PERSPECTIVES IN ASTROBIOLOGY
NATO Science Series A series presenting the results of scientific meetings supported under the NATO Science Programme. The series is published by IOS Press and Springer Science and Business Media in conjunction with the NATO Public Diplomacy Division. Sub-Series I. II. III. IV. V.
Life and Behavioural Sciences Mathematics, Physics and Chemistry Computer and Systems Sciences Earth and Environmental Sciences Science and Technology Policy
IOS Press Springer Science and Business Media IOS Press Springer Science and Business Media IOS Press
The NATO Science Series continues the series of books published formerly as the NATO ASI Series. The NATO Science Programme offers support for collaboration in civil science between scientists of countries of the Euro-Atlantic Partnership Council. The types of scientific meeting generally supported are “Advanced Study Institutes” and “Advanced Research Workshops”, although other types of meeting are supported from time to time. The NATO Science Series collects together the results of these meetings. The meetings are co-organized by scientists from NATO countries and scientists from NATO’s Partner countries – countries of the CIS and Central and Eastern Europe. Advanced Study Institutes are high-level tutorial courses offering in-depth study of latest advances in a field. Advanced Research Workshops are expert meetings aimed at critical assessment of a field, and identification of directions for future action. As a consequence of the restructuring of the NATO Science Programme in 1999, the NATO Science Series has been re-organized and there are currently five sub-series as noted above. Please consult the following web sites for information on previous volumes published in the series, as well as details of earlier sub-series: http://www.nato.int/science http://www.springeronline.nl http://www.iospress.nl http://www.wtv-books.de/nato_pco.htm
Series I: Life and Behavioural Sciences - Vol. 366
ISSN: 1566-7693
Perspectives in Astrobiology
Edited by
R.B. Hoover Space Science Department/SD50, NASA George C. Marshall Space Flight Center, Huntsville, AL, USA
A.Yu. Rozanov Paleontological Institute RAS, Moscow, Russia
and
R. Paepe GEOBOUND INTERNATIONAL Research Center & Free University of Brussels, Belgium
Amsterdam • Berlin • Oxford • Tokyo • Washington, DC Published in cooperation with NATO Public Diplomacy Division
Proceedings of the NATO Advanced Study Institute on Perspectives in Astrobiology Chania, Crete, Greece 7–16 October 2002
© 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without prior written permission from the publisher. ISBN 1-58603-512-6 Library of Congress Control Number: 2005925127 Publisher IOS Press Nieuwe Hemweg 6B 1013 BG Amsterdam Netherlands fax: +31 20 620 3419 e-mail:
[email protected] Distributor in the UK and Ireland IOS Press/Lavis Marketing 73 Lime Walk Headington Oxford OX3 7AD England fax: +44 1865 750079
Distributor in the USA and Canada IOS Press, Inc. 4502 Rachael Manor Drive Fairfax, VA 22032 USA fax: +1 703 323 3668 e-mail:
[email protected]
LEGAL NOTICE The publisher is not responsible for the use which might be made of the following information. PRINTED IN THE NETHERLANDS
v
Perspectives in Astrobiology R.B. Hoover et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
Preface Astrobiology is the multi-disciplinary field devoted to the investigation of the origin; physical, chemical and environmental limitations; and the distribution in space and time of life on Earth and in the Cosmos. Astrobiology seeks an answer to one of the most fundamental of all questions: — Is Life Restricted to Planet Earth or is Life a Cosmic Imperative? Understanding the characteristics, properties, habits, and diversity of living organisms on Earth is crucial to determining where and how to search for evidence of life elsewhere. New techniques and methodologies must be developed in order to determine a suitable suite of valid biomarkers that is needed to facilitate the differentiation of abiotic processes from true signatures of life. This is crucial to establishing the criteria needed to properly evaluate potential biosignatures in ancient Earth rocks and in a wide variety of Astromaterials (e.g., meteorites, interstellar dust particles and samples returned from future space flight missions to comets, asteroids and Mars). It is well known that microbial extremophiles (e.g., prokaryotes such as archaea and bacteria) were the first life forms to appear on Earth. They are also the most abundant and the most widely distributed life forms on our planet. Extremophiles inhabit deep ice, deep crustal rocks, hydrothermal vents, permafrost and the deepest layers of the Antarctic Ice Sheet, deep marine sediments, acidic brines and hypersaline, alkaline lakes and lagoons. They live in the most hostile environments of our planet, growing wherever there is a source of water, energy, and carbon compounds and represent good analogs for life forms that may be present elsewhere in the Solar System Their life processes result in the production of biominerals, chiral amino acids, biological fractionation of stable isotopes, macromolecular fossils, chemical biosignatures and microfossils. This “Perspectives in Astrobiology” volume includes papers treating a wide variety of these topics. They range from considerations of relict microbial communities of extreme environments (e.g. hydrotherms, hypersaline lagoons, and soda lakes and the subglacial Antarctic ice sheet) to complex organic molecules such as sugars under prebiotic conditions, biominerals and biotic and abiotic framboidal microstructures in Earth rocks, the processes of mineralization and fossilization of cyanobacteria, and biomarkers and microfossils detected in carbonaceous meteorites. Other papers discuss the use of stable isotopes and their biological fractionation as a baseline for evaluating extraterrestrial evidence and the use of chirality and composition of indigenous amino acids for differentiating between terrestrial and extraterrestrial organic matter in Astromaterials. Also treated in this volume are geomorph parallels, sediment patterns, and cyclicities in permafrost sediments of Earth and Mars; the survival of bacteria in space, eclipsing binaries, and advanced DNA and protein chip technology for future robotic missions to search for life in the Solar System. Richard B. Hoover Alexei Yu. Rozanov Roland Paepe
vi
Acknowledgements The Director Mr. Richard B. HOOVER, Astrobiology Group Leader at the Space Science Department/SD50, NASA George C. Marshall Space Flight Center, Huntsville, AL 35812, USA, the first Co-director Professor Alexei Rozanov, Palaeontological Institute of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 117997, Profsoyuznaya St., 123, Moscow, Russia, and the second Co-director Professor Roland Paepe, GEOBOUND INTERNATIONAL and the Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Belgium, like to thank everybody who contributed to the success of this very first NATO-ASI meeting dealing with the topic on “Perspectives in Astrobiology”. When it was presented to NATO, it was received with great enthusiasm by Dr. Walter Kaffenberger, Director of the NATO Scientific Affairs Division for which reason we want to thank him here in the first place. In the second place we feel greatly indebted for his renewed efforts inside the NATO Administration for allocating an exceptionally second funding after the first meeting was cancelled as a result of the September 11th event in 2001. So, exactly one year later, in October 2002, the second attempt to hold the meeting at the Creta Paradise Hotel in Hania, Crete, became possible again and successful. Also the managers of this hotel have been extremely understanding with reservations made for the first year and transferring these payments to the second year thus enabling the meeting to continue in 2002. NASA provided most of the funding for long and expensive traveling from the USA, especially from cities along the West Coast as well as for the establishment of the excellent website through which all registrations could easily and effectively be made and announcements and changes with regard to the programme and hotel accommodations could rapidly be dispatched. With this respect, a special tribute is hereby made to honour all efforts made by Mr. Ronald Koczor of NASA George C. Marshall Space Flight Center, Huntsville, AL 35812, USA as well as for taking up the thankless task of reviewing session papers with the Director of this NATO ASI. Special grants were provided by INTAS for participants originating from Russia and countries incorporated in the former Union of Socialist Soviet Republics. We are extremely grateful to Dr. Ingmar Schmidt of INTAS for helping the NATO ASI organizational committee with INTAS funding despite considerable problems that were also raised here further to the postponement of the meeting. Sponsoring by GEOBOUND INTERNATIONAL allowed traveling for Europeans and greatly facilitated logistics before, during and after the meeting. The considerable efforts made in this field by Dr. Elfi Van Overloop, Research Associate of GEOBOUND INTERNATIONAL and permanent contact person with the NATO Administration, contributed highly to the success of the smoothly running local organization as expressed by the Director of the NATO ASI in his final address. To all Greek Colleagues from the Technical University of Crete, especially to Professor Theodore Markopoulos, Head of the Geology Department and honorable host of the most southern part in Europe, we feel very thankful for their technical and moral support, for the organization of the field excursions, and not the least, for giving linguistically assistance throughout the congress. Finally we are most grateful to Wilhelmina Muhs, GEOBOUND INTERNATIONAL associate, for taking up the technical production of this book with IOS and serving as an intermediate between the publisher and NASA.
vii
NATO Participants Name
Country
e-mail
Hoover, Richard Paepe, Roland Rozanov, Alexei
Directors and Staff USA Belgium Russia
[email protected] [email protected] [email protected]
Koczor, Ronald Overloop, Elfi van
USA Belgium
[email protected] [email protected]
Duve, Christian de Horneck, Gerda Ivanov, Mikhail McKay, David Perez-Mercator, Juan Schidlowski, Manfred Vorobyova, Lena Yushkin, Nikolai Zavarzin, Georgy
Lecturers Belgium Germany Russia USA Spain Germany Russia Russia Russia
[email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]
viii
List of Student Participants Name
Starting Point
e-mail
Armstrong, John Huber, Julie Kaye, Jonathan Kolb, Vera Perry, Randall Schrenk, Matthew Turnbull, Margaret Wells, Llyd
USA Seattle, Washington Seattle, Washington Seattle, Washington Kenosha, Wisconsin Seattle, Washington Seattle, Washington Tucson, Arizona Seattle, Washington
[email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]
RUSSIA & adjacent countries Astafieva, Marina Moscow Gerasimenko, Ludmilla Moscow Simakov, Michael Sint Petersburg Simakova, Yulya Moscow Ushatinskaya, Galina Moscow Serozhkin, Yuri Kiev, Ukraine Plotnikova, Liudmila Kiev, Ukraine Nemliher, Yuriy Tallinn, Estonia Omarov, Bigalievich Almaty, Kazahkstan Kruchek, Semen Minsk, Bielorussia
Andras, Sik Blazquez, Jesus Bonaccorsi, Rosalba Çiçek, Caner Erdem, Ahmet Gomez Gomez, Jose Gutierrez, Jordi Rettberg, Petra Tamas, Simon Toporski, Jan
EUROPE & Turkey Budapest Madrid, Spain Trieste, Italy Canakkale Canakkale Madrid Barcelona Koln, Germany Budapest Portsmouth, UK
[email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]
[email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]
ix
1. SCHRENK Matthew, 2. NEMLIHER Yuri, 3. SIK Andreas, 4. ARMSTRONG John, 5. KOCZOR Ronald, 6. ENGEL Michael, 7. SERUSHKIN Yuri, 8. TOPORSKI Jan, 9. BLASQUEZ Jesus, 10. MCKAY David, 11. ZAVARZIN Georgiu, 12. ÇIÇEK Caner, 13. KAYE Jonathan, 14. SIMAKOV Michael, 15. RETTEBERG Petra, 16. MARKOPOULOS Theodoros, 17. PERRY Randall, 18. PEREZ-MERCADER Juan, 19. ROZANOV Alexei, 20. GUTIERREZ Jordi, 21. OMAROV Bigaliev, 22. KOLB Vera, 23. HUBER Julie, 24. TURNBULL Margaret, 25. HOOVER Richard, 26. YUSHKIN Nicolai, 27. ASTAFIEVA Marina, 28. HORNECK Gerda, 29. BONACCORSI Rosalba, 30. USHATINSKAYA Galina, 31. PAEPE Roland, 32. VAN OVERLOOP Elfi, 33. SCHIDLOWSKI Manfred, 34. GERASIMENKO Ludmila, 35. SIMAKOVA Yulia.
x
xi
Contents Preface Richard B. Hoover, Alexei Yu. Rozanov and Roland Paepe
v
Acknowledgements
vi
NATO Participants
vii
List of Student Participants
viii
Nature of Framboidal Structures in Black Shales (the Cambrian of the Siberian Platform and the Permian of the Barents Sea Shelf) Marina M. Astafieva
1
Bacteriomorphic Structures from the Sinsk Formation (Lower Cambrian of the Siberian Platform) Marina M. Astafieva
6
Constraining Subglacial Settings Using Clay-Supported Ice Rafted Detritus (Mud Grains) in Antarctic Marine Sediment: A Framework for Astrobiology Rosalba Bonaccorsi, Antonio Brambati, Lloyd H. Burckle and Alexander M. Piotrowski
11
Apsidal Motion Problem in the Eclipsing Binary Star DR Vulpeculae Caner Çiçek
21
Amino Acids: Probes for Life’s Origin in the Solar System Michael H. Engel, Vlad E. Andrus and Stephen A. Macko
25
Mineralization of Cyanobacteria L. Gerasimenko, V. Orleansky and L. Zaitseva
38
Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites Richard B. Hoover
43
Survival of Microorganisms in Space, an Experimental Contribution to the Discussion on Viable Transfer of Life in the Solar System Gerda Horneck
66
Reactions of Urazole and its Analogs with Sugars and Metals under Prebiotic Conditions Vera M. Kolb, Patricia A. Colloton and Kevin J. Rapp
76
Apatite as Biosignature Jüri Nemliher
81
xii
Tikhov’s Astrobotany as a Prelude to Modern Astrobiology Tuken B. Omarov and Bulat T. Tashenov
86
Computation of Sediment Cycles on Mars and Earth Elfi Van Overloop and Roland Paepe
88
Landscape, Sediment, Red Soil, Permafrost Geomorph Parallels on Earth and Mars Roland Paepe and Elfi Van Overloop
104
Biochemical Markers in Rock Coatings Randall S. Perry and Vera M. Kolb
120
The Influence of Space Parameters like Solar Ultraviolet Radiation on the Survival of Microorganisms Petra Rettberg Bacterial Paleontology A.Yu. Rozanov
126 132
Paleobiological and Biogeochemical Vestiges of Early Terrestrial Biota: Baseline for Evaluation of Extraterrestrial Evidence Manfred Schidlowski
146
Formation of Ordered Structures of Charged Grains in Gas-Dusty Atmospheres of Planets and Comets during Lightning Discharge Yuriy G. Serozhkin
170
Exobiology of Titan Michael B. Simakov
175
The Role of Living and Nonliving Organic Matter in Volkonskoite Formation Y.S. Simakova
181
Astrobiotechnology: Alternative Concepts for Astrobiology Solar System Exploration Jan Toporski and Andrew Steele
187
The Study of Remains of Microorganisms in Ancient Earth Sedimentary Rocks for Astrobiology Galina T. Ushatinskaya, Elena A. Zhegallo and Emil L. Shkolnik
196
Recent Microbiology and Precambrian Paleontology Georgy A. Zavarzin
201
Author Index
217
Perspectives in Astrobiology R.B. Hoover et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
1
Nature of Framboidal Structures in Black Shales (the Cambrian of the Siberian Platform and the Permian of the Barents Sea Shelf) Marina M. ASTAFIEVA Paleontological Institute RAS 117997, Profsoyuznaya St., 123, Moscow, Russia Abstract. The origin of framboidal structures and their mineralogical composition (on the example of black shales of the Upper Permian of the Barents Sea Shelf and the Cambrian of the Siberian Platform) are discussed. The biogenic origin of framboids is confirmed.
Framboidal structures are common in Earth rocks and meteorites—carbonaceous chondrites. There is little doubt that the origin of framboids in astromaterial is the same as in Earth rocks. But up to now, there is still not a common opinion concerning the origin of framboids, i.e.: whether they are biogenic or not, so it is very important to solve the problem of the nature of framboids in Earth rocks. Framboids are spherical aggregates of microcrystals. They are characterized by a complicated, honeycomb inner structure and an inner portion of globules, which is monograined with a diameter of 0.1–10.0 μm. Some framboids are only partially mineralized by pyrite (FeS2). The close spatial connection between framboidal pyrite and the detritus of buried organic matter can be seen. Hence, the origin of framboidal pyrite is connected with mineralization of organic matter [1]. Framboids are found in a wide variety of sedimentary rocks of differing ages, and they are also found in recent swamp sediments, peat, marine, and oceanic silt. The origin of framboids by recrystalization of amorphous iron (Fe) sulfides in the early stages of diagenesis in the local niches of hydrogen sulfide is not excluded. The formation of framboidal pyrite is believed to be a result of the activity of sulfatereducing bacteria (SRB) [2]. Although the feasibility of abiotic precipitation of ironsulfides is well documented, the importance of bacteria in the sulfide precipitation process, at least in marine settings, is not in serious doubt [3]; however, there is no reason to exclude the possibility of an abiogenic origin of framboids because nearly all compounds, generally considered to be biological, are readily synthesized from abiogenic components in natural environments. Even protein amino acids have been shown to be assembled from abiogenic components during the crystallization and thermal ordering of hydrocarbons [4]. The role of bacteria in sulfide precipitation is great because the precipitation of iron sulfides requires high H2S concentrations, and in marine sediments, the rapid increase of H2S with depth is the direct result of sulfate reduction by bacteria. Although the precipitation is probably rarely biologically controlled, it is unquestionably biologically induced [3].
2
M.M. Astafieva / Nature of Framboidal Structures in Black Shales
Figure 1. Framboids from: (a) and (b) the Upper Permian of the Barents Sea shelf (containing sulfur) and (c) (containing sulfur) and (d) (without sulfur) the Ogonyorian formation.
The black carbonate shales of the Kuonamka and Ogonyor formations of the Cambrian of the Siberian platform were chosen as objects of investigation. The sequences of both formations are situated in the Yudoma-Olenek region. Both formations are represented by the alteration of mudstones, siltstones and limestones, carbonate and siliceous rocks, and sapropelian. The age of formation is from Lower to Middle Cambrian [5]. In addition, the samples from the wells drilled on the Barents Sea Shelf near Mingasprom, Russia were studied. These rocks are the Upper Permian black, bituminous, and probably Posidonian shales. All samples were studied using CamScan. The chemical analyses were made using microzond analysis. All samples were treated by H2O2 for 30 min and heated in a muphel stove to exclude recent bacterial contamination. The microbial remains are mainly represented by framboidal structures. Framboids are numerous, and their diameters range from 3 to 10 μm (Fig. 1(a)–(d)). As a rule, framboids that are found are indivisible from (united with) the rock matrix, i.e.: they are indigenous to the rock. Rather often, it seems that the rock simply consists of these framboids, including the different layers (Fig. 1(a) and (b)). That is why there is no doubt that framboids are in situ, i.e.: they were formed simultaneously with the rock. Nevertheless, it is necessary to say that these framboids seriously differ in their chemical composition. Most of the framboids consist of sulfur (S) and iron (Figs 1(a)–(c) and 2) probably represented by pyrite. Framboidal pyrite is considered to be formed due to the activity of SRB [2]. The activity of these bacteria is connected with anaerobic conditions that are provided in the absence of oxygen. However, on account of the presence of SRB, it seems to be impossible to estimate the depth of paleobasin. Even the upper layer of a cyanobacterial mat a few millimeters thick provides anaerobic conditions beneath that are favorable for SRB development. The reception of sulfate from outside is the limiting factor for the development of such communities. The regeneration of sulfate is primarily possible by the oxidation of hydrogen sulfide under aerobic conditions and secondarily by the oxidation of H2S to sulfate under anaerobic conditions. As a whole, sulfidogenic assemblages play a great role in
M.M. Astafieva / Nature of Framboidal Structures in Black Shales
3
Figure 2. Chemical composition of framboids.
marine conditions, and most organic matter in the bottom sediments is decomposed in such a manner [6]. It is necessary to mention that among framboids of iron sulfide there are framboids that are morphologically indistinguishable from pyrite framboids but lack sulfur in their chemical composition (Figs 1(d) and 2). Framboidal structures can sometimes be composed by magnetite. Bacterial magnetite can be formed in two ways: (1) By means of biologically induced mineralization and (2) by means of biologically controlled mineralization. In the case of biologically induced mineralization, organisms do not control the processes of biomineralization, and the mineral parts are formed extracellular. Magnetite is formed as a result of the activity of thermophilic and moderately thermophilic ironreducing bacteria under anaerobic conditions. Environmental parameters, such as Eh and pH, greatly influence the formation of magnetite. In this case, magnetite is a final product of vital activities of these bacteria. In the case of biologically controlled mineralization, minerals are deposited on or inside the organic matrix or inside of vacuoles in the cell. The organism controls, to some extent, the process of mineralization. Because the intracellular level of pH and Eh is defined by the organisms themselves, the formation of minerals depends on the environmental parameters to a lesser extent. In this case, the magnetic particles of magnetite are formed by magnetotactic bacteria. The magnetite structures that are analogous to framboidal structures are formed by multiple twinning, which is connected with the bacterial growth but not with the phase transitions or outside influences that are usually responsible for the twinning [7,8]. It is necessary to note that magnetite can potentially be a physical indicator of biologic activity. Iron framboids devoid of sulfur are not only represented by magnetite. It is known that a lot of iron sulfides, such as pyrite, macinawite (FeS1–x), and amorphous FeS, are metastable in typical oxidizing earth conditions and that is why they are rarely encountered outside microbial anaerobic conditions [9]. As far as nice hematite pseudomorphs of pyrite are known [10], it is possible to suppose that hematite could form pseudomorphs of framboidal pyrite as a result of oxidation. But in the studied samples, classic pyrite framboids were found simultaneously with framboids in chemical compositions from which S was absent. Therefore, it is possible to speak about the local formation of hematite.
4
M.M. Astafieva / Nature of Framboidal Structures in Black Shales
The process of pyrite oxidation can probably occur with the filtration of surface waters through the rock containing pyrite framboids but not in underwater conditions because in that case the oxidation would touch the layer as a whole. The inclination is to favor the magnetite nature of framboids deprived of sulfur. The fact that pyrite and magnetite framboids could be found together can be explained by a certain deficit of a sulfate-ion in the basin of sedimentation. Moreover, both pyrite and magnetite are usually formed in warm water basins. In addition, the combined vital activity of SRB and iron-reducing bacteria should not be excluded. It is noteworthy that there is fossil benthic fauna in the studied intervals of sequences, i.e.: trilobites and brachiopods in Cambrian intervals and bivalves in the Upper Permian. However, the rock fragments with the benthic remains, in almost every case, are practically deprived of bacterial microstructures. In the bacteriomorph-enriched-microstructure fragments, there are no benthic macrofauna remains. This could probably be evidence of an irregularity of microbial transformation of organic matter and could be an indirect confirmation of the biological (bacterial) nature of our microstructures. There is an exception. The exception is the findings of remains of bivalve Posidonia in the Upper Permian black shales of the Barents Sea Shelf. Posidonia are a very peculiar, extremely thin-walled, flat bivalve. These fragile valves are noted in many samples; moreover, it seems that the best preserved pyrite framboids of are found in intervals with Posidonia. Posidonia characterize a particular facies in the Late Paleozoic and Early Mesozoic facies—usually occurring in bituminous, muddy sediments with plant debris, fish remains, and cephalopods. Benthic forms, such as brachiopods, corals, and bryozoans, are generally absent in the Posidonia facies. A lot of Posidonia, fishes, belemnite rostra, and hooks remains are the usual association of typical Posidonia shales. The lightness of Posidonia shells and the usual association of the genus suggest a pseudoplanatonic mode of life— perhaps these forms were attached by byssus to floating plants. The extreme thinness of the Posidonia shell valves also favors this assumption. Moreover, species of Posidonia are, as a rule, usually limited to dark shales containing such forms as fish and cephalopods during the entire history of their development [11]. That dark color of such sediments is considered to be caused by bituminous material, probably preserved under reducing conditions. Posidonia shale sedimentation probably occurred in a basin with stagnant waters, low maintenance of oxygen, and high maintenance of hydrogen sulfide. This corresponds to the data obtained by the analysis of the microbial remains of these deposits.
Conclusions The mineral composition of framboids is variable. Iron sulfides, especially pyrite, are predominant, and framboids of magnetite and perhaps of hematite are rather rare. The formation of framboidal structures is connected with the bacterial transformation and subsequent mineralization of organic matter. Framboids are deposited due to the vital activity of bacteria. There are two ways of framboidal formation, i.e.: biologically induced and biologically controlled mineralization; therefore, it is possible to speak about their biogenic origin.
Acknowledgements The author is grateful to everyone who has aided in conducting this work, especially A.Yu. Rozanov, E.A. Zhegallo, G.T. Ushatinskaja, V.I. Ustritskiy, T.M. Pchelina, N.V. Ustinov, and E.N. Preobrazhenskaya for their contribution in the discussion of the results and
M.M. Astafieva / Nature of Framboidal Structures in Black Shales
5
providing the rock material. The Author is also grateful to L.T.Protasevich for his assistance in electron microscope investigation. This study was supported by the Russian Foundation for Basic Research (projects 00–15–97764, 99–04–48806, and 00–05–64603).
References [1] Bogush IA, Burtsev AA. Ontogenesis of framboidal pyrite. In: Gavrilenko VV, Panina LK, Panova EG, Pinevich AA, Sukkarzhevsky SM, Vlasov DY, editors. Abstracts of the first international symposium, bio-inert interactions: life and rocks. St. Petersburg: St. Petersburg State University; 2002. p. 49–51. [2] Gerasimenko LM, Zavarzin GA. The relict cyanobacterial communities. In: The problems of preanthropogenous evolution of the biosphere, Moscow: Nauka; 1993. p. 222–53. [3] Kohn MJ, Riciputi LR, Orange DL. Sulfur isotopevariability in biogenic piryte: reflections of heterogeneous bacterial colonization? Am. Mineralogist 1998; 83(11–2) 2: 1454–68. [4] Yushkin NP. Biomineral homologies and organismobiosis. In: Mineralogy and life: biomineral homologies. Syktyvkar: Geoprint; 2000. p. 9–12. [5] Rozanov AYu, Repina LN, Apollonov MK, et al. Cambrian of Siberia. Novosibirsk: All-Russian Inc. Nauka, Siberian publishing firm; 1992. p. 135. [6] Zavarzin GA, Kolotilova NN. Introduction into environmental microbiology. Moscow: Knizhniy dom Universitet; 2001. p. 256. [7] Devouagard B, Posfai M, Hua X, Bazylinski DA, Frankel RB, Busek PR. Magnetite from magnetotactic bacteria: size distributions and twinning. Am. Mineralogist 1998; 83(11–2) 2: 1387–98. [8] Zhang Ch, Vali H, Romanek ChH, Phelps TJ, Liu ShV. Formation of single-domain magnetite by a thermophilic bacterium. Am. Mineralogist 1998; 83(11–2) 2: 1409–18. [9] Boston PJ, Spilde MN, Northup DE, Melim LA, Soroka DS, Kleina LG, Lavoie KH, Hose LD, Mallory LM, Dahm CN, Crossey LJ, Schelble RT. Cave biosignature suites: microbes, minerals, and Mars. Astrobiology 2001; 1: 25–55. [10] Godovikov AA. Mineralogy. Moscow: Nedra; 1975. p. 520. [11] Newell ND. Permian pelecypods of East Greenland. Medd. Gronland 1955; 110(4): 36.
6
Perspectives in Astrobiology R.B. Hoover et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
Bacteriomorphic Structures from the Sinsk Formation (Lower Cambrian of the Siberian Platform) Marina M. ASTAFIEVA Paleontological Institute RAS 117997, Profsoyuznaya St., 123, Moscow, Russia Abstract. The main types of biomorphic microstructures from black carbonate shales of the Sinsk formation (Lower Cambrian) of the Siberian platform are described. The possibility of the thin-layered part of the Sinsk formation being the vitally buried remains of cyanobacterial mat is discussed.
Introduction Some biomorphic structures of meteorites are practically indistinguishable from biomorphic structures of such Earth objects as black shales of the Sinsk formation of the Siberian Platform. That is why the black carbonate shales from the Sinsk formation were chosen as an object of investigation of fossil bacterial remains. Stratigraphically the Sinsk formation belongs to the middle part of the Botomian stage of the Cambrian and consists of the alteration of bituminous limestones and argillosiliceously-carbonate bituminous shales [1,2]. Rock samples from the type section of the Sinsk formation situated near the Sinyaya River (left tributary of the Lena River), and also from the Sinsk deposits from the region of Chekurovka (lower stream of the Lena River) were chosen for investigation, and the results of studies conducted by A. Yu. Rozanov and R. Hoover were applied. The preservation of biomorphs is different; rather often squashed and deformed, biomorphs smoothly pass into the rock and fuse with it. Sometimes it seems that the rock is composed from cocci and squashed tubes (Fig. 1(a) and (b)). Moreover, data of chemical analyses of rock matrix and biomorphic microstructures are identical; hence, it is possible to consider the bacterial remains to be found in situ. To exclude recent bacterial contamination, the samples were immersed in hydrogen peroxide for one-half hour and were dried in a muphel stove. The samples were studied under a CamScan 4 with a microanalyzer. The biomorphic microstructures in the rocks studied are represented by tubes, cocci, pyrite framboids, and thin threads, the formation of which are connected with activity of sulfate-reducing bacteria (SRB).
1. Tubes Single, long, empty tubes usually without branches are the most widely represented (Fig. 1(c)–(f)). The tubes form bundles occasionally, but there was no opportunity in this
M.M. Astafieva / Bacteriomorphic Structures from the Sinsk Formation
7
Figure 1. Biomorphic microstructures of Sinsk formation.
investigation to observe the sheaths of these bundles. There are traces of filament division into cells. The external surface of the tubes is often encrusted by relief papillae. There are two types of papillae. The first type of papillae is rounded or oval, sometimes weakly angular, very convex protuberances on the external side of the tubes (Fig. 1(c)–(e)). The surface of tubes with the second type of papillae resemble the texture of crocodile skin; the shape of these tubes in section is hill like (Fig. 1(f)). It seems that these papillae hills were formed by the curve of the tube wall and not by the thickness of it. Sometimes the tubes have a smooth surface. This is possibly connected with the peculiarities of mineralization or with the subsequent destruction or recession of these papillae.
8
M.M. Astafieva / Bacteriomorphic Structures from the Sinsk Formation
Regarding the biological nature of such papillae, it could be proposed that papillae are the biomorphic microstructures attributed to cyanobacteria; the tubes covered by papillae to some extent look like the picture of phage-defeated filamentous bacteria [3] and to a lesser extent resemble parasitizing vibrion found on chlorella cells [4]. In the chemical composition of the tubes and surrounding rocks, calcium (Ca) and silicon (Si) predominate; therefore, it is possible to propose silification or carbonatization of cyanobacterial cover. Moreover, tubes with papillae are practically indistinguishable from Phormidium—cyanobacteria, which are typical for thermophilic mats—encrusted by small siliceous beads, found in the discharge apron of thermal springs in New Zealand [5]. However, it is too early to make final conclusions because the rocks by themselves are argillaecarbonate, i.e.: they are comprised of both calcium and silicon. Among the studied biomorphic structures, tubes with papillae predominate. Judging by morphology, size, character of connection of tubes, and their division into cells of corresponding size, tubes with papillae are considered to be cyanobacteria, which play the leading role in cyanobacterial mats—specific stable bacterial communities. Cyanobacteria are the basis of such communities. In this case, the main synthesis of organic matter proceeds because of photosynthesis realized by cyanobacteria in the aerobic zone. In all recent mats, oscillatorial forms predominate as active filament forms. Under extreme conditions for the development of cyanobacteria, anoxygenic photosynthesis is provided by both green and purple photothrophic bacteria.
