Polymer Science and Technology Series
OLIGOMERIC STATE OF SUBSTANCES
No part of this digital document may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means. The publisher has taken reasonable care in the preparation of this digital document, but makes no expressed or implied warranty of any kind and assumes no responsibility for any errors or omissions. No liability is assumed for incidental or consequential damages in connection with or arising out of information contained herein. This digital document is sold with the clear understanding that the publisher is not engaged in rendering legal, medical or any other professional services.
POLYMER SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY SERIES Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons: Pollution, Health Effects and Chemistry Pierre A. Haines and Milton D. Hendrickson 2009 ISBN: 978-1-60741-462-9 Advances in Polymer Latex Technology Vikas Mittal 2009 ISBN: 978-1-60741-170-3 Oligomeric State of Substances S. M. Mezhikovskii, A. E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev 2009. ISBN: 978-1-60741-344-8
Polymer Science and Technology Series
OLIGOMERIC STATE OF SUBSTANCES
S.M. MEZHIKOVSKII, A.E. ARINSTEIN AND
R. YA. DEBERDEEV
Nova Science Publishers, Inc. New York
Copyright © 2009 by Nova Science Publishers, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means: electronic, electrostatic, magnetic, tape, mechanical photocopying, recording or otherwise without the written permission of the Publisher. For permission to use material from this book please contact us: Telephone 631-231-7269; Fax 631-231-8175 Web Site: http://www.novapublishers.com NOTICE TO THE READER The Publisher has taken reasonable care in the preparation of this book, but makes no expressed or implied warranty of any kind and assumes no responsibility for any errors or omissions. No liability is assumed for incidental or consequential damages in connection with or arising out of information contained in this book. The Publisher shall not be liable for any special, consequential, or exemplary damages resulting, in whole or in part, from the readers’ use of, or reliance upon, this material. Any parts of this book based on government reports are so indicated and copyright is claimed for those parts to the extent applicable to compilations of such works. Independent verification should be sought for any data, advice or recommendations contained in this book. In addition, no responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property arising from any methods, products, instructions, ideas or otherwise contained in this publication. This publication is designed to provide accurate and authoritative information with regard to the subject matter covered herein. It is sold with the clear understanding that the Publisher is not engaged in rendering legal or any other professional services. If legal or any other expert assistance is required, the services of a competent person should be sought. FROM A DECLARATION OF PARTICIPANTS JOINTLY ADOPTED BY A COMMITTEE OF THE AMERICAN BAR ASSOCIATION AND A COMMITTEE OF PUBLISHERS. LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOGING-IN-PUBLICATION DATA Mezhikovskii, S. M. Oligomeric state of substances / S.M. Mezhikovskii , A.E. Arinstein , R. Ya. Deberdeev. p. cm. Includes index. ISBN 978-1-61728-554-7 (E-Book) 1. Oligomers--Structure. I. Arinstein, Arkadii E. II. Deberdeev, R. Ya. III. Title. QD382.O43M494 2009 547'.7--dc22 2009006388
Published by Nova Science Publishers, Inc. New York
CONTENTS Preface of Editor
ix
Preface
xi
Preface by Authors Introduction
xiii xv
Part 1
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
1
Part 2
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
49
Part 3
Heterogeneous Oligomer Systems
183
Conclusion
249
References
253
Index
255
OLIGOMERIC STATE OF SUBSTANCES The book gives an original interpretation of modern ideas about oligomers as substances which, due to their molecular structure, demonstrate specific statistical behavior different form that of monomers or polymers. The criteria provided in this book allow us to distinguish monomers, oligomers and polymers in homologous series. The book presents theoretical aspects of small-scale structure of oligomers, and supramolecular structure formation models for liquid oligomeric systems. Theoretical and experimental results of the studies on phase transitions and anomalies of physical and chemical properties which oligomer systems have are considered. The book is aimed at scientists of academic profile working in the filed of physics and chemistry of oligomers and polymers, at researchers and specialists engaged in the development and production of materials based on oligomeric and polymeric systems. The book will be useful for professors, postgraduates and students of chemical and biological departments of universities and academies.
PREFACE OF EDITOR “The Science should be Cheerful, Fascinating and Simple as well as Scientists” Prof. Piotr L. Kapitsa The Winner Noble Price, Institute of Physical Problems, Academy of Sciences of USSR, Moscow
Oligomers (synthesis, properties and applications) are very important part of polymer material science as well as chemical industry. For some reasons oligomers are even more broad then material science. If monomers are bricks of polymers and composites the oligomers are blocks of polymers and composites as well as very important class of organic compounds for different applications (synthesis, medicine, agriculture, additives for polymers etc.). The contributors of this book are pupils of Prof. Alfred Anisimovich Berlin (1912-1978) who was pioneer, leader and organizer of oligomer science and industry in Soviet Union. The co-authors of this manuscript are working in the field of oligomers already 40-50 years. So, they accumulated tremendous amount of information and knowledge in the field of oligomers (ideas, theories, applications). All of them are included in this book. I hope that this manuscript will be very useful for the students, scientists and engineers who are working in the field of oligomers, polymers, composites and nanocomposites as well as in the field of application of chemistry for the medicine and agriculture. The contributors and editor of this book will be very happy to receive from readers some comments which we can take in account in our job in future. Prof. Gennady Efremovich Zaikov Institute of Biochemical Physics Russian Academy of Sciences Moscow, Russian
[email protected]
PREFACE The initial title presenting the subject of this book was “Chemical Physics of Oligomers”, however, we finally preferred the one which you can see on the front page. We have made this change for a variety of reasons. The first reason (the first but not the most important one). The term “state” together with the terms “oligomeric” and “substance” is linguistically substantial. A state is “the condition, internal or external circumstances something or somebody is in” (S.I. Ozhegov, Russian language thesaurus). In this regard, the word combination “Oligomeric State of Substance” seems as justified as the usual term “aggregative state of substance” or other less common expressions as, for example, “plasma state of substance”. The second reason. The title “Oligomeric State of Substance” is within the terminology of leading figures in polymer science (V.A. Kargin, S.Ya. Frenkel et al.), who used the term “polymeric state of substance” very broadly (for more information see Introduction in this book). The third reason. Stating that oligomer is a condensed state of matter and it has specific properties we renounce the traditional attitude to oligomers as only raw materials for polymer industry and want to attract more fundamental attention to oligomeric systems not limited by material science only (you can see more details throughout this book). And the last reason. The pretentious title of this book can cause not only evident disapproval and even irritation of some specialists but also a sense of curiosity among other readers. The curiosity that some readers will feel can transform into their desire to read this book. We hope that these readers will join the exciting research process concerning chemical physics of oligomers. This book summarizes the results of theoretical and experimental research in thermodynamics, kinetics and structure of liquid oligomers. The research is based on ideas mainly developed by Professor Alfred Berlin who was one of the greatest chemists of the second half of the last century. Moreover, some research results included into this publication were obtained in other research centers, particularly by Professor V. Irgac, Professor G. Korolev, Academician Yu. Lipatov, Professor S. Papkov, Academician A. Chohlov, Professor A. Chalykh, Professor S. Entelis, Professor K. Dushek, Professor K. Kveiya, Professor R. Koniksveld, Professor S. Krauze and many others. The book gives an original interpretation of modern ideas about oligomers as substances which, due to their molecular structure, demonstrate specific statistical behavior different from the statistics of monomers and polymers. This is the principal difference between this
xii
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
publication and other books concerning oligomers. This statement also relates to another book written by one of the authors “Physicohimiya Reactionnosposobnih Oligomerov” (Physical Chemistry of Reactive Oligomers, in Russian), published in 1998. The book in your hands uses some experimental results and statements from the latter, but presents them in a broader, completed and more accurate way giving somewhere a fresh look. The authors tried to maximize the contribution of the most important experimental results discussed at the latest international conferences on chemistry and physical chemistry of oligomers. We express many thanks to all the authors whose original research results were systematized in this publication. In particular, we’d like to thank the following individuals, without whose contributions, and discussions this work would not be half as useful: Academician A. Berlin, Professor I. Eruhimovich, Professor V. Irgak, Professor G. Korolev, Professor V. Kuleznev, correspondent member of the Russian Academy of Sciences V. Kulichichin, Professor V. Lancov, Academician Yu. Lipatov, Professor L. Manevich, Professor Yu. Morozov, Professor V. Hozin, Professor А. Chalykh et al. We’d also like to express our thanks to Professor A. Oleinic and Professor V. Shilov who reject some ideas which the authors support. This rejection stimulated new theoretical and experimental research as well as speculation on these ideas. We appreciate this fact greatly. We would like to express our deepest gratitude to the reviewers who have done much to improve this publication: Academician Aleksander Berlin and Professor Valerij Kuleznev. Special thanks to the managing editor, Professor Vadim Irzhak who added a reasonable pragmatism to the style of somewhere too enthusiastic authors. The only case when the position of the editor was not considered convincing and was not shared by the authors was the title of this book. Note, it was impossible to provide a separate letter for every value or variable used in writing and editing this book (even taking all the letters in three alphabets). That’s why various formulas in different sections of this book contain identical symbols describing values different in meaning and nature. The physical interpretation of symbols is provided for every specific calculation to avoid confusion. We tried to make the style of this book easy enough for readers with different levels of preparation and various interests in science. Therefore, you can find some inevitable imperfections. In some cases we could not avoid repetitions and sometimes we lost the main line of strict and sequential style, especially in the second part of this book. This book is aimed at scientists of academic profile working in the field of physics and chemistry of oligomers and polymers. We suppose it will be interesting for researchers and specialists engaged in development and production of materials based on oligomeric and polymeric systems. This book will be useful for professors, postgraduate and graduate students of chemical and biological departments of universities and polytechnic institutes.
PREFACE BY AUTHORS This book was first issued in Russia in 2005 in just 700 copies and became an instant bestseller. There was no further replication of the book due to the state in Russian book publishing system. However, we were aware of fact that this book in Russian is not readily available to the world scientific community in any number of copies. That is why we want to express our gratitude to Professor Gennady E. Zaikov, who inspired us to engage in its translation into English and agreed to be a scientific editor. We are also thankful to Timur R. Deberdeev for his inestimable contribution into formatting of the English version. Authors submit this book for judgment of English-speaking readers understanding that some of its aspects are points of discussion. But they don't consider it as a disadvantage. On the contrary, discussion is a way to find the grains of a veritable knowledge. Another convincing argument for such point of view was a review of the book written by the outstanding Russian academician Yuriy Sergeevich Lipatov, who sent it to the authors shortly before his decease. There he wrote: «Let me congratulate you with your book as the outstanding contribution to the science of polymers. I say “polymers” because its content and importance exceeds area of oligomers. In some way, it is the encyclopedia of the modern chemistry of polymers. I know nothing equal to it during last decades. The book contains lots of new interesting ideas and original approaches, and I have greatly enjoyed reading it. It doesn’t mean that I accept everything written there, but it is irrelevant in this case. It is a point of discussion. You have clearly delivered me your view of oligomers as the specific class of substances and this point of view is uncontestable. The book is integral, everything is presented logically and in a proper sequence. I wish the number of copies were not so scanty because this publication must be acquired by any library, research institute and university dealing with chemistry». Authors hope that the imperfection of translation will not prevent scientists and professionals in polymer science and technology from taking an interest in this publication. S.M. Mezhikovskii N.N. Semenov Institute of Chemical Physic Russian Academy of Science, Moscow, Russia A.E. Arinstein Technion-Israel Institute of Technology, Israel R. Ya. Deberdeev Kazan State Technological University, Russia
INTRODUCTION “Can we speak of a polymeric state of substance?”, – this question is used as the title for a problem-oriented and prognostic publication by S. Frenkel [1]. The author’s opinion is rather categorical. Yes, we can, but only if the term “state of substance” describes a form of molecular condensation. The process of polymeric structure formation (defined as polymerization, polycondensation, addition or ring-opening polymerization) is a chemical reaction involving dispersion and application of electrostatic forces to small molecules in order to form covalent bonds, where Van der Waals distances are reduced to covalent bond lengths in macromolecules. This process is called condensation (lat. ‘condensatio’ – concentration, accumulation, compaction, compression [2]). This compaction (“chemical” monomer → polymer transition) results in the formation of a new condensed state of substance with absolutely new fundamental properties. These new polymeric properties (such as elasticity) can not be described using the classical theory of aggregative state transitions. Thus, Oligomeric State of Substance is a specific form of condensed matter, different from polymer. It emerges spontaneously from a group of molecules, each being characterized by a specific length and rigidity. The nature of this specific form of condensed state is not only based on chemical transformations of molecules but is also related to the structure of a single oligomer molecule. Conformational properties and/or the existence of electrostatic centers in these molecules result in the formation of dense aggregates with various lifetimes and anisotropies in spatial arrangement. The nature of oligomer molecules defines their natural tendency to self-organization, which can be described neither by aggregative nor by phase transition theory. Oligomer systems with specific properties are very important in many biological and technical applications. For example, some cell enzymes, peptide antibiotics, genes, hormones and many other bioactive substances are oligomers [3]. The expert estimations showed that by the beginning of the ХХI century over 60% of polymer products in the world market were either based on reactive oligomers or used them as principal components. The fundamental characteristic of oligomers as a specific condensed state of substance is supported in various cosmological theories [4, 5] where they are considered a constituent stage of chemical molecule evolution which leads to the formation of living matter. Thus, the core subject of this book is the theoretical and experimental verifications of the statements concerning specific properties of oligomers as a condensed state of substance.
xvi
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
REFERENCES [1] [2] [3]
[4] [5]
Frenkel S.Ya., Fisika segodnya i zavtra. Prognozi nauki. (Physics today and tomorrow. Scientific predictions), Leningrad: Nauka, 1973, p. 176 (In Russian). Slovar’ inostrannih slov (Foreign words dictionary), edited by Lehin, I.V. and Petrov, F.N., Moscow: GIINS, 1954, p .348 (In Russian). Artuhov, V.G., et. al. Oligomernie belki: strukturno-funkcional’nie modifikacii i pol’ cub’edinichnih contactov (Oligomeric proteins: structure functional modifications and the function of subunit contacts), Voronezh: VSU, 1997. Goldanskii, V.G., et. al. Fizicheskaya himiya: Sovrem. problemi (Physical chemistry: present day problems), Moscow: Himiya, 1988, p. 198 (In Russian). Foks, R, Energiya i evolucia gizni na zemle (Energy and evolution of life on Earth), Moscow: Mir, 1992 (In Russian).
Part 1
OLIGOMERS AS THE OBJECT OF RESEARCH: BASIC PRINCIPLES ABSTRACT The discussion deals with the following issues: oligomers as the object of scientific research, classification principles of oligomer systems, their liquid state structure and thermodynamic aspects.
1.1. TERMINOLOGY, CONCEPTS AND DEFINITIONS 1.1.1. Briefly on The Subject The term “oligomer” (ολιγοζ meaning several or few, and μεροζ meaning part or repetition) was introduced into scientific terminology gradually. According to [1] particle “oligo-” was originally used in publications by I. Gelferich et al. in 1930 [2] to denote carbohydrates, containing 3 to 6 monose residues, oligosaccharides. Later on (1932 - 1938), the meaning of this term expanded to compounds with molecules comprising small numbers of monomers. For example, the term “oligonucleotide” was applied to compounds containing 8 to 10 nucleotide residues, and “oligopeptide” was applied to peptides containing about 10 amino acid residues [3]. In the course of time the meaning of the term “oligomer” expanded considerably and it was probably G. Danelio (1942) [4, 5] who used this term to describe any chemical substances in the intermediate position between monomers (low molecular weight compounds) and polymers (high molecular weight compounds). When considering the evolution of the term “oligomer” (and, to say, is still undergoing) [1, 6 - 11], it is necessary to note that the use of the other terms (sometimes earlier and sometimes later) for the description of these compounds can be seen in scientific literature. Some of these old-style terms (synthetic resins [12]) or special terms describing individual structural features of oligomers (macromers, low molecular weight polymers, pleinomers, telechelates, forpolymers, etc. [13–16]) are still used today. Each term is probably used within a sufficient logical or physical framework thus having the right to exist. But the usage of the aforementioned and similar terms is hardly reasonable at the present stage of scientific
2
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
development. It results not only in terminological confusion but also in the omission of the core aspect: a huge group of chemical compounds called oligomers is deprived of the strictly defined physical meaning as a condensed state of substance with special properties. These special properties are primarily the fact that oligomers are much more inclined to form more or less anisotropic aggregates than polymers with similar chemical structures. It is these anisotropic aggregates that allow us to declare macroscopic oligomer properties to be unique [11, 13, 15–20].
1.1.2. Meaning of Term “Oligomer” There is a certain discrepancy in terminology and between certain definitions of the term “oligomer”. It has both objective and subjective reasons. Oligomers have long been considered undesirable by-products in the synthesis of high molecular weight compounds; therefore, the image of oligomer as a “bad polymer”* appeared. It can be well traced in various definitions of oligomers. For example, encyclopedia of 1964 [3] calls oligomers “low molecular weight polymers”. Paper [13] gives a more precise definition: “oligomers are low molecular weight polymers with molecular weight of about М=500–10000 mass units”. V. Kern [8] provides a more complete definition: “oligomers are low molecular weight homogeneous substances homological to polymers”. Even in 1970s some Japanese authors [21] stated that the term “oligomer” has a range of applications corresponding just to “polymer products with a low degree of polymerization”. Following this logical conclusion we could state on the same basis but with no less uncertainty that polymers are oligomeric products with a high degree of polymerization or a high molecular weight. One of the subjective reasons that lead us to such a skeptical attitude to oligomers as a possible object for fundamental research is the fact that in many definitions (see, e.g. [1,4,10]) the term “oligomer” is related to compounds taking an intermediate position between oligomers and polymers, where the word “intermediate” has some hint on indefiniteness and ambiguity in meaning that is, “neither fish nor flesh” (“neither beginning nor ending some classification chain”; “corresponding to none of the opposite phenomena” [23]). But if we accept this intermediate position of oligomers as some objective entity such as the one appearing when analyzing the state of aggregation of matter: liquid is an intermediate state of matter between gas and solid body*, the aspects we underline change drastically. Let’s accept a classical thesis: to give a definition is to make some conception a part of a broader one and to explain its meaning. It is clear that differences in various definitions of the term “oligomer” arise from the fact that, on the one hand, we choose different objects as a broader concept (polymer, monomer, matter, homologous series) and, on the other hand, from different approaches to choosing a characteristic feature (molecular weight, molecular size and linear length, number of monomeric links, distance between chain ends, molecular *
It is suitable to demonstrate some historical examples here: the XIXth century chemists looked at uncrystallizable and undistillable ‘resinous woods’, formed as products of chemical reactions (which appeared in most cases to be polymer-like substances) just as if they were worthless substances [22]. * Note, it is about pure analogy. Aggregative transition is always a usual first-order phase transition, opposite to monomer ↔ oligomer ↔ polymer transformations which are quite different from phase transitions in their classical meaning (see below).
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
3
volume, flexibility, physical properties, and etc.) describing the meaning of the term “oligomer” and defining its intermediate position between monomers and polymers. First of all let us note that “broader concepts” of “polymer” and “monomer” used in many definitions in general sense are equivalent to the term “oligomer”. In addition, the aforementioned essential features are always correlated but these links in meaning are not equivalent. Of course, the molecular weight of molecules in one homologous series does not always increase with the chain length growth, but the compound with the same chain length as the first one but belonging to another homologous series can bear an incommensurably lower or higher molecular weight. Some compounds such as cyclical molecules will pass the molecular weight test as oligomers according to the above given definition because their molecular weight is about hundreds and thousands of oxygen units but we should take care when using the term “chain length” (periodicity) for their description*). And at last, the usage of a physical property as a characteristic feature often leads to mismatch of numerical values of the chosen parameter taken as the results of experiments based on different methods. You can see these critical values vary depending on the experimental conditions even when the same methods are being used. All these facts make it impossible to develop a clear gradation on the basis of the known definitions: according to some test results some chemical compounds may fall into the class of oligomers but according to the other tests they can be considered either polymers or monomers. This is the source of a long-history view that, nevertheless, still exists in some minds about oligomers as something indefinite and multiple meaning. For example, oligomers are described as “unfinished polymers” (forpolymers) or “axelrath” monomers (macromonomers).
1.1.3. Development of “Oligomer” Term Formulations The definition proposed by the IUPAC Commission on the molecular nomenclature [24] made things clearer in the late 1970s - early 1980s of the last century: “Oligomer is a substance consisting of molecules formed by atoms of one or several types or atomic groups (constitutional units), The definition proposed by the IUPAC Commission on the molecular nomenclature [24] made things clearer in the late 1970s - early 1980s of the last century: “Oligomer is a substance consisting of molecules formed by atoms of one or several types or atomic groups (constitutional units), associated in a recurring way. Physical properties of oligomer change if one or several constitutional units are added or deleted”. The oligomeric molecule can be most commonly presented as
*
Don’t forget that the second essential part of the word oligomer - μεροζ – can be translated not only as “a part” but also as “a definition”.
4
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
Y1
Y3 X1-X2 Y4
n
Y2
The n sum of constitutional units (Х1-Х2 …) of oligomeric molecule is also called an oligomeric block (OB). The Х1 and Х2 units can have the same (Х1 = Х2) or different chemical structures (Х1 ≠ Х2) or Х2 = 0. There are also end groups = у1, у2, у3, у4,...), whose chemical structures differ from chain monomers. The number of end groups can vary from 2 (Y1 and Y2 =1, Y3 = Y4=0) to more (Y1, Y2, Y3 and Y4 = 1), while end groups themselves can be the same (Y1 = Y2 = Y3 = Y4) or different (for example, Y1 = Y2 ≠ Y3 = Y 4) in an oligomeric molecule. The definition given above by IUPAC is considerably correct. The broader concept “oligomer” falls into is neither polymer nor monomer but a substance characterized by a structural feature. This definition forms the upper limit for the n number of oligomeric block constitutional units corresponding to the transition from oligomeric to polymeric state of the substance. Indeed, we can experimentally distinguish the fact of adding just one link to oligomeric block from n to n+1 because the change from Хn (oligomer) to a compound with Хn+1 blocks (polymer) never goes without changes of physical properties. Any further increase of oligomeric block length from n+1 to n+2 (a polymer with Хn+1 block changes into polymer with Хn+2 block) cannot be registered experimentally because polymers have identical physical properties within a small Δn. But IUPAC description is nevertheless short of accuracy for it doesn’t provide any considerable difference between the terms “oligomer” and “low molecular weight compound”. The fact is that when we go from Хn oligomeric block to Хn–1 block and further on, from Хn–1 (monomer) to Хn–2 (monomer) and etc., the change of physical properties can be experimentally registered (if we change the length of both oligomeric and monomeric molecular chains, physical properties will also change), so this method cannot help us to find the lower limit for the number of the nth oligomeric block constitutional units. This problem of uncertainty was solved by Alfred Berlin. His interpretation of gradation “monomer – oligomer – polymer” [25] is more accurate and physically justified. Analyzing the changes of partial values of various physical parameters Φ (for example, volatility, heat capacity, density, viscosity, melting and boiling temperatures, etc.) which characterize homologous series of organic compounds, А. Berlin defined three areas with considerably different dependence Φ on the n number of constitutional units. Their common but simplified graphical representation is shown in Figure 1.1.
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
5
Figure 1.1. Physical parameter Φ=f(n) (solid line) and increments of it’s value ΔΦ/Δn (df(n)/dn) (dashed line) of homologous series.
The first area which is characterized by linear function Φ=f(n), i.е. ΔΦ/Δn=const, corresponds to low molecular weight homologous, in other words, monomers (generally this linear function exists in some generalized coordinates {Y(Φ), n}, i.е. the function Y(Φ)=f(n), and ΔY(Φ)/Δn = const is linear.) The size of molecules within this homologous area is always less than the size of the segment which “limits” the Φ properties described by the classical physical chemistry laws [26, 27]. The second area represents a nonlinear dependence of the Φ parameter partial value increment on n, that is, ΔΦ/Δn≠const. In other words, the form of function Φ=f(n) describing a homologous series changes sharply when we reach a fixed number of constitutional units n. This is the lower limit of oligomeric area. In the upper limit of this area Φ does not depend on n any longer and its increment ΔΦ is equal to 0. But it is necessary to note that physical parameters Φ of the same homologous series or a physical parameter Φ in various homologous series can be described by different nonlinear functions f(n). The third area covers polymers with Φ independent from the chain length within small Δn, i.e. in this case ΔΦ/Δn=0. Though possessing a strictly logical structure, Berlin’s interpretation of the “oligomer” term definition still seems indefinite concerning the fact that many factors contribute to the boundary values of n. Indeed, theoretically estimated and experimentally obtained boundary values of n, showing that the substance belongs to this or that area (see, e.g. [28-42]) were proven to change even within one homological series depending on evenness or oddness of rows, branching or non-branching of the main chain, the nature of the end groups, as well as proven to depend on experimental methodology, or the physical parameter Φ chosen for registration, measurement conditions, test sensitivity and etc.
6
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
It is necessary to note, most publications show that researchers’ attention was mainly attracted to the area of large n. For example, the study by V. Privalko [39] presents an analysis of molecular pack density (ρα) as the function of molecular weight (М) in homologous series of tetramethylenoxide, ethylenoxide and styrene with М ~ 5·102 - 106. While analyzing the regular behavior principles (see Figure 1.2) in areas with М > 103 based on three models (intermolecular packs, overlapping statistical coils and statistically collapsing macromolecules), the author comes to a conclusion that the last fact corresponds to experimental data. As for the unusual effects discovered for substances with М < 103, they are considered to be caused by the influence of the end groups.
Figure 1.2. Dependence of density ρα on a molecular weight of tetramethyleneoxide (1) and ethyleneoxide (2) homologues at 750С and styrene (3) at 250С.
Hansen and Hou [41] proposed a model describing the dependence of heat capacity (λ) on average polymerization degree (Р) of molecules taking their orientation into account (different degrees of interaction between neighboring links connected by chemical and physical bonds). They have theoretically proven that λ is proportional to Р1/2 for short length molecular chains, however, with the molecular length increase, the increment of λ rapidly falls down, and that corresponds to the experimental data presented in [41] for homologous series of n-methylenes and n-styrenes. A titanic work was done by G. Korolev and А. Il’in [28]. They carried out the analysis of melting (Tm) and boiling (Tb) temperatures behavior and coefficients of molecular packing Kp in homologous series (Кp = Na.Vv /M · d, where Na is Avogadro number, Vv is Van der Waals molecular volume, М is molecular weight, d is density) as functions of molecular size (its Van der Waals volume) for 5000 various organic compounds. This enormous amount of experimental data allows us to make the following conclusions: 1) for research with a wide range of values Vv analyzed, the absolute majority of curves corresponding to functions Тm ,Тb, Кp, = f (Vv), presented in [28], show us (i.e., see Figure 1.3) a definite existence of linear and non-linear functional areas predicted by А. Berlin; 2) deviations from the above shown functions (see Figure 1.3 again) are caused by such “disturbing” factors as symmetry (and
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
7
asymmetry) of the molecular structure depending on the symmetry or oddness of the molecular rows, the shielding effect of the side groups on the centers of intermolecular interaction, presence of hinged bridges (e.g., -О- link), facilitating compact packing of molecules, and etc. Paper [28] gives a detailed analysis of various factors contributing to the influence of molecular structure on intermolecular interactions.
(A)
(B) Figure 1.3. Dependence of molecular packing coefficient Кp at 200С on the Van-der-Vaals molecular volume Vv for homologous rows of organic compounds with linear aliphatic chains and various nature of end groups: 1- amides; 2- acids; 3 – anhydrides; 4 – alcohols; 5 – nitriles; 6 – iodides; 7 – esters; 8 – aldehydes; 8 – bromides; 9 – ketones; 11 – amines; 12 – chlorides; 13 – phtorides; 14 – alkyl oxides.
The fact that the n boundary values depend on experimental conditions is well demonstrated in papers [8,9] where X-ray scattering was used to find a lower limit between oligomers and low molecular weight compounds. The authors showed that the long period value for crystallizing homologues which is determined by the size of crystallites is a linear function of n, which grows with the molecular size, increases up to some limit of the n value depending on the homologous row nature. In the area above, the linear principle does not work, as the chain gets the ability to fold. The lower boundary of oligomeric (or pleinomeric, according to the original author’s terminology) area was assigned to the limit value n=n1min where a longer period value function of n starts to take a contribution from the molecular
8
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
chain flexibility parameter. But according to another experiment with nothing but a lower crystallization speed different from the previous research, the crystallization temperature was close to the melting point of the analyzed sample with narrow MWD, and the area where the longer period function of n for the same homologous series was linear extended up to the values n=n2min, where n2min>>n1min. The increase of the boundary value nmin was caused by the new experimental conditions which allowed us to permit thermodynamically the opportunity of straightened molecules crystallization even for potentially flexible and relatively long chain monomeric molecules. The existence of such thermodynamically permitted conditions in the previous experiment was forbidden kinetically. The given example, however, proves Berlin’s statement: the results of specific experiments always show us three well-defined areas of the curve Φ=f(n) independent of the boundary values N: linear dependence area, non-linear dependence area and the area, where material properties do not depend on the polymerization degree. Thus, the laws describing the change of chain growth properties in low molecular weight, oligomer and polymer systems are totally different. If we consider that the group of these three totally different areas defines the term “oligomer” and take the intermediate one for oligomeric state characterized by nonlinear function Φ (n), any homologous row will show us an oligomeric interval. Such a definition, however, still has various interpretations, because the boarders of oligomeric area in homologous rows are set by external conditions and physical test parameter Φ. But it is not unusual. This is what we should expect. A fundamental constant, such as the water boiling point, also depends on measurement conditions, e.g., on pressure. The dependence of the matter properties on the macromolecule length (or the number of chain links) was chosen as a core characteristic distinguishing homologous rows in this method. It is a principal choice. It proved to be effective and showed us the way to systematic analysis of the term “oligomer”. Further on, this approach [43] developed an attempt to go from statements to physical values for functions describing the dependence of physical properties characterizing compounds in homologous rows on the length of molecules. We have analyzed patterns of internal energy density change with the growth of the n polymerization (polycondensation) degree in highly diluted solutions of organic compounds with various values of n. The mass concentration of solution was set constant to make the total number of monomer units constant and independent of n. The logical conclusions of the analysis presented in [43] can be reduced to the following qualitative statements: the molecules in highly diluted solutions make following contributions to the internal energy of the system: 1. 2. 3. 4.
internal energy of molecules, which does not depend on n; interaction energy of molecules and solution media, which does not depend on n; molecular interaction energy, i.e. intermolecular energy, which depends on n; interaction energy of chain segments, which depends on n only within the specific values of n.
