Lecture Notes in Electrical Engineering Volume 83
Subhas Chandra Mukhopadhyay, Aimé Lay-Ekuakille, and Anton Fuchs (Eds.)
New Developments and Applications in Sensing Technology
ABC
Subhas Chandra Mukhopadhyay School of Engineering and Advanced Technology (SEAT) Massey University (Manawatu Campus) Palmerston North, New Zealand E-mail:
[email protected] Aime Lay-Ekuakille Dipartimento d’Ingegneria dell’innovazione University of Salento Lecce, Italy E-mail:
[email protected] Anton Fuchs Institute of Electrical Measurement and Measurement Signal Processing Graz University of Technology Graz, Austria E-mail:
[email protected]
ISBN 978-3-642-17942-6
e-ISBN 978-3-642-17943-3
DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-17943-3 c 2011 Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilm or in any other way, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9, 1965, in its current version, and permission for use must always be obtained from Springer. Violations are liable to prosecution under the German Copyright Law. The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Typeset & Cover Design: Scientific Publishing Services Pvt. Ltd., Chennai, India. Printed on acid-free paper 987654321 springer.com
Guest Editorial
This special issue titled “New Developments and Applications in Sensing Technology” in the book series of “Lecture Notes in Electrical Engineering” contains invited papers from renowned experts working in the field of sensing technology. A total of 17 chapters describe the advancement in the area of smart sensors and sensor networks design, measurement techniques, signal processing, and efficient algorithms in recent times. The 17 carefully selected chapters are extended versions of the conference papers presented at the 4th International Conference on Sensing Technology (ICST 2010), held at University of Salento, Leece, Italy from June 3 to 5, 2010. This special issue has focussed on different aspects of modern sensing technology, i.e. intelligent measurement, information processing, adaptability, recalibration, data fusion, validation, high reliability and integration of novel and high performance sensors. The aspects and methods are used for applications in material testing and analysis, communication, quality inspection, biomedical and environmental measurements. The selection of the chapters in this special issue reflects the range of requirements and suitable approaches for current challenges in sensing technology. While future interest in this field is ensured by the constant supply of emerging modalities, techniques, and engineering solutions, many of the basic concepts and strategies have already matured and now offer opportunities to build upon. We are very happy to be able to offer the readers of ”Lecture Notes in Electrical Engineering” such a diverse special issue both in terms of its topical coverage and geographic representation. We hope that the readers will find it interesting, thought provoking, and useful in their research and practical engineering work. We would like to extend our wholehearted thanks to all the authors who have contributed their work to this special issue. Subhas Chandra Mukhopadhyay, Guest Editor School of Engineering and Advanced Technology (SEAT), Massey University (Manawatu Campus) Palmerston North, New Zealand
[email protected] Aime Lay-Ekuakille, Guest Editor Dipartimento d’Ingegneria dell’innovazione University of Salento Lecce, Italy
[email protected] Anton Fuchs, Guest Editor Institute of Electrical Measurement and Measurement Signal Processing, Graz University of Technology Graz, Austria
[email protected]
VI
Guest Editorial
Dr. Subhas Chandra Mukhopadhyay graduated from the Department of Electrical Engineering, Jadavpur University, Calcutta, India in 1987 with a Gold medal and received the Master of Electrical Engineering degree from Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore, India in 1989. He obtained the PhD (Eng.) degree from Jadavpur University, India in 1994 and Doctor of Engineering degree from Kanazawa University, Japan in 2000. During 1989-90 he worked almost 2 years in the research and development department of Crompton Greaves Ltd., India. In 1990 he joined as a Lecturer in the Electrical Engineering department, Jadavpur University, India and was promoted to Senior Lecturer of the same department in 1995. Obtaining Monbusho fellowship he went to Japan in 1995. He worked with Kanazawa University, Japan as researcher and Assistant professor till September 2000. In September 2000 he joined as Senior Lecturer in the Institute of Information Sciences and Technology, Massey University, New Zealand. He is working currently as an Associate professor with the School of Engineering and Advanced Technology of Massey University, New Zealand. His fields of interest include Sensors and Sensing Technology, Electromagnetics, control, electrical machines and numerical field calculation etc. He has authored over 200 papers in different international journals and conferences, edited nine conference proceedings. He has also edited seven special issues of international journals as guest editor and seven books with Springer-Verlag. He is a Fellow of IET (UK), a senior member of IEEE (USA), an associate editor of IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurements. He is in the editorial board of e-Journal on Non-Destructive Testing, Sensors and Transducers, Transactions on Systems, Signals and Devices (TSSD), Journal on the Patents on Electrical Engineering, Journal of Sensors. He is in the technical programme committee of IEEE Sensors conference, IEEE IMTC conference and IEEE DELTA conference. He was the Technical Programme Chair of ICARA 2004, ICARA 2006 and ICARA 2009. He was the General chair and co-chair of ICST 2005, ICST 2007, ICST 2008, IEEE Sensors 2008, ICST 2010. He has organized the IEEE Sensors conference 2009 at Christchurch, New Zealand as General Chair. He is co-editor in chief of the International Journal on Smart Sensing and Intelligent Systems (www.s2is.org). Aimé Lay-Ekuakille has a Master Degree in Electronic Engineering, a Master Degree in Clinical Engineering, a Ph.D in Electronic Engineering from Polytechnic of Bari, Italy. He has been technical manager of different private companies in the field of: Industrial plants, Environment Measurements, Nuclear and Biomedical Measurements; he was director of a Health & Environment municipal Department. He has been a technical advisor of Italian government for high risk plants. From 1993 up to 2001, he was adjunct professor of Measurements and control systems in the University of Calabria, University of Basilicata and Polytechnic of Bari. He joined the Department of Innovation Engineering, University of
Guest Editorial
VII
Salento, in September 2000 in the Measurement & Instrumentation Group. Since 2003, he became the leader of the scientific group; hence, he is the co-ordinator of Measurement and Instrumentation Lab in Lecce. He has been appointed as UE Commission senior expert for FP-VI (2005-2010). He is still: chair of IEEE-sponsored SCI/SSD Conference, member of Transactions on SSD and Sensors & Transducers Journal editorial board. He is Associate Editor of the International Journal on Smart Sensing and Intelligent Systems. He is currently organizing the next ICST2010 in Lecce, Italy. He is a member of the following boards and TCs: Association of the Italian Group of Electrical and Electronic Measurements (GMEE), SPIE, IMEKO TC19 Environmental Measurements, IEEE, IEEE TC-25 Medical and Biological Measurements Subcommittee on Objective Blood Pressure Measurement, IEEE-EMBS TC on Wearable Biomedical Sensors & System and included in different IPCs of conferences. Aimé Lay-Ekuakille is a scientific co-ordinator of different international projects. He has authored and co-authored more than 95 papers published in international journals, books and conference proceedings. His main researches are on Environmental and Biomedical instrumentation & measurements and, measurements for renewable energy. Anton Fuchs was born in Graz, Austria, in 1977. He received the Dipl.Eng. degree in telematics from Graz University of Technology in 2001 and joint the Institute of Electrical Measurement and Measurement Signal Processing, Graz University of Technology in 2002. He worked as a researcher, project manager, and lecturer and received the Doctoral degree in technical science in 2006 from Graz University of Technology. He was Visiting Researcher and Research Fellow at the Centre for Bulk Solids and Particulate Technologies, University of Wollongong, Australia in 2004 and in 2007/2008 respectively. In 2009 he received the venia docendi for “Process Instrumentation and Sensor Technology” from Graz University of Technology and became Associate Professor. Anton Fuchs is now with the Virtual Vehicle Competence Center in Graz, Austria. He is still Associate Professor and Distinguished Lecturer at Graz University of Technology. His main research interests include capacitive sensors and the measurement of transported material in industrial conveying processes. Anton Fuchs is author and co-author of more than 90 scientific papers and patents.
Table of Contents
Detection of Micro-cracks on Metal Surfaces Using Near-Field Microwave Dual-Behaviour Resonators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Julien Kerouedan, Patrick Qu´eff´elec, Philippe Talbot, C´edric Quendo, Alain Le Brun Improving the Energy Efficiency of Wireless Sensors through Smart Antenna Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Mason, A. Shaw, A.I. Al-Shamma’a Planar Electromagnetic Sensor for the Detection of Nitrate and Contamination in Natural Water Sources Using Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy Approach . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . M.A. Md Yunus, S.C. Mukhopadhyay Current Reconstruction Algorithms in Electrical Capacitance Tomography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . M. Neumayer, H. Zangl, D. Watzenig, A. Fuchs Non-destructive Control of Metallic Plate with Magnetic Techniques . . . . L. Battaglini, P. Burrascano, A. Canova, F. Ficili, M. Ricci, D. Rossi, F. Sciacca Gas Sensing Characteristics of Pure and ZnO-Modified Fe2 O3 Thick Films . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . N.K. Pawar, D.D. Kajale, G.E. Patil, S.D. Shinde, V.B. Gaikwad, Gotan H. Jain Design and Construction of a Configurable Full-Field Range Imaging System for Mobile Robotic Applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D.A. Carnegie, J.R.K. McClymont, A.P.P. Jongenelen, B. Drayton, A.A. Dorrington, A.D. Payne Cr2 O3 -doped BaTiO3 as an Ammonia Gas Sensor . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Gotan H. Jain, S.B. Nahire, D.D. Kajale, G.E. Patil, S.D. Shinde, D.N. Chavan, V.B. Gaikwad
1
15
39
65 107
123
133
157
Physical and Electrical Modeling of Interdigitated Electrode Arrays for Bioimpedance Spectroscopy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . M. Ibrahim, J. Claudel, D. Kourtiche, B. Assouar, M. Nadi
169
Water Quality Assessment through Smart Sensing and Computational Intelligence . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . O. Postolache, P. Silva Gir˜ ao, J.M. Dias Pereira
191
X
Table of Contents
Multi-spectral Analytical Systems Using LIBS and LII Techniques . . . . . Satoshi Ikezawa, Muneaki Wakamatsu, Yury L’vovich Zimin, Joanna Pawlat, Toshitsugu Ueda
207
Electromechanical Sensors Based on Carbon Nanotube Networks and Their Polymer Composites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P. Slobodian, P. Riha, R. Olejnik
233
Novel Planar Interdigital Sensors for Detection of Domoic Acid in Seafood . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.R. Mohd Syaifudin, K.P. Jayasundera, S.C. Mukhopadhyay
253
Nano-Biosensor Development for Biomedical and Environmental Measurements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D.M.G. Preethichandra, E.M.I. Mala Ekanayake
279
Nondestructive Evaluations of Iron-Based Materials by Using AC and DC Electromagnetic Sensors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Koji Yamada, Jiaoliang Luo, Masato Enokizono
293
STACK: Sparse Timing of Algorithms Using Computational Knowledge . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Vasanth Iyer, S. Sitharama Iyengar, Garmiela Rama Murthy, Kannan Srinathan, Mandalika B. Srinivas, Regeti Govindarajulu A New Approach to Estimation of Protein Networks for Cell Cycle Based on Least-Squares Method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Takehito Azuma, Masachika Kurata, Noriko Takahashi, Shuichi Adachi Author Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
305
321
333
Detection of Micro-cracks on Metal Surfaces Using Near-Field Microwave Dual-Behaviour Resonators Julien Kerouedan1,2, Patrick Quéffélec1, Philippe Talbot1, Cédric Quendo1, and Alain Le Brun2 1
Lab-STICC (UMR 3192), Université de Bretagne Occidentale, CS 93836, 6 avenue Le Gorgeu, 29238 Brest Cedex 3, France 2 EDF R&D / STEP, 6 quai Watier, BP 49, 78401 Chatou Cedex, France
[email protected]
Abstract. The aim of this paper is to demonstrate that micro-cracks at the surface of metals can be detected and imaged by using near-field micro-wave resonators. It deals with two novel sensors: a first-order dual-behaviour resonator (DBR) filter and a first-order DBR filter with an open-ing in the ground plane. Measurements were mainly carried out on a stainless steel mock-up with several EDM (i.e. manufactured by Electron Discharge Machining) rectangular surface notches presenting widths between 0.1 and 0.3 mm and depths between 0.5 and 3 mm. The results presented here show the high sensitivity of the DBR probes and their ability to differentiate between notches of different depths and notches of different widths. Keywords: electromagnetic sensors, non-destructive testing (NDT), microwaves, near-field resonator.
1 Introduction The fatigue and ageing of metal materials under operation conditions are major concerns in energy production plants. An early and non-destructive diagnostic of surface defects would allow one to carry out relevant preven-tive maintenance operations avoiding unnecessary replacements or early repairing of healthy components. Today, most of the automated non-destructive testing (NDT) solutions available to detect the surface-breaking defects are based on ultrasonic [1] or Eddy current techniques [2]. Despite their high sensitivity and resolution, they are unable to meet all the requirements of every real situation. Eddy current testing sensitivity to different external parameters sometimes makes signal analysis difficult, and ultrasonic techniques are not always suitable for the detection of small depth defects located near the inspection surface. Consequently, it sounded us relevant to evaluate the potential of microwavebased techniques to detect the surface defects with a depth shallower than 3 mm. Over the last years, microwave far- and near-field approaches were investigated to detect surface defects. With a far-field characterization [3], the spatial resolution is of the order of a half wavelength (λ/2). So, to detect micro-cracks it is necessary to work at very high frequencies, which causes high measurement equipment costs. In addition, at very high fre-quencies, signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) issues can appear. As a result, because of their poor spatial resolution, the far-field methods are un-suitable for S.C. Mukhopadhyay et al. (Eds.): New Developments and Appl. in Sen. Tech., LNEE 83, pp. 1–13. springerlink.com © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011
2
J. Kerouedan et al.
detecting small depth defects. On the other hand, the use of near-field techniques permits to significantly improve the spatial resolution. Indeed, with a near-field characterization, the spatial resolution primarily depends on two parameters: the size of the probe end and the lift-off distance (the lift-off distance is the distance between the probe end and the sample under test). Consequently, many near-field NDT methods have been recently developed to detect surface and subsurface defects in various materials over a wide range of frequencies. Two main categories of near-field techniques are reported in the literature: the methods based on reflection coefficient measurements and the methods relying on the use of resonators. The first type of near-field techniques consists in measuring the reflec-tion coefficient at the end of either an open-ended rectangular waveguide [4-6] or an open-ended coaxial line [7, 8]. The presence of a crack near the aperture of these open-ended structures induces changes in the reflection coefficient’s magnitude and phase. Due to the use of wellknown open structures of propagation, these methods are easily implemented. However, the detection of a micro-crack requires the measurement of magnitude variations of about the hundredth of dB and of phase variations of a few degrees. Thus, the detection of a surface micro-crack with this first near-field technique is achievable but it requires high levels of accuracy and re-liability for the measurement equipment to detect the very small magnitude and phase variations caused by the micro-crack. The second type of near-field techniques relies on the use of resonators to measure the changes in the resonance frequency and quality factor induced by the interaction with the surface flaws. These variations can be detected using a network analyzer. The resonators presented in the literature are terminated with either a tip [9, 10] or an electric or magnetic dipole [11] in order to guide the radiation issued from the resonator toward the sample under characterization. Many studies have highlighted the link between the spatial resolution of near-field resonators, the size of the probe end and the lift-off distance, and have showed that methods of material characterization resting on the use of resonators make it possible to obtain a spatial resolution lower than the micron at microwave frequencies [9]. These resonant techniques have proven to successfully image defects and non-uniformities in various metals [9-11]. The two major advantages of using near-field resonators to detect surface defects are the dependence of the spatial resolution on the probe end size and the lift-off distance, and the direct detection of variations in the resonance frequency and quality factor by using a network analyzer. The aim of our study was the detection of several rectangular EDM (i.e. manufactured by Electron Discharge Machining) notches with widths between 0.1 and 0.3 mm and depths shallower than 3 mm on the surface of a 20 mm thick austenitic stainless steel plate. After the analysis of the existing microwave-based techniques, it appeared to be interesting to investigate how well a near-field resonant probe could detect the rectangular EDM notches. In order to minimize the costs of the probe fabrication and measurement equipment, we focused our research on the realization of microstrip sensors with resonance frequencies of about 10 GHz. In addition, for practical reasons, we imposed a lift-off distance greater than or equal to 50 μm. To detect and image the surface defects, we developed a novel detection technique using the reflection (S11) and transmission coefficients (S21) of a dual-behaviour resonator (DBR) band-pass filter [12-14]. The main feature of this device is the high selectivity of the DBR resonator, which permits an easy measurement of the frequency shift with a network analyzer. In addition, the high sensitivity of the DBR probe makes it possible to detect micro-cracks at operating frequencies near 10 GHz.
Detection of Micro-cracks on Metal Surfaces
3
This paper presents the design and the results obtained with two original near-field resonant probes based on dual-behaviour resonators with and without an opening in the ground plane. Measurements carried out on different notches (with widths between 0.1 and 0.3 mm and depths between 0.5 and 3 mm) are presented, showing the influence of the depth and width of the notch on the behaviour of the DBR sensors. The sensitivity of the two probes is discussed.
2 First-Order DBR Filter Probe 2.1 Description of the Probe A first-order DBR band-pass filter results from the association of two different parallel band-stop structures [12, 13]. Fig. 1 shows (a) the design and (b) the reflection (S11) and transmission parameters (S21) of this first-order DBR band-pass filter. The filter that we studied was realized on an alumina substrate. It included two openended stubs. The low-frequency stub (LF stub for low-frequency stub) of length, l1, and characteristic impedance, Zs1, brings a transmission zero in the lower attenuated band, whereas the high-frequency stub (HF stub for high-frequency stub), of length, l2, and characteristic impedance, Zs2, brings a transmission zero in the upper attenuated band. A band-pass response between the lower and upper rejected bands is created by constructive recombination (Fig. 1.b). (a)
Zs1, l1 Z0
Z0
Zs2, l2
S11 (dB) and S21 (dB)
(b)
0 -10 -20 -30 -40
S21
S11
-50 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
Frequency (GHz)
Fig. 1. First-order DBR band-pass filter: (a) design, (b) reflection (S11) and transmission (S21) parameters
4
J. Kerouedan et al.
The characterization of a metallic component is realized by moving the DBR filter probe at a constant lift-off distance d above the surface (the lift-off distance d is defined as the distance between the probe end and the surface). Fig. 2 shows (a) a schematic and (b) a photograph of the first-order DBR probe over a notch. (a) LF stub Metallic strip Port 1
Substrate Port 2 HF stub
Z WHF 0 Y
X
h W
d Notch Metal
(b)
Fig. 2. (a) Schematic and (b) photograph of the first-order DBR band-pass filter probe over a notch; W and h represent the width and depth of the notch, d is the lift-off distance, and the length L of the notch is in the y-direction
The principle of micro-crack detection consists in measuring the changes in the capacitive coupling created between the HF stub (of width WHF) and the metal sample under test. The probe-metal coupling can be described by a coupling capacitance [14, 15] that decreases when a defect is located below the HF stub of the DBR probe. This variation of capacitive coupling induces an increase in the frequency of the transmission zero associated with the high attenuated band, fHF, but also an increase in the central frequency, f0, i.e., the frequency associated with the minimum of the filter reflection parameter S11. On the other hand, the frequency of the transmission zero associated with the low attenuated band, fLF, remains unchanged due to a lack of LF stub-defect interaction. The influence of the probe-metal coupling on the behaviour of the first-order DBR filter sensor was studied in detail in [14]. This study highlighted that for a given coupling capacitance the shifts in fHF are more important than the shifts in f0. The frequency fHF obtained by measuring the transmission parameter S21 of the DBR filter is thus the best indicator of the changes in the probe-metal interaction.
Detection of Micro-cracks on Metal Surfaces
5
2.2 Experimental Results 2.2.1 Measurements Carried Out on a Stainless Steel Mock-Up Measurements were carried out on a 20 mm thick austenitic stainless steel plate (conductivity σ = 1.4 × 106 S.m-1) with several EDM rectangular notches. The experimental setup is shown in Fig. 3. It consists of an Agilent PNA E8364A (45 MHz – 50 GHz) network analyzer and a motorized three-axis displacement device holding the probe.
Computer
Network analyzer
Probe
3-axes displacement device Steel plate with EDM notches Fig. 3. Photograph of the experimental setup
0 Notch Faultless metal
S21 (dB)
-5 Stainless steel -10 -15
Notch
-20 -25
Faultless metal -30 12,5 12,6 12,7 12,8 12,9 13,0 13,1 13,2
Frequency (GHz) Fig. 4. Measured transmission parameter S21 of the 50 μm wide HF stub filter set at d = 50 μm over a faultless metal plate and over a 200 μm wide, 3 mm deep and 10 mm long notch
6
J. Kerouedan et al.
ΔfHF (MHz)
The first experiments were focused on the detection of a 200 μm wide, 3 mm deep and 10 mm long EDM notch. Fig. 4 shows the transmission parameter (S21) responses measured with a 50 μm wide HF stub filter, for a lift-off distance d = 50 μm, when the probe was set over a faultless metal plate and over the middle of the notch. The presence of the notch causes an increase in fHF (ΔfHF = 51 MHz) and f0 (Δf0 = 26 MHz) (data not shown). In order to image the notch, the variations of the HF stub frequency (ΔfHF) were measured during several 1D scans over the notch. Fig. 5 shows four 1D scans in the x-direction with a 10 μm incrementing step measured with the 50 μm wide HF stub DBR filter for four different values of d between 50 and 150 μm. This figure highlights that ΔfHF is the highest in the middle of the notch, and that the DBR filter sensitivity decreases when the distance d increases. Additional measurements were carried out over a 200 μm wide, 1 mm deep and 10 mm long notch and over a 200 μm wide, 0.5 mm deep and 10 mm long notch in order to examine the influence of the notch depth on the response of the first-order DBR probe. Fig. 6 shows the values of ΔfHF measured with the 50 μm wide HF stub filter when 1D scans are performed in the x-direction over the 0.5, 1 and 3 mm deep notches (probe incrementing step = 10 μm, and lift-off distance d = 50 μm). The three plots presented in Fig. 6 differ by their height i.e. by their maximum ΔfHF value. The maximum ΔfHF values associated with the 0.5, 1 and 3 mm deep notches are 42, 45, and 51 MHz, respectively. These experimental results highlight the influence of the notch depth on the ΔfHF variations and show that the first-order DBR probe enables us to differentiate between notches of different depths in the stainless steel mock-up. In order to examine the influence of the notch width on the response of the firstorder DBR probe, other experiments were performed over notches of 100 μm and 300 μm width while maintaining the other dimensions unchanged: 1 mm depth and 10 mm length. 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0
Stainless steel
-500 -400 -300 -200 -100 0
d = 50 μ m d = 75 μ m d = 100 μ m d = 150 μ m
100 200 300 400 500
x- position (μm)
Fig. 5. 1D scans (x-direction) over a stainless steel plate with a 200 μm wide, 3 mm deep and 10 mm long notch measured with the 50 μm wide HF stub DBR filter for four different lift-off distances d. Variations of the HF stub frequency (ΔfHF) as a function of the x-position; x = 0 corresponds to the middle of the notch in the stainless steel mock-up.
ΔfHF (MHz)
Detection of Micro-cracks on Metal Surfaces
60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0
Stainless steel
7
h = 3 mm h = 1 mm h = 0.5 mm
-500 -400 -300 -200 -100 0 100 200 300 400 500
x- position (μm)
Fig. 6. 1D scans (x-direction) over three 200 μm wide and 10 mm long notches differing by their depth h measured with the 50 μm wide HF stub DBR filter for a lift-off distance d = 50 μm. Variations of the HF stub frequency (ΔfHF) as a function of the x-position; x = 0 corresponds to the middle of the notches in the stainless steel mock-up.
ΔfHF (MHz)
The experimental results associated with these two notches were compared to those obtained during the characterization of the 200 μm wide, 1 mm deep and 10 mm long notch. Fig. 7 shows the values of ΔfHF measured with the 50 μm wide HF stub filter when 1D scans are performed in the x-direction over the 0.1, 0.2 and 0.3 mm wide notches (probe incrementing step = 10 μm, and lift-off distance d = 50 μm). 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0
Stainless steel
w = 0.3 mm w = 0.2 mm w = 0.1 mm
-500 -400 -300 -200 -100 0 100 200 300 400 500
x- position (μm)
Fig. 7. 1D scans (x-direction) over three 1 mm deep and 10 mm long notches differing by their width W measured with the 50 μm wide HF stub DBR filter for a lift-off distance d = 50 μm. Variations of the HF stub frequency (ΔfHF) as a function of the x-position; x = 0 corresponds to the middle of the notches in the stainless steel mock-up.
8
J. Kerouedan et al.
The three bell shape curves presented in Fig. 7 differ by their height and by their width. The maximum ΔfHF values associated with the 0.1, 0.2 and 0.3 mm wide notches are 22, 45, and 71 MHz, respectively, and the widths of the curves associated with the 0.1, 0.2 and 0.3 mm wide notches are about 330, 430 and 540 μm, respectively. These experimental results show the ability of the first-order DBR probe to differentiate between notches of different widths in the stainless steel mock-up. 2.2.2 Measurements Carried Out on an Aluminium Mock-Up Measurements were carried out on a 20 mm thick aluminium plate (conductivity σ = 37.5 × 106 S.m-1) with several EDM rectangular notches, using the same experimental setup as in the study with the stainless steel mock-up (§ 2.2.1, Fig. 3). Fig. 8 shows the values of ΔfHF measured with the 50 μm wide HF stub filter when 1D scans are performed in the x-direction over a 100 μm wide, 1 mm deep and 1 mm long notch and over a 100 μm wide, 0.5 mm deep and 1 mm long notch located on the aluminium mock-up (probe incre- menting step = 10 μm, and lift-off distance d = 50 μm). 30
Aluminium
ΔfHF (MHz)
25
h = 1 mm h = 0.5 mm
20 15 10 5 0 -500 -400 -300 -200 -100 0 100 200 300 400 500
x- position (μm)
Fig. 8. 1D scans (x-direction) over two 100 μm wide and 1 mm long notches differing by their depth h measured with the 50 μm wide HF stub DBR filter for a lift-off distance d = 50 μm. Variations of the HF stub frequency (ΔfHF) as a function of the x-position; x = 0 corresponds to the middle of the notches in the aluminium mock-up.
The two plots presented in Fig. 8 differ by their height i.e. by their maximum ΔfHF value. The maximum ΔfHF values associated with the 0.5 and 1 mm deep notches are 14 and 21 MHz, respectively. These experimental results and those obtained with the austenitic stainless steel mock-up (§ 2.2.1, Fig. 6) highlight the ability of the firstorder DBR probe to differentiate between notches of different depths. Fig. 9 shows the values of ΔfHF measured with the 50 μm wide HF stub filter when 1D scans are performed in the x-direction over a set of three notches of the same
Detection of Micro-cracks on Metal Surfaces
9
length and depth (1 mm), but of different widths (0.1, 0.2 and 0.5 mm). The lift-off distance between the probe and the surface of the aluminium mock-up is d = 50 µm (probe incrementing step = 10 μm). 160
ΔfHF (MHz)
140
Aluminium
120
w = 0.5 mm w = 0.2 mm w = 0.1 mm
100 80 60 40 20 0 -500 -400 -300 -200 -100 0 100 200 300 400 500
x- position (μm)
Fig. 9. 1D scans (x-direction) over three 1 mm deep and 1 mm long notches differing by their width W measured with the 50 μm wide HF stub DBR filter for a lift-off distance d = 50 μm. Variations of the HF stub frequency (ΔfHF) as a function of the x-position; x = 0 corresponds to the middle of the notches in the aluminium mock-up.
The three curves presented in Fig. 9 differ by their height and by their width. The maximum ΔfHF values associated with the 0.1, 0.2 and 0.5 mm wide notches are 21, 37, and 110 MHz, respectively, and the widths of the curves associated with the 0.1, 0.2 and 0.5 mm wide notches are about 370, 460 and 780 μm, respectively. These measurement results and those obtained with the stainless steel mock-up (§ 2.2.1, Fig. 7) highlight the ability of the first-order DBR probe to differentiate between notches of different widths.
3 First-Order DBR Filter Probe with Open Ground Plane 3.1 Description of the Probe This second probe was developed to increase the lift-off distance d. In a previous work [14], we have demonstrated the feasibility of increasing the lift-off distance by increasing the HF stub width of the DBR filter. For example, we have shown that a 100 μm wide HF stub first-order DBR filter allows one to detect a 200 μm wide, 3 mm deep and 10 mm long EDM notch on the surface of a stainless steel plate until d = 150 μm [14]. To allow the notch detection for d > 150 μm, our idea was to create an opening in the ground plane below the HF stub of the first-order DBR filter so as to increase the radiation of the sensor. Simulations were performed with the finite element (FEM)-based commercial software package HFSSTM in order to determine the optimal shape and size of this
10
J. Kerouedan et al.
opening. For a 100 μm wide HF stub filter, the best compromise between sensitivity and resolution was obtained for a rectangular opening with a width Wo = 1 mm. Figs. 10 and 11 show respectively a schematic and two photographs of the DBR probe with open ground plane.
Fig. 10. Schematic of the first-order DBR filter probe with open ground plane
(a) BF stub
HF stub (b) Ground plane
Opening below the HF stub
Fig. 11. (a) Top view photograph and (b) bottom view photograph of the first-order DBR filter probe with open ground plane
3.2 Experimental Results All the measurements were carried out with the same experimental setup (Fig. 3) and the same stainless steel mock-up as in the study with the first-order DBR filter probe. Fig. 12 shows the transmission parameter (S21) responses measured using a 100 μm wide HF stub filter with open ground plane, for a lift-off distance d = 300 μm, when the probe was set over a faultless metal plate and over the middle of a 200 μm wide, 3 mm deep and 10 mm long EDM notch. This figure highlights an increase in fHF (ΔfHF = 33 MHz) induced by the presence of the notch.
Detection of Micro-cracks on Metal Surfaces
11
Fig. 13 gives the variations ΔfHF measured using the 100 μm wide HF stub filter with open ground plane when 1D scans are performed in the x-direction over the 200 μm wide, 3 mm deep and 10 mm long notch with a 50 μm incrementing step and for six different values of d between 100 and 650 μm. This figure shows that the DBR probe with open ground plane can easily detect the notch until d = 400 μm while it is impossible with the classic DBR filter probe (§ 2.2.1, Fig. 5).
0 Stainless steel
Notch Faultless metal
S21 (dB)
-5 -10 -15
Notch
-20 -25 Faultless metal -30 13.6 13.7 13.8 13.9 14.0 14.1 14.2
Frequency (GHz) Fig. 12. Measured transmission parameter S21 of the 100 μm m wide HF stub filter with open ground plane set at d = 300 μm m over a faultless metal plate and over a 200 μm m wide, 3 mm deep and 10 mm long notch
120
d = 100 μm d = 180 μm d = 250 μm d = 300 μm d = 400 μm d = 650 μm
Stainless steel
ΔfHF (MHz)
100 80 60 40 20 0 -2000 -1500 -1000 -500
0
500 1000 1500 2000
x- position (μm)
Fig. 13. 1D scans (x-direction) over a stainless steel plate with a 200 μm wide, 3 mm deep and 10 mm long notch measured using the 100 μm wide HF stub DBR filter with open ground plane for six different lift-off distances d. Variations of the HF stub frequency (ΔfHF) as a function of the x-position; x = 0 corresponds to the middle of the notch in the stainless steel mock-up.
12
J. Kerouedan et al.
At last, Fig. 14 shows the values of ΔfHF measured using the 100 μm wide HF stub filter with open ground plane when 1D scans are performed in the x-direction over a 200 μm wide, 3 mm deep and 10 mm long notch and over a 200 μm wide, 1 mm deep and 10 mm long notch, with a 50 μm incrementing step and d = 300 μm. The difference between the maximum ΔfHF values associated with the 1 mm deep notch (ΔfHF = 22 MHz) and the 3 mm deep notch (ΔfHF = 33 MHz) illustrates the influence of the notch depth on the ΔfHF variations. 40
ΔfHF (MHz)
35
Stainless steel
h = 3 mm h = 1 mm
30 25 20 15 10 5 0 -2000 -1500 -1000 -500
0
500 1000 1500 2000
x- position (μm)
Fig. 14. 1D scans (x-direction) over two 200 μm wide and 10 mm long notches differing by their depth h measured using the 100 μm wide HF stub DBR filter with open ground plane, for a lift-off distance d = 300 μm. Variations of the HF stub frequency (ΔfHF) as a function of the xposition; x = 0 corresponds to the middle of the notches in the stainless steel mock-up.
4 Conclusion A near-field microwave NDT method using dual-behaviour resonator filters was investigated in order to detect surface defects in metals. The detection principle was validated theoretically and experimentally. The experimental results obtained with the stainless steel mock-up and the aluminium mock-up showed the good spatial resolution and the high sensitivity of the DBR filter probes. In addition, the measurements carried out on EDM notches highlighted: 1) the influence of the width and depth of the notch on the HF stub frequency variations (ΔfHF) and 2) the enhancement of the detection sensitivity by using a first-order DBR filter with open ground plane. Further investigations will be aimed at studying the dependence of the ΔfHF variations on the dimensions (depth, width and length) of the notch. We also plan to evaluate the potential of the DBR probes to detect fatigue cracks and stress corrosion flaws.
Detection of Micro-cracks on Metal Surfaces
13
References 1. Krautkrämer, J., Krautkrämer, H.: Ultrasonic Testing of Materials, 4th edn. Springer, Berlin (1990) 2. Moore, P.O.: Nondestructive Testing Handbook (Electromagnetic Testing), 3rd edn., vol. 5. American Society for Nondestructive Testing (ASNT), Colombus (2004); Udpa, S.S. (technical ed.) 3. Shirai, H., Sehiguchi, H.: A simple crack depth estimation method from backscattering response. IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement 53, 1249–1253 (2004) 4. Yeh, C.-Y., Zoughi, R.: A novel microwave method for detection of long surface cracks in metals. IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement 43, 719–725 (1994) 5. Ghasr, M.T., Carroll, B., Kharkovsky, S., Austin, R., Zoughi, R.: Millimeter-wave differential probe for nondestructive detection of corrosion precursor pitting. IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement 55, 1620–1627 (2006) 6. McClanahan, A., Kharkovshy, S., Maxon, A.R., Zoughi, R., Palmer, D.D.: Depth evaluation of shallow surface cracks in metals using rectangular waveguides at millimeter-wave frequencies. IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement 59, 1693–1704 (2010) 7. Wang, Y., Zoughi, R.: Interaction of surface cracks in metals with open-ended coaxial probes at microwave frequencies. Materials Evaluation 58, 1228–1234 (2000) 8. Ju, Y., Saka, M., Uchimura, Y.: Evaluation of the shape and size of 3D cracks using microwaves. NDT&E International 38, 726–731 (2005) 9. Tabib-Azar, M., Su, D.-P., Pohar, A., Leclair, S.R., Ponchak, G.: 0.4 μm spatial resolution with 1 GHz (λ = 30 cm) evanescent microwave probe. Review of Scientific Instruments 70, 1725–1729 (1999) 10. Wei, T., Xiang, X.-D., Wallace-Freedman, W.G., Schultz, P.G.: Scanning tip microwave near-field microscope. Applied Physics Letters 68, 3506–3508 (1996) 11. Wang, R., Li, F., Tabib-Azar, M.: Calibration methods of a 2 GHz evanescent microwave magnetic probe for noncontact and nondestructive metal characterization for corrosion, defects, conductivity and thickness nonuniformities. Review of Scientific Instruments 76, 54701 (2005) 12. Quendo, C., Rius, E., Person, C.: Narrow bandpass filters using dual-behavior resonators. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques 51, 734–743 (2003) 13. Quendo, C., Rius, E., Person, C.: Narrow bandpass filters using dual-behavior resonators based on stepped-impedance stubs and different-length stubs. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques 52, 1034–1044 (2004) 14. Kerouedan, J., Quéffélec, P., Talbot, P., Quendo, C., De Blasi, S., Le Brun, A.: Detection of micro-cracks on metal surfaces using near-field microwave dual-behavior resonator filters. Measurement Science and Technology 19, 105701 (2008) 15. Kleismit, R.A., Kazimierczuk, M.K., Kozlowski, G.: Sensitivity and resolution of evanescent microwave microscope. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques 54, 639–647 (2006)
Improving the Energy Efficiency of Wireless Sensors through Smart Antenna Design A. Mason, A. Shaw, and A.I. Al-Shamma’a Liverpool John Moores University, Liverpool, United Kingdom
Abstract. There is a growing trend in the use of intelligent Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs) for a wide range of applications. In the early part of the decade the underlying hardware was largely in prototype form and used for small scale demonstration systems, but there is now growing interest in applications which are commercially viable. This work began on the premise that the sensor hardware has gradually become smaller, yet there are still a few peripheral components which are lagging behind; namely the battery and antenna. Here, a novel antenna design is presented; this antenna is of a practical size for use in WSNs, whilst also offering improved energy consumption over commonly used monopole antennas.
1 Introduction Antennas are critical to the operation of wireless communication systems such as those used for radio, television, and mobile phones. They are often taken for granted by an end user of such a product – many consumers are blissfully unaware of how much antenna design can impact on device performance, size and energy consumption. Antenna design is often forgotten in WSNs since the devices are deployed in close proximity to one another (i.e. with a separation of 10m or less). As a result, device communication with simple wire antennas is a simple and affordable solution, but is not necessarily efficient. This leads to data corruption during wireless transmission which can result in three possible scenarios: • Loss; the data is irreparable and is lost forever – in this case the energy put into capturing, processing and transmitting the data is wasted. • Recovery; some protocols may allow data recovery, implying that there is a permanent data overhead which incurs additional energy consumption. • Retransmission; important data may be repeatedly transmitted until the intended message is correctly received – this ensures reliability, but leads to wasted energy. Therefore, it is desirable to have a system which minimises data corruption in order to improve efficiency, particularly when one takes into account the fact that data transmission from a typical sensor node consumes three times more energy than data processing alone [1]. In addition to the energy problem, the physical form of the standard monopole antenna is considered to be unsuitable for many applications. In particular the authors S.C. Mukhopadhyay et al. (Eds.): New Developments and Appl. in Sen. Tech., LNEE 83, pp. 15–37. springerlink.com © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011
16
A. Mason, A. Shaw, and A.I. Al-Shamma’a
have been involved in the use of WSNs for inventory management [2, 3] and spot weld monitoring [4]. In these situations it is undesirable for the sensor node, or mote, antenna to protrude from the object to which it is attached, since both applications involve high speed movement which could damage or destroy the antenna should it be snagged. The devices used as part of the authors work are the commonly known MicaZ motes [1], one of which is shown in Figure 1. One can clearly see here that the monopole antenna protrudes some way from the mote; the length of the protrusion is linked to the operating frequency of the mote, and therefore its wavelength (λ) [5]. In this case the operating frequency is 2.45GHz, and λ = 122mm. Monopole antennas are typically λ/4 in length [6] and there is no exception here as the MicaZ antenna measures approximately 40mm1. The initial thought in this situation was to simply flatten the antenna and effectively shield it from damage. This scenario is shown clearly in Figure 2.
Fig. 1. Berkeley MicaZ mote with monopole antenna attached
Fig. 2. Mote antenna held in place with a nylon cable tie to prevent snagging 1
Note that λ/4 = 31mm at 2.45GHz, but the MicaZ antenna includes a sheath which is slightly longer than the antenna so as to offer limited protection.
Improving the Energy Efficiency of Wireless Sensors through Smart Antenna Design
17
A simple experiment, using one mote as a transmitter and another as a receiver, demonstrated that flattening the antenna caused significant signal strength degradation. When the transmitter and receiver are separated by 1m of air, the signal strength was found to be 10dBm less if the antenna was flattened, compared to if the antenna was in its normal position (see Figure 1). As a result of these findings it was thought that designing a new antenna for the motes might be a more effective solution, since significant losses in signal strength ultimately lead to data loss.
2 Designing a New Antenna 2.1 Antenna Requirements Since industry disliked the idea of the existing MicaZ monopole antenna alternative types were considered. Wire antennas such as dipoles are typically in the order of λ/2 in length, and loop antennas often have a circumference equal to λ. We can see that dipole and loop antennas would be larger than the standard monopole antenna supplied with the MicaZ and therefore likely to be an even greater concern for industrial use. Smaller sizes are possible for loops and dipoles, but they do not make effective radiators [7, 8]. The best remaining option was a PCB antenna. With size and practicality being major concerns of industry it seemed that a low profile PCB antenna would be ideal. It was thought that such an antenna would be suitable for retrofitting to the current MicaZ motes, and in the future could possibly be integrated with the mote circuitry in a combined PCB design. In order to facilitate this, an aim was set of creating an antenna no greater than the size of MicaZ PCB (i.e. - 57mm × 32mm). Although PCB antennas do have their advantages, it is noted in literature that they tend to suffer from a narrow impedance bandwidth, quite often in the order of just a few percent [5]. The impedance bandwidth [9] refers to the ability of an object to absorb or transmit energy into its surroundings; in the case of antennas, the later is desirable. Impedance bandwidth can be calculated using Equation 1, where fu is the upper operating frequency, fl is the lower operating frequency and f0 is the centre frequency. fu and fl refer to the points where the energy transmitted by an antenna is ≥ 88.9%. In some texts this is also referred to as the point where the voltage standing wave ratio (VSWR) is ≤ 2 [10], and describes the range over which antennas are effective radiators.
