Methods of Expe rim en taI Physics VOLUME 5
NUCLEAR PHYSICS PART A
METHODS OF
EXPERIMENTAL PHYSICS: L. Marton, Edit...
98 downloads
1992 Views
10MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Methods of Expe rim en taI Physics VOLUME 5
NUCLEAR PHYSICS PART A
METHODS OF
EXPERIMENTAL PHYSICS: L. Marton, Editor-in-Chief Claire Marton, Assistant Editor
1. Classical Methods, 1959 Edited by lmmanuel Estermann
2. Electronic Methods Edited by E. Bleuler and R. 0. Haxby 3. Molecular Physics Edited by Dudley Williams
4. Atomic and Electron Physics Edited by Vernon W. Hughes and Howard L. Schultz 5. Nuclear Physics (in two parts), 1961 Edited by Luke C. L. Yuan and Chien-Shiung Wu 6. Solid State Physics (in two parts), 1959 Edited by K. Lark-Horovitz and Vivian A. Johnson
Volume 5
Nuclear Physics Edited by
LUKE C. L. YUAN Brookhaven National laborafory Upton, New York
CHIEN-SHIUNG WU Columbia University New York, New York
PART A
1961
ACADEMIC PRESS
@
New York and London
Copyright @ 1961, by
ACADEMIC PRESS INC. ALL RIQHTS RESERVED NO PART OF THIS BOOK MAY BE REPRODUCED IN ANY FORM BY PHOTOSTATl MICROFILM, OR ANY OTHER MEANS, WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHERS
ACADEMIC PRESS INC. 111 FIFTH AVENUE NEWYORK3, N. Y.
United Kingdm Edition Published by ACADEMIC PRESS INC. (LONDON)LTD. 17 OLD QUEEN STREET, LONDONS.W. 1
Library of Congress Catalog Card Number 61-17860 PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 5, PART A D. E. ALBURGER, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, N e w York M. BLAU,Institut fur Radiumforschung, Vienna, Austria J. E. BROLLEY, JR.,Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico B. CORK,Lawrence Radiation Laboratory, University of California, Berkeley, California J. W. M. DUMOND,Department of Physics, California Institute of Technology Pasadena, California
R. D. EVANS,Department of Physics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts
H. FRAUENFELDER, Department of Physics, University of Illinois, Urbana, Illinois W. B. FRETTER, Department of Physics, University of California, Berkeley, California S. S . FRIEDLAND, Solid Xtate Radiations, fnc., Culver City, California
T. R. GERHOLM, Institute of Physics, University of Uppsala, Uppsala, Sweden W. W. HAVENS,Pupin Physics Laboratory, Columbia University, New York, New York R. HOFSTADTER, Physics Department, Stanford University, Standford, California D. J. HUGHES, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, N e w York* S. J. LINDENBAUM, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, New York G. C. MORRISON, Atomic Energy Establishment, Harwell, Berkshire, England G. D. O'KELLEY,Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, Tennessee F. REINES,Department of Physics, Case Institute of Technology, Cleveland, Ohio G. T. REYNOLDS, Princeton University, Princeton, New Jersey A. SILVERMAN, Department of Physics, Cornell University, Ithaca
*
Deceased. V
vi
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME
5,
PART A
R. M. STERNHEIMER, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, New York R. W. WILLIAMS,Department of Physics, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington
L. C. L. YUAN,Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, New York F. P. ZIEMBA, Solid State Radiations, Inc., Culver City, California
FOREWORD TO VOLUME 5A After a longer delay than originally expected, I a m able to present here the next volume in the series of Methods of Experimental Physics: the first part of the “Nuclear Physics” Methods. Much thought .and work went into this volume and I am in the best position to appreciate all the effort of my fellow editors who devoted so much time in preparing this particular volume. The aims of the publication did not change. The reception of the earlier volumes had proven th a t it was really useful to concentrate on “a concise, well illustrated presentation of the most important methods, or general principles, needed by the experimenter, complete with basic references for further reading. Indication of limitations of both applicability and accuracy is a n important part of the presentation. Information about the interpretation of experiments, about the evaluation of errors, and about the validity of approximations should also be given. The book should not be merely a description of laboratory techniques, nor should i t be a catalog of instruments.” I n these troubled times, when furthering of scientific education is so important, we hope th a t these volumes can be of real help as well to the educator, as to the research worker. At the time of writing my foreword, two other volumes are well under way. The manuscripts of the companion volume of the present one, Volume 5B, are accumulating rapidly and printing should follow this one within a few months. In an even more advanced stage is our Volume 3, “Molecular Physics,” which, under the very valuable leadership of Professor Dudley Williams, promises to become a perfect companion t o the already existing volumes. At the writing of this foreword, Volume 3 is just entering the page-proof stage. I would like to report also on further development. It has been suggested that, in order to enhance the usefulness of this collection to the graduate student, we supplement the planned six volumes with a seventh devoted to nothing but problems. I n discussing this idea with a number of my colleagues I found favorable reaction and a t present I a m investigating how t o organize such a volume. It is a pleasant duty to thank again all those who have devoted SO much time and work to the preparation of this volume. I n the first place come the volume editors whose intelligent and devoted handling of the material is beyond praise. One shouldn’t, however, forget the authors. They have been most accommodating and I join the volume editors in expressing my appreciation. The publishers deserve our gratitude for
vii
viii
FOREWORD TO VOLUME
5A
being very patient and very helpful during this longer delay than we expected. As in the past, Mrs. Claire Marton has been most helpful in handling many of the problems of the editorial office. To all these people go my heartfelt thanks. L. MARTON Washington, D. C. June, 19fl
PREFACE TO VOLUME 5A The field of experimental nuclear physics has in the last two decades, experienced a tremendous growth of activity in all its branches. The difficulty in performing nuclear physics experiments is also greatly multiplied with the increasing complexities of the problems involved. There are, at present, many articles and books which give excellent reviews on basic principles and details of techniques of various detectors, methods and specific topics in nuclear physics. But it is often hard to obtain comprehensive information on the principal methods and their relative merits for the measurement of a specific physical quantity in the field of nuclear physics. This knowledge is especially desirable when one wishes to make a choice among the various methods on the basis of their feasibility, the accuracies attainable, and the limitations in their application under specific conditions. For any specific method of measurement, the comprehensive procedure of converting the experimental data into the desired physical quantities including the necessary corrections involved is often not explicitly mentioned in the literature. It is the intention of the present volume to try to meet some of the requirements mentioned above. All possible methods that deal with the measurement of each particular physical quantity are grouped together so as to achieve a more coherent presentation. Furthermore, the scope of this book is not limited to the usual treatment of low energy nuclear physics only, but it comprises both the high and low energy regions. We hope that this volume will serve as an informative source and as a reference book for physicists in general and, in particular, as an instructive and useful guide for all those who are interested in doing research in this field. Every effort has been made to obtain leading experts in each field to prepare contributions on the specific topics involved so that their intimate knowledge and experience can be shared. Owing to the comprehensive coverage of this book and to the enthusiastic response of a large number of contributors who treated their subject matter so thoroughly, it was found necessary to divide the work into two volumes rather than to publish a single volume a8 originally planned. For this reason and because an unusually large number of contributors have been involved, there has been some unavoidable delay in the completion of this book. ix
X
PREFACE TO VOLUME 5 A
We wish to take this opportunity to express our deepest appreciation and thanks to all the contributors for their understanding and cooperation, to the publisher and to Dr. L. Marton, the Editor-in-Chiefl for their invaluable help and continuous encouragement. CHIEN-SHIUNG Wu Columbia University LUKEC. L. YUAN Brookhaven National Laboratory August 14, 1961
CONTENTS, VOLUME 5, PART A CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 5, PART A. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
v
FOREWORD TO VOLUME 5A . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . vii PREFACE TO VOLUME 5A . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 5, PARTB. . . . . CONTENTS, VOLUME 5, PART B. . . . . . . .
ix
. . . . . . . . . xv . . . . . . xvii ,
.
1. Fundamental Principles and Methods of Particle Detection 1.1. Interaction of Radiation with Matter . . . . . . . by R. M. STERNHEIMER 1.1.1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.1.2. The Ionization Loss d E / d x of Charged Particles 1.1.3. Range-Energy Relations . . . . . . . . . . 1.1.4. Scattering of Heavy Particles by Atoms . . . 1.1.5. Passage of Electrons through Matter. . . . . 1.1.6. Multiple Scattering of Charged Particles . . . 1.1.7. Penetration of Gamma Rays . . . . . . . .
.
.
. . . . .
. . . .
. . .
. .
1.2. Ionization Chambers. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . by ROBERTW. WILLIAMS 1.2.1. General Considerations. . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2.2. Pulse Formation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2.3. Quantitative Operation and Some Practical Considerations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2.4. Amount of Ionization Liberated. . . . . . . . . 1.2.5. Noise: Practical Limit of Energy Loss Measurable. 1.2.6. Some Types of Pulse Ionization Chambers . . . . 1.2.7. Current Ionization Chambers and Integrating Chambers. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1 1
4 44 55 56 73 76 89 89 95 100 103 105 107 109
1.3. Gas-Filled Counters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 110 by ROBERTW. WILLIAMS 1.3.1. Gas Multiplication; Proportional Counters . . . . 110 1.3.2. Geiger Counters and Other Breakdown Counters . 118 1.4. Scintillation Counters and Luminescent Chambers . . . 120 by GEORGET. REYNOLDS and F. REINES 1.4.1. Scintillation Counters. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 120 1.4.2. Solid Luminescent Chambers . . . . . . . . . . 159
xi
xii
CONTENTS. VOLUME
5.
PART A
1.5. cerenkov Counters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . and LUKEC. L. YUAN by S. J . LINDENBAUM 1.5.1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.5.2. Focusing cerenkov Counters . . . . . . . . . . 1.5.3. Nonfocusing Counters . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.5.4. Total Shower Absorption Cerenkov Counters for Photons and Electrons . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.5.5. Other Applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
162 162 168 186 189 191
1.6. Cloud Chambers and Bubble Chambers . . . . . . . . . 194 by W . B. FRETTER 1.6.1. Cloud Chambers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 194 1.6.2. Bubble Chambers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 203 1.7. Photographic Emulsions . . . . . . . . . . by M . BLAU 1.7.1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.7.2. Sensitivity of Nuclear Emulsions . . . . 1.7.3. Processing of Nuclear Emulsions . . . . 1.7.4. Optical Equipment and Microscopes . . 1.7.5. Range of Particles in Nuclear Emulsions 1.7.6. Ionization Measurements in Emulsions . 1.7.7. Ionization Parameters . . . . . . . . 1.7.8. Photoelectric Method . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . 208
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. 208 . 210 . 216 . 224 . 226 . 240 . 245 . 264
1.8. Special Detectors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 265 1.8.1. The Semiconductor Detector . . . . . . . . . . 265 by S. S. FRIEDLAND and F. P. ZIEMBA 1.8.2. Spark Chambers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 281 by BRUCECORK
.
2 Methods for the Determination of Fundamental Physical Quantities
2.1. Determination of Charge and Size . . . . . . . 2.1.1. Charge of Atomic Nuclei and Particles . . . 2.1.1.1. Rutherford Scattering . . . . . . . . 2.1.1.2. Characteristic X-ray Spectra . . . . . . by ROBLEY D. EVANS 2.1.1.3. Charge Determination of Particles in graphic Emulsions . . . . . . . . . by M . BLAU
. . . . 289
. . . .
289
. . . . 289
. . . . 293 Photo-
. . . . 298
CONTENTS, VOLUME
5,
PART A
...
XI11
2.1.2. Principal Methods of Measuring Nuclear Size. . . 307 by ROBERTHOFSTADTER 2.2. Determination of Momentum and Energy . . . . . . . 341 2.2.1. Charged Particles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 341 2.2.1.1. Measurement of Momentum. Electric and Magnetic Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 341 by T. R. GERHOLM 2.2.1.1.4. Measurement of Momentum with Cloud Chambers or Bubble Chambers . . . . . . . . . 375 by W. B. FRETTER 2.2.1.1.5. Momentum Measurement in Nuclear Emulsions 388 by M. BLAU 2.2.1.2. Determination of Energy . . . . . . . . . . . 409 2.2.1.2.1. Energy Measurement with Ionization Chambers 409 by R. W. WILLIAMS 2.2.1.2.2. Scintillation Spectrometry of Charged Particles 41 1 by G. D. O’KELLEY 2.2.1.2.3. Measurement of Range and Energy with Cloud Chambers and Bubble Chambers. . . . . . 436 by W. B. FRETTER 2.2.1.3. Determination of Velocity . . . . . . . . . . 438 2.2.1.3.1. Time-of-Flight Method . . . . . . . . . . . 438 by LUKEC. L. YUANand S. J. LINDENBAUM 2.2.1.3.2. Measurement of Velocity . . . . . . . . . . 444 by W. B. FRETTER 2.2.1.3.3. Measurement of Velocity Using cerenkov Counters. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 454 by LUKEC. L. YUANand S. J. LINDENBAUM 2.2.2. Neutrons. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 461 2.2.2.1. Recoil Techniques for the Measurement of Neutron Flux, Energy, Linear and Spin Angular Momentum . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 461 E. BROLLEY, JR. by JOHN 2.2.2.2. Time- of-Flight Method . . . . . . . . . . . . 495 by W. W. HAVENS, JR. 2.2.2.3. Crystal Diffraction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 566 by D. J. HUGHES
xiv
CONTENTS, VOLUME
5,
PART A
2.2.2.4. Determination of Momentum and Energy of Neutrons with He3 Neutron Spectrometer. . . . . 570 by G. C. MORRISON 2.2.3. Gamma-Rays . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 582 2.2.3.1. Internal and External Conversion Lines . . . . 582 by T. R. GERHOLM 2.2.3.2. Determination of Momentum and Energy of Gamma Rays with the Curved Crystal Spectrometer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 599 by J. W. M. DUMOND 2.2.3.3. Gamma-Ray Scintillation Spectrometry . . . . . 616 by G. D. O’KELLEY 2.2.3.4. Determination of the Momentum and Energy of Gamma Rays with Pair Spectrometers . . . . . 641 by D. E. ALBURGER 2.2.3.5. Shower Detectors. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 652 by R. HOFSTADTER 2.2.3.6. Gamma-Ray Telescopes. . . . . . . . . . . . 668 by A. SILVERMAN 2.2.3.7. Measurement of y-Ray Energy by Absorption. . 671 by ROBLEYD. ZVANS 2.2.3.8. Detection and Measurement of Gamma Rays in Photographic Emulsions. . . . . . . . . . . 676 by M. BLAU 2.2.4. Neutrino . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 682 2.2.4.1. Neutrino Reactions. . . . . . . . . . . . 682 by F. REINES
AUTHORINDEX . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
699
SUBJECTINDEX . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
718
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 5, PART B E. AMBLER,Low Temperature Section, National Bureau of Standards, Washington, D.C. F. AJZENBERO-SELOVE, Department of Physics, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania M. BLAU,Institut fur Radiumforschung, Vienna, Austria M. H. BLEWETT, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, New Yorlc 0. CHAMBERLAIN, Department of Physics, University of California, Berkeley, California B. CORK,Lawrence Radiation Laboratory, University of California, Berkeley, California H. DANIEL, M a x Planck Institute for Nuclear Physics, Heidelberg, Germany M. DEUTSCH, Department of Physics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts H. E. DUCKWORTH, Department of Physics, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada R. D. EVANS,Department of Physics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts G. FEHER,Department of Solid State Physics, University of California, L a Jotla, California H. FRAUENFELDER, Department of Physics, University of Illinois, Urbana, Illinois W. B. FRETTER, Department of Physics, University of California, Berkeley, California W. GENTNER,M a x Planck Institute for Nuclear Physics, Heidelberg, Germany S. GESCHWIND, Bell Laboratories, Murray Hill, New Jersey J. G. HIRSCHBERG, Project Matterhorn, Princeton University, Princeton, New Jersey J. C. HUBBS,E-H Research Laboratories, Inc., Oakland, California C. D. JEFFRIES, Department of Physics, University of California, Berkeley, California J. K. JEN, Applied Physics Laboratory, The Johns Hopkins University, Silver Spring, Maryland H. W. KOCH,Betatron Laboratories, National Bureau of Standards, Washington, D. C. xv
xvi
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME
5,
PART B
H. KOUTS,Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, N e w York D. W. MILLER,Department of Physics, Indiana University, Bloomington, Indiana W. A. NIERENBERG, Department of Physics, University of California, Berkeley, California G. D. O’KELLEY, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, Tennessee L. ROSEN,Department of Physics, Los Alamos Laboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico R. M. STERNHEIMER, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, New York A. N. WAPSTRA,Institute voor Kernphysisch Onderzoek, Amsterdam, Holland W. WHALING, Department of Physics, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, California
CONTENTS, VOLUME 5, PART B 2.3. Determination of Mass of Nuclei and of Individual Particles 2.3.1. Mass Spectroscopy by H. E. DUCKWORTH 2.3.2. Nuclear Disintegration Energies and Reaction Values by W. WHALING 2.3.3. Microwave Method by S. GESCHWIND 2.3.4. Cloud Chambers by W. B. FRETTER 2.3.5. Photographic Emulsions by M. BLAU 2.4. Determination of Spin, Parity and Nuclear Moments 2.4.1. Spectroscopic Methods 2.4.1.1. Optical and Ultra-Violet Spectroscopy by J. G. HIRSCHBERG 2.4.1.2. Atomic Beam by W. NIERENBERG and J. C. HUBBS 2.4.1.3. MICROWAVE METHOD by J. K. JEN 2.4.1.4. Nuclear Magnetic and Quadrupole Resonances by C. D. JEFFRIES and G. FEHER 2.4.2. Indirect Methods 2.4.2.1. Angular Correlation by H. FRAUENFELDER 2.4.2.2. Conversion Coefficients by A. N. WAPSTRA 2.4.2.3. Oriented Nuclei by E. AMBLER 2.5. Determination of Polarization of Electrons and Circular Polarized Photons by H. FRAUENFELDER
xvii
xviii
CONTENTS, VOLUME
5,
PART B
2.6. Determination of Life-Time 2.6.1. Long Life-Time by W. GENTNER and H. DANIEL 2.6.2. Short Life-Time by M. DEUTSCH 2.7. Determination of Nuclear Reactions 2.7.1.Determination of the Q-Value for Nuclear Reactions 2.7.2.Determination of Nuclear Energy Levels from Reaction Energies by F. AJZENBERG-SELOVE 2.7.3.Total Interaction Cross Sections 2.7.4. Differential Interaction Cross Sections 2.7.5.Elastic Cross Sections 2.7.6.Inelastic Cross"Sections 2.7.7.Nuclear Production Cross Sections by L. ROSENand D. W. MILLER 2.8. Determination of Flux Densities 2.8.1.Flux of Charged Particles by 0. CHAMBERLAIN 2.8.2.Flux of Photons by €1. W. KOCH 3. Sources of Nuclear Particles and Radiations
3.1. Natural Sources-Radioactivity by G. D. O'KELLEY
3.2. Artificial Sources 3.2.1.Low Energy Sources 3.2.1,l.Cascade Transformer 3.2.1.2.Van de Graaff by H. BLEWETT 3.2.1.3.Nuclear Reactor 3.2.1.4.Neutron Sources by H. KOUTS 3.2.2.Medium and High Energy Sources 3.2.2.1. Linear Accelerator 3.2.2.2.Cyclotron 3.2.2.3.Betatron
CONTENTS, VOLUME
5,
PART B
3.2.2.4. Synchrotron 3.2.2.5. Synchrocyclotron 3.2.2.6. Proton Synchrotron 3.2.2.7. Alternate Gradient Synchrotron 3.2.2.8. Fixed Field Alternate Gradient Synchrotron by H. BLEWETT
4. Beam Transport System by R. STERNHEIMER and B. CORK 5. Statistics by R. C’ VANS Appendix 1. System of Units 2. Kinematics by R. STERNHEIMER
AUTHORINDEX
SUBJECTINDEX
xix
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
1. FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES AND METHODS OF PARTICLE DETECTION
1 .l. Interaction of Radiation with Matter*
7
1.1 .l. Introduction In this chapter, we shall discuss the various processes which take place when charged particles and y radiation pass through matter. For any type of charged particle (proton, meson, electron, etc.), there will be a loss of energy as the particle traverses the material, due to the excitation and ionization of the atoms of the medium close to the path of the particle. The loss of energy per cm of path, dE/dx, is generally referred to as the ionization loss. In Section 1.1.2, we give a simplified derivation of the theoretical expression for dE/dx, the well-known Bethe-Bloch formula, including a discussion of the density effect which becomes important at high energies. The ionization loss of a fast charged particle is frequently used as a means of identifying the particle, by observing its track in a cloud chamber, bubbIe chamber, or in photographic emulsion. The ionization loss dE/dx is a function onIy of the veIocity v of the particle (for a given charge), so that a simultaneous measurement of dE/dx and of the momentum p enables one to determine the mass m of the particle. The ionization loss can also be used to determine approximately the energy of the particle, if its identity has been established by other methods. A further important property of the ionization process is that the energy w required to form an ion pair in a gas is approximately independent of the energy and the charge of the incident particle, so that when a particle is stopped in a gas, a measurement of the total number of ion pairs enables one to obtain the energy of the incident particle, provided that the value of w for the stopping gas is known. This property has been widely used in the operation of ionization chambers. 1 In Section 1.1.2, expressions for dE/dx are given for various cases, together with a discussion of the fluctuations of the ionization loss (Landau effect). The recent experiments on the ionization loss of relativistic charged particles will be discussed in some detail. For particles heavier than electrons (e.g., protons, K , T , or p mesons), the ionization loss dE/dx is the most important mechanism of energy loss. As a result, a particle with a given incident kinetic energy T will have a quite well-defined range R, which depends on T, on the mass m and on the
t See also, Vol. 4, B, Parts 6, 7,and 8.
1See also this volume, Chapter
1.2.
* Chapter 1.1 is by R. M. Sternheimer. 1
2
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
charge z of the particle, as well as on the stopping substance. The relation between R and T is known as the range-energy relation. Tables of the range-energy relation for protons of energies T , = 2 Mev to 100 Bev have been recently calculated by Sternheimer for the following materials : Be, C, All Cu, Pb, and air. These range-energy relations differ from the results of Aron et a1.2 in two respects: (1) the density effect correction is included a t the higher energies ( T , 2 2 Bev); (2) recent values of the mean excitation potential I (which enters into the Bethe-Bloch formula) have been used, which are somewhat higher than the value I = 11.52 ev employed by Aron et al. The tables of the range-energy reIations are given in Section 1.1.3, together with a table of the values of dE/dx which were used in the calculation of R ( T ) . Section 1.1.3 also includes a brief discussion of the range straggling. Section 1.1.4 gives various formulas pertaining to the scattering of heavy particles (heavier than electrons) by atoms. When electrons pass through matter, they lose energy by ionization in the same manner as any charged particle (see Section 1.1.2). However, in addition, a high-energy electron will produce electromagnetic radiation (bremsstrahlung) in the field of the atomic nuclei.* For electrons above the critical energy E , (e.g., 47 Mev for All 6.9 Mev for Pb), the energy loss due to radiation exceeds the ionization loss, and constitutes the predominant mechanism for the slowing down process. The y quanta from the bremsstrahlung can create electron-positron pairs, which in tu r n can produce additional y rays. The resulting electromagnetic cascade is called a shower and has been widely observed in cloud-chamber pictures both with incident electrons and y rays. Th e theoretical expressions for the bremsstrahlung and a discussion of shower production are presented in Section 1.1.5. The multiple scattering of charged particles is considered briefly in Section 1.1.6. The penetration of y rays through matter is characterized by a n absorption coefficient r which determines the exponential attenuation of the y ray beam. The processes which contribute to r are the photoelectric effect, the Compton scattering, and the pair production. A summary of the theoretical expressions for these three processes is given in Section 1.1.7. The discussion of Sections 1.1.4-1.1.7 follows closely the review article
* See also Vol. 4 , A, Section
1.5.2. R. M. Sternheimer, Phys. Rev. 116, 137 (1959). 2 W. A. Aron, B. G. Hoffman, and F. C. Williams, University of California Radiation Laboratory Report UCRL-121 (1 951); Atomic Energy Commission Report AECU-663 1
(1951).
1.1.
INTERACTION O F RADIATION W I T H MATTER
3
by Bethe and Ashkin3 on the “Passage of Radiations through Matter.” I n 1956, in order to solve certain difficulties connected with the decay of the strange particles (particularly the K meson), Lee and Yang4 discussed the consequences of a possible nonconservation of parity in the weak interactions (beta decay, strange particle decay, a- and p-meson decay). They suggested a number of experiments to test this hypothesis. These experimentss7 were performed soon after the publication of their paper, and have shown very clearly that parity is not conserved in the weak (decay) interactions, in contrast to the strong interactions which conserve parity to a high accuracy. An important consequence of parity nonconservation is th at the electrons (or positrons) from the beta decay of unpolarized nuclei should be strongly longitudinally polarized, i.e., the electron spin should be aligned predominantly antiparallel to the electron direction of motion, while for positron decays, the positron spin should be aligned predominantly parallel to the positron direction of motion. The magnitude of the polarization P is predicted to be v/c in each case, where v is the velocity of the particle (electron or positron). Thus for relativistic electrons or positrons, P should be essentially 100%. It should be noted that the prediction that P = v / c follows only from a particularly simple theory of parity nonconservation, namely the two-component theory of the neutrino. I n a separate article,*we have given a discussion of the proposals of Lee and Yang4 concerning parity nonconservation in weak interactions. This article also contains a description of the crucial experiments of Wu et d 6on the beta decay of oriented nuclei (Co60), and of Garwin and co-workersO on the polarization of the p+ from a+ decay, which together with the work of Friedman and Telegdi,7 were the first experiments that demonstrated the violation of parity conservation in weak interactions. We have also summarized*the two-component theory of the neutrino, which was proposed independently by Lee and Yang,g Landau,lo and Salam.” A large number of experiments have been performed to establish the longitudinal polarization of the electrons and positrons from beta decay. 3 H. A. Bethe and J. Ashkin, Passage of radiations through matter. In “Experimental Nuclear Physics” (E. SegrB, ed.), Vol. 1, p. 166. Wiley, New York, 1953. 4 T. D. Lee and C . N. Yang, Phys. Rev. 104, 254 (1956). 6 C. S. Wu, E. Ambler, R. W. Hayward, D. D. Hoppes, and R. P. Hudson, Phys. Rev. 106, 1413 (1957). 6 R. L. Garwin, L. M. Lederman, and M. Weinrich, P h p . Rev. 106, 1415 (1957). 7 J. I. Friedman and V. L. Telegdi, Phys. Rev. 106, 1681 (1957). 8 R. M. Sternheimer, Advances in Electronics and Electron Phys. 11, 31 (1959). 9 T. D. Lee and C . N. Yang, Phys. Rev. 106, 1671 (1957). 10 L. D. Landau, Nuclear Phys. 8, 127 (1957). 11 A. Salam, Nuovo n’mento 1 101 6,299 (1957).
4
1. PARTICLE
DETECTION
These investigations involve a variety of methods to determine the longitudinal polarization : scattering of the polarized electrons on nuclei (Mott scattering) ; scattering on polarized electrons (ferromagnetic 3d electrons of iron in a magnetic field), which is often referred to as Mdler scattering; circular polarization of the bremsstrahlung emitted by the polarized electrons; and annihilation of the polarized positrons in various materials. The experiments have in turn led to important developments of the theories presented in Sections 1.1.4 and 1.1.5 on the scattering and interaction of electrons in matter. These new theoretical results, as well as a review of the experiments on the longitudinal polarization, are presented in the latter part of the article on parity nonconservation." 1.1.2. The Ionization Loss dE/dx of Charged Particles 1.1.2.1. The Bethe-Bloch Formula. The theoretical expression for dE/dx is based on the Bethe-Bloch formula, which has been derived from the work of Bohr,12Bethe,13 Bloch,I4 and others. The Bethe-Bloch formula for particles heavier than electrons is given by
dx
-2p-6-
u
]
(1.1.1)
where n = number of electrons per cma in the stopping substance, m = electron mass, p = v/c, where v = velocity of the particle, z = charge of the particle, I = mean excitation potential of the atoms of the substance, Wmsx= maximum energy transfer from the incident particle to the atomic electrons, 6 is the correction for the density effect, which is due to the polarization of the medium, as will be discussed below, and U is a term due to the nonparticipation of the inner shells ( K ,L, .) for very low velocities of the incident particle. This term is generally called the shell correction term, and will be discussed below [see Eq. (1.1.34)l. The maximum energy transfer W,, is given by
..
Wmsx= 2mv2/(1 - p 2 )
( I .1.2)
for energies E << (mi2/2m)c2, where mi is the mass of the incident particle. Throughout this chapter, m (without subscript) denotes the mass of the electron. The Bethe-Bloch formula (1.1.1) is obtained in the following manner. The eIectromagnetic field of the passing particle will excite the
* Other aspects of electron polarization are discussed in Vol. IV, A, Chapter 3 5; this volume, Chapter 2.5. l2 N. Bohr, Phil. Mag. [6] 26, 10 (1913); [6] SO, 581 (1915). l a H. A. Bethe, Ann. Physik [7] 6, 325 (1930). l4 F. Bloch, 2.Physik 81, 363 (1933).
1.1.
5
INTERACTION O F RADIATION WITH MATTER
atomic electrons from their initial ground state to higher excited states, either discrete states or states in the continuum corresponding to ionization. For close collisions, with small values of the impact parameter b ( b 10-8 cm), tho at,omic electrons can he considered as free, i.e., the atomic binding forces are negligible compared to the field of the passing particle during the collision. Small values of b are associated with large energy transfers W . (W = l/b2.) The following approximate derivation of Eq. (1.1.1) follows closely that given by Fermi.16 The atomic electron is assumed to be essentially a t rest before the collision, i.e., its velocity veI is assumed to be small compared t o the velocity v of the incident particle. The impulse I* given t o the electron in the direction perpendicular to the path of th e passing particle is given by
-
(1.1.3) where F , is the perpendicular component of the force acting on the atomic electron. The factor (ze2/b2)in Eq. (1.1.3) gives the order of magnitude of FI,while the factor ( b / v ) is of the order of the collision time. An exact calculation shows th at II is actuaIly equal to 2ze2/bv. The longitudinal part of the impulse, Ill, is zero. I , is equal t o the momentum pel acquired by the electron. The corresponding energy acquired (which is lost by the passing partide) is given b y (1.1.4) The number of electrons per cm of path in the range of impact parameters db is 2 m b db. Hence the energy loss per cm t o electrons in from b t o b the range (b, b db) is
+
+
-dE(b)
$):(
=
-~
(27rnb db) =
4nnz2e4db -. mu2 b ~
( 1.1.5)
The complete rate of energy loss d E / d x is obtained by integrating Ey. (1.1.5) between the limits bmin and b,,,, which are the minimum and maximum values of b for which the above treatment of the energy transfer to the atomic electrons is valid. Approximate values of bmin and bmsxwill be obtained below. One thus finds - - d=E-
dx
l6
4?mz2e4 mv2
bmsx In -* bmin
(1.1.6)
E. Fermi, “Nuclear Physics,’’ p. 27. Univ. of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1950.
6
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
The upper limit b, arises from the fact that if the time of collision T is large compared to the period of revolution of the atomic electrons in their respective Bohr orbits, the passing particle does not lose any appreciable energy to the electrons, since the perturbation of the electron motion is then essentially an adiabatic process. I n the nonrelativistic region, the time of collision r is -b/v. At relativistic energies, the region of space in which the perpendicular component El of the electric field (and hence the impulse I J is large, is contracted by a factor (1 - p2)-1'2where p = v/c. Hence the time T during which a particular electron experiences the field El is also decreased by the factor (1 - p2)-lI2, so th a t we have 7
N
(b/v)(l -
p2)liZ.
(1.1.7)
If denotes the mean frequency of excitation of the electrons, b,, is determined by (1.1.8) 1/Y g (brn"JV)(1 - p 2 ) l i z whence (1.1.Y) b,,, g ( v / F ) ( l - p - 1 ' 2 . The lower limit bminarises from the limitation of the classical treatment presented above. Thus if the de Broglie wavelength X is larger than the impact parameter b, the above classical considerations will lose validity. I n this connection, X must be taken as the wavelength of the atomic electron in the center-of-mass system, which approximately coincides with the rest system of the incident particle (for particles heavier than electrons). Since we assume that vel <
=
h(l - P2)1/2/(mv)
( 1.1.10)
where h is Planck's constant h divided by 2 ~Upon . inserting Eqs. (1.1.9) and (1.1.10) into Eq. (1.1.6), one finds (1.1.11)
I n the logarithm of Eq. ( l . l . l l ) , f i Y is 1 / ( 2 ~ times ) the mean excitation potential of the atom (denoted previously by I ) . Thus the argument of the logarithm is 27rmv2/[1(1 - p2)]. Actually, an accurate treatment of the limits b,,, and bmi, gives
- _dE _ _-_4?mx2e4 _ In -. dx
mu2
2mv2 1(1 - p2)
( 1.1.12)
Equation (1.1.12) is ident,ical with the Bethe-Bloch formula ( l . l . l ) ,
1.1.
