Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
Edited by
David E. Radcliffe Miguel L. Cabrera
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Grou...
75 downloads
2491 Views
6MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
Edited by
David E. Radcliffe Miguel L. Cabrera
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Cover design: A. Radcliffe, New York City.
CRC Press Taylor & Francis Group 6000 Broken Sound Parkway NW, Suite 300 Boca Raton, FL 33487-2742 © 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC CRC Press is an imprint of Taylor & Francis Group, an Informa business No claim to original U.S. Government works Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 International Standard Book Number-10: 0-8493-3777-1 (Hardcover) International Standard Book Number-13: 978-0-8493-3777-2 (Hardcover) This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reprinted material is quoted with permission, and sources are indicated. A wide variety of references are listed. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the author and the publisher cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials or for the consequences of their use. No part of this book may be reprinted, reproduced, transmitted, or utilized in any form by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without written permission from the publishers. For permission to photocopy or use material electronically from this work, please access www. copyright.com (http://www.copyright.com/) or contact the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc. (CCC) 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, 978-750-8400. CCC is a not-for-profit organization that provides licenses and registration for a variety of users. For organizations that have been granted a photocopy license by the CCC, a separate system of payment has been arranged. Trademark Notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation without intent to infringe. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Modeling phosphorus in the environment / editors, David E. Radcliffe, Miguel L. Cabrera. p. cm. ISBN 0-8493-3777-1 (alk. paper) 1. Phosphorus--Environmental aspects--Mathematical models. 2. Phosphorus cycle (Biogeochemistry)--Mathematical models. I. Radcliffe, David Elliott, 1948- II. Cabrera, Miguel L. III. Title. TD427.P56M63 2006 577’.14--dc22 Visit the Taylor & Francis Web site at http://www.taylorandfrancis.com and the CRC Press Web site at http://www.crcpress.com
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
2006049391
Preface Models of phosphorus (P) transport in the environment are finding many uses today from research on mechanisms to regulatory applications such as the Total Maximum Daily Load and Source Water Assessment and Protection programs and even in the courtroom. Many of the basic approaches to modeling P were developed in the 1980s. Despite other advancements in modeling, such as graphic user interfaces and the use of geographic information system layers and databases for developing input files, the basic approaches to modeling P have changed very little. Our understanding of P processes has advanced, and these new ideas need to be incorporated into the current models. The purpose of this book is to describe the basic approaches to modeling P, how the current models implement these approaches, and ways to improve the current models. In the first section, an introductory chapter sets the background, and it is followed by chapters on the general approaches to modeling runoff and erosion (Chapter 2), P in runoff (Chapter 3), leaching of P (Chapter 4), and stream processes that affect P (Chapter 5). This section ends with a chapter on the important issue of model uncertainty (Chapter 6). The second section describes six state-of-the-science watershed-scale P transport models. We start with two of the most commonly used dynamic semidistributed models, the Soil Water Assessment Tool (Chapter 7) and the Hydrologic Simulation Program-Fortran (Chapter 8). Next are two fully distributed models of intermediate complexity, the Annualized Agricultural Nonpoint Source Pollution (Chapter 9) and the Nonpoint Source Pollution Model for Water, Sediment, and Phosphorus Losses (Chapter 10). The section ends with two lumped models, the Watershed Ecosystem Nutrient Dynamic-Phosphorus (Chapter 11) and the Generalized Watershed Loading Functions model (Chapter 12). The third section discusses phosphorus indices (PIs), which represent one end of the modeling spectrum in that they are field-scale, long-term estimates of the risk of P loss, or in some cases the actual P loss, from the edge of fields. Chapter 13 is a comprehensive look at the PIs developed in each state. Chapter 14 illustrates some of the problems encountered in incorporating PIs into farm-scale manure management software. The incorporation of best management practices into P transport models is a priority, and Section 3 includes a chapter on this topic (Chapter 15). Monitoring data from fields and streams are critical in calibrating and assessing the accuracy of watershed-scale models, and Section 3 concludes with a chapter on data for modeling (Chapter 16). The final section consists of a chapter on suggestions to improve modeling of P (Chapter 17). The idea for this book originated in the Modeling Workgroup of the Organization to Minimize Phosphorus Losses from Agriculture (SERA-17) (http://www.sera17. ext.vt.edu/). Many of the chapter authors are members of SERA-17, but the project has expanded beyond this group and includes a number of outside authors.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Editors David E. Radcliffe has been with the University of Georgia, Athens, since 1983, where he is a professor in the crop and soil sciences department. He teaches an undergraduate and two advanced graduate courses in soil physics and team teaches an introductory course in water resources. He received a B.S. in naval science from the U.S. Naval Academy and an M.S. and Ph.D. in soil physics from the University of Kentucky, Lexington. His research is focused on watershed-scale modeling of phosphorus and sediment transport and modeling of on-site wastewater systems. Dr. Radcliffe has published more than 70 journal articles and book chapters and has been an associate editor and technical editor for the Soil Science Society of America (SSSA) Journal. He has been chair of the Soil Physics Division of the SSSA and is currently a board member and fellow of the SSSA. Miguel L. Cabrera joined the University of Georgia, Athens, in 1990 and is currently a professor in the crop and soil sciences department. He teaches an undergraduate course in soil fertility, a graduate seminar course, and a graduate course in nutrient cycling models. He received a B.S. in agronomy (Ing. Agr.) from Facultad de Agronomia, Universidad de la Republica, in Uruguay, and an M.S. and Ph.D. in agronomy from Kansas State University, Manhattan. His research is focused on nitrogen and phosphorus cycling in soils fertilized with animal manures. Dr. Cabrera has published more than 100 journal articles and book chapters, has served as associate editor for Agronomy Journal, and is currently on the editorial board of Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems. He is a fellow of the ASA and SSSA.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Acknowledgments We would like to thank John Sulzycki and Jill Jurgensen with the Taylor & Francis Group for their support and patience. We thank the authors for their hard work in writing and reviewing chapters. Finally, we thank the following outside chapter reviewers: Ms. Carolyn Adams, East National Technology Support Center, USDA NRCS Dr. Wole Akinremi, University of Manitoba Dr. Bruce Beck, University of Georgia Dr. Douglas Beegle, Pennsylvania State University Dr. W. J. Chardon, University of Wageningen Dr. Thomas Daniel, University of Arkansas Dr. Paul Delaune, University of Arkansas Dr. Barnali Dixon, University of South Florida Dr. William Effland, USDA NRCS, Washington, D.C. Dr. Thomas Fisher, University of Maryland Dr. Don Flaten, University of Manitoba Ms. Jennifer Gilbert, University of Delaware Dr. James Hamlett, Pennsylvania State University Dr. Philip Haygarth, University of Sheffield Dr. William Jokela, USDA ARS, Marshfield, WI Dr. Peter Kinnel, Canberra, Australia Dr. Antonio Lo Porto, Water Research Institute, Bari, Italy Dr. John Lory, University of Missouri Dr. Rory Maguire, North Carolina State University Dr. Kyle Mankin, Kansas State University Dr. Anne McFarland, Tarleton State University Mr. Don Meals, Ice.Nine Environmental Consulting, Burlington, VT Dr. Nicolaos Nikolaidis, Technical University of Crete Dr. L. Mark Risse, University of Georgia Mr. Lawrence Schinkel, Alberta Agriculture Dr. J. Thomas Sims, University of Delaware Dr. Puneet Srivastava, Auburn University Dr. Allen Torbert, National Soil Dynamics Laboratory, USDA-ARS Dr. Peter Vadas, Pasture Systems and Watershed Management Research Unit, USDA-ARS Dr. Forbes Walker, University of Tennessee
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Contributors J.G. Arnold Grassland, Soil, and Water Research Lab USDA-ARS Temple, Texas Stefanie G. Aschmann USDA NRCS Portland, Oregon Keith Beven Environmental Science/Lancaster Environment Centre Lancaster University Lancaster, UK Ronald L. Bingner National Sedimentation Laboratory USDA-ARS Oxford, Mississippi Faycal Bouraoui European Commission–DG Joint Research Centre Institute for Environment and Sustainability Ispra, Italy Miguel L. Cabrera Crop and Soil Sciences Department University of Georgia Athens, Georgia E. Alan Cassell The Rubenstein School of Environment and Natural Resources University of Vermont Burlington, Vermont
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Indrajeet Chaubey Department of Biological and Agricultural Engineering University of Arkansas Fayetteville, Arkansas Theo A. Dillaha Department of Biological Systems Engineering Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University Blacksburg, Virginia Bradley Eisenhauer Department of Agronomy Purdue University West Lafayette, Indiana Margaret W. Gitau Biological and Agricultural Engineering University of Arkansas Fayetteville, Arkansas C.H. Green Grassland, Soil, and Water Research Laboratory USDA-ARS Temple, Texas Brian E. Haggard USDA-ARS Biological and Agricultural Engineering Department Crop, Soil, and Environmental Sciences Department University of Arkansas Fayetteville, Arkansas Daren Harmel USDA-ARS Grassland, Soil and Water Research Laboratory Temple, Texas
Philip Hess Department of Agronomy Purdue University West Lafayette, Indiana Brad Joern Department of Agronomy Purdue University West Lafayette, Indiana Robert L. Kort USDA NRCS Colchester, Vermont Zhulu Lin Crop and Soil Sciences Department University of Georgia Athens, Georgia
David E. Radcliffe Crop and Soil Sciences Department University of Georgia Athens, Georgia Elliot M. Schneiderman New York City Department of Environmental Protection Kingston, New York Andrew N. Sharpley Pasture Systems and Watershed Management Research Unit USDA-ARS University Park, Pennsylvania
Malcolm McGechan Environment Division Scottish Agricultural College Bush Estate Penicuik, UK
R. Srinivasan Department of Biological and Agricultural Engineering Texas A&M University College Station, Texas
K.W. Migliaccio Agricultural and Biological Engineering Department University of Florida Tropical Research and Education Center Homestead, Florida
Tamie L. Veith Pasture Systems and Watershed Management Research Unit USDA-ARS University Park, Pennsylvania
Nathan O. Nelson Department of Agronomy Throckmorton Plant Sciences Center Kansas State University Manhattan, Kansas
Jennifer Weld Department of Crop and Soil Sciences The Pennsylvania State University University Park, Pennsylvania
Trevor Page Environmental Science Lancaster Environment Centre Lancaster University Lancaster, UK
Mary Leigh Wolfe Biological Systems Engineering Department Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University Blacksburg, Virginia
John E. Parsons (Deceased) Department of Biological and Agricultural Engineering North Carolina State University Raleigh, North Carolina
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Yongping Yuan National Sedimentation Laboratory USDA-ARS Oxford, Mississippi
Table of Contents Section I Basic Approaches .....................................................................................................1 Chapter 1
Modeling Phosphorus Movement from Agriculture to Surface Waters .................................................................................3
Andrew N. Sharpley Chapter 2
Modeling Runoff and Erosion in Phosphorus Models......................21
Mary Leigh Wolfe Chapter 3
Modeling Phosphorus in Runoff: Basic Approaches ........................65
Miguel L. Cabrera Chapter 4
Basic Approaches to Modeling Phosphorus Leaching......................81
Nathan O. Nelson and John E. Parsons Chapter 5
Phosphorus Transport in Streams: Processes and Modeling Considerations ..................................................................................105
Brian E. Haggard and Andrew N. Sharpley Chapter 6
Uncertainty Estimation in Phosphorus Models ...............................131
Keith Beven, Trevor Page, and Malcolm McGechan Section II Models ...................................................................................................................161 Chapter 7
Phosphorus Modeling in Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) Model .................................................................................163
Indrajeet Chaubey, K.W. Migliaccio, C.H. Green, J.G. Arnold, and R. Srinivasan Chapter 8
Modeling Phosphorus with Hydrologic Simulation Program-Fortran ...............................................................................189
David E. Radcliffe and Zhulu Lin
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Chapter 9
Phosphorus Modeling in the Annualized Agricultural Nonpoint Source Pollution (AnnAGNPS) Model ...........................215
Yongping Yuan, Ronald L. Bingner, and Indrajeet Chaubey Chapter 10 ANSWERS-2000: A Nonpoint Source Pollution Model for Water, Sediment, and Phosphorus Losses .................................241 Faycal Bouraoui and Theo A. Dillaha Chapter 11 Watershed Ecosystem Nutrient Dynamics–Phosphorus (WEND-P Models) ..........................................................................261 Robert L. Kort, E. Alan Cassell, and Stefanie G. Aschmann Chapter 12 Modeling Phosphorus with the Generalized Watershed Loading Functions (GWLF) Model...............................277 Elliot M. Schneiderman Section III Phosphorus Indices, Best Management Practices, and Calibration Data...........................................................................................299 Chapter 13 Phosphorus Indices ..........................................................................301 Jennifer Weld and Andrew N. Sharpley Chapter 14 Challenges to Using and Implementing Phosphorus Indices in Nutrient Management Planning: an MMP Perspective ..............333 Philip Hess, Bradley Eisenhauer, and Brad Joern Chapter 15 Quantifying the Effects of Phosphorus Control Best Management Practices .....................................................................351 Margaret W. Gitau and Tamie L. Veith Chapter 16 Small Watershed Data Collection to Support Phosphorus Modeling ......................................................................383 Daren Harmel and Brian E. Haggard Section IV Modeling in the Future........................................................................................403 Chapter 17 Suggestions to Improve Modeling of Phosphorus ..........................405 David E. Radcliffe and Miguel L. Cabrera
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Section I Basic Approaches
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
1
Modeling Phosphorus Movement from Agriculture to Surface Waters Andrew N. Sharpley U.S. Department of Agriculture-Agricultural Research Service, University Park, PA
CONTENTS 1.1 Introduction.......................................................................................................3 1.2 Types of Models ...............................................................................................4 1.2.1 Process–Based Models..........................................................................5 1.2.2 Export Coefficient Models ....................................................................5 1.2.3 Statistical or Empirical Models ............................................................6 1.3 How Models Simulate P Transport ..................................................................6 1.3.1 Dissolved P............................................................................................6 1.3.2 Particulate P...........................................................................................8 1.4 Fertilizer and Manure Management ...............................................................10 1.5 Spatial Data Requirements for Modeling.......................................................11 1.6 Defining Future Best Management Practices.................................................12 1.7 How Models Simulate Fluvial Processes and Impact of P in Surface Waters....................................................................................12 1.7.1 Fluvial Processes .................................................................................12 1.7.2 Surface Water Impacts ........................................................................14 1.8 Summary .........................................................................................................14 References................................................................................................................15
1.1 INTRODUCTION Phosphorus (P), an essential nutrient for crop and animal production, can accelerate freshwater eutrophication, which is the most ubiquitous water quality impairment in the U.S., with agriculture a major contributor of P (Sharpley 2000; U.S. Geological Survey 1999). Environmental concerns from harmful algal bloom outbreaks
3
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
4
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
(Burkholder and Glasgow 1997) and regulatory pressure to reduce P loadings to surface waters via implementation of Total Maximum Daily Loads (TMDLs) (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 2000) have increased the urgency for information on the impacts of agricultural management, specifically conservation practices and best management practices (BMPs) on P loss. Because of the time and expense involved in assessing P loss, models are often a more efficient and feasible means of evaluating management alternatives. In their most comprehensive form, models can integrate information over a watershed scale to identify BMPs and critical source areas where BMPs are most likely to affect watershed-scale P losses. A common limitation to model application is the lack of detailed parameterization data on soil physical, chemical, and biological properties as well as on crop and tillage details. Thus, existing databases are increasingly being linked to nonpoint source models, often via geographical information systems (GIS). Generally, key input data for nutrient transport models involve land use, soil texture, topography, and management practices. Once these data are in digital form, GIS techniques can be used to combine them with experimental or model results to extrapolate other properties needed for model application. This introduction chapter previews the general principles of how models represent soil P release and transport, effects of mineral fertilizer and manure management on P loss, spatial resolution, and channel processes that translate edge-of-field losses to water body inputs. Future modeling efforts needed to address these issues are presented.
1.2 TYPES OF MODELS Models that simulate the runoff and water quality from watersheds can be categorized in several ways, but for purposes of this brief review they are segregated into three groups: 1. Process-based models: Models that explicitly simulate watershed processes, albeit usually conceptually. These models typically involve the numerical solution of a set of governing differential and algebraic equations that are a mathematical representation of processes such as rainfall runoff; infiltration leaching; P application method, rate, and timing; land management; and fate and chemical transformation of added P in soil. 2. Export coefficient models: Models that rely on land-use categorization — sometimes through a linkage to a GIS evaluation — coupled with export coefficients or event mean concentrations (EMCs), loosely categorized as spreadsheet approaches, although highly sophisticated in many cases. These models rarely, if ever, involve solution of a differential equation and almost always rely on simple, empirical formulations, such as the use of a runoff coefficient for generation of runoff from rainfall. 3. Statistical or empirical models: Models that involve regression or other techniques, which relate water-quality measures to various characteristics of the watershed. These models range from purely heuristic regression equations (e.g., Driver and Tasker 1990) to relatively sophisticated
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Phosphorus Movement from Agriculture to Surface Waters
5
derived-distribution approaches for prediction of the frequency distribution of loadings and concentrations (e.g., DiToro and Small 1984; Driscoll et al. 1989). All of the model types have their drawbacks related to availability of required data, scaling up from pedon input parameters, for example, to a watershed scale, and quantifying system functionality. For more detailed information on the approaches used in models described in the sections following and in other models, reviews are given as separate chapters in this publication.
1.2.1 PROCESS–BASED MODELS The Agricultural Nonpoint Source (AGNPS) Pollution model (Young et al. 1989, 1995) was originally developed to provide estimates of runoff water quality from watersheds of up to 20,000 hectares and to quantify the effects of BMPs targeted to specific areas. To make model output more meaningful to decision makers, such as conservationists and farmers, AGNPS, which ran on a storm or flow event basis, was recently superseded by an annualized version, Annualized AGNPS (AnnAGNPS) (Bingner et al. 2001; Croshley and Theurer 1998). The model operates on a cell basis that makes it possible to analyze spatially discrete management units (fields) within a watershed, thereby enabling identification of individual fields that may serve as critical source areas of nutrient export. AnnAGNPS is described in Chapter 9 of this book. The Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) was developed to assess the impact of land management on water quality in watersheds and large river basins (Arnold et al. 1998). The model runs on a continuous time step and is currently being utilized in a variety of large-scale studies to estimate the off-site impacts of climate and management on water use and nonpoint source loadings. SWAT is described in Chapter 7 of this book. Other process-based nutrient transport models include, but are not limited to Areal Nonpoint Source Watershed Environment Response Simulation 2000 (ANSWERS-2000) (Beasley et al. 1985; Bouraoui and Dillaha 1996), the Guelph Model for Evaluating the Effects of Agricultural Management Systems on Erosion and Sedimentation (GAMES) (Cook et al.. 1985), Hydrologic Simulation ProgramFortran (HSPF) (Johanson et al. 1984), Agricultural Runoff Model (ARM) (Donigian et al. 1977), Erosion Productivity Impact Calculator (EPIC) (Sharpley and Williams 1990), Groundwater Loading Effects of Agricultural Management Systems (GLEAMS) (Leonard et al. 1987), Watershed Ecosystem Nutrient DynamicsPhosphorus (WEND-P) (Cassell et al. 1998), and CENTURY (Parton et al. 1993). HSPF, ANSWERS-2000, and WEND-P are described in Chapters 8, 10, and 11, respectively.
1.2.2 EXPORT COEFFICIENT MODELS Export coefficient models have also been widely used to predict P loading of receiving water bodies (Beaulac and Reckhow 1982; Hanrahan et al. 2001;
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
6
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
Johnes et al. 1996). Export coefficients define P loss from a particular source or land use in a watershed and are usually derived from actual field measured losses of P or from EMC values, if runoff volumes are known (Johnes 1996; Johnes and Heathwaite 1997). Both export coefficients and EMCs fit easily into spreadsheet formats for watershed loading estimates. An advantage of EMCs is that they may be coupled with any hydrologic simulation model to produce loads. Export coefficient models calculate watershed export of P as the sum of individual loads from each source in the watershed. This approach accounts for the complexity of land-use systems, spatial distribution of data from various sources (point and nonpoint), and permits scaling up from plot to watersheds. As export coefficients are empirical, these types of models are as accurate as input data, as are process-based models (Hanrahan et al. 2001). Coefficients derived from short-term monitoring of small drainage areas, however, can contribute to predictive variability (Lathrop et al. 1998). The Generalized Watersheds Loading Functions (GWLF) model (Haith and Shoemaker, 1987) is an example of an export coefficient model and is described in Chapter 12.
1.2.3 STATISTICAL
OR
EMPIRICAL MODELS
Statistical models are empirical. Although they are derived from observations, the relationship described must have a basis in our underlying understanding of processes if we are to have faith in the predictive capabilities of the model (National Research Council 2000). Furthermore, extrapolation from empirical data is known to be fraught with danger. For example, scaling problems can occur when one extrapolates the results of scaled experiments to full-sized natural systems. One must, of course, always remain cognizant of the fact that system function may be scale dependent. Thus, these models are most judiciously used in the range of observational situations used to derive the model. Statistical or empirical models are most useful when they are based on first principles. The ability to describe system functions in terms of mathematical equations often gives the impression that the underlying principles are fully understood, as might be the situation in basic physics. Unfortunately, empirical coefficients introduced into these equations often hide the degree of uncertainty concerning these principles. This publication does not include reviews of any statistical models per se, but many P indices include statistical relationships and might be considered a type of statistical model. P indices are described in Chapter 13.
1.3 HOW MODELS SIMULATE P TRANSPORT 1.3.1 DISSOLVED P Most nonpoint source models simulate dissolved P transport in overland flow as a function of the extractability of P in the surface 5 cm of soil [e.g., Chemicals, Runoff and Erosion from Agricultural Management Systems (CREAMS), AGNPS]. This can be represented by Dissolved P = Extraction Coefficient × Available soil P × Overland flow volume (1.1)
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Phosphorus Movement from Agriculture to Surface Waters
7
2000 a. Overland flow 1500
Dissolved P (µg L-1)
1000
500
y = 1.98x + 79 R2 = 0.78
0 1000 b. Subsurface flow from lysimeters 750
500
250
0 0
y = 0.93x + 60 R2 = 0.79 200
400
600
800
Mehlich-3 extractable soil P (mg kg-1)
FIGURE 1.1 Relationship between the concentration of dissolved P in overland (a) and subsurface flow (b) from 30-cm-deep lysimeters and the Mehlich-3 extractable soil P concentration of surface soil (0 to 5 cm) from a central Pennsylvania watershed. (Adapted from R.W. McDowell and A.N. Sharpley, J. Environ. Qual. 30, 508–520, 2001; and A.N. Sharpley, P.J.A. Kleinman, R.J. Wright, T.C. Daniel, B. Joern, R. Parry, and T. Sobecki, in International Conference on Agricultural Effects in Ground and Surface Waters, J. Steenvooreden (Ed.), Wageningen, The Netherlands, International Association of Hydrologic Sciences.)
where dissolved P is orthophosphate loss in overland flow (kg ha−1), available soil P is the amount of P in a unit depth of surface soil — usually 5 cm — (Sharpley 1985b) as estimated by recommended soil test P methods (STP) (kg ha−1 5 cm−1), and extraction coefficient is the fraction of STP that can be released to overland flow for a given flow event volume (cm). Extraction coefficients can be determined as the slope of the linear regression of STP and overland flow dissolved P (Figure 1.1a). A similar relationship holds for subsurface flow P and surface STP, although the slope of the relationship (0.93) is almost half that for overland flow (slope of 1.98) (Figure 1.1b). The dependence of dissolved P transport in subsurface flow as well as overland flow suggests the importance of preferential flow pathways, such as earthworm burrows and old root channels, in the downward movement of P through the soil profile (Kleinman et al. 2003; McDowell and Sharpley 2001a; Sims et al. 1998).
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
8
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
Extraction coefficient
20
15
Native grass / pasture No till Reduced till Conventional till
10
0.30
y = 1.25x R2 = 0.90
5
0 0.001
0.01
0.1
1 -1
10
-1
Erosion (tonnes ha yr ) Decreasing soil cover FIGURE 1.2 Extraction coefficient — the slope of the relationship between soil test P and dissolved P in overland flow — as a function of erosion to represent soil vegetative cover for sites in Arkansas, Oklahoma, New York, and Pennsylvania. (Data adapted from D.H. Pote, T.C. Daniel, D.J. Nichols, A.N. Sharpley, P.A. Moore, Jr., D.M. Miller, and D.R. Edwards, J. Environ. Qual. 28, 170–175, 1999; McDowell and A.N. Sharpley, J. Environ. Qual. 30, 508–520, 2001; and A.N. Sharpley and S.J. Smith, Soil Tillage Res. 30, 33–38, 1994.)
Most models use a constant extraction coefficient value, assuming that STP extractability is similar among soils. A re-analysis of data published by McDowell and Sharpley (2001a), Pote et al. (1999), and Sharpley and Smith (1994) relating STP and overland flow dissolved P revealed a range of extraction coefficient values (Figure 1.2). Extraction coefficients were much greater for cropped (8 to 17) than grassed watersheds (1 to 4). Using erosion as a surrogate for land cover, extraction coefficients increased with greater erosion or decreased soil cover (Figure 1.2). Although erosion is influenced by other factors such as slope and soil structure, the sites used in this example were similar in slope (~4%). A larger soil P extraction coefficient represents a greater release of P as overland flow dissolved P per unit STP increases. This can be attributed to a lower degree of interaction between surface soil and overland flow with a protective grass cover than for a cropped situation, where the soil is more exposed to overland flow. Other factors that influence P release among soils are the dominant forms of P in soil, texture, aggregate diffusion, degree of interaction between soil and water, organic matter content, vegetative soil cover, and P sorption capacities.
1.3.2 PARTICULATE P As the sources of particulate P in overland flow and stream flow include eroding surface soil, stream banks, and channel beds, processes determining erosion also
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Phosphorus Movement from Agriculture to Surface Waters
9
control particulate P transport. In general, eroded particulate material is enriched with P compared to source surface soil, due to the preferential transport of finer (i.e., clay size), more sorptive soil and organic particles of greater P content than coarser inorganic particles (i.e., sand size). Sharpley (1985a) found that the plant available P content of sediment in overland flow was on average three times greater — or more enriched — than that of source soil and 1.5 times greater for total, inorganic, and organic P. The degree of P enrichment is expressed as a P enrichment ratio (PER), that is, the P concentration of sediment discharged divided by that of source soil. In assembling enrichment ratio information for the CREAMS model, Menzel (1980) concluded that for particulate P, a logarithmic relationship as in Equation 1.2 seemed to hold for a wide range of soil vegetative conditions. Ln (PER) = 2.00 – 0.16 Ln (Sediment discharge)
(1.2)
where sediment discharge is in kg ha−1. Most nonpoint source models adopted this approach to predicting particulate P transport in overland flow. This relationship is based on the well-documented increase in particulate P loss with increasing erosion (Figure 1.3). Based on the total P concentrations of source soils for each of the watersheds represented in Figure 1.3, PER decreases with an increase in erosion. As erosion increases, there is less particle-size sorting by overland flow, relatively less clay-size particles are transported, and P enrichment thus decreases.