⎛ f − fl ⎞ ⎟⎟ × 100 Bandwidth (%) = ⎜⎜ u ⎝ f0 ⎠
(Equation 1)
For the MicaZ mote, fl = 2.485GHz, fu = 2.400GHz and f0 = 2.443GHz [1], since the devices support multiple frequency channels for reduced interference. These figures lead to a minimum impedance bandwidth requirement of 3.48%. In addition to these requirements it was also thought that the antenna should have good directional properties (i.e. seek to radiate equally well in all directions). In literature this is often better defined as directivity, but this parameter is often difficult to quantify accurately, therefore this work takes a qualitative approach. Low directivity is critical for WSNs since it is often impossible to control the orientation of nodes during
18
A. Mason, A. Shaw, and A.I. Al-Shamma’a
deployment – in mobile applications (e.g. inventory management) orientation may also vary significantly with time. Antennas with only a single plane of polarisation cannot communicate well (if at all) with those orientated perpendicular to themselves [11]; monopole and dipole antennas suffer noticeably from this issue. To summarise before continuing, the new antenna was required to: • • • •
operate at the centre frequency (f0) 2.443GHz. have an impedance bandwidth greater than 3.48%. be no larger than 57mm×32mm×1.6mm. have a low directivity.
2.2 Coplanar Waveguide (CPW) Antenna During a review of literature relating to antenna design, it was discovered that Nithisopa et al [12] had designed a broadband co-planar waveguide (CPW) fed slot antenna which, in simulations, had proven suitable for use over the range of approximately 2.35-2.70GHz, resulting in an impedance bandwidth of 14%. The term CPW refers to the way in which the antenna is fed; two parallel slots are cut into a copper surface to act as a transmission line feed to the radiating elements of the antenna itself – this is illustrated in Figure 3. The radiating elements come in many different forms, although it appears that the slot type is popular. The copper surrounding the feed slots acts as a ground plane which promotes more uniform radiation than one would experience with similar structures such as patch antennas [5, 13, 14]. Based upon the work conducted by Nithisopa, an Ansoft HFSS [15] model was created as shown in Figure 3. The model was set up by following strict guidelines [16] provided by the developer of HFSS for the creation of CPW models. Table 1 gives information relating to the dimensions illustrated in Figure 3. Dimensions W1 and W2 are of particular importance in impedance matching the antenna to a typical 50Ω transmission line. Impedance matching is vital in antenna design in order to ensure that as much power as possible from the radio transceiver is transferred to the propagation medium via the antenna [17]. Poor matching leads to power being reflected by the antenna back toward the transceiver, resulting in reduced transmission range, wasted energy and potential damage to the transceiver itself. Figure 4 shows the difference in simulated performance as a result of using FR4 instead of Duroid substrate, as in Nithisopa’s work. The reason for changing substrate was simply a case of using materials to hand at the time for prototype manufacture, but one can see that the increase in dielectric constant (εr) reduces the impedance bandwidth. For Duroid εr ≈ 2, but for FR4 εr ≈ 4. Despite the decrease in impedance bandwidth FR4 still resulted in an impedance bandwidth – calculated to be 10% – far exceeding the requirements for this application. Table 1. CPW dimensions (mm) h
pcbX
pcbY
W1
W2
H1
H2
L1
1.6
90.0
45.0
0.5
2.4
23.0
10.5
39.0
Improving the Energy Efficiency of Wireless Sensors through Smart Antenna Design
19
Fig. 3. CPW antenna structure and dimensions
Fig. 4. Simulated reflected power for FR4 and Duriod substrates
Another interesting property of Nithisopa’s CPW antenna was its low directivity which is a significant advantage of CPW design when one considers other types of PCB antenna. Balanis [18] gives a guide to constructing a simple patch antenna, a structure mentioned in passing earlier. This structure consists of a rectangular conductive patch above a larger conductive ground plane. The two conductive layers are separated by a dielectric substrate, as shown in Figure 5. A comparison of the CPW antenna and a patch antenna created using the Balanis guide shows that the CPW antenna has a favourable radiation pattern for applications requiring low directivity; this is evidenced in Figure 6. The xz and yz planes are of particular interest at the 180° position where the patch antenna experiences attenuation in the order of 20dB – this is a direct result of the ground plane preventing transmission in this direction. The downside for the CPW antenna is increased attenuation in the plane of the PCB when compared with the patch antenna. However this is a reasonable compromise as the loss is much smaller than that caused by the patch antenna ground plane.
20
A. Mason, A. Shaw, and A.I. Al-Shamma’a
Fig. 5. A simulated patch antenna, constructed using a guide by Balanis [18]. Note that the model is transparent so that the electric vector field is visible across the entire structure.
Fig. 6. Simulated radiation patterns of the (a) patch and (b) CPW antennas
Improving the Energy Efficiency of Wireless Sensors through Smart Antenna Design
21
Despite the CPW antenna providing a bandwidth much greater than that required and having low directivity, it was still too large. Therefore further investigation ensued with CPW antennas remaining the focus of attention. 2.3 Folded Coplanar Waveguide (FCPW) Antenna In order to solve the issue of size with the CPW antenna, the largest dimension (pcbX) was considered. This dimension had to accommodate the radiating slots of length L1, which were ultimately responsible for radiating power into the transmission medium (i.e. the surrounding air). Thinking of the slots as being analogous to the two arms of a standard wire dipole antenna, some thought was given to what might happen if the slots were folded, therefore allowing them to be accommodated by a shorter pcbX dimension. Folded wire dipole [19] antennas are created by taking the two radiating elements of a standard λ/2 dipole and folding them to form a closed loop; this transition is shown in Figure 7. By applying a similar train of thought to the CPW antenna a new folded co-planar waveguide (FCPW) antenna was created. The simulation model for this antenna is shown in Figure 8, and Table 2 shows the dimensions used for this structure after applying parametric analysis to the model in order to optimise its radiation characteristics. The simulated radiation pattern is shown in Figure 9, and is not too far removed from that of Nithisopa’s CPW antenna. The simulated impedance bandwidth was calculated to be 61% - this is discussed further later.
Fig. 7. Converting the CPW antenna to a folded CPW antenna, with new dimensions also labelled Table 2. FCPW dimensions (mm) h
pcbX
pcbY
W1
W2
W3
H1
H2
H3
H4
L1
1.6
40.0
27.5
0.5
4.0
1.5
2.0
4.0
0.5
8.5
39.0
22
A. Mason, A. Shaw, and A.I. Al-Shamma’a
Fig. 8. FCPW antenna simulation model, showing the electric vector field surrounding the antenna
Fig. 9. FCPW antenna simulated radiation pattern
Improving the Energy Efficiency of Wireless Sensors through Smart Antenna Design
23
Given the promising impedance bandwidth and directivity results, the largest improvement with the FCPW antenna, in terms of achieving the initial goals, was size reduction. The initial requirements, stated in Section 2.1, were 57mm×32mm×1.6mm. The FCPW antenna is 40mm×27.5mm×1.6mm. This gives a total surface area saving of 39.7%, indicating that the antenna could be suitable for WSN nodes smaller than the Berkeley MicaZ. 2.4 Validating the Design The prototype FCPW antenna is shown in Figure 10. It has a bulkhead type SMA connector attached so as to allow connection to various devices (including the Berkeley MicaZ via an inter-series MMCX to SMA adaptor). Use of an SMA connector was convenient for experimentation purposes, the results of which are presented in the next section. It is imagined that this connector would not be necessary if the antenna were used in practise – instead the antenna could be connected directly to the radio transceiver of a wireless sensor node. The centre conductor of the SMA connector is soldered to the centre copper strip, whilst the outer conductor is connected to the antenna ground plane on either side of the centre strip. The simulated results for reflected power and those measured using the Anritsu VNA show a reasonable agreement (see Figure 11). At 2.45GHz the reflected power is just 2.6% - this means that 97.4% of the power incident to the antenna should be radiated. The impedance bandwidth during simulation was found to be 61%, whilst the measured bandwidth is 53%. This is more than adequate for the successful operation of the MicaZ mote over all of its selectable frequencies.
Fig. 10. Prototype FCPW antenna post construction
24
A. Mason, A. Shaw, and A.I. Al-Shamma’a
Fig. 11. Simulated vs. measured reflected power for the FCPW antenna
3 Radiation Pattern Measurement 3.1 Methodology Simulations gave an indication of the FCPW antenna radiation pattern, however physical confirmation of this was required in order to validate the design. Testing antennas is not a trivial task as one must take a number of steps to ensure that measurements are not subject to interference from surrounding sources; this is particularly relevant here due to the wide range of uses for the ISM 2.4GHz frequency band (e.g. WLAN infrastructure).
Fig. 12. Inside a typical anechoic chamber
Improving the Energy Efficiency of Wireless Sensors through Smart Antenna Design
25
Small antennas are typically tested in almost ideal conditions inside a structure known as an anechoic chamber [20]. Such chambers are usually shielded with a thick conducting metal, thus utilising the skin effect [21] to prevent signals from the outside world entering the chamber. An example of such a chamber is shown in Figure 12. Unfortunately, an anechoic chamber was not available for this work since they are costly to rent, and even more costly to build. Therefore an alternative method for testing was put into operation. It was thought that since WLAN infrastructure is typically localised to urban areas in the UK, tests could be carried out in a rural scenario where interference would be reduced. In addition, it was thought that a rural location, such as a large open field, would allow transmitted signals to simply travel away from the antenna and into space. This avoids issues with electromagnetic phenomena such as multipath fading [22-24].
Fig. 13. Antennas used for experimentation, including orientation indicators; (a) monopole (b) FCPW and (c) horn
26
A. Mason, A. Shaw, and A.I. Al-Shamma’a
In addition to the FCPW antenna two further antennas were required; a reference (for comparison purposes), and a receiver. The reference antenna constructed was a λ/4 monopole with a ground plane, designed to approximate the performance of the default MicaZ monopole antenna. A horn antenna was chosen as the receiver since they are well known to have a high directivity [25] and are therefore unlikely to be affected by signals which originate from anywhere but directly in front of the horn aperture. In addition, horn antennas are highly orientation sensitive and only accept radiation in a single plane when they are used at their fundamental operating frequency. The chosen horn had dimensions appropriate for use at 2.4GHz. All three antennas are shown in Figure 13. Both the receiver (horn) and transmitter (monopole or FCPW) needed to be suspended 1.5m above ground level in order to prevent reflections from the floor causing multipath interference. In order to do this, tripods were employed, as shown in Figure 14. The receiving horn antenna was bolted to the top of a large surveyor’s tripod. Since it was assumed that the ground in a rural setting would not be particularly level, a base was made for this tripod with a large bolt at each corner allowing the base to be levelled – a plumb line hanging from the centre of the tripod was used for levelling. A standard camera tripod with full height adjustment was used to mount the transmitter. Much of the tripod was made out of plastic rather than metal which was considered to be useful in terms of reducing its impact on the experimental results (e.g. due to coupling). The mounting here was moveable through 360°, allowing rotation of the transmitting antenna in order to obtain radiation pattern measurements.
Fig. 14. Experimental setup in an open field
Improving the Energy Efficiency of Wireless Sensors through Smart Antenna Design
27
The two antennas were placed 1.5m apart to ensure that the measurements were in the antenna far field (as opposed to the near field). The far field of the monopole antenna is 0.276m, but Balanis [26] notes that this is not a fixed rule and so it seemed appropriate to allow additional range. An Anritsu MS2024A vector network analyser (VNA) was used – the horn antenna was connected to its input port, and the transmitter to its output. The VNA was then used to measure the return loss2, in dB, at 2.45GHz. All measurements were repeated three times, and the averages used in the following sections; further repetitions were not practical because of changeable weather conditions and life time of the Anritsu VNA’s battery. 3.2 Measured Radiation Patterns The results of these experiments represent the measured return loss arbitrarily normalised to -50dB. The measurements shown are relative to the antenna orientations indicated in Figure 13. For the monopole antenna the electric field is polarised in the z direction, whilst for the FCPW it is taken to be in the y direction. With the pyramidal horn being a flared waveguide, it is possible to assume [27] that the electric field is parallel to the z axis of the waveguide (see Figure 13). This means that turning the horn antenna through 90° allows one to consider how the antennas perform when there is a polarisation mismatch. The measurements shown in Figures 15 and 16 include the situation where the antennas polarisations are matched and mismatched respectively. This is important for this work since we cannot often guarantee the relative orientation of the antennas of sensor nodes in a WSN.
Fig. 15. Monopole antenna radiation patterns with (a) matched and (b) mismatched polarisation
2
The ratio of received power (input) to transmitted power (output).
28
A. Mason, A. Shaw, and A.I. Al-Shamma’a
Fig. 16. FCPW antenna radiation patterns with (a) matched and (b) mismatched polarisation
3.3 Discussion Looking first at the results of the monopole antenna (Figure 15), we see good correlation of the measured radiation patterns with those from known and respected literature [28, 29]. This is an excellent indication of the validity of the measurement method used in this work. When polarisation between the monopole and horn antennas is matched, as in Figure 15(a), we see in the xy plane that the monopole antenna acts isotropically; this is indicated by the reasonably uniform distribution of measured radiated power. However, in the xz and yz planes significant attenuation occurs in the z axis. Unlike infinite ground planes, their finite counterparts do not completely block transmission [13] but there is definite attenuation (in the order of 5-10dB) due to the presence of the monopole ground plane between 90° and 270° (not inclusive). The maximum measured power occurs in the yz plane at 310°, and is 8.07dB. The patterns are also generally quite symmetrical in the z axis, again as one would expect, so a similar peak can be found at 50°. A wire antenna is said to have a polarisation which is parallel to the wire [11]. Therefore it is not surprising that, as shown in Figure 15(b), there is a significant loss experienced with the monopole antenna when polarisation is mismatched. This is particularly evident in the xy plane, where the radiated power reaches -40dB. There is some improvement in the xz and yz planes, although it is suspected that this is a result of reflections incident to the ground plane. It is possible that the ground plane is acting as a poor parabolic dish antenna in these cases. Let us now consider the case of the FCPW antenna beginning with the radiation pattern results when polarisation is matched, as shown in Figure 16(a). Radiation is weakest in the plane of the PCB since electric field lines formed as a result of opposing charges on the FCPW ground plane converge at the PCB edges but cannot join. This is further highlighted in Figure 17. A drop in the radiated power of approximately 10dB is also present at the 90° and 270° degree positions due to the lack radiating elements covering these positions. Whilst a 10dB loss is significant, it is not nearly as significant as the loss that HFSS reported (shown as a 35dB loss in Figure 9). Another noteworthy feature is that the FCPW antenna, whilst not
Improving the Energy Efficiency of Wireless Sensors through Smart Antenna Design
29
outputting peak power near that of the monopole antenna, does not drop much below 10dB, whilst the monopole antenna drops to almost -20dB along the z axis. Looking finally at the most exciting results from the FCPW antenna, shown in Figure 16(b), this antenna is much more tolerant of polarisation mismatch than the monopole antenna. In the xy plane there is typically a 2-3dB loss when compared with the monopole measurements shown in Figure 15(b); the same reductions in radiated power are present at the 90° and 270° positions. These reductions apply to the yz plane also. The most notable feature, however, is the xz plane which displays peaks of up to 4.05dB which is more than experienced by the antenna in the Figure 16(a). So, the question is, why does the FCPW antenna exhibit such results? Looking at Figure 18 one can see that the vector fields radiate perpendicular to the PCB in most cases. A result of this is the drop in radiated power shown in Figure 16(b) in the xz plane at 0°, because directly above the antenna there is a polarisation mismatch, whilst there is an increase shown nearer the edges of the board. At the edges of the PCB the electric field appears to change direction so that it is nearly orthogonal to the field in the centre. This indicates that the polarisation of the electric field is not strictly linear, as is the case with the monopole antenna. Figure 19 serves to reinforce this argument. Here the electric field is shown to be parallel to the PCB; in the centre of the antenna the field is parallel to the y axis, but near the edges this changes and the field becomes almost parallel to the x axis. The reason for this occurring is most likely due to the fold introduced to the antenna. Normally the electric field would form across the narrowest dimension of the radiating slots, but at the fold the electric field can form between the centre strip and the ground plane, opposing the direction of the central electric field. Since the results in Figure 16(a) and 16(b) are not identical (i.e. the two radiation patterns are not of the same magnitude) this indicates that the antenna has an elliptical rather than circular polarisation. This means that the antenna is not truly omni-directional, but does exhibit properties which are far more favourable than a simple monopole antenna. The next section of this chapter looks at the practical implications of these properties.
Fig. 17. FCPW antenna simulated electric field vector plot showing the formation of fields at the edges of the PCB
30
A. Mason, A. Shaw, and A.I. Al-Shamma’a
Fig. 18. HFSS simulated vector field pattern for the FCPW antenna showing the formation of multiple polarisations (side view, xz plane)
Fig. 19. HFSS simulated vector field pattern for the FCPW antenna showing the formation of multiple polarisations (top view, xy plane)
4 Energy Efficiency Measurements 4.1 Experimental Setup Whilst a measurement of the antenna’s radiation patterns was useful to understand how power was distributed around the FCPW antenna, it is important to highlight the
Improving the Energy Efficiency of Wireless Sensors through Smart Antenna Design
31
real world implications of these measurements. Since the objective is to replace the MicaZ antenna, it was thought that this could involve a direct comparison of the existing monopole antenna and the FCPW antenna. Therefore experimental results were obtained which compared the two antennas in operation when attached to a MicaZ mote. A PC application was written which utilised the Received Signal Strength Indicator (RSSI) feature of the motes to calculate a ten second average for signal strength, along with the number of data packets received (out of a maximum of 1000). It was decided to record both of these items of data to ensure not only a good signal strength, but also that data transmission was taking place. Figure 20 shows a screenshot of this application.
Fig. 20. Bespoke application for recording mote RSSI and packet loss information
Tests were conducted outdoors, and the setup as shown in Figure 21. The base station and a moveable MicaZ node were placed 1.5m above ground level, and the distance between the two was then increased in 1m increments, starting at 0.1m and ending at 25m3. The transmission power level of both the base station and the moveable node were set to 0dBm (i.e. 1mW). Various orientations of both the standard monopole and FCPW antenna were investigated, including what happened when a polarisation mismatch occurred.
3
The first interval was 0.9m in order to accommodate the 0.1m initial spacing.
32
A. Mason, A. Shaw, and A.I. Al-Shamma’a
Fig. 21. RSSI and packet loss measurement setup
4.2 Measured Results The results obtained for the standard MicaZ monopole antenna are shown in Figures 22 and 23, whilst those for the FCPW antenna are shown in Figures 24 and 25. Each figure includes six sets of results. The associated orientation of each set of results is given in terms of the plane which is parallel to the base station monopole antenna.
Improving the Energy Efficiency of Wireless Sensors through Smart Antenna Design
33
The orientations are relative to those shown in Figures 13. For a polarisation mismatch the base station antenna was moved from being vertical to being horizontal with respect to the Earth.
Fig. 22. MicaZ monopole antenna RSSI as a function of distance
Fig. 23. MicaZ monopole antenna packet loss as a function of distance
34
A. Mason, A. Shaw, and A.I. Al-Shamma’a
Fig. 24. MicaZ FCPW antenna RSSI as a function of distance
Fig. 25. MicaZ FCPW antenna packet loss as a function of distance
4.3 Discussion Comparing the RSSI results (Figures 22 and 24), the monopole antenna performs best when it is vertical with respect to Earth (i.e. with the xz and yz planes) and there is no polarisation mismatch. For the FCPW antenna, the best performance is achieved when
Improving the Energy Efficiency of Wireless Sensors through Smart Antenna Design
35
the copper face of the antenna is facing the base station (i.e. the xy plane) and there is no polarisation mismatch. It is notable that whilst the monopole antenna gives the highest RSSI result (yz plane), it displays the largest variation in results also. Comparing the results in the yz plane with no polarisation mismatch and those in the xy plane with a polarisation mismatch there is a 20-25dBm difference. Looking at the best and worst results for the FCPW, the difference is limited to a maximum of almost 10dBm. The RSSI results do not tell the whole story however, which is why the packet loss results (Figures 23 and 25) are also included. These results show that the monopole antenna experiences heavy packet loss when it is orientated in the xy plane, even at a distance of just 2m. As the distance increases this packet loss varies greatly, and on numerous occasions peaks at over 50% loss. For the FCPW antenna however, packet loss does not appear to occur at all until a distance of 11m, and even then it is not as pronounced as that experienced by the monopole antenna. It is thought that these results are due to the FCPW antenna having an elliptical polarisation, as discussed in Section 4. This is a significant finding, since it is likely that WSN nodes will be deployed in close proximity to one another in many applications, and therefore often it is short range communications (<10m) which are of most interest. These results indicate that the FCPW antenna would be far more efficient than the typical monopole in this situation. It is difficult to quantify precisely how much more efficient the FCPW antenna would be, as differing environments and data recovery mechanisms would result in differing levels of wasted energy. Using the data present in Figures 23 and 25, we can say that 6000 data packets are transmitted between the transmitter and receiver for every 1m increment, beginning at 0m (i.e. there are 1000 packets per orientation plane, and two polarisations). Table 3 attempts to give a quantitative evaluation of how much more energy is used effectively when using the FCPW antenna in this particular scenario. The energy consumed per packet transmitted was calculated using oscilloscope measurements shown in Figure 26. This calculated figure is 6.08mW per packet, assuming average power consumption during processing and transmitting of 37.5mW and 60.5mW respectively. As one can see from Table 3, a significant amount of energy is put to more effective use by utilising the FCPW antenna in both the 0-10 and 0-25m ranges. Whilst these experiments took place outdoors in line-of-sight conditions, it is not unreasonable to expect similar performance differences in real world applications.
Table 3. Energy efficiency comparison of the monopole and FCPW antennas
Distance
Packets transmitted
Energy wasted due to Increase in energy lost packets (J) used effectively (J) FCPW Monopole FCPW
Packets lost Monopole
0-10m
72000
2946
0
17.9
0
17.9
0-25m
156000
15784
6315
95.9
38.4
57.5
36
A. Mason, A. Shaw, and A.I. Al-Shamma’a
Fig. 26. Measured time period and current for a single packet transmission from the MicaZ mote
5 Conclusions This work presents an alternative antenna design appropriate for use at 2.45GHz. It is cheap to produce and provides more than adequate bandwidth for Zigbee devices such as the Berkeley MicaZ mote whilst remaining relatively small (40mm×27.5mm×1.6mm). It also has good omni-directional characteristics which makes it extremely well suited to applications where node orientation is not known and cannot be controlled. This leads to greater energy efficiency in these applications, since it means data loss is less likely. For WSNs this is an important outcome as energy constraints are often foremost in the minds of those planning sensor node deployments. It is also noteworthy that the useable impedance bandwidth makes the FCPW antenna appropriate for use in other wireless communications standards such as IEEE802.11 and IEEE802.16 (Wi-Fi and WiMAX, respectively). The former has a similar frequency range to IEEE802.15.4 compliant devices (such as the Berkeley MicaZ mote), whilst the later operates at 2.3, 2.5 and 3.5GHz.
References [1] Crossbow (2004). MPR/MIB Users Manual, http://www.xbow.com/ (April 6, 2010) [2] Mason, A., et al.: Inventory Management in The Packaged Gas Industry Using Wireless Sensor Networks. In: Mukhopadhyay, S.C., Leung, H. (eds.) Advances in Wireless Sensors and Sensor Networks, 1st edn., vol. 64, pp. 75–100. Springer, Heidelberg (2010) [3] Mason, et al.: Asset Tracking: Beyond RFID. Presented at the 7th Annual Postgraduate Symposium on the Convergence of Telecommunications (PGNET), Liverpool John Moores University, Liverpool, UK (2006)
Improving the Energy Efficiency of Wireless Sensors through Smart Antenna Design
37
[4] Mason, A.: Wireless Sensor Networks and their Industrial Applications, PhD, General Engineering Research Institute, Liverpool John Moores University, Liverpool (2008) [5] Balanis, C.: Microstrip Antennas. In: Antennas: Theory, Analysis and Design, 2nd edn., pp. 727–730. Wiley, Chichester (1996) [6] Ulaby, F.: Quarter wave monopole antenna. In: Fundamentals of Applied Electromagnetics, p. 358. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs (1999) [7] Balanis, C.: Loop Antennas. In: Antennas: Theory, Analysis and Design, 2nd edn., p. 203. Wiley, Chichester (1996) [8] Blake, L.: Radiation Resistance and Efficiency. In: Antennas, pp. 138–139. John Wiley & Sons, Chichester (1966) [9] Balanis, C.: Bandwidth. In: Antennas: Theory, Analysis and Design, 2nd edn., pp. 63–64. Wiley, Chichester (1996) [10] Garg, R., et al.: Broadbanding of Microstrip Antennas. In: Microstrip Antenna Design Handbook, pp. 534–535. Artech House, Norwood (2000) [11] Balanis, C.: Long Wire Antenna Polarisation. In: Antennas: Theory, Analysis and Design, 2nd edn., p. 496. Wiley, Chichester (1996) [12] Nithisopa, K., et al.: Design CPW Fed Slot Antenna for Wideband Applications. Piers Online 3, 1124–1127 (2007) [13] Garg, R., et al.: Effects of Finite Size Ground Plane. In: Microstrip Antenna Design Handbook, pp. 293–296. Artech House, Norwood (2000) [14] Ansoft. Probe Feed Patch Antenna Example. HFSS Users Guide, http://www.ansoft.com/ [15] Ansoft. Ansoft HFSS, http://www.ansoft.com/products/hf/hfss [16] Ansoft, Port tutorial series: Coplanar waveguide (CPW). HFSS v8 Training (2005), http://web.doe.carleton.ca/~mmariani/Thesis/ port_tutorial_CPW.ppt (22/05/2008) [17] Carr, J.: Transmission Lines Characteristic Impedance. In: Practical Antenna Handbook, 4th edn., p. 67. Tab Books (2001) [18] Balanis, C.: Microstrip Antennas: Patch Antenna Example. In: Antennas: Theory, Analysis and Design, 2nd edn., pp. 727–730. Wiley, Chichester (1996) [19] Kraus, J., Marhefka, R.: Folded Dipole Antennas. In: Antennas for All Applications, pp. 593–597. McGraw Hill Science, New York (2002) [20] Kraus, J., Marhefka, R.: Anechoic Chambers and Absorbing Materials. In: Antennas for All Applications, pp. 841–844. McGraw Hill Science, New York (2002) [21] Ulaby, F.: Plane Wave Propagation in Lossy Media. In: Fundamentals of Applied Electromagnetics, pp. 277–279. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs (1999) [22] Blake, L.: Interference. In: Antennas, pp. 26–27. John Wiley & Sons, Chichester (1966) [23] Carr, J.: Fading Mechanisms. In: Practical Antenna Handbook, 4th edn., p. 35. Tab Books (2001) [24] Basagni, S., et al.: Multipath Fading and Shadowing. In: Mobile Adhoc Networking, pp. 235–236. Wiley-Blackwell (2004) [25] Balanis, C.: Horn Antennas. In: Antennas: Theory, Analysis and Design, 2nd edn., pp. 651–711. Wiley, Chichester (1996) [26] Balanis, C.: Field Regions. In: Antennas: Theory, Analysis and Design, 2nd edn., p. 33. Wiley, Chichester (1996) [27] Blake, L.: Waveguides. In: Antennas, p. 94. John Wiley & Sons, Chichester (1966) [28] Balanis, C.: Antennas: Theory, Analysis and Design, 2nd edn. Wiley, Chichester (1996) [29] Kraus, J., Marhefka, R.: Antennas for All Applications. McGraw Hill Science, New York (2002)
Planar Electromagnetic Sensor for the Detection of Nitrate and Contamination in Natural Water Sources Using Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy Approach M.A. Md Yunus1,2 and S.C. Mukhopadhyay1 1
School of Engineering and Advanced Technology, Massey University, Palmerston North, New Zealand 2 Control and Instrumentation Engineering Department, Universiti Teknologi Malaysia, Skudai, Malaysia
Abstract. This paper highlights the progress of developing a low-cost system for detection of nitrate and contamination in natural water resources based on a planar electromagnetic sensor which consists of meander and interdigital structure. The sensor has been operated and evaluated using electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) approach, based on estimated electrical model; the results obtained from the experiments were interpreted. The objectives of the present work are to conduct simulation, experiments and analysis of a new nitrate detection method using novel planar electromagnetic sensors by means of electrochemical spectroscopy analysis. The sensor was tested with two aqueous solutions of nitrates forms namely, sodium nitrates (NaNO3) and ammonium nitrates (NH4NO3), each of different concentration between 5 mg and 20 mg dissolved in 1 litre of distilled water to observe their response. Furthermore, the sensor was tested with various kinds of prepared samples and natural water samples taken from natural sources around New Zealand. The simulation results using COMSOL have assisted in understanding the characteristic and response of the sensor to the change of properties in the aqueous solution. The experimental results have authenticated the results obtained from the simulation and show the sensor can well detect the presence of nitrate added in distilled water and distinguish the concentration level from the calculated sensitivities. The experiment results with the water sample taken from various places around New Zealand show a very good correlation of contamination level, translated from the qualitative and quantitative results. The work and improvement for future consideration are also discussed in this chapter.
1 Introduction The field of non-destructive testing or inspections is a very broad, interdisciplinary field that produces reliable information of the material under investigation so that proper actions can be taken for the benefits of animal, environment, and human. As has been reported [1], non-destructive testing and evaluation based on electromagnetic approaches are gaining worldwide attention since it was introduced due to simplicity, S.C. Mukhopadhyay et al. (Eds.): New Developments and Appl. in Sen. Tech., LNEE 83, pp. 39–63. springerlink.com © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011
40
M.A. Md Yunus and S.C. Mukhopadhyay
fast response, convenience, and low cost. In this research, particular electromagnetic approach of interest is the non-destructive testing or inspections based on the inductive and capacitive or electromagnetic effects. Such devices or sensors can be seen in the industrial areas [2], agriculture [3], and engineering/scientific applications e.g. land mine detection [4], health and food monitoring [5], manufacturing [6, 7], automation [8], structure inspection [9]etc. Towards the development of a planar electromagnetic device, the sensing or/and exciting elements are commonly flat and separated by substrates. Several examples of planar electromagnetic systems are discussed in this section. Inductive planar electromagnetic devices have been reported in [10-19] and extension used as sensors for testing (nondestructive testing) the integrity of materials (conductive and magnetic material) [20-29]. Other applications of inductive planar sensors are such proximity and displacement sensors [17, 30]. A method for inspecting integrity of different coins and successfully discerns between coins is introduced in [31]. Capacitive planar electromagnetic sensors or commonly known as co-planar interdigital sensors have been used for many applications, some of the examples are moisture measurement in pulp [32], monitoring the change impedance caused by the growth of immobilized bacteria [33], human health confirmation based on the content of water in human skin [34], humidity sensors [35], food inspection for human safety [36], and estimation of material dielectric properties such as food, saxophone reeds and leather [37-40]. Schlicker et.al. [4] have reviewed the advantages of applying electromagnetic sensors array at multiple positions and different orientations for detecting landmine and unexploded ordnance to overcome the weakness of existing technologies in discriminating between harmful object and harmless clutters. The inductive and capacitive sensor array were constructed and used separately, each array has a unique single drive structures that forms an electromagnetic field which penetrates deeper into the ground. The images obtained through scans over the ground surface and then enhanced using spatial filtering. It is shown that the inductive sensor array and capacitive sensor array are clearly responsive to metal and no-metal object, respectively. A serially closed circuit inductor-capacitor (LC) element which forms a passive sensor, and operates on wireless and remote query basis has been applied for environmental monitoring [41], bacteria growth monitoring [42, 43], monitoring of electrical properties of biological cell solutions [44], quantifying packaged food quality [45], real-time monitoring of water content in civil engineering materials [46, 47]. Despites of offering a good performance, this system is quite complex, considering the material properties estimation was achieved from impedance spectrum of the sensor measured using a remotely located antenna. The material properties (e.g. complex permittivity) are calculated from the impedance spectrum at resonant frequency with the inductance and capacitance of the sensor values based on calculation of analytical model. Moreover, looking at the current technologies, the potential of this system to be a portable or home appliance is hindered as it requires either an expensive impedance analyzer or lock in amplifier. Application of metal inspection is also not suitable as the presence of metal will disturb the responses of the transmitter and the receiver. In this research, our attention and interest have been drawn into to develop an electromagnetic sensor consisting both inductive and
Planar Electromagnetic Sensor for the Detection of Nitrate
41
capacitive element which can be integrated as a low cost, convenient, and suitable for in-situ measurement system for water quality monitoring, particularly nitrate detection.
2 Motivation The freshwater reserves make out almost 2.53% of the total water resources and from the freshwater reserves, we consume water for daily use that sourcing from groundwater (29.9% of freshwater reserves) and surface water (0.29% of freshwater reserve) [48]. We need clean water, as clean water is vital to our body, to our food, to the environment and human health, and also it is essential for water sports and recreation, and essential for fish and other wildlife species. Water is continuously absorbed to the land, flow into the sea from the river, evaporate into the sky and fall back into land, this process repeats over and over again. Under normal situation, the organic pollutants are biodegraded and converted into beneficial nutrient to the aquatic life. As for the inorganic pollutants, the hazards are limited because of their even dispersion in the water. Today, we have to face issues such as fulfilling the growing water demands while keeping it clean in the same time. The human civilizations have been contaminating the water supplies with foreign matters (whether in liquid or solid forms) that deteriorate the quality of the water and deliberately or not, increase the amount of inorganic pollution. Our research is mainly concerned with the amount of nitrate contamination in natural water sources as it is one of the much discussed issues in recent times. However, we are also looking into the detection of contamination level caused by any substances in natural water sources. Nitrate is a natural compound present in all ecosystems. It is a form of nitrogen that is used to create vital structural proteins and enzymes which help the plant to grow and develop. However, too much of it can be a problem and is difficult to remove from water due to its high solubility. Figure 1(a) illustrates the data for all the rivers throughout the world. It is seen little changes in nitrate mg (NO3)--N/L concentrations between the two decades under comparison can be observed from figure 1(a), while changes in the median value were not statistically significant [49]. Several parts in Europe, particularly in regions with intensive livestock production, concentrations higher than 50 mg/L were observed frequently in 39 groundwater bodies (14%). Around 20% of EU measure stations had concentrations in excess of the limit concentration, and 40% locations were in excess of the standard (25 mg/l) between 1996 and 1998. France and Sweden are showing an overall increase in nitrate concentrations in groundwater [50]. In New Zealand, the peak level of nitrate concentration in the rivers, taken as average value, has increased between 1990 and 2007 by approximately 66% [51]. Illness caused by nitrate poisoning is extremely fatal to infants; they are vulnerable to methemoglobinemia due to haemoglobin oxidation and can cause fatal consequences. It can affect the baby in very little time, sometime even in couple of days [52]. Livestock especially ruminants also exposed to the same problem, they will start to how signs like lack of coordination, labored breathing, blue membranes, vomiting, and abortions [53]. The high amount of nitrate in surface water and groundwater because of over fertilizing, resulting in accelerated growth of algae and
42
M.A. Md Yunus and S.C. Mukhopadhyay
weed (eutrophication). When the algae and weeds completely died and decomposed, the process remove oxygen from the water thus killing the fish and other aquatic life [54]. According to reports from experiments, there is still little information to come to a conclusion about the relationship of high nitrate intake and other human cancer like gastric cancer, thyroid Cancer and thyroid disease. However, the link cannot be ruled out due to inadequacy of data available [55, 56]. Figure 2 illustrates the maximum
(a)
(b)
Fig. 1. (a) Nitrate contamination of surface water in the world compared over two decades (b) Nitrate contamination of groundwater in the EU in 2003
Fig. 2. Recommended nitrate limit by government agencies in several counties in the world (all the values are presented in mg·(NO3)-1-N/L unit, to convert the value into mg·(NO3)-1/L unit, multiply by 4.33)
Planar Electromagnetic Sensor for the Detection of Nitrate
43
concentration in drinking water as recommended by agencies in several countries where it was mainly established for protection from methemoglobinemia [55]. The main sources of nitrate contamination are agricultural fertilizers and animal wastes, industrial wastes related to food processing, munitions, and septic tanks; especially in densely populated areas [57-59]. Other factors are application of nitrogen-rich fertilizers to turf grass. This occurs on golf courses and in residential areas, sites where accidental spills of nitrogenous materials may accumulate, and finally, manure storage by the farmers [60]. Nitrate detection methods can simply be divided into indirect and direct methods. Such applications of indirect methods, but not limited to, are the detection of results of nitrate reduction reaction such as nitric oxide gas followed by geometry or potentiometry [61], reaction to diphenylamine [62], reaction to salicylic acid followed by spectrophotometer[63], detection of ammonium ion resulting from the reduction of nitrate by trichloride in hydrochloric acid [64], spectrophotometric [65], polarography and voltmetric [66]. A recent indirect and in-situ detection of nitrate as reported in [67], measure the change of LED intensity emitted through a nitrate sensitive membrane using photo-detectors. This system has a good sensitivity with range of 0.002 and 1000 mM and a precision of 4%. However, one major drawback is the optical path has to be properly guided and aligned, requiring a regular repositioning to maintain the accuracy. In New Zealand, the measurement of nitrate level in water sources conducted by the government agencies which the data then made public has been conducted using absorption spectrophotometry using a specific reagent since over three decades [68, 69]. Most of the indirect methods were often developed and established for laboratory standards thus making it expensive due to many components requirement. It also often involved laborious measuring steps and inevitably consumes a lot of time. They also require controlled working condition, and preparation of extra reagent or chemical. The direct methods have been proven to provide much more simpler solution; such applications are chromatography [70] and biosensors incorporating enzymes, antibodies, and whole cells[16]. The most popular direct method which is also considered as low cost is potentiometry based on ion selective electrodes (ISE) [71, 72]. The application of the method had been reported in [61]. The advantages of this technology are such as unsophisticated sensor fabrication process, simple monitoring instrumentation, fast and rapid response, accurate, compact and acceptably responsive even to limited amount of sample, and suitable for continuous measurement. However, the strength of the output signal depends on the strength or concentration of the targeted ions and often requires amplification. Moreover, the output signal also susceptible to the interference from not targeted ions thus a large number of reagents were necessary for the purpose of neutralization of the noise and adversely might be harmful to the environment [64, 73]. Looking at the importance of nitrate detection and the challenges arise, this research motivates to develop a sensor which can be integrated as a low cost, convenient, and suitable for in-situ measurement system for water quality monitoring, particularly nitrate detection.