Indeed, if every link interacts only with its nearest monomer neighbors in the molecular chain, the number of internal degrees of freedom grows proportionally to the number of monomeric units, i.e. it depends linearly on the degree of polymerization. Therefore, internal
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
9
energy and interaction energy of every molecule will increase k times if we change the degree of polymerization k times. However, molecular concentration will be k times less for this degree of polymerization (assuming mass concentration of our solution is constant). As the corresponding contribution to the energy density is one molecule energy multiplied by molecular concentration, this value will remain constant. The interaction energy of molecules and solution media gives us the same results. The molecular interaction (pair interaction) energy contribution to the energy density is proportional to square concentration, collision probability and interaction energy of two molecules for a diluted solution within the gas approximation. The homologue molecules numeric concentration with a constant mass concentration is inversely proportional to the degree of polymerization n, and the collision probability is proportional to the multiplication of molecule volumes, i.e., squared degree of polymerization n2. Therefore, the squared concentration and collision probability multiplication are independent of the degree of polymerization. Thus, the pair interaction energy contribution to the system energy density depends only on the constant of the pair interaction proportional to the number of macromolecule constitutional units. Therefore, the homologue degree of polymerization shows contributions to the energy density so that its properties vary linearly with the internal energy change (see left area of Figure 1.1). Though this statement is true only for paired or neighboring interactions of chain links, it can be applied to almost any low molecular weight compound with a straight molecule. Any further increase of the chain length provides not only neighboring interactions but full intrachain contacts within one molecule due to inevitable bending deformations. Such a remote intrachain interaction effectively reduces the internal degrees of freedom and acts as a shield for interaction with other molecules and solution media. Therefore, the internal energy density depends less on the chain length due to all these factors and no longer corresponds to linear function (see middle area in Figure 1.1). Any further increase of the diluted molecule chain length promotes shielding effects (the same middle area in Figure 1.1). However, after a certain chain length, when the chain gets coiled, the chain length no longer influences the interchain interaction constant (see right area in Figure 1.1); this relates to the fact that a long enough chain can be described as a group of blobs (statistically independent real chain fragments) [44]. Thus we can reduce interaction between chains to interaction between blobs of different macromolecules. Because parameters of blobs, such as their size, depend only on chemical structure of the macromolecule and do not depend on chain length even at 1/n scale [44], the interchain interaction constant does not depend on chain length within the large values of n. The analysis of internal energy dependence on chain length for diluted and concentrated solutions and liquid melts of organic molecules gives us the same results. The most important statement in the previous discussion is that the remote intramolecular interactions (interactions within one chain) emerge. It is these interactions that shield interchain interactions and lead to deviation (decline) of Φ=f(n) dependence on linear function. These remote intrachain interactions between monomer (constitutional) units in a single molecule mark a transition from low molecular weight to oligomeric state of substance as n increases in a homologous row. Taking into account that this interaction is the result of bending deformations which can take place only in a relatively long macromolecule (for minimum chain length see next parts), it is reasonable and even natural to use a chain length parameter, but not, e.g., molecular weight, as the criterion of transition from low molecular
10
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
weight to oligomeric state of the substance (though these parameters are equivalent in some cases). But we should also take into account the fact that, apart from chemical structure, the rigidity (or flexibility) of the chain is defined by the system temperature and surroundings as well. So the conclusion is inevitable and logical: “low molecular weight compound – oligomer” transition takes place at different chain lengths depending on various conditions. While “monomer – oligomer” transition boundary is set by remote intrachain interactions emerging with the increase of the chain length, “oligomer – polymer” transition corresponds to collapse into globular conformation with the increase of the n value. According to statistical physics of polymers this state is achieved only at some minimum chain length. Therefore “oligomer – polymer” transition can also be sufficiently well described in terms of chain length. These statements also show us that the lower and the upper boundaries of the oligomeric area depend on the condition the tested molecule is in. This dependence is not a disadvantage of the proposed method to define these boundaries, but a physical property of the condensed state of substance in the form of oligomer. Therefore, the chain length is the core parameter to determine the oligomeric area boundaries. A macromolecular chain is capable of bending and taking a globular conformation depending on the system temperature and conditions. All we need is to find a minimum length of molecules with statistical flexibility for the lower oligomeric area boundary, and globular macromolecules for the upper oligomeric area boundary. In paper [44] the authors applied theoretical analysis (described in [45]) of statistical conformations of a long macromolecule including the influence of chain rigidity in a model of orientation-correlated migration to estimate deformation and ability to form a coil for chains with various rigidity and length values. This fact allowed us to estimate the upper and lower boundaries of oligomeric area in homologous rows. The dependence of the mean-square molecular radius to chain length ratio (R2(n)/n) on the chain length was chosen as the parameter characterizing the bending and coil-forming abilities of the macromolecule. We also took into account the fact that apart from the molecular chemical structure, the rigidity (or flexibility) of chain is defined by the system temperature. The higher the temperature is, the more rigid is the chain, the lower the temperature is, the more flexible it is. Figure 1.4 shows the results given in [44]. Every curve consists of three areas similar to schematic dependencies presented in Figure 1.1. However, the boundaries of these areas change with the change of the system temperature: the temperature increase results in a smaller oligomeric area size and the chain length shift to smaller values of n. This example proves that the molecular length – rigidity correlation can serve as the main criterion for classification of homologous as monomers, oligomers or polymers and boundaries between these areas depend on different system parameters, such as the temperature.
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
11
Figure 1.4. Plot R2(n)/n versus n for various temperatures: T1 – 1, T2 – 2, T3 – 3 (T1
1.1.4. Oligomeric System as Statistical Ensemble Let us discuss another essential aspect of oligomer science. We have previously stated that statistical flexibility of macromolecules defines the transition between low molecular weight and oligomeric states of a substance. It means that oligomers though having molecules of middle size obtain some statistical properties. This viewpoint is evidently controversial. Statistical methods cannot be applied to an individual monomer molecule. We can use statistics to describe only large groups of molecules. The conventional approach shown in [36] assumes that an infinitely long individual polymer chain is an object of statistical analysis (polymer statistics usually varies in the range of 1/n) and this statistics works fine, if we take, e.g., Flory Gaussian. But it is always assumed that oligomers have a finite chain length. So can we use statistics to describe a molecule of oligomer? The answer was given in papers [45, 46]. If the number of elements in a system consisting of one oligomeric molecule cannot be considered infinite, let us take a system comprised of all constituent links in all oligomeric molecules and consider its number of elements infinite. The authors used the average of an entire ensemble instead of the group of monomer links (which is typical of a polymer molecule) in one infinite chain to describe statistic properties of a single oligomer molecule in this ensemble, i.e. its internal degrees of freedom. This physical meaning was used for averaging in [45] to get the curves shown in Figure 1.4. Papers [45,46] give many important conclusions. First, according to this approach, oligomer is a statistical object. Second, unlike polymers, oligomers do not show Gaussian statistics (even ideal hypothetic oligomeric molecules)*. Third, statistical properties of oligomers depend on both energy and statistical
*
It was Yu. Lipatov in 1977 who questioned the usage of Gaussian statistics to estimate oligomer system properties [11].
12
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
properties of molecules. And, the last, oligomers are a group of oligomeric molecules but not a single molecule; this defines the bulk properties of oligomers. Let’s take a closer look at these statements. The scaling analysis of conformational properties showed that various orientation and correlation effects for chains with specific length/property ratio can be found for freely joined chains varying in rigidity (or flexibility) and length (in homologous rows) [46]. If we take into account the excluded volume parameter in these correlated systems within Onzager’s model of rigid rods, we can see critical concentrations of rods for microscopic areas (aggregates) with local orientational orderings of rods in the initially isotropic macroscopic system, which, therefore, have an increased density. This concentration depends on the row length. The density of rods packing in aggregates depends on regularity in their orientation. The size of such areas (orientational correlation length) is another characteristic of the system scale which must be compared both with the Kuhn segment size and macromolecular size. Three alternative correlations are possible: A) the correlation length parameter is lower than the Kuhn segment size, or the chain length. The system is a typical polymer with macroscopic properties not affected by microscopic local ordering. B) the correlation length parameter is higher than the Kuhn segment size or the chain length. A low chain length corresponds here to the systems with low-molecular weight elements. But the local ordering of the relatively long chains compared to their Kuhn segment length can change into macromolecular ordering and finally lead to liquid crystal state transition. C) the correlation length parameter is higher than the Kuhn segment size but lower than the chain length. The last alternative corresponds to oligomeric area where local ordering of segments in different chains influences their conformation beyond the Kuhn segment level, i.e., sets the entire system macroscopic properties. Further discussion on these statements is provided below (see Part 2.2). Note that the low-scale structure of oligomer systems (local orientational ordering areas) influences the macroscopic properties of the system and is the effect of collectivism in oligomeric molecules behavior. This structure corresponds only to a specific length/rigidity ratio. However, it is not only the molecular structure that influences the effective rigidity but also the environment and external conditions, such as temperature. Note another unusual fact: formation of oligomeric aggregates, that is, complication of the system structure by orientationally ordered structures, is stipulated not only by the energy consuming intermolecular interaction forces (such as dipole, hydrogen, coordination and other physical bonds) but also by the conformational statistical properties of oligomer molecules. These properties appear at specific length/persistent length ratio, which, in turn, means, that boundaries between low molecular weight, oligomeric and polymeric states are characterized by drastic changes in the statistical behavior of macromolecules. Since the spontaneous complication of the structure (or self-organization) is anti-entropic, oligomer systems are naturally inclined to the processes with the entropy drop (due to their statistical behaviour) which must be compensated by the internal system energy. Calculations carried out in [47] show that the entropy drop compensation by the positive energy efficiency is a specific feature of oligomers: the individual chains loose their free energy only if they
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
13
belong to a specific chain length range where all conformations are not equally probable but, instead, correlated, i.e., they are oligomers characterized by distance intramolecular interactions. It is these oligomer chains, if aggregating, that compensate the enthalpy drop by their internal energy. Therefore, a thermodynamic ensemble of molecules obtains a new specific group feature at the point of transition from low molecular weight to oligomeric state: inclination to form supramolecular structures, or orientationally ordered aggregates. This fact can not be stipulated by specific physical and chemical interactions. This feature disappears when we go from oligomers to polymers. This statement does not mean that: а) specific forces in oligomer systems (polar forces, hydrogen bonds and etc.) cannot lead to aggregation. They can – depending on the molecule chemical structure; b) supramolecular structures cannot be formed in polymer solutions and melts. They can, due to the same specific properties. All this means that the nature of supramolecular structures formation can be different for oligomer and polymer systems, though the statistical behavior of oligomers is an essential, sometimes dominating, factor of their aggregation. Therefore, we must take into account both energy and statistical properties of homologous molecules in order to obtain experimental or theoretical values of the criteria properties within the framework of the approach being discussed. It is based on homologous row differentiation according to the chain length. These properties do not describe a single oligomer molecule but the behavior of the entire ensemble. We cannot state in this case that a single oligomer molecule has essential physical features, instead, we consider them to be averaged in the effective oligomer molecules ensemble and affected, in their turn, by a single oligomer molecule structure. Hence, we cannot say that a single “oligomeric” molecule is the only carrier of oligomeric properties – they are extended beyond to their thermodynamic ensemble. In other words, the study of oligomers should not be limited by the study of a single molecule properties. We should analyze the thermodynamic properties of the whole oligomeric ensemble and kinetics of its advance to thermodynamic equilibrium to make the image complete. The last statement is discussed in separate chapters (see Parts 2.3 and 2.7).
1.2. CLASSIFICATION PRINCIPLES OF OLIGOMER SYSTEMS Thousands of natural and synthetic compounds can be considered oligomers according to the definitions given in the previous part. Various criteria for systematization according to different essential features [8,13,15,16,48,49] have been offered to describe this variety of oligomers. The part below provides the oligomers taxonomy according to [16].
1.2.1. Taxonomy of Oligomers 1. According to the Ability of Oligomers to Take or Not to Take Part in Chemical Reactions According to this feature oligomers are subdivided into two classes: а) reactive and b) non-reactive. This classification is rather relative, because various factors influence the reactivity of oligomers. For example, a chemical bond may be reactive within a specific
14
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
temperature range and inert beyond its boundaries, a catalyst may initiate a chemical reaction in an oligomeric system, and may not in another system, and a functional group may interact with one component and may not interact with another one. The subject of interest is not abstract reactivity but the behavior of a specific oligomer in specific storage and processing conditions.
2. According to Chemical Nature of Oligomeric Blocks The gradation here is the same as the standard classification in polymer chemistry: а) carbon-chain, b) element-chain, c) heterogeneous chain, d) cyclic oligomers, and etc. Each class can include subclasses: oligoalkyls, oligodienes, oligoarylens, oligoalkylensulfides, oligosyloxanes. and etc. 3. According to the Chemical Nature of Functional Groups For example, а) vinyl, b) acryl, c) hydroxyl, d) epoxy (dlycidyle), e) carboxyle, f) isocyanates, g) maleinates, h) peroxide, i) amide, j) sulfoxide, and etc. (for more information, see Table 1.1). 4. According to Functionality Parameters This classification subdivides oligomers into the following groups: a) According to the number of functional groups in a molecule: zero- , mono-, bi-, three, tetra-, and multifunctional oligomers. Non reactive oligomers have no functional groups, while reactive oligomers have one, two, three, four, and etc. functional groups. b) According to the arrangement of functional groups in a molecule: Oligomers can contain chain-end functional groups in oligomeric backbone (telechelates), and branched functional groups (alternants). Oligomers can contain regularly (structurally regular oligomers) or statistically alternating functional groups. c) According to the FTD and MWD parameters. This classification requires average functionality fi, that is the number of functional groups in the i-th molecule, to be supplemented by weight average (fw) and number average (fn) functionalities (as weight-average (Мw) and number average (Мn) molecular weights, correspondingly). Oligomers are subdivided into: oligomers with strongly defined functionality and ideal ratios fw/fn =1, Мw/Мn≥1; oligomers with fn ∼ Мn and fw/fn ∼ Мw/Мn and oligomers with fw /fn > 1 и Мw /Мn > 1. 5. According to Curing Pattern This classification subdivides oligomers into two large classes: a) а) polymerization oligomers (PO): curing goes without any release of low molecular weight by-products; b) b) condensation oligomers (CO): low-molecular weight products do not release during polymerization reaction*. *
Some authors [44, 50] reject classical definitions of polymerization and polycondensation [51] and consider them as sequential addition chain – growing process Аn + А → Аn+1 where A stands for a monomer molecule (polymerization) and combination of chain blocks having free end valencies Аn + Аm → Аn+m (polycondensation).
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
15
Each class offers possible sub-classification according to the chain-growth mechanism (such as radical polymerization, ionic polymerization, addition polymerization, migratory polymerization, equilibrium and non-equilibrium polycondensation, and etc.) and according to initiation or activation mechanisms (peroxide, radiative, photonic and catalytic initiation or activation by specific curing agents). PO – subclass includes, for example, oligodienes, unsaturated oligoesters, oligoesterepoxides, urethane-forming and other oligomers with multiple bonds or reactive cyclic units. CO – subclass includes various phenol- and urea-formaldehyde, glyptal and carbamide oligomers, mercaptooligosulfides, oligosyloxanediols, and etc. This classification is also relative because any functional group can react according to various mechanisms depending on conditions (see below).
6. According to Topological Structure of the Cured Products This classification offers various criteria to describe the end structure topology. The most popular gradation of oligomers is based here on the structure of polymer products which can be linear (a), branched (b) or cross-linked (c). Oligomer functionality is, evidently, the cornerstone of this classification. 7. According to Relaxation State of the Cured Products This gradation offers two sub-classes of oligomers: oligomers forming elastomeric compounds (a) and stiff polymers (b). A typical first class representative is the so-called “liquid rubber” which is hydrocarbon or urethane oligomeric compound with the number of links about > 10-20 and various functional groups. Second sub-class includes short-chain and multifunctional oligomers such as oligoestermaleinatfumarates, oligoester acrylates and etc. Strict definition of these groups is rather complicated and distinction is mostly conditional because the relaxation state of polymers formed as curing products of oligomers belonging to each class is determined by the test (operation) temperature, curing pattern, polyreaction kinetics, initial product FWD, presence of additives (such as plasticizers) and many other factors. This classification also includes a specific group of the so-called “heat-resistant oligomers”. These oligomer compounds are, certainly, not heat-resistant (they are liquid or low-melt) but their curing products are highly thermal and heat-resistant. The reason is either that curing process leaves initial oligometic heat-resistant blocks unchanged (for example, oligosiloxane blocks or fragments with interconnections) or that chemical curing of oligomers results in formation of new energy-consuming compounds (polyaromatic, polyinterconnected and other structures) [52-57].
This approach puts ring-opening and free valence migration reactions into the category of polycondensation processes, although no by-products are formed here.
Table 1.1. Classification of Structurally Regular Oligomers [25]
Functional group (FG) structure
1 -ОН, -Н, -СООН, -NН2 -Hal (-Br, -Cl, -F) N
R
N
R/ ,
O CH CH2 ,
S CH
H N CH
CH2 ,
NCO*
and etc. N C NR
CH2 NCO* C
N
FG label
Oligomeric block (OB) nature
2
3
The label for a functional group of the cross-linking agent* (СL) 4
А
Oligoalkylene, oligodiene
D, E, F
-
Polyaddition
B
C
-
Onium polymerization
С
B
-
The same
O
With СА
5
6
Oligoalkylene oxide, Oligoarylene oxide, oligoalkylene sulfide
A, F or without СА
Polymerization of cycles
Polyaddition, polymerization
E
Oligoester, oligocarbonate, oligoamide, oligoimide
A, D or without СL
Polymerization of isocyanates, polycyclotrimerization
Polyaddition, ionic polymerization
2
3
4
5
6
F
Oligourethane, oligosiloxane, various copolymers
A, G or without СL
Multiple bond polymerization
Polyaddition, radical and ionic polymerization
O N
Without СL
D
,
, CH2=CRCOO-, HOOCCH=CHCOOROOCCH=CHCOO-, RC≡C1
Network formation mechanisms
Table 1.1. (Continued).
Y
O C N C O
O
,
H2 2HC C C O H H2 2HC C O C O H ,
N
-
A or without СL
Multiple bond polymerization
Polyaddition, chain polymerization
H
-
F
-
Polyaddition
2
3
4
5
6
I
-
F or without СL
-
Quasi-radical or donoracceptor polymerization
,
1 2HC C R
G
,
,
18
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
8. According to Preliminary Expertise There are other principles of classification which supplement the previous gradation system. They are less strongly determined but important for a preliminary expertise. For example, reactive oligomers can be also described in terms of their production volume as those produced in large amounts and in small amounts. The first group are oligomers which have “occupied” the world market. They are produced in amounts reaching hundreds of thousands or even millions of tons. These oligomers include unsaturated oligoesters, oligoester aleinates/fumarates and oligoester acrylates; different brands of epoxide oligomers and urethane-forming oligomers, phenolformaldehyde and phenol carbamide oligomers; liquid rubbers (mostly based on diene and isoprene), and etc. [15.58-70.75]. The second group comprises specialty oligomers such as, for example, allylic or peroxide oligomers, vinyl oligoesters, oligosulfides, the so called “thermally stable oligomers” and many other products [52-57, 64, 71-74]. The production of these oligomers is not large and depends on the current market demand. But these products mainly stimulate the development of aircraft and deep-water vehicle production, data transfer and storage and other industries of high priority.
1.2.2. Taxonomy of Oligomers Introduced by A. Berlin The taxonomy of regular structure oligomers, proposed by A. Berlin in one of his last works [25] is now of a growing importance. This taxonomy seems to be the most rational among other approaches to reactive oligomers classification as it is targeted at the finite structure of polymers and provides reasonable methodology for selection of oligomeric systems and their transformation into polymers. This taxonomy includes topological structure analysis for the cured oligomer, consideration of its functional groups chemical nature, evaluation of the role of the cross-linking (curing) agents molecular structure and prediction of a possible cross-linking mechanism. This classification, which, in fact, covers most of the discussed features, generalizes the variety of reactions that may be used to cure oligomers; moreover, it also makes it possible to specify limitations for the application of reactive oligomers in distinct technological processes. Table 1.1 gives an outline of classification suggested by A. Berlin. The first column lists the chemical structures of the functional groups of oligomers; these structures are united into classes, which are denoted by letters from A to J (column 2). Column 3 lists the main types of oligomeric blocks associated with the particular classes of oligomers. Column 4 lists the cross-linking (curing) agents, if those are used to extend and branch the chain or form a network. They are labeled by the symbols of the corresponding functional groups. Letter M denotes the non-reactive fragment between functional groups of the cross-linking agent molecule. Its chemical structure can be the same or differ from the structure of an oligomeric molecule. The last two columns describe the well-known or presumed mechanisms of oligomer curing without (column 5) or in the presence (column 6) of curing agents. The table is so illustrative and simple that there is actually no need to discuss it in detail. It provides a compact presentation of the well-known conventional laws of organic chemistry. That is why many trivial and nontrivial conclusions can be made logically and easily. For example, liquid oligomers can be converted to solid crosslinked polymers by different
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
19
mechanisms depending on the nature of the functional groups. By selecting appropriate methods of initiation, one and the same oligomer may be cured by different mechanisms and form various end structures. For example, curing of epoxide oligomers (class D, see column 2) can involve various Class А and Class Е compounds such as amines. But we can also use chemical reactions to open the epoxide ring which make the second curing component unnecessary. The table also shows that functionality of reactive groups can vary in different reactions. For example, double chemical bond F is bifunctional in polymerization reactions: every elementary chain-opening act is a starting point for two kinetic chains and, therefore, leads to formation of polymer networks. But the same chemical bond F is multifunctional in step growth polymerization (reactions involving Class А and Class G compounds): one labile atom migrates along the double chemical bond to form a linear reaction product. Another example: Epoxy group D, monofunctional in reactions with amino or carboxyl group A, whereas it is bifunctional in catalytic polymerization. The authors of [13] had to modify concepts [76] on average functionality f of reactive oligomers and to introduce a new concept of functionality in a distinct chemical reaction fr in addition to molecular functionality fi described above to take all these conclusions based on Table 1.1 into account. We must take it into account when calculating fw and fn. However, A. Berlin admitted in [25] that this table cannot be considered a completed classification. Nevertheless it provides a relatively completed presentation of chemical “opportunities” targeted at insertion of informational framework to raw oligomers with its further fixation in the finite polymer product. Thus, this scheme makes it possible to perform task-specific search of oligomers and procedures to be used for their conversion to polymers and, therefore, to make at least qualitative predictions on the structure of polymer materials.
1.2.3. Taxonomy of Oligomer Blends The terminology and taxonomy of polymer and, moreover, of oligomer blends (OB) has not been completely acquired yet [16]. Therefore, to evade possible misinterpretation, below we outline the physical implications of concepts referred to in this book. However, we do not claim that the definitions given below are comprehensive and perfect. A blend in which one of the components is an oligomer is referred to as an oligomer blend (OB). The second component of the blend may be represented by any low molecular weight, oligomeric, or high molecular weight compound. Note also that not every blend, containing an oligomer and any of the second components listed above, which can be formally (sic!) classified as an oligomer blend, can really be classified as OB. Indeed, the formal approach to identification of the majority of industrial oligomers represents them as OBs because almost all homologous oligomers show wide FWD and molecular weight distribution. Nevertheless, it is necessary to note that this approach is not always reasonable. Indeed, the formal approach would lead to a conclusion that many commercialized oligomer forms contain small amounts of low molecular weight “synthesis inhibitors” to avoid uncontrolled spontaneous reactions during storage and processing or being a part of a synthesis process or doped with small amounts of “storage inhibitors”. This would also be the case with oligomeric products doped with small amounts of initiators, catalysts, activators, and etc., added to the system before curing. The role of
20
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
these active additives is very important and, sometimes, decisive for the curing process in its chemical and kinetic aspect [15, 50, 77, 78]. The MWD and FWD of oligomers are also essential for the formation of cured polymer material topological structure [13, 50]. However, minimal dosage of the second component described above has almost no effect on the supramolecular and phase structure of liquid oligomer mixtures (unless otherwise specified). Therefore, we must consider primarily the features which make a significant thermodynamic contribution to supermolecular and phase structures of initial mixture to classify oligomer blends as mixable or unmixable. The principles of “individual” oligomers classification discussed in the previous chapter are, of course, applicable to oligomer blends. But they become much more complicated due to the multiplicity of subsystems. For example, oligomer blends can include following reactive components: PO + PO, CO + CO and PO + CO. Any subsystem can itself include variations of functional groups and oligomeric block of different nature, the length of oligomeric block and the number of functional groups etc. But there are some features that characterize only oligomer blends. First of all, they are the second component state (monomer, oligomer or polymer) and thermodynamic compatibility (or incompatibility) of blend components. We can most commonly subdivide oligomeric blends into three groups according to the first criteria: a) oligomer – monomer blends, b) oligomer – oligomer blends and c) oligomer – polymer blends.
Oligomer - Monomer Blends Among the vast number of oligomer-monomer blends let us mention those which are commercially important. These blends are primarily represented by the mixtures of oligoestermaleinatefumarates with various vinyl monomers (mostly styrene); these blends are commonly referred to as “polyester resins” [58-60]. This class of OB also includes epoxide compositions (blends of oligoester epoxides with amines or other monomeric curing agents) [50,61,62], some novolak phenolformaldehyde compositions cured by, for example, hexamethylenetetramine [66], oligosulfides – oxidants blends [74] and urethane composites (blends of oligoester- or oligodiene glycols with di- and triisocyanates) [63-65]. These types of blends are used in the majority (with only few exceptions) of commercial formulations (e.g., see [79-85]). Oligomer - Oligomer Blends These blends comprise systems of two main types. This first group includes oligomers differing in the nature of functional groups: acryl and epoxide, epoxide and isocyanate, metacryl and hydroxyl, metacryl and maleinate groups etc. One of these blends is used for preparation of simultaneous inter-penetrating networks (IPNs). The major requirement that these blends should satisfy is that the functional groups of each oligomer in the pair interact by different reactions; this must, therefore, eliminate the reactions between different chains [86-90]. On the contrary, other polyreactions with the same mechanisms are used to copolymerize different components. A popular industrial binder PN-609 based on a mixture of oligomaleinate/fumarates with oligoester acrylate (e.g, triethylene glycol dimethacrylate is another representative of oligomer-oligomer blends [15]. Oligoester acrylates are used instead of ecologically hazardous styrene to significantly accelerate curing of “polyester resins”. This
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
21
list can be continued by the blends of “liquid rubbers” containing epoxide or unsaturated functional groups with corresponding reactive oligomers. The curing process of such mixtures must desirably lead to elongation and (or) branching of a linear chain [81, 82, 90]. Another large group of oligomer-oligomer blends is represented by oligomers with different concentrations of identical functional groups and either identical or various oligomer blocks in different molecules. These blends are produced either by manual mixing of finished products [92] or by specific synthesis [75]. By varying the contents of different oligomer molecules in these compounds, we can control the properties of the blends and the rigidity of the resultant polymer products. For example, we can add mono- or bifunctional oligomers into high-viscous polyfunctional oligomer blends to produce compounds with lower viscosity and less fragile networks of cured oligomers. A typical example of this class of oligomeroligomer blends is provided by oligoester acrylate compounds of commercial brands D-20/50 (a 1:1 mixture of oligomer based on glycol and phthalic acid terminated by two methacrylic acid groups and pentaerythritol-based oligomer with eight methacrylic acid groups per oligomer molecule) and D-35 (a 35:65 w/w mixture of the same bifunctional oligomer and pentaerythritol-based oligomer with six methacrylic groups per molecule). There are other oligomer – oligomer blends of the same type (e.g., see reviews [17, 75, 85, 91, 92]).
Oligomer - Polymer Blends Application of this class suggests at least two extreme situations. In the first case an oligomer is added to modify a polymer (let us refer to this system as a polymer-oligomer blend). In the second case a linear polymer is added to a reactive oligomer in order to make the future network more elastic (referred to as an oligomer-polymer blend). In both cases, curing products are polymer-polymer blends, but their structures are totally different: they differ in the nature of dispersion medium and dispersion phase, morphological parameters, and etc. Polymer – oligomer systems are, in turn, divided into two subsystems differentiated by oligomer reactivity. A) Non-reactive oligomer. Oligomer acts as a common plasticizer when added to a linear polymer. Nonreactive oligomer plasticizer remains chemically intact in a resultant curing material and reduces its physico-chemical characteristics (first of all, a module) displaying a well-known Rebinder effect [98] unless anti-plasticization processes occur. High vapor tension (non-volatility and resultant ecological attractiveness) are the main advantages of such nonreactive oligomer plasticizers over common monomer plasticizers: we can select oligomer with a specific chemical structure [96, 97] which is more effective in comparison with its low molecular weight analogue in the same conditions. These advantages of oligomer plasticizers stipulate their successful commercial production [93, 94, 99]. B) Reactive oligomer. When a polymer is added to a reactive oligomer, the so-called “temporary plasticization” (a term used in technical documentation) takes place. During the initial processing stages of a polymer-oligomer blend (mixing of components, rolling, extrusion, etc.), the reactive oligomer acts as a common plasticizer (i.e., its effect is similar to that of nonreactive oligomer): it lowers the softening and flow temperatures, reduces the viscosity of the blend, and etc. However, during further processing after triggering the chemical reactions, the
22
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev reactive oligomer (in contrast to its nonreactive analogue and low-molecular plasticizers) undergoes chemical transformations. There are two possible ways of reaction: either a network is formed with graft polymerization to a linear matrix or formation of such structures as “a snake in a cage” takes place. These objects perform a physical or chemical structural modification and eventually allow us to regulate the polymer substrate properties. Modification of final properties range for a cured system may depend on specific process conditions. Let us note, that the principle of “temporary plasticization” assumes a possibility of simultaneous physical and chemical modifications of linear polymers (in the same technological process) largely increasing practical opportunities to synthesize materials with predicted properties and to make the processing technology more efficient [77, 92, 99-108].
Compatibility of Components This feature subdivides oligomer blends into compatible (homogenious ≡ single-phase) and incompatible (heterogeneous ≡ two-or multi-phase) systems. Compatibility is obviously determined by chemical structure of components and system state parameters (such as temperature, pressure and concentration). Homogeneous Oligomer Blends can be homogeneous or heterogeneous at the supramolecular level of their structural organization. This structure itself can be isotropic or anisotropic. The reasons for structural heterogeneity of homogeneous liquids can vary very widely (see Parts 2.3 and 2.5). Heterogeneous oligomer blends are subdivided according to the size of dispersed particles (therefore, the classification used in colloidal chemistry of polymers is here applicable [98, 109, 110]), aggregative state of dispersion media or dispersion phase, temporary stability (or instability) of morphology, and etc. Many questions arise from this classification, and they have no definite answers at present. Further discussion on these problems is provided in further chapters in the third part of this monograph. All the above given classifications of oligomers and oligomer blends (as well as any of the other systems) are conventional and imperfect. Real systems are much more complicated than the proposed taxonomy. Therefore, all these principles and classifications of oligomers are subject to further detailing and improvement.
1.3. STRUCTURAL ORGANIZATION OF OLIGOMER BLENDS Description of oligomer systems usually involves their structural characteristics in initial state (before curing), intermediate state (during curing), and final product state (after curing). It is very important to choose a correct estimation parameter for these structures. As the term “structure” (“mutual alignment of incorporated elements” introduced in [111]) is too vague, it sometimes causes “science-like speculations” and incorrect conclusions. Therefore, it seems reasonable to correct terminology and general structural hierarchy used in physical chemistry of polymers [50, 112, 113] that is mainly suitable for oligomers.
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
23
1.3.1. Structural Hierarchy Fundamental physical properties of any system (such as a polymer) are proven to be determined by its “main” constitutional subsystem. A macromolecule is this subsystem in polymers. Its chemical structure and, therefore, its conformation and configuration affect the structure of all higher levels of organization. Two levels of structural organization – molecular and supramolecular – are usually considered when discussing linear polymers [113-116].
