This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
)2> 1/2
5.779
0.1962
0.2047
Aq / q
0.3314
6.798 10-4( T in K)
1.453 10 -2
Table 1. Quantities observed at Switterbrook.
We find C(T, Pv) -- 0.512, a significant positive correlation which can be seen in the fluctuations shown in Fig.2. This corresponds to heat and mass transfer processes, such as the first in Fig.l, where the differences between air and surface temperatures and water vapour contents are both the same sign. Somewhat surprisingly at first, we find significant negative correlations with velocity fluctuations, C(T,v 2)
-0.380 and C(pv,V2) = -0.471. These could, however, be qualitatively explained if we
postulate that higher velocities are leaving less time for conductive heat transfer and diffusional mass transfer from a warmer water surface. With the means and deviations of Table 1 and perfect correlation between Pv and T, the saturation deviation given by eq.(4) would be 0.0153 - 0.01191 - 0.00262. With the actual correlation of 0.512, this high cancellation does not take place and the standard deviation for dS/S is 0.0133. This is close to the figure of 0.01 used by Zapadinsky et al (1994) and, by inspection of Fig. 2, the fluctuation timescale is at least of the order of a nucleation ti,nescale of 0.1 s. Their conclusions for nucleation opposite to the "white noise" limit apply. To discover the consequences for sulphuric acid nucleation, we can refer to Fig. 6 of Easter and Peters (1994) with AT = 0.2 and their Aq = APv/p = 0.205/1.21=0.17 g kg -1. The increase in the binary homogeneous nucleation rate predicted for a correlation of 0.5 between the fluctuations lies between 1.1 and 1.5, a small increase compared to basic uncertainties in the rate. However, it is likely that measurements in other situations would reveal a larger increase due to fluctuations. To identify such situations, considerations of heat and mass transfer, like those shown in Fig. 1, are needed.
C correlation (eq.(5))
NOTATION T temperature u, v ,w velocity components
p pressure q observed quantity S saturation
v 2 square of total velocity Y ratio of specific heats p density
a, b correlated quantities (eq.(5))
Subscripts v refers to water vapour e refers to equilibrium
Nucleation from atmospheric fluctuations
219
REFERENCES Clement, C. F. (1995)J. Aerosol Sci. 26, $639-640. Clement. C. F. and Ford, I. J. ,(1996). The competition between aerosol growth and aerosol nucleation in the atmosphere, European Aerosol Conf. Easter, R. C. and Peters, L.K. (1994) Binary homogeneous nucleation: temperature and relative humidity fluctuations, nonlinearity, and aspects of new particle production in the atmosphere. J. Applied Meteorology 33 775-784. Zapadinsky, E. L., Sabelfield, K. K., Kulmala, M., Gorbunov, B. Z. and Rackimgulova, D. M. (1994) Monte Carlo simulations of heterogeneous nucleation on aerosol particles in the non-uniform media. J. Aerosol Sci. 25: S 101-S 102.
~176 E,
,
0.4
q,
,~T 1
'
,'
,I
"
i. ~
i
~
AT
o.o
,Tb_
.
-0.2
& e
lOs -O.8.
[
[
time
0.51
o.} 0.3
t~
. ~
'
0.2
APv g m -3
-0.6w
time
Fig. 2. Temperature (AT) and absolute humidity (Apv) fluctuations observed at Swifterbank during a 49.6 s time period.
A NEW SEMIPHENOMENOLOGICAL MODEL SIZE DEPENDENCE
FOR SURFACE
TENSION
P. S O P U C H + and A. SERVIDA 1=
f Institute of Thermomechanics, Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, Dolejskova 5, Prague :l:Dipartimento di Chimica e Chimica Industriale, Universitb. di Genova, Via Dodecaneso, 31 I- 16146 Genova, ITALY A b s t r a c t - In this communication, the bases of a new refined phenomenological model of cluster surface tension are presented. The model allows one to describe the dependence of the cluster surface tension with size. We also show that by augmenting the Lothe-Pound cluster free energy prescription with the new surface tension model provides an effective framework to represent in an unitary fashion the available experimental nucleation data for both the Becker-D6ring and Lothe-Pound fluids. Keywords - Surface tension, Cluster, Nucleation An essential part of the homogeneous nucleation models is the prescription of the cluster Gibbs free energy. Still nowadays, this represents a largely debated issue. There are two approaches. The first one the most well accepted relies on the capillarity approximation, while the second one makes use of the Lothe-Pound (LP) cluster model, which appears to the more consistent from the statistical point of view. In both cases, the surface contribution of the cluster free energy is evaluated making use of the macroscopic surface tension - assumption that may be unrealistic for clusters containing a few molecules. Within the framework of the Lothe-Pound theory, the Gibbs free energy of formation of a cluster consisting of i molecules is given by the expression: 2/3 AG i = Crsli - ikT In S + Ftr + Fro t - Fre p. (1) Here, a is the surface tension, S l is the equimolar surface of the monomer, T is the absolute temperature, S is the supersaturation, Ftr and Frot are the solid body translational and rotational Helmholtz free energies of the cluster, and Frep is the so called replacement free energy which is only -- -7kT. This theory gives good results for non-polar species using cy=croowhile it highly overestimates the nucleation rate for polar species. A possible explanation of the disagreement is that in reality for polar species c > (too. We have developed a simple model of the spherical cluster that really predicts a significant increase of the surface tension of small clusters of polar species (as opposite to the Tolman's correction). We use the classical approximation that a molecule moves in a potential field of its neighbours and the energy of the molecule is simply given by the sum of the internal energy of the molecule (we suppose that the one of the single molecule is not affected by its neighbours), of the kinetic energy like a solid body and of the potential energy in the field of near neighbours. The surface tension is an increase of the Helmholtz free energy as a consequence of the existence of the surface. Therefore, in our approximation cr is evaluated by the Helmholtz free energies of bulk and surface molecules. We use the approximation that the difference of potential energy of bonds strength highly dominates the difference of Helmholtz free energies of the molecule on the surface and in the bulk. Assuming that the bonds strength between the surface molecules and their neighbours are of the same magnitude like the ones between molecules in the bulk, noticing that the typical distance of neighbouring molecules in the cluster is -4~a (the second shortest distance in the structure fcc) where a-~/ml/Pliq, supposing that the typical area per one molecule on the surface is simply 2a 2 (the
220
A new semiphenomenological model for surface tension size dependence
221
square of the typical distance), and that the number of neighbours of the surface molecule divided by the number of neighbours in bulk, coefoo, equals approximately to 2/3 (Fig. 1.), we can write:
ooo =
u pot, bulk(coefoo_l) Upot,surf-Upot,bulk ('V~a) 2 = ("~a) 2 =-
Upot,bul k 3(.,~a)2 .
(2)
Assuming that the kinetic energy of one molecule in the liquid bulk, is approximately equal to that of single molecule in the gas phase, then Upot,bulk can be related to the heat of evaporation per one molecule. For liquids Ubulk----hliq, and hence: u pot,bulk = h liq - u kin,bulk - Uin = h g - h vap - u kin,bulk - Uin = (3) = Ukin,g + u i n
+kT-h
vap-
u kin,bulk - u in = kT -.- h v a p
Hence: hvap-kT ooo = 3(.V~a)2
(4)
9
The equation (4) satisfactorily relates fro,, to hvap for nonpolar species as opposite to the polar ones, for which eqn.(4) overestimates or,,,,. A possible explanation is that the surface dipoles have the tendency to orientate perpendicularly to the surface and therefore the free energy of the surface molecule is lowered. This may be described by the appearance of a peak part in the angle density distribution of bond potential energy w (Fig.2.). We assume that the spherical part of w. is equal to the corresponding value in the liquid bulk Wb= Upot,bulk/4rt.
21/2a
"~
~ ~ _~1~
C'
L~'
ufface
9
9
Figure 1.
Figure 2.
Figure 3.
Let us proceed to the case of a spherical cluster. The surface tension, defined for the equimolar surface is related to the number of the surface molecules by: se ~ = (frsurf-fbulk)n surf (5) Here, f denotes the Helmholtz free energy of a single molecule. However, a better estimate of nsurf could be obtained referring to the sphere connecting centers of surface molecules of radius re-a~2. Hence: cy
=
1_ a__~
frsurf - f b u l k
(6) 2r e (~/-2a)2 Approximating the Helmholtz free energy by the potential energy of bonds and using eqn. (2) we get: ~ _
( )2[
/
)1
1 a_.~ 1 1-~ ' urpot,surf - u ~ pot,surf 9 (7) 2re ( ' ~ a ) 2 ooo We assume that the peak part of w is not affected by curvature. From Figure 3. we see that the angle embracing the number of neighbours (proportional to the solid angle Ysol of the 'neighbours cone') divided by the number of the ones in the liquid bulk is:
Sopuch and Servida
222 ]too --71;+~
Ysol coef r = = 4n Hence: u pot,surf- u Hence:
1-cos~
pot,surf =
(8)
( c o e f r - c o e f ~ ) Upot,bulk.
(9)
2
(Y
1---~a 2r e
~c - o7,o = where: g
2
2
1+
hvap-kT
Pli___qq
ooo
m1 ]
cos
(10)
cos
2
'
_ _ Upot, bulk -
(11)
oooa 2
Determining the angle/3 from Fig. 3., we obtain: -4~ -a
2 ~c =
1+
1- a
cos
re-a//2 cos~'~176 2
2
(12)
Equation (12) shows that ~" parametrically depends only on density, surface tension of the plane surface, and on the evaporation heat. It is important to realize that the relationship (12) cannot be used for very small clusters because the peak part will be also affected by curvature. Using the Taylor expansion of eqn. (12) with respect to a 1/3 -1/3 a__ truncated to the second order and making use of the relation - (4n/3) i we obtain: re re -1/3 .-2/3 K i = 1 + otli + ot21 , (13) where ~
(7)~3
( 6 -1 )
2
--
(1
e
We have extended equation (13) with the third order term, obtaining: -1/3 -2/3 -1 •i = 1 + a l i + o~2i + o~3i
(15)
The coefficient a3 may be obtained from the condition that eqn. (1) gives the right value for r2 determined by comparison of the virial equation of state with the Mayer's conjecture. For AGi given by the Fisher's droplet model we have (Dillmann and Meier, 1991):
[(
kT Ps . . . . . . In ~c2 2~/3 ooos 1 q0 kT
21:-1
)3
q0
B ~-A
1 '
(16)
where ~: and qo are the constants of the Fisher's cluster model. Formally for the Lothe-Pound theory: x =-4
"
q0 =
2gmlkT h2
( /
24n m 1 Fre p ~ p-~m e x p \ - - ~ - - .
Combining equations (15) and (16) we obtain:
(17)
A new semiphenomenological model for surface tension size dependence
o~3 : 2
(
tx1 _o~_2 ~c2-1 21/~ 3 22/~
)fFt : 2
kT In - ( Psoo 2'2/3CooSl L \ q 0 k T
2-5
I3 q0NA
223
]t
-1
~ ct2 21/~3 2 ~ 3
. (18)
It can be shown that it is always a l > 0. For not very small clusters for which a2 can be neglected, eqn. (13) predicts ~"> 1. Figures 4 and 5 show the comparison between experimental data and the predictions of various nucleation models for water (expansion chamber) and chloroform (supersonic nozzle). DM stands for the Dillmann-Meier theory, B D for the Becker-D0ring theory, LP for the Lothe-Pound theory, and LPcor for the Lothe-Pound theory with our surface tension correction factor. We see, that LPcor reconciles the agreement between the Lothe-Pound theory and experimental results. LIST OF SYMBOLS (y (Yoo Sl T S AGi Ftr Frot Frep Uin ml Upot,surf Upot,bulk ukin,bulk Ukin,g hvap Ubulk hliq pIN a
se re nsurf ~(i) B
NA
qo i
Ps
Boltzmann's constant surface tension surface tension of a plane surface equimolar surface of the monomer absolute temperature supersaturation Gibbs free energy of formation of a cluster consisting of i molecules translational Helmholtz free energy of a cluster rotational Helmholtz free energy of a cluster replacement free energy internal energy of a molecule monomer mass potential energy of the single surface molecule potential energy of the single bulk molecule kinetic energy of the single molecule in the liquid bulk kinetic energy of the single molecule in the gas heat of evaporation per one molecule energy of the single bulk molecule enthalpy per one molecule in the liquid bulk liquid density the shortest distance in the fcc structure equimolar surface equimolar radius number of the surface molecules surface tension correction factor of a cluster (consisting of i molecules) second virial coefficient Avogadro number parameter in the expression for the surface tension correction factor parameter of the Fisher's cluster model parameter of the Fisher's cluster model number of molecules in a cluster equilibrium vapor pressure
J/K N/m N/m m2 K J J J J J kg J J J J J J J
kg/m 3 m
m2 m
mol/cm-3 mol-1
m-3 Pa
Sopuch and Servida
224
REFERENCES Dillmann, A. and Meier, G.E. (1991) J.Chem. Phys. 94, 3872. Miller, R.C. (1976) Ph.D. thesis, University of Missouri,, Rolla, MO. Anderson, R.J., Miller, R.C., Kassner, J.L.,Jr, and Hagen, D.E. (1980) J.Atmos.Sci. 37, 2509. Dawson, D.B., Wilson, E.J., Hill, P.G., and Russel, K.C., (1969) J. Chem. Phys. 51, 5389. 20
....
I ....
I ....
1 ....
J . l O 4cm.3s.1
I .... ..... -- --
15
~A
E .O (~ t_ 4_s m10
~N~N~a
9
0
....
220
I I
-----
LPcor Anderson
"
" ~
! ....
BD
LP
9
I ....
- DM
....
x\ " ~ ~
I ....
et
II
al!
I
Miller
~n..,,
I...,I,,..I 230
240
.... 250
!.,..I 260
.... 270
I,,,,I,,,,, 280
290
300
Temperature [K]
Figure 4. Comparison between various nucleation models and experimental measurements for H20.
j = l O~Scm -~s -1 0.01
QL. 0.001
190
200
210
220
230
240
Temperature [K]
Figure 5. Comparison between various nucleation models and experimental measurements for CHC13.
NUCLEATION
CONTROLLED
GROWTH
A . A . L U S H N I K O V +, M . K U L M A L A *
OF AEROSOL
PARTICLES
a n d H. A R S T I L A *
+Karpov Institute of Physical Chemistry 10, Vorontsovo pole, 103064 Moscow K-64, Russia, *Department of Physics, University of Helsinki, P.O. Box 9, FIN 00014 Helsinki, Finland A b s t r a c t - The condensational growth of aerosol particles initially formed by a nucleation process is considered within the theoretical approach proposed by Lushnikov ~: Kulmala, (1995) (referred hereafter to as LK) for treating source enhanced condensation processes. The molecules of condensing vapor are assumed to be able to form dimers, trimers etc. which evaporate very quickly if their masses are below certain value g = G, otherwise they are stable against evaporation and grow by joining the vapor molecules by one. The expression for the nucleation rate is derived. Special attention is given to the case G = 3. The probability for the dimer fragmentation as the function of temperature is found analytically. Keywords-
Nucleation, Condensation, Particle growth, Mass Spectra INTRODUCTION
Disperse particle formation and growth are of great interest in many branches of physics, physical chemistry and modern technology. Of special importance this problem is for the Physics of Aerosols (and Atmospheric Aerosols in particular). The aerosol formation processes are not yet completely understood despite numerous and of many years efforts of the scientists to attack this problem theoretically and experimentaly (see recent review by Laaksonen et al., (1995) and extensive citation therein). There are two directions of these attacks: 9 To find a proper parametrization of the particle formation rate, e.g. the spontaneous nucleation rate is attempted to be expressed in terms of the bulk surface tension, supersaturation ratio etc 4some additional parameters related to the embryo surface curvature and other size effects (see, e.g. Wilemski (1995) and references therein). This approach requires the Thermodynamics (implying a kind of equilibrium) to be exploited in deriving the final expression for the particle formation rate. The discrepancy by many decimal orders between such theories and experiments does not characterize this approach from the best side. Another, ab initio approach introduces into consideration the molecular interaction parameters (e.g. Ellerby et al (1991)). and tries to derive the thermodynamic properties of nucleating clusters from the "first principles". No unique description of the nucleation process is achieved, however. 9 To define the formation-growth kinetics in terms of the rates /3 and a of the elementary acts of a single molecule evaporation-condensation (see e.g. Nowakowski & Ruckenstein (1991) and references therein). In this case a formal kinetic approach is introduced allowing the formation process to be described in terms of particle size distribution evolving with time. The rates may be found from a theoretical consideration or defined experimentally. Of course, it is not easy and not yet fully done, but this problem is independent in a way from the solution of the kinetic equations describing the particle formation-growth process. Next, there is a hope that sufficiently developed spectra will reveal a kind of universality making thus the parametrization more easy and natural. Here we follow along the second route in studying the condensational formation of aerosol particles via nucleation stage. A spatially uniform system consisting of the carrier gas + condensible vapor + suspended disperse particles formed by the condensational process is considered. A source is assumed to provide the system with the vapor. The external conditions (temperature, pressure) support the nucleation of the vapor. The particles formed by the nucleation process grow then by condensation. The
225
226
L u s h n i k o v et al.
problem to solve is formulated as follows: to find the particle size distribution at a given moment of time, once initial conditions and the rates c~ and/3 are known. BASIC EQUATIONS Let us consider the condensing system consisting of the carrier gas and a source permanently producing molecules of a condensible substance (monomers) with the rate I(t) (the number of the monomers produced in a unit volume at a time). The mass of a condensing particle is measured in terms of the number g of the monomers comprising the growing particle. The key quantity to find is the mass spectrum %(t) the number of g-mers per unit volume at the time t. We assume: i. The molecules of the condensible substance are able to produce disperse particles along the scheme in which a monomer either attaches to the growing particle with the rate a9cl proportional to the m o n o m e r concentration cl(t) or escapes from its surface with the rate/39. ii. Evaporation is essential only for the particles whose mass is less than a given one denoted as G. This means that/3g = 0 at g _> G The LK consideration corresponds to G = 2 (dimers are stable). iii. The characteristic times of evaporation (/3~-1) are much shorter than that of the whole process ( o ( 1 / x / ~ I ) . This assumption allows us to consider the nucleation stage as a steady state process. Equations describing the particle formation-growth process look as follows: dc l oo G dt = I - Cl ~ % % + 2/32c2 + ~ /39c9 9=1
(1)
9--3
This equation describing time evolution of the monomer concentration contains now the contribution of evaporating g-mers. The second group of equations describes the nucleation stage which is assumed to be s t e a d y - s t a t e : 1 0 -- XO~lCl2 -- O~2CIC2 -- ~2C2 -}- ~3C 3 Z
(2) 0 - - O l g _ l C l C g _ 1 -- OlgClCg -- ]~9C9 ~- ~ g + 1 r 0 - - O Z G _ 2 C l C G _ 2 -- O ~ G _ I C l C G _ 1 -- ~ G _ l C G _ I
The nucleation stage finishes at g = G, and all subsequent equations describe the condensational growth of the particles formed by nucleation (g >__G): dcG
dt
= ZG(t) - a G c l c c
(3)
9
dcg d---t =
~
-
~162
where we introduced the nucleation rate (the rate of formation of G-mers)" ~G(t)
(4)
-- OIG-IC1CG-I
The strategy of solution of the whole problem includes the following three steps: i. to find the combination (~c-aClCC-1 entering the last equation of the set (2) as the function of cl. Since the time dependence of 2G enters only via cl(t) the former may be found on solving eq. (2)" ZG
1
~'---2- -- 1 + X 2 -}- Z2X 3 + . . . X 2 X 3 . . . X G _
1
(5)
Here we introduced: Z2(c1) = (alC~)/2 - - the rate of formation of dimers if the evaporation processes are forbidden and xa = f l g / ( % c i ) - c ; / c l with c~ = /~g/%. This expression appeared earlier in the
Nucleation controlled growth of aerosol particles
227
paper by Yang & Qiu (1986) ii.The "condensational part" of the program is treated in the same way as in LK. We introduce the new variable"
7 = jfOt cl(t')dt'
(6)
allowing one to cast eq. (3) into the form"
dcg = O~9-1Cg-1 -- 0~9C9 dr
(7)
The Green function gg(r) satisfying the following set of differential equations 1"
dga + saga = ~(r) dr
-
-
(s) d~ dr + aggg - a g - l g g - 1 formally solves eq. (7).
dr'
(9)
g9(7" -- TI)ZG(CI(TI)) CI(T--~
Cg(7") - -
o iii. Now it is possible to close eq. (1) for cl(t)"
de1
C1 ~
- - I -- G I " G ( C l )
-
)
r
R(r
-
Tt)~G(CI(Tt)) ~
0
where
oo
R(,)- ~ ~6~(~) 9-'G
dr'
c1(<)
(~o)
(Ii)
UNSTABLE TRIMERS" G = 3 At G = 3 the nucleation rate has especially simple form" Za
_121
1
~ 1 < 1 + ~/c1
(12)
The coefficients Ct1 and ~2 may be evaluated. The coefficient a l is the product of the relative thermal velocity of two vapor molecules by the cross section of the dimer formation. The latter process is imposible without a participance of a carrier gas molecule, otherwise two associating vapor molecules cannot get rid of the energy excess and reach the state with negative energy. This fact means the dependence of C~1 on the pressure of the carrier gas. The upper limit of a l is of the order of lO-11c.c./s (geometrical cross section by thermal velocity). The necessity to take into consideration three body processes diminishes this estimate by several orders. The evaporation rate of a dimer may be calculated exactly. We define the dimer as the state of two molecules with negative total energy (in the center of mass system). Next, the Gibbs distribution is applied in order to find the number of dimers and then a detailed balance leads to the final result in the form:
~2 =
ale-U~ Uo/kT Vo f vqe-tdt
(13)
o
1The definition given in LK contains the multiplier (rl/2 before the delta-function. the definition of 2"a
Here this multiplier is included in
Lushnikov et al.
