455 C. Giullot, R. Riwan and J . Le Cant,e, Surface Sci. 50 (1976) 581 R. J . Madix, Catal. Rev.-Sci. Engrg. 15 (1977) 293 M. Boudart and R. Levy, Science 181 (1973) 593 M. Pendereau and J. Oudar, Surface Sci. 20 (1970) 80 R. Wandelt, Surface Sci. Rept. 2 (1982) 1 and references therein C. R. Brundle and A. F. Carley, Chem. Phys. Lett. 31 (1975) 425 M.Kiskinova and D. W. Goodman, Surface Sci. 108 (1981) 64 R. I. Hedge, J. Tobin and J . M. White, J. Vacuum Sci. Technol. A 3 (1985 339 C. E. Mitchell, M. A. Henderson and J. M. White, Surface Sci. 191 (1987 425 M. Mundshau and R. Vanselow, Surface Sci. 166 (1986) L131 N. M. Abbas and R. J. Madix, Appl. Surface Sci. 7 (1981) 241 J . L. Gland and G . A. Somorjai, Surface Sci. 41 (1974) 387 R. W. Joyner, G. R. Darling and J. B. Pendry, Surface Sci. 205 (1988) 573 K. W. Frese, Surface Sci. 182 (1987) 85 and references therein L. Surnev, G. Rangelov and G. Bliznakov, Surface Sci. 159 (1985) 299 G . Ertl, in: The Nature of the Surface Chemical Bond, Eds. T. N. Rhodin and G. Ertl (North-Holland, Amst,erdam, 1979) p.313 T. Matsushima, Surface Sci. 157 (1985) 397 G.B. Fischer and S. J . Schmieg, J . Vacuum Sci. Technol. A 5 (1987) 1064 W.F. Egelhoff, Jr., J . Vacuir~nSci. Technol. A5 (1987) 700 F. Boszo, G. Ertl and M. Weiss, J . Cata1,ysi.s 50 (1977) 519 H. Conrad, G. Ertl, J. Ktppers a i d E. E. Latta, Surface Sci. 50 (1975) ?96 H.Conrad, G. Ertl, J. Ktppers and E. E. Latta, Surface Sci. 65 (1977) 335 C.M. Comrie, W. H. Weinberg and R. M. Lambert, Surface Sci. 57 (1976) 619 W . F. Egelhoff, J. Vacuum Sci. Technol. A 3 (2985) 1305 E. L. Hardegree, P. Ho and J . M. Whit.e, Surface Sci. 165 (1986) 488 V. Maurice, L. Peralta, Y. Berthier and J. Oudar, Surface Sci. 148 (1984) 623 S. R. Kelemen and T . E. Fischer, Surface Sci. 87 (1979) 53 J. Billy and M. Abon, Surface Sci. 146 (1984) L525 M. Kiskinova, Habilitation Thesis, 1989 F. Bonchek, T. Engel and E. Bauer, Surface Sci. 97 (1980) 595
68
Chapter 4 D. L. Adams and L. H. Germer, Surface Sci. 27 (1971) 21
M.Kiskinova, Habilitation Thesis,
1989
E. Shustorovich and R. C. Baetzold, Appl. Surface Sci. 11/12 (1982) 693 P. J. Feibelman and D. R. Hamann, Surface Sci. 149 (1985) 48 F. Comin, P. H. Citrin, P. Eisenberger and J. E. Rowe, Phys. Rev. B 26 (1982) 7060
S. Brennan, J. Stohr and R. Jaeger, Phys. Rev. B 24 (1981) 4871 R. G. Jones, S. Ainsworth, M. D.Crapper, C. Somerton and D. P. Woodruff, Surface Sci. 179 (1987) 425 E. W. Plummer, B. Tonner, N. Holzwart and A. Liebsch, Phys. Rev. B 21 (1980) 4306
T. W.Capehart and T. N. Rhodin, Surface Sci. 83 (1979) 367 E. W. Plummer and W. Eberhardt, Adv. Chem. Phys. 20 (1982) 49 and references therein G. Doyen and G. Ertl, J. Chem. Phys. 68 (1978) 5417 R. Wandelt, Surface Sci. Reports 2 (1982) 1 and references therein A. Gelman, W. Tysoe, F. Zaera and G. A. Somorjai, Surface Sci. 191 (1987) 271
S. Anderson and C. Nyberg, Surface Sci. 52 (1975) 489 L. Klebanoff, R. I<. Jones, D. T. Pierce and R. Celotta, Phys. Rev. B 36 (1987) 7849
G. G. Tibbetts, J . M. Burkst.rand and J . C. Tracy, Phys. Rev. B 15 (1977) 3652
P. J. Jupiter, A. J. Viescas, C. Carbone, J . Lindau and W. E. Spicer, J. Vacuum Sci. Technol. A 3 (1985) 1517 G. B. Fischer, Surface Sci. 62 (1977) 31 D. Spanjaard, C. Guillot, M. C. Desjonqueres, G. Treglia and J. Lecante, Surface Sci. Rept. 5 (1985) 1 J. L. Grant, T. B. Fryberger and P. C. Stair, Surface Sci. 159 (1985) 333
Chapter 5
ADSORPTION OF GASES O N SURFACES MODIFIED BY ELECTRONEGATIVE ADATOMS
5.1
5.1.1
CARBON MONOXIDE General Remarks for CO Adsorption on Clean Metal Surfaces
The most exploited model for explaining the CO bonding on transition metal surfaces is the synergic mechanism proposed by Blyholder for the description of the metal - CO bond in transition metal carbonyls where CO is known as a ligand in the transition metal inorganic chemistry [l].According to the model proposed by Blyholder, the metal - CO bonding involves donation from the strongly directed CO - 5u highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) to the unoccupied or partly occupied s, p or d, metal orbitals, and back donation from the appropriate metal (most often & occupied states) to the CO 2x lowest unoccupied molecular orbital ( L U M O ) . As a result: (i) CO 50 HOMO forms a bonding orbital, which, according to the simple chemical bond model, should cause an increase of the 5u binding energy (BE);
(ii) the mixing of the unoccupied CO 27~levels with the metal dp electrons will form a bonding configuration with a large amount of d, character. The degree of backdonation depends on the availability of suitably oriented metal orbitals and is supposed to be the major contribution to the bonding on transition metal surfaces [2]. The most recent theoretical approaches [3, 41 have shown that electrons from the other orbitals (e.g. s p ) can be backdonated to a lesser extent or hybridization with resonant unoccupied metal states also might contribute to the bonding. Since the 5u HOMO is essentially nonbonding and the 2~ LUMO is strongly antibonding, the formation of the chemisorption bond results in weakening of the C-0 bond , an increase of the C-0 bond length and a reduction of the C-0 stretching frequency below the free molecule value. A schematic
69
70
Chapter 5.
of the CO molecular orbital perturbations during the formation of the metal - CO chemisorption bond is shown in fig.5.1.
2
co
co 2lT*
ZlT-,
gas phase
co on Metal (no interaction)
Strongly Chemisorbed co on Transition Metal
Fig. 5.1. Schematics of the CO molecular orbitals energy perturbations as a result of the CO interaction with a metal surface Adsorption of CO on transition metal surfaces has turned out to proceed via a precursor channel which ensures a non activated pathway to chemisorption [5]. The values of the reported CO adsorption binding energies for the molecular CO state on the Group VIII transition metals within the limits of low CO coverages (initial heats of adsorption, AH'(C0)) are ranging from 140 to 190 kJ/mole. On metals from Groups VIB and VIIB one should discriminate between molecular and dissociated CO coexisting on the surface, the molecular adsorption energies being within the same range [6, 71. Metals from Group IB exhibit a completely different behaviour, showing a rather weakly bound molecular CO state with adsorption energies of the order of 30-70 kJ/mole. Except for weakly-bound CO on Ag and Au, the CO overlayers form ordered structures on all other single crystal metal surfaces under consideration [5, 71. The orientation of the chemisorbed CO molecule with respect to the substrate surface is determined exclusively by the CO coverage. On most of the single crystal surfaces (up to moderate coverages), the CO molecule is bonded via the C atom with a C-0 axis normal to the surface. Existence of off-normal bonded CO molecules has been reported for compressed CO overlayers (tilt angles 6'-12') and stepped surfaces (tilt angles 18') [5]. Nonnormal bonding configurations (strongly inclined or 'lying down') with an involvement of l ? r and 4u molecular orbitals of CO are observed for some transition metal surfaces (Fe(100) [8], C r ( l l 0 ) [9] and Mo(ll0)) [ l o , 111 at N
5.1. Carbon Monoxide
71
low CO coverages. This abnormally bound state is assumed to be a precursor for CO dissociation. T h e dissociation propensity of CO molecules varies on the different single crystal metal surfaces. Fig. 5.2. illustrates the energetic situation for CO and its constituents - 0 and C on some transition metal surfaces. The energy level of molecular CO is determined on the basis of the measured initial heats of adsorption, AH’. T h e energy level of dissociated CO, Ec,o, is estimated using the relationship:
Ec,o = EM-c+ MM-o - Dco,
(1)
where EM-C and EM-^ are the metal-carbon and the metal oxygen binding energies on the metal surface and DCO is the dissociation energy of CO molecule in gas phase (256 kcal/mole).
250I
-W0
,
DCO
\ E
3 1500
-rc
d
-
F W
W
-
50 -
.0
c
Pd ( 1 1 1 ) P t (Ill) Rucoooi)
Ni ciio Feccio)
w (110)
C
al
c
0
a
50-
c+o
Fig. 5.2. Potential energy diagram for CO adsorbed on P d ( l l l ) , P t ( l l l ) , Ru(0001), Ni(lll), Fe(ll0) and W(110), presenting the molecular and dissociat,ed CO states and the activation energy, of dissociation, EI
The activation energy of dissociation of chemisorbed CO molecule, E:, is estimated using the relationship derived in ref. [12]:
where the AH’S are the heats of atomic chemisorpt,ion of the corresponding dissociation products.
72
Chapter 5.
Fig.5.2. illustrates quite well that the dissociation propensity of the chemisorbed CO cannot be simply relat.ed to the M-CO adsorption bond strength. Obviously, it depends on the affinity of the substrate to the atomic constituents C and 0. It can be expected that changes in the properties of the surface by introduction of modifiers will affect the surface behaviour with respect t o CO dissociation by influencing the energy position both of the molecule and the products of dissociation.
5.1.2
Modifier Effect on the CO Adsorption Energy and on the Surface Adsorptive Capacity
Information concerning the effect of different electronegative modifiers on the CO adsorption energy and on the capacity of the surface for CO adsorption has been obtained mainly by means of the T P D method. This technique is adequate for metal surfaces modified by C1, S, Se, C, N , P, etc., where the desorption of reagents, such as CO, NO, Hz and hydrocarbons takes place at much lower temperatures than that at which the adsorbed modifier can be removed. As will be illustrated below, the introduction of a modifier induces changes both in the location of the T P D maxima and in t.he shape of the T P D spectra, which reflect the different aspects of the modifier effect.
Fig. 5.3. Effect of different amounts of C1 and S on the CO TPD spectra from Ni(lO0) for saturation CO coverages at 100 I< (from ref. (131) Figs. 5.3 and 5.4. show the effect of increasing amounts of various additives on the CO T D spectra from Ni(100) [13, 141. All these modifiers, as outlined in subsection 4.2., occupy the highest coordinated sites tending t o form ordered structures. The results in figs. 5.3 and 5.4. indicate that the presence of a modifier causes a substantial reduction in the occupation of
73
5.1. Carbon Monoxide
the most tightly bound ,&-GO state with increasing modifier coverage. The lower temperature desorption peaks are depopulated less rapidly, which is accompanied by the appearance of new weakly-bound states, associated with desorption from modifier-induced surface states. It should be pointed out that up to certain modifier coverages the highest temperature &state (resulting of desorption from non affected surface states) is not completely removed. It remains preferentially occupied in cases of low CO coverages, followed by a sequential occupation of the less st
024
L 1 0 200 300 400 500 600 IEMPEAAlURE
(I()
TEMPERATURE (I’
Fig. 5.4. Effect of different amounts of C and N on the CO T P D spectra from Ni(lO0) for saturation CO coverages at 100 K (from ref. [14])
A very similar effect of the electronegative additives as that illustrated in figs. 5.3 and 5.4. has been reported for CO adsorption on other modified fcc(100) and fcc(ll0) surfaces, e.g. S/Ni(100) [15, 161, S/Ni(110) 1171, S/Pd(100) [Is-201, S/Pt(llO) [21], N/Rh( 100) [ 2 2 ] ,C/Ni( 110) [23], C/Ni( 100) & (110) [24], etc. Fig. 5.5. shows the CO TPD spectra from Ni(100) modified with different amounts of P (an additive which does not tend to form ordered surface structures). Obviously, the lack of ordering of the modifier and the tendency of P to form amorphous islands (see Subsection 4.2.) lead to a weaker effect on both the CO bonding strength and the CO coverage. When assessing the relative strength of the modifier effect induced by different electronegative additives, two factors may be considered: (i) the critical modifier coverage at which the most strongly-bonded CO adsorption state (associated with CO adsorption on a nonaffected site) is completely eliminated;
Chapter 5.
74
100
200
300
400 500 600 TEMPERATURE IKI
Fig. 5.5. Effect of different amounts of P adsorbed on Ni(100) on the CO TPD spectra for saturated CO coverages at 100 I< (from ref. [13])
(ii) the modifier induced reduction of the adsorptive capacity of the surface (saturation CO coverage at the given adsorption temperature).
Fig. 5.6. presents the induced changes in the relative population of the most-strongly bonded CO molecular /??-state and in the total CO saturation coverage a t 120 K as a function of the coverage of different modifiers, such as C1, S, N , C, and P on Ni(100). The data in fig. 5.6. demonstrate that the rapid initial decay of the total CO coverage is mainly due to the fast reduction of the &states. This eliminated completely for modifier coverages of 0.25 or less in cases when the additive adatoms form ordered p(2 x 2) structures (Cl, S, N, C). It is obvious that the strongest effect is observed in the presence of C1, when the complete &CO statmeelimination is observed at C1 coverages of 0.15. In the case of P, which does not form ordered overlayers, the modification effect is weaker and the elimination of &CO occurs at P coverages exceeding O.G. The same trend in the strength of the modification effect is preserved also for the total CO coverage. There the maximum CO coverage has turned out to drop from 0.62 for a clean Ni(100) surface to 0.15, 0.18, 0.25 and 0.45 for ordered p(2 x 2 ) overlayers of C1, S , N
-
-
5.1. Carbon Monoxide
75
and C, respectively, and to 0.55 for the disordered P overlayer. For the most severe 'poisons', such as C1 and S, the surface can be considered as completely deactivated at modifier coverages approaching 0.5 when the formation of the c(2 x 2) structure is fully completed.
