P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 December 12, 2006
15:29
Springer Series in
OPTICAL SCIENCES
115
founded by H.K.V. Lotsch
Editor-in-Chief: W.T. Rhodes, Atlanta Editorial Board: A. Adibi, Atlanta T. Asakura, Sapporo T.W. H¨ansch, Garching T. Kamiya, Tokyo F. Krausz, Garching B. Monemar, Link¨oping H. Venghaus, Berlin H. Weber, Berlin H. Weinfurter, M¨unchen
i
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 December 14, 2006
17:38
Springer Series in
OPTICAL SCIENCES The Springer Series in Optical Sciences, under the leadership of Editor-in-Chief William T. Rhodes, Georgia Institute of Technology, USA, provides an expanding selection of research monographs in all major areas of optics: laser and quantum optics, ultrafast phenomena, optical spectroscopy techniques, optoelectronics, quantum information, information optics, applied laser technology, industrial applications, and other topics of contemporary Interest. With this broad coverage of topics, the series is of use to all research scientists and engineers who need up-to-date reference books. The editors encourage prospective authors to correspond with them in advance of submitting a manuscript. Submission of manuscripts should be made to the Editor-in-Chief or one of the Editors. See also http://springeronline.com/series/624
Editor-in-Chief William T. Rhodes Georgia Institute of Technology School of Electrical and Computer Engineering Atlanta, GA 30332-0250, USA E-mail:
[email protected]
Editoral Board Ali Adibi
Bo Monemar
School of Electrical and Computer Engineering Van Leer Electrical Engineering Building Georgia Institute of Technology 777 Atlantic Drive NW Atlanta, GA 30332-0250
[email protected]
Department of Physics and Measurement Technology Materials Science Division Link¨oping University 58183 Link¨oping, Sweden E-mail:
[email protected]
Toshimitsu Asakura
Herbert Venghaus
Hokkai-Gakuen University Faculty of Engineering 1-1, Minami-26, Nishi 11, Chuo-ku Sapporo, Hokkaido 064-0926, Japan E-mail:
[email protected]
Heinrich-Hertz-Institut f¨ur Nachrichtentechnik Berlin GmbH Einsteinufer 37 10587 Berlin, Germany E-mail:
[email protected]
Theodor W. H¨ansch
Horst Weber
Max-planck-Institut f¨ur Quantenoptik Hans-Kopfemann-Strasse 1 85748 Garching, Germany Email:
[email protected]
Technische Universit¨at Berlin Optisches Institut Strasse des 17. Juni 135 10623 Berlin Germany E-mail:
[email protected]
Takeshi Kamiya
Harald Weinfurter
Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports Science and Technology National Institute for Academic Degrees 3-29-1 Otsuka, Bunkyo-ku Tokyo 112-0012, Japan E-mail:
[email protected]
Ludwig-Maximilians-Universit¨at M¨unchen Sektion Physik Schellingstrasse 4/III 80799 M¨unchen, Germany E-mail:
[email protected]
Ferenc Krausz Max-planck-Institut f¨ur Quantenoptik Hans-Kopfemann-Strasse 1 85748 Garching, Germany E-mail:
[email protected]
ii
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
Peter G¨unter
7:40
Jean-Pierre Huignard
(Editors)
Photorefractive Materials and Their Applications 3 Applications With 316 Illustrations
iii
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
7:40
Peter G¨unter Institute of Quantum Electronics Nonlinear Optics Laboratory Swiss Federal Institute of Technology ETH Hoenggerberg HPF E 8 CH-8093 Zurich Switzerland Email:
[email protected]
Jean-Pierre Huignard Thales Research and Technology France RD 128 91767 Palaiseau Cedex France Email:
[email protected]
With 316 figures. Library of Congress Control Number: 2006925859 ISBN-10: 0-387-34443-8 ISBN-13: 978-0387-34443-0
e-ISBN 0-387-34728-3
C
Printed on acid-free paper.
2007 Springer Science+Business Media, LLC All rights reserved. This work may not be translated or copied in whole or in part without the written permission of the publisher (Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, 233 Spring Street, New York, NY 10013, USA), except for brief excerpts in connection with reviews or scholarly analysis. Use in connection with any form of information storage and retrieval, electronic adaptation, computer software, or by similar or dissimilar methodology now known or hereafter developed is forbidden. The use in this publication of trade names, trademarks, service marks, and similar terms, even if they are not identified as such, is not to be taken as an expression of opinion as to whether or not they are subject to proprietary rights. 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 springer.com
iv
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
7:40
Preface
This is the third and final volume of a three-volume series devoted to photorefractive effects, photorefractive materials, and their applications. Since the publication of our first two Springer books on “Photorefractive Materials and Their Applications” (Topics in Applied Physics, vols. 61 and 62) almost 20 years ago a great deal of research has been done in this area. New and often unexpected effects have been discovered and theoretical models developed, known effects could finally be explained, and novel applications have been proposed. We believe that the field has now reached a high level of maturity, even if research continues in all areas mentioned above and with new discoveries arriving quite regularly. We therefore have decided to invite some of the top experts in the field to put together the state of the art in their respective fields, having been encouraged to do so for more than ten years by the publisher, due to the fact that the former volumes have long been out of print. The first volume is devoted to a description of the basic effects leading to photoinduced refractive index changes in electrooptical materials. In the second volume the status of the most recent developments in the field of photorefractive materials is reviewed and the parameters governing photorefractive nonlinearity are highlighted. This third volume deals with the applications of the photorefractive effects and of materials. Starting about 35 years ago, the attractiveness of the photorefractive effect for data storage, optical metrology, optical signal processing, image correlation, and several others nonlinear optical applications has been recognized. One of the main reasons for this is the large nonlinearity or refractive index change, which can be induced by low light intensities using the photoinduced space-charge fields in electrooptical materials. Many new concepts have been demonstrated in laboratories over all these years. Several of these concepts have also proved useful in other areas of nonlinear optics. Particularly interesting was the observation of a large energy transfer from pump beams to the signal beam in two- and fourwave mixing experiments. These effects lead to coherent amplification of a wave form covering spatial information and to self-pumped optical phase conjugation with applications in the area of wave-front correction of self-induced optical resonators. Also, it is now possible with photorefractive nonlinearities to control optically the group velocity of a modulated signal beam interfering with a continuous beam in the crystal. In these interactions based on dynamic holography, a large group index can be achieved for the demonstration of superluminal and slowdown light propagation of a signal beam carrying temporal information.
v
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
vi
7:40
Preface
In this third volume a series of applications of photorefractive nonlinear optics and of optical data storage and processing are presented in several chapters. This and the other two volumes on photorefractive effects, materials, and applications have been prepared mainly for researchers in the field, but also for physics, engineering, and materials science students. Several chapters contain sufficient introductory material for those not so familiar with the topic to obtain a thorough understanding of the photorefractive effect. We hope that for researchers active in the field these books will provide a useful reference source for their work. We would like to thank all the authors who contributed to this work for their excellent contributions and great efforts in presenting attractive overviews of the topics they have developed in this book. We are very much indebted to Mrs. Lotti N¨otzli for her great administrative support. Zürich, Orsay, October 2005
Peter Günter, Zurich Jean-Pierre Huignard, Orsay October 2005
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
7:40
Contents
1 Introduction ..................................................................... Peter G¨unter and Jean-Pierre Huignard
1
2 Digital Holographic Memories ............................................... Lambertus Hesselink and Sergei S. Orlov 2.1 Introduction ................................................................. 2.2 Optical Architectures ...................................................... 2.3 Holographic Optics ........................................................ 2.4 Multiplexing Techniques .................................................. 2.5 Holographic Recording Materials ........................................ 2.6 Photorefractive Materials .................................................. 2.7 Fixing of Holograms in Photorefractive Media ......................... 2.8 Systems Issues .............................................................. 2.9 Demonstration Platforms ..................................................
7 7 8 11 17 21 22 25 30 32
3 The Transfer Function of Volume Holographic Optical Systems ..... George Barbastathis 3.1 Introduction ................................................................. 3.2 3D Spatial Heterodyning with Volume Holograms .................... 3.3 Derivation of the Optical Response of Volume Holograms ........... 3.4 Examples .................................................................... 3.5 Conclusions and Discussion ..............................................
51
4 Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing ........................ M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter 4.1 Volumetric Optical Data Storage ......................................... 4.2 Optical Pattern Recognition ............................................... 4.3 Holographic Associative Memories ...................................... 4.4 Photorefractive Materials as Volume Storage Media .................. 4.5 Optical Correlators Using Photorefractive Crystals ................... 4.6 All-Optical Nonlinear Associative Memories .......................... 4.7 Summary ....................................................................
77
51 52 56 58 74
79 94 104 109 120 122 128
vii
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
viii
7:40
Contents
5 True-Time-Delay Adaptive Array Processing Using Photorefractive Crystals ....................................................... G.R. Kriehn and K. Wagner 5.1 Introduction to True-Time-Delay Array Processing ................... 5.2 Output Time Delay and the BEAMTAP Algorithm .................... 5.3 The Traveling-Fringes Detector .......................................... 5.4 Photorefractive Volume Holography Using Polarization-Angle, Read–Write Multiplexing ......................... 5.5 Experimental Implementation of BEAMTAP .......................... 5.6 Conclusion .................................................................. 6
7
8
Photorefractive Mesogenic Composites for Applications to Image Processing ............................................................ Hiroshi Ono, Akira Emoto, and Nobuhiro Kawatsuki 6.1 Overview of Mesogenic Composites for Photorefractive Applications ................................................................. 6.2 Fundamental Properties of Photorefractive Mesogenic Composites for Image Processing ........................................ 6.3 Applications to Image Processing ........................................ Solid-State Lasers with a Photorefractive Phase-Conjugate Mirror ...................................................... T. Omatsu, M.J. Damzen, A. Minassian and K. Kuroda 7.1 Introduction ................................................................. 7.2 Optical Phase Conjugation for Solid-State Lasers ..................... 7.3 Phase-Conjugate Diode-Pumped Nd:YVO4 Laser Amplifiers ....... 7.4 Phase-Conjugate Laser Resonator ........................................ 7.5 Phase-Conjugate Laser Diode ............................................ 7.6 Summary .................................................................... Dynamic Holographic Interferometry: Devices and Applications .... Philippe Lemaire and Marc Georges 8.1 Introduction: Historical Background .................................... 8.2 Requirements for Applicability of HI .................................... 8.3 Potentialities of Photorefractive Crystals for Holographic Interferometry ........................................... 8.4 Holographic Camera with Continuous Laser Illumination for Scattering Objects ...................................... 8.5 Holographic Cameras with Continuous Laser Illumination for Transparent Objects .................................... 8.6 Holographic Camera with Pulsed Lasers ................................ 8.7 Conclusion ..................................................................
135 135 138 141 143 158 166
169
169 172 182
193 193 194 197 209 212 219 223 223 226 229 233 242 244 249
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
7:40
Contents
ix
Self-Organizing Laser Cavities ............................................... Gilles Pauliat, Nicolas Dubreuil, and G´erald Roosen 9.1 Introduction ................................................................. 9.2 Self-Organizing Cavities with Adaptive Fabry-Perot Filters .......... 9.3 Design of Self-Organizing Cavities with 4-Level Laser Amplifiers ............................................................ 9.4 Self-Organizing Cavities with Semiconductor Amplifiers ............ 9.5 Self-Organizing Cavities Operating on the Transverse Structure .... 9.6 Conclusion ..................................................................
253
10 Slow and Fast Lights in Photorefractive Materials ....................... Guoquan Zhang, Fang Bo, and Jingjun Xu 10.1 Dispersive Photorefractive Phase Coupling ........................... 10.2 Phase-Coupling-Induced Slow and Fast Lights ....................... 10.3 Experiments on Slow and Fast Lights in Photorefractive Materials ............................................. 10.4 Slow and Fast Lights with a Stationary Refractive Index Grating ................................................. 10.5 Prospects and Conclusions ..............................................
277
11 Holographic Filters ............................................................. Karsten Buse, Frank Havermeyer, Wenhai Liu, Christophe Moser and Demetri Psaltis 11.1 Introduction ................................................................ 11.2 Telecommunication Networks ........................................... 11.3 Reflection Gratings ....................................................... 11.4 Material Issues ............................................................ 11.5 Holographic Recording .................................................. 11.6 Devices ..................................................................... 11.7 Summary and Outlook ...................................................
295
12 Neutron Physics with Photorefractive Materials ......................... Martin Fally, Christian Pruner, Romano A. Rupp, and Gerhard Krexner 12.1 Basic Concepts ............................................................ 12.2 Materials ................................................................... 12.3 Experiments ............................................................... 12.4 Electro Neutron-Optics ................................................... 12.5 Neutron Holography ...................................................... 12.6 Outlook and Summary ...................................................
321
Index ....................................................................................
355
9
253 254 263 268 273 273
278 280 284 290 292
295 297 301 303 306 309 317
322 326 329 341 345 348
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 September 22, 2006
16:34
1 Introduction Peter G¨unter and Jean-Pierre Huignard
The objective of this third volume of the series on photorefractive effects and materials is to highlight the most recent applications of photorefractive nonlinear optics. As already outlined in volumes 1 and 2, which develop the basic physical mechanisms and the material properties, photorefractive effects exhibit a large diversity of very specific properties. At the origin in the 70’s, photorefractive crystals were proposed for high-capacity volume holographic storage using hologram multiplexing. At that time, this ambitious application already stimulated research on materials and system architectures in order to optimize their storage capacity. Nevertheless, if the concepts were demonstrated in the laboratory, no storage system based on holography was developed due the progress of other technologies such as magnetics and read-only bit-by-bit recording with an optical disk. Then it was realized that the recording of dynamic holograms in photorefractives through two-wave or four-wave mixing makes it possible to transfer energy from a pump beam to a probe, thus leading to coherent amplification of a wave front carrying spatial information. These effects, obtained with low incident optical powers, opened a wide range of new applications extending from image amplification to self-organized optical cavities. Photorefractive holography also permits one to demonstrate novel beam interactions leading to control of the group velocity of a light pulse. Beside this, the dynamic aspects of the holographic recording and readout in photorefractive materials enables the real-time implementation of optical processing functions operating in parallel over a large number of pixels. Also, these dynamic photorefractive volume gratings exhibit spectral and spatial band-pass responses leading to unique properties for signal or image filtering as well as pattern recognition by optical correlation methods based on Fourier transform processors. Moreover, there is now a renewed interest in the field of holographic storage applications due to advances in key technologies such as spatial light modulators and detector arrays. Highresolution holograms can now be recorded in some polymer or photorefractive materials after a fixing process for high-density storage of binary two-dimensional data with multigigabit output rates. This exhaustive list of specific characteristics involving the materials’ properties as well as the interactions between the interfering beams is rich in new proposals for applications in photonics. The different chapters included in this third volume address all the domains introduced above. They are written by leading experts in the field, who provide an extended
1
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 September 22, 2006
2
16:34
Peter G¨unter and Jean-Pierre Huignard
analysis of their recent research achievements in applications of photorefractive nonlinearities. Chapter 2 of this volume gives an overview of digital holographic memories, which have the potential for achieving capacities of one terabyte per disk at a rate of 1 gigabit per second. There is renewed interest in this field, which has benefited from recent progress in key component technologies such as spatial light modulators, compact lasers, and high-speed detector arrays. The storage medium is still a critical issue, but photorefractive crystals like LiNbO3 and photopolymers have already demonstrated their capabilities for hologram multiplexing, leading to an increase in storage density. Optical memory architectures are presented, but it is shown that system optimization is a complex problem with a large number of tradeoffs between several parameters such as the overall system capacity, material dynamic range, hologram efficiency, and signal-to-noise ratio. Consequently, continuing research into improving the characteristics of materials used for data recording in a holographic memory is clearly a key issue for the success of this storage technology. Volume holograms are becoming important optical elements, since they exhibit strong Bragg selectivity in the spatial and spectral domains. The basic properties of phase volume diffraction are used in Chapter 3 for developing a class of applications in which volume holograms are used in optical imaging systems as three-dimensional spatial heterodyning elements for accurate wave-front detection. In these innovative operating principles Bragg selectivity permits one to achieve extremely high positional or color sensitivity, which in turn provide new imaging functions such as high-resolution profilometry, 3D imaging at long distances, and hyper/spectral imaging. Also, the transfer function of an optical system including volume holographic components is analyzed. In particular, the depth selectivity of volume holographic components in imaging systems is outlined, and it is used in several experiments demonstrating new principles of optical slicing of 3D objects. These experiments, which rely on the use of phase volume gratings such as obtained with a fixed grating in a photorefractive crystal or in bulk photopolymer materials, may stimulate new ideas that may extend the limits of classical imaging systems. Parallel information processing is a field of great interest, since dynamic holography can process and manipulate laser beams carrying high-bandwidth spatial and temporal information. In this perspective, Chapter 4, which is reproduced from an earlier Springer Optical Sciences book, reviews the basics of data storage with volume holography and pattern recognition by optical Fourier processing of coherent images. The main system architectures are described and analyzed, and their limitations are discussed. It thus includes hologram multiplexing techniques, limitations on storage capacity due to the optical systems, recording materials and crosstalk between digital pages. Besides data storage, real-time parallel pattern recognition can be performed by a photorefractive correlator involving lenses for Fourier transformation of the complex amplitude of the wave front. The specific properties of analog multichannel optical correlation architectures are reviewed. Then the extension of these techniques to advanced concepts of all
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 September 22, 2006
16:34
1. Introduction
3
optical nonlinear associative memories are introduced in this chapter, and possible implementations using volume holographic elements are presented. Chapter 5 highlights that radio-frequency optical signal processing is a domain in which photorefractive-based system architectures can achieve massive parallelism for adaptive true-time delay processing of wide-bandwidth radar signals. This is due to photorefractive material capabilities to record complex gratings and diffract from these gratings with optically modulated beams that carry a wide radio-frequency bandwidth. In this approach, the adaptive weight coefficients of the signals issuing from each antenna module are represented by the amplitude and the phase of the holographic grating, which can be multiplexed in the same crystal volume. These properties permit one to perform antenna beam formation as well as other important analog signal processing operations such as time-integrating correlation or jammer excision. It is thus expected that photorefractive techniques will play a role in microwave photonics, where very wide bandwidth RF signals will be emitted by large phased-array antennas. Optoelectronics allows one to transmit and to process in parallel all the signals issuing from antenna modules operating in emission or receiving mode. These novel concepts have undoubtedly the capability to contribute to new advances in radar using hybrid optical-electronic signal-processing technologies. Another form of optoelectronic parallel information processing is introduced in Chapter 6. The novel approach in this chapter is the use of a reorientational photoinduced effect in dye-doped liquid-crystal molecules. An important advantage of this class of orientational photorefractive effects is that the operating voltage in low and it benefits from the large index modulation achieved with liquid crystal. In early experiments, dye-doped low-molar-mass liquid crystal shows good nonlinear performance but only for large grating periods. Recent improvements using material combining low-molar-mass liquid crystal with polymers have been obtained for applications that require a higher spatial resolution. The control of laser beam quality is now important in many industrial applications involving high-power diode-pumped laser sources. Thermal gradients in the gain media lead to strong aberrations, which severely degrade the beam quality. As reviewed in Chapter 7, nonlinear photorefractive optics can provide elegant solutions to compensate in real time for thermal aberrations of the beam either inside a cavity or in a master-oscillator power-amplifier architecture. A photorefractive nonlinear mirror can efficiently generate a conjugate beam with CW or pulsed lasers, in particular when using a self-pumped geometry. This chapter describes several important aspects of phase conjugation applied to different laser architectures. Moreover, the concept of the phase-conjugate mirror can also be applied to coherently combine the beams emitted by multichannel amplifiers or multielement laser diode arrays. This review, which includes very significant experimental results, outlines the importance of nonlinear materials in performing adaptive correction of laser beams or beam shaping, in particular for the nearinfrared spectral region. They permit a great improvement in laser brightness and bring additional capabilities for power scaling. These applications should stimulate research for improving existing materials’performance in this spectral range
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 September 22, 2006
4
16:34
Peter G¨unter and Jean-Pierre Huignard
and for studying new materials with high power-handling capabilities and short response time. An important application area of photorefractive holography that was developed in the early stages using conventional materials is interferometry applied to nondestructive testing or to high-precision measurements. The availability of high-sensitivity photorefractive crystals now permit one to realize dynamic interferometry of large objects. This subject is treated in detail in Chapter 8, which develops several metrological device architectures based on dynamic holography with sillenite crystals. The first system is a holographic camera using continuous laser illumination well suited for the measurement of the displacements of the surface of scattering objects. The second is adapted to interferometry of transparent objects, and the third uses pulsed lasers for studying vibrating structures. Photorefractive interferometry also benefits from the advanced digital processing methods for the detection of the interferogram and for calculation of data corresponding to object deformation. It is now a mature technology, and a few systems are commercially available. Adaptive photorefractive interferometry has a significant potential for metrological applications; it is a flexible tool that adapts to any three-dimensional object structure. There are numerous applications of lasers sources that require singlelongitudinal-mode operation, and this happens in particular in holographic interferometry. As proposed and analysed in Chapter 9, an innovative approach for single-mode oscillation without adjustments of static filters is to exploit a self-organizing process by an intracavity adaptive photorefractive filter. When the crystal is inserted in the cavity, the oscillating modes record a common Bragg grating. For a correctly designed cavity this dynamic grating acts as a spectral and spatial filter, which in turn modifies the relative losses of the modes. This results in a unique-mode laser oscillation corresponding to optimum gain and spectral filtering efficiency of the grating. This intracavity interaction is self-adaptive, and after a rather short time constant it forces the cavity to oscillate on a transverse single and longitudinal mode. These novel types of self-organizing cavities are undoubtedly important for achieving single-mode operation, and it can be easily implemented in diode-pumped solid-state gain media or with extended semiconductor laser cavities. Moreover, it has also been demonstrated that selforganization can also occur on the transverse-mode structure: a laser oscillating on several transverse modes can be forced to oscillate on a single mode due to spatial filtering by the photorefractive volume-grating structure. Chapter 10 deals with a new research topic. It investigates the propagation of a light pulse or of a modulated signal beam inside the volume of a photorefractive grating. It is demonstrated that slow and fast light propagation can be achieved due to the dispersive properties of phase coupling in two-wave mixing interactions. This effect occurs in different types of nonlinear media that exhibit strong dispersive properties, and in particular, dynamic holography in photorefractives can achieve a high value of the group index at low incident intensity. Wave coupling results in changes of both the intensity and phase of the pump and of the modulated signal beams interfering in the material. It results in an
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 September 22, 2006
16:34
1. Introduction
5
efficient phase transfer from the pump to the signal beam due to photorefractive two-wave mixing. Group-velocity tunability and transition between slow and fast light are demonstrated by tuning the recording parameters such as the pump intensity and the externally applied voltage to the crystal. It is shown that these parameters as well as the frequency detuning between the pump and signal beams contribute mainly to the control of the group time delay inducted by the slope of the photorefractive phase coupling. In Chapter 11, another type of holographic filter is realized with photorefractive crystals like doped lithium niobate or lithium tantalate. These crystals permit one to realize filters that exhibit very low spectral bandwidth, robustness, and low absorption losses in the telecommunication windows. Moreover, the index modulation of the Bragg filter can be permanently fixed with an appropriate thermal process. All these characteristics make the photorefractive filters suitable for dense-wavelength division multiplexing in very high bandwidth communication networks. This chapter details the devices, the selection of photorefractive materials properties, the recording process, and the thermal fixing. All these steps are optimized in order to attain the specific features required for telecommunication applications. The last chapter of this volume opens an original field of investigation and applications: neutron physics with photorefractive materials. Early experiments began with neutron diffraction from a photoinduced grating in polymetacrylate through a photo-neutron-refractive effect. Then, the same type of diffraction was also realized with a conventional photorefractive grating recorded in electro-optic lithium niobate crystal. It is shown in this chapter that these novel experiments are of interest for studying polymerization process and for probing fundamental properties of neutrons. This is the case of neutron diffraction by electrooptic crystals in which neutrons are exposed to the high photoinduced space charge field generated in the crystal volume. Future perspectives of photo-neutron-refractive materials and applications are discussed and neutron holography is also introduced in this last chapter. In conclusion, this collection of chapters provides a broad survey of the most advanced application fields of photorefractive nonlinear optics. The chapters deal with a large variety of components, devices, and systems architectures exploiting the unique characteristics of photorefractive materials. The authors of this volume are leading experts, and their contributions open innovative applications of dynamic holography and nonlinear wave mixing, and in laser optics, optoelectronics, signal processing, and metrology. This volume should serve the needs of the scientific and engineering communities interested in the applied aspects of photorefractive nonlinear optics. The editors of this volume express their warm regards to all the authors for their outstanding contributions and very fruitful cooperation in the preparation of the volume, which should help to stimulate further developments in the field. We also thank Mrs. Lotti N¨otzli for her very valuable secretarial support.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
17:23
2 Digital Holographic Memories Lambertus Hesselink and Sergei S. Orlov Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305-4035
[email protected]
2.1 Introduction Optical data storage is a phenomenal success story. Since its introduction in the early 1980s, optical data storage devices have evolved from being focused primarily on music distribution, to becoming the prevailing data distribution and recording medium. Each year, billions of optical recordable and prerecorded disks are sold worldwide. Almost every computer today is shipped with a CD or DVD drive installed. The roadmap for optical storage, therefore, is of significant interest, since it defines the industry’s view of future products. One such roadmap is shown in Figure 2.1, based on information provided by TDK in 2002. It shows that the end of the DVD roadmap is followed by super-resolution-blue-based technology, which provides up to 100 GB capacity per disk at a transfer rate of 200 Mbps. For larger capacities and transfer rates, a new approach is needed to further extend the roadmap. Near-field optical recording and holographic recording are generally viewed as being the most likely technologies for achieving transfer rates and capacities near 1 TB per disk at a rate of 1 Gbit/sec. In this chapter we explore holographic data storage systems (HDSS) technology, which has a long history of research and development. In the seventies, much fundamental materials and systems work was carried out on HDSS at RCA (Amodei and Staebler, 1971, Staebler et al., 1975), in the (then) Soviet Union [3] and Bell Labs [4], and many other industrial and university laboratories wordwide [5]. New and improved components were demonstrated and incorporated into complex systems. However, there was neither a strong market need, nor a cost competitive system demonstration to drive large-scale commercial development. Research activities subsided. In the mid-1980s, work at the Microelectronics and Computer Corporation and Stanford University, at Northrop, Caltech, and other laboratories signaled a renewed effort in holographic data storage [6]. The primary drivers this time around were new components developed for consumer applications, and a growing commercial need for largecapacity storage devices.
7
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
8
17:23
Lambertus Hesselink and Sergei S. Orlov
Holography
Data Rate (Mbps)
1000
Near Field
High-speed blue
Super resolution blue
100
Multilayer blue DVR-blue DVD 10 10
100
1000
F I G U R E 2.1. Optical data storage roadmap (source TDK, 2002).
The recording material, however, was not under development for other consumer applications. This led to the formation of the Photorefractive Information Storage Materials (PRISM) in April 1994, and the Holographic Data Storage Systems (HDSS) NSIC/DARPA/Industry/University consortia in April 1995. The PRISM activities were focused on fundamental materials issues, while new components would be integrated into systems reaching a 100-GB capacity and a raw transfer rate of 10 Gbit/sec [7] through component improvement and system optimization. System optimization, as usual, is a complex problem involving a large number of tradeoffs. For HDSS in particular, the tradeoff between capacity and transfer rate is different from that of other storage systems. Fundamentally, holographic data storage is based on multiplexing many holograms in the same volume of the recording medium. For media with a linear response, this implies that the dynamic range for each hologram is roughly equal to the total dynamic range of the medium divided by N, the number of holograms. Since the diffraction efficiency of each hologram is proportional to the squared index modulation, readout signal strength drops off as 1/N 2 . The larger the capacity of the device, the smaller the readout signal strength and the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). In turn, small SNRs cause large raw-bit error rates, which above a threshold of 10−3 to 10−4 cannot be further lowered by error-correction schemes. To boost SNR, detector integration times can be increased at the expense of data-transfer rates. High-capacity systems are therefore most easily demonstrated for small transfer rates, and vice versa.
2.2 Optical Architectures Broadly speaking, holographic data storage materials are divided into two classes: thin (a few hundred microns thick) photosensitive organic media and thick (a few millimeters to centimeters) inorganic photorefractive crystals. The thin media
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
17:23
2. Digital Holographic Memories
9
Holographic Engine Laser
SLM
Medium
CCD
Beam Steering Data In
Address ...011001...
0 1 Encode
Data Out
0
... 01100
Control Unit
Decode
F I G U R E 2.2. 90-degree optical architecture, including the electronic control unit.
lend themselves best for transmission-type architectures using a variety of shift or phase multiplexing techniques, while thick media are most suitable for angular multiplexing, typically in the 90-degree geometry. Although phase and wavelength multiplexing techniques have been thoroughly investigated, at present the required lasers and phase masks are not suitably developed to achieve large data densities [6, 8]. As an example, consider the case of the 90-degree geometry shown in Figure 2.2. The data-bearing object beam and the reference beam are incident upon a thick photorefractive medium from orthogonal directions. Intersecting plane signal and reference beams generate an interference pattern with regions of high intensity and low intensity, of the form I = I0 (1 + m cos K x) in which I0 is the intensity, m is the modulation factor, K is the grating vector, and x is transverse to the direction of propagation (Figure 2.2). Photons excite electrons into the conduction band in higher concentrations within the regions of constructive interference than within the regions of destructive interference. Electrons diffuse in the direction of the concentration gradient to the regions of destructive interference, where they relax to empty states in the energy band gap (intrinsic or dopant levels). The second architecture that has been widely investigated is built around a rotating disk, as shown in Figure 2.3. The medium is a photopolymer sandwiched between two glass plates. The photopolymer medium has a thickness of a few hundred microns. Conventional angular and wavelength multiplexing do not allow hundreds of holograms to be superimposed, since their sensitivities (the derivative of the square root of the diffraction efficiency with time normalized by the intensity and thickness of the medium) are inversely proportional to the medium thickness [8]. Shift multiplexing was developed for this purpose by Markov and Darskii and their coworkers, and later extended by the Psaltis group at Caltech. By moving the medium with respect to a fixed spherical reference wave and the object wave, the Bragg condition is violated, allowing a new hologram to be recorded with little crosstalk. Since
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
10
17:23
Lambertus Hesselink and Sergei S. Orlov
Signal beam
Page Composer
Laser diode
Reference Beam
Imaging lenses Photopolymer Sample Rotating disk
Computer
CCD camera
F I G U R E 2.3. Rotating disk architecture using photopolymer media.
Diffraction Efficiency, cnts/CCD pixel
the spherical reference wave does not provide much selectivity, this multiplexing method does not provide very high recording densities. By modifying the phase front of the reference beam using a random phase mask, excellent selectivity can be achieved. Alignment requirements, however, increase, since the Bragg selectivity curve becomes much narrower compared to the spherical wave case. By engineering the magnitude and the correlation function of the phase mask, the decorrelation distance is modified. Excellent densities can be achieved with this method, as shown in Figure 2.4. The shift multiplexing (mux) selectivity is equal ULSH-500-4 200 micron Polaroid Photopolymer 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0
0
2
4 6 8 Displacement, microns
10
12
150 μm using a spherical wave shift-mux
F I G U R E 2.4. Spherical wave and random-phase-mask multiplexing results for 200micron-thick photopolymer sample.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
17:23
2. Digital Holographic Memories
11
to the autocorrelation length of the speckle field, which is 1.2λ / NA in both the x and y directions where NA is numerical aperture and l is optical wavelength. In 1999, in an effort led by Siros and Stanford, the HDSS team demonstrated shift multiplexing using a correlation multiplexing based on a speckled reference wave, and achieved a density of 20 GB on a disk and a data transfer rate as high as 10 Gbit/sec, as described later in this chapter.
2.3 Holographic Optics Holograms are recorded using a reference beam and a signal beam comprising data. As shown in Figure 2.5(a), the reference beam R and signal beam S interfere to generate a fringe pattern, which is transferred to the medium. In holographic data storage systems, the recorded hologram typically takes the form of an index grating. As shown in Figure 2.5(b), readout is accomplished by illuminating the hologram with the original reference beam R, which diffracts off the recorded hologram to generate an output signal beam S. The electric field amplitude of the propagating reference wave is represented as R = R0 exp(iρ · r ),
(2.1)
where R0 is the complex amplitude, ρ is the wave vector, r is the spatial dimension. The electric field amplitude of the propagating signal wave is similarly represented as S = S0 exp(iσ · r ),
(2.2)
where S0 is the complex amplitude and σ is the wave vector. The interfering signal and reference wave vectors generate a grating with a grating wave vector K given by K = σ − ρ. x z
R
S
R
S
(a)
(b)
F I G U R E 2.5. Optical recording geometry (a) and readout (b).
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
12
17:23
Lambertus Hesselink and Sergei S. Orlov F I G U R E 2.6. Wave vector arrangement between object (σ ) and reference beam (ρ), giving rise to grating vector K.
Ky σ K ρ
Kz
This relationship is illustrated in Figure 2.6. The resulting hologram is given by the index grating n(y) = n 0 + Re[δn exp (i K y)],
(2.3)
in which x is the transverse direction of propagation and δn is a complex coefficient given by δn = n 1 R0 S0∗ /I0 ,
(2.4)
where n 1 is the proportionality constant that accounts for the material response to illumination and I0 is the total illumination. The diffraction efficiency η of a recorded hologram is given by η = sinc2 (eR · eS ((π|δn|L)/(λ cos θ ))) exp(−αL),
(2.5)
where L is the thickness of the medium, α is the absorption coefficient of the material, and eR and eS are the polarizations of the reference and signal beams, respectively. Note that the diffraction efficiency can approach 100% for relatively strong holograms. For relatively weak holograms, with negligible absorption, the diffraction efficiency can be represented by η = (eR · eS ((π|δn|L)/(λ cos θ)))2 .
(2.6)
Holograms recorded in a material having a substantial thickness display a property called Bragg selectivity. Bragg selectivity means that holograms recorded with a planar reference wave vector provide the strongest diffraction efficiency when read out with the same reference beam. The original reference beam and the hologram are said to be Bragg-matched. When the wave vector of the read out reference beam is substantially different, the diffraction efficiency is significantly less. The wave vector of the reference beam can be changed by changing the angle of incidence or wavelength of the reference beam. Bragg selectivity, therefore, allows multiple holograms to be recorded in a holographic data storage system because only the hologram Bragg-matched to the readout beam is reconstructed with substantial diffraction efficiency; all of the others are substantially attenuated. When multiple holograms are recorded in a material, the dynamic range of the index grating is divided up among the holograms. This dynamic range is
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
17:23
2. Digital Holographic Memories
13
characterized by M#, which is defined as 1
/
M# = (ηi 2 ),
(2.7)
in which M is the total number of holograms and ηi , is the diffraction efficiency of the ith hologram. In an ideal material, M# is independent of M for a large number of multiplexed holograms. In this case, M# is given by M = eR · eS ((π|δn|L)/(λ cos θ )).
(2.8)
The diffraction of each hologram in a system of M multiplexed holograms is therefore given by η = ((M#/M))2 .
(2.9)
Another important property of materials used in holographic data storage systems is the recording sensitivity. The material sensitivity, typically measured near t ≈ 0 can be determined using √ S = ∂( η)/∂t/I0 L . (2.10) The material sensitivity depends on material parameters and recording configuration and is generally reported in cm/J. The sample sensitivity can be determined using √ (2.11) S = ∂( η)/∂t/I0 t, where t is the exposure time. The sample sensitivity depends on the material thickness and is generally reported in cm2 /J. (The type of sensitivity referenced can be generally inferred from the units reported.) Inorganic photorefractive materials such as lithium niobate have sample sensitivity ranging from 0.01 to 0.1 cm2 /J and M# of about 1–10 for 1-cm-thick samples. Polaroid ULSH-500 photopolymers have sample sensitivity ranging from 20 cm2 /J and M# as high as 10 for 0.5-mm-thick samples. Development of stronger, more sensitive, and more stable holographic storage materials is an active area of research. Bragg selectivity is illustrated in Figure 2.7. Signal beam wave vector σ and reference beam wave vector ρi record a hologram grating having wave vector y
ρi
F I G U R E 2.7. Bragg mismatch illustrated on rotation of the reference beam wave vector.
ρj
σp
ΔK
K
K
z
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
14
17:23
Lambertus Hesselink and Sergei S. Orlov
K. In an isotropic medium, wave vectors σ and ρi have the same wave number β = 2nπ/λ, and therefore reside on the Ewald sphere. Because the original signal and reference wave vector are Bragg-matched, the vector sum lies on the Ewald sphere: σ = K + ρ.
(2.12)
A second reference beam with wave vector ρ j diffracts off the grating with wave vector K, and the resulting vector sum differs from the output signal by K: σ = K + ρ + K.
(2.13)
The second reference beam is therefore not Bragg-matched to the grating and is therefore substantially attenuated. When the wavelength is the same and the angle of the reference beam changes, as is the case for angle multiplexing, the Bragg selectivity is approximated as η = (eR · eS ((π|δn|L)/(λ cos θ)))2 sinc2 ((( K z L)/2)),
(2.14)
where K z is projection of K on the z-axis and sin c(x) = sin(πx)/πx. Thus, Bragg selectivity may be characterized by a minimum separation of grating vectors along the z-axis, given by ( K z )min = 2π/L. The first zero of the sinc function is obtained at this separation vector. The finite lateral extent of the medium puts a similar constraint on the minimum separation of grating vectors on the xand y-axes, so that the corresponding minimum separation vectors are given by ( K x )min = 2n/H and ( K y )min = 2n/W , respectively, for medium height H and width W, respectively.
2.3.1 Fourier Transform Configuration A particularly advantageous configuration for holographic data storage utilizes the Fourier transform properties of a spherical lens. In the Fourier transform configuration, shown in Figure 2.8. the signal path comprises a signal page generated by a spatial light modulator situated at the front focal plane of a lens, situated a σi (a)
f
f
ai
Sj (b) Aj(r)
F I G U R E 2.8. Fourier transform configuration for holographic data storage, shown for (a) a point source and (b) a spatial light modulator.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
17:23
2. Digital Holographic Memories
15
focal length f in front of the lens. The holographic recording material is situated near the rear focal plane of the lens, but not necessarily at the focal plane. Figure 2.8 (a) shows that point source ai becomes a plane wave on passing through the lens. More generally, Figure 2.8 (b) shows a spatial light modulator having a spatial distribution given by A j (r ), for position vector r, is transformed to a spectrum of wave vectors according to the relationship S j (r ) =
dσ exp(iσ · r )A j (2π f σ/λ).
(2.15)
Thus, in this configuration, each pixel corresponds to a plane wave in the holographic storage material. A recorded image of the signal page is imaged onto a detector array using an appropriate lens. In the Fourier transform configuration, the signal page is distributed throughout the holographic storage material and is therefore robust against local defects in the material. This configuration is relatively insensitive to displacements of the holographic storage medium, provided it remains in the same orientation. It is the most widely used optical configuration used in holographic data storage applications. Usually the medium is placed in between two Fourier transform lenses to create an almost symmetric optical system, which has the additional advantage that the magnification is close to one, and under these conditions the optical distortion aberration is close to zero. The medium is not placed exactly at the Fourier plane, since this gives rise to very high incident intensities of the signal beam, which leads to large object-to-referencebeam intensity ratios along the z-axis or thickness of the medium that are ideally kept close to one to optimize the recording efficiency. The medium therefore usually is placed either just before or behind the Fourier plane, breaking the perfect symmetry of the optical setup, yet allowing the aberrations to remain manageably small.
2.3.2 Grating Vectors as Data Channels The data capacity of a holographic data storage system can be estimated using a degrees of freedom model based on resolvable grating vectors [11, 12]. The finite extent of a holographic storage medium generally limits the resolution of grating vectors. In the direction of signal propagation, the grating vector resolution is given by K z = 2π/L; in the directions perpendicular to the direction of signal propagation, grating vectors are given by K y = 2π/W and K x = 2π/H . Here L , W , and H correspond to medium length, width, and height, respectively. In an isotropic medium, the maximum wave vector length is given by K = 4πn/λ, which defines a radius of a grating vector sphere that bounds the space of allowable grating vectors. The volume of this space is given by VK = ((4π)/3)K 3 .
(2.16)
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16
17:23
Lambertus Hesselink and Sergei S. Orlov
Defining a data channel as a resolvable grating vector, the total number of accessible data channels is given by Q = VK /( K X K Y K Z ), so that Q = ((32π)/3)((n 3 V )/(λ3 )),
(2.17)
where V is the volume of the holographic recording medium. This quantity allows two data channels in quadrature for each grating orientation, which generally requires coherent demodulation to separate the data channels. For one data channel in each grating direction, the total number of accessible data channels is given by [11, 12] Q = ((16π)/3)((n 3 V )/(λ3 )).
(2.18)
Equation 2.18 indicates that a material with an index of refraction of 2.5, such as lithium niobate, has a channel density of 2 × 1015 resolvable grating vectors. In a practical application, the number of degrees of freedom is reduced by a factor α to 1012 to 1013 due to the limited numerical aperture of a signal beam and limited angular excursion of the reference beam. In a holographic data storage system, the accessible data channels a Q are the product the number of pages N and the number of pixels per page P. Once we have determined the number of data channels, we may then estimate total capacity through Shannon’s law, namely, by multiplying the total number of channels by the capacity of a single channel: C total = α Q log2 (1 + SNR) = NP log2 (1 + SNR),
(2.19)
in which N is the number of pages and P is the number of pixels per page, and SNR denotes the signal-to-noise ratio. For a white Gaussian noise model, given the constraint of constant laser power, and for constant total diffraction efficiency, the SNR decreases with increasing number of pixels per page (SNR < 1/P). At the same time, due to a limited dynamic range, the total diffraction efficiency decreases as 1/N 2 , leading to a corresponding behavior of the SNR (SNR< 1/N 2 ). Thus, there exists a trade off between the SNR and the number of pages that can be superimposed. As a result, given parameters of the system (laser power, optical performance, electronic detection noise, media M#, data rate), there is an optimum number of pages that need to be written in a single location of the volume holographic memory for which the capacity C total is maximized [13]. For realistic parameters of storage in the 90-degree geometry lithium niobate system (P = 106 , M# = 1, laser power 1 watt) the theoretical upper bound on the optimum number of pages is estimated to be <2500, with total raw capacity per storage location of < 2.5 × 109 bits. It is worth noting that the capacity calculated above is merely an informationtheoretic upper bound and does not consider the effects of SNR reduction due to nonideal imaging, and interpixel and interpage crosstalk. The state-of-the-art demonstration of digital hologram recording in 90-degree geometry in lithium niobate [48] experimentally realized a capacity of 109 pixels per storage location (i.e., 1000 superimposed holograms of 1 Mpixel images). The resulting raw channel density of <350 bit/μm2 (calculated as the ratio of capacity and the area
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
17:23
2. Digital Holographic Memories
17
occupied by the holograms on the entrance face of the storage crystal) represented, however, only ≈1.08% of the theoretical volumetric density limit of 1/λ3 .
2.4 Multiplexing Techniques 2.4.1 Angular Multiplexing Figure 2.9. shows a diagram for angular multiplexing. Data are encoded on a signal beam using a signal-amplitude spatial light modulator (signal ASLM). The appropriate data pattern is loaded onto the signal ASLM through an appropriate electronic interface to a computer or peripheral system. The signal ASLM is situated at the front focal plane of a lens; the modulated signal propagates to the holographic medium in a Fourier transform configuration. Reference beams are plane waves incident on the holographic medium. Each reference vector is limited to a plane of incidence further situated so that the reference beams and an included wave vector in the signal beam lie in the same plane, as shown in Figure 2.9. A separate hologram is recorded with each reference wave, resulting in multiplexed holographic data pages. A data page is read out by illuminating the holographic medium with one of the reference beams. The output data page is focused on the output detector, and then demodulated by the appropriate electronics Throughout this chapter, we are primarily interested in page-oriented multiplexing, in which we organize a large quantity of data recorded as pixels of an image. Each pixel stored by each reference beam may be considered to be a separate data channel. Angular selectivity is maximized for included signal, and reference wave vectors are normally incident to perpendicular faces of the holographic storage medium [16, 17, 18]. For copolarized signal and reference beams, Output Detector
Holographic Medium
Reference Angles Signal ASLM
F I G U R E 2.9. Angle multiplexing architecture.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
18
17:23
Lambertus Hesselink and Sergei S. Orlov
the diffraction efficiency is expressed as η = (((π|δn|L)/(λ cos θ)))2 sinc2 (((π L sin(θρ − θσ ))/(λ cos θσ )) θ ), (2.20) where θρ is the mean angle of the first and second reference beams and θσ the angle of incidence of the signal beam. The minimum separation angle is defined as the first extinction of the sinc function, which occurs at
θ = ((λ cos θσ )/(n L sin(θρ − θσ ))).
(2.21)
In this expression, the separation angle refers to the angle inside the material; refraction at the surface of materials having a high index of refraction will substantially increase the minimum separation angle. In a holographic storage material such as lithium niobate having a thickness of 1 cm, the angular selectivity is 50 μrad in free space for recording/readout wavelengths of 500 nm, in the perpendicular geometry. Thus, 10,000 holograms can be accessed with an angular range of the reference beam of about 30 degrees. For moderate nonoverlapping angular spectra of the signal and reference beams we can derive a simple expression to estimate the accessible data channels. A reference wave illuminating the side face of the crystal therefore has a maximum number of degrees of freedom, the number of grating vectors separated by the minimum separation vectors of Q z = 2n L/λ. A signal wave illuminating a face has a maximum number of degrees of freedom Q x = 2n H/λ in the x dimension and Q y = 2nW/λ in the y dimension. In this geometry, the number of accessible data channels is further estimated by taking into account the angular bandwidths of the reference and signal beam to yield Q = ((8V )/(λ3 ))(NA)2 sin(/2),
(2.22)
where NA is the numerical aperture of a signal incident at surface normal and is the angular range of the reference beam, both in free space outside the material. For a wavelength of 500 nm, signal numerical aperture of 0.25, and reference beam angular range of 30 degrees, the number of data channels is about 1012 cm−3 .
2.4.2 Wavelength Multiplexing Wavelength multiplexing consists of hologram formation in which each reference wave consists of a plane wave of a different wavelength incident at the same angle, such that R1 = ((A1 /2) exp[i(ρ1 · r − ω1 t)] + ((A1 ∗ /2) exp[−i(ρ1 · r − ω1 t)],
(2.23)
where now |ρ1 | and the corresponding angular frequency ω1 vary but the orientation of ρ1 is the same for all reference beams. Only the recording reference waves are Bragg-matched, and any others result in Bragg-mismatched reconstruction. Figure 2.10 shows a diagram for wavelength multiplexing. As with the angular multiplexing case, a Fourier transform configuration is used. The signal and reference beams are incident on opposite sides of the holographic medium, known
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
17:23
2. Digital Holographic Memories
19
Output Detector
Holographic Medium
Reference Beam
Signal ASLM
F I G U R E 2.10. Generic wavelength-multiplexing architecture.
as a reflection configuration. Wavelength selectivity is maximized for included signal, and reference wave vectors correspond to counterpropagating directions in the holographic storage medium [15–18]. For copolarized signal and reference beams, the diffraction efficiency is expressed as η = (((π|δn|L)/(λ cos θ)))2 sinc2 (((2πnL sin(θ/2))/c) v),
(2.24)
where v is the frequency difference between the recording and readout reference beam, c is the velocity of light in free space, and θ is the angle between a planar signal and reference wave outside the medium. For reflection holograms, the minimum separation frequency is defined as the first extinction of the sine function, which occurs at
v = (c/(2n L sin(θ/2))).
(2.25)
For reflection holograms, the angle between the signal and reference beams is generally substantial. Frequency selectivity is highest for the counterpropagating geometry, in which the signal and reference beams are incident at opposite surfaces of a holographic storage medium and propagate in opposite directions.
2.4.3 Phase-Encoded Multiplexing Phase-encoded multiplexing uses a phase spatial-light modulator to control the reference beam and requires accurate control of the phase modulation and efficient collection of phase patterns to minimize crosstalk. An example architecture for phase-encoded multiplexing is shown in Figure 2.11. Here, a Fourier transform arrangement is used for both the signal and reference beam paths. A phaseencoded reference beam comprises a phase pattern eϕ(x,y) established by a spatial
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
20
17:23
Lambertus Hesselink and Sergei S. Orlov Output Detector
Holographic Medium
Reference PSLM Signal ASLM
F I G U R E 2.11. Holographic data storage system using phase-encoding multiplexing.
light modulator. In this example, a one-dimensional spatial light modulator is situated at the front focal plane of the lens, so that the resulting reference beam incident on the material has a wave-vector spectrum in one dimension. By using a set of orthonormal functions and an appropriate optical configuration, multiple holograms may be superimposed without significant crosstalk. When a reference beam is modulated in phase in one dimension, as shown in Figure 2.11, it consists of wave vectors spanning a plane. We choose a spacing of plane wave components such that the discrete spectrum of wave vectors ρ j corresponds to the wave vectors optimized for angular multiplexing. For proper selection of geometries, Bragg-mismatch can be neglected. For this case, Krasnov has shown that the diffracted signal is given by [19] dc ∝ (R j + Rc )Sl ,
(2.26)
in which the proportionality constant depends on the properties of the holographic material. For this special case, (R j · Rc ) defines the inner product between R j and Rc . To minimize crosstalk we require that the reference waves be orthogonal. In a practical application of phase encoding, we will typically have a configuration in which Bragg-mismatch cannot be completely neglected; a more detailed analysis is required [8]. Overall, we expect the crosstalk-limited signal-to-noise ratio of an orthogonal phase-encoded multiplexing system to be comparable to the case of angular multiplexing, and somewhat lower as we deviate from strict orthogonality. Capacity of a phase-encoded system is also expected to be similar to that of an angular multiplexed system. In practice, however, crosstalk between different pages and strict alignment requirements of the reference beam and the rest of the system limits the useful capacity severely. No experimental demonstration of a high-capacity system has been made todate. A simple way to think about phase multiplexing is to consider the system to be an interferometer, since the reference
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
17:23
2. Digital Holographic Memories
21
and object beams must be stable to within a fraction of a wavelength with respect to each other. This same stability also places very strong mechanical constraints on the system during readout.
2.4.4 Correlation Multiplexing For the holographic disk geometry, shift multiplexing is the most suitable and natural solution, since it doesn’t require any beam steering or wavelength change and is achieved by simply moving the medium with respect to the reference and object beams, as indicated in Figure 2.3. Shift multiplexing can be implemented using a spherical wave [20], or, alternatively, a random or pseudorandom speckle pattern as a reference beam [21]. Shift multiplexing in the spherical-referencebeam case relies on the fact that a spherical-type beam contains multiple angular components, and thus a shift of the media or the reference beam leads to conventional Bragg-mismatch. Multiplexing with a speckle beam is based on the spatial autocorrelation function of the beam used for the recording. In such case the diffraction efficiency of the hologram is determined by the degree of correlation between the speckle beam used for the recording and the speckle beam presented on readout (e.g., a spatially shifted version of the original beam). For random Gaussian speckle, the hologram shift selectivity is determined by the beam autocorrelation function [21]: η(δ) = η(0)|2Jl (kNAδ)/kNAδ|2 ,
(2.27)
where δ is the shift amount, k = 2π/λ, NA is the numerical aperture of the reference beam, and Jl is the first-order Bessel function of the first kind. The speckle selectivity does not depend on the direction of the media shift (Bragg-selective or Bragg-degenerate) and is independent of the media thickness, although the crosstalk buildup is usually much faster in the Bragg-degenerate direction (and in thin media). Since this chapter focuses on the use of thick photorefractive recording media, for details of correlation multiplexing, the reader is referred to Hesselink, 2004.
2.5 Holographic Recording Materials Although different applications require materials of varying properties, an ideal material would have a fast time response (< μsec), be as sensitive as photographic film (μJ/cm2 ), retain information for long time periods (>10 years), have a large spectral sensitivity range extending into the infrared region of the spectrum, and be available in large quantities, at good optical quality, in large size, and at low cost. Such a recording material does not exist today! In general, sensitive materials have small photorefractive response, and vice versa. For example, LiNbO3 is available in large size, of good optical quality, and at relatively low cost, and has a large index variation per absorbed photon. Its response time, however, is rather slow, on the order of milliseconds or longer, depending on the intensity of the recording
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
22
17:23
Lambertus Hesselink and Sergei S. Orlov
light. Thermal fixing has been demonstrated allowing nondestructive readout for periods of years, but this process typically requires temperatures of at least 100◦ C for fixing. Photopolymer materials usually have much higher sensitivity due to chemical amplification effects and a high dynamic range, but are rather limited in terms of thickness (1 mm or less). Other issues associated with polymers are significantly increased scatter levels compared to single-crystal photorefractives and volumetric shrinkage on photopolymerization. The latter effect can be somewhat mitigated by use of high-molecular-weight monomers and proper choice of the material chemistry. The shrinkage and scatter limits the available usable thickness of photopolymers. Typical minimum material parameters for optimized holographic performance are listed below [22]: Material: – Thickness: L > 0.5 mm; – Sensitivity: S = 500 cm/J (or S L > 20 cm2 /J); – Dynamic range: (M/#)planewave > 5.0 (or, (M/#)image > 2.0); – Shrinkage: < 0.05% (for 500 μm); – Scatter: < 10−5 srad−1 ; – Wavelength response: visible (<532 nm or blue). Media: – Disk wedge <0.5 mrad; – Format: 120 mm to 6.5 diameter disk; – Total wavefront error over <2 mm spot: < λ/10; – Scatter (including substrate) < 10−5 srad−1 . The performance of a holographic data storage system greatly depends on the quality and physical properties of the recording medium. The DARPA PRISM consortium has developed a precision tester [23] for measuring the performance of different holographic media using a common platform. Since 1996 many advanced holographic recording materials have been evaluated and compared using a common comparison framework. The most important parameters include image quality (degree of image distortion), sensitivity, dynamic range, fidelity (spatial resolution), stability, shrinkage, and available thickness. Based on the results published so far [24], the most promising photorefractive crystals remain Fe-doped lithium niobate, while Polaroid CROP materials represent the better option in the photopolymer family. For a comparison among various optical recording properties the reader is referred to Hesselink, 2004.
2.6 Photorefractive Materials Photorefractive materials record holograms through a photoinduced chargetransport (diffusion, drift, and photovoltaic effect), charge-carrier redistribution
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
17:23
2. Digital Holographic Memories F I G U R E 2.12. Photoexcitation of electrons in the presence of a periodic intensity pattern.