228
Let us now estimate the characteristics of the nucleation process for the following set of external parameters: r0 = 3- ]0-Scm, V0 = 4 . 1 0 - 2 3 c m 3, al = 3. lO-11cm3s -1, I = lOl~
-1, ~2 = 10Ss-1
(14)
We find: c~ = 3.101Scm -3 which means that 1 in the denominator of the expression for 273 (eq. (12)) may be ignored. We introduce the characteristic monomer concentration Cc, time tc and number concentration
Nc: Cc oc (I2c~/a~) 1/5,
tc cx cc/I
Wc (x (I/al)3/5(c~) -1/5
(15)
These parameters are just the dimensional groups introduced for reducing eq. (10) to the dimensionless form:
dcl c1---~T
=
1
-
G*c~
-
a(T
Cl
-
v')c~-'(T')dr'
(16)
0
where G* = 3-2-1/511/5a-~1/5(c~) -2/5, G - 3 and the function a ( r ) is defined in LK. Equation (10) was then solved numerically for the condensation coefficients ag corresponding to free-molecular, transition and continuous regimes of particle condensational growth in aerodisperse systems. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION Above set of parameters permits the numerical estimations of the characteristic values of the nucleationcondensation process: maximal monomeric concentration reaches cc (x 1012cm -3, total number concentration of the aerosol particles is Nc (x 10Scm -3 and the total time of the process (all particles have formed) tr cx 102s. These values, however, strongly dependent on not yet well defined kinetic parameters al and/31. It is important to notice that the value of G* is small (cx 10 -2) which means that no external parameters enter eq. (16). The solution to this equation is the universal function Cl(T) (and thus other kinetic functions). This fact, in principle, opens the possibilities to measure the kinetic constants a and defining only the scales of the kinetic curves. Similar estimations were also done for free nucleation process (I = 0). In this case the initial concentration co enters as external parameter, and the characteristic values of the process are introduced differently: ..... the concentration is measured in the units of Co, the characteristic time is defined as: t~ x/2ci/ C 30 ~ l 2 , This time is of the order of 10-4s at co = 1015cm -3. The total particle number N~ (x 1011cm -3. The value of G* - ,Jco/2c~ is also small in this case (a- (3( 10-2). The theoretical description presented above does not pretend to replace the existing approaches to the solution of the Nucleation problem. We believe, however, that our approach will be especially effective in considering the situations when a very short part of the mass spectrum involved into the nucleation process, i.e. G (x 1. -
-
I
I
t
REFERENCES Ellerby, H.M., Weakliem, C.L. and Reiss, H., (1991) J. Chem. Phys., 95, 9209 - 9218. Lushnikov, A.A. and Kulmala, M., (1995) Phys. Rev. E, 52, 1 6 5 8 - 1668. Wilemski, G., (1995) J. Chem. Phys., 103, 1 1 1 9 - 1126. "fang, C.H. and Qui, H., (1986) J. Chem. Phys., 84, 416 - 4 2 3 .
t
NUCLEATION AND CONDENSATION MEASUREMENT BY CONDENSATION
RATE WAVE
F. Mar~fk, J. Blaha, F. Lanka~ Institute of Thermomechanics Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, Dolej~kova 5, 182 00 Prague 8, Czech Republic A b s t r a c t : The homogeneous nucleation with subsequent spontaneous condensation of the vapors of water (molecular mass M~) in a carrier gas (Ar and He with molecuar mass M~) are investigated experimentally and theoretically in the expansion part of a shock tube. The amount of condensate produced in the condensation wave (CW) is evaluated by the principle of minimum entropy production and by measuring of the time of onset and termination of the CW. K e y w o r d s : Nucleation r a t e - Condensation shock wave 1. I N T R O D U C T I O N The homogeneous nucleation of water vapor in a carrier gas was first studied experimentally in the expansion part of a shock tube using light scattering by Barschdorff (1975) and the numerical solution was added by Sislian and Glass (1976). The nucleation and growth rate of droplets in argon was measured by Peters (1989) using the Mie-scattering method. Theoretical analysis and semianalytical solution (asymptotic expansion) Of the embedded condensation shock wave formation in a rarefaction fan was given by Delale et al. (1996). For supercritical conditions a sequence of condensation waves (CW) occurs. Behind the C W local thermodynamical equilibrium establishes. The Mach number Mew of the C W depends according to Mar~fk, et al. (1994) on the concentration c/- = p-i-/p- of the liquid fraction. Here p/- is the density of condensed vapor (spread as droplets) and p- = pc + p~, + p/- is the dei~sity of the whole mixture behind the CW (denoted by . . . . . ). Quantities before the C W are deiloted by " +" The Mach number Mew and the thickness (relaxation time of condensation T) of the first C W are determined experimentally from pressure course during the expansion. The nucleation rate J depends on the condensation rate c[/T and appropriate droplet growth model.
2. P H Y S I C A L
MODEL
The principle of the proposed method is visible in Fig. 1. The amount of condensate c/- behind the C W is evaluated from the energy balance and from the principle of minimum entropy production (Mar~/k, et al. (1994)). In the vicinity of C W we suppose the gaseous mixture with p - p~. + p,, = (~o- ct)RvT and for it are valid the following relations. The Math number of C W is givell by
Mcw = v+ + u(,~) a+
=
~/2(~ + 1)Qgzl + ~/2(?~ + 1)Q,?t + 4 2 '
where ^
RvT
229
~
9
Co
(1)
Mar5ik et al.
230
P4 CONDENSATION
a)
S H O C K
i
9
t+
t
,,
J--
b)
Figure 1. The principle of the nucleation and condensation rate measurement by ttle measurement of the time t + and of the thickness of the condensation shock r. From the equation of energy balance on the C W we have
':':
( M e w - ~_-~+)~ ~t =
glM c w ~''
(2)
Time course of quantities v+ , a + and T + in the expansion part of the shock tube is given by Riemann solution
2ai
v+=
LTS aLtl
~4+1 (1- - )
'
t,-
LTS t+ + . aL
(3)
Using formulae (1), and (2) we obtain the relation
'
ct = ct(TL,PL,;~4,}o,[~,LTs, h~=p,t+).
(4)
for the amount of condensate behind the C W . Besides the initial value of pressure PL and temperature TL and the material constants k4,~o,[~,,h~,=p it depends on the time t + of the C W onset.
3. G R O W T H
RATE MODEL
The almost equilibrium conditions behind the C W are reached within the relaxation time r. which is also measured. Condensation rate is approximately equal to
p+ dcl = p+ ct 4~r t++~ -- = --~-fitJ[r.(t +) + [ § -'~
T
at+
3
(5)
where t~l is the density of liquid and r.(t +) = ~t~T[t,~s+ is the radius of critical cluster, a is surface tension. S + = p+/p+ is saturation ratio and p,~ = pv~(T~) is saturation pressure.
Nucleation and condensation rate measurement by condensation wave
231
Considering molecular growth rate model where we suppose that the initial growth rate is mainly due to the supersaturation S and a stick coefficient ~. The radius of droplets at the time t + + r is then
~(t+ + ~.) = ~.(t+) +
(6)
@~+~s+~-
and the nucleation rate following from (5) is
3p+c~ J = 47rfi+T&(t + + T )
[nuclei t rnZs ]"
(7)
In order to determine the radius r(t +) we used the saturation ratio S + at time t +
4. E X P E R I M E N T A L
METHOD
The driver part is evacuated and filled with'the desired vapor to the pressure PLy. Carrier gas is added to the desired pressure and the acetate diaphragm is ruptured by the needle. The pressuretime course is recorded by a two-channel oscilloscope and evaluated from a photograph of the oscilloscope trace. The pressure-time jump is recorded by the pressure transducer of the distance LTS = 216 m m from the diaphragm.
5. R E S U L T S
AND
DISCUSSION
The nucleation rate calculated by Becker-DSring-Zeldovich theory is compared with our preliminary experiments, Fig. 2. These experiments give greater nucleation rates as the mentioned theory and support in this way the Barschdorff's (1975) results. The advantage of the proposed method is nonoptical record of condensation. Important is only the precise measurements of the time t + and the time interval T. T = 249 K log J
Iml~3sl] 24
20
!
A-At
16 !
12
10
2'0
3'0
40
5'0 60
Sill Figure 2. Nucleation rate of water vapor measured by condensation wave. Comparison with BeckerD5ring-Zeldovich theory.
Margfk et al.
232 6. L i s t o f s y m b o l s
[~/~] [1]
~ Cc-- --~ ~, = ~'p ~,
[1]
= ~
[1]
~0
Co ---- cc(Mv-Mc)+MCMc
[1]
~v = 0-~ p
[1]
h .... ~
[J/kg]
Lrs
[m] [kg/kmot] [Pa]
M~, M~ P=Pc+Pv R -~ x = - ~ Pvs
T
[J/ kgK] [1] [~] [K]
p
[.~/~] [kg/m ~]
R v ---
t
'
;,: - ~cv
[1]
~=o,3-o,s
[1]
~, c l L s
[N/m]
[~]
v
4
speed of sound mass fraction of carrier gas mass fraction of liquid phase specific heat at constant pressure of the whole mixture modified mass fraction of the liquid phase in carrier gas mass fraction of vapor evaporation heat nucleation rate pressure transducer distance molecular mass total pressure radius of a droplet and critical droplet gas constant of vapor saturatibn ratio of vapor time temperature CW velocity with respect to laboratory flow field velocity density adiabatic exponent of the whole mixture stick coefficient thickness of the CW surface tension
carrier gas liquid in the left part of the shock tube saturation vapor before and behind CW, respectively in the expansion part of the shock tube
Acknowledgement. This work was supported by the Grant Agency of the Academy of Sciences of tile Czech Republic, No. 276403 and by the Grant Agency of the Czech Republic, No. 101/96/0152. References [1] Barschdorff D (1975) Carrier gas effects on homogeneous nucleation of vapor in shock tube, Phys. Fluids 18, 5:529-535 [2] Delale CF, Schnerr GH, Mar~fk F (1995) Theory of embedded shock formation in rarefaction waves by homogeneous condensation, Eur. J. Mech. B/Fluids, No.i, pp. 81-102 [3] Mar~fk F, Sopuch P, Blaha J (1994) New nucleation theories and principle of minimum entropy production, in the Physical Chemistry of Aqueous Systems in the Proceedings of the 12th ICPWS, Eds. H. J. White, Jr. et al., Begell House, Inc., N. Y., 1995, pp. 278 [4] Peters F and Paikert B (1989) Nucleation and growth rate of homogeneously condensing water vapor in argon from shock tube experiments, Experiments in Fluids 7:521-530 [5] Sislian JP and Glass II (1976) Condensation of water vapor in rarefaction waves I. Homogeneous nucleation, AIAA JOURNAL 15, 2:1731-1737
PHASE TRANSITION OF CONDENSATE FORMED BY HETEROGENEOUS NUCLEATION OF CONDENSABLE VAPORS A COLD SUBSTRATE
ONTO
Hideo Shinagawa and Kikuo Okuyama Department of Chemical Engineering, Hiroshima Univesity, Higashi-Hiroshima 739, Japan
ABSTRACT The heterogeneous phase transition of organic vapors and water vapor on a cold substrate was observed by either slowly cooling a substrate or by accumlating vapor in a test chamber under reduced pressure conditions. The critical pressure and temperature at the onset of nucleation for liquid or solid condensate were measured. The experimental results for the critical vapor pressure and the critical supersaturation ratio are examined theoretically on the basis of the classical nucleation theory and equilibrium thermodynamics. 1. I N T R O D U C T I O N The heterogeneous phase transition of a condensable vapor on a cold substrate is encountered in low temperature industrial processes such as vapor recovery and gas drying. In spite of its practical importance, only a few studies of the heterogeneous formation of liquid water from water vapor have been reported (Chakarov et a!.,1991; Hwu et a1.,1988), therefore the knowledge concerening to the heterogeneous nucleation of condensable vapor remains uncertain and lacks generality because of scarcity of available data. The purpose of the present study is to observe the heterogeneous nucleation of unicomponent vapors, an azeotrope-forming vapor mixture, a eutectic-forming vapor mixture and a vapor mixed with non-condensable gas and to examine the dependence of the critical vapor pressure or the critical supersaturations on operating conditions. The data obtained have been compared with theoretical predictions based on the classical heterogeneous nucleation theory and the equilibrium thermodynimics. 2. EXPERIMENTAL The experimental apparatus consisted of a test chamber, a vapor feeder and an evacuation system. The test chamber was cylindrical in shape (94mm inner diameter and 82mm in height). The substrate was a polished copper disk (40ram in diameter, 2mm thick) which was glued to the top of the cylindrical bath equipped at the bottom of the test chamber for cooling. A copper-constantan thermocouple of 100 m diameter was buried in a groove machined from the center of the bottom of the substrate. A diaphragm vacuum gauge was connected to a side tube of test chamber to measure the vapor pressure. A glass window (170mm in diameter and 15mm thick) was mounted on an O-ring in a flange placed on the top of test chamber. The vapor feeder was made of Pyrex glass and consisted of a liquid storage compartment (60mm in diameter, 100mm in height) with a side tube to measure liquid temperature of test substance, and a vapor exit tube cotaining a critical nozzle. The evacuation system consisted of a rotary oil pump and an oil diffusion pump. Two types of experiments were conducted. One consisted of firstly stabilizing the flow rate of the test vapor or the test mixed vapor at a substrate temperature a few degrees K higher than the expected condensation temperature and then slowly cooling the substrate at a rate of about l K/min. We call this experimental method LST method (lowing substrate temperature with smaller cooling rate). Another consisted of stabilizing the substrate temperature by circulating continuously the coolant and then introducing the test vapor into the test chamber and accumlating in it. We call this experimental method AV method (accumlating vapor in a closed test chamber at constant substrate temperature). Most of experiments were conducted by the LST method, those by the AV method were limited to the uni-
233
234
Shinagawa and Okuyama
component vapor at the higher vapor pressures where the liquid condensate formed first. The test substances used for the uni-component vapor were benzene, carbon tetrachloride, cyclohexane, water ~md p-xylene. The test substance used for a azeotrope-forming vapor mixture, a eutectic-forming one and a mixed vapor with non-condesable vapor, respectively, were benzene-cyclohexane, p-xylene-water and benzene-nitrogen. The details of the experimental apparatus and procedures were descriled in our previous studies (Shinagawa et ai., 1992; Shinagawa et al., 1994). 3. EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Fig. l shows schematically the variations in vapor pressure p and substrate temperature T,, with elapsed time t which were observed in the experiments for the unicomponent vapors using the LST method. At low vapor pressure a solid condensate formed directly on the substrate 6_ at the critical point (C.P.) as shown in Fig.l-(a). At higher vapor pressures, liquid condensate usually appeared first at the first critical point (C.P. 1), followed by 1) subsequent lonnation of solid crystals independently from the liquid phase at the second critical point (C.P.2) or 2) rapid freezing Time t of the liquid condesate at the second critical point C.P.2 as (a) Direct solidification shown in Fig. l-(b) and (c). In the experiments using the AV method, the subsequent solidification and freezing were observbed to occur after the formation of liquid condensate in the same manner for those using the LST method while vapor pressures continued to rise in some degree up to C.P. 2 from C.P. 1. The values of p and T~ corresponding to the d-I ~ ~ pre,ssure break points were designated the critical vapor pressure and temperature, pc. and T~,., at C.P., C.P. 1 and C. P.2. The critical supersaturation ratio Sc was calculated using the experimental values of pc and T~, determined as Time t mentioned above. Fig.2 illustrates the relationship of lnSc vs (b) S u b s e q u e n t solidification I/T.s.,. for benzene. The relationships of lnSc vs. I/T.~ for ',all test substances are found to be linear as seen in Fig.2. The scatter in the data, inherent in nucleation phenomena, is conspicuous in the formation of solid condensate, the relationship between Sc and i/T,.(, can be correlated using |
i
~
,
~ i "<-_
i
lnSc=A +B IT.v(.
( 1)
where A and B are empirically determined constants. The functional form of Eq.(l) was found in previous work (Shingawa et al., 1992) to be appropriate for comparing the experimental data for benzene to the heterogeneuous nucleation rate equation derived from classical nucleation theory. For all test substances, Sc at the onset of liquefaction was found to be significantly smaller than that of solidification as seen in Fig.2 and 1.00+ 0.01. Thus heterogeneous nucleation of liquid from the vapor onto copper substrate occurs under pseudo-equilibrium conditions This was attributed to the very small contact angle between these liquids and the surface of the substrate (Shinagawa et a!.,1993). Since the liquid condensate forms under a
Time
t
(c) Subsequent freezing Fig.1 Tyoical changes in vapor pressure and substrate temperature with time in LST method
Heterogeneous nucleation of condensable vapors onto a cold substrate
235
supercooled pseudo-equilibrium state as described above and 0.8the solid condensate forms according to the relationship I I I Benzene between its critical vapor pressure and critical temperature, o LST,Direct solidification 9 LST,Liquefaction the boundary condition separating the formation of the liquid LST,Subsequent solidification 0.6 condensate from that of the solid condensate can be 9 LST,Subsequent freezing [] AV,Subsequent solidification determined by solving the simultaneous equations that 9 AV,Subsequent freezing describe the relationship between the equilibrium vapor _ In(Pel/Pes)---""// o 0.4 pressure of supercooled liquid and teml:~rature and that between the critical vapor pressure and critical temperature & for the solid condensate. It can be seen from Fig.2 that the -= predicted boundary temperature T~r agrees well with the 0.2 lowest temperature in the liquefaction. For all test substances t Tscb=260.6K I , the predicted boundary temperature agreed within + 2K / with the experimental one. For subsequent solidification and 0.0 _ .oO d,.,o'8. ~ freezing, it was found as seen in Fig.2 that (1) the I I I relationship between lnSc and I/T,,,. is linear and parallel to 3.6 3.8 4.0 4.2 4.4x10 -3 the relationship of logarism of the ratio of the equilibrium 1/Tsc [ K 1 ] vapor pressure for liquid p,, to the equilibrium vapor pressure for solid p,, vs. I/T~,., (2) the dependence of Sc on Fig.2 Critical supersaturation ratio for benzene as a function of I/T,.,. differs from that for direct solidificati6n, (3) Sc values critical temperature determined by LST and AV experiments are the same, and (4) subsequent solidification occurs in the lower temperature range near the boundary temperature while subsequent XlO 3 freezing occurs from the boundary temperature to the higher ~---T ....... I temperature range. _o The experiments for an azeotrope-forming vapor mixture (benzene and cyclohexane)were conducted by the 12 LST method. The critical vapor pressure and critical o P=675Pa temperature at the formation of solid and liquid condensates o P=1080Pa 10 were determined, based on the break point in the variation in A P=1374Pa the total pressure with time in the same manner for unicomponent vapor. According to the eutectic and azeotropic E 8 z nature of the binary mixture in the vapor-solid system and in O the vapor-liquid system, respectively, pure solids formed in O the region of higher composition of each component, and liquid mixture formed in the region of intermediate composition. The critical pressure for the formation of solid A 0 benzene from the mixed vapor agreed with that for uni0 O0 2component vapor. The critical pressure for the formation of solid cyclohexane from the mixed vapor decreased slightly -J 14 i A l 0.2 0. 06 0.8 1.0 compared with that from uni-component vapor. The liquid mixture tended to form at the equilibrium state. The Yb[-] boundary composition of mixed vapor separating the Fig.3 N u m b e r of crystals formed formation of pure solids from that of liquid mixtures was as a function of benzene determined by solving a nonlinear simultaneous equation content composed of the vapor-liquid equilibrium relationship based on the Margules equations and the critical pressuretemperature relationship for the formation of pure solids (Shinagawa et ai.,1993). The theoretical prediction mentioned above agreed reasonably with the experimental result. ,._.,
-
A
236
Shinagawa and Okuyama
The experiments for a eutectic-forming vapor mixture (p-xylene and water) were conducted by the [+ST method. Two critical temperatures, corresponding to the onset of nucleation, were determined at a given initial vapor pressure by observing a rapid decrease in the vapor pressure in the same manner for the uni-component vapor. A mixed vapor with a water content greater than 85% formed ice at the first critical point, and the critical partial vapor pressure agreed well with that for pure water. For mixed vapors in which the p-xylene content was greater than 30%, p-xylene crystals formed at the first critical point, but the critical vapor pressure tended to decrease with decreasing p-xylene content. For mixed vapors with a composition close to the euctic, it was unclear which crystal formed at the first critical point The relationship between the logarithm of the critical vapor pressure and the inverse of the critical temperature at the second critical point showed good linearity and was close to that at the eutectic condition. Using these experimental results, we discussed the conditions required for separating binary eutetic-forming vapors by sublimation (Shinagawa, et al., 1994). The experiments for benzene vapor mixed with non-condensable gas (nitrogen)were conducted by the LST method. The critical vapor pressure and critical temperarure were determined, based on a visual observation. The relationship between the critical vapor pressure and the critical temperature in the formation of first crystal for the vapor mixture agree reasonably with that for the pure benzene vapor. The duration period for the formation of crystals tended to be longer with increasing of the composition nitrogen gas. Fig.3 illustrates the number of crystals formed N as a function of benzene content yb. It can be seen from Fig.3 that the larger the content of non-condensable gas, the lager the number of crystal formed. This suggests that the phase transition from vapor to solid for the vapor mixture may change from one controlled by crystal growth to one controlled by nucleation with increasing of the content of non-condensable gas. 4. CONCLUSION The heterogeneous nucleation characteristics of condensable vapors on a cold substrate have been studied both experimentally and theoretically. The following points were clarified : (1) behavior of phase transition; (2) dependence of the critical supersaturation ratio on the critical temparature ;(3) boundary conditons separating the formation of liquid from that of solid ; (4) dependence of the critical vapor pressure on the composition of mixed vapor ; (5) effect of the composition of non-condensable gas on the nucleation.
REFERENCES Chakarov,V.M., A.D.Alexandrov, B.V.Toshov and A.D.Scheludko (1991) The nucleation of water on hexadecane. Colliods Surf. 52,17 5. H w u , W . H . , J.S.Sheu and J.R.Maa (1988) Adsorption and nucleation of water vapor on smooth solid substrate. J.Colloid Interface Sci. 1 2 1 , 3 0 3 . Shinagawa,H., K.Sotowa, Y.Kawamura and K.Okuyama (1992) Determination of the critical supersaturation ratio in heterogeneous nucleation of benzene vapor on a cold substrate. J.Chem.Eng .Japan. 25, 139. Shinagawa,H., K.Okuyama and Y.Kawamura (1993) Heterogeneous nucleation of organic vapor on a cold substrate. Can.J.Chem.Eng. 7 1 , 2 3 8 . Shinagawa,H., T.Hamada and K.Okuyama (1993) Heterogeneous nucleation characteristics of mixed vapor of benzene and cyclohexane. J.Chem.Eng.Japan. 26, 173. Shinagawa, H., K.Miyamoto, T.Hamada, B.E.Wyslouzil and K.Okuyama (1994) Determining the phase transition of condensate formed by heterogeneous nucleation of condensable vapors onto a cold substrate. J.Chem.Eng.Japan. 27,284. Shinagawa,H., T.Hamada, K.Miyamoto, and K.Okuyama (1994) Heterogeneous nucleation characteristics of a eutectic-forming vapor mixture on a cold substrate. Separation Sci.Technol. 29, 1843.
Kinetic theory of condensation on identical heterogeneous centers Grinin A.P., Kuni F.M., Kurasov V.B.
Department of Physics, St.Petersburg State University, Russia The supersaturation of the vapor ( is associated with the density of vapor molecules n by the simple equality 4 - n% 1 where n ~ is the density of the molecule number of saturated vapor over the flat surface. In order to characterize the action of external conditions we shall introduce the quantity = ~nc~o - 1 where ntot is the total number of the molecules referred to the volume unit. We shall denote by rhot the density of the free heterogeneous centers and by rhot the density of the total number of heterogeneous centers (both free and occupied by the droplets). Not to complicate our consideration we suppose the vapor consumption by droplets to preserve free-molecular character. For the cube root out of the number of molecules inside the droplet p we have dp= dt
c~ n ~ ~ ~" no~ ,
(1)
where c~ is the condensation coefficient, T is the characteristic time between collisions. Index "*" marks the values in some characteristic moment t, which refers to the period of intensive formation of embryos. We denote via p (p, t) the distribution of droplets on p at the moment t. This distribution is referred to the volume unit and expressed in units of n ~ . We can present distribution p (p, t) in the form p (p, t) - nr
V, O (p) f (z - p)
(2)
noo V
Here f is some function depending on p and t through the argument z - p, z is the coordinate, V is the volume. The choice of the coordinate z is defined according to dz = dp dt dt
237
(3)
Grinin et al.
238
(4)
zIt=. = o
Passing from p to the variable
z=z-p
(5)
(z
we rewrite (2) as following
p (p, t) = n ~ , V , o (z - ~) f (z)
(6)
noo V
Under the applicability of the macroscopic description we may consider, during the first period, the state of droplets which sizes exceed some (3-5) times the critical size as quasisteady state. At each instantaneous supersaturation value ~ this state is described by the steady distribution f8 (() (independent on p). We have to add the law of substance conservation r
(7)
and the conservation law for heterogeneous centers
(8)
~Ttot = 77 + N
where 9 represents the substance condensed by the droplets which is referred to the volume unit and is taken in units of n~, N is the number of the droplets. Taking into account (5) and (6), we have noo,
g=
v,
n~V
f_; dx (z - x) 3 f (x) oo
(9)
N - n~,V, f ~
dxf (x) (10) V The most important role belongs in the presented theory to parameter F defined by equality r = _~,dF(~) d~
[~:~"
(11)
When the macroscopic description can be applied, the value of F is large (some dozens of units). The large value of F allows us to obtain the following approximation for the essential part of the spectrum f(x)= fs(~,)exp(F(~(x)-~,))~,
r/(X)n~
(12)
239
Kinetic theory of condensation on identical heterogeneous centers
The next important parameter will be -
V d~ (x) --I~-0 ,~, dx
(13)
Linearizing ~ (x) in x near x -- 0 and using (13), we write (14)
(x) - ~, + --(-cx
We come to the set of equations describing the condensation during the first period g(x)=
f~
dx(z-x)3rl(x)exp
/-too,
(15)
cx
co
7/(z)-r/(-~)exp
(I),
( - f s / ~ d x e x p ( cx
Fg~,( x ) ) )
(16)
Referring to the unit volume, the number of droplets in the current moment is defined by relation N ( z ) = r / ( - ~ ) - r/(z) (17) The system of equations (15), (16) allows the iteration solution. One can construct iterations according to gi+l (x) -
v,+~ (~)
-
f-----~
/
(
dx (z - x) 3 rh (x) exp cx
(;(
~ (-oo)~xp
-L
d~
oo
g0=0
~xp ~
-
['g~,i,,(z))
rg, (z) )
~
(18) (19) (20)
v0=v(-oo)
It is obvious that g>go
71<~7o
g2 >go
7/2 <7/o
(21)
The set of inequalities shows that iterations really converge to the precise solution estimating it from above and from below by turn. As the criteria of iteration precision, let us use the smallness of the relative deviation in the whole number of droplets 5, = IN'+1 (cx~) - N, (cx~) ] N, ( cx~)
(22)
240
G r i n i n et al.
