ISBN: 0-07-237965-0 Description: ©2001 / Spiral Bound/Comb / 256 pages Publication Date: January 2001
Overview A labora...
81 downloads
1058 Views
8MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ISBN: 0-07-237965-0 Description: ©2001 / Spiral Bound/Comb / 256 pages Publication Date: January 2001
Overview A laboratory manual for developmental biology offering basic, easy to use, laboratory investigations (18 experiments) spanning various models including echinoderm (Sea Urchin), amphibian (Frog), chick embryo, and fern gametophyte.
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
Front Matter
Preface
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Preface
As with the earlier editions, the goal of this edition of Patterns and Experiments is to facilitate and encourage developmental biology and embryology laboratory experiences that bring students together with fascinating and dynamic developing systems. Professional biologists and nonbiologists both often relate that the study of some aspect of development of a living organism has been a memorable highlight in their educational experience. How fascinating it is to watch those tiny clusters of cells as one makes that first marathon set of observations of a batch of developing sea urchin embryos. How exciting it is to return to the lab to find a vigorously beating heart in an in vitro cultured chick embryo where there had been no visible heart and a much simpler form only twenty-four hours earlier. My own view of biology and my career plans changed when I had that experience. I want to say to students who will use this manual that I envy you the excitement that comes with those first opportunities to experiment with living, developing organisms. I hope that a few of you might be inspired to go on to careers researching developmental processes and sharing the fascination of development with your own students. This is a truly exciting time in developmental biology because we are now able to investigate directly many of the genetic mechanisms underlying various developmental processes. However, as you begin your study of developmental biology, whether you pursue that study only in this course or study development for many years to come, I would like to offer one bit of advice from the perspective of many years in developmental biology.As intently as you may study certain individual developmental processes,please try not to lose sight of the whole developing organism and the still broader picture of the role of development in the perpetuation of species. Much of the fascination and beauty of development is to be found at those levels. This third edition of Patterns and Experiments includes a number of additions and new features. Several of the additions are to the considerably expanded section on echinoderm development. There are much more detailed directions for caring for sea urchin and sand dollar embryos and larvae ( Laboratory 1 and Appendix A). Several colleagues have reported that their students have been frustrated with their inability to observe development beyond the earliest stages, and I think that these directions will make it much easier for students to observe additional parts of development.The simpler and more effective procedure for blastomere separation that has been incorporated into Laboratory 2 should make it easier for students to conduct “twinning” experiments like those that have such a rich history in developmental biology’s past. Laboratory 2 also includes a fascinating new experiment on the somewhat surprising, but very adaptive, capacity of echinoderm embryos and larvae to regenerate lost cilia. Also, reorganization of the echinoderm portion of the manual led to creation of a new part ( Laboratory 3) that includes investigation of differentiation of an enzyme system. This investigation provides students a chance to study specific localized genetic activation in differentiation.Also,“Suggestions for Further Investigation of Echinoderm Development” was reorganized and substantially rewritten. vii
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
Front Matter
Preface
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
There is an important addition to the chick embryo section as well. In Laboratory 11, an earlier brief suggestion about investigating heart duplication has been expanded to a full experiment on heart rudiment separation and heart tube duplication that includes informative new illustrations. Numerous other updates and additions, including several added illustrations, have been made throughout the manual. Well over one hundred new references have been incorporated into the “Suggestions for Further Investigation” that appear at the ends of the portions of the manual. Each set of references has been updated, and the majority of the new references are to works that have been added to the very dynamic literature of developmental biology since publication of the second edition of Patterns and Experiments in 1995. I’ve also added citations to a number of the useful websites, many of which have come into being since 1995 as well. I’ve tried for a modest mix of specialized websites as well as general ones that provide links to many more of the valuable resources now available on the World Wide Web and which are likely to incorporate additional links to important sites that surely will be developed in the coming years. Developmental biology is not a discipline isolated from other aspects of biology. This is particularly evident, for example, in regard to the worldwide ecological problem of declining populations of numerous amphibian species recognized during the 1980s and 1990s. Appendix G contains some suggestions concerning responsible use of amphibians in teaching that are relevant to this problem. That appendix also contains suggestions of strategies for teaching developmental biology without sacrificing adult vertebrate animals, which is an option that a number of biologists, including me, prefer to choose. I thank the colleagues and students who have used the earlier editions of this manual and have taken the time to share some of their experiences in developmental biology. They have made insightful comments about the manual and have offered helpful suggestions and criticisms.A number of those suggestions led to additions to the second edition, and others have influenced the development of this third edition. I also warmly thank the many colleagues from colleges and universities across the United States and Canada who have participated over the years in my summer workshops on the Developmental Biology Teaching Laboratory at the University of Maine’s Darling Marine Center. Those developmental biologists have brought their own individual perspectives and expertise to the workshop sessions, and we’ve shared some remarkable learning experiences in that beautiful setting. I owe them and my Darling Center colleagues a great deal. Finally, I wish once again to offer my thanks to Peter Volpe who was my colleague and mentor in preparation of the first edition of this manual. Several of the amphibian development labs, especially Laboratories 4, 5, 6, and parts of Laboratory 8 have been only slightly updated and have remained largely as Peter conceived them, as has Appendix B. Some years ago, Peter’s main interests moved into the areas of human development, medical genetics, and biomedical ethics, and he turned his full energy and attention to those pursuits. Thus, his direct involvement with this manual ended with the first edition, but his influence remains evident in a number of places. The manual’s current title stands as a recognition of his original contributions. Leland G. Johnson
viii
Preface
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
1. Fertilization and Early Development of Sea Urchins and Sand Dollars
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
L A B O R A T O R Y
1 Fertilization and Early Development of Sea Urchins and Sand Dollars
Echinoid echinoderms (sea urchins and sand dollars, which are also known as irregular urchins) have been the subjects of many investigations of fertilization and early development, and much of our understanding of developmental processes in animals has come from this research. Sea urchin and sand dollar gametes are readily obtained just before, and during, the breeding season and their developing embryos can be cultured in seawater or salt solutions that approximate the osmotic and ionic properties of seawater. Eggs and embryos of many species are quite translucent, so it is possible to observe a number of cell activities during early development, using a light microscope. In this laboratory, you will have opportunity to observe development from fertilization through assembly of the pluteus larva, which is the swimming, feeding larval form that is characteristic of many of the echinoid echinoderms. Techniques Please read and understand the techniques for obtaining gametes for fertilization and for the observation of embryos before you begin this laboratory. Obtaining Gametes As in other echinoderms, the sexes are separate in sea urchins and sand dollars. In nature, gametes are discharged into the water, and the sperm swim freely until they reach an egg. Since the sexes are difficult or impossible to distinguish by external features, sex of an individual animal must be determined by observing the gametes that it sheds. Injection of a small amount of potassium chloride into the coelom will induce an urchin to shed its gametes.The sex of the animal can then be determined by observing the color of gametes that are extruded from gonopores of the aboral (dorsal) surface of the animal within a few minutes after injection. The eggs of most sea urchins and sand dollars range in color from translucent yellow to pale orange, but eggs of some species are darker and may have a reddish cast. Sperm, when shed in mass, appear white or very light gray.
1
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
1. Fertilization and Early Development of Sea Urchins and Sand Dollars
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
You should be very careful about conditions under which gametes and embryos are maintained. Temperature control is especially important, and your instructor will provide information concerning temperatures that are appropriate for the species you are studying. 1. Gently blot excess water off an adult urchin and place it on a clean surface with its aboral (opposite to, or away from, the mouth) surface down. Induce shedding of gametes by injecting 1 or 2 ml of 0.5 M KCl through the membrane surrounding the mouth opening (perioral membrane). Sand dollars should be injected with a finegauge needle inserted at a very shallow angle.To enhance effectiveness of the KCl injection, it is advisable to divide the injected dose of KCl among two or three sites in the perioral membrane. Several websites demonstrate these techniques (see Materials, p. 8). It is very important to avoid possible contamination of eggs with sperm.This can be accomplished by using a separate syringe and needle for each animal, but that usually isn’t practical.An alternative technique is to retain enough KCl solution in the syringe so that some can be expelled after each injection to flush the needle. Then rinse the needle surface with distilled water and dry it with a clean Kimwipe before refilling the syringe and injecting the next animal. 2. Collect eggs by inverting a female over a beaker or a finger bowl containing seawater.The water level in the beaker should be such that the female’s gonopores are in the seawater. The eggs will flow out of the gonopores and settle to the bottom of the beaker.After the eggs have been shed, they should be washed by decanting the supernatant water and replacing it with clean seawater.This washing removes coelomic fluid, broken spines, and body surface debris from the water. Eggs should be washed twice if time permits. Alternatively, it is possible to collect shed gametes directly from the body surface with a pipette, which helps avoid contamination by debris and extraneous fluids. Direct collection by pipette often is the best technique to use when only a few gametes are shed, as is sometimes the case with sand dollars. It is best to proceed with fertilization immediately, but if necessary, the eggs of some species can be refrigerated at 5° C for several hours and still respond fairly well in fertilization. 3. Active sperm, unlike eggs, are viable for only a few minutes in seawater.Thus, it is necessary to keep the sperm quiescent by collecting them under “dry” conditions (that is, in an undiluted suspension). A small portion of the “dry” suspension can be diluted in seawater each time active sperm are needed. When an animal has been identified as a male, wipe away excess moisture from among the spines on the aboral surface. Invert the male over a clean, dry petri dish or Syracuse dish.After several large drops of the white sperm suspension are in the dish, remove the animal and snugly cover the dish with parafilm or aluminum foil. The sperm should be kept concentrated until just prior to use, when they are activated by dilution in seawater. Collected sperm may be stored “dry” at a cool room temperature for an hour or so, but they should be stored in a 5° C refrigerator if longer storage is required. Sperm of some species can be stored in a refrigerator for up to a day. 4. Observe suspensions of eggs and sperm microscopically and record your observations.To observe active sperm, add 1 drop of “dry” sperm to about 100 ml of seawater in a small container. Sperm are best observed using phase contrast, a dark-field technique, or some other type of microscopy that increases contrast or otherwise enhances visibility of very small objects. If you don’t have available phase-contrast optics or a dark-field arrangement on the microscope that you are using, close down the iris diaphragm of the microscope’s condenser. This will add some artificial contrast that will facilitate these observations. The newly shed echinoid egg is surrounded by a transparent jelly coat that has a refractive index similar to that of seawater. If you wish to observe the eggs’ jelly coats, mix a drop of India ink with a small quantity of seawater and observe eggs in the suspension. Since the India ink particles do not penetrate the jelly coat, each egg should appear to be surrounded by a clear area (the jelly coat) containing no ink particles.
Fertilization 1. The fertilization procedure involves mixing drops of a diluted sperm suspension with eggs in seawater. A dilute sperm suspension is prepared by placing 1 drop of the undiluted (“dry”) sperm in a beaker containing 100 ml of seawater. Mix with a clean pipette to obtain a uniform, faintly cloudy suspension.The “dry” sperm suspension is quite viscous so it is sometimes difficult to control the amount transferred to the beaker of seawater. The final diluted sperm suspension should be only slightly cloudy, not milky, in appearance, because use of an excessively dense sperm suspension can lead to polyspermy. Polyspermy, the entry of more than one sperm into an egg, results in abnormal, arrested development. Since sperm activation requires several minutes, the dilute sperm suspension should be allowed to stand for 5 to 8 minutes before use.
2
Laboratory 1
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
1. Fertilization and Early Development of Sea Urchins and Sand Dollars
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
TABLE 1.1 Timing of Some Fertilization Events 0 seconds 30– 40 seconds 35– 50 seconds
60– 70 seconds 65– 80 seconds 2 minutes 5 minutes
Insemination Exocytosis of cortical granules Initiation of fertilization membrane elevation (5–10 seconds following cortical granule exocytosis) Completion of cortical granule exocytosis Completion of fertilization membrane elevation Hyaline layer formed Fertilization membrane hardened
Transfer several drops of washed eggs to a container with about 100 ml of clean seawater.A thinly scattered layer of eggs on the bottom of a beaker or finger bowl is an appropriate egg density. Eggs, when they have settled, should cover no more than about one-third of the area of the bottom of the container.Then, add 2 or 3 drops of the dilute sperm suspension to the beaker or dish containing the eggs. Mix the sperm and eggs by stirring very gently with a clean pipette. 2. Transfer a sample of the suspension of eggs and sperm to a slide and observe it with a compound microscope.The most conspicuously observable event is the formation of the fertilization membrane (fertilization envelope), which is a visible indication that the union of sperm and egg has occurred. If fewer than two-thirds of the eggs display fertilization membranes after 2 or 3 minutes, add several more drops of dilute sperm suspension and stir gently. Repeat if necessary. The fertilization membrane gradually rises away from the surface of the egg, beginning in the area of sperm penetration and spreading outward around the entire egg. Fertilization membrane elevation is usually complete within 1 to 2 minutes. Elevation of the fertilization membrane is associated with the exocytosis of the contents of cortical granules that are located just below the surface of the egg.The fertilization membrane, which initially is thin and soft, hardens within a few minutes after its elevation.The translucent hyaline layer that forms just over the surface of the egg also develops within a few minutes. These processes are quite temperature dependent, and their timing varies among species, but table 1.1 shows the approximate sequence of events following the addition of sperm to eggs. Note that several of the listed processes cannot be observed with a light microscope. 3. Since the fertilization membrane is elevated rather quickly, you may miss its formation and wish to use another technique to observe the process directly. One means of direct observation consists of placing a drop of eggs and a drop of sperm side by side on a slide. With the microscope focused on the eggs, the 2 drops can be connected by pushing them together with a needle. This technique will permit you to observe sperm swarming around the eggs. Another method that facilitates direct observation involves placing a pair of 1-mm thick threads of modeling clay parallel to one another on a microscope slide.After laying down the clay, place a drop of unfertilized eggs on the slide between the two strips of modeling clay and add a coverslip. Focus on a group of eggs and, without moving the slide, add a drop of sperm at one edge of the coverslip.You should be able to observe the arrival of sperm in your field of view and the elevation of fertilization membranes on the eggs as you watch them.You may also be lucky enough to observe an egg in which you can see the fertilization cone form at the point where sperm entry is occurring. If you can produce dark-field or Rheinberg illumination on your microscope, you will find these dark-field techniques especially helpful in making these observations.
Caring for Embryos and Larvae 1. Once you are satisfied that most of the eggs have fertilization membranes, leave the beaker undisturbed until the zygotes have largely finished settling to the bottom.Then pour off the supernatant water and add clean seawater. This step eliminates many of the extra sperm that can degenerate later and foul the water around the developing embryos.
Laboratory 1
3
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
1. Fertilization and Early Development of Sea Urchins and Sand Dollars
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
(g)
(h)
FIGURE 1.1 Cleavage stages in the sand dollar, Dendraster excentricus. (a) Zygote shortly after fertilization. The fertilization membrane (fertilization envelope) has been elevated. Pigment granules in the jelly coat are visible outside the fertilization membrane. (b) 2-cell stage. (c) 4-cell stage. (d ) 8-cell stage, lateral view. (e) 16-cell stage, vegetal view. Note the presence of four micromeres that were produced during the fourth cleavage. (f ) 32-cell stage, lateral view. Note the cluster of micromeres in the vegetal region at the right of this photo. (g) 64-cell stage, lateral view. (h) Blastula shortly before hatching. (The egg cell in a is approximately 120 m in diameter, and all other photos are printed at the same magnification.) Photos by R. B. Emlet.
4
Laboratory 1
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
1. Fertilization and Early Development of Sea Urchins and Sand Dollars
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
2. Put a loose-fitting aluminum-foil cover over the beaker and set it aside or put it in an appropriate constant temperature chamber until you are ready to make the observations described in the following. Developing embryos and larvae must be maintained at a temperature appropriate for the particular species (See Appendix A, p. 201). 3. When blastulae eventually hatch, you will be able to see them swimming near the surface of the water in the upper part of the beaker. Sometimes shining a flashlight or microscope illuminator through the culture can help you to spot the swimmers. Once a substantial number of blastulae have hatched, pour the swimmers from the upper part of the culture into a clean beaker. Avoid pouring over the unhatched or nonswimming embryos that remain at the bottom of the original culture.These should be discarded so that they do not foul the water in the culture when they die and degenerate.While 100-ml beakers are very useful for some lab manipulations, longerterm cultures should be maintained in 250-ml or larger beakers. 4. Aerate the cultures twice daily by repeatedly and gently pipetting air to the bottom of the cultures. However, you need to be careful to avoid sucking embryos in and out the pipette.This means that once you have expelled air from the pipette into the culture, you should keep the pipette bulb compressed until you have lifted the tip of the pipette above the water’s surface. Cultures also may be aerated with a very slow stream of air bubbles from an air line or an air pump, but this needs to be done very cautiously because vigorous bubbling can damage swimming embryos and larvae. 5. If you wish to extend the time that you maintain cultures and feed the developing larvae, you will eventually need to exchange the water in the cultures. A convenient technique for water exchange is described on p. 13 in Laboratory 2. For some hints on feeding larvae, see Appendix A (p. 208).
Embryonic Development 1. Cleavage of echinoid echinoderm embryos (fig. 1.1) is holoblastic; that is, the entire cell is divided at cytokinesis during each cleavage division. The first cleavage, which is meridional, produces a two-cell embryo. The second cleavage division is also meridional and yields a four-cell embryo. In the third cleavage, the plane of division is at right angles to the first two cleavages and the product of the division is an eight-cell embryo with upper and lower quartets of cells. During the fourth cleavage, the four blastomeres of the upper (animal) quartet divide equally to form a single tier of eight medium-sized cells called mesomeres. However, the divisions of the other four (vegetal) blastomeres are very unequal, producing a middle tier of four larger macromeres and a lower tier of four much smaller micromeres that lie at the vegetal pole of the embryo.As cleavage proceeds, the embryo becomes organized as a single-layered, hollow ball of cells surrounding a cavity that is known as the blastocoel.The embryo at this stage of development is called a blastula. 2. An embryo will hatch as a blastula, and just before hatching, the blastula begins to rotate within its fertilization membrane as a result of ciliary activity. Hatching involves enzymatic digestion of the membrane, which becomes fainter in appearance as it thins. Eventually, the membrane opens at one side, allowing the blastula to roll out. The time from fertilization to hatching varies among species and also is strongly influenced by the temperature at which development takes place. Once embryos have hatched, they are harder to observe because they swim more or less continuously. Some individuals eventually become “beached” near the edge of drops on slides, but it is also possible to take active steps to slow or stop them. If Poly-L-Lysine-coated coverslips or slides are available,embryos will settle out of a drop onto the coated surface and be held still while you observe them.Alternatively, embryos and larvae can be anesthetized.To do this, mix about 8 drops from the culture with 1 drop of saturated MgCl2 solution in a small container before transferring the embryos or larvae to a slide for observation. 3. Gastrulation is a set of processes by which embryonic cells are repositioned as the basic body organization of the larva is established. It is somewhat difficult to observe details of gastrulation because embryos swim actively during these stages of development, but patient viewing of several embryos will permit you to see at least some of the interesting cellular activities that are involved. Review a description of gastrulation in your textbook or in references provided in the lab before observing various gastrulation processes for yourself. Just before gastrulation begins, one side of the blastula wall flattens and thickens to form a prominent vegetal plate. Cells of the vegetal plate play major roles in gastrulation. Gastrulation begins with the separation of the primary mesenchyme cells (fig. 1.2a) from the vegetal plate portion of the blastula wall and their subsequent inward movement (ingression). These cells are among the descendants of the micromeres that originally were established during the fourth cleavage. The primary mesenchyme cells move over the inner surface of the blastula wall to new positions where they form clusters of cells. Cells in these clusters will begin to assemble the crystalline spicules of the larval skeleton.
Laboratory 1
5
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
(a)
I. Echinoderm Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
1. Fertilization and Early Development of Sea Urchins and Sand Dollars
(b)
(c)
FIGURE 1.2 Gastrulation in sea urchin embryos. (a) Mesenchyme blastula of a sea urchin embryo. Primary mesenchyme cells have entered the blastocoel and are beginning to migrate over the blastocoel’s inner surface. Note the vegetal plate made up of relatively taller cells. (b) Scanning electron micrograph (SEM) of an external view of a gastrulating sea urchin embryo showing the invagination of the vegetal plate at the beginning of archenteron formation. Cilia have been removed from the surface of this embryo. (c) Composite of SEM photos showing the interior of an embryo during archenteron invagination. Note the primary mesenchyme cells migrating over the surface of the blastocoel wall. (a) is a differential interference contrast photo by R. B. Emlet; (b and c) are SEM photos by John B. Morrill. (c) is from Morrill and Santos, 1985, in R. H. Showman and R. M. Sawyer, eds., The Cellular and Molecular Biology of Invertebrate Development, Univ. S.C. Press.
mouth
anus skeletal rod
(a)
(b)
FIGURE 1.3 (a) Midgastrula stage of sea urchin development. As the archenteron lengthens, its wall thins. Some of the secondary mesenchyme cells at the tip of the archenteron have filopodia extending to the blastocoel wall. (This gastrula is approximately 120 m long.) (b) A sea urchin pluteus larva. Propelled by cilia, a pluteus swims with its mouth and arms directed upward. This pluteus measures approximately 200 m from apex to arm tip. (a) is a differential interference photo by Jeff Hardin, Dept. of Zoology, University of Wisconsin; (b) is a light micrograph by John B. Morrill.
6
Laboratory 1
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
1. Fertilization and Early Development of Sea Urchins and Sand Dollars
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Movements of the primary mesenchyme cells involve rather complex individual cell behavior, but the shape changes that initiate development of the archenteron ( primitive gut) depend upon the collective activity of a number of cells.Archenteron development begins with the invagination (inward sinking or “in-pocketing”) of the vegetal plate (fig. 1.2b and c).You should be able to observe some parts of this invagination process. Once it has been established by invagination, the archenteron lengthens, and its wall thins appreciably.The final phase of extension involves activity of the secondary mesenchyme cells, a group of cells that become evident at the archenteron’s tip when it has extended about halfway across the blastocoel. Some secondary mesenchyme cells extend long, thin projections known as filopodia that reach out to touch various sites on the inside of the blastocoel wall (fig. 1.3a). It is often possible to observe extended filopodia. Some of the contacts made by filopodia are temporary, and the cells retract these filopodia, but other filopodia remain attached if they have contacted the region of the oral ectoderm where the mouth will form. These attached filopodia contract, pulling the tip of the archenteron over into contact with the oral ectoderm, and the larval mouth develops in the contact area. The oral surface becomes flattened, giving the embryo an angular appearance that characterizes the prism stage of development. The angularity of prism-stage embryos contrasts distinctly with the spherical shape of the blastula and gastrula stages. Skeletal spicules are clearly evident in prism-stage embryos. Over the next day or two, you will be able to observe the differentiation of the pyramid-shaped, four-armed pluteus larva. First, two arms (the postoral arms), and slightly later, two more (the anterolateral arms) are extended (fig. 1.3b). These arms, along with the main portion of the body of the pluteus, are supported by skeletal rods whose development began with formation of the skeletal spicules. If you have a microscope with polarizing optics, it would be interesting for you to examine the developing skeleton using polarized light. A pluteus larva swims with its arms directed upward and its beating cilia set up currents that sweep small food particles into its mouth. Observe as much detail of gut structure, skeleton organization, and other features of the pluteus larva as time permits. For example, differentiation of esophagus, stomach, and intestine can easily be seen. Watch for muscular contractions in the digestive tract. Pluteus larvae will swim for some time but usually will not develop beyond the four-armed stage unless they are fed. Unfed larvae eventually starve, fall to the bottom of the culture container, and degenerate. Further development can be observed only if larvae are fed, and feeding usually requires availability of cultures of appropriate marine algae. (See comments on feeding pluteus larvae in Appendix A.)
Laboratory 1
7
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
1. Fertilization and Early Development of Sea Urchins and Sand Dollars
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Materials EQUIPMENT
GLASSWARE
AND
Beakers, various sizes, but 100-ml and 250-ml beakers are especially useful Clean syringes and hypodermic needles Clean Pasteur pipettes Petri dishes Aluminum foil or parafilm Microscope slides and coverslips Depression slides Compound microscope Dark-field stop for microscope, if available (see p. 206) Rheinberg filter for microscope, if available (see p. 207) Polarizing optics, if available (see p. 207) Poly-L-Lysine-coated coverslips or slides (optional) India ink (optional) Modeling clay SOLUTIONS
AND
CHEMICALS
Seawater or appropriate salt mixture (artificial seawater—see Appendix A) 0.5 M KCl solution Saturated MgCl2 solution (optional) ANIMALS Sea urchins or sand dollars
Some Useful Information Sources VIDEO —A DOZEN EGGS
This video includes several nice video sequences of sea urchin development photographed by Rachel Fink, Mount Holyoke College, and Seth Ruffins and Charles Ettensohn, Carnegie Mellon University. The video was produced under the auspices of the Society for Developmental Biology and is available from: Sinauer Associates, Inc., P. O. Box 407, 23 Plumtree Road, Sunderland, MA 01375-0407 WEBSITES www.stanford.edu/group/Urchin/ This is a website developed by teachers and Stanford University researchers that contains information about sea urchin development and techniques for studying urchins. http://sdb.bio.purdue.edu/ This is the very useful website of the Society for Developmental Biology. It includes a number of links to sites containing information about echinoderm development. http://worms.zoology.wisc.edu/urchins/SUmainmenu.html This website prepared by Jeff Hardin of the University of Wisconsin contains a number of instructive illustrations and micrographs as well as a lot of useful information about sea urchin development. CD-ROM—SEA URCHIN EMBRYOLOGY
This CD-ROM gives access to the same material available on the urchin website listed previously. It is inexpensive and is available from Hopkins Marine Station, Stanford University, Dept. of Biol. Sci., Pacific Grove, CA 93950-3094. CD-ROM—VADE MECUM: AN INTERACTIVE GUIDE
TO
DEVELOPMENTAL BIOLOGY
This CD-ROM, prepared by Mary Tyler and R. N. Kozlowski of the University of Maine, contains much information about development and techniques, including a good deal of information about echinoderm development. It is available from Sinauer Associates, Inc., P. O. Box 407, 23 Plumtree Road, Sunderland, MA 01375-0407.
8
Laboratory 1
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
2. Experimental Investigation of Early Development in Echinoderms
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
L A B O R A T O R Y
2 Experimental Investigation of Early Development in Echinoderms
Literally thousands of experimental investigations in developmental biology, as well as in cell and molecular biology, have been done using the gametes and embryos of echinoid echinoderms.The results of those many studies have greatly expanded knowledge in several areas of biology. It is quite easy to obtain sea urchin and sand dollar gametes, and the requirements for culturing embryos, at least through early phases of development, are fairly simple. Thus, a number of relatively simple experiments on these cells and embryos can be done in the teaching laboratory. In this laboratory, you will have opportunity to conduct several of these experiments.
SPERM CLUMPING Early in the twentieth century, F. R. Lillie studied sea urchin gametes extensively. Among his many observations was the discovery of a sperm clumping response induced by extracts from eggs’ jelly.When unfertilized eggs are separated from the seawater in which they have been standing for an extended period and the supernatant (or “egg water”) is added to a sperm suspension, the sperm form clusters. Later, the clusters disperse, but sperm that have reacted in this way are no longer capable of participating in fertilization interactions. These observations became the basis for the fertilizin-antifertilizin hypothesis of sperm-egg interaction developed by Lillie and others.This hypothesis suggested that “egg water” contains a soluble agglutinating factor from the jelly surrounding mature sea urchin eggs that might play a role in fertilization or possibly in polyspermy prevention. The fertilizin-antifertilizin hypothesis was later reexamined when the responses of sperm in “egg water” were analyzed further (Collins 1976; see “Suggestions for Further Investigation of Echinoderm Development” on p. 26). It was observed that “egg water” induces sperm to undergo the acrosome reaction, including extrusion of the acrosomal process, and that the sperm clumping seen in “egg water” isn’t an agglutination process such as that caused by antibodies or other cross-linking factors. Rather, sperm actively swim into rosettelike clusters where their acrosomal processes adhere. It is now clear that the inability of sperm previously subjected to “egg water” to participate in fertilization is due to the condition of their acrosomes rather than to an agglutinating factor from egg jelly coats that blocks binding sites.
9
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
2. Experimental Investigation of Early Development in Echinoderms
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Techniques 1. The jelly coat surrounding sea urchin eggs will slowly dissolve in seawater, so seawater in which eggs have been stored for a few hours can be used as “egg water” in making these observations.To more quickly prepare an “egg water” solution, vigorously shake a sample of unfertilized eggs in about 30 ml of seawater in a covered test tube. (Shaking helps to dissolve the jelly coats.) Filter the test tube’s contents and collect the filtrate (“egg water”). Place a drop of “egg water” on a slide or in a watch glass. Prepare a milky, diluted sperm suspension and add one drop of it to the “egg water.”Within 1 minute, the sperm suspension will take on a granular, or flocculent, appearance. Microscopically, it can be seen that the sperm are clustered. 2. You can test the functional capacity of the previously clumped sperm by tipping the suspension off the slide into a sample of fresh eggs on a depression slide. Check for fertilization membrane formation and, if you do observe any, determine the fertilization percentage. 3. If the fertilization percentage is very low, what conclusions might you draw? What are some alternative explanations of the results? What additional experimental step could you take to provide control results that would help to clarify interpretation of the results? Do the additional test. What are the results? What conclusions might you draw?
Materials EQUIPMENT Basic equipment and supplies for sea urchin and sand dollar experiments as listed in Laboratory 1 Test tube and stopper or cover for the tube during shaking Filter paper and funnel SOLUTIONS
AND
CHEMICALS
Seawater or appropriate salt mixture (artificial seawater—see Appendix A) 0.5 M KCl solution LIVING MATERIAL Sea urchins or sand dollars
ARTIFICIAL PARTHENOGENESIS The process of fertilization involves a complex set of cellular responses and interactions, and many aspects of the egg cell’s physiology change as a result of the activation occurring during and after sperm contact and entry. Some of these changes can be initiated artificially by various treatments. Egg activation without sperm contact is called parthenogenesis, and artificial parthenogenesis in sea urchin eggs has been investigated by many biologists since it was first studied by Oscar and Richard Hertwig during the 1880s. Many experimental treatments have been found to cause some, or even many, of the activation responses to occur in sea urchin eggs. In this experiment, you will have opportunity to investigate the effects of one of these treatments— immersion in seawater made hypertonic to egg cells by addition of 30 grams of sodium chloride per liter. This procedure is one recommended by the great early twentieth-century American developmental biologist Ethel Browne Harvey, who, near the end of her career, summarized and reinvestigated many of the experimental procedures used to investigate sea urchin development up to the 1950s. Techniques 1. Transfer a sample of freshly shed eggs to hypertonic seawater (HSW) by pipette and allow them to settle to the bottom of the beaker or dish. 2. After 20 minutes, wash the eggs by pouring off as much of the HSW as you can and resuspending them in normal strength seawater. (Since eggs of different species, and even different batches of eggs of a single species, respond differently, you might consider trying several additional treatment times.)
10
Laboratory 2
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
3. centage 4. 5.