23
I
---
---
---
---
++ ++
++ ++
++ ++
++ ++
Ec
Ev
between the deep traps and buildup of an internal space-charge field. The resulting index distribution is produced due to electrooptic (Pockels) effect Figure 2.12. In general, a variety of trapped and photoexcited states are possible, including electrons and holes. Typically, electrons are trapped at impurity centers and photoexcited into the conduction band. This example is illustrated as follows. Using the example of Figure 2.12, intersecting signal and reference beams generate an interference pattern with regions of high intensity and low intensity, which has the functional form I = I0 (1 + m cos K x),
(2.28)
in which m is the modulation factor that quantifies the contrast of the interference pattern. As shown in Figure 2.12, photons excite electrons into the conduction band in higher concentrations within the regions of constructive interference than within the regions of destructive interference. Electrons diffuse in the direction of the concentration gradient to the regions of destructive interference, where they relax to empty states in the energy band gap. In the presence of a photovoltaic current found in materials such as lithium niobate, the effect is enhanced. A graphical depiction of the relevant physical quantities associated with the photorefractive effect is shown in Figure 2.13 for a diffusion-dominated photorefractive medium. A periodic intensity variation I arises from the in interference of the signal and reference beams. This pattern establishes a Coulombic charge density ρ in the photorefractive material that records the intensity pattern; red indicates positive charge and blue indicates negative charge. At steady state, a periodic potential U associated with the charge density balances diffusion. The separation of electrons from fixed, positive ions establishes an electric field E, typically called a space-charge field, that replicates the functional form of the
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
24 I
17:23
Lambertus Hesselink and Sergei S. Orlov F I G U R E 2.13. Photorefractive effect in diffusion-dominated materials.
ρ
U
E
δn
interference pattern, up to a phase factor ϕ: E = |E SC | cos(K x + ϕ).
(2.29)
This expression is accurate only for small modulation depths, in which E SC = m E 1 and E 1 is the normalized space-charge field, representing the transport properties of the medium. In materials displaying the linear electrooptic (Pockels) effect, for example, the space-charge field generates a periodic index grating δn proportional to the electric field, such that 1 (2.30) δn = − n 3r m E 1 cos(K x + ϕ), 2 where n is the index of refraction and r is the effective Pockels coefficient, which in general depends on the Pockels tensor, light polarization, and crystal orientation [60]. Therefore, the resulting index grating replicates the initial interference pattern up to a phase shift, generating a volume hologram. In a holographic medium that does not display nonlinear beam coupling, the diffraction efficiency is [25] πmn3 r|E1 | η = sin2 . (2.31) 2λ cos θ Detailed accounts of photorefractive transport can be found in [26–31]. Lithium niobate is the most common photorefractive material used in holographic
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
17:23
2. Digital Holographic Memories
25
data-storage-system demonstrations. Other inorganic materials of interest include strontium barium niobate and barium titanate. Organic materials include reversible photorefractive polymers that may eventually be candidates for holographic storage systems [61]. Photorefractive polymer materials, however, require large applied electric fields, and good sensitivity as well as longterm stability of recorded holograms have not been demonstrated in the same medium.
2.7 Fixing of Holograms in Photorefractive Media Thermal fixing is the most widely used fixing method in LiNbO3 , followed by two-photon recording. These two primary techniques are described in somewhat more detail below.
2.7.1 Thermal Fixing In a simple photorefractive material with one photoexcitation process and one species of trapped charge, light used to record the hologram will typically erase the same hologram upon readout. Thus, for permanent storage and multiple reads without data degradation, photorefractive materials require a fixing process. Hologram fixing can be accomplished in a number of ways. One method makes use of complementary charge gratings residing in separate subsystems of charge transport that are not sensitive to the readout light. The gratings are complementary in the sense that they have opposite polarity and can screen each other. Figure 2.14 illustrates a generic process that uses complementary gratings to establish stable holograms. Subsystem A comprises a photoexcitable charge species, such as a trapped electron, as shown in Figure 2.14(a). A Coulombic charge density grating ρA is written in subsystem A through the photorefractive effect. A second charge density grating ρB is established in subsystem B using a different process, and ρA
ρB
ρA + ρB
(a) Initial Grating
(b) Complementary Grating
(c) Exposed Grating
F I G U R E 2.14. Graphical depiction of the evolution of complementary gratings.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
26
17:23
Lambertus Hesselink and Sergei S. Orlov
may be accomplished by changing a material environment parameter such as temperature, electric field, or type of illumination, as shown in Figure 2.14(b). Optical, holographic, and system considerations put constraints on the use of complementary gratings for nonvolatile readout. For image-bearing beams, an important issue is the expansion of the crystal on heating. If holograms are recorded at an elevated temperature and then cooled, the Bragg condition will be modified, and either the angle of the reference beam or its wavelength or both must be modified to obtain the greatest diffraction efficiency. This effect ultimately puts limits on the image field that may be reconstructed with acceptable fidelity, and will introduce additional crosstalk because not all of the signal can be Braggmatched simultaneously at the lower temperatures. It is a system issue whether simultaneous formation of holograms at high temperature or formation at low temperature and subsequent activation of mobile ions at high temperature give optimal performance. In lithium niobate, for example, subsystem A may establish an initial electronic charge density through the photorefractive effect and subsystem B is established as a complementary charge density through mobile ion transport at elevated temperature [2, 32–34] as shown in Figure 2.15. The ionic conductivity usually obeys an Arrhenius-type dependence on the temperature T: σi = en i μ0 exp(−((E a kB T ))).
(2.32)
where E a is activation energy (approximately 1.2 eV for hydrogen impurity and ≈1.4 eV for interstitial lithium migration), n i is the density of conducting ions, e is the electron charge, μ0 denotes the permeability of free space, and kB is Boltzmann’s constant. Mobile ions are thermally activated and move to screen e
e
e
e Illumination I(x), recording
I(x) ++
++ ni1(t=0) N+d1(t=0)
--
N+d1 (t = 0) grating Elevated Temp., Ionic Transport
ni 1 N+d1 ni 1 N+d 1
Ionic Compensation “Fixing”
Low T, Readout (Developing)
F I G U R E 2.15. Mechanism of hologram fixing via thermally assisted ionic drift.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
17:23
2. Digital Holographic Memories
27
out the electronic grating. The resulting hologram becomes screened. However, at lower temperatures, the ions have significantly lower mobility and the grating lifetimes can be considerably longer than for an electronic grating. Thus, at lower temperature, the ionic grating will represent a backbone of the fixed hologram, while upon light illumination, the electronic grating will redistribute itself, partially screening the fixed ionic grating. The ionic grating also eventually decays at a much slower rate (from several months to more than 10 years) depending on the residual conductivity at the storage temperature and the degree of electronic screening. Two alternative approaches exist for creation of fixed ionic gratings in lithium niobate. In the first case, electronic gratings are formed at room temperature. Initial exposure to the signal and reference beams generates an electronic grating, which is followed by ionic compensation at higher temperatures without illumination. At elevated temperatures (above approximately 100◦ C in LiNbO3 [1], ions become active and generate a complementary screening grating that compensates the space charge arising from the electronic grating. These paired electronic and ionic gratings constitute complementary gratings and are derived from charge patterns with opposite polarity. On cooling to room temperature, the ions are significantly less mobile and represent the ionic backbone of the fixed grating. Subsequent light exposure reveals the fixed grating by partially redistributing the electronic charges. In the presence of light exposure, the ionic grating is partially screened, but in the case of LiNbO3 , strong photovoltaic currents significantly reduce the screening. The actual degree of screening depends largely on the grating spacing, photorefractive impurity concentrations (e.g., Fe2+ ), and the reduction state of the material [34, 36]. In the second case, both electronic and ionic gratings are formed simultaneously at an elevated temperature [2]. Simultaneous formation of electronic and ionic gratings typically results in stronger complementary gratings because of mutual screening during formation, in which the magnitudes of both gratings may be substantial, but their difference remains relatively small [32, 33]. The typically used temperature range for this process is 150 to 180 degrees Celsius. Multiple fixed holograms based on ionic gratings have been demonstrated in LiNbO3 [2, 40, 41]. At least 500 holograms may be stored using ionic gratings, for which diffraction efficiencies in the range of 2 to 2.5% have been reported [2, 40, 41]. As part of the PRISM Consortium, Siros Technologies demonstrated fixed ionic gratings by recording over 500 pages of digital data in LiNbO3 [42]. Subsequently, the Psaltis group demonstrated fixing of thousands of holograms [43]. Holographic gratings based on charge redistribution inevitably decay due to ionic and electronic conduction. The lifetimes of fixed ionic holograms are limited by the finite ionic conductivity at low (i.e., room) temperature [34, 36]. Ionic gratings are partially screened by trapped electrons upon readout, which decreases the resulting diffraction efficiency, but proportionally increases the grating lifetime. A significant increase in fixed ionic hologram lifetime is realized in lithium
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
28
17:23
Lambertus Hesselink and Sergei S. Orlov Signal (near-IR) GATING BEAM (visible)
Reference (near-IR)
Reference (near-IR)
Reconstructed Signal beam
F I G U R E 2.16. Two-photon recording in LiNbO3 requires a visible incoherent gating beam in addition to two IR recording beams. During readout, only the IR reference beam is present. The light-induced IR sensitivity is about one hundred times higher than without the gating beam, giving rise to prolonged readout.
niobate with low hydrogen impurity content. Fixed hologram lifetimes of about 2 years at room temperature are projected in dehydrated lithium niobate crystals. Due to partial electronic compensation, the actual hologram lifetime is prolonged, but at the expense of reconstruction efficiency. Prolonged recording at elevated temperature (in highly doped lithium niobate) usually results in a nearly fully compensated gratings with no, or little, electrooptic contribution, but with a sufficiently strong index perturbation arising from the photochromic effect due to substantial modulation in the dopant concentrations. Such gratings possess prolonged lifetimes (over 50 years or more) and do not require light for development.
2.7.2 Two-Photon Fixing The difficulty with thermal fixing is that recording occurs at elevated temperatures with reading at room temperature. For thick media, the diffraction efficiency therefore reduces due to Bragg-mismatch. This problem and the associated complications of recording at elevated temperatures can be overcome by using a two-photon recording method. Two-photon recording techniques (Figure 2.16) have been investigated since the early days of research on holographic memories, in particular at Bell Laboratories [4]. The difficulty with the early work was the low sensitivity of the medium and the high power of the lasers required to record data in LiNbO3 . The Stanford group overcame this problem by modifying the composition of LiNbO3 by making it more stoichiometric, adding Fe and other dopants, combined with optimized oxidation and reduction postgrowth treatments [45]. We demonstrated an improvement in recording sensitivity of several orders of magnitude over previous results, making the medium approximately as sensitive as Fe-doped LiNbO3 in the green. Typical sensitivity and index changes as a function of stoichiometry are shown in Figure 2.17. It is interesting to note that the sensitivity exhibits a threshold behavior near 49.5 mol % Li2 O in the crystal. The details of the materials improvement and holographic aspects are described in Hesselink et al., 1998.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
17:23
2. Digital Holographic Memories
29
10-2
10-3
S
Δn
10-3
10-4
10-4 48.5
Index change (Δn)
Sensitivity (cm/J)
Sensitivity Index change Δn
10-5 49.0 49.5 Li2O in the crystal (mol%)
50
F I G U R E 2.17. Two-photon sensitivity and index change as a function of stoichiometry in undoped LiNbO3 .
At a Li2 O concentration of 49.9%, the total accumulated grating strength (M# or the sum of the induced refractive index changes of all superimposed holograms) in this material is very high, and we have measured values of M# ≈ 10. This is very significant for data storage applications, since it provides a large dynamic range for superimposing holograms. The single-photon sensitivity in the near IR is very small, thus providing a means for prolonged readout, as shown in Figure 2.18. There is a small initial drop in readout efficiency, but for longer times it proves to be quite stable. When the gating beam is turned on again during readout, information is erased. The Stanford group [46] demonstrated the first digitally recorded holograms using two-photon recording with red Ti:Sapphire light around 800 nm, and gating light from a green argon-ion beam [8]. Besides these two primary fixing
F I G U R E 2.18. Diffraction efficiency in a record-readout-erase cycle using two-photon recording in LiNbO3 .
Diffraction efficiency (%)
80 70
Recording gate on
Readout gate off Erasure gate on
60 50 40 30 20 10 0
0
50
100 150 Time (s)
200
250
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
30
17:23
Lambertus Hesselink and Sergei S. Orlov
techniques, other techniques for nondestructive readout are also discussed in the reference paper by Hesselink [8].
2.8 Systems Issues 2.8.1 Capacity Versus Transfer Rate Tradeoff The tradeoff between capacity and transfer rates is estimated by computing the number of photons incident on a detector element during page readout. From this calculation we can estimate the maximum number of superimposed pages readable with a certain SNR: 0.5 2 M # θQE Pηopt ηfix tread 2 , (2.33) Number of pages = M N pmin where M # is a variable based on system and materials parameters, θ is the number of photons per watt per second, QE the quantum efficiency of the detector array, ηopt the optical efficiency of the readout system, ηfix is the fixing efficiency, tread is the read time of the recalled data, M and N are the numbers of rows and columns on the data page, pmin denotes the number of photoelectrons needed to get a 20-dB SNR, and P is the power of the readout beam. It is assumed that bit patterns are balanced (although this does not have to be the case) by making half the pixels in a page on and half off. From this equation, the tradeoff between capacity (the product of the stored number of pages, the code rate, and the number of bits per page) and data transfer rate (the number of bits per page times the code rate divided by the readout time) is determined in a photon-limited system. Optical damage and crosstalk limitations are not considered. In practice, however, optical damage often tends to limit capacity, but can be significantly reduced by recording at elevated temperatures. Equation (2.33) provides an upper bound. Alternatively, Odoulov et al. [58] have shown that periodically poled LiNbO3 having thick domains on the order of the fractions of millimeters, the DC photovoltaic damage can be significantly reduced, thereby providing significantly improved storage performance through much higher attainable SNRs [8].
2.8.2 Signal Processing and En/Decoding In a data-storage system, the goal of error-correction coding, data modulation, and signal processing is to reduce the BER to a sufficiently low level while achieving such important figures of merit as high density and high data rate. The distinct feature of digital holographic data storage is that this technology treats each individual pixel of the hologram as a data channel and the entire image as set of data channels. This allows one to employ the modulation coding and signal-processing techniques to improve the system performance in terms of total capacity at an acceptable error rate.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
17:23
2. Digital Holographic Memories
Input Data
Error Correction Coding
Interleaving
31
Modulation Coding
Equalization Encoding
Holographic Storage Material
Equalization Decoding
Output Data
Error Detection & Correction
De-Interleaving
Demodulation
F I G U R E 2.19. Typical signal path ip a holographic data-storage system.
Coding and signal processing can involve several qualitatively distinct elements. The cycle of user data from input to output can include error-correction coding (ECC), interleaving, modulation encoding, signal preprocessing, data storage in the holographic system, hologram retrieval, analog signal detection and binary digitization (using a CCD or CMOS detector array), signal postprocessing, channel decoding, and ECC decoding of deinterleaved binary data. A simple example of a signal path in a holographic data storage system is shown in Figure 2.19. Input data are processed to generate data blocks with errorcorrection coding. The data are interleaved among blocks to distribute burst errors among multiple blocks. Data are subject to a modulation code that converts binary data into specific modulation formats to be recorded in a holographic material. On readout, data are demodulated and then deinterleaved. The error-correction algorithm is applied to correct and/or identify errors, generating the output data. The purpose of modulation coding is to simplify the detection of the analog signal values from the detector array. Modulation codes generally restrict available patterns for formatting data to a subset that are less likely to be corrupted during recording, storage, and/or readout. This restriction is typically achieved using constraints on the types of data patterns that may occur. A balanced constraint addresses the issue of variation in signal strength across a data page; in a system with binary channels, this issue is addressed by ensuring that a fixed number of OFF and ON pixels (0 and 1, respectively) occur in a block of a given size. A lowpass constraint addresses intersymbol interference arising in high-frequency data
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
32
17:23
Lambertus Hesselink and Sergei S. Orlov
patterns, typically by eliminating the data patterns most susceptible to intersymbol interference [52]. The simplest detection scheme is global threshold detection, in which a specific threshold value is chosen: Any CCD pixel with an intensity above the threshold is declared a 1, while the rest are declared 0. If all holograms result in equal diffraction efficiencies, a threshold intensity can be chosen to distinguish ON pixels from OFF pixels. Note that we use OFF and ON when referring to SLM or CCD pixels and 0 and 1 when referring to information bits [8, 52]. In the presence of variation in signal strength across a data page, this simple scheme does not perform satisfactorily because the optimal value of the threshold becomes dependent on the position within the page. A modulation code identified as an early alternative to the threshold approach in holographic data storage systems is a balanced constraint known as differential decoding, in which each zero and one of the data are encoded in the form of a group of two adjacent pixels A and B, one ON, one OFF [52]. Upon detection and demodulation, if the intensity of pixel A is lowest, the data bit is declared a 0, and if the intensity of pixel B is lowest, the data bit is declared a 1. Viewed a different way, a 0 1 sequence represents a data bit 0 and a 1 0 sequence represents a data bit 1. This method was applied to holographic data storage by the Stanford group in 1994, when a picture of the Mona Lisa and digital music were recorded and retrieved in the first demonstration of a digital holographic storage system [8, 52]. Other, more optimized, coding techniques were developed subsequent to this demonstration, and have been applied and implemented by a number of researchers worldwide [8, 47–50].
2.9 Demonstration Platforms A number of systems have been designed, built, and tested at Stanford University and Siros Technologies for a variety of purposes. They were built under sponsorship of the Center of Nonlinear Optical Materials, and the PRISM and HDSS consortia. The primary goals are to gain insight into the underlying physics of the recording mechanisms and the system tradeoffs required to achieve specified performance, and to integrate new components into working demonstration platforms. The most-significant demonstrations are briefly described in ensuing sections. Additional demonstrations are discussed in the review paper by Hesselink [8]. We limit ourselves here to the most significant demonstrations using LiNbO3 materials and the Stanford/HDSS final system demonstration, since it still describes the most advanced publicly disclosed digital storage system.
2.9.1 The Stanford University All-Digital System Demonstration (Heanue 1994) In 1994, we demonstrated the first fully digital holographic data storage system [52] by storing digital images and a short soundtrack. The purpose of this
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
17:23
2. Digital Holographic Memories
33
experiment was to show that a fully functional system could be implemented with off-the-shelf components. Particular emphasis was placed on using digital signal processing techniques to overcome noise issues limiting capacity and transfer rates. A new differential coding scheme was introduced that allowed us to significantly increase capacity while adding extra bits for channel and ECC coding. It allowed us to evaluate the tradeoffs between storage system capacity, bit-error rate, and data-transfer rate for several channel and ECC coding schemes. As described above, the capacity is limited for the most part by the attainable diffraction efficiency of the stored holograms. As the number N of holograms stored in a single stack increases, the diffraction efficiency falls as 1/N 2 , mentioned above. As the strength of the diffracted signal decreases, the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) decreases because the strength of noise due to scatter and CCD noise is independent of N. The total number of holograms that can be stored is thus determined by the minimum acceptable SNR. A holographic data storage system is also limited by page-to-page fluctuations in signal strength, which can occur due to laser instability or, for example, due to a nonoptimal choice of recording schedule. Intrapage distortion can occur due to imperfections in the optical system or in the SLM or CCD array. These noise sources limit the applicability of direct storage of images in analog form. The majority of previous holographic storage implementations have involved direct storage and retrieval of pictorial information. For example, Mok has demonstrated angular-multiplexed storage of as many as 5000 edge-enhanced analog images in a single crystal [15]. The noise-tolerant nature of digital storage makes it possible to overcome problems associated with the aforementioned noise sources. However, prior to the publication of our Science paper, no fully automated digital holographic data storage system had been implemented and no comprehensive study of the biterror-rate performance of a system operating at reasonable data transfer rates had been carried out. Achievable bit error rates have been projected previously by sampling a small number of digital information bits from a random sampling of 1000 holograms stored in a manually Bragg-tuned system [51]. Using various encoding techniques, we have implemented what to the best of our knowledge is the first fully automated system in which data are written and recalled in digital form. We have used a spatiorotational multiplexing system to store digital representations of color images and compressed video. Critical features of our implementation that allowed us to overcome previous obstacles include location of the Fourier plane outside the crystal volume, use of cylindrical lenses to implement spatial multiplexing, a novel differential encoding technique used to increase error immunity, use of Hamming error-correction codes, and the distribution of consecutive information bits over multiple data pages in order to decrease the probability of burst errors. With these techniques, bit-error rates of 10−6 have been achieved at readout rates of 6.3 × 106 pixels per second. We have used the system to evaluate tradeoffs between bit-error rate and storage capacity at a fixed data-transfer rate.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
34
17:23
Lambertus Hesselink and Sergei S. Orlov
A generic diagram of the Stanford system is shown in Figure 2.2 The storage medium is an Fe-doped LiNbO3 crystal cut such that its c-axis is at 45 degrees to the crystal surfaces. The crystal dimensions are 2 cm × 1 cm × 1 cm, of which only a 0.1-cm3 portion is used for data storage. The crystal is mounted on a computer-controlled rotation stage, which is in turn mounted on a computercontrolled translation stage, allowing the crystal to be moved in the vertical direction. The SLM is a 480 × 440 pixel liquid crystal array taken from an InFocus TVT-6000 video projector. It is addressed with an analog video signal produced by a framegrabber board in the computer. The camera is an intensified CCD array. Each stored hologram is read out in 1/30 second. The cylindrical lenses in the reference beam path are used to collimate the reference to an area of approximately 10 mm × 2 mm at the face of the crystal. The combination of the translation stage and the collimation of the reference beam allows holograms to be stored in four different stacks. The signal beam occupies an area of approximately 1.5 mm × 1.5 mm on the front face of the crystal. The Fourier plane is located approximately 3 mm in front of the crystal. A filter is used to select only the central spot of this transform. The filter prevents erasure of previously recorded stacks during writing and eases alignment tolerances at the CCD plane. By recording in a Fresnel plane, rather than the Fourier plane, the modulation depth is sufficiently uniform to eliminate the need for a diffuser [62]. Because previously recorded holograms were erased in this demonstration as additional holograms were recorded, an appropriate recording schedule had to be determined in order to store a large number of pages with equal diffraction efficiency [6]. If all holograms result in equal diffraction efficiencies, a threshold intensity can be chosen to distinguish ON pixels from OFF pixels. Note that we use OFF and ON when referring to SLM or CCD pixels and 0 and 1 when referring to information bits. An incorrect measurement of the time constant can result in a schedule that leads to unequal diffraction efficiencies for each of the stored holograms. A 10 percent error in the assumed time constant can result in more than a factor of 2 variation in diffraction efficiency. In addition, laser fluctuations or anomalous writing behavior can result in unequal diffraction efficiencies. In order to circumvent these problems, we used a differential encoding technique, in which the pixel sequence OFF-ON is written to the SLM to represent a 0 and the pixel sequence ON-OFF is written to represent a 1. In addition to being insensitive to page-to-page intensity fluctuations, the differential encoding technique results in a lower probability of error, assuming a model of additive white noise that is independent from pixel to pixel. For example, the probability of an error given that a 0 is transmitted in a threshold detection system is given by [63, 64] p≈
∞
aT
2 r + aL2 r r aL exp − dr, I 0 σ2 2σ 2 σ2
(2.34)
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
17:23
2. Digital Holographic Memories
35
where aH and aL are the average amplitudes of ON and OFF pixels, respectively, at the CCD array, σ is the standard deviation of the noise, I0 is the zero-order modified Bessel function of the first kind, and the thresold aT is set to be the mean of the ON and OFF values. The probability of an error given that a 0 is transmitted in a differential detection system is given by 2 ∞ x x aL x + aL2 dr I exp − p≈ 0 2 2σ 2 σ2 aT σ 2 x r + aH2 r r aH exp − × dxdr (2.35) I 0 2 2σ 2 σ2 0 σ These equations show that significant improvements can be made using differential encoding over simple thresholding schemes (Heanue, Bashaw, Hesselink, 1994). Another advantage to the differential encoding technique is that it can be used when single pages reconstruct nonuniformly. This nonuniformity can result from poor overlap of signal and reference beams in the crystal, nonuniform illumination of the SLM, or from the introduction of interference fringes due to multiple reflections in the optical system. When a substantial contribution to the variance is due to such large-scale nonuniformities, we expect difference encoding to offer further improvement over simple thresholding techniques. This is indeed the case. Ideally, each pixel on the SLM would be used to represent a single bit of data. The liquid-crystal array used in these experiments exhibited some interpixel crosstalk. In other words, pixels adjacent to an ON (transmitting) pixel exhibit a significant amount of transmission. Also, the SLM and the CCD array are manufactured with different horizontal-to-vertical pixel pitch ratios. Thus, using a simple optical system such as ours, it is impossible to image the SLM onto the CCD array such that each SLM pixel is imaged directly onto a CCD pixel. In practice, a multiple-lens arrangement could be used to achieve the proper anamorphic imaging; however, this greatly increases system complexity. The pitch mismatch results in a systematic geometrical source of errors if too fine a sampling grid is used. In order to circumvent these problems, we used a block of 8 × 8 pixels to represent one bit. The differential encoding technique increases the pixel-to-bit ratio to 8 × 16 pixels per information bit. The data is read out by sampling the CCD output at one pixel for each 8 × 8 pixel block imaged onto it. The difference in intensity between adjacent samples is used to determine whether the information bit is a 0 or a 1. We measured the raw bit error rate of our system to be between 10−3 and 10−4 at video readout rates. In order to improve performance, we implemented a Hamming error-correcting code in which 4 check bits are added to each string of 8 data bits. The Hamming code is capable of correcting a single bit error in the sequence of 12 bits assuming that only one bit error occurs in those 12. In order to reduce the potential of burst errors, each stored data page represented one bit
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
36
17:23
Lambertus Hesselink and Sergei S. Orlov
plane in a two-byte sequence. Thus, each bit in the 12-bit sequences was stored in a separate page in order to reduce the probability of multiple errors within a given sequence. With the error-correcting codes, we were able to achieve bit error rates of 10−6 , which is adequate for compressed video storage and more than sufficient for uncompressed image storage. We used our system to store both digital color image and low-resolution video data. The total capacity of the system was 1232 pages with 1592 bits per page, resulting in a raw capacity of 245 kB. Taking into account the necessary error-correcting bits, the total useful data capacity is 163 kB. The total pixel capacity of our system is 2.6 108 pixels, with a density of 3 × 109 pixels per cm3 . The transfer rate is 6.3 × 106 pixels per second. The CCD camera outputs one byte per pixel. The total pixel capacity of our system indicates that our storage capacity does not represent a fundamental limit. Rather, the primary limitation in determining the information storage capacity is the necessary oversampling on the SLM. With a higher-quality SLM designed in conjunction with the CCD array, we anticipate that the information capacity and data-transfer rates can be enhanced by several orders of magnitude.
2.9.2 The Siros Fully Automated Video Demonstration (1995) The Stanford demonstration showed that digital encoding techniques could be used to great advantage to improve raw BER, and in combination with errorcorrecting codes, digital images could be retrieved with low error rates. The capacity of this demonstration, however, was rather limited. The next step in the development of digital holographic data-storage systems accomplished storage of compressed high-resolution video data, requiring substantially larger data-storage capacity, and a good bit error rate of about 10−8 . Primarily due to the efforts of John Heanue, Andy Daiber, Ray Snyder, and Jim Colvin at Siros Technologies, the first video movie was stored and retrieved by recording approximately 5 MB of compressed video data. The optical arrangement was similar to the Stanford demonstration, except that the SLM was a Texas Instruments deformable mirror device, with a resolution of 640 × 480 pixels. This device overcame all problems of the previously used liquid-crystal devices. Both video imagery and sound were recorded in LiNbO3 with the MPEG standard using the system of Figure 2.20. Data were encoded using 6:8 channel codes and a Reed Solomon 15:13 error-correction scheme that corrects one byte error per code word. This system was shown on the Discovery Channel in 1995 as part of the Next Step program. In contrast to the Science demonstration, in this experiment the information was permanently stored using ionic fixing. After recording of all data stacks, the crystal was removed from the setup and placed in an oven. It was heated to approximately 120◦ C for 15 minutes, and then slowly cooled down to room temperature. Caused by hydrogen impurities in the crystal, the thermal fixing efficiency was rather high, approximately 50% (i.e., the diffraction efficiency after thermal fixing was approximately 50% of that before the fixing procedure) [42]. Data retrieval in this experiment was implemented in software.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
17:23
2. Digital Holographic Memories
37
Illumination Optics Galvanometer Optional Phase mask PM Lens
SLM
Storage medium
Relay Lens
FT Lens
FT Lens
CCD
F I G U R E 2.20. Generic 90-degree recording geometry.
2.9.3 The Siros Fully Automated System with Electronic Readout at Video Rates (PRISM, 1996) All previous demonstrations were under software control with off-line data retrieval. Although it is well recognized that software procedures can often be implemented in electronic hardware, there are many practical issues that make such an implementation far from trivial. At Siros, primarily through the efforts of Bob Okas and Ray Snyder in cooperation with GTE as part of the PRISM consortium effort, a fully electronic readout and control system was implemented in 1996. We believe that this was the first demonstration of a fully automated and electronically controlled system. The block diagram of the electronic layout is shown in Figure 2.21. The electronic architecture is based on a VME bus. The optical system architecture was the same as shown in Figure 2.20. Temperature fixing in LiNbO3 was implemented for nonvolatile readout, and a total capacity
CCD
Display
TCP Frame Grabber Decoding FPGA
Warp
68040 CPU
VME
F I G U R E 2.21. Electronic block diagram for the Siros real-time video readout system.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
38
17:23
Lambertus Hesselink and Sergei S. Orlov F I G U R E 2.22. The Siros smallprototype demonstration device incorporating a 800 × 600 DMD, a 1000 × 1000 SLM, and novel optical arrangement. Capacity is limited to less than 10 GB, with a maximum transfer rate of 10 MB/sec.
of 5 MB of video data was stored and retrieved at video rates. Channel 6:8 coding, ECC RS 13:15 coding, bit shuffling, and data warping were all implemented in electronic hardware, as well as overall system control [53]. A small compact demonstration system using LiNbO3 was built primarily by Mark McDonald at Siros to show that all components could be integrated into an approximately 5.25 form factor depicted in Figure 2.22. This system includes both recording and readout optics and components. Associative data retrieval capabilities were added to the Siros 90-degree demonstration platforms, as described in Hesselink 2004.
2.9.4 The Stanford University and Siros Fully Electronic Data Readout System Achieving 1 Gbit/sec (HDSS, 1999) In previous demonstrations at Stanford and Siros, the total system capacity was limited to tens of Mbytes, with transfer rates on the order of a few MB/sec, far from being competitive with current state-of-the-art optical and magnetic drives. The HDSS consortium was formed to develop the components and the systems to demonstrate 1 Gbit/sec transfer rate and a capacity of 125 GB on a 5.25 disk. This required the development of new components and electronics. A reflective 1000 × 1000 element ferroelectric liquid-crystal device was designed and built by IBM and Display Tech capable of recording 1000 frames per second. A pixelmatched detector array was developed by Kodak, having 1000 × 1000 pixels, and a frame rate of 1000 fps using 8-bit resolution. The output of this camera is divided into 64 digital channels. A pixel-matching very low distortion Fresnel lens was designed and manufactured by Rochester Photonics to achieve less than 0.3 pixel element distortion over the full one million pixels in the field of view. A novel random phase code reference beam was coaxially placed with the imaging lens. These components were assembled in the optical set up of Figure 2.20. In the first
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
17:23
2. Digital Holographic Memories
Alignment shutter Galvo
Control
39
PCI-
SLM VME
C7 CCD Camera
Decode x16 Mux 12 streams
ECC
F I G U R E 2.23. Electronic block diagram for the 1 Gbit/sec electronics.
high-speed demonstration, a 90-degree LiNbO3 arrangement was implemented using the electronic architecture of Figure 2.23. A 6:8 channel code and a ReedSolomon 136:156 ECC code for correcting up to ten-byte errors in the sequence are used for this demonstration. A team at Stanford University and Siros consisting primarily of Robert Okas, Sergei Orlov, Xiaochun Li, Eric Bjornson, Fedor Dimov, Bill Phillips, Ray Snyder, Darren Kwan, and Yuzuru Takashima developed the first implementation of a 1 Gbit/sec electronic readout system. Six data files were recorded, five JPEG images, and one counting sequence. The counting sequence was used so that the data could be easily inspected in numerical format. Each source file was divided into two pieces, giving a total of 12 data sequences, corresponding to the 12 output byte streams. Each recorded hologram stored data at a 55% efficiency due to 6:8 encoding, RS encoding, and masking. Thus, each image of 1,048,576 pixels corresponds to 576,000 bits. When this is divided into 12 streams it gives 6 Kbytes per image per output stream. Thus our source data files, each of approximately 48 KB (split into two 24-KB sections) required four images to store. The data were stored as four holograms and retrieved with an integration time of 600 microseconds, consistent with a 1-msec frame rate. Data passed through the entire system, and the 12 parallel byte streams were collected using the full electronics and checked for accuracy. The raw error rate was 8.7 × 10−5 [8].
2.9.5 IBM HDSS Materials and System Testers A research team at IBM Almaden in California has built three holographic digital data-storage test platforms [57]. The PRISM tester [23] shown in Figure 2.24 was designed and built for the purpose of having a stable platform for testing holographic data-storage materials. It was completed in 1996 and has provided an important means for testing a wide variety of materials ranging from photopolymers to inorganic photorefractive
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
40
17:23
Lambertus Hesselink and Sergei S. Orlov Holographic storage material (suspended from above) SLM (chrome-onglass data mask)
Fourier lens
Reference beam
θ
Object beam
2θ
F I G U R E 2.24. The primary features of the IBM PRISM holographic materials test apparatus. The SLM is a chrome-on-glass mask, and the detector array is a 1024 × 1024 pixels large CCD camera. A pair of precision rotation stages allow the reference beam to enter the storage medium under test at any horizontal incidence angle.
crystals. Two additional demonstration systems were also built at IBM, the DEMON I and II in 1997, shown in Figures 2.25 and 2.26. These platforms were used to study coding approaches [65] and to study the performance of holographic systems under various conditions . For example, IBM also stored videos similar to the earlier Siros demonstrations and achieved very 640 × 480 CCD LiNbO3 storage Fourier material lens Fourier lens 640 × 480 SLM
Five-element zoom lens Reference beam Object beam Intermediate image
Galvanometrically actuated scanner
F I G U R E 2.25. Salient features of the DEMON I holographic digital data-storage engine. A five-element zoom lens demagnifies the SLM image to an intermediate image plane, which is then imaged onto the CCD detector array with a pair of lenses. This tester was designed for use with LiNbO3 media.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
17:23
2. Digital Holographic Memories
41
1024 × 1024 CCD LiNbO3 Shortstorage focalmaterial length Fourier lens
Fourier lens
Polarizing beam splitter
Scan lenses
Reference beam Galvanometrically actuated scanner 1024 × 1024 reflective SLM
Apodizer
Object beam
F I G U R E 2.26. Primary features of the DEMON II holographic digital data-storage engine. This system has demonstrated over 100 bits/μm2 .
high data storage densities in DEMON II using LiNbO3 as a recording medium [48]. Important optical approaches were developed and tested for achieving flat topintensity profiles for the image-bearing signal beam [66] as well as methods for reducing the central spike in the object beam at the Fourier transform plane [57]. Additionally, associative retrieval methods were developed that proved superior performance of holographic-based searches over traditional digital computer searches, as described above.
2.9.6 Rockwell Ultrashort-Access-Time-Testbed Ultrashort data-access times were achieved by a team of researchers at Rockwell International Research Center in Thousand Oaks, CA, as part of the HDSS program. Using acoustooptic beam deflectors for the reference beam, access times of less than 50 microseconds were demonstrated in LiNbO3 in the 90-degree configuration as shown in Figures 2.27 and 2.28 [54, 55]. Short access times combined with associative data retrieval could provide an interesting market opportunity, since other storage devices based on rotating disks have access times of a few milliseconds, and cannot contain as much data under the head. In particular, for searching video databases such capability could be valuable. Besides these milestone demonstration platforms using LiNbO3 as the recording medium, researchers at other laboratories around the world have been investigating holographic storage in polymer-based media that take on the shape of a compact disk, and utilize architectures akin to the one shown in Figure 2.3. For
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
42
17:23
Lambertus Hesselink and Sergei S. Orlov Special ACD
Light From Laser xxx
F I G U R E 2.27. Architecture for ultrashort-access-time demonstration.
Reference Arm Arguer xxx ACD
FrequencyCompressing ACD
OCD
Image Arm LOTV
Holographic Recording Medium
example, much pioneering work has been carried out at Caltech and Holoplex, as described earlier in this chapter, as well as at Aprilis, Optware, InPhase Technologies, and others. References to this work can be found in Hesselink 2004. In this chapter we close by discussing the HDSS demonstration system that was built at Stanford University aspart of the DARPA HDSS program. It provides the highest data-transfer-rate demonstration to date, as high as 10 Gbit/sec. Since that demonstration, Aprilis has also demonstrated storage density exceeding 100 bit/μm2 , but at a much reduced data transfer rate closer to 100 Mbit/sec.
2.9.7 The Stanford University and Siros 100-GB Capacity and 1 Gbit/sec Readout System Demonstrator (1999) For thick media like LiNbO3 in the 90-degree geometry, capacity is usually limited by media dynamic range and noise rather than by multiplexing crosstalk. For thin media, such as photopolymers, however, this is not the case, and the number of superimposed holograms in a spatial location is largely determined by the limited number of degrees of freedom available for multiplexing. Angular multiplexing
F I G U R E 2.28. Photograph of Rockwell short-testbed demonstration system.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
17:23
2. Digital Holographic Memories PM600 Optical shaft encoder
Holographic photopolymer disk media
High-speed decoding electronics
43
Data out
spindle
lens
to Computer SLM
lens
C7 1000fps CCD
Computer
pulsed laser Sync. electronics
F I G U R E 2.29. Overall system layout for the HDSS WORM demonstration platform.
in the transmission geometry does not allow sufficient data storage density, and other multiplexing techniques such as shift and peristrophic multiplexing are required. Unfortunately, the displacements necessary for achieving low crosstalk in the shift-multiplexing technique are still too large and require the undesirable stop-and-go architecture for the rotating disk when a CW laser is used. To avoid this problem a very sensitive, relatively thick storage medium is required suitable for pulsed laser recording with nsec pulses. Recent developments in the DARPAfunded PRISM consortium have made great steps forward toward achieving such a medium for recording in the green region of the spectrum using a few hundred milliwatts of power. To achieve recording during constant rotation of the disk, a new multiplexing technique had to be implemented based on a phase-modulated reference beam. In such an architecture, performance can be readily analyzed and compared with more conventional technologies. In the system currently under test at Stanford University, densities of over 70 bits/μm2 are expected for a total system capacity of 125 GB and a transfer rate of 1 Gbit/sec using the electronics described above. The overall architecture for this system is shown in Figure 2.29. A 1024 × 1024 pixel-matched (12.8 μm square) 1000 fps Kodak C7 and IBM LC display are used as a detector and page composer respectively. Recording and readout are done using a pulsed doubled Nd:YAG laser (532-nm wavelength, 500-μJ/pulse, pulse width 25 nsec). A rotating holographic photopolymer disk is mounted on a precision air-bearing spindle. Typical rotation rate is 300 RPM. The angular addressing is done using a precision optical shaft encoder (16,384 counts per revolution). With appropriate synchronization electronics, the stability of the disk rotation speed and timing accuracy of the shaft encoder and laser pulses allow us to address different angular positions on the disk with overall positioning repeatability of better than ±0.1 μm. Different radial positions are addressed via moving the spindle with mounted disk using 25-nm resolution Newport PM600 translation stage. The HDSS WORM demonstration platform is shown in Figures 2.30 and 2.31.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
44
17:23
Lambertus Hesselink and Sergei S. Orlov
Reference Beam Diffuser SLM Diffuser
CCD FT Lens 1 Object Beam
FT Lens 2 Photo-polymer Disk Media
F I G U R E 2.30. Optical layout for the HDSS WORM demonstration platform.
The areal information density D (raw) for holographic disk storage can be approximated as 2 d × N, (2.36) D= ζ λF where d is the size of the SLM, λ is the wavelength of light, F is the focal length of the imaging optics, ζ is a dimensionless parameter that relates the actual hologram size to the Nyquist limit (typical values used in holographic storage systems are within the range from 1.1 to 1.6 depending on the image quality requirements), N is the number of holograms superimposed in the same storage location using different multiplexing techniques. The number of holograms that can be superimposed is limited by a variety of parameters such as required transfer rate (i.e., photon budget), material dynamic range (i.e., M/#), scatter, and information crosstalk. In order to achieve high storage density, it is therefore important to achieve high data density per hologram, which according to equation (2.36) requires a high NA for the imaging optics. The demonstration platform employs
F I G U R E 2.31. Photograph of the Stanford HDSS 1 Gbit/sec WORM demonstrator.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
17:23
2. Digital Holographic Memories
45
F I G U R E 2.32. Sample 1024 × 1024 data page (η ≈ 2 × 10−3 , right) and enlarged 48 × 48 portion of it (left).
a custom-built (by Coastal Optical Systems, Inc.) short-focal-length (17.1 mm) optical system that allows 1-Mpixel images to be relayed from SLM to CCD array with distortions of less then ±1.5 μm over the entire SLM format (13.1 mm × 13.1 mm). The total numerical aperture of 0.75 is divided between the central high-resolution, low-distortion portion (NA = 0.36) used by the SLM and the outer area used by the reference light-generating optical elements. The spot size in the photopolymer medium is ≈2mm2 , which corresponds to raw areal density per hologram of ≈0.5 bits/μm2 . In current implementation, a speckle correlation-shift multiplexing technique is used for hologram multiplexing Figures 2.4., 2.30. A sample multiplexed hologram recorded in rotating disk media and retrieved with a single laser pulse at 1000 fps is shown in Figure 2.32. The raw byte error rate is < 2 × 10−3 , which provides error-free reconstruction of data with currently used 136:156 Reed-Solomon ECC.
2.9.8 The Stanford Ultrahigh >10 Gbits/sec Optical Data Rate Demonstration (2000) In the holographic disk system at 1 Gbit/sec, the hologram signal strength largely exceeds the camera noise. Thus, the holograms can be read at much higher optical data rates, provided that the holograms can be physically transported under the optical readout head at sufficient and sustainable rates. The latter depends on the recording density and the disk linear velocity. In later experiments we achieved sustained optical data rates as high as 10 Gbit/sec [56] by increasing the optical efficiency of the optical delivery system. The storage density in these experiments was approximately 10 bits/μm2 .
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
46
17:23
Lambertus Hesselink and Sergei S. Orlov
Acknowledgments. This work was partially funded by the DARPA/NSIC/ Industry/University PRISM and HDSS Consortia. The authors acknowledge the technical contributions of and helpful discussions with the many researchers who participated in these consortia. One of us, L.H., wishes to acknowledge all the hard work done by the consortia members, present and past students, postdocs, and visitors to his group at Stanford University.
References 1. J.J. Amodei and D.L. Staebler. “Holographic pattern fixing in electrooptic crystals,” Appl. Phys. Lett. 18: 12, 540–542, 1971. 2. D.L. Staebler, W.J. Burke, W. Phillips, J.J. Amodei. “Multiple storage and erasure of fixed holograms in Fe-doped LiNbO3 ,” Appl. Phys. Lett. 26:4, 182–184, 1975. 3. V.I. Bobrinev, Z.G. Vasil’eva, E.Kh. Gulanyan, A.L. Mikaelian. “Multiple rerecording and fixation of holograms in lithium niobate crystale doped with iron,” Pis’ma v Zhurnal Eksperimental’noi i Teoreticheskoi Fiziki 18:4, 267–269, 20 Aug. 1973. Translated in JETP Letters, 18: 4, 159–160, 20 Aug. 1973. 4. D. Von der Linde, and A.M. Glass. “Multiphoton process for optical data storage in pyroelectrics,” Ferroelectrics, 10, 5–8, 1976. 5. F.S. Chen, J.T. LaMacchia, D.B. Fraser. “Holographic storage in lithium niobate,” Applied Physics Letters 13:7, 223–225, 1 Oct. 1968. 6. L. Hesselink, and M.C. Bashaw. “Optical memories implemented with photorefractive media,” Optical and Quantum Electronics 25:9, S611–S661, 1993. 7. L. Hesselink and G. Sincerbox, Principal and Co-Principal Investigators of the DARPA/NSIC/Industry, University consortia on PRISM and HDSS, 1994, 1995. 8. L. Hesselink, S. Orlov, M.C. Bashaw. “Holographic Data Storage Systems,” Proceedings of the IEEE 92:8, 1231–1280, 2004. 9. A.L. Mikaelian. “Holographic bulk memories using lithium niobate crystals for data recording,” in Optical Information Recording, E.S. Barrekette et al., eds. New York: Plenum, 1978, 2, pp. 217–233. 10. D. Psaltis and G.W. Burr. “Volume holographic memory systems: Techniques and architectures,” Computer 31, 52–60, 1998. 11. C.X.-G. Gu. “Optical neural networks using volume holography,” PhD dissertation, California Inst. Technology, Pasadena, 1990. 12. P. Yeh. Introduction to Photorefractive Nonlinear Optics. New York: Wiley, 1993. 13. M.A. Neifeld and W.C. Chou. “Information theoretic limits to the capacity of volume holographic optical memory,” Appl. Opt. 36, 514–517, 1997. 14. G.W. Burr, C.M. Jefferson, H. Coufal, M. Jurich, T.A. Hoffnagle, R.M. Macfarlane, and R.M. Shelby. “Volume holographic data storage at an areal density of 250 gigapixels/in2 ,” Opt. Lett. 26, 444–446, 2001. 15. F.H. Mok, “Angle-multiplexed storage of 5000 holograms in lithium niobate,” Opt. Lett. 18, 915–917, 1993. 16. C. Gu, J. Hong, I. McMichael, R. Saxena, and F. Mok. “Cross-talk limited storage capacity of volume holographic memory,” J. Opt. Soc. Amer. A 9, 1978–1983, 1992. 17. M.C. Bashaw, J.F. Heanue, A. Aharoni, J.F. Walkup, and L. Hesselink. “Crosstalk considerations for angular and phase-encoded multiplexing in volume holography,” J. Opt. Soc. Amer. B 11, 1820–1836, 1994.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
17:23
2. Digital Holographic Memories
47
18. E.N. Leith, A. Kozma, J. Upatnieks, J. Marks, and N. Massey. “Holographic data storage in three-dimensional media,” Appl. Opt. 5, 1303–1311, 1966. 19. AE. Krasnov. “Thick-film phase holograms recorded by means of coded reference waves,” Kvantovaya Elektron. 4, 2011–2013, 1977. English transl.: Sov. J. Quantum. Electron. 7, 1147–1148, 1977. 20. G. Barbastathis, M. Levene, and D. Psaltis. “Shift multiplexing with spherical reference waves,” Appl. Opt. 35, 2403–2417, 1996. 21. A.M. Darskii and V.B. Markov. “Shift selectivity of holograms with a reference speckle wave,” Opt. Spectrosc. (USSR) 65, 392–395, 1988. 22. S.S. Orlov. “Overview of holographic recording materials for major system architectures in holographic data storage applications,” presented at the National Storage Industry Consortium Int. Workshop Holographic Data Storage, Nice, France, 1999. 23. M.-P. Bernal, H. Coufal, R.K. Grygier, J.A. Hoffnagle, C.M. Jefferson, R.M. Macfarlane, R.M. Shelby, G.T. Sincerbox, P. Wimmer, and G. Wittmann. “A precision tester for studies of holographic optical storage materials and recording physics,” Appl. Opt. 35, 2360–2374, 1996. 24. R.M. Shelby. “Media requirements for digital holographic data storage,” in Holographic Data Storage, H. Coufal, D. Psaltis, and G.T. Sincerbox, eds. Berlin, Germany: Springer-Verlag, 2000, pp. 101–112. 25. H.W. Kogelnik. “Coupled wave theory for thick hologram gratings,” Bell Syst. Tech. J. 48, 2909–2947, 1969. 26. V.L. Vinetskii and N.V. Kukhtarev. “Theory of the conductivity induced by recording holographic gratings in nonmetallic crystals,” Fiz. Tverd. Tela: 16, 3714–3716, 1974. English transl.: Sov. Phys. Solid State, 16, 2414, 1975. 27. N.V. Kukhtarev. “Kinetics of hologram recording and erasure in electrooptic crystals,” Pis’ma Zh. Tekh. Fiz., 2, 1114–1119, 1976. English transl.: Sov. Tech. Phys. Lett. 2, 438, 1976. 28. N.V. Kukhtarev, V.B. Markov, S.G. Odulov, M.S. Soskin, and V.L. Vinetskii. “Holographic storage in electrooptic crystals. I. Steady state,” Ferroelectrics 22, 949–960, 1979. 29. G.C. Valley. “Erase rates in photorefractive materials with two photoactive species,” Appl. Opt. 22, 3160–3164, 1983. 30. G.C. Valley and J.F. Lam. “Theory of photorefractive effects in electro-optic crystals,” in Photorefractive Materials and Their Applications I, P. G¨unter and J.-P. Huignard, eds. Berlin, Germany: Springer-Verlag, 1988, pp. 75–98. 31. A. Yariv, S.S. Orlov, and G.A. Rakuljic. “Holographic storage dynamics in lithium niobate: theory and experiment,” J. Opt. Soc. Amer. B 13, 2513–2523, 1996. 32. M. Carrascosa and F. Agull´o-L´opez. “Theoretical modeling of the fixing and developing of holographic gratings in LiNbO,” J. Opt. Soc. Amer. B 7, 2317–2322, 1990. 33. G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter. “Photorefractive charge compensation at elevated temperatures and application to KNbO3 ,” J. Opt. Soc. Amer. B 10, 171–185, 1993. 34. A. Yariv, S. Orlov, G. Rakuljic, and V. Leyva. “Hologram fixing, readout, and storage dynamics in photorefractive materials,” Opt. Lett. 20, 1334–1336, 1995. 35. A. Yariv, S. Orlov, G. Rakuljic, and V. Leyva. “Hologram fixing, readout, and storage dynamics in photorefractive materials,” Opt. Lett. 20, 1334–1336, 1995. 36. S.S. Orlov and W. Phillips. “Hologram fixing and nonvolatile storage in photorefractive materials,” in Holographic Data Storage, H. Coufal, D. Psaltis, and G.T. Sincerbox, eds. Berlin, Germany: Springer-Verlag, 2000, pp. 127–148.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
48
17:23
Lambertus Hesselink and Sergei S. Orlov
37. M. Carrascosa and F. Agull´o-L´opez. “Theoretical modeling of the fixing and developing of holographic gratings in LiNbO3 ,” J. Opt. Soc. Amer. B 7, 2317–2322, 1990. 38. G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter. “Photorefractive charge compensation at elevated temperatures and application to KNbO3 ,” J. Opt. Soc. Amer. B 10, 171–185, 1993. 39. H. Kurz. “Lithium niobate as a material for holographic information storage,” Philips Tech. Rev. 37, 109–120, 1977. 40. H. Kurz. “Photorefractive recording dynamics and multiple storage of volume holograms in photorefractive LiNbO3 ,” Optica Acta 24, 463–473, 1977. 41. W.J. Burke, D.L. Staebler, W. Phillips, and G.A. Alphonse. “Volume phase holographic storage in ferroelectric crystals,” Opt. Eng. 17, 308–316, 1978. 42. J.F. Heanue, M.C. Bashaw, A.J. Daiber, R. Synder, and L. Hesselink. “Thermal fixing for digital holographic data storage,” Opt. Lett. 21, 1615–1617, 1996. 43. X. An, D. Psaltis, and G.W. Burr. “Thermal fixing of 10000 holograms in LiNbO3 ,” Appl. Opt. 38, 386–393, 1999. 44. D. von der Linde, A.M. Glass, and K.F. Rodgers. “High-sensitivity optical recording in KTN by twophoton absorption,” Appl. Phys. Lett. 26, 22–24, 1975. 45. L. Hesselink, S.S. Orlov, A. Liu, A. Akella, D. Lande, and R.R. Neurgaonkar. “Photorefractive materials for nonvolatile volume holographic data storage,” Science 282, 1089–1094, 1998. 46. D. Lande, S.S. Orlov, A. Akella, and R.R. Neurgaonkar. “Digital holographic storage system incorporating optical fixing,” Opt. Lett. 22, 1722–1724, 1997. 47. B. Marcus. “Modulation codes for holographic recording,” in Holographic Data Storage, H. Coufal, D. Psaltis, and G.T. Sincerbox, eds. Berlin, Germany: Springer-Verlag, 2000, pp. 283–292. 48. G.W. Burr and T. Weiss. “Compensation for pixel misregistration in volume holographic data storage,” Opt. Lett. 26, 542–544, 2001. 49. J.F. Heanue, K. Gurkan, and L. Hesselink. “Signal detection for page-access optical memories with intersymbol interference,” Appl. Opt. 35, 2431–2438, 1996. 50. G.W. Burr, H. Coufal, R.K. Grygier, J.A. Hoffnagle, and C.M. Jefferson. “Noise reduction of pageoriented data storage by inverse filtering during recording,” Opt. Lett. 23, 289–291, 1998. 51. F. Mok, D. Psaltis, and G. Burr. “Spatially- and angle-multiplexed holographaic random access memory,” in Proc. SPIE, Photonic Neural Networks, 1773, 334–345, 1992. 52. J.F. Heanue, M.C. Bashaw, and L. Hesselink. “Volume holographic storage and retrieval of digital data,” Science, 265, 749–752, 1994. 53. A.J. Daiber, R. Snyder, J. Colvin, R. Okas, and L. Hesselink. “Fully functional digital video holographic storage system,” presented at the Optical Soc. Amer. Annu. Meeting, Long Beach, CA, 1997, Paper ThR3. 54. J.H. Hong, I. McMichael, T.Y. Chang, W. Christian, and E.G. Paek. “Volume holographic memory systems: Techniques and architectures,” Opt. Eng. 34, 2193–2203, 1995. 55. J. Ma, T. Chang, S. Choi, and J. Hong. “Ruggedized digital holographic data storage with fast access,” Opt. Quantum Electron. 32, 383–392, 2000. 56. S.S. Orlov, W. Phillips, E. Bjornson, L. Hesselink, and R. Okas. “High data rate (10 Gbit/sec) demonstration in holographic disk digital data storage system,” Conference on Lasers and Elecro-Optics (CLEO’2002), OSA Technical Digest (Optical Society of America, Washington, DC), paper CMO2, pp. 70–71 (2002).
