Optically Amplified WDM Networks
This page intentionally left blank
Optically Amplified WDM Networks
John Zyskind Atul Srivastava
AMSTERDAM BOSTON HEIDELBERG LONDON NEW YORK OXFORD PARIS SAN DIEGO SAN FRANCISCO SINGAPORE SYDNEY TOKYO
Academic Press is an imprint of Elsevier
Academic Press is an imprint of Elsevier 30 Corporate Drive, Suite 400, Burlington, MA 01803, USA 525 B Street, Suite 1900, San Diego, CA 92101-4495, USA 84 Theobald’s Road, London WC1X 8RR, UK First edition 2011 Copyright Ó 2011 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior written permission of the publisher Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Science & Technology Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone (+44) (0) 1865 843830; fax (+44) (0) 1865 853333; email:
[email protected]. Alternatively you can submit your request online by visiting the Elsevier web site at http://elsevier.com/ locate/permissions, and selecting Obtaining permission to use Elsevier material Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN: 978-0-12-374965-9 For information on all Academic Press publications visit our website at books.elsevier.com Printed and bound in USA 11 12 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
For the loving memory of my mother Maya, and to my wife Sonali, daughter Srishti and sister Sushma, with love - Atul Srivastava
Dedicated with love to the memory of my father Professor Harold Zyskind - John Zyskind
This page intentionally left blank
Contents Foreword ...................................................................................................................ix Author Biographies...................................................................................................xi CHAPTER 1
Optical Amplifiers for Next Generation WDM Networks: A Perspective and Overview .......................................................1
CHAPTER 2
ROADM-Based Networks...........................................................23
CHAPTER 3
Challenges and Opportunities in Future High-Capacity Optical Transmission Systems ..................................................47
CHAPTER 4
EDFAs, Raman Amplifiers and Hybrid Raman/EDFAs ....................83
CHAPTER 5
Dynamic and Static Gain Changes of Optical Amplifiers at ROADM Nodes ...................................................................117
CHAPTER 6
Mastering Power TransientsdA Prerequisite for Future Optical Networks....................................................155
CHAPTER 7
Spectral Power Fluctuations in DWDM Networks Caused by Spectral-Hole Burning and Stimulated Raman Scattering ..... 201
CHAPTER 8
Amplifier Issues for Physical Layer Network Control ................221
CHAPTER 9
Advanced Amplifier Schemes in Long-Haul Undersea Systems .................................................................253
CHAPTER 10 Challenges for Long-haul and Ultra-long-haul Dynamic Networks.................................................................277 CHAPTER 11 Transport Solutions for Optically Amplified Networks ............... 297 CHAPTER 12 Optical Amplifier for Maintenance Friendly Fiber Networks....... 341 CHAPTER 13 Low Cost Optical Amplifiers....................................................363 CHAPTER 14 Semiconductor Optical Amplifiers for Metro and Access Networks ............................................................387 CHAPTER 15 Market Trends for Optical Amplifiers.......................................417 Index ......................................................................................................................445
vii
This page intentionally left blank
Foreword Rod Alferness Bell Labs, Alcatel-Lucent The power of light, harnessed with an array of components to generate, modulate, manipulate, and detect it, and supported by low-loss optical fiber for transmission that ushered in a new era of information transmission systems in the 1970s, is an incredible gift to mankind. One could have hardly expected more, butdalmost on queuedthe invention and development of the optical amplifier in the late ’80s and early ’90s completed the technology suite, unleashing the full potential and power of optics for communication networks. The resulting cost-effective, robust, highcapacity optical networks, together with packet-based data networks that ride over them, enabled the world-wide web that has dramatically revolutionized our daily lives. The global growth of WDM (wavelength division multiplexing) optical networks over the last 10 years has been remarkable. While most optical networks are generally not directly visible to the typical consumer, the very visible internet would be impossible without them. Spanning continents, crossing oceans, reaching across metropolitan areas and now also providing direct fiber to home connections, commercially deployed optical transmission systems with per fiber capacity as high as several Terabit/sec provide the enabling high-capacity connectivity that underpins the world-wide web. No longer simple point-to-point links, today’s optical networks are flexible, switchable wavelength routed networks, both ring and mesh, that provide wavelength granular networked pipes inside the physical fiber with alloptical on and off ramps in much the way time slots are used in time-division-based transport networks. None of this would be possible without the optical fiber amplifier. The optical amplifier is truly a gift of nature that is as close to ideal as one could expect. It is spectrally matched to fiber’s low-loss window and provides highly efficient, broadband, low noise gain. Critical for its enabling of WDM, it has a temporal response that allows essentially unlimited signal data rates while allowing multiple wavelengths to be amplified without cross-talk between independent communication signals carried by neighboring wavelengths. The potential of WDM to tap the bandwidth of fiber, without requiring superhigh bit rates and the necessary enabling high-speed electronics, had been well known for some time. But, WDM was not a cost-effective solution for high-capacity systems as long as each wavelength channel had to be separated and regenerated individually by a discrete electronic regenerator. However, the optical amplifier, with its ability to amplify multiple wavelengths simultaneously, first and foremost, made DWDM (dense wavelength division multiplexing) the cost-effective approach to building very-high-capacity optical transmission systems. That capability aloned first demonstrated in commercial products in the mid-1990sdwas revolutionary.
ix
x
Foreword
What at the time was far less obvious to most, even if a few could foresee it, was that in enabling DWDM transmission, the optical amplifier was also preparing the way to a fundamentally new network architecture using wavelengths as the networked parameterdthe common unit of “currency” for enabling and managing a network. These WDM networks, while they also depended on an array of other new technologies, including, most importantly, optical switching elements to build the wavelength add/drop multiplexers and wavelength cross-connect networking elements, depended on optical amplifiers not only to enable WDM transmission but also to compensate for the losses in these switching elements. WDM networks offered the potential to provision, manage, and protect capacity based on wavelength “chunks” via fully flexible, switched wavelength networks. It is these WDM networks that are the focus of this book. While to many this vision appeared far-out, it was actually a very natural consequence of adopting WDM for transmission systems. Nevertheless, a tremendous world-wide research effort was required to provide the knowledge base needed to answer key questions, invent and develop new technologies, and refine and demonstrate the value proposition of WDM networks to convince service providers around the globe to deploy these networks for both long-haul and metro networks. The editors of Optically Amplified WDM Networks, John Zyskind and Atul Srivastava, who played key roles in taking optical networks from a vision to reality, have assembled a group of world-known researchers and engineers to address the critical areas of the field. This comprehensive book covers the broad areas important to WDM networks. From the dynamics of optical amplifiers critical to the inherent power transients in reconfigured networks, to basic (and not basic) amplifier design, to the considerations and design of wavelength add/drop multiplexers, to a perspective of future market trendsdall are well covered. Not limited to fiber amplifiersderbium-doped and Ramandthey also address the potential role of semiconductor amplifiers with its somewhat less ideal temporal characteristics but possible cost advantages, especially when integrated on a single photonic integrated circuit with other optical functions. That role seems particularly interesting for future metro and access applications. This book provides a wealth of information, insight, and reference information presented in many cases by the people who did the original work in the field. As such the book should prove very helpful to researchers and practicing engineers in or entering the field, including students. It is also a useful resource for researchers addressing the next frontier for optical networkingdhigh-speed optical packet switched networksdwhich is expected to benefit from many of the same technologies and is at a stage today that WDM networks were about 15 years ago.
Author Biographies CHAPTER 1. (ATUL SRIVASTAVA AND JOHN ZYSKIND) Atul Srivastava has over 30-years of research and development experience, and is credited with many advances in the field of optics, semiconductor opto-electronics, and high-capacity optical fiber networks. At Bell Laboratories he was responsible for several key inventions in optical amplifiers including the ultra-wideband EDFA, fast gain control in amplifiers and the first demonstration of the 100-channel long distance terabit capacity WDM transmission He facilitated founding of a start-up company, Onetta in 2000 and as the Vice President of Technology at Onetta, led research and development of optical amplifiers and WDM sub-systems. He is currently president of a new technology consulting startup OneTerabit. He is credited with over 100 publications and15 patents and is a recipient of the Bell Laboratories President’s Gold Award, the Trophee du Telephone. He is also a Fellow of Optical Society of America.
[email protected] John Zyskind received his bachelors degree from the University of Chicago and his Ph.D. from the California Institute of Technology where he was a Fannie and John Hertz Fellow. In 1982 he joined Bell Laboratories where he did pioneering research on optical amplifiers for DWDM optical networks, led optical amplifier research for the MONET optical networking program, was named Distinguished Member of Technical Staff and received the Bell Labs President’s Gold Award. Dr. Zyskind has directed the development of commercial Terabit/sec, ultralong haul optical network products at Sycamore Networks and of optically amplified systems for hut skipping applications at Optovia Corporation and JDSU. He is currently Director of System Engineering at Oclaro’s Transport Systems Solutions Division. Dr. Zyskind has published over 200 refereed papers and conference presentations, has delivered 35 invited talks, holds 26 patents and has published two book chapters.. He has taught 18 short courses at OFC and CLEO. Dr. Zyskind is a Fellow of the Optical Society of America.
[email protected]
CHAPTER 2. ROADM BASED NETWORKS (BRANDON COLLINGS AND PETER ROORDA) Brandon Collings has over 15 years of optical networking research, design and development experience at Bell Laboratories, Internet Photonics, Ciena and JDSU.
xi
xii
Author biographies
He is currently the Chief Technology Officer for JDSU where he assists in the development of optical architectures and enabling components and sub-systems for next generation agile optical networks.
[email protected]. Peter Roorda has over 15 years experience in the design and development of agile optical networks and their key subsystems. In various technical roles at Nortel Networks and Innovance Networks, Peter has developed product concepts and architectures for emerging WDM, ROADM, optical amplifier and high speed transmission technologies. Currently at JDSU, Peter is product line manager for ROADM products.
[email protected]
CHAPTER 3. CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES IN FUTURE HIGH-CAPACITY OPTICAL TRANSMISSION SYSTEMS (XIANG LIU) Xiang Liu received his Ph.D. degree in applied physics from Cornell University in 2000. He joined Bell Labs as a member of technical staff in 2000, and has been working on high-speed optical communication technologies since then. Dr. Liu has authored/coauthored over 190 journal and conference papers, and holds over 35 US patents. He is a senior member of the IEEE and the OSA.
[email protected]
CHAPTER 4. OPTICAL AMPLIFIERS: CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES (JOHN ZYSKIND AND MAXIM BOLSHTYANSKY) Maxim Bolshtyansky received the M.S. in physics from Chelyabinsk Technical University, Russia in 1993, and the second M.S. and Ph.D. in optical physics from CREOL at University of Central Florida, Orlando, US in 1999. Since that time, he was working in various engineering and research roles at Lucent Technology, Onetta Inc, and is presently employed by JDSU. His research interests include detailed investigation and modeling of the gain media such as Raman and EDF and control algorithms for telecom applications.
[email protected]
Author biographies
CHAPTER 5. DYNAMIC AND STATIC GAIN CHANGES OF OPTICAL AMPLIFIERS AT ROADM NODES (ETSUKO ISHIKAWA, SETSUHISA TANABE, MASATO NISHIHARA, AND YOUICHI AKASAKA) Etsuko Ishikawa Is currently director of Research at Fujitsu Ltd. Her achievements include development of S-band optical amplifier using silica-based erbium doped fiber; research in spectral hole burning mechanism in erbium doped fiber amplifier.
[email protected] Setsuhisa Tanabe received the BS, MS, and PhD degrees in material chemistry from Kyoto University, Japan, in 1986, 1988, and 1993. He became an Assistant Professor of Kyoto University, where he was promoted to a Full Professor in 2008 at Graduate School of Human and Environmental Studies. He is the author of more than 100 original papers, 22 books, and 23 invited review papers. He is also the holder of 24 patents on rare-earth doped optical amplifiers and glass ceramic phosphors for solid-state lighting.
[email protected] Masato Nishihara received the B.E. degree in Electrical Engineering in 1998 and the M.E. degree in Electronics Engineering in 2000 from the University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan. He joined Fujitsu Laboratories Ltd., Kawasaki, Japan in 2000 and engaged in the research and development of the optical and electrical devices for the long-haul optical fiber transmission system.
[email protected] Youichi Akasaka of Fujitsu Laboratories of America has been working in the telecommunications industry since 1993, focusing on photonics innovation. He covers diverse areas of optical communications from components to system/ network. He received the B.S. degree from Kyoto University and M.S. and Ph.D. degrees from University of Tokyo. He received the IEICE Young Engineer Award for his pioneering work on optical fiber design in 1995.
[email protected]
CHAPTER 6. MASTERING POWER TRANSIENTS A PREREQUISITE FOR FUTURE OPTICAL NETWORKS (PETER KRUMMRICH) P. M. Krummrich received his Dr.-Ing. degree in Electrical Engineering from Technische Universitaet Braunschweig, Germany, in 1995, where he worked on Praseodymium-doped fiber amplifiers. In 1995 he joined Siemens AG where his research interest focused on distributed Erbium-doped fiber amplifiers, Raman
xiii
xiv
Author biographies
amplification, power transients, advanced modulation formats, adaptive equalizers, and PMD compensation. Since 2007 he is holding the chair for high frequency technology as full professor at Technische Universitaet Dortmund.
[email protected]
CHAPTER 7. SPECTRAL POWER FLUCTUATIONS IN DWDM NETWORKS CAUSED BY SPECTRAL-HOLE BURNING AND STIMULATED RAMAN SCATTERING (JOERG-PETER ELBERS AND CORNELIUS FUERST) Dr. Jo¨rg-Peter Elbers received the diploma and the Dr.-Ing. degree in electrical engineering from Dortmund University, Germany, in 1996 and 2000, respectively. From 1999-2001 he was with Siemens AG e Optical Networks, last as Director of Network Architecture in the Advanced Technology Department. In 2001 he joined Marconi Communications (now Ericsson) as Director of Technology in the Optical Product Unit. Since September 2007 he is with ADVA AG Optical Networking, where he is currently Vice President Advanced Technology in the CTO office. Dr. Elbers authored and co-authored more than 70 scientific publications and 15 patents. He is member of the IEEE LEOS (Laser and Electro-Optics Society) as well as the German VDI (Association of German Engineers) and VDE (German Association for Electrical, Electronic & Information Technologies). Dr. Elbers serves in technical programme committee of the European Conference on Optical Communication (ECOC). He is also member of the VDE expert committee for optical communications engineering.
[email protected] Cornelius Fuerst received the diploma and Ph.D. in physics from the Technical University of Munich, Germany, in 1995 and 1998, respectively, where he did research on femtosecond pulse lasers and ultrafast quantum effects of semiconductors. In 1998 he joined the fiber communication industry working for Siemens Optical Networks, Marconi Communications, Ericsson and ADVA Optical Networking (since 2009). Cornelius Fu¨rst filed more than 40 publications and 10 patent applications in the field of optical networking.
[email protected]
CHAPTER 8. AMPLIFIER ISSUES FOR PHYSICAL LAYER NETWORK CONTROL (DANIEL C. KILPER AND CHRISTOPHER A. WHITE) Dr. Daniel Kilper is currently a member of the Bell Laboratories Optical Transmission Systems and Networks Research Department at Alcatel-Lucent. He received
Author biographies
BS degrees in Electrical Engineering and Physics from the Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University in 1990 and the PhD and MS degrees in physics from the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor in 1992 and 1996. He was a research scientist at the Optical Technology Center at Montana State University before serving as an assistant professor in physics at the University of North Carolina at Charlotte until 2000. He is a senior member of IEEE and an associate editor for the OSA/ IEEE Journal of Optical Communications and Networking. He currently serves as interim chair of the GreenTouch Consortium technical committee. While at Bell Laboratories he has conducted research on optical performance monitoring, network energy trends, and on transmission, architectures and control systems for transparent and re-configurable optical networks. He has authored or co-authored more than 80 journal publications and conference presentations, three book chapters and six patents.
[email protected] Christopher A. White is a distinguished member of technical staff in the Bell Labs’ Chief Scientist’s Office. He holds a Ph.D. in theoretical quantum chemistry from the University of California, Berkeley. His research interests include the simulation and control of complex physical systems ranging from optical networks, to the next generation of smart power grid, and to the propagation of ideas in organizations.
[email protected]
CHAPTER 9. ADVANCED AMPLIFIER SCHEMES IN LONG-HAUL UNDERSEA SYSTEMS (ALAN LUCERO) Dr. Alan J. Lucero received his M.S. and Ph.D. in physics in 1989 and 1993 from the University of Connecticut. After completing a two-year postdoctoral fellowship at Bell Laboratories and two years at AT&T Advanced Technologies Systems, he assisted in the establishment of the Photonics Research and Test Center for Corning, Inc.. He joined Tyco Telecommunciations in 2000, where his current concentrations include 10, 40, and 100 Gb/s transport, advanced optical amplification schemes, coherent transmission, novel dispersion maps, and Q-fluctuation statistics. Dr. Lucero is a member of Phi Beta Kappa
[email protected]
CHAPTER 10. CHALLENGES FOR LONG HAUL AND ULTRA-LONG HAUL DYNAMIC NETWORKS (MARTIN BIRK AND KATHY TSE) Martin Birk received his M.S. and Ph.D. degrees from University of Ulm, Germany, in 1994 and 1999, respectively. Since 1999, he has been with AT&T Labs
xv
xvi
Author biographies
in New Jersey, working on high-speed fiber optic transmission at data rates of 40Gbit/s and above.
[email protected] Kathy Tse leads a team at AT&T working on Optical Systems performance and requirements. She has worked in the fiber optics are at AT&T since 1985. She received her MS and PhD from Brown University and BSc from Cornell.
[email protected]
CHAPTER 11. TRANSPORT SOLUTIONS FOR OPTICALLY AMPLIFIED NETWORK (WERNER WEIERSHAUSEN AND MALTE SCHNEIDERS) Werner Weiershausen received his Dipl.-Ing. degree in electrical and RF engineering from Technical University of Braunschweig in 1992, including AlGaAs based VCSEL research at University of Ulm. From 1992 to 1997 he has been with the Research Center of Deutsche Bundespost/T-Nova and 1997 with the University of Technology, Darmstadt, as a scientist in the fields of InP based semiconductor technology, integrated optics and fiber components. In 1998 he joined the Photonic Systems and Optical Networks Group at T-Systems, first working on theoretical and experimental research in the fields of high-speed optical WDM transmission and measurement methodology, later being project leader for different projects on R&D and technical consulting for optical networks. 2008 he changed to the Technical Engineering Center of Deutsche Telekom, working on the strategic evolution of the next-generation optical packet platform. Werner Weiershausen has been active in several national and European R&D projects (ACTS, IST, COST, BMBF) and different standardization bodies (ITU-T, IEC, DKE). Since 2003 he has been serving as SPIE Editor, Symposium Chair for Optics East Symposium and Conference Chair at Photonics West, USA. He is author or co-author of more than 80 publications, conference contributions and patents. Since August 2008 Werner Weiershausen is working for the management board (in the role of CSO) of the Finnish startup company Luxdyne Ltd, Helsinki, on sub systems for optical access (FTTH, PON).
[email protected] Malte Schneiders has more than nine years experience in the area of Optical Transport. He received his Diploma degree in electrical engineering from the Technical University of Dortmund, Germany in 2001. During his employment at Deutsche Telekom Group he has contributed already to several strategic projects, as well as to national and international research activities on the optimization of optical transport networks and high-speed transmission systems. Malte has authored or
Author biographies
co-authored more than 40 publications in scientific journals and conference proceedings and five patents in this field of investigations.
[email protected]
CHAPTER 12. OPTICAL AMPLIFIER FOR MAINTENANCE FRIENDLY FIBER NETWORKS (GLENN A. WELLBROCK AND TIEJUN J. XIA) Glenn Wellbrock is the Director of Optical Transport Network Architecture and Design at Verizon, where he is responsible for the development of new technologies for both the metro and long haul transport infrastructure. In addition to his 20+ years at Verizon (1984-2001 & 2004-present), Glenn worked at Marconi and Qplus Networks.
[email protected] Dr. Tiejun J. Xia is a Distinguished Member of Technical Staff at Verizon. He was a faculty member at the University of Michigan. He holds his Ph.D. degree from the University of Central Florida, M.S. degree from Zhejiang University, and B.S. degree from University of Science and Technology of China. He has published more than 100 technical papers and holds more than 40 granted or pending U.S. patents.
[email protected]
CHAPTER 13. LOW COST OPTICAL AMPLIFIERS (BRUCE NYMAN AND GREG COWLE) Bruce Nyman is currently with Tyco Electronics SubCom where he works on next generation undersea systems. From 2005 to 2009 he was with Princeton Lightwave as Vice President of system solutions. Previously, he developed optical amplifiers and measurement equipment at JDS Uniphase and optically amplified undersea systems at AT&T Bell Laboratories. He received his doctorate from Columbia University and is an IEEE fellow.
[email protected]
CHAPTER 14. SEMICONDUCTOR OPTICAL AMPLIFIERS FOR METRO AND ACCESS NETWORKS (LEO SPIEKMAN AND DAVID PIEHLER) Leo Spiekman is the Director of Amplifier Products at Alphion Corporation, Princeton Junction, NJ, where he is responsible for the development of
xvii
xviii
Author biographies
semiconductor devices for photonic amplification and switching, for applications in optical telecommunications and beyond. He has served in technical and leadership roles for several technical conferences, among which OFC and ECOC. He has (co-)authored over 60 contributed and invited papers, four chapters in books, and has three patents.
[email protected] David Piehler is an innovator and leader in the deployment and development of FTTH and HFC broadband access networks and in their underlying technologies. At Fields and Waves, he advises clients on technology and markets for nextgeneration broadband access at physical, network and services layers. He presently plays a leading role in the definition of next-generation networks, including OFDM-PON, 10G-PON and RFoG. Dr. Piehler received a Ph.D. in physics from the University of California at Berkeley for experimental work in nonlinear optics.
[email protected]
CHAPTER 15. MARKET TRENDS FOR OPTICAL AMPLIFIERS (DARYL INNIS) Dr. Inniss is the Component Practice Leader of Ovum’s Telecom research. Ovum is an ICT market research firm and Dr. Inniss’ research includes optical components for telecommunication and enterprise networks. Prior to joining Ovum Dr. Inniss was a Technical Manager at JDS Uniphase, and at Lucent Technologies, Bell Laboratories. Dr. Inniss holds a PhD in Chemistry from UCLA and an AB from Princeton University.
[email protected]
CHAPTER
Optical Amplifiers for Next Generation WDM Networks: A Perspective and Overview
1
Atul Srivastava*, John Zyskind** * OneTerabit, Morganville, NJ, USA, ** Oclaro, Inc., Acton, MA, USA
CHAPTER OUTLINE HEAD 1.1. Introduction ..................................................................................................... 1.2. Optical amplifiers: recent developments............................................................. 1.2.1. Wideband amplifiers ....................................................................... 1.2.2. Agile amplifiers .............................................................................. 1.2.3. Cost reduction and commoditization of amplifiers ............................. 1.2.4. Standardization of amplifiers ........................................................... 1.3. Optical amplifiers: present status ................................................................... 1.4. Chapter overviews ......................................................................................... 1.4.1. Chapter 2. ROADM-based networks (Brandon Collings and Peter Roorda) ...................................................................... 1.4.2. Chapter 3. Challenges and opportunities in future high-capacity optical transmission systems (Xiang Liu) ...................................... 1.4.3. Chapter 4. EDFAs, Raman Amplifiers and Hybrid Raman/EDFAs (John Zyskind and Maxim Bolshtyansky)....................................... 1.4.4. Chapter 5. Dynamic and static gain changes of optical amplifiers at ROADM nodes (Etsuko Ishikawa, Setsuhisa Tanabe, Masato Nishihara, and Youichi Akasaka)....................................... 1.4.5. Chapter 6. Mastering power transients: a prerequisite for future optical networks (Peter Krummrich) ................................... 1.4.6. Chapter 7. Spectral power fluctuations in DWDM networks caused by spectral-hole burning and stimulated Raman scattering (Joerg-Peter Elbers and Cornelius Fuerst) ..................................... 1.4.7. Chapter 8. Amplifier issues for physical layer network control (Daniel C. Kilper and Christopher A. White) .................................. 1.4.8. Chapter 9. Advanced amplifier schemes in long-haul undersea systems (Alan Lucero)................................................... 1.4.9. Chapter 10. Challenges for long-haul and ultra-long-haul dynamic networks (Martin Birk and Kathy Tse)........................................... 1.4.10. Chapter 11. Transport solutions for optically amplified networks (Werner Weiershausen and Malte Schneiders) ............................... Optically Amplified WDM Networks. DOI: 10.1016/B978-0-12-374965-9.10001-9 Copyright Ó 2011 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
2 3 3 3 8 9 11 11 11 12 13
13 14
15 15 16 16 17
1
2
CHAPTER 1 Optical amplifiers for next generation WDM networks
1.4.11. Chapter 12. Optical amplifier for maintenance-friendly fiber networks (Glenn A. Wellbrock and Tiejun J. Xia) .................... 1.4.12. Chapter 13. Low-cost optical amplifiers (Bruce Nyman and Greg Cowle) ................................................... 1.4.13. Chapter 14. Semiconductor optical amplifiers for metro and access networks (Leo Spiekman and David Piehler)................. 1.4.14. Chapter 15. Market trends for optical amplifiers (Daryl Inniss) ....... Acronyms ............................................................................................................. Acknowledgements ............................................................................................... References ...........................................................................................................
17 18 19 19 20 21 21
1.1 INTRODUCTION Since its invention in 1987, the erbium-doped fiber amplifier (EDFA) [1,2] has revolutionized the telecommunications industry. Today the EDFA is widely viewed as mature technology, while new network applications drive new requirements for further enhancement of optical fiber amplifiers. One such emerging application is dynamic optical networking using remotely reconfigurable optical add/drop multiplexers (ROADMs). With the ability to express optical channels through these ROADM nodes, service providers can reduce per wavelength cost in the network. On the other hand, longer reach between regeneration is needed to derive benefits from this network architecture, making the optical amplifier a key component in these reconfigurable dynamic networks. Amplifier designs will also be influenced by the renewed need for increased capacity on a fiber. Deployment of wavelength division multiplexed (WDM) systems transmitting 40 Gb/s per WDM channel is already under way, and a great deal of current work is directed at 100 Gb/s transmission. Meeting the demands for higher capacity within the constraints of current fiber plant and filtering limitations of wavelength switches will require advanced modulation and detection formats that encode multiple bits per symbol and, in many cases, involve differential or coherent detection. In general, these modulation schemes increase robustness against chromatic dispersion (CD), polarization mode dispersion (PMD), and filtering impairments, but place additional demands on the noise performance of the optical amplifiers due to their increased susceptibility to nonlinear impairments and, frequently, increased optical signal-to-noise ratio (OSNR) requirements. On the other hand, the amplifier characteristics, such as the gain spectrum, its dependence on channel loading, the cross saturation and dynamic response of the amplifier gain, and the optical noise added by the amplifiers, must all impose constraints on the design and operation of advanced networks. These important network design issues are addressed in a number of chapters in this book as well as the chapter summaries that follow. This book is intended to address recent developments in amplifiers driven by emerging trends in network applications as well as the interrelationship between
1.2 Optical amplifiers: recent developments
the amplifiers and these emerging trends. Experts on the amplifiers, on the network equipment in which they are used, and on the service provider networks in which the equipment is deployed were asked to examine how the emerging network trends drive amplifier requirements, how amplifier characteristics guide or constrain the design and operation of networks with more complex optical connectivity and higher capacities, and how, as a result, the engineering of solutions to various network design and operation challenges increasingly require network-wide analysis and network-wide solutions. Application spaces ranging from low-cost, shortreach access networks to terrestrial networks to ultra-long-haul transcontinental undersea systems are considered. In the remainder of this chapter, the recent trends in optical amplifiers that are driven in large part by emerging trends in network applications are discussed, then summaries of the remaining chapters are provided.
1.2 OPTICAL AMPLIFIERS: RECENT DEVELOPMENTS Four major trends characterize developments in the amplifiers over the past decade. These include the increase in amplifier bandwidth to support larger numbers of channels for higher network capacity, integration of optics and fast electronics to provide performance agility for dynamic networks, significant cost reduction, and standardization of amplifier modules. These trends are summarized below.
1.2.1 Wideband amplifiers In response to the exponential growth in data traffic, optical networks were designed with a growing number of dense wavelength division multiplexing (DWDM) channels. State-of-the-art commercial DWDM systems include EDFAs able to support up to 160 channels with 50 GHz channel spacing spanning both C- and L-bands. However, the deployed networks predominantly consist of channels in the C-band. Some geographical areas such as Japan have deployed amplifiers to support transmission systems in the L-band over the dispersion shifted fiber spans. Moreover, the use of a hybrid design of EDFAs in conjunction with Raman amplifiers is prevalent in special networks with ultra-long spans.