U,
ec''d
00
1
0
01
02 03 04 05 06 A D D I l I V t C O V t R A G t IMLI
2
01
Fig. 5.6. Dependence of the occupation of the Pz-CO state and the total CO uptake on the additive coverage. (from ref. [13])
A very similar effect is exhibited by electronegative additives on the adsorptive capacity and the relative population of the various molecular adsorption CO states on modified fcc(ll1) and hpc(0001) surfaces. Typical examples are the data reported for CO adsorption on S / P t ( l l l ) [25-271, S/Ni(111) [28, 291, C/Ni(111) [24, 301, O / N i ( l l l ) [31], C/Rh(111) [32], S/Ru(OOOl) [33], etc. An illustration of the S-induced changes in the CO T P D spectra from fcc(ll1) and hpc(0001) metal surfaces is given in fig. 5.7., where with increasing S coverage on P t ( l l l ) , the following effects are observed : (i) the CO peak maximum at low CO coverages shifts from 440 K for a clean surface to lower temperatures (down to 360 K for p(2 x 2) 0.25 S / P t ( l l l ) ) , accompanied by an increase of its half width for the same CO coverages;
Chapter 5 .
76
-
(ii) the maximum CO coverage is reduced from 0.66 for a clean surface to 0.24 at 0.25 S / P t ( l l l ) and drops to 0 at ( Ax A ) R 3 0 ° 0.33 S/Pt( 111).
250
ilo
350
400
4.k
so0
TEMPERATURE (K)
Fig. 5.7. CO T P D spectra for clean and sulfided P t ( l l 1 ) at To= 90 K (from ref.
PI) Approximations based on the initial reduction in population of the most strongly bound CO-state induced by the introduction of increasing amounts of a modifier have shown that, for additives forming ordered overlayers, one modifier adatom affects 3 CO adsorption states on fcc( 111) and hpc( 0001) surfaces and 4 states on fcc(100) and (110) surfaces. Part of the possible adsorption sites is eliminated whereas another part is converted into new modified adsorption sites where the CO molecule is less strongly bound. It should be noted that at low additive coverages, modified and unmodified adsorption sites coexist. The critical coverages, at which the latter are eliminated, are determined by the effective radii of the modifier influence and by the stability of the initial additive adlayer order in the presence of the reagent. Both factors will be considered in detail in the forthcoming subsections. The influence of the modifier on the adsorption energy of the CO molecular form is very well reflected in the T P D spectra, shown in figs. 5.4, 5.5 and
-
-
5.1. Carbon Monoxide
77
5.7. The elimination of the most favourable adsorption sites, associated with the clean surface is accompanied by the removal of the highest temperature adsorption peak. The clearest picture of the effect of the modifier on t,he strength of the CO adsorption bond in the affected adsorption sites can be obtained by comparing the initial heats of CO adsorption for additive free substrate surfaces and for surfaces covered with an ordered modifier overlayer at which all clean surface sites have been eliminated.
p(2x2) S-Pt(111)
( f i ~ a ) R 3 0 S-Pt(111)
S adatom in three-told hollow site
0 nearest Pt alom blocked for CO adsorption 0 next nearest Pt atom with modified properties with respecl to CO adsorption 1 reduced CO sticking coefiicient 2 reduced P1-CO btnding energy 3 increased ESD efficiency 4 stiffened CO bending vibrations
Fig. 5.8. Structural models of S - modified Pt(ll1) by S coverages 0.25 and 0.33.
Table. 5.1. presents some selected data obtained for the desorption energies, E d , and the pre-exponential factors of desorption, v, of GO adsorbed on several clean and modified substrate surfaces. Some of the data in Table 5.1. are obtained without taking into account the possible variations of the pre-exponential factors in the presence of a modifier (e.g. for Ni(100)). This assumption is not accurate, because the changes in the adsorption bond strength and the presence of coadsorbat,es always affect the degree of localization of the adsorption stmate,which determines the pre-exponential factor. That is why, in most recent studies, both parameters were evaluat,ed. As is evident from the data summarized in table 5.1., there is a compensation effect of a concurrent decrease of both parameters. An accurate investigation on the relative contribution of Ed and v reduction has shown that Ed has a greater effect because the rate of CO desorption increases in the presence of a modifier [33]. Within the framework of the transition state theory [34], the
78
Chapter 5.
Fig. 5.9. A scheme of the possible CO adsorptioii sites for Ni(100) modified with p(2 x 2 ) 0.25 S and c(2 x 2 ) 0.5 S overlayers
compensatiiig effect can be quantified as a natural relatioilship between the activation energies and the initial and the transition state entropies. Summarizing the results in Table 5.1., the general conclusion is that the surface - CO binding energy in the adsorption sites affected by the electronegative adatoms is always reduced. The absolute value of this reduction, which reflects the strength of the modifier influence on the particular adsorption site, varies in different adsorption systems. Let the CO initial heats of adsorption be compared for modified and nonmodified fcc( 111) and fcc( 100) surface, e.g. p(2 x 2) 0.25 S - P t ( l l 1 ) with clean P t ( l l 1 ) and p(2 x 2) 0.25 S - Ni(100) with clean Ni(100). The C O / P t ( l l l ) systems are very appropriate for this comparison, because within the limits of low CO coverages, CO occupies ‘on top’ sites on both ( P t ( l l 1 ) and S - P t ( l l 1 ) ) surfaces. The Pt-CO binding energy for CO residing on the nest-nearest neighbour P t atom of 0.25 S-Pt(ll1) (the only possible adsorption site on this surface as shown in fig. 5.8.) is reduced by 48 kJ/mol compared with that of CO on S-free P t ( l l 1 ) . Almost the same reduction in the binding energy is observed when the CO coverage on clean P t ( l l 1 ) is increased to 0.4 (see the T P D spectra in fig. 5.7.). Consequently, the S effect on the CO adsorption energy for S-CO separation 3.12 A is of the same order of magnitude as that experienced by CO in the denser CO overlayers on S-free P t ( l l 1 ) where the closest CO-CO
-
79
5.1. Carbon Monoxide
-
distances are 3.8 k. The picture is more complicated in the case of modified fcc(100) surfaces where several distinct S affected sit,es are observed at p(2 x 2) 0.25 S. On Ni(100) the three S affected CO states a.re separated from S at 3.53 A, 2.8 k and 2.5 A, respectively (fig. 5.9.) when the CO binding energy decreases with decreasing separation between the coadsorhates (from 110 down t o 30 kJ/mole). However, the Ed results summarized in Table 5.1., do not show a simple correlation between the modifier electronegativity and the magnit.ude of CO adsorption energy reduction. As will he discussed in the next subsection, this is due t o the fact that, the type of CO a.dsorpt,ion sites on modified surfa.ces depends on the adsorption t>emperatureand the tendency towards reconstruction. The complete deactivation of the fcc(ll1) metal surface with respect to CO adsorption at S coverages of 0.33 (when the (fi x &)R30° S structure is formed) indicates that the surfa,ce sites (on top, bridge and threefold) involving nearest neighbour Pt atoms a.re unfavourable for CO adsorption and can be regarded as S blocked ones. The critical concent~ra~tion of the modifiers causing complete blockage of t.he surface is larger for the fcc( 100) planes. This is due to the fact that the substrat,e surfwe struct,ure det,erniines the ordering of the modifier and the effective distances between the coadsorbates on the surface. According to the da ta summarized in Table 5.1., a wea,kly-bound CO state can be detected even on c(2 x 2) 0.5 S-Ni(100) where t.he maximum SCO distance is 2.5 k (compared wit,li 2.8 k for CO in a. three-fold site on 0.33 S-Pt(ll1)). This iiidica,tes that, apa.rt from the modifier - reagent separation, the modifier surface configuration also plays an important role in the determination of the actual extent of the blocking effect. Thus far systems have been considered in which the coadsorption of CO does not disturb the initia.1 order of the additive overlayer, i.e 110 rearrangement in the modifier overhyer takes place upon int,roduction of CO. A substantial difference in the T P D specha (which reflects the energetic statmeof CO and the capacity of tlie surface) is observed i n some ca.ses when the coadsorption of CO can induce a reconstruction of the modifier overlayer. The CO T P D spectra from p(2 x 2 ) Se-Pt(ll1) i n fig. 5.10. show some peculiar changes in the shape of the CO T P D spectra with increming the CO coverage [35]. These T P D changes are usually associa,ted with a t.ransition from first order to fractiona.1 or quasi-zero order desorption kinetics [36, 371. It should be not,ed that, because of this effect, which indica.tes significant changes in the mechanism of CO desorption from selenided-Pt(ll1) at OCO > 0.06, the corresponding Ed and Vd data in Ta.ble 5.1. a,re calculated for OCO < 0.05, and Oco 0.2. As can be seen in fig. 5.10., at OCO 0.2 the CO desorption is described by a second lower temperature desorpt,ion pea.k which follows first order desorption kinetics. This pea.k a.ppea.rsonly at, adsorption beniperatures below 130 K. At higher adsorption t,enipera.t,ures,tlie CO coverage is saturated at 0.16 and the T P D features resemble a zero order desorption process. When comparing the kinetic data for a p(2 x 2) 0.25 S-Pt(ll1) surface, it can be seen tha,t the ca.pa.cityof p(2 x 2) 0.25 Se-Pt(ll1) for CO adsorpt,ion
-
-
-
80
Chapter 5.
Table 5.1. CO Desorpt,ion Energies, E d , and Pre-exponential Factors, n, for Some Transition Metals Modified by Electronegative Additives SURFACE
MODIFIER
E:
E,'
(kJ/mole)
u:
4
(sec-' )
clean 140 98 1015 P(2 x 2 ) s 110, 90 1013 1012 c(2 x 2 ) s 30 P(2 x 2)O 120 40 1013 [221 p(2 x 2)N -90 93 1013 (2 x 2)p4gC ~241 P d ( 100) clean 160 lox5 I301 p(2 x 2)s 86, GO Ni(111) clean 140 1O l 5 p(2 x 2)s 91 1381 p ( 2 x 2)O 105 10l2 1311 Pt(111) clean 154 96 10l5 1o3 106 82 1013 10" [261 p(2 x 2 ) s 110 82 1013 io1O p(2 x 2)Se [351 Ru(0001) clean 170 1Ol6 MI p(2 x 2 ) s 105 5.1010 E d and V d are the adsorption parameters at very low co coverages (the desorption energy is equal to the initial heat. of adsorption because CO adsorption is a non activated process). E,' and v,’ are the desorption parameters for the corresponding saturation CO coverages for clean and modified surfaces. Ni(100) ~411
-
-
is smaller (- 0.16 compared to 0.25 a t T, > 130'). As will be shown below, this reduced capacity is a result of the CO induced changes in t,he initial Se surface order. Reconstruction effects on the capacity ofsome p(2x 2) X-Ni( 100) surfaces have been reported in ref. [44].
5.1.3
Modifier Effect on the CO Adsorption Kinetics
The influence of the additives on the CO a.dsorption kinetics has usuaJly been characterized by: (i) the changes in the initial sticking coefficient, So,
(ii) the dependence of the sticking coefficient on the adsorption temperature, S(T),
(iii) the variations of the sticking coefficient with CO coverage, S(0).
5.1. Carbon Monoxide
81
es = 0 2 5
%o .22 .20 16
.06
!-
250
300
4-
:
350
400
450
5 0
Fig. 5.10. CO T P D spectrafrom clean P t ( l l 1 ) and Pt(1ll) modified with p ( 2 x 2 ) S - and p(2 x 2) Se overlayers. T, = 220 I<. Dashed TPD spectra in the upper panel are for T, = 90 I< (from ref. [35])
For evaluation of SO, S ( T ) and S(B) usually the CO coverage versus CO exposure plots are used. As a measure of the CO coverage one can also use the appropriate XPS (intensity of the 01s or C l s peaks), AES data (the intensity of the C(KLL) or O(KLL) Auger transitions), etc. Typical CO uptake curves for clean and modified surfaces, where no reordering is induced in the mixed overlayer, are shown in fig. 5.11. A similar effect of the electronegative overlayers on the CO adsorption curves is observed for the other modified single crystal surfaces [15, 16, 28, 311. At low adsorption temperatures (80-120 K.),for all systems under consideration a visible effect of tlie additives on tlie CO initial adsorption rate ( S o ) is observed a t modifier coverages close to or above that corresponding to a p(2 x 2) 0.25 X overlayer [15, 16, 211. The modifier coverages at which SO becomes zero depend 011 the adsorption temperature and the type and surface order of the additive adatoms. At, T, < 100 I<, SObecomes zero when
Chapter 5.
82
0.8
T, = 9 0 K
CI
J
2 0.6 w
99
0.4
0
u
0
0.2 0.0
0.0
3.0
6.0 9.0 12.0 CO EXPOSURE (mborsec x 106,
15.0
Fig. 5.11. CO coverage vs CO exposure for clean and siilfided P t ( l l 1 ) with different S coverages (from ref. [ 2 6 ] )
the formation of a (& x 4)R30 0.33 S overlayer is completed on fcc(ll1) and hpc(0001) surfaces , whereas on the sulfided fcc(lOO), hcc(100), fcc(ll0) surfaces, SO does not become zero even in the presence of a c(2 x 2) 0.5 S overlayer. The lower adsorption temperature ensures an increase in lifetime of the weakly-bound CO states. That is why the reduction of the adsorption rate is less severe than that observed at higher adsorption temperatures. It is worth pointing out that for clean transition metal surfaces, S " ( C 0 ) is close to unity and remains independent of the adsorption temperatures up to 400 I<, while for modified surfaces, So(C0) is a stronger function of the adsorption temperature. Since the introduction of a modifier affects wit*lia different strength the population of the CO surface states, it is important to find out how the local sticking coefficient of the different GO adsorption states changes with increasing modifier coverage. In real catalysis, the reaction temperatures are always above 300 K. That is why, it is of great interest to explain the variations of So of the most tightly-bound CO states as a function of the additive coverage. An illustration of SOvariations as a function of the additive coverage for CO adsorption at 300 I< is given in fig. 5.12. It is obvious that SOsuffers a pronounced, almost linear reduction with increasing additive coverage, which is most severe in the case of a chlorided surface. The influence of electronegative adatoins on the initial rate of molecular adsorption of reagents, such as CO and NO can be satisfactorily explained within the framework of the precursor state model for nonactivated adsorption
-
5.1. Carbon Monoxide
83
’0
ADDITIVE COVERAGE (ML)
Fig. 5.12. Initial sticking coefficient, So, of the &CO state as a function of the additive coverage, The dashed line represents the theoretical dependence according to the relationship S," = St(1 - 4Bx) (from ref. [?a])
[6, 391 where the sticking coefficient can be described by the relationship S=
Q(t, 0) 1 -k (vd/va) exP[-(Ed - E a ) / h T ]
'
Here, vd and va are the pre-exponentials for chemisorption and desorption from the precursor state, Q is the trapping probability, which is coverage and temperature dependent, and Ea and E d are the activation energies for chemisorption and desorptioii from the precursor state. As pointed out in ref. [5, 71, for CO adsorption on most of the transition metal surfaces under consideration ndexp(-Ed/RT) << v,exp(-E,/RT) and SOZ Q is close to unity. The reason for the reduction of So with the intaroduction of an electronegative additive can be understood if one considers the modifier surface order illustrated in figs. 5.8. and 5.9. and the possible adsorption sites for CO on these surfaces. Within the framework of the description given by eq. ( 3 ) the reduction of So can be ascribed t o a decrease in lifetime of the CO precursor on the modifier affected adsorption sites, wliich results in an increase of the second term in eq. (3), i.e the desorption rate of the precursor cannot be neglected for the modified surface sites. One reason for the reduced lifetime of the precursor can be its reduced migration mobility due to the changes of the potential energy surface for CO diffusion in the presence of the modifier adatoms. The absence of an effect on So at low adsorption temperatures (90-100 K) for S coverages much less than 0.25 on most of the substrates under con-
Chapter 5.