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
17:23
2. Digital Holographic Memories
49
57. J. Ashley, M.-P. Bernal, G.W. Burr, H. Coufal, H. Guenther, J.A. Hoffngle, C.M. Jefferson, B. Marcus, R.M. Macfarlane, and R.M. Shelby. “Holographic data storage,” IBM J. Res. Develop. 44, 341–368, 2000. 58. S. Odoulov, T. Tarabrova, A. Shumelyuk, L.I. Naumova, and T.O. Chaplina. “Photorefractive response of bulk periodically poled LiNbO3 :Y:Fe at high and low spatial frequencies,” Phys. Rev. Lett., 84, 3294–3297, 2000. 59. F.H. Mok, D. Psaltis, and G. Burr. Proc. Soc. Photo- Opt. Instrum. Eng. 1773, 334, 1992. 60. P. G¨unter and J.-P. Huignard. “Photorefractive effects and materials,” in Photorefractive Materials and Their Applications I: Fundamental phenomena, P. G¨unter and J.-P. Huignard, eds. Berlin, Germany: Springer-Verlag, 1988, pp. 7–73. 61. B. Kippelen. “Overview of photorefractive polymers for holographic data storage,” in Holographic Data Storage, H. Coufal, D. Psaltis, and G. T. Sincerbox, eds. Berlin, Germany: Springer-Verlag, 2000, pp. 159–169. 62. R. Brauer, U. Wojak, F. Wyrowski, and O. Bryngdahl. “Digital diffusers for optical holography,” Opt. Lett. 16,1427–1429, 1991. 63. W.-H. Lee. “Effect of film-grain noise on the performance of holographic memory,” J. Opt. Soc. Am. 62, 797–801, 1972. 64. J.W. Goodman. Statistical Optics. New York: Wiley, 1985. 65. G.W. Burr, J. Ashley, H. Coufal, R. Grygier, J. Hoffnagle, C. M. Jefferson, and B. Marcus. “Modulation coding for pixel-matched holographic data storage,” Opt. Lett. 22, 639–641, 1997. 66. J.A. Hoffnagle and C.M. Jefferson. “Design and performance of a refractive optical system that converts a Gaussian to a flattop beam,” Appl. Opt. 39, 5488–5499, 2000.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
15:35
3 The Transfer Function of Volume Holographic Optical Systems George Barbastathis Mechanical Engineering Department, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 77 Massachusetts Ave., Room 3-461c, Cambridge, MA 02139 USA
[email protected]
Abstract. We present a theoretical formulation for analysis and design of optical systems that utilize three—dimensional spatial heterodyning implemented by volume holograms of arbitrary shape. Basic volume holographic properties of angle, wavelength, depth selectivity and degeneracy are characterized and the impact of these properties in terms of imaging performance is discussed.
3.1 Introduction Volume holography has been one of the principal applications of the science of photorefractives. A volume hologram is essentially a three-dimensional (3D) grating, or a superposition of 3D gratings, in a “thick” holographic material. Volume holograms diffract in the Bragg regime, which means that (a) there is only one diffracted order, the +1st ; and (b) the nature of the diffracted field is strongly dependent on the probe field that illuminates the hologram, e.g., if the probe field wavelength or angle of incidence is different from the reference beam, even slightly, then the diffracted beam may become very weak or altogether absent. By contrast, “thin,” or Raman—Nath, holograms diffract into multiple orders, and generally diffract in response to any probe field. Because of its two aforementioned key properties, volume holography has been attractive for numerous coherent information processing [1] applications, including interconnects [2], data storage [3, 4], telecommunications [1], and imaging [5]. In interconnects, the Bragg selectivity is used to create large numbers of noninteracting “data paths” [6]. Similarly, Bragg selectivity in holographic memories enables the multiplexing of thousands of data pages. In optical communications, the dispersion properties of volume diffraction are used instead as filter banks for spectral multiplexers or demultiplexers. Our research group at MIT has pursued a different class of applications of volume holograms in optical imaging systems [7] as 3D Spatial Heterodyning (3DSH) elements for accurate wavefront detection. In this case, Bragg selectivity is designed to result in extreme positional or color sensitivity, which in turn enables imaging functions with 51
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
52
15:35
George Barbastathis
demanding requirements, such as high-resolution profilometry [8] and 3D imaging at long working distances [9] with minimal scanning [10], hyperspectral imaging [11, 12], etc. 3DSH belongs to a class of “computational imaging” systems that simultaneously emphasize information extraction from the “raw” optical intensity (measured by a digital camera or detector array) and the transformation of the extracted information into maximum-utility representations via digital postprocessing. For example, we have used the pseudoinverse [13, 14], Viterbi [15], and Radon transform [16] algorithms to “restore” images obtained from 3DSH instruments implemented with volume holograms. This chapter is concerned with the analog or optical part of 3DSH computational imaging systems, in particular the response of optical systems with volume holograms as imaging elements. In Section 3.2 we describe the generic format of 3DSH/volume holographic imaging systems, and the various image acquisition modes. It then becomes evident that a uniform method of characterizing the imaging system, such as a point-spread function (PSF) or transfer function formulation is necessary. This derivation is carried out in Section 3.3. The result, expressed as a 3D Fourier transform constrained on a surface, is general within the limits of weak diffraction and paraxial approximation that are used to derive it. Examples are given in Section 3.4, selected with the intention of building intuition on the new formulation and also explaining the operation of volume holograms as imaging elements in 3DSH systems. The first example, in Section 3.1, is the Bragg-matched response of the volume hologram, which indicates some rather surprising properties that can be interpreted as field-dependent apodization and superresolution. The second example is the rederivation of well-known angle and wavelength selectivity properties of holograms in Section 3.2. The intent is to validate the new formulation, and also to indicate that the detail of the diffracted field can be quite dependent on the 3D shape of the hologram. The final example is the calculation of the volume holographic response to defocus, i.e., displacement of the probe source in the longitudinal direction, which is presented in Section 3.3. The depth selectivity property of volume holograms has been the key for many of our “optical slicing” 3DSH experiments, and it follows rather simply from the formulation. The results are summarized in Section 3.5, where suggestions for future work are also brought up.
3.2 3D Spatial Heterodyning with Volume Holograms The principle of 3D spatial heterodyning is shown in Figure 3.1. The incident or “probe” beam is mixed with a local oscillator signal represented by the volume hologram. The mixing process is not a product, but rather the phenomenon of volume diffraction itself, which includes multiplication, phase conjugation, and low-pass filtering (spatial integration), as can be seen from (3.4) in Section 3.3 ahead. The reason we refer to this process as 3D spatial heterodyning is because
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
15:35
3. The Transfer Function of Volume Holographic Optical Systems
probe wavefront
volume hologram
53
lens
detector probe field
diffracted field
“local oscillator” wavefront
F I G U R E 3.1. The principle of 3D spatial heterodyning with a volume hologram.
mixing happens along the propagation direction. The 3D feature increases the sensitivity, as we will see shortly. The outcome of the 3DSH process is carried by the field diffracted by the volume hologram. Typically it is convenient to spatially Fourier transform the diffracted field and observe its intensity on a digital camera or measure the spatially integrated intensity on a photoelectric detector. We now describe how the 3DSH method can be used for imaging. The first step is to construct the mixing element, i.e., the volume hologram. The typical recording process is a sequence of exposures of a photosensitive thick holographic medium, such as a photorefractive crystal or photopolymer. Each exposure is the result of interfering two mutually coherent beams inside the holographic medium. Although the holographic recording process is the most convenient, it is not the only one. Alternatives such as 3D interferometric lithography, layered nanofabrication, and the Nanostructured OrigamiTM 3D fabrication and assembly process are likely to become practical in the future as the field of 3D nanomanufacturing advances. One advantage of these techniques is that they can be used to fabricate high-index contrast 3D structures. In this chapter we restrict the discussion to low-index contrast, which is more likely to result from holographic processes. Once recorded or fabricated, the 3DSH/volume holographic element is used as shown in Figure 3.1. Light emitted or scattered by the object of interest is the probe field, with the possible addition of “objective optics” between the object and the volume hologram. The role of objective optics is to shape the probe field to a more convenient form, which can yield advantages such as long working distance and smaller physical size of the elements [8]. It is important to emphasize that the 3DSH imaging process does not involve the recording of a hologram of the object; the role of the hologram is simply that of an optical element in the train, like a “superlens.” The result of spatially heterodyning is to form projections of the object on the camera. For example, a useful form of projection that we have used extensively
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
54
15:35
George Barbastathis visible
invisible
invisible
focal plane
h1 h1
visible
focal plane
h2 h2
F I G U R E 3.2. Optical slicing with 3DSH. Left: focus at height h 1 above ground. Right: focus at height h 2 above ground.
in our 3DSH experiments is “optical slicing,” which is described in Figure 3.2. The 3DSH element in this case can be particularly simple, such as a volume hologram recorded as the interference between two plane waves or a plane wave and a spherical wave. The 3DSH element and the objective optics are arranged so as to define a “focal plane.” Unlike traditional optical systems, however, in the 3DSH system only a slit-shaped portion of the object that intersects the focal plane is visible; the remainder of the object is invisible. In the simple object depicted in Figure 3.2, setting the focal plane at distance h 1 from the ground plane would result in a slice of the tallest surface becoming visible, as indicated on the left-hand side. Setting the focal plane at h 2 instead makes a slice of the middle-height object visible. The optical slicing principle was first implemented with a confocal microscope. In both cases, the system rejects light originating away from the focal plane. At the same time, the field of view is limited to a point (confocal microscope with pinhole at detector plane) or a slice (3DSH and confocal microscope with slit-shaped pinhole.) The rest of the object is recovered by scanning in three and two dimensions, respectively. In the confocal microscope, extensive scanning is the only option to recover the object in its entirety. 3DSH provides alternative options that reduce or eliminate scanning altogether: (i) Multiplex method [11], where the 3DSH element is multiplexed so that multiple slices from the object are simultaneously imaged on nonoverlapping segments of a large camera. This unusual imaging mode is illustrated in Figure 3.3 and was implemented in collaboration with the optics group at Caltech [11, 12]. Provided that the dynamic range of the hologram and the photon count are sufficiently high, and that the camera has enough pixels available, the entire 3D object shape can be mapped onto the 2D camera without scanning. (ii) Rainbow method [17], where the object is illuminated with a rainbow as shown in Figure 3.4. In this case each color acts as its own slit and forms independently a depth-selective image on the camera. Therefore, scanning in the depth direction only is required to recover the object in its entirety.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
15:35
3. The Transfer Function of Volume Holographic Optical Systems
55
object surface object space (voxels)
camera space (pixels)
F I G U R E 3.3. Real-time 3D imaging in the multiplex 3DSH mode. The volume holographic element defines the map between object voxels and camera pixels according to the dotted arrows in the figure. Each camera pixel appears bright if its corresponding voxel intersects with the object (i.e., if it belongs to the object’s surface in the case of reflective objects, as shown here, or if a source exists in that voxel in the case of self-luminous or fluorescent objects, as in [11, 12]).
The implementation details of these methods are beyond the scope of this work. Instead, in the next section we lay out the fundamental theory that can be used to understand the model of the operation of volume holograms as 3DSH elements for imaging.
red camera
green focal plane
focal plane
h2
h1 h1
green
red camera
h2
F I G U R E 3.4. Image formation with the rainbow 3DSH mode. All color strips are imaged simultaneously, but each is visible if it is reflected by a part of the object surface that is in focus.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
56
15:35
George Barbastathis
probe plane
x
lens
volume x′′ hologram
image x′ plane
lens
z′′ y
y′
y′′
f1
f1
f2
f2
F I G U R E 3.5. Geometry of the 4-F optical system (telescope) with volume holographic aperture filter.
3.3 Derivation of the Optical Response of Volume Holograms Figure 3.5 shows the geometry that we will be considering in this paper. It consists of a 4F system (telescope) formed by two ideal thin lenses L1, L2 of focal lengths f 1 and f 2 , respectively. At the front focal plane of L1, the light distribution is assumed to be monochromatic and spatially coherent, with wavelength λ and amplitude p(x, y). Our goal is to determine the light amplitude distribution q(x , y ) at the back focal plane of L2. This system essentially conforms with the 3DSH paradigm of Figure 3.1 with the addition of a Fourier transforming lens as objective. If a thin transparency (amplitude or phase) is placed at the shared focal plane of the lenses in Figure 3.5, the answer is well known: the transparency (also known as “pupil function”) acts as a Fourier-plane filter. The significant difference considered here is that the Fourier filter is three-dimensional (3D). As a result, the filter behavior changes qualitatively: for example, we will see that the shift-invariance property is destroyed. In return, due to the 3D nature of the amplitude modulation, we obtain more degrees of freedom in determining the filter response. Let ε(x , y , z ) denote the 3D modulation of dielectric index in the vicinity of the shared focal plane. If the modulation has a spatial carrier, i.e., it can be written in the analytic form ε(x , y , z ) = εbb (x , y , z ) × exp {iK · r },
(3.1)
where r ≡ (x , y , z ) is the Cartesian coordinate vector, K = (K x , K y , K z ) is a grating vector, and εbb (x , y , z ) is a baseband (low-frequency) modulation, then we will call ε (x , y , z ) a “volume hologram.” Herein we will be considering volume holographic types of modulations only.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
15:35
3. The Transfer Function of Volume Holographic Optical Systems
57
The field generated from the propagation of p(x, y) through L1 to the vicinity of the shared focal plane is given by x x + yy z P(x , y , z ) = exp i2π p(x, y) exp −i2π λ λ f1 2 2 (x + y )z × exp −iπ d x d y. (3.2) λ f 12 Here and in the rest of this paper we will be neglecting amplitude terms of the form 1/iλz from the expressions for spherical waves. These terms contribute little to the diffraction integrals, in comparison with the fast-varying exponentials. It is clear that P(x , y , 0) reduces to the 2D Fourier transform of p(x, y). We also define the new function g (x , y , z ) = P(x , y , z ) × ε (x , y , z ).
(3.3)
One can think of g(x , y , z ) as the radiation field emitted by an elemental point scatterer inside the volume hologram in response to the Fourier-transformed probe field. We will now show that the output field is x 2 + y 2 x y 1 √ 1− , (3.4) , , q(x , y ) = ηG λ f2 λ f 2 λ 2 f 22 where η 1 is the diffraction efficiency of the volume hologram, and G(u, v, w) is the 3D spatial Fourier transform of g(x , y , z ). From this expression we have deliberately √ neglected the undiffracted portion of the input field itself, which is simply 1 − η × p(− f 2 x /f 1 , − f 2 y /f 1 ). From now on, we will also neglect √ proportionality constants such as η from the field expressions and arbitrarily normalize the maximum (Bragg-matched) diffracted intensity to one. The necessary normalization factors will be implicit in this section’s formulas, and will be explicitly calculated in subsequent sections. We begin by calculating the diffracted field at observation coordinates (xb , yb , z b ) in the vicinity of the hologram. Under the first-order Born and paraxial approximations, the diffracted field is z b − z g(x , y , z ) exp i2π e (x b , yb , z b ) = λ 2 (xb − x ) + (yb − y )2 × exp iπ dx dy dz (3.5) λ(z b − z ) The most natural selection for zb in the above equation is z b = f 2 , i.e., to the left of and immediately adjacent to L2. This selection, as long as the hologram is confined near the shared focal plane, as shown in Figure 3.5, ensures that the paraxial approximation used in (3.5) for the free-space Green function remains valid. We have also avoided the potential singularity that would occur if z b were allowed to be inside the volume hologram. It should be noted that (3.5) is the basis
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
58
15:35
George Barbastathis
of the 3D spatial heterodyning function of the volume hologram, as we noted in Section 3.2. The system output is the field generated by L2 at its back focal plane when the illumination immediately to the left of L2 is e (xb , yb , f 2 ) according to (3.5). From basic Fourier optics we therefore obtain x x b + y yb x 2 + y 2 q(x , y ) = exp iπ exp −i2π λ f2 λ f2 × e (xb , yb , f 2 ) dxb dyb . (3.6) Combining integrals (3.5) and (3.6) and performing the xb , yb integrations first, the result is x x + y y g(x , y , z ) exp i2π q(x , y ) = λ f2 x 2 + y 2 z dx xy dz , × exp −i2π 1 − (3.7) λ 2 f 22 which is consistent with (3.4). Result (3.4) is general, within the limits of validity of our approximations. As with any linear system, of particular interest is the special case p(x, y) = δ(x − x0 ) δ(y − y0 ), which gives us the impulse response h(x , y ; x 0 , y0 ) of the system. By direct substitution to (3.2) and (3.4) we obtain 1 y0 1 x0 x y h(x , y ; x 0 , y0 ) = E , , + + λ f1 f2 λ f1 f2 1 x 02 + y02 x 2 + y 2 , (3.8) − λ 2 f 12 2 f 22 where E (u, v, w) denotes the 3D spatial Fourier transform of the dielectric modulation ε(x , y , z ). Therefore, the system input—output relation can also be written as p(x, y)h(x , y ; x, y) dx dy. (3.9) q(x , y ) = It is evident from the impulse response (3.8) that the 4F system with a volume holographic pupil filter is not shift invariant. It should also be noted that (3.4) is computationally more efficient than (3.9) because the fast Fourier transform algorithm, albeit 3D, is still faster than 2D space-variant superposition.
3.4 Examples 3.4.1 Bragg-Matched Reconstruction We now turn to the first specific use of the general formulation described above. We will calculate the response of the volume hologram under “Bragg-matched”
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
15:35
3. The Transfer Function of Volume Holographic Optical Systems
59
probing, which is defined as a probe field that exactly phase-conjugates the reference beam used to record the hologram. Consider a signal hologram recorded as the interference of two mutually coherent reference and fields pf (x, y) and qs (x, y), respectively, formed at the input plane during the recording phase of the hologram. In the vicinity of the Fourier plane, the fields are transformed as Pf (x , y , z ) = dx dy pf (x, y) (x 2 + y 2 ) z x x + y y × exp −iπ exp −i2π , (3.10) λ f1 λ f 12 Q s (x , y , z ) = dx dy qs (x, y) x x + y y (x 2 + y 2 ) z exp −i2π . (3.11) × exp −iπ λ f1 λ f 12 As a result of the exposure, the refractive index of the holographic material is modulated according to |Pf + Q s |2 = |Pf |2 + |Q s |2 + Pf∗ Q s + Pf Q s ∗ .
(3.12)
Only the third term is relevant for Bragg-matched reconstruction. It can be shown that the remaining three terms are Bragg-mismatched, so we will neglect them from now on. Therefore, we write the dielectric modulation as ε(x , y , z ) = Pf ∗ (x , y , z ) Q s (x , y , z ) s (x , y , z ),
(3.13)
where the “hologram shape” function s(x , y , z ) is defined as 1, if r is inside the hologram, s(x , y , z ) = 0, otherwise.
(3.14)
In the narrowest definition, Bragg-matching is obtained if the hologram is probed with a field identical to the reference beam, i.e., p(x, y) = pf (x, y). Substituting into (3.9) and carrying out the integrations, we find that 1 dx dy qs (x, y) q(x , y ) = V 1 x 1 y 1 x 2 + y 2 x y x 2 + y2 ×S , , , + + − λ f2 f1 λ f2 f1 λ 2 f 22 2 f 12 (3.15) where the normalization factor V equals the hologram volume V = s(x , y , z ) dx dy dz .
(3.16)
Result (3.15) confirms the action of the volume hologram as a shift-variant
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
60
15:35
George Barbastathis
filter because of its 3D nature, namely, the third argument of the superposition kernel S(., ., .). It is evident that a thin transparency or diffractive element would have a shape function of the form s(x , y , z ) = s⊥ (x , y )δ(z ), and so its Bragg-matched response would reduce to the well-known result 1 x 1 y 1 x y , , + + dx dy qs (x, y) S⊥ q(x , y ) = V⊥ λ f2 f1 λ f2 f1 (3.17) where V⊥ denotes the hologram aperture s⊥ (x , y ) dx dy . V⊥ =
(3.18)
Returning to the 3D result expressed by (3.15), we define x − x , 2 y − y yˆ = , 2
xˆ =
(3.19) (3.20)
and without loss of generality, we assume that the system has unit magnification, i.e., f1 = f 2 ≡ f . We can then rewrite the superposition integral (3.15) as 1 q(x , y ) = dx dy qs (x, y) V ˆ + x) + yˆ (y + y) x + x y + y x(x ×S , , . (3.21) λf λf λf 2 We now assume that the superposition kernel assumes significant values only in the vicinity of the Gaussian image (x , y ) = −(x, y). Then, the variation of the superposition kernel within that region is primarily due to arguments x + x and y + y, rather than xˆ and yˆ . If we approximate xˆ and yˆ as constant over the region of integration, then indeed (3.21) looks like a convolution integral with position-variant PSF 1 x y xˆ x + yˆ y h(x, y) = S , , . (3.22) V λf λf λf 2 The assumptions that led us to this formulation are very similar to the familiar practice of quoting a field-dependent modulation transfer function (MTF) in optical engineering analysis. In the same spirit, we rewrite (3.21) in the spatial frequency domain (u, v) as ˆ yˆ ). Q(u, v) ≈ Q s (u, v) H (u, v; x,
(3.23)
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
15:35
3. The Transfer Function of Volume Holographic Optical Systems
61
ˆ yˆ ) is the field-dependent amplitude-transfer function The function H (u, v; x, (ATF), given by x y xˆ x + yˆ y 1 ˆ yˆ ) = F(x,y) S , , , (3.24) H (u, v; x, V λf λf λf 2 where F(x,y) denotes Fourier transformation with respect to (x, y). A straightforward calculation yields xˆ z yˆ z H (u, v; v, ˆ yˆ ) = dz s −λ f u − , −λ f v − ,z . (3.25) f f ˆ yˆ ) is a projection of the hologram shape function through Therefore, H (u, v; x, the straight line defined by equations xˆ z , f yˆ z y = −λ f v − , f
x = −λ f u −
(3.26) (3.27)
in the 3D hologram space. To interpret result (3.25), we consider the specific case of a rectangular hologram, which we further simplify by neglecting one lateral dimension. Thus, we take z x rect , (3.28) s(x , z ) = rect a L where a is the hologram aperture and L is the hologram thickness. The projection lines (3.26–3.27) for this case are illustrated graphically in Figure 3.6 for two spatial frequencies u 1 , u 2 , and several field locations xˆ1 through xˆ5 . The field-dependent ATF can be calculated explicitly from this picture, or by direct volume hologram
probe x plane ^x1
lens
x′′
H(u1 ; x^5) H(u1 ; x^1)
image plane
lens λf u1 λf u2
x′
z′′
H(u2 ; x^1)
^x5
H(u2 ; x^5) f
f
a L
f
f
F I G U R E 3.6. Illustration of the spatial frequency projections through the hologram, as described by (3.28)–(3.29). This picture also explains the shift variance of the volume holographic optical system in Bragg-matched condition.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
62
15:35
George Barbastathis
substitution into (3.25). For small fields ⎧ 0, ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ f a 1 ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ + + λf u , ⎪ ⎨2 ˆ 2 L|x| ˆ ≈ 1, H (u; x) ⎪ ⎪ f a 1 ⎪ ⎪ + + λ f u , ⎪ ⎪ ˆ 2 L|x| ⎪ ⎩2 0,
ˆ < a f we obtain L|x| if u < −u c (1 + α); if − u c (1 + α) < u < −u c (1−α); if −u c (1 − α) < u < u c (1 − α); if − u c (1 − α) < u < u c (1 + α); if u > u c (1 + α), (3.29)
where we used uc =
a 2λ f
(3.30)
for the cutoff frequency of the equivalent thin clear aperture, and α=
ˆ L|x| <1 af
(3.31)
for the correction to the band edge due to the hologram thickness L. We will refer to α as the “field-dependent apodization parameter” for reasons that will become obvious shortly. For large fields α > 1 we obtain ⎧ 0, if u < −u c (1 + α); ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ 1 f a ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ + λ f u , if − u c (1 + α) < u < u c (1 − α); ⎪ + ˆ ⎪ 2 L|x| 2 ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨ af , if u c (1 − α) < u < −u c (1 − α); ˆ H (u; x) ≈ L|x| ˆ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ f a ⎪1 ⎪ ⎪ + − λ f u , if − u c (1 − α) < u < u c (1 + α); ⎪ ⎪ ˆ 2 2 L|x| ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ 0, if u > u c (1 + α). (3.32) Finally, on-axis equation (3.25) reduces to
u . H (u; 0) ≈ rect 2u c
(3.33)
The effect of the third dimension is seen in Figures 3.7 and 3.8. The Braggmatched volume hologram acts as an apodizer that smoothens and reduces the PSF side lobes off-axis. For α > 1 we also observe significant narrowing of the main lobe of the PSF, which is attributed to the considerable broadening of the spatial bandwidth due to the long-haul projections at these points (see Figure 3.6.) This “superresolution” phenomenon has never been reported before to the author’s knowledge.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
15:35
H 1 u −uc uc −uc (1+ α) −u uc (1+ α) (1− α) u (1− α) c c (i) H
1/α u uc −uc uc (1− α) −uc (1− α)
−uc (1+ α)
uc (1+ α)
(ii) F I G U R E 3.7. Shift-variant transfer function of Bragg-matched hologram for (i) α < 1; (ii) α > 1. 1 xhat =0 xhat =500λ xhat =1,500λ
0.9 0.8
q(x′) [a.u.]
0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 −10
5
0 x′−xhat [λ]
5
10
F I G U R E 3.8. Shift-variant PSF for a = 103 λ, f = 2.5 × 103 λ, L = 2 × 103 λ, and three ˆ different values of x.
63
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
64
15:35
George Barbastathis
3.4.2 Angular and Wavelength Detuning We now consider the case of a volume hologram recorded in the system of Figure 3.5 with two mutually coherent reference and signal point sources of wavelength λf located at xf and x s on the input plane. Using the paraxial approximation, it is easy to see that the volume hologram recorded by the two resulting plane waves is then expressed as x2 − x2 2π xs − xf −x s(x , y , z ). (3.34) ε(x , y , z ) = exp i + z f 2 s λf f1 2 f1 We probe this hologram with a point source of wavelength λ located at x on the input plane. For later convenience, we define the normalized wavelength μ=
λ λf
(3.35)
and the lateral magnification of the 4F system m=
f2 . f1
(3.36)
Substituting in (3.3) and Fourier-ransforming, we obtain x s2 − xf2 + x 2 /μ xs − xf + x/μ 1 − G(u, v, w) = S u − . , v, w − λf f 1 λ 2λf f 12 (3.37) According to (3.4) we obtain the hologram response (x + μmx s ) + m(x − μxf ) y √ , , q(x , y ) = ηS λ f2 λ f2 (μm 2 xs2 − x 2 ) + m 2 (x 2 − μx f2 ) . 2λ f 22
(3.38)
To interpret (3.38) we first locate the Gaussian image of the probe point source by setting the first two arguments equal to zero: x = −μmxs − m(x − μxf ), y = 0.
(3.39) (3.40)
Substituting into (3.38), we find that the field qG at the Gaussian image is μ(1 − μ)xs2 − μ(1 + μ) xf2 + 2μ (μxs x f − x x s + x x f ) √ qG = ηS 0, 0, . 2λ f 12 (3.41) Since s(x , y , z ) is an index function, its Fourier transform has the property |S (u, v, w)| ≤ |S(0, 0, 0)|
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
15:35
3. The Transfer Function of Volume Holographic Optical Systems
65
for |u| + |v| + |w| > 0. It follows that the third argument in (3.41) above expresses Bragg mismatch, in other words, the decrease in diffracted power when xp = xf . We can see this more clearly by examining a few special cases: (a) Angle selectivity of slab-shaped hologram. We select the probe wavelength to equal the recording wavelength, i.e., μ = 1, and set x = xf + x. We also select the hologram shape as y z x s (x , y , z ) = rect rect rect . (3.42) a b L Using the same normalization as in (3.15), we find that (x s − x f )x , qG (x) = sinc λ f 12
(3.43)
which is consistent, in the paraxial approximation, with standard derivations that assume infinite hologram aperture. For example, the angular deviation corresponding to the first Bragg null is given by λf f 1 x = . f1 L xs − xf At arbitrary locations (x , y ) in the output plane, the field is given by y (x + mx s ) + m(x − xf ) sinc b q(x , y ) = sinc a λ f2 λ f2 2 2 2 2 2 2 (m x s − x ) + m (x − x f ) × sinc L . 2λ f 22
(3.44)
(3.45)
It is evident from (3.45) that the yˆ dimension is completely uncoupled from the Bragg-mismatch effect in this geometry. This is sometimes referred to as out-ofplane Bragg degeneracy.” Figure 3.9 shows the Bragg-matched response plotted against the probe location x and output coordinate x . As the probe is displaced away from its matched position x = x f , the Gaussian image is displaced in the opposite direction and is attenuated because of Bragg mismatch. The main lobe of the diffracted pattern remains approximately unchanged, but the side lobes can be seen to depend significantly on the amount of Bragg mismatch. This phenomenon has been typically neglected in interpage crosstalk calculations, which have instead approximated the diffraction pattern without taking into account the 3D nature of the pupil function. (b) Wavelength selectivity of slab-shaped hologram. We select the probe location to be identical to the recording reference source, i.e., x = xf , and the probe wavelength mismatch as μ = 1 + μ with |μ| 1. The Gaussian image location can then be identified as x = −m[xs + μ(x s − x f )], y = 0.
(3.46) (3.47)
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
66
15:35
George Barbastathis +100
x′ [λ]
+50
+0
−50
−100 +904
+952
+1000 x [λ]
+1048
+1096
F I G U R E 3.9. Bragg-mismatched PSF for angular detuning of a slab-shaped hologram with a = 500λ, L = 103 λ, xf = 103 λ, and a telescope with f 1 = f2 = 4 × 103 λ.
The Bragg-mismatched field at the Gaussian image location is qG (μ) ≈ sinc
μ (xs − xf )2 L 2λf f 12
.
(3.48)
Therefore, the wavelength selectivity is λf μ = 2 L
f1 xs − xf
2 .
(3.49)
At arbitrary locations (x , y ) in the output plane, the field in this case is given by y (x + xs (1 + μ)m) + mμx f sinc b q(x , y ) = sinc a λ f2 λ f2 ((1 + μ)m 2 x s2 − x 2 ) − m 2 μxf2 × sinc L . (3.50) 2λ f 22
Figure 3.10 shows the Bragg-mismatched response plotted against the relative wavelength μ and output coordinate x . The behavior of the diffracted field is similar to the case of angular detuning. (c) Wavelength degeneracy. We now consider the case μ = 1 and probe also displaced to a new location x = xf + x. The field at the Gaussian image
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
15:35
3. The Transfer Function of Volume Holographic Optical Systems
67
+200
x′ [λ]
+100
+0
−100
−200 0.808
0.904
1.000 μ
1.096
1.192
F I G U R E 3.10. Bragg-mismatched PSF for wavelength detuning and optics as in Figure 3.9.
is then qG (μ, x) ≈ sinc
μ(1 − μ) m 2 (x s2 + xf2 ) + 2μ m 2 (x s − xf )x L 2λ f 22
, (3.51)
from which we find that if the probe displacement satifies x =
(μ − 1)(xs2 + x f2 ) , 2(xf − xs )
(3.52)
then the diffracted power is maximized. This condition is known as “wavelength Bragg degeneracy,” and it has been used for nondestructive readout of holograms at wavelengths where the material sensitivity to photoexposure is very small. (d) Parallelepiped-shaped hologram. Very often the result of recording a volume hologram with limited-size beams is a parallelepiped shape, as shown in Figure 3.11. This is because the hologram is recorded only in the region where the signal and reference beams overlap. The question then arises, does this strange shape impact the performance of the volume hologram as imaging element? It can be seen that the hologram shape in this case can be written as y z x − θf z rect rect , (3.53) s(x , y , z ) = rect a B L where θf ≡ xf / f 1 in the paraxial approximation. Substitution into (3.4) and a straightforward integration yield y q(x , y ) = sinc (Aα) sinc B sinc (L(θf α + β)) , (3.54) λ f2
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
68
15:35
George Barbastathis F I G U R E 3.11. Parallelepiped-shaped hologram due to finite size of the reference and signal beams.
x′′ θs
z′′
a
L
where we have used the shorthand (x + μmxs ) + m(x − μxf ) , α= λ f2 (μm 2 x s2 − x 2 ) + m 2 (x 2 − μxf2 ) β= . 2λ f 22
(3.55) (3.56)
It is readily shown that the Gaussian image location and Bragg selectivities are identical to those derived earlier for the rectangular hologram. However, the point-spread function is quite different, as can be seen in Figures 3.12 and 3.13, +100
x′ [λ]
+50
+0
−50
−100 +904
+952
+1000 x [λ]
+1048
+1096
F I G U R E 3.12. Bragg-mismatched PSF for angular detuning of a parallelepipe-shaped hologram with all other parameters as in Figure 3.9.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
15:35
3. The Transfer Function of Volume Holographic Optical Systems
69
+200
x′ [λ]
+100
+0
−100
−200 0.808
0.904
1.000 μ
1.192
1.096
F I G U R E 3.13. Bragg-mismatched PSF for wavelength detuning of a parallelepipedshaped hologram with all other parameters as in Figure 3.9.
which describe the effect of angular and wavelength detuning, respectively. Notice in particular the change in side-lobe structure, which makes this situation unappealing for imaging applications.
3.4.3 Longitudinal Detuning (Defocus) Consider again a hologram recorded by two plane waves as in (3.34). In this section, we will consider a cylinder-shaped hologram with radius R and thicknes L, i.e.,
s(x , y , z ) = circ
x 2 + y 2 R
rect
z L
.
(3.57)
For further simplicity, we assume that the signal beam is on-axis, i.e., x s = 0. We are interested in the case in which the hologram is probed by a point source onaxis displaced by z 0 in the longitudinal direction. This is the case of a defocused probe beam, which is known to lead to the depth selectivity properties of volume holographic imaging (see Section 3.2). It is straightforward to derive the field in the vicinity of the hologram as z 0 x 2 + y 2 z 0 + z exp iπ . P(x , y , z ) = exp i2π λ λ z 0 z + f 12
(3.58)
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
70
15:35
George Barbastathis
After substitution into (3.4) we arrive at the expression z x 2 + y 2 q(x , y ) = dz rect dx dy circ L R × exp iπ A(z )(x 2 + y 2 ) − i2π Bx x + B y y + iπC z , (3.59) where z0 , λ(z 0 + f 12 ) x xf + , Bx = λ f 2 λf f 1 y By = , λ f2 xf2 x 2 + y 2 C= − . λ f 22 λf f 12 A(z ) =
z
(3.60) (3.61) (3.62) (3.63)
The integral in (3.59) can be simplified [5] as z q(x , y ) = dz rect F 2π A(z )R 2 , 2π B R exp {iπC z }, (3.64) L where B = Bx2 + B y2 and the function F(., .) is the field distribution near the focus of an ideal quadratic lens [8]. The last equation can be numerically integrated using the asymptotic expansions for F(., .) found in (8.8.17a–b), (8.8.20a–b) of [18]. The effect of defocus on the volume holographic optical system is seen in Figure 3.14 for three successive values of z 0 . For small defocus, the response is the familiar disk shape obtained from geometrical optics with a “blinking spot” in the center and ripples near the edge due to diffraction. As the defocus increases, so does the radius of the disk at the image plane, but simultaneously a second effect becomes evident: the disk is screened by a slitlike function. The slit was explained in [10] as a consequence of the Bragg selectivity of the hologram and was derived approximately using geometrical arguments. The derivation given here is more rigorous, since it takes diffraction effects fully into account within the paraxial approximation. The function of the hologram with defocused input can be explained with the help of Figure 3.15. The longitudinally displaced source produces a small disk Dp of spatially coherent illumination at the entrance plane of the optical system. The disk Dp can be thought of as the equivalent input to which the system is responding, in lieu of the true point source. Without the volume hologram, the telescope would have produced an image Di with radius equal to the radius of Dp multiplied by the lateral magnification m. However, if the defocus is sufficiently
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
15:35
z0 =64λ (i)
100
y′ (λ)
50
0
−50
−100 −1100
−1050
−1000
−950
−900
−900
−800
x′ (λ) (ii)
200
y′ (λ)
100
0
−100
−200 −1200
−1100
−1000 x′ (λ)
F I G U R E 3.14. Defocused response for a slab-shaped hologram with a = 103 λ, L = 103 λ, x f = 103 λ, and a telescope with f 1 = f 2 = 4 × 103 λ. The values of defocus and maximum intensity are (i) z 0 = 64λ, Imax ≈ 10−2 ; (ii) z 0 = 200λ, Imax ≈ 10−3 ; (iii) z 0 = 400λ, Imax ≈ 5 × 10−4 . The Bragg-matched maximum intensity is normalized to 1.
71
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
72
15:35
George Barbastathis (iii)
200
y′ (λ)
100
0
−100
−200 −1200
−1100
−1000 x′ (λ)
−900
−800
F I G U R E 3.14. (Continued)
large, then part of Dp is outside the Bragg range x that was derived in (3.44) of example (a) in Section 3.4.2 above. The Bragg-mismatched part of the disk is not imaged by the hologram; the remaining part that does get imaged looks like a slit oriented along the degenerate direction yˆ cut out of the disk Di . The effect of wavelength change on the defocused reconstruction is more complicated. Examples with mismatched wavelength are given in Figure 3.16. It can be seen that for sufficiently large defocus, the probe color can become Bragg matched
probe x plane 2Δ x probe D p source
lens
volume x′′ hologram
image x′ plane
lens
z′′ y
Bragg matched
Di y′
y′′
image
Bragg mismatched f1
f1
f2
F I G U R E 3.15. Schematic explanation of the defocused response.
f2
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
(i)
15:35
100
y′ (λ)
50
0
−50
−100 −1300
(ii)
−1250
−1200 x′ (λ)
−1150
−1100
−1300
−1200 x′ (λ)
−1100
−1000
200
y′ (λ)
100
0
−100
−200 −1400
F I G U R E 3.16. Defocused response as in Figure 3.14 with additional wavelength detuning μ = 1.2 and (i) z 0 = 64λ, Imax ≈ 10−2 ; (ii) z 0 = 200λ, Imax ≈ 2 × 10−3 ; (iii) z 0 = 400λ, Imax ≈ 3 × 10−2 .
73
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
74
15:35
George Barbastathis (iii)
200
y′ (λ)
100
0
−100
−200 −1400
−1300
−1200 x′ (λ)
−1100
−1000
F I G U R E 3.16. (Continued)
due to the color degeneracy effect described in example (c) of Section 3.4.2 above. A complete analysis of this effect is beyond the scope of this discussion, but it suffices to say that the effect is rather weak because only the Bragg-matched fraction of the defocused power is very small.
3.5 Conclusions and Discussion We have presented what is, to our knowledge, the first-ever analysis of a 3D spatial heterodyning imaging system with volume holographic pupil function. We derived the general-purpose formula (3.4), which can be used to compute the diffracted field of arbitrarily shaped holograms in response to arbitrary input fields. We applied the new formulation to rederive well-known angular, wavelength, and depth selectivity results. In the case of depth detuning in particular, we obtained a new expression that fully takes into account diffraction effects and also explains the ringing and wavelength degeneracies that have been observed in experimental implementations. Finally, a surprising effect of shift-variant response and superresolution in the Bragg-matched response was predicted. These observations support the argument that volume holograms are among the most powerful optical elements available to shape the optical response in
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
15:35
3. The Transfer Function of Volume Holographic Optical Systems
75
computational imaging systems. This property is particularly promising in the context of 3D imaging, where volume holograms have already proven successful in applications demanding with respect to high resolution. long working distance, and real-time and hyperspectral operation. The possibilities are by no means exhausted. For example, one can use the formulation derived herein to design phase- or amplitude-apodized holograms, chirped holograms, etc. It would also be extremely fruitful to combine the results of the present essentially Fourierbased approach with the photorefractive model and jointly optimize the optical design and material response. Acknowledgments. The author is grateful to Arnab Sinha and Kehan Tian for useful comments and assistance with the simulations. This research was supported by the Air Force Office of Scientific Research, the National Science Foundation Center for Materials Science and Engineering at MIT, and the Army Research Office Institute for Soldier Nanotechnologies at MIT.
References 1. Psaltis, D. Coherent optical information systems. Science 298, 1359–1363 (2002). 2. Psaltis, D., Brady, D., Gu, X.G., and Lin, S. Holography in artificial neural networks. Nature 343(6256), 325–330 (1990). 3. Li, H.-Y.S. and Psaltis, D. Three dimensional holographic disks. Appl. Opt. 33(17), 3764–3774, June (1994). 4. Heanue, J.F., Bashaw, M.C., and Hesselink, L. Volume holographic storage and retrieval of digital data. Science 265(5173), 749–752 (1994). 5. Barbastathis, G. and Brady, D.J. Multidimensional tomographic imaging using volume holography. Proc. IEEE 87(12), 2098–2120 (1999). 6. Lee, H., Gu, X.-G., and Psaltis, D. Volume holographic interconnections with maximal capacity and minimal cross talk. J. Appl. Phys. 65(6), 2191–2194, March (1989). 7. Sinha, A., Liu, W., Psaltis, D., and Barbastathis, G. Imaging with volume holograms. Opt. Eng. 43(9), 1959–1972, (2004). 8. Sinha, A. and Barbastathis, G. Volume holographic imaging for surface metrology at long working distances. Opt. Express 11, 3202–3209 (2003). 9. Sinha, A. and Barbastathis, G. Volume holographic telescope. Opt. Lett. 27, 1690– 1692 (2002). 10. Sinha, A., Sun, W., Shih, T., and Barbastathis, G. Volume holographic imaging in the transmission geometry. Appl. Opt. 43, 1533–1551 (2004). 11. Liu, W., Psaltis, D., and Barbastathis, G. Real time spectral imaging in three spatial dimensions. Opt. Lett. 27, 854–856 (2002). 12. Liu, W., Psaltis, D., and Barbastathis, G. Volume holographic hyperspectral imaging. Appl. Opt. 43(19), 3581–3599, (2004). 13. Sinha, A., Sun. W., Shih. T., and Barbastathis, G. n-ocular holographic 3D imaging. In OSA Annual Meeting (Orlando, FL, 2002). paper WD7.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
76
15:35
George Barbastathis
14. Barbastathis, G. and Sinha, A. n-ocular volume holographic imaging. In Cooperative Control: Models, Applications and Algorithms, Butenko, S., Murphey, R., and Pardalos, P. M., editors, 1–21. Kluwer Academic (2003). 15. Sun, W., Sinha, A., Barbastathis, G., and Neifeld, M.A. Volume holographic image restoration with the Viterbi algorithm. In Conf. on Lasers and Eletro-Optics (2004). 16. Shih, T. Volume holographic imaging of transparent 3D objects. B.S. thesis, Massachusetts Institute of Technology (2004). 17. Sun, W. and Barbastathis, G. Rainbow volume holographic imaging. In Conf. on Lasers and Eletro–Optics (2004). 18. Born, M. and Wolf, E. Principles of Optics. Pergamon Presss, 7th edition (1998).
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4 Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing∗ M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter Nonlinear Optics Laboratory, Institute of Quantum Electronics, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, ETH H¨onggerberg, 8093 Z¨urich, Switzerland
The field of three-dimensional optical storage has lately witnessed a tremendous increase of interest from both the scientific and the industrial communities. Volume holographic storage was proposed by van Heerden [1] shortly after the introduction of the laser, and interest in this technology has continued at varying degrees of intensity since. Holography potentially combines the advantages of high storage densities and ease of parallel data readout. The storage of multiple pages of information in the same volume and the parallel readout of many bits promise fast data access times and a high data bandwidth. Furthermore, in holography the information is distributed throughout the storage medium and is therefore less sensitive to local material imperfections. If Fourier holograms are stored in holographic memories, effects of imperfections in the medium are distributed throughout the page, and are not linked to individual pixels; thus valuable bits of data are not lost, and only the signal-to-noise ratio is diminished. This is in contrast to magnetic and conventional optical recording, where an individual bit of information is represented by a highly localized change in some physical property. This advantage may be less important in holographic digital data storage when additional redundancy of information storage and error correction can be easily implemented. Optical data storage currently finds commercial viability mainly in twodimensional low-cost data distribution on CD ROM (optical disk) and in quasiarchival storage on removable disk read–write drives (magnetooptical disk). Both of these technologies were made possible with the development of low-cost diode lasers in the past twenty years. An example of quasi-three-dimensional optical data storage is the new digital versatile disk (DVD) standard, where improvement in storage capacity with respect to CD ROMs is due to smaller bit size (shorter wavelength), reduction of the storage area sacrified for tolerances, and the use of more than one layer as storage plane. Volume holographic storage has been almost ∗ This chapter is reproduced from: P. G¨unter, Ed, Nonlinear Optical Effects and Materials (Springer Series in Optical Sciences 72, Chapter 5), Springer Verlag Berlin (2000).
77
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
78
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter
completely absent in the data storage market up to now. It has been incorporated only in a limited way into specialized commercial systems. One of the reasons for renewed interest in holographic data storage is improved input/output (I/O) technologies such as liquid-crystal spatial light modulators and integrated detector arrays that are capable of delivering high data bandwidth. The absence of these elements put a strong brake on the development of this technology in the past. The next few years will tell us whether volumetric data storage will make it possible to overcome the current I/O bottleneck in digital computers, where the processor speed far exceeds the ability of conventional rotating disk devices to import or export the data needed for manipulations. Other than for high-speed retrieval of data in a holographic memory system, the high parallelism of optical beams is also very attractive for computationally intensive data processing tasks, such as pattern recognition, edge enhancement, and spatial filtering, where vast amounts of data (a two-dimensional image is considered as a data page) have to be processed. Optical pattern-recognition systems are being developed for many applications such as identification of human pupils, partial or distorted fingerprints, robotic vision, and rapid searching of vast databases. Most of these applications make use of coherent light and the Fourier transform (FT) capability of lenses [2]. Especially, implementations of neural network models [3, 4], which are based on the structure of the human brain, are quite well suited to utilize the natural properties of light. These models of computational devices consist of many simple processing units or “neurons,” which communicate with each other via interconnection weights. Neural networks are successful in solving ill-defined problems, e.g., problems that are partially random, ill posed, or combinatorially complex, so that an algorithm cannot be easily formulated. These problems typically involve processing vast amounts of information, preferably in parallel, and often result in answers that need not be of high numerical accuracy. Communication and parallelism are more important than the computing power of individual neurons. Ideally, the architecture of a neural-network computer should reflect the highly parallel, associative, and nonlinear analog nature of the neural-network models. One approach to achieving such an architecture is to use optics for parallel communication and massive interconnection between a large number of processing units represented by planes of pixels having nonlinear optical properties. A sophisticated aspect of analog optical computing that is based on neural network architectures is that of associative memories (AM) [3]. In contrast to usual computer memories, where a separate unique address points to each stored datum (location addressing), in associative memories the output data is recalled directly using the input data itself (content addressing), without the use of separate addresses. Data can flow through the system, exciting chains of associations until a decision is reached in a global and parallel manner. Associative memories also have error-correction properties in that a complete undistorted set of data can be retrieved using a distorted or partial version of input data. In this chapter we discuss holographic memory systems with a particular emphasis on their applications to optical pattern recognition and associative memories. The problematics of volume digital data storage for computer memories
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing
79
is scratched only at the surface, and the interested reader is referred to some recent excellent reviews on this topic [5–9]. Stronger attention is given to implementations of optical processing and associative memory systems that use volume holograms recorded with the photorefractive effect, which is described in Chapter 4 of this book. For lack of space, optical associative memories based on matrix–vector multiplication (see, for instance, [10–13]) or more general optical neural network architectures [14] capable of learning will not be discussed here. The structure of this chapter is as follows. The first part (Sections 4.1 to 4.3) presents a general introduction to holographic data storage, optical pattern recognition, and holographic associative memories, respectively. In the second part (Sections 4.4 to 4.6) the same three topics are discussed by considering in detail implementations based on photorefractive materials. Section 4.1 reviews some recent advances in volumetric data storage, in which the storage capacity is discussed in relation to system architecture and multiplexing schemes. Section 4.2 focuses on optical pattern-recognition systems and discusses specific features of architectures based on volume holograms. Section 4.3 gives a general discussion of linear and nonlinear holographic associative memories. Section 4.4 considers photorefractive materials as volume storage media. We discuss recording schemes, storage capacity, and possibilities of hologram fixing and nondestructive readout. Implementations of optical correlators using photorefractive crystals are discussed in Section 4.5, while photorefractive all-optical associative memories including a deeper discussion of a system developed in our laboratory are presented in the last section. For a detailed discussion of the photorefractive effect itself, the reader is refered to Chapter 4.
4.1 Volumetric Optical Data Storage In this section we discuss system architecture and the storage density limitations of holographic memories. This discussion concentrates on digital storage of information, i.e., each data page is composed of pixels that are either “on” or “off”, which is the most interesting case for very-large-capacity memories. However, most of the conclusions are valid also for the case of analog storage of information, which is necessary for performing optical information processing, as described in Section 4.2.
4.1.1 Light Diffraction by Volume Gratings To analyze the storage capabilities of holographic volume media, we have to know the diffraction properties of volume refractive index or absorption gratings. Consider a thick holographic recording medium in which a grating has been recorded by interference of two plane waves, as shown in Figure 4.1. The grating with grating vector K = k1 − k2 can be read out using a probe beam Ii that may have the same or a different wavelength; the phase-matching conditions for the case of different wavelengths are visualized in Figure 4.1. For
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
80
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter η
nω1
I1
Ii
Id
nω2 kd ϑ0 ϑ0 ki
I2
k2 K
ζ
k1
d
F I G U R E 4.1. Schematic of holographic grating recording and readout using a readout beam of longer wavelength than the recording beams. The right side shows the wavevector diagram for isotropic Bragg diffraction. I1 , I2 , Ii , and Id are the intensities of the two recording waves and the incident and diffracted readout waves, respectively. k1 , k2 , ki , and kd are the corresponding wave vectors, K is the grating vector, and ϑ0 is the Bragg angle for readout at frequency ω2 inside the crystal.
thick gratings, one diffraction order can be observed (Bragg diffraction regime), whereas for thin gratings the light is diffracted into many diffraction orders (Raman–Nath regime). The conditions to be fulfilled in order to obtain a thick hologram have been put forward by Gaylord and Moharam [15]. They are Q≡
2πλd >1 n2
(4.1)
and λ2 ≥ 10, (4.2) n2 σ with λ the vacuum wavelength of the reading beam, d the interaction length (thickness of the medium), n the refractive index, and = 2π/|K| the grating spacing. The quantity σ is proportional to the strength (amplitude) of the grating modulation. For phase gratings one has σ = n, where n is the amplitude of the periodic refractive index modulation, for absorption gratings σ = αλ/2π, where α is the amplitude of the absorption constant modulation. Figure 4.2 depicts the conditions for a thick grating in the case of a phase grating only. The material thickness d as well as the refractive index modulation amplitude n are shown as a function of the grating spacing for the conditions corresponding to Q = 1 and ρ = 10. In order to consider a grating as thick, the interaction length and the grating modulation amplitude both have to be in the gray areas. Note that with condition (4.2) the maximum amplitude n for which a grating can still be considered as thick is approximately 10−4 already for a grating spacing of 10 μm. In thick gratings, light is diffracted only if the angle of incidence is close to the Bragg angle. This angle is derived from the phase-matching condition kd − ki = K. For the symmetric situation of Figure 4.1, the value of the angle of ρ≡
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing
81
400
d [μm]
300 200 100
Q=1
0 100 10–1
Δn
10–2
ρ = 10
10–3 10–4 10–5
0
2
4
6
8
10 12 14 16 18 20
Λ [μm]
F I G U R E 4.2. Material thickness (interaction length) d and refractive index modulation amplitude n as a function of the grating spacing. The gray areas give the regions where conditions (4.1) and (4.2) for a thick grating are fulfilled. Parameters: wavelength λ = 500 nm, refractive index n = 2.2.
incidence inside the crystal for which the Bragg condition is exactly fulfilled is given by λ . (4.3) ϑ0 = arcsin 2n The most important property of a thick hologram is its diffraction efficiency η, that is, the relative power being diffracted into the first (and single) Bragg order with respect to the total incident power in the material. A general form for η for a fixed transmission hologram with a sinusoidal refractive index modulation has been derived by Kogelnik [16] for isotropic materials using a coupled wave theory and has been extended recently to the anisotropic case by Montemezzani and Zgonik [17]. In this latter case one obtains Id (d) sin2 ν 2 + ξ 2 −2αd e , (4.4) η= = Ii (0) 1 + ξ 2 ν2 where it was assumed that both waves (Id and Ii ) are absorbed equally strongly with an amplitude absorption constant α [17]. The parameter ν is proportional to
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
82
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter
the grating strength and is defined as ν=
π nd , λ cos θ
(4.5)
where the angle θ is obtained from cos θ = (cos θ1 cos θd )1/2 , that is, from a geometric average of the projection cosines of the Poynting vector directions of the incident (θi ) and diffracted (θd ) waves onto the direction of the medium surface normal ζ of Figure 4.1. The parameter ξ describes the angular mismatch of the incident wave with respect to the perfect Bragg angle of (4.3). It is defined as kd , (4.6) 2 where k is the wave-vector mismatch and always points in the direction of the surface normal ζ . For the situation of Figure 4.1, equation (4.6) is approximated by ξ=
ϑ K d , (4.7) 2 and is expressed in terms of the grating vector magnitude K = |K| and the deviation v = v − v0 of the internal angle for the wave vector ki from the exact Bragg angle. In case of perfect Bragg matching (ξ = 0), (4.4) reduces to the well-known formula π nd 2 e−2αd . (4.8) η = sin λ cos θ ξ=
It should be noted that equations (4.4) through (4.6) as well as (4.8) are valid in general transmission geometries and include also the case of anisotropic Bragg diffraction, provided that the refractive index change amplitude n is calculated in a consistent way for the studied beam interaction [17]. Equations (4.3) and (4.7), in contrast, are specific to the symmetric geometry shown in Figure 4.1. The coupled wave theory leading to the above equations for the diffraction efficiency of transmission phase gratings can be applied also to the case of absorption or mixed absorption and phase gratings, as well as to the case of reflection-type holograms. Expressions describing all these cases for isotropic and anisotropic materials can be found in [16–18].