2. Cocci In addition to tubes, spherical forms known as cocci are widely distributed in our samples (Fig. 1(g)). They exist both as single forms set in the rock and as accumulations or colonies. Cocci often surround tubes and are sometimes the main element of the rock. Judging from positions of morphology, the signs of these cocci correspond to signs of purple bacteria.
3. Pyrite Pyrite is spread in different layers of rocks under investigation. The pyrite exists both in framboid shape that is typical for thermophile cyanobacterial mats [6]. The presence of pyrite automatically suggests the process of sulfate reduction that is produced by SRB. These bacteria use elemental sulfur and sulfates, which are formed as a result of photosynthesis, and trophically SRB are closely connected with the purple sulfur bacteria. In the presence of sulfates, SRB produce H2S that in turn can be used by purple sulfur bacteria in the process of anoxigenic photosynthesis. As a result, the sulfate is produced and can be used by SRB in its own turn. The development of sulfidogenics—SRB—is typical for the lower anaerobic zone of the cyanobacterial mat [4,7]. In silts or in dark anaerobic zones, the H2S is connected in dissoluble iron sulfides, falls into deposits, and exits the sulfur circle. With sufficient illuminaton, the phototrophic purple bacteria are the main consumers of sulfuretted hydrogen. In the case of a deficit of sulfuretted hydrogen, the sulfates are the main products of H2S oxidation, and in this case the sulfur is not accumulated. If the rate of formation of H2S or the rate of its admission is more than the rate of its oxidation by microorganisms, sulfur is formed immediately inside the cells of purple sulfur bacteria [3]. In the investigated specimens, pyrite us very rarely found, but cocci of purple bacteria are rather abundant. The data of chemical analyses deny the presence of sulfur in the studied samples. Consequently there was probably no H2S deficit. That is why it is reasonable
M.M. Astafieva / Bacteriomorphic Structures from the Sinsk Formation
9
to suggest that the formation of Sinsk rocks occurred in a photic zone. The pyrite formation was connected with the daily fluctuations of illumination. The deposition of the iron sulfide proceeded only while it was dark when the use of H2S by the purple bacteria was stopped. When it was light, the H2S was used by the purple bacteria. These findings support the theory that the microorganisms found formed cyanobacterial mats during Sinsk time. These mats are the benthic communities of microorganisms in which phototrophic bacteria are dominant. Among them, cyanobacteria are the main producers of organic matter and are responsible for the structure of the mat. Since recent cyanobacterial mats are represented by benthic forms, it is suggested that a benthic mode of life of the bacteria from the Sinsk formation form cyanobacterial mats. Therefore, it is possible to say that the Sinsk basin was relatively shallow watered, i.e.: the depth of basin should correspond to the photic zone. The fossil bacteria in the Sinsk deposits were found to be the most abundant and diverse in thin-layered parts of the sequence and a little less diverse in the more solid parts of the sequence. It is well known that all cyanobacterial communities form expressive layered structures with the characteristic alteration of mineral layers with development zones of different microorganism groups. Since the mats are only slightly pervious, the formation of minerals in thin layers connected with the type of bacteria is assisted. It cannot be excluded that it is the layered structure of the cyanobacterial community that is responsible for the presence of tubes with papillae—cyanobacteria—in thin-layered rocks. Sometimes it looks as if these rocks consist of bacterial remains. The fact that the communities were buried in vital position is an advantage. The preservation of the layered structure serves as a confirmation of such a conclusion. Hence, it can be suggested that the thin-layered part of Sinsk formation is mainly vitally buried remains of cyanobacterial mat. The presence of cyanobacteria by themselves in the Sinsk formation suggests the formation of its rocks in the photic zone, i.e.: under conditions of a relatively shallow-water basin and correspondingly about sufficient shallow waters of the Sinsk basin as a whole [8]. 4. Thin Threads There is one other type of filamentous biomorphic structure in specimens under investigation. This type is represented by very thin, straight threads or threads with branches (Fig. 1 (e)–(f)). In the recent stage of investigation these threads are considered to be actinomycetes. But these forms appear to be embedded in surface; hence, these forms can be considered to be later contamination. Acknowledgments The author is grateful to everyone who has promoted this work, especially A.Yu. Rozanov, E.A.Z Zhegallo, G.T. Ushatinskaja, and L.M. Gerasimenko for their contribution to discussion of the results, and L.T. Protasevich for his assistance in electron microscope investigation. This study was supported by the Russian Foundation for Basic Research (projects 00–15–97764, 99–04–48806, and 00–05–64603). References [1] Lower Cambrian stage subdivision. Stratigraphy 1984; 184. [2] Rozanov AYu, Repina LN, Apollonov MK, et al., Cambrian of Siberia. Novosibirsk. All-Russian Inc. Moscow: Nauka;1992. p.135.
10
M.M. Astafieva / Bacteriomorphic Structures from the Sinsk Formation
[3] Gorlenko VM, Dubinina GA, Kuznezov CI. Ecology of water microorganisms. Moscow, Nauka. [4] Gromov BV, Pavlenko GV. Ecology of bacteria. L.:University Press; 1989. p. 248. [5] Jones B, Renaut RW, Rosen MR. Microbial biofacies in hot-spring sinters: a model based on Ohaaki Pool, North Island, New Zealand. J. of Sedimentary Res., 68:1998; 413–34. [6] Zavarzin GA, The development of microbial communities in the history of Earth. The problems of preanthropogenous evolution of the biosphere. Moscow: Nauka; 1993. p. 212–21. [7] Gerasimenko LM, Zavarzin GA. The relict cyanobacterial communities. The problems of preanthropogenous evolution of the biosphere. Moscow: Nauka; 1993. p. 222–53. [8] Rozanov A Yu, Zavarzin GA. Bacterial paleontology. Herald of the Russian Academy of Sciences 1997:67; 109–13.
Perspectives in Astrobiology R.B. Hoover et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
11
Constraining Subglacial Settings Using Clay-Supported Ice Rafted Detritus (Mud Grains) in Antarctic Marine Sediment: A Framework for Astrobiology Rosalba BONACCORSIa,*, Antonio BRAMBATIa, Lloyd H. BURCKLEb and Alexander M. PIOTROWSKIb a Dip. di Scienze Geologiche, Ambientali e Marine (DiSGAM) University of Trieste, Via E. Weiss, 2 34127, TS, Italy b Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory, Columbia University, Rt. 9W Palisades, NY 10964, United States * Geokarst Engineering s.r.l AREA Science Park, Padriciano 99-34012, TS, Italy (present address) Abstract. The subglacial Antarctic Ice Sheet is one of the lesser known and most inaccessible places for direct sampling. This work, conducted under the Italian Program for Antarctic Research (PNRA), aims to use results of multicomponent analyses and observations on ice proximal marine sediment cores (Ross Sea, Glomar Challenger Area) as the key data set to introduce the first general sedimentary model(s) into an Astrobiology Roadmap scientific scheme, i.e.: Goals 5 and 8. Information obtained from Antarctic glacigenic sediments can provide plausible models for planetary bodies where glacial ice fields and related processes occur (i.e., the ice caps of Mars, and Jupiter’s icy moon, Europa). The analyses (Corg and biogenic opal) on diamicton mud grains (MDGS) suggest that fine-grained ice rafted detritus (IRD) can retain their original depositional settings, e.g.; exposed outcrops and subglacial lake basins, after incorporation within marine sediment and provide some information on the Antarctic interiors eroded by the East and West Antarctic Ice Sheets. Finally, observations on marine and ice cores suggest that MDGS and siltclay aggregates are more widely distributed throughout Antarctic sediments and glacial fields than previously believed. The most reliable models should consider potential sources and processes/mechanisms explaining high-Corg content in subglacially-derived material. Ice proximal marine sediment would provide an unlimited amount of MDGS samples as continent-derived material as test sources of organics of use in astrobiological research.
Introduction Among a variety of extreme settings, e.g.: permafrost, ultra-cold deserts, ice covered lakes, and subglacial cavities, the subglacial Antarctic Ice Sheets are among the lesser known and most inaccessible places to sample and approach through remote observations. Goals 5, 7, and 8 of the science scheme of the NASA Astrobiology Roadmap [1] address constraints on the limits of life in past- and present-day extreme environments. Information obtained from fine-grained IRD can provide plausible models for Antarctic glacial ice fields and subgla-
12
R. Bonaccorsi et al. / Constraining Subglacial Settings Using Clay-Supported Ice Rafted Detritus
Figure 1. Antarctic map showing the study area and sites with MDGS-associated observations—marine (solid dots), sea-ice cores (diamonds), and areas where subglacial lakes have been remotely detected (triangles) [14,15]: (1) Byrd Ice Core [16], (2) Vostok Ice Core [17,18], (3) Dry Valleys, and Taylor Glacierassociated moraines deposits [19], (4) sea-ice core at J–9 site [20], (5) J–9 site—sub-ice shelf sediments [7], (6) tertiary diamictons from CRP–1 [12], (7a) and (7b) late Quaternary marine sequences from the Western Ross Sea [8,13], (8) Prydz Bay [8], (9) cores ANTA95–77C2 [4] and ANTA95–89C outer slope settings (dots), (10) core ANTA98–16 (star) (M. Romana, personal communication, 2001); and (11) other central Eastern Ross Sea cores [21].
cial pools. Those extreme settings represent useful test beds for Mars ice caps [2] and icy moons, such as Europa, where analogue environments have been observed and/or are expected [2,3]. Glaciomarine diamicton sequences from the Antarctic continental margins (ice proximal zone) are mostly made up of in situ marine sediment mixed with variable amounts of subglacially derived material, i.e.: IRD including MDGS (Figs 2(b) and 3(b)–(d)) [4,5]. All IRD, and thus, diamicton MDGS, are definitely glacially scoured from the Antarctic interiors by the West Antarctic Ice Sheet (WAIS) (Fig. 1) and East Antarctic Ice Sheet (EAIS). As a result, cores from the ice proximal zone (Figs 1 and 2(a)) can also recover material from large areas associated with their (palaeo) drainage basin [6–11]. Downcore abundance and the composition of IRD lithic fractions in these types of sediment (Fig. 3) are generally used as proxies for change in the palaeoclimate-palaeoenvironmental signal, e.g.: calving events resulting from glacial/interglacial pulses of the ice sheet/ice shelf system, or for tracking sediment provenance [4–5,7–13]. Here the IRD are observed using a different paradigm. Why Are Antarctic Diamictons Relevant to Astrobiology-Addressed Research? Here we will support evidence that clay-supported IRD MDGS incorporated in Antarctic marine sediment, and/or diamicton matrix, can still retain information concerning their original settings. Although many possible sources can be expected for MDGS, this work mainly deals with possible provenance from subglacial sources, which are widespread beneath the EAIS, e.g.: subglacial lake basins in the East Antarctic Craton [14,15], and WAIS, e.g.: Byrd Basin area [6]. Then, results of multi-component analyses and observa-
R. Bonaccorsi et al. / Constraining Subglacial Settings Using Clay-Supported Ice Rafted Detritus
13
Figure 2. (a) Schematic sketch of the Antarctic continental shelf and slope with bathymetric depth and core locations, and (b) example of glaciomarine sediment containing iceberg rafted debris (IBRD) and MDGS from the deep-sea core ANTA95–89C.
Figure 3. (a) Chronostratigraphy of Core ANTA95–77C2 with indication of sampled depth-intervals and (b)– (e) photographs of MDGS/Matrix samples.
tions on ice proximal marine sediment cores (Ross Sea and Glomar Challenger Area) are used to draft the first general sedimentary model(s) of the Antarctic ice cap subglacialcontinental margin system into an Astrobiology Roadmap scientific scheme [1]. Building a conceptual model for the exchange of fine-grained debris and thus of energy between the atmosphere and the Antarctic subglacial habitats and between the Antarctic subglacial habitats and the sea would provide a useful test bed for two relevant astrobiology-related issues.
14
R. Bonaccorsi et al. / Constraining Subglacial Settings Using Clay-Supported Ice Rafted Detritus
First, the study of terrestrial analogues, such as subglacial diamicton and ice proximal glacial marine sediment, can aid prediction for similar settings at the Mars polar regions [2]. Thus, if continental/subglacial sources of organic matter can be unequivocally retained and unraveled in glacial marine sediment, the same type of information could be obtained from those Mars polar regions where they are expected. In fact, in Mars’ polar environment, IRDs and fine-grained sublimation tills (requiring cold and arid extreme) are considered suitable terrestrial analogues of Martian floods and their sampling was proposed under the Mars Pathfinder (MPF) landing-site selection [2]. Second, such a model would frame the possibility that subglacial lakes are really the most isolated ecosystem on Earth. Indeed, it is thought that subglacial lakes, such as Lake Vostok, are valuable analogues for possible ice-covered oceans of icy moons, such as Europa and Callisto [3].
1. Background 1.1. Mud Grains Are Widely Distributed in Glaciated Areas MDGS were first recognized as nonlithic, mud-supported ice-rafted particles in core ANTA95–77C2 (75° 50.0' S and 177° 42.9' W; at 627-m depth and 118.5-cm long) [4] and core ANTA95–89C (74° 29.100' S and 175° 34.059' W at 2058-m depth and 404-cm long (outer Slope) (Figs 2(a) and (b) and 3). Mud-supported particles were observed in a variety of cases. The map of Antarctica (Fig. 1) shows sites with MDGS-associated observations.
2. Material and Methods Multiple analyses of selected mud grains, sedimentary rock particles (SRP), and their hosting matrix were conducted on large-sized samples (30–50 mg). They were extracted from Unit A (glacial marine to open-sea lithofacies), Unit B (reworked diamicton), and Unit C (subglacial diamicton) of Core ANTA95–77C2 (Fig. 3) [4,5]. Selected grains were gently removed from external layer in order to ensure a few - mg aliquots of pure sample for separate analyses. The supporting matrix was crushed into small fragments for obtaining representative MDGS-free samples. A PerkinElmer® 2400 CHN Elemental Analyzer and a Carlo Erba® NA1500 were used for elemental analysis of total carbon and total organic carbon (TOC) determination. CaCO3 was measured with a carbon dioxide coulometer. Stereoscope, microscope, and smear slide observations (with a petrology microscope) were made to identify mud grain types and evaluate their qualitative content (fine-grained biogenic and mineral particles). Scanning electron microscope (SEM) photomicrographs on silty-sized centrifuged material were taken with a Leica® Stereoscan 430i. Full details have been provided [10,14,22].
3. Results MDGS contain higher TOC (0.36–0.77%; 0.57±0.09%; n=16) than the supporting matrix (0.29–0.51%; 0.40±0.06%; n=15) and SRP (0.16–0.43%; 0.32±0.09%; n=10) (Fig. 4 (c)). In MDGS, CaCO3 is the most variable parameter (0.09–54.4%; 0.32±0.09%) (Fig. 4 (a)); biogenic opal is constant throughout the matrix (12.91±16.43%; 15.1±1.1%; n=8) (Fig. 4(b)
R. Bonaccorsi et al. / Constraining Subglacial Settings Using Clay-Supported Ice Rafted Detritus
15
Figure 4. XY diagrams showing: (a) TOC versus Opal, (b) CaCO3 versus Opal, (c) TOC versus CaCO3, and (d) TOC matrix versus TOC component. See Section 4 for explanation.
and (d)) but highly variable in MDGS (4.2–44.0%; 32.8±14.4%; n=7). Matrix and MDGS belong to separate fields of the XY diagrams (Fig. 4 (a)–(d)) and show statistically significant compositional (z-Test two sample for means, two-tails: p<0.01) and textural differences. The ample range of Corg content (0.05–54.4%) found in MDGS, thus, could indicate quite different sedimentary settings. Furthermore, Sample GS–Y, 95–97 cm, contains small numbers of late Pleistocene diatoms (Opal=2.7%wt, clay-sized fraction) while authigenic minerals, i.e.: gypsum, carbonates, occur in the silt-sized fraction (SEM observation). In this sample, the extremely high Corg (TOC=~4.8%) and authigenic calcite (CaCO3=54.4%) highly contrast with values found in the embedding matrix, i.e.: Sample MX–95–97 cm (TOC=0.43%; CaCO3=0.21%; and Opal=~14%), and occur together with a mantle-derived radiogenic isotope signature, i.e., epsilon Nd(0)=~+4.6 and 87Sr/86Sr = 0.704–0.705 (for the leached, i.e.: carbonate-free, fraction) [10]. Those values resulted within the range of Antarctic Ice core Dome C [22], are associated with volcanic-derived detritus. This might indicate a subglacial setting where both volcanic debris (either from dust particles, or subglacial mud volcanoes sources) and relatively abundant organic sources are available. The highest TOC content of Sample GS– Y, 95–97 cm could derive from either organic-rich sources or efficient mechanisms of concentration of organics.
4. Discussion Several types of MDGS were observed (Fig. 3 (b)–(e)). First, the geochemical (Fig. 4) and textural variability [10,11] between the MDGS and the matrix indicate different sources and, at least for the studied cases, confirm a separate origin from their hosting matrix. Second, their widespread TOC, CaCO3, and opal % contents (Figs 4a–d) suggests that they can retain different sedimentary environments. The possibility that such grains can maintain the geochemical identity after their incorporation into over compacted and soft diamictons is in agreement with former observation of ice rafted material, i.e.: till pellets, incorporated in bottom marine sediment from their sources [18].
16
R. Bonaccorsi et al. / Constraining Subglacial Settings Using Clay-Supported Ice Rafted Detritus
Figure 5. SEM microphotographs of bulk silt-sized detritus from Sample GS–Y 95–97 cm.
At this point, a general model is needed; one that takes into account the widespread presence (geographic, environmental, and stratigraphic) and composition of such grains and draws relationship with their potential source areas (PSA).
5. Models, Sources, Processes, and Lithospheric Setting The most reliable models should consider the four following possibilities: (1) Potential sources, (2) processes at the ice sheet/bedrock interface, (3) alternative mechanisms explaining high degree of compaction of MDGS, e.g.: colloidal fractions bounding in ice pores [23], and (4) a final step consisting of embedding/preservation of MDGS within different settings, i.e.: subglacial, glacial marine, and open-sea sediment. 5.1. Potential Sources Subglacial pools throughout the East Antarctic Craton and West Antarctic Rift System are potential sources. Although TOC values alone are inadequate to distinguish among different sources of organic material, it is reasonable to hypothesize that certain amounts of organics found in MDGS could have some microbial source. Specifically, grains, such as Sample GS–Y, 95–97 cm (Fig. 3 (d) and Fig. 5) might have embedded fine-grained detritus from subglacial lake/pool systems. It is well known today that heterotrophic bacteria occurs in subglacial lake-associated sediments, such as those discovered near the basal layer of the Vostok ice core [24]. This type of bacterial material could be exported, then, toward more distal settings, e.g.: glaciomarine sediment, from glaciers overriding the lake basin and by silt-sized particles adhering to subglacial/englacial layers of freeze-on material. This possibility can be argued from the following: • • •
Muddy palletized material is currently observed from basal portions of ice cores, including the Vostok ice core. The widespread presence of subglacial lakes (up to 76 distinct basins) is well established through ice-penetrating radar from continental areas, such as the East Antarctic Craton [14,15,25] and the West Antarctic Rift. Those areas are part of a drainage system. This implies the existence of links between the subglacial pool systems and overriding ice sheets [15], and between the ice stream’s flow trajectories into the Ross Ice Shelf (RIS) and its outward continental margin [10].
In addition, the presence of authigenic calcium carbonate and gypsum, associated with abundant organic matter (Fig. 5), is in agreement with those observations made on the
R. Bonaccorsi et al. / Constraining Subglacial Settings Using Clay-Supported Ice Rafted Detritus
17
dirty-ice basal layer of the Vostok ice core (John Priscu, 2001 personal communication) containing subglacial microbial loop [17,18,24]. Furthermore, the presence of framboidal pyrite indicating low-energy/reducing environments could be consistent with such a source. At this point, it must be said that the estimated microbial biomass for Dry Valley Lakes, e.g.: Fryxell, Hoare, and Bonney, is several orders of magnitude higher (0.3–5 µg C L–1 and 436–818 µg C L–1) [26] than those found in the Vostok accreted ice (<0.1–0.003 µg C L–1) in which oligotrophic conditions, i.e.: TOC=6.6–7.5 µmol L-1) are expected [24]. However, the amount of organics in the near-surface sediments surrounding Lake Vostok may be higher than those found in the accreted ice if concentration mechanisms were acting there. Also, subglacial lakes other than Vostok could have different degrees of trophic conditions. Such a subglacial pool could have provided clay material to form certain types of MDGS. 5.2. Other Sources Sources other than subglacial lakes can be inferred from observations made on some mud grains. MDGS might be related to different modes of superglacial, subglacial to englacial drift at the bedrock/ice-sheet interface. For instance, ice-covered (epiglacial) lakes as those just mentioned above [26] could provide some organic-rich material. Furthermore, MDGS could represent the following four cases: (1) The remains of unconsolidated sedimentary deposits from land, e.g.: Beacon Supergroup, or exposed soils/permafrost from the ultra cold Dry Valley region near Taylor Glacier [19] and the Transantarctic Mountains; (2) stiff, but still remolded material, simply eroded from the exposed inner shelf by overriding grounded ice shelves during glacial advances or wind blown during major katabatic wind events; (3) the upstream erosion of subglacial marine-derived sedimentary basin located in the central Eastern Ross Sea [6,7,21]; and (4) marine sediments affected by sub marine erosion through gravitational processes. In case 3, sources of reworked/old carbon and varying amounts of biogenic opal could be beneath WAIS [20] and RIS where sedimentary basins of tertiary age occur. Furthermore, according to case 1, well-rounded quartz, i.e.: sand-sized grains, included in some MDGS may indicate that they were wrapped by some adhering organic-bearing clay, probably after erosion from sandstone in the Beacon group (south of David Glacier, East Antarctica), as reviewed by Anderson et al., (1992).
6. Models 6.1. Conceptual Model Figure 6 attempts a schematic, integrated model of WAIS, incorporating potential sources and processes, e.g.: freezing-on, responsible for the exchange of mineral and organic debris at the ice-sheet ice-sediment interfaces and throughout different Antarctic settings, i.e.: atmosphere, cryosphere, land, and sea. The interior ice reservoir below the ice divide is the portion of the ice sheet coupled with its bed. The ice slides over its bed from the onset region towards the ice shelf (open arrows). The fast-moving glaciers, i.e.: ice streams A–F, drain the interior ice flowing between regions of relatively stagnant ice (ice domes) and penetrate the RIS. The lubricating till lies beneath the ice streams and the graben system (or the East Antarctic Craton System), which is filled by sediments. Basal melting at the ice/sub-ice and gravitational transport would allow sinking of windblown materials (atmospheric sources) throughout the ice caps in an open rather than closed-system. Entrainment of material (rock flour and ancient marine sediment) from subglacial systems and links with atmosphere and coastal setting are also shown by different types of arrows.
18
R. Bonaccorsi et al. / Constraining Subglacial Settings Using Clay-Supported Ice Rafted Detritus
Figure 6. Schematic model of WAIS (modified from http://www.ig.utexas.edu/research/projects/wais).
7. Processes 7.1. Sediment Caption Caption/uploading, transport, and deposition of subglacial fine-grained sediments by glaciers and ice streams has to deal with those subglacial processes, i.e.: freeze-on, occurring at the sediment bed/ice interface [6,7,10,26]. In this framework different basal ice/thermal conditions (above and below the freezing point) have been proposed, e.g.; wet- to dry-based glaciers and ice sheets [26]. These conditions could be important because, among other things, they could either favor or contrast the formation/persistence of mud grains and processes responsible for the accretion of clay material around lithic nuclei, as well. 7.2. Incorporation in Different Types of Diamicton Matrix Some grains appeared to be more compositionally similar to their host diamicton matrix, e.g.: tertiary diatom-bearing grains. This may result from more interactions, e.g.: subglacial stress in over compacted diamicton, between grains and host matrix during their incorporation within the matrix itself and/or the deposition of glaciomarine diamictons. Indeed, several steps could be possible between the incorporation of fine grained sediment in the basal ice sheet and, thus, the world-wide presence of mud pellets in ice cores; their embedding into subglacial diamicton as ice shelf rafted debris; and the release of plastic mud grains after calving as IBRD (Fig. 2 (a)). The strong resistance to mixing of MDGS found in sedimentary sequence from ice shelf located cores only apparently contrasts with the instability on melting observed for those muddy particles that were tentatively isolated from Arctic and Antarctic ice cores [10].
8. Conclusions and Final Remarks 1. Unraveling the biogeochemical signals retained in subglacial ice rafted materials (Antarctic analogs) would provide a relevant issue for sampling return missions focused on Mars polar cap candidates where similar deposits are expected.
R. Bonaccorsi et al. / Constraining Subglacial Settings Using Clay-Supported Ice Rafted Detritus
19
2. Compositional and textural differences in mud grains must be the result of a combination of different glacial/subglacial sources and processes involving different types of materials (soils, loose sediment, and sedimentary sequences). 3. Marine sediment core samples, therefore, offer practical advantages—such as the ability to test a wide variety of subglacial settings deposited at different times, e.g.: Mesozoic to Pliocene and late Pleistocene to recent; an unlimited amount of different sources providing direct sampling on subglacial ecosystems from the past; and improved information to constrain subglacial models. 4. Improved conceptual model for the exchange of organic debris throughout different Antarctic compartments (atmosphere, cryosphere, land, and sea) would test the hypothesis that Antarctic subglacial lakes are a real isolated ecosystem and, thus, provide useful analogues for the ice-covered ocean(s) of Europa. 5. The extensive use of MDGS in astrobiological research should be tested using (1) elemental, chromatographic, and stable isotope analyses (EA-IRMS, and GC-MS) on bulk organics, e.g.: δ13C-org, δ15N-tot/org, and associated biomarker compounds (M. Romana, personal communication, 2001) and (2) a combination of advanced techniques, e.g.: Epifluorescence, FESEM, and ion microprobe, to search for microfossils, dormant spores, viable bacteria [19], and any associated biomarkers, e.g.: biologically-precipitated mineral phases.
Acknowledgments This work was funded by PNRA, the Office of Polar Programs (National Science Foundation) to lHB and a grant/cooperative agreement from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA). The authors are grateful to R.F. Anderson and S. Hemming for supporting TOC and Carbonate measurements and radiogenic isotope data at LamontDoherty Earth Observatory (L-DEO); and F. Drake (SETI Institute) for an early review of this work. Also, special thanks go to G.P. Fanzutti, F. Finocchiaro (DiSGAM), and R. Melis for valuable discussions. Special thanks are also due to L. Barker and P. Malone (L-DEO), and T. Quaia (for assistance with analyses at L-DEO and DiSGAM, respectively), and T. Ubaldini (University of Trieste) for assistance with SEM. The views expressed herein are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of NOAA or any of its sub-agencies.
References [1] Morrison D, Schmidt GK. NASA Astrobiology Roadmap. Moffet Field, CA: ARC 1999; 1–44. http://astrobiology.arc.nasa.gov/roadmap/goals/index.html. [2] Rice JW. Getting the first crack at Noachian clasts and sediments: a pathfinder’s prospectus. In: Workshop on Early Mars: Geologic and Hydrologic Evolution, Physical and Chemical Environments, and the Implications for Life. Houston, TX: April 24–27, 1997. http://www.lpi.usra.edu/meetings/earlymars/ pdf/3054.pdf. [3] Carr MH, Belton MJ, Chapman CR, Davies ME, Geissler P, et al. Evidence for a subsurface ocean on Europa. Nature 1998; 391: 363–5. [4] Bonaccorsi R, Brambati A, Finocchiaro F, Quaia T. From Basal till to Open-water sedimentation: late Quaternary to Early Holocene changes from Core ANTA95–77C2 (Glomar Challenger Basin, Ross Sea). Terra Antartica Report 2000; 4: 241–58. [5] Bonaccorsi R, Burckle HL, Brambati A, and 4 other authors. Multi-component analyses on Diamicton Mud Grains (Glomar Challenger, Ross Sea, Antarctica): can they track sources and processes related to the Ice Sheet/Ice Shelf System? Suppl. to EOS 2000; 81(19): 269. [6] Truswell EM, Drewry DJ. Distribution and provenance of recycled palynomorphs in surficial sediments of the Ross Sea, Antarctica. Marine Geology 1984; 59: 187–214.
20
R. Bonaccorsi et al. / Constraining Subglacial Settings Using Clay-Supported Ice Rafted Detritus
[7] Webb PN, Ronan TE, Lipps JH, DeLaca ??. Miocene Glaciomarine Sediments from beneath the Southern Ross Ice Shelf, Antarctica. Science 1979; 203: 435–7. [8] Domack EW, Harris PT, Taylor F, Quilty PG, De Santis L, Raker B. Late Quaternary sediment facies in Prydz Bay, East Antarctica and their relationship to glacial advance onto the continental shelf. Antarctic Science 1998; 10(3): 236–46. [9] Domack EW, Harris PT. A new depositional model for ice-shelves, based upon sediment core from the Ross Sea and the Mac Robertson shelf, Antarctica. Annals of Glaciology 1998; 27: 281–4. [10] Bonaccorsi R. Evolution of the Ice Sheet - Ice Shelf - Continental margin system (Ross Sea, Antarctica) from late Quaternary sedimentary records. University of Trieste 2001; Ph.D. thesis: 1–241. [11] Bonaccorsi R. Investigation on the non-lithic Ice rafted debris (Mud Grains) as source of continental/reworked organic matter affecting AMS 14C dating of Antarctic marine sediments. In: Young Researchers Project 2nd Year. University of Trieste 2002; Internal Report: 1–60. [12] Van der Meer JJM, Hiemstra JF. Micromorphology of Miocene Diamict, indication of grounded Ice. Terra Antarctica 1998; 5(3): 363–6. [13] Domack EW, Jacobson EA, Shipp S, Anderson JB. Late Pleistocene-Holocene retreat of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet system in the Ross Sea: Part 2 – Sedimentologic and stratigraphic signature. GSA Bulletin 1999; 111(10): 1517–36. [14] Siegert MJ, Dowdeswell JA, Gorman MR, McIntyre NF. An Inventory of Antarctic sub-glacial lakes. Antarctic Science 1996; 8: 281–6. [15] Siegert MJ, Kwok R, Mayer C, Hubbard B. Water exchange between the subglacial Lake Vostok and the overlying ice sheet. Nature 2000; 404: 643–6. [16] Gow AJ, Meese DA. Nature of basal debris in the GISP2 and Byrd ice cores and its relevance to bed processes. Annals of Glaciology 1996; 22: 134–40. [17] Jouzel J, Petit JR, Souchez R, et al. More than 200 meters of lake ice above subglacial Lake Vostok, Antarctica. Science 1999; 286: 2138–41. [18] Priscu ??, et al. Geomicrobiology of Subglacial Ice Above Lake Vostok, Antarctica. Science 1999; 286: 2141–4. [19] Fitzsimons SJ. Formation of thrust-block moraines at the margins of dry-based glaciers, south Victoria Land, Antarctica. Annals of Glaciology 1996; 22: 68–74. [20] Zotikov IA, Jacobs S. Oceanic inclusions in the J-9 sea-ice core. Antarctic Journal of the U.S. 1985; 20(5): 113–5. [21] Kluiving SJ, Bartek LR, van der Wateren FM. Multi-scale analyses of subglacial and glaciomarine deposits from the Ross Sea continental shelf, Antarctica. Annals of Glaciology 1999; 28: 90–6. [22] Grousset FE, Biscaye PE, Revel M, Petit JR, Pye K, Joussaume S, Jouzel J. Antarctic (Dome C) ice-core dust at 18 kyr. B.P: Isotopic constraints and origins. Earth and Planetary Science Letters 1992; 111: 175–82. [23] Ovenshine AT. Observations of Iceberg Rafting in Glacier Bay, Alaska, and the Identification of Ancient Ice-Rafted Deposits. GSA Bulletin 1970; 81: 891–4. [24] Karl DM, Bird DF, Björkman K, Houlihan T, Shackelford R, Tupas L. Microorganisms in the Accreted Ice of Lake Vostok. Science 1999; 286: 2144–7. [25] Kapitsa A, Ridley JK, Robin G, Siegert MJ, Zotikov I. Large deep fresh-water lake beneath the ice of central East Antarctica. Nature 1996; 381: 684–6. [26] Takacs CD, Priscu JC. Bacterioplankton Dynamics in the McMurdo Dry Valley Lakes, Antarctica: Production and Biomass Loss over Four Seasons. Microbial Ecology 1998; 36: 239–50.