84
sideration [15, 16, 26, 311 can be satisfactorily explained by an non-uniform distribution of the modifiers because of the tendency of most of the electronegative adatoms to form ordered islands even at very low coverages (see subsection 4.2.1.). Thus, up to some critical additive coverages a presence of modifier-free islands is possible where the adsorptive properties of the clean surface are preserved.
I
0.3 h
J
I Pt(ll1) I I
%(S)
= 0.Z5
S/Pt(lll)
Fig. 5.13. CO coverage versus CO exposure on the sulfided and selenided P t ( l l 1 ) surface at T, = 90 and 220 K (from ref. [35])
For all modified surfaces, where the introduction of reagents does not disturb substantially the initial order of the modifier, the dependence of CO sticking coefficient on the CO coverage resembles that for the adsorption on a clean surface, despite the reduced So value. This S(0) behaviour is illustrated in fig. 5.13. for CO adsorption on p(2 x 2) S-Pt(ll1) and p(2 x 2) SePt(ll1) at 90 K . The initial constancy of the S(B) plots followed by a gradual decrease above certain CO coverages, reflects a precursor mediated process where the molecules occupy identical adsorption sites. A more complicated behaviour with respect to the CO adsorption kinetics is observed in the cases when the coadsorption of CO results in a substantial reordering of the modifier overlayer. The effect of the structural changes in the mixed overlayers on the CO adsorption kinetics is illustrated by the S ( 0 ) plot in fig. 5.14. obtained at an adsorption temperature of 220 K for selenided P t ( l l 1 ) . As indicated in this figure, the stepwise reduction of S at 0 ~ > 0 0.04 is accompanied by structural changes in the overlayer where the new surface order offers less favorable adsorption sites (see fig. 5.19.). Finally, one exception should be mentioned, when a typical electronegative adatom does not cause a reduction of the initial adsorption rate of CO. This
85
5.1. Carbon Monoxide
is the system p(2 x 2) 0.25 O / P t ( l l l ) , where CO preserves the same So as on a clean surface. As discussed in det,ail in ref. [40], the main reason for that is the great affinity of CO and 0 coadsorbed on P t ( l l 1 ) for COa formation. But on other substrates (e.g. Ni(ll1) [31]), 0 behaves as a typical 'poison' with respect t o CO bonding strength, adsorption rate and adsorptive capacity of the surface.
0 .6
0.5
90 K
ie---o,---o
A
\
1 ’
Q s e ( ~=) 0.25 0
\
i 1
A
0,
Fig. 5.14. CO sticking coefficient, vs. CO coverage on sulfided and selenided Pt(ll1) at T, = 90 and 220 I< (from ref. [35])
5.1.4 Modifier Effect on the CO Adsorption Site Occupation Vibrational spectroscopy data (HREELS and IRAS) as well as some selected ESDIAD data have shown that the presence of electronegative coadsorbates, occupying the highest coordinated sites, always causes changes in the nature of the molecular adsorption sites of the reagents. Comparison between the observed molecular stretching frequencies Me-C and C-0 and the GO TPD spectra gives a good basis for correlating the binding sites with the corresponding adsorption binding energies. Since CO adsorption on various bare metal surfaces exhibits a different sequence of the site occupation, it is impossible to generalize the observed effects induced by the modifier on the CO site occupat,ion. For example, fig. 5.15. shows that, as a result of increasing S coverages on S/Ni(100) [41], the original CO vibrational modes, associated with 'on-top' bonding (at Bco < 0.5) are replaced by: (i) three new modes ascribed to twofold (3 = 1910-1960 cm-l) or fourfold (hl = 1740 cm-') S affected sites in the next nearest position for the p(2 x 2) S-Ni( 100) surface and (ii) one mode ascribed
86
Chapter 5.
t o a fourfold (hz = 2115 cm-l) S affected site for the c(2 x 2) S-Ni(100) surface (see the structural model in fig. 5.9., where b, hl and h2 sites are indicated). The corresponding CO adsorption binding energies are shown in Table 5.1.(110, 90 and 30 kJ/mole, respect,ively).
Fig. 5.15. A set of TPD and HREELS spectra, illustrating the effect of preadsorbed S on CO adsorption states on Ni(100) for an adsorpt,ion temperahre of 90 I< (from ref. [41])
In the case of S/Pd( 100) [19] where on a clean surface CO occupies twofold (bridge) sites, the presence of S up to moderate sulphur coverages does not affect substantially the CO stretching modes, although the T P D spectra show a strong reduction in the population of the highest temperature state. This is not surprising because, as outlined above, the S-affect,ed b state has same bridge coordination (fig. 5.9.). Similar t,o the case of S/Ni(100,) a peak at 2110 cm-I can be distinguished 011 c ( 2 x 2) S/Pd(100) also [19]. The latter is associated with a h2 adsorption site. A very similar behaviour of the CO site occupation w a s observed for C/Pd (100) [19]. The coordination of the modifier-affected CO adsorption sites is different in the case of substrate surfaces with fcc( 111)-like crystallographic symmetry. Detailed studies of CO adsorption on S / N i ( l l l ) [as],O / N i ( l l l ) [31], S and S e / P t ( l l l ) [26, 35, 42 ] have shown that the CO* modifier-affected sites are more likely to be ‘on-top’ sites on the next nearest substrate atom. Thus, the IR studies [28, 311 have shown that the S induced CO adsorption state is characterized by a stretching frequency 2100 cm-’ and its relative concentration grows a t the expense of the original bridge and on top adsorption
-
5.1. Carboil hlonoxide
87
sites (fig. 5.8.). The difference between O / N i ( l l l ) and S/Ni(111) is that the S induced CO* band frequency at 2108 cm-l is invariant with 0s and 0 ~ 0 , whereas the 0 induced CO" band frequency suffers a strong coupling effect with increasing Bco (fig. 5.16.).
A
I3 : e4
a 0
2200
2100
Wavenumber
zoo0 lcm-')
Fig. 5.16. Effect of oxygen (right) and sulphur (left) precoverages on C-0 ing frequencies for CO adsorbed on modified N i ( l l 1 ) (from refs. [28, 311)
stretch-
Regardless of the assignment of the coordination of the most strongly affected CO adsorption site, comparison with the available vibrational data for the C-0 stretching modes shows the following common features: (i) the most strongly perturbed CO' state (the most weakly bound one) always exhibits the highest vibrational frequency mode (of the order of 2110 cm-') which is closer to that of a free CO molecule; (ii) up to certain critical modifier coverages, the original (clean surface) CO bands coexist with the modifier-induced ones, the frequencies of the former being only weakly perturbed by the presence of the additive ad atoms. 5.1.5
Surface Order in Mixed Overlayers
The effect of the electronegative adatoms on the surface order of the coadsorbed CO molecules is studied exclusively by LEED. On all single crystal surfaces, CO tends to form commensurately and incommensurately ordered structures at moderate and high coverages [ 5 , 431. This tendency is preserved
88
Chapter 5.
only in the presence of negligible amounts of additives (less than 0.05) but even then the CO induced spots are fainter and the background is larger than that for CO on a clean surface [15-19, 26, 281. At higher additive coverages CO adsorption does not give rise to ordered structures, which means that CO adsorbs in a disordered manner. The lack of order can be easily understood since the introduction of foreign adatoms prevents long range ordering of the CO molecule, because of hindered occupation of certain surface sites. At moderate and high modifier coverages, when the additive adatoms have formed ordered structures, the possible adsorption sites for CO are restricted and usually, the initial surface order determined by the modifier, is preserved. For an example, CO adsorption on p(2 x 2) S-fcc(ll1) substrates is possible only in tlie "on top" positions on the next nearest substrate surface atom (see fig. 5.8.), which means that at saturation the CO molecules are in the same p(2 x 2) order as the modifier adatoms. In the case of p(2 x 2) - fcc(100) surfaces, the picture is not very clear because, as pointed out in ref. [44], CO-induced reconstruction is possible in the case of some of the modifiers. Most recent studies of mixed electronegative adatoms - CO systems have shown that the CO coadsorption might disturb tcheorder of the electronegative adatoms and, in some cases, can even result in a rearrangement of the modifier. There is a tendency for GO to exert this effect, above certain CO coverages and adsorption temperatures. As illustrated by tlie LEED data in fig. 5.17., at Oco > 0.05 and T, > 240 K CO induces a certain disorder in the initially well ordered p(2 x 2) S overlayers on P t ( l l 1 ) . This disorder is temperature irreversible and the initial well-ordered p(2 x 2) S layers are restored only after CO desorption. More severe structural changes have been observed upon CO coadsorption on p(2 x 2) Se-Pt(ll1). As shown i n figs. 5.18. and 5. 19., the coadsorption of CO causes a phase transformation and an establishment of a new x 8 ) R 1 9 . l 0 order in the mixed CO + Se overiayer. In this new order CO molecule again is adsorbed on the next-nearest on top Pt site, but the capacity of the surface for CO adsorption is reduced at the expense of the increased CO-Se separation. Detailed studies have shown that this phase transition proceeds easily at 0.lG > Oco > 0.04 and T > 130 K. As will be discussed below, the observed CO induced disturbance in the initial surface order of the electronegative additives is accompanied by a reduction of the constraint imposed by the modifier on the CO frustrat,ed translational modes parallel to the surface. The observed relation between the structure in the mixed overlayer and the energetics of the CO adsorption site for selenided P t ( l l 1 ) indicate that one of the most important factors which determine the strength of the modifier effect, is the separation (effective distance) between the electronegative adatom and the coadsorbed GO molecule, whereas the coordination number of the former is of less importance. As shown above, the fi order with 6 Se atoms coordinated around CO with a CO-Se separation of 4.22 A, turns out to be energetically more favoured than the p(2 x 2) structure with 3 Se adatoms spaced around CO at a distance of 3.19 A. The rapid decay of the modifier - CO repulsive forces with the increasing
8
(a
5.1. Carbon Monoxide
co + SIPt(ll1) LEED AK, CO
-
ESOIAD DATA
e,, .
-
210 K '
89
0.15
T,=240
K
F-.
Fig. 5.17. Top: CO' ESDIAD patterns as CO is adsorbed at 90 I< and after annealing at 270 K or upon CO adsorption at 240 I<. Bottom: LEED pattern changes as C O + S / P t ( l l l ) layer is annealed after CO adsorption at 90 K (left); LEED pattern changes as CO adsorption takes place at 340 I< (right.) (from ref.
WI) coadsorbate effective distance explains satisfactorily the absence of a CO induced phase transition in CO/p(2 x 2) S-Pt(ll1). Because of the difference in the Se and S adatom sizes (covalent radii 1.16 A and 1.04 A, respectively) shorter, i.e. the GO-S rethe CO-S effective distance will be by 0.14 pulsive strain will be weaker. Consequently, even when assuming the same activation energy for the transformat,ion of the p(2 x 2) S and p(2 x 2) Se overlayers, thermodynamically the reconstruction will be less favourable in the case of sulfided Pt(ll1). It is quite obvious that the different geometrical arrangements of the additive adlayers are an important factor in determining the possible number of the modifier induced new adsorption states. A recent IR study of the temperature effects on the GO site occupation on Ni(100) - p(2 x 2) X (X = C1, S, 0, N , C) surfaces has indicated that the break in the correlation adatom electronegativity - strength of the poisoning effect in some systems is due
A
Chapter 5.
90
CO
+ 8.IpHtlll-
WED AND CO* ESDIAD DATA
Fig. 5.18. CO’ ESDAD patterns (left) and the corresponding LEED structures (right) as CO is adsorbed 011 p(2 x 3 ) Se-Pt(ll1) at 220 I< (from ref. [42])
t o the reconstruction of the additive adlayer induced by CO above certain temperatures [44]. Table 5.2. summarizes the temperature changes in the CO site occupation (as judged by the measured C-0 stretch frequencies) observed for Ni( 100) - p(2 x 2)X surfaces. C-0 frequencies above 2000 cm-’ are attributed to ‘on top’ CO (‘t’), whereas those below 2000 cm-’ are associated with bridge bonded (‘b’) CO [5]. In all mixed systems considered in table. 5.2., the increase of temperature causes partial CO desorption. It is obvious that in the case of C1, S and 0 the bridge bonded CO is removed, while in the case of N and C the ‘on top’ CO states are desorbed preferentially. Another important feature is that both the C-0 stretch frequencies and the adsorption energy of CO remaining on the S, 0 and C1 modified surfaces after heating to 300 K, are very similar to the ones measured for clean Ni(100). These results for a strong temperature dependence of the CO site occupation for Ni(100), modified with p(2 x 2) overlayers of S, 0, and CI have been explained by considering the possibility for CO induced p(2 x 2) to c(2 x 2) transformation of the modifier overlayer. As a result, the surface will consist of patches of
-
91
5.1. Carbon Monoxide
POSTULATED Se AND CO ARRANGEMENT I N THE TWO PHASES p(2x2kSe with disordered CO
($7x$7)R19.1°rnixed Se-GO ordered layer
Fig. 5.19. CO and Se arrangement for the p(2 x 2) and
(8 x fi)R19.1°
mixed
overlayers on Pt(ll1) (from ref. [42])
c(2 x 2) adatoms and patches of a clean surface where the CO adsorption sites are least disturbed. This is another example of the possible changes in the structural order of the adlayer when the adatoins and the reagent tend to separate in two phases, instead of forming one mixed surface phase as was the case of CO + Se on P t ( l l 1 ) [42] As outlined in ref. [44], therinodyiiam~callythe CO induced reconstruction of a p(2 x 2) adatom overlayer on Ni(100) will be favoured only in the case when the energy gain for CO moving from the modifier perturbed ‘bridge’ site t o an energetically more favourable ‘on top’ adsorption state is larger than the energy required for the p(2 x 2) to c(2 x 2) transition. Since the estimated energy gain is found to be 40 kJ/mole, the lack of reconstruction in the case of N fits in well with the estimated energy of 80 kJ/mole for the p(2 x 2)N t o c(2 x 2)N transformation (whereas for 0, S and C1 this energy is 40-50 kJ/mole) [44]. Although to date, few studies have been concerned with the temperature and the reordering effects on the C-0 staretchingfrequencies, CO bending vibrations and the overlayer surface order, the available data indicate that the possibility of CO-induced structural transformations cannot be excluded. These are similar to that observed for CO/Ni(100) - p(2 x 2)X [44], CO/Pt(lll) - p(2 x 2) S and C O / P t ( l l l ) - p(2 x 2) Se [35, 421 in the other modified systems under consideration. Such structural changes are more likely to be responsible for the lack of a straightforward correlation be-
-
-
92
Chapter 5.