4.1.2 Hologram-Multiplexing Methods Utilization of the full data storage capacity of volume recording media requires hologram multiplexing. Beside the possibility of storing different holograms at different locations in a volume (spatial multiplexing), three methods have been proposed and tested to store several pages of information in the same region of the holographic medium: angular multiplexing, wavelength multiplexing, and phase multiplexing. In practice, a combination of spatial multiplexing with one of the
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing (a)
η
(b)
83
η
ksω1 ks
ksω2 K1 kR2
kR1
K2
K2
ζ
K1
ζ
kω2
kω1
F I G U R E 4.3. Wave-vector diagram of (a) angle multiplexing by deflecting the reference beams and (b) wavelength multiplexing.
other multiplexing techniques seems to be ideal. Stacks of pages will be recorded in relatively small regions of the medium, because this approach allows stacks to be recorded and erased without affecting other regions of the storage volume. Angular, phase, and wavelength multiplexing will be discussed shortly. (A) Angular Multiplexing For angular multiplexing, each page of information is addressed by a particular angle at which the reference wave (usually a plane wave) illuminates the holographic material. In the recording step, object pages (all having the same average wave vector kS ) are recorded each using a slightly different wave-vector direction kR for the reference wave (see Figure 4.3a) [1]. To read out a specific stored object, the hologram is illuminated with the reference beam under the angle that was used to create the hologram. The holographic systems discussed in the second part of this chapter are mostly based on this multiplexing technique. The good angle selectivity of angular multiplexed holograms is a direct consequence of using thick gratings; the minimum angle separation between neighboring reference waves can be easily derived from (4.4). Let us consider a holograms with a moderate grating strength (ν 1) as encountered in multiplexing a large number of pages. Then the diffraction efficiency falls to half of its peak value if the mismatch parameter is ξ ≈ 1.39. With (4.7) and K = 4πn sin ϑ0 /λ, one finds that for a symmetric geometry as in Figure 4.1, this value of ξ corresponds to an angular mismatch of ϑ = 2.78λ/(4πnd sin ϑ0 ) and is therefore inversely proportional to the grating thickness d. For an internal incidence angle ϑ0 = 20◦ , λ = 0.5 μm, n = 2.2, and d = 2 mm, one has ϑ ≈ 0.004◦ , so that approximately 1000 holograms can be recorded and independently read out by a total angular displacement on the order of 5◦ inside the medium. It should be noted that most implementations of digital holographic storage by angle multiplexing use an interaction angle of nearly 90◦ between the beams. This has the big advantage of a reduced scattering noise as well as a slightly better angle resolution.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
84
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter
In addition to the above-described method of changing the reference-beam angle of incidence, angular multiplexing can also be achieved by keeping a fixed crossing angle between the recording beams and rotating the storage medium between consecutive recordings. Each hologram in this orientation multiplexing is again characterized by a differently oriented main grating vector K. The readout address of each hologram is given by the orientation of the probe beam relative to the sample. Peristrophic multiplexing [19], a method whereby the hologram is rotated around the surface normal of the sample, is only one of the many possible variations. Although angular multiplexing requires accurate control of each reference angle for a good reconstruction of the stored objects, it is the most often used and investigated multiplexing technique. The angular multiplexing technique alone was shown by Mok et al. to allow storage of 500 objects or 5000 edge-enhanced objects (320 × 220 pixels) in a photorefractive LiNbO3 crystal [20, 21]. The reference beam direction was adjusted with an acoustooptic deflector in conjunction with a telescope. The holograms showed a diffraction efficiency of approximately 4 · 10−6 . Angular multiplexing together with spatial multiplexing, i.e., the holograms are stored in different regions of the volume, has been used to store 750 (128 × 128 pixels, diffraction efficiency 1 · 10−4 ) [22] and 10,000 images [23] by Tao et al. and Burr et al., respectively. Recently, angle multiplexing has also been used in connection with electrical fixing (see Section 4.5.3) to store 1000 holograms in a photorefractive crystal SBN:75 [24]. Angle multiplexing techniques that use a single laser beam have also been proposed [25]; experimental demonstration was limited to ten multiplexed holograms for the moment. (B) Phase Multiplexing Phase multiplexing uses a more complex reference than the plane-wave-like beams employed in angle multiplexing. The reference wave may be thought of as a linear combination of all possible reference beams used in the angular multiplexing scheme. The addresses of the stored images reside in the adjustable phases of different parts of the reference wave all overlapping with the signal wave in the holographic medium. The phase distortions of the reference beam can be random, introduced using a ground glass plate [26, 27], or deterministic, obtained by using a phase-only spatial light modulator. Multiple holograms may be superimposed without significant crosstalk by choosing a set of orthogonal j functions for the phase pattern, i.e., eiϕ (x,y) , where ϕ j (x, y) describes the phase distribution of the jth reference wave, which is related to the jth image. If the space x,y is divided into N discrete pixels, as obtained for instance by using a phase-only spatial light modulator, the orthogonality condition among the phase patterns is expressed by N n=1
j
m
eiϕn (x,y) eiϕn (x,y) = 0
if j = m,
(4.9)
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing
85
where n is an index related to the position of a given pixel in the phase pattern. For readout, the phase code corresponding to the desired object wave is used, and with efficient code selection only the desired object will significantly contribute to image reconstruction. The fixed alignment geometry allows faster access times as for angular multiplexing. However, the storage capacities of experimental implementations are rather low, partly due to the lack of high-precision phase-only spatial light modulators, which are able to provide complex wave-front structures. Denz et al. [28, 29] presented a deterministic phase-encoding method whereby N objects are stored with N pure and deterministic phase-coded reference beams. Using this method, the image beam simultaneously interferes with all N reference beams inside the storage medium. Each of these references is encoded in phase, and they are angularly spaced by more than the Bragg angle. It has been shown that if N is a power of 2, then N orthogonal phase addresses can be constructed by choosing the phases to be equal to 0 or π and using the Walsh–Hadamard transform [30]. This method of binary phase encoding has been experimentally verified by multiplexing 64 images (128 × 128 pixels) in a photorefractive BaTiO3 crystal [31, 32]. The access time to retrieve any of the stored images was 150 μs. By using a subsampling of phase codes, holograms stored by phase multiplexing can also be used for optical addition, subtraction, and inversion of images [33]. In an earlier experiment, sinusoidally phase-modulated reference beams [34] were also used for the storage of seven different holograms. An alternative multiplexing technique, which may be seen as a special case of phase multiplexing, has recently been proposed [35]. This shift-multiplexing technique is based on a set of reference waves converging to a region of the recording medium. The medium is shifted by a few micrometers between two exposures. In the local frame of the medium, the phase distribution of the reference rays is changed as a result of the shift, thus allowing discrimination of different hologram pages. Shift multiplexing may be implemented using various kinds of reference waves, including spherical waves [36] and highly noncollimated Gaussian waves. It offers the potential advantage of simplicity and of a better compatibility with today’s spinning disk technologies. Multiplexing of a limited number of holograms with a required hologram-to-hologram shift on the order of 5 μm has been reported [35]. (C) Wavelength Multiplexing For wavelength multiplexing, each hologram is recorded using a different laser wavelength. The direction of the reference and signal wave outside the medium remains constant [1]. With respect to angular multiplexing there is the advantage that no readjustment of angles is required. However, a tunable laser source is required. The wave-vector diagram for frequency multiplexing is shown in Figure 4.3(b) for the case in which the writing beams are symmetric with respect to the surface normal of the storage medium. A hologram written by interference of the reference wave with wave vector kω1 and object wave (ks,ω1 ) forms an index
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
86
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter
grating with grating vector K 1 . By illuminating the crystal with light from the same direction but of different frequency ω2 , no diffracted light results, because the vector kω2 is not Bragg-matched. Reflection gratings are often used in wavelength multiplexing because of their efficient use of k-space. The grating vectors are oriented nearly parallel to the reference beam and are of magnitude approximately twice that of the reference beam. Therefore, in this case the grating vectors may span a greater portion of k-space than grating vectors arising from oblique beams [37]. For reflection gratings recorded by counterpropagating beams, the number of holograms N that can be distinguished in a medium of thickness d and within a wavelength range of λ − λ/2 to λ + λ/2 can be easily estimated. As for the case of transmission gratings, the diffraction efficiency of a weak reflection hologram falls to half its maximum value if the mismatch parameter of (4.6) is ξ ≈ 1.39 [17], so that 2πn d λ. (4.10) N∼ = 2 λ 2.78 With this criterion (4.10) tells us that about 400 holograms can be distinguished for a d = 2-mm-thick medium with refractive index n = 2.2 and a total wavelength tuning of ±5 nm around a central wavelength of 500 nm. It has to be remembered that if broad-bandwidth lasers are used, the maximum number of multiplexed pages might be limited by the laser bandwidth and not by the material thickness [38]. In a first experimental demonstration using a tunable solid-state laser diode, 26 images were multiplexed by tuning the wavelength over the range 670 ± 6 nm [39]. More recently, a digital wavelength-multiplexed holographic data storage system based on the same tunable laser diode technology has been demonstrated [40]. A 60-kbyte data file split into 27 wavelength multiplexed pages was stored and retrieved. Instead of a counterpropagating (180◦ ) configuration, this system uses a 90◦ angle between reference and signal beams, which has the important advantage of reduced reflection noise.
4.1.3 System Architecture Holographic storage systems using one of the multiplexing techniques described above may be implemented with the system architecture depicted in Figure 4.4. This schematic architecture is useful for the estimation of the limitations on storage capacity due to the optical system, as will be discussed in Section 4.1.4. The system consists of three distinct optical arms: the reference arm, which provides the address of a data page; the object arm, where the input information is injected during hologram recording; and the output arm, which recovers the output page information upon readout. In the case of angular multiplexing, encoding corresponds to switching on one single pixel at the reference plane (x i , yi ), which, for instance, may be achieved by placing a spatial light modulator (SLM) in that plane. The position of the bright pixel defines the reference beam direction after the transforming lens. For phase
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing
reference plane ⊗ xi
87
yi
L η
y1
yo L ⊗
ψ
xo z f
object plane
a
M by M input array
f
L ⊗
ξ
d volume holographic medium
⊗ x1
f
f output plane
α
H by H hologram array
M by M output array
F I G U R E 4.4. Schematic diagram of the holographic storage system used to determine the storage capacity and storage density at a given signal-to-noise ratio; L: lenses, f : focal length of the lenses. a pixel size, α hologram size.
multiplexing, in contrast, a certain number of pixels with a mutually well-defined phase relationship is switched on at the reference plane and given the address of the recorded page. Finally, for wavelength multiplexing the wavelengths of both object and reference wave are changed. The electronic data stream representing the information to be stored (one data page) is transformed into a coherent optical signal by the use of an SLM (assumed to have M × M elements) placed at the object plane. The light diffracted from the SLM is collected by a lens and concentrated in a small region at the plane of the storage material as either a Fourier or Fresnel transform of the bit pattern. In the specific case of Figure 4.4, the lens in the object arm provides a Fourier transform relationship [41], between the optical distributions f (x0 , y0 ) in the front and g(ξ, η) in the back focal plane. Random phase shifters can eventually be used in conjunction with the SLM to reduce the dynamic range of the light distribution at the hologram plane. Finally, the output arm provides the transformation of the light diffracted off the hologram upon readout into an appropriate intensity distribution at the output plane, where a charge-coupled device (CCD) sensor array consisting of M × M pixels can be placed in order to obtain an electronic signal of the reconstructed
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
88
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter
page. This signal can now be interfaced to the host processor for further manipulations using electronic signal processing. Using parallel readout of the CCD, high transfer rates are achievable, possibly exceeding gigabits per second [6]. In general, if the holographic medium is large compared to the hologram size α, multiple holograms may be accommodated by spatially multiplexing H × H holograms across the surface. In the simplified scheme of Figure 4.4 it was assumed for simplicity that the pixel distance (pitch) at the object arm SLM is equal to the pixel size a, and that similarly, the hologram size α and the hologram distance are the same. As discussed above, for a volume holographic medium, multiple images may be superimposed onto a stack at the location of a single element of the H × H hologram array. Storage in stacks of holograms is preferred due to the limited superposition of holograms, and it allows stacks of pages to be recorded and erased without affecting other regions of the storage medium.
4.1.4 Storage Capacity of Volume Media The fundamental upper limit for storage capacity of volume media is determined from diffraction considerations [42]. However, in addition to diffraction, other effects such as the optical quality of the holographic medium, the aperture of the optical system, lens aberrations, and crosstalk noise may limit the practically achievable storage capacity and density. Some of these aspects are discussed below. (A) Storage Capacity Limitation Due to Diffraction The limiting storage capacity of volume media may be quickly estimated by extrapolating the results for two-dimensional media. Let us assume that the recording medium used for storage has an area A facing the recording and reconstructing beams. The area used for each hologram is A/H 2 = α 2 , as indicated in Figure 4.4, and elementary considerations of diffraction show that the number of bits that can be stored in such a hologram is on the order of α 2 /λ2 , where λ is the wavelength of the readout beam. Hence, the maximum number of bits that can be stored if the full area of the medium is occupied by thin holograms is about A/λ2 . By making the hologram thick compared to the fringe spacing, we add another dimension. Using angular multiplexing, each hologram can be addressed by choosing the direction of incidence of the readout beam. Diffraction limits the number N of angularly multiplexed holograms to the order of d/λ, where d is the sample thickness. At each stack position the storage capacity in bits is the product of N and storage capacity of thin holograms α/λ2 . The diffraction-limited storage capacity C of the full volume storage medium is therefore given by C max ≈ (α/λ2 )(d/λ)H 2 , which can be rewritten as Cmax ≈
V , λ3
(4.11)
where V = A d is the volume of the storage sample. As expected, this result is similar to what is expected using a nonholographic sequential three-dimensional
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing
89
optical recording by “focusing a bit” to a localized volume of λ3 (every cube with an edge of length λ acts as a separate storage cell). Indeed, it has been shown that even under consideration of optical system limitations, holographic and layeredbit recording techniques lead to similar storage capacity in volume media [43], with the holographic technique being slightly better if lenses with an F-number larger than about 1 are used. The result (4.11) can also be derived by considering wavelength multiplexing [1] or by calculating the maximum number of orthogonal wave-vectors that are available within the storage medium [9, 44–46]. For wavelengths in the visible region, (4.11) predicts a tremendous storage density of 1013 bits per cm3 . However, as shown below, this number is too optimistic because of other less-fundamental limitations that lead to lower, but more realistic, storage densities. (B) Storage Capacity Limitation Due to Optical System We first consider the capacity limitations for a thin (two-dimensional) holographic storage medium on the basis of the limits of the optical system. Several authors have considered this problem; specifically, three papers in the 1970s [47–49] reported conceptually similar analyses: they optimize the capacity of the holographic storage system with a proper selection of input, output, and hologram arrays and the aperture of the lenses in the system. Following these analyses, the two-dimensional capacity C (total number of bits that can be stored in a given system) and areal storage density D (number of stored bits per area) can be expressed solely as a function of the parameters of a general optical system (Figure 4.4) [47, 48, 50]: 2 DL C(2-dim) = , (4.12) 8Fn r λ 2 1 1 D(2-dim) = , (4.13) 8 Fn r λ where F is the lens F-number (the focal length f divided by the diameter D L ) and the Rayleigh criterion n r is taken as a measure indicating when two bits can still be resolved. A Rayleigh criterion of n r = 1.22 means that two bits can still be resolved if the center of the Airy pattern generated by one bit falls on the first minimum of the Airy pattern of the neighboring bit. Equations (4.12) and (4.13) are derived under the assumption that the lens in the object arm of Figure 4.4 has an “optimum diameter” D L equal to the sum of the sizes of the input and hologram arrays [48]: √ √ (4.14) D L = 2Ma + 2H α, √ where the factor 2 accounts for measuring along the diagonals. It should be noted that the total storage capacity given by (4.12) can be eventually exceeded by mechanically shifting the holographic medium in the transversal directions to allow for additional spatial multiplexing. In contrast, the density given by (4.13) cannot be exceeded in thin planar gratings. Inserting F = 1, n r = 1.22,
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
90
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter
and λ = 0.5 μm, one obtains an area storage density of D(2-dim) = 34 Mbit/cm2 . This value is rather modest if compared with the density of localized nonholographic two-dimensional storage devices such as CD or DVD. They present densities on the order of (1/nr λ)2 , corresponding to about 270 Mbit/cm2 if the same wavelength and Rayleigh criterion as above are assumed. This reduced density and the fact of having to use rather bulky systems are the price to be paid for parallel random access to the data. The above analysis is valid for thin two-dimensional media. Generalization to the three-dimensional case is easy; the maximum storage density can be expressed as [44] 2 1 1 Nmax (4.15) χ Dmax (3-dim) = 8 Fn r λ d where d is the material thickness, and Nmax is the maximum number of holograms that can be multiplexed at a given location. As will be seen below, Nmax is limited by crosstalk effects due to diffraction or other noise sources and depends on the minimum allowable signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) for detection. In (4.15) the detrimental effect of lens aberration that leads to further crosstalk among bits in the detector plane has been considered through the empirical quantity ⎛ ⎞4 1 ⎠ χ =⎝ (4.16) 1 + α L f nr λ first introduced by Akos et al. [51]. The constant α L is on the order of α L = 10−3 for conventional lenses, where it is assumed that for a fixed Fresnel number, the aberrations are proportional to the focal length of the lens. Recording of multiple hologram stacks may be accomplished most easily by shifting the holographic medium. We can therefore put H = 1 and calculate explicitly the dependence of the storage density on the input and hologram sizes using (4.14) and (4.15): 1 M 1 2 Nmax χ Dmax (3 − dim) = + . (4.17) 4 α a d Here we recall that a and α are the pixel and hologram sizes, respectively, which are approximately related by α = nr λ f /a. Putting this in (4.17) shows that in general, a certain compromise has to be taken between hologram size and pixel size. (C) Interpage Crosstalk and Storage Density The last term in (4.15) and (4.17) contains implicitly the dependence of the storage density on the multiplexing method. To fully evaluate the density Dmax , the maximal number of multiplexed holograms Nmax has to be calculated. This number is limited by the condition that pixels have to be distinguishable in the
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing
91
output plane. Assuming that all other noise sources have been reduced to a minimum, the only fundamental noise source remaining is the crosstalk between the stored pages during readout (interpage crosstalk). For angular multiplexing, this crosstalk-limited storage capacity of volume holographic memories has been calculated by Ramberg [50] and Gu et al. [52]. Considering Figure 4.4, it is found that a maximum number of objects can be stored when the angle between signal and reference beam is ψ = 90◦ and the separation between adjacent reference points on the yi -coordinate in the reference plane is chosen as = λ f /d [52]. For this optimum configuration, the worst signal-to-noise ratio (SNR)min in terms of intensity can be expressed as (SNR)min ≈
2d f , λY Nmax
(4.18)
where Nmax is the maximum number of angular multiplexed images, d is the medium thickness, f is the lens focal length, λ is the vacuum wavelength, and Y = 2y1,max is the linear dimension of the output plane (object image). Equation (4.18) shows that the maximum number of image pages depends on the minimum SNR that the detection system can handle. Its derivation assumes that the paraxial approximation is valid and that the transverse dimensions of the medium are much larger than the spatial bandwidth of the objects, i.e., the whole Fourier spectrum (spatial frequency spectrum) of the input object can be recorded. For f /Y = 1 and assuming that an SNR equal to 1 can be tolerated, one obtains from (4.18) Nmax ≈ 2d/λ, in agreement with the estimate made at the beginning of this section. Similar analysis of the interpage crosstalk noise can also be accomplished for the cases of wavelength and phase multiplexing. In the case of wavelength multiplexing, the crosstalk noise is minimal for ψ = 180◦ (antiparallel geometry) and the maximum noise appears for the middle hologram with frequency νm = ν0 , where νm is the frequency of the mth hologram and ν0 is the middle frequency, in the frequency schedule [53]. Assuming that ν0 /νmax ≈ 1, the signal-to-noise ratio for wavelength multiplexing is given by −1 P 1 − cos 2πmY 2 8 f 2 Y2 2 (SNR)min = π 1 + , (4.19) 8f2 m2 m=1 where N = 2P + 1 is again the number of stored holograms. In Figure 4.5 the SNR is shown as a function of the number of stored holograms following (4.18) and (4.19) for angle and wavelength multiplexing, respectively. The latter has a slightly more favorable crosstalk-limited signal-to-noise ratio than angular multiplexing. By examining a coupled wave theory in the Fourier regime, Bashaw et al. [54] compared the crosstalk for orthogonal phase-encoded and random phaseencoded multiplexing with the crosstalk of angular multiplexing. For an ideal storage medium (with no background scatter, no grating vector dispersion, and
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
92
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter 106 angle multiplexing frequency multiplexing
105
SNR
104 103 100 10 1 0
200
400 600 800 103 Number of holograms
104
105
F I G U R E 4.5. Logarithm of the worst signal-to-noise ratio as a function of the number of stored holograms N for angle and frequency (wavelength) multiplexing. Notice that for N > 1000 a logarithmic scale has been used. The SNR for frequency multiplexing has not yet been calculated for large N . The parameters are material thickness d = 1 cm, focal length f = 30 cm, λ = 500 nm, and output dimension Y = 3 cm.
an infinite lateral extent), they found that orthogonal phase-encoded multiplexing and angular multiplexing have similar crosstalk characteristics. Orthogonal phase encoding exhibits an SNR that is better by a factor of two than angular multiplexing as in (4.18). This improvement occurs because the crosstalk is the page average, rather than the worst-page crosstalk of angular multiplexing. These results partially contradict [55], where the SNR is estimated by a numerical analysis. It is claimed that at least until a capacity of about 500 holograms, the orthogonal Walsh–Hadamard binary phase-encoding scheme [28] produces a much better SNR on reconstruction than angular encoding [55]. With the minimum affordable SNR set, the relationships (4.18) and (4.19) allow one to calculate the limiting storage density Dmax (3-dim) for a volume hologram by means of (4.15) or (4.17). Figure 4.6 shows this theoretical storage density for the most common case of angle multiplexing. Even under consideration of the optical system limitations, if an SNR of unity can be afforded, a storage density of about 1 Tbit/cm3 is theoretically achievable. This value is about one order of magnitude lower than the storage density Dmax ≈ λ−3 (4.11) expected from pure diffraction considerations. However, it should be noted that for such a low SNR, a significant fraction of the stored bits might have to be used for errorcorrection purposes. For SNR = 10 one expects a storage density on the order of 100 Gbit/cm3 for typical array sizes of 1000 × 1000 pixels. If an SNR of 100 is required, the storage density would decrease to the order of 10 Gbit/cm3 , which is in agreement with a statistical analysis by Yi et al. [56] that also takes into account intrapage interpixel crosstalk, which arises from the limited spatial extent of the
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
storage density (gigabit/cm3)
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing
93
Pixel size: a = 3 μm
1000
a = 30 μm a = 3 μm
100
a = 30 μm
10 102
103
104 105 106 input/output array size
107
108
F I G U R E 4.6. Volume storage density (4.17) for angle multiplexing as a function of input– output parallelism with the input–output resolution as a parameter. The solid curves are for a signal-to-noise ratio SNR = 1, the dashed curves for SNR = 10. Parameters: lens Fnumber F = 1, n r = 1.22, λ = 500 nm, d = 1 cm. The decrease of the density for larger parallelism is due mainly to the effect of lens aberrations characterized by the constant α L = 10−3 in (4.16).
storage material. For both angular and wavelength multiplexing, a storage density between 4 and 20 Gbit/cm3 is predicted depending on the pixel size a for an SNR of 150 or a bit-error rate of 10−9 [56]. The decrease of the density for larger parallelism seen in Figure 4.6 is due mainly to the effect of lens aberrations characterized by the constant αL and is contained in the quantity χ in (4.16). More input pixels requires larger lenses with correspondingly longer focal lengths. Figure 4.6 also shows that the reduction in storage density with increasing parallelism is faster with coarser pixel size a. Thus at any chosen number of pixels, increasing the input–output pixel density also increases the storage density. To summarize, larger input dimensions reduce the storage density, as do also too-large pixels. Instead of storing Fourier holograms, image-plane holograms can also be stored. It has been shown that the SNR is independent of the pixel location at the output plane for wavelength and angle multiplexing and that the worst-case signal-to-noise ratio is slightly better than the worst-case SNR for Fourier transformed holograms recorded with the same parameters [57, 58]. (D) Storage Capacity Limitations Due to Material Quality The crosstalk calculations discussed above show that the storage density of volume media is significantly lower than the ultimate limit given by diffraction. This is particularly true if large signal-to-noise ratios and low bit-error rates of the reconstructed information are required. However, it was assumed that interpage or interpixel crosstalk and lens aberrations are the only noise sources in
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
94
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter
the holographic recording system. In practice, additional noise arises from imperfections of the storage material (such as scattering centers) and decreases the achievable storage density further. Despite the fact that their bad optical quality represents the principal limitation of many holographic media, unfortunately this noise source cannot be easily quantified. Bashaw et al. [54] use the quantity SNR1 to express the ratio between signal and scattered noise if only one hologram is recorded. In photorefractive materials the diffraction intensity decreases as the square of the number of stored holograms N (see Section 4.4.1), and so does the signal-to-noise ratio SNRscatt = SNR1 /N 2 that is due to scattering imperfections. Since the crosstalk signal-to-noise ratio decreases only with the first power of N, in many material samples the scattering noise dominates over crosstalk noise already for a relatively small number of stored holograms. In view of digital holographic storage, the construction of precise experimental test beds for the characterization of the material quality is very important [59]. Furthermore, material research to produce low-noise media is still of crucial importance in order to reach the full potential of volumetric optical data storage [60].
4.2 Optical Pattern Recognition Pattern recognition is one of the most natural signal-processing tasks for which the parallelism of optics provides important advantages. The two common types of optical pattern recognition systems, the joint Fourier transform correlator and the VanderLugt-type correlator, will be discussed in this section. We will focus especially on the performance characteristics of these correlators when volume holograms instead of thin holograms are used. A more detailed discussion on using thin holograms in correlators and the possibilities of electronic pre- and postprocessing can be found, for example, in N. Collings, “Optical pattern recognition” [61] and references therein.
4.2.1 Optical Correlators (A) Joint Fourier Transform Correlator In the joint Fourier transform correlator (JTC), which was first proposed by Weaver and Goodman [62], the object and scene patterns to be correlated are presented at the input plane simultaneously. Both are Fourier transformed by a single lens, and the interference pattern of their Fourier transforms is recorded in a hologram placed in the Fourier plane. The subsequent interrogation of this hologram with a collimated beam yields—after Fourier transforming—the correlation products of the object and the scene patterns. The JTC is especially advantageous when two unknown signals have to be correlated in real time because of its system simplicity. Provided that real-time devices for the input as well as for recording are available, search routines can be performed at the input data rate.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing reading beam
yo xo ⊗ s (xo, yo–h) s1 (xo, yo+ h)
zo
η ξ⊗
L
95
y1 ζ
x1 ⊗
L
z1
h h
input plane
f
f
f holographic medium
f correlation plane
F I G U R E 4.7. Schematic setup of a single-axis joint Fourier transform correlator. L: lenses, f : focal length of the lenses.
Consider a system as sketched in Figure 4.7. A transparency with a real transmittance s1 (x0 , y0 + h), which contains the object set, is positioned below the optical axis with its center at the point (0, −h), and a second transparency with a real transmittance s(x0 , y0 − h) representing the input object is positioned above the optical axis with its center at the point (0, h) at the front focal plane of a converging lens. The two transparencies are illuminated by a collimated beam from a laser and Fourier transformed by the lens. Then in the back focal plane, the light amplitude is F{S1 (x0 , y0 + h) + S(x 0 , y0 − h)}, where F is the Fourier transform operator. The interference of the two input waves creates an intensity distribution at the holographic material that is proportional to the product of the two FTs of the inputs: I (ξ, η) = |F{S1 (x0 , y0 + h) + s(x0 , y0 − h)}|2 = |S1 (ξ, η)|2 + |S(ξ, η)|2 + S1 (ξ, η)S ∗ (ξ, η)e−2iηh + S1∗ (ξ, η)S(ξ, η)e2iηh ,
(4.20)
where S(ξ, η) and S1 (ξ, η) are the Fourier transforms of s(x0 , y0 − h) and s1 (x0 , y0 + h), respectively, and ∗ indicates complex conjugation. This intensity distribution is recorded in a thin holographic medium. The correlation theorem states that the correlation of two functions is equivalent to the FT of the product of their complex field amplitudes in the Fourier plane. Therefore an optical Fourier transformation of the amplitude of the recorded hologram is needed. Illumination of the hologram with a plane wave and Fourier transforming the transmitted amplitude using the second lens in Figure 4.7 accomplishes this task. The output of the joint Fourier transform correlator can be found in the back focal plane of the second lens and is divided into three regions. In the first region, around the coordinate x 1 = y1 = 0, the sum of the autocorrelation of the two inputs is observed. The two side regions around the x1 = 0, y1 = ±2h coordinates correspond to the last two terms of (4.20) and contain the cross-correlation of the object with the scene pattern. The observed intensity distribution is proportional to the absolute square of the amplitude correlation function of the two
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
96
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter input plane
s
correlation plane
s1
F I G U R E 4.8. Input intensity distribution of a 4-channel JTC consisting of the reference set of objects s1 and the unknown input object s. The output plane centered at (x 1 = 0, y1 = 2h) contains the cross-correlation product of the two scenes.
scenes: I (x 1 , y1 ± 2h) = |F{S1 (ξ, η) · S ∗ (ξ, η)}|2 = |S1 (x0 , y0 + h) ⊗ s(x 0 , y0 − h)|2 2 = S1 (x0 ∓ x1 , y0 + h ± y1 )s(x0 , y0 − h)dx 0 dy0 , (4.21) where denotes the cross-correlation. Complex conjugates in the integral are omitted because the transmittances s and s1 were assumed to be real. In the case of two equivalent images, the cross-correlation has a maximum at (x 1 = 0, y1 ± 2h). In the case of an object set consisting of several images, the cross-correlation shows maxima at positions corresponding to the relative shifts between the similar portions of images in the input plane. This property can be used to identify the position of a smaller image inside a larger image, or to find out whether a certain object is present in a scene (multichannel JTC). If the input object s is similar to one of the objects contained in the reference set s1 , peaks of intensity will occur at the corresponding places (Figure 4.8). The height of the peak is a measure of the degree of similarity of two objects. Thus the identification is performed by detecting the position and relative intensities of the correlation peaks in the output plane. The JTC scheme described above is called a single-axis joint Fourier transform correlator because a single lens is used to perform the optical Fourier tranform of both object and reference image sets in front of the holographic medium. There exists a slightly modified technique (dual-axis JTC correlator) in which each signal is transformed by independent optics, greatly reducing the requirements on the Fourier transform lenses. Due to these practical considerations, most experimental investigations with JTCs have been performed using the latter scheme. Although the dual-axis JTC correlator relieves the stringent requirements of the FT lens, it does introduce the potential problem that the two Fourier planes have a relative tilt with respect to each other. It has been shown that this can lead to a degradation of the sharpness of the correlation peak [63]. JTC correlators have been demonstrated using photographic films in the Fourier plane or optically addressed spatial light modulators [64], as well as with real-time holographic recording media such as thermoplastic plates [63], bacteriorhodopsin
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing F I G U R E 4.9. Realization of a matched filter for the frequency-plane correlator; L: lens, f : focal length of the lens.
η reference plane wave ξ ⊗ L
yo xo ⊗
zo
ζ
ψ
s1(xo,yo) f input plane
97
f holographic medium
[65], atomic vapor [66], semi-insulating multiple quantum wells [67], and photorefractive crystals (4.68). The last of these are used as volume holograms, which can significantly alter the performance of this kind of correlator, as we will see in Section 4.2.2. (B) VanderLugt-type Correlator In the frequency-plane correlator (FPC) or VanderLugt-type correlator, the input pattern with a real transmittance s(x0 , y0 ) is compared with a fixed template. The template itself is recorded as a hologram. One method for the construction of the hologram was proposed by VanderLugt [69], and the correlator based on this method is called the VanderLugt correlator. The optical generation of the matched filter that contains the frequency spectrum of the object pattern s1 (x0 , y0 ) is shown in Figure 4.9. The input device is located in the front focal plane of a lens and a holographic recording device (e.g., a photographic film) is placed in the back focal plane. The amplitude and phase of the Fourier spectrum S1 (ξ, η) of s1 (x 0 , y0 ) are recorded by interference with a plane reference wave R(ξ, η) = |R|eicη that is assumed, for simplicity, to propagate in the ηζ -plane. If aberrations are neglected, the observed intensity pattern is given by I (ξ, η) = |R(ξ, η) + S1 (ξ, η)|2 = |R|2 + |S1 (ξ, η)|2 + R ∗ (ξ, η)S1 (ξ, η) + R(ξ, η)S1∗ (ξ, η). (4.22) The holographic medium is developed so that the transmission of the fixed recorded hologram is proportional to I (ξ, η). This filter is now reinserted in the optical system at the back focal plane of the first lens (Figure 4.10). An adjustment precision of a few microns perpendicular to the optical axis and a few tens of microns along the optical axis has to be fulfilled to achieve a proper result. When a transparency s(x0 , y0 ) is present at the input plane and illuminated with a collimated beam, the intensity distribution at the output plane can then be divided into three regions. The first region that appears on the optical axis contains the autocorrelation beam. The observed intensity distribution at the second region centered at (x1 = 0, y1 = f tan ψ) is proportional to the absolute square of the amplitude convolution function of the input and the stored scene. The third region
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
98
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter η
yo xo ⊗
zo
ξ ⊗
L
ζ
x1 ⊗
z1
ψ
s(xo,yo) f input plane
y1
L
f
f fixed template
f output plane
F I G U R E 4.10. 4 f -optical processing system for a frequency plane correlator. The fixed template is inserted at the back focal plane of the first lens.
appears with its center off the optical axis by an amount (x1 = 0, y1 = f tan ψ). The intensity distribution is proportional to the absolute square of the amplitude correlation function of the input object s(x0 , y0 ) and the stored object s1 (x0 , y0 ). As is the case in the JTC correlator, the detection of the correlation peak can be used either to identify the position of a smaller object inside a larger object or to find out whether a certain object is present in a scene. While conventional holographic pattern-recognition systems can identify a target rapidly by matching it to the information stored either in a template (FPC) or a frame store (JTC), they suffer a basic limitation in that the target images must match the template or frame store image exactly, i.e., these types of correlators are not rotation or scale invariant with respect to the input object. Only shifts of the input object within the input plane are permitted due to the fact that a lateral displacement in the input plane will lead to an additional phase factor in the Fourier plane. In this case the correlation pattern will remain the same and will be displaced in the correlation plane. A significant amount of progress has been made in generalizing the pattern-matching capabillity of the FPC using preprocessing operations (coordinate transforms, phase coding), optimized filtering (use of synthetic discriminant functions, circular harmonic filters, multiplexed filters, etc.) and postprocessing operations [61].
4.2.2 Optical Pattern Recognition Using Volume Holograms The above description of optical correlators is valid for a thin nonlinear holographic material placed at the filter plane. If the medium is thick, the Fourier plane of the image scene is just one layer of the hologram, which has important consequences for the correlator’s performance, as described below. (A) Joint Fourier Transform Correlator with Volume Media In using volume holograms such as photorefractive crystals in optical correlators, the Bragg condition for diffraction plays an important role. Nicholson et al. [70] considered the Bragg condition in an optical joint transform correlator using photorefractive Bi12 SiO20 . Their simplified analysis is based on Kogelnik’s results of diffraction from a volume hologram based on a plane-wave grating approximation. Gheen et al. [71] presented a more detailed analysis, which takes
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing yo xo ⊗ s(xo,yo–h)
s1(xo,yo+h) input plane
99
η
zo
ξ ⊗
L
ζ
A1
h h A4 BS output
x1 ⊗
y1
A2 f
ζ
d
A3
θ
holographic medium
F I G U R E 4.11. Optical joint transform correlator using a thick real-time holographic recording medium. The output plane (x 1 , y1 ) can be observed after the beam splitter BS.
into account the structure of the grating. The volume hologram is decomposed into a series of thin slices, and the contributions from the composite thin holograms are added to get the final result. With this method the intensity distribution at the output plane is calculated for the system sketched in Figure 4.11. It is assumed that the beams are not significantly affected through scattering or absorption as they pass through the material. Thus the result is valid only for small diffraction efficiencies. The x0 and ξ dimensions of the system are also ignored to simplify the analysis. The two input signals to be correlated, s(x0 , y0 − h) and s1 (x 0 , y0 + h) are Fourier transformed and illuminate the holographic medium, leading to a phase grating proportional to the intensity distribution. This hologram is read by the third beam, a plane wave that satisfies the Bragg condition for the grating spacing written by the zero-order Fourier components of the two scenes. The diffracted output wave propagates backward through the lens and is observed at the output screen. This geometry is not unique: the readout beam might also differ in wavelength and enter the crystal from the left side at the appropriate Bragg angle. The complex scattered amplitude at a distance ζ from the Fourier plane is calculated in a similar way as for thin holograms. Integrating these amplitudes along the crystal length d and propagating them to the output plane (x 1 , y1 ), one can show that the complex wave amplitude at that plane is kd(y0 − h)(y1 − h) s(y0 − h) s1 (y0 + h + y1 )sinc s(y1 ) = C dy0 , 2n f 2 aperture
(4.23) where the integration is over the aperture of the input signals, the coordinate x 0 has been ignored, and the waves s and s1 were again taken to be real functions. The constant C depends on material parameters, k is the wave number of the readout beam, and n is the refractive index of the material.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
100
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter
input object beam
holographic medium
a b
reference set beam
G1 G2 G3
c d
F I G U R E 4.12. Crosstalk problem. Spatial components along the grating vector lead to crosstalk. The regions G1–G3 are the desired gratings between the spatial components; a, b, c, d are the undesired crosstalk gratings.
d
The expression (4.23) is close to the desired correlation function (4.21). However, the Bragg effect has introduced an extra sinc term. The main effect of the sinc function is to limit the spatial extent of the input object s(x0 , y0 − h) so that s1 (x0 , y0 + h) is being correlated with only a portion of s. This effect varies over the output depending on the position, with the most severe restriction for the y1 values far from the center of the y1 -plane. The width w of the sinc function at the half-intensity level is given by w = 0.9n f 2 λ/ (d(h − y1 )), where λ is the vacuum wavelength of the readout wave. The output correlation is centered at y1 = −h when the coordinates y0 and y1 are chosen as mirror images with respect to BS. As a general guide, the Bragg condition can be neglected if w is larger than the spatial extent of the input object s(x0 , y0 − h). The Bragg condition limits the spread of wave vectors that can be reconstructed and thus the space-bandwidth product of the input scenes. For n = 2.23, f = 300 mm, λ = 500 nm, and a crystal thickness of d = 1 mm, the aperture of the input scenes is limited to y0,max = 7.6 mm. The number of pixels that can be processed in parallel, i.e., the space-bandwidth product, is on the order of the ratio of the input dimension to the smallest feature area in the entrance plane of the nonlinear medium [72]. √ Diffraction limits the smallest feature size to approximately λd. For the above parameters, the minimal feature size is about 22 μm, leading to a space-bandwidth product of about 105 . Using a thin medium (d = 1 μm), the minimum pixel size is around 1 μm, so that a space-bandwidth product of about 108 can be reached for an input aperture of 10 mm. Another serious problem is crosstalk between spatial components directed along the grating vector due to the nonvanishing crystal thickness (Figure 4.12). For spatial components directed orthogonally to the plane of incidence, no crosstalk occurs. A reduction of the recording angle ϕ and the crystal size d diminishes this problem. As we have pointed out, several aspects have to be considered when one is constructing a joint Fourier transform correlator using volume holograms. In order to avoid crosstalk effects, the two beams have to be aligned almost parallel and Fourier transformed by a single FT lens. The resolution limit in the Fourier plane, which depends on the material thickness, determines the pixel size. Efficient reconstruction can be realized only for writing beam components with incidence
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing F I G U R E 4.13. Construction of the matched filter using a volume holographic medium situated at the Fourier plane. The scene to be stored is Fourier transformed and interferes with a plane wave incident at an angle ψ. The plane ζ = 0 corresponds to the back focal plane of the lens.
101
η
yo xo ⊗
reference plane wave
ξ⊗
zo
ζ
d ψ
s1(xo,yo) f input plane
f
ζ
holographic medium
angles allowed by the Bragg acceptance which determines the maximum input object size; this leads to problems if wide fields of view are required from both input signals. These two aspects strongly limit the useful space-bandwidth product of such a device. On the other hand, utilization of a volume hologram does not lead to any advantage in such a system. Therefore we can conclude that holographic volume media are not well suited for implementing a JTC [73]. Nevertheless, several real-time correlators using volume holograms, especially photorefractive crystals, have been implemented due to the lack of fast, thin real-time holographic recording media [68, 74–76]. (B) VanderLugt Correlator with Volume Media A calculation similar to that Gheen et al. [71] for the joint transform correlator can also be performed for the VanderLugt-type correlator using the same assumptions. First the phase grating obtained during recording of the matched filter is calculated at a distinct plane in the holographic medium. The intensity distribution at the correlation plane is then obtained by coherently adding the contributions of each thin hologram. In order to simplify the analysis it is assumed that the normal to the front face of the storage medium is aligned parallel to the optical axis of the system. The configuration used for recording the holographic matched filter is shown in Figure 4.13. While for thin media illumination of the recorded hologram with an object wave s(x0 , y0 ) produces three ouput beams (Section 4.2.1.B), for thick media the convolution beam cannot be observed because it is not Bragg-matched. Here we are interested in the correlation beam that propagates in the same direction as the reference beam that was used in the resording step. Neglecting any variations in the x0 or ξ -dimension, the contribution δ E of the hologram layer at the plane ζ to the diffracted amplitude in the correlation beam is expressed as [77] δ E(η, ζ ) = C1 S1∗ (η, ζ )RS(η, ζ ),
(4.24)
where C1 is a complex constant proportional to the refractive-index-change amplitude in the hologram, and S1 is the complex amplitude of the optical field of
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
102
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter η
yo xo ⊗ zo
ξ ⊗ d
L
y1
L
s(xo, yo)
ζ
x1 ⊗ ψ
c
ζ input plane
f
f
holographic medium
z1
f
f
correlation plane
F I G U R E 4.14. Correlation of an input pattern s(x 0 , y0 ) with a matched filter in a VanderLugt-type correlator. The reconstructed reference beam is focused in the correlation plane.
the stored scene at the plane ζ given by kηy0 ky02 ζ dy0 , exp −i s1 (y0 ) exp −i S1 (η, ζ ) = C exp(ikζ ) 2f2 f aperture
(4.25) where C is a complex constant. The amplitude S(η, ζ ) in (4.24) is obtained with the analogous expression to (4.25), and R is the amplitude of the plane-wave reference wave used for storing the matched filter. Expression (4.24) is valid under the assumption that the phase hologram amplitude is linearly proportional to the light intensity. Note that for photorefractive materials this condition is valid only in the small-modulation regime [78]. After Fourier transforming by the second lens in the VanderLugt scheme (Figure 4.14), the complex amplitude K (y1 ) at the output plane can be calculated by integration of the contributions of the different hologram layers: d/2 K (y1 ) = −d/2
η2 1 exp (ik f ) exp ik F (δ E) dζ, iλ f 2f
(4.26)
where F denotes the Fourier transformation with respect to the coordinate η. Considering that the Fourier transformation of a plane wave is a delta function F(R) = |R|δ(y1 − c) and inserting the expressions for S1∗ (η, ζ ) and S(η, ζ ), the above integration leads to πdy0 (y1 − c) dy0 K (y1 ) = C3 s1∗ (y0 − y1 + c) s (y0 ) sinc f 2 nλ Aperture
(4.27) where C3 is again a complex constant. The distribution K (y1 ) is centered at y1 = c due to the convolution with the delta function. In (4.27) we accounted for refraction into the crystal, which results in the term n appearing in the denominator
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing
103
of the sinc function. The constant c = f tan ψ depends on the angle between the object beam and the reference beam during recording of the matched filter. Equation (4.27) indicates that the Bragg effect, which reduces the shift invariance, introduces an additional sinc function in the correlation plane. In the case of a large crystal size, i.e., the width of the sinc function is much smaller than the input scene dimension, the sinc function vanishes for y1 = c. The intensity distribution, which is the square of the amplitude distribution K (y1 ), is then given by 2 ∗ s1 (y0 ) s (y0 ) dy0 (4.28) lim I (y1 = c) = C3 d→∞ Aperture and in this limit the cross-correlation is obtained only for an exact positioning of the input image s1 (y0 ). The influence of the crystal thickness d on the output intensity distribution can be seen in Figure 4.15. The output intensity, which is given by |K (y1 )|2 , is calculated using (4.27). The parameters are as follows: wavelength λ = 500 nm, refractive index n = 2.23, focal length f = 30 cm, input aperture 2y0,max = 2 cm. In Figure 4.15 the loss of shift-invariance for increasing hologram thickness can be easily recognized. A further increase in crystal thickness narrows the final intensity peak at y1 = c. The lack of shift invariance allows us to distinguish between objects that are shifted in the input plane. An intensity peak is observed only if the input image shows some overlap of its bright areas with the bright areas of the stored scene. While for thick volume holograms the Bragg condition eliminates shift invariance in the y0 -direction, the system retains its shift invariance in the transversal (x 0 ) direction perpendicular to the plane of incidence. Thus the two-dimensional output intensity distribution is given by 2 I (x 1 , y1 ) = I (x 1 , c) = |C|2 s1∗ (x0 − x1 , y0 )s(x0 , y0 )dx0 dy0 . aperture
(4.29) Therefore, the effect of the thick hologram is to mask the two-dimensional correlation pattern except for one vertical stripe perpendicular to the plane of the beams (x1 ) whose position (c) depends on the angle of the reference beam. If we change the angle of the reference beam and record a different hologram with it, the one-dimensional stripe will be produced at a different location. One can store N different templates and get a system of N correlators with one-dimensional shift invariance. Although the shift invariance is lost in the one dimension, the utilization of volume holograms in the VanderLugt-type correlator is favorable due to the large storage density that can be reached. Instead of storing only one matched filter we can store many templates in one crystal by angular encoding. The shift invariance is lost, but a much greater amount of data can be processed in parallel.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
104
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter 1-dim. input scene
1-dim. stored scene 1.0
s ( yo)
s1 ( yo)
1.0 0.5
0.0
0.0
-1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 yo
-1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 yo
d = 1 μm
0.6 0.4 0.2 0 -1.0
-0.5
intensity [a.u.]
0.4 0.2 -0.5
0.0 0.5 y1 - c [cm]
0.4 0.2 -0.5
1.0
0.0 0.5 y1 - c [cm]
1.0
d = 1 mm
0.8
0.6
0 -1.0
0.6
0 -1.0
1.0
d = 100 μm
0.8 intensity [a.u.]
0.0 0.5 y1 - c [cm]
d = 10 μm
0.8 intensity [a.u.]
intensity [a.u.]
0.8
0.5
0.6 0.4 0.2 0 -1.0
-0.5
0.0 0.5 y1 - c [cm]
1.0
F I G U R E 4.15. Output intensity distribution as a function of the output dimension. Increasing the crystal thickness d leads to a single intensity peak at y1 = c.
If the loss of shift invariance represents a serious problem for a given system, another type of optical correlator, the reflection-type wavelength-multiplexed correlator, may be used. In volume media the reflection-type correlator has been shown to allow a larger shift invariance than JTC or VanderLugt correlators [79].
4.3 Holographic Associative Memories The holographic storage systems that are discussed in Section 4.1 are locationaddressable memories. To retrieve one document, a mechanical or optoelectronic control is necessary by which a specific reference beam is directed toward the
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing
105
storage medium. Thus these systems cannot be called associative memories. If a holographic memory has to implement the associative memory function, then reading must be content-addressable. The desired response must be obtained using a patterned key—either a separate one or a fragment of a stored pattern—without any extra control information. The associative properties of holography have been recognized ever since its invention by Gabor [80]. One can distinguish between linear and nonlinear holographic associative memories, the second kind possessing a nonlinear thresholding function for better discrimination.
4.3.1 Linear Holographic Associative Memories The good match between the parallelism and interconnectivity of optics and the requirements of associative memories was noticed early. Van Heerden [81] predicted in 1963 that a hologram would produce a “ghost image” of a stored image upon illumination of the hologram with a fragment of the original image. These early ghost image experiments were characterized by poor image qualities and low signal-to-noise ratios. The invention of off-axis holography greatly improved the SNR by angularly separating the desired signal term from the undesired noise due to self-interference among scattered waves from the original image. Some of the early experiments in holographic associations were performed by Collier and Pennington [82]. In these experiments a hologram was formed from two object waves. By illumination of the hologram with part of wave front A, a complete version of wave front B was reconstructed. If exposures from several pairs of different patterns (A, B) are recorded (superimposed), an information pattern associated with a particular key pattern can be reconstructed from the stored holograms with reasonable selectivity. The reconstructed wave front is a linear mixture of the images of the B patterns, with relative intensities that depend on the degree of matching of the stored field patterns with the field pattern that is used during reading. Thus one pattern will dominate, whereas the other terms in the mixture will represent superimposed noise. These holographic memories suffered from distortions, poor SNR, and low storage capacity. More recently, Paek et al. [83] proposed a ghost-image-type associative memory using second-order diffraction from a thin hologram to simplify the optical system and improve the output intensity, which usually suffers from the necessity to perform two optical correlation operations in series. As mentioned above, when a content-addressable memory is used to store arbitrary patterns, large storage capacity cannot be achieved by a superposition method because of the crosstalk noise between the patterns. Therefore pageoriented holographic memories were developed that used mechanical or acoustooptic deflection of reference beams to read out one of many spatially separated holograms [84]. This was one of the earliest applications of the optical VanderLugt-type correlator [69] for optical associative memories. In this application, memory data were stored in a large number of spatially multiplexed holograms. The small holograms, corresponding to the various stored entries,
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
106
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter
had to be written using narrow coherent beams confined to them only. During recording, different data planes or “pages” were recorded in a hologram by sequentially shifting a plane-wave reference beam over the entire recording medium. Content-addressable reading, on the other hand, has to be made in an all-parallel fashion, by interrogating all entries simultaneously and in parallel. In the readout phase the light from the input data page illuminated the entire set of holograms. A parallel associative search of all of the stored data could be performed simultaneously. A detector matrix determined the location of the resultant correlation peak, which determined the location of the hologram containing the matching data. This information was used to shift a readout reference to the proper hologram for readout of the associated data. The system could also be used for heteroassociation by shifting the readout beam to a hologram different from the matching one. Associations could be made by processing the correlation plane with lookup tables. Such page-oriented associative holographic memories are capable of large storage capacities, but they handle multiple associations serially because of the mechanical scanning of the readout beam. In response to the need for highly parallel architectures for neural network models, a new class of associative memories has been developed, which is also based on the VanderLugt-type correlator. Unlike page-oriented associative memories, these nonlinear holographic associative memories (NHAM) use nonlinear gain and feedback to implement competition between stored data [85].
4.3.2 Nonlinear Holographic Associative Memories The NHAM is an optical associative memory that combines the fully parallel image-to-image heteroassociative capabilities of ghost-image holography with the high SNR, processing gain, and storage capacity of thresholded VanderLugt correlators. They are potentially superior to linear associative memory approaches, because nonlinearities allow the selection of a particular stored image over all others on the basis of incomplete input data. As a consequence, the storage capacity is increased. Phase conjugation is often used to implement the features of gain, nonlinear feedback, and competition. The concept of NHAM can be also expanded to the optical implementation of neural-network models. A schematic diagram of a representative system is shown in Figure 4.16. The heart of the system is a hologram in which Fourier transforms of objects are recorded sequentially using angularly multiplexed reference beams. For readout of the NHAM, phase-conjugating mirrors or other means of forming retroreflected time-reversed beams are positioned on both sides of the hologram. When a partial or distorted version of an object addresses the hologram via the beam splitter, a set of partially reconstructed reference beams is generated. Each reconstructed reference beam corresponds to the correlation of the input with the stored object associated with that particular reference beam. This part of the system is identical to a matched VanderLugt correlator. The distorted reconstructed reference beams are phase conjugated by the reference-arm phase-conjugating mirror (PCM) and their paths retraced to the hologram. These beams reconstruct
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing
107
reference beams
retroreflection
hologram retroreflection + nonlinearity distorted input
stored images
F I G U R E 4.16. Recording and readout of reference-based nonlinear holographic associative memories (redrawn after [85]).
the complete stored objects. The reconstructed objects are phase conjugated by the object-arm PCM, and the process is iterated until the system settles into a self-consistent solution, or eigenmode, assuming that the gain of the PCMs is sufficient for oscillation. The most important common feature of NHAMs is nonlinearity. Without it these associative memories could not “choose” a particular image over all others, and the output would be a linear superposition of multiple recalled images. The nonlinear response and multistable operation allow selections between patterns to be made on the basis of incomplete data, since gain will exceed loss only for the stored pattern with the largest correlation with the input pattern. Nonlinearities also improve the signal-to-noise ratio and storage capacity over ghost-image holography or linear matched-filter correlators. For thin Fourier holograms, the effects of nonlinearities in the reference arm on the SNR and storage capacity of NHAMs has been extensively discussed by Owechko [85]. In this case, since the thresholded reference beam reconstructs not only the object, which has been written with that specific reference beam, centered on the input object, but also partially all other stored objects, an aperture has to be placed over the input plane to block these displaced objects. This aperture prevents ambiguities in the output plane at the cost of a reduced amount of shift invariance. An estimation of the number of stored objects N as a function of the degree of shift invariance leads to N ≈ ( φ f /z)2 [85], where φ is the range of reference-object beam angles for which the hologram has good diffraction
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
108
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter
efficiency, f is the focal length of the Fourier transform field, and z is the amount of shift invariance. For parameter values of f = 200 mm, z = 10 mm, φ = 30◦ , the maximum number of stored images is N = 110. For volume holograms, Bragg selectivity prevents reconstruction of an object written at a different angle than the original. In this case the storage capacity or storage density of an NHAM depends on the storage density of the storage crystal. If we assume that crosstalk during readout with the thresholded phaseconjugated reference beam is the only noise source, i.e., perfect thresholding, we can directly apply the results of Section 4.1.4 for the case of angular multiplexing. With (4.18) the number of images that can be stored and compared in parallel at the same time is N ≈ (2d f /λy(SNR)min ), where Y is the linear dimension of the stored objects and (SNR) min is the minimum tolerable signal-to-noise ratio. For a readout wavelength of λ = 500 nm, an output dimension of Y = 2 cm, a focal length of f = 200 mm, and a minimum signal-to-noise ratio of 100, we can store and associate in parallel 400 images for a 1-mm-thick crystal and 4000 images for a 10-mm-thick crystal. However, in practical NHAM it is often difficult to obtain perfect thresholding, so that the size of the stored image library is limited further. Implementations of nonlinear holographic associative memories can be categorized on the basis of the method used for generating the reference beams used in recording the holograms and on the resonator geometry. All-optical implementations will be discussed in Section 4.6. The basic principles of hybrid opticalelectronic NHAMs are the same as for all-optical ones, but the implementation of the nonlinearity and the input are quite different. Owechko implemented a hybrid NHAM that used a pseudoconjugation system consisting of video detectors and liquid-crystal light valves (LCLV) [86]. This approach allowed the programming of general nonlinear feedback functions. Between the reference loop video detector and the LCLV, the correlation plane is nonlinearly processed in electronic form using digital lookup tables in a PC board level image processor. With this image processor heteroassociations or multilayer optical neural networks can also be programmed [87].