1.2.2 Agile amplifiers There is a large market for optical amplifiers that until recently was driven by static point-to-point WDM system applications. However, the increasing unpredictability of traffic demand and the emergence of bandwidth-hungry applications such as video on demand have recently turned the industry’s focus to dynamic, reconfigurable optical networks based on ROADMs to route different wavelength channels. Sales of ROADMs are increasing with a compound annual growth rate exceeding 40%; by the end of 2010 the number of field deployed wavelength
3
4
CHAPTER 1 Optical amplifiers for next generation WDM networks
selective switches (WSS), a key component of modern ROADMS, is expected to exceed 100,000. Essentially all new metro, regional, and long-haul WDM system products developed by equipment manufacturers offer ROADM-based wavelength agility as a key feature. Similarly, all network deployments planned by Tier-1 carriers in the major industrial nations and many in emerging nations require reconfigurable wavelength agility to reduce operational expenses and increase service velocity. A recent report from Ovum-RHK (see Fig. 1.1 below) concluded that ROADMs and agile EDFAs lead the transition to a dynamic optical network. The report forecast that the growth of these two components will track each other closely with over 80% of 2010 module sales in both categories expected for agile components. This has created new challenges for the design of amplifiers including, for example, those related to dynamics and control of transients, spectral hole burning, and polarization-related impairments. Introduction of channels at higher data rates employing a coherent receiver, followed by high-speed digitization and signal processing, can pose additional constraints on the system tolerance due to their sensitivity to channel power fluctuation caused by transients. Increasingly the optical amplifier technical literature and commercial practice have dealt with such design challenges posed by dynamic, reconfigurable optical networks. Today specifications for new optical amplifier designs are almost always framed to support the requirements of reconfigurable optical networks. These developments have led to the realization that the optical amplifiers constituting the transmission path need to provide performance agility in order to provide high-quality service for the channel traffic propagating through the
FIGURE 1.1 Penetration of agile ROADM and EDFA modules as a percentage of revenue by product group, 2005e11. Source: Ovum-RHK
1.2 Optical amplifiers: recent developments
amplifier. In the network architecture, two types of events have to be considered: intentional reconfiguration or re-provisioning and unintended failures or faults leading to protection path switching. In both types of events the optical amplifiers in the transmission path need to have fast gain control, which is usually implemented via electronic control of the amplifier’s pump lasers. In order to effectively control the power transients in DWDM systems, it is important to understand the factors that influence the speed or the rate at which the surviving channel powers change during transients. This speed depends on both the EDFA characteristics and the number of EDFAs constituting the system [3]. In a single EDFA, the time constant of the power transients decreases with increases in saturated power output. In a system with long chains of EDFAs, the amplifiers strive to maintain the saturated output power levels. The time varying output of the first EDFA (after a fiber span loss) appears as an input to the second EDFA, which has time-dependent gain, and therefore the output power of the second EDFA changes at a faster rate. Consequently, with increasing numbers of amplifiers in the chain, the speed of transients becomes faster and faster, thereby requiring control on shorter and shorter time scales to limit the power excursion of surviving channels [4]. Proper transient control design needs to take into account the fastest single event in the network as well as the acceleration of this event due to the cascading of amplifiers. Another important characteristic for the control of the transients is the slew rate associated with the event causing a change in the channel loading of amplifiers which determines the rate of the surviving channels’ power change during transients. Events such as failure of a transmitter laser can happen over sub micro second time scales and connector pulls, which can happen by mistake, typically occur over hundreds of ms, whereas fiber breaks often happen over hundreds of milliseconds (ms) or even seconds, although in a rare worst case they can be much faster. Likewise, provisioning of channels can be implemented in a controlled fashion, one at a time, to minimize sudden changes in the power of the transmitting channels. The state-of the art switching technologies currently being implemented in ROADMs also have transition times of hundreds of milliseconds. Today’s predominantly data-centric transport network has evolved from the synchronous optical network (SONET)-based voice-centric one in the past. The availability of high-bandwidth OC-768 and higher rate port cards for the asynchronous transfer mode (ATM) switches and IP routers has led to the development of an intelligent optical layer network, where light wave paths provide connectivity between SONET terminal, ATM, and IP router devices. The function of the optical layer is to provide high-bandwidth wavelength service to the client layer. A DWDM system supports multiple wavelengths over the optical bandwidth of the optical amplifier, unlike the single-wavelength SONET systems of the past. The DWDM system is designed to support channels over the bandwidth of the in-line optical amplifiers. Though the restriction on the channel powers for acceptable quality of service is determined by the details of the system architecture such as
5
6
CHAPTER 1 Optical amplifiers for next generation WDM networks
OSNR and non-linear effects in the fiber, typically the transmission system is designed with about 10 dB power margin at the receiver to accommodate these variations. At high channel powers and channel counts, optical non-linear effects, four photon mixing (FPM), cross-phase modulation (CPM), and Raman effect can impair the service quality of the system and thereby further limit acceptable channel power excursion. In the event of a fiber cut or inadvertent disconnection of one of the tributaries carrying one or more wavelengths entering the optical line system, the SONET protection switching could be triggered for the express channels, and they could be routed through the protection path. This protection switching would occur if the express channel powers experienced either an upward or downward power surge due to transients in the EDFAs. The following sequence of events could occur in a SONET system. First, if the optical power of the channel either exceeds or dips below the set limits, the system would generate an alarm to the network control and management (NC&M) system. Second, if the power excursion exceeds the dynamic range of the receiver, either due to poor signal or failure in the receiver thresholding circuit, a LOS (loss of signal) defect will be detected when an all-zero pattern on the incoming SONET signal lasts 100 ms or longer [5]. Finally, the signal has to be switched to the protection path within 50 to 100 ms via SONET/SDH (synchronous digital hierarchy) or Optical 1:1 protection [6]. For the surviving express channels, it is desirable that the power transients are mitigated within the physical layer to restrict the power transients to the minimum possible under both the intentional add/drop event during network reconfiguration or accidental events so that unnecessary SONET protection switching can be avoided. In order to implement the fast gain control to limit the power transients to an acceptable level, it became essential to integrate the optical gain block assembly with fast electronics to form a gain controlled module. Controlled amplifier modules with 50 to 100 microsecond control loop time constant were developed six to eight years ago. An example of the performance of an amplifier module with ultra-fast gain control is shown in Fig. 1.2. When 99 out of 100 channels propagating through the amplifier are interrupted, the surviving channel would experience only about 2 dB of power overshoot. The fast gain control circuit returns the power of the surviving channel to within <0.3 dB of the original power in a few hundred microseconds. This level of performance was regarded as very valuable by the service providers and equipment manufacturers because it minimized the service interruption for the most common failure or reconfiguration events and it prevented unnecessary switching to the protection path. As discussed earlier, in the above example, an important factor is the rise or fall time of the event triggering the change in channel loading of the amplifiers in the transmission path. The transition time could range from microseconds to a few seconds; the amplifier control becomes easier with longer transition time. Reconfiguration and restoration times of modern ROADM networks will be governed by the switching speed of the wavelength selective switches at the nodes. Switching time in these devices, which is usually a combination of electronic
1.2 Optical amplifiers: recent developments
20 dB Channel Drop Response
2.0 1.0 0.0 -500
0 500 1000 Time (microseconds)
Signal (dB)
3.0
-1.0 1500
FIGURE 1.2 Signal power of lone surviving channel at the output of an ultra-fast gain controlled EDFA module when 99 out of 100 channels are dropped with a fall time of 0.2 microsecond. [7]
signal transmission delay after receiving a command and optical device switching speed, is usually in the range of hundreds of milliseconds for WSS-based ROADMs. Currently, because switching in the optical layer is primarily used for provisioning and reconfiguration in the event of a large failure, higher switching speed is not a priority for the carriers, and transition time of several seconds is acceptable. For fast protection however, layer 3 will be used with a combination of Multiprotocol Label Switching (MPLS) and fast-rerouting, which can occur in nearly 250 ms in some cases. As network traffic grows and network topologies become more complicated, electronic protection will become more complex and expensive and there will be value in optical switching technologies that can meet the timing requirements of protection switching. Rapid growth in data traffic, which already exceeds the voice traffic on public networks, is also having a profound impact on the network architecture and related requirements of the fault protection. This rapid change in the voice/data traffic balance has driven the evolution of networks toward IP-based architectures and a large and growing segment of data traffic may not require SONET/SDH ring restoration times, removing it as an absolute requirement for the whole network. The requirements of network provisioning and restoration are ultimately governed by the service level agreements. These can range from platinum level for the optical core, the leased lines and storage area networks for the financial industry, to the best effort IP voice and data services. Network designs supporting flexible restoration choices are best suited to serve the real needs of public networks. Moreover, use of Ethernet is growing in the metro and carrier grade networks because of its simplicity and scalability. Originally, Ethernet evolved primarily as a local area network (LAN) technology and did not possess the failure protection mechanism like SONET/SDH links. There are, however, new proposals to include protection mechanisms in Ethernet networks that can recover from node and link failures in under 50 milliseconds [8].
7
CHAPTER 1 Optical amplifiers for next generation WDM networks
Pricing USD (Thousands)
8
EDFA Prices 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 1996
2000
2004 Year
2008
2012
FIGURE 1.3 Price reduction of EDFAs in last 10 years. [9]
1.2.3 Cost reduction and commoditization of amplifiers Amplifier cost has decreased significantly in last 10 years. Cost of a typical twostage amplifier module with mid-stage access, variable gain design, and integrated electronic controls has dropped from nearly $8,000 to $2,500 in the last five years, a nearly 20% year-to-year cost erosion. This is due to significant cost reduction in pump lasers, erbium fiber, and other components as well as reduced labor costs. The emergence of several suppliers of amplifiers from eastern Asia has led to commoditization of amplifiers, particularly at the low end. The vendors have tried to offer an integrated line card or rack mountable unit solution to increase the value of their product relative to an amplifier module. Despite significant cost reduction and commoditization of amplifier components leading to pseudo-standardization of amplifiers at the performance level, there are no real standards or multisource agreements for the performance of optical amplifiers. This is because the equipment manufacturers perceive that they derive value and differentiation by designing their own amplifiers, since the system performance is strongly dependent on the amplifiers. The network equipment manufacturers (NEMs) typically use a combination of two or three different EDFA designs for pre-amplification and booster amplification and for in-line amplification for spans of different lengths. Sometimes Raman amplification is used as well for the occasional very long span or to configure a long reach transmission system. Variations in the span losses in a long reach system are accommodated by variable gain amplifiers typically based on placing a variable optical attenuator (VOA) between the amplification stages of multistage amplifiers. Moreover, historically, the equipment vendors have designed their own circuit packs requiring amplifiers with custom mechanical and electrical characteristics. Two approaches to amplifier sourcing are prevalent in the industry today: Several NEMs use only gain blocks, which are assemblies of passive optical components and pump lasers procured from an outside vendor, while the control electronics and firmware are designed in-
1.2 Optical amplifiers: recent developments
house and reside on their line card. This allows them to leverage the low cost supply of components from the industry while they have the ownership of the control electronics and related control algorithms. The second approach is the procurement of amplifier modules which have built-in electronic control and monitoring features. The line card communicates to the module over a serial or TL1 control interface with suitable commands. In the long run, the industry will benefit from the standardization of the performance level and optical design of amplifiers.
1.2.4 Standardization of amplifiers Amplifier designs ranging from simple single stage to more complex multistage amplifiers with variable gain evolved as a differentiator for system performance by equipment manufacturers and were initially made in-house. More recently, the equipment vendors outsourced the design and manufacturing of amplifiers to the component vendors while requiring more than one source in order to control cost and delivery risk. This led to a pseudo-standardization of optical amplifiers with three or four vendors making amplifiers with compatible optical, mechanical, electrical hardware, and software specifications. Geographically, however, the component suppliers from Japan and North America were predominant suppliers to the equipment vendors of their respective regions. This led to evolution of two major streams of amplifier products, broadly having distinct specifications, one in North America and the other in Japan. The International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) has recognized these trends and recently created standards for new characterization techniques such as transient measurement and optical amplifier module command sets. In an effort to standardize the various transient parameters across the industry, the transient measurement document also include definitions of the various parameters such as transient gain response time, gain overshoot, and gain offset. Similar standards are being developed for other measurements and physical interfaces of optical amplifier modules. There has been considerable progress in the standardization of measurement techniques of optical amplifier parameters, but relatively little has been achieved on the standardization of the performance parameters. As described above, this is primarily because the network equipment manufacturers believe they will gain significant advantage and differentiation in transmission system performance by having a custom design of optical amplifiers. However, because of the requirement of multiple sourcing for amplifiers, there has been industry-wide pseudostandardization, and as a consequence it has been possible to standardize the command set of the amplifier modules. Moreover, it has been realized that there is value in acceptance of common definition of agile amplifiers such as the transient characteristics and common measurement techniques which can be acceptable to both the WDM equipment vendors and component suppliers. An example of the EDFA transient parameters in the channel drop event as defined in
9
CHAPTER 1 Optical amplifiers for next generation WDM networks
net gain overshoot
gain overshoot
gain stability
Gain (dB)
10
gain offset initial gain
net gain undershoot
final gain
gain undershoot
transient gain response time constant (settling time) Time
FIGURE 1.4 EDFA Transient parameter definition in the event of channel drop. [10] Courtesy IEC
an IEC document [10] is shown in Fig. 1.4, which defines the commonly used parameters like transient gain response, gain overshoot, and gain offset. Further progress is needed in this direction and will lead to overall cost reduction of manufacturing and testing of products. A brief snapshot of the recent activities and progress of the IEC SC86C Working Group on Optical Amplifiers is given below.
1.4 Chapter overviews
1.3 OPTICAL AMPLIFIERS: PRESENT STATUS After nearly five years of focus on cost reduction and reduced progress in innovation, new directions in optical amplifier technology are becoming visible. These are in response to the major trends for the amplified optical networks of higher degree of connectivity and introduction of channels at higher data rates. Agility in amplifiers will be key to the successful deployment of ROADM networks requiring seamless provisioning and recovery in the event of failures. Features such as fast gain control at sub millisecond timescale and rapid spectral adjustments to counter the impairments due to higher order effects (spectral hole burning [SHB], Raman spectral tilt in fiber, and polarization dependent loss [PDL] of components) will be needed on an integrated basis across the whole system. Likewise, continuous demand to increase the OSNR of the signals to support ever increasing channel rates to 100 Gb/s and beyond over ultra-long-haul distances will require every dB to be made available, for example by deployment of hybrid Raman/EDFAs at every repeater site in the network. Another trend is the deployment of high-power cladding pumped amplifiers with watts of output power in the access network for distribution of video and other content. From the commercial standpoint, however, since the industry has become addicted to 15% to 20% price reduction year to year, these new features will have to be delivered at negligible incremental cost.
1.4 CHAPTER OVERVIEWS 1.4.1 Chapter 2. ROADM-based networks (Brandon Collings and Peter Roorda) Prior to the advent of optical amplifiers, optical communications systems were based on expensive optical-electronic-optical regeneration at the end of each span. Routing and switching traffic required conversion to the electronic domain. Optically amplified dense wavelength division multiplexing (DWDM) systems immediately enabled longer system reach, a dramatic increase in capacity, and lower cost per bit
11
12
CHAPTER 1 Optical amplifiers for next generation WDM networks
transmitted. Optically amplified DWDM networks have also opened the possibility of optical networking based on the optical transparency of amplified systems and the possibility of optically manipulating different DWDM channels based on their different wavelengths. Reconfigurable optical add/drop multiplexers (ROADMs), now being widely deployed, enable network operators to take advantage of the transparency of optically amplified networks. Network nodes are equipped with ROADMs to dynamically route DWDM channels optically and to avoid the expense of optical-to-electronic-to-optical conversion for channels that are expressed through the network node. This chapter covers the enabling technologies, architectures, and properties of ROADMs and ROADM-based networks. It includes a discussion of the evolution of ROADM components including the major enabling technologies: wave blockers used for the first ROADMs, photonic light wave circuit (PLC) ROADMs, and ROADMs based on wavelength selective switches (WSSs), used most widely today because of their superior cascadeability for 50 GHz spaced DWDM channels and graceful support for higher degree nodes. Also discussed are the architectures and ROADM characteristics that apply in each case. Amplifiers are necessary elements of ROADM nodes primarily to compensate the loss of the ROADM components. In this chapter, the requirements for such amplifiers are discussed as well as the impact of ROADM-based architecture on the operation of amplified networks and on the amplifier requirements. Of particular note is the ability of ROADMs to provide power equalization of channels for compensation of amplifiers’ spectral gain ripple. Finally, the chapter addresses new and emerging applications such as photonic restoration, which might increase network availability at reduced cost, and colorless and directionless ROADM architectures, which can increase routing flexibility and provide simplified physical interfaces with reduced cost.
1.4.2 Chapter 3. Challenges and opportunities in future high-capacity optical transmission systems (Xiang Liu) The introduction of WDM channels at higher data rate has provided tremendous growth in the capacity of transmission systems. As the channel rates grow beyond 40 Gb/s to 100 Gb/s and higher, one key challenge is to enhance the spectral efficiency of the system. The transition in channel bit rate to 100 Gb/s and higher requires the conventional on off keying (OOK) modulation scheme and direct detection scheme to be abandoned in favor of the more advanced modulation formats such as polarization multiplexed quadrature phase shift keying PM-QPSK and coherent detection schemes. Coherent detection also poses significant challenges for high-speed chip development for both analog-to-digital conversion and digital signal processing. For transmission at these bit rates, every dB of OSNR improvement will be critical to achieving high-capacity transmission over terrestrial distances. Improvement of the noise figure of in-line amplifiers, for example, by using hybrid Raman/EDFAs will be important for these systems.
1.4 Chapter overviews
This chapter provides an overview of the technology challenges for the implementation of future high-capacity systems incorporating channels at bit rates of 100 Gb/s and higher. Moreover, it explains the improvements needed in optical signal-tonoise ratio (OSNR) enhancement, and robustness against linear and non-linear impairments. This is followed by a review of the recent progress in the demonstration of high-bit-rate systems with novel modulation schemes including PM-QPSK, orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM), and others as well as the related practical implementation issues. The status of the current and future multilevel signal coding schemes for enhancing the spectral efficiency relative to the Shannon limit is analyzed. Finally, the key optical technologies for the future highcapacity transmission systems such as novel optical fibers, amplification schemes, modulation formats, and optical integration are discussed.
1.4.3 Chapter 4. EDFAs, Raman Amplifiers and Hybrid Raman/EDFAs (John Zyskind and Maxim Bolshtyansky) The advent of the erbium-doped fiber amplifier on the eve of the 1990s made highcapacity wavelength division multiplexed systems possible, allowing service providers to meet the exploding demand generated by the growth of the telecommunications industry and of the internet. Chapter 4 reviews the basic properties of optical amplifiers of importance for the original DWDM applications of optical amplifiers, such as gain, output power, and noise performance, and discusses recent developments related to advances in WDM networks, such as the ROADM-based wavelength-routed systems discussed in Chapter 2 and the WDM systems with channel rates of 100 Gb/s or more discussed in Chapter 3. For the ROADM-based networks, where channels follow diverse paths and are dynamically reconfigured, interactions between channels must be understood and managed. Properties of EDFAs such as their transient response and their spectral response are major sources of such interactions and are of increased importance for such networks. The chapter discusses recent advances in modeling the inhomogeneous behavior of erbiumdoped fiber amplifier (EDFAs), particularly spectral hole burning (SHB) and dynamic response in EDFAs, essential for the design of ROADM-based networks and EDFAs for ROADM-based networks. For high-capacity systems, amplifier properties such as the noise performance are of increased importance. Distributed Raman amplifiers and hybrid Raman/EDFA amplifiers, which can significantly improve noise performance compared with discrete EDFAs, are described.
1.4.4 Chapter 5. Dynamic and static gain changes of optical amplifiers at ROADM nodes (Etsuko Ishikawa, Setsuhisa Tanabe, Masato Nishihara, and Youichi Akasaka) Chapter 5 focuses on two of the major amplifier-based sources of interactions between channels, EDFA gain dynamics, and SHB resulting from inhomogeneous broadening. Gain dynamics are important because when channel loading in the
13
14
CHAPTER 1 Optical amplifiers for next generation WDM networks
EDFAs changes, the co-propagating surviving channels are impacted. This could happen because of reconfiguration of the channels through the network or because of a fault, such as a fiber break or connector pull. In either case, the surviving channels that were co-propagating through EDFAs with the affected channels will experience changes in their gains if the amplifier is not controlled. And the longer the chain of concatenated amplifiers is and the harder these amplifiers are driven (the higher the pump power and the higher the EDFA output power) the faster the gain dynamics can be. This chapter presents methods of fast gain control that can be incorporated in amplifier designs to manage these dynamic effects. As a result of SHB, the gain spectrum of the EDFAs depends on the wavelengths and powers of the individual channels that are populated, even if the amplifier is maintained at the constant inversion. Chapter 5 reviews the current understanding of the underlying physics and the complex spectral structure of hole burning. A numerical model of SHB is developed, and its use to predict the gain spectra for different allocations of provisioned channels is demonstrated. As the phenomenon is intrinsic to the physics of gain in EDFAs, it must be managed using the capability of the ROADMs to adjust the powers of individual channels to compensate for SHB.
1.4.5 Chapter 6. Mastering power transients: a prerequisite for future optical networks (Peter Krummrich) Optical power transients in amplified optical networks arise from both intentional provisioning and reconfiguration and unintended failures and restoration events. Since the discovery of power transients in the 1990s, it has been realized that while gain-saturated amplifiers contribute predominantly to the power fluctuations there are other effects, earlier considered to be negligibly small, such as stimulated Raman scattering (SRS) interactions among wavelength division multiplexer (WDM) channels in transmission fiber, SHB in amplifiers, and spectral gain ripple and tilt variation under amplifier automatic gain control (AGC), which can cause significant impairment. Moreover, there is the possibility of interplay among these effects causing unintended spectral shape changes and electronic gain control error to add up and propagate through the network. The importance of these effects has increased in recent years due to the advent of very-high-capacity ultralong-haul transmission systems in which a large number of DWDM channels traverse many amplifiers. This chapter provides a comprehensive overview of the SHB, SRS, and spectral tilt and gain ripple effects for the currently deployed amplifiers having electronic pump control. After a description of these issues and the related system impairments, the chapter considers the use of a variable optical attenuator and a spectral tilt device to mitigate the impairments. These techniques are evaluated using simulations and proof of concept experiments. It will be increasingly critical to address the power transient effects at every node of the future transmission systems, and it will
1.4 Chapter overviews
be necessary to do address this holistically rather than in piecemeal fashion in the EDFAs or transmission fiber alone.
1.4.6 Chapter 7. Spectral power fluctuations in DWDM networks caused by spectral-hole burning and stimulated Raman scattering (Joerg-Peter Elbers and Cornelius Fuerst) In the 1990s, SHB in the gain spectrum of EDFA was identified as a small higher order effect with magnitude of only a fraction of a dB. Likewise, the manifestation of SRS of DWDM channels in the transmission fiber was estimated to cause a small power transfer from short wavelength channels to the longer ones, both at the bit level and on average power basis. Even these small effects can cause significant impairment of channels in the modern WDM networks which consist of 100 or more channels covering most of the EDFA gain spectrum and transmission reach requiring concatenation of tens to hundreds of amplifiers, particularly when the channel loading in the network is changed. It therefore becomes an imperative for the system designers to quantify the system impact and then develop strategies to mitigate or manage the adverse impact of these effects. After briefly introducing the physics of these effects, this chapter provides an assessment of the system impact of SHB and SRS through experimental investigation of gain-controlled amplifiers in a circulating loop. This is followed by a model describing the impact of these effects based on treating the amplifier as a black box. Finally, the authors propose a wavelength-dependent light path assignment for the mitigation of signal impairments particularly to the long wavelength channels.
1.4.7 Chapter 8. Amplifier issues for physical layer network control (Daniel C. Kilper and Christopher A. White) One of the major consequences of the introduction of transparent network elements such as ROADMs is that the optically transparent portion of the network evolves from the point-to-point links of the original DWDM systems to more complex topologies such as optically transparent mesh networks. In such networks, mechanisms that couple power fluctuations between different channels can cause fluctuations to propagate through the network beyond the originating channels and to links in the network beyond those traversed by the originating channels, giving rise to feedback that can destabilize the network. As a result, the challenge of managing interactions among channels is more complex than in point-to-point systems. The local controls (based on mid-amplifier variable optical attenuator, pump control, and adjustment of channel powers at the transmitter) used in point-to-point systems are no longer adequate. They must be supplemented by network-wide control algorithms that employ the capabilities of the ROADMs to control individual channel powers and optimize these globally across the network. Chapter 8 examines the mechanisms of dynamic and static power coupling between channels in both constant gain and constant output power EDFAs, and the
15
16
CHAPTER 1 Optical amplifiers for next generation WDM networks
resultant issues of power stability in complex transparent networks. Network-wide control algorithms to compensate interchannel coupling effects and to maintain network stability are presented. Simulations are used to demonstrate the ability of such global optimization to control the instabilities that would otherwise occur with even the best local control.
1.4.8 Chapter 9. Advanced amplifier schemes in long-haul undersea systems (Alan Lucero) Undersea systems constitute a distinct application space characterized by intercontinental distances between nodes and the requirement that repeaters deployed on the ocean floor be extremely reliable. Undersea systems with conventional discrete EDFA repeaters support high-capacity DWDM transmission over thousands of kilometers with highly reliable underwater equipment. Improved repeater noise performance is important for higher capacity systems required to meet increasing traffic demand and for increased repeater spacing to reduce system cost. This chapter focuses on advanced hybrid amplifier technologies for undersea systems: hybrids of distributed Raman amplifiers (DRAs) with discrete EDFAs and hybrids of remote optically pumped amplifiers (ROPAs) with discrete EDFAs. They are used in hybrid configurations because discrete EDFAs have superior pump efficiency for producing gain and output power, but DRAs and ROPAs deliver superior noise performance. The chapter examines architectures and performance in ultra-long-haul, highcapacity DWDM systems of such hybrid amplifiers. Because of their superior noise performance, hybrid DRA/EDFAs can be used to increase capacity and repeater spacing. Because of the spectral flexibility of Raman amplification, hybrid DRA/ EDFAs can also be used to increase capacity by increasing the available optical bandwidth. Hybrid ROPA/EDFAs do not have the same spectral flexibility but are found to offer noise performance and transmission performance that is somewhat better than that of hybrid DRA/EDFAs.
1.4.9 Chapter 10. Challenges for long-haul and ultra-long-haul dynamic networks (Martin Birk and Kathy Tse) Service providers, who deploy and operate networks, have the final say in the field deployment of new technology for the next generation high-capacity transmission systems. They not only determine the practical feasibility of novel architecture concepts, but also set the specifications for the optical components to deliver the desirable system performance. As the optical networks transition toward mesh architecture with a higher degree (>3) of connectivity and rapid provisioning and restoration capability and the introduction of channel rates of 100 Gb/s and greater, the requirements of higher degree nodes with colorless, contentionless, and gridless features are being considered and defined. The challenge for the network equipment vendors lies in the identification and implementation of key optical component technologies in order to meet the current and future needs of the service providers.
1.4 Chapter overviews
This chapter starts with a brief history of the DWDM system capacity and network evolution and provides a review of the current status of optical mesh backbone network from point of view of a North American network operator. Requirements for the optical amplifiers in the present day ROADM based mesh networks are described to include optical link control, and key characteristics of static and dynamic amplifiers are discussed. Finally, the requirements for fully dynamic future mesh networks are described with the possibilities ranging from precabling provisioning to full photonic restoration.
1.4.10 Chapter 11. Transport solutions for optically amplified networks (Werner Weiershausen and Malte Schneiders) In recent years, the distinction between the system reach of metro and long-haul systems has diminished. Today’s metro systems can be easily extended to cover distances longer than 500 km. This development has profound impact on the architecture of the European national networks, where the size of networks is closer to that of current metro/regional networks. Moreover, since signal wavelengths can be extended to distances nearing 100 km without re-amplification, the requirement of a large number of central offices in the legacy national networks in countries like Germany has also diminished. It is therefore more cost effective to consider network architectures with fewer central offices, potentially eliminating up to 90% of the existing ones. Cost benefits will also be derived from the implementation of new technologies such as new modulation formats and coherent detection, particularly for high-data-rate channels. In this chapter, network architecture issues and physical impairments due to chromatic dispersion, polarization mode dispersion (PMD), and related mitigation techniques for these networks are described from the point of view of a European network operator. Simulation results are also presented to show a comparison of the system reach over different types of fiber for signals with return to zero (RZ) and carrier suppressed RZ (CSRZ) modulation formats and the use of Raman and EDFA hybrid amplifiers to optimize the network design.
1.4.11 Chapter 12. Optical amplifier for maintenance-friendly fiber networks (Glenn A. Wellbrock and Tiejun J. Xia) Managing necessary fiber maintenance activities is a significant challenge for network operators. Traffic must be rerouted from an active fiber to an inactive fiber, without reducing service availability or violating service level agreements by triggering protection switches. In SONET-based ring networks with point-to-point wavelength paths, it is relatively straightforward to switch at the synchronous optical network (SONET) level all of the affected traffic onto a protection fiber link. The deployment of optically transparent mesh networks based on ROADM nodes with multiple fiber degrees, where different wavelengths on a fiber span follow diverse paths through the network, make the task of identifying and switching all of the
17
18
CHAPTER 1 Optical amplifiers for next generation WDM networks
affected client traffic paths much more difficult. With large numbers of narrowly spaced DWDM channels and channel rates increasing from 10 Gb/s to 40 Gb/s and then to 100 Gb/s and beyond, the task of moving traffic at the electronic level is becoming all the more intractable. In Chapter 12 the authors review these emerging trends in network architecture and discuss the challenges these trends present for network maintenance. Finally, an elegant solution is proposed which avoids the complications entailed in optically transparent mesh networks with high capacity DWDM traffic. The principle is to switch the traffic at the fiber level at the amplifier nodes which terminate either end of the affected span so that all of the affected traffic and only the affected traffic is switched. This requires a new architecture for optical amplifier repeater nodes incorporating the necessary switching capability at the amplifier input and the amplifier output. Switching architectures and technologies, which must support the required switching speed to avoid triggering of protection switches or unacceptably long traffic interruptions, are reviewed.
1.4.12 Chapter 13. Low-cost optical amplifiers (Bruce Nyman and Greg Cowle) Cost reduction of optical amplifiers is of increasing concern because of continual pressure on the pricing of optical networking equipment, because of changes in applications and network architectures which are extending the range of applications of amplifiers beyond the line amplifier repeaters of the core network, and because the dominant EDFA technology is not as easily amenable to cost reduction through integration as other technologies such as semiconductors. This chapter examines the issues involved in lowering the cost of optical amplifiers focusing on single stage optical amplifiers because, by and large, they will be used in the highest volume, most cost sensitive applications, such as metro and access network line amplifiers, single-channel amplification for high speed, advanced modulation format channels, cable television (CATV) distribution booster amplifiers, and ASE sources for WDM passive optical networks (PONs). The alternative technologies for low-cost amplifiers, such as semiconductor optical amplifiers, and erbium-doped waveguide amplifiers (EDWAs) are covered. EDFAs, which are the dominant technology, comprise multiple components with different features and are based on different technologies. The challenges and opportunities of reducing the costs of the primary components of EDFAs and the labor costs of assembling EDFAs are discussed. EDWAs offer opportunities for cost reduction by integrating the features of many of the components required for optical amplifiers. However, the lower efficiency of converting pump-to-signal power in erbium-doped planar waveguides compared with erbium-doped fiber, poses an obstacle to the commercial realization of the potential cost advantages of EDWAs. A recent approach is the PLC erbium-doped fiber amplifier, in which many of the passive devices are integrated on a PLC but the gain is provided by an erbium-doped fiber. This approach combines the cost advantages of PLC integration with the
1.4 Chapter overviews
performance and pump efficiency of erbium-doped fiber and is especially advantageous for complex amplifier architectures requiring many optical components.
1.4.13 Chapter 14. Semiconductor optical amplifiers for metro and access networks (Leo Spiekman and David Piehler) In 1990s, semiconductor optical amplifiers (SOAs) were expected to emerge as a compact and low-cost alternative to EDFAs. However, because of the short time constant of their gain dynamics, the SOAs caused unacceptable levels of inter- and intra-channel distortions making them unsuitable for in-line amplification in DWDM systems. Schemes such as laser cavity formation to clamp the amplifier gain led to many years of research and development activity without significant commercial success. The ability of SOAs to amplify signals in the wavelength regions beyond the C- and L-band covered by the EDFAs did not give them much benefit because the commercial DWDM systems remain confined to these bands. The other proposed applications of SOAs such as switching, non-linear signal processing and wavelength conversion have also been confined to academic research. With the advent of PONs for access applications in recent years, however, there is renewed interest in SOAs to extend the total loss budget of such networks. This chapter addresses the architecture issues of PONs to show the benefits of including SOAs for network reach extension, for example. The standards of gigabit passive optical network (GPON), for example, specify a loss budget of 28 dB to be used in a combination of splitting loss and fiber loss. This limitation can be overcome by the inclusion of SOAs at the splitter as a mid-span amplifier. The ability of SOAs to amplify signals at the wavelengths 1550, 1310, and 1490 nm in PON standard is also discussed.
