Preface Wide bandgap Ill-nitrides differ from the rest of III-V compound semiconductors in many aspects. They cover a broad range of optical spectrum including the ultraviolet portion; their most thermodynamically stable structure is wurtzite; they exhibit strong piezoelectric fields; they are chemically and physically strong, etc. In addition to these inherent peculiarities, there are many technical challenges associated with the growth and processing of these materials. Most specifically, lack of commercially available native substrates has forced the researchers to use substrates with mismatched lattice constants and thermal expansion coefficients. New ideas have had to be developed in order to reduce the number of dislocations present in the resulting material grown atop these substrates. Doping problems also, especially p-type doping, had plagued the development of these materials for a long time. All these substantial differences have separated Ill-nitrides from the rest of III-V materials and they are generally discussed independently. In the past few years, due to the great number of potential applications (Figure 1), Ill-nitrides have been studied vigorously and as a result significant advancements have taken place in this field. InGaN-based blue LEDs have found their market in full color displays and white lighting; blue laser diodes will be used in the next generation highcapacity CD/DVD read/write systems; UV LEDs and photodetectors have seen tremendous improvements in their properties and it will not be long before they are commercially available to be used for detection of biochemical agents, early missile threat warning, air/water purification, or even higher quality white lighting. Also these materials
High capacity optical data storage
Early missile threat warning
Detection of biochemical agents
Water purification
White lighting
Power line monitoring
Figure 1. Some of the potential applications of Ill-nitrides.
Mobile wireless communications
I
Flame monitoring
vi
Preface
have been successfully utilized to constitute high-frequency high-power transistor for RF transmission purposes. The aim of this book is to gather some of the most crucial information on properties and applications of Ill-nitrides in one place in the form of a handbook for the benefit of the nitride community. The book chapters cover a broad range of subjects from the material growth technology to devices such as light emitters, photodetectors, and high-power highfrequency applications. In addition, some of the other interesting properties of Ill-nitrides such as ferromagnetism, negative differential resistance, and phonon/electron-phonon interactions will be discussed. Several distinguished scientists have contributed their knowledge to this book and they have tried not only to present a historical review of the Ill-nitrides, but also to offer up-to-date advancements and future directions towards better understanding of these materials. Manijeh Razeghi Northwestern University, USA Mohamed Henini Nottingham University, UK
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides M. Razeghi and M. Henini (Eds.) © 2004 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Chapter 1
Introduction M. Razeghi^ and M. Henini'' ^Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Center for Quantum Devices, Northwestern University, Cook Room 4051, 2220 Campus Drive, Evanston, IL 60208-3129, USA ^School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Nottingham, NG7 2RD, UK
1.1.
INTRODUCTION
Wide bandgap Ill-nitrides, including (AI,Ga,In)-N, have seen enormous success in their development especially in the latest stages of the 20th century. Many substantial problems had to be overcome before these materials could constitute useful devices. High density of dislocations due to the lack of lattice-matched substrates and low doping efficiency were the most challenging problems that researchers in this area had to face. At the beginning, it was hard to believe that a material with a dislocation density in the order of 10^10^^ cm~^ would become the building block of many viable devices. However, thanks to the hard work of researches in this field, today blue/violet light-emitting diodes and laser diodes based on (Al,In,Ga)-N have been successfully commercialized. Blue/green LEDs have already found their market in full-color LCD displays and traffic lights, while blue LDs are expected to shortly replace red lasers in the current CD/DVD read/write systems. The unique properties of Ill-nitrides lead to a range of applications from optoelectronic devices to high-power electronics. The wide bandgap of GaN makes this material suitable not only for light emitting source but also for high-temperature applications. GaN and its alloys have the potential to form high power electronics such as transistors or thyristors. UV solar-blind photodetectors based on AlGaN have been demonstrated by several groups [1]. These detectors have applications in early missile threat detection and interception, chemical and biological threat detection, UV flame monitoring, and UV environmental monitoring. Due to the polar nature of the Ga-N bond, GaN does not possess inversion symmetry. Thus, when GaN is subject to an alternating electric field, the induced polarization is not symmetric. This property of GaN can be used in non-linear optics applications such as second-harmonic generation [2]. The same lack of inversion symmetry results in a huge piezoelectric field. There are some other conceivable
E-mail addresses:
[email protected] (M. Razeghi),
[email protected] (M. Henini).
2
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
applications for Ill-nitrides such as surface acoustic wave generation [3], acousto-optic modulator [4], and devices that utilize negative electron affinity [5]. Group Ill-nitride materials are different from some conventional semiconductors such as silicon (Si) and GaAs in a sense that under ambient conditions, the thermodynamically stable structure is wurtzite. Although zinc blende structure for GaN or InN could exist by forcing the film to grow on {001} crystal planes of cubic substrates, the intrinsic tendency of Ill-nitrides is to form a wurzite structure with a hexagonal symmetry. The large difference in electronegativity between the group III elements and nitrogen (Al = 1.18, Ga = 1.13, In = 0.99, N = 3.0) leads to very strong chemical bonds in Ill-nitride material system which together with a wide direct energy gap is the origin of some interesting properties of Ill-nitrides [6]. Ill-nitrides have a bandgap energy tunable from 6.2 eV for AIN to 3.4 eV for GaN to 2 eV or below for InN (The energy gap of InN has been the subject of many debates and it is not agreed upon yet. There have been some recent reports on the bandgap energy of InN being as narrow as 0.7 eV) [7,8]. This corresponds to a wavelength range of 200-650 nm or higher, covering a broad spectral range, from UV to visible. Figure 1.1 demonstrates where Ill-nitride compound semiconductors stand compared to other semiconductors in the space of lattice constant-bandgap energy.
ZnS ZnO
0
•
Direct Bandgap
•
Indirect Bandgap
MgSe
A
C UJ
CdTe
InN* InSb — I —
3.0
I
3.5
4.0
I
1
4.5
1
1
-
5.0
7.0
Lattice Constant (A)
Figure 1.1. Bandgap energy vs. lattice constant of Ill-nitride family and some of the other ffl-V and II-VI compound semiconductors. Note: Bandgap of InN has been reported to be as narrow as 0.7 eV (InN* on the graph).
Introduction Table 1.1. Some of the important physical parameters of Ill-nitrides and sapphire Parameter Lattice constant, a (A) Lattice constant, c (A) Energy gap (eV) Thermal conductivity (W/cm K) Thermal expansion coefficient. a, (10-^K-^) Thermal expansion coefficient, a, (10"^K"^) Electron effective mass, m* (mg) Heavy hole effective mass, m^h (mo) Dielectric constant (so)
GaN
AIN
3.189 5.186 3.44 1.3 4.3 (17-477°C)
3.112 4.982 6.2 2.0 5.27 (20-800°C)
4.0 (17-477°C)
4.15 (20-800°C)
0.2 0.8 8.9
0.4 3.5 8.5
InN 3.545 5.703 1.9
AI2O3
4.758 12.991
-
-
0.3
5.6 (280°C)
-
3.8 (280°C)
7.7 (20-500°C)
0.11 1.6 15.3
-
Direct and indirect bandgap semiconductors are represented by triangles and circles, respectively. The direct bandgap of Ill-nitrides is one of their most beneficial features for optoelectronic device applications. In addition, the wide bandgap of Ill-nitrides results in a low intrinsic carrier density which in turn leads to low leakage and low dark current, especially important for photodetectors and high-temperature electronics. It is also known that Ill-nitrides are very robust materials with high melting points and mechanical strength. Adding to the list the ability to resist radiation damage yields a material system suitable for high-frequency, high-power and high-temperature applications. Some of the physical properties of Ill-nitrides are listed in Table 1.1. The data are complied from Refs. [9-11]. Some of the parameters for sapphire (the most widely used substrate for growth of Ill-nitrides) are also listed in this table. Owing to their direct bandgap, Ill-nitrides are promising candidates for optical devices such as laser diodes (LDs), light-emitting diodes (LEDs), and photodetectors. Not long ago, blue/violet LDs with lifetime of over 10,000 h were successfully demonstrated [12] and consequently commercialized. Implementation of blue LDs into CD/DVD read/write systems in computers will increase the data storage capacity by five times. This enhancement will become even larger when using UV LDs instead. The diameter of the focused laser beam is directly proportional to the laser wavelength. A, and inversely proportional to the numerical aperture, NA, of the imaging lens (Figure 1.2). The spot area is the square of the spot diameter:
A oc
VNAJ
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
' Spot size Figure 1.2.
Illustration of a compact disc and a focused laser beam for read/write purpose.
The maximum areal density is the number of bits per spot, b, per spot area, A:
It has been several years since GaN/InGaN blue LEDs found their market in automotive dashboard lighting, full-color LED displays, indicator lighting, and LCD back lighting (Figure 1.3). The success in mass production of these highly efficient high-brightness InGaN/GaN blue LEDs basically put an end to II-VI (ZnSe/ZnS) blue LED research. UV solar-blind photodetectors have also been demonstrated in AlGaN/GaN material systems. Early missile threat warning, detection of chemical/biological agents, flame detection, power line monitoring, and non-line-of-sight (NLOS) communication (when combined with UV light emitters) are among the most important applications of solarblind photodetectors. In addition to optical devices, a lot of advances have taken place in the area of highpower, high-frequency power transistors for RF transmission applications, thanks to the high thermal conductivity, high melting point, low dielectric constant, and high breakdown voltage of Ill-nitrides. GaN HEMTs can alleviate many of the problems associated with the current LDMOS technology for mobile wireless communications due to their inherently higher transconductance, good thermal management and higher cut-off frequencies. The GaN HEMT technology aims at applications such as ship-board, airborne and ground RADARs, high-performance space electronics, base station transmitters, C-band Satcom, Ku-K band VSAT and broadband satellites, LMDS and digital radio. GaN HEMTs are capable of generating high power per unit area that translates into smaller devices with higher impedances. Also their high breakdown voltage enables them to operate at high voltages eliminating the need for voltage conversion. In addition, due to their high electron velocity, high-frequency operation is possible. These
Introduction
Figure 1.3. GaN-based blue/green LEDs have been used for traffic lights, LCD back lighting, and full-color LED displays (image of US cellular field in Chicago, courtesy of www.diamond-vision.com).
properties combined with the direct nature of their bandgap have made the GaN family a promising candidate for high-power high-frequency electronics. Although not studied in as much details as InGaN-based blue light emitters, AlGaNbased UV LEDs have also been investigated by several groups and emitters with wavelengths as short as 267 runs have been demonstrated [13]. There are numerous applications for ultraviolet light emitters. White LEDs for efficient, low-cost lighting, high-density optical data storage, water purification, portable chemical and biological agent detection/analysis systems, and NLOS communication are a few of them. Currently available incoherent UV light sources include high-intensity arc discharge lamps and fluorescent lamps. Table 1.2 summarizes advantages and disadvantages of these two technologies along with those of Ill-nitride-based UV LEDs. By combining UV LEDs and UV photodetectors, a compact system that can immediately identify certain biological agents is possible. In principle, many biological agents fluoresce when excited by a UV light source. The fluorescence emission is normally several nanometers longer than the excitation wavelength. For instance. Figure 1.4 shows the absorption and emission spectra of Phenylalanine. In this example, a UV light source with a monochromatic emission at 257 nm along with a UV photodetector with a band pass-like detection spectra peaked at around 280 nm can form a system capable of detecting this particular agent (Figure 1.5). A series of such
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides Table 1.2. Advantages and disadvantages of (Al,In,Ga)-N based UV LEDs compared to the existing technologies Technology
Disadvantages
Advantages
High-intensity arc discharge lamps
High power
Fluorescent lamps
Efficient
Ill-nitride UV LEDs
Compact, low power consumption, efficient, low turn-on, easy for system integration, resistant to radiation damage and magnetic fields, light, inexpensive
Requires bulky power supply, short lifetime, high power consumption Linear sources (hard to focus their light) Immature technology
LED/photodetector sub-systems each tuned at a particular wavelength of interest can be used to detect a range of biological agents. There is a need for a secure means to send messages in the field using low-power communication systems, a requirement that cannot be met with conventional RF radios. Covert communication is made possible by UV sources that exploit the solar-blind region
257.5 nm
eHjN^ ^co^e 279.5 nm
Phenylalanine Absorption Fluorescence
*0^4Am I
300
I
400
>ii"^"»» »*'
I
500
600
700
Wavelength (nm) Figure 1.4.
Absorption and fluorescence curves of phenylalanine peak at 257.5 and 279.5 nm, respectively.
Introduction UV photodetector
UV light
Cloud of unknown agent Figure 1.5.
^^^
^
"
Fluorescence
Basic representation of a system for detection of biochemical hazards.
located at 280 nm and below. In this region of the spectrum, the terrestrial solar flux is essentially zero, and the very low background can be used for NLOS communications over distances up to 250 m. The strong extinction coefficient (high scattering, high absorption) of the signal in the UV makes it difficult to detect these emissions from a distance, particularly in the forward direction. The success of such a portable UV frequency communicator unit depends on the availability of a compact, powerful and energy-efficient optical source. Blue/UV LEDs are also currently being utilized to generate white light. LEDproduced white light is cheap, durable, and more efficient than currently used light sources. One of the important applications of white LEDs is in medical illuminators. Most surgical systems are based on incandescent Ught bulbs. These light sources are simple to use, easily dimmable, and have a low initial cost. However, they are also sensitive to shock and vibration, sensitive to voltage variations, have short lifetime, consume too much power, and are inefficient (10-20 ImAV). On the other hand, Hght sources based on LED technology have long lifetime, are compact, efficient, and durable, and require low maintenance. There are three common methods for generation of white light: one method is to combine red, green, and blue (RGB) colors in order to achieve white color. Although this method can be very efficient and allows for a very good color rendering, some problems such as color mixing and existence of the yellow-green gap are yet to overcome. Another way of generating white light is to use blue color together with yellow phosphorus. This method is simple and exhibits good color rendering. However, it is limited on efficiency due to phosphorus conversion efficiency and self-absorption. In addition, multi-phosphor versions are needed to improve color rendering. The third and last approach is to use UV LED pumped RGB phosphors. In this case, white light is determined by phosphors only (tolerant to LED variation), excellent color rendering is possible, and it is easy to manufacture.
8
Optoelectronic
Devices:
Ill-Nitrides
One of the newest GaN-related research topics is the GaN-based diluted magnetic semiconductors (DMS). Spin polarizers, spin transistors, and ultra-dense non-volatile semiconductor memory are among the new class of devices and circuits based on magnetic semiconductors. In this regard, GaAs DMS has been studied more extensively. However, the Curie temperature of (Ga,Mn)As is low ( ~ 110 K). (Ga,Mn)N DMS on the other hand, has been shown to have Curie temperatures exceeding room temperature [14,15], which shows promise for realization of room temperature spintronics devices based on GaN DMS. A number of renowned scientists have contributed their knowledge to this book. A variety of useful information on some of the important properties and applications of Ill-nitrides has been collected in this book and our hope is that the scientific community will find this information helpful.
REFERENCES [1] Razeghi, M. (2002) Proc. IEEE, 90, 1006. [2] Miragliotta, J. & Wickenden, D.K. (1998) in Non-linear Optical Properties of GaN 50 B, Eds. Pankove, I. & Moustakas, T.D., Academic Press, San Diego. [3] Duffy, M.T., Wang, C.C, O'Clock, G.D., McFarlane, S.H., III & Zanzucchi, P.J. (1973) /. Electron. Mater., 2, 359. [4] Lotsch, H.K.V. & Schroter, F. (1970) Das Laser-Farbfensehen. Laser, 2, 37. [5] Pankove, J.I. & Schade, H.E.P. (1974) Appl. Phys. Lett., 25, 53. [6] Razeghi, M. (1998) Int. J. High Speed Electron. Syst., 9, 161. [7] Davydov, V.Y., Klochikhin, A.A., Emtsev, V.V., Ivanov, S.V., Vekshin, V.V., Bechstedt, F., FurthmuUer, J., Harima, H., Mudryi, A.V., Hashimoto, A., Yamamoto, A., Aderhold, J., Graul, J. & Haller, E. (2002) Phys. Stat. Sol. (b), 230, R4. [8] Wu, J., Walukiewicz, W., Wu, K.M., Ager, J.W., IE, Haller, E.E., Lu, H., Schaff, W.J., Saito, Y. & Nanishi, Y. (2002) Appl. Phys. Lett., 80, 3967. [9] Madelung, O. Ed. (1991) Semiconductors: Group IV Elements and III-V Compounds, Springer, Berlin. [10] Madelung, O. (1996) Semiconductors—Basic Data, l""^ Edition Springer, Berlin. [11] Leszczynski, M., Suski, T., Perlin, P., Teisseyre, H., Grzegory, I., Bockowski, M., Jun, J., Porowski, S. & Major, J. (1995) J. Phys., D28, A149. [12] Nakamura, S., Senoh, M., Nagahama, S., Iwasa, N., Yamada, T., Kiyoku, H., Sugimoto, Y., Kozaki, T., Umemoto, H., Sano, M. & Chocho, K. (1997) Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 36, L1568. Part 2. [13] Yasan, A., McClintock, R., Mayes, K., Darvish, S.R., Kung, P. & Razeghi, M. (2003) Appl. Phys. Lett., 83, 4701. [14] Dietl, T., Ohno, H., Matsukura, F., Cibert, J. & Ferrand, D. (2000) Science, 287, 1019. [15] Reed, M.L., El-Masry, N.A., Stadelmaier, H.H., Ritmus, M.K., Reed, M.J., Parker, C.A., Roberts, J.C. & Bedair, S.M. (2001) Appl. Phys. Lett., 79, 3473.
optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides M. Razeghi and M. Henini (Eds.) © 2004 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Chapter 2
The Rise of Ill-nitrides: An Introduction Patrick Kung Department ofECE, Center for Quantum Devices, Northwestern University, 2145 Sheridan Road, Evanston, IL 60208, USA
The nitrides of group III metal elements or "Ill-nitrides" (or "III-N") commonly refer to aluminum nitride (AIN), gallium nitride (GaN), indium nitride (InN) and their alloys, all of which are compounds of nitrogen—the smallest group V element in the Periodic Table and an element with one of the highest values of electronegativity. Long regarded as a scientific curiosity, Ill-nitrides have now earned a most respected place in the science and technology of compound semiconductors, as well as modem electronic and optoelectronic devices. Unlike more conventional semiconductors, such as silicon (Si) or gallium arsenide (GaAs) which have a diamond or zinc-blende structure with a cubic symmetry, Ill-nitride semiconductors crystallize in their most stable form into a wurtzite crystallographic structure (Table 2.1) with nitrogen atoms forming a hexagonal close packed (hep) structure and the group III atoms occupying half of the tetrahedral sites available in the hep lattice [1,2]. Ill-Nitrides are polar crystals as they do not have a center of symmetry [3]. They thus possess many other potentially useful properties such as piezoelectricity [4], pyroelectricity [5] and non-linear optical properties [6,7]. The large difference in electronegativity between the group III and group V elements (Al = 1.18, G a = 1.13, In = 0.99, N = 3.1) results in very strong chemical bonds within the Ill-nitride material system, which is at the origin of most of the exceptional Ill-nitride physical properties (listed in Table 2.2); that have increasingly spurred interest within the research community. Most importantly, AlInGaN compounds exhibit a direct bandgap energy that can be continuously tailored between 0.7 and 6.2 eV, which corresponds to a wavelength range from 1.78 ixm to 200 nm and thus covers the near infrared, visible or near ultraviolet spectral bands. Figure 2.1 compares the bandgap energy versus lattice constants of Ill-nitrides with that of various semiconductors. Furthermore, because the intrinsic carrier concentration is an exponential function of the energy gap and the temperature, wide bandgap Ill-nitride semiconductors have a much lower intrinsic carrier concentrations over a larger temperature range than Si or GaAs. This results in lower leakage and dark currents, which is especially important in photodetectors
E-mail address:
[email protected] (P. Kung).
9
10
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides Table 2.1. Crystallographic data of Ill-nitrides III-N Structure type Crystal system Space group Origin
Wurtzite Hexagonal P6T,mc (No. 186) 3ml; (N^~): positions: 2b site symmetry: 3m» (ai,a2,«3) = (0,0,0.375) (III^^): positions: 2b site symmetry: 3m« (ai,a2,«3) = (0,0,0)
Coordination
and electronic devices. Another consequence of the strong chemical bonding is the physical (high melting points, mechanical strength) and chemical stability of these materials. These also enjoy high thermal conductivity. Their effective masses are higher than conventional semiconductors, thus leading to lower carrier mobilities, but this is made up for by the highsaturated electron drift velocities predicted for this material system. The refractive indices of Ill-nitrides are lower compared to narrower gap semiconductors, which results in a lower
Table 2.2. Physical properties of Ill-nitride materials
300 K energy gap (eV) Lattice constant, a (A) Lattice constant, c (A) Thermal expansion coefficient a^ (10~^K~*) Thermal expansion coefficient a, (10"^ K~') Electron effective mass, mg (mo) Hole effective mass, m^ (mo) Refractive index, n
AIN
GaN
6.2 3.112 4.982 5.27 (20-800°C)
3.44 3.189 5.186 4.3 (17-477°C)
0.7 3.545 5.703 5.6 (280°C)
4.15 (20-800°C)
4.0 (17-477°C)
3.8 (280°C)
0.2
0.11 0.5 (mhh) 0.17 (mih) 2.56 (1,0 fxm) 3.12 (0.66 |xm)
1100 -23.0 10.0
e(0)
2.2 (0.60 \xm) 2.5 (0.23 iJim) 9.14
e(oo)
4.84
Thermal conductivity, K (W/cm K) Melting point (°C) ^(f (kcal/mol) Heat capacity. Cp (cal/mol K)
2.0
0.8 2.35 (1.0 (Jim) 2.60 (0.38 |xm) 10.4 (ElIc) 9.5 (E 1 c) 5.8(Ellc) 5.4 (E 1 c) 1.7-1.8
3000 -68.2 7.6
>1700 -33.0 9.7
InN
9.3
The Rise of Ill-nitrides: An Introduction
11
A Direct Bandgap
6 1
•
Indirect Bandgap
5 H
>
ZnS
4 -\
ZnO
MgSe
• (D C LJJ Q. CD D) T3 C TO GQ
3 H
InN*
~-|— 3.0
I
3.5
4.0
'
I 4.5
'
\ 5.0
5.5
7.0
Lattice Constant (A) Figure 2.1. Bandgap energy versus lattice constant of various semiconductors, including Ill-nitrides. The bandgap energy of InN was recently reported to be 0.7 eV instead of earlier reported 2 eV.
reflectivity at the interface. This is an advantage for photodetector efficiency, but a disadvantage when trying to achieve lasers with low threshold currents. The historical development of Ill-nitrides can be punctuated by the series of milestones listed in Table 2.3, grouped into four phases. For a large part, the research work has often taken example from the development of GaAs-based compounds, first for the fundamental reason that GaN and GaAs are both III-V semiconductor compounds with a direct bandgap and secondly for the practical reason that the technology of GaAs could be adapted to manufacture GaN compounds—up to a certain extent. Phase I corresponds to the major part of the 20th century, before 1960. Although the first AIN, GaN and InN compounds were synthesized as early as 1907 [8], 1910 [9] and 1932 [10], respectively, i.e. much earlier than conventional GaAs and Si semiconductors, no significant progress could be reported until the end of the 1960s. This was mainly due to the fact that Ill-nitride crystals had been very difficult to synthesize. Thanks to the development of modem epitaxial growth techniques, it was possible during the Phase II (1960- 1970s) period to demonstrate the first growth of GaN thin films by hydride vapor phase epitaxy (HVPE) in 1969 [11]. This was quickly followed in 1971 with the first metalorganic chemical vapor deposition (MOCVD) [12] and then the first
12
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
Table 2.3. Historical milestones in the development of Ill-nitride semiconductors Phase I
1907 1910 1932
Synthesis of AJN Synthesis of InN Synthesis of GaN
Phase II
1969 1971
1974 1975 1976
Epitaxy of GaN, by HVPE MOCVD of GaN Stimulated emission in GaN (needles) by optical pumping Metal-insulator-semiconductor GaN-based LED MBE of GaN MBE of AIN Bulk ALN crystals
Phase III
1983 1986 1989
Concept of low temperature buffer layer MOVPE of crystalUne GaN using AIN buffer layer P-type GaN using LEEBI
Phase IV
1990 1991
Stimulated emission by optical pumping of high-quality GaN GaN buffer by MOCVD GaN p - n junction blue LED P-type AlGaN 2DEG at AlGaN/GaN interface High-quality InGaN GaN photoconductor P-type GaN using thermal anneaUng AlGaN/GaN HEMT or HFET GaN MESFET, MISFET Schottky barrier GaN photodiode Conmiercial candela class blue InGaN LEDs Bulk GaN crystals GaN/SiC HBT (GaN/SiC heterointerface) Microwave HFET, MISFET Microwave GaN MESFET Conunercial candela class "bluish-green" InGaN LED P-type InGaN GaN-AIN SIS junction detector AlGaN/GaN HFET photodetector GaN p - n junction photodiode Pulsed operation blue laser diode 410 nm InGaN yellow LED Commercial "pure green" InGaN LEDs Ion implanted GaN JFET Doped channel AlGaN/GaN HEMT AlGaN photoconductor White LED using phosphors First continuous wave blue laser diode Complete range of AlGaN photoconductors Ultraviolet LED
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
(continued)
The Rise of Ill-nitrides: An Introduction
13
Table 2.3. Continued
1998
1999
2000
2001 2002
2003 2004
10,000 h lifetime RT CW InGaN violet LD Schottky barrier AlGaN photodiode AlGaN/GaN HBT GaN MOSFET GaN p - i - n 32 X 32 focal plane array Visible blind AlGaN p - i - n photodiode Sample shipment of blue-violet laser diode Solar blind AlGaN p - i - n photodiode GaN p - i - n 128 X 128 focal plane array GaN avalanche photodiodes MOSHFET in AlGaN (metal-oxide semiconductor heterostructure FET) Commercialization of blue-violet laser diode InN bandgap determined to be 0.7 eV 256 X 256 AlGaN solar blind focal plane array AlGaN UV LEDs at 280 nm Sample shipment of UV laser diodes at 375 nm AlGaN UV LEDs at 265 nm AlGaN UV laser at 350.9 nm
molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) of GaN in 1974 [13]. The first epitaxial growth of AIN was reported in 1975 [14]. The quality of these GaN crystals was sufficient to enable the study of their optical properties. In particular, the first observation of stimulated emission from GaN needles was observed in 1971 [15], prefiguring the demonstration of a blueultraviolet wavelength laser diode 20 years later. However, as it was still impossible to realize bulk Ill-nitride crystals, the epitaxial process had to be performed on non-native substrates and the quality of the GaN films was very poor. Phase III of the development stage of Ill-nitrides, spanning the 1980s, can be considered as the critical period when two fundamental breakthroughs were made. The first one was the introduction of the concept of a low-temperature nucleation layer which permitted the growth of smooth GaN thin films on a foreign substrate in 1983 [16]. This was followed by the demonstration of high-quality crystalline GaN films in 1986 [17]. The second breakthrough was the demonstration of p-type GaN films through low-energy electron beam irradiation (LEEBI) to activate p-type dopants in 1989 [18]. The p-type activation process was later refined in 1992 using thermal annealing [19]. Phase IV corresponds to the period from 1990 until today. It experienced the most dramatic and spectacular research and development work in Ill-nitride based compound semiconductor science and technology to date [20-33]. It is clear that understanding and controlling the optical properties of Ill-nitrides have been the first and primary driving force behind the research work in an effort to realize blue and green light-emitting diodes (LEDs) and laser diodes (LDs). Such components had long been desired in order to achieve bright full color electroluminescent displays, traffic lighting, automobile lighting, and higher
14
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
density optical data storage. Now, wide bandgap Ill-nitride semiconductors have truly become the cornerstone technology for such devices, supplanting technologies such as silicon carbide (SiC) for blue LEDs, AlInGaP for green LEDs, and zinc selenide for blue and green LDs, even though these had been much more mature and well developed and had already been commercialized at the time the GaN material quality was still poor. This impressive research and development work culminated with the commercialization of candela class GaN-based blue LEDs in 1993 [34] and the realization of the first GaN-based laser diode under pulse operation in 1995 [35,36]. Since then, the development of lasers has followed an accelerated course, with milestones such as the demonstration of continuous wave operation [37], a lifetime of 10,000 h in 1997 [38], which led to the successful conMnercialization of room temperature continuous wave blue-violet laser diodes in 2001 [34]. One instrumental element in realizing long lifetime lasers was the development of lateral epitaxial overgrowth as a method to reduce dislocations in heteroepitaxially grown GaN [39,40]. The performance and reliability of these lasers have been sufficient to allow mass production and start establishing the basic specifications of a standard for next generation high-density optical disk video recordings. One of the leading standard format currently being developed, called "Blu-ray Disc", is expected to make possible "the recording, rewriting and playback of up to 27 GB of data on a single-sided, single-layer 12 cm CD/DVD-size disc using a 405 nm blue-violet laser" [41,42]. These scientific and commercial successes in realizing blue LEDs and lasers, accomplished in such a short period of time, have since spurred a plethora of activity associated with Ill-nitrides. For example, the first yellow/amber LED based on InGaN have been reported in 1995 [43]. Subsequently, the most commercially significant development since then has been the demonstration of a novel light source in 1996 in the form of a white LED that combined a blue LED and a phosphor coating [44]. The potential of this technology as a cheap, low energy consumption, more environmentally friendly solid-state light source has led to a large effort in the US called the "National Next Generation Lighting Initiative" that involves industry, universities and national laboratories [45]. Another current challenge for light emitters is to push the Ill-nitride technology to shorter wavelengths (below 340 nm) for applications such as laser-induced fluorescence of chemical/biological agents, water purification and non-line-of-sight communications. For these purposes, AlGaN ultraviolet LEDs emitting at 340 and 280 nm with increasing powers have been consistently reported [46-50]. Furthermore, AlGaN LED emitting at a wavelength as low as 267 nm have been successfully demonstrated in 2003 [51]. Sample shipments of UV laser diodes with wavelength as short as 375 nm have been initiated in 2002 [34]. And the shortest wavelength laser diode emitting at 350.9 nm was also recently demonstrated [52]. A further area of research with growing interest is that of visible-blind and solar-blind ultraviolet (UV) photodetectors based on Ill-nitrides for use in many applications such as covert space-to-space communications, early missile threat warning, UV astronomy.
The Rise of Ill-nitrides: An Introduction
15
chemical and biological agent detection, flame detection, engine and furnace monitoring [53,54]. Such devices can also be used for autocorrelation measurements [55]. The visible or solar blindness is the property that the photodetector is sensitive to UV light while being (ideally) insensitive to visible or solar light, and is a key parameter for photodetectors which are expected to detect UV light in a strong visible and/or infrared background. Compared to existing solid-state or other technologies, Ill-nitride semiconductors can lead to devices that are cheaper, more efficient and more robust. After the first report of a GaN ultraviolet photodetector in 1992 [56], that of GaN p - n junction photodiode in 1995 [57], and the demonstration of metal-semiconductor-metal GaN photodetectors [58], the entire range of AlGaN photodetectors has been demonstrated in 1996 with cut-off wavelengths from 200 to 365 nm [59-61], followed by the demonstration of AlGaN p - i - n photodiodes [62-65] and by the realization of increasingly larger size focal plane arrays between 1999 and 2002 [66-68]. With the recent report that the bandgap of InN is only 0.7 eV, there is likely to be a growing interest in Ill-nitrides for high-efficiency solar cells [69]. In addition to optoelectronic devices, Ill-nitrides have a proven potential for RFmicrowave-millimeter wave as well as high-power electronic devices in order to revolutionize high-power electrical energy control, conversion, and distribution, as well as to support applications such as all electric vehicles, wireless communications and radar technology. Two figures of merit generally used to characterize materials for electronic devices can be used to explain the interest that the research community has for Ill-nitrides. The first one, the Johnson figure of merit JFM = {E^VJlTff, where E^ is the breakdown voltage and V^ is the saturation velocity, is related to the electronic properties of materials. It characterizes the frequency-power trade-off, since high frequency usually requires small device dimension while high power need large device size. The Keyes figure of merit, KFM = ajicvjlire)^^^, where OY is the thermal conductivity of the materials and 8 is its dielectric constant, is related to the material thermal properties. It characterizes the device size and thermal resistance trade-off. The values are generally normalized to Si. The values for the JFM and KFM, listed in Tables 2.4 and 2.5, respectively [70], confirm GaN-based semiconductors are very promising for electronic devices. Table 2.4. Comparison of the Johnson figures of merit of different materials [70] Material
E^iWIcm)
n (cm/s)
Si GaAs GaN 6H-SiC 3C-SiC Diamond
3X10^ 4X10^ 50 X 10^ 40 X 10^ 40 X 10^ 100 X 10^
1.0 X 2.0 X 2.7 X 2.0 X 2.0 X 2.7 X
10^ 10^ 10^ 10^ 10^ 10^
[{E^V,)liTf
(VW)
9.1 X 10^^ 64.8 X 10^^ 18466 X 10^^ 6485 X 10^^ 6485 X 10^^ 73863 X 10^^
Ratio to silicon 1.0 7.1 2029 712 712 8117
16
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
Table 2.5. Comparison of the Keyes figures of merit of different materials [70] Material
o-T (300 K) (W/cm)
V, (cm/s)
er
ajiVJe.y^ (W/cm^V^^)
Ratio to silicon
Si GaAs GaN 6H-SiC 3C-SiC Diamond
1.5 0.5 1.3 5.0 5.0 20.0
1.0X10^ 2.0 X 10^ 2.7 X 10^ 2.0 X 10^ 2.0 X 10^ 2.7 X 10^
11.8 12.8 9 9.7 9.7 5.5
13.8 X 10^ 6.25 X 10^ 22.5 X 10^ 71.8 X 10^ 71.8 X 10^ 443.1 X 10^
1.0 0.45 1.6 5.2 5.2 32.1
The first experimental indication of this potential came with the reported observation of a two-dimensional electron gas at AlGaN/GaN heterointerface in 1992 [71]. The subsequent year saw the demonstration of AlGaN/GaN high-electron mobility transistors [72]. And in 1998, the first AlGaN/GaN heterojunction bipolar transistor was reported [73].
Table 2.6. Comparison of the lattice properties and energy gaps of ni-nitrides with potential substrate materials [69,70] Formula name (crystal symmetry)
GaN (hexagonal) AIN (hexagonal) InN (hexagonal) AI2O3 (trigonal) 4H-SiC (hexagonal) 6H-SiC (hexagonal) LiGa02 (orthorhombic) LiAlOi (tetragonal) ZnO (hexagonal) MgO (cubic) Si (cubic) GaAs (cubic) GaP (cubic)
Lattice constants (A)
a = 3.1891; c = 5.1855 a = 3.112; c = 4.982 a = 3.5365; c = 5.7039 a = 4.758; c = 12.991 a = 3.073; c = 10.053 fl = 3.081; c = 15.117 a = 5.402; b = 6.372; c = 5.007 a = 5.1715; c = 6.2840 a = 3.253; c = 5.213 4.216 5.4310202 5.65325 5.4512
Plane with nearest match to (0001) GaN
Effective a lattice constant (A)
Lattice mismatch with GaN (%)
Energy gap
(^GaN ~ '^subV'^sub
(0001)
3.1891
0
3.44
(0001)
3.112
2.47
6.2
(0001)
3.53656
-9.82
0.7
(0001) rotated 30° (0001)
2.747
16.09
>8.5
3.073
3.77
3.20
(0001)
3.081
3.51
2.86
(001)
3.119, 3.186
2.25, 0.10
(100)
6.81, 1.50
(0001)
2.986, 3.142 3.253
-1.97
3.44 (1.6 K)
(111) (111) (111) (111)
2.981 3.840 3.99745 3.8546
4.93 -16.96 -20.22 -17.26
7.9 1.1242 1.424 2.26
The Rise of Ill-nitrides: An Introduction
17
Table 2.7. Comparison of the thermal properties of Ill-nitrides with potential substrate materials, including their thermal expansion coefficient or TEC {d^), thermal conductivity, and melting point [70] Formula name
a-a(10-^K-^) 0-1000°C
Mismatch with GaN by cooling 1000°C (%) (TECcaN ~ TECsub) X (-1000 K)
Thermal conductivity (W/cm K)
Melting temperature (°C)
GaN AIN InN
5.6 (0 to 600°C) 5.7 5.7 (300°C) 8.6 4.46 4.44 -7
0 0.01 0.01 0.30 -0.11 -0.12 0.14
1.7-1.8 2.0 4.9 0.3
>1700 3000 1100 2015
AI2O3
4H-SiC 6H-SiC LiGaOs LiAlOs ZnO MgO Si GaP GaAs
7.8 13.85 3.90 4.7 6.7
0.22 0.83 -0.17 -0.09 0.11
4.9
0.36 1.3 1.1 0.5
-1600 -1700 -2000 2800 1412 1470 1240
Looking into the future, as InN exhibits the highest saturation velocity of all Ill-nitride compounds, as high as 4.2 X 10^ cm/s, InN is a highly potential material for the fabrication of high-speed field effect transistors. To support all these exceptional technological endeavors, epitaxial growth techniques have significantly improved. Indeed, instead of adapting existing equipment originally used for GaAs, which may have been useful for the demonstration stage, new MOCVD and MBE growth apparatus have been engineered to accommodate and facilitate the growth of Ill-nitrides, including high growth temperatures and in situ monitoring in MOCVD. Bulk GaN substrates have been successfully grown first in 1994 [74], using high-pressure and high-temperature growth techniques. Since then, easier methods have been developed which also led to large bulk crystals. Hundreds of micrometer thick GaN films are now grown by HVPE on a foreign substrate, followed by an epitaxial lift-off and polishing to obtain a quasi-bulk single crystal. AIN substrates are now also being developed, with higher quality than originally reported in the 1970s [75], in order to support the drive toward shorter wavelength optoelectronics. However, the quality, dimension, availability and cost of these substrates are still too high for widespread use. This is why, to date, the quasientirety of Ill-nitride thin films are still grown on non-native substrates and the choice of the most appropriate substrate material is still an issue. In Tables 2.6 and 2.7, the physical properties of several candidate substrate materials are compared with those of Ill-nitrides,
18
Optoelectronic
Devices:
Ill-Nitrides
including their lattice mismatch with GaN and the thermal mismatch when cooling by 1000°C. Three substrates stand out to be the most promising ones: silicon (Si), 6H silicon carbide (6H-SiC) and sapphire (AI2O3) [20-24,26,28,40]. The choice of Si remains a desirable approach because it is the most widely used electronic material, is widely available in large areas and is very cheap. However, it does not have a crystal structure and physical properties similar to Ill-nitrides, and exhibits a lattice mismatch of ~ 17% with GaN. Silicon carbide presents the closest match with Ill-nitrides (lattice mismatch with GaN is only 3.5%) out of the three candidates but SiC substrates are still expensive in comparison with other alternative substrates, although the technology is progressing rapidly to bring prices down thanks mainly to the commercial thrust from Ill-nitride based devices. Sapphire offers a compromise between these two extremes as it is the most widely used substrate to date; high-quality wafers are widely available and are cheaper than SiC, and it has a similar hexagonal crystal symmetry as Ill-nitrides. In summary, after nearly a century since the first synthesis of AIN, Ill-nitride semiconductors have become one cornerstone of modem optoelectronic and electronic devices thanks to a spectacular research and development in the last 20 years. It is still too early to estimate their scientific and economic impact, but one can confidently say that it is not less significant than that of gallium arsenide. REFERENCES [1] Kung, P., Sun, C.J., Saxler, A., Ohsato, H. & Razeghi, M. (1994) Crystallography of epitaxial growth of wurtzite-type thin films on sapphire substrates. J. Appl. Phys., 75, 4515. [2] Sun, C.J., Kung, P., Saxler, A., Ohsato, H., Razeghi, M. & Haritos, K. (1994) A crystallographic model of (00*1) aluminum nitride epitaxial thin film growth on (00*1) sapphire substrate. J. Appl Phys., 75, 3964. [3] Daudin, B., Rouviere, J.L. & Arlery, M. (1996) Polarity determination of GaN films by ion channeling and convergent beam electron diffraction. Appl. Phys. Lett., 69, 2480. [4] Bemardini, F., Fiorentini, V. & Vanderbilt, D. (1997) Spontaneous polarization and piezoelectric constants of III-V nitrides. Phys. Rev. B, 56, R10024. [5] Bykhovski, A.D., Kaminski, V.V., Shur, M.S., Chen, Q.C. & Khan, M.A. (1996) Pyroelectricity in gallium nitride thin films. Appl. Phys. Lett., 69, 3254. [6] Miragliotta, J., Wickenden, D.K., Kistenmacher, T.J. & Bryden, W.A. (1993) Linear- and nonlinear-optical properties of GaN thin films. J. Opt. Soc. Am. B, 10, 1447. [7] Hahn, D.N., Kiehne, G.T., Wong, G.K.L., Ketterson, J.B., Kung, P., Saxler, A. & Razeghi, M. (1999) Phase-matched optical second-harmonic generation in GaN and AIN slab waveguides. J. Appl. Phys., 85, 2497. [8] Fichter, F. (1907) Uber aliminiumnitride. Z Anorg. Chem., 54, 322. [9] Fischer, F. & Schroter, F. (1910) Berichte der Deutschen Chemischen Gesellschaft, 43, 1465. [10] Johnson, V.C, Parsons, J.B. & Crew, M.C. (1932) /. Phys. Chem., 36, 2588. [11] Maruska, H.P. & Tietjen, J.J. (1969) The preparation and properties of vapor-deposited singlecrystalUne GaN. Appl. Phys. Lett., 15, 327.
The Rise of Ill-nitrides: An Introduction
19
[12] Manasevit, H.M., Erdmann, P.M. & Simpson, W.I. (1971) The use of metalorganics in the preparation of semiconductor materials. IV. The nitrides of aluminum and gallium. /. Electrochem. Soc, 118, 1864. [13] Akasaki, I. et al. (1974) MITI report in Japanese only; Akasaki, I., Hayashi, I., 1976, Ind. Set. TechnoL, 17, 48. [14] Yoshida, S., Misawa, S. & Itoh, A. (1975) Epitaxial growth of aluminum nitride films on sapphire by reactive evaporation. Appl. Phys. Lett., 26, 461. [15] Dingle, R., Shaklee, K.L., Leheny, R.F. & Zetterstrom, R. (1971) Stimulated emission and laser action in gallium nitride. Appl. Phys. Lett., 19, 5. [16] Yoshida, S., Misawa, S. & Gonda, S. (1983) Improvements on the electrical and luminescent properties of reactive molecular beam epitaxially grown GaN films by using AlN-coated sapphire substrates. Appl. Phys. Lett., 42, 427. [17] Amano, H., Sawaki, N., Akasaki, I. & Toyoda, Y. (1986) Metalorganic vapor phase epitaxial growth of a high quality GaN film using an AIN buffer layer. Appl. Phys. Lett., 48, 353. [18] Amano, H., Kito, M., Hiramatsu, K. & Akasaki, I. (1989) P-type conduction in Mg-doped GaN treated with low-energy electron beam irradiation (LEEBI). Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 28, L2112. [19] Nakamura, S., Mukai, T., Senoh, M. & Iwasa, N. (1992) Thermal annealing effects on p-type Mg-doped GaN films. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 31, L139. [20] Sun, C.J. & Razeghi, M. (1993) Comparison of the physical properties of GaN thin films deposited on (0112) and (0001) sapphire substrates. Appl. Phys. Lett., 63, 973. [21] Sun, C.J., Kung, P., Saxler, A., Ohsato, H., Bigan, E., Razeghi, M. & Gaskill, D.K. (1994) Thermal stability of GaN thin films grown on (0001) AI2O3, (0112) AI2O3 and (OOOl)si 6HSiC substrates. J. Appl. Phys., 76, 236. [22] Saxler, A., Kung, P., Sun, C.J., Bigan, E. & Razeghi, M. (1994) High quality aluminum nitride epitaxial layers grown on sapphire substrates. Appl. Phys. Lett., 64, 399. [23] Dovidenko, K., Oktyabrsky, S., Narayan, J. & Razeghi, M. (1996) Aluminum nitride films on different orientations of sapphire and silicon. /. Appl. Phys., 79, 2439. [24] Kung, P., Saxler, A., Zhang, X., Walker, D., Wang, T.C., Ferguson, I. & Razeghi, M. (1995) High quahty AIN and GaN epilayers grown on (00*1) sapphire, (100) and (111) sihcon substrates. Appl. Phys. Lett., 66, 2958. [25] Saxler, A., Walker, D., Kung, P., Zhang, X., Razeghi, M., Solomon, J., Mitchel, W. & Vydyanath, H.R. (1997) Comparison of trimethylgallium and triethylgallium for the growth of GaN. Appl. Phys. Lett., 71, 3272. [26] Zhang, X., Kung, P., Saxler, A., Walker, D., Wang, T.C. & Razeghi, M. (1995) Growth of Al^Gai_;,N:Ge on sapphire and silicon substrates. Appl. Phys. Lett., 67, 1745. [27] Zhang, X., Kung, P., Saxler, A., Walker, D., Wang, T. & Razeghi, M. (1995) Photoluminescence study of GaN. Acta Phys. Polonica A, 88, 601. [28] Kung, P., Saxler, A., Zhang, X., Walker, D., Lavado, R. & Razeghi, M. (1996) Metalorganic chemical vapor deposition of monocrystalline GaN thin films on p-LiGa02 substrates. Appl. Phys. Lett., 69, 2X16. [29] Zhang, X., Kung, P., Saxler, A., Walker, D. & Razeghi, M. (1996) Observation of room temperature surface-emitting stimulated emission from GaN:Ge by optical pumping. /. Appl. Phys.,m, 65AA. [30] Zhang, X., Walker, D., Saxler, A., Kung, P., Xu, J. & Razeghi, M. (1996) Observation of inversion layers at AIN-Si interfaces fabricated by metal organic chemical vapour deposition. Electron. Lett., 32, 1622.
20
Optoelectronic
Devices:
Ill-Nitrides
[31] Kung, P., Saxler, A., Walker, D., Rybaltowski, A., Zhang, X., Diaz, J. & Razeghi, M. (1998) GalnN/GaN multi-quantum well laser diodes grown by low-pressure metalorganic chemical vapor deposition. MRS Internet J. Nitride Semicond. Res., 3 (1). [32] Saxler, A., Mitchel, W.C., Kung, P. & Razeghi, M. (1999) Aluminum gallium nitride shortperiod superlattices doped with magnesium. Appl. Phys. Lett., 74, 2023. [33] Yasan, A., McClintock, R., Darvish, S.R., Lin, Z., Mi, K., Kung, P. & Razeghi, M. (2002) Characteristics of high quality p-type Al;,Gai_;,N/GaN superlattices. Appl. Phys. Lett., 80,2108. [34] http://www.nichia.co.jp/info/history.html. [35] Akasaki, L, Amano, H., Sota, S., Sakai, H., Tanaka, T. & Koike, M. (1995) Stimulated emission by current injection from an AlGaN/GaN/GaInN quanmm well device. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 34, L1517. [36] Nakamura, S., Senoh, M., Nagahama, S.I., Iwasa, N., Yamada, T., Matsushita, T., Kiyoku, H. & Sugimoto, Y. (1996) InGaN-based multi-quantum-well-structure laser diodes. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 35, L74. [37] Nakamura, S., Senoh, M., Nagahama, S.I., Iwasa, N., Yamada, T., Matsushita, T., Sugimoto, Y. & Kiyoku, H. (1996) Continuous-wave operation of InGaN multi-quantum-well-structure laser diodes at 233 K. Appl. Phys. Lett., 69, 3034. [38] Nakamura, S., Senoh, M., Nagahama, S.I., Iwasa, N., Yamada, T., Matsushita, T., Kiyoku, H., Sugimoto, Y., Kozaki, T., Umemoto, H., Sano, M. & Chocho, K. (1997) InGaN/GaN/AlGaNbased laser diodes with modulation-doped strained-layer superlattices. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 36, L1568. [39] Usui, A., Sunakawa, H., Sakai, A. & Yamaguchi, A.A. (1997) Thick GaN epitaxial growth with low dislocation density by hydride vapor phase epitaxy. Jpn. J Appl. Phys., 36, L899. [40] Kung, P., Walker, D., Hamilton, M., Diaz, J. & Razeghi, M. (1999) Lateral epitaxial overgrowth of GaN films on sapphire and silicon substrates. Appl. Phys. Lett., 74, 570. [41] http://www.blu-ray.com. [42] New Blu-ray DVD format uses blue-violet lasers to achieve 27 GB recording capacity, http:// www.compoundsemiconductor.net (20 February 2002). [43] Nakamura, S., Senoh, M., Iwasa, N. & Nagahama, S.I. (1995) High-brightness InGaN blue, green and yellow light-emitting diodes with quanmm well structures. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 34, L797. [44] Sato, Y., Takahashi, N. & Sato, S. (1996) Full-color fluorescent display devices using a nearUV Hght-emitting diode. Jpn. J Appl. Phys., 35, L838. [45] http://lighting.sandia.gov/Xhghtinginit.htm. [46] Yasan, A., McClintock, R., Mayes, K., Darvish, S.R., Kung, P. & Razeghi, M. (2002) Topemission ultraviolet light-emitting diodes with peak emission at 280 nm. Appl. Phys. Lett., 81,801. [47] Yasan, A., McClintock, R., Mayes, K., Darvish, S.R., Zhang, H., Kung, P., Razeghi, M., Lee, S.K. & Han, J.Y. (2002) Comparison of ultraviolet light-emitting diodes with peak emission at 340 nm grown on GaN substrate and sapphire. Appl. Phys. Lett., 81, 2151. [48] Yasan, A., McChntock, R., Mayes, K., Darvish, S.R., Kung, P., Razeghi, M. & Molnar, R.J. (2002) 280 nm UV LEDs grown on HVPE GaN substrates. Opto-Electron. Rev., 10, 67. [49] Yasan, A., McChntock, R., Mayes, K., Kim, D.H., Kung, P. & Razeghi, M. (2003) Photoluminescence study of AlGaN-based 280 nm ultraviolet light-emitting diodes. Appl. Phys. Lett., 83, 4083. [50] Mayes, K., Yasan, A., McClintock, R., Shiell, D., Darvish, S.R., Kung, P. & Razeghi, M. (2004) High power 280 nm AlGaN light emitting diodes based on an asymmetric single quantum well. Appl. Phys. Lett., 84, 1046.
The Rise of lU-nitrides: An Introduction
21
[51] Yasan, A., McClintock, R., Mayes, K., Shiell, D., Gautero, L., Darvish, S.R., Kung, P. & Razeghi, M. (2003) 4.5 mW operation of AlGaN-based 267 nm deep-ultraviolet light-emitting diodes. Appl Phys. Lett., 83, 4701. [52] lida, K., Kawashima, T., Miyazaki, A., Kasugai, H., Mishima, S., Honshio, A., Miyake, Y., Iwaya, M., Kamiyama, S., Amano, H. & Akasaki, I. (2004) 350.9 nm UV laser diode grown on low-dislocation-density AlGaN. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 43, L499. [53] Razeghi, JVl. & Rogalski, A. (1996) Semiconductor ultraviolet detectors. /. Appl. Phys. Appl. Phys. Rev., 79, 7433. [54] Razeghi, M. (2002) Short wavelength solar-blind detectors: status, prospects, and markets. Proceedings of IEEE, Wide Bandgap Semicond. Devices: The Third Generation Semiconductor Comes of Age, 90, 1006. [55] Streltsov, A., Moll, K.D., Gaeta, A., Kung, P., Walker, D. & Razeghi, M. (1999) Pulse autocorrelation measurements based on two- and three-photon conductivity in a GaN photodiode. Appl. Phys. Lett., 75, 3778. [56] Asif Khan, M., Kuznia, J.N., Olson, D.T., Van Hove, J.M., Blasingame, M. & Reitz, L.F. (1992) High-responsivity photoconductive ultraviolet sensors on insulating single-crystal GaN epilayers. Appl. Phys. Lett., 60, 2917. [57] Zhang, X., Kung, P., Walker, D., Piotrowski, J., Rogalski, A., Saxler, A. & Razeghi, M. (1995) Photovoltaic effects in GaN structures with p - n junction. Appl. Phys. Lett., 67, 2028. [58] Walker, D., Monroy, E., Kung, P., Wu, J., Hamilton, M., Sanchez, F.J., Diaz, J. & Razeghi, M. (1999) High-speed, low-noise metal-semiconductor-metal ultraviolet photodetectors based on GaN. Appl. Phys. Lett., 74, 762. [59] Kung, P., Zhang, X., Walker, D., Saxler, A., Piotrowski, J., Rogalski, A. & Razeghi, M. (1995) Kinetics of photoconductivity in n-type GaN photodetector. Appl. Phys. Lett., 67, 3792. [60] Walker, D., Zhang, X., Kung, P., Saxler, A., Javadpour, S., Xu, J. & Razeghi, M. (1996) AlGaN ultraviolet photoconductors grown on sapphire. Appl. Phys. Lett., 68, 2100. [61] Walker, D., Zhang, X., Saxler, A., Kung, P., Xu, J. & Razeghi, M. (1997) A^Gai-^N (0 < X < 1) ultraviolet photodetectors grown on sapphire by metal-organic chemical-vapor deposition. Appl. Phys. Lett., 70, 949. [62] Walker, D., Saxler, A., Kung, P., Zhang, X., Hamilton, M., Diaz, J. & Razeghi, M. (1998) Solar blind GaN p - i - n photodiodes. Appl. Phys. Lett., 72, 3303. [63] Monroy, E., Hamilton, M., Walker, D., Kung, P., Sanchez, F.J. & Razeghi, M. (1999) Highquality visible-blind AlGaN p - i - n photodiodes. Appl. Phys. Lett., 74, 1171. [64] Walker, D., Kumar, V., Mi, K., Sandvik, P., Kung, P., Zhang, X.H. & Razeghi, M. (2000) Solar-blind AlGaN photodiodes with very low cutoff wavelength. Appl. Phys. Lett., 76, 403. [65] McClintock, R., Yasan, A., Mayes, K., Shiell, D., Darvish, S.R., Kung, P. & Razeghi, M. (2004) High quantum efficiency AlGaN solar-blind photodetectors. Appl. Phys. Lett., 84,1248. [66] Yang, B., Heng, K., Li, T., Collins, C.J., Wang, S., Dupuis, R.D., Campbell, J.C., Schurman, M.J. & Ferguson, I.T. (2000) 32 X 32 ultraviolet Alo.1Gao.9N/GaN p - i - n photodetector array. /. Quantum Electron., 36, 1229. [67] Brown, J.D., Boney, J., Matthews, J., Srinivasan, P. & Schetzina, J.F. (2000) UV-specific (320-365 nm) digital camera based on a 128 X 128 focal plane array of GaN/AlGaN p - i - n photodiodes. MRS Internet J. Nitride Semicond. Res., 5, 6. [68] Lamarre, P., Hairston, A., Tobin, S.P., Wong, K.K., Sood, A.K., Reine, M.B., Pophristic, M., Birkham, R., Ferguson, I.T., Singh, R., Eddy, C.R., Jr., Chowdhury, U., Wong, M.M., Dupuis, R.D., Kozodoy, P. & Tarsa, E.J. (2001) AlGaN UV focal plane arrays. Phys. Stat. Sol. (a), 188, 289.
22
Optoelectronic
Devices:
Ill-Nitrides
[69] Bhuiyan, A.G., Hashimoto, A. & Yamamoto, A. (2003) Indium nitride (InN): a review on growth, characterization, and properties. /. Appl Phys., 94, 2779. [70] Kung, P. & Razeghi, M. (2000) Ill-Nitride wide bandgap semiconductors: a survey of the current status and future trends of the material and device technology. Opto-Electron. Rev., 8, 201. [71] Asif Khan, M., Kuznia, J.N., Van Hove, J.M., Pan, N. & Carter, J. (1992) Observation of a twodimensional electron gas in low pressure metalorganic chemical vapor deposited GaNAl^Gai-;,N heterojunctions. Appl Phys. Lett., 60, 3027. [72] Asif Khan, M., Bhattarai, A., Kuznia, J.N. & Olson, D.T. (1993) High electron mobility transistor based on a GaN-Al^^Gai-^^N heterojunction. Appl. Phys. Lett., 63, 1214. [73] Ren, F., Abemathy, C.R., Van Hove, J.M., Chow, P.P., Hickman, R., Klaasen, J.J., Kopf, R.F., Cho, H., Jung, K.B., La Roche, J.R., Wilson, R.G., Han, J., Shul, R.J., Baca, A.G. & Pearton, S.J. (1998) 300°C GaN/AlGaN heterojunction bipolar transistor. MRS Internet I. Nitride Semicond. Res., 3, 41. [74] Teisseyre, H., Perlin, P., Suski, T., Grzegory, I., Porowski, S., Jun, J., Pietraszko, A. & Moustakas, T.D. (1994) Temperature dependence of the energy gap in GaN bulk single crystals and epitaxial layer. J. Appl. Phys., 76, 2429. [75] Gerlich, D., Dole, S.L. & Slack, G.A. (1986) Elastic properties of aluminum nitride. J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 47, 437.