Molecular Level It reflects the chemical structure of a system: chemical composition of repeating units, nature of co- valent bonds linking the units into a chain, nature of terminal and side groups, functionality, stereochemical structure (cis, trans, iso, syndio, etc.), arrangement of units in a chain (1-2, 1-4, head-to-tail), etc., which themselves determine thermodynamic parameters of a system such as the chemical affinity of components. Supramolecular Level It reflects the spatial arrangement of the system elements: nature and strength of physical bonds involved in intermolecular interaction, the extent of order in the arrangement of molecules or their segments (such as aggregation), distribution functions of aggregates according to their number and size (such as volume distribution) and etc. Intermolecular forces (hydrogen bonds, Van-der-Waals interactions, and etc.) contribution to packing of aggregates in liquid systems is supplemented by spontaneous volume fluctuations of molecular concentration. Cross-linked polymers require an additional topological level of structure [50] which is also used to describe oligomers. Topological Level This level reflects the MWD function, the distribution of network junctions (chemical and physical) with respect to their number and branching, distribution of interjunction chains in length, distribution of “internal” cycles with respect to their number and size, and etc. These three levels of structure cannot sufficiently describe blends and characterize objects in a wide range of state parameters. That is why a colloidal level of structure is introduced [98, 109, 110, 117-119]. Colloidal Level It is determined by thermodynamic parameters of the system components and described by phase state diagrams; distribution functions of dispersed particles with respect to their number and size (dispersity); component concentrations in corresponding phases; chemical nature of continuous and dispersed phases; kinetic morphological stability; phase inversion; interfacial phenomena; and etc. As we noted above, structural parameters are interrelated though belonging to different levels of structural hierarchy. For example, the structure of molecules affects conformation properties, packing in supramolecular structures and thermodynamic characteristics of the system which, in turn, determine its phase structure, particularly equilibrium concentrations
24
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
of components in coexisting phases. Reactive groups’ functionality and anisotropy of supramolecular elements affect curing kinetics and, therefore, are essential factors for branching of mesh-points and morphology parameters. The encyclopedia [112] provides three various features for classification of elements at any structural level: geometric, thermodynamic & kinetic.
Geometric Features a) absence or presence of far ordering. The maximum order level corresponds to a crystalline structure and the minimum level corresponds to an amorphous disordered structure. The supramolecular structure of crystallizing polymers has many forms and a hierarchy of levels (e.g., see [113, 120-124]). We have to stay beyond the level of problems in this publication to analyze it properly. Let us just note that polymer structure contains discrete elements; their size, shape and phase boundary remain unchanged during all the time of observation while fluctuating elements with these parameters do change during observation. b) absence or presence of close ordering. This feature is extremely important to describe amorphous and oligomer systems. For more information please see Part 2.3.2. Note that local areas (aggregates) with various molecular anisotropies can also appear in an oligomer system (see Part 1.1.3). These aggregates can be either discrete or fluctuating depending on stabilizing forces. Thermodynamic Features Discrete systems are thermodynamically stable, fluctuating systems are thermodynamically unstable. Note also the essential difference between oligomer blends based on reactive and noncreative oligomers. Indeed, the formation of all-level structures of a chemically cured product in reactive oligomer blends (polymer-polymer blend) occurs concomitantly with the permanent variation of the chemical structure of the components (at least one of them), whereas the formation of materials from non-reactive components (e.g. solid materials) is not accompanied by any chemical transformations. This means that during the cure of reactive oligomer blends, both thermodynamic parameters of the system as a whole and those, characteristic of each of the components, do vary. Because of this, the equilibrium, that is, thermodynamically stable values of the parameters belonging to different structural levels vary during the course of the process, whereas in nonreactive blends these parameters are the function of the parameters of state only and are specified from the very start of the process. Kinetic Features Structural transformations are kinetically described by two temporal parameters: 1) 1) transition time τ1 between two states or conformation of a structural element; 2) 2) the lifetime τ2 between formation and destruction of a structural element at certain conditions. Let us repeat that τ2 = ∞ for discrete structures, which are thermodynamically stable, while τ2 is finite for fluctuating systems. Various structural levels can have slightly different τ1. For example, consider a system with given state parameters. Aggregates will grow to their equilibrium size (that is, supramolecular
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
25
level) within transition time τ1, but sometimes cannot reach equilibrium molecular anisotropy (that is, topological level). The “oligomer structure” concept is also differentiated by scale criteria [98,109,113,119,125]. Unfortunately, the scaling of oligomers is not unified yet. The most common starting points to analyze chemical structure of polymers are micro- and macrolevels. These levels can be considered both supramolecular and colloidal. The analysis range for supramolecular structure of crystallizible polymers comprises shapes and sizes of crystals and crystallites. Amorphous polymers and oligomers are characterized by the size of heterogeneities of various nature and names (see below). Colloidal level is mainly described by the scale parameters which are usual for colloidal chemistry [98,109]. The microscopic analysis of a polymer structure comprises link, chain and macromolecule sizes and various characteristics as arguments: contour length, distance between chain ends, volume, and etc.
1.4. SOME THERMODYNAMIC CHARACTERISTICS OF OLIGOMER SYSTEMS We need to consider at least four interrelated aspects to analyze the thermodynamics of oligomer systems: thermodynamic, kinetic, colloidal and methodological aspects. Thermodynamic aspect introduces applicable law of phase equilibrium and statistical thermodynamics to oligomer systems. Kinetic aspect is based on the fact that a system needs a certain time to reach equilibrium at various structural levels. Colloidal aspect correlates morphological stability (or instability) and phase boundary of oligomer systems with their macroscopic properties. Methodological aspect argues the reliability of results obtained using various phase structure analysis methods. These results are rather contradictory both because of different resolution of these methods and different interpretation of the term “phase” by various authors.
1.4.1. Thermodynamic Aspect Back in 1937, V.A. Kargin, S.P. Papkov, and Z.A. Rogovin showed that polymer solutions obey the rule of phase equilibrium, which is one of the fundamental laws of physical chemistry. Since then, there numerous attempts have been made to find an analytical relation between the molecular parameters of components and their mutual solubility. However, no serious generalizations were obtained for a long time. It was only the lattice model of liquid created by Flory [127] and Huggins [128] using the concepts of the Gibbs equilibrium thermodynamics, which analytically related a change in the free energy of mixing (AGm) or a change in the chemical potential (Δμ) to the equilibrium fraction of polymer in solution: ΔFc = kT (n1 ln υ1 + n2 lnυ2 + χ1 n1 υ1 υ2)
(1.1)
Δμ = μ1 - μ1° = RT [ln (1-υ2) + (1 - 1/x) υ2 + χ12]
(1.2)
26
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
where k is Boltzmann constant, R is universal gas constant, n1 and n2 are number of polymer and solvent molecules correspondingly, υ1 and υ2 are volume fractions of solvent and polymer, μ1 is a solvent’s chemical potential in a solution, μ1° is a pure solvent’s chemical potential, х is a number of fragments in a polymer molecule in a lattice (this parameter is similar to a degree of polymerization), χ1 is Flori – Huggins constant (interaction parameter), which describes an excess free energy of interaction per a solvent molecule. This outstanding theory stimulated research (see, for example, reviews [129-135] and their references). The results provide a quantitative correlation between molecular structure parameters of components, their mutual solubility and some properties of blends. For example, Scott [136] and Tompa [137] derived the equation for ΔFc as a function of solution temperature and molecular weight of components. Scott-Tompa’s approximation allows us to estimate the critical parameters of various blends depending on х: polymer-monomer, polymer-oligomer, oligomer-oligomer and etc. Taking a mixture of two low-molecular liquids, for example, where x1 and x2 are obviously close to 1, we get (χ1)cr=2. For polymer (x2→∞) dissolved in a low-molecular liquid (x1 ≈ 1) we get (χ1)cr=0.5. Oligomer – oligomer blends (for example, x1 and x2 ≈ 103) have (χ1)cr=0.01. Two polymers have x1 and x2 → ∞ and are, therefore, incompatible. Thus, it seems that distinct information about the degree of polymerization and the molecular structure of components allows us to calculate the critical parameters of the blend and make a conclusion about compatibility of this or that pair of components. Indeed, sometimes this rule works properly. But a comparison of experimental and theoretical results for a variety of objects has shown that this theory is not always right. The most striking examples of such a mismatch of results challenge fundamental aspects of this theory: there are several pairs of certainly compatible polymers [139,140] with χ1 as a function of concentration [133,138]. This is what the theory cannot predict. Various correlation factors and “more precise” definitions were added to initial a priori modeling and theoretical apparatus of the theory to overcome these or those mismatches of experimental data and predictions of the classical Flori-Huggins theory (and its many modifications [136, 137, 141, 142]). Particularly, the empirical parameter S, that is, “degree of mixing” was introduced to describe the so called “segmental” solubility of polymers [142]. The value S=1 was taken for a degree of mixing reaching molecular level. The area S<0 corresponds to the segmental dissolution. The area S>>1 corresponds to a phase separation. These attempts to make the theory “fit” experimental results are unnatural. They couldn’t overcome limitations of the initial lattice model which doesn’t take into consideration structural, first of all supramolecular characteristics of polymers. Flori has removed many classical theory version defects [143] from his modified thermodynamical theory of liquid blends, where he used the main aspects of the corresponding states model, which Prigozhin [144] had worked out for solutions. We will not go into details of this theory, which has been discussed, commented and further developed by many well-known scientists (see for example [129,131,132-135,145-149]). Let us just mention that the Flori theory has naturally taken into account some specific structural features of the real polymer solutions, such as change of component volumes during mixing, association of components and etc. The special appeal of a new theory was a nontrivial effect that could be naturally derived from it. Flori has theoretically proven that mixing of polymers can reduce the system entropy while increasing the number of its combinating units, because the aggregation degree of each
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
27
component molecule also increases. Thus, the introduction of combinatorial and noncombinatorial parts for a total entropy provides us with reasonable explanation and qualitative description of the real effects and in some cases reduction of a total entropy in blends through calculation of their concurrent contributions into entropy component of a free energy. Further development of thermodynamics of polymer systems involves concepts of fluctuation theory and scale invariance (scaling). Fundamental generalizations developed by I.Prigojin [144], I.M.Liphshits and his successors [150], S.Edwards [151,152], P. de Jan [149], R.Kennigsfeld [153] et.al [145-148] allowed us to obtain quantitative results for various polymer system types: [145-148] they provided quantitative description of various polymer systems: polymers with flexible and stiff chains, mono- and polydisperse polymers, polymers with low or high affinity of components, concentrated or diluted solutions, near or far from critical points, in metastable and phase-transition states etc. The state-of-the-art theory for thermodynamics of large molecules is presented in monograph of А.Е.Chalykh et. al. [134] and a successful compilation by V.I.Klenin [135]. The reasons for the fact that an oligomer molecule can be identified neither as a monomer molecule (it’s not a point object) nor a polymer molecule (we cannot take the average of all conformations) are provided above. Application of statistical physics methods to monomers is only possible for ensembles of monomer units. However, these methods can be applied to a single polymer molecule. A possibility to use statistical laws for a single monomer molecule is a subject of long-term discussion. Some authors [154,155] show that the calculated flexibility of oligomer molecules is close to that of vinyl polymers thus making it possible to use Gaussian ball model for oligomers. Other reports [156,157] postulate persistent model and provide calculations based on “fermicular chain” of Porada [158], which describes behaviour of molecules of any stiffness (flexibility) – from sticks to balls. The authors of all reports interpreted experimental results as a confirmation for their own conclusions. For example, the authors of [156] used Flori equation to calculate flexibility of oligoglycoadipinate and toluylenediizocyanate [143] (ho2 /M)1/2 = ([η]θ M/Φ)1/3 M1/2
(1.3)
where (ho2)1/2 is a chain size that doesn’t interact with solvent, [η]θ is a characteristic viscosity in θ - solvent, Ф is a constant, that is universal for polymers, М is a molecular weight. The parameters (ho2 /M)1/2 and [η]θ in this report were calculated by StockmayerFixmann equation [159] using experimental viscosity data of oligomer objects. In other research [154] viscosimetry and light scattering methods were used for oligopropyleneglycole homologues with the molecular weight М= 400 – 4000. It gives an explanation for the scattered light depolarization factor and viscosity coefficient dependence on molecular weight М and oligomer concentration provided that these compounds keep the shape of statistical ball for molecular weights less significantly than that of other known polymers. At last, authors in [38] use Porada method to calculate the root-mean-square distance between chain ends: ho2 = 2а [( L/а) -1 + е-L/a]
(1.4)
28
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
where “L” is the full chain length and “а” is the persistent chain length, and obtained а = 8 8,6 А° for oligoethyleneglycoladipinate, that is according to their report [38], shows that hydrodynamic behavior of oligomers is close to behavior of polymer Gaussian balls, which have weak hydrodynamic interaction. V.P. Privalko [39] analyses some limitations of the Gaussian ball model. He declares that Gauss approximation is inadequate for the description of the short-chain oligomer molecules giving various examplary illustrations. In particular, experimental data, provided in [160] for the functional dependence of the first member χ1 of the enthalpy component series expansion χн on molecular weight for polystyrene solutions in real solvents. The critical range of М~1,2 – 1,5 ·103 (it depends on a solvent) has proven to have extreme behavior of χ1 that goes beyond the limits within М~1,5 - 5·104. The author [39] explains these properties of the function χ1 on М as a transformation of macromolecular conformation from straight nonGaussian to Gaussian ball shape*. Please note, that these interpretations of similarities and differences in “structural” behavior of oligomer and polymer molecules were not based on direct structural research and object-oriented theoretical calculations but on indirect dynamic experiments and calculations where their results were used. That is why we should agree with Yu.S. Lipatov in his opinion based on the results of these experiments and the ones alike [11], that “hydrodynamic oligomer characteristics agree well with non-flowing Gaussian ball model, though oligomers are not Gaussian balls because their molecular chain is too short”. The statistical properties of oligomer systems are more specific than that of monomers due to additional degrees of freedom contributing oligomer flexibility and differ from properties of polymers because their chain is too short for a sufficient ball conformation. Therefore theories that have been developed and confirmed for low-molecular and highmolecular weight compounds cannot be identically applied to oligomers when their conformational properties are not considered. Part 2.2 provides some approaches to understanding the oligomer structure formation thermodynamics.
1.4.2. Kinetic Aspect High viscosities of polymers and different constants of diffusion and relaxation of components in oligomer and polymer blends are the factors which determine the difficulty of getting the equilibrium state of such systems which is attained at different velocities and at different structural levels. Therefore, the methods of sample preparation for testing and the conditions and duration of sample storage (i.e its prehistory) may affect the experimental results. This very circumstance may be the reason for the highly contradictory experimental data reported on the mutual solubility (compatibility) of components in polymer blends [129,162-166]. This is well illustrated by the results reported in [166] which demonstrate the inconsistency of estimation of thermodynamical compatibility by the initial transparency of *
V.N. Kuleznev proposes a rather interesting comment [161] to this and similar experiments. He believes that critical phenomena in oligomer blends can be observed in a specific structural transition within a stage of a partial layer separation of macromolecules, when double phase structure is partially formed but the interphase surface segments are still compatible. Such a combination of macromolecular incompatibility and segment interaction is an effect of intrinsic dualism of polymer molecules. Oligomers show no dualism.
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
29
films (a proven method for estimation of compatibility). This method does not include relaxation kinetics because components can be thermodynamically compatible (incompatible) at various stages of experiment. Indeed, authors report that the films of a mixture comprising 70% oligovinylmethyl ether and 30% polystyrene obtained from solution in a common solvent (further removed), were transparent (that indicates compatibility of components) for 1.5-2 months after vacuum drying performed to delete the third component (mutual solvent), but got turbid when stored (mixture components become incompatible). Similar films containing 75% ether became turbid already in 5-8 days after preparation. Since no chemical processes occurred during the storage of both compositions (as it was reported), the initial transparency of the films cannot indicate thermodynamic compatibility of components. Indeed, if the optical densities of both films are measured in the first hours or days after preparation, we may conclude that both systems are compatible. Further testing of films in 10 days, for example, shows compatibility of the first sample and incompatibility of the second one. According to measures made 2 months later both blends look incompatible. This system is in fact partially compatible. Both blends are thermodynamically incompatible within a chosen range of state parameters (oligoester concentration is 70% and 75% correspondingly) and must go through a phase separation. But the phase separation process is rather longlasting in the first case due to insufficient concentration of the low-viscous component. That is why the system is non-equilibrium at certain moments. In other words a film is transparent for some period of time (system compatibility) due to not thermodynamical but not kinetic effect. S.P. Papkov shows similar law patterns [167] for systems with liquid crystal equilibrium: the transition into equilibrium state for a system of isotropic solution, crystal solvate and liquid crystal phase is long-lasting within a certain temperature range. These examples describe low segregation at the colloidal level. Other examples [168] describe processes of long-lasting equilibration: initially turbid blends become transparent in several months or even years due to low mutual diffusion rate. Therefore, thermodynamically compatible systems [118, 129,168] were considered incompatible. The examples shown above are more or less trivial because correct conditions and modes of check experiments easily prevent possible mistakes. However, equilibration processes at supramolecular and topological levels are less demonstrative and require further investigation [169-173]. They will be discussed below. Now we take a look at kinetic aspects of an equilibrium structure formation process in liquid oligomer systems. The macroscopically closed system can be presented as a group of microscopic subsystems (or system elements) changing matter and energy with other elements and environment during equilibration. These subsystems can be not only phase inclusions but also supramolecular structures such as concentration fluctuations with various temporal and spatial parameters. Various distribution functions are postulated for liquids: numeric, size and lifetime distribution – f(n), f(r) and f(τ0) correspondingly, which are Boltzmann, Gibbs distribution functions etc. [174-176] and amendments [176-178]. Distribution functions are, anyway, subject to change during relaxation period τi between initial system state (that is usually stochastic) f0 and equilibrium state (that doesn’t depend on initial conditions) fр. It’s not always possible to calculate f0(n,r,τ0) and fр(n,r,τ0) precisely so average values n, r, τ0 are used in practice.
30
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev Relaxation rate is a function of many variables. The first one [175] is the scale factor: τi = L/νi,
(1.5)
where τi is the characteristic relaxation time, L is the linear size of a system, νi is the equilibration rate by ith parameter. Relaxation rate is evidently influenced by the system state parameters. An important factor for blends is the phase organization and viscosity of dispersion phase and dispersive media. In addition, possible mutual close- order orientation is also important for relaxation process when equilibration of non-spherical molecules is discussed. Equilibration time of a macroscopic system is usually calculated by the slowest relaxation process on a subsystem level. Let’s note another aspect which is principally important. The experimental methods used to study a system are chosen by the single fluctuation relaxation time (or its lifetime) or by the average relaxation time of all fluctuations: the value τ0 must not exceed the resolution of a method (device) t∗, and the average relaxation time τi to equilibrium is used to set exposure τe (observation time, that is a period between preparation of a sample and experimental registration of its properties) because τi must be less than τe. The low molecular weight liquid systems have very low relaxation times of concentration fluctuations to equilibrium state which are characterized by inequalities τ0 < τi and τi < τe. (Numerical evaluations and descriptions of specific cases are provided in [175,176]). Thus, fluctuation equilibration kinetics doesn’t imitate relaxation rate in a macroscopic system (possible exceptions are discussed on the basis of nonequilibrium thermodynamics [179-181]). Polymers are usually characterized by a broad range of relaxation times, some of them (the upper limit) considerably exceed (exponentially) the observation time [174], or τi >> τe. Thus we can’t get precise information on the influence of kinetics within a reasonable observation time though a polymer system doesn’t reach its equilibrium state. This problem is shown in lots of publications (see, for example [174,182-185]). However, liquid oligomers having considerably lower upper limit of relaxation times due to their molecular structure than that of polymers, but still higher than that of low-molecular liquids, may have fluctuation lifetimes and equilibration rates close to the experimental observation time: τ0 ≅ t∗, and τi ≅ τe. Therefore, more methods can be used to study oligomers correctly [186], however, on the other hand, macroscopic properties of oligomers may also depend on temporal and temperature (or generally energy) history of a system, because various initial conditions and deviations from the equilibrium state may precede registration of a certain physical property. This problem is not an exception for any oligomer blends but is a more common case for systems with a limited compatibility, which have significantly increased amplitudes and correlation radiuses of long-wave fluctuations in metastable state or around the critical point. Unfortunately, literature sources do not provide us with a common opinion (e.g., see Part VI of monograph [134]) on unambiguous experimental criteria to define whether the system is in a thermodynamical equilibrium by the time of a test. It’s not just a result of a limited methodological opportunities and incorrect interpretation of experimental results. Such a
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
31
complication is stipulated by an objective aspect of the classical expression (1.5) with νi value of equilibration rate by the ith parameter. These values (rates) can be different for various tested criteria (parameters). Therefore, thermodynamic equilibrium of a macroscopic system is an effect of local equilibration processes at a subsystem level (structural hierarchies). In other words, concentration equilibrium in a system (molecular composition equilibrium) doesn’t correspond to the equilibrium number and size and especially inner structure (topological) distributions of supramolecular structures and completion of the phase separation process with stationary concentrations in contacting phases doesn’t characterize phase solution layering because of possible further coalescence and morphology system changes. All these aspects are evidently stipulated by thermodynamical equilibration kinetics. Further information on equilibration kinetics at various structural organization levels is presented in Parts II and III of this book.
1.4.3. Methodological Aspect The variety of experimental methods used in the study of thermodynamic compatibility of blended systems is based on four principles: 1) measurement of the wave properties (optical, electronic, X-ray methods etc.) of the system, 2) determination of its sorption capacity, 3) registration of the relaxation characteristics of the blend, 4) monitoring of the “third” component (label) properties, introduced into the system. The experimental methods can be also divided into four groups by their instrumentation, correspondingly [40,129,133,134,142,146,183-190]. Each method within a given group has its own advantages and disadvantages. For example, measurements of the optical density (light scattering, refraction, transmission etc.) of liquid systems cannot in principle provide information about particles less than <1000 А°, even if they are present in the system, the small-angle X-ray scattering cannot “see” particles greater than >1000 А°. According to the laws of optics we cannot differentiate between phase formations if the dispersion media and the disperse phase have close refraction factors. Therefore, even obviously heterogeneous systems may appear transparent in optical experiments. In addition, inclination of molecules to aggregation (formation of supramolecular heterogeneities) exerts a significant influence on a mutual solubility of components [191]. It is important to take all the characteristic structural parameters of molecular heterogeneities into account during the experiment. A typical mistake to be noted was apparently found for the first time by V.N. Kuleznev [118]. It is particularly often found in research which uses optical microscopy to estimate compatibility. Some authors describe any heterogeneity under microscope as an effect of phase formation. It’s not always like that. Any heterogeneity that the microscope’s lens reveals (even when artefacts are excluded) cannot prove that the second phase exists. The fact is: a single-phase blend can be heterogeneous and the size of some globular macromolecules (associates, concentration and density fluctuations), low molecular weight and oligomer molecules can be compared with the resolution of an instrument. These structures studied at the microscopic level can be erroneously considered heterophase particles. The fact is that thermodynamical properties of these heterogeneities, even interfaced, depend on quantity of a
32
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
matter in the system and according to Gibbs phase definition these systems cannot be in the thermodynamical phase. An objective restriction for dynamic methods is the impossibility to estimate system phase structure in a broad temperature range: All the temperature transitions that these methods detect correspond to the structure of a sample formed in certain preparation conditions and “fixed” by freezing. Let’s note here that obtaining of contradictory experimental data by various scientists may also be stipulated by different “resolution” of methods defined by sample preparation methods. A systematic research [142] is an examplary case here, as it offers various methods to study compatibility in a certain blend: dynamic mechanical spectroscopy, young modulus and elasticity modulus temperature functions change, dielectric loss method and thermo optical characteristics. The results obtained by the various methods proved to correspond to different phase organizations (thermodynamically compatible or incompatible system or a system with limited compatibility). Indeed, according to certain methods the glass temperature Тс, had a single value equal to the average Тс of components, that is typical for a homogeneous system. Other methods registered two values of Тс similar to Тс of individual components, that is, a property of a system with incompatible components. And one of the methods has shown three peaks on a curve (one average and two individual values), thus demonstrating limited compatibility of a system. A system with limited compatibility can obviously be in single-phase or two-phase states depending on state parameters (thermodynamics) and its history (kinetics), so methods with various preparation techniques will register different states of this system. But a system cannot have both compatible and incompatible components as some authors [142] reasonably note. This problem is well prevented by a critical attitude to methods and correct analysis of experimental data. It is relevant to mention here the following note of A.E. Chalykh [134]: “the main contradictions in presentation of results* root in not their experimental background but interpretation and a strange desire of scientists to abstract from data obtained by other researches. The fact of contradictory experimental data is illusive and reflects the complexity of the studied systems”. It is essential that the relaxation rate is less than scanning rate by temperature when dynamic methods are used to estimate compatibility. The main obstacle in the study of critical phenomena in low molecular weight liquids was the difficulty to achieve a small ΔТ during experiment [175,192]. Finally, it was mentioned before that a correct experiment is possible only with τ0>t∗. G.V. Korolev [190] has estimated relaxation characteristics of various oligomer liquids (oligomers with different functional groups and capable of intermolecular interactions) with regard to lifetimes of forming associates τа. Having compared them with the resolution of t∗ various research methods lets us estimate in the first approximation applicability of specific methods for analysis of specific systems (see also Part 2.5).
*
Phase equilibrium data.
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
33
1.4.4. Colloidal Aspect In considering the process of cellulose acetate dissolution in chloroform during experimental investigation of polymer dissolution in low-molecular solvents, Papkov et al. [126] were the first to distinguish several states of the phase structure formation in polymer systems with limited compatibility and some low-molecular blends. The solution was transparent at the selected initial temperature and concentration. However, if the temperature goes below the critical point (its position depends on concentration) the system shows turbidity: phase disintegration (transition, separation) occurs. In this case an emulsion is formed. It is characterized by the number and size distribution of constituent particles which depends on phase separation mechanism, temperature decrease rate and etc. Then the system morphology starts to change. The same phase particles gradually aggregate, which finally leads to formation of two transparent layers: cellulose solution in chloroform (upper layer) and chloroform solution in a polymer (lower layer). This process is called phase layering. Later on, similar observation results were obtained for many polymer and oligomer systems [168]. The recent decades provided a successful solution for such theoretical problems as phase formation in polymer systems, formation of their disperse structure, phase layering and etc. These results have formed a subject of an independent science that is colloidal chemistry of polymers [109]. Colloidal chemistry can be used for the following processes in oligomer systems: а) formation of a heterogeneous structure during chemical curing of oligomers, b) formation of a heterogeneous structure in source oligomers. The first one goes beyond the subject of this book, the second one will be discussed in Part III of this monograph. Note here that oligomer systems are more complicated than polymer-polymer blends with a constant morphology of samples from the moment of their preparation. For example, the history of a sample has almost no effect on morphology [193,194] of heterogeneous polymer-oligomer systems with a dispersive media viscosity 8 - 10 decimal exponents lower than the dispersion phase – this effect is similar to properties of polymer-polymer blends. But during the phase inversion, when the low-viscous (in comparison with dispersion phase) polymer solution in oligomer becomes a dispersive media, the phase layering time decreases to the object observation time [195]. This effect must be considered when dealing with material science problems. The initial oligomer system morphology before curing has a direct impact on the structure of a polymer formed of cured oligomer blends [125, 196], so the morphology parameters are, therefore, of primary importance by the time of the chemical reaction activation mechanism initiation. This aspect is very important both for oligomer-oligomer and oligomer-polymer blends, which are characterized by morphologically unstable evolution in time. Both the phase layering rate and form of disperse particles distribution function evidently depend on various factors: the initial size of emulsion droplets, dispersive media viscosity, surface tension, presence of surfactants and etc. [109,118,125,168,197,198]. Unfortunately, these important problems of colloid chemistry stay entirely unapplied to reactive oligomer systems (see also Part 3.3).
34
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
1.4.5. Compatibility and Phase Equilibrium In the “Encyclopedia of Polymers” the “compatibility of polymers” is determined as “a term that is commonly accepted in technological practice, which characterizes the ability of various polymers to form mixtures possessing satisfactory properties” [199]. Similar definitions are also given in some other monographs (see, for example, [118,119,200]). We will not stress the fact, that these definitions are formed conventionally, and just note that they can’t be used for oligomer systems because oligomers are used as materials not at their initial state but after certain transformations, so such characteristics as “satisfactory mechanic properties” is unacceptable here. The compatibility of oligomer systems, according to Krauze [129], is their ability to molecularly disperse on after contact that is formation of true solutions or, in other words, mixing at a molecular level. The mutual solubility of components is defined by thermodynamic constants and system state parameters. This characteristic is called * thermodynamical compatibility . There are thermodynamically compatible and incompatible systems and systems with limited compatibility. Systems are compatible if their components form solutions (components are dispersed at the molecular level) within a total concentration (0<С<100%) and mixing temperature**) range, that is, they have unlimited solubility. They are single-phase systems at any ratio of components. Solutions in these blends can, however, include various heterogeneities (deviations from ideal state that are represented by associates on a supramolecular level). If system components are totally insoluble and even do not swell (that is an exceptional case for oligomers), such systems are considered incompatible. Forced mixing of oligomers leads in this case to formation of heterogeneous (colloid) systems with every phase as an individual component. The dispersity in these heterogeneous systems is a function of many factors and, first of all, of the energy “injected” into a system. At last, there are systems with a pair of components in equilibrium which can be either compatible or form colloidal mixtures (emulsions, suspensions) of solutions with different concentration of initial components depending on temperature, pressure and the ratio of components. They are systems with limited compatibility components or, in other words, restricted compatible systems. The lion share of oligomer systems falls into this category. Components of systems with limited compatibility form true solutions within a certain range of concentrations and temperatures. When their dosage is beyond the limits of mutual solubility, colloidal systems of coexisting disperse phases are formed, where each phase is a solution. One of the components is in “excess” in the first phase and in “shortage” in another *
A certain period in polymer publications has been studied, when such characterizations as “technological”, “operational”, “mechanic”, “forced”, “segmental” etc. were added to the term “compatibility” to describe properties of thermodynamically incompatible polymers or polymers with a limited compatibility. In our opinion this differentiation doesn’t have a reasonable physical meaning. This problem has more than once been referred to in publications (see, for example [109,163]). Application of these “amendments” could be stipulated by kinetic aspects ignored during analysis of mixing and phase separation processes in polymer blends and failed attempts to provide “scientific” base under practical preparation methods of polymer blends with “satisfactory (?) properties”. ** This is a temperature range corresponding to practical storage, test and processing temperatures of oligomers. Such an interpretation is initially uncertain. First, these temperatures can differ by tens or hundreds degrees and be lower than glass or crystallization temperatures. Secondly, even single-component systems will have inevitable phase transition within a broad temperature range.
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
35
one. Equilibrium concentrations of components in coexisting phases, which are identical to mutual solubility boundaries, can be found on the phase state diagram. Each solution in coexisting phases has a unique degree of deviation from ideal state i.e. has its own level of supramolecular ordering. The presence of heterogeneities in solutions does not mean that these solutions are in heterogeneous state after the second or even the first order phase transition. It doesn’t even stand for microphase separation, as it sometimes stated. Let’s not discuss other opinions [109] and just note that a phase is by the classical Gibbs definition [201] “a combination of homogeneous system components with the same composition, physical and chemical properties, that doesn‘t depend on a quantity of matter and has an interface separating it from other system parts”. Even if we take into account the amendment by A.V. Rakovskiy [26], that led to subdivision of thermodynamic variables into “field” and “density” [202] types and states that “the physical properties are thermodynamical if they can be described by state parameter functions (volume, pressure, temperature and concentration functions) and by them only”, we’ll see that a phase still has two essential features: a) its properties do not depend on the quantity of matter in a phase (or the ratio of components) and b) presence of interface. According to Gibbs, only a combination of these features is the necessary and sufficient condition for the existence of a phase. These features only simultaneously combined can mean that the thermodynamic phase is formed instead of other heterogeneous liquids. That is why various supramolecular heterogeneities in oligomer liquids such as aggregates, associates or cybotactic groups are not “microfhases”. The term “micro” can be used here, but the term “phase” in inapplicable on the basis of Gibbs approximation. The compatibility of oligomers has been subject to investigation for more than 60 years, but it got a kind of a systematized research only in recent decades [129,133-135,165,203207]. Complete phase diagrams and experimental temperature and concentration dependencies for χ12, ΔН1, Δμ1 and other thermodynamic parameters for a broad range of oligomer systems were obtained only in recent years. The majority of them are systematized in the monograph [134]. Literature sources provide few examples of single-phase oligomer systems with unlimited compatibility of components within real processing temperature range. The examples include oligomer - monomer systems (for example oligoestermaleinefumarate - styrene, epoxyglycedyle ester – amine and oligodiol – castor oil blends etc.), oligomer - oligomer systems (for example, oligobutadieneurethanemetacrylate - n-methylene-dimetacrylate blends within n = 1-10, various molecular weight oligoesterepoxyde blends (340 - 7150), oligoesterdieneisocyanate – oligoglycole blends etc.) and even polymer - oligomer systems (butadiene-nitrile rubber - trioxyethylenedimetacrylate). The majority of oligomer blends are systems with limited compatibility, i.e. forming true solutions within a limited range of concentrations and test temperatures. Phase state diagrams provide quantitative information on the limits of mutual solubility of components [60,82,118,129,134,165,170,206-214]. The experimental phase diagrams of oligomer systems will be discussed in the third part of this book. This part of the monograph has its own tasks so we’ll concentrate on some general statements necessary for a logical representation of the data below. Figure 1.5 illustrates conditional phase state diagram in temperature (Т) – oligomer dosage (С) coordinates that is a generalization of experimental phase diagrams known for various oligomer systems [134,170,208-214]. The areas I and II of a single-phase system state
36
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
in Figure 1.5 are limited by binodal (solid curve). The area between binodal and spinodal (dashed curve) corresponds to the metastable system state (III). The area under spinodal is a two-phase system state (V). Single-phase and two-phase states of a system are stable, so no phase transitions occur within С and Т limiting areas I, II and V when state parameters vary. A characteristic feature of a system in metastable state [89] is that even infinitesimal change of state parameters (ΔТ and ΔС) leads to the phase transition and moves this system into one of stable areas, i.e. when ΔТ and ΔС ≠ 0 the metastable system becomes either single-phase or two-phase and stable. The structure of a solution in the metastable state around the critical point (area IV in Figure 1.5) has much denser fluctuation concentrations with larger correlation radius and lifetimes than in other states.