I. Echinoderm Development
2. Experimental Investigation of Early Development in Echinoderms
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Check for fertilization membrane elevation, and if fertilization membranes are present, determine the perof eggs that have them. After 10 minutes, wash the eggs again as in Step 2. Check again for fertilization membranes and percentage of eggs possessing them.
Analysis of Results 1. If fertilization membranes have been found, continue to observe the culture at intervals and be alert for signs of further development. If you detect developmental progress such as cleavage divisions, compare timing with control embryos. 2. Follow your culture long enough to observe hatching and gastrulation should they occur in any embryos developing from parthenogenetically activated eggs. However, parthenogenetically activated development only rarely proceeds beyond completion of a few cleavages.
Materials EQUIPMENT Basic equipment and supplies for sea urchin and sand dollar experiments as listed in Laboratory 1 SOLUTIONS
AND
CHEMICALS
Seawater or appropriate salt mixture (artificial seawater—see Appendix A) 0.5 M KCl solution Hypertonic seawater (seawater with 30 g NaCl added per liter) LIVING MATERIAL Sea urchins or sand dollars
BLASTOMERE SEPARATION One of the most famous experiments in the early history of developmental biology was performed on the sea urchin embryo. In 1892, Hans Driesch vigorously shook two-cell-stage sea urchin embryos in a test tube of seawater until some of the blastomeres (cleavage cells) separated from one another. Driesch followed the development of these isolated individual cells and found that, in at least some cases, such cells could give rise to quite normally proportioned, though undersized, larvae. Driesch concluded that each of the blastomeres at the two- and four-cell stages has the capability to develop into a whole embryo. Though the developmental capacity of early cleavage cells may not be quite so dramatic or extensive as Driesch thought it to be, his results are still regarded as an important milestone in the investigation of animal development. Driesch’s procedure is tricky to repeat, but in this laboratory, you will have an opportunity to investigate the results of blastomere separation using another technique. The technique that we will use may not be quite so rough as Driesch’s vigorous shaking, but it is harsh, and appropriate controls should be added to your experimental design if you have the opportunity to do so.Whether or not you carry them out, think about appropriate sets of control observations for each of the steps in the technique that follows. Techniques 1. Place a sample of sea urchin eggs in a 10 mM solution of p-aminobenzoic acid (PABA) in seawater.Then proceed with fertilization by adding a sperm suspension to the eggs, using the same techniques that you used in Laboratory 1. PABA prevents the hardening of the fertilization membrane that would normally occur within a few minutes after its formation and facilitates later removal of the membrane. 2. After zygotes have settled to the bottom, gently pour off the PABA solution and replace it with calciumfree seawater containing 50 ⌴ EGTA.
Laboratory 2
11
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
(a)
2. Experimental Investigation of Early Development in Echinoderms
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
(b)
(c)
FIGURE 2.1 Development of twinned embryos of the sea urchin, Lytechinus pictus. (a) Twinned embryos after two cleavage divisions. (These cells are slightly flattened. Each is about 60 m in diameter.) (b) Twinned early blastulae (magnification same as in a). (c) A dark-field photo of a control pluteus (right ) and a small pluteus that developed from an embryo twinned at the two-cell stage. (The control pluteus is about 200 m long.) Photos by L. G. Johnson.
12
Laboratory 2
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
2. Experimental Investigation of Early Development in Echinoderms
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
3. Pour off the supernatant after the zygotes once again have settled and add fresh calcium-free seawater solution. Repeat this washing step. 4. Use a simultaneous control culture to monitor developmental progress and sample your experimental culture only when cytokinesis of the first cleavage is proceeding in the control culture. 5. Following completion of the first cleavage division, pour the embryos through a 70-m mesh Nitex filter. Check a drop sample from your culture to see what percentage of the embryos have been separated into individual blastomeres. If most are still in the two-cell configuration, it may be necessary to repeat this filtering step. If this second pass through the filter does not result in blastomere separation, it may be necessary to use a filter with a smaller mesh size. 6. Once blastomeres have been successfully separated, allow the cells to settle and pour off the supernatant. Resuspend in normal seawater and proceed to the Analysis of Results section that follows.
Analysis of Results 1. Observe cleavage in your culture over the next few hours if you are able to do so. Watch for differing numbers of cells in the embryos. After two more cleavage divisions,“twinned” embryos will consist of four cells, while embryos whose blastomeres were not separated will contain eight cells. On the basis of what you know about results of the fourth cleavage in control sea urchin embryos, what cell-size classes might you expect in “twinned” embryos completing a third division subsequent to blastomere separation at the two-cell stage? 2. If you can return to check your experimental culture when the embryos have hatched and are swimming, try to determine whether you have embryos of more than one size in your culture. If you can, measure several embryos in your culture and make comparative measurements of embryos from a control culture. 3. If you can maintain your cultures long enough to do so, look for pluteus larvae in your experimental culture. Check for size differences among the plutei that you find and compare them with plutei from control cultures (fig. 2.1).
Materials EQUIPMENT Basic equipment and supplies for sea urchin and sand dollar experiments as listed in Laboratory 1 Nylon filters with appropriate mesh size (see Appendix A) Cylinders to hold filters, for example, 50-ml syringes with tip end cut off or 7.5-cm (3-inch) or 10-cm (4-inch) pieces of PVC pipe with an inside diameter of about 2.5 cm (1 inch) SOLUTIONS
AND
CHEMICALS
Seawater or appropriate salt mixture (artificial seawater—see Appendix A) 0.5 M KCl solution 10 mM p-aminobenzoic acid (PABA) in seawater (use the sodium salt of PABA, not the free acid) Calcium-free seawater containing 50 ⌴ EGTA Hypertonic seawater (seawater with 30 g NaCl added per liter) LIVING MATERIAL Sea urchins or sand dollars
Exchanging Seawater in Cultures Once embryos have hatched and are swimming, it is very difficult to exchange the water in the culture simply by pouring.The following technique permits removal of a large percentage of the water from a culture while leaving the swimming embryos or larvae behind. It also can be used when the medium around early, nonswimming embryos must be changed and there is not time to allow them to settle to the bottom of the container. 1. Submerge the filter-covered (35 to 40 m mesh size) end of a piece of PVC pipe in the culture. It may take a moment for the filter to be wetted by the seawater. ( You can pre-wet the filter using a squirt bottle filled with seawater.)
Laboratory 2
13
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
2. Experimental Investigation of Early Development in Echinoderms
PVC pipe
turkeybaster
embryo culture
filter
FIGURE 2.2 Diagram showing the use of a turkey baster and a filter-covered pipe to remove liquid from a beaker containing a suspension of embryos or larvae. The filter should have a mesh size between 35 m and 40 m (see Appendix A).
14
Laboratory 2
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
2. Experimental Investigation of Early Development in Echinoderms
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
2. Squeeze the bulb of an ordinary kitchen turkey baster and insert the baster’s tip into the piece of pipe (fig. 2.2). 3. Gently draw seawater into the baster by slowly releasing pressure on the bulb. This removes fluid from the culture while the filter at the end of the pipe blocks passage of embryos or larvae so they are left behind. 4. Discard the water in the baster and repeat Steps 1–3 until you have removed most of the water from the culture container. 5. Gently pour replacement water into the culture to the desired level.
DEVELOPMENTAL EFFECTS OF REDUCED CALCIUM ION CONCENTRATION Calcium ions are important in some cellular responses to external signals, in the intracellular regulation of various processes, and also are required for some cell movements. Therefore, it is not surprising that calcium ions must be present at or near the normal seawater concentration for development to proceed normally. In this experiment, you will have an opportunity to experiment with the effects of reduced calcium ion availability. Techniques 1. Concentrate a culture of embryos between the hatching blastula and very early mesenchyme blastula stages by drawing off almost all of the seawater in the beaker using a filter-covered piece of PVC pipe and a turkey baster (see p. 13). Be especially careful not to use strong suction as you near the end of this process because embryos can be damaged if they are drawn forcefully against the filter. 2. Fill the beaker with calcium-free seawater.Then reduce the volume again and refill the beaker with calciumfree seawater once more. 3. Observe samples of embryos from control (ordinary seawater) and experimental cultures at intervals over the next several days. Make morphological comparisons and developmental rate comparisons between control embryos in ordinary seawater and embryos developing in the calcium-free seawater. Watch especially for differences in gastrulation movements.
Materials EQUIPMENT Basic equipment and supplies for sea urchin and sand dollar experiments as listed in Laboratory 1 PVC pipe with filter-covered end—mesh size 35 to 40 m Turkey baster SOLUTIONS
AND
CHEMICALS
Seawater or appropriate salt mixture (artificial seawater—see Appendix A) Calcium-free seawater containing 50 ⌴ EGTA LIVING MATERIAL Sea urchins or sand dollars
CILIA REGENERATION Development of larval cilia is an interesting subroutine in the echinoderm developmental program. Cilia are essential for normal swimming and thus vital to the life and further development of the larva, but, like most parts of the larval body, they are temporary features in the developmental sequence leading to the adult. It is especially interesting that developing echinoid echinoderms can regenerate even large numbers of lost cilia and that they do so without significant delay to general developmental progress. This ability may represent an adaptive response to possible cilia loss in the natural environment. Larvae can be completely deciliated by one of several chemical treatments. Thus, they can serve as an experimental system for investigating synthesis and assembly processes involved in cilia development. In this experiment, you will have opportunity to observe the process of deciliation following very brief hypertonic shock and to follow the progress of cilia regeneration.
Laboratory 2
15
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
2. Experimental Investigation of Early Development in Echinoderms
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Techniques 1. Concentrate a culture of swimming blastula or later-stage embryos by drawing off almost all of the seawater in the beaker using a filter-covered piece of PVC pipe and a turkey baster (see p. 13). Be especially careful not to use strong suction as you near the end of this process because embryos can be damaged if they are drawn forcefully against the filter. 2. Transfer some of the embryos to a second beaker. They will serve as controls during the process. Then add normal seawater to the control beaker and add hypertonic seawater to the original beaker. 3. The total period of exposure to hypertonic seawater should be only about 30 seconds so you need to begin removing the hypertonic seawater almost immediately. Remove almost all of the water in the beaker using a filter pipe and turkey baster. Immediately fill the beaker with normal seawater and begin your observations.
Alternative Method 1. Concentrate a culture of swimming blastula or later-stage embryos by drawing off almost all of the seawater in the beaker using a filter-covered piece of PVC pipe and a turkey baster (see p. 13). Be especially careful not to use strong suction as you near the end of this process because embryos can be damaged if they are drawn forcefully against the filter. 2. Transfer some of the embryos to a second beaker containing seawater.They will serve as controls during the process. Fill the beaker with normal seawater. 3. Submerge the tip of another filter-covered piece of PVC pipe in a small quantity of normal seawater in a beaker. Slowly and gently pour the remainder of concentrated culture of swimming blastulae through the pipe so that the embryos are held against the filter inside the pipe. 4. Expose the embryos to hypertonic seawater by slowly lifting the filter-covered pipe and immersing its filter-covered end in hypertonic seawater for 30 seconds. 5. Slowly lift the filter-covered pipe out of the hypertonic seawater, invert it over a beaker containing a little seawater, and gently pour seawater on the filter, thereby washing the embryos out of the pipe into the beaker. Immediately fill the beaker with normal seawater.
Analysis of Results 1. Make a gross comparison between the experimental and control cultures. Do you see evidence of a difference in swimming behavior? Do you observe a tendency for the experimental embryos to settle out of the culture? 2. Collect samples from the experimental and control cultures and examine them microscopically. It is possible to observe differences in ciliation with an ordinary light microscope if the iris diaphragm is closed down, but you will get better results using some form of phase-contrast microscopy or the dark-field or Rheinberg techniques (see p. 206). The Rheinberg technique is especially useful for observing cilia. Do you see differences in swimming? In ciliation? 3. Repeat the observations in Steps 1 and 2 every few minutes for the next 60 to 90 minutes. If you have seen almost complete settling of the experimental embryos, watch for them to resume swimming. Try to correlate resumption of swimming with reappearance of cilia that you might observe directly. How much time do you estimate is required for complete cilia regeneration?
Possible Further Observations 1. You might be able to observe the process of cilia loss directly if you mix a drop of seawater containing some embryos with several drops of hypertonic seawater on a slide. Can you see cilia that have fallen off ? Try to pipette away the hypertonic seawater and replace it with normal seawater. If you succeed in doing so, place the slide on a piece of wet paper towel in a petri dish and cover the dish to reduce evaporation. How many minutes pass before you can see regenerating cilia? How long does it take for these small cilia to double in length? When do the blastulae begin to swim? 2. If you have a culture of embryos that have successfully regenerated their cilia, you might wish to do another experiment to test the ability to regenerate cilia several times in succession.
16
Laboratory 2
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
2. Experimental Investigation of Early Development in Echinoderms
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Materials EQUIPMENT Basic equipment and supplies for sea urchin and sand dollar experiments as listed in Laboratory 1 PVC pipe with filter-covered end—35 to 40 m mesh size (two are needed for the alternative method) Turkey baster SOLUTIONS
AND
CHEMICALS
Seawater or appropriate salt mixture (artificial seawater—see Appendix A) 0.5 M KCl solution Hypertonic seawater (seawater with 30 g NaCl added per liter)
Laboratory 2
17
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
2. Experimental Investigation of Early Development in Echinoderms
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
3. Experimental Investigation of Organization and Differentiation in Echinoderms
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
L A B O R A T O R Y
3 Experimental Investigation of Organization and Differentiation in Echinoderms
Embryos of various echinoderms have been used in literally hundreds of investigations of organization and differentiation during early development. This research has stretched from studies early in the twentieth century that gave rise to the historical double-gradient hypothesis to intense investigation of specific gene expression studies that has continued into this century.This lab introduces several of the types of experiments that have been part of this long series of investigations.
DEVELOPMENTAL EFFECTS OF LITHIUM CHLORIDE The results of the experimental exposure of echinoderm embryos to lithium ions played an important role in development of the historical double-gradient hypothesis of developmental control. Although the double-gradient hypothesis has undergone considerable reevaluation, the sometimes striking effects of lithium ions on major morphogenetic events in echinoderm embryos remain of interest. For example, abnormal development of structures derived from the vegetal area can result in formation of embryos with a proportionately large archenteron or even with an archenteron that bulges outward from the surface rather than invaginating properly into the blastocoel. This phenomenon is called exogastrulation. In light of lithium’s known effects on cellular signaling systems (see Suggestions section), it is not surprising that lithium has significant effects on developmental processes that depend upon cellular interactions. Lithium has been used more recently as a tool for the investigation of major organizational processes in early development. Techniques 1. Use a 60 mM solution of LiCl in seawater to prepare 30 mM and 15 mM solutions as well. 2. Fertilize sea urchin or sand dollar eggs in a 250 ml or larger beaker, using the standard techniques introduced in Laboratory 1. Once you are satisfied that most of the eggs have fertilization membranes, swirl the culture and pour off samples into several smaller beakers. Cover each culture loosely with aluminum foil and leave the beakers undisturbed until most of the zygotes have settled to the bottom. Then pour off as much of the supernatant water in each culture as you can, and replace it with normal seawater. Set the cultures aside or return them to an appropriate culture chamber. 3. When the embryos reach the two-cell stage, pour off as much of the supernatant water in each culture as you can and replace it with seawater containing LiCl at each of the concentrations that you have chosen to test. Keep one culture as a control in which you replace the discarded seawater with normal seawater.
19
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
3. Experimental Investigation of Organization and Differentiation in Echinoderms
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
4. Sometime between the time when hatching begins and the mesenchyme blastula stage, replace the lithium-containing seawater in the cultures with normal seawater. (It is probably best to transfer Lytechinus species while they are hatching; transfer other species closer to the mesenchyme blastula stage.) If you have enough separate culture containers, leave some embryos in lithium solutions. To replace the lithium-containing seawater with normal seawater, concentrate each culture of embryos by drawing off almost all of the seawater in the beaker using a filter-covered piece of PVC pipe and a turkey baster (see p. 13). Be especially careful not to use strong suction during this process because embryos can be damaged if they are drawn forcefully against the filter. Replace the discarded lithium-containing seawater with normal seawater. Repeat the process to further wash the embryos.
Analysis of Results 1. Observe samples of embryos from a control culture (embryos maintained continuously in normal seawater) and each of the experimental cultures at intervals over the next several days. 2. Make morphological comparisons and developmental rate comparisons between control embryos and embryos in the several experimental groups. Do you observe differences in gut (archenteron) development between experimental and control embryos? Among the experimental embryos, is there evidence of guts that are larger in proportion to body size than are those of control embryos? Are there any embryos that have a developing gut projecting outward rather than into the interior (exogastrulae)?
Materials EQUIPMENT Basic equipment and supplies for sea urchin and sand dollar experiments as listed in Laboratory 1 PVC pipe with filter-covered end—mesh size 35 to 40 m SOLUTIONS
AND
CHEMICALS
Seawater or appropriate salt mixture (artificial seawater—see Appendix A) 0.5 M KCl solution 60 mM LiCl solution in seawater LIVING MATERIAL Sea urchins or sand dollars
DEVELOPMENTAL EFFECTS OF NICKEL IONS Development of the larval skeleton involves an easily observed series of events.After primary mesenchyme cells enter the blastocoel, they migrate to establish a ring of cells. At two points within the ring, primary mesenchyme cells aggregate in two ventrolateral clusters and form the syncytial clumps that produce the first two skeletal spicules.This cell activity, along with expression of specific genes involved in differentiation of ventral and dorsal ectoderm, is involved in converting the previously radially patterned embryo into the bilaterally arranged prism-stage larva. Some ions, such as nickel, are known to affect this characteristic patterning process. In this experiment, you’ll be experimenting with this nickel effect. Techniques 1. Use a 2 mM stock solution of NiCl2 in seawater to prepare 1 mM and 0.1 mM solutions in seawater by dilution. If your experiments are limited by beaker availability or culture space and you can test the effect of only one concentration of nickel ions, consult classmates who test the other two concentrations so that you have opportunity to share observations of the effects of the several concentrations. 2. Fertilize sea urchin eggs in a 250 ml or larger beaker, using the standard techniques introduced in Laboratory 1. Once you are satisfied that most of the eggs have fertilization membranes, swirl the culture and pour off samples into several smaller beakers. Leave the beakers undisturbed until most of the zygotes have settled to the bottom. Then pour off as much of the supernatant water in each culture as you can and replace it with seawater containing NiCl2 at each of the concentrations that you have chosen to test. Keep one culture as a control
20
Laboratory 3
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
3. Experimental Investigation of Organization and Differentiation in Echinoderms
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
in which you replace the discarded seawater with normal seawater. Cover each culture loosely with aluminum foil and set the cultures aside or return them to an appropriate culture chamber. 3. Leave the developing embryos in the nickel-containing seawater until an early gastrula stage when you can observe some evidence of archenteron invagination. Concentrate each culture of gastrula embryos by drawing off almost all of the seawater in the beaker using a filter-covered piece of PVC pipe and a turkey baster (see p. 13). Be especially careful not to use strong suction during this process because embryos can be damaged if they are drawn forcefully against the filter. Replace the discarded nickel-containing seawater with normal seawater. Listen carefully for instructions regarding disposal of the nickel-containing solutions. 4. Repeat this washing step at least twice and refill the beakers with normal seawater each time. Listen carefully for instructions regarding disposal of the nickel-containing solutions. 5. Re-cover the beakers and maintain the cultures for further observation.
Analysis of Results 1. Periodically collect samples from the experimental and control cultures and examine them microscopically. Compare the developing embryos with embryos in your control culture. 2. Is the clustering of primary mesenchyme cells similar in the experimental and control cultures? When two skeletal spicules form in your control embryos, do you see evidence of spicule formation in the experimental cultures? Polarizing optics are very useful in making these observations if you have them available. If you do not have polarizing optics available, close down the iris diaphragm of your microscope’s condenser to provide added artificial contrast. 3. When you observe definitely bilaterally symmetrical prism-stage embryos in your control cultures, carefully examine embryos from your experimental cultures.Check for differences in continuing skeletal spicule growth and patterns of archenteron growth. Does the archenteron in the nickel-treated embryos bend to contact a flattened oral ectoderm area? Do the nickel-treated embryos appear to be bilaterally symmetrical?
Materials EQUIPMENT Basic equipment and supplies for sea urchin and sand dollar experiments as listed in Laboratory 1 PVC pipe with filter-covered end—mesh size 35 to 40 m Turkey baster SOLUTIONS
AND
CHEMICALS
Seawater or appropriate salt mixture (artificial seawater—see Appendix A) 0.5 M KCl solution 2 mM solution of NiCl2 in seawater; Please consult your institution’s Hazardous Material Officer for instructions regarding disposal of nickel-containing solutions
ENZYME SYSTEM DIFFERENTIATION A number of developmental biologists are investigating patterns of gene expression in echinoderm embryos and larvae. They detect specific gene activation in particular areas of embryos by techniques such as in situ hybridization, using specific probes for gene expression. An inexpensive and relatively simple approach to studying gene activation is to detect enzyme systems characteristic of areas or structures in embryos and larvae as they become functionally differentiated. One such enzyme system is the alkaline phosphatase that is specifically expressed in the developing gut.You will have an opportunity to test for alkaline phosphatase activity in this experiment. Techniques Preparing for staining: 1. Rear sea urchin or sand dollars to the gastrula, prism, and early pluteus stages using the techniques introduced in Laboratory 1.
Laboratory 3
21
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
3. Experimental Investigation of Organization and Differentiation in Echinoderms
FIGURE 3.1 An early pluteus larva stained with an indicator that is converted from colorless to colored in conjunction with reactions catalyzed by alkaline phosphatase. The colored substance indicates sites where genes for the alkaline phosphatase enzymes have been expressed and the enzyme system is functioning actively.
22
Laboratory 3
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
3. Experimental Investigation of Organization and Differentiation in Echinoderms
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
2. Concentrate an embryo or larva culture to a very small volume by drawing off almost all of the seawater in the beaker using a filter-covered piece of PVC pipe and a turkey baster (see p. 13). Be careful not to use strong suction as you near the end of this process because embryos can be damaged if they are drawn forcefully against the filter. 3. Position several coverslips coated with Poly-L-Lysine near the edge of a petri dish cover or inverted bottom set on a dark background. Shine a bright light through the culture that you have concentrated so that you can see the swimming individuals clearly. Draw as many of them as you can into a Pasteur pipette. 4. Transfer a couple of drops from the pipette to each coated coverslip. Be careful to avoid adding so much seawater that it flows off the edge of the coverslip. Wait several minutes until the embryos have begun to settle and adhere to the coated coverslip. Shine a bright light on the coverslip so that you can see the swimming individuals clearly.Then carefully draw off seawater from the coverslip, using a clean Pasteur pipette.As the volume of seawater on the coverslip decreases, more individuals will tend to stick to the surface. 5. If there are ten or twelve individuals stuck to the coverslip, proceed to the staining procedure that follows. If there are only five or six or fewer individuals on the coverslip, repeat Steps 3 and 4 before beginning staining. It is important to have a number of individuals on the coverslip because some will be lost during transfers in the staining process.
Staining procedure: 1. At each step in the enzyme reaction staining procedure, make transfers carefully. Hold coverslips by their edges and slide them very slowly into each staining jar. Remove coverslips from staining jars with similar caution because individuals are most likely to be washed off the coverslips as they pass through the surface films of the various solutions. It is wise to mark a front on each staining jar and transfer the coverslips consistently so that the embryo side is always directed forward. 2. Place the coverslips in ice-cold methanol (4° C or colder) in a staining jar and put them in the refrigerator for 5 minutes. 3. Carefully remove each coverslip from the jar, hold it vertically, allowing the methanol to drain by touching the bottom edge to absorbent paper (paper towel or blotting paper). 4. Transfer the coverslips to ice-cold seawater,* leave for 30 seconds, withdraw them, drain them by blotting the edges as in Step 3. 5. Repeat Step 4 by transferring the coverslips to a second staining jar containing ice-cold seawater. Drain and blot. 6. Transfer the coverslips to pH 9.1 buffer (room temperature) for 1 minute. Drain and blot. 7. Transfer to alkaline phosphatase substrate solution (room temperature) for 25 minutes.** Drain and blot. 8. Transfer to phosphate buffered saline (PBS) for 3 minutes.*** Then mount on a microscope slide (make certain that the embryo/larva side of the coverslip is toward the slide) and seal the edges.
Analysis of Results 1. Examine each slide carefully, looking for the bluish purple color that indicates alkaline phosphatase activity (fig. 3.1).
*Replace the seawater in the first seawater-containing staining jar after each use. **You may need to vary the time of exposure to alkaline phosphatase substrate depending on your results. ***Replace the PBS after each use. It is possible to skip the PBS wash and mount the coverslips immediately after removal from the alkaline phosphatase substrate.You might consider deleting this step if you are having problems with embryos/ larvae washing off coverslips. However, if you delete the PBS wash, reactions will continue, and stain eventually will diffuse out of the gut into other parts of the embryo larva.
Laboratory 3
23
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
3. Experimental Investigation of Organization and Differentiation in Echinoderms
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Materials EQUIPMENT Basic equipment and supplies for sea urchin and sand dollar experiments as listed in Laboratory 1 PVC pipe with filter-covered end—mesh size 35 to 40 m Turkey baster Pasteur pipettes 22 ⫻ 22 mm coverslips Watchmaker’s forceps Coverglass (coverslip) staining jars Petri dishes Blotting paper or paper towels Microscope slides SOLUTIONS
AND
CHEMICALS
Seawater or appropriate salt mixture (artificial seawater—see Appendix A) 0.5 M KCl solution Methanol pH 9.1 buffer Alkaline phosphatase substrate Phosphate-buffered saline Water-miscible mounting medium or nail hardener or New Skin Liquid Bandage Poly-L-Lysine solution
Useful Information Source http://worms.zoology.wisc.edu/urchins/SUpattern_Ni.html This website, developed by Jeff Hardin of the University of Wisconsin, contains information about development of embryonic patterns, especially the roles of primary and secondary mesenchyme cells, and the effects of nickel ions.
24
Laboratory 3
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
Suggestions for Further Investigation of Echinoderm Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
L A B O R A T O R Y
4 Observations and Experiments on the Living Frog Embryo
The continuous change of form in developing embryos has always provoked interest and curiosity, and amphibian eggs, which are large and fairly easy to collect and observe, long ago became popular subjects for those interested in studying animal development. Early investigators focused their attention on describing the orderly, normal course of developmental events, and a wealth of information was gathered by direct observation of the development of frog, toad, and salamander embryos. Later, this observational and descriptive work began to be supplemented by experimental studies. The distinguished German embryologist, Wilhelm Roux, who studied amphibian development in the 1880s, was one of the first to take an experimental approach to investigation of animal development. From the time that Roux pricked frog cleavage cells with a hot needle, the amphibian embryo has been subjected to a variety of experimental manipulations and to numerous alterations of its environment. In the United States, embryos of the common leopard frog Rana pipiens have been employed in many experimental studies of vertebrate animal development. Rana pipiens embryos are also widely used as subjects in biology courses dealing with development.This laboratory introduces the Rana pipiens embryo and some of the basic techniques used in obtaining and studying frog embryos. We will begin our study of the frog with a descriptive and experimental examination of fertilization and the early stages of development. In addition to uniting the haploid nuclei of the gametes to produce a diploid zygote, fertilization also initiates a complex set of activation responses in the egg. However, in some cases, an egg can develop in the absence of sperm; such development is known as parthenogenesis. The drone-producing egg of the honey bee is an excellent example of naturally occurring parthenogenic development. Other eggs that do not ordinarily develop parthenogenetically can be induced to do so by a variety of experimental manipulations. For example, the eggs of frogs, salamanders, and toads may be stimulated to complete early stages of development in the absence of the nuclear events of normal fertilization if they are inseminated with pretreated sperm that have been irradiated or chemically modified. Such treatment disrupts the genetic material of the sperm but does not interfere with its mobility or the ability of the sperm to penetrate and activate the egg.
33
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
Suggestions for Further Investigation of Echinoderm Development
testis
testis
FIGURE 4.1 The position of the testes in relation to the other internal organs of the frog.
34
Laboratory 4
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
Suggestions for Further Investigation of Echinoderm Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Your initial experience with the embryo of the leopard frog, Rana pipiens, will be a study of normal diploid embryos accompanied by a parallel examination of parthenogenetically activated embryos. An embryo deprived by artificial means of one set of parental chromosomes exhibits markedly impaired development. The African clawed frog, Xenopus laevis, is now widely used in developmental studies. Xenopus zygotes can be obtained readily, and the embryos can be experimentally manipulated as easily as those of the leopard frog. Although the leopard frog is the organism suggested for this laboratory, Xenopus can be substituted. However, there are some differences between the methods used for obtaining and handling Xenopus gametes and embryos and those used with Rana pipiens. Thus, you should consult information about Xenopus development in Laboratory 9 and Appendix C if you are using Xenopus for this laboratory. Techniques Preparation of Sperm Suspension Mature sperm are present in the testes of male leopard frogs throughout the year, although there is a period of relatively lower spermatogenic activity from late June to mid-September. 1. Pith (or anesthetize) a male frog and use a scissors and forceps to dissect out the pair of testes. ( If you are not adept at pithing, that is, destroying the central nervous system of the frog with a needle, then anesthetize the frog in a sealed container with a wad of cotton saturated with ether or chloroform.) The testes are yellowish, ovoid, paired bodies held to the kidneys by means of mesentery folds (fig. 4.1). 2. After removing the testes, roll each testis gently on paper toweling to free the organ of adhering blood and mesentery. Using blunt forceps, mince the pair of testes thoroughly in 10 ml of spring water or in a diluted (10%) Amphibian Ringer’s solution in a finger bowl. Tilt the finger bowl so that the testes can be macerated easily in the pool of fluid at one side of the bowl. 3. Allow the suspension to stand for 15 minutes, during which time the sperm will become active. Place a drop of the suspension on a glass slide and examine under the high-power objective of a compound microscope. Observe the shape of the sperm and check for motility.
Irradiation of Sperm Nuclear damage is one of the demonstrable effects of ultraviolet ( UV ) irradiation of the sperm cell. In particular, the energy of U V radiation induces abnormal bonding of the pyrimidine bases of nucleic acids. Chromatin material of the sperm cell can be disrupted by U V radiation without diminishing the sperm cell’s capacity to enter the egg. A phenomenon observed in cases of U V exposure is that of photoreactivation, in which the effect of the U V irradiation is perceptibly lessened by the presence of intense visible light (for example, overhead illumination).Accordingly, it is advisable to irradiate in a dimly lit room.An inexpensive U V source is a 15-watt germicidal lamp mounted in a fluorescent fixture.The inverse square law operates for U V radiation—the greater the distance, the longer the exposure time required to accomplish the desired effect. 1. Transfer a small quantity of the sperm suspension to each of two petri dishes. The sperm suspension should be spread thinly over the bottom of each dish. Label one petri dish “control” and the other “experimental”. Set aside the control dish. 2. Position the ultraviolet lamp 38 to 40 cm (15 to 16 in) above the table top. Place the uncovered experimental petri dish beneath the lamp and expose the sperm suspension to the rays of the lamp for 15 minutes. Occasionally swirl the sperm suspension gently to ensure equal exposure of all sperm to the rays. Do not expose your skin to direct UV radiation and do not look directly at the lamp.