Table 5.2. C-0 Stretch Frequencies, w , at Different Temperatures for p(2 x 2) Overlayers of Various Modifiers on Ni(100) (data from ref. [44]) ADDITIVE
w (cm-I) at
T = 170 I<
w (cm-I) at
bare Ni(100) p(2 x 2)Cl
1965 (‘b’), 2035 ( 1 ) 1945, 1955 (two ‘b’) and 2036 ( ‘ 2 ’ ) 1946 (‘b’) 1957 (‘b’) 1934 (‘b’) 2046 and 2067 (two 9’) weak 1937 (‘b’) 2081 (‘2’)
2038 (‘1’) 2028 ( ‘ t ’ )
p(2 x 2 ) s p(2 x 2)O p(2 x 2)N p(2 x 2)C
T, > 290 I<
2021 (9’) 2017 ( 1 ) weak at 1940 weak 1937 2060 ( ‘ t ’ ) with a reduced in t,ensity
-
(‘b’) means bridge CO bonding, and ( ‘ t ’ )means terminal CO bonding.
tween the strength of the poisoning effect a.nd the adatom electronegativity which applies in some cases to additives with close atomic sizes.
5.1.6
Modifier Effect on the CO Mobility and Bonding Orientation
Another important characteristic of the modified adsorption site is the effect on the molecule soft ‘bending’ vibrations parallel to the surface. These vibrations are sensitive to the modifier induced changes in the surface potential energy contour and are related to the adsorbate mobility and desorption rate. Information about the relative changes in the amplitudes of tlie translational (‘wagging’) vibrational modes by the introduction of a modifier ( S or Se) has been obtained recently from measuring the widths of the ESDIAD patterns of the excited neutral CO species from sulfided and selenided P t ( l l 1 ) . As described in refs. [45-471, the widths of t,he ESDIAD patterns of the neutral species are determined by the root-niean-square vibrational amplitudes of the Me-C-0 bending modes. The effect of p(2 x 2)S(Se) and x &)R19.l0 Se overlayers on tlie CO frustrated t,ranslational vibrational frequencies are summarized in table 5.3. Comparison of the wt data in table 5.3. and the wt values for a clean surface (48 c1n-l) shows that for both S and Se, the CO vibrational motions are constrained somewhat as compared to the unmodified surface. Considering the data on tlie reduced CO adsorption energies, which implies increased mobility and less hindered translational and rotational degrees of freedom, it is likely that the reason for the observed reverse effect (a hindrance of the CO surface motions) can be only the existence of substantial modifier - CO repulsive interactions. The trend in the changes of w t ( X ) going from p(2 x 2) to (fi x J?)R19.lo surface order shows that the new surface order established as a result of the CO induced phase transitions offers
(J?
5.1. Carbon hlonovide
93
CO adsorption sites with less hindrance to its vibrational freedom. Indeed, an inspection of the structural models for the arrangement of the coadsorx a ) 1 9 . l o orders shows that at the expense bates in the p(2 x 2) and of the reduced adsorption sites for CO (from 0.25 down to 0.16) the Se-CO separation in the J? order increases by 1.03 A (from 3.19 A for p(2 x 2) to 4.22 for the J? order). It should be noted that the order of Se is stabilized only by the presence of CO arranged in the same structural order. The sharp GO desorption peak froin the fi mixed overlayer reflects a drop in the CO desorption energy, because, as a result of the destruction of the J? configuration the less favourable CO p(2 x 2) adsorption configuration is restored.
(8
J?
Table 5.3. CO Frustrated Translation Vibrational Frequencies, wt,on S and Se Modified P t ( l l l ) , as Estimated on the Basis of the CO ESDIAD HWHM, 0,using the simple relationship w t ( 0 ) / w t ( X ) = O2(X)/0’(0),where: 0 ( 0 )= 6.3', w t ( 0 ) = 48 cm-' are the values for Bco
<
0.15 for clean P t ( l l 1 ) (data from refs. [16, 35,
421)
SU B STRATE p ( l x a ) S-Pt(ll1) p(2 x 2) Se-Pt(ll1) ( a x a ) 1 9 . 1 ' Se-Pt(ll1)
O( X ) (degrees) 4.5-5f 0.5 4.4 f 0.5 5.5 f 0.5
wt(X)
(cm-') 100-80 100 60
The ESDIAD results for CO adsorption on sulphided and selenided P t ( l l 1 ) with normally centered ESDIAD narrow patterns indicate that the CO molecule preserves its orientation with the C-0 axis normal to the surface both for the p(2 x 2) and (8x 8 ) R l g . l " surface orders. Certain slight 'offnormal' tilting of the coadsorbed CO, which causes extreme broadening of the ESDIAD patterns, were detected only in disordered CO Se overlayers [35]and at CO coverages larger than 0.25 on a p(2 x 2 ) O / P t ( l l l ) surface [40]. For transition metal surfaces where at low CO coverages the CO bonding orientation is not normal to the surface, the introduction of an electronegative modifier was found to inhibit the population of t,he "lying down'' adsorption state for CO. Such a modifier induced reorientation of molecularly adsorbed CO is observed for C r ( l l 0 ) [48,49] precovered with atomic oxygen. It should be pointed out that the CO state the intramolecular axis of which is nearly parallel to the substrate surface, is the most favourable adsorption state and serves as a precursor for CO dissociation. Thus, by removing this CO adsorption configuration, the electroiiegative adatoms are expect.ed to inhibit the CO dissociation as well.
+
94
5.1.7
Chapter 5. Effect of the Substrate Surface Orientation on the Range and Strength of the Modifier Effect
Summarizing all data concerning the various effects on the CO adsorption on modified surfaces, it is obvious that there is a significant difference in the effective range of the modifier effect for different substrate crystallographic planes. On the basis of available data, the best examples are the differences in the behaviour of the p(2 x 2) S-fcc(100) and fcc(ll1) planes (see figs. 5.8 and 5.9.), where S occupies fourfold hollow and threefold hollow sites, respectively. According to the assignments of the CO adsorption sites on the p(2 x 2) S modified surfaces, for the fcc(100) plane (fig. 5.9.), all S affected CO sites are bridge sites sharing a substrate surface atom with S, whereas for the fcc(ll1) plane all adsorption sites (bridge or on t.op) involving the nearest substrate surface atom are unfavourable for CO adsorption. Here it should be recalled that the separation of the threefold adsorption sites foq ( Ax fi)R30° S-Ni(ll1) from the S adsorption site is by 0.3 A larger than the separation of the four-fold adsorption site for c(2 x 2) S-Ni(100) (figs. 5.8 and 5.9). This result indicates that the strength and the extent of the effect of the same modifier and reagent cannot be simply correlated only with the separation between the adsorption sites because obviously the actual configuration of the modifier adsorption site is also of importance. Taking into account the present state of knowledge about the interaction of electronegative additives with the transition metal surfaces, described in the Section 4.2., the following explanation can be offered regarding the observed difference in the range of the S effect on the fcc(100) and fcc(ll1) planes. The interaction of S with the substrate atom from the second layer below the hollow is stronger for the fourfold S coordination on the fcc( 100) plane than for the threefold S coordination on the fcc(ll1) plane. As will be discussed in more detail in the forthcoming section 5.1.8., the stronger coupling with subsurface metal atoms will reduce the range of the blocking effect along the surface. This explanation fits in well with the data on the weaker poisoning effect in the case of additives such as C (which has the same electronegativity as S) which are deeply embedded in the substrate surface.
-
5.1.8
Modifier Effect on the Electronic Structure of the Adsorbed CO Molecule
Undoubtedly, the reduction of the adsorption energy of the CO molecule adsorbed on adsorption sites influenced by the additive adatoms will be accompanied by changes in the core and valence electron energies of the adsorbed CO. Recent ARUPS data on a CO-S/Ni(lOO) adsorption system [50] have revealed that the major effect of the coadsorbed S lies in the change in the energy position of the CO 517 level which moves by 0.7 eV to a lower binding energy, i.e. closer to its gas phase value. Since in the case of strong CO chemisorption (as outlined in subsection 4.1.1.) the stabilization of the 5s level is regarded as being due to 5u-metral bonding interactions, the S induced destabilization of the 5s levels indicates a reduction of the CO 5o-metal coupling in the S affected adsorption sites. This impeded 5a donation to the
-
5.1. Carbon Monoxide
95
metal can be ascribed to the repulsive interactions occurring bet,ween the CO 5a molecular orbitals and the energetically close 3 p orbitals of S . Another indication of the changes in the degree of coupling of the CO molecular orbitals with the metal in the modified adsorption sites is found in the work function results. Table 5.4. 0 1s and C 1s Core Level Binding Energies for CO Coadsorbed with Electronegative Adatoms SURFACE
Fe( 100)
[521 c ( 2 x 2) C-Fe(100) p(1 x 1) 0-Fe(100) c(2 x 2) S-Fe(100) Ni(100) [531 0.4 S/Ni(100) Rh(100)
P I
c0 (0 1s)
co ( C 1s)
(eV)
(eV)
530.6, 531.4, 532.2 (01) (02)
-
533.9 531.5 533.7 531.3
284.3
(03)
284.8 284.9 285.4 -
-
0.4 N/Rh(100) Mo( 110)
531.6 531.7
385.0
[541 (1 x 1 ) C-Mo(ll0)
533.1
285.5
~
Fig. 5.20. shows the typical changes induced in the work function data by the presence of electronegative ada.toms [31]. Similar work function results concerning CO adsorption on modified surfaces are reported for other systems where CO adsorption on a clean surfa.ce ca.uses positive changes in the work function (e.g. CO-S/Ni(lOO) [ l G ] , CO-O/Ir(llO) [15], etc.). The positive work function cha.nges induced by CO adsorpt,ion 011 a.11 c1ea.n transitmionmetal surfaces under considera.tion (with the exception of P t ) reflect the direction of the net charge transfer as a result, of the met,al/ CO 2 i ~bonding. It is obvious from fig. 5.20., tha.t on modified surfaces the total work function changes induced by the same amount of adsorbed CO tend to decrea,se with increa.sing modifier covera.ge. For very high modifier coverages, when the CO adsorption sites are strongly perturbed, negligible or even negative work function changes can be associated with the occupation of these sites. These work function results reflect the influence of the electronegative a.dditives on the contribution of the nietal/CO 277 backdona.tion to the CO adsorption bond. The smaller dipole moment of the perturbed CO molecules indicates a reduction of the metal/2i~coupling, i.e. weakening of the CO adsorption bond. Consequently, the ARUPS and the work function results indica.te that the
96
Chapter 5.
reduced metal surface - CO coupling in the affected adsorption sites is the result of modifier effects on both the donor and the acceptor component of the metal - CO bonding.
1.5
a
>,
1
2
1.0
al CI, e 0
z 0
._ 0 . 5 c
U E
a
A 0.10
OH@
LL
x
0
L
0.18 0.25
0.2
Co Coverage,
0.4
0.6
ecc0 (CO/Ni 1
Fig. 5.20. CO induced work function changes during adsorption on N i ( l l 1 ) modified with increasing amounts of oxygen (from ref. [31])
The changes in the metal surface - CO coupling also affect the core electron energies of the CO molecule. As can be expected, in the presence of a modifier both C 1s and 0 1s levels move to higher biiiding energies compared t o that measured for CO on a clean surface for the same adsorption site symmetry. Selected data concerning the effect of different modifiers on the 0 1s and C 1s binding energies for molecularly adsorbed CO are given in Table 5.4. This tendency of an increase of the 0 1s and C 1s binding energies of CO adsorbed in the modified sites is consistent with the general trend of reduced final state relaxation effects for adsorbates less strongly coupled with the surface.
5.1.9
Modifier Effect of the C O Dissociative A d s o r p t i o n
Thus far, the influence of the electronegative modifiers on the molecular adsorption state of CO was dealt with. As noted in subsection 5.1.1., the ten-
5.1. Carbon Monoxide
97
dency of the CO molecule to dissociate on clean transition metal surfaces increases going to the left in the corresponding row of the Periodic table. Under ultra high vacuum fractional CO dissociation at T > 300 can be observed on Fe, Mo, Re, W, Cr and Co surfaces [5, 71. The importance of CO dissociation as an intermediate step in the methanation and Fischer - Tropsch syntheses is well recognized [55]. This is due to the fact that the methane formation and the chain growth of higher hydrocarbons on the catalyst surface are preceded by rupture of the C-0 bond.
@,SO.
e. = .o 9.- .l
8.. .2
8. .a 9,. .I
Fig. 5.21. Changes in the CO TPD spectra on sulphur - covered Fe(100) with increasing sulphur coverage. CO exposure = 12 L (from ref. [59])
Recent HREELS and SEXAFS data [49,56-58] have defined the precursor state for CO dissociation as a tilted (flat-lying) molecular state characterized by an extensive occupation of t,he 27r CO molecular orbihls, compared to that for a normally bonded CO molecular adsorption state. As suggested in ref. [56], the energy positions and the intensities of the CO ?r and (I resonances in the SEXAFS spectra indicate an extreme elongation of the C-0 bond (1.47 A) and a lowering of the C-0 bond order of the precursor CO state. Consequently, in the adsorption state which serves as a precursor for CO dissociation, the CO occupied molecular orbitals are strongly rehybridized in comparison with the way CO is conventionally bonded. CO adsorption data
Chapter 5.