1.4.14 Chapter 15. Market trends for optical amplifiers (Daryl Inniss) At the peak of the telecom bubble in 1999e2000, the size of the optical amplifier market was projected to grow to $5 billion in five years. However, 10 years later the market size is more than one order of magnitude lower at $300 million, and is projected to remain on a plateau over the next five years. The market stagnation is caused by the continual demand for amplification cost reduction, which nearly compensates the 10% to 15% year-to-year growth in number of optical amplifier (OA) units deployed. Carriers are not willing to pay a premium for extra performance such as rapid gain control to suppress transients in the network. The market is therefore dominated by three or four incumbent suppliers, who also control the expensive in feeds and can offer integrated higher level solutions, such as a ROADM card incorporating WSS and OAs and optical performance monitoring (OPM). There has not been a new OA start-up in more than five years. There are some emerging bright spots such as the expected growth for low-cost, single-channel amps including SOAs for the PON application and high-bit-rate power boosters and pre-
19
20
CHAPTER 1 Optical amplifiers for next generation WDM networks
amps. The other area attracting market attention is the Raman amplifier, which is expected to rapidly grow in market size either as a stand-alone unit or in conjunction with the EDFA to support the higher OSNR requirement of the 100 Gb/s and higher data rate channels. This chapter presents an analysis of the market forces contributing to the present trends in the amplification segment. Current market drivers include the traffic growth in the core network, the move to narrower channel spacing in the metro area networks, and rapid introduction of ROADMs and 40 Gb/s and 100 Gb/s channels. The author also highlights the emerging market for the single-channel amplifiers in the access PON and high-power amplifiers in the CATV distribution fiber to the x (FTTx) networks. There is considerable pricing pressure on the amplifier suppliers, and the emergence of network equipment vendors from east Asia has posed even an greater challenge. The control of key components and ability to make higher functional modules combining amplifiers for example with dispersion compensating modules (DCMs), WSSs, etc. has prevented new entrants to the amplifier supplier market. At the same time there is a crowding of the amplifier vendor space and not yet enough consolidation. In summary, the author points out that while the amplifier market is in an evolutionary phase characterized by both steady growth and significant commercial challenges, there are opportunities for innovation and room for entrants with novel solutions.
ACRONYMS AGC ATM CATV CD CPM CSRZ DCM DWDM EDFA EDWA FPM FTTx GPON IEC LOS NC&M NEM OA
Automatic gain control Asynchronous transfer mode Cable television (or community antenna television) Chromatic dispersion Cross phase modulation Carrier suppressed return to zero Dispersion compensating module Dense wavelength division multiplexing Erbium-doped fiber amplifier Erbium-doped waveguide amplifier Four photon mixing Fiber to the x (x ¼ home, building, curb, .) Gigabit passive optical network (ITU-T G.984) International Electrotechnical Commission Loss of signal Network control and management Network equipment manufacturer Optical amplifier
Acknowledgements
OFDM OPM OSNR PDL PM-QPSK PLC PMD PON ROADM RZ SHB SOA SDH SONET SRS VOA WDM WSS
Orthogonal frequency division multiplexing Optical performance monitoring Optical signal-to-noise ratio Polarization dependent loss Polarization multiplexed quadrature phase shift keying Photonic light wave circuit Polarization mode dispersion Passive optical network Reconfigurable optical add/drop multiplexer Return to zero Spectral hole burning Semiconductor optical amplifier Synchronous digital hierarchy Synchronous optical network Stimulated Raman scattering Variable optical attenuator Wavelength division multiplexer Wavelength selective switch
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We are sincerely grateful to Tim Pitts and Melanie Benson of Elsevier for their gracious support and patience during the whole process of publication of this book. We are also thankful to the authors for their efforts in preparing the manuscript highlighting the recent developments in their respective fields. Finally, we hope the reader will enjoy reading this book and benefit from its contents.
References [1] E. Desurvire, J.R. Simpson, P.C. Becker, High-gain erbium-doped fibre amplifier, Opt. Lett. 12 (11) (1987) 888. [2] R.J. Mears, L. Reekie, I.M. Jauncey, D.N. Payne, Low-noise erbium-doped fibre amplifier operating at 1.54 mm, Electron. Lett. 23 (19) (1987) 1026. [3] R. Monnard, H.K. Lee, Suppressing Amplifier Transients in Lightwave Systems, Proceedings of the LEOS Summer Topical Meeting, Paper WE3 (2002). [4] Y. Sun, J.L. Zyskind, A.K. Srivastava, J.W. Sulhoff, C. Wolf, R.W. Tkatch, Fast Power Transients in WDM Optical Networks with Cascaded EDFAs, Electon. Lett. 33 (4) (1997) 313. [5] Telcordia GRE-253-Core, SONET Transport Systems: Common Generic Criteria, no. 4, December 2005. [6] P. Bonnenfant, Protection and Restoration in Optical Networks, Tutorial FF1, Optical Fiber Communications Conference, San Diego, CA, February 21e26, 1999. Optical
21
22
CHAPTER 1 Optical amplifiers for next generation WDM networks
[7]
[8] [9] [10]
Layer Protection and Restoration, Short Course SC113/153, Optical Fiber Communications Conference, Anaheim CA, March 17e22, 2001. R. Monnard, A.K. Srivastava, Optical Amplifier Transient Suppression Requirements for Dynamic DWDM Networks. Invited Paper Presentation: Optical Amplifiers and their Applications, Otaru, Japan, (2003) July 6e9, 2003. Ja´nos Farkas, Alberto Paradisi, Csaba Antal, Low-cost survivable Ethernet architecture over fiber, J. Opt. Netw. 5 (5) (2006) 398e409. Private communication from industry sources. International Electrotechnical Commission Documents, Optical Amplifiers - Test Methods - Part 4-1: Transient parameters – Two-wavelength method (61290-4-1) and Part 4-2: Broadband source method (61290-4-2) (to be published) Courtsey: IEC and David Menashe
CHAPTER
ROADM-Based Networks
2
Brandon C. Collings* and Peter Roorda** *
2 Applegate Drive, Robbinsville, NJ,
**
61 Bill Leathem Drive, Ottawa, Ontario
CHAPTER OUTLINE HEAD 2.1. Introduction ...................................................................................................... 23 2.2. Evolution of the ROADM component and network ................................................. 27 2.2.1. Wavelength blocker ......................................................................... 27 2.2.2. Planar light wave circuitry (PLC)-ROADM .......................................... 29 2.2.3. Wavelength selective switch............................................................. 30 2.3. Impact on optical amplifiers requirements........................................................... 35 2.4. Increased density and functional integration of ROADM technology ...................... 37 2.5. Emerging applications and uses of ROADM networks ........................................... 39 2.5.1. Colorless add/drop architectures....................................................... 41 2.5.2. Directionless add/drop architectures ................................................. 41 2.6. Summary........................................................................................................... 43 Acronyms ................................................................................................................. 44 References ............................................................................................................... 45
2.1 INTRODUCTION Early optical networks capitalized on the high bandwidth capacity and transmission reach offered by the combination of an optical frequency carrier and very low loss optical telecommunications fiber. As the need for bandwidth capacity continued to increase, the combination of multiple optical signals at distinct wavelengths onto a single transmission fiber, each carrying independent information streams, provided an economically attractive method to further increase the total information carried by a single fiber. Known as wavelength division multiplexing (WDM) and later dense wavelength division multiplexing (DWDM), this technique has driven the total bandwidth capacity of a single fiber from a relatively meager 155 Mb/s well into the multiple Tb/s capacities of today’s commercial systems, an increase of over four orders of magnitude. Given that DWDM technology transports independent information on separate wavelength channels, the use of wavelength-specific filtering to physically separate and route traffic within a network has proven to be a very cost effective approach to Optically Amplified WDM Networks. DOI: 10.1016/B978-0-12-374965-9.10002-0 Copyright Ó 2011 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
23
24
CHAPTER 2 ROADM-based networks
managing the overall traffic topology within an optical network. It is preferable to using exclusively electrical switching fabrics for two general reasons: The first is that the costs of the optical filtering elements to separate and insert a single DWDM wavelength channel are typically significantly lower than the corresponding costs of terminating all the DWDM channels into the electrical domain, electrically grooming that traffic, and then regenerating all traffic bypassing the node. The second reason is that, unlike typical electronic receiving, switching, and regenerating equipment, optical filtering is agnostic to the protocol and line rate of the traffic carried by a particular wavelength. This results in simpler network operation and upgrade as new and different traffic protocols and line rates can be introduced without replacing any intermediate elements of the network infrastructure. Prior to the introduction of reconfigurable optical network technology, networks generally consisted of point-to-point optical transmission systems interconnecting electrical switching fabrics or ring networks with optical channel filters permanently deployed at each node of the ring to extract and insert wavelengths from and onto the ring. Figure 2.1 illustrates a transmission network with fixed wavelength multiplexing and demultiplexing terminal nodes with electronic based regeneration and bandwidth management situated at the center of each node. In early DWDM deployments in the mid-to-late 1990s, point-to-point topologies were the norm. Optical reach limitations typically resulted in the need to terminate all wavelengths for regeneration purposes. In shorter reach networks where reach was not a constraint, electrical access to the payload to allow sub-wavelength granularity bandwidth management also necessitated the termination of wavelengths into electrical cross-connects or synchronous optical networks (SONET) or synchronous digital hierarchy (SDH) add-drop multiplexers (ADMs). As the optical reach of systems was extended and the number of wavelengths supported per fiber increased, it became both possible and desirable for some wavelength channels to optically bypass some nodes to both simplify the node and eliminate opto-electronic termination equipment previously required to allow traffic to bypass the node. To enable this, fixed wavelength optical add-drop multiplexers (OADMs), shown in Figure 2.2, were introduced in rings or linear chains. These
FIGURE 2.1 Diagram of a typical point-to-point DWDM transmission system employing fixed wavelength multiplexers and demultiplexers, electronic regeneration, and sub-wavelength bandwidth management
2.1 Introduction
FIGURE 2.2 Diagram of a typical point-to-point DWDM transmission system employing fixed wavelength OADM multiplexers and demultiplexers to add and drop optical wavelengths
OADMs were constructed using fixed filters that essentially determined at the time of the network commissioning which wavelengths would locally drop and which would pass through at each node. In addition to being fixed, wavelength banding could be used to reduce loss and filter-based spectral degradation. The introduction of fixed OADMs provided the opportunity to save network cost by eliminating unnecessary optical to electrical to optical conversion, but carried with it a number of key limitations that ultimately limited their application. Network operators were required to carefully plan the network topology at the time of deployment based on how they expected the network traffic to evolve. If these predictions were not accurate and barriers to new bandwidth service deployments surfaced, inefficient workarounds or new system deployments became necessary, both costly consequences considering the initial network may have unused, but inaccessible, bandwidth elsewhere. This effectively reintroduced much of the cost savings that had been achieved by optical bypass. Furthermore, when channels were added into fixed DWDM networks, significant care was needed to control the power level and the manner by which the channel was introduced to optimize performance and ensure existing channels were not impacted. While this was quite manageable in point-to-point configurations, the complexity of the power engineering quickly increased as fixed OADMs were introduced, essentially limiting fixed OADMs to tightly constrained applications (specifically linear OADM chains or hubbed rings). The combination of forecast-intolerant initial filter deployments with complex and manual wavelength deployment procedures conspired to slow network capacity deployment. Prior to the age of consumer driven internet applications and the concurrent explosion of user bandwidth consumption [1], reasonably accurate network planning was possible. Today however, network operators are simultaneously faced with escalating bandwidth requirements, less predictable and more dynamic traffic topologies, and an increasingly competitive marketplace. Therefore, many have turned to reconfigurable optical add/drop multiplexer (ROADM) technology to provide an optical network infrastructure over which they can flexibly deploy
25
26
CHAPTER 2 ROADM-based networks
wavelengths generally between any pair of nodes with relative independence from how other active wavelengths in the network are already provisioned. Furthermore, this flexibility is available to the operator without requiring any interruption of existing traffic, a critical requirement of network operation. This flexibility allows the network operators to grow and adapt the traffic topologies of their networks as traffic demands emerge in a cost effective and operationally efficient manner. It also extends the operational life of a deployed network infrastructure as capacity increases in regions with unanticipated higher demands can be accommodated. In comparison, in fixed-wavelength topology systems, the number of wavelengths serving a given region is determined during the initial network deployment, and areas with higher than anticipated growth can become capacity bottlenecks, resulting in the need for inefficient solutions. Also, as ROADM networks provide an infrastructure that is effectively optically transparent to the line rate and protocol of the traffic passing through it, newly provisioned wavelengths can use higher bit rates, seamlessly support traffic of differing protocols, and take advantage of recent transmission technology advancements such as advanced modulation formats [2] and impairment mitigation strategies [3,4]. Historically, optical networks have often been constructed using ring topologies with electronic switch fabrics interconnecting traffic between optical ring networks as needed at junction points. Another attractive feature of modern ROADM networks is the ability to replace these electronic interconnection facilities with the capability of directly routing optical wavelength channels between optical rings without translating the signals through the electrical domain. More specifically, ROADM networks can optically interconnect wavelengths between different node degrees (fiber trunk pairs entering a network node), essentially creating an alloptical wavelength cross-connect capable of routing wavelengths between any pair of degrees (provided no two like wavelength signals are attempted to be routed to the same degree). Given that equivalent electrical switch fabrics and associated optical transponders are more expensive to deploy, power, spare, and maintain, avoiding the translation through the electronic domain frequently yields significant network cost savings. This multidegree optical interconnection capability enables more general mesh network topologies and a flatter network structure that is generally easier to manage and expand. However, capitalizing on the ability to optically route wavelength channels within the mesh network requires that the optical transmitted wavelengths both have sufficient reach and do not suffer significant impairments from propagating through the ROADM nodes [5]. Finally, ROADM networks generally offer an increased level of embedded monitoring of the optical transmission layer as well as the automation of optical power control and wavelength routing. Many ROADM networks incorporate optical channel power monitors which, along with the ROADM components’ ability to independently control each channel’s optical power, enable the ROADM network to continuously monitor and automatically optimize every channel’s power level. This results in a network that is simpler and more reliable to deploy as fewer manual adjustments are required; more robust over time as power levels are
2.2 Evolution of the ROADM component and network
continuously adjusted toward an optimum operating point; and easier to monitor and detect problems before they become critical. These features translate into decreased operational expenditures and the reduction of new bandwidth service deployment intervals from multiple months down to, potentially, days or less, allowing for more rapid customer capture and less time to revenue from new services.
2.2 EVOLUTION OF THE ROADM COMPONENT AND NETWORK 2.2.1 Wavelength blocker Optical reconfigurability with wavelength granularity was initially introduced into two-degree nodes (nodes with two bi-directional pairs of transmission fibers) using a typical node architecture as shown in Figure 2.3. A broadband optical power coupler on the inbound transmission fiber provides a copy of all inbound wavelengths to a demultiplexing filter structure, allowing any independent combination of wavelengths to be received at this node. A similar structure, used in the reverse direction and connected to a coupler on the outbound transmission fiber, enables the injection of any combination of wavelengths. The critical optical component in this design is the wavelength blocker (WB), a two-port device that can independently attenuate (block) each and any combination of wavelength channels. The WB is placed between the drop coupler of one degree of the node and the add coupler of the other degree with the responsibility of blocking any wavelength signal terminating at this node. By blocking a wavelength channel that has been dropped, a new signal at the same wavelength can be inserted in the outbound direction of the opposite side of the node, allowing wavelength channels to be reused on either side of the node. This overall node architecture allows the network operator to independently select which channels entering/leaving a node are to be dropped/added by directing the WB to block those wavelength channels and which are to be routed through the node by directing the WB to be transparent to those channels.
FIGURE 2.3 Diagram of 2-D ROADM node using a wavelength blocker
27
28
CHAPTER 2 ROADM-based networks
In general, WB components are composed of three functional stages as shown in Figure 2.4. In the first stage, the wavelength channels are spatially separated by a dispersive element such as a diffraction grating. Each of the wavelength signals then encounters a spatial array of optically attenuating elements with one or more independently controllable element(s) per wavelength channel. Finally, all the spatially dispersed wavelength signals are recombined and launched into a single output fiber. Thus, channels can be independently attenuated or blocked through adjustment of the respective attenuation elements. The ability to independently attenuate unblocked channels enables equalization of the optical power levels of channels expressed through a node. Channel power equalization provides greater reach of the optical signals as the power levels of weaker channels (caused by uneven optical amplifier gain, spectrally dependent fiber attenuation, and Ramaninduced inter-channel energy exchange) are renormalized. As the equalization is typically automated, continuous and driven by closed-loop feedback from direct channel power level measurements, this also provides greater system stability and reliability. The WB solves the two key problems associated with fixed OADMs. First, decisions on which wavelengths are add/dropped can be flexibly determined as the network grows, avoiding stranding of unused wavelengths inherent in banded and fixed-wavelength OADMs. Secondly, the means to automate the power control function on a per-wavelength basis allows more controlled introduction of new wavelengths into the system and vastly reduces the complexity of provisioning new wavelengths. The high-capacity long-haul and regional portions of the core network were the initial segments in which systems incorporating WBs were deployed. Given the significant bandwidth these networks carried and the growth they experienced, the ability to flexibly add new wavelength channels reduced the operational expense of supporting that growth and extended the systems’ ability to accommodate that growth. Also, as these systems typically propagated over long distances, the ability to accurately and dynamically maintain the channels’ optical power levels at the desired levels increased the performance and reliability of the transmission which results in lower operational costs.
FIGURE 2.4 Functional diagram of wavelength blocker component
2.2 Evolution of the ROADM component and network
2.2.2 Planar light wave circuitry (PLC)-ROADM An early alternative approach to ROADM implementation was to use planar light wave circuitry (PLC) technology. PLC has been extensively used for arrayed waveguide gratings (AWG) for multiplexing and demultiplexing elements. As active optical functions, such as space switches and attenuators, can also be constructed in solid state PLC technology using Mach-Zehnder interferometers (MZI), the natural evolution of ROADM component technology was to integrate per-wavelength optical routing and power control capabilities with the channel multiplexer and demultiplexer. A functional diagram of a typical PLC-ROADM component and node is shown in Figure 2.5. Similar to the WB architecture, an optical copy of the channels entering a node is directed to a channel demultiplexing structure so that any combination of channels may be locally received. The other copy is directed to the opposite degree of the node and separated according to wavelength using an AWG demultiplexer. Each channel is then directed to a dedicated 2x1 optical space switch with the other input to the switch constituting the respective add port for that channel. The position of each 2x1 switch determines if the locally added channel or the channel from the opposite side of the node will be directed outbound from the node. The output of each switch is passed through an independent optical attenuator followed by all channels being recombined into a single output by an AWG channel multiplexer. The MZIs typically allow relatively fast (w1ms) switching enabling optical protection switching applications. The channel demultiplexer for channels propagating in one direction is integrated with the demultiplexer-switch/attenuator array-multiplexer structure for the channel propagating in the opposite direction (see Figure 2.5) to form a single component that provides the combined functionality for one fiber degree as depicted in the figure. An identical component is used for the second fiber degree in order to maintain equipment separability between opposite degrees of the node, and therefore diverse risk groups for protection purposes. Integration and co-packaging of these elements enable reduced overall costs relative to WB architectures. In addition, optical power monitors can be readily integrated
FIGURE 2.5 Diagram of 2-D ROADM node incorporating PLC-ROADM component
29
30
CHAPTER 2 ROADM-based networks
into the PLC component allowing very high-speed and accurate channel power level monitoring at add, express, and drop locations with low incremental costs. However, similar to the WB, node architectures built from PLC-ROADMs are practically limited to two-degree implementations. Another critical characteristic of PLC-ROADM technology (not necessarily present in WB components) is the limited ability to design AWG multiplexers with wide and predominantly flat channel passbands. For metro networks where a given optical channel may need to propagate through 16 or more nodes, and thus PLC-ROADMs, the repeated filtering by the AWG multiplexers and demultiplexers progressively reduces the bandwidth available to the channel. While the cascadability performance is acceptable for 100 GHz channel spaced applications with 10 Gb/s wavelengths where less than 30 GHz of net bandwidth is required (primarily due to the unlocked wavelength drift of the transmitting laser), PLC-ROADMs with a 50 GHz channel spacing cannot support that necessary amount of bandwidth. As the industry looked toward higher channel line rates, the need to provide as much channel bandwidth as possible, through more than 16 nodes and with 50GHz channel spacing, became a severe limitation for PLC-ROADM devices and consideration of these devices for new network designs declined.
2.2.3 Wavelength selective switch The third generation of ROADM technology and the one that is dominant in current systems is the wavelength selectable switch (WSS). Figure 2.6 shows the basic functional diagram of a 1xN port WSS which is capable of independently routing each channel injected into the common port to any one of the N output ports. Typically, WSS components are optically bidirectional such that the channels from the N ports are selectively multiplexed according to origin port onto the single common (output) port. In addition, the WSS can impart a provisioned amount of attenuation independently to each wavelength channel or may block any channel. Note that when N¼1, the resulting WSS has the same functionality as a WB. The common node architecture construction using WSS elements is shown in Figure 2.7. Similar to the WB node architecture (see Figure 2.3), a copy of the
FIGURE 2.6 Functional diagram of WSS component (Section 3.d.i)
2.2 Evolution of the ROADM component and network
FIGURE 2.7 Diagram of a WSS-based 4-degree ROADM node using a multiplexing WSS and colored add/drop
incoming channels is demultiplexed allowing any combination of channels to be locally received. The WSS is positioned on the outbound side of each degree. The channels coming into each degree are further split into multiple fibers with a copy of each set of channels directed to one of the N ports of each WSS of every other degree (except the degree in which the channels entered the node). Channels that are to be locally added are multiplexed together and injected into one of the N ports of the WSS. The common port of the WSS is connected to the output transmission fiber of the respective degree. Thus, across the N ports of every WSS, a copy of every channel entering the entire node is present. For each degree and for each wavelength, the WSS is then provisioned to route wavelength signals from one of the N ports to its respective common port. Therefore, with this architecture, any wavelength entering a node can be routed to the output of any one or more other degrees, limited by the condition that only a single channel for each wavelength may leave via each degree. Channel power level equalization is implemented by each WSS, independently imparting the proper amount of attenuation to each channel routed through the WSS. As can be seen in Figure 2.7, the value of N for the WSS determines the maximum number of degrees the node configuration can support. For core metro and long-haul networks, values of N as high as 8 are currently of interest. However, for networks residing closer to the end consumer with less need for multidegree optical mesh connectivity, there is strong interest in WSSs with N¼2 simply for the purpose of reducing the cost of the WSS component yet maintaining the full channel granularity flexibility of the higher-degree configurations. Figure 2.8 shows an alternative node architecture where a WSS is installed into each degree with the common port of each WSS connected to the inbound transmission fiber of respective degree. Some of the N ports are then connected to an
31
32
CHAPTER 2 ROADM-based networks
FIGURE 2.8 Diagram of a WSS-based 4-degree ROADM node using a demultiplexing WSS and colorless add/drop
input port of N:1 power splitters/combiners (PS) in each of the other degrees. For channels that are to be locally received, some of the N WSS ports are designated as drop ports and the WSS is instructed to route only one wavelength channel to each of these ports. Each WSS is then configured to direct each channel to the desired degree or drop port, or to block it completely. Channels to be locally added are combined using an M:1 optical power combiner and the output connected to one of the N:1 power combiner inputs. Note that the provisioning of the WSSs and each add multiplexing stage must be coordinated such that only one signal per wavelength is directed to each of the N:1 couplers to avoid a collision of same-wavelength signals. Channel power level equalization is also executed by introducing the proper attenuation to each channel routed through each WSS. In this architecture, each of the drop ports is not permanently assigned a specific wavelength, but rather the wavelength to be dropped from each of these ports is determined by which wavelength is routed to that port by the WSS. Similarly, the add ports have no permanent wavelength assignment. Add/drop ports with this characteristic are know as “colorless” ports and are attractive as they increase the level of flexibility as the operating wavelength of a given colorless port can be assigned and changed by the network operating system at any time. Also, as typically only a subset of the full complement of channels entering a node are needed to be locally added/dropped, colorless ports allow for fewer add/drop ports to be physically presented (relative to AWG demultiplexers which typically possess ports for all channels) thereby saving valuable faceplate space and cost. Figure 2.9 shows the general functional construction of a WSS component which is typically similar to that of a WB. The wavelength signals inserted into the common port of the WSS are spatially separated by a wavelength dispersive device and directed to an array of actuators capable of deflecting each wavelength beam in a controllable angle orthogonal to the axis of wavelength dispersion. The deflected
2.2 Evolution of the ROADM component and network
FIGURE 2.9 Diagram of a general example of the internal design of a WSS
signals are then recombined in the wavelength dispersion direction resulting in N beams of channel groups with each beam comprised of wavelengths that received the same amount of angular deflection. Each beam is coupled into one of the N output fibers. Thus, each channel can be independently routed by adjusting the deflection angle of each actuator for each respective wavelength to the deflection angle corresponding to the desired output port. To operate the device in reverse, the same process is followed with the light propagating in the reverse direction. Per channel attenuation and blocking is generally obtained by adjusting the deflection angle of each channel actuator to detune the coupling efficiency with the output fiber. WSS components can use a variety of deflection angle actuator array technologies [6] including micro electro-mechanical systems (MEMS) mirror arrays [7], arrays of liquid crystal on silicon (LCoS) phase modulators [8], liquid crystal (LC) polarization based switches [9], digital light processing (DLP) mirror arrays [10], and combinations of multiple technologies [11]. For MEMS actuators, an array of tiltable mirrors is fabricated, each with a highly reflective coating. By tilting each mirror (typically one mirror per channel), the beam for each channel can be independently steered among the output fibers allowing the desired output fiber to be selected and coupling efficiency to that fiber to be controlled. LCoS actuators are composed of a large two-dimensional array of optical phase modulators. Angular deflection is achieved by establishing a linearly varying phase retardation profile in one direction of the two-dimensional array. This manipulation of the phase front of the optical beam causes the beam to be deflected by an angle proportional to the rate of change of the phase retardation across the array. The other axis of the array is aligned with the wavelength dispersion direction.
33
34
CHAPTER 2 ROADM-based networks
Actuators using LC technology use the polarization rotation capability of a layer of LC material to variably adjust the orientation of the polarization state of the passing light, followed by a birefringent wedge, to spatially separate the incoming beam into two separate beams with a splitting ratio dependent on the alignment of the polarization state of the light with the axis of the wedge. Therefore, by controlling the polarization state with the LC layer, the beam can be deflected into one of two directions, or split into both directions with a variable ratio. By cascading x sets of these beam steering arrangements with decreasing (or increasing) deflection magnitudes, the ability to deflect the initial beam into 2x discrete output ports is achieved. Similar to the other technologies, an array of such deflection actuators is aligned to the wavelength dispersion direction. Attenuation and blocking can be achieved by adding a stage to partially or fully deflect the beam in an unused direction. The DLP mirror array actuator is composed of a two-dimensional array of binary tiltable mirrors. One axis of the array is aligned in the dispersion direction. In the orthogonal direction, all mirrors are actuated to the same binary state deflecting the entire beam. As the dimension of the individual mirrors is smaller than the practical optical beam size; the beam covers a large number of individual mirrors. Given the binary nature of the DLP mirror tilt, N values greater than 2 may require multiple bounces off of different sections of the DLP array. Similarly, attenuation can be achieved by tilting a fraction of the mirrors covered by the beam; however, as the discarded power is reflected in the other binary direction, attenuation functionality requires an additional bounce off an independent section of DLP mirrors. The most critical performance parameters for the WSS are generally the spectral bandwidth and shape of each wavelength channel and the suppression of wavelength channels from being emitted from unintended ports. To support higher line rate wavelengths, a wide and square channel bandwidth is necessary to avoid bandwidth narrowing from the cumulative filtering resulting from multiple passes through WSSs within the network. Secondly, sufficient suppression of wavelength channels from passing to unintended ports is critically necessary as insufficient suppression can result in an accumulation of optical crosstalk and ultimately signal performance degradation [12]. When used to build a WSS, each switch engine technology has both strengths and weaknesses. MEMS mirror arrays provide channel bandwidths in excess of 40GHz (for a 50GHz channel spacing) and port isolation performance typically better than 45dB, and allow for short optical path lengths that translate into compact physical component volumes maintained as the number of ports is increased. However, as the channel wavelength filtering is defined by the MEMS mirror geometry, variable wavelength channel passbands is not practical and wavelength channels cannot be broadcast to multiple output ports. Also, as channel attenuation is implemented through slight misalignment of the coupling to the output fiber, the open-loop attenuation accuracy depends on the stability of the MEMS mirror. LCoS and LC based actuators can support both variable wavelength channel passbands, accurate open-loop attenuation, and channel broadcast to multiple output ports to some extent; however, port isolation is typically around or
2.3 Impact on optical amplifiers requirements
below 40dB and wide channel passband widths can require a more challenging optical system design. Also, longer optical path lengths are generally needed which results in larger component volumes as the port count increases or the channel spacing decreases.
2.3 IMPACT ON OPTICAL AMPLIFIERS REQUIREMENTS Reconfigurable optical networks require optical amplification to compensate the attenuation of the transmission fiber in generally the same manner as needed by earlier fixed wavelength networks. However, due to the significant differences in both the network and node architectures along with the increasingly dynamic utilization of the networks’ flexibility, the requirements placed on the optical amplifiers differ significantly. To implement the flexibility and photonic cross-connect capabilities that define a reconfigurable optical network, the typical ROADM node architecture requires two optical amplifiers (as shown in the figures in the preceding section). In general, one amplifier on the inbound fiber to the node is positioned and designed to compensate the loss of the preceding fiber span, whereas the second amplifier is typically positioned adjacent to the outbound fiber to compensate the splitting and component losses within the node and prepare the channel optical powers for launch into the transmission fiber. Given this reference node configuration and the loss characteristics of modern ROADM components, the gain required by the outbound amplifier is generally around 19 dB (9dB for 8-degree splitting loss, 6 dB for the WSS component and 3 dB for channel power equalization). As the loss within the node is reasonably constant, this outbound optical amplifier (OA) is designed to have a constant amount of gain or a reasonably narrow variable gain range. In contrast, the inbound amplifier often requires larger amounts of gain, often 25 dB or more, to compensate for fiber spans of 80 km or more. Furthermore, as the fiber span loss varies from span to span (and it is operationally desirable to design as few amplifier variants as practical within a given network system product offering), the inbound amplifier is typically designed to have variable gain to allow a single amplifier variant to support the corresponding range of span losses. Also, as most networks incorporate chromatic dispersion compensation on a per span basis, the losses of these compensation elements are typically offset by inserting the dispersion compensation element between two gain stages of the inbound amplifier. Because the dispersion compensation elements have significant insertion loss, adding them between the input amplifier and output amplifier together would significantly degrade the performance of the ROADM node for two reasons: first, because the loss between the amplifiers would become significantly larger and comparable to or even greater than the span loss, and second, because typical dispersion compensation elements are composed of dispersion compensating fibers in which significant nonlinear penalties are generated at low powers, the power launched from the input amplifier would need to be reduced, which would degrade the ROADM node noise performance.