Figure 1.5. Conditional phase diagram of oligomer blended system and the chart of structure of solutions with shortage (I) and exceed (II) of oligomer before (I – II) and after (II – I) phase inversion point. III – metastable area, IV – area of UCST, V – two-phase state area; ω’b and ω”b – oligomer concentrations on the left and right branches of a binodal, ω’s - oligomer concentration on the left branch of a spinodal Т=Т1; С1 – oligomer dosage; Сi – oligomer dosage at the phase inversion point. •schematic presentation of an oligomer molecule; │ - schematic presentation of an polymer molecule
Oligomer systems are typically described by phase diagrams of an amorphous equilibrium according to classification by S.P. Papkov [168,206]. Sometimes amorphouscrystalline equilibrium [134,165] is observed [134,165]. The majority of oligomer system phase diagrams is asymmetric and has upper critical solubility temperature* (UCST). *
There are some unique systems, such as oligopropyleneglycole and oligoethyleneglycoleadipinate blends with both upper and lower critical temperatures registered [215].
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
37
The first one is stipulated by the fact that oligomer solubility limit in the second component in the area I (this component can be a monomer, oligomer or polymer) is far beyond the equilibrium concentration of the second component in oligomer (area II). This, in turn, explains merging of right bimodal and spinodal branches for some oligomer systems, i.e. oligomer concentrations in the oligomer excess area (the right part of the phase diagram) on binodal and spinodal are quite similar: ω”B ≈ ω”С. The existence of the upper critical layering temperature leads to permanent increase of mutual solubility of components with growth of temperature. As Figure 1.5 shows, a system remains a single-phase one within oligomer concentration С ≤ ω’B where ω’B is an oligomer concentration corresponding to the Т1 point at the left branch of a binodal at the conventionally chosen temperature Т1 = Const (it can be a blend storage temperature for example). An oligomer solution is formed in a second blend component at this point (these solutions are also called oligomer - weakened). If an oligomer dosage С ≥ ω”B, where ω”B, is an oligomer concentration at Т1 corresponding to a point at the right branch of a bimodal, the system is also a single-phase one, but this solution is enriched with oligomer, thus it is a solution of the second component in oligomer. The increase of oligomer dosage: С > ω’B moves the system into a metastable area which ends at С = ω’С, that corresponds to oligomer concentration at the left branch of a spinodal Т1. Further increase of concentration: С > ω’С leads to phase separation and formation of a two-phase system. Let’s note again that these phases are not individual components according to some publications. This system is formed by interfaced solutions of one component into another with oligomer concentration varying significantly. In this case a blend of two true solutions is formed within ω’С ≤ С ≤ ω”С. These solutions are: a) solution I with oligomer concentration ω’B and b) solution II with oligomer concentration ω”B. Let’s pay attention to another important detail. The oligomer dosage С always corresponds to its concentration in single-phase systems in weight (ω), volume (φ) or molar (ν) parts, and weight concentration ω increases when the С dosage grows. However, the concentration of an oligomer in components of two- phase systems is always constant when Т = const and has a value ω’B and ω”B, correspondingly. Increase of the total oligomer content in the blend within ω’С ≤ С ≤ ω”С and Т = const doesn’t lead to any changes of phase solution concentrations, but changes the volume ratio of dispersion and dispersive phases, which is in fact a phase inversion. This process is shown in the upper section of Figure 1.5. As we can see, at С < Сi , where Сi is the dosage of oligomer in the inversion point, the dispersive phase is solution I, while at С > Сi the dispersive phase is solution II.
CONCLUSION The criteria setting the boundaries of oligomeric state in homologous rows of organic substances has been proposed. The “monomer – oligomer transition” occurs through the longrange intramolecular interaction of constituent monomer units at the threshold chain length (the lower boundary). Longer chain obtains coil conformation at some length according to laws of statistics. This is the upper boundary for an oligomeric state. The statistics of
38
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
oligomers differs from the Gauss statistics. Oligomers prove to be a special condensed state of substance with specific properties.
REFERENCES [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11]
[12] [13] [14]
[15] [16] [17] [18] [19]
[20]
Oligomery // Ehnciklopedija Polimerov (Encyclopedia of Polymers).- M.: Sov. Ehnciklopedija, 1974, V. 2, P. 458 (in Russian). Helferich, B., Bohn, E., Winkler, S. // Berichte. 1930. Bd.63. S. 989 Oligomer // Kratkaja Khimicheskaja Ehnciklopedija (Brief Chemical Encyclopedia). M.: Sov. Ehnciklopedija, 1964, V. 3, P. 725 (in Russian). Uglea, C.V., Negulescu, I.I. Syntetic Oligomers. - Florida: CRC Press, 1989. Uglea C.V. Oligomer Technology and Application. - N.-Y.: Marcel Dekker, 1999. Van Der Want, G.M., Stavarman A.J. // Rec. Trav. Chim. Pays-Bas., 1952. V.71. P. 379. Zahn, H., et al. // Angew. Chem. 1956. Bd. 68. S.299; 1963. Bd. 75. S. 772. Kern, W. // Macromol. Chem. 1960. Vol. 38. P. 1; Cem.- Ztg. 1962. Bd.76. S.667. Tsuchia, E., Shinohara, I. // J. Soc. Org. Chem. Jap., 1964. N. 1. P. 14. Berlin, A.A. // Khim. Prom-St'. 1960. № 2. P.14. Lipatov, Ju. S. // Dokl. i Vsesojuznojj Konf. po Khimii i Fiziko-Khimii Polimerizacionnosposobnykh Oligomerov (Papers of All—Union Conference on Chemistry and Physical Chemistry of Oligomers). Chernogolovka: IHF RAN, 1977, V.1, P. 59 (in Russian). Ehpoksidnye Smoly (Epoxy Resins). // Spravochnik po Plasticheskim Massam (Plastic Masses Handbook). - M.: Khimija, 1969, V. 2, P. 53 (in Russian). Ehntelis S.G., Evreinov V.V., Kuzaev A.I. Reakcionnosposobnye Oligomery (Reactive Oligomers). M.: Khimija,1985 (in Russian). Kazanskijjm K.S., Rakovam G.V., Dubrovskijjm S.A. i Dr. Osobennosti Struktury Gidrogelejj, Obrazujushhikhsja Pri Trekhmernojj Radikal'nojj Polimerizacii Makromonomerov Poliehtilenoksida (Specifics of The Structure of Hydrogels, forming at Three-Dimensional Radical Polymerization of Polyethyleneoxide Macromonomers). Chernogolovka: Ikhf RAN, 1997 (in Russian). Berlin, A.A., Kefeli, T .Ja., Korolev, G.V. Poliehfirakrilaty. M.: Nauka, 1967. Mezhikovskijj, S.M. Fizikokhimija Reakcionnosposobnykh Oligomerov (Physical Chemistry of Reactive Oligomers). M.: Nauka, 1998 (in Russian). Mezhikovskii, S.M. Physico-Chemical Principles for Processing of Oligomeric Blends. - N.-Y.: Gordon & Breach, 1998. Gol'danskijj, V.G. i Dr. // Fizicheskaja Khimija: Sovrem. Probl (Physical Chemistry: Modern Problems). - M.:Khimija, 1988. S. 198 (in Russian). Artjukhov, V.G. i Dr. Oligomernye Belki: Strukturno-Funkcional'nye Modifikacii i Rol' Sub''edinichnykh Kontaktov (Oligomeric Proteins: Structural and Functional Modifications and The Role of Subunit Contacts). - Voronezh: VGU, 1997 (in Russian). Foks, R. Ehnergija i Ehvoljucija Zhizni Na Zemle (Energy and The Evolution of Life on Earth). - M.: Mir, 1992 (in Russian).
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
39
[21] Shinokhara, I. // Sehkju Toksiju Kogaku. 1971. T. 15. №5.S.353. Esikhasi S. // Kobunsi Kako. 1975. T. 14. №1. S. 12. [22] Bresler, S.E., B.L.Erusalimskijj. Fizika i Khimija Makromolekul (The Physics and Chemistry of Macromolecules).- M. – L.: Nauka, 1965 (in Russian). [23] Tolkovyjj Slovar' Russkogo Jazyka Pod Red. D.N. Ushakova (The Reference Dictionary of Russian Language Under The Editorship of D.N. Ushakov). - M.: GIINS, 1939, T. 3, S.962 (in Russian). [24] Osnovnye Opredelenija Terminov, Otnosjashhikhsja K Polimeram (The Main Definitions in Polymer Science) // Vysokomolek. Soed. 1978. T. 20A, №5. S.1167; // Pure and Fhll. Chem. 1974. Vol. 40. № 3. P. 531 (in Russian). [25] Berlin, A.A. // Dokl. i Vsesojuznojj Konf. po Khimii i Fiziko-Khimii Polimerizacionnosposobnykh Oligomerov (Reports of The All – Union Conference on Physical Chemistry of Polymerizing Oligomers). Chernogolovka: Ikhf RAN, 1977, T.1, S. 8 (in Russian). [26] Rakovskijj, A.V., Vvedenie, V. Fizicheskuju Khimiju (introduction To The Physical Chemistry). - M.: ONTI, 1938 (in Russian). [27] Melvin-Kh'juz Eh.A. Fizicheskaja Khimija. - M.: IIL, 1962. VT.1. [28] G.V. Korolev i A.A.Il'in «Sistemy Mezhmolekuljarnykh Vzaimodejjstvijj V Organicheskikh Zhidkostjakh Kak Modeli Fizicheskikh Setok V Zhidkikh Oligomerakh» (Systems of intermolecular interactions in Organic Liquids As Models of Physical Nets in Liquid Oligomers). - Chernogolovka: Ikhfch RAN, 1997, 27 P. (in Russian). [29] Mark, G., Flory, P. // J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1966, V.88. P. 3072. [30] Patrikeev, G.A. // DAN SSSR. 1975. V. 221. № 4. P. 134. [31] Vajjnshtejjn Eh.F. // DAN SSSR. 1976. V. 229. № 5. P. 336. [32] Vinogradov, G.V., Malkin, A. Ja. Reologija Polimerov (Rheology of Polymers). - M.: Khimija, 1977 (in Russian). [33] Chalykh, A.E., Diffuzija, V. Polimernykh Sistemakh (Diffusion in Polymer Systems). M.: Khimija, 1977 (in Russian). [34] Sotobayashi, H., Springer, I..// J High Polym. Japan. 1961. V.15. P. 478. [35] Zahn, H., Dominik, M. // Makromol. Chem. 1967. V. 44–46. P. 290. [36] Flori, P. Statisticheskaja Mekhanika Cepnykh Molekul (The Statistical Mechanics of Chain Molecules). - M.: Mir, 1971 (in Russian). [37] Kataoka, T., Ueda, S. // J. Polymer Sci. 1966, B. V.4. № 5. P. 317. [38] Bueche, F. // J Chem. Phys. 1952. V.20. № 12. P. 1959; 1956. V.25, № 3. P.599. [39] Privalko V.P. Molekuljarnoe Stroenie i Svojjstva Polimerov (Molecular Structure and Properties of Polymers). – L.: Khimija, 1986 (in Russian). [40] Godovskijj Ju. K. Teplofizicheskie Metody Issledovanija Polimerov (Thermophysical Research Methods for Polymers). – M.: Khimija, 1976 (in Russian). [41] Hansen D., Ho C.C. // J. Polym. Sci. 1965. A. V.3. P. 659. [42] Lohe P. // Koll.-Z. U. Z. Polymer. 1965. Bd. 204. S. 7. [43] Mezhikovskijj S.M., Arinshtejjn A.Eh. // Sb. Statejj «Polimery 2000» (Book of Articles „Polymers 2000“). – M.: Ikhf RAN, 2000. V. 1. P. 102 (in Russian). [44] Grosberg A.Ju., Khokhlov A.R. Statisticheskaja Fizika Makromolekul (Statistical Physics of Macromolecules). - M.: Nauka. 1989 (in Russian).
40
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
[45] Arinshtejjn A.Eh., Manevich L.I., Mezhikovskijj S.M. Statistika Oligomernojj Cepi V Zavisimosti Ot Ee Dliny, Zhestkosti i Temperatury (The Statistics of Oligomer Chain Depending on Its Length, Rigidity and Temperature). – Chernogolovka: Ikhf RAN, 1997 (in Russian). [46] Arinshtejjn A.Eh. Lokal'nye Svojjstva Sistem, Sostojashhikh Iz Makromolekul Konechnojj Dliny i Zhestkosti (Local Properties of Systems of Macromolecules With Finite Length and Rigidity). – Chernogolovka: Ipkhf RAN, 2002 (in Russian). [47] Arinshtein, S. Mezhikovskii. // inter. Conf. Colloid Chem. and Physical-Chemical Mechanics. Oral and Poster Presentatiens Abstracs. 1998. P. 362, PF1. [48] S.M. Mezhikovskijj. // Sinteticheskie Oligomery (Synthetic Oligomers). -Perm': AN SSSR, 1988, P.5 (in Russian). [49] S.M. Mezhikovskijj. Oligomery (Oligomers).- M.: Znanie, 1983 (in Russian). [50] V.I.Irzhak, B.A.Rozenberg, N.S.Enikolopov. Setchatye Polimery (Network Polymers). - M.: Nauka, 1979 (in Russian). [51] “Polikondensacija”. “Polimerizacija” (“Polycondensation”. “Polymerization”) // Ehnciklopedija Polimerov (Polymer Encyclopedia). - M.: Sov. Ehnciklopedija, 1974, V. 2, P. 856; P.883 (in Russian). [52] Berlin. A.A. // Usp. Khimii, 1975, V.44, No 3, P. 502. [53] Zapadinskijj B.I. ,.Liogon'kijj B.I. // Dokl. i Vsesojuzn. Konf. po Khimii i Fizikokhimii Polimerizacionnosposobnykh Oligomerov (Reports of i All-Union Conference on The Chemistry and Physical Chemistry of Oligomers).- Chernogolovka: AN SSSR, 1977, V.2, P. 340 (in Russian). [54] Zapadinskijj B.I. Osnovnye Napravlenija Sinteza Termostojjkikh Polimerov Oligomernym Metodom (The Main Trends in Synthesis of Thermal-Resistant Polymers By Oligomer Method). - Chernogolovka: AN SSSR, 1990 (in Russian). [55] Zapadinskijj B.I. // Al'fred Anisimovich Berlin. Izbrannye Trudy. Vospominanija Sovremennikov (Selected Publications. Reminiscences of Contemporaries). – M.: Nauka, 2002, S. 200 (in Russian). [56] K.A. andrianov, A.B. Zachernjuk. // Dokl. i Vsesojuzn. Konf. po Khimii i Fizikokhimii Polimerizacionnosposobnykh Oligomerov (Reports of i All-Union Conference on The Chemistry and Physical Chemistry of Polymerizing Oligomers).- Chernogolovka: AN SSSR, 1977, T.2, S. 258 (in Russian). [57] M.V. Sobolevskijj, I.I. Skorokhodov. Oligoorganosiloksany (Oligoorganosiloxanes).M.: Khimija, 1985 (in Russian). [58] G.V. Bening. Nenasyshhennye Poliehfiry (Unsaturetad Polyesters). - M.: Khimija, 1968 (in Russian). [59] L.N. Sedov, Z.V.Mikhajjlova. Nenasyshhennye Poliehfiry (Unsaturetad Polyesters). M.: Khimija, 1977 (in Russian). [60] S.I. Omel'chenko. Slozhnye Oligoehfiry i Polimery Na Ikh Osnove (Complex Oligoesters and Polymers Based on Them). - Kiev: Nauk. Dumka, 1976 (in Russian). [61] Kh. Li, K. Nevill. Spravochnoe Rukovodstvo po Ehpoksidnym Smolam (Handbook on Epoxy Resins). - M.: Ehnergija, 1973 (in Russian). [62] I.Z. Chernin, F.M. Smekhov, Ju. V. Zherdev. Ehpoksidnye Polimery i Kompozicii (Epoxy Polymers and Compositions). - M.: Khimija, 1982 (in Russian). [63] Dzh. Kh. Saunders, K.K. Frish. Khimija Poliuretanov (Chemistry of Polyurethanes).M.: Khimija, 1968 (in Russian).
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
41
[64] P. Rajjt, A. Kamming. Poliuretanovye Oligomery (Polyurethane Oligomers).- L.: Khimija, 1973 (in Russian). [65] Ju. Ju. Kercha. Fizicheskaja Khimija Poliuretanov (Physocal Chemistry of Polyurethanes).- Kiev: Nauk. Dumka, 1979 (in Russian). [66] R.W. Martin. The Chemistry of Phenolic Resins.-N-Y - L., 1956 [67] B.G. Zadoncev. Ehpoksiakrilaty. Sintez, Svojjstva, Primenenie (Epoxyacrylates. Synthesis. Properties. Appliocation) - Chernogolovka: AN SSSR, 1990 (in Russian). [68] I.K. Churakova, S.M. Mezhikovskijj. Osnovnye Napravlenija Proizvodstva Oligomerov Dlja Khimicheskogo formovanija (The Main Trends in Production of Oligomers for Chemical forming). - M.: Niitehchim, 1981 (in Russian). [69] Ju. M. Sivergin, R. Ja. Pernikis, S.M. Kireeva. Polikarbonat(Met-) Akrilaty (Polycarbonate(Met)-Acrylates) - Riga: Zinatne, 1988 (in Russian). [70] Mogilevich M.M., Turov B.S., Morozov Ju.L., Ustavshhikov B.F. Zhidkie Uglevodorodnye Kauchuki (Liquid Hydrocarbon Rubbers). – M.: Khimija, 1983 (in Russian). [71] S.S. Ivanchev. // Dokl. i Vsesojuzn. Konf. po Khimii i Fizikokhimii Polimerizacionnosposobnykh Oligomerov (Reports of i All-Union Conference on The Chemistry and Physical Chemistry of Polymerizing Oligomers).- Chernogolovka: AN SSSR, 1977, V.2, P. 314 (in Russian). [72] S.A. Voronov, V.S. Tokarev, Ju. A. Lastukhin. Geterofunkcional'nye Oligoperoksidy (Heterofunctional Oligoperoxides). - Chernogolovka: AN SSSR, 1990 (in Russian). [73] B.G. Zadoncev, B.I. Zapadinskijj, S.M. Mezhikovskijj. // Plast. Massy (Plastics), 1984, No 5, P. 18 (in Russian). [74] V.S. Minkin, R. Ja. Deberdeev, F.M. Paljutin, Ju. N. Khakimullin. Promyshlennye Polisul'fidnye Oligomery: Sintez, Vulkanizacija, Modifikacija (industrial Polysulphide Oligomers: Synthesis, Vulcanization, Modification). – Kazan': «Novoe Znanie», 2004 (in Russian). [75] A.P. Sineokov. Polifunkcional'nye (Met-) Akrilovye Monomery. Sostojanie i Perspektivy Razvitija (Polyfunctional (Met-) Acryl Monomers. The Present Situation and Trends of Development). - Chernogolovka: Oikhf AN SSSR, 1990 (in Russian). [76] S.G. Ehntelis, V.V. Evreinov, A.I.Kuzaev. // Usp. Khimii i Fiziki Polimerov. -M.: Khimija, 1973, S. 201. [77] A.A. Berlin, G.V. Korolev, T. Ja. Kefeli, Ju. M. Sivergin. Akrilovye Oligomery i Materialy Na Ikh Osnove (Acrylic Oligomers and Related Materials). -M.: Khimija, 1983 (in Russian). [78] Korolev G.V. // Al'fred Anisimovich Berlin. Izbrannye Trudy. Vospominanija Sovremennikov (Selected Publication. Reminiscences of Contemporaries). – M.: Nauka, 2002, P.241 (in Russian). [79] Reaction injection Molding and Fast Polymerization Reaction. Ed. By J.E.Kresta. N.Y.: Plenum Hress, 1982 [80] Reaction injection Molding. Ed. By J.E.Kresta. Washington: ACS, 1985. [81] Morozov Ju. L. // Doklady i Vsesojuznojj Konferencii po Khimii i Fizikokhimii Polimerizacionnosposobnykh Oligomerov (Reports of i All-Union Conference on The Chemistry and Physical Chemistry of Polymerizing Oligomers).- Chernogolovka: AN SSSR, 1977, V.2, P. 468 (in Russian).
42
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
[82] Ljubartovich S.A,. Morozov Ju. L, Tret'jakov O.B. Reakcionnoe formovanie Poliuretanov (Reactive forming of Polyurethanes). – M.: Khimija, 1990 (in Russian). [83] Malkin A.Ja., Begishev V.P. Khimicheskoe formovanie Polimerov (Chemical forming of Polyurethanes). - M.: Khimija, 1991(in Russian). [84] T.N. Smirnova. // Khim. Prom. Za Rubezhom (Chemical industry Abroad). -M.: Niitechhim, 1985, No 5, S. 64 (in Russian). [85] I.K. Churakova, S.M. Mezhikovskijj. -Khimicheskoe formovanie Oligomerov i Monomerov V SSSR i za Rubezhom (Chemical Phorming of Oligomers and Polymers in USSR and Abroad). -M.: Niitechhim, 1979 (in Russian). [86] Ju. S. Lipatov, L.M. Sergeeva. Vzaimopronikajushhie Polimernye Setki (interpenetrating Polymer Networks). - Kiev: Nauk. Dumka, 1979 (in Russian). [87] L. Sperling. Vzaimopronikajushhie Polimernye Setki i Analogichnye Materialy (Interpenetrating Polymer Networks) and Similar Materials. -M.: Mir, 1984 (in Russian). [88] Ju. S. Lipatov, T.T. Alekseeva. Osobennosti Khimicheskojj Kinetiki formirovanija Vzaimopronikajushhikh Setok (Peculiarities of The Chemical forming Kinetics of Interpenetrating Oligomer Networks). -Chernogolovka: Oikhf AN SSSR, 1990 (in Russian). [89] Alekseeva T.T. Dissert…. Dokt. Khim. Nauk. Ikhvs NANU, Kiev, 2001. [90] Lipatov Yu. Phase-Separated interpenetrating Polymer Networks. – Dnepropetrovsk: Uschtu, 2001. [91] Morozov Ju. L. Fizikokhimija Processov Pererabotki Reakcionnosposobnykh Oligomerov V Ehlastomernye Izdelija (Physical Chemistry ofprocessing Processes of Reactive Oligomers into Elastomer Products. - Chernogolovka: Oikhf AN SSSR, 1986 (in Russian). [92] R. Sh. Frenkel', V.I.Panchenko. Modifikacija Rezin Oligoehfirakrilatami (Modification of Rubbers By Oligoesteracrylates).- M.: Cniitehneftekhim, 1981 (in Russian). [93] B.P. Shtarkman. Plastifikacija Polivinilkhlorida (Plastification of Polyvynilchloride). M.: Khimija, 1975 (in Russian). [94] P.V. Kozlov, S.P. Papkov. Fiziko-Khimicheskie Osnovy Plastifikacii Polimerov (Physico-Chemical Basis of Plastification of Polymers). -M.: Khimija, 1982 (in Russian). [95] V.G. Khosin, A.G. Farakhov, V.A. Voskresenskii. // Acta Polymerica, 1983, № 8, S. 508. [96] R.S. Barshtejjn, V.I. Kirilovich, Ju. E. Nosovskijj.- Plastifikatory Dlja Polimerov (Plastification for Polymers) - M.: Khimija, 1982 (in Russian). [97] Khimicheskie Dobavki K Polimeram. Spravochnik (Chemical Addings To Polymers. Handbook). – M.: Khimija, 1973 (in Russian). [98] P.A. Rebinder. Fiziko-Khimicheskaja Mekhanika (Physicochemical Mechanics). - M.: Nauka, 1979 (in Russian). [99] A.A. Doncov, A.A. Kanauzova, T.V. Litvinova. Kauchuk -Oligomernye Kompozicii (Rubber – Oligomer Compositions). -M.: Khimija, 1986 (in Russian). [100] A.A. Berlin, S.M. Mezhikovskijj. // Zhvkho Im. D.I.Mendeleeva, 1975, No 5, P.531. [101] Berlin, S. Mezhikovskii. // Ideen Des Exakten Wissen, 1973, No 10, S.627. [102] S.M. Mezhikovskijj. Polimer-Oligomernye Kompozity (Polymer - Oligomer Composites). - M.: Znanie, 1989 (in Russian).
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
43
[103] Berlin. // Plaste U Kautschuk, 1973, No 10, S. 728. [104] A.G. Shvarc, B.N.Dinzburg. Sovmeshhenie Kauchukov s Plastikami i Sinteticheskimi Smolami (Combination of Rubbers With Plastics and Synthetic Resins). -M.: Khimija, 1972 (in Russian). [105] Berlin, S. Mezhikovskii. // Pure Apll. Chem., 1979, V. 51, P. 2345. [106] B.G. Zadoncev, S.A. Jaroshevskijj, S.M.Mezhikovskijj. // Plast. Massy, 1984, № 5, P. 9. [107] A.S. Kuz'minskijj, A.A. Berlin, S.N. Arkina. // Usp. Khimii i Fiziki Polimerov. (Advances ob chemistry and physics of polymers) M.: Khimija, 1973, P. 239 (In Russian). [108] B.G. Zadoncev, Ju. S. Zajjcev, S.A. Jaroshevskijj. Fiziko-Khimicheskie Osnovy Mterialovedenija Polimer-Oligomernykh Kompozitov (Physico-Chemical Basis of Material Science of Polymer – Oligomer Composites).- Chernogolovka: AN SSSR, 1986 (in Russian). [109] Ju. S. Lipatov. Kolloidnaja Khimija Polimerov (Colloid Chemistry of Polymers). Kiev: Nauk. Dumka, 1984 (in Russian). [110] “Kolloidnye Polimernye Sistemy”. // Ehnciklopedija Polimerov (Colloid Polymer Systems. // Polymer Encyclopedia), M.: Sov. Ehnciklopedija, 1972, V.1, P. 1072 (in Russian). [111] Tolkovyjj Slovar' Russkogo Jazyka. Pod Red. D.N.Ushakova (The Reference Dictionary of Russian Language Under The Editorship of D.N. Ushakov). - M.:GIINS, 1940, V. 4, P.567 (in Russian). [112] S.Ja. Frenkel', G.K. El'jashevich. // Ehnciklopedija Polimerov (Polymer Encyclopedia). - M.: Sov. Ehnciklopedija, 1977, V.3, P.550; (in Russian). [113] G.L.Slonimskijj // Tam Zhe, 1974, T.2, S. 320; [114] V.A. Kargin, G.L. Slonimskijj. Kratkie Ocherki po Fizikokhimii Polimerov (Brief Notes on Physical Chemistry of Polymers). - M.: Khimija, 1967 (in Russian). [115] G.S. Jjekh. // Vysokomol. Soed., 1979, V. 21 A, No 11, P. 2433. [116] Ju. B. Amerik, B.A. Krencel'. // Usp. Khimii i Fiziki Polimerov (Advances on Physics and Chemistry of Polymers). - M.: Khimija, 1973, P. 97 (in Russian). [117] V.I. Irzhak. // Usp. Khimii, 1997, T.66, №3, S.598. [118] V.N. Kuleznev. Smesi Polimerov (Polymer Blends). -M.: Khimija, 1980 (in Russian). [119] Dzh. Mehnson, L. Sperling. Polimernye Smesi i Kompozity (Polymer Blends and Composites). - M.: Khimija, 1979 (in Russian). [120] Amerik Ju. B., Krencel' B.A. Khimija Zhidkikh Kristallov i Mezomorfnykh Polimerov (The Chemistry of Liquid Crystals and Mesomorphic Polymers. – M.: Nauka, 1981 (in Russian). [121] Plateh N.A., Shibaev V.P. Grebneobraznye Polimery i Zhidkie Kristally (Comb-Like Polymers and Liquid Crystals). – M.: Khimija, 1980 (in Russian). [122] De Zhen P. Fizicheskie Svojjstva Zhidkokristallicheskikh Veshhestv (Physical Properties of Liquid Crystalline Substances). – M.: Mir, 1982 (in Russian). [123] Papkov S.P., Kulichikhin V.G. Zhidkokristallicheskoe Sostojanie Polimerov (Liquid Crystalline State of Polymers). – M.:Khimija, 1977 (in Russian). [124] Cukruk V.V., Shilov V.V. Struktura Polimernykh Zhidkikh Kristallov (The Structure of Polymer Liquid Crystals). – Kiev: Nauk. Dumka, 1990 (in Russian).