INTERACTION O F RADIATION WITH MATTER
7
except for the relativistic term -2p2 and the terms due to the density effect and the shell corrections ( - 6 - U ) in the square bracket of (1.1.1). The equivalence of the logarithms of Eqs. (1.1.1) and (1.1.12) can be easily verified by substituting Eq. (1.1.2) for W,,, in Eq. (1.1.1). 1.1.2.2. Dependence of the Ionization Loss on the Particle Velocity. The Density Effect. We will now discuss the genera1 behavior of Eq. (1.1.1) for dE/dx as a function of the particle velocity u. At low energies, -dE/dx decreases rapidly with increasing v. This decrease is essentially due to the fact that with increasing u , the collision times 7 decreases, resulting in a decrease of the excitation of the atomic electrons. The momentum transfer pel is proportional to 7 or to l / v . The resulting energy transfer equals p$/2m, and is therefore proportional to 1/u2, as is seen from Eq. (1.1.1). I n the relativistic region (v = c), the factor 1/v2 becomes nearly constant, and the velocity dependence is mainly determined by the behavior of the square bracket of Eq. (1.1.1). In view of Eq. (1,1.2), the logarithm of (1.1.1) can be written
L
=
2
111
2mv2 1(1 - p")'
(1.1.13)
The denominator (1 - p2) results in a logarithmic increase of dE/dx with increasing energy, which is called the relativistic rise. This increase takes place after dE/dx reaches a minimum a t u = 0 . 9 6 ~(see Figs. 1 and 2). As is seen from Eq. (1.1.1)) a part of this rise is due to the distant collisions [the factor (1 - p2)-' in the logarithm of (l)],and a part is due to the close collisions; this part results from the increase of Wm, with increasing energy. As is shown by Eq. (1.1,9), the increase due to the distant collisions arises directly from the relativistic increase of b,,. It is in this connection th at the density effect (represented by the term 6) becomes important. Thus with increasing energy, the cylindrical region around the path of the particle where the atoms are excited will increase However, the atoms close t o the path of the particle in radius (= Lax). will produce a polarization which reduces the electric field acting on the electrons at larger distances, thus diminishing th e energy loss to these electrons. The existence of this effect was first suggested b y Swann16 in 1938. It has been calIed density effect, since it depends strongly on the density of the medium, in as much as the polarization is proportional to n, the number of electrons per cm3. The density effect correction was first evaluated by Fermi" under simplified assumptions. Further calculations 16
'7
W. F. G. S w a m , J . Franklin Znst. 226, 598 (1938). E. Fermi, Phys. Rev. 66, 1242 (1939); 67, 485 (1940).
a
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
of this effect have been carried out by Halpern and Ha11,18Wick,lg Sternheimer,20s21BudinilZ2and others. I n the extreme relativistic region, the density effect correction 6 is given by 6
= -
ln(1 - p2) - ln(12/h2vp2) - 1
(1.1.14)
where v p is the plasma frequency of the electrons and is given by yP =
(ne2/i..m)1/2.
The term - ln(1 - 02) in 6 cancels the term due to (1 - p2) in the logarithm of Eq. (1.1.1). Thus the part of the relativistic rise due to the broadening of the field region is completely canceled by the density effect in the limit of very large energies. There remains the part of the rise due to the term In W,.,, i.e., due to the energy transfer in close collisions. W,,, increases as (1 - p2)-’ for not too high energies [Eq. (1.1.2)]. At very high energies [E > (mi2/2m)c2], W,,, increases approximately a s (1 - p2)-1/2. Indeed, Vmax approaches the value E - (mi2/2m)c2,a s is shown by the following general formula due to Bhabha.23
where E is the total energy of the particle (including the rest mass). Thus in the extreme relativistic region, the logarithm of (1.1.1) has a term - ln(1 - p2)3/2,whereas 6 has a term - ln(1 - p2), so that the relativistic rise is only one-third as large as it would be without the density effect. 1.1.2.3. Energy Loss due to eerenkov Radiation. It should be noted that the relativistic rise includes the energy loss due to Cerenkov radiation. The Cerenkov loss is given by the formula of Frank and T t ~ m m . ~ ~ (1.1.16) where the integral extends over the frequencies v for which pn > 1, and where n(v)is the index of refraction of the medium. The Cerenkov loss is 0. Halpern and H. Hall, Phys. Rev. 67, 459 (1940); 73, 477 (1948). G. C . Wick, Ricerca sci. 11, 273 (1940); 12, 858 (1941); Nuovo cimento [9] 1, 302 (1943). 20R. M. Sternheimer, Phys. Rev. 88, 851 (1952); 91, 256 (1953); 93, 351, 1434 (1954). 2 1 R. M. Sternheimer, Phys. Reu. 103, 511 (1956). 22 P. Budini, Nuovo cimento [9] 10, 236 (1953). 23 H. J. Bhabha, Proc. Roy. SOC. A164, 257 (1937). Z4 I. Frank and I. Tamm, Compt. rend. acad. sci. U.R.S.S. 14, 109 (1937). l8
l9
1.1.
INTERACTION OF RADIATION WITH MATTER
9
zero at low energies, and increases to a small saturation value in the region of the relativistic r i ~ e . ~ " The ~ ' magnitude of (1.1.16) is in all cases small compared to the magnitude of the relativistic rise. This result arises from the fact that there is a large number of absorption lines and cont i n ~ a , ~corresponding ~-~~ to excitation of the electrons in the K , L, M . . . shells, except for the very light atoms (H, He) where, however, there is still a wide spectrum of absorption frequencies corresponding to the continuum above the discrete spectrum for excitation from the 1s shell. As a result, the expression for the atomic polarizability C Y ( V ) contains a large number of terms, one term for each absorption frequency (discrete line spectrum or excitation to the continuum). For such a behavior of C Y ( V ) , the index of refraction %(.) is less than 1 over a considerable region of V . As a result the region of integration of (1.1.16) is considerably restricted, and actually the only region which makes an important contribution to (dE/dx)c is the region of v below the first absorption limit, i.e., effectively the optical and near-ultraviolet region, as has been shown by Sterr~heimer.~~ It should also be noted that the width of the spectral lines gives rise to a strong absorption of the cerenkov radiation for values of v close to the frequencies of the atomic transitions, thus resulting in a further reduction of the Cerenkov energy loss. For condensed materials, - (l/p)(dE/dx)c is of the orderz0 of lop3 Mev/g cm-2 and hence completely negligible compared to the total ionization loss (> 1 Mev/g cm-2).31 For gases, the cerenkov loss is somewhat more important,29of the order of 0.1 Mev/g for Hz and He, and 0.01 Mev/g cm-2 for gases with medium and large Z . Even for H,, the cerenkov loss accounts for only -15% of the relativistic rise. Comprehensive treatments of the stopping power problems in dense materials, including the Cerenkov radiation, have been recently given by fan^,^^ Budini and Taff Bra,3 5 and Tidman. 3 4 The Bethe-Bloch formula, Eq. ( l . l . l ) , includes the cerenkov loss. l7 Thus, in order to obtain the energy -(dE/dx)d deposited close to the path of the particle, it is necessary in principle to subtract - (dE/dx)c. A. Bohr, Kgl. Danske Videnskab. Selskab, Mat.-fys. Medd. 24, N o . 19 (1948). H. Messel and D. M. Ritson, Phil. Mag. [7] 41, 1129 (1950). 17 M. Schoenberg, Nuovo cimento [9] 8,159 (1951); 9,210,372 (1952); M. Huybrechts and M. Schoenberg, ibid. 9, 764 (1952). 28 P. Rudini, Phys. Rev. 89, 1147 (1953). 99 R. M. Sternheimer, Phys. Rev. 89, 1148 (1953); 91, 256 (1953); 93, 1434 (1954). 80 G. N. Fowler and G. M. D. B. Jones, Proc. Phys. SOC.(London) A66, 597 (1953). 81 See also J. R. Allen, Phys. Reu. 93, 353 (1954). 84 U. Fano, Phys. Reu. 103, 1202 (1956). 88 P. Budini and L. Taffara, Nuouo cimenlo [lo] 4, 23 (1956). *4 D. A. Tidman, Nuclear Phys. 2, 289 (1956); 4, 257 (1957). 26 24
10
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
We have (1.1.17) However, as pointed out above, (dE/dx) c is generally negligible compared to the relativistic rise of dE/dx, except for gases of low 2 (H2, He). While the energy loss due to Cerenkov radiation is very small compared to the total ionization loss, the Cerenkov effecta6has received an important application in the design of Cerenkov counters," which are based on the property that the Cerenkov radiation is absent unless the velocity of the particle exceeds a critical value vc determined by v,no/c
=
(1.1.18)
1
where no is the index of refraction of the radiating substance (usually a liquid) in the optical region. The Cerenkov counter is used as a velocity selector, and together with a momentum measurement, it enables one to identify charged particles by placing an upper or lower limit on the mass. 1.1.2.4. Evaluation of dE/dx. The M e a n Excitation Potential 1. Equation (1.1.1) can be written in the following form: Pdx:
P2
B
P + In Wmax,Mev + 0.69 + 2 In mic - 2p2 - 6 - U -
(1.1.19) where p is the density of the medium in g/cm3, so that -(l/p)(dE/dz) gives the energy loss in Mev/g cm-2; A and 3 are defined by:
A = 21rnx2e4/(mc2p) 3 = 1n[mc2(1OE ev)/P].
(1.1.19a) (1.1.19b)
I n Eq. (1.1.19), Wmax,Mev is the value of Wmax[Eqs. (1.1.2), (1.1.15)] in MeV. In order to obtain - (l/p)(dE/dz) in Mev/g cm-2, one must take A as: 0.1536(Z/A0)x~,where 2 = atomic number, A0 = atomic weight of stopping substance. The following expression for 6 has been obtained by Sternheimer :20,21 6 = 4.60GX 6 = 4.606X
+ C + U ( X I- X)' +C
(Xo < X < X i ) (1.1.20) ( X > Xl) (1.1.20a)
where X = loglo(p/m,c), X Oand X I are particular values of X which depend on the substance. X Ois the value of X below which 6 is zero; XI is the value of X above which the high-energy expression, Eq. (1.1.20a), applies.
* See also this volume,
Chapter 1.5. A review of the applications of the eerenkov effect has been given by J. V. Jelley, Progr. in Nuclear Phys. S, 84 (1953). as
1.1.
11
INTERACTION O F RADIATION WITH MATTER
In the region X > XI, the ionization loss becomes independent of the excitation potential I , as has been first shown by Fermi.I7 I n Eqs. (1.1.20) and (1.1.20a), a, s, wd C are constants which depend on the substance and on the value chosen for I . C is defined as
C = -2 ln(I/hv,)
-
1.
(1.1.21)
The mean excitation potential I has been the subject of numerous investigations. I n 1933, Bloch14showed that, on the basis of the ThomasFermi model, I should be proportional t o the atomic number: I = kZ,but he could not determine theoretically the value of the proportionality constant lc, which therefore has to be obtained from experiment. An early determination by Bethe36of I for air from the range-energy relation of (Y particles gave I,, = 80.5 ev. I n 1940, Wilson3? obtained a value for aluminuni,IA1= 150 ev. Both of these results giveI/Z 11.5 ev. I n 1951, Bakker and Segr&38 measured dE/dx for 340-Mev protons in a number of materials, and obtained values of I of the order of -92 - 1 0 2 ev for heavy elements. Measurements of the ranges of 340-Mev protons by Mather and Segr&39 led to similar values of I . For Al, Mather and Segr83g = 148 i -3 ev, in good agreement with Wilson’s37earlier result. found IA1 On the other hand, Sachs and Richardson40 from a determination of the absolute stopping power for 18-Mev protons in A1 obtained a substjailtially namely I , = 168 k 3 ev. For heavy elements Sachs higher value for IAl, and Richardson obtained I ,- 1 4 2 - 182 ev, which is also considerably higher than the results of Bakker and Segr&38From measurements of the range in A1 of protons of various energies from 35 to 120 MeV, Bloembergen and van Heerden4l deduced a value I A 1 = 162 & 5 ev. A similar measurement for 18-Mev protons in A1 by Hubbard and M a ~ K e n z i e ~ ~ gave I A I = 170 ev.43 I n 1955, C a l d ~ e 1 1recalculated ~~ the values of I from the data of Sachs and Richardson40 with the inclusion of the low-energy shell corrections [ C , and CL, see Eq. (1.1.34)]. Th e resulting values of I are somewhat smaller than those originally obtained by Sachs and Richardson, but are still considerably above the Bakker-Segr& values. Thus for Al, C a l d ~ e 1 1 ~ ~ found = 163 ev, and for the heavy elements, I,- 132 - 1 4 2 ev. M. S. Livingston and H. A. Bethe, Revs. Modern Phys. 9, 261 (1937).
R. R. Wilson, Phys. Rev. 60, 749 (1941).
** C . J. Bakker and E. SegrB, Phys. Rev. 81,489 (1951). R. L. Mather and E. SegrB, Phys. Rev. 84, 191 (1951). D. C . Sachs and R. J . Richardson, Phys. Rev. 83,834 (1951); 89, 1163 (1953) 41 N. Bloembergen and P. J. van Heerden, Phys. Rev. 83, 561 (1951). 4 * E. L. Hubbard and K. R. MacKenzie, Phys. Rev. 86, 107 (1952). 43 See also D. H. Simmons, Proc. Phys. Sac. (London)A66, 454 (1952). 4 4 D. 0. Caldwell, Phys. Rev. 100, 291 (1955). 40
12
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
Caldwell also showed that the various experiments are generally consistent with I values which are independent of the velocity of the incident particle. 4 6 This result was important, since it had bee%previously believed that I might be velocity-dependent, in order to reconcile data from different experiments. 4 6 Recently, two accurate determinations of I have been made from measurements of the range and stopping power of low-energy protons ( s 2 0 Mev). From measurements of the range of protons of various energies from 6-18 MeV, Bichsel et aL4’ have obtained the following I values for Be, Al, Cu, Ag, and Au: I B e = 63.4 f 0.5 ev, I A I = 166.5 k 1 ev, Icu = 375.6 k 20 ev, I A g = 585 k 40 ev, and I A u = 1037 k 100 ev. The result for Be confirms an earlier determination by Madsen and V e n k a t e ~ w a r l uwho , ~ ~ obtained IBe= 64 f 5 ev. The large value of I / Z for Be (1/Z i X 16) had been previously predicted by A. B ~ h (who r ~ ob~ tained I = 60 ev) on the basis of polarization effects caused by the presence of the two conduction electrons per atom. For Al,Cu, Ag, and Au, 13 ev, which is somewhat smaller the I values of Bichsel et al. give I / Z than Caldwell’s results,44but is considerably higher than the values of I / Z obtained by Bakker and Segr&.@ The other recent determination of I values has been made by Burkig and M a ~ K e n z i eThese . ~ ~ authors measured the stopping powers relative to aIuminum of a number of metals of 19.8-Mev protons. The resulting values The values of I of I are based on the value I A I = 166.5 ev of Bichsel et of Burkig and MacKenzie for Be, Cu, Ag, Au, and P b are: IBe= 64 ev, Icu = 366 ev, I,, = 587 ev, IAu = 997 ev, and I,, = 1070 ev. These values of I are in good agreement with the results of Bichsel et aL4’ In 1959, Zrelov and stole to^^^" measured the range R in copper of 660-Mev protons from the Dubna synchrocyclotron. These authors have obtained a value R = 257.6 f 1.2 gm/cm2, which leads to a calculated mean excitation potential ICu= 305 f 10 ev ( I / Z = 10.5 k 0.3 ev). This value of Icuis appreciably smaller than the values obtained by Bichsel et al.47and by Burkig and M a c K e n ~ i eat~ ~lower energies (6-20 Mev). Zrelov and stole to^^^^ have also determined the stopping power relative to copper for H, Be, C, Fe, Cd, and W for 635-Mev protons. For H, Be, and
-
See also W. Brandt, Phys. Rev. 104,691 (1956);111,1042(1958);112,1624(1958). M. Scharff, Kgl. Danske Videnskab. Selskab, Mat.-fys. Medd. 27, No. 15 (1953). 47 H. Bichsel, R. F. Mozley, and W. A. Aron, Phys. Rev. 106, 1788 (1957). 48 C. B. Madsen and P. Venkateswarlu, Phys. Rev. 74, 648 (1948). 49 V. C.Burkig and K. R. MacKenzie, Phys. Rev. 106,848 (1957). 4OeV. P. Zrelov and G. D. Stoletov, Zhur. Eksptl. i Teoret. Fiz. 86, 658 (1959): [translation: Soviet Phys. J E T P 9,461 (1959)l. 45
teJ. Lindhard and
1.1.
INTERACTION OF RADIATION WITH MATTER
13
C, the resulting values of I / Z are -14-15 ev (IH = 15, I B e = 61 f 6, I0 = 85 f 8 ev). The value of I B e is in good agreement with the results of earlier experiment^.^'-^^ On the other hand, for Cd and W, the values of I / Z are 9.8 and 9.2 ev, respectively, indicating that for heavy elements, the value of I / Z may be appreciably lower than the results (-13 ev) of references 47 and 49. The values of the constants a, s, and C for the density effect correction 6 which are given in reference 20 were based on the Bakker-Segr838values of I , whereas the results for 6 of reference 21 were obtained by means of . ~ ~denote these values of I by I1 and Iz, the higher I values of C a l d ~ e 1 1We respectively. The values of 6 for any intermediate 1 value, I = I O (e.g., that of Bichsel et aZ.47),can be obtained by logarithmic interpolation, as follows. Let 61 and 8 2 denote the values of 6 pertaining to I I and 12, respectively.20.21Then 60 appropriate to I = I0 is given by 60 =
where q is defined by
761
+ (1 -
7162
(1.1.22) (1.1.23)
Of course, Eqs. (1.1.22) and (1.1.23) apply also, within reasonable limits, if I0 is outside the range (IJZ), i.e., for I0 < I1 or I 0 > Iz. When the stopping material is a compound containing several atomic species, the stopping powers of the individual elements are approximately additive (Bragg’s rule). Thus Eq. (1.1.1) still holds for the compound, provided that the mean excitation potential I in this equation is replaced by the following average potential 1: (1.1.24) with (1.1.25) Here n, is the number of atoms of the ith type in the compound, with atomic number Z, and excitation potential Ii; fi of Eq. (1.1.25) is the oscillator strength of the atomic electrons belonging to the ith species. The density effect correction 6 of Eq. (1.1.1) must be replaced by 8 defined bv (1.1.26) i
where 6i is the value of 6 for the ith constituent.
14
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
In order to obtain - (l/p)(dE/dz) in Mev/g cm-2, the constant A of Eq. (1.1.19a) must be taken as follows:
(1.1.27)
where Ai is the atomic weight of the i t h element. Extensive experiments have been carried out by Thompsons0t o verify the additivity of the stopping powers for a number of organic compounds (containing C, H, N, 0, and Cl). I n these experiments, the 340-Mev protons from the Berkeley cyclotron were slowed down to 200 MeV. It was found that the stopping powers of the constituent elements in the compound are additive to within 1%. Small deviations (less than 1%) from additivity were observed; these were attributed to the influence of the chemical binding. Thompson also obtained values of I for the elements C, H, N, and 0, using liquid targets for H, N, and 0. 1.1.2.5. The Restricted Ionization Loss, - (l/p)(dE/dz)~,. Equation (1.1.1) or (1.1.19) gives the average energy loss of the charged particle. These expressions include the possibility of large energy transfers, up to the maximum value W,,, [Eqs. (1.1.2), (1.1.15)]. I n certain applications, one is, however, interested in the restricted energy loss with energy This is true in particular for transfers less than a certain fixed value WO. the grain count in nuclear emulsion* and for the drop count of tracks in cloud chambers. t For the grain count in emulsion, the relevant quantity is the ionization loss with energy transfers less than W O 5 kev,26because larger energy transfers generally result in the development of neighboring grains not directly in line with the track, so that the grain count along the track is no longer proportional to the complete ionization loss. A similar phenomenon takes place for cloud chamber tracks. For energy transfers which are larger than -1 kev, a cluster of drops is formed, so that the drop count along the track is not proportional to the complete ionization loss. The restricted energy loss, with maximum energy transfer W o is , given by
-
* See also this volume,
Chapter 1.8.
t See also this volume, Chapters 1.6 and
1.7. T. Thompson, University of California Radiation Laboratory Report UCRL-1910 (1952). See also T. Westermark, Phys. Rev. 93, 835 (1954). 60
1.1.
15
INTERACTION OF RADIATION WITH MATTER
or in terms of the constants A and B
P
p)
dx wo
=
$ [B + 0.69 + 2 In P + In -
wO,,,
- /Y
-6-u
mic
1
(1.1.29) where W0,Mevis the value of W Oin MeV. Whereas the average ionization loss - ( l / p ) ( d E / d z ) continues to rise the indefinitely with increasing energy (due to the increase of W,,,), restricted energy loss - ( l / p ) (dE/dz) W , levels off to a constant value at high energies, which is generally referred to as the Fermi plateau. This I I1111111
I11111111
I
11111111
I11111111
I Ill1
72
fi MESON MOMENTUM (IN Mev/c)
FIG.1. The ionization loss of p mesons i n 02 as a function of the p-meson momentum. The solid curve represents the restricted energy loss, - ( l / p ) ( d E / d x ) w ,with W o= 1 kev, as obtained from Eq. (1.1.28). The crosses represent the experimental data of Ghosh et aL61The theoretical curve and the experimental drop count (number of ion pairs per cm) have been normalized a t the minimum of ionization.
result arises from the fact that the logarithmic term in 6 exactly cancels the effect of the (1 - ,@) denominator in Eq. (1.1.28), as has been discussed above. An example of the relativistic increase of - (l/p) (dE/dz)w,, and the Fermi plateau at very high energies is presented in Fig. 1, which shows the restricted energy loss of p mesons in oxygen (at normal pressure) for an assumed value Wo = 1 kev. A measure of the relativistic increase is given by the ratio R = Jplat/Jmin, where JP1,, and Jmi,are the values of - (l/p)(dE/dz)~,in the plateau region and at the minimum of ionization 61 S. K. Ghosh, G. M. D. B. Jones, and J. G. Wilson, Proc. Phys. SOC.(London) A66, 68 (1952); A67, 331 (1954).
16
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
(v = 0.96c), respectively. As is seen from Fig. 1, for 0 2 , with W O= 1 kev, = 1.08 Mev/g cm-2, so that R = 1.51. we have Jplat= 1.63, Jmin Figure 1 also s h o w the data of Ghosh et aLblobtained from the drop count in an expansion cloud chamber filled with oxygen a t normal pressure (see Section 1.1.2.9). The theoretical curve and the experimental data have been normalized at the minimum of ionization (Jmi.= 44 ion pairs/cm). The equivalent number of ion pairs is indicated on the right-hand scale.
'*4"
- 1.2
z 2
1.11 10'
' " t l l l l l
"111111'
'
1
111111
' ' I J I I I '
lo3 lo" 10' lo6 p MESON MOMENTUM (IN Mev/c)
' " ' 1 ' 1 '
10'
FIG.2. The ionization loss of p mesons in He as a function of the p-meson momentum. The solid curve represents the restricted energy loss, -(l/p)(dE/dx) wO1with W O= 1 kev. The dashed curve shows the energy deposited along the track, -(l/p)(dE/dx)d, after subtraction of the estimated energy escape due to Cerenkov radiation, - (I/p) ( d E / d s ) c [see Eq. (1.1.17)]. The flat part of the curves a t very high momenta ( >lo5 Mev/c) is often referred to as the Fermi plateau.
The theoretical curve is in good agreement with the data, except a t the highest momenta of the experiment ( p , 2 10 Bev/c), where the data give an indication that the relativistic rise may be somewhat smaller than predicted by the theory. However, the uncertainties of the measurements make it impossible to decide at present whether there is a real discrepancy. The Cerenkov loss ( d E / d z ) c may also be partly responsible for the apparent disagreement, since it reduces the energy deposited along the track (dE/dz)d. However, - (l/p)(dE/dx)c is expected to be quite small for oxygen (-0.02 Mev/g ern+ in the region of the Fermi plateau29). Figure 2 shows the relativistic rise in helium at normal pressure. In this = 1.22, Jplst = 1.79 Mev/g so that R = 1.47. We have case, Jmin made an estimate of the cerenkov energy ~ o s sand , ~ ~the dashed curve of
1.1.
17
INTERACTION OF RADIATION WITH MATTER
Fig. 2 showsthe resultant energydepositedalong the track - (l/p) (dE/dz)d. The difference between the solid and the dashed curves represents the cerenkov loss, - (l/p)(dE/dz)~[see Eq. (1.1.17)]. The relativistic rise of - (l/p) (dE/dz)w o in gases has been observed in a large number of experiments. A summary of these experimental investigations is given in Section 1.1.2.9. 1.1.2.6. The Most Probable Ionization Loss Eprob. Fluctuations of the Energy Loss. As has been shown by Williams,62Landau,63and others, the ionization loss in a thin absorber is subject to appreciable fluctuations, because of the statistical nature of the ionization process. The energy loss in a thin absorber has a considerable spread about the most probable value Eprob. This spread is often referred t o as the Landau effect, since Landau was the first to calculate the expected distribution of the energy losses. Further contributions to this problem have been made by S ~ r n o nand ,~~ by Blunck and L e i ~ e g a n gThe . ~ ~ distribution is asymmetric, with a long tail on the side of high-energy losses which is due to the infrequent collisions with very large energy transfers which result in a relatively large angle scattering of the incident particle. The full width of the Landau distribution at half-maximum is of the order of 20% of Eprob for typical cases. From Landau’s theory,63one obtains the following expression for eproh for a thin absorber (of thickness t g/cm2) : Eprob
=
~
mv2p -
- P2
+ 0.37 - 6 - U (1.1.30)
Equation (1.1.30) can be written as follows:
B
P At + 1.06 + 2 In mic - + In
As an example, a thickness of 6.97 g/cm2 of Be gives a most probable loss = 10 Mev for 3.0-Bev protons. The Landau distribution for this case is shown in Fig. 3. This figure shows the rapid rise of the probability P ( E ) on the side of low-energy losses, and the long tail on the side of large energy losses. The maximum energy transfer of a 3-Bev proton to a single electron, Wmx = 17 MeV, is indicated on the abscissa for comparison with eprob
E. J. Williams, Proc. Roy. SOC.A126, 420 (1929). D.Landau, J. Phys. U.S.S.R. 8, 201 (1944). 6 4 K. R. Symon, quoted by B. Rossi, in “High-Energy Particles,” p. 32. PrenticeHall, New York, 1952. 6 s 0. Rlunck and S. Leisegang, Z.Physin‘k 128, 500 (1950). 61
sSL.
18
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
the values of Epr& and e~~ (average energy loss). can, of course, be ob= eP(e) de. The tained by integrating over the distribution, i.e., values of the loss E for which the distribution has half its maximum value 1 = a 1 - 8 ~€ ~ 0 ~9.13 ~ Mev and E Z = 11.20 MeV. The fractional spread (€2 - t l ) / ~ p r o= h 0.21 is a measure of the width of the distribution. The ratio ( € 2 - eprob)/(Eprob - el) is 1.38, which is a measure of the skewness of the distribution. The average loss in the same thickness of Be is: eAv = 6.97 X 1.593 = 11.10 MeV, where 1.593 Mev/g cm-2 is - ( l / p ) ( d E / d x ) (see Table 111). The difference between and Eprob is also
lo"
-
t
0.35
n
0.30 -
7
-
gr
W
=0.25 -
--zu0.20 -I
-
a
0.15 -
-
i m
0
0.10
-
0.05-
-
0- L
7
ENERGY LOSS 6 (IN M e V )
FIG.3. The Landau distribution of energy losses E for 3-Bev protons traversing a thickness 6.97 gm/cm2 of Be, for which €pr& = 10 Mev, EA" = 11.10 Mev, and W,, = 17 Mev.
an indirect measure of the importance of the infrequent large energy transfers. In similarity to the restricted energy loss, the most probable loss eprob also levels off to a constant value (Fermi plateau) at very high energies. This result is, of course, due to the fact that the close collisions (which would result in an unlimited increase of dE/dx) do not contribute to eprob, but only to the tail of the Landau distribution. A summary of the experimental determination of Eprob in thin absorbers will be given in Section 1.1.2.9. 1.1.2.7. Ionization Loss of Electrons. Equations (1.1.2.8) and (1.1.2.9) for (dE/dz)w, and Eqs. (1.1.30) and (1.1.31) for eprab are valid for any type of charged particle: electron, meson, etc. These expressions do not iiivolve the close collisions which differentiate slightly between
1.1. INTERACTION
O F RADIATION W I T H MATTER
19
electrons and particles heavier than electrons. On the other hand, Eqs. (1.1.1) and (1.1.19) for the average energy loss are applicable only for particles heavier than electrons. These expressions include a term due to close collisions. For electrons, this term is somewhat different, and the average ionization loss is given by:56
where T , is the kinetic energy of the electron. The factor $T, in the logarithm represents the effective maximum energy transfer W,,,. The reason for this result is that the maximum possible energy transfer from the incident electron t o the atomic electron is T,. However, since the two electrons are indistinguishable, one can call the incident electron after the collision that which has the highest energy. Since this energy is 2 $ T e , the effective maximum energy transfer is $T,. Aside from the replacement of W,, by +Te,the square bracket of Eq. (1.1.32) for electrons differs from that for heavy particles [Eq. (1.1.1)] by an amount: A = (17/8) - In 2 = 1.43
(1.1.33)
a t very high energies ( p = 1). In (1.1.33) the term In 2 is due t o the fact atomic electron) that the reduced mass of the system (indident particle is +m for a n incident electron, as compared to = m for a heavy p a r t i ~ l e . ~ ’ The term 17/8 is due t o the difference between the cross sections for close collisions of electrons as compared t o heavy particles. The effect of A on dE/dx is relatively small ( 5 10%) since the value of the square bracket of (1.1.32) is generally -20. 1.1.2.8. The Shell Correction Term U. We shall nbw discuss the correction U for the nonparticipation of the K , L, . . . electrons a t low energies of the incident particle. This correction has been introduced b y Bethe.36 U is given by
+
(1.1.34) where CKand CLare the K and L shell corrections, respectively. CKand C L are negligible at high energies, and become appreciable only when the velocity v of the particlgis decreased to a value of the order of the velocity 66
H. A. Bethe, in “Handbuch der Physik” (H. Geiger and K. Scheel, eds.), Vol. 24,
p. 273. Springer, Berlin, 1933; C. Mgller, Ann. Physik [5] 14, 531 (1932). 67 H. A. Bethe and J. Ashkin, i n “Experimental Nuclear Physics” (E. SegrB, ed.), Vol. 1, p. 253. Wiley, New York, 1953.
20
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
of the atomic electrons in the K and L shells, respectively. Thus the shell corrections will enter at a somewhat higher energy for heavy elements than for light elements. As an example, for Cu, 2 C ~ / 2is less than 0.05 for proton energies above T , = 65 MeV, corresponding to v, = 0.35~.CLbecomes appreciable only at still lower energies. For Cu, ~ C L / Z < 0.05 for T, > 11 Mev (v, > 0.15~).Detailed calculations of CK and CL have been carried out by Walske.68 The corrections for the M , N , and higher shells of heavy atoms are generally negligible, except at very low energies (T, 5 1 MeV). ,, where the present theory becomes unreliable for other reasons (capture and loss of electrons by the incident particle, see Section 1.1.2.10).
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
%
sz Q
tE
1.8 1.6
1.4
1.2 1.0’ I02
I
’ 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
lo3 p
’
‘ ‘ * l t 1 l ’
lo4
’
lo5
’
lo6 ’
11111111
lo7
MESON KINETIC ENERGY (IN MeV)
FIG.4. The average ionization loss of p mesons in Be, Al, Cu, Ag, and Au, as a function of the p-meson kinetic energy [Eq.(1.1.19)].
1.1.2.9. Example: - (l/p)(dE/dx) for /I Mesons in Various Materials. Experimental Verification of the Bethe-Bloch Formula at Relativistic Energies. In summary, Eqs. (1.1.1), (1.1.19) and (1.128)-(1.1.32) givethe
expressions for the ionization loss for 4 different possibilities: (1) average energy loss of particles heavier than eIectrons; (2) average energy loss of electrons; (3) restricted energy loss (energy transfers less than a fixed value W O;) (4) most probable loss in a thin absorber. As an example of the behavior of dE/dx as a function of energy, Figs. 4 and 5 show curves of -(l/p)(dE/dx) versus kinetic energy T, for /I mesons in various solids and gases. In calculating the curves of Fig. 4 for the solids, we used for the excitation potential I of each substance the 68
M. C. Walske, Phys. Rev. 88, 1283 (1952);101,940 (1956).
1.1.