44
M.A. Md Yunus and S.C. Mukhopadhyay
3 Construction and Operating Principle of Planar Electromagnetic Sensor A novel electromagnetic sensor has been designed and fabricated for the detection of nitrates and contamination in natural water sources [74]. The sensor was designed using Altium Designer 6 and it has been fabricated using simple printed circuit board (PCB) fabrication technology where the thickness of the PCB is around 0.25 mm. The sensor is then sprayed with Wattyl Incralac Killrust spray to form a coating layer in order to prevent any direct contact with water sample. The layer was applied at least twice, giving a protection layer with 10 micron width. Figure 3 shows the top and bottom layers of the planar electromagnetic sensor. The meander type of coil is connected in series with the interdigital coil and an ac voltage is applied across the combination of the coils. The meander coil produces a magnetic field and the interdigital coil produces an electric field. The combination of meander and interdigital coils produce electromagnetic field which interacts with the material under test. The purpose of providing a grounded backplane is to minimize the effect of background noise [75]. The total impedance is used as the characterization parameter for the parallel combination sensor as described in [75], however the calculation of the impedance is shown again here as it will be related to other section
Fig. 3. Left hand side (a) schematic diagram of the top layer, (b) Schematic diagram of the bottom layer. Right hand side (a) a picture of the top layer taken using a camera, (b) a picture of the top layer taken using a camera
Planar Electromagnetic Sensor for the Detection of Nitrate
45
(section 7). The electrical equivalent circuit of the series combination sensor is shown in figure 4. The sensor is connected to a function generator where Rg is the output resistance with nominal value of 50 Ω, R1 denotes the series surface mount resistor connected to the sensor as shown in figure 4. Hence, the real part, Rtotal_s and the imaginary part, Xtotal_s can be calculated from: I 1 = V3∠0 D R1
(1)
where I1 is the rms value of current through the sensor. The total impedance Ztotal_s is given by, Z total _ s = V1∠θ 1 I 1∠0 D
(2)
θ1 is the phase difference between v1(t) with v3(t) in degree, taking v3(t) as reference. Therefore, Rtotal_s and Xtotal_s are given by: Rtotal _ s = Z tota _ s cos (θ 1 ) − R1
(3)
X total _ s = Z total _ s sin (θ1 )
(4)
Fig. 4. Electrical equivalent circuit of SCS3
4 Simulation Using Comsol Multiphysics The COMSOL Multiphysics has been used to model of the sensor [75]. This section will discuss the improvement of the model which taking into account the factor and effect of coating film. 4.1 Description of the Model The sensor has been described in section 3 and the geometry configuration of the selected sensor is shown in figure 5. All sensors are drawn based on the dimensions taken from section 3. The quasi-statics electromagnetic equation set of the COMSOL
46
M.A. Md Yunus and S.C. Mukhopadhyay
3.5a electromagnetic module (electric and induction currents) is used for the model in time-harmonic analysis type. Both of magnetic (induction current) and electric (electric current) properties are considered and set meaning that vector potential à and the scalar electric potential Ṽ are the physical unknown to solve which derived after using a gauge transformation [76]. à and Ṽ are set to be vector and linear elements, respectively. This equation is expressed as following:
( jωσ − ω ε ε )A~ + ∇ × (μ 2
0
r
−1 0
)
(
)
~ ~ μ r−1 × A − σv × ∇ × A = J e
(5)
where ε0 is the permittivity of vacuum equals to 8.854×10-12 F/m, μ0 is the permeability of vacuum which sets to be 4π×10-7 H/m, εr is the relative permittivity, μr is the relative permeability, Je is the external current density, σ is the electric conductivity, v is the velocity of the conductor and ω is the angular velocity. 4.2 Subdomain Equation There are four physical variables: the scalar electrical potential Ṽ and the three components of magnetic vector potentials (Ã) Ãx, Ãy, and Ãz. The sensor models can be divided into four subdomains which are PCB copper tracks, insulating layer (Polytetrafluoroethylene or Teflon), environment (air/ pure water) [77, 78], and incralac coating film. Incralac is an acrylic coating for copper and bronze. It consists of a solution of methyl methacrylate copolymer incorporating benzotriazole [77, 79, 80]. All the subdomains are shown in figure 5 and use the same and unique system, equation (5), at this point. The domain properties for the sensor models are given in table 1.
Fig. 5. 3D-drawing and the boundary condition of the sensor
Planar Electromagnetic Sensor for the Detection of Nitrate
47
Table 1. Subdomain parameters of planar electromagnetic sensors
Subdomain name σ εr µr Je v
1 2 3 4 PCB copper tracks PCB insulating layer Air/Water Incralac coating film 5.998×107 0.004 0.8 1.45×10-12 1 4.5 1/82 9 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
4.3 Boundary Condition The PCB copper tracks are subjected with impedance boundary condition, given by: ε− j
n×H +
μ
σ ω ⋅ n × (E × n ) = 0
(6)
where H is the magnetic field intensity and E is the electric filed intensity. Insulating dielectric layers (pcb and incralac layers) are treated with continuity boundary equations given by: n × (H 1 − H 2 ) = 0
(7)
n ⋅ (J 1 − J 2 ) = 0
(8)
where J is the current density, the outer surface boundaries need the magnetic insulation and electric insulation, the equations are given by: n× A=0
(9)
n⋅J =0
(10)
The other boundaries are the input and output boundaries as shown in inset picture of figure 5. The input boundary requires magnetic insulation equation and port boundary. 4.4 Impedance Equations The induced current in the sensor is calculated by the integration of normal current density on the surface area of the sensor near the ground point which can be written as:
∫
I = J .ds
(11)
S
The induced voltage across the sensor is calculated over a number of finite elements. The general approximation is given by: Vinduced =
∑ M
i =1
(E
x
⋅ i x + E y ⋅ i y + E z ⋅ i z )i .N Ai
(12)
48
M.A. Md Yunus and S.C. Mukhopadhyay
where N stands for the number of turn in the conductor (not the number of meander spiral turn). Ex, Ey, and Ez are the electric field intensity for x, y, and, z component, respectively given in V/m unit, at the ith element. ix, ix, and iz are the current directions at x, y, and, z, respectively, at the ith element Ai is the cross section area at the ith element, given in m2.The current port boundary condition gives the total impedance of the sensor which derived from equations (11) and (12), the total impedance is given by: Z total _ s =
1 Vinduced = Y11 I
(13)
4.5 Simulation Results At this stage, the purpose of the simulation is to serve three objectives. The first objective is to calculate the sensor characteristic from the total impedance response when the environment is set to air. The second objective is to observe the sensor response when the environment is set to water condition while the rest of the properties remain the same as the first one. The third objective is to as compare the simulation results with the experimental results. For the first simulation (σ=0.8, εr=1and frequency range between 1 kHz and 100 MHz), the impedance values of the sensor decrease from 1 kHz to 10 MHz showing a capacitive behaviour as shown in figure 6. The inductive effect starts to appear after 10 MHz.
Fig. 6. Impedance characteristic (air) obtained from simulation results
For the second simulation, the environment was set as pure water (σ=0.8 and εr=82) and was simulated for frequency range between 1 kHz and 100 MHz. The Nyquist (complex impedance plane) plot shows that the real part (Z’) decreases with the increasing frequency and the imaginary part (Z’’) having a peak at 30 kHz. The simulation to calculate the response of the sensor to the decrease of electrical conductivity while the relative permittivity remains the same and to the increase of relative permittivity while the electrical permittivity remains the same have been conducted using the above model. However, it was difficult to get any good response
Planar Electromagnetic Sensor for the Detection of Nitrate
49
Fig. 7. Impedance response of the sensor to water using electric and induction currents model on a Nyquist plot
because of the dominancy of the inductive part. Therefore, a step has been taken to reduce the model by taking only the effect of electric field (electric current). As a result, the electric field is curl free and can be assign a scalar potential V when induction is disregarded. The equation of the subdomains then becomes: − ∇ ⋅ ((σ + jωε r ε 0 )∇V ) = 0
(14)
The PCB copper tracks, insulating layer and coating layer are subjected to continuity boundary condition of equation (8). The input boundary requires port boundary and the output boundary was set to ground. The impedance is calculated as discussed in section 4.6. Addition of aqueous solution into the environment results in changes of permittivity and conductivity of the environment. The aqueous solution will respond to the applied electric field by redistributing its electrons and protons, positive charges being attracted towards the negative electrode and vice-versa, thus changing the total impedance of the sensor. Therefore, the total impedance of the sensor will be determined by the content of aqueous solution involved. Figure 8 depicts the Nyquist plot when the environment set to pure water, a capacitive semicircle can be seen from the figure. When εr is fixed at 82 and σ is decreased between 1.45×10-12 (set to be the lowest conductivity, i.e. coating film) and 145, the complex spectra is shrinking to a smaller semicircle as illustrated in figure 9. The change of the electrical conductivity value seems to have a significant effect to the sensor’s response. Under the situation when σ is fixed at 1.45×10-12 and εr is decreased between 82 and 16, there is a slight deviation of the rest of the spectra as comparison to the initial value (σ=1.45×10-12 and εr=82). There is a significant change when the relative permittivity value was changed from 82 to 42 and lower. However, the changes between εr=41 and εr=16 are not proportional.
50
M.A. Md Yunus and S.C. Mukhopadhyay
Fig. 8. Nyquist plot of impedance curve of pure water using electric current model
Fig. 9. Nyquist plot of impedance curves with different water different σ values
Fig. 10. Nyquist plot of impedance curves with different water different εr values
Planar Electromagnetic Sensor for the Detection of Nitrate
51
5 Experimental Setup The sensor characteristic of the sensor was determined by measuring the total impedance (absolute) of the sensor at different frequencies between 10 kHz and 100 MHz when no material is placed near the sensor (air). Then, the next experiment involved the response of the sensors with distilled water, different concentration of nitrates samples in the form of Sodium Nitrate (NaNO3) diluted in 1 litre of distilled water and different concentration of Nitrates samples in the form of Ammonium Nitrate (NH4NO3) diluted in 1 litre of distilled water. The operating frequency range was between 25 Hz and 1 MHz. The experimental setup is shown in figure 11, the setup has a waveform generator where standard sinusoidal waveform with 10 Volts peak-to-peak value was set as the input signal for the sensor. An old microscope was used as a platform for the sample container and the sensor was immersed into the water sample. The Agilent 54622D mixed signal oscilloscope was interfaced to a PC where the output signals and the sensor’s impedance was recorded and calculated consecutively using developed program using LabView software.
Fig. 11. Experimental setup for the experiments
6 Experimental Characteristic of the Sensor Impedance curve in the simulation (figure 7) is steeper compared to the impedance curves obtained from experiment in figure 12, although showing a good similarities. The actual resonance frequency from the experiment is approximately at 30 MHz, about 20 MHz difference from the simulation (figure 7) under comparison. The combination of inductive and capacitive effects is presented between 3 MHz to 10 MHz.
52
M.A. Md Yunus and S.C. Mukhopadhyay
Fig. 12. Impedance characteristic obtained from experimental results
7 Experiment with Distilled Water, Different Concentration of NaNO3 and NH4NO3 Diluted in 1 Litre Distilled Water and Results Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy approach was used to estimate qualitatively the reaction of the sensor with water samples. The response in the frequency domain of an electrochemical reaction can be used to estimate the contamination in the water. Figure 13(a) describes a system for coated electrodes response to aqueous solution as has been described in [79, 81]. The circuit composed of the solution resistance (Rs), coating resistance (Rc), coating capacitance (Cc), charge transfer resistance (Rct), and double layer capacitance (Cdl). In this research, an additional meander inductance (L) has been added to represent the system as shown in figure 13(b).
Fig. 13. Equivalent circuit to describe the system
Figures 14 and 15 show the response of the sensor to the different concentration of Sodium Nitrate (NaNO3) diluted in 1 litre of distilled water and different concentration of Ammonium Nitrate (NH4NO3) diluted in 1 litre of distilled water, respectively. Both figures contain the response of the sensor to distilled water. The
Planar Electromagnetic Sensor for the Detection of Nitrate
53
simulated response of the sensor with distilled water in figure 7 as comparison to figure 14 or 15 (0 mg/L) showing an obvious peak. This is postulated that the total inductance as produced in the model is much larger than is actually existed as shown in the experiment result. In general, the sensor is giving capacitive loop and inductive loop at low frequency and high frequency, respectively. A typical electrochemical spectroscopy response with aqueous solution often show both capacitive and inductive semicircle [82]. However, our sensor shows significant deviation of the loops as can be seen in figure 14 and 15, this is caused by the presence of inductive characteristic [81] of the meander sensor, especially at high frequency. The impedance curve is shrinking and smaller as the concentration is increased, the simulation results in figure 9 suggests that it caused by the reduction of σ value. All the spectrums can be fitted using nonlinear least square fit (NLLS-fit) and simulation computer program to estimate the values of the circuit components in figure 13 in future.
Fig. 14. Nyquist plot for experiment involving different concentration of dissolved NaNO3
Fig. 15. Nyquist plot for experiment involving different concentration of dissolved NH4NO3
54
M.A. Md Yunus and S.C. Mukhopadhyay
For quantitative results, the sensitivities of the sensors are calculated from the real part as taking the value from the distilled value as reference in the following equation: %Real_part =
⎡ (Rtotal )sample − (Rtotal )distilled
∑ ⎢⎣ f
(R ) total
distilled
⎤ × 100⎥ ⎦
(14)
In the simulation results above (figure 10), the imaginary part showed a response other than linear, therefore the absolute difference value is used to calculate the imaginary part sensitivity as shown in equation: % Imaginary_part =
⎡ ( X total )sample − ( X total )distilled
∑ ⎢⎢ f
⎣
(X ) total
distilled
⎤ × 100⎥ ⎥ ⎦
(15)
Where (Rtotal)distilled is the real part of the impedance value when the sensor is immersed in the distilled water and (Rtotal)sample is the real part of the impedance value when the sensor is immersed in the water sample. (Xtotal)distilled is the imaginary part of the impedance value when the sensor is immersed in the distilled water and (Xtotal)sample is the imaginary part of the impedance value when the sensor is immersed in the water sample. The symbol f represents the frequency. Figures 16 shows the sensitivities value when tested with solution based on NaNO3 and NH4NO3. Similar response can be observed for both solution types, except the real part sensitivity and the imaginary part sensitivity of NH4NO3 are much higher than NaNO3.
Fig. 16. Sensitivity of the sensors to the aqueous solution
The real part negatives values progressively decreases with the total concentration of the chemicals. The linear equation y1 and y3 represent the real part sensitivity of NaNO3 and NH4NO3, respectively where x1 and x2 signify the total concentration of NaNO3 and NH4NO3, respectively. This indicates that the conductivity of the water
Planar Electromagnetic Sensor for the Detection of Nitrate
55
has increased as can be seen from the simulation result (figure 9). Good linear correlation with R2=0.965 and R2=0.982, between the real part sensitivities with the chemical concentration of NaNO3 and NH4NO3, respectively. The sensitivity of the imaginary part for both type of aqueous solution is increasing when the concentrations were increased in polynomial order of two as can be seen in figure 16. The linear equation y2 and y4 represent the imaginary part sensitivity of NaNO3 and NH4NO3, respectively where x2 and x4 signify the total concentration of NaNO3 and NH4NO3, respectively. The total sensitivities give good polynomial order of 2 correlation with R2=0.996 and R2=0.990. Double layer capacitance, Cdl (figure 13) is formed as ions from the solution accumulate around the electrodes surface [83]. The value of Cdl is usually higher than the coating, Cc [79, 81], so the small change of Cdl will be apparent in the imaginary part of the impedance response. The value of the double layer capacitance depends on many variables such as temperature, ionic concentrations, types of ions, oxide layers, electrode roughness, dielectric properties/relative permittivity [84, 85], etc. The change of the imaginary sensitivity is caused by the decrease in Cdl, resulting from a decrease in the relative permittivity of the water samples.
8 Experiment with Water Samples The sensor has been used to observe the response of the sensor with natural water mixed with contaminants. From the Nyquist plot and calculated sensitivities, the qualitative and qualitative responses are studied. The samples of different bottles were taken from previous research by Karunanayaka in [86]. Figure 17 shows the water samples collected from different places in the respective containers. The water samples were analysed using Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) technique to check the amount of organic material in the sample and summarized in table 2. Table 2 shows the amount of mineral in g·m-3 including the pH value.
Fig. 17. Water samples in containers, arranged in ascending order from left to right
56
M.A. Md Yunus and S.C. Mukhopadhyay
In this experiment mili-Q water was used as reference, milli-Q refers to water that has been purified and deionized to a high degree by a water purification systems where the operating frequency is between 20 Hz and 1 MHz. Figure 18 illustrates that similar curve obtained when the sensor tested with mili-Q water when compared with the curve for distilled water in figure 18 but with larger curve. This proves that mili-Q water is purer than distilled water. As a whole, all the water samples produced a significantly smaller complex plane curves compared to the mili-Q curve. Table 2. Content of water samples from NMR test results Sample
pH
570-1,Matakana raw 570-2,Matakana magnetic circle tank 570-3,IPL Mixed water UV 570-4, Edgecumbe raw 570-5, McCains D119 raw 570-6, Matakana raw2 570-7, McCains treated 570-8, Tauranga tapwater 570-9, Technical water system potable 570-10, Edgecumbe magnetic treatment
Mg Fe Ca (gm-3-Ca) (gm-3-Mg) (gm-3-Fe)
CaCO3 (gm-3CaCO3)
Sulphate (gm-3-SO4)
Total mineral (gm-3)
8.69
3.3
0.54
0.036
8
0.63
12.506
8.06
3
0.51
0.039
10
0.24
13.789
8.38
1.7
0.32
0.027
4
0.09
6.137
7.529
11.6
11.8
3.33
77
0.02
103.75
6.62
17.3
24.8
2.62
150
0.23
194.95
7.8 8.2
3 4.6
0.51 3
0.036 0.334
8 24
0.63 606
12.176 637.934
7.27
2.8
0.56
0.005
8
1.8
13.165
7.16
5.3
0.56
0.11
14
2.17
22.14
8.58
14.4
8.1
0.014
70
0.02
92.534
Fig. 18. Nyquist plot for experiment involving water samples
Typically, pure water has relative permittivity of 81 and electrical conductivity of 0.8 at room temperature. Any addition of other substance will reduce the relative
Planar Electromagnetic Sensor for the Detection of Nitrate
57
permittivity of the aqueous solution and increase the electrical conductivity. Therefore, we can say that the curves that deviate further away inside the mili-Q curve have more contamination. From figure 19, the most deviated curves are 570-1, 570-2, 570-3, 570-4, 570-5, 570-7, and 570-10. The sensitivities were calculated using equations (14) and (15), taking the values from mili-Q as reference. The sensitivity values calculated for the water samples as shown in figure 20 suggested that the water samples to be divided into three groups of unsafe to consume, use with caution and safe to consume. The unsafe to consume water sources are of 570-5 and 570-7. This can be explained from the highest imaginary sensitivities over 10000% and this condition is caused by high the total amount of mineral in 570-5 and 570-7 as given in table 2.
Fig. 19. Nyquist plot for experiment involving water samples excluding the response from mili-Q water and distilled water
Fig. 20. Sensitivity of the sensors to the aqueous solution arranged in order of increasing total mineral (gm-3) in table 2
58
M.A. Md Yunus and S.C. Mukhopadhyay
As for the safe to consume water samples, 570-8 and 570-9 are included giving the imaginary sensitivities just above 4000% where the total amount of mineral for each sample in Table 1 confirms the selection. Finally, 570-1, 570-2, 570-3, 570-4, 570-6 and 570-10 are all group together in consume-with-caution group as the total sensitivity has just passed 6000 % and just above 8000 %. Although some of the samples in the cautious group appear to be in low total amount of mineral, there are some discolorations caused by certain kind of algae or living organism inside the water samples, thus changing the electrical properties of the water samples as shown in figure 17. This may have cause the imaginary sensitivity to be significantly high as compared to the total amount of mineral given in Table 2. As conclusion, if we combine the qualitative data interpreted form the impedance spectra and the quantitative data from the total sensitivities, only water samples of 570-8 and 570-9 are acceptable high quality standard drinking water and safe to be consumed. This is indeed a better way to describe the contamination rather than single frequency result as has been described in [75].
9 Future Consideration and Conclusion For further improvements, the sensor will be miniaturized to reduce the overall cost. Furthermore, the concept of ion selective electrode (ISE) polymerised with pyrolle doped with nitrate will be developed which will increase the selectivity [72]. The process involves the replacement of copper track with graphite and polymerization of pyrolle doped with nitrate on the graphite through electrolysis to form polypyrolle. The concept of low cost system is also considered where the function generator will be replaced with a voltage controlled oscillator, auxiliary circuits will be built to measure the sensor impedance and a microcontroller will be used for signal analysis. The present study shows that a very distinct detection of nitrates and contamination in water can be achieved using the sensor using electrochemical data analysis approach. It can be used as a tool for water sources monitoring in farm where the nitrate level should not exceed 10 mg/L in New Zealand. The sensor has also been tested with drinking water samples and has shown very promising results to be a sensing tool of contamination detection in drinking water when electrochemical impedance spectroscopy was used in understanding the response between the sensors and aqueous solution.
References [1] Hull, B., John, V.: Non-destructive testing (1988) [2] Mesina, M.B., de Jong, T.P.R., Dalmijn, W.L.: Automatic sorting of scrap metals with a combined electromagnetic and dual energy X-ray transmission sensor. International Journal of Mineral Processing 82(4), 222–232 (2007) [3] Srinivasan, A.: Handbook of Precision Agriculture. The Haworth Press, New York (2006) [4] Schlicker, D., Washabaugh, A., Shay, I., et al.: Inductive and capacitive array imaging of buried objects. Insight 48(5), 302–306 (2006) [5] Mohd Syaifudin, A.R., Jayasundera, K.P., Mukhopadhyay, S.C.: A low cost novel sensing system for detection of dangerous marine biotoxins in seafood. Sensors and Actuators B: Chemical 137(1), 67–75 (2009)
Planar Electromagnetic Sensor for the Detection of Nitrate
59
[6] Mamishev, A.V., Sundara-Rajan, K., Yang, F., et al.: Interdigital sensors and transducers. In: Proceedings of the 2006 IEEE Sensors Applications Symposium, vol. 92(5), pp. 808– 845 (May 2004) [7] Guadarrama-Santana, A., Garcia-Valenzuela, A.: Principles and Methodology for the Simultaneous Determination of Thickness and Dielectric Constant of Coatings With Capacitance Measurements. IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement 56(1), 107–112 (2007) [8] George, B., Zangl, H., Bretterklieber, T., et al.: A Combined Inductive-Capacitive Proximity Sensor and Its Application to Seat Occupancy Sensing. In: I2MTC-International Instrumentation and Measurement, Singapore, pp. 13–17 (2009) [9] Kirchner, N., Hordern, D., Liu, D.K., et al.: Capacitive sensor for object ranging and material type identification. Sensors and Actuators a-Physical 148(1), 96–104 (2008) [10] Green House, H.M.: Design of Planar Rectangular Microelectronic Inductors. Ieee Transactions on Parts Hybrids and Packaging Ph10(2), 101–109 (1974) [11] Hwang, H.Y., Yun, S.W., Chang, I.S.: A design of planar elliptic bandpass filter using SMD type partially metallized rectangular dielectric resonators. In: 2001 IEEE Mtt-S International Microwave Symposium Digest,, vol. 1-3, pp. 1483–1486 (2001) [12] Um, K., An, B.: Design of rectangular printed planar antenna via input impedance for supporting mobile wireless communications. In: Proceedings of IEEE 55th Vehicular Technology Conference, Vtc Spring 2002, vol. 1-4, pp. 948–951 (2002) [13] Yunas, J., Rahman, N.A., Chai, L.T., et al.: Study of coreless planar inductor at high operating frequency. In: Proceedings of 2004 IEEE International Conference on Semiconductor Electronics, pp. 606–610 (2004) [14] Fava, J., Ruch, M.: Design, construction and characterisation of ECT sensors with rectangular planar coils. Insight 46(5), 268–274 (2004) [15] Quirarte, J.L., Silva, M.J.M., Palacios, M.S.R.: Software for analysis and design of rectangular planar arrays. In: 2004 1st International Conference on Electrical and Electronics Engineering (ICEEE), pp. 90–95 (2004) [16] Valderas, D., Melendez, J., Sancho, I.: Some design criteria for UWB planar monopole antennas: Application to a slotted rectangular monopole. Microwave and Optical Technology Letters 46(1), 6–11 (2005) [17] Li, L.W., Li, Y.N., Mosig, J.R.: Design of a novel rectangular patch antenna with planar metamaterial patterned substrate. In: 2008 IEEE International Workshop on Antenna Technology: Small Antennas and Novel Metamaterials - Conference Proceedings, pp. 119–122 (2008) [18] Oraizi, H., Noghani, M.T.: Design and Optimization of Linear and Planar slot Arrays on Rectangular Waveguides. In: 2008 European Microwave Conference, vol. 1-3, pp. 1468– 1471 (2008) [19] Fava, J.O., Lanzani, L., Ruch, M.C.: Multilayer planar rectangular coils for eddy current testing: Design considerations. Ndt & E International 42(8), 713–720 (2009) [20] Goldfine, N.J.: Magnetometers for Improved Materials Characterization in Aerospace Applications. Materials Evaluation 51(3), 396–405 (1993) [21] Goldfine, N.J., Clark, D.: Near-surface material property profiling for determination of SCC susceptibility. In: 4th EPRI Balance-of-Plant Heat Exchanger NDE Symp. (1996) [22] Yamada, S., Fujiki, H., Iwahara, M., et al.: Investigation of printed wiring board testing by using planar coil type ECT probe. IEEE Transactions on Magnetics 33(5), 3376–3378 (1997)
60
M.A. Md Yunus and S.C. Mukhopadhyay
[23] Mukhopadhyay, S.C., Yamada, S., Iwahara, M.: Experimental determination of optimum coil pitch for a planar mesh-type micromagnetic sensor. IEEE Transactions on Magnetics 38(5), 3380–3382 (2002) [24] Mukhopadhyay, S.C.: Quality inspection of electroplated materials using planar type micro-magnetic sensors with post-processing from neural network model. IEEE Proceedings-Science Measurement and Technology 149(4), 165–171 (2002) [25] Mukhopadhyay, S.C.: A novel planar mesh-type microelectromagnetic sensor - Part 1: Model formulation. IEEE Sensors Journal 4(3), 301–307 (2004) [26] Mukhopadhyay, S.C.: A novel planar mesh-type microelectromagnetic sensor - Part II: Estimation of system properties. IEEE Sensors Journal 4(3), 308–312 (2004) [27] Mukhopadhyay, S.C.: High Performance Planar Electromagnetic Sensors-A Review of Few Applications, pp. 33–41 [28] Mukhopadhyay, S.C.: Novel planar electromagnetic sensors: Modeling and performance evaluation. Sensors 5(12), 546–579 (2005) [29] Sheiretov, Y., Grundy, D., Zilberstein, V., et al.: MWM-Array Sensors for In Situ Monitoring of High-Temperature Components in Power Plants. IEEE Sensors Journal 9(11), 1527–1536 (2009) [30] AnimAppiah, K.D., Riad, S.M.: Analysis and design of ferrite cores for eddy-currentkilled oscillator inductive proximity sensors. IEEE Transactions on Magnetics 33(3), 2274–2281 (1997) [31] Karunanayaka, D., Gooneratne, C.P., Mukhopadhyay, S.C., Sen Gupta, G.: A Planar Electromagnetic Sensors Aided Non-destructive Testing of Currency Coins. NDT.net 11(10) (September 2006) [32] Sundara-Rajan, K., Byrd, L., Mamishev, A.V.: Moisture content estimation in paper pulp using fringing field impedance Spectroscopy. IEEE Sensors Journal 4(3), 378–383 (2004) [33] Radke, S.M., Alocilja, E.C.: Design and fabrication of a microimpedance biosensor for bacterial detection. IEEE Sensors Journal 4(4), 434–440 (2004) [34] Sekiguchi, N., Komeda, T., Funakubo, H., et al.: Microsensor for the measurement of water content in the human skin. Sensors and Actuators B-Chemical 78(1-3), 326–330 (2001) [35] Furjes, P., Kovacs, A., Ducso, C., et al.: Porous silicon-based humidity sensor with interdigital electrodes and internal heaters. Sensors and Actuators B-Chemical 95(1-3), 140–144 (2003) [36] Radke, S.M., Alocilja, E.C.: A microfabricated biosensor for detecting foodborne bioterrorism agents. IEEE Sensors Journal 5(4), 744–750 (2005) [37] Mukhopadhyay, S.C., Gooneratne, C.P., Demidenko, S., et al.: Low Cost Sensing System for Dairy Products Quality Monitoring. In: Proceedings of the IEEE Instrumentation and Measurement Technology Conference, IMTC 2005, vol. 1, pp. 244–249 (May 2005) [38] Mukhopadhyay, S.C., Sen Gupta, G., Woolley, J.D., et al.: Saxophone reed inspection employing planar electromagnetic sensors. IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement 56(6), 2492–2503 (2007) [39] Mukhopadhyay, S.C., Gooneratne, C.P.: A novel planar-type biosensor for noninvasive meat inspection. IEEE Sensors Journal 7(9-10), 1340–1346 (2007) [40] Yunus, M.A.M., Kasturi, V., Mukhopadhyay, S.C., et al.: Sheep skin property estimation using a low-cost planar sensor. In: Proceedings of the IEEE Instrumentation and Measurement Technology Conference, I2MTC 2009, pp. 482–486 (May 2009) [41] Ong, K.G., Grimes, C.A., Robbins, C.L., et al.: Design and application of a wireless, passive, resonant-circuit environmental monitoring sensor. Sensors and Actuators a-Physical 93(1), 33–43 (2001)
Planar Electromagnetic Sensor for the Detection of Nitrate
61
[42] Ong, K.G., Wang, J., Singh, R.S., et al.: Monitoring of bacteria growth using a wireless, remote query resonant-circuit sensor: application to environmental sensing. Biosensors & Bioelectronics 16(4-5), 305–312 (2001) [43] Ong, K.G., Bitler, J.S., Grimes, C.A., et al.: Remote query resonant-circuit sensors for monitoring of bacteria growth: Application to food quality control. Sensors 2(6), 219–232 (2002) [44] Hofmann, M.C., Kensy, F., Buchs, J., et al.: Transponder-based sensor for monitoring electrical properties of biological cell solutions. Journal of Bioscience and Bioengineering 100(2), 172–177 (2005) [45] Tan, E.L., Ng, W.N., Shao, R., et al.: A wireless, passive sensor for quantifying packaged food quality. Sensors 7(9), 1747–1756 (2007) [46] Ong, J.B., You, Z.P., Mills-Beale, J., et al.: A Wireless, Passive Embedded Sensor for Real-Time Monitoring of Water Content in Civil Engineering Materials. IEEE Sensors Journal 8(11-12), 2053–2058 (2008) [47] Sharavanan, B., Jung-Rae, P., Tarisha, M., et al.: Conformal Passive Sensors for Wireless Structural Health Monitoring. In: Material Research Society Symposia Proceeding, pp. 341–348 [48] Vorosmarty, C.J., Green, P., Salisbury, J., et al.: Global Water Resources: Vulnerability from Climate Change and Population Growth. Science 289(5477), 284–288 (2000) [49] http://www.unep.org/dewa/assessments/ecosystems/ water/vitalwater/10.htm [50] http://www.grid.unep.ch/product/publication/ freshwater_europe/ecosys.php [51] http://www.nzinstitute.org/index.php/nzahead/measures/ water_quality/ [52] Metcalf, N.F., Metcalf, W.K., Wang, X.: The Differing Sensitivities of the Hemoglobin of Fetal and Adult Red-Cells to Oxidation by Nitrites in Man - the Role of Plasma. Journal of Physiology-London 407, P44 (1988) [53] Donald, L.P., Charles, D.F.: Water Quality for Livestock Drinking. MU Extension Publication, University of Missouri-Columbia, vol. EQ 381, pp. 1–4 (2001) [54] Reichard, J., Brown, C.: Detecting groundwater contamination of a river in Georgia, USA using baseflow sampling. Hydrogeology Journal 17(3), 735–747 (2009) [55] Terblanche, A.P.S.: Health hazards of nitrate in drinking water. Water Sa 17(1), 77–82 (1991) [56] Ward, M.H., Kilfoy, B.A., Weyer, P.J., et al.: Nitrate Intake and the Risk of Thyroid Cancer and Thyroid Disease. Epidemiology 21(3), 389–395 (2010) [57] Di, H.J., Cameron, K.C.: Nitrate leaching losses and pasture yields as affected by different rates of animal urine nitrogen returns and application of a nitrification inhibitor a lysimeter study. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems 79(3), 281–290 (2007) [58] Di, H.J., Cameron, K.C.: Nitrate leaching in temperate agroecosystems: sources, factors and mitigating strategies. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems 64(3), 237–256 (2002) [59] Stanley, E.M.: Fundamental of Environmental Chemistry, 3rd edn. CRC Press, Taylor and Francis Group, Boca Raton (2009) [60] http://www.reopure.com/nitratinfo.html [61] Hassan, S.S.M.: Ion-selective electrodes in organic functional group analysis. Microdetermination of nitrates and nitramines with use of the iodide electrode. Talanta 23(10), 738–740 (1976)
62
M.A. Md Yunus and S.C. Mukhopadhyay
[62] Bartzatt, R., Donigan, L.: The colorimetric determination of nitrate anion in aqueous and solid samples utilizing an aromatic derivative in acidic solvent. Toxicological & Environmental Chemistry 86(2), 75–85 (2004) [63] Monteiro, M.I.C., Ferreira, F.N., de Oliveira, N.M.M., et al.: Simplified version of the sodium salicylate method for analysis of nitrate in drinking waters. Analytica Chimica Acta 477(1), 125–129 (2003) [64] Cho, S.-J., Sasaki, S., Ikebukuro, K., et al.: A simple nitrate sensor system using titanium trichloride and an ammonium electrode. Sensors and Actuators B: Chemical 85(1-2), 120–125 (2002) [65] Ferree, M.A., Shannon, R.D.: Evaluation of a second derivative UV/visible spectroscopy technique for nitrate and total nitrogen analysis of wastewater samples. Water Research 35(1), 327–332 (2001) [66] Gumede, N.J.: Harmonization of internal quality tasks in analytical laboratories case studies: water analysis methods using polarographic and voltammetric techniques. Faculty of Applied Sciences, Durban University of Technology, Durban (2008) [67] Maria Dolores, F.-R., et al.: The use of one-shot sensors with a dedicated portable electronic radiometer for nitrate measurements in aqueous solutions. Measurement Science and Technology 19(9), 95204 (2008) [68] Downes, M.T.: An improved hydrazine reduction method for the automated determination of low nitrate levels in freshwater. Water Research 12(9), 673–675 (1978) [69] http://www.mfe.govt.nz/publications/ser/technical-guide-newzealand-environmental-indicators/html/page4-12.html [70] Connolly, D., Paull, B.: Rapid determination of nitrate and nitrite in drinking water samples using ion-interaction liquid chromatography. Analytica Chimica Acta 441(1), 53–62 (2001) [71] Kjær, T., Hauer Larsen, L., Revsbech, N.P.: Sensitivity control of ion-selective biosensors by electrophoretically mediated analyte transport. Analytica Chimica Acta 391(1), 57–63 (1999) [72] Bendikov, T.A., Harmon, T.C.: A Sensitive Nitrate Ion-Selective Electrode from a Pencil Lead. An Analytical Laboratory Experiment. Journal of Chemical Education 82(3), 439– 441 (2005) [73] Moorcroft, M.J., Davis, J., Compton, R.G.: Detection and determination of nitrate and nitrite: a review. Talanta 54(5), 785–803 (2001) [74] Md Yunus, M.A., Mukhopadhyay, S.C.: Novel planar electromagnetic sensors for detection of nitrates and contamination in natural water sources. IEEE Sensors Journal (accepted for publication September 24, 2010) [75] Md Yunus, M.A., Mukhopadhyay, S.C., Sen Gupta, G.: A new planar electromagnetic sensor for quality monitoring of water from natural sources. In: 4th International Conference on Sensing Technology, ICST 2010, June 3-5, pp. 554–559 (2010) [76] COMSOL AC/DC Module, User’s Guide, Version 3.5a (November 2008) [77] Stafford, O.A., Hinderliter, B.R., Croll, S.G.: Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy response of water uptake in organic coatings by finite element methods. Electrochimica Acta 52(3), 1339–1348 (2006) [78] Light, T.S., Licht, S., Bevilacqua, A.C., et al.: The fundamental conductivity and resistivity of water. Electrochemical and Solid State Letters 8(1), E16–E19 (2005) [79] McNamara, C.J., Breuker, M., Helms, M., et al.: Biodeterioration of Incralac used for the protection of bronze monuments. Journal of Cultural Heritage 5(4), 361–364 (2004)
Planar Electromagnetic Sensor for the Detection of Nitrate
63
[80] Cano, E., Lafuente, D., Bastidas, D.M.: Use of EIS for the evaluation of the protective properties of coatings for metallic cultural heritage: a review. Journal of Solid State Electrochemistry 14(3), 381–391 (2010) [81] Tan, Y.J., Bailey, S., Kinsella, B.: An investigation of the formation and destruction of corrosion inhibitor films using electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS). Corrosion Science 38(9), 1545–1561 (1996) [82] Itagaki, M., Taya, A., Watanabe, K., et al.: Deviations of Capacitive and Inductive Loops in the Electrochemical Impedance of a Dissolving Iron Electrode. Analytical Sciences 18(6), 641–644 (2002) [83] Grahame, D.C.: The Electrical Double Layer and the Theory of Electrocapillarity. Chemical Reviews 41(3), 441–501 (1947) [84] Jeyaprabha, C., Sathiyanarayanan, S., Muralidharan, S., et al.: Corrosion inhibition of iron in 0.5 mol L-1 H2SO4 by halide ions. Journal of the Brazilian Chemical Society 17, 61–67 (2006) [85] Ravichandran, R., Nanjudan, S., Rajendran, N.: Corrosion inhibition of brass by benzotriazole derivatives in NaCl solution, Bradford. ROYAUME-UNI, Emerald (2005) [86] Karunanayaka, D.: Studies of Magnetic Filtration Techniques to Purify Potable Water and Waste Water. School of Engineering and Advanced Technology, Massey University, New Zealand, Palmerston North (2007)
Current Reconstruction Algorithms in Electrical Capacitance Tomography M. Neumayer, H. Zangl, D. Watzenig, and A. Fuchs Institute of Electrical Measurement and Measurement Signal Processing Graz University of Technology Kopernikusgasse 24/IV A-8010 Graz
[email protected]
1
Electrical Capacitance Tomography in General
Controller LAN
Front End Circuitry
Figure 1 depicts a scheme of an electrical capacitance tomography (ECT) sensor. A number of electrodes are mounted on the exterior of a nonconductive process pipe. By measurements of the capacitances between certain electrode, it is aim to compute an image of the material distribution. Electrical capacitance tomography is an inverse problem which uses capacitance measurements for determining information about specifics of a certain domain. The inverse problem is given by the task of determining the material distribution, which caused the measured capacitances. ECT is well-suited for industrial processes since materials typically involved in industrial processes like multiphase flows show good contrast in terms of the permittivity. Knowledge about the spatial distribution of the components is usually necessary to directly characterize the state of such processes and consequently be able to reach the aforementioned goals through process control [34]. Examples of processes including multiphase flow can be found in almost every industry, e.g. food production,
Shield
Fig. 1. Schematic of the ECT system and the reconstruction task. By measurements of the capacitances beteween the electrodes, the material distribution inside the pipe should be determined. S.C. Mukhopadhyay et al. (Eds.): New Developments and Appl. in Sen. Tech., LNEE 83, pp. 65–106. c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011 springerlink.com
66
M. Neumayer et al.
separation columns, fluidized beds, chemical reactors, oil production, waste water treatment, mining operations, and pneumatic conveying. The fact that the electrodes can be non-invasively mounted outside of the nonconducting process pipe makes ECT applicable to processes containing aggressive fluids. The inverse problem of ECT is an ill-posed inverse problem. Hadamard [3] gave a definition for well-posed inverse problems by the claims on • A solution exists. • The solution is unique. • The solution depends continuously on the data. If one of this definitions is hurt, which is truly the case in ECT, the inverse problem is of ill-posed nature. In this case a stable solution can only be found by incorporating available prior knowledge about the solution.
Fig. 2. 3D scheme of the electrodes and two inclusions.
A main difference between ECT and other tomographic methods like i.e. the computer tomography is, that ECT belongs to the class of so called soft field tomography systems. For every tomography assignment an appropriate physical value has to be chosen to gather information about the spatial parameters within the expanded object. A basic classification of tomography systems can be made by separating by the way of interaction between the object and the physical value used for the measurement. If the physical value is not influenced in its direction the method is called hard field tomography. An example for this is x-ray tomography. The beam pierces straight through the object. Only its intense is reduced - the effect is described by Lambert-Beers law. If the propagation of the physical value is influenced by the object the method is called soft field tomography. This is given in electrical tomography systems like that of ECT, where the distribution of the displacement currents (and therefore the capacitances between the electrodes) are influenced. Because of this soft field character electrical tomography systems have drawbacks in resolution compared to hard field systems.
Current Reconstruction Algorithms in Electrical Capacitance Tomography
67
The interaction of the field by the object further causes a spatial dependence of the sensitivity. This ends up in different achievable resolutions for the same object in different regions within the problem domain. Capacitive measurement systems generally provide high sensitivity in the region near the electrodes but provide only low sensitivity for distant objects. Thus, the sensitivity in the center of the pipe is low. Hence, the reconstruction of inclusions placed in the center of the pipe is harder than reconstructing the same inclusion when placed near the electrodes. All these facts make the inverse problem of ECT a comparatively hard inverse problem to solve and the obtainable resolutions are comparatively low with respect to methods like x-ray. However, the main advantage of electrical tomography systems is still the simple hardware concept. Compared to the necessary hardware of other tomographic methods like x-ray, γ-ray, microwaves, neutron tomography, positron emission tomography, electrical methods like ECT only require some attached electrodes and a measurement circuitry. Hence, ECT requires less space to mount the sensor. In contrast to the mentioned methods also no ionizing radiation is produced, which makes ECT a very save sensing technology. Although real ECT systems are always 3D systems like schematically depicted in figure 2, the inverse problem is mostly solved for a two dimensional problem. Thus, typical ECT systems provide cross sectional images. Of course, this simplification can only be made if the electrodes have a certain length compared to the diameter of the process pipe. Otherwise, 3D effects dominate the behavior of the coupling capacitances and the 2D reconstruction will fail. Typically, if the length of the electrodes is in the range of the diameter of the process pipe, the simplification is assumed to be allowed [28]. The number of electrodes is a critical parameter in the design of ECT systems, as the number of electrodes effects the number of measurements which can be taken. Typically the number of electrodes is between 8 and 16 [28]. Also ECT systems with an increased number of smaller electrodes were build, but these systems suffer from an decreased signal to noise ratio (SNR), as also the coupling capacitance between the electrodes decrease due to the smaller area of the electrodes. Also systems with (electronically) rotating electrodes [2] were proposed to increase the number of electrodes. However the effective number of measurements becomes only slightly higher compared to a system with 16 electrodes. 1.1
Physics within an ECT-Sensor
Like for any other electrical system the governing partial differential equations that describe the physical phenomena within the ECT-sensor are given by the Maxwell’s equations [1]: dB , dt dD ∇×H =J + , dt ∇×E =−
(1) (2)
68
M. Neumayer et al.
∇ · B = 0, ∇ · D = ρ.