Let us fulfil the calculation of iterations. Consider the second approximation. Introducing the parameter h according to
6Pv(-~) h-
~,,noo,c a
(23)
one has the equations d x (z - x) 3 exp
9~(~) = f , rl (-cx~) ?Zoo,
cx - ~ . f s
Oo
1
A_ ~(-oo) f,
exp
( h
(24)
exp (cz)
cx - -.f, exp (cx) C
?Zoo,
exp (cx)
C
(25)
1((h))) 1 - exp
h
- - ]', exp (cx) c
"
(26) N2 (cx)) = r / ( - o o ) (1 - exp ( - h ) )
(27)
Using (24) in the right-hand side of (19) one obtains the expression for the third approximation for N (oo) which is the only necessary for estimation of the precision of the second approximation. The maximum value of error 52 for droplets number is approximately 0.16, that can be checked up by direct calculations. So, with the sufficient precision for the modern experiment at the first period one can utilize 9 ~ gl
r / ~ 772
f ~ f2
N ~ N2
(28)
Then, having defined too as the moment when the half of all droplets is formed, we have an equation N2(0) = N2(o0)/2 which is an ordinary algebraic equation on ~. (or t.).
Condensation on the spectrum of heterogeneous centers with different activities
Kurasov V.B.
Department of Physics, St. Petersburg State University, Russia We shall define activity of heterogeneous center as some parameter w AF(w)
-
AF
(I)
I,,,=o - A w
with some positive A. Note that the choice of w - 0 now is rather arbitrary. The total number of heterogeneous centers with given activity w will be marked by 7]tot(W). We shall suppose that ?]tot in essential region is near some constant. The equilibrium vapor molecules density is marked by noo, the real vapor molecule density is marked by n. The power of the metastability will be characterized by the value of supersaturation ~ = n-n~ Every droplet is noo described by the molecule number u , or by linear size p free-molecular regime of growth we have @ dt ~ Let us introduce the size z according to
ul/a
Due to
t
z =
ft
~c~r-ldt '
(2)
.
Here t, is some characteristic moment of time. Considering t ( x ) as the moment when the droplet with given z has been formed (as a droplet) we can consider functions of time as functions of x . Hence, we can see that kinetic equation reduces to the fact that every droplet keeps the constant value of x. To reconstruct the picture of evolution one must establish the dependencies t ( z ) and ~(x). Introduce the value of ff = ~n o -o 1 where ntot is the total number of the molecules in the system. We shall mark by 7]t~ the total number of heterogeneous centers of all types: ?7t~ = f dwUtot(W) where Thot(W ) is the total number of heterogeneous centers of given type.
241
242
Kurasov Let fs be the stationary value of heterogeneous formed droplets sizes distribution measured in units of n~. It can be presented in the following form f~ = f<(((x), w)r/(x, w) where 7/(x, w) is the density on activity of the number of heterogeneous centers free from supercritical embryos and fr doesn't depend on 7/. We shall mark by n ~ g ( w ) the distribution on activity of total number of condensing substance molecules in heterogeneous droplets formed on the centers of activity w. To simplify the formulas we shall use O(w) = 7I(w)/Zhot(W) For the majority of heterogeneous centers types the following approximations of nucleation rates are valid during the period of the essential droplets formation
(( ,
~,
,
)
1
~,
(3) where
r--~,
dAF(()
d~
I~=~.lw=0
(4)
f < , = f<(~,, w)]w=0 and A F is the height of heterogeneous activation barrier. We can put F(w) = F Iw=0 for essential part of activity spectrum. We get for g, 0 the following equations
g(z w) - f,
(z - xj3exp,,-F (
- ~' *lOdxexp,w)~j~
(
~
G(~) - f d~g(z, w)
(6)
e z p ( - r ~ - ~*)dz)
O(z, w) -- exp( - f * e x p ( ) ~ w ) n ~ T]tot
oo
(5)
(7)
~ ,
9 =r
(8)
where f, = f< ,rhot We assume that linearization of the ideal supersaturation is valid ~(x) = ,~, + -~--cx with some positive parameter c. After substitution of this linearization in to system of condensation equations this system transfers to
g(z, w ) -
f,
F
~ ( z - x)3exp(cx - -~**G(x))O(x, w)dxexp(w)~)
(9)
Condensation on the spectrum of heterogeneous centers G(z) = f dwg(z, w) O(z, w) - exp( - f*exp(Aw)n~ F ?]tot
oo
243 (10)
exp(cx - -~, G(x))dx)
(11)
This system can be solved by iteration procedure and special renormalization with the universal solution. Iterational procedure can be constructed by the following way: For initial approximations we choose: 0
9o(Z, w) =
Oo(z,w) = 1
(12)
The recurrent procedure is defined according to
9i+l(z, w ) - f*
1-' - -~**Gi(x))Oi(x, w ) d x e x p ( w , ~ )
oo(Z - X ) 3 e x p ( c x
G,(z) - f dwg,(z, w) 0i+1(z, w) - exp( -f*ezp(Aw)n~176 ?]tot
exp(cx -
(13) (14)
Gi(x))dx)
(15)
oo
The direct calculation of iterations gives
m(z, w) - L
6ezp(cz) c~eZp(aw)
e~(x, w) - ~xp(-f~ Gl(X) -- f ( ,
,~x;(~)~;(c~)) C
6exp(cx) c ~
/ dwexp(Aw)?]tot
(16)
(17) (18)
The last integral causes some problems with convergence. When ?]tot = const it can not be calculated. At least there are two possibilities to overcome this difficulty. The simplest regularization by cut-off is the following one. We must substitute the value of ?]tot by the value ?]init calculated as
~..~ = ~o~e(x = - a , w)
Kurasov
244
after calculation of O(-a, w) which can be calculated on the base of ideal supersaturation, i.e. in the first iteration. As far as
01 (-a, w) -- exp(- fr ,n~exp(s
exp(-ca) ) C
the value of f, must be changed by
f, - fi ,rhot(W)exp(- f( ,n~exp(Aw) exp(-ca) ) c Let us calculate renornalized iterations. Then the expression for G will be the following
G1 - f~, where
~
f_oo rhot(W)exp(,kw)exp(-Aexp(,Xw))dw
6exp(cz) c4
exp(-ca) A=f~ ,noo~-C
When rhot = const the integral can be taken which leads to G1 = f i ,~Ttot
1 6exp(cz) ,~A c4
Note that the integral can be taken in the final limits which allows to take into account only the finite region of activities as far as an approximation of the total number of heterogeneous centers by the composition of Hevisaid's functions. The second approximation for 0 leads to the following result:
02(z, w ) - exp(-fr ,n~exp()~w) where
B-
e x p ( c x - Bexp(cx))dx)
F 6rltot 1 ~**fr c4 )~A
Note that the in principle the integral can be taken in the finite limits. After integration we get 1
02(z, w) -- exp(- fr ,n~exp(aw)--C-~(1 - exp(-Bixp(cz)))) Note that r/(w)= rlinit(w)O(z, w). For the final values one can get
02(00, w) -- exp(- f( ,n~exp(/~w) ~B 1.-~-)
(19)
MODELING
OF VAPOUR-LIQUID IN BINARY
TRANSIENT SYSTEM
NUCLEATION
Z. KOZiSEK AND P. DEMO Institute of Physics, Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, Cukrovarnicks 10, 162 00 Praha 6, Czech Republic A b s t r a c t - Transient nucleation of ethanol-hexanol system is studied within selfconsistent model. Dimensionless kinetic equation describing the time dependent process of formation of droplets from vapour phase is solved numerically to obtain the distribution function of nuclei and cluster flux. It is shown that for chosen system at the initial stadium prevails formation of ethanol rich clusters; for sufficiently long times (stationary state) formation of nuclei near the saddle point is dominant. The saddle point integration method used by Stauffer (1976) gives a reasonably accurate estimation of stationary nucleation rate. K e y w o r d s - kinetics; transient binary nucleation INTRODUCTION From pioneering work of Reiss (1950) about kinetics of phase transformations in binary systems, the study of stationary nucleation process, or, thermodynamics of binary systems prevails. Model suggested by Reiss (1950) unfortunately leads to equilibrium distribution function ( -KS w) , which does not fulfil the law of mass action ( W - work of formation of clusF~ ters, T - temperature, k - the Boltzmann constant and A is the number of monomers within the system). This model has been recently modified by Wilemski and Wyslouzil (1995) to fulfil the law of mass action and limiting consistency (i.e., equilibrium distribution function of monomers corresponds to the number density of monomers). The self-consistency was achieved by change of prefactor A. This modification has consequences to nucleation process because the transient frequencies of detachment of single molecules from cluster surface are computed from the condition of local equilibrium. Only limited number of works studied transient nucleation of binary systems. Wilemski (1975) derived the first estimation of time lag of binary nucleation assuming that the major flux through the subcritical cluster sizes follows the path defined by tan 13 - n*B/n*A, where n~, n~ denotes the number of A, t3 molecules within the cluster at the saddle point on the energy surface W ( n A , riB). Shi and Seinfeld (1990) developed the approximate solution for time dependent nucleation rate and time lag of binary nucleation. Wyslouzil and Wilemski (1995) numerically solved kinetic equation within self-consistent model and showed that Stauffer's (1976) analytical solution of stationary nucleation rate coincidences with numerical value in most systems. Recently, Wyslouzil (1996) analysed the transient nucleation at the saddle point and showed that both available analytical expressions overestimate the time lag of the saddle point nucleation flux by factor 2-6. Here, we concentrate on distribution function and cluster flux of ethanol-hexanol system because of availability of experimental data of Strey and Viisanen (1993). BASIC EQUATIONS The evolution equation of the number density of clusters is given by: dF(nA, nB,t) = JA(rtA -- 1, rtB,t ) -- gA(rtA,rtB,t)-[- gIB(rtA, rt B -- 1 , t ) - J R ( h A , r i B , t ) , dt
245
(1)
Ko~fgek and Demo
246
where F(nA, riB, t) is the number of clusters of nA (number of molecules of A component) + n B (number of molecules of B component) molecules at time t in unit volume and
JA(nA,ns,t) - k+A(nA,ns)F(nA, n B , t ) - kA(nA + 1,nB)F(nA + 1,riB,t)
(2)
JB(nA,ns,t) -- k+S(nA, nB)F(nA, n S , t ) - kB(nA,nB + 1)F(nA, nB+ 1,t),
(3)
resp. where the transient frequencies of attachment of molecules of A and B components kA,B + are taken as follows: ! -
k+
+
+
-2.;
.; 7
'
(4)
where m(nA, nB) and d(nA,nB) denote molecular mass and diameter of cluster of nA + ns molecules of A, B components, mA,B and dA,B denote the molecular mass and diameter of A, B components and NA,B are monomer concentrations of A, B components. Detachment frequencies kA,B were determined from the principle of local equilibrium (i.e., JA = JB = 0) for which following relationships hold:
k+(nA, nB)F~ nB) k+(nA, nB)rO(nA,nS)
-
kA(nA + 1,nB)F~ + 1,nB), ks(hA,riB + 1)FO(nA,nS + 1),
(5) (6)
where the self-consistent form of the equilibrium distribution function F~
(N~
xBexp(xAOA + XBOB)exp
--
kT
has been used. Above, N~, B are the monomer number densities in equilibrium with pure liquids, XA = 1 -- ZB = nA/(nA § riB), OA,B = SlCrA,B/kT, Sl is the surface area of a m o n o m e r and crA,B designates the surface tension of pure liquid A, B. The reversible work W(nA, riB) required to form a cluster containing nA + nB molecules from the vapour is computed by the capillarity approximation (see, e.g., Wyslouzil and Wilemski (1995)). Nucleation rate (or total cluster flux for given cluster size n) can be expressed by
J(n, t) =
~
[JA(nA, riB, t) + JB(nA, riB, t)].
(8)
nA+nB=n
This quantity depends only on cluster size and time, but not on composition. Resemble as in our previous work Koffgek and Demo (1995), we have used for numerical computation dimensionless form of kinetic equations. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION For numerical computation, we have chosen ethanol(E)-hexanol(H) system with following input data: T = 260 K, relative atomic mass ME = 46.07, MH = 102.17, density p~ = 817.5 kg m -3, PH = 845.4 kg m -3 and partial pressure of saturated vapor P ~ = 598.36 Pa, P ~ = 2.643 Pa. For interfacial energy we use the following empirical formula: a(xB)-
(25.02 + 7.31088XB -- 3.43199x~) X 10 -3
Jm -2
(9)
Furthermore, we take activity as = 1 and a H = 10, which leads to the saddle point (n),n~r) (16.11,29.08). We concentrate on dependence of distribution function and cluster flux for n =
Modeling of vapour-liquid transient nucleation in binary system
247
45 ~ n ) + n ~ / a s a function of cluster composition ZH to recognized the behaviour of nucleation process near the saddle point. 2.0
m,
1.0
45
............
n
45
1.5
g
~z
1.0
0.5
x
0.5 0.0 0.0'
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
.0 ' 0'.2 "" . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1.0
Fig. 1. Number density of clusters F as a function of cluster composition XH for cluster sizen -- 45 ~ n)+n*H at t i m e t -- 1.66• .6 s (dashed line), 3.33 x 10 .6 s (dot-dashed line) and 10 .5 s (solid line). Saddle point composition is depicted by dotted line.
1.0
XH
XH
Fig.
2. Dimensionless distribution function
f = F / F ~ as a function of cluster composition ZH for cluster size n -- 45 ~ n~: + n~ at time t = 1.66 X 10 .6 s (dashed line), 3.33 • 10 .6 s (dot-dashed l i n e ) a n d 10-Ss (solid line). Saddle point composition is depicted by dotted line.
First of all, we have determined the dependence of distribution function F (see Fig. 1) and normalized distribution function (see Fig. 2) on cluster composition z u at times t = 1.66 • 10 .6 s (dashed lines), 3.33 • ~0 - ~ ~ (dot-dashed lines) and 10 .5 s (full lines). At sufficiently long time for reaching the stationary state (t = 10 -s s), the m a x i m u m of cluster distribution function is localized near the saddle point composition Cs = 0.6435 (dotted lines on Figs. 1 and 2) - see Fig. 1. For shorter times this e x t r e m u m shifts to the lower composition xtt, i.e., the growth of ethanol is more preferable. This is caused by the fact that the rate of attachment of ethanol molecules on cluster surface is approximately two orders of magnitude higher than that for hexanol. Normalized distribution function (see Fig. 2) even reaches quickly its equilibrium value for lower cluster composition ZH, i.e., the equilibrium distribution function is reached in relatively short time in directions near to nE (number of ethanol molecules within the cluster) axis.
Secondly, we have determined the dependence of the cluster flux J = JE + Jtt from eqs. (2) and (3) near the saddle point for n = 45 ~ n ) + n~ on cluster composition XH (see Fig. 3). Resemble as for distribution function, the cluster flux is localized to lower composition XH at shorter times t = 1.66 x 10 -6 s (dashed line) and 3.33 • 10 .6 s (dot-dashed line). At stationary state t = 10 .5 s (full line) the m a x i m u m value of cluster flux is localized at the saddle point Cs = 0.6435 (dotted line on Fig. 3). Total cluster flux determined from eq. (8) (full lines on Fig. 4) for cluster size n = 40,45(~ n ) + n~4 ) and 55 molecules as a function of time has resemble behaviour as in single component system. It reaches some extremal value for cluster size n - 40 < n ) + n ; / a n d for sufficiently long time reaches its stationary value, which is rather higher than Stauffer's (1976) analytical solution of stationary nucleation rate (dotted line on Fig. 4). Cluster flux JE(n*E, n'H) + JH(n*E, n'H) at the saddle point (dashed line) reaches lower stationary value than total cluster flux and Stauffer's solution. CONCLUSION Condensation of ethanol-hexanol system for aE - 1, a u -- 10 at T - 260 K starts with formation
Ko~i'gek and Demo
248
of ethanol rich clusters. For sufficiently long time cluster flux for n - 45 ~ n ) + n~ reaches its maximum at the saddle point composition Cs = 0.6435. Stauffer's (1976) analytical solution gives very reasonable limit of stationary nucleation rate, which lies between the stationary limits of total cluster flux and cluster flux at the saddle point. ,
%
g X
0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1
45
,
,
.
,
,
,
,
.
,
.
,
.
,
.
.
.
7 _-'-. 6 'r
5 4 2
1 ~'-
,
i
0"~)'.0 ' '0'.2 ' 0
,
I
;,
i
;~=,.
,
1.0 X I 4
Fig. 3. Cluster flux JE + JH (see eqs. (2), (3)) as a function of cluster composition for * + nH * at time t -cluster size n = 45 ~ n E 1.66 x 10 .6 s (dashed line), 3.33 x 10 .6 s (dotdashed line) and 10 .5 s (solid line). Saddle point composition is depicted by dotted line.
O0
'2'
' 'J~' ' '6' txl 0 6 (s)
' '8'
' '10
Fig. 4. Total cluster flux J (see eq. (8)) for cluster size n = 40, 45 and 55 molecules (full l i n e s ) a n d cluster flux JE(n*F,,n*i_I)+ JH(n*F,,n*H) at the saddle point (dashed line) as a function of time. Stauffer's (1976) analytical solution of stationary nucleation rate is depicted by dotted line.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT This work was supported by Grant No. A1010615 of the Grant Agency of the Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic. In particular, we would like to thank to Drs. G. Wilemski and B. E. Wyslouzil for preprint of their articles, especially Wyslouzil (1996). REFERENCES Ko~fgek, Z. and Demo, P. (1995) J. Chem. Phys. 102, 7597. Reiss, H. (1950)J. Chem. Phys. 18, 840. Shi, G. and Seinfeld, J. H. (1990) J. Chem. Phys. 93, 9033. Stauffer, D. (1976) J. Aerosol. Sci. 7, 319. Strey, R. and Viisanen, Y. (1993) J. Chem. Phys. 99, 4693. Wilemski, G. (1975) J. Chem. Phys. 62, 3772. Wilemski, G. and Wyslouzil, B. E. (1995) J. Chem. Phys. 103, 1127. Wyslouzil, B. E. and Wilemski, G. (1995) J. Chem. Phys. 103, 1137. Wyslouzil, B. E. (1996) Binary nucleation kinetics. III. Transient behaviour and time lags, submitted to J. Chem. Phys.
MOTION PICTURES OF NUCLEATION AND GROWTH OF SOLID PHASES IN S U P E R C O O L E D M O L E C U L A R C L U S T E R S LAWRENCE S. BARTELL AND KURTIS E. KINNEY Department of Chemistry, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA Abstract - Motion pictures constructed from molecular dynamics simulations show the behavior of molecules during phase changes in molecular clusters of chalcogen hexafluorides. Keywords - Molecular dynamics, Nucleation, Motion pictures, Phase changes, Clusters To provide graphic illustrations of the molecularmotions leading to the formation and growth of nuclei, moving pictures made from molecular dynamics simulations of clusters of SF6 and SeF6 undergoing phase transitions will be shown. In computer simulations clusters serve as convenient and realistic models of phase changes in condensed matter because they are not subject to the constraints imposed by the periodic boundary conditions used in simulations of bulk phases. Both freezing [Kinney et al. (1995)] and certain solid state transitions can be followed. Astronomically large rates of homogeneous nucleation occur in clusters by virtue of the deep supercooling that can be attained. Nucleation rates in clusters can be studied experimentally in supersonic jets [BarteU and Dibble (1990)] as well as computationally [Bartell and Xu (1995)]. Two kinds of motion pictures have been generated, the first being of images of molecules executing thermal motions in the cores of clusters, initially in the bcc phase, that eventually transform to the monoclinic phase. In these movies, clusters are cooled 10 K every 50 ps, or every 40 seconds of viewing time. Cooling is accomplished by periodic 10 ps immersions in a heat bath to extract the required amount of heat. The second kind of movie is of Pawley projections [Fuchs and Pawley (1988)]. Such projections are arrays of dots representing projections of bond directions of all the molecules in a cluster on a hemisphere over the cluster. In the Pawley movie a cluster begins in the liquid phase, freezes to a single bee crystal, and finally becomes monoclinic. Cooling is slower to give the molten clusters enough time to freeze. What can be seen clearly in the movies of the molecular images are the haphazard structural fluctuations postulated by nucleation theory. These fluctuations correspond to the formation and disappearance of precritical embryos of the new phase that come and go until, by chance, one is formed that is large enough to become critical. At that point the nucleus grows spontaneously and the transition is rapidly completed. The embryos are made conspicuous by changing the colors of the molecules each time they acquire the orientation identifying them with the new phase, for as long as they persist in that orientation. The fluctuations are readily recognized by the flickering patches of color. Pawley projections give a different point of view, vividly illustrating the kinetic turmoil of the molecules as they collide with each other, and clearly displaying the substantial orientational disorder characteristic of the plastically crystalline bee phase. REFERENCES Bartell, L. S. (1995)J. Phys. Chem. 99, 1080. Bartell, L. S. and Dibble, T. S. (1990)J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 112, 890. Bartell, L. S. and Xu, S. (1995)J. Phys. Chem. 99, 10446. Fuchs, A. H. and Pawley, G. S. (1988)J. Phys. France 49, 41. Kinney, K. E., Xu, S. and Bartell, L. S. (1996) J. Phys. Chem. in press.
249
C O M P U T E R S I M U L A T I O N OF P R E N U C L E A T I O N CLUSTER USING 'PERCOLATION THEORY' Buxees Department
T. Singh*
of Mathematics, M i c h i g a n State University, Lansing, Mi. 48823, U . S . A .