INTERACTfON OF RADfATfON WfTH MATTER
21
average of the I values determined by Bichsel et aL4' and by Burkig and M a c K e n ~ i e .The ~ ~ resulting I values are: IBe= 64 ev, Id = 166 ev, Icu= 371 ev, IA== 586 ev, and I , = 1,017 ev. For Fig. 5, we used the I values given in reference 21 for Hz, He, and air: I H 2= 19 ev, I H e= 44 ev16Q and Isir= 94 ev (the last corresponding to I = 132 ev). For Ar and Xe, the values of I / Z were obtained by interpolation from the above I values = 230 ev, and ZXe = 684 ev. for Cu, Ag, and Au. This gives: IAr 4 and 5 show the ionization minimum (for T , 200-300 MeV) Figures and the relativistic rise at higher energies. The value of - (l/p) (dE/dz)a t the minimum decreases with increasing 2, on account of the increase of I
-
p MESON KINETIC ENERGY (IN MeV)
FIG.5. The average ionization loss of p mesons in Hz, He, air, Ar, and Xe, as a function of the p-meson kinetic energy [Eq. (1.1.19)]. The curves for He, air, Ar, and Xe pertain to normal pressure.
in the denominator of the logarithm of Eq. (1.1.1). For H,, three curves are presented corresponding to different pressures. On account of the density effect, the ionization loss decreases with increasing pressure a t very high energies ( T , 2 10 Bev). It may be noted that, in contrast to Figs. 1 and 2 for - ( l / p ) ( d E/d z)w0,which show a plateau at high energies, the curves of Figs. 4 and 5 have an unlimited logarithmic increase, which is, of course, due to the fact that they represent the average energy loss, including all possible energy transfers up to Wmax[cf. discussion following Eq. (1.1.29)]. Figures 4 and 5 also apply for protons, provided that the numbers on the abscissa are multiplied by the factor mp/m,, where m pand m,, are the 69 E. J WilIiams, Proc. Cambridge Phit. Soc. 33, 179 (1937).
22
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
proton and the p-meson mass, respectively. [ d E / d x for protons of energy T, is equal to dE/dx for p mesons of energy T,(m,/m,).] The Bethe-Bloch formula has been verified in numerous experimental investigations. A summary of the low-energy work on the ionization loss d E / d x and on the range-energy relation is to be found in the articles of Bethe and A ~ h k i n Allison ,~ and Warshaw,60and Taylor.61The experimental studies at relativistic energies are discussed in the review articles of Price62and of Uehling.'j3 Here we shall present a summary of some of the experiments performed at relativistic energies to verify the existence of the relativistic rise and of the Fermi plateau (due to the density effect). An outline of the main features of some of the experimental investigations on the relativistic rise and the density effect is given in Table I. The most extensive experiments on the energy loss in gases a t relativistic energies have been made by means of expansion cloud chambers,* by obtaining the drop count along the tracks of the particles. The momentum is determined by measuring the curvature in the magnetic field of the cloud chamber. One of the earliest experiments of this type is that of Ghosh and co-workerssl who measured the restricted energy loss (W O= 1 kev) of 1.1 mesons in 0 2 a t normal pressure. They observed a rise from 44 drops per cm to 60 drops per cm in going from the minimum ionization at p , = 0.4 Bev/c to the Fermi plateau starting at p , = 20 Bev/c. From their determinations of the drop count at p , = 7, 15, and 30 Bev/c, it is clear that the energy loss - (dE/dx)w-,does not increase indefinitely with increasing p,, but instead levels off to a saturation value. This result provides a direct confirmation of the existence of the density effect in gases a t high energies (see Fig. 1). Aside from the work of Ghosh et u Z . , ~ ~there have been several other cloud-chamber determinations of the relativistic rise, although these have generally somewhat poorer momentum determinations. Carter and W h i t t e m ~ r eperformed ~~ measurements in a helium-filled chamber, both for p mesons and electrons, and obtained evidence that high-energy electrons ionize more heavily than minimum, which would confirm the relativistic rise. These authors also obtained direct evidence for the relativistic rise by comparing the ionization due to p mesons with momenta between 70 and 250 Mev/c (14.7 f 0.35 droplets/mm on the photographic film) with the ionization for a group with p , > 1500 Mev/c
* See also in this volume, Chapter 1.6. S. K. Allison and S. D. Warshaw, Revs. Modern Phys. 26, 779 (1953). A. E. Taylor, Repfs. Progr. in Phys. 16, 49 (1952). 6a B. T. Price, Repis. Progr. in Phys. 18, 52 (1955). 83 E. A. Uehling, Ann. Rev. Nuclear Sci. 4, 315 (1954). G4 R. S. Carter and W. L. Whittemore, Phys. Rev. 87, 494 (1952). 60
1.1. INTERACTION
23
O F RADIATION WITH MATTER
TABLEI. Summary of Some of the Experimental Investigations on the Relativistic Rise and the Density Effect for the Ionization Loss For each particular method of determination, the experiments are listed in chronological order. For additional details and a more complete list of references, see text (Section 1.1.2.9).
Author
Method of determination
Corson and Cloud chamber (drop count) Brodeae (1938)
Sen Gupta67
Cloud chamber
(1940)
Hazen66(1945)
Cloud chamber
Haywardas (1947) Cloud chamber
Carter and Whittemore'4
Cloud chamber
(1952)
Ghosh et aL61
Cloud chamber
(1954)
Kepler et aLa9 (1958)
Cloud chamber
Type of particle, energy range, and material traversed
Results
Electrons (0.3-60 MeV) Observation of miniin cloud chamber mum of ionization filled with Nzat 1.5 (at T , 2 MeV) and atmos pressure. relativistic rise for electrons. Electrons (2-500 MeV) Observation of minimum of ionization and relativistic rise for electrons. Electrons in air. Two Observation of relativistic rise (of -40% energy groups: 1.42.1 Mev and 30-240 between two energy groups) in agreement MeV. with Bethe-Bloch formula. Electrons in He. High-energy electrons ( T , > 100 MeV) have 1.4 times minimum ionization, in agreement with theory. Increase of ionization p mesons in He (at between the two pressure P = 98 cm momentum groups Hg). Two momenin good agreement tum groups: p = 70with theory. 250 Mev/c, and p > 1500 Mev/c. p mesons in 0, (at nor- Observation of relativmal pressure); p = istic increase of ionization and levelling 0.3-30 Bev/c. off to Fermi plateau above 6 Bev/c in reasonable agreement with calculations including the density effect. p mesons with p / p c = Observation of relativistic rise and Fermi 3-80, and electrons plateau: in good with p/pc = 50agreement with 2000, in following
-
24
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
TABLE I. Summary of Some of the Experimental Investigations on the Relativistic Rise and the Density Effect for the Ionization Loss (Continued) ~~
Author
~
Type of particle, energy range, and material traversed
Method of determination
gases: He (1.3 atmos); Ar (0.2 atmos) ; Ar-He mixture (each a t 0.2 atmos); Xe-He mixture (each at 0.1 atmos) p mesons (0.3-70 Bev/c) in mixture of argon (P = 774 mm Hg) and ethylene (P = 46 mm Hg). p mesons in Ne.
Results theory for He; for other cases, calculated rise is somewhat larger than experimental values.
.
Parry et al.1° (1953)
Eyeions et
al.7'
(1955)
Proportional counter
Proportional counter
Palmatier, et aZ.I2 (1955)
Proportional counter
p
mesons (0.2-15 Bev/c) in argon at pressures from 2 to 40 atmos.
Lanou and Kraybi11728 (1959)
Proportional counter
p
mesons (3.3-140 Bev/c) in a mixture of 95% He and 5% CO2 a t a total pressure of 2.7 atmos.
Barbersl (1955)
Ionization chamber
Electrons (1-35 MeV) in Hi, He, and N2 (normal pressure).
Observation of relativistic rise and Fermi plateau in good agreement with theory. Observation of relativistic rise and Fermi plateau in good agreement with theory. Decrease of the relativistic rise with increasing pressure, in good agreement with calculations of Sternheimer20 on the density effect. Observation of relativistic rise in He and saturation of the most probable ionization loss a t p/m,c 200 (Fermi plateau). In this region, the ionization loss is 1.28 & 0.04 times minimum. Observations in good agreement with calculated relativistic rise for Nz, but experimental increase of ionization somewhat smaller than calculated increase of IdE/drl for Hzand
2
1.1. INTERACTION
O F RADIATION WITH MATTER
25
TABLEI. Summary of Some of the Experimental Investigations on the Relativistic Rise and the Density Effect for the Ionization Loss (Continued)
Author
Barbers2 (1956)
Method of determination
Ionization chamber
Type of particle, energy range, and material traversed
Electrons (1-35 MeV) in H2 and He a t 1 and 10 atmos pressure.
Results He, possibly clue to production of Cerenkov radiation which does not contribute t o ionization.20 Observations in good agreement with calculated relativistic rise. At 10 atmos, reduction of ionization due to density effect is observed for T, 10 Mev in HZ and for T. >, 18 Mev in He. The reductions at 35 Mev are in reasonable agreement with calculations of Sternheimer.20 Observed relativistic rise between 1.7 Mev (minimum) and 9.0 Mev in reasonable agreement with calculations. Relativistic rise of 1.17 k 0.03 between sea level spectrum and underground spectrum, in good agreement with calculations using density effect correction.
2
Herefords7 (1948)
Low-pressure counter
Shamos and Hudes88 (1951)
Low-pressure counter
McClureS6 (1953)
Pickup and Vo.yvodics9 (1950)
Electrons (0.2-9.0 MeV) in H 2 ( P = 7 cm Hg).
Cosmic-ray p mesons at sea level (average momentum = 3.5 Bev/e) and under 140 feet of rock (average momentum = 48 Bev/c); primary specific ionization in H2 filled counter ( P = 2.0 cm Hg). Observations in good Electrons (0.2-1.6 Low-pressure agreement with MeV) in He, He, Ne, counter Bethe’s theory of and Ar. primary specific ionization. p-decay electrons and First observation of Nuclear relativistic fi mesons -10% relativistic emu1sion rise of grain count in (grain count) in plate exposed to
26
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
TABLE I. Summary of Some of the Experimental Investigations on the Relativistic Rise and the Density Effect for the Ionization Loss (Continued) ~
Author
Method of determination
Type of particle, energy range, and material traversed
Results
emulsion between sea-level cosmic-ray T/m& 3 and spectrum; and highT/mor2 20, in reaenergy electrons, n sonable agreement mesons, and protons with theoretical prein plate exposed t o dictions. cosmic rays at high altitudes. Blob count increases Electrons (5 Mev-5 Nuclear Bev. emulsion -5% between 5 Mev and 15 MeV, then re(blob count) mains constant to 25 Bev; relativistic rise is smaller than value predicted by theory (14%). Grain count increases Nuclear n mesons (200 Mev/c-3 by -8% between Bev/c). emu1sion 500 and 1500 Mev/c, (grain count) in reasonable agreement with calculations of Budini.z* Ratio R of plateau to Electrons (y > lo), Nuclear minimum blob emulsion T mesons (y < loo), count, R = 1.14 k (blob count) and protons (y < 0.03, in good agree10). ment with theoretical value 1.14;slow rise of grain count until saturation is reached for > 100, in good agreement with calculations of Sternheimer.20 Nuclear Electrons from p decay Relativistic increase of emulsion (average energy = 14% (between mini(blob count) mum and plateau 34 MeV) and nionization), and slow mesons (31-230 Mevl. rate of rise, in good agreement with theory. Ratio R of plateau t o Nuclear T mesons (109.1 Mev) minimum grain emulsion from Krz decay, and count, R = 1.133. (blob count) p mesons (152.7
N
Morrishgo (1952)
Daniel et aLS4 (1952)
Stiller and Shapiros2 (1953)
Fleming and Lord93 (1953)
Alexander and JohnstongTa (1957)
1.1.
27
INTERACTION O F RADIATION WITH MATTER
TABLE I. Summary of Some of the Experimental Investigations on the Relativistic Rise and t h e Density Effect for the Ionization Loss (Continued)
Author
Method of determination
Type of particle, energy range, and material traversed MeV) from K,? decay.
JongejansSTb (1960)
Nuclear emuIsion (blob count)
Beam pions (5.2-5.7 Bcv/c) from Berkeley Bevatron; secondary pions produced by beam pions (1.8 < y 5 3.5); electron pairs (65 < y < 1100).
Whittemore and Street104 (1949)
Crystal counter (pulse-height distribution)
Cosmic-ray p mesons in AgCl crystal. Two energy groups: T, = 0.3 Bev (minimum ionization), and T, > 1.6 Bev.
Bowen and Roser1°6 (1952)
Scin tillator (pulse height distribution)
Cosmic-ray p mesons (30 Mev-3 Bev) in anthracene crystal.
Hudson and Hofstadterllo (1952)
Scintillator
Cosmic-ray p mesons in NaI (Tl) crystal ( p r > 225 Mev/c).
Baskin and Winckler (1953)
Scintillator
Cosmic-ray p mesons (80-2200 MeV) in xylene solution (with terphenyl).
O6
Results The authors have obtained an accurate calibration curve for grain count versus p p c for the region 0.5 < p < 0.95. Ratio R of plateau t o minimum grain count, R = 1.129 f 0.010. The relativistic rise of the grain count is slow, with an appreciable increase (-4%) taking place between y = 40 and y 1000 (plateau). Observed relativistic increase between the two energy groups is in agreement with the prediction of the Bethe-Bloch formula, including density effect correction. No detectable relativistic rise of most probable energy loss eprob, in good agreement with theory including the density effect. Observed pulse-height distribution in good agreement with calculations including the density effect. No relativistic rise is observed, in agreement with calculat i o n 9 including the density effect.
-
28
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
TABLE I. Summary of Some of the Experimental Investigations on the Relativistic Rise and the Density Effect for the Ionization Loss (Continued) ~~~
Author Bowen111 (1954)
Millar et (1958)
uZ.109
Paul and Reich"4 (1950)
Goldwasser, MiIIs, and Hanson 119 (1952)
Goldwasser et diZ1 (1955)
Method of determination
~~
Type of particle, energy range, and material traversed
Results
Relativistic increase in Accelerator-produced reasonable agreeT- mesons (60-220 ment with calculaMev), p- mesons tions; rise to plateau (245 Mev), and cosvalue may be somemic-ray p mesons (4 what faster than pregroups with average dicted by theory [obenergies: 0.37, 0.76, served rise: (10.9 i 1.47, and 5.23 Bev); 1.0)% at T, = NaI(T1) crystal. 50m,c*]. Scintillator Cosmic-ray p mesons Observed value of €i,rob (two energies: T p = (0.30 Bev)/e,,,b (2.2 0.30 Bev and 2.2 Bev) = 1.016 2c Bev); liquid scintil0.005, in good agreelation counter filled ment with BetheBloch formula, inwith triethylbenzene (plus tercluding density efphenyl). fect correction. Energy loss in Electrons (2.8 and 4.7 Observed mean energy loss is in better agreethin sample Mev) in samples ment with calculated (-0.3 gm/cma) of Be, C, H20, Fe, and value if density efPb. fect correction is included. Electrons (9.6 and 15.7 Observed most probaEnergy loss ble energy loss (-1 MeV) in thin samples (-1 gm/cm*) of Mev) is in good Be, polystyrene, Al, agreement with Cu, and Au. Landau formula, including correction for density effect. Energy loss Electrons (15.7 MeV) Direct observation of in thin samples of the density effect by comparing energy Teflon and Kel-F, and in the correloss in solid and gasesponding gases (same ous samples of the chemical composisame substance. The tion) : perfluororeduction of the ionization loss in the cyclobutane and chlorotrifluorosolid samples is in good agreement with ethylene. calculations of the density effect.
Scintillator
1.1.
INTERACTION O F RADIATION W I T H MATTER
29
TABLEI. Summary of Some of the Experimental Investigations on the Relativistic Rise and the Density Effect for the Ionization Loss (Continued)
Author Hudson121 (1957)
Method of determination Energy loss
Type of particle, energy range, and material traversed
Results
Electrons (150 MeV) in Observed energy loss thin targets (-2.5 eprob in good agreement with Landau gm/cma) of Li, Be, C, and Al. formuIa including the density effect correction.
(17.9 f 0.25 droplets/mm). The theoretically predicted value for this high-energy group of p mesons is 18.5 droplets/mm, in good agreement with the experimental result. Hazene6 verified the relativistic rise for electrons in air. Even earlier experiments by Corson and Brodese and b y Sen GuptaG7gave convincing evidence for the relativistic rise b y using cosmic-ray electrons. More recently, Hayward68 showed that high-energy is the minielectrons have a n ionization of 1.4Jni, in helium, where Jmin mum ionization. 9 measured the relativistic rise I n a recent experiment, Kepler et ~ 1 . 6 have of the ionization loss of p mesons and electrons in He, Ar, and Xe, by obtaining the drop count in a n expansion cloud chamber. Measurements were made for He a t -1.3 atmos, for Ar a t -0.2 atmos, for a n Ar-He mixture, each a t -0.2 atmos, and for a Xe-He mixture, each a t -0.1 atmos. I n each case, the cloud chamber contained alcohol and water vapor a t a partial pressure of -5 cm Hg. The p-meson momenta extend from minimum ionization (p/m,,c = 3) to p/m,c = 80. The electron momenta extend from p/mc = 50 to z 2 0 0 0 . Thus the entire region of the relativistic rise is covered in these measurements, including the Fermi plateau, which starts a t p/mc E! 1000. For the helium experiment, the theoryzkz2is in very good agreement with the data, if Williams’ valuesg of the excitation potential I for He is used (IH, = 44 ev;69 I for gas mixture = 49.4 ev69). For the argon and the argon-plus-helium experiments, the calculated rise is larger by a t least one standard deviation than W. E. Haaen, Phys. Rev. 67, 269 (1945). D. R. Corson and R. B. Brode, Phys. Rev. 63, 773 (1938). 67 R. L. Sen Gupta, Nature 146,65 (1940); Proc. NatE. Znst. SCi. fndiu 9,295 (1943). 88 E. Hayward, Phys. Rev. 72, 937 (1947). 60 R. G. Kepler, C. A. d’Andlau, W. B. Fretter, and L. F. Hansen, Nuovo cimento [lo] 7, 71 (1958). See also A. Rousset, A. Lagarrigue, P. Musset, P. Rancon, and X. Sauteron, Nuovo cimento [lo] 14, 365 (1959). 66
68
30
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
the experimental values. Thus for the Ar-He mixture, a t p/mc % 1700,the is 1.59 f 0.04, whereas the calculated resultz0is observed value of J/Jmin is 1.64. Here J is the observed ionization loss, - (l/p)(dE/dx)w,, and Jmin the value of J at the minimum of ionization. In this experiment, the effective maximum energy transfer W O(determined by the size of a blob = 40 drops) was 700-1000 ev. For the Xe-He mixture, the discrepancy is appreciably larger. For p/mc E 1000, the experimental J/Jmin = 1.58 -t 0.05, whereas the values calculated from the theories of BudiniZ2and SternheimerZ0are 1.78 and 1.75, respectively. On the whole, it appears that the experimental points for 4, AF-He, and Xe-He lie on a curve which increases less rapidly with increasing momentum than the theoretical curve obtained from the expression for - (l/p) (dE/dz)w, [Eq. (1.1.28)]. Kepler et ~ 1 have . given ~ ~ various possible reasons for this discrepancy for the heavy gases, in particular: (1) a variation of the maximum energy transfer W Owith atomic number 2, due to the 2 dependence of the binding energy of the struck electron; (2) the ratio of the energy loss to excitation and to ionization may depend on the velocity v and on 2, in such a manner as to decrease the slope of the curve of - ( l / p ) ( d E / d z ) w , versus p / p c at high momenta beyond the ionization minimum; (3) shielding effects of the inner electron shells in the heavy elements are important at very high energies. However, these shielding effects are taken into account, a t least in first approximation, by the density effect term 6 in Eq. (1.1.28). As a check on the Xe-He experiment, as Kepler et al.69 have determined the number of drops per cm at Jmin 28.9 k 0.6 under well-controlled conditions. This experimental value can be compared with the theoretical predictions: 31.8 0.4 drops/cm for the Bakker-SegrP excitation potentialszoI , and 29.6 ? 0.4drops/cm for the higher C a l d ~ e 1 values 1 ~ ~ ofz1I . It is seen that the experimental value is in good agreement with Caldwell's results, which are also favored by several other ionization loss experiments (see Section 1.1.2.4). Important experiments on the ionization loss a t relativistic energies have been carried out with proportional counters. I n these experiments, the Landau distribution is measured, from which, of course, one obtains the most probable loss Ep& The most accurate determinations are those of Parry et aL7Oon the ionization loss eprobof p mesons in argon, and those of Eyeions et d."who obtained Eprob for p mesons in a neon-filled counter. In both cases, a relativistic rise of -50% was found, and the leveling off to
+
70 J. K. Parry, H. D. Rathgeber, and J. L. Rouse, PTOC. Phys. Soc. (London) A66, 541 (1953). 7l D. A. Eyeions, B. G. Owen, B. T. Price, and J. G. Wilson, PTOC. Phys. Soc. (London) A68, 793 (1955).
1.1.
INTERACTION OF RADIATION WITH MATTER
31
the Fermi plateau was clearly observed. These two experiments used a cosmic-ray magnetic spectrometer, in which the high-energy particles are passed through a strong magnetic field and the resulting deflection is measured in a hodoscope array of Geiger counters placed below the proportional counter. Palmatier and c o - w o r k e r ~have ~ ~ investigated the relativistic rise and the Fermi plateau of Eprob for p mesons in a counter filled with argon a t various pressures up to 40 atmospheres. These authors have directly verified the dependence of Eprob on the pressure, i.e., the increase of the density effect with increasing pressure,20 and the resulting decrease of cprob,plat/Eproh,min, the ratio of the plateau to the minimum value of eprob. The calculated values of €,,rob are in reasonable agreement with these experimental results. Lanou and Kraybil1728have recently carried out a-similar investigation using p mesons of momenta 3.3-140 Bev/c in a proportional counter filled with a mixture of 95% He and 5% COZ at a total pressure of 2.7 atmospheres. These authors have observed the relativistic rise of cprobin helium, and have found that the rise saturates at momenta p/m,c 2 200 due to the density effect. In the region of the Fermi plateau, the most probable ionization loss is 1.28 k 0.04 times the value a t the minimum, in agreement with the calculations of Sternheimer.20,21 Several other experiments with proportional counters demonstrate the relativistic rise, but were not accurate enough to establish the existence of the Fermi plateau. Among these studies, we may mention the experiments of Kupperian and Palmatier,73Becker et aZ.,74 Price et aZ.,76and Eliseiev et aZ.76 Several experimenters have investigated the width A of the Landau distribution as a function of the value of A t / ( p 2 1 ) ,which enters as a parameter in Landau’s theory. West77found that, although the percentage width 100A/Eprob decreases with increasing At/(P21), as required by Landau’s theory, the value of A/cprob is larger than Landau’s result by a factor of -2. This discrepancy for the width of theidistribution can be reE. D . Palmatier, J. T. Meers, and C. M. Askey, Phys. Rev. 97, 486 (1955). R. E. Lanou and H. L. Kraybill, Phys. Rev. 113, 657 (1959). 73 J. E. Kupperian and E. D. Palmatier, Phys. Rev. 91, 1186 (1953). T 4 J. Becker, P. Chanson, E. Nageotte, P. Treille, B. T. Price, and P. Rothwell, Proc. Phys. SOC.(London)A66, 437 (1952). 75 R. T. Price, D. West, J. Becker, P Chanson, E. Nageotte, and P. Treille, Proc. Phys. soc. (London)A66, 167 (1953). 7 6 G. P. Eliseiev, V. K. Kosmachevsky, and V. A. Lubimov, Doklady Akad. Nauk. S.S.S.R. 90, 995 (1953); (English translation: NSF-tr-163, Dept. of Commerce, Washington, D.C.) 77 D. West, Proc. Phys. SOC.(London)A66, 306 (1953). 71
788
32
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
moved by improvements in the Landau theory which have been discussed by fan^^^ and H i n e ~ . ~ ~ Igo and co-workerssOhave measured the distribution of energy losses of 31.5-Mev protons in a $inch proportional counter filled with an Ar-C02 mixture (96 % Ar, 4 % C02). The pulse-height distribution was in reasonable agreement with the Landau distribution, although slightly wider in the region of the tail for large energy losses. Barbers1.s2has measured the specific ionization of electrons in Hz, He, and Nz in a n ionization chamber. The electrons were obtained from the Stanford linear accelerator and had energies ranging from 1 to 35 MeV. A collimated beam of electrons was sent through an ionization chamber into a Faraday cup, so that the ratio of the collected ionic charge to the charge collected in the Faraday cup is proportional to the specific ionization. In Barber's first experiment,S' H2, He, and Nz at atmospheric pressure were used. Under these conditions, one does not expect any density effect correction, since the density effect sets in above 35 Mev for gases a t normal pressure.20 A t minimum ionization, the number of ion pairs per cm (probable specific ionization) was 7.56 f 0.09,6.15 k 0.08, and 53.2 f 0.7 in H2, He, and N2, respectively (at normal temperature and pressure). These results were compared with the theoretical expression for the ~ , (l.l.28)] with W o= 17.4 kev restricted energy loss, - ( l / p ) ( d E / d ~ ) [Eq. for Hz, 16.4 kev for He, and 70 kev for Nz,as determined from the size of the ionization chamber and the experimental conditions. Barbers1 thus obtained the following values for w, the average energy required to produce an ion pair: 37.8 k 0.7, 44.5 k 0.9, and 34.82",; ev for Hz, He, and N'L,respectively. These results are in reasonable agreement with ,~~ and H ~ r s t , ~ ~ the values of w obtained by Jesse and S a d a u s k i ~Bortner and Bakker and S e g r P (see Section 1.1.2.12). The total number of ion pairs per cm a t the ionization minimum as obtained from the average energy loss, - (l/p)(dE/ds) [Eq. (1.1.1)] without any limitation on the maximum energy transfer, was found to be: 9.19 f 0.18,7.55 k 0.16, and 61.62::; for the three gases. The relativistic increase of the ionization from minimum (at -1.7 MeV) to 35 Mev is 1.17 for H2,1.20 for He, and 1.24 for Nz. For N P , the calculated increase of the ionization loss agrees within 1% with the observed rise, but for Hz and He, the predicted increase is U. Fano, Phys. Rev. 92, 328 (1953). K. C. Hines, Phys. Rev. 97, 1725 (1955). G. J. Igo, D. D. Clark, and R. M. Eisberg, Phys. Rev. 89, 879 (1953). *1 W. C. Barber, Phys. Rev. 97, 1071 (1955). 82 W. C. Barber, Phys. Rev. 103, 1281 (1956). W. P. Jesse and J. Sadauskis, Phy8. Rev. 90, 1120 (1953). R 4 T. E. Bortner and G. S. Hurst, Phys. Rev. 90, 160 (1953). 79
1.1.
INTERACTION O F RADIATION WITH MATTER
33
somewhat higher than the observed value, assuming that the energy loss per ion pair w is independent of the electron energy. In particular, for Hz, the deviation between the calculated and the observed values would correspond to an increase of (3.3 i-0.7)% in w as the electron energy is increased to 35 MeV. It is possible that the lowering of the rate of rise of the ionizatJionis due t o the production of c e r p k o v radiation29which is not reabsorbed t'o form ions in the gas. In Barber's second experiment,82 the specific ionization of electrons in H2 and He was measured at 1 and 10 atmospheres pressure. At 10 atomspheres, a sizable density effect is expected for both gases a t 35 MeV, whereas at 1 atmosphere the density effect correction is negligible. The experimental setup was essentially the same as in the first experiments1 (ionization chamber; Faraday cup). The theory is in good agreement with the experimental results which show that at 10 atmospheres, the specific ionization J [Eq. (1.1.28)] a t first increases above the minimum, from -2 to 10-15 MeV, but levels off above 10 Mev for H2 and 18 Mev for He. For Hz at 10 atmospheres, the value of J ( 3 5 Mev)/Jmi, is 1.12 upon inclusion of 6 (density effect), as compared to the experimental value: J / J m i ,= 1.11. (The calculated value of Jmin is 3.39 Mev/g cm-2.) Without the density effect, the calculated J / J m i ,would be 1.20. Thus the data provide a good confirmation of the existence of the density effect for gases at high pressure. Upon taking into account the experimental uncertainties, BarberB2finds that the ionization loss is decreased by (8 f 1 ) % by the density effect, as compared to the theoretical reductionz0of 6.5 %. Similar agreement is obtained for the measurements in He at 10 atmospheres, where the observed decrease of the ionization J at 35 Mev is (3.5 f 1.3) %, as compared to the calculated valuez0of 3%. Low-pressure Geiger counters have also been used to determine the relativistic rise of the ionization loss in gases. In a low-pressure counter, one attempts to measure the total number of ionizing collisions:
N = /owm"xP(W)dW where P(W) dW is the probability of a collision with energy transfer between Wand W dW. By contrast, a proportional counter measurement gives the total energy deposited: & = J ~ " " " P ( W ) W dW. The fluctuations in & are largely due to the presence of the large energy transfers W of the order of W,., which are weighted by the factor W in the integrand for &. For N , on the other hand, there is no factor Win the integrand, so that the large energy transfers are weighted much less heavily than for &, and the fluctuations in N are correspondingly reduced. The condition under which the Geiger counter measures N rather than & is that the incident
+
34
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
particles make on the average less than one ionizing collision in traversing the counter. N is proportional to the primary specific ionization J,, of the incident p a r t i ~ l e . ~ ~ Several experiments have been performed using low-pressure Geiger counters. The most extensive recent measurements for electrons in the 0.2-1.6 Mev energy rangepre those of McC1ureS6who obtained the primary specific ionization J,, of electrons in this energy range for Hz, He, Ne, and Ar. For Hz, the results could be fitted to the theoretical curve of J,, versus p/mc obtained by Bethe.86Somewhat earlier, H e r e f ~ r d , using ~’ counter measurements, obtained evidence for the relativistic rise of the ionization loss of electrons by measuring J,, for electrons in hydrogen in the range from 0.2 to 9.0 MeV. Evidence for the relativistic rise for p mesons in hydrogen has been obtained by Shamos and Hudes.88 The relativistic rise of the ionization loss in photographic emulsion has been the subject of numerous investigations. The first definite evidence for a -10% rise in the grain count in emulsion was obtained by Pickup and VoyvodicS9in 1950. The minimum value of the grain count G is obtained for a ratio T/moc2 3 of the kinetic energy T to the rest energy mgc2 of the particle. The rise starts at T/moc2 N 3 and continues until the plateau value G,,,, is reached for T/moc2 10-100. The precise value of T/moc2at which the plateau is reached has been the subject of some controversy, with some experiments favoring a rapid rate of rise of G to GPIsta t T / m d 10, while others give evidence of a more gradual rise for which the plateau is reached only for T/moc2 50-100. In the experiments, following a suggestion of Morrish,Soone obtains generally the blob count rather than the grain count. Here a blob is defined as either a single grain or a group of overlapping grains which cannot be resolved. It was found that the blob count is considerably more independent of the observer than the grain count.91 In the region between the minimum and the plateau, the blob count is proportional to the grain count.92For comparison of the theory with the grain or blob count observations, one must calculate the restricted energy loss [Eq. (1.1.2S)l with maximum energy transfer W O 5 kev. The reason is that for energy transfers W >, 5 kev, the delta-ray will have a large enough range to traverse one or more addi-
-
-
-
-
-
G. W. McClure, Phys. Rev. 90, 796 (1953). H. A. Bethe, in “Handbuch der Physik” (H. Geiger and K. Scheel, eds.), Vol. 24, p. 515. Springer, Berlin, 1933. *’ F.L. Hereford, Phys. Rev. 73, 982 (1947);74, 574 (1948). M. H. Shamos and I. Hudes, Phys. Rev. 84, 1056 (1951). 88 E. Pickup and L. Voyvodic, Phys. Rev. 80, 89 (1950). A. H. Morrish, Phil. Mug. [71 43, 533 (1952). 91 See also L. Jauneau and F. Hug-Bousser, J . phys. radium 13, 465 (1952). 92 B. Stiller and M. M. Shapiro, Phye. Rev. 92, 735 (1953). 86
88
1.1.
35
INTERACTION OF RADIATION WITH MATTER
tional grains not directly in line with the path of the particle. If only the grains along the track are counted, or if a blob count is made, in which all of the overlapping grains due to an energetic 6 ray are counted as a single unit, then the observed count will be essentially unaffected by the presence of the high-energy 6 rays, so that a cutoff at WO 5 kev is indicated, as was first pointed out by Messel and Ritson.26The resulting values of - (l/p)(dE/dx)wo as obtained by Sternheimer20n21 give a relativistic rise of 14% which saturates slowly and does not level off until T/moc2 100. The magnitude of the increase and the gradual character of the relativistic rise are in good agreement with the observations of Stiller and Shapirog2 using cosmic rays, and those of Fleming and Lordg3using cosmic-ray electrons and accelerator-produced 7-mesons. On the other hand, Budini’s calculations22*2s give a more rapid rate of rise, with GpIstbeing reached for T/moc2 between 10 and 40, depending on the specific assumptions made about the widths of the spectroscopic lines of the Ag and Br atoms of the emulsion. Budini’s calculations are in reasonable agreement with the results of Daniel et al. 9 4 which indicate a more rapid rate of rise than those of references 92 and 93. Data on the ionization loss in emulsion have also been obtained by McDiarmidlg6Michaelis and Violet,g6Morrishlg7and others. Alexander and Johnstong7ahave obtained a very accurate calibration curve for the grain density as a function of ppc for ?r and p mesons. In this work, the authors used T and p mesons of constant and precisely known energy from the K,2 and Kp2decays of K partides at rest. The calibration curve extends from p = 0.5 to0.95, corresponding to 1 < g* < 3, where g* is the grain density normalized to the minimum of ionization:
-
-
g* = (dE/dX)w,/[(dE/dX) Wolrnin.