(3) (4)
−1
−1
B = μH,
(5)
D = εE,
(6)
E denotes the electric field in Vm , H denotes the magnetic field in Am . B denotes the magnetic flux in Vsm−2 and D denotes the electric displacement in Cm−2 . Equation (1) is called Faraday’s law of induction and describe the interaction between the electric field and a time varying magnetic field. Equation (2) is called Ampere’s circuital law and describes that the sources of magnetic fields are electric currents (given by the the current density J in Am−2 ) and by time varying displacement currents. Equation (3) is sometimes referred as Gauss’s law of magnetism and has the physical interpretation that no magnetic monopoles exist. Equation (4) is called Gauss’s law and means that charges ρ in C are the source term for the electric field. Equation (1) to (4) are extended by the two material equations
where μ denotes the magnetic permeability and ε denotes the dielectric permittivity. The permeability μ is given by the product μ = μ0 μr where μ0 is the absolute permeability given by 4π × 10−7 VsA−1 m−1 and the dimensionless relative permeability μr . Similarly, ε0 denotes the absolute permittivity given by 8.854 × 10−12 AsV−1 m−1 and εr denotes the dimensionless relative permittivity. In addition J = σE,
(7)
describes the interaction between the current density J and the electric field E in a conductive media, where σ is the conductivity in Ω−1 m−1 . Equation (7) is referred as Ohm’s law. ECT specific simplifications Although several electric effects that can occur in the ECT-sensor are described by the Maxwell’s equations, typically some simplifications are made in order to get a more simple partial differential equation. The main assumptions are: • The interaction between the electric field and the magnetic field is neglected. • The conductivity of the materials is small. • No charges are present. The first assumption leads to the most drastic simplification as it reduces the type of differential equation from a hyperbolic (Helmholz type) to an elliptic type (Laplace type). From a physical point of view the reduction means that wave propagation effects within the ECT-sensor are neglected. For the typical frequency range and the typical dimensions of ECT-sensors this is a valid assumption. This can be verified by the fact, that the wavelength λ 1 λ= √ f με
(8)
Current Reconstruction Algorithms in Electrical Capacitance Tomography
69
is typical a several multiples of the sensor dimensions. In the case of conductive materials the wavelength is given by √ 2 2π λ = √ (9) ωμ σ 2 + ω 2 ε2 + ωε and thus is also dependent on the conductivity. It had been reported in [8] that in this case even for small conductivities the wave length can decrease to values in the range of the dimensions of the sensor. Another rule of thumb to estimate the occurrence of wave propagation effects is given by ωε ωμσLc 1 + 1 (10) σ where Lc is defined as characteristic distance over which E varies significantly. Although (10) is more a heuristic it also indicates the appearance of wave propagation effects within the ECT-sensor when conductive materials are present. The benefits of a full implementation of the Maxwell’s equations have been investigated in [4]. However, this assumptions were made for free space propagation. Due to the large cover angle of the electrodes, they act as shield. Hence, wave propagation effects have only a small impact and appropriate calibration techniques can further decrease their impact. Starting with (1) the partial differential equation for the ECT-sensor can be derived as follows: ∇ × E = 0,
(11)
which means that the curl of the electric field is zero. Hence, E can be expressed by the gradient of a scalar potential. Thus E is expressed by E = −∇V,
(12)
where V is the electric scalar potential in V. Taking the divergence of Faradays law (2) leads to dD ∇ · (∇ × H) = ∇ · J + = 0, (13) dt as the ∇ · (∇ × A) = 0 for any vector field A. By using the scalar potential V and taking the Fourier transform (13) becomes ∇ · (jωε∇V ) = 0,
(14)
where J has been set to zero. In ECT it is common to replace the term jω by 1 as it has no effect on the solution V . Hence, the quasistatic differential equation (14) becomes − ∇ · (ε∇V ) = 0,
(15)
70
M. Neumayer et al.
which is the well known partial differential equation from electrostatics. The same result can be obtained by using Gauss’s law ∇·D =ρ =0 ∇ · (εE) = 0
(16) (17)
and substituting (12). In the occurance of conductivity J in equation (2) can be expressed by J = σE, which turns the potential equation (14) to − ∇ · ((σ + jωε)∇V ) = 0
(18)
for the quasistatic case. Thus, the electrical behavior depends on the ratio of σ rσ,ωε = . (19) ωε In the case rσ,ωε 1 the conductivity is small compared to ωε. Hence, the behavior is determined by the permittivity distribution, which is the ideal case for applying ECT. In the case rσ,ωε 1 the effects are mainly determined by the conductivity. In this case electrical impedance tomography is in general a more suitable tool. For noninvasive ECT senor designs, the equivalent circuit becomes a serial circuit consisting of a resistor and a capacitance. Depending on the measurement circuitry the application of ECT results in reconstructed material distributions with high permittivities for the conductive objects. The effect of reconstructing objects with increased permittivity can already be observed for objects with a low conductivity. For rσ,ωε ≈ 1, the effects of the conductivity and the permittivity are in the same order of magnitude. Using an I/Q demodulator to determine the real and the imaginary part of the capacitance, it is possible to reconstruct both quantities [9]. In the presence of conductivity one might argue about the appropriateness of the name electrical capacitance tomography. However, in the noninvasive case the electrical coupling through the nonconductive pipe is always of capacitive nature. Hence the name has its justification. 1.2
Measurement Modi
This subsection refers to the different measurement modi which can be applied in electrical capacitance tomography systems. Although the name electrical capacitance tomography suggests that the capacitance between the electrodes is measured (or at least a quantity which is proportional to the capacitance like the displacement current) not all ECT systems measure the capacitance. As the difference lies in the measurement circuitry we will classify the different measurement modi by the used hardware terms • Low-Z measurements • High-Z measurements Figure 3 depicts the two schemes. Basically the classification is done through the input impedance of the measurement circuitry. A short summary about the main difference will be presented in the following. Detailed informations about the benefits of each circuit can be found in [5].
Current Reconstruction Algorithms in Electrical Capacitance Tomography
A
71
A
(a) Low-Z measurement. Not all am- (b) High-Z measurement. Not all caperemeters are depicted. pacitances are depicted. Fig. 3. Different measurement schemes for Low-Z and High-Z measurements.
Low-Z Measurement The low-Z measurement modi is depicted in figure 3(a). The measurement steps are the following • An AC-voltage is applied to one electrode which is referred as transmitter electrode. • The other electrodes are kept on ground potential and displacement currents are measured. These electrodes are referred as receiver electrodes. It should be noted that not all amperemeters are depicted in figure 3(a). As the dielectric currents is proportional to the capacitance by u i = 1 = jωCu,
(20)
jωC
the low-Z method may appear as the more natural method to obtain measurement data from the ECT sensor. A typical capacitance measurement pattern, which forms the input data of the reconstruction algorithm, is depicted in figure 4. The circuitry for Low-Z measurements are typically transimpedance amplifiers, where the electrode is connected with the virtual ground of the circuitry. Also circuits using resonant circuits in the input stage are used. In this configuration the receiver electrode is not connected to virtual ground but as the impedance of the resonant circuit is much lower than the impedance of the capacitance to measure, this configuration is also referred as low-Z circuitry. Additionally the resonant circuit builds a first filter stage against external disturbers.
72
M. Neumayer et al.
For the partial differential equation (15) the boundary conditions for the low-Z measurement modi are given as Dirchlet type boundary conditions given by VΓT ransmitter = VT , VΓReceiver = 0.
(21) (22)
The capacitances between the electrodes are computed using Gauss’s law given by 1 C=− n · ε∇V dΓ, (23) VT Γelec where n denotes the surface normal vector on the surface of the electrode. Hence the computations are sometimes referred as Dirchlet to Neumann map. Typical ECT systems are equipped with up to Nelec = 16 electrodes. Thus the number of independent measurements (the coupling capacitances between the electrodes) is given by Nelec (Nelec − 1) = 120 2
(24)
measurements. High-Z Measurement The high-Z measurement modi is depicted in figure 3(b). For the high-Z measurement modi the measurement steps are given by • An AC-voltage is applied between two different electrodes. • The floating potentials of the other electrodes are measured. Thus, not the capacitances are measured, but the floating potentials of the electrodes depends on the capacitances between the electrodes. Compared to the Low-Z measurement modi now all capacitances have an influence on the measured quantity. This is indicated by the capacitance between the two electrodes where the voltmeters are attached. Hence, in terms of an equivalent circuit, the system can be described by a large capacitive voltage divider. Due to the ground potential of the receiver electrodes in the other Low-Z measurement modi, the effect of the coupling capacitances between the receiver electrodes is eliminated. Thus, the equivalent circuit in the Low-Z case is the single coupling capacitance. The High-Z measurement modi seems unnatural for ECT. However, the scheme it is often used in electrical impedance tomography, where currents are impressed into the problem domain and the potential on some boundary points is measured. The circuitry for high-Z measurements are typically amplifiers with high input impedance. The boundary conditions to complete the partial differential equation (15) are given by VΓelec,i = V1 , VΓelec,j = V2
(25) i = j.
(26)
Current Reconstruction Algorithms in Electrical Capacitance Tomography
73
0.6
0.5
C (pF)
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
20
40
60
80
100 120 140 # of measurement
160
180
200
220
240
Fig. 4. Typical measurement pattern.
As the measured quantities are the potentials of the electrodes, the solution is directly obtained from the solution of V . 1.3
Prototype ECT-System at Graz University of Technology
Figure 5 depicts a photo of the ECT-system prototype which was developed at the Institute of Electrical Measurement and Measurement Signal Processing at
Fig. 5. Photo of a prototype ECT system.
74
M. Neumayer et al.
Graz University of Technology [6]. For commercial sensors we refer to [17]. To meet the demands of industrial tomography systems the ECT system was built for a non-invasively use. Center of the system is a plastic process pipe with an exterior diameter of 110 mm and a wall thickness of 3.5 mm. For the electrical access of the problem domain 16 electrodes are mounted in a symmetric arrangement at the exterior of the pipe. The cover angle of each electrode is 17.5 o , the length of the electrodes is 5 cm. Each electrode is equipped with it’s own front end circuitry which is mounted in a modular way on an installation board around the pipe. The front end circuitry includes an output driver stage, a receiver stage, an analog-to-digital-converter (ADC) and a digital logic for the transmission of the measured quantities to a host micro-controller, which is also mounted on the installation board. Thus, every electrode can act either as transmitter or as receiver. The input stage is build to measure the displacement currents. Hence, the senor is build on a low-Z principle. The measurement frequency used by the system is 40 MHz. The host-controller coordinates the measurement process and transmits the measured values to a personal computer (PC) where the reconstruction algorithms are implemented. For the communication a local-areanetwork (LAN) is used. 1.4
Calibration of ECT Systems
Like in nearly any other measurement system, also the capacitance measurements of an ECT system suffer from offset and gain variations. These measurement errors come to hand due to • • • • •
unmodeled physical effects, parasitic effects, different geometries, discretization errors, hardware imperfections.
Also, the fact that the ECT sensor is a 3D system but the reconstruction task is performed in 2D make a suitable calibration necessary. To minimize their impact, appropriate calibration strategies have to be applied. A common calibration scheme for a ECT-sensor is based on a simple Offset-Gain-calibration, i.e. C = CM,air + K · (CS − CS,air ),
(27)
where the index S labels measurement values from the sensor and M labels computed values from the forward model. The text in the index notes the filling of the sensor. The gain value K permits a degree of freedom for a problem dependent calibration. One possible choice for K is for example K=
CM,water − CM,air , CS,water − CS,air
(28)
Current Reconstruction Algorithms in Electrical Capacitance Tomography
75
which is useful for reconstruction tasks with a large range of permittivity values. For reconstruction tasks of material distributions with low permittivities a possible approach is given by K=
2
CM,air . CS,air
(29)
Reconstruction Algorithms in ECT – A Classification
Although accurate and reliable hardware and measurement circuitry plays - like in every other measurement system - an important role in the measurement chain much more effort concerning the topic of ECT has always been been put on reconstruction algorithms. As mentioned, the number of independent measurements is in general low, e.g. 120 independent measurements for a system with 16 electrodes. Imagine an image with 10 × 10 independent pixels, the number of independent values is already 100. An representation of the cross section using 10 × 10 pixel would indeed be very insufficient. As we will demonstrate in section 5, by the use of prior knowledge one is able to obtain far better results. In this book chapter we will present a selection of 5 different reconstruction algorithms/methods which can be applied to solve the inverse problem of ECT and describe them in more detail. This is done in section 4. To give 5 catchwords for our selection we decided for • • • • •
Linear backprojection LBP Optimal approximation OA Nonlinear iterative Kalman Filters Markov Chain Monte Carlo MCMC
Each algorithm has its certain properties concerning typical criterions like the speed or the quality of the result. We explicitly don’t want to make a classification of the methods concerning quantities like the computation time in this section. The computational load and thus the amount of the different methods will be obvious when the algorithms are explained. Instead, in this section we want to give a more generalized overview about the applicability of the five reconstruction methods and want to give some grading for the five algorithms in the concern of data representation. 2.1
Classification by the Type of Data Representation
By the term tomography people associate the representation of the result by an image. This is of course due to the increased ability of visual perception of human compared to other human senses. However, for further processing steps or process control, images are in general not the quantity of interest. Moreover process parameters like void fractions, areas of inclusions or mixture states are of interest. Hence, we first want to make a classification by
M. Neumayer et al.
True distribution
76
Parameter estimation
Data Extraction
Reconstruciton
Tomography
Determine parameter set q1, e.g. shape model
Determine parameter set q2, e.g. void fraction
LBP OA Nonlinear iterative Kalman filters MCMC Fig. 6. Illustration concerning the difference between tomography and parameter estimation.
• Tomography: algorithms that directly provide an image . • Parameter estimation: algorithms that estimate certain parameters θ. Figure 6 depicts this mentioned classification. The left path depicts the tomographic approach where the result of the reconstruction directly is an image. Out of this image certain parameters of interest can be computed. The right
Current Reconstruction Algorithms in Electrical Capacitance Tomography
77
path in figure 6 is referred as parameter estimation task. In this approach, the reconstruction result is a parameter set θ. As depicted in figure 6, it can be possible to generate a tomographic image out of the estimated parameters. This for example will be the case if θ presents the parameters of a shape model. Figure 7 exemplary depicts a shape representation of a closed contour, where for example the coordinates of the corner points are collected in θ. Hence, the application of
Fig. 7. Exemplary shape of a closed contour.
parameter estimation does not mean an abandonment regarding the quality of the result - it more means the use of a more appropriate material description assigned to the wanted quantity. Although tomography can be seen as a large scale parameter estimation problem, we explicitly want to use this term due to the fact, that the result is an image. By this principle classification between tomography and parameter estimation a first quantification about the properties and the applicability of the five methods between tomography and parameter estimation can be made. The bar chart in the lower part of Figure 6 tries to depict the range of the deployment of the methods. Full tomography implies a large scale parameter estimation problem. All of the five methods can be used for this. Reducing the optimization task toward a parameter estimation problem, methods like LBP or OA will become non applicable. Optimal approximation methods allow a slightly increased application towards the direction of parameter estimation problems. This comes by the design of the algorithms out of this method which will be explained later. The fact that the reduction of the parameter space leads to harder estimation problems comes due to the growing nonlinearity of the model when specific descriptions θ are used. The last three methods cover the whole range of inverse problems. For nonlinear iterative methods and Kalman filters this is because of the fact that these methods linearize the model in the current model state. This means that the computation of gradients becomes necessary. MCMC methods do not need gradient information. Instead they use sampling techniques to obtain the solution. Beside MCMC all algorithms in this book chapter are explained for tomographic applications. We decided for this because of the reasons that the
78
M. Neumayer et al.
produced results are comparable and because of the fact that the tomographic application leads to simpler algorithms. The following overview should provide an idea about the application of the five methods. • Linear backprojection: − Tomography: Linear backprojection [47], Landweber iteration [18], Offline iteration online reconstruction [26] • Optimal approximation − Tomography: OFOA and OSOA [7] [10] • Nonlinear iterative − Tomography: Gauss-Newton [32], [33] − Parameter estimation: Boundary element/ Level set [41], [12]. • Kalman Filters − Tomography: Kalman Filer [50], H∞ Filter [11] − Parameter estimation: Particle Filter [13] • MCMC − Tomography: [23] − Parameter estimation: by shape models [22], [14] 2.2
Classification Concerning the Type of Algorithm
For a second classification we want a distinction between deterministic methods and statistical methods. We define a deterministic algorithm, as an algorithm that computes the same result when calling it with the same input data twice. By this definition the first four algorithms are determinist algorithms. However, algorithms out of the methods of optimal approximation and Bayesian recursive algorithms are truly statistical methods. For optimal approximation techniques this decision comes by the fact, that the prior knowledge is incorporated out of statistical knowledge about the expected true material distribution. Although the resulting algorithm is a deterministic algorithm, its whole design is based on statistical assumptions and prior knowledge given by probability density functions (pdf). For deterministic approaches like nonlinear iterative methods the prior knowledge is incorporated in form of a regularization term. The design of regularization terms is often based on knowledge or assumptions like smoothness. By this no knowledge in the form of pdf’s is used. We will later mention that in certain cases a close connection between statistical methods using prior pdf’s and deterministic methods with regularized solutions exist in a way, that a regularization term can be formed out of the probability density function of the prior knowledge [23]. In the case of Kalman filters the inverse problem is treated by the way, that the parameter to estimate is a random variable. Hence, the Kalman filter is truly a statistical methods, although the algorithm is a deterministic algorithms. Finally, MCMC methods are fully statistical methods. The previous reconstruction algorithms provide a single reconstruction result, or a point estimate, for the input data. MCMC method evaluate Bayes law of probability, i.g. p(εr |d) =
p(d|εr )p(εr ) ∝ p(d|εr )p(εr ), p(d)
(30)
Current Reconstruction Algorithms in Electrical Capacitance Tomography
79
where p(εr ) is termed the prior, p(d|εr ) denotes the likelihood and p(d) denotes the evidence. p(εr |d) is known as posterior distribution. Thus, rather than providing a point estimate, MCMC methods provide a probability density function of the result.
3
Mathematical Tools in ECT
This section provides information about some mathematical tools needed to solve the inverse problem of electrical capacitance tomography. Basically two tools are needed for the later treatment of the inverse problem. • A method to compute the forward problem. • A method to compute derivatives. To solve the forward problem we shortly want to explain the idea of the finite element method as a method to solve equation (15). Further, some of the later introduced reconstruction algorithms require derivatives, i.e. how changes the measurement on some electrode, if some permittivity value is changed. As the numerical computation of such derivatives may become too time consuming, we will explain an analytical method to compute derivatives. 3.1
Finite Element Method
In the following we shortly want to explain the idea and the employment of the finite element method (FEM) to solve the governing partial differential equation within an ECT sensor. For detailed information about the finite element method we refer to [38]. A very readable introduction into the FEM is given by [39]. Numerical methods for solving partial differential equations have an approximative character. This means, that for example for solving (15) such methods seek for a solution Vˆ such that V ≈ Vˆ =
N
vj Nj .
(31)
j=1
Hence, the approximate solution is given in form of a series representation of linear independent functions Nj , which are weighted by vj . Thus, a method has to be found to determine the weights vj . A way to access this problem is given by method of weighted residuals. Given a (partial) differential equation of type Lu = f , where L denotes the differential operator, u denotes the solution and f is the right hand side term, the equation Lˆ u−f =
(32)
can be interpreted as the error of the approximate solution compared to the exact solution. As the exact solution ( = 0) can in general not be found, the method of weighted residuals tries to find u ˆ in such a way, that (Lˆ u − f )wdΩ = 0 (33) Ω
80
M. Neumayer et al.
holds. Hereby, w denotes a weighting function of the error . Again, the function w is given in form of a series representation w=
N
βi wi .
(34)
i=1
One can also say that with (33) the error is orthogonal to the functions w. It becomes clear that (33) is a weaker claim than = 0. Therefore, this formulation is called the weak formulation. The most used approach is to set wi = Ni , which is called the Ritz-Galerkin method. Applying the Ritz-Galerkin method on equation (15) ends up in ε∇Ni · ∇Vˆ dΩ = 0,
(35)
(36)
Ω
which is called the Ritz-Galerkin equation. Evaluating (36) for all functions Ni ends up in a linear equation system of form Kv = 0.
(37)
The matrix K is called stiffness matrix, the vector v is the solution vector, which contains the weights vj of equation (31). However, equation (37) is yet still free of boundary conditions. The incorporation of Dirichlet type boundary conditions should be shown by example on a 3 × 3 matrix. Given the equation system ⎡ ⎤⎡ ⎤ ⎡ ⎤ k11 k12 k13 v1 0 ⎣ k21 k21 k22 ⎦ ⎣ v2 ⎦ = ⎣ 0 ⎦ , (38) k31 k32 k33 v3 0 the value v3 should be set to the value v30 . This is done by the operation ⎤⎡ ⎤ ⎡ ⎤ ⎡ v1 −k13 v30 k11 k12 0 ⎣ k21 k22 0 ⎦ ⎣ v2 ⎦ = ⎣ −k23 v30 ⎦ , (39) 0 0 1 v3 v30 wherewith the boundary condition is applied. Applying this procedure to the equation system (37) leads to the equation system ˆ = b, Kv
(40)
whose solution v forms the approximated solution Vˆ of V . With the approach (33) and the Ritz-Galerkin method a way is given to find an approximate solution for differential equations. Nevertheless it is in most
Current Reconstruction Algorithms in Electrical Capacitance Tomography
81
cases impossible to find appropriate basis functions Ni for the whole problem domain Ω. Only in a very limited number of cases, i.e. for a plate capacitor, such functions can be reconstructed easily. For complex geometries this will in general not be possible. The way out of this problem is the finite element method. The problem domain is discretized in small subdomains, the so called finite elements. For those subdomains it is allowed to use simple basis functions Ni . Assuming that the discretization is fine enough the error made with this method is small. To give an example for a finite element, figure 8 depicts a triangular finite element and the basis function Ni (x, y). The basis function Ni has the attribute of beeing 1 in the node i and beeing 0 in the node j and k. The weights vi , vj and vk are elements of the vector v. In the finite element procedure, the vkNk
viNi
xk;yk
xi;yi vjNj xj;yj
Fig. 8. Triangular element with linear basis function.
Ritz Galerkin equation (36) is applied for each finite element, resulting in an equation systems Kelem velem = 0,
(41)
for each element. This so called element matrices Kelem and the element solution vectors velem are then assembled to build the equation system (37). After applying the boundary conditions the equation system can be solved to obtain the solution v. Charge computation In the case of low-Z measurements the dielectric currents between the electrodes are measured. As these currents correspond to the charge on the electrodes in the electrostatic case, the charges have to be computed out of the solution V . The relation between the capacitances and the charges is given by Q = CVT . Two methods for the computation of the charges are possible.
(42)
82
M. Neumayer et al.
Charge integration The first method is simply given by the integration of the inflowing displacement current over the boundary of the electrode. Hence n · ε∇V dΓ. (43) Qelec = − Γelec
Thereby, the permittivity ε denotes the electric material values of the surrounding area of the electrode and n is the normal vector on the surface of the electrode. The method is quite easy but requires the computation of the gradient. Charge method Alternative, a method named ”charge method” [19] can be used can be used to compute the charges. The method was introduced in electrical capacitance tomography but it can be used in the same manner for other problems with a Laplacian differential equation. For the use of the charge method only the stiffness matrix K and the solution vector v are used. The charges can be computed by evaluating
Qelec = (Kv)nelec . (44) nelec
Hence, the computation of a gradient is not necessary. (Kv)nelec is the scalar product between the vector v and the rows of the matrix K that correspond to nodes on the surface of the specific electrode. 3.2
Analytic Computation of Derivatives
After providing a method to solve the governing differential equations, we now want to present a method to compute derivatives. As some of reconstruction methods require gradient information, the computation of derivatives is of high demand. Although, the computations of a 2D forward problem can be carried within a fraction of a second (i.e. 50 ms), the numerical computation of derivatives is in general not preferred. E.g. for an inverse problem with 500 unknowns, the computation of the gradient would take up to 50 s when a difference quotient scheme is used. Hence, fast analytic methods are required. One analytic method to compute the derivatives from an underlying differential equation problem is the adjoint variable approach [48]. The method can be applied for scalar functions Ψ = Ψ (x, v(x)), (45) (e.g. the computed capacitance) where v(x) is the solution of an underlying system of the form Kv = b.
(46)
Current Reconstruction Algorithms in Electrical Capacitance Tomography
83
In the general case K, v and b also depend on x. Then, the total derivative of the i-th component of the gradient of Ψ is given by T ∂Ψ ∂Ψ ∂v dΨ = dxi + dxi . (47) ∂xi ∂v ∂xi The problem in (47) is the last derivative, where the solution vector v is derived to xi . Taking the derivative of (46) using the chain rule for the left hand side results in ∂K ∂v ∂b v+K = . (48) ∂xi ∂xi ∂xi ∂v With this ∂x can be expressed as the solution of a linear equation system i ∂v ∂b ∂K K = − v. (49) ∂xi ∂xi ∂xi However, the number of operations is still not reduced. Now by defining an adjoint variable vector γ with ∂Ψ T K γ= , (50) ∂v the inner product of (47) can be written as T ∂Ψ ∂v ∂v T =γ K . ∂v ∂xi ∂xi Using the right hand side of (49) for (51), (47) can be written as ∂Ψ ∂b ∂K dΨ = dxi + γ T − v dxi . ∂xi ∂xi ∂xi
(51)
(52)
Since by the fact that with (50) only one equation system more is to solve, the adjoint variable approach convinces with a dramatically reduced amount of computational effort. Applying the adjoint variable approach to the finite element method implementation (40) and the charge method (44) to compute the derivative of the charge measured on the j th electrode (the ith electrode is active) with respect to the permittivity of domain r, results in evaluating ˆi ∂Q ∂bi ∂K T dQi,j = ∂εi,j dε + γ − vi dεk , (53) k j ∂εk ∂εk k where the adjoint problem is given by ∂ nelecj (Kvi )nelecj ∂Q i,j T ˆ i γj = K = . ∂vi ∂vi
(54)
Hence, a method is provided to compute derivatives with high accuracy at the computational cost of solving an additional forward problem.
84
4
M. Neumayer et al.
Reconstruction Algorithms
In this section five reconstruction algorithms mentioned in 2 are explained in more detail. As not all aspects about their details can be explained in this book chapter, we will refer to the original publications. Other overviews about reconstruction methods can be found in and [36] and [37]. The first four algorithms aim on the reconstruction of the permittivity values of the finite elements inside the pipe. The permittivity values of the elements are collected inside the vector ε. Hence, this algorithms can be referred to the class of algorithms that perform a fully tomographic reconstruction. The fifth reconstruction algorithm uses a shape model to reconstruct the contour of an inclusion. Thus, the algorithm performs a parameter estimation. Figure 9 depicts the finite element mesh used for the algorithms. A more detailed view on the electrode (black region) is depicted in figure 9(b). The material values of the finite elements in the interior of the pipe form the elements of the vector ε.
(a) Finite element mesh of the ECT sensor.
(b) Detailed view on one electrode.
Fig. 9. Finite element mesh and detailed view on one electrode.
4.1
Linear Back Projection
To start, we first want to present the maybe most simple class of reconstruction algorithms, which are referred as linear back projection (LBP) methods. A common attribute of all algorithms out of this class is the extensive use of so called sensitivity information and linearisation. As the capacitances C(ε) depend nonlinearly on the permittivity distribution ε, the results of LBP methods can be expected to be in general of lower quality. In fact the reconstruction results of LBP methods are images where one can see the presence of materials. The color value may allow a distinction between different materials but it does not correspond to the permittivity of the material.
Current Reconstruction Algorithms in Electrical Capacitance Tomography
85
LBP methods are based on the simplification, that C(ε) can be approximated by [47] C = Sε, (55) where S is referred as sensitivity matrix. The elements of the sensitivity matrix can be computed by Si,j (k) = μ(k)
Ci,j (k) − Ci,j (ε1 ) ΔCi,j Δε
(56)
where the indices i and j indicate the capacitance for the specific transmitter electrode and the specific receiver electrode and k indices the specific finite element. Ci,j (ε1 ) is the capacitance when the pipe is filled with a material with permittivity ε1 , e.g. the pipe is filled with air. The terms ΔCi,j and Δε are given by ΔCi,j = Ci,j (ε2 ) − Ci,j (ε1 ), (57) Δε = ε2 − ε1 ,
(58)
where Ci,j (ε2 ) denotes the capacitance when the sensor is filled with a material with a permittivity of ε2 , e.g. oil. The capacitance Ci,j (k) denotes the capacitance, when only the material value of pixel (or finite element) k is set to ε2 , while the rest of the material values is set to ε1 . μ(k) in equation 56 is a correction factor which is related to the area of the element k. Hence, the elements of S are similar to normalized derivatives. It becomes clear, that the quality of the reconstruction depends strongly on ε1 and ε2 , as this material values are used for the linearization. I.e. if the linearization is performed for low contrast materials, the reconstruction will fail for high contrast material distributions. The now most simple LBP algorithm is given by ε = S T C,
(59)
where only the transposed of the sensitivity matrix is used to compute ε out of the measured capacitances C. One can imagine, that due to all simplifications, the reconstruction result will be of low quality. Moreover, from a physical point of view the use the transposed of the matrix S is an incorrect approach, as the physical units do not conform. In order to increase the quality of the reconstruction results, schemes like Landweber iteration [27] can be applied. Using the solution of (59), the iteration scheme εk+1 = εk + αk S T (C − SC)
(60)
can be applied, to increase the quality of the reconstruction result, where αk denote a step width. However, as the same sensitivity matrix S is used during the Landweber iterations, the inherent drawback of the the localness of S remains.
86
M. Neumayer et al.
To overcome the iterative behavior of the Landweber method, offline iteration online reconstruction (OIOR) was developed. OIOR is based on the propositon, that the systems xk+1 = Ak xk + B k v
(61)
D k+1 = Ak Dk + B k
(62)
and
xk+1 = Dk v
(63)
will produce the same time series for x, if x0 = D 0 v holds. This can be simply proven by applying complete induction. Based on this proposition, the iterative scheme (60) can be rewritten as εk+1 = εk − αk S T Sεk + αk S T C, = I − αk S T S εk + αk S T C.
(64) (65)
Applying the scheme of equation (62) to equation (65), leads to Ak = T I − αk S S and B k = αk S T . Hence, by (61) the Landweber iteration can be reexpressed by εk+1 = Ak εk + B k C,
(66)
where C equals v and εk = xk . Now using the properties of (63) and setting D0 = S T , a matrix Dk can be found by running equation (62) till convergence occurs. By this, the iteration procedure of the Landweber iteration can be done prior and the OIOR reconstruction algorithm is given by ε = DC,
(67)
where D is the result of (62). Concluding this subsection it can be said that by linear back projection a simple and fast reconstruction algorithm is given, as the reconstruction is performed by a matrix vector multiplication. The algorithm is obtained by using sensitivity information. Thus, for the design of the algorithm only some evaluations (the number of pixels) of the forward problem are necessary. Beside the material values ε1 and ε2 no explicit prior knowledge is used. Hence, the result can be assumed to be of lower quality. 4.2
Optimal Approximations
The reconstruction methods termed optimal approximation (OA) was developed at the Institute of Electrical Measurement and Measurement and Measurement Signal Processing (EMT) in 2007 [7]. In this section we will present optimal first order approximation (OFOA) and optimal second order approximation (OFOA)
Current Reconstruction Algorithms in Electrical Capacitance Tomography
87
techniques. Linear back projection methods take use of sensitivity information to design a function f for determining the material distribution by ε = f (C).
(68)
Now explicit prior knowledge is incorporated. However, one might argue about the appropriateness of using sensitivity information to design the function f . In fact, the question should be: ”What is the optimal function f ?”. An intuitive approach of formulating the problem is by seeking for a function f , that minimizes the difference between the reconstructed material distribution and the real material distribution in a quadratic sense, i.e. f ∗ = arg min ||f (C(ε)) − ε||22 . f
(69)
As it will in general be not possible to find an analytic solution for (69), two steps are necessary, to treat the problem. First, an appropriate function set for f has to be determined. In order to keep the computational complexity of the algorithm at the same level as back projection methods, a logical choice for f is given by ε = P h,
(70)
where the vector h contains the measured capacitances. For the OFOA and the OSOA, h is given by T hOF OA = 1 C1 C2 . . . CN , (71) T 2 . (72) hOSOA = 1 C1 C2 . . . CN C12 C22 . . . CN By the first entry in both vectors at least an affine algorithm is given. In the case of the OSOA the algorithm uses quadratic information. Hence, the algorithm is a nonlinear algorithm. The second step concerns the choice of ε in equation (69). The crux is now given by the fact, that the true material distribution is unknown. However, it is still possible to define a meaningful prior distribution π(ε) for ε. Thus, the specific permittivity distribution is a realization of π(ε). By this two steps it is possible the formulate (69) as a least squares problem of form HP T = E
(73)
where the rows of E are given by the samples of the prior distribution εTi of the prior distribution π(ε) and the rows of H are the corresponding vectors hTi . Thus, P can be computed by −1 P T = HT H HT E = H† E, (74) where H† is referred as Pseudo inverse of the matrix H. The computation of H† is done by singular value decomposition (SVD) for numerical reasons. In addition
88
M. Neumayer et al.
also the prior knowledge about the measurement noise can be incorporated, by taking multiple use of a material pattern εi in E and applying noisy realizations of hi in H. For the generation of samples εi from the distribution π(ε) several ways are possible. A possible way is to generate samples of π(ε) by means of Markov Chain Monte Carlo methods. However, a more simple way to generate samples is given by directly drawing realizations of the assumed material distribution. I.e. for material distributions mostly consisting of circular objects, a simple method is to arbitrarily place circular objects inside the domain Ω. Algorithm 1 lists the computational steps for the sampling procedure to generate a pattern. Algorithm 1. Algorithm to obtain samples εi and hi . 1: 2: 3: 4: 5: 6: 7: 8: 9: 10: 11:
Define a grid and set all elements to one Draw #incl ∼ U(1, #max incl ) for k = 1 to #incl do Draw [xcenter , ycenter ] ∼ U (in ROI) Draw ε ∼ U(εmin , εmax ) Draw rincl ∼ U(rmin , rmax ) Create an inclusion out of the parameters and place it on the grid end for Set all grid elements outside ROI to zero Map the distribution from the grid onto the finite element mesh (gives ε) Compute the forward problem to obtain the capacitances
(a) Rod like data.
(b) Gaussian data.
Fig. 10. Possible realizations of the sample data obtained by algorithm 1.
The procedure listed in algorithm 1 produces rod like prior data. Hence, sharp material boundaries are assumed in the training data. If one is interested in
Current Reconstruction Algorithms in Electrical Capacitance Tomography
89
smooth material transitions, one can replace the rods by Gaussian bumps. A possible way is to use the sampled radius as for the full with half peak (FWHP) value of the Gaussian bump to characterize the material distribution. Figure 10 depicts two realizations of the sampling algorithm for rod like data and for Gaussian bumps. By this, the matrices H and E can be assembled and by solving (73) for P the reconstruction matrix is found. To further increase the image quality, (70) can be modified to ε = P h − (P h0 − 1),
(75)
where h0 contains the measurements of the capacitances for an empty pipe. Thus, an offset correction is performed. Finally, local non feasible solutions (i.e. εr < 1) can be replaced to feasible material values. Concluding this subsection it can be stated that optimal approximation techniques are a statistical approach to obtain a reconstruction algorithm of the same computational cost as linear back projection methods. The computation of the projection matrix P is of higher computational cost, as sampling techniques are necessary. However, by this design prior knowledge can be incorporated. Hence, the quality of the results should be increased. In section 2 we stated that optimal approximation techniques are in general not suitable for parameter estimation tasks. This of course will be true for higher dimensional representations like shape models. However, if for example the fill level of a fluid in a horizontal mounted pipe should be determined, optimal approximation techniques would be a very suitable approach. 4.3
Nonlinear Iterative Methods
As the forward problem of ECT is of nonlinear nature, nonlinear reconstruction methods are in general better suited to provide reconstruction results of high quality compared to linear algorithms. A common reconstruction approach for nonlinear methods is to formulate the inverse problem as an optimization problem of form [32], [33] ε∗ = arg min ||C(ε) − C meas ||22 + αR(ε) . (76) ε
The first part in equation (76) is referred as misfit, as it describes the misfit between the current model output C(ε) and the measured data C meas . The second term is a so called regularization term. As the inverse problem has an illposed nature, the direct minimization of the misfit term would lead to completely wrong results. Hence, the regularization term acts as an penalization term in (76). The design of the regularization term R(ε) depends on the available prior knowledge about the material distribution. An often used approach is referred as Tikhonov regularization [35], where R(ε) is of form R(ε) = ||Lε||22 .
(77)
90
M. Neumayer et al.
In the most simple case, the regularization matrix L is chosen to be the identity matrix. In this case, the regularization penalizes large permittivity values. An other approach is to apply some smoothness assumption on the solution [32]. In this case the matrix L is a discrete version of the Laplace operator. If one is interested in reconstructing sharp material boundaries, methods like total variation (TV) can be used. However, they have the disadvantage of changing (76) to become a nonsmooth optimization problem. The weight between minimizing the measurement term and the regularization term is controlled by the regularization parameter α. The choice of α is critical, as a too large value of α means, that the result is mostly affected by the regularization, whereas a too low value of α means an unstable solution due to the ill-posedness. A method to determine an appropriate value for α is the so called L-curve criterion [29]. Hereby, log(||C(ε) − C meas ||22 ) is plotted versus log(||Lε||22 ) for different values of α. The resulting curve has sometimes a distinct corner called L-curve corner. Regularization parameters in the region of the L-curve corner are known to be good candidates for the regularization. Also adaptive methods of the form α = α0
||C(εr ) − Cmeas ||22 ||Lεr ||22
(78)
have been suggested [42]. By this, the regularization parameter is adapted by the ratio between the misfit term and the regularization term. α0 in equation (78) denotes a weighting factor that is set for one time. In general any optimization algorithm can be used to minimize (76). A very powerful class of optimization algorithms is given by second order methods or Newton methods. The term ”Newton method” is assigned to a class of optimization algorithms which take use of the second derivative of the objective function. Quadratic functions can be formulated as 1 Ψ (x + p) = Ψ (x) + gT p + pT Gp, 2
(79)
where x is the vector containing the optimization variables and p is any arbitrary vector. g is the gradient and G the Hessian [20]. To minimize Ψ a descent direction s can be found by applying the first optimality condition ∂Ψ = g + Gp = 0. ∂p
(80)
p = −G−1 g,
(81)
s = p,
(82)
Therefore, with
the search direction
is found, which leads to a fast decrease of (76) compared to steepest descent methods, where s = −g is used.
Current Reconstruction Algorithms in Electrical Capacitance Tomography
91
A special variant of Newton Methods forms the Gauss-Newton method, which offers some distinct advantages with respect to (76). The Gauss-Newton method is a Newton method for objective functions of type Ψ=
m
ri (x)2 = rT r.
(83)
i=1
Defining the Jacobian matrix J as J = ∇r1 ∇r2 . . . ∇rm ,
(84)
the gradient and Hessian can be written as [20] g = 2Jr,
(85)
and G = 2JJT + 2
m
ri ∇2 ri .
(86)
i=1
Since the residuals are minimized the second term in (86) can be neglected and a reasonable approximation for G is given by G ≈ 2JJT .
(87)
With this an iteration step of the Gauss-Newton method is given by the operations −1 Jr, (88) x(k+1) = x(k) − JJT where k denotes the iteration index. Applying the Gauss-Newton scheme to (76), ends up in −1 εk+1 = εk − s JJT + αLT L J r k + LT Lεk ,
(89)
where the residual vector r is defined as r k = C(εk ) − C meas .