98
for systems where a fraction of the adsorbed molecules can dissociate have shown that the precursor state for dissociation is occupied first and the fraction of the dissociated molecules decreases with increasing CO coverage. The number of dissociated molecules is restricted for the lack of sufficient appropriate (highly coordinated) adsorption sites for the dissociation products. It is worth pointing out that even on a unmodified surface, the dissociation by itself introduces the electronegative adatoms C and 0 which can act as poisons if they do not participate in further reaction steps. Consequently, if the dissociation occurs at the adsorption temperature, the surface is gradually deactivated by the increasing amount of C and 0 adatoms with increasing CO exposure. Actually, under the real conditions of the catalytic reaction of CO hydrogenation when C and 0 do not exceed certain critical coverages, they can be removed from the catalyst surface by the reaction steps: (i) zC (ii) 0
+ yH - hydrocarbons(gas);
+ 2H = HzO(gas)
Since the precursor CO molecular state for dissociation is supposed to be more strongly coupled to the substrate, it should be expected that the presence of electronegative additives will significantly affect this state, leading to the inhibition of CO dissociation. The effect of the increasing sulfur coverages on the CO T P D spectra from Fe(100) is illustrated in fig. 5.21. The clean surface CO peaks designated as a1, Q , and a3 are due to desorption from molecular adsorption states, whereas the high temperature one - P-peak is the result of recombination of the dissociation products C and 0. Thorough studies have proved that only the CO as-state is related to CO dissociation. The dissociation is competing with the a3 molecular desorption and occurs at temperatures higher than 450 K [52, 59, 601. The introduction of S affects the desorption spectra from the CO molecular adsorption states in the usual way (as described above), i.e. by removing the original clean surface states and replacing them with new less-strongly bound states. The major S effect is a reduction of the dissociated fraction and complete inhibitsionof dissociation at the p(2 x 2) 0.25 S layer. A close inspection of the T P D spectra shows that the inhibition of dissociation cannot only be associated with the removal of the a3 ‘precursor’ state. This state with reduced population still exists at 0s = 0.25 but cannot undergo dissociation because S has blocked most of the fourfold sites which are the adsorption sites favoured by the dissociation products C and 0. At low Os, the presence of S also hinders, to a certain extent, the recombination of the dissociation products reflected by the increasing temperature of the /3 peak. The same effects consisting of the removal of the most strongly bound CO molecular states and reduction of the fraction of dissociated CO have been observed during CO interaction with sulfur predosed Re(0001) and Re(1010) surfaces [63]. Fig. 5.22. illustrates how, with increasing S coverage, the capacity of the surface for CO adsorption and the fraction of dissociated GO are reduced. The inhibition effects on CO dissociation of the other electronegative adatoms are quantitatively the same. An illustration of the differences in
5.1. Carbon Monoxide
99
Fig. 5.22. Total amount of adsorbed and the dissociated fraction (as evaluated from the total CO TPD area and the area under the p recombination peak) as a function of sulfur coverage on Re(1010) (from ref. [63])
strength of the effects of different modifiers are the CO TPD spectra show11 in fig. 5.23. [52]. It is obvious that the effect on the energetics and populat,ion of the molecular adsorption states, and on the dissociation propensity of GO becomes less deleterious in the sequence S, 0, C. The modifier induced reduction of the adsorption rate on the S, 0, and C modified Fe( 100) surfaces also decreases in the same direction. The effects of the three electronegative additives on the molecular adsorption bond, the dissociation propensity and the CO sticking coefficient are summarized in table 6.5. It should be noted that in the case of a carbided surface, the fact that the fraction of dissociated CO is small, might be due to the tendency to diffusion of carbon into the bulk at elevated temperatures and this would liberate some C-free areas. The same trend in the strengths of the C and 0 effects on CO dissociation is observed with modified Mo(100) [Gl]. It has been found that, with increasing carbon coverage, the dissociated fraction linearly decreases from 504% for one monolayer of C (Il40( 100)-(1 x 1)C). This observation iudicat.es that the suppression of CO dissociation is due esclusively to blocking of the available fourfold sites. In the presence of oxygen there is complete inhibition of the CO dissociative adsorpt,ion at half a monolayer of oxygen, accompanied by a considerable reduction in the desorption energy of the CO molecular state. Obviously, because of its higher electronegativity, oxygen behaves like a more severe poison than carbon. The oxygen-induced inhibition of CO dissociation cannot be related to blocking of the available fourfold adsorption sites
Chapter 5.
100
l
a
200
400 TEMPERATURE
80 0
600 (K)
Fig. 5.23. Effect of carbon, oxygen and sulfur adlayers on CO desorption from Fe(100): (a) clean surface, 10 L exposure; (b) c(2 x2)C, 10 L exposure; (c) p(1 x 1 ) 0 , 100 L exposure; (d) c(2 x 2)S, 1000 L exposure (from ref. [52])
alone. The main reason for the observed pronounced destabilization of the CO molecular state on a p( 1 x 1) O-Mo( 100) surface is supposed to be the substantially reduced backdonation response of the surface in the presence of oxygen. This enhances the efficiency of oxygen as an inhibitor to the CO dissociation process which surpasses the efficiency expected when considering only the effect of blocking of the fourfold sites. Since the additives C and 0 are also dissociation products, their simultaneous presence a t the surface is unavoidable at the catalytic reaction temperatures. Studies of the effect of increasing equal carbon and oxygen coverages on
Effect of Electronegative Modifiers on the Average CO Adsorption Binding Energies, E d , the CO Adsorption Rate, SO,and t,he Dissociated Fraction of CO, &,o, on Fe(100) for T, = 150 I< ( d a t a from ref. [52])
Table 5.5.
SURFACE Fe(100) c(2 x 2) C-Fe(100) (1 x 1) 0-Fe( 100) c(2 x 2) S-Fe(100)
Ed (kJ/mole)
so
95 75 75 45
0.2 lo-?
1 10-4
AC,O(%)
-- 525 0 0
101
5.1. Carbon Monoxide
Fe (100) [G2] and M o ( l l 0 ) [54] on the molecular and dissociative adsorption of CO have shown the following peculiarities:
+
(i) the same total amount of equal concentrations of C 0 on the metal surface causes a weaker reduction in the CO adsorption bond strength than the same amount of C (the measured initial heats of CO adsorption on c(2 x 2) 0.5 C-Fe(100) equals 77 kJ/mol, while 95 k.J/mol corresponds to (0.250 0.25C)-Fe( 100) [G2]);
+
(ii) the effect on the dissociation rate is average between that of a surfacemodified one with the same amount of C or 0 adatoms alone. The weaker effect of the mixed C + 0 overlayers than that of C alone is attributed to the possible immobilization of the effect if C and 0 are bound in close proximity on the surface. As regards the CO dissociation rate, it has turned out that the additive effects on the kinetic parameters ( activation energy of dissociation and frequency factor) tend to compensate each other, and the net effect on the dissociation rate is relatively small [54]. Consequently, the major reason for the inhibition of CO dissociation is more likely the enhanced probability of desorption of the molecular CO state, rather than the inhibition of the dissociation rat8e. 5.1.10
Influence of the Chemical State of the Modifier on the Strength of Poisoning
In this subsection the dependence of the modified properties of transition metal surfaces on the chemical state of the modifier will be considered. As outlined in chapter 4.2., one of the factors determining how strong the poisoning is, is the actual chemical state of the electronegative additive 011 the surface. A good example of the relat,ion between the chemical state of the modifier and its effect on the CO molecular adsorption state and dissociation propensity are the recent HREELS studies of CO adsorption on oxygen modified Cr(ll0). Three states of oxygen are studied: the chemisorption state, the subsurface oxide and the oxide phase. Table 5 . 6 . illustrates selected data about, CO site occupation and adsorption rate for oxygen-modified C r ( l l 0 ) [44, 641. From the data in table. 5.6. the following important information can be derived: (i) the chemisorbed atomic oxygen species has a stronger direct site-poisoning effect than that of the intermediate oxidation state of Cr( 110), where oxygen is located in the near-surface region; (ii) the oxidized surface is significantly passivated with regard to CO adsorption and the weak CO features can be at,trihuted to the existence of isolated metal defect sites because of imperfect areas in the oxide layer obtained under mild conditions. It is obvious that the removal of the ‘lying down’ CO-state which serves as a precursor for CO dissociation is favoured only when oxygen is present on the
Chapter ,5.
102
Table 5.6. CO Adsorption State, the Corresponding C-0 Stretching Frequencies, wco, and the Initial Sticking Coefficient, So, for C r ( l l 0 ) Modified with Oxygen (data from ref. [64])
SURFACE
ADSORPTION STATE
Cr(ll0)
‘lying down’ CO 1150, 1330 ‘top’ 1955-1 975 ‘bridge’ 1865 ‘top’ 1975 ‘bridge’ 1865 co3 ? 1500 ‘lying down’ 1150-1 330 ‘top’ 1840-1 955 new stat.e 3035 very weak feat.ures at 1170, and 1350, and 1915
C r ( l l 0 ) with chemisorbed eo 0.15 Cr(11O) sub- o xi de
5
Cr(ll0) ‘oxide’
wco (cm-’)
SO
-
1
3.10-*
surface or a surface oxide phase being formed.The effect of the sub-surface oxygen, despite the fact that its absolute concentration is higher than that of the adsorbed oxygen, exhibits significantfly weaker effects on both the occupation of the molecular adsorption stmatesand the dissociation of CO. The difference in the poisoning effects exhibited by the same modifier present on the surface in various chemical states is well demonstrated by comparing the adsorptive properties of substrates ‘carbide’ and ‘graphite’ overlayers. Thus, as shown in fig. 5.24., surface carbon in the carbide form on N i ( l l 0 ) has weaker effect on both the CO adsorption energy and the capacity of surface for CO adsorption than is the case of surface carbon forming a basal layer of graphite [23]. Since the graphite phase grows in islands, the presence of two CO adsorption states when the surface is not completely covered with a graphite layer, is associated with CO adsorbed at the periphery of the graphite islands (CO adsorption energy 50 kJ/mole) and CO molecules residing on C-free pat,ches (CO adsorption energy 96 kJ/mole, i.e. close to that for high CO coverages on a clean surface) [2G,661. A complete surface deactivation is observed on completion of a monolayer of graphitic carbon, because the CO heat of adsorption for a. graphite surface is as low as 15 kJ/mole [GG]. A similar effect of the growing graphite phase on CO adsorption is observed for carbon modified Pt( 111) [ G S ] .
- -
-
5.1.11
Concludiiig Remarks
As will be illustrated in Chapter 8., the adsorptive properties of modified surfaces determine to a large extent the changes in activity and selectivity of the metal catalysts. Since CO coadsorption with electronegative additives is characteristic, it serves t o explain the poisoning effect with respect to reagent
103
5.1. Carbon Monoxide
1
1
.
1
.
I
150200 250
1
I
I
I
.
I
.
I
.
I
.
300 350 400 450 500 TEMPERATURE ( K )
Fig. 5.24. CO TPD spectra for CO from N i ( l l 0 ) ( 2 x l ) C and N i ( l l 0 ) with carbon in graphite islands (from ref. [23]) molecules which exhibit electron acceptor behaviour. The major changes in the CO adsorption kinetics, energetics, site occupation, surface dynamics and dissociative propensity revealed by means of extensive surface science studies are now summarized. These changes are as follows:
(1) Reduction in the CO adsorption rate due to a decrease of the lifetime of the GO precursor for adsorption on the surface sites affected by the modifier. The magnitude of this reduction depends on the adsorption temperature and modifier coverage.
(2) Reduction in the total adsorptive capability of the surface with respect t o molecular CO adsorption due t,o blocking of the favourable adsorption sites by the modifier.
(3) Sequential elimination of the original CO molecular adsorption states starting with the most tightly bound one. The critical modifier coverages at which the original CO adsorption states are completely eliminated depend on the size, the electronegativity and the surface order of the additive adatoms. (4) Appearance of new less strongly bound CO molecular adsorption states. They are associated wit81ithe occupat,ion of different adsorption sites in the close vicinity of the additive adatoms. CO molecules adsorbed in
Chapter 5.
104
these affected sites exhibit different vibrational modes, electronic structure and reduced adsorption binding energies compared to CO molecules adsorbed on clean surfaces.
(5) Constraints of the CO frustrated translational vibrational motions parallel to the surface, which indicates that the modifier induced changes in the surface potential energy cont,our affects the CO mobility as well. As is well known, the adsorbate surface dynamic are an important factor in the surface reactions.
(6) Suppression of the CO dissociation propensity and complete inhibition of GO dissociation above certain additive coverages. This effect on the CO dissociation propensity is due to several factors: (i) a decrease in the lifetime of the molecular CO adsorption state which is a precursor for dissociation; (ii) blocking of the energetically most favourable adsorption sites for the transition state and dissociation product,s; (iii) a possible increase of the activation barrier for dissociation,provided that the binding energies of the dissociation products C and 0 are affected substantially by the presence of a modifier; (iv) impeded CO surface diffusion, etc. The first three factors determine the magnitude of the poisoning effect on the nearest and next-nearest substrate surface atoms. Similar effects of electronegntive additives on the adsorption of acceptorlike molecules, such as NO, Na, 0 2 , are presented in the forthcoming sections.
5.2 5.2.1
NITRIC OXIDE General Remarks for NO Adsorption
011
Clean Metal Sur-
faces
Extensive studies of NO interaction with single crystal metal surfaces during the last decade are directly related to the fact that NO is one of the most tedious components in the automobile exhaust gases. In looking for the most effective catalyst for NO reduction, fundamental knowledge about its chemisorptive behaviour on the catalyst surface is necessary. Of greatest interest as catalysts for NO reduction are the metals P t , Rh and Pd. The electron structure of the NO molecule is similar to that of CO, the essential difference being caused by an additional electron occupying the antibonding 2n level. The presence of this unpaired electron in the 27r molecular orbital of NO promotes dissociation probability for NO compared with CO (the dissociation energy, D N O , for the NO molecule in gas phase is 717 kJ/mole, compared to 1072 kJ/mole for CO [67]). That is why NO exhibits a more pronounced tendency to dissociative adsorption than CO.
5.2. Nitric Oxide
105
The description of the possible NO adsorption bonding on the metal surfaces is made on the basis of the NO bonding in transition metal - nytrosil complexes [68-701. Similarly to CO, the formation of the adsorption bond is via N , N-5a lone pair and partly filled 27r orbitals being involved in the bonding. Because of the presence of an extra unpaired 27r electron the following three types of NO bonding to the surface are possible: (i) ‘on top’ linear bonding, with donor 5a/metal d, and covalent NO27r/metal d , (Ir-like) components; (ii) ‘on top’ bent bonding, where only the NO 27r-orbital participates in the formation of a covalent s bond as a result of overlap between the unpaired 27r electron and a s electron of the metal. In this bent configuration the 50 orbital remains non bonding; (iii) two-fold bridge bonding, where one of the metal atoms is involved in the formation of a donor (a-like) bond with the 5a orbital and the other, in the formation of a covalent ( d i k e ) bond with the 27 NO orbital.
I
I
100
400
700
1oOo
1 m
TEMPERATURE IK)
Fig. 5.25. NO, N2 and (from ref. [SS])
0 2
TPD spectra for increasing NO coverages on Rh(ll1)
This bonding configuration also has a.n N-0 axis perpendicular to the surface plane. Evidently, the backbonding component of adsorption is largest in case (iii) and smallest in case (ii), i.e. the dissociation of NO will be easiest in the case of bridging NO adsorption configuration. The strongest backbonding component for the bridging configuration is also confirmed by the fact that
106
Chapter 5
the occupation of bridge sites is accompanied by a larger increase of the work function than those observed with adsorption in the ‘on top’ sites. Vibrational spectroscopy data (HREELS and IR) have shown that the twofold bridge bonding is the preferred adsorption configuration of NO especially at low NO coverages [71-801. Besides, a variety of other bonding modes, associated both ‘on top’ configurations [74, 76, 79, 81-83], threefold sites [84] and side-on bonded species [75], have been observed.