I n the range 1 < g* < 1.6, the accuracy of the calibration curve for g* is estimated to be better than 1%. For the ratio of plateau to minimum grain count, the authors have obtained g,*l, = 1.133. Recently, J ~ n g e j a n s ~ has ’ ~ measured the relativistic rise of the grain density in Ilford G5 emulsion, using pion tracks of energy -5.4 Bev from the Berkeley Bevatron, and secondaries produced by the pions in the emulsion [pions stopping in the emulsion, with y between 1.8 and 2.5; J. R. Fleming and J. J. Lord, Phys. Rev. 92, 511 (1953). R. R. Daniel, J. H. Davies, J. H. Mulvey, and D. H. Perkins, Phil. Mag. [7]43, 753 (1952). 9 5 I. B. McDiarmid, Phys. Rev. 84, 851 (1951). 06 R. P. Michaelis and C. E. Violet, Phys. Rev. 90, 723 (1953). $7 A. H. Morrish, Phys. Rev. 91, 423 (1953). 978 G. Alexander and R. W. H. Johnston, Nuovo cimenfo [lo] 6, 363 (1957). wb B. Jongejans, Nuovo cimenlo [lo] 16, 625 (1960). 98 94
36
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
other secondary pions; electron pairs with y between 65 and 1100, where y = (T/moc2) I]. The momentum of the tracks was determined from multiple scattering measurements. For the ratio GPlat/Gmin,a value 1.129 k 0.010 was obtained, in good agreement with the results of Stiller and Shapirog2 (1.14 2 0.03), Fleming and Lordg3 (1.14 f O.Ol), and Alexander and Johnston97a (1.133 f 0.008). The rise of the grain density G to the plateau value was found to be slow, with a n appreciable increase 1000. This result is in good agreetaking place between y = 40 and y ment with the calculations of Sternheimer,20*21 and with the experiments of references 92 and 93. A calibration curve for g” versus (y - 1) is given in the paper of J0ngejans.97~This curve was calculated using a value of the excitation potential I = 501 ev for AgBr. In comparing the theory with these data for emulsion, it must be borne in mind that one would expect large fluctuations of the ionization loss in each grain, since the most probable energy loss Eprcb for a minimum ionizing particle in a 0.2 p AgBr grain is only -50 ev. On the other hand, the threshold value 7 for the energy deposit below which the grain is not exposed is of the order of several hundreds of volts. Thus the effect of Landau-type fluctuations on the grain count is expected to be quite important, as was first pointed out by BarkasI9*and subsequently by Brown.99I n view of these difficulties and limitations of the theory, the detailed quantitative agreement which has been obtained for emulsion is surprisingly good. In connection with the emulsion measurements on electron-positron pairs produced by y rays of very high energy ( E , 2 10 Bev), Perkins’** observed that there is a reduction of the ionization loss J below the value of twice minimum ionization (2Jmi,) due to the interference between the electromagnetic fields of the positron and electron. With increasing distance x from the origin of the pair, the ionization J varies form 0 to 2Jni,, as a result of the increase of the distance d between the positron and electron. Several authorslo’ have treated theoretically the problem of the ionization loss of an electron-positron pair, along the lines of Fermi’s cal~ulation’~ of the ionization loss of a single particle. The theory gives the dependence of the ionization J on the distance d. The asymptotic value 2Jmi. is attained when d becomes large compared to c/(2rvP)
+
-
W. H. Barkas, in “Colloque Bur la sensibilite des cristaur et des emulsions photographiques,” Paris, September, 1951; see also W. H. Barkas and D. M. Young, University of California, Radiation Laboratory Report URCL-2579, revised (1954). 99 L. M. Brown, Phys. Rev. 90, 95 (1953). loo D. H. Perkins, Phil. Mag. [7] 46, 1146 (1955). 1olA. E. Cudakov, Izvest. Akad. N a u k S.S.S.R. 19, 650 (1955); I. Mito and H. Ezawa, P r o p . Theoret. Phys. (Kyoto) 18, 437 (1957); G. Yekutieli, Nuovo cimento [lo] 6, 1381 (1957).
1.1.
INTERACTION OF RADIATION WITH MATTER
37
( = 0.51 X lodEcm for emulsion). Upon using the theoretical dependence of J on d, the measurements of J ( x ) enable one to obtain the value of the opening angle of the pair 0 ( = d/x), from which in turn one can estimate the energy E , of the parent y ray.lo2The results obtained by this methodLo3 are in reasonable agreement with the conventional determination of the y-ray energy from the subsequent development of the shower of electrons and y rays (see Section 1.1.5.2). Besides the experiments on photographic emulsion, crystal counters and scintillators* have also been used to observe the relativistic increase of the ionization loss of p mesons in condensed materials. The first of these experiments was carried out by Whittemore and Streeti0*in 1949, using a silver chloride crystal. These authors compared the ionization pulses produced by p mesons of range > 112 cm of P b (T, > 1.6 Bev) with those produced by minimum ionization p mesons (T, = 0.3 Bev) , and found a definite relativistic increase. The results were in agreement with the predictions of the Bethe-Bloch formula including the density effect correction. Experiments with p mesons passing through an anthracene scintillator have been performed by Bowen and Roser,lo6who obtained no detectable relativistic increase of the ionization loss Eprob above the minimum value. This result is in agreement with the theoretical predictions, since the density effect sets in at a relatively low energy (near the ionization minimum) for low atomic number, and is large enough to prevent any rise of €pro,, from occurring. Similar results were obtained by Baskin and W i n ~ k l e r using , ~ ~ ~a ~liquid ~ ~ ~scintillator of low Z (xylene). In these experiments, it is assumed that the light output of the scintillator is proportional to the energy deposited by the incident particle ( p meson). This assumption has been verified by Chou,lo8who showed that the response of most scintillators is nearly linear up to 3Jmin-4Jmi,. Millar, et al. lo9 have exposed a large-area liquid scintillation counter to cosmic-ray p mesons. The counter was filled with triethyl-benzene (plus terphenyl). The most probable loss Eprob and the Landau distribution were obtained both for T, = 0.30 Bev and T , = 2.2 Bev. The value of fprob
* See also in this volume, Chapter 1.4. A. Borsellino, Phys. Rev. 89, 1023 (1953). W. Wolter and M. Miesowice, Nuovo cimento [lo] 4, 648 (1956). lo4 W. L. Whitternore and J. C. Street, Phys. Rev. 76, 1786 (1949). 106T.Bowen and F. X. Roser, Phys. Rev. 86, 992 (1952). 108 R. Baskin and J. R. Winckler, Phys. Rev. 92, 464 (1953). 107 See also A. G. Meshkovskii and V. A. Shebanov, Doklady Akad. Nauk S.S.S.R. 83, 233 (1952). 108 C. N. Chou, Phys. Rev. 87, 903 (1952). 109 C. H. Millar, E. P. Hincks, and G. C. Hanna, Can. J . Phys. 36,54 (1958). 102
108
38
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
at 0.30 Bev is higher by (1.6 & 0.5) % than the value a t 2.2 Bev, in good agreement with Eq. (1.1.30) including the density effect correction 6. The prediction of the Landau theory for the width of the pulse-height distribution (18 % at half-maximum) is in reasonable agreement with the observed width (20.5% at half-maximum in the central area of the counter) when the width due to the counter resolution function (8%) is taken into account. Hudson and Hofstadterl'O have exposed a thallium-activated sodium iodide crystal [NaI(TI)] t o the cosmic-ray p-meson spectrum and have found that the resulting observed pulse-height distribution is in much better agreement with the theoretical distribution obtained upon inclusion of the density effect correction 6 (as calculated from the paper of Halpern and Hall's) than with a theoretical distribution obtained by setting 6 = 0. In each case, the theoretical curve was obtained by folding the Landau straggling distribution6awith the cosmic-ray p-meson spectrum. In a later investigation, Bowen'" used a NaI(T1) crystal to measure the energy loss of T- and p mesons of selected energies or energy groups. The T- mesons were produced by the Chicago 450-Mev cyclotron and had well-defined energies extending from 61 to 222 MeV. In addition, 245-Mev p- mesons arising from the decay of 227-Mev T- mesons were used. Moreover, four energy groups of the cosmic-ray p-meson spectrum were studied. These groups were separated in energy by using various thicknesses of iron absorber. The average energies of the p mesons in the four groups were: T, = 368,755,1470, and 5230 MeV. The energies of the T- from the cyclotron were: 61, 85, 118, 163, and 222 MeV. At each of these energies, the most probable loss Eprob was obtained from the observed pulse distribution. Bowen thus obtained values of epr& as a function of T/moc2. The theoretical prediction20321 for 6prab versus Tlmoc2 is in reasonable agreement with these data. Thus from the calculations one obtains an 8.2% increase (relative to minimum ionization) at T,, = 50mpc2,and an asymptotic value of the rise (at very high energies) of 11.4%. The experimental value is 10.9 5 1.0% at T, = 50m,c2. This result may indicate that eprob rises to the plateau value somewhat more rapidly than predicted by the theory. It may be noted that the reason why there is a relativistic rise of Eprob for NaI but none for anthracene or xylene is that with increasing 2, the density effect correction 6 sets in a t higher energies, thereby leading to a relativistic rise before the energy loss eprob saturates due to the onset of 6. The density effect has been extensively studied by observing the energy Hudson and R. Hofstadter, Phys. Rev. 88, 589 (1952). T. Bowen, Phys. Rev. 96, 754 (1954).
11oA. l11
1.1.
INTERACTION OF RADIATION WITH MATTER
39
loss of electrons in passing through thin foils. The straggling of the energy loss in thin foils was already clearly demonstrated in 1928 by the work of White and Millington,"2 as well as that of Madgwick.'13 More recently, Paul and Reich114measured the energy loss of 2.8-Mev and 4.7-Mev electrons in foils of Be, C, Fe, and Pb. Chen and Warshaw116showed that eprob for electrons with energies T , < 2 Mev is correctly given by Landau's theory.63 However, from their data they were unable to discriminate between the Landau distributionKaof energy losses, and the (somewhat wider) distribution of Blunck and Leisegang.66On the other hand, in the experiments of Kalil and Birkhoff,'ls an accurate comparison could be made with the Blunck-Leisegang distribution, and it was found that while for the heavy elements (e.g., Pb) this distribution is in essential agreement with the observations, for the light elements (e.g., Be) the predicted width of the distribution at half-maximum is too small by a factor of -1.8. However, the discrepancy for light elements was not observed in a more recent experiment by Hungerford and Birkhoff."' ~ ~ good ~ agreement with the BlunckKageyama et ~ 1 also. obtained Leisegang distribution for foils of Al, Cu, In, and Pb. Goldwasser, Mills, and Hansonllg have measured the energy loss of 15.7-Mev electrons in passing through thin samples of Be, polystyrene, Al, Cu, and Au. With the exception of Au, they found that good agreement for eproo could be obtained by using the asymptotic value of the density effect correction [Eq. (1.1.2Oa)l. For the case of Au, the expression for 6 for intermediate energies, Eq. (1.1.20), must be used, as was pointed out by Warner and Rohrlich.120The energy loss distributions of Goldwasser et aZ.l19 are in essential agreement with those predicted from the Landau theory.6a Goldwasser, Mills, and RobillardlZ1have obtained a direct demonstration of the density effect, by measuring the energy loss of 15.7-Mev electrons in (solid) Teflon and Kel-F, and then in the gases corresponding to Teflon and Kel-F (i.e., gases having the same chemical composition). It was found that the difference between the values of Cprob P. White, and G. Millington, Proc. Roy. SOC.A120, 701 (1928). E. Madgwick, Proc. Cambridge Phil. SOC.23, 970 (1927). 114 W. Paul and H. Reich, 2.Physik 127, 429 (1950). 116 J. J. L. Chen and S. D. Warshaw, Phys. Rev. 84, 355 (1951). 116 F. Kalil and R. D. Birkhoff, Phys. Rev. 91, 505 (1953). 117E. T. Hungerford and R. D. Birkhoff, Phys. Rev. 96, 6 (1954). 118 S. Kageyama, K. Nishimura, and Y. Onai, J . Phys. Sor. Japan 8, 682 (1953); Kageyama, S., and Nishimura, K., J . Phys. SOC.Japan 7 , 292 (1952). 119 E. L. Goldwasser, F. E. Mills, and A. 0. Hanson, Phys. Rev. 88, 1137 (1952). 120 C. Warner and F. Rohrlich, Phys. Rev. 93,406 (1954). lZ1 E.L. Goldwasser, F. E. Mills, and T. R. Robillard, Phys. Rev. 98, 1763 (1955); see also A. M. Hudson, Phys. Rev. 106, 1 (1957). 112
11*
40
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
in the solid and the gaseous phases is given by the predicted density effect correction 6. The ionization loss is rapidly becoming an important tool in bubble chamber investigations. The bubble count (number of bubbles per cm of path) is a function only of the velocity of the particle and the temperature . the ~ first ~ to~make .a systematic study of of the liquid. Glaser et ~ 1 were the bubble count as a function of the velocity of the particle, by using secondary protons and T+ mesons of momenta between 0.53 and 1.60 Bev/c from the Brookhaven Cosmotron. They found that the bubble density b is approximately proportional to 1/P2. This indicates that the bubble formation is proportional to the number of slow 6 rays (secondary elect,rons). The number of 6 rays per gm/cmZ is given by
where El' is the lower limit and Ez' is the upper limit of the energies of the 6 rays considered in ns; El' and E l are in electron volts. I n similarity to the grain count in emulsion or the drop count for cloud-chamber tracks, E 2 is taken as the energy of a S ray that has a long enough range to extend to a visible distance from the track of the incident (primary) particle. One thus obtains E2' = 50 kev. El' is taken as -3 times the mean excitation potential I of the atoms of the liquid, so that the 6 rays with energy E1' can be treated as free electrons during the collision. Thus El' is a t most a few kev, and therefore 126 is not very sensitive to the precise value of E i , since 1/Ez/ << l/El'. From their experimental data, Glaser et have obtained the following empirical expression for the bubble count b : b = (A/p2) B(T) bubbles/cm (1.1.36)
+
where A = 9.2 5 0.2 bubbles/cm for protons in propane, and B(T)is a function only of the temperature T. For propane, B C 8 at 56"C, =11 at 57"C, and B rises rapidly above 57°C to a value of =38 at 59.5"C. A is constant between 55°C and 59.5"C1but decreases rapidly below 55OC. (At 50°C no tracks are visible.) By using fast comparison tracks of known velocity, the velocity can be determined to an accuracy of 5% for proton tracks 10 cm long. ' ~ ~ suggested that instead of In a more recent paper, Willis et ~ 1 . have counting the number of bubbles along the track, the distribution of 122
D. A. Glaser, D. C. Rahm, and C. Dodd, Phys. Rev. 102, 1653 (1956);see also
G. A. Askarian, Zhur. Eksptl. i Teorel. Fiz. 30, 610 (1956);[translation: Soviet Phys. JETP 3, 4 (1056)l. 123 W.J. Willis, E. C. Fowler, and D. C. Rahm,Phys. Rev. 108, 1046 (1957).
1.1.
INTERACTION OF RADIATION WITH MATTER
41
lengths of the spaces between bubbles should be obtained. This method was found to be more accurate than the direct bubble count, because it avoids errors in the bubble counting method which are due to limited optical resolution of the images of neighboring bubbles and possible bubble coalescence. This procedure for bubble tracks is somewhat analogous to the blob count for nuclear emulsion tracks, since an aggregate of neighboring or overlapping bubbles (“blobs”) is effectively treated as a single unit. The bubble count obtained from the distribution of spacings can be fitted by the formula: b = C ( T ) / p 2 ,where C ( T )is a function only of the temperature. Willis et al. point out that a similar dependence to the 1/p2dependence of n6 is obtained by considering the restricted energy loss with maximum energy transfer WO= 70 kev, above which the 6 rays are assumed t o form separate tracks not in line with the track of the incident particle. Equation (1.1.28) for - (l/p) ( d E / d x ) w , gives a n approximate dependence l/p1,8a(in the velocity range of interest) which is experimentally indistinguishable from l/p2. Blinov et in a n experiment similar to th a t of Willis et ~1.~123 also obtain a l/p2 dependence for the bubble density as a function of velocity. 1.1.2.10. Capture and Loss of Electrons at Very Low Energies. For very low energies, the charged particle may capture an electron. Subsequently the electron may be lost again. This process is very complicated, and a complete theoretical treatment does not exist a t present. For a review of the literature on this problem, the reader is referred t o the review articles of Allison and Warshaw,60 and Bethe and Ashkin.3 A thorough discussion of the problems involved has been given by Bohr.126 From the Thomas-Fermi model, BohrlZ6has obtained the following expression for the capture cross section uc:
-
~ T U H ~ Z ~ ’ ~ ( V O /(VV > )> ~ Vo) (1.1.37) where v o = e2/h is the velocity of an electron in the first Bohr orbit of hydrogen (of radius aH),and v is the velocity of the incident particle. Equation (1.1.37) holds for heavy eIements, which have several atomic electrons with velocities vel larger than v. For light elements, where this condition is not fulfilled, Brinkman and K r a m e r P have derived the following formula for u c : UC
uc =
(2’~,/5)a,2zz(v,/v)’2
which is expected to hold for ( v / v o )
(1.1.38)
2 10.
124 G. A. Blinov, Iu. S. Krestnikov, and M. F. Lomanov, Zhur. Eksptl. i Teoret. Fiz. 31, 762 (1956); [translation: Soviet Phys. JETP 4 , 661 (1957)l. 126 N. Bohr, Kgl. Danske Videnskab. Selskab, Mat.-fys. Medd. 18, No. 8 (1948). 126 H. C. Brinkman and H. A. Kramers, Koninkl. Ned. Akad. Wetenschap., Proc. 33,
973 (1930).
42
1. PARTICLE DETECTION
The theory of the loss of electrons by a charged particle (ion) is less complicated. The cross section for loss al is of the order of r u H z S10-16 cm2 for v V O , i.e., for protons of -25 kev. uz falls off rather slowly with increasing v. The capture and loss cross sections of protons are equal (a, = u l ) for air at -20 kev and for hydrogen a t -50 kev. Above this energy, we have ae < a. For intermediate 2 values, BohrlZ6has obtained the followingestimate of a1: a1 7raH222/3(421). (1.1.39)
-
-
Thus for protons, q / a Cvaries as Z 1 / 8 T 6 for / 2 medium 2. The ratio is nearly independent of 2 and increases rapidly with energy. In agreement with this result, it is found experimentally that at predominates rapidly over ac as the energy is increased above the value (-25 kev) for which ac = a ~ . The processes of capture and loss of electrons are very important for the energy loss and range of fission fragment^.^ 1.1.2.11. The Stopping Power at Very Low Energies. For very low energies, where the velocity of the particle is less than the velocity of the atomic electrons ( T , 5 25 kev for protons), Fermi and Teller127have obtained the following expression for the energy loss: (1.1.40) where Ry is the Rydberg unit, and urn is the maximum velocity of the electrons of the substance if the latter are regarded as constituting a where TL is the number degenerate Fermi gas. Thus urn = (3~~/8?r)'/~(h/m), of electrons per ~ m Equation . ~ (1.1.40) shows that the energy loss increases with increasing v in this region, in contrast to the decrease with increasing v at higher energies ( = l / v 2 ) . Experimentally, good evidence has been obtained for the increase of the stopping power with increasing velocity a t low energies. Warshawl28 has made careful measurements of dE/dx for protons in Be, Al, Cu, Ag, and Au in the energy range from 50 to 400 kev. For all cases, he obtained a maximum of d E / d x in the neighborhood of T, = 100 kev. In the region below the maximum, an extrapolation of Warshaw's results (from -50 to -25 kev) could be well fitted by the Fermi-Teller formula. The maximum of the ionization loss dE/dx, to be denoted by J,, has the value 640 Mev/gmcm-2 for Be, where it occurs a t TP.,= 75 kev. For Al, J, = 440 Mev/gm cm+ and T,,, = 72 kev. For Cu, Ag, and Au, J , = 230, 140, and 100 Mev/gm cm-2, respectively. The corresponding values of T,,, are 140, 160, and 160 kev, respectively. 127
la*
E. Fermi and E. Teller, Phys. Rev. 73, 399 (1947). S. D.Warshaw, Phys. Rev. 76, 1759 (1949).
1.1.
INTERACTION OF RADIATION WITH MATTER
-
43
For somewhat higher energies (T, 400 kev), above T,,,, BohrlZ6has given an approximate theory based on the Thomas-Fermi model of the atom, and has obtained the following expression for the energy loss: dE-- 1 6 ~ n Z l ' ~ h e ~ -dx mu
(1.1.41)
In this region, -dE/dx goes as l / u , instead of the l / u 2 dependence which prevails at somewhat higher energies. Warshaw l Z 8has also obtained reasonable agreement of Eq. (1.1.41) with stopping power data for Cu, Ag, and Au in the range from T, = 350 to 550 kev. For a more detailed discussion of the stopping power measurements at low energies ( T , 2 2 MeV) the reader is referred to the review article of Allison and Warshaw.60 1.1.2.12. The Energy w Required to Produce an Ion Pair in a Gas. When a heavy charged particle passes through a medium, it excites and ionizes the atoms of the material. The ion pairs which are formed by direct action of the particle in the immediate vicinity of its path are called the primary ions. The most energetic of these primary ions, called delta rays, may travel a considerable distance before being themselves stopped by the medium. I n the slowing down process, the delta rays produce additional ions called secondary ions. The sum of the primary and secondary ionization constitutes the total ionization produced by the passing charged particle. It has been found experimentally that the energy w required to produce an ion pair is approximately independent of the energy and charge of the incident particle. Moreover, w does not vary appreciably for different gases, all values being of the order of 25-35 ev/ion pair. Typical values of w, obtained by Jesse and S a d a ~ k i s are ' ~ ~ as follows: 36.3 ev for H2, 42.3 ev for He, 35.0 ev for N2, 26.4 ev for Ar, 34.0 ev for air, and 32.9 ev for COz. Fano130has proposed a theory which explains both the fact that w is independent of the energy and charge of the incident particle, and also the smallness of the variation of w with the atomic number 2. The constancy of w as a function of E has been widely used in ionization chambers for the determination of the energy of particles. Thus if a particle is stopped in the gas of an ionization chamber, its initial energy is proportional to the total number of ions produced, which can be electronically measured by means of a linear amplifier. It is necessary to know the value of w for the gas in the ionization chamber; w can be determined by measuring the number of ions produced by a particle whose lZ9 W. P. Jesse and J. Sadaukis, Phys. Rev. 107, 766 (1957); see also T. E. Bortner and G. S. Hurst, Phys. Rev. 95, 1236 (1954); R. H. Frost and C. E. Nielsen, Phys. Rev. 91, 864 (1953). u0U. Fano, Phys. Rev. 70, 44 (1946); 72, 26 (1947).
44
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
energy is known by other means (e.g., natural a particle or particle originating from an exothermic nuclear reaction). 1.1.3. Range-Energy Relations The mean range R of a particle of kinetic energy TI is given by (1.1.42) where -(l/p)(dE/dx) is the average energy loss as obtained from Eq. (1.1.1) or (1.1.19). In this section, we shall restrict ourselves to particles heavier than electrons, since the range of high-energy electrons is determined by the bremsstrahlung and shower production rather than the ionization loss, as will be discussed in Section 1.1.5 [see Eqs. (1.1.81) and (1.1.82)]. 1.1.3.1. Summary of Range-Energy Relations. Range energy relations have been obtained by several authors. I n 1937, Livingston and Bethe36 published range-energy relations for protons, deuterons, and a particles in air. In obtaining these results, various experimental data on the ranges of natural a particles were used. The ranges of a particles and protons are related by (1.1.43) R,(T,) = 1.0072 R,(3.971 T,) - 0.20 cm where R,(T,) is the proton range for an energy T p ( E*T,), and R,(T,) is the a-particle range for an energy T,; 1.0072 = za2(mp/ma);3.971 = (m,/m,) [Eq. (1.1.44)], and the constant term131-0.20 cm is due to the capture and loss of electrons at low energies which has a somewhat different effect on a particles and protons. The proton range-energy relation of Livingston and Bethe extends up to 15 MeV. In 1947, Smith1S2obtained range-energy relations for protons up to 10 Bev, both for air and aluminum. For air, Smith used the same value of I as Livingston and Bethe:36 Iair = 80.5 ev; for Al, Wilson’s value3’ l a l = 150 ev was used. Somewhat later, Aron el aL2 calculated proton range-energy relations for a number of metals and gases, up to 10 Bev, using a value of I = 11.52 ev, which was essentially derived from Wilson’s result for Al. The calculations of Aron et al. as well as those of Smith neglect the density effect, which becomes important for proton energies T, above -2 Bev. The tables of Aron et al. have been extended by Rich and made^.'^^ A summary of the range measurements at various energies has been given by Bethe and A s h k h 3 P. M. S. Blackett and L. Lees, Pmc. Roy. SOC.A134, 658 (1932). J. H. Smith, Phys. Rev. 71,32 (1947). l a 3M. Rich and R. Madey, University of California Radiation Laboratory Report UCRL-2301 (1954). l31
182
1.1.
INTERACTION OF RADIATION WITH MATTER
45
There have been several determinations of the range-energy relation for nuclear emulsion. In 1953, V i g n e r ~ n 'obtained ~~ a range-energy relation, based on older data, particularly those of R ~ t b l a t , and ' ~ ~ Cuer and Jung. l3-5 Vigneron's results were later extended by Barkas and Young.137 Calculations of the range-energy relation for high energies, including the density effect correction in dE/dx, have been carried out by Baroni et ~ 1 . Friedlander, l ~ ~ Keefe, and M e n ~ n , ' ~have ~ " made a comparison of the ranges in emulsion and in aluminum for protons of energies 87, 118, and 146 MeV. Recently, Barkas and his c o - w o r k e r ~have ~ ~ ~ made very extensive measurements of the ranges in Ilford G5 emulsion, taking into account the effect of the water content of the emulsion on the rangeenergy relation. The water content determines the density of the emulsion. Barkas140 has calculated a new and very accurate range-energy relation for Ilford G5 emulsion for a "standard density" of 3.815 gm/cm3, and has given the correction which must be applied to ranges measured under nonstandard conditions to obtain the corresponding ranges for the standard density (and hence the energy of the particle). In obtaining the values of d E / d x used in calculating the range [Eq. (1.1.42)], Barkas has included both the shell correction U at low energies and the density effect correction 6 a t high energies. The mean excitation potential I was used as an adjustable parameter, to be determined so as to give the best fit of R ( T ) t o the available range measurements. I n this manner, a value I = 331 f 6 ev was obtained, which gives an average I / Z = 12.1 & 0.2 ev for the elements of emulsion (excluding the hydrogen). This value of I/2 is in good agreement with the recent results of Bichsel el aL4' and of Burkig and M a c K e n ~ i e . ~ ~ 1.1.3.2. Calculations of the Range-Energy Relations of Protons for 6 Substances. As mentioned above, the range-energy tables of Aron et aL2 do not take into account the density effect correction 6. Moreover, these tables were calculated for an excitation potential I = 11.52 ev, which is somewhat lower than the most recent value, I 12.5-132 ev, as obtained
-
l a 4 L.
Vigneron, J. phys. radium 14, 145 (1953) J. Rotblat, Nature 167, 550 (1951). 136 P. Cuer and J. J. Jung, Sci. et ind. phof. 22, 401 (1951). 137 W. H. Barkas and D. M. Young, University of California Radiation Laboratory Report UCRL-2579, revised (1954). 188 G. Baroni, C. Castagnoli, G. Cortini, C. Franzinetti, and A. Manfredini, Report BS-9, Istituto di Fisica dell'Universit8, Rome, 1954. la*s M. W. Friedlander, D. Keefe, and M. G . K. Menon, Nuovo cimenfo [lo] 6, 461 (1957). 189 W. H. Barkas, P. H. Barrett, P. Cuer, H. H. Heckman, F. M. Smith, and H. K. Ticho, Phys. Rev. 102, 583 (1956); Nuovo cimento [lo] 8, 185 (1958). $40 W. H. Barkas, Nuovo cimento [lo] 8, 201 (1958). la6
46
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
from references 47 and 49. Sternheimer' has carried out calculations to determine new range-energy relations for some of the commonly used materials, using the higher I values and including the density effect correction. Range-energy relations have been obtained for 6 substances : Be, C, Al, Cu, Pb, and air, for proton energies T , from 2 Mev to 100 Bev. The reason for choosing 100 Bev as the upper limit of the tables is th a t 10 Bev, upon this enables one to obtain pmeson ranges u p to T, applying a small correction for the fact th at the maximum energy transfer W,,, becomes slightly dependent on the mass ratio m,/m a t the highest energies considered. This correction will be given below. The ranges obtained in this work' are -1 to -9% higher for T , = 10 Bev than t,hose of Aron et aL2 and of Smith.132 The largest differences occur for Be (9.2%) and C (6.4%). Details of the calculations of the ranges are given in reference 1. The values of - ( l / p ) ( d E / d z ) were calculated from Eq. (1.1.1). The mean excitation potentials I were obtained from the work of C a l d ~ e 1 1 , ~ ~ . ~ ~ following I values were Bichsel et U Z . , ~ ~and Burkig and M a ~ K e n z i eThe used: IBe = 64 ev, Ic = 78 ev, Iair= 94 ev, IAl= 166 ev, Icu = 371 ev, and Ipb= 1070 ev. The density effect correction 6 was evaluated from the calculations of Sternheimer.20*21 The K and L shell corrections C K and CL a t low energies were obtained from Walske's Table I1
-
TABLE 11. Values of the Constants Used t o Obtain the Ionization Loss' Z is the mean excitation potential. A and B are the constants appearing in Eq. (1.1.19). C, a, s, X O ,and XI enter into the expression for the density effect correction 6 [Eqs. (1.1.20)and (1.1.2Oa)l. Material Z (ev) A
Be C A1 Cu
Pb Air
64 78 166 371 1070 94
(s) B
0.0681 0.0768 0.0740 0.0701 0.0608 0.0768
18.64 18.25 16.73 15.13 13.01 17.89
-C
2.83 3.18 4.25 4.71 6.73 10.70
a
S
0.413 0.509 0.110 0.118 0.0542 0.126
2.82 2.67 3.34 3.38 3.52 3.72
xo
XI
-0.10 -0.05 0.05 0.20 0.40 1.87
2 2 3 3 4 4
gives the values of the constants which were used in the calculation of the ionization loss [Eq. (1.1.19)] and the density effect correction 6 [Eqs. (1.1.20) and (1.1.2Oa)l. Table I11 gives the values of - (l/p)(dE/dx) for protons. The resulting range-energy relations are presented in Table IV. Recently Sternheimer140ahas derived an expression for the rangeenergy relation R(T,) for protons as a function of the mean excitation 140s
R. M. Sternheimer, Phys. Rev. 118. 1045 (1960).
1.1. I N T E R A C T I O N
O F RADIATION W I T H MATTER
47
TABLE 111. Values of the Ionization Loss -(l/p)(dE/dz) (in Mev/gm crn-l) for Protons in Be, C, Al, Cu, Pb, and Air1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 12 14 16 18 20 22.5 25 27.5 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75 80 90 100 110 120 130 140 150 160 180 200 225 250 275 300 325 350 375
131.9 97.45 78.06 65.59 56.69 50.15 45.03 40.99 37.63 32.44 28.62 25.65 23.30 21.38 19.41 17.80 16.47 15.34 13.53 12.15 11.05 10.15 9.412 8.788 8.254 7.791 7.385 7.026 6.424 5.933 5.527 5.187 4.896 4.644 4.424 4.232 3.908 3.647 3.384 3.173 3.000 2.853 2.730 2.625 2.534
140.6 104.4 83.97 70.74 61.29 54.28 48.81 44.47 40.87 35.29 31.17 27.96 25.42 23 34 21.21 19.46 18.01 16.79 14.82 13.32 12.12 11.14 10.33 9.645 9.062 8.556 8.112 7.719 7.061 6.526 6.079 5.706 5.388 5.112 4.872 4.659 4.304 4.016 3.728 3.497 3.307 3.148 3.013 2.896 2.797
A1
cu
Pb
Air
110.8 83.16 67.44 57.19 49.84 44.38 40.09 36.67 33.80 29.35 26.04 23.45 21.39 19.70 17.95 16.52 15.32 14.31 12.67 11.41 10.41 9.584 8.902 8.325 7.831 7.402 7.026 6.693 6.132 5.674 5.292 4.973 4.700 4.464 4.258 4.077 3.768 3.522 3.272 3.072 2.908 2.771 2.655 2.555 2.469
78.93 61.83 51.27 44.08 38.73 34.71 31.50 28.94 26.77 23.38 20.83 18.82 17.22 15.91 14.54 13.42 12.48 11.68 10.38 9.383 8.584 7.925 7.378 6.914 6.514 6.167 5.861 5.590 5.133 4.760 4.449 4.187 3.961 3.767 3.594 3.445 3.192 2.989 2.783 2.616 2.480 2.366 2.268 2.185 2.112
41.14 34.62 29.85 26.36 23.65 21.54 19.81 18.40 17.18 15.23 13.73 12.52 11.54 10.73 9.874 9.163 8.564 8.050 7.203 6.548 6.020 5.581 5.213 4,900 4.629 4.391 4.181 3.996 3.682 3.424 3.209 3.027 2.870 2.734 2.616 2.511 2.333 2.189 2.042 1.924 1.828 1.747 1.678 1.619 1.568
134.0 99.86 80.53 68.00 58.99 52.32 47.11 42.96 39.51 34.15 30.20 27.10 24.66 22.66 20.61 18.93 17.53 16.35 14.44 12.98 11.82 10.87 10.09 9.420 8.852 8.360 7.928 7.546 6.904 6.382 5.950 5.587 5.276 5.007 4.773 4.567 4.221 3.942 3.660 3.434 3.248 3.093 3.961 2.848 2.751
48
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
TABLE 111. Values of the Ionization Loss - (l/p) ( d E / d x ) (in Mev/gm crn-)) for Protons in Be, C, Al, Cu, Pb, and Air1 (Continued)
400 450 500 550 600 700 800 900 1000 1250 1500 1750 2000 2250 2500 2750 3000 3500 4000 4500 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000 10,000 12,500 15,000 17,500 20,000 22,500 25,000 27,500 30,000 40,000 50,000 60,000 70,000 80,000 90,000 100,000
2.453 2.321 2.215 2.129 2.059 1.950 1.871 1.812 1.767 1.692 1.649 1.623 1.608 1.599 1.595 1.593 1.593 1.597 1.604 1.612 1.621 1.638 1.655 1.670 1.685 1.699 1.728 1.753 1.774 1.792 1.808 1.822 1.835 1.847 1.886 1.915 1.939 1.959 1.976 1,991 2.005
2.709 2.563 2.448 2.355 2.278 2.159 2.074 2.009 1.960 1.879 1.833 1.806 1.791 1.782 1.778 1.777 1.778 1.784 1.793 1.802 1.813 1.834 1.854 1.873 1.890 1.905 1.939 1.968 1.993 2.014 2.033 2.050 2.065 2.077 2.122 2.156 2.183 2.206 2.225 2.242 2.257
2.392 2.268 2.169 2.090 2.022 1.921 13 4 9 1.795 1.754 1.687 1.649 1.629 1.618 1.613 1.611 1.613 1.615 1.624 1.635 1.647 1.659 1.682 1.704 1.724 1.743 1.759 1.796 1.827 1.853 1.876 1.895 1.913 1.929 1.944 1.991 2.027 2.056 2.080 2.100 2.118 2.134
2.049 1.945 1.863 1.795 1.741 1.658 1.598 1.555 1.522 1.471 1.443 1.429 1.422 1.420 1.422 1.425 1.429 1.440 1.452 1.465 1.478 1.502 1.524 1.544 1.562 1.579 1.615 1.645 1.671 1.693 1.712 1.729 1.745 1.759 1.804 1.839 1.866 1.890 1.909 1.926 1.941
1.523 1.448 1.390 1.343 1.305 1.246 1.205 1.175 1.153 1.120 1.104 1.099 1.099 1.102 1.108 1.114 1.121 1.135 1.150 1.164 1.178 1.204 1.227 1.248 1.267 1.284 1.321 1.351 1.377 1.399 1.418 1.436 1.451 1.465 1.511 1.546 1.574 1.597 1.616 1.633 1.648
2.666 2.524 2.413 2.323 2.249 2.136 2.055 1.995 1.950 1.877 1.838 1.819 1.809 1.806 1.808 1.812 1.818 1.834 1.851 1.870 1.889 1.924 1.958 1.989 2.017 2.044 2.102 2.151 2.194 2.232 2.265 2.296 2.323 2.348 2.433 2.499 2.552 2.597 2.631 2.661 2.687
1.1.