You are now ready to inseminate eggs with the control and experimental sperm.
Laboratory 4
35
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Suggestions for Further Investigation of Echinoderm Development
FIGURE 4.2 Two different views showing how to hold the female frog while “stripping” her eggs.
Side view
A
A⬘ gray crescent
View from vegetal pole
B
B⬘
FIGURE 4.3 Formation of the gray crescent in the frog’s egg. A and B represent unfertilized eggs; A⬘ and B⬘ represent eggs shortly after fertilization.
36
Laboratory 4
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
Suggestions for Further Investigation of Echinoderm Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Ovulation and Fertilization Ovulation can be induced by injecting frog pituitary extracts or fragmented pituitaries into mature, healthy female frogs. The pituitary hormones cause ovulation within 24–48 hours at room temperature (20–24° C) or within 4–5 days at 10° C. Injected female frogs will be available in the laboratory. (Pre-injected females can be purchased from commercial suppliers, or female frogs can be injected to provide eggs when needed in the laboratory.The procedures for inducing ovulation in Rana pipiens are described in Appendix B.) The female frog need not be sacrificed to release her eggs. Eggs are removed from the oviducts by the technique of “stripping.” 1. Hold the female frog with her back against the palm of one hand. Grasp and extend the frog’s hind limbs with your other hand. Position the frog’s back in your hand so that your fingers partially encircle the body just posterior to the forelimbs.The tips of your fingers will come to rest on the ventral surface of the frog (fig. 4.2). 2. Eggs can be forced from the cloaca by initially applying gentle pressure to the anterior part of the body and then progressively closing the hand toward the cloaca region. First, squeeze the female over paper toweling until she releases several eggs. Usually, they will be accompanied by cloacal fluid. Discard the first few eggs issued from the oviduct and wipe the cloacal region dry.Then proceed to strip 100 or more eggs into each of the petri dishes containing the unirradiated or irradiated sperm suspensions. When stripping the eggs, squeeze gently and move the female around over dishes to produce several chains of eggs rather than a single, heaped mound.To assure complete exposure to sperm, repeatedly draw sperm suspension into a clean pipette and squirt the sperm over the eggs. Observe the orientation of the black-pigmented area (animal pole) and the creamy white vegetal pole of the eggs. 3. Allow the eggs to remain in the sperm suspension for 15 minutes. After the 15-minute period, pour the sperm suspensions out of the petri dishes and flood the eggs with spring water (or 10% Ringer’s solution). Note: A mature female frog can release approximately 2000 eggs. A “stripped” female can be stored at 4° C, and she will subsequently yield viable eggs each day for about 4 days.When removed from the 4° C storage each day, she should be allowed to sit at room temperature for 30 minutes to effect temperature equilibration. 4. After fertilization, the egg becomes free to rotate slowly within the space (the perivitelline space) located between the egg itself and the vitelline membrane. Gravity causes the vegetal hemisphere containing the relatively heavier yolk to rotate to the underside. Soon after fertilization, and before the first cleavage begins, a light crescent-shaped area, the “gray crescent,” appears on one side of the egg in the boundary between the animal and vegetal regions (fig. 4.3), although it is often difficult to locate.The gray crescent is formed by the shifting of cytoplasmic components in the egg, and the position of the crescent is related to the penetration path of the sperm cell; the gray crescent appears on the side of the egg opposite the sperm entry point. One of the earliest observations made by embryologists is that the gray crescent establishes the bilateral symmetry of the frog egg. The plane of the first cleavage of the frog egg, in most cases, passes through the gray crescent.Thus, the first cleavage effectively divides the egg into bilaterally equal halves. 5. The jelly envelope, which initially is dense and viscous, absorbs water and swells to several times its original thickness.This thick envelope of jelly, comprised of two or three concentric layers, protects the egg from mechanical injury.The jelly layers swell maximally about 1 hour after eggs enter water. The jelly mass generally sticks to the glass bottom of the petri dishes, so use a clean scalpel or section lifter to free the jelly from the glass, and then gently lift the cluster of eggs from the bottom of the dish. With sharp scissors, cut the mass of eggs into small clusters of 5 to 10 eggs. You need not be hesitant or overly cautious in cutting the mass as it is almost impossible to shear an egg since the jelly-coated eggs are very resistant to mechanical injury. 6. Lift the small egg clusters with forceps and place the clusters in several finger bowls (4 inches in diameter) containing spring water (or 10% Ringer’s solution). Development will proceed well with 15 to 20 eggs in 250 ml of solution, but more crowded conditions generally should be avoided if it is practical to do so. To reduce evaporation, cover the finger bowls with loose aluminum-foil covers. No change of solution is required
Laboratory 4
37
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Suggestions for Further Investigation of Echinoderm Development
AP
(b) VP (a)
(c) FIGURE 4.4 Scanning electron micrographs of frog embryo cleavage stages. (a) First cleavage division. The cleavage furrow deepens more quickly in the animal pole (AP) than in the yolky vegetal pole (VP). (b) The 8-cell stage. The size difference between the smaller animal pole blastomeres and the larger, yolky vegetal pole blastomeres is apparent. (c) Early blastula stage viewed from above and to one side. SEM photographs of Xenopus laevis embryos courtesy of Dr. Robert E. Waterman.
38
Laboratory 4
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Suggestions for Further Investigation of Echinoderm Development
throughout embryonic development. At room temperature (20–24° C), first cleavage of the egg occurs within 2 or 3 hours after fertilization. The first cleavage furrow is evident first at the animal pole and later at the vegetal pole, and it divides the egg into two equal blastomeres (fig. 4.4). Subsequent cleavages partition the egg into an increasing number of smaller blastomeres.
External Features of Development Various stages of development can be made available at different times by distributing both the control (diploid) and experimental (parthenogenetically activated) eggs to various temperature-control cabinets set at different temperatures, if they are available.The eggs of the leopard frog can tolerate temperatures as low as 6° C and as high as 28° C. However, for optimum development, restrict the range to temperatures between 12° C and 26° C. 1. Repeated reference to figure 4.5 and table 4.1 will aid in identifying the stages of development.The stage numbers are those originally assigned by Waldo Shumway in 1940. Plan to make frequent observations during the course of the week to witness the continuous change in the form of the embryo.
TABLE 4.1 Embryonic Development of the Frog
Stage*
Description
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
Unfertilized Gray crescent 2-cell 4-cell 8-cell 16-cell 32-cell Mid-cleavage Late cleavage Dorsal lip Midgastrula Late gastrula Neural plate Neural folds Rotation Neural tube Tail bud Muscular response Heart beat Gill circulation Mouth open Tail fin circulation Opercular fold Operculum closed on right Operculum complete
Age (at 18° C) 0 1 3.5 4.5 5.5 6.5 7.5 16 21 26 34 42 50 62 67 72 84 96 118 140 162 192 216 240 284
in
Hours (at 25° C) 0 0.5 2.5 3.5 4.5 5.5 6.5 11 14 17 20 32 40 48 52 56 66 76 96 120 138 156 180 210 240
*Stages are numbered after Shumway (1940).
Laboratory 4
39
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Suggestions for Further Investigation of Echinoderm Development
1. Unfertilized
5. 8-cell
9. Late cleavage
13. Neural plate
2. Gray crescent
6. 16-cell
10. Dorsal lip
13. Neural folds
3. 2-cell
7. 32-cell
11. Midgastrula
15. Rotation
4. 4-cell
8. Mid-cleavage
12. Late gastrula
16. Neural tube
17. Tail bud
21. Mouth open
18. Muscular reponse
22. Tail fin circulation
19. Heart beat
23. Opercular fold
20. Gill circulation
24. Operculum closed on right
25. Operculum complete
FIGURE 4.5 Normal stages in the development of the frog embryo (Rana pipiens), based on Waldo Shumway’s series.
40
Laboratory 4
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
Suggestions for Further Investigation of Echinoderm Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
The process of development takes place in a series of stages that occur in a regular sequence. Cleavage of the fertilized egg leads to the blastula stage (stages 8–9), which is followed by the process of gastrulation (stages 10–12). Gastrulation is a complex set of cell movements that results in the establishment and positioning of the three germ layers (ectoderm, endoderm, and mesoderm). Subsequently, the gastrula elongates, and there is development of neural folds and the neural tube (the neurula stages of development, stages 13–16). Various outpocketings, inpocketings, thickenings, and other changes produce the sundry organs of the body. The developmental history of internal structures will be considered in the next laboratory; only the externally visible changes during development are considered here. 2. Cleavage of the frog egg is total (holoblastic); cytokinesis divides the entire egg, notwithstanding the relatively large amount of yolk. Notice that the first cleavage is meridional (vertical); the second is also meridional, but at right angles to the first.The third is latitudinal, separating four smaller, upper animal hemisphere cells from four larger vegetal hemisphere cells. After the first few divisions, cleavage of the cells in the vegetal hemisphere lags behind that of the animal hemisphere cells that contain relatively little yolk and continue to divide quite synchronously. Throughout early development, yolky vegetal cells are larger than the animal pole cells. 3. Notice the externally visible changes that occur during gastrulation.An essential feature is epiboly, a spreading overgrowth by animal hemisphere cells that eventually envelop and enclose the vegetal hemisphere cells. Gastrulation movements are first indicated by the appearance of a crescent-shaped groove, or depression (stage 10), on one side of the blastula below the equator.The depression itself is known as the blastopore, and the rim above the depression is referred to as the dorsal lip of the blastopore (fig. 4.6). The tips of the blastopore progressively extend around until they meet—passing through a succession of shapes: quarter circle (stage 10), half circle (stage 11), and full circle (stage 12). At stage 12, only a small area of vegetal pole cells is visible. This remaining visible yolk area is called the yolk plug. The ring-shaped blastopore will soon close, that is, narrow to a barely visible slit (stage 13). 4. The body elongates during neurulation, and the neural folds are conspicuously elevated at stage 14 (fig. 4.6).At the tail-bud stage (stage 17 ), the embryo can easily be removed from its surrounding jelly coats and vitelline membrane. Use two pairs of fine forceps to grasp the vitelline membrane and rip it apart without harming or distorting the embryo. Leave some of the embryos in their membranes so that you can determine when normal hatching occurs. Become familiar with some of the important landmarks of the embryo at the tail-bud stage (fig. 4.7). At the anterior end is the prominent oral sucker (cement gland), a V-shaped groove with prominent lips. Between the lips of the sucker may be seen a depression called the stomodaeum, or mouth invagination.An olfactory pit and the optic bulge are evident at each side of the head.The gill plate has become subdivided by transverse furrows into three bars: the first, second, and third branchial (visceral ) arches. Behind the gill plate, a lateral swelling marks the position of the pronephros, or early larval kidney.The tail bud appears as an outgrowth of the posterior end of the body. Note that the embryo rotates continuously within its jelly coat, propelled by the cilia that cover its body. 5. Try to detect the beating of the heart at stage 19 by using a bright light source and focusing carefully on the ventral surface immediately posterior to the V-shaped sucker. Look for circulation of blood through the external gills developed as branched filaments on the branchial arches of a stage 20 embryo. In late embryonic development, the tail is differentiated into a dorsal and ventral fin, and myotomes (muscle segments) become clearly visible. On the ventral side, at the base of the tail, the proctodaeum is evident in the area where the blastopore closed. In the final stages of embryonic development (stages 21–25), a mouth forms, and rows of horny teeth develop. Observe the development of an operculum on each side as the external gills are resorbed and replaced by internal gills.These membranous operculum folds grow back from the visceral arches and become fused with the trunk, leaving only one aperture, the spiracle, on the left side. The spiracle provides the means by which water taken through the mouth passes through the gill region to the exterior. The completion of operculum development on both sides (stage 25) marks the end of embryonic development.
Laboratory 4
41
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Suggestions for Further Investigation of Echinoderm Development
DL YP
Early gastrula
Late gastrula
Neural folds
FIGURE 4.6 Selected stages during gastrulation and neurulation of the frog embryo (DL: dorsal lip of blastopore, and YP: yolk plug). Photographs from R. G. Kessel and C. Y. Shin, Scanning Electron Microscopy in Biology, 1976, Springer-Verlag.
gill plate pronephros optic bulge tail bud olfactory pit
stomodaeum oral sucker
FIGURE 4.7 A tail-bud stage (stage 17) frog embryo.
(a)
(b)
FIGURE 4.8 Mitotic figures as seen in aceto-orcein squash preparations of tail-region cells of (a) haploid (n ⫽ 13) and (b) diploid (2n ⫽ 26) embryos.
42
Laboratory 4
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
Suggestions for Further Investigation of Echinoderm Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Haploid Development Compare the haploid (parthenogenetically activated) embryos with diploid (control) embryos and describe any differences you observe in detail. You may wish to confirm the chromosome number in the haploid embryos. Accurate counts of metaphase chromosomes can be obtained from squash preparations of tail tips of embryos at stages 22–23. Representative haploid (n ⫽ 13) and diploid (2n ⫽ 26) metaphase configurations are shown in figure 4.8. 1. Immerse an embryo at stage 22 or 23 in a 1⬊3000 solution of ethyl m-aminobenzoate methane sulfonate until it becomes immobile. Cut off the distal third of the embryo’s tail tip with a razor blade or scalpel. Transfer the tail tip to a clean slide with a wide-mouth pipette. 2. Remove the solution around the tail tip and add several drops of distilled water. Leave the tail tip in distilled water for 2 to 10 minutes. Distilled water causes osmotic swelling of the nucleus that helps to untangle the chromosomes from each other. 3. Draw off the distilled water and replace it with a large drop of a 2% aceto-orcein solution. Quickly add a clean coverslip over the tissue to prevent crystal formation in the stain drop. 4. After 5 minutes, place a paper towel above the coverslip and exert strong pressure on the coverslip with your thumb. Seal the edges of the coverslip with melted glycerine jelly applied with a fine brush. (A comparable semipermanent preparation can also be prepared by using a nonresinous mounting medium to ring the edges of the coverslip.) Examine the preparation microscopically for mitotic figures, especially cells in metaphase of mitosis. 5. The slides may be stored in a refrigerator at 2–4° C.The preparation will last for several days, and indeed, the quality of staining might actually improve with time.
Materials EQUIPMENT Wooden-handled probe (dissecting needle) for pithing Scissors and forceps for dissection Clean microscope slides and coverslips “Frog pipettes” Disposable Pasteur pipettes, other clean pipettes, or medicine droppers Petri dishes Clean scalpel or section lifter Watchmaker’s forceps 4-inch finger bowls or other containers for developing eggs UV light source (see Section B) Compound microscope Dissecting microscope Illuminator SOLUTIONS
AND
CHEMICALS
Spring water or 10% Amphibian Ringer’s solution (see Appendix B) Ethyl m-aminobenzoate methane sulfonate solution (1⬊3000 in spring water or 10% Amphibian Ringer’s solution) Distilled water 2% aceto-orcein solution Petroleum jelly ( Vaseline), nonresinous mounting medium, nail hardener, or New Skin Liquid Bandage. LIVING MATERIAL Pituitary-injected female Rana pipiens and male Rana pipiens ( hormone-injected Xenopus laevis adults may be used instead) PRESERVED MATERIAL OPTION Some biological supply companies provide sets of preserved Rana pipiens embryos at a number of stages of development. Embryos at each stage are supplied in a small separate container that can be conveniently opened for direct observation.
Laboratory 4
43
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
I. Echinoderm Development
Suggestions for Further Investigation of Echinoderm Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Some Useful Information Sources WEBSITES http://sdb.bio.purdue.edu/ This is the very useful website of the Society for Developmental Biology. It includes several sources of information about amphibian development, which can be found by following links to “Virtual LibraryDevelopmental Biology” and “Education.” http://worms.zoology.wisc.edu/frogs/welcome.html This website, prepared by Jeff Hardin, University of Wisconsin, is a good source of information on several aspects of amphibian development. www.ucalgary.ca/UofC/eduweb/virtualembryo/ This is a comprehensive website prepared by Leon Browder, University of Calgary, that has several links to sources of information on amphibian development. www.luc.edu/depts/biology/dev.htm This is Bill Wasserman’s Developmental Biology Page from Loyola University of Chicago. It contains a listing of Web resources, several of which provide information about amphibian development. www.utexas.edu/courses/zoo321/ This is a website prepared by Klaus Kalthoff, University of Texas, for his developmental biology course. Information about amphibian development can be found by following the links to “Movies” and “Related Web Sites.” VIDEO —A DOZEN EGGS This video includes a video sequence of frog gastrulation photographed by Ray Keller and John Shih, University of California, Berkeley.The video was produced under the auspices of the Society for Developmental Biology and is available from Sinauer Associates, Inc., P. O. Box 407, 23 Plumtree Road, Sunderland, MA 01375-0407.
44
Laboratory 4
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
4. Observations and Experiments on the Living Frog Embryo
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
L A B O R A T O R Y
5 Patterns of Frog Development
The embryonic development of amphibians, like that of other animal embryos, begins with a series of mitotic cell divisions called cleavage. During cleavage, chromosomal replication, mitosis, and cytokinesis occur repeatedly without any intervening cell growth. This pattern of repeated division, but no growth, establishes a large population of cells, each of which contains a small part of the cytoplasm of the original, very large zygote.At the end of the cleavage phase of development, these many cells are organized as the blastula, a sphere of cells enclosing an internal fluid-filled cavity. Subsequent development involves the extensive cell migrations of gastrulation that reposition the cells of the embryo so that they are prepared to proceed with further development and differentiation. Gastrulation establishes the three basic body layers (germ layers): ectoderm, mesoderm, and endoderm. In some developing animals (for example, sea urchins) that produce eggs containing very little yolk, the cells of the blastula are arranged in the form of a relatively thin-walled, hollow ball.The process of gastrulation consists of the pushing inward of the cells of the vegetal hemisphere (prospective endoderm and mesoderm) in a manner comparable to pushing in one side of a hollow rubber ball. In amphibians, however, the presence of a large mass of yolk-filled cells precludes such a simple inpushing process.The eventual interior positioning of the endoderm and mesoderm of the amphibian embryo is effected by more complex processes. Gastrulation establishes the three germ layers in their final positions relative to one another. Each of the three germ layers is defined by its developmental fate.The ectoderm contains cells that will produce the epidermal covering of the body as well as the nervous system and sense organs; the endoderm produces the lining of the digestive tract and its various derivatives (for example, the lungs, digestive glands, and bladder); and the mesoderm, which lies between the other two, gives rise to a variety of tissues (for example, muscular, skeletal, and circulatory systems).
45
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
(a)
II. Amphibian Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
4. Observations and Experiments on the Living Frog Embryo
Animal pole
(b) pigment vitelline membrane
blastocoel
blastocoel
yolk-laden blastomeres
dorsal lip of blastopore
Vegetal pole (c) ectoderm (presumptive neural plate) roof of archenteron (chordamesoderm) archenteron floor of archenteron (endoderm) dorsal lip of blastopore
Animal pole
yolk plug ventral lip of blastopore blastocoel
FIGURE 5.1 Diagrams of sections of the frog blastula (a), early gastrula (b), and late gastrula (c).
Animal pole blastocoel
Vegetal pole blastocoel
dorsal lip of blastopore
dorsal lip of blastopore
archenteron blastocoel
archenteron yolk plug blastocoel
dorsal lip of blastopore lateral lip of blastopore
dorsal lip of blastopore yolk plug ventral lip of blastopore
FIGURE 5.2 Morphogenetic movements during gastrulation in the frog embryo; diagrams of longitudinal sections (left ) and oblique sections showing surface features (right ).
46
Laboratory 5
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
4. Observations and Experiments on the Living Frog Embryo
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Observations The external changes in the developing embryo’s form that you observed in the previous laboratory reveal only a small fraction of the events occurring internally.The internal processes can be studied in detail when the embryo is prepared as follows.The embryo is embedded in paraffin and/or various organic polymers, and cut with a microtome into a continuous series of slices or sections. The sections are stained and mounted in sequential order for microscopic study. This laboratory will be devoted to examining prepared slides of various stages of development of the frog embryo. Familiarity with the internal changes is essential to fully comprehending the developmental processes and for understanding any experimental studies that you may conduct later. Blastula As cleavage occurs in the frog, the embryo comes to consist of a large number of cells, or blastomeres, which enclose a hemispherical cavity that lies wholly in the animal hemisphere.This cavity is the blastocoel, and the embryo at this stage is called a blastula. The blastocoel does not arise abruptly; in fact, its beginnings may be detected as small spaces among the blastomeres as early as the eight-cell stage. Examine a microscopic slide of a section of the frog blastula. (Fig. 5.1a is drawn from stained sections of preserved embryos.) The jelly layers have been removed, but the vitelline membrane may be discernible as a faint line surrounding the embryo.The nuclei of the cells appear as dark spots.The cells themselves are sharply defined in the animal hemisphere but are only faintly outlined in the vegetal hemisphere. Note the eccentric location of the blastocoel.The roof of the blastocoel is formed by about four layers of small animal cells.The outermost cell layer is deeply pigmented. Below the blastocoel are a number of layers of larger cells, heavily laden with granules of yolk. (Note: the blastocoel fluid may have been coagulated into a compact mass by the chemicals used in the preparation of the slide.) Gastrulation Study figure 5.2 carefully (also consult fig. 5.1).The illustrations on the left in figure 5.2 represent the developing embryo cut in the median plane; those on the right are stereodiagrams of the same embryos. The process of gastrulation in the frog embryo is heralded by the appearance of a deeply pigmented, pitlike depression. The depression itself is known as the blastopore, and its rim is referred to as the dorsal lip of the blastopore. The animal hemisphere cells that have been actively migrating, and have actually extended downward below the equator, roll around the lip of the blastopore into the interior. Laterally, to the right and left of the dorsal lip, animal hemisphere cells roll in, or tuck in, to establish the lateral lips of the blastopore, causing the blastopore to become crescent shaped.As animal hemisphere cells that have spread downward become folded under at the ventral lip of the blastopore, the blastopore becomes circular and is filled with a mass of yolky vegetal cells known as the yolk plug. The process of gastrulation involves several types of cell movements. The downward movement of animal hemisphere cells to envelop the yolk-laden cells of the vegetal hemisphere is known as epiboly. The inward movement of cells at the blastopore lips is referred to as involution. There is a considerable streaming of surface cells into the interior of the embryo, and simultaneous internal reorganization of the embryo involves substantial shifting of yolky vegetal cells. The cell movements during gastrulation were first investigated using vital stains that color, but do not damage, the embryonic cells. In a series of experiments in the 1920s,Vogt briefly placed small agar chips saturated with Nile Blue sulphate against various areas of amphibian embryos at the beginning of gastrulation. He then traced the movement of the stained cells and determined their eventual position
Laboratory 5
47
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
4. Observations and Experiments on the Living Frog Embryo
neural plate ectoderm
epidermal ectoderm
notochord dorsal (somite) mesoderm
dorsal lip of blastopore lateral mesoderm endoderm
neural plate ectoderm
epidermal ectoderm
notochord dorsal (somite) mesoderm
dorsal lip of blastopore
lateral mesoderm
endoderm FIGURE 5.3 A fate map of an early gastrula stage frog embryo, based on Vogt’s experiments with vital stains.
48
Laboratory 5
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
4. Observations and Experiments on the Living Frog Embryo
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
in the embryo at the end of gastrulation.This permitted construction of fate maps of the early gastrula, showing the eventual roles of cells in various regions (fig. 5.3). More recent research using injected intracellular dyes and other kinds of cell markers has confirmed the essential accuracy of these early fate maps.There are, however, variations among amphibian species in the details of fate maps. For example, fate maps of the clawed frog (Xenopus laevis) show that the fates of cells in some areas of the early gastrula depend upon whether these cells are at the surface or lie in deeper layers. It is also important to note that complex interactions among the cells of the early embryo are involved in determining the many different parts of the embryo. Your textbook will provide detailed information on what is now known about these various cell interactions. 1. Study a prepared section of an early gastrula in which the blastopore appears as a small dark notch and the blastocoel is conspicuous (fig. 5.1b). The blastopore is situated about 25° below the equator, in the boundary between the pigmented and unpigmented regions of the embryo. Some involution of cells is evident at the dorsal lip of the blastopore. Consult your textbook regarding the roles of cell shape change and cell movement in initiating and continuing inward migration of cells through the blastopore, beginning at the dorsal lip. 2. Study a longitudinal section through a late gastrula in which the blastocoel is still prominent, but the archenteron has formed (fig. 5.1c). Gastrulation movements have led to the formation of the slitlike archenteron, or primitive gut, which is lined by both future mesoderm and future endoderm cells. Cells that have moved to the interior through the dorsal lip and occupy the roof of the archenteron are future mesoderm cells. Cells along the midline of the archenteron roof are identified as the chordamesoderm and are destined to produce the notochord, while those to the right and left will produce the somites. Yolky endodermal cells form the floor and sidewalls of the archenteron. Later, the cells of the sides will spread upward to fuse beneath the chordamesoderm, thereby producing a complete, endodermally lined cavity, a true gut. At the same time, lateral mesoderm spreading and the differentiation of various portions of the mesoderm proceeds. The blastocoel becomes reduced to a small space on the ventral side and will eventually be obliterated. Identify the prominent yolk plug, bounded by the blastopore lips.
Study figure 5.4, which summarizes the movements of cells during gastrulation and identifies developmental fates of cells in various regions. It should be noted that considerable shifting of the yolk mass occurs, with a concomitant displacement of the center of gravity.The original animal pole of the egg becomes the anterior side of the future embryo, while the blastopore marks the posterior end of the future embryo. With the exception of the yolk plug, the outer surface of the egg is now covered with ectoderm. Two ectodermal regions are distinguishable: the epidermal ectoderm and the neural plate ectoderm. The future notochord and dorsal (somite) mesoderm are derived from the cells that involute at the dorsal and lateral lips of the blastopore. Future lateral mesoderm involutes at the lateral and ventral lips of the blastopore. Generalized Organogenesis in Vertebrates Once cells have migrated to their definitive locations in the gastrula, differentiation of the major organ systems proceeds. Before examining slides that show some aspects of organogenesis in the frog, it would be useful to familiarize yourself with a simplified and diagrammatic account of the development of the major parts of a generalized vertebrate embryo, depicted in figure 5.5. Note that the neural tube has its origin from ectodermal cells along the dorsal surface of the embryo. The mesodermal bands on either side of the neural tube and notochord, called the dorsal mesoderm, become divided transversely into components known as somites. The somites ultimately develop into the segmental muscles of the body. The mesodermal sheets adjacent to the developing gut constitute the lateral mesoderm. Each lateral mesodermal sheet splits into an outer somatic layer, adjacent to the ectoderm, and an inner splanchnic layer, next to the endoderm.The new cavity thus formed, which lies wholly within the mesoderm, is the coelom, or body cavity. The intermediate mesoderm (nephrotome) that lies between the developing somites and the spreading lateral sheets produces excretory and reproductive structures.The positions of the developing kidney and the genital ridge that initiates gonad development are indicated in figure 5.5.
Laboratory 5
49
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
4. Observations and Experiments on the Living Frog Embryo
An.
D
V
D
V
Veg.
D
D
posterior anterior
V
V
Epidermal ectoderm
An. Animal pole
Neural plate ectoderm
Veg. Vegetal pole
Endoderm
D
Dorsal
Notochord and mesoderm
V
Ventral
FIGURE 5.4 Diagrams of several stages of gastrulation in the frog embryo, including the developmental fates of cells in various regions.
50
Laboratory 5
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
4. Observations and Experiments on the Living Frog Embryo
neural groove
neural plate
neural tube
notochord
notochord mesoderm mesoderm
endoderm
endoderm archenteron
ectoderm
ectoderm
spinal cord
notochord vertebra
dorsal mesoderm
ectoderm
spinal cord
somite
notochord
somatic layer lateral mesoderm
coelom primitive kidney
splanchnic layer genital ridge coelom mesenchyme
dorsal mesentery digestive tract
FIGURE 5.5 A series of generalized diagrams showing major features of developing body organization in vertebrate embryos.
Laboratory 5
51
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
4. Observations and Experiments on the Living Frog Embryo
(a)
(b) neural fold
dorsal mesoderm
neural plate
endoderm
notochord
dorsal mesoderm endoderm
gut lateral mesoderm
lateral mesoderm
epidermal ectoderm
epidermal ectoderm
(d)
(c) neural crest neural tube dorsal (somite) mesoderm
lateral mesoderm epidermal ectoderm
FIGURE 5.6 Neural tube formation in the frog embryo.
notochord
rhombencephalon
spinal cord somite
mesencephalon infundibulum
prosencephalon
anal evagination
hypophysis stomodaeum
yolk heart
midgut
oral evagination pharynx (foregut)
FIGURE 5.7 Median longitudinal section of a 3-mm frog embryo.
52
Laboratory 5
liver diverticulum
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
4. Observations and Experiments on the Living Frog Embryo
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
The lateral mesodermal plates of the two sides grow toward the midline, both dorsal and ventral to the gut, until they come into contact with one another to form the two-layered dorsal and ventral mesenteries. Although the dorsal mesentery persists in the adult animal, nearly all of the ventral mesentery disappears, so that the two previously separate coelomic cavities join to become continuous. Although not represented in the illustration, mesodermal tissue that lies beneath the pharyngeal floor becomes involved in the formation of the heart. This brief account should assist you in understanding the relationships of the structures seen in sections of embryos at later stages of frog development. Neurulation in the Frog You observed earlier in intact embryos that the forerunner of the neural tube is the neural plate (stage 13), which appeared as a faintly outlined thickening of a wide strip of ectoderm above the notochord. The right and left borders of the neural plate subsequently became elevated as neural folds (stage 14). Finally, the neural folds curve inward and converge along the midline to form the neural tube (stages 15 and 16). 1. Compare a section of the neural plate stage, in which the ectoderm on the dorsal side of the embryo is flattened (fig. 5.6a), with a section of the neural fold stage, in which the margins of the neural plates are elevated, but the folds have not yet fused (fig. 5.6b).A neural fold is actually composed of two layers—an outer, pigmented epidermal layer and an inner neural layer. The former layer is thin, while the neural layer is thicker and is composed of tall columnar cells. 2. Note that by this time there has been a separation of the dorsal mesoderm that leaves the notochord as a distinct median rod. The future coelom, the cavity within the lateral mesoderm, is not yet evident at this stage. Note also that the endodermal roof of the gut has developed by the upward spreading of the archenteron’s sides. 3. Study a section in which the neural folds are in the process of fusing (fig. 5.6c). Cells that proliferate from the lateral inner margin of each neural fold are neural crest cells, the progenitors of pigment cells and a variety of other cell types. Laboratory 6 includes an experiment on the origin and the differentiation of neural crest cells. 4. Observe a cross section of an embryo in which formation of the neural tube is completed (fig. 5.6d). When the folds have finally closed, the outer layer of epidermal (skin) ectoderm is separated from the roof of the neural tube. The mesodermal tissue between the ectoderm and endoderm has differentiated dorsally into somites on each side of the neural tube and into lateral mesoderm enclosing the archenteron. Note the appearance of a cavity within each mesodermal somite. This cavity will close in later development as the somite differentiates into segmental muscle and other structures. The lateral mesoderm is composed of two layers of cells that, when separated, will enclose the body cavity (coelom). The coelomic cavity is still not conspicuous at this stage.