7.5
10 8 6
5.0 4
2.5
0 0.001
2
0.01
0.1
1
10
P enrichment ratio
Particulate P (kg ha-1)
Particulate P P enrichment ratio
1 100
Erosion (tonnes ha-1)
FIGURE 1.3 Particulate P loss and enrichment ratio of eroded sediment as a function of erosion in overland flow from watersheds in El Reno, Oklahoma. (Adapted from A.N. Sharpley, S.J. Smith, J.R. Williams, O.R. Jones, and G.A. Coleman, J. Environ. Qual. 20, 239–244, 1991; and S.J. Smith, A.N. Sharpley, J.W. Naney, W.A. Berg, and O.R. Jones, J. Environ. Qual. 20, 244–249, 1991.)
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
10
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
Once an appropriate PER is obtained from sediment discharge, particulate P loss can be calculated as Particulate P = Total soil P × Sediment concentration × PER × Overland flow volume
(1.3)
where particulate P is the loss in overland flow (kg ha−1), total soil P is the amount in a unit depth of surface soil (usually kg ha−1 5 cm−1), sediment concentration is g sediment L−1 overland flow, and PER is calculated from Equation 1.2, for a given flow event volume (cm).
1.4 FERTILIZER AND MANURE MANAGEMENT Fertilizer and manure management, as it affects P availability to overland flow over the near term, can profoundly affect prediction of P transport in overland flow. Although soil P represents a source of P enrichment in overland flow, the application of fertilizer and manure to soil — including type, method, timing, and rate of P application — can temporarily overwhelm relationships derived between STP and P in overland flow (Sharpley and Tunney 2000). As such, accounting for fertilizer and manure management in P models is essential to their accuracy under certain conditions. However, most models do not directly address the effect of applied P, either as fertilizer or manure, on P transport in overland flow. Rather, added P is incorporated into the soil P pool, and the extraction coefficient is adjusted. Thus, P transport in overland flow as affected by the amount, type, method, and time after applying P is, in general, poorly represented and predicted. Mineral fertilizer and manure represent concentrated sources of soluble P that can greatly increase dissolved P losses in overland flow. Consequently, the concentration of soluble P in these sources may provide effective predictions depending on the solubility of the P source, method of application, rate of application, and timing of application relative to the overland flow event (Figure 1.4) (Kleinman et al. 2002). Surface application of manure and mineral fertilizer concentrates P at the extreme soil surface where it is vulnerable to removal by overland flow (Eghball and Gilley 1999; McDowell and Sharpley 2001b; Sharpley et al. 1984). Although injection, knifing, and immediate incorporation of manure and fertilizer may decrease P losses, cultivation may increase site vulnerability to particulate P loss due to greater erosion potential (Andraski et al. 1985; Romkens et al. 1973). Modifying the effect of P source and application method on P concentrations in overland flow is the timing of application relative to when an overland flow event occurs (Sharpley 1997; Westerman and Overcash 1980). Immediately following application of a P source, the potential for P loss peaks and then declines over time, as applied P increasingly interacts with the soil and is converted from soluble to increasingly recalcitrant forms (Edwards and Daniel 1993). As a result, fertilizer and manure management effects on overland flow P are predictable.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Dissolved P in overland flow (µg L-1)
Modeling Phosphorus Movement from Agriculture to Surface Waters
11
6000 Poultry manure Swine slurry
4000 Dairy compost
Poultry litter
Dairy manure
2000
Poultry compost 0 0
2
4
6
8 -1
Water extractable manure P (g kg )
FIGURE 1.4 Relationship between water extractable manure P and the dissolved P in overland flow one week after manure or mineral fertilizer was broadcast (100 kg total P ha−1) on a Hagerstown silt loam soil (7 cm hr−1 rainfall for 30 min). (Adapted from P.J.A. Kleinman, A.N. Sharpley, B.G. Moyer, and G.F. Elwinger, J. Environ. Qual. 31, 2026–2033, 2002.)
1.5 SPATIAL DATA REQUIREMENTS FOR MODELING Models that assess nonpoint sources of P loss from agricultural lands rely on spatial data as input. Land use, soil properties, and topographic data that include stream locations and watershed boundaries are commonly required inputs. However, with an expansion in the geographical scale at which watershed processes are to be modeled, there is a great increase in the size of associated spatial databases. Data and parameter requirements also increase rapidly as models become more mechanistic to better represent physical and chemical processes and spatial interactions involved in P loss. The complexity of managing these large databases in support of a watershed model can limit the degree of spatial resolution of existing models. Spatial parameters are frequently lumped so that units having similar soil, land use, and topographic characteristics respond the same to driving variables, such as those used to simulate runoff generation. However, spatially lumped parameters can pose a problem when responses from lumped units cannot distinguish between relative spatial locations of individual units, which can be critical in determining P export from a watershed to a water body. To overcome the spatial data limitations thus far identified, a nested modeling approach is recommended. Field and farm scale models that incorporate the knowledge of P source and transport processes involved in P loss can be supported with highly detailed spatial databases that are already available in some areas or could be easily developed in others. Results and generalizations from these models could be aggregated to represent sub-basins in a simpler, less mechanistic model that requires lower spatial resolution. Similarly, results from sub-basin models could be further aggregated to represent whole watersheds of several hundreds of square kilometers in size. Beyond that scale and with enough knowledge of processes operating in individual subwatersheds,
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
12
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
the principles of mapping could be invoked to derive generalizations about large watersheds that span multiple physiographic regions, such as the Chesapeake Bay Watershed and Mississippi River Basin. Map units of the Major Land Resource Areas (MLRAs) of the U.S. are defined on the basis of topography, soils, and land use and, therefore, are ideally suited for extrapolating detailed studies of whole watersheds to the broader area of the MLRA map unit.
1.6 DEFINING FUTURE BEST MANAGEMENT PRACTICES The implementation of P control measures has often been carried out with insufficient knowledge as to the suitability of these practices for P control. A large number of BMPs exist; their suitability likely varies depending on the particular situation. Given that BMP impacts are largely site specific (Baker and Johnson 1983; Deere and Company 1995; U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 1993), defining future BMPs for P control depends a great deal on being able to establish the effectiveness of these BMPs under the variety of field conditions that are constantly encountered. Several factors complicate BMP assessment in a field situation: site variability, lack of controlled replication, and length of study time needed. In turning to models, we try to overcome some of these complications. Though models greatly simplify the natural system, they also provide a means of carrying out complex BMP evaluations. Nonetheless, the large amounts of data that have accumulated over the years can be extremely useful in working on a modeling approach to BMP evaluation (see Chapter 15 on BMPs in this book; Gitau et al. 2001). An initial step in modeling BMP-induced reduction in P loss is the characterization of the BMPs of concern with regard to their mechanisms of operation, such as source (i.e., soil P; type, rate, and form of P applied) and transport (i.e., runoff, erosion) factors controlling P loss. This characterization would enable identification of source and transport mechanisms impacted by particular BMPs and, thus, the determination of model changes that would be necessary to fully represent the BMPs (Gitau et al. 2001).
1.7 HOW MODELS SIMULATE FLUVIAL PROCESSES AND IMPACT OF P IN SURFACE WATERS In-channel processes modify the potential for agriculture to impact a downstream freshwater body. As surface water impacts drive activities such as TMDL development, understanding the role of in-channel or fluvial processes on P transport and the impact of transported P on downstream water bodies is necessary to link upstream changes in agricultural management with downstream water quality impacts.
1.7.1 FLUVIAL PROCESSES If simulating the influence of landscape processes on P transport seems complex, simulating fluvial processes that influence the form and amount of edge-of-field P
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Phosphorus Movement from Agriculture to Surface Waters
13
entering downstream water bodies is even more challenging. Basically, fluvial transport involves a complex and dynamic interaction of hydrologic, physical, chemical, and biological processes. As stream flow varies from base to storm flow, a greater cross-sectional area of channel sediments interacts with water, the course of some streams may even meander, and time of interaction between water and sediment or biotic material decreases. Fluvial erosion of gullies, ditches, and stream banks generally contributes subsoil material, which usually has a low P content and high P sorption capacity, which can function as a sink for P within the fluvial system (Baldwin et al. 2002; Sharpley et al. 1996). Fluvial P chemistry is dominated by the uptake and release of P by sediment, the direct and extent of which is a function of streamwater-dissolved P, sediment P (i.e., equilibrium P concentration), stream water pH, P released from dead biota, hydrolysis of organic P species, and changes in sediment crystallinity and oxidation and reduction. Biological uptake of P can decrease dissolved P, whereas bacteria can mediate a sizeable proportion — 30 to 40% — of sedimentary P uptake and release (Khoshmanesh et al. 1999; McDowell and Sharpley 2003). Biologically controlled P release during the decomposition of organic matter in sediments can be an important source of dissolved P at times of high temperature and low flow in areas with organic-rich sediments, such as streams draining forested areas. The effects of all these processes on fluvial P transport varies greatly, reflecting seasonal cycles, management of streamside land, sediment P forms, size of flow event, and streambed geology. Much information can be found on the influence of fluvial sediments on streamwater P. For example, McDowell et al. (2002) examined the processes controlling sediment P release to the Winooski River, Vermont, the largest tributary to Lake Champlain. Iron-oxide strip P (algal-available P) of the river sediments adjacent to agricultural land (3.6 mg kg−1) was significantly greater (p < .05) than that of sediments adjacent to forested land (2.4 mg kg−1). Notably, impoundment (731 mg kg−1) and reservoir sediments (803 mg kg−1) had greater total P concentrations than did river sediments (462 mg kg−1). This was attributed to more fines (< 63 µm) in impoundments and reservoirs (64%) than in river sediments (33%). Consequently, impoundment and reservoir sediments had lower abilities to release P to solution in the short term, thereby acting as P sinks. The results of this research clearly demonstrate that fluvial hydraulics has a strong influence on the properties of sediment within river systems. The input and delivery of fine sediments enriched with P was influenced by adjacent land use. The fluvial sediment, particularly at the outflow of the river into Lake Champlain for example, represents a store of P, which has a long-term potential to release a large amount of P to overlying waters. In the short term, however, river flow and physical properties of the sediments will influence the amount of sediment P leaving the watershed in the Winooski River, Vermont. Thus, modeling of inchannel or fluvial processes must account for variability in flow, local sources of P, and sediment properties, particularly near the point of impact. Because of these complexities, fluvial processes and changes in P forms and loads are not currently simulated or are simulated in a simple manner in most watershed models (Hanrahan et al. 2001).
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
14
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
1.7.2 SURFACE WATER IMPACTS Intuitively, biological responses are different among water bodies, with variations in geographic location, climate, water residence times, and surface area and depth of water body. For example, the Cannonsville Reservoir — which is part of the New York City water supply system — flushes in a matter of months, whereas Cayuga Lake — the longest Fingerlake in New York State — has a mean water residence time of about 12 years. Also, the Chesapeake Bay has a completely different set of critical biological indicators in comparison with the Gulf of Mexico (National Research Council 2000). In fact, the ratio of watershed drainage area and Bay water volume (2410 km2 km−3) is nearly an order of magnitude greater than any other lake or bay in the world; next is the Gulf of Finland (380 km2 km−3). As a result, simulation as well as management of the biological response within the Chesapeake Bay presents unique challenges because of the relatively large area for nutrient source inputs that must be considered. Although P loss in overland flow, the related effects of agricultural management, and how nutrients cycle within a water body can be simulated, it is still difficult to relate P loss as a function of watershed management to the biological response of a receiving water body. Because of the scales involved, connectivity, and dominant processes in terrestrial and aquatic systems, watershed and water-body response models have tended to develop independently. Summer et al. (1990) attempted to link watershed (i.e., AGNPS) and lake process (i.e., FARM POND) models. However, a lack of adequate water monitoring data, such as chemistry and flow rate, limits rigorous testing of their ability to simulate a lake’s response to changes in agricultural management and climate.
1.8 SUMMARY This brief introduction has presented background information on processes controlling P transport in overland and subsurface flow from agricultural landscapes and how nonpoint source models attempt to simulate P loss. New information on soil and site dependency of extraction coefficients relating STP and overland flow dissolved P and the use of enrichment ratios to estimate particulate P transport should be incorporated into these models. Also, incorporation of new formulations describing the release and transport of inorganic and organic P from manure in overland and subsurface flow will improve model predictions of P loss following land application of manures. However, much information on the fate and transport of P in agricultural landscapes and on the effectiveness of various BMPs to minimize this loss through source or transport controls is already available. Mechanisms are being developed to apply this information through innovative database management and integration with existing models to better use existing data rather than to reinvent the wheel. Many complex models are available and are gaining greater acceptance with managers and planners, as computers become more powerful and less expensive and as people become more comfortable using them. However, because models yield clear numerical results with which to gauge progress, they have a strong appeal to policymakers and managers — an appeal that can sometimes bring false confidence and misconceptions (Boesch et al. 2001). Though all models are wrong, some are useful. It is of critical importance that modelers clearly define what the model is useful
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Phosphorus Movement from Agriculture to Surface Waters
15
for and what it is not designed to do. Likewise, users must decide what they want to accomplish with a model. For example, one must consider the scale (i.e., field, watershed, or basin), time (i.e., flow event, annual, or multiyear), and level of accuracy (i.e., 0.1 or 10 kg ha−1 year−1) that needs to be simulated, as well as the amount of parameterization data available. Thus, a key to useful simulation of P loss is selection of the appropriate model and data to run it. If, for instance, one needs to identify areas in a watershed at greater risk for P loss to target remedial BMPs, then site-vulnerability tools such as the P index are available (Gburek et al. 2000; Lemunyon and Gilbert 1993). On the other hand, most P indices are not designed to quantify P loss as are many nonpoint source models described earlier in this discussion. Even so, it is clear that a great deal of uncertainty can exist in model computations. Uncertainty arises in connection with an imperfect representation of the physics, chemistry, and biology of the real world, caused by numerical approximations, inaccurate parameter estimates and data input, and errors in measurements of the state variables being computed. Whenever possible, this uncertainty should be represented in the model output (e.g., as a mean plus standard deviation) or as confidence limits on the output of a time series of concentrations or flows. The tendency described earlier for decision makers to believe models because of their presumed deterministic nature and exact form of output must be tempered by responsible use of the models by engineers and scientists such that model computations or predictions are not oversold or given more weight than they deserve. Above all, model users should determine that the model computations are reasonable in the sense of providing output that is physically realistic and based on input parameters within accepted ranges. Model uncertainty is addressed in Chapter 6 of this book. The role of modeling will be more and more important over the next decade in making management and policy decisions related to conservation programs and water-quality enhancement and enforcement. Also, the availability of water monitoring data is increasing in response to water quality concerns in the U.S. and other parts of the world and is providing new opportunities to develop, to calibrate, and to test watershed models. Monitoring data for models is discussed in Chapter 16 of this book. As we move forward, however, an interdisciplinary approach is needed that involves hydrologists, soil scientists, engineers, economists, animal scientists, and, possibly, rural sociologists. With the knowledge that many and varied working models exist, our efforts should be directed to improving or adapting existing models rather than reinventing or developing new models, except where major limitations have been clearly defined. Finally, and most importantly, it is essential that the most appropriate model be carefully selected to meet a user’s needs in terms of level of predictive accuracy needed, input data available, and scale of simulation being considered — both time and space.
REFERENCES Andraski, B.J., D.H. Mueller, and T.C. Daniel. 1985. Phosphorus losses in runoff as affected by tillage. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 49:1523–1527. Arnold, J.G., R. Srinivasa, R.S. Muttiah, and J.R. Williams. 1998. Large area hydrologic modeling and assessment part 1: model development. J. Am. Water Resour. Assoc. 34:73–89.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
16
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
Baker, J.L. and H.P. Johnson. 1983. Evaluating the effectiveness of BMPs from field studies. Pp. 281–304 in Agricultural Management and Water Quality, F.W. Schaller and G.W. Bailey (Eds.). Ames: Iowa State University Press. Baldwin, D.S., A.M. Mitchell, and J.M. Olley. 2002. Pollutant-sediment interactions: sorption, reactivity and transport of phosphorus. Pp. 265–280 in Agriculture, Hydrology and Water Quality, P.M. Haygarth and S.C. Jarvis (Eds.). Oxford: CABI International. Beasley, D.B., E.J. Monke, E.R. Miller, and L.F. Huggins. 1985. Using simulation to assess the impacts of conservation tillage on movement of sediment and phosphorus into Lake Erie. J. Soil Water Conserv. 40:233–237. Beaulac, M.N. and K.H. Reckhow. 1982. An examination of land use — nutrient export relationships. Water Res. Bull. 18:1013–1023. Bingner, R.L., F.D. Theurer, R.G. Cronshey, and R.W. Darden. 2001. AGNPS 2001 Web Site. http://www.ars.usda.gov/Research/docs.htm?docid=5199. Boesch, D.F., R.B. Brinsfield, and R.E. Magnien. 2001. Chesapeake Bay eutrophication: scientific understanding, ecosystem restoration, and challenges for agriculture. J. Environ. Qual. 30:303–320. Bouraoui, F. and T.A. Dillaha. 1996. ANSWERS-2000: Runoff and sediment transport model. J. Environ. Eng. 122(6):493–502. Burkholder, J.A. and H.B. Glasgow, Jr. 1997. Pfiesteria piscicidia and other Pfiesteriadinoflagellates behaviors, impacts, and environmental controls. Limnol. Oceanogr. 42:1052–1075. Cassell, E.A., J.M. Dorioz, R.L. Kort, J.P. Hoffmann, D.W. Meals, D. Kirschtel, and D.C. Braun., 1998. Modeling phosphorus dynamics in ecosystems: mass balance and dynamic simulation approaches. J. Environ. Qual. 27:293–298. Cook, D.J., W.T. Dickinson, and R.P. Rudra. 1985. GAMES — the Guelph model for evaluating the effects of agricultural management systems in erosion and sedimentation: User’s manual. Technical Report 126-71, School of Engineering, University of Guelph, Ontario. Croshley, R.G and F.G. Theurer. 1998. AnnAGNPS nonpoint pollutant loading model. Proceedings of the First Federal Interagency Hydrologic Modeling Conference, April 19–23, Las Vegas, NV. Deere and Company. 1995. Managing nonpoint source pollution in agriculture. Technical Report 272. 61265. Moline, IL: Deere and Company Technical Center. DiToro, D.M. and M.J. Small. 1984. Probability model of stream quality due to runoff. J. Environ. Eng. 110:607–628. Donigian, A.S., Jr., D.C. Beyerlein, H.H. Davis, Jr., and N.H. Crawford. 1977. Agricultural Runoff Management (ARM) Model Version II: Refinement and testing. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, EPA 600/3-77-098, Environmental Research Lab, Athens, GA. Driscoll, E.D., P.E. Shelley, and E.W. Strecker. 1989. Pollutant Loadings and Impacts from Highway Stormwater Runoff: Design Procedure. Mclean, VA: Office of Engineering and Highway Operations R&D, Federal Highway Administration. Driver, N.E. and G.D. Tasker. 1990. Techniques for Estimation of Storm-Runoff Loads, Volumes, and Selected Constituent Concentrations in Urban Watersheds in the United States. Reston, VA: U.S. Geological Survey. Edwards, D.R. and T.C. Daniel. 1993. Drying interval effects on runoff from fescue plots receiving swine manure. Trans. Am. Soc. Agric. Eng. 36:1673–1678. Eghball, B. and J.E. Gilley. 1999. Phosphorus and nitrogen in runoff following beef cattle manure or compost application. J. Environ. Qual. 28:1201–1210.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Phosphorus Movement from Agriculture to Surface Waters
17
Gburek, W.J., A.N. Sharpley, A.L. Heathwaite, and G.J. Folmar. 2000. Phosphorus management at the watershed scale: a modification of the phosphorus index. J. Environ. Qual. 29:130–144. Gitau, M.W., E. Schneiderman, W.J. Gburek, and A.R. Jarrett. 2001. An evaluation of best management practices installed in the Cannonsville Reservoir Watershed, New York. Proceedings of the 9th National Non-point Source Monitoring Workshop, August 27–30, Indianapolis, IN. Haith, D.A. and L.L. Shoemaker. 1987. Generalized watershed loading functions for stream flow nutrients. Water Res. Bull. 23(3):471–478. Hanrahan, G., M. Gledhill, W.A. House, and P.J. Worsfold. 2001. Phosphorus loading in the Frome catchment, UK: seasonal refinement on the coefficient modeling approach. J. Environ. Qual. 30:1738–1746. Johanson, R.C., J.C. Imhoff, J.L. Little, and A.S. Donigian. 1984. Hydrological Simulation Program-Fortran (HSPF): user’s manual. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, EPA-600/3-84-066, Athens, GA. Johnes, P.J. 1996. Evaluation and management of the impact of land use changes on the nitrogen and phosphorus load delivered to surface waters: The export coefficient modeling approach. J. Hydrol. 183:323–349. Johnes, P.J. and A.L. Heathwaite. 1997. Modelling the impact of land use change on water quality in agricultural catchments. Hydrol. Proc. 11:269–286. Johnes, P.J., B. Moss, and G. Phillips. 1996. The determination of total nitrogen and total phosphorus concentrations in freshwaters from land use, stock headage and population data: testing of a model for use in conservation and water quality management. Freshwater Biol. 36:451–473. Khoshmanesh, A., B.T. Hart, A. Duncan, and R. Beckett. 1999. Biotic uptake and release of phosphorus by a wetland sediment. Environ. Technol. 29:85–91. Kleinman, P.J.A., B.A. Needelman, A.N. Sharpley, and R.W. McDowell. 2003. Using soil phosphorus profile data to assess phosphorus leaching potential in manured soils. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 67:215–224. Kleinman, P.J.A., A.N. Sharpley, B.G. Moyer, and G.F. Elwinger. 2002. Effect of mineral and manure phosphorus sources on runoff phosphorus. J. Environ. Qual. 31:2026–2033. Krogstad, T. and Ø. Løvstad. 1989. Erosion, phosphorus and phytoplankton response in rivers of southeastern Norway. Hydrobiologia 183:33–41. Lathrop, R.C., S.R. Carpenter, C.A. Stow, P.A. Soranno, and J.C. Panuska. 1998. Phosphorus loading reductions needed to control blue-green algal blooms in Lake Mendota. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 55:1169–1178. Lemunyon, J.L. and R.G. Gilbert. 1993. The concept and need for a phosphorus assessment tool. J. Prod. Agric. 6:483–496. Leonard, R.A., W.G. Knisel, and D.A. Still. 1987. GLEAMS: groundwater loading effects of agricultural management systems. Trans. Am Soc. Agric. Eng. 30:1403–1418. McDowell, R.W. and A.N. Sharpley. 2001a. Approximating phosphorus release from soils to surface runoff and subsurface drainage. J. Environ. Qual. 30:508–520. McDowell, R.W. and A.N. Sharpley. 2001b. Phosphorus losses in subsurface flow before and after manure application to intensively farmed land. Sci. Tot. Environ. 278:113–125. McDowell, R.W. and A.N. Sharpley. 2003. Phosphorus uptake and release from stream sediments. J. Environ. Qual. 32: 937–948. McDowell, R.W., A. Sharpley, and A.T. Chalmers. 2002. Chemical characterisation of fluvial sediment: the Winooski River, Vermont. Ecol. Eng. 18:447–487.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
18
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
Menzel, R.G. 1980. Enrichment ratios for water quality modeling. Pp. 486–492 in CREAMS — A Field Scale Model for Chemicals, Runoff and Erosion from Agricultural Management Systems, vol. 3, W. Knisel (Ed.). Supporting Documentation, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Conservation Research Report 26, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C. National Research Council. 2000. Clean Coastal Waters: Understanding and Reducing the Effects of Nutrient Pollution. Washington, D.C.: National Academy Press. Parton, W.J., J.M.O. Scurlack, D.S. Ojima, T.G. Gilmanov, R.J. Scoles, D.S. Schimal, T. Kirchner, J.C. Menaut, T. Seastedt, E. Garcia Moya, A. Kamnalrut, and J.L. Kinyamario. 1993. Observations and modeling of biomass and soil organic matter dynamics for the grasslands biome world-wide. Global Biochem. Cycles 7:785–809. Pote, D.H., T.C. Daniel, D.J. Nichols, A.N. Sharpley, P.A. Moore, Jr., D.M. Miller, and D.R. Edwards. 1999. Relationship between phosphorus levels in three Ultisols and phosphorus concentrations in runoff. J. Environ. Qual. 28:170–175. Romkens, M.J.M., D.W. Nelson, and J.V. Mannering. 1973. Nitrogen and phosphorus composition of surface runoff as affected by tillage method. J. Environ. Qual. 2: 292–295. Sharpley, A.N. 1985a. The selective erosion of plant nutrients in runoff. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 49:1527–1534. Sharpley, A.N. 1985b. Depth of surface soil-runoff interaction as affected by rainfall, soil slope, and management. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 49:1010–1015. Sharpley, A.N. 1997. Rainfall frequency and nitrogen and phosphorus in runoff from soil amended with poultry litter. J. Environ. Qual. 26:1127–1132. Sharpley, A.N. (Ed.). 2000. Agriculture and Phosphorus Management: The Chesapeake Bay. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press. Sharpley, A.N., P.J.A. Kleinman, R.J. Wright, T.C. Daniel, B. Joern, R. Parry, and T. Sobecki. 2000. The National Phosphorus Project: interfacing agricultural and environmental phosphorus management in the U.S. Pp. 156–165 in International Conference on Agricultural Effects in Ground and Surface Waters, J. Steenvooreden (Ed.). Wageningen, The Netherlands: International Association of Hydrologic Sciences. Sharpley, A.N. and S.J. Smith. 1994. Wheat tillage and water quality in the Southern Plains. Soil Tillage Res. 30:33–38. Sharpley, A.N., S.J. Smith, B.A. Stewart, and A.C. Mathers. 1984. Forms of phosphorus in soil receiving cattle feedlot waste. J. Environ. Qual. 13:211–215. Sharpley, A.N., S.J. Smith, J.R. Williams, O.R. Jones, and G.A. Coleman. 1991. Water quality impacts associated with sorghum culture in the Southern Plains. J. Environ. Qual. 20:239–244. Sharpley, A.N., S.J. Smith, J.A. Zollweg, and G.A. Coleman. 1996. Gully treatment and water quality in the Southern Plains. J. Soil Water Conserv. 51:512–517. Sharpley, A.N. and H. Tunney. 2000. Phosphorus research strategies to meet agricultural and environmental challenges of the 21st century. J. Environ Qual. 29:176–181. Sharpley, A.N. and J.R. Williams (Eds.). 1990. EPIC-Erosion/Productivity Impact Calculator: I — model documentation. U.S. Department of Agriculture Tech. Bull. 1768. Sims J.T., R.R. Simard, and B.C. Joern. 1998. Phosphorus losses on agricultural drainage: Historical perspectives and current research. J. Environ. Qual. 27:277–293. Smith, S. J., A.N. Sharpley, J.W. Naney, W.A. Berg, and O.R. Jones. 1991. Water quality impacts associated with wheat culture in the Southern Plains. J. Environ. Qual. 20:244–249. Summer, R.M., C.V. Alonso, and R.A. Young. 1990. Modeling linked watershed and lake processes for water quality management decisions. J. Environ. Qual. 19:421–427.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Phosphorus Movement from Agriculture to Surface Waters
19
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. 1993. Guidance specifying management measures for sources of non-point pollution in coastal waters. EPA-840-B93-100c, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. 2000. The Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) program. EPA 841-F-00-009, Office of Water (4503F), U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C. Available at http://www.epa.gov/owow/tmdl/overviewfs.html. U.S. Geological Survey. 1999. The quality of our nation’s waters: nutrients and pesticides. U.S. Geological Survey Circular 1225, Information Services, Denver, CO. Available at http://www.usgs.gov. Westerman, P.W. and M.R. Overcash. 1980. Short-term attenuation of runoff pollution potential for land-applied swine and poultry manure. Pp. 289–292 in Livestock waste — A renewable resource. Proceedings of the 4th International Symposium on Livestock Wastes, April, Amarillo, TX. Young, R.A., C.A. Onstad, and D.D. Bosch. 1995. AGNPS: An agricultural nonpoint source model. Pp. 1001–1020 in Computer Models of Watershed Hydrology, V.P. Singh (Ed.). Highlands Ranch, CO: Water Resources Publication. Young, R.A., C.A. Onstad, D.D. Bosch, and W.P. Anderson. 1989. AGNPS: A nonpoint-source pollution model for evaluating agricultural watersheds. J. Soil Water Conserv. 44:168–173.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
2
Modeling Runoff and Erosion in Phosphorus Models Mary Leigh Wolfe Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, VA
CONTENTS 2.1 2.2
Introduction ....................................................................................................22 Modeling Runoff............................................................................................22 2.2.1 Runoff Volume ...................................................................................22 2.2.1.1 Curve Number Method.......................................................23 2.2.1.2 Curve Number Method Implementation ............................25 2.2.1.3 Infiltration-Based Approaches ............................................29 2.2.2 Hydrograph Development ..................................................................32 2.2.2.1 Kinematic Flow Routing ....................................................33 2.2.2.2 SCS Unit Hydrograph ........................................................34 2.2.2.3 Hydrograph Development Implementation ........................35 2.2.3 Streamflow, or Channel, Routing....................................................... 36 2.2.3.1 Hydrologic, or Storage, Routing ........................................37 2.2.3.2 Muskingum Routing Method .............................................37 2.2.3.3 Streamflow, or Channel, Routing Implementation .....................................................39 2.2.4 Peak Rate of Runoff ..........................................................................40 2.2.4.1 Rational Formula ................................................................40 2.2.4.2 SCS TR-55 Method ............................................................41 2.2.4.3 Peak Runoff Rate Implementation .....................................41 2.3 Modeling Erosion and Sediment Yield..........................................................44 2.3.1 USLE-Based Approaches...................................................................45 2.3.2 USLE-Based Approach Implementation ...........................................48 2.3.3 Process-Based Approaches ................................................................49 2.3.4 Process-Based Approach Implementation .........................................52 2.3.5 Channel Erosion.................................................................................53 2.3.6 Channel Erosion Implementation ......................................................54 2.4 Summary ........................................................................................................56 References................................................................................................................60 21
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
22
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
2.1 INTRODUCTION Runoff and erosion are the overland processes that transport phosphorus. The processes and equations describing the processes have been described in many references. The purpose of this chapter is to present the common approaches used for modeling runoff and erosion processes in models that simulate phosphorus transport and to illustrate similarities and differences in implementation among selected phosphorus models. Implementation of the processes varies among the phosphorus models, depending on model characteristics such as spatial representation of the drainage area (e.g., lumped or distributed), spatial scale (e.g., field or watershed), purpose of the model (e.g., event prediction or average annual predictions for management), computational time step (e.g., daily vs. shorter time steps during rainfall or runoff events), and land uses and conditions represented (e.g., agricultural, urban, forested land uses, frozen soils). Examples of implementation from the following models are included in the chapter: Annualized Agricultural Nonpoint Source (AnnAGNPS) (Cronshey and Theurer 1998), Areal Nonpoint Source Watershed Environment Response Simulation 2000 (ANSWERS-2000) (Bouraoui 1994), Erosion Productivity Impact Calculator (EPIC) (Sharpley and Williams 1990), Groundwater Loading Effects of Agricultural Management Systems (GLEAMS) (Knisel 1993; Leonard et al. 1987), Hydrologic Simulation Program-Fortran (HSPF) (Bicknell et al. 2001), and Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) (Neitsch et al. 2002). Unless otherwise noted, the information about the models is from the sources cited in this paragraph. Because of the variety of equations and variability in how they are implemented in different models, a mixture of units is used in this chapter. Generally, units are expressed as length, mass, time (L, M, T, respectively) or in both International System of Units (SI) and English units for empirical equations or as used in the cited models.