35
36
CHAPTER 2 ROADM-based networks
For many network applications where fiber spans are longer, the gain required by the inbound amplifier is often larger than that required of the outbound amplifier, and as the nominal output power levels of both inbound and outbound amplifiers is often similar (for economic considerations), the degradation of a given channel’s optical signal-to-noise ratio (OSNR) is dominated by the noise performance of the inbound amplifiers. As ROADMs enable all-optical mesh networking, the need is growing for optical links to propagate through larger numbers of nodes and fiber spans before requiring expensive conversion into the electrical domain, thereby applying pressure to reduce the OSNR degradation a link experiences as much as possible. Historically, one key limitation of optically amplified transmission systems has been the flatness of the amplification gain spectrum. As the gain spectrum of erbiumdoped fiber optical amplifiers is naturally far from constant versus wavelength and changes depending upon the erbium ion inversion operating point of the amplifier, many techniques have been employed to mitigate this characteristic and thereby provide as consistently spectrally constant gain as possible. However, despite many amplifier improvements, in non-ROADM systems, non-flat gain remains a considerable source of system reach limitations. Several spectral equalization approaches have been developed to compensate the unequal spectra gain and thereby extend the link reach by periodically resetting those spectral areas or channels that have received too little or too much gain back to their desired nominal power levels. As current ROADM components have the ability to manipulate each channel independently, they generally have the ability to also independently impart a controllable amount of attenuation to each channel, thereby providing channel power level equalization at each ROADM node. This naturally incorporated channel equalization allows for frequent channel power level rebalancing and minimizes the excursion magnitude each channel may experience before being rebalanced and consequently minimizes the potential subsequent OSNR degradation and nonlinear penalties. In order to accomplish this channel power equalization, some means by which to measure the individual channel powers is necessary in order to assign the proper amount of equalization. This ability to measure and control individual channel power levels at each network node generally allows ROADM networks to incorporate highly automated channel power level management. This provides the network operator a number of advantages including increased and accurate visibility into the network’s health and current operating points, continuous and accurate channel power level optimization, and the elimination of manual power level adjustments during installation (which requires time and expertise, is not typically high resolution, is not dynamic, and is prone to errors). In addition, this automated power control functionality can also be harnessed to provide the power level controlled introduction and removal of individual channels and nodes within an operating network. By implementing these controls, events that trigger rapid changes to the optical power levels in the network resulting in detrimental and transient gain deviations within the amplifiers can be limited. Specifically, the power levels of newly provisioned channels can be slowly increased such that the gain control algorithms of the amplifiers (and the channel
2.4 Increased density and functional integration of ROADM technology
power equalizers) can adiabatically adapt resulting in very limited power excursions of pre-existing channels. Similarly, when adding new segments to an operating network, the gain of the newly commissioned line amplifiers can be slowly increased so that no rapid power fluctuations are experienced. Conversely, during the decommissioning of a channel or network segment, the automated power control management system can slowly reduce the corresponding power appropriately until its level is insufficient to perturb the remaining portions of the network when the transponder or amplifier is finally disabled or physically disconnected. Therefore, within a properly operating system, power transients are quite significantly mitigated for a large number of the events within the normal scope of network operations. However, these control systems cannot mitigate all power level transientcausing events that may occur, namely fiber or hardware equipment failure and improper fiber cable disconnection. But, in each of these cases, the consequence is a rapid decrease in optical power within the network. As it is reasonable to architect and design ROADM network systems and their optical power management systems such that events resulting in a rapid increase in optical power should be rare under proper operating conditions, power level transient mitigation within the optical amplifiers may limit their focus on controlling gain transients resulting from a rapid decrease in input optical power. The inclusion of per-channel power level measurement also provides the opportunity to employ more sophisticated optical amplifier gain control algorithms that use this knowledge of the current present wavelength channel population as well as their relative power levels to provide more accurate and spectrally constant gain. However, there are some considerable practical limitations to this capability as the components employed to measure the channel power levels (optical channel monitors) typically make periodic measurements that are slow relative to the desired transient control time scales. Therefore, this information can be used to fine-tune the amplifier gain control during periods where the power levels are effectively stable; however, as real-time information of the current situation is not available during the short time scale while a transient event is transpiring, the gain control improvements are somewhat limited.
2.4 INCREASED DENSITY AND FUNCTIONAL INTEGRATION OF ROADM TECHNOLOGY Earlier sections in this chapter have highlighted the evolution of ROADM networks as enabled by the expanding performance and capabilities or ROADM technology. An important additional trend is the move toward higher ROADM component densities and the functional integration of ROADM sub-elements. A ROADM node is built up of a number of functional modules (often referred to as “line cards” or “circuit packs”): amplifier modules act as pre-amplifiers for signals entering the node and booster amplifiers for signals launching onto the fiber, ROADM modules provide the key optical switching and power attenuation
37
38
CHAPTER 2 ROADM-based networks
functions, multiplexer and demultiplexer modules provide channel separation for add/drop, and optical channel monitor modules provide per channel power monitoring at select points in the node. These modules are deployed onto a telecom shelf that provides communications among the modules and from a shelf controller that manages the coordinated operation of the elements. Typically, the key modules required for a two-degree ROADM node can occupy a large portion of an equipment chassis. The space consumed is largely dictated by the physical size of the underlying optical components in the node. Amplifier and ROADM components use up a significant portion of the space on the motherboard of shelf modules. Specifically, for ROADM modules, the height of the components often results in shelf modules that consume multiple “slots” in the shelfdtypically two or three slots per ROADM module in a 20-slot shelf. For this reason, recent component development activities have focused on miniaturization of ROADM components with particular emphasis on new low-profile wavelength selective switches with component height to enable single-slot implementations. As enabling optical components shrink, combining multiple architecturally adjacent components into a single module is required to further improve density. While collapsing the entire ROADM node into a single module is problematic due to the resulting “single point of failure” for terminating traffic, the goal of combining the amplifiers, ROADM components, and optical channel monitor (OCM) for one degree of a ROADM node into a single module is attracting considerable attention within the industry. This goal requires not only miniaturization of the various components, but also requires that the packaging for each subelement be optimized. Figure 2.10 a) indicates the key optical functional blocks of one direction of a WSS-based ROADM node. Today this configuration is often separated into multiple modules which may include a two-slot WSS module, a pre-amplifier module, a booster amplifier module, an OCM module, and a shelf processor to coordinate control and management of the node. Figure 2.10 b) is a photograph of an example module with all these functions integrated. Achieving this density requires not only miniaturization of the optical sub-elements, but also novel packaging approaches and advanced mechanical and thermal design techniques. This type of higher level integration will allow not only density improvements but the cost reductions associated with elimination of the electronics and mechanical costs of housing each element in individual modules. Once the traditional demarcation points between optical functions have been blurred through integration, there is potential to optimize the combined erbium-doped fiber amplifier (EDFA)-WSSOCM control to improve responsiveness and accuracy versus a node where real-time control is limited to individual modules. Also, this integrated approach will reduce the operational complexities associated with multiple different cards including inventory management, node commissioning, and fault isolation. The integration conceived of in Figure 2.10 is likely only an initial step toward more fundamental integration that may be achievable with such approaches as monolithic planar waveguide circuits.
2.5 Emerging applications and uses of ROADM networks
(a)
(b)
FIGURE 2.10 a) Functional diagram and b) photograph of a highly integrated ROADM circuit pack incorporating two optical amplifiers, a WSS, a channel monitor, and associated passive optical components and control electronics
2.5 EMERGING APPLICATIONS AND USES OF ROADM NETWORKS For most operators, the initial ROADM network deployments were motivated by wavelength topology flexibility and the multidegree cross-connect (ring interconnect) capabilities offered by ROADM network systems. These features use the dynamic switching capabilities of the ROADM systems during the wavelength provisioning
39
40
CHAPTER 2 ROADM-based networks
process. However, in general, once a wavelength is deployed within the network, it remains unchanged relatively indefinitely. Network operators are now looking at leveraging the dynamic flexibility inherent within ROADM networks to capture more operational advantages by using that network flexibility to better and more efficiently respond to transient events within the network such as fiber breaks and equipment failures. In an operation physically similar to the configuration of a new wavelength, a wavelength channel that has encountered a failed segment in the network can be re-provisioned along a new physical route avoiding the failed segment and its connectivity restored. In many cases, this “re-provisioning,” or photonic restoration, can be accomplished exclusively through the network management system without the requirement of any physical intervention into the network and can typically be accomplished in an interval of seconds to minutes. Typically, this photonic restoration would operate as a secondary mechanism to a primary service protection switch (such as SONET/ SDH or L2/L3). Therefore, the photonic restoration capabilities enabled by the ROADM network’s flexibility allows the network operator to increase the overall service availability by quickly and efficiently restoring connections with minimal field operations. Furthermore, with an automated control plane (such as generalized multi-protocol label switching [GMPLS]), this restoration capability can be integrated into the network operating system such that restoration activities are automated and occur without any operator intervention. Beyond restoration, the ability to re-route in-service wavelengths enables operators to balance traffic loads within their networks and relieve emerging congestion points by redirecting wavelengths away from the congestion and through areas of lower traffic. It also lets operators proactively shift critical traffic away from areas with planned potentially invasive maintenance activities. If photonic layer restoration is used simply to increase network availability by restoring a secondary path of a protected service, the desire to achieve wavelength reroute intervals in a minimal amount of time may not be a high priority assuming the interval is naturally on the order of seconds to minutes. Therefore, the speed in which wavelengths need to be turned up within the network (as in the case of a rerouted wavelength) may be sufficiently slow with respect to the transient suppression capabilities of the modern optical amplifiers. However, if interest develops in photonic layer restoration as a primary mechanism for service recovery (potentially for lower cost, best effort service classes), then one would expect the rate in which a wavelength would need to be turned up within a network to be minimized and perhaps begin to approach speeds where the capabilities of modern optical amplifier transient suppression capabilities for rapid optical power increase and decrease become critically necessary. Common ROADM architectures deployed today as illustrated in Figures 2.3, 2.5, and 2.7 impose some wavelength routing limitations that effectively prevent the full flexibility required for wavelength recovery and dynamic reconfigurability. Specifically, the wavelength and the ingress/egress direction of the add/drop channels are permanently assigned. This is a direct result of the fact that the transmit/
2.5 Emerging applications and uses of ROADM networks
receive signal is connected to a wavelength-specific port on a multiplexer/demultiplexer that is connected to WSS and couplers assigned to a specific direction.
2.5.1 Colorless add/drop architectures Currently, ROADM networks are transitioning to support “colorless” add/drop ports which, unlike colored add/drop ports, do not have a permanently assigned wavelength channel but rather are provisioned as to which wavelength channel will be added/dropped. Architectures to achieve colorless add/drop switching were discussed in an earlier section and illustrated in Figure 2.8. Colorless ports are attractive as generally fewer total add/drop ports are needed, resulting in simpler operations and potentially more compact physical interfaces. Also, coupled with wavelength tunable transmitters, colorless ports allow the wavelength to be selected and provisioned remotely, further simplifying deployment and enabling the remote and rapid modification of a channel’s wavelength needed to support ROADM-based wavelength connection recovery and rerouting. Colorless ports are generally created by replacing the fixed wavelength demultiplexing and multiplexing elements with either a WSS (only a single channel provisioned per port) as shown in Figure 2.8, or a power splitter and tunable filter array. In some cases, a power combiner is used as the multiplexing element. To support the growing interest in systems with a greater number of colorless ports, 1xN WSSs where N is greater than 8 are required. For the WSS, this generally means either a greater range of angular deflection is needed from the switch engine in order to address more fiber ports, a greater density of ports per deflection angle unit (together with some optical system modifications to pack coverage of more ports within the same deflection angle range), or a combination of both, are needed. With a MEMS switch engine, either can be achieved without requiring a change of the spot size in the diffraction direction on the mirror itself, thereby preserving isolation and bandwidth performance as well as physical size. LCoS based engines have some limitations on the maximum deflection angle from the pixelated 0-to-2 dimensional phase modulator array but can achieve greater deflection accuracy by illuminating a larger number of pixels in the deflection axis of the array. However, this may require modifications to the optical system in order to accommodate the larger coverage. LC stack-based engines require additional stacks for additional deflection stages, requiring a longer beam focus through the stacks and consequently a wider spot size, which likely translates in a larger optical system length and generally WSS device.
2.5.2 Directionless add/drop architectures In conventional ROADM nodes, each degree contains a separate group of channel add/drop ports which are multiplexed/demultiplexed within that degree and permanently leave/enter the node through their respective degree (see Figure 2.7). This permanent association of an add/drop port with a particular transmission
41
42
CHAPTER 2 ROADM-based networks
direction limits the dynamic flexibility of the network as the route of a signal from an add/drop port cannot be remotely altered until that signal reaches an adjacent ROADM mesh node. Thus, a second currently emerging trend is the development of architectures that support “directionless” add/drop ports in which the degree, and thereby transmission fiber pair in which the signals enter/leave the node, is fully flexible and is provisioned through the operation system. Therefore, with directionless ports, the network operator is able to select, provision, and alter a signal pair’s route at truly any point within the network giving greater and more thorough flexibility [13]. An example of a node with directionless add/drop ports is shown in Figure 2.11. A copy of the incoming channels from each degree is injected into the ports of a 1xN WSS which selects which wavelengths from which degrees are routed to its common port. This port is connected to the common port of a separate 1xM WSS which demultiplexes these wavelengths into M respective colorless and directionless ports. Given the single fiber connection between the two WSSs, only one instance of each wavelength channel may be dropped per bank of ports. For multiplexing, the same demultiplexing assembly can be used in the reverse direction or a power coupling structure may be used. To relieve the potential application limitations presented by the wavelength blocking characteristic within each the add/drop banks of the architecture illustrated in Figure 2.11, architectures based upon a new type of WSS are being considered. An example is shown in Figure 2.12. This architecture incorporates a new type of
FIGURE 2.11 Four degree ROADM node with “directionless” add/drop switching
2.6 Summary
FIGURE 2.12 Directionless ROADM node incorporating non-blocking NxM WSS
WSS that has N multi-wavelength ports on one side and M ports on the other and has the functionality that wavelengths can be independently routed between any port from the group of N ports and any port from the group of M ports, provided no two signals of the same wavelength are routed to the same port. However, signals within the same wavelength channel, but entering through different ports from the group of N ports, can independently be routed to distinct ports from the group of M ports. Therefore, the add/drop bank created using this wavelength non-blocking NxM WSS can support multiple add/drop ports being provisioned to the same wavelength channel but associated with different node degrees, removing the wavelength blocking limitation and further increasing the flexibility and capability of the network. The ideal architectures and supporting technologies for colorless and directionless ROADM nodes remain a subject of ongoing development and research, but a consensus is emerging that these general approaches will yield the required improvements in network flexibility and responsiveness.
2.6 SUMMARY The inclusion of optical reconfigurability into optical networks has had a profound impact on the application, construction, and operation of optical transmission systems and has placed some additional requirements as well as removed some traditional burdens on the optical amplification. All-optical mesh networking enabled by the WSS has resulted in the need for optical wavelengths to propagate further through the network, yet overcoming greater total loss given the additional
43
44
CHAPTER 2 ROADM-based networks
loss introduced by the ROADM node elements, placing greater burden on the quality of the optical amplification. However, through automated and more accurate channel power level control, some stringent gain and transient flatness requirements can be relaxed. As the capabilities, functionalities, and complexities of optically reconfigurable networks continue to evolve, the need for optical amplification and the requirements placed on that amplification are likely to increase. The introduction of colorless and directionless add/drop ports is expected to facilitate a more dynamic use of optical networks. This evolution will likely result in greater emphasis on network stability and improved transient behavior, in turn requiring higher performance optical amplification capabilities.
ACRONYMS ADM AWG DLP DWDM EDFA GMPLS LC LCoS MEMS MZI OA OADM OCM OSNR PLC PS ROADM SDH SONET WB WDM WSS
Add/drop multiplexer Arrayed wavelength grating Digital light processing Dense wavelength division multiplexing Erbium-doped fiber amplifier Generalized multi-protocol label switching Liquid crystal Liquid crystal on silicon Micro electro-mechanical systems Mach-Zehnder interferometer Optical amplifier Optical add/drop multiplexer Optical channel monitor Optical signal-to-noise ratio Planar light wave circuitry Power splitter (combiner) Reconfigurable optical add/drop multiplexer Synchronous digital hierarchy Synchronous optical network Wavelength blocker Wavelength division multiplexing Wavelength selective switch
References
References [1] Cisco White Paper: Global IP Traffic Forecast and Methodology, 2006-2011 [2] P.J. Winzer, R.J. Essiambre, Advanced Optical Modulation Formats, Proc. IEEE 94 (5) (2006) 952e985. [3] M.G. Taylor, Coherent Detection Method Using DSP for Demodulation of Signal and Subsequent Equalization of Propagation, IEEE Photonics Technology Letters 16 (2004) 674e676. [4] J. McNicol, M. O’Sullivan, K. Roberts, A. Comeau, D. McGhan, L. Strawczynski, Electronic Domain Compensation of Optical Dispersion. Optical Fiber Communication Conference, Optical Society of America, (2005), paper OThJ13. [5] F. Heismann, P. Mamyshev, 43-Gb/s NRZ-PDPSK WDM Transmission with 50-GHz Channel Spacing in Systems with Cascaded Wavelength-Selective Switches, Optical Fiber Communication Conference and Exposition and The National Fiber Optic Engineers Conference (2009), paper OThC1. [6] P. Wall, P. Colbourne, C. Reimer, S. McLaughlin, WSS Switching Engine Technologies, Optical Fiber Communication Conference and Exposition and The National Fiber Optic Engineers Conference (2008), paper OWC1. [7] D. Marom, D.T. Neilson, D.S. Greywall, C.-S. Pai, N.R. Basavanhally, V.A. Aksyuk, D.O. Lo´pez, F. Pardo, M.E. Simon, Y. Low, P. Kolodner, C.A. Bolle, WavelengthSelective 1K Switches Using Free-Space Optics and MEMS Micromirrors: Theory, Design, and Implementation, J. of Lightwave Tech. 23 (2005) 1620e1630. [8] B. Fracasso, J. L. de Bougrenet de la Tocnaye, M. Razzak, C. Uche, Design and Performance of a Versatile Holographic Liquid-Crystal Wavelength-Selective Optical Switch, J. of Lightwave Tech. 21 (2003) 2405e2411. [9] J. Kelly, Application of Liquid Crystal Technology to Telecommunication Devices, Optical Fiber Communication Conference and Exposition and The National Fiber Optic Engineers Conference (2007), paper NThE1. [10] M.T. Knapczyk, L. Grave de Peralta, A.A. Bernussi, H. Temkin, Reconfigurable Add– Drop Optical Filter Based on Arrays of Digital Micromirrors, IEEE J. of Lightwave Tech. 26 (2008) 237e242. [11] J. Homa, K. Bala, ROADM Architectures and Their Enabling WSS Technology, IEEE Communications Magazine 46 (7) (2008) 150e154. [12] B. Collings, F. Heismann, C. Reimer, Dependence of the Transmission Impairment on the WSS Port Isolation Spectral Profile in 50GHz ROADM Networks wit 43Gb/s NRZ-ADPSK Signals, Optical FIber Communication Conference, (2009), paper OThJ3. [13] P. Roorda, B. Collings, Evolution to Colorless and Directionless ROADM Architectures, Optical Fiber Communication Conference and Exposition and The National Fiber Optic Engineers Conference (2008), paper NWE2.
45
This page intentionally left blank
CHAPTER
Challenges and Opportunities in Future High-Capacity Optical Transmission Systems
3 Xiang Liu
Bell Laboratories, Alcatel-Lucent, Holmdel, New Jersey
CHAPTER OUTLINE HEAD 3.1. Introduction .................................................................................................. 3.2. Recent developments in high-capacity transmission systems ........................... 3.2.1. High spectral-efficiency modulation formats and detection schemes. 3.2.2. Orthogonal frequency-division multiplexing .................................... 3.2.3. Recent high-capacity transmission demonstrations ......................... 3.3. Technical challenges in future high-capacity transmission .............................. 3.3.1. OSNR requirements ..................................................................... 3.3.2. Nonlinear fiber impairments.......................................................... 3.3.3. Linear fiber impairments (including optical amplifier impairments) .. 3.3.4. Implementation challenges ........................................................... 3.4. Estimating a “Shannon limit” for fiber optical systems..................................... 3.4.1. Background ................................................................................. 3.4.2. A capacity estimation framework ................................................... 3.4.3. Capacity estimation results and implications .................................. 3.5. Emerging technologies for increasing system capacity and reach .................... 3.5.1. Novel optical transmission fibers ................................................... 3.5.1.1. Ultralow-loss fiber ................................................................. 3.5.1.2. Large core area fiber ............................................................. 3.5.1.3. Shorter span length............................................................... 3.5.2. Novel optical amplification schemes.............................................. 3.5.2.1. Amplification to cover the full fiber transmission band............ 3.5.2.2. High-order distributed Raman amplification ........................... 3.5.3. Photonic integrated circuits .......................................................... 3.5.4. Novel coding techniques .............................................................. 3.5.5. Compensation of fiber nonlinearity ................................................ 3.5.6. Spatial multiplexing ..................................................................... 3.6. Conclusion.................................................................................................... Acknowledgments ................................................................................................. Acronyms ............................................................................................................. References ........................................................................................................... Optically Amplified WDM Networks. DOI: 10.1016/B978-0-12-374965-9.10003-2 Copyright Ó 2011 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
48 49 49 52 54 57 57 59 60 60 61 61 62 65 68 68 68 68 69 70 70 71 71 71 72 73 73 74 74 75
47
48
CHAPTER 3 Challenges and opportunities
3.1 INTRODUCTION Optical transmission systems have been evolving dramatically over the past decade in order to meet the ever-increasing demand in telecommunication capacity. Dense wavelength-division-multiplexing (DWDM) is now widely used to support high capacity per fiber link, and further expansion in capacity is being achieved by increasing the data rate per wavelength channel. In most optical transmission systems, channel data rate has completed the migration from 2.5 Gb/s to 10 Gb/s, and 40 Gb/s is under active development. 100 Gb/s channel data rate is considered the next-generation standard for Ethernet (see, for example, IEEE P802.3ba 40 Gb/s and 100 Gb/s Ethernet Task Force, http://www.ieee802.org/3/ba/). The estimated communication traffic growth is 2 dB per year, or an increase of a factor of 100 in traffic in 10 years [1]. In addition to the demand for high capacity, optical transmission systems are desired to support long-haul optical transmission to effectively address metropolitan, regional, and national network applications. Moreover, the cost per bit, in terms of both capital and operational expenditure, needs to decrease with the increase of system capacity to support sustainable traffic growth. To satisfy these requirements for future high-capacity transmission systems, there are several technical challenges that we have to meet. First, high-spectralefficiency optical modulation formats have to be generated, and at high speed. Second, high-speed optical signals with these advanced modulation formats need to be received with optimized receiver sensitivity. Third, linear and nonlinear fiber transmission impairments, often critical to high-speed transmission, need to be mitigated. Finally, as we approach the Shannon information capacity limit [2] for nonlinear optical fiber transmission [3], the last resort may be an improved fiber link that offers reduced amplified spontaneous emission (ASE) noise, for a given fiber nonlinear penalty. Accompanying the above technical challenges are opportunities for innovating optical technologies that enable future high-capacity transmission systems to become a reality. In this chapter, we discuss promising technologies that may help address the challenges of realizing future high-capacity optical transmission systems. Particular emphasis is put on the system benefits of advanced optical amplification schemes. This chapter is organized as follows: In Section 2, we review the recent developments in high-capacity transmission systems. High spectral-efficiency modulation formats, as well as differential detection and digital coherent detection, are discussed. Multi-carrier modulation based on orthogonal frequencydivision multiplexing (OFDM) is briefly introduced, and compared with singlecarrier modulation. Some state-of-the-art high-capacity transmission demonstrations are highlighted. Section 3 describes the technical challenges in high-capacity transmission, in terms of the requirement on optical signal-to-noise ratio (OSNR) and the tolerance to linear and nonlinear fiber transmission impairments. Section 4 discusses the fundamental Shannon limit applicable for fiber-optic systems. Section 5 introduces a few emerging technologies for increasing system capacity and reach.
3.2 Recent developments in high-capacity transmission systems
Novel optical fiber types and amplification schemes, as well as photonic integrated circuits, are discussed. Emerging digital technologies such as coding and digital compensation of fiber nonlinearity are also discussed. Finally, Section 6 concludes this chapter.
3.2 RECENT DEVELOPMENTS IN HIGH-CAPACITY TRANSMISSION SYSTEMS 3.2.1 High spectral-efficiency modulation formats and detection schemes The evolution of high-capacity optical transmission systems is empowered by technological innovations in several key areas. A noticeable area of significant advance over the past few years is advanced modulation formats and detection schemes that enable high performance and high spectral-efficiency optical transmission [4e9]. The modulation format of an optical signal defines how the information is encoded at the transmitter, and the detection scheme specifies how the signal is received at the receiver. In forming an optical channel, its modulation format and detection scheme are naturally considered together. The choice of modulation format and detection scheme has strong system-level implications such as the OSNR requirement, the achievable spectral efficiency, and the tolerance to fiber chromatic dispersion (CD), polarization-mode dispersion (PMD), and fiber nonlinearity [10]. It is thus a common practice to select the optimum modulation format and corresponding detection scheme for a given set of system requirements. Most current DWDM optical transmission systems are primarily based on 10 Gb/s on-off-keying (OOK) channels on a 50 GHz channel grid with a spectral efficiency of 0.2 b/s/Hz. Capacity upgrade of these systems calls for 40 Gb/s and 100 Gb/s wavelength channels to be carried in the same system. To achieve this, several technical challenges need to be addressed. First of all, the optical spectral bandwidth of each 40 Gb/s or 100 Gb/s channel has to be similar to that of the 10 Gb/s OOK channel to be carried in the same DWDM system. This implies that more spectrally efficient modulation formats are required for channels with higher data rates. Second, the transmission distance of the 40 Gb/s and 100 Gb/s channels is preferred to be comparable to that of current 10 Gb/s channels. This means that advanced modulation formats and detection schemes are desired so that the signal tolerances to ASE noise, CD, PMD, and fiber nonlinearity are not compromised with the increase of per-channel data rate. Differentially coherent or self-coherent optical transmission based on differential phase-shift keying (DPSK) and direct detection [2e7,9] has recently emerged as an attractive vehicle for supporting high-speed optical transmission. The most basic DPSK format is differential binary phase-shift keying (DBPSK) carrying 1 bit/symbol. With partial-delay demodulation, DBPSK was shown to be capable of supporting 40 Gb/s transmission over a 50 GHz grid, corresponding to a spectral efficiency of 0.8 b/s/Hz [11,12].
49
50
CHAPTER 3 Challenges and opportunities
To further increase spectral efficiency, differential quadrature phase-shift keying (DQPSK) carrying 2 bits/symbol can be used. DWDM transmission of 10 107 Gb/s RZ-DQPSK channels over 2,000 km has recently been demonstrated with a net spectral efficiency of 1 b/s/Hz [13,14]. More phase levels can be used to carry more bits per symbol. For example, differential 8-ary phase-shift keying (D8PSK) [15] was used to carry 3 bits/symbol. The demodulation and retrieval of all the data tributaries of an m-ary DPSK signal become more complex with the increase of m. With the help of analog-to-digital conversion and digital signal processing (DSP), a simple yet universal digital self-coherent optical receiver for m-ary DPSK using only one pair of orthogonal demodulators was proposed [16]. The receiver sensitivity of direct-detection m-ary DPSK can be improved to approach that of coherentdetection through data-aided multi-symbol phase estimation (MSPE) [9,16]. Combining DPSK with pulse-amplitude modulation (PAM) [17] provides another means to carry more bits per symbol. The receiver sensitivity is optimized when the Euclidean distances between adjacent PAM levels are equal; they are also equal to the minimum differential-phase distance in the DPSK modulation [9]. Since DPSK acts on signal phase and PAM acts on signal amplitude, they can be independently received. The data tributaries associated with PAM can be received by a binary or multilevel decision circuitry depending on the number of the PAM levels. With the assistance of analog-to-digital conversion, D8PSKþPAM2 and D8PSKþ PAM4 formats, carrying 4 and 5 bits/ symbol respectively, have recently been demonstrated [17]. Figure 3.1 shows the constellation diagrams of four high spectral-efficiency DPSK-based modulation formats that have been experimentally demonstrated. All these formats are compatible with direct detection. The constellation diagrams are normalized such that the average signal power is unity. Evidently, with the increase of modulated phase and/or amplitude levels, the Euclidean distance between adjacent symbols decreases, resulting in a reduction in the tolerance to the ASE noise. We will discuss this issue in Section 2.2. Digital coherent detection has recently attracted extensive attention due to its capability to receive high-spectral-efficiency signals with high receiver sensitivity
FIGURE 3.1 Constellation diagrams of four high spectral-efficiency DPSK-based modulation formats demonstrated with direct detection, DQPSK, D8PSK, D8PSKþPAM2, and D8PSKþPAM4
3.2 Recent developments in high-capacity transmission systems
FIGURE 3.2 Constellation diagrams of four high spectral-efficiency modulation formats commonly used with digital coherent detection, QPSK, 8-QAM, 16-QAM, and 32-QAM
Sx
S
Rx
Sy
OLO
Ry
R PBS
90-deg Hybrid
PBS Signal
90-deg Hybrid
and to digitally compensate for transmission impairments such as CD and PMD [8,18e23]. With digital coherent detection, the optical field of a signal under detection is reconstructed in the digital domain, making it easy for compensation of linear impairments and data recovery. Figure 3.2 shows the constellation diagrams of popular modulation formats commonly used with digital coherent detection, qudrature phase-shift keying (QPSK) [8, 18e23] or 4-point quadrature amplitude modulation (QAM), 8-QAM [24], 16-QAM [25], and 32-QAM [26], carrying 2, 3, 4, and 5 bits/symbol per polarization, respectively. In digital coherent detection, polarization diversity is usually needed as the signal polarization state after transmission is unknown. Figure 3.3 shows a schematic of a polarization-diversity digital coherent receiver, consisting of an optical local oscillator (OLO), a polarization-diversity 28 optical hybrid, 4 balanced
Sx+Rx Sx-Rx
BD ADC
Sx+jRx Sx-jRx
BD
ADC
Sy+Ry Sy-Ry
BD
ADC
Sy+jRy Sy-jRy
ADC
BD
Ix Qx Iy
DSP
Qy
IIx,y ∝ real(Sx,y) Qx,y ∝ imag(Sx,y)
FIGURE 3.3 Schematic of a polarization-diversity digital coherent receiver. OLO: optical local oscillator; PBS: polarization-beam splitter; BD: balanced detector; ADC: analog-to-digital converter; DSP: digital signal processor
51
52
CHAPTER 3 Challenges and opportunities
detectors (BDs), 4 analog-to-digital converters (ADCs), and a DSP unit. The polarization-diversity optical hybrid mixes the incoming signal S with the reference source R generated by the OLO to obtain four pairs of mixed signals, (SxRx), (SxjRx), (SyRy), and (SyjRy), where j is the imaginary unit. The power waveforms of each pair of the output mixed signals are detected and compared by a BD followed by an ADC. The resultant four digital signals Ix,y and Qx,y are linearly related to the in-phase (I) and the quadrature (Q) components of each of the two orthogonal polarization components of the signal separated by the PBS at the signal port. These digital signals are provided to a DSP unit for further processing to determine the amplitude and phase of the unknown incoming signal S. Polarization-division multiplexing (PDM) is an effective means to double the spectral efficiency of a given modulation format. With the use of polarizationdiversity digital coherent receiver, PDM can be supported without additional complexity in receiver hardware, so digital coherent detection is naturally compatible with PDM. Indeed, most of recent demonstrations with digital coherent detection [23e26] were using PDM. Polarization de-multiplexing was performed in the digital domain by using algorithms such as the constant modulus algorithm (CMA) [9,22]. In addition, CMA-based equalization is capable of compensating for PMD, making digital coherent detection attractive for high-speed optical transmission where large system tolerance to PMD is desired. On the other hand, polarization de-multiplexing for PDM DPSK-based formats is not as convenient. In early DPSK experiments, polarization de-multiplexing was performed manually by using a polarization beam splitter [27e29]. Optical polarization de-multiplexing of a PDM signal is feasible in principle, albeit at the expense of added optical complexity. Electronic polarization de-multiplexing was demonstrated for a 100 Gb/s PDM-DQPSK signal, but the PMD tolerance is quite limited [30].