44
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
[125] Lebedev E.V. // Fizikokhimija Mnogokomponentnykh Polimernykh System (Physical Chemistry of Multicomponent Polymer Systems. – Kiev: Nauk. Dumka, 1986, V.2, P. 121 (in Russian). [126] S.P. Papkov, Z.A. Rogovin, V.A. Kargin. // Zhfkh, 1937, No 10, P.157; P. 607; P. 793; 1939, No 13, P. 206. [127] P.J. Flory. // J. Chem. Phys., 1942, No 10, P. 51. [128] M.L. Huggins. // J. Phys. Chem., 1942, V.46, P. 151. [129] S. Krauze. // Polimernye Smesi. Pod Red. D.Pola i S. N'jumena (Polymer Blends. Under The Editorship of S. Newman). -M.:Mir, 1981, V. 1, P. 26 (in Russian). [130] V.N. Kuleznev. // Mnogokomponentnye Polimernye Sistemy Pod Red. R.F.Golda (Multicomponent Polymer Blends. Under The Editorship of R.F.Gold). - M.: Khimija, 1974, P.10 (in Russian). [131] Sanches. // Polimernye Smesi. Pod Red. D.Pola i S. N'jumena (Polymer Blends. Under The Editorship of D.Pol and S. Newman). - M.:Mir, 1981. T.1, C.145 (in Russian). [132] T. Kvejj, T. Uehng. // Polimernye Smesi. Pod Red. D.Pola i S. N'jumena (Polymer Blends. Under The Editorship of D.Pol and S. Newman). - M.:Mir, 1981. V.1, P.172 (in Russian). [133] A.E. Nesterov, Ju. S. Lipatov. Obrashhennaja Gazovaja Khromatografija V Termodinamike Polimerov (The Reversed Gas Chromatography in Polymer Thermodynamics). Kiev: Nauk. Dumka, 1976 (in Russian). [134] Chalykh A.E., Gerasimov V.K., Mikhajjlov Ju.M. Diagrammy Fazovogo Sostojanija Polimernykh System (Phase State Diagrams of Polymer Systems). – M.: «Janus-K», 1998 (in Russian). [135] Klenin V.I. Termodinamika Sistem S Gibkimi Polimerami (Thermodynamics of Systems With Flexible Polymers). – Saratov: Izd-Vo Sarat. Un-Ta., 1995 (in Russian). [136] R.L. Scott. // J. Chem. Phys., 1949, V. 17, P.279. [137] H. Tompa. // Trans. Faraday Soc., 1949, V. 45, P.1142; 1950, V. 46, R.970. [138] A.A. Tager. // Vysokomolek. Soed., 1974, V.16A, No 1, P. 203; 1977, P.19A, No 8, P. 1659. [139] G.L. Slonimskijj, G.V. Struminskijj. // Zhfkh, 1956, V.30, No 9, P.1941; No 10, P.2144. [140] Ju. G. Oganesov, V.N. Kuleznev, S.S. Vojuckijj. // Vysokomol. Soed., 1970, V. 12 B, No 9, P.691. [141] S.N. Maron, N. Nacajiama. // J. Polymer Sci., 1959, V. 38, P.329; 1959, V. 40, P.59; 1959, V. 42, P.327; 1960, V. 47, P.169; 1961, V. 54, P.587. [142] V. Maknajjt, F. Karash, Dzh.Frid. // Polimernye Smesi. Pod Red. D.Pola i S. N'jumena (Polymer Blends. Under The Editorship of D.Pol and S. Newman). - M.:Mir, 1981. T.1, C.219. [143] P.J. Flory E.A. // J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1964, V. 86, P.3515; 1965, V. 87, P.1833; 1967, V. 89, P.6814; Trans. Faraday Soc., 1968, V. 64, P.2035; Macromolecules, 1968, V. 1, P.285. [144] I.R. Prigozhin. Molekuljarnaja Teorija Rastvorov (Molecular Theory of Solutions). -M.: Metallurgija, 1990 (in Russian). [145] D. Patterson E.A. // Polymer, 1966,V. 7, P.513; // J. Polymer Sci., 1968, V. 16 C, P.3378; // Macromolecules, 1969, V. 2, P.672; // Trans. Faraday Soc., 1969, V. 65, P.708.
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
45
[146] A.A. Tager. Fizikokhimija Polimerov (Physical Chemistry of Polymers). -M.: Khimija, 1978 (in Russian). [147] I.C. Sanchez, R.H. Lacombe. // J. Phys. Chem., 1976, V.80, P. 2352; P.2568. [148] L.P. Mcmaster. // Macromolecules, 1973, V. 6, P.760. [149] P. De Zhen. Idei Skejjlinga V Fizike Polimerov (Scaling Concepts in Polymer Physics). -M.: Mir, 1982 (in Russian). [150] Ju. Grosberg, A.R. Khokhlov. Statisticheskaja Fizika Makromolekul (Statistical Physics of Macromolecules). - M.: Nauka, 1989 (in Russian). [151] S.F. Edwards. // Proc. Phys. Soc., 1966, V.88 L, P. 265; // Fluides Moleculares. By Eds. R.Balian and G.Weill. -N.Y.: Gordon & Breach, 1976, P.113. [152] Doi M., Ehdvards S. Dinamicheskaja Teorija Polimerov (Dynamic Theory of Polymers). Mir: M., 1998 (in Russian). [153] R. Koningsveld A.A. // Adv. Colloid and interface Sci., 1968, V.2, P.151; // Macromolecules, 1969, V. 2, P207; // Pure Appl. Chem., 1974, V.39, P. 1. [154] G. Meyerhoff, U. Moritz. // Makromol. Chem., 1967, V. 109, P.143. [155] R. Kirste, G. Wild. // Makromol. Chem., 1969, V. 121, P.174. [156] A.E. Nesterov, Ju. S. Lipatov, B.E.Mjuller, L.V.Mozzhukhina. // Vysokomolek. Soed., 1968, V. 10 B, No 11, P.900. [157] L. Scholtan, L. Ying. // Makromol. Chem., 1967, V. 108, P.104. [158] G. Porod. // Monatsch. Chem., 1949, V. 80, P.251. [159] W. Stockmaer, M. Fixman. // J. Polymer Sci., 1963, V. 1 C, P.137. [160] Semlyen J.A. // Adv. Polym. Sci. 1976, V. 21,P.41. [161] V.N. Kuleznev. Chastnoe Soobshhenie (Separate Announcement). 2004 (in Russian). [162] N.M. Ptichkina. Diss…. Dokt. Khim. Nauk. Saratov: Niiskh Raskhn, 2000. [163] F.A. Avgonova. Diss…. Kand. Fiz-Mat. Nauk. M.: Ifkh RAN, 2000. [164] A.E. Nesterov, Ju. S. Lipatov. Termodinamika Rastvorov i Smesejj Polimerov (Yhermodynamics of Polymer Solutions and Blends). -Kiev: Nauk. Dumka, 1984 (in Russian). [165] A.E. Nesterov, Ju. S. Lipatov. Fazovoe Sostojanie Rastvorov Smesejj Polimerov (Phase State of Solutions of Polymer Blends). Spravochnik. -Kiev: Nauk. Dumka, 1987 (in Russian). [166] T.K. Kwei, T. Nishi, R.F. Roberts. // Macromolecules, 1974, V. 7, P.667. [167] S.P. Papkov // Chalykh A.E., Gerasimov V.K., Mikhajjlov Ju.M. Diagrammy Fazovogo Sostojanija Polimernykh Sistem (Phase State Diagrams of Polymer Systems). – M.: «Janus-K», 1998. Glava, 5, P. 183 (in Russian). [168] S.P. Papkov Fiziko-Khimicheskie Osnovy Pererabotki Rastvorov Polimerov (Fundamentals on Physico-Chemical Processing of Polymers in Solution). -M.: Khimija, 1971 (in Russian). [169] S.M. Mezhikovskijj. // Dokl. i Vsesojuzn. Konf. po Khimii i Fizikokhimii Polimerizacionnosposobnykh Oligomerov (Reports of i All-Union Conference on The Chemistry and Physical Chemistry of Oligomers).- Chernogolovka: AN SSSR, 1977, V.2, P. 362 (in Russian). [170] S.M. Mezhikovskijj. Dis. ... Dokt. Tekhn. Nauk. M.: Ikhf AN SSSR, 1983. [171] V.M. Lancov. Dis. ... Dokt. Khim. Nauk. M.: Ikhf AN SSSR, 1989. [172] A.G.Solov'ev, L.I.Murza // Vysokomol. Soed., 1995, V. 39 B, No 9, P.695.
46
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
[173] Ju. R. Ehrbich. // Dokl. Mezhdun. Konf. po Kauchuku i Rezine IRC’ (Reports of The international Conference on Caoutchouc and Rubber 94. M., 1994, V.3, P. 195 (in Russian). [174] Ja. I. Frenkel'. Kineticheskaja Teorija Zhidkosti (Kinetic Theory of Liquid). -M.-L.:AN SSSR, 1945 (in Russian). [175] M.A. Anisimov. Kriticheskie Javlenija v Zhidkostjakh i Zhidkikh Kristallakh (Critical Phenomena in Liquid and Liquid Crystals). M.: Nauka, 1987 (in Russian). [176] V.P. Skripov, V.P. Koverda. Spontannaja Kristallizacija Pereokhlazhdennykh Zhidkostejj (Spontaneous Crystallization of Overcooled Liquids). M.: Nauka, 1984 (in Russian). [177] J. Lothe, G.M. Pound. // J. Chem. Phys. 1962. V.36. No 5. P.2080. [178] H.Reiss, J.L.Katz // J. Chem. Phys. 1967. V.46. No 7. P.2496. [179] L.S. Polak, A.S. Mikhajjlov. Samoorganizacija V Neravnovesnykh FizikoKhimicheskikh Sistemakh (Self - Organization in Non-Equilibrium Physicochemical Systems). M.: Nauka, 1983 (in Russian). [180] G. Nikolis, I. Prigozhin. Samoorganizacija v Neravnovesnykh Sistemakh (Self – Organization in Non-Equilibrium Systems). M.:Mir, 1979 (in Russian). [181] V. Ehbeling. Obrazovanie Struktur pri Neobratimykh Processakh (Structure formation in Irreversible Processes). M.:Mir, 1979 (in Russian). [182] Ju. Ja. Gotlib, A.A. Dolinskijj, Ju. E. Svetlov. Fizicheskaja Kinetika Makromolekul. L: Khimija, 1986. [183] G.M. Bartenev, A.G. Barteneva. Relaksacionnye Svojjstva Polimerov (Reactive Properties of Polymers). M.: Khimija, 1992 (in Russian). [184] V.G. Rostiashvili, V.I. Irzhak, B.A. Rozenberg. Steklovanie Polimerov (Vitrification of Polymers). L.: Khimija, 1987 (in Russian). [185] V.G. Dashevskijj. Konformacionnyjj Analiz Makromolekul (Conformational Analysis of Macromolecules). M.: Nauka, 1987 (in Russian). [186] A.L. Buchachenko, A.M. Vasserman. Stabil'nye Radikaly (Stable Radicals). -M.: Khimija, 1973 (in Russian). [187] Ja. Rabek. Ehksperimental'nye Metody V Khimii Polimerov (Experimental Methods in A Polymer Chemistry). -M.: Mir, 1983. V.1-P.374. V.2. -P.479 (in Russian). [188] Strukturnye Issledovanija Makromolekul Spektroskopicheskimi Metodami. Pod Red. K.Ivina (Structural investigations of Macromoleculesby Spectroscopic Methods. Under The Editorship of K. Ivin).- M.: Khimija, 1980 (in Russian). [189] Ju. S. Lipatov, V.V. Shilov, Ju. P. Gomza, N.E. Krugljak. Rentgenograficheskie Metody Izuchenija Polimernykh Sistem (Roentgenographic Methods of Studying of Polymer Systems). - Kiev: Nauk. Dumka, 1982 (in Russian). [190] Korolev G.V., Berezin M.P. Kineticheskie Projavlenija Associativnojj Struktury Zhidkikh Oligomerov v Processakh Polimerizacii i Sopolimerizacii (Kinetic Demonstration of Associative Structure of Liquid Oligomers in Polymerization and Copolymerization Processes). Chernogolovka: Ikhfch RAN, 1994 (in Russian). [191] V.N. Kuleznev. // Vysokomolek. Soed. A.1993. T.35. No 8. S.1391. [192] M.A. Anisimov., V.A. Rabinovich, V.V. Sychev. Termodinamika Kriticheskogo Sostojanija individual'nykh Veshhestv (Critical State Thermodynamics of individual Substances). - M.: Ehnergoatomizdat, 1990 (in Russian). [193] S.N. Arkina. Dis. ...Kand. Khim. Nauk. M.:Ikhf AN SSSR, 1970.
Oligomers as the Object of Research: Basic Principles
47
[194] T.D. Mal'chevskaja. Dis. ...Kand. Khim. Nauk. M.:Nifkhi, 1980. [195] S.M. Mezhikovskijj. // Dokl. i Vsesojuz. Konf. “Smesi Polimerov” (Reports of The i All-Union Conference “Polymer Blends”). Ivanovo. 1986, P.15. [196] S.M. Mezhikovskijj. // Vysokomolek. Soed., 1987. T.29 A, No 8, C.1571. [197] S.M. Mezhikovskijj. Nekotorye Problemy Fizikokhimii Polimer-Oligomernykh Sistem i Kompozitov Na Ikh Osnove (Some Aspects of The Physical Chemistry of PolymerOligomer Systems and Related Composites). -Chernogolovka: Oikhf AN SSSR, 1986 (in Russian). [198] V.V. Shilov, Ju. S. Lipatov. // Fizikokhimija Mnogokomponentnykh Polimernykh System (Physical Chemistry of Multicomponent Polymer Systems). Kiev: Naukova Dumka, 1986. V.2. P.25 (in Russian). [199] ”Sovmestimost' Polimerov”. // Ehnciklopedija Polimerov (“Compatibility of Polymers”. // Polymer Encyclopedia). - M.: Sov. Ehnciklopedija, 1977, V.3, P.433 (in Russian). [200] V.E. Gul', A.E. Penskaja, N.A. Zanemonec, T.A. Zanina. // Vysokomolek. Soed., 1972, T.14A, No 2, S. 291. [201] Dzh. Gibbs. Termodinamicheskie Raboty (Works on Thermodynamics). -M.: Goskhimizdat, 1950 (in Russian). [202] M. Fisher. // Ustojjchivost' i Fazovye Perekhody (Stability and Phase Transitions). -M.: Mir, 1973, P. 275 (in Russian). [203] A.A. Tager, L.K. Kolmakova. // Vysokomolek. Soed.,1980, V.22 A, №3, P. 483. [204] Tager A.A., Fizikokhimija Polimerov (Physical Chemistry of Polymers). – M.: Khimija, 1978 (in Russian). [205] V.P. Volkov, G.F. Roginskaja, A.E. Chalykh, B.A. Rozenberg. // Usp. Khimii, 1982, V.51, No 10, P.1733. [206] Papkov S.P. Ravnovesie Faz V Sisteme Polimer-Rastvoritel' (Phase Equilibrium in A Polymer – Solvent System).- M.: Khimija, 1981 (in Russian). [207] Chalykh A.E. Diagrammy Fazovykh Sostojanijj Polimernykh System (Phase State Diagrams of Polymer Systems). – M.: Ifkh RAN, 1995 (in Russian). [208] G.F. Roginskaja. Dis. ... Kand. Khim. Nauk. Chernogolovka: Oikhf AN SSSR, 1983. [209] A.V. Kotova. Dis. ... Kand. Khim. Nauk. M.: Ikhf AN SSSR, 1988. [210] N.N. Avdeev. Dis.... Kand. Fiz.-Mat. Nauk. M.: Ifkh RAN, 1990. [211] T.B. Repina. Dis. ... Kand. Khim. Nauk. M.: Mgkhtu, 1995. [212] Shamalijj O.N. Dis. ... Kand. Khim. Nauk. M.: Ifkh RAN, 1995. [213] Andreeva N.P. Dis. ... Kand. Khim. Nauk. M.: Ikhf RAN, 2003. [214] Bukhtev A.E. Dis.... Kand. Khim. Nauk. M.: Ifkh RAN, 2003. [215] Ju. S. Lipatov, A.E. Nesterov, T.D. Ignatova. // Dokl. AN SSSR, 1975, T.222, №3, S. 609; 1975, T.224, No 4, S. 634.
Part 2
HOMOGENEOUS OLIGOMER SYSTEMS ABSTRACT Reasons of a molecular inhomogeneity in synthetic oligomer systems have been considered. The scaling analysis of a small – scale structure for a chain with limited length and finite bending rigidity has been carried out. Special consideration is given to the supramolecular structure of oligomers at the basis of associate – sybotactic models of liquid.
2.1. MOLECULAR HETEROGENEITY OF OLIGOMERS Despite their chain complexity, natural biological macromolecules are complicated individual compounds [1-3]. The molecular structure of synthetic oligomers is heterogeneous; it is characterized by distribution according to their molecular weight and functionality; typical of co-oligomers is distribution according to their composition [1] as well. Molecular heterogeneity of synthetic oligomers is conditioned by the random character of their formation process and by the side reactions during their synthesis. These side reactions result in the formation of deficient molecules; in some commercial products the content of the latter may reach the content of the target molecules [1,2,4-11]. Therefore, one of the major tasks in the physical chemistry of oligomers is the analysis of the molecular heterogeneity of some reactive oligomers. Many achievements in this field are due to the research of S. Entelis and his school [1,2,5,9]. Recent years have given special significance to these achievements because of the discoveries in the field of critical chromatography [2].
2.1.1. Molecular Weight Distribution Functions Molecular weight heterogeneity of oligomers is characterized by the parameters common for all polymers [12-15]: polydispersity index Mw /Мn, ratio Мz / Mw, and heterogeneity -1
coefficient of Schultz (Mw/Мn,) . In the physical sense, the latter is the relative dispersion of molecular weight distribution.
50
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
The Мn average number molecular weight can be described as the ratio of oligomer weight and the number of molecules n: Мn = (n1 M1 + n2 M2 +....) /(n1 + n2 + ....) = =Σ ni Mi /Σ ni
(2.1)
the Mw average number molecular weight can be described as 2
Mw = ∑ ni Mi / ∑ ni Mi = ∑ ϖi Mi
(2.2)
Mz is the average number molecular weight, Mz can be described as 3
2
(2.3)
Mz = ∑ ni Mi / ∑ ni Mi
where ni is the number of molecules with molecular weight Mi; ni = ϖi / Mi on condition that Σ ni Mi =1; ϖi is the mass fraction of molecules with molecular weight Mi. Unlike polymers, characterized by continuous functions of molecular weight distribution, oligomers are characterized by discrete functions. This means that while for polymers the numeric molecular weight distribution (М)ΔМ represents the numeric fraction of molecules with molecular weight from М to М+ΔМ, for oligomers, it represents the numeric fraction of molecules with molecular weight Mi, this fraction corresponds to a certain degree of polymerization. The same rule works for the mass molecular weight distribution of oligomers ϖ(M) which represents the mass fraction of molecules with exactly fixed molecular weight Mi. Analytically speaking, molecular weight distribution of oligomers is usually described by the three types of distribution functions: Flory, Schultz, and Poisson. The most probable distribution (Flory distribution) can be described as the function of polymerization degree (r) for mass fraction W(r) of the reacted functional groups (λ) W(r)= rλ
r-1
2
(2.4)
(1-λ)
or for the mole fraction r as measure n(r) n(r) = λ
n-1
(1-λ)2
(2.5)
In some cases the most probable distribution can be presented as αM
W(M)=M α-2 e-
αM
and n(M)= α e-
,
(2.6)
where α=1/М for mass and numeric functions of molecular weight distribution. A typical characteristic of the most probable distribution is the constancy of the average molecular weights ratio Мz : Mw : Мn = 3:2:1.
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
51
Poisson distribution describes oligomers with narrow molecular weight distribution: n(r) = е
-rn
r
[(rn ) / r!],
(2.7)
where rn – is the average number degree of polymerization. For this type of molecular weight distribution function, Mw / Мn = 1 +1/rn. Molecular weight distribution of oligomers in the range between the narrow (Poisson) and the most probable (Flory) distribution can be described by the G -distribution of Schultz, which can be analytically expressed by equation k+1
n(M)= [(α
k
) / G(k+1)] M e
-αM
,
(2.8)
where G(k) – is the gamma-function, parameters α and k can be described as k+1 = Мn / (Mw - Мn ) and α = (k+3) / Мz = (k+2) Mw. With this molecular weight distribution, the average molecular weights are connected to each other by ratio Мz : Mw : Мn = (k+3) : (k+2) : (k+1). You can see that at k=0 we get the most probable Flory distribution, and at bigger values of k we get Poisson distribution, typical of oligomers with narrow molecular weight distribution. Table 2.1 shows data on correlation between the methods of different oligomers synthesis and their molecular weight distribution functions. Table 2.1. Dependence of Molecular Weight Distribution Function Type on Method of Oligomer Synthesis [1] Type of Function
Poisson
Schultz
Method of Synthesis
Oligomer
Anionic step-growth oligomerization
Oligo-ethylene oxide
Anionic oligomerization Cationic oligomerization Radical oligomerization Anionic oligomerization with slow chain initiation or transfer Cationic oligomerization Oligocondensation
Flory
Cationic oligomerization Destruction with interchain exchange
Oligo-propylene oxide Oligobutadiene Vynyl oligomers
Molecular weight range 2 10 - 4.104 2 3 10 - 2.10 102 - 2.104 5
102 - 10 3 102 - 2.10
Oligo-alkylene oxides Oligobutadiene 102 - 104 Oligo-styrene and other vinyl 102 – 104 oligomers 3 Oligo-alkylene oxides 102 - 10 3 Complex oligoesters 102 - 5.10 Oligoesterepoxides
102 - 2.103
Oligotetramethylene oxide
102 - 10
Oligosulfides
102 - 104
4
52
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
As noted in [1], the analysis of molecular weight distribution parameters is a reliable instrument for the investigation of oligomerization process kinetics and mechanisms. Comparison of theoretical (for the chosen model of oligomerization) and experimental functions of molecular weight distribution and their compliance (or non-compliance) can serve as the measure of understanding the reaction mechanisms in the reactive environment, and, naturally, serve as the instrument to regulate the process of synthesis.
2.1.2. Functional Type Distribution Molecular (or structural) functionality f is the number of functional groups within the composition of one molecule of the given chemical compound. If some of the compound functional groups are not active within the conditions of a certain chemical reaction, we can use the concept of practical, or real functionality fр = f - f0., where f0 is the number of functional groups, which are non-reactive within the conditions of the given reaction. Naturally, fр < f. Molecules, which have no reactive groups, are called non-functional. Oligomers with f = 1; 2; 3 and etc., are, correspondingly, mono-, bi-, tri-, and etc., functional. We can distinguish oligomers according to the number and nature of reactive functional groups. Both characteristics determine the type of functionality. Together with molecular weight distribution, oligomers can be characterized by their distribution according to the types of functionality. The concept and term of functionality type distribution were first introduced into science by S. Entelis [1]. Functionality type distribution shows the relative content of molecules with different molecular functionality in the oligomer product. For reactive oligomers this is one of the most important physical and chemical characteristics. For quantification of functionality type distribution, similarly to molecular weight distribution, we use concepts of average number fn and average mass fw functionalities: fn = ∑ ni fi / ∑ ni 2
fw = ∑ ni fi / ∑ ni fi
(2.9)
where ni = pi /Mi is the number of moles of i -molecules with molecular weight Mi and functionality fi, their mass is pi . For average functionalities, as well as for f, we can use the concept of average realized functionality. The value of fn by itself doesn’t give final information about the polydispersity of oligomers according to functionality and doesn’t characterize their functionality type distribution. For example, fn=2 seems to be an ideal characteristic of bifunctionality, however, no strict bifunctionality of all molecules may occur, this value being the result of averaging: mono- and tri-functional molecules may exist in the system in equal share. Ambiguity may also occur when using ratio fw / fn to characterize polydispersity according to functionality. The presence of non-functional molecules (f=0) in the system does influence the value of fn, however, it does not influence the value of fw. For this reason, the
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
53
functionality type distribution functions can be shown as mass, numeric and integral distribution curves, correspondingly, ni fi - fi; ni - fi and ∑ ni fi - fi. It has already been mentioned above (see Part 2.1.1), that the usage of functionality type distribution and molecular weight distribution values gives us an opportunity to divide all the existing reactive oligomers into three groups. Table 2.2 shows coefficients of polydispersity for these three types of oligomers, and all the possible reasons of functionality type distribution in them. Table 2.2. Polydispersity Coefficients of Oligomer Systems According to Parameters of Molecular Weight Distribution and Functionality Type Distribution. [16-18] Type Numbe r
Oligomer Formula
Polydispersity Coefficient
Possible Reasons of Functionality Type Distribution
Mw / Мn ≥ 1 1
Deficiency in functionality fw / fn ≥ 1 fn ∼ Мn
2 fw / fn ∼ Mw / Мn
A 3
Mw / Мn ≥ 1
A A
fw / fn ≥ 1
Deficiency in functionality; Molecular weight Molecular weight distribution; content distribution
The above given table requires explanation. Oligomers of the first type with a strictly defined target functionality can ideally be characterized by functions fw / fn = 1 and Mw / Мn ≥1. However, in reality, fw / fn > 1, which can be explained by deficient molecules formation, along with the target ones, even in special synthesis, because of the side reactions, incompleteness of the process and other factors. Polyfunctional linear and branched oligomers with regular alternation of functional groups in chain (the second type) are characterized by linear dependence of molecular weight Mi on functionality fi; at fixed values of Мn, every value of Mw / Мn corresponds to a certain value of fw / fn. Polyfunctional linear or branched oligomers of the third type with non-regular alternation of functional groups in chain can have very different values of polydispersity according to molecular weight and according to functionality type; however, we always have fw / fn > 1 and Mw / Мn > 1.
54
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
2.1.3. Critical Chromatography of Oligomers Critical chromatography, which was discovered in 1980’s [19-21], is based on the fact that molecules are adsorbed due to phase transition. Unlike monomers adsorption, where typical thermodynamic limit is 1023 (Avogadro constant), polymers and oligomers adsorption involves a much fewer number of particles. The finiteness (numeric infinitesimal) in this type of chain systems blurs the point (e.g., temperature) of adsorption phase transition to the area, the width of which depends on the size of molecules. For small chains (oligomers), this point may reach several degrees. In this transition (critical) area, the properties of the system are practically the same as they are in the critical point, however, unlike the latter, the critical area is stable to the small changes of the external parameters. This makes it possible for the system of oligomer chain molecules to be present in the critical area for a comparatively long time, which is enough to study their characteristics, in particular, their molecular and structural heterogeneity of different parameters. In the succeeding years, due to papers [2224], theoretical fundamentals of polymers critical chromatography were developed. Their practical application allowed us to investigate experimentally the molecular heterogeneity of the commercial oligomers main classes, obtain the functions of their heterogeneity according to their composition, functionality, and etc. This unique instrumental method has other practical applications (it can be used to study all the stages of polymerization process, mechanisms of destruction and depolymerization processes and etc.), yet for the problems addressed in this monograph, the results of research on oligomer systems molecular heterogeneity are of primary interest. They have been described in a number of papers (e.g., see [25-27]) and systematized in the doctoral thesis of A. Gorshkov [2]. The present work addresses only several examples. Figure 2.1 shows a chromatogram of oligopropelyne oxide adsorption critical regime, which was obtained on the basis of trifunctional glycerin. This chromatogram reflects the possible variety of the end –OH groups of this oligomer. Figure 2.1 gives the results of epoxide oligomers classification according to the types of functionality in the critical regime, and the bivariate function of their heterogeneity in the coordinates of molecular weight distribution and functionality type distribution. This reflects the composition of epoxide oligomer linear molecules with different end groups.
2.2. SMALL SCALE OLIGOMER STRUCTURE: THEORETICAL ASPECTS During the macromolecules statistics investigation (e.g., see [3,15,28-31]), the question of relation between the conformational states of molecules and their chain length was one of the major problems. Naturally, in case of component chain links variation, the molecules from oligomer area were also investigated. However, the interests of the scientists were mainly focused on the analysis of macromolecular systems with a huge number of Kuhn segments in the chain. We started to use statistical methods for a purposeful study of molecular-structural distribution in oligomer systems much later [34-48]. It followed from these papers that comparatively short molecules, possessing finite rigidity (it is this type of molecules that can be oligomeric) show the peculiarities of statistical behavior, which, in the long run, determines the specific properties of oligomer systems.
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
55
In particular, for polymer systems, the scale of oriented-correlated areas is much smaller than the usual size of polymer coils, and, therefore, these areas do not have a strong influence on the conformational statistics of polymer molecules. For oligomer systems, however, the scale of correlated areas can influence the size of oligomer molecules. Hence, these orientedcorrelated areas, the result of local anisotropy of oligomer molecules, do influence the state of oligomer molecule.
Figure 2.1. Chromatogram of branched oligopropylene oxide in a critical mode, reflecting various types of end OH – groups.
Moreover, when describing the statistical properties of the comparatively short molecules, the asymptotic limit used to describe the infinitely long chains, is too rough to be an approximation. Non-Gaussian character of oligomer macromolecules conformations statistics is to be taken into account. These two circumstances make the statistical properties of oligomer macromolecules differ strongly from the properties of polymers. This fact influences the macroscopic properties as well. Following is the analysis of some (of the above-quoted) theoretical papers which do prove this statement.
56
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
2.2.1. Small Scale Structure of Limited Length Chain with Finite Bending Rigidity (Scaling Estimations) Publications [37,38] give the results of scaling estimation of the possible influence of small scale structure of a liquid oligomer system, composed of limited length and rigidity macromolecules, on its macroscopic properties. Following are some results of this study. A coil-type flexible polymer chain has a low density structure; the longer the chain, the lower is the volume density of the substance [3]. In fact, the volume of the freely-jointed chain with chain links number N and size a, has the value of Vch ~ a3N 3ν (1/3 < ν < 3/5), while the volume of the chain itself equals a3N. If the chain possesses certain rigidity, persistent length (Kuhn segment) is to be introduced, and the chain is to be considered freely-jointed, made up of Kuhn segments. The volume of this chain will be much larger:
Vch ~ (lK )3 ( N nK )3ν = (anK )3 ( N nK )3ν = a 3nK3( 1− ν) N 3ν
(2.10)
where N – is the number of chain links; lK=anK – is the length of a Kuhn segment, containing nK number of chain links; a – is the length of one chain link; for a globe ν = 1/3, for a Gaussian coil ν = 1/2, for a swollen coil ν = 3/5. Substance density in a single coil (density given in units of excluded volume) decreases with the increase of the Kuhn segment length as well as with the increase of the chain length: 3 ρ ch ~ a N ~
VK
1
, 1 < 3v < 3.
(2.11)
nK3(1−ν ) N 3ν −1
As the substance density in melt is close to one (Θ ∝ 1, 1 – Θ << 1) and depends neither on the length of the Kuhn segment nor on the chain length, there can be, in fact, an M number of chains in the volume of the chain Vch, the number of chains can be calculated according to the following ratio:
M ~ ΘnK3(1−ν ) N 3ν −1 , 1 < 3v < 3.
(2.12)
We can find the volume of a Kuhn segment in the volume of the given chain:
VK =
Vch ~ (anK )3 ( N nK )3ν −1 = a 3nK3( 1− ν)+1 N 3ν −1 N nK
(2.13)
This volume Vk (ellipsoid with axes L1 ~ anK, L2,3 = LK ~ anK(N/nK)(3ν – 1)/2 = anK3(1– ν )/2 (3ν – 1)/2 N ) is to be filled with M rods, the length of which is lK=anK , and their diameter is a ; they are the Kuhn segments of different chains. The calculated concentration of these rods is:
Cn ∞ M VK ~ Θ a3nK
(2.14)
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
57
As the Kuhn segments of different chains are statistically independent, the situation studied is equivalent to the well-known model of rigid rods. When the excluded volume is considered within the framework of Onsager model [49], the system is considered to possess critical concentration Ckr, where the system obtains orientational ordering. The value of this critical concentration is determined by the length and diameter of the rods:
Ckr ~ 1 alK2 ∞ 1 a3nK2 ,
Θkr ~ 1 nK
(2.15)
For rigid chains, with a large length of the Kuhn segment, the system density exceeds the critical density, and the rods orientations (Kuhn segments of different chains) in the given ellipsoid correlate, i.e. a “string” of the relatively straight chain segments appears. The width of this “string” corresponds to the size of the orientationally ordered area; this size is neither the size of the Kuhn segment, nor the size of the polymer molecule itself. In other words, the system appears to have another characteristic scale – the scale of the orientational correlation of polymer chain segments Lkor.
(A)
(B) Figure 2.2. Functional type distribution of epoxyoligomer in a critical mode (a) and its 2-D function of heterogeneity «functionality – MW» (b).
58
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
In order to access this new scale we can apply a plane perpendicular to the direction of the Kuhn segment of the chain (Figure 2.3). When we use this plane to cut the ellipsoid corresponding to the Kuhn segment of the chain, a circle is to be formed. When this circle crosses the rods (Kuhn segments of different chains) within the volume studied, a system of points appears, their concentration has the order of Cp ∞ Θ/a2, and the average distance between them is Δ ∞a/Θ1/2.
Figure 2.3. Plain section of ellipsoid, perpendicular to the Kuhn segment of a sample chain. Dots mark intersection of this plane with other Kuhn segments in a sector rested on a circular arc with a length Δ, where Δ is an average distance between intersection points of Kuhn segments with a cutting plane.