Tail-Bud Embryo (Stage 17) The tail-bud stage of the frog exemplifies the main features of the basic body plan of vertebrate embryo.The anterior region of the neural tube expands to form the brain.Three primary enlargements— the forebrain ( prosencephalon), midbrain (mesencephalon), and hindbrain (rhombencephalon)— characterize the cephalic part of the neural tube in all vertebrate embryos. Later subdivisions result in a brain with five well-defined regions characteristic of all vertebrate animals. The rudiments of the paired eyes (optic vesicles) are lateral outgrowths of the forebrain, and the future lens of the eye is derived from the neighboring superficial ectoderm. The auditory (otic) vesicle, which will later develop into the internal ear, is formed from a thickened patch of superficial ectoderm opposite the hindbrain. Other conspicuous features, characteristic of all vertebrate embryos, are the stomodaeum and the proctodaeum.The former is a shallow ectodermal depression that meets an endodermal out-pocketing (the oral evagination) at the extreme anterior end of the alimentary canal. The resulting two-layered Laboratory 5
53
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
4. Observations and Experiments on the Living Frog Embryo
(a)
(b)
epiphysis epidermal ectoderm
olfactory placode
prosocoel
retinal layer of optic cup
lens placode
prosencephalon (neural ectoderm)
prosocoel
prosencephalon
epidermal ectoderm optic cup
optic stalk hypophysis oral evagination
mesenchyme
oral membrane oral sucker stomodaeum
(c) mesencephalon mesocoel
optic cup infundibulum hypophysis
pharynx (foregut) oral sucker
(d)
(e) spinal cord rhombocoel
rhombencephalon notochord auditory vesicle
notochord
pronephros gut somatic layer of lateral mesoderm
pharynx yolk
dorsal mesocardium pericardial cavity oral sucker
endocardium myocardium
liver diverticulum
parietal pericardium
FIGURE 5.8 Representative cross sections of the 3-mm frog embryo.
54
Laboratory 5
somite
splanchnic layer of lateral mesoderm epidermal ectoderm
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
4. Observations and Experiments on the Living Frog Embryo
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
oral membrane will break through to form the definitive mouth.At the base of the tail, an ectodermal pit, the proctodaeum, will open into the hind end of the alimentary cavity to form the posterior aperture, the cloaca. As you study the slides of the 3- or 4-mm frog embryo, you will encounter rudiments of several other organs and systems. 1. Study a median longitudinal section of a 3- or 4-mm frog embryo (fig. 5.7 ). The three primary divisions of the brain ( prosencephalon, mesencephalon, and rhombencephalon) are evident.The prosencephalon is chiefly below, and in front of, the anterior end of the notochord; the mesencephalon is anterodorsal to the end of the notochord; and the rhombencephalon lies entirely over the notochord. An out-pushing in the ventral portion of the forebrain represents the infundibulum, the forerunner of the posterior lobe of the pituitary gland.The rudiment of the anterior lobe of the pituitary, the hypophysis, may be seen as a mass of ectodermal cells dorsal to the stomodaeal invagination. The -shaped markings are the somites, which formed from the dorsal mesoderm lateral to the notochord. Differentiated parts of the endodermal gut include the pharynx (foregut), liver diverticulum, midgut, and hindgut (not readily apparent).The mesodermal rudiments of the heart appear below the pharynx. 2. Study serial cross sections of the 3- or 4-mm frog embryo (fig. 5.8).The whole embryo has been cut transversely into a continuous series of slices, or sections, and mounted in an anteroposterior sequence on one slide. The most-anterior slices appear at the upper left-hand corner, and each row of sections is “read” from left to right. As you observe the structures in each section, try to build a mental reconstruction of the whole embryo from the various slices. a. The most-anterior sections pass through the forebrain, or prosencephalon. The conspicuous cavity of the forebrain is the prosocoel (fig. 5.8a). Notice that the wall of the forebrain, derived from neural ectoderm cells, is clearly delimited from the outer covering of heavily pigmented epidermal (skin) ectoderm. Ventrolaterally, on either side of the prosocoel, the epidermal ectoderm has thickened and invaginated to form the olfactory placodes, or nasal pits. In later development, these pits will enlarge to form the nasal cavities and will shift away from the surface of the head. The nasal cavities will, however, remain connected to the surface by tubes whose outer openings form the external nares. In many specimens at this stage, you may observe a narrow dorsal out-pushing of the brain vesicle.This dorsal evagination is the epiphysis, the forerunner of the pineal adult body. b. As you trace the sections posteriorly, observe that the olfactory placodes disappear and a cleft appears in the midventral line.This ventral ectodermal invagination is the stomodaeum (fig. 5.8b).The stomodaeal wall meets and fuses with an endodermal out-pocketing of the pharynx, the oral evagination.The region of contact between the stomodaeal invagination and the oral invagination is the oral membrane, or oral plate (fig. 5.8b). When the oral membrane becomes perforated, the stomodaeal cavity (mouth) opens into the pharynx. Notice the prominent paired ectodermal elevations on each side of the stomodaeum, called the oral suckers, or mucous glands. Identify the optic cups, which developed from the optic vesicles, two lateral evaginations of the wall of the prosencephalon (more specifically, of the diencephalon region of the prosencephalon).The optic cup has two layers; the thick (most lateral) layer is sensory and will form the retina of the eye.This thick sensory layer also induces the adjacent epidermal ectoderm layer to form the lens placode. Beneath the floor of the prosencephalon and dorsal to the foregut, notice the thickened stalk of ectodermal cells, the hypophysis, which is one of the rudiments of the pituitary gland. The spaces between the superficial ectoderm and the wall of the brain are filled with scattered mesodermal cells known as mesenchyme. Mesenchyme cells will develop into connective tissue, muscle, bones, and blood vessels of the head. c. At the level shown in figure 5.8c, the brain appears to have divided into two separate parts. Actually, this section passes through the thick-roofed midbrain (mesencephalon), represented by the dorsal component, and through the ventrally located infundibulum, an out-pocketing of the diencephalon region of the prosencephalon. Consulting figure 5.7 again will help clarify this relationship. The infundibulum together with the hypophysis will give rise to the pituitary gland.The previously observed, rodlike aggregation of cells comprising the hypophysis is still evident just ventral to the infundibulum. d. Continue to trace the sections posteriorly, and notice that the cavity of the brain becomes reduced in size and the roof becomes thinner (fig. 5.8 d ). The thin-walled roof serves to identify the rhombencephalon (the future metencephalon and myelencephalon). Beneath the brain is the conspicuous notochord with its large vesicular cells. Lateral and slightly ventral to the brain are the auditory vesicles, which later differentiate into the membranous labyrinth of the inner ear. The auditory vesicles originated from paired, thickened lateral depressions in the superficial ectoderm.
Laboratory 5
55
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
4. Observations and Experiments on the Living Frog Embryo
FIGURE 5.9 The exposed genital ridges of the frog tadpole, showing the lightcolored primordial germ cells (indicated by arrows). The illustration shows two tadpoles in parabiotic union; the technique of parabiosis is considered in Laboratory 6.
Notes and Observations
56
Laboratory 5
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
4. Observations and Experiments on the Living Frog Embryo
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Beneath the expanded pharynx, splanchnic mesodermal elements have formed the embryonic heart.The heart is contained in a large semicircular cavity, the pericardial cavity. The thicker layer of the developing heart is the myocardium; it represents the future muscular wall of the heart. In the cavity inside the myocardium, mesodermal cells are becoming organized into the continuous endothelial lining of the heart known as the endocardium. The outer thin layer of the pericardial cavity comprises the future parietal wall of the adult pericardial cavity. e. Examine serial sections more posteriorly until the gut is very reduced dorsally and the rudiment of the liver is visible as a fingerlike evagination of the ventral wall of the foregut.The liver diverticulum extends into the yolk mass (fig. 5.8 e). Consult figure 5.7 again in order to clarify the physical relationship between the anterior portion of the gut and the liver rudiment. On either side of the notochord, the dorsal mesoderm has segmented to form the somites. Notice the double-layered condition of the lateral mesoderm: the outer layer adjacent to the ectoderm is the somatic mesoderm, while the inner layer adjacent to the endoderm is the splanchnic layer. The cavity between these two layers is the coelom. Between the dorsal mesoderm (somite) and the lateral mesoderm is an area known as the intermediate mesoderm, or nephrotome (sometimes also called mesomeric mesoderm). At this stage, the intermediate mesoderm has enlarged and differentiated into the pronephros, the functional kidney of the larva.The pronephric duct, with its hollow cavity, may also be identifiable. Far posteriorly, locate the proctodaeum, which originates as a ventral invagination of the epidermal ectoderm.
Dissection of the 11-mm Embryo (Stage 25) During stages 23 to 25, a fold of integument, the opercular fold, grows back to enclose and cover the external gills on each side. This is completed sooner on the right side (stage 24) than on the left side (stage 25). The resulting gill chamber remains in communication with the exterior through a single, short funnel on the left side, known as the spiracle. The dissection described in the following for stage-25 embryos may be performed equally as well on stage 24 embryos. 1. Use a wide-mouth pipette to transfer a tadpole to the anesthetic solution. This is a 1⬊3000 solution of ethyl m-aminobenzoate methanesulfonate in either spring water or 10% Amphibian Ringer’s solution. Wait until the tadpole stops all swimming and other movements. Then test it for responsiveness to touch by gently poking it with a blunt instrument. When the tadpole shows no response to touch, transfer it to an operating dish.There should be at least enough of the anesthetic solution in the dish to prevent excessive drying. 2. Place the operating dish on the stage of a dissecting microscope and illuminate it from the side with a focusing illuminator. Turn the tadpole on its back in a shallow groove that you have prepared in your operating dish. Grasp the skin in the anal region (at the base of the tail) with two pairs of watchmaker’s forceps and tear open the ventral body wall. Observe the coiled intestine and attempt to trace its course.The tadpole feeds largely on plants and, like other herbivores, requires a large absorbing surface, provided by the long intestinal tract. Note that great length without great bulk is accomplished by the coiling of the tract into a compact spiral. Note also other abdominal structures such as the liver. Finish exposing the heart if it is not uncovered and examine it and other structures near it. 3. Return to the abdominal area and remove all digestive organs from the body cavity.You should now have exposed the dorsal aspect of the lining of the body cavity.Along the midline, you can observe the area of the developing gonads, the genital ridges (fig. 5.9). Switch your microscope to a higher magnification and carefully observe this area. The two ridges project into the coelomic cavity and are covered by coelomic epithelium (peritoneum). Note the large, light-colored protuberances on the ridges. These are primordial germ cells that have migrated into this area to colonize the gonads. 4. Make sketches of your observations on the internal anatomy of the tadpole.You may have to dissect several tadpoles in order to complete your observations on tadpole morphology.
Laboratory 5
57
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
4. Observations and Experiments on the Living Frog Embryo
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Materials EQUIPMENT Compound microscope Dissecting microscope Illuminator Watchmaker’s forceps Operating dish (see Appendix B) “Frog pipette” SOLUTIONS
AND
CHEMICALS
Ethyl m-aminobenzoate methanesulfonate solution (1⬊3000 in spring water or 10% Amphibian Ringer’s solution) LIVING MATERIAL Stage 25 (11-mm) frog embryos COMMERCIALLY PREPARED SLIDES Frog blastula section Early gastrula sagittal section Late gastrula or yolk plug sagittal section Neural plate or early neural groove representative cross sections (rep. c.s.) Neural fold or late neural groove rep. c.s. (some companies supply slides labeled “groove-tube transition”) Early neural tube rep. c.s. Late neural tube rep. c.s. Representative longitudinal sections of 3- or 4-mm frog embryos (selected sections on a “serial sagittal sections” slide can be used as well) Serial cross sections of 3- or 4-mm frog embryos
Some Useful Information Sources WEBSITES http://zygote.swarthmore.edu/index.html This comprehensive site, assembled by Scott Gilbert, Swarthmore College, includes a good deal of information about developmental processes in amphibians and has links to other relevant sites. www.uoguelph.ca/zoology/devobio/dbindex.htm This site contains Stephen Scadding’s supplemental materials for his developmental biology course at the University of Guelph, Ontario. It includes a set of labeled cross sections of frog embryos plus other information about frog development. http://sdb.bio.purdue.edu/SDBEduca/qt_embryos1.html This site, assembled by Laurie Iten, Purdue University, contains movies of serial sections and discussion of the value of serial section study.
58
Laboratory 5
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
5. Patterns of Frog Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
L A B O R A T O R Y
5 Patterns of Frog Development
The embryonic development of amphibians, like that of other animal embryos, begins with a series of mitotic cell divisions called cleavage. During cleavage, chromosomal replication, mitosis, and cytokinesis occur repeatedly without any intervening cell growth. This pattern of repeated division, but no growth, establishes a large population of cells, each of which contains a small part of the cytoplasm of the original, very large zygote.At the end of the cleavage phase of development, these many cells are organized as the blastula, a sphere of cells enclosing an internal fluid-filled cavity. Subsequent development involves the extensive cell migrations of gastrulation that reposition the cells of the embryo so that they are prepared to proceed with further development and differentiation. Gastrulation establishes the three basic body layers (germ layers): ectoderm, mesoderm, and endoderm. In some developing animals (for example, sea urchins) that produce eggs containing very little yolk, the cells of the blastula are arranged in the form of a relatively thin-walled, hollow ball.The process of gastrulation consists of the pushing inward of the cells of the vegetal hemisphere (prospective endoderm and mesoderm) in a manner comparable to pushing in one side of a hollow rubber ball. In amphibians, however, the presence of a large mass of yolk-filled cells precludes such a simple inpushing process.The eventual interior positioning of the endoderm and mesoderm of the amphibian embryo is effected by more complex processes. Gastrulation establishes the three germ layers in their final positions relative to one another. Each of the three germ layers is defined by its developmental fate.The ectoderm contains cells that will produce the epidermal covering of the body as well as the nervous system and sense organs; the endoderm produces the lining of the digestive tract and its various derivatives (for example, the lungs, digestive glands, and bladder); and the mesoderm, which lies between the other two, gives rise to a variety of tissues (for example, muscular, skeletal, and circulatory systems).
45
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
(a)
II. Amphibian Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
5. Patterns of Frog Development
Animal pole
(b) pigment vitelline membrane
blastocoel
blastocoel
yolk-laden blastomeres
dorsal lip of blastopore
Vegetal pole (c) ectoderm (presumptive neural plate) roof of archenteron (chordamesoderm) archenteron floor of archenteron (endoderm) dorsal lip of blastopore
Animal pole
yolk plug ventral lip of blastopore blastocoel
FIGURE 5.1 Diagrams of sections of the frog blastula (a), early gastrula (b), and late gastrula (c).
Animal pole blastocoel
Vegetal pole blastocoel
dorsal lip of blastopore
dorsal lip of blastopore
archenteron blastocoel
archenteron yolk plug blastocoel
dorsal lip of blastopore lateral lip of blastopore
dorsal lip of blastopore yolk plug ventral lip of blastopore
FIGURE 5.2 Morphogenetic movements during gastrulation in the frog embryo; diagrams of longitudinal sections (left ) and oblique sections showing surface features (right ).
46
Laboratory 5
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
5. Patterns of Frog Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Observations The external changes in the developing embryo’s form that you observed in the previous laboratory reveal only a small fraction of the events occurring internally.The internal processes can be studied in detail when the embryo is prepared as follows.The embryo is embedded in paraffin and/or various organic polymers, and cut with a microtome into a continuous series of slices or sections. The sections are stained and mounted in sequential order for microscopic study. This laboratory will be devoted to examining prepared slides of various stages of development of the frog embryo. Familiarity with the internal changes is essential to fully comprehending the developmental processes and for understanding any experimental studies that you may conduct later. Blastula As cleavage occurs in the frog, the embryo comes to consist of a large number of cells, or blastomeres, which enclose a hemispherical cavity that lies wholly in the animal hemisphere.This cavity is the blastocoel, and the embryo at this stage is called a blastula. The blastocoel does not arise abruptly; in fact, its beginnings may be detected as small spaces among the blastomeres as early as the eight-cell stage. Examine a microscopic slide of a section of the frog blastula. (Fig. 5.1a is drawn from stained sections of preserved embryos.) The jelly layers have been removed, but the vitelline membrane may be discernible as a faint line surrounding the embryo.The nuclei of the cells appear as dark spots.The cells themselves are sharply defined in the animal hemisphere but are only faintly outlined in the vegetal hemisphere. Note the eccentric location of the blastocoel.The roof of the blastocoel is formed by about four layers of small animal cells.The outermost cell layer is deeply pigmented. Below the blastocoel are a number of layers of larger cells, heavily laden with granules of yolk. (Note: the blastocoel fluid may have been coagulated into a compact mass by the chemicals used in the preparation of the slide.) Gastrulation Study figure 5.2 carefully (also consult fig. 5.1).The illustrations on the left in figure 5.2 represent the developing embryo cut in the median plane; those on the right are stereodiagrams of the same embryos. The process of gastrulation in the frog embryo is heralded by the appearance of a deeply pigmented, pitlike depression. The depression itself is known as the blastopore, and its rim is referred to as the dorsal lip of the blastopore. The animal hemisphere cells that have been actively migrating, and have actually extended downward below the equator, roll around the lip of the blastopore into the interior. Laterally, to the right and left of the dorsal lip, animal hemisphere cells roll in, or tuck in, to establish the lateral lips of the blastopore, causing the blastopore to become crescent shaped.As animal hemisphere cells that have spread downward become folded under at the ventral lip of the blastopore, the blastopore becomes circular and is filled with a mass of yolky vegetal cells known as the yolk plug. The process of gastrulation involves several types of cell movements. The downward movement of animal hemisphere cells to envelop the yolk-laden cells of the vegetal hemisphere is known as epiboly. The inward movement of cells at the blastopore lips is referred to as involution. There is a considerable streaming of surface cells into the interior of the embryo, and simultaneous internal reorganization of the embryo involves substantial shifting of yolky vegetal cells. The cell movements during gastrulation were first investigated using vital stains that color, but do not damage, the embryonic cells. In a series of experiments in the 1920s,Vogt briefly placed small agar chips saturated with Nile Blue sulphate against various areas of amphibian embryos at the beginning of gastrulation. He then traced the movement of the stained cells and determined their eventual position
Laboratory 5
47
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
5. Patterns of Frog Development
neural plate ectoderm
epidermal ectoderm
notochord dorsal (somite) mesoderm
dorsal lip of blastopore lateral mesoderm endoderm
neural plate ectoderm
epidermal ectoderm
notochord dorsal (somite) mesoderm
dorsal lip of blastopore
lateral mesoderm
endoderm FIGURE 5.3 A fate map of an early gastrula stage frog embryo, based on Vogt’s experiments with vital stains.
48
Laboratory 5
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
5. Patterns of Frog Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
in the embryo at the end of gastrulation.This permitted construction of fate maps of the early gastrula, showing the eventual roles of cells in various regions (fig. 5.3). More recent research using injected intracellular dyes and other kinds of cell markers has confirmed the essential accuracy of these early fate maps.There are, however, variations among amphibian species in the details of fate maps. For example, fate maps of the clawed frog (Xenopus laevis) show that the fates of cells in some areas of the early gastrula depend upon whether these cells are at the surface or lie in deeper layers. It is also important to note that complex interactions among the cells of the early embryo are involved in determining the many different parts of the embryo. Your textbook will provide detailed information on what is now known about these various cell interactions. 1. Study a prepared section of an early gastrula in which the blastopore appears as a small dark notch and the blastocoel is conspicuous (fig. 5.1b). The blastopore is situated about 25° below the equator, in the boundary between the pigmented and unpigmented regions of the embryo. Some involution of cells is evident at the dorsal lip of the blastopore. Consult your textbook regarding the roles of cell shape change and cell movement in initiating and continuing inward migration of cells through the blastopore, beginning at the dorsal lip. 2. Study a longitudinal section through a late gastrula in which the blastocoel is still prominent, but the archenteron has formed (fig. 5.1c). Gastrulation movements have led to the formation of the slitlike archenteron, or primitive gut, which is lined by both future mesoderm and future endoderm cells. Cells that have moved to the interior through the dorsal lip and occupy the roof of the archenteron are future mesoderm cells. Cells along the midline of the archenteron roof are identified as the chordamesoderm and are destined to produce the notochord, while those to the right and left will produce the somites. Yolky endodermal cells form the floor and sidewalls of the archenteron. Later, the cells of the sides will spread upward to fuse beneath the chordamesoderm, thereby producing a complete, endodermally lined cavity, a true gut. At the same time, lateral mesoderm spreading and the differentiation of various portions of the mesoderm proceeds. The blastocoel becomes reduced to a small space on the ventral side and will eventually be obliterated. Identify the prominent yolk plug, bounded by the blastopore lips.
Study figure 5.4, which summarizes the movements of cells during gastrulation and identifies developmental fates of cells in various regions. It should be noted that considerable shifting of the yolk mass occurs, with a concomitant displacement of the center of gravity.The original animal pole of the egg becomes the anterior side of the future embryo, while the blastopore marks the posterior end of the future embryo. With the exception of the yolk plug, the outer surface of the egg is now covered with ectoderm. Two ectodermal regions are distinguishable: the epidermal ectoderm and the neural plate ectoderm. The future notochord and dorsal (somite) mesoderm are derived from the cells that involute at the dorsal and lateral lips of the blastopore. Future lateral mesoderm involutes at the lateral and ventral lips of the blastopore. Generalized Organogenesis in Vertebrates Once cells have migrated to their definitive locations in the gastrula, differentiation of the major organ systems proceeds. Before examining slides that show some aspects of organogenesis in the frog, it would be useful to familiarize yourself with a simplified and diagrammatic account of the development of the major parts of a generalized vertebrate embryo, depicted in figure 5.5. Note that the neural tube has its origin from ectodermal cells along the dorsal surface of the embryo. The mesodermal bands on either side of the neural tube and notochord, called the dorsal mesoderm, become divided transversely into components known as somites. The somites ultimately develop into the segmental muscles of the body. The mesodermal sheets adjacent to the developing gut constitute the lateral mesoderm. Each lateral mesodermal sheet splits into an outer somatic layer, adjacent to the ectoderm, and an inner splanchnic layer, next to the endoderm.The new cavity thus formed, which lies wholly within the mesoderm, is the coelom, or body cavity. The intermediate mesoderm (nephrotome) that lies between the developing somites and the spreading lateral sheets produces excretory and reproductive structures.The positions of the developing kidney and the genital ridge that initiates gonad development are indicated in figure 5.5.
Laboratory 5
49
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
5. Patterns of Frog Development
An.
D
V
D
V
Veg.
D
D
posterior anterior
V
V
Epidermal ectoderm
An. Animal pole
Neural plate ectoderm
Veg. Vegetal pole
Endoderm
D
Dorsal
Notochord and mesoderm
V
Ventral
FIGURE 5.4 Diagrams of several stages of gastrulation in the frog embryo, including the developmental fates of cells in various regions.
50
Laboratory 5
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
5. Patterns of Frog Development
neural groove
neural plate
neural tube
notochord
notochord mesoderm mesoderm
endoderm
endoderm archenteron
ectoderm
ectoderm
spinal cord
notochord vertebra
dorsal mesoderm
ectoderm
spinal cord
somite
notochord
somatic layer lateral mesoderm
coelom primitive kidney
splanchnic layer genital ridge coelom mesenchyme
dorsal mesentery digestive tract
FIGURE 5.5 A series of generalized diagrams showing major features of developing body organization in vertebrate embryos.
Laboratory 5
51
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
5. Patterns of Frog Development
(a)
(b) neural fold
dorsal mesoderm
neural plate
endoderm
notochord
dorsal mesoderm endoderm
gut lateral mesoderm
lateral mesoderm
epidermal ectoderm
epidermal ectoderm
(d)
(c) neural crest neural tube dorsal (somite) mesoderm
lateral mesoderm epidermal ectoderm
FIGURE 5.6 Neural tube formation in the frog embryo.
notochord
rhombencephalon
spinal cord somite
mesencephalon infundibulum
prosencephalon
anal evagination
hypophysis stomodaeum
yolk heart
midgut
oral evagination pharynx (foregut)
FIGURE 5.7 Median longitudinal section of a 3-mm frog embryo.
52
Laboratory 5
liver diverticulum
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
5. Patterns of Frog Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
The lateral mesodermal plates of the two sides grow toward the midline, both dorsal and ventral to the gut, until they come into contact with one another to form the two-layered dorsal and ventral mesenteries. Although the dorsal mesentery persists in the adult animal, nearly all of the ventral mesentery disappears, so that the two previously separate coelomic cavities join to become continuous. Although not represented in the illustration, mesodermal tissue that lies beneath the pharyngeal floor becomes involved in the formation of the heart. This brief account should assist you in understanding the relationships of the structures seen in sections of embryos at later stages of frog development. Neurulation in the Frog You observed earlier in intact embryos that the forerunner of the neural tube is the neural plate (stage 13), which appeared as a faintly outlined thickening of a wide strip of ectoderm above the notochord. The right and left borders of the neural plate subsequently became elevated as neural folds (stage 14). Finally, the neural folds curve inward and converge along the midline to form the neural tube (stages 15 and 16). 1. Compare a section of the neural plate stage, in which the ectoderm on the dorsal side of the embryo is flattened (fig. 5.6a), with a section of the neural fold stage, in which the margins of the neural plates are elevated, but the folds have not yet fused (fig. 5.6b).A neural fold is actually composed of two layers—an outer, pigmented epidermal layer and an inner neural layer. The former layer is thin, while the neural layer is thicker and is composed of tall columnar cells. 2. Note that by this time there has been a separation of the dorsal mesoderm that leaves the notochord as a distinct median rod. The future coelom, the cavity within the lateral mesoderm, is not yet evident at this stage. Note also that the endodermal roof of the gut has developed by the upward spreading of the archenteron’s sides. 3. Study a section in which the neural folds are in the process of fusing (fig. 5.6c). Cells that proliferate from the lateral inner margin of each neural fold are neural crest cells, the progenitors of pigment cells and a variety of other cell types. Laboratory 6 includes an experiment on the origin and the differentiation of neural crest cells. 4. Observe a cross section of an embryo in which formation of the neural tube is completed (fig. 5.6d). When the folds have finally closed, the outer layer of epidermal (skin) ectoderm is separated from the roof of the neural tube. The mesodermal tissue between the ectoderm and endoderm has differentiated dorsally into somites on each side of the neural tube and into lateral mesoderm enclosing the archenteron. Note the appearance of a cavity within each mesodermal somite. This cavity will close in later development as the somite differentiates into segmental muscle and other structures. The lateral mesoderm is composed of two layers of cells that, when separated, will enclose the body cavity (coelom). The coelomic cavity is still not conspicuous at this stage.
Tail-Bud Embryo (Stage 17) The tail-bud stage of the frog exemplifies the main features of the basic body plan of vertebrate embryo.The anterior region of the neural tube expands to form the brain.Three primary enlargements— the forebrain ( prosencephalon), midbrain (mesencephalon), and hindbrain (rhombencephalon)— characterize the cephalic part of the neural tube in all vertebrate embryos. Later subdivisions result in a brain with five well-defined regions characteristic of all vertebrate animals. The rudiments of the paired eyes (optic vesicles) are lateral outgrowths of the forebrain, and the future lens of the eye is derived from the neighboring superficial ectoderm. The auditory (otic) vesicle, which will later develop into the internal ear, is formed from a thickened patch of superficial ectoderm opposite the hindbrain. Other conspicuous features, characteristic of all vertebrate embryos, are the stomodaeum and the proctodaeum.The former is a shallow ectodermal depression that meets an endodermal out-pocketing (the oral evagination) at the extreme anterior end of the alimentary canal. The resulting two-layered Laboratory 5
53
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
5. Patterns of Frog Development
(a)
(b)
epiphysis epidermal ectoderm
olfactory placode
prosocoel
retinal layer of optic cup
lens placode
prosencephalon (neural ectoderm)
prosocoel
prosencephalon
epidermal ectoderm optic cup
optic stalk hypophysis oral evagination
mesenchyme
oral membrane oral sucker stomodaeum
(c) mesencephalon mesocoel
optic cup infundibulum hypophysis
pharynx (foregut) oral sucker
(d)
(e) spinal cord rhombocoel
rhombencephalon notochord auditory vesicle
notochord
pronephros gut somatic layer of lateral mesoderm
pharynx yolk
dorsal mesocardium pericardial cavity oral sucker
endocardium myocardium
liver diverticulum
parietal pericardium
FIGURE 5.8 Representative cross sections of the 3-mm frog embryo.
54
Laboratory 5
somite
splanchnic layer of lateral mesoderm epidermal ectoderm
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
5. Patterns of Frog Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
oral membrane will break through to form the definitive mouth.At the base of the tail, an ectodermal pit, the proctodaeum, will open into the hind end of the alimentary cavity to form the posterior aperture, the cloaca. As you study the slides of the 3- or 4-mm frog embryo, you will encounter rudiments of several other organs and systems. 1. Study a median longitudinal section of a 3- or 4-mm frog embryo (fig. 5.7 ). The three primary divisions of the brain ( prosencephalon, mesencephalon, and rhombencephalon) are evident.The prosencephalon is chiefly below, and in front of, the anterior end of the notochord; the mesencephalon is anterodorsal to the end of the notochord; and the rhombencephalon lies entirely over the notochord. An out-pushing in the ventral portion of the forebrain represents the infundibulum, the forerunner of the posterior lobe of the pituitary gland.The rudiment of the anterior lobe of the pituitary, the hypophysis, may be seen as a mass of ectodermal cells dorsal to the stomodaeal invagination. The -shaped markings are the somites, which formed from the dorsal mesoderm lateral to the notochord. Differentiated parts of the endodermal gut include the pharynx (foregut), liver diverticulum, midgut, and hindgut (not readily apparent).The mesodermal rudiments of the heart appear below the pharynx. 2. Study serial cross sections of the 3- or 4-mm frog embryo (fig. 5.8).The whole embryo has been cut transversely into a continuous series of slices, or sections, and mounted in an anteroposterior sequence on one slide. The most-anterior slices appear at the upper left-hand corner, and each row of sections is “read” from left to right. As you observe the structures in each section, try to build a mental reconstruction of the whole embryo from the various slices. a. The most-anterior sections pass through the forebrain, or prosencephalon. The conspicuous cavity of the forebrain is the prosocoel (fig. 5.8a). Notice that the wall of the forebrain, derived from neural ectoderm cells, is clearly delimited from the outer covering of heavily pigmented epidermal (skin) ectoderm. Ventrolaterally, on either side of the prosocoel, the epidermal ectoderm has thickened and invaginated to form the olfactory placodes, or nasal pits. In later development, these pits will enlarge to form the nasal cavities and will shift away from the surface of the head. The nasal cavities will, however, remain connected to the surface by tubes whose outer openings form the external nares. In many specimens at this stage, you may observe a narrow dorsal out-pushing of the brain vesicle.This dorsal evagination is the epiphysis, the forerunner of the pineal adult body. b. As you trace the sections posteriorly, observe that the olfactory placodes disappear and a cleft appears in the midventral line.This ventral ectodermal invagination is the stomodaeum (fig. 5.8b).The stomodaeal wall meets and fuses with an endodermal out-pocketing of the pharynx, the oral evagination.The region of contact between the stomodaeal invagination and the oral invagination is the oral membrane, or oral plate (fig. 5.8b). When the oral membrane becomes perforated, the stomodaeal cavity (mouth) opens into the pharynx. Notice the prominent paired ectodermal elevations on each side of the stomodaeum, called the oral suckers, or mucous glands. Identify the optic cups, which developed from the optic vesicles, two lateral evaginations of the wall of the prosencephalon (more specifically, of the diencephalon region of the prosencephalon).The optic cup has two layers; the thick (most lateral) layer is sensory and will form the retina of the eye.This thick sensory layer also induces the adjacent epidermal ectoderm layer to form the lens placode. Beneath the floor of the prosencephalon and dorsal to the foregut, notice the thickened stalk of ectodermal cells, the hypophysis, which is one of the rudiments of the pituitary gland. The spaces between the superficial ectoderm and the wall of the brain are filled with scattered mesodermal cells known as mesenchyme. Mesenchyme cells will develop into connective tissue, muscle, bones, and blood vessels of the head. c. At the level shown in figure 5.8c, the brain appears to have divided into two separate parts. Actually, this section passes through the thick-roofed midbrain (mesencephalon), represented by the dorsal component, and through the ventrally located infundibulum, an out-pocketing of the diencephalon region of the prosencephalon. Consulting figure 5.7 again will help clarify this relationship. The infundibulum together with the hypophysis will give rise to the pituitary gland.The previously observed, rodlike aggregation of cells comprising the hypophysis is still evident just ventral to the infundibulum. d. Continue to trace the sections posteriorly, and notice that the cavity of the brain becomes reduced in size and the roof becomes thinner (fig. 5.8 d ). The thin-walled roof serves to identify the rhombencephalon (the future metencephalon and myelencephalon). Beneath the brain is the conspicuous notochord with its large vesicular cells. Lateral and slightly ventral to the brain are the auditory vesicles, which later differentiate into the membranous labyrinth of the inner ear. The auditory vesicles originated from paired, thickened lateral depressions in the superficial ectoderm.