INTERACTION O F RADIATION W I T H MATTER
49
TULE IV. Range-Energy Relations for Protons in Be, C, Al, Cu, Pb, and Air1 The range R is given in grn cm-z.
TP (MeV) 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 12 14 16 18 20 22.5 25 27.5 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75 80 90 100 110 120 130 140 150 160 180 200 225 250 275 300 325 350 375
Be
C
A1
cu
Pb
Air
0.0091 0.0180 0.0296 0.0436 0.0601 0.0789 0.0999 0.1232 0.1487 0.2061 0.2719 0.3459 0.4278 0.5175 0.6404 0.7750 0.9212 1.079 1.426 1.817 2.249 2.722 3.234 3.784 4.371 4.995 5.655 6.349 7.840 9.461 11.21 13.08 15.06 17.16 19.37 21.68 26.61 31.91 39.03 46.67 54.78 63.33 72.30 81.64 91.34
0.0084 0.0168 0.0275 0,0406 0.0558 0.0732 0.0926 0.1141 0.1376 0.1904 0.2508 0.3187 0.3937 0.4759 0.5884 0.7116 0.8452 0.9891 1.307 1.663 2.057 2.488 2.954 3.456 3.991 4.559 5.160 5.792 7.148 8.623 10.21 11.91 13.72 15.62 17.63 19.73 24.20 29.02 35.49 42.42 49.77 57.53 65.65 74.12 82.91
0.0115 0.0221 0.0355 0.0517 0.0704 0.0917 0.1155 0.1416 0.1700 0.2337 0.3062 0.3872 0.4766 0.5742 0.7073 0.8526 1.010 1.179 1.551 1.967 2.427 2.928 3.469 4.051 4.670 5.327 6.021 6.750 8.313 10.01 11.84 13.79 15.86 18.04 20.34 22.74 27.85 33.34 40.72 48.61 56.98 65.79 75.02 84.62 94.58
0,0190 0.0335 0.0513 0.0724 0.0967 0.1240 0.1542 0.1874 0.2234 0.3035 0.3943 0.4954 0.6066 0.7276 0.8922 1.071 1.265 1.472 1.927 2.434 2.992 3.599 4.253 4.954 5.699 6.488 7.321 8.195 10.06 12.09 14.27 16.58 19.04 21.63 24.35 27.19 33.23 39.71 48.39 57.66 67.49 77.82 88.61 99.85 111.5
0.0410 0.0676 0.0988 0.1345 0.1746 0.2190 0.2674 0.3198 0.3761 0.5000 0.6385 0.7912 0.9576 1.138 1.381 1.644 1.926 2.229 2,885 3.614 4.411 5.275 6.202 7.192 8.243 9.352 10.52 11.74 14.35 17.17 20.19 23.40 26.80 30.37 34.11 38.02 46.29 55.14 66.98 79.61 92.95 107.0 121.6 136.7 152.4
0.0087 0.0175 0.0287 0.0423 0.0581 0.0761 0.0963 0.1185 0.1428 0.1974 0.2598 0.3299 0.4073 0.4920 0.6078 0.7346 0.8720 1.020 1.346 1.712 2.116 2.557 3.035 3.549 4.097 4.678 5.293 5.940 7.327 8.835 10.46 12.20 14.04 15.99 18.03 20.17 24.73 29.64 36.23 43.29 50.79 58.68 66.95 75.56 84.50
50
1.
P AR T I C L E DETECTION
TABLE IV. Range-Energy Relations for Protons in Be, C, Al, Cu, Pb, and Air1 (Continued)
400 450 500 550 600 700 800 900 1000 1250 1500 1750 2000 2250 2500 2750 3000 3500 4000 4500 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000 10,000 12,500 15,000 17,500 20,000 22,500 25 ,000 27 ,500 30,000 40 ,000 50,000 60,000 70,000 80,000 90,000 100,000
101.4 122.3 144.4 167.5 191.3 241.3 293.7 348.1 404.0 548.9 698.8 851.7 1007 1163 1319 1476 1633 1946 2259 2570 2879 3493 4100 4702 5298 5889 7347 8784 10,202 11,604 12,993 14,370 15,737 17,095 22,450 27,711 32 ,899 38,030 43,112 48,152 53 , 158
91.99 111.0 131.0 151.8 173.4 218.6 265.9 314.9 365.3 495.8 630.7 768.2 907.3 1047 1188 1328 1469 1750 2029 2308 2584 3133 3675 4212 4743 5270 6570 7850 9112 10,359 11,595 12,820 14,036 15,243 20,003 24,677 29,286 33,843 38,356 42 ,833 47,278
104.9 126.4 148.9 172.4 196.7 247.6 300.7 355.6 412.0 557.7 707.7 860.4 1014 1169 1324 1479 1634 1943 2250 2555 2857 3456 4046 4629 5206 5777 7183 8563 9922 11,262 12 ,588 13,901 15,202 16 ,494 21,574 26,550 31 ,448 36,284 41,067 45,807 50,509
123.5 148.6 174.9 202.2 230.5 289.5 350.9 414.4 479.4 646.8 818.7 992.9 1168 1344 1520 1696 1871 2220 2566 2908 3248 3919 4580 5232 5876 6512 8077 9610 11,117 12,604 14,072 15,525 16,964 18,391 24,002 29,491 34 ,888 40,214 45,477 50,692 55,863
Pb
Air
168.6 202.3 237.6 274.2 312.0 390.5 472.2 556.3 642.2 862.7 1088 1315 1543 1770 1996 222 1 2445 2888 3326 3758 4185 5024 5847 6655 7450 8234 10,153 12,023 13,856 15,657 17,432 19,184 20,915 22,629 29,344 35,883 42,290 48,596 54,820 60 ,975 67,070
93.73 113.0 133.3 154.4 176.3 222.0 269.8 319.2 370.0 500.9 635.7 772.5 910.3 1049 1187 1325 1463 1737 2008 2277 2543 3067 3583 4089 4589 5081 6287 7462 8612 9742 10,853 11,950 13,032 14,102 18,282 22 ,336 26,295 30,177 34,002 37,781 41,519
1.1.
INTERACTION O F RADIATION W I T H MATTER
51
potential I . The expression for R(T,) is obtained by an interpolation of the previously calculated range-energy relations’ for Be, Al, Cu, and P b (see Table IV). The result for R(T,) is accurate to within 1% for values of I between 60 and 1100 ev. The expression for R(T,) can be used to calculate the range-energy relation for any substance, provided a n appropriate value of I is assumed. 1.1.3.3. Range-Energy Relations for Particles other than Protons. The Correction Factor Fi. The range R for any other particle i (heavier than an electron) with energy Tican be obtained from the proton ranges of Table IV by means of the relation
(tl)
R;(Ti) = - - R, zi2
)
3 Ti F i
(mi
( 1.1.44)
where z, is the charge of the particle, mi is its mass, mp = proton mass, and R,[(mp/m,) Ti] is the proton range for the appropriate energy (m,/m,) Ti. I n Eq. (1.1.44), the factor Fi corrects for the slight dependence of the maximum energy transfer W,,, on mi a t very high energies. Thus Wmax for 1.1, T , and K mesons is slightly smaller than for protons with the same value of yi = Ei/mic2, where Ei is the total energy (including rest mass) of the particle. Hence - (l/p) (dE/dz) is decreased and the range Riis slightly increased for mesons (Fi > 1). From Eqs. (1.1.1) and (1.1.15), one finds that the change of - (l/p)(dE/dz) is given by
Values of F, for p mesons are given in Table V. These values were obtained’ by numerical integration of Eq. (1.1.42) with - (l/p) (dE/dz) calculated from the appropriate W,,, for p mesons. Table V shows that the correction for 1.1 mesons is very small ( F , - 1 5 0.01), and that the values of F , are practically independent of 2, being nearly the same for Be and Pb. For 7r and K mesons, the corrections F , and F K are not tabulated, since one will not generally be interested in the ranges of these particles for y i 2 5 , in view of the large probability that they will interact before coming t o the end of the range. Actually for a given yi, the corrections are even smaller than for 1.1 mesons. Thus for Pb, F , = 1.0095 for Y~ = 100, and F K = 1.0017 for Y K = 100. It should be noted that a t very high energies [E >> (mi2/m)c2], spindependent effects on the energy loss in close collisions will be present,141 which are not included in the Bethe-Bloch formula. 1.1.3.4. Range Straggling. When a beam of particles loses energy by 141 See, for example, B. Rossi, York, 1952.
“
High-Energy Particles,” p. 14. Prentice-Hall, New
1.
52
PARTICLE DETECTION
TABLE V. Values of the Factor F, Which Enters into the Expression for the p-Meson Range R,, at Very High Energies [Eq. (1.1.44)11 F,, is given for Be and Pb, as a function of 7, = E,/m,,ea.
4 6
8 10 15 20 25 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
1.0013 1.0017 1.0021 1.0025 1.0032 1.0039 1.0047 1.0054 1.0066 1 -0077 1.0088 1.0098 1.0107 1.0116 1.0125
1.0010 1.0014 1.0017 1,0020 1.0027 1.0034 1,0041 1.0047 1.0058 1.0068 1.0079 1.0089 1.0098 1.0107 1.0115
ionization, all of the particles do not come to the end of their range and stop after traversing the same thickness of material. Instead there is a distribution of the ranges due to the statistical nature of the ionization loss process. This distribution is a Gaussian. The probability p(R) dR of a particle of well-defined initial energy T ohaving a range between R and R 4-dR is given by
p(R)dR
= __ 1 cYT1'2
[
exp - ( R
a~0)2] dR
(1.1.46)
where CY'
E
2(R - RQ);,= 2Jp(R)(R- Ro)'dR.
(1.1.47)
In Eqs. (1.1.46) and (1.1.47), Ro is the mean range142obtained above [Eq. (1.1.42)]by integration over the average energy loss - (l/p)(dE/dx). An approximate equation for ( R - Ro);, has been obtained by Bohr.12 For sufficiently large initial velocities v of the particle (2mv2 2 I K , where IK is the ionization potential of the K shell), Bohr's formula gives
loTo ( d E / d ~ )dT -~
( R - Ro);, = 4re4z2NZ
(1.1.48)
where T Ois the initial energy of the particle, N = number of stopping atoms per ema, and Z = atomic number of stopping material. I n practice, it is difficult to obtain directly the value of ( R - RO);, from the observed distribution of ranges. Instead one obtains the number142 See
also H. W. Lewis, Phys. Rev. 86, 20 (1952); U. Fano, ibid. 92, 328 (1953).
1.1.
INTERACTION O F RADIATION W I T H MATTER
53
FIG.6. Schematic number-distance curve, showing RQ, Rextrand S (cf. Bethe and Ashkin, reference 3, p. 246, Fig. 15b).
distance curve by plotting the number of particles which survive as a function of the thickness traversed. An example of such a curve is shown in Fig. 6. From the Gaussian of Eq. (1.1.46), one finds that the curve of N has half its maximum value, N = +No, at R = Ro,the mean range of the particles which are assumed t o be initially homogeneous in energy. Moreover, a t R = Ro,the theoretical curve of N versus R has its maximum slope, - (1/ad2).By drawing a tangent to the N versus R curve a t its steepest point ( R = Ro)and obtaining the intersection of the tangent with the R axis (see Fig. 6), one finds the extrapolated range, Re,,,, which is given by (1.1.49) Re,,= = RO TT 1 112a.
+
The difference Rextr- ROis defined3 as the straggling parameter S. Thus
S2 = h a 2 = +(R - Ro);,
(1.1.50)
and the distribution function p(R)dR [see Eq. (1.1.46)] can be written as f o l l o ~ s : ~ 1 (1J.51) p(R)dR = - exp ( R - R d 2 ]dR. 2s
[ (&)
The value of ( R - Ro);, obtained from the measured S by means of Eq. (1.1.50) can be compared with the theoretical expression, Eq. (1.1.48). Good agreement has been obtained in several experiments. As an example, the calculated percentage straggling of protons in 100S/Ro decreases slowly from 2.29 for RO= 5 cm, to 2.13 a t 149 H. A. Bethe and J. Ashkin, in “Experimental Nuclear Physics” (E. SegrB, ed.), Vol. 1, p. 244. Wiley, New York, 1953.
54
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
10 cm, 1.78 at 100 cm, 1.57 a t lo3 cm, 1.31 a t lo4cm, and 0.97 a t lo5em. Millburn and S ~ h e c t e r 'have ~ ~ found experimentally that SIRo varies very slowly with 2. Thus the value of SIR0 relative t o copper is 0.90 for Be, 0.95 for Al, 1.02 for Ag, and 1.06 for Pb. The range straggling in emulsion has been thoroughly investigated by Barkas et U Z . , ' ~ ~ who used protons and T+, T - , and p+ mesons, These authors have found that the Bohr formula [Eq. (1.1.48)] gives reasonable agreement with their data. They have also discussed various additional straggling effects which are present in range measurements with nuclear emulsion. Values of the range straggling for six substances (Be, C, Al, Cu, Pb, and air) have been recently calculated by Sternheimer.'45a In these calculations, the following expression for ( R - Ro)i,was used:
Equation (1.1.48a) differs from the Bohr formula [Eq. (1.1.48)] by the inclusion of the following factors in the integrand: (1) the factor (1 - &P2)/ (1 - pz), which is a relativistic correction that was first derived b y Lindhard and S ~ h a r f f (2) ; ~ ~the factor [l (2m/mi)y]-' which is derived in reference 145a, and which becomes important only for very high energies (y >, mi/2m); (3) the correction factor K which takes into account the effects of binding on the atomic electrons a t low velocities of the incident particle [v 5 (IK/2m)1'2].The correction K is similar to the binding effect corrections C K and CL which enter into the Bethe-Bloch formula [Eq. (1.1.34)]. K becomes 1 for sufficiently high energies ( T , 2 100 Mev for Al; 400 Mev for Pb). The expression for K has been obtained by Bethe.3v36 / R ~ The percentage range straggling t = 100[(R - R O ) ~ " ~decreases with increasing energy until a minimum is reached for T,/mLc2 2.5, which is in the same region as the minimum of the ionization loss d E / d x . Beyond the minimum, e increases with energy, as a result of the effect of the factor (1 - p2)-' in the integrand of (1.1.48a). We note th a t c as defined above is related to S by: t = 100(2/~)"~S/Ro.As a n example, for p mesons in Cu, e, decreases from 3.94 a t T , = 10 Mev to a minimum of 2.69 a t 280 MeV, and then increases to 3.07 at T, = 1 Bev, 4.07 at 3 Bev, and 5.74 a t 10 Bev. It is that B is almost independent of 2, showing only a small increase in going from Be to Pb (at a constant
+
-
144 G. P. Millburn and L. Schecter, University of California Radiation Laboratory Report UCRL-2234, revised (1953). l P sW. H. Barkas, F. M. Smith, and W. Birnbaum, Phys. Reu. 98, 605 (1955). 145B R. M.Sternheimer, Phye. Rev. 117, 485 (1960).
1.1.
INTERACTION O F RADIATION W I T H MATTER
55
energy T). As an example, for 300-Mev protons, Q,(Z)/~,(CU) is 0.885 for Be, 0.895 for C, 0.941 for Al, and 1.113 for Pb.
1.1.4. Scattering of Heavy Particles by Atoms For nonrelativistic velocities, the Rutherford formula for the elastic scattering of heavy particles by nuclei of charge Z e is given b y d@Ll(B.) =
2?re422Z2sin e de 16T2s i n 4 ( p )
(1.1.52)
where d% is the differential cross section, e is the scattering angle, ze is the charge of the particle, and T is its nonrelativistic kinetic energy. Equation (1.1.52) can also be written (1.1.53) where TYevis T in units MeV. For the scattering of identical particles of spin the M ~ t t formula l ~ ~ gives for the cross section:
a%(@)=
2T24e4 cos f? sin T2
e de 1 -~ [sin4
L
-
1
e +X e
1 cos sin2 e cos2 e
+ (protons, electrons),
tz
In tan2 e)].
(1.1.54)
The last term in the square bracket (involving ti) arises from the quantummechanical exchange phenomena which are a consequence of the identity of the incident particle and the scatterer. I n the inelastic collisions of heavy charged particles with atoms, it is of interest t o obtain the energy distribution of the secondary electrons (6 rays). The angle of ejection $ in the laboratory system is related as follows t o the energy W of the secondary electron:
W
=
(1.1.55)
2 mu2 cos2 $
where m = electron mass, v = velocity of incident heavy particle. The maximum value of $ is 90’ in which case W = 0. The cross section for ejection of a 6 ray with energy between W and W dW is
+
(1.1.56) 148 N. F. Mott, Proc. Roy. Soc. Al26, 259 (1930); see also N. F. Mott and H. S. W . Massey, “The Theory of Atomic Collisions,” 2nd ed. Oxford Univ. Press, London and New York, 1949.
56
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
The cross section for finding a 6 ray between $ and $
+ d$ is (1.1.57)
For relativistic energies, BhabhaZ3has shown that the collision cross section for a particle with spin 0 is given by ( 1.1.58)
where W,,, is the maximum possible energy transfer to the atomic electrons [Eq. (1.1.15)]. Of course, for p+ 0, Eq. (1.1.58) reduces to the nonrelativistic expression (1.1.56). It may also be remarked that for energy transfers W << W-,, Eq. (1.1.58) gives the same result for d@ as Eq. (1.1.56). In this important case, there are no relativistic corrections to the Rutherford formula. 1.1.5. Passage of Electrons through Matter
Electrons passing through matter lose energy by ionization and excitation of the atomic electrons of the medium, in the same manner as heavy particles. The expression for the ionization loss of electrons has been discussed in Section 1.1.2.7 [Eq. (1.1.32)]. However, in addition, for highenergy electrons, there is the possibility of radiation in the field of the nucleus (bremmsstrahlung). Above a certain energy, called the critical energy E,, the radiation loss predominates over the ionization loss, whereas for E < E,, the ionization loss is the dominant mechanism of energy loss. 1.1.5.1. Radiation by Electrons (Brernsstrahlung). The energy distribution and total cross section for the bremsstrahlung depend strongly on whether the field of the nucleus is effectively screened by the atomic electrons. Thus if the effective impact parameter b is small compared to the atomic radius a U,Z-'/~(aa = Bohr radius), there is essentially no screening, whereas for b >> a, the screening is virtually complete. The relevant parameter for the screening is E, defined by
-
(1.1.59) where Eois the initial total energy of the electron, E is its final energy, and hv (= Eo - E ) is the energy of the radiated quantum. For 5 >> 1, there is no screening, and the energy distribution of the radiation, as obtained
1.1.
INTERACTION O F RADIATION WITH MATTER
by Bethe and Heitler,14' is given by
@(Eo,v) dv
= 4 Z 2 r 0 2d-v ~
137 v
[ 1 + )(':
-
"1
- --
3 Eo
[In
("") - i] mc2hv
57
(1.1.60)
where T O = e2/mc2is the classical electron radius. For 5 = 0, we have complete screening, and @(EO,v)is given by
Equations (1.1.60) and (1.1.61) give only the probability of radiation in the field of the nucleus. There is also some radiation in the field of the atomic electrons. This contribution *el is of the order of 1/Z of the nuclear contribution. For the case of complete screening, Wheeler and Lamb148 have derived the following expression for the energy distribution : 4zr02 dv @,~(Eo,zJ) d v = __ 137 Y
([
1+
( : J 2
_--
3 Eo (1.1.62)
The bremsstrahlung in the field of the atomic electrons, in the limit of no screening, has been investigated by Borsellin0,'~9 Votruba,160Rohrlich, 161 Nemirovsky,162and Watson.lK3 Figure 7 shows the energy distribution of the photons from the bremsstrahlung as a function of the photon energy hv divided by the kinetic energy To of the incident electron. The curves pertain to various values of To/mc2 and were taken from the work of Bethe and Heitler.I4' These curves pertain to lead and include the effect of screening. It may be noted that the function plotted is the frequency distribution of the energy radiated hv@[in units mc25,see Eq. (1.1.66)]. This distribution approaches a constant value as v + 0, in contrast to the probability distribution 147 H. A. Bethe and W. Heitler, Proc. Roy. SOC. A146, 83 (1934); for a discussion of the screening, see also W. Heitler, "The Quantum Theory of Radiation," 2nd ed., p. 168. Oxford Univ. Press, London and New York, 1944. 14* J. A. Wheeler and W. E. Lamb, Phys. Rev. 66, 858 (1939). 149 A. Borsellino, Nuovo cimento [9] 4, 112 (1947); Rev. univ. nuc. Tucumdn Ser. A . Mat. y $8. ledrica A6, 7 (1947). 160 V . Votruba, Phys. Rev. 73, 1468 (1948). l61F. Rohrlich, Phys. Rev. 96, 657 (1954); see also J. M. Jauch and F. Rohrlich, I' The Theory of Photons and Electrons," p. 249. Addison-Wesley, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1955; F. Rohrlich and J. Joseph, Phys. Rev. 100, 1241 (1955); J. Joseph and F. Rohrlich, Revs. Modern Phys. 30, 354 (1958). 162 P. Nemirovsky, J. Phys. U.S.S.R. 11, 94 (1947). 16 3 K. M. Watson, Phys. Rev. 72, 1060 (1947).
58
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
itself, which behaves as 1 / v for small frequencies v. Figure 7 shows th a t for small To, the energy distribution hv4, decreases uniformly as hv is inhv9 decreases less rapidly near creased from 0 t o TO.With increasing TO, Y = 0, with the main decrease occurring close to the maximum value hv = TO.For any finite T O 9 , becomes 0 a t hv = TO.T h e value of hv4, at 20mc2h). v = 0 is independent of To (hva
hv/To
FIG. 7. Energy distribution of bremsstrahlung emitted by a fast electron. These curves were taken from the work of H. A. Bethe and W. Heitler [Proc. Roy. SOC.A146, 83 (1934)l; see also Bethe and Ashkin, reference 3, p. 270, Fig. 19. The curves pertain to lead, and include the effect of screening.
The energy loss of the electrons by radiation is given by
-
=
f$)rad
N
1”
hv4,(EoJv)d v
(1.1.63)
where vo = Eo/h, and N = number of atoms per cm3. Equations (1.1.60) and (1.1.61) show that (P(E0,v)is roughly proportional t o 1 / v for small frequencies v, so that the integrand hvQ(Eo,v)does not have any strong dependence on v, and actually becomes almost independent of Eo and v/To for sufficiently high energies ( T O2 100mc2)(see Fig. 7). As a result, - (dEo/dz),,d is approximately proportional to the primary energy Eo. Thus we write.
where
9.a
rs)
=
NEoQ,,,
rad
is the integral of (1.1.63) divided by Eo.
( 1.1.64)
1.1.
59
INTERACTION O F RADIATION WITH MATTER
For mc2<< Eo << 137rn~~Z-"~, screening can be neglected, and one finds (1.1.65)
where I is defined by @ -=
1)r02 =
137
Z(Z
+ 1)5.79 X lo-@ cm2.
(1.1.66)
one obtains: For the case of complete screening (Eo>> 137rn~~Z-'/~), = I ' [ 4 ln(183Z-1/3)
where
I' E Z(Z
+ $1
( 1.1.67)
+ {)5.79 X 10-z8 cm2
(1.1.68)
and where { is the correction for the contribution of the atomic elect r o n ~ ; {' ~is~of the order of 1.2-1.4. The distance Xo over which the electron has its energy decreased by a factor e is called the radiation length. Thus XOis defined by
l/Xo = 4NI' ln(183Z-1'3).
( 1.1.69)
For large energies, we have [from Eq. (1.1.67)]: (1.1.70)
where b = 1/[18 1n(183Z-1/3)]is very small compared to unity (b = 0.012 for air, 0.015 for Pb). Table VI gives values of the radiation length XO for various materials. TABLE VI. Values of .the Critical Energy E, and Radiation Length XOfor Various Substances This table is taken from Bethe and Ashkin, reference 3, p. 266. Substance
E , (Mev)
X O(gm/cm2)
340 220 103 87 77 47 34.5 24 21.5 6.9
58 85 42.5 38 34.2 23.9 19.4 13.8 12.8 5.8 36.5 35.9
~~
Hydrogen Helium Carbon Nitrogen Oxygen Aluminum argon Iron Copper Lead Air Water
~
83 93
60
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
Bethe and Heitler14’ have given the following approximate formula for the critical energy: E, S 1600mc2/Z (1.1.71) from which they have obtained the following expression for the ratio of the radiation loss to the collision loss:
-
(dEo/dz)r,fi - EoZ (dEo/dz),,11 - 1 6 0 0 ~’~ ~ ’
(1.1.72)
It should be noted that Eqs. (1.1.71) and (1.1.72) are very approximate, as can be seen by comparing the values of E, calculated from Eq. (1.1.71) with the actual values given in Table VI. With increasing energy of the electron, the radiation becomes increasingly peaked forward. Aside from a factor which depends slowly on E O and hv, the angular distribution of the radiation du/dQ is determined by:154
(1.1.73) where 0 is the angle of emission of the radiation and B is a constant. Thus the average angle of emission is given by
<@>
(1.1.74)
mc2/Eo
which becomes very small with increasing Eo. Recently tfberal1155has investigated the bremsstrahlung produced by fast electrons in single crystals. He has shown that interference phenomena are expected to occur which can enhance the radiation and markedly change the y-ray spectrum. A similar effect for pair production (see Section 1.1.7.3) is also discussed by Uberall. The crystal effect is small at low energies, and sets in for q noh/a, where q is the momentum transfer to the target atoms, a is the lattice constant, and no is of the order of 2 or 3. This condition corresponds to an electron energy To 200 Mev 1 Bev for pair production. The for bremsstrahlung, and y energy hv interference effect is confined to angles 00 of order 0 0 5 (137Z-’I3) X (mca/Eo) between the primary beam and the line of atoms participating in the interference. I n a second paper, tfberal1165has discussed the polarization of bremsstrahlung emitted from a monocrystalline target. The polarization P is all), where ul and ~ 1 are 1 the cross secdefined as: P = (aL - q ) / ( a l tionsjor producing radiation polarized perpendicular and parallel, respec-
-
-
+
lS4 A. Sommerfeld, “Atombau und Spektrallinien,” Vol. 2, p. 551. Vieweg, Braunschweig, Germany, 1939. lKK H. Vberall, Phys. Rev. 103, 1055 (1956); 107,223 (1957).
1.1.
INTERACTION O F RADIATION WITH MATTER
61
tively, to the production plane (formed by the incoming electron momentum PO and the emitted y-ray momentum k). He has shown that, in typical cases, P is increased by a factor of -1.5 above the value obtained when an amorphous target is used. Moreover, there is a net polarization with respect to the plane formed by the incident direction (PO) and the crystal axis. Thus for a Cu crystal, at T = O", with an incident electron energy EO= 600 MeV, for 0 0 = 20 X rad, the polarization POof the entire bremsstrahlung cone is E0.15 for z 3 kv/Eofrom 0 to 0.2. Between 2 = 0.2 and 0.5, PO decreases slowly to 0. Here eo is the angle between the primary direction and the crystal axis. For Oo = 5 X 10-8 rad, Po is 0.31 a t x = 0, and decreases rapidly with increasing x, becoming negative at z = 0.19, with minimum value PO= -0.11 at x = 0.33. Thus by using an appropriate angle 00, it may be possible to obtain partially polarized y radiation of sufficient intensity to perform high-energy polarization experiments. 1.I .5.2. Shower Production. As the eIectron proceeds through the material, it will create a shower, which is produced as follows. The electron loses energy by bremsstrahlung, producing a high-energy y ray. The y ray in turn can produce an electron and positron by pair production (see Section 1.1.7.3below). The pair in turn can radiate energy by bremsstrahlung, thereby producing photons, which can then create more pairs. In this way a cascade of photons and high-energy e+ and e- is produced, which is called a shower. The number of e+ and e- present increases at first with increasing thickness t, then attains a maximum a t a certain thickness t,, and decreases for larger t. I n this connection, as was mentioned above, it is convenient to define a critical energy E, by the condition that for EO = E,, the radiation loss, Eq. (1.1.701, is equal to the energy loss by ionization. Values of E , for various materials are given in Table VI. Figure 8 shows the expected number of electrons n as a function of the thickness t in radiation lengths Xo. I n the figure, loglo n is plotted against t for 4 different values of the total energy E Oof the primary electron, which is given in units of the critical energy E,. These curves were taken from the work of Rossi and Greisen.lS8Figure 8 shows that for a shower withiiincident energy E O = 100E,, n increases from n = 1 at t = 0 to a maximum n, G 10 a t t = t, 4, and thereafter decreases to n = 1 at t g 12, and is negligible for t >, 12. The thickness t, at which the maximum is reached, and the value n, at the maximum both increase with increasing energy EOof the primary electron. Thus for E O = 104E,, we have n, 1000, t, E 9. I n this case, n becomes negligible only for t 2 30. Many authors have treated analytically the complicated mathe166
B. Rossi and K. Greisen, Revs. Modern Phys. 13, 240 (1941).
1.