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides M. Razeghi and M. Henini (Eds.) © 2004 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Chapter 3
The Evolution of Nitride Semiconductors Satoshi Kamiyama, Hiroshi Amano and Isamu Akasaki Faculty of Science and Technology, High-Tech Research Center, and Nano-Factory, Meijo University, 1-501 Shiogamaguchi, Tempaku-ku, Nagoya 468-8502, Japan
It had been believed for long time that it was almost impossible to grow a high-quality GaN single crystal. This difficulty was overcome with low-temperature deposited buffer layer technology. This achievement opened up the pioneering path to the discovery of p-type conduction, control of n-type conductivity and verification of quantum size effects. These breakthroughs have led to the novel and high-performance devices such as high-efficiency blue, green and white light-emitting diodes, long-lived blue-violet lasers, low-noise UV detectors and high-speed transistors. Furthermore, UV-LEDs, which have recently been focused on as a leading edge of frontier application, have been improved by the reduction of threading dislocation density in an AlGaN layer. A device with external quantum efficiency of 1.4% at 363 nm peak wavelength has been demonstrated that could be used in such applications as lighting equipment in combination with three-color phosphors, exciting light sources of optical catalyst and so on. All of these nitride-based devices are able to operate in a harsh environment because of their toughness. They should also enable a great saving in energy and are suitable for the protection of the environment. Nitride semiconductors and their devices are expected to contribute significantly to the future of our world.
3.1.
INTRODUCTION
Group-Ill nitride semiconductors have been recognized as among the most promising materials for optical devices in the short-wavelength region because of their wide bandgap with direct transition. Since the AlGaInN system can cover a very wide wavelength range, from 200 nm to more than 1700 nm, it is also applicable not only to the short-wavelength devices but also the long-wavelength ones, as shown in Figure 3.1. The high electronsaturation velocity in GaN is also suitable for application in high-speed and high-power electronic devices. The superior physical and chemical stability of the nitride
E-mail address:
[email protected] (I. Akasaki).
23
24
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides 8
1
1
1
^sapphire
6 \ Q. CD O) •D C CD
4
1
//•
1
1
1
^Si
^GaAs
^1 GaN
\
BeSe n^
1
0.25
L
1—1
0.30
GaP ^
\
1
MgSe
\
' \ ' /f
- I\ 1
0
1
ZnSe \ ^ 1 cdS
6H-^
2
1
^InP
i •' i MgS
ZnS \ i ^ ;
\
; % \zno
00
1
AIN
BN
>
i
^SiC
\
InN
'
//•
0.35
i^ L
i Si i 1
1
0.50
^
CdSe
? InP
GaAs
L J — •
0.55
•
•'
1
1 —
0.60
In-plane Lattice Constant (nm) Figure 3.1. Direct bandgap energy as a function of in-plane lattice constant in AlGaInN system.
semiconductors will enable them to operate in harsh environments. Moreover, nitridebased devices are the most "environmentally friendly" ones available. To produce such novel devices, it is essential to grow high-quality nitride single crystals and to control their electrical conductivity. However, it has been quite difficult to grow high-quality epitaxial GaN films with a specular surface free from cracks. Moreover, its conductivity had never been controlled and, hence, many researchers retired from the nitride field. In the second half of the 1980s, there were two important breakthroughs: the development of extremely high-quality GaN single crystal with a specular surface free from cracks [1] and the discovery of p-type GaN together with the ability to fabricate a p - n junction light-emitting diode (LED) [2]. These breakthroughs have led to such developments as high-performance blue and green LEDs, violet laser diodes (LDs), ultraviolet (UV)-photodetectors (PDs) and field effect transistors (FETs). Very recently, the development of UV light-emitting devices has been focused on for frontier applications, such as lighting equipment in combination with three-color phosphors, light sources of high-density optical data-storage systems and excitation sources for optical catalysts. Many significant results concerned with the UV lightemitting devices have been reported in recent years. In this chapter, the evolution of group-Ill nitride semiconductors and blue lightemitting devices is reviewed. The recent advances of the crystal growth methods for
The Evolution of Nitride Semiconductors
25
low-dislocation-density and high-performance UV light-emitting diodes are also described.
3.2. NITRIDE RESEARCH IN THE EARLY DAYS
In 1969, Maruska and Tietjen succeeded in growing the first GaN single crystal on a sapphire substrate by hydride vapor phase epitaxy (HVPE) [3]. They also found that GaN has a direct-transition bandstructure with a bandgap energy of about 3.39 eV. This accelerated and inspired further research on GaN (Figure 3.2(a)). Dingle et al. demonstrated optically pumped UV stimulated emission from a GaN crystal at 2 K [4]. The first bluish-green LED having a metal-insulator-semiconductor (MIS) structure was developed by Pankove et al. in 1971 [5]. Ejder reported energy dispersion of the refractive index of GaN in 1971 [6]. In 1974, Monemar reported the temperature dependence of exciton recombination energy in GaN grown by HVPE [7].
1—'—\—'—\—'—r Source INSPEC Keyword GaN As of 1999 1000 h Laser diode (CW) h
y
Laser diode (pulse) •D
J) to C
500°C HBT commercial LED —•
100
o
FET-^"— LT-buffer /photodetector
1
MIS-LED/"
I /
10
/
study of V luminescence'
V •
I
stimulated e emission RT
p-type, (n-type) pn-junction LED
_ HVPE GaN W
(B)
31:
(C)
(D)
-rr*-»r
_L ^ L 1965 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 Calendar year Figure 3.2. Number of publications concerned with nitrides and their devices over the years.
26
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides (b)
IN, Figure 3.3.
Surface morphology of (a) GaN directly grown on a sapphire substrate and (b) GaN grown using LT-buffer layer on a sapphire substrate.
In contrast to traditional III-V compounds such as GaAs and InP, however, it was quite difficult to grow high-quality epitaxial GaN film and in particular, film with a flat surface free from cracks (Figure 3.3(a)). This was mainly due to the large lattice and thermal mismatches between the GaN epitaxial layer and the sapphire substrate. Moreover, the high residual electron concentration in GaN made it quite difficult to achieve p-type conduction and to control the conductivity of n-type GaN. As a result, many researchers withdrew from the field of research on nitride semiconductors (Figure 3.2(b)). One of the authors (LA.) started working on GaN in 1973, and grew single-crystalline GaN by molecular beam epitaxy in 1974 [8]. In 1981, he developed fairly bright bluishgreen MIS LED based on GaN grown by HVPE [9]. The emission wavelength was 495 nm and the external quantum efficiency T7ext was about 0.12%, which was a new record. This LED had the first flip-chip-type electrode so that we were able to fabricate it more easily. This LED, however, was not commercialized because the operating voltage, which is determined by the thickness of the insulating layer, ranged from several to 10 V and could not be controlled. However, he determined to continue to struggle with this difficult system at that time.
3.3.
BREAKTHROUGHS IN CRYSTAL GROWTH
In 1985, an extremely high-quality GaN with a specular surface free from cracks on a sapphire substrate was achieved by pioneering a low-temperature-deposited (LT-)buffer layer technology in the metal-organic vapor phase epitaxy (MOVPE) [1]. The essence of this method is to insert a slightly softer material between the epitaxial layer and the highly mismatched substrate in order to reduce the interfacial free energy. The surface morphology of GaN was dramatically improved by using an LT-AlN-buffer layer. The GaN film grown with the LT-buffer layer on a sapphire substrate is quite transparent and it has a specular surface free from cracks, as shown in Figure 3.3(b). The X-ray diffraction profiles [10] and photoluminescence (PL) property [11] showed that the crystalline quality of GaN was also significantly improved by using the LT-buffer layer.
The Evolution of Nitride Semiconductors
27
The residual electron concentration of the GaN grown with the LT-buffer layer was reduced to the order of 10^^ cm~^ (and soon after, to the order of 10^^ cm~^). Simultaneously, the electron mobility was greatly improved [12]. All of these results show clearly that, by inserting the LT-buffer layer, not only the crystalline quality but also the electrical and optical properties of GaN can be dramatically improved at the same time. In 1989, for the first time, distinct p-type GaN with low resistivity was discovered in Mg-doped GaN on the LT-buffer layer with low-energy electron-beam irradiation (LEEBI) [2]. Immediately, the first p - n junction UV (edge emission) and violet LED [2] were demonstrated. A p-type AlGaN and a p-type GaInN were also achieved in 1991 [13] and 1994 [14], respectively. In 1992, Nakamura succeeded in making p-type GaN by thermal annealing in a N2 atmosphere of Mg-doped GaN using Cp2Mg [15]. Regarding n-type doping, researchers attempted doping with SiH4 in 1986 [16], but it was difficult to control the conductivity due to the high density of residual donors. We also succeeded in controlling the conductivity of n-type nitrides using high-quality GaN or AlGaN grown with the LT-buffer layer in combination with SiH4 doping [17,18]. The electron concentration could be linearly controlled from an undoped level to 10^^ cm~^ without deterioration of surface morphology when the SiH4 flow rate was varied. Thus, essential technologies for the achievement of nitride-based devices were established in this period. These breakthroughs caused the transition from decline to prosperity in research on nitrides, which can be called the "Renaissance" in research on nitrides, as seen in Figure 3.2(c).
3.4. EVOLUTION OF NITRIDE-BASED BLUE LIGHT-EMITTING DEVICES Since the accomplishments of two important milestones, everything has progressed very quickly and work in the field began to grow tremendously. The high-crystalline nitrides have led to a revolutionary change in the optical properties of nitride materials and devices. Figure 3.4 shows the chronological change of the external quantum efficiency, T7ext of nitride-based blue LEDs. 7]^^^ had been saturated at about 0.1% before the breakthroughs were reached. It began to increase steeply after the success in growing high-quality nitride crystal, which resulted in the p - n junction LED. In 1992, rj^^^ of 1.5% was achieved [19], and in 1993, the first nitride-based blue LED was commercialized. At present, blue and green LEDs have rj^^^ of more than 20 and 10%, respectively. The LEDs are much brighter than incandescent lamps. A i7ext of 32% for a violet LED offers a promising excitation source for phosphors. Figure 3.5 shows the threshold power, Pth^ for optically pumped stimulated emission from nitrides over the years. Before 1985, the stimulated emission using optical excitation was obtained only at low temperatures and Pth was very high. After the two breakthroughs
28
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
10 1 t
[
•
HVPE
• A
MOVPE MBE
:
1/ J1
/' Q LU
/
1 P /
—I 0 _3
:
(flip-chip
GO
S
A" '
0-1
/ L
/
r
/
/ //
•
t
/
\ M
- AL
)./
//
/
0)
/
0.01
• h
1E-3bL
/
W —J—1
1970
1975
1
1
—1
1
\L-X
L-U
1 1/ 1 _ j — i _ j — 1 _ \
1980/ 1985 / 1990
LT-buffer
p-n junction
1 1 1
1995\ 2000 Commercial LED
Calendar Year Figure 3.4. Chronological change of the external quantum efficiency, i7ext of nitride-based blue LEDs.
mentioned above, stimulated emission was achieved at RT and Pth began to decrease exponentially. Then the first lasing operation with pulsed current injection was achieved in 1995 [20] and a LD having continuous-wave operation was announced in 1996 [21]. By 1998, an estimated lifetime of 10"^ h had been achieved [22], becoming commercially available in 1999. One can see that the performance of light-emitting devices and the number of related publications (Figure 3.2) scale with each other.
3.5.
PROGRESS IN THE STUDY OF NITRTOE-BASED QUANTUM STRUCTURES
In a related activity, in 1991, a quantum size effect was verified by Itoh et al. [23] using an AlGaN/GaN quantum well, which was grown on high-quality GaN. A high electron
The Evolution of Nitride Semiconductors ^ •
29
Stimulated emission (low temperature) Stimulated emission (room temperature)
^
^^^^'"9
r
(S): surface mode
80K A
2120K
10
(S)
: w
[
•
i \
):
\
(D
i CL
\ \ \
r^ 2K
o
( S ) \ ( ^ idet) 0.1
•
\ \
h
:
current inj.
0.01 1970
L_|—1—1—L_ —J 1 1
1975
1980
LT-buffer
jf\
r 1 / f
L3u
1990
p-n junction
1995 \
2000
Laser
Calendar Year Figure 3.5. Threshold power, P^YI for optically pumped stimulated emission from nitrides over the years.
mobility of a two-dimensional electron gas in AlGaN/GaN heterostructure was reported by Khan et al. in 1991 [24]. In 1993, Sakai et al. reported the theoretical band lineups of binary alloys of AIN, GaN and InN [25], which indicated that both AlGaN/GaN and GalnN/GaN systems have the type-I heterostructure. In 1994, it was shown that the wavelength dependence of the refractive indices of AlGaN and GaInN was suitable for optical confinement in DH or SCH structures [26]. A large piezoelectric field of about 5X10^ V/cm, which is induced by lattice mismatch, was observed in a GaN/AlN/GaN heterostructure in 1993 [27].
30
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
The GalnN/GaN multi-quantum well (MQW), which is currently used as an active layer in nitride-based LDs, was first reported in 1995 [28-30]. Since then, peculiar properties of GaInN have been revealed. Despite the strong compressive strain of more than 1% in GaInN layers grown on GaN, it was found to be grown coherently, even in MQWs [31]. It was found that the bandedge photoluminescence intensity from GaInN MQW was greatly increased when the width of the wells was small [29,30], which was later qualitatively explained by the quantum-confined Stark effect (QCSE), due to the presence of the piezoelectric field [32].
3.6.
REDUCTION OF THREADING DISLOCATION DENSITY
3,6.1 GaN The reduction of threading dislocations in a GaN layer has been a focus of activity. The GaN grown on a sapphire substrate with the LT-buffer layer still contains dislocations, as many as 10^-10^^ cm~^.These dislocations are considered to be a major cause of the degradation of LDs which operate at high current density of 2 - 4 kA/cm^, and may pose an obstacle to the high-performance of PDs and TRs. Various technologies have been developed for the reduction of the dislocation density in a GaN layer, which are summarized in Figure 3.6. One is the application of a method
Akasaki's group Direct growth
Rough surface: Many cracks Dislocation density > 10'"'' cm'^
(until 1985)
Residual donor cone. > 10^^ cm-^ LT-buffer technology LT-buffer
Specular surface: Free from cracks
GaN
Dislocation density 10^-10''° cm"^
(1986) Sapphire
^
Residual donor cone. <10^^cm'^
%
Multi-LT-Buffer ('98)
^
Mass Transport ('99)
-m^
PGS-ELO COO)
GaN LT-buffer
I
Sapphire
» GdiN Sapphire
LT-buffer ^
LT-buffer
\/)teaNil Sapphire
LT-buffer
Figure 3.6. Technologies for the reduction of the dislocation density in GaN layer.
The Evolution of Nitride Semiconductors
31
(later called micro-channel epitaxy (MCE)) proposed by Nishinaga et al. in 1988 [33]. A variety of methods similar to MCE have been reported for the reduction of the dislocation density in nitrides, the most important being the epitaxial lateral overgrowth (ELO) techniques. Usui et al. developed a thick GaN layer with a dislocation density as low as 10^ cm~^ grown by HVPE using an ELO technique [34]. Later, Nakamura et al. fabricated a LD in the low dislocation region of ELO-GaN, and reported an estimated hfetime of more than 10"^ h [22]. Today, reduction of dislocation density in nitrides has been achieved by a variety of methods based on ELO. Another approach was developed for the reduction of the dislocation density to as low as 10^ cm~^ over the entire wafer using a LT-interlayer technology in 1998 [35]. A mass transport of nitrides in 1999 [36] and direct growth on a grooved substrate (GS) covered with a LT-buffer layer in 2000 [37] were proposed for the partial reduction of dislocation density. These three methods, developed by us and shown in the frame in Figure 3.6, do not require the use of a Si02 mask, which may diffuse into the crystal and may act as an obstacle. These methods enable us to reduce the dislocation density to the order of 10^ cm~l 3.6.2 AlGaN For the realization of a low-dislocation-density AlGaN layer, which is very important for UV light-emitting devices, as discussed in Section 3.7, other modified approaches are necessary. A difficulty in the reduction of the dislocations in AlGaN is mainly caused by a low diffusion length of Al atoms or Al-containing molecules on the surface of the substrate during the crystal growth. This makes it impossible to grow crystals selectively on the windows between dielectric masks in the ELO technique. Two methods have been developed for the reduction of the threading dislocation density in AlGaN, as shown in Figure 3.7. The first method (Figure 3.7(a)) is similar to the method using periodically grooved substrate described in Figure 3.6 [38]. In this method, however, it is possible to relax the lattice mismatch between underlying GaN and overgrown AlGaN layers by insertion of the LT-AIN interlayer [39]. A dislocation density as low as in the order of 10^ cm~^ was partially obtained in Alo.2Crao.8N, which was confirmed by both plan-view TEM image (not shown) and the dark spots in the CL image. Furthermore, the overgrown AlGaN layer is not cracked at all, due to the effect of the LT-AlN interlayer. In the method with periodically grooved GaN and the LT-AIN interlayer, only the AlGaN over the trenched regions has a low dislocation density, and the AlGaN over terrace regions still has as many as 10^^ cm~^ dislocations [38]. For the further reduction of dislocations in a whole AlGaN layer without cracks, the second method was demonstrated [40]. This crystal growth method comprises a first GaN epitaxial growth on sapphire substrate, a second selective growth of GaN seed crystals through (lIOO) Si02 stripe masks and a third planarized growth of Alo.22Gao.78N through an LT-AIN interlayer. After the first growth, Si02 stripe masks along with (1100) axis.
32
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides (a)
(b) Alo.2Gao.8N
Alo.isGaosiN
LT-AIN
LT-AIN Interlayer
'Si02 GaN
GaN LT-Buffer
LT-Buffer Layer Sapphire (0001)
Sapphire (0001)
© <1'100>
10 ^m
Dark spot
Figure 3.7. Technologies for the reduction of the dislocation density in AlGaN layer (a) a method using a periodically grooved substrate and the LT-AIN interlayer, (b) a method using selectively grown GaN seed crystals with (1122) facets and the LT-AIN interlayer. Photographs are surface cathode-luminescence images, where the dark spots show the threading dislocations.
where the width and spacing are both 5 |ULm, were formed on the GaN surface. In the second step, the GaN seed crystals were selectively grown on the window, and they have a cross-sectionally triangular shape with (1122) facets under an optimum growth condition. The dislocations in both GaN seed crystals and AlGaN layers are bent laterally, and, therefore, the whole area has dislocation density as low as 2 X 10^ cm"^, which was confirmed by the CL image [40]. In the point of view of the area of active region, the first method is convenient for the fabrication of UV-LDs, and the second is suitable for the UV-LEDs or UV-PDs.
3.7. UVLED 3.7.1 Difficulty of High-efficiency UV-LED Recently, development of UV-light-emitting devices has been seen as the next target. They are applicable to lighting equipment combining three-color phosphors, a light source of a high-density optical data-storage system, an exiting source of an optical catalyst, a sensing device in biological use and so on. However, the external quantum efficiency of UV-LEDs grown on a sapphire substrate is much lower than that of blue and green LEDs by a factor of more than two orders. Although visible or near-UV light-emitting diodes (LEDs) with GaInN quantum well active layer have high efficiency due to the effect
The Evolution of Nitride Semiconductors
33
of an In-rich cluster [41], UV LEDs with wavelengths shorter than 370 nm have very low efficiency because of a lack of In-rich clusters. The active layer of UV light-emitting devices basically comprises In-free materials, such as AlGaN, due to the requirement of a wide bandgap, so carriers can easily diffuse into non-radiative recombination centers at or around threading dislocations. On the other hand, an AlGaInN quaternary active layer is expected to have both UV bandedge emission and high quantum efficiency with In-rich clusters, and it is applied to active layers in UV-LEDs [42,43]. However, the crystalline quality of the quaternary alloy is thought to be inferior, so that the efficiency of UV LEDs having AlGaInN active layer is still very low. 3 J,2 Wavelength Variation of UV-LED with Low Dislocation Density The growth technologies described in the previous section are expected to have a potential for realization of UV-LEDs with high quantum efficiency. We applied the growth technology shown in Figure 3.7(b) to the fabrication of all UV-LEDs [40]. Figure 3.8 shows the schematic device structure, where an n-Alo.15Gao.85N first cladding layer (0.3 jxm), an active layer, a p-Alo.4Gao.6N blocking layer (20 nm), a p-Al;cGai_;cN second cladding layer (0.2-0.4 |jLm) and a p"^-GaN (0.05 jxm) contact layer were successively grown on the Alo.15Gao.85N base layer. The material of the active layer and composition of p-Al^^Gai-^^N second cladding layer are varied with changing emission wavelength as mentioned below. A Ni/Au semi-transparent p-contact and an Au bonding pad electrode were deposited on the p-side, and a Ti/Al n-contact was formed on the n-side. Under the Au bonding pad, a thin Ti layer is deposited just on the p^-GaN contact layer in order to reduce the current injection there. Four kinds of active layers (summarized in Table 3.1) were used in UV LEDs for the variation of emission Semi-trans, p-contact p-pad contact , f ^ ^ ^^ p+-contact layer p-Alo.4Gao.6N C I Active layer . n-contact ^^^
LT-AIN interlayer GaN seed crystal
. p-pad contact Semi-trans, p-contact " n-contact
LT-buffer layer
Figure 3.8.
Schematic device structure of UV LED grown on high-quality AlGaN base layer with low dislocation density. Right-hand side shows a top view of UV LED.
34
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides Table 3.1. Structural parameters of UV-LEDs with different emission wavelength LED (a) (b) (c) (d)
Active layer
p-cladding layer
GaN (60 nm) MQW (GaN:3 nm) Alo.1Gao.9N (60 nm) Alo.i6Gao.84N (60 nm)
Alo.15Gao.85N (0.4 |xm) Alo.2Gao.8N (0.2 fxm) Alo.25Gao.75N (0.2 |xm) Alo.3Gao.7N (0.2 |xm)
wavelength. The active layers are made of (a) bulk GaN, (b) GaN/Alo.o8Gao.92N:Si MQW, (c) bulk Alo.ioGao.9oN and (d) bulk Alo.i6Gao.84N. The AIN molar fractions of p-Al;,Gai_;,N second cladding layer are 0.15 for (a), 0.2 for (b), 0.25 for (c) and 0.3 for (d), respectively. All the bulk active layers are undoped. The thickness of p-Al^^Gai-^^N second cladding layer is 0.4 |xm in LED (a) and that of others is 0.2 jxm. The peak wavelengths of electroluminescence under 50 mA (DC) drive are 363, 352, 338 and 323 nm for LEDs (a), (b), (c) and (d), respectively. The output power as a function of peak wavelength at 50 mA (DC) bias is shown in Figure 3.9. All LEDs have output powers of more than 0.1 mW, and they are greatly dependent on the peak wavelength. With shortening of the wavelength, output power is linearly reduced. This may partly be due to the deterioration of current spread in p-layers, which must lead to the reduction of light extraction from the device. The output power of the 363-nm device with GaN active layer has a maximum output power of 1.2 mW. This output power is still much lower
1.4
-
LED (a)
•
1.2
y y
1.0 0) o
0.8
_
y y
Q_
^
LED (c)
0.6
Q. 3
o
y
y^
•
y
LED(b)
y
0.4 • LED(d)^ 0.2 0.0 320
lf=50mA(DC), RT 1
1
1
330
340
350
•
1
1
360
370
Wavelength (nm) Figure 3.9. Wavelength variation of output powers at 50-mA operating current.
The Evolution of Nitride Semiconductors
20
40
60
35
80
Forward Current [mA] Figure 3.10.
Output power and operating voltage as a function of forward current of modified 363 nm UV LED with high light extraction efficiency.
than those of violet and blue LEDs with GaInN active layers. Some problems may remain, such as the still-unsolved non-radiative recombination in active layers and low light-extraction efficiency caused by poor current spread in p-layers and light absorption in p'^-GaN contact layer or semi-transparent metals. 3,7,3 Improvement of External Quantum Efficiency for 363-nm LED We modified the device structure of the 363-nm LED for the improvement of light-extraction efficiency [44]. It has a Si02 current blocking layer inserted between the p'^-GaN contact layer and the bonding pad electrode and a mesh-type p-side contact. The Si02 current blocking layer is placed just under the bonding pad so only current injection under the pad, which causes an absorption loss of emitting light, is blocked. The injection current can easily spread along the semi-transparent p-contact and p-Alo.15Gao.85N cladding layer. Therefore, no light is emitted under the bonding pad and light extraction efficiency may be improved. Compared with the conventional device, a uniform light emission image is obtained in the modified device. The wide emitting area is attributed to the grid-type p-side contact. V-I and L-I curves of these LEDs are shown in Figure 3.10. High output powers of 2.3 mW at 50 mA and 4.7 mW at 100 mA are achieved in the modified LED. The maximum external quantum efficiency is as high as 1.4%. Considering the absorption loss in the underlying GaN layer, this efficiency is quite high. When the transparent underlying layer and backside extraction configuration are used, the external quantum efficiency is expected to improve with at least one order of magnitude.
36
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
3.8. CONCLUSION The dramatic improvement of the crystalline quality of nitrides through the pioneering of the LT-buffer layer technology and the realization of p-type conduction gave rise to a "Renaissance" in the research of nitride semiconductors. The breakthroughs have led to high-performance blue, green, and white LEDs, violet LDs, FETs and UV-PDs. All of these nitride-based devices are robust and will potentially enable a tremendous saving of energy. Today, the performance of these devices is still improving, following steady progress in the areas of crystal growth, processing and fundamental physics. Further progress is required for expansion of device applications toward the frontier regions. As a next promising nitride-based device, high-efficiency UV-LEDs using Alo.22Gao.78N base layer with low dislocation density have been demonstrated. The new crystal growth method with GaN seed crystal with (1122) facets and lateral growth of Alo.22Grao.78N through LT-interlayer enables the overgrown Alo.22Gao.78N to have a low dislocation density of 2 X 10^ cm~^ and be crack-free over whole wafer. The UV-LEDs grown on the high-quality Alo.22Gao.78N base layer have high output powers of more than 0.1 mW at 50 mA drive in a wide range of wavelengths from 323 to 363 nm. Further improvement of the efficiency is achieved using a modified device structure, which avoids light absorption loss at the bonding pad electrode. The highest output power of 4.7 mW at 100 mA driving current is obtained with 363 nm emission wavelength. In conclusion, the evolution of nitride semiconductors, the most environment friendly materials available, will have a great impact on the future world.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors have the pleasure to thank T. Takeuchi, M. Iwaya, S. Nitta, C. Wetzel, S. Yamaguchi and T. Detchprohm for their good collaboration.
REFERENCES [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9]
Amano, H., Sawaki, N., Akasaki, I. & Toyoda, T. (1986) Appl Phys. Lett., 48, 353. Amano, H., Kito, M., Hiramatsu, K. & Akasaki, I. (1989) Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 28, L2112. Maruska, H.P. & Tietjen, J.J. (1969) Appl. Phys. Lett., 15, 327. Dingle, R., Shaklee, K.L., Leheny, R.F. & Zetterstrom, R.B. (1971) Appl. Phys. Lett., 19, 5. Pankove, J.I., Miller, E.A., Richman, D. & Berkeyheiser, J.E. (1971) /. Lumin., 4, 63. Ejder, E. (1971) Phys. Stat. Sol. (a), 6, 445. Monemar, B. (1974) Phys. Rev. B, 10, 676. Akasaki, I. & Hayashi, I. (1976) Kogyo Gijutsu, 17, 48 in Japanese. Ohki, Y., Toyoda, Y., Kobayashi, H. & Akasaki, I. (1981) Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser., 63, 479.
The Evolution of Nitride Semiconductors
37
[10] Koide, Y., Itoh, N., Itoh, K., Sawaki, N. & Akasaki:, I. (1988) Jpn. J. Appl Phys., 27, 1156. [11] Naniwae, K., Itoh, S., Amano, H., Itoh, K., Hiramatsu, K. & Akasaki, I. (1990) /. Cryst. Growth, 99, 381. [12] Akasaki, I., Amano, H., Koide, Y., Hiramatsu, K. & Sawaki, N. (1989) /. Cryst. Growth, 98, 209. [13] Akasaki, I. & Amano, H. (1992) Mater Res. Soc. Symp. Proc, 242, 383. [14] Yamasaki, S., Asami, S., Shibata, N., Koike, M., Tanaka, T., Amano, H. & Akasaki, I. (1995) Appl Phys. Lett., 66, 1112. [15] Nakamura, S. (1991) Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 30, L1705. [16] Sayyah, K., Chung, B.C. & Gershenzon, M. (1986) /. Cryst. Growth, 77, 424. [17] Akasaki, I., Amano, H., Kitoh, M., Hiramatsu, K., Sawaki, N., (1989) 175th Electrochemical Society Meeting. [18] Murakami, H., Asahi, T., Amano, H., Hiramatsu, K., Sawaki, N. & Akasaki, I. (1991) /. Cryst. Growth, 115, 648. [19] Akasaki, L, Amano, H., Itoh, K., Koide, N. & Manabe, K. (1992) Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser, 129, 851. [20] Akasaki, I., Amano, H., Sota, S., Sakai, H., Tanaka, T. & Koike, M. (1995) Jpn. J Appl. Phys., 34, L1517. [21] Nakamura, S., Senoh, M., Nagahama, S., Iwasa, N., Yamada, T., Matsushita, T., Kiyoku, H. & Sugimoto, Y. (1996) Jpn. J Appl. Phys., 35, L74. [22] Nakamura, S., Senoh, M., Nagahara, S., Iwasa, N., Yamada, T., Matsushita, T., Kiyoku, H., Sugimoto, Y., Nozaki, T., Umemoto, H., Sano, M. & Chocho, K. (1998) Jpn. J Appl. Phys., 37, L627. [23] Itoh, K., Kawamoto, T., Amano, H., Hiramatsu, K. & Akasaki, I. (1991) Jpn. J Appl. Phys., 30, 1924. [24] Khan, M.A., Van Hove, J.M., Kuznia, J.N. & Olson, D.T. (1991) Appl. Phys. Lett., 58, 2408. [25] Sakai, S., Ueta, Y. & Tarauchi, Y. (1993) Jpn. J Appl. Phys., 32, 4413. [26] Akasaki, I. & Amano, H. (1994) Mater Res. Soc. Symp. Proc, 339, 443. [27] Bykhovski, A., Gelmont, B. & Shur, M. (1993) /. Appl. Phys., 74, 6734. [28] Nakamura, S., Senoh, M., Iwasa, N., Nagahama, S., Yamada, T. & Mukai, T. (1995) Jpn. J Appl. Phys., 34, L1332. [29] Akasaki, L, Amano, H. & Suemune, I. (1995) Proceedings of the International Conference on Silicon Carbide and Related Materials, Kyoto, MoA-I-2. [30] Amano, H. & Akasaki, I. (1995) Extended Abstracts International Conference on Solid State Devices and Materials, Osaka, vol. 7, p. 683. [31] Takeuchi, T., Takeuchi, H., Sota, S., Sakai, H., Amano, H. & Akasaki, I. (1997) Jpn. J Appl. Phys., 36, L177. [32] Takeuchi, T., Sota, S., Katsuragawa, M., Komori, M., Takeuchi, H., Amano, H. & Akasaki, I. (1997) Jpn. J Appl. Phys., 36, L382. [33] Nishinaga, T., Nakano, T. & Zhang, S. (1988) Jpn. J Appl. Phys., 27, L964. [34] Usui, A., Sunakawa, H., Sakai, A. & Yamaguchi, A.A. (1997) Jpn. J Appl. Phys., 36, L899. [35] Iwaya, M., Takeuchi, T., Yamaguchi, S., Wetzel, C , Amano, H. & Akasaki, I. (1998) Jpn. J Appl. Phys., 37, 316. [36] Nitta, S., Kariya, M., Kashima, T., Yamaguchi, S., Amano, H. & Akasaki, I. (1999) Abstracts of Third International Symposium on Control of Semiconductor Interfaces, Karuizawa, B305. [37] Yano, M., Detchprohm, T., Nakamura, R., Sano, S., Mochizuki, S., Nakamura, T., Amano, H. & Akasaki, I. (2000) IPAP Conf Ser, 1, 292.
38
Optoelectronic
Devices:
Ill-Nitrides
[38] Iwaya, M., Nakamura, R., Terao, S., Ukai, T., Kamiyama, S., Amano, H. & Akasaki, I. (2000) IPAP Conf. Ser., 1, 833. [39] Kamiyama, S., Iwaya, M., Hayashi, N., Takeuchi, T., Amano, H., Akasaki, I., Watanabe, S., Kaneko, Y. & Yamada, N. (2001) J. Cryst. Growth, 223, 83. [40] Kamiyama, S., Iwaya, M., Takanami, S., Terao, S., Miyazaki, A., Amano, H. & Akasaki, I. (2002) Phys. Stat. Sol. (a), 192, 296. [41] Mukai, T. & Nakamura, S. (1999) Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 38, 5735. [42] Hirayama, H., Enomoto, Y., Kinoshita, A., Hirata, A. & Aoyagi, Y. (2000) Phys. Stat. Sol. (a), 180, 157. [43] Khan, M.A., Adivarahan, V., Zhang, J.P., Chen, C , Kuokstis, E., Chitnis, A., Shatalov, M., Yang, J.W. & Simin, G. (2001) Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 40, L1308. [44] Iwaya, M., Takanami, S., Miyazaki, A., Watanabe, Y., Kamiyama, S., Amano, H. & Akasaki, I. (2003) Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 42, 400.
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides M. Razeghi and M. Henini (Eds.) © 2004 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Chapter 4
Technology of MOVPE Production Tools M. Dauelsberg^, E.J. Thrush'', B. Schineller^ and J. Kaeppeler^ ^AIXTRON AG, Kackertstr. 15-17, 52072 Aachen, Germany ^Thomas Swan Scientific Equipment, Anderson Road, Buckingway Business Park, Swavesey, Cambridge CB4 5FQ, UK
4.1. INTRODUCTION This chapter will describe the activities of the AIXTRON group of companies in the MOVPE of Ill-nitrides. AIXTRON is a pure supplier of equipment for the semiconductor market, and therefore, we will describe our activities to deliver the state-of-the-art MOVPE tools to the Ill-nitride market. The MOVPE of Ill-nitrides became important in the early 1990s when Akasaki [1] and Nakamura [2] first demonstrated nitride-based light-emitting diodes (LEDs). These results motivated a lot of research groups to embark on research into the MOVPE of Ill-nitrides. These groups often started with modified reactors, which were originally used for the growth of GaAs- or InP-based materials. The precursors used for the group III component when growing Ga(Al,In)N are mainly the same as used for the growth of GaAs- or InP-based materials. These are TMGa, TEGa, TMAl and TMIn. Regarding the group V precursor, NH3 was normally used for growing Ill-nitrides. A notable difference between this reagent and ASH3 and PH3 is the higher bond energies (-70.6-72.8 kcal/mol for AsHs, - 7 6 . 9 81.4 kcal/mol for PH3 and - 100-105.7 kcal/mol for NH3 [3]), which requires a higher growth temperature of about 1100°C for GaN. A detailed description of the thermal chemistry is made in Section 4.3. As the existing reactors were designed for maximum growth temperatures of about 850-900°C, modifications were required to enable the reactors to run at temperatures up to or above 1100°C. For the substrate holder (susceptor) to reach these temperatures, most reactors are equipped with a radio frequency (RF) heater or resistance heater. Most of the fundamental research was performed on these small homemade reactors. In the mid-1990s, a few groups were able to grow LED structures on these small systems and the first interest in larger scale reactors for the production of blue LEDs developed. At that time, production processes for growing the GaAlInP-based epilayers used for LEDs operating in the yellow to red spectral region were established on multi-wafer
E-mail address:
[email protected] (J. Kaeppeler).
39
40
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
systems. These systems were not, however, able to grow GaN-based material because the maximum operation temperature was limited to 900°C. Another limitation concerned with the material for the wafer carrier (susceptor) was mainly the uncoated graphite. This could not be used in an NH3 containing ambient because NH3 or its decomposition products react with pure graphite at these elevated temperatures. The most common solution to this problem is to coat the graphite with SiC, which does not react, with NH3 at process temperatures, and therefore, protects the graphite against corrosion. Another important development which was addressed at this time concerned the provision of in situ monitoring of the wafer surface during growth. As there are still no commercial substrates available, which are lattice-matched, sapphire and SiC are the most commonly used substrates. In order to ameliorate the effects of the lattice mismatch between these substrates and GaN, a low-temperature nucleation layer is required [4]. As an aid to improving the growth control, especially during the transition between the growth of the low-temperature nucleation layer, which has a three-dimensional growth mode, and the epi-layer proper, which grows in a two-dimensional, step-flow, regime, in situ reflectance measurements have proved to be very useful. This means that optical access to the wafer surface is essential for MOVPE reactors. The current market requirements for production MOVPE machines are significantly changed from those of the late 1990s. Today, the market expects a system with high throughput and low cost of ownership (CoO) combined with high performance regarding the uniformity of layer properties such as thickness, wavelength, electro-luminescence intensity and doping level. This market also requires an up-scaling of the reactor to permit growth on larger wafer areas whilst at the same time improving the performance of the reactor. Computational modeling of nitride MOVPE processes and reactors is essential in the development of MOCVD equipment. The use of this technique improved the quality and reduced the time of the reactor development, and will, therefore, be explained here. The Planetary Reactor® and Close-Coupled Showerhead (CCS) reactor concepts will be described as these are the state-of-the-art production tools for GaN-based LED offered by the AIXTRON group of companies.
4.2. TYPES OF REACTORS 4,2,1 Horizontal Tube Reactors The horizontal reactor in its simplest form is a tube equipped with a heated wafer carrier through which the process gases flow, as shown in Figure 4.1. The concentration of the process gases will deplete from the gas inlet towards the gas outlet. This will cause a decrease in growth rate in the gas-flow direction. The most efficient means of compensating for this effect is to rotate the substrate, which will average the growth conditions in a radially symmetric manner. If the depletion curve can be tuned
Technology ofMOVPE Production Tools
41
Reactor wall / ^ ^
^.---''^ Susceptor
Gas Substrate
\
Reactor Figure 4.1. Schematic top view of a horizontal MOCVD reactor.
to a linear shape, this rotation will generate a flat, uniform layer thickness on the wafer. The rotation will also help to flatten the temperature profile of the substrate. Today, horizontal reactors are mainly used for the R&D of Ill-nitride layers and for the small-scale production of high-value device structures such as laser diodes. The horizontal reactor AIX 200/4RFS is optimized to the special requirements for this application. By using an inductively heated susceptor, substrate temperatures up to 1200°C can be reached. The susceptor utilizes a gas-driven rotation mechanism for the wafer platter (the so-called Gas Foil Rotation, GFR®). The group III and group V reagent gases are separately delivered to the substrate surface and guided over the heated substrate holder through a rectangular-shaped liner tube, as shown in Figure 4.2. The group III (metalorganics in N2 or/and H2) and the group V (NH3 in N2 or/and H2) components are kept separate until they reach the growth area above the substrate to avoid premature reaction between them. A stainless steel reactor with three optical ports allows optical
Group I
In-situ measurement tool (reflectance and temperature)
Group V
Figure 4.2. AIX 200/4 RFS reactor.
42
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
access to the substrate surface for the use of in situ measurement tools such as a reflectometer or pyrometer. 4,2,2 Planetary Reactors 4,2,2,1 Concept, The concept of the planetary reactor is based on the horizontal tube reactor. In the horizontal reactor, the gas is flowing with a nearly constant velocity across the wafer. The depletion of the process gases in the gas-flow direction will cause a continuous reduction in growth rate. The deposition rate on the wafer is governed by the flow and diffusion of group III species, as shown in Figure 4.3. Although the depletion of reagents can be compensated for by rotation of the wafer, the process gases will not be utilized very efficiently if the reaction time between gaseous precursors and wafer is limited. A decreasing velocity would increase the potential reaction time between reagents in the gas phase and wafer surface. This would cause stronger depletion whilst increasing the utilization efficiency of the process gases. Now, the velocity could be decreased by increasing the cross-section of the flow channel of such a reactor. This could be realized by increasing the width of the flow channel across the wafer in the gas-flow direction. The rotation of the main planetary disk is not of fundamental importance for layer-growth quality; it is mainly used to average the heat flux from the heater to the substrate holder to guarantee a uniform circular temperature distribution. The top view of such a reactor would look like a piece of cake. The planetary reactor can be regarded as an aggregate of such reactor sections to form a complete circular shape. Frijlink developed the concept of the planetary reactor in the late 1980s [5]. The substrates placed on a platen rotate around the gas inlet at the center of the reactor. The gas inlet is separated into two levels. Through the top inlet group III process gases are injected whilst the lower inlet is used to inject group V precursor and its carrier gas into the reactor. A schematic view of the reactor is shown in Figure 4.4. The ceiling of the reactor flow channel is made of quartz and is heated by radiation from the IR- or RF-heated susceptor. The temperature of this ceiling is controlled by the varying ratio of the two gases comprising the gas mixture, which flows between the ceiling and the water-cooled reactor top. These two gases are chosen to have a markedly different thermal conductivity from each other, such that the adjustment of the composition of the mixture effectively regulates the transport of heat from the ceiling. In most cases, these gases are H2 and N2.
Transport by flow Group I
Group V
Diffusi in cross-flow direction I Diffusion Figure 4.3. Transport of growth limiting species.
I
Technology of MOVPE Production Tools
43
In the original reactor built by Frijlink, IR lamps heated the susceptor. As described in Section 4.1, GaN growth requires susceptor temperatures of about 1100°C. Due to this requirement for higher process temperatures, planetary reactors for Ill-nitride growth are equipped with an inductive RF-heater. 4,22,2 Up-scaling, The first planetary reactor designed for Ill-nitride growth, the AIX 2000HT, had a 6 X 2 in. configuration. A few years later, this configuration was established as the state-of-the-art production tool for Ill-nitride-based LEDs. However during the late 1990s the production market was calling for larger reactor loads, prompting the evolution to the next size which had a 11 X 2 in. configuration. During this evolution, computational modeling was used to specify the reactor geometry. The main changes required were a larger susceptor diameter, a modified reactor height and a larger RF-coil for heating the larger susceptor. The modeling also provided guidance in the adjustment of the process parameters such as flow of carrier and process gases needed to transfer the process from the 6 X 2 in. to the 1 1 x 2 in. platform. It has been shown that the larger configuration maintains, or even out-performs, the process characteristics of the smaller reactor.The next up-scaling to the 24 X 2 in. configuration (AIX 2600G3 HT) changed one more important parameter, the satellite size, which was increased to fit one 4-in. wafer or three 2-in. wafers on each of the eight satellites. This increased the growth length in the radial direction on the susceptor and required some additional parameter adjustment but
Carrier + NHo
Carrier + group III elements + dopant
Tliermostated quartz glass ceiling Injector
Growth rate on rotated wafer
Wafer on rotating satellite
Rotating inductively heated susceptor
radius Figure 4.4.
Schematic view of Planetary Reactor® concept.
44
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
Figure 4.5.
AIX 2600G3 HT with 24 X 2-in. configuration.
the growth results following this tuning indicated that the process could again be transferred effectively to the larger configuration shown in Figure 4.5. 4,2.23 Growth Results, We will now discuss current developments and results relating to the growth of nitride semiconductors with a special focus on large-scale production. Here, the key issue is CoO, to which the main contributing factors are yield, precursor consumption, ratio of uptime to downtime, cycle time between runs, and the wafer area, which can be deposited on in a single run. All these topics must be addressed by the epitaxy tool manufacturer to support the customer in this challenging marketplace. Optoelectronic Devices and Structures. While the relatively mature optoelectronics sector is still focused on 2-in. processing capability, 4-in. sapphire wafers are becoming available in the market, making a switchover to 4-in. processing lines a commercially viable option in the near future. The epitaxy tool manufacturers such as AIXTRON must ensure smooth transitions from one wafer size to the other by making the processes scalable and transferable. The AIX 2600G3 HT system in its 24 X 2 in. configuration, which, as the world's largest epitaxy system, is also the workhorse of the optoelectronics industry, answers this issue by design. The susceptor of this reactor features eight Gas Foil Rotation™ recesses, each of which can hold disks for either three 2-in. wafers or for one 4-in. wafer. This allows the reactor to be operated in 24 X 2 or 8 X 4-in. configurations, and even mixed configurations using 2 and 4-in. wafers simultaneously are possible for evaluation purposes. Since the geometry of the process chamber is not changed, the process
Technology ofMOVPE Production Tools
45
conditions for both wafer sizes are identical and the change from 2 to 4-in. operation merely requires the exchange of the wafer disks, which can be done in a couple of minutes. When statistically evaluating the room temperature photoluminescence maps of all 24 wafers from the same run, a uniform distribution of the wafer properties, independent of their respective position on the susceptor, can be found. For instance, for an average wavelength of 475.4 nm with a standard deviation from wafer to wafer of just 1.11 nm, the on-wafer standard distribution of the wavelength was measured to be between 1.5 and 2.5 nm using a 3 mm edge exclusion. This performance is corroborated by additional data for a run in the green spectral range. The mean wavelength was at 525.3 nm with 1.7 nm standard deviation from wafer to wafer and on-wafer standard deviations in the order of 3 nm. The slightly higher variation in wavelength for these structures as compared with the first run is explained by the increased tendency of the InGaN quantum well material to undergo spinodal decomposition into In-rich clusters in a Ga-rich matrix. Energetically, these In-rich clusters form quantum-dot-like structures, which strongly affect the recombination efficiency and wavelength. In addition, the lattice mismatch between the Ga-rich matrix and the In-rich clusters gives rise to piezoelectric effects and spontaneous polarization, which also contribute to wavelength shifts and efficiencies. Such effects are more pronounced with the higher amount of In used in the green spectral range; hence, the higher sensitivity of the material to slight temperature variations as they naturally occur on the wafer surface. Reproducibility is one of the main factors that affects yield and CoO. Therefore, a stable epitaxy tool and process are prerequisites for mass production and the epitaxy tool manufacturer must address these issues while maintaining the tool's flexibility for different applications. Figure 4.6 shows the photoluminescence data from eight runs in the blue and green spectral ranges. The range of the emission wavelengths was measured to be ^^max-min = 2.4 nm for the blue and AAmax-min = 4.4 nm for the green spectral range. These results show that modern epitaxy systems produce predictably good results while offering the device manufacturers the flexibility to address their markets. As discussed earlier, the facile transfer of processes to larger wafer sizes has been established. Figure 4.7 shows the photoluminescence map of an LED structure grown on a 4-inch wafer under similar process conditions as discussed above. The slightly higher standard deviation of the wavelength is a consequence of greater inherent strain in the sapphire, which causes the edge of the wafer to bow, reducing the thermal contact to the substrate holder. This effect is currently being addressed by the wafer vendors and it is expected that they will find a solution soon. Electronic Device Structures. The high-power/high-temperature electronics device market is currently emerging from its research and development phase and is now attracting significant interest in the industrial mainstream. In contrast to
46
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
3
4
5
Run number Figure 4.6.
Example for tool and process stability for eight runs at two different wavelength regimes.
the optoelectronics market, the electronic device industry utilizes processing lines with 4-in. capability. The uniform deposition of all materials commonly used in electronic devices, most notably doped and undoped AlGaN of differing compositions, can be seen as the cornerstone for efficient and cost-competitive production of transistors. Figure 4.8 shows a thickness map measured by white light interference for AIN grown on a 4-in. sapphire wafer. At a thickness of 450 nm, a standard deviation of just 0.025 nm Peak Lambda
nm 505.0 499.0 493.0 487.0 481.0 475.0 469.0 463.0 457.0 451.0 445.0 Avge : 471.4 Median: 471.1 Std Dev: 1.098 % (5.175)
Figure 4.7.
Photoluminescence mapping of an InGaN/GaN MQW structure grown on 4-in. sapphire under simmilar process conditions as discussed above.
Technology ofMOVPE Production Tools Thickness
47 pm |0.950 0.850 0.750
\
0.650
\ \
0.550
1
0.450
1
0.350
1 1
;3"v:
0.250 0.150
/
H0.050 •-0.050
Avge : 0.458 Median : 0.466 Std Dev: 5.492 % (0.025) Figure 4.8. Thickness mapping for AIN grown on 4-in. sapphire at a growth rate of 1 ixm/h.
was achieved. Most notably, the high growth rate of 1 jjum/h in this process shows that mass production with short cycle times is possible for the production of transistor structures. In addition, the growth of binary AIN material is widely seen as challenging. Possible pre-reactions between TMAl and NH3 in the gas phase, which result in the formation of particulates and effect low growth rates in some alternative reactor designs, make the careful engineering of reactors mandatory. 4,2,2,4 Future Developments, The ever-changing marketplace with its constant focus on CoO and better device performance is likely to keep the epitaxy tool manufacturers busy for years to come. Current and future challenges will lay in making the wafer throughput higher, not only by following the proven routes of expanding the reactor chambers, but also by reducing cycle times between runs, increasing heat-up and cool-down ramp rates and improving wafer uniformities to increase the usable area per run. In addition to that, the stability and longevity of reactor parts, reduced and plannable maintenance efforts and the reduction in the usage of source materials will be at the heart of future developments. In this way, the epitaxy tool manufacturers will stand firmly by the side of their customers, addressing the arising issues of constant market evolution. 4,2,3 Close-coupled Showerhead Reactors 4,2,3,1 Concept, The concept of the CCS reactor is based upon a mathematical analysis of fluid flow undertaken more than 40 years ago. In a treatment by Schlichting [6], which employed an analytical solution of the relevant Navier-Stokes equations to describe the flow streamlines, velocity distribution and boundary layer arising when
48
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
a uniform flow of gas stalls against a perpendicular flat surface, it was shown that the boundary-layer thickness is independent of the distance from the stagnation point (i.e. the point at which the flow separates to pass around the object in the path of the flowing gas). The boundary layer is a notional layer of gas, adjacent to the solid surface, through which the velocity increases from zero at the surface to the free stream velocity. A diagrammatic representation of this situation is given in Figure 4.9. As the diffusion of growth precursors through this boundary layer, in the classical mass transfer limited regime commonly used for MOCVD, determines the growth rate and composition of higher alloys, its invariance with position on the susceptor implies that reactors of this geometry should inherently give good uniformity. It should be noted, however, that the analysis discussed earlier applies to an idealized situation where the susceptor is immersed in an infinite volume of gas, at a fixed temperature, which flows toward the susceptor with no other constraints. In practical reactors, there are generally a number of deviations from this ideal situation, which complicate the simple concept. One of the most important of these is a "wall drag" effect that causes the gases flowing through the deposition chamber to develop a parabolic velocity profile that increases progressively as the distance from the injection point to wafer is increased. Traditional designs that require the injected gases to expand into the deposition zone from a narrow entry point are also prone to complex "jetting", effects which can lead to recirculation cells at the gas injection point. Additionally, thermal buoyancy-driven recirculation cells, which arise from the change in density of the gas as it enters the hot reaction zone, can also degrade both the uniformity
Local horizontal flow vectors Figure 4.9.
Schematic diagram depicting streamlines, velocity profile and boundary layer for an idealized stagnation-point flow, rotating disk reactor (after H. Schlichting [6]).
Technology ofMOVPE Production Tools
49
and the interface quality of the structures grown. Finally, for the MOCVD growth of III-V compounds from group III metal alkyls and group V hydrides, the simple pyrolysis-based chemistry is complicated by a parasitic low-temperature reaction between these two types of reagent (the formation of addition compounds), which can undermine the control and chemical efficiency of the process and give rise to particulate contamination. A feature of the CCS reactor, shown diagrammatically in Figure 4.10 and as a photograph in Figure 4.11, is that it provides the means of minimizing these unwanted second-order effects such that the idealized behavior can be closely approximated to in a simple manner. This is done by introducing the reagents across the whole of the reaction zone from a multiplicity of separate injector tubes, embodied in a water-cooled showerhead, located very close to the growing wafers. The SIC coated graphite wafer platen is in the form of a short inverted cylinder, open at the bottom, which rotates about a fixed multi-zone spiral heater. The distribution of power to these zones can be adjusted within the control software to permit flat susceptor temperature profiles to be realized across the temperature range used for III-V epitaxy. The fact that the injection area is matched to that of the deposition zone mitigates against unwanted macroscopic jetting effects, whilst the close proximity of the injector to the growing wafers minimizes the scope for the development of the parabolic velocity profile referred to earlier. The proximity of the showerhead to the reaction zone also suppresses thermal buoyancy-driven instabilities, which tend to be exacerbated in reactors
Optical probes Showerhead water cooling Top plenum chamber
|«e^
Gas inlet bottom plenum chamber Three zone heater Thermocouple
t—^
Double 0-ring seal
Susceptor — Water cooled chamber Quartz liner
Exhaust
Figure 4.10.
Schematic diagram of 19 X 2-in. close-coupled showerhead reactor.
50
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
Figure 4.11. Close-coupled showerhead reactor (19 X 2 in.; open for loading).
having a large volume above the hot susceptor. In the patented design used for the Thomas Swan showerhead, the tubes are fed from two separate plenum chambers and are arranged on two interleaved matrices such that efficient mixing of the gases can be effected right at the edge of the reaction zone whilst still allowing complete mixing prior to the point of pyrolysis. The latter assertion is supported by both in-house and independent [7] fluid dynamic modelling, which has indicated that, under typical operating conditions, the gases from the two plenums are fully mixed, and the individual jets from the injection tubes are fully dissipated, by the time they arrive at the wafer surface. This ability of the CCS design to effectively mix the gases at the last possible moment is particularly important for the growth of GaN-based materials as the adducts between ammonia (which is used as the group V precursor) and the group III alkyls are easily formed because ammonia is a relatively strong base. The reduced interaction afforded by this "late mixing" yields a growth process with a high chemical efficiency, which, together with the reactor's relative mechanical and operational simplicity, contributes to a low CoO.
Technology ofMOVPE Production Tools
51
4.2.3.2 Scale-up, As discussed earlier the CCS arrangement intrinsically yields a uniform boundary layer thickness irrespective of position on the susceptor radius, which in turn provides the foundation for uniform deposition. A corollary to this argument is that the design should produce these desirable characteristics on any length scale, implying that there are no conceptual limitations to the realization of good uniformity, even for very large reactors of this type. Moreover, it can be argued that larger diameter reactors should have enhanced performance as any residual second-order perturbations of the gas flow caused by the proximity of the reactor wall, or rotation-induced re-circulation cells at the susceptor edge, should have a proportionately smaller effect as the reactor size is increased. This reasoning has been borne out by detailed fluid dynamic modelling (as discussed in Section 4.3), which provided the reassurance necessary to invest the considerable engineering effort required to increase the size from the original single 2-in. wafer variant to the current large-capacity multi-wafer reactors. Results from reactors ranging in capacity from 1 x 2 through 3 X 2 and 6 X 2 to 19 X 2-in. have shown, in fact, that it is easier to optimize the larger reactors for highly uniform, chemically efficient, deposition than is the case for their smaller counterparts, although all of the multi-wafer reactors have produced state-of-the-art material specifications, as discussed in Section 4.2.3.3. In addition to the more favorable gas flow pattern discussed earlier, another factor which makes the larger reactors easier to use is that thermal distinction between the separate zones of the multi-zone heater is more easily achieved as the size is increased. This implies that the susceptor temperature uniformity can be more easily controlled, which has a positive impact on the uniformity of parameters which are very temperature sensitive, such as the composition of InGaN and the growth and annealing of low-temperature nucleation layers on which most GaN-based structures are grown. 4.2.3.3 Growth Results GaN Template Growth in CCS Reactors. Using the proven "two-temperature" technique, which deposits GaN or AIN low-temperature nucleation layers prior to the growth of thick GaN epilayers at a higher temperature, specular GaN templates have been prepared on sapphire and silicon carbide substrates. Also, using a high-temperature AIN nucleation layer, GaN templates have been prepared on silicon. Typically, these exhibit a standard deviation in thickness below 2% across a 2-in. wafer, although the best-case values below 1% have been noted. Such uniformities have been achieved on 3 X 2, 6 X 2 and 19 X 2-in. reactors. The final surface morphologies of these layers (as indicated by atomic force microscopy) exhibit a "step-flow" pattern indicative of monolayer two-dimensional growth. These surfaces have RMS roughness values down to —0.13 nm over an area of 4 fxm^, as indicated by Figure 4.12a and b, which show the topologies of GaN template material grown on sapphire and silicon, respectively, in a 6 X 2-in. reactor. Two different regimes have been investigated for the growth of the high-temperature epilayers, one in which the isolated GaN crystallites, which result from the annealing
52
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
of the nucleation layer, coalesce quickly, and the other where a protracted period of threedimensional growth follows the growth and annealing of the nucleation layer. The rate at which the GaN coalesces, and the surface approaches, specular reflectivity, influences the ability to "grow out" misfit dislocations and this has a profound effect upon the conductivity of undoped material. GaN grown using conditions that promote rapid coalescence is found to be semi-insulating (up to 10^ fl/square), whereas GaN, grown in such a way that coalescence occurs gradually, is invariably conducting. Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) analysis of these materials has shown that the semi-insulating layers grown using the "rapid recovery" regime contain more edge-type dislocations than do the conducting layers grown using a "slow recovery" strategy. Real-time monitoring of the evolution of the surface morphology, using an in situ laser-based interferometer, has given considerable insight into, and afforded improved control of, the mechanisms responsible for these different growth regimes. Figure 4.13 shows the different interferograms that result when growth conditions are adjusted to produce templates which are (a) semi-insulating or (b) conducting. There are a number of strategies for managing the rate at which coalescence is approached. Bougrioua et al. [8] adjusted the growth rate, growth temperature and nucleation layer annealing time to achieve this end, whilst work at Cambridge University has used ammonia partial pressure during the annealing of the nucleation layer as the main controlling parameter. Higher partial pressures are found to promote a faster recovery of the reflectivity. It is important in terms of system flexibility that both types of template can be grown. Conductive templates are believed to have superior crystalline quality and are chosen for the buffer layers of device structures requiring ambi-polar current injection such as LEDs and lasers, whilst a high-resistivity buffer layer is mandatory to obtain good pinch-off characteristics for field effect transistors (PETS).