East
Metropolis Iet. al. p r e s e n t e d the first a p p l i c a t i o n of Monte Carlo method to statistical m e c h a n i c s Lee 2 et al. applied the p r o c e d u r e to simulate the structure of p h y s ic a l clusters. As noted by Haile 3, this is typically done using a fixed number of m o l e c u l e s N, contained in fixed volume V, and maintained at constant t e m p e r a t u r e T. Haile also alludes to methods, w h i c h are a blend of s t o c h a s t i c (Monte Carlo) and d e t e r m i n i s t i c (molecular dynamics) methods. In the present study 'percolation theory' as described by Stauffer 4 is employed to simulate potentially i r r e g u l a r growth of p r e n u c l e a t i o n clusters, which is more close to the reality of random movements of gas molecules. Since the g r o w t h is i r r e g u l a r the r e s t r i c t i o n s of fixed number of molecules or their o r i e n t a t i o n s does not apply and for the initial growth the v o l u m e need not be fixed either. For p r a c t i c a l reasons the m o l e c u l e s are chosen to be hard spheres. To initiate a cluster g r o w t h a m o l e c u l e is chosen for the s t a r t of the chain. A second m o l e c u l e is then a t t a c h e d to the surface of the first. The attachment if necessary may be forced to give a specific structure, if the phase change is from gas to solid phase such as the formation of c o m p u t e r chips (e.g. cubic lattice) or the a t t a c h m e n t is a c c o m p l i s h e d in a c c o r d a n c e with s a t i s f a c t i o n of a prescribed distribution function. (e.g. a uniform d i s t r i b u t i o n with respect to~'and a triangular d i s t r i b u t i o n with respect to ~'in spherical coordinates). In typical as phase reference the m o l e c u l e s will a p p r o a c h this e m b r y o n i c center from all directions; h o w e v e r only those m o l e c u l e s w o u l d stick w h i c h a p p r o a c h from a feasible direction and are not too energetic. The a d d i t i o n of more molecules and hence further growth of this cluster is a c c o m p l i s h e d by s e l e c t i n g a m o l e c u l e in the c o m p l e x chain subject to feasible a t t a c h m e n t of the new i n c o m i n g molecule. The method is innovative when compared to Monte Carlo p r o c e d u r e b e c a u s e it avoids any c o m p l e x i n t e g r a t i o n functions, further the internal energy and intrinsic p r e s s u r e may be c o m p u t e d at each step. The c l u s t e r may d i s p e r s e itself if the c o n t e n t s of internal energy become too high; however various growth termination criteria may be e m p l o y e d to save the cluster; by i m p o s i n g limits on the *Excerpted
from the Doctoral
Dissertation
250
of Buxees
T. Singh
Computer simulation of prenucleation cluster using precolation theory number of molecules or internal energy or entropy or any c o m b i n a t i o n t h e r e of. E n e r g y b a l a n c e r e q u i r e d to s t a b i l i z e the nucleation c l u s t e r has a l w a y s b e e n a s t i c k y p o i n t in v a r i o u s t h e o r i e s and s i m u l a t i o n s . In the p r e s e n t p r o c e s s the g r o w t h is q u i t e r a n d o m l e a d i n g to a c o m p l e x h y d r o c a r b o n type c h a i n e.g. of s e v e n t e e n m o l e c u l e s a n d l o w e r i n g of e n e r g y is a c h i e v e d by the d e p a r t u r e of four h i g h e n e r g y m o l e c u l e s f r o m t h i s c h a i n r e s u l t i n g in c o o l i n g of the c l u s t e r and its a s s u m p t i o n of a m o r e s t a b l e s p h e r i c a l c o n f i g u r a t i o n of 13 m o l e c u l e s . The f u r t h e r g r o w t h is established either by accretion or further condensation of m o l e c u l e s to a c h i e v e a b a l a n c e b e t w e e n s u r f a c e e n e r g y and f u g a c i t y of the c l a s s i c a l t h e o r y . The peculation theory is versatile enough to use any m a t h e m a t i c a l function. One c o u l d a l s o a r b i t r a r i l y fix a n u m b e r for the c l u s t e r or e n e r g y of the a r r a n g e m e n t at w h i c h the d e s i r e d configuration occurs or one could make it h a p p e n with some probability 'p' t h a t d e p e n d e d on n u m b e r of m o l e c u l e s or the c o m p l e x i t y and length of the above d e s c r i b e d chain. H o w e v e r in the n e w ( s y m m e t r i c a l ) a r r a n g e m e n t , it is l i k e l y t h a t t h e r e are f e w e r p o t e n t i a l s i t e s for g r o w t h , s o a c c r e t i o n c o u l d be of r e a s o n a b l e i m p o r t a n c e for d r o p l e t growth. D e p e n d i n g upon the energy of l e a v i n g m o l e c u l e s from the c o m p l e x chain, the n u c l e u s c o u l d be m u c h c o o l e r t h a n the e n v i r o n m e n t a n d s i m p l e d i s t i l l a t i o n m a y also a c c o u n t for the p a r t i c l e g r o w t h . Method:
The p s e u d o - c o d e
for the p r o g r a m m e
follows:
D e f i n e m a x i m u m r a d i u s , n u m b e r of m o l e c u l e s / * i n i t i a l i z a t i o n */ P l a c e m o l e c u l e s of r a d i u s 1 at the o r i g i n /* all m o l e c u l e s are a s s u m e d to be s p h e r i c a l of r a d i u s 1 */ for i = 1 to 3 p i c k x_i in N(0,1) for j = 1 to 3 set y_i = ( x _ i ) / ( x _ 1)^2 + ( x _ 3 ) ^ 2 ) ^ i / 2 /* this is n e c e s s a r y to g e t a u n i f o r m d i s t r i b u t i o n for the p o i n t of t a n g e n c y o v e r t h e s u r f a c e of the f i r s t m o l e c u l e */ c e n t e r s e c o n d m o l e c u l e = (0,0,0) + 2(y_l, y_2, y_3) c o m p u t e c e n t e r of m a s s /* m a i n loop */ for k = 2 to n u m b e r of m o l e c u l e { s e l e c t m o l e c u l e in c l u s t e r to a t t a c h to s e l e c t d i r e c t i o n u n i f o r m l y on e a c h as w i t h the f i r s t one n e w c e n t e r = ( o l d m o l e c u l e c e n t e r ) + 2 * ( n e w m o l e c u l e centre) for 1 = 1 to k-I { if all the f o l l o w i n g c h e c k s s u c c e e d { c h e c k if d i s t a n c e b e t w e e n n e w m o l e c u l e s and all the o l d o n e s is l a r g e r t h a n 2 (radii sum) c h e c k if n e w m o l e c u l e is i n s i d e the s p h e r e c e n t r e d at the c e n t r e of m a s s w i t h the w i d t h of the m a x i m u m a l l o w e d r a d i u s check the internal energy, intrinsic pressure, a n d the H e l m h o l z free e n e r g y of the n e w a r r a n g e m e n t do not e x c e e d the s p e c i f i c a t i o n s } add the n e w m o l e c u l e
251
Singh
252 )
else d e c r e m e n t
k and start the loop over
REFERENCES i.
N. Metropolis, A. W. Rosenbluth, M.N. Teller, ans E. Teller, J. Chem. Phys. 1087(1953).
2.
J.K. Lee, J. A. Barker, 58, pg. 3166(1973).
3.
J.M. Haile, M o l e c u l a r Dynamics Wiley Interscience, (1982).
4.
D. Stauffer, I n t r o d u c t i o n Francis, (1985).
Rosenbluth, A.H. Vol. 21, Pg.
and F.F. Abraham,
J. Chem Phys.
Simulation-Elementary
to P e r c o l a t i o n
Theory,
Vol
Methods
Taylor and
BIOLOGICAL A P P L I C A T I O N OF NUCLEATION T H E O R I E S - I; N U C L E A T I O N AND G R O W T H OF LUNG CANCER Buxees T i p t o n Singh* Department
of M a t h e m a t i c s , M i c h i g a n State University, Lansing, Mi, U.S.A.
East
Introduction: Cancer is a multi-stage process. Hence, any m a t h e m a t i c a l model must also have m u l t i p l e stages in which the behavior of the equations reflects the growth behavior of the stage under investigation. This paper is the first attempt to bring the n u c l e a t i o n theories out of Physical C h e m i s t r y L a b o r a t o r i e s and apply to problems of human need. Currently, the model considered the most realistic over many stages of cancer growth in vivo is the Gompertz model. (insert e q u a t i o n here). However, the model is c o n s i d e r e d r e a l i s t i c when there are a large number of cells (over 1,000,000). However, it does not accurately reflect the growth in the initial stages of the cancer, w h e r e it is c u r r e n t l y b e l i e v e d to be a p p r o x i m a t e l y exponential. Thus, it is necessary for any mathematical model to reflect this by changing the e q u a t i o n s that would describe the behavior of the cancer at any stage. Even then, the mode of growth is not n e c e s s a r i l y one of those d e s c r i b e d above. One p r o b l e m i m m e d i a t e l y apparent is that there is no d i s c u s s i o n about how the shape of the cancer m i g h t be from any set of d e r i v e d m a t h e m a t i c a l equations. A l m o s t u n i f o r m l y in the literature, the tumors are assumed to be spherical in three-dimensions, with the very rare v a r i a t i o n that the growth is ellipsoidal. However, even with a c u r s o r y perusal of medical literature, it is obvious clear that not only are c a n c e r s not n e c e s s a r i l y ellipsoidal, but even when they appear to be so, they are not n e c e s s a r i l y solid, and c e r t a i n l y do not possess either .a smooth or regular boundaries. Indeed, the b o u n d a r y is c o n s i d e r e d to be "dendritic" or "fractallike", which in turn requires a model that would exhibit this kind of behavior under appropriate conditions, which makes modifications of the current models necessary. Equations and Model. One such model that gives this kind of b e h a v i o r is viscous f i n g e r i n g in porous media. The t e c h n i q u e s u t i l i z e d to simulate the i r r e g u l a r growth from equations that *Excerpted
from the Doctoral
Dissertation
253
of Buxees T. Singh
Singh
254
would ordinarily give regular p a t t e r n s include either p e r t u r b a t i o n of initial or boundary conditions, or the i n t r o d u c t i o n of noise or some other forcing term in the g r o w t h equations themselves. Clearly, any combination of these is also possible, a l t h o u g h it is a p p a r e n t l y rarely attempted. Hence, a model that could p r e d i c t p r o p e r g r o w t h p a t t e r n s can be s u m m a r i z e d as followsFor the first stage, we have e x p o n e n t i a l g r o w t h n u m b e r of cells N with g r o w t h c o n s t a n t k:
over
time
in the
Note that this growth gives rise to a nucleus for the initial stage of one cell p r o l i f e r a t i n g in a tissue. One may m o d i f y this in any number of ways to o b t a i n a three d i m e n s i o n a l structure, such as: a) a s s u m i n g that the mean r a d i u s r = ax perturbations in each principal d i r e c t i o n alters the above e q u a t i o n to:
by = cz, over time,
with s u i t a b l e w h i c h in turn
b) c o n v e r t i n g the above into a first order h y p e r b o l i c p a r t i a l differential e q u a t i o n by a s s u m i n g all the cells are the same volume, w h e n c e N = N(x(t), y(t), z(t), t), w h i c h w o u l d yield: +
.
.
.
.
.
A f t e r the g r o w t h of the initial nucleus, for the second stage, we h a v e a choice of d i f f e r e n t e q u a t i o n s to try. One is to use the N a v i e r - S t o k e s e q u a t i o n s for fluid flow:
=
( s,(o,,,, o,
=
v
-
S(x,y,z,t) is the s t r e a m function, V ( x , y , z , t ) is the v e l o c i t y function. Note S(x,y,z,t) is a s t r e a m l i n e , w h i c h would be the a n a l o g u e of a " d e n d r i t e . F(x,y,z,t) is a forcing term w h i c h in t h i s instance could reflect, among o t h e r things, forces that are a c t i n g on the cancer from the s u r r o u n d i n g t i s s u e s and structures, the rate of s l o w i n g or a c c e l e r % t i n g of g r o w t h and volume due to
Biological application of nucleation theories - I
255
nutrition, vascularization, and i m m u n o l o g i c a l defenses. Here, h(t) is a source t e r m r e f l e c t i n g that the mass is g r o w i n g out from the centre. Note that if h(t) = constant, G(x,y,z) = 0, and F(x,y,z,t) = 0, this is a model of a u n i f o r m p o i n t source c e n t r e d at the origin for r a d i a l l y s y m m e t r i c flow. Lastly, for the limiting stage of G o m p e r t z i a n we start w i t h is-
~t
= _a
N&
(%)
growth,
the e q u a t i o n
w h e r e a and b are p o s i t i v e constants. We may again make kind of m o d i f i c a t i o n s as above to yield:
the
same
The natural q u e s t i o n is w h i c h is the best way to s i m u l a t e t h e s e e q u a t i o n s ? The most o b v i o u s m e t h o d i s to always work with the number of cells, w h i c h w o u l d r e q u i r e c o n v e r t i n g the N a v i e r - S t o k e s s y s t e m into one that i n v o l v e s the n u m b e r of cells, and then u s i n g percolation or a Monte-Carlo type method to generate and arrangement. This w o u l d p r o b a b l y be the most realistic, but is i m p r a c t i c a l due to the n u m b e r of cells i n v o l v e d to c o m p a r e the s i m u l a t i o n a g a i n s t k n o w n data. The other m e t h o d w o u l d entail perturbing the initial and/or b o u n d a r y c o n d i t i o n s as s t a t e d above, and then a l l o w i n g the g r o w t h to continue onward as if it were from a uniform start. By far, this is the m o s t c o m m o n a p p r o a c h for the v i s c o u s f i n g e r i n g model.
Effect of supersaturation, temperature and total pressure on the homogeneous nucleation of n-pentanol P. van Remoortere ~, C. Heath b, P.E. Wagner c, R. Strey', ~Max-Planck-Institut for Biophysikalische Chemie, Postfach 2841, D-37018 GOttingen, Germany, bWorcester Polytechnic Institute, Worcester, MA, USA c Institut ftir Experimentalphysik, Universit~it Wien, Boltzmanngasse 5, A- 1090 Wien, Austria
Abstract - The supersaturation and temperature dependencies of n-pentanol nucleation rates are found to be in close agreement with the so-called self-consistent classical theory. The pressure dependence is found to be much weaker, and opposite in sign, than the pressure effects found in diffusion cloud chambers. Keywords
-
homogeneous nucleation, pressure dependence, nucleation theory
INTRODUCTION Homogeneous nucleation of droplets from supersaturated vapors depends on vapor supersaturation, temperature and carrier gas pressure. Theories predict an extremely strong dependence on supersaturation, a moderate one on temperature and a rather weak pressure dependence. Recent nucleation experiments confirm the dependence on supersaturation, reveal slight deviations of the temperature dependence, but heavily disagree on the pressure dependence. While with expansion techniques only marginal pressure dependencies were detected, diffusion cloud chambers yield enormous pressure effects. The magnitude of the pressure effect is reported by Katz et al. (1992) and Heist et al. (1994,1995) to increase with the molecular mass of both the carrier gas and the condensable vapor, and decreasing temperature. In order to also examine this pressure effect most sensitively in an expansion chamber, we have chosen argon as the carrier gas, n-pentanol as the vapor and a rather low nucleation temperature (T=250 K) for investigating the pressure effect. EXPERIMENTAL NUCLEATION PULSE TECHNIQUE Using a nucleation pulse method (Strey et al. (1994)) homogeneous nucleation rates in the range of J (105 < J/cm "3s~ < 109), temperature (250 < T/K< 270) and total pressure (0.1 < p/bar <1) are measured. Hopressu re transducer calibration mogeneous nucleation is induced by a single pressure 100 pulse. Pressure, temperature and vapor supersaturation 9 , . ~ . / .... a 1 . 0 1 are maintained constant during the nucleation pulse of about 2 ms. The number concentration of nucleated ~ 80 ' J ' J ' ' ~ 0.99 J droplets is measured by light scattering. The growth of ,.,a" 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 the n-pentanol droplets formed is observed to be com,~ 60 paratively slow ensuring well-defined, constant conditi," ons during the nucleation pulse. The n-pentanol was -" o purchased from Merck (>99.0 %), and was the same ~ 40 used as in several other studies reported in this volume. ~= PRESSURE TRANSDUCER CALIBRATION The response of the pressure transducer (Kistler 9031, with charge amplifier 5011) is shown in Fig. 1. The calibration conditions were extended over a considerable Ap/p0 range, see insert. No systematic effect on temperature (in the range from 15 to 55 ~ nor total pressure
256
e,
20
,
l
2
Fig. 1
,
l
4
,
I
,
6
voltage change N
I
8
10
257
Effect of supersaturation, temperature and total pressure (in the range from 0.1 to 2 bar) was detected. As the insert shows, varying the conditions over these ranges results in only marginal deviation from the calibration factor previously determined in an extended calibration series. The magnitude of an expansion has no noticeble effect on the linearity of the pressure tranducer reading (see Fig. 1). Accordingly, the expansion pressure and also temperature are precisely determined. The latter is true, because the npentanol and argon form an ideal gas mixture to a high degree of accuracy, as calculations including higher order correction terms show. An increase of the nucleation rate with increasing magnitude of the expansion reported by Viisanen et al. (1993) is negligible for the constant small expansions with Ap/p0 0.3 considered here.
109
.....
n-pentanol .
.
.
.
.
108 $
107
10 n
2.70.
,"
IO s
5
10 15 supersaturation
Fig. 2
20
RESULTS NUCLEATION RATES VS. SUPERSA TURA TION AND TEMPERA TURE The nucleation rates vs. supersaturation for n-pentanol in argon are shown in Fig. 2. In order to perform the measurements we prepare a vapor carrier gas mixture with fixed ratio of vapor and carrier-gas in a separate receptacle. The variation of the supersaturation is achieved by varying the total pressure po n-pentanol before the expansion and along with it the vapor 30 pressure. The total pressures range from 0.5 to 0.7 ........ in0 bar. The pressure variation in this range is of subor2O dinate importance, as will be shown below. As can be seen, the variation of the nucleation rate over orders of magnitude is extremely steep. As noted preJ-,O'cmOs' viously by Hruby et al. (1996), this trend compares favorably with the self-consistent nucleation theory self-consistent theory (solid lines). The temperature dependencies can be ~8 o 7 compared in a so-called activity plot. In Fig. 3 we 9 this work 6 compile the present onset activities ao (- supersatu<) Strey, Wagner 1982 ration corresponding to a rate of 107 cm3s "l) (solid 5 o Hruby et al. 1996 points), the recent measurements of Hruby et al. 4 (1996) and older measurements of Strey and Wagner 220 230 240 250 260 270 280 (1982) using the former two-piston expansion chamT/K Fig. 3 ber (Wagner and Strey (1984)). As is evident from the overlap of the data there is quite good agreement between the different sets of experiments. This agreement is remarkable insofar as the older m e a s u r e ments were performed using a different batch of n-pentanol, and it emphasizes the reproducibility of these findings. o
>
U
|
i
|
i
|
EFFECT OF TOTAL PRESSURE The total pressure effect was examined by keeping the temperature and vapor pressure constant and varying the initial total pressure po. The final pressure p at nucleation is reduced by the expansion ratio, f3=p/po=0.7, and varies between 1 and 0.1 bar. As a result of the decreasing total pressure p the nucleation rates decrease slightly; thus the onset activity increases. In Fig. 4 we show the onset activities as a function of total pressure for 250 K (solid points). Note that each data point is supported by a whole nucleation rate isotherm such as shown in Fig. 2, and, accordingly, carries only a relatively small error
258
Van Remoortere et al.