3.2.2 Orthogonal frequency-division multiplexing Orthogonal frequency-division multiplexing (OFDM) is a widely used modulation/ multiplexing technology in wireless and data communications [31]. OFDM was recently introduced to optical fiber communication [32e35]. Enabled by digital coherent detection, coherent optical OFDM (CO-OFDM) [33,35e40] brings similar benefits as single-carrier-based coherent systems described in the previous section such as high spectral efficiency and high receiver sensitivity, while additionally offering transmitter adaptation capability [41] and efficient channel estimation and compensation [42]. Figure 3.4 shows the schematic of a PDM-OFDM transceiver setup. The original data is first divided into x- and y-polarization branches, each of which was mapped onto many frequency subcarriers with a given modulation format, e.g., QPSK or 16-QAM. These data subcarriers, together with a few pilot subcarriers, are then transferred to the time domain by inverse fast Fourier transform (IFFT). To form a complete OFDM symbol, a cyclic prefix is added in order to accommodate the penalty from inter-symbol interference (ISI) that may be caused by fiber CD and PMD. Training symbols (TSs) with known content are inserted
3.2 Recent developments in high-capacity transmission systems
PDM-OFDM Transmitter Ix
PBS
IQ-Mod J-SPMC
TS Insertion
P/S
Symbol Mapping
ytributary
S/P
IFFT
Data
Prefix Insertion
DAC
Symbol Mapping
S/P
xtributary
To fiber link
Qx
DAC CDAC
Iy IQ-Mod Qy
DAC 56GS/s
Prefix Removal
Synchronization and FE
J-SPMC
S/P
FFT
Rough EDC
Channel Estimation
PA-CPEC PA-CPEC
ytributary
P/S
Data
Channel Compensation
Symbol Mapping Symbol Mapping
P/S
xtributary
I’x
ADC
Q’x
ADC
I’y Q’y
ADC ADC
PolarizationDiversit Optical Hybridy
From fiber link
PDM-OFDM Receiver
OLO
FIGURE 3.4 Schematic of a PDM-OFDM transceiver setup. S/P: serial/parallel conversion; P/S: parallel/ serial conversion; TS: training symbol; DAC: digital-to-analog converter; IQ-Mod: I/Q modulator; PBS: polarization beam splitter. ADC: analog-to-digital converter; FE: frequency estimation; J-SPMC: joint self-phase modulation compensation [40]; EDC: electronic dispersion compensation; PA-CPEC: pilot-assisted common phase error compensation.
periodically in the OFDM symbol sequence to facilitate synchronization and channel estimation. The time-domain digital samples are converted by two digitalto-analog converters (DACs) to two analog electrical signals, which are used to drive two optical I/Q modulators. The modulated optical signals are combined by a PBS to form a PDM-OFDM signal. The receiver hardware is the same as that required for single-carrier digital coherent detection. Symbol synchronization, frequency estimation (FE), and channel estimation are performed with the help of the TSs. The data subcarriers are recovered after fast Fourier transform (FFT), channel compensation, and phase compensation (PE). The original data is finally obtained by symbol mapping and serialization. A key feature of CO-OFDM is its DSP capability at the transmitter, in addition to that at the receiver, thereby allowing an end-to-end software defined transmission link. The transmitter DSP capability makes it easy to realize high-level modulation formats such as 32-QAM [26] and 64-QAM [43], and to adapt modulation format and data rate depending on link condition, as commonly done in wireless communications.
53
54
CHAPTER 3 Challenges and opportunities
A Complete OFDM Channel Δf
Sub-channel 2 Sub-channel 1 ΔfG=mΔf (m=1,2,3…)
Sub-channel N
Sub-channel 3
........ fi
fj
Frequency
FIGURE 3.5 Illustration of the spectrum of an OFDM channel consisting of N sub-channels with the orthogonality among all the subcarriers preserved to allow crosstalk-free sub-channel access.
Another attractive feature of CO-OFDM is that it allows individual access to closely spaced sub-channels without coherent crosstalk among these sub-channels [44]. Figure 3.5 shows an illustrated spectrum of an OFDM channel that consists of N sub-channels. When the guard-band spacing (DfG) between adjacent sub-channels is equal to a multiple of subcarrier spacing (Df), each sub-channel can be individually received without suffering coherent crosstalk from neighboring sub-channels because the orthogonality among all the subcarriers (1, . fi,. fj,.) is preserved. When the guard-band spacing is set to be equal to the subcarrier spacing, no spectral efficiency is lost in grouping the subchannels together. The sub-channel access feature allows one to overcome the bandwidth bottleneck of ADC and DAC circuits to form an ultra-high-speed optical channel, albeit at the expense of increased optical complexity needed for receiving all the sub-channels. In fact, this feature has recently been exploited to demonstrate over 1 Tb/s CO-OFDM transmission with sub-channel access at 107 Gb/s [45] and 121 Gb/s [46]. The benefit of OFDM in reducing the coherent crosstalk between sub-channels has also been demonstrated in multi-carrier OOK [47], commonly referred to as coherent WDM, and 2-carrier DQPSK [48] and PDM-QPSK [49]. In the 2-carrier PDM-QSPK demonstration [49], cyclic prefix (or guard interval) usually used in CO-OFDM was removed to further increase the obtainable spectral efficiency. The ISI due to CD and PMD was compensated at the receiver using CMA-based blind equalization, as commonly done in single-carrier digital coherent detection.
3.2.3 Recent high-capacity transmission demonstrations With the advances in high spectral efficiency modulation formats and detection schemes, the last few years have witnessed many record-breaking high-capacity transmission demonstrations. Table 3.1 summarizes some of the state-of-the-art high-capacity transmission results in order of achieved spectral efficiency (SE). A key performance indicator is the SE-distance product (SEDP), which is directly related to the transmission capacity-distance product for the same optical bandwidth allocation.
SE (b/s/Hz) 1.4 [50]
Format/detection
2 [51] 4 [24]
43G DQPSK and 107G PDMDQPSK /DD 111G 2-Carrier NGI-CO-OFDM /DCD 112G PDM-QPSK/DCD 114G PDM-8QAM/DCD
6.2 [25] 7 [26]
104G PDM-16QAM/DCD 65.1G PDM-OFDM-32QAM /DCD
2 [49]
Reach (km)
Fiber type
Optical amplification
1280
SSMF
EDFA
6248
PSCF
7040 580
LCF Low-loss SSMF SSMF SSMF
630 240
Number of channels
SEDP (km-b/s/Hz)
20
1,792
2nd-order DRA and EDFA DRA and EDFA EDFA
135
12,496
72 320
14,080 2,320
EDFA and DRA EDFA and DRA
10 8
3,906 1,680
DD: direct detection with real-time BER measurement; DCD: digital coherent detection with offline DSP; SSMF: standard single-mode fiber; PSCF: low-loss (0.16 dB/km) low-nonlinearity pure silica core fiber; LCF: large-core fiber with 120 mm2 effective area and 0.184 dB/km loss; EDFA: erbium-doped fiber amplifier; DRA: distributed Raman amplifier
3.2 Recent developments in high-capacity transmission systems
Table 3.1 State-of-the-art high-capacity transmission demonstrations
55
56
CHAPTER 3 Challenges and opportunities
With direct detection (DD), a SE of 1.4 bit/s/Hz was demonstrated by copropagating 42.7 Gb/s DQPSK and 107 Gb/s PDM-DQPSK channels in a same DWDM system with 50 GHz channel spacing [50]. Transmission over a 1,280 km standard single-mode fiber (SSMF) link including four reconfigurable optical add/ drop multiplexer (ROADM) passes was achieved. The optical amplification was solely based on cost-effective erbium-doped fiber amplifiers (EDFAs) in the C-band. The achieved SEDP was 1,792 km$b/s/Hz. With digital coherent detection (DCD), DWDM transmissions with higher SE were demonstrated. At 2 b/s/Hz SE, a transmission capacity-distance product of 84.3 Petabit/skm (13.5Tb/s6,248km) was achieved by employing 111 Gb/s no-guardinterval (NGI) CO-OFDM with two PDM-QPSK-modulated carriers and secondorder distributed Raman amplifiers in combination with EDFAs in the extended L-band [49]. The fiber link consisted of 80 km low-loss (0.16 dB/km) low-nonlinearity pure silica core fiber (PSCF) spans. The resulting SE-distance product was 12,496 km/b/s/Hz. In another experiment, 112 Gb/s single-carrier PDM-QPSK was used, and transmission over transoceanic distance (7,040 km) was demonstrated over a fiber link consisting of large-core fiber (LCF) spans with 120 mm2 effective area (Aeff) and 0.184 dB/km loss, achieving a record SEDP of 14,080 km$b/s/Hz [51]. At 4-b/s/Hz SE, a record capacity of 32 Tb/s was demonstrated by using 320 114 Gb/s PDM-8QAM channels on a 25 GHz channel grid [24]. The transmission fiber link consisted of seven 82.8 km spans of ultra-low-loss fiber with an average loss coefficient of 0.176 dB/km and was amplified only by EDFAs in the C and L bands. The achieved SEDP was 2,320 km$b/s/Hz. At 6.2-b/s/Hz SE, 10-channel 112 Gb/s PDM-16QAM transmission over 630 km of SSMF was demonstrated with a DWDM channel spacing of 16.7 GHz [25]. A SEdistance product as high as 3,906 km$b/s/Hz was achieved. The highest SE demonstrated so far for long-haul DWDM transmission is 7 b/s/Hz, which is based on PDM-OFDM with 32-QAM subcarrier modulation [26]. Eight 65.1 Gb/s PDM-OFDM-32QAM channels were transmitted over 3 80 km SSMF spans with DRAs and EDFAs. The achieved SEDP was 1,680 km$b/s/Hz. Note that in the first demonstration listed in Table 3.1, DD was used and the bit error ratio (BER) after transmission was measured in real time. However, in the rest of the demonstrations, DCD with offline DSP was used, and the BER was not measured in real time. This is mainly due to the unavailability of ADC at sufficiently high sampling speed to support these high data rates. At lower data rates, e.g., 40 Gb/s, real-time DCD was recently demonstrated [23] for PDM-QPSK. With two independent DCD-based receivers, the real-time detection of a 100 Gb/s two-carrier PDM-QPSK signal with 20 GHz carrier spacing was reported [52]. Real-time CO-OFDM receivers have also been recently demonstrated [53,54], but at low per-channel data rates (<10 Gb/s). In the following section, technical challenges in realizing future high-capacity optical transmission systems with SE at or beyond 2 b/s/Hz and per-channel data rate at or beyond 100 Gb/s will be discussed.
3.3 Technical challenges in future high-capacity transmission
3.3 TECHNICAL CHALLENGES IN FUTURE HIGH-CAPACITY TRANSMISSION 3.3.1 OSNR requirements In optically amplified transmission, signal quality has a strong dependence on OSNR, which is commonly defined as the ratio between the signal power and the power of optical noise of two polarization states within a fixed bandwidth of 0.1 nm (or 12.5 GHz at a signal wavelength of about 1550 nm). The required OSNR to achieve a given BER in an optical channel depends on its data rate, modulation format, and detection scheme. For a fixed data rate, the required OSNR at low BER values can be estimated from the minimum Euclidean distance between two closest symbols in the signal constellation diagram (with a normalized average signal power) [6,9,55]. Using coherent-detection binary phase-shift keying (BPSK) as the reference, the OSNR penalty (or additionally required OSNR in dB for a given BER) can be estimated. Figure 3.6 shows the OSNR penalties of the high spectral-efficiency direct differential-detection formats and coherent-detection formats described in the previous section. For coherent-detection formats, PDM is assumed to be used as it essentially comes for free. The results are also summarized in Table 3.2. There are two important observations from Figure 3.6. First, coherent-detection formats substantially outperform direct-detection formats. This is because coherent detection offers higher receiver sensitivity or lowered OSNR requirement than direct detection, and PDM allows coherent-detection formats to double the number of bits per symbol without OSNR penalty. Second, the OSNR penalty quickly increases with the increase of the number of bits per symbol for both detection schemes. To achieve 5 bits/symbol with direct-detection D8PSKþPAM4, an OSNR penalty of almost 10 dB has to be paid. To achieve 12 bits/symbol with PDM-64QAM, the OSNR penalty is about 8.5 dB. This means that a trade-off has Table 3.2 OSNR penalties and phase (f) margin of high spectral-efficiency formats Differential-detection formats
Bits/symbol OSNRpenalty (dB) f-margin (degree)
DQPSK
D8PSK
D8PSKDPAM2
D8PSKDPAM4
2 2.1 45
3 6.4 22.5
4 7.4 22.5
5 9.9 22.5
Coherent-detection formats (w/ PDM)
Bits/symbol OSNRpenalty (dB) f-margin (degree)
QPSK
8-QAM
16-QAM
32-QAM
64-QAM
4 0 45
6 1.98 22.5
8 3.98 16.9
10 6.02 10.9
12 8.45 7.7
57
CHAPTER 3 Challenges and opportunities
10
Direct-detection formats D8PSK+PAM4 Coherent-detection formats
9
PDM-64QAM
8
OSNR penalty (dB)
58
D8PSK+PAM2
7 D8PSK
6
PDM-32QAM
5 PDM-16QAM
4 3 DQPSK
2 1 DBPSK 0 1
PDM-BPSK
PDM-8QAM
PDM-QPSK
2 3 4 5 6 Number of bits per symbol
7
8 9 1011 12
FIGURE 3.6 OSNR penalties of high spectral-efficiency direct-detection and coherent-detection formats as compared with coherent-detection BPSK
to be made between the OSNR performance and the SE to be achieved. Also, modulation formats with larger number of phase and amplitude states are more susceptible to implementation imperfections such as ISI due to transmitter and receiver bandwidth limitation and phase errors, which can result from laser phase noise, I/Q mismatch, and fiber nonlinearity. Another performance indicator of a modulation format is its phase margin, defined as the maximally allowed phase rotation in the signal constellation before one symbol is confused with another symbol in the absence of noise. The phase margins of these formats are also listed in Table 3.2. To avoid a large additional penalty, the phase error needs to be limited to be much less than the phase margin. For 64 QAM, the phase margin is only 7.7 degrees, and it is challenging to control the phase error to be acceptably small (e.g., w1 deg). For future high-capacity optical transmission systems, the net channel data rates are expected to be 100 Gb/s, 400 Gb/s, and even 1 Tb/s. It is worthwhile to inspect the OSNR requirements for these data rates when high spectral-efficiency formats are used. With advanced forward-error correction (FEC), a raw BER of 3.8103 can be corrected to 1016 under the additive white Gaussian noise assumption [52]. Table 3.3 lists the required OSNR at BER of 3.8103 for 100 Gb/s, 400 Gb/s, and 1 Tb/s channels with coherent-detection formats. The reference case is 100 Gb/s PDM-QSPK over 50 GHz channel grid, achieving a SE of 2 b/s/Hz [1]. Since PDMQPSK is a 4-bit/symbol format, an overhead of 100% is allocated for FEC and easy channel separation. For the rest of the cases listed in Table 3.3, we assume the use of a 50% overhead for FEC and channel separation. The required OSNR values are based on ideal performance. In practical digital coherent-detection systems, the
3.3 Technical challenges in future high-capacity transmission
Table 3.3 OSNR requirements for future high spectral-efficiency 100 Gb/s, 400 Gb/s, and 1 Tb/s transmission. Net data rate per channel Channel spacing SE (b/s/Hz) Format* R-OSNR** @3.8e3
100 Gb/s 50 GHz 2 PDMQPSK 12.1 dB
25 GHz 4 PDM8QAM 14.9 dB
400 Gb/s 75 GHz
50 GHz
5.33 PDM16QAM 21.7 dB
8 PDM64QAM w26 dB
1 Tb/s 187.5 GHz 5.33 PDM16QAM 25.7
125 GHz 8 PDM64QAM w30 dB
* The modulation formats (except for the first one) are selected such that an overhead of 50% is allocated for FEC and channel separation. ** The required OSNR (R-OSNR) values quoted here are for ideal performance [52,55].
implementation penalty is usually larger than 2 dB [23]. The implementation penalty is also usually larger for higher level modulation formats as they tend to be more sensitive to implementation imperfections such as bandwidth limitation, digitization noise, and laser noise. Even under the assumption of ideal performance, the required OSNR for 400 Gb/s transmission over the common 50 GHz channel grid, by using PDM-64QAM, is 14 dB higher than that for the reference case with 100 Gb/s PDM-QPSK over the same channel grid. This implies that technologic breakthroughs are mandatory in order to support future data rates such as 400 Gb/s and 1 Tb/s in the same channel grid as currently used for 40 Gb/s and planned for 100 Gb/s.
3.3.2 Nonlinear fiber impairments The previous section discussed the high OSNR requirements for supporting high spectral-efficiency transmission with high data rates per channel. One straightforward way to obtain higher OSNR is to increase the signal launch power into each amplified fiber span, assuming higher optical power can be supported by optical amplifiers. However, there is a limit on the optical power allowed due to fiber nonlinearity [10]. Generally, there is an optimum signal power for a given channel over a given transmission link, at which the transmission performance is maximized. For single-channel BPSK transmission in the absence of dispersion, the optimum launch power was found to correspond to a total mean nonlinear phase shift of about 1 rad. [56]. In DWDM transmission, the inter-channel nonlinear interactions further degrade the transmission performance. For higher level modulation formats, the power tolerance or nonlinear tolerance is usually lower [3,6]. The ultimate optical transmission capacity over a single-mode fiber link with the consideration of both OSNR requirement and fiber nonlinearity will be discussed in the next section.
59
60
CHAPTER 3 Challenges and opportunities
3.3.3 Linear fiber impairments (including optical amplifier impairments) Linear fiber impairments can be categorized in two types, the first type affecting only the phase of optical signal and the second affecting at least the signal amplitude. Typical phase-affecting-only impairments include CD, PMD, and group-delay ripple (GDR), while typical amplitude-affecting impairments include polarization-dependent loss (PDL), polarization-dependent gain (PGD), optical bandpass filtering, gain/loss ripple, inband crosstalk, and relative intensity noise (RIN). The phase-affecting-only impairments in principle can be compensated in digital coherent receiver, assuming sufficient ADC sampling speed and DSP capability. Many recent experiments based on digital coherent detection have shown large tolerance to CD, PMD [20e23], and GDR [59]. The amplitude-affecting impairments, on the other hand, leads to OSNR degradation and thus can not be fully compensated. Imperfect optical amplification can be caused by four major amplitude-affecting impairments, PDG, gain ripple, inband crosstalk resulting from multi-path interference (MPI) due to double-Rayleigh back scattering [60], and RIN transfer from pump lasers. In coherent detection, RIN noise can also come from the OLO when it is mixing with the signal at the optical 90-degree hybrid. It is thus important to minimize these amplitude-affecting impairments in designing optical amplifiers.
3.3.4 Implementation challenges The realization of future high spectral-efficiency optical transmission using the advanced modulation formats and detection schemes described earlier faces several Table 3.4 Linear fiber transmission impairments and the major optical elements that are responsible for these impairments. Linear impairments
Responsible optical elements
Phase-affecting-only
CD PMD GDR
Fiber, DCM Fiber, DCM, EDFA, OADM, OF. PDM-64QAM
Amplitude-affecting
PDL PDG Optical filtering Gain/loss ripple Inband crosstalk RIN
Fiber, DCM, OADM, OF. EDFA, DRA OADM, OF EDFA, DRA, OADM, OF OADM, OF, DRA DRA, OLO
DCM: dispersion compensating module; OADM: optical add/drop multiplexer; OF: optical filter
3.4 Estimating a “Shannon limit” for fiber optical systems
implementation challenges. First, to realize digital coherent detection, high-speed ADC is required. For CO-OFDM, high-speed DAC is additionally required. The highest ADC sampling speed implemented in commercial digital coherent receiver is about 20 GSamples/s, sufficient for 40 Gb/s PDM-QPSK [23]. For 100 Gb/s PDMQPSK, ADC with 50-GSamples/s sampling speed is desired. Virtually all the highspeed experimental demonstrations so far [24e26,49e51] are based on 50 GSamples/s ADCs (embedded in a digital storage oscilloscope), each of which consists of four interleaved 12.5 GSamples/s ADCs. To be cost-effective, single-chip ADC running at 50 Gsamples/s or higher is needed. Progress is being made toward achieving this goal [61]. In addition to high-speed ADC and DAC, a high-throughput digital signal processor is also required. For 100 Gb/s channel data rate, the required throughput is on the order of 1 Tb/s for PDM-QSPK assuming 2x oversampling and 5-bit ADC resolution. The throughput requirement becomes even higher for higher data rates and for higher-level modulations that require higher ADC resolution. To meet the DSP throughput demand with acceptable power consumption relies on efficient DSP algorithms and advances in silicon technology. Another implementation challenge associated with digital coherent detection is the need for narrow-linewidth lasers to avoid laser noiseeinduced penalty, especially when high-level modulation formats are used. In the 40 Gb/s PDM-QPSK transmitter reported in [23], external-cavity laser (ECL) with linewidth <100 kHz was used. Also, high laser frequency stability is desired, although not required [52]. Other implementation challenges include the need for optical I/Q modulators whose bandwidth is comparable to the modulation symbol rate and cost-effective and compact polarization-diversity optical hybrids. In the next section, fundamental capacity limits of fiber optical transmission systems assuming ideal implementation will be discussed.
3.4 ESTIMATING A “SHANNON LIMIT” FOR FIBER OPTICAL SYSTEMS 3.4.1 Background The search for fundamental limits on transmission of information over various channels has been an active area of research ever since Shannon published his pioneering paper in 1948 [2]. Shannon’s theory expresses the capacity of a memoryless channel for a given signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) at detection assuming the presence of a source of additive white Gaussian noise (AWGN) in the channel. The extension of Shannon’s theory to determine the capacity limit of the optical fiber channel has faced many challenges, the most important being the simultaneous presence of as many as three fundamental physical phenomena in fibers: amplified spontaneous emission (ASE), fiber chromatic dispersion (CD), and instantaneous Kerr fiber nonlinearity.
61
62
CHAPTER 3 Challenges and opportunities
Amplified spontaneous emission is the result of the quantum nature of light and imposes a physical lower limit on the noise level of optical amplifiers. Gordon demonstrated that ASE can be represented by a classical field that has the statistical properties of additive Gaussian noise [62,63]. The establishment of this equivalence enabled using Shannon’s formulation of channel capacity for lightwave channels impaired by ASE. Fiber chromatic dispersion creates differences of group velocity between different wavelengths, resulting in symbols overlapping in the time domain and thereby introducing memory. Dispersion compensation can be applied in the optical domain (using dispersion compensating fibers for instance) or in the electronic domain using digital signal processing after coherent detection. Both can provide complete dispersion compensation and remove entirely the memory effect associated to dispersion in the absence of fiber nonlinearity. Kerr fiber nonlinearity is a phenomenon present in fused silica optical fibers. It originates from the tight confinement of light in the fiber core producing optical intensities that reach the level of a Megawatt/cm2. Such high intensities result in signal distortions due to changes in the refractive index of fused silica induced by the instantaneous optical Kerr effect [64]. There have been several attempts to evaluate the impact of the Kerr nonlinearity on the capacity limit of fibers [65e73]. These studies either rely on empirical approaches [65,68], approximate solutions assuming low nonlinearity [66,67,69,71e73] or consider only specific nonlinear propagation effects [70]. None of these studies takes fully into account all elementary forms of signal-signal, signal-noise, and noise-noise nonlinear interactions. All elementary nonlinear interactions are taken into account by directly solving the stochastic version of the generalized nonlinear Schrodinger equation (GNSE) describing transmission in fibers. In one study [74], the stochastic GNSE was directly solved. However, WDM effects were excluded and signaling constrained to binary formats were limiting the ability to estimate capacity. A novel framework was recently developed [75,76] to more accurately estimate fundamental limits of fiber capacity. This framework employs a maximally compact square spectrum (signaling at the Nyquist rate), multi-level modulation, reverse (also referred to as backward) nonlinear propagation applied at both the transmitter and the (coherent) receiver, and operate in a highly dispersive regime that suppresses spectral broadening. All elementary nonlinear propagation effects originating from the instantaneous optical Kerr effect in fibers are taken into account by direct numerical solution of the stochastic GNSE. Some limitations of this framework cause the capacity estimates to be in the direction of capacity lower bound and therefore represent conservative capacity estimates. In the following subsections, a brief description of this framework and its key results is given.
3.4.2 A capacity estimation framework A schematic representation of the WDM channels spectrum and the optical noise is shown in Figure 3.7a. Each WDM channel is modulated to produce a square
3.4 Estimating a “Shannon limit” for fiber optical systems
FIGURE 3.7 Spectrum and optical path layouts: a) Spectrum: Each WDM channel has a compact spectrum of bandwidth essentially equal to the symbol rate RS that fits within a WDM frequency band only marginally larger than RS. Noise is broadband. b) Optical path layout: the frequency band of a WDM channel of interest propagates from the transmitter (Tx) to the receiver (Rx).
spectrum (maximum spectral compactness). This corresponds to the narrowest spectrum that can be produced without introducing inter-symbol interference (ISI) [77]. The optical power of each WDM channel is assumed to be known and identical for all channels. A guardband of a small percentage of the signal bandwidth is assumed between WDM channels (the guardbands are enlarged in Figure 3.7a to facilitate visualization). Optical core networks have evolved from having all WDM channels sharing the same point-to-point optical path to modern networks where each WDM channel is optically routed in the network using reconfigurable optical add-drop multiplexers (ROADMs) [78]. From the transmission point of view, ROADMs consist essentially of optical filters that impose spectral confinement of each WDM channel to a frequency band. In optically routed networks, the frequency bands of individual WDM channels (Figure 3.7a) have their own individual optical paths, independent of the paths of other WDM channels’ frequency bands. A single transmitter and a single receiver are associated with each WDM channel in a core optical network (see Figure 3.7b). Because WDM channels are independently routed, only the frequency components within the frequency band of a given WDM channel are guaranteed to propagate the entire distance between a transmitter-
63
64
CHAPTER 3 Challenges and opportunities
receiver pair. We take into account the spectral confinement of the signal by having all WDM channels filtered by first a multiplexing filter, then ROADMs periodically inserted at add/drop locations, and then a demultiplexing filter. The multiplexing and demultiplexing filters consist of identical square optical filters of bandwidth equal to the WDM frequency band. Each ROADM contains one demultiplexer followed by a multiplexer. The frequency band of a WDM channel includes both the modulated signal and the “in-band” noise generated during propagation, as represented schematically in Figure 3.7b. We assume that the scenario limiting the most the capacity of optically routed networks is the one where no out-of-band fields are available either at the transmitter or at the receiver for joint processing. It is this scenario that is considered in this framework. For a given optical path configuration, the transmitter and receiver are the locations where mitigation of signal distortions is implemented. In principle, if all nonlinear interactions could be reversed, by any combination of digital signal processing at the transmitter and receiver, Shannon’s channel capacity could be recovered. However, certain nonlinear interactions are fundamentally irreversible. We discuss below the conditions of reversibility of the nonlinear processes found during fiber propagation, in the context of optically routed networks. In the absence of noise, the GNSE is an equation that is exactly reversible[80] if all interacting signal fields are known at either the transmitter or the receiver. To exactly “undo” the effects of signal-signal nonlinear interactions, it is required to propagate backward all the WDM channels co-propagating with the WDM channel of interest, adding or dropping WDM channels at the appropriate locations along the reverse optical path. This means that, in optically routed networks, WDM channels that were “dropped” during forward propagation are now “added” during reverse propagation and conversely. Not having access to the full field of the “dropped” and “added” WDM channel at the transmitter or at the receiver (where compensation of nonlinearity is implemented) will generally result in capacity limitations. Moreover, reversibility also assumes that the spectrum of each signal remains well confined within the frequency band allocated to the WDM channel so that no truncation of the signal by optical filtering occurs. In the presence of ASE noise, a random noise field is continuously generated along the optical path during propagation. To completely “undo” the nonlinear signal-noise and noise-noise interactions resulting from ASE generation with reverse propagation would require the knowledge of the noise fields and the location where each noise realization has been generated. Since ASE noise is randomly generated, it is not known at the receiver where each part of the ASE originates. Therefore, it is not possible to completely reverse the impact of distributed ASE generation on nonlinear transmission. However, partial compensation remains possible [81e83]. In this framework, both signal and noise are considered with the presence of fiber dispersion and nonlinearity [75,76]. It is further assumed that the fiber loss is continuously compensated by distributed gain such that the signal power is constant during transmission. Such a configuration maximizes the optical signal-to-noise
3.4 Estimating a “Shannon limit” for fiber optical systems
ratio (OSNR) [84] at fixed nonlinear phase shift [85,86] and is referred to as ideal distributed amplification. An example of technological implementation of ideal distributed optical amplification is cascaded Raman pumping [87]. For high-speed transmission, the fiber length characterizing fiber dispersion is usually much shorter than that characterizing fiber nonlinearity. This regime of operation is often referred to as the pseudo-linear regime of transmission [88e89]. Such a regime largely suppresses nonlinear spectral broadening, providing a strong spectral confinement of the signal required in optically routed networks at high spectral efficiencies. Memory associated with signal-signal intra-channel nonlinearities typically dominates the overall channel memory [90] in the pseudo-linear regime. This channel memory can be eliminated through reverse propagation of every individual WDM channel in isolation, over the noiseless transmission line. Such reverse propagation simultaneously enables an increase in capacity and allows using a memoryless individual receiver per WDM channel with reduced impact on the capacity estimation. It is assumed that the full field is recovered at the receiver using ideal coherent detection. Capacity lower bound estimation can be performed for an alphabet constituted from a constellation of concentric rings equally spaced in field amplitude and with equal frequencies of occupation for each ring. The random selection of complex valued alphabets is generated by independent choice of discrete ring amplitudes with essentially continuous phases (second points on a uniform angular grid). For capacity estimation, at the receiver, we increase the statistics of the computationally involved and hence limited number of symbols by individually back-rotating each symbol by their initial modulation angles. For each ring, the resulting cloud of points is maximum entropy fitted to a bivariate Gaussian probability density function that expresses the noncircular feature of that cloud [75,76].