2.0|Lim
Figure 4.12. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) images of GaN on sapphire (a) and (b) silicon.
Technology ofMOVPE Production Tools
1800
2800
3800
4800
5800
53
6800
7800
Time (s) Figure 4,13. Laser interferograms taken whilst growing (a) semi-insulating, and (b) conductive GaN templates on sapphire.
Optoelectronic Structures Quantum Wells in CCS Reactors. Currently, the most commercially significant sector for MOCVD-grown GaN-based structures is that of LEDs. Consequently, we have devoted effort to the study of quantum wells that form the active region of such devices. We have noted that both InGaN/GaN and GaN/AlGaN quantum wells grown in a 6 X 2-in. system are characterized by abrupt interfaces as perceived by TEM (see Figure 4.14), and that their high resolution X-ray diffraction rocking curves exhibit both Pendelosung fringes and satellite peaks out to the eighth order, for 10 period multi-quantum well (MQW) structures [9]. Figure 4.15 shows results for InGaN/GaN structures and similar results are obtained for GaN/AlGaN quantum wells. Reciprocal space maps for both types of quantum well structures indicate that they are fully pseudomorphic when grown correctly. An example of such a map for an InGaN/GaN MQW structure is given in Figure 4.16. The technique used to construct this map employs the asymmetric (105) reflection and shows the spread both normal to (y-axis) and in the plane (jc-axis) of the layers, with the zero and + 1 order MQW satellite peaks straddling that of the bulk GaN peak. The precise alignment of the peaks on the x-axis indicates that the structures are fully strained. Similar results are obtained for GaN/AlGaN quantum well structures grown within the critical thickness constraints. To characterize the optical quality of InGaN/GaN, MQWS variable temperature photoluminescence (PL) measurements were made as a means of determining the internal quantum efficiency. For the best samples, high room temperature efficiencies up to 43%
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
54
Figure 4.14.
Bright field cross-sectional TEM of InGaN/GaN MQWS.
e/2e(degrees) Figure 4.15. X-ray rocking curves of InGaN /GaN quantum wells.
Technology ofMOVPE Production Tools
55
were obtained. In order to study the optical quality as a function of well composition (and therefore, emission wavelength), a series of InGaN/GaN single quantum wells were grown covering the wavelength range 370-570 nm (at 6 K). The indium content of the wells, which is a prime parameter in determining the emission wavelength, was controlled by varying the well and barrier growth temperatures and determined by X-ray diffraction measurements. At 6 K, the spectra of these samples were dominated by strong localized exciton emission, with attendant phonon replicas, across the whole of the wavelength range, as shown in Figure 4.17. The growth temperatures and indium contents of the quantum wells are also shown in this figure. The line-widths of the zero phonon lines are very narrow with the FWHM of the peak at 374 nm being 3.1 nm (28 meV), indicating quantum wells of very high quality. Further details are given in an earher publication [10]. Finally, the performance of our largest 19 X 2-in. system is exemplified by results from a growth campaign undertaken after its commissioning at a customer's site [11]. This work, aimed at establishing a capability for blue LED structures, was based upon a five- period InGaN/GaN MQW structure grown on an n-type silicon doped template, capped by a p-type magnesium doped layer. To determine the optical emission uniformity, PL mapping of the 19 X 2-in. wafers was undertaken using an Accent RPM 2000 system. The intra-wafer standard deviations of PL intensity and PL emission wavelength averaged 4.13% and 1.91 nm, respectively, within a 3 mm edge exclusion zone, whilst the corresponding inter-wafer standard deviations of the means of those parameters, from all the wafers, were 2.94% and 1.81 nm, the global average PL
Intensity measured on a logarithmic scale, interval between contours ~2.6x 3560
3580
3600
3620 3640 QX*10000(rlu)
3660
Figure 4.16. Reciprocal space map of InGaN/GaN MQWS.
3680
56
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides Wavelength (nm) 1.2
700
600
500
TIO^C 730°C
1.0 H
1.8
Figure 4.17.
2.0
2.2
2.4
400 750°C
2.6 2.8 Energy (eV)
770°C
3.0
800°C
3.2
3.4
3.6
6 K PL of single quantum wells with different indium contents.
wavelength for this run being 459.0 nm. An estimate of doping uniformity was also obtained from sheet resistance measurements made on these structures using a contactless resistivity profiler. This data, which predominantly samples the conductivity of the Si-doped buffer layer, yields a standard deviation of 0.61% across the wafers and 0.5% between them, implying good growth temperature uniformity. Following commissioning, the PL wavelength data were collected from 22 consecutive runs, made to the same recipe, as a test of the system's reproducibility. This indicated that the standard deviation of the global average wavelength (of the 19 wafers) over the 22-run series was 1.18 nm. Electronic Structures Two-dimensional Electron Gas Structures Grown in CCS Reactors. Using highresistivity GaN buffer layers, as described in the section "GaN Template Growth in CCS Reactors", AlGaN/GaN high electron mobility transistor (HEMT) structures have been grown. The conducting channel in such devices is a two-dimensional electron gas (2DEG) at the AlGaN/GaN interface, arising from a combination of spontaneous and piezoelectric polarization at this interface. The transport properties of this 2DEG are a sensitive measure of interfacial perfection with the mobility (for a given sheet carrier concentration) being degraded if the interface is not abrupt and the AlGaN is crystallographically relaxed rather than fully pseudomorphic. X-ray diffraction studies of HEMT structures with AlGaN
Technology ofMOVPE Production Tools
57
thicknesses up to ~ 40 nm thick and aluminium contents of up to ~ 30% have shown very good agreement between experimentally derived 6/26 rocking curves and simulations based upon perfect interfaces and zero relaxation in the AlGaN. Qualitatively, this implies that the structures are of high quality in these two respects. Additionally, XRD reciprocal space maps of such structures have indicated that the AlGaN is fully strained. Using such structures, state-of-the-art mobilities of greater than 1400 cm^ V~^ s~\ for a sheet carrier concentration ---10^^ cm~^, have been obtained on both sapphire and silicon carbide substrates using the CCS reactor.
4.3. COMPUTATIONAL MODELLING OF NITMDE MOVPE PROCESSES AND REACTORS 4.3,1 Introduction One of the challenges of multi-component MOVPE during the fabrication of modem electronic and optoelectronic devices based on nitride compound semiconductors lies in the accurate control of layer thickness and composition uniformity over large wafer surface areas and the control of heterostructure interface quality, while ensuring reproducibility, process reliability, high up time and low cycle times during this highly complex deposition process in an industrial volume production environment. Adding even more complexity to the above requirements, typical nitride MOVPE processes encompass a wide range of process conditions with frequent changes of operating pressure, growth temperature, carrier gas composition and gas flow rates throughout a single growth sequence. Modeling of nitride MOVPE processes has been used to gain insight into the fundamentals of the growth process itself [12, 13]. On the other hand, as MOVPE has evolved into a mass production technique, modelling has been of increasing value in supporting and guiding process development and equipment design [14]. Semiconductor equipment vendors routinely use computational modelling in order to improve reactor design and processes to shorten their development cycles and to cut down development and testing costs. The assessment of reactor design performance, even before the equipment is built and tested, is based on the prediction of flow dynamics, heat transfer, chemical species distribution and deposition profiles by computer simulations. Modelling has become an integral part of equipment and process development and is used at various stages of the design process, starting with the initial feasibility analysis of novel reactor concepts, the scaling of proven reactor types to larger wafer capacity and the design optimization of critical components, such as gas inlets and heaters. It has also provided guidance to process engineers in finding robust process regimes to achieve the required performance. It goes without saying that the consistent use of modelling provides the potential for significant cost savings.
58
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
4,3.2 Fluid Flow Dynamics^ Heat Transfer and Related Gas Phase Transport Phenomena Fluid flow in MOVPE reactors is characterized by incompressible mixed forced and natural convective flow. For basic flow analysis, dimensionless numbers are used, which arise from scaling the governing transport equations and characterize the behavior of MOVPE reactors [15]. The Reynolds number {Re) measures the ratio of flow momentum over diffusive momentum transport, i.e. viscous drag, and determines the size of momentum-driven return flow cells and vortices as well as the length of flow jets, but also the transition from laminar to turbulent flow. For circular tube flow, for instance, the onset of turbulent flow occurs at a critical value of Re ~ 2300. Under MOVPE conditions, the values of the Re number normally are rather low in the range from Re= 10 to 1000 and laminar flow is ensured. Nevertheless, in adverse cases, there may be momentum-driven vortices, which give rise to enhanced gas phase pre-reactions between precursor species or provoke memory effects. In the case of nitride MOVPE, the mean molecular weight and, hence, the density of the process gas mixtures tends to be higher (due to the required high amount of hydrides and the partial use of nitrogen as carrier) than for MOVPE of conventional III-V compound semiconductors, resulting in typically rather high Re numbers in the order of Re = 100-1000. As a consequence, usually extra care has to be taken with the design of gas inlets and process chambers in order to obtain satisfactory flow patterns. The Grashof and Rayleigh numbers serve to characterize the strength of natural convection. In MOVPE reactors, buoyancy-driven flows due to thermal gradients opposed to gravity are likely to occur. As these parameters vary as the cube of reactor height, tall vertical reactors are particularly prone to natural convection effects. Furthermore, they vary linearly with temperature gradient and as the square of density or pressure. The regimes used for the MOVPE of nitrides typically employ higher growth temperatures, higher density gas flows (composed of significant concentrations of ammonia and nitrogen), and quite often at higher operating pressures than are used for the (usually) entirely hydrogen-based regimes for the MOVPE of conventional III-V compound semiconductors. This regime presents greater challenges with respect to the control of process stability. Gas expansion caused by heating of the gas flow plays a major role in MOVPE reactors. Although gas flow in MOVPE reactors occurs as low Mach numbers (i.e. flow velocity is low compared with the speed of sound) and there are no compressibility effects, the temperature dependence of the gas density has to be accounted for by the ideal gas law. Other dimensionless numbers indicate the relative contribution of forced convection and diffusion to the mass transport of chemical species or to heat transfer (Peclet numbers). They can also be used to compare transport time scales with reaction times
Technology ofMOVPE Production Tools
59
(Damkohler numbers), thus characterizing whether growth is transport Hmited or reaction rate Hmited. Ample Hterature is available on the transport phenomena occurring in MOVPE reactors and on the application of modeling gas phase transport in order to relate typical performance figures (growth rate, composition, uniformity, interface abruptness) to process conditions and operating parameters [16-20]. By way of illustration. Figure 4.18 shows the predicted GaN growth rate profiles for various gas flow rates in a production scale planetary reactor accommodating 24 X 2-in. substrates for simultaneous processing. Under normal operation, the substrate carrier disks with 3 X 2-in. wafers are rotated to average the layer properties over the wafer area. In the data presented in this figure, one of the disks has been clamped to obtain the underlying growth rate depletion profile. The results indicate the predictive accuracy obtained using transport and reaction modelling of MOVPE deposition of GaN thin layers and the practical use of reactor scale modelling to understand the effect of various process tuning parameters in MOVPE reactors. 4,3,3 Chemical Kinetics Predicting process behavior in a transport and reaction model of the nitride growth process occurring in a MOVPE reactor requires a knowledge of gas phase and surface reaction mechanisms to be incorporated into the physical model, including the reaction pathways of various gas phase compounds and their reaction rate constants.
carrier gas flow = 12.25 Sim
Experimental: Carrier flow rate • 12.25 Sim o 15.25 Sim o 18.25 sIm
0.12 0.14 0.16 0.18 distance from center (m)
0.22
Figure 4.18. Dependence of GaN growth rate profiles on hydrogen carrier gas flow rates for rotated and static wafer carrier disks. Growth temperature, T = 1030°C, operating pressure, p = 200 mbar, precursors NH3 and TMGa (experimental data by AIXTRON Material Research Laboratory, Aachen, Germany).
60
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
The thermal decomposition of most metalorganic source materials is well understood and involves sequential first-order pyrolytic reactions. Rate constants for each step were determined by kinetic decomposition experiments under conditions close to MOVPE operating conditions [21] and, more recently, by means of ab initio computational chemistry [22, 23]. Both approaches yield rather good agreement. The onset of thermal decomposition of TMGa, for instance, occurs at a temperature of 350-400°C by cracking the first Ga-CH3 bond with an activation energy of —59 kcal/mol. The thermal cracking of NH3 has been the subject of experimental studies in combustion chemistry resulting in the elucidation of the detailed kinetic mechanisms and the quantitative measurements of reaction rates [24]. Gas phase decomposition proceeds in a second-order reaction with a rather high activation energy of ~ 95 kcal/mol, with initial cracking at temperatures well above 800-900*^C and ammonia dissociation of only a few percent at typical growth temperatures of GaN epitaxial layers (1000-1100°C). Apparently, at MOVPE, the majority of NH3 is decomposed catalytically on the growing surface through dissociative adsorption in conjunction with adsorbed group-III compounds. The use of alternative nitrogen sources, such as hydrazine derivatives like unsymmetric dimethyl-hydrazine (UDMH), has been investigated too. Experimental decomposition studies indicate 50% cracking at 420°C, i.e. a decomposition temperature well matched to that of the metal organic group-III precursors [25]. For deposition of GaN, the formation of adducts between ammonia and group-III precursors through a Lewis acid-base interaction plays a crucial role in determining the concentration of reactive intermediates. A number of experimental and modeling studies have focused on the gas phase pre-reaction of NH3 and TMGa or TMAl [2,26-28]. According to Thon and Kuech [26], the formation of the initial adduct between NH3 and TMGa takes place at temperatures below 200°C. Subsequent methane elimination leads to (CH3)2Ga-NH2, which can react to form dimeric and trimeric compounds with Ga and N atoms forming a ring. At temperatures above 700°C, the abundance of dimeric and trimeric species tends to decline again owing to their thermal decomposition. The strength of the Lewis donor-acceptor bond itself is rather weak, unless subsequent alkane elimination takes place leading to the formation of more or less stable compounds with direct bonds between III- and V-atoms. The relative magnitude of adduct strength and the barrier to alkane elimination is crucial for the MOVPE process and depends on the participating III-V elements. Apparently, aluminum and nitrogen form the most stable compounds among the relevant group-III elements, which explains the high risk of particle formation during growth of AIN. Ab initio quantum chemical computations of thermochemical properties and reaction rate constants attract particular attention. Using such techniques, gas phase and surface mechanisms for the MOVPE of GaN and AlGaN have been successfully modelled, even though large and geometrically complex molecules are involved [22,23].
Technology ofMOVPE Production Tools
61
4,3,4 Mathematical Model The mathematical model used for computational predictions of the MOVPE growth process is based on the continuum mechanical description offlow,heat transfer and multicomponent chemical species mass transfer, including the mathematical models for thermal radiation transfer, gas phase and surface chemical reactions and electromagnetic inductive heating. The continuum description is adequate since MOVPE reactors operate at sufficiently high pressures (10-1000 mbar) and large characteristic dimensions such that the Knudsen number, i.e. the ratio of the mean free path length over the characteristic dimensions of the flow domain, is below Kn
CpV'(puT) = V-(AVr)
VipuY,) = V | P A ( V F , + a , F , ^ ) j +/?„ p
/ = 1,...,A^
N 1=1
with p = density, u = velocity, p = pressure, p. = dynamic viscosity, Cp = heat capacity at constant pressure, T = temperature, A = heat conductivity, Yi = species mass fraction, Di = diffusion coefficient, a^ = thermodiffusion factor, M/ = molar mass, R = gas constant. For multi-component gas mixtures, as typically encountered during MOVPE, gas phase transport properties, such as viscosity, thermal conductivity and species diffusion coefficients, are temperature and mixture dependent. Most generally, they can be determined by kinetic gas theory (Chapman-Enscog theory), based on either experimentally obtained values or on estimated Lennard-Jones potential parameters for the single species and the application of appropriate mixing rules [30-32]. MOVPE growth exhibits a high sensitivity not only to local growth temperature and thermal uniformity on the substrate, but also to the thermal environment within the entire reaction chamber. For the purpose of predictive equipment, scale modelling the accurate calculation of temperatures is indispensable; hence, the modelling of thermal radiation in the MOVPE reactor and ambient is very important as it is the predominant mode of heat transfer. Some radiation models are based on ray tracing
62
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
or view factors and typically provide high spatial resolution but, on the other hand imply high computational effort. Another class of approaches, the so-called diffusive approximations, are based on the solution of the radiation transfer equation, as, e.g. the popular discrete ordinates method. A comprehensive review of radiation models is given in Ref. [33]. In practice, the choice of the radiation model usually involves a compromise between the degree of prediction accuracy and the computational effort. 43,5 Numerical Methods and Software Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) is the field of science dedicated to the development of numerical solution techniques for the above system of coupled partial differential equations. The most commonly used numerical technique for the regime of incompressible, viscous flow, including multi-component gas mixtures, is based on the finite-volume method. It consists of the discretization of the governing equations on structured or unstructured computational grids and the iterative solution of the resulting system of algebraic equations involving some pressure-correction scheme. For details on numerical techniques, refer to Refs. [34,35]. CFD has been a field of significant research and development over the past 20 years. Nowadays, flexible and robust multi-purpose commercial CFD packages for modelling flow and related multi-disciplinary physics are available as a result of those activities, quite a few of them with special focus towards applications in the semiconductor industry [36-38]. They differ mostly with respect to the variety of physical models they include. Combined with lower costs and higher performance of high-end PCs and Unix workstations, CFD-based modeling can be employed on a day-to-day basis without the need to use supercomputers other than for very advanced calculations.
4.4. IN SITU TECHNOLOGffiS The application of optical in situ technologies to the metal-organic chemical vapor deposition process enables the MOCVD engineer to directly observe the growth and facilitate process tuning. This chapter describes different in situ techniques of differing levels of complexity, which provide information about the growing film, including the determination of growth rate, surface quality, composition and doping levels. 4,4.1 Measurement of Layer Properties The most commonly used in situ measurement technique employs the evaluation of Fabry-Perot interference between a layer interface with differing indices of refraction and the growing surface, widely known as "in situ reflectivity measurement". The resultant
Technology ofMOVPE Production Tools
63
oscillation of the reflectivity yields information about the growth rate, the interface and surface roughness and, by counting the number of oscillations, the total thickness of the growing layer. The in situ reflectivity measurement employs a light beam and detection at normal incidence to the wafer surface. The energy of the light is chosen to be below the bandgap of the growing layer, facilitating an ideally infinite penetration depth without any significant quenching of the signal due to absorption in the layer, allowing for the direct comparison of the layer quality across all stages of the growth. Applying basic rules of optics yields for the growth rate r: _ A^ _ AQ ^~ At ~ 2nsXAt' where AQ is the probe-light wavelength in vacuum, n^ is the refractive index of the semiconductor layer and At is the time between two maxima of the Fabry-Perot oscillations. In the case of the EpiTune II measurement tool, the probing light is generated by a 950 nm LED. The time difference At is determined by numerically fitting the recorded trace over several oscillations, thus improving the accuracy with which the growth rate can be determined. In addition to the information, which permits the determination of the growth rate, the reflectivity signal bears additional information about the layer, most notably the roughness of the interface with the largest difference in refractive index and the roughness of the growing surface. These properties modulate the amplitude of the FabryPerot oscillations. Figure 4.19 shows an example of an ideal Fabry-Perot interference trace (dotted line). It can be seen that the signal amplitude of this trace remains constant. In reality, however, imperfections of the lower interface and the growing surface will disturb the interference condition, and hence quench the signal. The amount of quenching can be taken as a measure of the interface and surface quality and is an important piece of information that assists the epitaxy expert in the optimization of the growth conditions. 4,4,2 Measurement of Surface Temperature Another important class of in situ tools facilitates the measurement of the surface temperature by emissivity corrected pyrometry. Stefan-Boltzmann's law yields for the radiation Ms of a perfect black body at temperature T:
M^ = Cs(-^]=
^
^Vioo/
5.67Wm"^K"^
^
' (-^] vioo/ -
Stefan-Boltzmann constant
Material which does not resemble a perfect black body, however, requires the modification of this law by the introduction of emissivity factor e, which yields
64
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides 30
25
1
A A A /
f 1
1
r 1
! 1 ***,.J_i
^
! !
1 I
! !
1
1 j
\ '
! !
!\1 I
\
1
1 j
! !
TTT—UuJ_ • • J_ !
20
1
i i
V f in
15 L n
1 K
10
i\y', -
I !
0)
a:
'\ /•
if'
1
r^
-l
1 v
—^
V
[ 1
'J
^ J )/
IJ \J
1
1
500
1000
J "J
1J )J
1
1
\
i
M
i
!
\
i
!1 1!
\l
'J y
1 /
1 i
1
1500
2000
Time [s] Figure 4.19.
Schematic of an ideal Fabry-Perot interference trace (dotted), a quenched trace (bold) and its envelopes.
This emissivity factor is a material constant that has been evaluated for many common materials. In epitaxy, however, the growing layer and its emissivity factor are subject to constant change since emissivity and reflectivity of a surface are interconnected. Emissivity-corrected pyrometry (such as EpiTune II) utilises a single sensor head, which measures the reflectivity of the wafer surface as described earlier, calculates the emissivity and subsequently performs a pyrometric temperature measurement. This can be achieved by pulsing the probe light at frequencies of up to 20 Hz, making a quasisimultaneous reflectance, emissivity and temperature measurement possible. Figure 4.20 shows the experimentally obtained trace of reflectivity together with the traces representing the uncorrected and corrected pyrometric wafer temperature, as recorded during the epitaxy run used to produce a GaN layer. It can be seen that the pyrometrically measured wafer temperature is unstable, due to the changing emissivity of the surface, and oscillates with the same frequency as the reflectivity. By simultaneously measuring the reflectivity, the temperature measurement can be corrected to show the true temperature of the surface. From the physics of semiconductor growth, it becomes directly evident that most processes from dissociation to incorporation of species into the growing layer are highly temperature sensitive. In this context, the knowledge of the temperature on the wafer surface and the facility to accurately control it permit an increased level of reproducibility in modem
Technology ofMOVPE Production Tools
65
1000
980
o
960-
o
0) "TO
0
940
Q.
E 0
920
900 01:12:00
01:19:12
01:26:24
01:33:36
01:40:48
growth time [hh:mm:ss] Figure 4.20.
Traces showing the on-line recorded reflectivity (lower trace), pyrometric wafer temperature and corrected wafer temperature (upper traces) for the growth of a thick GaN layer.
Figure 4.21. Cross-sectional three-dimensional view of the sensor head, reactor lid, viewport and susceptor with wafer discs.
66
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
epitaxy systems. In addition, a reliable measurement of the surface temperature allows for the correction of process parameters during the run, either manually or automatically. 4,4,3 Integration of In Situ Technologies into Modern Epitaxy Systems 4,4,3,1 Mechanical Integration, Since in situ technologies are add-ons to modem epitaxy systems, their integration into the tool must combine the strengths of the sensors without curtailing the flexibility and stability of the reactor. In addition, their adaptation to multi-wafer systems requires the correlation of the measurement signal with the wafer that is being monitored. Figure 4.21 shows the incorporation of a sensor head on top of an AIX 2xxxG3 reactor lid. The sensor remains outside the process chamber and probes the wafer through a viewport and a small hole in the reactor's quartz ceiling. This insures that the impact of the measurement set-up on the process chamber is minimal and the reactor's performance is not impaired. In addition, the slow rotation speeds of the susceptors in modem MOCVD systems allow for each measurement to be correlated to the individual wafer. m-^-i
ISyrtw B!»«*e yagfi-anNcsI
i
iUxEat
j
^ aaiCTpaaz KIKTM PM ~ £mt:«6:46PM
3.^.±^...
Mt
{
Sleep
{ cycle purge {
Open
j
Misi2^ pumpdovw
. ^^^^^ •III
CCILIM
wt'&m mam 37.7}
22.»|
r^' 36.5)
'm^
•
32.BJ
^1 |^^;S'i!^^'||i|f Figure 4.22. Screen-shot of the control interface of an AIX 2600G3 HT epitaxy system. The right-hand panel of the display shows how recorded system parameters such as flows and temperatures (lower graph) and in situ measurement data (upper graph) can be displayed and analyzed during the run.
Technology ofMOVPE Production Tools
67
This method of incorporation can be adapted to virtually any kind of optical sensor head that utilises a normal incidence set-up, be it a reflectivity measurement (e.g. EpiRAS, EpiTune II) or pyrometry. 4.4,3.2 Software Integration. In the industrial as well as the research and development environment, the operators rely on a technically sound and seamless integration of each hardware component into the tool's control system. All information needs to be instantly accessible via the control interface of the system during the run. Figure 4.22 shows a screenshot of the user interface of an AIX 2600G3 HT reactor during a growth run. The right-hand side panels of the display show the reflectivity curves of the layer as well as additional information about the growth run. All information from in situ sensors taken on the individual wafers during the run is stored alongside the complete data-log of the system. Like this, information on individual wafers is retrievable and later on can be correlated to the system's performance.
REFERENCES [1] Akasaki, L, Amano, H., litoh, K., Sakai, H., Tanaka, T. & Manaba, K. (1992) Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser., 129, 851. [2] Nakamura, S., Mukai, T. & Senoh, M. (1994) AppL Phys. Lett., 64, 1687. [3] Simka, H., Willis, B.G., Lengyel, I. & Jensen, K.F. (1997) Prog. Cryst. Growth Charact., 35, 117. [4] Amano, H., Sawaki, N., Akasaki, I. & Toyoda, T. (1986) Appl. Phys. Lett., 48, 353. [5] Frijlink, P.M. (1988) A new versatile, large size MOVPE reactor. /. Cryst. Growth, 93, 207-215. [6] Schlichting, H. (1960) Boundary Layer Theory, McGraw Hill, New York. [7] Mihopoulos, T.G., Hummel, S.G. & Jensen, K.F. (1988) /. Cryst. Growth, 195, 725-732. [8] Bougrioua, Z., Moerman, L, Sharma, N., WalHs, R.H., Cheyns, J., Jacobs, K., Thrush, E.J., Considine, L., Beanland, R., Farvacque, J.L. & Humphreys, C.J. (2001) /. Cryst. Growth, 230, 573-578. [9] Thrush, E.J., Kappers, M.J., Dawson, P., Vickers, M.E., Barnard, J., Graham, D., Makaronidis, G., Rayment, F.D.G., Considine, L. & Humphreys, C.J. (2003) J.Cryst. Growth, 248, 518-522. [10] Thrush, E.J., Kappers, M.J., Dawson, P., Graham, D., Barnard, J.S., Vickers, M.E., Considine, L., MuUins, J.T. & Humphreys, C.J. (2002) Phys. Stat. Sol. (a), 192 (2), 354-359. [11] Paper 246 (2002). CS-lMax technical Digest. [12] Karpov, S.Yu., Talalaev, R.A., Makarov, Yu.N., Grandjean, N., Massies, J. & Damilano, B. (2000) Surf. ScL, 450, 191. [13] Mihopoulos, T.G., Gupta, V. & Jensen, K.F. (1998) /. Cryst. Growth, 195, 733. [14] Bland, S.W. (2002) /. Mater ScL: Mater Electron., 13, 679. [15] Jensen, K.F. (1989) /. Cryst. Growth, 98, 148.
68
Optoelectronic
Devices:
Ill-Nitrides
[16] Bergunde, T., Dauelsberg, M., Kadinski, L., Makarov, Yu.N., Yuferev, V.S., Schmitz, D., Strauch, G. & Jurgensen, H. (1997) J. Cryst. Growth, 180, 660. [17] Dauelsberg, M., Kadinski, L., Makarov, Yu.N., Bergunde, T., Strauch, G. & Weyers, M. (2000) /. Cryst. Growth, 208, 85. [18] Kleijn, C.R. & Hoogendoom, C.J. (1991) Chem. Eng. Sci., 46, 321. [19] Biber, C.R., Wang, C.A. & Motakef, S. (1992) /. Cryst. Growth, 123, 545. [20] Joh, S. & Evans, G.H. (1997) Numerical Heat Transfer Part A, 31, 867. [21] Stringfellow, G.B. (1999) Organometallic Vapor-Phase Epitaxy, Academic Press, London. [22] Simka, H., Willis, B.G., Lengyel, I. & Jensen, K.F. (1997) Prog. Cryst. Growth Charact., 35, 117. [23] Sengupta, D. CFD Research Corp. Huntsville, AL, unpubUshed results, www.cfdrc.com. [24] Davidson, D.F., Kohse-Hoinghaus, K., Chang, A.Y. & Hanson, R.K. (1990) Int. J. Chem. Kinetics, 22, 513. [25] Lee, R.T. & Stringfellow, G.B. (1999) /. Electron. Mater, 28, 963. [26] Thon, A. & Kuech, T.F. (1996) Appl. Phys. Lett., 69, 55. [27] Mihopoulos, T., (1999). PhD Thesis, MIT. [28] Chen, C.H. (1996) J. Electron. Mater, 25, 1004. [29] Bird, R.B., Stewart, W.E. & Lightfoot, E.N. (1960) Transport Phenomena, Wiley, New York. [30] Kleijn, C.R. (1995) Chemical vapor deposition processes, in Computational Modeling in Semiconductor Processing, Ed. Meyyappan, M., Artech House, Boston, pp. 97-230. [31] Reid, R.C., Prausnitz, J.M. & Poling, B.E. (1987) The Properties of Gases and Liquids, McGraw-Hill, New York. [32] Hirschfelder, J.O., Curtis, C.F. & Bird, R.B. (1954) Molecular Theory of Gases and Liquids, Wiley, New York. [33] Modest, M.F. (1993) Radiative Heat Transfer, McGraw-Hill, New York. [34] Patankar, S.V. (1980) Numerical Heat Transfer and Fluid Flow, Hemisphere, New York. [35] Ferziger, J.H. & Peric, M. (1996) Computational Methods for Fluid Dynamics, Springer, Berlin. [36] CFD-ACE + from CFD Research Corporation, www.cfdrc.com. [37] Fluent from Fluent Inc., www.fluent.com. [38] CFX from Ansys Inc., www.ansys.com/cfx/.
optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides M. Razeghi and M. Henini (Eds.) © 2004 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Chapter 5
MOCVD Growth of Group III Nitrides for High-power, High-frequency Applications M.A. di Forte-Poisson^'*, M. Magis^, M. Tordjmann^ and J. di Persio'' ^Thales Research & Technology, Domaine de Corbeville, 91404 Orsay Cedex, France ^Universite de Lille, LSPES-59655 Villeneuve d'Ascq, France
This chapter reports on the LP-MOCVD growth optimization of bulk GaN, GaAlN materials and GaAlN/GaN heterostructures grown on sapphire and silicon carbide substrates for MESFET and HEMT applications, and on the device performances obtained with these structures. High-purity GaN grown on sapphire and silicon carbide has been obtained, with carrier concentration lower than 10^^ cm~^. GaN/Al203 MESFETs based on such high-purity GaN buffer layers, have exhibited very promising static and microwave performances: high breakdown voltage ~ 200 V, ft = 12 GHz, /rnax = 25 GHz and CW output power in excess of 2.2 W/mm at 2 GHz. They have shown the best low-frequency noise (LFN) performances, with the lowest Hooge's parameter as compared to the values reported in the literature for different GaNbased FETs (HFETs and HEMTs). The incorporation of aluminum in the solid phase has been studied as a function of the growth parameters, and a parasitic reaction was clearly identified to occur in the gas phase between TMA and NH3, with a strong influence on the growth rate and the aluminum incorporation. The GaAlN bulk material appeared to be highly tensilely strained and electrically compensated for Al content higher than 20%. Plastic relaxation, associated with the generation of misfit dislocations and a strong decrease of the elastic strain, was observed in GaAlN alloy with 30% Al content, which well correlates with a critical thickness of 1000 A for this alloy composition. The thickness of the high bandgap layer of the GaAlN/GaN HEMT structures under study (Al content in the range 22-28.5%), grown on sapphire or SiC, is lower than the observed critical thickness, leading to a pseudomorphic growth which was confirmed by high-resolution X-ray diffraction (HR-XRD) and TEM. The critical impact of some growth parameters on the physical properties of the GaAlN/GaN epilayers grown on SiC has been identified and studied using HR-XRD, E-mail address:
[email protected]
69
70
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
AFM, C-V and Eddy current probe measurements. The SiC substrate surface preparation (both ex situ and in situ) and the nucleation layer growth conditions (growth temperature, thickness, composition and strain) have been found to be key steps of the GaAlN/GaN/SiC growth process. SiC substrates from different suppHers have been evaluated and their influence on the physical properties of the GaAlN/GaN HEMT structures investigated. Static characteristics of the devices such as maximum drain current /^ss or pinch-off voltage have been correlated with the nucleation layer composition of the HEMT structure and the defect density of the SiC substrate. The devices' performances related to our first GaAlN/GaN HEMT structures grown on sapphire and silicon carbide have confirmed the high potentiality of GaN and related alloys for high-power microwave transistors. Load-pull measurements performed at 2 GHz on devices related to GaAlN/GaN/Al203 HEMT structures, have shown a remarkably high output power density (4.4 W/mm) and absolute power level (3.5 W for 1 mm devices). These power level results for devices on sapphire substrates measured on wafer, are in good agreement with the international state-of-the-art. Nevertheless, the thermal effects, which lead to a significant reduction of the power density with the increase of the transistor size, have been found to be more pronounced for devices on sapphire. In order to improve the thermal properties of HEMT's material, the growth process of GaAlN/GaN HEMTs was transferred onto silicon carbide substrates. Devices related to GaAlN/GaN/SiC HEMT structures have been measured at 10 GHz using a load-pull system. They exhibited a CW output power in excess of 4 W/mm for a gate length of 0.25 |xm.
5.1. INTRODUCTION Wide bandgap semiconductors, such as SiC and GaN, exhibit many attractive properties far beyond the capabilities of Si and GaAs: the unique combination of the wide bandgap, the high breakdown field (over 2 MV/cm), the high saturation velocity and the ability to form high-quality GaAlN/GaN heterostructures with good transport properties make them ideal candidates for high-power, high-frequency applications. GaAlN/GaN high electron mobility transistors (HEMTs) with high impressive power densities up to 11.2 W/mm at 10 GHz have been reported by Cornell [1], and recently up to 20 W/mm at 4 GHz by Cree Research [2]. HRL [3] has demonstrated a current gain cutoff frequency (/t) of 110 GHz. This rapid progress in the performance of microwave power transistors, as compared to results published in early 1998 (2 W/mm), has been obtained thanks to the use of SiC substrates instead of sapphire. Although the device performance benefits from the high-thermal conductivity and high-thermal stability of SiC, the lattice mismatch (—3.5%) and the thermal expansion
MOCVD Growth of Group III Nitrides
71
difference of SiC relative to GaN (—3.2%) produce a high density of threading dislocations in the GaAlN/GaN HEMT structures. These dislocations together with the defects present in the substrate affect the background doping of the GaN buffer layer and degrade the device performance. In this chapter, we report on a comparative study of the physical properties of GaAlN/ GaN HEMT structures grown, respectively, on sapphire and silicon carbide substrates. The critical steps of the MOCVD growth process of GaN on SiC (substrate surface preparation, nucleation layer composition and growth parameters) are described and their effects on the physical properties of the HEMT structures and the associated device performances are presented. The GaN growth optimization on sapphire for MESFET applications and the obtained devices performances are also reported. MESFET devices have been developed mainly to test the GaN material quality and the potentiality of this material for microwave applications.
5.2.
GaN MESFET DEVICES
5.2.1 Experimental Procedure The non-intentionally doped and silicon (Si) doped GaN layers were grown at low pressure (50 mb), in an AIXTRON RF reactor on sapphire substrates, using triethylgallium (TEG) or trimethylgalHum (TMG) and ammonia (NH3) as gallium and nitrogen precursors. The growth was performed using the popular two step procedure. First, a nucleation layer (GaN or AIN) was deposited at low temperatures (480-560°C). Then, the GaN layers were grown at high temperatures (1050-1150°C) at a growth rate of about 1.2 |jLm/h, with a V/III ratio of 1500. Hydrogen was used as the carrier gas. Several growth parameters were varied to optimize GaN films: growth temperature and thickness of the nucleation layer, growth temperature and growth rate of the high temperature deposited GaN epilayer, V/III ratio, substrate orientation and the insertion of a second low temperature deposited GaN layer to reduce etch pit density. The material quality of GaN layers was assessed by various characterization techniques such as Hall and C-V measurements, HR-XRD, low-temperature photoluminescence (LT-PL), transmission electron microscopy (TEM), and secondary ion mass spectroscopy (SIMS). Reflectivity was used in complement to photoluminescence owing to its sensitivity to intrinsic properties of nid GaN. 5.2.2 Results Non-intentionally doped GaN samples with characteristics close to the state-of-the-art were obtained using a GaN nucleation layer on c-axis sapphire substrates.
72
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
The background concentration, which must be minimized to utilize GaN as a buffer layer for MESFET device [4] was found to be lower than 10^^ cm~^ under optimized growth conditions. These nid GaN samples showed full linewidths at half maximum (FWHM[ooo2]) in HR-XRD of about 250-300 arcsec and sharp band-edge emission lines of about 4 meV in LT-PL (10 K). LT-PL and reflectivity spectra of two highly resistive GaN samples (p, respectively, close to 10 and 50 fl cm), are shown in Figures 5.1 and 5.2, respectively. The reflectivity spectra exhibit three resolved resonances, due to excitons involving the Fg and the two Fj valence band holes, labeled A, B and C, respectively. The corresponding PL spectra display free exciton A and B transitions and the usual residual donor bound exciton line (DoX) observed in undoped GaN, which is 6-7 meV lower in energy than the A line. A shift of 6-7 meV between the excitonic transitions of the two samples is observed. This shift may be due to a residual strain in the GaN layer [5], whose level is strongly dependent on the growth conditions, nucleation and layer thickness. The more resistive GaN sample (p ~ 50 H cm), grown with the insertion of a second low temperature deposited GaN layer, appears to be less strained than the less resistive one (p ~ 10 n cm). Such a highly resistive GaN was used as a buffer layer for the GaN MESFET we have fabricated. N type doping of GaN has been achieved using silicon from silane. We have observed a linear variation of the silicon concentration incorporated with the increase of silane flow rate in the gas phase (Figure 5.3).
Reflectivity Photoluminescence
Figure 5.1. LT-PL and reflectivity spectra of highly resistive GaN (p = 10 O cm).
73
MOCVD Growth of Group III Nitrides " Reflectivity Pliotoluminescence p = 50 Q cm
Figure 5.2. LT-PL and reflectivity spectra of highly resistive GaN (p = 50 ft cm).
A good control of the carrier concentration was obtained in the range 5 X 10^^10^^ cm~^. Thickness and doping dispersion obtained on 2-in. GaN samples were less than 5%. No significant degradation of the GaN structural properties was observed with the incorporation of silicon. X-ray rocking curves revealed an increase of the FWHM from
6x10^^
0.0
1.0x10"^
2.0x10"^
3.0x10"^
4.0x10"®
5.0x10"®
SiH4 flow rate (mol/min) Figure 5.3. Hall carrier concentration of Si doped GaN as a function of silane flow rate.
74
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
300 arcsec for 5 X 10^^ cm~^ doped GaN samples to 430 arcsec for highly doped GaN samples (~ 10^^ cm~^). The 10 K photoluminescence linewidth of the near band edge transition of these samples increased from 5 to 80 meV as silicon level was increased. This broadening can be attributed to the random distribution of donor impurities. The MESFET epilayer structure under study consisted of a 3.6 ixm insulating GaN buffer and a 0.2 luim Si-doped GaN (~2 X 10^^ cm~^) (Figure 5.4). Hall measurements have shown a room temperature mobility of 330 cm^fV s with a carrier density of 3.8 X 10^^ cm^. The fabrication process was a conventional mesa isolated process with chlorine RIE used for mesa definition. Ti/Al/Ni/Au was used for ohmic contact formation and Pt/Au for the gate metal. Devices were realized with gate lengths (Lg) of 2 and 0.3 luim (Figure 5.4). Figure 5.5 shows the output I-V characteristic of a device with L^ = 2 juum and sourcedrain separation of 5 ixm. The gate-drain breakdown voltage is up to 200 V. Small signal microwave characterization performed on device with Lg = 0.3 ixm yielded current-gain and power-gain cut-off frequencies (/x and/^ax) of 12 and 25 GHz respectively as shown in Figure 5.6a and b. For the Lg = 0.3 ixm devices, the peak saturation current achieved at VGS = +1 V was 330 mA/mm and a maximum extrinsic transconductance {g^) of 32 mS/mm was obtained. CW power measurements were performed at 2 GHz using a load-pull system. A record output power density [6] of 2.2 W/mm with an associated power added efficiency (PAE) of 25% was measured on 0.3 jxm X 100 jxm devices (Figure 5.7). GaN MESFET devices have also been investigated through LFN characterizations.
ptmi mAlM/Au
Seure«
Sate
/
Channel GaN (2 ^.0^^ cm-^
Buffer ^ N - N X D
Nucleation
pE dapphire 5ubs1ratB Figure 5.4.
GaN MESFET structure.
Dm in
2000;(
Z,ifm
75
MOCVD Growth of Group III Nitrides
Vds max = 100 V, Id = 80 mA/mm Figure 5.5.
Vbr = 200 V
Output I-V characteristic of the MESFET (Lg = 2 ixm, Lsd = 5 |xm).
(a) 18 lO
-
16-
•
J
1412-
g
•
•
10-
^ • • •
8-
-
b4-
FT=12GHZ
• •
-
••
2-
4
X '
0-
10 Frequency (GHz) /lO -
•
'
'
100
. , . , ,' ' -
»
•
•
•
•
ZV ~
^ *
•
-
•
[
•
CD
i
15-
X
% «»
•
10-
Fn,a><=25GHz ^ 1
CD
¥*
50-
;
'•_
^\ *J > 10 Frequency (GHz)
Figure 5.6.
-
.^.^^ 100
(a) Current gain versus frequency; (b) power gain versus frequency.
76
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides 2.2 W/mm
15
5 10 Output Power (dBm) Figure 5.7.
20
Power performance of a 0.3 |xm X 100 jjum GaN MESFET on sapphire at 2 GHz.
10^
10^ Frequency [Hz]
Figure 5.8.
Input referred equivalent noise voltage spectral density for GaN MESFETs.
11
MOCVD Growth of Group III Nitrides
Figure 5.8 reports the noise spectra of the equivalent input voltage spectral density ^v for GaN MESFET devices. We have observed that all the noise spectra exhibit a llf noise shape and that pronounced generation-recombination {g-r) bumps are absent. On the other hand, it can be observed that the noise spectra exhibit a pronounced dependence on VGS- The noise magnitude at frequencies above 1 kHz decreases with decreasing VGSIn order to better address the device quality, the investigated devices were compared in terms of their Hooge's parameter, defined as follows: «H ^Vsat/d
where Sy is defined in Figure 5.8, g^ is the transconductance, Vsat is the electron saturation velocity in the channel, I^ is the drain current, L^ff is the length of the saturated velocity channel beneath the gate, / is the frequency and q is the elementary charge. Figure 5.9 compares the Hooge's parameters obtained in the present work with the values reported in the Hterature for different GaN-based FET's (HFET and HEMT) [7-9]. Moreover, it is worth noticing that the GaN MESFET devices exhibit values of the Hooge's parameter comparable, or at least lower, to the values reported in Ref. [7] for other HFET devices.
3i
• HEMT
I
o o 21 +
HFET
E cz I—
a. 11 + o o X
HFET
MESFET [This work]
'.S; 1 1997
Figure 5.9.
1998
1999 Year
2000
2001
Comparison of the Hooge's parameter for different GaN-based FET technologies.
78
Optoelectronic Devices: III-Nitrides
5.3. GaAlN/GaN HEMT DEVICES 53,1 Sapphire Substrate 5.3.1.1 Experimental Procedure, GaAlN bulk material and GaAlN/GaN HEMT heterostructures with Al content varying from 12.5 to 29% were grown in a single wafer AIXTRON reactor, on sapphire substrates, using triethylgallium (TEG), trimethygallium (TMG), trimethylaluminum (TMAl) and ammonia (NH3) as group III and group V precursors, respectively. The incorporation of aluminum in the solid phase has been studied as a function of the group III element molar fraction, V/III ratio and growth temperature. A parasitic reaction was clearly identified to occur in the gas phase between TMAl and NH3, which has strong influence on the growth rate and the aluminum incorporation. As a matter of fact, these two parameters were found to decrease as the NH3 flow (V/III ratio) is increased, as seen in Figure 5.10, while their variation with the Al/Al -|- Ga molar fraction appeared to be non-linear. 5.3.1.2 Material Property Results, GaAlN bulk material grown on GaN appeared to be highly tensilely strained. The strain, checked by HR-XRD was found to increase with Al incorporation (a =13
GPa; JCAI = 12.5% => a= 2.82 GPa; JCAI = 29%).
Plastic relaxation, associated with the generation of misfit dislocations and a strong decrease of the tensile strain, was observed in GaAlN alloy with 30% Al content, which correlates well with a critical thickness of 1000 A for this alloy composition [10].
— •
I
1
1
1
•
•
1 — 1
•
•
1
•
«
•
1
'
•
• — 1
1 ' 1
1.10
13-
1.05; J 1.00 - H
03^ 1 1 -
« 0.96 ,
"^ 1 0 -
0.85
81
2.0x10^
1
1
1
r — 1
2.5x10"
,
1
1
3.0x10'
1
1
1
1
3.5x10'
1
1
11
>
4.0x10^
'"1
1
(
" 1
1
4.5x10'
Motar fk>wNH^ (moi/min) Figure 5.10. Aluminum content and growth rate versus NH3 molar flow in GaAlN bulk material.
MOCVD Growth of Group III Nitrides
79
N-type doping of GaAlN material has been studied as a function of Al content, using Si from silane as dopant. The material appeared to be electrically compensated for Al content higher than 20%. However, SIMS analysis performed on such samples revealed silicon incorporation up to 10^^ cm~^ even in highly compensated samples, associated with a low oxygen concentration ([O] ~ 5 X 10^^ cm~^). The observed compensation could be explained by the amphoteric behavior of silicon (N type -^ P type material) due to the high nitrogen vacancy concentration generated in GaAlN bulk material with high Al content (low anmionia flow during the growth), or by the presence of a deep level bound to Al. More investigation studies have to be done on this specific aspect. The physical properties of the GaAlN/GaN bulk material we have grown are summarized in Table 5.1. GaAlN/GaN HEMT heterostructures under study consisted of a 3 ixm insulating GaN buffer layer followed by 0.03 (jim undoped and Si doped GaAlN layer with Al content varying from 22 to 29%. The surface morphology was observed to be "mirror like" for all the heterostructures. This roughly indicates that the high bandgap layer thickness is lower than the critical thickness in the range of the alloy composition studied. The transport properties of such heterostructures have been studied at low temperatures (10-300 K) and at high temperatures (300-500 K). The variation of the hall mobility and sheet carrier density for one of these heterostructures (x^i ~ 20%) is illustrated in Figures 5.11 and 5.12. We observe a constant value of the Hall mobility from 100 to 10 K, which can be explained by the formation of a two-dimensional electron gas (2DEG) at the GaAlN/GaN interface of the HEMT heterostructure. Our analysis of undoped and doped HEMT structures revealed that the 2DEG sheet charge density is mainly due to the spontaneous and piezoelectric polarization, while the contribution of the introduction of Si doping into the GaAlN layer plays a secondary role in the formation of such 2DEG sheet charge density. Table 5.1. Physical properties of GaAlN bulk material Run number {R °) Al content XAL(%)
Strain a (MPa)
Sheet resistance
Rnm AEC791 AEC789 AEC792 AEC788 AEC790 AEC805
12.5 15.4 16 19 23 29
1.3 1.75 1.75 2.19 2.5 2.82
1150 1250 1500 2800 10,000 > 20,000
Carrier concentration Nd-Na (cm'^)
Hall carrier concentration
1.5X10^^ 7X10^^ 5 X 10^^ 5-7x10^^
-
-
3 X 10^^
-
Hall mobility fjL (300 K) (cm^A^ s)
800
-
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
80 *tuuu •
3000-
1
—r
n ww « * « * * * * * * -f * * * 1
2-
CM
F o^
I
c
1
•
1
E
«
1
1 1
*
1 1
2000-
«* " *
^: !5 o
1
* X
1000900800700600- —f8 10
—1-
20
—^ 40
H — — 1 - —1 60 80100
1
200
400
Temperature (K) Figure 5.11. Temperature dependence of Hall mobility for an GaAlN/GaN HEMT heterostructure.
In the temperature range of 300-500 K, the sheet carrier density appeared to be constant as seen in Figure 5.12, while a 50% reduction in the Hall mobility is observed in the same range of temperature. This behavior of the mobility, also observed in SiC material, will lead to a decrease in the current density and output power density of the associated HEMT device. This is the major reason for the decrease in the device current density with the gate periphery, as previously published. aec 603b 1E13
10000
E o
Q
-J 1000
en O
J2
o £
1E12
100 300
350
400 450 Temperature (K)
500
Figure 5.12. Temperature dependence of Hall mobility and sheet carrier density for a GaAlN/GaN HEMT heterostructure.
MOCVD Growth of Group III Nitrides Btructufe hemt
Omega 63.04700 Phi4B.OO 2Theta126.06503 Psi 000
me
81
XO.DO YO.00
1K-
/
100-
\
"
tAptjniiteriL
\
-
Simulation
/ 101-
1
"^^
fM^*^f^^rt#^f^|,,
0.10.010,001-
-,
jiiiiti jiilitii i^wll^llllJ^J •SOflO
4000
-2000
1
li
U[.i,,,lT"iWp'i'l
0
2000
WL^
,
,
4O0S
,—Emu—1—ft~JR—3Kk—jJWWWfc—,
u
6000 ArgbClseconcte)
Figure 5.13. X-ray rocking curves of a GaAlN/GaN HEMT heterostructure (experiment and simulation).
The high-mobility value obtained at low temperatures (/177 K = 3670 cvc^fW s) for the above-mentioned HEMT structure reveals a good quality of the GaAlN/GaN interface, in good agreement with the structural properties checked by HR-XRD and TEM measurements. Figure 5.13 shows a nice fit of the experimental and calculated X-ray rocking curves related to the mentioned GaAlN/GaN HEMT heterostructure. The main characteristics of the HEMT heterostructure extracted from this profile have been the following: thickness of each layer (woaAiN = 30 nm, WoaN = 3 ixm), Al content of the high-bandgap layer (x^i = 19%). The observation of fringes on the experimental spectrum, which suggests a good structural quality of the HEMT heterostructure, was confirmed at the atomic scale by TEM (Figure 5.14). The GaAlN/GaN interface is perfectly delineated, as observed in Figure 5.14, and 57 monolayers (5.18 A) can be counted in the whole thickness of the GaAlN layer which fit the expected 300 A already measured using X-ray.
AEC 603
GaAIN
(JiiN
Figure 5.14.
TEM cross section of a GaAlN/GaN HEMT structure.
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
82 HEMT
AecS04.zfl6
3 11
OmegaG40K00 Phi 4 00 2Theta 128.010)0 Psi 0.03
Aec811.z00
Y0.00
Counls/s
Aec808.zQ0 Aec809.z00
\
llf-
/
J
im-
Aec810.z00 - Aec807.z00
\
10-
'^^Wl^
^ -2906
0
»m
20D0
I^^MM^^
Figure 5.15, X-ray rocking curves of six GaAlN/GaN/Al203 HEMT structures.
A good reproducibility of the growth process is illustrated in Figure 5.15, which shows the X-ray rocking curves of six HEMT structures which have been grown with the same growth parameters and following the same structure design. A nice superimposition of the different figures is observed which fit with an Al content of 22.5%. The good electrical characteristics of such HEMT structures: room temperature mobility higher than 1000 cvc^/W s associated with a high sheet carrier density of 1.4 X 10^^ cm~^, and a low sheet resistance of about 500 H, have been confirmed by the high performance of the corresponding HEMT devices. A successful comparison of our HEMT structures' electrical data (/i, A^^, /?•) with the already pubUshed data is shown in Figure 5.16. 2000
> lioe
I
•
m&^f Ridl»y # t l i
ABU
ATM! \ A •
" ^ S ^ ^ C I U SSBE
IC I f ^ ^ p , ^^^1*^
C
o 1000 E
a.
§00 *
Silicon Carbide Substrates
A NRCAPL,75,19iS.953 '
^
• .
6
7t
DERA data on SiC
THALES
r
8
I
10
12
I
I
14
I
I
I
It
IZJ
I I
I—I
fi
Sh^st Carrier Cons^ *10e12 [em*^
Figure 5.16.
GaAlN/GaN HEMT carrier concentration versus mobility data.
I
I ft
m
MOCVD Growth of Group III Nitrides
83
5,3,1.3 Device Results, Device processing has been performed using a conventional mesa isolated process with chlorine RIE (SiCl3, BCI3) for mesa definition. Either Ti/Al or Ti/Al/Ni/Au metallisations were used for ohmic contact formation and Pt/Au or Ir/Au for the gate metal. The devices were realized with gate lengths (Lg) of 0.5,0.3 and 0.15 juim. Typical ohmic contact resistances of 0.3-0.5 fit mm were obtained after RTA annealing of the metal alloys (850°C, 30 s) while gate contacts with an ideality factor lower than 2 and a Schottky barrier of about 0.8 eV have been achieved. The processed wafers have shown a good homogeneity within an edge exclusion of about 3-5 mm. The mapping of the device-related parameters such as the sheet resistivity of the active layer (Figure 5.17), the maximum saturation current /^ss, the pinch-off voltage Vp (Figure 5.17) and the transconductance g^ are in good agreement with the variation of the basic material properties {/JL, NS, XAI, etc.). For 0.5 juim X 100 |xm devices, we have obtained a typical g^ between 180 and 200 mS and an /^ss maximum of 0.85 A/mm at + 1 V. The bar chart given in Figure 5.18 depicts the main device results (/^ss, ,^m' ^p) of two processed 2-in. diameter GaAlN/GaN HEMT wafers, showing homogeneous data. This indicates stable processing conditions for both epitaxy and processing of the wafers. The small signal microwave performances of 0.5 ixm X 100 jjim devices from the above wafer (AEC837) are shown in Figure 5.19. They show a similar unilateral gain around 25 db at 2 GHz, current-gain and power-gain cut-off frequencies (fi and/j^ax)^ respectively, of 20 and 108 GHz. Load-pull measurements performed at 2 GHz on such wafers (AEC837 and AEC842) have shown remarkably high output power density and absolute power level for devices from wafer AEC837. The measurements have been performed on wafer without additional thermal coupling of the devices.
1
2
3
m •If
• •
368
s4;r
m 579
5
& «J
S41
n
m l«
• AEC 837 Figure 5.17.