bar of less than the symbol width in Fig. 4. We have chosen in Fig. 4 the same scale for the ordinate in order to demonstrate the smallness of the pressure dependence in comparision to the temperature dependence in Fig. 3. The smallness of the effect becomes even more clear if one considers that the temperature range encompasses a 20 % change while the pressure was varied over 1 order of magnitude. Although we did not accomplish our goal to demonstrate the influence of total pressure on homogeneeous nucleation, the measurements are still useful. They constitute an experimental proof that the procedure mentioned above which we apply for measuring isothermal nucleation rate curves (s. Fig. 2), i.e. changing the total pressure po and along with it the actual vapor pressure, is a valid procedure. DISCUSSION COMPARISON TO NUCLEATION THEORY As seen above from Fig. 2, the nucleation rates vs. supersaturation for n-pentanol in argon vary over orders of magnitude with similar steepness, as predicted by the self-consistent nucleation theory (Girshick and Chiu (1990)). The classical theory by Becker-Doering (1935) predicts nucleation rates, which are about 5 orders of magnitude smaller. Overall the temperature dependence predicted by the self-consistent theory is closely followed by the experimental data (Fig. 3), as noted previously in a more extended study of the temperature dependence (Hruby et al. (1996)). The additional factor, exp(| in the self-consistent theory compared to the classical one evidently has two improving effects: first, it shifts the predicted rate up by approximately 5 orders of magnitude, second it removes much of the disparate temperature dependence of the classical theory observed previously including other n-alcohols (Strey et al. (1986)). We do not wish to imply by omission that we consider the self-consistent theory as the only and ultimate nucleation theory. The agreement, however, is still remarkable. COMPARISON TO THEORETICAL PREDICTIONS OF PRESSURE EFFECTS Nucleation theories in general predict no explicit pressure dependence (straight horizontal lines in Fig. 4). However, due to an effect of argon pressure on the equilibrium vapor pressure of n-pentanol as well as on the surface tension, a slight variation with increasing total pressure on the order of a hundred bar is conceivable. The origin of this kind of pressure dependence is thermodynamically related to suggestions to conceive the single component vapor and carrier gas as a two component binary vapor system n-pentanol (Oxtoby and Laaksonen (1995) and Anisimov and 30 . . . . Vershinin (1990)). Ford (1992) predicted some rather small pressure effects, the nucleation rate Becker-Doering theory decreasing with increasing total pressure. In the 2O limit of low pressures the dependence changed sign to become decreasing with decreasing pressure, due an effect of the nuclei becoming nonisothermal. The pressure effect documented in Fig. m 10 4 has the same sign and small magnitude as preself-consistent ~eory 9 8 dicted by Ford, and might, accordingly, be attribuC o 7 J=10 7 cm'3s "1 ted to the nucleation becoming non-isothermal. 6 Kashchiev (1996) gave a general theoretical deri5 vation of possible pressure effects within the frame of the nucleation theorem treating the pressure ef4 ' ' , ' , ' 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 fect by second virial coefficients. Although, no Fig. 4 p/bar precise experimental values for virial coefficients exist for the present experimental settings, significant pressure effects only occur at high total pressures. Vasil'ev and Reiss (1996) propose some decrease of nucleation rates with increasing total pressure due to a kinetic ,,screening" effect. Strong effects, however, are again only expected for comparatively high total pressures and large critical nuclei. o t~
J
o.,. > ,=. U
J
I
9
Effect of supersaturation, temperature and total pressure
259
CONCLUSIONS In preparing for the pressure dependent nucleation experiments, we found an excellent linearity of the pressure tranducer, which in turn permits exact measurement of pressure and, accordingly, calculation of temperature. We note that the self-consistent classical nucleation theory provides a rather accurate description of the supersaturation and temperature dependencies of the nucleation rates and assumes independence of the nucleation rates on total pressure. Although we have chosen a system and experimental conditions, where according to diffusion chamber experiments the pressure effect on nucleation should be most pronounced, we only found a slight pressure effect, which has in fact the opposite sign compared to the effect found in diffusion cloud chambers. According to the theoretical estimates available only a small influence of total pressure on the nucleation process can actually be expected for the experimental conditions considered. The origin of the strong pressure effects observed from diffusion chamber experiments remains to be clarified. ACKNOWLEGDMENTS This work was performed in the department of Prof. M. Kahlweit to whom we are indebted for support. REFERENCES Anisimov, M.P. and Vershinin, S.N. (1990)J. Aerosol Sci. 21, 15 Becker, R. and DC~ring, W. (1935) Ann. Phys. 24, 719 Ford, I.J. (1992) Pressure Effect in Homogeneous Nucleation Theory from Imperfect Vapor-Carrier Gas Behaviour. Nucleation and Atmospheric Aerosols, Fukuta, N., and Wagner, P.E., Eds., Deepak Publishing, Hampton, p. 39 Girshick, S.L. and Chiu, C.-P. (1990) Kinetic Nucleation Theory: A New Expression for the Rates of Homogeneous Nucleation from an Ideal Supersaturated Vapor. J. Chem. Phys. 93, 1273 Heist, R.H., Ahmed, J. and Janjua, (1995) Effects of Background Gases on the Homogeneous Nucleation of Vapors, I. J. Phys. Chem. 99, 375 Heist, R.H., Janjua, M. and Ahmed, J. (1994) Effects of Background Gases on the Homogeneous Nucleation of Vapors, I. J. Phys. Chem. 98, 4443 Hruby, J., Viisanen, Y. and Strey, R. (1996) Homogeneous Nucleation Rates for n-pentanol. J. Phys. Chem. in press Kashchiev, D. (1996) Effect of carrier-gas pressure on nucleation. J. Chem. Phys. submitted Katz, J.L., Fisk, J.A. and Chakarov, V. (1992) The Accuracy of Nucleation Theory. Nucleation and Atmospheric Aerosols, Fukuta, N., and Wagner, P.E., Eds., Deepak Publishing, Hampton, p. 11 Oxtoby, D.W and Laaksonen, A. J. (1995) Chem. Phys. 102, 6846 Strey, R. and Wagner, P.E. (1982) Homogeneous Nucleation of 1-Pentanol in a Two-Piston Expansion Chamber for Different Carrier Gases. J. Phys. Chem. 86, 1013 Strey, R., Wagner, P.E. and Schmeling, T. (1986) Homogeneous Nucleation Rates for the n-Alcohols from a Two-Piston Expansion Chamber. J. Chem. Phys. 84, 2325 Strey, R., Wagner, P.E. and Y. Viisanen (1994) The Problem of Measuring Homogeneous Nucleation Rates and Molecular Contents of Nuclei: Progress in the Form of Nucleation Pulse Measurements. J. Phys. Chem. 98, 7748 Vasil'ev, O.V. and Reiss, H. (1996) Phys. Rev. E. submitted Viisanen, Y., Strey, R. and Reiss, H. (1993) Homogeneous Nucleation Rates for Water. J. Chem. Phys. 99, 4680 Wagner, P.E. and Strey, R. (1984) Measurements of Homogeneous Nucleation Rates for n-Nonane Vapor using a Two-Piston Expansion Chamber. J. Chem. Phys. 80, 5266
Effect of D i m e n s i o n a l i t y on t h e T e m p e r a t u r e
D e p e n d e n c e of R a t e of
Nucleation X.C. Zeng and K.J. Oh Chemistry Department University of Nebraska-Lincoln Lincoln NE 68588 USA
ABSTRACT Gas-liquid nucleation in 2D is investigated using a density-functional approach. Differences in the temperature dependence of nucleation rate in 2D and 3D are discussed. The study suggests that classical nucleation theory actually works reasonably well for 2D fluids in predicting the temperature dependence of the nucleation rate, whereas for 3D fluids it fails. INTRODUCTION For 3D gas-liquid nucleation, many experiments (Adams et a1.(1984), Wagner and Strey, (1984), Kacker and Heist (1985), Martens et al. (1987), Hung et al. (1989), Peters and Paikert (1989), El-Shall (1989)) have demonstrated that the classical theory of nucleation fails in predicting the temperature dependence of rate of nucleation; deviations of several orders of magnitude are typical. These deviations are attributed to the underlying capillarity approximation in the classical theory, in which the critical nucleus is treated as a macroscopic droplet in the background vapor and the droplet surface is treated as a sharp planar interface. Recently, the experimental findings have been confirmed also by several molecular based theories (Oxtoby and Evans (1988), Reiss et al (1990), Weakliem and Reiss (1993), Zeng and Oxtoby (1991), Talanquer and Oxtoby (1993), Kasaka et al. (1995)). From these theories better molecular insights have been gained. It is now understood that the effects of curvature and finite interfacial width of the mesoscopic droplet are important in the determination of the free energy of formation for the droplet. The focus of this paper is the 2D gas-liquid nucleation. Many real systems exhibit 2D fluid characteristics: e.g., physisorption of gases on solid surfaces (Steele (1974)), surfactant monolayers adsorbed on an air/water interface (Shaw (19S0)), and thining by evaporation of completely wetted water films on clean mica surfaces (Elbaum and Lipson (1994)). How important is the effects of curvature and finite interracial width of the 2D droplet? Can the classical theory be applicable at 2D? We have attempted to answer these questions by using a density-functional approach to investigate nucleation of 2D Lennard-Jones model fluids. THE CLASSICAL THEORY OF 2D NUCLEATION The steady rate of homogeneous nucleation J can be generally written as J = Joe-Agl*/ks T,
260
(1)
261
Effect of dimensionality on temperature dependence of rate of nucleation where J0 is a preexponential factor, T is the temperature, and AgZ* is the free energy of formation for the critical nucleus. The latter dominates the temperature dependence of the rate. In the Becker-Dbring (classsical) theory of gas-to-liquid nucleation, the capillarity approximation is made such that /k~/of a nucleus is taken as a sum of bulk and surface free energy contributions. In 2D the droplet is assumed to be circular and the interface between the gas and liquid is assumed to be a line. Thus, A ~ can be expressed as
A~'l = -Trr2Ap + 27rr~/,
(2)
where r and "7 are the radius and line tension of a droplet, respectively, and Ap = P t - Pv is the pressure difference between the droplet and the vapor. A droplet can grow only if the associated free energy of formation A9/is large enough to overcome the barrier A~/*. The latter can be determined from the extremal condition, OanlT,p -- O, and from which one can also derive the radius of the critical nucleus Or r* = "7lAp. Moreover, if the liquid is assumed to be incompressible and the gas to be ideal, the pressure difference Ap can be written in terms of A# = # - #~t or of the supersaturation S = Pv/P~a~, where #~t and P~t are the chemical potential and pressure at gas-liquid equilibrium, i.e., Ap = ptA# = ptkBTlnS. Combining above equations results in the free energy of formation for a critical nucleus, 9 A~'~CL :
lr~2
_
plAp
--
~/2
(3)
ptkBTlnS"
Finally the preexponential factor is given by J0 = n(1)2 ~/A#al
S V 2~m'
(4)
where m is the atomic mass, n(1) is the number density of monomer nuclei, and al is the area per particle in the bulk liquid (Zeng (1996)). THE DENSITY FUNCTIONAL THEORY FOR 2D LENNARD-JONES FLUIDS The density functional (DF) theory of nucleation has been shown elsewhere (Oxtoby (1992)). For 2D Lennard-Jones fluids (e.g., argon in 2D), one starts with the grand free energy density functional 1 where fh denotes the Helmholtz free energy density of a hard-disk fluid at density p, r is the attractive part of Lennard-Jones interaction, and # is the chemical potential. Setting the functional derivative of ~/with respect to p ( ~ to be zero gives the equation
U(p(r) ) = # - f d ~ p ( r ' ) r
"-
~'1)
(6)
which can be solved using a novel iteration method (Zeng and Oxtoby (1991)) to determine the density profile of a 2D critical droplet. During the iteration, the free energy
262
Zeng and Oh 100
100
0.1 o
10
o
0.01 0.001 0.0001
1
0.4
0 44
0.48
le--05 0.65 0.7 0.75 0.8 0.85 0.9 0.95 1 1.05 1.1
0.52
TIE
T&
Figure 1: Ratios of the gas-to-liquid nucleation rate of the classical theory to the densityfunctional theory versus temperature: for (a) 2D, and (b) 3D Lennard-Jones fluids. of formation for the critical droplet, A ~ F , nucleation can then be calculated via
can be obtained using Eq. (5). The rate of
J,)R = Joe -aaS~/k~r
(7)
Note that in the DF theory the capillarity approximation is avoided. Effects of both curvature and finite interracial width of the droplet on the free energy of formation are accounted for. In the limit of large droplets, however, the DF theory goes over to the classical theory. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION We have calculated the gas-to-liquid rates of nucleation for argon in 2D at several temperatures between the scaled triple point (T* = k.BT/~Ar -- 0.42) and critical point (T* = 0.5). For each temperature, the chemical potential change A# is determined by fixing JCL = 1 cm-2s -1 (using Eqs. (1) and (3)). With the same A# and temperature T, we evaluated JDF from Eq. (7), and then monitored the temperature dependence of the ratio JCL/JDF. Results are shown in Fig. l(a); the results for 3D nucleation are shown in Fig. l(b) (Zeng and Oxtoby 1991). Comparing Fig. l(a) and (b), we find the dot-curve in Fig. l(a) is, in fact, quite "flat". The classical theory overestimates the rate by a factor of 2 at T* = 0.42 and 10 at T* = 0.5, respectively. In contrast, for 3D fluids the classical theory underestimates the rate by five orders of magnitude near the triple point, while at a temperatures not far from the critical point the classical theory overestimates the rate by several orders of magnitude.
Effect of dimensionality on temperature dependence of rate of nucleation The results shown in Figs. 1 indicate that, in 2D, effects of curvature and finite interracial width of droplet are much smaller than those in 3D. The underlying physical reason is that for temperatures ranging from the triple point to the critical point, the 2D critical nuclei typically have more atoms than those in 3D (Zeng (1996)). If one imagines that a 3D critical nucleus could be compressed into a 2D one, the latter would have a much larger radius, thus much smaller curvature; the curvature effects in 2D on nucleation rate would be much smaller. The main conclusion of this study is therefore that the Becker-DSring classical theory of nucleation works quite well in the prediction of the temperature-dependence of 2D gas-liquid nucleation rates. Other improved classical theories (e.g., Dillmann and Meier (1989)) are expected to work better. A potential application of the result is for the measurement of line tensions of 2D liquid films. It is known that direct measurement of line tensions is very challenging. An indirect method proposed is via measuring the 2D gas-liquid rates of nucleation and then using the classical theory (Eqs. (1) -(4)) to infer the line tensions. Obviously, the indirect measurements rely upon the reliability of the classical theory of nucleation. The authors are grateful to Dr. Sturgeon for critical reading the manuscript. This work was supported by the National Science Foundation. Acknowledgement is also made to the donors of the Petroleum Research Fund administered by the American Chemical Society for support of this work. REFERENCES G.W. Adams, J.L. Schmitt, and R.A. Zalabsky (1984) J. Chem. Phys. 81, 5074. R. Becker and W. DSring (1935) Mol. Phys. 24, 719. A. Dillmann and G.E.A. Meier (1989) Chem. Phys. Lett. 160, 71. M. Elbaum and S.G. Lipson (1994) Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 3562. M.S. El-Shall (1989) J. Chem. Phys. 90, 6533. C. Hung, M.J. Krasnopoler, and J.L. Katz (1989) J. Chem. Phys. 90, 1856. A. Kacker and R.H. Heist (1985) J. Chem. Phys. 82, 2734. I. Kusaka, Z.G. Wang and J.H. Seinfeld (1995) J. Chem. Phys. 102, 913. J. Martens, H. Uchtmann, and F. Hensel (1987) J. Phys. Chem. 91, 2489. D.W. Oxtoby and R. Evans (1989) J. Chem. Phys. 89, 7521. D.W. Oxtoby (1992) J. Condens. Matter 4, 7627. F. Peters and B. Paikert (1989) J. Chem. Phys. 91, 5672. H. Reiss, A. Tabazadeh, and J. Talbot (1990) J. Chem. Phys. 92, 1266. D.J. Shaw (1980) Introduction to Colloid and Surface Chemistry, Butterworths, London. W.A. Steele (1974) The Interaction of Gases with Solid Surfaces, Pergamon, Oxford. V. Talanquer and D.W. Oxtoby (1993) J. Chem. Phys. 99, 4670. P.E. Wagner and R. Strey (1984) J. Chem. Phys. 80, 5266. C.L. Weakliem and H. Reiss (1993) J. Chem. Phys. 99, 5374. X.C. Zeng and D.W. Oxtoby (1991) J. Chem. Phys. 94, 4472. X.C. Zeng (1996) J. Chem. Phys. 104, 2699.
263
NUMBER OF CLUSTERS FORMED IN NUCLEATION-GROWTH PROCESSES J. S C H M E L Z E R ,
V. V. S L E Z O V (*)
Fachbereich P h y s i k der Universits Rostock, Universits D- 18051 Rostock, Germany, a n d Joint I n s t i t u t e of Nuclear Research, Bogoliubov L a b o r a t o r y of Theoretical Physics, 141 980 D u b n a , Russia (*) N a t i o n a l Science Center, K h a r k o v I n s t i t u t e of Physics a n d Technology, A c a d e m i c i a n Street 1, 310108 Kharkov, Ukraine
Abstract
The number of clusters, N, formed in nucleation-growth processes in firstorder phase transformations, and their average size, < R >, at the end of the stage of independent growth of the supercritical clusters are determined analytically. It is shown that the number of clusters, N, does depend only on the thermodynamic parameters like initial supersaturation, specific interfacial energy etc. but not on the values of kinetic parameters like the diffusion coefficient. Keywords: Phase transitions, Nucleation, Cluster Growth
INTRODUCTION Classical nucleation theory, as worked out first by Stranski, Kaischew [1], Becker, DSring [2], Volmer [3], Frenkel [4], Zeldovich [5] and others, is dealing primarily with the determination of the steady-state nucleation rate J, i.e., the estimation of the number of supercritical clusters formed per unit time interval in a unit volume of a thermodynamically metastable system.
264
Number of clustersformed in nucleation-growth processes
265
In the further development of the theory, non-steady state effects have been intensively studied connected with the finite time required for the system to reach steady-state conditions (for an overview see, for example, [6], [7], [8]). There exists, however, also another reason why the determination of the steady-state nucleation rate cannot give a comprehensive information concerning the course of nucleation processes. In most practical applications, a steady-state can be established in a system only for a limited period of time. This effect is due to a depletion of the state of the system, i.e., the decrease of the number of particles which can be incorporated into the new phase (see, e.g., [7], [9], [10]). As the result of such depletion effects only a finite number of clusters develops in the system. The determination of the number of clusters formed in a thermodynamically metastable system in dependence on the initial supersaturation and the average size of the clusters observed initially in nucleation experiments is a task beyond the scope of classical nucleation theory. The knowledge of these characteristics is, however, of a great technological importance allowing to vary the dispersity of the newly evolving phase in the ambient phase and in this way the properties of the respective materials. The determination of these characteristics- the number of clusters formed in nucleation-growth experiments and their average size in dependence on the initial supersaturation in the s y s t e m - is the aim of the present presentation. Hereby we consider the case that the growth of the clusters proceeds via diffusion processes of the monomeric particles. A comparison with the results obtained by Slezov, Schmelzer and Tkatch (1996) [11] for the kinetic (or ballistic) mode of growth and the results of computer simulations of the same process is also given.
MAIN
RESULTS
Based on the solution of the Frenkel-Zeldovich equation (cf. [81, [111), the number of clusters, N, formed in diffusion-limited growth processes can be expressed as
N = A(T)
[In (c--~)] 10/3 exp
[ln (C--~-)] 2
/
'
(1)
(2) The parameter B(T)is determined by eq.(3). 213
a2=47ra
47r}
(3)
SchmelzerandSlezov
266
co and coo are the initial and equilibrium concentrations of the condensing, respectively, segregating particles, kB is the Boltzmann constant, T the temperature, a the specific interfacial energy or surface tension, ws the volume of a monomeric particle in the newly evolving phase, p is some parameter with a value of the order one. As evident from eqs.(1) and (2), the number of clusters formed in the system is determined mainly by the initial supersaturation and the value of the interfacial specific energy (via the parameter c~2), it does not depend on the diffusion coefficient D. The stage of dominating nucleation is followed, in general, by a stage of dominating independent growth of the supercritical clusters present in the system. In this stage, the supercritical clusters grow at the expense of the excess monomers and the supersaturation tends to zero [A(t) = 0]. After this process is finished the transformation has reached a certain degree of completion and goes over into a third stage of competitive growth or Ostwald ripening. In nucleation-growth experiments commonly states are observed initially corresponding to the end of the stage of independent growth. In the calculation of the initial average sizes of the clusters observed experimentally one has to take into account, therefore, the deterministic growth of the supercritical clusters. This growth is stopped after the supersaturation reaches values near zero. Since we have determined already the number of clusters, N, formed in the course of nucleation, by a purely thermodynamic argumentation it is possible to give estimates also of the average size, < n >, or the average radius, < R >, of the clusters and its dependence on the initial supersaturation. Approximately, we may write the mass balance equation for the final state of independent growth in the form
(c-coo)-+
( c 0 - coo) = < n > N =
4~r < R >3 N, 3Ws
(4)
which is equivalent to < R >3=
(3~O,Coo \
co
47r ) ( N ) [ ( ~ - ~ - ~ ) - 1 ]
(5)
.
A substitution of the expression for N into eq.(5) yields, finally, 1/3
=C(T){
10/9
(c-~)-1}
[ln (c-~) ]
exp
I
B(T) I 31n
C(T) = 3a,
(
2(2p2)1/3
\ c~2 /
"
(6)
~
(7)
Number of clusters formed in nucleation-growth processes
An analysis of these equations shows that the number of clusters, N, increases with an increasing initial supersaturation while the average size, < R >, decreases. To this result a thermodynamic interpretation can be given as discussed earlier by Schmelzer and Ulbricht (1987) [10].
Acknowledgement The work was performed as a part of a project financed by the Bundesministerium f/ir Bildung, Wissenschaft, Forschung und Technologie (BMBF), Germany. One of the authors (V.V. Slezov) acknowledges also the financial support given by the SOROS foundation (Grant No. ISSEP-SPU042062).
References [1] Kaischew, R., Stranski, I. N., Z. Phys. Chem. A 170, 295 (1934) [2] Becket, R., Dhring, W., Ann. der Physik 24, 719 (1935) [3] Volmer, M.: Kinetik der Phasenbildung, Th. Steinkopf, Dresden, 1939 [4] Frenkel, Ya. I.: Kinetic Theory of Liquids, Oxford University Press, 1946 [5] Zeldovich, Ya. B., Soy. Phys. JETP 12, 325 (1942) [6] Zettlemoyer, A. C., (Ed.): Nucleation, Marcel Decker, New York, 1969; Nucleation Phenomena, Adv. Colloid Interface Science 7 (1977) [7] Gunton, J. D., San Miguel, M., Sahni, P. S.: The Dynamics of First-Order Phase Transitions In: Phase Transitions and Critical Phenomena, vol. 8, Eds. C. Domb, J. L. Lebowitz, Academic Press, London - New York, 1983 [8] Gutzow, I., Schmelzer, J.: The Vitreous State. Thermodynamics, Structure, Rheology, and Crystallization, Springer, 1995 [9] Binder, K., Stauffer, D., Adv. Phys. 25,343 (1976) [10] Schmelzer, J., Ulbricht, H., J. Colloid Interface Science 117, 325 (1987) [11] Slezov, V. V., Schmelzer, J., Tkatch, Ya. Y.: Number of Clusters Formed in Nucleation-Growth Processes: The Case of Kinetic Limited Growth, Phys. Rev. B, submitted for publication
267
THE ROLE
OF PARTICULATE
MATTER
(STRATOSPHERE
IN OZONE
PHOTOCHEMISTRY
AND TROPOSPHERE)
P.J. CRUTZEN Department of Atmospheric Chemistry, Max-Planck-Institute of Chemistry, P.O. Box 3060, D-55020 Mainz, Germany
Especially the discovery of the ozone more than ten years ago has clearly shown that heterogeneous reactions on aerosol can play a large role in ozone photochemistry. In the stratosphere low temperature reactions on nitric acid trihydrate (NAT), on water ice particles, or on particles consisting of ternary supercooled solutions of sulfuric acid, nitric acid and water, lead to rapid conversion of the "reservoir" species HC1 and C1ONO 2 into active chlorine (C1, C10, C1202) which act catalytically to rapidly destroy ozone. Because there is so much more particulate matter in the troposphere than in the stratosphere, it is most likely that they too play a significant role in tropospheric chemistry. Next follow some examples of processes that can be of major importance: * loss of boundary layer ozone in the Arctic during springtime: probably due to bromine activation reactions on snow and ice covered surface, or on ice particles. A high correlation of filterable bromine with low ozone had been discovered and more recent work has shown the existence of significant levels of BrO radicals. * the role of seasalt particles in the photochemistry of the marine boundary layer: It is quite possible that C1 and Br activation can occur by heterogeneous reactions on seasalt particles also in warmer environments, triggered a) in originally, continuentally polluted air masses via N 2 0 5 + X-
--,
XNO 2 + NO 3-
XNO 2 + hu
--,
X + NO 2
(X = C1, Br)
or
b) in NOx-pOor environments via HSO 5- + B r -
-,
SO4 = + H O B r
, followed in either case by the autocatalytic Br and BrO activating chain reactions HOBr + C1- + H +
--,
BrC1 + H20
268
The role of particulate matter in ozone photochemistry BrC1 + Br-
=
Br2C1-
=
Br 2 + hu
--,
2 Br
2(Br + 03
--,
BrO + 02)
2(BrO + HO 2
-,
HOBr + 02
net: 2 HO 2 + H + + 203 + Br- ---,
269
Br 2 + C1-
HOBr + 402 + H 2 0
The bromine activation (HOBr formation) next leads to catalytic 0 3 destruction via BrO + HO 2
--,
HOBr + 02
HOBr + hu
--,
OH + Br
OH+CO 2(+O2)
--,
CO 2 + H O 2
Br + 03
--,
BrO + 02
net: 03 + CO
--,
02 + CO 2
* Possible 03 (and NO) loss reactions in water droplets or on water coated ice particles
HO 2
--,
H + + 02-
02 - + O 3 + H +
---,
OH+202
02- + NO
--,
OONO-
--,
NO 3-
(?)
* Reactions of N205 on sulfate or other water containing aerosol:
N205 + H 2 0
---,
2HNO 3
, leading to NO x loss and diminishing 0 3 and OH concentration levels. * Interactions of DMS-derived sulfur compounds with seasalt in the marine boundary layer and reactions of SO2, H2SO4, NOx, N205 and HNO 3 on soil dust particles which remove these compounds from the gas phase. In the case of industrial SO2, the neglect of such heterogeneous reactions may well have led to overestimations of the climatic cooling effects of anthropogenic aerosols as many incorporation of sulfur in soil dust or seasalt will prevent the formation of new sunlight backscattefing sulfate particles.
270
Crutzen
REFERENCES Barrie, L.A. et al. (1988) Ozone destruction and photochemical reactions at polar sinrise in the lower Arctic atmosphere. Nature, 334, 138-141. Dentener, F. and Crutzen, P.J. (1993) Reaction of N20 5 on tropospheric aerosols: impact on the global distribution of NO x, 0 3 and OH. J. Geophys. Res., 98 (D4), 7149. Hausmann, M. and Platt, U. (1994). Spectroscopic measurements of bromine oxide and ozone in the high Arctic during polar sunrise experiment 1992. J Geophys. Res., 99, 25399-25413. Sander, R. and Crutzen, P.J. A model study indicating halogen activation in polluted air masses transported to the sea. J. Geophys. Res. (in press). Vogt, R., Crutzen, P.J. and Sander, R. A new mechanism for bromine and chlorine release from sea salt aerosol in the unpolluted marine boundary layer. Nature (submitted).