3.4.3 Capacity estimation results and implications A summary of the system and fiber parameters considered for our capacity calculation is given in Table 3.5. The system under consideration uses standard singlemode fiber (SSMF) and ideal distributed Raman amplification that makes the signal power stay constant during transmission. Raman pump stations and dispersion compensation are located every 100 km. Twenty of these spans form a 2,000 km link. To create the WDM signal, five 100 Gbaud WDM channels are first up-sampled to eight samples per symbol before performing reverse propagation and then multiplexing them on a 102 GHz grid using band-limiting 102 GHz optical square filters. The 2% WDM guardband was chosen to prevent small spectral broadening from translating immediately into WDM crosstalk, but it remains small enough not to significantly affect capacity. All WDM channels pass through ROADMs that are located every 100 km where they are demultiplexed, randomly delayed in time, and multiplexed back together and injected in the next span. At the receiver, the central channel (the WDM channel of interest) is demultiplexed before performing reverse propagation and downsampling to one sample per symbol to obtain the output
65
66
CHAPTER 3 Challenges and opportunities
Table 3.5 Simulation parameters for capacity estimation. Number of spans Span length Signal frequency ns Dispersion Dð ¼ 2pcb2 =l2 Þ Dispersion slope Dispersion pre-compensation Residual dispersion per span Net residual dispersion at the receiver Loss coefficient a Nonlinear coefficient g Number of WDM channels Number of symbols Symbol rate Rs (De-)multiplexer bandwidth Guardband Modulation in amplitude Modulation angle Number of rings Amplification scheme Spontaneous emission factor nsp Raman Pump frequency np Temperature T
20 100 km 193.55 THz (l¼1550 nm) 17 ps(nm-km) Set to zero -1050 ps/nm 20 ps/nm 0 ps/nm 0.2 dB/km 1.27 (W-km)1 5 2048 100 Gbaud 102 GHz 2 GHz Equi-spaced Ultra-fine angular grid 1 to 16 Distributed Raman 1 206.9 THz (1450 nm) 300 Kelvin
symbols. A dispersion map with optimum pre-compensation [91] and near optimum residual dispersion per span for transmission in the absence of nonlinearity compensation at the transmitter or receiver is used. Post-compensation of dispersion is set to have zero total residual dispersion from the transmitter to the receiver. The number of symbols is limited to 2,048, limited by computation time. Computation with different realizations of the input symbol constellation and noise seeds leads to similar results with variations of a few tenths of bits/s/Hz observed between different constellation realizations. Compensation of nonlinear propagation by reverse propagation implemented at the transmitter, at the receiver,and in various combinations of both has been studied. For the system considered, the capacity results remained virtually unchanged (within the simulation accuracy estimated to be a few tenths of bits/s/Hz) for different ratios of transmitter to receiver nonlinearity compensation. The capacity results presented here are for compensation of nonlinearity at the transmitter. The calculated fiber channel capacity per unit bandwidth for the system studied is displayed in Figure 3.8. At low SNR, the capacity increases gradually with increasing SNR, following very closely the prediction for a linear system based on the Shannon limit. At an SNR around 20 dB, the capacity saturates, since the signal
3.4 Estimating a “Shannon limit” for fiber optical systems
FIGURE 3.8 Lower bounds of the spectral efficiency limit of a 2,000 km WDM system operating at 100 Gbaud per channel with the consideration of fiber nonlinearity using different numbers of rings. A maximum of w5.6 bits/s/Hz using one polarization state is obtained for 16-ring constellations.
distortions from fiber nonlinearities increase rapidly with signal power (or SNR) and result in a decrease in capacity at higher SNR. For the one-ring configuration, the maximum achievable spectral efficiency is w4.2 b/s/Hz, converging to w5.6 b/s/Hz for 16 rings. A main result of this work [75,76] is the feasibility of spectral efficiency exceeding 5 b/s/Hz for the 2,000 km transmission system considered. Note that these capacity limit results are for a singly polarized signal over 2,000 km. Further capacity increase may be possible for a signal that is modulated on both states of polarization. Capacity also increases for systems of shorter length [76] as the total noise generated decreases and the propagation length increases reducing the cumulative impact of fiber nonlinearity. For 1,000 km, a capacity of w7 b/s/Hz for 16 rings is predicted in [76]. An increase of capacity can also result from improvements in fiber properties, such as lower intrinsic loss and larger effective areas, as well as changes in dispersion maps. The above results suggest that SE-distance products of 11,200 km$b/s/Hz and 7,000 km$b/s/Hz are theoretically achievable at spectral efficiencies of 5.6 b/s/Hz and 7 b/s/Hz, respectively, which are larger by at least 2.5 times the SE-distance products obtained in the state-of-the-art experimental demonstrations [24e26] as listed in Table 3.1 at these values of spectral efficiencies. This indicates that increasing the SE-distance product beyond what have been experimentally achieved so far [24e26] is possible. Based on the assumptions used in the capacity limit study, future increase in the SE-distance product for the same fiber link may be relying on optical amplification schemes that provide higher OSNR, coding schemes that offer higher coding gain, and nonlinearity compensation schemes that allow for higher signal power.
67
68
CHAPTER 3 Challenges and opportunities
3.5 EMERGING TECHNOLOGIES FOR INCREASING SYSTEM CAPACITY AND REACH It can be seen from the fundamental Shannon limit of fiber optical transmission system presented in the previous section that there is room to further increase the optical transmission system capacity beyond what has been demonstrated so far. In this section, we will discuss some of the emerging technologies that may enable future capacity increase and/or reach extension.
3.5.1 Novel optical transmission fibers 3.5.1.1 Ultralow-loss fiber A key assumption used in the capacity limit study presented in the previous section is transmission fiber loss of 0.2 dB/km. With recent advances in fiber fabrication [92], lower fiber loss becomes possible [93,94]. Pure-silica-core fiber (PSCF) with a loss as low as 0.15 dB/km at the center of the telecommunication window (1550 nm) has been demonstrated [93,94]. Since Rayleigh scattering is the dominant factor contributing to optical fiber loss, even lower fiber loss could be achieved using doped core with reduced Rayleigh scattering loss [95]. P2O5-doped silica core was found to have a Rayleigh scattering coefficient of about 80% of the pure silica value, or as low as about 0.1 dB/km at 1550 nm [96]. As a reference, low-loss fibers having attenuation between 0.16 and 0.17 dB/km at 1550 nm are commercially available, such as Corning’s VascadeÒ EX1000 fiber and Sumitomo’s Z-fiber. With the reduction in fiber loss, higher OSNR can be obtained with a fixed signal power (launched into each fiber span) for a given transmission distance. Notice that the fiber nonlinear effect is also enhanced with the reduction of fiber loss. It is useful to compare the OSNR gain with fixed mean nonlinear phase shift per span FNL [56] defined as the product of the signal launch power and effective fiber span length Leff, where Leff¼(1eaL)/a, L is the span length, and a is the fiber loss coefficient (in linear scale). Figure 3.9 shows the OSNR gain as a function of fiber loss coefficient for the case with fixed signal power and for the case with fixed FNL in a transmission system with 100 km fiber spans. Compared with the conventional SSMF loss of 0.22 dB/km, OSNR gains of 7 dB and 5.5 dB are obtained for fixed signal power and fixed FNL, respectively, when the fiber loss is reduced to 0.15 dB/km. From Figure 3.8, it can be seen that at high OSNR, a 1 dB increase in OSNR leads to an increase in capacity per unit bandwidth of w0.33 b/s/Hz, provided that the fiber nonlinear penalty is not increased. So the OSNR gains (at fixed FNL) provided by using ultralow-loss fiber would be very helpful in increasing system capacity.
3.5.1.2 Large core area fiber Another assumption used in the capacity limit study is fiber nonlinear coefficient (g) of 1.27 /W/km, a value typical for SSMF. With lower nonlinear coefficient, high nonlinear limit and thus higher capacity can be allowed. Lower nonlinear coefficient can be realized by using larger effective fiber core area (Aeff). In fact, PSCF [93,94]
3.5 Emerging technologies for increasing system capacity and reach
8
with fixed power with fixed ΦNL
OSNR gain (dB)
7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 0.22
0.21
0.2
0.19
0.18
0.17
0.16
0.15
0.14
Fiber loss coefficient (dB/km)
FIGURE 3.9 OSNR gain as a function of fiber loss coefficient with fixed signal launch power (dashed line) and with fixed mean nonlinear phase shift FFNL (solid line). The fiber span length (L) is assumed to be 100 km.
has an Aeff of 118 mm2, which is about 50% larger than that of SSMF (80 mm2). Theoretical study has recently shown that Aeff as large as 160 mm2 can be achieved with PSCF [97]. Figure 3.10 shows the OSNR gain under fixed FNL as a function of fiber effective area. Compared with the conventional SSMF, an OSNR gain of 3 dB can be obtained with the use of a 160 mm2 PSCF, assuming that the signal power is scaled up by 3 dB to maintain the same mean nonlinear phase shift. The CD coefficient of the large-core-area PSCF is 20.3 ps/nm/km at 1550 nm [92], which is slightly larger than that of the conventional SSMF (17 ps/nm/km) due to the reduction of the negative waveguide dispersion when the core size is increased. With digital coherent detection, CD can be compensated in the digital domain, so the slight increase in CD coefficient does not seem to be a concern. Actually, the increase in dispersion may even help reduce inter-channel nonlinear effects by introducing larger temporal walkoff among co-propagating WDM channels.
3.5.1.3 Shorter span length The fiber span length is assumed to be 100 km in the capacity study presented earlier. In terrestrial optical networks, span lengths much shorter than 100 km are not unusual. In submarine optical transmission, spans lengths are typically between 50 and 60 km. With shorter span length, the OSNR after transmission over a fixed distance with fixed signal launch power is increased. Based on the above discussion, we can define a figure of merit (FOM) for comparing the OSNR obtained after a given transmission distance under a fixed total mean nonlinear phase shift as, FOM(dB)¼a$Lþ10log(Aeff$L/Leff), where a is the
69
CHAPTER 3 Challenges and opportunities
NL (dB)
4
OSNR gain with fixed
70
3 2 1 0 -1 -2
60
80
100
Aeff (
120
140
160
m2)
FIGURE 3.10 OSNR gain under fixed fNL as a function of fiber effective area (Aeff)
loss coefficient in units of dB/km, Aeff is fiber effective area in mm2, and L and Leff are respectively the span length and effective span length in km. For the SSMF case with a¼0.22 dB/km, Aeff¼80 mm2, L¼100 km, we have FOM100 km,SSMF¼4.1 dB. For the PSCF case with a¼0.17 dB/km, Aeff¼120 mm2, L¼100 km, we have FOM100 km,PSCF¼9.8 dB, indicating a remarkable FOM gain of 5.7 dB compared with the SSMF case. When the span length is reduced to 80 km, we have FOM80 km,PSCF¼12.3 dB, which is 2.5 dB more than that obtained with 100 km span length. It is useful to link the FOM gain to the increase in transmission distance. Assuming a simplified yet representative scenario where the fiber nonlinear effect is solely dependent on FNL, a FOM gain of G-dB could be used to increase the transmission distance by G/2 dB when signal launch power is lowered by G/2 dB. This is because the OSNR and FNL values after the increased distance with the G-dB FOM gain remain the same as those after the nominal transmission without the FOM gain.
3.5.2 Novel optical amplification schemes 3.5.2.1 Amplification to cover the full fiber transmission band One obvious way to increase the per-fiber capacity is to increase the optical spectral bandwidth used for transmission. Currently, the optical spectral window used is primarily the C and L bands (1530w1610 nm). A key reason for this is that the silica fiber loss in this spectral window is the lowest. With the advances in low-loss fibers and the removal of the “water” attenuation peak at 1,380 nm, the S-band (1470e1530 nm) may also be effectively used. To realize transmission over the full optical communication band, optical amplifiers that provide efficient gain in this band are crucial. EDFA [98] and DRA [99] are well established for providing
3.5 Emerging technologies for increasing system capacity and reach
efficient amplification in the C and L bands. Future advances in both optical amplifier technology and fiber manufacturing may enable S-band amplification to be more efficient.
3.5.2.2 High-order distributed Raman amplification High-order distributed Raman amplification is a special Raman amplification scheme where the first-order Raman pumps of the optical signals are amplified by additional Raman pumps located at shorter wavelength during transmission. By doing so, more uniform signal power evolution and higher OSNR can be achieved [100]. Fibers with low loss, particularly at pump wavelengths, are essential for highorder distributed Raman amplification to be efficient. With low-loss PSCF, a high transmission capacity-distance product of 84.3 Petabit/skm (13.5Tb/s6,248km) was achieved by employing second-order distributed Raman amplification in combination with EDFAs in the extended L-band [49].
3.5.3 Photonic integrated circuits To support a sustainable growth in optical network capacity, the cost, size, and power consumption needed for each unit bandwidth has to be reduced, which could be achieved through the use of photonic integration. Large-scale photonic integrated circuits (PIC) [101] have been used to monolithically integrate 10-channel 10 Gb/s/ channel OOK transceivers in an InP platform [101]. A 10-channel 40 Gb/s/channel polarization-multiplexed RZ-DQPSK transmitter [102] and a 107 Gb/s DQPSK receiver [103] were recently demonstrated with InP-based PIC. More recently, a monolithic polarization-diversity coherent receiver with on-chip balanced detection in a silicon PIC has been demonstrated and shown to receive a 112 Gb/s PDMQPSK signal [104]. It is expected that PIC will play a major role in supporting future high-capacity optical communication systems.
3.5.4 Novel coding techniques According to the information theory, optimum coding is needed to approach the Shannon limit [2]. Forward error correction (FEC) is one type of coding schemes capable of providing substantial coding gain with small overhead [55]. FEC decoding can be performed after the received “analog” samples are quantized to recover the transmitted data, often referred to as hard-decision decoding, or before the quantization, often referred to as soft-decision decoding, which outperforms the earlier [55,105]. With digital coherent detection, multi-bit representation of each received sample is available, so soft-decision decoding can be straightforwardly implemented. With the use of 3-bit soft decision, a net coding gain of 10.2 dB was demonstrated at 10 Gb/s with a FEC overhead of 25% using a block turbo code (BTC) [106]. The performance of the demonstrated BTC is about 2.2 dB from the Shannon limit [106]. Better performance may be achieved by low-density parity check codes [106e108].
71
72
CHAPTER 3 Challenges and opportunities
In high spectral efficiency transmission, multi-level modulation formats are used, and a special coding technique called trellis-coded modulation (TCM) [109,110] is well suited. In TCM, modulation is considered an integral part of the coding process, and high coding gain can be obtained by using redundant signal sets rather than expanding the signal bandwidth [109,110]. A technical difficulty in implementing the advanced coding schemes at high data rates is associated with the high DSP complexity and computational load usually required by these schemes. It is expected that future advances in silicon technology will help push the system performance toward the Shannon limit.
3.5.5 Compensation of fiber nonlinearity As discussed in the previous section, fiber nonlinearity prevents channel capacity from approaching the Shannon limit, especially when signal power is high and/or transmission distance is long. In principle, deterministic effects may be compensated in the digital coherent receiver assuming that the receiver has full knowledge about the transmission link and the interacting channels. However, it is almost impossible to know all the interacting channels as optical channels are usually dynamically added and dropped in an optical transmission system. Also, the needed computation load would be too high to be practically supported. Moreover, the interaction between ASE noise and fiber nonlinearity and the interaction between stochastic PMD effect and fiber nonlinearity can not be fully compensated at the receiver. So, in practice, only partial compensation of fiber nonlinearity is feasible [3,6,9]. In single-channel transmission, the interaction between self-phase modulation (SPM) and ASE noise results in the Gordon-Mollenauer phase noise [56]. It was theoretically found that the Gordon-Mollenauer phase noise can be partially reduced through lumped nonlinear phase noise compensation at the receiver [57]. This was experimentally demonstrated with the use of digital coherent receiver [58]. In COOFDM transmission, the SPM effect can also be considered the four-wave mixing (FWM) effect among the subcarriers, and was found to degrade the transmission performance of CO-OFDM, especially when fiber dispersion is low [111] or the transmission link is in-line dispersion-compensated [112]. An efficient SPM compensation (SPMC) scheme was proposed for single-polarization OFDM by Lowery [113]. For PDM-OFDM, a joint SPM compensation (J-SPMC) scheme that jointly processes two signal polarization components was recently developed [114,115]. Both SPM compensation schemes require only one complex multiplication per sample, so they are very efficient in terms of the needed DSP load. Recently, J-SPMC was experimentally demonstrated in a dispersion-managed transmission system using a 22 Gb/s PDM-OFDM channel with QPSK subcarrier modulation [116] and a 44 Gb/s PDM-OFDM channel with 16-QAM subcarrier modulation [117], showing nonlinear tolerance (NLT) improvements of 3 dB and 5 dB, respectively. In dispersion-unmanaged high-speed CO-OFDM transmission, the simple single-multiplication based SPMC and J-SPMC schemes become ineffective due to dispersion-induced large waveform changes along the transmission
3.6 Conclusion
link. In this case, digital back-propagation [118,119], which reversely solves the nonlinear Schro¨dinger equation at the receiver through DSP, can be applied. Digital backward propagation can also be implemented at the transmitter [120]. However, digital backward propagation requires multiple back-propagation steps, each step requiring a DSP load similar to that of a generic digital coherent receiver, so the needed DSP resource and power are much increased. In WDM transmission, inter-channel cross-phase modulation (XPM) and FWM also cause nonlinear penalty. These penalties can be substantially compensated by using digital back-propagation, but this requires the receiver to jointly process the sampled fields of the interacting wavelength channels, which further increases the needed computational load [121]. For compensating inter-channel FWM, the phase relationship among the interacting channels also needs to be obtained, and this causes additional hardware complexity, e.g., by requiring phase locking between the transmitter laser and the optical local oscillator and/or higher receiver sampling bandwidth. Nevertheless, future advances in DSP circuits and in nonlinear compensation/mitigation methods may help relax the nonlinear Shannon limit.
3.5.6 Spatial multiplexing Spatial multiplexing has been widely used in wireless communications to increase information capacity [122]. Spatial multiplexing in wireless communications is based on multi-input and multiple-output (MIMO) technology where multiple antennas at both the transmitter and receiver are used to carry multiple data streams simultaneously within the same frequency band. The same concept may also be applied to optical fiber communications if a multimode fiber (MMF) supporting multiple spatial modes is used, together with the use of a “mode-diversity” transmitter capable of launching the signal beams into these spatial modes and a “modediversity” coherent receiver capable of reconstructing the optical fields in these modes. This optical MIMO scheme will allow one to break the fiber optical Shannon limit established for single-mode fiber transmission. The same MIMO processing used for polarization demultiplexing in digital coherent receiver can be extended for mode demultiplexing. A proof-of-concept optical MIMO transmission has been demonstrated with two transmitters and two receivers operating at a relatively low bit rate (50 Mb/s per mode) [123]. The technical challenges for realizing spatial multiplexing in future high-capacity optical transmission systems include the manufacturing of low-loss MMF, the efficient amplification of a multi-mode signal, and the practical implementation of the mode-diversity transmitter and modediversity coherent receiver.
3.6 CONCLUSION We have reviewed the state-of-the-art of high-capacity optical transmission. There are evident technical challenges ahead to meet the ever-increasing traffic demand of
73
74
CHAPTER 3 Challenges and opportunities
optical networks that essentially are backbones for all the communication needs. Accompanying the technical challenges come the opportunities for technologic innovations and oftentimes breakthroughs. Future advances in optical fiber and amplification technologies are expected to be essential in meeting these challenges.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The author is deeply grateful to Drs. Rene Essiambre and Peter Winzer for their insightful comments. In addition, the entire Section 4 on estimating a “Shannon limit” for fiber optical systems is directly based on their recent works on this important subject. The author is also grateful to many of his current and past colleagues in Bell Laboratories, Alcatel-Lucent, for fruitful collaborations and valuable discussions. Among them are S. Chandrasekhar, C. R. Doerr, D. A. Fishman, D. M. Gill, A. H. Gnauck, I. Kang, Y.-H. Kao, N. Kaneda, S. K. Korotky, G. Kramer, A. Leven, C. J. McKinstrie, L. F. Mollenauer, A. J. van Wijngaarden, X. Wei, C. Xie, and C. Xu. The author also wishes to thank A. R. Chraplyvy, C. R. Giles, J.-P. Hamaide, and R. W. Tkach for their support.
ACRONYMS
ADC ASE BER CD CMA CO-OFDM DAC DBPSK DPSK DQPSK DRA DSP DWDM EDC EDFA FEC FPGA FWM ISI J-SPMC
Analog-to-digital converter Amplified spontaneous emission Bit error ratio Chromatic dispersion Constant modulus algorithm Coherent optical orthogonal frequency-division multiplexing Digital-to-analog converter Differential binary phase-shift keying Differential phase-shift keying Differential quadrature phase-shift keying Distributed Raman amplifier Digital signal processing Dense wavelength-division multiplexing Electronic dispersion compensation Erbium-doped fiber amplifier Forward error correction Field programmable gate array Four-wave mixing Inter-symbol interference Joint self phase modulation compensation
References
MIMO MMF MSPE MZM NRZ OADM OFDM OLO OOK OSNR PAM PDM PMD PIC PSCF PSK QAM RZ SE SEDP SPM SPMC SSMF TCM WDM XPM
Multi-input and multiple-output Multimode fiber Multi-symbol phase estimation Mach-Zehnder modulator Non-return-to-zero Optical add/drop multiplexer Orthogonal frequency-division multiplexing Optical local oscillator On-off-keying Optical signal-to-noise ratio Pulse amplitude modulation Polarization division multiplexing Polarization-mode dispersion Photonic integrated circuits Pure silica core fiber Phase-shift keying Quadrature amplitude modulation Return-to-zero Spectral efficiency Spectral efficiency distance product Self phase modulation Self phase modulation compensation Standard single-mode fiber Trellis-coded modulation Wavelength-division multiplexing Cross phase modulation
References [1] R.W. Tkach, Scaling optical communications for the next decade and beyond, Bell Labs Technical Journal 14 (4) (2010) 3e9. [2] C.E. Shannon, A mathematical theory of communication, The Bell System Technical Journal 27 (1948) 379e423 and 623e656. [3] R.-J. Essiambre, G.J. Foschini, G. Kramer, P.J. Winzer, Capacity limits of information transmission in optically routed fiber networks, Bell Labs Technical Journal 14 (4) (2010) 149e162. [4] C. Xu, X. Liu, X. Wei, Modulation formats for high spectral efficiency fiber optic communications, IEEE J. of Select Topics in Quantum Electron. 10 (2004) 281e293. [5] A.H. Gnauck, P.J. Winzer, Optical phase-shift-keyed transmission, J. Lightwave Technol. 23 (2005) 115e130. [6] K.-P. Ho, Phase-modulated optical communication systems, Springer, New York, 2005. [7] P.J. Winzer, R.-J. Essiambre, Advanced optical modulation formats (Chapter 2), in: I.P. Kaminov, T. Li, A.E. Willner (Eds.), Optical Fiber Telecommunications V.B., Academic Press, San Diego, 2008.
75
76
CHAPTER 3 Challenges and opportunities
[8] K. Kikuchi, Coherent optical communication systems (Chapter 3), in: I.P. Kaminov, T. Li, A.E. Willner (Eds.), Optical Fiber Telecommunications V.B., Academic Press, San Diego, 2008. [9] X. Liu, S. Chandrasekhar, A. Leven, Self-coherent optical transport systems (Chapter 4), in: I.P. Kaminov, T. Li, A.E. Willner (Eds.), Optical Fiber Telecommunications V.B. Academic Press, San Diego. [10] F. Forghieri, R.W. Tkach, A.R. Chraplyvy, Fiber nonlinearities and their impact on transmission systems, in: I.P. Kaminov, T.L. Koch (Eds.), Optical Fiber Telecommunications III A., Academic, San Diego, 1997. [11] B. Mikkelsen, C. Rasmussen, P. Mamyshev, F. Liu, Partial DPSK with excellent filter tolerance and OSNR sensitivity, Electron. Lett. 42 (11) (2006) 1363e1364. [12] S. Chandrasekhar, X. Liu, A.R. Chraplyvy, Improving the filtering tolerance of 42.7 Gb/s partial-DPSK by optimized power imbalance, OFC’09, paper OMM1 (2009). [13] P.J. Winzer, G. Raybon, C.R. Doerr, L.L. Buhl, T. Kawanishi, T. Sakamoto, et al., 2000 km WDM transmission of 10 x 107 Gb/s RZ-DQPSK. ECOC’06, Post-deadline Paper Th 4.1.3 (2006). [14] G. Raybon, P.J. Winzer, C.R. Doerr, 1 Tb/s (10107 Gb/s) electronically multiplexed optical signal generation and WDM transmission, J. Lightwave Technol. 25 (2007) 233e238. [15] Y. Han, C. Kim, G. Li, Simplified receiver implementation for optical differential 8-level phase-shift keying, Electron. Lett. 40 (2004) 1372e1373. [16] X. Liu, Generalized data-aided multi-symbol phase estimation for improving receiver sensitivity in direct-detection optical m-ary DPSK, Opt. Express 15 (2007) 2927e2939. http://www.opticsinfobase.org/abstract.cfm?URI¼oe-15-6-2927. [17] N. Kikuchi, K. Mandai, K. Sekine, S. Sasaki, Incoherent 32-level optical multilevel signaling technologies, J. Lightw. Technol 26 (Jan. 1) (2008) 150. [18] M.G. Taylor, Coherent detection method using DSP for demodulation of signal and subsequent equalization of propagation impairments, IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett. 16 (2) (2004) 674e676. [19] Y. Han, G. Li, Coherent optical communication using polarization multiple-inputmultiple-output, Opt. Express 13 (19) (2005) 7527e7534. [20] C.R.S. Fludger, T. Duthel, D. van den Borne, C. Schulien, E.-D. Schmidt, T. Wuth, et al., 10 x 111 Gbit/s, 50 GHz spaced, POLMUX-RZ-DQPSK transmission over 2375 km employing coherent equalisation, OFC’07, post-deadline paper PDP22 (2007). [21] E. Ip, A.P.T. Lau, D.J.F. Barros, J.M. Kahn, Coherent detection in optical fiber systems, Opt. Express 16 (2008) 753e791. [22] S.J. Savory, Digital filters for coherent optical receivers, Opt. Express 16 (2008) 804e817. [23] H. Sun, K. Wu, K. Roberts, Real-time measurements of a 40 Gb/s coherent system, Opt. Express 16 (2008) 873e879. [24] X. Zhou, J. Yu, M.-F. Huang, Y. Shao, T. Wang, P. Magill, et al., 32Tb/s (320x114Gb/s) PDM-RZ-8QAM transmission over 580km of SMF-28 ultra-low-loss fiber, OFC’09, post-deadline paper PDPB4 (2009). [25] A.H. Gnauck, P.J. Winzer, C.R. Doerr, L.L. Buhl, 10 x 112 Gb/s PDM 16-QAM transmission over 630 km of fiber with 6.2-b/s/Hz spectral efficiency, OFC’09, postdeadline paper PDPB8 (2009).
References
[26] H. Takahashi, A. Al Amin, S.L. Jansen, I. Morita, H. Tanaka, DWDM transmission with 7.0-bit/s/Hz spectral efficiency using 8x65.1-Gbit/s coherent PDM-OFDM signals, OFC’09, post-deadline paper PDPB7 (2009). [27] C. Wree, N. Hecker-Denschlag, E. Gottwald, P. Krummrich, J. Leibrich, E.D. Schmidt, et al., High spectral efficiency 1.6-b/s/Hz transmission (8 x 40 Gb/s with a 25 GHz grid) over 200 km SSMF using RZ-DQPSK and polarization multiplexing, IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett. 15 (2003) 1303e1305. [28] P.S. Cho, G. Harston, C. Kerr, A. Greenblatt, A. Kaplan, Y. Achiam, et al., Investigation of 2-bit/s/Hz 40 Gb/s DWDM transmission over 4100 km SMF-28 fiber using RZ-DQPSK and polarization multiplexing, IEEE Photon. Tech. Lett. 16 (2004) 656e658. [29] D. van den Borne, S.L. Jansen, E. Gottwald, P.M. Krummrich, G.D. Khoe, H. de Waardt, 1.6-b/s/Hz Spectrally Efficient Transmission Over 1700 km of SSMF Using 40 85.6 Gb/s POLMUX-RZ-DQPSK, J. Lightwave Technol. 25 (2007) 222e232. [30] S. Chandrasekhar, X. Liu, A. Konczykowska, F. Jorge, J.-Y. Dupuy, J. Godin, Direct detection of 107 Gb/s polarization-multiplexed RZ-DQPSK without optical polarization demultiplexing, IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett. 20 (2008) 1878e1880. [31] See, for example, IEEE standards 802.11a, 802.11g, and 802.16. [32] A.J. Lowery, L. Du, J. Armstrong, Orthogonal frequency division multiplexing for adaptive dispersion compensation in long haul WDM systems, Optical Fiber Commun. Conf., Anaheim, CA., Paper PDP39, 2006. [33] W. Shieh, C. Athaudage, Coherent optical orthogonal frequency division multiplexing, Electron. Lett. 42 (2006) 587e589. [34] I.B. Djordjevic, B. Vasic, Orthogonal frequency division multiplexing for high-speed optical transmission, Opt. Express 14 (2006) 3767e3775. [35] S.L. Jansen, I. Morita, N. Takeda, H. Tanaka, 20 Gb/s OFDM transmission over 4,160 km SSMF enabled by RF-Pilot tone phase noise compensation, OFC’07, postdeadline paper PDP15 (2007). [36] W. Shieh, H. Bao, Y. Tang, Coherent optical OFDM: theory and design, Opt. Express 16 (2008) 841e859. [37] S.L. Jansen, I. Morita, T.C. Schenk, H. Tanaka, Long-haul transmission of 1652.5 Gbits/s polarization-division-multiplexed OFDM enabled by MIMO processing (Invited), J. Opt. Netw. 7 (2008) 173e182. [38] W. Shieh, X. Yi, Y. Ma, Q. Yang, Coherent optical OFDM: has its time come? [Invited], J. Opt. Netw. 7 (2008) 234e255. [39] X. Liu, F. Buchali, Intra-symbol frequency-domain averaging based channel estimation for coherent optical OFDM, Opt. Express 16 (2008) 21944e21957. [40] X. Liu, F. Buchali, R.W. Tkach, Improving the nonlinear tolerance of polarizationdivision-multiplexed CO-OFDM in long-haul fiber transmission, J. Lightwave Technol. 27 (16) (2009) 3632e3640. [41] A. Bocoi1, M. Schuster, F. Rambach, D.A. Schupke, C.-A. Bunge, B. Spinnler, Cost comparison of networks using traditional 10 and 40 Gb/s transponders versus OFDM transponders, OFC’08, paper OThB4 (2008). [42] B. Spinnler, F.N. Hauske, M. Kuschnerov, Adaptive equalizer complexity in coherent optical Receivers, ECOC’08, paper We.2.E.4 (2008). [43] X. Yi, W. Shieh, Y. Ma, Phase noise effects on high spectral efficiency coherent optical OFDM transmission, J. of Lightwave Technology 26 (2008) 1309e1316.