If we take unitary vectors for each one of the points, where the direction of the vectors coincides with the rod direction for the given point, we can get a secondary chain, the properties of which are almost the same as the properties of a rigid polymer chain, because the orientations of the two neighboring rods, and, therefore, secondary chain links, correlate. The correlation function of the chain links orientation along this chain is [50]:
⎛ ⎞ ⎡ (l Δ )Δ ⎤ ⎡ ⎤ = exp ⎢− nΔ ⎥ g (l ) ~ exp⎜ − l ⎟ = exp ⎢− ⎥ L L L ⎝ kor ⎠ ⎣ ⎣ kor ⎦ kor ⎦
(2.16)
where n – is the number of chain links or the number of rods between the two given rods in the radius sector LK and arc Δ (Δ ∝ a/Θ1/2 – is the average distance between the “points”), and Lkor – is the distance from the Kuhn segment of the given chain, for this very distance the orientations of the Kuhn segments of different chains do not depend on the given chain Kuhn segment orientation. For the two neighboring “links” (rods) at n = 1, correlation function is expressed through the angle of the relative orientation between them, this angle is determined by the density of their packing Θ. The required dependence 〈cosθ(Θ)〉 can be calculated using the Onsager model, modified in [51] for the case of high rods concentration:
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
g (1) = cos θ (Θ) ≈ 1 − [ln(1 − Θ)nK ]− 2
59 (2.17)
Expansion of the correlation function (1.7) in a series at n = 1 (2.18)
⎡ ⎤ a g (1) = exp ⎢ − Δ ⎥ ≈ 1 − Θ Lkor ⎣ Lkor ⎦
Taking into account (2.17) we can find the required correlation length Lkor, which shows the distance from the chosen Kuhn segment where the orientational effects stop:
Lkor ~
a [ln(1 − Θ)]2 nK2 Θ
(2.19)
This new scale of the system – correlation length Lkor – appears as the result of collective interchain interactions. Its comparison with the two other characteristic system scales: characteristic area size, corresponding to one Kuhn segment – LK ∝ anK(N/nK)(3ν – 1)/2 = anK3(1– ν )/2 (3ν – 1)/2 N , and characteristic size of the whole chain – Rch ∝ anK(N/nK)ν = anK1–ν Nν, allows us to access the microstructure of the whole system and its influence on the system properties. If Lkor < LK, i.e., the size of the ordered area does not exceed the characteristic size of the area, corresponding to one Kuhn segment, then the effects of local ordering do not appear when averaging the scale over this size. This means that the local ordering of the Kuhn segments in different chain characteristic of the rigid chain polymer systems does not influence the macroscopic properties of the polymer system as a whole. In this case, introduction of a persistent length (Kuhn segment) allows us to consider the polymer chain freely-jointed. This situation is possible in case the Kuhn segment length is short enough compared to the whole chain length, i.e.:
nK ≤ ln (1 − Θ )
− 3ν4+1
N
1− 3ν2+1
(2.20)
In other words, if inequality (2.20) is accepted, the macromolecular system is a classical polymer system and no specific properties related to the finiteness of the macromolecules length can appear in this system. If Lkor > Rch, i.e., the size of the ordered area exceeds the size of the polymer coil, then the local ordering of the Kuhn segments of different chains results in cardinal reconstruction of the molecule state: its “polymer” degrees of freedom get ‘frozen” and its properties get closer to the properties of the low molecular weight compounds. Certainly, these types of systems possess specific properties of their own which are related to the high anisotropy of the molecules. In particular, liquid crystal regulation can take place in these systems. A system can be considered to be of this type in case the Kuhn segment length is large enough:
nK ≥ ln (1 − Θ)
− 2
ν +1 N
1− 1
ν +1
(2.21)
60
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
And, finally, we consider the case when the size of the regulated area is larger than the characteristic size of the area corresponding to one Kuhn segment but does not exceed the characteristic size of the whole chain: LK < Lkor < Rch. It is with this ratio of the system characteristic scales that the local ordering of the Kuhn segments of different chains does influence the conformational structure of the macromolecule in the scale bigger than the Kuhn segment, i.e., it can influence the macroscopic properties of the whole system. This kind of influence appears on condition that the length of the Kuhn segment is large enough, however, it is considerably shorter than the whole chain length:
ln (1 − Θ )
− 3ν4+1
N
1− 3ν2+1
≤ nK ≤ ln (1 − Θ )
− ν 2+1
N
1− ν 1+1
(2.22)
The scaling analysis, which has been carried out, can be considered a theoretical basis for some of the statements given in Part 1.1.3. In fact, depending on the ratio between the length and the effective rigidity of the molecules, the system can behave very differently. For the case (2.20), when the chain length is much larger than the Kuhn segment length, the system behaves as a classical polymer. For another case (2.21), the system may either have a low molecular weight (if the chain length is not big enough) or the system may obtain a liquid crystal state, or a polymer crystal state, when the effective rigidity of the chains is so large that the Kuhn segment length almost reaches the whole chain length. The intermediate situation, described in (2.22), corresponds to the oligomer systems; their properties are neither the properties of the low molecular weight compounds nor the properties of polymers. In this case, the local structural ordering is determined not only by the architecture (ratio between the length and flexibility of molecules), but also by the environment, that is, the exterior conditions, e.g. temperature. At certain conditions this ordering can influence the macroscopic properties of the oligomer system. Note, that the above given scaling analysis took into account only steric interaction between the chains. As this type of interaction is typical of all the macromolecular systems studied, no matter what their chemical nature is, the conclusions made can be applied to the whole class of oligomer systems; the tolerance used is not principal as all the other possible types of interactions, conditioned by the chemical structure of the compound [52] (see Part 1.1.2.), usually intensify the effects discussed. Thus, from the scaling analysis we can conclude: a spontaneous appearance of areas with local orientational ordering is possible in oligomer systems. These small-scale structures, which can influence the macroscopic properties of the system, are the result of collectivism in statistical behavior of oligomer molecules. Their appearance is possible only at a certain ratio of molecular chain length and rigidity which usually corresponds to the oligomer area. It is not only the architecture of the molecules, but also the environmental and exterior conditions that determine their effective rigidity.
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
61
2.2.2. Oligomer Chain Statistics Depending on Length, Interlink Rigidity and Temperature The simplest model to describe conformational states of the long linear molecules is the model of an ideally flexible (phantom) polymer chain which is a chain of freely-jointed rigid rods with the length of l0 [3]. The orientations of the two neighboring chain links do not depend on each other. If the chain possesses interlink rigidity and the two neighboring links orientations correlate, we can introduce the concept of persistent length, or the concept of the Kuhn segment (a chain segment Δl, which has no memory of the orientation at the start). If the length of the Kuhn segment Δl equals the length of the new “rough molecule” elementary chain link, then the conformational states statistics for the molecule possessing a certain interlink rigidity can be described in the terms of absolutely flexible molecules. This approach is not suitable for oligomers, because it describes flexible and long molecules. As for the macromolecules possessing a certain interlink rigidity, this approach can be used only in case the length of the molecule has a great number of Kuhn segments. Typically, oligomer molecules are either not long enough or they are too rigid (in the latter case the Kuhn segment is too long). That is why the statistics of oligomer molecules conformational states differs from the statistics of long polymer chains. Special methods are to be used to describe oligomer molecules. These methods take into account finiteness (relative shortness) of the chain length, interlink rigidity, influence of the end groups on the state of the chain as a whole, conformational states of the internal links, and etc. Papers [36-38] show an attempt to describe the oligomer molecules conformations statistics taking into account the above listed requirements on the basis of the latticed model of orientational self-correlated wanderings [53-60]. Unlike the absolutely flexible chains model, where the wandering steps are independent, this model considers the macromolecular interlink rigidity, which assumes the dependence of the next step direction on the previous step direction. The ideology given in [37, 38] is as follows. The directions of each one step of wandering are not equiprobable. Therefore, probabilities of direction choice at each of the wandering steps on the lattice depending on the previous step direction are to be introduced. They are: • • •
probability to move in the same direction equals α+(T ); probability to move in a perpendicular direction equals α⊥(T ); probability to turnover 180° equals α−(T ).
These conditional probabilities are determined by the chain rigidity, and, in general, depend on the temperature (see below). Information on the spatial distribution of the molecular weight is contained in the distribution function G(Rn , n), which determines the probability that the n link of the chain, the beginning of which was at the origin of coordinates, after wandering in all the possible directions x, y and z, appeared to be in the lattice node with coordinates Rn ≡{Rnx = l0 mx , Rny = l0 my , Rnz = l0 mz }. At n = N distribution function G(RN , N) determines the probability of the fact that the chain end has shifted relative to its beginning by vector RN . This distribution
62
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
function G(RN , N) is calculated as the result of averaging on all the possible wandering trajectories:
(
)
(2.23)
N ⎛ ⎞ G R N , N = δ ⎜ R N − l0 ∑ e(n) ⎟ , ⎝ ⎠ n
N here l0 ∑ e( n) – is the vector connecting the beginning and the end of the chain, e(n) − is n the vector corresponding to the lattice edge where the leap at the n step of wandering occurs (the same vector e(n)≡e(l) corresponds to the n chain link, l = l0n, l0 − is the length of the lattice edge, corresponding to the length of one chain link), and brackets
...
mean
averaging on all the possible wandering trajectories. When averaging out the left part of the equation (2.23), there appear interesting analogies with the Ising chain as well as the Dirac equation (in the imaginary time) for a relative quantum mechanical particle (mathematical details are described in detail in [38]). The results show that when the end rigidity of the macromolecule is taken into account, it distribution function G(Rn , n) does not appear to be Gaussian, even if the chain length tends to infinity. After the transition to the continuous limit (the chain length l = l0n), the expression for the desired distribution function (in Fourier presentation on coordinates в) is as follows: ⎡ (1 − θ )(1 − E )l ⎤ 1 − E ⎡ (1 − θ )(1 + E )l ⎤ ~ G(p, l ) = 1 + E exp⎢− ⎥ − 2 E exp⎢− ⎥ 2E 2 θ l 2θ l0 0 ⎣ ⎦ ⎣ ⎦
where
(2.24)
2 E = 1 − l02p 2 2θ (1 + θ ) 3(1 − θ ) , θ = α+ – α– – is the parameter characterizing
the chain rigidity (θ = 0 corresponds to the absolutely flexible chain, and θ = 1 – corresponds to the rigid rod). From expression (2.24) it follows that even at asymptotically large chain length, distribution function is not Gaussian, which in Fourier presentation looks as follows:
(
~ GГ (p, l ) = exp − p 2l0l 6
)
(2.25)
If, however, the macromolecule rigidity is negligibly small (this means that parameter θ → 0), and it is possible to factor the function root E in the following row:
2 E ≈ 1 − l02p 2 θ (1 + θ ) 3(1 − θ ) , it appears that the first summand in the right part of the
equation (2.24) transforms into an expression which fully coincides with the Gaussian distribution function (2.25), and the second summand in the right part (2.24) at sufficiently large molecule length l tends to zero. Thus, the statistics of oligomer macromolecules conformations appears to be nonGaussian. However, a preliminary distribution function analysis of macromolecules possessing end rigidity shows that the conformations statistics of these chains is always nonGaussian irrespective of their length. Nevertheless, it is well known that the approximation of
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
63
Gaussian statistics works well for polymer (i.e., sufficiently long) chains. For these reasons it is very important to find the chain length and the conditions at which the non-Gaussian character of macromolecules conformations statistics and the same parameters at which Gaussian approximation is enough are to be taken into account. In order to answer the given question, paper [36] gives an analysis of the dependence of the root-mean-square size of the molecules with the end interlink rigidity (square of the distance between the beginning and the end of the chain) on chain length l=l0N and its “effective rigidity” θ, which, in its turn, depends on temperature T . Using (2.24) it is easy to calculate: 2 ~ 1 + θ ⎧⎪ 1 − exp(− l lкор ) ⎫⎪ = l0l ⎨1 − R 2 (l ) = − ∂ 2 G (p, l ) ⎬ 1 − θ ⎪⎩ l lкор ∂p ⎪⎭ p =0
(2.26)
where correlation length lкор = [2θ /(1 – θ )]l0, and the parameter of “effective rigidity” θ = α+ – α– depends on temperature (T ), i.e. θ ≡ θ (T ). There are two possible extreme cases: bending rigidity of the chain is small, which corresponds to condition θ << 1, and bending rigidity of the chain is large, which corresponds to condition 1 – θ ≡ ε << 1. At small values of θ (θ << 1, i.e. κ /T << 1) and at large values of l dependence (2.26) becomes linear, i.e. it corresponds to Gaussian coil:
R 2 (l ) ≈ l0l ⋅ (1 − lкор l ).
(2.27)
At θ close to 1 (1 –θ ≡ ε << 1, i.e. κ /T >> 1), and comparatively small values of l (l ≤ l0/ε) the obtainable dependence describes a practically rigid rod:
R 2 (l ) ≈ l 2 {1 − ε l 3l0 }.
(2.28)
However, even at θ close to 1, and rather large values of l (κ /T >> 1, 1 –θ = ε << 1, 2 l >> l0/ε) the squared dependence 〈R 〉 on l transforms asymptotically into a linear one
R 2 (l ) =
1+θ l0l = lK l 1−θ
(2.29)
which corresponds to chain transformation into a Gaussian coil. 2 Here we introduced value lК = 〈R 〉/l = [(1 + θ )/(1 – θ )]l0, which, by definition, represents the Kuhn segment of a macromolecule (the number of chain links in the Kuhn segment: nК = (1 + θ )/(1 – θ )). Note that the Kuhn segment length lК differs from correlation length lкор. This difference is related to transformation to the continuous limit. However, at small values of chain rigidity (θ << 1), all its characteristics practically do not depend on the
64
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
correlation length, and at 1 –θ = ε << 1 (rigid molecule) both values practically coincide (the difference is infinitesimal ε). 2 Dependencies (2.26) 〈R 〉 on l for some values of parameter θ (θ = 0.1; 0.5; 0.9; 0.99) are given in Figure 2.4. Note that for curves 1 and 2 asymptotic form is typical (2.27), and for curves 3 and 4 − (2.28).
Figure 2.4. Dependence of the mean square size of a chain 〈R2〉 on the chain length N = l /l0 at θ = 0,1 − 1; 0,5 − 2; 0,9 − 3; 0,99 − 4.
If we consider the chain length which only insignificantly exceeds the Kuhn segment (includes 2-3 Kuhn segments) as the criterion to neglect the non-Gaussian character of conformations statistics, then it appears that up to the value of θ = 0.4, the value of nК ≈ 1, and we can use the Gaussian statistics practically for any chain length. It is only at θ = 0.9 that the value of nК ≈ 10, i.e. limits of the chain length appear. Nevertheless, it is well known that for a flexible chain, Gaussian statistics works even for very short chains (3–4 chain links), and, it seems that the same criterion should work for the chains possessing a certain bending rigidity. It has experimentally been proven, however, that for the chains with a relatively small rigidity, there is a certain interval in homologous rows in which the system properties are not the properties of low molecular weight compounds, yet, it is wrong to say that the properties of these compounds are not the properties of polymers. This contradiction can be resolved if we use another criterion of the chain length estimation. This is to be the length at which we may neglect the non-Gaussian character of 2 conformational statistics. The scale at which the dependence of 〈R 〉 on N transforms into a 2 linear one can be chosen as this kind of criterion. In this case 〈R 〉 can be represented as a power function with the exponent depending on the chain length. It is clear that at small values of chain length this value may be equal to 2, and at very large values of chain length it may be equal to 1. The chain length at which this value does not exponentially differ from 1
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
65
is taken as critical length lГ, starting with which the chain conformational statistics can be considered Gaussian (i.e. this scale of lengths can be considered as the boundary between oligomers and polymers). The required value can be found through calculating the logarithmic derivative of the mean square of the chain size by chain length logarithm: (∂ln〈R2〉)/∂lnN. This dependence is given in Figure 2.5. Figure 2.5 shows that the second criterion gives significantly larger values of critical chain length lГ than the first criterion based on the estimation of the Kuhn segment lК. It appeared that at θ = 0.1 the value of nГ = lГ/l0 ≈ 10, at θ =0.25 − nГ = lГ/l0 ≈ 15, at θ =0.5 − nГ = lГ/l0 ≈ 20, and at θ =0.75 and θ = 0.9 − nГ = lГ/l0 > 100. The second criterion is preferable if we consider it connected with the scale at which polymer chain statistics becomes Gaussian.
Figure 2.5. Dependence of a logarithmic derivative of a mean square chain size with respect to the 2 chain length logarithm (∂ln〈R 〉)/∂lnN on the chain length N = l /l0 at θ = 0.1 − 1; 0,25 − 2; 0,5 − 3; 0,75 − 4; 0,9 − 5.
The dependence of the chain bending rigidity parameter θ on temperature can be derived from the following [38]. Because orientations of the neighboring chain links are not equiprobable and they correspond to the valence angles of the monomer chemical bond, their relative statistic weights are determined by the energy difference between the states Δε , and transformation from one relative orientation to another one is active through overcoming a certain energy barrier ΔE. At the same time, the statistical flexibility of the chain is determined by the difference in energy minima Δε of the corresponding valence angles, and the dynamic flexibility of the chain is determined by the height of the energy barrier between these states ΔE. If ΔE << Δε, and ΔE ~ T, then macromolecules are in an equilibrium conformational state and their statistical properties are determined by statistical flexibility. If we have a reverse
66
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
inequality ΔE >> Δε, then the mechanism of dynamic rigidity prevails, and the macromolecule may be in non-equilibrium conformational state. It is obvious, that the turn of the two neighboring chain links through the angles of π/2 and π is determined by activation energies E1 and E2 (E1<E2). The question is whether these energies E1 and E2 correspond to the energy difference between the conformational states of the chain links, or the energy barriers between them are not essential for this case. Taking into account the fact that macroscopic properties of macromolecular systems are usually determined by the statistical rigidity of the chains, it is much more natural to interpret energies E1 and E2 as energy differences between the conformational states of the chain links. With this interpretation, probabilities αi (α+; α−; α⊥) are proportional to exp(–Ei /T), and the temperature dependence of parameter θ is determined by the difference of energies E1 and E2:
θ (T ) =
1 − exp(− E2 T ) , 1 + 4 exp(− E1 T ) + exp(− E2 T )
(2.30)
In extreme cases of high and low temperatures, when, correspondingly, E1,2/T << 1 and E1,2/T >> 1, we receive
θ (T ) ≈ E2 6T ,
E2 T << 1,
(2.31a)
and
θ (T ) ≈ 1 − 4 exp ( − E1 T ) , E2 T > E1 T >> 1.
(2.31b)
Using expressions (2.31), we find the macromolecule mean square sizes at high temperature and low temperature limits:
R 2 ( N ) ≈ l0l{1 − E2 3Tl}, E2 T << 1,
(2.32a)
R 2 (l ) ≈ l 2 {1 − 4l exp(− E1 T ) 3l0 },
(2.32b)
and
E1 T >> 1.
It should be noted that at high temperatures deviations of the macromolecule size from the Gaussian coil size is inverse to temperature T, yet, at low temperatures, deviations of the macromolecule size from the straight linear rod depends on the temperature much stronger, that is exponentially. It means that with the growth of the temperature, rigid molecule quickly looses its straight linear characteristic; however, it acquires the Gaussian coil form only at sufficiently large temperatures. The above given analysis provides a theoretical justification of the statements which were declared in Part 1.1.3. In particular, it has been shown that the conformational states statistics of the chains which possess the end interlink bending rigidity can differ strongly from the
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
67
Gaussian statistics. Moreover, the non-Gaussian character of the macromolecule conformational statistics exists even in case when the dependence of the average size of this coil coincides with the Gaussian coil size: 〈R2(l)〉 ~ l. It should be underlined once again that this only seems to be a contradiction. It is obvious that in case of the smallest scale, the spatial function of molecular weight distribution differs from the Gaussian function. However, if this distribution can be averaged at the scale of the “straight” sections of the chain, then the spatial distribution of these “elementary” links can be considered Gaussian. The size of these “straight” sections of the chain can be easily estimated: in terms of the occasional wanderings model, the number of links in this section is equal to the average number of steps before the first turn
n = 1 ⋅ (α + + α − ) + 2 ⋅ (α + + α − )2 + 3 ⋅ (α + + α − )3 + ... = d α+ + α− , = (α + + α − ) ∑ z n = 2 dz n z =α +α ( − α − α ) 1 + − + −
(2.3)
and, therefore, the desired length is equal to
lпр =
(α + + α − )l0 . (1 − α + − α − )2
(2.34)
In the order of magnitude, this length coincides with the chain length lГ, where the dependence of the mean square size of the macromolecule on its length becomes linear (see Figure 2.5 and comments to it). This characteristic size of the macromolecule significantly exceeds the Kuhn segment size, traditionally calculated as the ratio between the mean square size of the macromolecule and its length (see (2.29)) or as the correlation length in the exponentially damped function of orientations correlation. Using ratio (2.34) we can estimate the number of chain links making the straight line section of the chain. For example, at the given values of parameters α+ + α− = 0.9 this section has 90 chain links. If α+ >> α− , then θ = α+ – α− ~ α+ + α− = 0.9. Figure 2.5 shows that the dependence 〈R2(l)〉 becomes linear at the same value of N, while the calculation according to formula nК ≈ 〈R2(l)〉/l gives a lower value (see comments to Figure 2.5). Therefore, if we use an expression like (2.34) as the criterion to estimate the characteristic scale of the macromolecule, where we can start to neglect the chain length rigidity, and if this very scale is used as the Kuhn segment, it will be much more adequate to the physical meaning of this concept than the usually applied criterion based on the exponential infinitesimal of the correlation function. The non-Gaussian character of the chain links can appear in two cases: if the resolution of the device (characteristic scale of the sensing electrode interaction with the molecule), used to estimate the polymer molecule state is smaller than the Kuhn segment; if the chain length is comparative to this scale or exceeds this scale insufficiently. It is these molecules that can be considered oligomers. There is also another important conclusion that follows from the above given analysis. It is not only physical and chemical properties of individual molecules, but also their
68
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
temperature that can determine low molecular weight, oligomer or polymer state of the compound. Parameter θ depends on the temperature exponentially, thus the length of the Kuhn segment can also change strongly with the change of the temperature. As the result, a compound which behaves like a flexible chain polymer at a certain temperature may change its properties and become an oligomer with the decrease of the temperature. A reverse situation is also possible, when with a sufficient increase of the temperature, a typical oligomer starts behaving like a flexible chain polymer. On the other hand, temperature transitions like oligomer ↔ polymer are not obligatory for all the substances. Physical and chemical properties of some molecules may have no transition of this kind in the range of the temperature from polymer (oligomer) melting to destruction.
2.2.3. Orientational Ordering of Oligomer Molecules: Influence of Environment Scaling estimations given in Part 2.2.1, have shown that concentrated rigid chain polymer or oligomer systems always possess a local orientational ordering, which, at certain conditions, can result in orientational self-ordering of the system as a whole. In the approximation of the average field, paper [38] shows the conditions at which these systems obtain orientational ordering, and transformations which occur between the ordered and nonordered states. Following is the analysis of some results of this research, concerning the peculiarities of this phenomenon conditioned by the specifics of the oligomer systems. These results do not only confirm but also add to the scaling estimations of the local anisotropy influence in oligomer systems on their macroscopic properties. The approach taken in [38] is based on the same background of the model of orientationally correlated wanderings which could describe the non-Gaussian conformational statistics of oligomer chains (see Part 2.2.2). The behavior of a sample chain in the environment of the ones alike is studied. During the spatial placing of this sample chain, the orientation of each one of its links is influenced by the orientation of the neighboring links along the chain as well as the orientation of the links of the neighboring chains. In case of a two-dimensional space, the degree of the system orientational ordering is characterized by the order parameter which is defined as the difference between the share of the monomer links nx and ny, oriented along the directions of x and y (ni = Ni/N, N = ΣNi , i = x, y):
η = nx − n y =
Nx − N y Nx + N y
.
(2.35)
If all the links of the polymer chains are oriented along the x direction then the order parameter η = 1; if they are oriented along the y direction then η = –1, and if the system as a whole is isotropic then η = 0. (Note that with this definition of the system orientational ordering, when every link is not a vector, but a director, a high degree of ordering can denote absolute straightening of the chain as well as formation of a folded structure.) The influence of the environmental orientation means that the probability of the direction choice at every step of wandering corresponding to the next chain link, can be renormed, and,
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
69
in this case, it depends not only on the properties of the chain itself, but also on the environmental orientation: • • •
probability to move in the same direction α+(T ) equals α+(T ) + δ+(η, T ); probability to move in a perpendicular direction α⊥(T ) equals α⊥(T ) – (δ+(η, T ) + δ– (η, T ))/2; probability to turn through the angle of π α–(T ) equals α–(T ) + δ–(η, T ).
Functions δ±(η) grow monotonously in the interval (–1, 1), and at the boundaries of this interval at η = 0 – they satisfy the conditions
⎧− α ± , ⎪ δ ± (η ) = ⎨0, ⎪α ± γ , ⎩ ⊥
η = −1, η = 0, η = 1,
(2.36)
the first one of which means that it is impossible to keep the orientation in the y direction, and the last one means that it is impossible to turn through the angle of 90°, if the environment is oriented in the x direction. As the value of α± + δ±(η) has a probability meaning, at any η the condition to be satisfied is 0 ≤ α± + δ±(η) ≤ 1. Parameterγ, determining the ratio between the straight line and the folded conformations of the chain in the highly oriented state satisfies the inequality – (α+ + α⊥) ≤ γ ≤ α– + α⊥. The basic idea of the system orientational state is to determine the share of the sampling chain links nx(η) and ny(η), oriented along directions x and y, depending on the orientational state of the environment (on the value of the order parameter η), within the model of orientationally self-correlated wanderings on the regular lattice. If the order parameter (in accordance with definition (2.35)) is expressed through the values of nx(η) and ny(η), a self-consistent equation is found which relates the order parameter η to the functions of δ±(η):
η=
β (η ) − β (−η ) 4α ⊥ − [β (η ) + β (−η )]
(2.37)
where β(η) = δ+(η) + δ-(η) – is a function which monotonously increases in the interval (–1, 1), at the boundaries of this interval at η = 0 function β+(η) satisfies the conditions (see boundary conditions for function δ±(η))
⎧− (1 − 2α ⊥ ), ⎪ β (η ) = ⎨0, ⎪2α , ⎩ ⊥
η = −1, η = 0, η = 1.
(2.38)
Note that parameterγ, determining the ratio between the straight line and folded conformations of the chain in the highly oriented state is not present in the self-consistent
70
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
equation (2.37). This can be explained by the fact that the degree of the system orientational ordering is determined just by parallelism or perpendicularity of the chain links to the isolated direction, while parallel or antiparallel relative orientations of the two links are considered equivalent. Within the phenomenological study, the apparent view of the function β(η) is unknown, therefore it is represented as expansion to the degrees according toη. With this expansion polynomial to the 4th degree is enough:
[
β (η ) = 12 (1 − a )η − (1 − 4α ⊥ )(1 − b)η 2 + aη 3 − (1 − 4α ⊥ )bη 4
]
(2.39)
where a and b are parameters which characterize the ordering influence of the environment. Taking into account (2.39), equation (2.38) takes on form:
η=
η (1 − a + aη 2 ) 4α ⊥ + (1 − 4α ⊥ )η 2 (1 − b + bη 2 )
(2.40)
Depending on the values of parameters a, b and α⊥, equation (2.40) can have from three up to five physical solutions, where three solutions correspond to the isotropic state of the system (η1 = 0), and two solutions correspond to the full orientational ordering of the system (η2,3 = ±1). They satisfy the equation (2.40) at any values of parameters a, b and α⊥. At some values of parameters a, b and α⊥, however, the equation (2.40) has two other non-trivial solutions
η± = ±
a − (1 − 4α ⊥ ) , which correspond to the partially ordered states. (1 − 4α ⊥ )b
When analyzing the stability of the equation (2.40) solutions, it was estimated that at b > 0 states η± are unstable, state η1 = 0 is stable at a > 1 – 4α⊥, and states η2,3 = ±1 are stable at a < (1 – 4α⊥)(1 + b). This means that at b > 0 and 1 – 4α⊥ < a < (1 – 4α⊥)(1 + b) both isotropic and fully ordered states are stable, unstable states η± are between them, i.e. a typical situation of bistability is to be here (see Figure 2.6, b > 0). At b < 0 we get a quite different picture: states η± are stable, state η1 = 0 is stable at a > 1 – 4α⊥, and states η2,3 = ±1 are stable at a < (1 – 4α⊥)(1 + b). The regions where the nonordered and ordered states are stable do not overlap; in the transition region the degree of the system ordering smoothly changes from minimal to maximal or, vise versa, from maximal to minimal. This means that at b < 0 the transition from the ordered state into the non-ordered state (and back) is not uneven like at b > 0, but smooth at a certain end interval of the parameters values (see Figure 2.6, b < 0). In case the width of the transition interval changes to zero, the reconstruction of the system state takes place as a jump (see Figure 2.6, b = 0). Parameters α⊥ and a can change depending on the exterior conditions, for example, if the system temperature changes. Both the effective rigidity of the chain (parameter α⊥), and the ordering influence of the environment (parameter a) are the functions of temperature. It is natural to suppose that α⊥(T ), changes from 0 at (T = 0) to 1/4 (at T =→ ∞) according to the Arrhenius law: (4α⊥(T ) = exp(–Eж/kT )), and a(T ) obeys the same law, but with a different activation energy (a(T ) = exp(–Eор/kT )); the value of 1 – a(T ) decreases from 1 to 0 with the
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
71
increase of the temperature. Corresponding bifurcational diagrams, where the control parameter is the dimensionless temperature τ = kT/Eж, Eор = Eж/2, and parameter b = ±0.3 or 0, are given in Figure 2.6 (b > 0, b < 0 and b = 0).
Figure 2.6. Bifurcation diagrams for the order parameter, which characterizes orientation ordering of a system at b=0,3>0 (bistability is observed in the temperature range τ1 - τ2), b=–0,3<0 (smooth transition between ordered and disordered states occurs in the temperature range τ1 - τ2), b = 0 (jump-like transition occurs between ordered and disordered states). The guiding parameter is a dimensionless temperature τ=kT/El. Stable states are marked with solid lines, unstable states are marked with dashed lines.
The same study has been done for a three-dimensional case. The peculiarity of the threedimensional state makes one scalar order parameter not enough to describe the degree of ordering. That is why we used the shares of monomers ni = Ni/N, oriented along directions x, y and z (ΣNi = N, i = x, y, z) as order parameters; for these values the normalization requirement is valid nx + ny + nz + = 1. For the three-dimensional space within the model of orientationally self-correlated wanderings on the regular cubic lattice we determined the share of the sample chain links nx(η), ny(η) and nz(η), oriented along directions x, y and z depending on the orientational state of the environment. As the result, we obtained a system of self-consistent equations, the solutions of which describe the orientational state of the system. Graphically the system of stationary states can be presented on the plane nx + ny + nz = 1, where a regular triangle has been cut; it corresponds to the region of physical values of parameters 0 ≤ ni ≤ 1 (see Figure 2.7).
72
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
Figure 2.7. State diagram of a three-dimensional system. a – isotropic (I) state; b – transition to the cholesteric ordering; c – cholesteric (Ch) state; d – transition to nematic ordering; e – nematic (N) state; • – stable state, ° – unstable state
The meaning of the obtained solutions is as follows. Unlike a two-dimensional system where only one transition (rigid or smooth) occurs, a three-dimensional system has a cascade of transitions. If the links of the macromolecules were initially in the non-ordered state, with the change of conditions they start getting oriented parallel to a certain plane. No orientational order can be observed in the plane itself, i.e. this situation is similar to the cholesteric state. Only when almost all the links of the macromolecules take an orientation parallel to a certain plane, orientational ordering in the plane takes place: the links start to line up along a certain director in the plane of cholesteric ordering. As the result, the system moves to a fully orientationally ordered state similar to nematic. The type of transition (rigid or smooth) that is realized at the first and second stages of ordering depends on the values of coefficients in the self-consistent equations. Among these coefficients are two linearly independent parameters after all conditions are satisfied (like conditions (2.36) or (2.38)).