7
8
9
10
1
2
3
"' 6
7
a
•3
10
Ugs ab/Y 4 770
M'i
-m.
m
saa
m
K>1
~m
a«6 S^
\sn
m
4^ .4?^
S3S
H
4
4f5
533
s^
5M 5?S
^
•
e m &n
4
im
m
H
-m
m
.4J1B
^.m
•AM%
>iSi
S
,
-^-i^;
4J14 4 5S2 4510
-48^
^
4.45B 4&. 4 496
'm
> AEC 837
tt
4JS4
441
Aim
Sheet resistance and pinch-off voltage mapping on a 2-in. GaAlN/GaN HEMT wafer.
84
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
I WW
AEC 837
AEC 842
Wafers
Figure 5.18.
Summary of device data such as ^^-max, /^^s, Vp from representative GaAlN/GaN 2-in. wafers in bar chart form.
Small devices (0.5 |xm X 100 luim) exhibited at 2 GHz a maximum output power density of 4.2 W/mm with a PAE of 45% as shown in Figure 5.20a. The scaling of output power and power density with device size is given in Figure 5.20b. The significant reduction of power density with increase in the transistor size is due to thermal effects. Nevertheless, the absolute power level of 3.2 W for 1 mm devices on sapphire substrates measured on wafer without efficient coupling to a heat sink is in good agreement with the international state-of-the-art. A summary of the microwave data (output power and PAE) before and after passivation are depicted in bar chart form in Figure 5.21a and b. The passivation increases both
50 ,
•
ft= 19.9 GHz fmax=108GHzJ
•
40 30 J
20 J
0 V g s = - 2 V , Vds = 20V, Lg=0.5Mm -10
^^•t^^^n^m
10
0.1
"W^r^^^
f (GHz) Figure 5.19.
Small signal microwave properties of typical 0.5 |xm X 100 jxm devices from wafer AEC837.
MOCVD Growth of Group III Nitrides
-15 -10
-5
0
400
5
85
600
800
Gate width [\\m)
Figure 5.20.
(a) Pout, PAE and gain versus pin for small devices (0.5 jxm X 100 iJim) at 2 GHz; (b) scaling of output power and power density with device size at 2 GHz.
microwave output power and PAE. However the degree of improvement depends on the individual wafer. High material quality GaAlN/GaN HEMT wafers have shown a minor influence on passivation (AEC837). In contrast, the data from wafers with somewhat lower quality (higher defect density) can be improved significantly by the passivation (AEC842).
B f f l g RF-power before passr^ation ir::..;.l RF-power final measurement
AEC 837 AEC 842 Wafers
^ • M PAE: before passivaljon P ^ ^ PAE: final meaBuremenl
AEC 837
AEC 842
Wafers Figure 5.21. (a) Summary of representative microwave data (output power) at 2 GHz before and after passivation (0.5 |xm X 100 jxm devices); (b) summary of representative microwave data (PAE) at 2 GHz before and after passivation (0.5 jjim X 100 |xm devices).
86
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
5,3,2 Silicon Carbide Substrate 5,3,2,1 Experimental Procedure, GaAlN/GaN heterostructures with 22% Al content were grown by MOVPE in a single wafer 200RF AIXTRON reactor on semi-insulating on-axis 4H-SiC substrates, using triethylgallium (TEG), trimethylaluminum (TMA), and ammonia (NH3) as group III and group V precursors. The growth has been performed at low pressure (50 mb), high temperature (1160°C), and the growth rate was roughly 0.5 |jLm/h for GaAlN and 1.2 juim/h for GaN. The GaAlN/GaN HEMT structures under study consisted of GaN or GaAlN nucleation layers, followed by a 1 ixm thick insulating GaN buffer layer, then a 27 nm Si doped GaAlN layer with 22% Al content, and finally a 3 nm thick undoped GaN cap layer. The transport properties of such heterostructures were studied as a function of temperature from 100 to 500 K. Hall mobihty about 1100 cm^A^ s at 300 K has been obtained, associated with a sheet carrier density of 1.2 X 10^^ cm~^. Since HEMT devices are expected to operate at high temperatures, there is considerable interest to study the influence of temperature on electron mobility. Such an influence can explain the limitation in power and efficiency of the HEMT devices at large drain bias. As shown in Figure 5.22, increasing temperature from room temperature to 500 K reduces the electron mobility by a factor of 2.5. Several growth parameters have been investigated, aiming at optimizing the material quality of the GaAlN/GaN HEMT structures, namely, the growth temperature, thickness and composition of the nucleation layer, and the SiC surface preparation. Various characterization techniques such as atomic force microscopy (AFM), TEM, HR-XRD,
1E14
-i
•
1
•
1
•
E o
t.
n 10000
r-
D— Mobility n— Sheet Carrier Density 1E13
'°^.• ° ^ „
^ 1000
n—D—D-HIl—13—[11-^3—D—D^KD;:;a~D—n—D—D-H^
(0
Si
O
"^^-O
1E12 100 150 200 250
o
100 300 350 400 450 500 550
Temperature (K) Figure 5.22.
Sheet carrier density and hall mobiHty of a GaAlN/GaN HEMT structure as a function of temperature.
MOCVD Growth of Group III Nitrides
87
capacitance-voltage (C-V) and Eddy current probe measurements have been used again for this study. 5,3.2,2 Material Property Results, Due to the large lattice mismatch between GaN and SiC (Aa/a ~ 3.5%), the deposition of the first monolayers is a critical point of the MOCVD process of GaN on SiC. Three major steps in the GaAlN/GaN/SiC growth process have been identified and their impact on the physical properties of the HEMT structures clearly demonstrated [11]: • •
nucleation layer growth temperature, nucleation layer composition. substrate surface preparation.
5,3,3 GaN Nucleation Layer Our first approach of the GaAlN/GaN/SiC growth studies has been concerned with the optimization of HEMT structures based on GaN nucleation layers. The growth temperature of the first GaN monolayers has been identified to have a marked influence on the structural properties of the GaAlN/GaN/SiC HEMT structures. At low growth temperatures, HEMT structures with a ''mirror like" surface morphology are obtained, while a three-dimensional growth process is observed at higher growth temperatures. This observation has been confirmed by HR-XRD measurements. As clearly seen in Figure 5.23, the rocking curves related to GaAlN/GaN/SiC HEMT structures grown at two different GaN nucleation layer growth temperatures, namely 985 and 990°C, exhibit very different X-ray signatures. A good crystallographic quality of the HEMT structure
10^ SiC
GaN FWHIVi=105arcsec FWHM=150arcsec Q.
63
64
65
67
Omega/2Theta (°) Figure 5.23. X-ray rocking curves of two GaAlN/GaN HEMT structures, for two different nucleation layer growth temperatures.
88
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
Figure 5.24.
TEM cross section of a GaN/SiC interface (low growth temperature GaN nucleation layer).
deposited at the lower GaN nucleation layer growth temperature is observed, evidenced by well-delineated peak satellites, up to the second order, of a superlattice structure implemented in the GaN buffer layer, which is indicative of sharp interfaces. TEM analysis revealed that GaN/SiC interfaces grown at low temperatures (980°C) are indeed sharp with steps originating from the substrate misorientation (Figure 5.24), while more ill-defined at higher growth temperatures. 5.3.4
Substrate Surface Preparation
We have observed that the SiC surface preparation is another key point of the GaAlN/GaN growth process on SiC, as illustrated below. AFM measurements performed on as-received substrates have confirmed the poor quality of the surface preparation realized by the substrate suppliers, as seen in Figure 5.25a. A "specific" surface preparation of SiC substrates by Novasic has allowed to obtain a very good surface morphology characterized by an RMS close to 0.7 A and steps at the atomic level (Figure 5.25b).
a) RMS = 6.9 A
b) RMS = 0.7 A
Figure 5.25.
Surface morphology of an "as-received" SiC substrate (a) and after a Novasic surface preparation; (b) 5 |xm X 5 |jLm surface area.
MOCVD Growth of Group III Nitrides
89
Moreover, correlated with this ex situ specific surface preparation by Novasic, we have observed that an in situ anneaUng of the SiC substrate at high temperatures (~ 1000°C) under hydrogen flow, has led to a real breakthrough of the crystalline quality of the GaAlN/GaN epilayers. A reduction of 50% of the GaN rocking curve FWHM (FWHM = 50 arcsec) has been measured as compared to the GaAlN/GaN epilayers grown on as-received substrates (FWHM = 1 0 0 arcsec). The SiC surface preparation also plays an important role on the electrical properties of such GaAlN/GaN HEMT structures. GaAlN/GaN HEMT structures grown on as-received SiC substrates have presented very high sheet resistances {Ru = 4000-15,000 d ) , very far from the targeted value of 500 fl obtained on SiC substrates with the specific surface preparation mentioned above. This evolution of the sheet resistance with the substrate surface preparation may be explained by a strong increase in the piezoelectric effect induced by strain or by the generation of deep traps due to the high density of defects at the GaN/SiC interface. Indeed, due to some surface kinetic aspects, the use of a GaN nucleation layer favors an island growth mode for the first monolayers on SiC. This growth mode would generate more tensile strain and defects in the GaN buffer layer. The substrate surface preparation could play, in this aspect, a catalyst role. This was confirmed by HR-XRD measurements. The GaN buffer lattice parameter (c) was found to be close to 5.158 A for the highly resistive HEMT structures as compared to the 5.1850 A for the unstrained GaN lattice. 5.3,5 GaAlN Nucleation Layers The strong influence of the substrate surface preparation and growth temperature on the growth of the first atomic layers on SiC makes the GaAlN/GaN/SiC growth process clearly non-reproducible using a GaN nucleation layer. In order to improve the reliability of the MOVPE process, we have investigated the growth of GaAlN/GaN/SiC HEMT structures with a GaAlN (Al content = 25%) based nucleation layer. In this case, the growth of the nucleation layer on SiC starts using a step flow mode, leading to a GaN buffer layer also grown in a step flow mode and so less tensilely strained in the HEMT structure. Indeed, the GaN buffer lattice parameter, checked by X-ray, was found to be close to 5.17 A in that case. As a rule, we found a clear improvement of the physical properties of the GaAlN/GaN HEMT structures, as compared to HEMT structures with GaN nucleation layers, with a good reproducibility from run to run. Due to less strain and less defects in the HEMT structures, the residual carrier level in the GaN buffer, checked by C- V measurements, was found to be a decade lower as depicted in Figure 5.26. Mapping of the sheet resistance and pinch-off voltage using C-V and Eddy current probe measurements performed on such GaAlN-based nucleation layer HEMT structures reveal a good homogeneity of these electrical characteristics on 2-in. wafers, as seen in Figure 5.27. Figure 5.28 shows an AFM image of the surface of such a layer and confirms a very good crystaUine quality of the GaAlN/GaN epilayers with a RMS close to 0.3 nm.
90
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides GaN nucleation layer
GaAIN nucleation layer
1.E+20
'R<^
> 0.4
Figure 5.26.
0.6 0.8 Depth (|im)
1
2 Depth (|im)
Capacitance-voltage depth profiles of two GaAlN/GaN HEMT wafers with GaN and GaAIN nucleation layers.
53,6 Device Results Devices related to GaAlN/GaN/SiC HEMT structures based on GaN and GaAIN nucleation layers have been fabricated using a conventional mesa isolated process with RIE for mesa definition. Ti/Al/Ni/Au was used for ohmic contact formation and Pt/Au for the gate metal. The devices were realized with gate length (Lg) of 0.5, 0.3 and 0.25 |xm. Under static measurements we found a maximum drain current /^ss around 1 A/mm and a pinch-off voltage of - 5 V for devices with a gate length of 0.5 juim and a GaN nucleation layer. Better static results have been obtained for devices with the same geometry but with GaAIN nucleation layer. As a matter of fact, an /^ss up to 1.5 A/mm has been recorded [12]. Devices related to HEMT wafers with GaN nucleation layers have been measured at 10 GHz using a load-pull system. They exhibited a CW output power in excess of 2.8 W/mm for a gate length of 0.5 luim, as shown in Figure 5.29.
Figure 5.27.
Sheet resistance and V pinch-ofiF mapping of a 2-in. GaAlN/GaN/SiC HEMt wafer.
MOCVD Growth of Group III Nitrides
Figure 5.28.
91
Surface morphology of a 2-in. GaAlN/GaN/SiC HEMT wafer: RMS = 0.3 nm.
At 2 GHz, we have obtained an absolute output power in excess of 6.5 W for 2 mm X 0.3 ^lm devices and a maximum output power density of 3.5 W/mm has been reached for 1 mm X 0.3 (xm devices. The scahng of the absolute output power and power density versus the gate width of the devices is given in Figure 5.30a and b. A comparison of our results with data from different wafer suppliers is made (Figure 5.30a and b).
5
Figure 5.29.
10 15 Input Power (dBm)
CW performance at 10 GHz of a 0.3 mm X 0.5 ^jim device measured under probes.
92
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides (a)
1
Ha
"ififtiaio
1 1
lfirl»
1
Id
„..._
a1 4 4
4
m
._._
_
•
1
•1
1x128
• •1
• C»4M4W m QCMM-OT
V
4
a
1
w-NBS130C—
_ ^
This work T
1
1
2
1
1 imnri
1
.•-•—..-.^
4
1
(b) « 123C80
tnas
Itxlli — * —
44
immb
3 pr
' 2
3
This work 4
Qitipwidiii lifiin) Figure 5.30.
(a) Scaling of the absolute power versus gate width measured at 2 GHz (Lg = 0.3 [xm). (b) Scaling of the power density versus gate width measured at 2 GHz (0.3 jxm).
The shorter gate of the devices (Lg = 0.3 |xm as compared to Lg = 0.5 U | Lm for the former device process) has led to significantly higher cut-off frequencies: /t increased from 20 to 35 GHz whereas /^ax is higher than 100 GHz.
93
MOCVD Growth of Group III Nitrides Vds = 30V and VQS = -ZVat 10GHz
-PoLrt[dBm] Gain[dB] ^PAE(%)
10 15 Pabs (dBm) Figure 5.31. Load-pull measurement at 10 GHz of a 0.3 mm X 0.25 ixm GaAlN/GaN/SiC HEMT device.
An improvement of the microwave performances has been observed for devices issued from HEMT wafers with GaAlN nucleation layer. CW on-wafer load-pull measurements have been performed at 10 GHz. For 0.3 mm X 0.25 ixm devices, a power density of 4 W/mm has been obtained with a PAE of 28% as shown in Figure 5.31.
5.4.
CONCLUSION
GaN MESFET structures and GaAlN/GaN HEMT structures have been grown on sapphire and silicon carbide by low-pressure MOVPE. The influence of some critical growth parameters on the physical properties of the device structures has been identified and their optimization has led to high-microwave performance devices such as CW output power up to 4 W/mm at 10 GHz for GaAlN/GaN HEMTs on SiC.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors would like to thank C. Brylinki and J.-C. Jacquet for fruitful discussions and a careful reading of the manuscript, B. Grimbert, E. Morvan, M. Laurent, N. Caillas, V. Hoel and J. Wtirfl for device processing, E. Delos, D. Ducatteau, C. Gaquiere and J. Graffeuil for microwave and noise measurements, R. Aubry, N. Sarazin, M. Peschang, D. Lancefield, R. Seitz, E. Pereira, D. Theron and the Novasic Company for material characterization, S. Delage and J.-C. De Jaeger in charge of GaN project at TRT/IEMN common laboratory and D. Pons who launched the GaN program at TRT. The research work presented here has been supported by the French Ministry of Defence (DGA/STTC).
94
Optoelectronic
Devices:
Ill-Nitrides
REFERENCES [1] Shealy, J.R., Kaper, V., Tilak, V., Prunty, T., Smart, J.A., Green, B. & Eastman, L.F. (2002) An AlGaN/GaN high-electron-mobility transistor with an AIN sub-buffer layer. /. Condens. Matter Phys., 14, 3499-3509. [2] Hobgood, H.McD. (2003) Silicon carbide crystal and substrate technology: a survey of recent advances, ICSCRM2003, Proc, Lyon, p. 46. [3] Micovic, M., Nguyen, N.X., Janke, P., Wong, W.S., Hashimoto, P., McCray, L.M. & Nguyen, C. (2000) Electron. Lett., 36, 358. [4] di Forte-Poisson, M.A., Huet, F., Romann, A., Tordjman, M., Trassaert, S., Boudart, B., Theron, D., Seitz, R. & Pereira, E. (1999) LP-MOCVD growth of GaN MESFETs, Proceedings of the European Workshop on Metal Organic Vapor Phase Epitaxy VIII, Prague, p. 77. [5] Leroux, M., Beaumont, B., Grandjean, N., Massies, J. & Gibart, P., (1996) Characterization of near band edge optical transitions in undoped GaN/Sapphire, grown by MVPE, HVPE and GSMBE, Proceedings of MRS Fall Meeting, Boston 1996. [6] Trassaert, S. (2000) Realisation Technologique de transistors aeffet de champ dans les fiUeres InP et GaN pour amplification de puissance Hyperfrequence, Thase de doctorat de I'Universite des sciences et technologies de Lille, 4 Fevrier 2000. [7] Balandin, A., Cai, S., Li, R., Wang, K.L., Ramgopal, V. & Viswanathan, C.R. (1998) Flicker noise in GaN/AlGaN doped channel heterostructure field effect transistors. IEEE Electron. Dev. Lett., 19 (12), 475-477. [8] Balandin, A., Morozov, S.V., Cai, S., Li, R., Wang, K.L., Wijeratne, G. & Viswanathan, C.R. (1999) Low flicker-noise GaN/AlGaN heterostructure field-effect transistors for microwave communications. IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory Tech., 47 (8), 1413-1471. [9] Levinshtein, M.E., Rumyantsev, S.L., Gaska, R., Yang, J.W. & Shur, M.S. (1998) AlGaN/GaN high electron mobility field effect transistors with low 1// noise. Appl. Phys. Lett., 37 (8), 1089-1091. [10] di Forte-Poisson, M.A., Romann, A., Tordjman, M., Dessertenne, B., Cassette, S., Surrugue, M., Frapsauce, N., Adam, D., Delage, S.L., Boudart, B., Gaquiere, C , Vellas, N., Lancefield, D. & di Persio, J. (2001) LP-MOCVD growth of GaAlN on sapphire. Application to HEMT's devices. Proceedings of the European Workshop on Metal Organic Vapor Phase Epitaxy IX, Wrexham, p. 115. [11] di Forte-Poisson, M.-A., Romann, A., Tordjman, M., Magis, M., Di Persio, J., Jacques, Ch. & Vicente, P. (2003) LP-MOCVD growth of GaN on Silicon Carbide. /. Cryst. Growth, 248, 533-538. [12] di Forte-Poisson, M.-A., Magis, M., Tordjman, J., Aubry, R., Peschang, M., Delage, S.L., Di Persio, J., Grimbert, B., Hoel, V., Delos, E., Ducatteau, D. & Gaquiere, C. (2003) LP-MOCVD growth of GaAlN/GaN heterostructures on Silicon Carbide. Application to HEMT's devices. Proceedings of MRS Fall Meeting, Boston.
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides M. Razeghi and M. Henini (Eds.) © 2004 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Chapter 6
Growth of Nitride Quantum Dots Hyun Jin Kim, Soon-Yong Kwon and Euijoon Yoon School of Materials Science and Engineering, Seoul National University, Seoul 151-742, South Korea
6.1. INTRODUCTION For the past few decades, low-dimensional quantum structures, such as quantum wells (QWs), quantum wires (QWRs), and quantum dots (QDs) have been attracting lots of interest due to their potential advantages compared with bulk materials (Figure 6.1). Among these, QDs are expected to be the most promising due to their unique electronic states, such as 5-function-like density of states, three-dimensional (3D) carrier confinement, etc. Due to their unique properties, the semiconductor laser with a QD active layer is expected to have ultra-low threshold current, reduced temperature sensitivity, narrower spectral line width, and high-modulation bandwidth, etc. [1,2]. Furthermore, the semiconductor photodetector with QDs are also expected to have the sensitivity for the normally incident light, enhanced photoexcited carrier lifetime, reduced dark current, and higher electric gain [3]. It was in 1982 that the concept of QDs was proposed for the first time as artificial atoms for semiconductor laser application by Arakawa and Sasaki [4]. Since then, there has been lots of research devoted to the realization of predicted potential advantages of QDs. However, it took about 10 years to realize the fabrication of the practical QD structures. In the 1990s, both selective growth and self-assembled growth technique without the formation of nonradiative defects were well developed. Particularly, the StranskiKrastanow (SK) growth mode was very successful for InGaAs/GaAs systems [5-7]. As a result, lasers, detectors for both inter-band and inter-subband transitions have been successfully demonstrated using the InGaAs/GaAs QDs [8-10]. From the late 1990s this material system has been extended to other material systems. Among those material systems, nitride semiconductors have received the most attention for applications to blue and ultraviolet (UV) light emitting devices, especially, due to the possibility of much bigger impact of QDs in GaN-based LDs [11]. In nitride semiconductors, the larger effective mass of electrons nic or the larger ratio of the effective mass of holes m^ to rric {mjm^), compared to GaAs-based semiconductors.
E-mail address:
[email protected] (E. Yoon).
95
96
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides Bulk
m
Quantum Film
KH
Quantum Wire
Quantum Dot
ii> -io>
^LJVJ Energy
Energy
Energy
Energy
Figure 6.1. Density of states in bulk material, quantum wells, quantum wires, and quantum dots.
results in an increase in the threshold current density of QW lasers: the threshold current density /th of GaN-based QW lasers is expected to be ~ 1 kA/cm^, whereas that of GaAsbased QW lasers to be ~ 100 A/cm^. On the other hand, it was suggested that, if QDs are used in the active region and the size of the QDs is small enough that the population of carriers in the higher subband can be ignored, the achievable threshold current /th in both GaAs-based and GaN-based LDs is almost the same, about 100 nA-1 mA, as shown in Figure 6.2. Therefore, with the use of QDs, the threshold current density is reduced by a factor of 100 in GaN-based lasers compared to GaAs-based lasers, suggesting that the impact of QDs is much bigger in GaN-based LDs than in GaAs-LDs. The promising aspect in the applications of the nitride QDs is also confirmed in the emission mechanism of the InGaN active layer. InGaN active layers for blue and green light emitting diodes (LEDs) are known to have excellent optical properties despite the presence of high-density defects. It is widely accepted that their high-luminescence efficiency is due to the carrier localization induced by the presence of compositional fluctuation and/or QD-like features usually observed in InGaN layers of sufficiently high In content [12]. Therefore, the introduction of QDs would also increase the luminescence efficiency in the system of high dislocation density and especially in material systems without compositional fluctuation such as low In content InGaN, AlGaN, etc. Since the late 1990s, several methods to form QDs using nitride semiconductors were suggested. They can be categorized into four methods: (1) using SK growth mode, (2) using "anti-surfactant", (3) using selective epitaxy, and (4) other novel methods. One of the most attractive methods for defect-free QD formation is the SK growth in lattice-mismatched semiconductor systems, widely used in the QD fabrication of other material systems, such as InGaAs/GaAs [5-9], InAs/InP [10,13], InP/GaAs [14,15],
Growth of Nitride Quantum Dots
97
Gan QW Lasers
(5
QD Lasers 4 6 m,, / m_ Figure 6.2.
8
10
Carrier density at transparency condition plotted as a function of the ratio of effective mass of holes to that of electrons for quantum well (QW) lasers and quantum dot (QD) lasers [11].
GaSb/GaAs [16], InSb/InP [17], SiGe/Si [18], ZnCdSe/ZnSe [19], etc. The schematic diagram of the SK growth mode is presented in Figure 6.3. In the SK growth mode, the mismatched epitaxy is initially accommodated by biaxial compression in a layer-bylayer (2D) growth region, traditionally called as "wetting layer". After the deposition of a few monolayers, the strain energy builds up. Then, the evolution to 3D islands becomes more favorable than the continued, strained planar growth. Such islands are referred to as self-assembled QDs (SAQDs).
Volmer-Wfeber mode
•••••••••••••H
••••••••••!
Figure 6.3. Schematic diagram of typical 3D growth mode (Volmer-Weber mode) and the StranskiKrastanow (SK) growth mode. A wetting layer between the substrate and the quantum dots is present in SK growth mode.
98
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides In contents of InGaN (%) 20 40 60 80
100
2 4 6 8 ID Mismatch of InGalSJ on GaN(%) \
4100^
AIN
CD
<
> P
50 ^
s
Ei c
4
(Ai O
0)
c
0)
1^0 O
GaN
Q. (Q
4o
c o o
G)
I 2 QQ
InN 3.1
^
3.2
3.3 3.4 Lattice constant (A)
3.6
3.6
Figure 6.4. Bandgap energies of AIN, GaN, and InN vs their lattice constants. Ticks and labels in top axis and right axis show the variation in lattice mismatch of InGaN grown on GaN and that of GaN grown on AlGaN, respectively.
Nitride semiconductors can be epitaxially grown to form a strained heterostructure, which is indispensable for the SK growth mode. Figure 6.4 shows the lattice constants of AIN, GaN, and InN compared with their bandgap energies. As shown in Figure 6.4, the lattice mismatch between AlGaN and GaN ranges from 0 to 2.4%, and that between InGaN and GaN ranges from 0 to 11.1%, which is sufficiently large to have all growth modes (the strained 2D growth mode, the SK growth mode, and the relaxed 3D growth mode). By the proper combination of QD and substrate materials, the extent of strain in the film and subsequent QD growth behavior can be controlled. It is also worth noting that the large difference in their bandgap energies in Figure 6.4 (from 0.7 eV (InN) to 6.2 eV (AIN)) is also advantageous for the realization of heterostructure with large band-offsets, which would enhance the carrier localization efficiency of QDs. The nitride QDs were also demonstrated by using "anti-surfactant". The pretreatment of the growth surface by anti-surfactant, such as tetraethylsilane (TESi, Si(C2H5)4), were found to result in the 3D growth mode of the subsequent layer, even in the case with little lattice-mismatch. The presence of the wetting layer was not confirmed in the QDs grown by this method. Since this growth mode does not require lattice mismatch, the restriction in the choice of film/substrate combination can be somewhat relaxed.
Growth of Nitride Quantum Dots
99
The method using selective epitaxy attempted in the nitride QD formation is similar to the method of patterning QWs, generally used in other III-V compound semiconductors. In this case, at first, pyramidal structures are grown on a patterned substrate using selective epitaxy. Then, QDs are grown on top of those pyramidal structures. However, this method has similar advantages with the method of patterning QWs, such as (1) the possibility of almost arbitrary lateral shape, size, and position realization, (2) general compatibility with the modem ULSI technologies in the patterning process of this method. However, there are some drawbacks, such as defects or damages induced by etching process. Besides the techniques described above, other novel techniques were also attempted to fabricate the nitride QDs, such as the nitridation of metallic droplets [20-22], the surface passivation and/or pretreatment [23-25], the laser ablation [26], the ion implantation [27], the colloidal synthesis [28], etc., by several research groups. In this chapter, various techniques to form nitride QDs are reviewed, and the current status of nitride QD research is discussed. In particular, emphasis is put on three major growth techniques such as growth of strain-induced SK QDs, growth by anti-surfactant, and growth by selective epitaxy. Table 6.1 summarizes the three major techniques for nitride QD formation and material systems explored. Effects of various parameters in each growth techniques and changes in physical properties are reviewed. Finally, novel formation techniques are briefly reviewed.
Table 6.1. Summary of three major techniques to form nitride quantum dots Techniques SAQDs by SK growth mode
Organization
Authors
Growth
Material system
CEA-Grenoble
Daudin et al.
MBE
CNRS
Damilano et al.
MBE
University of Tokyo Seoul National University University of Montpellier II
Tachibana et al.
MOCVD
Kim et al.
MOCVD
GaN/AlN [29-31,37]; InGaN/GaN [35] GaN/AlN/Si [32]; InGaN/GaN [33,34,36] GaN/AlN/6H-SiC [38]; InGaN/GaN [39-41] In-rich InGaN/GaN [42,43]
Briot et al.
MOCVD
InN/GaN [45]
QDs using anti-surfactant
RIKEN
Tanaka et al.
MOCVD; MBE
GaN/AlGaN/6H-SiC [49-53]; InGaN/GaN/6H-SiC [54]
QDs by selective epitaxy
University of Tokyo University of Tokushima
Tachibana et al.
MOCVD
Wang et al.
MOCVD
InGaN/GaN [55]; GaN/AlGaN [56] InGaN/GaN [57,58]
100 6.2.
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides GROWTH OF STRAIN-INDUCED QUANTUM DOTS
6,2,1 Self-assembled Quantum Dots by MBE One of the most attractive methods to form defect free QDs is the SK growth in latticemismatched systems. The growth of SAQDs by the SK growth mode has been successfully demonstrated using both MBE and MOCVD. The GaN QD growth using SK growth mode was reported for the first time by Daudin et al. [29]. They monitored the changes in growth mode of GaN on AIN by reflection high-energy electron diffraction (RHEED). Their growth of (0001) AIN and GaN with wurtzite structure was carried out by MBE on (0001) sapphire substrates. Atomic nitrogen was produced by an RF plasma source. After nitridation of a sapphire substrate by exposing it to nitrogen plasma, a thin (about 15 ml) AIN buffer was deposited at a substrate temperature T^ of 500°C, followed by the growth of a 2-|ULm-thick GaN buffer and of a 200-nm-thick AIN layer at 650°C. AIN layer was fully relaxed with respect to the GaN buffer, judging from the changes in RHEED streak spacing. Subsequently, GaN epilayer was deposited on AIN and its relaxation was studied by RHEED. The growth behavior of GaN on AIN was rather different depending on substrate temperature, 7^, as shown in Figure 6.5. At 720''C, the Bragg spot intensity increased after deposition of 2 ml, which was attributed to 2D/3D growth mode transition. For further GaN deposition, the Bragg spot intensity remained constant, indicating a persistent 3D growth mode. In contrast, at 620°C, the indication of 2D/3D transition is hardly observed and the Bragg spot intensity decreased rapidly down to the value corresponding to the reflectivity of a smooth GaN surface, suggesting a fast recovery of 2D growth. On the other hand, at intermediate temperature ranges, for example, at 690°C, the increase in the Bragg spot intensity after the deposition of 2 ml GaN was followed by a rapid decrease after deposition of about 6 ml. This rapid decrease in intensity was found to be associated with the transition of streaky RHEED pattern to spotty pattern. By precise control of SK growth mode by RHEED observation, GaN QDs were obtained [29,30]. The image of a smooth AIN base layer prior to GaN deposition is shown in Figure 6.6(a). When about 4 ml GaN layers were deposited on the AIN surface, GaN QDs were formed as shown in Figure 6.6(b). They are typically 10 nm wide, 2 nm high and their density was about 5 X 10^^ cm~^. The size and density of QDs could be further controlled by using growth interruption. Figure 6.6(c) shows GaN QDs obtained at 710°C by depositing 2 ml GaN, followed by exposure to N plasma for 50 s. Clearly, the QD density was reduced (5 X 10^^ cm~^), however, their size became larger (25 nm wide and 5 nm high) than in the previous case, due to the coalescence process occurring under atomic nitrogen flux. Inclined RHEED streaks were observed in this case, indicating that pyramidal QDs with sixfold symmetry and (10-13) facets were formed after the coalescence.
Growth of Nitride Quantum Dots (a)
101
3 :
2.5 [•
•
•
Tg = 720°C
'•
3 1.5 3 0.5 0 ^-0.5
\ f
Pl-^. [[
1
U A ^ /i
-
Time (s)
:
)
2
4
6
8
\
10 •
(0
c 0
Q
10
15
25
Thickness (ML) Figure 6.5.
Change in in-plane lattice parameter (dotted line) and Bragg spot intensity (full line) as a function of the thickness of GaN on AIN [29].
The atmosphere during the growth interruption played an important role in the coalescence process. GaN QD formation at 700°C by depositing 3 ml GaN on AIN surface and subsequent growth interruption under either N plasma or under vacuum for 3 min at 700°C resulted in different surface morphology. Growth interruption under vacuum led to further coalescence process with sparse and larger QDs, as shown in Figure 6.7, presumably due to the increase in the mean-free-path of Ga on N-deficient surface.
102
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
200 nm
200
nm Figure 6.6. (a) AFM observation of a smooth AIN surface, (b) GaN QDs formed by depositing 4 ml GaN on the AIN surface followed by cooling down under vacuum, (c) GaN QDs formed by depositing 2 ml GaN on the AIN surface followed by exposure to N plasma for 50 s [29].
Growth of Nitride Quantum Dots
103
Figure 6.7. 200 nm X 200 nm AFM images for GaN QDs grown on AIN at 700°C and experienced the growth interruption and cooling process (a) under N plasma flux, and (b) under vacuum [30].
The optical properties of the GaN SAQDs could be tailored by controlHng their sizes [31]. PL spectra at 2 K from "small dots" with a typical height of 2.3 nm (8 nm in diameter) and "large dots" with a typical height of 4.1 nm (17 nm in diameter) are compared in Figure 6.8. The PL peak from "small dots" is centered at 3.75 eV, nearly 0.3 eV blue shifted with respect to the GaN bandgap. On the other hand, that from "large dots" in the blue at 2.95 eV, i.e. 0.5 eV below the bulk GaN bandgap energy. This striking QD size effect is attributed to the quantum confined Stark effect caused by the presence of a huge piezoelectric field in the QDs along the c-axis. Estimated piezoelectric field present in these QDs was around 5.5 MV/cm, which is more than one order of magnitude larger than the piezoelectric field found in zinc-blende semiconductors for the same amount of strain. Due to this large value, piezoelectric field effects are dominating for QDs whose heights are larger than only 3 nm [31].
I I I—I I I I I—I I I—|—I—r—i—I I I I—|—r
hT=2K
2.4
Large dots
2.6 2.8
I I I—I—I I I I—I—pi
Small dots
3.0 3.2 3.4 3.6 Photon Energy (eV)
3.8 4.0
Figure 6.8. PL spectra (2 K) of small and large GaN QDs grown on AIN [31].
104
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
T ^ mm
CD
1000
600
600
400
200
Wavefength (nm) Figure 6.9. Room temperature PL spectra from GaN QDs on A1N/Si(lll). (a), (b), and (c) correspond to a single plane of GaN QD layer with nominal thickness of 7, 10, and 12 ml, respectively, (d) is the PL spectrum from four-layer-stacked QDs, producing white light [32].
Damilano et al. reported the further red shift of PL emission from GaN QD samples of different QD sizes [32]. They could observe the intense room temperature PL emission from blue to even orange, depending on QD size. Corresponding PL spectra of blue, green, and orange QDs are shown in Figure 6.9. They also grew the stacked GaN QD sample containing four planes of QDs of properly chosen sizes to produce white light, as shown in Figure 6.9(d). MBE growth of InGaN QDs by SK growth mode was also reported. The soHd composition of InGaN, consequently the amount of lattice mismatch, controls its growth mode. Grandjean et al. studied the growth of In^Gai_;,N on GaN with RHEED [33]. It is evident that the critical thickness for 2D/3D transition decreased with increasing In composition in InGaN as shown in Figure 6.10, and that InGaN with high In composition would be favorable for the growth of SAQDs. It was found that only 3 ml could be grown layer-by-layer before islanding when In composition was greater than 0.3. When In composition was less than 0.12, the growth mode no longer underwent a strong 2D/3D transition (denoted by open squares), but rather a progressive roughening of the growth surface occurred, most likely due to insufficient driving force for 2D/3D morphological transition. By careful control of the SK growth mode, the successful growth of InGaN SAQDs on GaN by MBE was made by Damilano et al. [34]. The mean size of their typical QDs was
Growth of Nitride Quantum Dots
105
15
c10 o 2 Q Q
5h
CM
• . . . . - •
0 Figure 6.10.
10
20 30 40 In composition (%)
50
Critical thickness associated with the 2D/3D growth mode transition at various In composition for the growth strained InGaN on GaN at 600°C [33].
about 35 nm in diameter and 4 nm in height. The QD density was ~ 5 X 10^^ cm~^, which was greater than the dislocation density in the GaN base layer (~5 X 10^ cm~^). The In content in these QDs was 15% and the critical thickness was 4 - 5 ml. Adelmann et al. also reported the growth of InGaN SAQDs on GaN by MBE [35]. When In content of their QDs increased to 35%, the mean QD size was decreased to about 27 nm in diameter and 2.9 nm in height. The QD density was increased to ~ 9 X 10^^cm~^ and the critical thickness was decreased to 2 ml. The changes in QD size affected the PL emission wavelength. Damilano et al. also reported that the PL peak energy from their Ino.2Gao.8N/GaN QDs shifted from 3.03 to 2.51 eV with increasing QD size, as shown in Figure 6.11 [34,36]. Changes in PL emission wavelength were attributed to both a decrease in the carrier quantum confinement energy and an increase in the quantum confined Stark effect. The main parameter which determines the QD energy level for a given In composition is the QD height because of the strong built-in electric field along the c-axis and relatively large QD diameter. Gogneau et al. proposed the modified SK mode to grow GaN QDs on AIN by MBE [37]. The schematic diagram of this technique is presented in Figure 6.12. A GaN layer was grown under Ga-rich conditions with absorbed excess Ga bilayer on the growing surface. The resulting GaN epilayer was 2D and had a flat surface as examined by RHEED (Figure 6.12(a)). After the growth was stopped under Ga flux, the surface remained 2D. The RHEED pattern remains unchanged (Figure 6.12(b)). Under vacuum, however, the Ga film desorbed in a few seconds (Figure 6.12(c)), and the GaN layer transformed into facetted 3D surface. The RHEED pattern evidences this island formation by the presence of additional lines characteristic of facets (Figure 6.12(d)).
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
106
-,
,
,
^
,
p—,
,
,
J
RcMDm temperature
,
,
,
y-
M\ 3.03 0V
J'2.85 eV
eV
A"'
t\ J.
2.51 eV
2.0
2.2
2.4
2.6
2.8
3.0
3.2
3.4
3.6
Photon energy (eV) Figure 6.11. Room temperature PL spectra of the InGaN/GaN QDs with different sizes. The PL peak energy of 3.03, 2.85, 2.71, and 2.51 eV correspond to the nominal thickness of 1, 1.5, 2, and 3 nm, respectively [36].
(c)
Ga
ftttt
(d)
Figure 6.12. Schematic diagram of the experimental procedure for the growth of GaN SAQDs by a modified SK growth mode. Ga desorption during growth interruption induces the SAQD formation [37].
Growth of Nitride Quantum Dots
107
(a)i
Figure 6.13. AFM images (1 |xm X 1 yun) of the high density GaN QDs grown on AIN by MBE at 750°C. The GaN coverages are (a) 2.8 ml, (b) 6 ml, (c) 10 ml, and (d) 13 ml [37].
They found that the formation of GaN QDs by this method was governed by GaN coverage. The resulting GaN QDs grown with different GaN coverages are shown in Figure 6.13. It was observed that the island density increased rapidly from the GaN coverage of 2.8-6 ml before saturation, and followed by a slow decrease. It also appears that the QD density can be controlled over about one order of magnitude
108
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
(3 X 10 - 2 X 10^^ cm~^ range) for coverages varying from 2.8 to 6 ml. In comparison, the density of GaN QDs grown by SK mode is already 5 X 10^^ cm~^ for a coverage of only 4 ml and saturates at around this value [30,31]- Therefore, the slight modification of growth process in MBE gave us process flexibility to control QD density as well as size.
6,2,2 Self-assembled Quantum Dots by MOCVD The growth of SAQDs using MOCVD was also reported by several groups. Miyamura et al. reported the growth of GaN SAQDs on AIN surface by MOCVD [38]. They grew a 110-nm-thick AIN layer on a (0001) 6H-SiC substrate at 1180°C with an NH3 flow rate of 2.0 slm. After the AIN layer was grown, the growth temperature was reduced to 960-990°C to grow GaN QDs, relatively lower than the typical GaN growth temperature. The growth temperature and V/III ratio were quite important parameters for the formation of GaN QDs. These parameters affected the migration and/or evaporation of Ga atoms on the GaN surface, leading to surface diffusion to form the 3D nanostructures. The flow rate of NH3 must be reduced to 3 seem (corresponding V/III ratio of 30) during the successful growth of GaN QDs to induce SAQD formation.
(a)
3.4 ML
(b)
5.8 ML 5.0 nm
2.5 nm
0.0 nm
9.2 ML
200 nm Figure 6.14.
AFM images (500 nm X 500 nm) of GaN QDs by MOCVD. The GaN coverages are (a) 3.4, (b) 5.8, (c) 6.9, and (d) 9.2 ml, respectively [38].
Growth of Nitride Quantum Dots
109
A typical morphology of GaN QDs grown on AIN by MOCVD is shown in Figure 6.14. The growth temperature was 965°C under the V/III ratio of 26. The initial GaN surface exhibited a typical 2D growth mode, as shown in Figure 6.14(a). However, as GaN coverage increased more than 4 ml, 2D/3D growth mode transition began with the formation of QDs by SK mode. The average diameter and height of the QDs were 20 and 2 nm, respectively, by AFM measurement. The density of the QDs could be increased to 5 X 10^^ cm~^ by optimizing the growth temperature and the GaN coverage. PL studies on the GaN QDs revealed the existence of the wetting layer, suggesting that the QDs were surely grown by SK growth mode. Figure 6.15 shows the PL spectra of AINcapped GaN samples at room temperature. The sample of Figure 6.15(a) is grown under GaN deposition of 4 ml, and it may contain the wetting layer and no QDs, as shown in Figure 6.14(a). The samples in Figure 6.15(b) and (c) both contain QDs evolved by increasing the equivalent thickness of GaN deposition more than 4 ml. QDs in Figure 6.15(b) and (c) were of different sizes controlled by V/III ratio and growth temperature. Figure 6.15(b) and (c) shows different intense peaks at around 4.1 and 3.5 eV, respectively. These peaks originate from the QD structure and are consistent with their average sizes. However, these three samples exhibit the same PL peak around 4.7 eV,
1
•
1
•
1.0
^
1 < Q D s (c)
1 • 1 > 1 Q D s (b) W L (a)
'
1
'
1 1-
Peak energy Sample (a): 4.77 eV Sample (b): 4.18 eV Sample (c): 3.59 eV
0.8
M
FWHM Sample (a): 240 meV Sample (b): 480 meV Sample (c): 580 meV
CO
S
0.6
c _i
S
1 /
by A r F excimejr I ^^5cited er(193nm)atRT
0-4
03
E o 2
0.2
0.0
A —
\
1
1
Gan bulk ...
1
2.5
1
1
3.0
1
1
3.5
1
1
4.0
1
1
1
4.5
1
5.0
1
1
5.5
1
i
6.0
Photon Energy [eV] Figure 6.15.
Room temperature PL spectra of GaN QDs grown on AIN by MOCVD [38].
no
Figure 6.16.
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
AFM images of (a) a GaN buffer layer, and InGaN SAQDs formed on GaN by the deposition of (b) 6.4 ml and (c) 19.1 ml [39].
which is the wetting layer peak, because QD samples grown by SK growth mode would have the wetting layer of almost the same thickness. The growth of InGaN QD on GaN using MOCVD was also reported by Tachibana et al. [39]. They grew 30 nm of a GaN nucleation layer at 500°C and a thick GaN buffer layer at 1075°C on (0001) sapphire substrate. After the growth of the thick GaN buffer layer, growth temperature was reduced to grow InGaN QDs. V/III ratio during InGaN QD growth was kept at about 7000, which was much higher than 30 used in the case of GaN QDs, presumably due to the increased lattice mismatch in InGaN/GaN QDs. The morphologies of the resulting InGaN QD layers with different coverages are shown in Figure 6.16. As InGaN coverage was increased, the density of QDs increased. The In content of the InGaN QDs was estimated as about 25%. The typical InGaN QDs were 19.5 nm wide and 4.5 nm high. The density of typical InGaN QDs was estimated as 6 x 1 0 ^ cm~^, relatively lower than the density of the GaN QDs on AIN addressed above. They further grew a stacked InGaN QD structure and investigated its optical properties [40]. The room temperature PL spectra from the InGaN QD structures with different
Growth of Nitride Quantum Dots
111
sjngle-sheet 3-stacked — 10-stacked HO'Cd 20 mW RT
'c CD
c
x10
2.0 Figure 6.17.
2.6 3.0 Energy [eV]
3.5
PL spectra at room temperature from (a) a single-layer InGaN QDs, (b) three-layer stacked InGaN QDs, and (c) 10-layer stacked InGaN QDs [40].
number of stacks are shown in Figure 6.17. Stacking of InGaN QDs resulted in an increase in QD density as well as integrated PL intensity. The PL intensity from the three-layer stacked InGaN QDs is about 40 times higher than that from the single-layer QDs. Moreover, the PL intensity from 10-layer stacked InGaN QDs is about 180 times higher than that from the single-layer QDs. In general, the integrated intensity is proportional to the number of stacks, and it is quite likely that the structural quality of InGaN QDs improved as stacking continued. They also grew a laser structure using this 10-layer stacked InGaN QDs [40,41]. The active layer was sandwiched by the Alo.07Crao.93N cladding layers. The cavity facet was fabricated by reactive ion etching (RIE). The laser structure was characterized at room temperature under optical excitation, and the stimulated emission could be observed as shown in Figure 6.18. Above the threshold excitation power, the width of emission peak
en 'c ID
. RT
^ ro
3^ (0
s
-(c)/=1.8/,,
1 1 Jlk
1 1
x1
nm
1
(a) n o r m a l _ E L — ^ ' ^ ' ^ ' ' - - ^ ^ ^
I
JKO.1
^0 "co
E LU
3<35
Figure 6.18.
400 405 Wavelength (nn1)
41
(a) PL spectrum at room temperature under low-power excitation. Stimulated emission spectra at (b) 1.44 and (c) 1.84 [41].
112
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
became as narrow as 0.1 nm (resolution limit), and the emission intensity was dramatically increased. The estimated carrier concentration at the threshold suggested that the lateral confinement of carriers in the stacked InGaN QDs at room temperature was not enough. Further improvement in the QD growth is necessary to obtain reduced QD lateral size and highly uniform QD size distribution and to achieve lower threshold carrier density. In most cases, the In compositions of reported InGaN QDs were limited to below 50%, possibly due to the difficulty of In incorporation into InGaN. However, the growth of In-rich InGaN QDs on GaN would be more favorable for SAQD formation via SK growth mode by increasing lattice mismatch. The growth of In-rich InGaN QDs was reported by Kim et al. [42,43]. They adopted a rather low growth temperature to obtain In-rich InGaN layer compared with the growth temperature of typical InGaN QWs to suppress the In evaporation. The In content of the InGaN QD was precisely estimated by electron probe microanalysis and it ranged around 70-80%. The AFM images of the In-rich InGaN QDs is shown in Figure 6.19. The temperature decrease from 730 to 640°C resulted in drastic changes in surface morphologies and the formation of QDs. The average diameter, height and density of the In-rich InGaN QDs were estimated as about 66 nm, 1.2 nm, and 5.5 X 10^ cm~^, respectively. The low aspect ratio of In-rich InGaN QDs is attributed to the high volatiUty of InN and the high lattice mismatch as high as 11% for pure InN with respect to GaN. Optical properties of the In-rich InGaN QDs were investigated by PL. Figure 6.20 shows 12 K PL spectra of the QDs grown at different input TMIn flow rate and growth time. Emission wavelength from In-rich InGaN QDs could be controlled by slight adjustment of growth conditions. As growth time and input TMIn flow rate decreased, emission peaks showed blue shift to even near-UV emission at 380 nm. PL emission from
Figure 6.19.
AFM image (4 jxm X 4 fxm) of InGaN SAQDs grown on GaN by MOCVD at (a) 730°C, and (b) 640°C [42,43].
Growth of Nitride Quantum Dots
1 d cc 3^ 1 c ; e
:
113
1
1
1 ^-(°) fh-""'^—/^'^
II
/^
„.IU 2lfi^^^22':r^^ 360
400
440
J 480
520
Wavelength (nm) Figure 6.20. PL spectra (12 K) of In-rich InGaN SAQD (a) grown at a standard condition (640°C, input TMIn flow rate 10 fxmol/min, growth time 5 s), (b) grown with less input TMIn flow rate (640°C, input TMIn flow rate 4 fjimol/min, growth time 5 s), (c) grown with shorter growth time (640°C, input TMIn flow rate, 10 |jLmol/min, growth time, 2 s) [42,43].
the QDs could also be observed at room temperature and their thermal stability was found to be much better than In-rich InGaN/GaN QW samples. It strongly suggests that carrier confinement in In-rich InGaN QD sample was enhanced by the introduction of QD structure. The peak emission wavelengths from In-rich InGaN QDs ranged from 380 to 430 nm, corresponding to much higher photon energy than the expected bandgap energy of In-rich InGaN. Large blue shift was also observed from the In-rich InGaN/GaN single QW and it was attributed to the large band-offsets, small effective mass, and very small height of In-rich InGaN QDs [44]. It is believed that the similar mechanism is responsible for the large blue shift in In-rich InGaN QDs and theoretical analysis is currently under way to fully understand the origins. Growth of InN QDs on GaN by MOCVD was demonstrated by Briot et al. [45]. It was found that the growth temperature and V/III ratio were the key process parameters to obtain high quality InN QDs due to the extreme volatility of InN. QD density could be controlled by growth temperature, V/III ratio, and growth time. The size of typical InN QDs grown at 550°C and a V/III ratio of 30,000 for 45 s were 25-35 nm in diameter and 2.7-5.6 nm in height, producing a fairly flat QD due to high surface diffusion under their growth conditions. 6,2,3 Stacking of Self-assembled Quantum Dots In general, QDs do not cover the whole area of surface. If QDs are used in the active layer, the volume fraction of QDs is much smaller than that of QWs, and the absolute luminescence intensity from the QD active layer is low. Therefore, stacking of QDs is indispensable for the device fabrication by increasing the total active volume responsible for carrier recombination process. Formation of highly uniform QDs is a prerequisite for
114
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
Figure 6.21. HRTEM image of a stacked GaN QDs grown at 720°C. AIN spacer layers were used between GaN QDs. Vertical correlation is clearly seen [30].
successful stacking. Otherwise, QD stacking itself generates defects and it renders QD obsolete for device applications. Widmann et al. reported the stacking of GaN QDs separated by an AIN spacer by MBE [31]. By HRTEM, they could observe the vertical correlation between the GaN dots, depending on the thickness of the AIN spacer layer. Whereas no vertical correlation was found for an AIN spacer thickness of 20 nm, such correlation was present for an AIN spacer thickness of 8 nm, as shown in Figure 6.21. The GaN 2D wetting layer, about 2 ml thick, was clearly seen. It is worth noting that the lateral spacing between adjacent QDs is about 3.5 times larger than the thickness of the AIN spacer, in good agreement with the theoretical estimation by Tersoff et al. [46]. The vertical correlation was attributed to the merging of the strain fields resulting from close-spaced islands, leading to the nucleation of a single island above them when depositing the next layer. The alignment of QDs is also affected by the presence of threading dislocations, as shown in the far left column of QDs in Figure 6.21 [31,47]. It is likely that combined strain field from both the underlying QDs and the threading dislocations would affect the vertical correlation of QDs.
Growth of Nitride Quantum Dots
115
I
500
250
[nm]
Figure 6.22. AFM images of the surface morphology of (a) single-layer, (b) three-layer, and (c) 10-layer stacked InGaN QDs [40].
Stacking of self-assembled InGaN QDs using MOCVD was also reported by Tachibana et al. [48]. The surface morphologies of stacked InGaN QDs at various number of stack layers with 5 nm spacer layer are shown in Figure 6.22. The integrated PL intensity increased with the number of QD stacks, as shown in Figure 6.17, and lasing by optical pumping from this stacked InGaN QDs was reported.
6.3. GROWTH OF QUANTUM DOTS BY ANTI-SURFACTANT At the early stage of the nitride QD research, the fabrication of QD structures was tried using anti-surfactant. Use of anti-surfactant could realize the QD growth regardless of strain in the film which was necessary for the formation of SAQDs by SK growth mode. Tanaka et al. reported the growth of GaN QD for the first time, with the help of Si as an anti-surfactant [49]. They grew the GaN QDs on a Si-face of (0001) 6H-SiC substrate by MOCVD. After depositing an 1.5-nm-thick AIN buffer layer, a 0.6-|xm-thick Al;cGai_;,N
116
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
layer was grown, with the Al content x was varying in the range of 0.07-0.2 by changing the gas flow ratio. TESi was then supplied to the Al_^Gai_;,N surface, followed by a short supply (5 s) of TMGa and NH3 gases for the growth of GaN QDs. Their growth temperature was varied in the range of 1060-1100°C. Typical morphology of their GaN QDs grown on Alo.2Gao.8N surface with Si antisurfactant is shown in Figure 6.23(a) and (b). The hexagon-shaped GaN QDs, with an average width of about 40 nm and a height of about 6 nm was uniformly distributed on the AlGaN surface. The QD density of this sample was around 3 X 10^ cm~^. In Figure 6.23(b), the detailed shape of GaN QDs was clearly observed. In contrast, a step flow growth of GaN on the AlGaN surface was observed without introducing TESi, as can
Figure 6.23. (a) Plan-view and (b) bird's eye view of a typical GaN QD formed on AlGaN surface using TESi as an anti-surfactant, (c) The GaN surface morphology without the use of TESi shows a step flow growth mode [49].
Growth of Nitride Quantum Dots
111
be seen in Figure 6.23(c). No QDs were observed in this case. The lattice mismatch between Alo.2Gao.8N and GaN was too small (—0.18%) to induce the SK growth mode. GaN QDs were only obtained when the AlGaN surface was exposed to the TESi gas flow before the GaN deposition procedure. However, the presence of a wetting layer was not confirmed in Figure 6.23, which is the unique feature of the SK growth mode. The GaN QD growth on the anti-surfactant exposed AlGaN surface is more or less Volmer-Weber growth, or 3D island growth. TESi dose was found to play an important role in QD formation. To find out the precise mechanism of Si anti-surfactant, the GaN samples grown with various TESi doses of 0,3.2, 4.8, 8.1, and 32 nmol were investigated [50]. As the input dose of TESi increased, a morphological transition from 2D to 3D was observed. A clear step and terrace feature (2D) prior to TESi exposure, as seen in Figure 6.24(a), was transformed to a 3D-like structure in Figure 6.24(e). From these features, they proposed a model of "masking by the Si-N bondings" to explain this morphological transition induced by TESi, which is schematically shown in Figure 6.25(a)-(c). Figure 6.25(a)-(c) corresponds to 0 nmol (2D), 2.2-4.8 nmol (quasi2D), and 8.1 nmol (quasi-3D) cases, respectively. With the supply of TESi, Si-N bonds on top of the Ga(Al) dangling bonds of the Al;cGai__^N surface would be formed. The Ga(Al) atoms at the surface could also be replaced with Si atoms. These changes in the surface structure and chemistry by the Si supply should energetically and kinetically affect the
Figure 6.24.
Effects of TESi dose on the GaN surface morphology [50].
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
118 (a) 2D striictyre ^^^
(*>) quasi-2D structure step flow mode
•
^i-N boiid
AlCiaN surface
<e) 1D OD structure
(d) plan-view
•
# ^
GaN growth area Si"N bonding
A-.
^ ^ ^ J ^ ^Si-N masking lerrilory
(c) surface potential energy t^etween Si N bonds
^^iiif
A(GaN(0001) surface Figure 6.25. Schematic diagram of the model explaining the structural transitions observed by AFM. (a), (b), and (c) correspond to 0, 2.2 to 4.8, and 8.1 nmol cases, respectively, (d) A plan-view diagram of (c) to illustrate the GaN nucleation sites affected by Si-N bonding, (e) A possible surface potential energy diagram across the region along the line A - B in (d) [50].
GaN nucleation process, resulting in morphological transition. Such an area caused by the nano-scale modification of the surface may act as a nano-scale mask where GaN deposition is suppressed. It may also create a kinetic energy barrier for adatom diffusion. Tanaka et al. thought that GaN deposition would be suppressed at this place (see the masking territory in Figure 6.25(d) and (e)). Figure 6.25(e) illustrates a possible surface potential energy diagram in their model across the region along the line denoted "n" in Figure 6.25(d). The potential gradient (chemical potential) induced by Si-N bonds would lead the migration of adatom to the potential-minima regions, and the deposition of
Growth of Nitride Quantum Dots
119
1 1 1 1 1 I I • • I'P I I I I I I I I 1 I
T = 80K , !\
40/l20nm 7/21 nm 3.5/10nm
t
3.40 3,45 3.50 3.55 3.60 3.65 Photon energy (eV) Figure 6.26.
PL spectra of GaN QDs with three different sizes [51].