Laboratory 5
55
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
5. Patterns of Frog Development
FIGURE 5.9 The exposed genital ridges of the frog tadpole, showing the lightcolored primordial germ cells (indicated by arrows). The illustration shows two tadpoles in parabiotic union; the technique of parabiosis is considered in Laboratory 6.
Notes and Observations
56
Laboratory 5
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
5. Patterns of Frog Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Beneath the expanded pharynx, splanchnic mesodermal elements have formed the embryonic heart.The heart is contained in a large semicircular cavity, the pericardial cavity. The thicker layer of the developing heart is the myocardium; it represents the future muscular wall of the heart. In the cavity inside the myocardium, mesodermal cells are becoming organized into the continuous endothelial lining of the heart known as the endocardium. The outer thin layer of the pericardial cavity comprises the future parietal wall of the adult pericardial cavity. e. Examine serial sections more posteriorly until the gut is very reduced dorsally and the rudiment of the liver is visible as a fingerlike evagination of the ventral wall of the foregut.The liver diverticulum extends into the yolk mass (fig. 5.8 e). Consult figure 5.7 again in order to clarify the physical relationship between the anterior portion of the gut and the liver rudiment. On either side of the notochord, the dorsal mesoderm has segmented to form the somites. Notice the double-layered condition of the lateral mesoderm: the outer layer adjacent to the ectoderm is the somatic mesoderm, while the inner layer adjacent to the endoderm is the splanchnic layer. The cavity between these two layers is the coelom. Between the dorsal mesoderm (somite) and the lateral mesoderm is an area known as the intermediate mesoderm, or nephrotome (sometimes also called mesomeric mesoderm). At this stage, the intermediate mesoderm has enlarged and differentiated into the pronephros, the functional kidney of the larva.The pronephric duct, with its hollow cavity, may also be identifiable. Far posteriorly, locate the proctodaeum, which originates as a ventral invagination of the epidermal ectoderm.
Dissection of the 11-mm Embryo (Stage 25) During stages 23 to 25, a fold of integument, the opercular fold, grows back to enclose and cover the external gills on each side. This is completed sooner on the right side (stage 24) than on the left side (stage 25). The resulting gill chamber remains in communication with the exterior through a single, short funnel on the left side, known as the spiracle. The dissection described in the following for stage-25 embryos may be performed equally as well on stage 24 embryos. 1. Use a wide-mouth pipette to transfer a tadpole to the anesthetic solution. This is a 1⬊3000 solution of ethyl m-aminobenzoate methanesulfonate in either spring water or 10% Amphibian Ringer’s solution. Wait until the tadpole stops all swimming and other movements. Then test it for responsiveness to touch by gently poking it with a blunt instrument. When the tadpole shows no response to touch, transfer it to an operating dish.There should be at least enough of the anesthetic solution in the dish to prevent excessive drying. 2. Place the operating dish on the stage of a dissecting microscope and illuminate it from the side with a focusing illuminator. Turn the tadpole on its back in a shallow groove that you have prepared in your operating dish. Grasp the skin in the anal region (at the base of the tail) with two pairs of watchmaker’s forceps and tear open the ventral body wall. Observe the coiled intestine and attempt to trace its course.The tadpole feeds largely on plants and, like other herbivores, requires a large absorbing surface, provided by the long intestinal tract. Note that great length without great bulk is accomplished by the coiling of the tract into a compact spiral. Note also other abdominal structures such as the liver. Finish exposing the heart if it is not uncovered and examine it and other structures near it. 3. Return to the abdominal area and remove all digestive organs from the body cavity.You should now have exposed the dorsal aspect of the lining of the body cavity.Along the midline, you can observe the area of the developing gonads, the genital ridges (fig. 5.9). Switch your microscope to a higher magnification and carefully observe this area. The two ridges project into the coelomic cavity and are covered by coelomic epithelium (peritoneum). Note the large, light-colored protuberances on the ridges. These are primordial germ cells that have migrated into this area to colonize the gonads. 4. Make sketches of your observations on the internal anatomy of the tadpole.You may have to dissect several tadpoles in order to complete your observations on tadpole morphology.
Laboratory 5
57
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
5. Patterns of Frog Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Materials EQUIPMENT Compound microscope Dissecting microscope Illuminator Watchmaker’s forceps Operating dish (see Appendix B) “Frog pipette” SOLUTIONS
AND
CHEMICALS
Ethyl m-aminobenzoate methanesulfonate solution (1⬊3000 in spring water or 10% Amphibian Ringer’s solution) LIVING MATERIAL Stage 25 (11-mm) frog embryos COMMERCIALLY PREPARED SLIDES Frog blastula section Early gastrula sagittal section Late gastrula or yolk plug sagittal section Neural plate or early neural groove representative cross sections (rep. c.s.) Neural fold or late neural groove rep. c.s. (some companies supply slides labeled “groove-tube transition”) Early neural tube rep. c.s. Late neural tube rep. c.s. Representative longitudinal sections of 3- or 4-mm frog embryos (selected sections on a “serial sagittal sections” slide can be used as well) Serial cross sections of 3- or 4-mm frog embryos
Some Useful Information Sources WEBSITES http://zygote.swarthmore.edu/index.html This comprehensive site, assembled by Scott Gilbert, Swarthmore College, includes a good deal of information about developmental processes in amphibians and has links to other relevant sites. www.uoguelph.ca/zoology/devobio/dbindex.htm This site contains Stephen Scadding’s supplemental materials for his developmental biology course at the University of Guelph, Ontario. It includes a set of labeled cross sections of frog embryos plus other information about frog development. http://sdb.bio.purdue.edu/SDBEduca/qt_embryos1.html This site, assembled by Laurie Iten, Purdue University, contains movies of serial sections and discussion of the value of serial section study.
58
Laboratory 5
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
6. Extirpation Experiments, Transplantations, and Parabiosis
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
L A B O R A T O R Y
6 Extirpation Experiments, Transplantations, and Parabiosis
After William Roux initiated experimentation on frog embryos, other scientists undertook a variety of experimental manipulations of amphibian embryos. Some experiments involved removal (extirpation) of small parts of embryos and careful analysis of the developmental defects that resulted. Other experiments included transplantations of various parts of embryos from place to place within the embryo and even the conjoining of two entire embryos ( parabiosis). Several developmental principles emerged from these “microsurgical” manipulations of amphibian embryos. One of the most important of these is the understanding that the developmental fates of various groups of cells are not rigidly determined early in development. In many cases, if a multicellular fragment of an early frog gastrula is transplanted from one region of the embryo to another, the cells will cooperate with the surrounding cells in their new environment to produce the structures that would normally develop in that part of the embryo. Later in development, however, cells of transplanted fragments develop differently. They tend to continue along the same developmental pathways that they would have followed in their original location. They differentiate as they would have had they not been transplanted and thus produce an anomalous patch of misplaced tissue. Clearly something has happened to the cells that has definitely established (determined) their developmental fates. Many experiments in developmental biology have demonstrated that developmental commitments of cells are determined through interactions with their cellular environments. One such interaction is embryonic induction, a form of cellular communication in which one group of cells transmits a chemical signal, or set of signals, that specifically influences the differentiation of a nearby group of cells.The induction of the lens of the eye by the optic cup is a well-known example of this phenomenon. One of the most famous series of experiments on embryonic induction employing microsurgical techniques and transplantations was performed by Hans Spemann and his brilliant (but tragically fated) student Hilde Mangold. Mangold and Spemann demonstrated the inductive role of archenteron roof tissue in organization of the main body axis in amphibians. More recent experimental analysis of amphibian development using microsurgical manipulation has focused on very early cellular interactions in amphibian embryos.Transplantation of individual cells of 64-cell stage Xenopus embryos have, among other things, clarified the developmental relationships of Spemann and Mangold’s organizer in amphibian embryos (see “Suggestions for Further Investigation” section on p. 90).
59
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
6. Extirpation Experiments, Transplantations, and Parabiosis
FIGURE 6.1 Steps in the removal of the jelly coats of the frog embryo.
FIGURE 6.2 Steps in the microsurgical removal of part of a neural fold of a frog embryo.
60
Laboratory 6
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
6. Extirpation Experiments, Transplantations, and Parabiosis
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
In this laboratory, you will have the opportunity to perform surgical manipulations on amphibian embryos. Specifically, you will attempt to (a) extirpate (surgically remove) an area of embryonic tissue, (b) transplant a piece of tissue to a new, or foreign, environment, and (c) graft two embryos together side by side. You will be using microsurgical needles and other instruments like those employed over the years in many important experiments on amphibian embryos. Techniques Extirpation of a Lateral Neural Fold This experiment consists of the extirpation (removal) of part of a single lateral neural fold from an embryo at a stage before the folds have come together (stage 14).This type of surgery is referred to as a “defect” experiment.The extirpation of one part, of course, affects the relationships of various other parts of the embryo to one another.What are the chances of survival of an embryo deprived of part of one lateral neural fold? Will a complete neural tube form from the other intact fold? Will the proliferation and invasion of cells adjacent to the wound surface restore or reconstitute the region from which tissue has been removed? 1. The operation should be done under aseptic conditions. The operating medium is Barth and Barth’s inorganic solution containing 0.1% gamma globulin.The composition of the operating medium is given in Appendix B. Perform all phases of the operation itself in Barth and Barth’s medium because it has been demonstrated to promote wound healing. After healing occurs, however, transfer the embryo to spring water or 10% Amphibian Ringer’s solution. 2. Aseptic conditions must be maintained. Before a glass needle is applied to the embryo, the tip of the needle should be dipped in 90% alcohol and then passed through a small beaker containing the operating medium. Some workers prefer to dip the glass needle in boiling water rather than in alcohol.Tungsten needles, as well as all other metal instruments, should be dipped in alcohol and then held over a flame.The stender dish, containing an agar bottom, should be covered with a sterile lid (except, of course, during the operation itself ). 3. With a wide-mouth “frog pipette,” transfer a frog embryo in the early neurula stage of development (stage 14) to an agar-bottomed stender dish containing the operating medium. Before you can operate on an embryo, you must remove its jelly coats and vitelline membrane. Use two pairs of watchmaker’s forceps and work under the low power of a dissecting microscope. Pierce the jelly envelopes with one prong of the left forceps as shown in figure 6.1. A firm grip on the jelly coat may be secured by closing the left forceps.Then, insert both prongs of the right forceps into the jelly coat, closely adjacent to the first prong. Pull the right pair of forceps in a quick motion away from the left pair of forceps.The embryo, still contained within its vitelline membrane, should “squirt” out of its ruptured jelly coats.The same procedure is used in removing the vitelline membrane—the vitelline membrane is firmly grasped with the left pair of forceps and torn apart with a quick jerk of the right pair of forceps. Afterwards, the denuded embryo must be handled carefully. 4. With a ball-tipped glass needle (or a watchmaker’s forceps), make a shallow depression in the agar in which the embryo can “sit” comfortably, dorsal side up. Using a fine-tipped glass needle, remove part of the neural fold on the right side as shown in figure 6.2.With a single complete motion, anterior to posterior, of your glass needle, make a thin tear in the pigmented epidermis very close to the outer edge of the right neural fold. Then tear carefully through the whitish mesodermal cells that lie underneath. When the grayish tan endodermal cells become visible, cut no deeper. Do not cut through these cells, which comprise the roof of the archenteron. If the roof of the archenteron is injured, discard the embryo and start anew with another embryo. Follow the first longitudinal cut or tear with a second longitudinal cut at the inner edge of the right neural fold (fig. 6.2). The subsequent two cuts are transverse cuts, anteriorly and posteriorly, to complete a rectangular area of neural fold tissue. ( Note:The epidermis has a tendency to peel away from the underlying mesoderm; care should be exercised to avoid loosening the epidermal layer.) 5. Lift the entire rectangular area of neural tissue away from the embryo with the tip of the glass needle. The excised piece should include a thick mass of whitish mesoderm with the overlying pigmented ectoderm. The grayish tan roof of the archenteron should not be punctured during the removal of the mesodermalectodermal mass.
Laboratory 6
61
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
6. Extirpation Experiments, Transplantations, and Parabiosis
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
FIGURE 6.3 Postoperative appearance of donor and host at embryonic tail-bud stage 17 (top): a conspicuous feature of the host embryo is the dome-shaped elevation in the ventral surface, the site of the neural fold implant. Self-differentiation of the neural fold graft is evident in the comparisons of the donor (a) and host (b) larvae (bottom). The host larva bears a distinctive circular mass of graft pigment cells on its ventral surface.
62
Laboratory 6
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
6. Extirpation Experiments, Transplantations, and Parabiosis
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
6. Leave the embryo in the operating medium until the wound heals over, usually within an hour.Watch the process of healing: What is the source of cells that spread over the wound surface? After complete healing, transfer the “half-fold” embryo, using a wide-mouth “frog pipette,” to spring water or 10% Amphibian Ringer’s solution in a glass dish (without agar). Maintain the embryo at cool temperatures (15°–18° C) to decrease susceptibility to bacterial infection. Allow the embryo to develop, and record observations of the external features of its development. Make comparisons with control embryos. 7. As indicated in the following, amphibian pigment is derived from the neural crest.The extirpation of one neural fold has resulted in the ablation of an appreciable supply of neural crest. Carefully examine each developing tadpole to detect any effect of neural crest removal on tadpole pigmentation. If facilities are available, rear some of the experimental animals through metamorphosis and note the possible effect on the postmetamorphic pigment pattern.
Transplantation Classic experiments by DuShane in the 1930s revealed that the neural crest elements are precursors of pigment cells.To demonstrate that the pigment cells are derived from the neural crest, we may transplant the crest material to another region of the body. Neural crest cells form a dorsally placed wedge between the lateral wall of the neural fold and the ectoderm on each side of the embryo, so the extirpation of a lateral neural fold also removes a portion of the neural crest. The lateral neural crest elements can then be implanted into the ventral (abdominal) surface of another embryo. 1. As previously described, remove the jelly coat and vitelline membrane from two embryos at stage 14. Place the two embryos, one dorsal side up (donor) and the other ventral side up ( host), in shallow, closely adjacent depressions in an agar-bottomed stender dish. The operating medium, once again, is Barth and Barth’s solution. 2. Prepare a small “pocket” in the ventral surface of the host embryo. Do not attempt to cut a rectangular piece of ventral ectoderm to receive the rectangular piece of neural fold.All that is required is a mere slit or slight hole that can be created by carefully slicing the abdominal ectoderm with the glass needle. The pocket can be enlarged to receive the transplant by carefully removing some of the mesoderm cells with the tip of the glass needle. 3. After you have prepared the host, use the same procedures employed in the preceding section to extirpate part of one lateral neural fold from the right side of the donor embryo. 4. Transfer the neural fold transplant on the tip of the glass needle to the ventral slit, or pocket, of the recipient embryo. It is not necessary to orient the transplant in any particular direction. Gently, yet firmly, push the whole mass through the narrow incision and anchor it against the yolk. It may be necessary to enlarge the pocket slightly to accommodate the transplant, but a tight-fitting transplant is desirable. 5. Once the implant has been pushed into the slit, quickly cover it with the flat surface of a piece from a thin-grade coverslip.The weight of the coverslip should hold the implanted tissue in place. 6. After an hour, the piece of coverslip should be carefully removed. If the transplant has not healed properly, place it under pressure again, with a piece of coverslip, for an additional half hour.After healing is complete, transfer both the donor and the host embryos to a glass dish containing spring water or 10% Amphibian Ringer’s solution. 7. Observe the differentiation of the implanted tissue using figure 6.3 as a guide. You will observe that in the early postoperative stage (stage 18), the relatively bulky implant becomes evident externally as a moderate bulge that will flatten, and the graft will become the center of a circular patch of chromatophores, especially melanophores.The melanophore-laden patch will stand in sharp contrast to the silvery adjacent areas of the host. If you examine the differentiated graft under a dissecting microscope, you will see that the circular graft area has all the aspects of a transparent piece of dorsal skin.
Laboratory 6
63
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
6. Extirpation Experiments, Transplantations, and Parabiosis
FIGURE 6.4 Dorsal (a) and ventral (b) views of two tail-bud-stage embryos joined in their developing gill regions.
FIGURE 6.5 Postmetamorphic parabiotic frogs that were united at the tail-bud stage of embryonic development.
64
Laboratory 6
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
6. Extirpation Experiments, Transplantations, and Parabiosis
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Parabiosis Biologists have been able to take advantage of the remarkable healing powers of amphibian embryos to fuse the cut surfaces of fragments of embryos and produce a variety of artificially combined embryos. It has even proven possible to fuse the front half of one embryo with the rear half of another. Many experiments, however, have involved fusion of two entire embryos in order to produce a parabiotic union in which the two circulatory systems communicate. In grafting two embryos together, various attachments can be made: back-to-back, front-to-front, and side-to-side. However, the most satisfactory position is side-to-side, since this union interferes least with feeding and permits more normal activity. The most suitable time for this operation is shortly after the closure of the neural folds, when the tail bud is well formed (stage 17). Fine glass needles are used for cutting, and the operation is performed under a dissecting microscope. 1. Prepare two grooves in an agar-bottomed stender dish containing the operating medium: the first should be a shallow depression in which an embryo can be placed on its lateral surface.The second groove should be a deep rectangular depression with steep vertical walls, constructed so that the two embryos can fit tightly together (fig. 6.4).The first depression is to be used in creating the wound surfaces in the gill regions of each of the two embryos; the second depression is to be used to hold the two embryos together. 2. After the necessary grooves have been prepared, obtain two embryos in the tail-bud stage of development and remove the jelly coats and vitelline membrane from each. The removal of the membranes should be done in a separate dish, not in the operating dish. 3. Transfer the denuded pair of embryos to the operating dish. With each embryo, in turn, placed right or left side up in the shallow depression, use a glass needle to remove an oval area of ectoderm from the right gill region of one embryo and from the left gill region of the other.The extirpated area should cover the entire protuberance of the gill plate. Care should be exercised to avoid cutting the pronephric swelling just posterior to the gill plate.The wounds in both embryos should be approximately the same size and shape. 4. The cut surfaces will tend to heal rapidly, so immediately after the patches of gill ectoderm have been removed, slip the two embryos into the rectangular depression with the cut surfaces pressed together.The embryos should be dorsal side down and should fit so tightly together that the wound surfaces are in intimate contact.The abdomens of the pair of embryos should protrude slightly above the surface of the rectangular depression.Apply a piece of thin coverslip on top of the pair of embryos.The weight of the coverslip should flatten the abdomens of the embryos, preventing them from moving out of position (recall that beating cilia move embryos at this stage). 5. Wound healing occurs within 3 to 5 hours. After healing is accomplished, remove the piece of coverslip and gently lift the pair out of the depression. With a wide-mouth pipette, transfer the conjoined pair to a finger bowl containing spring water or 10% Amphibian Ringer’s solution. Make frequent observations on the developing embryos and keep the pair alive as long as you can. Fused individuals have actually been reared through metamorphosis to adulthood (fig. 6.5).
Laboratory 6
65
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
6. Extirpation Experiments, Transplantations, and Parabiosis
Materials EQUIPMENT Glass microsurgical needles Watchmaker’s forceps Agar-bottom operating dishes (see Appendix B) with lids Ball-tipped glass needle (optional) Wide-mouth “frog pipette” Dissecting microscope Illuminator Pieces of thin-grade coverslips SOLUTIONS
AND
CHEMICALS
Barth and Barth’s operating medium Spring water or 10% Amphibian Ringer’s solution 90% ethyl alcohol LIVING MATERIAL Stage-14 Rana pipiens embryos (for extirpation and transplantation experiments) Stage-17 Rana pipiens embryos (for parabiosis experiment)
66
Laboratory 6
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
7. Dissociation and Reaggregation of Amphibian Embryonic Cells
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
L A B O R A T O R Y
7 Dissociation and Reaggregation of Amphibian Embryonic Cells
Many developmental studies have concentrated on the behavior of individual cells that have been isolated from their normal tissue relationships through various dissociation techniques. An early report of such work was H.V.Wilson’s (1907 ) study of the reaggregation of dissociated sponge cells. He found that sponges could be cut up and squeezed through cheesecloth to separate individual cells from one another and from skeletal material.These isolated individual cells moved about actively on the floor of seawater-containing vessels and aggregated into clumps of cells. The clumps ultimately underwent internal reorganization and differentiation to form functional miniature sponges. Johannes Holtfreter and his coworkers conducted a series of experiments in the 1940s and 1950s on the behavior of amphibian cells dissociated from embryos at early developmental stages.They found that dissociated amphibian cells also moved about and reaggregated into clusters, and they observed further that there was continuing cell movement within these reaggregated clusters.This movement resulted in a sorting of cells that ended with specific cell types localized in specific areas of the aggregates.They concluded that this sorting behavior of various cell types was based upon the tissue type or embryonic area from which the cells originally came.They called this tissue-type sorting process “selective affinity.” In the 1950s, Aron Moscona and his colleagues extended research on dissociation and reaggregation of embryonic cells to embryos of homeothermic vertebrates.Their work on chick and mouse embryos contributed a great deal to our understanding of behavioral properties of embryonic cells. For instance, they reported that cells dissociated during early stages of organ formation sorted out in reaggregates and participated in further development with other cells on the basis of tissue type rather than on the basis of species.They found chick cartilage cells reaggregated readily with mouse cartilage cells and cooperated in the production of a cartilage with the two cell types randomly dispersed in a common, continuous matrix. On the other hand, a mixture of chick cartilage and chick liver cells resulted in aggregates in which there was sorting into discrete cartilage and liver areas without any apparent intermingling of cell types. Malcolm Steinberg and his colleagues explored the cellular basis of the sorting that occurs within reaggregates and proposed a quantitative, thermodynamic model for cell sorting involving differential cell surface binding strengths. More recent investigations on cell surface properties by Gerald Edelman and his colleagues have helped to refocus these questions of cell affinities on the development of the intact embryo. They have established the existence of cell adhesion molecules (CAMs) that are tissuetype specific and that appear to be important for the assembly of the precise cell-to-cell contacts that are necessary for normal morphogenesis in developing embryos. References to various studies of dissociated cells and to research on cell surface properties of developing cells are cited in “Suggestions for Further Investigation” on page 90.
67
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
Notes and Observations
68
Laboratory 7
7. Dissociation and Reaggregation of Amphibian Embryonic Cells
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
7. Dissociation and Reaggregation of Amphibian Embryonic Cells
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
In this laboratory, we will examine basic aspects of reaggregation by dissociated cells of amphibian embryos. Amphibian cells are easier to work with than cells of homeothermic vertebrates ( birds and mammals). Amphibian cells have a much broader range of temperature tolerance, and because of their yolk content, they need not be provided with elaborate nutrient-containing media that also provide good potential growth conditions for a variety of bacteria and molds. You will employ a modified version of a culture technique developed by K.W. Jones and T. R. Elsdale in the 1960s. Jones and Elsdale obtained good reaggregation and, later, differentiation, using Steinberg’s physiological salt solution, supplemented with serum protein, to culture dissociated frog embryo cells. Egg albumin has been found to be an adequate substitute for the serum proteins and will be used in your medium. Techniques Dissociation of Embryonic Cells 1. Obtain a cluster of frog embryos in the late blastula, or very early gastrula, stage of development. With forceps, remove one embryo from the cluster and immerse it in 70% ethyl alcohol for 5 seconds only. This treatment will reduce the number of surface bacteria adhering to the jelly coats without adversely affecting the embryo. Immediately rinse off the alcohol by dipping the embryo in sterile Steinberg’s solution and then transfer the embryo to another container of Steinberg’s solution. 2. Before the cells of an embryo can be dissociated, it is necessary to remove the jelly coats around the embryo. You may remove the jelly coats and vitelline membrane with watchmaker’s forceps as described in Laboratory 6 (refer again to fig. 6.1). It is often preferable, however, to remove the jelly coats from the embryo using the “hand” method, rolling an egg around the palm of one hand. Carefully swab your hands with 70% alcohol and allow them to dry before handling eggs. Place an individual embryo cut loose from the egg mass on the palm of one hand.Then using either a forceps or the index finger of the other hand, gently roll the egg around in your palm.The jelly coats will stick to your hand, and you will be able to remove most of the jelly by continued careful rolling.You will get the knack and develop your own techniques by the second or third attempt. It is also possible to use embryos that have been chemically dejelled (see Laboratory 9). 3. Use a wide-mouth “frog pipette” to transfer the embryo to a small volume (2–3 ml) of dissociating (disaggregating) medium in a small container.This medium is Steinberg’s solution minus calcium and magnesium ions and contains 30 mg of EDTA (versene) per liter. If you use the hand dejelling technique or use embryos that have been chemically dejelled, you will need to break the vitelline membrane after this transfer. Sometimes it is helpful to hold the embryo steady by applying very gentle suction with a Pasteur pipette. With the embryo thus held in place, it is relatively easy to tear the vitelline membrane open with a watchmaker’s forceps.The cells of the embryo should begin to fall apart within a short time, but the process can be aided by gentle manipulation with watchmaker’s forceps or by gently squirting the cells and cell clumps in and out of a Pasteur pipette.
Preparation of Cultures 1. Dissociated cells can be collected from the bottom of the dissociating vessel with a clean Pasteur pipette. A washing step in which the cells are transferred to fresh Steinberg’s solution may be inserted at this point, or the cells may be transferred directly to reaggregating medium in a flat-bottom well slide or to reaggregating medium on a coverslip in a small Stender dish or a 60-mm petri dish.Transfer just enough cells to give a rather sparse scattering of cells on the culture floor. Set up as many cultures as you can with the cells that are available. 2. If you use well slides, set a coverslip over the top of each of them. Prewetting the coverslips by dipping them in Steinberg’s solution will help to prevent the fogging that interferes with later observations.Another method for fogging prevention is to fill each well completely so that the coverslip actually touches the medium. Drying will be prevented if you place a thin coat of vaseline around the rim of the well before putting the coverslip in place. Set the preparation on the stage of a compound microscope and focus the scanning objective on the cells. Try to disturb the cultures as little as possible during subsequent observations. If enough microscopes are available, set up several cultures on the stages of different compound microscopes. You can even observe additional cultures set on the stage of a dissecting microscope.This will be a less satisfactory way to observe cell behavior, but you may be able to detect reaggregation in these cultures also. In all cases, prevent overheating of the cultures by turning on microscope lamps or illuminators only when you are making observations.You may need to dissociate several embryos in order to set up the number of cultures that you want.
Laboratory 7
69
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
Notes and Observations
70
Laboratory 7
7. Dissociation and Reaggregation of Amphibian Embryonic Cells
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
7. Dissociation and Reaggregation of Amphibian Embryonic Cells
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Analysis of Results 1. Observe the process of reaggregation during the next few hours.Watch for several specific aspects of cell activity. Internal cytoplasmic streaming, cyclosis, is frequently observed in dissociated cells, as is the extension of cell surface protrusions. Watch for cell movement and the organization of cell clusters. Sometimes linear clumps, or chains of cells, form as a stage of reaggregation prior to the formation of spherical clusters.You may consider reaggregation to be complete when smooth, dark clusters have been formed. 2. Record the events of reaggregation, including various cellular activities. Note the stages and time progression of the process, as well as any other observations that you might make. One technique for recording results might be to sketch microscope fields of view at various time intervals. 3. You may elect to maintain your cultures for several days in an attempt to observe cell differentiation over a period of time. Maintain the cultures at room temperature and avoid contamination by covering the microscope with a shield of transparent plastic sheeting. After 5 or 6 days, you might be able to observe evidence of histological differentiation of some cells. However, such observations usually require that the reaggregates be fixed, sectioned, and stained for histological examination.
Materials EQUIPMENT Watchmaker’s forceps Wide-mouth “frog pipette” Clean, disposable Pasteur pipettes Glass well culture slides ( plastic culture slides or coverslips set in Stender dishes or small petri dishes may be substituted—see Techniques section) Coverslips Dissecting microscope Illuminator Compound microscopes SOLUTIONS
AND
CHEMICALS
70% ethyl alcohol Steinberg’s solution Disaggregating solution Reaggregating solution containing 1% egg white LIVING MATERIAL Late blastula or early gastrula frog embryos (see Techniques sections in Laboratory 4 and Laboratory 6)
Laboratory 7
71
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
7. Dissociation and Reaggregation of Amphibian Embryonic Cells
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
8. The Primordial Germ Cells of the Frog
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
L A B O R A T O R Y
8 The Primordial Germ Cells of the Frog
Late in the nineteenth century, August Weismann proposed that an organism consists of two discrete portions—a germ plasm that functions as a hereditary vehicle and is passed on from one generation to the next, and the remainder of the organism’s body that provides a supporting environment for the germ plasm during the individual’s lifetime. Weismann’s historically interesting concept focused biologists’ attention on the primordial germ cells, the forerunners of eggs and sperm, and provided an important stimulus for the initial attempts to elucidate their development before they can be detected in the developing gonads of vertebrate embryos. In the cases of several vertebrates (and some invertebrates as well), it was discovered that the antecedents of the primordial germ cells had their origins outside the developing gonads and that the cytoplasm later incorporated into primordial germ cells could be identified as early as the two-cell stage. In 1934, Bounoure traced the developmental history of the germ cells of the European frog, Rana temporaria. A specific portion of the cortical cytoplasm in the vegetal hemisphere that has an affinity for certain specific stains was designated the “germ plasm” because it subsequently becomes localized in the primordial germ cells. In the 1950s, Blackler exploited the unique staining response of this germ plasm to the stain Azure A to make more detailed observations of the origin and migration of primordial germ cells. As the cleavage period of frog development comes to an end, this specially staining cytoplasm, with its RNA-rich granules, is located in cells in the blastocoel floor.These cells later leave this endodermal location and migrate to the developing gonads. In the 1980s, additional data were obtained regarding both the very early developmental history of the germ plasm and the mechanisms by which the primordial germ cells make their way from the gut to the developing gonad (see the “Suggestions for Further Investigation” section on p. 91). A series of experiments involving surgical removal or ultraviolet irradiation established that removal, or destructive inactivation, of a specific portion of the vegetal hemisphere of the zygote results in the formation of gonads that lack primordial germ cells. The fundamental experiments that determined the dosages of U V radiation needed to produce sterile gonads and the action spectra of various wavelengths of U V light were reported by L. D. Smith in 1966. This laboratory is designed to repeat some of Smith’s U V irradiation experiments.