2.2 MODELING RUNOFF Runoff is a complex, variable process, influenced by many factors such as soil characteristics, land cover, and topography. Runoff calculations typically include estimating runoff volume, peak runoff rate, and hydrographs, or the time distribution of runoff. For some phosphorus models, peak runoff rate is computed only for use in erosion calculations. For example, in GLEAMS the peak rate is used in the erosion component for calculating the characteristic discharge rate, sediment transport capacity, and shear stress in a concentrated flow. Common approaches used in phosphorus models for estimating runoff volume, hydrographs, and peak discharge are described in the following sections.
2.2.1 RUNOFF VOLUME Runoff volume, often termed rainfall excess, is the total amount of rainfall minus infiltration and interception. Two general approaches are used to model runoff volume in phosphorus transport models: (1) the curve number (CN) method and (2) infiltration methods. The CN method directly calculates runoff volume, whereas the infiltration methods calculate infiltration first and then estimate runoff as the difference between rainfall and infiltration. Some phosphorus models include both CN
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Runoff and Erosion in Phosphorus Models
23
and infiltration methods. The CN method is usually used when daily rainfall values are available; infiltration methods require hourly — or other intervals shorter than daily — rainfall values. 2.2.1.1 Curve Number Method The most common method used to estimate runoff volume in phosphorus models is the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) Soil Conservation Service (SCS) (now Natural Resources Conservation Service, NRCS) runoff approach. The CN method correlates runoff with rainfall, antecedent moisture condition (AMC), soil type, and vegetative cover and cultural practices. Runoff volume is computed using the following relationships (SCS 1972): Q= S=
25, 400 − 254 , CN
( P − 0.2 S )2 P + 0.8 S
S in mm or
S=
(2.1) 1000 − 10 , S in in. CN
(2.2)
where Q is direct storm runoff volume (mm or in.), P is storm rainfall depth (mm or in.), S is the retention parameter or maximum potential difference between rainfall and runoff at the time the storm begins (mm or in.), and CN is the runoff curve number, which represents runoff potential of a surface based on land use, soil type, management, and hydrologic condition. Rainfall depth, P, must be greater than 0.2S (referred to as the initial abstraction, Ia) for the equation to be applicable. Values of CN have been tabulated (Table 2.1) by hydrologic soil group for AMC II, or average conditions. The CN ranges from 1 to 100, with runoff potential increasing with increasing CN. Required information to determine a CN value from the table includes the hydrologic soil group (defined in Table 2.2), the vegetal and cultural practices of the site, and the AMC (defined in Table 2.3). The CN obtained from Table 2.1 for AMC II can be converted to AMC I (dry) or III (wet) using the values in Table 2.3. Curve numbers can be determined from rainfall-runoff data for a particular site. Investigations have been conducted to determine CN values for conditions not included in Table 2.1 or similar tables. Examples include exposed fractured rock surfaces (Rasmussen and Evans 1993), animal manure application sites (Edwards and Daniel 1993), and dryland wheat–sorghum–fallow crop rotation in the semi-arid western Great Plains (Hauser and Jones 1991). The CN approach is widely used for estimating runoff volume. Because the CN is defined in terms of land use treatments, hydrologic condition, AMC, and soil type, the approach can be applied to ungaged watersheds. Errors in selecting CN values can result from misclassifying land cover, treatment, hydrologic conditions, or soil type (Bondelid et al. 1982). The magnitude of the error depends on both the size of the area misclassified and the type of misclassification. In a sensitivity analysis of runoff estimates to errors in CN estimates, Bondelid et al. (1982) found that effects of variations in CN decrease as design rainfall depth increases and confirmed Hawkins’s (1975) conclusion that errors in CN estimates are especially critical near the threshold of runoff.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
24
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
TABLE 2.1 Runoff Curve Numbers for Hydrologic Soil-Cover Complexes Land Use Description/Treatment/Hydrologic Condition Residential:a Average lot size (ha) 0.05 or less 0.10 0.13 0.20 0.40
Hydrologic Soil Group A
B
C
D
77 61 57 54 51
85 75 72 70 68
90 83 81 80 79
92 87 86 85 84
98
98
98
98
98 76 72
98 85 82
98 89 87
98 91 89
Commercial and business areas (85% impervious)
89
92
94
95
Industrial districts (72% impervious)
81
88
91
93
39 49
61 69
74 79
80 84
—
77
86
91
94
Average % imperviousb 65 38 30 25 20
Paved parking lots, roofs, driveways, etc.c Street and roads: Paved with curbs and storm sewersc Gravel Dirt
Open spaces, lawns, parks, golf courses, cemeteries, etc. Good condition: grass cover on 75% or more of the area Fair condition: grass cover on 50 to 75% of the area Fallow
Straight row
Row crops
Straight row Straight row Contoured Contoured Contoured and terraced Contoured and terraced
Poor Good Poor Good Poor Good
72 67 70 65 66 62
81 78 79 75 74 71
88 85 84 82 80 78
91 89 88 86 82 81
Small grain
Straight row
Poor Good Poor Good Poor Good
65 63 63 61 61 59
76 75 74 73 72 70
84 83 82 81 79 78
88 87 85 84 82 81
Contoured Contoured and terraced
(continued)
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Runoff and Erosion in Phosphorus Models
25
TABLE 2.1 (CONTINUED) Runoff Curve Numbers for Hydrologic Soil-Cover Complexes Land Use Description/Treatment/Hydrologic Condition Close–seeded legumesd or rotation meadow
Hydrologic Soil Group
Straight row Straight row Contoured Contoured Contoured and terraced Contoured and terraced
Poor Good Poor Good Poor Good
66 58 64 55 63 51
77 72 75 69 73 67
85 81 83 78 80 76
89 85 85 83 83 80
Contoured Contoured Contoured
Poor Fair Good Poor Fair Good
68 49 39 47 25 6
79 69 61 67 59 35
86 79 74 81 75 70
89 84 80 88 83 79
Meadow
Good
30
58
71
78
Woods or forest land
Poor Fair Good
45 36 25
66 60 55
77 73 70
83 79 77
—
59
74
82
86
Pasture or range
Farmsteads Note: Antecedent moisture condition II and Ia = 0.2S. a
Curve numbers are computed assuming the runoff from the house and driveway is directed toward the street with a minimum of roof water directed to lawns where additional infiltration could occur. b
The remaining pervious areas (lawn) are considered to be in good pasture condition for these curve numbers. c
In some warmer climates of the country a curve number of 95 may be used.
d
Close-drilled or broadcast.
Source: SCS. 1972. Hydrology, Section 4: National Engineering Handbook, U.S. Soil Conservation Service, Washington, D.C., Government Printing Office. With permission.
2.2.1.2 Curve Number Method Implementation The curve number method is used in several phosphorus models to compute runoff volume. The most common implementation (e.g., AnnAGNPS, GLEAMS, EPIC, SWAT) includes a modification of the CN to account for daily changes in soil moisture content (Williams et al. 1990). Typically, the models require the user to input a value for CN2, the curve number for average conditions, or AMC II. Then,
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
26
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
TABLE 2.2 Hydrologic Soil Group Descriptions and Antecedent Rainfall Conditions for Use with SCS Curve Number Method Soil Group A B
C
D
Description Lowest Runoff Potential. Includes deep sands with very little silt and clay, also deep, rapidly permeable loess. Moderately Low Runoff Potential. Mostly sandy soils less deep than A, and loess less deep or less aggregated than A, but the group as a whole has above-average infiltration after thorough wetting. Moderately High Runoff Potential. Comprises shallow soils and soils containing considerable clay and colloids, though less than those of group D. The group has below-average infiltration after presaturation. Highest Runoff Potential. Includes mostly clays of high swelling percent, but the group also includes some shallow soils with nearly impermeable subhorizons near the surface. 5-Day Antecedent Rainfall (mm)
Condition
General Description
I
Optimum soil condition from about lower plastic limit to wilting point Average value for annual floods Heavy rainfall or light rainfall and low temperatures within 5 days prior to the given storm
II III
Dormant Season
Growing Season
< 6.4
< 35.6
6.4 to 27.9 > 27.9
35.6 to 53.3 > 53.3
Source: SCS. 1972. Hydrology, Section 4: National Engineering Handbook, U.S. Soil Conservation Service, Washington, D.C., Government Printing Office. With permission.
curve numbers corresponding to AMC I (dry), CN1, and AMC III (wet), CN3, are computed as a function of CN2. The retention parameter, S, also changes due to fluctuations in soil moisture content. For example, the same relationship is used in EPIC and SWAT, with the soil water content expressed differently: FFC SW S = S1 1 − in EPIC or S = Smax 1 − in SWAT [ w1 − w2 ( FFC )] ( w1 − w2 SW ) FFC + e SW + e (2.3) where S1 (L) and Smax (L) is the value of S associated with CN1 (computed with Equation 2.2), FFC is the fraction of field capacity, SW is the soil water content (L3/L3), and w1 and w2 are shape parameters. FFC is computed in EPIC as FFC =
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
SW − WP FC − WP
(2.4)
Modeling Runoff and Erosion in Phosphorus Models
27
TABLE 2.3 Conversion Factors for Converting Runoff Curve Numbers Factor to Convert Curve Number for Condition II to
Curve Number for Condition II
Condition I
Condition III
0.40 0.45 0.50 0.55 0.62 0.67 0.73 0.79 0.87 1.00
2.22 1.85 1.67 1.50 1.40 1.30 1.21 1.14 1.07 1.00
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Note: AMC II to AMC I and III (Ia = 0.2S). Source: SCS. 1972. Hydrology, Section 4: National Engineering Handbook, U.S. Soil Conservation Service, Washington, D.C., Government Printing Office. With permission.
where SW is the soil water content in the root zone, WP is the wilting point water content (corresponds to 1500 kPa matric potential for many soils) (L3/L3), and FC is the field capacity water content (corresponds to 33 kPa matric potential for many soils) (L3/L3). In EPIC, values for w1 and w2 are obtained by simultaneous solution of Equation 2.3 with the assumptions that S = S2 when FFC = 0.5 and S = S3 when FFC = 1.0. In SWAT, w1 and w2 are determined by solving Equation 2.3 with the following assumptions: S = S1 when SW = WP, S = S3 when SW = FC, and the soil has a CN of 99 (S = 2.54) when completely saturated. The soil water content can be taken as being uniformly distributed through the root zone or top meter or some other depth of soil, or a nonuniform distribution of soil water can be considered. If more of the soil water is at the surface than deeper in the profile, the potential for runoff is greater. Some of the phosphorus models keep track of soil moisture by layer, so they have the potential to include the soil water distribution in their runoff calculations. For example, because EPIC estimates water content of each soil layer daily, the effect of depth distribution on runoff is expressed by using a depth-weighted FFC value in Equation 2.3:
FFC = *
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
∑iM=1 FFCi ∑
(
Zi − Zi −1 Zi
M Zi − Zi −1 i =1 Zi
),
Zi ≤ 1.0 m
(2.5)
28
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
where FFC* is the depth-weighted FFC value for use in Equation 2.3, Z is the depth (m) to the bottom of soil layer i, and M is the number of soil layers. Equation 2.5 reduces the influence of lower layers because FFCi is divided by Zi and gives proper weight to thick layers relative to thin layers because FFC is multiplied by the layer thickness. GLEAMS also computes a depth-weighted retention parameter: S = S1 1.0 −
N
∑ W SM UL i
i
i =1
(2.6)
i
where Wi is the weighting factor, SMi is the water content in soil layer i (L), and ULi is the upper limit of water storage in layer i (L). The weighting factors decrease with depth according to the equation: D −4.16 Di−1 −4.16 i Wi = 1.016 e RD − e RD
(2.7)
where Di is the depth to the bottom of layer i (L) and RD is the root zone depth (L). The sum of the weighting factors equals one. Assuming that the CN2 value in Table 2.1 (SCS 1972) is appropriate for a 5% slope, Williams et al. (1990) developed an equation to adjust that value for other slopes: 1 CN 2 s = (CN 3 − CN 2 )[1 − 2e −13.86 s ] + CN 2 3
(2.8)
where CN2s is the handbook CN2 value adjusted for slope and s is the average slope of the watershed (L/L). This adjustment is included in EPIC but not in SWAT. EPIC also accounts for uncertainty in the retention parameter, or CN, by generating the final curve number estimate from a triangular distribution. The mean of the distribution is the best estimate of CN based on using Equations 2.2 through 2.5, and 2.8 and an equation to adjust S for frozen ground. The extremes of the distribution are ±5 curve numbers from the mean. Another example of a modification in implementation of the CN method is seen in GLEAMS. In the U.S., soils are grouped by series name, and a hydrologic soil group is assigned to each series. However, a series name can include different soil textures, which would have different runoff potentials but would still be in the same hydrologic soil group. The developers of GLEAMS expanded Table 2.1 to give a range of curve numbers for each combination in the table to allow users to distinguish between similar soils within a series (Table 2.4). For example, CN2 for row crops with straight rows in good hydrologic condition could be 78 for a Cecil sandy loam and 82 for a Cecil clay loam. Care must be taken in utilization of the CN method in different scale models. The CN method was developed based on data from small watersheds, so it should
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Runoff and Erosion in Phosphorus Models
29
TABLE 2.4 Excerpt of Expanded Curve Number Table for GLEAMS Model Land Use Treatment or Practice
Hydrologic Condition
SR SR SR + CT SR + CT CNT CNT
Poor Good Poor Good Poor Good
Hydrologic Soil Group A Row Crops 65 72 77 60 67 73 66 71 75 57 64 70 64 70 75 59 65 70
B
78 74 76 71 76 71
81 78 79 75 79 75
C
85 82 83 79 81 79
86 83 84 80 82 80
87 85 86 82 84 82
D
88 87 87 83 86 84
90 88 88 84 87 85
91 89 89 85 88 86
92 90 90 86 89 87
Note: SR = straight row; CT = conservation tillage; CNT = contoured. Source: Knisel, W.G., GLEAMS: Groundwater Loading Effects of Agricultural Management Systems, Version 2.10, University of Georgia, Coastal Plain Experiment Station, Biological and Agricultural Engineering Department, Publication 5, p. 130, 1993. With permission.
not be applied to a whole watershed larger than that. A larger watershed is subject to spatial variability in rainfall amounts and increased transmission losses due to increased flow path lengths, changing the CN value from that of a smaller watershed. For example, Simanton et al. (1996) found that the optimum curve number — to match measured runoff values — decreased with increasing drainage area for 18 semi-arid watersheds in southeastern Arizona. Some phosphorus models divide large watersheds into subwatersheds or other smaller hydrologic response units. It is reasonable to apply the CN to the smaller response units and then to determine how the runoff from the individual units contributes to streamflow, through routing or other methods, as described in the following sections (2.2.3).
2.2.1.3 Infiltration-Based Approaches Infiltration is defined as the entry of water from the surface into the soil profile. From a ponded surface or a rainfall situation, infiltration rate decreases over time and asymptotically approaches a final infiltration rate. The final infiltration rate is approximately equal to the saturated hydraulic conductivity, Ks, of the soil. The amount and rate of infiltration depend on infiltration capacity of the soil and the availability of water to infiltrate. Infiltration capacity is influenced by soil properties, soil texture, initial soil moisture content, surface conditions, and availability of water to be infiltrated, i.e., precipitation or ponded water. Rainfall intensity affects infiltration rate. If the infiltration capacity of the soil is exceeded by the rainfall intensity (L/T), then water will pond on the soil surface, and the infiltration rate will equal the infiltration capacity. If the rainfall rate is less than the saturated hydraulic
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
30
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
conductivity of the soil, the infiltration rate will equal the rainfall rate, and ponding will not occur. A number of infiltration equations have been developed, ranging from solving the Richards (1931) equation to empirical equations. The Richards equation, the generalized equation for flow in porous media, is a partial differential equation derived from conservation of mass and Darcy’s equation describing flux. To simulate infiltration, the Richards equation is solved subject to appropriate boundary and initial conditions. Empirical infiltration equations typically include coefficients or exponents to represent soil properties and to generate the relationship of decreasing infiltration rate with time. Some infiltration equations that have been used in phosphorus models include the Holtan (1961) equation, which was used in the original ANSWERS event-based model (Beasley et al. 1982); the Philip (1957) equation, which is the basis of the infiltration calculations in HSPF; and the Green and Ampt (1911) equation. 2.2.1.3.1 Green and Ampt Approach Description In phosphorus models that include infiltration simulation (e.g., ANSWERS-2000, SWAT), the Green and Ampt (1911) equation as modified by Mein and Larson (1973) is the most common approach used to estimate infiltration. This approach is physically based, and its parameters can be determined from readily available soil and vegetal cover information. The approach has been tested for a variety of conditions and has successfully simulated the effects of different management practices on infiltration. The original Green and Ampt (1911) equation was derived using Darcy’s law for infiltration from a ponded surface into a deep, homogeneous soil profile with uniform initial water content. Water is assumed to enter the soil as slug flow resulting in a sharply defined wetting front that separates a zone that has been wetted from an unwetted zone. Infiltration rate is expressed as MS av f = Ks 1 + F
(2.9)
where f is infiltration rate (L/T), Ks is saturated hydraulic conductivity (L/T), M is the difference between final and initial moisture content (the difference in moisture content across the wetting front) (L3/L3), Sav is average wetting front suction (L), and F is cumulative infiltration (L). Substituting f = dF dt into Equation 2.9 and integrating with F = 0 at time (t) = 0 yields F K s t = F − S av M ln 1 + MS av
(2.10)
Mein and Larson (1973) extended the Green and Ampt equation to rainfall conditions by first determining cumulative infiltration at the time of surface ponding: Fp =
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
S av M R −1 Ks
(2.11)
Modeling Runoff and Erosion in Phosphorus Models
31
where Fp is cumulative infiltration at time of ponding (L) and R is rainfall rate (L/T). Before ponding occurs, the infiltration rate is equal to the rainfall rate. After ponding occurs, the infiltration rate is a function of the infiltration capacity of the soil. The Green-Ampt-Mein-Larson (GAML) model for infiltration rate is a two-stage model with f = R for t ≤ tp, and f is computed with Equation 2.9 after ponding. If R < Ks, surface ponding will not occur, providing the profile is deep and homogeneous as was assumed in the derivation of the equations and f = R. By recognizing that f = dF/dt and accounting for the preponding stage, Mein and Larson (1971) developed an equation for cumulative infiltration over time: F K s (t − t p + t ′p ) = F − MSav ln 1 + MS av
(2.12)
where t′p is the equivalent time (T) to infiltrate Fp under initially ponded conditions. Since Equation 2.12 is implicit in F, it might be desirable to increment F and to solve directly for time, t, and then for f from Equation 2.9. A number of studies have been conducted related to estimating the values of the GAML parameters Ks, M, and Sav. Skaggs and Khaleel (1982) reported that Bouwer (1966) and Bouwer and Asce (1969) showed that the hydraulic conductivity parameter should be less than the saturated value because of entrapped air. When measured values are not available, Bouwer (1966) suggested that an effective hydraulic conductivity of 0.5 Ks be used in place of Ks. Other adjustments to Ks have also been recommended to account for the impact of surface conditions on infiltration, resulting in the concept of an effective hydraulic conductivity, Ke. Similarly, it has been suggested that the final moisture content included in the determination of M be something less than saturation due to air entrapment in the field. The most difficult Green-Ampt parameter to estimate is the suction term, presented as effective suction at the wetting front by Green and Ampt and then as average suction at the wetting front by Mein and Larson. One accepted estimation method (Mein and Larson 1973) is using the unsaturated hydraulic conductivity as a weighting factor and defining Sav as 1
∫
Sav = ψ dKr
(2.13a)
0
where ψ is the soil water suction (negative of the matric potential) (L) and Kr is the relative hydraulic conductivity = K(ψ)/Ks. Neuman (1976) obtained a theoretical expression for Sav, similar to Equation 2.13a, by relating it to the physical characteristics of the soil: ψi
Sav =
∫ K dψ r
0
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
(2.13b)
32
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
where ψi is the suction at the initial water content. Morel-Seytoux and Khanji (1974) found that for most cases the value of Sav given by Equation 2.13a or 2.13b is a reasonable approximation for an effective matric drive, which is dependent on the relative conductivities of both air and water (Skaggs and Khaleel 1982). Because Equation 2.13 requires the K(ψ) relationship, researchers have developed predictive equations for K(ψ) or Sav , and Ke as well, based on readily available soil characteristics (e.g., Brakensiek and Rawls 1983; Rawls and Brakensiek 1986; Rawls et al. 1989). 2.2.1.3.2 Green-Ampt Approach Implementation The Green-Ampt approach is implemented in several phosphorus models. In ANSWERS-2000, Equation 2.10 is solved using Newton’s iteration technique to determine cumulative infiltration depth, F. The infiltration rate is then computed using Equation 2.9. ANSWERS-2000 replaces Ks with Ke, which is computed as the weighted sum of Ke under canopy cover and Ke for the area outside the canopy. The values are computed as functions of soil parameters, (i.e., Ks, effective porosity, bulk density, residual soil water, sand, silt, and clay fractions) and vegetation parameters (i.e., percent area outside the canopy, percent bare area under canopy, percent canopy area) using equations primarily from Rawls et al. (1989). The available porosity, M, is computed as the difference between porosity corrected for rocks and the antecedent soil moisture content. Sav is computed using an empirical equation developed by Rawls and Brakensiek (1985), in which Sav is a function of total porosity, sand fraction, and clay fraction. For implementation in the SWAT model, Equation 2.10 applied at time (t – ∆t) was subtracted from Equation 2.10 applied at time t to yield the following expression for F at time t: F + S av M Ft = Ft −1 + K s ∆t + S av M ln t Ft −1 + S av M
(2.14)
SWAT uses a successive substitution technique to solve Equation 2.14. For each time step, SWAT calculates the amount of water entering the soil. The water that does not infiltrate into the soil becomes surface runoff. SWAT uses effective hydraulic conductivity, Ke, in place of Ks; Ke is computed as a function of Ks and CN, thus incorporating land-cover impacts into the hydraulic conductivity value (Nearing et al. 1996). Similar to ANSWERS-2000, SWAT uses the expression developed by Rawls and Brakensiek (1985) to calculate Sav .