(90)
s in equation (89) is the step width of a line search parameter [20]. A line search is in general necessary, as the approximation of the Hessian and the gradient are only local approximations of the derivatives of (76). A further improvement of the reconstruction result can be achieved by taking care to physical constraints of the permittivity values. The relative permittivity can never become smaller than one and in most cases knowledge about the upper value of ε is available. Hence, the unconstrained optimization problem (76) becomes an optimization problem with inequality constraints. A method to take care to this constraints is called Active Set Method [20]. Another approach
92
M. Neumayer et al.
which allows to take care to the lower bound of the permittivity, is to replace ε by [15] ε = eε˜ + 1 , (91) and perform the optimization problem for the new variable ε˜. Summarizing the properties of nonlinear iterative methods it can be stated that the used approach forms a very flexible method to solve inverse problems of different kind and/or for different descriptions. E.g. also shape models in combination with boundary element methods have been implemented to solve the inverse problem of ECT by this method [41]. As the minimization of the cost functional is in general done by iterative method, the computation time for the solution is high compared to the previous methods. However, by the use of second order optimization methods in general only a few number of iterations are necessary to obtain appropriate results. Due to the linearization, nonlinear iterative methods offer the probability to reconstruct material distributions with high contrast ratios (e.g. oil bubbles in water), where linear algorithms generally fail. 4.4
Kalman Filters
Another class of algorithms which can be used to solve the inverse problem of ECT belongs to the class of recursive Bayesian algorithms. In particular the Kalman filter and Particle filter [16] methods belong to this class of algorithms. In principle this class of algorithms uses temporal information taken from measurements and a process model for estimating the desired quantity, or to be more precise the state of the model. Hence, mostly state space models are used as process models and the referred algorithms treat the state variables as random variables. Although the inverse problem of ECT is a nonlinear problem, the estimation of states was traditionally developed on linear models. Therefore, we will also start with linear systems of form xk+1 = Fk xk + wk ,
(92)
yk = Hk xk + vk .
(93)
Equation (92) and (93) form a linear time variant state space model for an autonomous system. Fk is refereed as system matrix and describes the evolution of the current state vector xk towards its new value xk+1 . wk is the so called process noise, which can be seen as a random input for the system. While equation (92) describes the dynamic evolution of the process, equation (93) describes the relation between the measurements yk and the current state vector xk by the matrix Hk . Hence, equation (93) is referred as measurement equation. vk describes additional additive measurement noise. ˆ k for the true State estimation refers now to the task to find an estimate x state xk using temporal information from measurements and the prior knowledge about the evolution of the state. In the following a very short introduction about
Current Reconstruction Algorithms in Electrical Capacitance Tomography
93
the Kalman [46] filter is presented. For detailed informations we refer to [49]. In 1960 R. Kalman presented a recursive filter scheme that provides an estimator that was designed by the claim ˆ )2 , min E (x − x (94) ˆ x
where E denotes the expectation. The resulting filter is known as the Kalman Filter. By (94) the Kalman filter minimizes the expectation of the quadratic error. The filter equations are given by ˆ k−1 x∗k = Fk x P∗k = Fk Pk−1 FTk + Qk −1 Kk = P∗k HTk Hk P∗k HTk + Rk ˆ k = x∗k + Kk (yk − Hk x∗k ) x Pk = (I −
Kk Hk ) P∗k .
(95) (96) (97) (98) (99)
For the derivations, Kalman assumed that all noise processes and the state vector are Gaussian distributed random variables, which means that they can be described by the mean and the covariance matrix. For the measurement noise vk and the process noise wk zero mean is assumed. Thus, measurement noise and the process noise are fully determined by the covariance matrix Rk and Qk . For example, π(v k ) is given by 1 T −1 π(v k ) ∝ exp − v k Rk v k . (100) 2 The matrix P∗k in equation (96) is the covariance matrix of the predicted state x∗k . ˆ k denotes the (final) estimation of the state using the actual measurement yk x ˆ k is denoted by Pk (equation (99)). (equation (98)). The covariance matrix of x As the covariance matrix Pk provides information about the uncertainty of the estimation result, a benefit the Kalman filter is, that it provides information about the quality of the result. Thus, although the filter scheme is an deterministic algorithm by the definition made in subsection 2.2, the Kalman filter provides statistical information. The Kalman filter given by the equations (95) to (99) estimates the state x of a linear dynamic system. To apply the Kalman filter to the nonlinear and ill posed-inverse problem of ECT some extensions to the vector y k and the matrices Rk and H k have to be made [50]. These extensions are mainly to incorporate a regularization and to deal with the nonlinearity. With εr replacing the state vector x the augmented measurement vector is given by C meas,k yk = . (101) 0
94
M. Neumayer et al.
Thus, the approach first seeks for an estimate, which minimizes the misfit between the measurement and the actual model output. With the augmented measurement equation J k (ε∗k ) , (102) H= αL the augmentation of (101) by 0 affects the claim to minimize the regularization term. Hence, the approach is similar to the nonlinear approach given by equation (76). J k denotes the Jacobian. By the augmentation of the measurement vector, also the covariance matrix Rk has to be adapted. This is typically done by Rv,k 0 , (103) Rk = 0 σ2 I where Rv,k is the covariance matrix of the measurements C meas,k and σ2 is typically chosen as the mean of the variances of the measurements [30]. To overcome the nonlinearity, an extended form of the Kalman filter is implemented [49]. Thus, the update equation (98) is replaced by C(ε∗r,k ) ˆr,k = ε∗r,k + Kk yk − ε , (104) αLε∗r,k forming an extended version of the Kalman filter. For the system matrix F often the identity matrix I is used. Thus, the system equation (92) is set to a random walk model. One might argue about the appropriateness of the use of Kalman filters, as this type of state estimators were designed for estimation tasks when dealing with dynamical systems. However, we applied the algorithm in order to demonstrate its applicability. A possible method to obtain a system matrix F which provides information about the dynamic behavior, is to use the search direction given by equation (82) for its design. As the extended Kalman filter does not incorporate any state constraints, the results produced by it may be infeasible. The incorporation of the physical constraints of the relative permittivity can be done by a method called maximum probability method [45]. The maximum probability method seeks for a state x by maximizing its probability to certain constraints. In the case of Kalman filtering the probability of the estimated state is given by the a-posteriori covariance matrix P . The correct state is found by solving minx (x − x∗ )T P −1 (x − x∗ ) s.t. bl ≤ x ≤ bu
(105) (106)
As x∗ is constant the problem can be written as minx xT P −1 x − 2x∗ T P −1 x s.t. bl ≤ x ≤ bu which is a simple quadratic programming problem.
(107) (108)
Current Reconstruction Algorithms in Electrical Capacitance Tomography
95
To conclude this section it has to be said, that the behavior of the Kalman filter is typically very similar to the nonlinear iterative methods. Basically, the minimization problem is formulated as a state estimation problem, to apply the Kalman filter. Hence, the Kalman filter can also be used for different representations. However, as the first of the presented algorithms, the Kalman filter provides information about the quality of the estimation result. This of course has to be treated carefully, as the inverse problem of ECT is a nonlinear problem and the Kalman filter was developed for linear models. 4.5
Markov Chain Monte Carlo
The previous presented algorithms provide a single point estimate for the material distribution. As a first algorithm, the Kalman filter has in principle the possibility to quantify the quality of the result. However, the Kalman filter is based on the assumption, that all processes are Gaussian. One can imagine, that this assumption will not correspond to the true distribution. In contrast to this point estimators, the now presented algorithm does not provide a single point estimate. It rather presents the result in form of a full probability density function (pdf). Statistical inversion theory is based on the evaluation of Bayes law of probability, which was given by equation (30) as p(εr |d) =
p(d|εr )p(εr ) ∝ p(d|εr )p(εr ). p(d)
The attractiveness of statistical inversion lies in several facts: • • • •
The approach is applicable to any forward problem. No derivatives have to be computed. Available prior knowledge can be incorporated in a natural way. Information about the measurement noise can be added in the same natural way. • The result is a probability density function. Hence, complete information about the uncertainty of the result is available. As we only want to demonstrate the aspects and the easy applicability of statistical inversion theory we keep our explanations more on an application level to use statistical inversion theory. For detailed informations we refer to [23]. In order to switch to the nomenclature used in the previous sections we replace the data d by the measurements C meas . Further we replace the material distribution εr by a more general representation which we term θ. Hence, equation (30) becomes p(θ|C meas ) =
p(C meas |θ)p(θ) ∝ p(C meas |θ)p(θ), p(C meas )
(109)
where again p(θ) is termed the prior, p(C meas |θ) denotes the likelihood, p(C meas ) denotes the evidence and p(θ|C meas ) is the posteriori distribution.
96
M. Neumayer et al.
Thus, rather than providing a single point estimate, it is possible to obtain a probability density function (pdf) of the posteriori distribution. Hence statistical inversion theory provides more information about the solution. The drawback of this information gain, is the drastically increased computational burden. As an analytic evaluation of (109) can become uncalculable in the case of complex forward problems or higher dimensional spaces, a sampling scheme has to be applied to obtain a sampled solution of the posteriori distribution. Thus, in general a large number of evaluations of the forward problem is necessary. As in higher dimensional spaces also the visualization and interpretation of the posteriori distribution becomes impossible, characteristics or point estimates have to be computed out of the density function. Such point estimates are for example the maximum a posteriori (MAP) estimate θMAP = arg max π(θ|dm ),
(110)
or the conditional mean θCM =
θπ(θ|dm )dθ.
(111)
It should be mentioned, that for Gaussian processes, the MAP estimate equals the result of a least squares approach [23]. Thus, a certain link between statistical and deterministic methods exists. For further explanations, the terms of Bayes law have to be discussed in more detail. Evidence: The evidence p(C meas ) is the pdf of the measured data and thus representing the marginal density function of the likelihood. Thus the computation of the evidence is only possible in low dimensional spaces. For higher dimensional spaces the computation becomes untraceable. However, the evidence has only the role of a normalization constant, which normalizes the posteriori distribution. Hence, the evidence can be skipped resulting in the reduced formula in equation (30) and (109). Likelihood: The likelihood p(C meas |θ) is assigned to be a probability density function, which expresses the probability that the measurements C meas are caused by the material distribution represented by θ. In other words, the likelihood answers the question ”How likely is it, that θ causes the measured capacitance values?”. Thus, the likelihood quantifies the misfit e = C meas − C(θ), which can be understood as the noise (compare with equation (93)). Hence, the likelihood is in essential the pdf of the measurement noise. I.e. in the case of additive Gaussian measurement noise, the likelihood is given by 1 π(C meas |θ) ∝ exp − eT Σ −1 e , (112) 2 where Σ denotes the covariance of the measurement noise. Estimators which maximize the likelihood are called maximum likelihood (ML) estimators. However, the ML estimate may lead to infeasible solutions, i.e. θ represents
Current Reconstruction Algorithms in Electrical Capacitance Tomography
97
a material distribution with relative permittivity values smaller 1, or material boundaries which lie outside the problem domain. Prior: The prior distribution p(θ) forms a key issue for the success full application of statistical inversion theory. By the prior it is possible to incorporate statistical knowledge about θ. The most simple prior is given by only evaluating the permissibility of θ, i.e. p(θ) = 0 for distributions θ which are infeasible and p(θ) = 1 for any valid distribution. By this, infeasible solutions are effectively neglected. An estimator which maximizes the posteriori, is called a maximum a posteriori (MAP) estimator. For the simple 0/1 prior the MAP estimator is in essential an ML estimator which avoids infeasible solutions. Using this simple prior the quality of the estimator is increased. However, by the choice of more specific priors it is possible to build highly effective estimators, which can be used to reconstruct complex material distributions θ. More information about the choice of prior distributions will be given later. Posteriori: The distribution p(θ|C meas ) is called the posteriori distribution. In essential the posteriori distribution gives answer to the question ”Given the prior π(θ), how likely is it, that θ causes the measured capacitance values?”. Hence, the posterior distribution provides statistical information about the probability of θ. Summarizing the explanation of the terms in Bayes law, it provides a systematic approach to quantify the probability for θ being the solution of the reconstruction task. However, so far Bayes law only provides the possibility to compute the posteriori probability p(θ|C meas ) of a, now called candidate, θ. To obtain a posteriori distribution Bayes law has to be evaluated for a large number of candidates. For lower dimensional spaces sometimes a grid based exploration of the posteriori distribution is possible. In the case of higher dimensional spaces this approach may become impossible or leads to unacceptable high computation times. Thus, the efficient exploration of the posteriori distribution π(dm |θ) becomes the major computational aspect when dealing with Bayesian methods. An efficient class of algorithms to solve Bayesian inference problems are so called Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods. The basic idea of MCMC can be found in a number of text books, e.g. [23]. The maybe most prominent algorithm out of the class of MCMC type algorithms is the Metropolis Hastings (MH) algorithm [40]. The basic idea is presented in algorithm 2. As by line 5 in algorithm 2 the evaluation of the forward problem becomes necessary, the high computational costs of statistical methods become clear. The principle of Bayesian inversion theory has been explained so far. However, for practical implementations in ECT some details about the the representation θ, the generation of proposal candidates θ and the design of priors π(θ) are
98
M. Neumayer et al.
Algorithm 2. Basic Structure of MH MCMC 1: Pick a valid initial candidate θ and compute the prior π(θ) and the likelihood π(C meas |θ) 2: for i = 1 to NM CM C do 3: Generate a proposal candidate θ 4: if π(θ ) > 0 then meas |θ )π(θ ) 5: Evaluate the MH acceptence ratio α(θ, θ ) = min 1, π(C π(C meas |θ)π(θ)
6: Draw u ∼ U(0, 1) 7: if u < α(θ, θ ) then 8: θ = θ 9: π(θ) = π(θ ) 10: π(C meas |θ) = π(C meas |θ ) 11: end if 12: end if 13: end for
necessary. The previous explained reconstruction algorithms aimed on reconstructing the material values of the individual finite elements within the pipe. For the statistical approach presented in this subsection, we want to demonstrate an approach using a shape representation. Hence, the approach is able to reconstruct sharp material transitions. In the further we will give a short introduction about the three missing topics. Shape models: For the first a decision for an appropriate shape model θ has to be made. Figure 7 already depicted an exemplary shape to represent the closed contour of an inclusion. In principles, it would be sufficient to store the coordinates of the corner points to build a shape description. However, a number of methods were developed, which can be used to represent closed contours, e.g. • • • •
Fourier models [44]. Spline representations. Radial basis functions [21]. Level set methods [25].
Level set functions may be a less appropriate shape description in concern with statistical inversion theory, as they were initially invented to describe the evolution of shapes. However, we stated them for completeness. When using the finite element method for solving the forward problem, the contour has to be mapped onto the permittivity values of the finite elements. This mapping causes an additional approximation error, as the obtained permittivity distribution on the finite elements will in general never correspond exactly to the contour. In the case of a boundary element method, the contour can be directly used. Generation of candidates: The generation of a proposal candidate θ out of the current candidate θ becomes one major issue when implementing
Current Reconstruction Algorithms in Electrical Capacitance Tomography
99
a sufficient MCMC methods. Concerning with shape reconstructions, the generation of a proposal candidate is refereed as move [22]. Figure 11 depicts the so called corner move. The idea of the corner move is to randomly
Fig. 11. Exemplary move to generate a proposal candidate θ .
pick a corner point of the shape and then to change the position randomly. In essential, this is the only move necessary to obtain a Markov Chain which reaches an equilibriums distribution. This comes by the fact, that by the corner move every possible shape can be generated out of the initial shape. However, to increase the performance additional moves like rotation, transition or scaling [22] are mandatory. Prior distributions: The last point to explain more in detail concern the choice of the prior distribution π(θ). As already mentioned, the most simple prior is given by only rejecting infeasible solutions. We only want to explain here one more specific prior given by 1 c(θ) π(θ) ∝ exp − 2 −1 I(θ) (113) 2σpr 2 Γ (θ)π where c(θ) denotes the circumference and Γ (θ) denotes the area of the inclusion. I(θ) forms the prior proving the feasibility of θ. Hence, this prior aims on the ratio of the circumference of the inclusion with respect to the circum2 ference of a circle with the same area as the inclusion. σpr is the variance, by which this ratio can can be controlled. To conclude this subsection it has again to be mentioned, that MCMC methods form a simple way to solve inverse problems of any kind. The major advantage of the method is the fact, that by the posterior distribution an evaluation of the quality of the result becomes possible. Also the fact that available prior knowledge can be incorporated in a natural way make the method attractive.
100
M. Neumayer et al.
The major drawback of the approach is the increased computation time due to the necessity of using a sampling technique to obtain the posterior distribution.
5
Reconstruction Results
This section provides reconstruction results for some of the presented algorithms. Figure 12 depicts a photography of the real material distribution. Several plastic rods and pipes have been placed inside the sensor. The gray colored objects are PVC rods, with a relative permittivity of εr = 3.5. The white colored rod is of another material, which has a slightly lower permittivity. The pipe is out of teflon which has a permittivity of about 2.2. As the material distribution is of complex nature, the tomographic algorithms using volumetric descriptions are preferable for the reconstruction. An algorithm for shape reconstruction would not be suitable for this material distribution. Hence, to demonstrate the ability of statistical inversion theory, we will demonstrate the reconstruction of a single inclusion.
Fig. 12. Photography of the real distribution.
Figure 13 depicts the reconstruction result obtained by the OIOR algorithm. Figure 14 depicts the result obtained by OFOA and OSOA. As both algorithms are out of the class of back projection methods and thus having the same computational costs, it makes sense to compare this results. The result obtained by the OIOR is a strongly blurred image. One can imagine that inclusions are situated in the lower part of the pipe. However, it is not possible to say something more about the specifics of the material distribution. Also the drawback of the decreased sensitivity in the center of the pipe and the fact, that for the design of the OIOR no prior knowledge was used comes fully to hand. In comparison
Current Reconstruction Algorithms in Electrical Capacitance Tomography
101
Fig. 13. Reconstruction result obtained by the OIOR algorithm.
the four results obtained by the OFOA and the OSOA offer results of increased quality. Although the OFOA is not able to reconstruct the interior of the teflon pipe. However, the air region on the right side of the half circle formed PVC rod is visible. Compared to the OIOR algorithm, the images firstly allow to interpret the distribution. The two results obtained by the OSOA clearly demonstrate the increased quality due to the nonlinear approach. The teflon pipe is now clearly visible. One can also see, that the choice of the prior distribution (rod like or Gaussian). The reconstructed permittivity distributions for the OFOA and the OSOA are higher compared to the real material values. Summarizing one can say, that the use of prior knowledge can help to highly increasing the quality of the reconstruction result. Figure 15 depicts the reconstruction result obtained by the nonlinear method. Compared to the results obtained by the OSOA, the quality is slightly increased. The result contains no artifacts in the upper region of the pipe as they can be seen in the results obtained by the OFOA and the OSOA. However, as the nonlinear method is based on an iterative algorithm, the reconstruction time increase by a factor of about 105 . The resluts obtained by the Kalman Filter are very similar to that of the nonlinear method. Hence, they are not depicted. Figure 16 depicts the result obtained by applying statistical inversion to reconstruct an elliptic object. Figure 16(a) depicts the conditional mean and the MAP-estimate as point estimates of the reconstruction result. One can see good accordance to the real distribution. As mentioned, a least squares estimator would also provide the MAP estimate for Gaussian processes. Hence, with an deterministic approach using a suitable shape model the same result could be obtained. The big advantage of statistical inversion theory is offered in figure 16(b). The so called scatter plot depicts randomly chosen points of the shape model. Hence, out of the variance of the scatter plot one can quantify the uncertainty of the point estimates.
102
M. Neumayer et al.
1
(a) OFOA with rod like data.
(b) OFOA with Gaussian data.
(c) OSOA with rod like data.
(d) OSOA with Gaussian data.
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
Fig. 14. Reconstruction result obtained by the OFOA and OSOA algorithm.
Current Reconstruction Algorithms in Electrical Capacitance Tomography
1
2
103
3
Fig. 15. Reconstruction result obtained by the nonlinear algorithm.
True Object MAP CM
(a) Conditional mean and MAP estimate.
(b) Scatter plot.
Fig. 16. Reconstruction result obtained by statistical inversion.
6
Conclusion
In this book chapter several reconstruction algorithms for ECT have been presented. The palette reached from linear methods which are suitable for real time applications, to nonlinear methods which offer increased possibilities, to fully statistical methods, which not only provide the single reconstruction result but a statistic about the solution of the problem. The chapter started with an introduction about ECT, containing physical aspects about the electrical effects within the sensor, different measurement principles as well as calibration schemes. In section 2 we tried to define a classification
104
M. Neumayer et al.
scheme for reconstruction algorithm based on the representation of the reconstructed data. By this we wanted to demonstrate that, although the presented algorithms perform a full tomographic reconstructions, some of the presented methods offer the probability for parameter reconstruction tasks. Section 3 presented some numerical tools. In section 4 five algorithms are presented in more detail. Finally some reconstruction results are presented for real measurement data.
References 1. Feynman, R.P.: Feynman Lectures On Physics (3 Volume Set). Addison-Wesley Longman, Amsterdam (1998) 2. Olmos, A.M., Carvajal, M.A., Morales, D.P., Garcia, A., Palma, A.J.: Development of an Electrical Capacitance Tomography system using four rotating electrodes. Sensors and Actuators A: Physical 148(2) (2008) 3. Hadamard, J.: Sur les problmes aux drives partielles et leur signification physique, pp. 49–52. Bull. Univ. of Princeton (1902) 4. Soni, N.K., Paulsen, K.D., Dehghani, H., Harov, A.: Finite Element Implementation of Maxwell’s equations for image reconstruction in electrical impedance tomography. IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging 25(1), 55–66 (2006) 5. Wegleiter, H., Fuchs, A., Holler, G., Kortschak, B.: Analysis of hardware concepts for electrical capacitance tomography applications. In: Proceedings of the IEEE Sensors Conference, vol. 7(3), pp. 436–519 (2005) 6. Wegleiter, H.: Low-Z Carrier Frequency Front-End for Electrical Capacitance Tomography Applications, Ph.D. thesis, Graz University of Technology, Austria (2006) 7. Zangl, H., Watzenig, D., Steiner, G., Fuchs, A., Wegleiter, H.: Non-Iterative Reconstruction for Electrical Tomography using Optimal First and Second Order Approximations. In: World Congress on Industrial Process Tomography WCIPT5 (2007) 8. Neumayer, M., Steiner, G.: Impact of Wave Propagation Effects in Electrical Tomography. In: Proc. of the Conference on the Computation of Electromagnetic Fields, Compumag (2009) 9. Neumayer, M., Steiner, G.: Industrial Process Tomography for Complex Impedance Recostruction. In: Proc. of the 13th International IGTE Symposium (2008) 10. Zangl, H., Neumayer, M.: A Fast Gain Invariant Reconstruction Method for Electrical Tomography. In: Proc. of the 14th International IGTE Symposium (2010) 11. Neumayer, M., Watzenig, D., Zangl, H.: An H∞ Approach for Robust Estimation of Material Parameters in ECT. In: World Congress on Industrial Process Tomography WCIP6 (2010) 12. Neumayer, M., Of, G., Schwaigkofler, A., Steinbach, O., Steiner, G., Watzenig, D.: Shape Determination in ECT using an Energy Norm Formulation. In: Proc. of the 14th international IGTE symposium (2010) 13. Watzenig, D., Brandner, M., Steiner, G.: A particle filter approach for tomographic imaging based on different state-space representations. Jnl. of Measurement Science and Technology 18(30) (2007) 14. Schwarzl, C., Watzenig, D., Fox, C.: Estimation of contour parameter uncertainties in permittivity imaging using MCMC sampling. In: 5th IEEE Workshop on Sensor Array and Multichannel Signal Processing (2008)
Current Reconstruction Algorithms in Electrical Capacitance Tomography
105
15. Steiner, G., Watzenig, D.: Electrical Capacitance Tomography with physical bound constraints. In: SICE Annual Conference (2008) 16. Simon, D.: Optimal State Estimation: Kalman, H-infinity, and Nonlinear Approaches. John Wiley & Sons, Chichester (2006) 17. Process Tomography Limited url: http://www.tomography.com/ (visited on 30.9.2010) 18. Yang, W.Q., Spink, D.M., York, T.A., McCann, H.: An image-reconstruction algorithm based on Landweber’s iteration method for electrical-capacitance tomography. Jnl. of Measurement Science and Technology 10 (1999) 19. Yan, H., Shao, F.Q., Wang, S.: Fast calculation of sensitivity distributions in capacitance tomography sensors. Electronics Letters 34(20), 1936–1937 (1998) 20. Fletcher, R.: Practical Methods of Optimization, 2nd edn. John Wiley and Sons Ltd., New York (2001) 21. Uhlii˜r, K., Patera, J., Skala, V.: Radial Basis Function method for iso-line extraction. Elect. Comp. and Informatics, 439–444 (2004) 22. Watzenig, D., Fox, C.: A review of statistical modelling and inference for electrical capacitance tomography. Jnl. of Measurement Science and Technology 20(5) (2009) 23. Kaipio, J.P., Somersalo, E.: Statistical and computational inverse problems. Applied Mathematical Sciences, vol. 160. Springer, New York (2004) 24. Brandst¨ atter, B., Holler, G., Watzenig, D.: Reconstruction of inhomogeneities in fluids by means of capacitance tomography. Jnl. for Comp. and Math. Electrical and Electronic Eng. 22, 508–519 (2003) 25. Osher, S., Fedkiw, R.: Level set methods and dynamic implicit surfaces. Applied Mathematical Sciences, vol. 153. Springer, New York (2003) 26. Liu, S., Fu, L., Yang, W.Q., Wang, H.G., Jiang, F.: Prior-online iteration for image reconstruction with electrical capacitance tomography. IEE Proceedings of Science, Measurement and Technology 151(3), 195–200 (2004) 27. Landweber, L.: An iterative formula for Fredholm integral equations of the first kind. American Journal of Mathematics 73(3), 615–624 (1951) 28. Yang, W.: Design of electrical capacitance tomography sensors, Meas. Sci. Technol. 21(4) (2010) 29. Hansen, P.C.: Rank-Deficient and Discrete Ill-Posed Problems. SIAM Monographs on Mathematical Modeling and Computation, vol. 4 (1998) 30. Watzenig, D., Steiner, G., Brandst¨ atter, B.: Managing Noisy Measurement Data by Means of Statistical Parameter Estimation in Electrical Capacitance Tomography. In: Proc. of the 13th International IGTE Symposium (2004) 31. Wegleiter, H.: Low-Z Carrier Frequency Front-End for Electrical Capacitance Tomography Applications, Dissertation, Graz University of Technology (2006) 32. Brandst¨ atter, B., Holler, G., Watzenig, D.: Reconstruction of inhomogeneities in fluids by means of capacitance tomography. Int. Journal for Computation and Mathematics in Electrical and Electronic Engineering (COMPEL) 22(3), 508–519 (2003) 33. Soleimani, M., Lionheart, W.T.: Nonlinear Image Reconstruction for Electrical Capacitance Tomography Using Experimental Data. Meas. Sci. Technol. 16, 1987– 1996 34. Scott, D.M., McCann, H.: Process Imaging for Automatic Control. CRC Press, Taylor & Francis (2005) 35. Tikhonov, A.N., Arsenin, V.Y.: Solutions of Ill-Posed Problems, Washington, DC (1977) 36. Isaksen, O.: A review of reconstruction techniques for capacitance tomography. Measurement Science and Technology 7, 325–337 (1996)
106
M. Neumayer et al.
37. Yang, W.Q., Peng, L.: Image reconstruction algorithms for electrical capacitance tomography. Measurement Science and Technology 14(1) (2003) 38. Zienkiewicz, O.C., Taylor, R.C.: The Finite Element Method, 5th edn. The Basis, vol. 1. Elsevier, Amsterdam (2000) 39. Polycarpou, A.C.: Introduction to the Finite Element Method in Electromagnetics. Synthesis Lectures on Computational Electromagnetics 1(1), 1–126 (2006) 40. Hastings, W.K.: Monte Carlo sampling methods using Markov chains and their applications. Journal Biometrika 57(1), 97–109 (1970) 41. Kortschak, B., Brandst¨ atter, B.: A FEM-BEM approach using level-sets in electrical capacitance tomography. Int. Journal for Computation and Mathematics in Electrical and Electronic Engineering (COMPEL) 24(2), 591–605 (2005) 42. Watzenig, D., Holler, G., Brandst¨ atter, B.: Adaptive regularization parameter adjustment for reconstruction problems. IEEE Transactions on Magnetics 40(2), 1116–1119 (2004) 43. Brebbia, C.A., Telles, J.C.F., Wrobel, L.C.: Boundary Element Techniques: Theory and Applications. Springer, New York (1984) 44. Zahn, C.T., Roskies, R.Z.: Fourier descriptors for plane closed curves. IEEE Transactions on Computers 21(3), 269–281 (1972) 45. Simon, D., Chia, T.L.: Kalman filtering with state equality constraints. IEEE Transactions on Aerospace and Electronic Systems 38(1), 128–136 (2002) 46. Kalman, R.E.: A new approach to linear filtering and prediction problems. Journal Basic Engineering 82, 35–45 (1960) 47. Xie, C.G., Huang, S.M., Hoyle, B.S., Thorn, R., Lenn, C., Snowden, D., Beck, M.S.: Electrical capacitance tomography for flow imaging: system model for development of image reconstruction algorithms and design of primary sensors. In: IEE Proc. Circuits, Devices, Systems, pp. 89–97 (1992) 48. Brandst¨ atter, B.: Optimal design with adjoint state approaches, Ph.D. thesis, Graz University of Technology, Austria (1999) 49. Grewal, M.S., Andrews, A.P.: Kalman Filtering: Theory and Practice Using MATLAB, 2nd edn. Wiley Interscience, Hoboken (2001) 50. Kim, H.C., Kim, K.Y., Park, J.W., Lee, H.J.: Electrical impedance tomography reconstruction algorithm using extended Kalman filter. In: Proceedings of the IEEE International Symposium on Industrial Electronics, ISIE, vol. 3, pp. 1677–1681 (2001)
Non-destructive Control of Metallic Plate with Magnetic Techniques L. Battaglini1, P. Burrascano1, A. Canova2, F. Ficili2, M. Ricci1, D. Rossi3, and F. Sciacca3 1
Università degli Studi di Perugia, Dip. di Ingegneria Industriale 2 Politecnico di Torino, Dip. Di Ingegneria Elettrica 3 AMC Instruments srl, spin-off del Politecnico di Torino
Abstract. Magnetic inspection techniques are nowadays widely used in system for Non-destructive Test (NDT) of various type of application. One of the most important application is the magnetic inspection of metallic object, that use family of sensor (Hall, GMR and coils) sensible to the magnetic flux (Hall and GMR are sensible to intensity of flux, and coils are sensible to the variation of the flux). System based on this techniques, in general, are able to read the sensor and, applying a proper software processing to the data collected, give information about the external an internal state (damage, presence of inclusion) of the object under test. An example of this method is the magneto-inductive inspection of metallic rope, widely used for the inspection of cableways. In this paper we will present a different application of this techniques, were the object that we want to test is a metallic plate (or sheet) and the output of a sensor designed ad-hoc for the application is combined to numerical techniques that can give a visual representation of the state of the object. Keywords: Non-destructive techniques, Magnetic Inspection, Electronic Sensor Design, Software Processing.
1 Introduction The various techniques for Non Destructive Testing of Materials (NDT) (based on electromagnetic sensors, ultrasound, X-ray, thermal, ...) are technologies that still continue their development today, started from the 50s. There is a growing requirement of both manufacturers and end-consumers for an increase in the quality of products, even in the case of large scale productions. The objective is that of obtaining a production which is able to have a complete control of possible defects; this result calls for an exhaustive verification: random inspections, performed by sampling the lot, show to be not adequate for the highest quality levels –even if are adopted sophisticated sampling plans-. The manufacturers move thus to the verification of the entire production by making use of “Online Non Destructive Testing” (Online NDT) techniques. Applying this latter approach to product inspection calls for accuracy, reliability, and the ability to process very large amount of raw data in each time unit (high throughput), in order to be effectively introduced in mass productions. S.C. Mukhopadhyay et al. (Eds.): New Developments and Appl. in Sen. Tech., LNEE 83, pp. 107–122. springerlink.com © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011
108
L. Battaglini et al.
It is possible to apply this approach of Online NDT to a larger and larger variety of types of industrial productions due to the impressive growth, developed in the recent years, of the signal processing capacity. This increased processing power has improved greatly the potential of some of these techniques, enabling them to respond to requests for a constant improvement of efficiency of production processes. In particular this increase in the processing power has allowed the evolution in the direction of a control of the entire production, directly performed into the production line. To obtain useful information from the raw data detected by the sensors, highresolution imaging systems are needed. Moreover systems often have to operate in real time, with limited acquisition times and adverse conditions of signal to noise ratio. A typical example of this approach can be observed in metal industries where Online NDT techniques begins to be adopted even in the case of automotive products or for household appliances: inspection procedures at the end of the line and non subjective, which are capable of detecting both included and surface defects, are currently introduced; they rely on a set of measurements and computer aided decisions. The great complexity of an entire production line monitoring is necessary to consider carefully the project is the system hardware and software processing, optimizing the overall performance of the system. The report presented here, we propose the results of a collaborative work between 1) the Faculty of Engineering, University of Perugia – Campus of Terni, 2) the Faculty of Engineering at Politecnico of Torino and 3) AMC Instruments SrL, a spin-off of Politecnico of Torino. All the skills were complemented at their best: those needed for designing the system architecture, those needed for processing multidimensional data and the skills needed for the realization of a product already engineered for its possible use in a production system. This cooperative work enabled us to develop an applied research study that appears to have excellent potential application. The paper presented here describes the different aspects of this project, motivates the different choices and shows the results that we get by applying the resulting system to a number of particularly significant benchmarks. The paper is organized as follows: in the first part the concept of the system and the realization of the sensor are described. Then are described the interface and the software developed for the processing of the information. Finally, in the last section, are reported and commented on the results of some laboratory measurements for some cases of particular interest. The last section draws some conclusions and indicates the possible development prospects.
2 Concept The basic idea of this work is to develop an electronic system able to detect (and, if possible, characterize) fault present in an manufactured product (in this case is speaking about metallic sheet), using magnetic techniques. A system like this is made by three fundamental block: • • •
Sensing Head (or Sensor) Acquisition System Software (and processing platform)
Non-destructive Control of Metallic Plate with Magnetic Techniques
109
The sensor has the purpose of get the basic information, in the analog domain. This is an hardware block, that has mechanics and electronics components. The electronic components are sensors and other mixed-signal blocks (filters, amplifiers, muxs…). The acquisition system is made basically by an acquisition board, that has the task of convert the information from analog to digital domain, under some specification, in order to make the results usable. This is a digital block, that use programmable logic and A/D converters. Then we have the software, that use a standard support (desktop PC) in order to connect with the previous block. This logic is widely used in automatic measurement system, and is commonly known as PC-based measurement system. The use of a PC-based system reduce the complexity of the acquisition block (acquisition board and software), that in the other case must be designed ad-hoc. The software block has the purpose of use the digital information obtained form the two previous block, in order to provide the final output. This block make an extensive use of numerical algorithim, in order to correctly process the data and obtain easy readable information. Figure 1 shows a basic diagram of the measurement chain.
Fig. 1. Basic block diagram of the system
3 Sensor Topology The firs problem to solve is, of course, how to get the right initial information, or more specifically, how to get a signal (possibly an electrical signal in voltage) that is, somehow, proportional with the presence of a discontinuity in the metallic sheet. The idea is to create a constant magnetic flux orthogonal to the sheet itself. In this condition the presence of a discontinuity (given from a fault or an inclusion) in the material, generate a variation in the flux, displaying the presence of a fault. In order to make the information readable form a standard acquisition system, the signal must be converted from magnet to electrical domain. In order to do this, some Hall effect sensor can be used (the use of Hall sensor instead GMR or Coils will be clarified later on). So the typical setup of this system, use a permanent magnet, with its north pole orthogonal with the sheet and an array of sensor between the magnet and the sheet (see figure 2). This type of configuration allow to reveal this kind of lack: • Discontinuity (holes, abrasions, scratch…) of various type on magnetic plate • Non-magnetic inclusions on magnetic plate • Magnetic inclusions on non-magnetic plate
110
L. Battaglini et al.
Fig. 2. Setup of the sensor. Hall probe are placed between metallic sheet and PM.
Obviously isn’t possible to reveal discontinuity in non-magnetic plate (ex: aluminium plate). Magnetic inclusion in magnetic material can generate little flux variation. The possibility of reveal such variation depends on factor like resolution of sensor and background noise. It’s important to notice that this kind of system born modular, so it can be adapted to sheet of different dimension. So, in order to monitor a sheet of a given dimension (where the dimension is a multiple of the dimension of the sensing head) more sensor can be mounted in modular way (see figure 3).
Fig. 3. Example of a modular system
This is a fundamental aspect for system that, like this, are intended to be used for monitoring object during production cycle.
4 Technological Choiches and Specifications Starting from the idea discussed before, the following step was a proper design of the electronic board of sensing head.
Non-destructive Control of Metallic Plate with Magnetic Techniques
111
Fig. 4. Position of the Array in the reference frame
The sensing head should have the following specification (see figure 4): 1. 2. 3.
Should have a resolution of 1mm in the X direction (refer to figure 4) Should work with a sliding speed of the sheet up to 2m/s (typical on-field speed <= 1m/s) The output should be the “magnetic” image of the total length of the sheet, that is known, so no position sensor are needed
In order to follow this specification the sensor head must have some particular characteristics. First, to obtain a resolution of 1mm in X, each sensor must be read individually, so, since every channel of the acquisition system should read one sensing head, that is made by N sensor (256 in the typical configuration), a multiplexing stage is required. More, every “scan” should be performed as faster as we can, due to the sliding speed of the object in the real application, otherwise the resolution in the Y (refer again to figure 4) direction decrease. This condition can be achieved using an high performance acquisition board, able to operate up to the GS/s. The specification for the output means that this output should be easily readable, so printing a magnetic “image” of the object, where the intensity and colors give immediate information about presence of lack, can be an interesting choice. Based on the specification discussed before, the choice is to develop a sensing head made by two electronic board. The first board is the sensor board, that is populated with the sensor array and a firs multiplexing stage. The second board is the conditioning board that contains the second multiplexing stage and some conditioning electronics. The choice of use two multiplexing stage depend on the fact that the number of sensor per array achieve the hundreds of units, and become difficult to find a device with the proper number of input on the market. For the sensor array we used hall
112
L. Battaglini et al.
effect sensor because this kind of devices are less dependent on speed than coils and have advantages in cost, packaging and range with respect to GMRs that are suitable for different applications.
5 Schematic The prototype made for laboratory test use a sensing head with an array of 256 hall sensor. A group of suitable Hall sensors for this application is the A139x family form Allegro Microsystem. This devices are 3,3V powered hall sensor in a high integrated MLP/DFN-6 package. The use of an high integration package allow to build a sensing head that can reveal down to 1mm fault using just a double array of probe. The family include device of several sensitivity and Bsat (see table below): - A1391, sensitivity = 1.5mV/G, Vpp, Cbypass= 20 mV, Bsat=1050G - A1392 sensitivity = 2.5 mV/G, Vpp, Cbypass= 40 mV, Bsat=700G - A1393 sensitivity = 5 mV/G, Vpp, Cbypass= 40 mV, Bsat=350G - A1395 sensitivity = 10 mV/G, Vpp, Cbypass= 80 mV, Bsat=175G For the first prototype we used the A1391. Figure 5 shows the sensor schematic. Every sensor has its proper low-pass filter, that is a single pole resistive network with a cut frequency of 450 Hz.
Fig. 5. Sensor schematic. The sensor used is an Allegro 1391, in DFN-6 package.
The sensing area of the head is made by a double array of sensor, placed in the middle of the board. The choice of duplicate the array depends on the specification for the resolution on X: to achieve this resolution the only way is to use two shifted parallel array of probe. The output of the filter is directly connected to the mux network. The sensor board is populated with 8 ADG732 analog mux (every mux has 16+16 input channels and 2 output, so every device can be considerate like a 2 separate mux), that can collect all the 256 signal. Every mux of the sensor board is driven by the real clock frequency of the system (that depends on the sliding speed of the plate). The conditioning board collect the output of all the mux of the sensor board, and all the signal are routed to the final multiplexing stage (another ADG732), that output 2 signal corresponding to the relative probe at time. This mux is driven by a frequency that is 1/16 of the acquisition clock (the frequency division in achieved by a commercial timer/counter). Figure 6 illustrates the complete multiplexing procedure. Figure 7 show the connection between sensor and conditioning board.
Non-destructive Control of Metallic Plate with Magnetic Techniques
Fig. 6. Multiplexing stage
Fig. 7. Prototype and connection of sensor (up) and conditioning (down) board.
113
114
L. Battaglini et al.
6 Sensor Interface and Preliminary Tests Although the overall sensor is quite complex, the architecture adopted allows to easily interface it by means of few signals. Figure 9 sketches the sensor inputs and the outputs: beside the +5V required to supply all the active elements, the sensor is completely driven by two digital signals: a single pulse that resets the internal counter followed by a square wave that acts as a clock. The output voltages from the probes are collected into two output analog signals as illustrated in the previous sections. All the signals are processed by a single National Instruments Data Acquisition Card NIUSB 6259 while the hardware management and the data acquisition tasks have been carried out by exploiting the LabVIEW software.
