This Page Intentionally Left Blank
PHYSICO-CHEMICAL ANALYSIS OF MOLTEN ELECTROLYTES
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
PHYSICO-CHEMICAL ANALYSIS OF MOLTEN ELECTROLYTES
Vladimír Daneˇ k† Institute of Inorganic Chemistry Slovak Academy of Sciences Bratislava, Slovak Republic
AMSTERDAM • BOSTON • HEIDELBERG • LONDON NEW YORK • OXFORD • PARIS • SAN DIEGO SAN FRANCISCO • SINGAPORE • SYDNEY • TOKYO
ELSEVIER B.V. Radarweg 29 P.O. Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam The Netherlands
ELSEVIER Inc. 525 B Street, Suite 1900 San Diego, CA 92101-4495 USA
ELSEVIER Ltd The Boulevard, Langford Lane Kidlington, Oxford OX5 1GB, UK
ELSEVIER Ltd 84 Theobalds Road London WC1X 8RR UK
© 2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. This work is protected under copyright by Elsevier B.V., and the following terms and conditions apply to its use: Photocopying Single photocopies of single chapters may be made for personal use as allowed by national copyright laws. Permission of the Publisher and payment of a fee is required for all other photocopying, including multiple or systematic copying, copying for advertising or promotional purposes, resale, and all forms of document delivery. Special rates are available for educational institutions that wish to make photocopies for non-profit educational classroom use. Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone (+44) 1865 843830, fax (+44) 1865 853333, e-mail:
[email protected]. Requests may also be completed on-line via the Elsevier homepage (http://www.elsevier.com/locate/permissions). In the USA, users may clear permissions and make payments through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA; phone: (+1) (978) 7508400, fax: (+1) (978) 7504744, and in the UK through the Copyright Licensing Agency Rapid Clearance Service (CLARCS), 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1P 0LP, UK; phone: (+44) 20 7631 5555; fax: (+44) 20 7631 5500. Other countries may have a local reprographic rights agency for payments. Derivative Works Tables of contents may be reproduced for internal circulation, but permission of the Publisher is required for external resale or distribution of such material. Permission of the Publisher is required for all other derivative works, including compilations and translations. Electronic Storage or Usage Permission of the Publisher is required to store or use electronically any material contained in this work, including any chapter or part of a chapter. Except as outlined above, no part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission of the Publisher. Address permissions requests to: Elsevier’s Rights Department, at the fax and e-mail addresses noted above. Notice No responsibility is assumed by the Publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made. First edition 2006 British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record is available from the British Library. Danek, Vladimir Physico-chemical analysis of molten electrolytes 1. Electrolyte solutions I.Title 541.3 72 ISBN-10: 0-444-52116-X
The paper used in this publication meets the requirements of ANSI/NISO Z39.48-1992 (Permanence of Paper). Printed in The Netherlands.
Dedicated to my wife Maria
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Publisher’s Note Vladimír Danˇek, 6 April 1940 – 28 November 2005 It is our sad duty to inform you that after submitting the manuscript for this book, Dr. Vladimír Daneˇ k passed away after a short illness in November 2005. In 1963 Dr. Daneˇ k joined the Institute of Inorganic Chemistry of the Slovak Academy of Sciences in Bratislava, of which he was the director in the period 1991–1995. His main field of interest was the physical chemistry of molten salts systems; in particular the study of the relations between the composition, properties, and structure of inorganic melts. He developed a method to measure the electrical conductivity of molten fluorides. He proposed the thermodynamic model of silicate melts and applied it to a number of two- and three-component silicate systems. He also developed the dissociation model of molten salts mixtures and applied it to different types of inorganic systems. More recently his work was in the field of chemical synthesis of double oxides from fused salts and the investigation of the physicochemical properties of molten systems of interest as electrolytes for the electrochemical deposition of metals from natural minerals, molybdenum, the synthesis of transition metal borides, and for aluminium production. During his career Dr. Daneˇ k was also head of the Department of Molten Salts, chairman of the Scientific Board of the Institute, chairman of the Scientific Collegium for Chemical Sciences of the Slovak Academy of Sciences, and member of the Presidium, the Executive Board, and chairman of the Commission for Chemical Sciences of the Scientific Grant Agency of the Ministry of Education of the Slovak Republic and the Slovak Academy of Sciences. In 1994 he was elected an active member of the New York Academy of Sciences. His numerous achievements were also recognized with the Award of the Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences, 1968; the Award of the Slovak Academy of Sciences, 1972, 1986 and 1989; the Dyonýz Štúr Silver Medal for Achievements in Natural Sciences, 1990; and the Dyonýz Štúr Golden Medal for Achievements in Natural Sciences, 2000. In the course of his distinguished career he published more than 240 papers in international journals and conference proceedings. We extend our condolences to his wife Maria and further family on their sad loss.
Acknowledgement Ing. Marián Kucharík, PhD, took on himself the task of correcting the proofs. Ing. Zden˘ek Pánek, DrSc, was responsible for compiling the index. vii
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Preface The idea of this book came to me after seeing a multitude of young scientists carrying out their PhD studies on molten salts and attending various conferences, many of whom were eager for any new knowledge on molten salts. Many of them focused their study on problems that would contribute a little more to the understanding of the structure of the system of interest using sophisticated and very expensive equipment. On the other hand, while being mostly interested in the quantum chemistry and molecular dynamics simulation calculations, their knowledge of the physical chemistry of inorganic melts is often poor. At the universities, we can also see another very encouraging development. After the resumption of relations between East and West at the end of the 1990s, a lot of young scientists from Eastern Europe and Asia came to the universities in Western Europe for a shorter or longer stay, or a PhD study. While in Eastern Europe and Asia, the measurement of physico-chemical properties is more frequent due to the lack of other expensive sophisticated physical equipment, in Western Europe and the United States, the emphasis is rather on the use of high-tech investigations. This book includes selected topics on the measurement and evaluation of physicochemical properties of molten electrolytes. It describes the features, properties, and experimental measurement of different physico-chemical properties of molten salt systems used as electrolytes for the production of different metals, metallic layer deposition, as a medium for reactions in molten salts, e.g. precipitation of double oxide powders used for functional and construction ceramics, special parts for steel and copper production, etc. The physico-chemical properties such as phase equilibria, density (molar volume), enthalpy (calorimetry), surface tension, vapor pressure, electrical conductivity, viscosity, etc. are the most important parameters of electrolytes needed for technological use. For each property, the theoretical background, experimental techniques, as well as examples of the latest knowledge and the processing of most important salt systems will be given. Most of the examples are among the published works of the author. The aim of the book is not only to present the state of the art studies on different properties of molten salt systems and their measurement, but also to present the possibilities of modeling molten salt systems, to be able to forecast the properties of an electrolyte mixture from the properties of the pure components in order to avoid experimentally demanding, and in most cases, also expensive measurements. Some direct methods of study on the structure (ionic composition) of molten electrolytes are also presented.
ix
x
Preface
During the last decades of the twentieth century, a substantial development of experimental and especially, computational techniques took place. Thus, new measurement methods and mathematical processing of data appeared. This new information is not given anywhere in a comprehensive form and therefore, a lot of people working in this field are not acquainted with it. This book thus fills a substantial gap in this field of science. The book also documents the latest research in molten salt chemistry and brings new results and new insights into the study of molten salt systems using the results of X-ray diffraction and XSAF methods, Raman spectroscopy, and NMR measurements. On the other hand, it is not the goal of this book to present an exhaustive review of the measurement of physico-chemical properties carried out in the last two or three decades. This would certainly exceed the framework of this book. The electrochemistry of molten salts is not included in this book either, since in my opinion, this topic would need a separate book due to its complexity and wealth of applications. The quantum chemistry and molecular dynamics simulation methods are omitted as well. However, recent books of this kind have been written by the Russian authors Antipin and Vazhenin (1964), and the American authors Blander (1964), Sundheim (1964), Mamantov et al. (1969), Lumsden (1966), and by Lowering and Gale (1983). Since then, new information on physical properties of molten salt systems has been disseminated only in papers in different journals. This book should serve as a textbook for all people working in the field of molten salt chemistry. It is aimed at undergraduate students working on their diploma work, for students working on their PhD theses, and also for other graduates, e.g. teachers at universities, scientists in academic institutes, research institutes, and in industry, i.e. to all who need up-to-date information on this subject. It is a pleasure for me to express my thanks to my teachers Professor Milan Malinovský, who taught me the theory of molten salts, Professor Kamil Matiašovský, who taught me his experimental skills, and Dr. Ivo Proks, who helped me to understand a little of thermodynamics. Professor Pavel Fellner of the Slovak Technical University is greatly acknowledged for his advice and comments which helped improve this book. I am very thankful to my colleagues at the Institute of Inorganic Chemistry of the Slovak Academy of Sciences for their help and good friendship during my whole professional career. Finally, my warm thanks and great admiration are devoted to my wife. Without her timeless patience, systematic support, and help, this book could not have been written. Vladimír Daneˇ k 2005
CONTENTS
Publisher’s Note .......................................................................................................... vii Preface.......................................................................................................................... ix 1
Introduction ........................................................................................................
2
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems............................................................ 5 2.1. Structure of melts containing metals of various valence ......................... 10 2.1.1. Systems of univalent electrolytes ................................................ 10 2.1.2. Systems containing divalent cations ........................................... 18 2.1.3. Systems containing trivalent cations ........................................... 26 2.1.4. Systems containing tetravalent cations ....................................... 41 2.1.5. Systems containing pentavalent cations ...................................... 47 2.1.6. Systems containing hexavalent cations ....................................... 50 2.1.7. Systems containing halides and oxides ....................................... 56 2.1.8. Systems containing jumping electrons ........................................ 79 2.1.9. Systems of silicate melts ............................................................. 101 2.1.10. Systems of molten alkali metal borates ...................................... 102 2.1.11. Systems of metallurgical slags .................................................... 104
3
Phase Equilibria ................................................................................................. 3.1. Thermodynamic principles........................................................................ 3.1.1. Gibbs’s phase law ........................................................................ 3.1.2. Lever rule..................................................................................... 3.1.3. Thermodynamics of solutions ..................................................... 3.1.4. Thermodynamic models of molten salts ..................................... 3.2. Phase diagrams of condensed systems ..................................................... 3.2.1. Binary systems............................................................................. 3.2.2. Ternary systems ........................................................................... 3.2.3. Quaternary systems...................................................................... 3.2.4. The CaO–Al2 O3 –SiO2 system .................................................... 3.3. Experimental methods............................................................................... 3.3.1. Thermal analysis .......................................................................... 3.3.2. Cryoscopy .................................................................................... 3.3.3. Differential thermal analysis ....................................................... xi
1
107 107 107 108 110 119 155 155 167 184 186 189 189 191 205
xii
Contents
3.4.
Calculation of phase diagrams .................................................................. 208 3.4.1. Coupled analysis of thermodynamic and phase diagram data.... 208 3.4.2. Calculation of the phase diagram of the quaternary system KF−KCl−KBF4 −K2 TiF6 ............................................... 213
4
Enthalpy .............................................................................................................. 4.1. Thermodynamic principles........................................................................ 4.1.1. Hess’ law...................................................................................... 4.1.2. Kirchoff’s law .............................................................................. 4.1.3. Enthalpy of reaction .................................................................... 4.1.4. Estimation of enthalpy of fusion ................................................. 4.1.5. Enthalpy balance.......................................................................... 4.2. Experimental methods............................................................................... 4.2.1. Calorimetry ..................................................................................
221 221 222 223 223 225 231 231 232
5
Density................................................................................................................. 5.1. Theoretical background............................................................................. 5.1.1. Molar volume............................................................................... 5.1.2. Partial molar volume ................................................................... 5.1.3. Application to binary and ternary systems.................................. 5.2. Experimental methods............................................................................... 5.2.1. Method of hydrostatic weighing ................................................. 5.2.2. Maximum bubble pressure method .............................................
255 255 255 256 257 266 266 268
6
Surface Tension .................................................................................................. 6.1. Thermodynamic principles........................................................................ 6.1.1. Gibbs equation ............................................................................. 6.1.2. Surface adsorption of ideal and strictly regular binary mixtures ............................................................................ 6.1.3. Surface tension in ternary systems.............................................. 6.1.4. Surface tension models................................................................ 6.2. Experimental methods............................................................................... 6.2.1. Capillary method ......................................................................... 6.2.2. Maximum bubble pressure method ............................................. 6.2.3. Detachment methods ................................................................... 6.2.4. The drop methods ........................................................................ 6.3. Contact angle............................................................................................. 6.3.1. Contact angle measurement......................................................... 6.4. Interfacial tension ...................................................................................... 6.4.1. Experimental methods .................................................................
271 271 273 278 284 286 290 290 292 296 303 305 305 306 307
Vapor Pressure ................................................................................................... 7.1. Thermodynamic Principles........................................................................ 7.1.1. Gas mixtures ................................................................................ 7.1.2. Liquid–gas equilibrium................................................................
313 313 313 314
7
Contents
7.2.
xiii
Experimental methods............................................................................... 315 7.2.1. The boiling point method ............................................................ 315 7.2.2. The transpiration method............................................................. 322
8
Electrical Conductivity...................................................................................... 8.1. Theoretical background............................................................................. 8.1.1. Electrical conductivity of “ideal” and real solutions .................. 8.1.2. Electrical conductivity in ternary systems .................................. 8.2. Experimental methods............................................................................... 8.2.1. Capillary cells .............................................................................. 8.2.2. Conductivity cell with continuously varying cell constant......... 8.2.3. Two-electrode cell........................................................................ 8.2.4. Four-electrode cell .......................................................................
327 328 329 345 346 349 352 354 356
9
Viscosity............................................................................................................... 9.1. Theoretical background............................................................................. 9.1.1. Viscosity of “ideal” and real solutions........................................ 9.1.2. Application to binary and ternary systems.................................. 9.2. Experimental methods............................................................................... 9.2.1. Method of torsional pendulum .................................................... 9.2.2. Falling body method.................................................................... 9.2.3. Rotational method........................................................................
359 359 360 361 369 369 377 380
10
Direct Methods of Investigation ....................................................................... 10.1. X-ray diffraction and XAFS measurements ............................................. 10.2. Raman spectroscopy.................................................................................. 10.2.1. Theoretical background ............................................................... 10.2.2. Characteristic features of Raman scattering in melts ................. 10.2.3. Experimental techniques of measurement................................... 10.2.4. Raman spectroscopy in various systems ..................................... 10.3. Nuclear magnetic resonance ..................................................................... 10.3.1. Theoretical background ............................................................... 10.3.2. Experimental technique of measurement .................................... 10.3.3. High temperature NMR measurement ........................................
385 385 388 388 390 391 395 402 402 405 406
11
Complex Physico-chemical Analysis ................................................................ 423 11.1. Dilute solutions ......................................................................................... 423 11.2. Whole systems........................................................................................... 424
References .................................................................................................................... 429 Index............................................................................................................................. 445
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Chapter 1
Introduction Inorganic ionic melts represent a group of waterless solvents and solutions, which is interesting both from the point of view of fundamental research as well as with regard to their present and prospective use in technical practice. At present we find them used, e.g. in the metallurgical production of aluminum, magnesium, alkali, and refractory metals, where they are used as electrolytes; in black metallurgy, where they form slags gathering unwanted admixtures and reaction products in iron and steel production. Molten electrolytes are used in galvanic metal plating in melts, e.g. in aluminum plating, boriding, or in the deposition of refractory metal layers (Ti, Mo, Nb, etc.). Molten mixtures of alkali metal halides and zirconium, thorium, beryllium, and uranium are used as heat-bearing medium in primary circuits of nuclear plants. Mixtures of molten alkali metal halides and hydroxides have a potential use in energy storage, where the relatively high value of the enthalpy of fusion is used. Molten carbonates of alkali metal halides are used as electrolytes in molten carbonate fuel cells. A big industrial field, where oxide melts are predominantly used, is the glass industry. Here, the high affinity of these melts to under-cooling and glass formation is exploited. Recently, there has also been an increase in the importance of melts in their use as a reaction medium for chemical and electrochemical synthesis of compounds for functional and construction ceramics, e.g. double oxides with spinellitic and perowskite structure and binary compounds with prevailing covalent bond character, mainly borides and carbides of transition metals. In order to decide the suitability of a certain melt in technical practice, an in-depth knowledge of its physico-chemical properties is unavoidable. The present database of the properties of inorganic melts is relatively broad. Many properties are known, such as phase equilibria, enthalpies of fusion, heat capacities, density, electrical conductivity, viscosity, surface tension, emf of galvanic cells of many molten systems, the measurement of which was stimulated first by their technological application. Nevertheless, the published data on the physico-chemical properties of the molten systems are often incomplete and in many cases the results given by different authors may more or less differ. The reason is that the experimental measurement of the physicochemical properties of inorganic melts is sometimes inadequate. First, because of the shortage of expensive construction material. Second, due to the relatively high costs connected with the construction of unique measurement devices. It is obvious that the choice of a suitable melt for a concrete application, which is often a multi-component mixture, is given by the requisite optimum physico-chemical 1
2
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
properties at a given temperature. With regard to the experimental difficulty of direct measurement, in choosing a concrete melt it is much cheaper to use convenient structural models that enable us to forecast the values of the physico-chemical properties of multi-component molten systems on the basis of knowledge of the properties of the pure components. It is then necessary to know the mathematical description of the functional property – composition and property – temperature dependences. The definite form of such dependences is given first by the structure (ionic composition) of the molten systems, which in many cases is still not satisfactorily known. Recently, research on the structure of inorganic ionic melts has rapidly advanced. A substantial improvement in the experimental techniques, especially in high-technology electronics and computer techniques, has contributed to this. However, the present knowledge of the physico-chemical properties of molten systems is in many cases on a higher level than the possibility of their interpretation. First, it follows from the lack of an adequate knowledge of their structure. High-temperature X-ray diffraction analysis applied to the liquid phase has not principally contributed to the classification of the structure of melts, mainly due to the lack of suitable approaches in structural analysis. More success was attained recently by the exploitation of sophisticated methods of high-temperature infrared and Raman spectroscopy, NMR, MAS NMR, and some numerical methods, especially methods of quantum chemistry and of molecular dynamics. While for the last mentioned methods of investigation the measuring devices could be acquired, with only small adaptations, devices for measurement of physico-chemical properties are not available on the market. The measurement, especially its precision depend on the skills of the scientists and the workers in the laboratory. For instance, the construction of a high-temperature torsional pendulum viscosimeter requires in-depth knowledge of many features of the technique. It should also be mentioned that for scientific purposes, the accuracy and precision of results must be at least one order higher than for industrial purposes. On the other hand, using generalized knowledge many industrial measurements could be avoided as necessary data could be estimated with good accuracy. Generally, any electrolyte is composed of a mixture of alkali metal halides, which serve as solvent, and the compound of the deposited metal. In addition, there may be other additives, which may improve the properties of electrolyte or enhance the metal deposition. For a certain purpose a concrete molten system must be used. For example, in the electro-deposition of metals from molten salts several types of molten systems were tested as electrolytes. From the analysis of literature and on the basis of the electro-active species used, they can be divided into two principal groups: • •
systems containing halo-complexes of deposited metals, systems containing oxides or oxy-complexes of deposited metals.
Introduction
3
In all of the investigated systems, one of the most important tasks to be solved is to find the proper composition of the electrolyte with regard to both the suitable physico-chemical properties and the desired character of the electrodeposited product. Both problems are closely related to the actual structure, i.e. the ionic composition of the melt. Quite recently attention was paid to the role of oxides, either as electro-active species, as impurities or as additives in the electro-deposition of transition metals. This may be demonstrated, e.g. in the case of electro-deposition of molybdenum, where the electrolysis of neither pure K2 MoO4 , nor the KF–K2 MoO4 mixture yields a molybdenum deposit. However, introducing small amounts of boron oxide, or silicon dioxide to the basic melts, smooth and adherent molybdenum deposits may be obtained. Also, in the case of niobium and tantalum deposition, the presence of oxygen either from the moisture or added on purpose leads to the formation of oxohalo-complexes, which due to their lowered symmetry and thus lower energetic state, decompose easier at the cathode yielding pure metal. It is thus the aim of the present book to serve as a guide in the measurement of the physico-chemical properties of molten salts and to characterize briefly the properties and the structure of different types of molten salt systems. In this book, only direct methods of measurements and different methods of processing the measured data are discussed. Computer simulation methods are not considered.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Chapter 2
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems The transition from the solid to the liquid state is so commonplace that ancient scholars tried to explain this phenomenon. The development of the natural sciences in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries enabled its deeper understanding, especially in connection with the development of suitable methods for the measurement of volume and heat. The first experiments to apply thermodynamic principles to the melting process of substances arose approximately at the time of the formulation of the second law of thermodynamics, i.e. in the middle of the nineteenth century. As it is known, the main advantage of classical thermodynamics lies in the fact that it is not necessary to know the structure of the investigated system. This enabled some of the most important classical thermodynamic conclusions on the melting process to be made before the general idea of the atomic structure of a substance was accepted. However, as the latter observations showed, melting depends on the structure of the crystalline state of matter and due to the great variability of the crystal structure of matter, different features of this phase transformation have to be investigated. Today it is obvious that, without the thorough knowledge of the crystal structure of solid substances, it is not possible to study the structure of the melt. It should be, however, also emphasized that X-ray structural analysis, which was broadly exploited for the study of the crystal structure of solids, did not enable explanation of all structural aspects of the molten state. For deeper understanding of the structure of melts obviously, new experimental and theoretical approaches are needed. From the general structural classification, the crystalline substances can be divided into four groups: (a) (b) (c) (d)
molecular, ionic, metallic, network forming.
At melting, each group forms its own type of melt. Of course, melts having the features of two of these groups may also occur. For example, silicate melts belong to the network forming as well as to the ionic melts.
5
6
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
The structure of inorganic melts is, in spite of their relative simplicity, not completely understood. The earlier calculations and simple models of molten salts were built up rather on intuition. However, they were the necessary first step for more sophisticated approaches. In general, inorganic melts increase their volume at melting. The number of substances that decrease their volume at melting is surprisingly low. From among the more common substances, we have e.g. Sb, Bi, Ga, H2 O, and RbNO3 . These substances are characterized by a low coordination of atoms, which indicates an “open” structure of the solid. At melting, their structure partially collapses, which is followed by a volume contraction. At a sufficiently high temperature, molten salts are miscible in any ratio. At lower temperatures, a limited miscibility can be observed. Partially miscible salts are in general mixtures of halides of multivalent metals with prevailing covalent bonds, like e.g. Al, Bi, and Sb, with halides having a high ratio of ionic bonds, e.g. CaCl2 and KCl. The shape of the dependence of the given property on composition gives certain information about the structure of these mixtures. The comparison of the values of molar volumes of mixtures of alkali metal halides and the mixtures of alkali metal halides with PbCl2 can be mentioned as an example. In the former case, the molar volume changes almost additively, which indicates that in the mixtures, the cations and anions are arranged more or less equally as in the pure salts. In the latter case, the change in molar volume on composition is almost additional only in the system NaCl–PbCl2 , and from potassium to cesium, there is always a more expressive minimum. This trend indicates that in these melts, structural changes causing deviation from ideal behavior take place. However, the molar volume of molten salt mixtures is in general not influenced much by structural changes, since the changes in the ionic ordering cannot be great. More sensitive in this direction is the electrical conductivity, which shows larger changes with the change in composition. An additive change of the electrical conductivity on composition is not known. For instance in the systems of alkali metal halides, in contrast to the molar volume, negative deviations in the concentration dependence of conductivity from the additivity can be observed. This effect supported the supposition of the formation of associates, leading to lowering the number of conducting ions in the melt. Even though until now, no further data supporting these ideas are available, it is clear that between cations of uneven size, an important interaction exists. The concept of “complexing” in molten salt mixtures is somewhat different from that for solutes in aqueous or organic solvents. In water solutions, every ion is separated from the other ions by the solvatation wrapping of water. Ions, simple or complex, are mutually influenced only by weak forces and each ion behaves independently. In molten salts, the positively and negatively charged ions are in close contact and the interaction forces are great. The heats of formation of complex anions, except for the stabile ions like [SO4 ]−2 , [NO3 ]− , etc., are in the order of a few kJ · mol−1. These values are lower than that of the activation energy of diffusion, which in these melts is
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
7
relatively fast. This leads to the idea of the fast formation and disintegration of the complex ions in halide melts. If the complex ion in the melt could be detected, its lifetime must be much longer than the vibration period of the heat vibrations of individual ions (10−13 s), and longer than the mean time of contact between individual cations and anions (10−10 s). The mean lifetime of the ion [CdBr 3 ]− in the system KBr–CdBr2 is around 10−2 s, thus this ion can be really regarded as a complex ion. In every pure alkali metal halide or earth alkali metal halide melt, the cation is surrounded by anions in the first coordination sphere and has cations in the second coordination sphere. This arrangement is caused by the coulombic forces between cations and anions. In simple binary univalent systems AX–BX (e.g. NaCl–KCl), the A+ cations are surrounded by X− anions in the first coordination sphere and by A+ and/or B+ cations in the second. However, the individual arrangement changes very quickly and its lifetime is very short (<10−13 s). Thus, it cannot be detected by spectroscopic methods. The large deviation from ideal behavior, the minimum in the enthalpy of mixing, and the inflection points on the partial molar entropy of charge-unsymmetrical binary systems have been attributed to special ordering effects. On the basis of simple structural models, it had been suggested that these effects could be explained by real “complex” formation. For binary mixtures containing divalent cations, complexes with the stoichiometry [MeX4 ]2− were proposed. On the basis of suitable structural models, S-shaped curves for the partial molar entropy and the minimum in the enthalpy of mixing at x(MeX2 ) = 0.33 were calculated. In systems containing trivalent cations, the formation of the [MeX6 ]3− complex anion has been suggested from the minimum in the enthalpy of mixing. A series of spectroscopic investigations support this view of “complexing.” Every component of the MX–MeX2 mixture in its pure molten state possesses a certain structure, defined by an average number of atoms in the first and second coordination spheres. The M+ cations are surrounded in the first coordination sphere by X− anions and have M+ cations in their second coordination sphere. The same situation applies to the molten MeX2 component. In the molten mixture, the Me2+ and M+ cations are in the first coordination sphere again surrounded by common X− anions but have M+ and/or Me2+ cations in their second coordination sphere. Mixtures dilute in MeX2 have an excess of M+ cations. The divalent Me2+ cations have higher field strength in comparison with the M+ cation. They thus attract more X− anions in order to supplement their coordination sphere to the maximum. This effort is compensated by the presence of M+ cations in the second coordination sphere. On the other hand, the probability of having two or more Me2+ cations in the second coordination sphere of M+ is small. Thus the first and second coordination spheres define the shape of the “complex” anion. When the concentration of MeX2 is sufficiently high, there are not enough M+ cations for the second coordination sphere to surround the “complex” anion and a new
8
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
microstructure of the melt arises. This leads to the change in the course of the enthalpy of mixing. For the MX–MeX2 systems, this change occurs in the composition range 0.3 < x(MeX2 ) < 0.35 while for the MX–MeX3 , it occurs in the range 0.2 < x(MeX3 ) < 0.25. However, the absence of the additive M2 MeX4 compound in the phase diagram of some systems does not necessarily imply the absence of the complex [MeX4 ]2− anions in the melt. The presence of complex anions in the melt has been proved by Raman and FTIR spectra. Divalent cations like Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, Zn, etc., due to the splitting of the d-electrons of the Me2+ cations in the environment of the X− anions, at mixing with alkali metal halides, show a certain degree of covalence of bonds. The splitting of d-electrons leads to an increase of energy, which is called the ligand field stabilization energy (LFSE). This splitting varies with the symmetry of the coordination sphere of the cation. The change of the cation coordination and its thermodynamic stability is also affected by the LFSE. This effect can be seen on phase diagrams of various systems. For instance in the systems MF–MgF2 , where M = Li, Na, K, Rb, and Cs, the ionic strength and the repulsive forces of the alkali metal cation in the second coordination sphere affect the stability of the complex compounds formed in the individual systems. The lower the polarization ability of the M+ cation, the more stable are the complex anions formed in the system and the more complex anions are formed. The Li+ cation does have the highest polarization ability among the alkali metals. Therefore in the system LiF–MgF2 , no complex compound is formed and the system shows continuous solid solutions. In the system NaF–MgF2 , two compounds – NaMgF3 and Na2 MgF4 – are formed, which melt incongruently due to the still high polarization ability of the Na+ cation. In the system KF–MgF2 again, two compounds KMgF3 and K2 MgF4 , are formed, however, due to the lower polarization ability of the K+ cation, they melt already congruently. The same situation also applies to the system RbF–MgF2 , but the fields of primary crystallization of both compounds, RbMgF3 and Rb2 MgF4 , are more extensive compared with those in the system KF–MgF2 . The Cs+ cation shows the lowest polarization ability. In the system CsF–MgF2 , thus four complex compounds are formed. There are three congruently melting compounds Cs3 MgCl5 , Cs2 MgCl4 , and CsMgCl3 , and one incongruently melting compound CsMg3 Cl7 . From the structural measurement, it follows that MgF2 crystallizes in the tetragonal system. The most expressive complex compounds MMgF3 (M = Li, Na, K, Rb, Cs) also crystallize in the tetragonal system. On the other hand, the complex compounds M2 MgF4 (M = Na, K, Rb, Cs) crystallize in the cubic system with an octahedral space group. Similar thermodynamic behavior can be observed also in other MCl–MeCl2 systems. It may be thus concluded that the cohesive energy of pure transition metal chloride melts is affected by LFSE. Upon mixing with alkali metal chlorides, the coordination of the transition metal cation does not change, i.e. its coordination in pure MeCl2 and in the MCl–MeCl2 mixtures is the same.
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
9
Regarding the thermodynamic behavior of the charge-non-symmetrical binary systems, the following general rules can be deduced. (i)
With regard to the Temkin’s model of ionic melts, the MX–MeXn systems show negative deviation from ideal behavior, which increases with: • • • •
increasing size of the alkali metal cation (e.g. by substituting Na+ with K+ ), decreasing size of the multivalent cation (e.g. by substituting Ca2+ by Mg2+ ), increasing polarizability of the alkali metal and/or multivalent cation (e.g. by substituting Mg2+ by Al3+ ), increasing charge of the multivalent cation (e.g. by substituting Ca2+ by Ti4+ ).
Some empirical rules can also be deduced regarding the behavior of the common anion. • • (ii)
(iii)
(iv)
the deviation from the Temkin’s ideal behavior decreases with increasing size of the anion (e.g. by substituting F− by Cl− ), the enthalpy of mixing increases in the sequence Cl < Br < I.
The appearance of inflection points on partial enthalpies of mixing and of minima in the interaction parameter indicates a possible formation of the complex anion in the mixture. In spite of the very high polarization ability of the Li+ cation and no minimum in the interaction parameter of the LiX–MeXn system, tetrahedral, octahedral, and/or a distribution of geometries has been observed by spectroscopic methods. In order to elucidate the structure of the melt, i.e. the ionic composition, besides the calculation of the thermodynamically consistent phase diagram, supplementary spectroscopic measurement is needed. Raman and IR spectroscopic studies have confirmed the appearance of MeX2− 4 complexes at x(MeX2 ) < 0.33 and of the MeX3− complexes at x(MeX ) < 0.25 with tetrahedral or octahedral symmetries, 3 6 respectively, for these complexes. The observed values and the shape of the enthalpies of mixing are not, or only very little affected by temperature.
At present, only the crude structural concept of Førland (1954) and conclusions made by Lumsden (1964) have described the above listed conclusions on a semi-quantitative level. The recent molecular dynamics computer simulations made by Liška et al. (1995b) and Castiglione et al. (1999) for the system NaF–AlF3 resulted in a non-realistic dependence of structure on concentration. Obviously the polarization forces of atoms, which have not been taken into account, seem to be of great importance. The most direct proof of the existence of complex ions was obtained using spectroscopic measurements. The presence of [CoCl4 ]−2 , [NiCl4 ]−2 , [CuCl4 ]−2 , [PbCl3 ]− , and
10
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
[PbCl4 ]−2 in mixtures of CsCl and the halide of the respective metal was confirmed using ultraviolet absorption spectroscopy. By means of the Raman spectroscopy, the presence of complex anions [AlF4 ]− , [AlF5 ]2− , and [AlF6 ]−3 in mixtures of AlF3 with NaF or KF was confirmed. On the basis of the conductivity, the enthalpy of mixing, as well as of other indices, the existence of a number of complex anions like [CdCl3 ]− , [CdCl4 ]−2 , [CdCl6 ]−4 , [ZnCl3 ]− , [ZnCl4 ]−2 , [PbCl4 ]−2 , [PbCl4 ]−4 , [MgCl4 ]−2 , [CuCl3 ]−2 , etc. in the systems of KCl and the chloride of the respective metal were foreseen. In the case of the systems KCl–CdCl2 , KCl–PbCl2 , and RbCl–PbCl2 , the dependence of the electrical conductivity on composition minima can be observed. They can be reasonably explained by the formation of the anions of the type [CdCl4 ]−2 , [CdCl3 ]− , [PbCl4 ]−2 , etc. The existence of associates such as [SO4 F]−3 , [MoO4 F]−3 , [TiF6 Cl]−3 , etc., which undergo at melting a more or less thermal dissociation, while thermodynamically proved, is under lively discussion.
2.1.
STRUCTURE OF MELTS CONTAINING METALS OF VARIOUS VALENCE
In general, the ionic composition of molten salt systems depends on the solvent used for the dissolution of the compound, which contains the metal to be deposited, and the chemical nature of this compound. Usually, chemical reactions take place between this compound and the solvent. At these chemical reactions, new complex anions are formed, atomic composition and stability of which depend on the electronic state of the central metallic atom and the polarization ability of the alkali metal cations. The chemical nature of the anions present also plays a non-negligible role. The above-mentioned phenomena will be explained in the following chapters. It is not the goal of this book to describe the behavior of all molten salt systems in question. This can be found in the textbooks of Inorganic Chemistry. The features of only the technologically most important systems will be described in the following chapters.
2.1.1. Systems of univalent electrolytes
Alkali metal halides, mainly sodium and potassium fluorides and chlorides, are usually used as solvents for salts of multivalent metals, which are deposited on electrolysis at the cathode. Alkali metal halides improve the physico-chemical properties of the electrolyte and in many cases, it is the only possibility to deposit the desired metal altogether. 2.1.1.1. Single salts
Alkali metal halide melts are characterized by a quasi-crystalline structure originating by dilatation of the crystal structure and by the occurrence of different kinds of positional disordering. Cations and anions are preferably surrounded by ions of the opposite charge
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
11
forming two one-into-another inserted quasi-crystalline structures. Forces of mutual ionic interactions are electrostatic and due to the above-mentioned ordering, they are centrosymmetrical. Due to the positional randomness, the geometrical compensation of the electrostatic forces is, with regard to the crystalline state, reduced as also the electrostatic polarization effects of ions. This leads to shortening of the inter-ionic distances and lowering of the coordination number of ions (Table 2.1). The statistical consequence of such mutual interactions is the formation of ionic pairs or associates. The positional disordering probably causes association of ions due to the polarization forces, whereby the extent of association increases with the increasing atomic number. Alkali metal halides increase in general their volume at melting (Table 2.2), which is due to the lowering of atomic coordination and the formation of a free volume. Several attempts to calculate the properties of alkali metal halides on the basis of the equation of state can be found in the literature. Reiss et al. (1959, 1960) estimated the reversible work needed for creation of a spherical cavity in liquids of rigid spheres and derived the equation of state for these liquids pV 1 + Y + Y2 = RT (1 − Y )3
(2.1)
Table 2.1. Cation–anion distances of alkali metal halides in the solid, liquid, and gaseous states, and their coordination numbers Salt LiF LiCl LiBr LiI NaF NaCl NaBr NaI KF KCl KBr KI RbF RbCl RbBr RbI CsF CsCl CsBr CsI
d(s) (nm)
Coord. number
d(l) (nm)
Coord. number
0.201 0.257 0.275 0.300 0.231 0.282 0.299 0.329 0.267 0.314 0.331 0.354 0.282 0.330 0.343 0.367 0.301 0.359 0.362 0.385
6 6 6 6 6 6
0.195 0.247 0.268 0.285 0.230 0.280 0.298 0.315 0.266 0.310 0.330 0.353 0.273 0.329 0.342 0.366 0.282 0.353 0.355 0.383
3.7 4.0 5.2 5.6 4.1 4.7 – 4.0 4.9 3.7 – – – 4.2 – – – 4.6 4.6 4.5
6 6 6
6
6 8 8
d(s) - at ambient temperature, d(l) - at 1.05 × Tfus , d(g) - at boiling temperature.
d(g) (nm) 0.153 0.203 0.217 0.239 0.184 0.236 0.250 0.271 0.213 0.267 0.282 0.305 0.225 0.279 0.295 0.318 0.235 0.291 0.307 0.332
12
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes Table 2.2. Thermodynamic parameters of melting of some alkali metal halides Sfus (J/mol · K)
Salt
Tfus (K)
Vfus /Vs (%)
LiF LiCl LiBr
1121 883 823
29.4 26.2 24.3
24.2 22.6 21.3
NaF NaCl NaBr NaI
1268 1073 1020 933
27.4 25.0 22.4 18.6
26.3 25.9 25.5 25.1
KF KCl KBr KI
1131 1043 1007 954
17.2 17.3 16.6 15.9
25.1 25.5 25.5 25.1
RbCl RbBr CsCl
995 965 920
14.3 13.5 10.0
23.8 24.2 22.2
where p is the pressure, V is the molar volume, T is the temperature, and Y =
π a3N 6V
(2.2)
In Eq. (2.2), a is the diameter of the rigid spheres and N is the Avogadro number. Wertheim (1963) and Thiele (1963) showed that the equation of state derived by Reiss et al. (1959, 1960) is identical with the equation of state derived by Percus and Yevick (1958), who presented the exact solution of the integral equation for the radial distribution function. Lebowitz et al. (1965) generalized later the validity of this theory for the mixture of simple liquids. The same equation of state was derived by Stillinger (1961), who showed that Eq. (2.1) can be applied to fused salts also if we replace the fused salts by a rigid sphere fluid in which the particle diameter a equals the sum of the cation’s and anion’s radii. Later Reiss and Mayer (1961), Mayer (1963), and Yosim and Owens (1964) calculated some thermodynamic properties of fused salts (entropy, heat capacity, entropy of fusion, compressibility, and surface tension) on the basis of this theory. The agreement between the calculated and experimental data is reported as good and in some cases as very good. However, this model fails in the calculation of transport properties. Vasu (1972a,b) used the results of the above-mentioned works for the calculation of contact correlation function in molten salts on the basis of a double hard core model, which describes better the real situation in molten salts. This contact correlation function was applied in the calculation of viscosity and electrical conductivity of molten alkali
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
13
metal halides. In this model, the coulombic interactions among particles in the melt were taken into account, replacing them by double hard core interactions. This respects the fact that the ions of the same sign cannot come closer than to a certain distance, which in the √ first approximation, equals the minimum distance in the NaCl type crystal lattice, i.e. a 2, where a is the cation–anion distance. In the melt, the distance can be even shorter because the regular arrangement of particles in the lattice disappears after melting and the particles can be deformed and compressed. Further, it is known from the radial distribution functions that the coordination number decreases after melting from 6 to 3.5–5.6. Therefore, Fellner and Daneˇ k (1974), for molten alkali metal halides, assumed that the minimum distance between the ions of the same sign√could be expressed in terms of aF, where the value of the factor F will be lower than 2. For the contact correlation function g(a) of oppositely charged ions, which is important in the calculation of the transport properties, it holds Y2 Y (1 − Y )−3 g(a) = 1 − + 2 4
(2.3)
where Y =
π a3N 3 F +1 6V
(2.4)
√ Vasu (1972a) used for the geometrical factor the value F = 2. Using Thorne’s equation for the viscosity of rigid spheres given by Chapman and Cowling (1960) and Eqs. (2.3) and (2.4), Vasu (1972a) derived for the viscosity of molten alkali metal halides, the equation η=
0.419Y 2 g(a) m1 m2 kT 1/2 m1 + m 2 a2 m 1 m2 0.475 0.993 + 1 + 0.375 × 1+ Y g(a) (m1 + m2 )2 [Y g(a)]2
(2.5)
where m1 and m2 are the masses of particles, k is the Boltzmann constant, and T is the absolute temperature. On the basis of the kinetic theory of liquids, Vasu (1972b) also derived the following equation for the electrical conductivity of molten alkali metal halides
κ = 3e
2
4g(a)a
2
2π kT M1 M2 M1 + M 2
−1 (2.6)
14
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
where κ is the electrical conductivity, e is the electronic charge, M1 and M2 are the atomic masses of particles, and the other symbols express the above mentioned meaning. In Table 2.3 the comparison of the calculated and experimental values of the viscosity and electrical conductivity at the temperature of T = 1.05 Tfus is given. As it follows from the table, the agreement between the calculated and the experimental results is good and in some cases, even excellent. One value of the factor F is applicable in the calculation of both the viscosity and electrical conductivity. The values of the molar volume, as well as of the viscosity and the electrical conductivity were taken from Janz et al. (1968). Experimental data for cation–anion distance as they were found in the diffraction studies of molten alkali metal halides and collected by Janz (1967) were used in the calculation. Since these data are known for 13 alkali metal halides only, the rest of the data was estimated from the gas phase as was recommended by Yosim and Owens (1964). It was found that the value of the factor F decreases in the series Li+ , Na+ , K+ , Rb+ , + Cs and attains the mean values 1.45, 1.36, 1.31, 1.29, and 1.26, respectively. This can be explained by the dependence of this factor on the size √ and polarizability on ions. For lithium salts, the value of the factor F is higher than 2. This is not surprising since in this case the effect of the anion–anion repulsion should be considered. Similarly, the
Table 2.3. Calculated and experimental viscosity and electrical conductivity of molten alkali metal halides (T = 1.05 Tfus ) MX
T (K)
a (nm)
F
ηexp (cP)
ηcalc (cP)
κexp (S/cm)
κcalc (S/cm)
LiF LiCl LiBr LiI
1174 927 864 758
0.195 0.247 0.268 0.285
1.46 1.45 1.42 1.47
2.05 1.49 1.55 2.19
2.33 1.58 1.41 1.68
8.80 5.95 4.92 3.96
10.03 5.92 4.84 3.41
NaF NaCl NaBr NaI
1331 1127 1074 982
0.230 0.280 0.298 0.315
1.38 1.35 1.34 1.38
1.65 1.19 1.23 1.31
2.07 1.26 1.34 1.31
5.10 3.74 3.06 2.40
5.55 3.98 2.98 2.49
KF KCl KBr KI
1185 1095 1058 1006
0.270 0.310 0.330 0.353
1.31 1.33 1.30 1.31
– 1.02 1.04 1.43
1.72 1.21 1.32 1.43
3.73 2.29 1.74 1.38
3.60 2.77 2.02 1.48
RbF RbCl RbBr RbI
1100 1037 1001 959
0.273 0.330 0.342 0.366
1.44 1.29 1.29 1.29
– 1.19 1.33 1.27
2.04 1.51 1.58 1.56
– 1.62 1.20 0.94
2.99 1.84 1.47 1.15
CsF CsCl CsBr CsI
1003 964 954 939
0.282 0.353 0.355 0.385
1.44 1.24 1.29 1.26
– 1.17 – 1.66
2.08 1.44 1.61 1.70
2.53 1.25 0.91 0.73
2.63 1.49 1.25 0.88
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
15
effect of the cation–cation repulsion must be taken √ into account in the case of RbF and CsF, where the value of the factor F is higher than 2 as well. A similar argument was given by Yosim and Owens (1964) to explain differences in the calculation of the absolute entropy of these melts. 2.1.1.2. Binary systems
Calorimetric measurements indicated that the enthalpy of mixing is frequently negative (the mixture has a lower enthalpy than the pure components). This is due to the following reasons: (a) (b) (c) (d)
the change in the repulsion energy of evenly charged ions is an important part of the enthalpy of mixing, structural changes in the process of mixing are small, the number of neighbors in the nearest coordination sphere is not changed, the change in the state of ion polarization.
On the other hand, van der Waals–London forces show generally small positive contribution to the enthalpy of mixing. Førland (1954) illustrated the change in the cation–cation repulsion by a crude model shown in Figure 2.1. The arrangement of ions before mixing is on the upper side, while the arrangement after mixing is given below. Since the arrangement of anions has changed, the change in the repulsion energy is approximately given by the relation 2e2 E ≈ − d1 + d 2
F−
Rb+ d1
Cs+
Rb+
d1 − d 2 d1 + d 2
(2.7)
Cs+
F− d2
Rb+ d1
2
Cs+
d1
F− d2
Cs+
d2
Rb+
F− d2
d1
Figure 2.1. Cation–cation repulsion energy change at the RbF–CsF mixing.
16
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
where e is the electronic charge. This crude estimation yields a negative enthalpy of mixing and indicates its variation with the size of the ions. In the extreme case, it can lead to the formation of binary compounds. In a similar manner, Lumsden (1964) has calculated the contribution to mixing if the anion is polarizable. His result for this contribution to energy is very similar to Eq. (2.7). The consequence of the above considerations is that binary systems of alkali metal halides form different types of phase diagrams, starting with the simple eutectic ones through the solid solution eutectic ones, the phase diagrams with the formation of a binary compound up to those with complete solid solubility. Tables 2.4 and 2.5 summarize the main features of individual phase diagrams. As it can be seen from the tables, binary compounds are formed only in systems with a common anion. The compounds originate in the systems Li+ , Rb+ //X− and Li+ , Cs+ //X− , where X = F, Cl, Br, I. On the other hand, phase diagrams with continuous solid solutions can be observed predominantly in systems with “soft” cations. These facts are connected with the value of the repulsion energy of evenly charged ions (see Eq. (2.7)). The higher the repulsion energy, the higher is the probability of binary compound formation. Table 2.4. Characteristic features of binary systems of alkali metal halides with a common anion System
Type of phase diagram
Compound
System
Type of phase diagram
Compound
LiF–NaF LiF–KF LiF–RbF LiF–CsF
lss ses ewc ewc
– – LiF·RbF LiF·CsF
LiCl–NaCl LiCl–KCl LiCl–RbCl LiCl–CsCl
css ses ewc ewc
NaF–KF NaF–RbF NaF–CsF KF–RbF KF–CsF RbF–CsF
lss ses ses css lss css
– – – – – –
NaCl–KCl NaCl–RbCl NaCl–CsCl KCl–RbCl KCl–CsCl RbCl–CsCl
css lss ses css css css
– – Lil·RbCl LiCl·CsCl LiCl·2CsCl – – – – – –
LiBr–NaBr LiBr–KBr LiBr–RbBr LiBr–CsBr NaBr–KBr NaBr–RbBr NaBr–CsBr KBr–RbBr KBr–CsBr RbBr–CsBr
css ses ewc ewc css ses ses css lss lss
– – LiBr·RbBr LiBr·CsBr – – – – – –
LiI–NaI LiI–KI LiI–RbI LiI–CsI NaI–KI NaI–RbI NaI–CsI KI–RbI KI–CsI RbI–CsI
css ses ewc ewc? css lss ses css lss lss
– – LiI·RbI 3LiI·2CsI – – – – – –
ses – simple eutectic system; lss – limited solid solutions; css – continuous solid solutions; ewc – eutectic system with compound(s); * – solid–solid transformation; ? – no experimental data, tentative PD.
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
17
Table 2.5. Characteristic features of binary systems of alkali metal halides with a common cation System
Type of phase diagram
System
Type of phase diagram
LiF–LiCl LiF–LiBr LiF–LiI LiCl–LiBr LiCl–LiI LiBr–LiI
ses ses ses css ses css
NaF–NaCl NaF–NaBr NaF–NaI NaCl–NaBr NaCl–NaI NaBr–NaI
ses ses ses css lss css
KF–KCl KF–KBr KF–KI KCl–KBr KCl–KI KBr–KI
ses ses ses css lss css
RbF–RbCl RbF–RbBr RbF–RbI RbCl–RbBr RbCl–RbI RbBr–RbI
ses ses ses? css css? css
CsF–CsCl CsF–CsBr CsF–CsI
ses* ses ses
CsCl–CsBr CsCl–CsI CsBr–CsI
lss lss css
ses – simple eutectic system; lss – limited solid solutions; css – continuous solid solutions; ewc – eutectic system with compound(s); * – modification transformation; ? – no experimental data, tentative PD.
For a molten alkali metal halide mixture with a common cation, the Gibbs energy of mixing is given by the equation
mix G = RT xA+ ln xA+ + xB+ ln xB+
(2.8)
where xA+ and xB+ are the cation fractions of A+ and B+ , respectively. In systems with a common anion, the Gibbs energy of mixing is given by the equation
mix G = RT xX− ln xX− + xY− ln xY−
(2.9)
where xX− and xY− are the anion fractions of X− and Y− , respectively. From the above equations it follows that for all systems with a common ion, the value of the Gibbs energy of mixing should be equal. However, in the general case the Gibbs energy of mixing is also affected by the enthalpy of mixing and by the non-ideal entropy of mixing. Comprehensive cryoscopic, calorimetric, and galvanic cell studies of alkali metal halide systems with a common anion and a common cation have been carried out. These measurements have shown that the enthalpy of mixing for these systems can, in general, be expressed by a parabolic type equation mix H = xi xj a + bxj + cxj2
(2.10)
18
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
where xi and xj are the mole fractions of the two components and a, b, and c are coefficients determined by a least-squares fit of the experimentally determined data. Rearranging Eq. (2.10) we get mix H /xi xj = λ = a + bxj + cxj2
(2.11)
where λ is the “enthalpy interaction parameter.” λ varies slowly with composition, revealing details that cannot be easily recognized from the dependencies of the enthalpy of mixing on composition. The limiting values of the interaction parameters for x2 → 0 or x2 → 1 are of particular interest since they are related to the partial enthalpies of solution of the salt components lim λ = λ0 = λ(x2 = 0) = H 2 (x2 = 0) x2 =0
lim λ = λ1 = λ(x1 = 0) = H 1 (x1 = 0)
(2.12)
x1 =0
2.1.2. Systems containing divalent cations
As it follows from numerous experimental measurements, some pure halides of divalent metals partially dissociate in the molten state according to the scheme MeX2 ⇔ MeX+ + X−
(2.13)
Other divalent cations have the tendency to form complex anions of the type [MeX3 ]− and/or [MeX4 ]−2 not only in the presence of the alkali metal halides, but also in the pure state. Some pure halides of divalent metals show a tendency to form auto-complexes. The ability to form auto-complexes according to the scheme 2MeX2 ⇔ MeX+ + MeX− 3
(2.14)
is demonstrated by e.g. mercury halides, MgCl2 , MgBr2 , and MgI2 , which is marked at melting by a significant increase in the electrical conductivity. A typical example of a salt that forms auto-complexes is ZnCl2 . The formation of complexes at melting takes place according to the scheme 2ZnCl2 = [ZnCl4 ]2− + Zn2+
(2.15)
According to Mackenzie and Murphy (1960), the high viscosity of about 500 Pa · s and the low conductivity of about 10−3 S · cm−1 of liquid ZnCl2 near its melting point,
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
19
indicate strong differences in structure compared with other typical fused salts. This is due to the presence of network structures in the melt. Hefeng et al. (1994) have found that the tetrahedrons consisting of four Cl atoms around Zn (ZnCl2− 4 ) are dominant and stable in molten ZnCl2 . Ballone (1986) pointed out that the local structural arrangement around the zinc ion is not significantly different in the molten or solid state. The network structure is often referred to as polymeric. As it follows from conductivity measurements, at increasing temperature a fast disintegration of the ligand structure takes place in the melt. The polymeric structure rapidly breaks down as the temperature increases and the proportion of ions, i.e. Zn2+ , ZnCl+ , 2− ZnCl− 3 , and ZnCl4 becomes higher, increasing the conductivity and decreasing the viscosity. The classic ionic melt originates, in the case of ZnCl2 , already at temperatures far above the melting point. Polyanions are probably also present in molten SnBr2 and PbCl2 . In general, the earth alkali metal halides increase their volume at melting (Table 2.6). This is due to the lowering of atomic coordination and the formation of free volume. Yamura et al. (1993) found that depolymerization also occurs with the addition of alkali metal halides, increasing the conductivity and decreasing the viscosity of the melt. These authors proposed that the addition of alkali metal chlorides to ZnCl2 induces depolymerization as expressed by the following equations [ZnCl2 ]n + Cl− = [ZnCl2 ]n−m + [ZnCl2 ]m Cl− [ZnCl2 ]m Cl− + Cl− = [ZnCl4 ]2− + [ZnCl2 ]m−1 Table 2.6. Thermodynamic parameters of melting of some earth alkali metal halides Salt
Sfus (J/mol · K)
Tfus (K)
Vfus /Vs (%)
MgF2 MgCl2 MgBr2
1536 987 984
– – –
37.6 43.5 35.1
CaF2 CaCl2 CaBr2 CaI2
1687 1045 1015 1052
– 0.9 4.0 –
17.6 27.2 28.8 39.7
SrF2 SrCl2 SrBr2 SrI2
1673 1146 930 811
– 4.1 2.1 –
10.9 13.4 11.3 24.2
BaF2 BaCl2 BaBr2
1593 1233 1130
– 3.6 11.8
13.4 13.4 28.4
(2.16) (2.17)
20
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
Von Bues (1955) found evidence of a polymer (ZnCl2 )n using Raman spectroscopy. After an addition of 33 mole % KCl, ZnCl− 3 species were suggested. When the ZnCl2 :KCl 2− molar ratio was 1:2, tetrahedral ZnCl4 species were mentioned. During the past four decades, numerous investigations of systems with divalent cations have been performed and a large area of molten salt chemistry was discovered. The main results were obtained by EMF, calorimetric, and other physico-chemical methods, and accurate enthalpies of mixing and chemical potentials are available. A brief summary of the results was given by Østvold (1992). Electrical conductivity at salt mixing is generally not additive. Duke and Fleming (1957) found for a mixture of KCl and ZnCl2 , negative deviation of the conductivity, which was explained by ion interactions or the formation of complex ions. Maximum conductivity was reached for the highest measured temperature and the largest addition of KCl. In general, the increase in conductivity is largest for the addition of alkali metal chloride with the smallest cation. Thus, lithium chloride will favor the conductivity most. Benhenda (1980) determined the conductivity of ZnCl2 –LiCl mixtures in the temperature range from 320 to 450◦ C. Furthermore, the effect of LiCl addition to ternary mixtures of ZnCl2 , KCl, and NaCl on the conductivity was determined by Driscoll and Fray (1993). A significant increase in conductivity was reached when 20 mole % LiCl was added. When mixing zinc chloride with different alkali metal chlorides, viscosity does not generally obey the additive rule. Though, for higher contents of zinc chloride, the viscosity will increase. The viscosity of four melts was determined by Driscoll and Fray (1993); the temperature dependence of viscosity showed Arrhenius behavior. Generally, the surface tension of the mixtures of ZnCl2 with alkali metal chlorides increases with decreasing amounts of ZnCl2 . Copham and Fray (1990) measured surface tension of four ternary ZnCl2 –NaCl–KCl melts and found that the surface tension decreases linearly with increasing temperature. Near the primary crystallization temperature of the mixture, the surface tension attains low values, indicating that the ratio of temperature to the temperature of primary crystallization (T/Tpc ) has a significant effect on the surface tension. Driscoll and Fray (1993), who determined the surface tension of another four melts, also came to the same conclusion. The vapor pressure of pure zinc chloride was measured by Meyer et al. (1989). However, a more accurate value for vapor pressure at 450◦ C, i.e. 55.5 Pa, was given by Anthony and Bloom (1975), who determined the vapor pressure in the temperature range 450–625◦ C. Bloom et al. (1970) had determined that the addition of NaCl or KCl reduces the vapor pressure of ZnCl2 . The vapor pressure of these binary mixtures was used to determine the activity coefficients of zinc chloride and alkali chloride. Haver et al. (1976) reported the weight loss of the bath for different electrolyte compositions and observed that when pure ZnCl2 was used, there was more loss; the weight loss decreases with additions of LiCl, NaCl, and KCl.
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
21
LiCl-MeCl2
λ /(kJ/mol)
0
−40
0.33
−80
−120
↓
0
0.33 ↓
x(MgCl2) 1 0 x(MnCl2) 1 0
0.33 ↓
x(CeCl2)
CsCl-MeCl2
0.33 ↓
1 0 x(ZnCl2)
1
Figure 2.2. Enthalpy interaction parameter in charge-unsymmetrical molten binary systems.
Most of the systems containing divalent cations show negative enthalpy of mixing, however, certain weakly interacting systems have shown positive values. The enthalpy interaction parameter λ depends strongly on composition. For a family of systems MX–MeX2 (M = Li, Na, K, Rb, Cs) the variation of λ with the mole fraction of MeX2 , x2 , may be a smooth but fast-changing function or a more complex function showing a minimum. The shape in the interaction parameter for different univalent–divalent systems shows variations depicted schematically in Figure 2.2. For the LiX–MeX2 systems almost linear behavior has been observed, whereas for the CsX–MeX2 binaries, a minimum of λ appears at x2 ≈ 0.33. For the remaining alkali metal halides (Na, K, Rb) intermediate behavior has been found. It was found out that the interaction parameter, λ, is in general not a linear function of the distance parameter δ12 . However, in the series with one salt as a common salt, the λ versus δ12 plot is linear. 2.1.2.1. Systems with common earth alkali metal halide
Let us consider the energy change that follows the substitution of the alkali metal cation by the earth alkali metal in a liquid alkali metal–earth alkali metal halide mixture. If the
22
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
structural changes by this process are minor, so that the number of neighbors in the nearest coordination shells is not changed, the change in the cation–cation repulsion energy is an important part of the energy change. When the anion–cation distances can be assumed to be constant and equal to the sum of the ionic radii, the change in energy following the substitution due to the change in cation–cation repulsion may be described by a crude model introduced by Førland (1964) and illustrated in Figure 2.3. Let us now consider the reaction, when one earth alkali metal cation is substituted by another
2 Me2+ X− MI+ mix(l) + MII+ X− MII+ pure(l) (2.18)
= 2 Me2+ X− MII+ mix(l) + MI+ X− MI+ pure(l) with the change in energy E(MeX2 ) = 2EMeXMII + EMI XMI − 2EMeXMI − EMII XMII
(2.19)
The change in coulombic energy following the substitution may be described roughly by the equation EC (MeX2 ) = e2
4 1 4 1 + − − dMeX + dMII X 2dMI X dMeX + dMI X 2dMII X
(2.20)
where e is the electronic charge and d with subscript is the respective interatomic distance.
X–
Me2+
d1
Me2+
d1
X–
M+
d2
M+
d2
d1
M+
d2
X–
Me2+
X–
Me2+
d1
M+
d2
Figure 2.3. Change in the cation–cation repulsion energy, E C , at mixing in univalent–divalent salt systems.
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
23
In addition to the change in coulombic interaction occurring when an earth alkali metal cation is substituted by another, according to reaction (2.18), there is also a change in polarization of the common anion due to the change in the cation environment. Førland (1964) and Lumsden (1964) pointed out that the anion would become polarized by the unsymmetrical electric field due to the different size and charge of the two cations on opposite sides of the anion (Figure 2.3). In the group (Me2+ X− M+ ), the anion X− is subjected to an electric field F =e
2
1
−
2 dMX
(2.21)
2 dMeX
If α is the polarizability of the anion, the polarization energy of the (Me2+ X− M+ ) group is αe2 αF 2 EP = − =− 2 2
2 2 − dMX 2dMeX
2 (2.22)
4 4 dMeX dMX
The change in polarization energy following reaction (2.18) can thus be approximated by the expression EP (MeX2 ) = −αe
2
1 4 dMe II X
−
1 4 dMe IX
−
4
2 dMX
1 2 dMe II X
−
1 2 dMe IX
(2.23)
The polarization energy of the pure salts can be neglected. From the above considerations it can be concluded that the slopes of the λ versus δ 12 plots for the common earth alkali halide systems should increase in the sequence Mg < Ca < Sr < Ba. This was indeed experimentally observed. Except for the lithium halide–earth alkali metal halide systems, the data are well represented by the λ versus δ 12 plot for each common earth alkali metal halide system. The slopes of λ versus δ12 plot increase when the radius of the common earth alkali metal cation is increasing. 2.1.2.2. Systems with common alkali metal halide
For these systems let us consider the following reaction 2+ − 2 M+ X− Me2+ mix(l) + Me2+ pure(l) I II X MeII 2+ − 2+ = 2 M+ X− Me2+ pure(l) II mix(l) + MeI X MeI
(2.24)
24
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
with the change in energy E(MX) = 2EMXMeII + EMeI XMeI − 2EMXMeI − EMeII XMeII
(2.25)
According to Førland’s model illustrated in Figure 2.3, the change in coulombic energy following the substitution may roughly be described by the equation EC (MX) = e
2
4 1 4 1 + − − dMX + dMeII X 2dMeI X dMX + dMeI X 2dMeII X
(2.26)
The changes in coulomb energy, when substituting one alkali metal cation by another one in a binary alkali metal–earth alkali metal halide melt, will tend to give negative λ versus δ 12 plot slopes, which are decreasing when the size of the common alkali metal cation is increasing. The change in polarization energy, which follows the substitution of one alkali metal halide cation by another one, can be estimated in the same way as outlined previously and can be approximated by the expression EP (MX) = −αe
2
4 4 dM II X
−
4 4 dM IX
−
4 2 dMeX
1 2 dM II X
−
1 2 dM IX
(2.27)
2.1.2.3. Influence of the common anion on the enthalpy of mixing
It is obvious from the foregoing discussion that the enthalpies of mixing for chargeunsymmetrical systems do not follow the simple conformal solution theory. When the anion in a strontium halide–alkali metal halide mixture from chloride to bromide and from bromide to iodide is changed, the enthalpy of mixing is decreasing. For all systems, the enthalpy interaction parameter, λ, is a linear function of δ 12 with the usual exception for lithium-containing systems. Two important features of the λ versus δ 12 plot should be emphasized: (1) (2)
the enthalpy of mixing is decreasing in the sequence common chloride, common bromide, common iodide, the slope of the λ versus δ 12 plot is also decreasing in the above sequence.