2.2.2 HYDROGRAPH DEVELOPMENT A hydrograph is the relationship between flow rate and time. In some phosphorus models, only the runoff hydrograph as it enters a receiving stream is computed. In others, the spatial variability of the hydrograph along the slope is simulated as well. Some phosphorus models do not directly compute a hydrograph; instead, all of the runoff is assumed to reach the receiving water in a certain time frame or the runoff is lagged in some way to determine when it arrives at the receiving water.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Runoff and Erosion in Phosphorus Models
33
Runoff, or overland flow, can be visualized as sheet-type flow — as opposed to channel flow — with small depths of flow and slow velocities (less than 0.3 m/sec). Considerable volumes of water can move through overland flow. Overland flow is spatially varied and usually unsteady and nonuniform — that is, the velocity and flow depth vary in both time and space. Input (rainfall) to the flow is distributed over the flow surface. Methods for determining hydrographs range from direct calculations of the basic hydrograph descriptors — peak flow, time to peak, and base time — to overland flow routing, which yields the relationship of runoff rate with space and time. Examples of the methods used in some phosphorus models are described in the following sections. 2.2.2.1 Kinematic Flow Routing The theoretical hydrodynamic equations attributed to St. Venant are based on the fundamental laws of conservation of mass (continuity) and conservation of momentum applied to a control volume or fixed section of channel with the assumptions of one-dimensional flow, a straight channel, and a gradual slope (Huggins and Burney 1982). With these assumptions, a uniform velocity distribution and a hydrostatic pressure distribution can be assumed, resulting in quasi-linear partial differential equations. Because these equations are not typically implemented in phosphorus models, they are not given here. Detailed derivations of continuity and momentum equations as they apply to unsteady, nonuniform flow can be found in Strelkoff (1969). Lighthill and Whitham (1955), cited by Huggins and Burney (1982), proposed that the dynamic terms in the momentum equation had negligible influence for cases in which backwater effects were absent. Neglecting these terms yields a quasi-steady approach, known as the kinematic wave approximation. The kinematic approximation is composed of the continuity equation ∂y ∂q =I− f + ∂t ∂x
(2.15)
and a flow (depth-discharge) equation of the general form q = α ym
(2.16)
where y is local depth of flow (L), q is discharge per unit width (L3/T/L), I is lateral inflow per unit length and width of the flow plane (L3/T/L2), f is lateral outflow per unit length and width of the flow plane (L3/T/L2), t is time (T), x is the flow direction axis (L), and α and m are parameters. The flow equation can be one describing laminar or turbulent channel flow, with the overland flow plane represented by a wide channel. Overton (1972) analyzed 200 hydrographs for relatively long, impermeable planes and found that flow was turbulent or transitional. Foster et al. (1968) concluded that both Manning’s and Darcy-Weisbach flow equations were satisfactory for describing overland flow on short erodible slopes.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
34
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
The most commonly used flow equation for overland flow is Manning’s equation, which can be written for overland flow as q=
1 5/ 3 1/ 2 y S n
(2.17)
where q is discharge (m3/s/m of width), n is the roughness coefficient, y is flow depth (m), and S is the slope of energy gradeline, usually taken as surface slope (m/m). Values of Manning’s n factor vary from 0.02 for smooth pavement to 0.40 for average grass cover. Manning’s n values are tabulated in a variety of sources (e.g., Linsley et al. 1988; Novotny and Olem 1994). Woolhiser and Liggett (1967) developed an accuracy parameter to assess the effect of neglecting dynamic terms in the momentum equation: k=
So L HF 2
(2.18)
where k is a dimensionless parameter, So is the bed slope (L/L), L is the length of bed slope (L), H is the equilibrium flow depth at the outlet (L), and F is the equilibrium Froude number for flow at the outlet (dimensionless). For values of k greater than 10, very little advantage in accuracy is gained by using the momentum equation in place of a depth–discharge relationship. Since k is usually much greater than 10 in virtually all overland flow conditions, the kinematic wave equations generally provide an adequate representation of the overland flow hydrograph (Huggins and Burney 1982). 2.2.2.2 SCS Unit Hydrograph The SCS unit hydrograph method generates a triangular-shaped hydrograph. The relationship among the time parameters of the hydrograph is described as D D + TL = + 0.6T c (2.19) 2 2 where Tp is time to peak (T), D is duration of excess rainfall (T), TL is lag, or mean travel time (T), and Tc is the time of concentration (T), or travel time from the most hydraulically remote point in the watershed to the watershed outlet. Lag time (h) is computed as Tp =
0.7
0.8
TL=L
1000 − 9 CN 4407( Sg )0.5
(2.20)
where L is the maximum length of flow (m), CN is the runoff curve number, and Sg is the average watershed gradient (m/m). The peak discharge is a function of amount of runoff computed with Equation 2.1: q p = qu AQ
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
(2.21)
Modeling Runoff and Erosion in Phosphorus Models
35
where qp is peak runoff rate (m3/s), qu is unit peak flow rate (m3/s per ha/mm of runoff), Q is the runoff volume (mm), and A is watershed area (ha). Unit peak flow rate, qu, can be obtained from charts (e.g., SCS 1986) or computed from Haan et al. (1994): log(qu ) = C0 + C1 log tc + C2 (log tc )2
(2.22)
where the Cs are from a table as a function of Ia/P, with Ia generally taken as 0.2 S, with S computed from Equation 2.2. 2.2.2.3 Hydrograph Development Implementation Phosphorus models use different methods to develop runoff hydrographs or route overland flow. For example, ANSWERS-2000 uses kinematic routing, HSPF includes a flow equation with an empirical relationship, SWAT computes a runoff lag time for delivery to channels, and AnnAGNPS applies the SCS unit hydrograph. ANSWERS-2000 applies the kinematic wave equations to route overland flow with an explicit, backward difference solution of the continuity equation combined with Manning’s stage-discharge equation. The hydraulic radius in Manning’s equation is assumed equal to the average detention depth in the cell — ANSWERS-2000 represents a watershed as a grid of cells. Detention depth is calculated as the total volume of surface water in a cell minus the retention volume divided by the area of the cell. This implies that the entire specified retention volume of an element must be filled before any water becomes available for surface detention and runoff. ANSWERS-2000 uses a surface detention model developed by Huggins and Monke (1966) to describe the surface storage potential of a surface as a function of the water depth on the soil surface. Each cell acts as an overland flow plane with a userspecified slope steepness and direction. Flow is routed from one cell to another until it enters a channel element, which then routes the runoff to the watershed outlet. In HSPF, overland flow is treated as a turbulent flow process. It is simulated using the Chezy-Manning equation and an empirical expression that relates outflow depth to detention storage. The rate of overland flow discharge is determined by the equations 1.67 3 Sd O = ∆tCr Sd 1.0 + 0.6 , Se
(
O = ∆tSr 1.6 S d
)
1.67
,
for Sd < Se
for Sd ≥ Se
(2.23a)
(2.23b)
where O is surface outflow (in./interval), ∆t is the length of the time interval, Cr is the routing variable = 1020 s /nL , Sd is the mean surface detention storage over the time interval (in.), Se is the equilibrium surface detention storage (in.) for current
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
36
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
supply rate, s is slope of the overland flow plane (ft/ft), n is Manning’s roughness coefficient, and L is length of the overland flow plane (ft). Equation 2.23a applies when the overland flow rate is increasing, whereas Equation 2.23b applies when the overland flow rate is at equilibrium or receding. SWAT determines when overland flow reaches a channel based on the time of concentration for the overland flow area. If tc is less than one day, SWAT adds the runoff generated on that day to the channel on that day. If tc is greater than one day, only a portion of the surface runoff will reach the main channel on the day it is generated. SWAT incorporates a surface runoff storage feature to lag a portion of the surface runoff release to the main channel. After surface runoff is calculated, the amount of surface runoff released to the main channel is calculated as
Qsurf = (Qsurf ′ + Qstor, i −1
) (1 − e
− surlag t c
)
(2.24)
where Qsurf is the amount of surface runoff discharged to the main channel on a given day (mm), Q′surf is the amount of surface runoff generated on a given day (mm), Qstor, i-1 is the surface runoff stored or lagged from the previous day (mm), surlag is the surface runoff lag coefficient, and tc is the time of concentration for the sub-basin (h). The expression [1 − exp(-surlag/tc)] in Equation 2.24 represents the fraction of the total available water that will be allowed to enter the reach on any one day. For a given tc, as surlag decreases more water is held in storage. The delay in release of surface runoff smooths the streamflow hydrograph simulated in the reach.
2.2.3 STREAMFLOW,
OR
CHANNEL, ROUTING
Many phosphorus models include channel processes in addition to upland processes. Routing streamflow entails computing the effect of channel storage on the shape and movement of a hydrograph, or flood wave. When a flood wave advances into a reach segment, inflow exceeds outflow and a wedge of storage is produced. As the flood wave recedes, outflow exceeds inflow in the reach segment, and a negative wedge is produced. In addition to the wedge storage, the reach segment contains a prism of storage formed by a volume of constant cross-section along the reach length. Streamflow routing involves relationships among inflow, outflow, and storage in each reach or segment of the stream. The continuity equation for unsteady flow relating inflow, outflow, and storage in a reach is
I −O =
dS dt
(2.25)
where I is inflow (L3/T), O is outflow (L3/T), S is storage (L3), and t is time (T). Flow routing procedures typically assume that the average of flows at the beginning
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Runoff and Erosion in Phosphorus Models
37
and end of a short time period ∆t (routing period) equals the average flow during the period. Expressing Equation 2.25 for a finite time interval yields I1 + I 2 O + O2 ∆t − 1 ∆t = S2 − S1 2 2
(2.26)
where the subscripts 1 and 2 refer to the beginning and end of the time period, respectively. The routing period should be selected to be sufficiently short to ensure that this assumption is not seriously violated. If ∆t is too long (> travel time through reach), the wave crest could pass through the reach during the routing period. Generally, ∆t is 1/2 to 1/3 the travel time through the reach. Most storage routing methods are based on Equation 2.26, which includes two unknowns: the storage and outflow at the end of the time interval. A second relationship is required to determine the unknowns. Different methods define the second relationship in different ways. 2.2.3.1 Hydrologic, or Storage, Routing Hydrologic, or storage, routing is the simplest form of routing and is based on the continuity equation (Equation 2.26) (Haan et al. 1994). The storage in a channel reach depends on the channel geometry and depth of flow. The flow rate can be related to the depth or cross-sectional area of flow, assuming steady, uniform flow using Manning’s equation for each cross-section: q=
1 2 /3 1 /2 R S A n
(2.27)
where q is the flow rate (m3/s); R is the hydraulic radius (m), which is equal to the cross-sectional area of flow divided by the wetted perimeter; S is the slope of the channel (m/m); and A is the cross-sectional area of flow (m2). Manning’s equation was previously presented for overland flow (Equation 2.17), in which an overland flow plane is assumed to be a very wide, shallow channel — which leads to R being approximated by y — and discharge is computed per unit width. A simple method for computing the storage in a reach is to multiply the length of the reach by the average cross-sectional area of the reach at a given flow rate. Flow routed down the channel as the outflow from one reach becomes the inflow to the next reach. Additional inflows from overland flow, tributaries, and ground water can be added to the inflow or outflow of each reach as well. 2.2.3.2 Muskingum Routing Method The Muskingum flow routing method is described in many references. The following description is adapted from Linsley et al. (1988). The Muskingum routing method models the storage volume in a channel length as a combination of wedge and prism storages. As defined by Manning’s equation,
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
38
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
the cross-sectional area of flow is assumed to be directly proportional to the discharge for a given reach segment. The Muskingum flow routing method is based on the continuity equation (Equation 2.25). The second relationship between storage and outflow is based on the following expression for storage in a reach of a stream: S=
b [ XI m / n + (1 − X )O m / n ] a
(2.28)
where a and n are constants from the mean stage–discharge relation for the reach, q = ayn, and b and m are constants from the mean stage–storage relation for the reach, S = bym. In a uniform rectangular channel, storage would vary with the first power of stage (m = 1), and discharge would vary as the 5/3 power of stage (Manning’s formula). In a natural channel with overbank floodplains, the exponent n may approach or become less than unity. The constant X expresses the relative importance of inflow and outflow in determining storage. For a simple reservoir, X = 0 (storage has no effect), whereas if inflow and outflow were equally effective, X would be 0.5. For most streams, X is between 0 and 0.3, with a mean value near 0.2. The Muskingum method assumes that m/n = 1 and lets b/a = K, yielding S = K[XI + (1 – X)O]
(2.29)
The constant K, known as the storage constant, is the ratio of storage to discharge and has the dimension of time. It is approximately equal to the travel time through the reach and in the absence of better data is sometimes estimated in this way. If flow data on previous floods are available, K and X are determined by plotting S vs. [XI + (1 – X)O] for various values of X. The best value of X is that which causes the data to plot most nearly as a single-valued curve. The Muskingum method assumes that this curve is a straight line with slope K. The units of K depend on the units of flow and storage. Substituting Equation 2.29 for S in Equation 2.26 and collecting like terms yields O2 = c0I2 + c1I1 + c2O1
(2.30)
KX − 0.5 ∆t K − KX + 0.5 ∆t
(2.30a)
where c0 = − c1 =
KX + 0.5 ∆t K − KX + 0.5 ∆t
(2.30b)
c2 =
K − KX − 0.5 ∆t K − KX + 0.5 ∆t
(2.30c)
c0 + c1 + c2 = 1
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
(2.30d)
Modeling Runoff and Erosion in Phosphorus Models
39
The routing period ∆t is in the same units as K. With K, X, and ∆t established, the values of c0, c1, and c2 can be computed. The routing operation then consists of solving Equation 2.30 with the O2 of one routing period becoming the O1 of the succeeding period. To maintain numerical stability and to avoid the computation of negative outflows, the following condition must be met: 2 KX < ∆t < 2 K (1 − X )
(2.31)
2.2.3.3 Streamflow, or Channel, Routing Implementation The SWAT model utilizes either the variable storage routing method developed by Williams (1969) and used in the hydrologic model (HYMO) (Williams and Hann 1973) and routing outputs to outlets (ROTO) (Arnold et al. 1995) models or the Muskingum method. The variable storage-routing method is based on the continuity equation. Travel time is computed by dividing the volume of water in the channel by the flow rate. Substituting the relationship for travel time into the continuity equation (Equation 2.26) and simplifying yields the expression for outflow from the reach segment: 2 ∆t I1 + I 2 O2 = + S1 2T T + ∆t 2
(2.32)
where T T is travel time. In the implementation of the Muskingum routing procedure in SWAT, the value for the weighting factor, X, is input by the user. As just noted, for most streams X is between 0 and 0.3 with a mean value near 0.2. The user can use this information or site-specific knowledge to assign a value for X. The value for K, the storage time constant, is estimated as K = coef1K bnkfull + coef2 K 0.1bnkfull
(2.33)
where K is the storage time constant for the reach segment, coef1 and coef2 are weighting coefficients input by the user, Kbnkfull is the storage time constant calculated for the reach segment with bankfull flows, and K0.1bnkfull is the storage time constant calculated for the reach segment with one tenth of the bankfull flows. An equation developed by Cunge (1969) is used to calculate Kbnkfull and K0.1bnkfull. Routing in HSPF is also based on the continuity equation. The second relationship is based on the assumption that outflows are functions of volume or time, or a combination of the two. If the outflow is a function of volume, the user defines the depth-surface area-volume-discharge relationship in an input table (an FTABLE in HSPF terms). This is one of four optional methods for computing overland flow. Another method is a simple power function method. Some phosphorus models also include transmission, or leaching, losses from channels during periods when a stream receives no groundwater contributions.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
40
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
For example, SWAT uses Lane’s method described in Chapter 19 of the SCS Hydrology Handbook (SCS 1983) to estimate transmission losses from intermittent or ephemeral channels. Water losses from the channel are a function of effective hydraulic conductivity of the channel alluvium, flow travel time, wetted perimeter, and channel length. Both volume and peak rate are adjusted when transmission losses occur in tributary channels.
2.2.4 PEAK RATE
OF
RUNOFF
2.2.4.1 Rational Formula The rational method is the most common method used for peak flow estimation in practice. The method is presented in many references. The following description is based on Haan et al. (1994). The rational equation is q p = CiA
(2.34)
where qp is the peak rate of runoff (cfs), C is a dimensionless runoff coefficient, i is the rainfall intensity (in./h) for a duration equal to the time of concentration, tc, and A is the drainage area (ac). To be dimensionally correct, a conversion factor of 1.008 should be included to convert acre-inches per hour to cubic feet per second; however, this factor is generally neglected. Time of concentration, tc, is defined as the travel time from the most hydraulically remote point in the watershed to the watershed outlet and is typically computed as a function of the length of flow and the slope of the watershed. The basic concept of the rational equation is as follows. If a steady rainfall occurs on a watershed, the runoff rate will increase until the entire watershed is contributing runoff. If a rainfall of duration less than tc occurs, the entire basin will not be contributing, so the resulting runoff rate will be less than from a rainfall with a duration equal to tc. If a rainfall of duration greater than tc occurs, the relationship between average rainfall intensity and duration for a given frequency shows that the average intensity will be less than if the duration was equal to tc. Thus, it is reasoned that a rainfall of duration tc produces the maximum flow rate. The rational equation is based on several assumptions: The rainfall occurs uniformly over the drainage area. The peak rate of runoff can be reflected by the rainfall intensity averaged over a time period equal to the time of concentration for the drainage area. The frequency of runoff is the same as the frequency of the rainfall used in the equation. The runoff coefficient, C, is the most difficult factor to accurately determine since it represents the impact of many factors — such as interception, infiltration, surface detention, and antecedent moisture conditions — on the peak runoff. Various tables
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Runoff and Erosion in Phosphorus Models
41
of C values are available in many sources. Some provide ranges of values for different conditions such as land use, rainfall intensity, and soil texture. Others provide single values for combinations of factors. Haan et al. (1994) note that in spite of the recognized shortcomings of the rational method, it continues to be widely used because of its simplicity, entrenchment in practice, coverage in texts, and lack of a comparable alternative. 2.2.4.2 SCS TR-55 Method SCS (1986) presented the Graphical method for computing peak discharge from rural and urban areas. The Graphical method was developed from hydrograph analyses using TR-20, “Computer Program for Project Formulation — Hydrology” (SCS 1983). In the Graphical method, the peak discharge equation is computed as qp = qu AQFp
(2.35)
where qp is the peak discharge (cfs), qu is the unit peak discharge (cfs/mi2/in. runoff), A is the drainage area (mi2), Q is the runoff (in.), and Fp is a pond and swamp adjustment factor. The unit peak discharge, qu, is a function of tc and Ia/P, the ratio of initial abstraction to rainfall amount. SCS (1986) provided tables and figures for determining qu based on known tc, CN, and P. Q is computed from the curve number equation, Equation 2.1, based on a 24-h P with a return period of the peak flow. Fp is based on the percentage of ponds and swampy areas, assumed to be distributed throughout the watershed. The value of Fp ranges from 1.0 for 0% pond and swamp areas to 0.72 for 5% pond and swamp areas. 2.2.4.3 Peak Runoff Rate Implementation Some phosphorus models do not include calculations of peak runoff rate. In some models, peak discharge can be determined from overland flow routing. In other models, peak runoff rate is computed for use in erosion calculations but not in hydrologic calculations. EPIC and SWAT compute peak runoff rate using a modified rational formula, whereas AnnAGNPS computes peak discharge similar to the TR-55 method, and GLEAMS uses a different empirical relationship. In EPIC and SWAT, the peak runoff rate is predicted based on a modification of the rational formula, with different units used in the two models:
qp =
αQA 360tc
in EPIC
qp =
α t QArea c
3.6tc
in SWAT
(2.36)
where qp is peak runoff (m3/s), α is a dimensionless parameter expressing the proportion of total rainfall that occurs during tc, Q is runoff volume (mm), A is drainage area (ha), tc is time of concentration (h), α tc is the fraction of daily rainfall
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
42
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
that occurs during tc, Area is drainage area (km2), and 360 and 3.6 are unit conversions. Equation 2.36 results from relationships for C and i, described in the following paragraphs, substituted into Equation 2.34 with changes in units. The runoff coefficient, C, is calculated for each storm as the ratio of the runoff volume and the amount of rainfall. The runoff volume is computed in the model, and rainfall is an input to the model. This modification eliminates the need to estimate C from published tables. The rainfall intensity, i, is determined as the average rainfall rate during the time of concentration. An analysis of rainfall data collected by Hershfield (1961) for different durations and frequencies showed that the amount of rain falling during the time of concentration, Rtc, was proportional to the amount of rain falling during the 24-h period, or Rtc = α tc R24 , where αtc is the fraction of daily rainfall that occurs during the time of concentration. For short-duration storms, all or most of the rain will fall during the time of concentration, causing αtc to approach its upper limit of 1.0. The minimum value of αtc would be seen in storms of uniform intensity (i24 = i). Thus, αtc falls in the range tc/24 ≤ α tc ≤ 1.0. When the value of α tc is assigned based on only daily rainfall and simulated runoff, there is considerable uncertainty. Thus, in EPIC α is generated from a gamma function with the base ranging from tc/24 to 1.0. SWAT estimates αtc as a function of the fraction of daily rain falling in the half hour of highest intensity rainfall:
α tc = 1 − e[ 2tc ln(1−α 0.5 )]
(2.37)
where α0.5 is the fraction of daily rain falling in the half hour of highest-intensity rainfall. If subdaily precipitation data are used in the model, SWAT calculates the maximum half hour rainfall fraction directly from the precipitation data. If daily precipitation data are used, SWAT generates a value for α0.5 from a triangular distribution, which requires four inputs: (1) average monthly half hour rainfall fraction, (2) maximum value for half hour rainfall fraction allowed in month, (3) minimum value for half hour rainfall fraction allowed in month, and (4) a random number between 0.0 and 1.0. The time of concentration is computed in EPIC and SWAT as the sum of surface and channel flow times. The time of concentration for channel flow is computed as the average channel flow length for the watershed divided by the average channel velocity. Average channel flow length is estimated as Lc = ( L )( Lca )
(2.38)
where L is the channel length from the most distant point to the watershed outlet (km) and Lca is the distance along the channel to the watershed centroid (km). Average velocity is estimated using Manning’s equation, assuming a trapezoidal channel with 2:1 side slopes and a 10:1 bottom width-to-depth ratio. Further,
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Runoff and Erosion in Phosphorus Models
43
assuming that Lca = 0.5 L and that the average flow rate is about 6.35 mm/h and is a function of the square root of drainage area yields the final equation for the time of concentration for channel flow, tcc: tcc =
1.1Ln 0.75 A0.125σ 0.375
(2.39)
where n is Manning’s roughness coefficient and σ is the average channel slope (m/m). A similar approach is used to estimate time of concentration for surface flow, tcs, assuming that tcs is the surface slope length divided by the surface flow velocity. Manning’s equation was applied to a strip 1 m wide and the average flow rate was assumed to be 6.35 mm/h. The resulting equation for estimating tcs in hours is tcs =
(λ n)0.6 18 S 0.3
(2.40)
where λ is the surface slope length (m) and S is the land surface slope (m/m). Williams et al. (1990) noted that although some of the assumptions used in developing the equations for tcc and tcs may appear liberal, they generally give satisfactory results from small homogeneous watersheds. The authors also stated that since the equations are based on hydraulic considerations, they are more reliable than purely empirical equations. For implementation in AnnAGNPS, the TR-55 Graphical method was extended to apply to drainage areas with tc greater than 10 h and to Ia/P ratios from 0 to 1. The equation is implemented in AnnAGNPS as a + ctc + etc2 q p = 2.77777778 ⋅ 10 −3 P24 Da 3 2 1 + btc + dtc + ftc
(2.41)
where qp is peak discharge (m3/s), P24 is 24-h effective rainfall (mm), Da is drainage area (ha), tc is time of concentration (h), and a, b, c, d, e, and f are regression coefficients for a given Ia/P and rainfall distribution type. The regression coefficients eliminate the need for look-up tables in the program. In GLEAMS, peak flow rate for daily runoff is computed with an empirical relationship: q p = 200( DA)0.7 S 0.159Q 0.917 DA0.0166 ( LW )−0.187
(2.42)
where qp is the peak runoff rate (ft3/s), DA is the drainage area (mi2), S is the hydraulic slope (ft/mi), Q is the daily runoff volume (in.), and LW is the length-to-width ratio of the watershed. The hydraulic slope of a field is defined as the slope of the longest flow path. The longest flow path is the flow line from the most remote point on the
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
44
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
field (drainage) boundary to the outlet of the field. This length and difference in elevation from the most remote point to the outlet are the same as those used in estimating a time of concentration of a drainage area. As the length-to-width ratio increases, the peak rate of runoff decreases — that is, runoff is attenuated, and the runoff peak occurs later in the runoff period.
2.3 MODELING EROSION AND SEDIMENT YIELD Erosion can be divided into three processes: detachment, transport, and deposition. Detachment is the dislodging of soil particles (sediment) by raindrop impact or runoff over the soil surface. Detachment occurs when the erosive forces of raindrop impact or flowing water exceed the soil’s resistance to detachment or when the kinetic energy of water exceeds the shear strength (cohesiveness) of the soil. After particles are detached, they are available for transport. Transport is movement of sediment from its original location (source area) to downslope locations. Some transport is caused by splash resulting from the impact of raindrops. The transport capacity of the flowing water is a function of the kinetic energy of the water and sediment characteristics — particle size, density, and shape. Raindrops impacting shallow flow will enhance the transport capacity of runoff. The third process, deposition or sedimentation, refers to the settling of sediment particles out of the flowing water. The transport capacity of flowing water varies for different particle types. Deposition occurs when the sediment load of a given particle type exceeds its corresponding transport capacity. Transport capacity varies as the velocity of the flowing water varies due to changes in surface conditions, such as vegetative cover, slope steepness, and, in the case of shallow rain-impacted flow, raindrop size, velocity, and frequency. Sediment is typically deposited on the toe of slopes and on flood plains. Because phosphorus is adsorbed more to finer soil particles than to coarser particles, the distribution of sediment particle sizes is also important. Because deposition of sands occurs first, followed by large aggregates and then small aggregates, the distribution of particles in the sediment leaving a field or entering a water body is usually different than the residual soil in the field. This increase in the proportion of fine soil particles is referred to as enrichment. One measure is the enrichment ratio; that is, the ratio of the specific surface area of the sediment to the specific surface area of the residual soil. The term sheet erosion describes removal of soil in thin layers from sloping land. Very little soil might move in this manner because water does not typically flow as a sheet down a slope, except on slopes with low gradients. Often, a flow pattern of small well-defined channels, or rills, forms, and erosion occurs in the rills and the areas between the rills, commonly termed rill and interrill erosion. Rills are generally 3 to 300 mm in depth. Through interrill erosion, soil is moved by raindrop splash and overland flow to rills. Flowing water in rills detaches soil particles from the rills and transports sediment originating in both rills and interrill areas. Rill erosion is a function of soil critical shear stress; cover conditions; soil slope; and surface runoff depth, velocity, and energy. Gully erosion is an advanced form of rill
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Runoff and Erosion in Phosphorus Models
45
erosion. Gullies can be described as rills, or channels, that are greater than 300 mm in depth and that cannot be removed by ordinary tillage operations. Erosion also occurs in stream channels. Soil can be removed from stream banks (undercut banks) or the bed. Channel erosion is similar to rill and gully erosion except it occurs in perennial streams (continuously flowing) as opposed to rill and gully erosion, which are ephemeral in nature. Approaches used in phosphorus models to simulate upland erosion and sediment yield can be classified into two general categories: approaches based on the Universal Soil Loss Equation (USLE) and process-based approaches. Some of the newer, more physically based erosion modeling approaches such as Water Erosion Prediction Project (WEPP) (Laflen et al. 1997) are not described here because such detailed modeling is generally not included in phosphorus models.