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
73
Note that the stage mechanism which can be used for the ordering of a three-dimensional system (first, a plane ordering, and then a complete ordering) makes the question of kinetic accessibility of the ordered states solved, though partially. Thus, within the model of orientationally correlated wanderings an isotropic at high temperatures system turns into a highly-oriented state with the decrease of the temperature. The transition described here, unlike the usual one, possesses a peculiarity. Usually, a system consisting of anisotropic elements turns into an anisotropic state with the decrease of the temperature because of the tendency towards ordering conditioned by the steric limits and/or by the orienting interaction of anisotropic elements. This tendency prevails over the disordering entropic factors. For the case studied here, an additional ordering factor appears, that is, the increase of the chain effective rigidity and, therefore, anisotropy of the system elements with the decrease of the temperature. As the result, we can obtain a liquid crystal system with the decrease of the temperature in a fully isotropic system. Although the study carried out here is not absolutely complete, it allows us to make a number of important conclusions. First, besides the phase transition of the 1st type (rigid appearance of the anisotropic phase), the 2d type transition is also possible. For oligomer systems this fact is essential. The 2d type transition systems are characterized by the following phenomenon. Correlated regions of finitesimal dimensions (the correlation radius is finitesimal) appear in the system before the point of transition into the ordered state. With the approach to the transition point the dimensions of these regions increase and in the very point they tend to infinity. In other words, the closer is the system to the transition point the more probable is the appearance of correlated regions in it, and the larger the dimensions of these regions are. Therefore, if the state parameters make the system not too far from the transition point, then orientationally correlated regions exist in the system even in the non-ordered state. In this book these regions are called cybotactic groupings. Second, it is well-known that the conditions of transition into the oriented state depend on the chain length [49,62-64]. For example, it has been shown that the transition into the rotational phase* occurs only in chains, the length of which is no more than 100-120 monomer units [64]. At the same time, the transition temperature decreases with the decrease of the chain length. This fact can be interpreted as follows: for long (polymer) chains (if the system does not possess any specific orienting interchain interactions) the mechanism of local orientationally ordered regions appearance is suppressed. It can be realized only for relatively short (oligomer) macromolecules. For very short chains the transition conditions are complicated (the transition temperature is lower), and, ceteris paribus, the tendency to local orientational ordering for the systems consisting of shorter chains is lower than for the systems consisting of longer chains. On the other hand, shorter chains are more mobile, and, from the kinetic point of view, the formation of orientationally correlated regions in them is *
According to Muller [61], rotational transitions are connected with the rotation of molecular chains around the “long axes”. Systems which consist of macromolecules possessing anisotropic bending rigidity and rotational degrees of freedom (“spin” of the chain around its axis which changes the direction of bending anisotropy) at certain conditions can move into the so-called “rotational phase”. The rotational phase is characterized by nematic ordering of the chain; rotational degrees of freedom remain ordered. It is the presence of non-correlated rotational degrees of freedom that differentiates the rotational phase of polymers from nematic. The rotational phase is characterized by a layer structure, where elongated macromolecules form monomolecular layers. The packing of the elongated chains in these layers as well as the packing of the layers themselves can be different, i.e. there are several types of rotational phases
74
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
more probable. As the result, these two factors, thermodynamic and kinetic, compete with one other, and, in macromolecular systems consisting of chains the lengths of which are not very large (and not very small), formation of locally oriented regions is possible. In other words, tendency to local orientational self-organization is peculiar not to all macromolecular compounds but only to relatively short homologues – oligomers.
2.2.4. Free Energy of Oligomer Molecules It has already been noted above (see Part 2.2.2) that the volume of the chain possessing a certain interchain rigidity is much larger than the corresponding volume of a flexible chain. Papers [3, 32, 65] show that if the Kuhn segment of the polymer molecule equals nК, than the size of the phantom chain (without the effects of the excluded volume) has the following order: 12
RRF ∝ l0 nk ⎛⎜ N nk ⎞⎟ ⎝
⎠
= l0 nk1 2 N 1 2 ∝ nk1 2 RFF
(2.41a)
and the size of the real (without self-intersection) chain is:
RRR ∝ l0 nk ⎛⎜ N nk ⎞⎟ ⎝
⎠
35
= l0 nk 2 5 N 3 5 ∝ nk 2 5 RFR
(2.41b)
The excess of the free volume inside the coil formed by molecules possessing interchain rigidity can be taken by the other chains. However, this leads to limits for certain conformations of the chains, and, therefore, the number of the degrees of freedom in the chain decreases. As the result, entropy of each of the chains decreases, which is thermodynamically unprofitable. Papers [66-68] describe this situation. It has been shown that entropic losses can be compensated by gain in energy. Within the model of orientationally correlated wanderings on a regular lattice, paper [67] considers a single phantom chain. The elastic energy of the chain is described as
H(N ) = κ
N ⎧ ⎪
∑ ⎨1−
n = 1⎪⎩
⎫
e( n) ⋅ e( n +1) ⎪ ⎬ ⎪ l02 ⎭
(2.42)
The symbols are the same as in Part 2.2.1: vector e(n)≡e(l ) corresponds to the nth chain link (l = l0 n, l0 − the length of the lattice edge, corresponding to the length of one chain link; the total chain length equals L = l0 ( N + 1)). Two neighboring chain links with the same orientation (the chain does not bend here) contribute nothing to the elastic energy of the chain. When calculating the potential energy of the chain bending this level equals zero.
which differ by the packing of the oriented chains as well as the orientation of the nematic ordering axis relative to the molecular layer plane. For details see [61-64]
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
75
Further on the following symbols have been accepted: if the chain turns through the angle of π /2, the corresponding contribution to the elastic energy of the chain equals ε⊥ = κ; if the chain turns through the angle of π , it equals ε– = 2κ = 2ε⊥. Thus, if due to the molecule conformation, the chain turned n⊥ times through the angle of π /2; n– times through the angle of π, and n+ = N – n⊥ + n– times the chain kept its orientation, the elastic energy of the chain equals:
H ( N , n⊥ , n− ) = n⊥ε ⊥ + n−ε −
(2.43)
The share of conformations corresponding to the set value of elastic energy:
Z( N , H ) =
⎧ n ε +n ε ⎫ 1 ∑ [exp⎨⎩− ⊥ ⊥ T − − ⎬⎭ × N (2d ) {n+ , n⊥ , n− }
(2.44)
× δ ( n+ + n⊥ + n− − N )δ ( n⊥ ε ⊥ + n−ε − − H )], where d – is the dimension of space (d=2 on the plane and d=3 in the space), δ(n) = 1, if n = 0 and δ(n) = 0, if n ≠ 0, temperature T in energy units. Free energy F and chain entropy S are expressed through the value of Z(N, H) by a standard method:
F ( N , H ) = −T ln Z (n, H ), S ( N , H ) = ln Z (n, H ) + H T
(2.45)
After corresponding transformations (2.44) we received an expression for the free energy of the system F(NH):
F ( N , H ) = −T ln Z( N , H ) = − 0,5ln 2π + κn + 2 NT ln 2 − T (2 N + 0,5) ln(2 N ) + + T ( n + 0,5) ln n + T (2 N − n + 0,5) ln(2 N − n), where n = H/κ . The minimum of free energy (by parameter n) is achieved at n ≈ Fmin ( N ) = − κ + ln 2π + T ln( N 2) − 2 NT ln{[1 + exp(− κ T )] 2}. 2
(2.46)
2N , then: 1 + exp(κ T ) (2.47)
Expression (2.47) sets the value of free energy for the phantom rigid chain molecule in a thermodynamically equilibrium state. Prohibitions for self-intersections were taken into account and the chain was considered more rigid, i.e. an effective rigidity of the chain was introduced κ∗ > κ , which resulted in the increase of the Kuhn segment of the molecule studied. If ratio (2.41а) is presented as
76
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev 12
RR ∝ l0 nk* ⎛⎜ N nk* ⎞⎟ ⎝
⎠
n*К = nК ( N nК )
15
12
= l0 nk*
N1 2
12
n*К
and
= nК 2 5 N 3 5 − 1 2 ,
i.e.
> nК , we receive a new ratio (2.41б). Therefore, for a real chain in a
thermodynamically equilibrium state the value of free energy is expressed as ∗ ⎧ ⎫ FР ( N ) = − κ + ln 2π + T ln( N 2) − 2NT ln ⎨⎡⎢1 + exp⎛⎜⎝ − κ ∗ T ⎞⎟⎠ ⎤⎥ 2⎬. 2 ⎣ ⎦ ⎩ ⎭
(2.48)
connection between κ∗ and κ on condition κ >> T is κ ∗ = κ 4 5 ( NT )1 5 . If the molecules exist independently of each other, free energy for each of the chains is calculated through the ratio (2.48). If interactions start, e.g., an aggregate is formed, their free energy changes. This change is related to the increase of the excluded volume conditioned by the prohibitions for chains intersections. On the one hand, due to this prohibition for intersections with other molecules it is impossible to realize some conformations of the chains. This means that the number of the degrees of freedom for each of the chains decreases. In the expression of free energy (2.48) the number of the degrees of freedom is set by the number of the chain links (N ); prohibition for some of the conformations will result in the decrease of the N value. On the other hand, prohibitions for the intersections of the chains compensate the prohibitions for self-intersection, and a real chain behaves like a phantom chain. This means that the effective rigidity of the chain κ∗, introduced in (2.48) decreases with the increase in the number of chains within the aggregate. At a certain degree of aggregation, the rigidity coefficient κ∗ takes its initial value κ . With the further increase of the chains concentration in the coil, their effective rigidity starts increasing again. This phenomenon is connected with the fact that the chain consists of almost straight sections which, starting from a certain critical concentration, obtain a correlated orientation. The same thing happens when the steric limits are considered for a system of rigid rods of finite width [49] –orientational ordering of the straight line sections appears in the aggregate of the chains, different chain bends are to be synchronized. Thus, for a chain within the aggregate of molecules, free energy is expressed as (2.48), however, parameters N and κ∗ do change: ∗ FА ( N ) = − κ − δκ + ln 2π + T ln⎛⎜⎝ N − δN ⎞⎟⎠ − 2 2
(2.49)
⎧
⎫
⎩
⎭
⎡ ∗ ⎛ ⎞⎤ − 2( N − δN )T ln ⎪⎨ 1 ⎢1 + exp⎜⎜ − κ − δκ ⎟⎟ ⎥⎪⎬. T ⎠ ⎥⎦⎪ ⎝ ⎪ 2 ⎢⎣
Resolution of expression (2.49) in a line (considering the change of values N and κ∗ to be small, the first summands remain) gives:
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems ⎧ ⎡ ⎤⎫ FА ( N ) = Fт ( N ) − ⎪⎨ T − 2T ln ⎢ 1 ⎛⎜⎜1 + exp⎛⎜ − κ ∗ T ⎞⎟ ⎞⎟⎟⎥ ⎪⎬δN − ⎝ ⎠ ⎠⎦ ⎪⎭ ⎪⎩ N ⎣2 ⎝
77
(2.50)
⎧ ⎫ ∗ ⎛ ⎞ ⎪ 2 N exp⎜ − κ T ⎟ ⎪ ⎪ ⎝ ⎠ −⎨ − 1 ⎪⎬δκ *, 2⎪ ⎪ 1 + exp⎛⎜ − κ ∗ T ⎞⎟ ⎝ ⎠ ⎩⎪ ⎭⎪
where δN is always positive, and δκ∗, depending on the number of chains in the aggregate can be both positive and negative. It is essential that with the decease of parameters N and κ∗ free energy of the system decreases. Expression (2.50) shows that there are two positive summands in the brackets by which δN is multiplied, and the first summand in the brackets by which δκ∗ is multiplied is equal to the number of the Kuhn segments on the chain length according to the order of value, and it is always larger than 1/2. This is the way by which a limit is set to the length of the chain. Due to the entangling of the chains with one another, the effective value of parameter N always decreases, and parameter κ∗ decreases until the number of chains within one aggregate exceeds the critical value. Therefore, the formation of aggregates consisting of a limited number of chains is thermodynamically efficient. With the growth of the aggregate size, parameter κ∗ becomes positive. This positive sign of δκ∗ does not mean that further growth of aggregates becomes thermodynamically inefficient. Depending on the ratio between the value of effective decrease of parameter N and effective increase of parameter κ∗ this can be both efficient and inefficient thermodynamically. It follows from expression (2.50) that at κ∗/T >> 1 and not very large values of N (corresponding to oligomer state) with the increase of the temperature, thermodynamic equilibrium can shift to the increase of the finite size of the chain aggregates. Figure 2.8, where the dependence of value
[(
)]
T − 2T ln 1 1 + exp( − κ ∗ T ) 2 N y(T ) = 2N −1 1 + exp(κ ∗ T ) 2
characterizing the shift of thermodynamic equilibrium for aggregate formation with the change of the temperature, for different values of N, shows that the value of y(T) depends on the rigidity coefficient and the chain length. If y(T) decreases, then the aggregate formation becomes thermodynamically less efficient with the increase of the temperature; if y(T ) increases, then the aggregate formation becomes thermodynamically more efficient with the increase of the temperature.
78
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
Figure 2.8. The dependence of y(T) on Т at κ∗=10, N=150 and N=250.
2.3. SUPRAMOLECULAR STRUCTURE OF OLIGOMERS The probability of different supramolecular structures in oligomer liquids has been postulated in many papers (e.g., see [69-75]) with the purpose to explain the peculiarities of rheology, sorption, polymerization and other macroscopic properties of oligomers and oligomer mixtures. Depending on the experimental results obtained, supramolecular structures have been considered to possess different patterns which can explain some of these specific effects. Until present, however, the studies have been carried out without any quantitative consideration of the supramolecular structures formation kinetics, without any regard to their possible distribution according to their number, size, life cycles and etc. The analysis of the oligomer supramolecular structure as well as the analysis of any other level of any system structure (see Part 1.3) has to consider three factors: geometric (mutual arrangement of the system elements in the environment), thermodynamic (the stability of the system and minimization of free energy), and kinetic (the time of relaxation to equilibrium and the life cycle of a structural element) [76].
2.3.1. Geometric Image of Oligomer Supramolecular Structure For a liquid, the concept of supramolecular structure is much broader than the geometric image, it can be expressed only through the reflexion of the molecules thermal movement. Paper [77] stresses that the geometric image of the liquid can be expressed through the analysis of the dynamic set of configurations, generated by the particles of the system during their thermal movement. Here, the self-drift of the particle is to be taken into consideration as well as its correlation with the nearest environment. It is natural that at different time scales (e.g., at different expositions in the experiment), the structural characteristics of the liquid can
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
79
appear to be different, that is, (in the sequence of “instant pictures”) the kinetic factor can become essential.
2.3.2. Short Range Order When speaking of the supramolecular structure of the liquid, the local (short range) order is to be concerned first of all. In arbitrary choice of the particle, the neighbors of its first and second coordination spheres are located at certain distances. The size of the particle is determined by the average number of neighbors and the particles packing in each of the spheres. The appearance of the order in the structure, according to the paradox definition [50,78], is a violation of the symmetry in the sense of the following example: an isotropic (homogeneous in all directions inside the body) liquid is more symmetric than the anisotropic one; the appearance of the local ordering results in violation of the symmetry of the macroscopic structure as a whole. The concept of the molecules local ordering in a liquid (in contrast to “no gas structure”) appeared in the 1920-ies, when Stuart introduced the notion of “cybotactic area” [79]. The ideology of the particles aggregation in the liquid systems has had a long history (see papers [73,77,80-82]), the attempts to express this idea quantitatively within the “colloidal approximation” go back to the works of Smolukhovsky [83] and Osvald [84]. The further development of the liquid state theory is connected with the works of Ya. Frenkel, J. Bernal et al. (e.g. see [73,80-82]). The local ordering in the macroscopic volume of the liquid shows itself as a structural inhomogeneity. This inhomogeneity is not a phase structure, because it does not have an interface. It can be an element of both homogeneous and heterogeneous structures. The reasons for the appearance of the structural inhomogeneity of the liquid and, of liquid oligomers, in particular, can be both energetic and statistic. Supramolecular structures can be generated in oligomer systems due to the strong dipole-dipole interactions, hydrogen or complementary group bonds, Van der Waals and dispersion forces of molecules interaction, phase transition, or the existence of random fluctuations of the particles thermal movement, the scale of the latter significantly increases in the metastable area and in the critical point as the result of the distance intramolecular interaction appearance (in case of fair ratio of length and flexibility of the molecule) and statistic flexibility of molecules. That is, supramolecular structures can be formed in oligomer systems due to the reasons of different nature; this fact determines different scales of different inhomogeneities lifetimes. According to Landau, the liquid inhomogeneities are considered to be certain structures characterized by a finite size and a finite lifetime [50]. Dimensional and time scales of these fluctuations can change in a very wide range [3,50,73,77,80,39,85]. Moreover, these fluctuations can vary in the degree of the local anisotropy: according to paper [50] the dimensional and orientational arrangements of particles in the environment inside the fluctuation are not equiprobable, the directions of orientation may be different in different fluctuations though belonging to the same macroscopic volume.
80
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
2.3.3. Terminology The classical physical chemistry (e.g., see [86]) uses the concepts of an associate (the same name particles of the А+А →2А, А+А+А → 3А types) and a complex (different name particles of the А+В→АВ, А+В+А→АВА, В+А+В→ВАВ types) to describe the structure of the low molecular weight non-electrolytes solutions. Papers on oligmers give many different terms to describe the supramolecular inhomogeneities; some of the terms have been borrowed from the classical chemistry vocabulary, the others have been newly introduced. The examples of these terns are as follows: agglomerates, aggregates, ensembles, associates (homo- or self-associates), blobs, domains, half-finished products, clusters, complexes (heteroassociates), micelles, segregates, cybotactic groupings, and etc. Each of these terms can be used; each of them bears a certain meaning. In order to describe the supramolecular structures of the oligomer systems, this book mainly uses the following terms: “aggregate”, “associate”, and “cybotactic grouping”. When describing the supramolecular structures of oligomers, the concept of “aggregate” is the most general, it includes both associative and cybotactic structures. The terms “associate” and “cybotactic grouping” concern the liquid state of oligomers, they describe different types of the long-living (commensurable with the experimental methods resolution) supramolecular structures (aggregates), which differ in the special location and molecules orientation inside the inhomogeneity of the liquid. As noted above, the term “cybotactic grouping” (χιβωτοζ - ark) was introduced in the 1920-ies [79], however, it was finally approved much later, thanks to the fundamental summaries of Ya.Frenkel [80]. Now this term is widely used in the descriptions of the structure of both traditional low molecular weight organic and metallic liquids [87]. Papers on polymers often use another term, “cluster” (bunch, swarm). This term is close to “cybotactic grouping”, however, the probability of spatial orientation of the primary particles of this structural element has not been taken into account here. For this reason, another term, “nematic cluster” has been introduced, which, as well as the word combination “anisotropic associate”, is sometimes used to denote the cybotactic areas of the liquid. These terms do reflect the physical meaning of the concept, however, they are too cumbersome. In order to differentiate the terms “associate” and “cybotactic grouping”, general and distinctive features can be used [80, 87-89]. General features: а) both structures are formed of the same name molecules, b) they are not the phase structures, c) their lifetime is longer than that of the average statistical fluctuations. The lifetime of the ith cybotactic grouping or the ith associate depends on the system composition and temperature; it is determine by the intermolecular interactions energy. Distinctive feature: cybotactic grouping are characterized by the different degrees of anisotropy in the spatial location of molecules; associates are always isotropic. At certain conditions associates can transform into cybotactic groupings and vice versa. The equilibrium macroscopic system possesses the following characteristic: the increase of ordering (aggregates formation, transfer associate → cybotactic grouping and etc.) in one area results in disordering in another area.
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
81
2.3.4. Associative-Cybotactic Schematics of Oligomer Liquid Supramolecular Structure A macroscopic oligomer system can be presented as a sum of microscopic subsystems (system elements) which exchange the substance and energy with each other and with the environment. It is not only the phase enclosures but also the supramolecular structures like concentration fluctuations with different time and space parameters that can represent these subsystems. Hypothetically we can consider a variety of models of the liquid supramolecular structure (e.g. see [80-82]).
K1 K2 Figure 2.9. Schematic presentation of associate ↔ Cybotaxis transition.
K3
a)
b)
K4
Figure 2.10. Diagrams of Cybotaxis ↔ Cybotaxis transition with various degree of anisotropy (а) and spatial orientation (b).
82
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
K5
+
a)
+
b)
K6
Figure 2.11. Schematic presentation of addition (separation) of «disorganized» molecule to Cybotaxis (а) and associate (b)
a)
b)
c)
Figure 2.12. Schematic presentation of a cybotaxic structure model of oligomer liquid. >⎯< «disorganized» molecule of a telechelate oligomer; cybotaxises are contoured with a dashed line. Cybotaxic liquids can differ on the number of cybotaxises in a unit of volume (а and b), on the size of cybotaxises (а and c).
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
83
Figures 2.9 – 2.12 show one of the possible schemes of the associate-cybotactic structure of the telechelatic oligomer liquid; the authors of this book accept this very scheme. The system is considered to consist of organized (aggregated) and non-organized molecules. The subsystem of aggregates, in its turn, can be divided into cybotactic groupings and associates. The direct and reverse transitions cybotactic grouping ↔ associate can occur at the same (k1 = k2) or at different (к1 ≠ к2 ) velocities (Figure 2.9). Cybotactic grouping can have different forms and degrees of anisotropy (Figure 2.10 а and b). The non-organized molecules can join or slip off aggregates (Figure 2.11). The aggregative liquids can have different life times of the aggregates, different numbers of aggregates in the same volume and different sizes of the aggregates (Figure 2.12).
2.4. THEORETICAL MODELS OF SUPRAMOLECULAR STRUCTURE FORMATION The peculiarities of the macroscopic properties (rheology, relaxation, diffusion, optical, sorption, and etc.), which were determined experimentally during the study of the oligomer systems (e.g., [90-101]), can be explained using the analogies with the quantitative models well known for the low molecular weight and polymer liquids, for example, the models of the liquid crystal state [102-106], the model of the “flickering clusters” [107, 108], and etc. [109113]. The explanations were often arbitrary, at the qualitative approximation level without any concern for the oligomer state specifics. Following are the considerations of some (of the many possible) theoretical models within the framework of the above given scheme (see Part 2.3.4 ), and, in some cases, these considerations provide a qualitative description of the aggregates formation kinetics, find the function of the aggregates distribution according to their size, the degree of the molecules anisotropy inside the aggregates, and predict the conditions at which the aggregative structure of oligomers can influence the macroscopic properties of the liquid oligomers.
2.4.1. Activation Model The following postulates make the basis of this theoretical model of the oligomer supramolecular structure formation [114-117]: • • •
•
the system consists of aggregates and “non-organized” molecules; there is a function of these aggregates distribution according to their number and size, it is determined by the preliminary history of the system; to reach a thermodynamically balanced function of these aggregates distribution according to their number and size, which does not depend on the initial conditions, the system is to overcome a certain energy barrier, determined by the nature of the components; the molecules activation (not in the chemical sense of the word), allowing them to form aggregates, occurs due to the thermal or mechanical (deformation) “injection” of energy into the system from the outside;
84
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev •
• • •
the external mechanical influence or the temperature increase can result in the activation of the “non-organized” molecules only (not included into the aggregates), but it does not influence the aggregates themselves; it is only due to the activated “non-organized” molecules joining that the aggregates size increases; aggregates can not dissociate and molecules can not split off them; the number of aggregates does not change during the process.
The theoretical approach to the aggregation process in paper [114] is based on the modified model of Becker-During, proposed in [118] to describe the continuous radical polymerization:
u&n = − vkn un + vkn − 1un − 1 + qn + 1un + 1 − qn un ,
u&1 = −vk1u1 + q2u2 , ∞
∞
n =1
n=2
n ≥ 2,
(2.51) (2.52)
v& = − v ∑ kn un + ∑ qn un ,
(2.53)
where un − is the concentration of aggregates, which consist of the n number of molecules; v − is the concentration of the separate molecules (a separate molecule and an aggregate consisting of 1 molecule have different physical natures); kn − is the constant of the velocity of separate molecules addition to an aggregate of the n size; qn − is the constant of the velocity of separate molecules splitting off an aggregate of the n size. For this case, it is supposed that these constants do not depend on the aggregate size n. Within the above given limits, the formation kinetics of the aggregates distribution according to their size, is described by the following system of equations:
u&n = − kvun + kvun −1,
n ≥ 2,
u&1 = − kvu1,
(2.54) (2.55)
∞
⎛
∞
⎞
n =1
⎝
n=2
⎠
v& = − vk ∑ un + p⎜⎜ c − ∑ nun − v⎟⎟ ,
(2.56)
where un − is the concentration of aggregates, which consist of the n number of molecules; v − is the concentration of the activated molecules, including the ones inside the aggregates; k − is the constant of the velocity of an activated molecule addition to an aggregate; p − is the constant of the molecules activation velocity; c − is the full concentration of the molecules in the system, including the activated molecules and the molecules inside the aggregate; a dot above the symbol denotes the time derivative.
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
85
The system of equations (2.54)–( 2.56) follows from equations (2.51)–(2.53) of the modified model of Becker-During, if qn ≡ 0, and a summand is added into equation (2.53), describing the process of the inert molecules activation. Using the formality of the generating function and introducing the function of two variables ∞
F ( z, t ) = ∑ z n un (t ).
(2.57)
∂ F ( z, t ) = ( z −1)kv(t )F ( z, t ). ∂t
(2.58)
n =1
or
the expressions for the w(t) function, related to the activated particles concentration v(t) by ratio dw(t)/dt = v(t) were obtained:
w(t ) =
c − Fz 0 ⎧⎪⎛ v0 kN ⎞ ⎟ 1− exp( − kNt )] − ⎨⎜⎜ p − c − Fz 0 ⎟⎠ [ kN ( p − kN ) ⎪⎩⎝
(2.59)
⎫ v0 ⎞ ⎛ 1− exp( − pt )]⎪⎬, − kF ⎜1− ⎟ [ ⎝ c − Fz 0 ⎠ ⎪⎭
where Fz0 = dF0(z)/dz, N =Σun = const − is the total number of aggregates in the system. For the concentration of aggregates: n um0 (2.60) un (t ) = exp − kw(t ) ∑ kw(t ) n − m, ( − )! n m m=1
[
]
[
]
as well as for
v( t ) =
c − Fz 0 ⎡⎛⎜ v kN ⎞⎟ ⎢ p− 0 exp( − kNt ) − ⎜ c − Fz 0 ⎟⎠ ( p − kN ) ⎢⎣⎝
(2.61)
v0 ⎞ ⎫⎤ ⎛ − p⎜1− exp( − pt )⎬⎥. ⎟ ⎝ c − Fz 0 ⎠ ⎭⎥⎦
2.4.2. Relaxation Model This model proposed in paper [119], unlike the activation model, considers the possibility of the aggregates growth as well as the possibility of their destruction. Apart from the first four postulates of the activation model, there are some additional conditions introduced. They take into account the peculiarities of relaxation and the equilibrium of the function of aggregates distribution according to their size:
86
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev •
on the way to equilibrium the distribution of the aggregates according to their size after the external influence changes due to separate activated molecules joining the aggregates and molecules splitting off the aggregates; the number of aggregates does not change in the course of the process, i.e. formation of new aggregates or dissociation of large aggregates does not occur; separate splitoff molecules can not serve as the basis for a new aggregate, they can only join the existing ones.
•
The relaxation kinetics of the earlier generated distribution of aggregates to the equilibrium state can be described by the above given system of equations (2.51)–(2.53) of the modified model of Becker-During, in which, for simplicity, it is supposed that the velocity constants of the activated particles joining to and splitting off the aggregates do not depend on the aggregate size, that is kn ≡ k and qn ≡ q. Then
u&n = −vkun + vkun −1 + qun +1 − qun,
n ≥ 2,
u&1 = − vku1 + qu2 ,
(2.62) (2.63)
∞
∞
n =1
n=2
v& = − vk ∑ un + q ∑ un ,
(2.64)
where, like in equations (2.51)−(2.53), un − is the concentration of aggregates, which consist of the n number of molecules; v − is the concentration of the activated molecules, including the ones inside the aggregates; k − is the constant of the velocity of an activated molecule addition to an aggregate; q − is the constant of the velocity of separate molecules splitting off an aggregate; a dot above the symbol denotes the time derivative. The system of equations (2.62)−(2.64) describes two processes: joining of the activated particles to the aggregates with the velocity constant k, and splitting of the active molecules off the aggregate with the velocity constant q. The are two conservation laws which correspond to the system of equations (2.62)− (2.64): ∞
∞
n =1
n =1
∑ un = N = const and ∑ nun = M = const,
(2.65)
where N − is the concentration of all aggregates in the system regardless of their size; M − is the concentration of the activated molecules in the system, including the ones inside the aggregates. Transformation of the system of equations (2.62)−(2.64) using the generating function F(z,t) (2.57) gives stationary solutions:
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
Fc ( z ) =
vc =
zF0 zc , 1− z (1− F0 zc N )
(2.66a)
q ⎛⎜ F0 zc ⎞⎟ 1− , N ⎟⎠ k ⎜⎝
(2.66b)
⎡
⎤
⎣
⎦
2 ⎛ ⎞ F0 zc = N ⎢⎢ ⎜1 − k M ⎟ + 4 k N + 1 − k M ⎥⎥. q ⎥ q 2⎢ ⎝ q ⎠
⎛
unс = F0 zс ⎜⎜1 − ⎝
87
F0 zс ⎞ n − 1 ⎟ . N ⎟⎠
(2.67)
(2.68)
The analysis of these equations shows that the evolution of the aggregated system to thermodynamic equilibrium can have several stages. Their number depends on the ratio of constants of joining and splitting off. Note, that the possibility of the stage-by-stage relaxation of oligomer system was established during the analysis of the low-scale chain structure with a limited length and a finite bending rigidity within the orientational correlated wanderings (see Part 2.2.3).
2.4.3. Activation-Relaxation Model Paper [120] considers the model which takes into account the fact that the activation and relaxation processes can occur simultaneously. The additional postulates for this model are as follows: • • • •
activation of the inert molecules due to the external (e.g. thermal) influence occurs according to the Arrhenius mechanism with the velocity constant k; activated molecules can relax to their initial state; from a certain critical value Nкр of the average aggregate size N, the capacity to have free molecules joined grows sharply; thermal influence results in the changes of k and Ncr..
This situation can be described by a system of kinetic equations “uniting” the above given systems of equations (2.53)–(2.55) and (2.62)–(2.64):
u&n = − vkun + vkun − 1 + qun + 1 − qun , n ≥ 2,
(2.69)
u&1 = − vku1 + qu2 ,
(2.70)
v& = − vk ∑ un + q ∑ un + Pc − Rv,
(2.71)
n =1
n=2
88
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
c& = − Pc + Rv,
(2.72)
where k − is the constant of the velocity of activated molecules addition to an aggregate; q − is the constant of the velocity of separate molecules splitting off an aggregate; p − is the constant of the molecules activation velocity; R – is the constant of the oligomer active molecules relaxation; c – is the concentration of the inert molecules; v – is the concentration of the active molecules; un − is the concentration of aggregates, which consist of the n number of molecules. Using the generating function (2.57), equations (2.69) – (2.72) were transformed to a stationary state: Fst(z) =
zu1st , c = ( R P)vst , u1st = 1− ( k q)v st N , 1− ( k q) zvst st
[
]
(2.73)
These equations allow us to (with regard to the second law of conservation (2.65), with the view of Σ nun + v + c = M ) to find any of these values. In particular, the value of F1zst (stationary value ∂F/∂z at z = 1), can be determined from the ratio:
k( F ) q 1 − N = 1zst ( M − F1zst ), 1+ R P F1zst
(2.74)
This implies that the aggregation velocity constant k depends on the average aggregate size, proportional to their total weight F1zst . The analysis of solutions (2.73) and (2.74) has shown that with the increase of Т, depending on the increase or decrease of the ratio (k/q)/(1+R/P), the value of F1zst can both increase or decrease. In the first case, when, with the growth of the temperature, the fraction (k/q)/(1+R/P) increases, and the amplitude of the k constant change during the increase of F1zst is sufficiently high, three stationary states are possible in the system: two stable and one unstable. This situation can be called bistable. This non-trivial consequence of this model allowed us to give an adequate explanation of the viscosity hysteresis phenomenon which has been first found for the oligomer systems in paper [121].