Strontium- and barium-containing systems do not deviate much from regular solution behavior. The relatively simple nature of these melts therefore indicates that the variation in the enthalpy of mixing with the common anion must be explainable by a model taking into account coulombic and polarization interactions between ions in a fairly simple manner. This behavior is also evidenced by the phase diagrams of the binary systems
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
25
M2 F2 –SrF2 (M = Li, Na, K). All three binary systems are the simple eutectic. Also in the same series of strontium chlorides, there are only simple eutectic systems for lithium, sodium, and potassium, but systems containing bigger rubidium and cesium cations with low polarization ability already form binary compounds. 2.1.2.4. Partial molar quantities in charge-unsymmetrical systems
Measurements of the chemical potential for each of the component salts in chargeunsymmetrical binary systems yield negative values, which become more exothermic with increasing concentration and by substituting the M+ cation from Li to Cs. Changes of the divalent salt in the MX–MeX2 systems give rise to more negative entropy and sharper S-curves for some systems, whereas binary systems having no minimum in the enthalpy interaction parameter λ show a smoother dependence of the partial entropy of MX on x(MeX2 ). This is schematically depicted in Figure 2.4 for three representative binary systems KCl–CaCl2 , KCl–MgCl2 , and KCl–CoCl2 .
∆Sparc(J/mol.K)
10
id.
5 0 –5
∆Hparc(kJ/mol)
id.
id.
KCl-MgCl2
KCl-CaCl2
KCl-CoCl2
0 –10 –20 –30 –40
0
10
x(MeCl2)
10
1
Figure 2.4. Schematic presentation of partial molar quantities in different univalent–divalent chloride systems.
26
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
2.1.3. Systems containing trivalent cations
Among the systems containing a trivalent cation, technologically most important are the cryolite-based melts used as electrolytes for aluminum production. Very important also are systems containing BF3 , which are used as electrolytes for boriding of steels and as heat-bearing medium in secondary circuits of nuclear power plants. To the melts containing a trivalent cation belong a great number of systems of alkali metal halide–rare earth metal halide systems. Lanthanide halides play an important role in the production of lanthanide metals by molten salt electrolysis and they are also used in a number of applications ranging from lighting to catalysis, through pyrochemical reprocessing of nuclear fuel. The above-mentioned three kinds of systems containing a trivalent cation will be described in the following chapters. 2.1.3.1. Structure of melts of the systems MF–AlF3 (M = Li, Na, K)
In spite of extensive investigations over six decades, the structure of these melts is still not sufficiently understood. The most accepted electrolytic dissociation scheme of molten cryolite is as follows: Na3 AlF6 = 3Na+ + AlF3− 6
(2.28)
By comparing the measured liquidus curve of cryolite with the theoretical one, Grjotheim et al. (1977) concluded that the AlF3− 6 anion undergoes further a partial thermal dissociation according to the scheme − − AlF3− 6 = AlF4 + 2F
(2.29)
with the equilibrium constant K=
aAlF− · aF2− 4
aAlF3− 6
=
4α 3 (1 − α)(1 + 2α)2
(2.30)
The degree of dissociation α was found to be 0.3. The scheme of the thermal dissociation was modified recently by Dewing (1986) in order to explain some discrepancies in the heat capacity of the NaF–AlF3 mixtures, and the dissociation constant was calculated on the basis of thermodynamic and spectroscopic data. Dewing proposed the following dissociation mechanism 2− − AlF3− 6 = AlF5 + F
(2.31)
− − AlF2− 5 = AlF4 + F
(2.32)
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
27
He also found that AlF2− 5 is the most abundant anionic species at x(AlF3 ) = 0.333 composition. The distribution of individual anions in the system NaF–AlF3 according to Dewing (1986) is shown in Figure 2.5. Recent Raman spectroscopic studies performed by Gilbert and Materne (1990) con2− − firmed the existence of the AlF3− 6 , AlF5 , and AlF4 anions in the melt. The existence 2− of the AlF5 anions in the liquid state was also postulated by Xiang and Kvande (1986) on the basis of liquidus temperature calculations. An attempt to confirm the presence of the AlF2− 5 anions in the MF–AlF3 (M = Li, Na, K) melts on the basis of vapor pressure measurements was also made by Zhou (1991). The study of structure and thermodynamics of the MF–AlF3 (M = Li, Na, K) melts using vapor pressure, solubility, and Raman spectroscopy measurements was conducted by Olsen (1996). From the Raman spectroscopic studies several conclusions could be drawn.
1.0 AlF4 − F−
Activity
0.8
0.6 AlF52−
0.4 AlF63−
0.2
0.0
NaF
0.1
0.2
0.3 x(AlF3)
0.4
0.5
0.6
Figure 2.5. Distribution of individual anions in the system NaF–AlF3 according to Dewing (1986).
28
• • •
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
all three systems have the principal group of bands located between 500 and 650 cm−1 , the bandwidths decrease when the size of the cation increases, the intensities of the bands change with composition.
A detailed interpretation of the spectra of the NaF–AlF3 and KF–AlF3 melts has shown that they are made up of three complex anionic species. This is most clearly seen in the KF–AlF3 system. The distribution of anions in the system KF–AlF3 according to the Raman spectroscopic and vapor pressure studies of Robert et al. (1997b) is shown in Figure 2.6. For Li-containing melts, it is not obvious from the spectra that there are three different bands. However, when the amount of LiF increases, there is a shift of frequency for the main band at around 570 cm−1 . It is assumed that in the system LiF–AlF3 , due to the strong polarizing ability of the Li+ cation, the AlF2− 5 anions are not present. More information on cryolite-based melts can be found in specialized books by Grjotheim et al. (1982) and Thonstad et al. (2001) devoted to the fundamentals of aluminum electrolysis.
1.0
F−
Activity
0.8
AlF4−
0.6 AlF52−
0.4
0.2 AlF63−
0.0
KF
0.1
0.2 0.3 ) x(AlF3
0.4
0.5
Figure 2.6. Distribution of individual anions in the system KF–AlF3 according to Robert et al. (1997b).
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
29
2.1.3.2. Systems containing boron trifluoride
Boron trifluoride, BF3 , is the source of boron in thermochemical and electrochemical boriding of steels and cutting tools. In the presence of alkali metal halides BF3 forms tetrafluoroborates, the stability of which depends on the alkali metal cation present. As a consequence of the high polarization ability of the Li+ cation, LiBF4 does not exist. NaBF4 is relatively stable only up to approximately 500◦ C, and KBF4 up to approximately 900◦ C. Above the mentioned temperatures, these compounds decompose to the respective alkali metal fluorides and BF3 (g). In exploitation of systems containing KBF4 , the appropriate choice of electrolyte composition prevents the formation of volatile compounds, as BF3 or BCl3 , which leads to undesirable emissions. Reactions of potassium tetrafluoroborate with molten alkali chlorides was investigated by Daneˇ k et al. (1976) using the cryoscopic method. The main aim of this work was to − study the stability of the BF− 4 anion in the presence of Cl anions and a different cationic environment. In molten alkali chlorides, the exchange reaction 4MCl + KBF4 ↔ 4MF + KBCl4
(2.33)
(M = Li, Na, K) may occur. In some cases, the originating tetrachloroborate anion may further decompose under the formation of gaseous BCl3 . It can be assumed that reaction (2.33) proceeds by successive exchange of fluorine in the BF− 4 anion for chlorine through − reaction steps BF3 Cl− , BF2 Cl− , and BFCl . Such a mechanism, however, cannot be 2 3 determined by means of the cryoscopic method. In Figures 2.7 – 2.9, the experimentally determined dependencies of the melting point depression of LiCl, NaCl, and KCl on composition, respectively, are compared with the theoretical course of liquidus curves for different values of the Storkenbeker’s correction factor kSt . From Figure 2.7, it follows that in molten LiCl, the BF− 4 anion undergoes exchange − reaction under the formation of BCl4 ions. At concentrations surpassing 0.05 mol · kg−1 KBF4 , the originating tetrachloroborate anions decompose owing to the polarization effect of the Li+ cations according to the equation − BCl− 4 = BCl3 + Cl
(2.34)
and gaseous BCl3 escapes from the melt. Consequently, the number of new particles in the melt decreases (kSt < 6) and the remaining melt corresponds to the ternary system LiF–LiCl–KCl. From the cryoscopic study in the system NaCl–KBF4 , it follows that in the concentration range of 0.02–0.25 mol · kg−1 KBF4 , the number of new particles is reduced from six to two, which indicates the change in the direction of the reaction (2.33) in this concentration range. At concentrations below 0.02 mol · kg−1 KBF4 , the reaction (2.33)
30
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
0 2
1 ∆T(K)
4
2 6
3
8
4
10
5
12
LiCl
0.05
0.10 0.15 m(KBF4)
0.20
0.25
Figure 2.7. LiCl melting point depression in the system LiCl–KBF4 . 1–kSt = 2; 4–kSt = 5; 5–kSt = 6.
2–kSt = 3;
3–kSt = 4;
0 2
1
∆T(K)
4 6 8
2 10 12
NaCl
0.05
0.10 0.15 m(KBF4)
0.20
0.25
Figure 2.8. NaCl melting point depression in the system NaCl–KBF4 . 1–kSt = 2;
2–kSt = 6.
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
31
0
∆T(K)
1
1
2 3 4
2
5 6 0.05
0.10 0.15 m(KBF4)
0.20
0.25
Figure 2.9. KCl melting point depression in the system KCl–KBF4 . 1–kSt = 1;
2–kSt = 2.
proceeds under the formation of BCl− 4 anions, however, owing to the low concentration of these anions and to the lower polarization ability of Na+ cations, compared with that of the Li+ , there are no conditions favoring the decomposition of the BCl− 4 anions. Above the concentration of 0.25 mol · kg−1 KBF4 , practically only tetrafluoroborate anions are present in the melt and the exchange reaction (2.33) does not proceed. In the system KCl–KBF4 , the Stortenbeker’s correction factor equals 1, which corresponds to the introduction of one new particle into the KCl melt with the addition of KBF4 . This indicates that the simple dissociation of KBF4 into K+ and BF− 4 is not accompanied by the exchange reaction (2.33). The probability of the exchange reaction (2.33) in the alkali metal chlorides could also be estimated using the thermodynamic calculation of the degree of conversion. For the sake of simplicity, let us assume that after introducing KBF4 into the MCl melt, only − the BF− 4 and BCl4 complex anions and no intermediate products will be present in the melt. If we add n mol of KBF4 into 1 mol of MCl (n 1) then, according to Temkin, xCl− ∼ = 1 and for the equilibrium constant of reaction (2.33), the simplified equation can be derived K=
xF4− xBCl− 4
4 x − xCl − BF 4
= 256n4
α5 1−α
(2.35)
32
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
where α is the degree of conversion of reaction (2.33). The values of the Gibbs energies and thus of the equilibrium constants in molten LiCl, NaCl, and KCl at the temperature of fusion of the respective alkali metal chlorides were calculated on the basis of the values of the Gibbs energy of the reactants presented in the JANAF Thermochemical tables (1971). Since the formation Gibbs energy of KBCl4 is not known, its value was estimated from the enthalpy of reaction KCl(s) + BCl3 (g) = KBCl4 (s)
(2.36)
determined by Titova and Rosolovkii (1971). The estimated formation Gibbs energy of liquid KBCl4 at temperatures of fusion of LiCl, NaCl, and KCl are supposed to be: f G0883 K ∼ = −800 kJ · mol−1 , f G01044 K ∼ = −783 kJ · mol−1 , f G01073 K ∼ = −1 −779 kJ·mol , respectively. The error in the estimation is approximately ± 10 kJ·mol−1 . For the exchange reaction (2.30) in the system LiCl–KBF4 , the value of the Gibbs energy is r G883 K ∼ = 35.2 kJ · mol−1 , which corresponds to the value of the equilibrium constant KLiCl ∼ = 8 × 10−3 . Hence, according to Eq. (2.35), the degree of conversion at −2 n < 10 is α ∼ = 1. This means that the exchange reaction (2.33) is completely shifted − to the right side. The BF− 4 anions are converted quantitatively into BCl4 , which is in agreement with the experimental findings. The Gibbs energy for the exchange reaction (2.33) in the system NaCl–KBF4 , r G1073 K ∼ = 189.4 kJ·mol−1 , corresponds to the equilibrium constant KNaCl ∼ = 2×10−9 . −3 −3 ∼ At n < 10 the degree of conversion is α = 1 and at n ≈ 10 (i.e. at m = 0.25 mol·kg−1 ) the value is α ∼ = 0.5. This indicates that with increasing the concentration of KBF4 , the equilibrium of the exchange reaction shifts from the right to the left side − and, besides BF− 4 , also BCl4 anions are present in the melt. In the system KCl–KBF4 , for the Gibbs energy and of the equilibrium constant of the exchange reaction, the values r G1043 K ∼ = 302 kJ · mol−1 and KKCl ∼ = 10−15 , respectively, were calculated. Thus, for n > 10−3 , the degree of conversion is α ∼ = 0. Hence, the calculation confirms the experimental results that the exchange reaction in this system does not take place. From the results of both the cryoscopic measurements and the thermodynamic calculation it follows that the stability of BF− 4 in molten alkali metal chlorides increases in the series LiCl < NaCl < KCl. In molten LiCl, the KBF4 anions are unstable and decompose under the formation of gaseous BCl3 . In molten NaCl, the exchange reaction between KBF4 and Cl− anions under the formation of KBCl4 proceeds only at very small concentrations of KBF4 , while no reaction occurs in molten KCl, where the BF− 4 anion is ◦ relatively stable up to approximately 900 C. The equilibrium constant of the exchange reaction (2.33) and the unknown value of the formation Gibbs energy of KBCl4 at 1073 K were calculated from the results of the cryoscopic measurement in the system NaCl–KBF4 . In this system, the equilibrium of the
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
33
exchange reaction, and thus also the depression in the melting point of NaCl, depends on the concentration of KBF4 . The equation for the melting point depression can be derived from the boundary conditions: Let for α = 0,
T = T1 = Kcr mB kSt, 1 = Kcr mB 2
and for α = 1,
T = T2 = Kcr mB kSt, 2 = Kcr mB 6
(2.37)
where Kcr is the cryoscopic constant of NaCl and mB is the molality of KBF4 added. Omitting again the intermediate products (BF3 Cl− , etc.), the number of new particles can be expressed as kSt = 1 + (1 − α) + α + 4α = 2 + 4α
(2.38)
The dependence of the melting point depression on the conversion degree can then be described by the equation T = Kcr mB (2 + 4α)
(2.39)
After rearranging and substituting, we get α=
T − Kcr mB 2 T − Kcr mB 2 T − T1 = = Kcr mB 4 Kcr mB 6 − Kcr mB 2 T2 − T1
(2.40)
Using values of α calculated in this way and by means of Eq. (2.35), the value of the equilibrium constant for any arbitrary concentration of KBF4 can be calculated. The results of this calculation are shown in Figure 2.10. The arithmetical mean of the values of the equilibrium constants is K = 7 × 10−7 , which corresponds to the reaction Gibbs energy r G1073 K ∼ = 188 ± 10 kJ·mol−1 . For the formation Gibbs energy of liquid KBCl4 , the value f G01073K ∼ = −769 ± 10 kJ · mol−1 was then calculated, which is in very good agreement with the estimated value of −779 kJ · mol−1 . As a possible electrolyte for electrochemical boriding of steels and cutting tools, the molten system KF−KCl−KBF4 studied by Daneˇ k and Matiašovský (1977) and Matiašovský et al. (1978), could be used. The phase diagrams of the boundary binary system KF–KBF4 have been studied by Barton et al. (1971) and Daneˇ k et al. (1976), while the binary system KCl–KBF4 was studied by Samsonov et al. (1959) and Daneˇ k et al. (1976). It was found that both the binary systems are simple eutectic. In the phase diagram of the system KCl–KBF4 , determined by Samsonov et al. (1959), the formation of the congruently melting compound 11KBF4 ·KCl was suggested. However, the existence of this compound was not confirmed in the later investigations made by Barton et al. (1971) and Daneˇ k et al. (1976).
34
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
1.0 α
0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 –4 10
10–2 10–3 n(KBF4)
10–1
Figure 2.10. Dependence of the degree of conversion on the content of KBF4 in the system NaCl–KBF4 .
The phase diagram of the ternary system KF−KCl−KBF4 was measured by Patarák and Daneˇ k (1992). The system is simple eutectic with the coordinates of the eutectic point of 19.2 mole % KF, l8.4 mole % KCl, 61.4 mole % KBF4 , and the temperature of eutectic crystallization of 422◦ C. Among the physico-chemical properties, the density of the ternary system KF−KCl−KBF4 was measured by Chrenková and Daneˇ k (1991), the surface tension by Lubyová et al. (1997), the electrical conductivity by Chrenková et al. (1991b), and the viscosity by Daneˇ k and Nguyen (1995). From the results of the physico-chemical analysis, it follows that deviations from the ideal behavior were observed in all the boundary binaries as well as in the ternary system. With regard to the fact that the investigated system has a common cation, the observed deviations from the ideal behavior have to be a consequence of the anionic interaction only. The observed interaction of components could be of different origin. A different character of interaction has to be considered in the boundary binaries KF–KBF4 and KCl–KBF4 . In the pure KBF4 melt the BF− 4 tetrahedrons tend to link, forming relatively weak B–F–B bonds. The strength of this bond depends considerably on temperature. Introducing F− ions into the KBF4 melt by addition of KF, the B–F–B bridges break off, which lowers the viscosity and leads to negative deviation from the ideal behavior in
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
35
the KF–KBF4 system. Besides, the mixing of small anions F− with relatively large BF− 4 takes place. In systems of this type, the deviation from additivity is proportional to the fractional difference in the radii of different anions. Therefore a relatively large deviation from ideality may be expected, which was confirmed by all measured physico-chemical properties. An opposite interaction effect takes place in the system KCl–KBF4 where the mixing of − two relatively large and polarizable anions BF− 4 and Cl occurs. As was found by Sangster and Pelton (1987), no important deviations from additivity were found in systems of alkali metal chlorides, bromides, and iodides with a common cation. Also, such behavior was confirmed by Chrenková and Daneˇ k (1990) in the system KCl–KBF4 by density, conductivity, and viscosity measurements. By introducing Cl− ions into the KBF4 melt, the substitution of fluoride atoms in the BF− 4 tetrahedrons by chloride takes place according to the general scheme − − − BF− 4 + nCl ⇔ [BF4−n Cln ] + nF
(2.41)
and [BF4−n Cln ]− mixed anions are probably present. Consequently, the lower stability of the B−Cl−B bridges and the lower concentration of the B−F−B lead to negative deviation of the properties in the KCl−KBF4 system. This explanation is supported also by the asymmetric course of the excess viscosity curve, which is due to the reaction (2.41) shifted to the right side in the region of high concentration of KBF4 . The negative deviations of the properties, found in the ternary system KF–KCl–KBF4 , have obviously the same origin as described for the boundary binary systems. As it follows from the course of the excess molar Gibbs energy of mixing (Figure 2.11), the excess molar volume (Figure 2.12), the excess molar conductivity (Figure 2.13), and the excess viscosity (Figure 2.14) of the system KF–KCl–KBF4 , the maximum interaction effect is localized near the KF–KBF4 boundary. The anionic interaction according to the reaction (2.41) was confirmed by means of infrared spectroscopy by Daneˇ k et al. (1997a). The IR spectra of KBF4 and of the quenched molten KBF4 −KCl (1:1 molar ratio) mixture are shown in Figure 2.15. With the exception of the 600–900 cm−1 region, the mid infrared spectra of both samples are almost identical. In agreement with the earlier study of the alkali metal tetrafluoroborates by Bates and Quist (1975), common vibrations can be assigned to crystalline KBF4 . Significant differences have been observed only in the 600–900 cm−1 region. It is obvious that beside the ν(1) vibration corresponding to KBF4 , the quenched molten KBF4 −KCl mixture produces two additional peaks at 760 and 796 cm−1 with a shoulder at 770 cm−1 . It may be assumed that these peaks arise due to the different B–F and B–Cl valence vibrations in the anions [BF4−n Cln ]− . The substitution of the fluorine atom by chlorine in the coordination sphere of the BF− 4 anion in the molten KF–KCl–KBF4 mixtures was thus confirmed. However, the type of the mixed anion was determined neither by physico-chemical analysis nor by spectroscopic methods.
36
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
KBF4 1
0.8
0.4
0.6
X(
) F4
KB
-450
X(
KF )
0.2
0.4
0.6 300
-300
150
0.8
0.2
0 -150
150
0
0 KF
0.2
0.6
0.4
1 KCl
0.8
X(KCl)
Figure 2.11. Excess Gibbs energy of mixing of the system KF–KCl–KBF4 . Values are in J · mol−1 .
KBF4 1
0.8
0.4
0.4
0.6
X(
X(
0.6 1.2
1 0.8
0.4
0.4
0.6
F 4)
KB
KF )
0.2
0.2
0.8 0.2
0 KF
0.2
0.4
0.6
X(KCl)
0.8
1 KCl
Figure 2.12. Excess molar volume of the system KF–KCl–KBF4 at 1100 K. Values are in cm3 · mol−1 .
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
37
KBF4 1
0.8
-12
-9
-6
-3
0.6
0.4
F 4)
X(
-15
KB
KF
0.6
0.4
X(
)
0.2
0.2
0.8 -3
0 KF
0.2
0.6
0.4
0.8
1 KCl
X(KCl)
Figure 2.13. Excess molar conductivity of the system KF–KCl–KBF4 at 1100 K. Values are in S · m2 /mol.
KBF4 1
0.8
0.4
0.6
X(
F 4) KB
X(
KF
)
0.2
0.4
0.6 -0.2
0.8
0.2
-0.15 -0.1
-0.1
-0.05
0 KF
0.2
0.4
0.6 X(KCl)
0.8
-0.05
1 KCl
Figure 2.14. Excess viscosity of the system KF–KCl–KBF4 at 1100 K. Values are in mPa · s.
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
Transmittance (a.u.)
38
600
700
v (cm−1)
800
900
Figure 2.15. IR spectra of KBF4 and of the quenched molten KBF4 –KCl (1:1 molar ratio) mixture.
2.1.3.3. Systems containing halides of rare earth metals
Lanthanide halides are used in a number of applications ranging from lighting to catalysis, through pyrochemical reprocessing of nuclear fuel. However, many of these industrial processes are still under development due to relatively little knowledge of the properties and the behavior of systems used. Different experimental methods have been used in order to fully characterize pure compounds and binary systems, such as DTA, X-ray, electrochemical techniques, etc., the latter making it possible to identify the nature of phase transitions that take place in the solid state. They have enabled distinguishing between the formation of compounds in the solid state (reconstructive phase transition) and their structural transition (nonreconstructive phase transition). Several reports have been published on the structure of rare earth chlorides studied by Mochinaga et al. (1991a) and Iwadate et al. (1994) using X-ray diffraction, by Saboungi et al. (1991) using neutron diffraction, and by Papatheodorou (1975, 1977) and Matsuoka et al. (1993) using Raman spectroscopy. These investigations revealed that the octahedral complex anion LnCl3− 6 and a loose disordered network of corner- or edge-sharing octahedral units exist in the melt. Moreover, the measurements of conductivity helped to study the dynamics of molten salts, reflecting the average dynamic structure. The molar conductivity of several rare earth chlorides was measured by Iwadate et al. (1986), Mochinaga et al. (1991b, 1993), and Fukushima et al. (1991), and the results suggested that the existence of dimmers or more polymeric complex anions might be presumed in
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
39
these melts. The structure of molten ErCl3 , Na3 ErCl6 , and K3 ErCl6 was investigated by Iwadate et al. (1993, 1994) and the existence of octahedral complex ions ErCl3− 6 was confirmed. Some clustering of distorted edge-sharing octahedrons was expected. The temperatures, enthalpies of phase transitions, and heat capacities of pure lanthanide chlorides (LaCl3 , CeCl3 , PrCl3 , NdCl3 , GdCl3 , DyCl3 , ErCl3 , and TmCl3 ) and of the M3 LnCl6 compounds (Ln = La, Ce, Pr, Nd; M = K, Rb, Cs) were determined by Gaune-Escard et al. (1994a). As far as thermodynamics is concerned, much attention has been paid to the M3 LnCl6 stoichiometric compounds that exist in most of the LnCl3 –MCl systems and have a more extended stability range than those of a different stoichiometry. Gaune-Escard and Rycerz (2003) determined the temperatures and enthalpies of the solid–solid phase transition, as well as of fusion of M3 LnCl6 compounds (Ln = La, Ce, Pr, Nd, Tb; M = K, Rb, Cs). They are presented in Table 2.7, together with the data of the enthalpy of formation taken from the literature. From the table, it follows that, the smaller the ionic lanthanide radius, the lower the formation temperature and the higher the melting temperature. This means that these compounds are not stable at low temperatures, which is in agreement with the results of thermochemical calculation made by Seiffert (2002). They originate already at higher temperatures from M2 LnCl5 and MCl. During cooling, they decompose back to the above-mentioned components. At 0 K they can exist only as a metastable phase. From the values given in Table 2.7 it may be concluded that the formation of the M3 LnCl6 compounds is associated with large enthalpy changes (45–55 kJ · mol−1 ) Table 2.7. Temperatures of formation and fusion of congruently melting M3 LnCl6 compounds Compound
Tform (K)
δform H (kJ/mol)
Tfus (K)
δfus H (kJ/mol)
K2 LaCl5 K3 CeCl6 K3 PrCl6 K3 NdCl6 K3 TbCl6
– 811 768 724 –
– 55.4 52.6 46.3 –
906 908 944 973 1049
78.1 39.1 48.9 48.0 53.2
Rb3 LaCl6 Rb3 CeCl6 Rb3 PrCl6 Rb3 NdCl6 Rb3 TbCl6
725 651 598 547 –
48.4 – – – –
978 1016 1037 1060 1049
50.2 52.4 54.0 58.8 –
Cs3 LaCl6 Cs3 CeCl6 Cs3 PrCl6 Cs3 NdCl6 Cs3 TbCl6
– – – – –
1055 1078 1093 1103 1153
1055 1078 1093 1103 1153
58.7 67.4 61.1 66.4 –
40
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
due to the so-called “reconstructive” phase transition, while their solid–solid transformation corresponds to more modest enthalpies of 7–8 kJ · mol−1 due to the structural (“non reconstructive”) phase transition. The linear dependence of both Tform and Tfus on lanthanide ionic radius allows estimation of the formation and fusion temperatures of the other K3 LnCl6 compounds. However, it should be stressed that the temperatures reported in the literature as formation temperatures do not always correspond to the formation of the compound. For the Rb3 CeCl6 , Rb3 PrCl6 , and Rb3 NdCl6 compounds, an additional thermal effect could be observed at significantly lower temperatures. This effect may arise most probably from the transition of the metastable phase at low temperature. From among the Cs3 LnCl6 compounds, only Cs3 LaCl6 , Cs3 CeCl6 , and Cs3 PrCl6 do exist at temperatures above 0 K. They originate from Cs2 LnCl5 and CsCl at 462, 283, and 143 K. Due to the low enthalpies of formation, decomposition does not occur upon cooling and metastable phases are formed. All Cs3 LnCl6 compounds undergo a structural phase transition at a nearly identical temperature of about 670–680 K. K3 CeCl6 , K3 PrCl6 , K3 NdCl6 , and Rb3 LaCl6 originate at higher temperatures and the formation of these compounds corresponds to a “reconstructive” phase transition. The crystal structure of these compounds is of the elpasolite-type and no other structural phase transition takes place before melting. For the other compounds, e.g. those that originate at lower temperatures (e.g. K3 TbCl6 , Rb3 PrCl6 , Rb3 NdCl6 , Rb3 TbCl6 , and all Cs3 LnCl6 ) and before melting, they undergo a solid–solid transformation, two different crystal structures are characterized: low-temperature monoclinic Cs3 BiCl6 -type and the high-temperature cubic elpasolite-type. In the electrical conductivity versus temperature plot of the first group of compounds, a significant (two orders of magnitude) conductivity jump is observed at the same temperature as determined for the “reconstructive” phase transition. A second, but smaller jump happens approximately at an identical temperature for all compounds (835–845 K). This effect is not observed in the DSC thermograms. For the second group of compounds formed at lower temperature, two conductivity regimes can be observed. The first conductivity break appears at a different temperature for each compound, has a smaller magnitude, and also spreads over a 40–50 K temperature range. Mutual solubility of molten lanthanide chlorides and alkali chlorides has been recently investigated intensively by Seifert et al. (1985–1988, 1990, 1991, 1993), Thiel and Seifert (1988), Mitra and Seifert (1995), Roffe and Seifert (1997), and Zheng and Seifert (1998). Numerous investigations of the composition and thermochemistry of lanthanide chlorides and bromides and their binary systems with the alkali halides have been carried out by Papatheodorou (1974a,b), Gaune-Escard et al. (1994a,b, 1995, 1996a,b), Takagi et al. (1994), and Rycerz and Gaune-Escard (1998).
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
41
Several investigations of the enthalpy of mixing of liquid rare earth halides with alkali metal halides were carried out. The sytems NdC13 –MCI (M is Na, K, Rb, Cs), NdBr3 –MBr (M = Li, Na, K, Rb, Cs), NdI3 –MI (M = Li, Na, K, Cs), LaCl3 – MCl (M = Li, Na, K, Rb, Cs), and TbCI3 –MCI (M = Li, Na, K, Rb, Cs), the NdF3 –KF, PrCI3 –NaCI, PrCI3 –KCI, DyCI3 –NaCI, DyC13 –KCl, LaCl3 –CaCl2 , PrCI3 – CaCl2 , NdCl3 –CaCl2 , and Ln(1)Cl3 –Ln(2)Cl3 binaries were studied by Hatem and Gaune-Escard (1993), Gaune-Escard et al. (1994a,b, 1996c), Gaune-Escard and Rycerz (1997), and Rycerz and Gaune-Escard (2002). The LnCl3 –MCl binary systems have relatively simple phase diagrams for the light alkali metal chlorides (LiCl and NaCl), while those including KCl, RbCl, and CsCl exhibit several compounds of stoichiometry M3 LnCl6 , M2 LnCl5 , and MLn2 Cl7 . All the M3 LnCl6 compounds melt congruently, whereas M2 LnCl5 and MLn2 Cl7 can melt congruently or decompose peritectically. Congruently melting MLnCl5 compounds exist only in the systems with lanthanum and cerium chlorides, while M2 Ln2 Cl7 melt congruently in the sequence K < Rb < Cs at increasing lanthanide atomic numbers, i.e. at decreasing lanthanide ionic radii. Accordingly, the congruently melting CsLn2 Cl7 exist in all chloride systems starting from cerium chloride, the RbLn2 Cl7 starting from samarium chloride and KLn2 Cl7 from europium chloride. The LaCl3 –KCl system forms an exception to the previous description, since it includes a single congruently melting compound, K2 LaCl5 .
2.1.4. Systems containing tetravalent cations
The most important representatives of tetravalent elements are titanium and zirconium because of their uses as advanced construction materials in different technologies. Systems of titanium and zirconium fluorides and chlorides with alkali metal fluorides and chlorides, respectively, can be found in the Phase Equilibria Diagrams Database (1993). A number of compounds with various stoichiometry are formed in these systems, depending on the size of the titanium and zirconium cation and the polarization ability of the alkali metal. Some of these compounds are very stable and melt congruently even at relatively high temperatures. On the other hand, some compounds melt incongruently and their existence is limited to a certain temperature range. In the systems LiF–TiF4 and NaF–TiF4 there are no compounds present, while in the systems MF–TiF4 (M = K, Rb, Cs), only two congruently melting M3 TiF7 and M2 TiF6 compounds are formed. In the systems LiCl–TiCl4 , NaCl–TiCl4 , and RbCl–TiCl4 , no compounds are formed, while in the systems KCl–TiCl4 and CsCl–TiCl4 , the congruently melting compounds K2 TiCl6 and Cs2 TiCl6 originate respectively. The systems MF–ZrF4 (M = Li, Na, K, Rb, and Cs) are very abundant in compounds. In all MF–ZrF4 systems, the congruently melting M3 ZrF7 and the incongruently melting M2 ZrF6 compounds originate. In the systems MF–ZrF4 (M = K, Rb, and Cs), there
42
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
exist the congruently melting compounds MZrF5 . Besides these, the following congruently melting Rb5 Zr4 F19 and incongruently melting Li4 ZrF8 , M5 Zr2 F13 (M = Na, K), M3 Zr2 F11 (M = Na, K), M3 Zr4 F19 (M = Li, Na), MZr2 F9 (M = Na, Rb), and LiZr4 F17 compounds are formed. In the last group of the zirconium tetrachloride containing systems, the congruently melting NaZrCl6 , M2 ZrCl6 (M = K, Cs), Na7 Zr6 Cl31 and the incongruently melting Na3 ZrCl7 and Na3 Zr4 Cl19 compounds are present. However, among all of the above mentioned compounds, the technologically most important are the K2 TiF6 and K2 ZrF6 , because of their frequent use in the electrochemical deposition of titanium and zirconium and the electrochemical synthesis of titanium and zirconium diborides. Titanium diboride exhibits a high melting point, electronic conductivity, wetability by molten aluminum, and a resistance towards chemical attack of aluminum and molten fluorides. Due to these properties, TiB2 is considered to be the most promising material for inert cathodes in aluminum electrolysis. Also zirconium diboride belongs to the category of promising constructive materials due to its favorable properties. Different methods used to prepare titanium diboride have been reviewed by Samsonov et al. (1975). At present, it is mainly produced as a powder by thermochemical reduction of boron and titanium oxides followed by hot pressing and sintering to process the final product. The less costly alternative appears to be to coat suitable substrate materials with TiB2 or TiB2 -based composites by hot pressing, plasma spraying, chemical vapor deposition, etc. The promising alternative for TiB2 preparation is the high-temperature electrochemical synthesis in molten salts. The electrolytes employed can essentially be divided into two groups according to the type of electro-active components. (a)
(b)
Molten systems containing oxygen-containing compounds of titanium and boron, e.g. Me2 B4 O7 , MeBO2 , B2 O3 , TiO2 , Me2 TiO3 (where Me denotes alkali metal): To improve the physico-chemical properties of the electrolyte, alkali metal halides, alkali earth metal oxides, or cryolite are added to the melt. In some cases, natural minerals such as ilmenite or rutile replace titanium oxide. Systems containing alkali metal fluoroborates and alkali metal fluorotitanates: The electro-active components are dissolved in a supporting electrolyte, which generally consists of a mixture of alkali metal halides. Alkali chlorides, in comparison to fluorides, exhibit some obvious advantages like price, low corrosion of construction materials and easy separation of the product from the cathodic deposit containing solidified electrolyte.
According to Matiašovský et al. (1988), very suitable electrolytes in the electrochemical synthesis of TiB2 are the melts of the quaternary system KF−KCl−KBF4 −K2 TiF6 ,
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
43
especially when coherent coatings on metallic bases have to be prepared. Besides the mentioned application, the molten system KF−KCl−K2 TiF6 is a promising electrolyte for the deposition of titanium. The knowledge of the structure of these electrolytes is needed for understanding the mechanism of the electrochemical process. The interaction of components and the chemical reactions taking place in the melt affect the ionic composition, determining the kind of the electro-active species. A suitable choice of the electrolyte composition may suppress the formation of volatile compounds, which leads to undesirable exhalation and lowers the efficiency of the process. One of the crucial problems in the chemistry of potassium hexafluorotitanate, K2 TiF6 , is its stability in the environment of different alkali metal fluorides and/or chlorides, since these compounds are usually used as complementary electrolyte components. The cryoscopic measurements in a system containing alkali metal halides and K2 TiF6 make it possible to determine the dissociation scheme of K2 TiF6 , or other reactions taking place between alkali metal halides and K2 TiF6 . The study of some systems of this type can be found in the literature. Janz et al. (1958) determined the freezing point depression in the eutectic mixture LiCl–KCl effected by the addition of M2 TiF6 (M = Li, Na, K) in the concentration range 0.008–0.066 m, and on the basis of the experimentally measured values proposed the following dissociation scheme M2 TiF6 = TiF4 + 2M+ + 2F−
(2.42)
Petit and Bourlange (1953) carried out cryoscopic measurements in the system NaCl–K2 TiF6 , but their conclusions were not unambiguous. They assumed that in the above system TiF4 , formed by dissociation of K2 TiF6 , reacts with chloride anions according to the equation TiF4 + 4Cl− = TiCl4 + 4F−
(2.43)
The behavior of K2 TiF6 in the alkali metal halides LiF, NaF, LiCl, NaCl, KCl, and in the LiCl–KCl and LiF–LiCl eutectic mixtures was studied using the cryoscopic method by Daneˇ k et al. (1975). The experimentally determined dependency of the melting point depression on molality and molar fraction of K2 TiF6 , in the proximity of the melting point of the above mentioned solvents were compared with the liquidus curves calculated according to the equation TA = KAcr mB r
(2.44)
where TA is the melting point depression of substance A, KAcr is the cryoscopic constant of substance A, mB is the molality of component B, and r is the correction factor for
44
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
component B in the system A–B introduced by Stortenbeker (1892) and is numerically equal to the number of new (foreign) particles, which are introduced into substance A by addition of one molecule of substance B. The necessary thermodynamical data were taken from JANAF Thermochemical Tables (1971) and from Janz (1967). From the measurements, it follows that in molten LiF and NaF, the correction factor r equals 3, which corresponds to the formation of three new particles: two K+ cations and one Ti-containing particle, most probably in the form of a complex anion (e.g. TiF2− 6 , − 3− TiF5 , or TiF7 ). The existence of the last two ionic species was discussed by Delimarskii and Chernov (1966), but the choice between them cannot be made by the cryoscopic method. In molten LiCl, NaCl, and KCl, the correction factor r was found to be 9, 5, and 3, respectively. Hence it follows that in molten sodium and potassium chloride, K2 TiF6 dissociates most probably according to the scheme K2 TiF6 = 2K + + 2F− + TiF4
(2.45)
As in the previous case, the cryoscopic method does not enable to determine whether Ti is bound in a complex anion (e.g. in TiF4 Cl2− 2 as proposed by Janz et al. (1958)) and, therefore, it is written as TiF4 . However, from the experimental results it can be concluded that in molten NaCl and KCl, no substitution reaction occurs between TiF4 and Cl− anions. On the other hand, the value of the correction factor in molten LiCl (r = 9) indicates that in this solvent titanium fluoride reacts with the chloride ions, thus increasing the number of new particles to 9, and the reaction can be interpreted by the dissociation scheme K2 TiF6 + 4Cl− = 2K + + 6F− + TiCl4
(2.46)
2− There is no evaporation of TiF4 since complex anions TiCl− 5 or TiCl6 are formed in the melt. It can be concluded that the substitution reaction occurs only in molten LiCl. This was also confirmed by the cryoscopic measurement in the LiCl–KCl eutectic mixture, where the value of the correction factor r indicates the formation of 7 new particles. This can be explained only by the dissociation of K2 TiF6 and the subsequent substitution of fluorine in TiF4 by chlorine. The results of cryoscopic measurement in the LiCl–KCl eutectic mixture obtained by Daneˇ k et al. (1975) do not agree with the data presented by Janz et al. (1958), who found only 3 new particles. However, the cryoscopy in eutectic mixtures might be the matter of discussion (see Section 3.3.2.3). The possibility of the substitution of fluorine atoms in TiF4 by the chlorine was confirmed by Daneˇ k et al (1975) and also by thermodynamic calculation of the degree of
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
45
TiF4 + 4MCl = TiCl4 + 4MF
(2.47)
conversion of the reaction
where M = Li, Na, and K. From the results of calculation, it follows that in molten LiCl for x(K2 TiF6 ) < 10−2 , the degree of conversion is α ∼ = 1, which indicates that the TiF4 is completely converted into TiCl4 . For NaCl as a solvent for x(K2 TiF6 ) > 10−3 the conversion degree is α ∼ = 0, which means that the substitution reaction in molten NaCl practically does not take place. In molten KCl, for x(K2 TiF6 ) > 10−3 is α ∼ = 0. Hence it follows that in this case, the substitution reaction also does not occur. However, if the above calculation is applied for a more concentrated solution, the picture is entirely different. In the case of LiCl, the degree of conversion α ∼ = 0.1 at 9 mole % K2 TiF6 can be expected. Hence it can be assumed that in the system LiF–LiCl–K2 TiF6 , at a sufficiently high concentration of fluoride ions, the equilibrium of reaction (2.47) is shifted completely to the left. The cryoscopic measurement in the eutectic mixture LiF–LiCl fully confirmed the above-mentioned assumption. The correction factor was found to be r = 3, indicating the formation of three new particles due to the dissociation of K2 TiF6 . This means that in the LiF–LiCl eutectic mixture the substitution reaction does not take place. Chrenková et al. (1998) studied the structure or ionic composition of the melts of the system KF−KCl−KBF4 −K2 TiF6 based on the measurements of phase equilibria, density and viscosity and using complex thermodynamic and physico-chemical analysis. From the results of the physico-chemical analysis, it follows that deviations from the ideal behavior were observed in all boundary binary, ternary, as well as in the quaternary systems. With regard to the fact that the investigated system has a common cation, the observed deviations from the ideal behavior have to be a consequence of the anionic interaction only. The phase equilibria and volume properties of the systems KF–K2 TiF6 and KCl– K2 TiF6 were studied in detail by Daneˇ k and Matiašovský (1989). They found that in these binary systems, the compounds K3 TiF7 and K3 TiF6 Cl are formed according to the reactions K2 TiF6 (l) + KF = K3 TiF7 (l) (2.48)
r G01100 K = 0.963 kJ · mol−1 K2 TiF6 (l) + KCl(l) = K3 TiF6 Cl(l) r G1100 K = 0.587 kJ · mol 0
−1
(2.49)
The formation of K3 TiF7 and K3 TiF6 Cl does not substantially affect the volume properties. This indicates that, either these compounds dissociate in the melt to a
46
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
3− 3− considerable degree, or the volumes of the anions TiF2− are 6 , TiF7 , and TiF6 Cl fairly similar. However, the formation of both the compounds affects the course of the volume properties differently. While the formation of K3 TiF7 is connected with small volume expansion, the formation of K3 TiF6 Cl is connected with substantially higher volume contraction. The difference probably agrees with different stereochemistry of both complex anions and with its relations to the other anions present. However, the formation of K3 TiF7 and K3 TiF6 Cl also takes place in the quaternary system KF–KCl–KBF4 –K2 TiF6 . The thermodynamic analysis of the phase equilibrium and of the volume properties of the systems KF–K2 TiF6 and KCl–K2 TiF6 , were used for the calculation of the dissociation degree of the K3 TiF7 and K3 TiF6 Cl compounds. The dissociation degree of K3 TiF6 calculated on the basis of the experimentally determined phase diagram is α0 = 0.64, which agrees very well with the values obtained on the basis of the density data, α0 (1000 K) = 0.6 and α0 (1100 K) = 0.7. The corresponding data for K3 TiF6 Cl are α0 = 0.78 from the phase equilibria, and α0 (1000 K) = 0.72 and α0 (1100 K) = 0.81 from the density data. In the binary system KBF4 −K2 TiF6 , at 1100 K the partial molar volume of K2 TiF6 for x(KBF4 ) → 1 is V(K2 TiF6 ) = 129.69 cm3 · mol−1 . This value is higher than the molar volume of pure K2 TiF6 (V 0 = 114.62 cm3 · mol−1 ), which indicates the formation of larger complex ions, e.g. TiF2− 7 . The partial molar volume of KBF4 for x(K2 TiF6 ) → 1 is V(KBF4 ) = 68.08 cm3 · mol−1 . This value is lower than the molar volume of pure KBF4 (V 0 = 75.12 cm3 · mol−1 ). The reason for this lowering is the decomposition of KBF4 and escape of gaseous BF3 from the melt, which was actually observed. On the basis of the given findings, the following chemical reaction may be considered to take place in the binary system KBF4 –K2 TiF6
KBF4 (l) + K2 TiF6 (l) = K3 TiF7 (l) + BF3 (g) 0 −1 r G1100 K = 10.71 kJ · mol
(2.50)
The relatively low positive value of Gibbs energy of the reaction, as well as the observed escape of gaseous BF3 , indicates that the reaction (2.50) probably takes place in the melt. Reaction (2.50) also takes place obviously in the quaternary system KF–KCl–KBF4 –K2 TiF6 . In the quaternary system KF–KCl–KBF4 –K2 TiF6 , the following chemical reaction is probable KCl(l) + 2K2 TiF6 (l) + KBF4 (l) = K3 Ti7 F(l) + K3 TiF6 Cl(l) + BF3 (g) r G1100 K 0 = 12.05 kJ · mol−1
(2.51)
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
47
The originating additive compounds dissociate thermally according to reactions (2.48) and (2.49). The Gibbs energies of reactions (2.50) and (2.51) were calculated on the basis of the Gibbs energies of dissociations of K3 TiF7 and K3 TiF6 Cl, as well as of the Gibbs energies of formations of KF, KCl, KBF4 , and BF3 taken from JANAF Thermochemical Tables (1971). From the physico-chemical properties of the melts of the system KF–KCl– KBF4 −K2 TiF6 , it follows that the most characteristic feature of these melts is the 3− with formation of the thermodynamically less stable ionic species TiF3− 7 and TiF6 Cl lowered symmetry of the coordination sphere in the melt. The presence of these anions in the melt facilitates most probably the electro-reduction of titanium and thus the formation of titanium diboride on the cathode.
2.1.5. Systems containing pentavalent cations
Among the pentavalent elements, the most important are niobium and tantalum. Niobium is an excellent material for surface treatment of steel materials for chemical industry due to its high hardness and corrosion-resistance in wet acidic conditions. Nowadays, niobium is also used for the preparation of superconductor tapes and it is used in other branches of industry, for instance in nuclear technology and metallurgy. Tantalum is also of similar importance. For these applications, it is necessary to prepare high purity metal. Molten salt electrolysis, as an alternative process to classical thermal reduction, provides niobium and tantalum with required quality. In order to optimize these processes, it is necessary to know details of both complex formation and redox chemistry of the species present in the melts. The possibility of obtaining metallic niobium and tantalum coatings was demonstrated in fluoride, chloride, as well as in mixed fluoride–chloride electrolytes. K2 NbF7 and K2 TaF7 are usually the electrolyte components, which serve as niobium and tantalum source, respectively. From the number of systems used as electrolytes for niobium deposition, the systems LiF–KF–K2 NbF7 and LiF–NaF–K2 NbF7 seem to be the most promising. Due to the high hygroscopic behavior of KF, the alternative NaF was used in the second system. Also from the theoretical point of view, the above mentioned systems are interesting as they are associated with the formation of the congruently melting compound K3 NbF8 , affecting the ionic composition of the melt and thus possibly influencing the mechanism of the electrochemical process on the electrode surface. In a number of papers, the measurement of different thermodynamic and transport properties of the LiF−KF−K2 NbF7 and LiF−NaF−K2 NbF7 melts was performed with the goal to clarify their structure, i.e. the ionic composition. For the study of the electrolyte structure, physico-chemical analysis has been used. The phase diagram of the system LiF−KF−K2 NbF7 was measured by Chrenková et al. (1999), the density by Chrenková et al. (2000), surface tension by Nguyen and
48
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
(a)
K2NbF7
(b)
F) 7
2 Nb
x(K
2 Nb
) F7 Nb
2
x(K
x(K
F) 7
0.8
0.8
0.6
0.6 −4
0.4
−3
0. 4
−2
0.2
0.2 −1
LiF
KF
Figure 2.16. Phase diagram ((a), values in ◦ C) and excess molar volume at 1100 K ((b), values in cm3 · mol−1 ) of the system LiF–KF–K2 NbF7 according to Chrenková et al. (1999, 2000).
Daneˇ k (2000b), and viscosity by Nguyen and Daneˇ k (2000c). The X-ray phase analysis and IR spectroscopy measurements of quenched melts were carried out by Van et al. (2000). To draw conclusions on the electrolyte structure from the concentration dependency of the particular property, the following thermodynamic, statistical, and material balance calculations were also used. In Figure 2.16, the phase diagram (a) and the excess molar volume (b) of the system LiF−KF−K2 NbF7 are shown for illustration. The electrochemical behavior of the melts of these systems was studied in detail by Van et al. (1999a,b) and described in a short overview by Daneˇ k et al. (2000a). From the complex physico-chemical analysis of the system LiF–KF–K2 NbF7 , it follows that the behavior and properties of the melts are affected by the formation of the congruently melting compound K3 NbF8 . Regarding the presence of the anion [NbF8 ]3− in the molten state the system behavior is not far from the ideal. The congruently melting compound K3 NbF8 was found to be not quite stable. At melting, it undergoes a partial thermal dissociation according to the scheme α KF + K2 NbF7 K3 NbF8 ←→
(2.52)
The degree of thermal dissociation of K3 NbF8 calculated from the phase diagram was found to be α0 = 0.44. A similar value also was calculated from the density measurements. Also, the formation of K3 NbF8 in the ternary system was confirmed by all the physico-chemical parameters. The system LiF–NaF–K2 NbF7 is the planar section of the quaternary reciprocal system Li2+ , Na2+ , K2+ // F− , [NbF7 ]2− . Both boundary binary systems LiF–K2 NbF7 and
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
49
NaF–K2 NbF7 form stable diagonals of the appropriate quaternary reciprocal systems. Van and Daneˇ k (2001) calculated the Gibbs energy of formation of K2 NbF7 on the basis of electrochemical measurements in the LiF–NaF–K2 NbF7 melts. However, the Gibbs energies of formation of other fluoroniobates, Li2 NbF7 and Na2 NbF7 , are not known so far. Thus the Gibbs energies of reactions of both ternary reciprocal systems could not be calculated. The phase diagram of the ternary system LiF–NaF–K2 NbF7 was studied by Chrenková et al. (2003a) using the thermal analysis and the subsequent coupled analysis of thermodynamic and equilibrium phase diagram data. The density was measured by Chrenková et al. (2005), the surface tension by Kubíková et al. (2003), and the viscosity by Cibulková et al. (2003). Figure 2.17 shows the phase diagram (a) and the excess molar volume (b) of the system LiF–NaF–K2 NbF7 for illustration. The X-ray phase analysis and the IR spectroscopy measurement were performed by Bocˇ a et al. (2005). Similarly, as in the system LiF–KF–K2 NbF7 , also the system LiF–NaF–K2 NbF7 is characterized by the formation of the complex anion [NbF8 ]3− in the melts, even though no crystallization field of any M3 NbF8 compound is present in the ternary phase diagram. Its presence was, however, confirmed by all the investigated physico-chemical parameters and is the general feature of this system. The formation of the [NbF8 ]3− anions is more pronounced in the melts of the system NaF–K2 NbF7 compared with those of the system LiF–K2 NbF7 . The infrared spectra of 25, 50, 75 mole % K2 NbF7 dissolved in equimolar LiF–NaF melt as well as the spectrum of pure K2 NbF7 were measured by Bocˇ a et al. (2005). Characteristic vibrations of fluoroniobate complex anions [NbF7 ]2− and [NbF8 ]3− are
K2NbF7
70 0
650
0.6
0.6
0.4
0.4
65 0
0.4
0.2
0
0.2 90
0
800
80
75 0
750
70 0
700
0. 8
F7 )
2 Nb
x (K
600
2 Nb
0.6
650
0.4
0.2
0.8
x (K
0.6
0. 8
F 7) Nb 2 x(K
F)
0.8
K2NbF7
(b)
0. 2
85 0
(a)
-0.6
-1.0
-1.8
95
0
-0.2
-1.4
LiF
0.2
0.4
N 0.6
x(NaF)
0.8
NaF LiF
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
NaF
x(NaF)
Figure 2.17. Phase diagram ((a), values in ◦ C) and the excess molar volume at 1100 K ((b), values in cm3 · mol−1 ) of the system LiF–NaF–K2 NbF7 according to Chrenková et al. (2003a, 2005).
50
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
Nb=O
[NbF8]3−
Nb=O
K 2 NbF 7
Relative transmitance
75%K2NbF7
50%K2NbF7
25%K2NbF7O
-Nb-O
[NbF7]2− 1200
1000
800 Wavenumbers (cm−1)
600
400
Figure 2.18. Infrared spectra of the quenched LiF–NaF melts with various K2 NbF7 content.
found at 546 and 476 cm−1 , respectively. As it follows from Figure 2.18, the intensity of the [NbF7 ]2− vibration increases with an increasing content of K2 NbF7 , while the [NbF8 ]3− vibration increases up to the content of 50 mole % of K2 NbF7 and then it decreases. This is in agreement with the results of the physico-chemical studies, especially those of the excess Gibbs energy of mixing, the excess volume, and the excess surface tension. 2.1.6. Systems containing hexavalent cations
Among the hexavalent elements, molybdenum and tungsten seem to be the most technologically important metals because of their use as deposits on steels in the form of protecting metal or metal boride layers. Since the main features of molybdenum and tungsten electrolytes are similar, the following text will deal with the properties of the former. Analysis of the literature data on the electro-deposition of molybdenum shows that several types of molten electrolytes have been tested. On the basis of the electro-active species used, they can be divided into two main groups: (i)
halide systems containing either K3 MoCl6 or K3 MoF6 dissolved in alkali metal halides, mainly chlorides and fluorides,
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
(ii)
51
mixed systems containing oxide compounds of molybdenum, such as molybdenum oxide, MoO3 , alkali metal molybdates, and CaMoO4 . Supporting electrolytes include: LiCl–KCl mixtures, sodium and lithium metaborates, KF–Na2 B4 O7 , KF–Li2 B4 O7 , KF–B2 O3 and CaCl2 –CaO.
Comparing results of molybdenum electro-deposition from several types of electrolytes, it was confirmed that the process is most successful in electrolytes consisting of a mixture of alkali metal fluorides and boron oxide (or alkali metal borate), to which molybdenum oxide or alkali metal molybdate is added as the electrochemical active component. From the literature it follows that the electro-deposition of molybdenum from the binary MeF–Me2 MoO4 mixtures is impossible. However, a small addition (1 mole %) of boron oxide or SiO2 to the electrolyte facilitates the electro-deposition of molybdenum. The presence of boron or silicon oxide most probably modifies the structure of the melt, which results in changes in the cathode process. The survey of electrochemistry of molybdenum deposition was given by Daneˇ k et al. (1997). Among the number of electrolytes studied, the most promising seem to be the melts of the system KF–K2 MoO4 –B2 O3 . In a number of papers, the measurement of different thermodynamic and transport properties of the KF–K2 MoO4 –B2 O3 melts was done with the goal to clarify their structure, i.e. the ionic composition on the basis of a complex physico-chemical analysis. From the theoretical point of view, the melts of this system represent very little investigated electrolytes containing both the classical ionic components and the network forming ones. The possible chemical interactions between them have not been well understood till now. The system KF–K2 MoO4 –B2 O3 is a considerably complicated subsystem of the quinary reciprocal system K+ , B3+ , Mo6+ // F− , O2− , in which a number of compounds is formed. The phase equilibrium in the system KF–K2 MoO4 –B2 O3 was studied by Patarák et al. (1993, 1997). The phase diagram of the investigated part of the ternary system KF–K2 MoO4 –B2 O3 up to 30 mole % B2 O3 , is interesting from the electrochemical deposition of molybdenum point of view, and constructed using the coupled analysis of thermodynamic and phase diagram data is shown in Figure 2.19. The very extended plateau on the crystallization surface of K2 MoO4 shifts the boundary line with the primary crystallization field of the additive compound K3 FMoO4 expressively to the KF corner, most probably due to the formation of the [BMo6 O24 ]9− heteropolyanions. The formation of the heteropolyanions [BMo6 O24 ]9− also indicates the excess Gibbs energy of mixing of the system, as shown in Figure 2.20. The enlarged shape of the isotherms of the crystallization surface of K2 MoO4 may also be probably due to the substitution of the oxygen atoms of the co-ordination sphere of molybdenum in the heteropolyanions [BMo6 O24 ]9− by the fluorine atoms. However, the existence of more polymerized heteropolyanions with Mo/B ratio being 9 or 12 cannot be excluded.
52
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
0.4
B
2O 3
0.4
0.2
0.2
88 0
0 80
0
0
72
76
720
0
760
72
840
0.0 KF
0.2
0.4 0.6 x(K2MoO4)
0.8
1.0 K2MoO4
Figure 2.19. Phase diagram of the system KF–K2 MoO4 –B2 O3 according to Patarák et al. (1997).
0.4
B
2O 3
0.4
4000
0.2
0.2
3000 2000 1000 0
0.0 KF
0.2
0.4 0.6 x(K2MoO4)
0.8
1.0 K2MoO4
Figure 2.20. Excess Gibbs energy of mixing of the system KF–K2 MoO4 –B2 O3 according to Patarák et al. (1997).
The density of the melts of the molten system KF–K2 MoO4 –B2 O3 was measured by Chrenková et al. (1994). For the concentration dependence of the molar volume in the investigated ternary system at the temperature of 827◦ C, the following equation was obtained V cm3 ·mol−1 = 29.89xKF + 89.50xK2 MoO4 + 44.62xB2 O3
+ xKF xK2 MoO4 8.50−5.28xK2 MoO4 + xKF xB2 O3 11.92−53.22xB2 O3
−xK2 MoO4 xB2 O3 81.31+102.51xB2 O3 + 110.29xKF xK2 MoO4 xB2 O3 (2.53)
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
53
The first three members represent the ideal behavior, the following three represent the interactions in binary systems and the last one, the interaction of all three components. The calculation of the coefficients was carried out by the method of multiple linear regression analysis and omitting the statistically non-important terms on the 0.99 confidence level. The standard deviation of the fit is 0.404 cm3 ·mol−1 . The different sign of the coefficients in the systems KF–B2 O3 and K2 MoO4 −B2 O3 indicate the different behavior of B2 O3 in KF and K2 MoO4 . The excess molar volume of the melts of the ternary system KF–K2 MoO4 –B2 O3 is shown in Figure 2.21. From the figure it follows that in this system a region of volume expansion exists with the maximum at 10 mole % B2 O3 and 20 mole % K2 MoO4 , and a region of volume contraction with the maximum at 40 mole % B2 O3 and 50 mole % K2 MoO4 . The volume expansion region indicates the formation of larger ions, while the volume contraction region indicates the formation of [BMo6 O24 ]9− heteropolyanions, according to the equation 6K2 MoO4 + 2B2 O3 = K9 [BMo6 O24 ] + 3KBO2
(2.54)
and the probable further polymerization of the melt is assumed. The deviation from the ideal behavior is more pronounced in comparison with the boundary binary systems, which indicates stronger interaction of all the three components. Such ternary interaction may be explained as the substitution of oxygen atoms in the coordination sphere of the [BMo6 O24 ]9− heteropolyanions by fluorine atoms. The viscosity of the melts of the KF–K2 MoO4 –B2 O3 system has been measured by Silný et al. (1995) using the computerized torsion pendulum method. The viscosity of
0.
4
x(B
2O 3)
−2
0.
2
−2
−4
−6
−10 −8
0
0 0 KF
0.2
0.4 x(K2MoO4)
0.6
0.8
1 K2MoO4
Figure 2.21. Excess molar volume of the ternary system KF–K2 MoO4 –B2 O3 at 827◦ C according to Chrenková et al. (1994).