Perspectives in Astrobiology R.B. Hoover et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
21
Apsidal Motion Problem in the Eclipsing Binary Star DR Vulpeculae Caner ÇIÇEK Çanakkale Onsekiz Mart University, Faculty Arts and Sciences, Department of physics, TR-17100 Çanakkale, Turkey
[email protected] Abstract. Photoelectric observations of the DR Vulpeculae (Vul) have been carried out in B and V colors at the Ege University Observatory and new light curves have been obtained for the system. The O-C diagram was analyzed using all reliable timings found in the literature and new values for the elements of the apsidal motion was computed. The apsidal motion period of the system, 36.8 yr, was obtained.
Introduction The variability of DR Vul (BD+260 3835=HDE 339770) was discovered in 1935 by Hoffmeister, [1]. In 1950, Tsesevich [2] assigned DR Vul to the β Lyr type and determined its period. Erloksova [3] constructed a mean light curve for DR Vul. The form of the mean light curve enabled Erloksova to assign this system to the Algol-type eclipsing stars. In investigating the variation of the period of DR Vul, Erloksova discovered a rotation of the line of apsides with a period 25 yr. Semeniuk [4] obtained the first photoelectric measurements of the brightness of DR Vul. Semeniuk constructed an O-C graph and from it, estimated the period of rotation of the line of apsides, U=38.5 yr, e=0.092, w=25.4 for the epoch of 1950. O’Connell [5] constructed the first complete photoelectric light curve of DR Vul and determined the photometric elements of the system. The O-C graph, based on photoelectric times of minima alone, enabled the determination the period of apsidal rotation, U=37.8 yr. Khaliullina [6] found a value of 36 yr and suggested the possibility of a superposition of two additional longer periods due to light-time effects. The light curve was published by Khaliullina and Khaliullin [7]. The apsidal motion of DR Vul was discussed by Wolf and Diethelm [8]. Finally, Wolf et al. [9] found a value of 36.3 yr for apsidal motion.
1. Observations DR Vul was observed photoelectrically at the Ege University Observatory on 40 nights during The 1993 and 1994 observing seasons. All observations were made with B and V filters which are very close to Johnson’s standard system. BD 260 3827 and BD 260 3837 were used as comparison and check stars, respectively. The data related to the variable comparison and check stars are given in Table 1. During the observations, no significant light variation of the comparison and check star was found. The atmospheric extinction coefficients in each color for each observational night were calculated from the observations of the comparison star using conventional methods. Then, all the instrumental differential B and V
22
C. Çiçek / Apsidal Motion Problem in the Eclipsing Binary Star DR Vulpeculae
Table 1. The data for the observed stars.
Figure 1. The light and color curves of DR Vul in 1993.
magnitudes (in the sense of variable minus comparison) were corrected for atmospheric extinction and the light time effect of the Earth’s motion. The instrumental differential B and V light and B-V color curves are shown in Figs 1 and 2. The photometric phases in Figs 1 and 2 are calculated by using the following light elements given by Çiçek, [10]:
HJD Min I JD = 2449162.4631(2) + 2 d .2509350(15) E.
(1)
2. Apsidal Motion Analysis During the observations of DR Vul, 12 primary and 7 secondary times of minima have been obtained by Çiçek, [11]. These minima have been presented in Table 2. Observed minima in different filters but in same epoch were averaged. The O-C values were calculated with the Eq. (1) using the following light elements given by Çiçek [11]. Observations of times of minima provide a simple method of determining the apsidal motion rate. For the eclipsing binaries with low orbital eccentricity, moments of the minima were given by Martynov [7], as follows: HJD Min = To + P.E + {± A cos( wo + w& E )},
(2)
where –A is for the primary minimum and E is integer, +A is for secondary minimum and E is halved, wo is the longitude of the periastron at an initial time and w& is the apsidal motion rate. The amplitude, A, in Eq. (2) is given by
C. Çiçek / Apsidal Motion Problem in the Eclipsing Binary Star DR Vulpeculae
23
Figure 2. The light and color curves of DR Vul in 1994. Table 2. New photoelectric minima times of DR Vul.
A = Pe
(1 + cos ec 2 i) , 2π
(3)
where e is eccentricity and i is orbital inclination. To improve the apsidal motion parameters, the differential correction method was used. The light elements given by Khaliullina [6] were used as initial values. By applying Eq. (1) to primary and secondary times of minima simultaneously, new light elements of the system were obtained. The result is as follows:
24
C. Çiçek / Apsidal Motion Problem in the Eclipsing Binary Star DR Vulpeculae
Figure 3. The O-C diagram for DR Vul.
HJD Min = 2446274 d .5038(10) + 2 d .25089080(32) E + 4.25(30)10 −9 E 2 ± 0.0701(7) cos(0 o.06076(34) E + 71o.30(81)) .
(4)
The computed O-C curves obtained with the above parameters are shown in Fig. 3. All times of minimum collected by Khaliullina [5], as well as the new ones given in Table 2, were used in this calculation. All Photoelectric and CCD times of minimum were used with a weight 1 in this computation. The current photographic data (as well as some of less precise measurements) were weighted with a factor of 0.2 while the earlier visual and photographic times of minimum were given a weight of 0.04 due to the large scatter in P gives the observed value of apsidal motion period to these data. The relation U obs = 360o w& be Uobs = 36.8 yr.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12]
Hoeffmeister C. AN 1935; 225: 405. Tsesevich VP.), Astron. Tsirk. 1950; 100. Erloksova GE. Perem. Zvezdy 1959; 12: 298. Semeniuk I. AcA 1968; 18: 1. O’Connell JK. Ric. Astron. Specola Vaticana 1972; 8: 14. Khaliullina AI. DR Vulpeculae—the quadruple system. MNRAS 1987; 225: 425–36. Khaliullina AI, Khaliullin KhF. Photometric investigation of the eclipsing binary star DR VUL-orbital parameters and apsidal motion. AZh 1988; 65: 108–16. Wolf M, Diethelm R. Period changes in the eclipsing binary Dr-vulpeculae. MNRAS 1993; 263: 527. Wolf M, Diethelm R, Sarounova L. A&A 1999; 345: 553. Çiçek C. [Ph.D. Thesis]. 1995. Unpublished. Çiçek C. IAU IBVS 2001; 5142. Martynov DYa. ed. Zessewitch, Moscow: 1971; 325.
Perspectives in Astrobiology R.B. Hoover et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
25
Amino Acids: Probes for Life’s Origin in the Solar System Michael H. ENGELa, Vlad E. ANDRUSa and Stephen A. MACKOb a School of Geology & Geophysics, The University of Oklahoma Norman, Oklahoma 73019 USA b Department of Environmental Sciences, The University of Virginia Charlottesville, Virginia 22903 USA
Abstract. Several hundred amino acids have been identified in organisms, but only 20 are the building blocks of proteins. As best as can be determined from the fossil record, the 20 protein amino acids have never varied with respect to structure or stereochemistry. Approximately 55 amino acids that have yet to be discovered in modern terrestrial organisms have been identified in carbonaceous meteorites. If life originated on Earth, a fundamental question that remains to be answered is what were the source(s) and mechanisms of formation of the amino acids that preceded life? Laboratory simulation experiments have not resulted in the synthesis of all of the protein amino acids. Also, these experiments always produce racemic amino acids (D/L=1), whereas life as we know it is based almost exclusively on L-amino acids. The alternative to laboratory synthesis has been investigations of ancient rocks, terrestrial and extraterrestrial. Given that life is ubiquitous on present-day Earth and no rock is an entirely closed system, the challenge has been to distinguish ancient, indigenous amino acids from those more recently introduced via contact with the Earth’s biosphere. Amino acids in Precambrian rocks are not easily distinguished from modern overprints. However, amino acids in carbonaceous meteorites with short residence times on Earth provide a unique opportunity to begin to assess what the Earth’s organic inventory may have been like prior to life’s origin. In addition to numerous exotic amino acids, several of the common protein amino acids essential for life occur in the Murchison and Orgueil meteorites. More importantly, these amino acids exhibit the L-enantiomer excess that was, arguably, a necessary precondition for the origin of life. The stable isotope composition of amino acids in the Murchison meteorite confirms their authenticity. It is hypothesized that at least some of the starting materials for life on Earth may have been introduced by impact events. There are several protein amino acids that occur in all living organisms on Earth but have not been synthesized in the laboratory by abiotic mechanisms and have not been detected in carbonaceous meteorites. It is suggested that the presence of these amino acids, e.g.: Phe, Lys, His, and Arg, on other planetary bodies would by evidence for the existence of life as we know it.
Introduction Soils, sediments, and sedimentary rocks on Earth contain a variety of organic compounds derived primarily from the biosphere. Compounds whose origins can be traced back to specific organisms are called biomarkers. Thus, most compounds—such as amino acids, sugars, and fatty acids, the building blocks of proteins, carbohydrates, and lipids—are not, by definition, biomarkers. They are essential components of all organisms, past and present. A
26
M.H. Engel et al. / Amino Acids: Probes for Life’s Origin in the Solar System
consequence of the ubiquitous nature of these compounds has been the extreme difficulty in distinguishing their origins in ancient materials. Given that all rocks and sediments are open systems, it is not yet possible to determine the extent to which organic compounds, such as amino acids, in ancient rocks are autochthonous or reflect a series of inputs from numerous sources with the passage of time. And, even if it were possible to establish that amino acids in ancient, Precambrian rocks, such as those in southern West Greenland, were the same age as the rocks in which they are contained, it is still not possible to establish whether these compounds formed by biotic or abiotic processes. The reasons for these uncertainties will be discussed below. Why amino acids, rather than other types of essential compounds, became the focus of attention for life’s origin may be attributed to a series of discoveries in the 1950s and early 1960s. Abelson [1] first reported the occurrence of amino acids in fossils. This discovery led to immediate speculation that it might be possible to begin to probe evolutionary change at the molecular level by establishing the amino acid sequences of proteins and peptides in fossils. At approximately the same time, Miller [2] reported that it was possible to synthesize amino acids from simple mixtures of inorganic compounds. This landmark discovery provided a possible mechanism for the synthesis of amino acids prior to life’s origin. The subsequent development of automated, liquid chromatographic methods for amino acid analysis [3,4] and gas chromatographic methods for determining amino acid stereochemistry [5,6] were quickly adopted for the analysis of fossil proteins and ancient sediments. Finally, the initial report by Nagy et al. [7] concerning hydrocarbons of biological origin in extraterrestrial materials, i.e.: the Orgueil meteorite, resulted in numerous early attempts to determine the distributions of amino acids in meteorites [8,9]. For the past forty years, scientists have continued to focus their attention on the distribution, stereochemistry, and more recently, the stable isotope composition of amino acids in ancient terrestrial and extraterrestrial materials with the hope of understanding how these compounds initially formed and subsequently became essential components of living organisms. The following discussion focuses on what is currently known about the occurrence of amino acids in ancient terrestrial and extraterrestrial materials and how this information may help us to understand life’s origin in the solar system.
1. Amino Acid Distributions 1.1. Terrestrial Materials There are 20 common, genetically encoded amino acids that are the building blocks of proteins in living organisms, past and present. For as far back in time as the fossil record enables us to determine amino acid composition, there is no indication that the structures of these building blocks have ever varied. While several hundred non-protein amino acids have been identified [10], their lower abundance and lack of preservation as components of common structural proteins greatly reduce the likelihood of their detection as indigenous components in older terrestrial materials. Amino acid distributions for specific proteins are often distinctive. However, even in well-preserved materials, distributions will change with the passage of time, owing to the decomposition of unstable amino acids, e.g.: Ser and Thr, and the formation of amino acids as the products of these decomposition reactions, e.g.: Gly, Ala, and Orn. For example, a comparison of amino acid constituents of shell protein for a modern Mercenaria shell with that of a well-preserved Pleistocene age Mercenaria shell are clearly similar (Fig. 1). However, it is also obvious that with the passage of time, the concentrations of Ser and Thr in the fossil shell have decreased. Given that amino acids such as Ser and Thr decompose
M.H. Engel et al. / Amino Acids: Probes for Life’s Origin in the Solar System
27
Figure 1. Amino acid distributions in fossil (Pleistocene) and modern Mercenaria shells.
fairly rapidly, their presence in fossils or sediments older than a few million years is almost always attributed to recent contamination. However, the absence of these amino acids in older materials does not necessarily indicate a lack of contamination. Samples that are millions (or several billion) years old may have been contaminated multiple times in the past, with ample time for unstable amino acids to have decomposed subsequent to contamination. The oldest examples of sediments deposited by water are found at Isua in southern West Greenland (~3.8 Ga). While these sediments have undergone extensive metamorphism, it was reported that they contained microfossil and chemical evidence for ancient life [11]. More recently there have been reports that carbonaceous inclusions in apatite crystals in the Isua rocks may, based on their stable carbon isotope compositions, be relics of ancient life [12]. If true, this would mean that life existed on Earth as far back in time as the rock record is presently known to extend. Given the severity of impact events during the first 500–600 Ma of Earth history [13], the window of opportunity for life’s origin on Earth would seemingly have been restricted to less than a few tens of millions of years. The recent report that the Isua rocks may contain extraterrestrial material from impacts [14] further clouds the issue as to whether these rocks are true records of early Earth processes or a combination of extraterrestrial and terrestrial materials. Nagy et al. [15] determined the distribution of amino acids in interior samples of Isua banded ironstones. The distributions were similar to those found for lichens that were growing on some of the rock surfaces (Fig. 2). It is impossible to say whether a fraction of any individual amino acid was indigenous, but the distribution clearly indicates that the chances for contamination by encrusting biota are significant. Although these rocks have relatively low porosity and permeability, Engel [16] demonstrated that amino acids in aqueous solution can readily diffuse into the interior of these banded ironstones. As will be discussed in Section 1.2, the challenge that remains is to develop methods for distinguishing ancient from more recent organic matter in Precambrian rocks. 1.2. Extraterrestrial Materials As indicated above, attempts to determine the distribution of amino acids in carbonaceous meteorites began in the early 1960s. The results of these studies became suspect as it be-
28
M.H. Engel et al. / Amino Acids: Probes for Life’s Origin in the Solar System
Figure 2. Amino acid distributions in Isua and lichens.
came apparent that the concentrations of amino acids in the samples were not much greater than those of the background levels in reagents, solvents, etc. that were available at that time [17]. Also, as in the case of the work of Nagy et al. [7] on Orgueil, there continued to be healthy skepticism concerning the possibility that samples of meteorites with extended residence times on Earth could have escaped contamination. Orgueil fell in France in 1864. Thus, almost 100 yr had elapsed from the time of its collection to the time of its analysis in the early 1960s. This is not to say that some of the compounds (amino acids, hydrocarbons, etc.) initially found in Orgueil and other carbonaceous meteorites were not indigenous. There just was no way at the time to prove that they were or were not. The fall of the Murchison meteorite in 1969 provided fresh extraterrestrial material for amino acid analysis by newly developed chromatographic and mass spectrometric methods. The majority of studies from 1969 to present have focused on various stones of Murchison since there were no additional observed falls of carbonaceous meteorites until the fall of the Tagish Lake meteorite in 2000. Shock and Schulte [18] reviewed the reported distributions of amino acids in stones of the Murchison meteorite. With the exception of one stone, the distributions of amino acids in the Murchison meteorite were consistent from laboratory to laboratory. Slight variations between laboratories were attributed to differences in the extraction efficiency of the methods employed. Typical amino acid distributions for the hydrolyzed water extract and the HCl extract of a Murchison meteorite stone subsequent to water extraction are shown in Fig. 3. Although up to 74 amino acids have been identified in the Murchison meteorite [19], several common protein and uncommon non-protein amino acids comprise the majority of this compound fraction, including α-aminoisobutyric acid (α-Aib), isovaline (Ival), βalanine (β-Ala), Gly, Ala, Asp, Glu, and Pro. The distribution of amino acids in similar extracts of the Orgueil meteorite [16] are also exotic, with Gly and β-Ala being major components (Fig. 3). Concentrations of major amino acid constituents of the water and HCl extracts of Murchison and Orgueil are listed in Table 1. Six protein amino acids (Phe, Tyr, Lys, His, Arg, and Trp) have never been detected in well-preserved stones of Murchison and Orgueil, and two others, Ser and Thr, have only been detected at trace levels [20]. This indicates that the stones have not been extensively contaminated during or subsequent to impact. It would be almost impossible to contaminate a meteorite with material of biological origin and not detect those amino acids.
M.H. Engel et al. / Amino Acids: Probes for Life’s Origin in the Solar System
29
Figure 3. Amino acid distributions in meteorites. Table 1. Amino acid concentrations (nmolg-1) in water and acid extracts of Murchison and Orgueil meteorite stones [16].
Carbonaceous meteorites from Antarctica have been analyzed for amino acids [21–23]. However, the fact that Antarctic meteorites have extended residence times on Earth increases the chances for contamination. Many Antarctic stones exhibit weathering features [24]. Given the porous nature of carbonaceous meteorites, it stands to reason that prolonged exposure to Earth enhances the prospects for the diffusion of compounds into the stones. Amino acids are present in Antarctic ice [25,26]. A comparison of the protein amino acid distribution in the hydrolyzed water extract of an Antarctic stone [23] with that of a hydrolyzed sample of Antarctic ice core (Ross Ice Shelf) is shown in Fig. 4. All of the amino acids in Antarctic meteorites are unlikely to be the result of contamination. However, it is not possible to distinguish indigenous compounds from contamination based on abundance and distributions alone. 1.3. Simulation Experiments Numerous experiments have been attempted to simulate the synthesis of amino acids prior to life’s origin. Miller [27] provides a summary of the synthesis of protein and non-protein amino acids via spark discharge experiments. Khare et al. [28] synthesized amino acids
30
M.H. Engel et al. / Amino Acids: Probes for Life’s Origin in the Solar System
Figure 4. Protein amino acid distributions in Antarctic ice and Yamato-74662. Table 2. Total concentration (nmol) of amino acids produced by spark discharge [30].
from inorganic precursor molecules using ultraviolet light as an energy source. Hennet et al. [29] synthesized amino acids under aqueous, hydrothermal conditions. It should be noted that none of these simulation experiments resulted in the synthesis of all of the protein amino acids or of the entire suite of non-protein amino acids detected in carbonaceous meteorites. However, as in the case of carbonaceous meteorites, simulation experiments result in the syntheses of large quantities of low-molecular-weight compounds, e.g.: Gly and Ala. Amino acid abundance decreases with increasing molecular complexity. In spark discharge experiments conducted by Engel et al. [30], Gly was an order of magnitude more abundant that any additional amino acids formed from the gaseous (ammonia, methane, hydrogen, and water) precursors (Table 2). This would be expected, assuming that higher molecular-weight compounds form from lower molecular-weight precursors. Whether any of these simulation experiments are indeed the actual pathways for the abiotic synthesis of life’s precursors on Earth or elsewhere is as yet unknown.
2. Amino Acid Stereochemistry 2.1. Terrestrial Materials One of the unique characteristics of life on Earth is that, owing to conformational constraints, the 20 genetically encoded amino acid constituents of proteins are almost exclu-
M.H. Engel et al. / Amino Acids: Probes for Life’s Origin in the Solar System
31
Figure 5. Gas chromatograms of (a) amino acid extracts from an Isua rock and (b) lichen on the rock’s surface. Details of analytical procedures were previously reported by Engle [16].
sively of the L-configuration. Glycine is the exception since it does not contain an asymmetric center. Trace levels of D-amino acids occur in bacterial cell walls [31]. They may also occur in living organisms at trace levels via racemization [32] subsequent to synthesis. However, upon death, D-amino acids represent an increasing percentage of residual proteins and peptides, the extent to which is largely dependent on the environment of preservation [33] and diagenetic reactions, [33,34]. While amino acids racemize at different rates, in theory, most amino acids in fossil proteins and peptides should be racemic, i.e.: D/L=~1.0, after several million years. However, given that racemization rates are dependent on temperature, pH, the presence of water, etc., it is conceivable that non-racemic amino acids may persist under extreme conditions of preservation (in particular if a protein retains its initial structural integrity). Also, residual peptides and amino acids may become incorporated in geomacromolecules, e.g.: humates and kerogens, during diagenesis, and it has been clearly shown that subsequent to incorporation, racemization may cease [34]. Since racemization is theoretically complete in a few million years under “normal” preservation conditions, it would be expected that autochthonous amino acids in ancient sediments should be racemic, or approximately so. This is rarely if ever the case. In addition to the fact that racemization may be hindered by incorporation into macro-molecular materials, rocks and sediments are open systems. Thus, with the passage of time, amino acids are introduced into older rocks by the migration of fluids, e.g.: meteoric waters and basinal brines. For example, the amino acids in the Isua rocks are not racemic, with L-amino acids present in excess (Fig. 5). While a percentage of these amino acids may have either formed by biotic or abiotic processes at the time the Isua sediments were deposited, clearly, subsequent events have resulted in the introduction of additional L-amino acids. As indicated above, lichens presently growing on the rocks are one possible source of contamination (Fig. 5). But additional episodes of contamination may have occurred prior to this. Also, the fact that the Isua rocks have been metamorphosed, implies that their present-day amino acid constituents are unlikely to be remnants of abiotic or biological processes at the time of deposition ~3.8 Ga ago.
32
M.H. Engel et al. / Amino Acids: Probes for Life’s Origin in the Solar System
Table 3. Amino acid D/L values for sequential extractions of a Murchison stone [38].
In summary, the Isua rocks represent a classic case of the challenges confronting scientists attempting to study the early history of organic compound synthesis on Earth. As will be discussed below, amino acids synthesized by abiotic processes are racemic. However, biologically-formed amino acids racemize with the passage of time. Thus, in older rocks, it is uncertain whether the occurrence of racemic amino acids was a consequence of one pathway or the other or a combination of both. Similarly, non-racemic amino acids may indicate subsequent inputs, but they do not preclude the possibility that some of the amino acids in the rock are indigenous. It is not possible to make this distinction at this time. 2.2. Extraterrestrial Materials It is generally assumed that amino acids in carbonaceous meteorites formed by abiotic processes. As will be discussed below, simulation experiments for the abiotic synthesis of amino acids result in the formation of racemic mixtures. Thus, from a historical perspective, it was assumed early on that indigenous amino acids in carbonaceous meteorites would be racemic. In cases where the D/L value for an amino acid was <1.0, i.e.: an Lexcess, this was attributed to contamination by the Earth’s biosphere at the time of or subsequent to impact [26]. It has also been recently suggested [35] that in some cases an Lenantiomer excess might be a consequence of the co-elution of another compound with the L-enantiomer, thus increasing its observed peak area. However, the fact that there have been relatively few published chromatograms documenting the stereochemistry of amino acids in carbonaceous meteorites has hindered progress in this important area of research. Kvenvolden et al. [36] were the first to determine the stereochemistry of amino acids in the Murchison meteorite. They reported that alanine was approximately racemic. However, their inability to monitor selected ions characteristic of the amino acid made it impossible at that time to verify the actual D/L value. Engel and Nagy [37] reported that several common protein amino acids in the hydrolyzed water extract of a Murchison meteorite stone were not racemic (L-enantiomer excess). They used selected ion monitoring to confirm that the D/L values were <1.0. More intriguing was the observation by Engel and Nagy [37] that amino acids recovered by acid hydrolysis of the residual Murchison stone subsequent to water extraction were even less racemized. Silfer [38] digested the residual mineral phase of a Murchison stone with HF subsequent to initial extractions with water and HCl and observed that the amino acids recovered by this third extraction step were even less racemized (Table 3). If the Murchison meteorite stones were superficially contaminated by amino acids during impact or subsequent collection, the amino acid contaminants should have been removed by the initial water and/or HCl extraction steps. More recently, Engel and Macko [20] published additional ion chromatograms documenting that common protein amino acids in extracts of the Murchison meteorite are non-racemic. There have been relatively few recent investigations of the stereochemistry of amino acids in carbonaceous meteorites other than Murchison. Ehrenfreund et al. [39] reported the abundances of the D- and L-enantiomers of several amino acids in CI (Orgueil and Ivuna) and CM (Murchison and Murray) carbonaceous meteorites. However, they determined
M.H. Engel et al. / Amino Acids: Probes for Life’s Origin in the Solar System
33
Table 4. Bulk organic stable isotope compositions of carbonaceous meteorites.
amino acid abundances by high-performance liquid chromatography and provided no mass spectrometric confirmation of the amino acid identities or confirmation of the D/L values by selected ion monitoring. Thus, their observations concerning stereochemistry remain unverified. It is interesting to note, however, that their report of racemic Ala in the hydrolyzed water extract of the Orgueil meteorite is in agreement with the previous finding of Engel [16], the latter being confirmed by mass spectrometry. However, Engel [16] also reported that Ala was not racemic in the subsequent acid hydrolyzate of the residual mineral phase of Orgueil (L-enantiomer excess). The stereochemistry of Ala in the Murchison meteorite has been the focus of much attention, largely because of its abundance and the facility by which the enantiomers can be resolved. However, it should be noted that racemic alanine can form via the decomposition of other amino acids [40]. Thus, it is possible that the D/L values reported for Ala in various stones of the Murchison meteorite are not the authentic values. This might also explain why Ala is more highly racemized than the other amino acids in Murchison and Orgueil. 2.3. Simulation Experiments While it has been long assumed that the abiotic synthesis of amino acids results in racemic mixtures, it was not until the 1960s that the technology became available to accurately determine the stereochemistry of amino acids. In fact, there have only been a few published reports documenting the stereochemistry of amino acids synthesized by laboratory simulation experiments in which gas chromatography/mass spectrometry was used to confirm the D/L values. For example, Khare et al. [28] reported that amino acids in extracts of tholins synthesized using ultraviolet light as an energy source were racemic. Similarly, Muñoz Caro et al. [41] reported the synthesis of racemic amino acids by ultraviolet irradiation of interstellar ice analogs. Hennet et al. [29] synthesized racemic amino acids under hydrothermal conditions and Engel et al. [30] reported the synthesis of racemic amino acids by spark discharge. The implication of these findings with respect to the report of non-racemic amino acids in carbonaceous meteorites by Engel and colleagues [20,25,37,42–44] is discussed in Section 4.
3. Stable Isotope Composition of Amino Acids in Carbonaceous Meteorites The absence of several amino acids, which are common protein constituents, in the Murchison meteorite is compelling evidence for the authenticity of the compounds that are present. It would be almost impossible to selectively introduce some amino acids and not the others during impact and/or subsequent collection, storage, and analysis. The excess of the Lamino acid enantiomers in the Murchison extracts [20,25,37,42–44] was, however, such a potentially important observation with respect to life’s origin, that an independent method for verifying their authenticity was sought. The bulk organic matter in carbonaceous meteorites is enriched in 13C and 15N relative to organic matter on Earth (Table 4). Similarly, Epstein et al. [45] reported that the stable carbon and nitrogen isotope values for the total amino acid fraction of the Murchison mete-
34
M.H. Engel et al. / Amino Acids: Probes for Life’s Origin in the Solar System
Table 5. Stable isotope values for amino acids in the Murchison meteorite [42,44].
orite were enriched in 13C and 15N (23.1 and 90.0‰, respectively) relative to amino acids of biological origin on Earth. Based on this information, Engel and Macko [46,47] proposed that it should be possible to determine the extent to which amino acids in the Murchison meteorite were indigenous as opposed to terrestrial overprints based on the stable isotope composition of their respective enantiomers. Assuming that the D- and L-enantiomers of an amino acid were formed by the same abiotic mechanism, they should, in theory have identical stable isotope compositions. In support of this hypothesis, Engel et al. [30] have shown that the stable carbon isotopes of the D- and L-enantiomers of Asp and of Ala formed by spark discharge are identical. If the L-enantiomer excess in the Murchison meteorite is a consequence of terrestrial contamination, then the L-enantiomer should be depleted in 13C and 15N relative to the D-enantiomer. Engel and Macko [47] have also shown that amino acids retain their stable carbon and nitrogen isotopic integrity during racemization. Thus, in any systems where partial racemization occurred, the isotope compositions of the respective enantiomers of an amino acid should remain the same, provided once again that there have been no exogenous inputs or kinetic isotope effects associated with the preferential reaction of one enantiomer relative to the other. Engel et al. [48] first documented the utility of this approach by determining the authenticity of amino acid enantiomers in fossil shells. The methodology for determining the stable carbon and nitrogen isotope compositions of amino acid enantiomers at low abundance levels using gas chromatography/combustion/isotope ratio mass spectrometry is reported elsewhere [49,50]. As can be seen in Table 5, the stable carbon and nitrogen isotope compositions of the amino acids in the Murchison meteorite are moderately to substantially enriched in 13C and 15 N relative to amino acid constituents of organisms on Earth. The stable carbon and nitrogen isotope compositions of the Earth’s biomass reflect fractionations that occur with primary production, largely a consequence of kinetic isotope effects associated with reactions such as photosynthesis. Subsequent fractionations result from the multitude of biosynthetic pathways in living organisms. These fractionations are preserved in heterotrophs, which reflect the isotopic compositions of their diets, plus or minus a few per mil [51,52]. Also, organic matter preserved in fossils and sedimentary rocks tends to retain the stable isotope composition of the biomass from which it is derived. In general, the range in δ13C and δ15N values for organic matter on Earth are approximately –10 to –40‰ and –10 to +10‰, respectively. Clearly, the stable isotope values for the amino acids in the Murchison meteorite are outside of these ranges. For amino acids in which stable isotope values could be determined for their respective D- and L-enantiomers, the values are, within experimental error, indistinguishable. This would not have been the case if the L-enantiomer excess were a consequence of contamina-
M.H. Engel et al. / Amino Acids: Probes for Life’s Origin in the Solar System
35
tion by biological materials. Pizzarello and Cronin [35] have suggested an alternative scenario invoking the co-elution of other compounds in the Murchison meteorite with the Lenantiomers. However, the probability of each L-enantiomer in Murchison co-eluting with a compound having a similar mass spectrum and identical carbon and nitrogen isotopic compositions is remote if not impossible. Thus, the stable isotope data confirm our initial conclusions based on the absence of specific protein amino acids in Murchison. That is, the L-excess is an authentic characteristic of the Murchison meteorite and is likely to be an authentic characteristic of the Orgueil meteorite as well.