GaN would occur preferentially at those places. The large amount of holes observed in Figure 6.24(b) and (c) would correspond to the area of nano-scale masking. Therefore, as the masking area increased, the surface structure with both 2D and 3D characteristics would appear, and eventually the whole surface would be composed of 3D structures [50]. They also investigated optical properties of these GaN QDs. Figure 6.26 shows the 80 K PL spectra of the GaN QD samples of different sizes [51]. The different QD sizes are obtained by changing the deposition time of GaN while keeping the substrate temperature constant. The PL emission energy was observed to shift to higher energy with decreasing QD size. This effect was supposed to be a combination of a blue shift from the confinement-induced shift of the electronic levels and a red-shift from the piezoelectric field-induced quantum-confined Stark effect. An LD structure with these GaN QDs was prepared and optical pumping experiment was made [52]. GaN QDs, with an average size of about 10 nm width, 1 - 2 nm height, and a density of about 10^^ cm~^ were used in this experiment. Their LD structure is schematically shown in Figure 6.27. Stimulated emission was clearly observed at 21 K from the GaN QD LD structure under high excitation pump power density, as shown in Figure 6.28. At the pump power density of 0.78 MW/cm^, a sharp peak centered at 3.49 eV appeared. The FWHM was about 10 meV. The emission peak showed a red-shift of about 50 meV from the spontaneous emission peak observed at 77 K. Recently, the GaN QDs formed by this technique was used for the active layer of UV LED [53]. The room temperature UV emission at 360 nm was reported by current injection. This is the first report on the device application by current injection. The growth of InGaN QDs using TESi anti-surfactant was also reported by Hirayama et al. [54] In order to achieve a surface suitable for the growth of InGaN QDs, a "twolayered buffer" was used: 100 nm-thick Alo.12Gao.88N layer (topmost) and 300-nm-thick Alo.24Gao.76N layer deposited at HOOT on a 6H-SiC substrate. Prior to the InGaN
120
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides N| Met
>^k23^%77^ ciliickling Jpyer ^bjO«G%9^N barrieriiiyef OaN quantum doii ^^.i2*^'*o.8s'^ byrri^r layer A^O^QSO.IWN cladding lnycr
Figure 6.27.
\ [ 3TOO) c^BWimd plane
The schematic diagram of a GaN QD laser structure with AlGaN barrier layers [52].
growth, a small amount of Si anti-surfactant modifying the surface properties was deposited at 1120°C, which is similar to that of the TESi pretreatment for GaN QD growth. Then, InGaN growth was performed at around 800°C. This resulted in a 3D nano-scale island growth. They found that the QD density was controllable in the range of cm by increasing the TESi dose. Similar trend was also reported in the growth of GaN QDs. A typical morphology of the InGaN QDs with an approximate density of 10^ ^ cm~^ obtained by this technique is shown in Figure 6.29. The average size and thickness of QDs are about 10 and 5 nm, respectively. Room temperature PL emissions from InGaN QDs grown with Si anti-surfactant were observed as shown in Figure 6.30 [54]. In this experiment, all InGaN QDs were
1
1
1
1
1
I
1
1
1
1
1 1 1 1 1
h 21K
1 1
1
1
1 J
MWA:m'
!\'' I •
f
•
[
• : 1
B
A
»
1
[
O.TgMWAim^
h r
3.35
Figure 6.28.
1
•
; r J,05MWifcm^
,..
' 1
1
A.^.—
.^4
1
1
1
1
n—"jr •
•
•
•
3.45 3,5 Energy (eV>
0.68MWA m^ '
1
?^^^^^
155
3.6
Emission spectra from GaN QDs with a cavity length of 1 mm under optical power densities of 0.68, 0.78, 1.05, 1.4MW/cm2 [52].
Growth of Nitride Quantum Dots
121
4. ^
if
I
1
-''•' lOOnni
Figure 6.29.
A typical A I ^ image of InGaN QDs grown on the AlGaN surface by using anti-surfactant [54].
grown with the same TESi dose. The PL peak energy position was controlled by changing the growth temperature, resulting in changes of In mole fraction of InGaN QDs. For comparison, InGaN QW structure with an estimated thickness of 5 nm was grown without TESi exposure on the AlGaN surface. It was found that the PL emission of the InGaN QD samples was several times stronger than that of the QW structure. This result strongly suggests that the increased luminescence efficiency is caused by the additional carrier confinement. From the calculation with PL peak positions in Figure 6.30, the In contents of InGaN QDs grown at 770, 800, 830, and 850°C were estimated as 52, 38, 25, and 22%, respectively. However, this calculation seemed to be based on the old value of InN bandgap energy of 1.9 eV; accordingly. In composition would be modified.
2.5
M Energy (eV)
Figure 6.30.
Room temperature PL spectra of InGaN QDs grown on AlGaN at various temperatures [54].
122
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
6.4. GROWTH OF QUANTUM DOTS BY SELECTIVE EPITAXY The aim of this method is to control the position, size and density of the QDs by high-resolution patterning techniques. With the help of the recent improvement of lithography techniques, it is expected that the position control and the uniformity of the QDs would be greatly enhanced by this technique; however, QD density obtainable by this technique is far lower than by either SK growth method or anti-surfactant growth method. Tachibana et al. reported the growth of InGaN QD structures by selective MOCVD on a Si02/GaN/sapphire substrate patterned by conventional photolithography [55]. At first, they grew a 2-|jLm-thick GaN layer on a (0001) sapphire substrate. Then, 40 nm of Si02 was deposited on the GaN layer by sputtering and the Si02 layer was patterned by conventional photolithography and a buffered HF solution. The pattern was grid-like, with 4 |xm period and square openings of 2 jxm side length. Selective growth of GaN was then performed and uniform hexagonal GaN pyramids were realized, as shown in Figure 6.31(b) and (c). Then, the growth of three periods of InGaN/GaN MQWs was
(a) IHQ ogG^o 98^^ barriers and capping layer
-,,. InGaN QD
InGaisi QW
(b)
^ A A
^
wP
^^
WW
Ww
A A A A A A A A 2um
(c)
100 nm
Figure 6.31. (a) A schematic of InGaN QDs formed at the apex of hexagonal GaN pyramids, (b) bird's-eyeview SEM micrograph, (c) cross section SEM micrograph [55].
Growth of Nitride Quantum Dots
123
followed on the hexagonal GaN pyramids. The schematic diagram of this structure is illustrated in Figure 6.31(a). The lateral size of InGaN QDs formed at the apex of GaN pyramids was no more than 30 nm, estimated from the curvature of the apex of pyramid in Figure 6.31(c). PL spectra were measured at room temperature. With the emission peak at 3.4 eV from the GaN bulk layer, a very broad peak (the FWHM is 290 meV) was also observed at 2.88 eV (430 nm), as shown in Figure 6.32. To identify the regions giving the PL emission at 430 nm, micro-PL intensity images were recorded at room temperature. Figure 6.33(a) shows an image consisting mainly of reflected light. Hexagonal shapes can be seen very clearly. Figure 6.33(b) shows a micro-PL intensity image of PL of wavelength around 430 nm. The same area was observed in Figure 6.33(b) as in Figure 6.33(a). It is evident that the detected light was from the InGaN QD structure on the apex of pyramids, not from the GaN bulk. They also reported the successful growth of GaN/AlGaN QD structures on a Si02/GaN/sapphire substrate patterned using the similar technique with that of InGaN QDs [48,56]. QD density of these dots was less than 10^ cm~^ due to the resolution limitation imposed by photolithography. Wang et al. demonstrated the formation of higher density InGaN QDs by selective growth on Si-patterned GaN epilayer/GaN buffer layer/(0001) sapphire substrate with the improved patterning technique [57,58]. The Si mask was patterned by a partial removal of Si mask by 30keV Ga^ focused ion-beam (FIB) irradiation and subsequent photoassisted wet (PAW) etching of remaining Si mask with a solution of 3KOH:H202. If the window is patterned only by FIB, the damage of the GaN underlayer is inevitable.
He-Cd Laser 5 W/cm3 RT
3.0
GaN Bulk-
3.2
Energy (eV) Figure 6.32. PL spectrum of the selectively grown InGaN QDs at room temperature [55].
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
124
Figure 6.33.
(a) Optical microscope image of selectively grown InGaN QDs, (b) micro-PL image at a wavelength of 430 nm [55].
mainly due to the highly energetic Ga"^ atoms penetrating the residual Si layer during FIB process. The growth of GaN pyramids and InGaN/GaN MQWs was followed. The schematic diagram of this procedure is shown in Figure 6.34. The typical top-view scanning electron microscope (SEM) image of an InGaN QD sample is shown in Figure 6.35(a). There are 25 QD structures in each luim square area (2.5 X 10^ cm~^) and they looked uniformly arranged. An AFM image of the InGaN QD array in Figure 6.35(b), however, showed that the dimensions of each QD were not completely uniform due to the fluctuations in the window size by this patterning technique.
p
FIB milling
Siiiiask(50iiiii)
siliiiiiii
of patterns PAW Etching with OKOH-l-HiOj)
MOCVD Selective growth of InGaN QDs
GftM Figure 6.34.
p
Schematic diagram of FIB/PAW process used for the fabrication of InGaN/GaN QDs [58].
125
Growth of Nitride Quantum Dots
Figure 6.35.
(a) A typical top-view SEM image of selectively grown InGaN QDs. Diameter of the FIB windows was 80 nm; (b) 3D AFM image of the same QDs [58].
The CL spectrum measured at 80 K from the InGaN QD sample is shown in Figure 6.36. In this measurement, the electron beam was focused on an area covering 25 QDs. A clear blue shift of about 240 meV could be observed when compared with the emission from a reference InGaN QW sample. This value corresponds to an InGaN QD with a diameter of ~ 3 nm. The FWHM of the emission peak from QD was 48 meV, whereas that of the emission peak from QW was 84 meV. This result shows that the size fluctuation of QDs was suppressed to a certain extent by their technique.
6.5. NOVEL TECHNIQUES FOR QUANTUM DOT GROWTH Oliver et al. reported the InGaN QD growth on a GaN/sapphire substrate by MOCVD [20]. They had grown two InGaN epilayers under identical conditions, and then annealed
InOsN/GaN ODs T=SOK FWHM =48 nitV
3.29
3.31
3.33
3.37
Energy («V) Figure 6.36.
Cathodoluminescence spectrum measured at 80 K from selectively grown InGaN QDs. The inset shows a PL spectrum obtained for a reference InGaN MQW sample [57].
126
Figure 6.37.
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
AFM images (1.8 fxin X 1.8 |xm) of InGaN epilayers on GaN after (a) annealing under NH3 for 30 s, (b) annealing under N2 for 30 s [20].
the two samples at 700°C for 30 s after the growth under different conditions: under NH3 flow or under N2 flow. The anneal under N2 flow changed the surface morphology significantly as shown in Figure 6.37(b). Small nanostructures with a density of 5 X 10^^ cm~^, and an average height of 0.93 nm could be found along with many small pits in the wetting layer. They observed very sharp emission peaks with typical linewidth of —700 ixeV at 4.2 K by micro-PL experiments. Their time-resolved PL studies on the sample revealed that excitons have lifetimes around 2 ns at 4.2 K. They suggested that pits in Figure 6.37(b) were created by the decomposition of In-rich regions in InGaN epilayer (formed by spinodal decomposition), which appeared to be unstable in a nitrogen atmosphere. The nanostructures observed in Figure 6.37(b) might be very small In droplets, also formed due to decomposition, since they found that these structures could be removed by the HC1:3H20 etchant. These In droplets would then react with ammonia, before or during the growth of the capping layer, and this would result in the formation of InGaN QDs, possibly by some interdiffusion with the GaN capping layer [20]. Similar methods using the nitridation of metallic droplets were also reported by other research groups. Kawasaki et al. demonstrated the GaN QDs formed on an AlGaN/SiC substrate by MBE using Ga droplets [21]. At first, they deposited the Ga droplets on the substrate surface by supplying Ga at 300°C. Then, the sample was annealed under NH3 gas flow for 10 min in order to nitridate the Ga droplets. Figure 6.38(a) shows the SEM image of QDs obtained by this technique at a nitridation temperature of 600°C. The histogram of the QD diameter in Figure 6.38(b) shows that the GaN QDs formed were between 4 and 15 nm in diameter with an average diameter of approximately 9 nm. The QD density was greater than 3 X 10^^ cm~^. Hu et al. also reported the growth of QDs by MOCVD using the formation of Ga liquid droplet and nitridation process [22]. The fabrication of InGaN QDs by surface pretreatment using TMIn was reported by Zhang et al. [23]. TMIn pre-treatment with only TMIn and NH3 input flow was made just before the growth of InGaN well layer. The typical microstructure of InGaN QDs formed
Growth of Nitride Quantum Dots
:••'
12
14
111
16
Figure 6.38. (a) SEM image of GaN QDs formed by Ga droplet formation and subsequent nitridation at 600°C. (b) Histogram of the GaN QDs with mean diameter of 9 nm, and standard deviation of 2 nm [21].
(a)
6.00 nm
*^^Pi^tf'•' ''':^^^0l • Sf^'i?
Figure 6.39. Cross section HRTEM images of InGaN SQW (a) with and (b) without TMIn pretreatment. Arrows point to the low-barrier/well interfaces [23].
128
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides (b)
-I
1
1
1
r-
-»
1
f
1
1-
^6oo InGaN dots (Sample D)
UOO ^
200
2.0 600 Figure 6.40.
2.2
2.4
2.6 2.8 3.0 Energy (eV)
3.2
3.4
(a) The AFM surface morphology of InGaN QDs from by TMIn pretreatment, (b) comparison of PL spectra of InGaN QDs and homogeneous InGaN film [24].
in QW with TMIn pre-treatment was shown in Figure 6.39(a). Obvious contrasts, originating from In-rich regions in the low-In composition matrix, can be clearly seen along the lower-barrier/well interface. The average dimension of the contrast was as small as ~ 4 nm in width and 1.5 nm in height. The microstructure of the SQW without the TMIn treatment is shown in Figure 6.39(b) for comparison. Both the lower- and upperbarrier/well interfaces are quite sharp without obvious contrast, indicating that the growth mode was 2D throughout the growth of SQW structure without TMIn pre-treatment. The surface passivation method was also attempted to form InGaN QDs on GaN by Chen et al. [24,25]. High-temperature grown GaN surface was passivated by air exposure for 24 h and it was reloaded for the growth of a low temperature GaN layer at 550°C. It was found that the surface of the low temperature GaN layer had nano-scale roughness. They suggested that the surface passivation would increase the energy barrier for the hopping of the atoms, resulting in a decrease in the surface diffusion length. Subsequently, the growth of InGaN QDs was followed at 800°C. Figure 6.40(a) shows the image of InGaN QD structure grown on the passivated GaN surface. The average size of InGaN QDs was measured as 80 nm in diameter and 5 nm in height. The density of QDs was estimated as 5X 10'^ cm . PL spectrum of InGaN QDs was shown in Figure 6.40(b), compared with that of homogeneous InGaN thin films grown without surface passivation. 6.6. CONCLUSIONS So far, we have reviewed the various methods to form nitride QDs. They were classified into four methods: (1) using SK growth mode, (2) using "anti-surfactant", (3) using selective
Growth of Nitride Quantum Dots
129
epitaxy, and (4) other novel techniques. Growth of GaN/AlGaN, InN/GaN, InGaN/GaN QDs by MBE or MOCVD reported in the Hterature was reviewed. The first paper on the growth of nitride QDs appeared in 1996 and the number of publications and researchers are relatively small compared to III-V QDs. Nitride QD research is still in the developmental stage, however, considering the strong potential of nitride QDs in device applications, especially in LDs, UV-LEDs, etc., the interest from both academia and industry in nitride QDs increases very rapidly and the future of nitride QDs seems very promising.
REFERENCES [1] Bimberg, D., Grundmann, M. & Ledentsov, N.N. (1999) Quantum dot heterostructures, Wiley, New York. [2] Tatebayashi, J., Hatori, N., Kakuma, H., Ebe, H., Sudo, H., Kuramata, A., Nakata, Y., Sugawara, M. & Arakawa, Y. (2003) Electron. Lett., 39, 1130. [3] Phillips, J., Kamath, K., Zhou, X., Chervela, N. & Bhattacharya, P. (1997) Appl. Phys. Lett., 71, 2079. [4] Arakawa, Y. & Sasaki, H. (1982) Appl. Phys. Lett., 40, 939. [5] Xie, Q., Kobayashi, N.P., Ramachandran, T.R., Kalburge, A., Chen, P. & Madhukar, A. (1996) J. Vac. Sci. Technol, B, 14, 2203. [6] Lubyshev, D.I., Gonzalez-Borrer, P.P., Mareg, E., Jr., Petitprez, E., La Scala, N., Jr. & Basmaji, P. (1996) Appl. Phys. Lett., 68, 205. [7] Heinrichsdorff, F., Krost, A., Grundmann, M., Bimberg, D., Bertram, P., Christen, J., Kosogov, A. & Werner, P. (1997) /. Cryst. Growth, 170, 568. [8] Allen, C.Ni., Poole, P.J., Marshall, P., Eraser, J., Raymond, S. & Fafard, S. (2002) Appl. Phys. Lett., 80, 3629. [9] Finkman, E., Maimon, S., Immer, V., Bahir, G., Schacham, S.E., Gauthier-Lafaye, O., Herriot, S., Julien, F.H., Gendry, M. & Brault, J. (2000) Physica E, 1, 139. [10] Borgstrom, M., Bryllert, T., Sass, T., Bustafon, B., Wemersson, L.-E., Seifert, W. & Samuelson, L. (2001) Appl. Phys. Lett., 78, 3232. [11] Arakawa, Y. (2001) Phys. Stat. Sol. (a), 188, 37. [12] Chichibu, S., Azuhata, T., Sota, T. & Nakamura, S. (1996) Appl. Phys. Lett., 69, 4188. [13] Yoon, S., Moon, Y., Lee, T.-W., Yoon, E. & Kim, Y.D. (1999) Appl. Phys. Lett., 74, 2029. [14] Sopanen, M., Lipsanen, H. & Ahopelto, J. (1995) Appl. Phys. Lett., 65, 1662. [15] Marchand, H., Desjardins, P., Guillon, S., Paultre, J.-E., Bougrioua, Z., Yip, Y.-F. & Masut, R.A. (1997) Appl. Phys. Lett., 71, 527. [16] Chidley, E.T.R., Haywood, S.K., Mallard, R.E., Mason, N.J., Nicholas, R.J., Walker, P.J. & Warburton, R.J. (1989) Appl. Phys. Lett., 54, 1241. [17] Ferrer, J.C, Peiro, F., Comet, A., Morante, J.R., Uztmeier, T., Armelles, G. & Briones, F. (1996) Appl. Phys. Lett., 69, 3887. [18] Eaglesham, D.J. & Cerullo, M. (1990) Phys. Rev. Lett., 64, 1943. [19] Lowisch, M., Rabe, M., Stegemann, B., Henneberger, F., Grundmann, M., Turck, V. & Bimberg, D. (1996) Phys. Rev. B, 54, R11074. [20] Oliver, R.A., Briggs, G.A.D., Kappers, M.J., Humphreys, C.J., Yasin, S., Rice, J.H., Smith, J.D. & Taylor, R.A. (2003) Appl. Phys. Lett., 83, 755.
130
Optoelectronic
Devices:
Ill-Nitrides
[21] Kawasaki, K., Yamazaki, D., Kinoshita, A., Hirayama, H., Tsutsui, K. & Aoyagi, Y. (2001) AppL Phys. Lett., 79, 2243. [22] Hu, C.-W., Bell, A., Fonce, F.A., Smith, D.A. & Tsong, I.S.T. (2002) Appl. Phys. Lett., 81, 3236. [23] Zhang, J., Hao, M., Li, P. & Chua, S.J. (2002) Appl. Phys. Lett., 80, 485. [24] Chen, Z., Lu, D., Yuan, H., Han, P., Liu, X., Li, Y., Wang, X., Lu, Y. & Wang, Z. (2002) J. Cryst. Growth, 235, 188. [25] Huang, J.S., Chen, Z., Luo, X.D., Xu, Z.Y. & Ge, W.K. (2004) /. Cryst. Growth, 260, 13. [26] Goodwin, T.J., Leppert, V.J. & Risbud, S.H. (1997) Appl. Phys. Lett., 70, 3122. [27] Borsella, E., Garcia, M.A., Mattei, G., Maurizio, C. & Mazzoldi, P. (2001) J. Appl. Phys., 90, 4467. [28] Mii, O.I., Ahrenkiel, S.P., Bertram, D. & Nozik, A.J. (1999) Appl. Phys. Lett., 75, 478. [29] Daudin, B., Widmann, F., Feuillet, G., Samson, Y., Arlery, M. & Rouviere, J.L. (1997) Phys. Rev. B, 56, R7069. [30] Widmann, F., Daudin, B., Feuillet, G., Samson, Y., Rouviere, J.L. & Pelekanos, N. (1998) J. Appl. Phys., 83, 7618. [31] Widmann, F., Simon, J., Daudin, B., Feulliet, G., Rouviere, J.L., Pelekanos, N.T. & Fishman, G. (1998) Phys. Rev. B, 58, R15989. [32] Damilano, B., Grandjean, N., Semond, F., Massies, J. & Leroux, M. (1999) Appl. Phys. Lett., 75, 962. [33] Grandjean, N. & Massies, J. (1998) Appl Phys. Lett., 72, 1078. [34] Damilano, B., Grandjean, N., Dalmasso, S. & Massies, J. (1999) Appl. Phys. Lett., IS, 3751. [35] Adelmann, C , Simon, J., Feuillet, G., Pelekanos, N.T., Daudin, B. & Fishman, G. (2000) A/?/?/. Phys. Lett., 76, 1570. [36] Damilano, B., Vezian, S., Grandjean, N. & Massies, J. (1999) Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 38, L1357. [37] Gogneau, N., Jalabert, D., Monroy, E., Shibata, T., Tanaka, M. & Daudin, B. (2003) /. Appl. Phys., 94, 2254. [38] Miyamura, M., Tachibana, K. & Arakawa, Y. (2002) Appl. Phys. Lett., 80, 3937. [39] Tachibana, K., Someya, T. & Arakawa, Y. (1999) Appl Phys. Lett., 74, 383. [40] Tachibana, K., Someya, T. & Arakawa, Y. (1999) Phys. Stat. Sol (a), 176, 629. [41] Tachibana, K., Someya, T., Arakawa, Y., Werner, R. & Forchel, A. (1999) Appl Phys. Lett., 75, 2605. [42] Kim, H.J., Na, H., Kwon, S.-Y., Kim, Y.-W. & Yoon, E. (2003) The Fifth International Conference on Nitride Semiconductors (ICNS-5), May 25-30, Nara, Japan. [43] Kim, H.J., Na, H., Kwon, S.-Y., Seo, H.-C, Kim, H.J., Shin, Y., Lee, K.-H., Kim, D.H., Oh, H.J., Yoon, S., Sone, C , Park, Y. & Yoon, E. (2004) J. Cryst. Growth, 269, 95. [44] Kim, H.J., Na, H., Kwon, S.-Y., Seo, H.-C, Kim, H.J., Shin, Y., Lee, G.-H., Kim, Y.-W., Yoon, S., Oh, H.J., Sone, C , Park, Y., Cho, Y.-H., Sun, Y. & Yoon, E. (2003) Phys. Stat. Sol (c), 0, 2834. [45] Briot, O., Maleyre, B. & Ruffenach, S. (2003) Appl Phys. Lett., 83, 2919. [46] Tersoff, J., Teichert, C. & Lagally, M.G. (1996) Phys. Rev. Lett., 76, 1675. [47] Louviere, J.L., Simon, J., Pelekanos, N., Daudin, B. & Feuillet, G. (1999) Appl Phys. Lett., 15, 2632. [48] Tachibana, K., Someya, T., Ishida, S. & Arakawa, Y. (2001) Phys. Stat. Sol (b), 228, 187. [49] Tanaka, S., Iwai, S. & Aoyagi, Y. (1996) Appl Phys. Lett., 69, 4096. [50] Tanaka, S., Suemune, L, Ramvall, P. & Aoyagi, Y. (1999) Phys. Stat. Sol (b), 216, 431. [51] Ramvall, P., Tanaka, S., Nomura, S., Riblet, P. & Aoyagi, Y. (1999) Appl Phys. Lett., 73,1104.
Growth of Nitride Quantum Dots
131
[52] Tanaka, S., Hirayama, H., Aoyagi, Y., Narukawa, Y., Kawakami, Y., Fujita, S. & Fujita, S. (1997) AppL Phys. Lett., 71, 1299. [53] Tanaka, S., Lee, J.S., Ramvall, P. & Okagawa, H. (2003) Jpn. J. Appl Phys., 42, L885. [54] Hirayama, H., Tanaka, S., Ramvall, P. & Aoyagi, Y. (1998) Appl. Phys. Lett., 72, 1736. [55] Tachibana, K., Someya, T., Ishida, S. & Arakawa, Y. (2000) Appl. Phys. Lett., 76, 3212. [56] Tachibana, K., Someya, T., Ishida, S. & Arakawa, Y. (2002) /. Cryst. Growth, 237-239, 1312-1315. [57] Wang, J., Nozaki, M., Lachab, M., Ishikawa, Y., Fareed, Q., Wang, T., Hao, M. & Sakai, S. (1999) Appl. Phys. Lett., 75, 950. [58] Lachab, M., Nozaki, M., Wang, J., Ishikawa, Y., Fareed, Q., Wang, T., Nishikawa, T., Nishino, K. & Sakai, S. (2000) /. Appl. Phys., 87, 1374.
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides M. Razeghi and M. Henini (Eds.) © 2004 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Chapter 7
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics H.X. Jiang and J.Y. Lin Department of Physics, Kansas State University, Manhattan, KS 66506-2601, USA
7.1.
INTRODUCTION
Ill-nitride wide bandgap semiconductors have been widely recognized as technologically important materials. Photonic devices based on Ill-nitrides offer many benefits including UV/blue/green emission (allowing chem-bio-agents detection and higher optical storage density), large band offsets of InN/GaN/AlN heterostructures (allowing novel quantum well device design), and inherently high emission efficiencies. These unique features may allow the creation of optoelectronic and photonic devices with unprecedented properties and functions. The research activities on Al;,Gai_;,N (3.4 < E^ < 6.2 eV) with high AIN mole fractions and devices operating in the ultraviolet (UV) spectral regions are still in their embryonic state. Achieving device quality Al-rich AlGaN with high conductivities and high quantum efficiencies remains as one of the foremost challenges for the nitride community. AIN and Al-rich AlGaN alloys, covering wavelengths from 300 to 200 nm, are ideal materials for the development of chip-scale UV light sources/sensors, because AlGaN is the only ultra-wide-bandgap semiconductor system in which the bandgap can be easily engineered through the use of alloying and heterostructure design. Efficient solid-state UV light sources/sensors are crucial in many fields of research and development. For instance, protein fluorescence is generally excited by UV light; monitoring changes of intrinsic fluorescence in a protein can provide important information on its structural changes [1]. Thus, the availability of chip-scale UV light sources is expected to open up new opportunities for medical research and health care. Solid-state UV light sources also have applications in water purification, equipment/personnel decontamination, and white light generation [2]. There is an urgent need to develop new approaches to further improve material quality with reduced dislocation density and unintentional impurities and improved surface morphologies in Al-rich AlGaN alloys, which would enhance the doping efficiency and device performance. AIN is an end point of the AlGaN alloy system. A full understanding of the AlGaN alloy system (particularly Al-rich AlGaN alloys) could not be achieved before the binary AIN
E-mail address:
[email protected] (H.X. Jiang).
133
134
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
material is well understood. Moreover, AIN is unique due to the fact that no other semiconductors possess such a large direct bandgap as well as the ability of bandgap engineering through the use of heterostructures. In spite of the recognition of the importance of AIN, many of its fundamental optical emission properties are not well known in the past due to the lack of high-quality materials as well as technical difficulties involved for the deep UV (down to 200 nm) optical measurements. Rapid progress has been made recently in the epitaxial growth and understanding of the basic physical properties, as well as the device applications of AIN epilayers. This chapter aims at providing a brief summary on these recent advances with emphasis on the fundamental optical properties, basic impurity parameters, and conductivity control of AIN and AlGaN epitaxial films with high Al contents. In Section 7.2, we discuss epitaxial growth and characterization techniques to identify high quality films; such as atomic force microscopy (AFM) for studying the surface morphology and SIMS for probing unintentional impurities such as oxygen. In Section 7.3, we present recent advances in understanding the fundamental optical properties of AIN. The detailed band structure near the F-point of wurtzite (WZ) AIN is presented. The unique band structure of AIN, i.e. the negative crystal-field splitting, affects profoundly the optical properties of AlGaN alloys, in particular of Al-rich AlGaN alloys. One of the immediate consequences is that the dominant band-edge emission in GaN (AIN) is with polarization of E L c {E\\c). Accordingly, the emission intensity in Al-rich Al^cGai-^^N alloys decrease with increasing x for epilayers grown on the c-plane sapphire. The recombination dynamics of the bound exciton (I2) and free exciton (FX) transitions in AIN epilayers were probed by deep UV time-resolved photoluminescence (PL). The PL decay lifetimes were found to be around 80 ps for the bound exciton and 50 ps for the free exciton at 10 K in AIN epilayers, which are slightly shorter than those in GaN. This is a direct consequence of the large energy bandgap of AIN. The extrapolated radiative decay lifetimes in AIN epilayers increases with temperature according to T^'^ between 100 and 200 K and are affected by the free-exciton dissociation at temperatures above 200 K, following the same trend as in GaN. From the low-temperature (10 K) emission spectra, the temperature dependence of the recombination lifetime, and the PL emission intensity activation energy, the binding energies of the donor bound excitons and free excitons in AIN were deduced to be around 16 and 80 meV, respectively. The observed large freeexciton binding energy implies that excitons in AIN are extremely robust entities that would survive well above the room temperature. Impurity transitions involving nitrogen vacancies generated during ion implantation and Al vacancies and/or complexes in as-grown layers have been studied. The results indicate that VAI and/or V A I - O N complexes are deep acceptors with an energy level of 2.59 eV above the valence band of AIN, which is directly correlated with the reduced conductivities in Al-rich AlGaN and AIN and is thus detrimental to optoelectronic devices using AIN and AlGaN epilayers. The experimentally determined nitrogen vacancy energy level is around
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics
135
260 meV. As a consequence of the large activation energy (0.26 eV) as well as high formation energy, VN in AIN cannot contribute significantly to the n-type conductivity. With recent advances in epitaxial growth, conductive n-type Al-rich Al^^Gai-^cN alloys with high Al contents (x > 0.7) have been obtained. Section 7.4 summarizes recent advances in the conductivity control of AlGaN alloys of high Al contents and AIN and understanding of impurity parameters in these materials. A room temperature n-type resistivity as low as 0.0075 H cm with an electron concentration of 3.3 X 10^^ cm~^ and mobility of 25 crn^fV s has been obtained for Alo.7Gao.3N. The resistivity was observed to increase by almost one order of magnitude as the Al content was increased by about 8%, due to the deepening of the Si donor level with increasing x. Transport measurements have indicated that n-type conduction in pure AIN can be achieved. It was found that heavy doping is needed to bring down the donor activation energy and achieve higher conductivities in Al-rich AlGaN alloys. Mg acceptor ionization energy in Al^^Grai-jcN alloys as a function of x has also been measured, from which a binding energy of 0.51 eV for Mg acceptor in AIN was determined. Although Mg acceptors are an effective mass state in this ultra-large-bandgap semiconductor, as a consequence of this large acceptor binding energy of 0.51 eV, only a very small fraction (about 10~^) of Mg dopants can be activated at room temperature in Mg-doped AIN, implying that it is extremely difficult to achieve p-type AIN by Mg doping. Section 7.5 discusses applications of AIN epitaxial layers. These include the insertion of AIN epilayers in UV and deep UV emitters, serving as active layers or dislocation filters. Since a high quality AIN epilayer is UV transparent all the way down to 200 nm and can be grown with superior surface morphology over an AlGaN alloy, it is an ideal template for the subsequent UV photonic device structure growth. Applications of AIN epilayers for other types of active device applications such as for surface acoustic wave (SAW) and electron emission devices are also discussed. In Section 7.6, we present concluding remarks with focuses on future prospects and remaining challenges.
7.2. EPITAXIAL GROWTH AND CHARACTERIZATION
AIN epilayers have been grown by MOCVD, MBE, RF reactive sputtering, and pulsed laser ablation on different substrates (sapphire, SiC, Si, diamond, and AIN bulk crystals) [3-42]. In general, it is much more difficult to obtain high-quality AIN epilayers than GaN epilayers. This is because the growth of high-quality AIN requires much higher temperature and lower V/III ratio. Moreover, achieving conductive Al;cGai_;,N alloys with high Al contents is very challenging due to several well-known mechanisms: (i) an increase in the ionization energy of the dopants and (ii) an enhanced compensation of native defects (cation vacancy and cation vacancy-oxygen complex) with an increase in
136
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
the alloy composition [43,44]. For MOCVD growth of AIN and Al-rich AlGaN alloys, the metal organic sources used are typically trimethylgallium (TMGa) for Ga and trimethylaluminum (TMAl) for Al. Mg and Si are the common choice as acceptor and donor impurities, respectively. For Mg-doping of AlGaN and AIN, bis-cyclopentadienylmagnesium (Cp2Mg) can be transported into the growth chamber with ammonia during growth. The gas sources are blue ammonia (NH3) for nitrogen and Saline (SiH4) for Si doping and the doping levels can be controlled by the flow rates. There are several methods to confirm the targeted Al contents in Al;fGai_;^-N alloys, including energy dispersive X-ray (EDX) microanalysis. X-ray diffraction (XRD) measurement, secondary ion mass spectroscopy (SIMS) measurement, and optical measurements such as the PL spectral peak position of the band-edge transition. For high Al content Al^cGrai-^cN alloys, the targeted Si- and Mg-dopant concentrations can be verified by SIMS measurements (by Charles Evans & Associates). Determining the quality of the Ill-nitride materials is key to improving the manufacturing process. Unlike many other Ill-nitride compounds, however, measuring the optical and electrical properties of AIN has been a challenge because the material is a good insulator, which renders some standard characterization methods, such as Hall measurement, useless. On the other hand, XRD measurements can provide information about crystalline quality; it provides, however, very little information about electrical and optical qualities of AIN epilayers. As shown in Figure 7.1, the full width at half maximum (FWHM) of the XRD rocking curve of the (0002) reflection peak of AIN epilayers grown on sapphire by the authors' group can be as narrow as 50 arcsec, which is smaller than that 80000 -
KSU-A897 70000 - AIN/sapphire
(002) Rocking Curve
60000 50000 B
40000 -
c
5
FWHM = 50"
30000 20000 -
1 1 J v_
100000-1000018.0
1
1
18.2
1
1
1
18.4
1
18.6
1
1
18.8
1
19.0
e (deg) Figure 7.1. XRD rocking curve of the (0002) reflection peak of AIN epilayers grown on sapphire by the authors' group at Kansas State University and the XRD measurement was performed by Air Force Research Laboratory, Sensors Directorate, Hanscom AFB (M.L. Nakarmi, Ph.D. Thesis, in preparation).
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics
137
of the same reflection peak in GaN epilayers grown on sapphire and is also comparable or even smaller than the best value reported for AIN grown on 6H-SiC (68 arcsec) [12]. However, the value is two times larger than that reported for thin AIN single crystalline platelets (25 arcsec) [36] and five times larger than that of AIN bulk crystals [27]. It is established now that the out-of-plane structural features in Ill-nitrides, e.g. the symmetric (0002) XRD peak in AIN, cannot be used to correlate the material quality and the optical and electrical properties [13,14]. This was attributed to the fact that in Ill-nitrides the edge dislocations only distort the asymmetric planes and induce no significant distortion on the symmetric planes. Thus, there is only a strong correspondence between the in-plane structural order and the electrical and optical properties of Ill-nitrides. For optoelectronic device applications based on AIN and high Al content AlGaN alloys, it is essential to characterize their optical and optoelectronic properties directly. It has been clearly demonstrated in the past that the optical characterization techniques, especially time-resolved optical studies, which provide the temporal characteristics of carrier recombination, together with spectra information are indeed a powerful method for determining the optical processes or transition mechanisms involved because different optical transitions have different dynamical behaviors. The dynamics of injected carriers involved in optical processes is determined by the sample crystalline quality, purity, alloy composition, and quantum well interface properties in different materials and device structures. More importantly, the dynamics of various optical transitions can provide important information regarding excitation and energy transformation processes and recombination lifetimes of injected carriers, which are strongly correlated with quantities such as the quantum efficiency and optical gain. Recently, a deep UV laser spectroscopy system has been developed in author's laboratory (Figure 7.2) which allows one to make picosecond time-resolved PL measurements of AIN and thus, to effectively characterize, and thereby improve the material's quality. The deep UV picosecond time-resolved laser spectroscopy system consists of a frequency quadrupled 100 fs Ti:sapphire laser with an excitation photon energy set around 6.28 eV (with a 76 MHz repetition rate and a 3 mW average power), a monochromator (1.3 m), and a streak camera with a detection capability ranging from 185-800 nm and a time resolution of 2ps. Because only high-quality semiconductor materials emit predominantly exciton PL, the identification of excitonic spectra reveals the optical quality of the sample. The effectiveness of PL spectroscopy measurement is illustrated in Figure 7.3(a), where the room temperature PL spectra for two selective AIN epilayers (KSU A-767 and KSU A-1080) grown under different growth conditions are shown, which contain different oxygen impurity concentrations. The oxygen and carbon impurity profiles as measured by SIMS are shown in Figure 7.3(b) for sample KSU A-1080. Comparing the PL spectra of the two samples, it can be seen that the optical quality or
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
138 MCP-PMT Single Photon Counting ~30ps
Monochromator (186-800 nm)
Monochromator (800-1700 nm)
H >^ ^ ^
MCP-PMT Single Photon Counting ~30 ps
InGaAs Detector
195 nm (10 mW) 200 fs
Figure 7.2. The femto-second deep UV time-resolved photoluminescence measurement system at Kansas State University. The system is integrated with a near-field scanning optical microscopy and is specifically designed for high Al content AlGaN and AlInGaN alloys, covering the band-band emission in pure AIN. Capabilities include: 2 ps time resolution, 50 nm spatial resolution (SNOM/AFM), 190 nm < A < 1700 nm.
(b)10^^
(a) 8 6-1
4J
AIN (KSU A-767) ©2=1x1020 cm-3
A
300 K
5.98 eV
1
2
£ 8
Jw AIN (KSU A-1080) O2=2x10i7cm-3
I 5.98 eV:
6 4 2
(x10)
0 4 E(eV)
5
^10^ E E o 6 ^o^^ o O
J\ 10^' 0.0
0.5 1.0 Depth (|um)
1.5
Figure 7.3. (a) Room temperature PL spectra measured for selective AIN epilayers grown under different conditions. The oxygen concentrations are also indicated, (b) Oxygen and carbon impurity profiles in sample KSU-A1080, as probed by SIMS (performed by Charles Evans & Associate) (M.L. Nakarmi, Ph.D Thesis, in preparation).
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics
139
the intensity ratio of the band-edge to the deep-level impurity transitions depends strongly on the growth conditions. Furthermore, Figure 7.3(a) shows that the PL emission intensity ratio of the band-edge transition line near 5.97(±0.01) eV to the impurity transition line near 3.40 eV is directly correlated with the oxygen impurity concentration. In the better-optimized AIN epilayer (KSU A-1080) with a lower oxygen impurity concentration, the emission intensity of the impurity transition is two orders of magnitude lower than that of the band-edge transition at room temperature, indicating a significant improvement in material quality. Figure 7.4 compares the PL spectra of AIN and GaN epilayers covering a broad spectral range from 2.2 to 6.2 eV for AIN and 1.8 to 3.6 eV for GaN [34]. It is interesting to note that although the 10 K band-edge emission intensity is about one order of magnitude lower in AIN than in GaN, the room temperature emission intensities are comparable for both compounds. This impHes that it is possible to obtain AIN that displays less thermal quenching and fewer problems resulting from impurities, dislocations and nonradiative recombination channels than GaN, particularly at elevated temperatures. This points to the great potential of AIN for many device applications, because it is already well known that the detrimental effect of dislocations/impurities in GaN is much less severe than in other III-V and II-VI semiconductors. For optimized epilayers grown by MOCVD, the surface morphology of AIN is comparable to those of GaN. This is illustrated in Figure 7.5, where scanning electron (b) 0.4
(a) 12T=10K AIN, KSUA-742
^ <
8-1
1
4-1
T = 300 K AIN, KSU A-742
6.033 eVj
5.960 eV
4.36 eV 2.94 eV
(x100)
0 0.4 3.480 eV 1
GaN, KSU 567
=) < £
40
1 1 i • • 2.16 eV
1 ^ 0 1.5
GaN, KSU 567
1
80
2.0
(X1000)
'
2.5
3.0
E(eV)
<
3.421 eV
2.12 eV
I
0.2
1
1
3.5
^*^(x20^l
4.0
0.0 1.5
2.0
2.5 3.0 E(eV)
3.5
4.0
Figure 7.4. PL spectra of AIN and GaN epilayers measured at (a) 10 K and (b) 300 K, which cover broad spectral ranges to include both the band-edge and deep-level impurity transitions (after Ref. [34]).
140
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides Layer structures
Layer structures
AI2O3 KSU567.GaN
A\fi^ KSUA841-AIN
Figure 7.5. Scanning electron microscopy images of AIN and GaN epilayers showing that the surface morphology of AIN epilayer is as smooth as that of GaN epilayer (M.L. Nakarmi, Ph.D. Thesis, in preparation).
microscopy (SEM) images for both GaN and AIN epilayer surfaces are shown. The typical AFM root mean square surface roughness of GaN and AIN in a 10 |xm X 10 |jLm scan area is about 0.8 nm. For undoped AIN epilayers, the emission intensity of the band-edge emission is, in general, correlated with the surface morphology.
7.3. OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF AIN 7,3.1 Band Structure of Wurtzite AIN Besides important practical applications, AIN is also a unique semiconductor compound for fundamental studies. In contrast to all the other II-VI and III-V binary semiconductors, AIN in the zinc-blende (ZB) structure has a larger bandgap than that in the WZ structure [45]. AIN is also the only WZ semiconductor compound that has been predicted to have a negative crystal field splitting at the top of valence band [46-48]. Confirmation of these predictions are important because the negative crystal field splitting can lead to unusual optical properties of AIN than other WZ semiconductors such as GaN [49]. Our knowledge concerning the band structure and optical properties of AIN is still very limited as compared to GaN. For example, the detailed band structure parameters near the F-point of AIN are less understood. The bandgap was determined in the past only by optical absorption, reflectance, and transmission measurements with energy values scattered around 6.1-6.3 eV at liquid helium temperatures [50]. Due to poor optical quality of AIN in the past, the band structure parameters, including the effective masses of electrons and holes as well as the character and splitting at the valence band-edge and
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics
141
the associated fundamental optical transitions including the band-to-band and excitonic transitions have not been well investigated. It is, therefore, of fundamental and technological importance to fill in the unknowns for AIN. With recent new progresses in the growth of AIN epilayers, the properties of the fundamental optical transitions in AIN can be studied. By comparing the experimental results with first-principles calculations, a coherent picture for the band structure parameters of WZ AIN near the T-point has been obtained [51]. The results reveal significant differences between AIN and GaN in their band-structure parameters, and hence, their fundamental optical properties. The results also explained the puzzling discrepancy in energy bandgap values of AIN obtained previously by different methods [50]. Figure 7.6(a) shows typical temperature dependent band-edge PL emission spectra for AIN. In obtaining the PL spectra shown in Figure 7.6(a), the laser excitation beam was directed to the sample at an angle of ~ 50° with respect to the c-axis of the sample (or the crystal growth direction). At 10 K, two emission lines at 6.033 and 6.017 eV are resolved. Based on time-resolved and temperature-dependent PL studies, as well as their light polarization dependence (discussed below), these emissions are attributed to the free A-exciton (FX) and its associated neutral donor bound (I2) exciton transitions, respectively. As the temperature increases, the relative intensity of the I2 transition peak at 6.017 eV decreases, while that of the FX transition at 6.033 eV increases, which
(a)
(b) 0.5
5.961 eV 1
A
r
AIN epilayer
f'^exc-2L0
^
0.0
T=300 K~
T=220 K 3
1
^.y.'.v_
J
^ f^^ T=100K. ._>AU
5.9
6.0 E(eV)
-1.0 /ln[l3jlo] = -ln[1+Ce-(Eo/kT)]| En= 80 meV
~yk-
J
^
T=60 K 1
T=30K 6.017evU". 6.033 eV , / \ T=10K .^.^ V-
1
5.8
-0.5 T=150K
6.1
6.2
-1.5
-2.0 0.003
0.006
0.009
0.012
0.015
1/T(1/K)
Figure 7.6. (a) PL spectra of AIN epilayer measured at different temperatures between 10 and 300 K. An additional weak emission line indicated as hv^^^-21.0 that becomes visible at room temperature is due to the Raman scattering of the excitation laser line with two longitudinal optical phonons (2L0). (b) The Arrhenius plot of PL intensity [ln(4ini) vs. 1/7] for AIN epilayer. The solid line is the least squares fit of data to Eq. (7.1), from which a free exciton binding energy of 80 meV is obtained (after Ref. [51]).
142
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
resembles the behavior of I2 and FX seen in GaN [49,52]. This is expected because the donor-bound excitons dissociate at higher temperatures into FX and neutral donors D^, (D^X ^ FX + D^). Figure 7.6(b) shows the Arrhenius plot of the PL intensity of the FX transition line at 6.033 eV. The solid line in Figure 7.6(b) is the least squares fit of the measured data to the equation below, which describes the thermal dissociation (activation) of free excitons: / e m i m = /o[l + C e ( - ^ « ^ ^ ^ V ^
(7.1)
where IQ^\{T) and /Q are, respectively, the PL intensities at a finite temperature Tand 0 K, while EQ is the activation energy, i.e. the free exciton binding energy E^^, in AIN. A binding energy of EQ = 80 meV is obtained from the fitting, which agrees with the value determined from the temperature dependence of the FX decay lifetime [53]. The energy gap at 10 K is thus 6.033 eV + 0.080 eV = 6.11(±0.01) eV. To gain the insights of the detailed band structure parameters near the F-point, firstprinciple band structure calculation have been performed for WZ AIN at the experimental lattice constants. The local density approximation (LDA) as implemented by the allelectron, relativistic, WIEN2k code has been used [54]. The calculated band structure together with the measured bandgap and exciton binding energy are shown in Figure 7.7(a). Compared with the band structure of GaN shown in Figure 7.7(b) [49], the most significant difference is the negative crystal-field splitting ACF ( - 2 1 9 meV) in AIN instead of a positive value (+38 meV) in GaN. This is because AIN, being more ionic, has a much smaller c/a ratio (1.601 vs. 1.626 for GaN) and a much larger u parameter (0.3819 vs. 0.3768 for GaN). Here, M is a dimensionless cell-internal coordinate that distinguishes the two nearest-neighbor anion-cation bond lengths in WZ structure. For an ideal WZ structure with c/a = (8/3)^^^ and u = 0.375 the two bond lengths are equal. Neglecting this effect in calculations can lead to large errors. This larger structural distortion in AIN also explains why WZ AIN has a smaller bandgap than ZB AIN, whereas for all the other binary semiconductors the opposite trend exists [55]. There are many important consequences of this large negative AQF in AIN. First, the order of the valence bands in AIN is different from that of GaN. The valence bands, given in increasing order of their transition energies, are Fvvbm (A), Tg^ (B), Fyy (C) for AIN, whereas in GaN the order is Fpvbm, Tvy, Tjy [49]. Because of the large energy separation between the top most valence band and the second and third valence bands (Figure 7.7), fundamental optical transitions near the F-point, as well as the transport properties of the free holes in AIN, are predominantly determined by the top Fvvbm band instead of the top r9vbm band in GaN. Secondly, the optical properties of AIN differ significantly from GaN. Table 7.1 lists the calculated square of the dipole transition matrix elements / = \{il/y\p\il/c)\ between the conduction state and the three valence states at F of WZ AIN for lights polarized parallel (||) and perpendicular (±) to the c-axis. For an arbitrary light polarization, the matrix element 1(6) = cos^^/(£'||c) + sin^^/(£' _L c), where E denotes
143
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics (a)
Band Structure of Wurzite AIN
(b) Band Structure of Wurzite GaN
6.3 6.2 6.1
\ v
r
CBM E^= 80 meV
6.0
ES=E^=20meV
6.11 e V
>
Eg= 3.504 eV
^7vbm
VBM
/^lU
r
|, AE^3=6meV
meV
-0.2
AE^^= 37 meV
-0.3 \y
13 meV
-0.4 -0.5 Figure 7.7. (a) Calculated band structure of wurtzite AIN near the T-point. At k = 0, the top of the valence band is split by crystal field and spin orbit coupling into the r7vbm (A), Tgv (B), and T ^ (C) states. The sign 1 (II) denotes the direction perpendicular (parallel) to the c-axis of the AIN epilayer. The A band exciton binding energy is denoted as £^ [51]. (b) Calculated band structure of wurtzite GaN near the F-point. At A; = 0, the top of the valence band is split by crystal field and spin orbit coupling into the FQvbm (A), T^^ (B), and Fvv (C) states. The A band exciton binding energy is denoted as E^ (after Ref. [49]).
the electric field component of the light and 6 is the angle between E and the c-axes. Our results show that the recombination between the conduction band electrons and the holes in the top most valence state (XiYhm or A) is almost prohibited for E L c, whereas the recombination between the conduction band electrons and holes in the (r9v or B) and (Fvv or C) valence bands are almost forbidden for E\\c, as is shown schematically in Figure 7.8(a). This is in sharp contrast to GaN in which the theoretical and experimental results have shown that the recombination between the conduction band electrons and the holes in the top most valence band (FQvbm oi* A) is almost prohibited for E\\c [49,56]. To further confirm this unusual band structure in AIN, the polarization dependence of the A-exciton and donor-bound exciton emission lines has been measured in AIN Table 7.1. Calculated square of the dipole transition matrix elements / (in a.u.) of WZ AIN for light polarized parallel (||) and perpendicular ( ± ) to the c-axis (after Ref. [51]) Transition
/ (^Ik)
I{E
1 7c *"*• 1 7vbm
0.4580 0 0.0007
0.0004 0.2315 0.2310
Fvc ^ F9v
Lc)
144
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides (a) AIN: r-Poin1t
GaN: r-Point ^7c
6.34 eV
6.32 eV
3.547 eV
6.11 eV
3.510| eV
'r
A
E//C B n
E l C ^7
B
'' E±c
(b)
3.504 eV
— r.
E//C
T=10K, A-742 AIN/Sapphire 6.033 eV
(D°. X ) ElC
GaN/Sapphire]
i
3
E 4-1
6.00
E(eV)
6.04
•
, E // c
3.42 3.44 3.46 3.48 3.50 3.52 3.54
E(eV)
Figure 7.8. (a) The selection rules for the optical transitions at the F-point in AIN and GaN. The sign ± (||) denotes the direction perpendicular (parallel) to the c-axis of the epilayers. (a) Measured polarization dependence of the A-exciton emission spectra in AIN and the donor-bound exciton in GaN (after Ref. 151]).
and GaN, respectively. To do so, a polarizer was placed in front of the entrance slit of the monochromator, so that the PL emission with either E ± c or E\\c was collected. Figure 7.8(b) presents a comparison of the emission spectra of an AIN epilayer obtained for £" _L c and E\\c for AIN and GaN. It conclusively demonstrates that the free A-exciton and the associated bound-exciton transitions in AIN (GaN) are almost prohibited for £ 1 c (£"1^), consistent with the theoretical calculation. It is interesting to note that the PL spectral peak position shift between the £ .L c and E\\c components, as expected for the free electron-hole transition, is not observed in Figure 7.8(b). This is primarily due to the fact that the exact selection rule only applies to the free-hole transition at F = 0, without considering the excitonic effect. The transition is not totally forbidden under the influence of the excitonic effect [57]. Instead, one expects the forbidden transition appears at the same energy position as the allowed
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics
145
transition, but with weaker emission intensity [57], Moreover, strain effect and substrate misorientation can also relax the selection rule. The understanding of the AIN band structure can be used to explain nicely some puzzling experimental data for AIN, such as the strong dependence of the measured bandgap on the details of the experiments. The c-axis of nitride films grown epitaxially is always parallel to the crystal growth direction. In many optical measurements such as absorption, transmission, and reflectance, the propagation direction k of the excitation light is generally parallel to the c-axis and the light is, thus, polarized perpendicular to the c-axis, E ± c (the so called a polarization). As illustrated in Figure 7.8(a), the transition between the Fjc and the top valence band rvvbm. which determines the minimum energy gap of AIN, is not active for E ± c. Therefore, this type of optical measurement cannot obtain the true fundamental bandgap of AIN. Instead, it measures the energy gap between the conduction band and the B (or C) valence band because these transitions are active for a polarization. This explains why larger bandgaps, about 6.3 eV, were reported in earlier measurements [50], whereas the value of 6.11 ± 0.01 eV is obtained by PL. This is in contrast to the case for GaN epilayers, in which the emission to the topmost valence band is allowed for a polarization [49,56]. Thus, different optical measurements would generally yield the same bandgap value in GaN [50]. The absorption coefficients for GaN and AIN were calculated for two different light polarization directions, E ± c and E\\c. The results are shown in Figure 7.9, which clearly show that optical measurements with polarization orientation of E ± c, would reveal for (a) 5
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 11 1 1 1 1 1 y i 1 1 '
(b)
' y
AIN
-
_
_
^ l l /
/«!
-
-
"1^1 1 1 1 i - < < i 1 1. 1 . 1 . 1 . . .
3.5
3.6
3.7
3.8
3.9
4
4.1
4.2
6.1
6.2
6.3
6.4
6.5
6.6
1 . . 1
6.7
6.8
Energy (eV) Figure 7.9.
Calculated absorption coefficients a^ and a^ of AIN for light polarization E 1 c and E\\c (after Ref. [51]).
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
146
AIN an apparent energy gap of Eg + AAB ~ 6.3 eV that is about 0.2 eV larger than the minimum energy gap. 7,3,2 Unique Polarization Properties ofAlGaN Alloys and AIN The unusual valence band structure of AIN gives rise to unique optical properties of AlGaN alloys and their associated UV emitters. Several studies have been carried out to explore the polarization properties of AlGaN alloys and AIN [26,30,58]. Figure 7.10 shows the low temperature (10 K) PL spectra for Al_;cCrai-;,N alloys (0 < x < 1). The experimental measurement geometry is depicted in the inset of Figure 7.10, where the PL emission with either E\\c or E 1 c polarization orientation can be collected using a polarizer in front of the monochromator. The dotted (solid) lines indicate the band-edge emission spectra collected with the polarization of £" ± c (E\\c). Several features are evident: (a) the emission peak position increases with increasing x for both polarization components and (b) the PL emission intensity, /pL, decreases with increasing jc for £^ _L c polarization component. The PL emission component evolves from E ± c being dominant for GaN to E\\c for AIN. Once again, the PL spectral peak position shift between the £" _L c and E\\c components (of about 0.21 eV), as expected for the free electron-hole transition, is not observed due to the excitonic effect [57]. The bowing parameter for AlGaN alloys can be obtained by fitting data with the equation Eg(x) = (1 - A:)£'g(GaN) +x£'g(AlN) - bx(l — x), where h denotes the bowing 10-
T=10K x=0
QI
/laser
AlxGa-, XN/AI2O3
monochromator polarizer
8H
E±c E//c
x=0.5 E
x=0.7
x=1
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5 5.0 E(eV)
5.5
J
6.0
6.5
Figure 7.10. Low temperature (10 K) PL spectra of Al;fGai_;^N alloys of varying JC, for from jc = 0 to 1. The experimental geometry was depicted in the inset, where the electrical field of PL emission (£") can be selected either parallel (||) or perpendicular ( ± ) to the c-axis (after Ref. [58]).