54
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
the melts increases with increased contents of both K2 MoO4 and B2 O3 . Within the experimental error the viscosity of melts in the system KF–K2 MoO4 increases linearly with the increasing content of K2 MoO4 . Taking into account this additive behavior in the binary system KF–K2 MoO4 and adopting the formal value of 1000 Pa · s for the viscosity of pure boron oxide, the following final equation was obtained for the concentration dependence of the viscosity in the ternary system KF–K2 MoO4 –B2 O3 at 877◦ C: η (mPa·s) = 1.28xKF + 2.81xK2 MoO4 + 999xB2 O3 2 −xKF xB2 O3 3317−3658xKF + 1336xKF −xK2 MoO4 xB2 O3 3242−3586xK2 MoO4 + 1348xK2 2 MoO4
+xKF xK2 MoO4 xB2 O3 3214 + 4157xB2 O3
(2.55)
The standard deviation of the fit is 0.082mPa · s. The viscosity of the ternary system at 927◦ C is shown in Figure 2.22. From the regression analysis, it follows that the interactions in the binary system KF–K2 MoO4 is statistically non-important, compared with those in the binary systems KF–B2 O3 and K2 MoO4 –B2 O3 . Thus, the values of the standard deviations of approximation relate mostly with the viscosity of the ternary melts. The viscosity of the melts of the ternary system increases very steeply with the increasing content of boron oxide. This observation is, however, not surprising, because of the polymerization ability of the boron oxide. The formation of more voluminous
0.
x(
B
2O 3)
4
0.
2
3
3.2
3.4
2.8 2.6
1.4
0
1.6
1.8
2
1.2
0 KF
0.2
0.4 x (K2MoO4)
2.2
2.4
0.6
0.8
1.0 K2MoO4
Figure 2.22. Viscosity of the ternary system KF–K2 MoO4 –B2 O3 at 927◦ C according to Silný et al. (1995).
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
55
(B4 O7 )2− and BF4− anions will obviously increase the viscosity of the melt as well. However, the increase in the viscosity is higher than it might be expected from the pure polycondensation of boron oxide. Evidently bigger particles than the boroxol rings are formed in the ternary system, especially near the K2 MoO4 –B2 O3 boundary. According to the conclusions based on the phase equilibrium and density measurements, it may be assumed that these bigger particles are the [BMo6 O24 ]9− heteropolyanions formed in the melt according to Eq. (2.54). The statistically important ternary interaction, however, may be also ascribed to the entry of the fluorine atoms into the co-ordination sphere of molybdenum in the heteropolyanions. Also surface tension measurements in the system KF–K2 MoO4 –B2 O3 , performed by Nguyen and Daneˇ k (2000a), supported the above mentioned conclusions. From the viscosity, as well as the phase equilibrium, surface tension, and density measurements it is evident that the system KF–K2 MoO4 –B2 O3 is very complex. Beside the chemical reactions, the polymerization tendency of the melts, especially in the region of higher contents of boron oxide, makes this system difficult to study. Similar electrolytic preparation of molybdenum coatings has been investigated by Silný et al. (1993) and Zatko et al. (1994) in the molten system KF–K2 MoO4 –SiO2 . From the above system, these authors obtained coherent, smooth and well-adhesive molybdenum layers on electrically conductive substrates in a relatively narrow composition region. The quality of the deposit depends on the silica content in the melt. The authors explained the positive role of SiO2 in the molybdenum electro-deposition due to the change in the structure of the electrolyte and the formation in the melt of heteropolyanions [SiMo12 O40 ]4− according to the reaction 12K2 MoO4 + 7SiO2 + 36KF = K 4 [SiMo12 O40 ] + 6K2 SiF6 + 22K2 O
(2.56)
Such heteropolyanions are rather voluminous and thus, much more polarizable. In the vicinity of the cathode in the electric double layer, this anion is strongly polarized and finally disintegrated into smaller species, from which consecutive molybdenum deposition takes place. The X-ray diffraction analysis of the solid deposit on the top closure and furnace wall proved that the deposit consists of pure K2 SiF6 , which supports the assumption on the formation of the above-mentioned heteropolyanions. Unfortunately, the authors did not study the mechanism of the cathodic process in this system. From the physico-chemical and thermodynamic analysis of the molten systems KF–K2 MoO4 –B2 O3 and KF–K2 MoO4 –SiO2 , it can be concluded that the formation of heteropolymolybdates containing boron, [BMo6 O24 ]9− , and silicon, [SiMo12 O40 ]4− , as a central atom is most probably responsible for an easy molybdenum deposition. Besides, the entry of fluorine atoms into the coordination sphere of molybdenum in the heteropolyanions lowers the symmetry and thus, also the electrochemical stability of such electro-active species.
56
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
2.1.7. Systems containing halides and oxides
The presence of oxides and the formation of oxofluoro-complexes in molten electrolytes may be sometimes unwanted, but in many cases they are the fundamental features of the system. For instance, the formation of oxide complexes in alkali–alkaline earth chloride melts may be mentioned. The formation of oxofluoride complexes in molten cryolite– alumina melts, used as electrolytes for aluminum production, is typical as well. On the other hand, the presence of oxofluoride complexes in electrolytes used for niobium production was initially regarded as unwanted. Recently, however, it has been proven that their presence in niobium electrolytes plays an important role in the niobium electrodeposition. In the following, some technologically important examples of systems containing halides and oxides will be described. 2.1.7.1. Oxofluoro-complexes in magnesium electrolytes
The physico-chemical properties such as density, conductivity, and viscosity of the magnesium chloride electrolyte are of substantial importance for the current efficiency of the magnesium electrolysis. The solubility of the reaction products, Mg and Cl2 , in the electrolyte is also important to attain the high current efficiency. Interfacial properties between the Mg electrolyte and the metal may depend significantly on the oxide concentration of the bath. In modern electrolytic cells for magnesium production, the metal is collected above the melt surface, the density of the melt thus being higher than that of the metal. Therefore the composition of the MgCl2 electrolyte is usually adapted by the addition of NaCl and KCl with or without CaCl2 or BaCl2 . Together with MgCl2 , some oxide impurities are also added into the melt mostly in the form of MgO. The very low MgO solubility in halide melts supports the fact that Mg2+ –O2− interaction is very strong. This also indicates a possible Mg–O–Cl complex formation in MgCl2 –alkali chloride melts containing oxide impurities. However, little is known about the Mg–O–Cl complexes, which may form in such melts and in this way increase the MgO solubility. Combes et al. (1980) used calcia-stabilized zirconia electrodes to determine the O2− concentration in the MgCl2 –NaCl–KCl mixtures at 1000 K with different BaO additions. They suggested that the following reactions take place in the melt: 2Mg2+ + O2− → Mg2 O2+
(2.57)
Mg2 O2+ + O2− → 2MgO(s)
(2.58)
The solubility of MgO in the equimolar NaCl–KCl mixture at 1000 K was found to be very low. The solubility of other alkaline-earth oxides in the equimolar NaCl–KCl melts are low, but are considerably higher than that of MgO and do increase in the sequence MgO < CaO < SrO < BaO. However, in earth alkali metal chloride-rich melts,
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
57
the solubility of the corresponding oxides is considerable. The large difference in the solubility of oxides indicates different dissolution mechanisms of oxides in the alkali metal chloride and earth alkali metal chloride melts. Boghosian et al. (1991) studied the solubility of earth alkali metal oxides in alkali metal–earth alkali metal chlorides and NaCl–MeCl2 melts. They found that the oxide solubility is in general very low and increases markedly with the MeCl2 concentration and with increasing atomic number of the earth alkali metal atom. The very low oxide solubility in earth alkali metal chlorides can be explained by the reaction (e.g. for the MgCl2 melts) MgCl2 (l,mix) + MeO(s) = MeCl2 (l,mix) + MgO(s)
(2.59)
For this reaction, r G0 0, for Me = Ca and Ba. The observed enhanced solubility of MeO is most probably caused by the oxide complex formation according to the reaction mMeCl2 (l) + nMeO(s) = Mem+n On Cl2m (l)
(2.60)
It was found that in the NaCl–MeCl2 mixtures containing 25 mole % MeCl2 , where Me = Mg, Ca, Sr, and Ba, the solubility of MeO at 850◦ C is x(MgO) = 6×10−5 , x(CaO) = 10−3 −10−4 , and x(SrO) = 0.039. In the BaCl2 system, the BaO/BaCl2 molar ratio at saturation equals 1. The oxochloro-complexes formed in these melts were further justified using cryoscopic measurements. An increasing temperature of the primary crystallization of the binary NaCl–MeCl2 melt was observed when the oxide was added. Model calculations in combination with the two sets of experimental data (solubility and cryoscopy) indicated that the Me/O ratios for the different complexes are Mg2 O, Ca3 O, Ca4 O, Sr3 O, Sr4 O, Ba3 O, and Ba4 O. The equilibrium constants for the formation reactions of the neutral complexes, based on the reaction (m+n)M2+ + nO2− + 2mCl− = Mm+n On Cl2m
(2.61)
are very large. Mediaas et al. (1997) studied the effect of fluoride additions to MgCl2 -containing melts on the MgO solubility. It was found that in the MgCl2 –MgF2 melts, and at 840◦ C, the MgO solubility increases linearly with MgF2 concentration. The solubility of MgO in pure MgCl2 melt at 840◦ C was determined to be xsat (MgO) = 0.0061, while in the 60 mole% MgCl2 + 40 mole% MgF2 mixture, it was xsat (MgO) = 0.0109. They determined the effect of temperature on the MgO solubility for pure MgCl2 and for two MgCl2 –MgF2 mixtures with x(MgF2 ) = 0.1816 and x(MgF2 ) = 0.2016 in the temperature range 676◦ C < t < 930◦ C. It was found that for pure MgCl2 the derivative
58
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
dln xsat (MgO)/d(1/T ) equals −5200 K and for the two mixtures −4200 K. In the MgCl2 – NaCl–NaF ternary system, three different oxide solubility experiments were performed: (a)
(b)
(c)
NaF and MgCl2 were added to a MgCl2 –NaCl mixture saturated with MgO at 850◦ C such that x(MgCl2 ) = 0.63. The MgO solubility increases with increased NaF content up to x(NaF) ≈ 0.08, thereafter it remains constant at x(NaF) = 0.20. NaF was added to a MgCl2 –NaCl mixture saturated with MgO at 850◦ C. The initial MgCl2 concentration was x(MgCl2 ) = 0.63. An increase in MgO solubility up to about 8 mole % NaF was observed. On further NaF additions to x(NaF) = 0.18, the MgO solubility decreases. A melt closer in composition to the electrolyte used for electro-winning of magnesium was investigated. The MgCl2 mole fraction was kept constant at x(MgCl2 ) = 0.10. The temperature was 900◦ C. No effect could be observed for NaF content on the MgO solubility for x(NaF) ≤ 0.06.
A reasonable thermodynamic model was tried to explain the effect of fluoride concentration on the MgO solubility in the MgCl2 –NaCl–NaF ternary melts. However, both the activity model used to calculate the activity of MgCl2 and MgF2 and the understanding of the Mg–O–Cl(F) complexes formed in the melt seemed to be too simple to give a reasonable mechanism for MgO solubility in these complicated melts. The MgO solubility in technical electrolytes for Mg production is very low (in the ppm range). Together with MgCl2 , BaO may also be introduced into the Mg electrolyte. Even when BaO dissolves readily in NaCl–BaCl2 melts, the solubility of BaO in MgCl2 containing melts is also very low, since BaO(s) reacts with MgCl2 (l) along with the formation of BaCl2 (l) and MgO(s). 2.1.7.2. Oxofluoroaluminate complexes in cryolite–alumina melts
The cryolite–alumina melts, used as electrolytes for aluminum production are technologically very important. Aluminum oxide (alumina) is dissolved on purpose in cryolite–based melts as it is the source of aluminum. The electrolyte composition is one of the most important technological parameters at aluminum production. Specification of the optimum electrolyte composition, mainly concerning the alumina and aluminum fluoride content, characterizes the particular producer and belongs to the priorities at achieving the maximum current efficiency. The melts of the system Na3AlF6 –Al2 O3 are the basis of the electrolyte used in aluminum production. The most accepted phase diagram of this system is that published by Chin and Hollingshead (1966). During approximately half a century of investigations on the structure of the melts of the system Na3AlF6 −Al2 O3 , there have been numerous suggestions on the nature of the possible oxygen-containing species present in the melt. A comprehensive review on this topic was given by Grjotheim et al. (1982). However, in the last two decades, it was
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
59
generally accepted that complex oxofluoroaluminate anions are the most probable species formed. Dewing (1974) suggested that alumina dissolves predominantly during the formation of AlOF1−x anions, while Førland and Ratkje (1973), Ratkje and Førland (1976) x on the basis of cryoscopic measurements suggested that the reaction 1−y
= AlOFy Al2 OF4−x x
(3−x−y)
+AlFx−y
(2.62)
takes place in the melt. The probable values for x are 6 or 8, while for y, it may be 2, (3−x−y) − is AlF3− indicating that AlFx−y 6 or AlF4 , which are the most important anions in oxide-free cryolite melts. The more recent investigations based mainly on Raman spectroscopic measurements by Gilbert et al. (1976, 1995) indicate that anions with bridging Al–O–Al bonds are present, and have most probably the following structure
F F
Al
O O
Al
F F
F and/or
|
F |
F −Al −O −Al −F | | F F
It was suggested that these species originate in the melt by the reaction of AlF3− 6 with dissolved alumina. Julsrud (1979) proposed a thermodynamic model for cryolite-alumina melts based 4− on cryoscopic and calorimetric measurements and considered the Al2 OF2− 6 , Al2 OF8 , 2− 4− Al2 OF6− 10 , Al2 O2 F4 , and Al2 O2 F6 species to be present in alumina saturated melts. Sterten (1980) developed a model of cryolite melts saturated with alumina on the basis of experimental NaF and AlF3 activities. He found that Al2 OF4−x and Al2 O2 F2−x x x 1−x were the most probable species in these melts. AlOFx was of minor importance. He 4− claimed that in very basic melts, CR > 5, the Al2 O2 F2− 4 and Al2 O2 F6 complexes were 2− dominant, while in acidic melts, CR < 3, the complexes Al2 OF6 and Al2 O2 F2− 4 were the most abundant. Kvande (1980, 1986) suggested that Al2 OF4− 8 is the most abundant species in cryolite melts with low alumina contents. He further claimed that the solubility of alumina in NaF–AlF3 melts attains a maximum at the composition of cryolite. Based on this, he argued that it is reasonable to assume that alumina, when dissolving, reacts predominantly with AlF3− 6 anions according to the following reaction scheme 2− − Al2 O3 + 4AlF3− 6 = 3Al2 OF6 + 6F
(2.63)
60
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes 4− Al2 O3 + 4AlF3− 6 = 3Al2 OF8
3 2− Al2 O3 + AlF3− 6 = 2 Al2 O2 F4
(2.64) (2.65)
Reactions of alumina with F− ions are less probable, since the alumina solubility in pure molten NaF is very low. Zhuxian and Gang (1989), using the Monte Carlo method, simulated the structure of the oxofluoro-complexes originating in the molten cryolite after the addition of aluminum oxide at 1010◦ C. From the results, it follows that the species AlOF1−x (x = 2−5), x 6− Al2 OF2− , and Al OF are formed in the melt. They also suggested that above 9 mole % 2 6 10 Al2 O3 , besides the mentioned complexes, the Al2 O2 F2− anion may also originate. 4 Bache and Ystenes (1989) used the IR spectroscopy and X-ray powder diffraction analysis in order to determine the qualitative composition of quenched or heated equimolar mixtures of cryolite and chiolite with the addition of 10 mass % Al2 O3 . In the IR spectrum of this quenched mixture, new bands arise at 530, 870, and 1170 cm−1 , which do not belong either to cryolite or to chiolite. In the IR spectra of these samples, these bands do not occur. In the X-ray diffraction pattern of the above-mentioned quenched mixture, only one peak arises, which does not belong either to cryolite or chiolite. For heated samples, all main peaks of α-Al2 O3 were detected. On the basis of Raman spectroscopy investigation, Robert et al. (1993) gave a new insight into the character of the oxofluoroaluminate species. The Raman spectra of Robert et al. did not confirm the presence of the species with non-bridging Al–O bonds. Only those having bridging Al–O–Al bonds, the Al2 OF4−x and Al2 O2 F2−x complexes, were x x present in the melt. The above picture of the cryolite–alumina melts was recently confirmed also by Raman spectra and vapor pressure studies carried out by Gilbert et al.(1995). At low Al2 O3 concentrations, they observed a new band at 450 cm−1 in the Raman spectrum which they ascribed to the anion Al2 OF4− 8 originating in the basic region (CR > 3) or to the anion Al2 OF2− existing in the neutral (CR = 3) and acidic region (CR < 3). With increasing the 6 concentration of Al2 O3 , the 510–515 cm−1 band sharply increases, which they ascribed 2− to the anion Al2 O2 F2− 4 . Based on a new dissociation scheme of cryolite, the AlF5 anion was considered to be the most abundant species in molten cryolite. A new reaction scheme at the dissolution of Al2 O3 in cryolite was therefore suggested 2− − − Al2 O3 + 4AlF2− 5 + 4F = 3Al2 OF6 + 6F
(2.66)
4− − Al2 O3 + 4AlF2− 5 + 4F = 3Al2 OF8
(2.67)
3 2− − Al2 O3 + AlF2− 5 + F = Al2 O2 F4 2
(2.68)
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
61
Picard et al. (1996) performed theoretical calculations of the stability of the till now presumed oxofluoroaluminate anions. For these anions, they also calculated the vibration frequencies and intensities of bands originating in the infrared region. Their calcula4−x tions indicated that the most stable anion is AlOF− species, the 2 . Among the Al2 OFx 2− 2−x most stable seems to be Al2 OF6 and of the Al2 O2 Fx species, the highest stability have those with x = 2–6. From the calculated vibration frequencies and the intensities of bands, it follows that bands at 460 and 185 cm−1 , which arise in Raman spectra measured by Gilbert et al. (1976), belong to the Al2 OF4−x and Al2 O2 F2−x species. Bands x x −1 observed by Gilbert et al. (1976) at 530 and 310 cm were ascribed only to the Al2 O2 F2−x x complexes. Raman spectroscopy, vapor pressure, and the solubility of alumina in cryolite measurements were used by Robert et al. (1997a) in order to elucidate the structure of the system NaF–AlF3 –Al2 O3 . On the basis of the obtained data, they suggested that at low 4− concentrations of alumina, the first originating species are Al2 OF2− 6 and Al2 OF8 . With 2− increasing the content of aluminum oxide, the anion Al2 O2 F4 is formed, but with further Al2 O3 addition, the intensity of the Al2 O2 F2− 4 band decreases. This is explained by the formation of a next anion with a similar structure, but with weaker bonds. The solubility of Al2 O3 in NaF–AlF3 melts was recently measured by Diep (1998) and the results were explained in terms of possible oxofluoroaluminate species formed in the melt at alumina saturation. In order to explain the maximum alumina solubility at CR = 3, 2− he introduced a new species, Al3 O3 F3− 6 , which consists of three AlO2 F2 tetrahedrons linked by the oxygen corners. Thermodynamic calculations indicated that the oxygencontaining compounds Na2Al2 OF6 , Na6Al2 OF10 , Na2Al2 O2 F4 , and Na3Al3 O3 F6 had to be present to describe the Al2 O3 solubility limit in the NaF–AlF3 –Al2 O3 ternary. He found that when these compounds were present at the composition of alumina saturation, the melts behave approximately ideally. It is thus reasonable to believe that the Al2 OF2− 6 species are dominant at low Al2 O3 concentration while the Al2 O2 F2− species are predominant at high alumina contents. The 4 two species are formed according to the reactions 4Na3 AlF6 + Al2 O3 = 3Na2 Al2 OF6 + 6NaF
(2.69)
At low oxide content and at high alumina concentration, the reaction is 2Na3 AlF6 + 3Al2 O3 = 3Na2 Al2 O2 F4
(2.70)
Direct oxygen determination in MF–AlF3 –Al2 O3 (M = Li, Na, K) melts in dependence on the cryolite ratio and the alumina content was performed using the method of carbothermal reduction by Daneˇ k et al. (2000b). The MF–AlF3 melts with alumina, successively added in 5–7 steps from 0 mole % and beyond the solubility limit, were heated at
62
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
9.6 % Al2O3
Al3O3F63–
pure Na2Al2O2F4
Al2OF62–
Relative oxygen content
Al2O2F42–
1000◦ C in an inert argon atmosphere. Samples were analyzed for oxide content using a LECO TC-436 Nitrogen/Oxygen analyzer. During the LECO measurement, the samples are heated with carbon powder in a graphite crucible at a constant heating rate to 2900◦ C over a short time. The oxygen, present in the sample, reacts at specific temperatures with carbon powder resulting in a characteristic LECO curve showing the dependence of the actual oxygen content on temperature. On this curve, several peaks corresponding to the decomposition of individual present oxofluoroaluminates were observed. The temperature at which carbon starts to react with oxygen in the sample depends on the energy with which oxygen is bonded in the present compound, i.e. on the Gibbs energy of formation of the individual compound. The LECO curves obtained in the system NaF–AlF3 –Al2 O3 at 1000◦ C and the cryolite ratio CR = 4 are shown in Figure 2.23. Similar LECO curves were also obtained for the systems LiF–AlF3 –Al2 O3 and KF–AlF3 –Al2 O3 . The LECO curves showed that generally two distinct peaks could be observed. From an energetic point of view, it can be assumed that the double oxygen bridge is more stable, thus requiring higher temperatures to be decomposed, compared with the single Al–O–Al bond. Hence, oxygen-containing species decomposing at lower temperature are most probably those in which two aluminum atoms are linked by one bridging oxygen atom, while the species decomposing at higher temperatures are those having two aluminum
7.2 % Al2O3 5.2 % Al2O3 3.6 % Al2O3 2.1 % Al2O3 1.0 % Al2O3
500
1000
1500
2000 t(°C)
2500
3000
Figure 2.23. LECO curves obtained in the system NaF–AlF3 –Al2 O3 at the cryolite ratio CR = 4.
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
63
atoms linked by two bridging oxygen atoms. This assumption was confirmed by analyzing the synthesized Na2Al2 O2 F4 compound. On the LECO curve, only a single peak occurred at the temperature identical with the second peak in the system NaF–AlF3 –Al2 O3 (see Figure 2.23). It was therefore concluded that this peak was due to the Al2 O2 F2− 4 complex anion. The content of oxygen present in the individual oxofluoroaluminate species was calculated as the fraction of the total alumina dissolved with respect to the area of the peak corresponding to the given oxygen-containing species. In Figures 2.24–2.26, the distributions of individual oxofluoroaluminate anions in the systems LiF–AlF3 –Al2 O3 , NaF–AlF3 –Al2 O3 at CR = 3, and KF–AlF3 –Al2 O3 at CR = 3, respectively, are shown. The obtained LECO data, described in the figures with open symbols, were compared with the results of the Raman work by Robert et al. (1997a) (described by full symbols). These two essentially different methods for determining the content of oxyfluoroaluminate species in melts gave a very similar variation of the oxygen-containing complexes with increasing contents of Al2 O3 . In the LiF–AlF3 –Al2 O3 system, only a moderate quantity of Al2 OF2− 6 is present, while Al2 O2 F2− is the dominating species over the entire composition range. The distribution 4 of species does not depend to any significant extent on the cryolite ratio, obviously due
5 Al2O2F42−
Mole % of species
4
3
2 Al2OF62−
1
0
0
1
2 Mole % Al2O3
3
4
Figure 2.24. Distribution of species in LiF–AlF3 –Al2 O3 melts at various CR. ◦, • – CR = 1.2; , – CR = 2; , – CR = 3.
64
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
12 Al2O2F42−
Mole % of species
10 8 6
Al2OF62−
4 2 Al3O3F63−
0
0
2
4 Mole % Al2O3
6
8
2− Figure 2.25. Distribution of species in NaF–AlF3 –Al2 O3 melts at CR = 3. ◦, • – Al2 OF2− 6 ; , – Al2 O2 F4 ; 3− – Al3 O3 F6 .
60 Al2O2F42-
Mole % of species
50 40 30 20
Al2OF62–
10
Al3O3F63–
0
Al3O4F43–
0
4
8 12 Mole % Al2O3
16
20
2− Figure 2.26. Distribution of species in KF–AlF3 –Al2 O3 melts at CR = 3. ◦, • – Al2 OF2− 6 ; , – Al2 O2 F4 , 3− 3− – Al3 O3 F6 ; ✩, – Al3 O4 F4 .
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
65
to the very low solubility of alumina and the large surplus of available LiF and AlF3 to form oxofluoroaluminates. In the NaF–AlF3 –Al2 O3 melts, it was found that the first peak is split and two species having aluminum atoms linked with one oxygen bridge are obviously present. Daneˇ k et al. (2000) attributed the lower temperature shoulder to the Al2 OF2− 6 species, while the shoulder at the higher temperature was attributed to the formation of the Al3 O3 F3− 6 species. Up to 2 mole % of Al2 O3 , no other species was found in the melt. The Al2 O2 F2− 4 species are present already above the mentioned Al2 O3 content and at high Al2 O3 contents, they become dominant. The observed oxofluoroaluminate species distribution in NaF–AlF3 –Al2 O3 melts is in accordance with the results of Julsrud (1979), Sterten (1980), Kvande (1980, 1986), and Robert et al. (1997) obtained by quite different methods. As in the previous systems, in the KF–AlF3 –Al2 O3 also two main oxygen peaks were detected. The first peak shows a shoulder at the lower temperature, which means that two different oxofluoroaluminate species with single oxygen bonded aluminum atoms are present. The first shoulder was attributed to the Al2 OF2− 6 species, while the first main peak belongs most probably to the more stable Al3 O3 F3− 6 species. The second main peak has a shoulder at higher temperatures as well. The main second peak is 3 attributed to Al2 O2 F2− 4 , while the high temperature shoulder is attributed to Al3 O4 F4 . 2− Similarly as in the NaF–AlF3 –Al2 O3 melts, at low Al2 O3 content, only the Al2 OF6 and Al3 O3 F3− 6 species are observed in measurable amounts. Above a certain Al2 O3 concentration, Al2 O2 F2− 4 species arises, its content steeply increases, becoming the dominating species at high Al2 O3 concentrations. The shoulder of the second peak at a higher temperature belongs to a minor amount of Al3 O4 F3− 4 . The presence of this species is necessary in order to explain the very high alumina solubility in this system. Brooker et al. (2000) measured the Raman spectra of the ternary eutectic mixture LiF–NaF–KF (FLINAK), to which they added small amounts of AlF3 (or NaAlF3 ) and Na2 O. The temperature varied in the range 25–500◦ C. Na2 O served as the source of oxygen, since aluminum oxide does not dissolve in FLINAK. When Na2 O was added to the mixture of FLINAK + 5 mole % AlF3 (or Na3AlF6 ) at 500◦ C, new bands occurred in the Raman spectrum, the intensity of which increases with increasing amounts of added −1 −1 Na2 O, while the intensity of bands assigned to AlF3− 6 (ν1 ≈ 540cm ), (ν2 ≈ 326cm ) −1 decreases. The new bands, especially the very intensive one at 494 cm , were assigned 2− to the Al2 OF2− 6 anion. Presence of the Al2 O2 F4 anion was regarded as little probable by the authors. The authors found that the 494 cm−1 band (at 500◦ C) shifts with decreasing temperature to 509 cm−1 (at 25◦ C). The same holds also for the other Al2 OF2− 6 bands. 2− This indicates marked temperature instability of the Al2 OF6 anion. Lacasagne et al. (2002) studied the structure of the NaF–AlF3 –Al2 O3 melts up to 1025◦ C by in situ NMR of 27Al, 23 Na, 19 F, and 17 O, using a laser-heated experimental set-up. The Al2 O3 additions to cryolite varied in the range of 0.6 to 8.2 mole %. The observed changes in 27Al and 17 O chemical shifts gave direct experimental evidence
66
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
on the existence of at least two different oxofluoro-aluminate species in the cryolite– alumina melts. Zhang et al. (2002, 2003) measured the solubility of alumina in neutral and basic cryolite melts in the composition range 3 ≤ CR ≤ 12.5 at 1300 K. Using thermodynamic activity probes for Al and Na, they monitored the activity of NaF and AlF3 in the melt at different alumina concentrations. From the obtained solubility data as well as of those published by Skybakmoen et al. (1997), the distribution of the solutes in dependence of the alumina concentration was calculated for the composition range 1.5 ≤ CR ≤ 12.5 and compared with the literature data. The present model very well describes the experimentally determined alumina solubility data. The authors found that in the acidic melt at CR ≈ 1.5, Na2 Al2 OF6 is the dominant solute. In less acidic melts, Na2 Al2 O2 F4 becomes more dominant, while in the basic melts, Na4 Al2 O2 F6 provides the significant solubility of alumina. The 3D geometry for the three solutes was proposed. 2.1.7.3. Oxofluoro-complexes in niobium electrolytes
The crucial problem in niobium deposition in molten salts is the presence of oxygen in the electrolyte, because it is extremely difficult to prepare a melt free of O2− ions, especially in the case of industrial applications. It was formerly assumed that the presence of O2− ions might decrease the quality of Nb coatings or prevent the formation of Nb coatings completely. Therefore a great part of the research efforts was concentrated on the influence of O2− ions on the reduction mechanism of Nb and the formation of niobium oxofluoro-complexes in the melt. Though electrolyte impurities, such as oxides, hydroxides, chlorides, bromides, and iodides, were formerly considered to be undesirable, later it was found that the presence of small amounts of oxides in the melt increases the current efficiency of the electrolysis. Christensen et al. (1994) obtained the highest current efficiency in melts with O/Nb molar ratios in the range 1 < n0 /nNb < 0.5. The presence of oxide in the melt causes the formation of various niobium oxofluorocomplexes. It was shown that relatively pure Nb coatings can be obtained from FLINAK melts if n0 /nNb is less than 1. However, it has been shown by Konstantinov et al. (1981) and Khalidi et al. (1991) that, even a small amount of O2− ions can entirely change the mechanism of Nb deposition depending on the types of the niobium oxofluorides formed in the melt. Daneˇ k et al. (2000a) and Bocˇ a et al. (2005) showed that from the number of systems used as electrolytes for niobium deposition, the most promising seems to be the system LiF–KF–K2 NbF7 or LiF–NaF–K2 NbF7 . From the physico-chemical and spectroscopic measurements, it follows that the formation of the [NbF8 ]3− anion is the general feature of the investigated systems. However, this obviously leads to an increase in the symmetry of the C2 v local structure of the [NbF7 ]2− anion to the D4 h of the [NbF8 ]3− , and thus does not facilitate the deposition of niobium.
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
67
When oxide ions are present in the melt, the formation of the oxofluoro-complex [NbOF5 ]2− according to the reaction [NbF7 ]2− +O2− = [NbOF5 ]2− +2F−
(2.71)
was observed. At a lower concentration of oxide ions in the melt, the ligand displacement in the coordination sphere of the [NbF7 ]2− anion by oxygen and the formation of an oxofluoro-complex lowers the local structure symmetry due to the formation of the C4 v local structure of the [NbOF5 ]2− anion. With increasing O2− contents and due to the presence of free oxide ions in the melt, [NbOF5 ]2− ions are transformed to the [NbO2 F]− according to the reaction [NbOF5 ]2− +O2− +e− = [NbO2 F]− +4F−
(2.72)
and they coexist in the melt with mono-oxofluoro-complexes despite the low concentration of oxide ions. Van et al. (1999a,b, 2000) used voltammetry, calculation of the Gibbs energy of formation of K2 NbF7 , and IR spectroscopy in order to clarify the complex formation in the high oxidation states of the metal. In Figure 2.27, the cyclic voltammogram obtained in the LiF–NaF–K2 NbF7 melt with an initial Nb(V) concentration of 166.46 mol · cm−3
0.06
Ox2 0.04
i (A)
0.02
Ox1 0.00
R1 –0.02
R3
–0.04 –2.0
R2 –1.5
–1.0
–0.5
0.0
0.5
1.0
E (V) Figure 2.27. Cyclic voltammogram taken in the LiF–NaF–K2 NbF7 melt at 750◦ C.
68
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
at 750◦ C and a scan rate of 0.36 V · s−1 is shown. Three reduction waves may be observed. The first wave, R1 , at −0.24 V is followed by a sharp peak, R2 , at −0.87 V, and then a hump, R3 , at −1.15 V. In the positive potential scan direction, the reduced species are re-oxidized in two steps, Ox2 at −0.83 V and Ox1 at −0.25 V. The third reduction wave, R3 , is caused by presence of the [NbOF5 ]2− complex, which is formed in the melt when the oxide ions are added. [NbOF5 ]2− is then reduced in a one-step-reaction at a potential of about 100 mV lower than Nb(IV). Characteristic vibrations of niobium oxofluoro-complexes were found in the 1000–400 cm−1 region. Figure 2.28 shows the infrared spectra of K2 NbF7 dissolved in equimolar LiF–KF melt with c(Nb) = 570 mol · m−3 and various n0 /nNb ratios at 700◦ C. The IR spectrum of the sample with n0 /nNb = 0.2 shows a sharp band at 926 cm−1 , which is characteristic for the Nb=O stretching vibration in [NbOF5 ]2− (Figure 2.28a). The absorption band at 738 cm−1 is supposed to correspond to the vibrations of bridging
(d)
878 (c) 807 495
Transmitance
918 875 804 (b)
1083
498
738
478 615
930
(a)
549
1200
1000
800
600
400
Wavenumber (cm−1) Figure 2.28. Infrared spectra of the LiF–NaF quenched melts with different contents of K2 NbF7 .
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
69
oxygen–niobium bonds. The broad complex band near 550 cm−1 consists of several overlapping components due to Nb–F vibrations of both [NbOF5 ]2− and [NbF7 ]2− complexes. With the addition of the oxide up to the ratio n0 /nNb = 1, a pronounced decrease in intensity and a shift of the Nb=O band to 918 cm−1 are observed. This indicates the presence of [NbOF6 ]3− in the melt (Figure 2.28b). Moreover, two new bands at 875 cm−1 and 804 cm−1 , assigned to O–Nb–O stretching vibrations in di-oxofluoro-complexes, are observed. The Nb–F band is shifted to 498 cm−1 , the position found for [NbO2 Fy ](y−1)− . No Nb=O band near 920 cm−1 in the spectrum of the melt corresponding to the ratio n0 /nNb = 1.5 indicates no or a negligible amount of double bonds (Figure 2.28c). Absorptions at 878, 807, and 495 cm−1 are consistent with O–Nb–O and Nb–F stretching vibrations in di-oxofluoro-complex [NbO2 Fy ](y−1)− . The IR spectra indicates a transformation of [NbF7 ]2− through [NbOFx ](x−3)− to [Nb(V)O2 Fy ](y−1)− with increasing the oxide content in the melts. The ligand displacement reactions can be described as [NbF7 ]2− +O2− → [NbOFx ](x−3)− +(7−x)F−
(2.73)
[NbOFx ](x−3)− +O2− → [NbO2 Fy ](y−1)− +(x −y)F−
(2.74)
where, according to Pausewang and Rudorf (1969) and von Barner et al. (1991), x could be 5 and 6, and y may attain the value of 2, 3, or 4. It may be concluded that the successive ligand displacement in the [NbF7 ]2− anion by oxygen and the formation of oxofluoro-complexes can be described by the following general scheme 2− NbF2− → NbOF(x−3)− +xO2− → NbO2 F(x−1)− x x 7 +xO
(2.75)
The first step taking place at n0 /nNb < 0.7 lowers the local structure symmetry due to the formation of the C4 v local structure of the [NbOF5 ]2− anion and facilitates the deposition of niobium. Good experimental conditions for the deposition process can be expected in such a case. However, at n0 /nNb > 1, inhomogeneous niobium deposits containing probably potassium–niobium phase and niobium oxide solid solution were obtained. However, a non-metal deposit could be obtained as well. Infrared spectra of solid K2 NbF7 and spectra of Nb(V) in molten KF–LiF were measured by Fordyce and Baum (1966). The spectra showed bands characteristic of the 2− NbF2− 7 ion. Solid K2 NbF7 has been shown to contain discrete NbF7 ions with C2v symmetry. According to Keller (1963), the Raman spectrum of this salt has bands at 388, 630, and 782 cm−1 . Contrary to this, solid CsNbF6 , which contains octahedral NbF− 6, shows Raman bands at 280, 562, and 683 cm−1 .
70
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
According to Pausewang and Rudorf (1969), solid dioxofluorides of the type Alk3 (NbO2 F4 ) (Alk = Na, K, Rb) are also known. The (NbO2 F4 )3− ion has a sixcoordinate arrangement of the ligands with the two oxygen atoms in cis position to each other (C2v symmetry). von Barner (1991) investigated the formation of Nb(V) fluoro- and oxofluorocomplexes in eutectic LiF–NaF–KF melts (FLINAK) as a function of the oxide contents. On the basis of the Raman spectra of the melts and infrared spectra of solidified melts, the possible structures for the complexes were discussed. Raman spectra of the molten system LiF–NaF–KF–K2 NbF7 at 650◦ C indicates the −1 −1 presence of NbF2− 7 ions with vibration frequencies at 626 cm (p), 371 cm (dp), and 2− 290 cm−1 (dp). The NbF7 ions have C2v symmetry, as previously suggested by Hoard (1939) for solid K2 NbF7 . Depending on the value of the oxygen to niobium(V) ratio, at least four different species are formed in the LiF–NaF–KF melts. In the range O < mol of O2− /mol (n−3)− of Nb(V) < 1, vibration frequencies due to the NbOFn species are observed at −1 −1 −1 921 cm (p), 583 cm (p), and 307 cm (dp) for oxide to niobium(V) mole ratios up to approximately 2. (n−3)− When an oxide is added to the melt, complexes with the general formula NbOFn are formed. The most probable value of n is 5, giving rise to a monomeric NbOF2− 5 . Infrared spectra of solidified melts support the existence of a niobium–oxygen double bond in this complex. The vibration spectrum is in accord with the band pattern of monomeric NbOF2− 5 with a C4v symmetry. The nature of the species that are formed at high oxide to niobium ratios are more uncertain, but it seems likely that the first of them has a niobium–oxygen ratio of 1/2 (n−1)− (i.e. [NbO2 Fn ]n ). Bands in the Raman spectrum of the melt at 878 and 815 cm−1 and in the infrared spectrum of the solidified melt at 879 and 809 cm−1 are ascribed to the stretching vibrations of the NbO2 entity. The vibration spectra (Raman of the melt and infrared of the solidified melt) are consistent with the formation of NbO2 F3− 4 ions of C2v symmetry. In melts saturated with the oxide, structures of the [NbO3 Fn ](1+n)− type probably exist. Furthermore, some kind of polymerization is likely to occur in this melt, since frequencies typical of vibrations of distorted NbO6 octahedrons with edge shearing were observed by McConnell et al. (1976). By means of computer programs, it has been possible to obtain the Raman spectra of the three pure complexes, believed to be NbF2− 7 , 3− NbOF2− , and NbO F . 2 5 4 2.1.7.4. Alkali metal fluoride melts containing boron and/or titanium oxide
Among the systems of alkali metal fluorides containing boron oxide, the melts of the system LiF–KF–B2 O3 –TiO2 were tested as possible electrolytes in the electro-chemical synthesis of titanium diboride, especially when well-dispersed powders should be
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
71
prepared. The use of such electrolytes was motivated by the effort to exclude special and expensive boron and titanium sources, such as potassium fluoroborate and potassium fluorotitanate, which moreover introduced a surplus of potassium fluoride. Moreover, the systems of alkali metal halides containing boron oxide are technologically important too, since they may serve as potential electrolytes for boriding of steels and other metallic surfaces. The system LiF–KF–B2 O3 –TiO2 is a considerably complicated subsystem of the quinary reciprocal system Li+ , K+ , B3+ , Ti4+ // F− , O2− , in which a number of compounds are formed. However, the phase equilibria in the system LiF–KF–B2 O3 –TiO2 have been investigated and are still unsatisfactory. The existing phase equilibrium studies are as follows. The phase diagram of the binary system LiF–B2 O3 was studied by Berul and Nikonova (1966) and by Chrenková and Daneˇ k (1992a), especially in the range of high concentrations of LiF. This system is a part of the ternary reciprocal system Li+ , B3+ // F− , O2− and according to the Gibbs energy of reaction of the metathetical reaction, 6LiF(l) + B2 O3 (l) = 3Li2 O(l) + 2BF3 (g) r G01200K = 609.6kJ·mol−1
(2.76)
the system LiF–B2 O3 is the stable diagonal of the ternary reciprocal system. Berul and Nikonova (1966) studied the phase diagram of this system up to 55 mole % B2 O3 . According to this source, the congruently melting compound LiF·B2 O3 with the temperature of fusion of 840◦ C is formed in this system. In the composition interval of 5–23 mole % B2 O3 , the liquidus curve is parallel to the composition axis at 835◦ C, probably due to the existence of immiscibility in the liquid state. According to Daneˇ k and Chrenková (1992a), a miscibility gap in the region 5–23 mole % B2 O3 was found with the monotectic temperature of 836◦ C and the upper consolute temperature of 862◦ C at approximately 14 mole % B2 O3 . The part of the phase diagram of the system LiF–B2 O3 investigated by Daneˇ k and Chrenková (1992a) is shown in Figure 2.29. Among the possible chemical reactions in the ternary reciprocal system Li+ , B3+ // − F , O2− leading to the compound formation, the following four are considered to be probable: 6LiF(l) + 4B2 O3 (l) = 6LiBO2 (l) + 2BF3 (g) r G01200 K = 38.02 kJ·mol−1 8LiF(l) + 4B2 O3 (l) = 6LiBO2 (l) + 2LiBF4 (g) r G01200 K = 432.9 kJ·mol−1
(2.77)
(2.78)
72
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
880
t(°C)
860
840
820
800
LiF
0.1
x(B2O3)
0.2
0.3
Figure 2.29. Investigated part of the phase diagram of the system LiF–B2 O3 . • – Berul and Nikonova (1966); – Danˇek and Chrenková (1992a); —– ⇒ aLiF = xLiF .
6LiF(l) + 7B2 O3 (l) = 3Li2 B4 O7 (l) + 2BF3 (g) r G01200 K = −9.23 kJ·mol−1 8LiF(l) + 7B2 O3 (l) = 3Li2 B4 O7 (l) + 2LiBF4 (g) r G01200 K = 385.7 kJ·mol−1
(2.79)
(2.80)
From the values of the Gibbs energies of reaction, it follows that the equilibrium of reactions (2.78) and (2.80) is shifted considerably to the left side and the reactions do not take place. On the other hand, reactions (2.77) and (2.79) can take place with respect to the values of the Gibbs energies of reaction especially when BF3 escapes from the system. In order to explain the structure of the LiF–B2 O3 melts, the composition of the quenched samples was determined by means of X-ray powder diffraction analysis and IR spectroscopy. Both methods eliminated the presence of LiBF4 in the mixtures. On the other hand, the presence of LiBO2 up to 5 mole % B2 O3 and of Li2 B4 O7 at higher
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
73
contents of boron trioxide was confirmed. In dilute solutions of B2 O3 in molten LiF, reaction (2.77) obviously take place, while at higher B2 O3 contents, lithium metaborate polymerizes into more condensed polyanions. The repulsive effect of both the present anions, F− and the [B4 O7 ]2− leads at a certain content of B2 O3 to liquid separation into the LiF-like melt with a limited solubility of Li2 B4 O7 and the B2 O3 -like one, creating the immiscibility region. It should be concluded that LiF–B2 O3 is a quasi-binary system. In fact, the system is a projection of the LiF–LiBO2 –B2 O3 non-linear cross-section into the LiF–B2 O3 diagonal. The congruently melting compound LiF·B2 O3 mentioned by Berul and Nikonova (1966) is probably only the dystectic point on this cross-section. The density of the system LiF–B2 O3 was measured by Chrenková and Daneˇ k (1992c). The dependence of the molar volume on composition at 850◦ C was described by the equation V cm3 ·mol−1 = 14.365 + 21.573xB2 O3
(2.81)
and for the partial molar volume of B2 O3 in the infinitely diluted solution of LiF, the value VB2 O3 = 35.84 cm3 ·mol−1 was found, which is lower than the molar volume of pure B2 O3 at this temperature, VB02 O3 = 44.78 cm3 ·mol−1 . This volume contraction could be ascribed to the formation of lithium metaborate and the volatile BF3 according to reaction (2.74). BF3 escapes from the melt causing the volume contraction. In the ternary system LiF–Li2 O–B2 O3 , the phase diagram of the pseudo-binary system LiF–LiBO2 is known. The ternary congruently melting compound 2LiF·3LiBO2 with the temperature of fusion of 755◦ C, is formed in this system. The phase diagram of the system NaF–B2 O3 up to 65 mole % B2 O3 was studied by Bergman and Nagornyi (1943) and the cryoscopy in the system NaF–B2 O3 by Makyta (1993). It was found that in this system, sodium metaborate, sodium tetraborate, and gaseous boron trifluoride are created in the melts. The phase diagram of the ternary system LiF–NaF–B2 O3 studied Nikonova and Berul (1967). No ternary compound was found in this system. The liquidus curve of KF in the system KF–B2 O3 up to 20 mole % B2 O3 was determined by Chrenková and Daneˇ k (1992b) and Patarák et al. (1993), Patarák (1995). According to the value of the Gibbs energy of the metathetical reaction, 6KF(l) + B2 O3 (l) = 3K2 O(s) + 2BF3 (g) G01100K = 940kJ·mol−1
(2.82)
the system KF–B2 O3 should be the stable diagonal of the ternary reciprocal system K+ , B3+ // F− , O2− . However, a number of compounds are formed in this ternary reciprocal
74
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
system. From the thermodynamic analysis of the liquidus curve of KF, it follows that the reaction 8KF(l) + 7B2 O3 (l) = 3K2 B4 O7 (l) + 2KBF4 (l) G01200 K = −201.7 kJ·mol−1
(2.83)
yielding two complex compounds, KBF4 and K2 B4 O7 , takes place in the melts. The presence of both the compounds was also confirmed by means of the X-ray powder diffraction analysis and IR spectroscopy in the quenched samples. The positive deviation of the real liquidus curve from the theoretical one is most probably due to further polymerization of the borate species. Cryoscopic measurements of B2 O3 in molten sodium and potassium fluorides were performed by Makyta (1993). He obtained the best fit of the experimental and theoretical liquidus curve for the reaction 32KF(l) + 25B2 O3 (l) = 6KBO2 (l) + 9K2 B4 O7 (l) + 8KBF4 (l)
(2.84)
The last two compounds were confirmed by both the X-ray analysis and IR spectroscopy of quenched melts. K2 B4 O7 is created preferentially with an increasing content of B2 O3 in the mixture. The presence of metaborate anions, however, was not detected, most probably due to its low concentration in the melt. The density of the system KF–B2 O3 was measured by Chrenková and Daneˇ k (1992c). The density course in this system shows a minimum at 20 mole % B2 O3 . The concentration dependence of the molar volume at 1100 K was described by the second order polynomial V cm3 ·mol−1 = 30.14 + 23.33xB2 O3 −47.23xB2 2 O3
(2.85)
Differentiating Eq. (2.82) according to xB2 O3 , and inserting into the equation VB2 O3 = V + xKF
∂V ∂xB2 O3
(2.86)
we obtain the equation for the partial molar volume of B2 O3 at the temperature of 1100 K 2 VB2 O3 cm3 ·mol−1 = 6.384 + 47.225xKF
(2.87)
As it follows from this equation, for xKF → 1, the partial molar volume of B2 O3 at 1100 K attains the value VB2 O3 = 53.61cm3 ·mol−1 . This value is substantially higher than the molar volume of pure B2 O3 , VB2 O3 = 44.62 cm3 ·mol−1 , which indicates the
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
75
formation of larger ions. The formation of K2 B4 O7 and KBF4 according to equation (2.84) was confirmed by Makyta (1993) and Chrenková and Daneˇ k (1992b) using the X-ray diffraction and IR spectroscopic analyses of quenched melts. The IR spectroscopic and X-ray diffraction investigation of the interaction of components in the system KF–B2 O3 was carried out by Babushkina et al. (2000). Samples of the quenched melts were taken for measurement. The wave numbers of the observed bands in the IR spectra of investigated samples are given in Table 2.8. As it can be shown from the table, up to 15 mole % KF, the IR spectra of samples contain only bands of pure B2 O3 . The addition of KF obviously does not cause any substantial change in the structure. In the IR spectra of samples with 30 mole % KF and more, new well-defined bands can be observed, which may be attributed to the vibration modes of different species. The addition of KF to the B2 O3 melt and the successive increase in its concentration should lead to the formation of distorted tetrahedral oxofluoroborates linked in boroxol rings and chain fragments composing a 3D network. On the other hand, the addition of KF to the B2 O3 melt initiates the depolymerization of the 3D network and the disintegration of the boroxol rings under formation of smaller fragments. The structure of possible species present in the KF–B2 O3 melts are demonstrated schematically in Figure 2.30. The formation of the [BO3 F]4− tetrahedrons in the concentration range up to 70 mole % NaF in the system NaF–B2 O3 was suggested by Maya (1977), about what indicates the bands at 770 and 1000 cm−1 in the IR spectra. However, these bands may also be attributed to the formation of other tetrahedral species, e.g. BF− 4 or [BOn F4−n ]. From the IR spectra of the system KF–B2 O3 , it can be seen that by the addition of more than 30 mole % KF to molten B2 O3 the intensity of all the bands increased and attained the maximum at the molar ratio n(KF):n(B2 O3 ) = 2:1. At this concentration, for every Table 2.8. Assignment of the wave numbers of observed bands in the IR spectra of the quenched samples of the system KF–B2 O3 to the individual structural species
xKF xB 2 O 3 Wave number cm−1 [BO3 ]3− in boroxol rings 0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.30 0.50 0.70 0.85 0.90 0.95 1.00
1.00 0.95 0.90 0.85 0.70 0.50 0.30 0.15 0.10 0.05 0.00
700, 1450 700, 1450 700, 1450 700, 1370 710, 1350 550, 750, 1330 550, 730, 1340 550, 730, 1330 1350
[BO3 F]4− and [BO2 F2 ]3− distorted tetrahedrons
920, 1050 950, 1100 900, 1050 900, 1050 900, 1050 850, 1050 without bands
–O– bridges 1250 1250 1250 1250 1230 1270 1260 1260 1250 1250
76
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
F− O − O − \ − O − B〈O − B〈 O + KF → − O − B 〈O − B〈 O + KF → O − B〈 O − B〈 O − O − ∞ ∞ − 1 [B3O 6 ]3nn−
[BO 3 ]3nn− , [BO 3 F] 4−
D 3h
→
D 3h
C 3v
F− − F− | F \ O − B〈 −O− B〈 O O − B〈 O− [BO 3 ]3nn− , [BO 3 F] 4− , [BO 2 F2 ]3− D 3h
C 3v
−
− O O − − 〉 〈 B O B − O O−
pyroborate, [B 2 O 5 ]4−
C 2v
−
O− O − B〈 − O
orthoborate, [BO 3 ]3−
F F F〉 B〈 F
−
[BF4 ]− , Td
Figure 2.30. Disintegration of the 3D network of B2 O3 by addition of KF and structure of the possible species in the KF–B2 O3 melt.
atom of boron, one supplementary atom of fluorine is introduced, which theoretically enables boron to be fully in four-fold coordination. However, at this molar ratio of the components, the diffraction lines of potassium fluoride could be already observed, which would indicate the formation of all the possible structures containing boron and fluorine. At the next KF addition to B2 O3 (>70 mole % KF), no new bands or vanishing of the existing ones in the IR spectra could be observed, which refers to the steadiness of the ensemble of oxofluoroborate species in this concentration region. The phase diagram of the system LiF–KF–B2 O3 up to 30 mole % B2 O3 was determined by Chrenková and Daneˇ k (1992b). In the region of the primary crystallization of LiF, a liquid miscibility gap was found to exist at compositions from 5 to 23 mole % B2 O3 in
500
77
0 80
700
600
500
0 60
0 70
0.1
0 80
6
0.9
0.2
83
0.8
) O3 B2 x(
x (K F)
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
KF
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5 x (LiF)
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
LiF
Figure 2.31. Investigated part of the phase diagram of the system LiF–KF–B2 O3 .
the LiF–B2 O3 boundary system and up to 12 mole % KF. The reaction of components according to the equation 2LiF(l) + 6KF(l) + 7B2 O3 (l) = Li2 B4 O7 (l) + 2K2 B4 O7 (l) + 2BF3 (g) r G01200 K = −136.5 kJ·mol−1
(2.88)
was supposed to take place in the ternary system LiF–KF–B2 O3 . The phase diagram of this system is shown in Figure 2.31. The phase equilibrium study in the system LiF–KF–B2 O3 –TiO2 was performed by Chrenková and Daneˇ k (1992b). Owing to the low solubility of titanium oxide in alkali metal halides, the phase equilibrium study was performed in the cross-section with a constant content of 5 mole % TiO2 only, since the addition of TiO2 into molten LiF or the molten LiF–KF mixtures, insoluble Li2 TiO3 precipitates immediately from the melt. The solubility of TiO2 increases significantly when B2 O3 is present. However, at concentrations of LiF higher than 50 mole %, precipitation of Li2 TiO2 occurs anyway. The phase equilibrium in the ternary reciprocal system Li+ , K+ //F− , [TiO3 ]2− was studied by Nikonova and Berul (1967). Also this system was studied up to approximately 40 mole % LiF only, since above this, the LiF content Li2 TiO3 precipitates from the melt. It was found that the system KF–Li2 TiO3 is the stable diagonal of the above-mentioned reciprocal system. This could also be confirmed by the calculation of the standard Gibbs energy of the metathetical reaction 2KF(l) + Li2 TiO3 (l) = 2LiF(l) + K2 TiO3 (l) r G01200K = 32 kJ·mol−1
(2.89)
78
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
Reactions of titanates with alkali metal fluorides and the phase diagrams of the ternary 2− + + − reciprocal systems Li+ , Na+ // F− , TiO2− 3 and Li , K // F , TiO3 were investigated by Sigida and Belyaev (1957) and Belyaev and Sigida (1957), respectively. From the results of these works, it follows that Li2 TiO3 is soluble in NaF, KF, Na2 TiO3 and K2 TiO3 , but insoluble in LiF. However, in systems based on LiF, the addition of Na2 TiO3 or K2 TiO3 may cause precipitation of Li2 TiO3 from the melt. The phase diagram of the ternary reciprocal system Na+ , K+ // F− , TiO2− 3 was studied by Sholokhovich (1955). Two binary compounds, Na2 TiO3 ·K2 TiO3 and (Na2 TiO3 )3 · 2NaF, are formed in this system. The authors qualify this ternary reciprocal system as irreversible. The dissolution of M2 TiO3 (M = Li, Na, K) in molten NaF and KF and the ionic structure of the melts were studied using the cryoscopic method by Makyta and Zatko (1993). From the measurement, it follows that the number of new particles created in the melt by introducing one molecule of alkali metal titanate is 1 for systems with a common cation, and 3 for reciprocal systems. The proposed mechanism of dissolution explains the dissolution of Li2 TiO3 in NaF and KF and its precipitation from systems containing LiF as a solvent. The explanation was based on the comparison of the calculated (α calc ) and experimental (α exp ) values of the degree of conversion of the exchange reaction α 2MF + N2 TiO3 −→ 2NF + M2 TiO3
(2.90)
where α is the degree of conversion. The calculation confirmed the presumption that reaction (2.1.7.4.–15) runs in the region of the diluted solution quantitatively. The system (LiF–NaF–KF)eut –KBF4 –B2 O3 is a part of the (LiF–NaF–KF)eut – K2 TaF7 –KBF4 –B2 O3 –Ta2 O5 system, where melts were proposed as electrolytes in the electrochemical synthesis of tantalum diboride by Polyakova et al (1998, 1999). The phase equilibrium in the ternary systems NaF–NaBF4 –B2 O3 and KF–KBF4 – B2 O3 were studied by Selivanov (1960). Both are simple eutectic systems. However, Maya (1977) later found that in the system NaF–NaBF4 –B2 O3 , at low oxide contents the compound Na3 B3 O3 F6 is formed. In the mixture containing up to 33.3 mole % B2 O3 , the ternary compound Na2 B3 O3 F5 is formed. In the ternary system, KF–KBF4 – B2 O3 , the cross-section KF–B3 O3 F3 up to 60 mole % B3 O3 F3 was studied by Andriiko et al. (1988). In this system, the ternary compound K3 B3 O3 F6 , melting congruently at 560◦ C, is formed. The formation of oxofluoroborate species as a function of oxygen content in fluoride solvents was investigated using Raman and IR spectroscopy by von Barner et al. (1999). For n0 /nB mole ratios up to 0.4, it is suggested that [B2 OF6 ]2− with the B–O–B bridge is formed in equilibrium with the BF− 4 complex. In the samples with oxide to boron mole ratios near one, the ion B3 O3 F3− with a six–membered non-planar B3 O3 6 ring of alternating B and O atoms and with two fluorine atoms coordinated to each boron atom in a tetrahedral configuration, could be identified.
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
79
The density, viscosity, X-ray diffraction analysis, and IR spectroscopy of quenched melts of the system (KF–LiF–NaF)eut –KBF4 –B2 O3 were measured by Chrenková et al. (2003b). From the results, it follows that in the binary system FLINAK–KBF4 , no new compounds are formed. However, the BF− 4 anion partially decomposes due to the high polarization ability of the Li+ cation. In the system FLINAK–B2 O3 , the components react under the formation of potassium tetraborate (K2 B4 O7 ), and volatile boron trifluoride (BF3 ), or potassium tetrafluoroborate (KBF4 ). The last compound was, however, not observed in the IR spectra. According to Maya (1977), Andriiko et al. (1988), and von Barner et al. (1999), there are two principal compounds originating in the ternary system FLINAK–KBF4 – B2 O3 . The compound K3 B3 O3 F6 originates at the molar ratio nB /n0 ≈ 1, while the compound K2 B2 OF6 is formed at nB /n0 ≥ 2. The presence of these compounds in the system FLINAK–KBF4 –B2 O3 was also confirmed by Chrenková et al. (2001). This is evident both from the X-ray diffraction pattern and the IR spectra of the investigated samples. In Figure 2.32 (according to Chrenková et al. (2001)), the IR spectra of samples with different nB /n0 ratio are compared with those of the pure compounds K2 B2 OF6 and K3 B3 O3 F6 . From Figure 2.31, it follows that at the molar ratio nB /n0 = 1, predominantly 2− the anion B3 O3 F3− 6 is formed, while at the ratio nB /n0 = 3, only the anion B2 OF6 is present. At the molar ratio nB /n0 = 2, both the species are present in the melt. 2.1.8. Systems containing jumping electrons
Electronic conduction in inorganic melts can occur when atoms of the same kind in different oxidation states are present. Such systems exhibit an increased electrical conductivity with an exponential character of its temperature dependence, caused by a diffusion-like motion called hopping mechanism. The hopping mechanism is characterized by low mobility at elevated temperatures and the charge carrier is termed as a small-polaron. The mobility of the small-polaron is much lower compared to that of the carrier in a broad semi-conductor band. At low temperatures, the small-polaron moves by Bloch-type band motion, while at elevated temperatures it moves by thermally activated hopping mechanism. Holstein (1959), Friedman and Holstein (1963), Friedman (1964) performed the theoretical calculations of small-polaron motion and showed that the temperature dependencies of the small-polaron mobility in the two regimes are different. In the high-temperature hopping regime, the electrical conductivity is thermally activated and it increases with increasing temperature. As shown by Naik and Tien (1978), its temperature dependence is characterized by the following equation κ0 Em κ(T ) = 3/2 exp − kT T
(2.91)
80
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
Relative transmitance
B2OF6–
B2OF6–
1
B2OF6–
B2OF6–
2 KF
BF4–
3 4 KF KF
5 KF
B3O3F63– B3O3F63– B3O3F63– B3O3F63–
1600
1400
1200
1000
800
600
400
Wavenumber(cm–1) Figure 2.32. Infrared spectra of quenched samples in the system (LiF–NaF–KF)eut –KBF4 –B2 O3 . 1 – K2 B2 OF6 ; 2 – nB /n0 = 3; 3 – nB /n0 = 2; 4 – nB /n0 = 1; 5 – K3 B3 O3 F6 .
where κ0 is a constant, Em is the activation energy for mobility, and T is the thermodynamic temperature. In this case, the charge of the carrier is localized at a specific site, for example on a cation, and its movement under the influence of electric field occurs in discrete leaps from one site to another. The hopping mechanism is expected at temperatures exceeding 500◦ C. In inorganic melts, the hopping mechanism is caused by the presence of “free” electrons, which are responsible for the partial electronic conductivity. “Free” electrons originate in the melt, when cations of the same kind in two oxidation states are present and the electrons jump between the two ions, being in different oxidation states. Such a
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
81
“localized” group, i.e. the electron and the entrapping atomic displacement, denoted as the small-polaron, has only a low mobility and it can be easily described on the basis of the diffusion theory. This phenomenon was observed e.g. in metal–metal halide systems and in the system CuCl–CuCl2 . The above mechanism for the charge transport in melts was supposed by Rice (1961) and elaborated by Raleigh (1963) to explain the exponential conductivity increase with increasing metal content in the system Bi–BiCl3 . In this case the electron is jumping between Bi+ and Bi3+ ions. Rice (1961) and Raleigh (1963) supposed that the concentration of electrons is proportional to the concentration of cations in the lower oxidation state. Such a condition is well fulfilled in metal–metal halide systems in the range of high concentrations of metal halide (when the metal is a minor component). However, in systems with comparable concentrations of both the cations, the situation is somewhat different. An electron can jump only when an electron donor has an electron acceptor in its neighborhood. The probability that such an acceptor is available is equal to the product x(Mex+ )·x(Me(x+1)+ ). The exponential character of the temperature dependence of electrical conductivity is due to the fact that the concentration of cations in lower oxidation state increases with increasing temperature, which consequently increases the jump probability of the electron. Some examples of electronic conductivity in the melt will be described in the following chapters. 2.1.8.1. Metal–metal halide systems
Properties of the metal–metal halide systems have been studied since the first Davy’s observations of colored melts near the cathode at the electrolysis of alkali metal hydroxides. However, already the knowledge of these molten systems was substantially improved 50 years ago by the pioneering work of Bredig et al. (1958), who investigated the phase equilibria in a number of alkali metal–alkali metal halide and earth alkali metal–earth alkali metal halide systems. Further interest was also aroused in the case of •
• • •
rare metal–rare metal halide systems investigated by Mellors and Senderoff (1959), Eastman et al. (1950), Druding and Corbett (1961), Polyachenok and Novikov (1963), and McCollum et al. (1973), the bismuth–bismuth chloride system, whose phase diagram was investigated by Yosim et al. (1959, 1962) and Hoshino et al. (1979), aluminum–aluminum chloride, zinc–zinc chloride, and cadmium–cadmium chloride systems studied by Elagina and Palkin (1956) and Palkin and Belousov (1957), galium–galium chloride and indium–indium chloride systems investigated by Palkin and Ostrikova (1964), Chadwick et al. (1966), Chernykh and Safonov (1979), and Fedorov and Fadeev (1964).