Fig. 8. Schematic diagram of the sensor connections
In general, in order to faithfully retrieve information from all the probes, the ADC sampling rate fADC must be commensurable with the clock frequency fClk. To accomplish this aim in this work we have employed the Clock signal also as External Clock for the ADC conversion assuring the synchronization between switching of the multiplexers and sampling, fADC =fClk. This choice also implies the collection of only one sample for each probe during the sweep of the arrays. Furthermore the Clock square wave contextually acts as enable signal for the conversion process: indeed the number of samples acquired by the DAQ card for any analog input channel is equal to the number of cycles of the square wave. Of course by varying fClk also the resulting sample rate of the single probe fS varies linearly. In particular we had fClk =128×fS. At the same time, fS can not exceeds values that lead to a clock period comparable with the characteristic switching time of the muxes. We have carried out some preliminary tests to check the working conditions of the hardware and software components, some results are reported below. Figure 9 illustrates a typical turn-on time of the sensor reporting the time diagram of the all signals involved.. As expected, at the arrive of the reset pulse there is a discontinuity on the amplitude of the arrays output signals corresponding to the jump of the counter from a random to “0” value. Then, when the clock signal reaches the sensor, the muxes start to interrogate the probes.
Non-destructive Control of Metallic Plate with Magnetic Techniques
115
Fig. 9. Test on synchronization of the input and output signals of the sensor.
Fig. 10. Test on maximum achievable sampling rate with actual multiplexers
Figure 10 illustrates the limitations in the maximum sampling rate achievable by comparing the analog signal from one array for three different fS values. We note that for fS equal or greater than 15 kHz the settling time of the muxes is comparable with the clock period, thus hampering the right collection of the probes signals. We have also measured the effective magnetic field impinging on the different probes: in Figure 11 are reported the steady values of the probe voltages with the permanet magnet adopted in the experiments reported. Since the zero field value of the outputs is of about 1.65 V and the probe sensitivity is of 1.25mV/Gauss, we estimate a mean Bz component near to 400 Gauss at the probes positions.
116
L. Battaglini et al.
Once performed the functional tests of the sensor, we have connected it to a XY motorized scanner, also computer controlled by the Labview software and by the NIUSB6259 card. In this way we have been able to simulate the relative sliding of the metal sheet under the sensor at velocities comparable with the ones typical of the production and we have carried out some resolution tests on artificial defects. Special attention has been paid to synchronize the scanner motion with the clock generation, in order to have a constant resolution during each scan. Moreover the duration of the clock signal was automatically calculated in order to cover a desired sample length. By fixing the scanner velocity vSCAN at vSCAN =0.1 m/s we have performed different tests by varying the Clock rates in order to have fS in the range 0.5-2 kHz corresponding to a spatial sampling between 5 and 20 samples/mm.
Fig. 11. Steady state voltage value of the probes with the permanent magnet adopted (1st array Black, 2nd array - Grey)
Before discussing the results attained on artificial and real samples, let us firstly introduce some details on the signal processing steps implemented in order to reconstruct and enhance the images of the samples investigated.
7 Image Processing The sensor has been designed to work with both ferritic and austenitc steel sheets, i.e. ferromagnetic and paramagnetic materials respectively. In the latter case, the presence of defects consisting of ferromagnetic inclusions a well as locally changes in the crystallographic characteristic of the steels leads to very low variations of the magnetic field (δB/B < 10-3) thus leading to a voltage signal comparable with the noise introduced by electric devices and by the environment. (K. Szielasko, et al 2006, W. S. Singh et al 2008) At the same time, hardware processing on the multiplexer output signal is strongly limited since the information content coming from each probe must be preserved. Moreover the active filtering of each probe is quite onerous and with poor scaling
Non-destructive Control of Metallic Plate with Magnetic Techniques
117
properties. It is therefore necessary to perform some digital processing procedure to enhance the signal to noise ratio of the collected data. To gain insight into the image processing protocol developed, in this section we illustrate all the processing steps by referring to a benchmark sample. In particular, to test the resolution of the sensor we have realized a collection of holes with different diameters D into a ferromagnetic plate 4mm thick. The set consists of six through-holes with D=7,6,5,4,3,2 mm and a single blind-hole with D=1.5mm and 1mm of depth. Adopting the configuration previously described (sensor + XY scanner) , by specifying a scan length L, we attain at the end of the ADC process two rows of data, one for each array, containing a number of samples NS given by the expression NS=128×L×ρ where ρ=fS/vSCAN is the resolution, expressed in samples per millimetres, along the scan direction. By reshaping the two vectors we obtains two matrices, IM1 and IM2, corresponding to the magnetic images collected by the 1st and the 2nd array respectively. These images have a number of pixels, Nx×Ny, equal to: [Nx,Ny]=size(IM1,IM2)= NS=128×(L×ρ). For example, referring to the reference sample, we have chosen the following values: L=250mm, vSCAN=100mm/s, fS=2kHz → ρ= 20 samples/mm, Ny=5000 pixel while the effective lift-off between sample and probes was about 4-5mm.
Fig. 12. a) Photo of the benchmark sample; b) direct acquired “magnetic” image
Due to the different “steady-state” value of each probe (see Fig.11), the images IM1 and IM2 are not directly readable, as shown in Fig.12-b. An AC “software” coupling implemented for any probes separately allows to remove the lines pattern. Once carried out the AC coupling, the new images, IMAC1 and IMAC2, exhibit a more desirable aspect (Fig.13). Nevertheless, as clearly evidenced in the 3D surface plot, they yet suffer the contextual presence of a “Salt&Pepper” noisy component and of a slow background intensity variation. In the present case, for the larger through-holes, such noisy level is quite lower than the signal amplitude but it becomes comparable with the signal of the smaller holes, thus hampering its detection. In order to attenuate such components, we have implemented a 2D band-pass filter in the frequency domain. Indeed the background drift exhibits a spatial frequency spectrum characterized by low wave vector values while the “Salt&Pepper” noise is characterized by highfrequency oscillations.
118
L. Battaglini et al.
Fig. 13. Colormap and 3D surface of the AC-coupled image.
Fig. 14. Colormap and 3D surface of the image form one array after the 2D band-pass filter.
Fig. 15. Colormap and 3D surface of the overall image attained at the end of the processing.
By filtering out a proper range of wave-vectors values, we have significantly reduced these unwanted effects. The effect of the band-pass 2D filter is illustrated in Figure 14. At this step the images of both arrays have been successfully enhanced. The final processing task implemented concerns the increase of the image resolution. This goal is accomplished by :1) merging IMBP1 and IMBP2; 2) performing on the extended
Non-destructive Control of Metallic Plate with Magnetic Techniques
119
image the deconvolution respect than the 2D impulse response of a point-wise defect previously measured. In particular we have exploited the Wiener deconvolution filter in the frequency domain combined with the total variation regularization.(N. Wiener, 1949, Rudin 1992). Figure 15 summarizes the result of the overall processing protocol. We note that: 1) the resolution of the final image, IMTOT was effectively increased respect than the original images; 2) there is a good agreement between photographic and magnetic images; 3) even the blind-hole is clearly detected.
8 Experimental Results Once defined the processing protocol, we have applied it to several images attained from artificial and real samples, both ferritic and austenitic. In the following we report the result regarding few relevant cases. As first testing sample, we have replicated the sequences of through- and blindholes in a austenitic plate 4mm thick. Beside the sequences of aligned hole, we have added some small mechanical punchings near the holes, see Fig.16-a. The result of the scan is reported in Fig.16-b.
Fig. 16. Magnetic image attained for an austenitic plate with through-holes, blind-holes and mechanical punchings.
Due the paramagnetic feature of austenite, the field variations associated to the through-holes are some order of magnitude lower than for the ferritic case. This implied the reduction of the lift-off value as well as a higher attenuation of highfrequency image components. Nevertheless the sensor resolution also allows to detect
120
L. Battaglini et al.
the presence of holes. At the same the blind-holes and the mechanical punchings are clearly detected and visualized. We retain that such quite surprisingly behaviour should be due to the the local variation of the sheet magnetic properties induced by mechanical stress. (Vincent et al. 2005, Wilson et al. 2007)
Fig. 17. Magnetic image attained for a ferritic plate with scratches.
Fig. 18. Magnetic image attained for an austenitic plate with oxide-scales.
Non-destructive Control of Metallic Plate with Magnetic Techniques
121
Fig. 19. Magnetic image attained for an austenitic plate with marks.
9 Conclusions We have designed and realized a sensor able to scan the surface of steel sheets by performing a 2D magnetic image of the sample surface. This image is carried out by exploiting two arrays of Hall probes. An electronic circuit has been realized to easily interface and drive the arrays. Quite generally the data can be affected by several unwanted noises that could require a combination of different filtering and denoising approaches to be effective. In the present application, we combined 2D frequency domain filtering with Wiener deconvolution and Total Variation deblurring. Several alternative strategies can be pursued like wavelet denoising, principal component analysis, etc. (Truchetet and Laligant 2008) .The protocol has been applied to samples having defects with different geometric extension and metallurgic nature. In all the tested cases the algorithm have leaded to a good identification of the defects. In particular, also defects with extension of few mm2 can be detected with a satisfactory signal to noise ratio. Moreover the results obtained evidenced a good correspondence between “magnetic” and “true” image of the samples, therefore such technique could be a valid integration/alternative to standard vision inspection techniques, especially in applications where the environmental noise degrades the vision approach.
Acknowledgment L. Battaglini, P.Burrascano and M. Ricci acknowledge financial supporting by Fondazione Cassa di Risparmio di Terni e Narni.
122
L. Battaglini et al.
References Szielasko, K., et al.: High-Speed, High-Resolution Magnetic Flux Leakage Inspection of Large Flat Surfaces. In: Proceedings of the European Conference on NDT 2006 (2006) Singh, W.S., et al.: Detection of leakage magnetic flux from near-side and far-side defects in carbon steel plates using a giant magneto-resistive sensor. Meas. Sci. Technol. 19, 15702 (2008) Wiener, N.: Extrapolation, Interpolation, and Smoothing of Stationary Time Series. Wiley, New York (1949) Rudin, L.I., Osher, S., Fatemi, E.: Nonlinear total variation based noise removal algorithms. Physica D 60, 259–268 (1992) Vincent, A., et al.: Magnetic Barkhausen noise from strain-induced martensiteduring low cycle fatigue of 304L austenitic stainless steel. Acta Materialia 53, 4579–4591 (2005) Wilson, J.W., Tian, G.Y., Barrans, S.: Residual magnetic field sensing for stress measurement. Sensors and Actuators A 135, 381–387 (2007) Truchetet, F., Laligant, O.: Review of industrial applications of wavelet and multiresolutionbased signal and image processing. J. Electron. Imaging 17, 31102 (2008)
Gas Sensing Characteristics of Pure and ZnO-Modified Fe2O3 Thick Films N.K. Pawar1, D.D. Kajale2, G.E. Patil2, S.D. Shinde3, V.B. Gaikwad3, and Gotan H. Jain2,* 1
K.A.A.N.M.S. Arts, Commerce and Science College, Satana, India 2 Materials Research Lab., Arts, Commerce and Science College, Nandgaon 423 106, India
[email protected] 3 Materials Research Lab., K.T.H.M. College, Nashik 422 005, India
Abstract. Thick films of AR grade Fe2O3 were prepared by screen-printing technique. The gas sensing performances of thick films were tested for various gases. It showed maximum response to H2S gas at 300oC for 200ppm.The films were surface modified by dipping them in a solution of 0.1M zinc acetate for different intervals of time. The modified Fe2O3 films showed enhancement in response to H2S gas at 100ppm than the response to pure Fe2O3 film at comparatively low temperature (200oC). The adsorption-desorption phenomenon is the function of surface misfits and surface morphology of the film. Zinc oxide increases the reactivity of film to H2S gas, suppressing the response to other gases. A systematic study of sensing performance indicates the key role-played by Zinc oxide on the surface. The sensitivity, selectivity, response and recovery time of the sensor were measured and presented. Keywords: Fe2O3 gas sensor, thick film, dipping technique, H2S gas sensor, Sensitivity, Selectivity.
1 Introduction Hydrogen sulphide gas is harmful to human body and environment. The threshold limit value (TLV) defined for H2S is 10 ppm. Human exposure to H2S gas at level higher than 250 ppm are likely to result in neurobehavioral toxicity and may even cause death[1]. Metal oxide semiconductor gas sensors have advantageous features such as high sensitivity under ambient conditions, low cost and simplicity in fabrication [2, 3]. The sensor performance can be improved by increasing the porosity .The fundamental sensing mechanism of metal oxide based gas sensors relies on change in electrical conductivity due to the interaction process between the surface complex such as O-, O2- , H+ , OH+ ,reactive chemical species and the gas molecules to be detected[4]. Semiconductor ZnO is sensitive to many sets of gases and has high satisfactory stability, but it has some disadvantages, such as high working temperature of 4000C–5000C; poor gas selectivity and comparatively low sensitivity. Furthermore, it has also been reported that the gas sensitivity and selectivity of semi conductive complex oxides can be *
Corresponding author.
S.C. Mukhopadhyay et al. (Eds.): New Developments and Appl. in Sen. Tech., LNEE 83, pp. 123–132. springerlink.com © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011
124
N.K. Pawar et al.
influenced by dipping or doping. Some workers discovered that complex oxides exhibit good sensitivity to reducing gases [5, 6]. α- Fe2O3 has non stoichiometric structure and free electron originating from oxygen vacancies contribute to electronic conductivity change when the composition of the surrounding atmosphere is attended. Metal oxide gas sensors are stable at high temperature [7]. Sensing principal is based on the change in the electrical resistance of semiconductor oxide films when specific gas interacts with its surface [8]. Nano Composite of SnO2/ Fe2O3 showed sensitivity to CO, H2S, NO2 and Ethanol [9]. Some reports say α- Fe2O3 form has been recognized as having minimal gas sensing response. ZnO is a very attractive material having a wide band gap. It is one of the most versatile and useful oxide because its typical properties e.g. resistivity control over the range 10-3 – 10–5 ohm cm, direct band gap, absence of toxicity, abundance in nature, high electrochemical stability. Recently, Sun et al. have found that Fe2O3 exhibited is sensitive to H2S based on the catalytic chemiluminescence at 360o C [10, 11]. However, the application of these sensors is limited by some disadvantages, for instance, poor selectivity, long response time, high operating temperature or the limited detection range. Recently, Fe2O3 has been proved to be an important solid state gas sensor. γ- Fe2O3 doped with Zn showed good response to acetone and ethanol (C2H5OH) [12]. αFe2O3 is an n-type semiconductor oxide and has been widely used as gas sensors. However, most of the researches on α- Fe2O3 sensors were focused on the sensing properties towards alcohol. In the present paper the Fe2O3 film was surface modified by ZnO and its performance for different gases was studied. The ZnO- Fe2O3 surface modified film enhanced the sensitivity to H2S gas at comparatively low temperature as compared to sensitivity to pure α-Fe2O3 film. The surface modified film showed maximum response to H2S gas at 2000C, where as the pure film showed maximum response to H2S at 3000C, as well as the selectivity was observed to be increased. Scanning electron microscopy was used to study the microstructure and surface morphology of the films. TGA/DTA was used to characterize the material.
2 Experimental 2.1 Preparation of Fe2O3 Thick Films The AR grade powder of Fe2O3 was calcined at 1000oC for 6h and further milled for 2h. The thixotropic paste was formulated by mixing the fine powder of Fe2O3 with a solution of ethyl cellulose (a temporary binder) in a mixture of organic solvents such as butyl cellulose, butyl carbitol acetate and terpinol etc. The ratio of the inorganic to organic part was kept at 75:25 in formulating the paste. This paste was screen printed on a glass substrate in a desired pattern [13]. The films were fired at 550oC for 30min. Silver contacts were made for electrical measurements. 2.2 Preparation of ZnO Surface Modified Fe2O3 Thick Films The modified Fe2O3 thick films were obtained by dipping pure Fe2O3 thick films in a 0.1M aqueous solution of Zinc acetate for different intervals of dipping time of 5, 10,
Gas Sensing Characteristics of Pure and ZnO-Modified Fe2O3 Thick Films
125
20, 30 and 45min. These films were dried at 80oC, followed by firing at 550oC for 30min. These films so prepared are termed as ‘surface modified films’. 2.3 Details of Gas Sensing System Specially designed gas sensing system was used for sensing of various toxic gases [14]. The sensing setup consisted of glass dome vessel of 25 liter volume. The dome vessel was kept on circular metallic base. Inside the dome the film was mounted where the heating coil was fitted to maintain the temperature. There were electrical feeds through the base plate. The heater was fixed on the base plate to heat the sample under test up to required operating temperatures. A sample under test can be mounted on the heater. The Cr–Al thermocouple was mounted to measure the operating temperature. The output of the thermocouple was connected to a digital temperature indicator. A gas inlet valve was fitted at one of the ports of the base plate. The required gas concentration inside the static system was achieved by injecting a known volume of a test gas with a gas-injecting syringe. A constant voltage was applied to the sensor and the current was measured by digital piccoammeter. Air was allowed to pass into the glass chamber after every gas exposure cycle.
3 Characterization Results 3.1 Microstructural Analysis Scanning electron microscopic (SEM) studies were carried out by using JEOL 6300 (LA) Japan. Figure 1(a-b) depicts the SEM images of an unmodified and ZnOmodified (30min) Fe2O3 thick films fired at 550oC.
(a) Fig. 1. SEM images of: (a) Unmodified, and (b) ZnO-modified (30min) Fe2O3 thick films.
126
N.K. Pawar et al.
(b) Fig. 1. (continued)
3.2 Elemental Analysis The elemental analysis of the films was carried out to know the constituent elements such as Fe, O and Zn associated with various films. It is clear from the Table 1 that the weight percentage of Zn increased with dipping time, reached to a maximum at dipping time 30min and decreased further increase in dipping time. The film with the dipping time of 30min was observed to be more oxygen deficient (22.07). This oxygen deficiency may make the sample possible to adsorb a large amount of oxygen species. Table 1. Elemental analysis of unmodified and ZnO modified Fe2O3 films.
Sample Unmodified Fe2O3 Dipping time (modified) 5 min 10 min 30 min 45 min
Fe (wt %) 77.36
O (wt %) 22.64
Zn (wt %) -
75.32 74.88 69.59 74.30
22.77 22.46 22.07 22.27
1.91 3.05 7.94 3.60
3.3 Thermal Stability of Pure and ZnO Modified Fe2O3 Thick Films Thermo gravimetric analysis (TGA) of pure and surface modified samples was carried out and their profiles are represented in figure 2. Thermo gravimetric analysis (TGA) of the films was conducted in air using Mettler Toledo Star System 851 at a heating rate of 10oCmin-1 in the temperature range from30oC to 900oC. Fig. 2 shows the TGA
Gas Sensing Characteristics of Pure and ZnO-Modified Fe2O3 Thick Films
127
profiles of unmodified (pure) and surface modified (30min) ZnO-Fe2O3 thick films. Table 2 lists losses or gains in weight of these films observed during TGA in the different temperature ranges. It can be concluded from the profiles that the weight of pure sample continuously decreased up to temperature 550oC and then remained constant in the temperature range 550o C to 678oC. It shows smallest weight gain in the temperature range 678oC to 853oC. Surface modified Fe2O3 film was more stable than the pure Fe2O3. The variation in weight with temperature was comparatively a less weight loss and a more weight gain in the surface modified sample which can be attributed to the adsorbed oxygen content. The film with the high amount content of Zn (7.94 wt%) was observed to contain the small amount of oxygen (22.07 wt %, Table 1), which could be attributed to the largest deficiency of oxygen in the film. It is therefore quite possible that the material would adsorb the largest possible amount of oxygen, showing relatively larger gain in weight (7.79 wt%) in the temperature range of 375oC to 900oC. The zinc oxide on the surface modified sample would form misfit regions between the grains of Fe2O3 and could act as efficient catalyst for oxygenation.
Fig. 2. TGA profile of: pure, and ZnO -modified (30min) Fe2O3 thick films. Table 2. Thermal analysis of Unmodified Fe2O3 and surface modified Fe2O3.
Temperature
Unmodified Fe2O3 Loss
Gain
(wt %)
(wt %)
25 - 525
6.25
--
525-765
---
765- 875
--
oC
Temperature
Modified Fe2O3 Loss
Gain (wt
(wt %)
%)
25 - 95
---
0.4
---
95-145
---
---
1.2
145 - 875
--
15.6
oC
128
N.K. Pawar et al.
3.4 Dependence of Electrical Conductivity on Temperature Fig. 3 represents the variation of conductivity with temperature for the pure and ZnO surface modified Fe2O3 samples. The conductivity varied nonlinearly with temperature for all samples, showing negative temperature coefficient.
1000/T(1/oK)
log(conductivity)mho/m
-2.3 1.38
1.58
1.78
-3.3 -4.3
1.98
2.18
2.38
2.58
pure
5min
10min
20min
30min
45min
-5.3 -6.3 -7.3
Fig. 3. Electrical profile of pure and modified Fe2O3 thick films
3.5 Measurement of Sensor Response Gas response of a sensor is defined as the ratio of the conductive change upon exposure to a test gas to the conductance in air
Where Gg and Ga are conductance of a sample in the presence and absence of a test gas respectively and ∆G is the change in conductance. Figure 4 (a) shows that the optimum operating temperature for pure Fe2O3 film is 300oC and Figure 4(b) shows histograms indicating the response values (to H2S gas) of the ZnO surface modified Fe2O3 films treated for different intervals of times. The maximum response was for the sample dipped for 30min. table 1 depicts that the 30 min. dipped sample has the highest 7.94 wt% of Zn. The response to H2S goes on increasing with the amount of Zn, attains its maximum at 7.94 wt% and decreases further. The largest sensitivity in case of the sample with 7.94 wt% of Zn (for 30min.) may be because of more available sites for the oxygen to be adsorbed and in turn to oxidize the test gas. However, the decrease in response may be due to the insufficient number of misfits available in the surface that acts as a catalyst.
Gas Sensing Characteristics of Pure and ZnO-Modified Fe2O3 Thick Films
129
250
sensitivity
200 150 100 50 0 150
200
250
300
350
400
450
Temp. (0C)
(a)
sensitivity
500 pure 10min 30min
450 400 350 300
5min 20min 45min
250 200 150 100 50 0 150
200
250
300 350 Temp.(oC)
400
450
(b) Fig. 4. (a). Variation of H2S gas response to pure Fe2O3 film with operating temperature; (b). Variation in response to H2S gas with temperature for pure and modified Fe2O3 films
3.6 Microstructural Analysis Fig 5 shows the bar diagram indicating the selectivity of the ZnO surface modified Fe2O3 sensor operated at 200oC to H2S gas against CO, LPG, NH3, CO2, Cl2, O2, ethanol and H2 gases. It is evident from the figure that the sensor was highly selective to H2S gas against other gases. The high selectivity to H2S can be attributed to the surface modification of Fe2O3 films. 3.7 Response and Recovery Time Response and recovery times are basic parameters of gas sensors. The response time has been defined as the time taken to attain 90% of final value, and the recovery time as time taken to recover 90% of the original value. the response time and recovery time of surface modified ZnO-Fe2O3 thick film at 200oC are found 4sec. and 46 sec
130
N.K. Pawar et al.
respectively i.e. the 90% response and recovery time were attained within 4sec and 46sec respectively. The very short response and moderate recovery times are the important features of the surface modified ZnO-Fe2O3 sensor.
500 400 300 200 100 0 H2 pure fe2o3
CO
CO2
NH3
LPG
O2
Cl2
Ethan H2S ol
0.023 -0.053 0.141 -0.139 6.692 0.21 0.125 1.389 21.34
ZnO- fe2O3 0.576 -0.006 0.262 0.185 0.189 0.433 0.214 0.272 441.3
Fig. 5. Comparison of gas response of ZnO surface modified film (30min) to different gases at 200OC.
4 Discussions The gas sensing properties of the pure and ZnO surface modified Fe2O3 were studied. It is well known that the gas sensing property is greatly influenced by the temperature. The TGA makes it clear that as the temperature changes the weight percentage of ZnO also changes. This change in the weight percentage may cause the change in the structure of the film that causes the corresponding change in sensitivity. In order to determine optimum operating temperature the additive amount of ZnO on the surface, selectivity to the various gases and the response of all the modified films at different dipping time interval were tested to various gases at different temperature. It is observed that the response of the sensors to the various gases varies with the change in temperature, dipping time, as well as concentration of ZnO on the surface of the film. The pure film showed maximum sensitivity at 3000C to H2S along with response to Ethanol. The surface modified film (dipping time 30min) enhanced the sensitivity (441) to H2S gas with suppressing the response to Ethanol at 2000C. The selectivity of the gas sensor is an important parameter for practical application of gas sensor. As compare to pure Fe2O3 sensor the surface modified film showed better selectivity and sensitivity at comparatively low temperature. 4.1 Adsorption of Oxygen When oxygen is adsorbed on the zinc zones of strong localization at elevated temperatures, the potential barrier between the Fe2O3 grains may be raised further and as a result the total resistance increases in comparison with the sample without zinc. It is known that abstraction of electrons from bulk Fe2O3 by the adsorbed oxygen results in
Gas Sensing Characteristics of Pure and ZnO-Modified Fe2O3 Thick Films
131
the formation of surface states. The amount of oxygen adsorbed on the surface of ZnO-Fe2O3 film would be larger since zinc oxide would form misfit regions between the grains of Fe2O3 and would act as an efficient catalyst for oxygenation. 4.2 Desorption of Oxygen When reducing gas such as H2S adsorb between the grains of Fe2O3, the potential barrier would be decreased as a result of oxidative conversion of the H2S gas and desorption of oxygen. Due to desorption of adsorbed oxygen ions and conversion of zinc oxide into sulphides the resistance of the film would change abruptly leading to high response to H2S. 4.3 The Amount of Surface ZnO and Response to H2S The gas-sensing mechanism of α-Fe2O3 -based sensors belongs to the surfacecontrolled type, which is based on the change in conductance of the semiconductor. The oxygen adsorbed on the surface directly influences the conductance of the α-Fe2O3 based sensors. The amount of oxygen adsorbed on sensor surface depends on the operating temperature, particle size, and specific surface area of the sensor [15]. As mentioned in the earlier work of the semiconductor gas sensor gas sensing mechanism the state of oxygen on the surface of Fe2O3 sensor undergoes the following reaction O2 (gas) → O2 (ads)
(1)
O2 (ads) + e−→ O2− (ads)
(2)
O2− (ads) + e−→ 2O− (ads)
(3)
O− (ads) + e−→ O2− (ads)
(4)
The oxygen species capture electrons from the material, which results in the concentration changes of holes or electrons in the Fe2O3 semiconductor. When the sensor is exposed to H2S, the reductive gas reacts with the oxygen adsorbed on the sensor surface. Then the electrons are released back into the semiconductor, resulting in the change in electrical conductance of the Fe2O3 sensor. It can be expressed in the following reaction H2S + 3O2−→ H2O + SO2 +6e−
(5)
For the Fe2O3 sensors, the low response at low operating temperature can be attributed to the low thermal energy of the gas molecules, which is not enough to react with the surface adsorbed oxygen species. As a result, the reaction rate between them is essentially low and low response is observed [15, 16].
5 Conclusions Pure Fe2O3 and surface modified ZnO- Fe2O3 thick film gas sensors were prepared by screen printing technique. The pure Fe2O3 film showed maximum selectivity (189) to H2S gas at 300OC along with the selectivity (13.15) to Ethanol at same temperature. The surface modified film showed enhancement in gas response. The ZnO- Fe2O3
132
N.K. Pawar et al.
(30min dipped) film showed enhancement in response to H2S gas. The selectivity to H2S gas was 441 at 200oC. The notable change in selectivity response to H2S is enhancement in selectivity to H2S gas at comparatively lower temperature 200oC. The modified film completely suppressed the response to ethanol. Compared to pure Fe2O3 gas sensor the ZnO surface modified Fe2O3 gas sensor seems to be a more promising gas sensor at lower temperature 200oC for detecting H2S gas due to its higher selectivity and sensitivity, as well as shorter response and recovery time.
References 1. Struve, M.F., Brisbios, J.N., James, R.A., Marshall, M.W., Dorman, D.C.: Neurotoxicological Effects Associated with Short-Term Exposure of Sprague-Dawley Rats to Hydrogen Sulfide. Neurotoxicology 22(3), 375–385 (2001) 2. Bendahan, M., Boulamani, R., Seguin, J.L., Aguir, K.: Characterization of ozone sensors based on WO3 reactively sputtered films: influence of O2 concentration in the sputtering gas, and working temperature. Sensors and Actuators B 100, 320–324 (2004) 3. Hofer, U., Frank, J., Fleisscher, M.: High temperature Ga2O3-gas sensors and SnO2-gas sensors: a comparison. Sensors and Actuators B 72, 6–11 (2001) 4. Yamazoe, N.: New approaches for improving semiconductor gas sensors. Sensors and Actuators B 5, 7 (1991) 5. Tianshu, Z., Ruifang, Z., Yusheng, S., Xinquin, L.: Synthesis and gas-sensing characteristics of high thermostability -Fe2O3 powder. Sensors and Actuators B 32, 181–184 (1996) 6. Li, B., Yue, Z., Li, L., Zhou, J.: Low-fired microwave dielectrics in ZnO-TiO2 ceramics doped with CuO and B2O3. Journal of Material Sci. 13(7), 415–418 (2002) 7. Fleischer, M., Meixner, H.: Fast gas sensors based on metal oxides which are stable at high temperatures. Sensors and Actuators B 43, 1 (1997) 8. Madou, M.J., Morrison, S.R.: Chemical sensing with solid state devices, p. 431. Acedemic Press, San Diego (1999) 9. Rumyantseva, M., Kovalenko, V., Gaskov, A., Makshina, E., Yuschenko, V., Ivanova, I., Ponzoni, A., et al.: Nanocomposites SnO2/Fe2O3: Sensor and catalytic properties. Sensors and Actuators B 118, 208–214 (2005) 10. Zhang, Z.Y., Jiang, H.J., Xing, Z., Zhang, X.R.: A highly selective chemiluminescent H2S sensor. Sensors and Actuators B 1021, 55–161 (2004) 11. Sun, Z.Y., Yuan, H.Q., Liu, Z.M., Han, B.X., Zhang, X.R.: A highly efficient chemical sensor material for H2S: α-Fe2O3 nanotubes fabricated using carbon nanotube template. Adv. Mater. 17, 2993–2997 (2005) 12. Jing, Z.: Synthesis, characterization and gas sensing properties of undoped and Zn doped γ-Fe2O3 based gas sensors. Material Science and Engineering A 441, 176–180 (2006) 13. Jain, G.H., Gaikwad, V.B., Patil, L.A.: Studies on gas sensing performance of (Ba0.8Sr0.2)(Sn0.8Ti0.2)O3 thick film resistors. Sensors and Actuators B 122, 605–612 (2007) 14. Jain, G.H., Patil, L.A., Wagh, M.S., Patil, D.R., Patil, S.A., Amalnerkar, D.P.: Surface modified BaTiO3 thick film resistors as H2S gas sensors. Sens. Actuators B 117, 159–165 (2006) 15. Aroutiounian, V.M., Aghababian, G.S.: The theory of semiconductor gas sensors. Sens. Actuators B 50, 80–84 (1998) 16. Chang, J.F., Kuo, H.H., Leu, I.C., Hon, M.H.: The effects of thickness and operation temperature on ZnO:Al thin film CO gas sensor. Sens. Actuators B 84, 258–264 (2002)
Design and Construction of a Configurable Full-Field Range Imaging System for Mobile Robotic Applications D.A. Carnegie1, J.R.K. McClymont1, A.P.P. Jongenelen1, B. Drayton1, A.A. Dorrington2, and A.D. Payne2 1 School of Engineering and Computer Science, Victoria University of Wellington, Wellington, New Zealand 2 Department of Engineering, University of Waikato, Hamilton, New Zealand
Abstract. Mobile robotic devices rely critically on extrospection sensors to determine the range to objects in the robot’s operating environment. This provides the robot with the ability both to navigate safely around obstacles and to map its environment and hence facilitate path planning and navigation. There is a requirement for a full-field range imaging system that can determine the range to any obstacle in a camera lens’ field of view accurately and in real-time. This paper details the development of a portable full-field ranging system whose bench-top version has demonstrated sub-millimetre precision. However, this precision required non-real-time acquisition rates and expensive hardware. By iterative replacement of components, a portable, modular and inexpensive version of this full-field ranger has been constructed, capable of real-time operation with some (user-defined) trade-off with precision.
1 Introduction Mobile robotic devices are critically dependent upon extrospective sensors in order to be able to operate in an environment. Specifically, accurate range finding is required in order to be able to negotiate around obstacles, map the environment and implement efficient path planning. Such ranging needs to not only be accurate, but also able to be acquired in real-time with a high field-of-view coverage. Infrared ranging is often used for close-range obstacle avoidance and has become increasingly popular with the development of the inexpensive Sharp GP2 range of analogue and digital detectors [1]. However, such sensors are limited in range and are seldom reliable past 3 metres or so. Ultrasonic techniques are often employed when ranging to ~10 metres (dependent upon the carrier frequency) however they suffer significantly from the broadness of the transmitted beam, exacerbated by the comparative difficulty in focussing an acoustic rather than an EM wave. Subsequently for this technique to be of use in mobile robotic ranging and mapping, considerable software processing is often required to counter the multiple path reflections. Furthermore, because of the inherent dead-band, ultrasound must often be augmented by an IR sensor for close range obstacle detection. The limited range of these techniques is a significant impediment to mobile operation in a large open environment, and hence laser-based ranging using a projected S.C. Mukhopadhyay et al. (Eds.): New Developments and Appl. in Sen. Tech., LNEE 83, pp. 133–155. springerlink.com © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011
134
D.A. Carnegie et al.
dot or line is often employed. Sick [2] (for example) are a major supplier of such laser based systems and produce a variety of devices with fields of view ranging from 70° through to 360°. The wider fields of view are achieved at the expense of lower acquisition rates or significantly greater cost. Whilst precision to the millimetre level is obtainable, this is normally only achievable if range is significantly compromised. Consequently, laser scanning systems that provide an acceptable compromise between long range, good precision, wide field of few and low acquisition times are typically extremely expensive and outside the budget of many mobile robot projects. Certainly this expense often precludes their incorporation into commercial devices. A niche exists for the development of a ranging system that provides a wide field of view, high precision, and a short acquisition time. Furthermore, such a system would ideally be able to alter its field of view simply by changing the lens or incorporating a telephoto system adjustable by the user (or autonomously by the robot) during range acquisition. These requirements can be satisfied by a Full-Field Range Imaging System (FFRIS), whereby the range to every object in a field of view (determined by an optical lens) can be obtained simultaneously. A specific requirement by the authors is to obtain a FFRIS that can be mounted on robots in their mobile robotic fleet, three of which are pictured in Figure 1. Ideally this FFRIS could be used in both an indoor and an outdoor environment.
Fig. 1. Robotic platforms requiring extrospective sensors, (a) MARVIN an indoor security robot, (b) two robots designed for urban search and rescue applications
The authors believe it is instructive to relate the development of our successful FFRIS in terms of the successive design iterations that addressed particular problems or limitations that were identified at each stage in the development process. We hope that such a description will aid the reader in appreciating the problems inherent in the development of full-field ranging systems and hence understand the justification of
Design and Construction of a Configurable Full-Field Range Imaging System
135
the techniques and components selected for this particular implementation. In the process, we hope that the reader gains an added appreciation of full-field ranging techniques, image capture devices, high frequency modulatable illumination sources and drivers, FPGAs as embedded control systems, external memory requirements and interfacing, and power supply issues. This list is too exhaustive to cover any one topic in much detail given these space constraints, but the integration of these into a complete functional system forms the basis of this work. To begin the discussion, the next section will outline the theory behind FFRIS operation. Section 3 details the requirements of a FFRIS that would make such a device useful for mobile robotics. Section 4 discusses an initial design solution that successfully implemented full-field ranging but could not be employed on mobile robots because of its cost, bulk, power requirements and long acquisition times. Section 5 provides a solution to many of these problems, but still resulted in a system that had to be bench-mounted. The successful device is presented in detail in section 6, where a modular, robust, compact and inexpensive FFRIS is constructed. The chapter concludes with the results of this new device.
2 Principles of Full-Field Image Ranging Many techniques exist for determining the distance to an object using an optical source, including: • • • •
passive stereo and photogrammetry, active triangulation and structured light, interferometry, direct and indirect time-of-flight (ToF)
Space does not permit a full discussion of the merits of each of these techniques and the reader is referred to numerous books and articles which review these techniques. The FFRIS utilises an indirect time-of-flight measurement technique over a field of view determined by the optics of a standard camera lens and therefore the following discussion is limited to an introduction of the ToF method. The images presented in Figures 2 to 4 below are extracted from [4]. A direct time-of-flight system records the time for a pulse of light to be emitted, reflected off an object and returned to a receiver placed adjacent to the illumination source as illustrated in Figure 2. These systems can be point, line, or full-field scanning or full-field non-scanning depending upon the configuration of the source and sensor. Distance d is simply determined by
d=
ct 2
Equation 1
where t is the total flight time and c is the speed of light. A significant problem with such systems is that the distance resolution is critically dependent on the resolution of the timer. For example, to obtain 1 cm distance
136
D.A. Carnegie et al.
resolution the timer must be able to resolve the returned pulse to within 66 ps. The expense and complexity of the electronics required to achieve this resolution renders such systems of questionable value for most range determination applications.
Fig. 2. Principle of distance determination using direct time-of-flight.
To overcome the high bandwidth requirements of the direct ToF method, a number of techniques exist that encode the distance information indirectly, often through amplitude or phase. For example in [4] a light source and a high-speed shutter are pulsed at the same frequency as illustrated in Figure 3. There will be a delay in the light reaching the shutter that is proportional to the object’s distance. As indicated in Figure 4, objects that are nearer to the illumination/shutter system will have a higher proportion of the reflected pulse pass into the image sensor than objects that are more distant. The intensity of the received light can therefore be used as an indicator of object distance. However this intensity may also be affected by changes in object orientation, reflectivity and ambient lighting, and these effects need to be eliminated by appropriate system normalisation. An alternative technique is a heterodyne approach where intensity modulated light at frequency fm is projected onto a scene and the receiving camera shutter is modulated at a slightly different frequency fs = fm + δ. The modulation frequency fm is in the range 10 MHz –100 MHz, and δ is typically 1 – 5 Hz. These signals are effectively mixed and integrated by the camera system to produce a beat signal of frequency δ. The light received at the camera has a phase offset of the modulation envelope introduced due to the time taken for the light to travel twice the distance from the imaging system to the object. Calculating distance then becomes an issue of accurately determining the phase offset φ of the signal at the beat frequency δ. Distance is related to the phase offset by:
Design and Construction of a Configurable Full-Field Range Imaging System
d=
φ c 4π f m
137
Equation 2 .
The phase offset φ can be determined by a variety of techniques including the Discrete Fourier Transform and an inner-product method. Space constraints restrict a more detailed review of the theory and implementation of full-field ranging systems. The interested reader is referred to reviews of such systems in [5] or the more detailed descriptions of the techniques we employ in [6-10] or further theoretical treatment in [11].
Fig. 3. Principle of distance determination using direct time-of-flight.
Fig. 4. Principle of distance determination using direct time-of-flight.
FFRIS devices currently on the market include systems developed by PMDTechnologies [12], Mesa Imaging [13] and Cantesa [14], with two typical examples illustrated in Figure 5. Our bench-top system has demonstrated several advantages over the offerings from either of these manufacturers particularly in terms of configurability and versatility. This will be explained in subsequent sections.
138
D.A. Carnegie et al.
Fig. 5. (Left) Cam Cube 3-D Range Imaging Camera from PMDTechnologies [12] (Right) SR4000 Range Imaging Camera from Mesa Imaging [13]
3 Full Field Range Imaging System Requirements As discussed in the introduction, a full-field ranging system is of significant potential use as an extrospective sensor for mobile robots. In order for such a system to implement active ranging using either a homodyne or heterodyne approach, the system must possess the following: • • • • • •
The ability to precisely modulate an illumination source (preferably at frequencies in excess of 10 MHz) A sensor to image the intensity of the received illumination The ability to precisely modulate a “shutter”. This will control the timing (and hence the intensity) of light entering the sensor The ability to precisely frequency lock the shutter and illumination modulation The ability to process the received frames to determine the phase (that encodes the distance) An intelligible output of the range to objects within the device’s field of view
Furthermore, it is desirable that the FFRIS also contains: •
•
The ability to alter the modulation frequencies (both shutter and illumination). This provides the user with the ability to experiment with different configurations. The authors have found this to be invaluable for determining the frequencies that produce the best precision results [15,16]. It would be additionally useful if these frequencies could be changed “on the fly”, in other words be configurable without requiring the downloading of new code. The ability to alter the illumination intensity. This permits the range of the system to be increased if required (assuming the user has taken precautions regarding eye safety).