Fig. 5.26. Dissociated NO amount (as a fraction of saturated NO coverage at 100 K ) and the amount of molecularly desorbed NO as a function of t.he initial NO coverage for several single crystal metal surfaces (from ref. [86])
With the exception of P t ( l l l ) , P d ( l l 1 ) and Pd(100)’ NO adsorption on the transition metals (Nil Ru, Rh, Ir, Cu, Pt(100)) which were also studied is complex, with both molecular and dissociative adsorption states [85]. The relative amount of dissociated NO decreases with increasing NO coverage a t the expense of an increasing amount of undissociated NO [85-901. At low
5.2. Nitric Oxide
107
-
NO coverages the decomposition of NO usually occurs at temperatures 200300 K , the decomposition temperature increasing to 400 K for high NO coverages. The removal of dissociation products by associative desorption as N2 and 0 2 is possible for substrates which do not exhibit a strong tendency to nitride or oxide formation, e.g. on Ni surfaces the dissociation product 0 remains [89, 901, whereas it desorbs as 0 2 from Ru, Rh and P t [71, 86, 871. Figs. 5.25 and 5.26 illustrate the NO, N2 and O2 T P D spectra for increasing NO coverages on R h ( l l 1 ) and the dependence of the fraction of dissociated NO on the initial NO coverages for several substrates. From the T P D spectra in fig. 5.25 it is obvious that the 0 adsorption state on Rh, which is one of the most promising catalysts for NO reduction, is rather stable and can enrich the surface and alter the reaction pathways. Similarly t o CO, NO tends to form various ordered structures on single crystal surfaces determined by the NO coverage and substrate nature [43]. With most transition metals the NO initial sticking coefficient is close to unity and the initial heats of adsorption are in the range 100-120 kJ/mole [85911. At low NO coverages, the activation energy of dissociation for substrates such as Rh, Ru and Ni is of the order of 90 kJ/mole. If NO coverages are high, desorption of part of NO is necessary for the creation of vacant sites for NO dissociation [78]. 5.2.2
Modifier Effect on the N O Molecular A d s o r p t i o n
A. A d s o r p t i o n kinetics and energetics. As outlined above, from all NO/single crystal transition metal systems, studied to date, no NO dissociation occurs in the N O / P t ( l l l ) , N O / P d ( l l l ) and NO/Pd(100) systems [72, 73, 81, 82, 91-95]. That is why some of these systems will be used for illustrating the effect of electronegative modifiers, such as 0, S and Se, on the NO molecular adsorption kinetics and energetics. In contrast to CO [40, 96, 971, no oxidation to NO2 occurs in the NO 0 coadsorption system on P t ( l l 1 ) [82, 981, since thermodynamically the NO2 reduction is the favoured process [99]. Figs. 5.27. and 5.28. present the NO T P D spectra and the adsorption kinetics plot for p(2 x 2) 0.25 O-Pt(ll1). The higher temperature NO T P D peak from O / P t ( l l l ) , located a t 340 K saturates at NO coverage 0.25, whereas the maximum NO coverage on 0.25 O / P t ( l l l ) is 0.38. Compared t o the data for a clean Pt(ll1) surface, both the capacity of the surface to adsorb NO, and the initial heat of adsorption are reduced by the presence of oxygen. Similar results for NO adsorption on 0.25 O / P t ( l l l ) have been observed by M. Bartram et al. [98]. These authors have also worked at a higher oxygen coverage and have shown that in the presence of 0.75 0 the NO saturation coverage and adsorption energy are reduced further. The kinetic curves in fig. 5.28. show that the presence of 0.25 0 does not affect the initial adsorption rate of NO. Figs. 5.29 and 5.30. present the NO T P D spectra for p(2 x 2) 0.25 SPt(ll1) and p(2 x 2) 0.25 S-Pt(ll1) surfaces. In the case of a sulphided surface, NO desorbs in a single peak located a t 270 K . Together with the reduced adsorption capacity, the sulphided surface also exhibits a decrease in
+
-
-
-
Chapter 5
108
I
100
200
300
400
TEMPERATURE [K]
Fig. 5.27. NO TPD spectra for increasing NO coverages on p(2 x 2) 0.25 0P t ( l l 1 ) . Dashed curve shows the NO TPD spectra for saturated NO coverage on Pt'(111). To= 100 I< (from ref. [82])
0.5 a
3 NO FLUX [ 1O+’ 4M0LECULES/crn2]
Fig. 5.28. NO coverage vs.exposure plots for NO adsorption on clean (a) and modified with p(2 x 2) 0.25X overlayers P t ( l l 1 ) . X: (b) - 0; (c) S; (d) Se. To= 100 K (from ref. [82])
5.2. Nitric Oxide
109
-
3
n
1
1OL'
200
300
400
500
TEMPERATURE [K]
Fig. 5.29. NO T P D spectra for increasing NO coverage on ~ ( 2 x 2 0.25 ) S-Pt(ll1). T h e dashed curve shows the NO T P D spectrum for a saturated NO coverage on clean P t ( l l 1 ) . T, = 100 I< (ref. [82])
dT/dt= 1.5 K/sec
0.04 10
Fig. 5.30. NO T P D spectra for increasing NO coverage on p(2 x 2 ) 0.25 SeP t ( l l 1 ) . T h e dashed curve shows the NO TPD spectrum for a saturated NO coverage on clean P t ( l l 1 ) . T, = 100 I< (ref. [82])
Chapter 5
110
the NO adsorption rate (fig. 5.31.). The NO TPD spectra from a selenided surface are more complicated, consisting of three T P D peaks, located at 280, 245 and 225 K at saturation. The effect of Se on the adsorption capacity and adsorption rate at 100 K is similar to that of S. At elevated adsorption temperatures (- 200 K), the capacity t o NO adsorption on Se becomes much less which, as will be shown in the forthcoming sections, is due to structural changes in the overlayer. The effect of 0, S, and Se overlayers on the NO initial heats of adsorption (equal to the NO desorption energy in the limit of very low NO coverages, E z , ) , saturation coverage and initial sticking coefficient at adsorption temperatures 100 K and 200 (determined on the basis of the NO T P D data) is illustrated in Table 5.7. The reduced capacity of the 0.25 O / P t ( l l l ) at 200 K is obviously due t o the removal of the lower temperature state (see fig. 5.27.). In the case of Se, because of the NO induced phase transformation in the overlayer, the NO desorption spectra resemble a fractional order desorption process and this poses difficulties in accurately estimating Ez. The data summarized in Table 5.7. indicate that the molecular adsorption kinetics and energetics of NO are affected in the same way as for the molecular adsorption of CO. Comparing the electronegativities of the modifiers considered in Table 5.7. (3.5, 2.5 and 2,4) and the covalent radii (0.77, 1.04 and 1.16 A) for 0 , S and Se, respectively, the weakest poisoning effect is exerted by the modifier with the highest electronegativity: oxygen. This indicates that the of the modifier is probably a more important factor. Table 5.7. NO Desorption Energy, Ei (in kJ/mole), NO Saturation Coverage, 6sat for T, = 100 and 200 I< (in ML), and NO Initial Sticking Coefficient, SO,for a Clean and Modified P t ( l l 1 ) Surface. (from ref. [S2]) SURFACE
Ei
Pt(ll1) p(2 X 2) 0.25 0 - P t ( l l 1 ) 0.75 0 - P t ( l l 1 ) [98] p(2 X 2) 0.25 S-Pt(ll1) p(2 x 2) 0.25 Se-Pt(ll1)
99 91 86 79 76
N
6 (100 I<)
6 (200 I<)
So
0.55
0.4
1
0.40 0.15 0.17 0.16
0.25 0.17 0.08
-1
--
-
0.75 0.7
A more detailed study of the effect of different amounts of a modifier on the NO molecular adsorption rate has been proposed in ref. [102], where the S-induced reduction of the NO initial sticking coefficient, SO,is found to obey the relation &(S) = So(1 - 28s) (8s is S coverage in ML). Obviously, the influence of sulphur on the NO adsorption rate is weaker than that expected from the simple consideration of four blocked adsorption sites for adatom residing in a fourfold adsorption site. This is probably due to the fact that, for a precursor mediated adsorption process (as is the case of CO and NO molecular adsorption), the sites unfavourable for chemisorption can still serve as possible residence sites of the precursor state.
5.2. Nitric Oxide
111
I
Fig. 5.31. NO uptake versus NO exposure for clean (dashed line), and modified Pt(ll1): p(2 x 2 ) S (open circles) and p(2 x 2) Se (half filled circles) (from ref. 1821)
Studies of the effect of different modifier coverages on NO adsorption are helpful in establishing the sequence and the effectiveness i n the eliiiiinat 1011 of the NO adsorption states The rapid removal of the most strongly bound NO state is illustrated in Figs. 5.32. and 5.33., as well as the reduction in the total amount of NO adsorbed as a result of increasing S coverage on a Pd( 100) surface. It is obvious that for this system the greatest poisoning effect will 0.1. For this low S coverage range, be observed to a S coverage limit of the initial drop of 0 ~ indicates 0 that 1 S adatom blocks 3 adsorption sites of NO and all sites associated with the 535 I< T P D peaks are removed at 0s 0.1. According to the HREELS data, the effect of S on the adsorbed NO bond order, is rather small when S coverages are low, and the reason for that will be discussed in the next Subsections. Both the T P D and the vibrational data show that at 0s < 0.15, no new S-induced NO adsorption states appear At moderate and high S coverages, the reduction in the adsorptive capacity of the surface becomes less severe (1 NO per S) and new S induced weakly bound NO adsorption states arise. Similar effects, like those described above, on the amount and the desorption energy of molecularly adsorbed NO have also been reported for other modified transition metal surfaces, e.g. S/Rh(100) [loo], S/Pt(100) [ l o l l , S/Ni(100) [102], N , O / N i ( l l l ) [103], O/Rh(111) [78], and S/Pd [104]. B. Site occupation and electronic structure of the coadsorbed N O molecule. HREELS [78, 98, 1051, UPS [98] and ESDIAD [82] data have shown that in the presence of electronegative modifiers, the amount of NO in a two-fold bridge bonding configuration is greatly attenuated and completely
-
-
-
112
Chapter 5
166
2 M
NO/NO t S
42
.35
30
.a 15 .09
03S
31
Fig. 5.32. NO TPD spectra for saturated NO coverages from sulphur predosed Pd(100). T, = 80 I< (from ref. [95])
removed above certain modifier coverages. Instead, on surfaces modified by electronegative adatoms, NO occupies exclusively ‘on top’ sites. Compared with Me-NO and N-0 stretching frequencies for linear ‘on top’ NO on a clean surface the Me-NO stretching frequency decreases, and the N-0 stretching frequency increases with the introduction of the modifier and the increase of the modifier coverage. This effect is attributed to an increase of the NO bond order (i.e. a decrease of the degree of coupling of the NO molecule with the surface in the presence of the modifier). Table 5.8. illustrates the changes in the Me-NO and N-0 stretching frequencies and in the NO 2n, l n , 50 and 4a binding energies induced by the presence of 0.25ML and 0.75ML oxygen on P t ( l l 1 ) . It becomes clear from Table 5.8. that the main differences observed for the ‘on top’ NO species on clean and modified with 0.25 0 - P t ( l l l ) , and the ‘on top’ NO species on 0.75 0-Pt(ll1) are the appearance of a second low stretching frequency mode at 510 cm-’ and the increase of the binding energies of the NO molecular orbitals in the case of 0.75 0-Pt(ll1). Assuming that the presence of an electronegative additive should result in a reduction of the ability of the surface for r-backbonding, the observed changes in the NO vibrational and UPS can be satisfactorily explained with ‘on top’ bent NO bonding on 0.75
5.2. Nitric Oxide
NO/NO+S
Pd (100) Dosed at 8Ou
1-
0 2
113
.P.... '.--.. *...._----. ....._..., .........-........... ....
'1\
'.
-\--
I
.I
I
Sulfur
1 .4
.3
Covercqe (monoloyer)
Fig. 5.33. Effect of sulphur coverage on the total NO coverage (full line) aud the local coverages in the most strongly bound ( a t 535 K (dashed line)) and the less strongly bound ( a t N 440 K ) NO adsorption states on Pd(100) (from ref. [95])
0-Pt(ll1). As described in Section 5.2.1., this NO bonding configuration occurs with a negligible x-backbonding contribution. The same argument of a reduced backdonation ability of the modified surface explains the removal of the bridge bonding configuration, where the r-backbonding contribution is significant. Table 5.8. Pt-NO ( w l ) and N-0 ( w 2 )Stretching Frequencies (in cm-') and NO Z A , I T , 5u and 40 Binding Energies (in eV) for NO Adsorbed on a Clean and Oxygen-Covered P t ( l l 1 ) Surface (from ref. [98]) SURFACE Pt(ll1) Pt(ll1) 0.250/Pt( 111) 0.750/Pt(lll)
w1
w2
2*
lX+5fJ
two-fold bridge NO 1490 2.1 9.1 'on top' NO 390 1710 3.9 9.4 9.5 280 1740 2.9 Z 10 265 & 510 1775 3 . 3 450
4u 14.9 13.9 13.9 14.3
The same trend of a preferential 'on top' 1inea.rconfiguration on the modifier affected sites has been observed for NO/O-Rh(lll), where on a mod-
Chapter 5
114
ifier - free surface NO adsorbs in a two-fold bridge configuration for the whole coverage range at which T, = 100 K [78]. The presence of oxygen (0 < 00 < 0.8) causes a shift from bridge to an ‘on top’ linear NO configuration, and when oxygen coverages are very high (00 > 0.8), a backward shift to bridge NO takes place. Relative to the vibrational data, the NO desorption states distinguished in the NO T P D spectra, the following three NO adsorption configurations have been proposed:
-
(i) O-affected bridge NO, which appears when oxygen coverages are very high and desorption takes place at 280 K;
-
(ii) 0 affected ‘on top’ linear NO, which is the preferred adsorption state for moderate oxygen coverages and when desorption takes place at 380 K;
-
(iii) unperturbed bridge NO which exists up to moderate oxygen coverages and desorbs at 430 I<. The N-0 stretching frequency value measured for the oxygen affected ‘on top’ NO is slightly higher than that of the ‘on top’ linear (- 30 cm-’) NO frequency measured for the other P t group metals. Almost the same stretching frequency value was reported for NO on 0-Ru(0001) [log]. The effect of (O+N), produced by NO dissociation, on the NO site occupation on Ru(0001), i.e. moving from bridge to ‘on top’ adsorption site [log], is similar. Modifier-induced changes in the electronic structure of the NO molecule adsorbed on the affected sites are also evidenced by:
+
(i) the intensity and energy changes in the (Is 5a) emission peak in the MQS spectra [103]; (ii) the 0 1s or N 1s core level energy changes of the adsorbed NO molecule [l02], and (iii) the changes in sign of the dipole induced by NO adsorption on clean and modified surfaces [102, 1031.