The investigation of these systems was initiated by their importance in the electrolytic metal production and material science, their potential use in fuel cells, nuclear power
82
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
plants, etc. A short review of the metal–molten salt systems with the emphasis on the electrochemical properties of the dissolved metal was given by Haarberg and Thonstad (1989). In some systems there is a total miscibility between metal and salt, in others, the metal solubility. All the phase diagrams are characterized by the lowering of the melting point of the salt when the metal is added. This phenomenon is indicative of true solutions. Several systems exhibit a region with two immiscible liquid phases, i.e. “the miscibility gap”. Systems with miscibility gap show positive deviation from Raoult’s law, i.e. the activity coefficient of the salt is larger than unity. Above a certain temperature, which is called “the critical temperature of miscibility” or above the “consolute temperature”, salt and metal are completely miscible at all compositions. In Figure 2.33, the phase diagrams of the KX–K (X = F, Cl, Br, I) and RF–R (R = Li, Na, K, Rb, Cs) systems according to Bredig et al. (1958) are shown. The melting points of the metals are always lower than those of the respective salts. The characteristic feature of these systems is the formation of a more or less extended miscibility gap. In the potassium–potassium halide systems, the concentration extent of immiscibility increases
904°
900 LiF – Li
KF – K
850
1200
849°
NaF – Na
800
790°
1000
KCI – K 751.5°
750
728° K Br – K 717° 708°
700
KF – K
800
KI – K
RbF – Rb
658.5°
650 CsF – Cs
0
20
40 60 Mol. % K
80
100
600 RF
25
50 75 Mol. % Metal
R
Figure 2.33. Phase diagrams of the systems KX–K (X = F, Cl, Br, I) and RF–R (R = Li, Na, K, Rb, Cs) according to Bredig et al. (1958).
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
83
with the increasing ionic radius of the anion, while in the alkali metal fluoride–alkali metal systems, it decreases with the increasing ionic radius of the cation, vanishing in the CsF–Cs system. In principle, the occurrence of the miscibility gap is caused by the polarization ability of ions and the magnitude of the repulsing forces between ions of the same kind. In the KX–K systems the repulsive forces between K+ ions are, however, shielded by anions of different size, which influences the width of the miscibility gap. The phase diagrams of the MeCl2 –Me (Me = Ca, Sr, Ba) systems according to Bredig et al. (1958) are shown in Figure 2.34. While the immiscibility in these systems extends almost over the whole concentration range, the upper critical temperature decreases from calcium to barium. This effect is coherent again with the magnitude of the repulsion forces between Me2+ cations. Figure 2.35 shows the phase diagrams of the systems MeF2 –Me (Me = Ca, Ba) according to Bredig et al. (1958). There is no miscibility gap in these systems; however, the tendency to admixture is evident. Obviously the repulsion forces between Me2+ cations are not so strong as to create a miscibility gap, since they are shielded by the F− anions. Finally, in Figure 2.36, the phase diagrams of the system BiCl3 –Bi according to Yosim et al. (1959, 1962) and of the system CeCl3 –Ce according to Mellors and Senderoff (1959) are shown. Wide regions of immiscibility are characteristic for these systems, which are due to the very strong repulsive forces between Bi3+ and Ce3+ cations, respectively. When a metal dissolves in a pure molten salt, a color change is often observed. The intensity of the color often increases with an increasing concentration of the dissolved metal. Solidified melts with dissolved metal are usually gray due to finely
1200 1200
Liquid
1200
Liquid
1000 1100
1000
Two liquids Liq.
Two liquids Two liquids
1000 800 900 825°
800 773°
800
828°
767°
600
700 CaCI2 20 40 60 Mol. %
80
Ca
Sr CI2 20 40 60 Mol. %
80 Sr
600 BaCI2 20
40 60 Mol. %
80 Ba
Figure 2.34. Phase diagrams of the systems MeCl2 –Me (Me = Ca, Sr, Ba) according to Bredig et al. (1958).
84
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
1400
1400
Liquid
Liquid
1200
1300 CaF2 ss + Liquid
1200
1000
1100 1000
800
900
730°
800
CaF2 + Ca
CaF2
20
40 60 Mol %
80
Ca
BaF2 20
40
60
80
Ba
Figure 2.35. Phase diagrams of the systems MeF2 –Me (Me = Ca, Ba) according to Bredig et al. (1958).
800 Liq.2
700 Liq.1
600
850
Liq.1 + Liq.2
500
Liq.
800
400
Two liquids
802°
BiCl3 + Liq.1
300
Liq.1 + BiCl
750
Liq.2 + Bi
200 100
Liq.2 + BiCl
BiCl + Bi
BiCl3 + BiCl
700
0 0 BiCl3
20
40
60 Mol. %
80
100 Bi
CeCI3
20
40 60 Mol. %
80
Ce
Figure 2.36. Phase diagrams of the systems BiCl3 –Bi according to Yosim et al. (1959, 1962) and CeCl3 –Ce according to Mellors and Senderoff (1959).
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
85
dispersed metal. Corbett and von Winbush (1955), Corbett et al. (1957, 1961) studied several systems and observed color changes after the addition of metal to the pure molten salt. Transport of subhalides from the melt into the gas phase was also examined. The next characteristic feature of the metal–metal halide systems is the partial electronic conductivity caused by the presence of the same metallic atoms in two oxidation states. In general, the conductivity of the melt is given by the equation κ= zi F u i c i (2.92) i
where ci is the molar concentration of the conducting particles (ions and electrons) with charge zi , ui is their mobility, and F is the Faraday constant. In the low concentration region of the metals of the MX–M melts, the total conductivity can be divided into the ionic and electronic conductivities, respectively. The conducting particles are cations and anions, forming the ionic part of the total conductivity, and electrons, forming the electronic conductivity. Equation (2.92) can thus be written in the form
κ = κion + κel = F zM+ uM+ cM+ + zX− uX− cX− + ze− ue− ce−
(2.93)
According to Bredig (1964), the electron can jump only when a donor (M) has an acceptor (M+ ) in its neighborhood. The probability that such an arrangement is available is in due proportion to xM0 xM+ . The molar concentration of electrons then should be equal to the expression ce − =
x M 0 xM + Vmelt
(2.94)
Experimental conductivity data in binary systems can be presented in different ways. (1)
The measured conductivity of the mixture is treated as the sum of the conductivity of the molten salt and that of the dissolved metal κMX−M = κMX + κM
(2)
(2.95)
The electrical conductivity is expressed in terms of equivalent conductivities λMX−M = xMX λMX + xM λM
(2.96)
where xMX and xM are equivalent fractions of molten salt and dissolved metal, respectively. The equivalent conductivity of the dissolved metal is then given by λM =
λMX−M −(1−xM )λMX xM
(2.97)
86
(3)
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
An alternative expression is
κMX−M VMX−M = xM λM + (1−xM )κMX VMX
(2.98)
where Vi are the molar volumes. The chosen presentation of experimental data depends on the purpose for which the data will be used. 2.1.8.2. Electronic conduction in aluminum electrolytes
The current efficiency in modern cells of aluminum electrolysis may exceed 95%. It is generally accepted that the major part of loss in current efficiency is due to the reaction between dissolved metal and electrolyte. Model studies by Ødegard et al. (1988) indicates that sodium dissolves in the electrolyte in the form of free Na, while dissolved Al is predominantly present as the monovalent species AlF− 2 . Any electronic conductivity is most likely associated with the Na species, which may form trapped electrons and electrons in the conduction band. Morris (1975) ascribed the loss in current efficiency during Al production to electronic conduction. In a theoretical and experimental study, Dewing and Yoshida (1976) subsequently maintained that the electronic conductivity was too low to account for the loss in current efficiency in industrial aluminum cells. However, the existence of electronic conduction in NaF–AlF3 melts was demonstrated later by Borisoglebskii et al. (1978) also. Several authors studied the solubility of Al in melts of the system NaF–AlF3 –Al2 O3 . In addition to dissolved aluminum, sodium also has to be considered, and the solubility depends on the composition of the melt, as shown in Table 2.9. Most authors agree that the solubility decreases with decreasing NaF/AlF3 ratio and increasing alumina content. Ødegard et al. (1988) performed an extensive study of the effect of several additives on the total aluminum solubility. The results were summarized by the equation
log(cAl ) = −1.825−0.5919/CR + 3429/T −3.39×10−2 cAl2 O3 /cAl2 O3 (sat) −2.41×10−2 cMgF2 −2.03×10−2 cCaF2 −2.49×10−2 cLiF
(2.99)
where CR is the molar NaF/AlF3 ratio and all concentrations are in mass %, T is the temperature in K, and cAl2 O3 (sat) is the saturation concentration of alumina. Reaction models were fitted to experimental data using the available activity data and the Temkin’s
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
87
Table 2.9. Solubility of Al and Na in NaF–AlF3 –Al2 O3 melts NaF/AlF3
t (◦ C)
molar ratio 1 3 3 6 3 3 3 3 2.25 2.25 3 4
1000 1000 1000 1000 980 980 980 980 962 1000 1000 1000
Al2 O3
Solubility
References
(mass %)
Al (mass %)
Na (mass %)
Total as Al (mass %)
sat. sat. sat. sat. 2 4 6 8 sat. 0 sat. sat.
– 0.065 – – 0.06 0.05 0.04 0.03 – – – –
– 0.090 – – 0.12 0.09 0.08 0.06 – – – –
0.075 0.10 0.14 0.33 0.11 0.09 0.07 0.05 0.054 0.076 0.083 0.090
Thonstad (1965); Ødegard et al. (1988); Yoshida et al. (1986).
model. Near the cryolite composition, two most probable dissolution reactions were considered Al(l) + 3NaF(l) = AlF3 (diss) + 3Na(diss)
(2.100)
+ 2Al(l) + AlF3 (diss) + 3NaF = 3AlF− 2 + 3Na
(2.101)
+ The presence of monovalent aluminum in the form of AlF− 2 rather than Al or AlF has also been suggested by Saget et al. (1975) and Yoshida et al. (1986) to explain the concentration dependence on the solubility. Thonstad and Oblakowski (1980) demonstrated that the migration of the dissolved metal species such as AlF− 2 may take place in cryolite-alumina melts. Hence a certain activity of sodium is established at the metal/electrolyte interface. The excess electrons associated with dissolved sodium likely cause electronic conduction, which may limit the obtainable current efficiency. Earlier results of electronic conductivity in the molten system Na3AlF6 –Al2 O3 (sat)–Al at 1000◦ C obtained by Haarberg et al. (1993) were also reproduced with high accuracy later by Haarberg et al. (2002). The total conductivity was determined to be 3.11 S · cm−1 , while the ionic conductivity is 2.22 S · cm−1 . Assuming that the increase in conductivity is due to the electronic conduction, the electronic conductivity is 0.89 S · cm−1 . This corresponds to a transport number of electrons of 0.29 in the aluminum-saturated electrolyte. However, a gradient with respect to the dissolved metal near the cathode during industrial electrolysis cuts down the effect of electronic conduction. Haarberg et al. (2002) found that the electronic conductivity increases with an increasing NaF content and increasing temperature. The variation of the Na activity shows the same trend. This supports the
88
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
theory that localized electrons with relatively high mobility are formed in the melt due to the interaction between Al and the electrolyte to form dissolved Na. It is commonly accepted that due to the mixing of the electrolyte in industrial cells, the concentration gradients of dissolved metal are present only in the boundary layers at the cathode and the anode, as illustrated in Figure 2.37. Therefore, during electrolysis in cryolite–alumina melts there is a gradient in the transport number of electrons, te , across the cell te =
κe κe +κion
(2.102)
In a cell where ions and electrons migrate simultaneously, the current density of electrons, ie , is proportional to the electrochemical potential of electrons ηe ie =
κe F
∂ηe ∂x
(2.103)
The ionic current density, iion , is given by iion = −
κion F
∂µNa ∂ηe − ∂x ∂x
(2.104)
Anode 0 xg
Bath
xm L n0(e) nm (e)
Cathode nL(e)
Figure 2.37. Profile of electron concentration across the bath during Al electrolysis.
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
89
where µNa is the chemical potential of Na in the electrolyte. The total current density, i, through the cell is i = ie +iion
(2.105)
Combining and rearranging Eqs. (2.102) – (2.105) yield the following expression for ionic current density,
iion =
i L
L
L tion dx −
µNa te dµNa
κion LF
0
(2.106)
µ0Na
where L is the inter-electrode distance (see Figure 2.36). The ionic current density during electrolysis can be determined from Eq. (2.106) using the obtained data for electronic conductivity in dependence on the Na activity. The current efficiency is given by the equation CE =
iion 100 i
(2.107)
This treatment is based on the assumption that there is no convection in the electrolyte. This is far from the situation during industrial electrolysis. However, the major contribution from electronic conduction originates in the diffusion layer near the cathode, which can be assumed to be stagnant. A detailed description of the mathematical approach and the results of measurement can be found in the literature (Thonstad and Oblakowski, 1980; Haarberg et al. 1991, 1993, 1998, 2002). 2.1.8.3. The sodium oxide–sodium vanadate system
In the combustion of fuels containing vanadium and alkali in gas turbines originate ionic melts as undesirable side products. These melts consisting mostly vanadium and sodium oxides lead to the formation of corrosive sediments on construction materials of turbines and steam pre-heaters, and form corrosion products on the heating surfaces. The layer of molten ash by its chemical and transport properties accelerates the corrosion process due to the transport of oxygen to the metal–melt interface, where the anodic oxidation of the metal proceeds. The electrons and corrosion products proceed in the opposite direction through the melt to the melt–gas interface, where the cathodic depolarization reaction takes place. Regarding the study of chemistry of this corrosion, the knowledge of the physico-chemical properties of the basic system V2 O5 –Na2 O appears to be of prime importance.
90
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
Vanadium pentoxide decomposes partially at melting according to the reaction 1 α V2 O5 ←→ V2 O4 + O2 2
(2.108)
The equilibrium of this reaction depends on the partial pressure of oxygen and temperature. On the basis of the experimentally determined temperature dependence of the equilibrium constant, Pantony and Vasu (1968) calculated the heat of reaction (2.108) and obtained the value 6.12 kJ·mol−1 . The theoretical value, however, calculated on the basis of the thermodynamic data is 1.86 kJ·mol−1 . The difference, 4.26 kJ·mol−1 , represents the partial molar heat of solution of V2 O4 in V2 O5 . The high value of the heat of solution indicates the formation of vanadyl-vanadates in the melt. This is obviously responsible for the properties of molten V2 O5 , which appears to be a semi-conductor of the type n. The electronic conductivity is stipulated by the increased concentration of V2 O4 in the quasi-crystalline structure of V2 O5 and its existence is also confirmed by a small change in the conductivity at the solid→liquid phase transition of V2 O5 . The addition of Na2 O or of other alkali and alkaline earth oxides to V2 O5 favors the dissociation of V2 O5 and consequently, also the formation of defects in its quasicrystalline structure, thus facilitating the transport of oxygen across the layer of molten ash. The compounds formed by V2 O5 and alkali metal oxides are known as “vanadium bronzes” and their crystal structure is close to that of V2 O5 . Vanadium bronzes, Nax V2 O5 , where x varies in the range 0.13 < x > 0.31, represent a series of non-stoichiometric compounds with univalent metal M atoms localized in the distorted structure of V2 O5 . The valence electrons of M metals are trapped by the vanadium atoms of the V2 O5 matrix so that V(IV) atoms are in tetragonal distortion with a moderate spin-orbital coupling. The trapped electron is equivalent to the small polaron of Holstein (1959). The electrical conductivity of such a system is exponentially dependent on temperature. During solidification, vanadium bronzes release oxygen, whereas they bind it during melting. According to Flood and Sørum (1946), besides the non-stoichiometric compound Nax V2 O5 , another compound, Na0.9 V3 O8 , should be formed. On the other hand, according to Ozerov (1957) and Illarionov et al. (1957), in the above system there exists a stable compound Na0.33 V2 O5 and yet another compound, which could not be unambiguously identified. Reisman and Mineo (1962), in the study of interaction of components of the system V2 O5 –Li2 O determined that three compounds are formed in this system: the incongruently melting compounds 2Li2 O·17V2 O5 and 2Li2 O·5V2 O5 and the congruently melting lithium metavanadate Li2 O·V2 O5 . The existence of alkali metal metavanadates of the type MeVO3 was also determined in systems containing Na2 O and K2 O. Reisman and Mineo (1962) assumed that also in the system V2 O5 –Na2 O, most probably the
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
91
incongruently melting compound 2Na2 O·5V2 O5 would be formed. The existence of an analogous incongruently melting compound 2K2 O·5V2 O5 was determined by Illarionov et al. (1956). Figure 2.38 shows the phase diagram of the system V2 O5 –NaVO3 measured by Daneˇ k et al. (1973). It was confirmed that two compounds are formed in this system: the congruently melting 2Na2 O·17V2 O5 and the incongruently melting 2Na2 O·5V2 O5 . At freezing, close to the phase transition temperature of 724◦ C the compound 2Na2 O·17V2 O5 releases oxygen, most probably according to the scheme 2Na2 O·17V2 O5 = 17Na0.235 V2 O5 + O2
(2.109)
The originating compound belongs to the group of vanadium bronzes as stated by Flood and Sørum (1946). At melting, reaction (2.109) proceeds in the opposite direction, since below the melting point the partial pressure of oxygen is evidently higher than above the melting point. The compound 2Na2 O·17V2 O5 is analogous to the compound 2Li2 O·17V2 O5 identified by Reisman and Mineo (1962). There is a narrow area of solid solutions of V2 O5 in the vanadium bronze Na0.235 V2 O5 , the existence of which was also assumed by Illarionov et al. (1957). The identification of the compound 2Na2 O·5V2 O5 confirmed the assumption of its existence presented by
800
750
650
550
2Na2O.5V2O5
600
2Na2O.17V2O5
t(°C)
700
500
V2O5
0.2
0.4
0.6 x(NaVO3)
0.8
NaVO3
Figure 2.38. Phase diagram of the system V2 O5 –NaVO3 according to Danˇek et al. (1973).
92
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
Reisman and Mineo (1962), who determined the analogous compound 2Li2 O·5V2 O5 . On the other hand, no compound of this type was found by Illarionov et al. (1957). The physico-chemical properties, i.e. density, viscosity, and electrical conductivity, of the system V2 O5 –NaVO3 were measured by Daneˇ k et al. (1974). In Figure 2.39, the density isotherms of the system V2 O5 –NaVO3 mixtures are presented. From the course of the isotherms it is evident that the density changes only slightly with increasing concentrations of Na2 O in the melt. On the other hand, the temperature dependence of the density of mixtures close to the composition corresponding to vanadium bronze Na0.235 VO3 , seems to be of definite interest. The coefficient of thermal expansion of this melt appears to be markedly lower than of any other mixtures over the entire investigated concentration range. This indicates a qualitative difference in the structure of the melt. It can be assumed that the combination of V2 O5 groups in vanadium bronze is more pronounced, which leads to a relative decrease in the free volume of the melt and is indicated by the decrease in the coefficient of thermal expansion. This assumption was also confirmed by the course of the viscosity isotherms of the molten system V2 O5 –NaVO3 , which are shown in Figure 2.40. The maximum on the viscosity isotherms corresponds to the formation of vanadium bronze Na0.235 VO3 . Such a maximum on the viscosity isotherms can be explained only by the formation of big structural entities in the melt. The isotherms of the electrical conductivity are presented in Figure 2.41. Also in this case, the maximum on the isotherms corresponds to the composition of vanadium bronze. The coincidence of these maximums on the isotherms of both the viscosity and the
2.6
ρ(g.cm−3)
2.5
2.4
2.3
2.2
V2O5
0.2
0.4 0.6 x(NaVO3)
0.8
NaVO3
Figure 2.39. Isotherms of the density of the molten V2 O5 –NaVO3 mixtures. – 750◦ C; – 800◦ C; – 850◦ C; – 900◦ C.
◦ – 650◦ C; • – 700◦ C;
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
93
100
η(mPa.s)
80
60
40
20
0
V2O5
0.2
0.4 0.6 x(NaVO3)
0.8
NaVO3
Figure 2.40. Isotherms of the viscosity of the molten V2 O5 –NaVO3 mixtures. – 750◦ C; – 800◦ C; – 850◦ C; – 900◦ C.
◦ – 650◦ C; • – 700◦ C;
2.5
κ(S.cm−1)
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
V2O5
0.2
0.4 0.6 x(NaVO3)
0.8
NaVO3
Figure 2.41. Isotherms of the electrical conductivity of the molten V2 O5 –NaVO3 mixtures. • – 700◦ C; – 750◦ C; – 800◦ C; – 850◦ C; – 900◦ C.
◦ – 650◦ C;
electrical conductivity can be explained only by the existence of “free” electrons, which are responsible for the partial electronic conductivity of these melts. As the existence of neutral sodium atoms in the presence of V(V) atoms is highly improbable, the partial electronic conductivity can be explained by transfer of the valence electron from the alkali metal to the free d-orbital of the vanadium atom. A direct evidence of the existence
94
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
2.0
κ (S.cm−1)
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0 650
700
750
800 t(°C)
850
900
950
Figure 2.42. Polytherms of the electrical conductivity of the molten V2 O5 –NaVO3 mixtures. – V2 O5 ; ◦ – 10% NaVO3 ; – 18% NaVO3 ; – 21% NaVO3 ; • – 33% NaVO3 ; – 50% NaVO3 .
of V(IV) atoms, and thus of the formation of the small polaron inside the array of V2 O5 was delivered by the EPR measurements carried out by Gendell et al. (1962) in lithium bronzes. The temperature dependencies of the electrical conductivity of the molten V2 O5 –NaVO3 mixtures are shown in Figure 2.42. The exponential character of electrical conductivity polytherms of mixtures in the concentration range 10–50 mole % NaVO3 indicates the presence of the small polaron in these melts. 2.1.8.4. Alkali metal sulfates containing cobalt sulfate
In the combustion of fuels containing sulfur and alkali in gas turbines, molten ash deposits originate, which contains alkali sulfates. Sulfur trioxide, which has been identified by Cutler (1971) as the main corrosive agent in molten alkali sulfates, is easily soluble in sulfate melts, acts as an oxidizing agent, and increases the solubility of the oxidation layers in the sulfate melts. Umland and Voigt (1970) followed the influence of cobalt content in the metal on the mechanism and rate of corrosion in molten sulfates. CoSO4 produced by the corrosion of Co-containing steels and alloys, gives rise to a complex anion [Co(SO4 )2 ]2− , which shows an increased stability in a certain temperature region. Since Co can exist in more than one oxidation state, a stabile redox system originates on the respective phase interfaces according to the following reaction scheme Co ↔ Co2+ + 2e−
(2.110)
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
95
Co2+ + O2− ↔ CoO
(2.111)
2− CoO+SO2− 4 + SO3 ↔ [Co(SO4 )2 ]
(2.112)
The originating complex anion enables the transfer of electrons from the metallic surface to the melt/gaseous phase interface according to the following scheme [Co(SO4 )2 ]2− ↔ [Co(SO4 )2 ]− +e−
(2.113)
According to Umland and Voigt (1970), the system Co(II)/Co(III) attains maximum stability at a temperature of approximately 750◦ C. Analogical sulfate–metallic anions originate also with iron; however, these are more stable at temperatures in the range 500–600◦ C. Matiašovský et al. (1973) measured the density, viscosity, and electrical conductivity of the ternary eutectic mixture of alkali metal sulfates, Li2 SO4 –Na2 SO4 –K2 SO4 , with the addition of NiSO4 and CoSO4 as the products of the sulfate corrosion. The viscosity versus temperature plots of the melts of the alkali metal sulfate ternary eutectic mixture with the addition of CoSO4 is shown in Figure 2.43. The addition of CoSO4 increases the viscosity of the ternary eutectics. The course of the polytherms of the viscosity with a higher content of CoSO4 is not monotonous. At the temperature 700◦ C anomalies on the polytherms could be seen, beginning at the concentration of 5 mole % CoSO4 and at 10 mole % the anomaly is strongly expressed. It can be expected that in the concentration range 2–5 mole % CoSO4 , besides the ionic the electronic conductivity also starts to
60 50
η(mPa.s)
40 30 20 10 0 550
600
650
700
750
t(°C) Figure 2.43. Viscosity polytherms of the alkali metal sulfate ternary eutectics with the addition of CoSO4 . eutectics with the addition of CoSO4 . ◦ – ternary eutectics; • – 2% CoSO4 ; – 5% CoSO4 ; – 10% CoSO4 .
96
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes 2.8 2.7 2.6 κ (S.cm−1)
2.5 2.4 2.3 2.2 2.1 2.0 1.9 550
600
650
t(°C)
700
750
Figure 2.44. Conductivity polytherms of the alkali metal sulfate ternary ◦ – ternary eutectics; • – 2% CoSO4 ; – 5% CoSO4 ; – 10% CoSO4
participate in the charge transfer. Its share increases with increasing the concentration of CoSO4 . This explanation is in accordance with the exponential character of the course of the electrical conductivity polytherms of the ternary sulfate eutectics with the CoSO4 addition, which are shown in Figure 2.44. It could be accepted that the anomaly on the viscosity polytherms at 700◦ C and the exponential character of the polytherms of the electrical conductivity of the melts of the system Li2 SO4 –Na2 SO4 –K2 SO4 –CoSO4 is coherent with the formation of the complex [Co(SO4 )2 ]2− in the melt. The transport of electrons from the metal/melt interface to the melt gas interface in the sulfate corrosion is possible due to the presence of the stable redox system described by Eq. (2.113) in the melt. 2.1.8.5. Silicate systems containing iron oxides
The system CaO–FeO–Fe2 O3 –SiO2 is the basic system of metallurgical slags. The ratio of di- and trivalent iron in the melt depends on the oxygen partial pressure, temperature, and composition of the melt. When the melt is held at equilibrium with metallic iron in an inert atmosphere, only Fe2+ cations are present in the melt. Toropov and Bryantsev (1965) used these conditions in the measurement of the electrical conductivity of the MgO–FeO– SiO2 melts. Air is another atmosphere with defined oxygen partial pressure. In this case, the content of di- and trivalent iron depends on temperature and the melt composition. The electrical conductivity of the FeOy –CaO–SiO2 melts in air was measured by Dancy and Derge (1966) and Engell and Vygen (1968). The conductivity of melts in the atmosphere
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
97
of pure oxygen, when only tri-valent iron was present in the melt was measured by Hirashima and Yoshida (1972), Lopatin et al. (1973), and Morinaga et al. (1975). In the investigation of properties of the CaO–Fex Oy –SiO2 melts in air, it is necessary to know the equilibrium composition of the melt as the function of the temperature and total melt composition. Larson and Chipman (1953) and Timucin and Morris (1970) studied the phase diagram of this system, where the equilibrium contents of di- and trivalent iron in the melt were determined in quenched samples. The presence of ions of the same kind in two oxidation states results in an increased electrical conductivity of the melt due to the contribution of the electronic conductivity caused by the electrons jumping between the two ions in different oxidation states. Daneˇ k et al. (1986) measured the electrical conductivity of the melts of the system CaO–FeO–Fe2 O3 –SiO2 in air atmosphere and in the temperature range of 1530–1920 K. The composition of samples lying in two cross-sections with constant molar ratios k1 = x(CaO)/x(SiO2 ) = 1 and k1 = x(CaO)/x(Fe2 O3 ) = 4 were chosen. The equilibrium compositions of the melts at the given experimental temperature were calculated according to the equation r = 1.7273−6.592×10−4 T /K + 0.223k1 + 0.116x (Fe2 O3 )
(2.114)
where r = x(Fe2 O3 )/[x(FeO)+x(Fe2 O3 )], T is the thermodynamic temperature, and x (Fe2 O3 ) is the molar fraction of Fe2 O3 in the weighed-in mixtures. Equation (2.114) was derived by Daneˇ k et al. (1986) using the data published by Larson and Chipman (1953) and Timucin and Morris (1970). The composition dependence of the conductivity of the investigated melts at 1723 K is shown in Figure 2.45. The conductivity of the investigated melts increases with increasing concentrations of calcium oxide, iron oxides, and temperature. The exponential increase of the conductivity with the increasing content of iron oxides indicates the presence of other conducting particles in the melt. Free electrons jumping from Fe(II) to Fe(III) atoms are suggested to contribute to the conductivity. Licˇ ko and Daneˇ k (1983) showed that the electrical conductivity of ionic silicate melts is proportional to the sum of the product of the mobility and the concentration of conductive particles. κ=
zi F ui (ci −ci0 )
(2.115)
i
where ci is the molar concentration of the conductive particle i with the charge number zi , ci0 is the molar concentration of that part of the cations which do not participate in the charge transfer, F is the Faraday’s constant, and ui is the mobility of the conductive
98
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
0.00 1.2
0.05
x(FexOy) 0.10
0.15
κ(S.cm−1)
1.0
0.8
1
0.6
2
0.4
0.2 0.3
0.4
0.5 x(SiO2)
0.6
Figure 2.45. The dependence of conductivity on composition of the investigated melts of the system CaO– FeO–Fe2 O3 –SiO2 at 1723 K. 1 – section k1 = x(CaO)/x(SiO2 ) = 1; 2 – section k1 = x(CaO)/x(Fe2 O3 ) = 4.
particle i. Licˇ ko and Daneˇ k (1983) also showed that in silicate melts with high SiO2 content (minimum 40 mole %) the charge is transported exclusively by cations. In the system CaO–FeO–Fe2 O3 –SiO2 , the contribution of electrons also has to be included. Equation (2.115) then can be written in the form 0 0 κ = F [2uCa2+ (cCa2+ −cCa 2+ ) + 2uFe2+ (cFe2+ −cFe2+ )
(2.116) 0 + 3uFe3+ (cFe3+ −cFe 3+ ) + ue− ce− ]
Equation (2.116) was solved using the multiple linear regression analysis. Concentrations of Ca2+ and Fe2+ were calculated from melt densities measured by Licˇ ko et al. (1985). In the calculation of the liquidus surface of CaSiO3 in the system CaO–Fe2 O3 –SiO2 , Daneˇ k (1984) stated that half of the Fe(III) atoms is coordinated tetrahedrally, i.e. they behave as network formers. This means that only the other half of the Fe(III) atoms, which are highly coordinated, behaving as a network modifier,
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
99
can participate in the charge transport. The concentration of the conductive Fe3+ cations is then given by the equation cFe3+ =
xFe2 O3 Vmelt
(2.117)
where Vmelt is the molar volume of the melt and xFe2 O3 is the molar fraction of Fe2 O3 in the melt. The concentration of electrons in the melt was determined as follows. In the system with comparable concentrations of both Fe2+ and Fe3+ cations, the electron can jump only when a donor (Fe2+ ) has an acceptor (Fe3+ ) in its neighborhood. The probability that such an acceptor is available is equal to 2xFe2 O3 . The concentration of electrons is then equal to cFe3+ =
2xFe2 O3 xFeO Vmelt
(2.118)
The dependence of the electrical conductivity on the concentration of conductive particles in the system CaO–FeO–Fe2 O3 –SiO2 was calculated using the multiple linear regression analysis. The dependence takes the form κ = −A+B1 cCa2+ +B2 cFe2+ +B3 cFe3+ +B4 ce−
(2.119)
where Bi = zi F ui . The standard deviation of approximation was sd = 3×10−2 S · cm−1 . The calculated constants A and Bi at the temperatures of 1723 K and 1823 K are given in Table 2.10. Comparing Eqs. (2.116) and (2.119) it follows for A 0 0 0 A = B1 cCa 2+ +B2 cFe2+ +B3 cFe3+
(2.120)
Licˇ ko and Daneˇ k (1983) regarded the limiting concentration ci0 as the cations, which do not participate in the charge transport. Those cations were supposed to be fixed in Table 2.10. Constants A, Bi , mobility, and diffusion coefficients of the conductive particles in the CaO–FeO–Fe2 O3 –SiO2 melts at 1723 and 1823 K Parameter
T (K)
Ca2+
Fe2+
Fe3+
e−
Bi (S · cm2 · mol−1 )
1723 1823 1723 1823 1723 1823 1723 1823
38.6 41.9 2.0 2.2 1.5 1.7
35.1 38.4 1.8 2.0 1.4 1.6 0.61 0.53
32.7 35.6 1.1 1.2 0.56 0.61
2170 2050 225 212 334 315
µi · 104 (cm2 · s−1 · V−1 ) Di · 105 (cm2 · s−1 ) A(S · cm−1 )
100
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
larger structural units, clusters, which could be composed of silicate polyanions linked to cations by polar covalent bonds. In the system CaO–FeO–Fe2 O3 –SiO2 such bonding occurs especially in the case of Fe(III) atoms. As regards the other conductive particles, the tendency towards such behavior can be expected at Fe(II) and less at Ca(II) atoms. The limiting concentrations of Ca(II) and Fe(II) atoms in the investigated system were estimated from the value of the absolute term A. Provided that c0 2+ /c0 2+ = rFe2+ /rCa2+ , Fe Ca ∼ 6×10−3 mol· where ri are the ionic radii, the following values were obtained: c0 = Ca2+
0 −3 mol·cm −3 . These values correspond to approximately 15 ∼ cm−3 and cFe 2+ = 7.5×10 mole % CaO and 18 mole % FeO in the systems CaO–SiO2 and FeO–SiO2 , respectively. The mobility of the conductive particles, i.e. Ca2+ , Fe2+ , and Fe3+ cations and electrons, were calculated from the Bi coefficients in Eqs. (2.119) and (2.120). The calculation was carried out for 1723 and 1823 K. From the obtained mobility values, the corresponding values of the diffusion coefficients were calculated using the Nernst–Einstein equation. The calculated values are given in Table 2.10. The mobility and diffusion coefficients of the cations were found to decrease in the order uCa2+ > uFe2+ > uFe3+ , which can be explained by different forces acting between the cations and the non-bridging oxygen atoms of the SiO4 tetrahedrons. Cations with a higher value of the z/r ratio (z is the charge number and r is the radius) form stronger bonds between them and the non-bridging oxygen atom. Due to steric reasons, the coordination number of the cation becomes lower. Such a cation is stronger bound in its position and the Me–O bond becomes more covalent, which results in the decrease of cation mobility. The mobility of the electrons was found to be two orders higher than that of the cations. For electron jump, some fluctuation in the composition or a different arrangement of the ionic atmosphere of both the exchange cations is needed. Fe(II) and Fe(III) atoms present in silicate melts are differently coordinated and the distances from the nearest neighbors (i.e. the oxygen atoms) are also different. The distances between the exchange sites are relatively great and this is why for the jump frequency, values close to the mean value of the vibration frequencies of the thermal movement in the melt can be expected. The mobility of such electrons was defined by Raleigh (1963)
ue − =
e νR R 2 6kT
(2.121)
where e is the electron charge, νR is the jump frequency, and R is the mean distance between the exchange sites given by the relation R∼ =
V NA
1/3 (2.122)
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
101
where V is the molar volume and NA is the Avogadro’s constant. From Eq. (2.121) the mobility and jump frequency of the electron can be calculated. For 1723 K and V ≈ 23cm3 ·mol−1 , one obtains νR ≈ 1.7×1013 s−1 , which is a feasible value comparable to the vibration frequency of thermal movement. The reciprocal frequency value is the mean lifetime of the given arrangement τ ≈ 6×10−14 s. The high degree of the symmetry of oxygen covers of both the exchange cations is indicated by the νR and τ values. Energy levels of the excited states of the electron in both oxidation states of Fe atoms are probably close to each other. 2.1.9. Systems of silicate melts
The structure of glass-forming oxides SiO2 , GeO2 , P2 O5 , B2 O3 , etc., is based on the linked AO4 tetrahedrons (SiO2 , GeO2 , P2 O5 ) or AO3 triangles (B2 O3 ). Førland (1955) concluded that the structure of molten SiO2 differs only little from that of cristobalite. The plausibility of this conclusion follows from the fact that the Si–O bonds are extremely strong. However, in spite of this, the melting enthalpy of SiO2 is only 9.58 kJ · mol−1 and the melting entropy is 4.8 J · mol−1 ·K −1 , which means that molten SiO2 has an arrangement very similar to that of cristobalite. The densities of molten SiO2 and cristobalite are nearly equal; the viscosity of molten SiO2 is high. SiO2 belongs to tectosilicates, its structure consists of SiO4 tetrahedrons linked by their apexes into a three-dimensional network. The structure contains only bridging oxygen atoms, i.e. those, bound to two neighboring central silicon atoms by covalent Si–O–Si bonds. Let us consider what happens with the structure when adding another oxide (e.g. MeO) to SiO2 . The situation can be expressed by the scheme |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
− Si −O− Si −+MeO → − Si −O− Me2+ − O− Si −
(2.123)
Now, not all of the oxygen atoms are linked to the two central silicon atoms. This is due to the addition of oxygen atoms further, so that the n(O)/n(Si) ratio exceeds 2. In principle, the process can be characterized as the decrease in the number of bridging oxygen atoms accompanied by the simultaneous formation of the two-fold number of nonbridging oxygen atoms. With increasing the MeO content, the tectosilicate structural type changes to inosilicates (e.g. pseudo-wollastonite) through sorosilicates (e.g. akermanite) to the structural type of nezosilicates (e.g. dicalcium silicate). The dependence of the number of bridging oxygen atoms on the content of MeO is linear from tectosilicates to nezosilicates. Let us further consider the glass-forming ability of the MeO–SiO2 melt. Here “glass” means the product formed by cooling the melt into the solid without crystallization. The glass-forming ability of systems depends on the energy of the bonds in the cooling melt, which disrupt in the course of crystallization. For the two limiting cases
102
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
(tectosilicate–nezosilicate), therefore there are quite different conditions for glass formation. Crystallization of SiO2 requires disruption of the very strong Si–O bonds and a new regular arrangement corresponding to the crystalline state. The crystallization process is a reconstructive one, while in the case of nezosilicates, the disruption of Si–O bonds is not necessary (the crystallization mechanism is not a reconstructive one). Practice shows that crystallization of SiO2 does not virtually take place, while nezosilicates, on the other hand, crystallize very rapidly, so that one can assume a similar, even though irregular state of arrangement of the tetrahedrons in the melt when compared with the crystalline phase. Generally speaking, the ability to crystallize is indirectly proportional to the degree of polymerization, which in turn depends on the content and properties of the MeO oxides. In the silicate chemistry, the oxides are divided into three principal groups: (1) (2) (3)
Network forming oxides, which participate in the formation of the polyanionic network, i.e. GeO2 , P2 O5 , B2 O3 . Network modifying oxides, which do not participate in the formation of the polyanionic network, i.e. alkali metal oxides and earth alkali metal oxides. Amphoteric oxides, which may act both as network forming or network modifying oxides depending on the actual composition of the melt. Typical amphoteric oxides are Al2 O3 and Fe2 O3 .
There is, of course, no sharp boundary between individual groups. For instance, magnesium oxide can act also as a network forming oxide in basic melts with a relatively high content of MgO, when sufficient non-bridging oxide atoms are available. Magnesium oxide then forms MgO4 tetrahedrons, which may link two SiO4 tetrahedrons together. Such melts exhibit relatively high viscosity. Another characteristic feature of the silicate melts is the formation of two immiscible liquids in the region of high concentration of SiO2 . Such a behavior is observed, for example, in the systems of alkali metal silicates and earth alkali metal silicates. The chemistry of silicate melts is rather complicated and special monographs devoted to this problem can be found in the literature. Therefore, only the main characterization is presented here.
2.1.10. Systems of molten alkali metal borates
Using X-ray diffraction techniques, Zarzycki (1956) showed that vitreous and molten boron oxide are composed of BO3 triangles linked by their apexes into an irregular threedimensional network. Grjotheim and Krogh-Moe (1954) pointed out that the structure of boron oxide glass is similar to that of its hexagonal crystalline form and that it consists of two types of irregular BO4 tetrahedrons. The first one is a hybrid between triangular
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
103
and tetrahedral configuration with the boron located much closer to the three oxygen atoms. The other is a distorted tetrahedron with various B–O bond lengths. The mean coordination number of boron in the B2 O3 melt, 3.1, as determined by Biscoe and Waren (1938), does not provide explicit evidence of any change in the boron coordination. In the binary glass-forming systems of alkali metal borates, it is possible to observe change in the trend of a number of physico-chemical properties in the concentration range of approximately 20 mole % of alkali metal oxide. This phenomenon is known in the literature as “boric acid anomaly”, and it is due to the change in the structure of the B2 O3 melt caused by the alkali metal oxide addition and is related to the ability of boron to change its coordination number. Krogh-Moe (1958, 1960) concluded that the change in the coordination number of boron from 3 to 4 takes place up to a content of 33 mole % of alkali metal oxide, which corresponds to the maximum concentration of 50% of four-coordinated boron. This assumption has been explicitly experimentally confirmed using the measurements of nuclear magnetic resonance carried out by Silver and Bray (1958) and Bray and O’Keefe (1963). These authors found out that within the concentration range of x = 0–30 mole % of alkali metal oxide the concentration of four-coordinated boron, N4 , may be quite accurately expressed by the relation N4 =
x 100−x
(2.124)
Equation (2.124) can be interpreted so that each oxygen atom added will change the coordination of two boron atoms from the triangular to the tetrahedral. As a result of this, there is no non-bridging oxygen atoms present within this concentration range. This fact has also been confirmed by the X-ray structural analyses of various crystalline borates, performed by Krogh-Moe (1958, 1960). The comparison of results of NMR studies, made by Silver and Bray (1958) and Bray and O’Keefe (1963), on the glass-forming ability of alkali metal borates, indicates that the degree of polymerization in alkali metal borate systems is much higher than in the silicate systems. On the basis of the above mentioned facts, one may reasonably expect the analogy between structures of the crystalline phase and liquid phase in the systems of alkali metal borates also. The structure of alkali metal borate melt can be imagined as a three-dimensional network of apex-joined BO3 triangles and BO4 tetrahedrons, where the cations are located in the free spaces. The properties of such melts will obviously depend on the number of boron atoms in the individual co-ordination, on the amount of alkali metal cations and bridging oxygen atoms, and also on the amount of nonbridging oxygen atoms at higher concentrations of alkali metal oxide. In the region of low content of the alkali metal oxide, each added oxygen atom of the alkali metal oxide changes the coordination of two boron atoms from 3 to 4. For instance, in the compound
104
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
Na2 O · 4B2 O3 there are two boron atoms in tetrahedral coordination, six boron atoms in triangular coordination, and all oxygen atoms are bridging. The above-described trend is maintained up to approximately 30 mole % of alkali metal oxide. Above this concentration, non-bridging oxygen atoms arise as the result of the reverse transition of some boron atoms from the tetrahedral into the triangular coordination. The number of boron atoms in the tetrahedral coordination decreases, approaching zero at 70 mole % of the alkali metal oxide. It should be, however, noted that the picture of the structure of the melt is only approximate and differences between the liquid and crystalline phase may occur. The chemistry of borate melts is described in detail in special monographs devoted to this problem. Thus the above mentioned short characteristics are given here only.
2.1.11. Systems of metallurgical slags
Pyrometallurgical metal production involves as a by-product, a slag, the amount of which often exceeds several times the produced metal. Slag is a poly-component system of metallic and non-metallic oxides forming compounds and molten mixtures, and containing some amounts of metals, sulfides, and gases. The main role of slag is to act as a collector of unwanted components of the charge and of impurities formed during the melting or refining of the metal. The correct choice of slag composition affects the total loss of the metal, its quality, energy demands, consumption of refractory lining, and thus in general, the overall economy and environmental aspects of the pyrometalurgical process. In the pyrometallurgical production of iron, steel, and non-ferrous metals, the so-called combined slags, or silicate slags with a high content of calcium oxide are frequently used. The base of these slags is the system, CaO–FeO–Fe2 O3 −SiO2 . Magnesium oxide is introduced into these slags by dissolution of the basic refractory lining. Aluminum oxide is present after the concentration melting of raw materials. Zinc oxide is introduced into the pyrometallurgical slags mainly in the processing of secondary raw materials. The properties of some of these slags were discussed in Section 2.1.9. In the middle of the 1970s, the process of continuous copper production was started in Japan. This process, using calcium–ferritic slags, was developed on the basis of the theoretical work of Yazawa (1977). The base of the calcium–ferritic slags is the system CaO–FeO–Fe2 O3 that in a real pyrometallurgical processes contains as admixtures SiO2 , Al2 O3 , MgO, ZnO, and in the pyrometallurgical production of copper as Cu2 O. Takeda et al. (1980) studied the thermodynamics of calcium–ferritic slags at 1473 and 1573 K. Their work includes a formula for calculating the concentrations of Fe2+ and Fe3+ in dependence on concentration, partial pressure of oxygen, and temperature. An extensive study of physicochemical properties of the systems CaO–FeO– Fe2 O3 −Mx Oy (Mx Oy = SiO2 , Al2 O3 , MgO, ZnO) and of the system CaO–Fe2 O3 −Cu2 O was made by Vadász and Haulík (1995, 1996, 1998), Vadász et al. (1993, 2000, 2005),
Main Features of Molten Salt Systems
105
Fedor (1990), and Fedor et al. (1991). The density, surface tension, electrical conductivity, and viscosity have been measured at the temperature of 1573 K and in a relatively wide concentration range. The density and surface tension were measured by means of the maximum bubble pressure method using a device similar to that described in Section 6.2.2. The viscosity was measured using the rotational method, and the electrical conductivity, by means of the two-electrode method. From the theoretical point of view, on the basis of the complex physico-chemical analysis of these melts, considerations of their structure, i.e. the ionic composition was made. Using the multiple linear regression analysis, the equations describing molar volume and the surface tension on composition were obtained. From the individual interaction parameters, the formation of different structural entities in the melts was proposed. It has been suggested that the structure of the investigated calcium–ferritic melts is mostly influenced by the properties of the Fe(III) atoms. In the basic medium of calcium–ferritic slags, this amphoteric element exhibits an acidic character. Its acidity depends on the nature and concentration of the following oxides present in the melt. In the calcium–ferritic melts, Fe(III) atoms form simple complex anions. With increasing the concentration of oxygen anions, the co-ordination of the central Fe atom changes according to the following scheme 4− − + FeO5− 4 (4) → Fe2 O5 → FeO2 → FeO (6)
(2.125)
where the co-ordination number is given in parentheses. The obtained density and surface tension data, as well as the interpretation of the interactions found in the individual CaO–FeO–Fe2 O3 −Mx Oy systems suggest that cations Ca2+ , Fe2+ , Zn2+ , Cu+ may be present in the respective investigated melts. Due to 5− 5− the low concentration of network forming oxides, isolated SiO4− 4 , AlO4 and FeO4 tetrahedrons are formed in these basic melts, the donor of the oxygen atoms being either CaO, FeO, or both CaO + FeO oxides. The observed ternary interactions may be most 8− probably attributed to the formation of the anions SiFeO7− 7 and FeAlO7 , in which one Si atom is substituted by Fe and/or Al forming two tetrahedrons linked by a corner. 4− 9− However, it could not be excluded that also species, such as FeO+ 2 , Fe2 O5 , AlO6 , etc. may be present in the melts of the systems investigated. In the system CaO–Fe2 O3 −Cu2 O, due to the absence of silica and the low concentration of other network-forming oxides, only isolated FeO5− 4 tetrahedrons and CaO·FeO ionic pairs are formed in the basic melts. From the behavior of the cuprous oxide, the formation of the Ca4 Cu2 O5 compound might be assumed. In Table 2.11 the values of the molar volumes of essential pure oxides CaO, FeO, and Fe2 O3 , obtained in the calculation of the molar volume of individual systems are given. The agreement of values obtained from the measurement in independent systems is surprisingly excellent. The calculated values coincide fairly with the literature data.
106
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
Table 2.11. Molar volumes of pure oxides calculated from individual independent systems 0 (cm 3 ·mol−1 ) VCaO
0 (cm 3 ·mol−1 ) VFeO
0 VFe (cm3 ·mol−1 ) 2 O3
CaO–FeO–Fe2 O3 −SiO2 (1573 K) CaO–FeO–Fe2 O3 −Al2 O3 (1573 K) CaO–FeO–Fe2 O3 −MgO (1623 K) CaO–FeO–Fe2 O3 −ZnO (1573 K) CaO–Fe2 O3 −Cu2 O (1573 K)
16.41 ± 0.26 16.31 ± 0.60 16.50 ± 0.14 16.44 ± 0.38 16.42 ± 0.35
17.03 ± 0.28 17.00 ± 0.63 17.01 ± 0.15 17.22 ± 0.42 −
38.79 ± 0.48 38.11 ± 1.37 39.01 ± 0.34 38.06 ± 0.45 39.29 ± 0.36
Average
16.42 ± 0.35
17.07 ± 0.37
38.65 ± 0.60
System
Table 2.12. Surface tension of pure oxides calculated from individual independent systems σCaO (cm3 ·mol−1 )
σFeO (cm3 ·mol−1 )
σFe2 O3 (cm3 ·mol−1 )
CaO–FeO–Fe2 O3 −SiO2 (1573 K) CaO–FeO–Fe2 O3 −Al2 O3 (1573 K) CaO–FeO–Fe2 O3 −MgO (1623 K) CaO–FeO–Fe2 O3 −ZnO (1573 K) CaO–Fe2 O3 −Cu2 O (1573 K)
657.6 ± 12.8 661.6 ± 7.8 656.7 ± 11.8 617.5 ± 16.7 686.9 ± 25.7
588.6 ± 11.3 585.1 ± 7.0 582.8 ± 12.7 589.4 ± 25.4 −
376.2 ± 7.3 375.0 ± 4.5 374.4 ± 7.9 363.3 ± 14.8 379.5 ± 15.7
Average
656.1 ± 15.0
586.5 ± 14.1
373.7 ± 10.0
System
For illustration, Licˇ ko and Daneˇ k (1982) published a similar value for the molar volume of CaO at 1873 K, V 0 (CaO) = 18.28 cm3 ·mol−1 , and Bottinga and Weill (1970) published the following values for the molar volumes of oxides: V 0 (CaO) = 16.5 cm3 · mol−1 , V 0 (FeO) = 12.8 cm3 · mol−1 , and V 0 (Fe2 O3 ) = 52 cm3 · mol−1 , all at the temperature of 1723 K. The differences may be caused by different temperatures since the molar volume is rather sensitive to temperature. The calculated values of the surface tension of pure oxides are given in Table 2.12. Again, surprisingly excellent agreement can be observed. For the surface tension of pure oxides, the following values could be found in the literature for comparison: Daneˇ k and Licˇ ko (1982), based on the measurement in the system CaO–MgO–SiO2 , published for CaO at 1800 K the value σ (CaO) = 726 mN ·m−1 , Daneˇ k et al. (1985a) calculated from the measurements in the system CaO–FeO–Fe2 O3 –SiO2 for CaO, FeO, and Fe2 O3 at 1723 K, the values σ (CaO) = 689 mN ·m−1 , σ (FeO) = 502 mN ·m−1 , and σ (Fe2 O3 ) = 467 mN ·m−1 , respectively. For FeO, the value σ (FeO) = 585 mN ·m−1 was reported by Richardson (1974).
Chapter 3
Phase Equilibria 3.1. THERMODYNAMIC PRINCIPLES
The isobaric phase diagrams of condensed systems represent the graphical description of the phase equilibria in the temperature versus composition coordinates. In the phase diagrams, the fields of existence of individual phases can be seen. Phase diagrams are useful tools in many areas of industry, such as metallurgy, material science, glass making, aluminum production, etc. The construction of a trustworthy phase diagram is usually the first step in the development of a new technology. The basic laws and principles in the phase equilibrium theory are given in the next few chapters. 3.1.1. Gibbs’s phase law
Let us consider a closed system with f phases and k components that do not react mutually. The composition of each phase can be expressed using k − 1 molar fractions, since it holds that the sum of the mole fractions in each phase is equal to 1. For the description of f-independent phases with k components, we therefore need f (k − 1) independent data on composition. To these we still have to add data on temperature and pressure, so we have altogether f (k − 1) + 2 intensive data, if the temperature and pressure are equal in the whole system. If the system considered is in equilibrium, the intensive criterion of the thermodynamic equilibrium must be fulfilled, thus the chemical potentials of all the k components in all the f phases have to be equal. This criterion thus defines the number of binding conditions between the intensive variables. This number is k(f − 1), because the number of binding conditions is one less than the number of phases. Then the difference between both the quantities defines the number of intensive variables, which are independent in a system with k components and f phases being in equilibrium – the variance, or the number of degrees of freedom v v = f (k − 1) + 2 − k(f − 1) = k − f + 2
(3.1)
This is the mathematical expression of the Gibbs phase law. It is an explicit and simple guide in the study of phase equilibria.
107
108
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
Examples (1)
A closed vessel filled with gaseous oxygen. We have 1 component (oxygen) and 1 phase (gaseous). v =k−f +2=1−1+2=2
(2)
(3.2)
The system has two degrees of freedom, we can change the temperature and pressure without the occurrence of a new phase. A closed vessel partially filled with water. We have 1 component (water), 2 phases (water and its vapor pressure). v =k−f +2=1−2+2=1
(3)
(3.3)
The system has 1 degree of freedom, since the temperature and pressure are not independent any more. A certain temperature corresponds to a certain equilibrium pressure and vice versa. When the pressure decreases, the water evaporates completely. A closed vessel filled partially with a mixture of ethanol and water. We have 2 components (water and ethanol) and 2 phases (a liquid solution of ethanol and water and a mixture of gaseous ethanol and water vapor). v =k−f +2=2−2+2=2
(3.4)
The system has 2 degrees of freedom. We can change the pressure and composition of the liquid phase. However, once these quantities have a certain value, the temperature and the composition of the gaseous phase are already defined. 3.1.2. Lever rule
The lever rule can be derived from the mass balance as well as from the balance of the amount of substance. On a straight line we can show a mixture X lying in between two pure components A and B and their respective mole fractions and the amount of substances:
A
X
B
n1', x1'
n1, x1
n1'', x1''
For the amount of substance balance it holds then: n1 = n1 + n1
(3.5)
Phase Equilibria
109
n1 x1 = n1 x1 + n1 x1
n1 + n1 x1 = n1 x1 + n1 x1
(3.6)
n1 x1
(3.8)
+ n1 x1
n1 x1 − x1
=
n1 x1
(3.7)
+ n1 x1
= n1 x1 − x1
(3.9)
and finally: n1 BX x1 − x1 = ≡ n1 x1 − x1 AX
(3.10)
According to the lever rule, it follows that the ratio of the amount of substances equals the ratio of the lengths of sections to which the figurative point of the system divides the connection of both components. It can be easily shown that this rule holds for any three figurative points of a system lying on the straight line. Similarly as the lever rule holds in the two-component systems, in the three- and four-component systems, apply the triangle and quadrangle rules. According to the triangle rule, every phase, figurative point of which lies in the field of the triangle with the peaks A, B, and C, can be divided without residue into three phases, corresponding to the figurative points A, B, and C. Phase F divides first according to the lever rule into phases C and D and then the phase D divides again according to the lever rule into phases A and B. C
F
A
D
B
According to the quadrangle rule, every couple of phases, the figurative points of which lie on the ends of one of the diagonals of the general quadrangle (e.g. A, C), can
110
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
be changed to the other couple of phases, the figurative points of which lie on the other diagonal of this quadrangle (i.e. B, D).