2.3.1 USLE-BASED APPROACHES The USLE was developed by Wischmeier and Smith (1965, 1978) to predict longterm average annual erosion (rill and interrill combined) for conservation planning — that is, for determining appropriate combinations of cropping systems and management practices for specific fields to meet soil conservation goals. Site-specific characteristics represented in the equation include soil type, rainfall patterns, topography, and cropping and management practices. The USLE does not predict deposition or sediment yield and does not predict gully or channel erosion. The USLE (Wischmeier and Smith, 1978) is expressed as A = RKLSCP
(2.43)
where A is soil loss per unit area (M/L2/T), R is the rainfall and runoff factor (EI units/T, where T is usually annual), K is the soil erodibility factor (M/L2/EI unit from the unit plot), L is the slope length factor (dimensionless), S is the slope steepness factor (dimensionless), C is the cover and management factor (dimensionless), and P is the support practice factor (dimensionless). The numerical value for R in the soil loss equation must quantify the raindrop impact effect and must also provide relative information on the amount and rate of runoff likely to be associated with the rain (Wischmeier and Smith 1978). The rainfall erosion index derived by Wischmeier (1959) was selected as best in meeting those requirements. Values for average annual R were presented on a map of the U.S. (Wischmeier and Smith 1978). Further discussion of the R factor by Wischmeier and Smith (1978) explained the concept of the EI rainstorm parameter. EI for a given rainstorm is defined as the product of total storm energy (E) and the maximum 30-min intensity (I30), where E is in hundreds of ft-tons per acre and I30 is in in./h. The sum of the storm EI values for a given period is a numerical measure of the erosive potential of the rainfall within that period. The average annual total of the storm EI values in a particular locality is the rainfall erosion index for that locality. Because of apparent cyclical patterns in rainfall data, the published rainfall erosion index values were generally based on station rainfall records exceeding 20 years.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
46
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
The soil loss equation and factor evaluation charts were initially developed in terms of English units commonly used in the U.S., with A being computed in tons/ac/yr; R in 100 ft-tons/acre × in./h, defined as a Wischmeier English EI unit (Foster 1982); and K in tons/ac × EI. Wischmeier and Smith (1978) noted that because the factor definitions are interdependent, direct conversion of acres, tons, inches, and feet to metric units would be awkward and undesirable; converting the computed A value is more desirable. The factors L, S, C, and P were derived based on a unit plot concept. The unit plot is 72.6 ft long with a uniform 9% slope in clean-tilled continuous fallow condition with straight-row farming up and down the slope. The values of the L, S, C, and P factors are ratios of soil loss for the field and management system of interest to a field with the unit plot conditions. Thus, the USLE computes erosion for a unit plot as RK and then adjusts that value by multiplying by LSCP to account for the difference in erosion between the unit plot and the area of interest. Values for R, K, L, S, C, and P are available in Wischmeier and Smith (1978) as well as in other references. Values for those factors have been developed through field experiments and other analyses. Generally in phosphorus modeling, sediment yield is the quantity of interest as opposed to the average annual soil erosion or movement within a field or site. Estimates of sediment yield based on the USLE are often computed by multiplying the USLE soil erosion value by a sediment delivery ratio or by the ratio of sediment yield to gross erosion. Sediment delivery ratios lump together all the transport and deposition processes that occur in a field or watershed into a single value. Sediment delivery ratios are typically determined using empirical functions of watershed characteristics such as slope length and drainage area. Such sediment delivery ratios should be used with caution because sediment delivery depends on additional factors such as runoff amount and peak runoff (Williams 1975); upslope erosion, unless no deposition occurs (Kinnell 2004b); and sediment characteristics (Walling 1983). The Revised USLE (RUSLE) (Renard et al. 1991, 1997) was developed to update the USLE based on more recent data as well as a new evaluation of the original USLE. RUSLE is essentially the same as the USLE, with some differences in the estimation of some factor values. The R factor is the same except that RUSLE includes updated values for the western U.S. and accounts for the reduction in erosion due to ponding on flat slopes. RUSLE includes seasonal variation of K, whereas the USLE K is assumed constant through the year. The S factor in RUSLE is significantly modified from the original USLE as a result of extensively reevaluating the original database, adding factors for short slope lengths, and providing new values for thawing soils (McCool et al. 1987). The L factor was developed by McCool et al. (1989) from the original USLE database, augmented with theoretical considerations. The factor is computed in the same way, but the exponent in the relationship used in RUSLE is a function not only of slope steepness, as in the USLE, but also of the ratio of rill-to-interrill erosion for the soil. The USLE C factor is a lumped factor to account for above-ground, surface, and below-surface effects. RUSLE uses a subfactor approach in which subfactors accounting for prior land use, canopy cover, surface cover, surface roughness, and soil moisture are multiplied to yield the C
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Runoff and Erosion in Phosphorus Models
47
factor. These subfactors depend on cropping and management and can be expressed as a function of residue cover, canopy cover, canopy height, surface roughness, below-ground root mass and residue, prior cropping, and time. RUSLE also uses a subfactor approach for the P factor. Subfactors account for contouring, strip cropping, and terracing. Use of subfactors allows a more detailed evaluation of factors affecting P, particularly when considering a combination of practices. Also, it allows a correction for the impact of large storms on contouring. Three major limitations of the USLE restrict its application in many modeling analyses (Foster 1982). First, the USLE is not intended for estimating soil loss from single storm events. Second, it is an erosion equation and does not estimate deposition. Third, it does not estimate gully or channel erosion. Several modifications of the USLE have been developed to address these limitations. Williams (1975) replaced the USLE R factor with runoff variables in developing the Modified USLE (MUSLE) to compute sediment yield: Y = 11.8(Q*q p )0.56 KLSCP
(2.44)
where Y is the sediment yield (t/ha), Q * is the runoff volume (m3), and qp is the peak runoff rate (m3/s). Williams (1975) concluded that runoff variables increased the prediction accuracy, eliminated the need for a delivery ratio, which was used in the USLE to estimate sediment yield, and enabled the equation to give single-storm estimates of sediment yield. Foster et al. (1973) modified the USLE to include both rainfall and runoff terms (Onstad and Foster 1975):
(
)
A = 0.5 Rst + 15Qq1p/ 3 KLSCP
(2.45)
where A is soil loss for a storm (tons/ac), Rst is the storm rainfall factor (EI units), Q is the runoff volume (in.), and q*p is the peak runoff rate (in./h). The objective of the modification was to better account for the contributions of interrill and rill erosion than the original USLE by using terms more directly targeted at these two forms of erosion. The coefficients were evaluated assuming that under certain conditions detachment by rainfall and runoff is about evenly divided. Equations like 2.44 and 2.45 that specify the USLE or the RUSLE variables K, C, and P when the R factor is not based on EI, the product of total storm energy and the maximum 30-min intensity, are not sound (Kinnell 2004a). K is, by definition, the average annual soil loss per unit of R. If the basis of R is changed, then values of K that differ from those used in the USLE and RUSLE must be used. Also, since runoff is not explicitly considered in determining the R factor in the USLE and RUSLE, variations in runoff associated with variations in vegetation, crop management, and support practices are incorporated implicitly in the USLE and RUSLE C and P factors. Consequently, the USLE and RUSLE C and P factors can only be used if runoff for the unit plot condition is used in determining R.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
48
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
The USLE and RUSLE overpredict small soil loss and underpredict high soil loss (Risse et al. 1993). The failure of the EI index to explicitly consider runoff as a factor in determining the erosivity of individual rainfall events is a major factor in generating this overprediction–underprediction problem. Kinnell and Risse (1998) showed that combining the EI index with the runoff ratio markedly improved the accuracy of the prediction of erosion if event runoff amount was determined accurately.
2.3.2 USLE-BASED APPROACH IMPLEMENTATION EPIC contains three equations to simulate rainfall and runoff erosion: the USLE, the MUSLE (Williams 1975), and the Onstad-Foster modification of the USLE (Onstad and Foster 1975). The model user specifies which equation interacts with other EPIC components. As indicated previously, the three equations are identical except for their energy components. In EPIC, a coarse fragment factor, which is a function of the percent rock in the first soil layer, has been added to each equation as a multiplicative factor. Erosion is calculated in SWAT using MUSLE with the coarse fragment factor. SWAT also provides USLE estimates of erosion for comparison purposes. The USLE estimates are not used for any calculations in SWAT. Delivery of sediment to the main channel from overland flow is lagged in SWAT for large drainage areas with a time of concentration greater than one day, similar to the lag of runoff (Equation 2.24). After the sediment load in surface runoff is calculated, the amount of sediment released to the main channel is calculated as − surlag sed = (sed ′ + sed stor,i −1 ) 1 − e tc
(2.46)
where sed is the amount of sediment discharged to the main channel on a given day (metric tons), sed′ is the amount of sediment load generated on a given day (metric tons), sedstor,i-1 is the sediment stored or lagged from the previous day (metric tons), surlag is the surface runoff lag coefficient, and tc is the time of concentration (h). The expression [1 − exp(-surlag/tc)] in Equation 2.46 represents the fraction of the total available sediment that will be allowed to enter the reach on any one day. The sheet and rill erosion model in AnnAGNPS is based on RUSLE. Factor values are determined for each cell; AnnAGNPS represents a watershed as a grid of cells. The C factor is assigned an annual value for non-cropland and a series of 24 values, each representing an increment of 15 or more days, for each year in the operation management schedule for cropland. The P factor is assigned an annual value for non-cropland and a series of annual values for cropland, one value for each year in the operation management schedule. EI values are expressed for the watershed as 24 values, each representing an increment of 15 or more days, for the calendar year. The delivery ratio for each cell to its receiving reach is computed by particle-size classes, proportioned to the respective fall velocities of the classes. AnnAGNPS also computes gully erosion. The runoff from the cell that drains through the gully is based on the ratio of the gully drainage area to the cell drainage area. The mass of sediment is determined from gully runoff and a power equation using
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Runoff and Erosion in Phosphorus Models
49
a user-supplied coefficient and exponent for the equation (Merkel et al. 1988). The sediment from the gully is added to the appropriate stream reach.
2.3.3 PROCESS-BASED APPROACHES Process-based approaches represent detachment, transport, and deposition separately, in contrast to the USLE, which computes an overall erosion rate. Rill and interrill erosion are often calculated separately. Channel erosion is represented as a separate process. The main concept for modeling upland erosion is that sediment load is controlled by either the amount of sediment made available for transport through detachment or the transport capacity of the flowing water. Deposition occurs when sediment load exceeds transport capacity. Detachment by flow can occur when transport capacity exceeds sediment load. A detachment capacity can be defined based on the local conditions, but the actual detachment rate depends on the degree to which the transport capacity is filled. Conservation of mass of sediment provides a framework for the interrelationship among detachment, transport, and deposition. Bennett (1974) presented the conservation of mass (continuity) equation for sediment, including dispersion of sediment while it is suspended in flow. The form of the equation normally used in dynamic upland erosion models omits dispersion because it is normally negligible (Foster 1982): ∂qs ∂(cy) + ρs = Dr + Dl ∂x ∂t
(2.47)
where qs is the sediment load per unit width (M/L/T), x is distance along the slope (L), ρs is mass density of the sediment particles (M/L3), c is concentration of the sediment in the flow (volume of sediment/volume of flow, L3/L3), y is flow depth (L), t is time (T), Dr is rill erosion rate (M/L2/T), and Dl is delivery rate of sediment from interrill areas (M/L2/T). The term ∂qs /∂x is the build-up or loss of the sediment load with distance; ρs ∂(cy)/∂t is the storage rate of sediment with the flow depth; and Dr and Dl are contributions of sediment from lateral inflow. Dr and Dl are the net result of detachment and transport by rainfall and runoff. To solve the continuity equation for sediment, relationships are needed for Dr , Dl, and shear stress. A number of relationships have been proposed to describe the various processes. Some of those relationships are summarized in the following paragraphs. The next section provides examples of the relationships used for the various erosion processes in phosphorus models. Relationships have been proposed that relate detachment by rainfall, which is important in interrill erosion, to both rainfall and soil characteristics. Many investigators have found that the amount of soil detached by rainfall is directly related to rainfall intensity. Total rainfall mass, or kinetic energy at impact, also has been found to influence rainfall erosivity. A number of soil characteristics have been identified as influencing rainfall detachment (e.g., moisture content, organic matter, pH, structure, bulk density, amount of air-filled pore space, degree of aggregation, particle
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
50
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
size, percentage of clay). The influence of overland flow on detachment by rainfall has been included in some relationships. Transport by rainfall, or splash, is a function of slope steepness, amount of rain, rainfall intensity, soil properties, microtopography, and wind velocity. Though this form of transport is often negligible and not included in most models, relationships have been proposed to describe transport by rainfall as a function of rainfall and soil properties. Detachment by overland flow is a function of the shear stress, or tractive force, on the soil boundary. Shear stress is defined by the surface slope and the velocity and depth of flow (Kilinc and Richardson 1973). Relationships have been proposed that express detachment by runoff as a function of variables such as flow rate, velocity, slope, shear stress, critical shear stress, and soil erodibility. Transport by runoff is a function of flow rate, depth, and velocity, rainfall effects, soil depth, and slope steepness. Transport capacity also depends on sediment characteristics, such as particle size and density. Though differences exist between the hydraulics of shallow flows in upland areas and deeper channel flows, important similarities can be identified between streamflow and shallow flow concentrated in small channels. Researchers have investigated the applicability of sediment transport equations for streamflow to transport by overland flow. Alonso et al. (1981) evaluated nine sediment transport equations with respect to field and laboratory data. They concluded that although no equation satisfactorily represented the entire spectrum of sediment and flow characteristics, three of the tested equations could give satisfactory estimates of transport capacity over different subsets of the data range. The Yalin (1963) equation can be used to compute sediment transport capacities for overland flows and to predict transport rates of light materials in streamflows. The Yang (1973) equation best estimated streamflow transport capacity in the range of fine to coarse sands, whereas the Laursen (1958) equation predicted reasonably for small streamflows carrying very fine sands and silts. Foster and Meyer (1972) also chose the Yalin equation for determining transport capacity of overland flow because of the equation’s theoretical soundness for shallow flow. The Yalin equation assumes that sediment motion begins when the lift force of flow exceeds a critical lift force (Foster and Meyer 1972). Once a soil particle is entrained in flowing water, the drag force of the flow carries the particle downstream until the particle weight forces it out of the flow and back to the ground surface or channel bed. Observations of the erosion process on natural soils during simulated rainstorms indicated that a large fraction of the transported soil moves by saltation and by a rolling fashion along the bottom of the small-flow channels. Such soil is detached and transported in the form of aggregates having larger diameters but lower densities than primary particles (Moldenhauer and Koswara 1968). When the flow slows, these aggregates readily deposit. These observations indicate that once aggregates are detached from cohesive agricultural soils, their transport is very similar to that of noncohesive grains, the type of particles for which the Yalin equation was developed. Foster and Meyer (1972) also cited the simplicity of the equation and its excellent fit to observed data as reasons for selecting it. The Yalin equation requires only two common flow parameters: hydraulic radius and slope of the energy-grade line. The
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Runoff and Erosion in Phosphorus Models
51
transportability of a soil is described by particle density, particle diameter, and the critical lift force, which is given by the extended Shields’ diagram (Mantz 1977). Foster and Meyer (1972) presented the Yalin equation as 1 Ws = 0.635δ 1 − ln(1 + σ ) Sg ρw dV* g σ
(2.48)
where
σ = Aδ δ=
(2.48a)
Y − 1 (if Y < YCR, δ = 0) YCR
A = 2.45( Sg )−0.4 (YCR )0.5 Y=
V*2 ( Sg − 1) gd
V = ( gRS f)1/ 2
(2.48b)
(2.48c)
(2.48d)
(2.48e)
where Ws is transport capacity (M/L/T), Sg is particle specific gravity (dimensionless), ρw is mass density of the fluid (M/L3), d is particle diameter (L), V* is shear velocity (L/T), g is acceleration of gravity (L/T2), δ is the dimensionless excess tractive force, YCR is critical lift force given by the Shields’ diagram, R is hydraulic radius, and Sf is slope of the energy-grade line. In the derivation of the equation, the constant 0.635 is the only empirically derived factor other than the critical lift force from the Shields’ diagram. The Yalin equation was developed for particles of uniform size. Foster and Meyer (1972) modified the equation to predict transport rates of mixtures. The basis of the Yalin derivation was that the sediment transport rate is equal to the number of particles in transport over a unit area times the weight and velocity of each particle. To modify the equation, a mixture of sizes was assumed to reduce the number, but not the velocity, of particles of a given size in transport. Yalin assumed the number of particles in transport to be proportional to δ. For a mixture, the number of particles of a given size i was assumed to be proportional to δi. Then the number of transported particles of size i in a mixture was δ ( N e )i = N i i T
(2.49)
where Ni is the number of particles transported in sediment of uniform size i for a δi and T = ∑in=1 δ i where n is the number of size groups.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
52
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
As derived by Yalin, the left side of Equation 2.48 is proportional to the number of particles in transport. If the left side of Equation 2.48 is equal to P, the nondimensional transport is then ( Pe )i =
Piδ i T
(2.50)
where (Pe)i is the effective P for particle size i in a mixture and Pi is P calculated for uniform material of size i. The actual transport rate, Wsi, of each particle size in a mixture is then expressed as Wsi = ( Pe )i Sg ρw gdV*
(2.51)
2.3.4 PROCESS-BASED APPROACH IMPLEMENTATION Some models, including GLEAMS, HSPF, and ANSWERS-2000, use a processbased approach to model erosion. Specifically, they consider detachment, transport, and deposition processes discretely. The GLEAMS model uses the same equations as the CREAMS model with only slight modifications. The following description of the GLEAMS erosion equations is from Foster et al. (1980). Detachment is computed as q DI = 0.210 EI (s + 0.014) KCP p Vu x DR = 37983mVu q1p/ 3 72.6
m −1
(2.52)
qp s 2 KCP Vu
(2.53)
where DI is interrill detachment rate (lb/ft2/sec), DR is rill detachment capacity rate (lb/ft2/sec), EI is Wischmeier’s rainfall erosivity (energy × 30-min intensity), x is length of the overland flow element (ft), s is sine of the slope angle, m is slope length exponent, K is USLE soil erodibility factor [(tons/ac)(ac/100 ft-tons)(h/in.)], C is USLE cover management factor, qp is peak runoff rate (ft/sec), and Vu is runoff volume (ft). Equations 2.52 and 2.53 were derived from the equation of continuity for sediment transport (Bennett 1974), incorporating expressions to describe rill and interrill erosion (Foster et al. 1977). The sum of Equation 2.52 and 2.53 defines the sediment load. Sediment transport by overland flow is computed in GLEAMS using the Yalin equation for multiple particle classes — sand, silt, clay, and small and large aggregates––with sizes estimated internally after Foster et al. (1985). HSPF includes calculations of detachment by rainfall and runoff, transport, and deposition. Soil detachment by rainfall is computed as RAIN DET = ∆t (1.0 − CR)( SMPF )( KRER) ∆t
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
JRER
(2.54)
Modeling Runoff and Erosion in Phosphorus Models
53
where DET is sediment detached from the soil matrix by rainfall (tons/ac/interval), ∆t is time interval (h), CR is the fraction of the land covered by snow and other cover, SMPF is the supporting management practice factor based on the USLE P factor, KRER is a detachment coefficient dependent on soil properties, RAIN is rainfall intensity (in./interval), and JRER is a detachment exponent dependent on soil properties. When simulating the washoff of detached sediment, the transport capacity of the overland flow is estimated and compared to the amount of detached sediment available. HSPF includes two options for these calculations. One option is identical to the method used in the Agricultural Runoff Management (ARM) model (Donigian and Crawford 1976b; Donigian et al. 1977) and Nonpoint Source (NPS) model (Donigian and Crawford 1976a), which are both predecessors to HSPF that include some dimensionally nonhomogeneous equations designed for 15- and 5-min intervals. The second option is dimensionally homogeneous and generally less dependent on the time step. In the second option, the transport capacity is calculated as SURO STCAP = ∆t ( KSER) ∆t
JSER
(2.55)
where STCAP is the capacity for removing detached sediment (tons/ac/interval), KSER is a coefficient for transport of detached sediment, SURO is surface outflow of water (in./interval), and JSER is an exponent for transport of detached sediment. The amount of washoff of detached sediment, WSSD (tons/ac/interval), is equal to the detached sediment storage when STCAP exceeds the amount of sediment in storage. When STCAP is less than the amount of detached sediment in storage, the situation is transport limiting, so WSSD is equal to STCAP. In addition, detachment and transport of soil particles from the soil matrix by flowing water is computed as SURO SCRSD = ∆t ( KGER) ∆t
JGER
(2.56)
where SCRSD is scour of matrix soil (tons/ac/interval), KGER is a coefficient for scour of the matrix soil, and JGER is an exponent for scour of the matrix soil. The sum of the two fluxes, WSSD and SCRSD, represents the total sediment outflow from the land segment.
2.3.5 CHANNEL EROSION Detachment (or scour), transport, and deposition in channels are functions of flow, channel, and sediment characteristics. Incoming flow and sediment affect channel erosion. If the incoming sediment load exceeds the flow’s transport capacity, deposition occurs. If incoming sediment load is less than the transport capacity, erosion can occur. In channels where deposition occurred previously during periods of excessive upland erosion, sediment yield might continue at a high rate after upland sediment yield is reduced because the previously deposited sediment is susceptible
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
54
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
to being eroded. Often in modeling, however, the previously deposited sediment is assumed to have the same critical shear stress as the channel soil. Similar to upland erosion, channel erosion simulation methods are often based on the continuity equation for sediment. Transport capacity can be represented by several different sediment transport equations for channels. Detachment is often based on shear stress exerted by the flowing water as compared to the critical shear stress required to detach soil from the stream bed or bank.
2.3.6 CHANNEL EROSION IMPLEMENTATION HSPF simulates transport, deposition, and scour of sediment separately for noncohesive (sand) particles and for cohesive (silt and clay) particles. Erosion and deposition of sand is affected by the transport capacity of the flow. If the amount of sand being transported is less than the transport capacity, then sand will be scoured from the bed. Scour occurs until the actual sand load becomes equal to the carrying capacity of the flow or until the available bed sand is all scoured. Conversely, deposition occurs if the sand load exceeds the transport capacity. The user selects one of three methods to compute transport capacity of the flow for sand: the Toffaleti’s method, the Colby method, or a user-provided power function of velocity. In Toffaleti’s method, the stream is divided into four zones: bed, lower, middle, and upper, which extends to the surface. The sand particle concentration is computed by a power relation for each of the three upper zones. The velocity profile is represented by a power relation. Transport capacity is then computed for each zone based on the concentration and velocity. The total sand transport capacity is the sum of the transport capacity for the four zones. Colby’s method computes transport capacity using empirical relationships based on the median bed sediment diameter, average stream velocity, hydraulic radius, fine sediment load concentration, and water temperature. The deposition and scour of cohesive sediment fractions (silt and clay) in HSPF is dependent on the shear stress exerted on the bed surface. Whenever shear stress is less than the user-supplied critical shear stress for deposition, deposition occurs. Whenever shear stress is greater than critical shear stress for scour, scouring of cohesive bed sediments occurs. Shear stress is calculated as a function of the slope and hydraulic radius of the reach. The concentration of suspended sediment lost to deposition (DEPCONC) during a simulation interval is −W τ AVDEPM 1− τ CD DEPCONC = CONC 1 − e
(2.57)
where CONC is the concentration of suspended sediment at the start of the interval (mg/L), W is the settling velocity for the sediment fraction (m/interval), AVDEPM is the average depth of water in the reach (m), τ is shear stress (lb/ft2 or kg/m2), and τCD is critical shear stress for deposition. The rate of resuspension, or scour, of cohesive sediments from the bed is derived from a modified form of Partheniades’s (1962)
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Runoff and Erosion in Phosphorus Models
55
equation. The concentration of suspended sediment added to suspension by scour during a simulation interval (SCRCONC) is
SCRCONC =
τ M 1000 − 1 AVDEPM τ CS
(2.58)
where M is the erodibility coefficient (kg/m2), 1000 is a conversion factor, and τ CS is the critical shear stress for scour (lb/ft2 or kg/m2). The user must supply values for M and τ CS for each fraction of cohesive sediment that is modeled. If the amount of scour calculated is greater than available storage in the bed, the bed scour is set equal to the bed storage, and the bed storage is set equal to zero. Since the value specified for τ CS should be greater than that for τ CD, only one process (deposition or scour) occurs during each simulation interval. In SWAT, sediment transport in the channel is a function of two simultaneous processes: deposition and degradation. SWAT has the capability to compute deposition and degradation using the same channel dimensions for the entire simulation, or SWAT can simulate downcutting and widening of the stream channel and can update channel dimensions throughout the simulation. Previous versions of SWAT used stream power, defined as the product of water density, flow rate, and water surface slope by Bagnold (1977), to estimate deposition and degradation in the channel (Arnold et al. 1995). In SWAT2000, the equations have been simplified, and the maximum amount of sediment that can be transported from a reach segment is a function of the peak channel velocity. Available stream power is used to reentrain loose and deposited material until all of the material is removed. Excess stream power causes bed degradation, which is adjusted for stream bed erodibility and cover. The maximum amount of sediment that can be transported from a reach segment is spexp concsed ,ch,mx = csp vch , pk
(2.59)
where concsed,ch,mx is the maximum concentration of sediment that can be transported by the water (ton/m3 or kg/L), csp is a coefficient defined by the user, vch,pk is the peak channel velocity (m/s), and spexp is an exponent defined by the user. The exponent, spexp, normally varies between 1.0 and 2.0 and was set at 1.5 in the original Bagnold stream power equation (Arnold et al. 1995). The maximum concentration of sediment calculated with Equation 2.59 is compared to the concentration of sediment in the reach at the beginning of the time step, concsed,ch,i. If concsed,ch,i > concsed,ch,mx, deposition is the dominant process in the reach segment, and the net amount of sediment deposited is calculated as the difference between the two concentrations multiplied by the volume of water in the reach segment. If concsed,ch,i < concsed,ch,mx, degradation is the dominant process in the reach segment. Sediment routing in a reach is accomplished in AnnAGNPS using a unit-width, steady-state, uniform, spatially varied sediment discharge model, with a modified Einstein deposition equation and the Bagnold suspended sediment formula for the
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
56
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
transport capacity by particle size class. The sediment transport capacity for each particle size (Theurer and Cronshey 1998) is qsc =
kτ vw2 vf
(2.60)
where k is transport capacity factor (nondimensional) with values provided for each of five particle types, τ is bed shear stress (mg/m2), vw is flow velocity (m/s), and vf is particle fall velocity (m/s). Channel erosion occurs if the transport capacity exceeds the incoming sediment load to the reach and sediment is available to be eroded from the channel bed or bank. Channel erosion in GLEAMS simulates erosion in terrace channels, diversions, major flow concentrations where topography has caused overland flow to converge, grass waterways, row middle or graded rows, tail ditches, and other similar channels (Foster et al. 1980). The channel element does not describe gully or large streamchannel erosion. With the exception that shear stress and detachment by flow are estimated differently, the same concepts and equations are used in both the channel and overland flow elements. As with the overland flow element, changes in the controlling variables along the channel are allowed. Thus, a channel with a decreasing slope or a change in cover can be analyzed. Detachment by flow is calculated as D = Kch (1.35τ − τ cr )1.05
(2.61)
where D is detachment capacity (lb/ft 2 /s), K ch is an erodibility factor [lb/ft2/s)(ft2/lb)1.05], τ is average shear of the flow in the channel (lb/ft2), and τcr is a critical shear stress (lb/ft2) below which erosion is negligible. Shear stress is assumed to be triangularly distributed in time during the runoff event to estimate the time that shear stress is greater than the critical shear stress, during which shear stress is assumed constant and equal to peak shear stress for the storm. Erosion can proceed to a nonerodible layer, and then the channel widens and the erosion rate decreases.