62
PARTICLE DETECTION
matical problems involved in shower production. A review of these calculations is given in the book by Ro ~ si.'~ ' Wilson168has recently treated the problem of the shower development by a Monte Carlo method, in which a large number of electrons are followed through the material, with a statistical (probability) determination of the bremsstrahlung and pair production processes in each particular case history." Neglecting scattering, by means of an approximate ((
5
4
3 C
2 2
s
I
0
-I
0
t
FIG.8. The number n of electrons in a shower as a function of the thickness traversed of B. Rossi and K . Greisen [Revs. Modern Phys. 13, 240 (1941)l. t in radiation lengths. These curves were taken from the work
theoretical model of shower production, Wilson finds for the mean range r (in units Xo) of an electron of initial energy Eo r
=
ln 2 In
(-E ,EoIn 2 + 1).
(1.1.75)
The distribution of ranges around r is approximately Gaussian, and the root mean square straggling s (in units X , ) is given by (1.1.76) Wilson has shown from his Monte Carlo calculations that for a n incident electron, one is more likely to find 1, 3, 5 . . . than 2, 4,6, . . . electrons and positrons a t a given thickness in the shower, since electrons lS7
B. Rossi, " High-Energy Particles," Chapter 5. Prentice-Hall, New York, 1952. R. R. Wilson, Phys. Rev. 84, 100 (1951); 86, 261 (1952).
1.1.
INTERACTION O F RADIATION W I T H MATTER
G3
and positrons are formed in pairs. On the other hand, if the shower is initiated by a y ray, one is more likely to find 2 , 4 , 6 . . , than 1 , 3 , 5 . . . electrons and positrons a t any thickness in the shower, Wilson’s shower curves as obtained b y the Monte Carlo method are more spread out than those of the general (analytic) shower theory, i.e., the shower penetrates to a greater thickness t than according to the general t,heory. One of the reasons for this difference is that Wilson’s calculations take into account the fact that the low-energy y rays have a relatively long mean free path (see Section 1.1.7.4). 1.1.5.3. Production of Secondary Electrons by Electrons. Scattering of Electrons by Electrons and Nuclei. The cross section for ejection of secondary electrons (6 rays) by an electron passing through matter is given by146
d@e(T.W) ., I
=
( + ( T -1W)’ - W ( T 1- W )cos [
re4 - dW wi1
T
ln
(‘+)I} (1.1.77)
where T is the kinetic energy of the primary electron, and W is the energy transfer, i.e., the kinetic energy of the secondary electron. In Eq. (1.1.77), the second and third (cosine) terms in the curly bracket are exchange terms. For small W , these terms become negligible, and the resulting cross section [re4/(TWZ)]dW is the same as that for primary heavy particles (e.g., protons) [see Eq. (1.1.56)]. For relativistic energies of the incident electron, the electron-electron scattering cross section has been obtained by Mdler,L69and is given by
1
+
( T - W ) z+ ( T
+ mcz)2
(1.1.78)
For T < mc2, Eq. (1.1.78) reduces to the nonrelativistic Mott formula, Eq. (1.1.77), in which the cosine factor in the last term is ~ 1unless , W7 is very close to either 0 or T. I n his calculations,169MGller summed over both directions of polarization of the two electrons, so that Eq. (1.1.78) represents the average cross section for unpolarized incident electrons. However, recently in connection with the experiments on parity n o n co n ~e r v a tio n ~in-~beta decay, it has become of interest to evaluate the cross sections for polarized electrons scattered by polarized electrons, in particular for the case that the two spin directions are parallel or antiparallel to each other, and along 159 C. Mdler, Ann. Physik [5] 14, 531 (1932).
64
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
the relative direction of motion of the electrons. This problem arises because it has been shown from the two-component theory of the neutrino,*ll that the electrons and positrons from beta decay are expected to be longitudinally polarized10.16't-162 (i.e., with average spin direction along the direction of motion). The value of the polarization P is predicted to be: P = T v/c, where v = velocity of p particle, and the minus sign applies to electrons, while the plus sign applies to positrons. Thus high-energy electrons from p decay (v c) are almost 100% polarized, with the spin pointing opposite to the direction of motion. A method of determining the longitudinal polarization consists in scattering the &decay electrons on the electrons in a ferromagnetic sample of material. As is well known, if a strong magnetic field is applied to an iron sample, the 3d electrons of iron will be polarized in the direction of the applied field.* Thus if a magnetic field is applied along a direction parallel or antiparallel t o the direction of the incident p electrons, one can obtain the polarization P of the incident beam from a comparison of the c o u n h g rates of scattered electrons a t a particular angle, for the two field directions. This result arises from the fact that the cross sections for parallel spin directions (bp and for antiparallel spin directions & are appreciably different from each other, for all values of the incident energy, provided that the energy transfer W is sufficiently large (WIT 2 0.2, where T is the kinetic energy of the incident electron). The first calculation of the spin-dependent cross sections r#Jp and (ba was carried out by Bincer,163and we shall here briefly summarize his results. For the differential cross sections in the center-of-mass system of the two electrons (to be abbreviated as c.m. system), one obtains
-
d(bp =
eddn [2 C O S ~t7 2~284sin4 t7
dr#Ja=
e4dQ [I -2 ~ ~ sin4 8 4 t7
--
+p(3
G + C O S ~t7)
COS~
+
B4(1
+
s)]
COS~
(1.1.79)
+
G + B2(2 + 3 C O S ~t7 - C O S ~8)
COS~
+ 84(5 - 4
G + C O S ~t7)]
COS~
(1.1.80)
where 8 is the c.m. scattering angle, B is the c.m. velocity of either electron (in units of c), is the total c.m. energy of either electron, and d o is the element of solid angle in the c.m. system. We have S2 = (y - l ) / ( y l),
+
* See also Vol. 4, A, Chapter
3.5. J. D.Jackson, S. B. Treiman, and H. W. Wyld, Phys. Rev. 106, 517 (1957). Iel L. Wolfenstein and L. A. Page, BUZZ. Am. Phys. Sac. [Z] 2, 190 (1957). 162 R. B. Curtis and R. R. Lewis, Phys. Rev. 107, 543 (1957). A. M. Bincer, Phys. Rev. 107,1434 (1957);see also G.W. Ford and C. J. Mullin, Phys. Rev. 108, 477 (1957). l60
1.1.
65
INTERACTION O F RADIATION WITH MATTER
where y = E/mc2,with E = total laboratory energy of incident electron. Upon defining x = cos' 8, Eqs. (1.1.79) and (1.1.80) can be rewritten as follows : d+P
(1.1.81) @a
( 1.1.82)
We note that cos
e = 1 - 2w
(1.1.83)
where w is the fractional energy transfer, w = W/T. Thus after integrating over the azimuthal angle, one obtains
J dn
=
27r sin ede
=
-2nd(cos #)
=
47r dw.
(1.1.84)
I n view of Eq. (1.1.83), we have: x = (1 - 2 ~ ) Upon ~ . substituting these results in Eqs. (1.1.81) and (1.1.82),one finds for the average differential cross section per unit w (for unpolariaed electrons) :
x [ y y i - 2~
+ 3 ~ -2 2w3 +
w4)
- (27
- i ) ( w - 2w3
+
W4)l.
(1.1.85)
Finally, upon using the relations: T = (y - 1)mc2, and W = wT, one can easilyshow that Eq. (1.1.85) is equivalent to Eq. (1.1.78) ford@(T,W). From Eqs. (1.1.81) and (1,1.82), one obtains
+ +
&, -- ~ ' ( 1 &
+
62 x2) - 2 y ( l - Z) 1 - 5' 87' - 2y(4 - 52 2') 4 - 62 22"
+ +
+
( 1.1.86)
Figure 9 shows the curves of as a function of w, for y = 1,3, and co , as obtained by B i n ~ e r . 'It~ ~ is seen that decreases rapidly with increasing w, independently of y. The minimum value is attained for w = 0.5 (0 = go"), and is given by (Y - 1)' = 4(2y2 - 2y
(1.1.87)
+ 1)
which becomes 0 for y 4 1 (nonrelativistic energies) and
+ for y
4
co
.
66
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
The dependence of the electron-electron scattering cross section on the relative directions of polarization has been used in a few experiments t o determine the longitudinal polarization of electrons from B decay. 164,18i, The arrangement of the experiment of Frauenfelder et ~ 1 . lis~ shown ~ I .3
.8
.6
0, +o
.4
.2
0 0
.I
.2
.3
A
.5
W
FIG.9. The ratio &/&, for electron-electron scattering, as a function of the relative kinetic energy t,ransfer w.This figure is taken from the work of A. M. Bincer [Phys. Rev. 107, 1434 (1957), Fig. 11, and is reprinted with the permission of the author and the Editor of the Physical Review.
schematically in Fig. 10. The scattered electrons are recorded in coincidence by the counters 61 and Cz.The counting rates are compared for opposite directions of the magnetizing current around the Deltamax scattering foil. The scattering angle 0 is usually so chosen that it corre164 H. Frauenfelder, A. 0. Hanson, N. Levine, A. Rossi, and G. De Pasquali, Phys. Rev. 107, 643 (1957). lo5 N. Benczer-Koller, A. Schwarzschild, J. B. Vise, and C. S. Wu, Phys. Rev. 109,
85 (1958).
1.1.
67
INTERACTION O F RADIATION W I T H MATTER
sponds approximately to the maximum relative energy transfer w = 0.5, for which has its smallest value, as discussed above. For w = 0.5, the two final electrons have equal energies in the laboratory system and are emitted symmetrically with respect to the incident direction a t a n angle 8, given by sin2 8, = 2/(7 3). (1.1.88)
+
A description of the experiments on the M3ller scattering of P-decay electrons, as well as a more complete discussion of the theory, can be found in reference 8.
COLLIMATOR
& SOURCE
FIG.10. Schematic view of the experimental arrangement of Frauenfelder et a1.ln4 used to demonstrate the longitudinal polarization of electrons from the fl decay of P32 and Pr144,by means of the Mflller (electron-electron) scattering.
For the scattering of relativistic electrons b y nuclei, McKinley and FeshbachlGB have obtained the following expression :
I
+ ZsP - s i n ( p ) [ l - sin(+0)] . 137
(1.139)
This expression applies provided th at 2/137 is not too large, Le., not for the heaviest nuclei. For P + 1, Eq. (1.1.89) may be rewritten as follows:167 Ze2 cos2(&8) sin4((B8) -{I+--
-)
d @ = ( 2E
] (2ssin
a 2 sin(;O)[l - sin(@)] 137
cos2 (Be)
0 dB)
(1.1.90)
where E is the total laboratory energy of the electron. We note th a t both in (1.1.89) and (1.1.90), 0 is the angle of scattering in the center-of-mass system. W. A. McKinley and H. Feshbach, Phys. Rev. 74, 1759 (1948). R. Hofstadter, Revs. Modern Phys. 28, 214 (1956).
lB8
68
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
In connection with the longitudinal polarization of the electrons from beta decay,loJao-lezthe Mott scatteringleaof the electrons from a heavy nucleus has also been used to detect the po1arization.t I n this type of experiment, the longitudinal polarization of the electrons is first transformed into a transverse polarization, for instance, by deflecting the electrons through -90" by means of an electrostatic field. A system of crossed electric and magnetic fields may also be used, t o take advantage of the fact that the focusing condition for the electrons can then be made identical with the condition for turning the spin through 90". After the particles have thus acquired a substantial amount of transverse polarization (spin d perpendicular to momentum p), they are scattered through an angle 0 in the plane perpendicular to the (d,p) plane, which we assume to be horizontal, and the up-down asymmetry of the scattered intensity is observed. That is, the intensity of the electrons scattered through an angle 8 in the upward direction is different from the intensity of the electrons scattered through the same angle 8 in the downward direction. As was first shown by Mottlesin 1929, the asymmetry in the scattering of transversely polarized electrons is largest for heavy elements and for large scattering angles (6 90"-150"). For a beam with transverse polarization P , the ratio R of the scattered intensities in both azimuthal directions perpendicular to the (d,p) plane (i.e., upward and downward in the example discussed above) is given by
-
(1.1.91)
where s(0)is a function, first calculated by Mott,le8which depends on the atomic number of the scatterer, the incident electron energy, and the angle of scattering 8. The most complete recent calculation of S(0) has been carried out by Sherman,169who has tabulated s(e)at intervals of 15" for various values of the electron velocity p, for three elements: mercury (2 = 80) ; cadmium (2 = 48);and aluminum (2 = 13). s(0) is given by
- p*)1'2 s(e) = 2PE(1 [F(B)G*(B)+ F*(e)G(0)] sin e(da/dQ)
(1.1.92)
where 5 = 2/(137p), X is the de Broglie wavelength, P(0) and G ( 0 ) are the
t See also Vol. 4, A, Section 3.5.1. 168 N. F. Mott, PTOC. Roy. Soc. Al24,425 (1929);A136,429 (1932);see also the discussion in N. F. Mott and H. S. W. Massey, "The Theory of Atomic Collisions," 2nd ed., pp. 74-85. Oxford Univ. Press, London and New York, 1949. lEg N. Sherman, Phys. Rev. 103, 1601 (1956).
1.1.
69
I N T E R A C T I O N O F RADIATION WITH MATTER
regular and irregular solutions, respectively, of the Schroedinger equation for the electron in the field of the nucleus. These functions are in general complex, and the asterisk denotes the complex conjugate. In Eq. (1.1.92) du/dQ denotes the differential cross section for an unpolarized beam of electrons, which is given by
+ ]GI2 sec2(+0)].
du/dQ = X2[t2(1- pz) ]PIz csc2(+0)
(1.1.93)
has also tabuIn addition to the asymmetry function i3(0), Sherman*eB lated the values of the real and imaginary parts of F and G, as well as the
FIQ.11. The asymmetry factor -S(O) for mercury (2 = 80) as a function of the scattering angle e. The values of S(O) were obtained from the results of Sherman.leg The curves for electron velocities j3 = 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, and 0.9 correspond to electron energies T, = 10.5, 46.6, 128, 341,and 661 kev, respectively.
differential cross section du/dQ. As mentioned above, Ii3(0)l is largest for heavy elements and large values of 0. Figure 11 shows the curves of s(0) versus 0 for 2 = 80 and for various velocities p. x(e)is zero for 0 = 0" and 180" for all energies, and a t B = 1for all angles 0. Several experiments have 0.6 (T, 130 kev), been carried out at 0 = 90" using electrons with p for which lS(90")1 has its maximum value. It may be noted that for p = 0.6, IS(0)l increases from 0.271 a t 90" to 0.424 a t 120" and 0.418 at 135'. Nevertheless, it has been found desirable t o work a t -90" because of the rapid decrease of the cross section du/dQ with increasing angle.
-
-
70
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
FIQ.12. The ratio 9 = (du/dn)/(duz/dn)for mercury (2 = 80) as a function of the scattering angle 0. The solid curves of 7 were obtained from the results of Sherrnan.lBg The dashed curve of 9 for fi = 0.6 was calculated from the formula of McKinley and FeshbachlG6[Eq.(1.1.89)].
Figure 12 shows the values of the ratio q for mercury, as obtained by Sherman,169 where q is defined by (1.1.94) where duR/dQ is the Rutherford cross section, which is given by the factor outside the curly bracket of Eq. (1.1.89): (1.1.95) The dashed curve in Fig. 12 shows the values of q predicted by the formula of McKinley and FeshbachIG6for = 0.6, i.e., the curly bracket of Eq. (1.1.89). It is seen th at the actual values of q differ appreciably from the McKinley-Feshbach result, as would be expected in view of the large 2 value (2/137 = 0.58). Among the earlier determinations of S(O), we may mention the calculations of Mott, 1 6 * Bartlett and Watson,17o Bartlett and Welton,'" and Mohr and T a ~ s i e . " ~ J. H. Bartlett and R. E. Watson, Proc. Am. Acad. A d s Sci. 74, 53 (1940). J. H. Bartlett and T. A. Welton, Phys. Rev. 69, 281 (1941). l72 C. B. 0. Mohr and L. J. Tassie, Proc. Phys. Soc. (London) A67, 711 (1954); C. B. 0.Mohr, Proc. Roy. Soc. A182, 189 (1943). 170
1.1.
INTERACTION O F RADIATION WITH MATTER
71
It should be pointed out that the function S(0) was originally introduced by Mott"j8in connection with the double scattering of a n initially unpolarized beam of electrons. I n this case, the polarization P after a single scattering through an angle O1 is given by S(B1),and the direction of the spin d after the scattering is perpendicular to the plane of the scattering. After a second scattering, the relative intensity of the beam as a function of the angle cp between the first and second planes of scattering is given by I(el,ez,cp) = 1
+ s(e1)s(e2)co~ (o
(1.1.96)
where 0 2 is the angle of the second scattering. Among the more recent double scattering experiments which have attempted to verify the theoretical values of S(0),we may cite the works of Shull et u Z . , ' ~ ~ Ryu et u Z . , ' ~ ~ and Louisell et A review of these investigations has been given by Tolhoek. 176 The Mott scattering has been used in several e x p e r i m e n t ~ ' ~ ~on - ~the 8~ longitudinal polarization of p-decay electrons, and has shown th a t the polarization agrees with the predicted value, P = v/c, within the experimental errors.8 The same conclusion was obtained from the experiments using the MIdller scattering.'64s165 1.1 -5.4. Range of p Rays in Matter. In some cases, a crude value of the energy of a beam of homogeneous p rays is obtained by measuring the socalled practical range R, in some material, such as aluminum. The practical range is obtained by extrapolating the straight-line (maximum slope) part of the graph of transmission versus thickness traversed, and taking into account the background (cf. Fig. 6). For p rays in aluminum, Katz and P e n f ~ l dhave l ~ ~ given the following expressions for R, as a funcC. G.Shull, C. T. Chase, and F. E. Myers, Phys. Re*. 63, 29 (1943). N. Ryu, K. Hashimoto, and I. Nonaka, J . Phys. Soc. Japan 8, 575 (1953). l76 W. H. Louisell, R. W. Pidd, and H. R. Crane, Phys. Rev. 94, 7 (1954). 178 H. A. Tolhoek, Revs. Modern Phys. 28, 277 (1956). 177 H. Frauenfelder, R.Bobone, E. von Goeler, N. Levine, H. R. Lewis, R. N. Peacock, A. Rossi, and G. De Pasquali, Pkys. Rev. 106, 386 (1957). 178 H. De Waard and 0. J. Poppema, Physica 23, 597 (1957). 179 P. E. Cavanagh, J. F. Turner, C. F. Coleman, G. A. Gard, and B. W. Ridley, Phil. Mag. [8]2, 1105 (1957). l80 A. I. Alikhanov, G. P. Eliseiev, V. A. Lubimov, and B. V. Ershler, Nuclear Phys. 6, 588 (1958). 181 A. de-Shalit, S. Kuperman, H. J. Lipkin, and T. Rothem, Phys. Rev. 107, 1459 (1957). 182 H. J. Lipkin, S. Kuperman, T. Rothem, and A. de-Shalit, Phys. Rev. 109, 223 (1958). 183 L. Katz and A. S. Penfold, Revs. Modern Phys. 24, 28 (1952). l73
17*
72
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
tion of the incident electron energy TO(in MeV) :
R,
=
412Tonmg/cm2
n = 1.265 - 0.0954 In TO
(1.1.97)
for 0.01 d To =< 2.5 MeV, and
R,
=
530To - 106 mg/cm2
(1.1.98)
for 2.5 5 T O6 20 MeV.
FIG.13. The practical range R P of low-energy electrons in aluminum as a function of the electron kinetic energy To.This curve was calculated from the range-energy relation given by L. Katz and A. S. Penfold [Revs. Modern Phys. 24, 28 (1952)]. See also Eqs. (1.1.97) and (1.1.98) of text.
Figure 13 shows a plot of Eqs. (1.1.97) and (1.1.98). This curve is in good agreement with the experimental data on the maximum range of electrons from natural beta emitters. Among the earlier works on the range of low-energy /3 rays, we may mention those of Marshall and Ward, l S 4 FeatherJ1S5Flammersfeld, l 8 6 Bleuler and Zunti, l*7 Glendenin, and Hereford and Swann.lE9 lS4
J. Marshall and A. G. Ward, Cun. J. Research A16, 39 (1937).
N. Feather, Proc. Cambridge Phil. SOC.34, 599 (1938). A. Flammersfeld, Nuturwissenschaften 33, 280 (1946). lg7 E. Bleuler and W. Ziinti, Helv. Phys. Actu 19, 137, 375 (1946); 20, 195 (1947). la*L. E. Glendenin, Nucleonics 2, 12 (1948). lag F. L. Hereford and C. P. Swann, Phys. Rev. 78, 727 (1950). lS6
I**
1.1.
INTERACTION OF RADIATION W I T H MATTER
73
1.1.6. Multiple Scattering of Charged Particles When a charged particle penetrates a thick absorber, it undergoes a large number of small-angle Coulomb scatterings. This process, which is called multiple scattering, was first treated quantitatively by Williams.l90 In addition, the particle may undergo a small number of relatively largeangle scatterings, for which the probability can be directly obtained from the Rutherford scattering formula. We shall here be concerned with the multiple scattering only. The resultant distribution of the space angle 6 between the incoming and outgoing directions of the particle is given by (1.1.99)
where
<e2> is the mean square value of
(2)
<e2>
= 2OI2In - =
8 and is given by1g1
el2 In [ 4 ~ Z ~ / % ~($)2]iVt
(1.1.100)
Here Omin is the minimum angle of scattering in a single encounter, Omin Ei X/a, where X is the de Broglie wavelength of the particle and a is the radius of the atom, a a& 1‘3. In Eq. ( l . l . l O O ) , t is the thickness of material traversed, z is the charge of the particle, m is the electron mass (regardless of the type of scattered particle: proton, meson, etc.), N is the number of atoms of absorber per cm3, and el is that angle for which there is, on the average, only one collision with 8 > 01 throughout the absorber. el2 is given by e12 = 4 T ~ ~1)9e4t/(p42. ( ~ (1.1.101)
-
+
Equation (1.1.100) can be written as follows: <e2>
=
0*1572(2 4- 1)z2t ln[1.13 X 104Z4/3z2A-1tp-2](1.1.102) A (PO)
where pv is in MeV, t is in gm cm-2, and A is the atomic weight in gramsThe expression preceding the logarithm in (1.1.102) is el2. Rossi and GreisenlS8have given a somewhat different formula for < e2> which has been frequently used in experimental applications. This expression is given by (1.1.103) E. J. Williams, Proc. Roy. SOC.A169, 531 (1939);Phys. Rev. 68,292 (1940). H. A. Bethe and J. Ashkin, in “Experimental Nuclear Physics” (E. SegrB, ed.), Vol. I, p. 285. Wiley, New York, 1953. 1**
191
74
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
where Xo is the radiation length in the material [cf. Eq. (l.l.G9) and Table VI], and E, is a constant energy given by
E,
=
( 4 X~ 137)1%c2
=
21.2 MeV.
( 1.1.104)
As was shown by Bethe and Ashkin,lgl Eq. (1.1.103) applies only for relatively large thicknesses t > to, where t o is given by
to
=
6.7(137/2)2A113gm cm-2.
(1.1.105)
For Pb, to = 110 gm cm-2, while for C, to = 8000 gm cm-2. For small thicknesses, Eq. (1.1.103) overestimates the mean square multiple scattering angle. Thus for 3-Bev protons and samples of thickness t = 10 gm cm-2 of C, Cu, and Pb, < 0 2 > u2 = 0.123", 0.248', 0.388' from Eq. (1.1.102) for C, Cu, and Pb, respectively, whereas the corresponding values from Eq. (1.1.103) are: <82>1'2 = 0.159", 0.289", and 0.429', respectively. The factor F by which Eq. (1.1.103) differs from (1.1.102) is: F = 1.29, 1.17, and 1.11 for C, Cu, and Pb, respectively (for t = 10 gm cm-2). It is often useful to consider the projected angles 8, and 01/, i.e., the projections of the angle 8 on the zy plane perpendicular to the direction of motion of the particle. The distribution of the 8, values is a Gaussian: (1.1.106) where
< eZ2> is the mean square value of <e,2>
=
;<e2>
8, and is given by
(1.1.107)
with < 8 2 > given by Eq. (1.1.102). Thus the denominator of the exponent is the same ( = <e2>) for both P(8) and P,(Q [Eqs. (1.1.99) and do, for the projected angle 8, (1.1.106)]. Of course, the distribution P1/(02/) has the same form as P,(8,) do,. The distribution of the lateral displacement r of the particles has been determined by Ferrni,Ig2and is given by (1.1.108) where t' = t/X, is the thickness traversed in units of radiation lengths X O . More elaborate theories of the multiple scattering have been developed Snyder and Scott,Ig6 by Goudsinit and S a ~ n d e r s o n , ~ ~ ~ E. Fermi, quoted by B. Rossi and K. Greisen, Revs. Modern Phys. 13,265 (1941). S. Goudsmit and J. L. Saunderson, Phys. Rev. 67, 24 (1940). ls4 G. MoliBre, 2. Naturforsch. Sa, 78 (1948). 195 W. Paul and H. Steinwedel, in "Beta- and Gamma-Ray Spectroscopy" (K. Siegbahn, ed.), p. 1. Interscience, New York, 1955. 196 H. S. Snyder and W. T. Scott, Phys. Rev. 76, 220 (1949). 192
193
1.1.
INTERACTION OF RADIATION WITH MATTER
75
Lewis,lg7and Bethe. l g 8 These theories treat more accurately the transition from the small-angle region of multiple scattering to the large-angle region where single scattering predominates. This transition region is sometimes called the region of plural scattering. I n a recent investigation, Nigam and c o - w ~ r k e r s have ' ~ ~ made a critical study of the MoliBre theorylS4of multiple scattering, and have obtained a consistent treatment of the scattering of a charged particle by the field of an atom, up to the second Born approximation. I n this work, Nigam et al. have used the expression of Dalitz2""for the scattering cross section of a relativistic particle of spin in a screened atomic field, for which the potential is: V = -(Ze2/r)exp(--r), where K is a n arbitrary constant, and r is the distance from the nucleus. It was found that the deviation of the complete expression for the "screening angle " 8, from the value given by the first Born approximation is considerably smaller than was obtained by MoliBre. Moreover, the expression for the distribution function P(e) contains additional terms of order xZ/137, which were not obtained by Moliitre. Nigam et al. have carried out calculations of the distribution function P(0) for the case of 15.6-Mev electrons scattered by Au and Be, in order t o The compare their theory with the experimental results of Hanson el aLZo1 theoretical results are in good agreement with the data. The two cases considered correspond to electrons of average energy 15.7 Mev scattered by a gold foil of thickness t = 37.2 mg/cm2, and 15.2-Mev electrons scattered by a beryllium sample of thickness t = 491.3 mg/cm2. The experimental distributionsof Hanson etal. havea llewidth O,(exp) = 3.78" for Au and 4.33" for Be. Here 0, denotes the angle (measured from the direction of the incident beam) a t which P(0) has fallen off t o l/e of its value a t e = 0". e, is thus given by < 02> l i 2 for a Gaussian distribution [Eq. (1.1.100)]. It may be noted, however, th a t the actual multiple scattering d i s t r i b ~ t i o n ~ ~deviates ~ - ' ~ ~ somewhat from a Gaussian a t all angles. I n particular, at large angles (0 >, 28,), the actual P(0) lies above the Gaussian of Eq. (l.l.lOO), and slowly approaches the single-scattering cross section (which decreases only as m e - * ) . For comparison with the values of e,(exp), the theory of Nigam et a l l g 9gives 0, = 3.80" for Au, and 4.35" for Be, in very good agreement with the data. On the other hand, MoliBre's theorylg4gives e, = 3.83" for Au, and 4.56" for Be. The result
+
H. W. Lewis, Phys. Rev. '78, 526 (1950). 1**H.A. Bethe, Phys. Rev. 89, 1256 (1953). 199 B. P. Nigam, M. K. Sundaresan, and T. Y. Wu, Phys. Rev. 116, 491 (1959). zoo R. H. Dalitz, Proc. Roy. Soe. A206, 509 (1951). 201 A. 0. Hanson, L. H. Lanzl, E. M. Lyman, and M. B. Scott, Phys. Rev. 84, 634 (1951).
76
1. PARTICLE DETECTION
for Be is thus too large by 5%. It may be noted that from the simple expression of Bethe and Ashkin given above [Eq. (1.1.102)], one obtains 0, = 3.94" for Au and 4.33" for Be. The value for Au is too large by 476, while the result for Be agrees exactly with B,(exp). On the other hand, the formula of Rossi and Greisen [Eq. (1.1.103)] would give the values 5.82" for Au and 6.56"for Be, which are both considerably larger than O,(exp). The multiple scattering has been frequently used for a crude measurement of pv for charged particles in nuclear emulsion.202If the track of the particle is subdivided into sections (cells) of length t , the average angle between successive sections is given by (1 .l.109)
where ,6 = v/c, t is measured in microns, pv is in MeV, A~ is in degrees, and K(t,,6) is a slowly varying function of t and p. The theoretical value194*196 of K is between 23 and 24, which is in satisfactory agreement with the experimental results both of the Bristol groupzo3and of C o r ~ o n , * ~ ~ namely K = 25.1 f 0.6 for P = 1 and t = 100. 1.1.7. Penetration of Gamma Rays For y rays passing through matter, there is an exponential attenuation such that the intensity I ( z ) after traversing a thickness 2 is given by
I ( z ) = I(O)exp( - Nuz)
=
I(O)exp( -m)
(1.1.110)
where I(0) is the incident intensity (at 5 = 0), N is the number of atoms of absorber per cm3,u is the total cross section for absorption or scattering of the y rays, and r = Nu(cm-') is the absorption coefficient of the radiation. There are three processes which contribute to 6: (1) the photoelectric effect, which consists of the ionization of atomic electrons by the incident photon. (2) The Compton scattering of the photons by the atomic electrons. I n this process, the atomic electrons can generally be considered as free, and the energy transfer to the electron is a function of the scattering angle O of the ? ray and its initial energy hvo. The energy transfer is determined in a straightforward manner from conservation of momentum and energy. (3) The production of an electron-positron pair in the field of a nucleus. P. H. Fowler, Phi.?. Mag. [7] 41, 169 (1950). Gottstein, M. G. K. Menon, J. H. Mulvey, C. O'Ceallaigh, and 0. Rochat, Phil. Mag. [7] 42, 708 (1951). go4 D. R. Corson, Phys. Rev. 80, 303 (1950); 84, 605 (1951). Zo2
2osK.
1.1.
77
INTERACTION OF RADIATION WITH MATTER
The photoelectric effect predominates at low y energieszo6(hv < 0.05 Mev for All hv < 0.5 Mev for Pb). The Compton effect gives the main contribution at intermediate energies (0.05 < hv < 16 Mev for Al; 0.5 < hv < 4.8 Mev for Pb). The pair production predominates a t high energies (hv > 16 Mev for Al; hv > 4.8Mev for Pb). We shall now consider separately each of these three processes. For a general review of the subject of the interaction of y rays with matter, the reader is referred to the review articles of Bethe and Ashkinj3 Davisson and Evans,206and D a v i s ~ o n . ~ ~ ’ 1.1.7.1. Photoelectric Effect. For energies far above the K absorption edge and in the nonrelativistic range (hv << mc2) the cross section for the photoelectric effect from the K shell is given byzo8 @,,hot.K
(1.1.111)
=
where 40 is the Thomson scattering cross section:
40 =
sT3 (x)’ = 6.651 X mc2
cm2.
( 1.1.112)
In obtaining Eq. (1.1.111), the Born approximation was used, the wave function of the outgoing electron being taken as a plane wave. This procedure is not justified when the kinetic energy of the ejected electron is of the same order or less than the binding energy of the K electrons.2n9 Thus for relatively small y energies hv [i.e., for hv/(Z2Ry) 1 - 10, is considerably smaller than would be where R y = Rydberg unit], aPhat,~ given by Eq. (1.1.111). The ratio of the actual @ ) p h o t , ~to the value of the expression (1.1.111) is 0.12 for hv = ZZRy, 0.43 for hv = 10Z2Ry, and 0.90 for hv = 1000Z2Ry. For very high y energies, hv >> m d , relativistic effects become important. This problem has been treated by SauterlZ1OHulme,211 and others. The following formula obtained by Hall is valid in the limit hv >> mc2, and includes the effect of the Coulomb field of the nucleus on
-
2 0 6 See, for example, W. Heitler, “The Quantum Theory of Radiation,” 2nd ed., p. 216, Fig. 21. Oxford Univ. Press, London and New York, 1944. 206 C. M. Davisson and R. D. Evans, Revs. Modern Phys. 24, 79 (1952). 207 C. M. Davisson, in “Beta- and Gamma-Ray Spectroscopy” (K. Siegbahn, ed.), p. 24. Interscience, New York, 1955. 208 H. Hall, Revs. Modern Phys. 8, 358 (1936). a** M. Stobbe, Ann. Physik [5] 7, 661 (1930). Z1O F. Sauter, Ann. Physik [5] 9, 217 (1931); 11, 454 (1931). 211 H. R. Hulme, Proc. Roy. Soc. A133, 381 (1931). P1z H. Hall, Phys. Rev. 46, 620 (1934); 84, 167 (1951).