D
A F C
B
According to the lever rule, phases A and C will first compose phase F and then phase F decomposes according to the lever rule into phases B and D. The quadrangle rule applies especially in phase diagrams of three-component systems with the formation of a congruently melting compound and in the phase diagrams of reciprocal systems. In the presence of a complex chemical compound Z = Aq Br in the system A–B, it is often advantageous to investigate the behavior of a component A in the subsystem A–Z. This approach requires transformation of the composition coordinates. The transformation of the composition coordinates of component A from the system A–B to the system A–Z is based on the following scheme xA + (1 − x)B = yA + (1 − y)Aq Br
(3.11)
where x is the mole fraction of component A in the original system A–B and y is the mole fraction of the same component A in the transformed system A–Z. The transformed composition coordinate y is given by the expression y=
(q + r)x − q (q + r − 1)x − q + 1
(3.12)
3.1.3. Thermodynamics of solutions
In this chapter, we focus on the fundamentals of the theory of solutions, which is needed for the understanding of the equilibrium phase diagrams. The thermodynamic analysis
Phase Equilibria
111
of the temperature dependence of the phase transition on the composition of the systems will be emphasized, since this approach forms the rational basis of the calculation for the phase diagrams. For the composition, we will use mole fractions since they do not depend on temperature and pressure. Different relations have been used in the literature to describe the dependence ai, l = f(Ti ). For instance, in the monographs by Blander (1964), Denbigh (1966), and Prigogine and Defay (1962) the activity is considered to be a function of the molar heat of fusion, while in others, e.g. in the monograph by Kogan (1968), the activity is considered to be a function of the partial molar heat of fusion. Since every phase diagram shows dependencies of the activity of components in their saturated solution on temperature (liquidus curves, liquidus areas) we will examine this dependency in a binary mixture. 3.1.3.1. Application of the relation µs, A = µl, A
Let us consider an isothermal process in which 1 mol of pure solid component in equilibrium with its saturated solution transforms into a liquid state (melting). In equilibrium, the equality of the chemical potentials of this component in both the phases must be valid (e.g. for the component A) µs, A = µl, A
(3.13)
Because it holds that µi = µ0i + RT ln ai , we get µ0s, A + RT ln as, A = µ0l, A + RT ln al, A
(3.14)
Since A is the pure solid component, as, A = 1 and after rearranging we get µ0s, A T
−
µ0l, A T
= RT ln al, A
(3.15)
The derivative of Eq. (3.15) according to the temperature at constant pressure yields d
µ0s, A T
dT
d −
µ0l, A T
dT
=R
d ln al, A dT
(3.16)
The derivatives on the left side of Eq. (3.16) are equal to d
µ0i T
dT
1 = 2 T
dµ0i T − µ0i dT
=
1 1 (−Gi − T Si ) = − 2 T2 T
dH dni
=−
Hi T2
(3.17)
112
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
Remember that the derivative of H, the enthalpy (not molar) of the system according to ni is the molar enthalpy, Hi . Then Eq. (3.16) attains the form Hl, A − Hs, A d ln al, A = dT RT 2
(3.18)
The difference Hl, A –Hs, A represents the change in the enthalpy at the transition of 1 mol of the pure component considered from the solid to the liquid state, which is thus the molar enthalpy of fusion Dfus HA and Eq. (3.18) has the final form d ln al, A fus HA = dT RT 2
(3.19)
Equation (3.19) is the differential form of the Le Chatelier–Shreder’s equation. We can obtain the integral form of this equation after integration in the range from the activity al, A at temperature T to the activity al, A = 1 (the pure solvent) at temperature Tfus, A . In the simplified case, we assume that the difference between the heat capacity in the liquid and the solid state of the component considered, s/l Cp , does not depend on temperature. We then get ln al, A =
fus HA R
1 Tfus,A
−
1 T
+
s/l Cp R
Tfus,A Tfus, A − 1 − ln T T
(3.20)
which is the so-called generalized Le Chatelier–Shreder’s equation in the integrated form. Assuming further that s/l Cp of the component equals zero (Dfus HA = constant), we obtain the Le Chatelier–Shreder’s equation in its simplified form ln a1, A
fus HA = R
1 Tfus, A
1 − T
(3.21)
However, in the calculation of the phase diagrams, i.e. the dependences of the activity of components in their saturated solution on temperature, we use the Le Chatelier–Shreder’s equation in the form explicit for temperature T =
fus HA Tfus, A fus HA = fus HA − RTfus, A ln al, A fus SA − R ln al, A
(3.22)
3.1.3.2. Application of the Planck function G/T
The equilibrium between the pure solid component and its saturated solution is given by the simultaneous validity of the following equations at constant pressure
Phase Equilibria
113
G0 Gl = s T T 0 Gl Gs d =d T T
(3.23) (3.24)
0 = f (T , x), where x is the mole fraction of the substance B in the At P = constant G l 0s = f (T ). Since Gl = G0 + RT ln al , with respect to liquid saturated solution, and G l Eq. (3.24) it holds 0 G0l + RT ln al ∂ Gs ∂ G0l + RT ln al ∂ dT (3.25) dT + dx = ∂T T ∂x T ∂T T It holds that
∂ ∂T
R
Since
∂ ∂T
G T
G0l T
x
= 0. By rearranging we get T
∂ ln al ∂T
= x,P
T
dT +
x
∂ ln al ∂x
T
∂ dx = − ∂T
G0l − G0s T
dT
(3.26)
−Hx,P , then T2 d ln al (T , x) =
fus H 0 dT RT 2
(3.27)
where fus H 0 = Hl0 − Hs0 . Equation (3.27) is obviously equal to Eq. (3.19). The application of the Planck function is called as the “differential” method. 3.1.3.3. Application of the relation a1 = f(T, x)
For the equilibrium of the given type it formally holds that a1 = f (T , x), P = constant, and also consequently ln a1 = f (T , x). Both al and ln al are functions of state. Then, using the properties of the exact differential, we can write ∂ ln al ∂ ln al d ln al = dT + dx (3.28) ∂T x ∂x T Equation (3.28) can be integrated if both the right-hand terms are known. From the derivative of the definition equation Gl = G0l + RT ln al according to T at x = constant it follows ∂ ln al 1 ∂(Gl − G0l ) = (3.29) ∂T x R ∂T x
114
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
or
∂ ln al ∂T
=− x
(H l − Hl0 )x RT 2
(3.30)
Hence the first right-hand term of Eq. (3.28) has been established. The second right-hand term will be determined by means of Eq. (3.30) applied to the phase equilibrium liquidus–solidus
∂ ∂T
Gl T
x
∂ dT + ∂x
Gl T
∂ dx = ∂T
T
G0s T
dT
(3.31)
dT
(3.32)
or
(H l )x − T2
∂ dT + ∂x
(G0l + RT ln al ) T
T
Hs0 dx = − T2
and after rearrangement
∂ ln al ∂x
dx = T
(H l − Hs0 )x dT RT 2
(3.33)
Equation (3.33) is the second right-hand term of Eq. (3.28). Substituting the corresponding terms from Eqs. (3.30) and (3.33) into Eq. (3.28) we get d ln al =
(−H l + Hl0 )x (H l − Hs0 )x dT + dT RT 2 RT 2
(3.34)
fus H 0 dT RT 2
(3.35)
or d ln al =
Equation (3.35) is obviously identical with Eq. (3.27) and it is the differential form of Eq. (3.21). 3.1.3.4. Two liquid phases coexisting in equilibrium
From Eq. (3.33) it follows that
dT dx
∂ ln al ∂x T (H l − Hs0 )x
RT 2 =
(3.36)
Phase Equilibria
115
and since H l − Hs0 = mix H l + fus H 0 , Eq. (3.36) can be written in the form
dT dx
RT 2 =
∂ ln al ∂x
T
(3.37)
(mix H l + fus H 0 )x
The term fus H 0 is always greater than zero. What concerns the term (∂ ln al /∂x)T , the situation could be more complicated. When the course of the dependence ai = f(xi ) is monotonous over the whole concentration range, only one liquid phase exists in the system and (∂ ln al /∂x)T > 0. However, when the course of the function ai = f(xi ) is not monotonous, as it is demonstrated in Figure 3.1, the activities of the given component i in the coexisting liquid phases of compositions corresponding to the points Q and R are equal and it holds again that (∂ ln al, Q /∂x)T > 0 and (∂ ln al, R /∂x)T > 0. This situation is typical for systems exhibiting a miscibility gap and is associated with a sufficiently large positive deviation from the ideal behavior. In the system, two liquid phases coexist in equilibrium. These two liquids of composition corresponding
1.0
Q
R
0.8
0.6 ai 0.4
0.2
0.0 0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
xi Figure 3.1. The function ai = f (xi ) in a system exhibiting a miscibility gap.
116
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
to the points Q and R are evidently in equilibrium. Single-phase solutions with the composition coordinates situated between points Q and R are metastable with respect to the two-phase system. 3.1.3.5. Gibbs energy at mixing
In the calculation of the phase diagrams the mixing molar Gibbs energy plays an important role as well. Consider the change of the molar Gibbs energy at mixing of two pure liquid compounds A and B, which takes place at a certain temperature and pressure mix G = Gmix − nA µ0A − nB µ0B
(3.38)
The molar Gibbs energy of the mixture, Gmix , equals the sum A + nB G B = nA µA − nB µB Gmix = nA G
(3.39)
Equations (3.38) and (3.39) can be added together, which yields mix G = nA (µA − µ0A ) + nB (µB − µ0B )
(3.40)
Since µi − µ0i = RT ln ai , then it holds mix G = nA RT ln aA + nB RT ln aB
(3.41)
or, because of ai = xi · γi mix G = nA RT ln xA + nB RT ln xB + nA RT ln γA + nB RT ln γB
(3.42)
3.1.3.6. Ideal solutions
According to Lewis, the fugacity of an arbitrary component in the ideal solution is proportional to its mole fraction through the whole concentration region and at all temperatures and pressures fi = xi fi0
(3.43)
where fi and f 0i are the fugacities of the component in the solution and in the pure state, respectively. From this definition, two important consequences follow. (1)
The origin of solution is connected neither with volume contraction nor with volume dilatation.
Phase Equilibria
117
Proof: From Eq. (3.43) we get ln fi = ln xi + ln fi0
(3.44)
The derivative according to pressure at constant temperature and composition gives d ln fi0 d ln fi = dP dP
(3.45)
Since Vi d ln fi = dP RT
d ln fi0 V0 = i dP RT
and
(3.46)
from which it follows that Vi = Vi0
(3.47)
and finally, for the binary system it holds Vmix = nA V A + nB V B − nA VA0 − nB VB0 = 0 (2)
(3.48)
The origin of solution is connected neither with the release nor with the absorption of heat. Proof: Differentiating Eq. (3.43) according to temperature at constant pressure and composition we get d ln fi0 d ln fi = dT dT
(3.49)
Since ∗
d ln fi H − Hi = i 2 dT RT
(3.50)
and thus ∗
∗
H i − H i = H i − Hi0
(3.51)
H i = Hi0
(3.52)
from which it follows that
118
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
The change in enthalpy at the formation of the binary solution equals Hmix = nA H A + nB H B − nA HA0 − nB HB0 = 0
(3.53)
For an ideal solution γ i = 1 and Eq. (3.42) simplifies to the form mix G∗ = nA RT ln xA + nB RT ln xB
(3.54)
For every solution it holds that mix G∗ = mix H ∗ − T mix S ∗
(3.55)
and since the solution is ideal, mix H ∗ = 0 and mix G∗ = −T mix S ∗
(3.56)
mix S ∗ = −R (nA ln xA + nB ln xB )
(3.57)
from which it follows that
The molar entropy of mixing of the ideal solution is thus not equal to zero. This is due to the fact that the mixing of pure components proceeds spontaneously and is connected with rearrangement of the melt and thus with an increase in entropy. According to the value of the individual members on the right side of Eq. (3.55) we divide the solutions into the following categories (the asterisk denotes the ideal mixing) ideal solutions: mix G = mix G∗ ,
mix H = 0,
mix S = mix S ∗
(3.58)
mix H = 0,
mix S = mix S ∗
(3.59)
mix H = 0,
mix S = mix S ∗
(3.60)
regular solutions: mix G = mix G∗ , Temkin’s ideal solution: mix G = mix G∗ ,
Phase Equilibria
119
3.1.3.7. Real solutions
The difference mix G – mix G∗ in real solutions, i.e. the difference of Eq. (3.42) and Eq. (3.54), is called the excess molar Gibbs energy of mixing and is denoted as ex G ex G = mix G − mix G∗ = nA RT ln γA + nB RT ln γB
(3.61)
Differentiating partially the excess molar Gibbs energy of mixing according to the amount of substance (e.g. A) we get
∂ex G ∂nA
= RT ln γA + RT
nB
nA
∂ ln γB ∂ ln γA + nB ∂nA ∂nA
= RT ln γA
(3.62)
since the expression in parentheses is according to the Gibbs–Duhem’s equation equal to zero. A similar relation can be derived also for the component B. Equation (3.62) is frequently used in the calculation of the activity coefficients of the components. In order to describe the behavior of the real solutions, i.e. the deviation of the solution from the ideal behavior, we use different thermodynamic models. 3.1.4. Thermodynamic models of molten salts
In order to compare the theoretical models with the experimental results, we need to know the form of the functional dependence ai = f(xi ). This dependence can be obtained either on the basis of a certain structural model or empirically. The dependence of such a kind must, however, fulfill certain limiting conditions. According to the character of the functional dependence ai = f(xi ) it is convenient to distinguish molten salt systems of type I and II. The systems of type I must fulfill two conditions: dal =1 dxl
(3.63)
dal = H1∗ = 0 x1 →0 dxl
(3.64)
lim
x1 →1
lim
where H1∗ is proportional to the Henry’s constant (H1∗ = f0 H ) and is also called the Henry’s constant. The first condition expresses the validity of Raoult’s law and the second one is equivalent to Henry’s law. As soon as at least one of the above-mentioned conditions is not fulfilled, the systems are those of type II. If γ i > 1 (and thus ai > xi ), we speak about the positive deviation from the ideal behavior, if γ i < 1 (and thus ai < xi ) it deals with negative deviation. For type I solutions we postulate the validity of the Raoult’s and Henry’s laws. Then the dependence ai = f(xi ) will have the form shown in Figure 3.2. In the concentration region < 1;
120
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes 1
Activity
γ<1
a=x γ<1
0 1
x(R)
Molar fraction
x(H)
0
Figure 3.2. The dependence ai = f (xi ) for systems of type II.
x(R) > it holds ai ∼ = xi . This region is called the Raoult’s region. In the concentration region < x(H); 0 > it holds ai ∼ = Hi∗ xi and this region is called the Henry’s region. 3.1.4.1. Concept of activity and activity coefficients in molten salts
In the literature on molten salts, the single ion activity coefficient is often used erroneously. The use of single ion activity coefficients depends on the chosen standard state and may thus be confusing. The ion activity and the ion activity coefficient concepts have been used for a long time in the thermodynamic treatment of dilute aqueous solutions of electrolytes and have also been extended to non-aqueous mixtures, molten salts, and slags. It was, however, generally agreed, that single ion activity cannot be experimentally determined and it cannot be calculated without non-thermodynamic assumptions. It should thus be emphasized that when the single ion activity is applied, the standard state and the convention used should be clearly defined. For simplicity, only solutions of symmetrical binary univalent electrolytes will be considered here. The measurable thermodynamic quantity of interest in this connection is the change in chemical potential, µMA , of the component MA in the mixture. The activity of MA,
Definition of single ion activity coefficient.
Phase Equilibria
121
aMA , is defined by the equation µMA = µMA − µ0MA = RT ln aMA
(3.65)
where µMA and µ0MA is the chemical potential in the given mixture and in the standard 0 , is by definition equal to one. state, respectively. In the standard state, the activity, aMA Equation (3.65) emphasizes that the choice of the standard state usually corresponds to the selection of a state, in which we want the activity to be equal to one. For a dissociating electrolyte MA, the activity coefficient, γMA may be defined by the equation µMA = RT ln(cM+ cA− γ MA )
(3.66)
where cM+ and cA− are concentrations of the ions M+ and A− , respectively. In this equation, different concentration units may be used, e.g. molarity, molality, etc. The most rational concentration units are considered to be the mole (ionic) fractions based on the species actually present in the system. In a similar way as in Eq. (3.65), the single ion activities aM+ and aA− are usually defined by the general equations µM+ = µ0M+ + RT ln aM+
(3.67)
µA− = µ0A− + RT ln aA−
(3.68)
where µM+ and µA− are the chemical potentials of the ions M+ and A− in the given solution, respectively. The single ion activity coefficient, γM+ , is defined by the equation aM+ = cM+ γM+
(3.69)
and correspondingly also for γA− . From Eqs. (3.67) and (3.68), it can be seen that the single ion activity coefficients will depend on the chosen concentration units and the chosen standard states for the ions. From the above equations it follows that the activity coefficient of the salt, γMA , is related to the single activity coefficients by the equation γMA = γM+ γA− = γ±2
(3.70)
where γ± is called the mean activity coefficient. It should be, however, stressed that none of the quantities connected with single ions, i.e. µM+ , aM+ , γM+ , or µM+ , aA− , γA− , can be obtained from thermodynamic measurements.
122
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
It should be stressed that the single ion activities and activity coefficients can be introduced only formally. The reason is that due to the electro-neutrality we cannot differentiate the Gibbs energy of the system according to the amount of cations keeping the amount of the anions constant. The concept of the chemical potential of a single ion seems to be thus somewhat dubious. The chosen standard state is normally based upon either Raoult’s or Henry’s law. The particular choice depends on the convenience and experimental accessibility.
Standard states.
(1)
(2)
Henrian activities (solute standard state) When dealing with dilute solutions, it is often convenient to refer to the infinitely dilute solution when defining the standard states. In this case, the activity coefficient of the solute is taken to approach one as the solution is infinitely diluted, and the standard state is defined as the (hypothetical) state with unit concentration (ci = 1) and with unit activity coefficient (γ i = i). Mathematically, this standard state is defined by ai /ci = 1 as ci → 0. The choice of infinite solution as the basis for defining this hypothetical standard state effectively assigns to the environment of each solute species and the chemical properties of the pure solvent. This means that the variations in Gibbs energy accompanying concentration change in the Henry’s law region (γ i = 1) are ascribed solely to the change in the partial molal entropy of the solute, which is associated with expanding or contracting the volume of solution available to each solute species. This standard state is most useful when activities of different compounds are compared in dilute solutions of the same solvent, and is commonly used, for example, when dealing with aqueous solutions of electrolytes or dilute solutions in molten salts (cryoscopy). When defining a Henrian standard state, it is imperative to consider those species actually existing in the infinitely dilute solution, or behavior according to Henry’s law will not be observed. In the case of electrolytes, this means that the individual ions must be selected as the species of interest. The standard state of each ionic species is chosen so that the ratio of its activity to its concentration becomes one at infinite dilution, at 101.325 kPa pressure, and the actual temperature. It should be noted that with the state of infinite dilution as the standard state, such dilution is applied to all ions in solution and not just to the particular ion under consideration. This stipulation with respect to all ions is important because it is the ionic environment, which is mostly responsible for departures from ideality and not just the characteristics of the particular ion under consideration. Raoultian activity (solvent standard state) When dealing with liquid mixtures over a rather wide composition range, or at higher concentrations, it is most convenient to choose the pure components,
Phase Equilibria
123
supercooled if convenient, as the standard states with unit activity. With this choice, the activities of a compound in different solvents can be directly compared, since the activities are expressed relative to the same standard state, the pure component. This standard state is usually preferred in the thermodynamic treatment of fused salts and slags. The fused salt system of the ions Na+ , K+ , Cl− , and has the following restriction due to electro-neutrality
Systems of reciprocal salt mixtures.
Br−
nNa+ + nK+ = nCl− + nBr−
(3.71)
where ni is the amount of individual ions. In terms of the phase rule, the system has three components. To some extent they can be chosen arbitrarily, e.g. a mixture containing one mole of positive and negative charge can be described as xNa+ NaCl + xBr− KBr + (xCl− − xNa+ )KCl
(3.72)
with the Gibbs energy per one mole of the mixture G = xNa+ µNaCl + xBr− µKBr + (xCl− − xNa+ )µKCl
(3.73)
The same system can also be described as (seen from simple stoichiometric calculation) xNa+ xCl− NaCl + xK+ xCl− KCl + xNa+ xBr− NaBr + xK+ xBr− KBr
(3.74)
with the Gibbs energy per one mole of the mixture G = xNa+ xCl− µNaCl + xK+ xCl− µKCl + xNa+ xBr− µNaBr + xK+ xBr− µKBr
(3.75)
Since the Gibbs energy and the chemical potentials in Eqs. (3.73) and (3.75) are identical, one obtains by combining the two equations µKBr = µKCl + µNaBr − µNaCl
(3.76)
which means that by describing the system by one more components than necessary, one automatically obtains an additional equation connecting the chemical potentials. If we further introduce the activity from the equations µNaCl = µ0NaCl + RT ln aNaCl , and so forth
(3.77)
124
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
we obtain the chemical equilibrium expression RT ln
aNaBr aKCl = µ0NaBr − µ0KCl + µ0NaCl + µ0KBr = −ex G0 aNaCl aKBr
(3.78)
where ex G0 is the Gibbs energy change for the metathetical reaction NaCl + KBr = NaBr + KCl
(3.79)
when all the components are in their standard state, which is here chosen to be the pure components (Raoultian standard states). According to Temkin (1945), the partial molar entropy of a salt component, e.g. NaCl, in an ideal fused salt mixture is given by S NaCl = −R ln(xNa+ xCl− )
(3.80)
where xNa+ =
nNa+ nNa+ + nK+
and
xCl− =
nCl− nCl− + nBr−
(3.81)
in accordance with this, the activity coefficient of a component, γNaCl , is therefore defined by the equation aNaCl = xNa+ xCl− γNaCl , and so forth
(3.82)
Each salt activity, aNaCl , may formally be split into separate ionic activities aNaCl = aNa+ aCl−
(3.83)
with corresponding ionic activity coefficients γNaCl = γNa+ γCl−
(3.84)
Equation (3.83) corresponds to the formal division of the standard chemical potential µ0NaCl µ0NaCl = µ0Na+ + µ0Cl−
(3.85)
However, in this case µ0NaCl refers to a state where Na+ has Cl− as a close neighbor and vice versa, and can be expressed as the Gibbs energy of formation of NaCl. In Eq. (3.85), this has arbitrarily been divided into ionic standard chemical potentials.
Phase Equilibria
125
If we further make the non-thermodynamic assumption that µ0Cl− from the component NaCl is the same as µ0Cl− from the component KCl, and so forth, one ends up with a contradiction, which can be demonstrated in the following way. For the metathetical reaction (3.79) we have G0 = µ0KCl + µ0NaBr − µ0NaCl − µ0KBr = 0
(3.86)
By introducing the standard chemical potentials of the single ions as given in Eq. (3.86) we end up with the contradiction that G 0 equals zero. The same conclusion follows, when the activity terms, Eq. (3.82), are introduced into the expression for the equilibrium constant in Eq. (3.78) and then introducing the single activity coefficients by Eq. (3.84), we get (γNa+ γBr− )(γK+ γCl− ) −ex G0 = exp (3.87) (γNa+ γCl− )(γK+ γBr− ) RT If γCl− from the component NaCl is assumed to be the same as γCl− from the component KCl and so forth, one ends up with the contradiction −ex G0 1 = exp (3.88) RT This demonstrates that it is not advisable to split up salt activities in this way into ion activities when using the Raoultian standard state. Conclusions.
(1) (2) (3)
(4)
As concluding remarks the following points should be emphasized.
It is generally agreed that single ion activities cannot be determined by thermodynamic measurements. In any work applying single ion activities, the convention used should be clearly stated and carefully analyzed. Single ion activities should be used for components where the activities are expressed in terms of the ideal dilute solution as the standard state (Henrian activities). In the treatment of thermodynamic properties of mixed systems of molten salts or slags used as standard state pure components (Raoultian standard states), the use of single ion activity is to be avoided, as it leads to contradictions.
3.1.4.2. Model of regular solutions
The model of regular solutions is very frequently used for which the conditions expressed in Eq. (3.59) are valid. This means that the deviation from the ideal behavior is ascribed to the change in enthalpy at the interaction of the components on mixing. For the excess
126
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
Gibbs energy of regular solutions different relations have been postulated, for example according to Redlich and Kister ex G0 = xA xB A + BxB + CxB2 + · · ·
(3.89)
ex G0 = xA xB A + B (xA − xB ) + C (xA − xB )2 + · · ·
(3.90)
ex G0 = xA xB (xA A + xB B)
(3.91)
or Guggenheim
or Margules
or van Laar ex G0 = xA xB
AB AxA + BxB
(3.92)
as also other relations. For simple regular solutions it holds ex G0 = xA xB A
(3.93)
where A is the coefficient of interaction of the components in the simple regular solutions. From conditions (3.59) it follows that in these solutions the excess entropy of mixing is equal to zero and it thus holds ex G0 = ex H 0
(3.94)
The model of regular solutions thus ascribes deviations from the ideal solution to the non-zero enthalpy of mixing. From the excess Gibbs energy of mixing, we can calculate the activity coefficients of the components, however, the mole fractions must be calculated from the amounts of substances xA =
nA , nA + n B
xB =
nB nA + n B
(3.95)
Then it holds nB nA A nA + n B nA + n B nA nB ex G = ex G0 (nA + nB ) = A nA + n B
ex G0 = xA xB A =
(3.96) (3.97)
Phase Equilibria
127
Note that ex G is the extensive property while ex G0 is the intensive one. The partial derivative of ex G according to the amount of substance of the respective component at T, P, and ni = constant yields
∂ex G ∂nA ∂ex G ∂nB
= RT ln γA =
AxB2
= A (1 − xA ) = 2
T , P , nB
= RT ln γB =
AxA2
= A (1 − xB ) = 2
T , P , nA
∂ex H ∂nA ∂ex H ∂nB
(3.98)
T , P , nB
(3.99) T , P , nA
For the activity coefficients we then obtain the relation
A γi = exp (1 − xi )2 RT
(3.100)
If the liquid phase behaves like a simple regular solution, for the dependence of the liquidus temperature on composition (the Le Chatelier–Shreder’s equation (3.22)) we get
T =
fus Hi + A(1 − xi )2 fus Hi + RT ln γi = fus Si − R ln xl, i fus Si − R ln xl, i
(3.101)
3.1.4.3. Temkin’s model of ideal ionic solutions
Both the above-mentioned models could be applied only to the systems of type I. For the description of the dependence ai = f (xi ) of inorganic molten systems of type II, the Temkin’s model of ideal ionic solution is used most frequently. The Temkin’s model is based on three postulates. (1)
(2)
(3)
The solution as a whole as well as its components are composed solely from ions 3− (simple, e.g. Na+ , Ca2+ or complex, e.g. SO2− 4 , AlF6 ). Electrically neutral particles (molecules) are not present. With regard to the high concentration of electrically charged particles, substantial electrostatic forces originate among them. Consequently, every ion is surrounded by ions of the opposite charge. This excludes the interchange of the cation in its position by an anion and vice versa. Thus, as a whole, the solution is composed of two independent, mutually interlocked solutions, i.e. of the solution of cations and the solution of anions. In its “own” solution, all ions are equivalent regardless of their dimensions and charge and they are randomly (statistically) distributed.
128
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
From the third postulate two important conclusions follow. (a) (b)
The enthalpies of mixing of the cation and anion solutions equal zero, thus also the enthalpy of mixing of the solution as a whole equals zero, mix H = 0. The entropy of mixing of the cation and anion solutions has solely the configurational character. The entropy of mixing as a whole is equal to the sum of the entropies of mixing of both the ionic solutions, thus it is not equal to the entropy of mixing of the ideal solution, mix S = mix S∗ .
Deviations from the classical ideal solution in the Temkin’s model are thus ascribed to the non-ideal entropy of mixing. Let us consider a general type of molten ionic binary mixture AX–BY (e.g. NaCl–LiI). In such a mixture cations A+ and B+ and anions X− and Y− are present. The entropy of mixing of such a mixing is equal to the sum of the entropies of mixing of both the independent solutions of cations and anions mix S = mix SA+ + B+ + mix SX− + Y−
(3.102)
Since it was postulated that in every solution the ions are mixing randomly it holds
mix SA+ + B+ = mix SA∗ + + B+ = −R nA+ ln xA+ + nB+ ln xB+
mix SX− + Y− = mix SX∗ − + Y− = −R nX− ln xX− + nY− ln xY−
(3.103) (3.104)
or
mix S = −R nA+ ln xA+ + nB+ ln xB+ + nX− ln xX− + nY− ln xY−
(3.105)
where nA+ , nB+ , nX− , and nY− are the amounts of ions and xA+ , xB+ , xX− , and xY− are their molar fractions, respectively, defined by the equations (according to the postulate) xA+ =
nA+ nB+ nX − nY − , x += ,x − = , x −= nA+ + nB+ B nA+ + nB+ X nX − + n Y − Y nX− + nY− (3.106)
If mix H = 0, then mix G = −T mix S. For mix G in general it holds mix G =
ni (µ − µi )
(3.107)
i
In order to obtain the relation for the chemical potential of the component e.g. AX we must partially differentiate Eq. (3.107) according to nAX . But when we exchange nA+
Phase Equilibria
129
for dnA+ , we automatically exchange also nX− for dnX− (the solution must remain on the whole electrically neutral). We must thus make the derivative according to nA+ and nX− simultaneous. For the chemical potential of the component AX we thus get
µAX − µ0AX
∂mix G = ∂nAX
nB , nY
∂mix G = ∂nA+
ni=A
∂mix G + ∂nX−
(3.108) ni=X
and
µAX − µ0AX = RT ln xA+ + RT ln xX− = RT ln xA+ xX− = RT ln aAX
(3.109)
For the activity of the component AX it thus holds aAX = xA+ xX−
(3.110)
Similar relations can be obtained also for the other components. Examples LiF(1)–NaF(2): x 1 x1 + x 2 = xLiF x1 + x 2 x1 + x 2 x 2 x1 + x 2 = = xNaF x1 + x 2 x1 + x 2
aLiF = xLi+ xF− = aNaF = xNa+ xF −
daLiF dxLiF = = 1; dxLiF dxLiF
daNaF =1 dxNaF
The system is thus of type I. One molecule of LiF introduces into the molten NaF one new particle, the cation Li+ . We also obtain the same result for NaF, where one molecule of NaF introduces into the molten LiF one new particle, the cation Na+ . LiF(1)–BaCl2 (2): x12 x1 x1 = x1 + x2 x1 + 2x2 2 − x1 2 4x23 2x2 x2 = = x1 + x2 x1 + 2x2 (1 + x2 )2
aLiF = xLi+ xF− = 2 aBaCl2 = xBa2+ xCl −
2x1 (2 − x1 ) + x12 4x1 − x12 daLiF = = 2 dxLiF (2 − x1 ) (2 − x1 )2 lim
x1 → 1
daLiF = kst,Ba Cl2 /LiF = 3 dxLiF
130
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
This system thus belongs to those of type II. One molecule of BaCl2 introduces into the molten LiF three new particles, Ba2+ and 2Cl− . 12x22 (1 + x2 ) − 4x23 · 2 daBaCl2 = dxBaCl2 (1 + x2 )3 daBaCl2 = kSt, LiF/BaCl2 = 2 x2 →1 dxBaCl2 lim
One molecule of LiF introduces into the molten BaCl2 two new particles, Li+ and F− . The Temkin’s relation for the ai = f(xi ) dependence represents the limiting relation and thus enables the rational introduction of the Stortenbeker’s correction factor. The dependence ai = f(xi ) for the systems of type II is shown in Figure 3.3. The slope of the tangent to the dependence ai = f(xi ) intersects on the x-axis a section, which is the reciprocal value of the Stortenbeker’s correction factor. According to the Boltzmann statistics, the probability of a given arrangement of N particles is proportional to the factor e−E/kT divided by the total sum of all possible arrangements of N particles. E is the energy of the given arrangement. The configurational
Activity
1
1/k(St) = 1/2
0 1
Molar fraction
Figure 3.3. The dependence ai = f (xi ) for systems of type II.
0
Phase Equilibria
131
partition function Q for a binary mixture composed of A and B particles can be written in the form 1 . . . e−E/kT dr1 . . . drN (3.111) Q= NA !NB ! where NA and NB are the number of particles A and B, respectively and N = NA + NB . Since E does not change when A and B do change their configurations, all configurations must have the same statistical weight. Thus A and B are randomly distributed in all the configurations of the N particles. Such a mixture forms an ideal solution. The enthalpy of mixing is zero and the entropy of mixing is given by the equation mix S = −N k(xA ln xA + xB ln xB )
(3.112)
where Nk = R. The simplest molten salts mixture must be composed of at least three kinds of particles, e.g. A+ , B+ , and C− , where A+ and B+ are cations, C− is the common anion, and NA+ + NB+ = NC− . The Gibbs energy of mixing is given by the equation mix G = −RT (xA+ ln xA+ + xB+ ln xB+ )
(3.113)
where xA+ and xB+ are the molar fraction of cations A+ and B+ , respectively, defined by the equations xA+ =
nA+ , nA+ + nB+
xB+ =
nB+ nA+ + nB+
(3.114)
Equation (3.113) together with Eq. (3.114) define the Temkin’s ideal solutions. In a binary system there are three kinds of ions, e.g. A+ , B+ /X− . However, only the amount of two of these three constituents can be independently changed because of the constraint given by the condition of electro-neutrality
Reciprocal salt mixtures.
nA+ + nB+ = nX−
(3.115)
Ternary ionic systems contain four kinds of ions, which can be constituted in three different ways: (A+ , B+ , C+ /X− ), (A+ /X− , Y− , Z− ), or (A+ , B+ /X− , Y− ). The first two arrangements are additive ternary systems (the former one is a system with a common anion, the latter one is a system with a common cation), while the last one is a ternary reciprocal system. Having in mind the restriction of electro-neutrality, there are only three independent salt components, from which the solution could be built up.
132
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
Let us now pay attention to ternary reciprocal systems. They contain two different cations and two different anions. Due to such a composition, they differ somewhat from the additive ternary systems. There are four constituents, AX, AY, BX, BY, but only three of them are independent components. The solution can be made up in four ways, i.e. AX–AY–BX, AX–AY–BY, AX–BX–BY, and AY–BX–BY. In each of these cases, the composition of the final solution will differ. Let us consider one mole of a solution in which the composition is xA+ = 0.3 and xX− = 0.5. Using three salts only the solution can be composed in two different ways. From these two figures it follows that xB+ = 0.7 and xY− = 0.5. The composition of the solution built up in the two ways is given in Table 3.1. Both of these ways will lead to the same final solution, but the Gibbs energy of mixing in both ways will differ. While the composition of an ordinary ternary system is represented by a triangle, the ternary reciprocal system is represented by a square, corners of which represent the pure constituents AX, AY, BX, BY. The final solution that we are considering lies inside the two triangles AX–BX–BY and AY–BX–BY. There are two peculiarities of the ternary reciprocal system. The first one concerns the activities and the chemical potentials. Regardless of the way the solution was made up, the activities and chemical potentials of all the four constituents are defined and are the same no matter which of the three components were chosen. In our example for the Temkin’s ideal solution aAX = xA+ xX− = 0.15, aAY = 0.15, aBX = 0.35, and aBY = 0.35. The second peculiarity results from the reciprocity of composition and thus from the equilibrium between AX, BY and AY, BX. The Gibbs energy of this equilibrium equals the sum of the standard Gibbs energies of formation of the components for the metathetical reaction AX + BY ↔ AY + BX
(3.116)
Remembering that xA+ = 0.3, xX− = 0.5, xB+ = 0.7, and xY− = 0.5, it is obvious that in the final solution there is always one salt missing, one on the left side or one on the right side. Thus the Gibbs energy of mixing must contain the term ±xi xj r G0 , where i and j are the cation and anion of the missing salt. The sign of the term is positive if i and Table 3.1. Amounts of AX, AY, BX, and BY salts to be in a ternary melt Amount of salt/mol
Salt AX AY BX BY
Case 1
Case 2
0.3 – 0.3 0.4
– 0.3 0.2 0.5
Phase Equilibria
133
j are for a salt on the right side of Eq. (3.116) and negative if it is on the left side. Thus mix G r G 0 = xA+ ln xA+ + xB+ ln xB+ + xX− ln xX− + xY− ln xY− ± xi xj + ... RT RT (3.117) This equation says that the term mix G/RT must be different from the ideal term xi ln xi if r G0 for the reaction (3.116) differs from zero. If the mixture is made up by AX, BY, and AY, reaction (3.116) is shifted to the right. Therefore mix G must increase by xB xX r G0 , since BX is formed in the melt. If the mixture is made up by AX, AY, and BX, reaction (3.116) is shifted in the opposite direction and BY is formed. This result was first obtained by Flood et al. (1954) using a thermodynamic approach and was later expanded by Blander and Yosim (1963) and Førland (1964). The activity coefficients in reciprocal salt systems can be calculated knowing the components that form the system. From the above we can deduce that one of the terms for the activity coefficient of the component, e.g. AY is RT ln γAY = ± xB xX r G0 · · ·
(3.118)
where r G0 is the Gibbs energy of the metathetical reaction (3.116) for which the “−” sign is valid. For the metathetical reaction running in the opposite direction, the “+” sign is valid. This is easily comprehensible in a qualitative way. If r G0 for reaction (3.116) is negative, the reaction will be shifted to the right and the amount of AY and BX neighbors in the mixture will be larger than predicted by random mixing. Therefore positive deviations from the ideality for AY and BX will occur. There is, however, a problem in dilute solutions, when values of xB or xX approach zero, since the activity coefficients of AY should then approach those in the binaries AX–AY or AX–BX. This problem overcomes the quasi-lattice theory. The quasi-lattice theory is based on a quasi-lattice, which consists of two interlocking sub-lattices of cations and anions. Only the nearest neighbor interactions are taken into account and the energy of any nearest neighbor pair is assumed to be independent of its environment (additivity of pair bond interactions). Nearest neighbor interactions are ignored, which means that all the binary systems are ideal. In the dilute solution of AX in BY, there is always some probability that A+ will meet − X and a new pair bond will originate. The fundamental energy change when this occurs is E. The Gibbs energy change depends also on the coordination of the A+ environment Z. The following equation must then hold for the metathetical reaction (3.116) −r G0 = ZE
(3.119)
134
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
where Z is the coordination number. Coordination numbers in molten salts appear to be about 4–5. If the quasi-lattice equations for the activity coefficients will be expanded up to the second order E, we obtain RT ln γAY = xB xX ZE − xB xX (xB xY + xA xX − xA xY )
ZE 2 + ... 2RT
(3.120)
where the second term on the right-hand side is the first correction for the non-random mixing. In order to overcome the problem with activity coefficients in dilute solutions, Førland (1964) suggested the addition of four additive binary terms ex ex ex xA Gex A + xB GB + xX GX + xY GY
= xA xX xY λA + xB xX xY λB + xX xA xB λX + xY xA xB λY
(3.121)
where Gex i is the excess Gibbs energy of mixing and λi is the interaction parameter for the binary system with i as a common ion. Adding the contribution from non-random mixing we obtain RT ln γAY = ± xB xX r G0 − xB xX (xB xY + xA xX − xA xY )
(r G0 )2 2ZRT
+ xB xX (xX − xY )λB + xX (xB xY + xA xX )λA + xB (xB xY + xA xX )λY + xB xX (xB − xA )λX
(3.122)
Equation (3.122) gives the activity coefficient and the corresponding Eq. (3.123) shows the total excess Gibbs energy of mixing when the components AX, BX, and AY are mixed ex mix Gex = ± xB xY r G0 + xA Gex A + xB GB ex + xX Gex X + xY GY + xA xB xX xY
(r G0 )2 2ZRT
(3.123)
In these equations, the “−” sign has to be chosen when r G0 is for the metathetical reaction AX + BY → AY + BX, and the sign “+” when r G0 is for the reaction AY + BX → AX + BY. Equations (3.122) and (3.123) are not necessarily valid for ionic systems. These equations have also been derived from the conformal ionic solution theory, thus providing a fundamental underpinning for this equation with a theory, which properly includes coulomb interactions. The form of the “non-random mixing” term has only been shown to be proportional to (r G0 )2 from the conformal solution theory. The term holds for a large scale of salts. The proportionality constant (2ZRT)−1 was chosen by analogy
Phase Equilibria
135
with the quasi-lattice theory. To compensate for the fact that the higher order term is not included, a large value of the parameter Z (= 6) appears to be necessary. If we look at the properties of Eqs. (3.122) and (3.123) we can see that they have right limiting values. When xB+ = xY− = 1 we obtain mix Gex = 0. If any one of the ion fraction approaches zero, then the equation reduces properly to that for the binary systems. The equation can be improved somewhat, if the additive binary terms are more generalized to read like the left-hand side of Eq. (3.121). The non-random mixing term containing (r G0 )2 can cause an S-shaped character of the ln γAY versus xB+ xX− plot. For instance, when xB+ + xX− , the ln γAY curve will have a positive contribution from this term up to xB+ = 0.333 and negative at xB+ > 0.333. An example for this behavior is the LiF–KCl system.
3.1.4.4. Molecular model
Contrary to the concept of the random mixing of ions, Fellner (1984), Fellner and Chrenková (1987) proposed the molecular model for molten salt mixtures in which it is assumed that in an ideal molten mixture, molecules (ionic pairs) mix randomly. The model composition of the melt, i.e. the molar fractions of ionic pairs in the molten mixture, is calculated on the basis of simultaneous chemical equilibrium among the components of the mixture. For instance, in the melt of the system M1 X–M2 X–M2Y one can assume + – + – + – + – 2– random mixing of the ionic pairs M+ 1 ·X , M2 ·X , M2 ·Y , M1 ·X , and 2M2 ·XY . The applicability of the model for the description of the behavior of thermodynamic properties of molten mixtures is tested by comparing the experimental and calculated solid–liquid phase equilibria in the system studied. It should be noted that this model is formally similar to the approach wherein the calculation of the thermodynamic equilibrium molecules of constituents instead of ionic pairs are considered.
3.1.4.5. Thermodynamic model of silicate melts
Owing to their polymeric character, silicate melts belong to the solutions of type II, which do not follow Raoult’s law. The classic regular solution approach is not applicable, since the limiting laws are not obeyed. The Temkin’s model of ideal ionic solution, which has been widely applied in molten salt systems, cannot be used, since the real anionic composition, owing to a broad polyanionic distribution, is not known a priori. Any structural model of silicate melts should be in agreement with certain experimentally determined physico-chemical properties of the given silicate system: •
high equivalent conductivity, increasing with a decreasing cation size, the conductivity being of ionic character, at least for the cations of I A and II A groups;
136
• • • •
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
the activation energy of viscous flow is roughly constant within the range of 10–60 mole % M2 O (M = alkali metal); the volume expansion is up to 10 mole % M2 O almost zero, approaching asymptotically for higher M2 O contents the value at about 50 mole % M2 O; the compressibility increases with increasing M2 O content up to 10–15 mole %, remaining further on constant values up to the concentration of about 50 mole %; conductivity measurements have proved the presence of anions, studies of transport phenomena have shown that the O2− anions do not contribute to the charge transfer.
It can be assumed that the course of the above relationships will also be similar in the MeO–SiO2 systems. On the basis of the above facts, the structure of the MeO–SiO2 melts can be imagined as a lattice of SiO4 tetrahedrons polymerized to a certain degree, where cations are situated in the free spaces between the tetrahedrons. This concept was used by Pánek and Daneˇ k (1977) to formulate the thermodynamic model of silicate melts. In the thermodynamic model of silicate melts, the chemical potential of component is expressed as the sum of chemical potentials of all energetically distinguishable atoms constituting the given component. Depending on the composition, oxygen atoms can be present as free oxygen anions, bridging, and non-bridging oxygen atoms. All oxygen atoms are thus not equivalent, i.e. their chemical potential is not equal. The material balance of the available oxygen atoms and the Si–O bonds then gives the amounts of individual oxygen atoms. Silicon atoms are present exclusively in fourfold coordination, while other network forming atoms, e.g. B, Al, Fe, etc., may be present both as cations and/or central atoms in tetrahedral structural units. In the latter case, these atoms participate at least partially on the formation of the polyanionic network, which has to be taken into account in the calculation of the activity of the component as well. Activities of individual components are calculated on the basis of the theory of conformal solutions (Reiss et al., 1962). This theory was derived for ionic systems without the formation of complex ions, in which both anions and cations have identical charges. This theory was later applied to systems containing ions of various valences (Saboungi and Blander, 1975). It should be emphasized that the application of this theory to silicate melts has only a formal character. Let us define the polymerization degree of silicate melts as the fraction of bridging oxygen atoms in a single formula unit. The assumptions, on the basis of which activities of components in the mixture are calculated, are as follows: (a) (b)
linear dependence of the polymerization degree on MeO content throughout the tectosilicate–nezosilicate series is assumed, polymerization degree of SiO4 tetrahedrons does not change during melting,
Phase Equilibria
(c)
137
arrangement of polyanions in the melt in the vicinity of the melting point or the temperature of primary crystallization is identical at close distance to that in the crystalline state.
Let us now consider an arbitrary melt in the MeO–SiO2 system (Me = Mg, Ca, Fe, . . .). The melt is composed of the following kinds of atoms: • • • •
the Me2+ cations, silicon atoms in tetrahedral coordination surrounded by two kinds of oxygen atoms, bridging oxygen atoms, linking two neighboring SiO4 tetrahedrons by means of Si–O–Si covalent bonds, and non-bridging oxygen atoms, bound to the silicon atom by one covalent bond and creating the coordination sphere of Me2+ cations.
The two kinds of oxygen atoms have evidently different energetic states. Their mutual molar ratio defines the structure of the melt, i.e. its polymerization degree as well as the chemical potentials of the components. With regard to this structural aspect of silicate systems, the chemical potential of an arbitrary component may be defined as the sum of chemical potentials of all atoms forming the component considered, when their particular energetic states are taken into account. The chemical potential of the ith component in an arbitrary solution is defined by the relation µi =
ni, j µj
(3.124)
j
where ni, j is the amount of atoms of the jth kind in the ith component and µj is the chemical potential of atoms of the jth kind in the solution. For instance, the chemical potential of CaSiO3 , which is formed in the CaO–SiO2 system, equals the sum of the chemical potentials of calcium atoms, silicon atoms, and the bridging and non-bridging oxygen atoms. The activity of the ith component in the solution is also defined by the equation µi = µ0i + RT ln ai
(3.125)
where µ0i is the chemical potential of the pure ith component, defined similarly to the chemical potential of this component in the solution µ0i =
j
ni, j µ0i, j
(3.126)
138
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
where µ0i,j is the chemical potential of the pure jth atoms in the pure ith component. Substituting Eqs. (3.124) and (3.126) into Eq. (3.125) we obtain
ni, j µi, j =
j
ni, j µ0i, j + RT ln ai
(3.127)
j
The real mole fraction of the jth atoms in the ith component and in the solution are given by the relations ni, j yi,0 j = ni, j
j
ni, j xi i yj = xi ni, j i
(3.128)
(3.129)
j
where xi is the mole fraction of ith component in the solution. The chemical potentials of the jth atoms in the pure ith component and in the solution may also be expressed using Eqs. (3.128) and (3.129) in the following way 0 µ0i, j = µ+ j + RT ln yi, j
(3.130)
µj = µ+ j + RT ln yj
(3.131)
where µ+ j is the chemical potential of a hypothetical liquid composed exclusively of the jth atoms. Inserting Eqs. (3.130) and (3.131) into Eq. (3.127) we get for the activity of the ith component in the solution the relation ln ai =
ni, j ln yj −
j
ni, j ln yi,0 j
(3.132)
j
or after rearrangement ai =
j
yj 0 yi,j
ni, j (3.133)
Equation (3.133) for the activity of a component derived in this way is completely universal and may be used in any system. The calculation of the activity of a component in an actual system using this equation thus respects the characteristic features of silicate melts, e.g. the different energetic state of individual atoms of the same kind. Such cases may
Phase Equilibria
139
occur in the presence of three-valence atoms like B3+ , Al3+ , Fe3+ , etc., or four-valence atoms like Ti4+ . In order to describe the structural aspect of the given silicate melt, it is necessary to perform correctly the material balance of individual oxygen atoms as well as of the above-mentioned double-acting atoms. The material balance is based on the following principles. Let us assume that in the system consisting of m oxides, the polymeric network is formed by three- and fourfold coordinated atoms jA (j = 1, 2, . . . m) linked to the bridging (−O−) and non-bridging (−O− ) oxygen atoms. Denoting the fraction of the k-fold coordinated jA atoms as αk,j , the following inequality must hold α3,j + α4,j ≤ 1
(3.134)
The distribution of the atoms according to their coordination, or to their participation in a covalent network, is then determined by the following material balance n(jA) = n0 (jA) + n3 (jA) + n4 (jA)
(3.135)
n0 (jA) = (1 − α3,j − α4,j )n(jA)
(3.136)
n3 (jA) = α3,j n(jA)
(3.137)
n4 (jA) = α4,j n(jA)
(3.138)
where
where nk (jA) is the amount of the k-fold coordinated jA atoms and n0 (jA) is the amount of those jA atoms, which are not built into the polyanionic network. Then the amount of n(jA − O) bonds is given by the relation n(jA − O) =
m
[(3α3, j + 4α4, j )n(jA)]
(3.139)
j =1
Assuming that the total amount of oxygen atoms, n(O) equals the sum of the bridging, n(−O−), and non-bridging, n(−O− ), oxygen atoms, we can calculate their amounts from the material balances of the total amounts of oxygen atoms and the jA−O bonds according to the equations n(O) = n(−O − ) + n(−O− )
(3.140)
n(−O−) = n(jA − O) − n(O)
(3.141)
140
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
If the solution does not have a physical reason (i.e. the values of n(i) are negative), it is necessary to assume that non-bridging oxygen atoms and oxide ions O2− are present. The material balance is then given by the equations n(O) = n(−O− ) + n(O2− )
(3.142)
n(−O− ) = n(jA − O)
(3.143)
For the typical modifying atoms such as alkali metals and earth alkali metals it is assumed that α3,j = α4,j = 0
(3.144)
while for the typical network-forming elements of the IV group of the periodic system like silicon and germanium α4,j = 1. In other cases, the value of αk,j can be chosen in order to fit the calculated and experimentally determined phase diagrams. The formal polymerization degree P of the melt with a given composition can be calculated from Eqs. (3.140) and (3.141). Since the polymerization degree was defined as the fraction of the bridging oxygen atoms in the total oxygen atoms, then it can be written m
n(jA − O) − n(O) n(−O−) = = P = n(O) n(O)
j =1
[n(jA)(3α3,j + 4α4,j )] n(O)
−1
(3.145)
For instance, for the MeO–SiO2 system with the composition (1−x) MeO + x SiO2 it holds that n(jA) = x, m = 2, 1A = Me, 2A = Si, α3,1 = α3,2 = α4,1 = 0, and α4,2 = 1. The polymerization degree is then P =
4x −1 1+x
(3.146)
In such a melt for x = 0.333, i.e. for the composition of orthosilicate, is P = 0, and for the pure SiO2 melt, (x = 1), P = 1. The thermodynamic model of silicate melts has been applied in the calculation of various types of binary, ternary, and pseudo-ternary phase diagrams.
Application of the model to different systems.
(i) (ii)
simple binary and ternary eutectic systems, binary and ternary systems with the formation of several congruently and incongruently melting compounds,
Phase Equilibria
141
Table 3.2. Temperatures and enthalpies of fusion of different compounds Compound Al2 O3 (A) 3Al2 O3 ·2SiO2 (A3 S2 ) B2 O3 (B) CaO (C) CaO·Al2 O3 (CA) CaO·2Al2 O3 (CA2 ) 12CaO·7Al2 O3 (C12A7 ) 2CaO·Al2 O3 ·SiO2 (C2AS) CaO·Al2 O3 ·2SiO2 (CAS2 ) CaO·MgO·2SiO2 (CMS2 ) 2CaO·MgO·2SiO2 (C2 MS2 ) CaO·SiO2 (CS) 2CaO·SiO2 (C2 S) 3CaO·2SiO2 (C3 S2 ) CaO·TiO2 (CT) CaO·TiO2 ·SiO2 (CTS) MgO·Al2 O3 (MA) MgO·SiO2 (MS) 2MgO·SiO2 (M2 S) MnO·SiO2 (MS) Na2 O (N) Na2 O·B2 O3 (NB) Na2 O·2B2 O3 (NB2 ) Na2 O·3B2 O3 (NB3 ) Na2 O·4B2 O3 (NB4 ) K2 O (K) K2 O·B2 O3 (KB) K2 O·2B2 O3 (KB2 ) Li2 O·B2 O3 (LB) Li2 O·2B2 O3 (LB2 ) SiO2 (S) TiO2 (T)
(iii)
Tfus (K)
fus H (kJmol−1 )
2293 2123 723 2843 1878 2033 1728 1868 1826 1665 1727 1817 2403 1718 2243 1656 2408 1850 2171 1564 1405 1239 1016 1045 1088 1154 1223 1088 1117 1190 1996 2103
111.4 188.3 22.2 52.0 102.5 200.0 209.3 155.9 166.8 128.3 85.7 56.0 55.4 146.5 127.3 139.0 200.0 75.2 71.1 66.9 47.6 72.4 81.1 105.7 133.4 32.7 64.8 104.1 67.7 120.4 9.6 66.9
References Barin et al. (1973, 1977) Barin et al. (1973, 1977) Barin et al.(1973, 1977) Barin et al. (1973, 1977) Barin et al. (1973, 1977) Barin et al. (1973, 1977) Barin et al. (1973, 1977) Barin et al. (1973, 1977) Barin et al. (1973, 1977) Ferrier (1971) Barin et al. (1973, 1977) Barin et al. (1973, 1977) Barin et al. (1973, 1977) Barin et al. (1973, 1977) Estimated Nerád et al. (2000) Barin et al. (1973, 1977) Barin et al. (1973, 1977) Barin et al. (1973, 1977) Barin et al. (1973, 1977) Barin et al. (1973, 1977) Barin et al. (1973, 1977) Barin et al.(1973, 1977) Estimated Estimated Therm. Propert. (1965) Estimated Barin et al. (1973, 1977) Barin et al. (1973,1977) Barin et al. (1973, 1977) Barin et al. (1973,1977) Barin et al. (1973, 1977)
ternary systems with four crystallization areas, where the figurative point of the fourth crystalline phase lies beyond the pseudo-ternary diagram.
Silicate, alumino-silicate, ferro- and ferri-silicate, calcium–titanium–silicate, and alkali metal borate systems were chosen. The basic thermodynamic data of the individual components, i.e. the temperatures and enthalpies of fusion, were mainly taken from the literature and are summarized in Table 3.2. Data published by Bottinga and Richet (1978) were taken into account as well. However, for some components, the values of the enthalpy of fusion were not known. In such cases, these data were estimated on the basis of thermodynamic analogy. Besides, the full chemical formula and the acronym of the component is given in the table.
142
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
In the application of the model to calculate the phase diagrams, the liquidus temperature of component i, Ti,liq , is calculated using the values of the enthalpy and temperature of fusion according to the simplified and adapted Le Chatelier–Shreder equation Ti,liq =
fus Hi Tfus,i fus Hi − RTfus,i ln ai
(3.147)
where Tfus, i and fus Hi are the temperature and enthalpy of fusion of the ith component, respectively, and ai is its activity calculated according to Eq. (3.133). In most cases it could be assumed that fus Hi = constant. However, when necessary, i.e. at great differences between the melting and eutectic temperatures, the change of fus Hi with temperature could be expressed in the form fus Hi (T ) = fus Hi (Tfus ) − CP , s/l (Tfus − T )
(3.148)
The first crystallizing phase at the given composition is determined according to the condition Tpc = max(Ti, liq ) i
(3.149)
Pánek and Daneˇ k (1977) calculated various binary or pseudo-binary phase diagrams of the ternary system CaO–MgO–SiO2 . The systems, SiO2 –CaO·SiO2 , CaO·MgO·2SiO2 –SiO2 , CaO·SiO2 –CaO·MgO·2SiO2 , CaO·SiO2 – 2CaO·MgO·2SiO2 , CaO·MgO·2SiO2 –2CaO·MgO·2SiO2 , CaO·SiO2 –2CaO·SiO2 , and CaO·MgO·2SiO2 –2MgO·SiO2 were chosen. The experimental phase diagrams of these systems were taken from Levin et al. (1964, 1969, 1975) for comparison. The authors neglected in all cases the change in the enthalpy of fusion with temperature. In Figures 3.4 and 3.5, the comparison of the calculated and experimentally determined phase diagrams of the systems, CaSiO3 –Ca2 MgSi2 O7 and CaSiO3 –Ca2 SiO4 , respectively, are shown as examples. In the CS–C2 S system, the incongruently melting compound C3 S2 is formed, which affects the activity of CS or C2 S in the melt. For this reason, this fact should be considered in the calculation of the partial systems CS–C3 S2 and C3 S2 –C2 S.
The CaO–MgO–SiO2 system.
The comparison of liquidus surfaces of CaSiO3 calculated using the thermodynamic model of silicate melts with the experimental ones was used by Daneˇ k (1984) to study the real structure of melts of the CaO–“FeO”–SiO2 system in equilibrium with metallic iron and that of the CaO– “Fe2 O3 ”–SiO2 system in equilibrium with air (P (O2 ) = 21kPa), i.e. the participation of individual Fe(II) and Fe(III) atoms in the polyanionic network. The phase equilibrium
The CaO–“FeO”–SiO2 and CaO–“Fe2 O3 ”–SiO2 systems.
Phase Equilibria
143
1800
T(K)
1750
1700
1650
CS
0.2
0.4 0.6 x(C2MS2)
0.8
C2MS2
Figure 3.4. Phase diagram of the CaSiO3 –Ca2 MgSi2 O7 system.
2400
T(K)
2200
2000
C3S2
1800
1600 CS
0.2
0.4
x(C2S)
0.6
0.8
C2S
Figure 3.5. Phase diagram of the CaSiO3 –Ca2 SiO4 system.
144
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
in the four-component CaO–FeO–Fe2 O3 –SiO2 system has been studied by Muan and Osborne (1965) and Timucin and Morris (1970). Relatively unambiguous is the situation in the CaO–“FeO”–SiO2 system, where Fe(II) atoms are placed in the interstitial sites with higher than fourfold coordination. However, according to the results of density measurement performed by Lee and Gaskell (1974), these melts tend to micro-segregate into regions richer in calcium oxide and regions richer in iron oxide. On the other hand, Fe(III) atoms in the CaO–“Fe2 O3 ”–SiO2 system can enter the polyanionic network being in the fourfold coordination (network former) or, similar to the Fe(II) atoms, being in higher coordination and behave as the network modifier. The dependence of interatomic distance Fe–O on composition is similar to that of Si–Si, which corresponds to the transition of Fe(III) atoms from the octahedral sites to the tetrahedral ones. The calculated part of the phase diagram of the CaO–“FeO”–SiO2 system is shown in Figure 3.6. A similar part of the experimental phase diagram according to Muan and Osborn (1965) is shown in Figure 3.7 for comparison. The boundary curves of the CaSiO3 liquidus surface were also obtained by the calculation of the liquidus surfaces of Ca2 SiO4 and Fe2 SiO4 . The boundary curve with tridymite could not be determined because of a large immiscibility gap in the region of high SiO2 concentration, which the thermodynamic model does not take into account.
70
00
1100
°C
°C
°C 1200
CS
1300 °C
°C 1400
1500
CS 50
°C
xm ole %
SiO
2
60
10
C3S2 40 C2S
0 °C
100
C2S
F2S
30 0
10
20 30 x mole % FeO
40
50
Figure 3.6. Calculated part of the phase diagram of the CaO–“FeO”–SiO2 system.
Phase Equilibria
145
70
Rridymite
Pseudowl
°C
Wollastonite
°C 00
13
Ro
C2S
°C
nk
°C
00
14
C3S2 40
00
00
14
11
CS 50
1200 °C
xm
ole
%S
iO
2
60
Oilvine
C2S 30 0
10
20 30 x mole % FeO
40
50
Figure 3.7. Part of the phase diagram of the CaO–“FeO”–SiO2 system taken from Muan and Osborn (1965).
As it follows from Figures 3.6 and 3.7, a relatively good agreement between the experimental and calculated liquidus surface was obtained when all Fe(II) atoms present are in higher coordination and behave as the network modifier. The dotted lines in Figure 3.8 represent isotherms in the CaSiO3 liquidus surface calculated for the case, when all Fe(II) atoms behave as a network former. It is evident that such an assumption is not correct. However, some of the Fe(II) atoms in tetrahedral coordination cannot be excluded. The calculation of the CaSiO3 liquidus surface in the CaO–“Fe2 O3 ”–SiO2 system was carried out for two cases: (i) (ii)
all Fe(III) atoms are in the tetrahedral coordination and together with the SiO4 tetrahedrons participate in the polyanionic network formation, only half of the Fe(III) atoms is in tetrahedral coordination, while the other half behaves as the network modifier being in higher coordination.
The third possibility, that all Fe(III) atoms behave as network modifiers was, as improbable, not considered. The calculated part of the phase diagram of the CaO–“Fe2 O3 ”–SiO2 system is shown in Figure 3.8. The similar part of the experimental phase diagram according to Muan and Osborn (1965) is shown in Figure 3.9 for comparison. The boundary curves of the CaSiO3 liquidus surface were also obtained by the calculation of the liquidus surfaces
146
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
C
CS 50
°C
CS
C3S2 40
13 00 °C
00 14
13 00 °C
15 00 °
xm ole
%
SiO
2
60
Fe2O3
C2S
C2S 30 0
10
20 x mole % Fe2O3
30
Figure 3.8. Calculated part of the phase diagram of the CaO–“Fe2 O3 ”–SiO2 system.
60
Tridymite
C2S
Ra
nk
1300
13
°C
00
°C
00
°C
°C 14
xm
C3S2 40
00
15
CS 50
ole
%
SiO
2
Pseudowol
Hematite
C2S
P
30 0
10
20 x mole % Fe2O3
30
Figure 3.9. Part of the phase diagram of the CaO–“Fe2 O3 ”–SiO2 system taken from Muan and Osborn (1965).
of Ca2 SiO4 and Fe2 O3 . The other limitations concerning the boundary limits and the immiscibility gap are similar to the CaO–“FeO”–SiO2 system. The dotted lines in Figure 3.8 represent isotherms of the CaSiO3 liquidus surface for the first case (i). This assumption is obviously not fulfilled. Very good agreement with the experimental phase diagram was attained in the second case. It may therefore be
Phase Equilibria
147
stated that in the melts of the CaO–“Fe2 O3 ”–SiO2 system having the x(CaO)/x(Si O2 ) modulus in the range 0.6–1.5, roughly half of the Fe(III) atoms present is coordinated tetrahedrally and behaves as the network former, while the other one contributes to the polyanion destruction and behaves as the network modifier. Such an arrangement does 4− not exclude the possibility of the anion formation of the Fe2 O2− 4 and Fe2 O5 type as it is mentioned in the article of Mori and Suzuki (1968). The coordination of Al(III) atoms in aluminosilicate melts is one of the most important research directions in the structure of the melts containing alumina. This interest is associated with an extensive utilization of these melts in different sections of the silicate industry, such as glass, cement, porcelain production, etc. Conclusions on the structure of aluminosilicate melts are mainly based on the interpretation of physico-chemical properties, such as density and viscosity, in terms of composition, particularly of the x(CaO)/x(Al2 O3 ) ratio. The basic idea was the concept that in melts with the ratio x(CaO)/x(Al2 O3 ) ≥ 1, all the Al(III) atoms are in tetrahedral coordination and that the octahedral coordination of Al(III) atoms occurs only at ratios x(Ca)/x(Al2 O3 ) < 1, i.e. at the excess of alumina with respect to CaO. The coordination of Al(III) atoms in the CaO–Al2 O3 –SiO2 system melts was studied using the thermodynamic model of silicate melts by Liška and Daneˇ k (1990). This system is rather complicated because of the formation of a number of binary and ternary compounds. The calculation was performed on the assumption that one half of the Al(III) atoms are in tetrahedral coordination over the entire concentration range in question, and that the other half of the Al(III) atoms are in higher coordination, obviously in the octahedral one. The latter part thus does not participate in the formation of the polyanionic network. The calculated phase diagram of this system is shown in Figure 3.10, while the experimentally determined phase diagram according to Muan and Osborn (1965) is shown in Figure 3.11. The immiscibility region near the SiO2 apex was neglected in the calculation as such behavior is not considered in the thermodynamic model. Furthermore, because of the lack of thermodynamic data, the crystallization of rankinite, tricalcium silicate, tricalcium aluminate, and calcium hexaaluminate was not included in the calculation. From the comparison of the calculated and experimentally determined phase diagram of the CaO–Al2 O3 –SiO2 system, it follows that the Al(III) atoms are in partial tetrahedral coordination also in the composition range for x(CaO)/x(Al2 O3 ) ≥ 1. This finding is relatively surprising considering the available information on the behavior of Al(III) atoms in silicate melts. However, it is in agreement with a very similar behavior of Fe(III) atoms in the melts of the CaO–Fe2 O3 –SiO2 system. It can be concluded that the thermodynamic model of silicate melts is very suitable for describing phase equilibrium also in aluminosilicate systems.