ICE NUCLEATION-
A REVIEW
GABOR VALI Department of Atmospheric Science, University of Wyoming Laramie, WY 82071, USA Abstract-Ice formation in cirrus has been successfully analysed by a number of authors in terms of homogeneous nucleation on dilute sulfuric acid aerosol: laboratory measurements were reconciled with nucleation rates derived from classical theory and field observations support the estimated temperature and humidity regimes at which ice formation is expected. Even so, there is need for further work on this topic. The origin of ice in lower tropospheric clouds is not resolved- it remains a question of great importance and in need of new efforts. In the realm of basic studies, the finding that monolayers and bacterial proteins can be very effective freezing nuclei opened new horizons and may also have implications for atmospheric processes. K e y w o r d s - Homogeneous freezing nucleation. Freezing nucleation by monolayers. Bacterial ice nuclei. Ice formation in clouds. INTRODUCTION The phase transitions of water to ice have crucial consequences in the atmosphere and in biological systems. Studies of the processes even with pure water face many obstacles, and the heterogeneous processes are yet more complex. Improvements in observational and computational methods are producing slow but significant progress. Three topics related to atmospheric ice nucleation will be covered in this review. Two of these - o n e concerning the lowest temperatures, the other those very close to 0~ - are areas of great scientific activity and significant advances. In the third, the traditional focus of atmospheric ice nucleation research, progress appears quite slow. UPPER TROPOSPHERIC AND POLAR STRATOSPHERIC CLOUDS Cirrus clouds have come into increasing scientific focus over the last decade or so, because of their role in the Earth's radiation budget and climate. Polar stratospheric clouds have been shown to be important participants in the complex chemistry leading to ozone depletion. These concerns brought about renewed interest in homogeneous freezing and in the supercooling of haze particles. New laboratory experiments and field observations were coupled with improvements in theoretical descriptions. There were no major conflicts in the data accumulated on homogeneous freezing over the fifty or so years since the first observations that the practical limit to supercooling of water in the laboratory is around -40~ The dependence of this limit on sample volume has been well demonstrated, and the rate of ice formation was successfully interpreted in terms of nucleation rates (Jsl). With rough values for many constants, especially for the interfacial energy between the ice embryo and water, the quasi-thermodynamic theory was reconciled in many slightly different forms with the empirical results. Reviews of work up to about 1990 are in G6tz et al. ( 1991 ), Pruppacher and Klett (1978) and numerous other texts. These laboratory and theoretical results were also in reasonable accord with observations of rapid glaciation in the tops of deep convective clouds and with the prevalence of ice in cirrus forming at temperatures near -40~ More recent work refined the situation in many respects. First, evidence was accumulated supporting the dominance of homogeneous freezing in the formation of cirrus at cold enough temperatures. Second,
271
272
Vali
further laboratory experiments extended somewhat the empirical data base. Third, the possibility was investigated that haze particles (concentrated solution droplets of subcritical size for growth at the prevailing humidities) may freeze directly. Fourth, revisions in the theory of homogeneous freezing yielded better agreement with observations. Fifth, model calculations of cirrus formation were greatly improved. Field evidence about ice formation in cirrus and in wave clouds at temperatures near the homogeneous freezing temperatures of water was obtained both by direct sampling from aircraft (Sassen and Dodd, 1988; Heymsfield and Miloshevich, 1993, 1995; Jensen et al., 1994, Str6m and Heitzenberg, 1994) and from lidar observations (Sassen and Dodd, 1988; Sassen, 1992). These papers are augmented by the growing body of publications reporting aircraft, lidar, radar and satellite observations of cirrus and other upper tropospheric clouds in general; these works continue to confirm that the great majority of these clouds is composed of ice crystals at concentrations of few tens to few hundreds per liter. While radiative properties of some cirrus indicate that higher numbers of small crystals may be present, this point is still not clarified. One of the direct observations of ice nucleation is the brief aircraft sounding reported by Sassen and Dodd (1988); the transition from droplets to ice crystals was observed within a height interval of 50 m in slowly ascending air at a temperature between-35.0 and-35.6~ These aircraft data were supported by a change in lidar depolarization ratio corresponding to the phase change. Heymsfield and Miloshevich (1993, 1995) report more detailed aircraft data that lead to very similar conclusions. Ice formation was observed to besparse at temperatures higher than -35~ and became very rapid at temperatures of-37~ and lower. Importantly, humidity and updraft measurements accompanied the particle observations. The, maximum relative humidities reached - limited by the uptake of vapor by growing droplets or crystals - were found to decrease with temperatures decreasing from near-34~ to-56~ Ice formation rates went from near-zero to very high values just past the points of maximum relative humidity, consistent with the onset of homogeneous nucleation as solution concentrations just decreased and droplet sizes increased sufficiently for the freezing rates to become significant. For the conditions of the observations, measurable or 'significant' rates were estimated as 0.01 cm -3 s-1. Calculated relative humidity peaks, based on observed droplet sizes at the onset of freezing, on laboratory values for Jsl and on assumed compositions of sulfuric acid for the nuclei of condensation, showed good agreement with observations. The representativeness of sampling from aircraft, the inaccuracies involved in obtaining truly Lagrangian observations and the fact that all the data cited come from the same season and location (October-December, Colorado) are some of the limitations that have to be borne in mind. Stimulating results from colder temperatures were reported by Knollenberg et al. (1993) and by Strtim and Heitzenberg (1994). Both sets of observations, in the tops of tropical cumulonimbus at temperatures near-80~ and in orographically induced cirrus at -55~ indicated the presence of small ice crystals (10..20 ~tm) in concentrations reaching 104 L -1. These concentrations are much higher than those usually observed for particles which can be definitely identified as crystals by direct capture or by imaging probes. According to Knollenberg et al., the most likely source of these crystals was the freezing of sulfuric acid droplets near the cloud-top temperatures, though the origin of crystals at lower levels in the clouds couldn't be ruled out. When combined with the results of Arnott et al. (1994) it is clear that the sizes of cirrus particles, at least at temperatures below -40~ tend to have a wide spread, tending to negative exponential distributions for sizes up to about 100 lam and more variable above that. Analyses of optical properties of cirrus have also pointed to the existence of large numbers of small crystals. It will be interesting to see to what extent the differences between these observations and those summarized in the preceding paragraph originate from different instrumental capabilities and from real variabilities in cloud properties. New laboratory data on homogeneous freezing was produced by DeMott and Rogers (1990). Using a large chamber subjected to slow expansion, they obtained measurements of Jsl in the temperature range -30...-38~ At temperatures above -34~ there was evidence for a significant contribution by heterogeneous nucleation. (The solute effect resulting from the CCN on which the cloud droplets form is negligible for droplet sizes of several p,m diameter in the chamber.) The rates deduced by DeMott and Rogers compare
Ice n u c l e a t i o n ~ A review
273
well with the rate estimated by Sassen and Dodd from field data: Jsl ~ 107 cm -3 s-1 at -36~ however the magnitudes of the experimental uncertainties are not well known and can be expected to be quite large owing to the indirect way that nucleation rate is deduced. In fact, it is clear that neither cloud chamber experiments, nor experiments with droplets suspended in other media (emulsions) can be freed from quite fundamental limitations in the determination of Jsl. The theory of homogeneous freezing has been reexamined in several of the papers already cited, and received a thorough revision by Pruppacher (1995). His formulation of the classical theory incorporates improved values for the thermodynamic constants, and incorporates singularities of these constants near -45~ (suggested by Angell (1982), and argued against by Bartell and Huang (1994)). However, the activation energy is estimated by Pruppacher from empirical values of Jsl, so that only consistency, not proof, has been achieved between theory and experiment. The classical nucleation theory of spherical embryos with bulk properties has been refined by the diffuse interface theory of Gr~in~isy (1993) and applied to the homogeneous freezing of water (Gr~imisy, 1995); he reports substantially improved agreement with observations. Observations of liquid droplets at temperatures lower than-40~ indicate some limit to generality of the role of homogeneous freezing in upper tropospheric clouds. Hallett and Lewis (1967) argued on the basis of optical phenomena, Sassen (1992) showed lidar depolarization data, and there are a number of reports of aircraft icing, all indicating that liquid droplets can exist in the atmosphere at temperatures below -40~ These observations can be interpreted as evidence for the existence of haze particles at those conditions, below the saturation needed for growth to droplets. The associated question is what may be the freezing temperatures of such haze droplets? That question is even more acute with respect to the freezing of sulfuric acid aerosol and of sulfuric acid-nitric acid-water mixtures in the stratosphere. Observations in polar stratospheric clouds (PSC's) showed clearly that transformations to solids take place at temperatures below 195 K, but the conditions and chemical composition of the clouds are still subjects of intense investigation (e.g. Tolbert, 1994). Earlier attempts to determine the nucleation temperatures of H2SO4/H20 solutions with relatively large sample sizes (Ohtake, 1993; Song, 1994) appear to have been influenced by heteronuclei, as evidenced by the small differences between the melting point curves (Gable et al., 1950) and the freezing points for acid concentrations to about 35% by weight. Beyer et al., (1994) working with smaller samples (5~tl) found approximately 22 ~ supercooling, still less than the accepted values for homogeneous nucleation. Recent data by Bertram et al. (1996), working with aerosol rather than bulk material, show much colder nucleation temperatures for this concentration range, falling along a smooth curve starting from the homogeneous nucleation temperature of about-35~ for pure water. This curve is very close to the theoretical estimates of Jensen et al. (1994) and of Larsen (1994) based on equations for homogeneous nucleation and on extrapolations of the relevant constants. The agreement between observations and theory (for the 0...35% concentration range) is fairly reassuring, though some reservations must be expressed. First, the formation of an ice embryo in a surrounding of both H2SO4 and H20 molecules in the liquid state should consider different kinetics than truly homogeneous nucleus formation. Second, solution effects for equilibrium conditions are used to estimate effects on homogeneous nucleation temperatures even though experiments such as Rasmussen and Mackenzie (1972) and Ganguly and Adiseshaiah (1992) showed that homogeneous nucleation temperatures are depressed by significantly larger amounts than the melting temperatures. The importance of this factor is emphasized by DeMott et al. (1994). Large uncertainties must therefore be acknowledged in the theory, even beyond the difficulty of assigning appropriate interfacial energy values. On the experimental side, the control of composition and of humidity, as well as the observation of the phase change are major difficulties. Further work on these topics is clearly warranted, including determinations of the chemical composition of the aerosol involved. While there is ample evidence for the prevalence of sulfuric acid aerosol in the upper troposphere, and the involvement of nitrates in the polar stratosphere, there are also disparate observations such as those of Hagen et al. (1995) and of Podzimek et al. (1995) of small fractions of soluble material in upper tropospheric aerosol in the size range 0.04...0.13 ~tm, and the existence of larger particles (to 5 ~tm diameter) in concentrations of the order 1
274
Vali
cm -3. It is worth noting that the formulation of detailed models of cirrus and PSC formation (Jensen et al., 1994; Larsen, 1994; Heymsfield and Miloshevich, 1995) and the parametric model of DeMott et al. (1994) offer the opportunity to evaluate theoretical and laboratory results in comparison with field data. For acid concentrations between 35% and 67% by weight, the solid phase is assumed to be sulfuric acid tetrahydrate (SAT). The large-volume experiments of Ohtake (1993) and of Song (1994) yielded solidification temperatures near 200 K, but with a large degree of scatter. Beyer et al. (1994) report similar temperatures but also show that the length of time to solidification is quite large, so that the freezing of small sulfuric acid aerosols of high concentrations is unlikely. Anthony et al. (1995) report on the basis of FTIR observations that submicron sulfate aerosol of 35...90% composition remained liquid for periods up to 3 hours when held at temperatures between 190 K and 230K. It thus appears that homogeneous nucleation in such sulfuric acid aerosol will only take place at temperatures < 190 K. For practical applications to PSC's, ternary systems involving water, sulfuric acid and nitric acid need to be considered but will not be discussed here as they are covered by the review paper of T. Peter in this volume. CLOUDS IN THE LOWER TROPOSPHERE The formation of ice in lower tropospheric clouds, between the temperatures of the melting point and of homogeneous nucleation, remains a question of great importance for understanding the global climate and water balance yet progress is quite slow in this area. The fundamental problem is that the origins of ice particles are understood only partially and in very rough terms. Predictive capabilities are limited by the complexities of tropospheric aerosol, by inadequate theoretical formulations and by the lack of proven instrumentation for ice nucleus measurements. Interpretations of field observations are hindered by the direct connections between ice formation and cloud dynamics and by the existence of secondary ice generation processes. Recognition of these limitations resulted from the period around the 1970's which saw intense laboratory experimentation as well as numerous field studies utilizing aircraft equipped with ice particle probes. The major findings of that period, and progress since then, led to the recognition that ice particle concentrations in clouds are at times much higher than measured ice nucleus concentrations, that some of that discrepancy is due to secondary processes such as the Hallett-Mossop process, and that ice nucleation can proceed via different pathways and from a variety of natural nucleating substances. The current situation can be best characterized as one focussed on searching for solutions to overcome or bypass one or other of problems which stand in the way of making the findings more precise, more specific to given cloud systems and instances. Inherent to this search is the openness to new ideas. Two concepts have been put forward that may lead to new findings. Braham (1986) and Beard (1992) call attention to the fact that in warm-based convective clouds the freezing of rain or drizzle drops grown by coalescence seems to be a key element of ice initiation and development. Field observations of Rangno and Hobbs (1991) in maritime clouds appear to support the role of drop freezing in what they term the first stage of ice enhancement. In contrast, for continental clouds Rangno and Hobbs (1994) show evidence for possible linkages between cloud depth and the width of the droplet spectrum at cloud top and ice initiation. Common to all of these scenarios is some connection between events traditionally considered part of the warm-rain process and ice development. Possible mechanisms that lead to preferential freezing of the larger cloud droplets or rain drops are condensation on large condensation-freezing nuclei or the capture of large freezing nuclei by the drops. These processes have not yet been properly observed. Also, the relative sparsity in precipitation samples of freezing nuclei active at temperatures above-8~ would have to be reconciled with the idea of drop freezing in clouds by demonstrating that the activity is lost with time. The other suggestion that is motivating further investigations is that the residues of evaporating cloud droplets have enhanced ice nucleating abilities. Beard (1992) explores this idea and also links it with the possibility that such residues might be the contact-freezing nuclei discussed in the preceding paragraph. Laboratory evidence for this process is claimed by Rosinski and Morgan (1991).
Ice nucleation ~ A review
275
The measurement of ice nuclei with high spatial and temporal resolution as well as with indication of the mode of action remains an elusive goal. Some progress may emerge from the continuous-flow diffusion chamber design of Rogers (1994). In laboratory studies of silver iodide and related aerosols, DeMott (1995) showed the that the relative contributions of different nucleation modes depend on the aerosol type, temperature and, in some cases, on the specific history of when the aerosol is introduced into the cloud. These data opened the opportunity for more detailed comparisons with the results of cloud seeding (Meyer et al., 1995) than has been possible earlier. In general, modeling of the initiation of ice is done in ever greater detail, though the input assumptions remain roughly defined (e.g. Meyer et al., 1992). On the other hand, Baker (1991) performed calculations to show that a process often considered in ice nucleation - activation by high supersaturations with respect to w a t e r - is unlikely to be significant in clouds. ORGANIC ICE NUCLEI While monitoring of atmospheric ice nuclei, and observations of their activity in creating ice particles within clouds, are the principal concerns for establishing the origins of ice in clouds, the questions what substances and what mechanisms make efficient heteronuclei are clearly complementary to the primary foci. Important new results in these areas are summarized in the following paragraphs. Epitaxial fit between ice and the nucleating substrate is a well known factor favoring nucleation. That an alcohol monolayer could provide such a substrate and nucleate ice at temperatures near- 1~ was a startling discovery (Gavish et al., 1990). In fact many details of the monolayer structure, of the monolayer-ice interface and of the size of the ice embryo has now been elucidated by Popovitz-Biro et al. (1994) and Majewski et al. (1994). The initial work reported in 1990 demonstrated that 2D crystals of aliphatic alcohol monolayers whose lattice dimensions are close to that of ice would be efficient ice nuclei. The alcohol series CnH2n+IOH for n= 16...31, in the form of monolayers spread over water drops, produced a double series of nucleation temperatures for as n increased. For each series, nucleation temperatures rise toward higher values from near -14~ the freezing temperature found for the smallest n-values. For even values of n the highest nucleation temperatures reached -8~ for n>22, and for odd values of n the nucleation temperatures gradually rose to near-1 ~ for n=31. In comparison, carboxylic acids of similar chain lengths produced ice nucleation at temperatures around-16~ The lattice match, as determined by grazing-incidence X-ray diffraction (GID), was better for the alcohols than for the acids confirming the role of epitaxy. In the more recent reports, measurements with D20 covered with the aliphatic alcohol monolayers confirmed the findings with H20, showing the same series of nucleation temperatures but shifted toward higher temperatures. Monolayers of mixtures of two different alcohols, which produce poorly ordered surfaces, led to lower nucleation temperatures than either of the components separately; this confirms the role of structural fit to ice. This contrasts with the situation when up to 50% of a fluorocarbon alcohol is mixed with the n=20 hydrocarbon alcohol: no change in nucleation temperatures was found indicating that these two alcohols form separate crystalline domains. The influence of the chain length is interpreted as governing the lateral coherence length, and the tilt angle of the chain with respect to the b-axis, in all leading to better lattice match with increasing chain length. Perhaps the most difficult point to clarify is the reason for the difference between the even and odd members of the series, for example why the two longest members of the series, n=30 and n=31 yield nucleation temperatures differing by 7~ There is no clear evidence for differences in packing arrangements, so the hypothesis is that the orientation of the (CH2OH) head groups, and possibly rearrangement of this group, account for the differences in nucleating ability. This notion is also supported by experiments with alcohols in which ester or amide groups have been inserted mid--chain; the dependence of nucleation temperatures on overall chain length and parity was overridden by a dependence of the parity of the hydrocarbon fragment connecting the OH head group to the introduced functional group.
276
Vali
Examinations, using GID, of the monolayers just prior to and immediately following ice nucleation, as well as GID patterns from the ice itself allowed Majewski et al. (1994) to set an upper threshold for the critical size of the ice embryos at temperatures very near 0~ A coherence length of 25 ,~ was found for ice formed under the alcohol monolayer (which in itself has much larger coherence length) so that the critical size of nuclei is taken to be about 20 ]k corresponding to about 50 water molecules. [This is a surprisingly small critical size, comparable to that estimated to be necessary for homogeneous nucleation near-40~ In addition to the critical-size estimates, the GID observations showed that the monolayer undergoes a gradual change as the temperature is lowered from 6~ to 1~ but retains its structure through nucleation, growth and subsequent melting of the ice underneath it. The nucleated ice crystals were shown to have their c-axes perpendicular to the interface. Since binding of an ice layer to the monolayer would impose proton ordering, the question arises, and remains unanswered at this point, how far this proton ordering might extend into the ice. At least a partial, independent confirmation of the nucleating abilities of the aliphatic alcohol monolayers is given by Davey et al. (1994). Working with the relatively inactive n=30 member of the series, they found that nucleation is almost immediate with that monolayer at-8~ and that at higher temperatures, to -4~ nucleation will take place at with gradually increasing delay times (to near 12 h at -4~ Unfortunately, the nucleation temperatures observed in their apparatus with the monolayer differed only by few degrees from those obtained in the control experiments, so that the presence of other sources of nucleation can't be ruled out. The difference noted many years ago between threshold temperatures for freezing nucleation of chiral or racemic varieties of amino acids was confirmed anew by Gavish et al. (1992). These materials have very poor lattice fit to ice and do not differ in this respect from one another. Thus the observations require other interpretation. By noting that higher nucleation temperatures are found for those varieties that have polar axes, independently whether that occurs for the chiral-resolved or racemic variety, the authors propose that electric fields within cracks of the crystals raise the nucleation temperatures. Visual observations confirmed that cracks are preferred locations for deposition nucleation at-15~ Macroscopic electric fields, and electric charges on particles have been suggested before as factors in ice nucleation, but solid evidence has been difficult to produce; whether the suggestion for this microscopic electric-field effect will be more amenable to confirmation will remain to be seen. Bacterial ice nuclei were discovered in the 1970's. Their activity as freezing nuclei at temperatures as high as-2~ raised a great deal of interest in identifying the active agents. Practical applications were identified for bacterial nucleants as initiators of freezing, as well as for the elimination of these bacteria and consequent delaying or elimination of freezing in natural systems. Fungal species of similar activity were also found by the late 1980's. Most of the material relating these biological ice nucleants is now assembled in a single volume (Lee, Warren and Gusta, 1995) so readers are referred to that for details. What is missing from the compendium, for lack of any systematic attack of the issue, is work on the possible atmospheric role of these nucleants. For evolutionary reasons still not known, bacteria of a handful of species (out of the millions in existence) developed the ability to synthesize ice nucleating proteins in their outer membrane. In contact with supercooled water they initiate freezing at temperatures close to 0~ The fraction of individuals within a population of bacteria (either natural or cultured) which nucleate ice at a given temperature is quite variable and often quite small. Also, the nucleating material is a small fraction of the bacterial membrane. These facts made identification and isolation of the active agent quite difficult. It was accomplished by identifying the DNA segment responsible for expression of nucleating ability, confirming this by splicing this gene into otherwise non-active species and then deducing the protein structure that the gene elicits. Presence of the protein in the outer membrane was confirmed and visualized by antibody attachment; the protein forms clusters of a large range of sizes in abundances related to the activity of the sample. The protein molecules
Ice nucleation ~ A review
277
are 150...200 kDa size and are characterized by repetitive segments of nucleotides. Quantitative comparisons between protein amount per cell, numbers of clusters and nucleating ability led to the realization that activity is a function not only of the amount of protein produced but also of factors governing its aggregation. What these factors are is not yet established, nor is the structure of the nucleating site. Gamma ray deactivation analysis led to an estimation of the sizes of the nucleating units: at-13~ a single protein molecule may be sufficient while a t - 3 ~ a cluster of = 104 molecules is indicated. Perhaps the broadest impact that studies of organic ice nuclei have is that they produced new, quantitative methods for the characterization of the nucleation process and of the substrate surface. At the same time, ice nucleation came to the attention of scientists in diverse fields of research, with many of these scientists using ice nucleation as an analytical tool for the elucidation of genetic, plant pathological and many other problems. Implications for atmospheric ice nucleation are speculative - there is little known about the organic components of atmospheric aerosol in general, and it seems certain that research to improve that situation will be quite demanding considering the tiny amounts of organic material that may be involved in producing ice nucleation. Assessments of particles of biological origin in air and in precipitation (e.g. Matthias-Maser and Jaenicke, 1992; Casareto et al., 1996) indicate that the search should be continued. REFERENCES Angell, C. A., 1982: Supercooled water, in "Water- a comprehensive treatise, Vol. 7", Franks, E (Ed.), Plenum Press, pp. 1-81. Anthony, S. E., R. T. Tisdale, R. S. Disselkamp, M. A. Tolbert and J. C. Wilson, 1995: FI'IR studies of low temperature sulfuric acid aerosols. Geophys. Res. Lett., 22, 1105-1108. Arnott, W. P., Y. Y. Dong, J. Hallett and M. R. Poellot, 1994: Role of small ice crystals in radiative properties of cirrus- a case study, FIRE II, November 22, 1991. J. Geophys. Res. (Atmosph.), 99, 1371-1381. Baker, B. A., 1991: On the nucleation of ice in highly supersaturated regions of clouds. J. Atmos. Sci., 48, 1904-1907. Bartell, L. S. and J. Huang, 1994: Supercooling of water below the anomalous range near 226 K. J. Phys. Chem., 98, 7455-7457. Beard, K. V., 1992: Ice initiation in warm-base convective clouds: an assessment of microphysical mechanisms. Atmos. Res., 28, 125-152. Bertram, A. K., D. D. Patterson and J. J. Sloan, 1996: Mechanisms and temperatures for the freezing of sulfuric acid aerosols measured by FTIR extinction spectroscopy. J. Phys. Chem., 100, 2376-2383. Beyer, K. D., S. W. Seago, H. Y. Chang and M. J. Molina, 1994: Composition and freezing of aqueous H2SO4/HNO3 solutions under polar stratospheric conditions. Geophys. Res. Lett., 21, 871-874. Braham Jr., R. R., 1986: Coalescence-freezing precipitation mechanism. 10th Conf. on Planned and Inadvertent Weather Modification, Amer. Meteor. Soc. 142-145. Casareto, B. E., Y. Suzuki, K. Okada and M. Morita, 1996: Biological micro-particles in rain water. Geophys. Res. Lett., 23, 173-176. Davey, R. J., S. J. Maginn, R. B. Steventon, J. M. Ellery, A. V. Murrell, J. Booth, A. D. Godwin and J. E. Rout, 1994: Nucleation of crystals under Langmuir monolayers - kinetic and morphological data for the nucleation of ice. Langmuir, 10, 1673-1675. Demott, P. J., 1995: Quantitative descriptions of ice formation mechanisms of silver iodide-type aerosols. Atmosph. Res., 38, 63-99. DeMott, P. J. and D. C. Rogers, 1990: Freezing nucleation rates of dilute solution droplets measured between -30 ~ and -40~ in laboratory simulations of natural clouds. J. Atmos. Sci., 47, 1056-1064.