4.3.3 Ring Resonator Associative Memories Another type of associative memory is the ring resonator NHAM that was first described by Anderson [88]. He demonstrated a ring phase conjugate resonator containing the holograms and an externally pumped two-wave mixing configuration to introduce gain to offset the loop loss (Figure 4.17). This system was designed to have two eigenmodes representing orthogonal patterns defined by a hologram prestored in a bleached silver halide emulsion. For a plane-wave input the system would usually resonate with equal strength in each of the two modes. However, if the input object is similar to one of the resonator modes, competition for the pump energy in the gain element will decrease amplification of the second mode below threshold and suppress its oscillation. Therefore, by injection of a portion of one of the original patterns the function of association is performed.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing
(a)
(b)
gain
pump
T object wave
109
T injected signal
recording medium
hologram
F I G U R E 4.17. Holographic ring resonator memory. (a) Recording of hologram. (b) Recall by injected signal. Gain is supplied by a pumped photorefractive medium. The general transformation of the original object in the ring is represented by the black-box operator T (redrawn after [88]).
The system locks so that the resonance of the other eigenmode is suppressed [89]. Note that this approach is different from the previously described NHAM architectures. Here during recording of the hologram the reference beam is derived from the object beam itself (Figure 4.17). During readout there is no individual thresholding on the reconstructed reference beam. Instead, a nonlinear gain competition mechanism favors one reconstruction over other possible ones. This results in a simpler design and automatic generation of reference beams during recording, but at the cost of losing storage capacity. These systems also lack some of the discrimination obtainable using separate reference beams, but they do incorporate competition between stored modes using nonlinear gain saturation. In related systems, the sharp thresholding characteristics of resonators and the competition between modes could be used to implement self-learning and different neural network operations on an all-optical basis [90, 91].
4.4 Photorefractive Materials as Volume Storage Media An ideal material for volumetric data storage would have a fast response during writing (submicroseconds), be as sensitive as photographic film (microjoules/cm2 ), retain information for long time periods (>10 years), have a broad sensitivity range extending into the near-infrared region of the spectrum, and be available in large quantities at good optical quality and large sizes. High optical quality and low scatter are required to ensure that the signal-bearing wave front is not adversely distorted and that the noise level from scattered light is manageable. Also, a large refractive index modulation is needed so that there is sufficient dynamic range to multiplex the many holograms. Unfortunately, such a material does not exist today. Photopolymers offer a good sensitivity (mJ/cm2 )
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
110
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter
and a long storage time (years), but the fixing of the holograms leads to film shrinkage, which degrades the quality of the reconstructed pages and shifts the Bragg angle. The main problem with these materials is the limited film thickness of a few tens of micrometers, which limits the number of multiplexed holograms [92, 93]. In a different approach, photochemical hole-burning is used for a large capacity memory system. But high capacities have been demonstrated only for very low temperatures (a few K) [94]. Most promising candidates for volume storage media are photorefractive crystals [60], which have been widely investigated for real-time holography, phase conjugation, and data storage [9]. These crystals offer a large effective optical nonlinearity available at low continuous optical power densities of a few mWcm−2 and long storage times for fixed holograms. It is generally accepted that the photorefractive phase gratings in electrooptic materials arise from optically generated charge carriers that migrate when the crystal is exposed to a spatially varying illumination pattern. A thorough introduction to the photorefractive effect (PE) has been given in Chapter 4 of this book. The effect has been observed in many photoconductive inorganic electrooptic crystals including LiNbO3 , KNbO3 , BaTiO3 , BSO, GaAs, CdTe, as well as in the organic crystals COANP:TCNQ, MNBA, and DAST [49, 95–101]. Besides crystalline materials, photorefractive polymers (see Chapter 4) have also been suggested for holographic data storage. The major limitation in achieving useful device performance in these materials is the thinness (<350 μm) and the large applied fields that are necessary for the observation of the PE. Some of the important system characteristics and experimental techniques that are relevant for applications of photorefractive materials within associative memory systems or as data-storage elements are discussed in this section.
4.4.1 Recording Schemes One potential problem with photorefractive materials when used as storage media is the partial erasure of previously stored holograms while storing a new hologram page. Therefore, holograms stored with equal energies may reconstruct images of unequal brightness, those recorded later being brighter than holograms recorded earlier. To maximize the storage capacity, all the stored holograms should be of almost equal diffraction efficiency. Also, for many applications such as neuralnetwork implementations or associative memories, it is crucial that each hologram be stored with a distinct diffraction efficiency. To ensure a constant hologram strength, two storage schemes have been proposed: sequential recording and incremental recording. Both can be applied to each of the three multiplexing techniques for volume holograms of Section 4.1.2. (A) Sequential Storage Procedure An obvious method used to avoid excessive erasure of the previously stored holograms is to record subsequent holograms for shorter and shorter times. In
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing
111
1.0 1st hologram 2nd hologram 3rd hologram 4th hologram 5th hologram
0.8
Δni Δnsat
0.6 0.4 Δnsat, i
0.2
Δnsat
0.0
t1
t2
t3
t4 t5
F I G U R E 4.18. Relative refractive index change of 5 holograms as a function of time. The recording of the next hologram in the sequence is stopped when its refractive index change is equal to that of the previous recorded holograms.
this way, the diffraction efficiency decrease of “old” holograms is reduced, and at the same time the initial diffraction efficiency of “new” holograms diminishes with hologram number. This kind of sequential approach was used already in early times by Burke et al. [102]. However, their sequence of exposure times was such that an absolutely constant diffraction efficiency over 18 hologram pages could not yet be achieved. Accurate formulas for the sequence of recording times needed to reach equal refractive index changes and thus equal diffraction efficiencies over multiple pages may be obtained by taking into account the write and erase characteristics of the material. In first approximation (see Chapter 4), the erasure of the amplitude of the refractive index change n of a hologram recorded for a time t during subsequent recording of another hologram for a time t can be expressed as t t n = n sat 1 − exp − exp − , (4.30) τw τe where n sat is the saturation amplitude of the index modulation when only one hologram is recorded, τw is the exponential time for hologram recording, and τe is the exponential erasure time. For equal illumination intensities the time constants τw and τe are usually equal. However, in some materials, such as LiNbO3 , the erasure time τe can be significantly longer than τw . As illustrated in Figure 4.18, in order to obtain a constant diffraction efficiency for all pages, the recording of the ith hologram has to be stopped whenever its diffraction efficiency equals that of the (i − 1)th hologram that is being erased. For a material with equal recording and erasure time constants (τw = τe = τ ) the required recording time for the ith hologram can be calculated making use of
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
112
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter
(4.30), so that one finds the time ti as [103] 1 + (i − 1)β ti = τ ln (i > 1), 1 + (i − 2)β
(4.31)
where β = n 1 / n sat is the ratio of the index of refraction modulation recorded during the first exposure to the saturation index modulation. In Figure 4.18 the saturation parameter β was set to β = 0.8. At the end of the recording schedule all holograms show the same refractive index amplitude change. For full recording of the first hologram (β = 1) [31] reduces to the expression given earlier [42, 104]. It is important to consider how the saturation amplitude of the refractive index change n sat,i depends on the total number of stored holograms N. One obtains n sat,i = n sat,i = n sat
β , 1 + (N − 1)β
(4.32)
which for N 1/β reduces to n sat,i n sat
1 . N
(4.33)
Therefore the grating amplitude is inversely proportional to the number of stored holograms, and with (4.8), the diffraction efficiency of each single hologram page decreases as the square of the number of hologram pages N. Using the sequential recording schedule given by (4.31), 500 angle-multiplexed holograms with 0.01% diffraction efficiency have been stored in a LiNbO3 crystal [105]. (B) Incremental Storage Procedure Since the above sequential recording schedules are all calculated from the material’s response times and the maximum attainable index modulation, any small error in material characterization can result in highly nonuniform diffraction efficiencies. Making the long initial exposures also introduces problems from beam fanning and coupling between the recording beams, both of which tend to restrict the maximum attainable index modulation below the theoretical value. These problems can be avoided by recording with a series of short exposures, so-called incremental recording. For incremental storage [106–108], each hologram i out of N holograms is recorded with a series of exposures δti , each relatively short compared with the material’s response time. During recording, the object and reference pair are sequentially displayed, repetitively cycling through all N pairs. As this process is repeated, the diffraction efficiencies of all the holograms gradually increase. After many cycles, the recording process approaches saturation, where the increase of the recording increment is exactly matched by the decrease during the (N − 1) erasure steps. This approach puts more severe constraints on the stability of the holographic setup than sequential recording. The interference pattern must be
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing 0.25
Δnsat,5 Δnsat,1 ε 2
Δni
0.20
Δnsat
113
Δnsat,1
0.15 δt
0.10 0.05 0.00
1st hologram 5th hologram
0
1
2
T
3
4
5
t / τw
F I G U R E 4.19. Relative amplitude of the refractive index change as a function of the writing time for the first and the last image (out of five) in the recording cycle. The refractive index change increases until the increase of the recording increment is exactly matched by the decrease during the erasure steps. The maximum difference in the saturation refractive index change for each hologram is given by the parameter ε. Parameters: τe = τw ; δti = δt = 0.1τW ; N = 5; T /τW = 0.5.
stable over all the time needed to record the hologram stack, and not only during recording of a single page. The principal aspects of incremental recording are depicted in Figure 4.19. After many cycles the system asymptotically converges toward a state for which the amplitude of each hologram shows only small variations around a constant average level and recording can be stopped. For short incremental recording time δti as compared to the photorefractive time constants, the asymptotic refractive index change amplitude n sat,i for hologram i is found to be n sat,i = n sat
δti δti + (T − δti )
τw , τe
(4.34)
where τw and τe are again the writing and erasure time constants of the material, and T = δti is the total cycle time through all holograms. For τw = τe , (4.34) simplifies to n sat δti n sat,i = n sat = , (4.35) T N in analogy with (4.33), valid for sequential recording. Here the second equality holds only if equal incremental times δt are chosen for every hologram page. It should be remarked that sequential and incremental storage achieve the same final grating modulation level in exactly the same time period [107, 109]. The same holds also for a third technique, parallel storage using N mutually incoherent but pairwise coherent beam pairs [109–111], a technique that has been proposed also
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
114
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter
for hologram copying from an archival storage medium to a secondary storage medium. As seen in Figure 4.19, at equilibrium, for incremental recording the hologram diffraction efficiency ηi shows a small variation ε because holograms incremented more recently are stronger. Of course, this variation can be minimized by shortening the recording increment time δt [106, 108]. If we require that all the holograms satisfy ηsat ≤ ηi ≤ ηsat (1 + ε), then the maximum δt is determined from the erasure during time (N − 1)δt to be τe δt = n sat ln(1 + ε). (4.36) 2(N − 1)
normalized diffraction efficiency
Thus the signal uniformity can be made to satisfy the system requirement by using the single parameter δt. For sake of visualization, in Figure 4.19 a relatively long incremetal time with consequently large variation ε/2 around the average value n sat,i = n sat /5 was chosen. In order to prove the validity of (4.35), five angularly multiplexed holograms have been recorded with a distinct ratio of their diffraction efficiencies in a nominally pure BaTiO3 crystal, where the assumptions of an exponential rise and decay and equal record and decay time constants are well fulfilled. The normalized target diffraction efficiencies ηsat,i /ηsat ∼ = ( n sat,i / n sat )2 of the five holograms have been chosen to be η1 = 1, η2 = 0.5, η3 = 0.8, η4 = 1, η5 = 0.2. The ratio of the writing times δti are equal to the ratio of the square root of the normalized diffraction efficiencies. Each incremetal writing time δti is selected to be short compared with the material’s response time. Setting δt1 = 4 s, the others must be selected as δt2 = 2.8 s, δt3 = 3.6 s, δt4 = 4 s, and δt5 = 1.8 s. The recording procedure was stopped after 50 cycles when saturation was reached. In Figure 4.20 the normalized diffraction efficiency is shown as a function of the angle of the readout beam. 4
1
1.0
3 0.8 0.6
2
0.4
target values η1 = 1 η2 = 0.5 η3 = 0.8 η4 = 1 η5 = 0.2 5
0.2 0.0 9.6
9.7
9.8
9.9 10.0 10.1 10.2 10.3
10.4
θ [deg]
F I G U R E 4.20. Normalized diffraction efficiency ηsat of five angle-multiplexed holograms recorded with different writing times δti in an incremental recording scheme as a function of the readout angle of the reference beam.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing
115
The experimental values of the diffraction efficiencies at the Bragg angle of each of the five holograms are quite close to the predicted ones. It should be noted that these recording schemes assume that the space-charge field of each hologram depends only on the record and erase time and that τw and τe are the same for all holograms, i.e., the dependence of the space-charge field and of the photorefractive response time on the grating spacing or on the wavelength of the incident light is not considered. Crosstalk effects and beam-coupling are also not considered. These effects become important if many holograms are stored using angle or wavelength multiplexing and deviations of the predicted diffraction efficiencies occur that are due to these effects.
4.4.2 Storage Capacity of Photorefractive Holographic Media For the case of photorefractive materials, besides crosstalk and the optical system (see Section 4.1.4), further mechanisms limit the achievable storage capacity. These limitations are due to the finite dynamic range of the photorefractive material [112] and to noise from crystal imperfections and have to be taken into account in determining the storage density of photorefractive crystals. In Section 4.4.1 we have seen that the saturation value of the refractive index change decreases with 1/N , where N is the number of stored holograms. In the case of unequal writing and erasure time constants (τw = τe ) the saturation refractive index change amplitude falls off for large N as [103] n sat,i =
n sat τe , N τw
(4.37)
which is valid for both sequential and incremental recording. Unequal recording and erase time constants can be observed, for instance, in photorefractive LiNbO3 , where the bulk photogalvanic effect is important in the formation of the space-charge field. The refractive index change and diffraction efficiency for a strong volume hologram as a function of the number of stored holograms are shown in Figure 4.21. While the signal-to-noise ratio related to crosstalk noise decreases inversely proportionally to the number of stored pages (Section 4.1.4), the signal-to-noise ratio related to scattering or detector noise decreases more rapidly and essentially quadratically with the number of pages N. This is because the noise amplitude can be considered to be essentially independent of N, while the intensity of the useful signal (proportional to the hologram diffraction efficiency) decreases as 1/N 2 because of (4.37) and (4.8). One may define the minimum allowable signal diffraction efficiency ηmin , which is sufficient to overcome a constant noise level in the apparatus, such as scattering or detector noise. The maximum number of pages Nmax that can be stored can then be easily calculated as τe φmax −1 , (4.38) Nmax = 1 + τw φmin
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
116
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter 1.00
Δnsat, i / Δnsat
(a)
~1/N
0.10
0.01
1
10
100
1.00
F I G U R E 4.21. (a) Normalized refractive index change as a function of the number of stored images. Solid line: symmetric recording/erasure (τW = τe ); dotted line: asymmetric recording/erasure (τe = 5 τW ) from (4.34); dashed line: asymptotic fall-off as 1/N for large N and τe = 5 τW (4.37). (b) Saturation diffraction efficiency as a function of the number of stored images for φmax = 3π/2.
(b)
ηsat,i
τe = 5 τw 0.10
0.01
τe = τw
1
10
100
Number of holograms
where φmin = (ηmin )1/2 and the maximum strength parameter φmax = (π n sat d )/(λ cos θ) is defined by the argument of the sine function in (4.8) and contains the maximum achievable refractive index change n sat and the material thickness d. In Table 4.1 we show an example of the maximum number of storable holograms Nmax and corresponding storage density D. An (arbitrary) minimum diffraction efficiency ηmin of 0.001% (10 mWcm−2 read beam resulting in a 100 nWcm−2 diffracted beam) and a maximum strength parameter φmax = 3π/2 are assumed. The results are summarized for the case of τe = τw and for τe = 5τw . In this example the storage density reaches a few tens of Gbit/cm3 , which is less than T A B L E 4.1. Number of stored holograms Nmax and the storage density D assuming a maximum strength parameter of φmax = 3π/2 and a minimum allowable diffraction efficiency of 0.001% for a d = 1-cm-thick crystal. The storage density is calculated using (4.15) and the parameter values F = 1, f = 50 mm, nr = 1.22, λ = 0.5 μm, and α L = 10−3 φmax = 3π/2
Nmax
D [Gbit/cm3 ]
τe = τw τe = 5τw
1490 7450
18 91
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing
117
predicted in Figure 4.6 from limitations due the optical system, diffraction, and crosstalk. This is because the additional limitation due to scattering and detector noise implicitly contained in the value of ηmin further reduces the maximum number of holograms Nmax . Note that the effect of dynamically forming noise gratings [113], arising by interference of a new reference wave with the the Braggmismatched diffraction from older gratings, has been neglected both here and in the treatment of Section 4.1.4. It should be kept in mind that the minimum diffraction efficiency that one can afford in a given system is limited not only by noise, but also by speed and data-rate issues [114]. At the detector a sufficient number of photons has to be integrated for each bit, and thus a too-weak diffracted beam goes at the expense of processing speed. As an example, for the 5000 320 × 220pixel holograms of [21], which were read out with a 50 mW/cm2 beam, and a diffraction efficiency of η = 4 × 10−6 , one can compute a necessary readout time on the order of one ms [9]. Despite the low diffraction efficiency, this readout time still corresponds to the fastest data rates of available CCD cameras, indicating that a fast data rate might represent one of the most important advantages of holographic memories over conventional optical point storage devices. To further increase the storage capacity of a photorefractive memory, conventional error-encoding techniques can be used to reduce the minimum signal-tonoise ratio required to achieve an acceptable bit-error rate. Neifield et al. [115] suggested that a factor-of-2 improvement in capacity can be achieved even when error-correction bits diminish the number of storage bits per page. Thus photorefractive memory systems with a storage capacity of few tens of Gbit/cm3 seem to be feasible. Recent research in academia and industry (primarily in the U.S.) has resulted in a number of impressive laboratory demonstrations, most of which are based on photorefractive materials. Holographic memories seem now to possess the storage density, readout speed, and fidelity required for competitive commercial products. The first fully digital holographic storage system using a photorefractive crystal was demonstrated by Heanue et al. [116]. The total useful capacity of that system based on a LiNbO3 crystal was 163 kBytes. In a later prototype demonstrator constructed by McMichael et al. [117], 20,000 holograms each containing approximately 70 kbits of data were stored in 20 different locations of a LiNbO3 crystal, corresponding to a raw capacity of about 1.4 Gbits. Fully digital holographic storage systems capable of real-time retrieval and electronic decoding of MPEG compressed video have been demonstrated recently [118]. The often cited goal of storage of megabit data pages with gigabit-per-second data rate has been recently demonstrated by an IBM group [119]. Pixel-matched recontruction of 1024 × 1024 arrays of binary pixels with 1 ms optical exposure of the holograms gave a raw bit-error rate as low as 2.4 × 10−6 using globalthreshold detection. A digital holographic storage system incorporating thermal fixing or optical fixing by means of a two-color gating technique has also been demonstrated [120, 121].
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
118
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter
4.4.3 Hologram Fixing and Nondestructive Readout The use of photorefractive crystals in holographic storage data systems, neural networks, and associative memories requires that the stored holograms not be erased during readout. The storage time in the dark is also finite and depends mainly on the dark conductivity of the materials. At least three possibilities are exploited to overcome these problems: the use of long-lived complementary gratings often achieved through heating of the crystal (thermal fixing), nondestructive readout using a wavelength at which the photorefractive material is not photoconductive, and sustained readout using refresh and low-intensity probe techniques. The thermal fixing procedure takes advantage of mobile ions resident in the crystal as a consequence of the growth process, which replicate a hologram or a series of holograms formed by trapped electrons or holes. This process can be described schematically as follows [122–124]: During or after hologram recording, the sample is heated to temperatures in the 100◦ –200◦ C range. At these temperatures the mobile ions move to form another grating and neutralize the electronic grating (fixing stage). On cooling to room temperature, a homogeneous illumination is used to partially erase the electronic grating and bring out the replica (developing stage). The complementary grating remains and cannot be optically erased at lower temperatures. This technique was demonstrated first in LiNbO3 [125, 126] and later in Bi12 SiO20 [127], in KNbO3 [128–130], and in BaTiO3 [131]. With this process an erase-time constant at room temperature for the fixed gratings of several years (LiNbO3 ) or a few days (KNbO3 ) instead of minutes or seconds, respectively, can be achieved even under illumination of the crystal. Another mechanism relies on domain patterns in ferroelectrics. Replication of a space-charge field due to trapped charge is achieved by domain formation. The exact configuration taken by domain walls to compensate the space-charge distribution is not yet known. Three models have been proposed: local switching of the spontaneous polarization wherever the total field (the sum of the applied and the space-charge field) exceeds the coercive field (Figure 4.22a) [132], needle-shaped (a)
(b) P
+ + −− + − + − + − + − + − + −
P + + −− + − + − + − + − + − + −
F I G U R E 4.22. (a) Local switching of domains wherever the applied and the space-charge field are larger than the coercive field. (b) needle-shaped domains nucleate at one electrode and propagate through the crystal until they are stopped by the space-charge field. The charges shown are those redistributed by means of the photorefractive effect. These charges are compensated by the bound surface charges at the boundaries of the domains (charge density σ = 2P · n, where n is the domain wall normal).
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing F I G U R E 4.23. The photorefractive space-charge field induces a deformation of domain walls in an unpoled crystal, so that this field is screened.
119
P ++− + − + − + − + − + − + − + −
−
domains nucleated at one electrode propagate toward the other electrode until they are stopped by the space-charge distribution (see Figure 4.22b) [133], and deformation of the domain walls by the space-charge field. These domain gratings are not erased by light, and they can be reconverted into photorefractive gratings by applying an electric field. It has been demonstrated that the diffraction efficiency of the revealed photorefractive grating is higher than that of the photorefractive grating that originally generated the domain grating. Deformation of the domain walls by the space-charge field such that this field is screened (Figure 4.23) has been proposed by Cudney et al. [134]. In this case it is possible to record and simultaneously compensate an optically induced spacecharge pattern by depoling the crystal before the grating is created. By repoling the crystal a diffracted beam reappears. Evidence of these effects have been identified in Srx Ba(1−x) Nb2 O6 [135, 136], BaTiO3 [133], and KNbO3 [137]. Recently, storage and fixing of 1000 anglemultiplexed holograms by ferroelectric domain switching has been demonstrated in Sr0.75 Ba0.25 Nb2 O6 [24]. The lifetime of the fixed gratings was on the order of 14 hours. The spectral sensitivity of the photorefractive material can also be used for nondestructive readout. Simple plane-wave holograms written at one wavelength may be read by Bragg-matched light of another wavelength, where the medium is not photoactive. For image-bearing holograms, however, light at the readout wavelength cannot in general be Bragg-matched to all the components of the signal. A nonvolatile memory with different recording and readout wavelengths that uses preformatted data has been demonstrated by Psaltis et al. [138]. This kind of technique is also being explored in connection with shift-multiplexing using spherical reference waves [36]. Recently, two-color illumination has also been attracting considerable interest because of the possibility of obtaining twophoton photorefractive recording at cw power levels. As in previous observations with pulsed light [139, 140], the gating light at the wavelength λ2 populates certain defect levels and increases the absorption at another (usually longer) wavelength λ1 . A hologram can therefore be recorded with the wavelength λ1 , to which the material would be otherwise insensitive. Readout at the wavelength λ1 only does not affect the hologram and is therefore nondestructive [141–143]. While this effect was first attributed to the presence of Pr3+ or other rare-earth ions, the real origin of the involved defect levels is still unknown. The sensitivity
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
120
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter
of the two-color recording effect is enhanced [143] by use of LiNbO3 crystal with a composition close to stoichiometric [144] instead of the more common congruently grown crystals. In addition to these techniques, which rely on the properties of the materials, there are feedback techniques that refresh and sustain holograms during their use [145–148]. In one of these techniques, holograms are periodically copied when their diffraction efficiency falls below a certain level [145]. Holograms may also be circulated between two photorefractive crystals by transferring data from one to the other before the holograms in the first are erased during readout, and then reversing the roles of the crystals [146]. However, the effectiveness of many of these techniques is limited by noise effects, and noisy gratings are copied and amplified as well. As an alternative to all optical approaches, hybrid prototype systems where refreshing is performed using an optoelectronic device acting both as spatial light modulator and detector array have been demonstrated recently [148]. The optoelectronic device is integrated into an optical system with phase-conjugate readout of the photorefractive memory, which makes this approach potentially very interesting for the construction of very compact lensless dynamically refreshed holographic storage systems.
4.4.4 Coherent Erasure and Updating of Holograms High-storage-density optical holographic memories should have the capability of updating pages of information. In photorefractive crystals, erasure of recorded holograms is usually performed either by uniform illumination of the storage crystal at the recording wavelength or by heating the crystal if thermal fixing has been used. These bulk erasure processes apply indiscriminately to all multiplexed holograms in a stack. Selective erasure of a single stored hologram has been demonstrated using a coherent erasure technique [149]. This technique is based on superimposed recording of a π-phase-shifted image. The selective erasure is shown to be much faster than the incoherent erasure owing to the coincidence of the previous charge distribution and the π -phase shifted new light illumination pattern. In another demonstration, incremental recording was used for recording of the initial binary holograms as well as for replacing (selective erasure and updating) a single hologram out of four [150]. This method can not be used only to erase a single hologram but also to erase a single bit or part of a hologram by applying the phase shift not to the reference beam but to the part of the image that is to be erased. Note also that, when after storing a binary image a second image is stored with a π-phase shifted reference beam, some parallel logical operations such as XOR and OR can be implemented [151].
4.5 Optical Correlators Using Photorefractive Crystals In Section 4.2 we have discussed the general features of the joint Fourier transform (JTC) and VanderLugt-type optical correlators and analyzed the consequences of using thick photorefractive materials for the necessary optical processing.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing
121
Despite the fact that the Bragg condition in volume media destroys shift invariance and partly limits the applicability of such systems, recent implementations of optical correlators (see Section 4.2) based on photorefractive nonlinearities are numerous [68, 71, 74–76, 79, 152–165]. While many of these works are laboratory optical-table-size demonstrations, some compact devices have been constructed as well. Rajbenbach et al. [68, 158] have constructed a compact photorefractive JTC system based on a Bi12 SiO20 (BSO) designed for an industrial application, namely, to sort mechanical tools of different basic two-dimensional geometrical shapes. The reference set of objects is presented to a CCD camera, while the unknown object is viewed by a second camera. The two video signals are mixed so as to generate a single video image that is displayed by a liquid-crystal display in order to build a single-axis JTC. To write the grating in the photorefractive BSO crystal a visible green beam from a frequency-doubled Nd:YAG minilaser is used. The real-time phase hologram is read out by a Bragg-matched plane wave from a HeNe laser. A CCD sensor in the correlation plane analyzes the diffracted signal. The response time ranges between 35 and 100 ms for illumination intensities on the order of 10 mW/cm2 . Recognition of tools out of a set of four has been demonstrated, but the system can easily be expanded to more objects. In another demonstration that uses a BSO crystal as well, Yu et al. [75] employed a Galilean telescope to decrease the angles between the object beams in the JTC, which relaxes partly the limitations due to Bragg diffraction. The use of photorefractive crystals as a buffer memory for JTC-type correlators has been suggested by Alves et al. [166]. In order to get the full advantage of using thin holograms in the Fourier plane they proposed to use a photorefractive crystal as a buffer memory for providing a fast data-access time and to store many filters. To achieve correlation at video rate each image has to be compared to a set of filters in less than 40 ms. The Fourier transform of this image is recorded in a nonlinear material by interfering with a plane wave. A third beam carrying the Fourier transform of the filters reads out the hologram. If the whole set of filters can be read out from the photorefractive crystal in less than 40 ms, dead time exists between each video image, which can be used to refresh data. Alves et al. analyze the refreshing scheme and show also erasure and updating of the stored filters in the memory. Nevertheless, fast correlation with such a system has not yet been implemented. If a thin real-time holographic medium is used to record the images that are to be compared, fast image correlation with a large set of filters seems to be possible. A photorefractive crystal for permanent storage of matched filters in a VanderLugt-type hybrid digital/optical correlator has been demonstrated by Duelli et al. [164]. In contrast to most photorefractive crystal-based correlators, where the thick photorefractive material is placed in the filter plane, in this system the optical memory is used as an input device for the reference library and a phase-modulating liquid-crystal television is placed in the filter plane. Thus the correlator is fully shift-invariant. During the recognition process the input scene is Fourier transfomed electronically and displayed on the LCTV, and a sequential search of the input scene within the library of reference objects is performed by
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
122
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter
rotating the storage crystal and reading out the angularly multiplexed matched filters. This correlator shows a high discrimination, sharp correlation peaks, a high light efficiency, and is fully shift-invariant in spite of the photorefractive crystal thickness. In addition to inorganic crystals and organic polymers, another class of thin photorefractive materials, semiconductor multiple quantum well (MQW) devices have been employed for optical correlation in a JTC configuration [67]. In this class of materials the photorefractive effect is mediated by resonant effects such as the Franz–Keldysh effect or the quantum-confined Stark effect [167, 168]. Due to the large carrier mobility these materials exhibit a fast response time, and a correlation operation can be performed in time on the order of 1 μs. On the other hand, the high mobility is detrimental for the achievable resolution, which is limited to a feature size of about 10 μm. All optical correlation has also been demonstrated using infrared wavelength and bulk photorefractive semiconductor materials as real-time holographic media in both types of optical correlators [71, 160].
4.6 All-Optical Nonlinear Associative Memories In this section we mention some reported associative memory systems based on the general architecture described in Section 4.3.2. We distinguish between implementations using thin and thick holograms. An associative memory containing a photochromic saturable absorber as nonlinear threshold element realized recently in our laboratory is treated in greater depth at the end of this section. For optical associative memories based on optical resonators we refer to Section 4.3.3.
4.6.1 Thin Storage Media Implementations All-optical implementations of NHAM can be differentiated by the form and implementations of the nonlinearities and by the storage medium used. The use of thin Fourier transform holograms for storing the pages of information has the advantage of shift-invariance and the capability of heteroassociations by manipulating the correlation plane. A great disadvantage is the lack of Bragg selectivity, which results in a low storage capacity compared to volume holograms. Most implementations use a single-iteration nonresonant configuration, where the object arm phase-conjugating mirror (PCM) is missing (see Figure 4.16). The first all-optical associative memory was demonstrated by Soffer et al. [169, 170]. They used thin thermoplastic Fourier transform holograms as the storage medium and a PCM based on degenerate four-wave mixing (DFWM) in BaTiO3 . The output of the hologram acted as a probe for the DFWM system, generating an amplified phase-conjugate of the correlation plane. A partial version of one of the stored objects was used to address the hologram. The conjugated backward-propagating beam illuminated the hologram, re-creating a complete version of the stored objects. Thresholding was not demonstrated in this system,
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing
123
which was basically a linear associative memory. The discrimination of the two stored images was due to the coding of the objects using high-spatial-requency diffusers. Furthermore, Paek and Psaltis demonstrated a single nonresonant associative memory that used a simple mirror to retroreflect the reconstructed reference beams. In their system, four spatially multiplexed objects are recorded simultaneously using a single reference beam. This approach is equivalent to sequentially recording objects centered in the same aperture but with angularly shifted planewave reference beams. During readout the presence of a correlation peak in a particular subregion is a unique label for which the stored object is being recognized. A pinhole array acts as the thresholding element; only the peaks of the correlations pass and the sidelobe noise is suppressed [171]. Using a PCM instead of a simple mirror in connection with a pinhole array association of two stored objects has also been demonstrated [172]. But the discrimination in these implementations was not complete, since faint images of other stored holograms could still be observed in the output plane. Moreover, the quality of the reconstructed images was quite poor. This was attributed to the relative large size of the pinholes. Although a thin hologram was used, which allows shift-invariance, this advantage has been lost due to the fixed pinhole array. Paek and Psaltis discussed approaches for restoring the shift-invariance by eliminating the pinhole array and using quadratic nonlinearities in the correlation plane. A novel method of thresholding was demonstrated by Wang et al. [173]. They used a bistable Fabry–Perot etalon. This nonlinear element was situated in the correlation plane, and holding beams were used to bias the etalon. If the peak of the autocorrelation function was sufficient to switch the etalon, the holding beam at that point was be transmitted. Since the holding beams were aligned to be counterpropagating to the reference beams, after switching, the transmitted holding beam read out the hologram and reconstructed the associative image. The need for a PCM was therefore avoided, but the system’s complexity increased. Although auto- and heteroassociation could be implemented by directing the holding beams to the same or different holograms, the use of a separate holding beam for each stored image is not practical for large data storage.
4.6.2 Volume Storage in Associative Memories The use of volume holograms in associative memories to extend the storage capacity was first pointed out by Yariv et al. [174]. They demonstrated all-optical association between two images stored in a photorefractive BaTiO3 crystal. The reconstructed reference waves from the holographic memory were coupled to a photorefractive bistable ring resonator by means of multimode optical fibers. The ring resonator performed the function of thresholding, in which only one of the two waves survives and illuminates a transparency similar to the one used to record the holographic memory. Xu et al. [175, 176], stored four objects in a photorefractive KNSBN:Co crystal, and liquid-crystal electrooptical switches served as the (optoelectronic) thresholding element. Similar to the bistable
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
124
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter
Fabry–Perot etalon, counterpropagating holding beams have to be used in order to bias the switches and to read out the associated image. Lu et al. [177] presented a multilayer associative memory, which is basically similar to a Hopfield network [4] with nonlinear processing on the inner product between the input and the stored patterns. The hybrid optical–electronic implementation involved storage of volume holograms in two photorefractive crystals while thresholding of the reconstructed reference waves was performed electronically. Reconstruction of one out of four images was demonstrated. Heteroassociation was also demonstrated. Kang et al. [178], Tanaka et al. [179], and Chen et al. [180] used a LiNbO3 crystal as a thick holographic recording medium and a PCM that provided optical feedback, thresholding, and gain. Unfortunately, the thresholding behavior was not analyzed, and associative readout was demonstrated only for a single image or for orthonormal images. Association has also been demonstrated by Ingold et al. [181] using a nonresonant cavity with image-bearing beams. The nonresonant cavity consists of an optical feedback configuration containing a photorefractive crystal and a nematic liquid crystal. The photorefractive KNbO3 crystal is used as an optical amplifier for several beams and for image comparison, and the nematic liquid crystal as a thresholding element. Associative readout, error correction, and image completion are demonstrated for two and three stored black-and-white images. Associative recall of stored images has been demonstrated for one, mostly two, and at maximum five stored images in almost any published all-optical nonlinear holographic associative memories. The maximum number of angularly multiplexed holograms was limited by the high loss through the hologram and other optical components. A further limit was imposed by the low gain of the nonlinear elements. The thresholding capabilities as well as the storage capacity and practical limitations of the proposed or demonstrated systems were mostly not described. In the following we describe in some more detail an all-optical nonlinear holographic associative memory that was developed recently in our laboratory [182]. It is similar to that of Soffer et al. [169] in that it is a single-pass NHAM that uses a phase-conjugating mirror for retroreflection of the reconstructed reference beams. A schematic setup is shown in Figure 4.24. The images are stored in a volume holographic medium consisting of a photorefractive LiNbO3 crystal by angle multiplexing. Since the phase conjugation is realized via degenerate four-wave mixing in a photorefractive KNbO3 crystal, its reflectivity is essentially linear. Therefore an additional nonlinear element has to be added in order to provide thresholding. This is achieved by inserting a saturable absorber with a tunable threshold into the correlation plane. The absorber consists of a photochromiccolorant-doped polymethylmetacrylate (PMMA) and the threshold intensity for absorption saturation can be adjusted by simultaneous illumination with UV incoherent light [183]. As mentioned earlier (Section 4.2.2B), the thickness of the photorefractive crystal makes the holograms Bragg selective, which destroys the shift invariance in the plane of incidence and with it the main advantage of using Fourier holograms.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing stored images
reference beams input plane
θ
C
C O
LiNbO3:Ce
L
gain crystal KNbO3:Fe L
f
C
125
output plane
f
saturable absorber KNbO3 phaseconjugating mirror
F I G U R E 4.24. Schematic of our all-optical associative memory; L : lenses, f : focal length of the lenses.
Furthermore, shift invariance is also destroyed by the presence of a stationary diffuser, which is attached to the liquid-crystal display present in the object arm. A two-dimensional analysis (see (4.29)) shows that for thick media the intensity distribution Iref,i (u) of the reconstructed reference beam i can be approximated by the square of an overlap integral of the transmission functions of the partial input image tinput (x, y) and the stored image ti (x, y) corresponding to that reference beam, i.e., the cross-correlation sampled at the point zero: 2 ∗ Iref,i (u) = Iref,i (u = u i ) ∝ tinput (x, y)ti dx dy , (4.39) aperture
where u is the spatial coordinate in the plane of incidence at the saturable absorber, u i is the location of the focus of the reference beam i at the absorber, and x and y are the spatial coordinates at the input plane. The integration runs over the aperture of the input scene. During associative readout the reconstructed reference beams pass through the saturable absorber, are phase conjugated, and retrace their paths to the hologram passing through the saturable absorber again. This double pass through the absorber greatly enhances the intensity difference between the beams, such that only one of the reconstructed reference beams has a nonnegligible intensity by the time it addresses the LiNbO3 crystal from the right side. Due to the strong angular selectivity of the thick hologram, only the stored image that is most similar to the input is reconstructed and observed in the output plane. The number of stored images that can be associated in parallel is increased by amplifying the reference beams. A gain crystal transfers energy from a pump beam to the reconstructed reference beams via photorefractive two-beam coupling. This is necessary since
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
126
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter
Output Intensity Ratio
1000
100
10 0.04 wt.% doped PMMA 0.02 wt.% doped PMMA
1
0
1
2
3 4 5 6 7 Input Intensity Ratio
8
9
10
F I G U R E 4.25. Thresholding characteristic of the saturable absorber. The full squares are measured data for 0.02 wt.% and the open squares are data for 0.04 wt.% colorant-doped PMMA. The curves give the theoretically expected transmission ratios according to a simple model presented in [183].
the diffraction efficiency decreases with the number of images that are stored in the LiNbO3 crystal, and thus the signal-to-noise ratio increases at the output plane. The thresholding effect of the saturable absorber can be seen in Figure 4.25, where the intensity ratio of two reference beams after the thresholding process is shown as a function of the intensity ratio before thresholding. The saturable absorber strongly enhances the intensity ratio and suppresses the weaker reference beam almost completely. An intensity ratio of one to two of the reconstructed reference beams before thresholding is necessary to reach a signal-to-noise ratio of one to ten in the output plane. The readout time of our implementation of an associative memory is limited by the response time of the amplifier and the saturable absorber and is about 1 second for the intensities we used. Ten black-and-white images (letters) with an area overlap of 20–80% have been stored in the LiNbO3 crystal and successfully read out using a partial input. The exposure time per image per cycle during recording was 10 s, and 60 cycles were necessary to reach saturation using an intensity for the object and reference beams of approximately 25 mW/cm2 . Due to the long writing time, the erasure of the recorded holograms during associative readout is negligible. Photographs of the observed output using a partial input are shown in Figure 4.26. The image completion properties can be seen in Figure 4.27. In this case five objects have been stored and the output has been viewed with a CCD camera. This was necessary due to the very small amount of light that was used for the associative readout. Only 80 pixels (out of 85,000 of the entire screen and out of 40,000 of the entire associated image) are necessary to get full reconstruction of the associated image. The small dot that is used as the input has a large overlap
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing F I G U R E 4.26. Ten letters have been stored and associative readout using only a partial input image.
127
stored images
H M B A K F D N E C H M B A K F D C N E input images
readout images
⇒
⇒ ⇒ ⇒ ⇒ ⇒ ⇒ ⇒ ⇒ ⇒
with the letter A and a smaller overlap with the letter M. Notice that crosstalk is virtually absent. One serious problem encountered by associative memories is to distinguish between strongly correlated images and, in particular, images that are partially or totally enclosed by others. Recently we have presented a storage scheme for amplitude-modulated images that eliminates this problem in nonlinear holographic associative memories [184]. The method is based on controlling the diffraction efficiency of each hologram corresponding to a stored image. It was demonstrated that the weighted storage method allows the discrimination of highly correlated images. The weighted storage can be accomplished by adequately varying the exposure time of each hologram.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
128
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter F I G U R E 4.27. Reconstruction of 5 stored images. Only 80 pixels are necessary to get full reconstruction of the stored images. The white area was used as input, while the gray letters are shown only in order to indicate the overlap of the small input area with the stored images.
4.7 Summary Holographic data storage has received renewed interest in the last few years. In this chapter we discussed some recent advances in holographic memory systems and given the major emphasis to their applications to optical processing using photorefractive media, such as pattern recognition and associative memories. Several theoretical studies have shown that the storage capacity of a practical optical holographic system is much lower than the ultimate diffraction limit, but it can still reach about 20 Gbit/cm−3 for a bit-error rate on the order of 10−9 . The limitations are introduced by the optical system and crosstalk during readout. Among the most promising materials to implement a holographic storage device are photorefractive inorganic crystals. They offer a large effective optical nonlinearity available at low continuous optical power densities of a few mWcm−2 and long storage times for fixed holograms. Due to erasure of previously recorded holograms, special recording schemes have to be used to achieve
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing
129
a constant diffraction efficiency of all stored holograms. Nowadays, the storage capacity in these materials is limited by the intrinsic scattering noise. But still photorefractive storage systems with a storage capacity of few tens of Gbit/cm−3 seem to be feasible. Although this number has not been achieved yet, it has been shown that recording of 1-Mbit data pages with 1-Gbit/s data-transfer rate upon readout are possible in practice. These large storage densities are of great importance if these systems are to be applied to perform image processing. We have discussed the influence of the volume nature of the stored data pages on the performance characteristics of the two common types of optical correlators (joint Fourier transform correlator and VanderLugt-type correlator). The latter is especially attractive in using angularly multiplexed holograms for storage of matched templates and thus for performing several pattern recognitions in parallel. Also, nonlinear holographic associative memories gain from the recent advances in photorefractive storage systems. The latest results for this kind of optical processing task have been summarized, and an associative memory system constructed in our laboratory has been described in deeper detail. Nevertheless, while a few holographic storage devices with limited capacity are present in niche markets, practical commercial systems for mass-storage or associative memories do not yet exist. Material problems remain the principal obstacle. In the case of holographic associative memories, association at TV frame rates with a large set of stored images still appears as a distant goal. Moreover, in order to implement higher-order tasks (such as rotation and scale invariance) these systems have to be incorporated into general neural-network architectures.
References 1. P.J. vanHeerden: Appl. Opt. 2, 393 (1963). 2. K. IIzuka: Engineering Optics. T. Tamir, ed., Optical Sciencies (Springer-Verlag, Berlin Heidelberg New York, 1986), vol. 35. 3. T. Kohonen: Self-Organization and Associative Memory. T.S. Huang, M.R. Schroeder, eds., Springer Series in Information Sciences (Springer, Berlin, 1987), vol. 8. 4. J.J. Hopfield: Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 79, 2554–2558 (1982). 5. G. Pauliat, G. Roosen: Int. J. Opt. Comp. 2, 271–291 (1991). 6. L. Hesselink, M.C. Bashaw: Opt. Quantum Electr. 25, S611–S661 (1993). 7. C. Alves, P. Aing, G. Pauliat, G. Roosen: Optical Memory & Neural-Networks 3, 167–190 (1994). 8. J.H. Hong, I. McMichael, T.Y. Chang, W. Christian, P. Eung Gi: Opt. Engin. 34, 2193–2203 (1995). 9. C. Alves, G. Pauliat, G. Roosen: Insulating materials for Optoelectronics, ed. by F.A. L´opez, (World Scientific, Singapore, 1995) pp. 277–328. 10. N.H. Farhat, D. Psaltis, A. Prata, E. Paek: Appl. Opt. 24, 1469–1475 (1985). 11. E. Kim, S. Lee, W. Lee: Jap. J. Appl. Phys. 29, 1304–1306 (1990).
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
130
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter
12. M. Takino, N. Ohtsu, T. Yatagi: Jap. J. Appl. Phys. 29, 1317–1320 (1990). 13. K.J. Weible, G. Pedrini, W. Xue, R. Thalmann: Jap. J. Appl. Phys. 29, L1301–L1303 (1990). 14. S. Jutamulia, F.T.S. Yu: Optics and Laser Technology 28, 59–72 (1996). 15. T.K. Gaylord, M.G. Moharam: Appl. Opt. 20, 3271–3273 (1981). 16. H. Kogelnik: Bell Syst. Tech. J. 48, 2909–2947 (1969). 17. G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik: Phys. Rev. E 35, 1035 (1997). 18. E. Guibelalde: Opt. Quantum Electr. 16, 173–178 (1984). 19. K. Curtis, A. Pu, D. Psaltis: Opt. Lett. 19 (1994). 20. F.H. Mok, M.C. Tackitt, H.M. Stoll: Opt. Lett. 16, 605–607 (1991). 21. F.H. Mok: Opt. Lett. 18, 915–917 (1993). 22. S. Tao, R. Selviah, J.E. Midwinter: Opt. Lett. 18, 912–914 (1993). 23. G.W. Burr, F.H. Mok, D. Psaltis: Conference on Lasers and Electro-optics, Anaheim, CA (1994). p. 9. 24. J. Ma, T. Chang, J. Hong, R. Neurgaonkar, G. Barbastathis, D. Psaltis: Opt. Lett. 22, 1116–1118 (1997). 25. S. Naruse, A. Shiratori, M. Obara: Appl. Phys. Lett. 71, 4–6 (1997). 26. J.T.L. Macchia, D.L. White: Appl. Opt. 7, 91 (1968). 27. C.C. Sun, R.H. Tsou, W. Chang, J.Y. Chang, M.W. Chang: Opt. Quantum Electr. 28, 1551–1561 (1996). 28. C. Denz, G. Pauliat, G. Roosen, T. Tschudi: Opt. Commun. 85, 171–176 (1991). 29. C. Denz, G. Pauliat, G. Roosen, T. Tschudi: Appl. Opt. 31, 5700–5705 (1992). 30. J. Lembcke, C. Denz, T. Tschudi: Opt. Mat. 4, 428–432 (1995). 31. C. Alves, G. Pauliat, G. Roosen: Opt. Lett. 19, 1894–1896 (1994). 32. J. Lembcke, C. Denz, T.H. Barnes, T. Tschudi: Photorefractive Materials, Effects and Devices, Kiev, Ukraine (Technical Digest, 1993), pp. 574–577. 33. C. Denz, T. Dellwig, J. Lembcke, T. Tschudi: Opt. Lett. 21, 278–280 (1996). 34. D.Z. Anderson, D.M. Lininger: Appl. Opt. 26, 5031–5038 (1987). 35. D. Psaltis, M. Levene, A. Pu, G. Barbastathis, K. Curtis: Opt. Lett. 20, 782–784 (1995). 36. G. Barbastathis, D. Psaltis: Opt. Lett. 21, 432–434 (1996). 37. G.A. Rakuljic, V. Leyva, A. Yariv: Opt. Lett. 17, 1471–1473 (1992). 38. F.T.S. Yu, F. Zhao, H. Zhou, S. Yin: Opt. Lett. 18, 1849–1851 (1993). 39. S. Yin, H. Zhou, F. Zhao, M. Wen, Z. Yang, J. Zhang, F.T.S. Yu: Opt. Commun. 101, 317 (1993) 40. D. Lande, J.F. Heanue, M.C. Bashaw, L. Hesselink: Opt. Lett. 21, 1780–1782 (1996). 41. W.T. Cathey: Optical Information Processing and Holography. S.S. Ballard, ed. (John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1974). 42. K. Bløtekjaer: Appl. Opt. 18, 57–67 (1979). 43. T. Tanaka, S. Kawata: J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 13, 935–943 (1996). 44. J.R. Wullert, Y. Lu: Appl. Opt. 33, 2192–2196 (1994). 45. T. Jannson: Optica Acta 27, 1335 (1980). 46. D. Brady, D. Psaltis: Opt. Quantum Electr. 25 (1993). 47. P. Graf, M. Lang: Appl. Opt. 11, 1382–1388 (1972). 48. A. VanderLugt: Appl. Opt. 12, 1675–1685 (1973). 49. P. G¨unter, U. Fl¨uckiger, J.P. Huignard, F. Micheron: Ferroelectrics 13, 297 (1976). 50. R.G. Ramberg: RCA Rev. 33, 5–52 (1972). 51. G. Akos, G. Kiss, P. Varga: Opt. Commun. 20, 63–67 (1977). 52. C. Gu, J. Hong, I. McMichael, R. Saxena: J. Opt. Soc. Am. A 9, 1978–1983 (1992).
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing
131
53. K. Curtis, C. Gu, D. Psaltis: Opt. Lett. 18, 1001–1003 (1993). 54. M.C. Bashaw, J.F. Heanue, A. Aharoni, J.F. Walkup, L. Hesselink: J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 11, 1820–1836 (1994). 55. K. Curtis, D. Psaltis: J. Opt. Soc. Am. A 10, 2547–2550 (1993). 56. X. Yi, P. Yeh, C. Gu: Opt. Lett. 19, 1580–1582 (1994). 57. X. Yi, S. Campbell, P. Yeh, C. Gu: Opt. Lett. 20, 779–781 (1995). 58. K. Curtis, D. Psaltis: Opt. Lett. 19, 1774–1776 (1994). 59. M.P. Bernal, H. Coufal, R.K. Grygier, J.A. Hoffnagle, C.M. Jefferson, R.M. MacFarlane, R.M. Shelby, G.T. Sincerbox, P. Wimmer, G. Wittmann: Appl. Opt. 35, 2360–2374 (1996). 60. G.T. Sincerbox: Opt. Mat. 4, 370–375 (1995). 61. N. Collings: Optical Pattern Recognition Using Holographic Techniques (AddisonWesley, Wokingham, England, 1988). 62. C.S. Weaver, J.W. Goodman: Appl. Opt. 5, 1248–1249 (1966). 63. T.C. Lee, J. Rebholz, P. Tamura: Opt. Lett. 4, 121–123 (1979). 64. Q. Zhan, T. Minemoto: Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 32, 3471–3476 (1993). 65. R. Thoma, N. Hampp: Opt. Lett. 17, 1158–1160 (1992). 66. I. Biaggio, J.P. Partanen, B. Ai, R.J. Knize, R.W. Hellwarth: Nature 371, 318–320 (1994). 67. A. Partovi, A.M. Glass, T.H. Chiu, D.T.H. Liu: Opt. Lett. 18, 906–908 (1993). 68. H. Rajbenbach, S. Bann, P. R´efr´egier, P. Joffre, J.-P. Huignard, H. Buchkremer, A.S. Jensen, E. Rasmussen, K. Brenner, G. Lohman: Appl. Opt. 31, 5666–5674 (1992). 69. A. VanderLugt: IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory IT 10, 139–145 (1964). 70. M.G. Nicholson, I.R. Cooper, M.W. McCall, C.R. Petts: Appl. Opt. 26, 278–286 (1987). 71. G. Gheen, L. J. Cheng: Appl. Opt. 27, 2756–2761 (1988). 72. I. Biaggio, B. Ai, R.J. Knize, J.P. Partanen, R.W. Hellwarth: Opt. Lett. 19, 1765–1767 (1994). 73. R.A. Athale, K. Raj: Opt. Lett. 17, 880–882 (1992). 74. J.O. White, A. Yariv: Appl. Phys. Lett. 37, 5 (1980). 75. F.T.S. Yu, S. Wu, S. Rajan, D.A. Gregory: Appl. Opt. 31, 2416–2418 (1992). 76. D. Pepper, J. Yeung, D. Fekete, A. Yariv: Opt. Lett. 3, 7–9 (1978). 77. F.T.S. Yu: Optical Information Processing (John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1983). 78. N.V. Kuhktarev, V.B. Markov, S.G. Odulov, M.S. Soskin, V.L. Vinetskii: Ferroelectrics 22, 949 (1979). 79. F.T.S. Yu, S. Yin: Opt. Engin. 34, 2224–2231 (1995). 80. D. Gabor: Nature 161, 777 (1948). 81. P.J. vanHeerden: Appl. Opt. 2, 387–392 (1963). 82. R.J. Collier, K.S. Pennington: Appl. Phys. Lett. 8, 44–46 (1966). 83. E.G. Paek, E.C. Jung: Opt. Lett. 16, 1034–1036 (1991). 84. G.R. Knight: Appl. Opt. 13, 904–912 (1974). 85. Y. Owechko: IEEE J. Quantum Electr. 25, 619–634 (1989). 86. Y. Owechko: Appl. Opt. 26, 5104–5111 (1987). 87. R.A. Athale, H.H. Szu, C.B. Friedlander: Opt. Lett. 11, 482–484 (1986). 88. D.Z. Anderson: Opt. Lett. 11, 56–58 (1986). 89. D.Z. Anderson, M.C. Erie: Opt. Engin. 26, 434–444 (1987). 90. M. Saffman, C. Benkert, D.Z. Anderson: Opt. Lett. 16, 1993–1995 (1991). 91. G. Montemezzani, G. Zhou, D.Z. Anderson: Opt. Lett. 19, 2012–2014 (1994). 92. K. Curtis, D. Psaltis: Appl. Opt. 33, 5396–5399 (1994).