The CaO–Al2 O3 –SiO2 system.
148
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
SiO2
CS
CAS2
C2S A3S2
C2AS
20
CaO
40 C12A7 60CA CA1280 Mass %
Al2O3
Figure 3.10. Calculated phase diagram of the CaO–Al2 O3 –SiO2 system.
SiO2
CS C3S2
CAS2
C2S C3S
C2AS
20 CaO
A3S2
C3A40 C12A7 60CA CA280 CA6 Al2O3 Mass (%)
Figure 3.11. Experimental phase diagram of the CaO–Al2 O3 –SiO2 system according to Muan and Osborn (1965).
Phase Equilibria
149
Silicate systems containing TiO2 are of considerable technological and geochemical interest. Titanium dioxide is a common component of industrial glasses, enamels, pyro-ceramics, and of some metallurgical slags. The structural role of Ti(IV) in silicate melts has been studied in many spectroscopic investigations, e.g. by Yarker et al. (1986), Abdrashitova (1980), Schneider et al. (1991), Mysen and Neuville (1995), and Liška et al. (1995). It is a complex function of several variables, namely TiO2 and SiO2 concentration, type, and content of the modifying cations and temperature. Despite the number of investigations, a consensus has been reached neither regarding the coordination state of Ti(IV) atoms, nor on how the structure of the melts is modified by their presence. The results obtained by various methods are often contradictory. In situ high-temperature Raman spectroscopy of melts along the Na2 Si2 O5 −Na2 Ti2 O5 join performed by Mysen and Neuville (1995) has shown that the Raman spectra of Ti-bearing glasses and melts are consistent with Ti(IV) in at least three different structural positions: The CaO–TiO2 –SiO2 system.
(a) (b) (c)
Ti(IV) substitutes for Si(IV) in tetrahedral coordination in structural units of the melt (acts as network former), Ti(IV) forms TiO2 -like clusters with Ti(IV) in tetrahedral coordination, Ti(IV) as network modifier, possibly occurring in octahedral or fivefold coordination.
The structural behavior of Ti(IV) was also determined by Nerád and Daneˇ k (2002) by the calculation of phase diagrams of the pseudo-binary systems, CaSiO3 –CaTiSiO5 , CaSiO3 –CaTiO3 , Ca2 SiO4 –CaTiO3 , CaTiSiO5 –CaTiO3 , and CaTiSiO5 –TiO2 , in the binary system CaO–TiO2 , as well as in the whole ternary system CaO–TiO2 –SiO2 . The comparison of the calculated phase diagram of the ternary system CaO–TiO2 – SiO2 (Figure 3.12) and that of the experimentally determined (De Vries et al., 1955), Figure 3.13) is shown for demonstration. In the CaO–TiO2 –SiO2 system the following phases are present: CaO, TiO2 , SiO2 , Ca3 SiO5 , Ca2 SiO4 , Ca3 Si2 O7 , CaSiO3 , CaTiO3 , Ca3 Ti2 O7 , and CaTiSiO5 . Some existing phases, namely rankinite and tricalcium silicate, were not included in the calculation because of lack of relevant thermodynamic data. The calculation was performed taking into account that all the Ti(IV) atoms present are in tetrahedral coordination, i.e. they act as network formers. In the region of high content of SiO2 , the calculation of the phase equilibrium fails as the formation of two liquids is not considered in the thermodynamic model of silicate melts. This is also the reason for the enlarged liquidus surface of CaTiSiO5 up to the high content of silica.
150
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
SiO2 0.8
0.8
2
x(S iO )
0.6
0.6
CaSiO3
0.4
0.4 CaTiSiO5
Ca2SiO4
0.2
0.2
Ca3Ti2O7 CaTiO3
CaO
0.2
0.4
x(TiO2)
0.6
0.8
TiO 2
Figure 3.12. Calculated phase diagram of the CaO–TiO2 –SiO2 system.
SiC2 1713˚
1698˚
1550˚
1780˚ Silico
1650
1698˚
1600
00
16 00
15
CaSiO3 1318° ° 98 13
16
00
° 25 14
° 03 14
1353° 1348°
1373 Rutile
Sphere
1800
CT5 1382°
1365° 1375°
1375°
00 °
1335°
19
Ca3SiO3
00 20
2130˚-Ca3SiO4 2065˚
1700 1600 1535
00
14
CaSiO3 1544˚ 1463˚ 1467˚ Ca3Si2O7
1670° ? Ca0
1670° ?
Perovskite
16
1365° Rutile
1650°
16
00
00
2000
2200
2400
1800
00
15
18
CaO 2570˚
00
1695˚1780˚ Ca3Ti2O7 Ca3Ti2O3 1970˚
1460˚
1760˚
Ti2O3 1830˚
Figure 3.13. Experimental phase diagram of the CaO–TiO2 –SiO2 system according to De Vries et al. (1955).
Phase Equilibria
151
In the TiO2 -rich region, the experimental liquidus surface of TiO2 fits best the simple model ai = xi . The reason may be the basic nature of the TiO2 -rich melts. More probable is that not all the Ti(IV) atoms are in tetrahedral coordination. From the comparison of the calculated and experimental phase diagrams, it follows that the thermodynamic model of silicate melts is suitable for the description of the phase equilibrium also in titania-bearing silicate systems and provides deeper information on the behavior of Ti(IV) atoms. It was, however, shown that Ti(IV) atoms behave in silicate melts as network formers, except in the region of its high concentration, and in highly basic melts. Liška and Daneˇ k (1990) also calculated the phase diagrams of the following ternary and pseudo-ternary systems:
Other silicate systems.
• • • •
MgO·SiO2 –CaO·MgO·2SiO2 –CaO·Al2 O3 ·SiO2 , CaO·MgO·2SiO2 –MnO·SiO2 –CaO·Al2 O3 ·2SiO2 , MgO·Al2 O3 –2CaO·SiO2 –2CaO·Al2 O3 ·SiO2 , 2CaO·Al2 O3 ·SiO2 –MgO·Al2 O3 –CaO·Al2 O3 ·2SiO2 .
The experimentally determined phase diagrams were taken from Levin et al. (1964, 1969, 1975). It was again assumed that one half of the Al(III) atoms are in tetrahedral coordination and the other half are in higher coordination and behave as network modifiers. The last system with four crystallization areas is interesting where the figurative point of the fourth crystalline phase lies beyond the pseudo-ternary diagram. The calculated and experimentally determined phase diagrams of this system are shown in Figures 3.14 and 3.15, respectively.
Cor u
1500
ndu 15 m 50
CAS2
00
1550
16
C2AS
20
40 60 Mass (%)
80
MA
Figure 3.14. Calculated phase C2AS–MA–CAS2 system.
152
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes CAS2
Corundum
00
00
15
15
16
00
1600
C2AS
20
40 60 Mass (%)
80
MA
Figure 3.15. Experimental phase diagram of the diagram of the C2AS–MA–CAS2 system according to Levin et al. (1964, 1969, 1975).
As mentioned in Section 2.1.10, in the binary glass-forming systems of alkali metal borates there is the ability of boron to change from the threefold to fourfold coordination. This observation was verified by Daneˇ k and Pánek (1979) on calculating the liquidus curves in alkali metal borate systems using the thermodynamic model of silicate melts adapted according to the characteristic feature of borate melts. These authors calculated the liquidus curves in binary systems, B2 O3 –Na2 O·4B2 O3 , Na2 O·4B2 O3 –Na2 O·2B2 O3 , Na2 O·2B2 O3 –Na2 O·B2 O3 , Li2 O·2B2 O3 –Li2 O·B2 O3 , and K2 O·2B2 O3 –K2 O·B2 O3 . The values of the enthalpy and temperature of fusion were taken from Barin et al. (1973, 1977). In the calculation of the activity of components, the numbers of individual kinds of atoms, i.e. the M+ cations, the boron atoms in the threefold and fourfold coordination, and the bridging and non-bridging oxygen atoms, in the pure components were taken into account. The numbers of individual kinds of atoms in the formula unit of pure components are listed in Table 3.3. Systems of alkali metal borates.
Table 3.3. Numbers of individual kinds of atoms in pure alkali metal borates Component* B2 O3 (B) M2 O·4B2 O3 (MB4 ) M2 O·3B2 O3 (MB3 ) M2 O·2B2 O3 (MB2 ) M2 O·B2 O3 (MB) * M = Li, Na, K.
M+
B(3)
B(4)
–O–
–O–
– 2 2 2 2
2 6 4 2 1
– 2 2 2 1
3 13 10 6.5 2.5
– – – 0.5 1.5
Phase Equilibria
153
The number of three- and four-coordinated boron atoms in the formula unit was calculated according to Eq. (2.124). The calculation of the non-bridging oxygen atoms was based on the experimental data measured by Bray and O’Keefe (1963). For illustration, some of the calculated phase diagrams are shown. The experimental and calculated phase diagrams of the Na2 O·4B2 O3 –B2 O3 systems and Na2 O·4B2 O3 – Na2 O·2B2 O3 are shown in Figures 3.16 and 3.17, respectively. In the calculation of the liquidus curve of the Na2 O·4B2 O3 –Na2 O·2B2 O3 system the presence of the incongruently melting compound Na2 O·3B2 O3 has been taken into account. There is slightly less agreement with experimental liquidus curves as observed in the Li2 O·2B2 O3 –Li2 O·B2 O3 and K2 O·2B2 O3 –K2 O·B2 O3 systems, where the assumption of the similarity of the structure of solid and liquid phases holds to a lesser degree. The experimental and calculated phase diagrams of the Li2 O·2B2 O3 –Li2 O·B2 O3 and K2 O·2B2 O3 –K2 O·B2 O3 systems are shown in Figures 3.18 and 3.19, respectively. The effect of different polarizing ability of the individual alkali metal cations plays evidently a more substantial role. From the comparison of the experimental and calculated liquidus curves, it follows that the thermodynamic model of silicate melts describes satisfactorily the courses of liquidus curves in these complex glass-forming systems. It is expected that this model can also be applied in other inorganic glass-forming systems, like germanates, phosphates, etc.
1100 1050
T(K)
1000 950
850 800 NB4
0.2
0.4
NB9
NB5
900
0.6
x(B)
0.8
B
Figure 3.16. Phase diagram of the Na2 O·4B2 O3 –B2 O3 system. Dashed line – calculated.
154
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
1125 1100
T(K)
1075 1050
NB3
1025 1000 975 NB2
0.2
0.4 0.6 x(NB4)
0.8
NB4
Figure 3.17. Phase diagram of the Na2 O.4B2 O3 –Na2 O·2B2 O3 system-Dashed line – calculated.
1225
1200
T(K)
1175
1150
1125
1100
1075 LB
0.2
0.4 0.6 x(LB2)
0.8
LB2
Figure 3.18. Phase diagram of the Li2 O·2B2 O3 –Li2 O·B2 O3 system. Dashed line – calculated.
Phase Equilibria
155
1250
1200
T(K)
1150
1100
1050
1000 KB
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
KB2
x(KB2) Figure 3.19. Phase diagram of the system K2 O·2B2 O3 –K2 O·B2 O3 . Dashed line – calculated.
3.2.
PHASE DIAGRAMS OF CONDENSED SYSTEMS
In the following chapters, examples of phase diagrams of two-, three-, and multicomponent systems are described with the characterization of their topology, crystallization paths, transformation processes, and the equilibrium of the coexisting phases in agreement with the Gibbs phase law. Emphasis will be put first to phase diagrams frequently used in the molten salts technology, i.e. those with simple eutectics, with solid solutions, with the formation of complex compounds melting congruently and incongruently, and with the polymorphic transformation of components. 3.2.1. Binary systems
The phase diagrams of two-component systems are represented in the two-dimensional space, where the composition is shown on the x axis (in molar or in mass fractions) in agreement with the lever rule, and the temperature is given on the y axis (in ◦ C or in Kelvin). They are the so-called isobaric diagrams, since the constant pressure, mostly the atmospheric one, is assumed. The Gibbs phase law attains thus the form v =k−f +1=2−f +1=3−f
(3.150)
156
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
The individual curves or straight lines in the phase diagrams, which are denoted as boundary lines, represent the equilibrium between two phases. In a phase diagram of the binary system, the plane above both the boundary lines has the highest degree of freedom possible, i.e. v = 2. On the boundary lines, the degrees of freedom decreases to v = 1 and in the eutectic point, where the boundary lines meet, the degree of freedom is equal to zero. In the following text, the composition in all cases will be expressed in the coordinates of the molar fraction of the component B, thus x(B). 3.2.1.1. Simple eutectic systems
The phase diagram of a simple two-component eutectic system contains four planes (Figure 3.20). The plane L represents the region of presence of the homogeneous solution of the components A and B. The plane A + L is the region of coexistence of the crystals of the solid phase A and the melt saturated with the component A, the plane B + L is the region of coexistence of the crystals of the solid phase B and the melt saturated with the component B. Finally, the plane A + B is the region of coexistence of both the solid phases A and B, it is thus their solid, mechanical mixture.
Tfus, A
X
L Tfus, B Tpc, A
A+L
T nL
nA B+L
T3 A+B A
x(B)
x1(B)
xe
Figure 3.20. Phase diagram of the simple binary eutectic system.
B
Phase Equilibria
157
Points Tfus, A and Tfus, B represent the melting points of components A and B. The lines starting from the individual melting points represent curves of primary crystallization, i.e. their liquidus curves. Both the liquidus curves meet at the eutectic temperature Te in the eutectic point with the composition xe . The eutectic temperature is the lowest temperature at which the liquid phase is present in the system. At cooling of the melt with composition x(B), from the temperature representing to the figurative point X in the plane L, the composition of the melt does not change until the point Tpc, A is attained. In the plane L, the system has two degrees of freedom (k = 2, f = 1, v = 2), thus we can arbitrarily change the temperature and composition of the melt without the appearance of a new phase. At the point Tpc, A , first crystals of component A appear, and the melt starts to coexist with the solid phase A. The cooling of the melt slows down owing to the evolution of the crystallization heat of component A. The system has one degree of freedom (k = 2, f = 2, v = 1), we can change the temperature, and the composition is already defined. This situation is shown at the temperature T, where the solid component A coexists with the melt with composition x1 (B). The amount of the solid phase and the melt is given by the lever rule, the system is composed of nA mol of component A and nL mol of melt with composition x1 (B). When the systems cool down to the eutectic temperature also the solid phase B starts to crystallize. At the eutectic temperature the system has no degree of freedom (k = 2, f = 3, ν = 0), which means that its cooling stops due to the evolution of the crystallization heat of component B, even when the surroundings cool down further. The system stays at the eutectic temperature until its full solidification. A wholly analogical situation is also in the plane of the primary crystallization of component B. Below the eutectic temperature the system has again one degree of freedom (k = 2, f = 2, v = 1), at the given composition the temperature can be arbitrarily changed.
3.2.1.2. Systems with the formation of solid solutions
Solid solutions can be substitutional or interstitial. In the case of substitutional solid solutions, the foreign atoms substitute the atoms of the host structure. In the case of interstitial solid solutions, the foreign atoms are dislocated in free spaces of the host structure. The phase diagram of the two-component eutectic system with the formation of a solid solution of one component has five planes (Figure 3.21). The plane L represents the region of homogeneous solution of components A and B. The plane Ass + L is the region of coexistence of crystals of the saturated solid solution of the component B in component A and the melt saturated with the component A. The plane B+L is the region of coexistence of the crystals of the pure solid phase B and the melt saturated with the component B. The plane Ass is the region of non-saturated solid solutions of the component B in component
158
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
Tfus, A
L
X
Tfus, B Tpc, Ass Ass + L NL nAss
B+L
Ass
Te
Ass + B A
x(Ass)
x(B) x1(B)
B
Figure 3.21. Phase diagram of the two-component eutectic system with formation of solid solution Ass.
A and, finally, the plane Ass + B is the region of coexistence of both solid phases, i.e. the crystals of the saturated solid solutions of the component in component A and the crystals of the component B. It deals thus again with the mechanical mixture of both the solid phases. Points Tfus, A and Tfus, B represent the melting points of components A and B. The upper line, which originates from the melting point of the component A, represents the curve of its primary crystallization, the line exiting from the melting point B represents the curve of the primary crystallization of the component B. Both the curves of primary crystallization meet at the eutectic temperature Te in the eutectic point with the composition xe . The lower line originating in the melting point of the component A, breaks at the eutectic temperature and at lower temperatures approaches the y axis and represents the line of saturated solid solutions of the component B in component A. From the course of this curve, it follows that the composition of the saturated solid solutions changes with temperature. At cooling of the melt with the composition x(B) from the temperature representing the figurative point X, the composition of the melt does not change in the plane L until
Phase Equilibria
159
the point Tpc, Ass is reached. In the plane L the system has two degrees of freedom (k = 2, f = 1, v = 2); we can arbitrarily change the temperature and composition without occurrence of a new phase. At further cooling at the point Tpc, Ass , the first crystals of the saturated solid solution Ass arise, the melt starts to coexist with the solid solution Ass. Due to the evolution of the crystallizing heat of the solid solution Ass, the cooling of the system slows down. The system has one degree of freedom (k = 2, f = 2, v = 1), we can change the temperature, and the composition of the melt is already defined. At further cooling, the solid solution Ass coexists with the melt of the composition x1 (B). The amount of the solid phase and of the melt is given by the lever rule, the system is composed of the nAss mol of the solid solution Ass and n1 mol of the melt with the composition x1 (B). When the system cools down to the eutectic temperature the solid phase B also starts to crystallize. At the eutectic temperature, the system has no degree of freedom (k = 2, f = 3, v = 0), which means that due to the evolution of the crystallization heat of the component B the cooling stops, even though the surroundings further cools down. The system stays at the eutectic temperature until it totally freezes. Below the eutectic temperature, the system again has one degree of freedom (k = 2, f = 2, v = 1), at the given composition we can arbitrarily change the temperature.
3.2.1.3. Systems with limited solubility in the liquid phase
As a consequence of impossibility to arrange particles in the liquid phase in one solution only, the formation of two liquids, which are not miscible, may occur. Such a situation can be frequently observed in glass-forming silicate melts in the region of high concentrations of SiO2 . Partial miscibility in the liquid phase is quite uncommon in binaries of molten salts. Partial miscibility is more frequent in reciprocal salt systems and probably as a rule, in the high metal concentrations of the metal–metal halide systems. The phase diagram of the two-component eutectic system with limited miscibility in the liquid phase has five planes (Figure 3.22). The plane L represents the region of existence of the homogeneous solution of the components A and B. The plane A + L is the region of coexistence of the crystals of component A and the melt saturated with component A. The plane B + L represents the region of coexistence of crystals of the pure component B and the melt saturated with component B, and the plane A + B is the region of coexistence of both the solid phases A and B. The plane L1 + L2 is the region of coexistence of two so-called conjugate liquids L1 and L2 . The phase admixture in the melt begins at the so-called critical temperature Tcrit . On cooling the melt of the composition x(B) from the temperature represented by the figurative point X, the first drops of the conjugate liquid having the composition x1 (B) can be observed on the admixture curve at the point Tad . The system has only one degree of freedom (k = 2, f = 2, ν = 1), we can change only the temperature, and
160
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
X Tfus, A Tcrit Tad nL 1
L1
L
nL L2 2
Tfus, B
L1 + L2
Tm
nA
nL
Tpc, A
A+L
B+L
Te
e A+B A
xL 1
x 1(B ) x(B )
xL x'(B) 2
B
Figure 3.22. Phase diagram of the two-component eutectic system with limited miscibility in the liquid phase.
the composition of both conjugate liquids is given by the admixture curve. On further cooling, the composition of both the conjugate liquids is given by the points L1 and L2 . The amounts of both the conjugate liquids are given again by the lever rule. On further cooling, at the monotectic temperature Tm , an invariant equilibrium exists between the solid phase A and the two liquid phases L1 and L2 having the composition xL1 and xL2 . At this temperature the monotectic reaction L1 = A + L2
(3.151)
occurs. The cooling stops since k = 2, f = 3, ν = 0 until all L2 disappears. On continued cooling, the system behaves similar to the simple eutectic system. 3.2.1.4. Systems with unlimited solubility in solid and liquid phases
The common feature of these phase diagrams is that the melt is in univariant equilibrium with one crystalline phase of a variable composition. A complete series of solid solutions are formed.
Phase Equilibria
161
L
Tfus, A L+
(A
X +B
) ss
Tpc nL n (A + B)ss
Tfus, B
(A + B)ss
A
x'(A)
x(A)
B
Figure 3.23. Phase diagram of the system of continuous solid solubility in the solid and liquid phases.
Systems with one two-phase region. The phase diagram of the system with unlimited solubility in the solid and liquid phases having one two-phase region is shown in Figure 3.23. There are three planes in this phase diagram. The plane L represents the region of existence of homogeneous liquid solution of compounds A and B. The plane (A + B)ss + L is the region of the coexistence of the crystals of the solid solutions Ass and the melt saturated with component B. The plane (A + B)ss represents the region of continuous solid solutions of phases A and B. During cooling the mixture of the composition x(A), at Tpc solid solution Ass with the composition x (A) starts to crystallize. On further cooling, the composition of the saturated liquid follows the upper curve, while the composition of the solid solutions follows the lower one. The amounts of the saturated liquid L and the solid solution Ass change according to the lever rule. At the lower curve, the liquid phase disappears and the mixture solidifies. The phase diagram of the system with unlimited solubility in the solid and liquid phases having two two-phase regions is shown in Figure 3.24. Such phase diagrams have four planes. The plane L is the region of homogeneous liquid solutions of A and B. The plane L + (A + B)ss is the region of coexistence of crystals of the solid solution (A + B)ss and the melt saturated with Systems with continuous solid solutions with a minimum.
162
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
Tfus, A L
Tfus, B
L
L+ + (A
(A
+B
ss B)
)s
s+
X
Tm
m (A + B) ss
A
xm
B
Figure 3.24. Phase diagram of the system with continuous solid solutions with a minimum.
components A. The plane (A + B)ss + L is the region of coexistence of crystals of the solid solution (A + B)ss and the melt saturated with component B. Finally, the plane (A + B)ss represents the region of the continuous solid solutions of phases A and B. The crystallization path of a mixture of any composition except of xm , is similar as in the previous case of the systems with one two-phase region. When cooling the mixture of composition xm , at temperature Tm the liquid and solid phases are in equilibrium and they have identical composition. The system seems to be univariant, since there are two components, two phases, and thus one degree of freedom. However, in the case of an extreme on the boundary line, the degree of freedom decreases by one. The system in the minimum is thus non-variant and the cooling of the system stops until all the melt completely freezes. 3.2.1.5. Systems with the formation of a congruently melting compound
Even when these systems have formally three components, only two of them are independent, since the number of components decreases by the number of reactions that take place among them. In this case, it is the reaction A + B = AB. Sometimes the phases A and B are called components and the phase AB is called a constituent.
Phase Equilibria
163
L
Tfus, A T fus, AB
X1
A+L
X2 Tfus, B
T pc, AB
T pc, A AB + L
nL AB + L
nA
Tel
nL
n AB
e1
B+L
Te2
e2 A + AB AB + B A
x1(B)x'1(B)
AB x2(B)x'2(B)
B
Figure 3.25. Phase diagram of the two-component eutectic system with the formation of the congruently melting compound.
The phase diagram of the two-component eutectic system, in which one congruently (explicitly) melting compound is formed, has seven planes (Figure 3.25). The compound AB divides the phase diagram into two simple eutectic systems. The plane L represents the region of existence of the homogeneous solution of compounds A and B. The plane A + L is the region of coexistence of the crystals of the solid phase A and the melt saturated by the component A. The plane B + L is the region of coexistence of the crystals of the solid phase B and the melt saturated by the component B. Both the divided planes AB + L are the regions of coexistence of the component (constituent) AB with the respective melts saturated with the component (constituent) AB. The planes A + AB and AB + B are the regions of coexistence of the two solid phases A and AB, and AB and B, respectively. Points Tfus, A , Tfus, B and Tfus, AB represent melting points of the components A and B, and AB that of the compound AB. Lines originating from the individual melting points represent the curves of their primary crystallization. The curves of primary crystallization meet at the eutectic temperatures Te1 and Te2 at the eutectic points e1 and e2 . The crystallization processes of components in the systems of this type are identical as in the simple eutectic systems.
164
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
3.2.1.6. Systems with the formation of an incongruently melting compound
The phase diagram of the two-component eutectic system in which the incongruently (hidden) melting compound is formed has six planes (Figure 3.26). But in this case the compound formed does not divide the phase diagram into two simple eutectic systems. The plane L represents the region of existence of the homogeneous solution of components A and B. The plane A + L is the region of the coexistence of crystals of the solid phase A and the melt saturated with component A. The plane A4 B + L is the region of the coexistence of crystals of the solid A4 B and the melt saturated with component A4 B. The plane B + L is the region of coexistence of crystals of the solid phase B and the melt saturated with component B. The planes A + A4 B and A4 B + B are the regions of coexistence of two solid phases A and A4 B and A4 B and B, respectively. The points Tfus, A and Tfus, B are again the melting points of components A and B. The lines originating from the individual melting points represent the curves of their primary crystallization. The curve of primary crystallization of the component A stops at the peritectic temperature at the peritectic point P. Below the peritectic temperature, the curve
X1 Tfus, A
L Tpc, A X2 nL
Tp
nA
Tfus, B
A+L
P
A4B+ L nL
A+A4B
Tpc, A4B
B+L
nA4B
Te
e
A4B+B A x1(B) A4B x'1(B) x2(B)x'2(B)
B
Figure 3.26. Phase diagram of the two-component eutectic system with the formation of the incongruently melting compound.
Phase Equilibria
165
of the primary crystallization of A4 B continues. The curves of primary crystallization of the components A4 B and B meet at the eutectic temperature Te in the eutectic point e. At cooling of the melt with the composition x1 (B) from the temperature of the figurative point X1 the first crystals of component A arise at the temperature Tpc, A , the melt starts to coexist with the solid phase A. The cooling of the system slows down due to the evolution of the crystallization heat of the component A. The system has one degree of freedom (k = 2, f = 2, v = 1). Below this temperature the solid component A coexists with the melt saturated with the component A. For the case shown in Figure 3.26 the saturated melt has the composition x1 (B). The amount of the solid phase and of the melt is given by the lever rule, the system is composed of nA mol A and nL mol of melt with the composition x1 (B). When the system attains the peritectic temperature the peritectic reaction A + L = A4 B starts and crystals of the compound A4 B appear. Since now there are three phases in the system (component A, compound A4 B, and melt L), the system has no degree of freedom (k = 3 – 1 = 2, f = 3, v = 0), which means that its cooling due to the evolution of the reaction heat of the peritectic reaction must halt, even when the surrounding cools further. The system stays at the peritectic temperature until the melt disappear and the system solidifies. Below the peritectic temperature, there is again a mechanical mixture of the crystals of component A and the crystals of compound A4 B. At cooling of the melt with composition x2 (B) from the temperature representing the figurative point X2 , the first crystals of the compound A4 B arise at the temperature Tpk,A4B and the melt coexists with the solid compound A4 B. The cooling of the system slows down due to the evolution of the crystallization heat of the compound A4 B. The system has one degree of freedom (k = 2, f = 2, v = 1). Below this temperature, the solid compound A4 B coexists with the melt having the composition x2 (B). The amount of the solid phase and that of the melt is given by the lever rule. The system is composed of nA4 B mol A4 B and nL mol melt with the composition x2 (B). When the system attains the eutectic temperature the solid phase B also starts to crystallize. At the eutectic temperature, the system has no degree of freedom (k = 2, f = 3, v = 0) and its cooling will stop. The system maintains the eutectic temperature until its total solidification. In the field of primary crystallization of the component B, the crystallization proceeds like in the simple eutectic system. Below the eutectic temperature, we have a mechanical mixture of crystals A4 B and B, the system has again one degree of freedom (k = 2, f = 2, v = 1).
3.2.1.7. Systems with polymorphic transformation of one component
In this case one of the components exists in two or more crystallographic modifications and the temperature of the highest polymorphic transformation lies above the eutectic temperature of the system.
166
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
X1
L
Tfus, A
A+L nL Tpt
Tpc, A
X2
Tfus, B
nAα
A+L
nA
Tpc, A
B+L
nL nL Te
nAβ e
A+ B A
x1(B)
x'1(B)
x2(B) x'2(B) x''1(B)
B
Figure 3.27. Phase diagram of the two-component eutectic system with polymorphic transformation of one component.
The phase diagram of the two-component eutectic system with the polymorphic transformation of one component has five planes (Figure 3.27). The plane L represents the region of the existence of a homogeneous solution of the components A and B. The plane Aα + L is the region of coexistence of the crystals of the α-modification of the solid phase A and the melt saturated with the component Aα . The plane Aβ + L is the region of coexistence of the crystals of the β-modification of the solid phase A and the melt saturated with the component Aβ , and the plane B + L is the region of coexistence of the crystals of the solid phase B and the melt saturated with the component B. Finally, the plane Aβ + B is the region of coexistence of two solid phases Aβ and B. The points Tfus, Aα and Tfus, B represent the melting points of the components Aα and B. The lines originating in the individual melting points represent the curves of their primary crystallization. The curve of the primary crystallization of component Aα ends at the temperature of the polymorphic transformation Tpt . Below this temperature, this curve continues as the curve of the primary crystallization of component Aβ . The curves of primary crystallization of components Aβ and B meet at the eutectic temperature Te at the eutectic point e.
Phase Equilibria
167
Cooling the melt with composition x1 (B) from the temperature of the figurative point X1 , the first crystals of the component Aα arise at temperature Tpc, Aα , where the melt coexists with the solid phase Aα . Below this temperature, the solid component Aα coexists with the melt of the composition x1 (B). The amount of the solid phase and the melt is given by the lever rule. The system is composed of nAα mol Aα and of nL mol melt of the composition x1 (B). When the system attains the temperature of the polymorphic transformation of the component A, Tpt , the polymorphic transformation Aα → Aβ
(3.152)
starts to take place and the crystals of the β-modification of the solid phase A arise. Since three phases (Aα , Aβ , and the melt L) are present, the system has no degree of freedom (k = 3 − 1 = 2, f = 3, v = 0), which means that its cooling must stop due to the evolution of the transformation heat. The system keeps at the polymorphic transformation temperature until all crystals of the α-modification of the component A transform to the β-modification. Below the temperature of the polymorphic transformation, the crystals of the β-modification coexist with the melt of the composition x1 (B). The amount of the solid phase and of the melt is given by the lever rule and the system is composed of nAβ mol Aβ and nL mol melt with the composition x1 (B). Cooling the melt with the composition x2 (B) from the temperature of the figurative point X2 , the first crystals of Aβ arise at the temperature Tpc, Aβ , the melt starts to coexist with Aβ . Below this temperature, Aβ coexists with the melt of composition x2 (B). The amount of the solid phase and of the melt is given by the lever rule, the system is composed of nAβ mol Aβ and nL mol melt with the composition x2 (B). When the system cools down to the eutectic temperature, the solid phase B also starts to crystallize, the system has no degree of freedom (k = 2, f = 3, v = 0) and its cooling stops. Below the eutectic temperature we have the mechanical mixture of crystals Aβ and B, the system has again one degree of freedom (k = 2, f = 2, v = 1). 3.2.2. Ternary systems
The isobaric phase diagrams of three-component systems are determined by four variables: three concentration coordinates and the temperature. With regard to the condition that the sum of mole or mass fractions equals one, it is possible to show these phase diagrams in three-dimensional space, where the concentration coordinates are shown in the x–y plane and the temperature on the z axis. The representation of the figurative point of a three-component system in the equilateral triangle using three concentration coordinates is shown in Figure 3.28. The parallels with
168
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
M
xB(M)
A
xC(M) x(B)
) x(B
x(C )
C
xA(M)
B
Figure 3.28. Representation of the figurative point of a three-component system in a triangle diagram.
the individual axes passing the figurative point M cut off on each axis sections which are equal to the concentration coordinates of the individual components. The composition of the figurative point M in the A–B–C system can be read, for example on the A–B axis, where the first section represents the molar (mass) fraction of the component B, the second one represents the molar (mass) fraction of the component C, and the third one is the molar (mass) fraction of the component A. 3.2.2.1. Simple eutectic systems
The spatial view of the phase diagram of the simple ternary eutectic system is shown in Figure 3.29. The three-sided prism represents the shape of this phase diagram. On its sides lie the individual binary subsystems. Points Tfus, A , Tfus, B , and Tfus, C represent the melting points of the components A, B, and C. Lines originating from the melting points of the components and lying on the sides of the prism represent the curves of their primary crystallization. Each component has thus two curves of primary crystallization belonging to two binary systems. Curves of primary crystallization meet at the respective eutectic temperatures Te1 , Te2 , and Te3 at the eutectic points e1 , e2 , and e3 .
Phase Equilibria
169
Figure 3.29. Spatial view of the simple ternary eutectic system.
The boundary curves, coming out from the individual binary eutectic points, represent curves of the common crystallization of both components of the respective binary subsystems. All boundary curves meet at the ternary eutectic point, which is the lowest temperature where there is the liquid phase in this ternary system. With respect to the fact that in the ternary system the temperature of primary crystallization of each component is affected by the presence of two other components, the phase diagram of the ternary system has three planes of primary crystallization belonging to the individual components. On the plane Tfus, A −e1 −et −e2 component A crystallizes primarily, the plane Tfus, B −e1 −et −e3 is the primary crystallization plane of the component B, and the plane Tfus, C −e2 −et −e3 belongs to the primary crystallization of the component C. The space above the three planes mentioned represents the region of homogeneous solution of all the three components. The space between the plane Tfus, A −e1 −et −e2 and the temperature of the ternary eutectics is the region of coexistence of the crystals of the solid phase A and the melt saturated with the component A. Between the plane
170
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
Tfus, B −e1 −et −e3 and the temperature of the ternary eutectics is the region of coexistence of the crystals of the solid phase B and the melt saturated with the component B, and, finally, between the plane Tfus, C −e2 −et −e3 and the temperature of the ternary eutectics is the region of coexistence of crystals of the solid phase C and the melt saturated with the component C. Below the temperature of the ternary eutectics lies the region of the mechanical mixture of three solid phases A, B, and C. As the graphical presentation of the ternary phase diagrams using the triple-sided prism is inconvenient, the vertical projection of the diagram into the x–y plane is used as it is shown in Figure 3.30. Projections of the binary eutectics e1 , e2 , and e3 in the x–y plane (Figure 3.30) are e1 , e2 , and e3 points in the Figure 3.29. The projection of the ternary eutectic point et (Figure 3.30) is the point et (Figure 3.29). Projections of the boundary lines e1 −et , e2 −et , and e3 −et in the x–y plane (Figure 3.30) are curves e1 −et , e2 −et , and e3 −et in Figure 3.29. In the triangle diagram thus three planes originate. The plane pc(A) is the projection of the plane of primary crystallization of the component A, the plane pc(B) is the projection of the plane of primary crystallization of the component B,
C
pc(C ) e1
e2
> >
pc(A)
A
<
> et
>
X
M
e3
pc(B)
B
Figure 3.30. Vertical projection of the phase diagram of the simple ternary eutectic system into the x–y plane.
Phase Equilibria
171
and the plane pc(C) is the projection of the plane of primary crystallization of component C. In every projection of a ternary phase diagram (like altitude curves on geographic maps) also isotherms, i.e. curves having identical temperature of primary crystallization (not shown in Figure 3.30) are shown. In a mixture A–B–C, the composition of which is on Figure 3.30 shown by the figurative point X lying in the field of primary crystallization of the component A. This mixture is at a temperature above the temperature of primary crystallization of A and is thus a homogeneous solution of all the three components. The melt has three degrees of freedom (k = 3, f = 1, v = 3), we can arbitrarily change its temperature, and the content of two components without the appearance of a new phase. At its cooling from the given temperature the composition of the solution does not change until the temperature of primary crystallization of component A is attained. Therefore any shift of the point X cannot be seen. At the temperature of primary crystallization, the first crystals of component A appear, the solid phase A begins to coexist with the melt saturated with component A. The cooling rate of the system slows down due to the evolution of the crystallization heat of component A. At further cooling, the solid component A crystallizes from the saturated melt which becomes depleted of this component. The composition of the melt thus moves in the course of the arrow on the straight line A–X facing the point M. Between the temperature of primary crystallization and the boundary line (on the X–M straight line) the system has two degrees of freedom (k = 3, f = 2, v = 2), for example we can change two concentration coordinates of the melt and the temperature will be already determined, or the temperature and one concentration coordinate of the melt and the second concentration coordinate will be already determined. In point M also the component C begins to crystallize from the melt. The cooling rate slows down still more due to the evolution of the further crystallization heat of component C. On the boundary line e1 −et the system has only one degree of freedom (k = 3, f = 3, v = 1), only one variable can be changed, for example one concentration coordinate of the melt or the temperature, and the other variables will be determined by the line e1 −et . On continued cooling of the system both the components, A and C, will crystallize simultaneously and the composition of the melt will move on the boundary line e1 −et until the ternary eutectic point et is attained, where also the component B begins to crystallize. At the eutectic temperature the system has no degree of freedom (k = 3, f = 4, v = 0), which means that its cooling will stop. The system maintains the eutectic temperature until its whole solidification. Completely analogical is the crystallization process of mixtures lying in the crystallization fields of the components B and C. Below the eutectic temperature the system has again one degree of freedom (k = 3, f = 3, v = 1), at the given composition we can change arbitrarily the temperature.
172
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
3.2.2.2. Systems with formation of a congruently melting binary compound
In the ternary system, in which a congruently melting binary compound is formed, the figurative point of the binary compound AB lies in the boundary binary system A–B. The vertical projection of the phase diagram of such a ternary eutectic system is shown in Figure 3.31. The phase diagram of such a system has four planes. The plane pc(A) is the vertical projection of the plane of primary crystallization of the compound A, plane pc(B) represents the plane of primary crystallization of the component B, and the plane pc(C) refers to the primary crystallization of compound C. Finally, the plane pc(AB) is the projection of the plane of primary crystallization of compound AB. In the case of the congruently melting compound AB its figurative point lies inside the plane of the primary crystallization of this compound. In comparison with the simple eutectic ternary system a new boundary line, et1 − et2 , which represents the common crystallization of compounds C and AB, will arise. The joint AB–C divides the ternary system A–B–C into two simple
C
X3 pc (C)
e4 >
e4 <
>
et1 <
et2
<
M1
>
>
pc (A) X1
M2 >
M3
>
p c(B) X2 pc (AB)
A
e1
AB
e2
Figure 3.31. Phase diagram of the ternary eutectic system with the formation of the congruently melting binary compound.
Phase Equilibria
173
eutectic ternary systems A–AB–C and AB–B–C. The point where the joint AB–C crosses the boundary line et1 − et2 represents the highest temperature at the boundary line et1 − et2 . Let us have a mixture A–B–C, the composition of which is on Figure 3.31 represented by the figurative point X1 . The crystallization process at cooling from temperatures higher than the temperature of primary crystallization is equal to the case of a simple ternary eutectic system. The compound will crystallize first, the composition of the melt will move to the point M in which it begins to crystallize the compound AB also. At the next cooling, compounds A and AB crystallize simultaneously and the composition of the melt moves on the boundary line from the point M up to the eutectic point et1 , where also the component C will crystallize and where also the whole system solidifies (according to the triangle rule the point X1 lies in the triangle A–AB–C). An analogical situation happens also in the case of the mixture, the composition of which is given by the figurative point X3 . However, it depends on the position of X3 , in which of the two ternary eutectic points, the system will solidify. Since the summit of the boundary line et1−et2 is the eutectic point of the binary system AB–C, the boundary line falls down from its summit towards both ternary eutectic points. Thus mixtures, the composition of which lies in the triangle A–AB–C will solidify in the eutectic point et1 , while mixtures with composition lying in the triangle AB–B–C will solidify in the eutectic point et2 . If we have a mixture, the composition of which is shown by the figurative point X2 , then on cooling, the compound AB begins to crystallize first and this compound will coexist with the melt saturated by it. At the following cooling from the saturated solution even further amounts of the solid compound AB and the melt will by impoverished by this compound. The composition of the melt will thus move along the course of the arrow on the straight line AB–X2 towards the point M2 . In this point also the compound C begins to crystallize from the melt. At the ensuing cooling of the system the composition of the melt moves along the boundary line et1 − et2 in the direction of the arrow up to the ternary eutectic point et2 , where also the solid phase B starts to crystallize until the total solidification of the system (according to the triangle rule the figurative point X2 lies in the triangle AB–B–C).
3.2.2.3. Systems with formation of an incongruently melting binary compound
Similarly as in the previous case, incongruently melting binary compounds can originate in the ternary system as well. The vertical projection of the phase diagram of such a system is shown in Figure 3.32. The phase diagram of the ternary system with the formation of an incongruently melting compound has four planes. Planes pc(A), pc(B), pc(C), and pc(A4 B) are the projections of the planes of primary crystallization of the compounds A, B, C, and A4 B, respectively. The figurative point of the binary compound A4 B lies in the boundary of the binary
174
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
C
X3 pc(C) e3
" X1
>
pc(A)
Pt
X1 A
A4B
X1"
'
>
et λ
X2
>
>
<
>
e2
pc(B)
pc(A4B) Pb
e1
B
Figure 3.32. Phase diagram of the ternary eutectic system with the formation of an incongruently melting binary compound.
system A–B, however, it lies outside the plane of its primary crystallization. In Figure 3.32 it is shown on the left side of the binary peritectic point Pb . Contrary to the previous case, the phase diagram of this type has only one ternary eutectic point et . The second singular point is the ternary peritectic point Pt . The boundary line Pt −et represents the simultaneous crystallization of the component C and the compound A4 B. The crystallization path of mixtures, the figurative points of which lie in the region of the primary crystallization of the component A, pc(A), depend on the part of this crystallization field, in which the figurative point of the system lies. Three cases may occur. If point X lies in the area of the quadrangle A–A4 B–α–e2 (point X1 on Figure 3.32), according to the triangle rule its crystallization path must end in the mechanical mixture of the solid A, A4 B, and C (apexes of the triangle A–A4 B–C) at the point Pt . Since we are in the crystallization area of component A, at the cooling of the melt crystals, A will appear
Phase Equilibria
175
first and these will coexist with the melt saturated by component A. At the following cooling, crystals of A crystallize from the saturated melt next and the composition of melt will move on the straight line A−X1 in the direction of the arrow up to the point β. In point β also compound A4 B begins to crystallize, the system has one degree of freedom and the composition of the melt will move from point β on the boundary line Pb −Pt up to the point Pt , where also component C begins to crystallize until the whole system solidifies. If the mixture has the composition placed in the triangle A4 B–Pt –α (point X1 in Figure 3.32) or A4 B–Pb –Pt (point X1 ), their crystallization paths, according to the triangle rule, must end in the mechanical mixture of solid A4 B, B, and C (apexes of the triangle A4 B–B–C) in the ternary eutectic point et . The crystallization paths, however, will in both cases proceed in a different way. At cooling of mixture X1 primarily component A begins to crystallize and after the composition of the melt attains on the boundary line e2 −Pt point γ , also component C begins to crystallize moving the composition of melt into point Pt . At point Pt , however, always four phases coexist: A, A4 B, C, and the melt. The system has thus no degree of freedom. At the temperature of the ternary peritectic point the cooling of the system will stop and according to the quadrangle rule the peritectic reaction A + L ⇒ A4 B + C
(3.153)
takes place until the component A disappears. The system thus attains one degree of freedom and at its ensuing cooling, the composition of the melt moves from point Pt to the point et , where the whole system solidifies into the mechanical mixture of crystals A4 B, B, and C. From the mixture X1 component A crystallizes first as well moving the composition of the melt from point X1 towards point β . After the composition of melt attains point β on the boundary line Pb −Pt , also compound A4 B crystallizes, since with regard to the quadrangle rule the melt starts to dissolve compound A according to the reaction A + L1 ⇒ A4 B + L2
(3.154)
The composition of the melt moves then on the boundary line Pb −Pt (one degree of freedom) towards point Pt . However, the composition of the melt will never attain point Pt , as if the composition of the originating melt L2 attains point β on the straight line X1 −A4 B, the original composition X1 changes according to the lever rule to the mixture of the melt and A4 B, i.e. the whole component A has been dissolved. The system attains one degree of freedom and the primary crystallization of A4 B proceeds until point β , followed by the secondary crystallization of C and the composition of melt moves on the
176
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
boundary line Pt −et into point et , where the whole system solidifies under the formation of a mechanical mixture of crystals A4 B, B, and C. On cooling the mixture with the composition X2 , which lies in the crystallization field of the compound A4 B, the primary crystallization of A4 B proceeds. The composition of the melt moves on the straight line A4 B−X2 from point X2 up to the point λ, where also component B starts to crystallize. The system has only one degree of freedom and the composition of the melt thus moves on the boundary line e1 − et to the ternary eutectic point et , where the whole system solidifies under the formation of a mechanical mixture of crystals A4 B, B, and C. In the case of a mixture shown on Figure 3.32 by the figurative point X3 , the situation is similar as in a simple eutectic ternary system. Starting with the crystallization of component C, the composition of the melt moves up to the point δ, where the component A4 B begins to crystallize. At the ensuing cooling, the composition of the melt moves on the boundary line Pt −et up to the ternary eutectic point, where also component B crystallizes until the whole system solidifies. Below the temperature of the ternary eutectic point the system formed is a mechanical mixture of the solid phases A, A4 B, and C if the composition of the system lies in the triangle A–A4 B–C, or A4 B, B, and C if the composition of the system lies in the other part of the concentration triangle. 3.2.2.4. Systems with formation of a congruently melting ternary compound
The vertical projection of the phase diagram of this ternary system is shown in Figure 3.33. The phase diagram has four planes pc(A), pc(B), pc(C), and pc(ABC), representing the vertical projections of the planes of the primary crystallization of the individual compounds. The figurative point of the ternary compound ABC lies inside the ternary system A–B–C. There are three boundary lines et1 −et2 , et2 −et3 , and et3 −et1 representing the common crystallization of compounds B, C, and A with AB, respectively. The joints of the figurative point ABC with the apexes of the concentration triangle divide the phase diagram into three simple eutectic ternary systems A–ABC–B, B–ABC–C, and A–ABC– C. The points, where the individual joins of ABC with the apexes cross the boundary lines, form the summits of the boundary lines. The crystallization path of mixtures lying in the planes pc(A), pc(B), and pc(C) is completely equal to a simple ternary eutectic system. When the figurative point of the mixture lies inside the plane pc(ABC) (e.g. of that represented by the figurative point X) the compound ABC will crystallize first, the composition of the melt will move to the point M in which compound A also begins to crystallize. At the following cooling, compounds A and ABC crystallize simultaneously and the composition of the melt moves on the boundary line from point M to the eutectic point et1 , where also the component B will crystallize and where also the whole system solidifies (according to the triangle rule the point X lies in the triangle A–ABC–B).
Phase Equilibria
177
Figure 3.33. Phase diagram of the system with the formation of the congruently melting ternary compound.
3.2.2.5. Systems with formation of an incongruently melting ternary compound
The vertical projection of the phase diagram of this system is shown in Figure 3.34. The phase diagram has four planes pc(A), pc(B), pc(C), and pc(ABC), which are the projections of the planes of primary crystallization of the compounds A, B, C, and ABC, respectively. The figurative point of the ternary compound ABC lies outside the plane of its primary crystallization. In contrary to the previous case, the phase diagram of this type has only one ternary eutectic point et and two singular points, which are the ternary peritectic points Pt1 and Pt2 . The boundary lines Pt1 −et and Pt2 −et represent the simultaneous crystallization of components B and ABC, and C and ABC, respectively. The crystallization path of mixtures, the figurative points of which lie in the region of the primary crystallization of the component A, pc(A), depend on the part of this crystallization field, in which the figurative point of the system lies. The crystallization paths are rather complicated and therefore they will not be discussed here. However,
178
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
C
pc(C)
e3
Pt
2
<
ABC
<
> > pc(ABC)
>
Pt
pc(A)
et
>
e2
pc(B)
>
1
AB
e1
Figure 3.34. Phase diagram of the system with the formation of the incongruently melting ternary compound.
three final compositions are reached below the temperature of the ternary eutectic point. The system is formed from the mechanical mixture of the solid phases • • •
A, ABC, and C if the composition lies in the triangle A–ABC–C, A, ABC, and B, if the composition lies in the triangle A–ABC–B, B, ABC, and C, if the composition lies in the triangle B–ABC–C.
3.2.2.6. Ternary reciprocal systems
Ternary reciprocal systems are those of the general type Ap Xq −Br Ys , i.e. not having a common ion. For example, the systems LiF–NaCl, KF–Na2 SO4 , KCl–Na3AlF6 , etc. belong to this category. Like in the other ternary systems, in the ternary reciprocal systems several congruently and incongruently melting binary and ternary compounds can originate. Phase diagrams of the ternary reciprocal systems are represented in the vertical projection as rectangles, whereas on the opposite apexes of the diagonals, figurative points of the compounds without the common ion are placed.
Phase Equilibria
179
e3
AY pc(AY)
BY pc(BY)
>
et
1
e4
X2
>
e2
>
x(AY)
X1
M1 S
>
et
pc(AX) x(BX)
AX
<
2
pc(BX)
>
M2
e1
BX
Figure 3.35. Phase diagram of the simple ternary reciprocal system.
The phase diagram of a simple ternary reciprocal system is schematically shown in Figure 3.35. In the systems of this type the exchange in the metathetical reaction between components takes place, for example p = q = r = s = 1,
Simple ternary reciprocal systems.
AX + BY = AY + BX
G0
(3.155)
Although these systems contain four chemical compounds, in fact they belong to the three-component systems, since the number of components is lowered by the metathetical reaction (3.34). The exchange reaction is characterized by the change in the Gibbs energy G0 , the value of which determines the stabile pair of compounds. If for the above exchange reaction, the change of the Gibbs energy is negative, the reaction runs from the left to the right side and the stabile pair is the system AX–BY. As a next rule, the stabile pair of compounds is formed by the small–small and big–big ionic compounds.
180
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
The phase diagram of the AX–BY system has four planes, pc(AX), pc(BX), pc(AY), and pc(BY), which are the projections of the crystallization planes of the components AX, AY, BX, and BY, respectively. There are five boundary lines, representing the simultaneous crystallization of two compounds. The dashed line marks the stabile system AX–BY, which divides the reciprocal system into two simple eutectic ones. The value of G0 defines the equilibrium composition of the system. Any figurative point of the system, which lies inside the given stabile triangle, can, according to the triangle rule, decompose into the respective three components. This means that in the triangle AX−BX−BY the component AY cannot be present while the component BX cannot be present in the triangle AX−AY−BY. Of course, on the diagonal AX−BY, according to the quadruple rule all four components AX, BX, AY, and BY are present. Their equilibrium concentration is determined by the value of the equilibrium constant of the exchange in the metathetical reaction, i.e. by the value of the reaction Gibbs energy. If we have a mixture AX–AY–BY, the composition of which is in Figure 3.35 shown by the figurative point X1 , the crystallization path at its cooling is completely similar as in the case of a simple ternary eutectic system. The component BY begins to crystallize first, the composition of the melt moves towards point M1 , where also component AX starts to crystallize. At the ensuing cooling, both the components fall out from the melt simultaneously and the composition of the melt moves on the boundary line et1 − et2 from point M1 up to the eutectic point et1 , where also component AY starts to crystallize and where also the whole system will solidify. Similar situation will happen also in the case of the mixture X2 , lying inside the triangle AX−BX−BY. The component BY begins to crystallize first, the composition of the melt moves up to the point M2 , in which the component AX also starts to crystallize. At further cooling both components, BY and AX, crystallize from the melt simultaneously and the composition of the melt moves on the boundary curve et1−et2 from point M1 up to the eutectic point et2 , where also the phase BY starts to fall out and where also the whole system solidifies. It depends thus on the composition of the mixture in which both the ternary eutectic points of the system will solidify. The boundary line et1−et2 falls down from its summit S towards both the eutectic points. This summit is simultaneously the eutectic point of the pseudo-binary system AX–BY. The phase diagram of the ternary reciprocal system A+ , B2+ // X2− , Y2− is shown in Figure 3.36. Since the bivalent cation B2+ is smaller than the univalent A+ one, the stable diagonal is formed by the BX–A2Y pair. Two binary compounds, A2 BX2 and A2 B2Y3 , are formed. These two binary compounds divide the concentration rectangle into three simple ternary eutectic systems A2 BX2 –A2Y–BX, A2 X–BX–A2 B2Y3 , and BX–A2 B2Y3 –BY, and the ternary system A2 X–A2Y–A2 BX2 with continuous solid solutions in the binary boundary system
Systems with formation of two congruently melting binary compounds.
Phase Equilibria
A2X
181
A2Y
A2(X,Y)ss β-A2X e1
A2 Y e2
A2BX2
e3 A2B2Y3
BX e4
BY BX
BY
Figure 3.36. Phase diagram of the ternary reciprocal system A+ , B2+ // X2− , Y2− .
A2 X–A2Y. The compound A2 X undergoes a solid–solid phase transformation prompted in the phase diagram by the dashed line. The phase diagram of the A+ , B2+ // X2− , Y2− system has six crystallization areas belonging to primary crystallization of the individual phases. The solidification of any mixture may end in four ternary eutectic points, depending on its starting composition. The phase diagram of this type forms, for example the K2 SO4 –PbSO4 –K2 WO4 – PbWO4 system, which was measured by Belyaev and Nesterova (1952). This system has marginal importance in the production of tungsten. It is the irreversible transition-type ternary reciprocal system with stable diagonal PbWO4 –K2 SO4 . The phase diagram of the ternary reciprocal system A+ , B2+ // X– , Y2−− is shown in Figure 3.37. There are three incongruently melting binary compounds: ABX3 and A2 BX4 , originating in the AX–BX2 system, and A2 B3Y4 , originating in the A2Y–BY system. The AX–BY system System with formation of three binary incongruently melting compounds.
182
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
A2Y
AX
E2
ABX3 P3 P2 E1 P1
A2BX4
A2B3Y4
BX2
BY
Figure 3.37. Phase diagram of the ternary reciprocal system A+ , B2+ // X– , Y2−− .
forms the stable diagonal of the ternary reciprocal system. In the ternary subsystem AX–BX2 –BY, there are two ternary peritectic and one ternary eutectic point. In the ternary subsystem AX–A2Y–BY there is one ternary peritectic point, where three solid and one liquid phases meet. The variance of the system equals zero and thus the following reaction takes place BY + L1 → AX + L2
(3.156)
After all the BY disappears, the system moves up to the ternary eutectic point, where the whole system solidifies. The phase diagram of this type forms the NaCl–MgCl2 –Na2 SO4 –MgSO4 system and was measured by Speranskaya (1938). The melts of this system find its utilization in the electrochemical production of magnesium.
Phase Equilibria
183
A2BY2
A2Y
BY
E2 E3
A3B2X 3Y2 E1
E5 P E4
AX
ABX3
BX2
Figure 3.38. Phase diagram of the ternary reciprocal system A+ , B2+ // X– , Y2−− .
The phase diagram of the ternary reciprocal system A+ , B2+ // X– , Y2−− is shown in Figure 3.38. Two binary compounds ABX3 and A2 BY2 , and one ternary compound A3 B2 X3Y2 , all melting congruently, originate in this system. The joins between the figurative point of the compound A3 B2 X3Y2 and the individual simple and binary compounds divide the ternary reciprocal system into four simple ternary eutectic phase diagrams, one phase diagram with the crystallization field of a compound, the figurative point of which lies outside its concentration triangle, and one phase diagram without a ternary eutectic point. There are five ternary eutectic and one peritectic points. The crystallization path of all mixtures, figurative points of which lay inside the triangles BY–A3 B2 X3Y2 –BX2 and A3 B2 X3Y2 –P–BX2 , starts with the primary crystallization of BY, A3 B2 X3Y2 , or BX2 , followed by the crystallization of the neighboring salt till the peritectic point P is reached. System with formation of two binary and one ternary congruently melting compounds.
184
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
Here the system contains three solid and one liquid phases and the variance equals zero. Two different reactions take place BY + L → BX2 + L
(3.157)
BY + L → A3 B2 X3 Y2 + L
(3.158)
or
After all the BY disappears, the system moves towards the ternary eutectic point E4 , where the whole system solidifies. The phase diagram of this type forms the KCl–K2 SO4 –MgCl2 –MgSO4 system and was measured by Jänecke (1912). The melts of this system are technologically important in the electrochemical production of magnesium. 3.2.3. Quaternary systems
Quaternary systems are composed of four components with a common ion and form four ternary and six binary systems. The concentration diagram of the quaternary system can be represented by a tetrahedron. The vertical projection of every ternary system is placed on one face of the tetrahedron. The phase diagram of the quaternary system A+ , B+ , C2+ , D2+ // X– with the formation of the congruently melting binary compound BCX3 is shown in Figure 3.39. The binary compound BCX3 divides the AX–BX–CX2 and DX2 –BX–CX2 ternary systems into four simple ternary subsystems. The crystallization paths of ternary mixtures end in one of the six ternary eutectic points Ei , where the ternary mixtures solidify. The crystallization path of any quaternary mixture follows the dotted boundary lines inside the concentration tetrahedron and ends in one of the two quaternary eutectic points Eqi . Phase diagrams of quaternary systems are represented in the literature often also in the form of unfolded tetrahedron surface. Such representation of the phase diagram of the quaternary system A+ , B+ , C2+ , D2+ // X– is shown in Figure 3.40. This picture serves a better understanding of the phase equilibria within the ternary systems and on the boundary between them, but does not enable to study the phase equilibria inside the quaternary system. This phase diagram looks like that of the NaF–KF–CaF2 –BaF2 system, measured by Bukhalova and Sementsova (1967). 3.2.3.1. Quaternary reciprocal systems
Quaternary reciprocal systems are composed of six components, which form three ternary reciprocal systems and two ternary systems with a common ion. The concentration diagram of this system can be represented by a three-sided prism, on each side is the vertical
Phase Equilibria
185
AX
E5 E1 E6 E2
E q1
CX 2
E q2
E4
BCX3
DX2
E3
BX Figure 3.39. Phase diagram of the quaternary system A+ , B+ , C2+ , D2+ // X– with the formation of a congruently melting binary compound.
projection of one of the ternary reciprocal systems and on both the bases are the vertical projections of the ternary system with a common ion. The three-sided prism of the quaternary reciprocal system A+ , B+ , C2+ // X– , Y– is shown in Figure 3.41. As it can be seen from the figure, in the CX2 –CY2 system the incongruently melting compound CX2 ·CY2 originates and in the systems AX–CX2 and AY–CY2 , the congruently melting compounds ACX3 and ACY3 originate, respectively. These compounds give rise to several eutectic points and two peritectic points. Such a representation of the phase diagram, however, does not tell anything about the phase relation inside the prism of the quaternary reciprocal system. This phase diagram resembles the phase diagram of the Na+ , K+ , Ca2+ // F− , Cl− system, which was measured by Bukhalova and Maslennikova (1962). As it can be seen, in Figure 3.41 are depicted only phase equilibria on the surface of the three-sided
186
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
AX
E5
CX 2
DX2 E4
BCX3
E1
E3 E6
E2
AX
BX
AX
Figure 3.40. The unfolded tetrahedron surface of the phase diagram of the quaternary system A+ , B+ , C2+ , D2+ // X– with the formation of a congruently melting binary compound.
prism, i.e. those of the ternary and ternary reciprocal systems. The phase equilibria of the quaternary reciprocal system, i.e. those inside the three-sided prism could not be drawn, since they have not been studied. Phase diagrams of quaternary reciprocal systems are represented in the literature only in the form of the unfolded surface of a three-sided prism. Such presentation of the phase diagram of the quaternary reciprocal system A+ , B+ , C2+ // X– , Y– is shown in Figure 3.42. 3.2.4. The CaO–Al2 O3 –SiO2 system
The phase diagram of the CaO–Al2 O3 –SiO2 system is an indispensable tool in metallurgy, production of refractory ceramics, special glasses, and in cement production. In Figure 3.43, the phase diagram of this system according to Osborn and Muan (1960), revised in the CaO·6Al2 O3 field by Gentile and Foster (1963), is shown.
Phase Equilibria
187
BY
AY
ACY 3 CY 2
CXY solid soln.
AX
BX
ACX 3
CX 2 Figure 3.41. Phase diagram of the quaternary reciprocal system A+ , B+ , C2+ // X– , Y– with the formation of two congruently and one incongruently melting compound.
The CaO–Al2 O3 –SiO2 system forms a rather complicated phase diagram, in which a number of binary and two ternary compounds are formed. In the binary system CaO–SiO2 two incongruently melting compounds, 3CaO·SiO2 and 3CaO·2SiO2 , and two congruently melting compounds, 2CaO·SiO2 and CaO·SiO2 , are formed. While the two congruently melting compounds show a broad field of primary crystallization, the two incongruently melting compounds show only a narrow field of primary crystallization, which is located on both sides of the crystallization field of dicalcium silicate. Tricalcium and dicalcium silicates are the main hydraulic components of the cement clinker. In the SiO2 -rich side of the CaO–SiO2 phase diagram, the region of the two liquids may be seen, extending also into the ternary system. On the SiO2
188
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
CY 2
ACY 3 CY 2
ACY3
e e
AY
CY 2
e
CXY
e
e
p
e
e
e
solid soln.