278
Vali
Demott, P. J., M. P. Meyers and W. R. Cotton, 1994: Parameterization and impact of ice initiation processes relevant to numerical model simulations of cirrus clouds. J. Atmos. Sci., 51, 77-90. Gable, C. M., H. F. Betz and S. H. Maron, 1950: Phase equilibria of the system sulfur trioxide-water. J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 72, 1445-1448. Ganguly, S. and K. S. Adiseshaiah, 1992: Ice nucleation in emulsified aqueous salt solutions- a differential scanning calorimetry study. Colloids and Surfaces, 66, 105-111. Gavish, M., R. Popovitzbiro, M. Lahav and L. Leiserowitz, 1990: Ice nucleation by alcohols arranged in monolayers at the surface of water drops. Science, 250, 973-975. Gavish, M., J. L. Wang, M. Eisenstein, M. Lahav and L. Leiserowitz, 1992: The role of crystal polarity in alpha-amino acid crystals for induced nucleation of ice. Science, 256, 815-818. Gtitz, G., M6sz~iros, E., and Vali, G., 1991" Atmospheric Particles andNuclei, Akad6miai Kiad6, Budapest. Gr~imisy, L., 1993: Diffuse interface theory of nucleation. J. Non-Crystalline Solids, 162, 301-303. Gr~.nS.sy, L., 1995: Diffuse interface analysis of ice nucleation in undercooled water. J. Phys. Chem., 99, 14182-14187. Hagen, D. E., J. Podzimek and M. B. Trueblood, 1995: Upper-tropospheric aerosol sampled during project FIRE IFO II. J. Atmos. Sci., 52, 4196--4209. Hallett, J. and R. E. J. Lewis, 1967: Mother of pearl clouds. Weather, 22, 56--65. Heymsfield, A. J. and L. M. Miloshevich, 1993: Homogeneous ice nucleation and supercooled liquid water in orographic wave clouds. J. Atmos. Sci., 50, 2335-2353. Heymsfield, A. J. and L. M. Miloshevich, 1995: Relative humidity and temperature influences on cirrus formation and evolution: Observations from wave clouds and FIRE II. J. Atmos. Sci., 52, 4302-4326. Jensen, E. J., O. B. Toon, D. L. Westphal, S. Kinne and A. J. Heysmfield, 1994: Microphysical modeling of cirrus .1. Comparison with 1986 FIRE IFO measurements. J. Geophys. Res. (Atmosph.), 99, 10421-10442. Knollenberg, R. G., K. Kelly and J. C. Wilson, 1993: Measurements of high number densities of ice crystals in the tops of tropical cumulonimbus. J. Geophys. Res., 98, 8639-8664. Larsen, N., 1994: The impact of freezing of sulfate aerosols on the formation of polar stratospheric clouds. Geophys. Res. Lett., 21,425-428. Lee, R. E. Jr., Warren, G. J., and Gusta, L. V., 1995: Biological Ice Nucleation and Its Applications, APS Press, The American Phytopathological Society, St. Paul, Minnesota. Majewski, J., R. Popovitzbiro, K. Kjaer, J. Alsnielsen, M. Lahav and L. Leiserowitz, 1994: Toward a determination of the critical size of ice nuclei - a demonstration by grazing incidence X-ray diffraction of epitaxial growth of ice under the C31H63OH alcohol monolayer. J. Phys. Chem., 98, 4087-4093. Matthias-Maser, S. and R. Jaenicke, 1992: Identification and size distribution of biological aerosol particles with radius > 0.2 um., in "Nucleation and Atmospheric Aerosols", Edited by N. Fukuta and P.E. Wagner, A. Deepak Publ., pp.413-416. Meyers, M. P., P. J. Demott and W. R. Cotton, 1992: New primary ice-nucleation parameterizations in an explicit cloud model. J. Appl. Meteor., 31,708-721. Meyers, M. P., P. J. Demott and W. R. Cotton, 1995: A comparison of seeded and nonseeded orographic cloud simulations with an explicit cloud model. J. Appl. Meteor, 34, 834-846. Ohtake, T., 1993: Freezing points of H2SO4 aqueous solutions and formation of stratospheric ice clouds. Tellus B - Chem. Phys. Meteor, 45, 138-144.
Ice nucleation B A review
279
Podzimek, J., D. E. Hagen and E. Robb, 1995: Large aerosol particles in cirrus type clouds.Atmos. Res., 38, 263-282. Popovitzbiro, R., J. L. Wang, J. Majewski, E. Shavit, L. Leiserowitz and M. Lahav, 1994: Induced freezing of supercooled water into ice by self-assembled crystalline monolayers of amphiphilic alcohols at the air-water interface. J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 116, 1179-1191. Pruppacher, H. R., 1995: A new look at homogeneous ice nucleation in supercooled water drops. J. Atmos. Sci., 52, 1924-1933. Pruppacher, H. R. and Klett, J. D., 1978: Microphysics of clouds and precipitation, D. Reidel Publ. Co., Dordrecht, Holland. Rangno, A. L. and R V. Hobbs, 1991: Ice particle concentrations and precipitation development in small polar maritime cumuliform clouds. Quart. J. Roy. Meteor Soc., 117, 207-241. Rangno, A. L. and E V. Hobbs, 1994: Ice particle concentrations and precipitation development in small continental cumuliform clouds. Quart. J. Roy. Meteor Soc., 120, 573-601. Rasmussen, D. H. and A.P. MacKenzie, 1972: Effect of solute ice-solution interfacial free energy; calculation from measured homogeneous nucleation temperatures, in "Water structure at the water-polymer interface", Edited by H. H. G. Jelinek, 126-145. Rogers, D. C., 1994: Detecting ice nuclei with a continuous-flow diffusion chamber-some exploratory tests of instrument response. J. Atmos. Ocean. Tech., 11, 1042-1047. Rosinski, J. and G. Morgan, 1991: Cloud condensation nuclei as source of ice-forming nuclei in clouds. J. Aerosol Sci., 22, 123-133. Sassen, K., 1992: Evidence for liquid-phase cirrus cloud formation from volcanic aerosols -climatic implications. Science, 257, 516-519. Sassen, K. and G. C. Dodd, 1988: Homogeneous nucleation rate for highly supercooled cirrus cloud droplets. J. Atmos. Sci., 45, 1357-1369. Song, N. H., 1994: Freezing temperatures of H2SO4/HNO3/HO2 mixtures: Implications for polar stratospheric clouds. Geophys. Res. Lett., 21, 2709-2712. Str6m, J. and J. Heintzenberg, 1994: Water vapor, condensed water, and crystal concentration in orographically influenced cirrus clouds. J. Atmos. Sci., 51, 2368-2383. Tolbert, M. A., 1994: Sulfate aerosols and polar stratospheric cloud formation. Science, 264, 527-528.
FORMATION MECHANISMS OF POLAR STRATOSPHERIC CLOUDS THOMAS PETER Max-Planck-Institut ffir Chemie, Mainz, Germany A b s t r a c t - The physical chemistry of polar stratospheric clouds is far from being well-understood and the uncertainties affect our understanding of polar ozone destruction, in particular in the northern stratosphere. However, the scientific field is very rapidly developing. This paper summarizes the current state of our knowledge of the microphysics and heterogeneous chemistry of polar stratospheric clouds with emphasis on liquid and solid particle thermodynamics and on kinetics of non-reactive gas uptake leading to particle growth. The consequences of the present uncertainties for the chemical processing of stratospheric air are briefly discussed. K e y w o r d s - Stratospheric aerosols; microphysics; heterogeneous chemistry INTRODUCTION Considerable progress has been made within the first half of this decade in our understanding of the composition and physical phase of polar stratospheric clouds (PSCs). Possibly most important is the recognition of the liquid state that PSCs can take on under certain conditions. Previously PSCs had been assumed to consist of solid particles only, like ice or nitric acid trihydrate (NAT), which are both crystalline. The three conventional types of PSCs distinguishable by Lidar (Light Detection And Ranging), type-la, type-lb and type-2, can tentatively be identified as NAT, ternary droplets and ice, respectively, although in-situ chemical analysis is still pending. Presently, open questions are how the solid particles form and how the chemical reactivity of the particles depends on their physical state. Furthermore, with highly resolved PSC observations from the Arctic becoming available there is evidence that not all PSCs may be explained in terms of liquid, NAT or ice particles under thermodynamic equilibrium conditions. Whether transient non-equilibrium states of the aerosol or other phenomena, like the currently discussed amorphous states, enable to understand these cases remains to be seen. THE PHYSICAL STATE OF PSCs Only one year after the discovery of the Antarctic ozone hole Crutzen and Arnold [1986] and Toon et al. [1986] suggested that PSCs would contain nitric acid. Especially the thermodynamically most stable nitric acid trihydrate (NAT = HNO3.3H20) could possibly account for the clouds existing at temperatures 5-7 K above the frost point. Based on this information the following 3-stage concept of PSC formation emerged [Poole and McCormick, 1988], which is used in most chemical transport models up to date. It was thought that: 1. at sufficiently low temperatures (T = 200-210 K) the ubiquitous stratospheric H2SO4/H20 aerosol particles could freeze and act as solid condensation nuclei;
280
Formation mechanisms of polar stratospheric clouds
281
2. around 195 K NAT formed on the frozen aerosol particles due to heterogeneous bimolecular nucleation and subsequent condensation of HNO3 and H20; 3. below 190 K ice can grow on NAT particles after heterogeneous unimolecular nucleation of H20. This 3-stage concept is summarized in Fig.1. Thermodynamic vapor pressures measured by Hanson and Mauersberger [1988] confirmed that NAT was indeed the thermodynamically most stable HNOa hydrate under stratospheric conditions. This also corroborated the 3-stage concept. Moreover, the concept sucessfully explained the PSC mes of the American Antarctic campaign (AAOE, 1987) which clearly showed the onset of particle growth when the saturation temperature with respect to NAT was reached [Fahey et al., 1989]. On the other hand, these Antarctic observations were made in late winter after air masses had been exposed to very cold conditions over extended periods of time and could not reveal how the PSCs were initially formed during early winter. However, the two main ideas after the confusion caused by the discovery of the ozone hole, heterogeoneous chemistry on PSCs [Solomon et al., 1986] and formation of stable HNOa hydrates, had been developed very quickly, and theory, laboratory experiment and field observation seemed to be in good agreement. CONVENTIONAL 3-STAGE PSC-MODEL The Different Types of Stratospheric Particles Below -195 K Below Frost Point (-187 K)
Initial Conditions o
O
O o
0
o
o
0
o
o
o
O
o
o
Sulfuric acid NAT = Type-I,
o
0
o
o
~)
o
NAT nucleation on the largest aerosol particles Nitric acid trihydrate
Ice = Type II particles,
o
0
o
o
N
o 0 o
"
Background H2SO 4 aerosol D
O
o0
l
Ice nucleation on the largest NAT particles; NAT is also incorporated into the ice
F ] Ice with a NAT impurity ~ Removal by sedimentation
Figure 1" Conventional 3-stage concept for PSC formation as it is currently applied in most of the large-scale chemical models. (1) Initial conditions with background H2SO4/H20 aerosol assumed to freeze at some temperature above 195 K. (2) Below about 195 K NAT nucleates directly from the vapor phase on the largest frozen aerosol particles. (3) Below about 187 K ice nucleates on NAT. Sufficiently large NAT and ice particles are removed due to sedimentation. Adapted from Drdla and Turco [1990]. At the turn of the decade several observations gave first hints that PSC particles do often not form according to the 3-stage concept. Lidar observations in the Arctic [Browell et al., 1990] indicated the existence of two distinct classes of type-1 PSCs, one of which (type-lb) consisting of a large number of non-depolarizing particles, which must be either spherical or, if non-spherical, have sizes much smaller than the Lidar wavelength [Toon et al., 1990]. Next, Hofmann et al. [1990] and Schlager et el. [1990] in two joint balloon experiments showed that in airmasses passing the Norwegian mountains PSCs formed only when supercooling with respect to NAT by 3-4 K was reached. Using a microphysical model Peter et al. [1992] established agreement between the 3-stage concept and these observations under two assumptions: first, the particles had undergone strong lee-wave-induced cooling briefly before observation; second, the crystalline compatibility
Peter
282
oc~s--- so2--- H~O4 OXIDATION+NUCLEATION
- 230
-220
UQUID AEROSOL ~i SULFURIC
-210
FROZEN?
I-- --I I O I i | I _
_
I _
.; NO
_,00
PSC-I I 190
NAT ~
~ H20/I"INO:~'42SO4
PSC-II ICE~H#:) t.,.-~../"e1420
Figure 2: Two possible pathways for the stratospheric aerosol upon cooling. Left path: conventional 3-stage concept ( / / / / S A T , \\\\ NAT, ]]11ice). Right path: aerosol remains liquid, takes up HNO3 and freezes out water ice below the frost point.
between NAT and the underlying frozen sulfuric acid had to be assumed very low. While the lee wave assumption is now fully accepted, a proper description of the microphysics in future must take account of liquid particles. Finally, also in 1990, referring to his laboratory measurements with Mauersberger, Hanson described the observation of HNO3/H20 liquid films prior to NAT formation [Hanson, 1990]. Stimulated by these observations Arnold [1992] suggested that H2SO4/H20 aerosols might remain liquid to temperatures close to the NAT equilibrium temperature, at which point it could take up HNO3. However, he had to rely on HNO3 solubility measurements of Reihs et aI. [1990] who themselves thought that HNOz would remain a minor component of the liquid aerosol. The low probability of the binary H2SO4/H20 aerosols to freeze as sulfuric acid tetrahydrate (SAT) was further corroborated by Luo et al. [1994a] who investigated the freezing process of binary H2SO4/H20 aerosols using classical homogeneous nucleation theory. These calculations depend crucially on thermodynamic input parameters, like the surface energy of the SAT embryo, which are still quite uncertain. Larsen [1994] showed Antarctic and Arctic denitrification could be explained within the 3-stage concept only if surface energies of the SAT embryo were much lower than assumed previously. On the other hand, based on observations in metallurgy MacKenzie et al. [1995] argued that the surface energy might actually be up to a factor of five larger than the one adopted by Luo et al. [1994a]. Hence, the question arose, wha~ would happen if temperatures fell below the NAT existence temperature and the particles were still liquid. Figure 2 summarizes the two possible pathways of the stratospheric aerosol with falling temperatures. The left path shows the conventional 3-stage concept: freezing of the H2SO4/H20 droplets, then sublimative NAT nucleation on the frozen particles, and finally water ice nucleation. The right path shows the droplets remaining liquid, take up H20 and HNO3, and eventually solidify below the frost point as water ice. It is at present not clear whether or not the surface layer of remaining acidic liquid will eventually freeze, possibly seeded by the ice nucleus. The acids might then form SAT and NAT layers on the ice which could possibly protect the ice core against evaporation. As mentioned above, NAT evaporates only 5-7 K above the frost point, and SAT even more than 25 K higher [Middlebrook et al., 1993].
283
Formation mechanisms o f polar stratospheric clouds
THERMODYNAMICS OF HNO3/H2SO4/H20 SOLUTIONS Vapor pressure measurements in the laboratory clearly indicate the onset of HNO3 uptake at low temperatures [Molina et al., 1993], but thermodynamic models are required to bridge the data gap when concentrations change from aqeous H2SO4 to aqeous HNO3. Ion-interaction models for the description of highly concentrated electrolytes have been used in many scientific disciplines. Using such thermodynamic models Carslaw et al. [1994], Tabazadeh et at. [1994] and Drdla el• al. [1994] successfully explained stratospheric particle measurements by Dye el, al. [1992] as liquid ternary solution droplets, justifying an earlier approach by Peter and Crutzen [1993]. Carslaw et al. used a form of the Pitzer ion-interaction model [Pitzer, 1987]. Ion-interaction models comprise electrostatic far field interactions between the ions similar to the theory of Debye and Hiickel [1923] and near field interactions due to two and three body collisions between individual ions or solvent molecules. The interaction parameters are determined from available thermodynamic data, and the model equations allow a thermodynamically self-consistent extrapolation to other conditions, for example lower temperatures. 10
.,...~
i
....
,~. .
E o
i ....
H2SO4
/ HNO
i
....
1 ....
60
i
1
i
I
I
!
1
i
.~
,---,,
3 / H20
i
1
1
i
l
""
o~ 40
~ ~ ....
1
r
E....j
20
. _O
)
E 0.1 _=
" ....
.~ r
O >
g l o .2
.. 0.01
2
I1) O
,,,
T9 i c e {
I
~ I
190
, I
~ ~
200 T[K]
J ~
I
~
,
~
l
0
(a)
TNAT
1 ~ J I ,v,,
1
,
210
10 -4• ' 185
190
195
200
T[K]
Figure 3: (a) Total particle volume observed as function of temperature onboard the American high-altitude research aircraft ER-2 on 24 January, 1989, during a flight northbound from Stavanger, Norway. Flight level was 55 mbar (about 19 km altitude). Amount of H2SO4 in the aerosol corresponds to normal background conditions (0.53 ppbv H2S04 upon evaporation). With decreasing temperatures the particles initially grow due to H20 uptake by the H2SO4/H20 binary (dotted line for 5 ppmv H20). Below 193 K volume increase is much stronger, and is in agreement with the combined H20 and HNO3 uptake by the ternary aerosol (heavy solid line for 10 ppbv HNO3, thin solid lines for 5 and 15 ppbv). NAT particle growth without nucleation barrier is shown by the dashed line. NAT and ice equilibrium temperatures are indicated by vertical arrows. (b) Liquid concentrations as functions of temperature (with 10 ppbv HNOa). Concentrations for H2SO4, HNO3 and HC1 in wt% for the ternary aerosol (solid lines) and for H2SO4 in the absence of HNO3 (dotted line). Note the change from linear to logarithmic scales below 2 wt%. Adapted from Carslaw et al. [1994]. Figure 3a shows the measurements of aerosol volume vs. temperature by Dye et al. [1992] on 24 January, 1989 north of Norway at about 55 mbar. The thick solid curve based on the thermodynamic model calculations of the coupled uptake of H20 and HNO3 by Carslaw et al. [1994] can fully explain the data. On the other hand it is clear that H20 uptake alone (dotted curve) cannot account for the observations. Also NAT formation, if one assumed thermodynamic equilibrium without a nucleation barrier, would lead to very different particle volumes with decreasing temperatures (dashed line). Figure 3b shows the strong changes in liquid composition of the aerosol particles leading to the observed volume growth in Fig.3a. A combination of decreasing temperatures and water uptake
284
Peter 200
~" 196 "~" 194
NAT
~a.192 E 190 188
186 30
40
50
60
70
80
90
1O0
Total Pressure (mbar)
Figure 4: Equilibrium temperatures for NAT (upper curve) and ice (frost point, lower curve) and temperature for the onset of substantial HN03 uptake into stratospheric ternary solution (STS) droplets. Adapted from MacKenzie et al., 1995. leads to an enhanced solubility of HNO3. Below about 193 K the coupled HNOa/H20 uptake leads to the transformation from a binary H2SO4/H20 solution above 195 K into a quasi-binary HNO3/H~O solution below 190 K. The temperature below which substantial amounts of HNO3 are taken up so that the gas phase starts to become depleted lies between the NAT equilibrium temperature and the frost point. This is illustrated in Fig.4 from MacKenzie et aI. [1995] as a function of pressure altitude. In parallel, effort was made to backup these results by experimental investigations of the freezing behaviour of solutions of stratospheric composition. Ohtake [1993] investigated only the H2SO4/H20 binary system and showed that the solutions tended to supercool considerably. Beyer et al. [1994] and Song [1994] investigated ternary solutions but did not exclude the possibility of freezing under stratospheric conditions. Finally, Koop et al. [1995] investigated various HNO3/H~SO4 mixtures with compositions as given by Fig.3b between 195 K and 188 K. They kept 1-ml samples of these solutions for hours at temperatures corresponding to the stratospheric values and thus excluded the possibility of homogeneous freezing above the frost point. In seeding experiments with compounds of stratospheric interest (magnetite representing meteoritic material, aluminium oxide representing rocket exhausts, silicates representing volcanic debris, etc.) they showed that these compounds did not induce heterogeneous nucleation. The overall conclusion was that under equilibrium conditions the stratospheric aerosol droplets are unlikely to freeze at temperatures above the water ice frost point. HNO3 HYDRATES OTHER THAN NAT With their mass-spectrometric laboratory investigations Hanson and Mauersberger [1988] characterized the thermodynamic properties (vapor pressures and coexistence curves with water ice and nitric acid monohydrate) of NAT. Based on FTIR-spectroscopic measurements Tolbert et al. [1992] suggested that NAT might occur in two modifications (a-NAT and ~-NAT), but whether this affects the thermodynamic properties of NAT is currently not clear. In any case NAT is the most stable nitric acid hydrate under stratospheric conditions. However, according to a general physical chemistry principle (Ostwald's rule) it is often not the stable hydrate which nucleates first, but rather some metastable phase which, only after some time, transforms into the stable end product. Worsnop et al. [1993] measured vapor pressures of the previously discovered metastable nitric acid dihydrate (NAD) which may exist close to the coexistence curve of NAT and the monohydrate (NAM). In the same work Worsnop and coworkers report a higher hydrate, possibly the decahydrate close to the NAT/ice coexistence curve. Two other hydrates of nitric acid have been identified which could play an important role during the initial formation of solid hydrates under
Formation mechanisms of polar stratospheric clouds
285
stratospheric conditions: Marti and Mauersberger [1994] presented evidence for the formation of HNO3.5H20, and Fox et al. [1995] identified the mixed hydrate H2SO4.HNO3.5H20. Whether these hydrates really form under stratospheric conditions is at present completely open, since observational techniques sophisticated enough to distinguish these hydrates in the stratosphere are not yet available. The thermodynamic properties of all other nitric acid hydrates, except NAT, are not well established. This is also true for NAD which has been the most extensively studied of these metastable phases. Worsnop et al. [1993] measured the H20 and HNO3 vapor pressures of NAD which indicated a maximum of the melting point curve of NAD around 220 K. On the other hand, Ji and Petit [1993] made a calorimetric measurements of the NAD melting points showing a more than 15 K higher melting point curve. At present it is not known what the reason for the strong disagreement between both measurements is. HYPOTHESES OF FROZEN PSC FORMATION Laboratory measurements in combination with the success of thermodynamic models in describing HNO3/H2SO4/H20 ternary solutions has lead to a reversal of our understanding of solid and liquid PSCs. Until three years ago PSCs were thought to consist of solid particles. Now we know that at least in the Arctic the clouds are often liquid: the appearence of type-lb clouds can be understood in terms of ternary droplets. However, the formation of solid particles (type-la) remains unclear. At present there are five hypotheses on stratospheric particle freezing: 1. the binary H2SO4/H20 solution droplets freeze out sulfuric acid tetrahydrate (SAT), then NAT nucleates sublimatively on SAT (the 3-stage concept); 2. the binary droplets initially remain liquid and take up large amounts of HNO3 when T < 193 K, and subsequently NAT freezes out from these ternary solutions [Molina et al., 1993]; 3. even the ternary droplets remain liquid a~ long as temperatures do not fall below Tic,, at which point water ice precipitates from the solutions [Koop et al., 1995]; 4. rapid temperature fluctuations may cause the formation of quasi-binary HNO3/H20 droplets with close to 1:3 stoichiometry, which freeze as NAT above the frostpoint [Meilinger et al., 1995]; 5. amorphous solid solutions of H2SO4 and H20 form at low temperatures and crystallize upon warming as sulfuric acid hemihexahydrate or SAT which may then serve as nuclei for amorphous solid HNO3/H20 particles (so-called type-lc PSCs) at temperatures below the NAT equilibrium point [Tabazadeh et al., 1995]. As described above, hypotheses (1) and (2) by now can be almost ruled out as the initial step of solid particle formation given the evidence from laboratory experiments. The 3-stage concept may still be an important mechanism in the Antarctic, where due to the low temperatures the particles remain solid for extended periods of time after their initial freezing. However, in the Arctic particles go through repeated cooling and warming cycles, which lead often to complete melting. And even in the Antarctic the perception that NAT does not readily nucleate is supported by a spectroscopic analysis of infrared field observations [Toon and Tolbert, 1995]. Freezing experiments under thermodynamic equilibrium conditions suggest that the a~rosol is unlikely to freeze above Tic~ and therefore support hypothesis 3. However, this effectively means that even in the Arctic stratosphere, where the winter remains warmer than in the Antarctic, temperatures are required to drop below the frost point. The present lack of knowledge on mesoscale meteorology makes it impossible to judge if mesoscale temperature fluctuations could satisfy this condition. Although this appears to be a strong requirement, wave structures in aerosol layers observed by airborne Lidar [Godin et al., 1994] indicate gravity-wave induced adiabatic cooling and warming cycles of 2.5 to 10 K.