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
132
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter
93. H.S. Rhee, H.J. Caulfield, C.S. Vikram, J. Shamir: Appl. Opt. 34, 846–853 (1995). 94. B. Kohler, S. Bernet, A. Renn, U.P. Wild: Opt. Lett. 18, 2144–2146 (1993). 95. A. Ashkin, G.D. Boyd, J.M. Dziedzic, R.G. Smith, A.A. Ballman, J.J. Levinstein, K. Nassau: Appl. Phys. Lett. 25, 233 (1966). 96. R.L. Townsend, J.T. LaMacchia: J. Appl. Phys. 41, 5188 (1970). 97. M. Peltier, F. Micheron: J. Appl. Phys. 48, 3683 (1977). 98. A.M. Glass, A.M. Johnson, D.H. Olson, W. Simpson, A.A. Ballmann: Appl. Phys. Lett. 44, 948 (1984). 99. K. Sutter, J. Hulliger, P. G¨unter: Solid State. Commun. 74, 867–870 (1990). 100. K. Sutter, J. Hulliger, R. Schlesser, P. G¨unter: Opt. Lett. 18, 778–780 (1993). 101. S. Follonier, C. Bosshard, F. Pan, P. G¨unter: Opt. Lett. 21, 1655 (1996). 102. W.J. Burke, P. Sheng: J. Appl. Phys. 48, 681–685 (1977). 103. E.S. Maniloff, K.M. Johnson: J. Appl. Phys. 70, 4702–4707 (1991). 104. D. Psaltis, D. Brady, K. Wagner: Appl. Opt. 27, 1752–1759 (1988). 105. F. Mok, M. Tackitt, H.M. Stoll: OSA Technical Digest Series 18, 76 (1989). 106. Y. Taketomi, J.E. Ford, H. Sasaki, J. Ma, Y. Fainman, S.H. Lee: Opt. Lett. 16, 1774– 1776 (1991). 107. E.S. Maniloff, K.M. Johnson: Opt. Lett. 17, 961 (1992). 108. Y. Taketomi, J.E. Ford, H. Sasaki, J. Ma, Y. Fainman, S.H. Lee: Opt. Lett. 17, 962 (1992). 109. S. Campbell, Z. Yuheng, Y. Pochi: Opt. Commun. 123, 27–33 (1996). 110. S. Piazzolla, B.K. Jenkins, J.A.R. Tanguay: Opt. Lett. 17, 676–678 (1992). 111. V.A. Vanin: Sov. J. Quantum Electron. 8, 809 (1978). 112. J.H. Hong, P. Yeh, D. Psaltis, D. Brady: Opt. Lett. 15, 344–346 (1990). 113. C. Gu, J. Hong: Opt. Commun. 93, 213–218 (1992). 114. P. Aing, C. Alves, G. Pauliat, G. Roosen: J. Phys. III France 4, 2427–2440 (1994). 115. M.A. Neifield, M. McDonald: Opt. Lett. 19, 1483–1485 (1994). 116. J.F. Heanue, M.C. Bashaw, L. Hesselink: Science 265, 749–752 (1994). 117. I. McMichael, W. Christian, D. Pletcher, T.Y. Chang, J.H. Hong: Appl. Opt. 35, 2375–2379 (1996). 118. L. Hesselink, S.G. Orlov, A. Akella, D. Lande, A. Liu: Proc. Waseda International Symposium on Phase Conjugation & Wave Mixing, Tokyo, Japan (1997), pp. 36–39. 119. R.M. Shelby, J.A. Hoffnagle, G.W. Burr, C.M. Jefferson, M. Bernal, H. Coufal, R.K. Grygier, H. G¨unther, R. M. Macfarlane, G. T. Sincerbox: Opt. Lett. 22, 1509–1511 (1997). 120. J.F. Heanue, M.C. Bashaw, A.J. Daiber, R. Snyder, L. Hesselink: Opt. Lett. 21, 1615– 1617 (1996). 121. D. Lande, S.S. Orlov, A. Akella, L. Hesselink, R.R. Neurgaonkar: Opt. Lett. 22, 1722–1724 (1997). 122. M. Carrascosa, F. Agull´o-L´opez: J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 7, 2317–2322 (1990). 123. L. Arizmendi, P.D. Townsend, M. Carrascosa, J. Baquedano, J.M. Cabrera: J. Phys.: Condensed Matter 3, 5399–5406 (1991). 124. V.V. Kulikov, S. I. Stepanov: Sov. Phys. Solid State 21, 1849–1851 (1979). 125. D.L. Staebler, W.J. Burke, W. Phillips, J.J. Amodei: Appl. Phys. Lett. 26, 182–184 (1975). 126. P. Hertel, K.H. Ringhofer, R. Sommerfeldt: Phys. Stat. Sol. (a) 104, 855–862 (1987). 127. L. Arizmendi: J. Appl. Phys. 65, 423–427 (1989). 128. G. Montemezzani, P. G¨unter: J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 7, 2323–2328 (1990). 129. G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, P. G¨unter: J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 10, 171–185 (1993).
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
16:55
4. Photorefractive Memories for Optical Processing 130. 131. 132. 133. 134. 135. 136. 137. 138. 139. 140. 141. 142. 143. 144. 145. 146. 147. 148. 149. 150. 151. 152.
153. 154. 155. 156. 157. 158. 159. 160. 161. 162. 163. 164. 165. 166.
133
X.L. Tong, M. Zhang, A. Yariv, A. Agranat: Appl. Phys. Lett. 69, 3966–3968 (1996). D. Kirillov, J. Feinberg: Opt. Lett. 16, 1520 (1991). F. Micheron, G. Bismuth: Appl. Phys. Lett. 20, 79–81 (1972). R.S. Cudney, J. Fousek, M. Zgonik, P. G¨unter, M.H. Garrett, D. Rytz: Appl. Phys. Lett. 63, 3399–3401 (1993). R.S. Cudney, J. Fousek, M. Zgonik, P. G¨unter, M.H. Garrett, D. Rytz: Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 3883–3886 (1994). F. Micheron, G. Bismuth: Appl. Phys. Lett. 23, 71–73 (1973). Y. Qiao, S. Orlov, D. Psaltis, R.R. Neurgaonkar: Opt. Lett. 18, 1004–1006 (1993). R.S. Cudney, P. Bernasconi, M. Zgonik, J. Fousek, P. Gunter: Appl. Phys. Lett. 70, 1339–1341 (1997). D. Psaltis, F. Mok, H.S. Li: Opt. Lett. 19, 210–212 (1994). K. Buse, F. Jermann, E. Kratzig: Appl. Phys. A 58, 191–195 (1994). K. Buse, F. Jermann, E. Kratzig: Opt. Mat. 4, 237–240 (1995). Y.S. Bai, R.R. Neurgaonkar, R. Kachru: Opt. Lett. 21, 567–569 (1996). Y.S. Bai, R. Kachru: Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 2944–2947 (1997). S.G. Orlov, A. Akella, L. Hesselink, R.R. Neurgoankar: Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics (CLEO 97), Baltimore (1997), Postdeadline paper CPD29 1-3. Y. Furukawa, K. Kitamura, Y. Ji, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, C. Medrano, P. Gunter: Opt. Lett. 22, 501–503 (1997). D. Brady, K. Hsu, D. Psaltis: Opt. Lett. 15, 817–819 (1990). H. Sasaki, Y. Fainman, J.E. Ford, Y. Taketomi, S.H. Lee: Opt. Lett. 16, 1874–1876 (1991). S. Boj, G. Pauliat, G. Roosen: Opt. Lett. 17, 438–440 (1992). J.J.P. Drolet, E. Chuang, G. Barbastathis, D. Psaltis: Opt. Lett. 22, 552–554 (1997). J.P. Huignard, J.P. Herriau, F. Micheron: Appl. Phys. Lett. 26, 256–258 (1975). H. Sasaki, J. Ma, Y. Fainman, S.H. Lee, Y. Taketomi: Opt. Lett. 17, 1468–1470 (1992). J.V. Alvarez Bravo, L. Arizmendi: Opt. Mat. 4, 419–422 (1995). N. Peyghambarian, K. Meerholz, B.L. Volodin, Sandalphon, B. Kippelen: Proc. Photoactive Organic Materials: Science and Applications (ISBN 0 7923 3973 8), Avignon, France, 25–30 June 1995, (1996). pp. 281–292. R.C.D. Young, C.R. Chatwin: Opt. Engin. 36, 2754–2774 (1997). Z.Q. Wen, X.Y. Yang: Opt. Commun. 135, 212–216 (1997). R. Tripathi, J. Joseph, K. Singh: Opt. Commun. 143, 5–10 (1997). J. Rodolfo, H. Rajbenbach, J.P. Huignard: Opt. Engin. 34, 1166–1171 (1995). H. Rajbenbach, C. Touret, J.P. Huignard, M. Curon, C. Bricot: Proc. SPIE 2752, 214–223 (1996). H. Rajbenbach: Proc. SPIE 2237, 329–346 (1994). G.S. Pati, A. Roy, K. Singh: Opt. Commun. 129, 81–8 (1996). D.T.H. Liu, L. Cheng: Appl. Opt. 31, 5675–5680 (1992). G. Asimellis, M. Cronin Golomb, J. Khoury, J. Kane, C. Woods: Appl. Opt. 34, 8154–8166 (1995). G. Asimellis, J. Khoury, C.L. Woods: Opt. Engin. 36, 2392–2399 (1997). M.D. Lasprilla, S. Granieri, N. Bolognini: Optik 105, 61–64 (1997). M. Duelli, A.R. Pourzand, N. Collings, R. Dandliker: Opt. Lett. 22, 87–89 (1997). B.L. Volodin, B. Kippelen, K. Meerholz, B. Javidi, N. Peyghambarian: Nature 383, 58–60 (1996). C. Alves, G. Pauliat, G. Roosen: Opt. Mat. 4, 423–427 (1995).
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
134
16:55
M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, M. Zgonik, and P. G¨unter
167. D.D. Nolte, D.H. Olson, G.E. Doran, W.H. Knox, A.M. Glass: J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 7, 2217–2225 (1990). 168. A. Partovi, A.M. Glass, D.H. Olson, G.J. Zydzik, K.T. Short, R.D. Feldmann, R.F. Austin: Opt. Lett. 17, 655–657 (1992). 169. B.H. Soffer, G.J. Dunning, Y. Owechko, E. Marom: Opt. Lett. 11, 118–120 (1986). 170. G.J. Dunning, E. Marom, Y. Owechko, B.H. Soffer: Opt. Lett. 12, 346–348 (1987). 171. E.G. Paek, D. Psaltis: Opt. Engin. 26, 428–423 (1987). 172. H.J. White, N.B. Aldrige, I. Lindsay: Opt. Engin. 27, 30–37 (1988). 173. L. Wang, V. Esch, R. Feinleib, L. Zhang, R. Jin, H.M. Chou, R.W. Sprague, H.A. Macleod, G. Khitrova, H.M. Gibbs, K. Wagner, D. Psaltis: Appl. Opt. 27, 1715–1720 (1988). 174. A. Yariv, S. Kwong, K. Kyuma: Appl. Phys. Lett. 48, 1114–1116 (1986). 175. H. Xu, Y. Yuan, Y. Yu, K. Xu, Y. Xu: Appl. Opt. 29, 3375–3379 (1990). 176. H. Xu, Y. Yuan, J. Zhang, K. Xu: Opt. Commun. 92, 326–336 (1992). 177. G. Lu, M. Lu, F.T.S. Yu: Appl. Opt. 34, 5109–5117 (1995). 178. H. Kang, C. Yang, G. Mu, Z. Wu: Opt. Lett. 15, 637–639 (1990). 179. Y. Tanaka, Z. Chen, T. Kasamatsu, T. Shiosaki: Jap. J. Appl. Phys. 30, 2359–2362 (1991). 180. Z. Chen, T. Kasamatsu, T. Shiosaki: Jap. J. Appl. Phys. 31, 3178–3181 (1992). 181. M. Ingold, M. Duelli, P. G¨unter: J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 9, 1327–1337 (1992). 182. M. Duelli, R.S. Cudney, P. G¨unter: Opt. Engin. 34, 2044–2048 (1995). 183. M. Duelli, G. Montemezzani, C. Keller, F. Lehr, P. G¨unter: JEOS Pure Appl. Opt. 3, 215–220 (1994). 184. M. Duelli, R.S. Cudney, P. Gunter: Opt. Commun. 123, 49–54 (1996).
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
16:49
5 True-Time-Delay Adaptive Array Processing Using Photorefractive Crystals G.R. Kriehn1 and K. Wagner2 1
2
California State University, Fresno, Electrical and Computer Engineering Department, 2320 E. San Ramon Ave. M/S EE94, Fresno, CA 93711-8030
[email protected] University of Colorado, Boulder, Optoelectronic Computing Systems Center, Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Boulder, CO 80309-0425
[email protected]
5.1 Introduction to True-Time-Delay Array Processing Radio frequency (RF) signal processing has proven to be a fertile application area when using photorefractive-based, optical processing techniques. This is due to a photorefractive material’s capability to record gratings and diffract off these gratings with optically modulated beams that contain a wide RF bandwidth, and include applications such as the bias-free time-integrating correlator [1], adaptive signal processing, and jammer excision, [2, 3, 4]. Photorefractive processing of signals from RF antenna arrays is especially appropriate because of the massive parallelism that is readily achievable in a photorefractive crystal (in which many resolvable beams can be incident on a single crystal simultaneously—each coming from an optical modulator driven by a separate RF antenna element), and because a number of approaches for adaptive array processing using photorefractive crystals have been successfully investigated [5, 6]. In these types of applications, the adaptive weight coefficients are represented by the amplitude and phase of the holographic gratings, and many millions of such adaptive weights can be multiplexed within the volume of a photorefractive crystal. RF modulated optical signals from each array element are diffracted from the adaptively recorded photorefractive gratings (which can be multiplexed either angularly or spatially), and are then coherently combined with the appropriate amplitude weights and phase shifts to effectively steer the angular receptivity pattern of the antenna array toward the desired arriving signal. Likewise, the antenna nulls can also be rotated toward unwanted narrowband jammers for extinction, thereby optimizing the signal-to-interference-plus-noise ratio.
135
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
136
16:49
G.R. Kriehn and K. Wagner
5.1.1 Narrowband Processing and Limitations Beam steering and jammer nulling can be performed on RF signals from onedimensional (1-D) or two-dimensional (2-D) antenna arrays—which can either be regularly sampled on a uniform grid of antenna element positions, or sparsely or irregularly/randomly sampled in space. For simplicity, we will limit the discussion to a linear, 1-D, equi-spaced antenna array (although the optical BEAMTAP system presented here works equally well for 2-D and even irregularly-spaced arrays). In such a 1-D array, an RF signal at frequency ω arriving from a far-field source becomes a plane wave propagating at an angle θ with respect to the array axis, resulting in RF signals, sn (t) = ei(ωt+φn ) , from the nth antenna element with a phase shift φn = n D(ω/c) cos θ , where D is the element spacing and c is the speed of light. To coherently combine these RF signals, each signal must be multiplied by a conjugate phase factor and summed, which provides a beam-steered output s(t) = n w n sn (t)—where the complex weights w n = e−iφn |an | may include an additional amplitude taper |an | that can be used to lower the sidelobe level compared to a simple sinc function in the case of a uniformly weighted array. Optically, photorefractive crystals can be used to implement the weighted multiplications by recording appropriate gratings that have the desired strengths and phase shifts. Subsequent diffraction of the single-sideband, optically-modulated signals coming from each antenna element off these gratings and combining the resulting beams with a lens onto a photodetector performs the coherent summation via heterodyne detection with a strong reference beam. The detected output thus produces a current proportional to the desired beam-steered signal. Unfortunately, as the RF bandwidth B of an antenna array, the antenna diameter (N D for an N element 1-D equi-spaced linear array), and the maximum detectable angle from boresight θmax all increase, the propagation delay time across the aperture T = N D cos θmax /c eventually becomes resolvable within the system bandwidth (i.e., when T B > 1). As a result, narrowband techniques are no longer adequate (as is the case when using the simple phased-array beam steering process described above), because these narrowband phased-array beam steering approaches produce unwanted beam squint. This is an undesired rotation of the main beam receptivity angle as a function of frequency, which decreases the signal strength and bandwidth of the final output. In addition, narrowband processing also results in null squint (which is the deleterious rotation of adaptively formed antenna nulls that are pointed toward jammers), so that when the jammers hop to new frequencies, they are no longer nulled, and these interfering signals leak through into the system output.
5.1.2 Wide Fractional Bandwidth Processing To solve this problem, wideband true-time-delay beam-steering techniques become necessary, in which the phases φn = n D(ω/c) cos θ are recognized as being linearly dependent upon the frequency, but are compensated for over a specific bandwidth. This allows for the diffraction of a coherently modulated optical field
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
16:49
5. True-Time-Delay Adaptive Array Processing Using Photorefractive Crystals
137
off of a phase-shifted photorefractive grating to remain independent of the RF offset frequency for frequencies as large as the inverse optical transit time through the photorefractive crystal (30 GHz for a 5 mm thick crystal of index 2.0), rather than the much smaller frequency offset in which the phase will change in a resolvable manner due to the inverse RF transit time across the array (10 MHz for a 30 m diameter array). In conventional array processors, tapped-delay lines are used to provide delayed signal histories of every antenna element—but unfortunately, the optical implementation of N wideband tapped-delay lines is problematic for N > 32 when using multi-channel acousto-optic devices [7, 8], or for N > 100 when using ultra-wideband hyperfine optical delay-line technology [9]. Therefore, scaling these optical implementations using traditional time-delay-and-sum architectures [10] for very large antenna arrays using hundreds (or even many thousands) of elements becomes impractical, and the full potential for massive parallelism using photorefractive array processors appears to then be limited. We have, however, solved this problem with the introduction of the optical BEAMTAP (Broadband Efficient Adaptive Method for True-time-delay Array Processing) algorithm [11], in which the linear operation of time delay of the antenna element signals is commuted with the complex weight multiplication. After multiplication, all of the equivalent delays are then combined, resulting in a new sum-and-time-delay algorithm. Although this equivalent algorithm provides no fundamental advantage for digital implementations, it enables the use of a photorefractive crystal (which has little internal time delay), for processing RF signals from large wideband antennas by volume multiplexing the adaptive weights as required by BEAMTAP. The volume multiplexing capability of a photorefractive crystal for up to a billion independently resolvable gratings is sufficient to accommodate an antenna array with up to a million elements using as many time delays as necessary (which, in this case, is roughly a thousand for octave bandwidths).
5.1.3 Chapter Outline Previously, we have developed photorefractive, signal-processing architectures that use an electronic feedback closed-loop adaptive process to record the photorefractive grating with the required amplitude and phase in order to optimally beam steer and jammer null the signals from the array, even if the fiber feed network has unwanted phase errors or arbitrary topology mappings from the antennas to the optical processor [6]. In this chapter, we describe the improved wideband results of an experimental photorefractive implementation using the BEAMTAP algorithm. We first provide a brief overview of the algorithm in addition to a review of the key device required for sum-and-time-delay based processing—an accumulating traveling photodetector known as the traveling-fringes detector—developed by Dolfi et al. at Thales [12, 13]. Next, we describe our technique for simultaneous reading and writing of photorefractive gratings for wideband RF modulated beams from an array of modulators that cover a wide angular bandwidth at the input and output using the parallel-tangents, equal-curvature condition [14, 15]. Finally, we combine these technologies into an operating BEAMTAP system that
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
138
16:49
G.R. Kriehn and K. Wagner
uses an emulated input from an antenna array based on a traveling-wave, acoustooptic device. Results of simultaneous main beam forming and wideband jammer nulling are presented for the first time.
5.2 Output Time Delay and the BEAMTAP Algorithm The conventional broadband time-delay-and-sum approach to adaptive beam forming and jammer nulling requires that a true-time-delay, tapped-delay line be used for every element in a phased-array antenna. Unfortunately, this approach is both inefficient and difficult to implement optically, since a complex spatio-temporal, optical time-delay module (such as an acousto-optic deflector) is required for every element in the array. A solution to this problem can be found if, instead of choosing to delay the signals after they are first detected at the antenna array, the signals are alternatively delayed at the output. This has the tremendous advantage of only requiring a single tapped-delay line for a formed beam, irrespective of the antenna array size. The weight matrix can then be thought of as a structure analogous to a switching matrix, which is used to route signals from each antenna element to an appropriate delay and allows the signals to be time aligned for coherent summation at the output. The number of resolvable delays required to coherently sum these signals will be proportional to the size of the antenna array, but only a single delay line will be required. An example of this is shown in Fig. 5.1. A chirped signal that is incident upon the antenna array is detected at each antenna element, whereby the detected signals are routed through the switching matrix and relayed to their respective time delays for coherent summation. Since the spatio-temporal RF chirp arrives at the top antenna element first, the greatest amount of time delay must be applied to this particular signal before it can be coherently summed with the signals arriving at other antenna elements later in time. Each successive signal arriving at lower antenna elements requires less delay, and since the RF signal arrives at the bottom antenna element last, no time delay is required at this particular element. After leaving the tapped-delay line, the signals are time aligned for coherent summation at the final output. Adaptive beam forming can be integrated into this type of architecture by providing a method by which the switching matrix can be programmed to route the signals to their respective time delays. To accomplish this, a second tapped-delay line is required, giving rise to BEAMTAP. Figure 5.2 illustrates the architecture for the optical implementation of BEAMTAP. As seen in the figure, a single coherent laser is split using two beamsplitters to drive both a fiber feed network and the BEAMTAP processor. The fiber feed network from the phased-array antenna is shown on the left, in which an RF signal impinging upon the array is detected at each antenna element and used to drive an array of electro-optic modulators (EOMs). The modulated light from the EOMs, which contains the RF signal information from each of the antenna elements, is
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
16:49
5. True-Time-Delay Adaptive Array Processing Using Photorefractive Crystals
139
F I G U R E 5.1. Using output time delay, only a single accumulating tapped-delay line is required to coherently sum the signals from an antenna array irrespective of the array size. The signals from each of the antenna elements are routed through a switching matrix that relay the signals to their respective time delays so that they can be coherently summed at the output. By applying a feedback signal that contains a desired steering signal to a second input delay line, the appropriate switches can be chosen for the beam forming operation.
then remotely fed via fiber to the BEAMTAP processor and is imaged at the plane z 0 into a photorefractive crystal by the lens system L 0 . Within the processor, the diffracted light from an acousto-optic deflector (AOD) located at the plane x0 interferes with the remotely fed fiber signals sn (t) from the array and forms holographic gratings within the photorefractive crystal (PRC). Diffraction of the phased-array signals off this grating is then detected with a special accumulating, scrolling detector known as the traveling-fringes detector (TFD), which has a carrier velocity matched to the magnified acoustic velocity of the AOD by the lens systems L 1 and L 2 —producing a resonant charge carrier distribution q(x2 , t). The TFD heterodyne detects, delays, and coherently sums the signals from each of the individual antenna elements to form an output signal o(t). The output signal o(t) is then amplified, filtered, and subtracted from a desired signal d(t) to form a feedback signal f (t), which is capable of updating
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
140
16:49
G.R. Kriehn and K. Wagner
F I G U R E 5.2. Optical implementation of BEAMTAP. The main components include electro-optic modulators (EOMs) and the fiber feed network, an acousto-optic deflector (AOD), a photorefractive crystal (PRC), and the traveling-fringes detector (TFD).
the holographic weight matrix formed within the photorefractive crystal to ensure both adaptive beam forming and jammer nulling. In this system, the TFD implements the tapped-delay line used for coherently summing the signals from each of the antenna elements; the PRC acts to spatially route holographically diffracted signals from the phased-array antenna to their appropriate delays on the TFD for coherent summation (which is analogous to the switching matrix); and the AOD serves as the second tapped-delay line necessary for weight adaptation of the holographic gratings. The final output o(t) is given by a correlation-convolution integral, T D /2
o(t) = R κ2 −TD /2
N
sn (t − tn + τx − tr2 )
n=1
t−T g2 sn∗ (t2 − tn + τx − tr2 ) [d(t2 + (T − td )) − g1 o(t2 )] dt1 dτx , × −∞
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
16:49
5. True-Time-Delay Adaptive Array Processing Using Photorefractive Crystals
141
in which the feedback signal [d(t2 + (T − td )) − g1 o(t2 )] correlates against fixed, delayed versions of the signals from the antenna elements sn∗ (t2 − tn + τx − tr2 ) to form the holographic weight matrix within the photorefractive crystal—which is then convolved with the delayed signals from the antenna sn (t − tn + τx − tr2 ), and coherently summed across the N elements by the time aperture TD of the TFD. Although complex, the process is equivalent to the time-domain least-meansquare (LMS) beam former, [16, 17] where the output is given by t sn (t − mτ ) sn∗ (t2 − mτ ) [d(t2 ) − o(t2 )] dt2 , (5.1) o(t) = m
n
−∞
which performs the necessary correlation-convolution integral to maximize the signal-to-interference plus noise ratio (SINR). In the case of optical BEAMTAP system, the summation over the M delays within the tapped-delay line is replaced with a continuous accumulation over the time aperture TD of the TFD. The remaining time delays (such as tn , τx , tr 2 , etc.) are simply a consequence of maintaining causality within the system, and are explained in detail in the theoretical development of the BEAMTAP architecture [11]. A critical issue with this system is the need for a high degree of isolation between the reading and writing beams within the photorefractive crystal, while simultaneously maintaining Bragg-matched diffracted readout over a wide angular aperture, since signals arriving at the antenna array may span a large angular spectrum. A high degree of isolation is required because any leakage of the writing beam from the feedback AOD into the output will limit the amount of feedback gain—and therefore the jammer null depth—available to the processor before the system breaks into oscillation [6]. Therefore, it becomes necessary to find an experimental geometry in the photorefractive crystal that satisfies both of these requirements. This can be accomplished with polarization-angle, read-write multiplexing in barium titanate (BaTiO3 ) using the parallel-tangents, equal-curvature condition [14, 15]. After examining the TFD in more detail, discussion of this geometry within BaTiO3 (as it relates to the experimental implementation of BEAMTAP), forms the basis for the rest of the chapter.
5.3 The Traveling-Fringes Detector The traveling-fringes detector (TFD) used in the photonic implementation of the BEAMTAP processor consists of a photo-conducting layer of gallium arsenide (GaAs) that exploits a resonantly-enhanced amplitude of the traveling-wave photo-carrier grating for efficient broadband detection of optically-modulated, high-frequency RF signals as moving interference patterns, and is a key enabling technology for BEAMTAP. Dolfi originally developed this device due to its large conversion efficiency at high (microwave) frequencies and a high optical saturation level owing to its large detection volume [13]. Adapting the TFD to BEAMTAP, the device provides the necessary opto-electronic conversion for
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
142
16:49
G.R. Kriehn and K. Wagner
broadband detection, as well as providing the opto-electronic architecture with the necessary physical time delay required for true-time-delay processing. This section briefly reviews the TFD originally designed for narrow fractional bandwidth detection at a high microwave carrier frequency (1–20 GHz), and shows how to use the TFD in combination with a traveling-wave acousto-optic deflector in the BEAMTAP system for wide fractional bandwidth detection. The TFD uses a photoconductive layer of GaAs to detect RF signals based upon the synchronous drift of photo-generated carriers with a moving interference pattern [12]. Interfering two beams of coherent light tilted by an angle θ with a difference frequency f d , yields a fringe velocity v f = f d λ/ sin(θ ). For broadband operation, in order to keep the fringe velocity constant—even at varying frequencies—the angle of the incident light needs to be scanned in proportion to its frequency, which is exactly the case for light diffracted from a traveling-wave deflector such as an acousto-optic device, as shown schematically in Fig. 5.3. The light that is incident on the photoconductive layer of the detector produces photogenerated charge carriers with a drift velocity v(n, p) = μ(n, p) E a , where μ(n, p) is the mobility of the charge carrier being resonated (μn for electrons and μ p for holes) and E a is the applied field. By varying the applied field transversely across
Z AcoustoOptic Device
Traveling Fringes Detector
Moving Fringes
p(x, t)
X Accumulating Resonant Hole Distribution
RF Input
f
920
L
1
Modulated Signal
L
2
Mixer
Ouput
C
Carrier LNA
f
MHz
920
Signal BW f
250
250
L
920 MHz
R = 50 Ω L
+ V _
MHz
F I G U R E 5.3. Detection of a broadband RF signal using an acousto-optic device imaged onto a velocity matched traveling fringes detector. Traveling fringes produced by the interference of a diffracted beam from the AOD with the DC beam are resonated with the carrier drift velocity by varying the field applied transversely across the photoconductive region of the detector and the magnification.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
16:49
5. True-Time-Delay Adaptive Array Processing Using Photorefractive Crystals
143
the layer, a resonance peak occurs using an electron resonance when the fringe velocity v f equals vn [13]. The accumulation and detection of the intensity pattern in the TFD can be modeled as a drifting diffusion equation in a semiconductor for the motion of photogenerated carriers under the influence of an applied electric field [13, 18], such that o(t) = R
0 −TD v f
t
−∞
I (x, t )
1 4π Dn (t −
t )
e
−
[x−vd (t−t )]2 4Dn (t−t )
− (t−t τ
)
dt d x.
(5.2)
Here the length L = TD vd , R is the detector responsivity (A/W), TD is the time window over which the interference pattern is accumulated by the detector, Dn = kB T μn is the diffusion constant of the electrons, and τ is the carrier lifetime. q Integration of Eq. 5.2 yields an exponentially decaying spatial sensitivity away from the electrode, given by exp(−x/τ vd ), that can be partially compensated for by shifting the illuminating Gaussian spot away from the collecting electrode; and a position-dependent, bandwidth-limiting, transfer function due to carrier 2 3 diffusion, √ T (ω, x q ) = exp(−x Dn ω /vd ). This leads to a 3 dB roll-off at 2π f c ≈ vd log2/ Dn τ . For 1:1 imaging of an acousto-optic deflector with a velocity 4.2 mm/μs onto a GaAs traveling-fringes detector with μn = 8500 cm2 /Vs and a lifetime τ = 10 ns, this yields a 3.2 GHz corner frequency, which is as wide as high frequency AODs can achieve. The frequency limit of the broadband TFD can be further increased through the use of lower mobility holes (to 20 GHz), or by magnifying the acousto-optic deflector onto the TFD and increasing the applied voltage correspondingly (thereby increasing v f = Mva and thus f c ). When the TFD is operating in this regime, diffusion is negligible over the detection aperture and will not limit the system bandwidth as the charges drift across the sensitive photoconductive region of the device. The output can be approximated as an ideal accumulating traveling-wave delay line.
5.4 Photorefractive Volume Holography using Polarization-Angle, Read-Write Multiplexing Photorefractive crystals are useful for spatial-temporal information processing of coherent optically-modulated signals due to the real-time, read-write capabilities of the holographic medium. However, when used to write volumetric holographic gratings for real-time applications, it is necessary to isolate the recording, or writing beams, from the diffracted read-out beam. This isolation is an extremely important factor in adaptive feedback systems because it determines the amount of feedback gain, and therefore the jammer null depth, of the overall processor [19]. This section is therefore devoted to exploring the usefulness of read-write multiplexing for the BEAMTAP system, and demonstrates an important holographic application using photorefractive crystals.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
144
16:49
G.R. Kriehn and K. Wagner
5.4.1 Parallel-Tangents, Equal-Curvature Condition The parallel-tangents, equal-curvature condition [14, 15] is an effective geometry that has been previously used to achieve a high degree of read-write isolation while simultaneously maximizing the Bragg-matched angular aperture between the orthogonally polarized writing and reading beams. The process involves matching the tangents and curvatures of the ordinary and extraordinary momentum surfaces, as shown in Fig. 5.4. The geometry is such that the grating vector K g written between two ordinary beams kw1 and kw2 at angles θw1 and θw2 , respectively, will be Bragg matched to the extraordinary polarized reading beam when read out with a k-vector kr at an angle θr . In this configuration, the ordinary writing beams do not couple due to the small effective electro-optic coefficient r22 , while the readout beam accesses the large coefficient r42 in barium titanate (BaTiO3 ) or r33 in strontium barium niobate (SBN), producing an efficiently diffracted output. The diffracted output angle θeq , with k-vector keq , is chosen so that both the tangents and the curvatures of the ordinary and extraordinary surfaces are matched at θw2 and θeq . For small deviations away from this exact geometry, the Bragg matching condition is satisfied to first and second order so that if one of the writing beams contains a large angular spectrum and multiple grating vectors K g are recorded within the material, the entire angular spectrum can still be Bragg matched and read out using the reading beam kr .
F I G U R E 5.4. Geometry which describes the parallel-tangents, equal-curvature condition. Two ordinary polarized beams, kw1 and kw2 with angles θw1 and θw2 , respectively, write a grating K g in the photorefractive crystal. The grating is read out by an extraordinary polarized beam kr at an angle θr , producing a diffracted beam keq at an angle θeq . Both the writing beam kw2 and the diffracted beam keq can subtend a large angular bandwidth while still maintaining excellent Bragg matching.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
16:49
5. True-Time-Delay Adaptive Array Processing Using Photorefractive Crystals
145
5.4.2 Parallel-Tangents, Equal-Curvature Condition in BaTiO3 Solving for the parallel-tangents, equal-curvature condition in BaTiO3 to determine an experimental setup for polarization-angle, read-write multiplexing in BEAMTAP requires that the equal-curvature condition be derived in a region that simultaneously satisfies the parallel-tangents condition at an angle θeq from the c-axis of the crystal. In the x z plane, the ordinary and extraordinary surfaces map out a circle and ellipse, respectively, where 2 k z2 2π k x2 + 2 = (5.3) 2 no no λ 2 k z2 2π kx2 + 2 = . (5.4) 2 ne no λ Converting to polar coordinates, k x = k sin(θ ) and k z = k cos(θ ), which allows for the tangents of the two surfaces to be solved for as a function of θw2 and θeq —the angles of the second ordinary write beam and the extraordinary read beam, respectively: dkz = −tan(θw2 ) (5.5) dk x or d 2 dkz no =− tan(θeq ), (5.6) dk x ext ne where setting the two equations equal to each other sets the tangents of the two surfaces equal to each other as well [20]. The extraordinary angle θeq is provided here as a function of the ordinary angle θw2 (both of which are internal to the crystal), giving ne 2 −1 tan(θw2 ) . (5.7) θeq = tan no Next, to obtain the second-order phase matching condition, a specific set of ordinary and extraordinary angles satisfying the parallel-tangents condition is chosen so that the diffracted read-out beam is at an angle where the ordinary and extraordinary momentum surfaces have equal curvatures in the x z plane. For a function y = f (x) in the Cartesian coordinate system, the curvature ρ is defined as the rate of change of the slope of the tangent of f (x) with respect to the arc length, where
f (x)
ρ= . (5.8) {1 + [ f (x)]2 }3/2 The curvatures of the ordinary and extraordinary surfaces are thus given by [14] 1 (5.9) ρ(θ)or d = ko (n o /n e )2 ρ(θ )ext = (5.10)
3/2 , ko 1 + [n e (θ)sinθ ]2 n 2o − n 2e /n 4e
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
146
16:49
G.R. Kriehn and K. Wagner
where the extraordinary index of refraction is a function of the angle θ and is equal to −1/2 cos2 θ sin2 θ n e (θ) = + 2 . (5.11) n 2o ne Substituting, Eq. 5.11 into the curvature of the extraordinary momentum surface equation in Eq. 5.10, and setting it equal to the curvature of the ordinary momentum surface equation in Eq. 5.9, defines the equal-curvature angle [14], with the elegant although non-intuitive solution cos(2θeq ) =
10/3
− no ne − ne
10/3
+ no ne + ne
no no
2/3 8/3
10/3
2/3 8/3
10/3
.
(5.12)
Finally, when the equal-curvature angle is defined, it can be substituted into the parallel-tangents equation to determine the angle on the ordinary momentum surface that simultaneously satisfies both the parallel-tangents and the equalcurvature condition. Figure 5.5 shows the method by which the four angles defining this geometry are calculated. The ordinary k-circle is first translated at the point kw2 by a vector
R to the parallel-tangents, equal-curvature angle (given by Eq. 5.12) at the point keq , so that the two surfaces are brought into coincidence. Then, a second c-axis Translated Ordinary Momentum Surface
^z
θ eq θ w2 θr θ w1
Parallel ko Tangents ΔR
k e (θ) k eq
k w2
Kg
Kg
kr
ΔR
k w1
^x
Intersection Ordinary Momentum Surface
Extraordinary Momentum Surface
F I G U R E 5.5. Geometric construction by which the angles of the 4 beams are found using the parallel-tangents, equal-curvature condition. The ordinary k-circle is translated by
R to the parallel-tangents, equal-curvature angle on the ellipse, and a second intersection between the translated circle and ellipse determines the angle of the extraordinary read beam θr . Translating from the read beam and parallel-tangents, equal-curvature angle by − R determines the two writing beam angles, θw1 and θw2 , respectively.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
16:49
5. True-Time-Delay Adaptive Array Processing Using Photorefractive Crystals
147
intersection between the circle and ellipse is sought, which determines the angle of the extraordinary-polarized read beam θr . However, the exact parallel-tangents, equal-curvature condition presented by Sarto [14] must be modified, since there is only one additional intersection point for negative uniaxial crystals such as BaTiO3 , which occurs at an inconvenient angle greater than 180◦ . Because the 180◦ angle crossing is difficult to work with experimentally, the symmetry of the system can be broken by slightly deviating away from the exact parallel-tangents, equal-curvature condition by a degree or two. With the deviation included, an additional intersection point at an angle close to θeq arises from the re-introduction of a small parabolic second-order momentum mismatch—and this provides the true representation of Fig. 5.5. Finally, once this intersection and the point is found, the ordinary k-circle can be translated back by − R, where kr − R touches the original ordinary momentum surface determines the k-vector (and hence, the angle) of the final write beam, kw1 . For BaTiO3 at an operational wavelength of 532 nm, n o = 2.4746 and n e = 2.4118 [21]. Using Eq. 5.12, the equal-curvature angle is thereby found to be θeq = 53.6877◦ , and using the parallel-tangents equation, the corresponding ordinary momentum surface angle θw2 = 55.0827◦ . With the extraordinary, equal-curvature angle and the ordinary, paralleltangents angles determined by the ordinary and extraordinary indexes of refraction, the translation vector R can be defined so that the ordinary momentum surface at the parallel-tangents angle at kw2 can be translated to the paralleltangents, equal-curvature angle on the extraordinary momentum surface. R is given by
R = ke (θe ) − ko (θw2 ) = [ke (θe ) sinθe − ko sinθw2 ] xˆ + [ke (θe ) cosθe − ko cosθw2 ] zˆ . (5.13) The exact equal-curvature condition is broken here by deviating the angle θw2 by 1◦ increments over a ± 10◦ angular range, with the “equal-curvature” angle, θeq , being re-calculated at every deviation. With the symmetry broken, an additional crossing near θeq is introduced. In the translated coordinate frame, the grating vector is given by K g = [kw2 + R] − [kw1 (θ) + R] = keq − [kw 1 (θ) + R], so the momentum mismatch of the read beam kr as a function of θ can be defined as k = (keq − K g ) − kr (θr ) = [kw1 (θw1 ) + R] − kr (θr ). Figure 5.6 shows the momentum mismatch over angles that are near the parallel-tangents, equalcurvature angle—providing a clearer picture of the exact nature of the mismatch. In Fig. 5.6, only curves with momentum mismatch ≤ ±π/L (where L = 2 mm is the length of the crystal), are shown for angles ≤ θeq (θeq , θeq − 1◦ , . . . , θeq − 5◦ ). Several angles > θeq are certainly within the bounds of a ±π/L momentum mismatch as well, and could have just as easily been chosen, but were not considered for the sake of simplicity. The bounds on the momentum mismatch were chosen to lie within ±π/L so that the Bragg efficiency of an extraordinary plane wave diffracting off a grating
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
148
16:49
G.R. Kriehn and K. Wagner
45o +c Axis θw2 Angular Spread where Δk < π/L Crystal Normal
X
Z
x z
F I G U R E 5.6. Momentum mismatch k and k z surrounding the parallel-tangents, equalcurvature angle. Notice that at the exact parallel-tangents, equal-curvature angle (bold) the angular bandwidth over which the momentum mismatch is approximately zero is maximized. As the exact angle is deviated away from its optimum value, the momentummatched angular bandwidth decreases, but an additional crossing where the momentum mismatch equals zero arises, allowing for a convenient read-write multiplexing geometry.
written between two properly oriented ordinary writing beams would only suffer a 4 dB loss when probing a wide angular spectrum in the second writing beam. Although this restriction is somewhat of an arbitrary constraint for determining an experimental geometry, it allows for the momentum mismatch to remain small, minimizes the loss of Bragg-matched angular bandwidth surrounding the paralleltangents, equal-curvature angles, constrains the additional crossing to remain at a convenient angle to work with experimentally, and provides greater experimental tolerances during alignment. Since Fig. 5.6 shows that there are several optimal read-beam angles that can be chosen to satisfy the ±π/L constraint, there is considerable flexibility in determining the exact experimental geometry, depending upon desired location of the new crossing between the ordinary and extraordinary momentum surfaces (i.e., where k = 0). Figure 5.6 also shows that the momentum mismatch has been projected into the z-coordinate frame of the crystal cut since the beams surrounding the parallel-tangents, equal-curvature condition are traveling approximately 45◦ with respect to the +c axis of the crystal, which in a 45◦ cut piece of BaTiO3 , is in the z direction. Once exiting the crystal, the beams then travel (more or less) in the z direction of the laboratory coordinate frame. The difference between the actual momentum mismatch k (dashed lines), and the momentum mismatch projected along the z-axis (solid lines), remains negligible for the purposes of these calculations. Figure 5.7 shows an example of the theoretical Bragg efficiency as the angle of the second writing beam is deviated away from the chosen parallel-tangents, equalcurvature angle, but still satisfies the 4 dB criteria over a broad angular spectrum— shown here to span between 20◦ –25◦ . For a crystal of length L = 2 mm, the
F I G U R E 5.7. Bragg efficiency vs. angle for the chosen geometry of the experimental read-write multiplexing system. The deviation from the optimum condition is chosen to satisfy a 0.5 dB Bragg efficiency criteria.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006 16:49
149
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
150
16:49
G.R. Kriehn and K. Wagner
Bragg-matching diffraction efficiency is given by ⎡ 2 ⎤
kz L sin( 2 ) ⎦. η = 10 · log10 ⎣
(5.14)
kz L 2
The figure is also representative of the actual geometry chosen for the experimental read-write multiplexing system, where the Bragg efficiency was arbitrarily chosen so that it did not drop more than 0.5 dB below its maximum value surrounding the parallel-tangents, equal-curvature condition. This corresponds to an ordinary momentum-surface angle θw2 = 51.0827◦ [−4◦ from the optimum θw2 (opt)], and defines the extraordinary equal-curvature angle to be θeq = 49.6350◦ . This produces an anticipated theoretical Bragg-matched angular aperture of about 20◦ internal to the crystal and 50◦ external to the crystal. With the chosen geometry, the intersection between the extraordinary and the translated ordinary momentum surface occurs at the extraordinary angle θr = 61.9200◦ , and the final ordinary writing angle θw1 is found by translating the k-vector corresponding to the extraordinary read angle θr back by − R. Specifically, k x (θw1 ) = ke (θr )sinθr − Rx (θ R )
(5.15)
k z (θw1 ) = ke (θr )cosθr − Rz (θ R ),
(5.16)
which forces the final ordinary write-beam angle θw1 to be tanθw1 =
k x (θw1 ) , k z (θw1 )
(5.17)
so that θw1 = 63.1557◦ . Finally, to determine the experimental geometry of the polarization-angle, readwrite multiplexing system, the external angles must be calculated. For a 45◦ cut crystal, the internal and external theoretical angles normal to the surface, as determined by the Anisotropic Snell’s Law, are given in Table 5.1, with the overall geometry of the system shown graphically in Fig. 5.8. Because the second writing beam is shown to contain an angular spectrum θ in Fig. 5.8, upon reconstruction, T A B L E 5.1. Theoretical geometry for the polarization-angle, read–write multiplexing system using the parallel-tangents, equal-curvature condition
θw1 θw2 θr θeq
θ
Internal angles (w.r.t. c axis)
Internal angles (w.r.t. normal)
External angles (w.r.t. normal)
63.1557◦ 51.0827◦ 61.9200◦ 49.6350◦ 20◦
18.1557◦ 6.0827◦ 16.9200◦ 4.6350◦ 20◦
50.4521◦ 15.2017◦ 44.8981◦ 11.3600◦ 50◦
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
16:49
5. True-Time-Delay Adaptive Array Processing Using Photorefractive Crystals
151
Extraordinary Polarized Parallel-Tangents, Equal-Curvature Beam
Extraordinary Polarized Reading Beam
11.3600
Ordinary Polarized Writing Beam #1
+c Axis 15.2017 44.8981 Δθ
50.4521
BaTiO 3
Ordinary Polarized Writing Beam #2
F I G U R E 5.8. Theoretical geometry showing the relationship between the ordinarypolarized reading beams, the extraordinary-polarized writing beam, and the diffracted parallel-tangents, equal-curvature beam. The entire angular aperture of the second write beam is reconstructed when read out with the orthogonally-polarized read beam.
the entire spectrum will be reconstructed as long as its internal angular aperture remains less than about 20◦ , as alluded to in Fig. 5.7.
5.4.3 Experimental Demonstration of Wide-Angular Aperture Readout Figure 5.9 shows the experimental setup of a system used to demonstrate the concept of the parallel-tangents, equal-curvature condition. Two ordinary beams are input into the crystal at angles θw1 and θw2 , with the θw2 beam focused into the crystal with a lens having an effective numerical aperture (due to space constraints) of NA = 0.5 to test the Bragg-matched angular readout bandwidth, providing an angular aperture of about θext = 53◦ external to the crystal and just over θint = 20◦ internal to the crystal. The third beam, which is extraordinary polarized, is input into the crystal at an angle θr . This read-out beam diffracts off the grating within the photorefractive crystal, is passed through a horizontal polarizer to filter out the writing beams, and imaged onto a charge-coupled device (CCD) camera. Experimentally, the reading beam angle was only deviated by 0.08◦ from its theoretical angle in order to achieve maximum diffraction efficiency over as broad an angular aperture as possible. This provides good confidence in the
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
152
16:49
G.R. Kriehn and K. Wagner
F I G U R E 5.9. Experimental setup using the parallel-tangents, equal-curvature geometry. Two ordinary write beams are used to write a grating in the photorefractive crystal, one of which contains a wide angular aperture. The extraordinary polarized beam efficiently reads out the hologram, reconstructing the wide angular aperture recorded in the BaTiO3 crystal.
material parameters utilized in the parallel-tangents, equal-curvature condition’s theoretical derivation as well as the accuracy of the 45◦ crystal cut. Figure 5.10 shows images of the light that diffracts off the hologram and is captured by the CCD camera when the read beam is rotated about the optimum readout angle θr by 0.05◦ increments. The top left-most picture shows the output at an angle θopt − 0.20◦ ; the bottom right-most picture shows the output at an angle θopt + 0.20◦ ; and the incremental 0.05◦ changes can be seen in the progression of images along each of the three columns. Notice that the middle pictures in the central columns show the optimum diffracted angular bandwidth, spanning 20.2◦ internal to the crystal (denoted by the light present in the horizontal direction). This compares extremely well with the theory just presented, since the internal Bragg-matched angular bandwidth was expected to be on the order of about 20◦ . Furthermore, these results also follow the experimental and theoretical intensity plots first presented by Sarto [14], who performed his experiments at a wavelength of 514 nm. Notice that the angular bandwidth near the parallel-tangents, equalcurvature geometry is actually larger than the angular bandwidth in the Braggdegenerate (vertical) direction. This is because the difference in curvature between
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
16:49
5. True-Time-Delay Adaptive Array Processing Using Photorefractive Crystals
153
F I G U R E 5.10. Images showing the diffracted output of a beam using the paralleltangents, equal-curvature condition over a large angular bandwidth. Each picture shows the diffracted output as the read beam is deviated away from the optimum angle by 0.05◦ increments. The middle picture in the central column shows the optimum diffracted angular bandwidth, which occurs at θr .
the sphere and the ellipsoid of revolution changes more quickly in the Braggdegenerate direction than in the plane of the parallel-tangents, equal-curvature condition. This clearly indicates that large z-dimensional angular bandwidth and efficient diffracted readout is possible. The high degree of isolation between the reading and writing beams is verified in Sec. 5.5. The asymmetry between the pictures when the read-beam angle is deviated either negatively or positively from the optimal readout angle occurs as a result of the nature of the Bragg mismatch introduced by the change in curvature of the ellipsoid of revolution after the sub-optimally aligned read beam attempts to diffract off the grating in the crystal. When the read beam is deviated negatively from its optimal angular alignment (Fig. 5.10a–d), the central portion of the beam is still sufficiently Bragg matched to allow a subset of k-vectors to propagate. However, at large angles deviating away from θeq , the diffracted waves no longer
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
154
16:49
G.R. Kriehn and K. Wagner
meet the phase matching requirements necessary to propagate any light. This is because the diffracted k-vectors lie completely inside the ellipsoid of revolution. Conversely, when the read beam is deviated positively from its optimal angular alignment (Fig. 5.10f–i), the central angular components try to launch k-vectors that now lie outside of the ellipsoid of revolution. Again, light will not propagate. However, the sphere and ellipse still intersect at angles that deviate away from θeq , and these angular components are sufficiently Bragg matched to allow propagation within the crystal.
5.4.4 Polarization-Angle, Read-Write Multiplexing with BaTiO3 Once the polarization-angle, read-write multiplexing system was characterized using the parallel-tangents, equal-curvature condition, an experimental open-loop version of the optical BEAMTAP processor was built. Figure 5.11 shows the experimental implementation of the system, including the polarization-angle, read-write multiplexing system used to isolate the writing beams from the reading beam within the photorefractive crystal. Vertically polarized light from a Coherent 5 W Verdi laser is initially passed through a half-wave plate and Glan laser prism to act as a variable attenuator before being spatially filtered and collimated by a 50 mm focal length lens. The beam is then split into 2 beams via an additional wave plate and polarizing beam splitter. One beam serves as a clean reference beam for detection at the traveling fringes detector (TFD), and the other beam is passed through a 3:1 beam compressor. When split by an additional wave plate and
F I G U R E 5.11. Detailed layout of the complete experimental photorefractive BEAMTAP system employing polarization-angle read-write multiplexing for isolation of the ˆ ˆ o-polarized writing beams from the e-polarized reading beam. Key components include the two AODs (acousto-optic deflectors), PRC (photorefractive crystal), and the TFD (traveling-fringes detector).
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
16:49
5. True-Time-Delay Adaptive Array Processing Using Photorefractive Crystals
155
polarizing beam splitter, and Fourier transformed into the acousto-optic devices (AODs) using 500 mm focal length lenses, 225 μm × 75 μm spots are produced in each of the wideband AODs (which are well matched to the 75 μm piezo-electric transducer height). The AODs serve as the entrance into either the feedback arm, or the array emulator arm of the processor. Light which enters the emulator arm diffracts off the acoustic gratings of the AOD, which emulates a well-sampled array of signals from an antenna array with an off axis incident RF plane wave. (This yields a traveling-wave signal across the array aperture, just like the modulation produced by the AOD.) The first diffracted order is allowed to pass through an iris while the DC beam is blocked, with the diffracted light then being collimated and split into two orthogonally polarized beams by a Glan Thompson polarizing beam splitter—each with excess of 40 dB ˆ and e-polarized ˆ polarization isolation. The obeams are then focused and imaged (using a single 2f telescopic lens system) into the photorefractive crystal (PRC) using 150 mm and 200 mm focal length lenses, respectively. Finally, as the two ˆ and e-polarized ˆ spots are imaged into the crystal, the obeams are rotated to the write-beam angle θw2 and the parallel-tangents, equal-curvature angle θeq using two pairs of mirrors. The wide angular bandwidth writing angle and the paralleltangents, equal-curvature angle are used for these two beams because the signals arriving from the antenna array may span a large angular bandwidth—in the emulated antenna, the AOD diffraction angles imaged through the photorefractive crystal span an angular range of about 5.0◦ external to the crystal, or about 2.0◦ internally. In the BEAMTAP arm of the processor, the lateral 225 μm spot in the feedback AOD (with acoustic velocity va = 4.2 mm/μsec) creates a tap-delay line with a delay of 54 ns within the 1/e2 Gaussian beam profile. Light that diffracts off ˆ this delay line is focused into the crystal, and because the beam is o-polarized, it ˆ writes a cross-correlation hologram with the o-polarized beam from the emulator arm of the processor. In addition, the angle by which this light is focused into the crystal is set to be centered about the first write beam angle θw1 , with an angular divergence from the AOD of 3.6◦ that is 1:0.75 afocally imaged into the ˆ photorefractive crystal. The e-polarized beam from the emulator is Bragg matched ˆ to the gratings written by the o-polarized beams using the parallel-tangents, equalcurvature condition across the entire angular bandwidth of the emulated antenna array. This reproduces the full angular bandwidth coming from the feedback AOD with only a 3 dB roll-off due to slight deviations from the optimum parallelˆ tangents, equal-curvature geometry. The e-polarized reading beam thus reads out the weight matrix formed by the cross-correlation between the emulated array of signals with the desired signal from the feedback arm of the processor. The ˆ e-polarized light that scatters off this grating diffracts out of the crystal at the read beam angle θr , which is shown in Fig. 5.12 as a top view of the photorefractive crystal. Figure 5.12a shows the overlap of the two ordinary-polarized write beams and the extraordinary-polarized parallel-tangents, equal-curvature beam in the photorefractive crystal. Figure 5.12b shows only the read-out beam, and the light is seen to be clearly diffracting off the hologram to the read beam-angle θr . Note
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
156
16:49
G.R. Kriehn and K. Wagner
F I G U R E 5.12. (a) The overlap of the two ordinary polarized write beams and the extraordinary polarized parallel-tangents, equal-curvature beam in the photorefractive crystal. (b) Only the parallel-tangents, equal-curvature beam, which is used to read out the hologram in the crystal, is shown here. Notice that the beam is clearly diffracted into the read beam angle θr .
that this diffracted beam holographically reproduces the spatio-temporal field profile that was produced by the feedback arm’s traveling-wave AOD (windowed by the time-integrated correlation function with each antenna element from the emulator arm), so that the different RF frequency components are diffracted at an angle proportional to their frequency. This is required for interferometric dispersion-free detection on the TFD, and is illustrated in Fig. 5.3. After the photorefractive crystal, the diffracted beam is adjusted to coincide with the writing beam angle θw1 by a pair of mirrors so that the angle will be properly aligned for coherent, dispersionless, interferometric detection on the TFD with the clean reference beam. The clean reference beam is adjusted to the feedback AOD DC reference beam angle by an additional set of mirrors and is rotated by a half wave plate so that it has the same polarization as the diffracted beam from the photorefractive crystal. The feedback AOD DC reference beam, as well as the original write beam kw1 are blocked by irises so that they will not be detected. This is the key isolation step of the read-write isolation subsystem. Finally, the clean reference beam and the diffracted read beam are focused onto the TFD, where they interfere to produce a set of moving interference fringes. By ensuring that the angular alignment of the diffracted read beam and the clean DC reference beam duplicates the original angular spectrum produced by the feedback AOD, the interferometric detection of each frequency component will produce traveling fringes moving at the same velocity as the imaged acoustic velocity—allowing them to be resonantly detected and accumulated by the TFD. If this condition is not obeyed, then the different frequency components from the desired signal that are detected by the phased-array antenna, diffracted by the photorefractive crystal, and interferometrically detected on the TFD will produce fringes moving at different velocities, and will not be resonantly detected. But with
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
16:49
−40.0
−40.0
−60.0
−60.0 Power (dBm)
Power (dBm)
5. True-Time-Delay Adaptive Array Processing Using Photorefractive Crystals
−80.0
−100.0 −120.0 −140.0 919.96
157
−80.0 −100.0 −120.0
919.98 920.00 920.02 Frequency (MHz)
(a)
920.04
−140.0 919.96
919.98 920.00 920.02 Frequency (MHz)
920.04
(b)
F I G U R E 5.13. (a) Beam forming of a single 1 GHz tone using polarization-angle readˆ write multiplexing. The detected power is that of the e-polarized read beam. (b) The isolation remains fixed with time, and is on the order of 45 dB—which is within 3 dB of the overall RF feedthrough in the system.
the velocity of the photogenerated carriers resonantly matched to the velocity of the interference pattern, the detected output contains the coherent addition of each of the antenna array elements provided by the emulator arm of the BEAMTAP processor. Figure 5.13a shows the detected beam-formed output for a single 1 GHz tone using the polarization-angle read-write multiplexing scheme. The detected power ˆ shown is the e-polarized read beam, since the reading and writing beams are angularly separated from each other, and both writing beams are blocked by irises after the photorefractive crystal. When light from the reading beam is blocked in the emulator arm of the processor, the signal detected at the output of the TFD is minimized—this is because the writing beam is isolated by both polarization and angle from the reading beam. Figure 5.13b shows that the writing beam has been isolated from the reading beam by 45 dB. Furthermore, this isolation remains fixed with time due to the additional degree of orthogonality introduced into the system by angularly separating the two beams. This was verified by taking the data after four hours of waiting once the system was initially setup, indicating that the polarization-angle, read-write multiplexing geometry is extremely robust. This is also in contrast to an alternative read-write isolation scheme that only used polarization multiplexing in crystalographically-cut SBN, in which fluctuations in the isolation were unavoidable due to secondary coupling effects between the writing and reading beams resulting from a buildup of an unwanted space-charge field. It is of interest to note that the RF feedthrough in the system is within 3 dB of the leakage from the writing beam, indicating that a substantial amount of optical isolation has been achieved. Further isolation would not actually improve the system performance unless the RF feedthrough could also be suppressed.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
158
16:49
G.R. Kriehn and K. Wagner
5.5 Experimental Implementation of BEAMTAP The culmination of the theoretical, analytical, and experimental work presented thus far allows for the integration of various subsystems—most notably an impedance matched TFD capable of detecting large fractional bandwidths and polarization-angle read-write multiplexing—into the overall framework of an experimental demonstration of BEAMTAP. However, this type of integration also requires phase stabilization of the interferometric reference beam with respect to the diffracted light from the photorefractive crystal. As a final step toward this end, a phase-stabilization subsystem was built to stabilize the interferometric reference beam with respect to the diffracted light from the photorefractive crystal.