ACX3
CXY
e
p
CX 2
BY
BX
AX
CX 2
e ACX3
e
CX 2 Figure 3.42. The unfolded surface of the three-sided prism of the phase diagram of the quaternary reciprocal system A+ , B+ , C2+ // X– , Y– with the formation of two congruently and one incongruently melting compound.
corner of the ternary system, the crystallization fields of the two modifications of SiO2 , the cristobalite and tridymite, can be seen. Very complicated and many times revised, due to the formation of a number of binary compounds, is the CaO–Al2 O3 system. From the CaO side it is at first the incongruently melting compound 3CaO·Al2 O3 , with the peritectic decomposition temperature of 1539◦ C. The next compound 5CaO·3Al2 O3 melts congruently at 1392◦ C. However, Nurse et al. (1965) later found out that it is the compound 12CaO·7Al2 O3 that crystallizes congruently at the temperature 1455◦ C. According to Rolin and Thanh (1965), the next two compounds, CaO·Al2 O3 and CaO·2Al2 O3 , melt congruently at 1605◦ C and 1750◦ C, respectively. The last compound in this system is CaO·6Al2 O3 , which melts incongruently at the peritectic decomposition temperature of 1850◦ C. Only one compound forms in the Al2 O3 –SiO2 system, the mullite, 3Al2 O3 ·2SiO2 , which melts according to some authors congruently and according to the others incongruently. The enigma of the fusion of mullite is discussed in detail by Davis and Pask (1972) and Risbud and Pask (1978).
Phase Equilibria
189
80
C
ris to b 15 ali 00 te
20
16 00
2L iqu ids
170 0
SiO2
00 14 1600
Anorthite
20
00
00
14
1500
2CaO.SiO2
Gehelnite
1700
19 00
20
00 15
3 3CaO AI2O3
20 CaO
00 CaO.2AI2O3 CaO.AI2O3
CaO.6AI2O3
1900
15
16 1800
2000
2200
2400
Lime
1800
00
17
00
18
80
3AI2O3.2SiO2
Corundum
2CaO.AI2O3-SiO2
00
3CaO.2SiO2
40 1600
13 00
CaO.AI2O32SiO2
1400
2CaO.2SiO2
Mullite
00 15
CaO.2SiO2
60
1800
140 0
1500
CaO2.SiO2
Pseudo– woilastonite
2000
40
1700
e ymit 0 Tnd 130
3CaO.AI2O3 5CaO.3AI2O3 CaO.AI2O3 CaO.2AI2O3 CaO.6AI2O3 AI2O3
Figure 3.43. Phase diagram of the CaO–Al2 O3 –SiO2 system according to Osborn and Muan (1960) and Gentile and Foster (1963).
The two congruently melting ternary compounds, gehlenite – 2CaO·Al2 O3 ·SiO2 and anorthite – CaO·Al2 O3 ·2SiO2 , melt at temperatures 1593◦ C and 1553◦ C, respectively, and show broad fields of primary crystallization.
3.3.
EXPERIMENTAL METHODS
3.3.1. Thermal analysis
Experimental determination of phase diagrams is convenient by using the thermal analysis method at which the temperature of the investigated sample is registered at its cooling by a constant rate of 2–5◦ C/min. Due to the thermal effects connected with the phase transformations (crystallization, polymorphic transformation), breaks appear on the cooling
190
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
T fus
temperature
T pc
Te
Te
1
2
3
time Figure 3.44. Cooling curves of samples with different composition.1 – pure component, 2 – arbitrary mixture, 3 – eutectic mixture.
curve of the sample as well as delays pertinent to the respective phase transformation. Cooling curves of three different types of samples in a simple binary eutectic system are schematically shown in Figure 3.44. Curve No. 1 shows freezing of the pure component. On the curve, only one delay can be seen, which is caused by the evolution of the crystallization heat of the component. At melting temperature, this one-component system has no degree of freedom, since two phases coexist: the solid compound and its melt (k = 1, f = 2, v = 0). The temperature of the system therefore stays constant until its whole solidification. In practice we can, however, observe at the end of the delay a temperature decrease caused by the transport of bigger heat amounts to the surroundings, than it could be evolved at crystallization of the compound. Curve No. 2 shows the cooling of the binary mixture with an arbitrary composition except of the eutectic one. On the curve, one break and one delay can be seen. The break is due to the start of the primary crystallization of one of the components. At primary crystallization, the binary system has one degree of freedom, as the solid component and the melt saturated with the component coexist (k = 2, f = 2, v = 1). Thus the cooling
Phase Equilibria
191
due to the evolution of the crystallization heat only slows down until the eutectic point is attained. At the eutectic temperature a cooling delay happens since the system does not have any degree of freedom (k = 2, f = 3, v = 0). The temperature of the system again keeps constant theoretically up to the complete solidification of the mixture. Again in practice a decrease in the temperature can be seen, caused by the transport of more heat into the surroundings than it evolves by crystallization. Curve No. 3 shows freezing of the eutectic mixture. Only one delay can be seen on the curve, caused by evolution of the crystallization heat of both the components. At the eutectic point the binary system has no degree of freedom, since two solid phases coexist: two solid phases and the melt saturated by both the components (k = 2, f = 3, v = 0). The temperature of the system thus stays constant again until its total solidification. In practice, however, we can see again at the end of the delay a decrease in temperature caused by the evolution of more heat to the surroundings, than it can be evolved by the crystallization of components. By thermal analysis of a sufficient number of samples, it is possible to construct a phase diagram of the investigated system. Figure 3.45 shows the cooling curve of the mixture 5% NaF + 95 mole % NaBF4 measured by Chrenková (2001). The figurative point of this mixture in the phase diagram of the NaF–NaBF4 system lies in between the eutectic point and pure NaBF4 . The enthalpy of fusion of NaBF4 is fus HNaBF4 = 13.5kJ/mol at 408◦ C. The first break on the cooling curve occurs at 400◦ C, where NaBF4 crystallizes as a primary phase. The break at the cooling curve is not very distinct due to the small amount of heat evolved at the crystallization of NaBF4 . The shape of the break depends also on the cooling rate and at fast cooling, the break could not be detected at all. The temperature halt at 380◦ C corresponds to the eutectic temperature with the simultaneous crystallization of NaF and NaBF4 . A small under-cooling by approximately 6◦ C could be observed at the eutectic crystallization followed by a short temperature halt. Both the little-distinct break and the small under-cooling indicate the rather fast cooling of the melt. The duration of the temperature halt at the eutectic temperature depends on the amount of heat evolved at the eutectic crystallization. It is evident from the phase rule that the amount of eutectic melt increases from the pure component to the eutectic composition and in the same manner also the amount of heat evolved at the eutectic crystallization increases. Plotting the time duration of the eutectic crystallization versus the composition, we get the so-called “Tamman triangles” (Figure 3.46). This procedure helps to detect the position of the eutectic point.
3.3.2. Cryoscopy
Cryoscopy is an analytical method measuring the melting point depression of the solvent A caused by the addition of a small amount of the substance B. The classical cryoscopy
420
410
400°C
t(°C)
400
390
380°C
380
370 4000
4500
5000 τ (sec)
5500
6000
Figure 3.45. Cooling curve of the mixture 5% NaF + 95 mole % NaBF4 .
T fus, A T fus, B
Te eutectic halts
A
x(B)
B
Figure 3.46. The halts of temperature at eutectic crystallization form the Tamman triangles.
Phase Equilibria
193
in molecular solvents is usually used for the determination of either the heat of fusion of the solvent or the molecular mass of the solvent. As will be shown in the next section, cryoscopy in ionic melts is used either for the determination of the heat of fusion of the solvent or the number of new (foreign) ionic particles, which occur in the solvent when a very small amount of solute is added to the solvent. However, cryoscopy in ionic melts may sometimes provide ambiguous results. These problems occur in such cases, when association reactions take place in the solvent and the molecular mass is not definitely known. Also the uncertainty in the value of the heat of fusion can result in incorrect results. On the other hand, the interpretation of the cryoscopic result could be sometimes uncertain, especially then, when the number of new particles can be caused by two or more chemical reactions. A special case is cryoscopy performed in solvents with dystectic melting, i.e. in those, which undergo at melting a thermal dissociation. This case will be discussed in Section 3.3.2.2. 3.3.2.1. Theoretical background
The equilibrium between the activity of the saturated solution of the solvent A and temperature in a simple binary eutectic system A–B is described by Le Chatelier–Schreder’s equation ln aA =
fus HA R
1 Tfus, A
−
1 T
(3.159)
where aA is the activity, Tfus, A is the temperature of fusion, and fus HA is the enthalpy of fusion of the component A. Let us now examine the course of the liquidus curve upon the melting point of the component A. Since we are working with dilute solutions, for the solvent A the following limiting relations are valid xA → 1, aA → xA , T → Tfus, A
(3.160)
ln xA = ln(1 − xB ) ∼ = −xB
(3.161)
For ln xA we can write
and for the right side of Eq. (3.159) fus HA R
1 Tfus, A
−
1 T
=
fus HA T − Tfus, A fus HA −Tfus, A = 2 R T Tfus, A R Tfus, A
(3.162)
194
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
After substitution and rearrangement we get Tfus, A =
2 RTfus, A
fus HA
xB = Ktd, A xB
(3.163)
where Tfus, A is the melting point depression and Ktd, A is the constant of thermal depression of the solvent A. Ktd, A is the analogy of the cryoscopic constant and depends solely on the properties of the solvent A. Equation (3.163) is the classical equation valid for cryoscopic measurements in solutions, which fulfills Raoult‘s law. For solutions being ionic in character, the processing of the Le Chatelier–Shreder’s equation in the vicinity of the melting point of the component A must be slightly different T − Tfus, A R ln aA = fus HA (3.164) T Tfus, A Rearranging the right side we get RT ln aA = T
fus HA − fus HA = T fus SA − fus HA Tfus, A
(3.165)
and further T (fus SA − R ln aA ) = fus HA
(3.166)
and finally T =
fus HA fus SA − R ln aA
(3.167)
Equation (3.167) is the simplified and modified Le Chatelier–Shreder’s equation expressed explicitly for T. Differentiating Eq. (3.167) according to temperature we get dT 1 daA Rfus HA = 2 dxA (fus SA − R ln aA ) aA dxA
(3.168)
For the tangent to the liquidus curve in the point xA = 1 it holds 2 RTfus, dT daA daA A = lim = Ktd, A lim xA →1 dxA xA →1 dxA fus HA xA →1 dxA
k0 = lim
(3.169)
For systems being ionic in character is daA = kSt, A xA →1 dxA lim
(3.170)
Phase Equilibria
195
where kSt,A is the semi-empirical correction factor introduced by Stortenbeker (1892), which is numerically equal to the number of new (foreign) particles of molecular dimensions, which one molecule of the solute B introduces into the pure solvent A. In practice, we lay the polynomial best fit through the dependence of the experimentally determined temperatures of primary crystallization, T, on molar fractions of the solvent, xA , and the limit of its first derivative for xA → 1 gives the slope k0 . Knowing the enthalpy of fusion of the solvent and thus also the value of the constant of thermal depression, Ktd, A , we can easily calculate the Stortenbeker’s correction factor. The cryoscopic measurement is frequently used in the literature. Examples of such measurement can be found also in this book. 3.3.2.2. Cryoscopy in solvents with dystectic melting
In binary systems of alkali metal halides and transition metal halides, sulfates, molybdates, tungstates, etc., like NaF–AlF3 , KF–NbF5 , KF–K2 SO4 , additive complex compounds originate, which undergo at melting a more or less extended thermal dissociation according to the general scheme α
Ap Bq −−→ pA + qB
(3.171)
Evidences of such behavior for p = q = 1 were discussed, for example by Daneˇ k and Cekovský (1992) and Daneˇ k and Proks (1999). Due to the thermal dissociation of the complex compound AB, its liquidus curve exhibits a curvature at the temperature of fusion with a slope at the composition of AB equal to zero. Such a phenomenon is called the dystectic mode of melting (Figure 3.47). Thus at the temperature of fusion the following equation is fulfilled
dT dxw (AB)
=0
(3.172)
xw (AB)=1
where xw (AB) is the weighed-in mole fraction of solvent AB. The curvature radius of the liquidus curve depends on the degree of dissociation α of the complex compound AB. The flatter the liquidus curve, the higher is the dissociation degree. Very interesting from the theoretical point of view is the evaluation of cryoscopic measurements made in these solvents, when a chemical reaction takes place between the solvent and solute. In such a case, there arises the problem of defining the number of foreign particles in order to determine the nature of the probable chemical reaction. A typical example of such systems with great technological importance is cryolite, Na3AlF6 , with dystectic mode of melting. On dissolving some compounds, like metal oxides in cryolite, besides the formation of new compounds due to the chemical reactions between cryolite and the solute, also the formation of compounds identical with cryolite dissociation products
196
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
T fus(A)
T fus(B)
T fus(AB)
T eut, 1
T eut, 2
A
x w(B)
B
Figure 3.47. Phase diagram of the A–B system with dystectic melting of component AB.
may occur, regardless of the accepted dissociation scheme of cryolite. The theoretical derivation of relations valid for cryoscopic measurements in such solvents was given by Proks et al. (2002). Let us consider the dissolution of the admixture X in the dystectically melting solvent AB. The course of the liquidus curve of substance AB in the AB–X system (Figure 3.48) is described by the Le Chatelier–Shreder equation, which in the limit for xr (AB) → 1 we can express in the differential form lim
xr (AB)→1
dxr (AB) 1 fus H (AB, T ) = lim xr (A)→1 xr (AB) dT RT 2 =
fus H (AB, Tfus (AB)) = Ktd 2 (AB) RTfus
(3.173)
where xr (AB) is the real mole fraction of solvent AB (i.e. the equilibrium activity) and Tfus (AB) and fus H(AB, Tfus (AB)) is the temperature and enthalpy of fusion of AB, respectively. Turning over and extending Eq. (3.173) we get
dT dT dxw (AB) 1 xr (AB) = lim = xr (AB)→1 dxr (AB) xr (AB)→1 dxw (AB) dxr (AB) Ktd lim
(3.174)
Phase Equilibria
197
Tfus(AB)
kSt = 1
kSt = 2
Teut kSt = 3
AB
x(X)
X
Figure 3.48. Phase diagram of the AB–X system with dystectic melting of component AB and a chemical reaction between solvent AB and solute X.
Now we will examine the behavior of xr (AB) with regard to xw (AB) in the limiting region xw (AB) → 1, when X reacts with AB under the formation of new, foreign compounds and compounds identical with the products of thermal dissociation of AB, for example according to the scheme AB + X = AX + B. The increase in the amount of substance AB caused by the reaction of 1 mol of admixture X with substance AB is denoted by l (l is non-zero only when AB melts dystectically) and the decrease in the amount of substance AB caused by the reaction of 1 mol of admixture X with substance AB is denoted as m. For xr (AB) we get lim
xw (AB)→1
= =
lim
xr (AB)
xw (AB)→1
xw (AB) + l[1 − xw (AB)] − m[1 − xw (AB)] xw (AB) + l[1 − xw (AB)] − m[1 − xw (AB)] + kSt [1 − xw (AB)]
xw (AB) + n[1 − xw (AB)] xw (AB) = =1 xw (AB)→1 xw (AB) + n[1 − xw (AB)] + kSt [1 − xw (AB)] xw (AB) lim
(3.175)
198
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
where l−m = n. It is thus possible to substitute in the limiting region xw (AB) for xr (AB). Equation (3.174) then transforms to the form lim
dT dxr (AB) 1 = lim dxw (AB) xw (AB)→1 dxw (AB) Ktd
(3.176)
lim
dT dxr (AB) .Ktd = lim xw (AB)→1 dxw (AB) dxw (AB)
(3.177)
xw (AB)→1
or
xw (AB)→1
The right side of Eq. (3.177) can be expressed in the form xw (AB) + n[1 − xw (AB)] xw (AB) + n[1 − xw (AB)] + kSt [1 − xw (AB)]
xr (AB) =
xw (AB) + n[1 − xw (AB)] F
=
(3.178)
Differentiating Eq. (3.178) according to xw (AB) we get dxr (AB) 1 xw (AB)F n n[1 − xw (AB)]F = − − − dxw (AB) F F F2 F2 =
F − F xw (AB) − nF − F n[1 − xw (AB)] F2
(3.179)
and in the limiting region dxr (AB) F (1 − n) − F {xw (AB) + n[1 − xw (AB)]} = lim xw (AB)→1 dxw (AB) xw (AB)→1 F2 lim
(3.180)
For F and its first derivative F in the limiting region we get lim
xw (AB)→1
F =
lim
xw (AB)→1
{xw (AB) + n[1 − xw (AB)] + kSt [1 − xw (AB)]} = 1 (3.181)
lim
xw (AB)→1
F = 1 − n − kSt
(3.182)
and finally for Eq. (3.180) dxr (AB) 1 − n − (1 − n − kSt ) = = kSt xw (AB)→1 dxw (AB) 1 lim
(3.183)
Phase Equilibria
199
The derivative on the left side of Eq. (3.183) is not necessary to calculate separately. Its value is always equal to the number of new substances (kSt ) originating in the reaction between the solvent AB and the admixture X, distinguishable from the dissociation products of the solvent AB. However, it is necessary to choose such reaction schemes between AB and X for which kSt equals the left side of the experimentally determined value of Eq. (3.177). In the following application of the above-presented thermodynamic approach to the Na3AlF6 –Al2 O3 system, we confront the common approach with the new one with regard to the general dissociation scheme of cryolite, which transforms into the form α
A3 B −−−→ AB + 2B
(3.184)
According to the recent Raman spectroscopic investigation performed by Robert et al. (1997a) and direct oxygen LECO analysis carried out by Daneˇ k et al. (2000b), aluminum oxide dissolves in cryolite under the formation of two main oxofluoroaluminates, Na2Al2 O2 F4 and Na2Al2 OF6 , according to the general scheme 2Na3 AlF6 + Al2 O3 = Na2 Al2 OF6 + Na2 Al2 O2 F4 + 2NaF
(3.185)
which indicate the introduction of two new substances when 1 mol Al2 O3 is dissolved in an infinite amount of cryolite, i.e. kSt = 2. The phase diagram of this system according to Chin and Hollingshead (1966) and the calculated slopes of the liquidus curves for three chosen kSt are shown in Figure 3.49. The material balance regarding the above reaction is as follows: Let us consider 1 mol of mixture with the composition x1 (=xw (Na3AIF6 ) mol Na3AlF6 + x2 (=xw (X)) mol Al2 O3 , where x2 << x1 . Cryolite dissociates according to reaction (3.184) with a dissociation degree α. The dissolution of Al2 O3 in cryolite is accompanied by the reaction (3.185). At equilibrium, we get the following amounts of the individual substances n(Na3 AlF6 ) = [(1 − α)x1 − 2x2 ] mol n(NaAlF4 ) = αx1 mol n(NaF) = (2αx1 + 2x2 ) mol n(Na2 Al2 OF6 ) = x2 mol n(Na2 Al2 O2 F4 ) = x2 mol The total amount of all substances is ni = [x1 (1 + 2α) + 2x2 ]mol. As we are in the region of dilute solutions, the mole fractions can be set equal to the activities, i.e. the
200
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
1340
1320
T(K)
1300
1280 kSt = 1
1260
1240 kSt = 3
1220
Na3AlF6 0.05
0.10
kSt = 2
0.15 0.20 x(Al2O3)
0.25
0.30
Figure 3.49. Phase diagram of the Na3AlF6 –Al2 O3 system according to Chin and Hollingshead (1966).
real mole fractions of substances. For the real mole fraction of cryolite, we then get n(Na3 AlF6 ) + n(NaAlF4 ) + n(NaF) x1 (1 + 2α) = ni x1 (1 + 2α) + 2x2
xr (Na3 AlF6 ) =
(3.186)
Differentiating Eq. (3.186) according to x1 and inserting the limiting conditions (x1 = 1, x2 = 0) we get lim
xr (Na3 AlF6 )→1
∂xr (Na3 AlF6 ) ∂x1
=
(1 + 2α)(x1 + 2x1 α + 2x2 ) − (x1 + 2x1 α)(1 + 2α − 2) (x1 + 2x1 α + 2x2 )2
=
(1 + 2α)(1 + 2α) − (1 + 2α)(2α − 1) 2 = kSt = 2 (1 + 2α) (1 + 2α)
(3.187)
Phase Equilibria
201
as according to Grjotheim et al. (1982) α, attains at 1000◦ C the value of 0.3, the Stortenbecker’s correction factor equals 1.25, which is in contrast to the expected value. Such a procedure obviously does not yield the correct result. However, as it follows from the approach presented by Proks et al. (2002), it is not necessary to take into account the dissociation of cryolite in the calculation of kSt , since the solvent does not consider the originating dissociation product of cryolite as a foreign species. The material balance is thus as follows. The equilibrium amounts of individual substances are n(Na3 AlF6 ) = (x1 − 2x2 ) mol n(NaF) = 2x2 mol n(Na2 Al2 OF6 ) = x2 mol n(Na2 Al2 O2 F4 ) = x2 mol The total amount of all substances is cryolite we then get the relation xr (Na3 AlF6 ) =
ni = 1 + x2 mol. For the real molar fraction of
n(Na3 AlF6 ) + n(NaF) x1 = ni 1 + x2
(3.188)
Differentiating Eq. (3.188) according to x1 and inserting the limiting conditions (x1 = 1, x2 = 0) we get lim
xr (Na3 AlF6 )→1
∂xr (Na3 AlF6 ) ∂x1
=
(1 + x2 ) + x1 = 2 = kSt (1 + x2 )2
(3.189)
which is in very good agreement with the experimentally determined value kSt = 1.99. This means that 1 mol Al2 O3 introduces two new species into an infinite amount of cryolite. This is in accordance with the assumed reaction (3.185). The new species are the compounds Na2Al2 OF6 and Na2Al2 O2 F4 , since NaF is already present in cryolite due to its thermal dissociation. 3.3.2.3. Cryoscopy in eutectic mixtures
For the equilibrium solidus–liquidus of the component i in a simple eutectic system in which no compounds are formed and the solubility of the components in the solid state does not exist, the differential form of the Le Chatelier–Shreder’s equation holds d ln ai =
fus Hi dT RT 2
(3.190)
202
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
where ai and fus Hi are the activity and the enthalpy of fusion of the component i, respectively, T is the temperature, and R is the gas constant. For simplification, it is assumed that fus Hi = f (T ) and the solution is ideal, i.e. ai = xi . Then by integration and rearrangement of Eq. (3.190), for the melting point depression, T, (in fact it is the depression of the temperature of primary crystallization) of the solvent A that was effected by minor additions of the solute B in the A–B system, the well-known relation is obtained T =
2 RTfus, A
fus HA
(3.191)
T xB
The problem is whether it is possible to carry out analogous measurements also in the eutectic mixtures A–B, i.e. to determine the depression of the eutectic temperature affected by minor additions of the substance C. For this case, Førland (1964) derived an equation similar to Eq. (3.191) substituting Tfus, E (eutectic temperature) in Eq. (3.191) for Tfus, A , fus HE (enthalpy of fusion of the eutectic mixture, which is independent of the concentration of the component C, xC ) for fus HA , and xC for xB . However, it could be a matter of discussion, whether the equation proposed by Førland has a general validity. Fellner and Matiašovský (1974) derived an equation for cryoscopy in the eutectic mixtures, which was not found to be analogous with the Le Chatelier–Shreder’s equation. Let us consider an ideal ternary system A–B–C. In this case Eq. (3.190) must be valid for all the three components. From the integral form of Eq. (3.190) for the components A and B, the equation of a projection of the monovariant line of the simultaneous crystallization of these components, E–P in Figure (3.50), can be derived ln xA ln xB 1 − = fus HA fus HB R
1 Tfus, A
−
1 Tfus, B
(3.192)
The concentrations of components A and B at the eutectic point will be denoted as xA∗ and xB∗ . In Eq. (3.192), the temperature is not expressed explicitly; it can be calculated by introducing Eq. (3.192) into the integral form of Eq. (3.190) for the components A and B, respectively. As mentioned above, Førland’s equation for the depression of the eutectic temperature is based on the assumption that fus HE = constant. Thus assuming the relation fus HE = xA∗ fus HA +xB∗ fus HB , the ratio of xA and xB on the monovariant line of the simultaneous crystallization of A and B should be also constant, i.e. it must not be a function of xC . However, this condition is fulfilled only on the assumption that the monovariant line E–P is, at least in the proximity of the binary eutectic point E, identical with the E–C. The diagram presented by Førland for illustration of the proposed relation was drawn in such a way that it might fulfill the above condition. However, in a common case, the slope of the tangent to the line of the simultaneous crystallization of the components A and B can
Phase Equilibria
203
C
P
E
A
B
Figure 3.50. Phase diagram of the ternary system A–B–C in which no solid solutions are formed.
be calculated, after substituting for A in Eq. (3.192) the expression xA = 1–xB –xC , by differentiating Eq. (3.192) as an implicit function dxC xA fus HA = −1 − dxB xB fus HB
(3.193)
Equation (3.193) can be derived also directly from the differential form of Eq. (3.190). The slope of the connection E–C in oblique-angled coordinates equal –1/x+ B , whereas according to Eq. (3.193), for this slope, we obtain x ∗ fus HA d xC = −1 − A∗ xC →1 d xB xB fus HB lim
(3.194)
This limit equals to −1/xB∗ solely in the case when fus HA = fus HB . Only in this case the ratio xA /xB in an ideal system is constant and equal to the ratio xA∗ /xB∗ . Consequently, the statement that the ratio xA /xB is constant implies the condition that the enthalpies of fusion of both components, which compose the eutectic mixture, are equal.
204
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
Setting i = B from Eq. (3.193) into Eq. (3.190), the following relation is obtained dT = −
RT 2 d xC xA fus HA + xB fus HB
(3.195)
which actually appears to be the differential form of the equation of the monovariant line of the simultaneous crystallization of the components A and B. This equation may be derived also directly from Eq. (3.190). From a comparison of Eqs. (3.195) and (3.190) it follows that in Eq. (3.195) the increase in the concentration of component C is presented as dxC and not as d ln xC . Only if fus HA = fus HB , by rearranging Eq. (3.195) the following relation is obtained dT =
RT 2 RT 2 d(xA + xB ) = d ln(xA + xB ) fus HA (xA + xB ) fus HA
(3.196)
In the limiting case for xC → 0, from Eq. (3.195) it follows RTE2 dT =− + xC →0 dxC xA fus HA + xB+ fus HB lim
(3.197)
Thus the cryoscopic measurements may be performed also in eutectic mixtures, since the dT value of the lim dx can be determined. However, it is to be taken into account that the xC →0
C
reasons, why the function T = f xC ) is not linear, are in this case somewhat different. This difference must be considered in experimental work, especially in the estimation of maximum value of xC , at which the error in the determination of temperature resulting from the non-constant value of the denominator in Eq. (3.195) still lies below the limit of experimental determinability. In a common case, for the calculation of the enthalpy of fusion of the eutectic mixture evidently also the temperature dependence of fus HA and fus HB , as well as the enthalpy of mixing of components has to be considered. This, however, does not affect the principal meaning of the above-derived dependencies. Cryoscopic measurements in the eutectic mixture used Daneˇ k et al. (1975) in order to determine the behavior of K2 TiF6 in the LiF–LiCl eutectic mixture. K2 TiF6 in pure LiCl reacts with the chloride anions according to the scheme K2 TiF6 + Cl− = 2K + + 6F− + TiCl4
(3.198)
creating nine new particles, which means that the fluoride ions in TiF4 were substituted by the chloride ions. However, the equilibrium of reaction (3.198) would be substantially shifted to the left side at sufficiently high concentrations of fluoride ions. According to the
Phase Equilibria
205
thermodynamic calculation, this situation could occur in the LiF–LiCl eutectic mixture. The experimental verification of this assumption was made by cryoscopic measurements. The experimentally measured values of the eutectic temperature depression caused by the addition of K2 TiF6 were compared with those calculated on the basis of the determined value of the cryoscopic constant of the LiF–LiCl mixture. The Stortenbeker’s correction factor was found to be kSt = 3, indicating the formation of three new particles due to the dissociation of K2 TiF6 . Hence it follows that in the LiF–LiCl eutectic mixture the dissociation of K2 TiF6 can be described by equation K2 TiF6 = 2K + + 2F− + TiF4
(3.199)
and the substitution reaction does not take place. The verification of this result anticipates the knowledge of the enthalpy of fusion of the LiF–LiCl eutectic mixture. The corresponding data were not known and they were thus determined using the cryoscopic method. In the measurement of the eutectic temperature depression in the LiF–LiCl eutectic mixture, sodium chloride was used as the solute. From the slope of the tangent to the determined monovariant line the value of the enthalpy of fusion of the eutectic mixture fus HE = 20.1 ± 1.3 kJ·mol−1 was obtained. The value of the enthalpy of fusion of the LiF–LiCl eutectic mixture was verified by calculation according to the equation fus HE = xLiF fus H LiF + xLiCl fus HLiCl + mix H
(3.200)
where fus HLiF , fus HLiCl , and fus HE are the enthalpies of fusion of pure components and of the eutectic mixture at the eutectic temperature, respectively, xLiF and xLiCl are the molar fractions of LiF and LiCl, respectively, and mix H is the enthalpy of mixing. The dependence of the enthalpy of fusion on temperature was calculated using the JANAF Thermochemical Tables (1971). The activity coefficients of LiF and LiCl in the eutectic mixture at the eutectic temperature were calculated from the phase diagram determined by Haendler et al. (1959). Since the values of the activity coefficients were found to be close to one (γ LiF = 0.951, γ LiCl = 0.991), the solution could be considered as ideal and thus the enthalpy of mixing close to zero. Assuming that the solution is regular, the value of −0.15 kJ·mol−1 was calculated, which is below the limit of the accuracy of the measurement. The calculated value of the enthalpy of fusion of the LiF–LiCl eutectic mixture fus HE ∼ = 20.9 kJ·mol−1 is in very good agreement with the experimentally measured value. 3.3.3. Differential thermal analysis
Differential thermal analysis is a powerful tool in the investigation of matter. Using this method, different phase transformations and reactions can be determined. The principle of
206
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
this method is similar to the thermal analysis, but in the differential thermal analysis, the temperature difference between the sample and the reference substance during constant heating rate is measured. A typical experimental set-up is shown schematically in Figure 3.51. Two small crucibles made preferably of platinum are placed abreast in a ceramic block, which serves as the heat absorber. The amount of sample ranges from 0.05 to 0.5 g. In the temperature range of measurement, the reference substance must not undergo any phase transformation or any reaction with the surroundings. Fine aluminum oxide powder, carefully purified and dried, is generally used as a reference substance. To the bottom of each crucible the hot joint of one thermocouple is attached. Both the thermocouples are linked outside the ceramic block by equal wires. Such a linkage enables the measurement of temperature difference of both the crucibles during heating and the difference versus time is recorded. Such a connection, however, yields zero voltage when
Heat shields
Heating tube
Ceramic block Reference substance Sample Thermocouples
µV Figure 3.51. The experimental set-up for differential thermal analysis.
Phase Equilibria
207
the sample shows no heat effect and a straight line is then registered. However, the final scan strongly depends on the configuration of the equipment used. The temperature detection, restricted to the surface of the crucibles, does not fully respond to the heat flow in the bulk sample. This results in a baseline drift of thermograms that may cause some uncertainties in the evaluation of the temperature of the thermal effect. The use of the differential thermal analysis in the phase diagram determination is illustrated in Figure 3.52. A hypothetical binary eutectic system A–B with the formation of the incongruently melting compound A4 B was chosen. There are three thermograms (a) to (c) shown as examples. In thermogram (a), the first heat effect at temperature a1
a
c
b
Temperature
a2
a
b3 a1
A4 B
b2
A
-dt c1
b1
a1
B
x(B)
a2
Temperature c
b
-dt
-dt
b1
b2
b3
Temperature
c1
Temperature
Figure 3.52. Phase diagram determination using differential thermal analysis. Thermograms (a) to (c) correspond to different compositions of the hypothetical system.
208
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
corresponds to the melting of the eutectic mixture in the subsystem A–A4 B, followed by the progressive melting until the liquidus is reached at the temperature a2 , where the complete system becomes liquid. In thermogram (b), the first heat effect at temperature b1 corresponds to the eutectic melting in the subsystem A4 B–B, followed by the progressive melting of A4 B up to the temperature b2 , where the amount of pure A4 B, still present as a solid, undergoes isothermal peritectic transformation into solid A and a liquid. Thereafter, the next progressive melting of A takes place up to the liquidus temperature b3 . Finally, the thermogram (c) represents the fusion of the eutectic mixture in the A4 B–B system. Thermograms similar with (c) can also be obtained for the fusion of pure components A, B, as well as for the intermediate compound A4 B.
3.4.
CALCULATION OF PHASE DIAGRAMS
The theoretical calculation of phase diagrams is an important tool both in forecasting the properties of materials, as well as in the study of the structure of the melts, and became a self-sustaining field of science. Several characteristics of the phase diagrams can be related to the calculations and to particular terms in the theory. Extension of the deviation from ideal behavior is an important feature, which can explain the probability of the formation of compounds. The calculation of phase diagram can prove to be useful for many practical reasons. One can (i) (ii) (iii)
predict ternary phase diagrams a priori from the data of pure materials and on the binary systems, utilize the thermodynamic self-consistency of the theory to check phase diagrams for inconsistency or phenomena, which are not likely to occur, utilize the theory fitted to a very few experimental points in order to extrapolate from those few measurements. Thus, the use of the theory can minimize the number of measurements one needs to characterize any given system.
3.4.1. Coupled analysis of thermodynamic and phase diagram data
For the calculation of the phase diagrams using coupled analysis of thermodynamic and phase diagram data, the thermodynamic data represent enthalpies of fusion, enthalpies of mixing, heat capacities, and all other data that are available from the literature. The phase diagram data are the measured temperatures of primary crystallization, temperatures of secondary crystallization, etc. as well as the temperatures of the eutectic temperatures. The calculation of the phase diagrams of condensed systems using the coupled analysis of the thermodynamic and phase diagram data is based on the solution of a set of equations
Phase Equilibria
209
of the following type fus G0i (T ) + RT ln
al, i (T ) =0 as, i (T )
(3.201)
where fus G0i is the standard molar Gibbs energy of fusion of the component i at the temperature T, R is the gas constant, and as, i (T) and al, i (T) are the activities of component i in the solid and liquid phase, respectively. Assuming immiscibility of components in the solid phase (as, i = 1) and that the enthalpy of fusion of the components does not change with temperature, for the thermodynamic temperature of primary crystallization of the component i, Tpc, i , we get Tpc, i =
fus Hi0 + RTpc, i ln γl, i fus Si0 − R ln xl, i
(3.202)
where fus H0i and fus S0i are the standard enthalpy and standard entropy of fusion, respectively, xl, i and γ l, i is the mole fraction and the activity coefficient of component i, respectively. The activity coefficients can be calculated from the molar excess Gibbs energy of mixing
RTpc, i ln γl. i
∂ nGEter = ∂ ni
(3.203)
T , p, nj =i
where ni is the amount of component i and n is the total amount of all the components. In the ternary system A−B−C the molar excess Gibbs energy of mixing in the liquid phase, GEter can be described by the following general equation GEter =
k(j ) l(j ) m(j )
xA xB xC
Gj
(3.204)
j
where xi are the mole fractions of the components, Gj are the empirical coefficients in the composition dependence of the molar excess Gibbs energy of mixing and k(j), l(j), m(j) are adjustable integers. For the boundary binary systems one of the integers equals zero. Using Eq. (3.202), the following mathematical model for the coupled thermodynamic analysis was used Tpc, i = F0, i +
j
Fj, i Gj
(3.205)
210
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
where Tpc, i was obtained from the phase diagram measurement. The first term on the right side represents the ideal behavior and the second one, the deviation from the ideal behavior. For the auxiliary functions F0, i and Fj, i , with respect to the Gibbs–Duhem relation, the following equations hold fus Hi0
F0,i =
(3.206)
fus Si0 − R ln xl, i k(j ) l(j ) m(j ) ∂ nxA xB xC ∂ ni nj =i
Fj, i =
(3.207)
fus Si0 − R ln xl, i
If an intermediate compound Z = Ap Bq Cr (p + q + r = 1) is formed in the ternary system, Eqs. (3.204), (3.206), and (3.207) for this compound must be modified GEter =
k(j ) l(j ) m(j )
xA xB xC
− p k(j ) q l(j ) r m(j ) Gj
(3.208)
j
F0, Z =
p Fj, Z =
∂ G ∂ nA
fus HZ0
+q nB , nC
(3.209)
p q
fus SZ0 − R ln KxA xB xCr ∂ G ∂ nB
+r
nA , nC p q
∂ G ∂ nC
nA , nB
fus SZ0 − R ln KxA xB xCr
(3.210)
where
−1 K = pp q q r r
(3.211)
k(j ) l(j ) m(j ) G = n xA xB xC − p k(j ) q l(j ) r m(j )
(3.212)
and
If the molar enthalpy of mixing of the system is known, the molar Gibbs energy of mixing can be expressed as follows Gmix = Hmix + T Smix
(3.213)
Phase Equilibria
211
The enthalpy of mixing can be expressed as a function of composition in the form Hmix =
α
β
i i xAX xBX Hi
(3.214)
i
where Hi are empirical coefficients determined, for example using the least-squares method from experimental data, and α i and βi are integers. A similar equation can be written for the entropy of mixing Smix =
α
β
i i xAX xBX Si
(3.215)
i
In the three-component systems, two different procedures may be used for the calculation of the molar excess Gibbs energy of mixing. In the first one, the molar excess Gibbs energy of mixing is calculated separately for the individual binary boundary systems using the binary phase diagram data. The resulting coefficients for the binary systems are then used for the calculation of the molar excess Gibbs energy of mixing in the ternary system using the ternary phase diagram data only. This approach is frequently used in the so-called “symmetrical” ternary systems, in which the excess Gibbs energy of mixing of all three binary systems is approximately of the same order. In the second procedure, the calculation of the molar excess Gibbs energy of mixing in the ternary system is performed in one step using Eq. (3.204). The use of this approach is advantageous in the “asymmetrical” ternary systems, in which the excess Gibbs energy of mixing of one binary system substantially differs from those of the other two binaries. The application of the first approach to such ternary systems describes well the binaries, but does not yield a reliable ternary diagram. For such a case, the latter approach is more convenient, however, on account of the lower precision of the calculated binary diagrams. Qiao et al. (1996) defined the thermodynamic criterion for judging the symmetry of the ternary systems and its application. Based upon the previous significant studies and the enlightening analysis made by works of Toop (1965), Ansara (1979), Hillert (1980), Lukas (1982), and taking into account interactions among components, the thermodynamic criterion for defining the symmetry of ternary systems from the energetic point of view, was explicitly proposed as follows: “If the excess thermodynamic properties of the three binary subsystems of the A–B–C ternary system are similar to each other, the ternary system is symmetric. If the deviation of the binary system A–B and A–C from the ideal behavior are similar, but differ markedly from that of the binary system B–C, then the A–B–C ternary system is asymmetric. In the asymmetric system the component A in two binary subsystems with thermodynamic similarity should be chosen as the thermodynamic asymmetric component.”
212
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
As an example of the asymmetric ternary system, Qiao et al. (1996) presented the system PrCl3 –CaCl2 –MgCl2 . The excess molar Gibbs energy of the binary systems CaCl2 –MgCl2 and PrCl3 –MgCl2 show positive deviations from ideal solutions, while the PrCl3 –CaCl2 system shows negative deviations from ideality. Hence, according to the above-mentioned thermodynamic criterion, MgCl2 is the asymmetric component. For most LnCl3 –CaCl2 –MgCl2 (Ln = rare earth metals) systems, MgCl2 can be reasonably chosen as the asymmetric component. According to Papatheodorou et al. (1967), in pure MgCl2 there are Mg–Cl–Mg bridging bonds. When CaCl2 or LnCl3 is added to MgCl2 , the original bridging bonds are broken. This additional energy is absorbed and the total energy of the system increases, which shows in the thermodynamic properties of the system. As an example of the asymmetric system, NdCl3 –CaCl2 –LiCl could be mentioned, where apparent negative deviations from ideal solutions have been observed in all binary subsystems. However, in the binary system NdCl3 –LiCl, the negative deviations are much bigger than in the NdCl3 –CaCl2 and CaCl2 –LiCl systems. From the view of the asymmetric distribution of energy in the ternary system, it is reasonable to choose CaCl2 as the asymmetric component. The asymmetric model was successfully applied also in molten slag systems. As it was shown by Pelton and Blander (1986), in the CaO–FeO–SiO2 system there is one acidic (SiO2 ) and two basic (CaO and FeO) components. Thus the most appropriate seems to be SiO2 as the asymmetric component. However, according to the above-mentioned criterion, FeO should be chosen as the thermodynamic asymmetric component, since the CaO–SiO2 system shows much more negative deviations from the ideal behavior than the systems, CaO–FeO and FeO–SiO2 . After a systematic comparison of the calculated and measured results of excess thermodynamic properties and phase diagrams, it can be concluded that the key point in the choice of the suitable geometric model to predict ternary thermodynamic properties from the binary ones is to choose reasonably between the symmetric or asymmetric models. In most cases, the main source of error in the calculation arises from the incorrect choice of the asymmetric component in the asymmetric model. The coupled thermodynamic analysis, i.e. the calculation of the coefficients Gj in Eq. (3.204) is performed using the multiple linear regression analysis omitting the statistically non-important terms according to the Student test on the chosen confidence level. As the optimizing criterion for the best fit between the experimental and calculated temperatures of primary crystallization, the following condition was used for all the p measured points p
Tpc,exp,i − Tpc,calc,i
i=1
2
= min
(3.216)
Phase Equilibria
213
Beside the condition (3.216) for the calculation of the molar excess Gibbs energy of mixing, the minimum necessary Gj coefficients for attaining thermodynamically consistent phase diagram and a reasonable standard deviation of approximation are required. E = f (T ). The calculation is mostly performed assuming fus Hi = f (T ) and Gter Using a coupled analysis of thermodynamic and phase diagram data, phase diagrams of the Fe–Cr–O, Fe–Ni–O, Cr–Ni–O systems (Pelton et al., 1979a), Mn3 O4 –Co3 O4 and Fe3 O4 –Co3 O4 spinelitic systems (Pelton et al., 1979b), binary and ternary systems of the NaCl–Na2 SO4 –Na2 CrO4 –Na2 MoO4 –Na2 WO4 system (Liang et al., 1980), AlF3 –LiF– NaF system (Saboungi et al., 1980), Na+ , K+ // F− , SO2− 4 system (Hatem et al., 1982), etc., were calculated. Thompson et al. (1987) has developed a special program F*A*C*T (Facility for the Analysis of Chemical Thermodynamics) to calculate the phase diagrams of various systems, for example 70 binary alkali metal halide systems with common ions (Sangster and Pelton, 1987) and a number of binary and ternary alkali metal salt systems (Sangster and Pelton, 1987). In the following section, an example of the coupled analysis of the thermodynamic and phase diagram data will be presented. 3.4.2. Calculation of the phase diagram of the quaternary system KF−KCl−KBF4 −K2 TiF6
As an example, the coupled analysis of the thermodynamic and phase diagram data of the KF−KCl−KBF4 −K2 TiF6 system performed by Chrenková et al. (2001) is presented. This system is important because of its potential use as an electrolyte for electro-deposition of titanium diboride. The molar excess Gibbs energy of mixing in the liquid phase in the quaternary system KF−KCl−KBF4 −K2 TiF6 was calculated as the sum of the molar excess Gibbs energies of mixing in the binary systems, of the molar excess Gibbs energies of mixing in the ternary systems, and of the quaternary interaction terms. The molar excess Gibbs energy of mixing in the boundary binary systems was descibed using the following general equation b(k) c(k) GEi,bin = x 1 x 2 Gk (3.217) k
and in the ternary systems GEj,ter
=
3
GEi,bin +
b (k) c (k) d (k) x 2 x 3 Gk
x1
(3.218)
k
i=1
For the molar excess Gibbs energy of mixing in the quaternary system, the final equation is then 4 b (k) c (k) d (k) e (k) GEquat = GEj,ter + x1 x2 x3 x4 Gk (3.219) j =1
k
214
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
where the second term represents the quaternary interactions. Coefficients b (k), c (k), d (k), and e (k) are integers in the range 1−3. Two additive binary compounds, K3 TiF7 and K3 TiF6 Cl, are formed in the system. In the calculation this fact was taken into account using Eqs. (3.208) to (3.212). The coupled thermodynamic analysis, i.e. the calculation of coefficients Gk , Gk , and Gk in Eqs. (3.204), (3.205), and (3.206), respectively, has been performed using the multiple linear regression analysis omitting the statistically non-important terms in the molar excess Gibbs energy of mixing at 0.99 confidence level according to the Student’s test. The values of the enthalpy of fusion of individual components used in the calculation are summarized in Table 3.4. The experimentally determined temperatures of primary crystallization in the ternary KF−KCl−KBF4 system were measured by Patarák and Daneˇ k (1992), those of the KF−KBF4 −K2 TiF6 system by Chrenková et al. (1996), and those of the KCl−KBF4 −K2 TiF6 system by Chrenková et al. (1995). The temperatures of primary and eutectic crystallization in the KF-KCl−KBF4 −K2 TiF6 system were measured by Chrenková et al. (2001). For the excess molar Gibbs energy of mixing in the boundary binary systems the general equation GEi, bin = x1 x2 G1 + G2 x2 + G3 x22
(3.220)
was found to be valid. The values of the coefficients Gi together with the standard deviations of the fits are given in Table 3.5. For the excess molar Gibbs energy of mixing in the individual ternary systems the following equations were obtained
GEKCl−KF−KBF4 =
3
GEi, bin + G1 x1 x22 x3 + G2 x1 x22 x32
(3.221)
i=1
Table 3.4. Temperatures and enthalpies of fusion of compounds used for the phase diagram calculation Compound
fus (KJ · mol−1 )
Tfus (K)
Reference
KF KCl KBF4 K2 TiF6 K3 TiF7 K3 TiF6 Cl
27.196 26.154 17.656 21.000 57.000 47.000
1131 1045 843 1172 1048 969
Knacke et al. (1991) Knacke et al. (1991) Knacke et al. (1991) Adamkoviˇcová et al. (1995a) Adamkoviˇcová et al. (1995b) Adamkoviˇcová et al. (1996)
Phase Equilibria
215
Table 3.5. Coefficients Ci of the concentration dependence of the molar excess Gibbs energy of mixing and the standard deviations of the temperature of primary crystallization in the binary subsystems of the quaternary system KF−KCl−KBF4 −K2 TiF6 System KCl−KF KF−KBF4 KF−K2 TiF6 KCl−KBF4 KCl−K2 TiF7 K2 TiF7 −KBF4
G1 (J · mol−1 )
G2 (J · mol−1 )
G3 (J · mol−1 )
σ (◦ C)
2144 ± 547 3836 ± 233 −11507 ± 1743 50 ± 22 −7531 ± 2458 8475 ± 830
−7379 ± 284 −14434 ± 790 −19918 ± 6050 3725 ± 736 25700 ± 6335 −25810 ± 1426
6111 ± 829 6625 ± 833 33344 ± 5830 −7175 ± 2367 −31125 ± 8457 12905 ± 713
1.2 1.9 6.5 5.6 5.0 6.1
GEKF−K2 TiF6 −KBF4 =
3
GEi, bin + G1 x13 x2 x3 + G2 x13 x2 x32
(3.222)
i=1
GEKCl−K2 TiF6 −KBF4 =
3
GEi,bin + G1 x1 x23 x32 + G2 x1 x2 x33 + G3 x12 x22 x33
i=1
GEKCl−KF−K2 TiF6 =
3
+ G4 x13 x2 x3
(3.223)
GEi, bin + G1 x1 x2 x3 + G2 x1 x22 x3 + G3 x13 x22 x33
(3.224)
i=1
The calculated coefficients of the concentration dependence of the excess molar Gibbs energy of mixing together with the standard deviations of the fit temperature in the ternary systems are given in Table 3.6. The ternary system KCl−KF−KBF4 is a simple eutectic with the coordinates of the eutectic point 21 mole % KF, 19 mole % KCl, 60 mole % KBF4 , te = 409◦ C. Table 3.6. Coefficients Ci of the concentration dependence of the molar excess Gibbs energy of mixing and the standard deviations of the temperature of primary crystallization in the ternary subsystems of the quaternary system KF−KCl−KBF4 −K2 TiF6 System KF–K2 TiF6 –KBF4
Coefficient
KCl–KF–KBF4
KCl–KF–K2 TiF6
G1 (J · mol−1 ) G2 (J · mol−1 ) G3 (J · mol−1 ) G4 (J · mol−1 ) σ (◦ C)
−22709 ± 1429 −36041 ± 1843 – – 6.8
36975 ± 2173 −31585 ± 2067 −1241825 ± 89126 – –
−14718 ± 5725 −198846 ± 16972 – – 15.2
KCl–K2 TiF6 –KBF4 −263005 ± 16623 92415 ± 8284 796972 ± 72485 41055 ± 5182 17.6
216
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
The inaccuracy in the calculated ternary phase diagram is ± 6.8◦ C. In the ternary system KF−K2 TiF6 −KBF4 , the intermediate compound K3 TiF7 divides the system into two simple eutectic systems. The calculated coordinates of the two ternary eutectic points are: e1 : 26 mole % KF, 68 mole % KBF4 , 6 mole % K2 TiF6 , te1 = 450◦ C, e2 : 3 mole % KF, 69 mole % KBF4 , 28 mole % K2 TiF6 , te2 = 435◦ C. The inaccuracy in the calculated ternary phase diagram is ± 15.2◦ C. In the ternary system KCl−K2 TiF6 −KBF4 , the intermediate compound K3 TiF6 Cl divides the ternary system into two simple eutectic systems. The calculated coordinates of the two ternary eutectic points are: e1 : 18 mole % KCl, 66 mole % KBF4 , 16 mole % K2 TiF6 , te1 = 449◦ C, e2 : 6 mole % KCl, 63 mole % KBF4 , 31.0 mole % K2 TiF6 , te2 = 417◦ C. The inaccuracy in the calculated phase diagram is ± 17.6◦ C. In the ternary system KF−KCl−K2 TiF6 two intermediate compounds, K3 TiF7 and K3 TiF6 Cl, are formed. The calculated coordinates of the three ternary eutectic points are: e1 : 13 mole % KF, 25 mole % KCl; 62 mole % K2 TiF6 , te1 = 635◦ C, e2 : 21 mole % KF, 50 mole % KCl, 29 mole % K2 TiF6 , te2 = 620◦ C, e3 : 46 mole % KF, 44 mole % KCl; 10 mole % K2 TiF6 , te3 = 586◦ C. The phase diagram was calculated from the binary boundaries and from the quaternary mixtures measured, therefore the standard deviation of the fit is not given. The calculated phase diagram of this system is shown in Figure 3.53. The experimentally determined phase diagram measured by Chernov and Ermolenko (1973) is probably not quite correct because of little experimental data in the region of the presented peritectic point. Finally, for the excess molar Gibbs energy of mixing in the quaternary system KCl(1)–KF(2)–K2 TiF6 (3)–KBF4 (4), the following equation was obtained: GEquat =
4
GEj, ter + G1 x1 x2 x3 x43 + G2 x13 x2 x32 x42 + G3 x1 x2 x33 x4
(3.225)
j =1
The calculated coefficients of the excess molar Gibbs energy of mixing and the standard deviation of the measured and calculated temperature of primary crystallization for the quaternary system are listed in Table 3.7.
Phase Equilibria
217
K2TiF6
80
0 .8
75
70 65
0 .6
0
0 .8
0
0
0
0 .6 750
650
65 0
70 0
e1
0 .4
0 .4
e2 0 .2
0 .2
0.2
0.4
0 80
75
0 65
0
60 0
e3
70
0
750
KCl
0
0
65
70
0.6
0.8
KF
Figure 3.53. The calculated ternary phase diagram of the KCl−KF−K2 TiF6 system.
Three quaternary eutectic points were found in the quaternary phase diagram KF−KCl−KBF4 −K2 TiF6 . Their coordinates are: e1 : 2.8 mole % KF, 5.8 mole % KCl, 64.5 mole % KBF4 , 26.9 mole % K2 TiF6 , te1 = 413◦ C, e2 : 4.9 mole % KF, 13.7 mole % KCl, 73.9 mole % KBF4 , 7.5 mole % K2 TiF6 , te2 = 389◦ C,
Table 3.7. Coefficients Ci of the concentration dependence of the molar excess Gibbs energy of mixing and the standard deviation of the temperature of primary crystallization in the quaternary system KF−KCl−KBF4 −K2 TiF6 G1 (J · mol−1 ) G3 (J · mol−1 ) G2 (J · mol−1 )
2009367 ± 145628 249546 ± 20491 15367354 ± 1123575
80% K2TiF6 + 20% KBF4 800 0.6
750 700
0.6
0.4
0.4 0 70
65 0
0 60
0.2
0.2
0.4
0.6
75 0
70 0
60 0
600
0 65
80% KCl + 20% KBF4 0.2
65 0
60 0
80% KF + 20% KBF4
Figure 3.54. Cross section of the quaternary phase diagram of the KF−KCl−K2 TiF6 −KBF4 system at 20 mole % KBF4 .
60% K2TiF6 + 40% KBF4 700 65 0 60 0 0.4
0.4
60 0
0.2
0.2
550
0.2
0 50 50 5
0.4
0 60
0 65
70 0
500 500
60% KCl + 40% KBF4
0 55
60 0
60% KF + 40% KBF4
Figure 3.55. Cross section of the quaternary phase diagram of the KF−KCl−K2 TiF6 −KBF4 system at 40 mole % KBF4 .
Phase Equilibria
219
40% K2TiF6 + 60% KBF4 50 0 450 0.3
0 45
450
0.3
0.2
0.2
50 0
0.1
0.1
0 50
450 450
40% KCl + 60% KBF4
0.1
0 50
0 45
0.2
0.3
0 55
40% KF + 60% KBF4
Figure 3.56. Cross section of the quaternary phase diagram of the system KF−KCl−K2 TiF6 −KBF4 at 60 mole % KBF4 .
e3 : 14.0 mole % KF, 11.2 mole % KCl, 74.0 mole % KBF4 , 0.8 mole % K2 TiF6 , te2 = 336◦ C. The inaccuracy in the calculated phase diagram is ± 20.7◦ C. The cross sections of the quaternary phase diagram KF−KCl−KBF4 −K2 TiF6 with constant content of 20, 40, and 60 mole % KBF4 are shown in Figures 3.54–3.56.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Chapter 4
Enthalpy The heat measurement of various reactions is the first step in entering the realm of thermodynamics. Every study of any chemical process starts with the laboratory work connected with the first law of thermodynamics. On the other hand, when the thermodynamic considerations do not lead to a reasonable result, it is necessary to go back to the laboratory work. The basic unit of heat is joule (J). The older unit is calorie (cal). The relation between them is 1 J = 4.314 cal.
4.1. THERMODYNAMIC PRINCIPLES
The measurement of enthalpy, or heat, of different chemical processes is the objective of the first thermodynamic principle – the law of energy conservation. Every chemical process is connected with a certain amount of enthalpy, which the system receives from or delivers to the surroundings. Consider a closed system in which a chemical reaction takes place and that can exchange only heat with the surroundings. During the reaction, an amount of heat is liberated to the surroundings. We can define the function U – internal energy, as the energy, which the system has exchanged with the surroundings at transition from the start to the final state. The change in the internal energy for this process is given by the sum of the heat delivered to the system and the exerted work dU = dQ + dW
(4.1)
Equation (4.1) is the mathematical expression of the first law of thermodynamics. In the adiabatic process, the system does not exchange heat with the surroundings, thus dQ = 0
and
dU = dW
(4.2)
and for the adiabatic expansion, it holds dU = P dV 221
(4.3)
222
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
Similarly, when the system does not exchange work with the surroundings, then dW = 0
and
dU = dQ
(4.4)
In both the cases, the change in the internal energy depends only on the starting and final state of the system. From experience, we know that work can be changed to heat (e.g. heating of the liquid at mixing). There is thus an equivalence of work W and heat Q:W = J · Q, where J is a physical quantity called the mechanical equivalent of heat and its value and the dimensions are: J = 4.184 J/cal (J is the unit of heat and work called Joule). This is the principle of equivalency of heat and work. The first thermodynamic principle includes two basic laws enabling us to measure heat of any reaction at the optional temperature: the Hess’s and the Kirchoff’s laws. 4.1.1. Hess’ law
Most of the processes take place at constant pressure. In 1840, Hess found that the total heat, which the system releases or consumes at a chemical reaction, is equal regardless of whether the reaction runs in one step or stepwise. This is the principle of Hess’s law. The Hess’s law can be demonstrated on the oxidation of sulfur S + 32 O2 = SO3
QP = −395.68 kJ
S + O2 = SO2
QP = −296.75 kJ
SO2 + 12 O2 = SO3
QP = −98.93 kJ
Total
QP = −395.68 kJ
Now we introduce a new function, the enthalpy H = U + PV
(4.5)
Enthalpy is the function of state and its value depends only on the starting and final state of the system (QP = H2 – H1 ). In the case of a chemical reaction, its value depends only on the state of the chemical reactants and the reaction products. The molar heat capacities at constant volume and constant pressure are defined by the relations dQV dQP ∂U ∂H CV = ; CP = (4.6) = = dT ∂T V dT ∂T P and their units are [CV ] = [CP ] = J/(mol · K). The unit of specific capacity is [CV ] = [CP ] = J/(kg · K).