77
78
CHAPTER 3 Challenges and opportunities
[44] W. Shieh, Q. Yang, Y. Ma, 107 Gb/s coherent optical OFDM transmission over 1000 km SSMF fiber using orthogonal band multiplexing, Opt. Express 16 (2008) 6378e6386. http://www.opticsinfobase.org/oe/abstract.cfm?URI¼oe-16-96378. [45] Y. Ma, Q. Yang, Y. Tang, S. Chen, W. Shieh, 1 Tb/s per channel coherent optical OFDM transmission with subwavelength bandwidth access, OFC’09, post-deadline paper PDP1 (2009). [46] R. Dischler, F. Buchali, Transmission of 1.2 Tb/s continuous waveband PDMOFDM-FDM signal with spectral efficiency of 3.3 but/s/Hz over 400 km of SSMF, OFC’09, post-deadline paper PDP2 (2009). [47] A.D. Ellis, F.C. Garcia Gunning, Spectral density enhancement using coherent WDM, IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett. 17 (2) (2005) 504e506. [48] A. Sano, H. Masuda, E. Yoshida, T. Kobayashi, E. Yamada, Y. Miyamoto, et al., 30 x 100 Gb/s all-optical OFDM transmission over 1300 km SMF with 10 ROADM nodes, In Proc. ECOC2007, paper PD1.7 (2007). [49] H. Masuda, E. Yamazaki, A. Sano, T. Yoshimatsu, T. Kobayashi, E. Yoshida, et al., 13.5 Tb/s (135 111 Gb/s/ch) no-guard-interval coherent OFDM transmission over 6,248 km using SNR maximized second-order DRA in the extended L-band, OFC’09, post-deadline paper PDPB5 (2009). [50] C. Sethumadhavan, X. Liu, et al., Hybrid 107 Gb/s polarization-multiplexed DQPSK and 42.7 Gb/s DQPSK transmission at 1.4 bits/s/Hz spectral efficiency over 1280 km of SSMF and 4 bandwidth-managed ROADMs, ECOC’07, post-deadline paper PD 1.9 (2007). [51] G. Charlet, M. Salsi, P. Tran, M. Bertolini, H. Mardoyan, J. Renaudier, et al., 72x100Gb/s Transmission over transoceanic distance, using large effective area fiber, hybrid Raman-Erbium amplification and coherent detection, OFC’09, post-deadline paper PDPB6 (2009). [52] K. Roberts, M. O’Sullivan, K.-T. Wu, H. Sun, A. Awadalla, D. Krause, et al., Performance of dual-polarization QPSK for optical transport systems, J. Lightwave Technol. 27 (16) (2009) 3546e3559. [53] S. Chen, Q. Yang, Y. Ma, W. Shieh, Multi-gigabit real-time coherent optical OFDM receiver, OFC’09, paper OTuO4 (2009). [54] Q. Yang, N. Kaneda, X. Liu, S. Chandrasekhar, W. Shieh, Y.K. Chen, Real-time coherent optical OFDM receiver at 2.5-GS/s for receiving a 54 Gb/s multi-band signal, OFC’09, post-deadline paper PDPC5 (2009). [55] J.G. Proakis, Digital Communications, fourth ed., McGraw Hill, New York, 2000. [56] J.P. Gordon, L.F. Mollenauer, Phase noise in photonic communications systems using linear amplifiers, Opt. Lett. 15 (1990) 1351e1353. [57] X. Liu, X. Wei, R.E. Slusher, C.J. McKinstrie, Improving transmission performance in differential phase-shift-keyed systems by use of lumped nonlinear phase-shift compensation, Opt. Lett. 27 (2002) 1616e1618. [58] K.-P. Ho, J.M. Kahn, Electronic compensation technique to mitigate nonlinear phase noise, J. Lightwave Technol. 22 (2004) 779e783. [59] V. Veljanovski, M. Alfiad, D. van den Borne, S.L. Jansen, T. Wuth, Equalization of FBG-induced group-delay ripples penalties using a coherent receiver and digital signal processing, OFC’09, paper JThA40 (2009).
References
[60] J. Bromage, P.J. Winzer, R.-J. Essiambre, Multiple Path Interference and its Impact on System Design (Chapter 15), in: M.N. Islam (Ed.), Raman Amplifiers for Telecommunications, Springer, New York, 2004. [61] I. Dedic, 56 GS/s ADC: Enabling 100GbE. OFC’10, invited paper (to be presented) (2010). [62] J.P. Gordon, W.H. Louisell, L.R. Walker, Quantum fluctuations and noise in parametric processes II, Phys. Rev. 129 (1963) 481e485. [63] J.P. Gordon, W.H. Louisell, L.R. Walker, Quantum statistics of masers and attenuators, Phys. Rev. 130 (1963) 806e812. [64] G.P. Agrawal, Nonlinear Fiber Optics, fourth ed., Elsevier Science & Technology, San Diego, 2006. [65] P.P. Mitra, J.B. Stark, Nonlinear limits to the information capacity of optical fibre communications, Nature 411 (2001) 1027e1030. [66] J. Tang, The Shannon channel capacity of dispersion-free nonlinear optical fiber transmission, J. Lightwave Technol. 19 (2001) 1104e1109. [67] E. Narimanov, P.P. Mitra, The channel capacity of a fiber optics communication system: Perturbation theory, J. Lightwave Technol. 20 (2002) 530e537. [68] E. Desurvire, A quantum model for optically amplified nonlinear transmission systems, Optical Fiber Technol. (2002) 210e230. [69] J. Tang, The channel capacity of a multispan DWDM system employing dispersive nonlinear optical fibers and an ideal coherent optical receiver, J. Lightwave Technol. 20 (2002) 1095e1101. [70] K.-P. Ho, Channel capacity of WDM systems using constant-intensity modulation formats, Proc. Opt. Fiber Commun. Conf. (OFC) paper ThGG85 (2002) 731e733. [71] K.S. Turitsyn, S.A. Derevyanko, I.V. Yurkevich, S.K. Turitsyn, Information capacity of optical fiber channels with zero average dispersion, Phys. Rev. Lett. 91 (2003) 203901, 1e4. [72] L.G. Wegener, et al., The effect of propagation nonlinearities on the information capacity of WDM optical fiber systems: cross-phase modulation and four-wave mixing, Physica D 189 (2004) 81e99. [73] M.H. Taghavi, G.C. Papen, P.H. Siegel, On the multiuser capacity of WDM in a nonlinear optical fiber: Coherent communication, IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory 52 (2006) 5008e5022. [74] I. Djordjevic, B. Vasic, M. Ivkovic, I. Gabitov, Achievable information rates for high-speed long-haul optical transmission, J. Lightwave Technol. 23 (2005) 3755e3763. [75] R.-J. Essiambre, G.J. Foschini, G. Kramer, P.J. Winzer, Capacity limits of information transport in fiber-optic networks, Phys. Rev. Lett. 101 (2008), paper 163901. [76] R.-J. Essiambre, G.-J. Foschini, P.J. Winzer, G. Kramer, Capacity limits of fiber-optic communication systems, Proc. Opt. Fiber Commun. Conf. (OFC) OThL1 (2009). [77] H. Nyquist, Certain topics of telegraph transmission theory, Trans. Am. Inst. Electr. Eng. 47 (1928) 617e644. [78] A.A. Saleh, J.M. Simmons, Evolution toward the next-generation core optical network, J. Lightwave Technol. 24 (2006) 3303e3321. [79] G.J. Foschini, Layered space-time architecture for wireless communication in a fading environment when using multi-element antennas, Bell Labs Technical Journal 1 (1006) 41e59.
79
80
CHAPTER 3 Challenges and opportunities
[80] C. Par’e, A. Villeneuve, P.-A. B’elanger, N.J. Doran, Compensating for dispersion and the nonlinear Kerr effect without phase conjugation, Opt. Lett. 21 (1996) 459e461. [81] W. Forysiak, N. Doran, Reduction of gordon-haus jitter in soliton transmission systems by optical phase conjugation, J. Lightwave Technol. 13 (1995) 850e855. [82] C.J. McKinstrie, S. Radic, C. Xie, Reduction of soliton phase jitter by in-line phase conjugation, Opt. Lett. 28 (2003) 1519e1521. [83] A. Mecozzi, Probability density functions of the nonlinear phase noise, Opt. Lett. 29 (2004) 673e675. [84] G.P. Agrawal, Fiber-Optic Communication Systems, third ed., John Wiley & Sons, San Diego, CA, 2002. [85] L.F. Mollenauer, J.P. Gordon, Solitons in Optical Fibers: Fundamentals and Applications, Academic Press, Burlington, MA, 2006. [86] R.-J. Essiambre, G.J. Foschini, P.J. Winzer, G. Kramer, E.C. Burrows, The capacity of fiber-optic communication systems, Proc. Opt. Fiber Commun. Conf. (OFC) OTuE1 (2008). [87] J.-C. Bouteiller, K. Brar, J. Bromage, S. Radic, C. Headley, Dualorder Raman pump, Photon. Technol. Lett. 15 (2003) 212e214. [88] R.-J. Essiambre, G. Raybon, B. Mikkelsen, Pseudo-linear transmission of high-speed TDM signals: 40 and 160 Gb/s, in: I. Kaminow, T. Li (Eds.), Optical Fiber Telecommunications IV, Academic Press, San Diego, CA, 2002, pp. 232e304. [89] G.P. Agrawal, Lightwave Technology: Telecommunication Systems, John Wiley and Sons, Hoboken, New Jersey, 2005. [90] L.K. Wickham, R.-J. Essiambre, A.H. Gnauck, P.J. Winzer, A.R. Chraplyvy, Bit pattern length dependence of intrachannel nonlinearities in pseudolinear transmission, Photon. Technol. Lett. 16 (2004) 1591e1593. [91] A. Mecozzi, C.B. Clausen, M. Shtaif, S.-G. Park, A.H. Gnauck, Cancellation of timing and amplitude jitter in symmetric links using highly dispersed pulses, Photon. Technol. Lett. 13 (2001) 445e447. [92] M.-J. Li, D.A. Nolan, Optical transmission fiber design evolution, J. Lightwave Technol. 26 (2008) 1079e1092. [93] K. Nagayama, M. Kakui, M. Matsui, T. Saitoh, Y. Chigusa, Ultralow-loss (0.1 484 dB/km) pure silica core fibre and extension of transmission distance, Electron. Lett. 38 (20) (2002) 1168e1169. [94] Y. Chigusa, Y. Yamamoto, T. Yokokawa, T. Sasaki, T. Taru, M. Hirano, et al., Lowloss pure-silica-core fibers and their possible impact on transmission systems, J. Lightwave Technol. 23 (2005) 3541e3550. [95] K. Tsujikawa, K. Tajima, K. Shiraki, I. Sankawa, Method for predicting Rayleigh scattering loss of silica-based optical fibers, J. Lightwave Technol. 25 (2007) 2122e2128. [96] K. Tsujikawa, K. Tajima, K. Ieda, K. Nakajima, K. Kurokawa, K. Shiraki, et al., Evaluation of Rayleigh scattering loss in photonic crystal fibers by using bi-directional OTDR measurement, OFC’07, paper OThA8 (2007). [97] K. Mukasa, K. Imamura, R. Sugizaki, T. Yagi, Comparisons of merits on wide-band transmission systems between using extremely improved solid SMFs with Aeff of 160mm2 and loss of 0.175dB/km and using large-Aeff holey fibers enabling transmission over 600nm bandwidth, OFC’08, paper OThR1 (2008).
References
[98] E. Desurvire, Erbium-Doped Fiber Amplifiers, John Wiley & Sons, New York, NY, 1994. [99] M.N. Islam (Ed.), Raman Amplifiers for Telecommunications, Springer, New York, NY, 2004. [100] S. Radic, Forward, Bidirectional, and Higher-Order Raman Amplification, Raman Amplifiers for Telecommunications, in: M.N. Islam (Ed.), Springer, New York, NY, 2004 (Chapter 9). [101] R. Nagarajan, C.H. Joyner, R.P. Schneider, J.S. Bostak, T. Butrie, A.G. Dentai, et al., Large-scale photonic integrated circuits, IEEE J. Sel. Topics Quantum Electron. 11 (Jan) (2005) 50. [102] M. Kato, P. Evans, S. Corzine, J. Gheorma, M. Fisher, M. Raburn, et al., Transmitter PIC for 10-channel 40Gb/s per channel polarization-multiplexed RZ-DQPSK modulation, OFC’09, paper OThN2 (2009). [103] C.R. Doerr, L. Zhang, L.L. Buhl, J.H. Sinsky, A.H. Gnauck, P.J. Winzer, A.L. Adamiecki, et al., High-speed InP DQSPK receiver, OFC’08, post-deadline paper PDP23 (2008). [104] C.R. Doerr, P.J. Winzer, S. Chandrasekhar, M. Rasras, M. Earnshaw, J. Weiner, et al., Monolithic silicon coherent receiver, OFC’09, post-deadline paper PDPB2 (2009). [105] G. Kramer, A. Ashikhmin, A.J. van Wijngaarden, X. Wei, Spectral efficiency of coded phase-shift keying for fiber-optic communication, J. Lightwave Technol. 21 (2003) 2438e2445. [106] T. Mizuochi, Recent progress in forward error correction and its interplay with transmission impairments, J. Sel. Top. Quantum Electron. 12 (2006) 544e554. [107] R.G. Gallager, Low Density Parity Check Codes, Monograph, M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, MA, 1963. [108] D.J.C. MacKay, R.M. Neal, Near Shannon limit performance of low density parity check codes, Electronics Letters, July (1996). [109] G. Ungerboeck, Channel coding with multilevel/phase signals, IEEE Trans. Inform. Theory IT 28 (1982) 55e67. [110] G. Ungerboeck, Trellis-coded modulation with redundant signal sets part I: introduction, IEEE Communications Magazine 25-2 (1987) 5e11. [111] A.J. Lowery, et al., Calculation of power limit due to fiber nonlinearity in optical OFDM systems, Opt. Express 15 (2007) 13282e13287. [112] K. Forozesh, et al., The influence of the dispersion map in coherent optical OFDM transmission systems, 2008 IEEE LEOS Summer Topic Meetings, paper WC2.4 (2008). [113] A.J. Lowery, Fiber nonlinearity pre- and post-compensation for long-haul optical links using OFDM, Opt. Express 15 (2007) 12965e12970. [114] X. Liu, R.W. Tkach, Joint SPM compensation for inline-dispersion-compensated 112 Gb/s PDM-OFDM transmission, OFC’09, paper OTuO5 (2009). [115] X. Liu, F. Buchali, R.W. Tkach, Improving the nonlinear tolerance of polarizationdivision-multiplexed CO-OFDM in long-haul fiber transmission, J. Lightwave Technol. 27 (16) (2009) 3632e3640. [116] X. Liu, F. Buchali, R.W. Tkach, S. Chandrasekhar, Mitigation of fiber nonlinear impairments in polarization-division multiplexed OFDM transmission, Bell Labs Technol. J. 14 (4) (2010) 47e59.
81
82
CHAPTER 3 Challenges and opportunities
[117] X. Liu, S. Chandrasekhar, A.H. Gnauck, R.W. Tkach, Experimental demonstration of joint SPM compensation in 44 Gb/s PDM-OFDM transmission with 16-QAM subcarrier modulation, Submitted to ECOC’09 (2009). [118] X. Li, X. Chen, G. Goldfarb, E. Mateo, I. Kim, F. Yaman, et al., Electronic postcompensation of WDM transmission impairments using coherent detection and digital signal processing, Opt. Express 16 (2008) 880e888. [119] E. Ip, J.M. Kahn, Compensation of dispersion and nonlinear impairments using digital backpropagation, J. Lightwave Technol. 20 (2008) 3416e3425. [120] X. Liu, D.A. Fishman, A fast and reliable algorithm for electronic preequalization of SPM and chromatic dispersion, OFC’ 06, paper OThD4 (2006). [121] E. Mateo, L. Zhu, G. Li, Impact of XPM and FWM on the digital implementation of impairment compensation for WDM transmission using backward propagation, Opt. Express 16 (2008) 16124e16137. [122] G.J. Foschini, Layered space-time architecture for wireless communication in a fading environment when using multi-element antennas, Bell Labs. Technol. J., Autumn Issue (1996) 41e59. [123] H.R. Stuart, Dispersive multiplexing in multimode optical fiber, Science 289 (2000) 281e283.
CHAPTER
EDFAs, Raman Amplifiers and Hybrid Raman/EDFAs
4
John Zyskind*, Maxim Bolshtyansky** *
Oclaro, Inc. Acton, MA,
**
JDSU at Robbinsville, NJ
CHAPTER OUTLINE HEAD 4.1. Introduction .................................................................................................. 4.2. An overview of EDFAs, DRAs AND HYBRID RAMAN/DRA..................................... 4.2.1. EDFA gain, output power, and noise figure ..................................... 4.2.2. DRA and hybrid Raman/EDFA gain and noise figure ........................ 4.3. Gain spectra and DWDM applications ............................................................. 4.3.1. DWDM amplifiers and average inversion......................................... 4.3.2. Spectral hole burning ................................................................... 4.4. EDFA dynamics ............................................................................................ 4.4.1. Overview of dynamic effects in EDFAs ......................................... 4.4.2. Inhomogeneous effects in EDFA transient response ...................... 4.5. Conclusions ................................................................................................ List of Acronyms ................................................................................................. References .........................................................................................................
83 84 84 89 93 93 96 104 104 108 111 112 113
4.1 INTRODUCTION The invention of the erbium-doped fiber amplifier (EDFA) in the 1980s [1,2] and its introduction in the 1990s revolutionized optical communications by enabling dense wavelength division multiplexing (DWDM) and an exponential growth in the capacity of optical fiber communications systems [3,4]. The advent of EDFAs and of DWDM optically amplified networks raised a new set of challenges including problems related to concatenated chains of optical amplifiers, such as managing the accumulation of optical noise generated by optical amplifiers and of variations in the spectral gain and noise of amplifiers. New challenges also arose related to transmitting signals over multiple fiber spans such as the accumulation of chromatic dispersion, polarization mode dispersion, and distortion arising from optical nonlinearities. These problems are all of concern in a point-to-point system. More recently, the introduction of wavelength routing network elements to enable rapid network configuration is producing another major advance in optical networks [5]. Reconfigurability enables service providers to meet dynamic demands and Optically Amplified WDM Networks. DOI: 10.1016/B978-0-12-374965-9.10004-4 Copyright Ó 2011 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
83
84
CHAPTER 4 EDFAs, Raman amplifiers and hybrid Raman/EDFAs
increase velocity of service delivery. Reconfigurable optical add/drop multiplexers (ROADMs) and wavelength selective switches are key enabling technologies for dynamic networks, but they rest on the DWDM foundation laid by optical amplifiers. These new network architectures, in turn, place additional demands on the performance and features of optical amplifiers beyond the requirements for point-to-point systems. Because different wavelengths follow distinct paths through reconfigurable networks, and because the paths are often longer than for point-to-point systems, more stringent constraints are placed on amplifier gain ripple, amplifier noise figure, and polarization dependent gain. Spectral hole burning in EDFAs and accumulation of tilt due to stimulated Raman scattering (SRS) interaction among signal channels as they propagate through the network must be controlled more tightly. Large changes in channel loading of the optical amplifiers can result both from reconfiguration of the network and from faults in branching networks. Dynamic gain control of the amplifiers becomes critical to manage the dynamic cross saturation in the amplifiers and the potentially large changes in SRS-induced tilt. [6,7]. It is also important to consider constraints on the management and operation of the network, such as sequencing of channel reconfigurations and scheduling of amplifier adjustments, imposed by the characteristics of the amplifiers. In addition to reconfigurability, future networks will need much higher capacity to meet the exploding demand for bandwidth. This is expected to drive the development in the next few years of systems carrying 100 Gb/s per wavelength channel and subsequently systems with even higher capacity (see Chapter 3 and references therein). Such systems will place more stringent demands on amplifiers in a number of respects, particularly noise performance and, where coherent systems capable of electronic dispersion compensation are adopted, perhaps relax requirements related to the use of dispersion compensating modules. This chapter will focus on the properties of the most commonly used optical amplifiers, Erbium-doped fiber amplifiers (EDFAs) and distributed Raman amplifiers (DRAs) focusing on those which are important for the design and performance of reconfigurable optical networks and for high capacity networks. In Section 4.2 we will review the standard characteristics of EDFAs and DRAs before, in Sections 4.3 and 4.4, dealing with the spectral and dynamic properties which take on added importance in reconfigurable optical networks.
4.2 AN OVERVIEW OF EDFAs, DRAs AND HYBRID RAMAN/DRA 4.2.1 EDFA gain, output power, and noise figure The erbium-doped fiber amplifier was the first optical amplifier widely used in optical communications systems, and it resulted in a dramatic growth in transmission capacity with the deployment of wavelength division multiplexed (WDM) systems [3,4,8]. EDFAs are very widely deployed and are the basis of the vast majority of optically amplified systems. The heart of the EDFA is a single mode fiber, the core of which is doped with Er3þ ions. Amplification occurs by resonant
4.2 An overview of EDFAs, DRAs and hybrid Raman/DRA
(b) ≈1-10 s 4I11/2 iat ad nr no
1590 nm
1480 nm
ms 4I 13/2
1560 nm
I15/2
1530 nm
980 nm
ive
4
sp≈10
Emission/Absorption (dB/km)
(a)
5 4 g*
3 α
2
α
1
g*
0 1450
1500
1550
Emission Absorption
1600
1650
Wavelength (nm)
FIGURE 4.1 (a) Energy level scheme of ground and first two excited states of Er ions in a silica matrix. The sublevel splitting and the lengths of arrows representing absorption and emission transitions are not drawn to scale. In the case of the 4I11/2 state, s is the lifetime for nonradiative decay to the 4I13/2 first excited state and ssp is the spontaneous lifetime of the 4I13/2 first excited state. (b) Absorption coefficient, a, and emission coefficient, g*, spectra for a typical aluminum co-doped EDF.
interaction with the Er ions, the level scheme of which is shown in Figure 4.1. The most important feature of the level scheme is that the transition energy between the 4 I15/2 ground state and the 4I13/2 first excited state corresponds to photon wavelengths (approximately 1530 to 1560 nm) for which the attenuation in silica fibers is lowest. Amplification is achieved by creating an inversion by pumping atoms into the first excited state, typically using either 980 nm or 1480 nm diode lasers. Because of the superior noise figure they provide and their superior wall plug efficiency, most EDFAs are built using 980 nm pump diodes. 1480 nm pump diodes are still often used in L-band EDFAs (see Section 4.3.1) although here, too, 980 nm pumps are becoming more widely used. The high angular momentum electronic states are spread in energy by the Stark splitting arising from electric fields in the glass matrix. The Stark broadening accounts for most of the spectral width of the absorption and emission coefficients shown in Figure 4.1. The spectral width of the emission coefficient determines the optical bandwidth over which the EDFA can provide gain and makes WDM transmission possible over EDFA-based transmission links. The gain in an EDFA can be found by calculating the population of the first excited state, N2, at every point of the erbium-doped fiber (EDF), then calculating the propagation of a signal (or pump) through the fiber as it interacts with ions in the ground state experiencing absorption, which results in attenuation, and interacts with ions in the first excited state experiencing stimulated emission, which results in amplification [9]. A full formulation is based on the microscopic cross sections for the absorption and emission processes, the spatial distribution of Er populations
85
86
CHAPTER 4 EDFAs, Raman amplifiers and hybrid Raman/EDFAs
(fraction of Er ions in each electronic state as a function of radial position within the fiber core and along the fiber length), and the lifetime for spontaneous emission from the first excited state. Most practical EDFA models are based [10,11] on a population equation such as Equation 1, and a propagation equation such as Equation 2, in which the microscopic quantities, which are difficult to measure, are replaced by a number of derived macroscopic fiber parameters that are easily determined by measurements on a fiber. N2 ðzÞ ¼
X k
Pk ðzÞaðlk Þ X Pk ðzÞðaðlk Þ þ g ðlk ÞÞ 1þ hnk z k
dPk ¼ uk ½aðlk Þ þ g ðlk Þ,N2 ðzÞ,Pk ðzÞ þ 2uk g ðlk Þ,N2 ðzÞ,hnk Dn dz uk ½aðlk Þ þ a0 ðlk ÞPk ðzÞ
Equation 1
Equation 2
Equation 1 gives the inversion where: N2 is the fraction of Er ions in the first excited state; Pk(z) is the power at wavelength lk as a function of z, the length coordinate along the fiber; a(lk) is the absorption coefficient in inverse meters at wavelength lk for an erbium-doped fiber in which all the ions are in the ground state shown in Figure 4.1 for a typical erbium-doped fiber; g* is the emission coefficient in inverse meters for an erbium-doped fiber which is fully inverted, i.e. all the erbium ions are in the first excited state also shown in Figure 4.1; h is Planck’s constant; nk is the frequency corresponding to wavelength lk; and 2 is the saturation parameter, which is equal to the effective area times the erbium ion number density divided by the lifetime for spontaneous emission of the first excited state. In Equation 2, Pk is the power of the kth wavelength; uk is a direction indicator which is þ1 for propagation in the þz direction and -1 for propagation in the ez direction; and a0 is the background absorption coefficient of the EDF exclusive of the erbium-induced absorption. The absorption coefficient, a(lk), the emission coefficient, g*, and the saturation parameter, 2, contain the same information as the microscopic quantities such as emission, absorption cross section, first excited state spontaneous lifetime, and number density of Er ions, but unlike the microscopic quantities are readily determined by standard optical measurements on the EDF. This formulation assumes that the populations of the ground and first excited states are constant in time. Because the data rates are generally much faster than the lifetime of the Er 4 I13/2 metastable level, this steady state model is generally, though not always, a good approximation as discussed in Section 4.3.2. It is important to note that an assumption underlying this model is that saturation in the EDF gain medium is homogeneous, i.e., all Er ions in the fiber have identical absorption and emission spectra. This is an approximation and generally a fairly good one but as we shall see in Section 4.3.2 and 4.4.2, its validity is limited which has consequences for both the spectral characteristics of EDFAs and their dynamic behavior which are significant for applications in reconfigurable networks.
4.2 An overview of EDFAs, DRAs and hybrid Raman/DRA
Another important approximation made for Equations 1 and 2 is the so-called 2-level approximation when the transfer time from the pump level to the upper lasing 4I11/2 metastable level is assumed to be very small. For 1480 nm pumping, where the pump level and upper lasing level are different manifold sublevels within the 4I13/2 metastable electronic state, this is a very good approximation. For 980 nm pumping, the pump level is the third 4I11/2 state, which has a small but significant lifetime for nonradiative decay to the 4I13/2 metastable electronic state. In order to get accurate modeling in all cases, especially when modeling dynamic effects or when pump and signal powers are very high, one needs to account for that level (thus the equations will become dependent on N3 in addition to N2), and measure the lifetime of the 4I11/2.second excited state. This lifetime depends on the EDF composition and is typically between 1 and 10ms. The three level formulation can be found in a number of references [9,12,13,14] and is beyond the scope of this chapter. Gain in optical amplifiers produced by stimulated emission must always be accompanied by spontaneous emission. When spontaneously emitted photons are captured and guided in the optical fiber core, they induce stimulated emission and are amplified in the same way as the signals, giving rise to amplifier spontaneous emission (ASE). While optical amplifiers typically improve system noise performance by increasing the ratio of signal power to electronic receiver noise, the ASE that always accompanies optical amplifier is a source of optical noise. Because of the higher signal power at the receiver in optically amplified systems, it is the ASEinduced optical noise that fundamentally limits the noise performance of optically amplified systems. The efficiency of producing as much gain as possible with as little ASE as possible is characterized by the spontaneous emission factor given in Equation 3, where se is the emission cross section, sa is the absorption cross section, and N1 is the number density of Er ions in the ground state: nsp ¼
se N2 g N 2 ¼ se N2 sa N1 g N2 aN1
Equation 3
For simplicity, the wavelength dependences of the emission cross section, the absorption cross section, the emission coefficient, absorption coefficient, and the spontaneous emission factor are not shown. The total ASE power in both polarizations and in an optical bandwidth Bo is given in terms of nsp by Equation 4 where h is Planck’s constant, n is the photon energy, and G is the gain in linear units: PASE ¼ 2nsp hnðG 1ÞBo
Equation 4
Note that PASE is proportional to nsp which is equal to 1 when the amplifier is fully inverted, (N2¼N the total number density of Er ions and N1¼0) and, for a given level of gain, increases as the inversion becomes lower. The impact of this optical noise is characterized by the noise figure of the optical amplifier. The amplifier noise figure is the ratio of the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of a noiseless receiver placed at the output of the amplifier to the SNR of a noiseless
87
88
CHAPTER 4 EDFAs, Raman amplifiers and hybrid Raman/EDFAs
receiver placed at the input. In the former case the receiver is subject to the optical noise generated by the amplifier and in the latter only the shot noise is considered. The noise figure is given by [9]: 2 ðG 1Þ 1 n2sp ðG 1Þ eðBo Be Þ 2ðG 1Þnsp eBo þ þ þ G G G2 Isin G2 Isin 1 z2nsp þ G z2 ¼ 3dB
NF ¼ 2nsp
Equation 5 Where Be is the electrical bandwidth of the receiver, e is the electron charge and Iin s is the photocurrent that would be generated if the input power to the amplifier were coupled directly into the receiver (so that G$Iin s is the photocurrent of the receiver following the amplifier). On the right hand of the first line, the first term represents the contribution of signal-spontaneous beat noise, and the second term represents signal shot noise, neither of which depends on the optical bandwidth, Bo. The third term represents spontaneous-spontaneous beat noise and the fourth term spontaneous shot noise, both of which depend on the optical bandwidth and which can be decreased by reducing the optical bandwidth. The approximation in the second line holds when the optical bandwidth Bo is small. That in the third line holds when, in addition, the gain is large. The 3 dB limit for maximum inversion (nsp¼1) is the so-called quantum limit and represents the ideal noise performance of a fully inverted optical amplifier. Because input losses add directly to the noise figure dB for dB and practical inversion is difficult to maintain over the full operating range of gains required for an amplifier, commercial amplifiers typically are specified with noise figures between 5 and 7 dB, although for very wide ranges of operating gains, the noise figure for low gains when the input power is high and/or the pump power is low can be much higher. A more accurate estimation of amplifier noise figure can be obtained by numerically solving Equations 1 and 2 (or corresponding equations for the 3 level system), and keeping track of ASE power separately from signal power. Note that Equation 2 contains a spontaneous emission term that has factor of 2 to reflect ASE power in two polarizations. After total ASE power in both polarizations is calculated for the output of the amplifier, the noise figure can be calculated according to the formula: 1 PASE þ1 Equation 6 NF ¼ G hn,Bo Substituting the expression from Equation 4 for PASE in Equation 6, one can demonstrate again, that for high values of inversion (nsp ¼ 1) and for high values of optical gain G, the noise figure becomes 3dB. In WDM systems EDFAs are typically operated in saturation in which case the available signal output power is approximately proportional to (and limited by) the
4.2 An overview of EDFAs, DRAs and hybrid Raman/DRA
pump power while the gain is roughly proportional to the column depth of erbium, or for a given EDF design, the length of the fiber. As the cost of the pump lasers typically constitute a significant fraction of the cost of an EDFA, the EDFA cost depends strongly on the EDFA output power. Systems typically have chains of concatenated amplifiers separated by fiber spans or, with the advent of ROADM-based wavelength routing networks, by lossy wavelength routing elements. The noise performance of such a system with multiple amplifiers between the transmitter and receiver is characterized in terms of the optical signal-to-noise ratio (OSNR) of the signal arriving at the receiver defined as the ratio of the signal power in the channel to the ASE power in a 0.1 nm optical bandwidth. The OSNR of a system consisting of a chain of Namp amplifiers, each with noise figure NF(in dB) and Pout sig per channel (in dBm) and each preceded by a fiber span or other loss element of loss Lspan is given by [8] OSNRðdBÞ ¼ 58 NF þ Pout sig Lspan 10,log10 Namp
Equation 7
Equation 7 shows the key amplifier characteristics that are important in determining the noise performance of the system. The OSNR at the end of the system increases by 1 dB for every 1 dB reduction in the noise figure of the EDFAs. However, the attainable noise figure is limited in principle by the 3 dB quantum limit and in practice to somewhere between 5 and 7 dB, depending on the amplifier design due to the optical insertion loss of components placed before the input end of the EDF. The OSNR also increases 1 dB for every 1 dB increase in the output power as well as for every dB decrease in span loss. However, the usable output power per channel is limited by the nonlinear limits above which nonlinear impairments in the transmission fiber set in, which depends on the system design but typically falls in the range between 0 and 5 dBm and typically limits the total useful output power to approximately 20 to 21 dBm for a system with 80 DWDM channels. In fact it is better to view the system noise perforout mance as depending dB for dB on Pin sig which is equal to Psig -Lspan . The noise performance depends only logarithmically on the number of amplified spans so it can often be improved by spacing the amplifiers more closely so that Namp goes up but Lspan is reduced. But this improved performance comes at the increased financial cost of building, managing, and maintaining additional repeater sites.