4. Conclusions Assuming that life originated on Earth, it is highly unlikely that the precursors for this event were racemic or that homochirality emerged by random event(s) during the earliest stages of life’s origin [53,54]. There have been no successful experiments for the abiotic synthesis of non-racemic amino acids under early Earth conditions, although the recent report by Hazen et al. [55] on selective adsorption of D- an L-enantiomers on mirror-related crystal growth surfaces of calcite certainly merits further investigation. Our observation that amino acids in carbonaceous meteorites exhibit a moderate to strong excess of their respective Lenantiomers provides an alternative source for homochirality that preceded life’s origin on Earth, i.e.: impact events during the first few hundred million years subsequent to the formation of the planet. The question is, why do amino acids in extraterrestrial materials, such as carbonaceous meteorites, exhibit this L-excess? At first glance, the obvious suggestion might be that the meteorites contain vestiges of life from elsewhere in the solar system. However, the fact that several protein amino acids are not present in the carbonaceous meteorites suggests that these materials are not relics of life as we know it. It is possible that their absence is a consequence of differences in stability, but this hypothesis is as yet untested. An alternative explanation is that the amino acids in carbonaceous meteorites were initially racemic and that the L-excess is a consequence of abiotic processes that resulted in the preferential destruction of the D-enantiomers [54,56–58]. Several protein amino acids, including Phe, Arg, Lys, and His, are present in all organisms on Earth. These amino acids have never been synthesized in simulation experiments and have not been detected in carbonaceous meteorites. The presence of these amino acids on another planetary body, such as Mars, would be a strong indicator for the previous existence of life. The challenge will be to avoid contamination of the Martian surface with amino acids from Earth during sample collection. Given the likelihood that organic compounds formed on Mars will be isotopically distinct from those on Earth, compound specific stable isotope analysis should prove useful for documenting the authenticity of these compounds if they are present.
References [1] Abelson PH. Organic constituents of fossils. Carnegie Inst. Wash. Year Book 1954; 53: 97–101. [2] Miller SL. Production of amino acids under possible primitive earth conditions. Science 1953; 117: 528–9. [3] Spackman DH, Stein WH, Moore S. Automatic recording apparatus for use in the chromatography of amino acids. Anal. Chem., 1958; 30: 1190–206. [4] Hamilton PB. Ion exchange chromatography of amino acids: a single column, high resolving, fully automatic procedure. Anal. Chem., 1963; 35: 2055–64. [5] Charles R, Fischer G, Gil-Av E. Resolution of (±) 2-n-alkanols by gas-liquid partition chromatography. Isr. J. Chem. 1963; 1: 234–5.
36
M.H. Engel et al. / Amino Acids: Probes for Life’s Origin in the Solar System
[6] Pollock GE, Oyama VI, Johnson RO. Resolution of racemic amino acids by gas chromatography. J. Gas Chromatogr. 1965; 3: 174–6. [7] Nagy B, Meinschein WG, Hennessy DJ. Mass spectrometric analysis of the Orgueil meteorite: evidence for biogenic hydrocarbons. Ann. NY Acad. Sci. 1961; 93: 25–35. [8] Degens ET, Bajor, M. Amino acids and sugars in the Bruderheim and Murray meteorites. Naturwiss. 1962; 49: 605–6. [9] Kaplan IR, Degens ET, Reuter JH. Organic compounds in stony meteorites”, Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 1963; 27: 805–34. [10] Hunt S. The non-protein amino acids. In: Barrett GC, editor. Chemistry and biochemistry of the amino acids. London: Chapman and Hall; 1985, p. 55–138. [11] Pflug HD, Jaeschke-Boyer H. Combined structural and chemical analysis of 3,800-Myr-old microfossils. Nature 1979; 280: 483–6. [12] Mojzsis SJ, Arrhenius G, McKeegan KD, Harrison TM, Nutman AP, Friend RL. Evidence for life on Earth before 3,800 million years ago. Nature 1996; 384: 55–9. [13] Chyba CF, Sagan C. Endogenous production, exogenous delivery and impact shock synthesis of organic molecules: an inventory for the origins of life. Nature 1992; 355: 125–32. [14] Schoenberg R, Kamber BS, Collerson KD, Moorbath S. Tungsten isotope evidence from ~3.8-Gyr metamorphosed sediments for early meteorite bombardment of the Earth. Nature 2002; 418: 403–5. [15] Nagy B, Engel MH, Zumberge JE, Ogino H, Chang SY. Amino acids and hydrocarbons in the ~3,800Myr old Isua rocks, southwestern Greenland. Nature 1981; 289: 53–6. [16] Engel MH. [Ph.D. thesis]. Tucson (AZ): The University of Arizona; 1980. [17] Hayes JM. Organic constituents of meteorites. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 1967; 31: 1395–440. [18] Shock EL, Schulte MD. Summary and implications of reported amino acid concentrations in the Murchison meteorite. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 1990; 54: 3159–73. [19] Cronin JR, Pizzarello S, Cruikshank DP. Organic matter in carbonaceous chondrites, planetary satellites, asteroids and comets. In: Kerridge JF, Matthews MS, editors. Meteorites and the early solar system. Tucson: University of Arizona Press; 1988. p. 819–57. [20] Engel MH, Macko SA. The stereochemistry of amino acids in the Murchison meteorite. Precambrian Res. 2001; 106: 35–45. [21] Kotra RK, Shimoyama A, Ponnamperuma C, Hare PE. Amino acids in a carbonaceous chondrite from Antarctica. J. Mol. Evol. 1979; 13: 179–84. [22] Cronin JR, Pizzarello S, Moore CB. Amino acids in an Antarctic carbonaceous chondrite. Science 1979; 206: 335–7. [23] Shimoyama A, Ponnamperuma C, Yanai K. Amino acids in the Yamato carbonaceous chondrite from Antarctica. Nature 1979; 282: 394–6. [24] Welten KC. Concentrations of siderophile elements in nonmagnetic fractions of Antarctic H- and Lchondrites: A quantitative approach on weathering effects. Meteoritics and Planet. Sci. 1999; 34: 259–70. [25] Engel MH, Macko SA. Stable isotope analysis of amino acid enantiomers in the Murchison meteorite at natural abundance levels”, In: Hoover RB, editor. Instruments, methods, and missions for the investigation of extraterrestrial microorganisms. Proc. SPIE 1997; 3111: 82–5. [26] Bada JL, Glavin DP, McDonald GD, Becker L. A search for endogenous amino acids in Martian meteorite ALH84001. Science 1998; 279: 362–5. [27] Miller SL. The prebiotic synthesis of organic compounds on the early Earth. In: Engel MH, Macko SA, editors. Organic geochemistry: principles and applications. New York: Plenum Press; 1993. p. 625–37. [28] Khare BN, Sagan C, Ogino H, Nagy B, Er C, Schram KH, Arakawa ET. Amino acids derived from Titan tholins. Icarus 1986; 68: 176–84. [29] Hennet RJ-C, Holm NG, Engel MH. Abiotic synthesis of amino acids under hydrothermal conditions and the origin of life: a perpetual phenomenon? Naturwiss. 1992; 79: 361–5. [30] Engel MH, Macko SA, Qian Y, Silfer JA. Stable isotope analysis at the molecular level: A new approach for determining the origins of amino acids in the Murchison meteorite. Adv. Space. Res. 1995; 15: 99–106. [31] Perry RS, Engel MH, Botta O, Staley JT. Amino acid analyses of desert varnish from the Sonoran and Mojave Deserts. Geomicrobiology 2003; in press. [32] Helfman PM, Bada JL. Aspartic acid racemization in tooth enamel from living humans. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 1975; 72: 2891–4. [33] Goodfriend GA, Collins MJ, Fogel ML, Macko SA, Wehmiller JF, editors. Perspectives in amino acid and protein geochemistry. New York: Oxford University Press; 2000. [34] Rafalska JK, Engel MH, Lanier WP. Retardation of racemization rates of amino acids incorporated into melanoidins. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 1991; 55: 3669–75. [35] Pizzarello S, Cronin JR. Alanine enantiomers in the Murchison meteorite. Nature 1998; 394: 236.
M.H. Engel et al. / Amino Acids: Probes for Life’s Origin in the Solar System
37
[36] Kvenvolden KA, Lawless J, Pering K, Peterson E, Flores J, Ponnamperuma C, Kaplan IR, Moore C. Evidence for extraterrestrial amino acids and hydrocarbons in the Murchison meteorite”, Nature 1970; 228: 923–6. [37] Engel MH, Nagy B. Distribution and enantiomeric composition of amino acids in the Murchison meteorite”, Nature 1982; 296: 837–40. [38] Silfer JA. [Ph.D. Thesis]. Norman (OK): University of Oklahoma; 1991. [39] Ehrenfreund P, Glavin DP, Botta O, Cooper G, Bada JL. Extraterrestrial amino acids in Orgueil and Ivuna: Tracing the parent body of CI type carbonaceous chondrites. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 2001; 98: 2138–41. [40] Engel MH, Hare PE. The condensation of amino acids and sugars: An evaluation of stereochemistry, decomposition and rearrangement reactions. Carnegie Inst. Wash. Year Book 1982; 81: 425–30. [41] Muñoz Caro GM, Meierhenrich UJ, Schutte WA, Barbier B, Arcones Segovia A, Rosenbauer H, Thiemann WH-P, Brack A, Greenberg JM. Amino acids from ultraviolet irradiation of interstellar ice analogs. Nature 2002; 416: 403–6. [42] Engel MH, Macko SA, Silfer JA. Carbon isotope composition of individual amino acids in the Murchison meteorite. Nature 1990; 348: 47–9. [43] Engel MH, Macko SA, Nagy B. The organic geochemistry of carbonaceous meteorites: amino acids and stable isotopes. In: Engel MH, Macko SA, editors. Organic geochemistry, principles and applications, Plenum Press: 1993. p. 685–95. [44] Engel MH, Macko SA. Isotopic evidence for extraterrestrial non-racemic amino acids in the Murchison meteorite. Nature 1997; 389: 265–8. [45] Epstein S, Krishnamurthy RV, Cronin JR, Pizzarello S, Yuen GU. Unusual stable isotope ratios in amino acid and carboxylic acid extracts from the Murchison meteorite. Nature 1987; 326: 477–9. [46] Engel MH, Macko SA. The separation of amino acid enantiomers for stable carbon and nitrogen isotope analyses. Anal. Chem. 1984; 56: 2598–600. [47] Engel MH, Macko SA. Stable isotope evaluation of the origins of amino acids in fossils. Nature 1986; 323: 531–3. [48] Engel MH, Goodfriend GA, Qian Y, Macko SA. Indigeneity of organic matter in fossils: A test using stable isotope analysis of amino acid enantiomers in Quaternary mollusk shells. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 1994; 91: 10475–8. [49] Silfer JA, Engel MH, Macko SA, Jumeau EJ. Stable carbon isotope analysis of amino acid enantiomers by conventional isotope ratio mass spectrometry and combined gas chromatography/isotope ratio mass spectrometry. Anal. Chem. 1991; 63: 370–4. [50] Macko SA, Uhle ME, Engel MH, Andrusevich VE. Stable nitrogen isotope analysis of amino acid enantiomers by gas chromatography/combustion/isotope ratio mass spectrometry. Anal. Chem. 1997; 69: 926–9. [51] DeNiro MJ, Epstein S. Influence of diet on the distribution of carbon isotopes in animals. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 1978; 42: 495–506. [52] DeNiro MJ, Epstein S. Influence of diet on the distribution of nitrogen isotopes in animals. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 1981; 45: 341–51. [53] Goldanskii VI, Kuzmin VV. Chirality and the cold origin of life. Nature 1991; 352: 114. [54] Bonner WA. The origin and amplification of biomolecular chirality. Orig. Life Evol. Biosphere 1991; 21: 59–111. [55] Hazen RM, Filley TR, Goodfriend GA. Selective adsorption of L- and D-amino acids on calcite: Implications for biochemical homochirality. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 2001; 98: 5487–90. [56] Greenberg JM. Prebiotic chiral molecules created in interstellar dust and preserved in comets, comet dust, and meteorites: an exogenous source of life’s origins. In: Hoover RB, editor. Instruments, methods and missions for the investigation of extraterrestrial microorganisms. Proc. SPIE 1997; 3111: 226–37. [57] Bailey J, Chrysostomou A, Hough JH, Gledhill TM, McCall A, Clark S, Ménard F, Tamura M. Circular polarization in star-formation regions: Implications for biomolecular homochirality. Science 1998; 281: 672–4. [58] Rikken GLJA, Raupach E. Enantioselective magnetochiral photochemistry. Nature 2000; 405: 932–5.
38
Perspectives in Astrobiology R.B. Hoover et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
Mineralization of Cyanobacteria L. GERASIMENKO, V. ORLEANSKY and L. ZAITSEVA Institute of Microbiology of RAS, Prospect 60-letya Octyabrya 7/2, Moscow, 117812, Russia Abstract. Mineralization (silification, carbonatization and phosphatization) of cyanobacteria was studied in nature and laboratory. The increase in concentration of silica, phosphates, carbonates, and calcium leads to a sequence of morphological changes of cyanobacteria: (1) Formation of slime sheath, (2) formation of isolated globules of minerals on the slime sheath, (3) mineralization of slime sheaths of viable cells, and (4) mineralization of trichomes of dead cells.
Cyanobacteria are ancient organisms that were surprisingly stable over the entire evolution of life on Earth. The similarity of organic remains from ancient stromatolites, oncolites, and phosphorites to extant cyanobacteria [1–3] suggests the predominant role of these photosynthetic organisms in biogenic carbonates deposition. Accordingly, the observation of the mineralization processes in nature and laboratory experiments allows us to understand cyanobacterial activity in the geological past. Cyanobacteria, together with other bacteria, form microbial communities that dominated Earth for over 3 billion years and were responsible for important geological processes, including the accumulation of many sedimentary rocks and mineral resources. However, eukaryotic organisms pushed cyanobacteria from epicontinental marine basins to ecological niches, often with extreme conditions: hyperhaline lagoons of the sea, soda lakes, and hot springs, where thermophilic, halophilic, and alkaliphilic microbial communities survive even today. Thermophilic communities were observed in the caldera of the volcano, Uzon, in Kamchatka and Kuril Islands; halophilic communities, in the lagoons of Sivash in Crimea; and alkaliphilic communities in soda lakes in Siberia. In hot springs with a large content of silica, the community is partly mineralized (Fig. 1(a) and (b)). These siliceous crusts contain mineralized microbial remains, i.e.: modern microfossils [4]. Different stages of silification were found in these crusts (Fig. 1(c)). The process of mineralization begins with the penetration of silica within the cell and precipitation of minute globules on the cell walls. During the next stage, globules fuse into a single crust surrounding the cell. The external surface of the cells is smooth, while the internal surface is globular. Later, opal globules fill the spaces between and within the filaments until completely silicified rock is formed. In the laboratory, it was shown that penetration of silica occurs only after the cell’s death. Living cells have mechanisms of precluding high silica concentrations, namely the formation of the thick slime sheaths. The thermophilic and halophilic mats often contain carbonate inclusions represented by aragonite and calcite. Cyanobacteria observed in these mats are also carbonatized. The rigid correlation between the content of cyanobacteria in the mat [5] indicates that one of the reasons is the alkalization of the media resulting from the active photosynthesis of cyanobacte-
L. Gerasimenko et al. / Mineralization of Cyanobacteria
39
Figure 1. Natural mineralized mat (Kamchatka): (a) Modern stromatolite, Bar=20 sm; (b) cross section of stromatolite, Bar=2 sm; (c) mineralized cyanobacterium Mastigocladus laminosus, Bar=5 μm; and (d) mineralogy of mat.
ria. Laboratory experiments show that the precipitation of carbonates reaches its maximum when photosynthetic conditions are optimal [6]. The increase in the content of calcium++ (Ca++) and carbonates in the medium results in morphological changes, primarily in the formation of slime sheaths. Later Ca-carbonate globules precipitate on sheaths of living cells and gradually mineralized the entire trichomes of dead cells. Experimental data show that some content of carbonates or carbon dioxide (CO2) in the media plays a decisive inhibiting effect on the growth of cyanobacteria. High concentrations of carbonates increase the pH of the medium to >11; and high concentrations of CO2 decrease the pH to <5. The cells die and mineralization of trichomes occurs. The action of phosphorus on the growth and mineralization of cells was studied carefully. Our experiments showed that halophilic cyanobacteria—Microcoleus chthonoplastes, the dominant organism of cyanobacterial mats—can survive in a wide range of inorganic phosphorus concentrations. However, irrespective of concentrations, the active re-
40
L. Gerasimenko et al. / Mineralization of Cyanobacteria
Figure 2. Formation of mineral microtubes of fluorine-apatite. Bar=1μm.
moval of phosphorus from the medium was observed in the first 3 hr and was completed in 24 hr [7,8]. Experiments showed that not all phosphorus penetrated the cell, the larger part of it was absorbed on the surface. The higher its concentration in the medium, the more intensive is the absorption. The active influx of phosphorus into the cell occurs by its active transport through the membrane. It accumulates in larger quantities than outside the cell, and its concentration there is higher than the cell requires for its metabolism. In Microcoleus chthonoplastes, the active transport occurs with a maximum rate in the first 3 min of contact. In 3 days, a two-fold decrease in rate was observed. Phosphorus can be stored in microbial cells in the form of inorganic polyphosphates that serve as a phosphorus reserve to provide for cell survival under phosphorus starvation. Various fractions of polyphosphates may respond differently to changes in the environment. Fractional distribution of the phosphates in cyanobacteria grown in the presence of different concentrations of polyphosphates corresponded to morphological alterations in the cells related to their mineralization. The superficial accumulation of acid-insoluble polyphosphates, localized close to the cell surface, stimulated the mineralization of slime sheaths. Under a high concentration of phosphorus (lethal for cells) the accumulation of orthophosphates and nucleoside phosphates was observed. This is when mineralization of trichomes begins [8]. The x-ray investigation of mineral sheaths and trichomes showed that the emerging, poorly crystallized phosphate minerals of the apatite group have a major diffractionary maximum that is close to francolite [7]. To obtain a crystallized apatite in the laboratory, NaF was added to the medium since F is an isomorphic element of the apatite structure [9]. The solid precipitate was studied with scanning electron microscopy, and electron micrographs showed dispersive-lay spherulite-like particles on which there were well-ordered microtubes (Fig. 2). They may be situated on or in the precipitate, near trichoms or on them. The microtubes ranged in diameter from 0.8 to 1.1 μm, and their length varied from 1.0 to 12.0 μm. Microtubes consist of small, individual, especially smooth spherulites of 0.2–0.5 μm, and the spherulites may be densely packed. The observed mineral microtubes resemble modern and ancient microfossils by their gross morphology. Thus, the data presented show that in some cases, filamentous or tubular structures may not represent the fossilized microorganism itself. That is why it is necessary to be careful in their interpretation. Thus, the action of different ions on cells is similar in spite of the fact that phosphorus, calcium, and carbonate are necessary components for the growth of all cyanobacteria, but silica is a necessary element only for specific groups of alga. The increase in concentration of these components leads to morphological changes of the cells (Fig. 3), which are: 1. The surface of the cells becomes covered with a slime sheaths. This sheath may be twice as thick as the trichomes. The appearance of this sheath in cyanobacteria and many other microorganisms indicates an unfavorable environment and is a cellular
L. Gerasimenko et al. / Mineralization of Cyanobacteria
41
Figure 3. Different stages of mineralization of cyanobacteria. (a) Viable trichomes of Microcoleus chthonoplastes, (b) slime sheaths, (c) viable trichomes glide from mineral sheath, (d) mineralized sheath. Bar=3 μm.
response for its protection. The sheath consists of an amorphous substance containing polysaccharide microfibrils as a matrix. The latter may become a center of a mineralization process in that they form mineral microtubes around the cyanobacterial filaments. 2. As ion concentration increases, isolated mineral globules precipitate on the sheaths, then emerge in them. Later they fuse on larger bodies and finally form a complete mineral sheath. Mineral accumulation occurs only in the slime sheath and does not involve trichomes. Cells remain viable, and occasionally, it was observed that trichomes move out of the mineral covering leaving an empty tube behind. 3. As concentration increases, the culture dies, and the trichome itself becomes mineralized. Large rates of absorption in first few minutes explain the good preservation of morphological structures of cyanobacteria in ancient rocks.
Acknowledgments This work was supported in part by the Russian Foundation for Basic Research, projects NoNo 00–05–64603, 02–04–48094, and INTAS 97–30776.
References [1] Rozanov AYu, Zhegallo EA. Problem of origin of ancient phosphorites of Asia. Lithology and Mineral Resources 1989; 3: 62–82. [2] Stal LJ. Cyanobacterial mats and stromatolites. In: Whitton BA, Potts M, editors. The Ecology of Cyanobacteria. The Netherlands: Kluver Academic Publishers; 2000. p.61–120. [3] Riding RE, Awramik SM. Microbial sediments. Berlin-Heidelberg-New York: Springer-Verlag; 2000. [4] Krilov IN, Orleansky VK, Tichomirova NS. Silification: everlasting preparations. Priroda 1989; 4: 4–12. [5] Zavarzin GA, editor. Calderic microorganisms. Moscow: Nauka; 1989. [6] Nekrasova VK, Gerasimenko LM, Romanova AK. Physiological especially of photosynthesis of Mastigocladus laminosus. Microbiology 1983; 52 (4): 549–51. [7] Gerasimenko LM, Goncharova IV, Zhegallo EA, Rozanov AYu, Ushatinskaya GT. Proccess of mineralization (phosphatization) of cyanobacteria. Litology and Mineral Resources 1996; 2: 208–14.
42
L. Gerasimenko et al. / Mineralization of Cyanobacteria
[8] Gerasimenko LM, Goncharova IV, Zaitseva LV. The affect of P-content on the growth and mineralization of cyanobacteria. Microbiology 1998; 67 (2): 254–9. [9] Goncharova IV, Gerasimenko LM, Zavarzin GA, Ushatinskaya GT. Formation of mineral phosphate microtubes. Current Microbiology 1993; 27: 187–90.
Perspectives in Astrobiology R.B. Hoover et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
43
Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites Richard B. HOOVER Astrobiology Group Leader, Space Science Department/SD50 NASA George C. Marshall Space Flight Center, Huntsville, AL 35812 Abstract. The detection of biominerals, chemical biomarkers, and putative microfossils in the Mars meteorite, ALH84001, stimulated the newly emerging fields of astrobiology and bacterial paleontology. The debate triggered by the ALH84001 results highlighted the importance of developing methodologies for recognizing chemical biomarkers, biominerals, and microfossils in living and fossilized bacteria in ice, permafrost, rocks, meteorites, and other astromaterials prior to the return of samples from comets, asteroids, and Mars. Comparative studies of the chemical, mineral, and morphological biomarkers in living and fossil microorganisms are essential to developing the expertise needed to differentiate biogenic forms from abiotic microstructures and to recognize indigenous biosignatures and distinguish them from recent biological contaminants. At the NASA Marshall Space Flight Center (MSFC) and the Paleontological Institute of the Russian Academy of Sciences (PIN/RAS), ultrahigh-resolution imaging and x-ray elemental analysis has been carried out on living bacteria, ancient microbes cryopreserved in ice and permafrost, biominerals and microfossils in a wide variety of rocks and meteorites. The environmental scanning electron microscope (ESEM) and field emission scanning electron microscope (FESEM) studies have resulted in the detection of a large number of indigenous biomarkers and lithified or carbonized microfossils found embedded in situ in the rock matrix of carbonaceous meteorites. Many of these forms are similar to microfossils and biominerals seen in living and fossil magnetotactic bacteria and cyanobacteria from hypersaline soda lakes; phosphorites of Khubsugul, Mongolia; and high carbon rocks of the Siberian and Russian Platforms. Some of the assemblages of microfossils in carbonaceous meteorites exhibit consistent consortia and microbial ecosystems. Many of the forms are large and extremely complex, exhibiting recognizable nanostructures, such as flagella, spines, biofilms, apical cells, and reproductive stages (trichomes, spores, akinetes, and hormogonia) such as are known in modern Nostocacean cyanobacteria. A review of the prior studies and recently obtained images, and x-ray data from a wide variety of carbonaceous meteorites and terrestrial rocks is provided herein.
Introduction The discovery by McKay et al. [1] of chemical biomarkers and possible microfossils in an ancient meteorite from Mars, ALH84001, initiated the field of astrobiology and renewed a scientific debate that highlighted the need to develop bioindicators and biomarkers for recognition of traces of life in the cosmos. The minute (100–400 nm) dimensions of the putative nanofossils in ALH84001 (Fig. 1 (a)) triggered a debate on the size limitations of microbial life on Earth. It has subsequently been shown that living on Earth there are dwarf
44
R.B. Hoover / Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites
Figure 1. (a) Putative 400-nm nanofossils in ALH84001 and (b) a novel motile archaeon (120- to 400-nm diameter) from the Rainbow deep sea hydrothermal vent.
bacteria, nanofossils, nanobacteria, and nanocells [2–7] and a nanoarchaeon symbiont [8] that have sizes comparable to the possible nanofossils of ALH84001. (Fig. 1 (b)) At MSFC, a minute anaerobic hyperthermophile from the Rainbow deep-sea hydrothermal vent (Fig. 1 (b)) was isolated. This autonomous obligate sulfurophile is growing in pure culture and motile with flagella. These coccoidal microbes exhibit a very wide size distribution, ranging from individuals with a diameter of ~100 nm or less to forms as large as 1 δm. Even though the lower limit on the size of autonomous microbial life on Earth has not yet been definitively established, it is now clear that terrestrial microorganisms can have sizes comparable to the ALH84001 forms, and therefore, the putative Martian microfossils cannot be arbitrarily dismissed solely on the basis of size. Knowledge of microbial life on the nanometer scale has been greatly extended and new information of great importance to astrobiology has been discovered concerning the limitations of cellular life on Earth. Knowledge concerning the upper size limit of prokaryotic life has also been increased by the discovery of a sulfide-metabolizing anaerobic bacterium. Thiomargarita namibiensis [9] is so large (cell size ~0.75 mm) that individual bacterial cells can be easily seen with the unaided eye.
1. Thermophiles and Psychrophiles as Analogs for Life on Mars and Europa It is now known that microbial extremophiles thrive in a wide range of environments on Earth. The discovery of these hardy life forms greatly enhances the possibility that viable microbiota might have existed in the ancient oceans or rivers of Mars or the oceans that exist today beneath the ice crust of Europa. Psychrophiles and thermophiles might also survive today, living within the hydrothermal vents, fumaroles, and deep crustal rocks of Mars. Psychrophiles may live or be cryopreserved in the ice crust of Europa or in the permafrost, glaciers, and polar ice caps of Mars. Sulfur- (S-) and sulfate-reducing bacteria and archaea are microbial extremophiles of significance to astrobiology. On Earth, they inhabit a wide variety of anaerobic and hypooxygenic eco-niches, such as geysers, volcanic fumaroles, deep-sea hydrothermal vents, deep crustal rocks, marine sediments, deep aquifers, animal intestines, soda lakes, high salinity lakes, soils, alkaline evaporates, and cryo-environments [10–12]. Sulfate or sulfur respiration is an anaerobic process with a combination of energy conservation by redox phosphorylation at the substrate level and electron flow on acceptors as sulfur or sulfur compounds. Hydrogen sulfide (H2S) is the end product of both catabolic processes (sulfur and sulfate respiration). Pikuta and Hoover [13] reviewed anaerobic sulfate- and sulfur-reducing bacteria on Earth and have suggested that they represent possible analogs for microbial life that might inhabit Jupiter’s volcanic moon, Io. This frozen world
R.B. Hoover / Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites
45
Figure 2. Viking 2 image of snow at the Lander site (48˚ N, 226˚ W) on May 18, 1979 (detector temperature: 18.1 ˚C) (Photo courtesy MSFC and NASA).
has active volcanoes driven by tidal heating from its proximity to the giant planet Jupiter. The temperature of Io ranges from –150 ˚C to over 2,000 ˚C. The surface of Io is covered with elemental sulfur and sulfur compounds, and the atmosphere of Io is primarily sulfur dioxide. Recent studies of sulfur- and sulfate-reducing bacteria at MSFC have resulted in the isolation and sequencing of two new species: (1) an alkaliphilic Sulfate-reducing bacterium from soda Mono Lake in northern California [14] (Desulfonatronum thiodismutans, sp. nov.) and (2) a thermophilic archaean (Thermococcus sulfurophilus, sp. nov.) [15] from the Rainbow deep-sea hydrothermal vent.