Design and Construction of a Configurable Full-Field Range Imaging System
• •
139
An embedded processor so that the device can be operated independent of a host PC. Circuitry to protect the illumination source from over-current or overheating (which would shorten the lifetime of the illumination source).
Finally, for the device to be useful as an extrospective sensor on a mobile robot, the device should preferably be all of: • • • •
Inexpensive. Due to the low quantity of production this requires use of offthe-shelf components Portable. We require the system to be able to run without the need of mains power or attached PC Low – or at least variable – acquisition time. The system must be able to operate in real-time even if this incurs a loss of precision. Configurable. The system should be configurable for use over a variety of ranges, lighting conditions, object reflectivities and required spatial and range resolutions
Our solution, as mentioned in the introduction, is the result of several development iterations. We initially demonstrated the proof-of-concept of full-field range imaging using a heterodyne technique, and then iteratively solved limitations and problems until arriving at our final design solution that is suitable for mounting on a mobile robot.
4 Initial Design Proof of concept of the principle of operation was first obtained using a heterodyne approach [6]. This system utilised AD9852 direct digital synthesizer (DDS) ICs interfaced to a reprogrammable microcontroller to provide the shutter and illumination modulation frequencies. This DDS is a 300 Mega-Samples Per Second (MSPS) device with high frequency resolution provided by a software programmable 48 bit tuning word. The illumination was provided by red Agilent HLMP EL series LEDs that could be successfully driven at up to 20 MHz, and the shutter modulation was provided by a photo-cathode modulated Photek MCP125 Image Intensifier connected to a standard 80 – 200 mm focal length Nikon F-mount zoom lens and an 8-bit monochrome Pulnix TM9701 camera. This system successfully produced images oscillating at the beat frequency (the difference of the shutter and illumination modulation frequencies, i.e. a heterodyne technique), and a DFT in time was applied to each pixel to provide an estimate of the phase that represents time-of-flight from which the range was determined. This device, operating at 10 MHz and beat frequencies of 1, 2 and 5 Hz, was successful in producing a highly linear response with a standard deviation of ~ 1 centimetre for objects ranging from 1 metre to 5 metre distance. However, there was a systemic offset error, and the 8-bit limitation of the camera system dramatically
140
D.A. Carnegie et al.
depreciated the system’s performance. Furthermore, the low modulation frequency also impacted performance as (from Equation 2) the range precision is proportional to the modulation wavelength. 4.1 Revised Design For the next iteration of the design [7], the Pulnix camera was replaced by a 12 bit Pantera TF 1M60 capable of 100 Hz operation at 512 × 512 resolution (i.e. 2 × 2 binning mode) or 200 Hz operation at 128 × 128 resolution (i.e. 8 × 8 binning mode). The image intensifier was replaced by a custom ordered Photek model that had a response almost an order of magnitude faster – the photocathode being capable of being gated down to 1 ns. The slow response LEDs were replaced with four 80 mW Mitsubishi ML120G21 laser-diodes that have a potential modulation frequency of the order of 100 MHz, and the higher speed (400 MSPS) DDS chips, AD9952 were employed to generate the modulation signals up to 200 MHz with a resolution of 0.093 Hz (from the 32 bit tuning word – lower than the AD9852 but still adequate for this application). In practice, the maximum useable modulation frequency of this improved system was limited to 90 MHz. Sub millimetre precision was obtained at a modulation frequency of 35 MHz, with precision peaking at approximately 0.6 mm at 65 MHz. This system clearly demonstrated the success of our proof of concept. Subsequent improvements [8] included the introduction of an FPGA to provide laser level control and intensifier gain control. The FPGA was also configured to generate a shuttering signal to gate the photocathode of the intensifier to ensure it turned off during CCD frame transfer in order to limit image smear. For the phase determination, it was now possible to arrange the drive signals so that the beat signal falls completely within a frequency bin. Hence an inner-product approach could be used in place of the previous DFT. This algorithm was almost an order of magnitude faster and provided essentially the same phase resolution. This improved system could obtain 0.5 mm resolution for acquisition times > 22 seconds, but even at 10 seconds, a precision of 0.6 mm could be obtained. Employing the 8 × 8 binning, the system could generate range images between 15.7 and 68.5 Hz with a best precision of 2.5 mm [15]. The penalty for this however, was significantly reduced spatial resolution. The primary remaining acquisition time limitation was the employment of the digital camera attached to the image intensifier. Affordable cameras at the time possessed a slow frames-per-second acquisition rate, typically 50 Hz to 100 Hz, with higher rates only possible with pixel binning. This system was also severely limited by the utilisation of the image intensifier. This device was costly (~6000 euro) and bulky as can be seen in Figure 6, where the image intensifier is the tube-like device attached to the camera. Furthermore, the intensifier requires three independent voltages, one of the order of -50 to +10 V, another ~700 V, and the third at a level of approximately 6 kV (note the presence of the high voltage power supplies in the foreground of Figure 6). Finally, the range processing was performed off-line by an externally interfaced PC. So whilst successful, this form of the FFRIS was limited to being a bench-top device.
Design and Construction of a Configurable Full-Field Range Imaging System
141
Fig. 6. Original FFRIS configuration featuring image intensifier and high-voltage external power supply
5 Real-Time Capable Design As mentioned, the primary limitations of the previous systems were the bulk and expense of the image intensifier and the limitations in frame acquisition imposed by the requirement for a commercial digital camera. The next iteration in the system development [9] replaced the Image Intensifier and the digital camera with a PMDTechnologies PMD19k-2 image sensor chip. This CMOS based PMD sensor permits the gain modulation of the imaging pixels to be controlled on-chip, effectively replacing the shuttering function previously performed by the image intensifier and the image acquisition function of the camera. This vastly reduced the bulk and power requirements of the FFRIS, rendering the system potentially portable. Furthermore the component costs of the system were reduced by over 80%! One disadvantage however, is that the pixel array sizes of these chips are currently limited – although significant improvements are expected in the near future. At this point, the decision was made to produce a semi-modular system comprising • • • •
an FPGA development board (based on the Stratix III), an Illumination board containing the laser diodes and driver circuitry, an Imaging Sensor board (with the sensor and lens attached as a daughter board), a VGA/Ethernet board for VGA output display and interfacing to a PC.
This is illustrated in Figure 7 [9]. Note the circular arrangement of the illumination diodes on the right. This semi-modular system provided the capability to upgrade or change one of the boards without necessitating a full system redesign, for example the sensor or illumination diodes could be exchanged with little effect on the remaining hardware.
142
D.A. Carnegie et al.
Fig. 7. System architecture of modular bench-top full-field imaging system
In the previous design iteration an FPGA controlled the gain of the laser diodes and produced a shuttering signal. Now that an FPGA was embedded in the system, the capability existed to utilise it to generate the modulation frequencies and hence eliminate the requirement of employing the DDS chips. This significantly simplified the FFRIS board design. Furthermore, by choosing an FPGA with sufficient capacity, the received frames could be stored and processed on-chip to determine the phase and hence the range to objects in those frames. Eliminating the requirement for an external PC is a significant improvement for mobile robotic applications. A Stratix III Development kit hosting an Altera Stratix III EP3SL150 FPGA was employed. This FPGA was chosen primarily for its easily reconfigurable phase-locked-loop resources which provide the ability to reconfigure the phase, frequency and duty cycle of the output channels in real time. This FPGA also has enough on-chip logic and memory resources to buffer the frames and hence calculate the full-field range images in real-time. The FPGA now incorporated [9] (again change with previous xxx) the tasks of: • • • • •
Driving the modulation signals Controlling data retrieval from the sensor Calculating range images Timing and control of signals for VGA display of range image data Handling JTAG interface and Ethernet connections to a PC in order to receive and process user commands or transferring data for long-term storage
The Illumination board comprised independently driven infrared (808 nm) and visible red (658 nm) laser diodes employed in two independent banks of 8. These diodes were driven in a controlled current configuration (by the FPGA) with a continuous
Design and Construction of a Configurable Full-Field Range Imaging System
143
total optical output power of 800 mW. Lasers of different wavelength were employed to investigate how their different reflectivities affected the performance of the FFRIS. Extra care is required in using the IR lasers however, since eye damage can easily result due to the beam being undetectable by the unassisted retina, preventing a natural blink reflex. Parallel work by the authors (for example [15,17]) provided a theoretical framework to select optimum frequencies within the achievable system bandwidth. A problem encountered is that range ambiguity occurs if the phase shift exceeds 2π and is a significant issue as the modulation frequency is increased. The maximum unambiguous range du is inversely related to the modulation frequency fm as:
du =
c 2 fm
Equation 3
Hence for a 10 MHz modulation frequency ranges up to 15 metres can be resolved unambiguously, but at 60 MHz, this reduces to 2.5 metres. In other words, at this modulation frequency the system would not be able to resolve the difference between an object located at 3 metres distance from one located at 5.5 metres. This problem has been resolved [16,18] by employing two modulation frequencies simultaneously, however a discussion of this is outside the scope of this chapter. The PMD 19K-2 3D Video Sensor Array from PhotonICs is employed as the imaging sensor. This sensor features a 160 × 120 array of pixels grouped into four independently modulated blocks of 40 × 120 pixels. Each modulation block presents a capacitive load of 250 pF at the driver interface. To drive these blocks at modulation frequencies of 10 MHz and above, ultra high current pin drivers (EL7158 from Intersil) are employed.
Fig. 8. Assembled FFRIS utilising Stratix III FPGA development board
144
D.A. Carnegie et al.
For this particular sensor, a rise and fall time of 12 ns can be achieved, limiting the maximum modulation frequency (without skew) to 41 MHz. Maximum contrast is achieved with a modulation input of +2.5 V. At a modulation frequency of 41 MHz, the imaging sensor’s modulation inputs have an impedance of approximately 15.5 Ω each and so the current draw per modulation input is 160 mA, with a worst case total current draw of 640 mA. The complete assembled system is illustrated in Figure 8.
6 Portable Version The system described so far demonstrates many of the requirements that we wish for our final system, however its size is constrained by the large physical dimensions (210×180×70 mm) of the Stratix III development board as can be appreciated in Figure 8. For the portable version, suitable for mounting on a mobile robot, the modular construction of the previous design is retained to allow a versatile system since it can be expected that the FPGA will be replaced in the future with a more powerful version, the illumination diodes may be exchanged for different wavelengths, bandwidth or intensity, and certainly advances are expected in sensor capacity. The new system has the arrangement of Figure 9 [19] which illustrates how the four boards sandwich against each other to minimise physical dimensions. The boards are separated and attached to each other using M3 PCB standoffs. Physical sizing is determined in the first instance by the circular cut-out for the Illumination board. This must have a minimum diameter of 35 mm to accommodate the optical lens (diameter 30 mm). The laser diodes of the Illumination board have an 8 mm diameter, and to accommodate 16 requires them to be centred on a circle with a minimum diameter of 43 mm. To accommodate the on-board voltage regulation and laser driving circuitry, and the 6 mm diameter of the standoffs, a board design of 100 mm square is required (considerably smaller than the dimensions of the Stratix III development board). The system is designed to be generic and flexible in terms of the components it will tolerate. The device is designed to meet the processing requirements of a 1 Mpixel image although we expect it to be some time before such a sensor becomes inexpensively available. Similarly, the current ratings for the components are overspecified which has obvious implications for the power source. Again this is done deliberately to accommodate circuit additions in the future if required. The following sections detail the function of each board and a brief description of how this was implemented. Communication between the boards is facilitated by a generic I/O interface that carries 17 differential transmit lines, 17 differential receive lines, a +3.3 V rail spread across 20 pins, a +12 V rail spread across 19 pins, 4 single ended I/O lines, and 4 JTAG lines (TDO, TDI, TMS, TCK). This is implemented with a 172 pin high speed mezzanine male connector. The form of this connector is modelled on the external interfaces provided on the Stratix III development kit.
Design and Construction of a Configurable Full-Field Range Imaging System
145
Fig. 9. System architecture of portable modular full-field imaging system
6.1 FPGA Board This board is the “heart” and “brains” of the entire system. It is configured to internally contain the NIOS processor which performs many of the system control function. The FPGA board connects to the image sensing/capture board via one of the two generic digital I/O ports and via these ports controls the image capture and illumination processes. The FPGA board also connects to the External Interface board to facilitate the FPGA sending captured images to peripheral devices such as a PC or VGA monitor. The FPGA selected has to have sufficient I/O lines to access the generic I/O ports and to interface to external RAM. As discussed, the prototype version utilised the Altera Stratix III family of FPGAs. For this portable implementation, the Altera Cyclone III EP3C40 is preferred due to the substantially lower cost. This version of the Cyclone family contains 39,600 logic elements, 4 PLLs, ~ 1 Mbit RAM, and 535 User I/Os. This is deemed sufficient for our initial purposes, but should a future iteration require additional processing of the raw images, then the EP3C120 contains three times the number of logic elements and RAM and provides for an easy upgrade path (pins are mostly identical). A 50 MHz oscillator is employed as the system clock. The design of the full-field range imaging system utilises four discrete blocks of memory for processing and storage of images. The prototype system implements the RAM required for image processing on the FPGA’s internal 5499 Kbit static random access memory. This is sufficient for storage and processing of image frames from the 160 × 120 (19K2) pixel PMD sensor but not for higher resolution sensors and so provision for external memory must be provided.
Fig. 10. Block diagram of FPGA board
146 D.A. Carnegie et al.
Design and Construction of a Configurable Full-Field Range Imaging System
147
6.2 Memory Requirements Five different types of memory are required for this system: • • • • •
Accumulator – required for the storage of images during image processing Output buffer – stores the images to be accessed by the NIOS processor, the VGA output and/or the Ethernet output NIOS program – stores the firmware of the NIOS processor NIOS Ethernet frame buffer – required to store image frames to output to a peripheral computer Flash FPGA configuration memory – stores the FPGA configuration to be loaded at start up.
In determining the choice of memory to satisfy the above requirements, it is important to note that the Cyclone III family supports several high speed external memory interfaces to allow external memory to be connected to the FPGA with little customisation of hardware or software. These supported memory devices include DDR, DDR2 and SDR SDRAM. DDR2 SDRAM is preferred over the older memory types for this application. The accumulator is used to store the accumulated real and imaginary terms (up to 16 bits each) for each pixel needed to calculate the phase [20]. Hence for a 1 Mpixel image this would require 4 MB. For an image processing routine operating at a clock frequency of 10 MHz, the accumulator must operate at a data rate of 320 MBit/s (32 bits/pixel × 10 MHz). The accumulator must read and write a pixel value each time it performs a mathematical operation. This increases the required data rate of the accumulator to at least 640 MBit/s. Depending upon the application, the output buffer may be required to hold between 1 and 4 frames at 16 bits per frame. An application that only requires the distance information would simply require 1 frame, if amplitude was also required then 2 frames would be necessary and if the raw pixel data is needed then all 4 frames would need to be stored. Hence for a 1 Mpixel frame, in the worst case, 8 Mbytes are required. This output buffer is accessed by the NIOS processor, the VGA output process and the image processing process. All three accessing processes are clocked at 10 MHz and so the memory must be able to transfer data to each process at a speed of 320 Mbit/s. Time multiplexing is utilised to handle the three accessing processes. This increases the required data transfer speed to 960 Mbit/s (320 Mbit/s by each process). For the accumulator and output buffer, the Micron MT47H64M8 DDR2 SDRAM is selected. This device has a memory size of 512 Mbit and operates at a clock frequency of 333 MHz. It has an 8-bit wide data bus allowing data transfer rates of 2.7 Gbit/s. For the NIOS program, the Micron MT47H32M16 DDR2 SDRAM is selected, effectively being a 16 bit variant of the H64M8 above. The NIOS Ethernet buffer RAM stores frames that are to be output to a peripheral computer via the Ethernet connection. We have designed 1 Gbyte of memory, sufficient to buffer 256 1 Mpixel output frames. This is implemented using the M47H512M8 DDR2 SDRAM which has a memory size of 4 Gbit and operates at a frequency of 333 MHz. It has an 8-bit wide data bus allowing data transfer rates of
148
D.A. Carnegie et al.
2.7 Gbit/s. Two of these devices operating in parallel increase the memory density to 8 Gbit (1 Gbyte) and double the data transfer rate to 5.3 Gbit/s. The Flash configuration is 64 Mbyte which is deemed to be easily sufficient for any current or future sized configuration files. 6.3 Illumination Circuit Board As explained previously, 16 laser diodes are incorporated into the Illumination board and are chosen to be the 130 mW CWML101J27 Mitsubishi devices, operating at 660 nm. These are driven by the iC-HK 155 MHz laser switches to provide up to 150 mA continuous current or 700 mA maximum pulsed current. A block diagram representation of this board is provided in Figure 10. It is important at start-up that the diode current be gradually increased to allow the laser to reach a steady operating temperature since at low temperatures the high currents could potentially cause catastrophic optical damage. The diode current in earlier iterations of the board was controlled by an on-board microcontroller. This functionality is now undertaken by the FPGA, and the diodes are modulated from the FPGA via a control signal marked in Figure 11 in the form of a Two-Wire Interface TWI bus. This control signal feeds into a digital to analogue convertor (DAC) (AD5311 from Analog Devices) and then to the laser switch. A protection circuit has also been included to switch off the laser diodes if the control or modulation signals from FPGA board become disconnected from the Laser Illumination board.
Fig. 11. Block diagram for Illuminator Board
Design and Construction of a Configurable Full-Field Range Imaging System
149
A DIP switch allows the user to select between running the laser diodes at maximum power or half power. The half power option operates the laser diodes at a safer optical intensity when output power is not a critical consideration for image ranging a scene. 6.4 Image Sensing and Capture Board This board connects to the FPGA via the generic digital interface. This board handles all the digitising of the captured images from the sensor and all the signal modifications to drive the image sensor. It also busses power and modulation control signals from the FPGA board to the illuminator board. It is illustrated in block diagram form in Figure 12.
Fig. 12. Block diagram for the Image Sensing and Capture Board
The FFRIS requires control over the modulation of the sensor and must be able to access the raw pixel values. These requirements eliminate many of the image sensors currently on the market. We chose not to wait for an improvement over the PMD 19k sensor to become available, and elected instead to design the Image Capture board so that it could immediately host the PMD Daughter board from the previous system incarnation. As this image board is only a sub-system of the complete FFRIS, it will be straight-forward to design a modified board in the future as appropriate sensors become available (this is the motivation behind the modular design – to easily implement hardware changes without incurring a system redesign). The PMD daughter board connects to this board so that the imaging sensor is centred on the board, ensuring that the attached optical lens will be aligned with the circular cut-out of the Laser Illumination board.
150
D.A. Carnegie et al.
The image sensor has two analogue video outputs. A 16-bit Imaging Signal processor ADC (AD9826 from Analog Devices) is provided to convert the two analogue video streams from the image sensor into digital frames to be processed by the FPGA. This ADC can sample the video streams at a maximum rate of 15 million samples per second. Each 16-bit data word is transferred to the FPGA in two sequential bytes on an 8-bit data bus via the generic I/O interface. The generic I/O interface between the FPGA and Image Capture board utilises LVDS signals to improve the quality of the transmitted signals. LVDS receivers and transmitters convert the LVDS signals to the single-ended CMOS signals required by the image sensor, ADC and high current pin drivers. The LVDS receiver/transmitters are the SN65LVDT388/389 8-way high speed drivers, and the repeater is the SNLVDS100. The Image Capture board busses the modulation and control signals to the Illumination board via Serial Advanced Technology Attachment (SATA) connections. 6.5 External Interface Board This board provides all the necessary communication drivers to allow the system to connect with peripheral devices such as an external computer or VGA monitor. It also provides communication interfaces to allow configuration and management of the imaging system by an external control computer. Figure 13 presents a block diagram of the main sub-systems of the External Interface board.
Fig. 13. Block diagram of the External Interface board
Design and Construction of a Configurable Full-Field Range Imaging System
151
Image frames can be displayed on an external standard 640 × 480 resolution VGA monitor over a VGA interface allowing users to examine four frames of raw and processed data simultaneously in real time. The VGA output is driven by a triple 10bit high speed video DAC (ADV7123, from Analog Devices). This DAC has three separate 10-bit input ports that drive three complementary outputs to produce the analogue red, green and blue video streams to display images on a VGA monitor. All the VGA data and control signals are sent over the generic I/O interface from the FPGA board to the External Interface board. The External Interface board uses a standard VGA jack to allow the connection of any standard VGA monitor. An 8-bit microcontroller (ATMega32U4 from Atmel) incorporating a USB controller is employed to provide the communication interface between the control computer and the range imaging system (which contains a Mini–B USB connector). The MCU provides full-speed and low-speed USB connections and allows the range imaging system to appear as a USB device to any USB host running on an external computer. The External Interface board contains a RJ-45 jack with an integrated Ethernet interface to allow long term storage of processed and raw image frames on an external computer. A stand-alone Ethernet controller (DM9000A from Davicom) provides both the MAC and PHY transceiver and is interfaced to the FPGA via a 16-bit data bus over the generic I/O interface. The NIOS processor is responsible for writing image frames to the Ethernet controller chip.
7 Power Supply As can be seen from Figures 10 – 13, the component boards require a plethora of voltages, including +1.2, +1.8, +2.5, +3.3, +5.0, +12 V. These are provided on the component boards by an appropriate regulator, but such designs are straight-forward and will not be further described here. The power consumption of the image ranger sub-systems has been calculated based on the maximum ratings of the components utilised on each board plus a future expansion capacity. The resultant maximum rating of each board is (rounded up to the nearest 5 W): • • • •
FPGA Board – 25 W. External Interface Board – 5 W. Image Sensing and Capture Board – 10 W. Laser Illumination Board – 50 W.
The FPGA board power consumption is primarily set by the configuration of the FPGA, specifically the speed and the number of resources utilised, 20 W being the measured output of the working Stratix as configured in the bench-top system. Based on the power consumption calculation the input power supply must be able to deliver 90 W of power. The power supply will typically be from a 12 V source and hence the supply must be capable of providing a maximum of 7.5 A. The External Interface board incorporates protection and filter circuits to provide a clean power supply to the unregulated power bus that runs through the entire system. A 40 A rated Schottky diode (48CTQ060SPBF, from Vishay) provides reverse polarity protection
152
D.A. Carnegie et al.
on the input voltage and two power-out connectors, fused at 10 A each limit the total current. An inductor-capacitor (LC) filter, rated at 23 A, provides filtering on the input power supply to prevent high frequency noise.
8 Results The completed and assembled unit is illustrated in Figure 14 [19]. With the modular board arrangement, it has dimensions of 120×200×120 mm (excluding protruding connectors) which is approximately 30% of the size of the bench top system of Figure 8. This comparison is illustrated in Figure 15. Different connectors could be employed to further reduce the device’s physical size, but this is not a priority since the current sizing can easily be accommodated on our mobile robots. With the PMD sensor, 19200 simultaneous range measurements at sampling frequencies of up to 24 Hz to centimetre precision have been achieved. Sub-centimetre acquisition requires sampling at rates of 0.1 Hz or lower. Range disambiguation has been implemented [16,17] with little loss of precision.
Fig. 14. Completed portable FFRIS
The field of view of the system is limited only by the optical hardware. Using a 16 mm focal length lens results in a field of view (horizontal × vertical) of 22.2° × 16.5°. Care must be taken with the selection of lens as wider angle lenses in particular will introduce optical distortion. Calibration of the system for different lens types will mitigate this effect. Figure 16 displays a sample (face of a mannequin) output from the system where colour has been used to illustrate the range. This image was taken with a modulation frequency of 36 MHz and a frame integration time of 20 ms. As required, changes in acquisition time, laser intensity, and modulation frequencies can easily be made by a user.
Design and Construction of a Configurable Full-Field Range Imaging System
153
Fig. 15. Comparison of portable and bench top FFRIS
Fig. 16. Colour enhanced range full-field range image
9 Summary Reviewing the original specifications, this completed FFRIS satisfies all of the essential and desirable requirements. Specifically: • •
The system is able to operate at configurable modulation frequencies up to 40 MHz. All modulation and synchronisation frequencies are generated within the FPGA and are precisely frequency locked with each other.
154
D.A. Carnegie et al.
• • • • •
•
•
•
The illumination intensity of the laser diodes can be easily changed in software. Full-field range measurements are calculated by the on-board embedded FPGA. This range can be visually displayed, or provided in numerical form for another processor. No external PC is required unless the configuration details are to be altered or the frames transferred for long-term storage or analysis. The lasers are protected from over-current during turn-on or in the event of loss of modulation or control signals. The device can be entirely powered by the 12 V batteries that power most of the fleet’s mobile robots. The system has been currently over-engineered allowing for a maximum power consumption of 90 W. In operation 50 – 60 W is a more typical figure, but this can increase particularly if greater intensity is required from the laser diodes. Regardless, for the mobile robots in our fleet, the robot’s locomotive motors easily dominate power requirements. The device is inexpensive. The largest cost is the sensor (currently 1000 euro), with the next most expensive component being the FPGA which is of the order of 100 euro. Total component cost of the system is approximately 2000 euro. It is compact with the most significant room for improvement being a change of the connectors. Whilst commercial production could further reduce the system size, it is comparable to other systems currently on the market. Acquisition time and modulation frequency can be varied in software to provide versatility between real-time operation where precision may not be so critical through to longer acquisition, high precision measurements when greater environmental detail is required.
Whilst other devices on the market may outperform our system in one or more of spatial resolution, frame rate, depth precision or size, none out perform us on all of these criteria. The most significant advantage of our solution is that it is extremely configurable and provides a solution for a greater range of situations than any other systems we have investigated.
References [1] Sharp GP2Y3A003K and GP2Y2A002K at http://sharp-world.com/products/device/catalog/index.html [2] Sick, http://www.sick.com/ [3] Jongenelen, A.P.P.: Development of a Configurable Range Imaging System for Unambiguous Range Determination, PhD Thesis under examination, Victoria University of Wellington (2010) [4] Christie, S., Hill, S.L., Bury, B., Gray, J.O., Booth, K.M.: Design and Development of a Multi-Detecting Two-Dimensional Ranging Sensor. Measurement Science and Technology 6, 1301–1308 (1995)
Design and Construction of a Configurable Full-Field Range Imaging System
155
[5] Blais, F.: Review of 20 years of range sensor development. Journal of Electronic Imagine 13(1), 231–243 (2004) [6] Carnegie, D.A., Cree, M.J., Dorrington, A.A.: A high-resolution full-field range imaging device. Review of Scientific Instruments 76(8) (2005) [7] Dorrington, A.A., Carnegie, D.A., Cree, M.J.: Towards 1 mm depth precision with a solid-state full-field range imaging system. In: Proceedings of SPIE: Sensors, Cameras, and Systems for Scientific/Industrial Applications, San Jose, CA, USA, vol. 6068 (2006) [8] Dorrington, A.A., Cree, M.J., Payne, A.D., Conroy, R.M., Carnegie, D.A.: Achieving sub-millimetre precision with a solid-state- full-field heterodyning range imaging camera. Measurement Science and Technology 18, 2809–2816 (2007) [9] Jongenelen, A.P.P., Carnegie, D.A., Payne, A.D., Dorrington, A.A.: Development and characterisation of an easily configurable range imaging system. In: Proceedings of the 24th International Conference Image and Vision Computing (NZ), Wellington, New Zealand, pp. 79–84 (2009) [10] Payne, A.D., Dorrington, A.A., Cree, M.J., Carnegie, D.A.: Characterization of modulated time-of-flight range image sensors. In: SPIE – 7239 3D Imaging Metrology, San Jose, CA, USA (2009) [11] Büttgen, B., Seitz, P.: Robust optical time-of-flight range imaging based on smart pixel structures. IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems I: Regular Papers 55, 1512–1525 (2008) [12] PMDTechnologies, http://www.pmdtec.com/ [13] MESA Imaging, http://www.mesa-imaging.ch/ [14] Canesta Inc., http://canesta.com/ [15] Dorrington, A.A., Cree, M.J., Carnegie, D.A., Payne, A.D., Conroy, R.M., Godbaz, J.P., Jongenelen, A.P.P.: Video-rate or High-Precision: A Flexible Range Imaging Camera. In: Proceedings SPIE Image Processing: Machine Vision Applications, San Jose, CA, USA, vol. 6813 (2008) [16] Jongenelen, A.P.P., Carnegie, D.A., Payne, A.D., Dorrington, A.A.: Maximizing precision over extended unambiguous range for TOF range imaging systems. In: Proceedings of the 27th IEEE International Instrumentation and Measurement Technology Conference, Austin, TX, USA, pp. 1575–1580 (2010) [17] Jongenelen, A.P.P., Bailey, D.G., Payne, A.D., Dorrington, A.A., Carnegie, D.A.: Analysis of Errors in ToF Range Imaging with Dual-Frequency Modulation. IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation & Measurement (publication pending) [18] Payne, A.D., Jongenelen, A.P.P., Dorrington, A.A., Cree, M.J., Carnegie, D.A.: Multiple frequency range imaging to remove measurement ambiguity. In: 9th Conference on Optical 3-D Measurement Techniques, Vienna, Austria, pp. 139–148 (2009) [19] McClymont, J.: The Development of Extrospective Systems for Mobile Robots. ME Thesis, Victoria University of Wellington (2010) [20] Jongenelen, A.P.P., Bailey, D.G., Payne, A.D., Carnegie, D.A., Dorrington, A.A.: Efficient FPGA Implementation on Homodyne-Based Time-of-Flight Range Imaging. Journal of Real-Time Image Processing, Special Issue (2010) (publication pending)
Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 as an Ammonia Gas Sensor Gotan H. Jain1,*, S.B. Nahire2, D.D. Kajale1, G.E. Patil1, S.D. Shinde3, D.N. Chavan4, and V.B. Gaikwad3 1
Materials Research Lab., Arts, Commerce and Science College, Nandgaon 423 106, India
[email protected] 2 G.M.D. Arts, B.W. Commerce and Science College, Sinnar, India 3 Materials Research Lab., K.T.H.M. College, Nashik 422 005, India 4 Department of Chemistry, Arts Commerce and Science College, Lasalgaon 422 306, India
Abstract. The thick films of pure BaTiO3 (BT) were prepared by screenprinting technique. The gas sensing performances of these films were tested to various gases by using static gas sensing system at various operating temperatures. The pure film showed maximum response to H2S gas at 350oC but poor selectivity. Different wt% of Cr (0.56, 5.27 and 6.07) was added in BaTiO3, base material, followed by sintering at 550oC for 30min. The thick films of such powder were prepared by screen-printing technique. The thick films of this Crdoped BT were prepared and tested to various gases. The Cr2O3-doped BT film (5.27wt %) showed maximum response to ammonia gas at 350oC and suppresses the response to H2S gas. The response of 5.27wt% film was observed to be the most amongst the 0.56 and 6.07wt. The selectivity of the Cr2O3-doped BT was found to be more against the other gases. The 90% response and recovery levels were attained within 3 and 20 s, respectively for Cr2O3-doped BT (5.27wt %) film. The very short response and recovery time are the important features of this Cr2O3-doped BT film to NH3 gas. Keywords: BaTiO3, thick films, NH3 gas sensor, sensitivity, selectivity.
1 Introduction In the recent, sensors have attracted a great deal of attention from scientists and engineers. Even in the near future, it is expected to gain importance in view of the construction of more or less intelligent ensembles, which integrate actuating, sensing and computing subsystems. Detection of various gases using solid-state chemistry has generated a great deal of interest, both in academia and in industry. Although much research has been focused on sensors based on SnO2 technology, other inorganic oxides are receiving increased attention. These include binary oxides, such as oxides of titanium, tungsten, and gallium, and more complex ternary oxides. Compounds having pervoskite structures are among one of the most important classes of ternary oxides. Barium titanate (BaTiO3) is one of the most intensively investigated *
Corresponding author.
S.C. Mukhopadhyay et al. (Eds.): New Developments and Appl. in Sen. Tech., LNEE 83, pp. 157–167. springerlink.com © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011
158
G.H. Jain et al.
ferroelectrics and has been widely used in electronic industry in applications for capacitors, thermocouples, transducers, sensors and actuators, etc. A number of studies have focused on the chemistry and physics of the response of these materials to gases. Depending on the conditions, these compounds can behave as n- or p-type semiconductors. Because of their structural similarity, similar mechanisms of interaction with gases are expected to occur for these compounds, although the relative importance of the mechanisms for any specific operating condition would depend, in each instance, on the specific compound. It is well known that a number of pervoskite oxides (ABO3) have been used as gas sensor materials because of their stability in thermal and chemical atmospheres. So over the last decade, the pervoskite oxide ceramics such as BaTiO3 (BT) have created and promoted interest in chemical sensors. It is capable of detecting a particular gas in the high temperature region, 175-450oC, near and above the temperature giving the maximum resistivity [1]. Modifications in the microstructure, the processing parameters and also the concentration of acceptor/donor dopants can vary the negative temperature coefficient of the resistance (NTCR) and conductivity of BaTiO3. It is also known in literature [2-6] that PTCR (positive temperature coefficient region) disappears completely when donar-doped BaTiO3 was annealed at high temperatures in atmosphere of low oxygen partial pressure. BaTiO3 is well known for the detection of CO [8, 9], CO2 [10-12], humidity [13], etc. Various attempts have been made to improve the selectivity and sensitivity of BaTiO3 by using dopants and additives [14, 15]. There are a few reports dealing with BaTiO3-based gas sensors. Efforts are, therefore, made to develop BaTiO3 - based gas sensors and for the improvement in its sensing performance by doping and modifying the surface of the thick films. Pure and modified BaTiO3 are observed to be most sensitive to H2S gas. Some well-known materials for H2S gas sensing are SnO2-ZnO-CuO [16], SnO2-Pd [17], SnO2-Al2O3 [18], SnO2CuO [19-24], SnO2-CuO-SnO2 [25], and ZnSb2O6 [26]. Researchers have developed various types of sensors by adding different additives [1,27-29] into semiconducting BaTiO3. The sensing materials modified by incorporating different additives, either by doping or dipping technique. The sensing performance of pure and modified BaTiO3 films was studied in terms of the change in conductance in the presence and absence of gases.
2 Experimental 2.1 Preparation of BaTiO3 Powder Powders of Ba(OH)2.8H2O and TiO2 of analytical reagent grade were ball milled to mix thoroughly at the same molar concentrations. The mixture was sintered at 1000oC for 6h to obtain BaTiO3 [30, 31]. The fine-grain powder of BaTiO3 was obtained by milling in a planetary ball mill for 2h. The sub micron size powder was then used to formulate the paste for printing of thick films. 2.2 Preparation of BaTiO3 Thick Films The thixotropic paste was formulated by mixing the fine powder of BaTiO3 with a solution of ethyl cellulose (a temporary binder) in a mixture of organic solvents such as
Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 as an Ammonia Gas Sensor
159
butyl cellulose, butyl carbitol acetate and terpineol, etc. The ratio of the inorganic to organic part was kept at 75:25 in formulating the paste. This paste was screen printed [32, 33] on a glass substrate in a desired pattern. The films were fired at 550oC for 30 min. Silver contacts were made for electrical measurements. 2.3 Preparation of Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 Thick Films Different wt% of CrO3 was added in BaTiO3, base material, followed by sintering at 550oC for 30min. CrO3 is not thermally stable above its melting temperature (197oC). At higher temperature, it loses oxygen to give stable Cr2O3. In this way, the Cr2O3doped BaTiO3 powder was obtained. The thick films of such powder were prepared by screen-printing technique. 2.4 Thickness Measurements The thickness of the thick films was measured by using the Taylor-Hobson (Talystep, UK) system. The thicknesses of the films were observed in the range from 65 to 70μm. The reproducibility in thickness of the films was possible by maintaining the proper rheology and thixotropy of the paste.
3 Characterization Results 3.1 Structural Properties Fig. 1 shows the X-ray diffractogram of a Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 thick film, for 5.27wt% of Cr. The observed peaks are matching well with the reported data [34] of BaTiO3 confirming the single phase of the compound. The presence of separate Cr2O3 peaks indicates the composite nature of the material i.e. independent identity of Cr2O3. The average grain size calculated from Scherrer formula was 278 nm.
Fig. 1. X-ray diffractogram of Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 thick film
160
G.H. Jain et al.
3.2 Microstructural Analysis Fig. 2(a) depicts a SEM image of an unmodified BaTiO3 thick film fired at 550oC. The film consists of voids and a wide range of particles with particle sizes ranging from 200 to 1330nm distributed non-uniformly. Fig. 2(b-d) depictS SEM images of Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 thick films fired at 550oC with 0.56, 5.27 and 6.07wt% of Cr, respectively. The agglomeration of particles increases as Cr2O3 wt% increases. The change in doping concentration changes the particle sizes. The particle sizes ranging from 0.3 to 1.0μm (Fig. 2(b)), 0.5 to 1.0μm (Fig. 2(c)), and 0.66 to 2µm (Fig. 2(d)) were observed.
(a)
(c)
(b)
(d)
Fig. 2. SEM images of (a) unmodified BaTiO3 film and Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 films with (b) 0.56wt%, (c) 5.27wt%, and (d) 6.07wt% of Cr.
3.3 Elemental Analysis The constituent elements such as Ba, Ti, O and Cr associated with various films are represented in Table 1. It reveals from the table that the film with 5.27wt% of Cr was observed to be the most oxygen deficient as compared to other samples. This deficiency could be attributed to the larger oxygen adsorption capability of the sample.
Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 as an Ammonia Gas Sensor
161
Table 1. Quantitative elemental analysis
Samples Unmodified BaTiO3 Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 : 0.56wt% Cr : 5.27wt% Cr : 6.07wt% Cr
Ba 80.46 82.08 79.07 76.39
wt% of Ti O 12.63 6.91 13.17 4.19 11.30 4.36 12.28 5.26
Cr 0.56 5.27 6.07
3.4 Electrical Conductivity of Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 Films Fig. 3 represents the variation of conductivity with temperature for the pure and Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 (BT) films. The legends suffixed with ‘a’ are the graphs for the conductivities of the films in the air ambient, while legends suffixed ‘g’ are the graphs for conductivities of the films in the NH3 gas ambient. It is clear from the graphs that the conductivity is varying approximately linearly with temperature for all films. The conductivity of Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 films was observed to be increased.
Log(conductivity)1/Ohm-m
-0.2
BT(a) BT+0.56wt%Cr(a) BT+5.27wt%Cr(a) BT+6.07wt%Cr(a)
-1.2
BT(g) BT+0.56wt%Cr(g) BT+5.27wt%Cr(g) BT+6.07wt%Cr(g)
-2.2 -3.2 -4.2 -5.2 -6.2 1.3
1.5
1.7
1.9
2.1
2.3
2.5
2.7
1000/T(oK-1)
Fig. 3. Variation of electrical conductivity with temperature
3.5 Gas Sensing Performance 3.5.1 Gas Response of Unmodified BaTiO3 Film with Operating Temperature The variation of H2S gas response with operating temperature ranging from 100 to 450oC is shown in Fig. 4. The response goes on increasing with the temperature, attains its maximum (350oC) and then decreases with further increase in temperature. It is clear from graph that the optimum operating temperature is 350oC.
162
G.H. Jain et al.
60
Gas response
50 40 30 20 10 0 100
150
200 250 300 350 Operating Tem p.( oC)
400
450
Fig. 4. H2S gas (100ppm) response with operating temperature
3.5.2 Selectivity Fig. 5 shows the histogram of the selectivity of pure BaTiO3 film to various gases. The table attached to histogram shows the gas response values to various gases. It reveals that H2S gas is most selective against CO2 and poor selective against NH3 gas.
Gas response
50 40 30 20 10 0 Pure BT
CO
LPG
7
11
H2S
NH3
Ethanol
CO2
53.38
21
10
3.2
Gases
Fig. 5. Selectivity of pure BaTiO3 films to various gases
3.5.3 Gas Response of Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 Films with Operating Temperature Fig. 6 depicts the variation of NH3 gas response with operating temperature. The response to NH3 gas goes on increasing with temperature for pure and doped films. The film with 5.27wt% of Cr was observed to be the most sensitive to NH3 gas and its optimum operating temperature was 350oC.
Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 as an Ammonia Gas Sensor
120
Pure BT BT+0.56w t%Cr BT+5.27w t%Cr BT+6.07w t%Cr
100 Gas response
163
80 60 40 20 0 100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
o
Operating temp.( C)
Fig. 6. Variations in NH3 gas (100ppm) response with operating temperature
3.5.4 Selectivity Fig. 7 shows the bar diagram of the selectivity of pure and Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 films to various gases at optimum operating temperature. The table attached to bar diagram indicates the gas response values to various gases. It is observed that the pure BaTiO3 film showed highest H2S gas response while Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 films showed highest response to NH3 gas.