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics
147
parameter. The bowing parameter determined from Figure 7.10 is Z? = 0.86 eV, which is within the range of reported values [59-61]. By analyzing extant data, it was suggested that the intrinsic bandgap bowing parameter for AlGaN alloys is ^ = +0.62(±0.45) eV [60]. A correlation was found between the measured bandgaps and the methods used for epitaxial growth of the Al^Gai-^^N: directly nucleated or buffered growths of Al;,Gai-;cN initiated on sapphire at temperatures T > 800°C usually lead to stronger apparent bowing (Z?>+1.3eV); while growths initiated using low-temperature buffers on sapphire, followed by high-temperature growth, lead to weaker bowing (^ < +1.3 eV) [60]. The degree of polarization (P) is defined by P = (Ij_ - I\\)/(Ij_ + /||), where /^ and /|| are the integrated PL intensities for the polarization components of £^ -L c and E\\c, respectively. Figure 7.11(a) plots P as a function of x. P decreases almost linearly with increasing jc, and P = 0 3.tx = 0.25. The representative band structures near the F-point of Al;,Gai_^N alloys are depicted in Figure 7.11(b) for (a) x = 0, (b) x = 0.25, and (c) x= 1. The conduction bands have Fy symmetry in both AIN and GaN. Compared with the band structure of GaN, the most significant difference in AIN is the negative crystalfield splitting AQF (-219 meV) compared with a positive value (+38 meV) in GaN, as
(a) 1.0
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
Al content (x)
Figure 7.11. (a) The degree of polarization P vs. x in Al^^Gai-^cN alloys, (b) The band structure of wurtzite Al;,Gai_;,N near the F-point for jc = 0, 0.25, and jc = 1 (after Ref. [58]).
148
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
discussed in Section 7.3.1. Because of this large negative ZICF in AIN, the order of the valence bands in AIN is different from that in GaN. The top valence band has T^ (Fy) symmetry in GaN (AIN) because of the positive (negative) ZicF- Therefore, light emission due to the recombination between the conduction band electrons and the holes in the top valence band is polarized with £'||c in AIN, which is opposite to that in GaN (£• _L c). This unique band structure of AIN affects acutely the optical properties of AlGaN alloys, in particular of Al-rich AlGaN alloys. When Al content is increased from X = 0 to 0.25, the valence band with T^ symmetry evolves as the lowest valence band (C-band) in GaN to the topmost valence band (A-band) in Al;,Gai_;,N alloys {x > 0.25). At X = 0.25, three valence bands become degenerated at the F-point and the degree of polarization P becomes zero. Thus, the experimentally observed x dependence of the polarization degree shown in Figure 7.11(a) is a direct consequence of the band structure evolution with x. Figure 7.12(a) shows the FWHM of PL emission spectra of Al;,-Gai_;^;N alloys with different x measured at 10 K. The variation of the FWHM with x follows the general trend of the previous theoretical prediction [62-64], i.e. it increases as a function of x, but decreases as x further increases from jc = 0.7 to 1. Figure 7.12(b) shows the variation of the integrated PL emission intensity of Al;,Gai_;,N alloys with the Al content, Ipi vs. x, measured at 10 K for both polarization orientations of £" .L c and E\\c. The emission intensity of the £ ± c component decreases with increasing x, while /pL of the E\\c component is almost independent of x except for GaN. It is well documented that, the overall PL emission intensity decreases with increasing x in Al^Gai_;^N alloys [51,63]. (a)
100^
T=10K AI,Gai.,N:
80
0)
E, 60 J •
1 40S 20 0-
(b)
•
•
•
• •
"•
1 I
'
•
1
11
8
.-^ d "1 E
•
6 4.
X
• E_Lc • X
0)
X •
X
X
•
•
X E//C X
; J
2 •
c
n. U T 0.0
1
0.2
04^
0.6
0.8
1
Al content (x) Figure 7.12. (a) The full width at half maxima (FWHM) of PL vs. x in A^Gai-^^N alloys at 10 K. (b) PL emission intensities for E L c and E\\c vs. x in AljcGai__^N alloys measured at 10 K (after Ref. [58]).
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics
149
The efficiency of UV light emitting diodes (LEDs) using Al^^Gai-jcN alloys as active layers is also known to decrease with increasing emission wavelength. The results shown in Figure 7.12(b) suggest that the unique optical property of AlGaN alloys is partly responsible for the low emission efficiency in AlGaN alloys and related UV LEDs, i.e. the emission intensity of the E\\c component decreases with increasing x. The fact that the emission intensity of the E\\c component is almost independent of x seems to preclude the dislocations and nonradiative centers being the dominant cause for the reduced emission efficiency in Al;^Gai __^N alloys with increasing x. In terms of implications of this unique polarization property on device applications, the most significant effects include (i) the power output of LEDs decreases and (ii) the light guiding for edge-emitting laser diodes (LDs) with a predominantly TM mode enhances with an increase of the Al content if AlGaN alloys are being used as active layers, due to the negative crystal-field induced unique polarization property of AlGaN alloys. It is well known in conventional LEDs that the extraction efficiency is only about 5% from each side due to internal reflection. The light can only escape from the top and bottom surfaces when it is within a cone of about 6^ ~ 20°, where 9^ is the critical angle of total internal reflection. For all types of existing LEDs from near infrared to blue color, emitted photons in this cone are able to escape since the polarization of emitted light is mainly perpendicular to the crystal axis within this cone (E 1 c) [65]. However, for UV LEDs using Al^Gai-;,N as active layers (x > 0.25), the most dominant emission will be photons with polarization parallel to the c-axis iE\\c), which implies that UV photons can no longer be extracted easily from the escaping cone. Figure 7.13(a) illustrates schematically this situation for UV LEDs using Al;cGai_;cN alloys as active layers, which shows that only photons polarized perpendicular to the c-axis (E 1 c) can be extracted from the escaping cone (^c ~ 20°). However, the E ± c polarization component is prohibited in the escape cone. We thus emphasize that finding methods for enhancing the light extraction is more critical in UV LEDs with Al;cCrai_;cN active layers than in blue/green LEDs with InGaN/GaN active layers. Techniques for extracting light of transverse propagation such as |x-LEDs [66], photonic crystals [67,68] and other methods are not only recommended, but also necessary for future high-power short wavelength nitride UV emitters. For edge-emitting LDs based on AlGaN alloys, since light cannot leak out from the top and bottom layers due to their unique polarization property, the guiding effect of light is thus enhanced. Figure 7.13(b) shows the schematic diagram of LDs with Al^^Gai-j^N alloys as active layers. The transverse electric (TE) mode is usually the dominant laser emission in all other semiconductor LDs, where the electric field of the mode is parallel to the layer interfaces. However, for LDs with Al_^Gai_;cN as active layers (x > 0.25), the transverse magnetic (TM) mode should be the dominant laser emission, in which the magnetic field is parallel to the layer interfaces.
150
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides (a)
AixGa^,xN(x>oj2g^ LED with AIGaN as active layer
(b)
I / / /
/
AlyGai.yN(y>x) AlxGai.xN(x;>0^ AlyGai.yN(y>x) LD with AIGaN as active layer
Figure 7.13. (a) Schematic diagram of UV LEDs with Al^Gai -j,N alloys as active layers. The light escape cone is about dc ^ 20°, within which any photons extracted are nearly polarized perpendicular to the c-axis. (b) Schematic diagram of LDs with Al;,Gai _^N alloys as active layers. In contrast with other semiconductor LDs with TE being the dominant mode, the TM mode is expected to be the dominant mode in AIGaN UV LDs (after Ref. [58]).
7.3.3 Exciton Recombination Dynamics in AIN The recombination dynamics associated with the fundamental optical transitions in AIN are unknown due to the lack of high quality materials as well as technical difficulties involved for the deep UV (down to 200 nm) time-resolved PL measurements in the past. The availability of AIN epilayers with high optical quality as well as the deep UV picosecond time-resolved PL system opens the possibility to probe the recombination dynamics associated with fundamental optical transitions in AIN. Recently, deep UV picosecond time-resolved PL spectroscopy has been employed to study the recombination dynamics of the donor-bound exciton (I2) and free exciton (FX) transitions [53]. Figure 7.14(a) shows the low-temperature (10 K) PL spectrum for an AIN epilayer, in which the dominant emission line at 6.015 eV is due to the neutral donor-bound-exciton recombination (D^X) or I2. A second emission line at the higher energy side around 6.031 eV is also clearly resolved, which is attributed to free-exciton transition (FX). The I2 and free exciton emission peak positions shown in Figure 7.14(a) are 2 meV different from the PL spectra shown in Figure 7.6(a). This is quite common for Ill-nitride epilayers as
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics (a)
(b)
1.5
AIN epilayer KSU1767
151 | i/"\
<
6.015 e V /
T=10K 5.92
5.96
6.00
6.04
E(eV)
6.08
6.12
5.90
yl6.031 eV
(y y
5.95
6.00
X_(FX) 6.05
6.10
E(eV)
Figure 7.14. (a) Low-temperature (10 K) CW PL spectrum of an AIN epilayer grown on sapphire, in which the donor-bound exciton recombination is a dominant transition line at low temperatures, (b) PL spectra measured at different temperatures for an AIN epilayer. The arrows indicate the PL spectral peak positions of the bound exciton (I2) and free exciton (FX) transition lines. The spectra are vertically shifted for a better illustration. (after Ref. [53]).
the magnitude of strain usually varies from sample to sample. The emission spectral line shape resembles those of GaN epilayers in which both free- and bound-excitons emission lines were present [49,52]. The separation between the two peaks is around 16 meV, which corresponds to the binding energy of I2, E^^, in AIN epilayer. The temperature evolution of the time-integrated PL spectra is shown in Figure 7.14(b). Other than the larger separation energy between the I2 and FX emission lines seen in AIN than in GaN (16 vs. 6 meV), the temperature variation of the PL spectra of AIN shown here is very similar to that of GaN epilayers [69,70]. The thermal activation energy of the donor-bound-exciton obtained by measuring the temperature-dependent bound exciton emission intensity in the lowtemperature region agrees with the value of 16 meV obtained from the spectroscopy measurement. This value is about 2.5 times larger than in GaN (^bx = ^-^ meV) [49,52, 71-73]. This enhanced binding energy of the donor bound exciton in AIN is attributed to the fact that the free exciton binding energy, E^, in AIN is larger than that in GaN due to the larger effective masses of electrons and holes in AIN. The temporal responses of the h and FX recombination lines were measured at their respective spectral peak positions at 10 K as displayed in Figure 7.15(a). The decay lifetimes were found to be around 80 ps for I2 and 50 ps for FX transition at T = 10 K. The bound exciton lifetime in AIN is slightly shorter than the approximately 100 ps reported for GaN epilayers [49,52,71]. Values ranging from 50 to 350 ps for the lifetime of free excitons in GaN epilayers depending on the purity and crystalline quality
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
152 (a)
Qj^.^
T = 1 0 K , AINepilayers Tj - 8 0 ps, l2(E=6.015 eV)
=-
0-L Tpx~50 ps, FX(E=6.031 eV)
0.2
0.4
Time (ns)
0.6
100
150
T(K)
Figure 7.15. (a) Temporal responses of PL emissions measured at 10 K at the bound exciton and free exciton spectral peak positions in an AIN epilayer. (b) Top: emission energy dependence of the decay lifetime of the bound exciton and free exciton transition hnes in an AIN epilayer measured at 10 K. The time-integrated emission spectrum is also included. Bottom: temperature dependence of the recombination lifetime of the bound and free excitons measured at their respective spectral peak positions (after Ref. [53]).
of the materials have been reported [49,52,71]. In semiconductors, the radiative recombination rate of fundamental optical transitions increases quadratically with the bandgap, r^ocE^, while the nonradiative recombination rate decreases exponentially with an increase of the bandgap [74,75]. This means that the estimated ratio of the exciton hfetime in AIN to GaN would be roughly (3.4 eV/6.1 eV)^ « 0.3. Thus, it is believed that the observed low-temperature free exciton lifetime of 50 ps is predominantly the radiative recombination lifetime in AIN. Figure 7.15(b) plots the decay lifetime (jeff) of the I2 transition line as a function of the emission energy (£'emi) measured at T = 10 ^ and the temperature dependence of the recombination lifetime of the I2 and FX transitions measured at their respective spectral peak positions. The decay lifetime decreases monotonically from 102 ps at £" = 6.004 eV to 78 ps at £ = 6.027 eV. Similar behaviors have been observed for the I2 and Ii (acceptor bound exciton) transition lines in GaN epilayers [76,77], which was attributed to the existence of a distribution of the binding energy of the bound exciton. The measured decay lifetime of the FX transition is almost independent of ^emi- Decay lifetimes of both the I2 and FX transitions decrease with increasing temperature; however, the FX decay lifetime decreases slower than the I2 transition, which corroborates the results shown in Figure 7.14(b)—the bound exciton dissociates first into a neutral donor and a free exciton with increasing temperature.
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics
153
The radiative recombination lifetime of free excitons, Tj-ad, can be obtained from the measured decay lifetimes (r^ff) and quantum efficiency, rj = /enii(r)//enii(0), with the assumption that the radiative recombination is the dominant process at low temperature, where /emi(^) and /emi(O) are the PL emission intensities at temperature T and 0 K, respectively. The radiative lifetime (Tj-ad) can be obtained from the following equation [78]: 'T'rad = Teff/T?.
(7.2)
By taking /emi(O) "^ 4mi(10 K), the temperature dependence of Tj-ad for AIN epilayers has been obtained for T > 100 K, as shown in Figure 7.16. From Figure 7.14(b), the process of the bound exciton dissociation into FX transition affects the measured decay lifetime and quantum efficiency largely at 7 < 100 K. As shown in Figure 7.16, r^ad increases with T according to T^^^ in the temperature range of 100 < T < 200 K for AIN, a well-known feature of free excitons or free carriers in semiconductors [79]. A similar behavior has been observed in GaN between 50 and 100 K [78]. The temperature range for the relation '^rad ^ T^^^ to hold in AIN is higher than in GaN, which is attributed to a larger binding energy of the bound exciton in AIN. At temperatures above 200 K, the measured decay lifetime of FX transition is affected by the dissociation of free excitons. However, the FX transition is usually the dominant transition at room temperature in AIN. The observed temperature dependence of Tj-ad shown in Figure 7.16 corresponds very well to a theory based on free exciton dissociation (solid line) [78], from which a free
3UU] Ex = 80 meV
200-
/
[
100. /
•
•
•
/•.••' -p3/2
O)
o
1
50 yy
AIN epilayer
yy' 100
(FX) 150
200
300
log(T) (K) Figure 7.16.
Temperature dependence of the radiative decay lifetime of free excitons in AIN. The solid line is the fit based on a theory of free exciton dissociation in Ref. [78] (after Ref. [53]).
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
154
exciton binding energy of E^ = 80 meV is deduced for AIN. This value also agrees fairly well with the thermal activation energy of the free exciton obtained by measuring the temperature-dependent free exciton emission intensity at higher temperatures, i.e. the slope of the InC/gmi) vs. 1/7 plots shown in Figure 7.6(b). We believe this value represents the largest free exciton binding energy ever observed in semiconductors and implies that the excitons are highly robust in AIN, which could have a great significance upon deep UV photonic device applications based on AIN. The effects of Si doping on the donor-bound exciton recombination dynamics in AIN epilayers have been investigated. Doping-induced PL emission linewidth broadening, enhanced nonradiative decay rate, and bandgap renormalization have been observed [80]. Figure 7.17(a) shows the low-temperature (10 K) PL spectra for a set of Si-doped AIN epilayers grown under identical conditions with different Si dopant concentrations, Nsi, in which the dominant emission peak is due to the donor-bound exciton or I2 transition. The top panel of Figure 7.17(b) shows that the I2 emission intensity decreases continuously with increasing A^si- This implies an increased defect density as well as a reduced materials quality with an increase of A^si- This fact contrasts the results obtained for GaN and AlGaN, in which Si-doping in general improves the material quality and the PL emission
(a)
6 6.024 eV
4
FWHM= 16.8 meV
2
(b)
I T=10K, Si-AIN
/
3-
""i.^.,,^^^^
E
0 6.015 e v i
4
FWHM= 17.3 m e V ^ /
2
T = 1 0 K , Si-AIN
Nsr4x10i7cm-3
Z)
%
20
X
18
6.000 eVi
<
FWHM= ; ia4meV,'
\ \
16 6.02
5.991 eV i FWHM= / 20.0 meVr"' 90
5.95
^
\
6.00 E
6.00 data
\
5.98 6.05 (eV)
6.10
6. 15
fit: AEp=-KxNsi^^^
5.96 10
10^ ,-3^
Nsi(cm-^)
Figure 7.17. (a) Low-temperature (10 K) PL spectra of the band-edge transitions in Si-doped AIN with different Si-doping concentrations, Nsi. (b) The integrated PL intensity, full width at half maximum (FWHM), and the PL energy peak position of the I2 emission line, Ep, as functions of Nsi in Si-doped AIN epilayers and the solid line is the least squares fit of data with Eq. (7.4) (after Ref. [80]).
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics
155
intensity [81-83]. AFM studies also reveal that the surface roughness increases with increasing A^si^ varying from 0.7 nm for A^si = 0 to 6 nm for A^si = 1-5 X 10^^ cm"^, indicating a reduced material quality with increasing A^si ^^^ corroborating the PL results. The FWHM of the h transition line can be described by a model that accounts for the emission line width broadening due to local potential fluctuations induced by random distributions of doping impurities [81,82], FWHM = Eo-\- a ^ A ^
(7.3)
where EQ is the FWHM at A^si = 0, a, a constant depending on materials, and r^, the Debye and Thomas-Fermi screening radius for nondegenerate and degenerate doping concentrations, respectively. The solid line in the middle panel in Figure 7.17(b) is the least squares fit of data with Eq. (7.3). The fitted value of £"0 is 15.1 meV, which is in excellent agreement with the FWHM (15.5 meV) of the I2 transition in undoped AIN shown in Figure 7.14(a). Silicon doping also induces bandgap renormalization. The bottom panel of Figure 7.17(b) shows that the spectral energy peak position (^p) of the I2 emission line decreases (i.e. is red-shifted) with an increase of A^si ^^ Si-doped AIN epilayers. Bandgap renormalization is usually due to free carrier screening and is written as A£'p = —Kn^^^, where AE^ is the reduction of the bandgap, n is the electron concentration, and K is a. proportionality constant depending on materials [84-86]. However, no free electrons were found in these samples since all of our AIN epilayers studied here exhibit high resistivity. The bandgap reduction in this case is presumably due to the screening of ionized impurities. In such a context, AE^ is assumed to be proportional to A^si for compensated materials, A£p = -KN'^^
(7.4)
The dotted line in the bottom panel of Figure 7.17(b) is the least squares fit of data with Eq. (7.4) and clearly shows the effect of doping-induced bandgap renormalization in Si-doped AIN epilayers. The PL temporal responses of AIN epilayers with different Si doping levels have been measured at their respective spectral peak positions and the results are shown in Figure 7.18(a). Figure 7.18(b) shows that the PL decay lifetime, r, decreases linearly with increasing A^si- ^^ Figure 7.18(b), the solid line is a linear fit of the experimental data. The fitted value of r = 82 ps at A^si = 0 is also in excellent agreement with the decay lifetime (80 ps) of the I2 transition in undoped AIN shown in Figure 7.15(a). It was believed that the linear decrease of PL decay lifetime with A^si is associated with an increased nonradiative recombination rate with increasing A^si^ which corroborates the PL intensity decreasing with A^si shown in Figure 7.17.
156
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides (a)
2 T=10K Si-doped AIN
0 -2H _a) _4
-8-]
A
Nqi=4.0x10^^cm-2 ^Si' Nsi=1.5x10^Scm-
-10
0.0
0.1
0.2
0.3
Time (ns)
0.5
1.0 Nsj(x10^Scm-3)
Figure 7.18. (a) Temporal responses of the I2 recombination line in Si-doped AIN epilayers with different A^si measured at their respective spectral peak positions, (b) PL decay lifetime as a function of A^si- The solid line is a linear fit of the experimental data (after Ref. [80]).
7,3.4 Optical Properties of Nitrogen and Aluminum Vacancy Complexes in AIN Epilayers As-grown GaN is usually n-type; however, as-grown AIN is highly resistive and n-type conductivity is very difficult to obtain. For many years, it was believed that nitrogen vacancies (V^) were the cause of the high background n-type conductivity in unintentionally doped GaN [87]. First principle calculations indicate that the isolated nitrogen vacancy in GaN has large formation energy and can be excluded as the source of n-type conductivity [88]. Nitrogen vacancies have been observed in electron-irradiated GaN epilayers and is well understood now; however, little is known about V^ in AIN. Previous theoretical investigation revealed that V^ in AIN is a GaN epilayers and the energy level of V^ in GaN was determined to be around 25 meV [89]. This is close to
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics
157
a value of 30 meV obtained from a tight-binding calculation [90] and seems to be consistent with the value obtained from the effective-mass theory without central-cell correction [91]. More recent positron annihilation experiments show that Ga vacancies are the dominant acceptors in n-typc GaN [92]. Furthermore, the Ga vacancy concentration was observed to be equal to the total acceptor density determined by the temperature-dependent Hall experiments. The depth profile of Ga vacancies is similar to that of O, suggesting that the Ga vacancies formed during the growth are bound to defect complexes with the oxygen impurities [92]. While the properties of V^ in GaN are relatively well understood now, Httle is known about V^ in AIN. A previous theoretical investigation showed that VN is a shallow donor with an activation energy of about 300 meV [90]. A recent calculation indicated that as-grown AIN epilayers do not contain V^ because of the high formation energy of V^ [93]. While deep levels offer preferential recombination routes, they are frequently nonradiative and thus inimical to photonic devices. It is known that in GaN, high dose ion-implantation induces nitrogen vacancies that cannot be recovered completely by thermal annealing [94]. Co, Mn, and Cr ions were implanted into AIN epilayers at an energy of 250 keV and with a fixed dose of 3 X 10^^ cm~^ [95,96]. The ion-implanted AIN epilayers were then thermally annealed in nitrogen ambient at various temperatures up to 1325°C for 15 min. Structural characterization was done through high-resolution XRD measurements. FWHM of XRD rocking curve of (0002) peak of the as-grown AIN epilayers was around 400 arcsec, which increased by about 30% for Co-implanted AIN epilayers, but the peak position did not change. Figure 7.19 compares the low temperature (10 K) PL spectra of as-grown and Co-, Mn-, and Cr- implanted AIN epilayers [96]. The arrows indicate the peak positions of the spectra. The as-grown epilayer exhibits a strong band-edge emission line at 6.05 eV and its longitudinal optical (LO) phonon repHcas at 5.94 eV (ILO) and 5.83 eV (2L0). For the ion implanted AIN, the band-edge transition at 6.05 eV is absent, which could not be recovered by thermal annealing in nitrogen ambient up to 1325°C [95]. However, a new emission line with a peak position at 5.87 eV is evident. The spectral peak position and the intensity of the new peak suggest that point defect recombination centers were created during ion-implantation. Furthermore, PL spectra of Co-, Mn- and Cr-implanted samples were identical independent of the implanted species, which also suggests that the 5.87 eV emission line is not related with the implanted ions, but to the nitrogen vacancies (VN) created during ion-implantation [95]. It was believed that ions with energy 250 keV only displace nitrogen atoms to generate nitrogen vacancies (VN) in AIN. Antisites and N intersitials (Ni) are energetically less favorable due to the large lattice mismatch in the covalent radii of Al and N. The 5.87 eV emission line was attributed to the band-toimpurity transition, involving electrons bound to V^ and free holes [96]. Because of the high formation energy of V^ in AIN [93], VN ^nd hence the V^ related optical transition is absent in as-grown AIN epilayers.
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
158
12 8
4-1
6.055 eV T=10K A-838, Undoped-AIN 5.943 eV: 5.831 eV ,
JL ^ *
< (x200)
^y* —-i«w^
0 2
Co-AIN
1-1 5.5
(x200)
/K .—^ 5.6
5.7
5.8
5.9
6.0
6.1
6.2
6.3
E(eV) Figure 7.19. PL spectra of as-grown AIN and Cr, Mn and Co-implanted AIN epilayers measured at 10 K. For the ion-implanted AIN epilayers, the band-edge transition at 6.05 eV disappears and a new emission hne is observed at 5.89 eV (after Ref. [95]).
Time-resolved PL was employed to measure the recombination lifetime of the VN related emission line at 5.87 eV in the Co-implanted sample. The measurement reveals that the decay kinetics was a single exponential with a very short decay time constant (<20ps), which precludes the possibility for a donor-acceptor-pair (DAP) transition. Fast decay lifetime indicates that it is a band-to-impurity type rather than a DAP type transition. For the band-to-impurity transitions, the decay rate is proportional to the total impurity (defect) concentration. The results thus indicate that the concentration of nitrogen vacancies generated by ion implantation is quite high, which is consistent with the absence of the band-edge transitions (6.05 eV) in ion-implanted samples. Since the Al vacancy (VAI) is believed to be a deep acceptor with an energy level larger than 2 eV [90], the possibility of V^i being involved in the 5.87 eV PL emission can also be precluded. Figure 7.20(a) shows the temperature dependence of the 5.87 eV emission line in the Co-implanted AIN measured from 10 to 250 K. The peak position changes slightly with temperature and in fact depicts a week blue shift with increasing temperature in the range from 10 to 180 K. This further supports the assignment that the 5.87 eV emission line is a band-to-impurity transition, since the spectral peak position of this type of emission is
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics (a) T=250 K T=200 K
159
(b)
AIN:Co
AIN: Co 5.90 eV 1
"E
=^ 1 Eo=0.26 eV
fitted by Ln[le^i/lo]=-Ln[1+ce
5.8
5.9
6.0
0.004
0.005
0.006
0.007
1/T(1/K)
E(eV)
Figure 7.20. (a) PL spectra of Co-implanted AIN epilayer measured from 10 to 250 K. (b) The Arrhenius plot of the integrated PL emission intensity at 5.87 eV in the temperature range between 170 and 250 K. The solid line is the least squares fit of data with Eq. (7.1). The fitted value of activation energy (£"0) is also indicated (after Ref. [96]).
expected to follow the temperature variation of the bandgap with an initial blue shift before thermal energy for impurity ionization is reached. Above 170 K, the integrated PL intensity (/jnt) of the 5.87 eV emission line decreases with temperature rapidly and diminishes completely above 250 K, which is predominantly due to the thermal activation process of V^, •V^+e"
(7.5)
where EQ is the thermal activation energy. Figure 7.20(b) is the Arrhenius plot of the PL intensity of the 5.87 eV emission line for the temperature range between 170 and 250 K. The soHd line is the least squares fit of the data with Eq. (7.1). The fitted value of the activation energy EQ is 260 meV, which agrees quite well with the theoretically calculated 300 meV energy level of V^ [90]. Since V^ emission line is located at 5.87 eV with an energy level of 260 meV, the bandgap of AIN can be deduced to be 5.87 eV + 0.26 eV = 6.13 eV, which agrees well with a previous determination of 6.11 eV [53]. This, in turn, also supports the interpretation that the emission line at 5.87 eV in ion implanted AIN is due to a band-to-impurity transition involving V^. The results suggest that nitrogen vacancies in AIN cannot contribute significantly to the n-type conductivity, as a consequence of the large activation energy (0.26 eV) as well as high formation energy. In GaN, the well-known yellow line (YL) with emission energy at around 2.15 eV is often present [43,44,97-99]. The transition mechanism of the YL in GaN is still under debate; however, recent results point towards the donor-to-acceptor pair (DAP) transition
160
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
between a shallow donor and a deep acceptor related with Ga vacancy (Vca) or Ga vacancy and oxygen complex (Vca-ON) in GaN [44,92,100-106]. The YL intensity in GaN was observed to increase with increasing oxygen, Si, and Vca concentrations [92,103-106]. The formation energy of Al vacancy decreases with increasing Al content in AlGaN, and becomes very low with a triple negative charge state in AIN (Vif) [43,44,102]. Although impurity transitions in AIN are much less studied, a broad violet line (VL) at 3.40 eV was commonly observed and the involvement of Al vacancy (VAI) ^nd oxygen (ON) complexes (VAI-ON) has been suggested [44,107]. Needless to say, the presence of a strong VL is detrimental to optoelectronic devices using AIN and AlGaN epilayers with high Al contents, similar to the effect of YL on GaN. The room temperature PL spectra for selective AIN epilayers are shown in Figure 7.3. A VL emission line at 3.40 eV is the dominant transition in sample KSU-A767 with an oxygen concentration of 1 X 10^^ cm~^, while it almost disappears in sample KSU-A1080 with a much lower oxygen concentration o f 2 x lO^^cm"^, which indicates that the VL is directly correlated with oxygen impurities in AIN. The decay lifetime of the 3.40 eV emission line measured at 10 K was longer than 1 |JLS, which precludes the possibility for a band-to-impurity type transition that has a recombination lifetime in the order of 1 ns [108,109]. The broad emission band of VL also indicates that it is a DAP type transition [44]. From the temperature evolution of the time-integrated PL emission intensity of the 3.40 eV line, a thermal activation energy EQ = 60 meV is obtained. This suggests that the 3.40 eV emission line is a DAP transition involving a deep acceptor and a shallow donor (with an ionization energy of around 60 meV). The chemical origin of the shallow donor involved in VL in AIN might be related with Si or O impurities, while the deep acceptor involved is most likely the VAI-ON complex as previously suggested [43,102]. The concentration of Al vacancies depends on Fermi level and impurity concentration [43,44, 102]. It is known that impurity incorporation can enhance the formation of Al vacancies during the crystal growth to form energetically stable VAI oi* ^AI complexes [92,101,102]. Thus the VAI-ON impurity complex, which bears analogy to the Voa-ON impurity complex involved in YL in GaN, is the most favorable candidate for the origin of the VL in AIN or AlGaN with high Al contents. However, VAI-SIAI or other types of VAI complexes as an origin of the deep acceptor are also possible, although their formation energies are larger than that of VAI or VAI-ON complex in AIN.
7.4. IMPURITY PARAMETERS AND CONDUCTIVITY CONTROL IN HIGH Al-CONTENT AlGaN AND AIN
7,4,1 Si Donors and N-type AlGaN and AIN Highly conductive n-type and p-type Al;cGai-;,N alloys with high Al contents {x > 0.6) are needed for the realization of high-performance practical deep UV optoelectronic
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics
161
devices. Achieving conductive Al^^Gai-^^N alloys with high Al content is very challenging due to an increase in the ionization energy of the dopants and an enhanced compensation of native defects (cation vacancy and cation vacancy-oxygen complex) with an increase in the alloy composition [43,44]. Oxygen solubility in AIN is high and oxygen-free AIN crystals and surfaces are not easy to obtain. However, it is necessary to control the oxygen concentration before an efficiency doping can be implemented. Progress has been made over the past many years in terms of conductivity control in the high Al-content AlGaN alloys. N-type conduction in high Al-content Al^^Gai-^cN (x > 0.5) has been obtained by Si-doping by several groups by both MOCVD and MBE growth [110-113]. More recently, using In-Si co-doping, n-type Alo.65Grao.35N epilayers have been achieved with an electron concentration of 2.5 X 10^^ cm~^ and mobility of 22 cvc^fN s corresponding to a resistivity of 0.011 fl cm [114]. Most recently, the authors' group has achieved highly conductive n-type Alo.7Gao.3N epilayers (with a resistivity p = 0.0075 /2 cm) by heavy doping with silicon atoms (A^si = 3.5 X 10^^ cm"^) [115]. It was observed that a minimum silicon doping level of 10^^ cm~^ is necessary for achieving high conductivities in AlGaN alloys with high Al contents [116,117]. On the other hand, pure AIN was usually referred to as a ceramic material due to its very large bandgap, poor crystalline quality, and highly insulating nature and was considered useful as a semiconductor only when alloyed with GaN or used as buffer and spacer layers in nitride structures and devices. However, recent advances on epitaxial growth have shown that it is possible to control the conductivity of AIN by Si doping [116,117]. Figure 7.21(a) shows the typical Hall measurement results for an Alo.7Gao.3N alloy sample with a Si dopant concentration A^si = 3.5 X 10^^ cm~^ in the temperature range from 70 to 600 K. The temperature variations of the free electron concentration and mobility are typical for a semiconductor in which the electron transport is dominated by the ionized impurity scattering at low temperatures and by polar optical phonon scattering at higher temperatures. Compared with GaN in which the maximum mobility appeared around 100 K [118], the temperature for the maximum mobility in n-type Alo.7Gao.3N is much higher due to increased ionization energy of Si donors. In Figure 7.21(b), the temperature variations of the resistivity of Alo.7Gao.3N alloys with different Si-dopant concentrations are presented. The topmost curve is for the sample with the lowest dopant concentration (A^si = 1-5 X 10^^ cm~^), in which a clear thermal activation process is observed. However, this thermal activation behavior becomes less evident as the Si-doping level increases. The sample reaches a lowest resistivity at A^si ~ 3.5 X 10^^ cm~^, beyond which the resistivity increases with further increase in dopant concentration. This could be due to the self-compensation effect or scattering from heavily doped impurity atoms. This trend is more obvious from Figure 7.22(a), which shows the dopant concentration dependence of the room temperature resistivity. The variation of the Si donor activation energy EQ in Alo.7Gao.3N alloy as a function of the Si dopant concentration is presented in Figure 7.22(b), where the values of EQ were obtained from
162
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
(a) _ 0.9E o
a
-|—'—r
0.8-^
(b)0.05KSU-A1496 n-AloyGao.sN Ne;=3.5x10^^cm-3H
• Nsi=1.5x10^9cm-3 o Nsi=2.0x10^9cm-3" A Nsi=2.5x10^9cm-3
0.04-
O Nsi=3.0x10^9cm-3 • Nsi=3.5x10^9cm-3+ Nsi=4.0x10^9cm-3
•••
0.7-
a 0.034.0-
3.0-
Si 0.02* o oo o
25• •• 20-
0.01 * * * * • • • • • • •
15-
1 — I — I — I — I
100 200 300 400 500 600 700
0
T(K)
-r -r -r
100 200 300 400 500 600 700 T(K)
Figure 7.21. (a) (From top to the bottom): variations of resistivity p, electron concentration n, and electron mobility /x with temperature for n-Alo.7Gao.3N with Si-dopant concentration N^i = 3.5 X 10^^ cm~^). (b) Temperature dependent resistivity of an n-Alo.7Gao.3N with varying Si doping levels from 1.5 X 10^^ to 4.0 X 10*^ cm~^ (after Ref. [115]).
the Arrhenius plots of the resistivity data. The inset of Figure 7.22(b) illustrates an example of an Arrhenius plot of the resistivity for Nsj = 3.5 X 10^^ cm~^. The solid line in the inset is the least squares fit of data with p = po/[l + C txp(-Eo/kT)]
(7.6)
where EQ is the donor activation energy, k is Boltzmann constant, and C is a fitting constant, from which a value £^0 of ^^ ^^^ was obtained for Si donor in Alo.7Gao.3N alloy at a dopant level of A^si = 3.5 X 10^^ cm~^. There is a clear trend that £"0 decreases with an increase in the Si-doping level. This is due to the bandgap renormalization effect [119,120], and it can be described by the following equation: Eo = Eo(0) - K(Nsi) 1/3
(7.7)
where K is the renormalization constant, £"0(0) is the extrapolated activation energy at Nsi = 0. In Figure 7.22(b), the solid line represents the least squares fit of EQ with Eq. (7.7). £'o(A^si = 0) was deduced to be 55 meV. A simple calculation shows that the binding energy of a shallow donor in Alo.7Gao.3N alloys is about 60 meV using a linear relation for the parameters between GaN (e = 9.5 and ml/rriQ = 0.2) and AIN (e = 8.5 and ml/m^ = 0.4), which is consistent with the experimental observation. K was obtained as 0.65 X 10~^ meV cm, which is also consistent with a value (2.1 X 10~^ meV cm)
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics (a) 0.035 n
' — 1 — 1 — 1 — 1 — 1 — 11 — 1 — 1 — 1 — 1 — 1 — 1 —
163
(b) 35
n-Alo.7Gao.3N • 0.030 -
T=300K
•
0.025 E o a 0.020-
•
a^ > 0.015-co
-
> CD
-
'(/)
E
0
a:
•
0.010-
•
0.005 0 000 - ' 1 1 .0 1.5
•
'1
•
-
1 — 1 — 1 — 1' — 1 — ' — 1 — ' — 1 — ' —
2.0 2.5
3.0 3.5
Nsi(10^9cm-3)
4.0 4.
2 3 Nsi(10^9cm-3)
Figure 7.22. (a) Room temperature resistivity as a function of the Si dopant concentration, A^si • (t>) The Si donor activation energy in Alo.7Gao.3N as a function of dopant concentration, A^si- Filled circles are measured values and solid line is the least-squares fit with the bandgap renormalization effect of Eq. (7.7). The inset is an Arrehenius plot of resistivity of n-Alo.7Gao.3N with A^si = 3.5 X 10^^ cm~^. Filled circles are the measurement result; solid line is the least squares fit of data with Eq. (7.1). The fitted activation energy is 23 meV (after Ref. [115]).
suggested for GaN [121,122]. The resistivity results shown in Figure 7.22(b) suggest that heavy doping is needed to achieve highly conductive Al;cGai_;cN alloys with high x for device applications. Another interesting parameter one could obtain from Eq. (7.7) is the maximum Si-doping level required to bring EQ down to zero (metallic behavior). Using the fitting results, this doping level can be extrapolated to be about 2 X 10^^ cm~^. However, the resistivity data shown in Figure 7.22 indicate that heavy doping could induce degradation of material quality and impurity compensation. Thus, an optimal doping scheme has to be employed in obtaining highly conductive Al;cGai-;cN alloys with high x. The attainment of highly conductive Al^^Gai-^^N alloys with high Al contents made the measurement of the Si donor parameters in Al^^Gai-^^-N alloys as a function of the Al content in high x end possible [116,117]. Figure 7.23(a) presents the room temperature Hall measurement results of n-Al^cGai-^^N (x > 0.7), showing the Al content (x) dependent resistivity, electron concentration, and electron mobility, respectively. This set of samples were grown on sapphire substrates by MOCVD with a thickness of about 1 iJim. A 0.5 (xm AIN epilayer was first deposited on (0001) sapphire substrate with a low temperature buffer, followed by the growth of Si-doped Al;,Gai_;,N epilayer [117]. The Si dopant concentration (Nsi) was 3.5 X 10^^ cm~^ in all samples as guided by the result shown in Figure 7.22(a). The dopant concentration, A^si^ for selective samples was
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
164
^) 1
(a) E o
UU- -
1
I
I
1
'
1
•
1
'
1
•
1
J
75-
a
•
> b^ 5 0 O UJ
• 25-
•
^ o
0.03-
^
0.02
Q.
r
0.01- V
(3 4
0- — ' — 1 — ^
85
90
Al Content (%)
95
100
•
n-AI^Gai
A
-
x= 0.77
8 12 16 1000/T(K-^)
-
T—'—1—'—1—'—1—'—1—•—
65 70 75 80 85 90 95 100 Al Content (%)
Figure 7.23. (a) Room temperature Hall measurement results of n-Al;,Gai -J>i (x > 0.7). The top, middle and bottom sections of (a) show the resistivity, electron concentration, and electron mobihty as functions of the Al content (x), respectively; lines are guide to the eye. For all samples, the silicon dopant concentration was 3.5 X 10^^ cm~^. (b) Si donor activation energy as a function of the Al content, x. The inset shows the fitting result for Alo.77Gao.23N, and an activation energy of 41 meV was obtained (after Ref. [117]).
determined by SIMS measurements. The resistivity increases with the Al content (x) rapidly and the dependence can be described by the following empirical equation: p(Al^Gai_^N) = p(AlN) X IQ-^^-^^^^-^^
(7.8)
from which one can deduce that the resistivity of n-Al;,.Gai_;^N (x > 0.7) increases by about one order of magnitude when Al content, jc, is increased by about 8%. This rapid increase in resistivity with x is predominantly due to an increase in donor ionization energy. The temperature-dependent resistivity results for n-Al;,Gai_;,N (x > 0.7) in the temperature range from 70 to 620 K have been measured. At the fixed Si dopant concentration of3.5X lO^^cm"^, a strong temperature dependence is seen for samples with high Al content (x > 0.8). Weaker temperature dependence is observed for samples with lower Al contents (x < 0.8), which indicates the trend of moving towards the metallic behavior due to heavy Si doping. The Al content dependence of the Si donor ionization energy (£"0) is depicted in Figure 7.23(b), which clearly shows that EQ increases linearly with an increase in the Al content. The inset of Figure 7.23(b) illustrates an Arrhenius plot of the resistivity data for Alo.77Gao.23N, where a value of 41 meV for the Si donor activation energy (£"0) was obtained in this alloy sample. This deepening of £"0 is due to the fact that with an increase
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics
165
in the Al content in AlGaN alloys, the bandgap and electron effective mass increase, while the dielectric constant and bandgap renormalization effect decrease. For pure AIN, an estimated value ofEo of about 120 meV is obtained by extrapolating the experimental data shown in Figure 7.23. Taniyasu et al. estimated that the donor ionization energy in heavily doped AIN is about 85 meV [116]. It is believed that, for optimized materials, the predominant cause for the rapid increase in resistivity of Al-rich Al^^Gai-^^N alloys with x is the deepening of the Si donor energy level. These recent experimental results indicate that we can achieve measurable n-type conductivity in pure AIN. The effect of persistent photoconductivity has been observed in Si-doped AIN grown by MBE, suggesting that Si may undergo a DX-like metastability [111]. However, more recent results seem to suggest that silicon impurities act more like an effective mass state [116,117], in agreement with a previous theoretical prediction [102]. These discrepancies may be accounted for by the fact that the concentrations of oxygen impurities and Al vacancies (VAI) or VAI complexes have been significantly reduced in highly conductive AlGaN alloys grown recendy by MOCVD and MBE. By further optimizing the growth condition and hence minimizing the effects of impurity compensation, it is possible to further improve the conductivity of pure AIN by heavy doping. 7,4,2 Mg Acceptors in AlGaN and AIN Understating the electrical properties of Mg-doped AlxGai-xN alloy is critical for further improving the p-type conductivity and hence the performance of optoelectronic devices based on these materials. Several groups have reported MOCVD growth and electrical properties of Mg-doped Al;cGai_;cN alloys with low Al contents [123-126]. The authors' group has achieved p-type conduction in Al;cGai-;cN epilayers for x up to 0.27 [127]. Mg doping in AIN has also been attempted. However, all as-grown and post growth annealed Mg-doped layers were highly resistive, although SIMS measurements revealed that Mgdopant concentration was about 7 X 10^^ cm~^ in Mg-doped AIN epilayers [127]. Figure 7.24(a) shows PL spectra measured at different temperatures for Mg-doped AIN epilayers. The low temperature (10 K) PL spectrum of an undoped AIN epilayer grown under identical conditions is also included for comparison. The band-edge transition at 6.06 eV is the dominant transition in undoped AIN epilayers, which is at a slightly higher energy position than those shown in Figures 7.6 and 7.14. Two broad emission lines with much lower emission intensities related with deep-level impurities at about 2.94 and 4.40 eV are also observable in undoped AIN at 10 K. Mg-doped AIN exhibits two dominant emission lines at 4.70 and 5.54 eV at 10 K, which are absent in undoped AIN and are thus attributed to Mg impurity related transitions. The spectral peak positions of these emission lines suggest that they are either band-to-impurity or DAP transitions. However, the slow component of the recombination lifetimes of both emission lines measured at 10 K are about 1 |JLS (not shown), which precludes the possibility for the band-to-impurity
166
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides (a) AIN: Mg
4
^
3
KSU-A1081
KSUA-1081 •
T=300K
(b)
....JxlO)
AIN: Mg Ep=5.54 eV Eo=60 eV
E _a)
(x10) _l
1 .-. ^ ^ - v i(x10) '
1 J fitted by Ln[l3jlo]=-Ln[1+ce-^o/kT]
0.00 2.0T
^.5.54 eV^
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.10
.
.
•
.
•
0.12
Ep=4.70 eV Eo=0.50 eV
•••^.^
\ / ^ 6.02 eV 4.70 e V N - / \ I
(180
6.06 eV
(x100)
T=10K, Undoped
^^
2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0 6.1 E(eV)
1.0 0.003
0.004
0.005
0.006
1/T(1/K)
Figure 7.24. (a) PL spectra measured at different temperatures for Mg-doped AIN epilayers. The low temperature (10 K) spectrum of an undoped AIN epilayer is also included for comparison. The arrows indicate the PL spectral peak positions, (b) The Arrhenius plots [ln(/emi) vs. 1/T] for two emission Unes in Mg-doped AIN: (a) 4.70 eV at r < 150 K and (b) 5.54 eV at T > 150 K. The solid Unes are the least squares fits of data with Eq. (7.1). The fitted activation energies (iE^o) ^ ^ indicated in the figure (after Ref. [127]).
type transitions which are known to have a recombination lifetime in the order of 1 ns in nitrides [128]. Figure 7.24(b) shows the Arrhenius plots of the PL intensities of the 5.54 and 4.70 eV emission lines in Mg-doped AIN measured in the temperature regions T < 150 and > 150 K, respectively. The solid lines are the least squares fit of data with the thermal activation behavior described by Eq. (7.1). The fitted activation energy £"0 (= 60 meV) for the 5.54 eV emission line again suggests that the 5.54 eV emission line is a DAP transition involving a Mg acceptor and a shallow donor (with an ionization energy of 60 meV). Although the ionization energy of the shallow donor involved in the optical transition is in agreement with a value estimated for substitutional shallow donors in AIN by the effective mass theory by taking an electron effective mass of m* = 0.33mo [129,130], the chemical nature of the donor impurity involved is not clear. Possible candidates are Si and O impurities. The monotonic decrease of the 5.54 eV emission intensity with increasing temperature shown in Figure 7.24(a) is due to the thermal dissociation of the shallow donors involved. By neglecting the Coulomb interaction between the ionized donors and acceptors {-e^/sr with r being the distance between the ionized donor and acceptor and s being the static dielectric constant), a value of Ep, = 0.52 eV for the Mg acceptor binding energy in AIN is deduced from E;, ^ E^ - 5.54 eV - 0.06 eV with £„ = 6.12 eV at 10 K [53].
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics
167
The 4.70 eV emission line was assigned to a DAP transition involving a deep-level donor and Mg acceptor. Due to the competing recombination channel at 5.54 eV at low temperatures, the thermal activation process of the 4.70 eV emission line is more complicated than that of the 5.54 eV line. However, the Mg impurity level Ep^ can also be obtained simply from the Arrhenius plot of the 4.70 eV PL intensity for T > 150 K, above which the 5.54 eV emission hne is no longer present. Based on the PL spectral peak position of the 4.70 eV line, it can be concluded that the energy level of the donor involved is deeper than that of the Mg impurities. Thus, the thermal activation behavior of the 4.70 eV hne is a direct measure of the activation of Mg impurities. A value of EQ = 0.50 eV is obtained from Figure 7.24(b) for the 4.70 eV emission hne, which corroborates quite well with the Mg acceptor binding energy of 0.52 eV deduced from the Arrhenius plot of the 5.54 eV hne. Therefore, the Mg acceptor level in AIN is about 0.51(± 0.01) eV above the valence band. Again by neglecting the Coulomb interaction between the ionized donors and acceptors, the binding energy of the deep-level donor (E^) involved in the 4.70 eV transition can be calculated from E^^ ^ E^ - 4 JO eV - 0.5 eV « 0.90 eV. Based on the results shown in Figure 7.24, the energy diagram for the impurity levels in AIN can be constructed, as shown in Figure 7.25. The upper limit of Mg^ level in AIN is estimated to be about 0.97 eV if we assume that the Mg^ level is lined up within the bandgaps of GaN and AIN near the interface of a AlN/GaN heterojunction [131,132]. The conduction band offset parameter is assumed to be 70% for the GaN/AIN heterostructure and EA is 0.17 eV for Mg acceptors in GaN [125,133,134]. The lower limit of the Mg^ energy level in AIN is determined by the effective mass theory with values scattered
0.90 eV
T
1.81 eV
\ shallow donor 0.06-0.12 eV
CB
deep donorT 4.70 eV 5_54ev6.11eV 3.50 eV 0.17 eV • ^ -
0.80 eV (30 %) GaN
0.97 eV
MgO (calculated)
_
I Mg°(exp). 0.51 eV 1 AIN
0.421 eVt O.aOieV '
•
*_
VB
Figure 7.25. Energy diagram showing the impurity levels, including Mg acceptor level, in AIN. The upper limit of Mg acceptor level in AIN is estimated to be about 0.97 eV by lining up its energy levels within the bandgaps of GaN and AIN near the interface of an AlN/GaN heterojunction. The shaded region shows Ej^ predicted by the effective mass theory with uncertainty due to scattered values of the reported hole effective masses (after Ref. [127]).
168
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
between 0.42 and 0.80 eV, as indicated by the shaded region in Figure 7.25, due to the uncertainty in the hole effective mass in AIN [135,136]. The experimental value of £A = 0.51 eV is close to the lower limit values obtained by the effective mass theory. By using the experimentally determined value of Ep^ = 0.51 eV and the high frequency dielectric constant of s(oo) = 4.6 [136,137], an average hole effective mass m^ of about 0.8mo in AIN is estimated, which agrees well with several calculation results [130,138]. The value of ml in GaN is determined to be about 0.46mo by using m}} = 2.03mo and m^ = 0.33mo [139]. The larger ml in AIN suggests a smaller hole mobility in AIN than in GaN. Figure 7.26 presents the determined Mg acceptor ionization energy in AIN and in Al;^Gai_;,N as a function of the Al content x. The dotted line is the linear extrapolation of data from Al^^Gai-^^N alloy with low Al content. The solid line is to guide the eyes by including the value for Mg-doped AIN. It is clear that the activation energy increases with the bandgap, as predicted by the effective mass theory. With the value of Mg acceptor ionization energy being determined for AIN, the issue regarding the possibility of achieving p-type AIN with Mg doping can be addressesed. As a consequence of the large value of Ej^ = 0.51 eV, only a very small fraction (e~^^^^^ = g-0.51/0.025 _ 2Q-9^ of the Mg dopants can contribute free holes for conduction at room
(a) 1.0
(b) 10^ AlxGa-i.xN: Mg
10
AlxGa-i.xN: Mg guide to the eyes
16
D Hal-effect data
0.8
E 10'
EA=0.17+0.5X
A 0.6
PL data guide to the eyes
10^ p=NAe-^A/^T N^=^ 020cm-3
>
10
(D< LJJ
10
10"-^ o 10°
a
|ih=1 cnr» A/s |Xh=10cm^A/s guide to the eyes„„.-
10^ 10^
0.0 0.0
0.2
0.4 0.6 0.8 Al content (x)
1.0
10^ 0.0
0.2
0.4 0.6 Al content (x)
0.8
1.0
Figure 7.26. (a) Mg acceptor activation energy in Mg-doped Al^Gai-;cN as a function of the Al content (x). Closed squares are data from AI^GSLI-XN of low Al contest as determined from Hall measurements, whereas the filled triangle is the data for AIN obtained from Figure 7.24(b). The dotted line is the linear extrapolation of data from Al;,Gai_;,N of low Al contest to x = 1 and the solid line is a guide to the eyes, (b) Calculated hole concentration (p) and resistivity (p) of Mg-doped Al^^Gai -J
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics
169
temperature in Mg-doped AIN. This prevents the determination of any free hole concentrations by conventional measurements (such as Hall effect and capacitancevoltage). Based on the values of the Mg acceptor activation energies in Al^cGai-^cN shown in Figure 7.26(a), the hole concentration (p) and resistivity (p) of Mg-doped Al^^Gai-^cN as functions of the Al content x can be calculated and the result is shown in Figure 7.26(b). For a Mg dopant concentration (N^) of 10^^ cm~^ and a hole mobility (fi^) of 1 or 10 cvci'N s, the resistivity of Mg-doped AIN, p = (pfi^ey^, is estimated to be as high as p = 3 Mil cm with a free hole concentration of ;? = 2 X 10^^ cm~^ and a mobility of /Xh = 10 cm^A^ s. This implies that it is extremely difficult to achieve p-type AIN by Mg doping. It is also interesting to point out that the binding energy of Mg acceptor (0.51 eV) is comparable to that of C acceptor (0.50 eV) in C-doped AIN [140], indicating that p-type AIN is also very difficult to achieve by C doping. It was previously reported that low resistivity AIN epilayers could be achieved by C doping with a C fraction as high as 14% of AIN [141,142]. However, it is believed that C can no longer be treated as dopants in that case because such high C concentrations should instead form AlCN alloys with undetermined optical qualities.
7.5. AIN EPILAYERS FOR DEVICE APPLICATIONS 7,5,1 AIN Epilayer as a Template The benefits of inserting an AIN epitaxial layer as a template for the growth of subsequent Ill-nitride device structures have been demonstrated in several experiments [143,144]. Shibata et al. have shown that the FWHM of the XRD rocking curve of GaN grown on sapphire substrate with a low-temperature GaN (LT-GaN) buffer layers was 216 and 466 arcs for (0004) and (2024) reflections, respectively. However, the FWHM of GaN grown on an AlN/sapphire template exhibited low values of 61 and 232 arcs for (0004) and (2024) reflections, respectively [143]. Furthermore, smooth surface morphology, no pit termination with clear step formation, was observed in n-GaN grown on AlN/sapphire template as probed by AFM. The threading dislocation density of GaN grown on AIN/ sapphire templates was as low as 5 X 10^ cm~^ as probed by transmission electron microscopy measurements. Compared with the n-GaN grown directly on sapphire using a low temperature GaN buffer, cathodoluminescence measurements revealed a 50-60% reduction in dark spot density in n-GaN grown on AlN/sapphire template, indicating that the n-GaN epilayers grown on AlN/sapphire templates comprise lower dislocation density compared with the GaN grown directly on sapphire using LT-GaN buffer [143]. InGaN multiple-quantum-well LEDs were also grown on an AlN/sapphire template by MOCVD [144]. It was found that the FWHM of XRD rocking curves in GaN (0004) oy-lB scan mode were about 82.8 and 231.6 arcsec for the LEDs grown on an AlN/sapphire template and on sapphire, respectively. The results indicated that the LED structure on
170
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
the AlN/sapphire template shows a better crystalline quality and more perfect interfaces than the one on sapphire using a LT-GaN buffer layer, which was due to the small mismatch in the lattice constant and the thermal expansion coefficient between the template and the GaN-based epilayers. Furthermore, the thermal stability of the LED grown on AlN/sapphire template was demonstrated to be superior to the LEDs deposited directly on sapphire substrate. As illustrated in Figure 7.27, the output power at 200 mA decreased by 7.3% for LEDs on the AlN/sapphire template upon increasing temperature from 25 to 95°C, while that for the LED on sapphire decreased by 23.9%. The peak external quantum efficiency decreased from 0.23 to 0.22% and from 0.15 to 0.10% for the LEDs on the AlN/sapphire template and on sapphire, respectively. The EL spectrum peak (a)
mu
[
500 • —
3
^•
$
3O0 _
—
Wc
^^^^ ' ^
wic 9^^
O
iOf'^-*'-H^'
a. -3
20O
o '^
f^
«n sapphire
vO^''^
n
k.
50
1
.
100
1
ISO
J_
L
1
200
Current (mA) (b)
025
O.TO
t
i
_h^^^^^^^
^•^^•fc'
10
100
Current (m A) Figure 7.27. Temperature dependence of light output power (a) and external quantum efficiency (b) vs. current of LEDs grown directly on sapphire and on the AlN/sapphire template (after Ref. [144]).
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics
111
at 20 mA shifted to lower energy by 17.2 meV for the LED on the AlN/sapphire template upon increasing temperature, while that for the LED on sapphire shifted by 32.7 meV. The results clearly demonstrated that the LED on the AlN/sapphire template exhibited a higher output power and a better thermal stability with respect to the conventional LED on sapphire using a low-temperature GaN buffer layer, which is due to the low threading dislocation density in the active layer and the high thermal conductivity of AIN layer [144]. Recently, several groups have successfully demonstrated the operation of deep UV emitters based on AlGaN alloys grown on AlN/sapphire template [145-149]. By employing a 350 nm thick high-temperature AIN epilayer together with a 30 period Alo.85Gao.15N/AlN (50 A/50 A) superlattice topped with a 50 nm AIN compliance layer as a dislocation filter, as illustrated in Figure 7.28, the growth of a very short wavelength AlGaN-based single quantum well UV LED structure with peak emission at 267 nm has been successfully carried out [147]. An output power of 4.5 mW in pulsed operation mode and 165 |ULW in CW operation mode was achieved for an array of four LEDs in parallel. These results demonstrated that high quality AIN epilayer template is indispensable in achieving Ill-nitride deep UV LEDs with high performance. So far, active devices based on AIN p - n junctions have not yet been attempted since p-type doping of AlGaN with high Al content has been very difficult. However, a very interesting work on n-AlN/p-diamond heterojunction diodes was carried out at the Walter Schottky Institute [37]. Si-doped wurzite (0001) AIN epilayer was grown on (100) naturally boron-doped diamond (p-type) substrates by plasma-induced MBE [38]. The surprisingly good structural quality of the AIN film was assessed by high resolution XRD. The fabricated p - n heterojunction diodes show clear diode characteristics with rectifying ratios between 10^ and 10"^ at low voltages. Under forward bias, an intense light emission in the blue (2.7 eV) and UV (4.8 eV) was obtained. Although the origin of the Hght
Sa|jptiircMW.I)
| 1000 1060 1100 1160
Growth T(^C) Figure 7.28.