4.2.2 DRA and hybrid Raman/EDFA gain and noise figure The distributed Raman amplifier, which requires much higher pump powers than EDFAs, was later to be commercialized and is not as widely deployed. The DRA is based on the stimulated Raman effect which is a non-resonant effect occurring in all fibers and, unlike the EDFA, does not require the presence of special dopants. Figure 4.2 shows the gain coefficient spectra for Raman amplification in Silica fiber [15]. Because it is based on the Raman shift and is nonresonant, the spectrum of the gain coefficient is not a function of the absolute wavelength, but of the energy
89
CHAPTER 4 EDFAs, Raman amplifiers and hybrid Raman/EDFAs
Raman Gain Spectra of silica 1.2
~100 nm near l=1500 nm
Parallel Pol.
1
Norm. Gain Coeff.
90
Orthogonal Pol.
0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Frequency (THz)
FIGURE 4.2 Normalized Raman gain coefficients in a typical silica fiber as a function of the frequency difference between the pump and signal wavelengths [15].
difference or, equivalently, the frequency difference, between the pump light and the signal. By combining pump light from multiple pump diodes with suitably selected wavelengths, the composite gain spectrum, which will be the sum of the gain spectra induced by the individual pumps, can be tailored to the desired shape and wavelength range [16,17]. The spectral flexibility of distributed Raman amplification is one of its key properties and advantages. Another notable characteristic of Raman amplification is the strong polarization dependence of the gain coefficients which necessitates the use of unpolarized pumps. The propagation of a signal at wavelength lj with optical power Pj in channel j, including both signal power and ASE power, interacting in a fiber via stimulated Raman scattering with signals and pumps propagating at other wavelengths can be described [18] by Equation 8: j1 X dPj ¼ ½CR ðni ; nj Þ,Pi Pj þ 2,hnj ,dn,CR ðni ; nj Þ,Pi dz i¼1 Z nj N X nj ,CR ðnj ; ni Þ,Pi Pj 2,hvj ,Pj CR ðnj ; nj nÞ,dn ni n¼0 i ¼ jþ1
aðlj ÞPj þ BaR ðlj ÞP j Equation 8 In this equation CR ðni ; nj Þ is the Raman gain coefficient for pumping of frequency nj by frequency ni; the first term in the first sum represents Raman gain imparted to
4.2 An overview of EDFAs, DRAs and hybrid Raman/DRA
wavelength lj by shorter wavelengths, i.e., higher frequencies, and the second term in the first sum represents spontaneous emission at lj in a resolution bandwidth of the calculation dn captured by the fiber core in the direction of signal propagation; the second sum represents depletion lj due to Raman pumping by lj of wavelengths longer than lj; the integral term represents depletion of lj by pumping of spontaneous emission at longer wavelengths; and the last two terms, represent, respectively, depletion by attenuation and the addition of captured Rayleigh backsckattering of the signal at lj propagating in the opposite direction. It can be seen that a signal will interact not only with the pump wavelengths but also with other signal wavelengths, although if the pump wavelength is chosen at the peak of the gain spectrum, the interaction with the pump wavelength will generally be considerably stronger because of the wider wavelength separation. A more accurate treatment [19] includes the temperature dependence, which can be significant especially when the difference between signal and pump frequencies are not large, and anti-Stokes ASE related effects. The peak Raman gain coefficient for common transmission fibers ranges from about 0.35 m1$W1 for some standard single mode fiber to about 0.7 m1$W1 for TrueWave non-dispersion shifted fiber (NZDSF) [20]. Because of these small values, Raman amplification requires large pump powers, typically hundreds of mW, to produce significant amplification and the deployment of DRAs had to await the development of pump lasers with adequate power. Unlike Raman amplification, the Raman gain in dB is proportional to the pump power in linear units (as long as pump depletion due to signal amplification and interaction among pumps can be neglected). Because in the counterpropagating configuration amplification occurs predominantly near the output end of the span near the Raman pump source where the signal power is low, there is normally little gain saturation. The counter-propagating configuration is preferred because it minimizes the polarization dependent gain resulting from the highly polarization dependent Raman gain coefficient [21] and the effect of relative intensity noise (RIN) transfer from the pump to the signal [22]. When multiple pump wavelengths are used, the gain spectra for the signal band are the accumulation of the gain spectra produced by the individual pumps at different signals and significant exchange of power among the high power pump wavelengths is possible. The effects can be modeled using Equation 8. In additional to its spectral flexibility, distributed Raman amplification also has superior noise performance. Because the amplification occurs over an appreciable fiber length, at the point in the fiber span where the signal first encounters net gain, the effective input of the amplifier, its power has suffered much less reduction by attenuation than would be the case for a transmission span with a discrete amplifier (such as an EDFA) located at the end of the span. Because the signal power at the effective input of the amplifier is higher the noise performance is correspondingly better. The location of the input of the distributed Raman amplifier is not well defined and in fact varies depending on the power of the Raman pump. As a result the noise performance of a DRA is normally characterized in terms of an effective noise figure, which is defined as the noise figure of
91
92
CHAPTER 4 EDFAs, Raman amplifiers and hybrid Raman/EDFAs
the hypothetical (nonphysical) discrete amplifier which if placed at the output of the span would provide the same gain and PASE as the distributed Raman amplifier [23]. This can be calculated in terms of the noise figure of the distributed Raman span (rather than the amplified span referenced to the signal input of the span NFDRA amplifier input as is usual) using Equation 9. span ðdBÞ Lspan ðdBÞ NFeff ðdBÞ ¼ NFDRA
Equation 9
Here, Lspan is the loss experienced by signal when the fiber is not pumped by Raman pump. That means that this loss accounts for effects such as channel-to-channel Raman interaction even in the absence of Raman pump. This is because when the Raman amplifier is substituted by an equivalent discrete amplifier at the output of the span for the effective noise figure calculation, the channels inside the span would continue to interact with each other via Raman effect, thereby modifying the input to that discrete amplifier accordingly. A distributed Raman on-off gain (the ratio of the signal power at the end of the span with the Raman pump on and with the no pump power) of 10 to 15 dB can be achieved with practical pump levels which results in an effective noise figure in the range of less than zero dB almost down to 2 dB. This is about 5 to 6 dB better than can be achieved with a discrete EDFA at the end of the span. In fact the effective noise figure for DRA is most often less than the 3 dB quantum limit. This is possible because the effective noise figure is not referenced to the physical input of the DRA. Cost, which scales as pump power and thus as gain, and performance impairments such as double Rayleigh scattering and Rayleigh back scattering of backward ASE place practical limits on the available distributed Raman gain. As a result, DRAs are most often used in conjunction with EDFAs in a hybrid configuration. The DRA serves as a preamplifier providing a portion of the gain required to compensate the span loss and largely determining the noise performance of the hybrid amplifier which is thereby significantly lower than that of a conventional EDFA. The EDFA, which follows the DRA, provides the bulk of the gain necessary to compensate the loss of fiber spans and elements such as dispersion compensating modules and ROADMs. Such hybrid Raman/EDFAs can achieve effective noise figures typically 3 to 6 dB better than can be achieved with an EDFA alone. In the systems widely deployed today based on 10 Gb/s and 40 Gb/s line rates, hybrid Raman/EDFAs are commonly applied in two ways: first, at the output of exceptionally long spans to mitigate the degree to which the long span reduces the OSNR of the system; second, as the basic amplifier for most or all spans in systems where ultra-long reach is required (such as in wavelength routed networks where wavelengths would have long, unregenerated paths). In future systems with higher capacity (100 Gb/s and beyond) per channel, it may be desirable to use Raman amplification at the amplifier sites for all or most spans to meet the more demanding OSNR requirements of systems with such high line rates.
4.3 Gain spectra and DWDM applications
4.3 GAIN SPECTRA AND DWDM APPLICATIONS 4.3.1 DWDM amplifiers and average inversion The most widespread applications of EDFAs are in DWDM systems in which channels at closely spaced wavelengths (typically about 40 channels at 100 GHz channel spacing for metro/regional systems or about 80 channels at 50 GHz channel spacing for long-haul systems) are amplified at the end of each span. The spectra of the gain coefficient, g(l), the gain per unit length, in units of dB/m, is given in Figure 4.3 for a typical erbium-doped fiber with aluminum co-doping in the core. The gain spectrum of the EDF in an EDFA can be determined by multiplying the gain coefficient corresponding to length averaged inversion of the erbium-doped fiber by the length of the erbium doped fiber. It can be seen that if the inversion is reasonably high, there will be significant gain in the so-called C-band between about 1525 nm and 1565 nm. From Figure 4.3 it can also be seen that over the C-band the gain as a function of wavelength will be quite non-flat. At high inversion there will be a sharp peak near 1530 nm and at lower inversion there is a broader peak at a wavelength greater than 1550 nm. To obtain the required uniformity of signal power and OSNR over the populated channels at the end of a link it is necessary to use a gain flattening filter (GFF), the filter profile of which is complementary to the EDF gain profile to obtain sufficiently flat gain over the spectral range of the channel plan. The addition of a GFF necessitates a more complex amplifier design to minimize penalties to the noise figure and output power resulting from the optical insertion loss of the GFF.
4
Gain Coefficient g (dB/m)
3
Emission spectrum g*(λ ), i.e. inv=100%
Inversion N2 100% 95% 90% 85% 80% 75% 70% 65% 60% 55% 50% 45% 40% 35% 30% 25% 20% 15% 10% 5% 0%
2 1 0 -1 -2 -3 -4 1460
-Absorption spectrum -α (λ ), i.e. inv=0% 1480
1500
1520
1540
1560
1580
1600
Wavelength (nm)
FIGURE 4.3 EDF gain coefficient spectra for different values of the of the EDF inversion N2.
93
94
CHAPTER 4 EDFAs, Raman amplifiers and hybrid Raman/EDFAs
An EDFA architecture incorporating many of the features commonly found in amplifiers designed for application in DWDM systems is shown in Figure 4.4. There are two amplifying stages, the first stage playing the greatest role in determining the two-stage EDFA’s noise figure and the second stage playing the largest role in determining its output power, the two amplifier parameters that play the greatest role in determining the OSNR at the end of the link. Each stage has an EDF pumped by a 980 nm pump diode to create the inversion necessary for gain. The 980 nm pump light is coupled into the EDF by a pump/signal wavelength division multiplexer (WDM) to co-propagate with the signal. Each stage also has optical isolators to suppress reflections and monitor photodiodes for monitoring input and output powers to measure and control the optical gain. The first stage has an optical supervisor channel (OSC) filter to drop the OSC, a lower data rate signal typically at 1510 nm, used by the network management system to control the amplifier and monitor its status. The second stage has an OSC add filter to add the outgoing OSC signal at the output port. The GFF is placed between the two amplifying stages so that its optical insertion loss increases the noise figure by much less than if it were placed at the amplifier input and decreases the amplifier output power by much less than if it were placed at the EDFA’s output. In addition to the GFF, a variable optical attenuator (VOA) and, for systems employing channel bit rates of 10 Gb/s or greater, a dispersion compensating module (DCM), usually based on dispersion compensating fiber (DCF), are
1st Stage (Pre-Amp) Pin
DWDM Input
OSC PD WDM
PD
OI
PS OSC Drop
Pout
EDF Pump OI WDM
Mid-Stage GFF, VOA & DCF Pin GFF VOA
G1
PD
Pout
EDF Pump OI WDM
OSC OI WDM
PS
PS
980 pump
2nd Stage (Hi Power)
Mid-Stage Access
DWDM Output
PS
980 pump
LMA
PD
OSC Add
G2 DCM
FIGURE 4.4 Representative architecture of mid-stage access EDFA. G1 is the gain of the first stage. LMA is the loss of the mid-stage including that of the DCM and G2 is the gain of the second stage. DCM: dispersion compensating module. EDF: erbium-doped fiber. GFF: gain flattening filter. OI: optical isolator. OSC: optical supervisory channel. PD: photodiode used to measure input or output power. PS: power splitter. WDM: wavelength division multiplexer. VOA: variable optical isolator. OSC WDM multiplexes or demultiplexes the signal channel band and the OSC wavelength. Pump WDM multiplexes signal band and pump wavelength.
4.3 Gain spectra and DWDM applications
sometimes placed in the mid-stage. As shown in Figure 4.3, the gain spectrum will depend on the average level of inversion of the EDF along its length. As the average inversion is reduced the gain level at short wavelengths decreases more rapidly than the gain at long wavelengths, changing the tilt of the gain spectrum. Because the GFF has a long spectral profile it can flatten the gain at only one value of average inversion. The EDFAs are commonly operated in constant gain mode which enables the EDF to be held at a constant average inversion. The EDF thus retains the design gain spectrum, even as the channel loading varies over the life of the system. The VOA is used to enable the EDF to operate at its design average inversion at which its gain spectrum is flattened by the GFF for a range of gains of the full two-stage EDFA to support a range of transmission fiber span losses. [24,25] This range of gains over which the VOA may be used to adjust the gain while keeping it flat and meeting the EDFA’s other specifications, such as noise figure, is referred to as the gain dynamic range. The VOA may also be used to compensate power tilt induced by transmission effects (for example the attenuation spectrum of transmission fiber and/or stimulated Raman scattering interaction among signal channels during propagation in the transmission fiber [26]. The DCM is used to compensate the chromatic dispersion of the fiber span which is necessary for directly modulated signals at data rates of 10 Gb/s or greater. As with the GFF, placing these optical elements between the two stages minimizes the impact of their insertion loss on the link noise performance. For the performance of DWDM systems it is important that the variations in channel power and channel OSNR at the receivers are not large; this requires a relatively flat gain spectrum for the amplifiers. The gain ripple, which is the difference between the maximum and minimum gain, is a key figure of merit specified in the design of optical amplifiers for DWDM applications and is typically 1 to 1.5 dB. The DCF can have losses up to and exceeding 10 dB which places limitations on the noise performance and gain dynamic range of the EDFA. Providing gain to compensate for the insertion loss of the DCF also requires increased pump power which increases cost. While the DCF is necessary in most current systems, coherent systems which are being introduced for 40 Gb/s channels and are anticipated for 100 Gb/s, can compensate for large amounts of chromatic dispersion electronically and will not require in-line dispersion of chromatic dispersion. The opportunity to eliminate the insertion loss of the DCF offers the opportunity to simplify the design of the EDFA, reduce its cost, and improve the noise performance over a wider range of operating gains. In most applications the DWDM channels have wavelengths in the so-called C-band with slight variations in the lowest and highest wavelengths in the channel plan depending on the application and on each system integrator’s system design. From Figure 4.3 it can be seen that it is also possible to obtain amplification at wavelengths greater than about 1570 nm to beyond 1,600 nm (designated the L-band) by operating at a much lower inversion such that there is net loss in the Cband but, because the absorption coefficient a(l) at these wavelengths is so low, there is net gain [27,28]. The gain coefficient in the L-band is relatively low,
95
96
CHAPTER 4 EDFAs, Raman amplifiers and hybrid Raman/EDFAs
requiring the use of longer lengths of EDF and/or the use of EDFs with higher Er concentration to achieve comparable net optical gain. The gain spectra of distributed Raman amplifiers can be tailored and flattened for a desired signal band by suitable choice of the wavelengths and powers of the pump lasers The aggregate gain spectrum will be the sum of the individual gain spectra induced by the individual pumps as can be seen from Equation 8, which for any signal wavelength will depend just on the differences between the frequencies of the individual pumps and the signal frequency.
4.3.2 Spectral hole burning The model of gain in EDFAs represented by equation 2 is based on homogeneous saturation as can be seen by the fact that the spectral dependence enters only through the spectral dependences of g*(l) and a(l)and the single parameter N2 which mediates the relative strengths of their contributions through the degree of inversion. If the saturation were indeed purely homogeneous, then when the amplifier gain is compressed (the gain is reduced from its small signal value due to gain saturation induced by signal power), the gain spectrum would not depend on the wavelength of the saturating signal but only on the resulting level of inversion. This homogeneous model would hold if every Er ion had identical level structure and the g*(l) and a(l) spectra were identical for every ion. Although the homogeneous model is actually a fairly good approximation, it is only an approximation. Because the Er ions are embedded in a glass matrix the sites where different Er ions are located are not identical. Different sites are subject to different electric fields and interactions with the surrounding atoms, resulting in modest differences in the response of different Er ions to saturating signals at different wavelengths and polarizations. The saturation is not completely homogeneous and the saturated spectrum does have some dependence on the wavelength of the saturating signal as illustrated in Figure 4.5 [29]. Two gain spectra are shown, one for a saturating signal at 1531 nm and the other for a saturating signal at 1553 nm. The two gain spectra are indistinguishable except in the vicinity of the saturating signals. Near 1531 nm the gain spectrum saturated by a signal at that wavelength is compressed by up to about 1.2 dB more than that saturated by the signal at 1553 nm, and near 1553 nm the gain spectrum saturated by a signal at that wavelength is up to 0.25 dB more compressed. The inset shows the difference between the two spectra. This difference spectrum is indistinguishable from zero, within experimental uncertainty, except for the vicinities of the two saturating wavelengths. The features that appear at the two saturating wavelengths are called spectral holes and the phenomenon is termed spectral hole burning (SHB). As the gain compression for these gain spectra was about 12 dB at 1553 nm and significantly more at 1531 nm, the spectral holes are relatively small (and in fact were thought to be negligible at room temperature until sensitive difference spectrum techniques were used to detect them). But spectral holes are large enough, especially
4.3 Gain spectra and DWDM applications
λsat for Blue Curve Difference of gain spectra
10
λsat for Red Curve
Hole Depth (0.5 dB/div)
GAIN (dB)
15
Holes at λsat 1540
1560
WAVELENGTH (nm)
5 1540
1560 WAVELENGTH (nm)
FIGURE 4.5 Detection of SHB using difference spectra. The traces for two gain spectra with similar levels of gain compression are shown. For one trace the gain compression is induced by a saturating signal at 1531 nm and the other the saturating signal was at a wavelength of 1553 nm. The inset shows the spectrum with 1553 nm wavelength saturating signal subtracted from that with 1530 nm wavelength saturating signal and clearly shows the spectral holes burned at the saturating wavelengths [29].
in the blue part of the spectrum, to be of concern in the operation of wavelength routed networks with wavelength paths traversing many amplifiers. More complex SHB spectra have also been reported, including features such as collateral holes centered at wavelengths which do not coincide with that of the saturating signal [30,31]. In DWDM systems it is common that only a small number of channels are populated when a link is first installed and turned up. With time, as the traffic on the route increases, more channels are turned up until eventually the full channel plan is populated. In reconfigurable, wavelength routed networks the set of channels populated on any given link can change as traffic patterns change and as traffic demand grows. Because the set of populated channels will change over the life of a link, the gain flatness should be maintained not only when the full channel plan is populated but also for population by any subset of the full channel plan; SHB introduces a dependence of the gain flatness on which channels are populated. Thus it is important to understand SHB in order to design EDFAs that have the required gain flatness for any possible combination of populated channels. The mechanism of SHB is discussed by Siegman [32] and can be understood with reference to Figure 4.6 which shows the difference between homogeneous and inhomogenous saturation for an ideal two-level laser system. Figure 4.6a
97
98
CHAPTER 4 EDFAs, Raman amplifiers and hybrid Raman/EDFAs
(a) Γhom >> Γinhom
Unsaturated
Γhom
Saturating signal Saturated
Γhom
A Single Transition energy
(b) Saturating signal
Γinhom >> Γhom
Unsaturated 2Γhom
Saturated
Γinhom Multiple Transition Energies
FIGURE 4.6 Schematic illustration of the mechanism of saturation of homogeneously and inhomogeneously broadened transitions. (a) Unsaturated (dashed curve) and saturated (solid curve) gain spectra of homogeneously broadened transition, with energy in arbitrary units on the horizontal scale and transition gain or gain coefficient on the vertical axis. All atoms have the same transition energy with a Lorentzian line shape centered at the transition energy and a linewidth of Ghom. The transition saturation is uniform across the lineshape, independent of the energy of the saturating signal. (b) Unsaturated (dashed curve) and saturated (solid curve) gain spectra of inhomogeneously broadened transition, with energy in arbitrary units on the horizontal scale and transition gain or gain coefficient on the vertical axis. Atoms at different site types and orientations have different transition energies with natural linewidth Ghom . The distribution of transition energies is assumed to be Gaussian and much wider than Ghom imparting to the transition an overall Gaussian line shape with width Ginhom >>Ghom. The saturating signal burns a hole in the gain spectrum the width of which is twice the homogeneous linewidth Ghom and which is centered at the saturating signal’s energy.
illustrates homogenous saturation. Saturation is homogeneous when all of the ions have identical gain spectra, are Lorentzian in shape, and have a width corresponding to the natural linewidth of the atomic transition. A saturating signal at any wavelength within the gain spectrum (for illustration a saturating signal at the center of the gain spectrum is shown) will result in the same gain
4.3 Gain spectra and DWDM applications
spectrum if the degree of inversion is the same. By contrast, Figure 4.6b illustrates the mechanism for inhomogeneous saturation. In this case the transition energies for atoms located at different types of sites in the glass matrix, which experience different electric fields from neighboring atoms of the silica matrix, are slightly shifted. The aggregate gain spectrum is the accumulation of these individual atomic gain spectra. A saturating signal interacts preferentially with atoms that have transition energy at the photon energy corresponding to the saturating signal’s frequency and less strongly with atoms the transition energy of which is separated from the saturating signal photon energy by more than the transition linewidth. As a result saturation usually, but not always, occurs preferentially in that portion of the gain spectrum in close proximity to the saturating signal’s wavelength, resulting in a spectral hole. The modeling of SHB in EDFAs has proven challenging because the Er3þ ion 4 I15/2 ground state and 4I13/2 first excited state have high angular momentum resulting in a large number of sublevels of each electronic energy level. These sublevels are separated by small energy shifts due to Stark splitting arising from electric fields the erbium ions experience in the glass matrix. As a result of this Stark splitting, SHB in EDFAs is considerably more complicated, and difficult to model, than the simple two-level system depicted in Figure 4.6. The details of the strengths and energies of transitions between the various sublevels of the two electronic states, which would be needed for an explicit model of the SHB in EDFAs are not well known and are difficult to determine. Desurvire [9] attempted to extract the transition energies and strengths as well as the homogeneous and inhomogeneous linewidths from low temperature spectroscopic measurements but even with these powerful experimental tools, because of the complexity of the level structure and transition characteristics (such as dependence of the erbium ion absorption spectrum on the direction of the local electrical field in relation to the optical polarization), it was not possible to extract a model with useful predictive power. Instead, a semi-empirical approach to modeling SHB in EDFAs based on the Giles Model of Equations 1 and 2 has been quite successful. [33] In this model it is recognized that the usual absorption and emission coefficients, a(l) and g*(l), respectively, represent averages of the actual atomic absorption and emission coefficients over the erbium ions in all the various sites in the glass matrix: aðlÞ ¼ ai ðlÞ Equation 10 g ðlÞ ¼ gi ðlÞ where indices i indicate the values for the ith ion and the angle brackets denote averaging over all the atoms i. The average absorption and emission coefficients can be determined without knowledge of the atomic energy level schemes or the strengths of the transitions among the different sublevels purely from optical
99
100
CHAPTER 4 EDFAs, Raman amplifiers and hybrid Raman/EDFAs
measurements of fibers. The values for the ith atom can be written in terms of a deviation function xi(l): ai ðlÞ ¼ aðlÞ,ð1 þ xi ðlÞÞ gi ðlÞ ¼ gðlÞ,ð1 þ xi ðlÞÞ
Equation 11
where the deviation function is the same for the emission and absorption coefficients and has the properties hxi ðlÞi ¼ 0 xi ðlÞ << 1
Equation 12
Gðl1 ; l2 Þ ¼ hxi ðl1 Þ,xi ðl2 Þi
Equation 13
A correlation function
is introduced which can be determined experimentally and which carries enough information about the deviation function to calculate the effect of SHB. The correlation function can be used to calculate effective absorption and emission coefficients that include the effects by virtue of their dependence on the correlation function: P
2 ~ ðlÞ ¼ aðlÞ41 þ a
i;j
2 g~ ðlÞ ¼ g ðlÞ41
3 aðli ÞPi ,g ðlj ÞGðlj ; lÞPj ðg ðli ÞPi þ z,hc=lÞaðlj ÞGðlj ; lÞPj 7 P 5 ðg ðli ÞPi þ z,hc=lÞðaðlj ÞPj þ ðg ðlj ÞPj þ z,hc=lÞÞ
P i;j
i;j
3 aðli ÞPi ,g ðlj ÞGðlj ; lÞPj ðg ðli ÞPi þ z,hc=lÞaðlj ÞGðlj ; lÞPj 7 P 5 aðli ÞPi ðaðlj ÞPj þ ðg ðlj ÞPj þ z,hc=lÞÞ i;j
Equation 14
The local gain coefficient in dB/m, including the effects of SHB, takes a similar form as the local gain coefficient in the homogeneous Giles model of equations 1 and 2, only with the effective absorption and emission coefficients in place of the average absorption and emission coefficients, respectively: ~ ðl; zÞ,ð1 N2 ðzÞÞ Gðl; zÞ ¼ g~ ðl; zÞ,N2 ðzÞ a
Equation 15
The overall gain can be obtained by integrating G(l,z) over the length of the erbiumdoped fiber, z. The effect of inhomogeneity, which gives rise to SHB, is contained in the effective absorption and emission coefficients given in Equation 14 through their dependence on the correlation function G(l1,l2). It is important to note that determination of the correlation function does not require knowledge of the energy level shifts of the different types of ions present in the glass matrix. Rather, following the same paradigm as the Giles average inversion model [10,11], the correlation coefficient can be determined by optical measurements readily carried out on erbium-doped fibers using techniques and equipment similar to those used for characterization of erbium-doped fiber parameters for the standard homogeneous Giles/average inversion model.
4.3 Gain spectra and DWDM applications
An accurate method of determining the correlation coefficient based on practical fiber measurement is to saturate the gain with a signal at one wavelength (l1) and measure the gain as a function wavelength (values of l2) and determine the correlation G(l1,l2) by comparing the measured gain spectrum with that calculated using Equations 14 and 15 and adjusting G(l1,l2) to achieve the best fit. To get the correlation function over the full (l1,l2) space, this is repeated for different saturating wavelengths spanning the relevant the full gain spectrum. In Bolshtyanskly’s paper [33] the correlation coefficient was determined from gain measurements on a 2.5 nm by 1 nm grid of saturating wavelengths (l1) and probe wavelengths (l2), respectively, with a 0.3 mW input power at 1565 nm, a third wavelength, to set the basic compression level. The input power at each value of the saturating wavelength, l1, was adjusted of the saturating signal to keep the amplifier compression constant. The copropagating 1480 nm pump power was held constant at 150 mW. The resulting correlation function is shown in Figure 4.7. Note that it is symmetric, as would be expected from Equation 13. It is important to use 1480 nm pumping for such experiments, because 980 nm pumping would introduce additional effects modifying the gain spectrum in the C-band due to the site dependent pumping effect (see below). The power of this technique is demonstrated by its ability to predict the SHB for conditions different from those used to determine the correlation function. Figure 4.8a shows the difference between the gain spectra measured when the saturated signal (l1) has a wavelength of 1535 nm and 1545 nm and a reference gain spectrum with the saturating signal at 1565 nm The signal input power is 0.05 mW and the pump power is 50 mW which results in a gain compression which is about 3 dB less than the conditions used to determine the correlation function. Figure 4.8b 1565 1560 1555 1550 1545 1540 1535 1530 1525 1525 1530 1535 1540 1545 1550 1555 1560 1565
FIGURE 4.7 Measured correlation function G(li , lj) determined as described in the text [33].
101
CHAPTER 4 EDFAs, Raman amplifiers and hybrid Raman/EDFAs
(a)
1
Experimentally observed SHB SHB (dB)
0.5
0 1525
1535
1545
1555
1565
1575
-0.5
-1
(b)
1
Simulated SHB 0.5
SHB (dB)
102
0 1525
1535
1545
1555
1565
-0.5
-1
FIGURE 4.8 (a) Experimentally observed SHB for saturating signals at 1535 nm (thin dark curve) and 1545 nm (light, thick curve). In each case the spectrum shown is the difference between the spectrum with the respective saturating wavelength and a reference spectrum with a saturating wavelength at 1565 nm at the same average gain compression as in Figure 4.5. (b) Simulated SHB using the model described in the text and the correlation function G(li , lj) shown in Figure 7 [33].
shows simulations using the extracted correlation function of Figure 4.7 of the same conditions. Note that despite the significant difference between the operating point used to determine the correlation function and the operating point for the measurements of Figure 4.8a, the simulations of Figure 4.8b show good agreement with the measurements including faithful reproduction of the secondary peak at about 1533 nm when the saturating signal has a wavelength of 1545 nm. Figure 4.9 shows the measured and simulated dependences of SHB depth on gain compression when the saturated signals have wavelengths at 1530 nm (near the small signal gain peak of erbium-doped fiber) and 1545 nm. The ability of the simulations to faithfully
4.3 Gain spectra and DWDM applications
predict the nonlinear and dissimilar dependences on gain compression of SHB depth for saturating signals at both wavelengths demonstrates the predictive power and broad applicability of the this semi-empirical method of simulating SHB. The parameters of this model can be extracted from optical measurements readily made on erbium-doped fibers using tools and instruments commonly used to determine the fiber parameters for the widely used Giles model without requiring knowledge of unknown spectroscopic properties of the erbium ions in the glass matrix of the fiber core. The model provides good predictive power useful in designing erbium-doped fiber amplifiers. Such models are now used by leading suppliers of erbium-doped fiber amplifiers and allow the spectral properties, particularly the gain spectrum, to be predicted for essentially any channel-loading scenario that might arise in a system application. SHB is the chief contributor to dependence of the gain shape on which channels are populated in gain controlled EDFAs. Bolshtyansky and Cowle [34] have recently studied a large number of scenarios using the model described above and found that for most channel population scenarios the deviations in channel gain arising from SHB are small but that significant effects can arise in certain cases, usually when a small number of channels are populated and most of them are near 1530 nm and one or two of them are located in a different region of the EDFA gain spectrum. They have also demonstrated that in hybrid Raman/EDFAs the Raman pump configuration can be designed so that by adjusting the Raman pump wavelengths it should be possible to compensate and significantly mitigate the effects of SHB [35].
1.2
Signal λ = 1530nm
SHB depth (dB)
1
0.8
0.6
Signal λ = 1545nm 0.4
Simulation Experiment
0.2
0 0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
Compression (dB)
FIGURE 4.9 SHB depth as a function of gain compression for saturating signals at 1530 nm and 1545 nm. The simulation results are calculated using the correlation function G(li , lj) shown in Figure 4.7 [33].
103
104
CHAPTER 4 EDFAs, Raman amplifiers and hybrid Raman/EDFAs
Alternatively, the channel power adjustment capability of ROADMs can be used to rebalance channel powers to mitigate the effects of SHB. In transoceanic systems traversing very