+
N mixture Thus, for NO adsorbed on Ni(ll1) precovered with 0 or a 0 [103], MQS studies have shown that the (Is 5u) emission peak decreases and shifts t o higher binding energies with increasing amount of 0 or 0 + N present on the surface, whereas the intensity of the 2s emission hardly changes even after the complete disappearance of the ( 1 s 5a) peak (attributed to a change in the spatial extension of the Is and 5a orbitals). For the same systems parallel work function measurements have shown that the NO induced work function changes are in a direction opposite to those for molecular NO adsorption on a clean N i ( l l 1 ) surface, i.e. for a saturated NO coverage on 0.2 O / N i ( l l l ) , the work function drops down t,o -0.2 eV below the clean surface value, whereas a saturated NO coverage on a bare surface causes an increase of +1 eV. These work function results indicate opposite signs of the dipole moments for NO adsorbed on modified and unmodified fcc(ll1) surfaces, which agrees very well with the designation of the modifier-induced changes in the NO bonding configurations described above. The same trend
+
+
-
5.2. Nitric Oxide
115
in the NO induced work function changes reported for the NO/S-Ni(lOO) system, accompanied by a tendency towards an increase of the NO-0 1s binding energy (from 531.2 eV for a S-free surface to 532.2 eV for c(2 x 2) 0.5 S-Ni(100) [102]) is consistent with the decreased metal - NO coupling in the presence of electronegative adatoms. Modifier induced changes in the occupation of surface sites are more complicated in the case of fcc(100) single crystal planes. HREELS data for NO adsorption on S/Pd(100) [95] have shown that the appearance of the new Sinduced NO adsorption states is favoured above certain concentrations of the modifier on the surface. At low S coverages (6s < 0.15), the presence of S: (i) hardly affects the N-0 stretching frequencies of bridge-bonded (1510 cm-1) and ‘on top’ bonded (- 1700 cm-’) NO, and this indicates a negligible disturbance of the NO bond order; (ii) does not change the sequence which adsorption sites are filled (starting with the bridge bonding configuration); but (iii) prevents on top to bridge conversion, observed on S-free surfaces along with partial ‘on top’ NO desorption.
For higher S coverages (0.15 < 0s 5 0.5), three adsorption NO configurations are observed: one bridge, one ‘on top’ and a third very weakly bound NO (desorption temperature 165 K and stretching frequency 1750 cm-l). The latter was associated with the same h2 four-fold hollow site postulated for GO on c(2 x 2) S-Ni(100) [41, 981 (see fig. 5.9.). Finally, in order to illustrate the effect of the chemical state of the electronegative additives on the NO adsorption configuration, the vibrational data concerning NO adsorbed on (100) faces of NiO [lo61 are worth mentioning. The IR data have shown only linearly ‘on top’ bonded NO molecules with N-0 stretching frequencies 1800 cm-’ for all NO coverages, the adsorption sites being the Ni2+ ions in the oxide surface lattice. Comparison of these data with the vibrational data for NO adsorbed on a fcc(100) metal surface precovered with adsorbed oxygen, reveals that the oxidation of the surface results in a more severe reduction of the r-backbonding component as manifested by a higher N-0 stretching frequency (indicating a larger NO bond order) for linear ‘on top’ NO on a metal oxide surface.
-
5.2.3
Surface Order in Mixed Overlayers
The introduction of a modifier above certain critical coverages prevents the formation of the usual NO ordered structures as is the case for CO. LEED data 0.03 on the NO/S-Pd(lOO) system have shown that the presence of only ML sulphur prevents the formation of the p(4 x 2) NO ordered structure, with NO occupying two-fold bridge sites. The p(4 x 2) structure is readily observed on a S-free surface when by heating of a NO saturated surface to 410 K part of the ‘on top’ NO desorbs and another part converts into bridge bonded NO. The S induced inhibition of the long range order of the bridge bonded NO species agrees well with the observed impediment of the ‘on top’
-
Chapter 5
116
bridge conversion in the presence of S due to the reduced stability of the ‘on top’ NO species. However, the presence of small amounts of S (0s < O.l), does not prevent the formation of a c(2 x 2) NO ordered structure observed at NO coverages of 0.5 on a S-free surface. Since the appearance of c(2 x 2) patterns on a sulphided Pd( 100) surface is observed at NO coverages as low as 0.25 this indicates that up to certain value for S coverages, NO tends to adsorb in a separate phase where the local NO density reaches 0.5 ML. This tendency t o formation of a separate surface adsorption phase clearly explains the negligible influence of S on the N-0 stretching frequencies at 0s < 0.1 (because a few NO molecules are directly coordinated to the S adatoms), as discussed in Subsection 5.2.3. 4
N
b.
0.
c.
d.
I
Fig. 5.34. Changes in the LEED patterns induced by annealing of a p(3 x 2 ) 0.25 Se 0.16 NO mixed layer to different temperatures. For the sake of clarity, the NO TPD curve for a saturated NO coverage on p(2 x 2) Se-Pt(ll1) obtained at 90 K is given. The arrows connected with LEED panels indicate both the annealing temperature and the remaining part of the TPD spectrum (from ref. [82])
+
Studies of the effect of NO adsorption on the initial structural order of the modifier on the surface have been carried out for P t ( l l l ) , precovered with p(2 x 2) overlayers of oxygen, sulphur and selenium [82]. For p(2 x 2) 0.25 O-Pt(ll1) and p(2x 2) 0.25 S-Pt(ll1) no extra LEED spots or disturbance of the initial modifier surface order are detected upon NO adsorption in the temperature range 90-250 I< (at higher adsorption temperatures NO starts t o desorb). The picture is completely different in the case of a selenided P t surface where the initial p(2 x 2) Se order is preserved only when NO adsorption is carried out at temperatures lower than 170 I<. As shown in fig. 5.34., annealing of the mixed NO p(2 x 2) Se with saturated NO coverage
+
-
5.2. Nitric Oxide
117
of 0.16, obtained at 100 I<, to various temperatures causes streaking of the extra spots in the original p(2 x 2) patterns followed by the conversion of the p(2 x 2) pattern into a mixture of p(2 x 2) and (Ax &)R30° patterns at 230 K when part of NO desorbs. With a further increase in the annealing temperature and complete desorption of NO, the initial p(2 x 2) Se order is restored.
-
? 0
n 3
$
- 1
dT/dt=
1.5 K/sec
= 40 pA
v
0
.-x
--
C.
c n I
0
b. /
a.
100
200
300
temperature
400
[K]
Fig. 5.35. NO TPD spectrafrom: (a) asaturated NO coverage (- 0.07) on p(2 x2) NO+(& x &)R30 Se-Pt(ll1); (b) after additional 10 L NO exposure at 90 K on (a); (c) from saturated NO coverage on p(2 x 2) Se-Pt(ll1) obtained at 90 K (from ref. [SZ])
In fig. 5.35., the NO T P D spectra obtained after NO adsorption on p(2 x 2) S e / P t ( l l l ) at 220 K when the mixed p(2 x 2) + ( Ax fi)R3Oo structure is formed are compared with the NO T P D spectra obtained by direct desorption of NO from a p(2 x 2) S e / P t ( l l l ) surface, saturated with NO a t 90 I<. It is worth pointing out that the same NO T P D spectra as those observed after 220 K NO adsorption can be obtained if a ~ ( 2 x 2S) e / P t ( l l l ) surface saturated by NO at 90 K is annealed to 230 K prior desorption. The coverages of the Se and NO constituents in the overlayer with mixed p(2 x 2) + x &)R30 structures are 0.25 (initial) for Se and 0.07 for NO. The new structural order obviously offers less adsorption sites for NO, because the surface with an already formed mixed structure can not adsorb more NO even after a long additional NO exposure at 90 I< (curve b in fig. 5.35.). Considering the adsorptive capacity of the P t ( l l 1 ) surface, the best explanation of the new surface order is an NO-induced phase transition from &)R30° Se, accompanied by the formation of a separate p(2 x 2) Se to ( A X
-
(a
118
Chapter 5.
p(2 x 2) NO phase. This tendency of forming of two-phase, immisibly ordered islands, is a probable development where many coadsorbates with dominant repulsive interactions are concerned [43, 107l.The lack of NO induced restructuring on p 0 and p(2 x 2) S-Pt(ll1) and the decrease of the adsorptive capacity of the surface in the sequence 0, S, Se (see Table 5.7.) indicates the significant contribution of the size of the modifiers to the strength of the poisoning effect, i.e. the steric effect seems tooverweigh the electronic one. Indeed, comparison of the adsorptive capacities of P t(ll1 ) precovered with p(2 x 2) overlayers of oxygen, sulphur or selenium, shows that, in the case of oxygen the fraction of NO molecules beyond 0.25 (corresponding to the low temperature TPD peak in fig. 5.27.), resides on bridge sites, sharing a Pt atom with the adsorbed oxygen. ESDIAD data for NO adsorbed on a modified P t ( l l 1 ) surface [82] indicate that for p(2 x 2) S-Pt(ll1) and a selenided surface (in both structural orders) only ‘on top’ linearly-bonded NO species are present, whereas for p(2 x 2) O-Pt(lll), when the NO coverage exceeds 0.2 a bridge bonded configuration is also possible. The observed structural changes in the NO (C0)-electronegative adatom coadsorbate layers, when each adsorbate tends to form a separate adsorption phase complicate the description of the poisoning effect. However, the experimental data show definitely that, even when forming a separate phase, the molecular adsorption state of the reactants is destabilized (they desorb at a lower temperature than from a clean surface) and the local density that is reached in this separate phase, is far below that which is rea&ed bll a clean surface. Several factors should be considered when trying to explain these effects: (i) for the formation of dense compressed overlayers of CO or NO a longrange order is needed which is constrained by the presence of ordered modifier islands; (ii) the reduced mobility of the coadsorbed molecules which leads to an increase of the pre-exponential factor for desorption, i.e. an increase of the desorption rate; (iii) the possible propagation of the local modifier coadsorbed molecule repulsive interactions through the adlayer via molecule - molecule interactions; (iv) the existence of a long range electronic effect of the modifier which extends beyond the next-nearest neighbours. The relative contribution of each effect is likely to be different for the various coadsorbate systems, and no generally applicable definition can be proposed at this stage. 5.2.4
Modifier Effect on the NO Dissociative Adsorption
A significant fraction of NO readily dissociates on most of the transition metal surfaces at temperatures higher than 200 K. This described already in Section
5.2. Nitric Oxide
119
5.2.1. There are minor exceptions like some planes of P t and Pd. In these systems, where the NO dissociation process is competing with molecular NO desorption, the introduction of an electronegative additive always results in the inhibition of the dissociation, accompanied by the reduction of the surfacemolecular adsorption capacity. The fraction of NO, dissociated on S/Ni( 100) as a function of S coverage, and the corresponding NO and Nz T P D spectra is shown in fig. 5.36. It is obvious that NO dissociation is completely inhibited, for sulphur coverages of 0.25 when a p(2 x 2) S ordered structure is formed and all NO adsorption sites are influenced by the additive. The complex N2 T P D spectra are due to the influence of the other dissociative product (0) which remains on the Ni surface. The data in fig. 5.36. can be summarized as follows: (i) the relative fraction of dissociated NO molecules decreases with increasing S coverage; (ii) the inhibition of the dissociation is stronger than the reduction of the surface adsorption capacity for molecular adsorption; (iii) the sulphur induced reduction in saturated NO coverage is adsorption sites per S adatom, and (iv) the sulphur induced inhibition of NO dissociation is
per S adatom.
-
-
2 NO
4 NO molecules
For the NO-S/Ni( 100) system, what makes it complicated, is that, with the dissociation of the first NO doses 0 and N , are also introduced to the surface and they also inhibit, to a certain extent, further NO dissociation. This self poisoning effect accompanying the NO dissociation on a clean surface is weaker than that induced by S [89]. Comparison with the case of a N or 0 precovered surface has shown that the presence of sulphiir influences twice as many dissociation sites [102], i.e. this further proofs the relevance of the adatom size over the electronegativity with respect to the strength of the modifier. Here it is worth noting that, when the effect of 0 on the adsorptive properties of Ni is studied, the possible 0 induced reconstruction and formation of oxide islands will complicate the picture. As reported in ref.[l06], no NO dissociation occurs on NiO (100) surfaces. Generally, the same trend in the S ‘poisoning’ effect has been reported for NO/p(2 x 2) S-Pt( 100) [loll and NO/S-Rh( 100) [loo]. In the presence of a p(2 x 2) 0.25 S overlayer on Pt(100) the dissociation of NO is completely inhibited and the molecular adsorption state is destabilized (the NO T P D data suppose a reduction of the Pt-NO binding energy by more than 50 k.J/mol for NO adsorbed on p(2 x 2) S-Pt(100) [loll). As a result. of this inhibition of NO dissociation, the p(2 x 2) S-Pt(100) surface is completely deactivated in respect of the reaction CO+NO = COz+N2, which proceeds readily on S-free Pt(100). In the case of NO on sulphided Rh(100) it has been found that at 300 I< the presence of only 0.08 S inhibits Completely NO dissociat,ion which is accompanied by a significant decrease in the amount of molecularly-adsorbed NO.
120
Chapter 5.
05 04
03 02
ji 1
01
0 04
9
03 02 0 : 0
02 01
0
01
02
03
04
05
Fig. 6.36. (Left) NO and Nz TPD spectra from Ni(100) with different sulphur precoverages, 0s (in ML), exposed to various NO doses at 110 K. The NO exposures from bottom to top within each manifold are: 0.2, 0.2, 1.0, 1.5, 2.0 and 10 L. (Right) Dependence of the total NO coverage (a), dissociated NO fraction (b), and molecular NO fraction (c) on the S coverage, 0s. NO exposures from bottom to top in each panel is 0.2, 0.6, 1.0, 1.5, 2.0 and 10 L (from ref. [102])
Other electronegative adatoms, such as 0 and N , also cause a decrease of the NO dissociation propensity but they act as less severe deactivators than S [78, 103, 1091. In the case NO/O R h ( l l l ) , the presence of oxygen causes the following changes in the adsorption behaviour of NO : (i) destabilization of the NO molecular adsorption state and the adsorption state of the dissociative product N, both NO and Nz desorption occurring at lower temperatures in the presence of oxygen; (ii) inhibition of NO dissociation at 00 turbed bridge NO is removed.