2.4 SUMMARY Runoff and erosion are important transport mechanisms for phosphorus. Runoff transports dissolved forms of phosphorus, whereas erosion transports sedimentadsorbed phosphorus. Runoff and erosion processes are simulated in different ways in different phosphorus models. Table 2.5 summarizes the approaches used in some models. The most common approach for estimating runoff volume is the SCS curve number method in which runoff is correlated with rainfall, soil type, land cover, hydrologic condition, and antecedent soil-moisture content. This method is applicable to small watersheds and estimates the total storm runoff from total storm rainfall, ignoring rainfall intensity. A second approach for estimating runoff volume is to
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Runoff Model
Volume
Hydrograph
Erosion Peak Rate
Channel Flow Routing
Upland
AnnAGNPS
Curve number modified for soil moisture content
SCS unit hydrograph
Similar to TR-55
Daily to watershed outlet
Based on RUSLE; Ephemeral Gully Erosion Model
ANSWERS2000
Green-Ampt infiltration equation
Kinematic routing with Manning’s equation
Implicit with routing
Kinematic routing with Manning’s equation
Empirical detachment equations
EPIC
Curve number modified for soil moisture content
NI
Modified rational formula
NI
GLEAMS
Curve number modified for soil moisture content
NI
Empirical relationship
NI
USLE, MUSLE, Onstad-Foster modification of USLE Empirical interrill and rill detachment equations
Sediment Transport Delivery ratio based on Hydrogeomorphic USLE (HUSLE) (Theurer and Clarke 1991) Yalin equation extended by Mantz (1977)
NI
Yalin equation
Channel Modified Einstein equation for sediment transport; Bagnold suspended sediment formula for transport capacity Based on unit stream power and critical shear theory used in the WEPP model (Alberts et al. 1995) NI
Modeling Runoff and Erosion in Phosphorus Models
TABLE 2.5 Representation of Runoff and Erosion Processes and Quantities in Selected Field- and Watershed-Scale Models
NI
(continued)
57
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
58
TABLE 2.5 (CONTINUED) Representation of Runoff and Erosion Processes and Quantities in Selected Field- and Watershed-Scale Models Runoff
Erosion
Volume
Hydrograph
HSPF
Empircal equations based on soil water storage
Chezy-Manning flow equation with an empirical relationship
Outflow depth related to detention storage
SWAT
Curve number modified for soil moisture content; Green-Ampt infiltration equation
Runoff lag time based on time of concentration
Modified rational formula
WEND-P
Regional water quantity budget
NI
Peak Rate
NI
Channel Flow Routing Continuity equation plus outflow as function of volume or time or simple power function Variable storage routing or Muskingum routing plus transmission losses from channels NI
Note: NI = not included; WEND-P = Watershed Ecosystem Nutrient Dynamics-Phosphorus.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Upland Empirical relationship for rainfall–runoff detachment
Sediment Transport Empirical relationship
Channel Transport, deposition, and scour for noncohesive and cohesive sediments
MUSLE + USLE for comparison purposes
NI
Deposition, degradation
Assigned erosion rate
NI
NI
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
Model
Modeling Runoff and Erosion in Phosphorus Models
59
determine infiltration using the Green-Ampt or other infiltration equation and then to subtract infiltration from rainfall to determine the amount of runoff. The runoff hydrograph can then be determined empirically or through kinematic routing of the runoff over the land surface. The runoff from overland flow can then be routed through the channel to the watershed outlet in a watershed-scale model. Erosion models can be broadly categorized as USLE- and process-based approaches. The USLE computes average annual soil erosion as a function of soil properties, slope steepness and length, cover management practices, and supporting, or conservation, practices. The USLE estimates gross erosion, or soil movement, rather than sediment yield since it does not estimate deposition. A process-based model estimates detachment and sediment transport separately and considers their interaction to determine deposition. Many of the current process-based erosion prediction methods used in phosphorus models utilize the K, C, and P factors from the USLE. This is often inappropriate because those factor values are interdependent and were determined using a particular representation of rainfall–runoff energy (i.e., the USLE R factor). The phosphorus models often use a different representation of rainfall–runoff energy; thus, the USLE K, C, and P values are inappropriate. Appropriate representations of runoff and erosion quantities and rates to include in phosphorus fate and transport models depend on the purpose of the model, as well as on the spatial and temporal scales of the model. The purpose of such models is usually either to determine the relative impact of different management practices on phosphorus fate — often termed management models — or to predict the absolute values of phosphorus fate and transport. The use of the CN approach for runoff volume estimation and the USLE or its modifications for erosion prediction can be adequate in management models. Those approaches have been shown in many instances to accurately predict the relative impacts of different land-management practices and site characteristics. Problems arise when those same approaches are implemented when the goal is absolute prediction. For runoff prediction, the CN approach was developed for small watersheds. It is not appropriate to apply it in a spatially lumped model to a large watershed. It can be appropriate to apply it in a distributed model where the CN and resulting runoff are determined for small land areas independently. The USLE does not represent sediment deposition or sediment yield. The sediment delivery ratio used in conjunction with the USLE has limitations because variation of the ratio with factors such as flow conditions, erosion amount, and sediment characteristics is not included in commonly used sediment delivery ratio estimations. Limitations of some other USLE-based equations were described previously. Models designed for absolute prediction should use process-based representations. Infiltration-based approaches have the potential to give more accurate predictions of runoff than the curve number approach. At this time, only limited use has been made of process-based erosion models such as WEPP (Laflen et al. 1997) in models of phosphorus fate and transport. Utilization of such process-based models to simulate soil erosion processes provides the opportunity to improve the absolute prediction of phosphorus fate and transport.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
60
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
REFERENCES Alberts, E.E., M.A. Nearing, M.A. Weltz, L.M. Risse, F.B. Pierson, X.C. Zhang, J.M. Laflen, and J.R. Simanton. 1995. Chapter 7. Soil component. Pp. 7.1–7.47 in USDA-Water Erosion Prediction Project: Hillslope Profile and Watershed Model Documentation, D.C. Flanagan and M.A. Nearing (Eds.). NSERL Report 10, USDA-ARS National Soil Erosion Research Laboratory, West Lafayette, IN. Alonso, C.V., W.H. Neibling, and G.R. Foster. 1981. Estimating sediment transport capacity in watershed modeling. Trans. ASAE 24(5):1211–1220, 1226. Arnold, J.G., J.R. Williams, and D.R. Maidment. 1995. Continuous-time water and sedimentrouting model for large basins. J. Hydraul. Eng. 121:171–183. Bagnold, R.A. 1977. Bedload transport in natural rivers. Water Resour. Res. 13:303–312. Beasley, D.B., L.F. Huggins, and E.J. Monke. 1982. ANSWERS: a model for watershed planning. Trans. ASAE 23(4): 938–944. Bennett, J.P. 1974. Concepts of mathematical modeling of sediment yield. Water Resour. Res. 10(3): 485–492. Bicknell, B.R., J.C. Imhoff, J.L. Kittle, Jr., T.H. Jobes, and A.S. Donigian, Jr., 2001. Hydrological Simulation Program-Fortran: HSPF Version 12 User’s Manual. Athens, GA: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency National Exposure Research Laboratory. Bondelid, T.R., R.H. McCuen, and T.J. Jackson. 1982. Sensitivity of SCS models to curve number variation. Water Res. Bull. 18(1):111–116. Bouraoui, F. 1994. Development of a continuous, physically-based, distributed parameter, nonpoint source model. Ph.D. dissertation Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg. Bouwer, H. 1966. Rapid field measurement of air-entry value and hydraulic conductivity of soil as significant parameters in flow system analysis. Water Resour. Res. 2:729–738. Bouwer, H. and M. Asce. 1969. Infiltration of water into nonuniform soil. J. Irrig. Drain. Div., ASCE 95(4):451–462. Brakensiek, D.L. and W.J. Rawls. 1983. Agricultural management effects on soil water processes part II: Green-Ampt parameters for crusting soils. Trans. ASAE. 26(6):1751–1757. Cronshey, R.G. and F.G. Theurer. 1998. AnnAGNPS nonpoint pollutant loading model. Paper presented at the First Federal Interagency Hydrologic Modeling Conference, April 19–23, Las Vegas, NV. Cunge, J.A. 1969. On the subject of a flood propagation method (Muskingum method). J. Hydraul. Res. 7(2):205–230. Donigian, A.S., Jr., D.C. Beyerlein, H.H. Davis, Jr., and N.H. Crawford. 1977. Agricultural Runoff Management (ARM) model version II: refinement and testing. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, EPA 600/3-77-098, Environmental Research Laboratory, Athens, GA. Donigian, A.S., Jr. and N.H. Crawford. 1976a. Modeling pesticides and nutrients on agricultural lands. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, EPA 600/2-7-76-043, Environmental Research Laboratory, Athens, GA. Donigian, A.S., Jr., and N.H. Crawford. 1976b. Modeling nonpoint pollution from the land surface. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, EPA 600/3-76-083, Environmental Research Laboratory, Athens, GA. Edwards, D.R. and T.C. Daniel. 1993. Abstractions and runoff from fescue plots receiving poultry litter and swine manure. Trans. ASAE 36(2):405–411. Foster, G.R. 1982. Modeling the erosion process. Pp. 295–380 in Hydrologic Modeling of Small Watersheds, C.T. Haan, H.P. Johnson, and D.L. Brakensiek (Eds.). St. Joseph, MI: American Society of Agricultural Engineers.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Runoff and Erosion in Phosphorus Models
61
Foster, G.R., L.F. Huggins, and L.D. Meyer. 1968. Simulation of overland flow on short field plots. Water Resour. Res. 4:1179. Foster, G.R., L.J. Lane, J.D. Nowlin, J.M. Laflen, and R.A. Young. 1980. A model to estimate sediment yield from field sized areas: Development of model. Pp. 36–64 in CREAMS — A Field Scale Model for Chemicals, Runoff, and Erosion from Agricultural Management Systems, Volume 1: Model Documentation. USDA-SEA Conservation Report 26. Foster, G.R. and L.D. Meyer. 1972. Transport of soil particles by shallow flow. Trans. ASAE 15(1):99–102. Foster, G.R., L.D. Meyer, and C.A. Onstad. 1973. Erosion equation derived from modeling principles. American Society of Agricultural Engineers Paper 73-2550. St. Joseph, MI: American Society of Agricultural Engineers. Foster, G.R., L.D. Meyer, and C.A. Onstad. 1977. A runoff erosivity factor and variable slope length exponents for soil loss estimates. Trans. ASAE 20(4):683–687. Foster, G.R., R.A. Young, and W.H. Neibling. 1985. Sediment composition for nonpoint source pollution analyses. Trans. ASAE 28(1):133–139, 146. Green, W.H. and G.A. Ampt. 1911. Studies on soil physics — 1 — the flow of air and water through soils. J. Agric. Sci. 4:11–24. Haan, C.T., B.J. Barfield, and J.C. Hayes. 1994. Design Hydrology and Sedimentology for Small Catchments. San Diego, CA: Academic Press. Hauser, V.L. and O.R. Jones. 1991. Runoff curve numbers for the Southern High Plains. Trans. ASAE 34(1):142–148. Hawkins, R.H. 1975. The importance of accurate curve numbers in the estimation of storm runoff. Water Res. Bull. 11(5):887–891. Hershfield, D.M. 1961. Rainfall frequency atlas of the United States for durations from 30 minutes to 24 hours and return periods from 1 to 100 years. U.S. Department of Commerce Technology. Paper 40. Holtan, H.N. 1961. A concept for infiltration estimates in watershed engineering. USDA-ARS Bull. 41–51. Huggins, L.F. and J.R. Burney. 1982. Surface runoff, storage, and routing. Pp. 167–225 in Hydrologic Modeling of Small Watersheds, C.T. Haan, H.P. Johnson, and D.L. Brakensiek (Eds.). St. Joseph, MI: American Society of Agricultural Engineers. Huggins, L.F. and E.J. Monke. 1966. The mathematical simulation of the hydrology of small watersheds. Technical Report 1, Water Resources Research Center, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN. Kilinc, M. and E.V. Richardson. 1973. Mechanics of soil erosion from overland flow generated by simulated rainfall. Hydrology Paper 3, Colorado State University, Fort Collins. Kinnell, P.I.A. 2004a. Letter to the editor: the mathematical integrity of some USLE variants. Soil Sci. Soc. Amer. J. 68:336–337. Kinnell, P.I.A. 2004b. Sediment delivery ratios: a misaligned approach to determining sediment delivery from hillslopes. Hydrol. Proc. 18:3191–3194. Kinnell, P.I.A. and L.M. Risse. 1998. USLE-M: empirical modelling rainfall erosion through runoff and sediment concentration. Soil Sci. Soc. Amer. J. 62:1667–1672. Knisel, W.G., Ed. 1993. GLEAMS: Groundwater Loading Effects of Agricultural Management Systems, version 2.10. University of Georgia, Publication 5, Coastal Plain Experiment Station, Biological and Agricultural Engineering Department, Athens, GA. Laflen, J.M., W.J. Elliot, D.C. Flanagan, C.R. Meyer, and M.A. Nearing. 1997. WEPPpredicting water erosion using a process-based model. J. Soil Water Conserv. 52(2): 96–102. Laursen, E. 1958. The total sediment load of streams. J. Hydraul. Div. 84(1):1–36.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
62
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
Leonard, R.A., W.G. Knisel, and D.A. Still. 1987. GLEAMS: Groundwater Loading Effects of Agricultural Management Systems. Trans. ASAE 30(5):1403–1418. Lighthill, M.J. and G.B. Whitham. 1955. On kinematic waves 1. Proc. Royal Soc., London, Ser. A, Mathematics and Physical Sciences (1934–1990). 229 (1178):281–316. Linsley, R.K., M.A. Kohler, and J.L.H. Paulhus. 1988. Hydrology for Engineers. London: McGraw-Hill. Mantz, P.A. 1977. Incipient transport of fine grains and flakes by fluids — extended Shields diagram. J. Hydraul. Div. ASCE 103(HY6):601–615. McCool, D.K., L.C. Brown, G.R. Foster, C.K. Mutchler, and L.D. Meyer. 1987. Revised slope steepness factor for the Universal Soil Loss Equation. Trans. ASAE 30(5):1387–1396. McCool, D.K., L.C. Brown, G.R. Foster, C.K. Mutchler, and L.D. Meyer. 1989. Revised slope length factor for the Universal Soil Loss Equation. Trans. ASAE 32(5):1571–1576. Mein, R.G. and C.L. Larson. 1971. Modeling infiltration component of the rainfall–runoff process. Bulletin 43, Water Resources Research Center, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN. Mein, R.G. and C.L. Larson. 1973. Modeling infiltration during a steady rain. Water Resour. Res. 9(2):384–394. Merkel, W.A., D. Woodword, and C.D. Clarke. 1988. Ephemeral Gully Erosion Model. Pp. 315–323 in Modeling of Agricultural, Forest, and Range Hydrology, St. Joseph, MI: American Society of Agricultural Engineers. Moldenhauer, W.C. and J.C. Koswara. 1968. Effect of initial clod size on characteristics of splash and wash erosion. Soil Sci. Soc. Amer. Proc. 32(6):875–879. Morel-Seytoux, H.J. and J. Khanji. 1974. Derivation of an equation of infiltration. Water Resour. Res. 10(4):795–800. Nearing, M.A., B.Y. Liu, L.M. Risse, and X. Zhang. 1996. Curve number and Green-Ampt effective hydraulic conductivities. Water Res. Bull. 32:125–136. Neitsch, S.L., J.G. Arnold, J.R. Kiniry, J.R. Williams, and K.W. King. 2002. Soil and Water Assessment Tool theoretical documentation version 2000. TWRI Report TR-191, Texas Water Resources Institute, College Station, TX. Neuman, S.P. 1976. Wetting from pressure head in the infiltration model of Green and Ampt. Water Resour. Res. 12(3):564–566. Novotny, V. and H. Olem. 1994. Water Quality: Prevention, Identification, and Management of Diffuse Pollution. New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold. Onstad, C.A. and G.R. Foster. 1975. Erosion modeling on a watershed. Trans. ASAE 18(2):288–292. Overton, D.E. 1972. Kinematic flow on long impermeable planes. Water Res. Bull. 8(6):1198–1204. Partheniades, E. 1962. A study of erosion and deposition of cohesive soils in salt water. Ph.D. thesis, University of California, Berkeley. Philip, J.R. 1957. The theory of infiltration: 1 — the infiltration equation and its solution. Soil Sci. 83:435–448. Rasmussen, T.C. and D.D. Evans. 1993. Water infiltration into exposed fractured rock surfaces. Soil Sci. Soc. Amer. J. 57(2):324–329. Rawls, W.J. and D.L. Brakensiek. 1985. Prediction of soil water properties for hydrologic modeling. Pp. 293–299 in Watershed Management in the 80’s, E.B. Jones and T.J. Ward (Eds). New York: American Society of Civil Engineers. Rawls, W.J. and D.L. Brakensiek. 1986. Comparison between Green-Ampt and curve number runoff predictions. Trans. ASAE 29(6):1597–1599.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Runoff and Erosion in Phosphorus Models
63
Rawls, W.J., J.J. Stone, and D.L. Brakensiek. 1989. Infiltration. Pp. 4.1–4.12 in Water Erosion Prediction Project: Hillslope Profile Version, L.J. Lane and M.A. Nearing (Eds.). National Soil Erosion Laboratory Report 2, USDA-ARS, West Lafayette, IN. Renard, K.G., G.R. Foster, G.A. Weesies, and J.P. Porter. 1991. RUSLE: Revised universal soil loss equation. J. Soil Water Conserv. 46(1):30–33. Renard, K.G., G.R. Foster, G.A. Weesies, D.K. McCool, and D.C. Yoder. 1997. Predicting soil erosion by water: a guide to conservation planning with the Revised Universal Soil Loss Equation (RUSLE). U.S. Department of Agriculture Agricultural Handbook 703, Washington, D.C. Risse, L.M., M.A. Nearing, A.D. Nicks, and J.M. Laflen. 1993. Error assessment in the Universal Soil Loss Equation. Soil Sci. Soc. Amer. J. 57:825–833. Richards, L.A. 1931. Capillary conduction through porous mediums. Physics 1:313–318. Sharpley, A.N. and J.R. Williams (Eds.). 1990. EPIC — Erosion/productivity impact calculator: 1: model documentation. U.S. Department of Agriculture Technical Bulletin 1768, Washington, D.C. Simanton, J.R., R.H. Hawkins, M. Mohseni-Saravi, and K.G. Renard. 1996. Runoff curve number variation with drainage area, Walnut Grove, Arizona. Trans. ASAE 39(4): 1391–1394. Skaggs, R.W. and R. Khaleel. 1982. Infiltration. Pp. 119–166 in Hydrologic Modeling of Small Watersheds, C.T. Haan, H.P. Johnson, and D.L. Brakensiek (Eds.). St. Joseph, MI: American Society of Agricultural Engineers. Soil Conservation Service (SCS). 1972. Hydrology, Section 4: National Engineering Handbook. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office. Soil Conservation Service (SCS). 1983. Computer program for project formulation-hydrology. Draft, SCS Technical Release 20, Washington, D.C. Soil Conservation Service (SCS). 1986. Urban hydrology for small watersheds. U.S. Department of Agriculture Technical Release 55, Washington, D.C. Strelkoff, T. 1969. One-dimensional equations of open channel flow. Trans. Hyd. Div. ASCE 95(HY3):861–876. Theurer, F.D. and C.D. Clarke. 1991. Wash load component for sediment yield modeling. Pp. 7-1–7-8 in Proceedings of the Fifth Federal Interagency Sedimentation Conference, Washington, D.C.: Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. Theurer, F.G. and R.G. Cronshey. 1998. AnnAGNPS–reach routing processes. Paper presented at the First Federal Interagency Hydrologic Modeling Conference, April 19–23, Las Vegas, NV. Walling, D.E. 1983. The sediment delivery problem. J. Hydrol. 65:209–237. Williams, J.R. 1969. Flood routing with variable travel time or variable storage coefficients. Trans. ASAE 12(1):100–103. Williams, J.R. 1975. Sediment-yield prediction with universal equation using runoff energy factor. Pp. 224–252 in Present and Prospective Technology for Predicting Sediment Yields and Sources, Publ. ARS. 5-40. U.S. Gov. Print Office, Washington, D.C. Williams, J.R. and R.W. Hann. 1973. HYMO: Problem-oriented language for hydrologic modeling––user’s manual. publ. ARS-S-9, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Washington, D.C. Williams, J.R., C.A. Jones, and P.T. Dyke. 1990. The EPIC model. Pp. 3–92 in EPIC— Erosion/Productivity Impact Calculator: 1: Model Documentation, A.N. Sharpley and J.R. Williams (Eds.). U.S. Department of Agriculture Technical Bulletin 1768, Washington, D.C. Wischmeier, W.H. 1959. A rainfall erosion index for a Universal Soil-Loss Equation. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. Proc. 23:246–249.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
64
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
Wischmeier, W.H. and D.D. Smith. 1965. Predicting rainfall erosion losses from cropland east of the Rocky Mountains. U.S. Department of Agriculture Handbook no. 282, Washington, D.C. Wischmeier, W.H. and D.D. Smith. 1978. Predicting rainfall erosion losses — a guide to conservation planning. Agriculture Handbook 537 U.S. Department of Agriculture Science and Education Administration, Washington, D.C. Woolhiser, D.A. and J.A. Liggett. 1967. Unsteady one-dimensional flow over a plane — the rising hydrograph. Water Resour. Res. 3(3):753–771. Yalin, M.S. 1963. An expression for bed load transportation. J. Hydraul. Div. ASCE 89(HY3):221–250. Yang, C.T. 1973. Incipient motion and sediment transport. J. Hydraul. Div. ASCE 99(HY10):1679–1704.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
3
Modeling Phosphorus in Runoff: Basic Approaches Miguel L. Cabrera University of Georgia, Athens, GA
CONTENTS 3.1 Modeling Dissolved Inorganic Phosphorus....................................................66 3.1.1 Dissolved Inorganic Phosphorus Derived from Soil ..........................66 3.1.1.1 Model Based on Laboratory-Derived Relationships............66 3.1.1.2 Model Based on Field-Derived Relationships .....................69 3.1.2 Dissolved Inorganic P Derived from Surface-Applied Manures........73 3.1.2.1 Model Based on Laboratory-Derived Relationships............73 3.1.2.2 Model Based on Field-Derived Relationships .....................75 3.2 Modeling Particulate Inorganic P in Surface Runoff.....................................75 3.3 Summary and Conclusions .............................................................................77 References................................................................................................................77
The potential impact of phosphorus (P) in accelerating eutrophication of surface waters has made evident the need for simulation models to estimate P concentrations in surface runoff and P exports from watersheds. Although much progress has been made with P simulation models, there are still difficulties in obtaining accurate estimates of runoff P. Some of these difficulties are caused in part by incomplete modeling of the mechanisms involved, as well as a lag in the incorporation of recent scientific results into models. A complete model of runoff P should include all important P fractions present in surface runoff. In general, P in runoff is divided into dissolved P and particulate P based on fraction size. Dissolved P is associated with fractions < 0.45-µm, whereas particulate P is associated with fractions > 0.45-µm. Dissolved and particulate P can contain organic and inorganic forms, both of which can contribute to eutrophication of surface waters. However, whereas inorganic P is immediately available to algae (Nürnberg and Peters 1984), organic P has to be mineralized before it can be utilized. Because of this immediate availability of inorganic P, most models of P in surface runoff have concentrated on modeling inorganic P. This chapter reviews basic approaches used to model dissolved inorganic P and particulate inorganic P in surface runoff and highlights current additional needs. Some of the approaches described here are used in current P simulation models such Agricultural Nonpoint Source 65
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
66
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
(AGNPS), Areal Nonpoint Source Watershed Environment Response Simulation 2000 (ANSWERS-2000), Erosion Productivity Impact Calculator (EPIC), Hydrologic Simulation Program-Fortran (HSPF), and Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT).
3.1 MODELING DISSOLVED INORGANIC PHOSPHORUS Two main sources of dissolved inorganic P in runoff are P present in the soil and P present in surface-applied animal manures. Approaches used for each of these sources will be presented separately.