5.5.1 Phase-Stabilization in BEAMTAP Phase stabilization is required in BEAMTAP because the output signal must have an accurate measurement of the jammer phase if the system is to undergo proper adaptation. If the phase of the interferometric reference beam changes by greater than 90◦ , but the jammer phase remains constant, then after subtraction at the differencing node, a positive jammer feedback signal—instead of a negative one— is applied to the feedback AOD for weight adaptation. Thus a strong correlation grating is written in the photorefractive crystal with the jammer that serves to increase the signal strength of the jammer at the output rather than to null it. The problem does not arise because the system is incapable of handling a dynamic environment where the jamming signal evolves with time, but because phase instabilities in the reference arm induce a false change in the jammer phase that the processor incorrectly “adapts” to. Therefore, it is critical that the optical phase in the interferometric reference arm and the diffracted light from the emulator arm remain constant. Referring back to the experimental setup of BEAMTAP (see Fig. 5.11), the two thicker lines show the path of the interferometer that must undergo phase stabilization—the diffracted light from the emulator arm off the photorefractive crystal, and the interferometric reference arm. (The second interferometer that writes gratings in the photorefractive crystal self stabilizes due BEAMTAP’s adaptive feedback mechanism.) Unfortunately, a simple pilot tone cannot be injected into the system (which would write a photorefractive grating, be subsequently diffracted off the grating and be detected at the TFD—thus enabling it to be used for stabilization), because this would require a connection between the electronics used to generate the feedback signal and the electronics used to generate the phased-array antenna signal for the emulator. Due to electrical reflections and finite isolation in the RF components used to generate these signals, if there is a connection between the feedback arm and the phased-array arm, part of the jammer signal leaks back into the feedback signal and serves as a beam forming source that points a beam (rather than a null) toward the jammer.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
16:49
5. True-Time-Delay Adaptive Array Processing Using Photorefractive Crystals
159
As alluded to Fig. 5.11, the problem can be solved by using the carrier for the signal of interest at 920 MHz as a reference for phase stabilization, as long as the two carriers in the two arms are generated separately and not connected electrically to each other in any way. Using the carrier is convenient, especially since it is the strongest frequency component of the signal of interest, and is always detected with relatively strong efficiency. A 920.01 MHz phase-locked local oscillator is then used to down convert the signal to 10 kHz, where it finally fed into a lock-in amplifier to detect the phase of the signal. The error signal that is produced drives a piezo-electric mirror that compensates for any path length changes in the reference arm of the BEAMTAP processor. Using the carrier frequency does not ensure a problem free solution though, since information content is present with the carrier. It thus becomes necessary to isolate the carrier from the rest of the signal bandwidth to keep any nonlinearities from folding frequency information into the 920 MHz signal. To avoid this problem, a specific modulation scheme was developed to ensure that the carrier could be efficiently isolated from the information bandwidth. This is illustrated in Fig. 5.14. At the output, the detected signal of interest is comprised of a 920 MHz carrier and double-sideband modulation that can potentially span up to 500 MHz of bandwidth. These signals are then mixed down with a 920.01 MHz local oscillator to produce a 10 kHz tone and a number of frequency components that are close to baseband, spanning about 250 MHz in width. However, if the original signal bandwidth is chosen so that it starts at 1 MHz, instead of at DC, then a 1 MHz window is created between the mixed carrier signal and the information
F I G U R E 5.14. A modulation scheme that allows for the unwanted signal bandwidth to be separated from the desired 10 kHz, mixed down carrier for phase modulation. A 1 MHz window separates the carrier from the modulation bandwidth, allowing for a lowpass filter with a 20 kHz cutoff to remove the unwanted frequency bandwidth.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
160
16:49
G.R. Kriehn and K. Wagner
bandwidth. A sharp, low pass filter with a 20 kHz cutoff frequency can then be used to remove these unwanted frequency components. This produces a clean 10 kHz signal that can be efficiently used for phase stabilization using the lock-in amplifier and piezo-electric mirror.
5.5.2 Experimental Beam Forming and Jammer Nulling Results With an impedance matched TFD, polarization-angle read-write multiplexing system, a phased-array antenna emulator, and a phase stabilization subsystem, the BEAMTAP system is now capable of simultaneous beam forming and jammer nulling. Figure 5.15 shows the electronic RF setup for the full optical system, which includes a jammer signal source and closed loop adaptation. An arbitrary waveform generator and a signal generator are used to create a variable bandwidth jamming signal that is incoherent with the rest of the system. The agile signal generator provides the 920 MHz signal of interest, and the two signals are combined, amplified, and input into the emulator. The synthesized sweeper, which is only phase locked to the agile signal generator, provides the desired steering signal d(t), which, when subtracted from the output o(t), generates the feedback signal f (t). This signal is similarly amplified and applied to the feedback AOD. With the two signals in place, the read beam from the emulator, using the parallel-tangents, equal-curvature condition, diffracts off the photorefractive grating produced by the two writing beams, and is interferometrically detected. The output signal is amplified by 78 dB, and a portion of the signal coupled to a spectrum analyzer to provide the final output to the system. A second portion of the signal is tapped off to the phase stabilization subsystem, and the rest is used to help generate the feedback signal f (t). A variable attenuator is used to allow for changes in the feedback gain, and an RF switch is used to quickly switch between open-loop and closed-loop adaptation. In the phase stabilization subsystem, the stable reference is provided by the carrier of d(t), and the output o(t) provides the signal to be stabilized. Narrowband Adaptive Processing
Figures 5.16 and 5.17 show the first experimental results of simultaneous beam forming and jammer nulling with BEAMTAP. Figure 5.16a shows a 920 MHz tone that was applied to the phased-array antenna as the signal of interest, (b) the open-loop beam-formed output, and (c) the closed-loop signal with negligible loss. The feedback gain in the system is 20 dB lower than the total cascaded gain shown in Fig. 5.15 to provide a reference for comparison against higher feedback gains in later experiments. Figure 5.17 shows the applied phased-array jamming signal, incident at the same angle of arrival (AOA) as the angle of interest (which is one of the most difficult scenarios to account for in adaptation), but at a 820 MHz instead of 920 MHz. The jammer power is 10 dB higher than the signal of interest. But because the jamming signal is not perfectly Bragg matched to the photorefractive grating written at 920 MHz (which is the signal of interest), the open-loop results (b) show that the jammer is detected on a sidelobe
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
16:49
5. True-Time-Delay Adaptive Array Processing Using Photorefractive Crystals
Arbitrary Waveform Generator
161
Trigger Mixer
10 MHz Ref
Oscilloscope +30 dB
Signal Generator
10 MHz Ref
Agile Signal Generator
Synth. Sweeper
Signal
Jammer -20 dB CPL
+30 dB
3 dB CPL
-2 dB -1 dB
1650 MHz
Signal
+30 dB
Full Optical System
-20 dB CPL
-2 dB -1 dB
f(t) o(t)
Signal & Jammer
Spectrum Analyzer
Feedback System
d(t)
Signal Generation
Spectrum Analyzer
1650 MHz
AOD
Output o(t)
AOD PRC
-20 dB CPL TFD -3 dB CPL
Variable Hybrid RF Coupler Switch Attenuator
Phase Stabilization System
+20 dB
+20 dB
+20 dB
+18 dB (TA) To Piezeo-Electric Mirror High Voltage Oscilloscope
Bias PZT Amplifier
Signal Generator
Mixer
-20 dB CPL
PZT Filter
PZT Bias Circuit Lock-In Amplifier Trigger
Mixer
Oscilloscope
-3 dB CPL 5 MHz
5 MHz
10 kHz Signal 10 kHz Reference
Output
LPF Gain 20 kHz +20 dB Circuits 20 kHz +20 dB
F I G U R E 5.15. Electronic setup for the full adaptive beam-forming and jammer-nulling BEAMTAP system with the feedback loop closed to enable the adaptive jammer-nulling operation. Notice that the feedback arm has been sufficiently modified for closed-loop adaptation and that an RF switch has been added to readily switch been open and closedloop performance.
of the main beam, and is consequently suppressed by 10 dB with respect to the desired output signal. After closed loop adaptation (c), the jammer is nulled by an additional 15 dB, indicating a total signal-to-interference-plus-noise ratio (SINR) improvement of 25 dB. The null depth remains constant, even over lengths of time
0.0
(a)
919.6
919.8
920.0 Frequency (MHz)
920.2
920.4
(b)
919.6
−90.0 −100.0
920.4
−100.0 920.2
−100.0 920.0 Frequency (MHz)
−80.0
−90.0
−90.0 919.6
−70.0
−60.0
−50.0
−40.0
−30.0
−20.0
−10.0
0.0
10.0
−80.0
919.8
Open-Loop Signal Power
−80.0
−60.0
−50.0
−40.0
−30.0
−20.0
−10.0
0.0
10.0
−70.0
Power (dBm)
−70.0
−60.0
−50.0
−40.0
−30.0
−20.0
−10.0
Phased-Array Signal Power
Power (dBm)
162 820.2
820.4
Power (dBm)
919.8
(c)
920.0 Frequency (MHz)
920.2
Closed-Loop Signal Power
920.4
819.8
820.0 Frequency (MHz)
820.2
820.4
(a)
(b)
819.6
819.8
(c)
820.0 Frequency (MHz)
820.2
ClosedLoop Jammer Power
820.4
F I G U R E 5.17. (a) shows the the applied phased-array jamming signal which is also present at that the same angle of arrival as the signal of interest, but at a different frequency and 10 dB higher in power. (b) shows the open-loop jammer output, and (c) shows the closed-loop nulling of the jammer. Since the jammer is detected on a sidelobe 10 dB down, and nulled 15 dB more, the system shows a total SINR improvement of 25 dB.
819.6
819.6
90. 0 100. 0
−100.0
−100.0 820.0 Frequency (MHz)
80. 0
−80.0 −90.0
70. 0
60. 0
50. 0
40. 0
30. 0
20. 0
10. 0
0.0
10.0
−90.0 819.8
OpenLoop Jammer Power
−70.0
−60.0
−50.0
−40.0
−30.0
−20.0
−10.0
0.0
10.0
−80.0
−70.0
−60.0
−50.0
−40.0
−30.0
−20.0
−10.0
0.0
10.0
Phased-Array Jammer Power
Power (dBm)
F I G U R E 5.16. (a) shows the applied phased-array signal of interest in a narrowband test of the adaptive BEAMTAP processor. (b) shows open-loop beam-formed output, and (c) shows the closed-loop signal of interest with negligible loss. The gain in the system is 20 dB lower than the total cascaded gain shown in Fig. 5.15.
Power (dBm)
10.0
Power (dBm)
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006 16:49
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
16:49
5. True-Time-Delay Adaptive Array Processing Using Photorefractive Crystals
Jammer Dynamical Closed-Loop Grating Decay (30 s)
0.0
0.0
10.0
−10.0
−20.0
−20.0
−30.0
−30.0 Power (dBm)
Power (dBm)
Closed-Loop Jammer Dynamics (30 s)
−40.0 −50.0 −60.0 −70.0 −80.0
163
−40.0 −50.0 −60.0 −70.0 −80.0
−90.0
−90.0
−100.0
−100.0 0
2
4
6
8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 Time (s)
(a)
0
2
4
6
8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 Time (s)
(b)
F I G U R E 5.18. (a) shows the jammer nulling dynamics over a 30 s time scale. Closedloop adaptive null depths of 15–20 dB are shown here. Notice that the system reaches steady-state after about 1 s of adaptation time once the RF switch is flipped to close the adaptive feedback loop. (b) shows the effects of the erasure of the grating components responsible for the nulling of the jamming signal once the BEAMTAP system is switched from closed-loop to open-loop adaptation. Notice that it takes about 1 s for the system to erase the jammer-nulling grating.
much longer than 15 minutes—indicating excellent phase stabilization within the system. Next, Fig. 5.18a shows the time evolution of the jammer power over 30 s as the processor is switched between open-loop and closed-loop adaptation. After adapting, the stable closed-loop null depth for the jammer is between 15–20 dB, with the system reaching steady state after about 1 s of adaptation time (once the RF switch is flipped to close the adaptive feedback loop). The adaptation is somewhat slow because the jammer is arriving at the same AOA as the signal of interest. This creates competition between the beam forming and jammer nulling operations, although a nulling rate of over 3 dB per 50 ms is achieved, even in this case. Furthermore, there is enough time delay present in the processor to successfully distinguish between the two signals with only a minimal loss of the signal power. Using more optical power or higher feedback gain should result in much faster nulling dynamics (with sub-millisecond nulling being achievable) when the signal and jammer arrive from different AOAs. Figure 5.18b shows the dynamics of the erasure of the grating components responsible for jammer nulling after the system is switched from closed-loop to open-loop operation. The grating decays away exponentially, as expected, and the jammer power gradually increases to its expected open-loop power level. The grating takes about 1 s to decay back to its open-loop state. After erasure, the jammer power remains constant, which also indicates robust phase stabilization. A second experiment was also performed where the feedback gain was increased by 20 dB and the experiment was repeated. With higher gain, the
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
164
16:49
G.R. Kriehn and K. Wagner
competition between the beam forming and jammer nulling operations was stronger, and the processor had difficulty distinguishing between the two signals. The signal of interest was nulled by about 20 dB, and the jammer by 30 dB. Even though the jammer was suppressed by 40 dB, the actual SINR improvement was only 20 dB, 5 dB worse than the previous case. This occurred, again, because the signal of interest and the jamming signal arrived at the same AOA. When arriving from distinct angles, much better results are to be expected. Broadband Adaptive Processing
After this initial proof of concept demonstrating simultaneous, narrowband adaptive beam forming and jammer nulling, information bandwidth was added to the jammer signal to demonstrate broadband adaptive nulling. As an intermediate experiment, Fig. 5.19 shows results of the (a) phased-array emulator signals (b) open-loop signals, and (c) closed-loop signals of a narrowband, 920 MHz signal and 10 MHz bandwidth jammer centered at 880 MHz. The broad pedestal present 40 dB down on the signal is actually just phase noise that is generated by the signal source, and is not indicative of a broadband signal. The open-loop results demonstrate that both the signal and jammer are detected, but after closed-loop adaptation, the jamming signal is nulled to the level of the noise floor, with the expected (slight) degradation of the signal of interest. The final SINR improves by about 18 dB. However, notice that the total null depth of the carrier frequency of the jammer is about 45 dB. As a final experiment, the jammer informational bandwidth was extended to 100 MHz, while keeping the carrier frequencies of the signal and jammer (920 MHz and 880 MHz, respectively) constant. Now, a portion of the frequency spectra of the jamming signal overlaps with the frequency spectra of the signal of interest at 920 MHz, with both signals being produced by the array emulator as if they were arriving at the same AOA. This, by far, is the most difficult test for the adaptive processor, since the only degree of freedom between the signal and jammer within the narrow bandwidth surrounding the signal tone is a lack of phase coherence between the two signals. Figure 5.20 shows the experimental results of the (a) phased-array emulator signals, (b) open-loop signals, and (c) closed-loop signals. Notice in open-loop adaptation, a large portion of the jammer frequency components have already been nulled. This is a result of the Bragg mismatch of these frequencies with the grating written between the desired signal and signal of interest at 920 MHz. In a sense, the residual frequency spectra of the jamming signal is a plot of the frequency selectivity of the Bragg diffraction in the photorefractive crystal due to the illuminated time aperture in the AOD. The sinc-like pattern (plotted on a log scale) is due to the jammer frequency reading out the signal grating, and appears slightly shifted due to a small misalignment of the read-write multiplexing geometry. Once the RF switch is flipped for closedloop adaptation, the processor still successfully nulls the residual jammer to the level of the noise floor, providing about 45 dB of total null depth for the carrier
850
870 890 910 Frequency (MHz)
930
950
(c)
Frequency (MHz)
850 860 870 880 890 900 910 920 930 940 950
Closed-Loop Signal [o(t)]
810
830
850
(b)
870 890 910 Frequency (MHz)
Open-Loop Signal [o(t)]
930
950
100.0
90.0
80.0
70.0
60.0
50.0
40.0
30.0
20.0
10.0
0.0
810
830
850
(c)
870 890 910 Frequency (MHz)
Closed-Loop Signal [o(t)]
930
950
F I G U R E 5.20. (a) shows the signals being applied to the phased-array emulator, now with a jammer spanning 100 MHz of bandwidth, which overlaps in frequency space with the signal of interest, at 920 MHz. Both the signal of interest and the jammer signal are at the same angle of arrival. (b) and (c) show the open and closed-loop performance of the processor. Due to Bragg matching, only a subset of the jammer nulling frequency components are sufficiently detected at the output, which the system successfully nulls in closed-loop adaptation.
(a)
−100.0
−100.0 830
−90.0
−70.0
−60.0
−50.0
−40.0
−30.0
−20.0
−10.0
0.0
−90.0 810
Phased-Array Antenna Signals
−80.0
−70.0
−60.0
−50.0
−40.0
−30.0
−20.0
−10.0
0.0
−80.0
Power (dBm)
F I G U R E 5.19. (a) shows the signals being applied to the phased-array emulator. Now a 10 MHz bandwidth chirp is present in the jammer signal at 820 MHz, along with a narrowband signal at 920 MHz at the same angle of arrival. (b) and (c) show the open and closed-loop steady-state signals of the BEAMTAP system, showing that even though a residual jammer component is present at the output before closed-loop adaptation, it is nulled to to noise floor once the closed-loop RF switch is flipped.
(b)
Frequency (MHz)
Frequency (MHz)
(a)
850 860 870 880 890 900 910 920 930 940 950
850 860 870 880 890 900 910 920 930 940 950
−90.0 −100.0
−100.0
−80.0
−70.0
−60.0
−50.0
−40.0
−30.0
−20.0
−10.0
0.0
−100.0
Open-Loop Signal [o(t)]
−90.0
−70.0
−60.0
−50.0
−40.0
−30.0
−20.0
−10.0
0.0
−90.0
Power (dBm) −80.0
−70.0
−60.0
−50.0
−40.0
−30.0
−20.0
−10.0
Phased-Array Antenna Signals
Power (dBm)
−80.0
Power (dBm)
0.0
Power (dBm)
165 Power (dBm)
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006 16:49
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
166
16:49
G.R. Kriehn and K. Wagner
of the jammer—and leaves an attenuated, yet still detected, signal of interest at 920 MHz. Clearly the processor is extremely robust, and is capable of performing simultaneous, broadband adaptive beam forming and jammer nulling under adverse signal conditions (including main-beam jammers), providing the feedback gain is not too strong so as to completely null the signal of interest. Even better performance with deeper jammer nulls, increased SINR improvement, and faster nulling is expected when the signal and jammer arrive from resolvable angles onto the array.
5.6 Conclusion The significance of the work presented in this chapter has centered around an experimental demonstration of a photorefractive RF photonic system that is capable of broadband adaptive signal processing, enabling simultaneous beam forming and jammer nulling operation for large antenna arrays. To that end, this chapter has presented a novel solution using the BEAMTAP algorithm which is based on an output time delay reformulation of adaptive beam forming that enables the use of photorefractive crystals as the adaptive weights. The critical components include the sum-and-time-delay which can be implemented by using a scrolling, accumulating detector known as the traveling-fringes detector for coherent summation at the output; a photorefractive crystal using dynamic holography to store the adaptive weight matrix; and an acousto-optic deflector to provide adaptation for robust, simultaneous beam forming and jammer nulling. In addition, this chapter has provided insight into polarization-angle, read-write multiplexing using the parallel-tangents, equal-curvature condition in 45◦ -cut BaTiO3 . The parallel-tangents, equal-curvature condition is a special condition ˆ that allows for anisotropic Bragg matching of gratings written by two o-polarized ˆ beams and read out by an e-polarized beam over an extremely wide angular bandwidth. This read-write isolation is critical, as it separates the reading beam from the writing beams and prevents the system from breaking into oscillation, and is the determining factor of the amount of jammer null depth available to the processor. Experimental results showed 45 dB of read-write isolation, which was ultimately limited by the RF feedthrough of the system. In conclusion, this chapter has demonstrated the feasibility of the photorefractive implementation of RF photonic adaptive processing using BEAMTAP for the next generation of phased-array antennas. Experimental demonstrations of beam forming and jammer nulling have illustrated the flexibility and robustness of the processor, in addition to verifying the usefulness of the algorithm and the optical architecture for future phased-array antenna applications. We wish to acknowledge the support by Dr. William Miceli of ONR, Dr. Steve Pappert of SPAWAR, and the Office of the Secretary of Defense DDR&E through the MURI program grant no. N00014-97-1-1006. Finally, we are also grateful to Dr. D. Dolfi for providing us with the traveling-fringes detector, and also the
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
16:49
5. True-Time-Delay Adaptive Array Processing Using Photorefractive Crystals
167
work Dr. T. Sarto and R. T. Weverka, upon which all of the parallel-tangents, equal-curvature condition work is based.
References 1. D. Psaltis, J. Yu, and J. Hong, “Bias-Free Time-Integrating Optical Correlator Using A Photorefractive Crystal,” Applied Optics 24, 3860–3865 (1985). 2. J. H. Hong and T. Y. Chang, “Frequency-Agile RF Notch Filter That Uses Photorefractive 2-Beam Coupling,” Optics Letters 18, 164–166 (1993). 3. J. H. Hong and T. Y. Chang, “Adaptive RF Notch Filtering Using Photorefractive 2-Beam Coupling,” IEEE Journal Of Quantum Electronics 30, 314–317 (1994). 4. R. M. Montgomery and M. R. Lange, “Photorefractive Adaptive Filter Structure With 40-dB Interference Rejection,” Applied Optics 30, 2844–2849 (1991). 5. J. H. Hong and I. Mcmichael, “Novel Optical Technique For Phased-Array Processing,” Optical Engineering 30, 1976–1980 (1991). 6. R. T. Weverka, K. Wagner, and A. Sarto, “Photorefractive processing for large adaptive phased arrays,” Applied Optics 35, 1344–1366 (1996). 7. L. B. Lambert, M. Arm, and A. Aimette, “Electro-optical signal processing for phasedarray antennas,” in Optical and electro-optic information processing, J. Tippett et al., eds., (MIT press, 1965), p. 715. 8. D. R. Pape, “Multichannel Bragg cells: design, performance, and applications,” Optical Engineering 31, 2148–2158 (1992). 9. T. M. Turpin, F. F. Froehlich, and D. B. Nichols, “Optical tapped delay line,”, US Patent 687029, 2003. 10. R. M. Montgomery, “Acousto-optic/photorefractive processor for adaptive antenna arrays,” In Proc. SPIE, B. M. Hendrickson and G. A. Koepf, eds., Optoelectronic Signal Processing for Phased-Array Antennas II 1217, 207–217 (Bellingham, Wash., USA, 1990). 11. G. Kriehn, A. Kiruluta, P. E. X. Silveira, S. Weaver, S. Kraut, K. Wagner, R. T. Weverka, and L. Griffiths, “Optical BEAMTAP Beam-Forming and Jammer-Nulling System for Broadband Phased-Array Antennas,” Applied Optics 39, 212–230 (2000). 12. D. Dolfi, T. Merlet, A. Mestreau, and J.-P. Huignard, “Photodetector for microwave signals based on the synchronous drift of photogenerated carriers with a moving interference pattern,” Applied Physics Letters 65, 2931–2933 (1994). 13. T. Merlet, D. Dolfi, and J.-P. Huignard, “A Traveling Fringes Photodetector for Microwave Signals,” IEEE Journal of Quantum Electronics 32, 778–783 (1996). 14. A. W. Sarto, K. H. Wagner, R. T. Weverka, S. Weaver, and E. K. Walge, “Wide angular aperture holograms in photorefractive crystals by the use of orthogonally polarized write and read beams,” Applied Optics 35, 5765–5775 (1996). 15. M. Cronin-Golomb and M. P. Tarr, “Applications of birefringent phase matching for photorefractive devices,” Optics Letters 20, 2252– (1995). 16. B. Widrow, P. E. Mantey, L. J. Griffiths, and B. B. Goode, “Adaptive Antenna Systems,” Proceedings of the IEEE 55, 2143–2161 (1967). 17. R. T. Compton, Adaptive Antennas (Prentice Hall, 1988). 18. S. M. Sze, Physics of Semiconductor Devices, 2 ed. (John Wiley, 1981).
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 November 1, 2006
168
16:49
G.R. Kriehn and K. Wagner
19. A. W. Sarto, Ph.D. thesis, University of Colorado, Boulder, 1996. 20. I. C. Chang, “Noncollinear acousto-optic filter with large angular aperture,” Applied Physics Letters 25, 370–372 (1974). ¨ 21. K. Buse, S. Riehemann, S. Loheide, H. Hesse, F. Mersch, and E. Kratzig, “Refractive Indices of Single Domain BaTiO3 for Different Wavelengths and Temperatures,” Physica Status Solidi A 135, K87–K89 (1993).
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
7:43
6 Photorefractive Mesogenic Composites for Applications to Image Processing Hiroshi Ono,1 Akira Emoto,1 and Nobuhiro Kawatsuki2 1
Department of Electrical Engineering, Nagaoka University of Technology, 1603-1 Kamitomioka, Nagaoka 940-2188, Japan
[email protected] 2 Department of Materials Science and Chemistry, Himeji Institute of Technology, 2167 Shosha, Himeji 671-2201, Japan
[email protected]
The industry of optoelectronics, including optical memeory, optical communication, and optical information processing, has developed since the last century. Over the past decade, interest has grown in nonlinear optical materials allowing operations in real time on the phase and on the amplitude of coherent wavefronts. Such nonlinear interaction is a fascinate subject, with great promise for application to image distortion compensation, coherent image amplification, optical image filtering, and novel laser resonator design. Photorefractive materials are by far the most efficient nonlinear optical media for optical wave mixing and phase conjugation, which are indispensable for the realization of most of photonics applications. Among many kinds of photorefractive materials, mesogenic materials show a high diffraction efficiency and relatively fast response under a low operating voltage. The aim of the present chapter is to summarize the development of the photorefractive mesogenic composites and to demonstrate optical information processing using photorefractive mesogenic composites.
6.1 Overview of Mesogenic Composites for Photorefractive Applications Before we discuss the applications to image processing, reviews of material development are in order regarding the photorefractive characteristics of the mesogenic composites. In 1994, the first observation of the orientational photorefractive effect in a mesogenic material utilized dye-doped 4-cyano-4 -pentylbiphenyl (5CB) [1, 2, 3]. Reorientation of liquid-crystalline molecules can occur even
169
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
170
7:43
Hiroshi Ono, Akira Emoto, and Nobuhiro Kawatsuki
(a) 51%
C5H11
CN
25%
C7H15
CN
(b)
(c) *
16% OC8H17 8%
C5H11
CN CN
CH3 C H2
C
n
C
*
O
OMe
F I G U R E 6.1. The chemical components of a photorefractive polymer-dispersed liquid crystal (PDLC) fabricated by the solvent-induced phase-separation method. (a) E7 as low-molar-mass nematic liquid crystal, (b) fullerene as photoconductive sensitizer, and (c) polymethylmethacrylate as polymer matrix.
in weak optical and electrical fields, so a space-charge field, which can be orders of magnitude larger than an optical field, should produce impressive photorefractivity. The photorefractivity in mesogenic materials is based on orientattional birefringence, and effects are named “orientational photorefractive effects.” One of the advantages of photorefractive mesogenic systems is that the operating voltage required is much lower than that required for other organic photorefractive materials [4, 5, 6], including polymer composites, organic crystals, and organic glasses. The dye-doped low-molar-mass liquid crystals show highperformance photorefractivities, but unfortunately, good photorefractive performance is observed only for large fringe spacing (>10 μm), which is not suitable for high-resolution applications. Nowadays, a sophisticated method for improving the resolution of photorefractive liquid crystals is to combine the low-molar-mass liquid crystal with polymer [7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15]. One avenue is to use use polymer-dispersed liquid crystals (PDLCs) [7, 8, 9, 12, 13, 14, 15]. The PDLC films are composed of liquid droplets surrounded by polymer matrix materials. Photorefactive PDLCs, which contain PMMA, E7, and C60 (see Figure 6.1 and are fabricated by means of the solvent-induced phase-separation method, were presented by Ono and Kawatsuki in 1997 [7]. Golemme et al. also reported observation in photorefractive effects in the functionalized PDLCs as described in Figure 6.2, which are fabricated by means of the thermally induced phase separation method [8]. To investigate the photorefractive properties they performed four-wave mixing experiments, and a high diffraction efficiency and a high refractive index modulation were obtained in a 53-μm-thick sample with an applied electric field of 22 V/μm. The resolution of the photorefractive liquid crystal was improved by using the PDLCs, and a Bragg-type grating can be written in the photorefractive PDLCs. However, scattering losses are very large for the diagonal beam incidence because of the phase separation in photorefractive PDLCs.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
7:43
6. Photorefractive Mesogenic Composites for Applications to Image Processing (a)
171
(b)
O O2N
*
NO2
H C C n* H2 N
NO2
F I G U R E 6.2. The chemical components of a photorefractive polymer liquid crystal fabricated by the thermally induced phase-separation method. (a) 2, 4, 7-trinitro-9-fluorenone as photoconductive sensitizer and (b) poly-(9-vinylcarbazole) as func-tionalized polymer matrix.
In 1998, Ono and Kawatsuki presented a new avenue to solve the problems in both photorefractive PDLCs and low-molar-mass liquid crystals [10]. Their presentation is to use a high- and low-molar-mass liquid-crystalline mixture as shown in Figure 6.3. The low-molar-mass liquid crystal can dissolve the polymer liquid crystal and the resulting polymer dissolved liquid crystal composite (PDLCC) exhibits the mesophase without phase separation. The mesogenic groups in the PDLCC film easily align in the homeotropic configuration, and this alignment is stable under no electric field even at room temperature, which is preferable to reducing the scattering loss. The photorefractive properties of the PDLCC described in Figure 6.3 were extensively investigated, and an extreamely high net (b)
(a) 51%
C5H11
CN
25%
C7H15
CN
16% OC8H17
CN
8%
C5H11
CN
(c) C O (CH2)6 H3C C CH2 O
O
C O
CN
O
x
F I G U R E 6.3. The chemical components of a photorefractive polymer dissolved liquid crystal composite (PDLCC). (a) E7 as low-molar-mass liquid crystals, (b) fullerene as photoconductive sensitizer, and (c) polymer liquid crystal.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
172
7:43
Hiroshi Ono, Akira Emoto, and Nobuhiro Kawatsuki
(a) 51% H11C5
CN
25% H15C7
CN
16% H17C8O
CN
(b) O2 N
NO2
O2N 8%
H11C5
CN O
(c)
H3C C
C O (CH2)6
O
COO
CN
O CH2 50 H3C C
C O (CH2)2
N
O CH2 50
F I G U R E 6.4. The chemical components of a functionalized photorefractive polymer dissolved liquid crystal composite. (a) E7 as low-molar-mass liquid crystals, (b) 2,4,7-trinitro9-fluorenone (TNF) as photoconductive sensitizer, and (c) functionalized polymer for photorefractive PDLCC.
gain coefficient was achieved with low applied electric fields and low scattering loss in the thick-grating regime. Another merit in the phtorefractive PDLCC is to use the high functionalized polymer liquid crystals as shown in Figure 6.4(c) [11, 15]. The functionalized polymers have both mesogenic and photoconductive active groups in polymer side chains. The photorefractive PDLCC containing the functionalized copolymer has been investigated for use in real-time holography [16, 17].
6.2 Fundamental Properties of Photorefractive Mesogenic Composites for Image Processing 6.2.1 Two-Wave Mixing in Photorefractive Mesogenic Composites The nonlocal origin of the photorefractive effect manifests itself in a phase shift (φ) between the recording index and the light fringe pattern that creates it, enabling
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
7:43
6. Photorefractive Mesogenic Composites for Applications to Image Processing (a)
173
(b)
F I G U R E 6.5. A schematic diagram of the two-beam coupling experimental geometry and the resulting self-diffraction in the (a) Raman–Nath and (b) Bragg regimes.
two-beam coupling. Undoubted evidence of photorefractivity is provided by the demonstration of the phase-shifted refractive index grating [18, 19]. Two-beam coupling experiments have been considered the cornerstone of decisive experimental proof of photorefractivity in new materials. Diffraction in a photorefractive grating is treated differently if the grating is thin (Raman–Nath) or thick (Bragg) [20, 21]. For the Raman–Nath regime of optical diffraction, the angular spread of the grating vector is much larger than the Bragg diffraction angle, and multiple orders of diffraction are there fore allowed as schematically described in Figure 6.5(a), while the coupled wave theory is valid in the Bragg regime and the light energy is transferred between the two beams as shown in Figure. 6.5(b). Figure 6.6 shows typical diffraction patterns for the photorefractive PDLCC sample. When the diffraction is of the Raman–Nath type, a multiple diffraction process was effective at certain values of dc voltage applied to the PDLCC sample, and a result, in a far field after the sample, the first- and higher-order diffraction spots appeared as shown in Figure 6.6(a). In the Bragg regime, one has to notice that the intensities of the two transmitted beams are different. The asymmetric diffraction pattern is a result of photorefractive-like nonlocal gratings generated in the PDLCC sample. According to the theory of two-beam coupling
F I G U R E 6.6. Demonstration of diffraction from (a) thin (Raman–Nath) and (b) thick (Bragg) gratings in the photorefractive PDLCC. The chemical components of the PDLCC were presented in Figure 6.4. The value of the parameter Q was set to be about (a) 0.1 and (b) 20. The photorefractive gratings were written using p polarized, mutually coherent, He-Ne laser beams that emit continuous-wave 632.-nm light, with an intensity of 6 mW each. The applied dc field was 0.3 V/μm.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
174
7:43
Hiroshi Ono, Akira Emoto, and Nobuhiro Kawatsuki
in photorefractive materials, the intensities of the two beams transmitted in the photorefractive material are [19, 21] 1 + ξ −1 , 1 + ξ −1 ed 1+ξ , I2 (z) = I2 (0) 1 + ξ e−d
I1 (z) = I1 (0)
(6.1) (6.2)
where ξ is the input intensity ratio, d the thickness of the photorefractive grating. The gain coefficient is given by 2πn 1 sin φ, (6.3) λ cos θ where n 1 is an amplitude of index modulation, λ is wavelength, and 2θ is the incident angle between two coherent beams. Thus diffraction on a photorefractive grating is treated differently if the grating is “thin” or “thick.” The two limiting cases can be decided by the follwing parameter [20]: =
2πλd , (6.4) n2 where n is the refractive index and is the grating spacing. According to Kogelnik’s coupled-wave model, the most rigorous treatments suggest that Q values of over 10 are required to produce a true volume grating (Bragg regime). Figure 6.7 shows typical asymmetric energy transfer signals in two-beam coupling experiments [22]. The intensity of one beam was monitored while another beam was opened at t = 0 s, and the same experiment was repeated for another beam. The fringe spacing was set to be 2.6 μm and the Bragg condition for diffraction on thick gratings was achieved. No signals were detected in the case Q=
2.0
2.0
(b)
(a) 1.5 I(t)/I(t=0)
I(t)/I(t=0)
1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 −0.5
1.0 0.5
0
0.5 Time (s)
1
0.0 −0.5
0
0.5
1
Time (s)
F I G U R E 6.7. The typical energy transfer signals in the two-beam coupling experiments for photorefractive PDLCC described in Figure 6.3. The composition of polymer liquid crystal and E7 is (a) 0:100 and (b) 0:90. Fullerene was used as photoconductive sensitizer for two composites. The applied dc field was 0.18 V/μm and the fringe spacing was 2.6 μm. The film thickness was 50 μm [22].
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
7:43
6. Photorefractive Mesogenic Composites for Applications to Image Processing −3
−2
−1
−0
+0
+1
+2
175
+3
(a) (b)
F I G U R E 6.8. Self-diffraction patterns from (a) PDLC and (b) PDLCC samples. The chemical components of photorefractive PDLC and PDLCC are presented in Figures 6.1 and [6.3], respectively. The polymer concentration was 10 wt%, the grating constant 20μm, and the film thickness 10 μm. The dc field applied to the PDLC sample was 6.0 μm and that to the PDLCC sample, 0.4 V/μm [23].
of E7/C60 without polymer as shown in Figure 6.7(a), while a large beam-coupling signal appeared by adding the polymer to E7/C60 as shown in Figure 6.7(b). This means that the resolution of the photorefractive liquid crystals was improved by the addition of the polymer. From the point of view of morphology, we can divide photorefractive liquid crystals containing polymers into two classes: (a) polymer and low-molarmass liquid crystals are phase separated (PDLC) and (b) polymer and low-molarmass liquid crystals are miscible and the resulting mixture exhibits mesophase (PDLCC). The photorefractive properties of the mesogenic composites are expected to be strongly dependent on the morphology. Figure 6.8 shows typical self-diffraction patterns for PDLC and PDLCC samples [23]. Judging from the value of the parameter Q 1.0, we have to deal with a thin grating case, e. g., a Raman–Nath diffraction for which the directions of the mth diffraction orders are given by θm = arcsin(mλ/) [21]. Since the diffraction is of the Raman– Nath type, a self-diffraction process was effective at certain values of dc voltage applied to the PDLC and PDLCC samples, and as a result, in a far field after the sample, the first- and higher-order diffraction spots appeared. The necessary applied dc voltage is strongly dependent on the morphology of the photorefractive mesogenic composites, and the higher dc field is necessary for the PDLC in comparison with the PDLCC. Higher-order diffraction was almost invisible in the PDLC sample, while higher-order diffraction was clearly visible in the PDLCC sample due to the larger refractive index change in the photorefractive PDLCC. The PDLC films strongly scatter the light under no electric field because of the mismatch between the refractive index of the liquid crystals and that of the PMMA binder. Applications of a dc electric field across the PDLC films make the director of the liquid crystalline droplets align parallel to the field. Since the ordinary refractive index of E7 is nearly matched with that of the PMMA binder, the films become transparent for the normally incident light. However, the scattering losses are relatively large for the diagonal beam incidence as shown in Figure 6.8(a). According to PDLC studies for display applications [24], p-polarized light can couple into the extraordinary refractive index of the liquid crystal in the aligned PDLC film. This coupling into the extraordinary refractive index, which is different from the polymer index, provides a refractive index mismatch that scatters
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
176
7:43
Hiroshi Ono, Akira Emoto, and Nobuhiro Kawatsuki
light. In the case of PDLCC samples, the scattering losses are negligibly small and the clear diffraction spots appear as shown in Figure 6.8(b) because the polymer and low-molar-mass liquid crystals are miscible without phase separation.
6.2.2 Degenerate Four-Wave Mixing in Photorefractive Mesogenic Composites Optical phase conjugation is a fascinating subject, with great promise for application to image distortion compensation, coherent image amplification, optical image filtering, and novel laser resonator design [25]. All optical devices in which the optical phase conjugation phenomenon plays an important role have already been demonstrated in various systems. Phase conjugation in the photorefractive mesogenic composites has been measured with the degenerate four-wave mixing (DFWM) configuration shown schematically in Figure 6.9. Photorefractive mesogenic composites used for DFWM experiments were based on a low-molar-mass nematic mixture, functionalized copolymer, and sensitizer (see Figure 6.4) [26, 27]. Figure 6.10 shows the absorption spectrum of the photorefractive mesogenic composite film. The copolymer and TNF form charge-transfer complexes, and the light in the visible region was absorbed. Experiments of optical phase conjugation were carried out using a frequencydoubled Nd-YAG laser of 532 nm or a He-Ne laser of 633 nm. As shown in Figure 6.10, the electronic transition of the photorefractive mesogenic composite is on-resonant with a wavelength of 532 nm and off-resonant with a wavelength of 633 nm. The output laser beam was divided into three beams that were directed onto the mesogenic composite possessing orientational photorefractive effects. Two of the three beams formed the counterpropagating pump fields E 1 , PBS1
PBS2
He-Ne laser
E2
Detector
E3
Sample PBS3
E4
E1
F I G U R E 6.9. Experimental setup for degenerate four-wave mixing with counterpropagating-pump geometry. E 1 and E 2 denote the forward and backward pump beams, respectively. E 4 represents the probe beam and E 3 the phase-conjugate signal beam.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
7:43
6. Photorefractive Mesogenic Composites for Applications to Image Processing 500
Absorption (/cm)
F I G U R E 6.10. Absorption spectra of the photorefractive mesogenic composite. The chemical components of the composite were presented in Figure 6.4. The photorefractive mesogenic composite was prepared by mixing the nematic mixture (E7), copolymer, and TNF (20:78:2 wt%). The thickness of the mesogenic composite was 50 μm [26].
177
400 300 532 nm 200 633 nm 100 0 400
500
600
700
800
Wavelength (nm)
E 2 , and another beam was used as the probe beam with electric field amplitude E 4 . Interaction of these beams in the photorefractive polymer composite leads to generation of the fourth beam of field amplitude E 3 , which is phase conjugate to the probe beam E 4 . The polarization directions of the three beams were independently controlled by three half-wave plates. Under the degenerate four-wave mixing configurations, beams 1, 2, 3, and 4 are of the same angular frequency ω E 1 and E 2 are taken to be the counterpropagating pump beams. E 4 is the probe beam and E 3 is the phase-conjugated wave as shown in Figure 6.9. In general, the interference between the beams gives rise to six sets of spatial intensity modulations in the photorefractive mesogenic composite, each with a different fringe spacing. Two sets, between E 1 and E 4 and between E 2 and E 3 , form transmission gratings, while the other four form reflection gratings. In the case of the photorefractive liquid crystals the grating period of the relection grating is shorter than the resolution limit, and the coupling equations including six sets of spatial intensity modulations can be further simplified by assuming that the phase-conjugated response is mostly dependent on transmission gratings. If only transmission gratings are dominant, we arrive at the following equation [18]: d exp ( + α2 )(r − r ) dr ≡ c E 1 (0)/J (r ), (6.5) E 3 = c E 1 (0) ) I (r 0 r where r = z/ cos θ, the z axis is perpendicular to the transmission grating vector, 2θ is the crossing angle between the beams E1 and E 3 , α is the absorption coefficient, I0 = 4j=1 I j , and c=
E 2 (d)E 4∗ (0) exp(−αd/2) I1 (0)/J (0) − 1
(6.6)
Taking the square of both sides of equation (6.6), one gets the intensity of the phase-conjugation beam. The phase-conjugate reflectance is defined as the intensity ratio of probe and phase-conjugate beams.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
178
7:43
Hiroshi Ono, Akira Emoto, and Nobuhiro Kawatsuki
Reflectance (%)
25 20 15 10 5 0 0.0
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 Applied dc field (V/μm)
0.5
F I G U R E 6.11. Phase-conjugate reflectance from the photorefractive mesogenic composite (see Figure 6.4) versus applied dc field. The frequency-doubled Nd-YAG laser (filled circles) or He-Ne laser (open circles) was used as the pump beam. The grating spacing was 3.0 μm. In the case of the experiments using the frequency-doubled Nd-YAG laser, beam powers were I1 = 6.5 mW, I2 = 13.1 mW, and I4 = 6.5 mW. In the case of experiments using the He-Ne laser, beam powers were I1 = 5.9 mW, I2 = 12.7 mW, and I4 = 6.0 mW. Beams 1 and 4 were of the same polarization state (s-polarization) and the polarization direction of beam 3 was perpendicular to that of the other two beams ( p-polarization) [26].
Figure 6.11 shows the typical dependence of the steady-state value of the phase conjugate reflectance (= I3 /I4 × 100) as a function of the electric dc field applied to the photorefractive mesogenic composite. The reflectance increased monotonically as the electric field increased and attained its maximum value of around 20%. A larger external electric field is a necessary condition for observation of the phase-conjugation signal generated by the He-Ne laser beam in comparison with that in the experiment using the frequency-doubled Nd-YAG pump beam. The applied electric field permits charge migration along the grating vector and improves the efficiency of the photocharge generation. We consider that the photocharges are efficiently generated using the frequency-doubled Nd-YAG pump beam because the absorption coefficient at the wavelength of the frequencydoubled Nd-YAG laser beam is larger than that at the wavelength of the He-Ne laser beam as shown in Figure 6.10. The refractive-index-modulation depth n 1 is dependent on the period of the grating . In order to check the influence of this effect on the magnitude of the reflectivity of the phase-conjugated mirror, we performed an experiment enabling us to control the period of the grating K I , which can be carried out by changing the 2θ angle between the E1 and E 4 beams. The phase-conjugate reflectance and the index-modulation depth estimated from the above-mentioned theory are plotted versus the grating period , which is shown in Figure 6.12. The superlinear increase in the index-modulation depth and phase-conjugate reflectance was observed with increasing grating spacing. Although the resolution of our photorefractive mesogenic composite is fairly improved in comparison with the photorefractive low-molar-mass liquid crystal without polymer, for small grating
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
7:43
6. Photorefractive Mesogenic Composites for Applications to Image Processing
Reflectance (%)
3.0 15
2.5 2.0
10
1.5 1.0
5
0.1 0.2 0.3 Grating pitch (mm)
0.5 0.0 0.4
Index modulation depth
(× 10−3) 3.5
20
0 0.0
179
F I G U R E 6.12. Phase-conjugate reflectance in percent and index-modulation depth versus grating spacing. The chemical components of the composite were presented in Figure 6.4. The photorefractive mesogenic composite was prepared by mixing the nematic mixture (E7), copolymer, and TNF (20:78:2 wt%). The thickness of the mesogenic composite was 50 μm. The frequency-doubled Nd-YAG laser was used as the pump beam. The applied electric field was 0.3 V/μm and beam powers were I1 = 6.5 mW, I2 = 13.1 mW, and I4 = 6.5 mW. Open and filled circles represent reflectance and index modulation depth, respectively [26].
spacings the index-modulation depth will be limited by elastic forces when the mesogenic molecules are reoriented. According to equation (6.6), the phase-conjugate reflectance is strongly dependent on both the spatial phase shift (φ) and the index-modulation depth (n 1 ). In Figures 6.13(a) and 6.13(b) the phase-conjugate reflectivities, which can be calculated from equation (6.6), are plotted versus the pump-beam intensity ratio. The experimental data described in Figure 6.13(a) were obtained when beams 1, 2, and 4 were of the same polarization state ( p-polarization), while those in Figure 6.13(b) were obtained when beams 1 and 4 were of the same polarization state (s-polarization) and the polarization direction of beam 2 was perpendicular to that of the other two beams. In the case of the p-polarization state, two-beam coupling between beams 1 and 4 was observed, while the two-beam coupling effects can be ignored when beams 1 and 4 are of the s-polarization state. In the case of the s-polarization state, one may assume that the response is local, and in the first approximation one may put φ = 0 because the two-beam coupling effects can be ignored. In the case of the p-polarization state, the phase-conjugate reflection must be calculated from equation (6.6) including the spatial phase shift obtained from the two-beam coupling experiments. According to equation (6.6), the dependence of phase-conjugate reflectivity on the pump ratio is a manifestation of the same phase that produced the directionality in two-wave mixing. Since the sign of the spatial phase shift is reversed by changing the direction of the applied dc electric field, the photorefractive media with negative and positive phase shift display an optimum pump ratio of over [filled circles in Figure 6.13(a)] and under unity [open circles in Figure 6.13(a)], respectively. In contrast, as shown in
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
180
7:43
Hiroshi Ono, Akira Emoto, and Nobuhiro Kawatsuki 20
Reflectance (%)
(a) 15
10
5
0 0.001 0.01
0.1
1
10
100 1000
3.0 (b) Reflectance (%)
2.5 2.0
F I G U R E 6.13. Phase-conjugate reflectance versus pump power ratio. The chemical components of the composite were presented in Figure 6.4. The photorefractive mesogenic composite was prepared by mixing the nematic mixture (E7), copolymer, and TNF (20:78:2 wt%). The thickness of the mesogenic composite was 50 μm. The probe-beam intensity was set to 5.0 mW. The applied dc field was set to 0.4 V/μm (filled circles) and −0.4 V/μm (open circles). (a) Beams 1, 2, and 4 were of the same polarization state ( p-polarization) and (b) beams 1 and 4 were of the same polarization state (s-polarization) and the polarization direction of beam 2 was perpendicular to that of the other two beams. The solid lines denote the theoretical fitting results [27].
1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 0.001 0.01 0.1 1 10 100 1000 Pump power ratio (I2 / I1)
Figure 6.13(b), in the case of s-polarization state, the photorefractive mesogenic composite displays an optimum pump ratio of around unity because the two-beam coupling effects can be ignored.
6.2.3 Real-Time Holography in Photorefractive Mesogenic Composites Real-time holographic gratings have drawn much attention in the past few years because of their potential application for parallel and real-time optical processing. Photorefractive mesogenic material is promising for real-time holographic applications and has been the subject of considerable interest in real-time holography because it presents high-sensitivity, high-diffraction efficiency and real-time capabilities. Real-time measurements of the diffraction efficiency of the transmission holograms were carried out using the system described in Figure 6.14. The holographic gratings were created by means of a frequency-doubled Nd-YAG laser with a
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
7:43
6. Photorefractive Mesogenic Composites for Applications to Image Processing
181
F I G U R E 6.14. Schematic of the experimental setup for real-time holographic recording and reading. λ/2: half-wave plate, BS: beam splitter, M1–M4: mirror, and ND: neutral density filter [28].
532-nm wavelength. The total intensity of the writing beams was varied between 1 and 7 mW and a beam ratio of 1/1. The fringe spacing was also varied between 2.2 and 2.8 μm. To enhance the generation efficiency of the photoinduced charges and their redistribution, a dc electric field was applied and the value was varied between 0 and 0.3 V/μm. The sample was tilted 60 degrees from the bisector of the two incident writing beams to provide a projection of the grating wave vector along the direction of the applied dc field. The diffracted beam intensity was monitored with a He-Ne laser with a 633-nm wavelength where our photorefractive PDLCCs (see Figure 6.4) scarcely absorb as shown in Figure 6.15. In order to obtain the intensity of the diffracted beam at each time, a photodiode detector was positioned in the Bragg diffraction direction, and a detector was connected to a digital oscilloscope and a personal computer detected the diffraction beam. The diffraction efficiency is defined as the intensity ratio of the diffracted beam and the incident beam. Figure 6.16 shows the diffraction efficiency versus applied dc fields (top) and writing power (bottom). The diffraction efficiency was increased as the applied dc voltage and TNF concentration were increased. The photoconductivity is increased as the TNF concentration is increased. Improvements in
F I G U R E 6.15. Absorption spectra of the photorefractive PDLCCs. The chemical components of the composite were presented in Figure 6.4. The TNF concentration was described in the figure. A frequency-doubled YAG laser (532 nm) was used as the hologram writing beam, and a He-Ne laser (633 nm) was used as the probe [28, 29].