73
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
Notes and Observations
74
Laboratory 8
8. The Primordial Germ Cells of the Frog
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
8. The Primordial Germ Cells of the Frog
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Fortunately, experimental effects on primordial germ cell development can be determined by direct visual observation of the genital ridge of the stage-25 tadpole.The primordial germ cells appear as distinct, light-colored protuberances (fig. 8.1) that can be observed with a dissecting microscope. It is relatively easy to assess the results of experiments affecting the quantity of germ cells in the developing gonads simply by dissecting the tadpole at stage 25. Techniques Irradiation 1. Obtain frog gametes using techniques that you have used previously and proceed with fertilization.When the eggs have been flooded with fresh spring water or 10% Amphibian Ringer’s solution (15–20 minutes after fertilization), work quickly to remove the jelly coats that surround them.The jelly coats must be removed since they might absorb UV radiation strongly enough to prevent it from reaching the egg. It is possible to dissect the jelly coats from the egg by careful manipulation under the dissecting microscope with two pairs of watchmaker’s forceps. For an inexperienced worker, however, this is often a frustrating and tedious task and might take more time than you can afford in this experiment.An alternative technique is to place an individual egg, cut loose from the egg mass, on the palm of one hand.Then use either a forceps or the index finger of the other hand to roll the egg around your hand gently.The jelly coat will stick to your hand, and by careful movement of the egg, you will be able to get most of the jelly off in a short time. You will get the knack and develop your own techniques by the second or third attempt. Quickly place dejellied eggs in a separate container of spring water. Discard any eggs that appear to be ruptured or damaged in any other way. Dejelly as many eggs as you can during a period of 30 minutes, inspect them under the dissecting microscope, and discard, or repeat dejellying, those with significant amounts of jelly remaining. 2. With a wide-mouth “frog pipette,” transfer several dejellied eggs to a quartz microscope slide that you have prepared in advance. (Quartz permits passage of much more UV radiation than glass does.) The slide should have a very thin roll of modeling clay at each end. Permit the eggs to rotate so that the vegetal hemispheres are downward, and then remove most of the water from the slide with a Pasteur pipette or some absorbent material. Place a second slide on top of the first. Flatten the eggs between the two slides by exerting firm but gentle pressure on the upper slide over the rolls of modeling clay. Do not press so hard that the eggs rupture! This flattening will keep the eggs from rotating if you should need to invert the slides. Slight flattening also permits more even irradiation of one hemisphere and reduces the amount of water (which would also absorb UV radiation) intervening between the egg and the slide surface. 3. Make certain that proper safety precautions have been taken in arranging the UV source for your experiments.The UV source should be set up behind a glass barrier. It is convenient, for example, to place the lamp inside a fume hood. Make certain that your skin and eyes are protected at all times, even if the lamp is well shielded, and be careful in positioning slides for irradiation or in removing them after exposure. 4. All experiments on irradiation of the vegetal pole should be accompanied by appropriate control experiments in which the animal hemispheres of other eggs receive an equal dose of radiation. Slides should be placed horizontally below (or above) the UV source, depending upon its positioning. Irradiate either the vegetal hemisphere (experimental group) or the animal hemisphere (control group). If the supply of quartz slides is limited, the second slide in each preparation may be an ordinary glass slide. However, always make certain, both for experimentals and controls, that the portion of the eggs to be irradiated is adjacent to a quartz slide. 5. The dosage of UV radiation received by the eggs will be a function of exposure time and distance from the UV source. Smith (1966) reported that dosages of about 15,000 erg /mm2 of UV irradiation caused depletion of germ cells without causing obviously abnormal development or significant mortality.As there are various types of UV sources, conduct several experimental trials with your particular UV source varying the times and distances widely.This is especially important to do if equipment for measuring UV output is not available.With a Mineralite lamp or a 15-watt germicidal lamp mounted in a fluorescent fixture, for example, a good initial trial dose of irradiation would be a 15-minute exposure at a distance of 45 cm.
Laboratory 8
75
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
(a)
8. The Primordial Germ Cells of the Frog
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
(b)
FIGURE 8.1 Tadpoles fused in parabiotic union in experiments of E. P. Volpe and S. Curtis designed to test the possibility that amphibian primordial germ cells migrate via the circulation as they do in chick embryos. (a) Unirradiated parabionts at Shumway stage 25; both embryos possess two conspicuous rows of whitish, large primordial germ cells (indicated by arrows). (b) Irradiated embryo (right ), devoid of primordial germ cells, joined to an unirradiated embryo (left ), having two prominent rows of germ cells.
Notes and Observations
76
Laboratory 8
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
8. The Primordial Germ Cells of the Frog
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
6. After irradiation, place the eggs in spring water (or 10% Amphibian Ringer’s solution) and allow them to develop to stage 25 (see fig. 4.5). At this stage, the primordial germ cells, if present, can be observed in dissected tadpoles as light-colored bodies clustered on the genital ridges, which are a pair of elevated longitudinal bands of tissue along the dorsal wall of the body cavity (fig. 8.1).The genital ridges are easily observed after the viscera of an anesthetized tadpole have been removed.
Analysis of Results 1. Record the protocol of your experiment. Include data on time from fertilization to irradiation for each group of eggs. It is also very useful to record data on time from fertilization to first cleavage for each group, because such data permit you to describe the time of irradiation as a function of the total fertilization-to-cleavage period.This makes it easier to compare the outcomes of different experiments in which temperature differences or other unavoidable variations in experimental conditions might otherwise complicate comparisons and conclusions. 2. Record data on stages of developmental arrest in those embryos that die. Are there differences between control and experimental embryos in the total numbers of developmental arrests or the stages at which they occur? Are there differences from the other groups of embryos that you have observed earlier? 3. Prepare a table that includes results in terms of germ cell quantities related to UV dosages (either measured and calculated dosages or your distance and exposure time data). Designations such as “many” (or “normal?”), “some,”“few,” and “none” (or “sterile?”) probably will be necessary because exact numbers of germ cells are often difficult to determine.
Materials EQUIPMENT Wooden-handled probe (dissecting needle) Scissors and forceps for dissection Disposable Pasteur pipettes, other clean pipettes, or medicine droppers Petri dishes Clean scalpel or section lifter Watchmaker’s forceps 4-inch finger bowls or other containers for developing eggs Wide-mouth “frog pipettes” Quartz microscope slides and clean glass microscope slides Dissecting microscope Illuminator UV radiation source SOLUTIONS
AND
CHEMICALS
Spring water or 10% Amphibian Ringer’s solution (see Appendix B) Modeling clay Ethyl m-aminobenzoate methanesulfonate solution (1⬊3000 in spring water or in 10% Amphibian Ringer’s solution) LIVING MATERIAL Pituitary-injected female Rana pipiens Male Rana pipiens
Laboratory 8
77
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
8. The Primordial Germ Cells of the Frog
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
9. Experimenting with Xenopus Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
L A B O R A T O R Y
9 Experimenting with Xenopus Development
The African clawed frog, Xenopus laevis, has been the subject of a great deal of research on vertebrate development, especially in investigations of cellular interactions in cell differentiation specification during establishment of basic body patterns. For many reasons, Xenopus is also being used increasingly in developmental biology teaching laboratories. Xenopus adults are hardy and easy to maintain, and they are responsive at all times of the year to hormonal stimulation of reproductive activity. Xenopus can be reared in captivity in great numbers, and its use can relieve demand on wild frogs whose populations appear to be in decline in some areas (see p. 238). Development of Xenopus embryos proceeds more rapidly than that of Rana pipiens, so more aspects of development can be observed in a shorter time, although Xenopus’ rapid development can result in some early developmental stages being missed. This laboratory includes basic techniques for working with Xenopus embryos and several experiments on developmental processes in Xenopus. Cleavage and gastrulation stages of Xenopus superficially resemble those of Rana pipiens (shown on p. 47), but Xenopus development proceeds more rapidly (compare table 9.1 with table 4.1, p. 39), and there are developmental differences between the species in some processes such as specific cell movements during gastrulation. As development continues, Xenopus embryos and tadpoles come to differ more noticeably from those of Rana pipiens. Selected normal stages of Xenopus development are illustrated in figure 9.1. Xenopus tadpoles hover steadily in the water and filter out small food particles. This feeding behavior is in marked contrast to Rana pipiens tadpoles, which attach and feed by rasping material off plant surfaces. If you wish to feed Xenopus tadpoles and observe continuing development, consult Appendix C for sources of more information on methods.
IN VITRO FERTILIZATION Some observations of Xenopus embryos and experiments of Xenopus development can be conducted with embryos obtained from matings of hormonally stimulated Xenopus pairs, but others require access to zygotes shortly after fertilization or the availability of a number of embryos at the same stage of development.These latter needs can be met by in vitro fertilization techniques similar to those described for use with Rana pipiens in Laboratory 4.
79
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
(a) Stage 5 1.5 mm
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
9. Experimenting with Xenopus Development
(b) Stage 7 1.5 mm
(c) Stage 111//2 1.5 mm
(d) Stage 17 1.6 mm
(e) Stage 26 3.0–3.3 mm
(f) Stage 35/36 5.3–6.0 mm
(g) Stage 45 8–10 mm
(h) Stage 51 28–36 mm
(i)
St. 48
St. 49
St. 50
St. 51
St. 52
St. 53
St. 54
FIGURE 9.1 Selected Nieuwkoop and Faber stages in the development of the African clawed frog, Xenopus laevis. Ages given are approximate times required to reach the various stages at room temperature (22–24° C). Measurement of greatest dimension is given for each stage because the embryos are drawn at several different scales. (a) Stage 5: Age 2 3/4 hr. Advanced 16-cell stage. Vegetal pole cells (macromeres) are completely separated by cleavage grooves. (b) Stage 7: Age 4 hr. Early (large cell) blastula. (c) Stage 11 1/2: Age 11 3/4 hr. The large yolk plug is almost completely circular. Its diameter is about one-third the diameter of the entire embryo. (d ) Stage 17: Age 18 3/4 hr. Late neural fold stage. Anterior, lateral enlargements of the neural folds are eye rudiments. (e) Stage 26: Age 1 day, 5 1/2 hr. First muscular contractions produce movements. Eyes and auditory vesicles protrude, gill area is distinctly grooved, and pronephric kidney rudiment is visible. Myotomes are evident, indicating segmental muscle development. (f ) Stage 35/36: Age 2 days, 2 hr. Beginning of hatching. Pigment cells (melanophores) are visible on the back, the heart has been beating for several hours, and gill rudiments are visible. (g) Stage 45: Age 4 days, 2 hr. Feeding begins. Tentacle rudiments are present and the operculum partly covers the gills. The intestine is coiled with one and one-half revolutions. (h) Stage 51: Age about 17 days. Swimming, feeding tadpole. Hind-limb bud is conical in shape; its length is about one and one-half times its breadth. Forelimb bud appears oval in lateral views. (i ) Sketches of the structure of the hind limbs at several stages up to stage 54 (about 26 days after fertilization).
80
Laboratory 9
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
9. Experimenting with Xenopus Development
TABLE 9.1 Xenopus Development at 22 to 24° C Stage*
Description
Approximate Age in Hours
1 2 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 22 24 28 35/36 45 53 58
Fertilization 2-cell 4-cell 16-cell Large cell blastula Small cell blastula Horseshoe-shaped blastopore Slit blastopore Early neural fold Late neural fold Neural tube 1-day Muscular response Transparent outer fin Hatching Feeding Paddle limbs Forelimb eruption
0 1.5 2 2.75 4 7 11.75 14.75 17.5 18.75 20.75 24 26.25 32.5 50 98 576 (24 Days) 1056 (44 Days)
*Stages after Nieuwkoop and Faber (1956).
Techniques 1. Obtain a female Xenopus that has been injected with human chorionic gonadotropin. Use the stripping technique described on page 37 to see if she is releasing eggs. 2. If you have a female that is releasing eggs, dissect one testis from a humanely sacrificed male Xenopus (see p. 35). ( Wrap the male frog in wet paper towel and place it in the refrigerator so that the second testis will be available for subsequent use.) Clean the testis by rolling it on a piece of paper towel.Then place it in a watch glass or a very small finger bowl with about 10 ml of diluted Amphibian Ringer’s solution. Macerate the testis with clean forceps or dissecting needles. 3. Wait for about 5 minutes to allow sperm to become active. Strip eggs from the female into a petri dish that has previously been rinsed with dilute Ringer’s solution. Pipette several ml of the sperm suspension over the eggs.To assure complete exposure to sperm, draw up the sperm suspension in the pipette and spread it over them again. Repeat this procedure two or three times during the next 5 minutes. Record the time of initial insemination as the time of fertilization. 4. Fifteen minutes after insemination, flood the petri dish with diluted Amphibian Ringer’s solution. Zygotes can now be transferred to other containers for observation or experimental manipulation.
Materials EQUIPMENT Dissecting microscope and illuminator Compound microscope Wooden-handled probe (dissecting needle) for pithing Scissors and forceps for dissection Watchmaker’s forceps Watch glasses or small finger bowls Petri dishes “Frog pipette” Pasteur pipettes Finger bowls or other rearing dishes
Laboratory 9
81
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
Notes and Observations
82
Laboratory 9
9. Experimenting with Xenopus Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
SOLUTIONS
AND
II. Amphibian Development
9. Experimenting with Xenopus Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
CHEMICALS
Diluted (10%) Amphibian Ringer’s solution LIVING MATERIAL Hormonally stimulated female and male Xenopus
EXPERIMENTING WITH PRECLEAVAGE PROCESSES Subcortical cytoplasmic rotation, which occurs after sperm entry, is a key event in embryonic axis specification. Inductive interactions critical for axis determination do not occur normally if this rotation is disrupted by treatments such as altered gravity relationships, chilling, increased atmospheric pressure, or UV radiation. Subcortical rotation is accomplished by the action of microtubules. Normal microtubule assembly and microtubule-powered cytoplasmic motility can be disrupted by chilling because these processes are very temperature sensitive. In this experiment, eggs are chilled during the critical period after insemination when these cytoplasmic movements are occurring. For more information, consult Scharf and Gerhart (1983) cited on page 93 in “Suggestions for Further Investigation of Amphibian Development.” Techniques 1. Before fertilization, prepare 100-ml beakers containing about 40 ml of chilled (1–2° C) diluted Amphibian Ringer’s solution. These beakers may have been in a controlled temperature chamber long enough to come to temperature, or they may have been in water in a larger container set in an ice-water bath. Check the temperature of the chilled Ringer’s solution before proceeding with fertilization. 2. Proceed with in vitro fertilization and maintain the eggs in diluted Amphibian Ringer’s solution at room temperature until 50 to 60 minutes after insemination. 3. Pipette a few eggs into chilled, diluted Ringer’s solution and leave them in place for 4 minutes. 4. Carefully remove the beakers from the chamber or bath. If you have two beakers with chilled eggs, allow one to warm gradually to room temperature.Warm the eggs in the other beaker quickly by carefully pouring off the chilled dilute Ringer’s solution and replacing it with room temperature dilute Ringer’s solution. If you have only one experimental beaker, choose one of these methods of warming. 5. When the Ringer’s solution has come to room temperature, cover the beakers to prevent excessive evaporation. Your instructor may suggest that you carefully transfer the eggs to appropriate rearing dishes for observations of further development. Place unchilled control embryos in similar dishes adjacent to the dishes containing the experimentally chilled embryos.
Observations 1. Examine both the experimental and control embryos frequently over the next 2 or 3 days. 2. Pay particular attention to development of axial structures, such as neural tube and somites. Compare heads of experimental and control embryos. Are there tail abnormalities in the experimental embryos? Are there any embryos that develop as largely disorganized masses of cells? Is there evidence of swelling that might indicate fluid accumulation (edema)? 3. Continue to make comparisons between experimental and control embryos, at least until there are hatched, swimming tadpoles among the controls.
Materials EQUIPMENT Dissecting microscope and illuminator “Frog pipette” 100-ml beakers
Laboratory 9
83
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
9. Experimenting with Xenopus Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Finger bowls or other rearing containers Ice bucket or other container for chilling diluted saline solution or temperature-controlled chamber set at 1–2° C SOLUTIONS
AND
CHEMICALS
Diluted (10%) Amphibian Ringer’s solution LIVING MATERIAL Xenopus zygotes just after fertilization (see p. 81 for materials needed)
CHEMICAL METHOD FOR EGG JELLY REMOVAL A number of experimental treatments require removal of the jelly coats around eggs at the time of ovulation.A mechanical technique for jelly removal was described on page 61.There are several chemical treatments for jelly removal, one of which is described in the following. Techniques 1. Fifteen minutes after insemination, transfer the eggs to be dejellied to a 100-ml beaker containing about 40 ml of a 2% solution of cysteine HCl in diluted Amphibian Ringer’s solution. 2. At half-minute intervals, gently swirl the eggs and observe them with a dissecting microscope.As the jelly coats are removed, the eggs come to lie closer together.The time required to remove jelly coats varies among egg batches, but usually is between 2 and 7 or 8 minutes. Begin rinsing the eggs just before the jelly is completely removed because the cysteine HCl will continue to act during the first rinse, and excessive treatment, which will damage the eggs, must be avoided. Gently pour off the cysteine HCl solution and add diluted Ringer’s solution. Gently swirl the beaker, pour off this solution, and add fresh diluted Ringer’s. Repeat this washing procedure at least once more, but be gentle in handling the eggs, as they are no longer protected from damage by their jelly coats. 3. The dejellied eggs are now ready for observation and experimentation. 4. This technique can also be applied to developing embryos through cleavage and early gastrulation stages if done with great care.
Materials EQUIPMENT 100-ml beakers “Frog pipette” Finger bowls or other rearing containers Dissecting microscope and illuminator SOLUTIONS
AND
CHEMICALS
Diluted (10%) Amphibian Ringer’s solution 2% Cysteine HCl in diluted Amphibian Ringer’s solution (pH adjusted to 7.8 with NaOH ) LIVING MATERIAL Xenopus zygotes just after fertilization (see p. 81 for materials needed)
LITHIUM AND PATTERN FORMATION It has been known for many years that early developmental processes in a number of animals are disrupted by exposure to lithium ions.The nature of cellular responses to lithium has been investigated only more recently, and it now seems clear that lithium interferes with some cell signaling processes. In amphibian embryos, it appears that lithium ions alter the specificity of the cells’ responses to inductive signals, particularly in the specification of various mesodermal regions. Dorsal, axial structures
84
Laboratory 9
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
9. Experimenting with Xenopus Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
develop from cells that would otherwise contribute to ventral structures.These alterations can have dramatic effects on the establishment of body patterns. In this experiment, early Xenopus embryos will be exposed to lithium ions. Techniques 1. Embryos used in this experiment should have their jelly removed but remain inside their vitelline membranes.The embryos may be ones that have been chemically dejellied or ones that have been dejellied mechanically (see p. 61). 2. Pipette dejellied embryos into a 0.3 M LiCl solution in a 100-ml beaker. The embryos should have between 32 and 128 cells (embryos between stage 5 and stage 7, p. 80) if possible. ( Exposure of later blastula-stage embryos gives interesting, but quite different, results if the only embryos you have available are more advanced.) 3. Leave the embryos in the LiCl solution for 6 to 8 minutes if they have been chemically dejellied or for 12 to 15 minutes if they were mechanically dejellied. 4. Wash the embryos by gently pouring off the LiCl solution and replacing it with diluted Amphibian Ringer’s solution. Repeat the washing twice more by pouring off the medium and replacing it with fresh diluted Ringer’s solution. 5. Gently transfer the treated embryos and appropriate control embryos to rearing dishes where they can be maintained for further observation.
Observations 1. Examine both the experimental and control embryos frequently over the next 2 or 3 days. For information and guidance, consult Kao et al. (1986), Kao and Elinson (1988), and Kao and Danilchik (1991), cited on page 92 in “Suggestions for Further Investigation of Amphibian Development.” 2. Pay particular attention to any tendency for dorsal and anterior structures to be more prominent than usual, relative to posterior and ventral structures. In other words, watch for exaggerated head development and stunted tail development. Watch also for swelling indicative of fluid accumulation (edema). 3. Continue your comparisons between experimental and control embryos until there are hatched, swimming tadpoles among the controls.
Materials EQUIPMENT Dissecting microscope and illuminator 100-ml beakers Finger bowls or other rearing containers SOLUTIONS
AND
CHEMICALS
Diluted (10%) Amphibian Ringer’s solution 0.3 M LiCl in diluted Amphibian Ringer’s solution LIVING MATERIAL Dejellied Xenopus embryos, preferably having between 32 and 128 cells (embryos between stage 5 and stage 7). If embryos are obtained from a mated pair, sort embryos to find some at appropriate stages.
INHIBITING GASTRULATION WITH TRYPAN BLUE The effects of the polysulfonated dye Trypan Blue on vertebrate development were first discovered in investigations of teratological agents, that is, substances that cause grossly abnormal development. Trypan Blue was found to interfere with the cell movements of gastrulation. In several more
Laboratory 9
85
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
Notes and Observations
86
Laboratory 9
9. Experimenting with Xenopus Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
9. Experimenting with Xenopus Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
recent studies on the effects of inhibited gastrulation, small quantities of Trypan Blue have been injected into the blastocoel (see Kao and Danilchick 1991, cited in “Suggestions for Further Investigation of Amphibian Development,” p. 92). In this experiment, we will briefly immerse embryos in a Trypan Blue solution.This is a technically easier, though somewhat less precise, method of introducing Trypan Blue into embryos, but it was the method used when the effect was first discovered (Waddington and Perry 1956, cited in “Suggestions for Further Investigation of Amphibian Development,” p. 92). Techniques 1. Embryos should have their jelly removed but remain inside their vitelline membranes.The embryos may be either chemically or mechanically dejellied (see p. 61). 2. Transfer some dejellied embryos having between 8 and 32 cells (about stage 5 embryos) to a 0.025% Trypan Blue solution in a 100-ml beaker. If you do not have embryos at these stages available, substitute slightly more advanced embryos. In any case, make certain that you record the developmental stages of the embryos transferred. 3. Put dejellied control embryos into diluted Amphibian Ringer’s solution in an identical beaker and place it near the experimental beaker. Loosely cover all the beakers to retard evaporation. 4. After 24 hours, gently wash the experimental embryos by carefully pouring off the Trypan Blue solution and adding diluted Ringer’s solution. Repeat this gentle washing procedure several times until the solution around the embryos is clear. 5. Gently transfer the treated embryos and appropriate control embryos to rearing dishes where they can be maintained for further observation.
Observations 1. Observe and compare Trypan Blue-treated and control embryos at the time that the experimental embryos are washed. Pay particular attention to the development of the head region of the embryos. Are there differences in neural tube development, eye development, or olfactory placode development? Are there any embryos in which gastrulation appears to have been completely inhibited, that is, the embryo is an unorganized ball of cells? Are there tail abnormalities in the treated embryos? Is there any evidence of swelling that might indicate fluid accumulation (edema)? 2. Compare control and treated embryos at intervals over the next several days, at least until there are hatched, swimming tadpoles among the controls. 3. Compare results with those of your classmates. Are there any evident correlations between severity or types of abnormality and the stage of development at which Trypan Blue treatment was begun?
Materials EQUIPMENT Dissecting microscope and illuminator “Frog pipette” 100-ml beakers Finger bowls or other rearing containers SOLUTIONS
AND
CHEMICALS
Diluted (10%) Amphibian Ringer’s solution 0.025% Trypan Blue solution in diluted Amphibian Ringer’s solution LIVING MATERIAL 8- to 32-cell (about stage 5) Xenopus embryos, or slightly more advanced embryos—if embryos are obtained from a mated pair, sort embryos to find some at appropriate stages
Laboratory 9
87
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
9. Experimenting with Xenopus Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Some Useful Information Sources WEBSITES www-cbd.ups-tlse.fr/organismes/xenopus.html This website, assembled at the Centre de Biologie du Developpement in Toulouse, France, contains illustrations of the Xenopus developmental stages defined by P. D. Nieuwkoop and J. Faber, as well as an atlas of Xenopus development and links to sources of related information, including care and breeding of Xenopus. http://sdb.bio.purdue.edu/ This is the very useful website of the Society for Developmental Biology. It includes several sources of information about amphibian development, which can be found by following links to “Virtual LibraryDevelopmental Biology” and “Education.” http://worms.zoology.wisc.edu/frogs/welcome.html This website, prepared by Jeff Hardin, University of Wisconsin, is a good source of information on several aspects of Xenopus development. www.luc.edu/depts/biology/dev.htm This is Bill Wasserman’s Developmental Biology Page from Loyola University of Chicago. It contains a listing of Web resources, several of which provide information about development of amphibians, including Xenopus. www.utexas.edu/courses/zoo321/ This is a website prepared by Klaus Kalthoff, University of Texas, for his developmental biology course. Information about amphibian development can be found by following the links to “Movies” and “Related Web Sites.” http://gto.ncsa.uiuc.edu/pingLeto/xenopus.html This website, prepared by Alan Beck, San Diego, California, contains information about care and maintenance of Xenopus adults and provides some interesting background information about the animal. VIDEO—A DOZEN EGGS
This video includes a video sequence of frog gastrulation, photographed by Ray Keller and John Shih, University of California, Berkeley. The video was produced under the auspices of the Society for Developmental Biology and is available from Sinauer Associates, Inc., P. O. Box 407, 23 Plumtree Road, Sunderland, MA 01375-0407.
88
Laboratory 9
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
Suggestions for Further Investigation of Amphibian Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
SUGGESTIONS FOR FURTHER INVESTIGATION OF AMPHIBIAN DEVELOPMENT There are many good sources of additional information about amphibian development, including your textbook and the general sources given in the reference list. Amphibian embryos have been studied in thousands of descriptive and experimental studies that have elucidated many principles, not only of amphibian development, but of vertebrate development in general. Some important classical historical papers on amphibian development are available in Willier and Oppenheimer (1964). Viktor Hamburger’s book on experimental embryology (Hamburger 1988) emphasizes work in Hans Spemann’s laboratory, work in which Hamburger himself participated. Fässler and Sander (1996) describe the discoveries of the very gifted Hilde Mangold who suffered a tragic death in an accident at the age of twenty-six. The suggestions that follow are limited to topics introduced in the laboratories included in this manual, but other specific aspects of amphibian development can readily be pursued through various search programs. Frog Development Patterns Developmental patterns of the leopard frog, Rana pipiens (Shumway 1940), are familiar to biologists and biology students in North America, and many important investigations of amphibian development have been done on the embryos of this frog. But for a number of reasons, the African clawed frog, Xenopus laevis, has largely supplanted the leopard frog in research and is being used increasingly in teaching laboratories (Deuchar 1972; Dawid and Sargent 1988; Kay and Peng 1991). Details of cell movement and interaction during gastrulation have been investigated in Xenopus (Keller 1986; Keller et al 1991), and the cortical rotation in the egg that follows sperm contact has been thoroughly studied in Xenopus (Gerhart et al 1989; and see Experiments with Precleavage Processes, in a following section.). Investigators using improved cell marking techniques have clarified details of several basic developmental processes (Saint-Jeannet and Dawid 1994; Davis and Kirschner 2000; Chalmers and Slack 2000). Possibly the most exciting recent advances attained studying Xenopus have had to do with inductive interactions in the early embryo (Gerhart et al 1986; Gerhart 1987). Growth factors similar to, or identical with, ones that act in regulating growth in cell cultures and in vivo in adult organisms appear to act during inductive events in amphibian embryonic pattern determination (Wylie 1990;Thomsen et al 1991; Jessel and Melton 1992). It is not yet fully clear what exact role these diffusible control factors might have in establishing specific regional differentiation patterns (Smith et al 1989; Marx 1991; Green and Smith 1991; Dawid 1994; Green 1994; Slack 1994). Some very old problems in amphibian development are being revisited in light of this research on diffusible factors. For example, the importance of regional specificity of the archenteron roof in inducing the anteroposterior differentiation of the nervous system has been assumed since Otto Mangold’s classic experiments. And yet, normal anteroposterior expression of four genes, including three homeobox genes, was obtained in a system where the mesoderm and the responding ectoderm were kept end to end, without any possibility of specific vertical signals passing between them (Doniach et al 1992). Thus, planar signals passing through the ectoderm from end to end can induce the anteroposterior pattern. If such signaling is a part of normal development, additional explanations for anteroposterior regional specification in nervous system differentiation must be sought. It is interesting that such planar induction has not been demonstrated in Rana pipiens embryos (SaintJeannet and Dawid 1994). Even the history of some famous discoveries has been reexamined. For example, it has been suggested (Lenhoff 1991) that Spemann’s development of the concept of embryonic induction (Hamburger 1988) may have been anticipated and inspired by work that Ethel Browne Harvey did on Hydra regeneration in the very early 1900s.