2.4.4. Kinetic Model The above given models postulated that the number of aggregates does not change during the evolution of the oligomer system to equilibrium. The model proposed by V.Irzhak et al. [122], does not impose any limits to the number of aggregates.
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
89
This model, like the model described in paper [120], assumes that the process of the stationary state achievement is realized due to the exchange of separate oligomer molecules between the aggregates*:
Here the i index denoted the aggregate size, i.e., the number of the oligomer Х1; pi and qi+1 are the constants of the molecules joining or splitting off the aggregates with the size of i and i +1, correspondingly. Within the model assumed, the aggregates restructuring can be described by the following system of differential equations: ∞ ∞ dx1 = − p1 ⋅ x12 − x1 ⋅ ∑ p j ⋅ x j +q 2 ⋅ x 2 + ∑ q j ⋅ x j dt j=1 j= 2 dx 2 = p1 ⋅ x12 − p 2 ⋅ x1 ⋅ x 2 − q 2 ⋅ x 2 + q 3 ⋅ x 3 dt .....
dx i = p i −1 ⋅ x1 ⋅ x i −1 − p i ⋅ x1 ⋅ x i − q i ⋅ x i + q i +1 ⋅ x i +1 dt ..... where хi – is the concentration of the aggregate Xi, j– is the summation index. The analytical solution of this system for the different values of i, p and q (an example is given in Figure 2.13) has shown that the time to reach the stationary value of concentration τст depends on the aggregate size; the total concentration of aggregates reaches the stationary value very quickly, the time is almost the same as for the aggregates with the size of х1. This indicates that, for oligomer systems, the stationary state in different properties can occur in different ways: for the properties depending on the total (quantitative) concentration of aggregates, it occurs earlier; for the properties depending on the size of the aggregates (e.g., mass concentration), it occurs much later.
*
Here, as well as earlier, it is natural to assume that the redistribution in oligomer systems occurs due to the transference of the separate molecules between the aggregates, i.e., the process well known in the theory of the phase transitions as the process of Slezov-Lifshitz [123] is realized. The velocity of the aggregates transference in the high-viscous environments as a whole, can not be compared to the velocity of the separate oligomer molecules movement.
90
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
Figure 2.13. Redistribution kinetic curves of concentration of aggregates with aggregate size i: 1(1), 2(2), 3(3), 4(4), 5(5), 10(6), 15(7), Σхi (8).
2.4.5. Liquid Drop Model Based on the liquid concentration model, proposed by Ya.Frenkel [80] and developed for the supercooled vitrescent substances in papers [124-126], V.Irzhak, proposed an original alternative of the drop model for oligomer systems [127]. This model allowed us to determine the dependence of the aggregates distribution function on the intermolecular interaction and the chain rigidity. According to Frenkel [80], the drops generated during the liquid condensation, can be considered as complexes: K A1 + A n −1 ←⎯→ An ,
therefore concentration аn of aggregate (drop) An
a n = Ka1a n −1 = ξ n / K , where
ξ = Ka1 =
1 + 2 Ka10 − 1 + 4 Ka10 2 Ka10
,
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
91
K is the equilibrium constant, а10 is the total concentration of the elementary particles A1 in the system. The average aggregate size is
~ (1−ξ)-1. A consistent assembly of the aggregate, consisting of the cylindrical molecules has been considered. The value of the kinetic constants of the formation and destruction of the aggregate made up of two molecules is determined by the cohesion energy. The model assumes that the interaction between the aggregates and their dissociation into large fragments does not exist. The kinetics of this process can be described by the following system of equations:
da1 = −2k1a12 − ka1 ∑ f i a i + 2 k '1 a 2 + k' ∑ f i a i dt i=2 i=3 da 2 = k1a12 − k '1 a 2 − kf 2a1a 2 + k ' f 3a 3 dt da 3 = kf 2 a1a 2 − k' f 3a 3 − kf3a1a 3 + k ' f 4a 4 KK dt da n = kf n −1a1a n −1 − k ' f n a n − kf n a1a n + k ' f n +1a n +1 KK dt
(2.75)
where an is the concentration of aggregates, consisting of the n number of molecules; k1 and
k '1 are the constants of formation and dissociation for А2; k and k′ are the same constants for А3, А4,…Аn aggregates; k>>k1, k ' << k '1 ; fn is the parameter characterizing the number of “seats” of the n size aggregate and the number of molecules which are capable of splitting off this aggregate. It is assumed that these two reactions are characterized by one and the same value of parameter fn. An aggregate consisting of two elementary particles (a dimer) is formed according to the scheme:
The cohesion occurring between the particles in unstable: fn of the direct and reverse reactions is the same. Much more durable and favorable is the following bond:
92
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
The number of “seats” fn depends on the aggregate size n. It can be expresses by the formula
f n = 3,6( n − 0,92 )
(2.76)
When equilibrium occurs, the system (2.75) gives:
a2 =
k1 2 a1 = K1a12 k'1
a3 =
k f2 f a1a 2 = K1K 2 a13 KK k' f 3 f3
an = K
(2.77)
f n −1 f a Bξ n −1 a1a n −1 = K1K n − 2 2 a1n = 1 KK fn fn n − 0,92
К1 << К are the corresponding equilibrium constants,
B=
K1 , and ξ = Ka1 . 1,8K
Figure 2.14 shows the curves of the mass function of the aggregates size distribution
wn =
na n ∑ ia i
for different values of ξ. It can be seen that in the wide range of values n the
i exponential law works.
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
93
Figure 2.14. Mass function wn of the size distribution of aggregates. ξ = 0,1(1), 0,3(2), 0,5(3), 0,7(4), 0,9(5) и 0,95(6).
The first frequency moment λ = 1
ξβ , where β=2. ∑ ia i ≈ 1 − ξ i=2
In the range of 0<ξ≤0.8
a 01 = a1 (1 +
4qξ2 ) 1− ξ
(2.78)
where q~B<1. The equation (2.78) allows us to determine the dependence of parameter ξ and the value of а1, that is, actually, the share of elements, included into the aggregates, on the equilibrium constants K1 and K. The curves of one of these functions are given in Figure 2.15 as an example.
94
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
Figure 2.15. Dependence of parameter ξ on equilibrium constants K1 and K. q=0,01(1), 0,05(2), 0,1(3), 0,15(4), 0,2(5), 0,25(6), 0,35(7) and 0,5(8).
As it can be seen, parameter ξ increases with the growth of K. Therefore, the exponent value in the function of the aggregates size distribution decreases, and the average aggregate size grows. The presence of dependencies a1(q,K) and ξ(q,K) allows us to determine the frequency moments λ = k
∑ ika i ,
i=2
the average aggregate size < R > = λ1 , and the distribution n
λ0
dispersion D = λ 2 − λ1 as the functions of the equilibrium constants. λ1 λ1 λ 0 The aggregate formation free energy takes into account the intermolecular interaction energy and the chain rigidity. The efficient intermolecular interaction is due to the rigid districts of the oligomer molecules. If ϕ is the share of the rigid chain links of all the oligomer chain links (1-ϕ is the share of the absolutely flexible fragments), then the value of the free energy is proportional to ϕ, and the equilibrium constant can be expressed as follows: K(ϕ) = It is obvious that with the increase of ϕ the equilibrium constant increases Kϕ. (K(ϕ=0)=1), and the distribution function changes as well.
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
95
2.5. LIFETIMES OF SHORT RANGE ORDERING It has already been noted above that the short range ordering in the oligomer liquids can be formed due to the forces of different nature and different energy saturation. If the supramolecular structures are formed due to the thermal fluctuations, then, according to Ya.Frenkel [80], the liquid particle transfer from one equilibrium state into another one is an activation process, and the “settled” life time of the particle close to the equilibrium state is determined by the Arrhenius function of the temperature: τ = τ0 е w/kT,
(2.79)
where τ0 is the average length of the particle presence in this fluctuation until its decay or “split-off”, and w is the activation energy of the decay or split-off process. In the simplest case τ ∼ the atomic fluctuations period ≈ 10-12 s. It is natural that the lower is the 0
temperature, the higher is τ. For Т, corresponding to the liquid state of the system, the lowest boundary of τ usually does not exceed 10-7 - 10-9 s. If, however, in the process of the temperature decrease, and, for the mixed systems, in the process of the concentration decrease as well, the system finds itself in a metastable area, then the life time of the fluctuations increases significantly [128], and in the critical point τ → ∞ [73, 128,129]. Note two circumstances. On the one hand, the range of temperatures (and concentrations), corresponding to the critical point, is very narrow [129, 130], and it is very difficult “to get” into this range [73,128,130]. On the other hand, for oligomers characterized by the wide intermolecular distribution [1], in case of the molecules aggregation due to the weak forces, the probability of the life time increase of some fluctuations can multiply. This can be explained by the fact that for the polydisperse systems, as it has been shown in experiments of R.Koningsveld [131, 132] and proven in papers [133, 135], the local “critical” and “metastable” states can appear at any point of the phase diagram. The point is not about the macroscopic effects, but about the appearance of the local concentration fluctuations, the state of the latter can correspond to the “critical” and “stable” ones. This assumption, although not obvious, first, has a theoretical basis [136]; second, it has been proven by experiments [88,136-140]. It is for this purpose that it is used in many papers by many different authors to explain some peculiarities of the translation diffusion of oligomers [70], their rheological behavior [141,143,144], and the phase separation processes during curing [134,135,145] and etc. For example, the abnormal viscosity growth in natural rubberoligomer systems, connected with the appearance of the large-scale fluctuations, were experimentally proven only for the polydisperse components of the mixture [141]. Different is the situation during the oligomer aggregation due to the strong forces – dipole-dipole, hydrogen and other bonds. G.Korolev [142,146,147], within the ideology of the physical nets [147], analyzed the possibility of realization and registration of the interaction between the atomic groups within the molecule (intermolecular interaction centers), characterized by the different bonding energies (see Table 2.3).
96
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
Table 2.3. Bonding energy of intermolecular interaction centers formed by different atomic groups [146] Atomic group
Е, kcal/mole
Atomic group
Е, kcal/mole
10.8
4.3
7.6
3.6
7.3
3.6
6.6
1.5
6.3
0.7
4.4
0.5
Paper [146] considers the process of the molecules “bonding” into aggregates in analogy with [149,150] as the process of the equilibrium polycondensation. The difference is that unlike the chemical reactions of consistent addition, resulting in the formation of the stable (in real conditions) covalent bonds between the molecules, “physical polycondensation” results in the formation of the final product, characterized in the same conditions by the lability of the bonds between the intermolecular interaction centers. The mechanism of the bonds formation can be described by a simple scheme of reversible polycondensation: k
2→ G G + G ⎯⎯ 2
k
1 G2 ⎯ ⎯→ G+G
(2.80) (2.81)
where G is the atomic group – bearer of the intermolecular interaction centers, G2 is the intermolecular bond, k1 and k2 are constants of the velocities of dissociation and regeneration of the bond (direct and reverse processes). The life time of G2 is related to the monomolecular constant of the k1 bond dissociation velocity by the ratio [146]: τ= 0.69 / k1.
(2.82)
In its turn, k1 = k01е-Е1/RT,
(2.83)
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems 12
97
-1
where the value of k01 ≈ 10 s (frequency of the atomic groups fluctuations), and the value of Е1 is the energy of dissociation for the corresponding intermolecular interaction centers (see Table 2.3). τ obeys the Arrhenius law for the life time of the bonds, formed by the intermolecular interaction centers as well as for the thermal fluctuations. It is absolutely obvious that the more intermolecular interaction centers are used in the aggregate formation, the longer is its life time. If the molecule contains several intermolecular interaction centers, then τ grows with the increase of the chain length N. Calculations have shown [151] that the aggregate life time increases in a power dependence on the number of intermolecular interaction centers, the exponent of power grows with the increase of the interaction energy Е1 (see Figure 2.16). The life time of the aggregate is several times higher that that of a separate bond [152]. The estimations of R.Fox [153], indicate: the life time of the aggregate consisting of three intermolecular interaction centers is 1 s, while for each of the bonds this time is about 10-9 s.
Figure 2.16. Dependence of lifetime of aggregates τ1 on the chain length N at various binding energy E/kT: 0 (1); 0,5 (2); 1,0 (3); 1,5 (4); 2,0 (5).
Due to different reasons, it is not every intermolecular interaction center that takes part in the aggregate formation, an important characteristic of the oligomer supramolecular structure formation process is the equilibrium concentration of the intermolecular bonds υ, which grows with the decrease of the temperature to the limiting value of υ0, corresponding to the total content of all the potential intermolecular interaction centers, capable of bond formation. Paper [146] shows that υ/υ0 =(1+γ) –( (1+γ) -1)1/2,
(2.84)
98
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev γ=k1/8k2υ0 =k01.ехр[(Е2 - Е1)/RT]/8k02υ0
(2.85)
where the value of υ/υ0 has the meaning of the equilibrium concentration level, the share of the potential intermolecular interaction centers transformation into the intermolecular bonds, k01, k02, Е1 and Е2 are the preliminary exponents and activation energies of the corresponding reactions. Since the oligomer molecule may have several (in general case, n) potential intermolecular interaction centers, υ = n.С, where С is the oligomer molecules concentration. Figure 2.17 shows the dependencies obtained in [146], with the dependence of υ/υ0 and τ on Е/Т. The comparison with the resolution of the different techniques (Table 2.4) allows us to determine a priori the applicability of the latter for the study of oligomers, containing the atomic groups capable of intermolecular interaction centers formation with the different values of Е1, at different temperature ranges and in different model conditions, corresponding to curves 1-3 in Figure 2.17.
Figure 2.17. Т/Е generalized dependence of the degree of aggregation (ν/ν0 ) (1-3) and the lifetime (τа) (4) of an aggregative bond. К01 /(К02 ν0): 103 (1), 105 (2) and 107 (3).
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
99
Table 2.4. Temporary resolution of different experimental techniques [146] Technique
t∗, s
Efficiency of radical initiation ESR for a spin sensing electrode 3 cm range (without saturation transfer)
10
3 cm range (with saturation transfer)
5⋅10 - 10
2 cm range NMR for high resolution
≥ 4⋅10
impulse methods
10 - 10
Kinetic parameters of radical polymerization Relaxometry dielectrical
> 10
mechanical
>10 >1
-10
5⋅10
- 10
-11
-9
- 10
-8
: ∼ 10
-4
-10
-10
-6
Thermomechanics
-7
-5
-4
-6
10 - 10
-3
-1
An important detail is to be noted here (see Part 2.8.1). It follows from Figure 2.17 that in the temperature region of 20 - 80°С, the life time of aggregates formed by the intermolecular -5
interaction centers with the bond energy of 0.5 - 10 kcal/mole (see Table 2.3) equals < 10 -6
10 s. At the same time, the classical papers by A.Berlin and G.Korolyov [154] show different anomalies of the oligoesteracrylate initial polymerization velocity. These anomalies are considered to be conditioned by the existence of the “kinetically favorable orders” (in our terminology, cybotactic groupings) in oligomers. If this assumption is correct, then the necessary condition for their kinetic method discovery is, at least, the commensurability of the aggregates life time with the time of the elementary act of the metaacrylic bonds chemical 4 reaction. The latter equals the value of > 10- s, which is two orders higher than the kinetic method resolution (see Table 2.4). It seems that the aggregative structures could not have been revealed in the above described kinetic experiments. This contradiction disappears if you take the following ideas into account [146]. The estimations show that the aggregates τ can be registered in the above described experiments if 4 their value is ≥ 10- s, and the value of Е is ≥ 12 kcal/mole. This situation is quite possible. 1
The molecules of oligomers, oligoesteracrylates in particular, usually have several intermolecular interaction centers* with Е1 = 3 - 9 kcal/mole. If we assume that the interactions of separate bonds are not isolated but correlated, and the supramolecular aggregate is kept by the interaction of the “bunch” of the n bonds of intermolecular interaction centers *), then the aggregate can dissociate, or two “bonded” molecules can be separated due to the translation diffusion, provided that all of the n bonds connecting
* A similar postulate has been used by R.Fox [153] in order to prove the possibility of the anti-entropy processes during the formation of the biologically active macromolecules.
100
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
neighboring molecules dissociate simultaneously. This requires an energy fluctuation much higher than12 kcal/mole. -2
-4
Therefore, the value of the aggregates τ > 10 - 10 s is enough for the total n bonding energy of one molecule intermolecular interaction center to be > 12 kcal/mole. For the majority of oligomers this condition ∑ Е1 ≥ 12 kcal/mole can be satisfied. Thus, there are no principal objections against the formation of the long living (commensurable with the experimental methods resolution) aggregates with anisotropic orientation of the molecules within the liquid oligomers.
2.6. EXPERIMENTAL EXAMINATION OF OLIGOMER SUPRAMOLECULAR STRUCTURE 2.6.1. Analysis of Structure Components Distribution Function The radial distribution functions of the fluctuations g(r) are the most frequently used primary characteristics of liquid structures [155,156] and they determine the particle detection probability at a distance r, r+dr from the other chosen point of the plane with a bigger time averaging in comparison with τ (average time of settled life near the equilibrium center). They are obtained by the Fourier transformation of static structure factor S (k), characterizing the average particle configurations in the system volume: 3
-1
g(r) = 1 + (8π ρ) ∫ [S(k) - 1] exp(-ikr) dk,
(2.86)
S(k) is deduced experimentally according to the data [156]: 2
S(k),= I/I0 N f
(2.87)
where I and I0 are the densities of exciting and scattered radiation, N is the number of scattering centers in the volume V, f is the dissipation factor, k is the module of wave scattering vector, ρ = N/V is the average numerical density. It is possible to determine the imperfections by changing the length of the wave and scattering angle, that is, by setting k, its linear dimensions of the emission wavelength. There 2
is a simple dependence between S(k) and average fluctuations 〈(N - N) 〉 / N [157] in the long-wave limits: 2
lim S(k) =1 + ρ∫ [g(r) - 1] dV = 〈(N - N) 〉 / N
(2.88)
k →0
(there is a line over the two last N) (ensemble\assembly average is marked by angle brackets). In order t account not only spatial but also temporary structure particle order correlation, in principle, it is possible to use the dynamic structural factor S (k,ω), determined by the neutron scattering method.
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems S(k,ω) = ρ∫∫ exp [-I (kr - ωt)] G(r, t) dr dt,
101
(2.89)
where the function G(r, t) is the number-average particle number density around point r at the time moment t in the case if the origin of the coordinates is overlapped by one of the particles: if t=0; w is the frequency content. Integration S (k,ω) in all frequencies results in the static structure factor [77]. Unfortunately, such papers, relative to oligomeric systems, have not been published, yet. The radial distribution experimental function, obtained by the primary X-ray scattering curve transformation (I = f (2θ), where θ is the scattering angle), consists of the open-chain interatomic spacing distribution function and the intermolecular interatomic spacing distribution function. Intermolecular part speculation of the electron density radial distribution function is a rather complicated procedure, connected with the introduction of some estimates and assumptions, checked experimentally afterwards. Intermolecular distribution function analysis is usually carried out in the frame of the paracrystalline order, and the average statistical periodicity value of the basal plane and of the nearest environment are determined. Methodical and methodological basis application of radiography for oligomeric system study is stated in the monograph [158]. Figure 2.18 shows the radial distribution normalized curves, obtained in the [158] for solid and liquid states of the three oligoalkyleneglycol – oligo ethyleneglycol (OEG) with the molecular weight of 1000, atacticoligo propyleneglycol (OPG) with the molecular weight of 1000 and oligotetramethylene glycol (OTMG) with the molecular weight of 1350. Molecular chain fragments of the given oligomers are shown in Figure 2.19. Experimental distribution functions in Figure 2.18 characterize the deviation scope of the atomic center numbers, located in the spherical layer with the density g(r) at a distance of r from the central atom, from the number of these centers at the same layer with density p (with a line over p).
Figure 2.18. Experimental curves of the normalized radial distribution function G(r) for oligoalkyleneglycoles. 1 - liquid OEG; 2 - crystalline OEG; 3 - liquid OPG; 4 - liquid OTMG with Smax = 6,4 A°; 5 -crystalline OTMG; 6 - liquid OTMG with Smax = 8,7 A.
102
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
Figure 2.19. Chain fragments of OEG (a), OPG (b) and OTMG (c).
To obtain the distance distribution function between the atoms of the different molecules it is necessary to subtract theoretical curve of the intermolecular distance distribution from the experimental curve. However, the result of such subtraction will show the real picture only in case, the theoretical curve is calculated only for those molecule chain conformations, which are realized in the oligomer in the reality. Thus, only the right choice of the conformation model made the calculation approximation result in the experiment. The analysis of the theoretically possible oligoalkyleneglycol molecule conformations and their correlation with the potential energy rotation angle-dependence map and the calculation of literary data for high-polymeric analogues [159], complemented in [158], allowed the authors of the work [158] to choose optimum schemes of molecule layout in basal planes for given oligomers (the specific example is presented in Figure 2.20), to plot a distribution bar chart of intermolecular distances in solid and liquid states and compare them with their experimental functions (Figure 2.21).
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
103
Figure 2.20. Layout chart of molecules in basis planes of a crystalline cell (a) and the model paracrystalline lattice (b) of a liquid OTMG.
Figure 2.21. Experimental curves and calculated histograms of distribution of molecular distances in crystalline (а) and liquid (b) OPG.
It is possible to see, though there are changes both in the basal plane (they naturally increase) and in the periodicity of the nearest environment of the investigated oligomers during the transfer from the solid (crystalline state) to liquid state, nevertheless, that the paracrystalline order models describe well the local atomic order features of the given oligomers in the liquid state. In other words, liquid oligomers preserve the elements of the local atomic order typical of their solid state. According to the estimates given in [158], the interaction zones (the volumes with the relative position correlation of the structural elements inside them) spread for the liquid state of the investigated oligoalkyleneglycol approximately to 30 inter planar spacing and it makes 50-60 А° in the direction of the perpendicular molecular axes. At the same time, the extension of the correlated volume along the molecular axis does not exceed 1,5 А°, that is, the inter open-chain periodicity for such oligomeric liquids is practically missing.
104
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
2.6.2. Radiographic and Electron Microscope Examination Regular structures of bigger size have been found for other oligomers as well. In a number of works [137,160-166] an integrated study of oligomers of the following homologous series have been carried out through radiographic and electron-microscopic examination: α, ω -tetramethyleneglycol (MTG) of the general formula СН2=С(СН3)СОО[(СН2)4О]n СО (CН3) С=СН2, where n = 5-210, and Мn = 500-15300; α, ω -dimethacrylatoligoethyleneglycolformal (MEF) СН2=С (СН3)СОО[(СН2)2ОСН2О]n СО (CН3) С=СН2, where n= 7-98, and Мn = 650-12800; α, ω - dimethacrylatoligodiethyleneglycolformal (MDF) СН2=С(СН3)СОО[(СН2)2О(СН2)2СН2О]n СО (CН3) С=СН2, where n= 4-55, and Мn= 600-10600 and α, ω -bis-(4-methacrylatoxyethylurethanetoluylene ethersoligoethyleneglycol (METG)
2-aminoformic)
[СН2=ССН3СООСН2СН2ОСОNНС6Н6(СН3)NНСО-]2 О(СНСНО)n, where n=1 -140, and Мn = 600 - 10000. According to their molecular weight, these oligomers constitute the viscous or cereous fluids as well as solid crystalline materials in ambient temperature. For example, oligomers METG with Mn <1600 are amorphous, the crystallinity degree of oligomers with Мn =2250 is no more than 10%. With the growth of the oligomeric block length of the METG, however, it increases and after reaching 50% with Мn >3000, the crystallinity goes beyond the limits. The liquid oligomer roentgenogram of the MTG and MEF type with n < 10 is characterized by radiosity, however, when the value n > 17 shows on the roentgenogram (see Figure 2.22) there apeear characteristics specific for ordered liquid-crystalline systems with the “long range ordering” elements [159,165]. During the electron microscope examination, described in [162, 163], all oligomers were transferred into the liquid state by heating to 3-5°С above the melting temperature and then were instantly cooled in the liquid nitrogen. The fixation of the melted oligomer supramolecular structure was supposed to take place in that case. Figure 2.23 shows the platinum carbonic replicas obtained from the oligomer sample chips of the homologous series METG frozen in such a way. It is possible to see that the electron microscope image of the oligomer supramolecular structure is determined by their molecular weight. For all oligomers
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
105
of the series under study with Мn < 1200 this image is presented in the form of the closepacked globules with the size of 160 -500 А°.
Figure 2.22. X-ray pattern of dimetacrylate-oligotetramethyleneglycole (Мn = 5900).
Figure 2.23. Electron microscopic pictures of frozen METG chips with Мn: 1200(a), 1600 (b), 2250 (c) and 3600 (d). (Χ 30000).
For the frozen oligomer melts with Мn = 1600 and 2250 the structure becomes more complex and the electron microscope shows the form of the laminate structures with the plate thickness of about 100-130 and 150-180 А°. The structure of the frozen melt with Mn=3600 is characterized by the presence of the various size and form fibrillar structures with
106
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
sufficiently distinct contours. There are maximums of such oligomer type on the curves. Their position also depends on the oligomer molecular weight. The values of the long period for METG oligomers with Mn=1200 and 2250 are equal to 150 А° and 170 А°. The packing of the molecules both in solid (crystalline) and in liquid (paracrystalline) states in general is determined by the oligomeric block, but not by the end groups when comparing the intensity and interplanar spacing of the special oligomers and corresponding oligotetramethyleneglycols. It was possible to make a conclusion that the local order in the liquid oligomers is provided by the intermolecular interaction of the anisometric part of the molecule, as the result, supramolecular structures are formed with periodicity not along the molecular chain but in the perpendicular direction. In the ordered structures of such kind the molecular motion is hindered due to the strong dipole-dipole interactions.
2.6.3. Thermodynamic Estimations A number of experimental works appeared in the recent years devoted to the examination of the oligomer structure organization dispersed in the polymeric matrix. Extensive studies in this direction have been made by A.E. Chalikh (the summary is given in monograph [166]), where the confusion processes, diffusion and interodilution at the phase equilibrium determination have been studied for a wide range of oligomers (methacrylic, epoxy, urethane\urethan, hydrocarbon and etc.) and polymers (PVC, PMMA, polycarbonate, polyimides and etc.). Thus, papers [140, 167] studied the mixture thermodynamics in the PVC system of oligoetheracrylate by microinterferometric method . The theory of Flory [15,168] allows us to differentiate contributions of combinatorial (Δ к
R
S1 ) and non combinatorial mixing entropies (ΔS1 ) and to divide, in that way, the molecule fraction in the mixture, the structural order of which has changed in comparison with the order degree in the components formed before mixing. According to [15,168] the general mixing entropy is determined as: к
S1 = ΔS1 + ΔS1
R
(2.90)
к
ΔS1 is always positive, as the molecule rearrangement number in the mixture is more R
than that in the individual components, ΔS1 , reflecting the order increase or, on the contrary, disorder in the molecule arrangement of the same components during mixing, in comparison with their individual state, can take either positive or negative values. к
R
Figure 2.24 shows the mixture composition dependences ΔS1, ΔS1 and ΔS1 on the mixture composition of trihydroethylendimethacrylate - PVC [167]. Unusual high absolute values of the mixing redundant entropy draw our attention to such a phenomenon first of all. It should be noted that the concentrated dependences of combinatorial and non combinatorial к
components of the general entropy are completely different. ΔS1 naturally decreases (the number of combinatorial units during mixing has increased) with the increase of ϕ1 in the
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
107
whole interval concentration range, but ΔS1R changes extremely. At first it increases, and then if 0.2<ϕ1<0.6 decreases proportionally to the oligomer concentration in the solution. The changes of the total entropy has an extreme form because the contribution of non combinatorial entropy in ΔS1 is far above the concentration ΔS1. The value ΔН1 (as the function of ϕ1) also passes through the maximum (Figure 2.25).Two opposite situations can be distinguished in the concentrated dependences of thermodynamic parameters. If ≤ 0.2 there R
к
is an increase of ΔН1, ΔS1 and ΔS1 and the decrease of ΔS1 . It proves the fact that in the given range of solution concentrations in PVC there is a structure disorder of the mixture components in comparison with their initial state. If ϕ1 > 0.2 there is a decrease of values Δ Н1, ΔS1 and ΔS1R, which is interpreted in [139,167] as the order system increase and, particularly, as the micro volume formation with a high oligomer concentration. Comparison of the given data with the phase plot of the system [166] shows that the molecule aggregation OEA in the mixture PVC starts at a considerable distance from the binodal and increases as it approaches it (on the binodal). The order degree reaches its maximum if the concentration is R
close to ultimate, and the values ΔН1 and ТΔS1 approach so closely that the value Δμ1 = ΔН1 − ТΔS1 tends to zero (Figure 2.25), this means that the system is ready to form a new order level-phase division.
Figure 2.24. Concentration dependencies ΔS1, ΔS1R, ΔS1K in a system PVC - trioxyethylenedimetacrylate. ϕ1 –is the volume fraction of oligomer [167].
108
S.M. Mezhikovskii, A.E. Arinstein and R. Ya. Deberdeev
Figure 2.25. Dependence of F ≡ Δμ1, ΔΗ1, ΤΔS1 on ϕ1 in PVC - trioxyethylene-dimetacrylate at 90 and 150 °С [167]. R
Figure 2.25 shows that the contribution for the enthalpy component in Δμ1 of the given mixture is distinctly less than that for the entropic, i.e. the molecule dispersion driving force, first of all, is the entropic part of the chemical potential for the system PVC-OEA. In other words, most of the solution energy is spent on the order fracture of the initial components, when mixing PVC and n-hydrooxyethylene-dimethacrylates at the first stage (if ϕ1 ≤ 0.2). This is the possible explanation of the initially bigger values of the redundant mixing entropy, mentioned above, and only if ϕ1>0.2, we can see the new processes start, which result in the stable oligomer concentration (aggregate) fluctuation formation with a higher molecule order degree than that in the initial (before the mixing) oligomer state.
2.6.4. Orientation Phenomena The coefficient ε is the effectiveness measure of the polymer chain influence on the “sample” (oligomerоus) additives orientation determined by the ratio [169]
uiu j
g
= ε uiu j
m
(2.91)
where vector u describes the chemical bond orientation, and the vector components are marked by indices i and j; the bonds are marked indices g and m, related to the “sample” molecule and polymer matrix, correspondingly, ε is the coefficient, characterizing the
Homogeneous Oligomer Systems
109
measure of their interaction: ε=0 in the lack of interaction, ε=1 if there is a complete correlation. Papers [95,96] studied the orientation relaxation of the ten-link deuterated butadiene oligomer in its “home” polybutadiene matrix by the 2Н NMR method. The orientation of the oligomer turned out to exceed twice the polybutadiene orientation under the infinite matrix dilution [96]. In the range of the oligomer molecular weight from 500 to 4000, the coefficient of the orientation interaction is ε=1 for all degrees of matrix swell