78
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
the outgoing electron, which becomes appreciable for heavy elements : @phot.K
3 Z6damc2 2 1374 hv
= - - -exp[ -TCY
+ 2 d ( 1 - In
CY)]
( 1.1.113)
where CY = 2/137. Equation (1.1.113) shows that a p h o t , R decreases quite slowly with increasing v (only as v-l) in the relativistic region, as compared to the k 7 1 2 decrease at nonrelativistic y energies [Eq. (1.1.111)]. Aside from the approximate calculations mentioned above, which are based in part on the Born approximation, and on the use of plane-wave or nonrelativistic wave functions, Hulme et ~ 1 . have ~ ~ 3 carried out exact calculations for the photoelectric effect from the K shell, using the appropriate Dirac wave functions in the field of the nucleus. The calculations of Hulme et al. were carried out for two y-ray energies, hv = 0.354 and 1.13 MeV, and for three values of 2 : 26, 50, and 84. These results have been extensively used to check the validity of various approximation formulas and to obtain smooth curves of versus hv in the intermediate energy region (hv 1 Mev). I n obtaining the photoelectric absorption coefficient, one must include the contribution of the absorption from the L, M , . shells. Latyshev214 has made direct measurements of the photoelectrons ejected from the K and L shells of P b and Ta, for the ThC’ y rays (hv = 2.62 Mev). ,,, have Detailed calculations of the total photoelectric cross section ,,@ been carried out by White1215who used the results of StobbelZo9 Sauterj210 and Hulme et aL213According to White,21bthe ratio [ of the total photoelectric cross section @phot to the K shell contribution aphot.K is -1.15 for heavy elements. White has obtained E for various values of 2, for two y-ray energies: (1) a t the K absorption edge; (2) for mc2/hv = 1.5 (i.e., hv = 0.340 Mev). At the K edge, [ = 1.02 for 2 = 6, 1.11 for 2 = 29, 1.14 for 2 = 50, and 1.167 for 2 = 92. For hv = 0.340 MeV, [ = 1.01 for 2 = 6, 1.07 for 2 = 29, 1.10 for 2 = 50, and 1.138 for 2 = 92. Figure 14 shows the plot of loglo(@ph,t/&,)versus hv for C, All Cu, Sn, and Pb, as obtained from the results of White. For C and All and decreases approxifor the heavier elements a t low photon energies, aphot mately as Y - ” ~ , as expected from Eq. (1.1.111). On the other hand, for Pb is proportional to v-1 [see at high energies, between 5 and 50 MeV, aphot Eq. (1.1.113)]. White’s calculations include the effect of the L and M
-
. .
Z13
H. R. Hulme, J. McDougall, R. A. Buckingham, and R. H. Fowler, Proe. Roy.
Sac. A149, 131 (1935).
G. D. Latyshev, Revs. Modern Phys. 19,132 (1947). G. R. White, Natl. Bur. Standards Rept. 1003 (1952); see also Appendix I by C. M. Davisson, in “Beta- and Gamma-Ray Spectroscopy” (K. Siegbahn, ed.), p. 857. Interscience, New York, 1955. 214 216
1.1.
INTERACTION O F RADIATION W I T H MATTER
79
shells, which becomes the sole contribution to the photoelectric effect a t low energies below the K absorption edge. Thus for Sn, the break in the cm2 curve of @)phot at 29.25 kev is due t o the K edge [@,hot = 1.05 X = 8.58 x on low-frequency side of K edge ( L and M shells only); cm2 on high-frequency side ( K L M shells contribute)]. Similarly, for Pb, the break a t 88.2 kev is due to the K edge, while the discontinuity in the region of 15 kev is due to the L absorption edges (LI, LII, ,5111). Below 13.07 kev (LIrledge), only the M , N , and 0 shells contribute to the photoelectric effect.
+ +
PHOTON ENERGY h v ( I N MeV)
FIG.14. The cross section *,,hot for photoelectric absorption for C, Al, Cu, Sn, and Pb, as a function of the photon energy hv. These curves were obtained from the results of White.216
The theoretical results presented above are in fairly good agreement with various experiments on the photoelectric e f f e ~ t . ~ ~ ~ s ~ ~ ~ , ~ ~ ~ 1.1.7.2. Compton Scattering. The Compton scattering consists of the scattering of y-rays b y atomic electrons which can be considered as free (no atomic binding forces) for sufficiently high y-ray energies. From the laws of conservation of energy and momentum, one finds th a t the frequency v of the scattered quantum is given by v =
yo
1
+ (hvo/mc2)(1 - cos e)
(1.1.114)
where vo is the frequency of the incident quantum, and 0 is the angle of H. A. Bethe and J. Ashkin, in “Experimental Nuclear Physics” (E. Segr6, ed.), Vol. 1, p. 304. Wiley, New York, 1953.
1.
80
PARTICLE DETECTION
FIG.15. Schematic diagram of Compton effect, showing notation used in the text: hvo and hv are the energies of the incident and the scattered quanta, respectively;
T
is the kinetic energy of the recoil electron.
scattering of the y ray. The notation used is shown in Fig. 15. The kinetic energy T of the electron is given by
T
=
h(vo -
V)
=
2 m ~ ~ ( h vCOS' o ) ~cp
(hvo
+ mc2)2- (hvo)2cos2
cp
( 1.1.115)
where (a is the angle between the directions of the outgoing electron and the incident y. The angles cp of the electron and 6 of the y ray are related as follows: tan
cp = Y Os c:;':
0 = (mcT$hv)
cot(&@.
(1.1.116)
The energy of the scattered photon decreases with increasing 6. The minimum value, attained for 6 = 180", is given by (1.1.117) The maximum possible angle of the recoil electron is cp = go", in which case the energy of the electron is T = 0, while the scattered y ray continues with its initial energy (hv = hvo) in the forward direction. The differential cross section for Compton scattering was first obtained by Klein and NishinaZ17in 1929. The Klein-Nishina formula gives
) 817
0. Klein and Y . Nishina, 2.Physik 62, 853 (1929).
(1.1.118)
1.1.
81
INTERACTION OF RADIATION W I T H MATTER
where ro = e2/mc2, k = hv, ko = hvo, and d@c is the cross section for scattering of the y ray through an angle e into the solid angle dQ. Upon substituting Eq. (1.1.114) for k = hv, one obtains
(1.1.119) where y 3 ko/mc2. Equation (1.1.119) gives the cross section as a function of the angle 8. For small values of y, the distribution follows the 1 cos2 0 law characteristic of classical electromagnetic theory. As y increases, the distribution becomes increasingly peaked forward, as is generally the case for any high-energy process. The differential cross section as a function of the energy k is given by
+
d@c =
[
?rro2mc2dk 1 + J2;( kko
- 2(y Y+2 1)
+
(1
+ 2r)k y2ko
1
I k~ r2k
(1.1.120)
with
1
1
+
5 -k 5 1 27 - ko
(1.1.121)
Detailed calculations of various quantities and spectra pertaining to the Compton scattering have been carried out by Figure 16 shows the spectrum of the scattered quanta [Eq. (1.1.120)] for incident y energies hvo = 0.5, 1, 2, and 3 MeV. The minimum value hv,i. [Eqs. (1.1.117), (1.1.121)] increases slowly with increasing hvo. Thus hvmin= 0.169 Mev for hvo = 0.5 MeV, and hvmi, = 0.236 Mev for hvo = 3 MeV. (The asymptotic value in the limit v o 4 co is m c 2 / 2 = 0.255 Mev.) It is seen from Fig. 16 that, as hv is increased above hvmin,d @ ~ / d ( h vfirst ) decreases t o a minimum value, and then increases uniformly up to hv = hvo. The minimum of the cross section becomes increasingly more shallow as the primary energy hvo is increased. The total Compton scattering cross section @C is given by
-
(1.1.122) where 40is the Thomson cross section [Eq. (1.1.112)]. For small y (y
<< l),
A. T. Nelms, Nail. Bur. Standards Circ. 642 (1953). See also R. Latter and H. Kahn, “Gamma-Ray Absorption Coefficients.” Published by The Rand Corporation, Santa Monica, California, 1949; G. Allen, Natl. Advisory Comm. Aeronaut. Tech. Notes 2026 (1950). zl$
82
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
Eq. (1.1.122) gives 9 c Ei 4
0 0 - 2Y)
(1.1.122a)
whereas for very large y (y >> l), one obtains (1.1.122b) Equations (1.1.122) show that the Compton cross section decreases uniformly with increasing energy of the y quantum. Figure 17 shows a , was taken from Bethe and Ashkin, referplot of % / 4 0 versus h v ~ which ence 3, p. 322. For comparison, we have also shown the photoelectric
PHOTON ENERGY hv (IN MeV)
FIG.16. Spectrum of Compton scattered quanta, as obtained from Eq. (1.1.120), for incident photon energies hvo = 0.5, 1, 2, and 3 MeV.
cross section divided by 2,in the same units 40 [i.e., @phot/z+O]. The reason by 2 is that a p h o t pertains to the photoelectric effect for for dividing aphat the entire atom, so th at @.phot/Z represents the photoeffect per atomic electron and is therefore the quantity t o be compared with 9 c (Compton scattering per electron). We note th at the energy hvo E h ; ~for which +phot/Z = 9~increases with increasing 2. Thus hih = 0.02, 0.05, 0.13, and 0.53 Mev for C, All Cu, and Pb, respectively. As hvo is increased above h h , the photoelectric effect rapidly becomes unimportant compared to the Compton scattering as a source of y-ray attenuation. It should be noted th at the expression for @c [Eq. (1.1.122)] no longer applies for very low photon energies, where the binding of the atomic electrons must be taken into account. I n this case, the incoherent (Compton) scattering will be reduced, both because of the binding of the atomic
1.1.
INTERACTION O F RADIATION WITH MATTER
83
electrons, and because of the effect of the exclusion principle in preventing transitions to occupied atomic levels. On the other hand, there will also be a substantial amount of coherent scattering from the atom as a whole, so that the total scattering cross section will generally be larger than the value Z@cwhich would be calculated from Eq. (1.1.122). For a discussion of these effects, the reader is referred to the review article of Davisson.*07 The Klein-Nishina formula has been tested in various experiments, and has been shown to be in good agreement with the experimental dat~.206,207.216
and the photoelectric cross section per FIG.17. The Compton total cross section electron, iP,hot/Z, for C, Al,Cu, and Pb, as functions of the incident photon energy hvo. The curves of GphOt/Z were obtained from the results of White.216
1.1.7.3. P a i r Production. The theory of the pair production by y rays is closely related to the theory of the bremsstrahlung by a high-energy electron. The general formula obtained by Bethe and Heitler147using the Born approximation is very complicated and will not be given here. However, the formula simplifies considerably if the energies of both positron and electron are not too high so that screening can be neglected, i.e., if ( 1.I . 123)
where E+ and E- are the total energies of the positron and electron, respectively, and k = hv is the energy of the incident photon. If in addition to Eq. (1.1.123) , all energies involved are large compared to mc2,the
1. PARTICLE
84
DETECTION
energy distribution of the positrons (or electrons) is given by Q(E+) dE+
=
45 dE+
ka
kmc2 ( I. 1.124)
where 5 is defined by
5
(Z2/137)ra2
(1.1.124a)
with T O = e2/mc2 (classical radius of the electron = 2.82 X cm). As is also true for the general Bethe-Heitler formula, Eq. (1.1.124) gives a symmetric energy distribution for the positron and electron. Actually for small velocities v+ and v- of the pair, and for large 2, the Coulomb effect (which is neglected in the Born approximation) becomes important and results in a somewhat asymmetric distribution favoring higher energy positrons. For very large energies E+, E-, the screening is complete (4 = 0 ) , and Q(E+)is given by Q(E+) dE+
=
45dE+
[( +
~-
k3
+ Em2+ +E+E-)ln(183Z-1’s) - +E+E-]. (1.1.125)
Figure 18 shows the energy distribution of the pair particles (positrons or electrons) as obtained from the calculations of Bethe and Ashkin (reference 3, p. 328). For hv up to 10mc2,the curves do not include screening and are valid for all elements; for higher photon energies] the calculations of Bethe and Ashkin were done for Pb and include the effect of screening. It is seen that for small values of hv, the energy distributions are generally quite flat between the minimum and maximum values, T+,mi,= 0 and T+,,,, = k - 2mc2, where T+ is the kinetic energy of the positron. For k/mc2 5 30, the distribution has a broad maximum at T+ = +T+,mx= +lc - mc2.For larger k/mc2, Q(E+) has a broad minimum at +T+,m.xand two subsidiary maxima on each side of the minimum, which implies that for large k/mc2, either the positron or the electron tends to carry off most of the energy of the y ray. For any finite k/mc2, = k - 2mc2. the distribution is zero a t the two ends, T+,mi,= 0 and T+,msx Figure 18 shows that the distributions are symmetrical with respect to T+ = $T++,., = +lc - me2. This is a consequence of the use of the Born approximation for Q(E+), which gives identical spectra for the positron and electron. In analogy with the bremsstrahlung in the field of the atomic electrons] which has been discussed above [Eqs. (1.1.62), (1.1.68)], there is also the possibility of pair production in the field of the atomic electrons. Wheeler
1.1.
85
INTERACTION O F RADIATION WITH MATTER
and Lamb14*have shown that, for complete screening, the electronic pair production is a fraction [/Z of the production in the field of the is the same quantity that appears in the nucleus, where [ (-1.2-1.4) formula for the bremsstrahlung [Eq. (l.l.68)l. Thus, for the case of complete screening, the total @(E+)dE+ (including the electronic con[) in the definition of b tribution) is obtained by replacing Z2 by Z(Z [Eq. (1.1.124a)I. For low energies, where screening can be neglected (hv 5 20 Mev), the pair production in the field of the atomic electrons 15* Rohrlich,'j' Nemirovhas been calculated by B o r s e i l i n ~ , 'Votruba, ~~ sky,L62and Watson.153
+
10
a
NE N I Lb : I
- 4
'? -
w"
a
2
'0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4 (E;
0.5
0.6
07
Q0
0.9
I
mc2)/~v-2mc2)
FIG.18. Energy distribution of the positron (or electron) in an electron pair as a function of the positron kinetic energy for various energies hv of the incident y ray. These curves were taken from the calculations of Bethe and Ashkin (reference 3, p. 328, Fig. 38). For hv 5 IOrnc~,the curves do not include screening and are valid for all elements. For higher photon energies, the curves pertain to Pb and include the effect of screening.
The angular distribution of the pair electrons becomes increasingly forward with increasing energy of the primary quantum, in analogy with the bremsstrahlung distribution. In particular, for high y energies k, the average angle between the incident y ray and the direction of motion of the electron (or positron) is given by <9>
Emmc2/E
(1.1.126)
where E is the energy of the electron (or positron). Equation (1.1.126) is completely analogous to Eq. (1.1.74) for the bremsstrahlung. The pair production in monocrystalline targets has been discussed by ubera11.166
86
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
The total cross section for pair production cally for two limiting cases:
aPaiF can be obtained analyti-
' / ~ screening), Eq. (1.1.124) is valid, (1) For me2 << hv << 1 3 7 r n ~ ~ Z - (no and one finds (1.1.127) ~ screening), integration of Eq. (2) For h v >> 1 3 7 m ~ ~ Z - "(complete (1.1.125) gives = $[? ln(183Z-1'3) - A]. (1.1.128) For intermediate values of hv, the total cross section @pair must be obtained by numerical integration. Figure 19 shows the resulting curves of 14
12 10 @'pair
v
@
8 6
4 2 n "I
2
5
10
20
100 200 hv/mc2
500
2000
l0,OOO
FIG.19. The total cross section for pair production Qlpair as a function of the 7-ray energy, for air and Pb, and for the hypothetical case of no screening. These curves were taken from the calculations of Bethe and Ashkin (reference 3, p. 338, Fig. 41).
for the (hypothetical) case of no screening, and for air and Pb (including screening), as obtained by Bethe and Ashkin (reference 3, p. 338). It is seen that for large energies (hv/mc2 2 50), the values of for air and P b fall below the curve for no screening, and slowly approach the asymptotic value [Eq. (1.1.128)] which is 14.1 for air and 11.6 for Pb. As mentioned above, the Bethe-Heitler theory based on the Born approximation cannot be expected to give accurate results for high Z and low energies of the positron or electron, since the wave functions for these particles will then be appreciably distorted by the Coulomb field
1.1.
87
INTERACTION O F RADIATION WITH MATTER
of the nucleus. Jaeger and Hulme220have calculated the pair production cross sections at two photon energies (hv = 3mc2 and 5.2mc2), using the exact Dirac wave functions for the pair particles. At hv = 3mc2, they obtained results for 2 = 50, 65, and 82; at hv = 5.2mc2, the calculations were carried out for 2 = 82 only. For the worst case, 2 = 82, hv = 3mc2, the Born approximation cross section is too low by a factor of 2 (0.34 X cm2, as compared to 0.67 X cm2 from the exact calculation). For the other 2 values, and hv = 3mc2, the Bethe-Heitler result is also too small, but the deviation decreases rapidly with decreasing 2 or increasing hv. Thus for hv = 5.2mc2, 2 = 82, the error is only 16%. Recent experimental results a t high energies (210 Mev)221-227 have shown that the measured pair production cross sections are appreciably lower than the Bethe-Heitler calculated values, and that the deviation is proportional to Z2. Thus Lawson,222from his measurements at 88 MeV, concluded that the ratio of the experimental to the theoretical cross section can be approximately represented by
~
~= 1 -~1.5 x 1~ 0-522. /
a
(1.1.129) ~
In view of these results, Bethe et al.2zshave carried out an accurate calculation of the pair production, in which the Born approximation was not used. They have found that the correction to the Born approximation result of Bethe and Heitler147is a reduction of the cross section proportional to Z2, as is indicated by the experimental data. Upon applying this correction, Bethe et a1.228have obtained excellent agreement with the measurements of LawsonZP2 at 88 MeV, and those of DeWire et aLZz4a t 280 MeV. It may be noted that the correction to the Born approximation is a reduction of the cross section a t high energies, as compared to an increase of the cross section at low energies.220 The correction goes through 6 Mev.226n228 zero at hv 1.1.7.4. Total Absorption Cross Section for y Rays. The total cross section u for the removal of a y-ray photon from the incident beam is given by u z= a p h o t 2a.c @'pair. ( 1.1.130) Z z O J . C. Jaeger and H. R. Hulme, Proc. Roy. SOC.A163, 443 (1936); J. C. Jaeger,
-
+
+
Nature 137, 781 (1936). 2 2 1 C. D. Adams, Phys. Rev. 74, 1707 (1948). a22 J. L.Lawson, Phys. Rev. 76, 433 (1949). 223 R. L. Walker, Phys. Rev. 76, 527 (1949). 224 J. W. DeWire, A. Ashkin, and L. A. Beach, Phys. Rev. 83, 505 (1951). 2zaC. R.Emigh, Phys. Rev. 86, 1028 (1952). z*BE. S. Rosenblum, E. F. Shrader, and R. M. Warner, Phys. Rev. 88, 612 (1952). 227 A. I. Berman, Phys. Rev. 90, 210 (1953). 228 H.A. Bethe and L. C. Maximon, Phys. Rev. 93, 768 (1954); H. Davies, H.A. Bethe, and L. C. Maximon, ibid. 93, 788 (1954).
~
88
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
The complete absorption coefficient c equals Nu.Figure 20 shows the mass absorption coefficient T/P (in units cmZ/gm) for Al, Cu, and Pb. For Pb, we have presented the separate contributions to r / p due to the photoelectric effect, Compton effect, and pair production (dashed curves). The values of r / p were obtained from the tables of White.216It is seen from Fig. 20 that, as a function of frequency, T has a minimum, which 4 for Pb. occurs at hv ? 20 Mev for Al, .=8 Mev for Cu, and ~ 3 . Mev For Pb, the minimum lies in the region where the Compton effect is predominant. For lower v, the photoelectric effect predominates, and the with increasing v is responsible for the decrease of rapid decrease of apbot ale c
$'
0.16
E
0
-$g
0.14
0.12
I-
0.10
2
'a
0.08
0.06
t 0.04 a 0
2 O.O2 0
0.1
0.5
0.2
I
2
5
10
20
50
100
PHOTON ENERGY h Y (IN MeV)
FIG.20. The mass absorption coefficient T/P for Al, Cu, and Pb, as a function of the photon energy hv. For Pb, the separate contributions of the photoelectric effect, Compton effect, and pair production are shown by the dashed curve8. The curves of r / p shown in this figure were obtained from the tables of White.216
the total absorption coefficient c. At frequencies somewhat above the position of the minimum, the pair production becomes the main effect, and is responsible for the rapid increase of with increasing v, until a t very high energies (hv 5 Bev), T approaches a constant value as a result of the saturation of due to screening. The minimum of r implies that y rays of energies of the order of 5-20 Mev have a relatively long mean free path in matter. The values of ~ / at p the minimum for Al, Cu, and Pb, are as follows, according to the data of White: 0.0217 cm2/gm for Al; 0.0306 cm2/gm for Cu, and 0.041 cm2/gm for Pb. The corresponding values of the maximum mean free path are: Amsx = 46.1 gm/cm2 for A1 (at hv = 20 Mev); ,A, = 32.7 gm/cm2 for Cu (at hv = 8 Mev); X, = 24.4 gm/cm2 for P b (at hv = 3.4 Mev).
-
1.2.
IONIZATION CHAMBERS
89
C ~ l g a t has e~~ carried ~ out measurements of the total y-ray absorption cross section a for y energies of 0.411, 0.664, 1.33, 2.62 Mev using radioactive sources, and 4.47,6.13, 17.6 Mev using y rays from nuclear reactions. The measurements were made for a variety of absorbers (polyethylene, C, Al, Cu, Sn, Pt, Pb, Bi, and U). I n general, the theory is in good agreement with these data, when account is taken of a small correction due to Rayleigh in addition to the three principal effects: the photoelectric effect, Compton scattering, and pair production in the field of the nucleus and the atomic electrons. The present theory is in reasonable agreement with measurements of the absorption coefficient at various energies up to 280 M ~ v . ~ ~ ~ , ~
1.2. Ionization Chambers* 1.2.1. General considerations’ An ionization chamber is a device which measures the amount of ionization created by charged particles passing through a gas. The basic processes of ionization of gases by charged particles have been discussed in Chapter 1.1.7 If an electric field be maintained in the gas by a pair of electrodes, the positive and negative ions will drift apart, inducing charges on the electrodes which can be detected as a voltage pulse. Or if a steady flux of particles enter the chamber one can measure the average current caused by the ionization. The latter application will be specifically considered in Section 1.2.7; the other sections of this chapter, however, will be principally devoted to the ionization chamber as a detector of single particles and therefore as a pulse instrument. 1.2.1.1. Essentials of a Pulse Ionization Chamber. Figure 1 shows schematically the essential parts of this very simple device. One of the electrodes, the “collector” (a misnomer, as we shall see), is designed to have a low capacity both to the other electrode and to ground, so that a very small charge will still give a measurable potential change. The small amount of charge is characteristic: if the particle loses 1 Mev in collisions S. A. Colgate, Phys. Rev. 87, 592 (1952). W. Franz, Z. Physik 98, 314 (1935); P. Debye, Physik. Z. 31, 419 (1930). t See also Vol. 2, Chapter 4.1 and Vol. 4, B, Chapter 7.5 and Section 9.2.3. 1 General references for Sections 1.2 and 1.3 are: D. H. Wilkinson, “Ionization Chambers and Counters.” Cambridge Univ. Press, London and New York, 1950; B. B. Rossi and H. Staub, “Ionization Chambers and Counters.” McGraw-Hill, New York, 1949; S. C. Curran and J. D. Craggs, “Counting Tubes.” Academic Press, New York, 1949; see also Vol. 4, A, Section 2.1.5. **o
*an
-
* Chapter
1.2 is by Robert W. Williams.
90
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
with the gas, the number N of electrons released will be about 30,000, or coulomb. The passage of a particle creates the ionization, for all practical purposes, instantaneously. The positive ions then drift toward the negative electrode with a velocity of the order of (1cm/sec) X [(760 mm Hg)/p X [ E / ( l volt/cm)] or in a typical case 0.001 cm/psec. The electrons, if they do not suffer attachment and thereby become heavy negative ions, will drift toward the positive electrode with velocities, under comparable conditions, of 1-5 cm/psec. For definiteness assume, as is usually the case, that the collector is the anode. The collector potential is lowered both by the motion of electrons toward it and by the motion of positive ions away from it. It is instructive to calculate explicitly the potential change in a highly idealized case; for
a charge of 5 X
'\ \
I
I
= -k
FIG. 1. The essentials of a pulse ionization chamber (schematic). The dotted line illustrates the path of an ionizing particle whose passage leaves pairs of ions in the gas of the chamber.
example, insulated long cylindrical electrodes with cylindrical sheets of positive and negative charge, Q+ = Q- = Q formed a t radius r1 (Fig. 2). Let the initial potential difference between inner and outer electrodes be Vo(b)- V O ( Uwhere ), V,(r) is the potential at any point in the chamber before the charge sheets have been moved apart, and assume that the negative sheet of charge collapses uniformly toward the central electrode and the positive one expands toward the outer electrode. When the two charge distributions are at r- and r+ respectively we find from elementary calculation that the potential has changed by an amount which is independent of the magnitude of the initial potential, and which can be written (1.2.1)
This result, that the potential change of the electrode is proportional t o the fraction of the total potential drop through which the charge has
1.2.
IONIZATION CHAMBERS
91
moved, is not restricted to this special geometry; it will be discussed in more detail in Section 1.2.2. We use it here to note that the total voltage pulse, if all the ions are ultimately collected, is Q/C as expected, and that the part of this pulse corresponding to electron motion occurs orders of magnitude more rapidly than the part due to ion motion. It is therefore important t o know under what circumstances the electrons will remain free as they drift through the gas, and what mechanisms may prevent complete collection of all ions.
FIG.2. Idealized cylindrical ionization chamber.
1.2.1.2. Behavior of Ions and Electrons in Gases. The positive ions which are formed upon passage of a charged particle through the gas remain nearly in thermal equilibrium with the gas. The presence of the electric field causes them to drift toward the cathode, but the increase in kinetic energy is very small and they rapidly reach a terminal mean velocity for which the energy gained from the electric field is dissipated in molecular collisions. This “drift velocity’’ would be expected to depend on the ratio of field strength to mean free path, and indeed it is observed experimentally t o be, in the ionization-chamber range, a linear function of E / p : 760E (1.2.2) w = Ko-
P,
with E in volts per centimeter and p in mm Hg, K Oranges from about 8 cm/sec for Ne, t o 2.5 cm/sec for Ar, t o 1 cm/sec for Xe.2 Negative ions 2 A. M. Tyndall, “The Mobility of Positive Ions in Gases.” Cambridge Univ. Press, London and New York, 1938.
92
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
(not electrons) have about the same drift velocities. A simple theory of drift velocity8 yields the expression
_e _X -E muP where is the mean free path and u the ion’s speed, assumed the same for all ions. Since practical limitations (Section 1.2.3) usually restrict the average value of E / p to not more than -1 volt/cm/mm Hg, the minimum time required for ions to cross even a small ionization chamber, say 1 cm, will be -0.2 msec, and in most cases it will be considerably longer. In nearly all cases where ionization chambers are used to count individual particles only the fast portion of the pulse, due to the motion of the electrons, is utilized. The electrons which are released in the initial ionization prove to remain free, in most gases, until they impinge on an electrode (or other surface). The exceptions are electronegative gases which have an appreciable probability to form negative ions by electron attachment. For 0 2 , the most dangerous offender, the probability of attachment, per collision, is 10V to Water vapor has a similarly large attachment probability, and Clz, NH,, N20, HzS, SO?, NO, and HC1 are all known to be bad. In a nonattaching gas-Ar, N2, CH4 are among the commonly used ones-the electrons continue to drift toward the anode, but acquire from the field a kinetic energy many times their thermal energy, because the mechanisms of energy transfer to the gas are relatively inefficient. The denoted by the ratio of mean kinetic energy to thermal energy (#KT), “agitation energy” 7,is typically of the order of 100 in a noble gas, where elastic collision and atomic excitation are the only available energytransfer mechanisms; it is down by an order of magnitude in diatomic gases, and is not much greater than 1 in polyatomic gases. Table I gives some values5 for the drift velocity and agitation energy of electrons in various gases. Argon is a particularly important gas; it is convenient and is widely used. Its first excitation level is very high, 11.5 volts, and in consequence the electron agitation energy is large. A small amount of polyatomic impurity gas lowers the agitation energy greatly; Rossi and Staub’ find w
=
8 13. B. Rossi and H. Staub, “Ionization Chambers and Counters,” p. 6. McGrawHill, New York, 1949. D. H. Wilkinson, “Ionization Chambers and Counters,” p. 41. Cambridge Univ. Press, London and New York, 1950. 6Based on R. H. Healey and J. W. Reed, “The Behavior of Slow Electrons in Gases,” Amalgamated Wireless, Ltd., Sydney, Australia, 1941; and tables in Wilkineon,‘ and Rossi and Staub,s
1.2.
93
IONIZATION CHAMBERS
about a factor of ten for 10% COZ at E / p = 1. This has the effect of increasing the drift velocity, for two reasons: the electron speed is lowered [see Eq. (1.2.2)], and because of the Ramsauer resonance effect on the cross section of noble gas atoms for electrons the mean free path proves to increase, in the region of interest (which is from -10 ev to -1 ev). Table I includes the drift velocity in 5 % and 10% CO,; at E / p = 1 the increase over pure Ar is a factor of ten; there is a comparable increase when the mixture is compared to pure C02, because the mean free path of -1 ev electrons in argon is so great. TABLEI. Drift Velocity w and Ratio of Agitation Energy t o Thermal Energy 9 for Electrons in Various Gases a t Room Temperature; Principally from Healey and Reed5 Values are approximate and in noble gases are strongly impurity sensitive.
E/p
He Ne Ar HI
N2
coo
0.95 Ar 0.05 COz 0 . 0 9 Ar 0 . 1 coz
=
0.2 v/cm/mm Hg
w (cm/piiec)
tl
0.5 0.5 0.3 0.4 0.4 0.1
62 120 2.7 6.5 1.5
11
E / p = 1 v/cm/mm Hg
---
w (cm/Mec) 0.9 1.5 0.5 1 .o 0.8 0.55
3.3
4.3
0.9
5.3
9
53 216 285 9.3 21.5 1.5
R. H. Healey and J. W. Reed, “The Behavior of Slow Electrons in Gases.” Amalgamated Wireless, Ltd., Sydney, Australia, 1941. 0
The greater drift velocity of Ar-C02 mixtures is often of great practical value in obtaining a faster pulse, and these mixtures are widely used. Unpurified tank argon alone will give rise to an electron drift velocity considerably greater than that of Table I, and is satisfactory for many applications where E / p is large (-1) and where accurate pulse height is not essential. In high-pressure cylindrical-geometry chambers, where E / p at the outer electrode is usually quite low, the Ar-C02 mixture may show some attachmentJ6and pure Ar will give better performance. There are two additional complications in the motions of ions or elec6 Under ordinary conditions COO has negligible electron attachment. Experience with cosmic-ray ionization chambers [H. S. Bridge, W. E. Hazen, B. B. Rossi, and R. W. Williams, Phys. Rev. 74, 1083 (1948)Jindicates that a t very low E / p values (-0.01), “pure” Ar has distinctly less attachment than Ar-COZ mixtures.
94
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
trons in gases which can lead to reduction in pulse height; we now consider the first of these, diffusion. The center of gravity of a group of ions which is liberated at a point in an electric field will have a displacement proportional to the time, while the mean distance of the ions from the center of gravity will increase as the square root of the time. The importance of diffusion can be measured by the ratio of the latter distance to the former one. This ratio can be calculated from kinetic theory; the mean free path cancels out, and one has, for a gas at room temperature.’ diffusion distance drift distance
=
o.18
d+
(1.2.3)
where q is the agitation energy and V the voltage difference between the point of release of the ions and the final position of the center of gravity. For heavy ions 7 = 1 and the effects of diffusion will generally be small. For electrons 7 may be -100 in noble gases, and diffusion may be important; electrons may diffuse back to the cathode, or out beyond the boundaries of the apparatus. The “ C 0 2 effect ” may be utilized to reduce r] and therefore decrease the electron diffusion. The second effect is recombination, the neutralization of positive and negative ions before they are collected. This is a complex subject, considered in detail by Wilkin~on,~ and we shall only summarize the principal results. The recombination coefficient a is defined by writing the rate of disappearance of ions, when n+ positive ions and n- negative ions per cubic centimeter are present, as an+n-,8 with a depending on agitation energy, and, of course, on the nature of the negative ions; a is cm3/sec for heavy negative ions, and cm3/sec for electrons. In air chambers or other chambers where attachment is more or less complete, recombination can be a serious cause of pulse loss, particularly in those current chambers which contain a large density of ionization (Section 1.2.7). Free-electron chambers are better both because of the smaller value of 01 and the shorter time which the electrons spend in the gas. The over-all improvement factor is -lo7; therefore free-electron chambers do not suffer from recombination effects under any circumstances ordinarily realized. Ionization chambers used as monitors of the direct beams of pulsed machines (synchrotrons, etc.) present special problems. They will be considered in Section 2.7.1. 7 D. H. Wilkinson, “Ionization Chambers and Counters,” p. 37. Cambridge Univ. Press, London and New York, 1950. * This assumes that an ion, when created, does not recombine preferentially with the other member of the pair. The assumption is surely correct if the negative ions are electrons, b u t it might be expected to break down in very high-pressure air.