2. Sediments, Water, Snow, Glaciers, and Permafrost on Mars The carbonate minerals and magnetites in close association with possible microfossils in ALH84001 triggered intense debate concerning the possibility of life and water on Mars. The primary requirement for active microbial life on Earth is liquid water and a source of energy and organics, although some microbes can remain viable for long time periods in a frozen or desiccated state without water. Viking, Global Surveyor, and Odyssey images and data have provided dramatic evidence for water and ice on present-day Mars. The absence of water on Mars can no longer be thought to preclude the possibility of Martian microbial life or microfossils. Viking, Pathfinder, Global Surveyor, and Odyssey data have established that water was very abundant on ancient Mars and presently exists in the polar ice caps and permafrost of Mars. The Mars Global Surveyor Mars Orbiter Camera (MOC) images provide evidence that large quantities of liquid water were present on ancient Mars when the ALH84001 microfossils would have been formed. Viking images also provided dramatic evidence of water snow on Mars at the Lander site (48˚ N, 226˚ W) over several days in May of 1979 (Fig. 2). This is obviously snow and not frost as it is absent on vertical surfaces and collects in small depressions. The Viking detector temperature was – 8.10˚C, and thus it is impossible for this to be carbon dioxide (CO2) frost. The snow is on rocks in full sunlight, as indicated by the sharp spacecraft shadows. Solar heating of the soil and rocks on Mars should produce localized melting to permit liquid water to seep into the soil grain interstices and form thin water films within the permafrost. These films might be capable of supporting indigenous microbial life and the positive Viking Labeled Release data [16,17] should be carefully reexamined. Zuber et al. [18] analyzed elevation measurements from Mars Orbiter Laser Altimeter (MOLA) on Global Surveyor in 1998. These data show the volume of water ice in the Mars North Polar Cap is 1.2 million km3, about half the size of the Greenland Ice Cap. The Mars North Polar Cap in summer was 1,200-km across and 3.8-km thick with a shape showing it
46
R.B. Hoover / Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites
Figure 3. (a) MOC image of double rimed polygons in Mars permafrost and (b) double-rimmed polygons in permafrost of Kolyma lowlands of northeast Siberia. (Photos courtesy MSFC and NASA).
to be primarily composed of water ice. This is almost the same thickness as the Central Antarctic Ice Sheet at Vostok. Large areas of the ice sheet are extremely smooth—varying only a few feet over many miles, and other areas exhibit pinnacles and are cut by deep fracture crevasses and moulins (crevasses cut by flowing water) plunging to 1 km depth. The margins of the Mars polar cap are surrounded by giant conical mounds that are possibly pingos formed of ice and rocks tens of kilometers in diameter and over 1 km in height. There are also double-rimmed polygonal patterns in the permafrost similar to those known in patterned ground of the permafrost of Siberia, Alaska, and Antarctica. MOC, aboard the Mars Global Surveyor, also shows large amounts of water ice frozen in the Mars permafrost. MOC images show double-rimed polygons in the permafrost of Mars (Fig. 3 (a)) [20–24]. Images of similar double-walled polygons in permafrost were taken during the International Expedition Beringia by R. Hoover to the Kolyma lowlands of northeast Siberia (Fig. 3 (b)) and as also explained later in this volume by R. Paepe and Van Overloop, in Taylor Valley (Antarctica) in comparison with the Mars Moc image. The polar ice caps of Earth and Mars are paleomicrobiological traps capable of cryopreserving ancient microfossils, organic remains, and intact microbial cells in dead and viable states [19,25]. Prior meteorite impact events may have ejected crustal rocks and debris from sediments, volcanic deposits, glaciers, and permafrost into the atmosphere and onto the polar ice caps. Consequently, if microbial life presently exists or has existed on Mars in the geological past, the traces, remains, and biosignatures of this microbial life should be cryopreserved in a frozen state in the permafrost and polar ice caps. Marsic et al. [26–28] have described the DNA amplification and gene cloning of ribosomal RNA extracted from anaerobic psychrophiles of the Fox Tunnel of Alaska and from a living 40,000-yr-old Pleistocene moss cultured from samples collected in the Kolyma lowlands of northeastern Siberia. On Earth, the permafrost, ice wedges, glaciers, and polar ice sheets preserve organic chemicals, molecular biomarkers, intact cells, and viable ancient microorganisms, fungi, and mosses for several hundreds of thousands to millions of years, and analogous processes may operate on Mars. Abyzov et al. [29,30] detected viable Pleistocene microorganisms distributed throughout the Central Antarctic Ice sheet at Vostok, and Gilichinsky et al. [31,32] found ancient viable microorganisms cryopreserved in permafrost. The long-term preservation of microbes in ice is of astrobiological significance since many species of microorganisms can remain viable for geological periods of time frozen in glaciers, permafrost, and the polar ice caps of Earth. If life ever existed on these bodies, it might have remained viable, cryopreserved in the polar ice cap of Mars; the ice crusts of Europa, Ganymede, or Callisto; or the water ice of comets. Hoover et al. [33] discussed terrestrial ice-diatoms, snow algae, and cyanobacteria as analogs for the types of microbiota that might be capable of surviving in the ice of comets. Diatoms are the most prolific eukaryotic life forms of the terrestrial
R.B. Hoover / Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites
47
cryosphere. They are abundant in permafrost, glaciers, polar ice, and at the ice/ocean interfaces. Although diatoms are primarily photosynthetic organisms, some species live in the total darkness of deep-sea sediments and grow epiphytically on larger life forms in the hydrothermal vent ecosystem. Diatoms also employ heterotrophic nutritional modes to survive in the absolute darkness of the deep abyss or during the long polar winters. ALH84001 demonstrated that impact ejection phenomena can result in the transfer of crustal material from one planetary body to another. [34–36] Viable microorganisms exist in Antarctic ice, and complex microbial ecosystems thrive in deep crustal rocks and marine sediments. Rocks and ice ejected from Earth by large impact ejection events could transport terrestrial organic chemicals and microbiota into space, where they might contaminate comets, planets, or the parent bodies of carbonaceous chondrites. The Mars meteorites confirm that impact ejection can transport crustal rocks from Mars to Earth and that the terrestrial ecosystem is not closed. Carbonaceous chondrites can no longer be considered pristine because their parent bodies must have been contaminated by countless interactions and collisions with debris encountered during the past 4.6 Ga. Meteorites have obviously been extensively contaminated during their lifespan and exhibit dramatic heterogeneity the centimeter, millimeter, micrometer, and nanometer size scales. Any materials present on the meteorite when it entered the Earth’s atmosphere should be considered indigenous and only postarrival contaminants should be considered contamination. Furthermore, evidence for chemical and mineral biomarkers and microfossils that may be found in situ in meteorites should not be dismissed as contaminants solely because they may be similar to terrestrial microorganisms or biochemicals. The extreme hardiness of a wide variety of microbial extremophiles has clearly shown that the possibility of trans-planetary cross contamination of microbiota can no longer be totally excluded. Indeed, the ability of some microbes to survive phenomenal shocks, high pressure, hard vacuum, and deep-space temperatures for geological epochs combined with the presence on Earth of meteorites from Mars and the Moon indicate that microbial life may be far more widely distributed throughout the cosmos than previously thought possible.
3. Bioindicators and Biomarkers in Rocks and Meteorites The heated debate that followed the reported detection of biomarkers and possible microfossils in ALH84001 was reminiscent of the debate after the 1961 detection by Claus and Nagy [37,38] of organic biomarkers and possible microfossils in carbonaceous meteorites. Critics advanced a wide array of objections to the evidence for biomarkers and microfossils and the proponents ultimately retreated. Studies [39] established that forms such as Clause and Nagy had called organized elements are readily found in situ in freshly fractured surfaces of carbonaceous meteorites and cannot be dismissed as pollen contaminants. The other biomarkers that Claus and Nagy originally detected have also been confirmed. Extensive research on biomineralization, biological fractionation of stable isotopes, geomicrobiology, microbial extremophiles, and bacterial paleontology is now underway. [40] This debate has shown that it is critical that bioindicators and biomarkers be recognized and uniformly applied to terrestrial rocks, meteorites, and other astromaterials. Biomarkers that represent valid evidence of biogenic activity when found in terrestrial rocks should also be considered to represent valid evidence of biogenic activity, even if they are encountered in meteorites, astromaterials or returned samples from Mars, Europa, or comets. Since it is not possible to rule out prior planetary cross contamination by natural impact ejection phenomena, great care must be exercised (sterilization procedures, negative controls, in situ studies, etc.) to ensure that if returned samples contain Earth-like microorganisms they will not be automatically discarded as contaminants.
48
R.B. Hoover / Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites
There are a number of mineral and chemical bioindicators, e.g.: carbonates, silicates, phosphorites, polycyclic aramotic hydrocarbons (PAHs), hydrocarbons, and amino acids, that can also be produced by abiotic processes. It is now well known that microbial activity plays a critical role in the formation of the atmosphere and the mineral composition of the oceans. Photosynthesis by plants and marine phytoplankton govern the carbon (C):nitrogen (N):phosphorous (P) ratio in the deep oceans by the Redfield [41,42] ratio (C:N:P=106:16:1). This gives rise to important bioindicators that may be observed by gamma-ray or neutron spectroscopic detection of biologically significant element ratios. Individual bioindicators are not proof of biogenicity, but when found in association with other biomarkers the case becomes far more compelling. Important bioindicators and biomarkers include the following: • • •
• • •
• • • • • •
Biologically active elements: C, hydrogen (H), oxygen (O), N, P, S, silicon (Si), calcium (Ca), iron (Fe), magnesium (Mg), manganese (Mn), molybdenum (Mo), and copper (Cu). Ratios of bioelements: photosynthetic Redfield ratio—C:N:P=106:16:1. Biologically induced minerals: carbonates, tufa, ikaite, breunnerite, magnesite, siderite, calcite, aragonite, phosphorites, hydroxyl apatite, vivianite, pyrite, pyrrhotite, maghemite, mackinawite, hematite, goethite, magnetite, griegite, magnetosomes, framboidal iron and pyrite, millerite, todorokite, feitknechtite, argentite, silica biopolymers, and opal. Evaporites and clay minerals: dolomite, gypsum, halite, sulfates, illite, smectite, chlorite, and laterite. Chemical biomarkers and biomolecules: amino acids, chiral amino acids, fatty acids, lipids; nucleosides, nucleotide bases, guanylurea, urea, ammeline, melamine, purines, and pyrimidines. Geochemical fossils: PAHs, alkanes, isoalkanes cycloalkanes, humic acids, dichlorobenzene, thriophrenes, polymeric organic matter, cholestane, tetrapyrroles, porphyrins, asphaltene, lignins, kerogen, isoprenoids (pristine and phytane), steranes, triterpenoids, and methyl hopanes and hopanoids. Biological fractionation of stable isotopes: (δ13C; δ15N; δ18O; δ34S). Fossil structures: stromatolites, microbialites, oncolites, desert varnish, and banded iron formations. Microfossils and biogenic assemblages: microfossils of cells, cell walls, cysts, biofilms, magnetosomes in chain-of-pearls alignments, remains of cells, cell walls, flagella, processes, trichomes, and filaments and sheaths. Reproductive stages/life cycles: diplococci, chains of cells, hormogonia, spores, akinetes, heterocysts, and resting states. Microfossils of biologically consistent microbial ecosystems: lithified or mineralized microbial colonies and consortia. Ancient DNA and intact or viable microorganisms: cryopreserved in glaciers, ice sheets, and permafrost or desiccated and reserved in fossil tissues, amber, salt crystals, or other evaporite minerals.
Geomicrobiology is an important field of scientific research, and several important mineralogical biomarkers can be recognized. Many nanobacteria utilize phosphorus in the production of apatite shells, and many cyanobacteria produce phosphorite sheaths. Phosphorus and apatite are also present in carbonaceous chondrites. The recent discovery of extensive concentrations of microfossils of cyanobacteria and bacteria have provided convincing evidence of the biogenic origin of many of the phosphorite deposits on Earth, such as the great Khubsugul, Mongolia deposits. Chalk, limestone, and other carbonate rocks on Earth are produced by accumulations of the shells of microorganisms, such as foraminifera,
R.B. Hoover / Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites
49
coccoliths, discoliths, etc. The carbonate globules in SNC meteorites are important mineral biomarkers. The possible microfossils in ALH84001 were found in association with the carbonate globules. The carbonaceous chondrites include important carbonate minerals, such as Breunnerite ((Mg0.8Fe0.2)CO3), dolomite (Ca Mg(CO3)2), calcite (CaCO3), and magnesite (MgCO3). Dufresne and Anders [43] reported dolomite as small polycrystalline aggregates in the Orgueil meteorite and as well-rounded grains in Ivuna. They concluded that the dolomite crystal perfection and crystallization time implied a damp environment lasted for more than 1,000 yr on the parent body of the Orgueil meteorite. The Orgueil carbonates are of great interest because in 1963, Clayton [44] showed that the δ13Cratios in Orgueil lie in the 60‰ to 70‰ range. This clearly proves that the Orgueil carbonates are extraterrestrial since this value is significantly higher than ever seen in terrestrial carbonate rocks and biological materials. The δ13Cvalues for the meteoritic carbon are considerably higher than ever encountered on Earth. This fact clearly establishes that the carbon is indigenous and not the result of terrestrial contamination. The δ13Cvalues for meteorite organic matter are considerably lighter and constitute a valid biomarker that is consistent with biological fractionation of stable isotopes that are well known and accepted as indicating biogenic activity in terrestrial rocks. The dominant silica minerals in carbonaceous meteorites include olivine ((Mg,Fe)2SiO4), fosterite (MgSiO4) and fayalite (Fe2SiO4). Taylor et al. [45] studied the Murray and the Al Rais C2 carbonaceous meteorites and determined the δ18O values for olivine were always significantly lighter than the rock matrix values. This suggests that these components had dramatically different origins. Silicates and silica biopolymers are found in algae, e.g.: diatoms, chrysophytes, chrysomonads, and xanthophytes; sponge spicules; protozoans, e.g.: radiolarians, silicoflagellates, zoomastigophora, testacid sarcodina, siliceous foraminifera, and Rhizopod amebae; and in nanoplankton like loricate choanoflagellates. Indeed, the great diatomite deposits represent the most abundant form of common opal on our planet. Simpson and Volcani [46] have provided an excellent review of silicon and siliceous structures in biological systems. Claus and Nagy [37] reported the detection of some diatom frustules in the Orgueil meteorites, but they were dismissed as recent contaminants from terrestrial soil diatoms. Diatoms and other siliceous microbes produce instant microfossils that can remain intact and unaltered for hundreds of millions of years. The taxonomy of the diatoms, forams, etc. is based entirely on their shell morphology and their microstructure, which is completely adequate for their identification and classification to genus, species, and variety. Bacterial paleontology is essential to identify morphological biomarkers indicating biogenic activity in meteorites and astromaterials. 3.1. Chemical Biomarkers in Earth Rocks and Meteorites Earth rocks and meteorites contain important chemical fossils and biomarkers. The carbon content of the Orgueil meteorite was so high that it was at first thought to be from terrestrial contamination. The carbon in carbonaceous chondrites is predominantly a polymer-like material. Kerogenous organic compounds similar to peat, lignite coal, or tar are not soluble in common solvents. These forms of carbon are not known to be formed on Earth without the intervention of microbial processes and therefore are considered valid biomarkers. Carbonaceous chondrites also contain other biomarkers—complex organics including aliphatic and aromatic hydrocarbons, chiral amino acids (some with no known use in terrestrial biochemistry), purine and pyrimidine bases, fatty acids, lipids, porphyrins, isoprenoids, pristine, phytane, and hopanoids. Numerous independent investigators have studied this rich suite of complex organic chemicals indigenous to carbonaceous meteorites. Nooner and Oro [47] investigated extractable aliphatic hydrocarbons, and Olson et al. [48] studied the aromatic hydrocarbons in
50
R.B. Hoover / Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites
many different types of carbonaceous meteorites including Ivuna type CI1 (Ivuna, Alais, and Orgueil), Murray type CM2 (Murray, Mighei, Al Rais, Nogoya, Boriskino, Santa Cruz, Renazzo, Bells, Cold Bokkeveld), Ornans type CO3 (Ornans, Felix, and Lance) Karoonda type CK4 (Karoonda), and Vigarano type CV3 (Vigarano, Mokoia, and Warrenton). Olson et al. [48] reported detectable levels of aromatic hydrocarbons in the benzene eluates of the Murray meteorite, including naphthalene, 2-methyl naphthalene, biphenyl, acenaphthene, fluorine, phenanthrene, and a trace of anthracene. They also examined the aromatic hydrocarbons in the Bruderheim meteorite, the fossiliferous Precambrian gunflint chert and a hornblende diorite igneous rock and found that the aliphatic hydrocarbons of the meteorites had distribution patterns similar to those of gunflint chert. Subsequent studies have shown that carbonaceous chondrites contain a complex suite of chemical biomarkers, including polymeric matter and organics, complex cycloalkanes, purines, pyrimidines, amino acids, and even chiral amino acids [48–59]. The distribution of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (m/e = 178 (phenanthrene (C14H10)), 202 (pyrene (C16H10)), 228 (chrysene (C18H12)), 252 (benzopyrene (C20H12)) in the Murchison meteorite [51] are very similar to the PAH distribution in ALH84001. In Murchison, Hayatsu et al. [52,53] detected indigenous purines and triazines, as well as 15 carboxylic acids and 11 aliphatic acids, which they could attribute to abiogenic processes, such as Fisher-Tropsch synthesis. Hydrocarbon analysis by gas chromatography/mass spectrometry was carried out on pristine samples of the Murchison meteorite collected immediately after its fall [54,55]. Kvenvolden et al. [56,57] detected 74 amino acids in Murchison, including a large number of non-protein species that are rare or completely unknown in terrestrial biology. They reported that the Murchison amino acids were racemic and had unusual stable isotope distributions [58,59], and therefore, were indigenous and could not have resulted from recent terrestrial contaminants. If the Murchison amino acids were recent contaminants, they should have not been racemic (equal mixtures of L- and D-enantiomers), rather they should have been almost exclusively the L-enantiomer. It is known that amino acids will become racemic over geological epochs—racemic mixtures are commonly found in ancient terrestrial organic matter. Engel and Nagy [60] recently detected a slight excess in L-amino acids in Murchison, indicating they were biogenic, i.e.: not Miller-Urey or Fisher-Tropsch synthesis products. The work of Engel et al. [61] and subsequently that of Cronin and Pizzarrello [62] has confirmed the presence of chiral amino acids indigenous to the Murchison meteorite. 3.2. Porphyrins in Earth Rocks and Meteorites Porphyrins are electron transport critical tetrapyrroles of profound importance to life on Earth. These complex biomolecules are encountered in life-critical pigments and enzymes. Magnesium is at the center of the tetrapyrrole ring in chlorophyll, which is one of several photosynthetic pigments that transduce light into chemical energy in plants, cyanobacteria, and other phototrophic microorganisms. Iron is at the center of the ring in the haeme groups of cytochromes responsible for transporting oxygen and carbon monoxide in blood and in the catalase enzyme, which catalyses the decomposition of cellular hydrogen peroxide. Porphyrin metal complexes are strong biomarkers, since porphyrins play a crucial role in the electron transport in oxidation-reduction reactions in almost all living organisms on Earth. The porphyrin ring is formed when four pyrrole rings (tetrapyrroles) condense with a metal ion (Fe, Mg, nickel (Ni), vanadium (V)) at the center of the porphin ring. Porphyrins are excellent biomarkers since they are both essential to critical biological processes and stable over geological time periods and conditions. As far back as 1935, Triebs [63] demonstrated that porphyrins are present in coal, phosphorites, oil shales, bituminous rocks, and petroleum. Park and Dunning [64] established by carbon isotope studies that the porphyrins
R.B. Hoover / Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites
51
were indigenous to petroleum. There are many pigments in living matter, e.g.: chlorophylls, bacteriochlorophylls, that are possible precursors for the petroleum porphyrins. Petroleum scientists have long considered the indigenous metallo-porphyrins as clear evidence of the biogenic origin of crude oil. Chlorins are porphin derivatives with hydrogen additions to the pyrrole ring, e.g.: dihydroporphin (chlorin) and tetrahydroporphin. Hodgson and Baker [65,66] investigated porphyrins in the Orgueil, Murray, Cold Bokkeveld and Mokoia carbonaceous chondrites and concluded that the meteorite porphyrins were indigenous and either from life forms different from terrestrial life or with a different diagenetic history after death. In Orgueil, they detected indigenous porphyrin pigments, which were spectrally similar to those in terrestrial sedimentary rocks. The absorption bands were consistent with vanadyl porphyrins in coal, petroleum, and oil shales. Vanadyl and nickel porphyrins are considered by petroleum geologists as some of the most important indicators of the biogenic origin of crude oil. These bands were not found in the solvent blank, granite, or ordinary chondrites. Hodgson and Baker [66] also detected substantial metal porphyrin complexes in Orgueil, Murray and Cold Bokkeveld, and Mokoia carbonaceous chondrites. They obtained excitation spectra with soret (390–413 nm) and nonsoret (490–615 nm) excitation bands present. Similar studies yielded negative results with other meteorites: Vigarano (C3), Indarch (Enstatite, E4), and the Bruderheim and Peace River stony chondrites (L6). The infrared (IR) spectra resemble those from organics in ancient terrestrial sedimentary rocks, e.g.: the Posidonia shale. Orgueil lacked chlorins (porphyrin derivatives where pyrrole rings have hydrogen additions). Since these closely related pigments are present in almost all terrestrial organisms, they should have been abundant if the meteorite porphyrins were due to recent terrestrial contaminants. (Chlorins very slowly convert to porphyrins and they are also absent in ancient terrestrial sediments.) Hodgson and Baker [66] have noted that indigenous porphyrins in Orgueil suggest the “strong possibility of biogenic agencies in the origin of the meteorite,” and the lack of chlorins indicates the indigenous meteoritic porphyrins are from prebiotic synthesis or ancient life. Nagy et al. [67] performed mass spectrometry analysis of Orgueil and found evidence of indigenous long-chain fatty acids. These organic chemicals showed patterns of molecular fragments (aliphatic and hydrocarbons) similar to fossil biological materials and petroleum. 3.3. Polymer-Type Organic Matter in Earth Rocks and Meteorites For many years, geochemical biomarkers have provided a standard tool for petroleum exploration. Good biomarkers must be stable for geologically significant periods of time (billions of years) and of definitive biogenic origin. Alteration of the original biochemicals by diagenesis and catagenesis is usually minimal and the basic carbon skeleton is preserved intact. Functional groups may be lost, e.g.: –OH, =O, etc., but the chemical structure derived from biological origins remains recognizable. Fossil biomolecules of cell membranes (fatty acids and lipids) are of known biological origin and are not produced abiotically. Fatty acids and long straight-chain hydrocarbon lipids are found in cell membranes of all three kingdoms of life on Earth. Nagy and Bitz [67] found fatty acids in cretaceous sedimentary rocks and meteorites. The long chain n-fatty acids they encountered in the Orgueil meteorite were absent in negative control blanks, indicating that they were not contaminants or introduced by their procedures. Murphy and Nagy [68] examined the sulfur compounds of the Orgueil lipid fraction. Hopanoids, isoprenoids, triterpanes, cholestanes, and steranes are important geochemical fossils and biomarkers because they are identifiable in the most ancient rocks and afford distinct biosignatures linked to specific kingdoms of life. Cholestane is the geologic product derived from the biochemical cholesterol and hopanoids are pentacyclic hydrocarbons
52
R.B. Hoover / Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites
Figure 4. (a) Diagenetic processes convert biologically produced cholesterol into geologic product 5 alpha(H) cholestane, (b) hopane, and (c) methylhopane and demethylaedhopane (25-norhopane) carbon skeletons.
that are derived from hopanes (Fig. 4). These types of biomarkers allow the petroleum geologists and astrobiologists to obtain information about the type of biological entity responsible for the geochemical, and therefore, they constitute important and valid biomarkers. Hopanoids are the predominant biosignatures of bacterial membranes, and they are totally unknown in archaea and rarely encountered in eukarya. In terrestrial sediments and rocks, there are 1014 tons of hopanoids derived from the membranes of ancient bacteria. This exceeds the total mass of carbon in all living organisms on Earth. The hopanoid carbon skeleton contains several chiral centers, so many stereoisomers are theoretically possible. The three different isomers found in the chiral centers at the C-17, C-21, and C-22 ring systems are the most significant in terrestrial rocks of the geosphere. In ancient marine sediments, Summons et al. [69] found 2-methylhopanes, which are derived from 2-Me-bacteriohopanepolyols (membrane lipids synthesized in large quantities only by cyanobacteria). Brocks et al. [70] extracted the cyanobacterial biosignatures (2methylhopanes) from 2.7 Ga old Archaean kerogenous shale. Astonishingly, C-28–C-30 steranes were also present in these rocks deep within Pilbara Craton of Australia. The detection of steranes in ancient shales dramatically extended the geological antiquity of eukaryotic biology. Steranes are valid biomarkers—biomolecules that are breakdown chemicals from complex sterols made only by eukaryotic life. These complex biomarkers show that the eukarye existed on Earth 500 Ma earlier than previously known. Although a few bacteria incorporate sterols into their membranes, none of the prokaryota form the elaborate sterols that are precursors for the C-28–C-30 steranes. Membranes in the cells of archaea are very different from those of the eukarya and none of the archaea has ever been found to synthesize sterols. Isoprenoids are branched-chain hydrocarbons with methyl substitutions in a pattern reflecting synthesis from one or more isoprene units. Geochemically, the most important isoprenoids are the saturated hydrocarbons phytane and pristine. Isoprenoids are biomarkers that are typically derived from photosynthetic microorganisms (with a possible contribution from isotopically light methanogenic archaea, which yield only small quantities of pristane and phytane relative to total biomass and no n-alkanes when pyrolyzed). Pristane is a common isoprenoid hydrocarbon, containing 19 carbon atoms, that is found in living organisms as well as in sediments and crude oils. Phytane is not found in living organisms. Pristane/phytane ratios <1 are associated with carbonate source rocks while values >4 are taken to indicate biological organic matter. Cronin and Pizzarello [71] found n-methyl and isoprenoid alkanes in Murchison using gas chromatography-mass spectroscopy, IR, and proton nuclear magnetic resonance spec-
R.B. Hoover / Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites
53
troscopy; however, they concluded that these valid biomarkers must have been due to terrestrial biological contamination. The aliphatic fraction of Murchison was found to be a structurally complex suite of branched alkyl-substituted, cycloalkanes (C-15–C-30). Gelpi and Oro [72] detected isoprenoids in 19 of the 20 carbonaceous chondrites they analyzed. They also concluded that these isoprenoids must have been the result of terrestrial biological contamination. Interpretation of these biomarkers as indigenous would have required a paradigm shift regarding biogenic activity and life in the meteorite parent body. When these petroleum biomarkers are found in terrestrial rocks they are readily accepted as the result of ancient biological activity. When similar suites of indigenous petroleum geochemicals are detected in meteorites they are dismissed as recent terrestrial contaminants or the result of abiogenic processes, e.g.: Miller-Urey or Fisher-Tropsch synthesis. Nagy [73] reviewed carbonaceous meteorites and the geochemistry of kerogens and hydrocarbons found in petroleum, coal, and oil shales. 3.4. The Biological Fractionation of Stable Isotopes The biological fractionation of the stable isotopes [74–76] of carbon, 13C and 12C, and sulfur, 34S and 32S, is a very well known and extremely important biomarker. Stable isotope studies and the detection of light carbon abundance are accepted as valid evidence of biogenic activity in extremely ancient Archaean terrestrial rocks that do not contain recognizable microfossils. Hence the observation of biological fraction of carbon in carbonaceous meteorites should also be considered strong evidence of indigenous biogenic activity in the parent body. Kvenvolden et al. [57] determined the carbon isotope abundances in the different carbonaceous phases of the Murchison meteorite and found the carbonate carbon to have a δ13C value of +45.4‰, which is vastly higher than terrestrial inorganic carbonates. In addition the organic carbon (Corg) of Murchison had a δ13C between –7.1‰ and –7.3‰. Terrestrial carbon of biological origin is significantly lighter (δ13C ranging from –10‰ to –60‰ depending on the nature of the organism and the carbon source. The δ13C values of the carbon in the Murchison mineral matrix and the soluble and insoluble polymeric carbon of Murchison are entirely consistent with biological fractionation of the Indigenous heavy carbon and imply biological activity on the meteorite parent body. The stable isotope results provide independent support of the evidence for indigenous microfossils and cyanobacterial ecosystems that have been detected in situ in freshly fractured samples of Murchison. As Nagy [73] concluded the carbon isotopes of the Murchison meteorite indicate that: the carbon is indigenous and not terrestrial; the δ13C of the Murchison Corg is dramatically lower than that of the mineral matrix; the δ13C of the Murchison Corg is higher than that of all terrestrial organic and inorganic matter; and biological fractionation is indicated in the meteorite stable carbon isotopes and it is clear that the terrestrial biological contamination is insignificant. Galimov [74] has investigated the thermodynamic isotopic fractionation of stable isotopes in a variety of biological systems. Figure 5 shows Galimov’s plots of the biological fractionation of stable carbon isotopes in the amino acids of several different life forms, such as (Fig. 5(a)) the green algae Chlorella pyrenoidosa, (Fig. 5(b)) the photosynthetic seaweed Gracilaria sp., and (Fig. 5(c)) the photosynthetic flagellated eukaryote Euglena gracilis. Galimov points out that the fractionation of the amino acids in the Murchison meteorite (Fig. 5(d)) is analogous to that seen in terrestrial biological systems. The values of δ13C for terrestrial abiotic carbon never exceeds, +10‰ and the stable isotope values of carbon in terrestrial life forms ranges from –4‰ (for autotrophs) to –85‰ (for methanotrophs). Since the stable isotope ratio δ13C for the carbon of Murchison meteorite ranges from +50‰ to +20‰, it is obviously impossible to interpret the Murchison amino acids as having resulted from contamination from any biological material found on Earth.
54
R.B. Hoover / Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites
Figure 5. Galimov data on the biological fractionation of stable carbon isotopes in the amino acids of (a) green algae Chlorella pyrenoidosa, (b) Gracilaria sp., (c) eukaryote Euglena gracilis, and (d) the Murchison CM2 carbonaceous meteorite (Courtesy E. Galimov).
Sulfate-reducing bacteria and archaea thrive in highly alkaline environments and in hot environments, such as geysers, fumaroles, and volcanic and deep-sea hydrothermal vents. The thermophilic and hyperthermophilic archaea represent the oldest known lineages of the sulfate-reducing bacteria on Earth. Some evidence indicates that these microorganisms have inhabited Earth for at least 3.5 Ga. The environments of early Earth, Mars, and Io may have been very similar, with water and intense volcanic activity. The sulfur- and sulfate-reducing microbes are excellent analogs for life on Mars and Io. Since dissimilatory bacterial sulfate reduction yields sulfides that are depleted in δ34S, the detection of biological fractionation as shown by δ34S values should be explored as a biomarker for optimizing the probability of finding evidence of life in Martian samples.
4. Morphological Biomarkers and Microfossils Morphological biomarkers include fossilized biofilms, desert varnish, microbialites, oncolites, laminated organo-sedimentary remains of bacterial and algal mats (stromatolites), nanofossils and microfossils of the carbonized or lithified remains of bacteria, archaea, cyanobacteria, algae, pollen, spores, resting stages, and organic-walled microfossils, such as hystrichospheres, pollen, and acritarchs. Research in bacterial paleontology [45] has made great progress in the recognition of fossil bacteria, algae, cyanobacteria, protozoans, fungi, actinomycetes, acritarchs, biofilms, and nanobacteria. Microfossils of cyanobacteria are well known from Cambrian and Precambrian cherts, oil shales, shungites, phosphorites and graphites [77–85]. Fossilized microbialites, and laminated organo-sedimentary structures (bacterial mats and stromatolites) were found in ~3.7 Ga old [86,87] rocks. Mojzsis [88] found molecular biomarkers in 3.8-Ga-old sedimentary rocks—the earliest trace
R.B. Hoover / Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites
55
of a biosphere. Rasmussen and Buick [89,90] found filamentous microfossils and petroleum in 3.2 Ga old volcanogenic massive sulfide deposits. Electron microscopy studies in the United States and Russia have revealed abundant lithified, carbonized, and embedded microfossils in every carbonaceous meteorite examined, but similar forms have been notably absent in other meteorites. These studies have concentrated on freshly fractured interior surfaces of the meteorites since the fusion crust and pre-existing cracks of meteorites can easily become contaminated by fungi, actinomycetes, and organotrophic bacteria. At the Paleontological Institute in Moscow, scanning electron microscope (SEM) studies were carried out on coated samples, and the x-ray analysis conducted with the LINK analyzer. At MSFC, uncoated samples were examined using ESEM and FESEM. These systems are capable of producing high resolution imaging of uncoated samples and biological materials and spectral analysis using energy dispersive x-ray spectroscopy (EDAX). Sterile sample handling techniques and optical microscopy methods have been used to examine numerous carbonaceous chondrites and stony meteorites. Field expeditions were carried out to investigate the morphology, life cycle processes, and ecological associations of living and cryopreserved bacteria, algae, and cyanobacteria in permafrost, cryoconite communities of Siberia and Alaska. Laboratory studies also included the Vostok deep ice cores [91–93], and magnetotactic bacteria and microfossils [94–98] in terrestrial rocks for comparison with lithified/carbonized remains found embedded in situ in a meteorite matrix.