Suggestions
89
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
Suggestions for Further Investigation of Amphibian Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Surgery A number of aspects of amphibian development have been investigated through the use of microsurgical techniques. For example, developmental biologists analyzing pigment pattern development in frogs employed some very bold microsurgical techniques pioneered by the great American experimental embryologist Ross Harrison (1908) in his studies of nervous system development. Harrison used tissue culture (a technique then in its infancy), surgical separation, and recombination of large pieces of developing embryos to elucidate principles of nervous system development. He cut embryos transversely and swapped anterior halves between embryos. Such chimeric embryos actually developed into normally formed tadpoles and frogs. Following DuShane’s (1945) and Twitty’s (1945) work on pigment pattern development in frogs, Volpe (1963, 1964) reemployed Ross Harrison’s embryo halving and fusing technique to investigate pigment patterns in chimeric frogs. Microsurgery was the key technique in studies of embryonic induction by Hans Spemann and his student and colleague Hilde Mangold (Hamburger 1988). Mangold transplanted blastopore dorsal lip tissue and her results led to development of the “primary organizer” concept. Another Spemann student, Otto Mangold, transplanted pieces of archenteron roof tissue in his study of regional inductive specificity. Nieuwkoop (1973, 1977) did microsurgery on blastulae to combine animal cap ectoderm with vegetal hemisphere cells after the removal of marginal (equatorial) cells. He discovered that mesodermal cell type differentiation was induced in the animal cap tissue. His results helped to open the way to a modern understanding of inductive relations among cells during early development in amphibian embryos. Gurdon and his colleagues (1985) used the same techniques and tissue combinations in their study of specific genetic activation in response to induction by vegetal cells. By the 1980s, it had become very clear that induction by Spemann and Hilde Mangold’s “primary organizer” was by no means the first demonstrable set of cellular interactions in amphibian development (see earlier “Frog Patterns” section). Again, microsurgical techniques played a key role in the pivotal discoveries. For example, Dale and Slack (1987) did an elegant series of experiments in which they made various combinations of inducing and responding cells of the 32-cell stage Xenopus embryo. If you would like more information on applications of microsurgical techniques, consult your text, the papers just cited, and papers cited in the “Frog Patterns” section. Dissociation Study of the behavior and reaggregation of dissociated cells began with the experiments of H. V. Wilson (1907). His original sponge reaggregation experiments are interesting to repeat and can be spectacularly extended by mixing cells from two species of sponges that differ in pigmentation. Tom Humphreys also used sponge cells to examine the mechanism of cell aggregation. His work is of interest because he used techniques developed in Aron Moscona’s laboratory, such as rotating cultures that permit greater repeatability and quantification of the results of reaggregation experiments (see Humphreys 1963). Jones and Elsdale (1963) found that the ultimate course of the differentiation of reaggregated frog embryo cells was altered if the protein component of the medium was subjected to heating prior to use. Comparison of differentiation following reaggregation in media containing slightly heated or unheated egg albumen could be made.The original report, by an undergraduate student, on the use of egg albumen in reaggregation medium (Bradfield 1967) indicated that there was a concentration effect.The relationship of concentration of albumen to the rate of reaggregation could be studied further.You may also wish to compare the techniques of Barth and Barth (1959) with those of Jones and Elsdale (1963). Giudice (1962) dissociated the cells of sea urchin embryos and found that they would reaggregate, and reorganize, the general framework of the embryos. Other workers have extended this research on dissociated echinoderm embryos. (See “Suggestions for Further Investigation,” p. 27). Aron Moscona’s papers on his work with dissociated and reaggregated chick embryos trace the early development of a fascinating area of research. Malcolm Steinberg’s interesting papers present his quantitative, thermodynamic model of cell sorting.
90
Suggestions
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
Suggestions for Further Investigation of Amphibian Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Another historically interesting extension of the dissociation studies was the work of Weiss and Andres (1952).They dissociated (by grinding up!) tissues from young chick embryos of pigmented breeds and injected the cells into blood vessels of older embryos. They interpreted their results as indicating that cells disseminated by the vascular route selectively lodged on the basis of tissue type in the organs of the host.Their interpretation was based largely on the fate of pigment cells. Malcolm Steinberg’s quantitative models focused attention on cell surface interactions such as those involving cell adhesion molecules (CAMs). Studies on CAMs by Gerald Edelman and others helped to relate the cell surface properties studied in dissociated cells to cell activities in embryonic morphogenesis (Steinberg 1996). Primordial Germ Cells The primordial germ cells of vertebrate embryos are a particularly interesting group of cells, both because they are ancestors of the gametes that the individual will eventually produce and because of their intriguing migration during development. In the developing frog embryo, the origin of primordial germ cells can be traced back to a specific area of cytoplasm, known as the germinal plasm, located in the vegetal area of the egg. During cleavage, this cytoplasm becomes incorporated into the cells that give rise to primordial germ cells (Bounoure 1934; Blackler 1958; Wiley 1980). Experiments by Blackler on Xenopus laevis, the South African clawed frog, have provided evidence that primordial germ cells give rise to all gametes that ultimately develop in the gonad (Blackler 1962). This countered the view that some gametes may not be descendants of the primordial germ cells but were induced to become gametes by the presence of primordial germ cells. Blackler (1965) also demonstrated that primordial germ cells develop in harmony with the gonad that they colonize and differentiate into the type of gamete characteristic of that gonad (that is, egg or sperm), regardless of their own genetic constitution.You may find the radical transplantation techniques that Blackler employed in these experiments interesting. Volpe and Curtis (1968) joined tail-bud stage (stage 17) frog embryos at the gill region in parabiotic unions to examine the possibility of vascular transfer of germ cells between parabionts. In unions of vegetal pole-irradiated embryos with unirradiated embryos, the irradiated member of the pair invariably lacked germ cells.These results provided evidence against the migration of frog primordial germ cells via the vascular route. These experiments might be extended by examining parabiotic unions involving fusions of other areas of the body surface (see Rugh 1962). As with other aspects of frog development, much of the more recent research on primordial germ cells has been done on Xenopus. Some experiments have focused on the reorganization of germinal plasm after fertilization (Ressom and Dixon 1988) and on the factors determining the number of primordial germ cells formed (Akita and Wakahara 1985).Research on effects of ultraviolet irradiation on primordial germ cell development in Xenopus included investigation of UV irradiation of early embryos (Thomas et al 1983) and of oocytes (Holwill et al 1987). If you wish to do additional experiments on primordial germ cell development, you might begin by consulting the papers cited, especially L. D. Smith’s (1966) paper on his fundamental UV irradiation experiments. Metamorphosis and Regeneration You have had opportunities to investigate early development in amphibians, and most of the topics in these “Suggestions for Further Investigation” are related to those early developmental processes. In this section, however, there are some suggestions about several aspects of later stages of development that you might find interesting. Metamorphosis and its hormonal control have been investigated focusing on Xenopus tail resorption (Brown et al 1996; Elinson et al 1999). Several studies have employed isolated, cultured tails of Xenopus larvae (Weber 1961; Schaffer 1963; Nishikawa 1989). It is relatively easy to set up experiments with isolated Xenopus larvae tails, and if you want to repeat or extend these experiments, good basic information on techniques is available in Scadding (1984) as well as in the papers just cited.
Suggestions
91
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
Suggestions for Further Investigation of Amphibian Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Amphibians have been favorite subjects for research on regeneration for many years. Some of the most extensive studies have involved the axolotl,Ambystoma mexicanum (Schreckenberg and Jacobson 1975; Stocum 1979; Armstrong and Malacinski 1989), but limb regeneration in Rana pipiens (for example, Fry 1966) and Xenopus larvae has also been investigated. In 1962, Dent explored the developmental loss of limb regenerating capacity that occurs in Xenopus, and work on Xenopus tail (Maden and Corcoran 1996) and limb regeneration is continuing (Korneluk and Liversage 1984; Sessions and Bryant 1988; Filoni and Paglialunga 1990; Endo et al 2000). Wound healing (Radice 1980) and eye regeneration (Underwood and Ide 1992) have also been studied in Xenopus tadpoles. E. M. Deuchar (1975) worked with much earlier developmental stages when she examined tail-bud regeneration between stages 26 and 39. If you want to study regeneration in Xenopus, you might begin by repeating or extending Deuchar’s experiments or Hauser and Lehmann’s (1962) very interesting experiments on regeneration in isolated, cultured Xenopus larvae tails. Vitamin A and similar compounds, such as retinoic acid, have striking effects on the regeneration process. These effects have been studied in axolotls (for example, Scadding 1989; Ludolph et al 1990) and in Xenopus (Scadding and Maden 1986 a & b; Scadding 1989).Although there are unanswered questions about what was once thought to be an established role for retinoic acid as a morphogen during normal limb pattern formation, the effects of retinoic acid on limb regeneration certainly are fascinating. If you wish to investigate these effects further, consult the papers cited or one of several reviews of retinoic acid effects and other molecular aspects of limb regeneration (Tsonis 1990; Bryant and Gardiner 1992; Muneoka and Sasson 1992). You will find other general and theoretical information about limb development in your textbook and in papers such as those by Bryant et al (1981) and Muneoka et al (1986). Lithium and Other Chemical Treatments The study of effects of lithium ions on developmental processes has a long history, and lithium effects on amphibian development and differentiation have been under investigation for some time (for example, Barth and Barth 1967). Lithium ions disrupt normal anteroposterior pattern development in Xenopus embryos in a dose- and timing-dependent maneuver (Kao et al 1986; Kao and Elinson 1987; Klein 1991; Drysdale and Elinson 1993). Cellular mechanisms of lithium effects are being elucidated (Berridge et al 1989; Klein and Melton 1996), and it appears that a lithium effect on a cellular signal transduction system could indeed be involved in lithium’s pattern-disrupting effect on amphibian development (Maslanski et al 1992). For many years, biologists tested the effects of literally hundreds of substances on developmental processes. Many of these studies could be classified as part of teratology, the study of grossly abnormal development.Teratology provided clues regarding birth defects and other unexplained instances of abnormal development. But more recently, results of earlier teratology studies have suggested approaches to be employed in modern investigations of developmental mechanisms. For example,Waddington and Perry’s (1956) study of the teratogenic effect of the dye Trypan Blue suggested a tool that could be used in investigation of the effects of disrupted gastrulation (Gerhart et al 1989). Other similar applications are currently being made (Kao and Danilchick 1991). Experimenting with Precleavage Processes Several microtubule-dependent events in early development can be disrupted by chemical or cold treatments that interfere with microtubule assembly. One of these is resumed meiosis, which normally leads to completion of the second meiotic division and establishment of the haploid egg pronucleus. Cold treatment within a short period of time after insemination interferes with the process so that two sets of maternal chromosomes are retained. Subsequent fertilization events establish a triploid genome in the zygote. If you wish to experiment with this response, you might try an initial treatment of 15 minutes of chilling at 2–3° C, starting between 10 and 15 minutes after insemination (Smith 1958; Kawahara 1978). Consult Laboratory 4 for methods of preparing cells for chromosome observation.Artificially produced
92
Suggestions
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
Suggestions for Further Investigation of Amphibian Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
triploidy has been used as a cell marker in a number of developmental studies (for example, Smith et al 1988; Rollins-Smith and Blair 1990).You may wish to consult these papers regarding methods and applications. Cortical cytoplasmic rotation, another event that occurs shortly after insemination, is also subject to disruption by several experimental treatments. Interference with cortical rotation disrupts subsequent development so that there is deficient development of anterodorsal parts of the embryo (Gerhart et al 1989). Inductive interactions critical for axis determination do not occur normally if cortical rotation is disrupted.This has been demonstrated in experiments where normal rotation was impeded by altering gravity relationships, chilling, applying increased atmospheric pressure, or treating with UV irradiation (Scharf and Gerhart 1983; Vincent et al 1986; Vincent and Gerhart 1987). These experiments showed clearly that there are important determinative events that precede even the beginning of cleavage.Although there is still far to go, our understanding of the cell biology of early development is growing. Developmental Diversity in Amphibians The basic pattern of frog development presented in textbooks is based on the development of several North American and European species as well as Xenopus.This pattern includes embryonic development leading to a tadpole that feeds for some time before undergoing metamorphosis. There are other patterns. In some frog species, the free-swimming tadpole phase is very much shortened or even absent.There are frogs that produce large eggs that develop quickly into small froglets, bypassing the free-swimming tadpole phase. Some even have internal fertilization.These patterns allow for completion of development without access to water, or in some cases, with unpredictable timing of access to water. The familiar pattern of reproduction in North American frogs involves no parental care of offspring, but some Central and South American species brood their developing young in various ways. Some species actually have brood pouches within which development proceeds. You can learn more about these fascinating frogs by consulting papers by Del Pino and Elinson and their colleagues. An almost bizarre form of parental care occurs in an Australian frog, Rheobatrachus silus (Corben et al 1974;Tyler and Carter 1981).A female of this species swallows her young and broods them in her stomach until they undergo metamorphosis and pop out of her mouth as small frogs! During the time that she is brooding young, the female frog refrains from eating and suspends normal digestive functioning, including all gastric glandular secretion. Sadly, this interesting gastric-brooding species seems to have disappeared from its limited range in southeastern Queensland, Australia. Between the early 1970s, when its reproduction was first studied, and the early 1980s, numbers declined dramatically. By the early 1990s, it appeared that this amazing frog might even be extinct. Unfortunately, this pattern of decline toward extinction is all too common and seems to be the condition of numerous amphibian species worldwide (see Appendix G,Amphibian Conservation section, p. 238). Amphibian Development References General Sources Deuchar, E. Xenopus laevis and developmental biology. Biol. Rev. 47:37–112; 1972. Deuchar, E. Xenopus: The South African Clawed Frog. London: Wiley; 1975. DiBernardino, M.A. Frogs. In:Wilt, F. H.;Wessells, N. K., eds. Methods in Developmental Biology. New York:Thomas Y. Crowell; 1967: 53–74. Elinson, R. P.Amphibians. In: Gilbert, S. F.; Raunio,A. M., eds. Embryology: Constructing the Organism. Sunderland, MA: Sinauer; 1997: 309–329. Fässler, P. E.; Sander, K. Hilde Mangold (1898–1924) and Spemann’s organizer: achievement and tragedy. Roux’s Arch. Dev. Biol. 205:323–332; 1996. Guille, M. Molecular Methods in Developmental Biology; Xenopus and Zebrafish.Totowa, NJ: Humana Press; 1999: Methods in Molecular Biology, vol. 127.
Suggestions
93
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
Suggestions for Further Investigation of Amphibian Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Gurdon, J. B.African Clawed Frogs. In:Wilt, F. H.;Wessells, N. K., eds. Methods in Developmental Biology. New York: Thomas Y. Crowell; 1991: 75–84. Hamburger, V. A Manual of Experimental Embryology. Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 1960. Hamburger,V. The Heritage of Experimental Embryology: Hans Spemann and the Organizer. New York: Oxford University Press; 1988. Hausen, P.; Riebesell, M. The Early Development of Xenopus laevis: An Atlas of the Histology. New York: SpringerVerlag; 1991. Jones, C.M. et al.Amphibian Embryo. In: Sharpe, P.T.; Mason, I., eds. Molecular Embryology Methods and Protocols. Totowa, NJ: Humana Press; 1999: Methods in Molecular Biology, vol. 97. Kay, B. K.; Peng, H. B., eds. Xenopus laevis: Practical Uses in Cell and Molecular Biology. (Methods in Cell Biology; vol. 36) San Diego: Academic Press; 1991. New, D. A.T. The Culture of Vertebrate Embryos. New York: Logos/Academic; 1966. Nieuwkoop, P. D.; Faber, J. Normal Table of Xenopus laevis. Hamden, CT: Garland Publishing; 1994 (reprint of 1956 edition with new forward by J. Gerhart and M. Kirschner). Rugh, R. Experimental Embryology. 3d ed. Minneapolis: Burgess; 1962. Slack, J. M. W. From Egg to Embryo. 2d ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1991. Slack, J. M.W. Xenopus and other amphibians. In: Bard, J. B. L. Embryos: Color Atlas of Development. London:Wolfe; 1994: 37–53. Willier, B. H.; Oppenheimer, J. M. Foundations of Experimental Embryology. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall; 1964 (contains reprinted original papers of Roux and Spemann). Wolpert, L. The Triumph of the Embryo. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 1991.
Reviews and Research Papers FROG DEVELOPMENT PATTERNS Chalmers, A. D.; Slack, J. M. W.The Xenopus tadpole gut: fate maps and morphogenetic movements. Development 127:381–392; 2000. Davis, R. L.; Kirschner, M. W. The fate of cells in the tailbud of Xenopus laevis. Development 127:255–267; 2000. Dawid, I. B.; Sargent, T. D. Xenopus laevis in developmental and molecular biology. Science 240:1143–1447; 1988. Dawid, I. B. Intercellular signaling and gene regulation during early embryogenesis of Xenopus laevis. Jour. Biol. Chem. 269:6259–6262; 1994. Deuchar, E. M. Xenopus laevis and developmental biology. Biol. Reviews 47:37–112; 1972. Doniach,T. C.; Phillips, R.; Gerhart, J. C. Planar induction of anteroposterior pattern in the developing nervous system of Xenopus laevis. Science. 257:542–545; 1992. Gerhart, J. Determinants of early amphibian development. Am. Zool. 27:593–605; 1987. Gerhart, J.; Black, S.; Scharf, S.; Gimlich, R.; Vincent, J. P.; Danilchik, M.; Rowning, B.; Roberts, J. Amphibian early development. BioScience 36(8):541–549; 1986. Gerhart, J.; Danilchik, M.; Doniach,T.; Roberts, S.; Rowning, B.; Stewart, R. Cortical rotation of the Xenopus egg: consequences for the anteroposterior pattern of embryonic dorsal development. Development 1989 Supplement 37–51; 1989. Green, J. B.A.; Smith, J. C. Growth factors as morphogens—Do gradients and thresholds establish body plan? Trends in Genetics 7:245–249; 1991. Green, J. B.A. Roads to neuralness: embryonic neural induction as derepression of a default state. Cell 77:317–320; 1994. Jessel,T. M.; Melton, D. A. Diffusible factors in vertebrate embryonic induction. Cell 68:257–270; 1992. Keller,R.E.The cellular basis of amphibian gastrulation.In:Browder,L.,ed.Developmental Biology:A Comprehensive Synthesis; Vol. 2. New York: Plenum, 1986: 241–327. Keller, R.; Shih, J.;Wilson, P.; Sater,A. Pattern and function of cell mobility and cell interactions during convergence and extension in Xenopus. In: Gerhart, J., ed. Cell-Cell Interactions in Early Development. New York: WileyLiss, 1991: 31–62. Lenhoff, H. M. Ethel Browne, Hans Spemann, and the discovery of the organizer phenomenon. Biol. Bull. 180:72–80; 1991. Marx, J. How embryos tell heads from tails. Science 254:1586–1588; 1991. Pogany, G. C. Effects of sperm ultraviolet irradiation on the embryonic development of Rana pipiens. Dev. Biol. 26:336–345; 1971. Saint-Jeannet, J.-P.; Dawid, I. B. A fate map for the 32-cell stage of Rana pipiens. Dev. Biol. 166:755–762; 1994.
94
Suggestions
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
Suggestions for Further Investigation of Amphibian Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Saint-Jeannet, J.-P.; Dawid, I. B. Vertical versus planar neural induction in Rana pipiens embryos. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 91:3049–3353; 1994. Shumway, W. Stages in the normal development of Rana pipiens: I. External form. Anat. Rec. 78:139–147; 1940. Slack, J. M. W.The inducer that never was. Nature 369:279–280; 1994. Smith, J. C.; Cooke, J.; Green, J. B.A.; Howes, G.; Symes, K. Inducing factors and the control of mesodermial patterns in Xenopus laevis. Development 1989 Supplement 149–159; 1989. Thomsen, G.; Woolf,T.; Whitman, M.; Sokol, S.; Melton, S. A. Activins and the induction of axial mesoderm and dorsanterior structures in Xenopus. In: Gerhart, J., ed. Cell-Cell Interactions in Early Development. New York: Wiley-Liss, 1991: 79–91. Winkelbauer, R. Mesodermal cell migration during Xenopus gastrulation. Dev. Biol. 142:155–168; 1990. Wylie, C. Activins and induction. Nature 347:337–338; 1990. SURGERY Dale, L.; Slack, J. M.W. Regional specificity within the mesoderm of early embryos of Xenopus laevis. Development 100:279–295; 1987. DuShane, G. P. The embryology of vertebrate pigment cells. Part I. Amphibia. Quart. Rev. Biol. 18:109–127; 1945. Gimlich, R. L. Acquisition of developmental autonomy in the equatorial region of the Xenopus embryo. Dev. Biol. 116:340–352; 1986. Gimlich, R. L.; Gerhart, J. C. Early cellular interactions promote embryonic axis formation in Xenopus laevis. Dev. Biol. 104:117–130; 1984. Gurdon, J. B.; Fairman, S.; Mohun,T. J.; Brennan, S.The activation of muscle-specific actin genes in Xenopus development by an induction between animal and vegetal cells of a blastula. Cell 41:913–922; 1985. Harrison, R. G. Embryonic transplantation and development of the nervous system. Anat. Rec. 2:385–437; 1908. Nieuwkoop, P. D.The “organization center” of the amphibian embryo: its origin, spatial organization and morphogenetic action. Adv. Morphog. 10:1–39; 1973. Nieuwkoop, P. D. Origin and establishment of embryonic polar axes in amphibian development. Curr. Top. Dev. Biol. 11:115–132; 1977. Twitty, V. C.The developmental analysis of specific pigment patterns. Jour. Exp. Zool. 100:141–178; 1945. Volpe, E. P. Interplay of mutant and wild-type pigment cells in chimeric leopard frogs. Dev. Biol. 8:205–221; 1963. Volpe, E. P. Fate of neural crest homotransplants in pattern mutants of the leopard frog. Jour. Exp. Zool. 157:179–196; 1964. DISSOCIATION Barth, L. G.; Barth, L. J. Differentiation of cells of the Rana pipiens gastrula in unconditioned medium. Jour. Embryol. Exp. Morph. 7:210–222; 1959. Bradfield, B. The use of egg white as a protein additive in medium for embryonic frog cell reaggregation. Proc. S. D. Acad. Sci. 46:259–260; 1967. Edelman, G. M. Expression of cell adhesion molecules during embryogenesis and regeneration. Exp. Cell Res. 161:1–16; 1985. Edelman, G. M. Cell adhesion molecules in the regulation of animal form and pattern. Annu. Rev. Cell Biol. 2:81–116; 1986. Edelman, G. M.Topobiology. Sci. Amer. May: 7–88; 1989. Giudice, G. Restitution of whole larvae from disaggregated cells of sea urchin embryos. Dev. Biol. 5:402–411; 1962. Giudice, G.; Mutolo, V. Reaggregation of dissociated cells of sea urchin embryos. Advances in Morphogenesis 8:115–158; 1970. Humphreys,T. Chemical dissolution and in vitro reconstruction of sponge cell adhesions: isolation and functional demonstration of the components involved. Dev. Biol. 8:27–47; 1963. Jones, K.W.; Elsdale,T. R.The culture of small aggregates of amphibian embryonic cells in vitro. Jour. Embryol. Exp. Morph. 11:135–154; 1963. Moscona, A. Cell suspensions from organ rudiments of chick embryos. Exp. Cell Res. 3:535–539; 1952. Moscona,A.The dissociation and aggregation of cells from organ rudiments of the early chick embryo. Jour. Anat. 86:287–301; 1952. Moscona, A. Development of heterotypic combinations of dissociated embryonic chick cells. Proc. Soc. Exp. Biol. Med. 92:410–416; 1956. Moscona, A. The development in vitro of chimeric aggregates of dissociated chick and mouse cells. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 43:184–194; 1957. Moscona, A. How cells associate. Sci. Amer. May: 132–144; 1961.
Suggestions
95
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
Suggestions for Further Investigation of Amphibian Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Spiegel, M.; Spiegel, E. S. Reaggregation of dissociated embryonic sea urchin cells. Am. Zool. 15:583–606; 1975. Steinberg, M. S. Reconstruction of tissues by dissociated cells. Science 141:401–408; 1963. Steinberg, M. S. Does differential adhesion govern self-assembly processes in histogenesis? Equilibrium configurations and the emergence of a hierarchy among populations of embryonic cells. Jour. Exp. Zool. 173:395–434; 1970. Steinberg, M. S. Adhesion in development: an historical overview. Dev. Biol. 180:377–388; 1996. Steinberg, M. S.; Poole,T. J. Cellular adhesive differentials as determinants of morphogenetic movements and organ segregation. In: Subtelny, S.; Green, P. B., eds. Developmental Order: Its Origin and Regulation. New York: Alan R. Liss; 1982: 351–378. Steinberg, M. S.; Takeichi, M. Experimental specification of cell sorting, tissue spreading, and specific spatial patterning by quantitative differences in cadherin expression. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 91:206–209; 1994. Townes, P. L.; Holtfreter, J. Directed movements and selective adhesion of embryonic amphibian cells. Jour. Exp. Zool. 128:53–120; 1955. Weiss, P.; Andres, G. Experiments on the fate of embryonic cells (chick) disseminated by the vascular route. Jour. Exp. Zool. 121:449–488; 1952. Wilson, H. V. On some phenomena of coalescence and regeneration in sponges. Jour. Exp. Zool. 5:245–258; 1907. PRIMORDIAL GERM CELLS Akita,Y.;Wakahara, M. Cytological analyses of factors which determine the number of primordial germ cells (PGCs) in Xenopus laevis. Jour. Embrol. Exp. Morph. 90:251–265; 1985. Blackler, A. W. Contribution to the study of the germ-cells in Anura. Jour. Embryol. Exp. Morph. 6:491–503; 1958. Blackler, A. W. Transfer of primordial germ-cells between two subspecies of Xenopus laevis. Jour. Embryol. Exp. Morph. 10:641–651; 1962. Blackler, A. W. Germ-cell transfer and sex ratio in Xenopus laevis. Jour. Embryol. Exp. Morph. 13:51–61; 1965. Bounoure, L. Recherches sur la lignee germinale chez la grenouille rousse aux premiers stades du developpement. Ann. Sci. Nat. 10e Ser. 17:67–248; 1934. Holwill, S.; Heasman, J.; Crawley, C. R.; Wylie, C. C. Axis and germ line deficiencies caused by u.v. irradiation of Xenopus oocytes in vitro. Development 100:735–743; 1987. Ressom, R. E.; Dixon, K. E. Relocation and reorganization of germ plasm in Xenopus embryos after fertilization. Development 103:507–518; 1988. Smith, L. D. The role of germinal plasm in the formation of primordial germ cells in Rana pipiens. Dev. Biol. 14:330–347; 1966. Thomas,V.; Heasman, J.; Ford, C.; Nagajski, D.;Wylie, C. C. Further analysis of the effect of ultra-violet irradiation on the formation of the germ line in Xenopus laevis. Jour. Embryol. Exp. Morph. 76:67–81; 1983. Volpe, E. P.; Curtis, S. Germ cell chimerism: absence in parabiotic frogs. Science 160:328–329; 1989. Wylie, C. C. Primordial germ cells in anuran embryos:Their movement and its guidance. BioScience 30(1):27–31; 1980. METAMORPHOSIS
AND
REGENERATION
Armstrong, J. B.; Malacinski, G. M.; eds. Developmental Biology of the Axolotl. New York: Oxford University Press; 1989. Brown, D. D.; Wand, Z.; Furlow, J. D.; Kanamori, A.; Schwartzman, R. A.; Remo, B. F.; Pinder, A.The thyroid hormoneinduced tail resorption program during Xenopus laevis metamorphosis. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 93:1924–1929; 1996. Bryant, S. V.; French, V.; Bryant, P. J. Distal Regeneration and Symmetry. Science 212:993–1002; 1981. Bryant, S.V.; Gardiner, D. M. Retinoic acid, local cell-cell interactions, and pattern formation in vertebrate limbs. Dev. Biol. 152:1–25; 1992. Dent, J. N. Regeneration in larvae and metamorphosing individuals of the South African clawed toad. Jour. Morphol. 110:61–77; 1962. Deuchar, E. M. Regeneration of the tail bud in Xenopus embryos. Jour. Exp. Zool. 192:381–390; 1975. Elinson, R. P.; Remo, B.; Brown, D. D. Novel structural elements identified during tail resorption in Xenopus laevis metamorphosis: lessons from tailed frogs. Dev. Biol. 215:243–252; 1999. Endo, T.; Tamura, K.; Ide, H. Analysis of gene expression during Xenopus forelimb regeneration. Dev. Biol. 220:296–306; 2000. Filoni, S.; Paglialunga, L. Effect of denervation on hind limb regeneration in Xenopus laevis larvae. Differentiation 43:10–19; 1990. Fry, A. E. Hind limb regeneration in Rana pipiens larvae. Copeia (3):530–534; 1966.
96
Suggestions
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
II. Amphibian Development
Suggestions for Further Investigation of Amphibian Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Hauser, R.; Lehmann, F. E. Regeneration in isolated tails of Xenopus larvae. Experientia 18:83–84; 1962. Korneluk, R. G.; Liversage, R.A.Tissue regeneration in the amputated forelimb of Xenopus laevis froglets. Can. Jour. Zool. 62:2383–2391; 1984. Ludolph, D. C.; Cameron, J. -A.; Stocum, D. L.The effect of retinoic acid on positional memory in the dorsoventral axis of regenerating axolotl limbs. Dev. Biol. 140:41–52; 1990. Maden, M.; Corcoran, J. Role of thyroid and retinoid receptors in the homeotic transformation of tails into limbs in frogs. Dev. Genetics 19:85–93; 1996. Muneoka, K.; Holler-Dinsmore, G.; Bryant, S. V. Intrinsic control of regenerative loss in Xenopus laevis limbs. Jour. Exp. Zool. 240:47–54; 1986. Muneoka, K.; Sassoon, D. Molecular aspects of regeneration in developing vertebrate limbs. Dev. Biol. 152:37–49; 1992. Nishikawa, A.; Kaiho, M.; Yoshizato, K. Cell death in the anuran tadpole tail: Thyroid hormone induces keratinization and tail-specific growth inhibition of epidermal cells. Dev. Biol. 131:337–344; 1989. Radice, G. P.The spreading of epithelial cells during wound closure in Xenopus laevis. Dev. Biol. 76:26–46; 1980. Scadding, S. R.Thyroxine induced resorption of Xenopus laevis tail tissue in vitro. Jour. Biol. Ed. 18:82–84; 1984. Scadding, S. R.; Maden, M. Comparison of the effects of vitamin A on limb development and regeneration in Xenopus laevis tadpoles. Jour. Embryol. Exp. Morph. 91:35–53; 1986a. Scadding, S. R.; Maden, M.The effects of local application of retinoic acid on limb development and regeneration in tadpoles of Xenopus laevis. Jour. Embryol. Exp. Morph. 91:55–63; 1986b. Scadding, S. R. Vitamin A inhibits amphibian tail regeneration. Can. Jour. Zool. 65(2):457; 1987. Scadding, S. R. Histological effects of vitamin A on limb regeneration in the larval axolotl, Ambystoma mexicanum. Can J. Zool. 68:159–167; 1989. Schaffer, B. M. The isolated Xenopus laevis tail: a preparation for studying the central nervous system and metamorphosis in culture. Jour. Embryol. Exp. Morph. 2:77–90; 1963. Schreckenberg, G. M.; Jacobson,A. G. Normal stages of development of the axolotl, Ambystoma mexicanum. Dev. Biol. 42:391–400; 1975. Sessions, S. K.; Bryant, S.V. Evidence that regenerative ability is an intrinsic property of limb cells in Xenopus. Jour. Exp. Zool. 247:39–44; 1988. Stocum, D. L. Stages of forelimb regeneration in Ambystoma maculatum. Jour. Exp. Zool. 209:395–416; 1979. Tsonis, P. A. Molecular approaches in limb development and regeneration. Trends in Biochemical Sciences. 15:82–83; 1990. Underwood, L. W.; Ide, C. F. An autoradiographic time study during regeneration in fully differentiated Xenopus eyes. Jour. Exp. Zool. 262:193–201; 1992. Weber, R. Induced metamorphosis in isolated tails of Xenopus larvae. Experientia 18:84–85; 1961. LITHIUM
AND
OTHER CHEMICAL TREATMENTS
Barth, L. G.; Barth, L. J. Competence and sequential induction in presumptive epidermis of normal and hybrid frog gastrulae. Phys. Zool. 40:97–103; 1967. Berridge, M. J.; Downes, C. P.; Hanley, M. R. Neural and developmental actions of lithium: a unifying hypothesis. Cell 59:411–419; 1989. Drysdale,T. A.; Elinson, R. P. Head ectodermal patterning and axial development in frogs. Amer. Zool. 33:417–423; 1993. Gerhart, J.; Danilchik, M.; Doniach,T.; Roberts, S.; Rowning, B.; Stewart, R. Cortical rotation of the Xenopus egg: consequences for the anteroposterior pattern of embryonic dorsal development. Development 1989 Supplement 37–51; 1989. Kao, K.; Danilchik, M. Generation of body plan phenotypes in early embryogenesis. In: Kay and Peng (see General Sources section earlier); 1991: 271–284. Kao, K. R.; Elinson, R. P. Dorsalization of mesoderm induction by lithium. Dev. Biol. 132:81–90; 1988. Kao, K. R.; Masui, V.; Elinson, R. P. Lithium-induced respecification of pattern in Xenopus laevis embryos. Nature 322:371–373; 1986. Klein, P. S.; Melton, D. A. A molecular mechanism for the effect of lithium on development. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 93:8455–8459; 1996. Klein, S. L. Xenopus dorsal pattern formation is lithium-sensitive. Roux’s Arch. Dev. Biol. 199:427–436; 1991. Maslanski, J. A.; Leshko, L.; Busa, S. B. Lithium-sensitive production of inositol phosphates during amphibian embryonic mesoderm induction. Science 256:243–245; 1992. Waddington, C. H.; Perry, M. M.Teratogenic effects of Trypan Blue on amphibian embryos. Jour. Embryol. Exp. Morph. 4:110–119; 1956.