3.1.1 DISSOLVED INORGANIC PHOSPHORUS DERIVED
FROM
SOIL
Models for dissolved inorganic P derived from the soil have used two main approaches: one using laboratory-derived relationships and one using field-derived relationships. The underlying assumption in both approaches is that soils have a pool of P from which runoff water can desorb P. 3.1.1.1 Model Based on Laboratory-Derived Relationships This model of dissolved P in runoff is based on studies dealing with the kinetics of P desorption-from-soil. Sharpley et al. (1981a) used the following equation to estimate the amount of dissolved inorganic P desorbed from soil: P desorbed (mg kg−1) = K Po Tα Wβ
(3.1)
where K, α, and β are parameters, Po is desorbable P (mg kg−1), T is extraction time (min), and W is the water-to-soil extraction ratio (cm3 g−1). According to Sharpley et al. (1981a), Equation 3.1 can be derived by assuming that P desorption is controlled by nonlinear diffusion. These authors developed parameters for Equation 3.1 by treating four soils with different amounts of P — 0, 47.5, 95, and 190 µg P g−1 soil — incubating them at 25°C for 3 days, and then shaking duplicate samples with distilled water at a water-to-soil ratio of 10:1, 40:1, 100:1, 200:1, 400:1, and 1000:1 for 5 to 180 min. The water extracts were then analyzed for inorganic P using Murphy and Riley’s (1962) method. It should be noted that in addition to measuring inorganic P, this method may include a small fraction of organic P. Because of that, the P determined with this method is usually called dissolved reactive P (DRP). Parameter Po in Equation 3.1 represents the pool of desorbable P present in the soil and was estimated following the 3-day incubation with two sequential 1-h extractions with water at a water-to-soil ratio of 40:1 (Sharpley et al. 1981a). Parameter α was estimated by plotting for each soil P amendment and water-to-soil ratio, the log(P desorbed) vs. the log(T ), and fitting a straight line. The following derivation shows the rationale for such a procedure. For a given soil and water-to-soil ratio W, Equation 3.1 can be simplified by taking decimal logarithms on both sides to yield log (P desorbed) = log (K) + log ( Po) + β log (W) + α log (T )
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
(3.2)
Modeling Phosphorus in Runoff: Basic Approaches
67
In Equation 3.2, the sum of log (K) + log (Po) + β log (W) represents the intercept of the straight line fitting log (P desorbed) vs. log (T), whereas α represents the slope of the line. Sharpley et al. (1981a) found that for a given soil α was fairly constant across P amendments and extracting ratios. Parameter β was estimated by plotting for each soil, P amendment, and shaking time the log (P desorbed) vs. the log (W) and fitting a straight line. The following derivation shows the rationale for such a procedure. For a given soil and given shaking time T, Equation 3.1 can be simplified by taking decimal logarithms on both sides as follows: log (P desorbed) = log (K) + log (Po) + α log (T ) + β log (W)
(3.3)
In Equation 3.3, the sum log (K) + log (Po) + α log (T ) represents the intercept of the straight line fitting log (P desorbed) vs. log (W), whereas β represents the slope of the line. Sharpley et al. (1981a) found that β was fairly constant across soils, P amendments, and extracting times. Finally, parameter K in Equation 3.1 was determined by plotting for each soil, W, and T the amount of P desorbed vs. desorbable P (Po) and fitting a straight line to the data. For a given soil, W, and T, the slope of the line is given by Slope = K Tα Wβ
(3.4)
Thus, K can be calculated as follows: K = Slope/(Tα Wβ)
(3.5)
Sharpley et al. (1981a) found that for a given soil, the values of K at different shaking times and water-to-soil ratios were fairly similar. Because the aforementioned procedure for the determination of α, β, and K is time consuming, Sharpley (1983) explored the possibility of estimating these parameters from soil properties and found that the following equations could be used to obtain reasonable estimates of α, β, and K for 78 soils from the continental U.S. and Puerto Rico.
α = 0.815 (percent clay/percent organic C)−0.540
R = 0.89
(3.6)
β = 0.141 (percent clay/percent organic C)0.429
R = 0.84
(3.7)
KB = 0.630 (percent clay/percent organic C)−0.698
R = 0.82
(3.8)
KL = 1.422 (percent clay/percent organic C)−0.829
R = 0.95
(3.9)
where KB represents the value for K when desorbable P (Po) is measured by the Bray-1 soil test method (Bray and Kurtz 1945) and KL represents the value for K when desorbable P is measured by isotopic dilution (Sharpley 1983).
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
68
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
Vadas and Sims (2002) developed the following equations to estimate α, β, and K for 23 sandy soils from Delaware. They measured desorbable P (Po) with iron (Fe)-oxide impregnated filter strips.
α = 0.024 (Feox /organic C)−0.346 R = 0.86
(3.10)
β = 0.107 (Feox + Alox)0.251
R = 0.72
(3.11)
K = 2.168 (Feox + Alox)−0.773
R = 0.85
(3.12)
where Feox and Alox are acid ammonium oxalate-extractable Fe and aluminum (Al) (mmol kg−1), and organic C is expressed in mmol kg−1. Vadas and Sims (2002) used this approach because determining α, β, and K from clay content, as proposed by Sharpley (1983), might not be accurate for sandy soils with little clay where P chemistry is controlled mainly by Fe and Al oxides. Equation 3.1 estimates P desorbed from soil in terms of mg kg−1 soil. Thus, to estimate the concentration of dissolved inorganic P in surface runoff in mg P L−1 it is necessary to know the amount of soil that interacts with surface runoff as well as the volume of surface runoff. The amount of soil that interacts with runoff can be calculated from the effective depth of interaction (EDI) and the bulk density of the soil under consideration. Therefore, Sharpley et al. (1981b) proposed the following model to estimate dissolved inorganic P in runoff: DIP = (K Po EDI Db Tα Wβ)/V
(3.13)
where DIP is dissolved inorganic P in runoff (mg L−1), Po is desorbable P measured by Bray-1 P (mg P kg−1), EDI is the effective depth of interaction (mm), Db is the soil bulk density (g cm−3), K, α, and β are constants, T is time of contact (min), W is the water-to-soil ratio during runoff (cm3 g−1), and V is the runoff volume per unit area (mm). Parameters EDI and Db are needed to calculate the amount of soil from which P is released, which in turn is used to estimate W. To obtain estimates for EDI, Sharpley (1985a) carried out rainfall simulation experiments with soil packed in boxes that received different amounts of straw (0.5, 1.25, 2.5, 3.75, and 5 mg ha−1) and were positioned at slopes of 2, 4, 6, 8, 12, and 20%. Constants K, α, and β were calculated from the percent of clay and the percent of organic C of the soil, and DIP was measured in the runoff. Because all the terms of Equation 3.13, with the exception of EDI, were known for each treatment, Equation 3.13 was then solved for EDI to obtain estimates for this parameter. Sharpley (1985a) found that EDI increased with slope rainfall intensity, and rate of wheat straw and that EDI could be estimated from the following equation: ln EDI = i + 0.576 ln(soil loss; kg ha−1)
(3.14)
i = –3.13 + 0.071 soil aggregation
(3.15)
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Phosphorus in Runoff: Basic Approaches
69
where soil aggregation is the proportion of particles less than 2 µm in dispersed soil divided by the proportion of particles less than 2 µm in undispersed soil. Although the concepts on which Equations 3.13, 3.14, and 3.15 are based appear valid, these equations have not been used in current simulation models. Thus, further investigation is needed on the development and use of this approach to simulate DIP in runoff. Vadas et al. (2002) used Equations 3.10 through 3.15 to estimate DIP concentrations in surface runoff from coastal plain soils and found that the approach overestimated DIP values by a factor of about 20. They suggested that the source of the overestimation may have been the presence of sediment in runoff, which would have caused resorption of the dissolved P initially released from the soil. Consequently, they developed a correction factor of the form: corrected P (mg L−1) = estimated P (mg L−1)/error
(3.16)
error = 2.68 × ln(sediment yield, kg ha−1) + 4.94
(3.17)
where
Vadas et al. (2002) suggested incorporating this approach into Field Hydrologic and Nutrient Transport Model (FHANTM) 2.0, a model developed to simulate fieldscale water and P movement in the watershed of Lake Okeechobee in Florida (Fraisse and Campbell 1997). 3.1.1.2 Model Based on Field-Derived Relationships The model based on field-derived relationships uses the following equation to estimate the concentration of dissolved inorganic P in runoff: DIP = Po/Kd
(3.18)
where DIP is the dissolved inorganic P in runoff (mg P L−1), Po is desorbable P (mg P kg−1), and Kd is P partitioning coefficient (L kg−1). The partitioning coefficient, Kd, is generally obtained from rainfall simulation studies by determining the slope of a straight line fitted to a plot of flow-weighted concentration of inorganic P in runoff vs. desorbable P in soil, Po. The reciprocal of the slope is Kd. The amount of desorbable P in soil to be used in this equation has been measured by several procedures, including Mehlich-3 P, Bray-1 P, water-extractable P, and soil P sorption saturation (Vadas et al. 2005a). Values of Kd obtained by Vadas et al. (2005a) were 345 to 500 L kg−1 for Mehlich-3 P or Bray-1 P, 63 to 89 L kg−1 for water-extractable P, and 39 L kg−1 for soil P sorption saturation. The approach described in Equation 3.18 is similar to the one used in the EPIC model, except that the desorbable P pool in EPIC is called labile P and was defined by Sharpley et al. (1984) as the P extracted from soil by a loose anion exchange resin saturated with bicarbonate ions. Because values of anion exchange resin P in soil are not as available as values of P extracted by common soil test P extractants, Sharpley et al. (1984) developed equations to estimate labile P from values of Olsen
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
70
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
TABLE 3.1 Equations to Estimate Labile P from Common Soil Test P Extractants Equation
Independent Variable Range
R2
Labile P = 0.55 Bray-1 P + 6.1 Labile P = 1.09 Olsen P + 3.2 Labile P = 0.10 Mehlich-1 P + 10.2
Calcareous Soilsa 1 to 77 3 to 38 3 to 338
0.83 0.74 0.51
Labile P = 0.56 Bray-1 P + 5.1 Labile P = 1.07 Olsen P + 4.1 Labile P = 0.13 Mehlich-1 P + 11.4
Slightly Weathered Soilsb 4 to 79 3 to 42 3 to 215
0.79 0.77 0.39
Labile P = 0.14 Bray-1 P + 4.2 Labile P = 0.55 Olsen P + 2.1 Labile P = 0.24 Mehlich-1 P + 2.9
Highly Weathered Soilsc 3 to 222 2 to 50 2 to 147
0.76 0.61 0.84
Labile P = 0.84 Bray-1P + 20.6 Labile P = 0.61 Olsen P + 0.84 Labile P = 0.97 Mehlich-3 P + 19.7
Continental U.S. Soilsd 1 to 221 1 to 131 2 to 226
0.51 0.96 0.62
Note: All variables are expressed in mg P kg−1. a b c d
n n n n
= = = =
20. 35. 23. 24.
Sources: R.G. Myers, A.N. Sharpley, S.J. Thien, and G.M. Pierzynski, Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 69, 511–521, 2005; and A.N. Sharpley, C.A. Jones, C. Gray, and C.V. Cole, Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 48, 805–809, 1984. With permission.
P, Bray-1 P, and Mehlich-1 P. Table 3.1 shows these equations for 78 soils from the continental U.S. and Puerto Rico, which were divided into calcareous (n = 20), slightly weathered (n = 35), and highly weathered (n = 23) soils. In recent work, Myers et al. (2005) suggested a standardized method for extraction of labile P with anion exchange resin membrane strips saturated with bicarbonate ions. In the proposed method, 1 g of soil is placed into a 125-mL wide-mouth bottle with 80 mL of deionized water and is shaken for 24 h with three anion exchange resin strips (each 2.08 × 4.15 cm, BDH 551642S), followed by P elution and determination. Myers et al. (2005) also presented equations relating labile P to Bray1 P, Olsen P, and Mehlich-3 P for 24 soils from the continental U.S. (Table 3.1). These equations are useful to initialize the labile P pool in the EPIC model (Jones et al. 1984) as well as in other models that use the same approach, such as AGNPS, ANSWERS-2000, HSPF, and SWAT (Figure 3.1).
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Phosphorus in Runoff: Basic Approaches
71
TABLE 3.2 Equations to Estimate the Phosphorus Availability Index (PAI) from Soil Characteristics Equation to Estimate Parameter PAI
Range of Independent Variables
Calcareous Soilsa PAI = –0.0061 CaCO3 (%) + 0.58 R2 = 0.71
CaCO3: 0.5 to 54
Slightly Weathered Soilsb BS: 40 to 100 PAI = 0.0043 BS(%) + 0.0034 labile Labile P: 4 to 53 P (mg/kg) + 0.11 pH – 0.70 pH: 5.2 to 8.3 R2 = 0.75 Highly Weathered Soilsc PAI = –0.047 ln(CL,%) + 0.0045 labile CL: 0.4 to 76 P(mg/kg) – 0.053 OC(%) + 0.39 Labile P: 3 to 43 R2 = 0.78 OC: 0.4 to 3.8 Notes: CaCO3 = calcium carbonate; BS = base saturation; CL = clay; OC = organic carbon. a b c
n = 20. n = 35. n = 23.
Source: A.M. Sharpley, C.A. Jones, C. Gray, and C.V. Cole, Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 48, 805–809, 1984. With permission.
Fresh Organic P
Fertilizer P
Stable Organic P
Labile P
Stable Inorganic P
Active Inorganic P
FIGURE 3.1 Flow diagram for phosphorus model in EPIC.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Runoff P
72
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
In addition to being directly involved in the estimation of runoff P, the labile P pool in EPIC and similar models is also important because it is used in the initialization of the active inorganic P pool, as described by the following equation: active inorganic P = labile P × (1 – PAI)/PAI
(3.19)
where active inorganic P is mg P (kg soil) −1, labile P is mg P (kg soil) −1, and PAI is the phosphorus availability index (unitless). Parameter PAI is determined by measuring labile P at the end of a six-month incubation of soil samples that receive different amounts of P fertilizer at the start of the incubation. The slope of the graph of labile P vs. P fertilizer added (g labile P/g P fertilizer added) is the value of PAI. Because the determination of this parameter is time consuming, Sharpley et al. (1984) developed equations to estimate it from soil characteristics, as shown in Table 3.2. In addition to being used in the initialization of the active inorganic P pool, parameter PAI is also used to calculate the rate of transfer between labile P and active inorganic P, as follows: P transfer = 0.1 {labile P – [active P × PAI/(1 – PAI)]}
(3.20)
Vadas et al. (2006) found that replacing the 0.1 P sorption rate factor in Equation 3.20 with a dynamic one provided more accurate estimates of labile P in nine soils from the eastern U.S. Incorporation of this dynamic P sorption factor in EPIC and other models would be expected to improve the estimation of short-term runoff P from soils receiving incorporated applications of P fertilizer, particularly in the case of soils with large clay contents. Parameter PAI is also used to define the rate constant of P transfer (Kas) between the active inorganic P pool and the stable inorganic P pool (Figure 3.1), as shown here: rate of transfer = Kas (4 × inorganic active P – inorganic stable P)
(3.21)
where Kas = exp( –1.77 PAI – 7.05). The active inorganic P pool is in turn used to initialize the inorganic stable P pool: inorganic stable P = 4 × inorganic active P
(3.22)
where both pools are expressed in mg P kg−1. The active inorganic P and the stable inorganic P pools are important in runoff P estimation because they can affect the labile P pool, which is directly involved in soluble P in runoff, as indicated before. Another pool that may have an important influence on the labile P pool is the stable organic P pool, but values for organic P are not commonly found in soil databases. Thus, Sharpley et al. (1984) developed a regression equation to estimate organic P from total nitrogen (N) in soil: organic P (mg kg−1) = 44.4 + 1130 total N (%) R2 = 0.64
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
(3.23)
Modeling Phosphorus in Runoff: Basic Approaches
73
One of the drawbacks of the EPIC P model (and other models that use the EPIC routine) is that fertilizer P added in inorganic or organic (manure) form is assumed to be incorporated into the soil, even when the fertilizer is surface applied as in the case of pastures. Consequently, the added P is assumed to move rapidly into the labile P pool and subsequently into the active inorganic P and stable inorganic P pools (Figure 3.1). As a result, the EPIC model tends to underestimate the amount of soluble P in runoff derived from surface applications of manure to grasslands (Pierson et al. 2001). The addition of a surface pool to hold surface-applied fertilizer or manure would likely improve simulations of runoff P from grasslands by the EPIC-based models.
3.1.2 DISSOLVED INORGANIC P DERIVED MANURES
FROM
SURFACE-APPLIED
Models for dissolved inorganic P desorbed from manures have also used two approaches: one that uses laboratory-derived relationships and one that uses fieldderived relationships. 3.1.2.1 Model Based on Laboratory-Derived Relationships This model is based on the assumption that manures have a pool of water-extractable P from which runoff water can solubilize P. Vadas et al. (2004) used manure extraction data from Dou et al. (2000, 2002) and Kleinman et al. (2002b), as well as runoff P data from Kleinman et al. (2002a) and Kleinman and Sharpley (2003), to develop the following model for dissolved inorganic P (DIP) in runoff from surface-applied dairy slurry, poultry manure, and swine slurry. Dairy Slurry: DIP (mg P L−1) = [(0.024W0.27) × (extractable P) × (runoff/rainfall) × 0.35]/W (3.24) Poultry Manure: DIP (mg P L−1) = [(0.003W + 0.32) × (extractable P) × (runoff/rainfall)]/W
(3.25)
Swine Slurry: DIP (mg P L−1) = [(0.004W + 0.23) × (extractable P) × (runoff/rainfall) × 0.60]/W (3.26) In Equations 3.24, 3.25, and 3.26, W is the water-to-manure ratio (L kg−1 dry manure), extractable P (mg P kg−1 dry manure) is inorganic P extracted by shaking manure with deionized water at a water-to-manure ratio of 250 (cm3 g−1 dry) for 60 min, and runoff/rainfall is the ratio of runoff volume over rainfall volume. The equations for slurries include a reduction factor (0.35 for dairy and 0.60 for swine) that represents P infiltrated into the soil in the free-draining water present in the slurries. The assumption is that P that infiltrates into the soil is not exposed to
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
74
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
surface runoff. This infiltration factor is used to calculate runoff P in the first runoff event only; it is not used in subsequent events. Vadas et al. (2004) found that these equations yielded good estimates of DIP concentration in runoff from soil boxes where manures had been surface applied and subjected to simulated rainfall. In further work, Vadas et al. (2005b) collected more manure extraction data, combined the poultry and swine data into one equation, made all extraction equations nonlinear, and updated all equations, as follows. Dairy Slurry: DIP (mg P L−1) = [1.2W/(W + 73.1)] × (extractable P) × 0.4 × (runoff/rainfall)/W
(3.27)
Poultry and Swine Manure: DIP (mg P L−1) = [2.2W/(W + 300.1)] × (extractable P) × 0.4 × (runoff/rainfall)/W
(3.28)
The 0.4 factor in Equation 3.27 and 3.28 is only used for slurries and only for the first runoff after manure application. In the same work, Vadas et al. (2005b) proposed replacing the runoff/rainfall factor with a P distribution factor, which is the fraction of manure-extractable inorganic P released by rain transported in surface runoff. Calculation of the P distribution factor requires knowledge of rainfall rate as well as times for start and stop of runoff with respect to start of rainfall. The concept behind the P distribution factor is that the amount of rain causing release of manure P to runoff is that which occurs between the start and stop of runoff. In contrast, the rain that occurs between the start of rainfall and the start of runoff causes release of manure P that is leached into the soil instead of being carried off by runoff. Vadas et al. (2005b) showed that the P distribution factor allowed better estimations of DIP in runoff from soil boxes and field plots than the use of the runoff/ rainfall factor. They also observed good relationships between the runoff/rainfall factor and the P distribution factor and between the runoff/rainfall factor and the percent of error in estimation of DIP by using runoff/rainfall instead of the P distribution factor. P distribution factor = 0.95 (runoff/rainfall)0.255
R2 = 0.59***
(3.29)
% error = 0.88 (runoff/rainfall)−0.68
R2 = 0.72***
(3.30)
where *** indicates significance at the 0.001 probability levels. Vadas et al. (2005b) proposed that Equation 3.29 or 3.30 could be used to estimate either the P distribution factor or correct DIP estimations obtained by using the runoff/rainfall factor. The advantage of using the runoff/rainfall factor over the P distribution factor in simulation models is that the data to calculate runoff/rainfall are usually computed in runoff simulation models, whereas data to estimate the P distribution factor are not available in simulation models that use daily time steps. Vadas (personal communication, 2006) has recently developed a manure and P runoff model that incorporates these concepts to simulate manure on the surface and transformation with time so that DIP in runoff can be estimated on an event basis. © 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Phosphorus in Runoff: Basic Approaches
75
It should be pointed out that Equations 3.27 and 3.28 estimate only dissolved inorganic P in runoff. Vadas et al. (2004) found that equations containing the first two terms of Equation 3.24, 3.25, and 3.26 could also be used to estimate release of organic P from manures, but this approach has not been tested for estimating organic P in runoff. Thus, additional work is needed to simulate dissolved organic P in runoff, which may be significant, especially if the pH of manure drops after application to a field. Work by Tasistro et al. (2004) showed that the pH of poultry litter that was surface applied to a tall fescue and Bermuda grass pasture dropped from 8.5 to 6.5 within 30 days after application. The same study also showed that decreasing the pH of poultry litter increased the amount of water-soluble organic P released. Thus, additional research on the release of organic P to runoff is needed to further improve P models. The model recently developed by Vadas et al. (personal communication, 2006) includes dissolved organic P in runoff. 3.1.2.2 Model Based on Field-Derived Relationships Models based on field-derived relationships estimate dissolved inorganic P concentration in runoff from the rate of manure application or from the rate of soluble P applied with the manure. For example, DeLaune et al. (2004a) presented data on dissolved inorganic P concentration as a function of broiler litter application rate for the first three runoff events after application. In subsequent work, DeLaune et al. (2004b) developed a linear relationship between dissolved inorganic P concentration in runoff and soluble inorganic P applied: DIP (mg P L−1) = 2.40 + 1.49 soluble P applied (kg ha−1)
(3.31)
A similar relationship is used in the Georgia phosphorus index to estimate inorganic P in runoff, which is then multiplied by runoff volume to estimate total P loss (Cabrera et al. 2002). DeLaune et al. (2004a) also developed an equation to estimate total P loss in runoff from pastures as a function of the rate of soluble P applied: DIP (kg P ha−1) = 1.79 + 0.44 soluble P applied (kg ha−1)
(3.32)
A potential problem with this approach is that it ignores transformations of manure P after application. Recent work shows that water-extractable P in manure increases after application (McGrath et al. 2005; Tasistro et al. 2004).
3.2 MODELING PARTICULATE INORGANIC P IN SURFACE RUNOFF Sharpley and Smith (1992) conducted research to estimate bioavailable particulate P (BPP), which includes particulate inorganic P as well as other bioavailable P sources that are attached to soil particles > 0.45 µm. They estimated BPP with the following equation: BPP (mg P L−1) = soil BP (mg kg−1) × sediment in runoff (g L−1) × ER
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
(3.33)
76
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
where ER is the enrichment ratio, which represents the P concentration in eroded sediments divided by the P concentration in the surface soil, and soil BP is the bioavailable P in the soil estimated by extracting the soil with 0.1 M sodium hydroxide (NaOH) at a solution-to-soil ratio of 500 to 1 for 17 h. The value of ER can be estimated from soil loss as follows: ln(ER) = 1.21 – 0.16 ln(Soil loss; kg ha−1)
(3.34)
A similar approach to that described in Equation 3.33 is used in the EPIC model. Sharpley (1985b) presented different equations for estimating ER for different soil pools as used in EPIC. To visualize the effects of desorbable soil P and soil loss on total bioavailable P (DRP + BPP), Equations 3.13 and 3.33 were used to estimate the concentration of total bioavailable P in a 35-mm runoff event from a soil with 10% clay, 1% organic C, and a bulk density of 1.35 g cm−3. The results presented in Figure 3.2 clearly show that when yearly soil losses are small (< 0.5 Mg ha−1 yr−1), total bioavailable P in runoff is below 1000 µg P L−1, even at soil test P levels as great as 250 mg P kg−1. As soil test P levels and soil losses increase, the concentration of total bioavailable P increases to values as great as 4000 µg P L−1. It should be noted that these results are for Bray-1 P and may be different for other soil tests. Sharpley and Smith (1992) used Equation 3.13 and 3.33 to estimate bioavailable P in surface runoff from native grasslands and cropped fields and compared estimated values to measured values. They found that the model tended to underestimate
Particulate + Soluble P (µg P L-1)
4000
3000
2000
1000
250 200 Bra 150 y-1 P ( m 100 50 gP k g -1 )
5
Soil
10
15
20 -1
ha (Mg Loss
25 -1 yr )
FIGURE 3.2 Concentration of particulate + soluble P in a 35-mm runoff event from a hypothetical soil as affected by soil test P (Bray-1) and yearly soil loss (no application of manure).
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Phosphorus in Runoff: Basic Approaches
77
TABLE 3.3 Method Used by Different Models for Calculating Inorganic P in Runoff Model AnnAGNPS ANSWERS-2000 GWLF HSPF SWAT WEND-P
Method of Calculating Inorganic P in Runoff Based on EPIC model Based on EPIC model Requires input on runoff P concentration for each land use Similar to EPIC Based on EPIC model Proportional to soil P content
Notes: AnnAGNPS = Annualized Agricultural Nonpoint Source; ANSWERS = Areal Non-Point Source Watershed Environment Response Simulation; GWLF = Generalized Watershed Loading Functions; HSPF = Hydrologic Simulation Program-Fortran; SWAT = Soil and Water Assessment Tool; WEND-P = Watershed Ecosystem Nutrient Dynamics-Phosphorus.
bioavailable P in runoff from native grasslands and no-till fields and suggested this underestimation may have resulted from an inadequate modeling of the release of P from vegetation.
3.3 SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS Current approaches to modeling P in runoff consider dissolved and particulate inorganic P derived from soil as well as dissolved inorganic P derived from surfaceapplied manures (Table 3.3). Some approaches are based on laboratory data, whereas others are based on field data. Further work is needed to improve these models and to include dissolved and particulate organic P derived from soil and surface-applied manures. Additional work is also needed to model the release of P from vegetation.