5. Evidence of Magnetotactic Bacteria in Meteorites Magnetosomes and magnetite associated with magnetotactic bacteria are valid biomarkers. Anaerobic or microaerobic microorganisms produce magnetosomes with recognizable properties and definitive evidence of biogenicity. In 1975, Blakemore [99] announced the discovery of a magnetotactic bacterium, which he named Aquasprillum magnetotacticum, Schleiffer et al. [100] later transferred this species to the new genus, Magnetospirillum gen. nov., and described a new species, Magnetospirillum gryphiswaldense. Several other species of magnetotactic bacteria and algae have subsequently been found in anaerobic, microaerobic environments, and in soils, permafrost, and loess [101,102]. These microorganisms produce membrane-bounded magnetic crystals of magnetite (Fe3O4) or griegite (Fe3S4) [103–104]. The magnetite crystals are uniform and in the single-magnetic domain size range (typically about 35 to 150 nm) [105]. Matrix-controlled biomagnetite crystals are specific to species and occur in several configurations, e.g.: cubo-octahedral, elongated hexagonal prismatic, or bullet shaped. To optimize the magnetic properties, microorganisms usually configure the magnetites into one or more chains-of-pearls strands along the longitudinal axis of the organism [106,107]. Axis dipoles are oriented with the crystal axis—magnetite [108] or griegite [109] aligned to the chain direction. These microstructures are strong biomarkers because their unique morphological properties and chain-of-pearls distribution can be recognized in living organisms and rocks, and they distinguish biological magnetosomes from abiotic. Iron-reducing bacteria can also produce extracellular magnetite globules by dissimilatory iron reduction. The biomagnetite crystals produced in this way may exhibit lower crystallinity and a wider grain size than those found in magnetosomes. Mckay et al. [110] recently showed that the parallelepiped magnetites of ALH84001 exhibit the precise characteristics of biogenic magnetites. These results provide strong evidence for biogenic activity in this ancient Mars meteorite. Microfossils of magnetotactic bacteria with chains of magnetosomes and/or extracellular magnetites have now been detected in several meteorites, e.g.: ALH84001, Orgueil, Nogoya, and the Tagish Lake meteorites.
56
R.B. Hoover / Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites
Figure 6. (a) Orgueil microfossil with extracellular magnetite and chain-of-pearls magnetosomes, (b) magnetosomes in living purple sulfur bacteria Rhodopseudomonas rutilis, (c) ESEM image of microfossils in Nogoya carbonaceous meteorite and two-dimensional X-ray Maps in (d) Al, (e) Ca, (f) Fe, (g) O, and (h) S.
In 1967, Tan and VanLandingham [111] conducted transmission electron microscopy (TEM) studies of acid-resistant biological-like microstructures that they found in the Orgueil carbonaceous meteorite. They found numerous acid resistant cylindrical forms that were rounded on one end and tapered at the other (Fig. 6 (a)). TEM images show electrondense magnetites aligned as a chain of pearls along the longitudinal axis. Vainshtein [112,113] provided TEM images of living purple sulfur bacteria, Rhodopseudomonas rutilis, with similar configuration of magnetosomes (Fig. 6 (b)). An iron- and oxygen-rich microfossil in the Nogoya carbonaceous meteorite, which has similar microstructure to the magnetotactic microfossils of Orgueil, is shown in Fig. 6 (c) along with an accompanying ESEM image and two-dimensional x-ray maps showing the Al, Ca, Fe, O, and S distributions.
6. The Murchison Meteorite On the morning of September 28, 1969, a bright orange fireball with a silvery rim and a dull orange conical tail illuminated the sky over Victoria, Australia. Hundreds of black stones fell in a 1-mi wide and 10-mi long scatter ellipse at around the town of Murchison (36˚37’ S, 145˚14’ E). In December 2000, Hoover visited Murchison, Australia and discussed the event with several individuals who had witnessed the fireball and collected stones soon after their fall. Several reported hearing a hissing noise that sounded like “truck tires on a wet pavement” as soon as they saw the fireball. The fireball was seen to separate into several pieces, which was followed by the sound of several loud explosions. A strong smell of methyl alcohol was detected. Several of the Murchison stones landed on the golf course without scorching the grass or becoming embedded in the relatively soft ground.
R.B. Hoover / Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites
57
The low-density meteorite was obviously slowed and cooled by passage through denser parts of the atmosphere; one specimen penetrated a sheet metal roof of a shed and landed on hay without igniting the hay. Clearly, the Murchison stones hit the ground at terminal velocity and were not extremely hot when they arrived. Some Orgueil meteorite stones, which landed in France in 1864, were found with frost coatings shortly after their fall, indicating that the interior remained frozen and quickly cooled the fusion crust to allow moisture to condense and freeze. Lovering, who did the first scientific studies of Murchison, reported that frost was also observed on some nickel-iron meteorites.1 He received a sealed Murchison sample as he arrived at a television studio with Apollo 11 moon rocks one day after the fall. When the sealed Murchison bag was opened, a gas that had a strong odor of methyl alcohol was released. Pristine Murchison stones kept in sealed vials at the Victoria Museum still retain a strong sulfurous odor similar to asphalt and tar. Although the Murchison parent body remains unknown, the stable isotopes, and mineralogical analysis reveals that it certainly was not from Earth, the Moon, or Mars. Pollack et al. [114] note that the IR (0.4 to 1.1 δm)observations of Mars’ moon, Phobos, are similar to the spectral properties of the Murchison (CM2), Murray (CM2), and Orgueil (CI1) carbonaceous chondrites but different from basalt and other materials tested. They suggested that the 20-km diameter moon, Phobos, may be a carbonaceous chondrite that was captured by Mars in the early history of the solar system when Mars had a more extended gaseous envelope. The IR spectral reflectance properties of Murchison also resemble those of the 1,018-km diameter asteroid, Ceres [115]. Asteroids are considered the most probable parent bodies for the Ivuna-type (CI) and Mighei-type (CM) meteorites, but extinct cometary cores or protocometary bodies are also possibilities [116]. Observations of the Murchison fireball from the nearby towns of Mildura and Sheparton, Australia allowed Halliday and McIntosh [117] to compute an orbit for the parent body. Their calculations indicated a perihelion of 0.992 AU for an aphelion of 3 AU, which is consistent with the peak concentration of carbonaceous, i.e.: C-type, asteroids. This result implies that Murchison was overtaking Earth with a low relative velocity (~13 km/s) and that it would have never approached much closer to the Sun than the orbit of Earth. This result is consistent with the indigenous volatiles and suggests that conditions on the parent body may well have been conducive to microbiota, including photosynthetic bacteria and cyanobacteria that are known from cryoconite environments in glaciers and polar ice caps. During a portion of the orbit, Murchison would have been close enough to the Sun for indigenous water to have been in a liquid state, but not close enough for the volatiles to be driven off or for heat loads or radiation levels detrimental to microbial life. Seargent [118] noted the similarity of this orbit with periodic comet Finlay and the C-type Apollo asteroid 1979 VA (comet WilsonHarrington) and considered the possibility that Murchison may have come from a comet. The cosmic-ray exposure age (800,000 yr) [119] indicate that Murchison may have been a large boulder whose stem eroded from sustained cometary activity.
7. Microfossils of Cyanobacteria and Acritarchs in Carbonaceous Meteorites The search for microfossils in freshly fractured samples of carbonaceous meteorites has been carried out at MSFC using the Hitachi FESEM and the ElectroScan Corp. ESEM. Numerous samples from museums and meteorites collected during the Antarctica 2000 Expedition were studied. Mautner et al. [120] have shown that meteorite organic matter is a suitable nutrient for organotrophs and the meteorite fusion crust and old fractures are very susceptible to contamination by recent fungi, actinomycetes, and bacteria. During this research, fungal contamination of the fusion crust and pre-existent cracks, was detected in one sample of Murchison provided by the Field Museum in Chicago. These fungi were
58
R.B. Hoover / Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites
Figure 7. (a) Murchison meteorite microfossils similar to Nostocacean cyanobacteria tapered filament with apical cell and multiple cells in a common sheath, and (b) multiple filaments similar to Microcoleus cyanobacteria in common sheath in the Orgueil meteorite.
readily recognized as recent contaminants by several methods, such as the high oxygen and nitrogen content seen in the EDAX spectra, by the motion and behavior of the filaments under the electron beam, and by the appearance and color of these recent contaminants, which were clearly neither embedded nor lithified, as seen with optical microscope. Several pristine Murchison samples that had been carefully maintained in sealed vials since they were collected shortly after the meteorite landed in 1969 were provided on loan by Bill Birch of the Victoria Museum in Melbourne, Australia for this research. ESEM and FESEM studies of freshly fractured interior surfaces reveal that all of these meteorites contain abundant microfossils. Forms recognizable as the remains of biofilms, nanobacteria, cyanobacteria, and bacteria have been found. Figure 7 (a) shows a lithified form with a follicle-like structure (apical cell) at the apex (~2 δm in diameter) similar to known cyanobacteria of the genus Nostoc. These microstructures are virtually identical in size and morphology to the forms described as resembling filamentary blue-green algae (cyanobacteria) that were found in the Orgueil meteorite by Palik [121] of the Microbiological Institute of the Eötvös Lorand University in Budapest. This form is in proximity to three sheath covered cells and multiple filaments within a common sheath, similar to microfossils of cyanobacteria (cf. Phormidium sp.and Microcoleus sp.) that are preserved in the Cambrian phosphorites of Khubsugul, Mongolia. In Fig. 7.b. multiple trichomes in a common sheath are foundt in situ in the Orgueil meteorite. These forms are similar to those known in both living halophilic cyanobacteria Microcoleus spp. and fossil forms that are known from the Cambrian phosphorites of Khubsughul, Mongolia. In Fig. 7 (b), it is seen that another group of trichomes is only partially exposed, with the rest of the sheath projecting downward and encased in the mineral matrix of the meteorite. Clusters of coccoidal bacteria are seen on the surface of the horizontal group of sheaths. Figure 8 shows a long hollow sheath, similar to that of Nostocacean cyanobacteria, surrounded by embedded remains of coiled hormogonia in the Murchison meteorite. Since cyanobacteria are photosynthetic microorganisms, they are not logical candidates for recent contaminants because they would not have reason to invade the interior of the black meteorite stones. Acid-resistant organic-walled microfossils and acritarchs have been found in several meteorites. Claus and Nagy first described them, and subsequently, they have been extensively studied [122–130]. Rossignol-Strick and Barghorn [39] concluded that these acidresistant, hollow-walled forms were definitively not pollen. They also considered them to be indigenous to the Orgueil meteorite and of extraterrestrial origin. Timofejev [131] photographed (Fig. 9 (a)) numerous acritarch-like microfossils found in the Mighei meteorite. Figure 9 (b) and (c) show two of the acritarch-like microfossils found in the Orgueil and Murchison meteorites.
R.B. Hoover / Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites
59
Figure 8. Embedded remains in the Murchison meteorite showing emergent trichomes, sheath, and coiled hormogonia of cyanobacteria.
Figure 9. (a) Acritarch-like microfossils found in the Mighei meteorite by Timofejev and ESEM images of Acritarch-like forms found by Hoover in (b) Mighei meteorite, and (c) in a pristine Murchison sample collected near Murchison East, Victoria (donated by John Lovering to the Victoria Museum on Feb. 10, 1971).
Since acritarchs are extinct microorganisms of uncertain affinities (probably resting spores of extinct marine phytoplankton), they cannot be considered as logical suspects for recent contaminants for these carbonaceous meteorites.
8. Conclusions Carbonaceous meteorites contain a complex suite of chemical, mineral, and morphological biomarkers. Independent and later collaborative investigations at NASA’s MSFC and the PIN/RAS have resulted in the detection of a suite of large, clearly biogenic, lithified, and embedded microstructures that are interpreted to be indigenous microfossils. Many of the forms found are similar to known photosynthetic microbes or extinct algae. In some cases, they have been found in complex assemblages of consistent microbial ecosystems and consortia. They are commonly encountered embedded and carbonized or lithified in recently fractured surfaces of the meteorite matrix. Using these methodologies, a single recognizable pollen grain has yet to be encountered, and based on their microbiology and the type of preservation, these microfossils that have been found cannot be dismissed as recent pollen contaminants. Many are recognizable as bacteria, cyanobacteria, algae, and acritarchs. Microfossils have been encountered in every carbonaceous chondrite studied: CI (Alais, Tagish Lake, and Orgueil), CM (Murchison, Mighei, Murray, and Nogoya), CO (Rainbow, Kainsaz; DaG 749), CV (Allende and Efremovka), CR (Acfer324), and CK (Karoonda), belonging to the petrographic types 1, 2, 3, 5, and 7. Similar microstructures were not found in the non-carbonaceous meteorites that were studied, including a diogenite (DIO) from
60
R.B. Hoover / Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites
Tunisia (Tatahouhine, DIO); several ordinary chondrites, e.g.: Holbrook, L/LL6; Nikolskoye, L4; Barratta, L4; and stony meteorites collected on the Moulton escarpment of the Thiel Mountains (TIL99001–TIL99019) during the Antarctica 2000 Expedition. 8.1. Evidence of Indigenicity Microfossils have been found embedded in freshly fractured surfaces of the meteorite matrix and elemental distributions by EDAX analysis (C, O, Fe, Ni, S, N, and P) and two dimensional x-ray maps indicate that many of the microfossils are lithified and/or carbonized. Consequently, they cannot be interpreted as recent contaminants and are interpreted as indigenous. Some have affinities to extinct groups—acritarchs and hystricospheres—which would not be expected to contaminate meteorites that were observed to fall within the last century. 8.2. Evidence for Biogenicity Some of the forms have recognizable cell walls, membranes, sheaths, and glycocalyx. Many are present as colonies, coccoidal clusters, and macrocolonies (similar to cyanobacteria and purple sulfur bacteria). Evidence of life cycle processes—including replication, e.g.: dividing cells/diplococci, hormogonia, spores, and chains of cells—as well as ecologically consistent microbial assemblages and communities (similar to cryoconite communities from Antarctica, including Microcoleus spp., Phormidium frigidum, and Nostoc spp.) has been encountered. Many of the microfossils that were found exhibit strong similarities to living cyanobacteria, magnetotactic bacteria, living algae, and extinct plankton. On one sample of the Murchison meteorite, on the fusion crust and in old fissures, there was evidence of recent fungi and actinomycetes that are interpreted as recent (postarrival) biocontaminants. Microbiota or microfossils that may have been present on the meteorite when it entered Earth’s atmosphere, should be considered indigenous. Therefore, this suite of complex microstructures found in situ in freshly fractured surfaces of carbonaceous meteorites is interpreted as representing the indigenous biogenic remains of microbiota and microbial communities that were present on the meteorite parent body prior to arrival at Earth’s surface.
Acknowledgments Great thanks go to Alexei Yu. Rozanov for extensive collaborations, Greg Jerman and James Costen for electron microscopy support, Bill Birch, Director of the Victoria Museum in Melbourne for pristine samples of the Murchison meteorite.
Endnote 1.
Private communication between John Lovering and Richard Hoover. December 2000.
References [1] McKay DS, Gibson, Jr. EK, Thomas-Keprta KL, Vali H, Romanek CS, Clemett SJ, Chillier XDF, Maechling CR, Zare RN. Search for past life on Mars: possible relic biogenic activity in Martian meteorite ALH84001. Science 1996; 273: 924–30.
R.B. Hoover / Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites
61
[2] Kieft TL. Size matters: dwarf cells in soil and subsurface terrestrial environments. In: Colwell RR, Grimes DJ, editors. Non-culturable microorganisms in the environment. Washington DC: American Society for Microbiology; 2000. 19–46 p. [3] Folk RL. SEM Imaging of bacteria and nannobacteria in carbonate sediments and rocks. J. Sedimentary Petrology 1993; 63: 990–9. [4] Folk RL, Lynch FL. The possible role of nannobacteria (dwarf bacteria) in clay mineral diagenesis and the importance of careful sample preparation in high magnification SEM study. J. Sedimentary Res. 1997; 67: 597–603. [5] Akerman KK, Kuronen I, Kajander EO. Scanning electron microscopy of nanobacteria—novel biofilm producing organisms in blood. Scanning Electron Microscopy 1993; 15 (Suppl. III): 90–1. [6] Kajander EO, Kuronen I, Akersman K, Pelttari A, Ciftcioglu N. Nanobacteria from blood, the smallest culturable autonomously replicating agent on Earth. In: Hoover RB, editor. Instruments, methods, & missions for the investigation of extraterrestrial microorganisms, Proc. SPIE 1997; 3111: 420–35. [7] Vainstein M, Kudryashova E, Suzina N, Ariskina E, Voronkov V. Formation of bacterial nanocells. In: Hoover RB, editor. Instruments, methods, & missions for astrobiology, Proc. SPIE 1998; 3441: 95–104. [8] Huber H, Hohn MJ, Rachel R, Fuchs T, Wimmer VC, Stetter KO. A new phylum of archaea represented by a nanosized hyperthermophilic symbiont. Nature 2002; 417: 63–7. [9] Schulz HN, Brinkhoff T, Ferdelman TG, Hernandez Marine M, Teske A, Jørgensen BB. Dense population of a giant sulfur bacterium in Namibian shelf sediments. Science1999; 284: 493–5. [10] Olson GJ, Dockins WS, McFeathers GA. Sulfate reducing and methanogenic bacteria from deep aquifers in Montana. Geomicrobiol. J. 1981; 2: 327–40. [11] Stetter KO, Zillig W. Thermoplasma and the thermophilic sulfur-dependent archaebacteria. In: Woese CR, Wolfe RS, editors. The Bacteria, Vol. III, Orlando: Academic Press Inc.; 1985. 85–170. [12] Stetter KO. Diversity of extremely thermophilic archaebacteria. In: Brock TD, editor. Thermophiles: general, molecular and applied microbiology. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.; 1986. 39–74 p. [13] Pikuta EV, Hoover RB. Sulfate- and sulfur-reducing bacteria as terrestrial analogs for microbial life on Jupiter’s satellite Io. In: Hoover RB, Levin GV, Paepe R, Rozanov AYu, editors. Instruments, methods, & missions for astrobiology IV, Proc. SPIE 2002; 4495: 232–54. [14] Pikuta EV, Hoover RB, Bej A, Whitman W, Marsic D, Garriott O. Thermococcus sulfurophilus sp. nov., a new hyperthermophilic, sulfur-reducing archaeon isolated from deep-sea hydrothermal vent. Extremophiles 2003; Submitted. [15] Pikuta EV, Hoover RB, Bej A, Marsic D, Whitman WB, Cleland D, Krader P. Desulfonatronum thiodismutans sp. nov., a novel alkaliphilic, sulfate-reducing bacterium capable of lithoautotrophic growth. Int. J. Syst. Evol. Microbiol. 2003; 53: 1327–32. [16] Levin GV. The Viking labeled release experiment and life on Mars. In: Instruments, methods, & missions for the investigation of extratesstrial microorganisms, Proc. SPIE 1997; 3111: 146–61. [17] Miller JD, Straat PA, Levin GV. Periodic analysis of the Viking Lander labeled release experiment. In: Hoover RB, editor. Instruments, methods, & missions for astrobiology, IV. Proc. SPIE 2001; 4495: 96–107. [18] Zuber MT, Smith DE, Solomon SC, Abshire JB, Afzal RS, Aharonson O, Fishbaugh K, Ford PG, Frey HV, Garvin JB, Head JW, Ivanov AB, Johnson CL, Muhleman DO, Neumann GA, Pettengill GH, Phillips RJ, Sun X, Zwally HJ, Banerdt WB, Duxbury TC. Observations of the north polar region of Mars from the Mars orbiter laser altimeter. Science 1998; 282: 2053–60. [19] Hoover RB, Gilichinsky D. Significance to astrobiology of microorganisms in permafrost and ice. In: Paepe R, editor. Permafrost response on economic development, environmental security and natural resources, NATO-ARW (held in Novosibrisk, Siberia, 12–16 November, 1998). Kluwer Publishing; 2001. p. 553–80. [20] Paepe R, Van Overloop E, Hoover R. Interference or comparison between Mars and terrestrial landscapes as an evidence of water and its cycles. SPIE 1999; 3755: 130–43. [21] Paepe R, Hoover R, and Van Overloop E. Patterned ground as an evidence of water on Mars. In: Paepe R, Melnikov V, editors. Permafrost response on economic development, environmental security and natural resources, NATO ASI Series 2, Environmental Security 2001; 76: 581–8. [22] Paepe R, Van Overloop E, and Hoover R. Permafrost patterns and sedimentological cycles on Mars. ESA’s Publication Division (EPD), Special Publication 2001; SP–496: 239–42. [23] Paepe R, Paulissen E. Frost wedge forms in relation to their geomorphological and stratigraphic position in Taylor Valley (Antarctica). Professional Paper, Belgian Geol. Surv. 1974: 3: 26. [24] Paepe R. and Van Overloop, E. Landscape, Sediment, Red Soil, Permafrost Geomorph Parallels on Earth and Mars, NATO ASI Series 2, Environmental Security, 2005 (this volume, in press). [25] Hoover RB, Pikuta EV, Marsic D, Ng JD. Anaerobic psychrophiles from Alaska, Antarctica, and Patagonia: implications to possible life on Mars and Europa. In: Hoover RB, editor. Instruments, methods, & missions for astrobiology, IV. Proc. SPIE 2001; 4495: 313–24.
62
R.B. Hoover / Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites
[26] Marsic D, Pikuta EV, Hoover RB, Ng JD. Cloning of the 16S ribosomal RNA gene of a psychrophilic bacterium from the Alaskan fox Permafrost Tunnel. In: Hoover RB, editor. Instruments, methods, & missions for astrobiology, IV. Proc. SPIE 2001; 4495: 313–24. [27] Marsic D, Hoover RB, Gilinchinsky DA, Ng JD. Gene cloning of the 18S rRNA for ancient viable moss from the permafrost of northeastern Siberia. In: Hoover RB, editor. Instruments, methods, & missions for astrobiology, II. Proc. SPIE 2000; 3755: 163–73. [28] Marsic D, Hoover RB, Gilichinsky D, Ng JD. Extraction and amplification of DNA from an ancient moss.://www.promega.com/enotes/applications/ap0004_print.htm. Promega eNotes; 1999. Last accessed November 10, 2003. [29] Abyzov SS. Microorganisms in the Antarctic ice. In: Friedman EI, editor. Antarctic Microbiology. New York: Willey-Liss, Inc.; 1993. 265–96 p. [30] Abyzov SS, Mitskevitch IN, Puglozova MN, Barkov NI, Lipenkov VYa, Bobin NE, Koudryashov BB, Pashkevich VM. Long-term conservation of viable microorganisms in ice sheet of Central Antarctica. In: Hoover RB, editor. Instruments, methods, & missions for astrobiology. Proc. SPIE 1998; 3441: 75– 84. [31] Gilichinsky D, Wegener S, Vishnivetskaya T. Permafrost microbiology. Permafrost and Periglacial Proc. 1995; 2: 281–91. [32] Gilichinsky DA. Permafrost as a microbial habitat: extreme for the Earth, favorable in space. In: Hoover RB, editor. Instruments, methods, & missions for astrobiology. Proc. SPIE 1997; 3111: 472–80 [33] Hoover RB, Hoyle F, Wickramasinghe NC, Hoover MJ, Al-Mufti S. Diatoms on Earth, comets, Europa and in interstellar space. Earth, Moon, and Planets1986; 35: 19–45. [34] O’Keefe JD, Ahrens TJ. Meteorite impact ejecta: dependence of mass and energy lost on planetary escape velocity. Science 1977; 198: 1248–51. [35] Melosh HJ. Ejection of rock fragments from planetary bodies. Geology 1985; 13: 144–8; The rocky road to panspermia. Nature 1988; 332: 687–8; Impact ejection, spallation and the origin of meteorites. Icarus 1984; 56: 260–99. [36] Gladman BJ, Burns JA. Mars meteorite transfer: simulation. Science 1996; 274: 161–2. [37] Claus G, Nagy B. A microbiological examination of carbonaceous chondrites. Nature 1961; 192: 594– 6. [38] Nagy B, Meinschein WG, Hennessy DJ. Mass spectroscopic analysis of the Orgueil meteorite: evidence for biogenic hydrocarbons. Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci. 1961; 93: 25–35. [39] Rossignol-Strick M, Barghoorn ES. Extraterrestrial abiogenic organization of organic matter: the hollow spheres of the Orgueil meteorite. Space Life Sci. 1971; 3: 89–107. [40] Rozanov AYu, Zavarzin GA. Bacterial paleontology. In: Hoover RB, editor. Instruments, methods, & missions for astrobiology, Proc. SPIE 1998; 3441: 218–84. [41] Redfield AC. On the proportions of organic derivations in sea water and their relation to the composition of plankton. In: James Johnston Memorial Volume. Liverpool; 1934. 176–92 p. [42] Redfield AC. The biological control of the chemical factors in the environment. Amer. Sci. 1958; 46: 225–21. [43] DuFresne ER, Anders E. On the chemical evolution of carbonaceous chondrites. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 1962; 26: 1085–114. [44] Clayton RN. Carbon isotope abundance in meteorite carbonates. Science 1963; 140: 192–3. [45] Taylor Jr. HP, Duke MB, Silver LT, Epstein S. Oxygen isotope studies of minerals in stony meteorites. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 1965; 29: 489–512. [46] Simpson TL, Volcani BE, editors. Silicon and siliceous structures in biological systems. New York: Springer-Verlag; 1981. 1–585 p. [47] Nooner DW, Oro J. Organic compounds in meteorites, 1. Aliphatic hydrocarbons. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 1967; 31: 1359–94. [48] Olson RJ, Oro J, Zlatkis A. Organic compounds in meteorites, 2. Aromatic hydrocarbons. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 1967; 31: 1935–48. [49] Folsomme CE, Lawless J, Romiez M, Ponnamperuma C. Heterocyclic compounds indigenous to the Murchison meteorite. Nature 1971; 232: 108–9. [50] Kvenvolden KA, Lawless JG, Pering K, Peterson E, Flores J, Ponnamperuma C, Kaplan IR, Moore C. Evidence for extraterrestrial amino acids and hydrocarbons in the Murchison meteorite. Nature 1970; 228: 923–6. [51] Basile BP, Middleditch BS, Oro J. Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in the Murchison meteorite. Organic Geochem. 1984; 5: 211–6. [52] Hayatsu R, Studier MH, Moore LP, Anders E. Purines and Triazines in the Murchison meteorite. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 1975; 39: 471–88. [53] Hayatsu R, Matsuoka S, Scott RG, Studier MH, Anders E. Origin of organic matter in the early solar system-VII. The organic polymer in carbonaceous chondrites. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 1977; 41: 1325–39.
R.B. Hoover / Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites
63
[54] Oro J, Gilbert J, Lichstein H, Wikstrom S, Flory DA. Amino acids, aliphatic and aromatic hydrocarbons in the Murchison meteorite. Nature 1971; 230: 105–6. [55] Studier ML, Hayatsu R, Anders E. Origin of organic matter in early solar system-V. Further studies of meteoritic hydrocarbons and a discussion of their origin. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 1972; 36: 189– 215. [56] Kvenvolden KA, Lawless JG, Ponnamperuma C. Non-protein amino acids in the Murchison meteorite. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 1971; 68: 486–90. [57] Kvenvolden KA, Lawless JG, Pering K, Peterson E, Flores J, Ponnamperuma C, Kaplan IR, Moore C. Evidence for extraterrestrial amino acids and hydrocarbons in the Murchison meteorite. Nature 1970; 228: 923–6. [58] Epstein S, Krishnamurthy RV, Cronin JR, Pizarello S, Yuen GU. Unusual stable isotope ratios in amino acid and carboxylic acid extracts from the Murchison meteorite. Nature 1987; 326: 477–9. [59] Engel MH, Macko SA, Silfer JA. Carbon isotope composition of individual amino acids in the Murchison meteorite. Nature 1990; 348: 479. [60] Engel M, Nagy B. Distribution and enantiomeric composition of amino acids in the Murchison meteorite. Nature 1982; 296: 837–40. [61] Engel MH, Macko SA. Stable isotope analysis of amino acid enantiomers in the Murchison meteorite at natural abundance levels. In: Hoover RB, editor. Instruments, methods, & missions for the investigation of extraterrestrial microorganisms. Proc. SPIE 1997; 3111: 82–6. [62] Cronin JR Pizzarello S. Enantiomeric excesses in meteoritic amino acids. Sci. 1997; 275: 951–5. [63] Triebs A. Chlorophyll- und hemin-derivatine in bituminosen gesteinen, erdolen, kohlen, phosphoriten. Ann. Chem. 1935; 517: 172–96. [64] Park R, Dunning HN. Stable carbon isotope studies of crude oils and their porphyrin aggregates. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 1961; 22: 99–105. [65] Hodgson W, Baker BL. Evidence of porphyrins in the Orgueil meteorite. Nature 1964; 202: 125–31. [66] Hodgson GW, Baker BL. Porphyrins in meteorites: metal complexes in Orgueil, Murray, Cold Bokkeveld and Mokoia carbonaceous chondrites. Geochim, Cosmochim. Acta 1969; 33: 943–58. [67] Nagy B, Bitz MC. Long-chain fatty acids in the Orgueil meteorite. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 1963; 101: 240–8. [68] Murphy MTJ, Nagy B. Analysis of sulfur compounds in lipid extracts from the Orgueil meteorite. J. Am. Oil. Chem. Soc. 1966; 43: 189–96. [69] Summons RE, Janke LL, Hope JM, Logan GA. 2-methylhopanoids as biomarkers for cyanobacterial oxygenic photosynthesis. Nature 1999; 398: 554–7. [70] Brocks JJ, Logan GA, Buick R, Summons RE. Archean molecular fossils and the early rise of eukaryotes. Science 1999; 285: 1033–6. [71] Cronin R, Pizzarello S. Aliphatic hydrocarbons of the Murchison meteorite. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 1990; 54: 2859–68. [72] Gelpi E, Oro J Organic compounds in meteorites-IV. Gas chromatographic-mass spectrometric studies on the isoprenoids and other isomeric alkanes in carbonaceous chondrites. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 1970; 34: 981–94. [73] Nagy B. Carbonaceous meteorites. New York: Elsevier Scientific Publishing Co.; 1975. 1–747 p. [74] Galimov EM. The biological fractionation of isotopes. New York: Academic Press; 1985. 1–261 p. [75] Neir AO, Gulbransen EA. Variations in the relative abundance of the carbon isotopes. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1939; 61: 697. [76] Buick R, Des Marais DJ, Knoll AH. Stable isotopic compositions of carbonates from the Mesoproterozoic Bangemall Group, northwestern Australia. Chem. Geol. 1995; 123: 153–71. [77] Zhmur SI. Origin of oil shales of Baltic syneclise: Information 2. Kukersite. Litol. Polezn. Iskop. 1989; 3: 48–56. [78] Zhmur SI, Gorlenko VM. Nature of Cambrian Kuonamka oil shales of Siberian Platform. Litol. Polezn. Iskop. 1990; 3: 122–6. [79] Zhmur SI, Gorlenko V, Rozanov AYu, Zhegallo EA, Labzova RV. Cyanobacterial benthic systemproducer of carbon substance of shungites of Early Proterozoic of Karelia. Litol. Polezn. Iskop. 1993; 6: 65–79. [80] Zhmur S. Origin of oil shales of Baltic syneclise: information—dyctionemic shales. Litol. Pol. Iskop. 1988; 6: 78–86. [81] Gerasimenko LM, Goncharova IV, Zhegallo EA, Zavarzin GA, Zaitseva LV, Orleansky VK, Rozanov AYu, Ushatinskaya GT. Filamentous cyanobacteriae: the process of their mineralization (phosphatization). Litol. Pol. Iskop. 1996; 2: p. 208–14. [82] Gerasimenko LM, Zavarzin GA, Rozanov AYu, Ushatinskaya GT. Cyanobacterial mats and mineralization of cyanobacteria. In: Hoover RB, editor. Instruments, methods, & missions for astrobiology. SPIE 1998; 3441: 254–63.