Layer structure of a 280 nm UV LED using AIN epilayer as a template (after Ref. [147]).
172
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
emission was unclear, both the UV and the blue light emission were only detected under forward bias of the diode, pointing to an electron-hole recombination process through the interface. The presence of defects at the heterojunction interface should also allow tunneling-assisted emission processes, which was also suggested by the diode ideality factor of 3. The authors believe that many fabrication steps for n-AlN/p-diamond heterojunction diodes can be improved, such as growth parameters, AIN and diamond doping levels, contacts and device technology, etc. [38]. The work opens up interesting perspectives for future optoelectronic devices operating in the deep UV spectral region. 7.5.2 AIN for Surface Acoustic Wave Devices The increase in the operation frequencies of wireless communication systems has stimulated the research and development of high-frequency, low-cost, microelectronic filters with standard technological processes. SAW filters implemented on conventional piezoelectric materials (such as quartz or lithium niobate) are widely used in consumer electronics, in which frequency control is required. The resonance frequency of a SAW device is determined by the equation/ = Vph/A, where/is the resonance frequency, Vph is the phase velocity of the SAW, and A is the wavelength [150]. The wavelength A is primarily defined by the pitch of the interdigital transducer (IDT). From a materials point of view, there exist three main methods for increasing the frequency of operation of the SAW device [41]. In the first instance, high-velocity waves, such as leaky SAW, have been employed and materials such as LiTaOs and LiNbOs have shown high-phase-velocity waves ranging between 6000 and 7000 m/s [41]. In the second instance, materials, such as lithium tetraborate (Li2B407), the SAW velocity of which is 6780 m/s, have been developed [41]. Finally, improved SAW filter performance can also be achieved by using the layered structures of piezoelectric thin films grown on highvelocity substrates. For instance, zinc oxide (ZnO) on sapphire [151,152] and AIN on sapphire [153,154] have been developed, obtaining high velocities of 5500 and 6700 m/s, respectively. Thin piezoelectric film technology that enables one to choose the proper film/ substrate combination. AI2O3 nonpiezoelectric substrates and high-quality AIN piezoelectric films are ideal candidates for the realization of high-frequency [42,155-161] temperature-compensated [162,163], low-cost SAW filters due to their high SAW velocities and opposite temperature coefficients. More recently, the layered structure of AIN on diamond has been developed to take advantage of the high acoustic velocity as well as the high thermal conductivity of diamond [41]. Caliendo has characterized the acoustic and thermal properties of SAW delay lines, implemented on AIN thin and thick films sputtered on AI2O3 substrates at low temperature [42]. SAW delay lines working at frequencies up to 2.4 GHz were fabricated on poly crystalline AI2O3/AIN structures using only a simple optical lithography at 7.5 |ULm. Experimental electromechanical coupling factor and phase velocities of SAWs propagating along x- and ^-propagation directions, for different AIN film thickness to
173
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics 5750-j
5725J 5700J
B ^
0 0
zy-Al,0,/AIN
^
AlN/zx-AljO, MWzy-Alfi^
1 ^^^ J ^ 565oJ
t
1 5625J
•
* 5575 J 5550J
"7
552 5 ^
zx-AljO/AIN 1
•
1 '
1
•
1 •
1 •
1
'
1 ' 1 ' 1 • 1 '
r
0.0 0.2 04 06 08 10 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 20 2.2 h/X Figure 7.29. Theoretical dispersion curve (phase velocity vs. h/X) and experimental phase velocities (dots) for SAWs propagating along x- and y-axes of z-cut AI2O3/AIN structures. The theoretical curve takes into account only the interdigital transducer (IDT) electrical loading (Ref. [42]).
SAW wavelength (A) ratio (h/X), were estimated and were found to be in good agreement with the theoretical values relative to SAWs propagating in single-crystal AIN films on AI2O3 substrates. Figure 7.29 shows the theoretical dispersion curve (phase velocity vs. h/X) and experimental phase velocities (dots) for SAWs propagating along x- and j-axes of z-cut AI2O3/AIN structures. The theoretical curve takes into account only the IDT electrical loading. The opposite temperature coefficient of delay (TCD) of AI2O3 and AIN can allow the realization of temperature-compensated (temperature coefficient of frequency (TCF) = 0 ppm/°C) acoustic devices at a specific film thickness. For this purpose, the author measured the first-order TCF of AIN/AI2O3 structures for different h/X values. The TCF compensated point was found to be around h/X = 1.116 (/o = 2.39 GHz) with the estimated value of TCF equal to 0.5 ppm/°C. The experimental data confirm that AIN poly crystalline films have a negative TCD ( = - TCF); this value is asymptotically reached upon increasing h/X. In particular, TCD is equal to -23.45 ppm/°C for h/X = 1.86. These data provide the feasibility to achieve temperature-compensated SAW devices with proper AIN film thickness [42]. 7,5,3 AlN'based Field Emission Devices AIN is a promising material for field emitters because electrons in materials with nearly zero electron affinity can be easily extracted from the surface to vacuum [164]. The reported value ranges from negative to 0.25 eV [165,166]. High-performance electron field emitters have applications in vacuum microelectronic devices, such as field emission
174
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
displays (FEDs) and high-frequency micro-vacuum tubes. However, for AIN, the reported field emission current is too low, and the turn-on electric field is too high for the device application. The reason for the low-field emission current and high turn-on electric field is probably that the electron concentration in the undoped AIN samples is so low that the electrons necessary for field emission cannot be efficiently supplied to the surface [164]. Recently, Taniyasu et al. of NTT have not only demonstrated n-type conduction in AIN epilayers by Si doping [116], but also studied the field emission properties of Si-doped AIN by using a diode (sample-anode) configuration in an ultrahigh vacuum chamber [164]. They found that heavy Si doping is very effective in improving the field emission properties of AIN. As the Si doping concentration increases, the turn-on voltage decreases, and, consequently, the field emission current increases greatly. For a Si doping concentration, [Si], of 1 X 10^^ cm~^, the largest current density was as high as 220 mA/cm^. In addition, the field emission current was extremely stable; the fluctuation in field emission current over time was only 3%. The authors believe that there are three factors that contribute to the field emission properties of the heavily Si-doped AIN with [Si] ~ 10^^ cm~^. The first is the formation of a Si impurity band below the conduction band [116]. The electrons necessary for field emission are effectively supplied to the surface through this impurity band. The second is nearly zero electron affinity. Because the Si impurity band is around 86 meV below the conduction band in heavily doped AIN, the energy barrier for electrons in the Si impurity band is still low enough for the field emission. The third process is field enhancement due to sharp ridges induced by Si doping, whose top has a radius of curvature in the nanometer range [116]. The sharp ridge formation decreases the effective energy barrier of field emission and thereby enhances field emission efficiency. The authors estimated that the ridge effect decreases the energy barrier by 1.5 eV. Thus, Si-doped AIN is a very promising material for field emitters. More impressively, they have achieved a triode-type FED using heavily Si-doped AIN. Their FED has a vertical triode structure consisting of the heavily Si-doped AIN, mesh grid, and phosphor coated anode screen as shown in Figure 7.30(a). The heavily Si-doped AIN was set on the cathode electrode. The mesh grid was separated from the AIN surface by a glass spacer and acted as an extraction electrode. The field-emitted electrons were accelerated by the anode voltage. The electrons that pass through the Al thin layer excited the phosphor. The luminescence emitted from the phosphor was observed through the glass. After the FED fabrication, the air was evacuated from inside the FED and the vacuum pressure was kept at 7 X 10~^ Pa. Figure 7.30(b) shows photographs of the FED (a) before and (b) during operation. Green luminescence was emitted from the center of the phosphor screen. The luminescence area on the phosphor screen is almost the same as the opening area of the mesh grid. Uniform and bright luminescence was observed over the entire field emission area. The brightness increased as the field emission current IQ was increased. They obtained the brightness of 300 cd/m^ at VQ = 2.3 kV, Vj^ = S kV, and IQ = 16 jjuA. The authors believe that this
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics
175
Figure 7.30. (a) Schematic diagram of the field emission display structure using the heavily Si-doped AIN. The device has a vertical triode structure consisting of the Si-doped AIN field emitter, mesh grid, and phosphor-coated anode screen, (b) The photographs of the FED (a) before and (b) during operation at VQ = 2.3 kV and FA = 8 kV. The green luminescence with the brightness of 300 cd/m^ is emitted from the center of the phosphor screen and scattered light is observed from the surrounding area (Ref. [164]).
brightness is high enough for display appHcation. The authors have also confirmed the stability of the field emission current and the luminescence properties in an actual FED, which originates from the high physical and chemical stability of the AIN surface due to the strong Al-N bond strength [164].
7.6. CONCLUDING REMARKS As a semiconductor material, AIN is about 10 years behind GaN in terms of its property control, basic understanding, and potential applications for optoelectronic devices. However, as of this writing, rapid progress has been made in epitaxial growth of AIN. The crystalline quality, surface morphology, optical quality, and the ability for conductivity control have improved significantly. By employing AIN epilayer as a template, UV LEDs with emission wavelengths shorter than 340 nm and milliwatts output power under CW operation have been achieved [145-149]. These recent results demonstrate that AIN materials are very promising for deep UV photonic device applications. However, methods for improved material qualities as well as conductivity control still need to be further explored. The use of AIN bulk single crystals as substrates are expected to reduce crystal defect densities due to its better lattice constant, and thermal expansion coefficient matches over other substrates. Thus epitaxial growth
176
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
conditions for AIN epilayers and the subsequent UV emitter device structures on AIN bulk substrates have to be optimized. Due to the rapid evolution in material quality, basic properties of AIN remain to be probed for different structures (e.g. heteroepitaxial vs. homoepitaxial layers and epitaxial layers vs. bulk crystals) to gain insight into the fundamental values. These include the fundamental band structure parameters, effective electron and holes masses, dielectric constants recombination dynamics associated with the fundamental optical transitions, mechanisms of the impurity/defects (or defect complexes) related optical transitions, and n- and p-type impurity parameters. Properties of native defects and their effects on doping issues must be continuously investigated. The fundamental limit and hence the feasibility for achieving p-type doping needs to be continuously assessed. We envision that device quality conductive n-type AIN epilayers will be available within 2 - 3 years. This will enable the fabrication of active deep UV solid-state photonic devices down to 200 nm, which will open up many important and new applications. Furthermore, conductive AIN will be the first active dielectric material in which the index of refraction can be controlled by applying electric field or by carrier injection. This could bring out unforeseen properties and applications. Active devices in the wavelength scale have not been explored in deep UV wavelength regime. Nano-photonics involves photonic structures and devices with sizes comparable with the wavelengths of the light they manipulate (A/n), where n is the index of refraction, which is typically in the range of 50-200 nm for deep UV nitride devices. As the lateral size approaches the emission photon wavelength scale, quantum nature of light is expected to play an important role. Fundamental issues including the size effects (and surface effects) on the carrier dynamics in submicron and nano-cavities must be fully explored. Recent work has shown that both the surface recombination velocities in asgrown Ill-nitride epilayers and etched sidewalls are one order of magnitude lower than the corresponding values in GaAs [167,168]. This together with other unique features of Ill-nitrides makes them very attractive for the study of nano-photonic structures and devices. It would be very interesting to study the effects of artificially built-in photonic crystals and microcavities on the recombination processes of AIN based materials and devices. Ill-nitride photonic crystals are expected to possess special functionalities in the visible and UV spectral regions. It is our belief that Ill-nitride micro- and nano-photonics structures and devices will open many more important applications and is a burgeoning field with outstanding potentials. As we move toward deep UV wavelength (or ultra-wide-bandgap) regime, we have entered a virgin territory in the field of semiconductors. We are challenged in all fronts by this new class of semiconductor materials, ranging from material growth, characterization techniques, understanding new phenomena, to invention of new devices. Though the light emitted by AlGaN alloys dims with an increase of Al composition due to the diminishing ability of human eyes for seeing deep UV photons, we believe that the future
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics
111
prospects of AlGaN-based materials and devices are bright because of the unique features of AIN that have already been revealed. AIN and AlGaN alloys are likely to become parts of solutions of a wide variety of problems ranging from improved efficient lighting for energy savings, national security, entertainment, medical and health care and information technology.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We are indebted to the contributions from our group members: M.L. Nakarmi, K.B. Nam, J.Li, K.H. Kim, J. Shakya, N. Nepal, Z.Y. Fan, T. Oder, S.X. Jin, and K. Zhu. We gratefully acknowledge the theory input and collaboration of Dr. S.-H. Wei's group at NREL. The authors' research program at Kansas State University is supported by grants from ARO, NSF, DOE, and DARPA.
REFERENCES [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19]
Lakowicz, J.R. (1999) Principles of Fluorescence Spectroscopy, 2^^ Edition. Bergh, Craford, G., Duggal, A. & Haitz, R. (2001) Phys. Today, December, 42. Yoshida, S., Misawa, S. & Itoh, A. (1975) Appl Phys. Lett., 26, 461. O'clock, G.D., Jr. & Duffy, M.T. (1973) Appl. Phys. Lett., 23, 55. Khan, M.A., Kuznia, J.N., Skogman, R.A., Olson, D.T., Millan, M.M. & Choyke, W.J. (1992) Appl. Phys. Lett., 61, 2539. Militello, M.C., Gaarenstroom, S.W. & Simko, S.J. (1992) Surf. Sci. Spectra, 1, 3. Chourasia, A.R., Chopra, D.R. & Hatwar, T.K. (1992) Surf. Sci. Spectra, 1, 75. Saxler, A., Kung, P., Sun, C.J., Bigan, E. & Razeghi, M. (1994) Appl. Phys. Lett., 64, 339. Okano, H., Tanaka, N., Takahashi, Y., Tanaka, T., Shibata, K. & Nakano, S. (1994) Appl. Phys. Lett., 64, 166. Meng, W.J., Sell, J.A., Perry, T.A., Rehn, L.E. & Baldo, P.M. (1994) J. Appl. Phys., 75, 3446. Vispute, R.D., Narayan, J., Wu, H. & Jagannadham, K. (1995) J. Appl. Phys., 77, 4724. Chaudhuri, J., Thokala, R., Edgar, J.H. & Sywe, B.S. (1995) /. Appl. Phys., 77, 6263. Keying, B., Wu, X.H., Keller, S., Li, Y., Kapolnek, D., Keller, B.P., DenBaars, S.P. & Speck, J.S. (1996) Appl. Phys. Lett., 68, 643. Zhu, Q., Botchkarev, A., Kim, W., Aktas, 6., Salvador, A., Sverdlov, B., Morkog, H., Tsen, S.-C.Y. & Smith, D.J. (1996) Appl. Phys. Lett., 68, 1141. Dovidenko, K., Oktyabrsky, S., Narayan, J. & Razeghi, M. (1996) /. Appl. Phys., 79, 2439. Johnson, M.A.L., Fujita, S., Rowland, W.H., Jr., Bowers, K.A., Hughes, W.C., He, Y.W., ElMasry, N.A., Cook, J.W., Jr. & Schetzina, J.F. (1996) /. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 14, 2349. Hossain, F.R.B., Tang, X., Wongchotigul, K. & Spenser, M.G. (1996) Proc. SPIE, 1%11, 42. Zettering, M., Ostling, M., Wongchotigul, K., Spencer, M.G., Tang, X., Harris, C.I., Ordell, N. & Wong, S.S. (1997) /. Appl. Phys., 82, 2990. Malengreau, F., Vermeersch, M., Hagege, S., Sporken, R., Lange, M.D. & Caudano, R. (1997) /. Mater Res., 12, 175.
178
Optoelectronic
Devices:
Ill-Nitrides
[20] Bourret, A., Barski, A., Rouviere, J.L., Renaud, G. & Barbier, A. (1998) /. Appl. Phys., 83, 2003. [21] Smith, S.A., Wolden, C.A., Bremser, M.D., Hanser, A.D., Davis, R.F. & Lampert, W.V. (1997) Appl Phys. Lett., 71, 3631. [22] Yeadon, M., Marshall, M.T., Hamdani, F., Pekin, S., Morko?, H. & Gibson, J.M. (1998) /. Appl Phys., 83, 2847. [23] Bourret, A., Barski, A., Rouviere, J.L., Renaud, G. & Barbier, A. (1998) /. Appl Phys., 83, 2003. [24] Schowalter, L.J., Shusterman, Y., Wang, R., Bhat, I., Arunmozhi, G. & Slack, G.A. (2000) Appl Phys. Lett., 76, 985. [25] Fan, Z.Y., Rong, G., Newman, N. & Smith, D.J. (2000) Appl Phys. Lett., 76, 1839. [26] Yuan, Y., Chen, B., Qiu, S. & Chen, L. (2000) Proc. SPIE Int. Soc. Opt. Eng., 4086, 773. [27] Schowalter, L.J., Shusterman, Y., Wang, R., Bhat, I., Arunmozhi, G. & Slack, G.A. (2000) Appl Phys. Lett., 76, 985. [28] Goennenwein, S.T.B., Zeisel, R., Ambacher, O., Brandt, M.S., Stutzmann, M. & Baldovino, S. (2001) Appl Phys. Lett., 79, 2396. [29] Ishihara, M., Manabe, T., Kumagai, T., Nakamura, T., Fujiwara, S., Ebata, Y., Shikata, S., Nakahata, H., Hachigo, A. & Koga, Y. (2001) Jpn. J. Appl Phys., 40, 5065 Part 1. [30] Wu, J.D., Sun, J., Ying, Z.F., Shi, W., Ling, H., Li, F.M., Zhou, Z.Y., Wang, K.L. & Ding, X.M. (2001) /. Vac. ScL Technol A, 19, 299. [31] Onuma, T., Chichibu, S.F., Sota, T., Asai, K., Sumiya, S., Shibata, T. & Tanaka, M. (2002) Appl Phys. Lett., 81, 652. [32] Taniyasu, Y., Kasu, M. & Kobayashi, N. (2002) Appl Phys. Lett., 81, 1255. [33] Kuokstis, E., Zhang, J., Fareed, Q., Yang, J.W., Simin, G., Asif Khan, M., Gaska, R., Shur, M., Rojo, C. & Schowalter, L. (2002) Appl Phys. Lett., 81, 2755. [34] Li, J., Nam, K.B., Nakarmi, M.L., Lin, J.Y. & Jiang, H.X. (2002) Appl Phys. Lett., 81, 3365. [35] Onojima, N., Suda, J. & Matsunami, H. (2002) Jpn. J. Appl Phys., 41, L1348 Part 2. [36] Hong, S.U., Han, G.P., Pack, M.C., Cho, K.I. & Yoon, S.G. (2002) Electrochem. Solid State Lett., 5, G54. [37] Schlesser, R., Dalmau, R., Yakimova, R. & Sitar, Z. (2002) Mater. Res. Soc. Proc, 693, 19.4.1. [38] Miskys, C.R., Garrido, J.A., Nebel, C.E., Hermann, M., Ambacher, O., Eickhoff, M. & Stutzmann, M. (2003) Appl Phys. Lett., 82, 290. [39] Natali, F., Semond, F., Massies, J., Byrne, D., Laiigt, S., Tottereau, O., Vennegues, P., Dogheche, E. & Dumont, E. (2003) Appl Phys. Lett., 82, 1386. [40] Kai, Y., Yoshimura, M., Mori, Y. & Sasaki, T. (2003) Jpn. J. Appl Phys., 42, L229 Part 2. [41] Iriarte, G.F. (2003) /. Appl Phys., 93, 9604. [42] Caliendo, C. (2003) Appl Phys. Lett., 83, 4851. [43] Van de Walle, C.G. & Neugebauer, J. (2004) J. Appl Phys., 95, 3851. [44] Mattila, T. & Nieminen, R.M. (1997) Phys. Rev. B, 55, 9571. [45] Wei, S.-H., Nie, X., Batyrev, I.G. & Zhang, S.B. (2004) Phys. Rev. B, in press. Code BWR828. [46] Suzuki, M., Uenoyama, T. & Yanase, A. (1995) Phys. Rev. B, 52, 8132. [47] Wei, S.-H. & Zunger, A. (1996) Appl Phys. Lett., 69, 2719 and references therein. [48] Persson, C , Ferreira da Silva, A., Ahuja, R. & Johansson, B. (2001) /. Crystal Growth, 231, 397.
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics
179
[49] Chen, G.D., Smith, M., Lin, J.Y., Jiang, H.X., Wei, S.-H., Asif Khan, M. & Sun, CJ. (1996) Appl. Phys. Lett., 68, 2784. [50] Edgar, J.H., Strite, S., Akasaki, L, Amano, H. & Wetzel, C. Eds. (1999) Gallium Nitride & Related Semiconductors, INSPEC publication, London. [51] Li, J., Nam, K.B., Nakarmi, M.L., Li, J., Lin, J.Y., Jiang, H.X., Carrier, P. & Wei, S.H. (2003) Appl Phys. Lett., 83, 5163. [52] Jiang, H.X. & Lin, J.Y. (2002) in Ill-nitride Semiconductors—Optical Properties, Eds. Manasreh, M.O. & Jiang, H.X., Taylor&Francis, New York, Chapter 2. [53] Nam, K.B., Li, J., Nakarmi, M.L., Lin, J.Y. & Jiang, H.X. (2003) App/. Phys. Lett., 82, 1694. [54] (a) Blaha, P., Schwarz, K., Madsen, G.K.H., Kvasnicka, D., & Luitz, J., (2001) WIEN2k Code, Vienna University of Technology, November, (b) Blaha, P., Schwarz, K., Sorantin, P., Trickey, S.B. (1990) Comput. Phys. Commun., 59, 399. [55] Yeh, C.-Y., Wei, S.-H. & Zunger, A. (1994) Phys. Rev. B, 50, R2715. [56] Eckey, L., Podlowski, L., Goldner, A., Hoffmann, A., Broser, L, Meyer, B.K., Volm, D., Streibl, T., Hiramatsu, K., Detchprohm, T., Amano, H. & Akasaki, I. (1996) Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser., 142, 943. [57] Zhang, Y., Mascarenhas, A., Ernst, P., Driessen, F.A.J.M., Friedman, D.J., Bertness, K.A. & Olson, J.M. (1997) J. Appl. Phys., 81, 6365. [58] Nam, K.B., Li, J., Nakarmi, M.L., Lin, J.Y. & Jiang, H.X. (2004) Unique optical properties of AlGaN alloys and related UV emitters. Appl. Phys. Lett., 84 in press. [59] Shan, W., Ager, J.W., III, Yu, K.M., Walukiewicz, W., Haller, E.E., Martin, M.C., McKinney, W.R. & Yang, W. (1999) /. Appl. Phys., 85, 8505. [60] Lee, S.R., Wright, A.F., Crawford, M.H., Peterson, G.A., Han, J. & Biefeld, R.M. (1999) Appl. Phys. Lett., 74, 3344 and references there in. [61] Paduana, Q.S., Weybume, D.W., Bouthillette, L.O., Wang, S.Q. & Alexander, M. (2002) Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 41, 1936. [62] CoH, G., Bajaj, K.K., Li, J., Lin, J.Y. & Jiang, H.X. (2001) Appl. Phys. Lett., 78, 1829. [63] Kim, H.S., Mair, R.A., Li, J., Lin, J.Y. & Jiang, H.X. (2000) Appl. Phys. Lett., 76, 1252. [64] Coli, G., Bajaj, K.K., Li, J., Lin, J.Y. & Jiang, H.X. (2002) Appl. Phys. Lett., 80, 2907. [65] Morkoc, H., Strite, S., Gao, G.B., Lin, M.E., Sverdlov, B. & Bums, M. (1994) J. Appl. Phys., 76, 1363. [66] Jin, S.X., Li, J., Lin, J.Y. & Jiang, H.X. (2000) Appl. Phys. Lett., 77, 3236. [67] Oder, T.N., Shakya, J., Lin, J.Y. & Jiang, H.X. (2003) Appl. Phys. Lett., 83, 1231. [68] Oder, T.N., Kim, K.H., Lin, J.Y. & Jiang, H.X. (2004) Appl. Phys. Lett., 84, 466. [69] Viswanath, A.K., Lee, J.I., Yu, S., Kim, D., Choi, Y. & Hong, C.H. (1998) /. Appl. Phys., 84, 3848. [70] Smith, M., Lin, J.Y., Jiang, H.X. & Asif Khan, M. (1997) Appl. Phys. Lett., 71, 635. [71] Pozina, G., Bergman, J.P., Paskova, T. & Monemar, B. (1999) Appl. Phys. Lett., 75, 4124. [72] Mair, R.A., Li, J., Duan, S.K., Lin, J.Y. & Jiang, H.X. (1999) Appl. Phys. Lett., 74, 513. [73] Shan, W., Xie, X.C, Song, J.J. & Goldenberg, B. (1995) Appl. Phys. Lett., 67, 2512. [74] Henderson, B. & Imbusch, G.F. (1989) Optical Spectroscopy of Inorganic Solids, Clarendon Press, Oxford. [75] Landsberg, P.T. (1991) Recombination in Semiconductors, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. [76] Chen, G.D., Smith, M., Lin, J.Y., Jiang, H.X., Asif Khan, M. & Sun, C.J. (1995) Appl. Phys. Lett., 67, 1653.
180
Optoelectronic
Devices:
Ill-Nitrides
[77] Smith, M., Chen, G.D., Lin, J.Y., Jiang, H.X., Asif Khan, M. & Sun, CJ. (1995) Appl Phys. Lett., 67, 3295. [78] Im, J.S., Moritz, A., Steuber, F., Harle, V., Scholz, F. & Hangleiter, A. (1997) Appl Phys. Lett., 70, 631. [79] Lasher, G. & Stem, F. (1964) Phys. Rev., 133, 554. [80] Nam, K.B., Nakarmi, M.L., Li, J., Lin, J.Y. & Jiang, H.X. (2003) Appl Phys. Lett., 83, 2787. [81] Nam, K.B., Li, J., Nakarmi, M.L., Lin, J.Y. & Jiang, H.X. (2002) Appl Phys. Lett., 81, 1038. [82] Yoshikawa, M., Kunzer, M., Wagner, J., Obloh, H., Schlotter, P., Schmidt, R., Herres, N. & Kaufmann, U. (1999) J. Appl Phys., 86, 4400. [83] Schubert, E.F., Goepfert, I.D., Grieshaber, W. & Redwing, J.M. (1997) Appl Phys. Lett., 71, 921. [84] Casey, H.C. & Stem, F. (1976) J. Appl Phys., 47, 631. [85] Zeng, K.C., Lin, J.Y., Jiang, H.X. & Yang, W. (1999) Appl Phys. Lett., 74, 3821. [86] Pakua, K., Wojdak, M., Palczewska, M., Suchanek, B. & Baranowski, J.M. (1998) MRS Internet J. Nitride Semicond. Res., 3, 34. [87] Look, D.C., Reynolds, D.C., Hemsky, J.W., Sizelove, J.R., Jones, R.L. & Molnar, R.J. (1997) Phys. Rev. Lett., 79, 2273. [88] Neugebauer, J. & Van de Walle, C.G. (1994) Phys. Rev. B, 50, 8067. [89] Yang, Q., Feick, H. & Weber, E.R. (2003) Appl Phys. Lett., 82, 3002. [90] Jenkins, D.W. & Dow, J.D. (1989) Phys. Rev. B, 39, 3317. [91] Moore, W.J., Freitas, J.A., Jr., Lee, S.K., Park, S.S. & Han, J.Y. (2002) Phys. Rev. B, 65, 081201R. [92] Oila, J., Kivioja, J., Ranki, V., Saarinen, K., Look, D.C., Molnar, R.J., Park, S.S., Lee, S.K. & Han, J.Y. (2003) Appl Phys. Lett., 82, 3433. [93] Mattila, T. & Nieminen, R.M. (1996) Phys. Rev. B, 54, 16676. [94] Kucheyev, S.O., Williams, J.S., Jaegadish, C , Li, G. & Pearton, S.J. (2000) /. Appl Phys., 76, 3899. [95] Frazier, R.M., Stapleton, J., Thaler, G.T., Abemathy, C.R., Pearton, S.J., Rairigh, R., Kelly, J., Hebard, F., Nakarmi, M.L., Nam, K.B., Lin, J.Y., Jiang, H.X., Zavada, J.M. & Wilson, R.G. (2003) J. Appl Phys., 94, 1592. [96] Nepal, N., Nam, K.B., Nakarmi, M.L., Lin, J.Y., Jiang, H.X., Zavada, J.M. & Wilson, R.G. (2004) Appl Phys. Lett., 84, 1090. [97] Suski, T., Perlin, P., Teisseyre, H., Leszczynski, M., Grzegory, I., Jun, J., Bockowski, M., Porowski, S. & Moustakas, T.D. (1995) Appl Phys. Lett., 67, 2188. [98] Tu, L.W., Lee, Y.C., Chen, S.J., Lo, I., Stocker, D. & Schubert, E.F. (1998) Appl Phys. Lett., 73, 2802. [99] Kwon, Y.H., Shee, S.K., Gainer, G.H., Park, G.H., Hwang, S.J. & Song, J.J. (2000) Appl Phys. Lett., 76, 840. [100] Skrome, B.J., Jayapalan, J., Vaudo, R.P. & Phanse, V.M. (1999) Appl Phys. Lett., 74, 2358. [101] Neugebauer, J. & Van de Walle, C.G. (1996) Appl Phys. Lett., 69, 503. [102] Stampfl, C. & Van de Walle, C.G. (1998) Appl Phys. Lett., 72, 459. [103] Saarinen, K., Laine, T., Kuisma, S., Nissila, J., Hautojarvi, P., Dobrzynski, L., Baranowski, J.M., Pakula, K. & Porowski, S. (1997) Phys. Rev. Lett., 79, 3030. [104] Schubert, E.F., Goepfert, I.D. & Redwing, J.M. (1997) Appl Phys. Lett., 71, 3224. [105] Oila, J., Ranki, V., Kivioja, J., Saarinen, K., Hautojarvi, P., Likonen, J., Baranowski, J.M., Pakula, K., Suski, T., Leszczynski, M. & Grzegory, I. (2001) Phys. Rev. B, 63, 045205. [106] Saarinen, K., Suski, T., Grzegory, I. & Look, D.C. (2001) Phys. Rev. B, 64, 233201.
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics
181
107] Youngman, R.A. & Harris, J.H. (1990) /. Am. Ceram. Soc, 73, 3238. 108] Nam, K.B., Nakarmi, M.L., Li, J., Lin, J.Y. & Jiang, H.X. (2003) Appl. Phys. Lett., 83, 878. 109] Smith, M., Chen, G.D., Lin, J.Y., Jiang, H.X., Salvador, A., Kim, W., Aktas, O., Botchkarev, A. & Morkoc, H. (1996) Appl. Phys. Lett., 68, 1883. 110] Skierbiszeski, C , Suski, T., Leszczynski, M., Shin, M., Skowronski, M., Bremser, M.D. & Davis, R.F. (1999) Appl. Phys. Lett., 74, 3833. I l l ] Zeisel, R., Bayerl, M.W., Goennenwein, S.T.B., Dimitrov, R., Ambacher, O., Brandt, M.S. & Stutzmann, M. (2000) Phys. Rev. B, 61, R16283. 112] Adivarahan, V., Simin, G., Tamulaitis, G., Srinivasan, R., Yang, J. & Asif Khan, M. (2001) Appl. Phys. Lett., 79, 1903. 113] Nam, K.B., Li, J., Nakarmi, M.L., Lin, J.Y. & Jiang, H.X. (2002) Appl. Phys. Lett., 81, 1038. 114] Cantu, P., Keller, S., Mishra, U.K. & DenBaars, S.P. (2003) Appl. Phys. Lett., 82, 3683. 115] Zhu, K., & Nakarmi, M.L., et al., to be published. 116] Taniyasu, Y., Kasu, M. & Kobayasu, N. (2002) Appl. Phys. Lett., 81, 1255. 117] Nakarmi, M.L., et al., to be published. 118] Saxler, A., Look, D.C., Elhamri, S., Sizelove, J., Mitchel, W.C, Sung, CM., Park, S.S. & Lee, K.Y. (2001) Appl. Phys. Lett., 78, 1873. 119] Casey, H.C. & Stem, F. (1976) /. Appl. Phys., 47, 631. 120] Nam, K.B., Nakarmi, M.L., Li, J., Lin, J.Y. & Jiang, H.X. (2003) Appl. Phys. Lett., 83, 2787. 121] Meyer, B.K., Volm, D., Graber, A., Alt, H.C, Detchprohm, T., Amano, A. & Akasaki, I. (1995) Solid State Commun., 95, 597. 122] Look, D.C & Molnar, R.J. (1997) Appl. Phys. Lett., 70, 3377. 123] Tanaka, T., Watanabe, A., Amano, H., Kobayashi, Y., Akasaki, I., Yamazaki, S. & Koike, M. (1994) Appl. Phys. Lett., 65, 593. 124] Akasaki, I. & Amano, H. (1991) Mater. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc, 242, 383. 125] Suzuki, M., Nishio, J., Onomura, M. & Hongo, C (1998) /. Cryst. Growth, 189/190, 511. 126] Sugiura, L., Suzuki, M., Nishio, J., Itaya, K., Kokubun, Y. & Ishikawa, M. (1998) Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 1, 3878 Part 1. 127] Nam, K.B., Nakarmi, M.L., Li, J., Lin, J.Y. & Jiang, H.X. (2003) Appl. Phys. Lett., 83, 878. 127] Li, J., Oder, T.N., Nakarmi, M.L., Lin, J.Y. & Jiang, H.X. {2002) Appl. Phys. Lett., 80, 1210. 128] Smith, M., Chen, G.D., Lin, J.Y., Jiang, H.X., Salvador, A., Kim, W., Aktas, O., Botchkarev, A. & Morkoc, H. (1996) Appl. Phys. Lett., 68, 1883. 129] Zeisel, R., Bayerl, M.W., Goennenwein, S.T.B., Dmitrov, R., Ambacher, O., Brandt, M.S. & Stutzmann, M. (2000) Phys. Rev. B, 61, R16283. 130] Majewski, J.A., Stadele, M. & Vogl, P. (1997) Mater. Res. Soc. Symp Proc, 449, 887. 131] Hang, D.R., Chen, C.H., Chen, Y.F., Jiang, H.X. & Lin, J.Y. (2001) /. Appl. Phys., 90, 1887. 132] Langer, J.M. & Heinrich, H. (1985) Phys. Rev. Lett., 55, 1414. 133] Nam, K.B., Li, J., Kim, K.H., Lin, J.Y. & Jiang, H.X. (2001) Appl. Phys. Lett., 78, 3690. 134] Li, J.Z., Lin, J.Y., Jiang, H.X., Salvador, A., Botchkarev, A. & Morkoc, H. (1996) Appl. Phys. Lett., 69, 1474. 135] Mireles, F. & UUoa, S.E. (1998) Phys. Rev. B, 58, 3879. 136] Akasaki, I. & Amano, H. (1997) Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 36, 5393 Part I. 137] Fischer, S., Wetzel, C , Haller, E.E. & Meyer, B.K. (1995) Appl. Phys. Lett., 67, 1298. 138] Suzuki, M., Uenoyama, T. & Yanase, A. (1995) Phys. Rev. B, 52, 8132. 139] Chen, G.D., Smith, M., Lin, J.Y., Jiang, H.X., Wei, S.-H., Asif Khan, M. & Sun, C.J. (1996) Appl. Phys. Lett., 68, 2784. [140] Katayama-Yoshida, H., Kato, R. & Yamamoto, T. (2001) J. Cryst. Growth, 231, 438.
182
Optoelectronic
Devices:
Ill-Nitrides
[141] Wongchotigul, K., Chen, N., Zhang, D.P., Tang, X. & Spencer, M.G. (1996) Mater. Lett., 26, 223. [142] Wongchotigul, K., Chen, N., Zhang, D.P., Tang, X. & Spencer, M.G. (1996) Mater. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc, 395, 279. [143] Arulkumaran, S., Sakai, M., Egawa, T., Ishikawa, H., Jimbo, T., Shibata, T., Asai, K., Sumiya, S., Kuraoka, Y., Tanaka, M. & Oda, O. (2002) Appl. Phys. Lett., 81, 1131. [144] Zhang, B., Egawa, T., Ishikawa, H., Liu, Y. & Jimbo, T. (2004) /. Appl. Phys., 95, 3170. [145] Chitnis, A., Zhang, J.P., Adivarahan, V., Shatalov, M., Wu, S., Pachipulusu, R., Mandavilli, V. & Asif Khan, M. (2003) Appl Phys. Lett., 82, 2565. [146] Zhang, J.P., Chitnis, A., Adivarahan, V., Wu, S., MandavilH, V., Pachipulusu, R., Shatalov, M., Simin, G., Yang, J.W. & Asif Khan, M. (2002) Appl. Phys. Lett., 81, 4910. [147] Yasan, A., McClintock, R., Mayes, K., Shiell, D., Gautero, L., Darvish, S.R., Kung, P. & Razeghi, M. (2003) Appl. Phys. Lett., 83, 4701. [148] Fischer, A.J., Allerman, A.A., Crawford, M.H., Bogart, K.H.A., Lee, S.R., Kaplar, R.J., Chow, W.W., Kurtz, S.R., Fullmer, K.W. & Figiel, J.J. (2004) Appl. Phys. Lett., 84, 3394. [149] Fan, Z.Y., Lin, J.Y. & Jiang, H.X. (2004) Proceedings of the International Symposia (Stateof-the-Art Program on Compound Semiconductors XL), 2004-02, The Electrochemical Society, p. 24. [150] Shibata, Y., Kaya, K., Akashi, K., Kanai, M., Kawai, T. & Kawai, S. (1995) /. Appl. Phys., 77, 1498. [151] Emanetoglu, N.W., Patounakis, G., Liang, S., Gorla, C.R., Wittstruck, R. & Lu, Y. (2001) IEEE Trans. Ultrason. Ferroelectr. Freq. Control, 48, 1389. [152] leki, H., Tanaka, H., Koike, J. & Nishikawa, T. (1996) Microwave Low Insertion Loss SAW Filter by Using ZnO/Sapphire Substrate with Ni Dopant, vol. 2, IEEE, New York, pp. 409 -412. [153] Sato, K., Umino, S., Tsubouchi, K. & Mikoshiba, N. (1985) Low Temperature Growth of Epitaxial AIN Films on Sapphire, vol. 1, IEEE, New York, pp. 192-197. [154] Assouar, M.B., Elmazria, O., Le Brizoual, L., Belmahi, M. & Alnot, P. (2002) Growth of Piezoelectric Aluminium Nitride for Layered SAW Devices, IEEE, New York, pp. 333-336. [155] Shibata, T., Hori, Y., Asai, K., Nakamura, Y., Tanaka, M., Kaigawa, K., Shibata, J. & Sakai, H. (2000) Proceedings, IEEE Ultrasonics Symposium, San Juan, Puerto Rico, 22-25 October, IEEE, New York, p. 287. [156] Tomobechi, S., Kameda, S., Masu, K. & Tsubouchi, K. (1998) Proceedings, IEEE Ultrasonics Symposium, Sendai, Japan 5-8 October, IEEE, New York, p. 73. [157] Larson, J.D., Ruby, R.C., Bradley, P.D., Wen, J., Kok, S. & Chien, A. (2000) Proceedings, IEEE Ultrasonics Symposium, San Juan, Puerto Rico, 22-25 October, IEEE, New York, p. 859. [158] Lanz, R., Dubois, M. & Muralt, P. (2001) Proceedings, IEEE Ultrasonics Symposium, Atlanta, Georgia, 7-10 October, IEEE, New York, p. 843. [159] Takagaki, Y., Santos, P.V., Wiebicke, E., Brandt, O., Schonerr, H.P. & Ploog, K.H. (2002) Appl Phys. Lett., 81, 2538. [160] Okano, H., Tanaka, N., Takahashi, Y., Tanaka, T., Shibata, K. & Nakano, S. (1994) Appl Phys. Lett., 64, 166. [161] Okano, H., Tanaka, N., Shibata, K. & Nakano, S. (1993) Jpn. J. Appl Phys., 32, 4052. [162] Lakin, K.M., McCarron, K.T. & McDonald, K.T. (2000) Proceedings, IEEE Ultrasonics Symposium, San Juan, Puerto Rico, 22-25 October, IEEE, New York, p. 855. [163] Tsoubuchi, K. & Mikoshiba, N. (1985) IEEE Trans. Sonics Ultrason., SU-32, 634. [164] Taniyasu, Y., Kasu, M. & Makimoto, T. (2004) Appl Phys. Lett., 84, 2115.
AIN Epitaxial Layers for UV Photonics
183
[165] Benjamin, M.C., Wang, C , Davis, R.F. & Nemanich, RJ. (1994) Appl. Phys. Lett., 64, 3288. [166] Grabowski, S.P., Schneider, M., Nienhaus, H., Monch, W., Dimitrov, R., Ambacher, O. & Stutzmann, M. (2001) Appl Phys. Lett., 78, 2503. [167] Boroditsky, M., Gontijo, I., Jackson, M., Vrijen, R., Yablonovitch, E., Krauss, T., Cheng, C.C, Scherer, A., Bhat, R. & Krames, M. (2000) /. Appl Phys., 87, 3497. [168] Aleksiejunas, R., Sudzius, M., Malinauskas, T., Vaitkus, J., Jarasiunas, K. & Sakai, S. (2003) Appl Phys. Lett., 83, 1157.
optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides M. Razeghi and M. Henini (Eds.) © 2004 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Chapter 8
Properties of III-V Nitrides Substrates and Homoepitaxial Layers Jaime A. Freitas Jr. Naval Research Laboratory, Electronic Science and Technology Division, Electronic Materials Branch, Washington, DC 20375, USA
8.1. INTRODUCTION The unique combination of extreme values of fundamental physical and chemical properties rank the III-V nitride semiconductor system as one of the most promising material systems for the fabrication of a variety of optical and electronic devices capable of performing at extreme conditions of power, frequency, temperature, and in harsh environments. Despite the remarkable improvement in the quality of thin heteroepitaxial GaN and AIN films achieved in the last decade, their properties are still seriously limiting the performance of devices demanding higher material yields, e.g. laser diodes and highfrequency/power devices. The high growth temperature usually required to produce these wide bandgap materials exacerbates fundamental material problems such as residual stress, difference in thermal expansion coefficient, low energy defect formation, and impurity incorporation. In addition, doping activation and self-compensation are difficult to control at the typically high deposition temperatures. Overcoming these limitations will require the use of native substrates to grow electronic grade homoepitaxial layers. Nominally unintentional doped (UID) heteroepitaxial GaN films, deposited commonly on sapphire or SiC, are partially compensated and have room temperature net free-electron concentrations typically between ~ 5 X 10^^ and ~ 1 X 10^^ electrons/cm^. These films can be doped with Mg to reproducibly achieve p-type conductivity with concentration in the lower 10^^ holes/cm^ range [1]. The control of the conductivity type led to the fabrication and commercialization of a number of optical devices, despite the high concentration of dislocations (typically between 10^ and 10^^ cm~^), the limitation on the hole concentration, and the lack of identification and further reduction of the background donor concentration. A number of models were suggested to explain the large background concentration of free-electrons observed in UID heteroepitaxial GaN films. Previous
E-mail address:
[email protected] (J.A. Freitas, Jr.).
185
186
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
calculations have indicated that the nitrogen vacancy (Ny) could behave as the active shallow donor in GaN [2]. Basically, a Ny would form a void surrounded by four Ga atoms contributing with three electrons, from which two of them will reconstruct leaving a single electron available for conduction. However, more recent first-principles calculation results have shown that the formation energy of Ny is too high to allow the incorporation of such a high concentration of donors during the growth [3]. Detailed electronic transport studies of electron irradiated samples showed conclusively that the binding energy of Ny donor is considerably higher than that observed for shallow donors in UID films [4]. Although impurities such as oxygen and silicon have been considered as the potential pervasive shallow donors in GaN, only recently detailed experimental work had identified the chemical nature of the these donors [5]. Despite the considerable progress accomplished lately for the growth of bulk AIN, large area bulk AIN is not fully developed and commercialized yet. Previously, low-temperature (amorphous) and high-temperature (polycrystalline) thin (< 1000 A) AIN films were employed mostly as intermediated layers (nucleation/buffer layers) for GaN heteroepitaxial growth on sapphire and SiC, respectively [6-9]. Increasing interest on optical devices operating at deep-UV wavelength range has motivated the material scientists to grow high-quality AIN heteroepitaxial layers [10-12]. AIN has been deposited by both MOC VD and MBE techniques, and more recently by hydride vapor phase epitaxy (HVPE) [13-15]. Surface preparation and structural properties of heteroepitaxial AIN have been investigated in detail [16,17]. Plan view and cross-sectional TEM studies verified that the dislocation density of these heteroepitaxial layers are typically between ~ 1 X 10^ and 2 X 10^^ cm~^, which are close to the values commonly observed in heteroepitaxial GaN films [18]. Typically, UID AIN films are insulators. Research on carbon doping of AIN indicates that p-type conductivity with hole mobility of 60 cm^fV s was achieved for a doping level of ~ 10^^ cm~^ [19]. n-Type conductivity has been reported for Si-doped AIN films with electron concentration of about 1 X 10^^ cm~^ [20]. Attempts to increase the free-electron concentration resulted in lower net carrier concentration, which suggests that self-compensation is dominant at high doping levels. The potential difficulties on controlling the electrical properties of AIN substrates may indicate that this material will be more suitable for passive applications such as substrates for optical devices and highfrequency devices based on ternary or quaternary alloys with high Al content. Considering that AIN has the same crystallographic structure as GaN, it may be an adequate substrate option to replace sapphire and/or SiC for heteroepitaxial growth. As summarized in Table 8.1, except for the lower thermal conductivity value as compared to SiC, AIN seems to be a foreigner substrate of choice for GaN epitaxial growth. This chapter will review the status of growth of bulk and thick freestanding (FS) III-V nitride substrates and their structural, optical, and electronic properties, and their potential application as substrates for epitaxial growth.
Properties of III- V Nitrides Substrates and Homoepitaxial Layers
187
Table 8.1. Comparison between some properties of GaN and commonly used substrates Material Parameter
GaN
AIN
AI2O3
Si
6H-SiC
ZnO
Aa/fl (%)
0 1.7 [22] 2.1 [23] 3.1 [30]
-2.4 2.85 [24]
- 1 6 [21] 0.25 [25]
- 1 7 . 6 [21] 1.56 [26]
-1.9 0.54 [29]
3.48 [31]
5.0 [25]
2.616 [32]
-3.5 4.9 [27] 3.9 [28] 4.46 [33]
K (W/cm K)
4.75 [34]
8.2. GROWTH OF III-NITRIDE SUBSTRATES The III-V nitrides or Ill-nitrides semiconductors crystallize in the wurtzite structure and cubic structures such as zinc blende (sphalerite) or rock salt. The thermodynamically stable structures are wurtzite for bulk AIN, GaN, and InN and zinc blende for BN. The rock salt structure is stable only at elevated pressures [35-37]. The cubic zinc blende phase of GaN and InN are metastable and have been realized only in thin heteroepitaxial layers deposited on highly mismatched substrates (OOl)-oriented, e.g. GaAs, InAs, MgO, Si, and p-SiC [38-43]. Ill-nitrides cannot be grown from the stoichiometric melts by well-established techniques such as Czochralski or Bridgman because of the extremely high melting temperatures and very high decomposition pressures for nitrogen, as indicated in Table 8.2. Therefore, crystal growers across the world have modified or adapted different methods requiring lower temperatures and pressures to grow Ill-nitride semiconductors. 8.2.1 Growth of Bulk and Thick-film GaN There are several techniques under development for producing bulk GaN crystals including vapor phase transport, growth from supercritical fluids, and growth from flux [49-53]. However, only high-pressure-high-temperature (High nitrogen Pressure Solution technique, HPS) and HVPE methods have produced large area substrates, which will be discussed in detail in this chapter. Unseeded GaN hexagonal platelets or needles (the latter formed at higher supersaturation conditions) have been grown by the HPS method from gallium melts saturated Table 8.2. Melting conditions for Ill-nitrides semiconductors Material AIN GaN InN
T (K), theory
PN^ (kbar)
~ 3500 [44] - 2 8 0 0 [46] - 2 2 0 0 [44,45]
0.2 [45] 45 [47,48] 60 [45]
188
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
with 1 at.% nitrogen at temperatures up to 1700°C and nitrogen pressures of 20kbar [54-56]. The supersaturation in the growth solution is achieved by the application of a temperature gradient of 2-20°C/cm along the axis of the crucible. The nitrogen dissolves at the hotter end of the crucible and the GaN crystallizes at the cooler end. For a typical process duration of 150-200 h relatively thin (—300 |xm thick) hexagonal platelets are grown with a rate of <0.1 mm/h, in the{ 1010} directions (perpendicular to c-axis), with maximum lateral dimensions up to 10 mm X 14 mm. The mechanism hindering the lateral growth of the platelets after 150-200 h can be related to changes in the mass transport mechanisms in the solution due to the presence of the crystal [57]. The (0002) XRD rocking curve full width at half maximum (FWHM) of these crystals are typically between 30 and 40 arcsec showing the presence of low angle (1-3 arcmin) boundaries separating grains of 0.5-2 mm in size [58]. High-resolution transmission electron microscopy studies indicate that threading dislocations commonly observed in heteroepitaxial GaN films are not detected in the HPS bulk GaN. Planar defects such as stacking faults and dislocation loops are present in large concentrations on the crystal basal plane, mostly at the rough side of the crystal (the initial growth surface, where the density can be as high as 10^ cm~^), but their concentrations reduce drastically with increasing film thickness [59]. Growth of crack free UID GaN films with thickness ranging from 100 to 300 |xm on two-inch c-plane sapphire substrates using the HVPE technique have been reported by a number of research groups [60-62]. The substrates are placed on a 1030°C horizontal susceptor in a hot-wall HVPE reactor. Ga metal and HCl are pre-reacted to form GaCl gas, which is transported by nitrogen carrier gas to the hot growth-zone where it reacts with NH3 and deposits GaN on the (0001) sapphire substrate. For a V/III ratio from 20 to 35, a growth rate between 30 and 100 |xm/h can be reproducibly achieved. These thick layers can be removed from the sapphire substrates by laser-assisted lift-off (248 nm line of KrF laser, with 20 ns pulse width and 50 Hz pulse rate). A laser beam energy density of 0.2-0.3 J/cm^ was enough to release the nitrogen from the film forming a thin layer of liquid Ga at the film/substrate interface. To prevent fractures induced by the wafer bowing during the laser lift-off process, the GaN/sapphire templates were kept hot at a temperature below the decomposition temperature [60]. The growth surfaces of the FS GaN templates are extremely rough with large number of hillocks, and so they are inadequate for homoepitaxial growth. Flat, smooth surfaces are obtained after mechanical polishing, which introduces subsurface damage extending up to 4000 A below the surface. The polished growth surfaces (Ga-face) are reactive ion etched (RIE) to remove the damage [61]. Efficient chemical-mechanical polishing process of the growth surface is still in development. GaN (0002) XRD reflections obtained from the FS-UID HVPE-GaN wafers were measured at both surfaces (growth and interface) and with different wafer orientations for beam widths of 500 and 100 |xm in order to establish the source of the rocking curves broadening. The reflection intensities versus angle of the sample scanned with the 500 [xm
Properties of III-V Nitrides Substrates and Homoepitaxial Layers
189
beam at the growth surface and the interface, measured with two orientations rotated 90° around the c-axis in reference to the cleavage plane, resulted in asymmetric lines with FWHM values between 633 and 721 arcsec, clearly showing multi-components contribution [63]. Note that these values are nearly identical, indicating that they are independent of the surface and orientation of the wafer. Measurements performed with 100 |jLm beam width results in sharp symmetric lines with 56 and 162 arcsec for the front and back surfaces, respectively, as shown in Figure 8.1 [63]. From the difference in the horizontal scales used in the plots, we conclude that the irregular broadening observed with the larger beam is due mostly to the larger number of imperfections seen by the beam. The range of angular variations and mosaicity is effectively limited to within the region of a single grain, such that the observed broadening in this case characterizes the mosaicity within the grain. The dislocation density of these substrates is typically < 10^ cm~^ [61]. Thick HVPE GaN substrates have also been realized on GaAs (111) using a two-step growth process, which basically is accomplished by depositing a low temperature 50 nm thick GaN buffer layers prior to the growth of the high-temperature film deposited at 1000°C. These GaN films can be easily removed from the substrates by selective etching. Films with 100 iJim of thickness have typical X-ray rocking curve FWHM of 4.7 min and dislocation density of < 10'^ cm~^ [64]. A number of techniques have been modified to use seeds in the attempt to increase crystal growth rate. HPS grown GaN platelets have been successfully used as substrates for subsequent re-growth in the c-axis ((0001)) direction by HPS and HVPE methods [65]. 1.2
1.0
"T
1
\
1
1
J—I \
1
\
1
p
"1~~^—I
I
I
I
I
I
I
GAN FS-HVPE Sample#2
2 0.6
0.4 h
Front
0.2 h 0
,i^^^^^^*^^
-600 -500 -400 -300 -200 -100 0
100 200 300 400 500 600
Relative Crystal Angle (arc-sec) Figure 8.1. X-ray rocking curves measured with 100 jxm beam width. Note the large difference on the FWHM between the spectrum acquired in the growth surface and the interface side of the FS-HVPE GaN substrate (after Ref. [63]).
190
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
Growth rates of about 10 and 50 ixm/h were achieved on the Ga-polar (0001) face of the substrates using HPS and HVPE techniques, respectively. Samples grown by both methods resulted in substrates with fewer than 100 dislocations/cm^. Recently, recrystallization of GaN powder using FS-HVPE substrates seeds have been accomplished by using powder precursors mixed with molten inorganic salt-fluxes at high-pressure and high-temperature conditions [66]. Samples of 15 mm X 18 mm size with dislocation densities lower than 100 cm~^ were produced. Another approach to synthesize larger GaN samples employed the fast growth rate characteristic (over 100 juum/h) of the HVPE technique and selected FS-HVPE substrate, to realize GaN boules longer than 3 nmi in length. Wafers cut from these boules typically show (0004) X-ray rocking curve FWHM of 38 arcsec and dislocation density less than 10"^ cm~^ [67]. 8.2,2 Growth of Bulk and Thick-film AIN Bulk AIN crystals have been produced by sublimation, vaporization, and solution routes [68]. The nitrogen vapor pressure over AIN is six orders of magnitude lower than over GaN, which makes it possible to grow bulk crystals at atmospheric or subatmospheric pressure [69]. Due to the excessively high melting point, estimated over 2800°C, AIN cannot be grown from the melt. AIN has been successfully grown by sublimation, but the high reactivity of aluminum gas at high sublimation temperatures (typically around 2000°C) cause problems with regards to AIN purity and crucible stability [70-72]. The largest crystal dimensions previously reported was of 470 mm^ [72,73]. In this technique, the AIN precursor, prepared by direct reaction of aluminum powder and nitrogen at 1850°C, was sealed in a tungsten crucible and an unseeded multi-grain crystal grew at the rate of 0.3 mm/h at 2250°C in a nitrogen atmosphere. Samples produced by sublimationrecondensation technique are continuously improving. Boules of 15 mm diameter, grown at a 0.99 mm/h rate, are easily reproduced. These boules contain grains exceeding 1 cm, which typically show X-ray rocking curves with FWHM of around 100 arcsec or less and dislocation density less than 10"^ cm"^ [74-76]. Recently, crystals with X-ray rocking curve of FWHM less than 10 arcsec and dislocation densities of 800-1000 cm~^ have been fabricated [77]. Bulk growth techniques that minimize the effects associated with container reactions and impurity inclusions are highly desirable. Bulk AIN crystals with centimeter-sized areas have been fabricated using RF energy, oscillating at frequencies between 450 kHz and 4 MHz at power levels up to 100 kW, to directly heat the precursor kept at pressures over 100 atm to prevent decomposition. Crystals with X-ray rocking curve with FWHM of 27 arcsec have been produced [78]. Polycrystalline AIN boules of 1.25-in. diameter with centimeter-sized crystals have also been fabricated by vapor phase technique in a RF heated reactor, under a 600 Torr nitrogen atmosphere, in the temperature range between 2000 and 2400°C. Growth rate of 0.3 mm/h was achieved under these conditions [79]. Large boules of AIN crystals, with 25 mm diameter and 15 nmi in length, have been
Properties of III-V Nitrides Substrates and Homoepitaxial Layers
191
fabricated by physical vapor transport technique using AIN powder and N2 gas as precursors, in the temperature range between 2100 and 2250°C and pressure between 200 and SOOTorr [80]. Microprobe analyses indicate that these crystals are free of residual impurities such as carbon and oxygen. X-ray rocking curve studies show a single line with FHHM value of 0.08°. Large area, ranging from 0.5 to 1.75 in. diameter, thick (0001) AIN films have been deposited on Si and/or SiC substrates by HVPE technique, and chemically removed from the substrates [81]. These FS films were used as seeds to grow AIN boules of few millimeters of thickness. Wafers of 200-500 ijum of thickness were sliced from the boules. After lapping and polishing, selected wafers were used again as seeds for the growth cycle to improve the boules crystalline quality. The typical value of the X-ray rocking curve FWHM of the (0002) reflection is of 700 arcsec, using a wide (10 mm X 1 mm) X-ray beam [82]. Spontaneous nucleated AIN crystals can also be grown from the single precursor A1C13-NH3. This process requires several successive steps, namely, the synthesis of A1C13-NH3, the evaporation and transport to a reaction chamber and the decomposition and growth of single crystal AIN. The dry A1C13-NH3 is obtained by a sequence of few processing steps. Initially, dry AICI3 is produced after heating pure Al powder in dry HCl flow. The AICI3 is saturated with ammonia at 150°C to form a polyammoniate polycrystalline powder with composition AlCl3-(1.5-2.5NH3). The polyammoniate is slowly heated in He flux at 417-420°C to distill the white monoammoniate powder. The distilled A1C13-NH3 precursor powder is placed in the cold zone of a two-zone quartz tube reactor. The temperature of the evaporator is increased up to 300-320°C to produce A1C13-NH3 vapor subsequently transported by hydrogen or helium carrier gas to the hotter zone to decompose the A1C13-NH3 and grow the AIN crystals. AIN platelets with hexagonal cross-section (up to ~4naLm^ and 150 juim thick) are spontaneously nucleated on graphite or quartz substrates in the temperature range between 1300 and 1400°C. A detailed discussion of the growth technique has been reported elsewhere [83]. The AIN (0002) XRD reflections obtained from various samples fabricated from monoammoniate, using a beam width of 500 |xm, show symmetric lines with FWHM between 36 and 54 arcsec. Figure 8.2 shows an XRD line with FWHM of 36 arcsec measured on one hexagonal platelet with an area of about 3 mm^ [84]. The small FWHM value and the high intensity of the single-line indicate the high single-crystalline quality of this sample.