Suggestions
97
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
CORTICAL ROTATION
AND
II. Amphibian Development
Suggestions for Further Investigation of Amphibian Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
COLD-INDUCED TRIPLOIDY
Gerhart, J.; Danilchik, M.; Doniach,T.; Roberts, S.; Rowning, B.; Stewart, R. Cortical rotation of the Xenopus egg: consequences for the anteroposterior pattern of embryonic dorsal development. Development 1989 Supplement 37–51; 1989. Kawahara, H. Production of triploid and gynogenetic diploid Xenopus by cold treatment. Dev. Growth & Differ. 20:227–236; 1978. Rollins-Smith, L. A.; Blair, P. Contribution of ventral blood island mesoderm to hematopoiesis in postmetamorphic and metamorphosis-inhibited Xenopus laevis. Dev. Biol. 142:178–183; 1990. (This research included experimental production of triploidy.) Scharf, S. R.; Gerhart, J. C.Axis determination in eggs of Xenopus laevis: a critical period before first cleavage, identified by the common effects of cold, pressure and ultraviolet irradiation. Dev. Bio. 99:75–87; 1983. Smith, P. B.; Flajnik, M. F.;Turpen, J. B. Experimental analysis of ventral blood island hematopoiesis in Xenopus: embryonic chimeras.Dev.Biol.131:302–312;1988.(This research included experimental production of triploidy.) Smith, S. Induction of triploidy in the South African clawed frog, Xenopus laevis (Daudin). Nature 181:290; 1958. Vincent, J.-P.; Gerhart, J. C. Subcortical rotation in Xenopus eggs: an early step in embryonic axis specification. Dev. Biol. 123:526–539; 1987. Vincent, J.-P.; Oster, G. F.; Gerhart, J. C. Kinematics of gray crescent formation in Xenopus eggs: the displacement of subcortical cytoplasm relative to the egg surface. Dev. Biol. 113:484–500; 1986. AMPHIBIAN DEVELOPMENTAL DIVERSITY Corben, C. J.; Ingram, G. J.;Tyler, M. J. Gastric brooding: unique form of parental care in an Australian frog. Science 186:946–947; 1974. Del Pino, E. M. Marsupial Frogs. Sci. Amer. May: 110–118; 1989. Del Pino, E. M. Modifications of oogenesis and development in marsupial frogs. Development 107:169–187; 1989. Del Pino, E. M.; Elinson, R. P. A novel development pattern for frogs: gastrulation produces an embryonic disk. Nature 306:589–591; 1983. Del Pino, E. M.; Loor-Vela, S. The pattern of early cleavage of the marsupial frog Gastrotheca riobambae. Development 110:781–789; 1990. Elinson, R. P.; Del Pino, E. M.;Townsend, D. S.; Cuesta, F. C.; Eichhorn, P. A practical guide to the developmental biology of terrestrial-breeding frogs. Biol. Bull. 179:163–177; 1990. Elinson, R. P. Change in developmental patterns: embryos of amphibians with large eggs. In: Raff, R. A.; Raff, E. C., eds. Development as an Evolutionary Process. New York: Alan R. Liss; 1987: 1–21. Elinson, R. P. Fertilization and aqueous development of Puerto Rican terrestrial-breeding frog, Eleutherodactylus coqui. Jour. Morph. 193:217–224; 1987. Elinson, R. P.; Del Pino, E. M. Cleavage and gastrulation in the egg-brooding marsupial frog, Gastrotheca riobambae. Jour. Embryol. Exp. Morph. 90:223–232; 1985. Tyler, M. J.; Carter, D. B. Oral birth of the young of the gastric brooding frog Rheobatrachus silus. Anim. Behav. 29:280–282; 1981.
98
Suggestions
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
III. Chick Embryo Development
10. Patterns of Chick Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
L A B O R A T O R Y
10 Patterns of Chick Development
The study of the chick embryo has a long history that reaches back to the time of Aristotle and includes such great names in the history of biology as William Harvey, C. F.Wolff, and many others. In modern times, the chick embryo has been exploited in so many developmental studies that it can safely be said that the developing chick is one of the most intensively studied of all organisms. Interest in patterns of chick development goes beyond the basic description of avian ontogeny because there are marked parallels between early chick development and the development of mammalian embryos, which are more difficult to obtain and study.This laboratory is intended to introduce you to the general processes of chick development and to some of the techniques used in the study of chick embryos. Many of the early events in chick ontogeny are not as readily observed as are similar processes in the frog. One reason for this difficulty is the organization of the chicken’s “egg.” The egg proper (the “yolk” in everyday terminology) is surrounded by secretory products of the female reproductive tract that include the white (or albumen), the shell membranes, and the shell (fig. 10.1). All of these accessory layers are added after the time of fertilization.The egg itself is a large, extremely yolky cell with a restricted less yolky cytoplasmic area on one side that contains the nucleus. As the large mass of yolk is not cleaved, the mitotic divisions of cleavage are restricted to this small active area, the blastodisc.As cleavage proceeds, the blastodisc is converted into a multicellular structure that is several cells thick. Further development proceeds within this active area, which is called the blastoderm after cleavage divisions have made it multicellular. You will begin your study of chick development by removing blastoderms from the yolk and examining living chick embryos at several stages of development. First, you will briefly examine an embryo that has been incubated for 2 or 3 days.After this initial exposure to embryo handling techniques, you will make more detailed observations of an embryo at the stage of development commonly called the “33-hour chick embryo.”This embryo clearly displays many results of the completion of earliest developmental processes. Following this introduction to the living 12- to 15-somite chick embryo, you will examine embryos at several other stages of development and trace some general patterns of chick development.
99
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
III. Chick Embryo Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
10. Patterns of Chick Development
vitelline membrane
blastoderm dense albumen less dense albumen
outer shell membrane air space chalaza inner shell membrane
shell
yolk
FIGURE 10.1 The organization of a chicken’s egg and accessory material surrounding it.
FIGURE 10.2 Opening the incubated egg into saline solution.
FIGURE 10.3 Cutting the blastoderm free from the yolk.
100
Laboratory 1 0
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
III. Chick Embryo Development
10. Patterns of Chick Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Observations Learning to Handle Chick Embryos You can make only limited observations of living chick embryos while they remain in place on the yolk surface, so you need to learn techniques for removing the embryo and surrounding blastoderm tissue from the yolk and for transferring the embryo to a dish for further observations.You can begin your study of chick development by removing a 2- or 3-day blastoderm from the yolk.You will study details of embryos at this developmental stage later, so use this particular embryo only to practice the removal technique and to become familiar with the relationships of the embryo and blastoderm to the yolk and the vitelline membrane that encloses them. 1. Pour sterile saline solution into a finger bowl to a depth of about 1.5 cm. Crack the incubated egg out into the saline (fig. 10.2). It is sometimes helpful to crack the shell gently around at least half of its circumference before attempting to open it. Hold the egg very near the saline as you apply pressure to separate the two halves. If the yolk breaks in such a way that the blastoderm is badly torn, discard the egg and saline and start over with a new egg. The blastoderm usually will be in view when the egg has been broken into the bowl, but it may be necessary to gently turn the yolk, using a section lifter, spatula, forceps handle, or your finger.The embryo and extraembryonic blood vessels around it should be plainly evident at 2 or 3 days of incubation. If you see only a small, dense, white spot, the egg is probably sterile and ought to be discarded. 2. Firmly grasp the blastoderm near the edge of the area that contains blood vessels with watchmaker’s forceps. Penetrate the yolk about 0.5 cm before closing the forceps. Hold the forceps closed as you begin to cut around the outside of the blastoderm with a sharp scissors (fig. 10.3). This cutting of the blastoderm, and the vitelline membrane that covers it, should be done with a fairly rapid snipping action.You will encounter problems caused by the yolk rushing out at the first cuts unless the blastoderm is held in place at the very top of the yolk. After you have cut around the entire blastoderm, the vitelline membrane and blastoderm area can be gently floated off the yolk into the saline. When the blastoderm is floating free, gently slide it onto a submerged plastic spoon. Then, use your watchmaker’s forceps to hold the blastoderm in place as you slowly lift the spoon out of the saline and transfer it to a Syracuse dish or small petri dish containing saline. 3. Briefly examine the embryo and blastoderm under a dissecting microscope. If the vitelline membrane has also been transferred, use your watchmaker’s forceps to separate it from the blastoderm and examine it.Your instructor also may ask you to make other general observations or to practice turning over the blastoderm. When you have finished, discard the embryo and blastoderm, as well as the yolk, and proceed to detailed observations of stages of chick development.
The Living 12- to 15-Somite (33-Hour) Chick Embryo The length of incubation time required to provide embryos of this stage is somewhat variable and depends upon such factors as the previous handling of the eggs, incubation temperature, and possibly even upon the season of the year. In modern incubators, it usually takes somewhat more than 33 hours of incubation to carry development to this stage. It is, therefore, more accurate to describe the developmental stage of this, or any other, embryo in terms of either a recognized standard such as the Hamburger-Hamilton stages or of a clear morphological criterion such as somite number. 1. Crack an incubated egg and empty its contents into saline as done previously. The yolk is less likely to break at this earlier stage than at more advanced stages of incubation, but if the yolk breaks, discard the egg and saline and start over with another egg. You may need to rotate the yolk to bring the blastoderm into view. At this stage of development, the blastoderm area appears to consist of a series of irregular concentric rings. If there is a single, small, dense, white spot, the egg is probably sterile and ought to be discarded, but be cautious about discarding eggs until you are relatively certain about them. Even in the case of a normal blastoderm, the immediate response of students frequently is,“I can’t see a thing.” If the blastoderm area of yolk protrudes above the level of saline, add enough saline to submerge the blastoderm.
Laboratory 10
101
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
III. Chick Embryo Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
10. Patterns of Chick Development
proamnion
prosencephalon
optic vesicle mesencephalon rhombencephalon
border of foregut
sinus terminalis ventricle vitelline (omphalomesenteric) vein somite area opaca
closed neural tube
open neural folds notochord
primitive streak
area pellucida blood island
FIGURE 10.4 Dorsal view of a 14- or 15-somite chick embryo. prosencephalon
optic vesicle aortic arch I ventral aorta dorsal aorta bulbus cordis
border of foregut
ventricle sinoatrial region vitelline (omphalomesenteric) vein
anterior intestinal portal dorsal aorta somite notochord
FIGURE 10.5 Diagrammatic ventral view of a 14- or 15-somite chick embryo.
102
Laboratory 1 0
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
III. Chick Embryo Development
10. Patterns of Chick Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
2. Firmly grasp the area just outside the blastoderm with your watchmaker’s forceps. Continue to hold the forceps closed as you cut around the outside of the blastoderm. It is important to maintain your hold on the blastoderm as you complete your circular cut just outside the position of your forceps. If you relax your hold on the blastoderm at this time, it almost certainly will be lost as yolk rushes out through the cuts. After you have cut around the entire blastoderm, the vitelline membrane and blastoderm area can be gently slid off the yolk into the saline. Some yolk will adhere to the blastoderm, and it may be necessary to break the connection of this yolk with that being left behind by cutting into the yolk repeatedly with your scissors. When the blastoderm, with a small amount of adherent yolk, has been floated free, it can be transferred in a wide-mouth “chick pipette” to a Syracuse dish or small petri dish that is about 2/3 full of saline. Several difficulties can be encountered in this step. Since the blastoderm and vitelline membrane tend to stick to the inside of the pipette unless it is completely wetted, it is necessary to flush the pipette several times by repeatedly drawing saline in and out. Another problem is the tendency of stringy albumen to remain attached to the vitelline membrane and to pull the membrane and the blastoderm back out of the pipette during the transfer. This can cause damage to the blastoderm and is a source of considerable frustration. This stringy albumen either can be cut with a scissors or pinched off with a forceps. Sometimes, however, the only effective technique is to hold the flat handle of the forceps over the mouth of the pipette during the transfer process. It is also helpful to hold the pipette as close to horizontal as possible and to make the transfer quickly because there is a tendency for everything to run out of such a wide opening. Gently expel the contents into saline in a Syracuse dish. 3. Further work should be done under a dissecting microscope, and it is frequently helpful to switch from a light to a dark background and back again. Most students find it easier to see details of an embryo if it is illuminated from below or from the side rather than from above. Experiment with various patterns of illumination to find one that gives you a good view of the embryo.The blastoderm may still be covered by the vitelline membrane. If it is lying with the vitelline membrane on top, you will need to turn it over gently. When you have the ventral side exposed, remove the largest yolk granules by picking them off with your forceps or by squirting a gentle stream of saline from a Pasteur pipette. If the vitelline membrane still is attached, free the blastoderm by teasing it loose around the edges, using a forceps and a wooden-handled probe or a microsurgical needle. If this is done carefully, the blastoderm should survive the procedure without injury. It probably will be necessary to transfer the blastoderm to a second Syracuse dish with clean saline before further observations can be made. Be very careful during this final transfer of the fragile, unprotected blastoderm and make certain that the inside of your “chick pipette” is thoroughly pre-wetted. 4. Examine, sketch, and/or describe dorsal and ventral views of the 12- to 15-somite chick embryo using figures 10.4 and 10.5 for reference. It is difficult to locate some of the structures represented in figure 10.4 with certainty in the living embryo, but there are a number of general structural features that can be observed. Identify the somites, which are paired, compact chunks of mesodermal tissue that occur lateral to the neural tube. With your embryo against a dark background, count the number of somite pairs. If your embryo has fewer than 10 pairs, or more than 17 pairs, of somites, it may be difficult to use the descriptions that follow, and you should ask your instructor whether you ought to try another embryo. 5. You will note that there are differences in the apparent consistency of the blastoderm parts surrounding the embryo body proper. The relatively clear area adjacent to the embryo (area pellucida), along with the embryo itself, is separated from the yolk by a fluid-filled space when it is in place in the egg. The remainder of the blastoderm (area opaca) is situated in closer contact with the yolk, and its cells have attached yolk granules.This gives it a more opaque appearance. 6. During your examination of the dorsal side of the blastoderm, gently poke the embryo with a microsurgical needle, probe, or forceps tip in order to clarify its structural dimensions. Note that the embryo has a definite head region that is a clearly delineated tubular structure. Gently lift the head a little to demonstrate this for yourself.The head end of the embryo is, therefore, segregated from the remainder of the blastoderm. In the more posterior areas, you will note continuity of the still-flat posterior part of the embryo with the remainder of the flat blastoderm. The progressive segregation of the originally flat and continuous blastoderm into a rounded embryonic body area and an extraembryonic area is accomplished by a set of processes known as body folding. The necessity for this body folding is a function of the pattern of chick embryo cleavage, which is restricted to the flat disc of active cytoplasm on one side of the egg.
Laboratory 10
103
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
III. Chick Embryo Development
10. Patterns of Chick Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
first cleavage furrow
blastoderm (cellular blastodisc)
discrete cells cleavage furrow
FIGURE 10.6 Surface views of chick embryo cleavage.
blastoderm
yolk subgerminal space
epiblast hypoblast
FIGURE 10.7 Diagrammatic representation of the separation of the hypoblast and epiblast (delamination) in the chick embryo blastoderm. (These sections of blastoderms are more advanced than the blastoderms shown in fig. 10.6.)
104
Laboratory 1 0
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
III. Chick Embryo Development
10. Patterns of Chick Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
7. Examine the embryo against a light background and look for scattered reddish or orangish spots, the blood islands.These blood islands are early sites of blood cell production and are in the process of fusing to produce blood vessels.You may also be able to see some color in the sinus terminalis, which is a ringlike vessel encircling the margin of the blastoderm area that contains developing blood vessels. The cellular blastoderm does extend beyond the sinus terminalis, so the sinus does not mark the blastoderm margin. 8. While examining the ventral surface of the embryo, observe the heart and the vitelline (omphalomesenteric) veins, the large vessels that enter it posteriorly.You may observe some heart beating, but it probably will be just irregular pulsations. Note that there is an enclosed hollow gut ( foregut) in the anterior part of the embryo that is open posteriorly (fig. 10.5).This posterior opening to the outside is known as the intestinal portal.The foregut at this stage has been described as resembling the finger of a glove. Probe the gut to demonstrate its dimensions to your own satisfaction. 9. You may supplement your study of the 12- to 15-somite embryo by examining a commercially prepared stained slide of an embryo at this stage of development (that is, a “33-hour chick” slide).
Cleavage in the Chick Embryo Now that you have had opportunity to examine an embryo when some of the early phases of development have been completed, we will return to the initial stages of chick development and retrace some of the processes that produced the embryo that you have studied. Fertilization occurs in the upper portion of the hen’s oviduct, and cleavage begins there.The first developmental processes following fertilization occur as the egg passes through the hen’s oviduct and shell gland (uterus), and it is quite difficult to obtain embryos at these stages and prepare them for study.Therefore, we will simply describe some of the highlights of development before egg laying without asking you to make direct observations. Cleavage proceeds as the egg moves through the oviduct. Cleavage in the chick embryo is a form of incomplete (meroblastic) cleavage since the huge mass of yolk is not divided into separate cells. It is called discoidal cleavage because cleavage divisions are restricted to the active cytoplasmic area, the blastodisc. Early in cleavage, mitosis is not followed immediately by complete cytokinesis; that is, the nuclei are segregated by furrows in the center of the blastodisc (fig. 10.6). As additional mitotic divisions occur, the furrowing process spreads peripherally from the center. Soon, however, some discrete cells are produced as cytokinesis is completed in the center of the blastodisc (properly called the blastoderm from this point). Eventually, the blastoderm becomes several cells thick, and a fluid-filled subgerminal space develops underneath it. Gastrulation and Neurulation The beginning of gastrulation, the process that ultimately produces the major body layers (germ layers), also occurs during passage through the hen’s reproductive tract. Some of the cells of the blastoderm separate themselves from the remainder of the blastoderm and move down toward the subgerminal space to form small islands of cells (fig. 10.7).This initial segregation process occurs through the movements of individual cells or small groups of cells.Then a sheet of cells moves forward from a sickle-shaped area at the posterior margin of the blastoderm into the subgerminal space.This sheet incorporates the islands of cells that entered earlier. As a result of these processes, the embryo consists of two layers separated by a space.These layers are the newly formed lower layer, or hypoblast, which is rather loosely organized, and the upper layer, or epiblast, within which the cells are arranged in an orderly epithelial type of organization. This process of separation into two layers is known as delamination. The developmental fate of the hypoblast will be the production of the extraembryonic endoderm of the yolk sac and the yolk stalk, which connects the yolk sac to the embryonic gut. Following delamination, cells of the epiblast move to new positions in the embryo where they will participate in
Laboratory 10
105
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
III. Chick Embryo Development
10. Patterns of Chick Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
prospective extraembryonic ectoderm prospective epidermal ectoderm prospective neural ectoderm prospective notochord
prospective endoderm
prospective mesoderm
FIGURE 10.8 Fate map of the epiblast of the chick blastoderm before migration through the primitive streak commences. Cells of the future notochord, mesoderm, and endoderm areas will leave the surface and pass to the interior through the primitive streak.
Anterior Stage 1
area opaca
Stage 2
area pellucida
thickened area
Posterior
Anterior Stage 3
Stage 3⫹
developing primitive streak
Posterior
FIGURE 10.9 Stages in the formation of the primitive streak (Hamburger-Hamilton stages 1, 2, 3, 3⫹).
106
Laboratory 1 0
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
III. Chick Embryo Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
10. Patterns of Chick Development
the development of all parts of the embryonic body and several extraembryonic membranes. The developmental roles of the cells in various areas of the original epiblast can be summarized in the form of a fate map, such as the one shown in figure 10.8. At the time that the egg is laid, delamination is arrested and is resumed only if the egg is brought to incubation temperatures. When incubation is initiated, delamination continues, and other organizational changes occur in the blastoderm.A markedly thickened area develops in the epiblast on the posterior side of the blastoderm (fig. 10.9).This thickening is the beginning of the formation of the site of cellular migration that will occur during later stages of gastrulation.This area, the primitive streak, elongates as incubation proceeds. When active cell migration begins in the primitive streak, cells of the epiblast layer move across the surface to congregate at the primitive streak, leave the surface to move down in the direction of the subgerminal space, and then change direction to move out away from the streak to take their new places (fig. 10.10). Some of them spread laterally to establish the mesodermal layer, which is a new, third layer situated between the two previously existing layers. Other cells migrating through the primitive streak move downward where they displace hypoblast cells to establish the midline tissue that becomes the embryonic endoderm that produces the gut. 1. As migration through the streak continues, several structural features of the fully developed, or definitive primitive streak, can be identified (fig. 10.10). The midline of the streak becomes depressed, forming a shallow trough, the primitive groove, that lies between paired primitive ridges. At the anterior end of the streak, there is a particularly marked accumulation of migrating cells, Hensen’s node. Just posterior to this enlargement, the midline portion of the streak is deeply depressed to form the primitive pit.
Henson’s node (primitive knot) primitive pit primitive ridge primitive groove mesoderm cells epiblast
(a)
hypoblast
migrating cells
Henson’s node
primitive pit ectoderm
primitive streak
notochord
mesoderm endoderm
(b)
Anterior
Posterior
FIGURE 10.10 The mechanics of gastrulation in the chick embryo. (a) Diagrammatic cross section of the blastoderm showing the migration of epiblast cells through the primitive streak to produce mesoderm and embryonic endoderm. (b) Diagrammatic longitudinal section of the primitive streak showing the migration of cells that produce the notochord.
Laboratory 10
107
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
III. Chick Embryo Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
10. Patterns of Chick Development
proamnion Hensen’s node notochord
primitive groove primitive ridge
(b)
(a)
head fold
blood islands
(c) FIGURE 10.11 Early stages in the development of the chick embryo. (a) Definitive streak stage (stage 4). (b) Head-process stage (stage 5). (c) Head-fold stage (stage 6). (The stages are defined in V. Hamburger and H. L. Hamilton, 1951, J. Morphol. 88:49–92.) Photographs provided by Dr. H. L. Hamilton with the permission of the Wistar Press.
proamnion head fold anterior intestinal portal neural fold notochord neural plate hensen’s node
FIGURE 10.12 Dorsal view of “24-hour” chick embryo (stage 8, four pairs of somites). (The stage is defined by V. Hamburger and H. L. Hamilton, 1951, J. Morphol. 88:49–92.) Photograph provided by Dr. H. L. Hamilton with permission of the Wistar Press.
108
Laboratory 1 0
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
III. Chick Embryo Development
10. Patterns of Chick Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Examine a commercially prepared whole-mount slide of a definitive primitive streak stage ( H.-H. stage 4, 12to 16-hours incubation time) chick blastoderm and identify the areas of the streak and other features of the embryo (see fig. 10.11). 2. During early stages of migration through the primitive streak, the cells of the forming mesodermal layer spread laterally and posteriorly from the streak in the form of cell sheets. Migration of mesoderm in an anterior direction from the streak begins with a cord of cells that has moved through the primitive pit region. This cell cord produces the middorsal supporting element known as the notochord (figs. 10.10 and 10.11). As the notochord develops, the primitive streak begins to regress. The anterior end of the streak retreats, causing a shortening in the length of the streak.The shortening streak leaves behind the lengthening notochord that almost appears to be reeled out by the retreating tip of the primitive streak (fig. 10.11). Examine a commercial whole-mount slide of an 18-hour chick blastoderm. It may be necessary to examine several slides of this stage of development and to focus up and down on the slides in order to satisfy yourself that you have actually seen the notochord and other features of the blastoderm at this stage. 3. Before the completion of gastrulation, other developmental events are already under way.The formation of the central nervous system, neurulation, begins with the formation of a thickened area of ectoderm lying over the region of the notochord. This thickened neural plate rolls up into the cylindrical neural tube by processes that are roughly similar to those seen in the frog embryo. We will examine details of neural tube formation later. At the same time that the neural tube is forming, mesoderm paralleling the midline of the embryo becomes organized into the paired, segmentally arranged somites. As mentioned earlier, somite number is a much more reliable standard for communication of developmental stage than is incubation time because development of additional pairs of somites is closely related to the general level of ontogeny of the whole embryo.The first evidence of the body folding process that segregates the embryo proper from the remainder of the blastoderm can also be seen at about the same time.The head fold has undercut an embryo of this incubation stage to establish the embryo’s head (fig. 10.12). Examine a commercial “24-hour” embryo slide and identify as many of these features as possible. Prepare a living blastoderm of 28 to 30 hours incubation for study, using the technique employed in sections A and B. Identify the major landmarks of the embryo once again and then proceed to investigate the three-dimensional structure of the embryo. Probe the head region from the dorsal side and the foregut from the ventral side in order to clarify the nature and results of the head-folding process. Your instructor may request that you examine sections of the 24-hour embryo or other slide material to amplify the general outlines of early development that we have considered. Whether or not you make further observations on very early stages of chick development, we urge you to expand your understanding of early chick development by filling in details from your textbook and from the references listed in the “Suggestions for Further Investigation” section.
Laboratory 10
109
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
III. Chick Embryo Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
10. Patterns of Chick Development
wall of neural tube
skin ectoderm of head
optic vesicle somatic mesoderm splanchnic mesoderm subcephalic pocket
(a)
dorsal aorta
notochord aortic arch I head mesenchyme
(b)
endoderm
foregut
ventral aorta ectoderm dorsal aorta foregut
wall of neural tube notochord
(c)
coelomic space ventral aorta
dorsal aorta foregut
endocardium of ventricle epimyocardium of ventricle
thyroid rudiment
(d) dorsal aorta
vitelline vein (e)
anterior intestinal portal
FIGURE 10.13 Representative cross sections of 12- to 15-somite chick embryo.
110
Laboratory 1 0
Johnson:Johnson & Volpe’s Patterns & Experiments in Developmental Biology, 3/e
III. Chick Embryo Development
10. Patterns of Chick Development
© The McGraw−Hill Companies, 2004
Internal Structural Details of the 12- to 15-Somite Stage Chick Embryo Now that you have surveyed some basic events in early development and have a general grasp of some of the processes that lead to the formation of the “33-hour” chick, we will return to that stage of development for a somewhat more detailed study. The relationships of the various body layers to one another and their differentiation into specific structural elements of the embryo can be reconstructed through the study of serial sections of the embryo. 1. In order to put your study of serial sections in perspective, reexamine a commercially prepared “33-hour” chick whole-mount slide before you begin to examine serial sections. Note again such features as the differentiation of various areas of the neural tube, the structure and location of the heart, and the apparent extent of progress of body folding in freeing the head from the flat blastoderm (consult figs. 10.4 and 10.5). 2. Begin your study by skimming rather quickly through all of the sections from the anterior tip of the embryo through the last section. You will notice that the embryo apparently is unattached in the first sections that you encounter and that it is separated from the remainder of the blastoderm by a definite space, the subcephalic pocket (fig. 10.13a). As you proceed through the sections, you will reach those where the embryo is no longer physically separated from the remainder of the flat blastoderm.The point where this continuity is first observed is at the end of the free, tubular portion of the embryo, produced by body folding up to this time. Move on through the remainder of the slides noting the continuity of the embryo with the rest of the flat blastoderm and the general shape changes seen in embryonic structures at various levels of the body as you move posteriorly. 3. Return to the first sections of the head and trace the neural tube posteriorly through the body. Within a few sections, the neural tube will broaden laterally (fig. 10.13a).These lateral extensions are the optic vesicles that will produce major portions of the eyes. As you move further posteriorly, the neural tube changes in shape and size as the optic vesicles fade out and various other regions of the brain are sectioned. Eventually, the future spinal cord level of the neural tube is reached. Sections of the neural tube in the spinal cord region are characterized by a narrow, tall, sometimes slitlike, central cavity and a laterally compressed shape. Note also that the floor and roof of the spinal cord are relatively thin compared to the lateral walls.As you continue tracing sections, you will move into the region where the neural tube has not yet closed. In this region, you can identify the open neural groove and the paired neural folds (fig. 10.13g). By moving back and forth through the region of transition from closed to open neural tube, you should be able to mentally reconstruct the process of neural tube closure.You may wish to make sketches of your concept of neural tube closure and later compare them with those in textbooks. 4. During your examination of the neural tube, you undoubtedly will have noticed the circular notochord that lies just ventral to the neural tube. Quickly trace the notochord through its entire extent. Note that it does not extend all the way to the tip of the head, but rather is first encountered at a level of the body just posterior to the point where the optic vesicles fade out. Near its posterior end, sections of the notochord enlarge, and eventually, the notochord fuses with the floor of the open neural plate.As you progress beyond this point, you are entering the area of the primitive streak. It is somewhat difficult to give an exact description of guidelines that indicate that you have reached sections of the streak, but figure 10.13h is a representative section of the primitive streak level of the embryo.As you examine sections that include the primitive streak, you will note that streak tissue, the developing mesoderm, and probably the endoderm as well, are connected.This tissue continuity is characteristic of the levels of the body where the primitive streak is functioning. 5. The foregut (fig. 10.13b) appears in serial sections just posterior to the level at which the optic vesicles fade out.Trace the foregut posteriorly.You will note that it becomes laterally expanded and that it appears to be quite flattened dorsoventrally. However, remember that during your study of the living embryo at this stage, it was possible to insert a substantial object such as the tip of a microsurgical needle through the intestinal portal into the foregut. Continue tracing the foregut until the floor of the gut appears to pull apart within a span of three or four sections.You have now reached the level of the anterior intestinal portal (fig. 10.13e).You should