1.2.
95
IONIZATION CHAMBERS
1.2.2. Pulse Formation Quantitative use of the ionization chamber as a particle detector requires consideration of shape and magnitude of the voltage pulse caused by release of ionization. We at first calculate the potential change of the collecting electrode due to the motion of a single charge, assuming that the electrode is essentially insulated (i.e., referring to Fig. 1, that the time constant RC of the grid resistor and the capacity of the collector is large compared to the collection time of an ion). The result which was obtained for a special case in Section 1.2.1 can be obtained for arbitrary two-electrode geometry under the assumption (always true in practice, even in a Geiger counter) that the charge released in the gas is small compared to the charges residing on the electrodes which give rise to the initial potential difference Vb Va. Consider an electron of charge -e at point r l in the gas. The potential at rl will consist of two parts: the potential Vo(rl) due to the charges on the electrodes, which is, by our assumption, essentially independent of any charges which may be present in the gas, and V8(rl), the potential due to other ionization which may be present in the gas. Then the electrostatic energy of the electron consists of two independent parts, the spacecharge energy and the energy in the field of the electrodes, and we may consider the latter ~ e p a r a t e l y The . ~ energy of the system of electrodes, plus the electron, is
-
+BqiVi = i[-eV,(r,)
-k
&ova0
- QoVao].
where V , and v b are the electrode potentials, and the subscript 0 refers to initial values. As the electron drifts from rl to r 2 the work done on it by the field must be extracted from this system; QO and VbO must remain fixed, but Val the collector potential, can change by some amount AV. Thus we have -e[Vo(rz) - Vo(r1)l
=
+[-eVo(rd
+ eV&d +
QO
AVI (1.2.4)
which is the desired result. 9 The space charge has no direct effect on the size of the pulse due to one electron but it may affect the velocity of the electron and therefore the pulse shape, and secondary effects of the electron. In pulse ionization chambers these questions are unimportant because the space charge is so small, but they are crucial in Geiger counter operation (Section 1.3.2).
1.
96
PARTICLE DETECTION
Two examples will serve to illustrate the behavior of pulse ionization chambers utilizing electron collection (the pulse shape of “slow” chambers is not usually interesting). First the parallel-plate chamber of separation d, ion-pair formed at X;O from the positive electrode, at t = 0. AV will have a rapid contribution from the motion of the electron which has drift velocity w-, and a much slower contribution from the positive ion (drift velocity w+). -e A V = - (C =
w-t
+ wft )
-e
(7w+t + 2)
-e C
finally.
--
until w-t until w+t
= =
xo
d - xo
Figure 3 illustrates this pulse using drift velocities characteristic of argon. To take advantage of the fast electron-collection pulse one must eliminate the effects of the slow positive ions by incorporating a low-frequency rejection network in the collector circuit of the chamber or, more commonly, in the amplifier-e.g., a short time-constant T in a resistancecapacitance coupling stage such that RC = r << t+, the collection time of the ions. The rapidly-rising (electron-collection) part of the pulse will not be much affected so long as r >> t- where t- is the collection time of the electrons, but the positive-ion pulse will be reduced by roughly r/t+. For a given form of input pulse the detailed shape of the pulse after passing through the low-frequency rejection network can be obtained by standard transient-response analysis-Wilkinsonl gives several examples. The dotted line in Fig. 3 illustrates the effect of a time-constant r = 5t(10% pulse-height loss). An approximation which is sufficient for some purposes is to assume that the voltage rise due to the electrons is undistorted, but that the voltage then returns t o zero with the time constant r, and with no positive ion contribution. A network which gives a more nearly square-topped pulse is illustrated in Fig. 4;it consists of a shorted delay line in series with a resistance equal to its characteristic impedance. It is less convenient than the RC, and causes a 50% amplitude loss, so that it is usually used only when there is some reason to require a good pulse shape. The pulse-shaping action of this network is illustrated in Fig. 5. The second example of the voltage pulse in an electron-collection chamber is that of cylindrical geometry: a small central electrode, of radius a, is surrounded by a concentric cylinder of radius b. This is a simple, lowcapacity arrangement, and its chief virtue is that the electron-collection
1.2.
IONIZATION CHAMBERS
97
C 3Q.C d C
nv t
, I \'\ \
'.. -
FIQ.3. Idealized voltage pulse from a parallel-plate ionization chamber. An ion pair is released at distance Xa from the negative electrode. The time scale would be approximately right if, for example, d were 2 cm, V were 1000 volts, and P were 1 atmos. The dashed line indicates the effect of a five-microsecond time constant.
0-jD.L.
FIQ.4. Shorted-delay-line pulse-shaping network. Rk is equal to the characteristic impedance of the delay-line.
t
-AV
FIQ.5. Effect of delay-line pulse shaping on a typical pulse from a cylindrical ionization chamber; 270 is the round-trip time of the line, and must be greater than t-, the electron collection time, if t h e pulse is to have a flat top.
98
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
pulse is reasonably independent of the point at which the electron is released, since most of the potential drop occurs near the central wire, Figure 6 shows the electron pulse in a chamber with b/a = 120, calculated for a single electron [curves (a) and (a’)]; for uniform ionization in the chamber [curves (b) and (b‘)]; and for uniform ionization along a straight line passing through the axis of the chamber [curve (c)]. The pulse shape,
FIG.6. Electron pulse in a cylindrical ionization chamber: 1- is the drift time from outer to inner electrode; curves (a) and (a’) are for a single electron, (b) and (b’) for a uniform distribution, and (c) for a linear distribution.
AV(t)/AVfina~,is calculated from Eq. (1.2.1), with elapsed time related to drift velocity by
t=
J:&
and with two assumptions for w: constant (solid curves) and proportional to (E)”q(dotted curves). Inspection of curve (a) shows that a considerable portion of the chamber volume gives rise to pulses of nearly maximum height. It is easy to show that uniform ionization gives a pulse which is a fraction f of the total-charge-collection pulse, f = b2/(b2 - u2)
This is 0.90 for b/a
=
120.
- 1/[2 ln(b/u)]
1.2.
IONIZATION CHAMBERS
99
The parallel-plate chamber can be modified so that it gives an electron pulse independent of the point of production,1° by adding a third electrode. A grid at a fixed potential, near the collecting electrode, will shield the collecting electrode from the rest of the chamber (Fig. 7) so that only that portion of the electron’s travel which takes place between the grid and the collector will cause a pulse to be induced. The electrostatic situation near the edge of an electrode will in general be complicated-either the field will be quite distorted and therefore the effective volume, and expected pulse shape, somewhat uncertain, or the field shape can be maintained by “guard electrodes”-extra electrodes, Grid, Useful Volume
-
Collector
h
FIG. 7. Schematic diagram of a gridded chamber. Electrons originating in the shaded area will give pulses of nearly uniform height as they pass between the grid and the collector.
held at the average potential of the collecting electrode, which maintain the symmetry of the field beyond the edge of the collecting electrode. The pulse induced by an electron near the edge of the collector is more complicated in this case; detailed calculations in simple cases are given by Rossi and S t a ~ b . ~ In many applications of ionization chambers one is interested in average current or in total amount of charge collected (Section 1.2.7). For these chambers (as well as for “slow” pulse chambers which respond to the motion of ions) the details of the eIectron pulse are unimportant. The guard electrode helps t o define accurately the volume of gas from which ionization is collected. The role of the guard electrode in preventing leakage current is discussed in Section 1.2.7. 10 For the detailed theory of this device, Bee D. H. Witkinson, “Ionization Chambers and Counters,” p. 74. Cambridge Univ. Press, London and New York, 1950.
100
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
1.2.3. Quantitative Operation and Some Practical Considerations 1.2.3.1. Attachment, Diffusion, Recombination. Those basic phenomena of the passage of electricity through gases which affect the operation of ionization chambers are discussed in Section 1.2.1. Their importance may range from very little in the case of large E / p and nonabsolute pulseheight requirements (e.g., a low-pressure parallel-plate chamber used as a counter) to considerable in the opposite extremes (e.g., a high-pressure cylindrical chamber used for proton recoil pulse-height spectrum work). The maximum value of E / p which can be used is determined by the condition that there should be no gas multiplication (Section 1.3.1) even in the region where E / p is largest. For cylindrical or spherical chambers this means that E / p will necessarily be low in the region near the outer electrode; and in general the difficulties mentioned are associated with low E / p . Even with parallel-plate chambers the inconvenience of working with high voltages will often put a practical limit on the available E / p . Electron attachment can be eliminated by sufficiently rigorous exclusion of electronegative gases, of which O2 and H20 are the most frequent offenders. Noble gases can be purified very effectively by circulation over hot calcium c h i p ~ . ~Purified Jl argon in a clean metal-and-glass chamber with soldered seals has been found to remain free from attachment for years, in an application in which the minimum E / p was about 0.01 v/cm/mm Hg. However, a chamber containing volatile material (e.g., rubber gaskets) must be purified frequently if quantitative performance under low E / p conditions is to be maintained. The Ar-C02 mixture previously referred to can also be purified with hot ~ a l c i u r nand , ~ is free of attachment under most conditions. However, there are indications12 that at very low E / p this mixture, unlike pure argon, shows noticeable attachment. Gases which cannot be purified by such drastic methods, e.g., BF3 (which in pure form does not have serious attachment), must be prepared with great care. Graves and Fromanla describe a suitable technique for preparing BF3for ionization chambers. Recombination can be shown to be negligible14under nearly any circumstances in chambers in which no attachment takes place. This subject will therefore be treated in Section 1.2.7, in connection with current chambers. L. Colli and U. Facchini, Rev. Sci. Instr. 23, 39 (1952). H. S. Bridge, W. E. Hazen, B. B. Rossi, and R. W. Williams, Phys. Rev. 74,1083 (1948). l 3 A. C. Graves and D. K. Froman, “Miscellaneous Physical and Chemical Techniques of the Los Alamos Project,” p. 154. McGraw-Hill, New York, 1952. l4 D. H. Wilkinson, “Ionization Chambers and Counters,” Chapter 111. Cambridge Univ. Press, London and New York, 1950. 11
la
1.2.
101
IONIZATION CHAMBERS
Diffusion effects are important only for electrons under conditions of large agitation energy q [Eq. (1.2.3)].A typical situation in which diffusion may be important occurs when ionization is released adjacent to the wall of the chamber, as when a noncollimated alpha-particle source is incorporated in the negative electrode as a calibrating standard. It can be assumed that electrons which diffuse back t o the negative electrode are lost, and with the help of Eq. (1.2.3) an estimate of the pulse loss from this effect can be made. Addition of a polyatomic gas, with consequent 10 r
0
0.5
1.0
15
2 .o
2.5
E (ev) FIG.8. Attachment probability h upon collision of an electron with an oxygen molecule, as a function of electron energy E. From Wilkinson,6 by permission.
reduction of 7, is of course desirable for applications where diffusion must be minimized. An example of a complete diffusion calculation is worked out by Rossi and Staub.16 1.2.3.2. Checks for Quantitative Operation. Spurious Effects. The most commonly used test for proper ionization-chamber operation is the examination of the pulse height, from some reproducible source, as a function of collecting voltage. If a chamber exhibits a good “plateau”region in which pulse height is independent of voltage-it is usually considered free from the defects we have outlined. However, examination of the dependence of electron attachment coefficient on electron energy, Fig. 8, shows that in oxygen, at least, there is a region in which increasing electron energy causes an increase in attachment coefficient, which might l6 B. B. Rossi and H. Staub, “Ionization Chambers and Counters,” p. 27. McGrawHill, New York, 1949.
102
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
compensate the decreased number of collisions which electrons suffer at higher energies. Also, the drift velocity (in impure argon, for example) l6 may not increase with E. The existence of a plateau is therefore not a sufficient indication, in a pulse chamber, that all electrons are being collected. A source of alpha particles of known energy can be used to release a known amount of ionization in the chamber (Section 1.2.4), say Qo. The pulse height due to the electron motion should then be
Vo = (fQo/C,)G where f is the (average) fraction of total voltage drop through which the electrons move, C, the collector capacity, and G the amplifier gain. A quantitative check system based on this principle is outlined by Bridge and associates.6 A more elaborate method of checking, which does not depend on knowing the capacity of the chamber, has been used by Hazen and collaborators.I6 They provide a polonium source which remains at the potential of the negative electrode but can be moved toward the collecting electrode, reducing the degree of attachment by reducing the path length through which the electrons move. Constant pulse height as the source is moved in is a reliable check in this case. A still more elaborate method, using a pulsed X-ray source and measuring the fraction of total current carried by electrons, is described by Rossi and Staub.” In the design and construction of pulse ionization chambers a reasonable care must be taken to avoid spurious pulses from high-voltage leakage or breakdown or electrical pickup. Any good insulators can be used (in contrast to the current chambers described in Section 1.2.7, which require very high quality insulators) ; in particular, glass-Kovar seals are very useful. In most applications it is possible to provide a grounded conductor (guard electrode) which separates the high-voltage insulator from the collector insulator, thereby greatly reducing the dificulties caused by leakage across the high-voltage insulator. It is sometimes convenient to have the collector at high voltage, and to connect it to the amplifier through a coupling condenser. The condenser must then be selected very carefully. Ceramic condensers seem to be the most satisfactory. The signal obtained from a pulse chamber is often of the order of a millivolt or less. Obviously the collector and the amplifier input must be completely shielded. Ordinarily a double shield (i.e., a grounded case See F. E. Driggers, Phys. Rev. 87, 1080 (1952). B. B. Rossi and H. Staub, “Ionization Chambers and Counters,” p. 58. McGrawHill, New York, 1949. l8
l7
1.2.
IONIZATION CHAMBERS
103
outside the high-voltage electrode) is necessary; occasionally one must take special precautions-such as connecting all grounds together only a t the first tube of the amplifier-to prevent electrical pickup. The use of a short time-constant in the amplifier eliminates most ac and microphonic difficulties, although in low-level work it is often necessary t o operate the preamplifier filaments on dc.
1.2.4. Amount of Ionization liberated The basic process by which a fast charged particle loses energy in a gas have been discussed in Chapter 1.1,* where it is pointed out th a t the total energy loss of a particle of charge Z and velocity @ is, within certain limitations, just proportional to Z 2 times a function of @.Experimentally it is found that a given energy loss gives rise t o a number of ion pairs that depends on the gas, but is approximately (to at worst 10%) independent of the nature and speed of the particle. One can understand in a qualitative way why this should be so: the primary energy-loss event results either in excitation of the gas molecule, or in ionization. I n the latter case the electron may be ejected with considerable energy, but if so it will itself undergo further excitation or ionization collisions, 80 that the energy ultimately either goes into ionization or into excitation (whence it is dissipated in collisions or escapes as radiation.I8 The partition of energy between ionization and excitation depends mainly on the behavior of rather slow electrons even though the primary particle may be of very high energy. The energy loss corresponding to the formation of one ion pair W proves t o be a few times the ionization potential. T he constancy of W means th at the energy of a particle which stops in an ionization chamber can be measured by measuring the quantity of ionization released, or more generally the energy lost in the chamber by particles passing through is directly proportional to the ionization. This is an important and much-used property of the ionization chamber, and for quantitative work i t is clearly necessary to have accurate empirical data ~ ' provided a large amount on W . The work of Jesse and S a d a u k i ~ ' ~ -has of information on W ;it extends previous work, and where a cross-check
* See also Vol. 4, A, Parts 1 and 4. Xenon and, to a lesser extent, krypton and argon give off a considerable fraction of this energy as "scintillation" light in the visible and ultraviolet region. See R. A. Nobles, Rev. Sci. Znstr. 27, 280 (1956);C. Figgler and C. M. Huddleston, Phys. Rev. 96, 600 (1954);A. Sayres and C. S. Wu, Rev. Sci. Instr. 28, 758 (1957).Such noble gas scintillations are discussed in Chapter 1.4. 18 W. P. Jesse and J. Sadaukis, Phvs. Rev. 97, 1668 (1955);100, 1755 (1955);W.P. Jesse, H. Forstat, and J. Sadaukis, ibid. 77,782 (1950). 20 W.P. Jesse and J. Sadaukis, Phys. Rev. 102, 389 (1956). 21 W.P. Jesse and J. Sadaukis, Phys. Rev. 107, 766 (1957). 16
104
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
is possible it agrees with other contemporary data; the relative accuracy between different gases is a few tenths of a per cent, and the absolute accuracy about 1%. Their principal results are summarized in Table 11, TABLE 11. Average Energy, in ev, to Make an Ion Pair W for Beta Particles, Po210Alpha Particles, and Low-Energy Alpha Particles, in Pure Gases* Gas He Ne Ar Kr Xe Hz
Air Nz 0 2
COZ CaHi CzHe CHI CzHz
Mean W,g for beta particles
W , for PoZlO alpha particles
W , for alpha particles of 1.2 Mev
42.3 36.6 (26.4) 24.2 22.0 36.3 34.0 35.0 30.9 32.9 26.2 24.8 27.3 25.9
42.7 36.8 26.4 24.1 21.9 36.3 35.5 36.6 32.5 34.5 28.0 26.6 29.2 27.5
42.4 37.4 (26.4) 24.1
37.1 38.1 36.3 29.8 28.5 31 .O 29.0
W. P. Jesse and J. Sadaukis, Phys. Rev. 102, 389 (1956); 107, 766 (1957).
where values of W are listed as the energy loss in electron volts corresponding to one ion pair. The table is actually based on the assumption that in argon W is a true constant for different particles; this assumption is strongly supported in reference 21. The constancy of W in argon for alpha particles of varying velocities has been checkedlS for a range of 1 to 9 MeV. There is evidence from a study of Po210 recoil nuclei20 that these extremely slow and heavy particles have a W ,in argon, about four times that of alpha particles. However, fission fragments already exhibit “normal” behaviorzz-they have a W of 36 ev in air, and presumably would show the standard W in argon. Bakker and SegrtP found W for 340-Mev protons to be 35.3 for Hz and 33.6 Nz,3% lower than the W,gvalues of Table 11. BarberZ4studied the specificionization of high-energy electrons (1 to 34 Mev). By assuming the validity of the theoretical energy-loss expression he found, for elec22 D. H. Wilkinson, “Ionization Chambers and Counters,” p. 21. Cambridge Univ. Press, London and New York, 1950. [See D. West, Can. J. Research A26, 115 (1948); N. D. Lassen, Phys. Rev. 70, 577 (1946).] ** C. J. Bakker and E. Segr6, Phys. Rev. 81, 489 (1951). 24 W. C. Barber, Phys. Rev. 97, 1071 (1955).
1.2.
IONIZATION CHAMBERS
105
trons of -2 MeV, W values of 37.8 0.7 in Hz, 44.5 t- 0.9 in He, and 34.8 5-0.9 in Nz. At higher energies the Nz value remains constant but the Hz value increased by about 3% a t 34 MeV, presumably because Cerenkov radiation begins to carry off some of the energy. The general conclusion to be drawn is that in pure noble gases, and in hydrogen, W is independent of the energy and nature of the particle, to about 1%, over a wide range. I n air and other complex gases one can expect a lessened ionization efficiency a t high specific ionizations, i.e., an increase in W which can be of the order of 10%. However, it has been found’g that in the noble gases of very high ionization potential, notably helium, minute admixtures of impurity reduce the value of W very decidedly: for example, 100 parts per million of Ar in He has a 25% effect. Presumably this is caused by ionizing collisions of metastable He atoms with argon atoms (the first excited state of He is higher than the ionization potential of Ar). Argon should be free of this difficulty, since it has a much lower ionization potential. Statistical fluctuations in the actual number of N of ions formed in a chamber around the average number of fl = A E / W (where energy AE is lost in the chamber) present two quite different problems. If the particle loses all its energy, fluctuations in the rate of energy loss will be correlated, since the total energy is fixed, and the standard deviation in N will be it has been calculated to be about two-thirds of this.25 less than 4%; But if the energy lost in the chamber, AE, is only a small fraction of E , the fluctuations in AE will depend on the number of primary collisions N , and on the energy given to the delta ray in each collision; the standard deviation will be considerably greater than The problem is more characteristic of proportional counters than of ionization chambers, since the former must be used when AE is small; discussion is therefore postponed to Section 1.3.1.
dz.
1.2.5. Noise: Practical Limit of Energy Loss Measurable
The smallest charge which can be detected as a pulse in an ionization chamber is limited by the intrinsic noise of the first stage of the amplifier. Amplifier noise as it affects the sensitivity of ionization chambers is discussed by ElmoreZ* and Gille~pie.~’ * Depending on conditions (fast or slow rise, large or small chamber capacity), different sources of noise may become the predominant source of noise charge. The optimum signal-to-
* See also Vol. 2, Chapter 12.5. U. Fano, Phys. Rev. 72, 26 (1947). W. C. Elmore, Nucleonics 2, (3), 16 (1948). 27 A. B. Gillespie, “Signal, Noise, and Resolution in Nuclear Counter Amplifiers.” Pergamon, New York, 1953. 26
26
106
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
noise situation proves to be one in which rise time is comparable with pulse duration. Elmore shows that in a typical short-pulse-duration chamber, if C,,, is the chamber capacity in micromicrofarads, R, the “equivalent shot noise resistance” in ohms, and T the pulse duration in microseconds, the most probable noise charge in electron charges is Q/e
-
CPpfdR./7
for the best signal-to-noise ratio. The equivalent resistance R, is defined so that 4kTR, = 2eI,/gm2 where k is the Boltzmann constant, and I , and gm are the plate current and transconductance of the first tube of the amplifier. A typical value for R, is 10000, for 7 , 10 psec, and for C , 30 ppf, so that Q / e 300 ion pairs equivalent noise. This would correspond to about 9000 ev of energy loss in the chamber. Of course fluctuations of three or four times the most probable noise occur frequently, and the minimum charge which can be detected reliably corresponds to about 5 times this, or an energy loss of 50,000 ev. This is somewhat better than is usually achieved in practice, although Wilkinson28cites some experience indicating that it may be attainable. Improvement by further lengthening T is not very effective, even if speed of response can be sacrificed, since grid resistor noise, independent of T , becomes important. For T not restricted, Elmore finds for the optimum case the most probable noise is
-
Q / e = 735[C,,t(R,/R,)11’2 where R, is the effective grid resistance (the grid resistor in parallel with the equivalent noise resistance of grid current). For a high gm tube such as the 6AK5, R, is limited by grid current, so one is limited to a threshold sensitivity which proves to be two or three times better than that of the short-pulse limit. The pulse duration and rise time, for a typical case, might be 50 Msec. The selection of amplifier rise time and clipping time depends not only, or even principally, on the noise problem, but on the particular application in hand-the speed of counting, necessity for accurate timing, shape of ionization chamber pulses, quantitative preservation of pulse height, etc. If accurate reproduction of pulse shape is not important, signal-to-noise and pulse-height reproduction can both be improved by using a rise time and clipping time which are equal, and somewhat longer than the rise time of the slowest chamber pulse. For a detailed discussion of several specific cases, see Wilkinson,’ Chapter 4. x8 D. H. Willcinson, “Ionization Chambers and Counters,” p. 142. Cambridge Univ. Press, London and New York, 1950.
1.2. IONIZATION
CHAMBERS
107
1.2.6. Some Types of Pulse ionization Chambers 1.2.6.1. Alpha-Particle Chambers. The typical energy release of a radioactive or induced alpha emission is several MeV, so it is clear from the foregoing that the ionization chamber is very well suited to the detection of these particles, or measurement of their energy. Typical ranges of these alpha particles in air at one atmosphere are a few centimeters, so that it is easy to contain the entire path of the particle in the chamber. Absolute counting of alpha particles is usually accomplished by placing a thin deposit containing the alpha-active material on the negative electrode of the chamber. Ideally this constitutes a ‘ I 27r” counter (assuming the electrode is plane), so that the fractionf of all disintegrations counted is +. However, the finite thickness t of the deposit will introduce a correction; the fraction which escapes can easily be shown to be $(l - t/2R), where R is the range of the particle in the material; since there will be which is the least energy an escaping alpha can have some energy Emin and still be counted, because a nonlinear discriminator of some sort must be set to reject the unwanted small pulses due to noise, etc., the range is the range of a particle of energy Emin, and the fraction reduced by R(Emin), becomes f = +{ 1 - t/2[R - R(EmiJ]}. A second correction is required to take into account the backscattering of alpha particles which start into the material in a direction away from the gas, but are deflected into the counting volume by multiple scattering. Rossi and S t a ~ give b ~ ~ numerical results of a calculation of this effect for various materials and energies. Typical values would be, for an alpha particle of 3.68 cm range, an increase in f of 8 % for gold or 2 % for aluminum. Measurement of alpha-particle energy by means of ionization chambers is considered in Section 2.2.1.2. 1.2.6.2. Proton Recoil Detectors. Neutrons can be studied by observing the ionization of recoil protons from n - p collisions in the counter gas, if it is hydrogenous, or in a hydrogenous foil or lining of the chamber. A proton recoil at an angle 0 with respect to the direction of a neutron of energy EOwill have an energy of EOcos2 e (nonrelativistic). I n the energy range from a few hundred kilovolts to a few Mev the recoils can be stopped in the gas (a 5-Mev proton has a range of 34 cm in air at 1 atmosphere) and the recoil chamber can be used as a measure of the energy and absolute flux of neutrons; this application is discussed in Section 2.2.2.1. As a method for counting neutrons on a relative basis the recoil ioniza29 B. B. Rossi and H. Staub, ‘‘Ionization Chambers and Counters,” p. 127 McGrawHill, New York, 1949.
108
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
tion chamber is usually less satisfactory than the proportional counter (Section 1.3.1) because the continuous energy distribution of the protons leads to many undetectable recoils. A large number of specific designs of proton recoil detectors are discussed in references 3 and 4. More recent work is discussed by Johnson and Trai130 and by Berenson and S h ~ r m a n . 3 ~ 1.2.6.3. Boron Trifluoride Chambers and Fission Chambers. Neutron: of all energies can be detected by the energy released in an ionization chamber by a nuclear disintegration; it is sometimes convenient to detect high-energy protons this way also. For neutrons the most widely used reaction is Bl0(n,a) Li7, which releases 2.34 Mev for thermal neutrons, and of course more for fast neutrons. The cross section for this reaction is very large, so that even though natural boron contains only 19% BO ' it leads to relatively high efficiency counters. Among the gaseous compounds of boron BFt is the most stable and satisfactory. It is reasonably free from electron attachment when pure, but the commercial gas often contains impurities which are difficult to remove and which lead to attachment. A method of preparing the pure gas is described by Graves and Froman. l3 Boron enriched in Bl0is available from suppliers of stable isotopes. BO ' has a cross section for slow neutrons which varies as l / v up to energies in the kilovolt range. Thus it lends itself to absolute measurements of neutron density n (rather than flux nv) in the low-energy range, since the disintegration rate is proportional to nvu, and therefore, to n, since u l/v. An ionization chamber filled with BF3provides a very stable method for a relative measurement of neutron flux, since it can be arranged so that the majority of the pulses are the same height (by using cylindrical geometry or a gridded chamber) and the pulse height is essentially independent of the applied voltage. However, the pulses are small and for most applications a proportional counter (Section 1.3.1) is more convenient. For measuring an integrated flux or time-average flux a current chamber (Section 1.2.7) filled with BF3 is very satisfactory. Another useful reaction for neutron measurement is the fission of heavy nuclei. Fission releases nearly 200 MeV; the fragments have a range of about 2 cm in air, and ionize most heavily at the start of their range. Very thin deposits of fissionable material are necessary to obtain the full energy of the fragment, but the energy release is so large that for counting this is not very critical. UZ3& has a large slow-neutron fission cross section, and competes in
-
30 31
C . H. Johnson and C. C. Trail, Rev. Sci. fnstr. 27, 468 (1956). R. E. Berenson and M. B. Shurman, Rev. Sci. Instr. 20, 1 (1958).
1.2.
IONIZATION CHAMBERS
109
efficiency with boron. U233and Pu239 are also slow-neutron fissionable, but have higher alpha activities. However, none of these substances is generally available. At higher neutron energies several heavy elements show convenient fission “thresholds”; some of these are listed in Table 111. Above bismuth TABLE 111. Approximate Thresholds of Various Heavy Substances for Fission by Neutronsn Nucleus
Threshold
NpZ3’
0.4Mev 0.5 Mev 1.1 Mev 1.3 Mev 60 Mev
Pa232 U238
Th234 Bi2o9
*From B. T. Feld, in. “Experimental Nuclear Physics” (E. SegrB, ed.), Vol. 2, p. 347. Wiley, New York, 1953.
all of these elements are alpha-active. Rapid electron collection and a short resolving time are necessary to prevent “pile up”-imitation of a large fission pulse by two or more alpha pulses.
1.2.7. Current Ionization Chambers and Integrating Chambers* Historically the earliest use of ionization chambers was not as singleparticle detectors but as meters for the average rate of ionization occurring in a gas, and such current-or charge-meters still have very wide utility; for example, in detecting and measuring radioactivity, in radiological health measurements, in cosmic-ray intensity studies, and in beammonitoring at particle accelerators. In general the problems of current chambers are quite different from those of pulse chambers and they will not be discussed here in The current t o be measured is usually very small and the use of good insulators is essential. Polystyrene, amber, quartz, and Teflon are satisfactory. Guard electrodes to prevent a direct leakage path between high-voltage electrode and collector (Section 1.2.3.) are essential in this application. Care should be taken th a t ionization cannot collect on an insulating surface. The second principal problem of current chambers is recombination. Since the recombination rate of ions is proportional to the square of the ionization density, recombination affects the linearity as well as the
* See also Vol. 4,A, Section 2.1.5. For more information on current chambers see D. H. Wilkinson, “Ionization Chambers and Counters,” Chapter 5. Cambridge Univ. Press, London and New York, 1950. 32
110
1.
PARTICLE DETECTION
absolute accuracy of ionization chambers. I n many applications reproducibility and accuracy are the essential qualities demanded of the current chamber. A pure, nonattaching gas is essential unless the E / p values are everywhere high. A small amount of attachment, which may be quite acceptable in a pulse chamber, will often lead to recombination and therefore to nonquantitative, nonlinear effects in a current chamber. Recombination is particularly serious in chambers used with pulsed accelerators, since the ion density is high during the pulse even though the average ion current may be low. A well-designed ionization chamber can have a time-constant of weeks, and its accuracy is usually limited by the precision of measurement of current or amount of charge. The transient response of a current chamber is of course quite different depending on whether or not attachment is taking place. I n a free-electron chamber the part of the current carried by electrons will have a response in the microsecond region. Rossi and S t a ~ describe b ~ ~ a chamber which was used to detect changes in gamma-ray flux occurring in less than 1 psec.
1.3. Gas-Filled Counters* 1.3.1. Gas Multiplication; Proportional Counterst
I n the discussion of the behavior of electrons in gases (Section 1.2.1) it has been assumed that the electrons released by the initial ionizing particles do not create further ionization after they have been slowed down to the mean agitation energy. They continually gain energy from the electric field, at, an average rate weE,where w is the drift velocity, but it has been assumed that they lost this energy in elastic collisions or excitation collisions with gas molecules. If the field strength is sufficiently great, however, some electrons will acquire an agitation energy greater than the ionization‘potential of the gas molecules, and new ionization will be formed. If-the average rate of ionizing collisions is a per centimeter, the average number of electrons after I centimeters, per original electron, would be n = eaz. This effect is called gas mu2tipZication.f By its use the total amount of ionization from a given initial act can be increased, thereby increasing the available signal. It is, of course, an undesirable 33 B. B. Rossi and H. Staub, “Ionization Chambers and Counters,” p. 106. McGrawHill, New York, 1949. t See also Vol. 4, A, Section 2.1.4. $ See also Vol. 2, Chapter 4.1.
* Chapter
1.3 is by Robert W. Williams.
1.3. GAS-FILLED
COUNTERS
111
effect in an ionization chamber, where its presence destroys the quantitative relationship between the energy lost in the chamber and the amount of ionization released. A counter which is designed to use gas multiplication as a n amplifying device is called a proportional counter. It will normally have a very smallradius positive electrode, so that the region of high field and therefore of gas multiplication will be confined to a small volume near the electrode. The most frequently used geometry is cylindrical, with concentric electrodes of radii a and b, and with a << b. We will discuss only this case; others which are found useful, such as a small loop of wire inside a sphere, or a grid of parallel wires inside a disk, are fairly obvious extensions. Since the region of multiplication is confined to a small volume near the central (positive) electrode, nearly all the electrons released by the particle to be detected will traverse the entire region of multiplication and therefore will have an average multiplication, which we designate by M , and which is independent of the part of the chamber in which the ionization was released. The signal will therefore be proportional to the initial ionization, provided that the space-charge near the wire remains small enough that the field distribution is substantially unaltered (otherwise the multiplication probability will be reduced). The space-charge limitation means that the largest usable M , in a given counter, will depend on the amount of ionization released by the particle traversing the counter, and will be larger for a small initial ionization. An actual calculation of gas multiplication is not very useful, since it depends on cross sections which are not well known, and may be impuritysensitive. The most practical scheme for designing counters is to extrapolate from empirical data with the help of scaling laws. Assuming th