> 0.8, i.e. when almost all undis-
Parallel T P D and HREELS studies indicate that no dissociation is likely for 0 affected ‘on top’ and bridge NO [78]. 5.2.5
Differences in the Effect of O x y g e n on the A d s o r p t i v e Properties and Reactivity of P t ( l l 1 ) with respect to CO and NO
In this Subsection is illustrated that, depending on the particular system, the same electronegative additive can serve as a ‘poison’ with respect to one
5.2. Nitric Oxide
121
reactant (NO) or can participate in a catalytic reaction with another (CO), although both molecules are behaving as electron acceptor coadsorbates. As has been outlined in Section 5.1., oxygen on P t ( l l 1 ) does not serve as a typical poisoning additive with respect to CO adsorption and participates as a reactant in the important (from the viewpoint of environmental protection) catalytic reaction of CO oxidation. It has been found that, contrary to the expectations concerning the behaviour of an usual ‘poison’, the increase of the oxygen-modified CO adsorption states resulting in a more facile reaction [96, 1081.
k---------A
-- 0.0
2.0
C02 product
CO rwnainlng (450K)
4.0 6.0 8.0 10.0 CO EXPOSURE [ r n b a r . ~ e c . l O - ~ ]
12.0
Fig. 5.37. CO coverage as a function of exposure o n clean P t ( l l 1 ) (dashed curve) and p(2 x 2) O-Pt(ll1). T h e amounts of CO and COz desorbing from CO/p(2 x 2) O-Pt(ll1) during heating are also shown (from ref. [40])
The effect of 0 on the adsorption rate and sequence in the adsorption site occupation of NO and CO on p(2 x 2) O-Pt( 111) will now be compared. In the case of NO, the presence of a p(2 x 2) 0 overlayer leads to: (i) a decrease of the NO initial sticking coefficient (see Table 5.7.); (ii) a reverse in the site occupation, with preferential occupation of linear ‘on top’ sites [98], and
-
(iii) an appearance of a weakly bound NO state with a desorption energy 36 kJ/mole at NO coverages exceeding 0.2, when NO starts to occupy bridge sites (see fig. 5.27.) [82, 981. In the case of CO, the presence of a p(2 x 2) 0 overlayer does not affect the initial rate of CO adsorption (see fig. 5.37.). This indicates that the CO molecules are trapped at 90 K with an equa.1 efficiency in the precursor
Chapter 5
122
OXYGEN COMRAGE CO C O V E W E (YL):
= 2 5 O/Pt 1 r.42 CO/W
2=.3* 3=.32 4z.24 5z.14
dT/dt= 1.4 K/D*c I
Fig. 5.38. COz, CO, and ref. [40])
0 2
TPD spectra from CO/p(2 x 2 ) O-Pt(ll1).
(from
state above each surface site, i.e. the presence of oxygen does not affect the lifetime of the adsorption precursor as has been supposed for the case when the additive acts as a ‘poison’. N o CO desorption occurs at temperatures below 280 K , even at a saturation CO coverage of 0 42 on p(2 x 2) O--Pt(lll), i.e. the oxygen induced destabilization effect (provided t,hat it exists) on the CO adsorption state is much weaker than in the case of NO. At temperatures above 280 K (as is illustrated in fig. 5.38.),the oxidation reaction takes place. However, comparison with the CO T P D spectra from a clean P t ( l l 1 ) surface (see the bottom panel in fig. 5.7.) for a CO coverage of the order of 0.40, where CO desorption starts at 320 I<, permits making the assumption that the effect of oxygen on the stability of the CO adsorption state (if there is any) is insignificant. The most interesting behaviour observed for CO adsorption on p(2 x 2) O-Pt( 111) is that there is no preferential occupation of the ‘nonmodified’ (‘on top’ next-nearest P t site in fig. 5.8.) and both ‘on t,op’ sites on the nearest (directly coordinated with 0) and nest nearest Pt are filled together [40]. As the bond orientation of the coadsorbed CO molecules is concerned, the ESDIAD data have shown that CO ‘on top’ bound on the nearest Pt atom is slightly tilted (- 5’). This bonding configuration of CO and 0 sharing the same P t atom is supposed to be a precursor for COz formation. The difference in behaviour of the NO + 0 and CO + 0 coadsorbed layers on Pt(ll1) has been discussed recently in ref. [98]. It has been shown that the ready CO oxidation is due not only to the lower activation barrier for CO oxidation (53 kJ/mol, compared to 110 kJ/mole for NO oxidation on Pt) , but
-
5.2. Nitric Oxide
123
also to the lower adsorption binding energy of NO. In the case of NO, sharing P t atoms with the oxygen adatoms (a bonding configuration which is likely to be a precursor for NO2 formation) the NO adsorption bind is strongly reduced. Thus, because of the reduced activation barrier for NO desorption, no NO2 formation is observed in NO 0 coadsorbate overlayers. Consequently, the absence of an oxygen-induced ‘poisoning’ effect with respect to CO adsorption on P t implies that the strong CO-0 affinity leading to the formation of C02 might compensate the repulsive forces between these two electron-acceptor coadsorbates.
+
5.2.6
Differences in the Effects of the N O Dissociation Products 0 and N and the Reactivity of Pt and Rh Surfaces with Respect to CO Oxidation and NO Reduction
Since, as outlined above, P t an Rh are presently the best catalysts used for the effective removal of the troublesome automobile exhaust gases NO and CO, it is of particular interest to know how the presence of the NO dissociative products will affect the adsorptive behaviour of the reagents. According to the T P D data summarized in ref. [86], the rate-limiting step in the CO(a) NO(a) = C02(g) N2(g) reaction on R h ( l l 1 ) is the reaction CO(a)+O(a) = CO,(g). On Rh(ll1) when allsites are affected by N adatoms both NO and CO adsorb in ‘on top’ sites, where the contribution of the 7rbackdonation to the adsorption bond is reduced. On the one hand, this leads to destabilization of the molecular adsorption state, and on the other, to inhibition of NO dissociation which is an intermediate step in the NO reduction process. Thus, because of its reduced adsorption binding energy (by 30-40 kJ/mol), in a close proximity of N , CO desorption occurs at temperatures close to and even lower than that at which CO oxidation on Rh takes place. This also leads to an increase in relative concentration of oxygen on the surface, which, above certain coverages, will start t o act as a deactivator of further NO dissociation. The inhibition of NO dissociation in the presence of additives is more severe in the case of Pt, where NO dissociation is more difficult. Because of the presence of at least four different species on the surface (NO, CO, 0 and N ) the real picture is much more complicated. Thus, one should take into account that, besides the electronegative adatoms (0,N and eventually C) there exists a mutual effect of NO and CO coadsorption. The latter is quite different for coadsorbed layers on Pt and Rh. In the case of R h ( l l l ) , NO acts t o a certain extent as a deactivator with respect t o CO adsorption. This causes (similarly to N) destabilization of the molecular CO adsorption state by inducing a discreet new CO adsorption state with a population increasing with the CO coverage. On the contrary, the NO adsorption behaviour on Rh(l1 l), including the dissociation propensity, are negligibly affected by the presence of CO. The only CO effect concerns the capacity for NO adsorption, which could be expected from a site exclusion view, because NO cannot remove CO from the surface. The absence of a measurable effect of CO on the NO dissociation can be attributed to the fact that CO occupies exclusively ‘on top’ sites. Thus the threefold sites favourable for 0 and N adsorption on fcc(ll1) surfaces are free.
+
-
+
Chapter 5
124
The picture is different for P t ( l l l ) , where the presence of CO causes a continuous reduction in stability and coverage of the molecular NO adsorption state with increasing CO coverage, whereas the effect of NO on the CO adsorption behaviour on P t ( l l 1 ) is much weaker. That is why, under the typical reaction conditions, where the concentratmionof CO in the gas phase 5-10 times larger than that of NO (both gases adsorb on Rh and Pt is with sticking coefficients close to unity), Rh will be a better catalyst for NO reduction, whereas Pt remaiiis the best one for CO oxidation. Finally, it should be noted that the above considerations merely express a very simplified picture. As has been shown in the previous subsections, when different species with the same surface dipole polarity (electron acceptors in this particular case) are coadsorbing, it is likely that they will tend to form separate islands. This tendency is frequently observed with coadsorbate systems, such as 0 CO, CO NO, etc.[43, 1071. Such a separation of the reactants in islands impedes the surface reaction to an additional extent.
-
+
5.3
+
NITROGEN AND OXYGEN
The interest in understanding the effect of electronegative modifiers on the interaction of N2 with transition metal surfaces has arisen because nitrogen is one of the reactants participating in the important catalytic reaction of ammonia synthesis, where iron is the most effective catalyst [110]. Since N2 dissociation is believed to be the rate limiting step in t>hehigh pressure ammonia synthesis from Nz and H z , it is important to find out to what extent the presence of additives such as S and 0 will affect the interaction of Nz with the catalyst surface. 5.3.1
General Reinarks for N? A d s o r p t i o n on Transition Metal Surfaces
The nitrogen molecule is isoelectronic with and structurally similar to the CO molecule. Generally, with both molecules the formation of the molecular adsorption bond is via the combination of a a / d , donor Component, where a orbitals are lone pair orbitals of the adsorbing molecules, and a En*/ dz acceptor component, where the E* are unoccupied antibonding orbitals in the adsorbing inolecules. The difference between the N2 and CO bonding is that the a valence orbitals 2uu and 3ug, shared equally between the two nitrogen atoms in a free molecule, mix upon interaction with a metal surface to form two new a orbitals which show a lone pair character to some extent. The resulting donor bond is weaker than that of CO (formed with the participation of the CO-5a lone pair only). By analogy with CO, the backdonation component in the Me-Nz bonding involves the lrgantibonding orbital [ l l l ] . The backdonation component is expected to be more important in CO than N2 bonding, since the 2r CO orbitals lie at a lower energy (of 0.6 eV) than the l?rg Nz ones [112]. As a result the adsorption binding energy of N2 is rather small rangkg from 20 t o 40 kJ/mol for transition metals, such as P d ( l l 0 ) [114], Re (1120) and Re(OOO1) [115], Fe(ll0) and Fe(100) [116], Ru(0001) [117], Ni(ll0) [118, 1191, etc. [113]. These weakly bound molecular
-
5.3. Nitrogen and Oxygen
125
states occupy usually ‘on top’ sites wit,li the molecular axis perpendicular to the surface plane [ill, 114, 117-1231. It is worth mentioning that studies of the influence of the nitrogen coverage on the Me-N:, and N-N stretching frequencies have shown that the Me-N2 stretching frequency increases (e.g. from 278 t o 291 cm-’ for N2 on Ru(0001) [117]), whereas the N-N frequency shifts to lower energies with increasing nitrogen coverage (e.g. from 2252 t o 2198 cm-’ for the same system [117]). This trend is opposite to the one observed in CO/transition metal adsorption systems. The reason for this behaviour has not been completely clarified, but one of the possibilities is the formation of a In, band with a significant dispersion as a result of overlapping between the spatially extended N2 17rg orbitals in denser nitrogen overlayers. It would be reasonable to suppose that, if the In, band broadens sufficiently, it might cross the Fermi level and induce the observed reduction in the N-N stretching frequency. Since the changes on the N-N stretching frequency with increasing Nz coverage are accompanied by a reduction in the NZ desorption energy, the above explanation will be adequate, supposing parallel changes in the donor bonding contribution. Because of the weak adsorption bond, the adsorption rate and the saturation nitrogen coverage for molecular Nz adsorption are strongly dependent on the adsorption temperature. Thus, at room temperature for most of the transition metals under consideration, the initial sticking coefficient is less than lo-’. Actually, at temperatures exceeding the desorption temperatures of the molecular nitrogen, the only stable state on the surface can be nitrogen atoms produced as a result of dissociative nitrogen adsorption [113]. It has been established that the dissociation propensity of N2 is structurally sensitive, e.g. Fe( 111) and polycrystalline Fe are more active with respect t o Nz dissociation and ammonia synthesis than the less open Fe(100) and Fe(ll0) planes [113]. Similarly t o F e ( l l l ) , the open plane of Re(1120) and polycrystalline Re is more active than the close-packed Re(0001) [115, 1241, etc. Recently, HEELS and ARUPS data [125-1281 have shown t,hat there is a second adsorption state of N:, on the open Fe(ll1) surface. The orientation of the N:, molecules in this state and the bonding to the surface differ from the ‘end-on’ linear configuration described above. The second Nz adsorption state det,ected on the open Fe(ll1) plane has an unusually low N-N stretching frequency and is described as a ‘side-on’ r-bonded complex with both N atoms interacting with the metal, with a stronger backdonation contribution compared to ‘end-on’ configuration. The ‘side-on’ Nz cqnfiguration is assumed to be an immediate precursor of Nz dissociation. As described i n ref. [127], the adsorption in this ‘precursor’ state can occur via the more weakly bonded Lend-on’linear state (by interstate conversion) and also by direct adsorption. The direct adsorption process has a rather low initial sticking coefficient (and is the only adsorption channel at higher temperatures and low pressures when the concentration of the ‘end-on’ linear state becomes negligible. The same ‘r-bonded’ N2 species have also been observed on a Cr( 111) surface [ 1291.
Chapter 5
126 5.3.2
Modifier Effect on the sorption
N2
Molecular and Dissociative Ad-
Oxygen, often introduced as an impurity in the reactant mixture is one of the most effective poisons in ammonia synthesis [130]. Studies of thg effect of increasing amounts of oxygen over polycrystalline Fe on the dissociative nitrogen adsorption have shown a linear decrease of the atomic N uptake with increasing oxygen coverage [131]. The effect of preadsorbed oxygen is assumed t o be due t o the fact that both nitrogen and oxygen prefer the same type of adsorption sites. This indicates that the two effects are additive because, as outlined in section 3.2.' both 0 and N cause reconstruction of the Fe surfaces with a strong tendency t o compound oxide and nitride formation. Similar effect on nitrogen dissociative adsorption on Fe is also induced by the presence of sulphur adatoms [113]. The effect of oxygen on the molecular adsorption process on N i ( 110), where dissociation under UHV conditions is negligible consists of a linear displacement of N2 with a negligible influence on the stability of t,he molecular state (slight downward shift of the N 2 T P D peak by 10 I<) and on the Me-N:! and N-N stretching frequencies [119]. The linear decrease of the saturation N2 coverage, e ( N z ) , is found to obey the following relationship:
-
where Omax(N2) is the saturation N:! coverage on a O-free surface, and e(0) and O,(O) are the actual oxygen coverage and the critical oxygen coverage at which O(N2) becomes 0. It has been established that 6,(0) is 0.5 and one oxygen adatom blocks one N2 adsorption site. This result agrees well with the simple blocking model of competitive adsorption. The study of the influence of ordered and disordered 0 overlayers on molecular nitrogen adsorption over Ru(0001) [117] hasbeendone in greater detail. I t has been found that the increase in oxygen coverage from 0 to 0.25 when the p(2 x 2) 0 surface structure is formed, causes a gradual attenuation of the original 94 I< and 117 I< N2 T P D states and an appearance of a new NZ TPD peak at 140 K. The original N2 T P D peaks completely disappear at p(2 x 2) 0.25 0 when only the new TPD feature at 140 K remains. An increase of oxygen coverage beyond 0.25 causes further reduction of the nitrogen coverage [the new O-induced N2 state) until the surface is completely deactivated for nitrogen adsorption at a 0.5 0 p(2 x 1) coverage. An interesting finding is that, irrespective of the reduction of the surface adsorptive capacity (following the same blocking mechanism a5 described by eq.(4)