Absorption (/cm)
500 400 300
523 nm
200
(c)
100
(b)
0 400
633 nm
(a) 500
600
Wavelength (nm)
700
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
182
7:43
Hiroshi Ono, Akira Emoto, and Nobuhiro Kawatsuki
1.0
35 30
Normalized eff iciency
Diffraction efficiency (%)
40
(c)
25 20 (b)
15 10
(a)
5 0 0.00
(c)
0.8 0.6
(a)
0.4 (b) 0.2 0.0
0.05
0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 Applied dc field (V/μm)
0.30
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
Writing power (mW/cm2)
F I G U R E 6.16. Hologram recording properties of photorefractive PDLCCs. The chemical components of the composite were presented in Figure 6.4. The concentration ratio by weight (polymer:E7) was 20:80 and TNF concentration was (a) 0.64, (b) 1.00, and (c) 2.00 wt%. The fringe spacing was 2.8 μm. Top: The diffraction efficiencies are plotted versus applied dc field. The writing beam power was 12 mW/cm2 . Bottom: The diffraction efficiencies are plotted versus writing beam power. The applied dc field was 0.3 V/μm [29].
photoconductivity are due to an increase in the quantum efficiency of mobile charge generation. The resultant improvement of the space-charge field may play a role in improving the diffraction efficiency. The sensitivity was improved by increasing the TNF concentration. The grating was generated by irradiating at total power (2.8 mW/cm2 ) of writing beams (1 mW for one writing beam in laser spot half-diameter of 4.8 mm), while maintaining a high grating efficiency of around 15%. These values give the nonlinear coefficient of 0.57 cm2 /W, which is a relatively large magnitude.
6.3 Applications to Image Processing 6.3.1 Image Amplification in Photorefractive Mesogenic Composites Optical image reconstruction, a type of intensity amplification of a twodimensional optical image, was demonstrated using a photorefractive PDLCC described in Figure 6.4. Figure 6.17 shows the experimental setup for reconstruction of a two-dimensional optical image from nonlocal gratings in the photorefractive mesogenic composite. A linearly polarized He-Ne laser beam (λ = 633 nm) was divided into two beams by a polarizing beam splitter (BS), one of the two beams was expanded, and an image was imprinted onto it by a transparent object (signal). This image was Fourier transformed by a lens, and the photorefractive mesogenic film was placed in the Fourier plane. The other beam (pump) was superposed on the same spot and interfered with the signal beam.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
7:43
6. Photorefractive Mesogenic Composites for Applications to Image Processing
183
F I G U R E 6.17. Schematic of the experimental setup for measuring the image reconstruction from nonlocal gratings in the photorefractive mesogenic composite. The signal and pump beams are p-polarized, where PD represents a photodiode, M1, M2, M3, and M4 mirrors, and BS a polarized beam splitter.
The electric fields of the two light waves can be written as E j = A j exp[i (ωt − k j · r)],
j = 1, 2,
(6.7)
where A1 and A2 are the wave amplitudes of the signal and pump beams, ω is the angular frequency, and k1 , k2 are the wave vectors. The gain coefficients depend on the beam intensity ratio m, and the dependence can be estimated by the experimental observation as shown in Figure 6.18. We now write A1 = I1 exp(−iψ1 ), (6.8) A2 = I2 exp(−iψ2 ), (6.9)
F I G U R E 6.18. Gain coefficients of the photorefractive mesogenic composite versus the intensity ratio (m) between the signal and pump beams. The chemical components of the composite were presented in Figure 6.4. The photorefractive mesogenic composite was prepared by mixing the nematic mixture (E7), copolymer, and TNF (20:79:1 wt%). The thickness of the mesogenic composite was 50 μm. The applied dc electric field was 0.2 V/μm.
Gain coefficients (1/cm)
140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0
0
50 100 150 200 250 300 m
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
184
7:43
Hiroshi Ono, Akira Emoto, and Nobuhiro Kawatsuki
where ψ1 and ψ2 are phases of the complex amplitudes A1 and A2 . By examining the two-beam coupled equations, these phases can be obtained as 1+m β ψ1 (d) − ψ1 (0) = − ln , (6.10) 1 + med 1+m β ψ2 (d) − ψ2 (0) = − ln , (6.11) 1 + me−d where
πn 1 cos φ. (6.12) λ cos θ The two-dimensional optical image was focused by a Fourier-transform lens with f = 30 cm and the signal beam was considered to have an electric field distribution given by [30]:
x 2 + yi2 1 w(xi , yi , f ) = exp ik f + i · F{u(x, y)}, (6.13) iλ f 2f β=
where u (x, y) is the electric field of the input optical image, and the Fourier transform of a complex function u of two independent variables x and y is represented here by F {u(x, y)}. The second coherent wavefront (pump beam) of known amplitude and phase is added to the signal wavefront described by equation (6.13) and the two wavefronts interfered with each other. The output image-intensity distribution is described by |v(X, Y )|2 : √ v(X, Y ) = F −1 I 2 + iψ2 (d) , (6.14) where the inverse Fourier transform of a function G is represented by F −1 (G). Figure 6.19 shows the comparison between experiments and numerical simulation results, and the experimentally measured image-intensity distributions are in good agreement with the theory.
6.3.2 Edge Enhancement of Optical Image In this section, we expolit the high-performance optical nonlinearity inherent in the photorefractive PDLCC (see Figure 6.4) to demonstrate and explain edge enhancement of a two-dimensional optical image. Figure 6.20 illustrates the the experimental setup for the edge enhancement of the optical image, combining Fourier transform holographic operation and the high-performance photorefractivity in the PDLCC. A laser-diode-pumped Nd:YAG second-harmonic-generating laser beam at λ = 532 nm was divided into two beams by a polarizing beam splitter and one of the two writing beams was expanded and an image was imprinted onto it by a transparent object (signal beam). This image was Fourier transformed by a lens and the photorefractive PDLCC film was placed in the Fourier plane. Another beam (reference beam) of the two writing beams was superposed on the same spot and interfered with the
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
7:43
6. Photorefractive Mesogenic Composites for Applications to Image Processing 6 (a)
5
Intensity (a.u.)
Intensity (a.u.)
6
185
4 3 2 1 0 0.0
5
(b)
4 3 2 1
0.5
1.0 1.5 X-axis [mm]
2.0
0 0.0
2.5
0.5
1.0 1.5 X-axis [mm]
2.0
2.5
F I G U R E 6.19. (a) Experimentally observed and (b) theoretically calculated reconstructed images from nonlocal gratings in the photorefractive mesogenic composite. Bold solid curves represent the input (signal) images and fine solid curves reconstruct images amplified by the pump beam. The intensity ratio (m) between the signal and pump beam was 50. The photorefractive mesogenic composite was prepared by mixing the nematic mixture (E7), copolymer, and TNF (20:79:1 wt%). The thickness of the mesogenic composite was 50 μm. The applied dc electric field was 0.2 V/μm.
signal beam. The grating constant of the interference light was controlled by the crossing angle of the writing beams and set to be around 2.5 μm. In general, the reconstructed image is a faithful replica of the original image only if the intensity of the signal beam is less than the intensity of the reference beam. If this condition is violated, edge enhancement can be produced in the reconstructed image because the largest index modulation will be produced Input image Lens Object
Sample
Reconstructed image
Mask Probe
Reference
F I G U R E 6.20. Experimental setup for nonlinear intensity filtering by a Fourier transform holographic configuration. To enhance the generation efficiency of the photoinduced charges and their redistribution, a dc electric field of 0.2 V/μm was applied. A laser-diode-pumped Nd:YAG second-harmonic-generating laser beam at λ = 532 nm was used as signal beam and the holographic optical image was reconstructed by a He-Ne laser with a 633-nm wavelength (reading beam) where our photorefractive PDLCCs scarcely absorb. The sample was tilted 45 degrees from the bisector of the two writing beams to provide a projection of the grating vector along the direction of the applied dc field. In this experiment, the signal and reference beams are linearly polarized parallel to each other and are s-polarized in order to prevent strong two-beam coupling. The reading beam is also linearly polarized orthogonally to the writing beams and is p-polarized.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
186
7:43
Hiroshi Ono, Akira Emoto, and Nobuhiro Kawatsuki
F I G U R E 6.21. Demonstration of the edge enhancement of two-dimensional optical images. In photograph (a), the intensity of the signal beam is 1/10 the intensity of the reference beam. In photograph (b), it is 20 times the intensity of the reference beam. The bright lines in the images are separated by approximately 0.5 mm [31].
when two optical fields of the same intensity interfere. When the intensity of the refernce beam is much larger than that of the signal beam, the central maximum of the Fourier transform has an intensity greater than the intensity of the reference beam and produces a localized grating with a poor diffraction efficiency. Toward the wings of the diffraction pattern, the intensity of the reference beam, and a highly effiecient grating is formed. The low spatial frequencies of the signal are attenuated while the high spatial frequencies are efficienctly reconstructed, thus giving rise to the edge enhancement in the image, as demostrated in Figure 6.21. Quantitative considerations were performed by means of Fourier transform holograms [31, 32]. Figure 6.22 contains a plot of the calculated and experimentally observed images with the object being a single slit. As shown in Figure 6.22, the enhancement of the edges of the two-dimensional optical images as the intensity ratio is increased and the experimental results are in good agreement with the theoretical expectation.
6.3.3 Spatial Frequency Selective Reconstruction of Optical Images In this section, we demostrate spatial frequency selective reconstruction of two-dimensional optical images using functionalized mesogenic composites possessing real-time holographic capabilities (see Figure 6.4). Figure 6.23 illustrates the experimental setup for spatial frequency selective reconstruction of the two-dimensional optical image, combining a Fourier transform holographic operation and photo-densities in the photorefractive mesogenic composite. The twodimensional optical image was Fourier transformed by a lens, and a part of the
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
7:43
6. Photorefractive Mesogenic Composites for Applications to Image Processing F I G U R E 6.22. (a) Theoretical and (b) experimentally observed plots of the intensity of the observed image of a single slit 3.0 mm wide when a real image of this object is focused in the photorefractive PDLCC by a 30-mm-focal-length lens. The ratio of the intensity of the signal beam to the intensity of the reference beam is described in the figure [31].
(a)
187
(b)
1/10
2/1
20/1
spatial frequency was brought into interference with the reference beam in the Raman–Nath regime. In order to clarify quantitatively the mechanism of spatial frequency selective reconstruction using photorefractive mesogenic materials, we consider the image plane when the object is a single square as shown in Figure 6.24(a). Under our experimental conditions, the input image is Fourier-transformed by a lens as shown in Figures 6.24(b) (experiment) and 24(c) (calculation). The observed image was in good agreement with the theoretical image. In the Raman-Nath thingrating regime, multiple diffraction orders are generated. Two-beam interference between the Fourier-transformed two-dimensional optical image and the reference PBS
M1
He-Ne laser λ/2
BE
+1
Mask2
BE
−1
L1 M3 Mask1
Sample
L2
M2
F I G U R E 6.23. Schematic of the experimental setup for spatial frequency selective reconstruction using photorefractive mesgenic materials. The Fourier transform operation is performed in the Raman–Nath diffraction regime and the spatial frequency selective reconstruction appears in the self-diffraction beams.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
188
7:43
Hiroshi Ono, Akira Emoto, and Nobuhiro Kawatsuki
F I G U R E 6.24. (a) Photograph of test input image, (b) Fourier-transformed image generated by a lens (experiment), and (c) calculated image. Three patterns A, B, and C denote the three kinds of reference beam patterns used in this study.
beam provides holographic gratings. In the back focal plane of the imaging lens, intensity distributions of the spatial frequencies of the image appear, since the Fourier spectrum and the reconstructed images depend on the intensity distribution of the reference beam. Thus the image with favored spatial frequency can be reconstructed by controlling the intensity distribution of the reference beam, and these processes can be applied to optical two-dimensional image processing for the spatial frequency selective reconstruction. As a first example of the frequency selective reconstruction, three kinds of reference beam with different intensity distribution patterns are used for the demostration; the intensity of the signal beam is almost equal to that of the reference beam at the focal plane. The reference beam with pattern A or B is superposed onto the Fourier-transformed image, with high spatial frequencies in the horizontal and vertical directions of the input optical image, respectively, while the reference beam of pattern C is overlapped with the signal image with low spatial frequencies. Figure 6.25 contains a picture of the experimentally observed and calculated images with the object being a single square as shown in Figure 6.4. The experimentally observed images [Figure 6.25(a)] were almost in good agreement with the calculated images [Figure 6.25(b)]. As another case of spatial frequency selective reconstruction using the photorefractive mesogenic composite, we demonstrated spatial frequency selective reconstruction by controlling the intensity of the reference beam. In this case, the diameter of the reference beam was much larger than that of the Fouriertransformed signal beam and assumed to be large enough for the reference beam profile to be homogeneous in comparison with the signal beam profile. Since a highly efficient grating is formed when the intensity of the signal beam is comparable to that of the reference beam, spatial frequency selective reconstruction is expected to be achieved by simply controlling the reference beam intensity, although the cylindrical symmetry is necessary for the spatial frequency of the reconstructed image. Figure 6.26 contains a two-dimensional plot of the experimentally observed and calculated images with the object being a single square on varying the intensity ratio. The observed images are in good agreement with the theoretical expectation.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
7:43
6. Photorefractive Mesogenic Composites for Applications to Image Processing F I G U R E 6.25. Comparison of (a) experimentally observed images and (b) numerical simulation results. Patterns A, B, and C are in accordance with the images obtained from three reference beam patterns [33].
F I G U R E 6.26. Comparison of (a) experimentally observed images and (b) numerical simulation results as a function of the intensity ratio between the signal and reference beams. The beam intensity ratio was set to be (1) 0.470, (2) 0.017, and (3) 0.003 [33].
189
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
190
7:43
Hiroshi Ono, Akira Emoto, and Nobuhiro Kawatsuki
References 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18.
19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29.
E.V. Rudenko and A.V. Sukhov: JETP Lett. 59, 143 (1994). E.V. Rudenko and A.V. Sukhov: JETP 78, 875 (1994). L.C. Khoo, H. Li, and Y. Liang: Opt. Lett. 19, 1723 (1994). W.E. Moerner and S.M. Silence: Chem. Rev. 94, 127 (1994). S.J. Zilker: Chemphyschem, 1, 72 (2000). G.P. Wiederrecht: Annu. Rev. Mater. Res. 31, 139 (2001). H. Ono and N. Kawatsuki: Opt. Lett. 22, 1144 (1997). A. Golemme, B.L. Volodin, B. Kippelen, and N. Peyghambarian: Opt. Lett. 22, 1226 (1997). G.P. Wiederrecht and M.R. Wasielewski: J. Am. Chem. Soc. 120, 3231 (1998). H. Ono, I. Saito, and N. Kawatsuki: Appl. Phys. Lett. 72, 1942 (1998). H. Ono, T. Kawamura, N. Kawatsuki, H. Norisada, and T. Yamamoto: Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 38, L1258 (1999). Y. Bai, X. Chen, X. Wan, Q. Zhou, H. Li, B. Zhang, and Q. Gong: Appl. Phys. B 73, 35 (2001). Y. Bai, X. Chen, X. Wan, Q. Zhou, H. Li, B. Zhang, and Q. Gong: Appl. Phys. Lett. 80, 10 (2002). N. Kamania, S. Putilin, and D. Stasel’ko: Synth. Met. 127, 129 (2002). H. Ono, H. Shimokawa, A. Emoto, and N. Kawatsuki: J. Appl. Phys. 94, 23 (2003). H. Ono, T. Kawamura, N.M. Frias, K. Kitamura, N. Kawatsuki, H. Norisada, and T. Yamamoto: J. Appl. Phys. 88, 3853 (2000). H. Ono, T. Kawamura, N.M. Frias, K. Kitamura, N. Kawatsuki, and H. Norisada: Adv. Mater. 12, 143 (2000). J. Feinberg and K.R. MacDonald: Phase-conjugate mirrors and resonators with photorefractive materials, in: Photorefractive Materials and Their Applications II, ed. by P. G¨unter and J.-P. Huignard (Springer 1988) pp. 151–198. P. Yeh: Photorefractive effects, in: Introduction to Photorefractive Nonlinear Optics (John Wiley & Sons, Inc. New York 1993) pp. 82–117. H. Kogelnik: Bell Syst. Tech. J. 48, 2909 (1969). P. Yeh: Wave propagation in periodic media, in: Introduction to Photorefractive Nonlinear Optics (John Wiley & Sons, Inc. New York 1993) pp. 118–182. H. Ono and N. Kawatsuki: J. Nonlinear Opt. Phys. & Mater. 8, 329 (1999). H. Ono, H. Shimokawa, A. Emoto, and N. Kawatsuki: J. Appl. Phys. 94, 23 (2003). P.S. Drzaic: Electro-optical effects, in: Liquid Crystal Dispersions (World Scientific, Singapore 1995) pp. 183–352. R. Fisher: Optical Phase Conjugation (Academic Press, Inc., London 1983). H. Ono, K. Kitamura, N. Kawatsuki, and H. Norisada: Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 40, 1328 (2001). H. Ono, K. Kitamura, and N. Kawatsuki: Liq. Cryst. 29, 1339 (2002). H. Ono, T. Kawamura, N.M. Frias, K. Kitamura, N. Kawatsuki, H. Norisada, and T. Yamamoto: J. Appl. Phys. 88, 3853 (2000). H. Ono, T. Kawamura, N.M. Frias, K. Kitamura, N. Kawatsuki, H. Norisada, and T. Yamamoto: Adv. Mater. 12, 143 (2000).
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 October 27, 2006
7:43
6. Photorefractive Mesogenic Composites for Applications to Image Processing
191
30. J.W. Goodman: Fourier transforming and imaging properties of lenses, in: Introduction to Fourier Optics (McGraw-Hill, Inc 1968) pp. 77–100. 31. H. Ono, T. Kawamura, N. Kawatsuki and H. Norisada: Appl. Phys. Lett. 79, 895 (2001). 32. P. Hariharan: Wavefront reconstruction, in: Optical Holography (Cambridge University Press, 1996) pp. 11–24. 33. A. Emoto, H. Ono, and N. Kawatsuki: Liq. Cryst. 30, 1201 (2003).
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 September 26, 2006
17:13
7 Solid-State Lasers with a Photorefractive PhaseConjugate Mirror T. Omatsu,1 M.J. Damzen,2 A. Minassian2 and K. Kuroda3 1
Department of Information and Image Sciences, Chiba University, 1-33, Yayoi-cho, Inage-ku, Chiba 263-8522, Japan 2 The Blackett Laboratory, Imperial College, Prince Consort Rd., London SW7 2BW, UK 3 Institute of Industrial Science, University of Tokyo, 4-6-1, Komaba, Meguro-ku, Tokyo, 153-8505, Japan
7.1 Introduction The maintenance of high-spatial-quality radiation in laser devices as they are scaled to high powers is important for many practical applications, including laser material processing, remote sensing, and optical pumping. However, it is increasingly difficult to maintain a fundamental TEM00 high-spatial-quality mode, and a key problem in solid-state lasers is due to the onset of thermally induced refractive-index distortions in the laser amplifier. This is caused by the intensive inversion mechanism that heats the laser medium. Similarly, in high-power semiconductor diode lasers, the beam quality is severely degraded since to achieve high power (e.g., multiwatt), the emitters of the device need to be scaled to large dimensions (broad-stripe emitter) or multiple arrays of emitters must be used. The broad-stripe emitter leads to highly multimode operation and the emitter arrays are further degraded since the output radiation is spatially incoherent. Phase conjugation provides a general technique for the maintenance of high spatial quality. It is interesting to note that soon after the original demonstration of phase conjugation by stimulated Brillouin scattering in 1972 [1], the first application in which phase conjugation was applied was correction of the distortions in a laser amplifier. This was achieved by double-passing the phase-conjugate return back through the distorting amplifier to produce a beam with aberration-corrected wavefront [2]. The resultant laser output radiation was thereby intensified by received two-pass amplification but without degradation in spatial quality. Since this early demonstration much effort has been applied to the application of phase conjugation to laser operation. Many mechanisms have been investigated for phase conjugation including stimulated Brillouin scattering [3], four-wave mixing in a thermal grating media [4] and in resonant amplifier media [5, 6], and via photorefraction [7, 8, 9].
193
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 September 26, 2006
194
17:13
T. Omatsu, M.J. Damzen, A. Minassian and K. Kuroda laser amplifier
(a)
(b)
input high- double-pass quality beam aberrationcorrected beam output coupling beam laser mirror
PCM
aberrated beam
PC beam
aberration-free fundamental mode beam splitting/ (c) combining element
coherently combined output beam multichannel amplifier
F I G U R E 7.1. Key architectures in which phase conjugate mirror (PCM) is applied to laser operation: (a) double-phase amplifier with aberration correction; (b) phase-conjugate laser resonator in which one of the laser cavity mirrors is a PCM; and (c) PCM is used to coherently combine the radiation from a multichannel amplifier.
This chapter describes aspects of phase conjugation due to the photorefractive mechanism applied to laser systems and presents experimental results in diode lasers and continuous-wave diode-pumped solid-state lasers. Figure 7.1 illustrates some of the key architectures in which phase conjugation can be applied to laser operation. Figure 7.1a shows the case of a double-pass amplifier with aberration correction, Figure 7.1b shows the case of a phase-conjugate laser resonator in which one of the laser cavity mirrors is a phase-conjugate mirror (PCM), and Figure 7.1c shows where the phase-conjugate mirror is used to coherently combine the radiation from a multichannel amplifier. The latter case of a multielement amplifier can also be related to the case of a multiple emitter semiconductor diode array with phase-conjugate feedback. Results will be described in this chapter of photorefractive phase-conjugate geometries applied to double-pass amplifiers, laser oscillators, and multielement diode arrays.
7.2 Optical Phase Conjugation for Solid-State Lasers Distortion in a high-power solid-state laser is produced by the intense pumping mechanism producing the inversion in the amplifying medium. In addition to the
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 September 26, 2006
17:13
7. Solid-State Lasers with a Photorefractive Phase-Conjugate Mirror
195
phase distortion produced by thermally induced refractive changes, a significant stress-induced birefringence is produced. In a rod geometry, the principal axes of the birefringence follow the cylindrical geometry of the rod and consist of radial and circumferential components. Radiation passing through the rod experiences phase retardation by an amount dependent on the spatial position in the rod. A linearly polarized input beam will be amplified and emerge as a depolarized beam. The latter effect of depolarization is most pronounced in laser crystals with isotropic refractive index (e.g., Nd:YAG), but by using laser crystals with strong naturally birefringent (e.g., Nd:YVO4 ) the depolarization effects can be largely removed. The thermally induced refractive index change in a diode end-pumped geometry leads to a thermal lensing with dioptic power (m−1 ) given by [10] ηh · dn /dT Pa 1 = , f 2κ πω2
(7.1)
where f is the focal length of the thermal lens, Pa is the absorbed inversion pump power, ω is the pump beam radius, ηh is the fraction of the pump power converted to internal heat, dn/dT is the temperature coefficient of the refractive index, and κ is the thermal conductivity. It can be seen that the thermal lensing effect increases with pump power and its strength at any given pump power is increased for laser materials with high thermal coefficient of refractive index and low thermal conductivity. For example, with diode pumping at 808 nm in a neodymium laser operating at 1064 nm, the photon defect leads to a heating efficiency of ηh = 24%. The actual heat generating efficiency may be considerably higher than this for intense pumping due to additional up-conversion effects. For Nd:YAG the thermal conductivity is 13 Wm−1 K−1 and the thermal coefficient is 7.3 × 10−6 K−1 [10], while the equivalent values for Nd:YVO4 are 5 Wm−1 K−1 and 3.0 × 10−6 , respectively. Due to the high absorption at the diode wavelength, Nd:YVO4 tends to have high inversion density and exhibits relatively high up-conversion effects [11]. Strictly, the approximation of the thermal lens theory assumes quadratic distribution of the temperature and refractive index, and this occurs at the center region of the pumping. Near the edges of the pump region the refractive index distribution can be more complex, leading to strong aberration effects for highly pumped laser crystals. When used in a laser resonator, the laser amplifier’s thermally induced distortions lead to changes in the cavity stability due to the pump-dependent thermal lens, and the distortions lead to reduction in beam spatial quality. The ISO standard for quantifying beam quality is the M2 beam propagation parameter, which is closely related to the number of times diffraction-limited that compares the divergence of the radiation to a perfect Gaussian distribution. In lamp-pumped Nd:YAG, the thermal effects become significant at the 10 W optical output level, and above 20 W or more the spatial quality is degraded such that increasing output power is at the expense of increasing M2 spatial factor. For lamp-pumped systems the electrical efficiency of the laser is typically ≈ 1%, corresponding to kilowatt pump powers for optical power ≈ 10 w. Diode-pumped
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 September 26, 2006
196
17:13
T. Omatsu, M.J. Damzen, A. Minassian and K. Kuroda
solid-state lasers are of considerable interest due to the a significant increase in the laser efficiency. This arises due to a number of factors including the high efficiency of the diode laser but more particularly due to the ability to precisely match its spectral output to an absorption line in the solid-state lasing species, leading to a nearly 100% conversion of pump photons to optical inversion of the laser transition. The photon energy defect between the diode pump and the laser wavelengths can also be much smaller than in the lamp-pumped case, and this results in a lower heating fraction in the laser amplifier. Despite the lower heat input, the diode-pumping geometries employed usually involve small volumes that are intensively pumped and lead to thermally induced lensing that can be even higher than that of lamp-pumped systems. Hence, in end-diode-pumped neodymium lasers, while these systems have much higher efficiency, the influence of thermal lensing causes difficulties due to short focal length and beam-quality reduction at optical output powers near ≈10 W, which is comparable to lamppumped systems. In semiconductor diode lasers, single spatial mode operation can be typically achieved up to 100 mW. For edge-emitting diodes the emitter dimensions may be 1 micron by 3 microns for single-mode operation. The divergence angle (full width at high maximum) of the radiation is ≈40◦ by 10◦ with the high divergence (fast axis) corresponding to the small 1-micron emitter dimension and the smaller divergence (slow axis) due to the wider stripe dimension. The power limitation is primarily due to facet damage due to the very high intensity associated with small emitter size. To obtain higher powers, a broad-stripe geometry is used with stripe dimension up to 500 microns. The output power in the broad stripe can be several watts, but the spatial quality in the slow axis is highly multimode, with M2 ≈ 50 in the slow-axis dimension. Highe-output-power diodes use a line array of broad stripes to form a diode bar with overall emitter width of 10 mm. Output powers of diode bars now exceed 60 W but have M2 ≈ 1000, since the individual emitters are incoherent. Higher powers can be obtained by stacking diode bars to allow output powers exceeding one kilowatt but with high M2 in the fast-axis dimension. High-power-diode lasers have spectral bandwidths of typically 2–3 nm. For solid-state lasers, the wavefront distortion and lensing effects imposed on a wavefront propagating through the inverted laser amplifier may be unraveled by the photorefractive PCM. If the incident beam is a high-quality TEM00 spatially Gaussian mode, this allows the double pass to recover the beam quality. For a phase-conjugate laser, the PCM can recover and maintain the beam quality on each round trip of the resonator. The fundamental Gaussian mode with a uni-phase waist at the plane output cavity mirror will be the self-consistent spatial distribution with minimum diffraction loss. For a perfect PCM, all cavity configurations will be inherently stable with the round-trip ABCD matrix of the cavity being the unit matrix. For semiconductor diode lasers, much investigation has centered on the use of phase-conjugate feedback into the diode amplifier for coherent control of its spatial form and for spectral-line-width narrowing. Interesting self-frequency scanning effects have been observed in early investigations using a self-pumped photorefractive PCM.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 September 26, 2006
17:13
7. Solid-State Lasers with a Photorefractive Phase-Conjugate Mirror
197
To ensure that the photorefractive phase conjugator operates effectively for laser systems demands that a self-pumped phase-conjugation scheme be utilized (e.g., corner pumped or ring-pumped). The photorefractive material must also have good sensitivity at the laser wavelength and be able to achieve high efficiency (high reflectivity) and ideally fast response time. The photorefractive crystal, barium titanate (BaTiO3 ), has among the highest nonlinearity and displays very efficient self-pumped operation, but its highest sensitivity is in the visible part of the spectrum. Solid-state lasers and high-power semiconductor diode lasers operate predominantly in the near-infrared region. By doping barium titanate with rhodium the photorefractive sensitivity of this material is extended out to longer wavelengths and most significantly to the important wavelength region near 1064 nm, where the main lasing transition of neodymium-doped solid-state lasers occurs. The slow response of the photorefractive effect is a further issue. The most efficient crystals such as barium titanate are among the slowest in their response, and due to decreasing absorption and sensitivity at long wavelengths this can limit applicability in some real-world domains. Since the photorefractive response is intensity-dependent, the operation in high-power laser systems allows improvement in response speed. Ultimately, since the mechanism of photorefraction requires absorption of the radiation for charge excitation and transport, the photorefractive material may itself be excessively heated and cause difficulties unless it is adequately cooled. Despite this issue, demonstrations of high-power solid-state laser operation have been made using photorefractive self-pumped PCM with a low absorption material at the laser wavelength 1064 nm.
7.3 Phase-Conjugate Diode-Pumped Nd:YVO4 Laser Amplifiers Most demonstrations in solid-state lasers have been based on a master-oscillatorpower amplifier (MOPA) scheme with two (or four) passes of a Nd:YAG amplifier with either flashlamp-pumping or quasi-CW diode pumping. Nd3+ -doped YVO4 is a promising laser material for high-average-power diode-pumped operation because it exhibits large stimulated emission cross-section as well as large absorption at laser diode frequency in comparison with Nd:YAG [12, 13, 14]. These factors combine to make Nd:YVO4 suitable for diode-pumping. However, its poor thermal properties such as low thermal conductivity make the power scaling difficult to achieve. Previous reports have presented that the Nd:YVO4 exhibits strong thermal lensing and aberration due to the quantum defect and nonradiative decay including up-conversion excitation. One solution to correct these thermal effects is application of photorefractive phase conjugation to the Nd:YVO4 laser amplifiers. In recent years, Omatsu et al. have demonstrated a multiwatt CW neardiffraction-limited output from a side-pumped Nd:YVO4 double-pass amplifier with a ring self-pumped Rh:BaTiO3 PCM in an external loop cavity geometry
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 September 26, 2006
198
17:13
T. Omatsu, M.J. Damzen, A. Minassian and K. Kuroda F I G U R E 7.2. Schematic diagram of a double-pass amplifier.
Amplifier g(z) Ps (0) Ppc (0) z=0
z = L RPs (L) = Ppc (L)
[15]. Furthermore, they extended the phase-conjugate double-pass amplifier to generate 7.4-watt diffraction-limited picosecond pulses [16, 17].
7.3.1 Theory 7.3.1.1 Numerical Simulation of Output Power from the Amplifier
The geometry of the double-pass amplifier is shown schematically in Figure 7.2. A signal beam S travels in the amplifier along the z-axis. The phase conjugate (PC) is produced by the reflection of the amplified signal beam on the right-hand end (Z = L) of the amplifier. The reflectivity of the PCM is R. The signal and phase-conjugate beams experience saturated gain, which is an extension of the steady-state model given by [18], g(z) =
g0 , 1 + (PS (z) + PPC (z)) /(A · Is )
(7.2)
where g0 is the small signal gain, Isat is the saturation intensity, A is the crosssection of the signal and phase-conjugate beams, and Ps and PPC are the powers of the signal and phase-conjugate beams, respectively. A transversely diode-pumped Nd:YVO4 amplifier initially proposed by Alcock et al. has an elliptical gain volume. Recent operation of this scheme with continuous-wave diode-pumping has shown that it exhibits a high small-signal gain exp(g0 L) of typically ≈10, 000[19]. By substituting Is = 1 kW/cm2 , A = 0.2 mm × 1.0 mm, and g0 L = 9.2, equation (8.2) was numerically solved to yield the output power Pout = PPC (0) as a function of the signal input power at various R. Figure 7.3 shows the numerically simulated output power as a function of the incident signal power at various values of R. The threshold incident power for efficient output is less than 5 mW, because of the high gain of the amplifier. Above the threshold, the output power is ultimately limited by the signal beam saturating the amplifier itself. As the reflectivity is increased, the output power increases. The phase-conjugate reflectivity required for obtaining > 6 W is approximately 20%. Above a phase conjugate reflectivity of 30%, the output power is limited to the saturation level. 7.3.1.2 Photorefractive Phase-Conjugate Reflectivity
A photorefractive ring-PCM based on a BaTiO3 crystal allows higher reflectivity and faster temporal response in comparison with a total internal reflection
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 September 26, 2006
17:13
7. Solid-State Lasers with a Photorefractive Phase-Conjugate Mirror
R=0.6 R=0.5 R=0.4 R=0.3
Output Power (W)
8 6
199
R=0.2 R=0.1
4
R=0.05 R=0.01
2 0
0
50 100 Input Power (mW)
150
F I G U R E 7.3. Output power from a double-pass amplifier as a function of input power at various values of R.
geometry (TIR- or CAT-PCM). Thus, the ring-PCM is a more promising candidate to be applied to a laser amplifier. Reflectivity in the ring-PCM can be numerically simulated on the basis of coupled mode equations given by [20], d A1 dz d A2 dz d A3 dz d A4 dz
1 (A1 A∗2 + A3 A∗4 )A2 =− γ , 2 I0 1 (A∗ A2 + A∗3 A4 )A1 = γ 1 , 2 I0 1 (A1 A∗2 + A3 A∗4 )A2 = γ , 2 I0 1 (A∗ A2 + A∗3 A4 )A3 =− γ 1 , 2 I0
(7.3) (7.4) (7.5) (7.6)
where A1 , A2 , A3 , A4 are the complex amplitudes of the probe, forward-pump, backward-pump, and phase-conjugate waves, γ is the photorefractive two-wave mixing gain, and I0 is the total averaged light intensity, respectively. In the case of the ring-PCM, the boundary conditions can be given by A1 (L) = r A3 (L), A4 (L) = r A2 (L), A2 (0) = 0, A4 (0) 2 , RPCM = A (0)
(7.7) (7.8) (7.9) (7.10)
1
where r is the product of the mirror reflection complex coefficient, L is the crystal length, and RPCM is the phase-conjugate reflectivity, respectively. These equations can be solved to yield phase-conjugate reflectivity RPCM at a given mirror reflectivity parameter |r |2 in the external loop cavity. Figure 7.4 shows theoretical plots of phase-conjugate reflectivity at various |r |2 . The threshold gain product
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 September 26, 2006
200
T. Omatsu, M.J. Damzen, A. Minassian and K. Kuroda
1 PC Reflectivity
17:13
|r|2=1
F I G U R E 7.4. Simulated phaseconjugate reflectivity of the ringPCM as a function of two-wavemixing gain.
|r|2=0.9 |r|2=0.8
0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0
2
4 κL
6
8
g0 L for obtaining a value of RPCM of higher than 20% is estimated to be ≈ 2.4 at |r |2 = 0.8. 7.3.1.3 Wavelength Selectivity of a Photorefractive Phase-Conjugate Mirror
An undesirable spectral narrowing phenomenon is frequently observed in laser systems with a photorefractive PCM. This phenomenon reflects the finite twowave-mixing gain-band of refractive index gratings formed in the photorefractive PCM. According to the conventional coupled-mode theory and band-transport model, the two-wave-mixing gain-band of refractive index gratings formed in the PCM is given by [20] λ = (2κ 2 n/π) cos θb , K , κ∝ 2 K + K D2
(7.11) (7.12)
where κ is the two-wave mixing gain coefficient of the BaTiO3 crystal, n is the refractive index of the crystal, θb is Bragg’s angle of the refractive grating, is the grating period, K is the wave-number of the refractive-index grating, and K D is Debye’s wave-number, respectively. These show that the gain-band depends strongly on the grating period. The ring-PCM geometry is preferable in obtaining a broader two-wave-mixing gain-band, because it can prevent the formation of reflection and 2k gratings with the grating period shorter than the laser wavelength.
7.3.2 Experiments 7.3.2.1 CW regime
A schematic diagram of the diode-pumped Nd:YVO4 double-pass amplifier with the ring-PCM is shown in Figure 7.5. The amplifier used is a transversely diodepumped 1.1 at% a-cut Nd:YVO4 slab with a bounce geometry. The amplifier exhibits typically a single-pass gain of > 10, 000. The Nd:YVO4 slab had dimensions
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 September 26, 2006
17:13
7. Solid-State Lasers with a Photorefractive Phase-Conjugate Mirror
201
F I G U R E 7.5. Schematic diagram of CW Nd:YVO4 amplifier with PCM.
of 20 mm × 5 mm × 1 mm. The end surfaces of the crystal were AR-coated for 1064 nm and cut at 2◦ relative to the normal of the pump face to suppress self-lasing within the crystal. The crystal, wrapped in indium foils, was sandwiched between two aluminum blocks, providing thermal conduction through the top and bottom faces. The temperature of the blocks was maintained at ≈ 10◦ C using a water recirculating chiller. The pump diode is a CW single-bar diode array with fast axis collimator and line-focused by a cylindrical lens ( f = 12.7 mm) onto the Nd:YVO4 crystal. The polarization of pump diode was parallel with the c-axis of the Nd:YVO4 crystal, yielding maximum pump absorption (α ≈ 30 cm−1 ). Owing to the strong absorption, 90% of the pump power is absorbed in a depth of 0.7 mm. The focal length of the thermal lens in the Nd:YVO4 due to quantum-defect heating was estimated to be < 0.1 m under maximum pumping on the basis of the heat diffusion equation [21]. A commercial Nd:YVO4 laser with 100 mW of diffraction-limited and singlelongitudinal mode output was used as the signal laser. The signal laser beam is collimated to a φ1 mm spot, and is directed toward the amplifier by mirror M2 with 14% reflection for 1064 nm. The polarization of the signal beam was rotated by a half-wave plate (HWP1 ) to be parallel to the c-axis of the Nd:YVO4 crystal, thereby yielding maximum gain. An optical isolator is placed between the signal laser and the amplifier in order to prevent feedback. The signal laser beam is line-focused in the vertical direction by a cylindrical lens, CL1 , with a focal length of 100 mm to form an ellipsoidal spot in the amplifier with dimensions of ≈ 0.2 × 1 mm2 , so that the injected signal beam can overlap sufficiently well with the elliptical gain volume. The amplified signal beam, emerging from the amplifier, is recollimated by another cylindrical lens, CL2 , with a focal length of 100 mm. The amplified signal beam is directed toward a 45◦ -cut BaTiO3 crystal with a 3200-ppm Rh doping by two turning mirrors, M3 and M4 , with high reflectivity for 1064 nm. The signal beam is relayed to be a 3–4-mm spot onto the BaTiO3 crystal by a spherical lens L1 . The maximum signal intensity on the crystal was ≈ 25 W/cm2 . A half-wave plate HWP2 makes
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 September 26, 2006
202
17:13
T. Omatsu, M.J. Damzen, A. Minassian and K. Kuroda
the polarization of the signal beam to lie in an extra ordinary plane of the BaTiO3 crystal, yielding maximum two-beam coupling gain. The BaTiO3 crystal measures 10 mm × 9 mm × 2 mm with the entrance and exit surfaces AR-coated for 1 μm. A two-wave-mixing gain of > 15 cm−1 was obtained. The photorefractive crystal is formed into a ring PCM by two mirrors (M5 , M6 ) and two spherical lenses. In the external loop, two spherical lenses ( f = 200 mm) form 4 f -relay-imaging optics, such that the crystal location coincides with the conjugate points of the imaging optics. The coherence length of the signal laser is longer than the external loop length (> 80 cm), leading to formation of reflection gratings that decrease and fluctuate the phase-conjugate reflectivity. The formation of reflection gratings is prevented by the vibration of the M6 mirror driven by an attached stepping motor with a vibration frequency of 5–10 Hz [22]. With this system, the reflectivity of the ring PCM is ≈ 40%, which is consistent with the theoretical value. Figure 7.6 shows the single-pass gain of the amplifier as a function of pump diode power with signal power of 6 mW. At a maximum pumping power of 23.4 W, the amplified signal power was 2.8 W, corresponding to a single-pass gain of 470. The experimental output power of a double-pass amplifier with the ring-PCM is shown in Figure 7.7. The output power increased as a function of the pump diode power, and reached up to 7.8 W at the pump power of 23.4 W. There is good agreement between experimental output power and theoretical output power. Finally, a double-pass gain of as high as 1300 and an optical extraction efficiency of as much as 33% were obtained. In order to compare the system with a conventional double-pass amplifier, the PCM was replaced by a conventional high-reflectivity plane mirror. Open circles in Figure 7.7 show the experimental plots of output of the double-pass amplifier with the conventional mirror. When the pump diode power was comparatively low, the output power was not significantly different from that of the double-pass amplifier with the PCM. When the pump power was 23.4 W, the output power was limited to 75% of that of the amplifier with the PCM. When the pump diode power is high, strong thermal lensing and distortions of the amplifier aberrate the amplified signal wavefront. And thus, the use of the 103
Gain
102
101
100
0
10 20 LD Power (W)
F I G U R E 7.6. Experimental plots of single-pass gain in a CW Nd:YVO4 amplifier.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 September 26, 2006
17:13
Double-pass Amplifier Output (W)
7. Solid-State Lasers with a Photorefractive Phase-Conjugate Mirror
8
PCM Conventional Mirror
203
F I G U R E 7.7. Experimental output power from a CW Nd:YVO4 double-pass amplifier with PCM.
6 4 2 0
0
10 20 LD Power (W)
conventional mirror enhances the distortion of the reinjected signal wavefront. Consequently, spatial overlapping between the reinjected signal beam and active region is reduced, whereas the PCM, having a potential to compensate thermal distortion, can allow much more efficient spatial overlapping between the reinjected signal and pumped regions. Therefore, highly efficient output from the double-pass amplifier with the PCM was obtained. To investigate the potential of phase correction in this system, the spatial form of the double-pass amplified beam was measured. The experimental far-field spatial patterns of the amplified signal beam are shown in Figure 7.8. The original signal beam had a near-perfect Gaussian profile, as shown in Figures 7.8(a). Figures 7.8(b) and (c) illustrate the output beam patterns in the double-pass amplifier with the PCM and conventional mirror, respectively. Though the beam profile of the output of the double-pass amplifier with the PCM was fatter along the vertical axis than the original one, the profile along the horizontal axis was a perfect diffractionlimited one. On the other hand, the output with the conventional mirror, instead of PCM, was deeply modulated and showed strong astigmatism. These demonstrate that the double-pass amplifier with the PCM has a good potential for correction of thermal distortion inside the amplifier. Further improvement in the quality of correction of astigmatism in the amplified signal beam has been shown to be achieved by addition of a Dove prism in the loop producing a 90◦ rotation of the beam [23]. Figure 7.9 shows the time evolution of output power of the double-pass amplifier with the PCM at the beginning of buildup. After several seconds (less than 10 seconds) following the amplifier being turned on, the phase-conjugate reflectivity grows to reach a steady-state level. 7.3.2.2 Picosecond Regime
High-average-power picosecond diode-pumped solid-state lasers have received considerable attention in many fields. Nd:YVO4 , which exhibits a broad emission band (≈ 1 nm), is a promising picosecond laser material. To date, Couderc et al. have demonstrated 650-mW and 2.8-ps output from a passive mode-locked diodepumped Nd:YVO4 laser based on a second-order nonlinear process [24].
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 September 26, 2006
204
17:13
T. Omatsu, M.J. Damzen, A. Minassian and K. Kuroda
F I G U R E 7.8. Beam profiles of (a) the oreginal signal, (b) the output of the double-pass amplifier with the PCM, and (c) the output of the double-pass amplifier with the conventional mirror.
Double-Pass Amplifier Output (a.u.)
The demonstration of the operation of a 7.4-watt picosecond output from a double-pass side-pumped Nd:YVO4 amplifier with a ring self-pumped Rh:BaTiO3 phase-conjugate mirror is presented.
1
0.5
0
0
10
20 Time (s)
30
40
F I G U R E 7.9. Temporal evolution of the output from a CW Nd:YVO4 amplifier with PCM.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 September 26, 2006
17:13
7. Solid-State Lasers with a Photorefractive Phase-Conjugate Mirror
205
Signal (ML-YVO4 laser) Isolator1 Isolator2
Rh:BaTiO3
PBS Output L1
Nd:YVO4 CL3
HWP1
HWP2 CL CL1 2 CW-LD Pump 35W
F I G U R E 7.10. Schematic diagram of a picosecond Nd:YVO4 amplifier with PCM.
Figure (7.10) shows a schematic diagram of the experimental setup, which is nearly identical to that of the CW double-pass amplifier with the PCM. The signal laser used for the amplifier is a commercial diode-pumped CW modelocked Nd:YVO4 laser with a pulse width of 7.2 ps and a repetition rate of 100 MHz. To prevent feedback to the signal laser, an optical isolator (isolator1 in the figure is placed between the signal laser and the amplifier. To eject the amplified output from the system, another optical isolator (isolator2 ) formed by a polarizing beam splitter (PBS), a Faraday rotator (FR), and a half-wave plate (HWP1 ) is placed between isolator1 and the amplifier. The collimated signal beam is directed toward the amplifier by a mirror M1 , with its polarization parallel to the c-axis of the Nd:YVO4 crystal. The crystal was transversely pumped by a water-cooled CW-single-bar diode array. The diode center wavelength was 809 nm with a wavelength width (FWHM) of 1.9 nm. The effective absorption depth is < 1 mm. This diode had a relatively broad spectrum in comparison with the diode used in the CW experiment, thereby producing a deeper active region. Maximum pump diode power was 36 W with a single-pass gain G (= exp(g0 L)) greater than 10,000. The collimated signal beam is directed into the amplifier by a 75-mm vertical cylindrical lens, CL1 , to form a line focus with dimensions ≈ 0.2 mm × 1.0 mm. The amplified signal beam is delivered using cylindrical lenses CL2 , CL3 , and a spherical lens L1 to form a φ2-mm circular spot on the BaTiO3 . The crystal had dimensions of 5 mm × 4 mm × 4 mm. A half-wave plate HWP2 rotated the polarization to be parallel to the extraordinary plane of the BaTiO3 crystal, thereby yielding maximum two-beam coupling gain. Frequency-narrowing effects due to wavelength selectivity of the PCM can broaden output pulses. And thus, an efficient PCM for ultrashort pulses requires broad-band two-wave mixing gain, which makes ultrafast operation difficult to achieve. As stated above, use of a ring-PCM geometry is one solution for obtaining efficient phase conjugation for ultrashort pulses. The BaTiO3 crystal formed the ring-PCM with two turning mirrors and two 4 f -imaging lenses. The angle between probe and forward-pump beams was
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 September 26, 2006
206
17:13
T. Omatsu, M.J. Damzen, A. Minassian and K. Kuroda F I G U R E 7.11. Experimental plots of output power from a picosecond Nd:YVO4 amplifier with PCM as a function of input signal power.
Output Power (W)
8 6 4 2 0
0
50 100 Input Power (mW)
150
≈ 24◦ . The experimental two-wave-mixing gain with this system was > 6 cm−1 . Since the coherence length of the signal laser (< 3 mm) was much shorter than the external loop length (≈ 60 cm), the formation of reflection gratings was negligible even without the vibration of the M6 mirror. By substituting experimental parameters n = 2.5, κ = 6 cm−1 and = 2.5μm into (10), wavelength selectivity λ of the two-wave-mixing gain is estimated to be ≈ 5 nm, which is sufficiently broader than the spectral bandwidth (≈ 0.35 nm) of the signal pulse. And thus, the pulse broadening effect due to wavelength selection by the PCM should be negligible and efficient phase-conjugate reflectivity can be expected. Once the amplified signal laser was injected into the PCM, the PCM output started to build up gradually, and several minutes later its reflectivity reached a steady level. The slow temporal evolution was due to the relatively low concentration of the Rh ions in the BaTiO3 crystal. After the PCM built up sufficiently well, its temporal response to changes in the incident beam was much faster (less than one minute). With this system, the reflectivity of the PCM was typically ≈ 40%. Experimental reflectivity agreed well with the theoretical value. The phases-conjugate beam was fed back into the amplifier, and after passing through the amplifier it was reflected off by the PBS. During the experiments there was no damage to the crystals due to pico second pulses. The output power from the double-pass amplifier was measured by varying the signal power. Figure 7.11 shows the output power from the double-pass amplifier with PCM as a function of signal beam power at pumping power of 36 W. The threshold input power for obtaining efficient output was 2–3 mW. Above threshold the output power eventually saturated, giving a maximum output power of 7.4 W with an input power of 137 mW. This corresponds to an extraction efficiency of > 20%. In Figure 7.12, the simulated curve at the phase-conjugate reflectivity R of 40% is also plotted. There thus was demonstrated good agreement between the experimental and simulated results. Output power as a function of pump diode power was also measured (Figure 7.12). The signal power was fixed to be 137 mW. Output power is proportional to the pump power. A slope efficiency of 22% was obtained. This value was not as high as that in the CW experiment. The diode had a relatively broad spectrum, and a relatively deeper active region was produced, which reduces spatial
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 September 26, 2006
17:13
7. Solid-State Lasers with a Photorefractive Phase-Conjugate Mirror
F I G U R E 7.12. Output power as a function of pump diode power.
8 Output Power (W)
207
6 4 2 0
0
10
20 30 Pump Power (W)
40
overlapping between the signal beam and the active region. The output beam exhibited a near-perfect Gaussian profile and its beam propagation factors M x2 in the horizontal direction and M y2 in the vertical direction were <1.3 and 1.1, respectively. In order to compare our system with a conventional double-pass amplifier, we replaced the PCM with a conventional high-reflection plane mirror. The output exhibited strong aberration, and its beam propagation factor M x2 was ≈ 3.1 in the horizontal direction. The output power in this case was limited to ≈ 6 W. An experimental intensity autocorrelation trace of the output pulse, obtained by second harmonic generation in a 5-mm KTP crystal, is shown in Figure 7.13. An FWHM of 13 ps was measured, which corresponded to a 9.2-ps pulse width for a Gaussian-shaped pulse. A finite gain-band of the amplifier can also broaden output pulses. In general, the pulse-broadening result in the amplifier with finite gain-bandwidth is given by [18] 2 = τin2 + τout
(16 ln(2)) ln G D , ωg2
(7.13)
where G D is the small-signal gain of the double-pass amplifier, ωg is the gain-bandwidth, and τin and τout , are pulse widths of input and output pulses, 1 SH intensity (a.u.)
SH intensity (a.u.)
1 0.8 0.6 0.4
0.6 0.4 0.2
0.2 0 −20
0.8
−10
0
10
20
0 −20
−10
0
Time delay (ps)
Time delay (ps)
(a)
(b)
10
20
F I G U R E 7.13. Autocorrelation traces of output pulses from the phase-conjugate amplifier.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 September 26, 2006
208
17:13
T. Omatsu, M.J. Damzen, A. Minassian and K. Kuroda F I G U R E 7.14. Frequency spectrum of output pulses from a phase-conjugate amplifier.
Power (a.u.)
1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0
1063
1064
1065
1066
Wavelength (nm)
respectively. In the Nd:YVO4 amplifier with ωg /2π = 300 GHz and high gain G D ≈ 104 , this gives a output pulse width of 9.0 ps. This value is consistent with the experimental one. In addition, as shown in Figure 7.13; the spectral bandwidth (0.19 nm) of the output pulse from the double-pass amplifier was relatively narrower than that of the signal pulse (0.35 nm), while the phase conjugate had a spectral bandwidth of 0.35 nm. The corresponding Fourier-transform-limit was 8.8 ps. Consequently, pulse broadening is due mainly to the finite gain-bandwidth of the amplifier. Such a technique provides attractive features for the realization of highquality, all-solid-state, compact picosecond 1-μm lasers operating at high average power. 7.3.2.3 Nanosecond Regime
Initially, high-quality Q-switched output from a double-pass amplifier with the photorefractive PCM was demonstrated. To date, several researchers have demonstrated the generation of high-quality Q-switched pulses from master-oscillator power amplifier systems with the photorefractive PCM based on Rh:BaTiO3 . Brignon et al. presented a flash-lamp-pumped Nd:YAG four-pass amplifier with a CAT-PCM, and generated a 65-mJ diffraction-limited Q-switched pulse at a pulse repetition frequency of 10 Hz [25]. The CAT-PCM exhibits a small incident aperture compared with the ring-PCM, and thus it is not suitable for generation of high-energy nanosecond pulses. Tei et al. demonstrated 360-mJ near-diffraction-limited Q-switched output from two diode-pumped Nd:YAG zigzag slab amplifiers with the ring-PCM with pulse repetition frequency of 100 Hz [26]. This pulse energy is the highest, to the best of our knowledge, obtained by a phase-conjugate amplifier in the nanosecond regime.
P1: OTE/SPH P2: OTE SVNY276-Gunter-v3 September 26, 2006
17:13
7. Solid-State Lasers with a Photorefractive Phase-Conjugate Mirror
209
7.4 Phase-Conjugate Laser Resonator A phase-conjugate resonator (PCR), in which one end mirror is a phase-conjugate mirror (PCM), is another alternative solution for correction of thermal distortions in laser resonators [27]. Self-pumped photorefractive PCM can allow a laser oscillation of the PCR without external pumping beams to the PCM. To date, McFarlane et al. have demonstrated the laser oscillation of a pulsed dye laser using a CAT-PCM and achieved a narrowband output with a line-width of 2 GHz. However, there is no report concerning photorefractive PCR lasers in the 1-μm region. Recently, laser oscillation of a CW diode-pumped Nd:YVO4 phase-conjugate resonator based on a ring self-pumped Rh:BaTiO3 phase-conjugate mirror was demonstrated [28]. In this system, a 7.5-W output with high beam quality was obtained. A schematic diagram of the experimental setup is shown in Figure 7.15(a). A 1.1 at% a-cut Nd:YVO4 slab with dimensions of 20 mm × 5 mm × 1 mm forms the transversely diode-pumped amplifier with a bounce geometry. Two mirrors (M1 , M2 ) with reflectivities of 10% and 4% for 1064 nm form a master resonator. Two cylindrical lenses (CL1 , CL2 ) with focal lengths of 100 mm are placed inside the resonator in order to make the fundamental laser mode overlap sufficiently well with the elliptical gain volume. Mirror M1 acts as the output coupler of the laser system. The laser output emerging from the mirror M1 is directed toward a power meter. The other laser output emerging from the mirror M2 is directed towards a ring-PCM based on a 400-ppm Rh-doped BaTiO3 crystal with dimensions of 5 mm × 4 mm × 4 mm. A spherical lens L1 is used to form a spot size with diameter 2–3 mm on the BaTiO3 crystal in the ring-PCM. The polarization of laser output is rotated by a half-wave plate (HWP1 ) to be parallel to the c axis of the BaTiO3 . The phase-conjugate reflection from the ring-PCM