286
Peter
Recently Meilinger et al. [1995] investigated the non-equilibrium changes in the type-lb droplet compositions due to rapid temperature fluctuations as they can occur downstream of mountain ridges (lee waves). They found that these fluctuations may cause the droplets to assume HNO3 concentrations much larger than under equilibrium assumptions, and these quasi-binary HNO3/H20 droplets possibly freeze as NAT. Further details on their calculations are given by Peter and Meilinger in the present Proceedings Volume. Finally, Tabazadeh et al. [1995] suggested that amorphous solid solutions of HNO3 and H20 (so-called type-lc PSCs) could form at a temperature inbetween the NAT equilibrium temperature ar.d the frost point. This could possibly explain observations of PSCs whose vapor pressures indicate neither ternary liquid nor NAT in equilibrium. Such HNO3/H20 particles evidently have to grow on solid cores, otherwise the HNO3 uptake would simply lead to ternary solutions. Tabazadeh et al. [1995] suggested that these cores could be SAT particles which themselves could result from crystallization of H2SO4/H20 particles in an amorphous, glassy state. Support for this hypothesis comes from laboratory experiments [Iraci et al., 1994] and field observations [Larsen et al., 1996] which seem to show a crystallization upon warming, a well-known process of glasses when heated above the glass point. On the other hand, the glass points of binary and ternary solutions of HNO3, H2SO4 and H20 are below 165 K, therefore the application of the concept of glasses to stratospheric aerosols appears to be questionable. In a very recent paper Ha et al. [1996] reveal that particular single component systems may develop a distinct solid phase some degrees above the glass point which is neither glass nor crystal. Whether such a polyamorphism does exist in the system of interest here is presently not clear. FORMATION O F I C E CLOUDS IN OROGRAPHICALLY INDUCED WAVES When temperatures fall a few degrees below the frost point water ice clouds (type-2 PSCs) develop either by nucleation from the vapor phase or by freezing from ternary solution droplets. The modeling of the full particle kinetics of ice and NAT particles according to the 3-stage concept, i.e. sublimative nucleation, diffusively limited growth, NAT core release by evaporating ice particles and SAT core release by evaporating NAT particles, is described by Toon et al. [1989], Poole et al. [1990], Drdla and Turco [1991], Peter et al. [1992] and Panegrossi et el. [1996]. The reliability of these modeling studies is limited mainly due to the neglect of the liquid phase and uncertainties in the nucleation processes. In-situ measurements of water ice clouds are rare, because the high-altitude research aircraft ER-2 deliberately avoids the turbulent regions around the ice clouds, and because stratospheric balloons are not easy to position in these mesoscale features. In the only in-situ type-2 PSC observations during the European ozone expedition EASOE particles were measured with a balloonborne optical particle counter over northern Sweden [Deshler et al., 1994]. The measurement was made on 27 January, 1992, when stratospheric temperatures above the Norwegian mountains had dropped below the frost point, causing water ice particles to nucleate. Deshler et al. [1994] attributed the observed strong temperature and particle density fluctuations to the lee wave perturbation above and behind the mountains. Individual particle layers with up to 5 #m large particles were visible. Using a meteorological mesoscale model with high-resolution orography [Volkert and Intes, 1992] calculated the small-scale temperature fluctuations exerted by the mountain lee waves and showed that lee-wave induced temperature changes can amount to many degrees Kelvin. Most surprising is the fact that the temperatures measured aboard the balloon are 5-10 K too high for ice to be in equilibrium. Pure water ice particles would evaporate within a few minutes under such subsaturated conditions. Peter et al. [1994] suggested that the HNO3 impurities in the ice might form small NAT clusters, which upon heating of the ice could accumulate at the ice
Formation mechanisms of polar stratospheric clouds Sedimentation- induced T > TNAT T < TNAT
287
NAT- coating
T < TICE T > TICE T > TNAT
o o-@--@--o
frozen
aerosol
H2SO4 ] H20
NAT grows on aerosol
T < Tic E
frozen a c q u i r e s aerosol NAT- H2SO4 / H20 coating
on NAT
Leewave- induced T > TIC E
ice crystal
ice grows
NAT- coating
T > TIC E T > TNA T T >> TNA T
o -O-o liquid aerosol
H2SO4 / H20 / HNO3
growing ice
shrinking ice
pressure
aerosol
crystalwith crystal acquires reduction liquid? NATNATdue to NAT- frozen? impurities coating rich layer
Figure 5: Upper panel: Sketch of the NAT coating mechanism proposed by Wofsy et al. (1990). Ice partilces sediment into warm regions where NAT particles have not yet formed and acquire a NAT coating which protects them against evaporation. Lower panel: Sketch of the evolution of an ice crystal with NAT-impurities nucleating in a liquid H2SO4/H20 aerosol particle. In this case ice evaporation is slowed due to a NAT-coating (Tice < T < TNAT) or due to a lowering of its vapour pressure (T > TNAT). surface since the water molecules evaporate faster than the NAT clusters. Eventually this could form a few NAT monolayers on top of the ice leading to a protection of the ice, i.e. to a slowing of the evaporation process due to a lowering of the vapor pressure (see Fig.5, upper panel). Wofsy et al. [1990] had suggested a similar coating mechanism for ice particles sedimenting into atmospheric layers which are too warm for pure ice to exist but still cold enough for NAT. The settling ice particles could then acquire a NAT coating on their way through these layers (Fig.5, lower panel). The increase of the ice particle lifetime due to NAT coating might strongly affect their importance as sites for heterogeneous chemical reactions in the lower Arctic stratosphere. CHLORINE ACTIVATION ON LIQUID AND THE SOLID PARTICLES Our understanding, not only of the thermodynamics, but also the reaction kinetics of liquid stratospheric particles has advanced considerably within the last three years. The accurate determination of (non-reactive) solubilities of individual reaction partners in the HNO3/H2SO4/H20 solutions is also central for a correct description of the reactivity. Figure 6 shows measurements by Elrod et al. [1995] and Hanson and Ravishankara [1994] of the reaction probability 7 of CION02 for the reaction C1ON02 + HC1 pmide ~C12 + HN03 (1) in H2SO4/H~O binary and HNO3/H2SO4/H20 ternary solutions along with data for NAT (dotted line) from Hanson and Ravishankara [1993]. In contrast to reaction probabilities on solids there is a reliable framework for theoretical treatment of liquid phase reactions [Hanson et al., 1994]. If reactant concentrations are not too high the reaction probability can be calculated from the solubility and diffusion of the two reactants into the liquid and can be expressed as "7 -~ 4RT/~clONO~ (DIgII[Hc1])z/2/vcloNo2.
(2)
288
Peter ~w
>,
i
|
,
l
w
i
l
!
0.12
.m
o
I,,.,..
c~
0.08
tO
0.04 ~176176176
0 194
1
I 196
I
[]
~'~
! 198
i
200
202
T/K
Figure 6: Reaction probabilities for HCl+C1ONO2 in liquid aerosols (solid and dashed lines) and on NAT (dotted line) as a function of temperature assuming 5 ppmv H20, 0.5 ppbv H2SO4 and 2 ppbv HC1 at 100 mbar. Solid line: calculated from Eq.(2), see text. Dashed line: same as solid line, but assuming in addition 10 ppbv HN03 to be present. Open squares: measurements with HNOa [Elrod et al., 1995]. Filled squares: measurements without HNO3 [Elrod et al., 1995]. Filled triangles: without HNOa estimated from Hanson and Ravishankara [1994].
Figure 6 shows the measured reaction probabilities in comparison with theoretical curves (solid line: H2SO4/H20; dashed line: H2SO4/HNOz/H20) calculated from Eq.(2). The solubility of HC1 is calculated using the model vapor pressures given by Luo et al. [1995]. The liquid diffusion constant (Dr) is calculated from the cubic cell model [cp. Luo et al., 1994b]. The second-order rate coefficient (K zx) is calculated assuming the reaction to be diffusion limited, and the Henry's law constant of chlorine nitrate is estimated as H*aoso2 -- 103 mol 1-1atm -1 at 202 K and assuming - 6 kcal mo1-1 for the enthalpy of solvation [Hanson and Ravishankara, 1994]. The good agreement between the measurements and the theoretical estimate suggests that the temperature dependence of the reaction probability is governed by the solubility of HC1 in the liquid aerosol. Furthermore, it supports the suggestion by Hanson and Ravishankara that C1ON02 probably remains undissociated in the liquid, so that its interaction with the liquid involves mainly hydrogen bonding. At low temperatures chlorine activation can occur efficiently not only in binary and ternary solution droplets, but also on the surfaces of solid stratospheric particles. In Fig.6 the dotted curve shows the reaction probability for Eq.(1) on NAT [Hanson and Ravishankara, 1993]. Abbatt and Molina [1992] investigated the same reaction, but for higher HC1 concentrations. A crude extrapolation of their data to 2 x 10-r mbar HC1 shows that the corresponding 7 is more than one order of magnitude lower than the dotted line in Fig.6. There still appears to be a significant uncertainty in the solid phase reaction probabilities. In any case Fig.6 shows that the 7's on the droplets can be higher than those on solid NAT particles, as also pointed out by Ravishankara and Hanson [1996]. CONCLUSIONS The thermodynamics of stratospheric solution droplets have been extensively studied in the last three years. The thermodynamics of nitric acid trihydrate (HNOa.3H20), a major candidate expected to form PSCs, is well-established. There is some evidence that other hydrates of nitric acid could also play a role in the PSC formation mechanism, like HNOa.2H20, HNOa.bH20,
Formation mechanisms of polar stratospheric clouds
289
HNO3.10H20 or H2SO4.HNO3"5H20, but knowledge of the thermodynamics of these particles is still far from complete. Our understanding of the nucleation and kinetics of non-reactive gas uptake by solid and liquid particles is currently developed to different degrees. The growth kinetics of solid stratospheric particles have been investigated since the late eighties. Main uncertainties concern the following nucleation processes: freezing of the H~SO4/HNO3/H20 aerosol particles in the form of nitric or sulfuric acid hydrates, formation of nitric acid hydrates (NAT, NAD, etc.) on frozen H2SO4 surfaces, and nucleation of water ice on these hydrates. Also, once nucleated, it is at present uncertain whether ice particles grow as pure water ice or whether HNO3 may co-condense, possibly leading to the formation of protective coatings. To these uncertainties in the microphysis of PSCs add the uncertainties concerning the chemical reactivity of chlorine gases on liquid and solid surfaces. As a consequence, our understanding of PSC formation and chlorine processing in the Arctic winter stratosphere is incomplete. This limits our diagnostic and, in particular, our prognostic capabilities. Most urgent is a physico-chemical insitu analysis of PSC particles together with Lagrangian measurements along a complete life-cycle of the PSCs. Acknowledgements and notes: The author is indebted to Drs. Beiping Luo, Kenneth Carslaw and Thomas Koop for their scientific assistance in the preparation and to Ms Jennifer Carslaw for carefully reading the manuscript. Special thanks also to Ms Iris Bambach and Ms Gerhild Feyerherd of the MPI drawing office. This paper is a part of a review to be published in Solar System Ices (eds. M. Festou, C. de Bergh), in: Astrophysics and Space Science Library Series, Kluwer Acad. Publ., 1996. REFERENCES Arnold, F., Stratospheric aerosol increases and ozone destruction: Implications from mass spectrometer measurements, Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem., 96, 339-350, 1992. Abbatt, J.P.D., Molina, M.J., The heterogeneous reactions of HOCI+HC1 ~ C12+H20 on ice and nitric acid trihydrate: Reaction probabilities and stratospheric implications, Geophys. Res. Lett., 19, 461-464, 1992. Beyer, K.D., Seago, S.W., Chang, H.Y., Molina, M.J., Composition and freezing of aqueous H2SO4/HNO3 solutions under polar stratospheric conditions, Geophys. Res. Lett., 216, 871-874, 1994. Browell, E.V., Butler, C.F., Ismail, S., Robinette, P.A., Carter, A.F., Higdon, N.S., Toon, O.B., Schoebed, M.R., Tuck, A.F., Airborne Lidar observations in the wintertime Arctic stratosphere: Polar stratospheric clouds, Geophys. Res. Left., 17, 385-388, 1990. Carslaw, K.S., Luo, B.P., Clegg, S.L., Peter, Th., Brimblecombe, P., Crutzen, P.J., Stratopsheric aerosol growth and HNO3 gas phase depletion from coupled HNO3 and water uptake by liquid particles, Geophys. Res. LetL, 21, 2479-2482, 1994. Crutzen, P.J., Arnold, F., Nitric acid cloud formation in the cold Antarctic stratosphere: A major cause for the springtime "ozone hole", Nature, 32~, 651-655, 1986. Debye, P., Htickel, E., Zur Theorie der Elektrolyte. I. Gefrierpunktserniedrigung und verwandte Erscheinungen, Phys. Z., 24, 185-206, 1923. Deshler, T., Peter, Th., Mtiller, R., Crutzen, P.`I., The lifetime of leewave-induced ice particles in the Arctic stratopshere: I. Balloonborne observations, Geophys. Res. I,ett., 21, 1327-1330, 1994. Drdla, K., Turco, R.P., A one-dimensional model of Type-I and Type-II PSC formation with temperature oscillations, XV. General Assembly EGS, Copenhagen, 1990. Drdla, K., Turco, R.P., Denitrification through PSC formation: A 1-D model incorporating temperature oscillations, J. Atmos. Chem., 12, 319-366, 1991. Drdla, K., Tabazadeh, A., Turco, R.P., Jacobson, M.Z., Dye, ,I.E., Twohy, C., Baumgardner, D., Kelly, K.K., Chan, R.P., Loewenstein, M., Analysis of the physical state of one Arctic polar stratospheric cloud based of observations, Geophys. Res. I,ett., 21, 2473-2478, 1994.
290
Peter
Molina, M.J., Zhang, R., Wooldridge, P.J., McMahon, J.R., Kim, J.E., Chang, H.Y., Beyer, K.D., Physical chemistry of the H2SO4/HNO3/H20 system: Implications for polar stratospheric clouds, Science, 26i, 1418-1423, 1993. Ohtake, T., Freezing points of H2SO4 aqueous solutions and formation of polar stratospheric clouds, Tellus, 45B, 138-144, 1993. Panegrossi, G, Fua, A., Fiocco, G., A 1-D model of the formation and evolution of polar stratospheric clouds, d. Atmos. Chem., 23, 5-35, 1996. Peter, Th., Crutzen, P.J., The role of stratospheric cloud particles in polar ozone depletion - An overview, J. Aerosol Sci., 2~, Sl19-S120, 1993. Peter, Th., Mfiller, R., Drdla, K., Petzoldt, K., Reimer, E., A micro-physical box model for EASOE: Preliminary results for the January/February 1990 PSC event over Kiruna, Bet. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem., 96, 362-367, 1992. Peter, Th., Mfiller, R., Crutzen, P.J., Deshler, T., The lifetime of leewave-induced ice particles in the Arctic stratosphere: II. Stabilization due to NAT-coating, Geophys. Res. Lett., 21, 1331-1334, 1994. Pitzer, K.S., A thermodynamic model for aqueous solutions of liquid-like density, Reviews Minerology, I7, 97-142, 1987. Poole, L.R., McCormick, M.P., Polar stratospheric clouds and the Antarctic ozone hole, J. Geophys. Res., 93, 8423-8430, 1988. Poole, L.R., Pitts, M.C., Polar stratospheric cloud climatology based on Stratospheric Aerosol Measurement II observations from 1978-1989, J. Geophys. Res., 99, 13,083-13,089, 1994. Poole, L.R., Solomon, S., Gandrud, B.W., Powell, K.A., Dye, J.E., The polar stratospheric cloud event of January 24, 1989 Part 1. Microphysics, Geophys. Res. Lett., 17, 537-540, 1990. Ravishankara, A.R., Hanson, D.R., Differences in the reactivity of type-I polar stratospheric clouds depending on their phase, J. Geophys. Rex., 101, 3885-3890, 1996. Reihs, C.M., Golden, D.M., Tolbert, M.A., Nitric acid uptake by sulfuric acid solutions under stratospheric conditions: determination of Henry's law solubility, J. Geophys. Res., 95, 16545-16550, 1990. Schlager, H., Arnold, F., Hofmann, D., Deshler, T., Balloon observations of nitric acid aerosol formation in the Arctic stratosphere: I. Gaseous nitric acid, Geophys. Res. Lett., 17, 1275-1278, 1990. Solomon, S., Garcia, R.R., Rowland, F.S., Wuebbles, D.J., On the depletion of Antarctic ozone, Nature, 321, 755-758 , 1986. Song, N., Freezing temperatures of H2SO4/HNO3/H20 mixtures: Implications for polar stratospheric clouds, Geophys. Res. Lett., 21, 2709-2712, 1994. Tabazadeh, A., Turco, R.P., Drdla, K., Jacobson, M.Z., A study of Type I polar stratospheric cloud formation, Geophys. Res. Lett., 21, 1619-1622, 1994. Tabazadeh, A., Toon, O.B., Hamill, P., Freezing behavior of stratospheric sulfate aerosols inferred from trajectory studies, Geophys. Res. Lett., 22, 1725-1728, 1995. Tolbert, M.A., Koehler, B.G., Middlebrook, A.M., Spectroscopic studies of model polar stratospheric cloud films, Spectrochim. Acta, 48A, 1303-1313, 1992. Toon, O.B., Hamill, P., Turco, R.P., Pinto, J., Condensation of HNO3 and HC1 in the winter polar stratospheres, Geophys. Res. Lett., 13, 1284-1287, 1986. Toon, O.B., Turco, R..P., Jordan, J., Goodman, J., Ferry, G., Physical processes in polar stratospheric ice clouds, J. Geophys. Res., 94, 11,359-11,380, 1989. Toon, O.B., Browell, E.V., Kinne, S., Jordan, J., An analysis of Lidar observations of polar stratospheric clouds, Geophys. Res. Lett., 17, 393-396, 1990. Toon, O.B., Tolbert, M.A., Spectroscopic evidence against nitric acid trihydrate in polar stratospheric clouds, Nature, 375, 218-221, 1995. Volkert, H., Intes, D., Orographically forced stratospheric waves over northern Scandinavia, Geophys. Res. Lett., 19, 1205-1208, 1992. Wofsy, S.C., Salawitch, R..J., Yatteau, J.H., McElroy, M.B., Gandrud, B.W., Dye, J.E., Baumgardner, D., Condensation of HNOs on falling ice particles: Mechanism for denitrification of the polar stratosphere, Geophys. Res. Lett., 17, 449-452, 1990. Worsnop, D.R., Fox, L.E., Zahniser, M.S., Wofsy, S.C., Vapor pressures of solid hydrates of nitric acid: Implications for polar stratospheric clouds, Science, 259, 71-74, 1993.
Formation mechanisms of polar stratospheric clouds
291
Dye, J.E., Baumgardner, D., Gandrud, B.W., Kawa, S.R., Kelly, K.K., Loewenstein, M., Ferry, G.V., Chan, K.R., Gary, B.L., Particle size distributions in Arctic polar stratospheric clouds, growth and freezing of sulfuric acid droplets, and implications for cloud formation, J. Geophys. Res., 97, 8015-8034, 1992. Elrod, M.J., Koch, R.E., Kim, J.E., Molina, M.J., HCI vapour pressures and reaction probabilities for C1ONO2+HC1 on liquid H2SO4-HNO3-HCI-H20 solutions, Faraday Discuss., 100, in press, 1995. Fahey, D.W., Kelly K.K, Ferry G.V., Poole L.R., Wilson J.C., Murphy, D.M., Loewenstein, M., Chan K.R., In-situ measurements of total reactive nitrogen, total water, and aerosol in a polar stratospheric cloud in the Antactic, J. Geophys. Res., 94, 11299-11315, 1989. Fox, L.E., Worsnop, D.R., Zahniser, M.S., Wofsy, S.C., Metastable phases in polar stratospheric aerosols, Science, 267, 351-355, 1995. Ha, A., Cohen, I., Zhao, X., Lee, M., Kivelson, D., Supercooled liquids and polyamorphism, J. Phys. Chem., 100, 1-4, 1996. Hanson, D.R., The vapor pressures of supercooled HNO3/H20 solutions, Geophys. Res. Lett., 17, 421-423, 1990. Hanson, D., Mauersberger, K., Laboratory studies of the nitric acid trihydrate: Implications for the south polar stratosphere, Geophys. Res. Lett., 15, 855-858, 1988. Hanson, D.R., Ravishankara, A.R., Reaction of C1ONO2 with HCI on NAT, NAD, and frozen sulfuric acid and hydrolysis of N205 and C1ONO2 on frozen sulphuric acid, J. Geophys. Res., 98, 22,931-22,936, 1993. Hanson, D.R., Ravishankara, A.R., Reactive uptake of C1ONO2 onto sulfuric acid due to reaction with HC1 and H20, J. Phys. Chem., 98, 5728-5735, 1994. Hanson D.R., Ravishankara A.R., Solomon S., Heterogeneous reactions in sulfuric acid aerosols: A framework for model calculations, J. Geophys. Res., 99, 3615-3629, 1994. Hofmann, D.J., Deshler, T., Arnold, F., Schlager, H., Balloon observations of nitric acid aerosol formation in the Arctic stratosphere: II. aerosol, Geophys. Res. Lett., 17, 1279-1282, 1990. Iraci, L.T., Middlebrook, A.M., Wilson, M.A., Tolbert, M.A., Growth of nitric acid hydrates on thin sulfuric acid films, Geophys. Res. Lett., 21, 867-870, 1994. Ji, K., Petit, J-C., Identication par microcalorimetrie d'un nouvel hydrate de l'acide nitrique pouvant jouer un role dans la chimie heterogene stratospherique, C. R. Acad. Sci., 316, 1743-1748, 1993. Koop, T., Biermann, U.M., Raber, W., Luo, B.P., Crutzen, P.J., Peter, Th., Do stratospheric aerosol droplets freeze above the ice frost point?, Geophys. Res. Lett., 22, 917-920, 1995. Larsen, N., The impact of freezing of sulfate aerosols on the formation of polar stratospheric clouds, Geophys. Res. Lett., 21, 425-428, 1994. Larsen, N., Knudsen, B., Rosen, J.M., Kjome, N.T., BMloonborne backscatter observations of type 1 PSC formation: Inference about physical state from trajectory analysis, Geophys. Res. Lett., 23, 1996. Luo, B.P., Peter, Th., Crutzen, P., Freezing of stratospheric aerosol droplets, Geophys. Res. Lett., 21, 1447-1450, 1994a. Luo, B.P., Clegg, S.L., Peter, Th., M/iller, R., Crutzen, P.J., HCL solubility and liquid diffusion in aqueous sulfuric acid under stratospheric conditions, Geophys. Res. Lett., 21, 49-52, 1994b. Luo, B.P., Carslaw, K.S., Peter, TH., Clegg, S., Vapour pressures of H2SO4/HNO3/HC1/ HBr/H20 solutions to low stratospheric temperatures, Geophys. Res. Lett., 22, 247-250, 1995. MacKenzie A.R., Kulmala, M., Laaksonen, A., Vesala, T., n the formation of type 1 polar stratospheric cloud particles, Geophys. Res. Lett., 21, 1423-1426, 1994. Marti, J.J., Mauersberger, K., Evidence for nitric acid pentahydrate formed under stratospheric conditions, J. Phys. Chem., 98, 6897-6899, 1994. Meilinger, S., Koop, T., Luo, B.P., Huthwelker, Th., Carslaw, K.S., Krieger, U., Crutzen, P.J., Peter, Th., Size-dependent Stratospheric Droplet Composition in Mesoscale Temperature Fluctuations and their Potential Role in PSC Freezing, Geophys. Res. Lett., 22, 3031-3034, 1995. Middlebrook, A.M., Iraci, L.T., McNeill, L.S., Koehler, B.G., Wilson, M.A., Saastad, O.W., Tolbert, M.A., Fourier transform-infrared studies of thin H2SO4/H20 films: Formation, water uptake, and solid-liquid phase changes, J. Geophys. Res., 98, 20,473-20,481, 1993.
AEROSOL PRODUCTION CAUSED BY CIVIL AIR TRAFFIC: AN OVERVIEW OF NEAR-FIELD INTERACTIONS B. I(,;~RCHER AND B.P. LUO Universitit Miinchen, Hohenbachernstr. 22, D-85354 Freising, Germany
A