64
R.B. Hoover / Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites
[83] Zhegallo EA, Rozanov AYu, Ushatinskaya GT, Hoover RB, Gerasimenko LM, Ragozina AL. Atlas of microorganisms from ancient phosphorites of Khubsughul (Mongolia). NASA/TP—2000–209901. Marshall Space Flight Center: MSFC, AL; 2000. 1–167 p. [84] McKay DS, Rozanov AYu, Hoover RB, Westall F. Phosphate biomineralization of Cambrian microorganisms. Proc. SPIE 1998; 3441: 170–6. [85] Rozanov AYu, Zhegallo EA, Hoover RB. Microbiota of the Botogol Graphites. In: Hoover RB, editor. Instruments, methods, & missions for astrobiology II. Proc. SPIE 1999; 3775: 38–48. [86] Schopf JW, editor. Earthís earliest biosphere: its origin and evolution. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 1983. 1–543 p. [87] Grotzinger JP, Knoll AH. Stromatolites in Precambrian carbonates: evolutionary mileposts or environmental dipsticks? Ann. Rev. Earth and Planet. Sci. 1999; 27: 313–58. [88] Mojzsis, SJ, Harrison TM. Vestiges of a beginning: clues to the emergent biosphere recorded in the oldest known sedimentary rocks. GSA Today 2000; 10: 1–2. [89] Rasmussen B. Filamentous microfossils in a 3,225 million-year-old volcanogenic massive sulfide deposit. Nature 2000; 405: 676–9. [90] Rasmussen B, Buick R. Oily old ores: evidence for hydrothermal petroleum generation in an Archean volcanogenic massive sulfide deposit. Geology 2000; 28: 731–4. [91] Marsic D, Hoover RB, Gilichinsky DA, Ng JD. Gene cloning of the 19s rRNA of an ancient viable moss from the permafrost of northeastern Siberia. In: Hoover RB, editor. Instruments, methods, & missions for astrobiology II, Proc. SPIE 1999; 3775: 163–75. [92] Abyzov SS, Mitskevitch IN, Paglazova MN, Hoover RB, Ivanov MV. Microorganisms and unicellular algae in the Ice Sheet of Antarctica. In: Hoover RB, editor. Instruments, methods, & missions for astrobiology II, Proc. SPIE 1999; 3775: 176–87. [93] Hoover RB, Abyzov SS, Ivanov MV. Environmental scanning electron microscopy investigations of ancient microorganisms from deep ice above Lake Vostok. In: Hoover RB, editor. Instruments, methods, & missions for astrobiology II, Proc. SPIE 1999; 3775: 187–98. [94] Zhmur SI, Rozanov AYu, Gorlenko VM. Lithified remnants of microorganisms in carbonaceous chondrites. Geochem. Int. 1997; 35: 58–60. [95] Hoover RB. Meteorites, microfossils, and exobiology. In: Hoover RB, editor. Instruments, methods, & missions for the investigation of extraterrestrial microorganisms. Proc. SPIE 1997; 3111: 115–36. [96] Hoover RB, Rozanov AYu, Zhmur SI, Gorlenko VM. Further evidence of microfossils in carbonaceous chondrites. In: Hoover RB, editor. Instruments, methods, & missions for astrobiology. Proc. SPIE 1998; 3441: 203–16. [97] Gerasimenko LM, Hoover RB, Rozanov AYu, Zhegallo EA, Zhmur SI. Bacterial paleontology and studies of carbonaceous chondrites. Paleontological J. 1999; 33: 439–59. [98] Hoover RB, Rozanov AYu. Biomorphic microstructures in Mighei carbonaceous meteorite. In: Hoover RB, editor. Instruments, methods, & missions for astrobiology II, Proc. SPIE 1999; 3775: 120–30. [99] Blakemore R. Magnetotactic Bacteria. Sci. 1975; 190: 377–9. [100] Schleiffer K-H, Schuler D, Spring S, Weizenegger M, Amann R, Ludwig W, Kohler M. The genus Magnetospirillum gen. nov., description of Magnetospirillum gryphiswaldense sp. nov. and transfer of Aquaspirillum magnetotacticum to Magnetospirillum magnetotacticum. Syst. appl. Microbiol. 1991; 14: 379–85. [101] Fassbinder JWE, Stanjek H, Vali H. Occurrence of magnetic bacteria in soil. Nature 1990; 343: 161–3. [102] Maher B, Thompson R. Paleoclimatic significance of the mineral magnetic record of the Chinese loess and paleosols, Quater. Res. 1992; 37: 155–70. [103] Heywood BR, Bazylinski DA, Garratt-Reed A, Mann S, Frankel RB. Controlled biosynthesis of greigite (Fe3S4) in magnetotactic bacteria, Naturwissenschaften 1990; 77: 536–8. [104] Heywood BR, Mann S, Frankel RB. Structure, morphology and growth of biogenic greigite (Fe 3S4). In: Alpert M, Calvert P, Frankel RB, Rieke P, Tirrell D, editors. Materials synthesis based on biological processes. Pittsburgh: Materials Research Society; 1991. 93–108 p. [105] Bazylinski DA, Frankel RB, Heywood BR, Mann S, King JW, Donaghay PL, Hanson AK. Controlled biomineralization of magnetite (Fe3O4) and greigite (Fe3S4) in a magnetotactic bacterium. App. and Environ. Microbiol. 1995; 61: 3232–9. [106] Bazylinski DA, Heywood B, Mann S, Frankel RB. Fe3O4 and Fe3S4 in a bacterium. Nature 1993; 366: 218. [107] Bazylinski DA. Anaerobic production of single-domain magnetite by the marine, magnetotactic bacterium, strain MV–1. In: Frankel RB, Blakemore RP, editors. Iron biominerals, New York: Plenum; 1990. 69–77 p. [108] Bazylinski DA, Garratt-Reed AJ, Frankel RB. Electron microscopic studies of magnetosomes in magnetotactic bacteria, Microscopy Res. Techn. 1994; 27: 389–401.
R.B. Hoover / Microfossils, Biominerals, and Chemical Biomarkers in Meteorites
65
[109] Bazylinski DA, Frankel RB. Biologically controlled mineralization of magnetic iron minerals by magnetotactic bacteria. In: Lovley DR, editor. Environmental microbe-metal interactions. Washington DC: ASM Press; 2000. 109–43p. [110] Thomas-Keptra KL, Bazylinski DA, Kirschvink JL, Clemett SJ, McKay DS, Wentworth SJ, Vali H, Gibson EK Jr, Romanek CS. Elongated prismatic magnetite crystals in ALH84001 carbonate globules: potential Martian magnetofossils. Geochimica Cosmochimica Acta 2000; 64(23): 4049–81. [111] Tan WC, VanLandingham SL. Electron microscopy of biological-like structures in the Orgueil carbonaceous meteorite. Geophys. J. Roy. Astr. Soc. 1967; 12: 237, Fig. 3. [112] Vainshtein M, Suzina N, Sorokin V. A new type of magnet-sensitive inclusions in cells of photosynthetic purple-bacteria. System. Appl. Microbiol. 1997; 20: 182–6. [113] Vainshtein M, Kudryashova E, Suzina N, Ariskina E, Sorokin V. On functions of non-crystal magnetosomes in bacteria. In: Hoover RB, editor. Instruments, methods, & missions for astrobiology. Proc. SPIE 1998; 3441: 280–8. [114] Pollack JB, Veverka J, Pang K, Colburn D, Lane AL, Ajello JM. Multicolor observations of Phobos with Viking Lander cameras: evidence for a carbonaceous chondritic composition. Science 1978; 199: 66–9. [115] Matson DL, Veeder GL, Lebofsky LA. Infrared observations of asteroids from Earth and space. In: Morrison D, Wells WC, editors. Asteroids: an exploration assessment. NASA/CP—2053. Scientific and Technical Information Branch: Washington DC; 1978. 20–7 p. [116] Bunch TE, Chang S. Carbonaceous chondrites-II. Carbonaceous chondrite phyllosilicates and light element geochemistry as indicators of parent body processes and surface conditions. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 1980; 44: 1543–77. [117] Halliday IA, McIntosh BA. Orbit of the Murchison meteorite. Meteoritics 1990; 25: 339–40. [118] Seargent DAJ. The Murchison meteorite: circumstances of its fall. Meteoritics 1990; 25: 341–2. [119] Caffee MW, Goswami JN, Hohenberg CM, Swindle TD. Cosmogenic neon from precompaction irradiation of Kapoeta and Murchison. Geophys. Res. 1983; 88: B267–73. [120] Mautner MN, Leonard RL, Deamer DW. Meteorite organics in planetary environments: hydrothermal release, surface activity, and microbial utilization. Planet. Space Sci. 1995; 43: 139–47. [121] Palik P. Further life-forms in the Orgueil meteorite. Nature 1962; 194: 1065. [122] Nagy B, Frederickson K, Urey HC, Kudynowski J, Claus G, Andersen CA, Percy J. Electron probe microanalysis of organized elements in the Orgueil meteorite. Nature 1963; 198: 121–25. [123] Claus G, Nagy B. Considerations of extraterrestrial taxa. Taxon 1962; 11: 160–1. [124] VanLandingham SL. The naming of extraterrestrial taxa. Taxon 1963; 12: 282. [125] Briggs MH, Kitto GB. Complex organic microstructures in the Mokoia meteorite. Nature 1962; 193: 1126–7. [126] Staplin FL. Microfossils from the Orgueil meteorite. Micropaleontol. 1962; 8: 343–7. [127] Ross R. Panel discussion: the identity of ‘organized elements.’ Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 1963; 108: 608–9. [128] VanLandingham SL. Evidence for microfossils in Alais, Orgueil carbonaceous meteorite. Nature 1965; 208: 947. [129] VanLandingham SL, Sun CN, Tan WC. Origin of round body structures in the Orgueil meteorite. Nature 1967; 216: 252–3. [130] Urey HC. Biological material in meteorites: a review. Science 1966; 151: 157–66. [131] Timofejev BW. Lebensspuren in meteoriten: resultate einer microphytologischen analyse. Grana. Palynol. 1963; 4: 92–9.
66
Perspectives in Astrobiology R.B. Hoover et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
Survival of Microorganisms in Space, an Experimental Contribution to the Discussion on Viable Transfer of Life in the Solar System Gerda HORNECK German Aerospace Center DLR, Institute of Aerospace Medicine, 51170 Cologne, Germany Abstract. The concept of interplanetary transfer of life requires that organisms cope with three major challenges: (1) The escape process, (2) the long-term stay in space, and (3) the landing process. The first step involves hypervelocity impact by comets or asteroids under strong or moderate shock metamorphism of the ejected microbebearing rock fragment. Experiments have shown that bacterial spores can survive such a simulated meteorite impact. The second step deals with the ability of microorganisms to withstand the complex interplay of the parameters of space, e.g.: vacuum, ultraviolet and ionizing radiation, and temperature extremes, when traveling in space over extended periods of time. Experiments in space, such as on board of Apollo, Spacelab 1 (SL 1), the Long Duration Exposure Facility (LDEF), FOTON, MIR, and the European Retrievable Carrier (EURECA), as well as at space simulation facilities on ground, have given the following five results: (1) Extraterrestrial solar UV radiation is a thousand times more efficient than UV at the surface of the Earth and kills 99% of bacterial spores within a few seconds; (2) space vacuum increases the UV sensitivity of the spores; (3) although spores survive extended periods of time in space vacuum (up to 6 yr) genetic changes occur, such as increased mutation rates; (4) after 6 yr in space, up to 70% of bacterial spores survived if protected against solar UV radiation and dehydration; (5) spores could escape a hit of a cosmic HZE particle, e.g.: iron ion, for up to 1 Ma. Calculations using radiative transfer models for cosmic rays and biological data from accelerator experiments have shown that a meteorite layer of 1 m or more effectively protects bacterial spores against galactic cosmic radiation for 1 Ma or more. It is concluded that radiation-resistant microbes could survive a journey from one planet to another in our solar system if they are located inside a meteorite thus shielded against cosmic radiation. However, viable transport between solar systems seems to be not possible, assuming impact ejection as the first step. The last step, capture and landing on a planet depends very much on the atmospheric conditions and the size of the meteorite. So far, few experiments have been done to investigate the effects of the landing process.
Introduction A century ago, S. Arrhenius formulated the theory of Panspermia, which postulates that microscopic forms of life, e.g.: spores, can be propagated in space and driven by the radiation pressure of the sun as a mechanism of transport for the germs of life from one planet to another [1]. Recent discoveries, such as the Martian meteorites, the high UV resistance of mi-
G. Horneck / Survival of Microorganisms in Space
67
Figure 1. Steps of a hypothetical scenario of interplanetary transfer of life using meteorites as transport vehicle [3].
croorganisms at the low temperature of deep space, and the recovery of viable spores after extended periods of time in space [2], have given support to revisit the theory of Panspermia. During a hypothetical interplanetary transfer process, the organisms have to cope with the following three major challenges: (1) The escape process, i.e.: removal to space of biological material that has survived being lifted from the surface to high altitudes; (2) the interim state in space, i.e.: survival of the biological material over time scales comparable with the interplanetary or interstellar passage; and (3) the entry process, i.e.: the nondestructive deposition of the biological material on another planet (Fig. 1). In the following, results from experimentation in space will be presented to test the feasibility of step two, i.e.: the impact of the space environment on the seeding of life throughout the solar system.
1. Bacterial Endospores as Test Organisms Many microorganisms found in terrestrial soils are capable of forming spores to cope with unfavorable environmental conditions; particularly, bacterial endospores withstand extremely hostile conditions in the dormant state. They exhibit a high degree of resistance to inactivation by various physical and chemical stresses, such as desiccation, extreme temperatures, UV and ionizing radiation, and various aggressive chemical insults including alcohol, acid and basic solutions, and oxidizing agents. Hence, bacterial endospores have been recognized as the hardiest known forms of life on Earth [4]. The high resistance of Bacillus (B.) endospores is mainly due to two factors: (1) A dehydrated, highly mineralized core enclosed in a thick protective envelop, the cortex, and the spore coat layers (Fig. 2), and (2) the saturation of their DNA with small, acid-soluble proteins whose binding greatly alters the chemical and enzymatic reactivity of the DNA [5]. In the presence of appropriate nutrients, spores respond rapidly by germination and outgrowth, resuming vegetative growth and cell replication. Hence, spore formation represents a strategy by which a bacterium escapes temporally and/or spatially from unfavorable conditions; bacterial endospores exhibit incredible longevity—survival times of 25 to 250 Ma have been reported [6,7]. Because of their microscopic size, they can be easily relocated, e.g.: by wind and water, over long distances to remote areas.
68
G. Horneck / Survival of Microorganisms in Space
Figure 2. Electronmicrograph of a spore of B. subtilis with the inner core containing the DNA surrounded by protective layers, the long axis of the spore is 1.2 μm, the core area 0.25 μm2 (courtesy of S. Pankratz).
Their exceptionally high resistance against environmental extremes over long periods of time makes bacterial endospores suitable candidates for studying the likelihood of transport of life between the planets of our solar system. During such a hypothetical interplanetary transfer, the spores would be exposed to a complex interplay of environmental stresses, such as shock waves and high temperatures during the ejection process [8], extreme vacuum, intense radiation from the sun and of galactic origin, and varying temperatures depending on the orientation to the sun during the interim stay in outer space [9], and finally, accelerations and high temperatures during the entry into a planetary atmosphere and landing on the planet’s surface. The responses of B. subtilis spores to these different parameters of a hypothetical trip between the planets have been studied in ground-based spacesimulation facilities and in several space experiments. The results are summarized in Sections 2–4.
2. Escape From a Planet Hypervelocity impacts of large objects, such as meteorites, asteroids, or comets, are considered to be the most plausible process capable of ejecting microbe-bearing surface material from a planet or moon into space. The peak shock pressure received by the Martian meteorites, so far detected on Earth, range from about 20 GPa to about 45 GPa with estimated post-shock temperatures between about 100 ˚C at 20 GPa and about 600 ˚C at 45 GPa. Although these impacts are very energetic, a certain fraction of ejecta is not heated above 100 ˚C. These low-temperature fragments are ejected from the so-called spall zone, i.e.: the surface layer of the target, where the resulting shock is considerably reduced by superimposition of the reflected shock wave on the direct one [10,11]. It has been calculated that within the last 4 Ga more than 109 fragments with a diameter of ≥2 m and temperatures ≤100 ˚C were ejected from Mars, of which about 5% arrived on Earth after a journey in space of ≤8 Ma. The corresponding numbers for a transfer from Earth to Mars are about 108 fragments ejected from the Earth with about 0.1% arriving on Mars within 8 Ma [9]. During the preceding period of heavy bombardment, even 10 times that amount is estimated. Hence, the Martian meteorites, so far detected on Earth, probably represent only a diminishing fraction of those imported from Mars within Earth’s history.
G. Horneck / Survival of Microorganisms in Space
69
Table 1. Parameters of outer space [13].
In experiments, simulating impacts comparable to those experienced by the Martian meteorites, the survival of microbes was tested after subjecting spores of B. subtilis to accelerations, jerks, or shock waves [12]. In shock recovery experiments with an explosive set-up, the survival of spores of B. subtilis was studied using a shock treatment in the pressure range that some Martian meteorites have experienced [8]. It was found that a substantial fraction of spores (up to 10–4) were able to survive a peak shock pressure of 32±1 GPa and a post-shock temperature of about 250 ˚C. These data support the hypothesis that bacterial spores may survive an impact-induced escape process in a scenario of interplanetary transfer of life. Assuming a mean spore density of 108 spores/g in, for example, desert soil or rock, a 1-kg rock would accommodate ~1011 spores, of which up to 107 could survive even extremely high shock pressures that occur during a meteorite impact. At more moderate shock waves as they would occur in the spall zone of an impact, even substantially higher survival rates are expected.
3. Responses of Microorganisms to the Environment of Outer Space 3.1. Parameters of Outer Space That Are a Potential Threat to Microbial Life The environment that microorganisms have to cope with in outer space is characterized by a high vacuum, an intense radiation climate of galactic and solar origin, and extreme temperatures (Table 1). In free interplanetary space, pressures down to 10–14 Pa prevail. Within the vicinity of a body, the pressure may significantly increase due to outgassing. In a low Earth orbit of an altitude below 500 km, pressure reaches 10–7–10–4 Pa. The major constituents of this environment are molecular oxygen and nitrogen as well as highly reactive oxygen and nitrogen atoms. In the vicinity of a spacecraft, the pressure further increases, depending on the de-
70
G. Horneck / Survival of Microorganisms in Space
gree of outgassing of the spacecraft itself. In the Shuttle cargo bay, a pressure of 3×10–5 Pa was measured. The planets in this solar system are continuously bombarded by charged particles coming from unknown sources outside our solar system and from the sun. The galactic cosmic rays are composed of energetic particles, which cover a broad spectrum of energy and mass values; ~98% are atomic nuclei and 2% are electrons and positrons. The nuclear component consists of ~87% protons, about 12% α particles, and ~1% nuclei of Z>2, the so-called HZE particles. These nuclei are stripped of all their orbital electrons and have traveled for several million years through the galaxy before entering the solar system. When these charged particles enter the solar system, they interact with the outbound streaming of the solar wind and the interplanetary magnetic field, which vary with the solar activity. In interplanetary space, the annual radiation dose amounts to ≤0.1 Gy/a, depending on mass shielding with the highest dose at 0.15 g/cm2 shielding due to built up radiation [14]. The spectrum of solar electromagnetic radiation spans over several orders of magnitude, from short-wavelength x-rays to radio frequencies. At the distance of 1 AU (Sun to Earth), solar irradiance amounts to 1,360 W m–2, which is the solar constant. Of this radiation, 45% is attributed to the infrared fraction, 48% to the visible fraction, and only 7% to the ultraviolet fraction. The extraterrestrial solar spectral UV irradiance has been measured during several space missions, such as SL 1 and EURECA [15]. The temperature of a body in space depends on its position regarding the Sun, and also on its surface, size, and mass. It is determined by the absorption and emission of energy. In Earth orbit, the energy sources are the solar radiation (1,360 W m–2), the Earth albedo (480 W m–2), and terrestrial radiation (230 W m–2). In Earth orbit, the temperature of a body can reach extreme values. In different space exposure experiments, the samples were subjected to temperatures in the range of 243–318 K [3,16]. The time it would take for boulder-sized rocks to travel from one planet of our solar system to another, e.g.: from Mars to Earth, by random motion has been calculated to range between several hundred thousand to millions of years [17]; however, smaller, e.g.: microscopic, particles that are more frequent might only need a few years. For an interstellar transport, such as from one solar system to another, even longer time periods, up to 10 Ma may be required [3]. 3.2. Effects of Space Vacuum Vacuum leads to extreme desiccation of the cells exposed to it. This desiccation may cause dramatic changes in such important biomolecules as lipids, carbohydrates, proteins, and nucleic acids. On desiccation, the lipid membranes of cells undergo dramatic phase changes from planar bilayers to cylindrical bilayers [18]. The carbohydrates, proteins, and nucleic acids undergo so-called Maillard reactions, i.e.: amino-carbonyl reactions, to give products that become cross linked, thus, eventually leading to irreversible polymerization of the biomolecules [18]. Concomitant with these structural changes are functional changes, including altered selective membrane permeability, inhibited or altered enzyme activity, decreased energy production, alteration of genetic information, etc. Damage to the DNA, like increased mutation rates and DNA strand breaks were observed in bacterial spores recovered from vacuum exposure [19–21]. Vacuum-induced mutants showed a unique molecular signature of tandem-double base changes at restricted sites in the DNA [22]. This extremely dehydrating effect of space vacuum has been considered to be one of the factors that may prevent interplanetary transfer of life [23]. However, space experiments have shown that up to 70% of bacterial and fungal spores survived short-term, e.g.: 10 days, exposure to space vacuum, even without any protection [24]. The chances of survival
G. Horneck / Survival of Microorganisms in Space
71
Table 2. Survival rate of spores of B. subtilis after exposure to space vacuum (10–6–10–4 Pa) on board of SL 1, EURECA, and LDEF [24–26].
in space were increased if the spores were embedded in chemical protectants, such as sugars or salt crystals, or if they were exposed in thick layers. For example, 30% of B. subtilis spores survived a nearly 6-yr exposure to space vacuum if embedded in salt crystals, whereas nearly 70% survived in the presence of glucose (Table 2) [25]. It has been suggested that sugar or polyalcohol stabilizes the structure of the cellular macromolecules, especially during vacuum-induced dehydration, leading to increased rates of survival. In all experiments, ground controls were simultaneously subjected to vacuum at the space simulation facilities of the DLR. Survival rates of the ground controls were in most cases slightly higher than those of the space samples; however, this difference was not significant. Nevertheless, the damage to the DNA, observed in B. subtilis spores after exposure to space vacuum—as well as to vacuum in the laboratory—would accumulate during long-term interplanetary transfer, because DNA repair is not active in the dormant spore state. Survival would ultimately depend on the efficiency of the repair systems after rehydration and subsequent germination and growth. 3.3. Effects of Solar UV Radiation UV radiation is very potent in starting up various kinds of photochemical reactions in cellular systems, such as alteration/damage of proteins and DNA, which will interfere with proper cell function. The biological effectiveness of the different wavelengths of the solar spectrum is described by the action spectrum [27]. Particularly, UV–C (190–280 nm) and the short-waveband edge of UV–B (280–315 nm) radiation that do not reach the surface of Earth due to effective shielding by the stratospheric ozone layer are of high biological effectiveness (Fig. 3). Compared to the terrestrial UV radiation climate, the extraterrestrial UV spectrum was about 1,000 fold more effective in killing spores of B. subtilis [28,29]. This high biological effectiveness of extraterrestrial UV radiation is mainly caused by damage to the spore DNA induced by the UV–C part of the spectrum (Fig. 3). If the spores were simultaneously exposed to solar UV-radiation and space vacuum, they responded with an increased UV sensitivity (Fig. 3) [19,24]. This increased efficiency is caused by altered photoproducts generated within the desiccated DNA of B. subtilis spores when exposed to UV radiation in space vacuum [19,30]. It was concluded that these vacuum-specific photoproducts, which are less amenable to the DNA-repair processes, were responsible for the UV super-sensitivity of spores if irradiated under vacuum conditions [24]. However, it has recently been shown that spores within an artificial meteorite of about 1 cm in diameter were effectively shielded against the harmful impact of extraterrestrial solar UV radiation [31].
72
G. Horneck / Survival of Microorganisms in Space
Figure 3. Action spectrum of inactivation of spores B. subtilis by extraterrestrial solar UV radiation; results from space missions SL 1 and D2 and EURECA [26].
Figure 4. Biostack concept [35] to determine the biological effects of single HZE particles of galactic cosmic radiation.
3.4. Effects Galactic Cosmic Radiation The so-called HZE particles are the most biologically effective species of galactic cosmic radiation because of their extremely dense pattern of energy deposition [32,33]. Lesions in the biologically sensitive structures are produced with higher efficiency and prove less amenable to repair than those generated by sparsely ionizing types of radiation, such as x rays. Since the HZE particles in interplanetary space are present at very low abundance, e.g.: about 1/cm–2 day–1 at a LET>225 keV/μm [34], special methods must be developed for tracing their path within the biological system. The Biostack concept [35] consists of a sandwich-like structure where layers of biological objects, e.g.: bacterial spores, plant seeds, and insect eggs, are placed between nuclear track detectors (Fig. 4). This device al-
G. Horneck / Survival of Microorganisms in Space
73
lows the determination of the relative position of the HZE particle trajectory within the biological layer after processing (etching) the track detectors. The micron-sized spores of B. subtilis were the smallest biological specimens studied. It was found that the spores were inactivated well beyond a distance of 1 μm from the HZE particle track; however, even those centrally hit by an HZE particle had a 30% chance of survival [36]. Considering the low flux of HZE particles and the small size of bacterial spores, it may take up to 1 Ma before a spore is hit and damaged by an HZE particle when travelling through interplanetary space. 3.5. Assessment of Long-Term Survival in Outer Space Maximum exposure times in space, reached so far experimentally, were provided by the nearly 6-yr LDEF mission [25]. If arranged in thick layers, in the presence of sugars as chemical protectors, and shielded against solar UV radiation by 2 mm of aluminum, up to 70% of bacterial spores survived the 6-yr space journey (Table 2). However, the vast majority of rocks would need more than 10,000 yr, or even millions of years, to travel, for example, from Mars to Earth [37]. To assess the chances of microbial survival in outer space for such long lasting trips, two separate theoretical studies were recently performed [9,38]. Based on experimental data from laboratory experiments on radiation effects and DNA stability, they concurringly concluded that for such long travel times, boulder sized rocks ≥1 m in diameter are required to effectively shield resistant microorganisms, such as bacterial spores, against the impact of galactic cosmic radiation. However, one has to bear in mind that a very low fraction of Mars ejecta, in the order of 10–7, may reach Earth much faster, e.g.: in ≤1 yr after ejection [37]. For these fast transfers, the LDEF data are representative.
4. Landing on a Planet When captured by a planet with an atmosphere, most meteorites are subjected to very high temperatures during landing. However, because the fall through the atmosphere only takes a few seconds, the outermost layers form a kind of heat shield and the heat does not reach the inner parts of the meteorite. During entry, the fate of the meteorite strongly depends on its size. Large meteorites may brake into pieces, but the pieces may still be large enough to remain cool inside until hitting the surface of the planet. Medium sized meteorites may obtain a melted crust, but the inner part remains cool. Micrometeorites of a few microns in size may tumble through the atmosphere without being heated above 100 ˚C. Therefore, it is quite possible that a substantial number of microbes can survive the landing process on a planet. However, no experiments have been done so far to investigate the biological effects of the landing process. Recently, the European Space Agency has developed a facility, called STONE, which is attached to the heat shield of a FOTON satellite to test mineral degradations during landing. This facility might be an ideal tool to study the effects of landing of bacterial spores embedded in an artificial meteorite.
References [1] Arrhenius S. Die Verbreitung des Lebens im Weltenraum. Die Umschau 1903; 7: 481–5. [2] Horneck G. Could life travel across interplanetary space? Panspermia revisited. In: Rothschild LJ, Lister A, editors. Evolution on planet Earth: the impact of the physical environment. San Diego: Academic Press; 2003. in press.