Gas response
120 90 60 30 0
CO
LPG
H2S
NH3
Ethanol
CO2
Pure BT
7.0
11.0
53.4
21.0
10.0
3.2
BT+0.56w t%Cr
0.8
0.8
21.0
41.0
2.3
1.0
BT+5.27w t%Cr
1.2
1.3
4.2
111.7
3.6
2.3
BT+6.07w t%Cr
1.8
1.6
10.0
71.0
4.3
2.6
Gases
Fig. 7. Selectivity of Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 films to various gases
164
G.H. Jain et al.
3.5.5 Response and Recovery Time of Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 Sensor The transient response of Cr2O3-doped (5.2wt%) BaTiO3 film to NH3 gas is depicted in Fig. 8. The gas response of this film was found to be largest at 350oC. The 90% response and recovery levels were attained within 3 and 20s, respectively for this sample. The very short response and recovery time are the important features of this Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 film to NH3 gas.
100oC 200oC 300oC 400oC
100
Gas response
80
150oC 250oC 350oC 450oC
60 40 20 0 0
4
8
12 Time(s)
16
20
24
Fig. 8. Transient response of Cr2O3-doped (5.27wt%) BaTiO3 to NH3 gas
4 Discussions It is known that atmospheric oxygen molecules are adsorbed on the surface of Cr2O3doped BaTiO3 semiconductor oxide in the forms of O- and O2- thereby decreasing the electronic conduction. Atmospheric oxygen molecules take electrons from the conduction band of Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 to be adsorbed as O-BaTiO3. The reaction is as follows: O2(g) + 2e- → 2O-BaTiO3
(1)
The Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 is more oxygen deficient as compared to pure BaTiO3. The excess Ba ions (due to oxygen vacancies) act as donors [35]. When reducing gas molecules like NH3 react with negatively charged oxygen adsorbates, the trapped electrons are given back to conduction band of Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3. The energy released during decomposition of adsorbed ammonia molecules would be sufficient for electrons to jump up into conduction band of Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3, causing an increase in the conductivity of sensor. The possible reaction is: 2NH3 + 3O-BaTiO3 → 3H2O + N2 + 3e-
(2)
For this reaction to proceed to the right hand side, some amount of activation energy has to be provided thermally. An increase in operating temperature surely increases the thermal energy so as to stimulate the oxidation of NH3 (equation (2)). The reducing gas
Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 as an Ammonia Gas Sensor
165
(NH3) donates electrons to Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3. Therefore, the resistance decreases, or the conductance increases. This is the reason why the gas response increases with operating temperature. The point at which the gas response reaches maximum is the actual thermal energy needed for the reaction to proceed. However, the response decreases at higher operating temperatures, as the oxygen adsorbates are desorbed from the surface of sensor [36]. Also, at high temperatures the carrier concentration increases due to intrinsic thermal excitation, and the Debye length decreases. This may be one of the reasons for the decreased gas response at high temperatures. When the optimum amount of Cr (5.27wt%) is incorporated into the BaTiO3 material, the Cr2O3 species would be uniformly distributed. Due to this, not only the initial resistance of the film is high but this amount would also be sufficient to promote the catalytic reaction effectively and the overall change in the resistance on exposure of ammonia gas leading to high sensitivity. When the amount of Cr2O3 on the surface of base material, BaTiO3, is less than the optimum, the dispersion may be poor and the sensitivity of the film is observed to be decreased since this amount may not be sufficient to promote the reaction effectively. On the other hand, as the amount of Cr2O3 on BaTiO3 surface is more than the optimum, an additive Cr2O3 would be distributed more densely. As a result, base material BaTiO3 would be masked and the overall change in the resistance on the exposure of gas would be smaller leading to lower response to ammonia gas.
5 Conclusions Following statements can be made from the experimental results. 1) 2) 3) 4)
The thick films of unmodified BaTiO3 were sensitive to H2S gas. The Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 was observed to be semiconducting in nature. The Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 was most sensitive and selective to NH3 gas. The resistance of the Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 films in ambient air was observed to be very high. 5) The resistance of the Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 films was observed to decrease suddenly upon exposure to NH3 gas at optimum operating temperature. 6) The fast recovery of the sensor could be attributed to the larger oxygen deficiency in BaTiO3. The larger oxygen deficiency would enable BaTiO3 to adsorb more oxygen ions, helping the sensor to recover fastly. 7) Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 was observed to be more sensitive to NH3 gas than unmodified BaTiO3.
References 1. Zhou, Z.G., Tang, Z.L., Zhang, Z.T.: Studies on grain-boundary chemistry of pervoskite ceramics as CO gas sensors. Sens. Actuators B 93, 356–361 (2003) 2. Haayman, P.W., Van Dam, R.W., Klaasens, H.A.: Method of preparation f semiconducting materials. German Patent 929350 (1995) 3. Jaffe, P., Cook Jr., W.R., Jaffe, H.: Piezoelectric Ceramics, p. 94. Academic Press, New York (1971)
166
G.H. Jain et al.
4. Sahuri, O., Wakino, K.: Processing techniques and applications of positive temperature coefficient thermistors. IEEE Trans. Component 10, 53 (1963) 5. Ravi, V., Kutty, T.R.N.: Current limiting action of mixed phase BaTiO3 ceramic semiconductors J. Appl. Phys. 68, 4891 (1990) 6. Kutty, T.R.N., Ravi, V.: Varistor property of n-BaTiO3 based current limiters. Appl. Phys. Lett. 59, 2691 (1991) 7. Zhou, Z.G., Tang, Z.L., Zhang, Z.T.: Studies on grain-boundary chemistry of pervoskite ceramics as CO gas sensors. Sens. Actuators B 93, 356–361 (2003) 8. Tang, Z.T., Zhou, Z.G., Zhang, Z.T.: Experimental studies on the mechanism of BaTiO3 based PTC CO gas sensor. Sens. Actuators B 93, 391–395 (2003) 9. Ishihara, T., Kometani, K., Nishi, Y., Takita, Y.: Improved sensitivity of CuO-BaTiO3 capacitance type CO2 sensor. Sens. Actuators B 28, 49–54 (1995) 10. Liao, B., Wei, Q., Wang, Q.Y., Liu, Y.X.: Study on CuO-BaTiO3 semiconductor CO2 sensor. Sens. Actuators B 80, 208–214 (2001) 11. Haeusler, A., Meyer, J.U.: A novel thick film conductive type CO2 sensor. Sens. Actuators B 34, 388–395 (1996) 12. Wang, J., Xu, B.K., Liu, B.F., Zhang, J.C., Zhang, T.: Improvement of nanocrystaline BaTiO3 humidity sensing properties. Sens. Actuators B 66, 159–160 (2000) 13. Wagh, M.S., Patil, L.A., Seth, T., Amalnerkar, D.P.: Surface cupricated SnO2-ZnO thick films as a H2S gas sensor. Mater. Chem. Phys. 84, 228–233 (1985) 14. Kanefusa, S., Nitta, M., Haradome, M.: High sensitivity H2S gas sensor. J. Electrochem. Soc. 132, 1770–1773 (1985) 15. Lantto, V., Romppainen, P.: Response of some SnO2 gas sensors to H2S after quick cooling. J. Electrochem. Soc. 135, 2550–2556 (1988) 16. Tamaki, J., Maekawa, T., Miura, N., Yamazoe, N.: CuO-SnO2 element for highly sensitive and selective detection of H2S. Sens. Actuators B 9, 197–203 (1992) 17. Manorama, S., Sarala Devi, G., Rao, V.J.: Hydrogen sulfide sensor based on tin oxide deposited by spray pyrolysis and microwave plasma chemical vapor deposition. Appl. Phys. Lett. 64, 3163–3165 (1994) 18. Sarala Devi, G., Manorama, S., Rao, V.J.: Gas sensitivity of SnO2/CuO heterocontacts. J. Electrochem. Soc. 142, 2754–2756 (1995) 19. Tamaki, J., Shimanoe, K., Yamada, Y., Yamamoto, Y., Miura, N., Yamazoe, N.: Dilute hydrogen sulfide sensing properties of thin film prepared by low pressure evaporation method. Sens. Actuators B 49, 125–186 (1998) 20. Vasiliev, R.B., Rumyantseva, M.N., Yakovlev, N.V., Gaskov, A.M.: CuO/SnO2 thin film heterostructures as chemical sensor for H2S. Sens. Actuators B 50, 186–193 (1998) 21. Mangamma, G., Jayaraman, V., Gnanasekaran, T., Periaswami, G.: Effects of silica addition on H2S sensing properties of CuO-SnO2 sensors. Sens. Actuators B 53, 133–139 (1998) 22. Yuanda, W., Maosong, T., Xiuli, H., Yushu, Z., Guorui, D.: Thin film sensors of SnO2CuO-SnO2 sandwich structure to H2S. Sens. Actuators B 79, 187–191 (2001) 23. Tamaki, J., Yamada, Y., Yamamoto, Y., Matsuoka, M., Ota, I.: Sensing properties of dilute hydrogen sulfide of ZnSb2O6 thick film prepared by dip-coating method. Sens. Actuators B 66, 70–73 (2000) 24. Yamazoe, N., Kurokawa, Y., Seiyama, T.: Effects of additives on semiconductor for gas sensor. Sens. Actuators B 4, 283–289 (1983) 25. Lee, M.S., Meyer, J.U.: A new process for fabricating CO2-sensing layers based on BaTiO3 and additives. Sens. Actuators B 68, 293–299 (2000)
Cr2O3-doped BaTiO3 as an Ammonia Gas Sensor
167
26. Ishihara, T., Kometani, K., Nishi, Y., Takita, Y.: Improved sensitivity of CuOBaTiO3capacitive type CO2 sensor by additives. Sens. Actuators B 28, 49–54 (1995) 27. Lee, J.D.: Concise In-organic Chemistry, 5th edn., p. 698 28. Manku, G.S.: In-organic Chemistry, pp. 465–467 29. Patil, L.A., Wani, P.A., Sainkar, S.R., Mitra, A., Pathak, G.J., Amalnerkar, D.P.: Studies on “fritted” thick films of photoconducting CdS. Mater. Chem. Phys. 55, 79 (1998) 30. Aslam, M., Chaudhary, V.A., Mulla, I.S., Sainkar, S.R., Mandale, A.B., Belhekar, A.A., Vijaymohan, K.: A highly selective ammonia gas sensorusing surface-ruthenated zinc oxide. Sens. Actuators A 75, 162–167 (1999) 31. Chaudhary, V.A., Mulla, I.S., Vijaymohan, K.: Impedance studies of an LPG sensor using surface ruthenated tin oxide. Sens. Actuators B 55, 127–133 (1999) 32. Niranjan, R.S., Chaudhary, V.A., Sainkar, S.R., Patil, K.R., Mulla, I.S., Vijaymohan, K.: Surface ruthenated tin oxide thin-film as a hydrocarbon sensor. Sens. Actuators B 79, 132– 136 (2001) 33. Chaudhary, V.A., Mulla, I.S., Vijaymohan, K.: Comparative studies of doped and surface modified tin oxide towards hydrogen sensing: synergistic effects of Pd and Ru. Sens. Actuators B 50, 45–51 (1998) 34. ASTM Data Manuals, pp. 34–129 35. Ishihara, T., Kometani, K., Hashida, M., Takita, Y.: Application of mixed oxide capacitor to the selective carbon dioxide sensor. J. Electrochem. Soc. 138, 173 (1991) 36. Cotton, F.A., Wilkinson, G.: Advanced Inorganic Chemistry, 2nd edn., p. 828. Interscience Publishers, John Wiley & Sons (1967)
Physical and Electrical Modeling of Interdigitated Electrode Arrays for Bioimpedance Spectroscopy M. Ibrahim1, J. Claudel1, D. Kourtiche1, B. Assouar2, and M. Nadi1 1
Electronic Instrumentation Laboratory of Nancy, Nancy University, France 2 Institute Jean Lamour, Nancy University, France
Abstract. This paper concerns a theoretical and electrical modelling of interdigital sensor in a wide band frequency. A theoretical approach is proposed to optimize the use of the sensor for bioimpedance spectroscopy. CoventorWare® software was used to modelize in three dimensions the interdigital sensor system for measuring electrical impedance of biological medium. Complete system simulation by Finite element method (FEM) was used for sensor sensitivity optimization. The influence of geometric parameters (number of fingers, width of the electrodes, …), on the impedance spectroscopy of biological medium was studied. A high level description of the sensor and the biological medium was also developed under VHDL-AMS with SystemVision® software from mentor graphics. The simulation results are compared with measurements obtained with a true interdigitated sensor illustrating a good correlation. This shows that even the theoretical model is simple, it remains very effective.
1 Introduction Electrical impedance measurement has been demonstrated as a potential useful approach in biomedical applications. This method allows to determine the physiological status of ex vivo or living tissues as well as their electromagnetic characterization [1]. The changes induced by some pathologies could be associated with variations of essential tissue parameters such as the physical structure or the ionic composition that can be reflected as changes in the passive electrical properties. The range of applications derived from this technique is quite wide [2, rigaud et morucci]. Planar interdigitated electrode arrays have become more prominent as a sensor device due to the ongoing miniaturization of electrodes and the low cost of those systems [3]. An important advantage of these sensor devices is the simple and inexpensive mass-fabrication process and the ability to use these devices over a wide range of applications without significant changes in the sensor design [4-5]. Typically these sensors have been used for the detection of capacitance, dielectric constant and bulk conductivity in biological medium [6-7]. Basically, the structure consists on two S.C. Mukhopadhyay et al. (Eds.): New Developments and Appl. in Sen. Tech., LNEE 83, pp. 169–189. springerlink.com © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011
170
M. Ibrahim et al.
parallel coplanar electrodes whose design (width, gap between electrodes, length) is repeated periodically [8]. This paper, based on previous work [9], presents a new approach of physical and electrical modelling system of a biological sensor. The electrical and physical modelling of the Interdigital sensor and the medium was developped by using COVENTORWARE® and Systemvision (MENTORGRAPHICS®) sofware respectively. Section two describes the correlation between design parameters and frequency behavior in coplanar impedance sensors. By developing total impedance equations and modeling equivalent circuits we propose a theoretical optimization of the geometrical parameters of the sensor. One objective was to get the optimal ratio between the width of the electrodes and the gap. The third section gives a description of the sensor and medium model with the finite element method FEM using CoventorWare® software. We studied the influence of the medium’s physical properties on the frequency sensor response. We simulated the influence of electrodes number and we found the number 16 as optimized for a cross section 1mm*1mm. In the fourth section, we give a description of electrical model for IDT sensor with VHDL-AMS (SystemVision software®). This software provides an electrical approach that can be readily used in current electronic design flow to include distributed physics effects. VHDL-AMS language permits to simulate the sensor and medium. It allows fast simulations to validate a simplified model and to serve as a reference to power conditioning. The sensor manufacturing is described in the fifth section. A test bench based on a measurement system composed by RCL meter connected with computer was built to test the sensor. Preliminary bioimpedance measurements were done on calibrated ionic solution of NaCl. Section six concludes on the validity of models and presents the perspectives.
2 Theoretical Aspect 2.1 Description of Interdigital Sensors Interdigital sensor is equivalent to a parallel plate capacitor (Figure 1) [10-11]. An electric field is created between the positive and negative electrodes (instantaneous polarity) shown on figure 1 (a) and (b) respectively. When a medium is placed on the sensor, the electric field across the medium under test is also shown on figure 1 (c). The dielectric properties of the material as well as the geometry of the material under test affect the capacitance and conductance between the two electrodes. The variation of the electric field can be used to determine the properties of the material depending on the application. To use them in bioimpedance domain, a potential difference is applied between two electrodes and the electrical impedance between the electrodes is measured. The electrodes of the interdigital sensor are coplanar, so the measured impedance will have a very low signal-to-noise ratio.
Physical and Electrical Modeling of Interdigitated Electrode Arrays
171
Fig. 1. Funtion principle of an Interdigital sensor.
The main dimensional characteristics parameters of such a pair of electrodes are (figure 2): 1. 2. 3. 4.
The number of digits N. The length of digit L. The digit width W. The distance between a digits S.
Fig. 2. Interdigitated sensor structure and dimensional parameters
2.2 Equivalent Circuit Model Figure 3.a gives the configuration of the planar structure when switched as an interdigitated impedance cell. When such a cell is immersed in an electrolyte, the simplified equivalent electrical circuit is represented by figure 3.b.
Fig. 3. (a) Configuration of interdigitated impedance cell and (b) its equivalent circuit
172
M. Ibrahim et al.
The electrical elements in the equivalent circuit modelize the physical phenomena that determine the total electrical impedance (Z) detected in the measurement cell (figure 3.a). Thus, the equivalent model elements could be expressed in terms of physical quantities. The resistance RSol of the resistance is the sensing element and is related to the electrolyte conductivity σSol by the cell constant KCell [12]: RSol =
KCell
(1)
σSol
The cell constant KCell is equal to [13] : KCell =
1
with K (k ) = ∫
0
2
(N - 1)L
1
(1 - t² )(1 - k²t² )
()
K k
. K
( 1 - k² ) ⎛π W ⎞ . ⎟ ⎝2 S+W⎠
dt and k = cos⎜
(2)
Where N is the number of fingers, S the finger spacing, W the finger width and L the finger length. The function K(k) is the incomplete elliptic integral of the first kind [14]. So, the cell constant depends entirely on the geometry of the sensor. The lead resistance RLead is the result of the series resistances of the connecting wires. Direct capacitive coupling between the two electrodes is represented by the cell capacitance CCell given by: CCell =
ε 0. ε r, Sol
(3)
KCell
with εr,sol ≈ εr,water = 80. One model element which is not drawn in figure 1.b is a capacitor representing the direct capacitive coupling between the connecting wires. This capacitor comes in parallel with CCell and will therefore virtually increase the observed cell capacitance. The impedances that explain the interface phenomena occurring at the electrodeelectrolyte interfaces, are simplified to the double layer capacitances CDL. These are depending on the electrode material and the electrolyte solution but, for horizontal electrode surfaces, they can be approximated by: CDL = 0.5.A. CDL, Surface = 0.5.W.L.N.CDL, Surface
(4)
where A is the electrode surface and CDL,Surface the characteristic of the double layer capacitance of the electrode-electrolyte system. One must notice that the factor 0.5 is the result of CDL determined by only half of the electrode surface A. The characteristic of the double layer capacitance CDL, Surface is supposed to be equal to the characteristic capacitance of the Stern layer for electrolytes having a quite high ionic strength. This characteristic capacitance of the Stern layer is approximated by CStern, Surface = 10-20 μF/cm2 [15, 16].
Physical and Electrical Modeling of Interdigitated Electrode Arrays
173
Based on the equivalent circuit of figure 1.b, the total observed impedance can be expressed as
( )
Z jω = 2RLead +
Z1
(5)
j.ω.CCell. Z1 + 1
Where Z1 = RSol +
2 j.ω.CDL
2.3 Theoretical Optimization of the Sensor
Impedance, Ohm
Figure 4 shows a schematic graph of total impedance of equivalent circuit (Figure 3.b). There are three zones in the impedance spectrum, which correspond to the three kind of elements in equivalent circuit. The frequency dependent property of these zones can be analysed using the equivalent circuit mentioned above. As shown in Figure 3.b, there are two parallel branches (CCell and CDL). When the frequency is not adequatly higher than fHi, the current cannot cross the middle of the dielectric capacitor. That is, the capacitor is inactive, and just acts as an open circuit. Then , the total impedance corresponds to the double layer capacitance and solution resistance in series. Although both CDL and RSol provide to the total impedance below fHi, each of them dominates at different frequencies.
Cdl
Rsol
Ccell
Frequency, Hertz
Fig. 4. Schematic diagram of total impedance–frequency plots
The CDL becomes essentially resistive at the frequency lower than fLow, and it contributes mainly to the total impedance value: Z≈
2 + jω .CDL.RSol j.ω .CDL
(6)
174
M. Ibrahim et al.
and fLo ≈
1
(7)
π. RSol CDL
The impedance increases with the decrease in the frequency (double layer region). However, above fLow, double layer capacitance offers no impedance. This is explained by the fact that only the resistance of the solution contributes to the impedance while below fHi the influence of CCell is not yet indicative, the total impedance is independent of the frequency (resistance of the solution zone). This results into a frequency band, restricted by fLo and fHi, in which the results (e.g. the conductivity) can be deduced from the observed impedance using:
( )
Z jω = 2RLead + RSol
(8)
To optimize the impedance cell leads to maximize the plateau width in the curve of figure 4. When the frequency is higher than fHi, the current cross the middle of the dielectric capacitor instead of crossing the electrolyte solution resistance. That is, the branch (CDL + RSol + CDL) is inactive, and the branch (CCell) is active. In this zone, the dielectric capacitance of the medium governs the total impedance, and the double layer capacitance and medium resistance could be neglected. Thus, the total impedance value is inversely proportional to the frequency: Z≈
RSol j.ω .CCell.RSol + 1
(9)
and fHi ≈
1
(10)
2. π .RSol.CCell
Or in terms of conductivity parameters:
σSol
fLo ≈
(11)
0.5.π .W. L. N. CDL, Surface . KCell
and fHi ≈
σSol 2.π . ε 0. ε
(12) r, Sol
Note that the higher boundary frequency, fHi, is not dependent on the geometry, according to the theory, when the wiring capacitance is not present. Obviously, maximising the width of the plateau can only be done by decreasing the lower boundary frequency. In order to make the lower boundary frequency (11) as low as possible, the geometrical term
Physical and Electrical Modeling of Interdigitated Electrode Arrays
W. L. N. KCell (N, L, S, W)
175
(13)
should be maximised. When using a square structure of L*L, one variable can be eliminated since L*L : L = N. (W+S) - S With L in mm and S in microns L+S≈L Finaly L = N. (W+S)
(14)
However, it is more illustrative to introduce a factor a = S/W. Using the substitutions: W=
L N
.
1
and S =
(a + 1)
L N
.
a
(a + 1)
(15)
Which are based on equation (15) together with the ratio a, expression (13) becomes: 2.L
.
1
(N - 1) (a + 1)
()
K k
. K
( 1 - k² )
= X (N, L) * Y(a)
(16)
Where
(
)
X N, L =
2.L
(N - 1)
and Y(a ) =
1
(a + 1)
()
K k
. K
( 1 - k² )
The function K has the same meaning as it had in equation (2). This optimisation expression, which has to be maximised in order to minimise flo, can be split into two parts. The first is the factor X (N, L), showing that the cell size L*L must be as large as possible while the number of fingers must be reduced. Since there is no maximum in the desired cell size, with respect to the optimisation of flo, the value L can be chosen arbitrarily. A cell size of about 1*1 mm² will be used in the modeling. The optimal number of fingers N has a minimum for N = 2 since this is the lowest possible number of fingers. On the other side, the sensitivity of the impedance measurement depends on the number of fingers. Then, the modelling allows us to study the influence of the number of fingers on the impedance measurement. The highest the number of fingers, the highest the sensitivity. The factor X (N, L) is related to the sum W+S according to equation (14), the second factor in expression (16) has only the ratio W/S = a as a parameter. In figure 5 this factor is plotted as a function of a, a varying from 0 to 10. For a = 1, the finger width is equal to the gap between them. It can be seen that this is not the optimal ratio, for a = 0.66 the optimisation function has a maximum which means that the finger width should be approximately 1.5 the gap width W = 3S/2. This maximum for the function denoted in the figure as f (a) is equal to 0.66.
176
M. Ibrahim et al.
Therefore, when designing a square structure, the design rule, based on the maximum frequency range criterion becomes according to equation (14): L = (2.5N-1).S. When the minimum number of fingers, N = 2, is also taken into account, the design rule becomes : L = 5S. 0.7
Y(a) 0.6 X: 0.66 Y: 0.51
0.5
Y(a)
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
a
Fig. 5. Optimisation of the S/W ratio.
3 COVENTORWARE® Modeling 3.1 Model Description In this section, the model of the sensor loaded by the blood medium is described. This model was developed for simulation with the finite element method FEM using CoventorWare® software. We used the module MEMS electro quasistatic harmonic response proposed by the software. 3.1.1 Sensor Modeling The structure of the impedance sensor used in this simulation is at micron scale. It is composed by layers of glass and platinum and is showed in figure 6. A glass layer of length 1 000 µm and width of 1 000 μm has been defined as a substrate thickness of 1 000 μm to carry the system (gray layer on figure 6). The glass is a good electrical insulator (10-17S.m-1) with a relative permittivity around 5-7. As the glass has a very small permittivity, we do not need to put an insulating layer between the substrate and the electrodes. Next, we define a mask of platinum electrodes (thickness 1 μm) known as a good conductor 9.66*106 S·m-1, using the graphical editor of CoventorWare. This is deposited on the glass (red layer on figure 5). The effective region of electrodes forms a square 1 000 μm*1 000 μm.
Physical and Electrical Modeling of Interdigitated Electrode Arrays
177
Fig. 6. 3D view of a planar interdigitated electrode arrays.
The characteristic parameters of the electrodes, the length of digit L, the number of digits N, the digit width W and the distance between a digits S, were selected according to formulas of optimization given in section 2: L is fixed at 1000 μm, W=
3.S 2
μm, S =
L
(5.N/2 − 1)
μm
and N is a variable. For example, N = 4 electrodes, S = 1000/(5.4/2-1) = 111 μm and W = 3.111/2 = 167 μm. 3.1.2 Modeling the Medium The medium modeled is composed by two layers: The two layers DL, that describe the interface phenomena occurring at the electrode-electrolyte interfaces, are simplified to a single equivalent layer. This is the first layer shown on figure 7 (green layer). The second layer is the blood (blue layer). The double layer can be formed from interface phenomena platinum electrodemiddle blood, with a thickness about 50 A° [17]. The relative permittivity of the layer DL (thickness 50 A°) for medium blood is about 97 [18]. The 50 A° thickness creates problems for the mesh system, then they were shifted to a thickness of 10 µm (equal to 50 A°*2*1000) and a relative permittivity 194 000 (equal to 97 *2*1000) in order to not change the capacity of this layer. One can notice that DL layer is almost insulating. We tested the blood as a biological medium with 0.7 S/m as conductivity and 80 at a frequency of 1 Ghz as relative permittivity [19]. The layer of the blood was equal to 500µm of thickness.
178
M. Ibrahim et al.
Fig. 7. 3D view of a planar interdigitated electrode arrays and the blood medium.
3.2 Results and Discussion A 1 volt sinusoïdal signal between terminals of interdigitated electrodes and a frequency range from 100 Hz to 1000 GHz was applied. The biological impedance was measured for different cases of electrode configuration. For the first three models, we arbitrarily chose N equal 16 electrodes. Figure 8 shows the influence of the double layer DL on biological impedance of the blood medium. Simulation results are obtained with and without interface double layer DL. One can notice that the impedance is constant in the second case (without DL) and does not take into account the cut off frequencies fLo and fHi. The impedance consists of only resistance in parallel with capacitance (negligible). Figure 9 shows the influence of the conductivity of the blood medium. Simulation results are obtained for two different conductivity : 0.7 and 9 m/s. When the conductivity increases, the RSol decreases and the plateau shifts to a lower impedance. In addition, a change in the height of the plateau implies a change in the boundary frequencies fLo and fHi, (equations 11 and 12 of section 2). Figure 10 gives the influence of medium permittivity on biological impedance and the boundary frequencies fLo and fHi. By comparing simulation results for two different permittivities, one can observe that the permittivity does not affect the impedance for small frequencies (less than 107 Hertz). For high frequencies when the permittivity increases, the impedance decreases and the fHi takes a smaller value which is similar to the equations (12) of the second paragraph. Figure 11 gives simulation for N fingers. Six different structures were used with respect to the conditions of optimization explained above in the paragraph sensor modeling. The case N equal 2 is taken as reference since this is the lowest possible number of fingers. In this case we can see that the impedance shows an unpredicted resonance at high frequencies.
Physical and Electrical Modeling of Interdigitated Electrode Arrays
179
For N equals 8 a resonance is not observed but an unstable plateau occurs for high frequencies. Where N equals 12, there is not resonance or instability, but the distinction of fHi is not clear. The two curves of 16 and 20 electrodes are almost together, and we can distinguish three regions of frequencies between fLow and fHi. For N equal 30, the impedance curve shows a resonance at high frequency.
10
10
Impedance, Ohm
10
10
10
10
10
7
16 electrodes, with interface double layer DL 16 electrodes, out interface double layer DL
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
10 2 10
10
4
flow
10
6
10
8
fhigh1010
10
12
Frequency, Hertz
Fig. 8. Simulated impedance of a blood medium deposited on the structure of the sensor number of fingers 16 electrodes, with and without interface double layer DL.
10
10
Impedance, Ohm
10
10
10
10
10
10
8
16 electrodes, conductivity = 0.7 s/m 16 electrodes, conductivity = 9 s/m
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
10 2 10
10
4
flow
flow 10
6
10
8
fhigh 10
10
fhigh
10
12
Frequency, Hertz
Fig. 9. Impedance-frequency characteristics for t conductivities of 0.7 S / m and 9 S/m
M. Ibrahim et al.
7
10
16 electrodes, permittivity = 80 16 electrodes, permittivity = 5200
6
10
5
Impedance, Ohm
10
4
10
3
10
2
10
1
10
0
10 2 10
4
10
6
10
10
8
10
12
10
10
Frequency, Hertz
Fig. 10. Influence of the blood permittivity on the impedance. 7
10
2 electrodes 8 electrodes 12 electrodes 16 elctrodes 20 electrodes 30 electrodes
6
10
5
10
Impedance, Ohm
180
4
10
3
10
2
10
1
10
0
10 2 10
4
10
6
10
8
10
10
10
12
10
Frequency, Hertz
Fig. 11. Biological impedance of the medium at various the number of digits N.
Physical and Electrical Modeling of Interdigitated Electrode Arrays
181
4 VHDL-AMS Modeling 4.1 Model Description In this section, we describe the model of the sensor and the medium that we developed and simulated using the high-level behavioral language VHDL-AMS using SystemVision software. The systems libraries was used to describe the model as an electrical circuit. 4.1.1 Electrical Modeling for Sensor and Medium In VHDL-AMS, the sensor and medium are described as an electrical circuit. In this circuit, the impedance of medium depends on the geometry of the sensor; therefore one must model the sensor loaded by the medium. The general model, in figure 12, is obtained by symmetry from the simple model between two classical plane electrodes; that represents the impedance between two fingers.
Fig. 12. General electrical model for an interdigitated sensor with medium
CDL, e represents the double layer capacity per finger, ZMed, e and CCell, e the impedance of medium and the cell capacitance between two fingers. These components are governed by the same equations (1), (3) and (4), but with a different cell constant, which does not contain the term N and (N-1) : the electrodes form factor Ke (equation 17). Ke =
2
.
L K
()
K k
( 1 - k² )
(
)
= KCell. N - 1 and ZMed =
ZMed,
e
(N - 1)
= Zbe(jω ). KCell
(17)
This model can be easily be simulated in VHDL-AMS, but its remains very difficult to write its equations. It is necessary to simplify it in order to allow a simple use. To do this, one supposes that the effect of the double layer can be divided into two equal parts. We divide the interface capacity into two equal parts to obtain a parallel circuit between the electrodes (figure 13). This new model can be simplified in a simple circuit with 4 components : 2 double layer capacitors CDL, the cell capacitor CCell and the medium impedance ZMed. This is the circuit presented in the
182
M. Ibrahim et al.
theoretical part in figure 3.b. This simplified model proves that one can find the conductivity and permittivity of medium by using cell constant.
Fig. 13. Steps to simplify the model.
4.1.2 VHDL-AMS Description The sensor loaded by a blood sample is described, using VHDL-AMS, like a dipole consisting on simple passives components. Their values are calculated, from the geometric characteristics of the sensor and the medium. For example, the electrode constant is calculated with the Euler method in a loop (figure 14). The final circuit is realized by placing basic components with a loop; it is the “Port Map” function (figure 15). constant nu constant ki constant kip
: real : real : real
:= W/(W+G); :=sin(nu*MATH_PI/2.0); :=sqrt(1.0-ki**2);
pure function K(x:real) return real is variable y,nbr,pas,t,result: real; begin result:=0.0; pas:= 1.0/100000.0; for nbr in 1 to 99999 loop t:=real(nbr)/100000.0; y:= result + pas*(1.0/sqrt((1.0-t**2.0)*(1.0-(x**2.0)*(t**2.0)))); result:=y; end loop; return y; end K; constant Fac:real:= L*K(ki)/(2.0*K(kiP)); --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------constant ccel: real:=PHYS_EPS0*(epssub+epsech)*Fac;
Fig. 14. Example of calculation of constants (here: the electrodes form factor and CCell).
Physical and Electrical Modeling of Interdigitated Electrode Arrays
183
begin proc1 :for i in 1 to (N/2) generate c1:entity WORK.capa(ideal) generic map (cap => cdl) port map ( P1 => P1, P2 => NM(2*i-1)); c2:entity WORK.capa(ideal) generic map (cap => cdl) port map ( P1 => P2, P2 => NM(2*i)); end generate proc1; proc2 :for i in 1 to (N-1) generate c1:entity WORK.res(ideal) generic map ( re => rsol) port map ( P1 => NM(i), P2 => NM(i+1)); c2:entity WORK.capa(ideal) generic map ( cap => ccel)
Fig. 15. Placement of components by Port Map for an electrolytic medium.
4.2 Results and Discussion 4.2.1 Ionic Solution Sample An ionic solution is characterized by its conductivity σSol. So, the medium impedance ZMed,e is a resistance. This model has been simulated in VHDL-AMs using SystemVisionTM with the same parameters used in ConventorWare® model. We choose N=16, L=1mm, W=38µm, S=26µm and σSol=0.7 S/m. The frequency analysis simulation is made by connecting an alternative current source to the sensor. An AC current of 1A was applied at a frequency varying from 100Hz to 1GHz. Figure 15 gives the simulation result of the impedance variation. The central plateau is the resistance of the solution. Impedance (Ohm) 10
10
10
4
- simulation for 16 electrodes, conductivity=0,7 S/m
3
2
10
2
10
3
10
4
10
5
10
6
10
7
10
8
10
9
Frequency (Hz)
Fig. 16. Simulated impedance of a sensor with 16 electrodes, for an electrolytic medium with a conductivity of 0.7 S/m.
184
M. Ibrahim et al.
4.2.2 Blood Sample The electric and dielectric behavior of blood sample present more properties than a simple ionic solution. It is constituted by free cells in an electrolyte : the blood plasma. The cells are composed by an electrolyte which is contained in an insulating membrane. The classical modeling is a resistance for the electrolyte, and a résistance in series with a capacitor is given by Fricke’s model (figure 17). We take for ZMed,e the equation of figure 17 with the electrodes form factor. For this simulation, we keep the same geometric parameters than the previous simulation for ionic solution. The values for blood’s parameters are σP=1.5 S/m, σC=1 S/m, Cm=1.75 µF/cm² and Ø=55%. The surface capacity of membrane is high but less than the capacity of double layer. Its effect appears at higher frequency. The results of the simulation are given in figure 18 and figure 19.
Fig. 17. Fricke’s Model for blood and its equivalent impedance in [Ohm.m]. With rP, rC, Cm, a and Ø the resistivity of plasma in [Ohm.m], the intern resistivity of blood cells in [Ohm.m], the membrane surface capacity in [F/m], the radius of blood cells in [m] and the volume in percentage of blood cells. Impedance (Ohm) 4
10
3
- Simulation for 16 electrodes; blood model
10
2
10
2
10
3
10
4
10
5
10
6
10
7
10
8
10
9
10
Frequency (Hz)
Fig. 18. Simulated impedance of a sensor with 16 electrodes, for a blood medium.
Physical and Electrical Modeling of Interdigitated Electrode Arrays y 10
p
185
y
-2
Conductivity (S) 10
10
-4
-6
Capacity (F) 10
10
10
-8
-10
-12
10
2
10
3
10
4
10
5
10
6
10
7
10
8
10
9
Frequency (Hz)
Fig. 19. Conductance and capacity of a sensor with 16 electrodes for blood medium.
The figures 18 represents the impedance; one can see two plateaux which correspond respectively to the plasma resistance and plasma resistance in parallel with blood cell resistance. The value of capacitance is difficult to evaluate in this type of curve, but it is easily find in the figure 19. Figure 19 gives the conductance and the capacity versus the frequency. For the conductivity, each plateau represents respectively the plasma resistance and the plasma resistance in parallel with the blood cell resistance. In capacity, each plateau represents respectively the double layer capacity, the blood cells capacity and CCell.
5 Experimental Validation 5.1 Sensor Manufacturing The sensor was provided by our colleague from the IJL team (Institut Jean Lamour, Henri Poincaré-Nancy 1 University). It was obtained by a deposit of 500 nm platinum on an insulating glass substrate in a 5 steps process: • • • • •
Sensor cleaning with acetone and isopropanol. Deposition of a platinum by ion-beam sputtering. UV lithography: deposit resin, mask application, insolation and development. Ion beam etching. Removal resin with acetone and isopropanol.
Its geometrical parameters are N=100, W=4µm, S=8µm and L=1000µm. This is a first prototype sensor for which we recycled a mask designed for SAW interdigitated sensor previously developped at IJL. A printed circuit board (PCB) was designed and built to connect the sensor with an appropriat measuring instrument. The connections between the sensor and the PCB were realized using a gold wires bonding figure 20.
186
M. Ibrahim et al.
Fig. 20. Sensor and PCB connection and its gold wires bonding and partial microscopic view of the fingers
5.2 Measurements The measurement system is composed of an LCR meter HP4284A controlled by © VEE software with a GPIB interface. It allows a fast and automatic measurements between 20Hz and 1 MHz. A photography of this system is given in the figure 20a. The measurements were performed with a calibrated drop of ionic solution. This solution contains 0.9% of NaCl, and has an approximate conductivity of 0.72 S/m. We placed a drop directly on the sensor, as shown on figure 21.b. The sensor connections (bonding) were not isolated, and can cause some errors of measurements. These first measurements were done just to validate the model . Figure 22 shows the measurement results compared to VHDL-AMS simulation results.
(a) Fig. 21. (a): Measurement system using the HP4284A PRECISION LCR METER. (b): Deposit of a drop of calibrated solution on the sensor.
Physical and Electrical Modeling of Interdigitated Electrode Arrays
187
(b) Fig. 21. (continued) Impedance (Ohm) 5
10
4
Measured impedance for a NaCl calibrated solution: conductivity = 0.72 S/m
10
Simulated impedance for an ionic solution: conductivity = 0,72 S/m 3
10
2
10
2
10
3
10
4
10 Frequency (Hz)
5
10
6
10
7
10
Fig. 22. Comparison between measurements and the two simulations
Simulation of complex system by the finite element method with CoventorWare®, takes lot of memory for computation. For N equal 100 electrodes, our simulation equipment was not able to model and simulate the whole system. The preliminary experimental measurements agree with the simulation. One can see a plateau at higher frequency, at a level close to that of simulation, but the instrument frequency limitation do not allow to check the precise level. The slope of the curve is slightly lower in measurement, because the real system response is not exactly the same those classical passive electronic components.
188
M. Ibrahim et al.
6 Conclusion This paper presents a comparative approach for simulation of biological sensor modeling in physical and electrical domains using two softwares. CoventorWare® software for three dimensional interdigilal sensor simulation techniques to analyse the influence of the physical properties of the medium and the impedance response was used. The simulation results are in agreement with the theoretical equations of optimization. This optimization method used for bioimpedance spectroscopy sensor is obtained from theoretical equations, by developing total impedance equations and modeling equivalent circuits. The equations given relate the cutoff frequencies to the geometric parameters of the sensor and physical properties of the measured medium. A geometric structure of the sensor was proposed. The use of a square cross section permit to eliminate one of the geometric parameters of the sensor, that simplifies the optimization and the analysis of the sensor. Electrical modeling of the interdigital sensor and the medium is carried out with VHDL-AMS software from MENTOR GRAPHICS®. The use of VHDL-AMS language shows the advantage to combine multiphysical domains. The approach can be readily used in current electronic design flow to include distributed physics effects into modelling and simulation process with VHDL-AMS. Simulations results give similar results as physical simulation. However, all the physical properties are not represented, especially at high frequency. The useful properties are correctly simulated. The use of behavioural models in simulation simplify physics and explore interactions between different domains in a reasonable amount of time compared to physics modelling with CoventorWare® software. The simulation results of the impedance obtained with VHDL AMS don’t show any resonance because all the geometric parameters, such as thickness of the medium and the interactions between ions were not include in the model. The experimental results obtained with a sensor, designed by the IJL (Institut Jean Lamour, Nancy University) team, are in agreement with those obtained by simulation. The future goal is to design a specific sensor by optimizing its dimensions for blood measure samples. It will be necessary to design a tank on the active area of the sensor, to avoid measurement errors, and do measurement at higher frequency. The simulation and measured curves present many similarities; the preliminary experiment measures are satisfactory. The next goal is to realise our own sensor by optimizing dimensions to measure blood samples. It will be necessary to design a tank limited to the active area of the sensor, to reduce measurement errors, and allows measurement at higher frequency.
References