Enthalpy
223
Heat capacities depend on temperature and pressure, or on temperature and volume. For practical use, the temperature dependence of CP is given in tables in the form of empirical equations of the type CP = a + bT + cT 2 + dT 3 + · · ·
(4.7)
CP = a + bT + eT −2
(4.8)
These equations are valid in the temperature interval in which the heat capacity is measured. The total amount of heat needed for heating 1 mol of a substance is T2 QP =
CP dT
(4.9)
T1
4.1.2. Kirchoff’s law
Denoted by H1 , the heat of reaction, which the system exchanges with the surroundings at the temperature T1 , what is the heat of reaction, if the reaction takes place at temperature T1 ? In other words, we are looking for the dependence of enthalpy on temperature at constant pressure
∂H ∂T
= P
=
∂Hproducts
∂T
−
P
nj CP , products −
∂Hreactants
∂T
P
ni CP , reactants = CP
(4.10)
Equation (4.10) is the differential form of Kirchoff’s law. In the integral form, it becomes T2 H2 = H1 +
CP dT
(4.11)
T1
4.1.3. Enthalpy of reaction
If an exothermic reaction takes place at constant pressure adiabatically (the system does not exchange heat with the surroundings), the released heat causes an increase in temperature of the reaction products from temperature T1 to temperature T2 . Then it holds: HT +
T2 T1
CP + iCP , inert dT = 0
(4.12)
224
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
where i denotes the amount of inert substance, which does not participate directly in the reaction. Equation (4.12) enables us to calculate the final temperature T2 , of the reaction products at the end of the adiabatic reaction. Most of the chemical processes are accompanied by energetic changes. Since most reactions proceed at constant pressure, it is convenient to characterize the reaction by enthalpy change. The stoichiometric equation is thus completed by the respective enthalpy change, H
HT0 =
bB(S) + cC(g) = rR(1) + sS(S) nj Hj0 − ni Hi0 = rHR0 + sHS0 − bHB0 − cHC0
(4.13)
As it can be seen from the reaction (4.13), the enthalpy change depends also on the coefficients r, s, b, and c, thus on the given stoichiometry. For instance 1 H2(g) + O2(g) = H2 O(1) 2
(4.14)
0 = −285.24 kJ · mol−1 H298
The index 0 means that the starting as well as the final substances, are considered to be in a standard state. Since we do not know the absolute values of the enthalpies or the internal energies, we have chosen for practical purposes a certain exactly defined standard state, which we compare with the given quantity. The following standard states are mostly used. Gases: The gas in the ideal state at a pressure of 101 325 Pa and the given temperature (e.g. at 298.16 K, or at a temperature of the system). Liquids: The liquid at a pressure of 101 325 Pa and the given temperature. Solids: The most stable crystallographic modification at a pressure of 101 325 Pa and the given temperature. The enthalpy of elements is considered to be zero. A very important type of reaction enthalpy is the enthalpy of formation, which is the amount of heat the system obtains from the surroundings at the origination of 1 mol of the given compound directly from the elements in the standard state. There are different kinds of reaction enthalpy that we can observe in molten salt chemistry. Bonding energy is the mean value of the dissociation energy of the given bond (in a reaction where atoms of elements in the gaseous state originate from the molecules); Enthalpy of mixing is the enthalpy connected with the formation of 1 mol of solution of the given concentration from pure liquid components;
Enthalpy
225
Enthalpy of dissolution is the enthalpy connected with the dissolution of the given solution; it depends on the composition and can be calculated from the integral dissolution enthalpies of solutions in the final and starting states; Integral enthalpy of dissolution is the same as in the previous case, when one of the components is in the solid or gaseous state; it depends on the composition of the solution and for dilute solutions, it approaches a certain limiting value; Enthalpy of fusion is the heat connected with the transition of the compound from the solid to the liquid state; Enthalpy of polymorphic transformation is the heat connected with the transition of the compound from one crystallographic modification to the other. 4.1.4. Estimation of enthalpy of fusion
For thermodynamic calculations and analyses of phase diagrams of binary systems whose components form a binary compound, partially or totally dissociating at melting, it is necessary to know the enthalpies of fusion of the components of the binary compounds, and of both eutectic mixtures, as input quantities. When these data cannot be found in the literature, it is possible to estimate them using entropy or enthalpy balances. 4.1.4.1. Enthalpy of fusion of binary compounds (Aq Br )
The enthalpy of fusion of a binary compound Aq Br can be estimated in two quasi-similar ways. In principle, the calculation is based on the summation of entropies of substances at the temperature of fusion of the additive compound Aq Br . (a)
If the temperatures and enthalpies of fusion of both the substances A and B are known, the enthalpy of fusion of the additive compound Aq Br can be estimated from the entropies of fusion of both substances A and B according to the relation fus H (Aq Br ) = [qfus S(A) + rfus S(B)] · Tfus (Aq Br )
(b)
(4.15)
In this estimation, the entropy of mixing of both the compounds A and B to form the additive compound Aq Br is neglected. The entropy of the Aq Br melt at the temperature of fusion can be calculated either as the sum of the entropy of the crystalline compound Aq Br at the temperature of fusion and the entropy of fusion of Aq Br Smelt (Aq Br ) = Scr (Aq Br ) + Sfus (Aq Br )
(4.16)
or as the sum of the entropy of the mechanical mixture of the A and B melts in the corresponding stoichiometric ratio at the temperature of fusion, and the entropy of mixing
226
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
of this mixture at the same temperature Smelt (Aq Br ) = qSmelt (A) + rSmelt (B) + mix Smelt (Aq Br )
(4.17)
The entropy of mixing can be calculated from the relation mix Hmelt (Aq Br ) − R [q ln amelt (A) + r ln amelt (B)] Tfus (Aq Br )
mix Smelt (Aq Br ) =
(4.18)
The enthalpy of fusion of Aq Br can then be calculated according to the relation fus H (Aq Br )
Tfus (A) CP , cr (A) = q dT + fus S(A) + T 0
+r
Tfus (B)
CP , cr (B) dT + fus S(B) + T
CP , melt (A) dT T
Tfus (A)
Tfus (Aq Br )
0
+
Tfus (Aq Br )
CP , melt (B) dT T
Tfus (B)
mix Hmelt (Aq Br ,Tfus ) − R [q ln a(A, melt) + r ln a(B, melt)] Tfus (Aq Br )
Tfus (Aq Br )
− 0
CP , cr (Aq Br ) · Tfus (Aq Br ) T
(4.19)
In Eq. (4.19) a(X) = γ (X) · x(X), where a(X), γ (X), and x(X) are the activity, activity coefficient, and mole fraction of X (X ≡ A or B), respectively, and x(A) = q/(q + r), and x(B) = r/(q + r). Equation (4.19) is the complete entropy balance to form the molten additive compound Aq Br at the temperature of fusion from the crystalline substances A and B at the temperature of absolute zero. In Eq. (4.19), it is assumed that the heat capacity of the crystalline substances is known over the whole temperature range from absolute zero to the temperature of fusion. Several simplifications can, however, be made if some quantities are not available. If the heat capacity of the crystalline compound Aq Br is not known, it can be estimated in the first approximation using the Neumann–Kopp’s rule CP , cr (Aq Br ) = qCP , cr (A) + rCP , cr (B)
(4.20)
Enthalpy
227
Substituting Eq. (4.20) into Eq. (4.19), and using the relation fus CP (X) = CP ,melt (X) − CP ,cr (X)
(4.21)
Equation (4.19) is simplified to the form fus H (Aq Br ) = Tfus (Aq Br ) · q fus S(A) + + r fus S(B) +
Tfus (Aq Br )
Tfus (Aq Br )
Tfus (A)
fus CP (A) dT T
(4.22)
fus CP (B) dT T
Tfus (B)
mix Hmelt (Aq Br ) + − R q ln amelt (A) + r ln amelt (B) Tfus (Aq Br )
In systems with dystectic melting of the Aq Br compound, the activities and activity coefficients of constituents depend on the degree of dissociation, α, of the dissociation α reaction Aq Br −−→ qA + rB. At equilibrium, the constituents A, B, and Aq Br are present in the melt in the ratio αq:αr:(1 − α). 4.1.4.2. Enthalpy of fusion of an eutectic mixture
In the thermodynamic balance calculation as well as in the cryoscopic measurement in eutectic mixtures, the enthalpy of fusion of the eutectic mixture is necessary. In the literature, however, such data are very scarce and thus they must be estimated on the basis of the enthalpy or entropy balance. The enthalpy of fusion of the eutectic mixture can be calculated by evaluating the changes of the enthalpy or entropy accompanying the following processes: (a)
(b)
Starting from the solid state, the crystalline components A and A q Br or B and A q Br are first mixed to form the corresponding eutectic mixture at the eutectic temperature and then the solid mixture is melted, Starting from the solid state, the crystalline components A and A q Br or B and A q Br are first heated from the eutectic temperature to their melting points, consequently they are melted at this temperature, then cooled to the eutectic temperature, and finally, at this temperature, they are mixed to form the molten eutectic mixture.
228
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
The enthalpy or entropy balance (the latter being obtained using the LeChatelier– Shreder’s equation applied to both components) yields the following relation for the heat of fusion of the eutectic mixture fus H (eut) = y(eut, A or B)fus H (A or B) + y(eut, Aq Br ) fus H (Aq Br ) +
Tfus (eut)
fus CP (Aq Br )dT
Tfus (Aq Br )
+ mix Hmelt (eut)
(4.23)
where y(eut, Y) is the mole fraction of Y in the A–A q Br or B–A q Br system. If the enthalpy quantities of the A q Br compound are not known, the value of f us H(A q Br ) is estimated according to Eq. (4.19) (or Eq. (4.22)), and that of f us CP (A q Br ) is calculated using the Neumann–Kopp’s rule. 4.1.4.3. Applications
For most binary systems, the thermodynamic quantities in Eqs. (4.19) (or Eq. (4.22)) and (4.23) are not known. It is also, however, possible to use simplified forms of these relations to estimate the heats of fusion of binary compounds and binary eutectics. In the estimation of the heats of fusion of binary compounds, simplifying assumptions can be divided into three limiting groups: (a)
mix Hmelt (Aq Br ) = 0 Ex (A B ) = 0 mix Smelt q r
γ (X, melt) = 1 (ideal solutions) (b)
mix Hmelt (Aq Br ) = 0 Ex (A B ) = 0 mix Smelt q r
γ (X, melt) = 1 (regular solutions) (c)
mix Hmelt (Aq Br ) = 0 Ex (A B ) = 0 mix Smelt q r
γ (X, melt) = 1 or = 1
Enthalpy
229
In the first approximation, in order to estimate the heats of fusion of binary eutectics, the most simplified form of Eq. (4.23) can be used under the following conditions mix Hmelt (eut) = 0
(4.24)
fus CP (Aq Br ) = 0
(4.25)
Kosa et al. (1993) used Eqs. (4.22) and (4.23), simplified according to the conditions (a), (b), and (c), in the estimation of heats of fusion of the binary compounds Na3 FSO4 and K3 FSO4 as well as for the heats of fusion of the eutectic mixtures in the systems NaF–Na3 FSO4 , Na3 FSO4 –Na2 SO4 , KF–K3 FSO4 , and K3 FSO4 –K2 SO4 (q = r = 1). The temperatures and heats of fusion and the temperature dependencies of the heat capacities for the crystalline and liquid phases of NaF, KF, Na2 SO4 , and K2 SO4 were taken from Barin and Knacke (1973). mix Hmelt (AB), mix Hmelt (eut), and the activity coefficients of components were calculated using the data published by Hatem et al. (1982) assuming that they are independent of temperature. The coordinates of the individual eutectic points were taken from Kleppa and Julsrud (1980). The estimated values of the heats of fusion of Na3 FSO4 and K3 FSO4 were compared with those measured by Adamkovicˇ ová et al. (1991, 1992). The estimated values of the heat of fusion of binary compounds Na3 FSO4 and K3 FSO4 are given in Table 4.1 and those of the individual eutectic mixtures in the systems NaF–Na2 SO4 and KF–K2 SO4 in Table 4.2. The estimation errors for the heats of fusion of binary compounds are related to the experimental values. The estimation errors for the heats of fusion of the eutectic mixtures are related to the values calculated using
Table 4.1. Estimated heats of fusion of Na3 FSO4 and K3 FSO4 under different simplifying conditions mix H melt (AB) (kJ · mol−1 ) 1. (a) (b) (c) 2. (a) (b)
γ
E (AB) mix Smelt (J · mol−1 · K −1 )
estim (AB) mix Hmelt (kJ · mol−1 )
0 0 4.08
60 60 64
−13 −13 −7
0 0
75 75
−13 −13
(%)
Na3 FSO4 :1060 K, fus Hexp = (69 ± 4) kJ · mol−1 0 2.78 2.78
1 =1 γ NaF = 0.837 γ Na2 SO4 = 1.003
K3 FSO4 :1148 K, fus Hexp = (86 ± 3) kJ · mol−1 0 −2.58
1 = 1
230
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
Table 4.2. Estimated heats of fusion of eutectic mixtures in subsystems of systems NaF–Na2 SO4 and KF–K2 SO4 , for various values of input parameters fus H(AB) (kJ · mol−1 ) 1.
57 57 58 52 54
0 2 −9 −2
0.36 0 0 0 0
= 0 = 0 0 0 0
41 40 40 36 38
−2 −2 −12 −5
−0.61 0 0 0
= 0 = 0 0 0
39 39 40 38
0 3 −3
= 0 = 0 0 0
73 73 72 64
0 −1 −12
0.42 0 0 0 0
KF–K3 FSO4 :1051 K 86 86 86 75b
4.
= 0 = 0 0 0 0
(%)
Na3 FSO4 –Na2 SO4 :1021 K 69 69 69 60b 64b
3.
fus H estim (eut) (kJ · mol−1 )
NaF–Na3 FSO4 :1054 K 69 69 69 60b 64b
2.
fus Cp (Y)a (J · mol−1 · K −1 )
mix Hmelt (eut) (kJ · mol−1 )
K3 FSO4 –K2 SO4 :1143 K 86 86 86 75b
−0.18 0 0 0
= MF, M2 SO4 , or M3 FSO4 (fus CP (M3 FSO4 ) according to Neumann–Kopp’s rule). Estimated values (c.f. Table 4.1.).
aY b
experimentally determined heats of fusion of binary compounds and mixing enthalpies of the corresponding eutectic mixtures. As it follows from Table 4.1, the estimated heats of fusion of Na3 FSO4 and K3 FSO4 are lower than the measured values and the error in the estimation lies within the range 7–13%. This difference is probably due to the limited validity of the Neumann–Kopp’s rule, which in most cases, yield higher values of heat capacities of crystalline AB compounds in Eq. (4.19). The first three estimations of the heat of fusion of individual eutectic mixtures (see Table 4.2) indicate that the zero value of the enthalpy of mixing and the difference in the heat capacity at fusion have a very low influence on the estimated value of the enthalpy of fusion of the eutectic mixtures. The estimation error is in the range 0–12%.
Enthalpy
231
In general, the reliability of estimation of the enthalpy of fusion of the binary compounds and eutectic mixtures depends on • • •
the volume of input information, the choice of simplifying conditions, the difference between the melting points of the components and binary compounds and the eutectic temperatures.
The more the experimental knowledge on the system in question is available, the more reliable is the estimation of the sought quantity. On the other hand, it is sometimes better to omit a dubious value of the experimentally determined input quantity. 4.1.5. Enthalpy balance
The enthalpy balance of significant processes can be evaluated by solving the equation ψ(H, composition, T ) = 0
(4.26)
For this reason, the aim of a complete enthalpy analysis is to ascribe an unambiguous assignment of enthalpy values (measured or calculated) to the individual figurative points of the phase diagram of the system in question, i.e. to determine the shape of the function ψ. Since the absolute values of the internal energy cannot be determined, ψ could be established merely for the increase in enthalpy from some basic values corresponding to a certain reference state of the system. This could be, for instance the enthalpy value of the elementary particles, the combination of which yields the respective system at 298 K. If we designate the increase in enthalpy due to the combination of the building blocks into the given system as form H (Tref = 298 K), then the absolute enthalpy of the system at the experimental temperature Tm is given by the equation Habs (Tm ) =
Tm νi Hi (Tref ) + form H (Tref ) +
Csyst (T )dT
(4.27)
Tref
where Hi (Tref ) are the absolute enthalpies of particles constituting the system in its reference state, ν i are the stoichiometric coefficients in the equation according to which the system in question is formed from the elementary particles, and Csyst (T ) is the isobaric molar heat of the system. 4.2.
EXPERIMENTAL METHODS
The selection of a calorimetric method suitable for the measurement of heat effect of the investigated process is affected by several factors. Almost all of these factors influence the precision of the measurement. Such factors are for example, the rate of the measured
232
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
chemical reaction, physical properties of the sample, reaction of the sample with the crucible, temperature, etc. Since no criterion exists on the basis of which it would be possible to evaluate individual calorimetric methods, the aim of this chapter is to give an informative survey about them. However, the emphasis will be on calorimetry at medium and high temperatures. 4.2.1. Calorimetry
Calorimetry constitutes a powerful tool to investigate materials. It is a measurement technique that enables us to obtain values of the thermodynamic quantities of substances. The methods used for the characterization of thermodynamic properties of molten salts include temperature, enthalpy, and heat capacity measurements as mixing enthalpy and phase diagram determinations for their mixtures. 4.2.1.1. Principle of calorimetry
Calorimeter is a device for the measurement of heat evolved or consumed at the change of state of the system. This change can evoke change of the phase composition, temperature, volume, or chemical composition. The main components of calorimeter are schematically shown in Figure 4.1. If we denote the temperature of the calorimetric vessel or cover by Tc , the temperature of the calorimetric cover by Ts , then the amount of heat Q, which the calorimeter gains during a time unit from the investigated system at the given process, can be calculated from the calorimetric equation proposed by Tian (1923) dQ dTc (4.28) =W + K (Tc − Ts ) dt dt where W is the heat capacity of the calorimetric vessel and K is the coefficient of the heat transfer. The second member on the right-hand side of Eq. (4.28) represents the amount of heat transferred from the calorimetric vessel to the calorimetric cover. Based on Tian’s calorimetric equation, the calorimeters are conveniently classified according to the following scheme: 1. Isoperibolic calorimeter 2. Adiabatic calorimeter 3. Isothermal calorimeter 4. Calorimeter with constant heat flow
Ts = constant, Tc changes Tc = Ts , both temperatures change Tc = Ts = constant dQ/dt = constant, Tc = Ts = constant
There are also other criteria for the classification of calorimeters. They can also be divided according to the aim for which they are used, i.e. (a) (b)
calorimeters for reacting and non-reacting systems, low-, middle-, and high-temperature calorimeters,
Enthalpy
233
A B C D E
Figure 4.1. Main parts of the calorimeter. A – calorimetric vessel, B – calorimetric cover, C – thermometer, D – shield, E – stirrer.
(c) (d) (e)
simple and twin calorimeters, static and dynamic calorimeters, calorimeters and micro-calorimeters.
One of the characteristics for the isoperibolic calorimeter is to maintain the temperature of the cover at a constant value. The heat effect of the process taking place in the calorimeter is evaluated from the time course of the temperature curve. The typical course of this curve at an exothermic process is shown in Figure 4.2. The temperature difference between the calorimetric vessel and the calorimeter cover read-off from the temperature versus time curve has to be corrected for the heat introduced by stirring as well as for the heat exchange between the calorimetric vessel and the cover. Isoperibolic calorimeters also comprise calorimeters based on the measurement of heat flow, since they fulfill the condition Ts = constant, Tc changes. With these calorimeters, the temperature difference (Tc – Ts ) is not measured but directly the heat flow between the calorimetric vessel and the cover. Isoperibolic calorimeter.
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
Temperature
234
Ts
Time Figure 4.2. Temperature versus time plot of an exothermic process measured in an isoperibolic calorimeter.
With the adiabatic calorimeter, exchange of heat between the calorimetric vessel and the cover is suppressed. This happens so that the temperatures of the vessel and the cover are maintained at almost the same temperature. The condition (Tc – Ts ) = 0 can be attained at constant cover temperature by heating or cooling the calorimetric vessel using an internal heater or heat sink placed inside the calorimetric vessel. This “compensation” method is suitable for endothermic processes. For the adiabatic method, the characteristic feature is not only the equality of temperatures of the calorimetric vessel and of the cover, but also their changing value – the measurement proceeds at dynamic conditions, where the temperature of the calorimetric cover follows the temperature of the calorimetric vessel.
Adiabatic calorimeter.
With the isothermal calorimeter, the condition (Tc – Ts ) = constant, is attained by a total transfer of heat of the process taking place in the calorimetric vessel to the heat sink, where it will cause a partial phase transformation of the substance in the heat sink. The thermal effect of the investigated process is then determined from the volume change of the calorimetric substance. According to the phase transformation, isothermal calorimeters using transformation of the solid phase to the liquid or of the liquid to the vapor phase are known.
Isothermal calorimeter.
Enthalpy
235
Constant heat flow calorimeters are characterized by a constant temperature difference between the calorimetric vessel and the cover. To this group of calorimeters also belong the high-speed calorimeters for the measurement of heat capacities and the heats of modification transformation of substances, which are electrical conductors or semiconductors, where the heating is provided by their electrical resistance.
Calorimeters with constant heat flow.
4.2.1.2. Measurement of temperature
In order to calculate the heat evolved or absorbed in the calorimeter, it is necessary to measure (except for the isothermal calorimeter) the change if temperature of the calorimetric vessel and cover, as well as the heat capacity of the calorimeter. For calorimetry performed at medium and high temperatures, thermocouples are used most frequently. For example, they are made of iron and constantan for medium temperatures or of platinum, rhodium, and iridium for high temperatures. Very frequently, a number of thermocouples linked in series in order to obtain a voltage measurable with sufficient precision, are used. Presently, resistance thermometers are the most suitable temperature meters because of their high precision and stability. Mainly, they are used when resistance elements are wound directly on the surface of the calorimetric vessel and cover. Change of resistance with temperature can be in the current range of the temperature change of the calorimeter (less than 3 K) regarded as linear. Thermistors are resistance thermometers, where the temperature-sensible element is the semiconductor, and are made of a mixture of different metal oxides. The large resistance of the thermistor enables us to lower substantially its dimensions in comparison to the resistance thermometer. Thermistors are very sensible and give a fast response, which is very suitable for use in small calorimeters. Quartz crystals have been used as thermometers in calorimetry relatively recently. Their use is based on the fact that the resonance frequency of the quartz crystal cut in a certain orientation to the axis of its crystal structure depends on temperature, whereby the temperature dependence is high and almost linear. 4.2.1.3. Calibration of calorimeters
Calibration of the calorimeter means the measurement of heat capacity, and depends on the type of calorimeter, the purpose of its use, as well as on the kind of the thermal effect. Reaction calorimeters are frequently calibrated using a known heat of a chemical reaction. No standard reaction is internationally accepted. For the measurement of heat capacities, drop calorimeters are frequently used and the calibration is made using a substance, the temperature dependence of which on heat capacity is known. As substances, metals like Cu, Ag, Au, and aluminum oxide in the form of sapphire are used. Calorimeters
236
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
for the measurement of exothermic heat effects are calibrated most effectively directly using electrical energy. For calibration, the dependence of voltage on the calibration resistance, the current intensity, and the time have to be measured with utmost accuracy.
4.2.1.4. Calorimetry of reacting systems
Changes in enthalpy of chemical reactions are determined by calorimetry of reacting systems. The reaction heat is calculated from measured heats of formation, solution, and mixing, using the Hess’ law. One important factor, which influences the selection of the measurement method, is the duration of the chemical reaction investigated. For fast reactions, i.e. when the reaction is over at least within 30 min, the most suitable calorimeter is the isoperibolic calorimeter, since the heat effect can be determined quite precisely. The reaction proceeds in the calorimetric vessel, provided with a thermocouple, the drop-device of one component into the other, and the stirrer. The calorimetric cover is heated to a constant temperature. At the measurement of heats of mixing, respectively of heats of dissolution, both liquid components must be thoroughly heated before mixing to the same temperature before mixing. This can be made in such a way that the one component is placed just above the other one in a second crucible, which is then overturned or immersed and both components are mixed. On the other hand, for slow reactions, adiabatic and isothermal calorimeters are used and in the case of very small heat effects, heat-flow micro-calorimeters are suitable. Heat effects of thermodynamic processes lower than 1 J are advantageously measured by the micro-calorimeter proposed by Tian (1923) or its modifications. For temperature measurement of the calorimetric vessel and the cover, thermoelectric batteries of thermocouples are used. At exothermic processes, the electromotive force of one battery is proportional to the heat flow between the vessel and the cover. The second battery enables us to compensate the heat evolved in the calorimetric vessel using the Peltier’s effect. The endothermic heat effect is compensated using Joule heat. Calvet and Prat (1955, 1958) then improved the Tian’s calorimeter, introducing the differential method of measurement using two calorimetric cells, which enabled direct determination of the reaction heat. In the following list, the Calvet-type twin micro-calorimeter, working up to temperature of 1200 K, is shortly described. The micro-calorimeter consists of the following main parts: • • •
innerside of the external steel jacket is provided with a cylindrical furnace G; the calorimetric block, composed of three sections: top, middle, and bottom, aluminum oxide parts D, F, H; the alumina block has two holes, inside which are the thermopiles E, consisting of several hundreds of thermocouples and providing maximum thermal flux;
Enthalpy
• • •
237
each thermopile surrounds the calorimeter cell B, made of thin-walled alumina, 17 mm in diameter and 80 mm in height; the calorimetric block is surrounded by two mantles C, serving as thermal and electric shielding; the thermocouple A, placed in the center of the calorimeter measures the total temperature.
In order to provide good time and temperature stability of the calorimeter, the two thermopiles are connected in opposite direction, which eliminates most of the problems with external thermal disturbances. The computer, processing all the input temperature signals, controls the calorimeter. The isoperibolic Calvet’s twin micro-calorimeter is schematically shown in Figure 4.3. The most important conditions to be taken into account in the calorimetric measurement are the elimination of all the effects arising from the interaction between the material
A B C
D
E F G H
Figure 4.3. Schematic representation of the isoperibolic Calvet’s twin micro-calorimeter. A – thermocouple, B – calorimetric cell, C – thermal and electric shielding, D, F, H – three parts of the calorimetric block, E – thermopile, G – furnace.
238
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
and atmosphere (e.g. oxidation, water attack, etc.), sample and crucible, solvent–solute mixing effects, mixing of components with non-equal temperature, etc. All these effects can substantially lower the precision and accuracy of the calorimetric measurement.
4.2.1.5. Calorimetry of non-reacting systems
Calorimetry of non-reacting systems involves the measurement of heat capacity dependencies on temperature, which enables us to calculate the enthalpies of phase transformations. Based on the prevailing mode of the heat exchange between their individual parts, calorimeters for this purpose can be classified as low-, medium-, and high-temperature calorimeters. In the measurement of thermodynamic parameters of molten electrolytes, mostly the last two types of calorimeters are used. In the mid-temperature region for the measurement of heat capacities, the adiabatic calorimeters with direct heating of the sample and the drop calorimeters with heating of samples outside the calorimeter – in a furnace, are used. For measurement of reaction heat during heating of the sample, differential scanning calorimeters (DSC) are suitable. In the DSC calorimeter produced by the concern Perkin-Elmer, the temperature of the sample during heating is maintained based on temperature of the standards. In the temperature region of the reaction, additional heating of the sample, and respectively, of the standards, compensates the heat effect in order to attain a zero temperature difference between them. The reaction heat is then calculated from the delivered amount of energy. DSC calorimeters are also produced by the concerns Dupont, Setaram, and Rigaku Denki. In the high-temperature region, the main method of measurement is the drop calorimetry, where the sample is heated to the chosen temperature outside the calorimeter in a furnace and the heat capacity is calculated from the temperature dependence of the enthalpy changes measured after dropping the sample into the calorimeter. The application of this technique affects, however, the behavior of the sample heated in the furnace (decomposition, reaction with the crucible, etc. should be avoided) as well as at the cooling from the furnace temperature to that of the calorimeter. Sometimes the sample does not complete its phase transition at cooling (e.g. at the temperature of fusion, a part of the sample crystallizes while the other part becomes glassy). In such a case, the drop calorimeter must be supplemented by a solution calorimeter in order to get the enthalpy differences of all the samples to a defined reference state. For the drop technique, the isoperibolic calorimeters are most frequently used. The calorimetric device consists of two main parts: a furnace and a heated block. Between the calorimetric block and the furnace, there is a system of shields controlled by a mechanic, hydraulic or electromagnetic device, which prevents the heat transfer from the furnace to the calorimetric block. The calorimeter is made of copper with a cavity closed by a shield. A resistance thermometer wound on the block measures its temperature. Such a calorimeter can work up to 1700°C, especially when the furnace
Enthalpy
239
is heated using a Pt–Rh wire wound directly on the sintered alumina (Degussite) tube. However, for high-temperature measurements some problems arise, such as finding a suitable material for the sample carrier when very reactive samples are measured, the vapor expansion when a volatile sample is sealed in a Pt–Rh tube, etc.
4.2.1.6. Heat capacity measurement
An exhaustive survey of different experimental calorimetric techniques used for heat capacity determination was given very recently by Gaune-Escard (2002) and is excerpted here with her kind permission. The heat capacity at constant pressure, CP , is the derivative with respect to temperature of the enthalpy change induced by temperature variation (c.f. Eq. (4.6)). At high temperature, the methods used for CP determination are based on the simultaneous measurement of the enthalpy temperature variation versus time at a programmed rate of heating. In indirect methods, heat content measurements are performed over a large temperature range, for instance by drop calorimetry, and CP is derived by the analytic derivation of heat content plots versus temperature. In direct methods, the sample is heated over a large temperature range either continuously, or by successive small temperature increments with a linear dependence of temperature on time. Heat content determinations at high temperatures are generally easier than direct heat capacity measurements. They were widely used in early stages of measurement to obtain CP data of molten salts. The enthalpy increment of a substance between temperatures T1 and T2 , HT2 − HT1 (T2 > T1 ), is measured in general using a drop calorimeter. Two techniques are employed, depending on the way the measurements are carried out.
Measurement of the heat content.
(i)
(ii)
The sample is heated to a high temperature T2 and the actual heat content measurement is then performed in a calorimeter at the experimental temperature T1 , which is usually 25°C. The sample is at a low temperature T1 and the actual heat content measurement is performed in a high-temperature calorimeter at an experimental temperature T2 . This method is the so-called “inverse drop method”. It should be preferred in principle for melts, having the tendency to form glasses, since in this case, nonequilibrium final states could be obtained on cooling.
The dependence of the enthalpy increments HT − H298 on temperature in the temperature range 610–867°C for K3 NbF8 measured by Nerád et al. (2003) is shown in Figure 4.4. The enthalpy of fusion of K3 NbF8 was determined as the difference
240
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
360
Hrel (kJ.mol–1)
320
280
240
200
160 850
900
950
1000
1050
1100
1150
1200
T (K) Figure 4.4. Determination of the enthalpy of fusion of K3 NbF8 according to Nerád et al. (2003).
between extrapolated values of the enthalpy of melt and the enthalpy of crystalline phase at the temperature of fusion. The enthalpy of fusion fus H(K3 NbF8 ) = (60.5 ± 3.1) kJ . mol−1 at 777°C temperature has been evaluated. The following heat capacity values of the solid and liquid K3 NbF8 were obtained from the temperature dependence of HT − H298 :Cp (K3 NbF8 , sol) = (380.4 ± 18.8) J · mol−1 · K −1 for the crystalline phase and Cp (K3 NbF8 , liq) = (395.9 ± 31.9) J · mol−1 · K −1 for the melt. These values are valid in temperature intervals of the data used to evaluate the relative enthalpy equations. Similarly, Holm et al. (1973) measured the enthalpy increments HT − H298 of the congruently melting compounds of 2:1 and 1:1 alkali metal chlorides and magnesium chloride using a high-precision adiabatic drop calorimeter. From the results obtained at several experimental temperatures corresponding with solid and liquid samples, they determined the enthalpies of fusion of these compounds. Values for heat capacities for the molten salt mixtures were also derived. The heat capacities for the 2:1 and 1:1 compounds were estimated from those of the binary compounds according to the relation CP = nCP (AlkCl) + CP (MgCl2 ),
n = 1 or 2
(4.29)
The enthalpies of fusion of K2 TiF6 and K3 TiF7 were determined by Adamkovicˇ ová et al. (1995a,b) using the high-temperature calorimeter Setaram HTC 1800 K. The calorimeter was in the DSC mode at scanning rate of 1 K · min−1 . The sample was sealed in a platinum crucible and placed in the upper alumina crucible of the calorimetric cell.
Enthalpy
241
The lower alumina crucible of this cell contained a platinum crucible with small pieces of Al2 O3 as the reference substance. The data of the sample temperature and the difference between the crucibles were recorded. Na2 SO4 and KCl were used as calibration salts. The following enthalpies of fusion of K2 TiF6 and K3 TiF7 were determined: fus H (K 2 TiF6 ) = (21 ± 1) kJ · mol−1 at the temperature of fusion of 1172 K and fus H (K 3 TiF7 ) = (57 ± 2) kJ · mol−1 at the temperature of fusion of 1048 K. When a sample is subjected to a linear temperature increase, the rate of heat flow into the sample is proportional to its instantaneous heat capacity. Regarding this rate of heat flow as a function of temperature, and comparing it with that for a standard sample under the same conditions, we can obtain the heat capacity as a function of temperature. The procedure has been described in detail by O’Neil (1966). The principle of this method is shown schematically in Figure 4.5. Empty cells are placed in the sample and reference holders. An isothermal baseline is recorded at the lower temperature, and the temperature is then programmed to increase over a range. An isothermal baseline is then recorded at the higher temperature as indicated in the lower part of Figure 4.5. The two baselines are used to interpolate a baseline over the scanning section, as shown in the upper part of Figure 4.5. The procedure is repeated with a known amount of sample in the sample cell, and a dH/dT versus time trace is recorded. The deviation from the baseline is due to the absorption of heat by the sample. We may then write The ratio method.
dH dTP = mCP dT dt
(4.30)
where m is the mass of the sample, CP is the heat capacity, and dTP /dt is the programmed rate of temperature increase. While the above equation would yield values of CP directly, in order to minimize experimental errors, the procedure is repeated with a known amount of the standard sample, the heat capacity of which is known with a sufficient precision. Thus, only two ordinate deflections at the same temperature (Y and Y ) are required to yield a ratio of the CP values of the sample and the standard. This global method yields modestly accurate results. It consists of small successive temperature increments made during the linear increase in temperature with time (Figure 4.6). Each small temperature step is followed by an isothermal delay, which ensures thermal equilibration of the sample. From the difference of the thermal equilibrium aberration between the two cells during a heat pulse, the heat capacity of the sample placed in the working cell can be obtained as a function of temperature. The two crucibles contained in the cells are chosen in such a way so as to have as similar amounts as possible.
The “step” method.
242
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
dH/dT Standard material
CP C ′P
=
m′ ⋅ ′ Y m Y
Y'
Sample
Y Baseline time
T dTP /dt
time Figure 4.5. Heat capacity determination by the ratio method.
As the experimental parameters are time dependencies of enthalpy on temperature, the heat capacity can be written in the form dH dt P = dT dt P
CP =
dH dT
P
(4.31)
The temperature T varies linearly with time t, thus the integration between times t1 and t2 , which corresponds to temperatures T1 and T2 , yields an average heat capacity
Enthalpy
243
H, T
Sample Blank
Ti
Ti-1
Time Figure 4.6. Heat capacity measurement using the “step method.”
value C P in the small temperature interval T1 – T2 t2 t1
dH dt
dt = P
t1 CP t2
dT dt
T1
dt = P
T2
dH dT
T1 dt =
P
CP dt = CP (T2 − T1 ) (4.32) T2
This method thus provides nearly “true” heat capacity values of materials, except in the vicinity of phase transition temperatures, where the corresponding enthalpy increments superimpose those induced by temperature increments of the “step method” and invalidate the C P evaluation. During the experiment, the cells are maintained in a purified argon flow. In the temperature range 300–1100 K, CP measurements are carried out step by step, each heating step usually 5 K at the heating rate of 1.5 K/min, is followed by a constant temperature plateau for 400 s. The same experiment should be repeated with two empty cells identical to those used for the experimental sample run (blank experiment). The heat capacity of the sample is obtained at each temperature from the difference between the enthalpy increments obtained at each temperature step, in the two experimental series.
244
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
This method has been applied by Gaune-Escard et al. (1996a), Rycerz and GauneEscard (1999), and Gaune-Escard and Rycerz (1999) to several rare earth halides and their compounds with alkali metal halides. 4.2.1.7. Determination of enthalpy of mixing
A survey of different experimental techniques used in mixing calorimetry was given very recently by Gaune-Escard (2002). Calorimetry for the determination of mixing enthalpy can be divided into two groups: for temperatures up to 1200 K and above 1200 K. Several experimental techniques may be used for the determination of mixing enthalpies. The main problem met in all of them is the elimination of all side effects arising from: • • • • •
interaction between material and the atmosphere, like oxidation or moistening, interaction between the crucible and the melt, difficulties with the mixing of components with very different densities, stirring necessary to homogenize the mixture, mixing of components with different temperatures, etc.
The main techniques for calorimetry of liquid systems at high temperatures will be described in the following chapters. The simplest method to measure the heat at mixing a certain amount nA of a liquid salt A, considered as the solvent and kept at the experimental temperature TE , with the weighted amount nB of a solid salt B kept at the room temperature T0 , is the “drop method.” This method is very easy to operate and has been described already by Kubashewski and Evans (1964) and was applied to micro-calorimetry. The schematic description of this method is shown in Figure 4.7a. The measured enthalpy corresponds to the enthalpy of mixing according to the equation Mixing of liquids with solids.
nA A(l,TE ) + nB B(s,T0 ) = (nA + nB )AB(l,TE )
(4.33)
and includes not only the enthalpy of mixing, which should be determined, but also for the salt B, the heat capacity term of solid B in the temperature range T0 –Tfus , the enthalpy of fusion, and the heat capacity increment for liquid B from Tfus to TE . For many systems, however, there is the uncertainty in the sum of the enthalpy increments of the same order of magnitude as the enthalpy of mixing itself and can lead to unreliable results of the mixing enthalpy measurement. An improvement of the “drop method” was achieved by the “indirect drop method” (Figure 4.7b). In this variant of the drop method, the solid sample B is preheated and the mixing is carried out in two steps. First, the sample B is dropped into the
Enthalpy
245
1
1
2 2
3
3
4 5
(a)
4
6
5
7
(b)
Figure 4.7. The “drop” (a) and the “indirect drop” (b) methods. (a) 1 – drop tube; 2 – quartz liner; 3 – quartz or platinum crucible; 4 – molten salt; 5 – kaowool base; (b) 1 – drop tube; 2 – stopper; 3 – funnel; 4 – quartz liner; 5 – quartz or platinum crucible; 6 – molten salt; 7 – kaowool base.
lower end of the funnel provided with a stopper, in which it preheats. After thermal equilibration of sample B, the vertical shift of the drop tube enables the mixing of both salts. Vertically moving the drop tube in the molten mixture, or using an additional stirring device, ensures the homogeneity of the mixture. In order to enable to work in vacuum or in an inert atmosphere, the upper part of the system is provided with a set of taps and tightening rings, and the manipulation with the drop tube and with the stirrer is eventually operated electro-magnetically. The “indirect drop method” was used in various modifications, for example, in the determination of the enthalpy of mixing for the system K2 S2 O7 –K2 SO4 –V2 O5 by Fehrmann et al. (1986). The above described drop methods enable successive additions. The main advantage of the drop methods are the simplicity and readiness. This is in contrast with the more direct and accurate liquid–liquid mixing techniques, which enable measuring the mixing of liquid components directly and, in principle, with better accuracy. Mixing of two liquids. The “break-off bubble” method was developed by Gaune-Escard (1972) and has often been used in the mixing enthalpy measurements of molten salt mixtures. The schematic representation of this method is shown in Figure 4.8a. Inside
246
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
1 2 1
1
3
2
2
4
3
3 5
4
4
5
5 6 6
6
7
7 8
7 8 (a)
(b)
(c)
Figure 4.8. The “break-off bubble” (a), the “break-off ampoule” (b), and the “suspended cup” (c) methods. (a) 1 – drop tube; 2 – plug; 3 – quartz liner; 4 – quartz or platinum crucible; 5 – break-off ampoule with molten salt B; 6 – molten salt A; 7 – kaowool base. (b) 1 – manipulation tube; 2 – nichrome support; 3 – pyrex ampoule; 4 – pyrex crucible; 5 – silver tube; 6 – molten salt B; 7 – molten salt A; 8 – break-off tip; (c) 1 – crucible holder; 2 – quartz liner; 3 – silver crucible; 4 – silver tongs; 5 – silver cup; 6 – molten salt B; 7 – molten salt A; 8 – kaowool base.
the pyrex (or quartz) liner, a cylindrical crucible contains the liquid salt A, while salt B is placed in a spherical thin-walled pyrex or quartz ampoule. The ampoule has to be made of thin glass to enable being broken with a single strike. The mixing of the two liquids happens by crushing the bubble against the bottom of the crucible, or by striking the plug against the wall of the bubble. The heat effect arising from the ampoule break was checked by blank experiments and has been found to be very small and reproducible. The break-off bubble method was used recently in the determination of the enthalpy of mixing in the alkali halide – rare earth halide systems by Gaune-Escard et al. (1996). The last method is similar in its principle to that developed by Kleppa (1960) in his pioneering and extensive calorimetric investigation of molten salts. In his arrangement, salt B was placed in an ampoule made of a pyrex tube fitted with a break-off tip (Figure 4.8b). In comparison with the break-off bubble method, a slight shift in composition due to the effect of surface tension and the wetting of the crucible and the ampoule
Enthalpy
247
can happen. In the previous break-off bubble method, the homogeneity of the sample would be preserved, as the melt is contained in a single vessel instead of two. In the case, when the melt reacts with the glass, as for instance the molten alkali metal hydroxides, a “suspended cup” method (Figure 4.8c) was developed by Aghai-Khafri et al. (1976). Inside the pyrex or quartz liner, a cylindrical silver crucible contained the liquid hydroxide B while the salt or hydroxide A is contained in a small silver cup. This silver cup is held by tongs and could be released by external manipulation of the tongs. The mixing of the two liquids occurs by dropping the silver cup into the crucible. However, the thermal effect connected with the drop of the cup into the liquid A is very small and reproducible. All the mixing techniques described are only a few of those used in practice. The choice of a suitable mixing technique used for a particular system depends on the physicochemical properties of the melts under investigation. Most experimental constraints might be met when working with volatile substances like AlCl3 . In the investigation of the ternary system KCl–AlCl3 –AlCl3 NH3 performed by Hatem et al. (1988), both reactants, the liquid KCl−AlCl3 mixture and the liquid AlCl3 NH3 , were contained in closed pyrex ampoules, both kept inside the calorimeter. The inner ampoule containing AlCl3 NH3 had a very thin base, which could easily be broken by the sharp edge of the outer ampoule. Rather sophisticated calorimetric devices were used and great care was taken in order to obtain reliable enthalpy of mixing data of other very reactive melts. For instance, in the investigation of zinc halide-containing melts made by Papatheodorou and Kleppa (1973), a novel experimental arrangement and procedure was adopted in order to control the mass loss due to evaporation of the zinc halides. Inside the fused silica liner, a cylindrical crucible contained the low vapor pressure salt in the liquid state. Zinc halides were contained in an evacuated “double break-off” fused silica bubble. The mixing of the two liquids starts by crushing the break-off tip against the bottom of the crucible. Due to a slightly lower pressure in the bubble, a part of the melt sucks up into the bulb and mixes with the zinc halide. Crushing of the upper break-off tip then finishes the mixing, when the zinc halide is released into the crucible and mixes with the remainder of the melt. In some cases, a slight endothermic baseline shift might be observed after mixing. This may happen every time a volatile sample is investigated due to the mass loss of the sample. In order to correct for this baseline shift, a series of blank experiments should be performed. The heat of solution of lead oxide in oxide melts was investigated by Holm and Kleppa (1967) and Østvold and Kleppa (1969) using the following experimental arrangement. Approximately 60 g of oxide melt was contained in an Au20Pd crucible with 17 mm diameter and 75 mm height. The lead oxide, which should be dissolved in the melt of another oxide, was placed in a very shallow platinum cup with about a 10 mm diameter. This cup was attached by means of three platinum wires to a fused silica tube, which could
248
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
be manipulated from the outer side of the furnace. The solution reaction was initiated by lowering the platinum cup into the melt. Stirring was provided either by means of a platinum plunger or simply by moving the platinum cup up and down in the Au20Pd crucible. Corrections were made for the endothermic heat associated with the mass displacement due to the vertical temperature gradient of the calorimeter and the non-homogeneity of the melt. However, the additional heat due to stirring, represented 10–50% of the total heat of reaction, while without stirring, the correction was only 10–20%. Unlike most other salts, measurement of mixing enthalpies of molten alkali metal carbonates, due to their corrosive nature, cannot be performed in fused silica containers and be mixed by the usual “break-off” technique. Andersen and Kleppa (1976) showed that the Au20Pd alloy was corroded only negligibly by alkali metal carbonate melts kept under a relatively high CO2 pressure. The experimental arrangement included plunger as well as a dipper crucible that could be manipulated from the outer side of the furnace. The mass loss of the most volatile carbonate, Rb2 CO3 , was about 0.3%. However, in spite of the relatively small vaporization losses, the attack of vapors on the fused silica liner was considerable and the lower part of the device had to be discarded after 10–15 experiments. For temperatures above 1200 K, different calorimeters should be used because of construction material restrictions. Due to considerable difficulties with the “homemade” calorimeters, in the majority of cases, commercial equipment is used. One of the most widespread devices working up to 1800 K is the calorimeter Setaram. The whole calorimetric assembly comprise the following parts. The vertical cylindrical furnace consists of a graphite resistor surrounding a gas-tight alumina tube, with an inner diameter of 23 mm and a length of 600 mm, in which the calorimetric detector is placed and the experimental chamber, localized. The geometry of the resistor provides a 140-mm long constant temperature zone in the central part of the tube. The furnace has an external water-cooled jacket and can be heated up to about 2000°C. The furnace is supplied with low-voltage current. Its temperature is controlled by an electronic system monitored by a Pt–Pt13Rh thermocouple within the central part of the furnace. A set of valves and flow meters enables evacuation of the furnace and the experimental chamber, and either the gas flow or maintenance under pressure of the purified gas. The samples are introduced into the calorimeter and maintained under experimental conditions at ambient temperatures after preliminary evacuation, using a very simple charging device, similar to that previously designed for Calvet’s calorimeters. The features of the calorimetric detector and of the mixing and stirring systems, located within the experimental chamber, vary according to the nature of the experiment. The acquisition and processing of the experimental data is operated by a computer. Mixing calorimetry above 1200 K.
Enthalpy
249
F
D Cw B A Cr
E
Figure 4.9. Vertical section of the high-temperature calorimeter Setaram. See text for description.
Figure 4.9 shows the vertical section of the transducer high-temperature calorimeter Setaram. The calorimetric transducer is made up of a calorimetric transducer circuit A and a temperature-sensing thermocouple B held by alumina mountings. The transducer consist from set of thermocouples supported by capillary tubes forming a differential network and whose junctions are arranged according to two superimposed sets of ring gear housed in a cylindrical covering D. Cw and Cr are the working and reference crucibles, respectively, made of sintered alumina. The reference crucible Cr is slid into the bottom ring gear and held in place by a transverse bar E on which it rests and is supported by its ends on the wall of the covering. The covering is held by three parallel suspension wires F sealed into its wall and fitted with longitudinal canals incasing the conductors running to the calorimetric transducer and the temperature-sensing thermocouple. The tube D holds the ring supporting the thermocouples in the proper place and constitutes a thermal screen of the assembly. The whole assembly is suspended in the central
250
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
part of the furnace by three hollow alumina tubes H, which protect the junction wires of the thermocouples. A systematic study showed that to obtain reproducible and accurate values of the thermal changes of mixing, this kind of calorimeter is characterized by the following two conditions: (i) (ii)
high sensitivity of the detector, appropriate integration of the thermal flux produced within the working cell by the heat change upon mixing.
The former condition is best met using a sufficient number of thermocouples and the latter, by having a regular arrangement of the thermopile junctions around the working crucible. Therefore in their Setaram calorimeter, Gaune-Escard and Bros (1974) and Hatem et al. (1981) found it necessary to make some modifications of the commercial design. Several calorimetric detectors were built in accordance with these conditions. In one detector version, the 16 upper thermocouple junctions were located alternately on two horizontal levels about 10 mm apart. For technical reasons, and since no thermal excursion arises within the reference crucible Cr , the lower set of junctions were kept on the same horizontal level. Finally, in a number of later investigations another kind of detector having more thermocouples was permanently used. Due to easy operation, the “drop method” is usually used to obtain the enthalpy of formation of a liquid mixture A–B. However, it should be emphasized once more that the enthalpy change of the liquid–liquid mixing is calculated as the difference between two rather large quantities, thus introducing large errors. The situation could be illustrated by the molten mixture NaF–K2 SO4 , which was investigated by Hatem and Gaune-Escard (1979). The enthalpy of mixing was found to be 6.7 kJ/mol at x NaF = 0.6, and the correction term was about 250 kJ/mol. In order to improve the results, it is therefore necessary to eliminate or substantially decrease the enthalpy increment term arising from the enthalpy of fusion of the solid sample B added to the liquid bath A and its heat capacity term. This can be achieved if the sample B is introduced into the liquid bath A at a temperature equal or as close as possible to the experimental temperature TE . Also the “indirect drop method” was adapted in order to bring nearer the temperatures of both the salts. A small alumina sphere of 6 mm in diameter, closing the aperture of the funnel, attached on the upper side, an manipulation alumina rod and on the bottom, a thin alumina stirrer, was added. In the alumina rod, a Pt6Rh–Pt30Rh thermocouple is located, measuring the temperature of the solid salt B. When sample B reaches thermal equilibrium, the funnel is opened by lifting the alumina rod, enabling the mixing of both salts. The thin alumina stirrer is used to homogenize the mixture by moving up and down.
Methods of mixing.
Enthalpy
251
Many factors are to be taken into account to obtain reliable results. The powdered solid salt B may sinter before opening the funnel, causing incomplete mixing. The salt B should have suitable physico-chemical properties, such as vapor pressure, chemical reactivity with respect to the funnel and the container, etc., to remain in the funnel during thermal stabilization and to fall down completely when the funnel is open. In some experiments, a large difference between the densities of the liquids A and B does not enable to obtain a homogeneous mixture. In these cases, the addition of a stirring device is necessary. A thin alumina rod sufficiently long to immerse into the liquid is added and acts as stirrer. Such a device was used by Hatem and Gaune-Escard (1980) to investigate the system LiF–K2 SO4 . A number of ionic mixtures were investigated in this way over a temperature range between 1000 and 1500°C, such as the systems NaF–Na2 SO4 and KF–K2 SO4 (Hatem et al., 1982), NaF–Rb2 SO4 (Hatem and Gaune-Escard, 1984), ZrF4 –MF (M = Li, Na, K, Rb) (Hatem et al., 1989), AlF3 -based mixtures (Peretz et al., 1995), KF–NdF3 (Hatem and Gaune-Escard, 1993), etc. In the course of a critical analysis by Hayer et al. (1993) of all the thermodynamic data, it was shown that the difference between two sets of measurements at 1000 K obtained either with a Calvet’s micro-calorimeter or with the apparatus described above is less than 2%. At higher temperatures, such a comparison was not possible due to the scarce data available. An automatic sample charger was also designed and developed that enables a completely automated operation at very high temperatures. It allows a complete experimental run with successive addition of 30 samples. Each individual mixing experiment is computer operated and calorimetric thermograms are also automatically integrated. It should be, however, noted that no apparatus or method can be considered universal in the domain of high-temperature mixing calorimetry, and adaptations should always be made in accordance with the particular requirements of the system under investigation. 4.2.1.8. Double calorimetry of glass-forming systems
Owing to their polymeric nature, many silicate compounds and systems tend to form glasses. When cooling rapidly from the molten state, a part of the sample crystallizes, while the other part remains glassy. This is the main disadvantage while measuring their heat capacity, heat content, enthalpy of fusion, and mixing. Direct measurement of enthalpy changes taking place during physico-chemical processes in silicate systems is intrinsically inaccurate mainly because of the following reasons: (a) (b)
processes in question are frequently very slow, thermal losses due to the dissipation of heat into environment of the calorimeter during high-temperature processes in silicate systems are difficult to calculate or compensate.
252
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
However, the enthalpy balance of processes can be evaluated by solving Eqs. (4.26) and (4.27). The enthalpy balance is related to the heating and to the general reaction taking place in the system. In both cases, the initial and the final states of the system comprise the same number of elementary particles, hence the first term on the right-hand side of Eq. (4.27) is always canceled. When calculating the changes of enthalpy in the two types of processes, one can thus operate with relative enthalpy values, Hrel (Tm ) Tm Hrel (Tm ) = Hform (Tref ) +
Csyst (T )dT
(4.34)
Tref
The solution of the sample in a 2:1 mixture of concentrated hydrofluoric and nitric acids at Tref = 298 K was chosen as the reference state. The relative enthalpy, Hrel (Tm ), was measured by indirect method of double calorimetry. This procedure enables us to determine Hrel (Tm ) as the sum of enthalpy increase measured during the cooling of the system in a drop calorimeter (cool H) and during its dissolution in a solution calorimeter (sol H). Equation (4.34) can thus be written in the form Hrel = −(cool H + sol H )
(4.35)
The Hrel values determined by double calorimetry are independent of the magnitude of both cool H and sol H. In silicate systems, they often vary when one composition is repeatedly measured. This may happen because the value of cool H (and hence that of sol H also) depends on the non-reproducible state of the sample after cooling down in the drop calorimeter. The samples may often consist of a mixture of glass and crystalline phases including not only the components of the system but also the products of their decomposition. When a reaction takes place in the system, the respective reaction enthalpy is given by the following relationship when using the method of double calorimetry cool Hstart + sol Hstart − cool Hprod − sol Hprod (4.36) react H = = Hrel, prod − Hrel, start Utilization of the dissolution enthalpies in Eq. (4.36) is justified when the individual phases are adequately diluted in an amount of the chosen solvent. With regard to the error in the solution calorimetry, the enthalpy of mixing and the enthalpy of dissolution could be neglected only when the amount of the solvent in the solution formed has not changed. The isobaric enthalpy analysis of silicate systems was developed by Proks et al. (1977a) and Eliášová et al. (1978). These authors used two calorimeters to measure the enthalpy
Enthalpy
253
difference between the molten sample at high temperature and its dilute solution at 298 K, which was the chosen reference state. Samples of approximately 1 g weight are heated in sealed cylindrical Pt10Rh crucibles to the chosen temperature in the drop calorimetric furnace. The drop calorimeter was described in detail by Proks et al. (1977b). After equilibrating the temperature and keeping it for one hour, the crucible was dropped into the calorimetric block kept at 298 K. The temperature of the sample in the furnace was measured by a Pt30Rh–Pt6Rh thermocouple with an accuracy of ± 3 K. Increase in temperature in the calorimetric block after the sample was dropped into it was measured by means of a sensitive resistance bridge. The value of the enthalpy increase, cool H, was obtained by evaluating the total heat dissipation from the block to the surroundings. The total error of measurement in the drop calorimeter did not exceed 5 J at enthalpies measured up to 3000 J. After measurement in the drop calorimeter, the crucible with the sample was opened by carefully cutting off the lid. The entire sample was removed, ground to the particle size less than 0.04 mm and homogenized. A part of the sample was subjected to X-ray powder diffraction and IR spectroscopic analyses. The heat of solution, sol H, of the sample was then measured in the solution calorimeter, described in detail by Proks et al. (1967). Approximately 0.05 g of sample was dissolved in 100 ml of the 2:1 mixture of concentrated hydrofluoric and nitric acids. The measurement of the heat of dissolution was repeated 3 times on an average. The sum of the two values, the enthalpy of cooling, cool H, and the enthalpy of dissolution, sol H, is the so-called relative enthalpy, Hrel , of the sample. From the temperature dependence of the relative enthalpy, the heat capacity as well as all the following enthalpy, changes could be calculated. By this method, the heat of fusion of Akermanite, Ca2 MgSi2 O7 , (Proks et al., 1977a), the enthalpy analysis of the system 2CaO · MgO · 2SiO3 –CaO · MgO · 2SiO2 (Eliášová et al., 1978), the heat of fusion of Wollastonite, CaSiO3 (Adamkovicˇ ová et al., 1980), the heat of incongruent decomposition of Merwinite, 3CaO · MgO · 2SiO2 (Kosa et al., 1981), the enthalpy of incongruent decomposition of tricalcium aluminate, 3CaO · Al2 O3 (Adamkovicˇ ová et al., 1985), the enthalpy of crystallization of the eutectic melt in the system 2CaO · Al2 O3 · SiO2 –CaO · Al2 O3 · 2SiO2 (Kosa et al., 1987), the heat of fusion of Gehlenite, 2CaO · Al2 O3 · SiO2 (Žigo et al., 1987), etc., were determined for instance.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Chapter 5
Density 5.1. THEORETICAL BACKGROUND
Density is defined as the mass per unit volume at constant temperature and pressure ρ=
m V
(5.1)
The unit of density is kg · m−3 . In practice, smaller units, e.g. (g · cm−3 ), are frequently used. The reciprocal value of density is the specific volume. The density of melts depends on the temperature and pressure. The dependence on temperature is expressed by the coefficient of thermal expansion 1 α= V
∂V ∂T
(5.2) P
where V is the volume of the system. The density dependence on temperature at constant pressure is usually expressed in empirical equations of the type ρ = ρ0 (1 + at + bt 2 + · · · )
(5.3)
For simple melts in which the composition does not change with temperature, density is a linear function of temperature.
5.1.1. Molar volume
The molar volume can be calculated from density according to the relation V =
M ρ
(5.4)
When the composition of the melt does not depend on temperature, the molar volume is, like the density, a linear function of temperature V = V0 (1 + αt) 255
(5.5)
256
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
For the n-component mixture Eq. (5.1) looks as follows n
xi M i
i=2
V =
(5.6)
ρexp
In Section 3.1.3.1., it was shown that the ideal mixing of components is connected neither with volume contraction nor with volume dilatation. However, in real binary mixtures, positive as well as negative deviations from the ideal behavior can be observed. The dependence of molar volume on composition is usually expressed in the polynomial form V =
n
ai x2i
(5.7)
i=0
where ai are the experimental polynomial coefficients. 5.1.2. Partial molar volume
Let us consider a two-component melt. The volume of this system can be expressed as the function of temperature, pressure, and the amount of substances of both the components dV =
∂V ∂T
dT + P , n1 , n2
∂V ∂P
dP + T , n1 , n2
∂V ∂n1
dn1 +
T , P , n1
∂V ∂n2
dn2 T , P , n2
(5.8) The partial derivatives
∂V ∂n1 T , P , n 2
and
∂V ∂n2 T , P , n 1
are the partial molar volumes of
the components and are denoted as V 1 and V 2 . In general, the partial molar volume of the ith component is defined by the relation Vi =
∂V ∂ni
(5.9) T , P , nj =i
The partial molar volume depends on temperature, pressure, and the composition of the system. The physical sense of the partial molar volume is the volume increase caused by the addition of 1 mol of component to an amount of solution such that the composition of the solution at constant temperature and pressure does not change. The partial molar volume can thus attain a negative value also.
Density
257
5.1.3. Application to binary and ternary systems 5.1.3.1. Binary systems
The evaluation of partial molar volumes from the experimentally determined dependency of the molar volume on composition in binary systems is made generally using the method of intercepts. Let us consider a binary melt at constant temperature and pressure in which just one mole of the mixture is present. Then it holds dV = V 1 dx1 + V 2 dx2 where V is the molar volume of the mixture. As it holds that dx1 = −dx2 , then ∂V = V2 −V1 ∂x2 T , P
(5.10)
(5.11)
For the system it also holds that
V = x1 V 1 + x2 V 2 = V 1 + x2 V 2 − V 1
(5.12)
Inserting Eq. (5.11) into Eq. (5.12) we get V 1 = V − x2
∂V ∂x2
(5.13) T,P
and similarly also V 2 = V + x1
∂V ∂x2
(5.14) T,P
Thus, if the dependency of the molar volume of the system on composition is known from the density measurement, it is possible to calculate the partial molar volumes of both the components according to Eqs. (5.13) and (5.14). In the graphic representation they are the intercepts, which for a given composition, cut the tangent of the molar volume versus composition plot on the y axes at x2 = 0 and x2 = 1. 5.1.3.2. Ternary systems
The partial molar volume of a component in the ternary system can be calculated in sections with constant ratio of two components. For instance, in the system A–B–C the partial molar volume of the component A can be calculated according to a relation similar to Eq. (5.14). Since (1 – xA ) = xB + xC , Eq. (5.14) transforms to ∂V V A = V + (xB + xC ) (5.15) ∂xA T , P
258
Physico-chemical Analysis of Molten Electrolytes
For the section xB /xC = N Eq. (5.15) can be written in the form
VA
∂V = V + xC (N + 1) ∂xA
(5.16) T,P
Similar equations can be derived also for component B and C. For excess molar volume in real ternary systems, the validity of the Redlich– Kister’s (1948) general equation can be assumed. For the description of the composition dependency on the molar volume, the following equation is used V =
3 i=1
x i Vi +
3 i, j =1 i=j
xi xj
n n=0
Anij xjn +
m
Bm x1a x2b x3c
(5.17)
a, b, c=1
The first term represents the additive (ideal) behavior, the second the binary interactions, and the third the interactions of all the three components. The coefficients of the regression equation (5.17) are calculated using the multiple linear regression analysis method. Omitting the statistically non-important terms on the chosen confidence level and minimizing the number of relevant terms a solution is obtained, which describes the concentration dependence of the investigated property with a standard deviation of the fit, in the same order as the experimental error. For statistically important binary and ternary interactions, appropriate chemical reactions are sought. Their thermodynamic probability is checked calculating their standard reaction Gibbs energies. The reaction products are identified using the X-ray phase analysis and IR spectroscopy of the quenched melts. Again it is assumed that the composition at high temperature is at least qualitatively conserved after quenching. In the following, two examples are presented. They differ in the complexity of available experimental data, as in the second example, only a part of the ternary system was experimentally accessible. The first example presents analysis of the volume properties of the ternary system, which is experimentally accessible through the whole concentration triangle. The density of melts of the system LiF−NaF−K2 NbF7 was measured using the Archimedean method by Chrenková et al. (2005). The values of the constants a and b of the temperature dependence on density, ρ = a − bt, obtained using the linear regression analysis together with the standard deviations of approximation are given in Table 5.1. In the first step, we examine the behavior of K2 NbF7 in its infinitely diluted solution in LiF and NaF. This requires a calculation of the concentration dependency of the partial molar volume of K2 NbF7 in the systems LiF–K2 NbF7 and NaF–K2 NbF7 . Example 1.
Density
259
Table 5.1. Coefficients a and b of the temperature dependency of density, ρ = a − bt, and the standard deviations of approximation of the investigated melts of the system LiF−KF−K2 NbF7
xLiF xNaF xK2 NbF7 a g · cm−3 sd × 104 g · cm−3 b × 104 g · cm−3 · ◦ C t (◦ C) 1.000 0.000 0.000
0.000 1.000 0.000
0.000 0.000 1.000
2.1968 2.5814 3.2791
4.6247 6.360 10.928
0.4 0.5 1.2
860−960 1010−1100 750−860
0.900 0.800 0.700 0.600 0.500 0.400 0.300 0.200 0.100
0.100 0.200 0.300 0.400 0.500 0.600 0.700 0.800 0.900
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000
2.2598 2.2857 2.3268 2.3810 2.4037 2.4269 2.4301 2.5116 2.7061
5.102 5.118 5.277 5.552 5.596 5.575 5.434 6.043 7.789
– – – – – – – – –
850−1050 850−1050 850−10