74
G. Horneck / Survival of Microorganisms in Space
[3] Horneck G, Mileikowsky C, Melosh JH, Wilson JW, Cucinotta F, Gladman B. Viable transfer of microorganisms in the solar system and beyond. In: Horneck G, Baumstark-Khan , editors. Astrobiology, the quest for the conditions of life. Berlin-Heidelberg-New York: Springer-Verlag; 2002. p. 57–74. [4] Nicholson WL, Munakata N, Horneck G, Melosh HJ, Setlow P. Resistance of Bacillus endospores to extreme terrestrial and extraterrestrial environments. Microb. Mol. Biol. Rev. 2000; 64: 548–72. [5] Setlow P. Mechanisms for the prevention of damage to DNA in spores of Bacillus species. Ann. Rev. Microbiol. 1995; 49: 29–54. [6] Cano RJ, Borucki MK. Revival and identification of bacterial spores in 25 to 40 million-year-old Dominican amber. Science 1995; 268: 1060–4. [7] Vreeland RH, Rosenzweig WD, Powers DW. Isolation of a 250 million-year-old halotoleratn bactereium from a primary salt crystal. Nature 2000; 407: 897–900. [8] Horneck G, Stöffler D, Eschweiler U, Hornemann U. Bacterial spores survive simulated meteorite impact. Icarus 2001; 149: 285–90. [9] Mileikowsky C, Cucinotta F, Wilson JW, Gladman B, Horneck G, Lindegren L, Melosh J, Rickman H, Valtonen M, Zheng JQ. Natural transfer of viable microbes in space, part 1: from Mars to Earth and Earth to Mars. Icarus 2000; 145: 391–427. [10] Melosh HJ. Impact ejection, spallation and the origin of meteorites. Icarus 1984; 59: 234–60. [11] Melosh HJ. Ejection of rock fragments from planetary bodies. Geology 1985; 13: 144–8. [12] Mastrapa RMF, Glanzberg H, Head JN, Melosh HJ, Nicholson WL. Survival of Bacillus subtilis spores and Deinococcus radiodurans cells exposed to the extreme acceleration and shock predicted during planetary ejection. [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the 31st Lunar and Planetary Science Meeting; 2000; Houston. [13] Horneck G. Astrobiology studies of microbes in simulated interplanetary space. In: Ehrenfreund P, Krafft C, Kochan H, Pirronello V, editors. Laboratory astrophysics and space research. Dordrecht: Kluwer; 1999. p. 667–85. [14] Reitz G, Beaujean R, Heilmann C, Kopp J, Leicher M, Strauch K. Results of dosimetric measurements in space missions. Adv. Space Res. 1998; 22 (4): 495–500. [15] Labs D, Neckel H, Simon PC, Thuillier G. Ultraviolet solar irradiance measurement from 200 to 358 nm during Spacelab 1 mission. Solar Physics 1987; 107: 203. [16] Horneck G. Exobiological experiments in Earth orbit. Adv. Space Res. 1998; 22: (3)317–26. [17] Melosh HJ. The rocky road to Panspermia. Nature 1988; 332: 687–8. [18] Cox CS. Roles of water molecules in bacteria and viruses. Origins Life Evol. Biosphere 1993; 23: 29–36. [19] Horneck G, Bücker H, Reitz G, Requardt H, Dose K, Martens KD, Mennigmann HD, Weber P. Microorganisms in the space environment. Science 1984; 225: 226–8. [20] Dose K, Bieger-Dose A, Labusch M, Gill M. Survival in extreme dryness and DNA-single-strand breaks. Adv. Space Res. 1992; 12: (4)221–9. [21] Dose K, Bieger-Dose A, Dillmann R, Gill M, Kerz O, Klein A, Meinert H, Nawroth , Risi S, Stridde C. ERA-Experiment “Space Biochemistry”. Adv. Space Res. 1995; 16: (8)119–29. [22] Munakata N, Saito M, Takahashi N, Hieda K, Morihoshi F. Induction of unique tandem-base change mutations in bacterial spores exposed to extreme dryness. Mutat. Res. 1997; 390: 189–95. [23] Nussinov MD, Lysenko SV. Cosmic vacuum prevents Radiopanspermia. Origins Life Evol. Biosphere 1983; 13: 153–64. [24] Horneck G. Responses of Bacillus subtilis spores to space environment: results from experiments in space. Origins Life Evol. Biosphere 1993; 23: 37–52. [25] Horneck G, Bücker H, Reitz G. Long-term survival of bacterial spores in space. Adv. Space Res. 1994; 14: (10)41–5. [26] Horneck G, Eschweiler U, Reitz G, Wehner J, Willimek R, Strauch K. Biological responses to space: results of the experiment “Exobiological Unit” of ERA on EURECA I. Adv. Space Res. 1995; 16: (8) 105–11. [27] Jagger J. Introduction to Research in Ultraviolet Photobiology. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice Hall; 1967. p. 53. [28] Horneck G, Rettberg P, Rabbow E, Strauch W, Seckmeyer G, Facius R, Reitz G, Strauch K Schott JU. Biological dosimetry of solar radiation for different simulated ozone column thickness. J. Photochem. Photobiol. B: Biol. 1996; 32: 189–96. [29] Cockell CS , Horneck, G. The history of the UV radiation climate of the Earth—theoretical and spacebased observations. Photochem. Photobiol. 2001; 73: 447–51. [30] Lindberg C, Horneck G. Action spectra for survival and spore photoproduct formation of Bacillus subtilis irradiated with short wavelength (200 - 300 nm) UV at atmospheric pressure and in vacuo. J. Photochem. Photobiol. B: Biol. 1991; 11: 69–80.
G. Horneck / Survival of Microorganisms in Space
75
[31] Horneck G, Rettberg P, Reitz G, Wehner J, Eschweiler U, Strauch K, Panitz C, Starke V, BaumstarkKhan C. Protection of bacterial spores in space, a contribution to the discussion on Panspermia. Origins Life Evol. Biosphere 2001; 31: 527–547. [32] Horneck, G. Radiobiological experiments in space: a review. Nucl. Tracks Radiat. Meas. 1992; 20: 185– 205. [33] Kiefer J, Kost M, Schenk-Meuser K. Radiation biology. In: Moore D, Bie P, Oser H, editors. Biological and medical research in space. Berlin: Springer; 1996. p. 300–67. [34] Benton EV, Parnell TA. Space radiation dosimetry on U.S. and Soviet manned missions. In: McCormack PD, Swenberg CE, Bücker H, editors. Terrestrial space radiation and its biological effects. New York and London: Plenum Press; 1988. p. 729–94. [35] Bücker H, Horneck G. Studies on the effects of cosmic HZE-particles in different biological systems in the Biostack experiments I and II, flown on board of Apollo 16 and 17. In: Nygaard OF, Adler HI, Sinclair WK, editors. Radiation research. New York: Academic Press; 1975. p. 1138–51. [36] Horneck G. 1993. The Biostack concept and its application in space and at accelerators: studies on Bacillus subtilis spores. In: CE Swenberg, G Horneck, EG Stassinopoulos, editors. Biological effects and physics of solar and galactic cosmic radiation, Part A. New York: Plenum Press; 1993. p. 99–115. [37] Gladman BJ, Burns JA, Duncan M, Lee P, Levison HF. The exchange of impact ejecta between terrestrial planets. Science 1996; 271: 1287–392. [38] Clark BC. Planetary interchange of bioactive material: probability factors and implications. Origins Life Evol. Biosphere 2001; 31: 185–97.
76
Perspectives in Astrobiology R.B. Hoover et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
Reactions of Urazole and its Analogs with Sugars and Metals under Prebiotic Conditions Vera M. KOLB, Patricia A. COLLOTON and Kevin J. RAPP Department of Chemistry, University of Wisconsin-Parkside Kenosha, Wisconsin 53141-2000, USA Abstract. This work reports the selectivity of urazole, a prebiotic mimic of uracil, in its reactions with sugars. This selectivity is important in prebiotic synthesis of nucleosides. Urazole makes metal complexes. Thus, it may exist on meteorites as such. Some physical properties of urazole-metal complexes that are relevant for their recovery from the meteorites have been investigated.
Early and more recent [1–7] work has shown that urazole, a prebiotic analog of uracil with a comparable hydrogen- (H-) bonding ability to adenine (Fig. 1), readily makes nucleosides with ribose and deoxyribose under prebiotic conditions, in the aqueous medium. Urazole reacts with ribose and deoxyribose in a regioselective manner. A single substitution on a hydrazidic nitrogen (N) occurs and reaction on the imide nitrogen is observed. A mixture of four nucleosides, α and β pyranosides (p), and α and β furanosides (f) is obtained. This reactivity pattern of urazole leaves its imide group, C=O-NH-C=O, free and available for H-bonding with adenine. Urazole distinguishes between ribose and deoxyribose in a significant way: with ribose it gives predominantly the β-p nucleoside, while with deoxyribose it provides the α-p nucleoside. In the reaction of 2-deoxyribose with urazole or its cyclic analogs, such as 4methylurazole and 4,4-dimethylpyrazolidine-3,5-dione, a crystalline precipitate, which is an exclusive enantiospecific product, 1R, 2R α-p, as determined by x-ray studies [2,3,5] (Fig. 2) is formed. Urazole with 2-deoxy-L-ribose gives a precipitate with the exclusive 1S,
Figure 1. (a) Urazole and (b) uracil.
V.M. Kolb et al. / Reactions of Urazole and its Analogs
77
Figure 2. Summary of work on the reactions of urazoles with sugars.
2 S α-p stereochemistry [6]. Therefore, the stereochemistry of deoxyribose influences that of the urazole's hydrazidic nitrogens in the nucleoside that is formed. With 2-deoxy-Dglucose the reaction with urazole is stereospecific, since only one isomer, β-p, forms in solution [7]. The summary of these reactions is given in Fig. 2. The α-effect in the reaction of urazole with sugars was also studied. This effect predicts an enhancement in the nucleophilic reactivity of the -NH-NH- unit in urazole due to the interaction of lone-electron pairs on the neighboring nitrogens. It was found that the cyclic analogs of urazole, such as 4-methylurazole and 4,4-dimethyl- pyrazolidine-3,5-dione, are reactive, but the open-chain analogs, such as 1,2-diacetylhydrazine and 1,2-dicarbethoxyhydrazine, are not. Therefore, these open-chain analogs will not compete with urazole for sugars in the prebiotic medium [4,7]. A representative experimental procedure for the synthesis and isolation of the urazole nucleosides can be found in the work by Robinson et al. [2]. The selectivity of the reactions of urazole with sugars is of great prebiotic importance. Instead of a combinatorial mixture of the nucleosides, specific nucleosides are preferred in the reaction mixtures, and only one may crystallize out. This is an unanticipated, but welcome result of the chemical evolution. Whether or not urazole nucleosides make complexes with metal salts at the natural pH at which they are formed, which is acidic (under the basic conditions sugars decompose) is of great intrest. Such complexation could stabilize the nucleosides or impart to them some catalytic properties. The first step was to study the complexation of urazole. Urazole, indeed, forms complexes with metals under the acidic conditions, including cobalt (Co), nickel (Ni), silver (Ag), and zinc (Zn) [8,9]. Others have shown analogous complexation of guanazole [10,11], and doubly deprotonated urazole under the basic conditions [12]. Since urazole and guanazole are important prebiotic molecules, whose prebiotic syntheses have been demonstrated [1], it is suspected that they may be present on meteorites. However, a question arises: Can these molecules be easily detected if they make complexes with various metals that may be present on meteorites? Such complexes need to be broken up during the extractions of organics from the meteorites in a manner that does not chemi-
78
V.M. Kolb et al. / Reactions of Urazole and its Analogs
cally change the parent ligands, urazole and guanazole. Otherwise, one would miss a possible presence of these compounds on meteorites. Reported here are the preparation, some physical properties, and solubility of these metal complexes, which are believed to be relevant for the problem of their recovery from meteorites. All starting compounds were from commercial sources (Sigma Aldrich and Fisher): Guanazole (3,5- diamino-1,2,4-triazole), urazole (1,2,4-triazolidine-3,5-dione), cobalt (II) nitrate (Co (NO3)2 • 6H2O), nickel (II) nitrate (Ni (NO3)2 • 6H2O), silver (I) nitrate (Ag NO3), and zinc (II) nitrate (Zn (NO3)2 • 6H2O). The complexes of guanazole were prepared by the published method [10,11]. The same method was adapted for the synthesis of urazole complexes, as shown below. The previously published procedure was not followed for the reactions of the doubly deprotonated urazole with the metal salts in which buffers were used to bring the pH up to ~8 [12]. In contrast, for this effort, the reaction was performed under natural pH, which is acidic, for both urazole and the metal salts that were used (pH was ~4). Urazole (0.354 g, 3.5 mmol) was dissolved in warm water (1.5 ml) and acetone (8.0 ml). The Co, Ni, or Zn nitrates (0.5 mmol) were each separately dissolved in acetone (2.0 ml) (for Ag nitrate a small volume of water was also added). The metal nitrate solution was added to the urazole solution and refluxed for 30 min. During this time, a precipitate formed, which was suction filtered, washed with acetone, and dried. (In the case of Ag nitrate, an immediate precipitate formed.) The IR spectra of the complexes were taken in the Nujol mull and also as KBr powder (reflectance method). What follows is a summary of our results for KBr powder. The IR spectra of the urazole complexes indicate that urazole interacts with metals via its carbonyls. Urazole’s carbonyl shows a strong band at 1,692 cm–1. In some complexes, this band shifts towards lower frequencies, e.g.: in Zn, 1,686 cm–1, strong; Co 1,681 cm–1, strong). In some other complexes, the band moves towards higher frequencies but is accompanied by a strong band at a lower frequency, perhaps indicating some type of vibrational coupling (Ag, 1,710 cm–1, strong, 1,634 cm–1, strong; Ni 1,714 cm–1 strong, 1,605 cm–1, strong). These IR frequencies are different than those reported for the complexes of doubly deprotonated urazole [12], as expected. The melting points of all the urazole complexes are quite high. Most of them did not reach the point of melting or decomposition at 300 ˚C, except for the silver complex that decomposed at 236–240 ˚C. The solubility’s of urazole complexes were measured qualitatively, by solubility criteria of a couple of milligrams of a complex in 2 mL of water, 5% HCl, or 5% NaOH. All complexes were insoluble in water, and they were only slightly soluble or insoluble in 5% HCl or 5% NaOH. In the latter, the Ag complex reacted to give a silver mirror. Guanazole is known to exist as a mixture of several tautomers (Fig. 3). The IR spectra of the guanazole metal complexes are substantially different from the spectra of guanazole but do not unambiguously point to the tautomer(s) that reacts. These spectra are in a general agreement with previously published spectra [10]. Solubility of guanazole complexes is similar to that of the urazole complexes. Other authors [10] have proposed that in the complexation of guanazole with metals the ring nitrogens act as donor atoms due to a charge distribution. To confirm this, higher level calculations have been performed (ab initio) on the various tautomers of guanazole (Fig. 3). The electrostatic potential surfaces and HOMO and LUMO pictures indicate that the sp2 hybridized ring nitrogens indeed have favorable electron-density distribution for complexation. In conclusion, these results indicate that urazole has a good ability to complex with various metals. It does so via its carbonyl form. Guanazole, which also forms complexes, reacts in one or several of its tautomeric forms. Guanazole probably reacts via its ring sp2
V.M. Kolb et al. / Reactions of Urazole and its Analogs
79
Figure 3. Guanazole tautomers.
nitrogens. Due to the complexing ability of these two molecules with metals, they may exist on meteorites as metal complexes, and special procedures may be needed to isolate these compounds from meteorites.
Acknowledgments The Wisconsin Space Grant Consortium/NASA, to whom gratitude is expressed, has sponsored this work. Thanks are expressed to Cal Y. Meyers and Paul D. Robinson for the x-ray studies and a continual interest in this work. Special thanks are due to Randall Stewart Perry for discussions of the astrobiological potential of our work with metal complexes.
References [1] Kolb VM, Dworkin JP, Miller SL. Alternative bases in the RNA world: the prebiotic synthesis of urazole and its ribosides. J. Mol. Evol. 1994; 38: 549–57. [2] Robinson PD, Meyers CY, Kolb VM, Colloton PA. First example of a crystalline urazole nucleoside. (1R, 2R)-Urazole-αα-D-pyranosyl-2-deoxyriboside. Acta Cryst. 1996; C52: 1215–8. [3] Kolb VM, Colloton PA, Robinson PD, Lutfi HG, Meyers CY. (1R, 2R)-4,4-Dimethylpyrazolidine-3,5dione-α-D-pyranosyl-2-deoxyriboside. Acta Cryst. 1996; C52: 1781–4. [4] Kolb VM, Colloton PA. On the mechanism of formation of urazole nucleosides: reaction of open-chain and cyclic analogs of urazole with D-Ribose and 2-Deoxy-D-ribose. In: Moore GT, Brandt SD, editors. Mission to planet Earth. Milwaukee: Wisconsin Space Grant Consortium;1997. Part II. [5] Meyers CY, Hou Y-Q, Kolb VM, Robinson PD. (1R,2R)-4-Methyl-α-D-pyranosyl-2-deoxyriboside from reaction of 4-Methylurazole with 2-Deoxy-D-ribose. Acta Cryst. 1997; C53: 1502–5. [6] Robinson PD, Kolb VM, Colloton PA, Meyers CY. First Example of a Crystalline Urazole Nucleoside with an L-Configured Sugar. (1S,2S)-Urazole-α-L-Pyranosyl-2-deoxyriboside. Acta Cryst. 1997; C53: CIF, QP00003, IUC9700004. [7] Kolb VM, Colloton PA. manuscript in preparation. [8] Kolb VM, Colloton PA, Rapp KJ. Abstract 5–5. Second Florida Heterocyclic Conference. Gainsville, Florida; 2001.
80
V.M. Kolb et al. / Reactions of Urazole and its Analogs
[9] Kolb VM, Colloton PA, Rapp KJ. Abstract 36. RNA Based Life Conference. Bloomington, Indiana; 2001. [10] Gabryszewski M, Wieczorek B. Syntheses and properties of the Co(II), Ni(II), Zn(II) and Cd(II) complexes with 3-amino-1,2,4-triazole, 4-amino-1,2,4-triazole, 3,5-diamino-1,2,4-triazole and 3-amino-5methylthio-1,2,4-triazole. Polish J. Chem. 1999; 73: 2061–6. [11] Gabryszewski, M., and Wieczorek, B., (1998), “Silver (I) complexes with 1,2,4-triazole, 1-ethyl-1,2,4triazole, 3-amino-1,2,4-triazole, 4-amino-1,2,4-triazole and 3,5-diamino-1,2,4-triazole”, Polish J. Chem., 72, 2352–3. [12] Batyr DG, Baloyan BM, Popa EV, Kharitonov YuYa. Coordination compounds of manganese (II), iron (II), cobalt (II), nickel (II), copper (II), and zinc (II) with hydrazodicarbonimide (urazole). Koord. Khim. 1981; 7: 598–604.
Perspectives in Astrobiology R.B. Hoover et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
81
Apatite as Biosignature Jüri NEMLIHER Institute of Geology, Tallinn Technical University, Estonia Estonia pst 7, 10143 Tallinn, Estonia
[email protected] Abstract. An overview of biomineralization processes is given with special respect to phosphatic minerals formation. The properties of Phanerozoic apatite biominerals are described as being a biosignature of high rank.
Introduction According to definition, biomineralization is a process during which a mineral phase generation takes place due to biological activity of organisms [1]. The referenced work reports a total of 31 biogenic minerals, while to date the number of known mineral modifications, which can be attributed to biomineralization, has increased to more than 200 (from lectures on the Astrobiology Conference, Chania 2002). Most belong to minerals formed due to microbial activity. Considering the rank of biological control over mineral phase formation, a sort of gradation might be constructed [1], from induced to matrix mineralization (Fig. 1). On Earth, the first known matrix mineralization occurrence is Cloudina from the Upper Proterozoic of Namibia [2]. Starting from Early Cambrian, the skeletal biomineralization has become abundant and characteristic of many taxonomic groups, extinct and living. The
Figure 1. Schematic drawing, illustrating relationships between biological control and mineral homogeneity and bodies, formed during this process.
82
J. Nemliher / Apatite as Biosignature
most common biominerals are silica (opal), calcite, aragonite, and apatite. Considering the rank of variability of those mineral modifications, the most stable form is silica, where substitutions are absent; calcium-carbonates of biological origin might be estimated to tolerate 0.1% of lattice parameters variations due to substitution of Sr and Magnesium into mineral. The most flexible mineral is apatite, where the range of lattice parameter variations is as high as 6%. The large range of lattice parameter variability is by reason of very large chemical substitutions into the mineral lattice as well as into different positions [3,4]. Among the most important substitutions, OH, chlorine, and CO3, should be noted, because the amount and position in the apatite lattice generally cause the observable crystallochemical properties [5]. Alongside the crystal lattice reticularis, the other characteristic features of bioapatite properties on the sub-atomic level are strains, content, and crystallite dimensions. Those characteristics fall into range, they are best observed using the x-ray wavelength. In this paper, an overview of bioapatite is given, ascribing those features that might be treated as biosignatures.
1. Apatite Biomineralization Apatite is considered to be one of the oldest biominerals. According to stable isotope studies, possible biogenic origin has been attributed to 3.85–3.80 Ga old apatite from the Akilia and Isua formations in Greenland [6]. This evidence has been regarded as a possible trace of the earliest life on Earth [7]. From the point of view of origin, the majority of the phosphate deposits on our planet are related to products of induced mineralization mechanisms. During geological history, the biogeochemical pathways of this sort of mineralization have been completely changed. In spite of that, completely different trophic pathways of microbiota involved into formation of e.g. Khubsugul cyanobacterial phosphorates versus Holocene upwelling phosphorites (Zavarzin, pc), resulted as the same mineral modification [8]. Since the Cambrian, the matrix-mineralized phosphate became common. The bestknown mass-accumulation of skeletal, primarily phosphatic, remains are related to the Upper Cambrian in Northwest part of the East European Platform (Obolos-Phosphorites), forming phosphorite deposits of commercial interest [9]. These data are based on the whole-pattern fitting of x-ray detection (XRD) patterns, as described in Nemliher and Kallaste [10]. Some XRD patterns of apatite modifications formed by different participation of biological mechanisms are shown on Fig. 2. Basically, observable XRD patterns contain information on lattice parameters and crystallinity, which can be divided into strain component and component, caused by tiny dimensions of crystals of individual samples.
2. Lattice Parameters Lattice parameters represent a reticularis of atoms in a particular lattice direction and can be regarded as a co-function of chemical composition. Considering the published data on different apatite modifications [4], most lattice parameter variations can be attributed to amounts of and relationships between these particular ions, i.e.: as fluorine (F), OH and CO3. A scatter plot of lattice parameters of apatite modifications and differing origin is shown in Fig. 3, showing a certain taxa-specificity of mineral modification. Also, taxaspecific composition of bioapatite can be correlated with the phylogenetic age of the same
J. Nemliher / Apatite as Biosignature
83
Figure 2. Untreated XRD patterns (Co-radiation, λ=1.788965 Å) of some apatite modifications, ordered by the degree of biological control: (a) Hydrothermal carbonate-F-apatite from Staffel, Germany; (b) sedimentary apatite of Middle Ordovician, Estonia; (c) apatite of shell of Recent Discinisca striata, Lüderitz, Namibia; (d) apatite of bones of recent squirrel (Sciurus vulgaris), Estonia; (e) apatite of archaeological human enamel, St. Barbara Cemetery, 14th century, Estonia; (f) apatite of conodonts, Lower Ordovician, Estonia.
group; the most recent groups of skeletons built up of apatite with the highest OH content. On the other hand, apatites of endogenic as well as metamorphic origin have lattice parameters that resemble F-apatite [4], thus the area of biogenic apatites is a somewhat connected to biota.
84
J. Nemliher / Apatite as Biosignature
Figure 3. Scatter plot of lattice parameter values of different recent skeletal apatites and Holocene upwelling phosphorites [11,12].
Figure 4. Calculated average crystallite dimensions of some bioapatites: (a) Shell, mineral, and dentine; (b) enamel (enameloid) tissues.
3. Crystallinity The crystallinity of studied samples shows significant differences between bioapatites and those formed during endogenic processes. The last are built up of crystallites, whose dimensions in both lattice directions always exceed thousands of angstroms while skeleton parts consists of particles, whose dimensions are tens or hundreds of angstroms. Sedimentary apatite varieties are somewhat intermediate, however, tending to be closer to bioapatites. In spite of the visual similarity of XRD patterns of, for example, a conodont apatite (Fig. 2(f)) and a hydrothermal one (Fig. 2(a)), the profile shape function, which satisfactorily matches the conodont XRD reflections, is much more complicated and consists of two
J. Nemliher / Apatite as Biosignature
85
bell-shaped functions, which are represented by modified Lorentzians. The most complicated hard tissues, such as enamel and different enameloids, are built up of two crystallites series, one of which is similar to a dental type while the other is around 10 times larger (Fig. 4). Both crystallites are represented by discrete series.
4. Bioapatite Properties as Biosignature Considering the astrobiological definition of biosignature as being “any measurable property of a planetary object, its atmosphere, oceans, geologic formations, or sample that suggests that life is or was present” (McKay, from lecture on the Astrobiology Conference, Chania 2002), the complex mineral properties are well suitable as being detected as a biosignature. The properties of ferric minerals have been considered as biosignatures of life activity of magnetotactic bacteria [13,14]. In this light, the properties of apatite mineral deserve serious attention as a biosignature. Moreover, combination of lattice parameters values with crystallinity, described above, should be treated as a biosignature of high rank.
Acknowledgements This work is supported by ESF (Grant No. 5275).
References [1] Lowenstam HA. Minerals formed by organisms. Science 1981; 211: 1126–1131. [2] Grant SWF. Shell structure and distribution of Cloudina, a potentional index fossil for the terminal Proterozoic. Am. J. Sci. 1990; 290 A: 261–294. [3] Elliott JC. Structure and chemistry of the apatites and other calcium orthophosphates. AmsterdamLondon-NY-Tokyo: Elsevier; 1994. [4] McConnell D. Apatite—its crystal chemistry, mineralogy, utilization and geologic and biologic occurrences. Vienna-Heidelberg-New York: Springer; 1973. [5] Puura I, Nemliher J. Apatite varieties in recent and fossil linguloid brachiopod shells. In: Brunton CHC, Cocks LRM, Long SL, editors. Brachiopods past and present. The Systematics Association Special Volume Series 2001; 63: 7–16. [6] Moijzis SJ, Arrhenius G, McCeegan KD, Harrisson TM, Nutman TM, and Friend CRL. Evidence for life on Earth before 3,800 million years ago. Nature 1996; 384; 55–59. [7] Gedulin B, Arrhenius G. Sources and geochemical evolution of RNA precursor molecules: the role of phosphate. In: Bengston S, editor. Early life on Earth. Nobel Symp. 84. New York: Columbia Univ. Press; 1994. p. 91–106. [8] Nemliher J. Mineralogy of Phanerozoic skeletal and sedimentary apatites: an XRD study. Dissertationes Geologicae Universitas Tartuensis 1999; 8: 1–47. [9] Trappe J. Phanerozoic Phosphorite depositional systems. A dynamic model for a sedimentary system. Springer 1998: Lecture Notes in Earth Sciences; 76. [10] Nemliher J and Kallaste T. Post mortem alteration of shell apatite of Discinisca tenuis from Lüderitz, Namibia. Lithol. & Min. Res. 2002; 37: 18–24. [11] Nemliher J, Kallaste T, Puura I. Hydroxyapatite varieties in recent fish scales. Proc. Acad. Sci. Estonia. Geology 1997; 46: 187–96. [12] Nemliher J, Baturin GN, Kallaste T, Murdmaa IK. Alteration of OH-apatite from seafloor during fossilization. Lithol. & Min. Res., 2003; 38: in press. [13] Thomas-Keprta KL, Clemett SJ. Truncated hexa-octahedral magnetite crystals in ALH84001: presumptive biosignatures. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA, 2001; 98: 2164–70. [14] Thomas-Keprta KL, Clemett SJ, Bazylinski DA, Kirschvink JL, McKay DS, Wentworth SJ, Vali H, Gibson EK, Romanek CS. Magnetofossils from ancient Mars: a robust biosignature in the Martian meteorite ALH84001. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 2002; 68: 3663–72.
86
Perspectives in Astrobiology R.B. Hoover et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
Tikhov’s Astrobotany as a Prelude to Modern Astrobiology Tuken B. OMAROV and Bulat T. TASHENOV Astrophysical Institute, Almaty, 480020 Kazakhstan Abstract. Development of astrobotanical research by G.A. Tikhov in the Kazakh Academy of Sciences is considered seminal to today’s astrobiology.
In 1949, in Kazakhstan, Gavriil A. Tikhov published a book entitled “Astrobotany” [1]. Later in 1953, the author published a paper, “The Possibility of Life in the Other Worlds” [2] and a book “Astrobiology” [3]. These works of Tikhov were the results of research activity by the Section of Astrobotany, founded in 1947 at the Academy of Sciences of Kazakhstan. Tikhov was an eminent astrophysicist. As early as 1906, he began his astrophysical researches at the Pulkov Observatory, which is located in suburb of St. Petersburg. In particular, his suggestion to employ coloured filters for planet observation had an important role in the development of planetary science as a whole. By 1909 he obtained the first images of Mars in different light spectrums. This allowed him to find a difference in the size and brightness of visible objects on Mars in different spectrum segments. As an astronomer, who, from his early years, believed in the existence of life on Mars, he tried unsuccessfully to detect, on the spectrograms, a major absorbency spectrum of chlorophyll that is very characteristic for Earth’s plant surface. Tikhov was convinced that life is an extremely persistent and stubborn matter, and therefore, he wondered whether the absence of the absorbency spectrum of chlorophyll in Mars’ spectrograms is due to extreme climatic conditions. At conditions of very low ambient temperature, the absorbency spectrum of chlorophyll can be very extended; it would not be possible to detect it using the reflected signal of plants that hypothetically could grow on Mars. This may be the result of decreased spectrum of chlorophyll absorbency and, simultaneously, increased levels of solar energy absorbency. In 1945, while working in Kazakhstan, Tikhov decided to investigate this question through a detailed study of the optical properties of plants growing in different climatic zones of Earth. During the same year, the first scientific expeditions the Section of Astrobotany were launched. This was possible due to the vigorous support of the president of the Kazakh Academy of Science at that time, K.I. Satpaev. Indeed, with time, such expeditions confirmed that in harsh climatic zones, the absorbency spectrum of chlorophyll becomes smeared and, sometimes, even disappears, as it was reported for Canadian fir. Therefore, in the early 1950s, Tikhov dismissed a main argument against the possibility of life on Mars; it was the beginning of the active introduction of astro-spectrophotometry methods to botany. In fact, the fluorescence in the infrared spectrum and other optical features of plant material were demonstrated for the first time during this period. Simultaneously, a sophisticated and unique spectrophotometer for field experiments was developed and constructed in
T.B. Omarov and B.T. Tashenov / Tikhov’s Astrobotany as a Prelude to Modern Astrobiology
87
the Section of Astrobotany. This allowed scientists to detect spectral features of plants in situ without traditional mechanical destruction of the given plant material. Tikhov was also planning to construct a special climate chamber for imitating climatic conditions on Mars. Interestingly, the question of the possible creation of an organization of a special Observatory of Planets at Section of Astrobotany was discussed during that period. In Almaty, Leningrad, and Moscow the research activity of Section of Astrobotany was widely argued and discussed. Interestingly, this polemic further strengthened Tikhov’s scientific ideas and beliefs. However, he died in 1960. And later, in 1964 when K.I. Satpaev passed away, the scientific activity of Section of Astrobotany was completely terminated. The first achievements in space research did not provide optimistic results regarding the possibility of life on the planets of the solar system. At that time, many scientists took a very negative approach towards Tikhov’s ideas. Remarkably, a scientific plan from the Section of Astrobotany contained a paragraph entitled “Programming of Living Conditions on the Planets.” Tikhov believed that the study of the possibility of life on Mars as a research subject of the Section of Astrobiology is a part of the fundamental problem of life expansion in the universe. In 1953, Tikhov considered the feasibility of the occurrence of living organisms on the planets of the solar system. According to his opinion, the question of the possibility of life existing on other planets should be considered on the basis of the following main points: • • •
Laws of life in the universe are generally ubiquitous but unique by their emergence. Adaptability of living organisms to different conditions is extremely high. Plants have an optical adaptability to different environmental conditions.
Tikhov determined that so-called biological geo-centrism was be a point of view that accepts the possibility of life exclusively on Earth. The ideas of Tikhov should be revisited based on continuing and developing studies of the solar system using modern space technologies paralleled with expanding interest in the question of the possibility of the existence of life on other planets. In particular, some astronomers and biologists are of the opinion that the current research efforts should be focused on the relatively small moons of Jupiter and Saturn. Nowadays, astrobiology is active again as the science of the forms and development of life in extreme conditions, distinctive for the Earth and other planets. During recent years, these studies have brought new arguments and an important conclusion that the area in which life exists on the Earth turns out to be much wider than it was earlier presumed to be. At NASA’s Ames Research Center, the Institute of Astrobiology has been opened, and very frequent scientific conferences are being organized worldwide by