8.3.
STRUCTURAL PROPERTIES OF III-NITRIDES SUBSTRATES
The lattice parameters of semiconductors are affected by factors such as stoichiometry, excess of free-carriers, high concentration of point and extended defects, external stresses
192
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides 10.0 [ AIN (decomposition) Sample#2 7.5
CO
O
^5.0 36 arc-sec
2.5
-300
-200
-100
0
100
200
300
Relative Crystal Angle (arc-sec) Figure 8.2.
Room temperature first-order polarized Raman scattering spectra of a ~ 167 iJim thick FS-HVPE GaN substrate (after Ref. [84]).
(e.g. heteroepitaxial layers), etc. Therefore, Ill-nitride lattice parameters are still not completely determined. Lattice parameters values acquired from samples fabricated by different techniques are listed in Table 8.3, illustrating the effects of the material quality on its lattice parameter values. Ideal wurtzite structure is characterized by lattice parameter ratio (c/a) and w-parameter value (u = bic, where b is the bond-length in the c-direction) of 1.633 and 0.375, respectively [91]. The deviation from this ideal arrangement occurs with changing of da ratio and/or the M-parameter. Although deviations from the ideal arrangement are often observed in the wurtzite structure, the correlation between the da and the M-parameter is kept: if da decreases, than the u value increases in such a way that the four tetrahedral distances remain nearly constant and the tetrahedral angles are distorted [92]. Compounds characterized by larger departure from the ideal da ratio show greater differences in Table 8.3. Lattice parameter of wurtzite AIN and GaN fabricated by different techniques Crystal (description) AIN (bulk) AIN (powder) AIN (on SiC) GaN (homoepitaxial layer on bulk GaN:Mg) GaN (bulk, 5 X 10^^ electrons/cm^) GaN (powder) GaN (on sapphire)
a{k)
^(A)
Reference
3.1106 3.1130 3.110 3.1885 3.1890 3.1893, 3.190 3.1892
4.9795 4.9816 4.980 5.1850 5.1864 5.1851, 5.190 5.1850
[85] [86] [87] [87] [88] [86,89] [90]
Properties of III-V Nitrides Substrates and Homoepitaxial Layers
193
Table 8.4. Structural parameters of potential GaN substrates Material AIN GaN ZnO
c/a
u
.601 [93] .627 [93] .6024 [91]
0.385 [91] 0.377 [91] 0.345 [91]
the electronegativities [92,93]. Only wurtzite structures with c/a ratio lower than the ideal value of 1.633 are stable. These structural parameters for GaN, and AIN and ZnO, potential substrates for GaN epitaxial grown, are listed in Table 8.4. Note that the w-parameter for GaN is very close to its ideal value, while AIN is above and ZnO is below this value. The Ill-nitrides commonly have their faces perpendicular to the c-axis. These faces are polar with either nitrogen or gallium termination. There has been a considerable controversy in regards the identification of GaN face polarities [94,95]. Presently, there is a common agreement that the nitrogen-terminated face is chemically active, whereas the gallium-terminated face is inert. Therefore, the face polarity can be easily identified by selective chemical etching techniques [96]. The hexagonal (2H) phase of GaN and AIN (wurtzite structure belonging to the space group C^^ or P6^mc) has two molecules per unit cell. Group theory predicts eight zonecenter optical modes, namely lAi(TO), lAi(LO), 25i, l£:i(TO), 1J&I(LO), and 2^2. The two BY modes are optically inactive, but all of the six allowed modes have been observed by Raman spectroscopy [97,98]. The first order Raman scattering (RS) spectra of a FS-HVPE GaN sample measured at room temperature for different sample orientations and light polarizations are represented in Figure 8.3. Using sample orientation and polarization selection rules for the incident and scattered light we measured the first order Raman spectra with the Z{X,XY)Z, Y{Z,XZ)Y, and Y{X,XZ)Y symmetries, as represented in Figure 8.2 by Porto's notation [99]. The Raman shift for the allowed modes Ai(TO), £i(TO), El, Ai(LO) and £i(LO) are 534, 559, 569,734, and 740 cm~\ respectively. Analyses of the peak positions and linewidths of the observed first order phonons confirm the good crystalline quality and lower biaxial stress of the wurzite FS-HVPE GaN substrates [63]. RS spectra of a number of GaN samples fabricated by HPS method also show most of the optical phonons expected for the 2H-GaN polytype. However, due to the high background concentration of free-electrons in these samples, the Ai(LO) mode is replaced by a new mode resulting from the interaction between the Ai(LO) with the conduction electron plasmons [100]. High-quality AIN crystals fabricated by thermodecomposition of aluminum chloride monoammoniate, was used to study the first order RS spectra of AIN. Figure 8.4 shows the Raman spectra measured at two different sample orientations and light polarizations. The Raman fines for the allowed modes Ai(TO), £:i(TO), El, Ai(LO) and £i(LO) are
194
Optoelectronic Devices: IILNitrides
GaN FS-HVPE Sample#2
'^exc =514.5 nm
I A^(LO) o
10^'
10^" 300
400
500
600
700
800
900
Raman Shift (cm''')
Figure 8.3. XRD reflection of the c-plane AIN fabricated from monoammoniate precursor (sample#2) measured with beam width of 500 jjim (after Ref. [63]).
observed at 608.5, 667.2, 655.1, 888.9, and 909.6 cm~ , respectively. The peak positions and relatively small linewidths of the phonon lines indicate that this low-temperature growth process can fabricate low defect and stress-free crystals. A complete discussion of the RS study will be presented elsewhere [101].
8.4.
OPTICAL AND ELECTRONIC PROPERTIES OF III-NITRIDE SUBSTRATES
Wurzite GaN has the conduction band minimum at the center of the Brillouin zone (F-point, k = 0), and has a r7-symmetry with a quantum number J^ = 1/2. The valence band of 2H-GaN has its maximum also at the F-point, which results in a direct fundamental bandgap. As result of the crystal-field (4cr) and spin-orbit {A^Q) coupling, the top of the valence band splits into three sub-bands with symmetries Fg, F-j^^^^^^, and F'^IQ^^J.^ which are traditionally labeled A, B, and C, respectively [102-108]. There is a considerable disagreement on the value of the fundamental bandgap due to residual strain within the individual samples, which causes a considerable large variation in the value of A^rIn addition, uncertainty in the Rydberg value to be added to the exciton energy increases the uncertainty of the fundamental bandgap energy. Assuming the thick HVPE GaN is stress-free and using a Rydberg value of 24 ± 3 meV the low-temperature bandgap of 2H-GaN has been estimated to be 3.499 ± 6 eV [109].
Properties of III-V Nitrides Substrates and Homoepitaxial Layers
195
zouu X(Z,YZ)X 2000- AIN decomposition 2 +2 Sample#2 ^2 o 1500O Ai(TO) 2 1000-
Ei(TO)
1\ Jli
Ei(LO)
1
500-
p i
'^
NlMyi«ii.i»<(l>ifrtl^***^
n ^lf<)w^*|*»w*^<Ml»^>wn|<^*f»W•^l'«|'>"*''*'**l^<>W'"'V*^#'^ 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 7000_
6000-
1 o ^
5000 -
>^
1
E2|
Z(Y,XY)Z AIN decomposition Sample#2
^
4000-
3000-
0)
1
20001000-
Ai(LO)
E2^ 1
>
L
,,.A-
— 1 — 1 — 1 — 1 — 1 — 1 — 1 — 1 — 1 — 1 — 1 — 1 — 1 — 1 — 1
02()0 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 Raman Shift [c;m-i]
Figure 8.4. Room temperature polarized Raman spectra of bulk AIN grown by thermodecomposition of AICI3NH3. The letters inside the parentheses represent the incident and the scattered light polarization, while the letters outside of the brackets represent the direction of the incident and scattered light (after Ref. [101]).
Reported calculations of AIN generally agree that the A^^ is negative and promotes the ^7upper band to higher energy than the Tg band. However, there is a considerable disagreement with regard to the calculated values for effective masses (m* between 0.27 and 0.35mo, and m^ between 1.54 and 1.62mo), crystal field, and spin-orbit splitting [103,107,110]. There is also a considerable discrepancy in the measured values of the dielectric constant of AIN [111,112]. However, we can estabUsh lower and upper bound values for the free-exciton energy of 37 and 70 meV, respectively. Thus, assuming that the bandgap at low temperature is 6.12 eV, we expect to observe excitons in the spectral range between 6.05 and 6.08 eV [84,113]. 8.4.1 Bulk and Thick-film GaN Bulk GaN crystals grown by HPS method are typically n-type and degenerate, with temperature-independent carrier concentration and mobilities typically between
196
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
10^^-10^^ cm"^ and 30-90 cm^A^ s, respectively [100]. This result is consistent with the strong LO-phonon/conduction electron-plasmons couphng mode observed in the Raman spectra [100]. Oxygen is assumed to be the shallow donor responsible for the observed high concentration of free-electron [114]. The low-temperature PL spectra of such samples typically show an intense broad band with peak around 2.25 eV and a weelc and relatively broad bandedge emission near 3.5 eV [115]. The large shift of the edge emission results from the large concentration of free carriers causing the semiconductor-metal transition, or the so-called Bumstein-Moss effect [116,117]. Unintentionally doped thick FS-HVPE GaN films are also typically n-type, but with much lower background free-electron concentration than HPS bulk GaN. Detailed electrical transport experiments yield a room temperature carrier mobility of 1245 cm^A^s and a carrier concentration of 6.7 X 10^^ cm~^ for an acceptor concentration of 1.7 X 10^^ cm"^ [118]. Assuming an ideahstic reduction of two orders of magnitude of the background donors and acceptors, to keep the same compensation level, the maximum mobility at room temperature is expected to reach 1350 cm^fV s [118]. Low-temperature PL spectra of similar UID FS-HVPE GaN films typically show intense recombination emission lines associated with annihilation of excitons bound to neutral donors (X-D^) and their phonon replicas (nLO-XD^). Also commonly observed are weak zero-phonon lines from shallow-donor/shallow-acceptor pairs (DAP) recombination and their phonon replicas (nLO-DAP). Broad luminescence bands observed below 3.0 eV are discussed elsewhere [119]. Figure 8.5 shows the PL spectra of a ~12|jLm thick heteroepitaxial film (sample#l) from reactor 1 and a ~ 150 [xm thick FS film (sample#2) from reactor 2. The spectrum of sample#2 shows, in the 3.52-3.46 eV region, emission lines related to the excited state of the free-exciton A (FX^), the ground state of the freeexciton B (FXB), the ground state of the free-exciton A (FXj^), and the dominant exciton bound to a neutral donor (X-D^). Around 3.45 eV we detect the so-called two-electron satellite (2ES) spectrum resulting from the recombination processes in which the neutral donors are left in an excited state after the exciton annihilation. Note that for energies below 3.42 eV we observe the one-phonon replicas of all features listed above. The PL spectrum of sample#l, dotted line, shows most of the features observed in the spectrum of sample#2. However, these features are broader and smeared, and shifted to higher energy due to inhomogeneous broadening and compressive strain, respectively, caused mostly by the substrate [120]. Figure 8.6 shows four PL spectra of sample#2 measured with higher resolution (bandpass < 100 fieV) at 5 K under several laser excitation intensities, as indicated in the figure. The dominant features in all spectra are emissions associated with the recombination of ground-state excitons bound to neutral donors (often designated I2, or X-D^) centered around 3.4714(2) eV (all energy values are corrected for index refraction of air). The dominant peak is composed of three peaks at 3.4714(4), 3.4718(9), and 3.4722(8) eV (average values obtained from a number of measurements), assigned to A excitons bound to different neutral donors [121]. To identify the chemical nature of these
Properties of III-V Nitrides Substrates and Homoepitaxial Layers
10^
105
197
GaN FS-HVPE Sample#2 6K
o CD
104
^ w
103
5^
102
10^
10°
3.34
3.38
3.42 3.46 Energy (eV)
3.50
3.54
Figure 8.5. PL spectra (6 K) of a —12 ijum heteroepitaxial film (sample#l) and of a —150 |xm thick freestanding film (sample#2). The presence of a variety of sharp excitonic lines in this spectral region indicates the high crystalline quality of both samples (after Ref. [120]).
3.465 3.470 3.475 3.480 3.485 Energy (eV) Figure 8.6. High-resolution and low-temperature PL spectra of the sample#2 in Figure 8.3 measured with different laser power densities. The line assignments are discussed in the text (after Ref. [121]).
198
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
three background donors, high-resolution IR absorption and high sensitivity SIMS measurements were carried out on the same set of samples characterized by high resolution PL spectroscopy [122]. Figure 8.7 shows the low-temperature IR absorption spectra for sample#l (dotted line) and sample#2 (continuous line). The shallowest and not fully compensated donor, Nl, is dominant in sample#l, while the deepest observed donor, N2, is present at higher concentrations in sample#2. A third shallow donor, N3, is observed only in sample#2. Assigning the dominant spectral lines to ls-2p transitions, the values 30.19 ± 0.1, 33.21 ± 0.1, and 31.23 ± 0.1 meV are obtained for the ground state binding energies of donors Nl, N2, and N3, respectively [122]. The 0.3 meV shift of the peak positions of Nl and N2 in sample#l to higher energy as compared with sample#2 results from the biaxial strain in the heteroepitaxial sample#l. High sensitivity SIMS measurements were performed to identify the atomic nature of these donors. Special concern was dedicated to the SIMS impurity background and references for each tested impurity. C, CI, H, O, Si, and S impurity levels were measured. The detected concentrations of O and Si are ~ 2.4 X 10^^ and ~ 1.2 X 10^^ cm~^ for sample#l (heteroepitaxial layer), and ~ 2.1 X 10^^ and ~ 3.7 X 10^^ cm~^ for sample#2, respectively. The concentration of O in both samples is about the same, while sample#l has about 34 times more Si than sample#2.
0.6 FS-HVPE GaN Sample#2
18
20
22 24 26 Energy (meV)
28
30
Figure 8.7. FTIR transmission spectra of sample#l and sample#2. Note the change in the relative intensity of the Hnes Nl and N2. The unidentify transition at 19.3 meV, marked with "?" has been assigned to widely separated pairs or triads (after Ref. [122]).
Properties of III-V Nitrides Substrates and Homoepitaxial Layers
199
The integrated absorption coefficients (IAC) for donors Nl and N2 are, respectively, 10,177 and 1918 for sample#l and 302 and 1931 for sample#2. It is important to point out that the IAC for N2 is about the same for both samples, while the Nl IAC is approximately 34 times larger for sample#l than sample#2. These results, since none of the other investigated impurities tested by SIMS are consistent with the IR results, indicate that the shallow donors Nl and N2 observed in our HVPE samples are Si and O, respectively [122]. Assuming a similar lAC for N3 (D?), a concentration of 2.1 X lO^'^cm"^ is obtained. This extremely small value confirms the high sensitivity of FTIR spectroscopy to detect background impurities. The three PL lines at 3.4714(4), 3.4718(9), and 3.4722(8) eV, represented in Figure 8.6, based on the FTIR and SIMS results, are assigned to A excitons bound to O, D?, and Si neutral donors, respectively. This identification is consistent with the linear dependence between exciton binding energies and impurity binding energies, which follows the empirical Haynes rule with linear coefficient of 0.214 [120,123]. In addition, the Si and oxygen impurity binding energies measured from the 2ES spectra are in excellent agreement with the IR binding energy values [124]. Although n-type bulk substrates are convenient for optical devices fabrication, semiinsulating (SI) substrates are most desirable for high-frequency devices fabrication. Material scientists have employed different approaches, adequate for each growth techniques, to reduce the background carrier concentration by controlling the growth conditions and/or doping with impurities to provide the necessary concentration of compensating centers. Degenerated HPS bulk GaN substrates, doped during the growth with Mg, show increasing resistance with increasing doping concentration. For concentrations between 10^^ and 10^^ cm~^ resistance was observed to be as high as 10^ fl at about 600 K [125]. Infrared transmission measurements performed in such samples show no free-carrier absorption and improved optical properties. Nominally undoped FS-HVPE GaN, which are also typically n-type with background carrier concentration < 1 X 10^^ cm~^, can be grown SI by using intentionally introduced transition metal impurities during the growth to compensate the residual donors. Iron concentration lower than 1 X 10^^ cm~^ are sufficient to compensate unintentionally incorporated impurity and native defects. The resistivity of such samples measured at 250°C was 3 X 10^ fl cm and at room temperature was estimated as 2 X 10^ fl cm [126]. Zn doping, with concentration ranging between 10^^ and 10^^ cm~^, was also successfully employed to grown SI GaN films with resistivity 10^^ n cm at 300 K and 10^ fl cm at 500 K [127]. 8.4.2 Bulk and Thick-film AIN Despite the large concentration of residual oxygen in AIN grown by sublimationrecondensation, typically between 3 X 10^^ to 1 X 10^^ cm~^, it is still SI at room
200
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides AIN sublimation 5K
5 keV, 3 \xA
Energy (eV) Figure 8.8. CL spectrum (5 K) of an a-plane AIN sample fabricated by sublimation-recondensation technique. The nature of NBE and the two broad emission bands are discussed in the text (after Ref. [130]).
temperature. This is due to the fact that most of the oxygen is not incorporated as a substitutional shallow donor, but as impurity forming complexes with point and extended defects, which are located deep in the gap and behaving as compensating centers [128, 129]. AIN wafers grown by HVPE show a typical resistivity exceeding 10^ H cm at room temperature and 10^ fl cm at 500 K [82]. Figure 8.8 shows the low-temperature cathodoluminescence (CL) spectrum from 2.0 eV to approximately 6.2 eV of the a-face AIN sample OOG of Ref. [130], which has a considerable low oxygen content. In addition to an intense sharp emission near-bandedge (NBE) around 6.0 eV, two broad and featureless bands with peaks near 3.5 eV (VB) and 4.4 eV (UVB) are also observed, which have been previously associated with oxygen impurities [128,129]. The high-resolution CL spectrum of the sample represented in Figure 8.8 is highlighted in Figure 8.9. The continuous line represents the best fit to the experimental data, represented by the open circles, using Lorentzian line shapes. The intensity and the sharpness of the lines attest to the high crystalline quality of the sample. Thermoionization studies of the recombination processes in the spectral range represented in Figure 8.9 strongly suggests that the most intense line at 6.010 eV is associated with the annihilation of FXA bound to a shallow neutral impurity with an exciton binding energy of about 15 meV [130]. The Hues at 6.026 and 6.041 eV are observed up to 150 K, which may be related to the annihilation of free excitons [130]. Figure 8.10 shows the low-temperature CL spectra of sample#2, grown by thermodecomposition of aluminum chloride monoammoniate, in the spectral range between 2.0 and 6.2 eV. The spectrum measured with a 0.5 (A e-beam current shows two
Properties of III-V Nitrides Substrates and Homoepitaxial Layers
201
350
5.98
Figure 8.9.
6.00
6.02 Energy (eV)
6.04
6.06
High-resolution CL spectra of the sublimation AIN sample represented in Figure 8.8. The assignments of the NBE lines are discussed in the text (after Ref. [130]).
broad overlapping bands with peaks at 3.6 and 4.3 eV. Note the similarity of all these spectral features with that observed in the CL spectrum of the sublimation sample. The spectra measured with 1.0 and 5.0 |JLA currents show an additional band at 5.3 eV, whose origin is not understood [84]. Figure 8.11 shows the high resolution CL spectrum in
10"^ AIN (decomposition)
^m
sample#2
O 10^
3.0
3.5
4.0 4.5 Energy (eV)
5.0
Figure 8.10. Low-temperature CL of a c-plane AIN (sample#2) measured at three different electron beam currents. The spectra between 2.0 and 4.1 eV were corrected with a calibrated light source to removed instrumental response (after Ref. [84]).
202
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides lU
i
1
'
1
'——
1
'
r
'
1 —^
1
• AIN decomposition «- 10^ r sample#2 ; 5keV, 2|iA
•
3
M
^o 102 -
'
5K 40K 60K 80 K 90K
°
c
IF' ft*
0
\
• 1 = -
:
u4
^ 10^ _l O
E
. ^^\.ij
-
jfen'-^
.
|R^/\*\ A ' y ° \ ^ °o
t^° °o \ HE
10°
do a,
1
5.96
,
\
5.98
._
1
.
1
6.00 6.02 Energy (eV)
1
1
6.04
.
'
1
" ^ ^ ^
6.06
6.08
Figure 8.11. High-resolution CL spectra of sample#2 measured at different temperatures. The assignments of the NBE hnes are presented in the text (after Ref. [84]).
the NBE spectral region measured at various temperatures of the thermodecomposition sample. The spectra show the expected systematic reduction of the CL intensity upon increasing temperature from 5 to 90 K. Note that the intensity of the line at 6.0089 eV reduces at a faster rate than that of the lines at 6.0250 and 6.0363 eV. This behavior is commonly observed in recombination processes involving complexes, such as excitons bound to neutral impurities, where one of the components (i.e. the exciton) has lower binding energy. Based on this observation and the similarity of these spectra with that of GaN, the line at 6.0089 eV is assigned to a recombination process associated with the annihilation of exciton bound to a shallow neutral impurity (probably a donor, XD^, due to the small energy value), while the lines at 6.0250 and 6.0363 eV are assigned to recombination processes associated with the annihilation of FX. The value of the FX binding energy to the shallow donor is given by the slope, Ex/kT, of the exponential quenching curve at the highest temperatures (i.e. 17.76 meV), and it is consistent with the 16.10 meV separation between the XD^ and FXA lines [84]. The asymmetry at the lower energy side of the XD^ line may indicate the presence of an additional line at 6.0058 meV, resolved assuming Lorentzian line shapes in the spectral fitting, which may be associated to a second shallow donor. The major difference of the lowest temperature spectrum of Figure 8.11 as compared with the spectrum in Figure 8.9 is the relative intensity of the three major bands. This observation suggests a pervasive character of the shallow donors associated with the NBE emission bands in bulk AIN. Therefore, a more systematic study is required to access the intrinsic material properties.
Properties of III-V Nitrides Substrates and Homoepitaxial Layers
203
CL measurements performed in samples fabricated by RF assisted vapor phase technique and HVPE show the same spectral features observed in the CL spectra of samples grown by sublimation and thermodecomposition. This observation strongly supports the idea of pervasive impurities incorporation in AIN independent of the growth technique [79,82].
8.5. OPTICAL AND ELECTRONIC PROPERTIES OF HOMOEPITAXIAL III-NITRIDE FILMS
The viability of improved quality bulk and thick FS films of GaN and AIN substrates open the possibility to fabricate high-quality device grade homoepitaxial layers and ternary and quaternary epitaxial alloy layers for the fabrication of high-performance and high-yield devices. 8,5.1 Homoepitaxial GaN Films Epitaxial films have been deposited on bulk HPS GaN substrates by MBE, using surface cracked ammonia as nitrogen precursor, and MOCVD methods [131,132]. Detailed lowtemperature PL and reflectance measurements were performed on the MOCVD film to identify the nature of the lines observed in the NBE spectral region [132]. The lines assigned to the recombination process involving excitons bound to shallow donors have FWHM of about 100 |xeV, indicating the high crystalline quality of the homoepitaxial layer. X-ray diffraction experiment performed on similar structures indicates that the homoepitaxial film has lower lattice parameter c than the substrate, which typically has room temperature free-carrier concentration in excess of 5 X 10^^ cm~^ [133]. UID and Si-doped (< 1 X 10^^ electrons/cm^) homoepitaxial layers were deposited on FS-HVPE GaN substrates with nominal surface roughness of about 5 nm by low-pressure OMCVD. Films with thicknesses of about 5 |xm are characterized by growth surface roughness of about 0.2 nm RMS and reduced thread dislocation density, as compared with the substrate [134]. The full-gray line spectra of Figure 8.12 marked as HOMO-UID, measured on the UID homoepitaxial film, shows a reduction of the total intensity of the neutral donor-bound exciton related emissions and a relative decrease in the intensity of the free-exciton line. The lower energy side of the neutral donor-bound exciton emission band is also reduced, suggesting that the dominant donor is at the highest energy side of this band. This is consistent with the reduction in the concentration of the neutral background in the UID homoepitaxial layer. The PL spectrum of this Si-doped layer is characterized by a larger increase in the high-energy side of the neutral donor-bound excitons indicating that Si is in fact the shallower donor in GaN [134]. These results further strengthen the identifications of O and Si proposed in Refs. [117,118].
204
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
Homo-layers: unintentional doped (UID) 33%Si doped
3.460 3.465 3.470 3.475 3.480 3.485 3.490
Energy (eV) Figure 8.12. High-resolution PL spectra of tow MOCVD films, an UID and a Si-doped GaN, deposited on FS-HVPE substrates. The assignments of the lines associated with excitonic recombination processes are discussed in the text (after Ref. [134]).
8,5,2 Homoepitaxial AIN Films UID homoepitaxial films deposited by MOCVD on high-quality AIN substrates misaligned 10° from the c-axis, with a nominal thickness of 0.5 |xm, have been investigated by variable-temperature high-resolution CL spectroscopy. The NBE CL spectrum measured at 5 K, represented in Figure 8.13, show six individual lines assigned
5.98
6.00 6.02 Energy (eV)
6.04
Figure 8.13. High-resolution CL spectra of a MOCVD AIN film deposited on a sublimation AIN substrate. The details of the line assignments are presented in the text (after Ref. [135]).
Properties of III-V Nitrides Substrates and Homoepitaxial Layers
205
to recombination processes involving the annihilation of free-excitons and excitons bound to neutral donor and acceptor impurities. These assignments rely on detailed thermal quenching studies [130]. These lines are considerably narrower than those previously observed in the substrate, which indicates the higher structural and optical properties of the homoepitaxial layer [135]. UID homoepitaxial HVPE films of about 2 fim have also been successfully deposited on wafers grown by HVPE. The increased ratio of the intensity of NBE emission lines to the intensity of the deep emission bands of the homoepitaxial layer in comparison with the ratio of these bands in the HVPE substrates strongly suggests the improved quality of the homoepitaxial layers [80].
8.6.
CLOSING REMARKS
A number of techniques have been used to evaluate the morphological, structural, optical and electronic properties of bulk and thick FS-HVPE films of AIN and GaN grown by a number of techniques for substrates application. Similar studies carried out on homoepitaxial layers deposited on some of these substrates indicate that films with improved structural, optical, and electrical properties could be realized. However, epitaxial-ready surface is still an important issue to be addressed in detail. Chemicalmechanical polishing and reactive ion etching has been used to achieve epitaxial ready surface with 0.3-0.5 nm RMS of roughness, but these processes have not been fully developed yet [67,77,136-139]. The well-estabhshed technology for the fabrication of LEDs on sapphire and SiC ensures that these substrates will remain as the substrate of choice for the foreseeable future. Therefore, bulk or quasi-bulk Ill-nitride substrate may play a role in the fabrication of devices that require high power density and low leakage current such as LD and high-frequency and/or high-power devices. The limited size of the Ill-nitride substrates and their present high commercial cost are serious limiting factors for a generalized use of these substrates for the fabrication of optical and electronic devices. Presently, an increasing numbers of R&D institutions are seeking commercialization of AIN and GaN substrates grown by a variety of techniques. It is expected that in the longterm, after a few growth techniques and associated processes are fully developed, the cost will drop and high-quality substrates will be available, as realized in other semiconductor material systems.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This work was in part supported by ONR contracts N0001401WR20178 and N0001401WR20015 (Dr C.E.C. Wood). Dr S.K. Lee, Dr D.D. Koleske, Dr L.M. Ivanova,
206
Optoelectronic
Devices:
Ill-Nitrides
Dr L J . Schowalter, and Prof. G.A. Slack are gratefully acknowledged for providing the samples. I am thankful to Dr E.R. Glaser and Dr B. Feigelson for helpful discussions.
REFERENCES
[20 [21 [22:
[23 [24;
Nakamura, S. (1992) Jpn. J. Appl Phys., 31, L139. Jenkins, D., Dow, J.W. & Tsai, M.-H. (1992) J. Appl Phys., 76, 4130. Van de Walle, C , Stampfl, C. & Neugebauer, J. (1998) J. Cryst. Growth, 189/190, 505. Look, D., Reynolds, D.C., Hemsky, J.W., Sizelove, J.R., Jones, R.L. & Molnar, R.J. (1997) Phys. Rev. Lett., 79, 2273. Moore, W.J., Freitas, J.A., Jr., Braga, G.C.B., Molnar, R.J., Lee, S.K., Lee, K.Y. & Song, LJ. (2001) Appl. Phys. Lett., 79, 2570. Yoshida, S., Mizawa, S. & Gonda, S. (1983) Appl. Phys. Lett., 42, 427. Amano, H., Sawaki, N., Akasaki, I. & Toyoda, T. (1986) Appl. Phys. Lett., 48, 353. Nakamura, S. (1991) Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 30, L1705. Weeks, W., Bremser, M.D., Ailey, K., Carlson, E., Perry, W. & Davis, R.F. (1995) Appl. Phys. Lett., 61, 401. Walker, D., Zhang, X., Kung, P., Saxler, A., Javadpour, S., Xu, J. & Razhegi, M. (1996) Appl. Phys. Lett., 68, 2100. Yasan, A., McCUntock, R., Mayes, K., Shiell, D., Gautero, L., Darvish, S.R., Kung, P. & Razhegi, M. (2003) Appl. Phys. Lett., 83, 4701. Mayes, K., Yasan, A., McClintock, R., Shiell, D., Darvish, S.R., Kung, P. & Razhegi, M. (2004) Appl. Phys. Lett., 84, 1046. Morita, M., Ueugi, N., Isogai, S., Tsuboushi, K. & Mikoshiba, N. (1981) Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 20, 17. Yoshida, S., Mizawa, S., Fujii, Y., Takada, S., Hayada, H., Gonda, S. & Itoh, A. (1979) /. Vac. Sci. Technol, 16, 990. Melnik, Yu., Tsvetkov, D., Pechnikov, A., Nikitina, I., Kuznetsov, N. & Dmitriev, V. (2001) Phys. Stat. Sol. (a), 188, 463. Jasinski, J., Liliental-Weber, Z., Paduano, Q.S. & Weybume, D.W. (2003) Appl. Phys. Lett., 83,2811. Wu, Y., Hanlon, A., Kaeding, J.F., Sharma, R., Fini, P.T., Nakamura, S. & Speck, J.S. (2004) Appl. Phys. Lett., 84, 912. Liliental-Weber, Z., Sohm, H., Newman, N. & Washburn, J. (1995) /. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 13, 1578. Wongchotigul, K., Chen, N., Zang, D.P., Tang, X. & Spencer, M.G. (1996) Mater. Lett., 26, 223. Taniyasu, Y., Kasu, M. & Kobayashi, N. (2002) Phys. Stat. Sol. (b), 234, 845. Liu, L. & Edgar, J.H. (2000) Mater. Sci. Eng. R, 37, 61. Krukowski, S., Leszczynski, M. & Porowski, S. (1999) Gallium Nitride and Related Semiconductors, EMIS Datareviews Series No. 23, Eds. Edgar, J. H., Strite, S., Akasaki, I., Amano, H. & Wetzel, C , INSPEC, IFF, Lodon, pp. 21. Florescu, D.I., Asnin, V.M., Pollak, F.H., Jones, A.M., Ramer, J.C., Schurman, M.J. & Fergunson, I. (2000) Appl. Phys. Lett., 11, 1464. Slack, G.A. (1973) J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 34, 321.
Properties of III- V Nitrides Substrates and Homoepitaxial
Layers
207
[25] Belyaev, L.M. (1980) Ruby and Sapphire, American Publishing Co., New Delhi, p. 1; translated from Russian, Rubin Isaphir, Nauka Publishers, Moscow, 1974. [26] Wyboume, M.N. (1999) in Properties of Crystalline Silicon, Ed. Hull, R., lEE, London, p. 165. [27] Slack, G. (1964) /. Appl Phys., 35, 3460. [28] Burgemaister, E.A., Von Muench, W. & Pettenpaul, E. (1979) J. Appl. Phys., 50, 5790. [29] Madelung, O. Ed. (2004) Semiconductors: Data Handbook, S"""^ Edition Springer, Berlin, p. 198. [30] Leszczynski, M., Suski, T., Perlin, P., Teisseyere, H., Grzegory, I., Bockowski, M., Jun, J., Porowski, S. & Major, J. (1995) /. Phys. D: Appl Phys., 28, A149. [31] Madelung, O. Ed. (2004) Semiconductors: Data Handbook, Springer, Berlin, p. 89. [32] Soma, T. & Kagaya, H.-M. (1999) in Properties of Crystalline Silicon, Ed. Hull, R., lEE, London, p. 153. [33] Bagdasarov, Kh.S., Dobrovinskaya, E.R., Pishchik, V.V., Chemik, M.M., Yu, Yu., Gershun, A.S. & Zvyagintseva, I.E. (1973) Sov. Phys. Crystallogr, 18, 242. [34] Madelung, O. Ed. (2004) Semiconductors: Data Handbook, 3""^ Edition Springer, Berlin, pp. 196, [32]. [35] Perlin, P., Jauberthie-Carillon, C., Itie, J.P., Miguel, A.S., Grzegory, I. & Polian, A. (1992) Phys. Rev. B, 45, 83. [36] Ueno, M., Onodera, A., Shimomura, O. & Takemura, K. (1992) Phys. Rev. B, 45, 10123. [37] Ueno, M., Yoshida, M., Onodera, A., Shimomura, O. & Takemura, K. (1994) Phys. Rev. B, 49, 14. [38] Mizuta, M., Fujieda, S., Matsumoto, Y. & Kawamura, T. (1986) Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 25, L945. [39] Lima, A.P., Tabata, A., Leite, J.R., Kaiser, S., Schkora, D., Schottker, B., Frey, T., As, D.J. & Lischka, K. (1999) J. Cryst. Growth, 201/202, 396. [40] Tabata, A., Lima, A.P., Teles, L.K., Scolfaro, L.M.R., Leite, J.R., Lemos, V., Schottker, B., Frey, T., Schkora, D. & Lischka, K. (1999) Appl. Phys. Lett., 74, 362. [41] Powel, R.C., Lee, N.E., Kim, Y.W. & Green, J.E. (1993) J. Appl. Phys., 73, 189. [42] Lei, T., Fanciulli, M., Molnar, R.J., Moustakas, T.D., Graham, R.J. & Scanlon, J. (1991) Appl. Phys. Lett., 59, 944. [43] Paisley, M.J., Sitar, Z., Posthill, J.B. & Davis, R.F. (1998) /. Vac. Sci. Technol. A, 1, 701. [44] Van Vechten, J.A. (1973) Phys. Rev. B, 7, 1479. [45] Grzegory, I., Krukowski, S., Jun, J., Boaekowski, M., Wroblewski, M. & Porowski, S. (1994) AlP Conf Proc, 309, 565. [46] Class, W., (1968) Contract Rep. NASA-Cr-1171. [47] Karpinski, J., Jun, J. & Porowski, S. (1984) /. Cryst. Growth, 66, 1. [48] Karpinski, J., Jun, J. & Porowski, S. (1984) /. Cryst. Growth, 66, 11. [49] Vodakov, Yu.A., Mokov, E.N., Roenkov, A.D., Boiko, M.E. & Baranov, P.G. (1998) J. Cryst. Growth, 183, 10. [50] Kraler, G., Zachara, J., Podsiadlo, S., Adamowicz, L. & Gebicki, W. (2000) J. Cryst. Growth, 1\1, 39. [51] Dwilinski, R., Doradzinski, R., Garczynski, J., Sierzputowski, L., Baranowski, J.M. & Kaminska, M. (1998) Diamond Relat. Mater, 1, 1348. [52] Yoshikawa, A., Ohshima, E., Fukuda, T., Tsuji, H. & Oshima, K. (2004) /. Cryst. Growth, 260, 67. [53] Aoki, M., Yamane, H., Shimada, M., Sarayama, S., Iwata, H. & DiSalvo, F.J. (2004) /. Cryst. Growth, 266, 461.
208 [54] [55] [56] [57] [58]
[59]
[60] [61] [62] [63] [64] [65] [66] [67] [68] [69] [70] [71] [72] [73] [74] [75] [76] [77] [78]
[79]
Optoelectronic
Devices:
Ill-Nitrides
Porowski, S. (1996) J. Cryst. Growth, 166, 583. Porowski, S. (1998) J. Cryst Growth, 189/190, 153. Grzegory, I. & Porowski, S. (2(XX)) Thin Solid Films, 367, 281. Grzegory, I., Bockowski, M., Lucznik, B., Krukowski, S., Romanowski, Z., Wroblewski, M. & Porowski, S. (2002) /. Cryst. Growth, 246, 177. Grzegory, I. & Porowski, S. (1999) Gallium Nitride and Related Semiconductors, EMIS Datareviews Series No. 23, Eds. Edgar, J. H., Strite, S., Akasaki, I., Amano, H. & Wetzel, C , INSPEC, ffiE, Lodon, pp. 359. Liliental-Weber, Z. (1999) Gallium Nitride and Related Semiconductors, EMIS Datareviews Series No. 23, Eds. Edgar, J. H., Strite, S., Akasaki, L, Amano, H. & Wetzel, C , INSPEC, lEE, Lodon, pp. 230. Kelly, IVI.K., Vaudo, R.P., Phanse, WM., Gogens, L., Ambacher, O. & Stutzmann, M. (1999) Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 38, L217. Park, S.S., Park, Il-W. & Choh, S.H. (1999) Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 38, L217. Paskova, T., Darakchieva, V., Paskov, P.P., Soderwall, U. & IVIonemar, B. (2002) J. Cryst. Growth, 246, 207. Freitas, J.A., Jr., Braga, G.C.B., Moore, W.J., Tischler, J.G., Culbertson, J.C., Fatemi, M., Park, S.S., Lee, S.K. & Park, Y. (2001) J. Cryst. Growth, 231, 322. Kumagai, Y., Murakami, H., Seki, H. & Koukitu, A. (2001) J. Cryst. Growth, 246, 230. Bockowski, M., Grzegory, I., Krukowski, S., Lucznik, B., Romanowski, Z., Wroblewski, M., Borysiuk, J., Weyher, J., Hageman, P. & Porowski, S. (2002) J. Cryst. Growth, 246, 194. D'Evelyn, M.P., Webb, S.W., Vagarali, S.S., Kadiglu, Y., Park, D.-S., Chen, Z., United States Patent Application Patent No.US2003/0183155 Al, October 2, 2003. Xu, X., Vaudo, R.P., Loria, C , Salant, A., Brandes, G.R. & Chaudhuri, J. (2002) /. Cryst. Growth, 246, 223. Slack, G.A. (1998) Mater Res. Soc. Symp. Proc, 512, 35. Chase, M.W. (1998) NIST-JANAF Thermochemical Tables, 4'^ Edition American Chemical Society and American Institute of Physics, p. 130. Cox, G.A., Cummins, D.O., Kawabe, K. & Tredgold, R.H. (1967) J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 28, 543. (a) Krukowska-Fulde, B. & Niemyski, T. (1970) Electron. Technol, 3, 3.(b) Ishii, T., Sato, T. & Iwata, M. (1971) Mineral. J., 6, 323. Slack, G.A. & MacNelly, T.F. (1976) J. Cryst. Growth, 34, 263. Slack, G.A. & MacNelly, T.F. (1977) /. Cryst. Growth, 42, 560. Schwalter, L.J., Susterman, Y., Wang, R., Bhat, I., Arunmozhi, G. & Slack, G.A. (2000) Appl Phys. Lett., 76, 985. Schwalter, L.J., Rojo, J.C, Slack, G.A., Susterman, Y., Wang, R., Bhat, I. & Arunmozhi, G. (2000) J. Cryst. Growth, 211, 78. Rojo, J.C, Slack, G.A., Morgan, K., Raghothamachar, B., Dudley, M. & Schwalter, L.J. (2000) J. Cryst. Growth, 231, 317. Raghothamachar, B., Dudley, M., Rojo, J.C, Morgan, K. & Schowalter, L.J. (2003) J.Cryst. Growth, 250, 244. Nause, J. (1999) Gallium Nitride and Related Semiconductors, EMIS Datareviews Series No. 23, Eds. Edgar, J. H., Strite, S., Akasaki, I., Amano, H. & Wetzel, C , INSPEC, lEE, Lodon, pp. 375. Noveski, V., Schlesser, R., Freitas, J.A., Jr., Mahajan, S., Beaudoin, S. & Sitar, Z. (2003) Mater Res. Soc. Proc, 798, 28.
Properties of III-V Nitrides Substrates and Homoepitaxial
Layers
209
[80] Singh, N.B., Berghamns, A., Zang, H., Wait, T., Clarke, R.C., Zingaro, J. & Golombeck, J.C. (2003) /. Cryst. Growth, 250, 107. [81] Nikolaev, A., Nikina, I., Zubrilov, A., Mynbaeva, M., Melnik, Yu. & Dmitriev, V. (2000) MRS Internet J. Nitride Semicond., 595, W651. [82] Melnik, Yu., Soukhoveev, V., Ivantsov, V., Sizov, V., Pechnikov, A., Tsvetkov, K., Kovalenkov, O., Dimitriev, V., Nikolaev, A., Kuznetsov, N., Silveira, E. & Freitas, J.A., Jr. (2003) / Phys. Stat. Sol. (a), 200, 22. [83] Pletyushkin, A.A. & Slavina, N.G. (1968) hvestyiya Akademii Nauk SSSR Neorg. Mater., 4, 893. [84] Freitas, J.A., Jr., Braga, G.C.B., Silveira, E., Tischler, J.G. & Fatemi, M. (2003) Appl. Phys. Lett., 83, 2564. [85] Tanaka, M., Nakahata, S., Sogabe, K., Nakata, H. & Tabioka, M. (1997) Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 36, L1062. [86] Angerer, H., Brunner, D., Freudenberg, F., Ambacher, O., Stutzmann, M., Hopler, R., Metzger, T., Bom, E., DoUinger, G., Berggmaier, A., Karsch, S. & Komer, H.-J. (1997) Appl. Phys. Lett., 71, 1504. [87] Leszczynski, M., Suski, T., Domagala, J. & Prystawko, P. (1999) Gallium Nitride and Related Semiconductors, EMIS Datareviews Series No. 23, Eds. Edgar, J. H., Strite, S., Akasaki, L, Amano, H. & Wetzel, C , INSPEC, lEE, Lodon, pp. 6. [88] Leszczynski, M., Teisseyre, H., Suski, T., Grzegory, I., Bockowski, M., Jun, J., Porowski, S., Pakula, K., Baranowski, J.M., Foxon, C.T. & Cheng, T.S. (1996) Appl. Phys. Lett., 69, 73. [89] Shintami, A. & Minagawa, S. (1994) /. Cryst. Growth, 22, 1. [90] Detchprohm, T., Hiramatsu, K., Itoh, K. & Akasaki, I. (1992) Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 31, L1454. [91] Wyckoff, R.W.G. (1965) Crystal Structures, 1, Wiley, New York, pp. 111-113. [92] Schulz, H. & Thiemann, K.H. (1977) Solid State Commun., 23, 815. [93] Jeffrey, G.A., Parry, G.S. & IVlozzi, R.L. (1956) / Chem. Phys., 25, 1024. [94] Ponce, F.A., Bour, D.P., Young, W.T., Suanders, M. & Steeds, J.W. (1996) Appl. Phys. Lett., 69, 337. [95] Liliental-Weber, Z., Kisielowski, C , Ruvimov, S., Grzegory, L, Bockowski, M., Jun, J. & Porowski, S. (1996) /. Electron. Mater, 25, 1545. [96] Weyher, J.L., MuUer, S., Grzegory, I. & Porowski, S. (1997) J. Cryst. Growth, 182, 17. [97] Freitas, J.A., Jr. & Khan, M.A. (1994) Mater Res. Soc, 339, 547. [98] Bergman, L., Dutta, M. & Nemanich, R.J. (2000) Raman Scattering in Materials Science. Springer Series in Materials Science, vol. 42, Eds. Weber, W.H. & Merlin, R., p. 273. [99] Porto, S.P.S. (1969) in Light Scattering Spectra of Solids, Ed. Wright, G.B., Springer-Verlag, New York, pp. 1. [100] Perlin, P., Camassel, J., Knap, W., Talercio, T., Chervin, J.C, Suski, T., Grzegory, I. & Porowski, S. (1995) Appl. Phys. Lett., 67, 2524. [101] Tischler, J., Freitas, J.A., Jr. (2004) Appl. Phys. Lett., 85 (11). [102] Gil, B., Briot, O. & Aulombard, R.L. (1995) Phys. Rev. B, 52, R17028. [103] Suzuki, M., Uenoyama, T. & Yanase, A. (1995) Phys. Rev. B, 52, 8132. [104] Shikanai, A., Azuhata, T., Sota, T., Chichibu, S., Kuramata, A., Horino, K. & Nakamura, S. (1997) 7. Appl. Phys., 81, 417. [105] Volm, D., Oettinger, K., Streibl, T., Kovalev, D., Ben-Chorin, M., Diener, J. & Meyer, B.K. (1996) Phys. Rev. B, 53, 16543. [106] Chichibu, S., Azuhata, T., Sota, T., Amano, H. & Akasaki, I. (1997) Appl. Phys. Lett., 70, 2085.
210
Optoelectronic
Devices:
Ill-Nitrides
[107] Kim, K., Lambrecht, W.R., Segall, B. & van Schilfgaarde, M. (1997) Phys. Rev. B, 56, 7363. [108] Chuang, S.L. & Chang, C.S. (1996) Phys. Rev. B, 54, 2491. [109] Gil, B. & Leroux, M. (1999) Gallium Nitride and Related Semiconductors, EMIS Datareviews Series No. 23, Eds. Edgar, J. H., Strite, S., Akasaki, I., Amano, H. & Wetzel, C , INSPEC, lEE, Lodon, p. 65. [110] Wei, S.-H. & Zunger, A. (1996) Appl. Phys. Lett., 69, 2719. [ I l l ] Collins, A.T., Lightowlers, E.C. & Dean, P.J. (1967) Phys. Rev., 158, 833. [112] Jones, D.J., French, R.H., Mullejans, H., Loughin, S., Domeich, A.D. & Carcia, P.P. (1999) J. Mater Res., 14, 4337. [113] Shishkin, Y., Davity, R.P., Choyke, W.J., Yun, P., King, T. & Morkog, H. (2001) Phys. Stat. Sol. (a), 188, 591. [114] Wetzel, C , Suski, T., Ager, J.W., IE, Weber, E.R., Haller, E.E., Fisher, S., Meyer, B., Molnar, R. & Perlin, P. (1997) Phys. Rev. Lett., 78, 3923. [115] Perlin, P., Suski, T., Leszczynski, M. & Teisseyre, H. (1997) Optoelectronic Properties of Semiconductors and Superlattice. GaN and Related Materials, vol. 2, Ed. Pearton, S.J., Gordon & Breach, London, p. 315. [116] Bumstein, E. (1954) Phys. Rev., 93, 632. [117] Moss, T.S. (1954) Proc. Phys. Soc. (London), B76, 775. [118] Look, D.C. & Sizelove, J.R. (2001) App/. Phys. Lett., 19, 1133. [119] Freitas, J.A., Jr., Nam, O.H., Davis, R.F., Saparin, G.V. & Obyden, S.K. (1998) Appl. Phys. Lett., 72, 2990. [120] Freitas, J.A., Jr., Braga, G.C.B., Moore, W.J., Lee, S.K., Lee, K.Y., Song, I.J., Molnar, R.J. & Van Lierde, P. (2001) Phys. Stat. Sol., 188, 457. [121] Freitas, J.A., Jr., Moore, W.J., Shanabrook, B.V., Braga, G.C.B., Lee, S.K., Park, S.S. & Han, J.Y. (2002) Phys. Rev. B, 66, A#233311. [122] Moore, W.J., Freitas, J.A., Jr., Braga, G.C.B., Molnar, R.J., Lee, S.K., Lee, K.Y. & Song, I.J. (2001) Appl. Phys. Lett., 79, 2570. [123] Haynes, J.R. (1960) Phys. Rev. Lett., 4, 361. [124] Moore, W.J., Freitas, J.A., Jr., Lee, S.K., Park, S.S. & Han, J.Y. (2002) Phys. Rev. B, 65, 81201. [125] Staszewska, L., Suski, T., Grzegory, I., Porowski, S., Perlin, P., Robertson, J.L., Contreras, S., Wasik, D., Witowski, A., Cote, D. & Clerjaud, B. (1999) Phys. Stat. Sol. (b), 216, 567. [126] Vaudo, R.P., Xu, X., Salant, A., Malcame, J. & Brandes, G. (2003) Phys. Stat. Sol. (a), 200, 18. [127] Kuznetsov, N.I., Nikolaev, A.E., Zubrilov, A.S., Melnik, Yu.V. & Dmitriev, V.A. (1999) Appl. Phys. Lett., 75, 3138. [128] Slack, G.A., Schowalter, L.J., MorelU, D. & Freitas, J.A., Jr. (2002) /. Cryst. Growth, 246, 287. [129] Youngman, R.A. & Harris, J.H. (1990) /. Am. Ceram. Soc, 73, 3238. [130] Silveira, E., Freitas, J.A., Jr., Slack, G.A. & Schowalter, L.J. (2003) Phys. Stat. Sol. (c), 0, 2618. [131] Mayer, M., Pelzmann, A., Kamp, M., Ebling, K.J., Teisseyre, H., Nowak, G., Leszczynski, M., Grzegory, L, Porowski, S. & Karczewski, G. (1997) Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 36, L1634. [132] Kormitzer, K., Ebner, T., Tonke, K., Sauer, R., Kirchner, C , Schwegler, V., Kamp, M., Leszczynski, M., Grzegory, I. & Porowski, S. (1999) Phys. Rev. B, 60, 1471.
Properties of III-V Nitrides Substrates and Homoepitaxial
Layers
111
[133] Leszczynski, M., Prystawko, P. & Porowski, S. (1999) Gallium Nitride and Related Semiconductors, EMIS Datareviews Series No. 23, Eds. Edgar, J. H., Strite, S., Akasaki, I., Amano, H. & Wetzel, C , INSPEC, TEE, Lodon, pp. 391. [134] Freitas, J.A., Jr., Moore, W.J., Shanabrook, B.V., Braga, G.C.B., Lee, S.K., Park, S.S., Han, J.Y. & Koleske, D.D. (2002) /. Cryst. Growth, 246, 307. [135] Silveira, E., Freitas, J.A., Jr., Kneissl, M., Treat, D.W., Johnson, N.M., Slack, G.A. & Schowalter, L.J. (2004) Appl Phys. Lett., 84, 3501. [136] Weyher, J.L., Mueler, S., Grzegory, L & Porowski, S. (1997) J. Cryst. Growth, 182, 18. [137] Myers, T.H., VanMil, B.L., Holbert, L.J., Peng, C.Y., Stinespring, CD., Alam, J., Freitas, J.A., Jr., Dmitriev, V.A., Pechnikov, A., Shapovalova, Y. & Ivantsov, V. (2002) /. Cryst. Growth, 246, 244. [138] Lee, K. & Auth, K. (2001) Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 40, L13. [139] Schauler, M., Eberhard, F., Kirchner, C , Schwegler, V., Pelzmann, A., Kamp, M., Ebeling, K.J., Bertram, F., Riemann, T., Christen, J., Prystawko, P., Leszczynski, M., Grzegory, I. & Porowski, S. {1999) Appl. Phys. Lett., 74, 1123.
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides M. Razeghi and M. Henini (Eds.) © 2004 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Chapter 9
Ill-nitride Ultraviolet Light Emitting Sources Alireza Yasan and Manijeh Razeghi Center for Quantum Devices, Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Northwestern University, Cook Room 4051, 2220 Campus Drive, Evanston, IL 60208-3129, USA
9.1.
INTRODUCTION
Research on Ill-nitrides started some 80 years ago when the first AIN was synthesized from metallic aluminum [1]. After that, GaN and its family have been grown with various methods and after several breakthroughs, finally blue/violet LEDs were demonstrated. Following the commercialization of blue laser diodes, the interest shifted towards shorter wavelength light emitters, i.e. UV LEDs and laser diodes. From the standpoint of device structure, UV light emitters resemble well-known blue/violet LEDs, i.e. double heterostructure or quantum well (QW) active layer structure. A blue/ violet LED structure can be modified for UV emission by simply decreasing the indium content in the In^cGai-^cN active layer. The minimum wavelength that can be achieved using ternary InGaN active layers is ~ 365 nm. For shorter wavelengths, ternary AlGaN should be used instead of InGaN. To date, a number of groups have demonstrated UV LEDs [2-10] and LDs [11,12] and the quest for high-power devices still continues. Due to the high density of dislocations and doping difficulties, realization of highefficiency UV light emitters is more challenging than that of blue/violet light emitters. In this chapter, we briefly review the growth, processing, and characterization of ultraviolet light emitters based on the Ill-nitride material system, with more emphasis on deep UV LEDs (A < 280 nm), due to the challenges involved. Figure 9.1 presents a timeline of the evolution of Ill-nitride materials and related light-emitting devices.
9.2. THE NEED FOR UV LIGHT EMITTERS There are numerous applications for ultraviolet light emitters. A 360 nm UV laser would cause a fivefold increase in information storage in compact discs. This is due to the inverse relationship between the areal packing and the square of the wavelength.
E-mail address:
[email protected] (A. Yasan).
213
Optoelectronic Devices: Ill-Nitrides
214 Synthesis of AIN from metallic Al
1928
Synthesis of GaN powder (and later on InlN)
1932
Single crystal GaN by HVPE, vapor transport C VD & MBE
h=>
1969
GaNbyMDCVD
1971
= >
1971
Introduction of lowtemperature buffer
First p-type GaN by LEEBI of GaN:Mg
1983
1989
1991
Commercialization of blue lasers (400 nm, 5mW,40mA,5V)
UV laser diodes @ 375 nm (2 mW, 45 mA,4.5V)
AlGaNUVLEDs® 280 nm
Short-wavd ength AlGaN-basedUV laser diodes
1999
2002
2002
Riture
10,000 hrs lifetime RTCWInGaN violet LD
1997
First p-n GaN blue LED
P-type GaN by thermal annealing
First GaN LED (MIS structure, no p-type)
= >
1992
First CWInGaNbased blue-violet LD
1996
Figure 9.1. Timeline of the evolution of IE-nitride materials and related optoelectronic devices.
High-efficiency low-cost white lighting is another major application of UV LEDs that can have an impact on the market in near future. There are three common methods for generation of white light: one method is to combine red, green, and blue (RGB) colors