REFERENCES Bray, R.H. and L.T. Kurtz. 1945. Determination of total, organic, and available forms of phosphorus in soil. Soil Sci. 59:39–45. Cabrera, M.L., D.H. Franklin, G.H. Harris, V.H. Jones, H.A. Kuykendall, D.E. Radcliffe, L.M. Risse, and C.C. Truman. 2002. The Georgia phosphorus index. Cooperative Extension Service, Publications Distribution Center, University of Georgia, Athens. DeLaune, P.B., P.A. Moore, Jr., D.K. Carman, A.N. Sharpley, B.E. Haggard, and T.C. Daniel. 2004a. Development of a phosphorus index for pastures fertilized with poultry litter — factors affecting phosphorus runoff. J. Environ. Qual. 33:2183–2191. DeLaune, P.B., P.A. Moore, Jr., D.K. Carman, A.N. Sharpley, B.E. Haggard, and T.C. Daniel. 2004b. Evaluation of the phosphorus source component in the phosphorus index for pastures. J. Environ. Qual. 33:2192-2200.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
78
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
Dou, Z., J.D. Toth, D.T. Galligan, C.F. Ramberg, Jr., and J.D. Ferguson. 2000. Laboratory procedures for characterizing manure phosphorus. J. Environ. Qual. 29:508–514. Dou, Z., K.F. Knowlton, R.A. Kohn, Z. Wu, L.D. Satter, G. Zhang, J.D. Toth, and J.D. Ferguson. 2002. Phosphorus characteristics of dairy feces affected by diets. J. Environ. Qual. 31:2058–2065. Fraisse, C.W. and K.L. Campbell. 1997. FHANTM: Field hydrologic and nutrient transport model: version 2.0. Agriculture Biology Engineering Department, Institute of Food and Agriculture Science, University of Florida, Gainesville. Jones, C.A., C.V. Cole, A.N. Sharpley, and J.R. Williams. 1984. A simplified soil and plant phosphorus model. I. Documentation. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 48:800–805. Kleinman, P.J.A. and A.N. Sharpley. 2003. Effect of broadcast manure on runoff phosphorus concentrations over successive rainfall events. J. Environ. Qual. 32:1072–1081. Kleinman, P.J.A., A.N. Sharpley, B.G. Moyer, and G.F. Elwinger. 2002a. Effect of mineral and manure phosphorus sources on runoff phosphorus. J. Environ. Qual. 31:2026–2033. Kleinman, P.J.A, A.N. Sharpley, A.M. Wolf, D.B. Beegle, and P.A. Moore, Jr. 2002b. Measuring water-extractable phosphorus in manure as an indicator of phosphorus in runoff. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 66:2009–2015. McGrath, J.M., J.T. Sims, R.O. Maguire, W.W. Saylor, C.R. Angel, and B.L. Turner. 2005. Broiler litter diet modification and litter storage: impacts on phosphorus in litters, soils, and runoff. J. Environ. Qual. 34:1896–1909. Murphy, J. and J.P. Riley. 1962. A modified single solution method for the determination of phosphate in natural waters. Anal. Chim. Acta 27:31–36. Myers, R.G., A.N. Sharpley, S.J. Thien, and G.M. Pierzynski. 2005. Ion-sink phosphorus extraction methods applied on 24 soils from the continental USA. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 69:511–521. Nürnberg, G. and R.H. Peters. 1984. Biological availability of soluble reactive phosphorus in anoxic and oxic freshwaters. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 41:757–765. Pierson, S.T., M.L. Cabrera, G.K. Evanylo, P.D. Shroeder, D.E. Radcliffe, H.A. Kuykendall, V.W. Benson, J.R. Williams, C.S. Hoveland, and M.A. McCann. 2001. Phosphorus losses from grasslands fertilized with broiler litter: EPIC simulations. J. Environ. Qual. 30:1790–1795. Sharpley, A.N. 1983. Effect of soil properties on the kinetics of phosphorus desorption. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 47:462–467. Sharpley, A.N. 1985a. Depth of surface soil-runoff interaction as affected by rainfall, soil slope, and management. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 49:1010–1015. Sharpley, A.N. 1985b. The selective erosion of plant nutrients in runoff. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 49:1527–1534. Sharpley, A.N., L.R. Ahuja, M. Yamamoto, and R.G. Menzel. 1981a. The kinetics of phosphorus desorption from soil. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 45:493–496. Sharpley, A.N., L.R. Ahuja, M. Yamamoto, and R.G. Menzel. 1981b. The release of soil phosphorus in runoff in relation to the kinetics of desorption. J. Environ. Qual. 10:386–391. Sharpley, A.N., C.A. Jones, C. Gray, and C.V. Cole. 1984. A simplified soil and plant phosphorus model. II: prediction of labile, organic, and sorbed phosphorus. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 48:805–809. Sharpley, A.N. and S.J. Smith. 1992. Prediction of bioavailable phosphorus loss in agricultural runoff. J. Environ. Qual. 21:32–37. Tasistro, A., M.L. Cabrera, and D.E. Kissel. 2004. Water soluble phosphorus released by poultry litter: effect of extraction pH and time after application. Nutr. Cycl. Agroecosys. 68:223–234.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Phosphorus in Runoff: Basic Approaches
79
Vadas, P.A. and J.T. Sims. 2002. Predicting phosphorus desorption from mid-Atlantic coastal plain soils. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 66:623–631. Vadas., P.A., J.T. Sims, A.B. Leytem, and C.J. Penn. 2002. Modifying FHANTM 2.0 to estimate phosphorus concentrations in runoff from mid-Atlantic coastal plain soils. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 66:1974–1980. Vadas, P.A., P.J.A. Kleinman, and A.N. Sharpley. 2004. A simple method to predict dissolved phosphorus in runoff from surface-applied manures. J. Environ. Qual. 33:749–756. Vadas, P.A., P.J.A. Kleinman, A.N. Sharpley, and B.L. Turner. 2005a. Relating soil phosphorus to dissolved phosphorus in runoff: a single extraction coefficient for water quality modeling. J. Environ. Qual. 34:572–580. Vadas, P.A., B.E. Haggard, and W.J. Gburek. 2005b. Predicting dissolved phosphorus in runoff from manured field plots. J. Environ. Qual. 34:1347–1353. Vadas, P.A. 2006. A new model for surface application of animal manure and manure phosphorus transformation and loss in runoff. (Personal communication). Vadas, P.A., T. Krogstad, and A.N. Sharpley. 2006. Modeling phosphorus transfer between labile and nonlabile P pools: updating the EPIC model. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. (In press).
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
4
Basic Approaches to Modeling Phosphorus Leaching Nathan O. Nelson Kansas State University, Manhattan, KS
John E. Parsons* North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC
CONTENTS 4.1 Introduction.....................................................................................................81 4.2 Functional Definition of P Leaching ..............................................................83 4.3 Model Components Affecting P Leaching.....................................................83 4.3.1 Hydrology............................................................................................83 4.3.1.1 Vertical Flow ........................................................................83 4.3.1.2 Nonequilibrium and Preferential Flow ................................86 4.3.1.3 Lateral Flow .........................................................................89 4.3.2 Phosphorus Chemistry ........................................................................90 4.3.2.1 Inorganic P Leaching ...........................................................90 4.3.2.2 Dissolved Organic P Leaching ............................................96 4.3.2.3 Preferential and Subsurface Particulate P Transport...........96 4.4 Model Evaluation............................................................................................97 4.5 Conclusions.....................................................................................................98 References................................................................................................................99
4.1 INTRODUCTION Leaching is an active process in the phosphorus (P) cycle, thereby affecting P transport in agroecosystems. Although subsurface P transport is not the predominant loss pathway in most regions (Hansen et al. 2002; Lemunyon and Daniel 2002; Osborne and Kovacic 1993; Peterjohn and Corell 1984), there is increasing evidence of vertical P movement in soils when P applications exceed crop P removal over extended periods of time. For example, many studies have documented elevated subsoil P concentrations * Deceased
81
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
82
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
resulting from repeated waste applications (King et al. 1990; Maguire et al. 2000; Mozaffari and Sims 1994; Nelson et al. 2005; Novak et al. 2002; Sharpley et al. 1984a). Leaching processes affect P distribution within the soil, removing P from surface horizons where it would be available for crop uptake or loss through runoff and erosion. In soils with low P sorption capacities, leaching can potentially remove more P from the root zone than crop uptake (Nelson et al. 2005). P can also be lost to surface waters through leaching and subsurface transport in soils where P loading exceeds crop P removal (resulting in a high soil test P), P sorption capacities are low (sandy or organic soils), and subsurface transport is expedited by artificial drainage systems. Sims et al. (1998) reviewed past research and found evidence indicating that subsurface P losses from tile-drained lands can be an environmentally significant component of the total P exported from agricultural watersheds, where 4 of 21 studies had tile drainage P concentrations > 0.3 mg L−1. Culley and Bolton (1983) estimated that tile drainage contributed 25% of total P and 50% of dissolved P exported from a 51-km2 watershed in Ontario, Canada. An adequate description of P leaching is an important component of modeling the fate and transport of P in the environment. As with other model processes, an adequate model for describing P leaching is dependent on the characteristics of the agroecosystem being modeled and the modeling objectives. Because most soils have strong P sorption characteristics, P has historically been considered immobile within soils; therefore, most watershed- and field-scale models tend to underestimate vertical and subsurface P transport. However, accurately representing P leaching processes is important in long-term simulations with excessive P applications (e.g., with animal waste). In these cases, underestimation of P leaching can result in unrealistically high estimates of P accumulation in surface soils, potentially overestimating P loss through erosion and overland flow (Knisel 1993; Stone et al. 2001). It is important to consider subsurface pathways in artificially drained soils because subsurface drainage can be an order of magnitude greater than surface runoff; therefore, relatively low P concentrations in subsurface drainage can produce greater P losses than from surface runoff (Deal et al. 1986). Excessive accumulation of P in soils buffers soil solution P concentrations to changes in management. Therefore, P leaching losses from artificially drained soils can continue for many years after initial detection of increased P concentrations in drainage waters, despite changes in management practices (Breeuwsma and Silva 1992; Schoumans and Groenendijk 2000). Unremediable circumstances could eventually result if traditional models, which focus on P loss through surface pathways and underestimate P leaching losses, are used to decide issues with long-term consequences, such as siting of confined animal feeding operations. Computer models, with accurate P leaching subroutines, are therefore a primary tool in the prevention of P leaching losses from tile-drained soils and the protection of ecologically sensitive water bodies in regions dominated by sandy soils, such as the eastern U.S. coastal plain. The objective of this chapter is to develop a framework for evaluating a model with respect to its capabilities to describe, in part or entirety, P transport from field to surface waters through leaching processes and subsurface flow pathways.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Basic Approaches to Modeling Phosphorus Leaching
83
4.2 FUNCTIONAL DEFINITION OF P LEACHING A complete description of P leaching processes requires continuity and conservation of mass to describe P movement from the soil surface through the profile with eventual delivery to surface water — through tile drainage or interflow — or deep ground water. Because this is a complex process, mostly occurring on a time scale of decades or more, P leaching is often either ignored or simplified as one of the following partial descriptions: Vertical movement of P past a given depth, such as the bottom of a specific soil layer: surface horizon, root zone, or soil pedon Delivery of P to surface water through subsurface flow by means of a user-supplied or management-dependent P concentration in interflow and tile drainage Furthermore, a single model may use both partial descriptions but may lack the continuity and conservation of mass linking them in an actual setting.
4.3 MODEL COMPONENTS AFFECTING P LEACHING Incorporating complete or partial descriptions of P leaching into a simulation model requires coupling models that describe system hydrology and P transformations (Figure 4.1). Although a watershed model may handle hydrology separately from P transformations, the methods used to describe the hydrology will affect the output from the P reaction/transport submodel. For example, simplifications in model hydrology may preclude more complex descriptions of P transformation and transport since some of the water fluxes and content distributions may not be simulated.
4.3.1 HYDROLOGY A wide range of techniques is used for modeling water movement through soils with a correspondingly wide range of complexities. This chapter is not meant to be a complete review of these techniques but rather a brief review of the techniques as they affect the model capabilities to simulate P leaching, with a focus on methods employed by models described in subsequent chapters. Modeling the complete leaching process requires, at minimum, a hydrological model with two-dimensional water flow. In the unsaturated soil, lateral water fluxes can be assumed to be negligible and vertical flow dominates; however, lateral flow in the saturated portion of the soil is necessary for describing flow to surface waters. 4.3.1.1 Vertical Flow The one-dimensional Richards equation offers the most complete description of vertical water movement in soils and is C (h)
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
∂h ∂ ∂h ∂K (h) = K (h) − ∂z ∂t ∂z ∂z
(4.1)
84
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
adsorption
Adsorbed P desorption precipitation
Mineral P Soil Surface Vertical Flow Interflow
dissolution
Solution P 2-
HPO4 H2PO4 Organic P
Soil P Transformations immobilization
Organic P mineralization
Soil Surface
Vertical Flow
Stream
Tile Drainage Base Flow
Drain Tile
FIGURE 4.1 General soil P transformations and subsurface transport pathways in crosssectional views of naturally drained and artificially drained landscapes.
where h is the matric potential (cm), K(h) is the unsaturated hydraulic conductivity (cm h−1) expressed as a function of matric potential, z is the depth (cm), t is time (h), and C(h) is the capacitance function or d/dh (cm3 cm−3 cm−1) where θ is the volumetric water content (cm3 cm−3). This is referred to as the h-based formulation and is more easily applied in situations with the presence of a water table. The Richards equation is frequently used for modeling water flow in laboratory column leaching studies (Porro et al. 1993), occasionally used in field-scale water quality models such as SWATRE and Root Zone Water Quality Model (RZWQM) (Jacques et al. 2002; Johnsen et al. 1995) but is seldom used for watershed-scale models. The Richards equation allows simulation of unsaturated water flow and typically uses relatively small temporal and spatial increments, thus facilitating the use of the advection-dispersion equation (ADE), also known as the advectiondispersion-reactive equation or convection-dispersion equation (Leij and van Genuchten 2002; Parsons 1999; Wierenga 1995). Drawbacks to the Richards equation are that (1) boundary conditions can be difficult to define especially for continuous models; (2) it requires computationally intensive numerical solutions that tend to be susceptible to numerical instabilities and may not converge to a solution; and (3) generally it requires labor-intensive inputs to describe the relationship among soil moisture tension, water content, and hydraulic conductivity. These drawbacks, combined with the high spatial variability of soil properties, prohibit routine implementation of the Richards equation at field and watershed scales. However, inputs may be adequately estimated from soil texture alone (Starks et al. 2003), potentially removing the requirement for intensive soil characterization. A much simpler approach for estimating percolation uses a simplified field capacity-water balance (FCWB) method — also referred to as the cascade method, or plate theory method — in which soil water in excess of a measured or userdefined field capacity flows to the underlying soil horizon (Diekkruger et al. 1995;
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Basic Approaches to Modeling Phosphorus Leaching
85
Wegehenkel 2000). The general equation for determining percolation by the field capacity method is Perc = (SWC – FC) * β if SWC > FC, Perc = 0
if SWC ≤ FC,
(4.2) (4.3)
where Perc is the percolation (cm), SWC is the soil water content of the layer (cm), FC is the field capacity of the layer (cm), and β is a coefficient that determines the fraction of soil water excess (SWC – FC) that can drain during a time step, usually a function of saturated hydraulic conductivity. The simplifications of the FCWB method greatly reduce the computational complexity and the required inputs compared to the Richards equation. Although the FCWB method requires fewer soil parameters than the Richards equation, field capacity is a somewhat arbitrarily defined soil property. Field capacity is generally defined as the content of water, on a mass or volume basis, remaining in a soil two or three days after having been wetted with water and after free drainage is negligible (Soil Science Society of America 1997). Field capacity is often determined as the water content at –33 kPa soil water potential, but soil water potential at field capacity can be as high as – 4 kPa (Wierenga 1995). Furthermore, field capacity is affected by soil structure, texture, layering, and antecedent moisture (Hillel 1982). Field capacity can also change throughout the year (Romano and Santini 2002) and should not be viewed as an intrinsic soil property (de Jong and Bootsma 1996). The FCWB method only considers water flow at water contents in excess of field capacity, neglecting any water redistribution at lower water contents. This results in a few relatively large percolation events rather than continuous drainage predicted with models employing the Richards equation (Diekkruger et al. 1995). Using a FCWB method will generally preclude the use of the advection-dispersion equation because large spatial and temporal increments are usually used with FCWB methods. Large spatial and temporal increments can result in numerical instability in solutions to the advection-dispersion equation, especially for longer simulations and when solutes undergo sorption and precipitation reactions (Leij and van Genuchten 2002). Although models employing the FCWB method may not be able to account for the effects of diffusion and dispersion on P transport, multiple soil layers (e.g., soil horizons) tend to reduce the overall effect of hydrodynamic dispersion on solute transport (Porro et al. 1993), and the coefficient of hydrodynamic dispersion is not a sensitive parameter in P leaching models (Notodarmojo et al. 1991). In situations with shallow water tables, such as those requiring artificial drainage, the field-capacity concept does not apply. The free vertical drainage assumption for determining the field capacity is violated since the vertical drainage rate is confined by the presence of a water table. As the unsaturated soil reaches hydraulic equilibrium, the water contents tend to be determined by the water table and not field capacity. Modeling approaches such as those in DRAINMOD (Skaggs 1978) employ a drained-to-equilibrium profile and allow the water table fluctuations to govern vertical water fluxes in the unsaturated zone.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
86
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
Several studies have compared results from hydrology models employing the onedimensional Richards equation to those using various FCWB methods (de Jong and Bootsma 1996; Diekkruger et al. 1995; Eitzinger et al. 2004; Wegehenkel 2000). The use of small spatial increments in FCWB models increases the accuracy of predictions. Simplified FCWB methods, using small spatial increments (< 10 cm), are capable of predicting average soil water contents and long-term percolation amounts with accuracy similar to models using the one-dimensional Richards equation. However, models employing the FCWB method tend to use large spatial increments (> 10 cm); therefore, they tend to overpredict percolation volumes and predict percolation in only a few relatively large events. Despite its drawbacks, the FCWB method is a very common method of predicting percolation in field- and watershed-scale models (Table 4.1). 4.3.1.2 Nonequilibrium and Preferential Flow The terms nonequilibrium flow and preferential flow are used to describe the rapid transport of water and solutes through certain soil channels (e.g., cracks, root channels, macropores) while bypassing a fraction of the soil matrix (Hendricks and Flury 2001). Because preferential flow transports solutes through large pores, bypassing the soil matrix, breakthrough of conservative tracers in structured soils occurs sooner than would be expected based on the advection-dispersion equation (Gerke and Kohne 2004). Furthermore, solute transport through preferential flow reduces soil–solute interaction, a particularly important factor when considering adsorbed solutes such as P. Various approaches for modeling preferential flow in soils were reviewed by Simunek et al. (2003) and included single-porosity, dual-porosity, and dual-permeability models. Single-porosity models are the simplest of the three approaches, where the Richards equation is used with one additional parameter to represent nonequilibrium water contents in the soil. The advantage of the single-porosity model is that it only requires one additional parameter; however, the model results are independent of the antecedent moisture content. Dual-porosity models divide the soil into two regions: fractures, which have mobile water; and the soil matrix, which has immobile water. Although the soil matrix will not conduct water in a dualporosity model, it can exchange and retain water. Dual-permeability models divide the soil into two flow regimes: one representing the fractures and the other representing the matrix, both of which conduct water. Simunek et al. (2003) and Hendricks and Flury (2001) provide a comprehensive explanation of the aforementioned models. The major drawback of dual-porosity and dual-permeability models is the large number of parameters needed for their implementation. For example, dual-permeability models may require as many as 16 parameters to describe water flux (Gerke and van Genuchten 1993), compared to six parameters generally required to solve the Richards equation and only three parameters to solve the FCWB model. Dualpermeability models not only require a large number of parameters, but there is also little guidance on how to obtain these parameters (Simunek et al. 2003). Despite the large number of soil parameters required, dual-porosity models have been implemented for water and solute transport at the field scale. Gerke and Kohne (2004) developed a dual-permeability model that described bromide transport in a tiledrained field. Their model showed substantial improvement over model simulations
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Vertical Flow
Model
Preferential Flow
Tile Drainage
AnnAGNPS
FCWB with two soil layersa,b
NI
Hooghoudt equationa
ANSWERS-2000
FCWB single layer profileb,c
NI
GWLF
FCWBe
HSPF
Empirical equationg
SWAT
FCWB with 10 soil layersh,i
EPIC
FCWB with 14 soil layersj
Interflow
Base Flow
Darcy’s equationa
NI
Constant drainage rated
Empirical equationd
NI
NI
NI
Empirical equatione,f
Empirical equationf
NI
NI
Empirical equationg
Empirical equationg
Kinematic storage model based on field capacity concepth
Based on a steady state groundwater recharge equation assuming a linear relationship to changes in water table heighth
Empirical equation based on field capacity conceptj
NI
Bypass- or crack-flow, intended for use with high shrink/swell soils (Vertisols), not intended for use in other soils8
NI
Empirical equation based on field capacity concepth
NI
Basic Approaches to Modeling Phosphorus Leaching
TABLE 4.1 Hydrological Classification of Selected Field- and Watershed-Scale Models
(continued)
87
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
88
TABLE 4.1 (CONTINUED) Hydrological Classification of Selected Field- and Watershed-Scale Models Vertical Flow
Preferential Flow
GLEAMS
FCWB with 12 soil layersk
NI
RZWQM
Green-Ampt infiltration and Richards equation for redistributionm
Model
Dual-porosity model with Richards equation for matrix and gravitational flow in fracturesn
Tile Drainage Hooghoudt equation with GLEAMSWTl Richards equation with source/sink component linked to the Hooghoudt equation m
Interflow
Base Flow
NI
NI
NI
NI
a
R.L. Bingner and F.D. Theurer, 2005, AnnAGNPS technical processes: documentation version 3.2, http://www.ars.usda.gov/Research/docs.htm?docid=5199. D.K. Borah and M. Bera, 2003, Trans. ASAE 46, 1553–1566. c F. Bouraoui, 1994, Ph.D. dissertation, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg. d ANSWERS user’s manual. e D.A. Haith and L.L. Shoemaker, 1987, Water Resour. Bull. 23, 471–478. f K.Y. Lee, T.R. Fisher, and E. Rochell-Newall, 2001, Biogeochem. 56, 311–348. g B.R. Bicknell, J.C. Imhoff, J.L. Kittle, Jr., T.H. Jobes, and A.S. Donigian, Jr., 2001, Hydrological Simulation Program-FORTRAN (HSPF): user’s manual for release 12, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency National Exposure Research Laboratory, Athens, GA, in cooperation with U.S. Geological Survey, Water Resources Division, Reston, VA. h S.L. Neitsch, J.G. Arnold, J.R. Kiniry, J.R. Williams, and K.W. King, 2002a, Soil and water assessment tool theoretical documentation: version 2000, GSWRL Report 0201, BRC Report 02-05, TWRI Report TR-191, College Station, TX. i S.L. Neitsch, J.G. Arnold, J.R. Kiniry, J.R. Williams, and K.W. King, 2002b, Soil and water assessment tool user’s manual version 2000, GSWRL Report 02-02, BRC Report 02-06, TWRI Report TR-192, College Station, TX. j J.R. Williams, 1995, Pp. 909–1000 in Computer Models of Watershed Hydrology, V.J. Singh (Ed.), Highlands Ranch, CO: Water Resources Publications. k W.G. Knisel and J.R. Williams, 1995, Pp. 1069–1114 in Computer Models of Watershed Hydrology, V. J. Singh (Ed.), Highlands Ranch, CO: Water Resources Publications. l M.R. Reyes, R.L. Bengtson, and J.L. Fouss, 1994, Trans. ASAE 37, 1115–1120. m K.E. Johnsen, H.H. Liu, J.H. Dane, L.R. Ahuja, and S.R. Workman, 1995, Trans. ASAE 38, 75–83. n J. Simunek, N.J. Jarvis, M.Th. van Genuchten, and A. Gardenas, 2003, J. Hydrol. 272, 14–35. b
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
Note: AnnAGNPS = Annualized Agricultural Non-Point Source; ANSWERS = Areal Non-Point Source Watershed Environment Response Simulation; BRC = Blackland Research Center; EPIC = Erosion Productivity Impact Calculator; FCWB = field capacity-water balance; GLEAMS = Groundwater Loading Effects of Agricultural Management Systems; WT = Water Table; GSWRL = Grassland, Soil and Water Research Laboratory; GWLF = Generalized Watershed Loading Functions; HSPF = Hydrologic Simulation ProgramFortran; NI = Not Included; RZWQM = Root Zone Water Quality Model; SWAT = Soil and Water Assessment Tool; TWRI = Texas Water Resources Institute.
Basic Approaches to Modeling Phosphorus Leaching
89
employing the equilibrium-based Richards equation. RZWQM, a field-scale model employing a dual-porosity hydrologic model (Table 4.1), was used to model the transport of metribuzin, a pesticide that adsorbs to soil, through structured soils (Malone et al. 2004). Predicted metribuzin losses from RZWQM were in close agreement with observed values, whereas Groundwater Loading Effects of Agricultural Management Systems (GLEAMS) simulations produced a ten-fold underprediction of metribuzin losses. The MACRO model, employing a dual-porosity hydrologic model, has been used to model preferential P transport through macropores following slurry spreading (McGechan 2002a) and from grazing cattle (McGechan 2003). 4.3.1.3 Lateral Flow Lateral flow within field- and watershed-scale models can generally be categorized as tile drainage, interflow, or base flow (Figure 4.1); however, many models may interchange terminology for these processes. A complete P model would have allowances for P transport by each pathway. Tile drainage refers to interception of shallow groundwater with an artificial drainage system, which then transports the water directly to a surface ditch or canal. Tile drainage systems expedite the flow of shallow ground water to surface water and greatly decrease solution–soil interaction. Hooghoudt’s equation is often used to quantify the amount of drainage flux: q=
8 Kd e m + 4 Km 2 L2
(4.4)
where q is the drainage rate (cm h−1), K is the lateral saturated conductivity (cm h−1), de is the effective depth to the impermeable layer (cm), m is the water table height above the drain at the midpoint between drains (cm), and L is the drain spacing (cm) (van der Ploeg et al. 1999). The depth from the drains to the impermeable layer is often adjusted to account for the convergence of the flow lines near the drains. The adjusted depth, de, corrects the flow for this and depends on the size and spacing of the drains (van der Ploeg et al. 1999). Models described in the following chapters simulate tile drain flow in a variety of ways, including the Richards equation linked with the Hooghoudt equation using a source/sink term, the FCWB linked with the Hooghoudt equation, and empirical methods (Table 4.1). Interflow refers to lateral flow below and near the soil surface (Figure 4.1), usually during periods of saturation resulting from a perched water table. Interflow returns to streams within minutes to hours of rainfall events (Haygarth and Sharpley 2000). Interflow modeling techniques include the kinematic storage model, Darcy’s equation based on the lateral gradient from the source area to the exit to the stream, and empirical methods (Table 4.1). Base flow is background, low-magnitude flow arising from groundwater discharge to the stream. Travel time for base flow is on the order of days to months (Preedy et al. 1999). Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) determines base flow with a steady-state lateral groundwater recharge equation using a form of Hooghoudt’s equation (Neitsch et al. 2002b), whereas Hydrologic Simulation Program-Fortran
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
90
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
(HSPF) and Generalized Watershed Loading Functions (GWLF) determine base flow with empirical equations (Bicknell et al. 2001; Lee et al. 2001).
4.3.2 PHOSPHORUS CHEMISTRY Subsurface P transport is the product of water flux and P concentration; therefore, modeling the leaching process requires a description of P transformations within the soil combined with one of the aforementioned hydrologic models (Figure 4.1). Total P concentration in soil water includes inorganic and organic forms of dissolved and particulate P (Heathwaite and Dils 2000; Toor et al. 2003; Turner and Haygarth 2000). Because of the complexities of the organic P cycle and vertical particulate P transport, many models only consider dissolved inorganic P in the leaching process. 4.3.2.1 Inorganic P Leaching Inorganic P reacts with a variety of solutes and mineral surfaces in the soil system. Phosphorus is generally thought to precipitate as calcium (Ca) phosphates in alkaline to neutral soils or aluminum (Al) and iron (Fe) phosphates in more acidic soils but can also precipitate as magnesium (Mg) or manganese (Mn) phosphates depending on soil solution characteristics. Phosphorus is also strongly adsorbed to mineral surfaces. Phosphate adsorption can be simplified into two processes: (1) a fast, reversible reaction of P adsorption to surface sites; and (2) a slow, more irreversible reaction of P diffusion followed by precipitation (van der Zee and van Riemsdijk 1988). The combination of adsorption or desorption and precipitation or dissolution reactions control inorganic P concentrations in soil solution. Sorption and precipitation reactions are affected by organic and inorganic solutes and solution pH; therefore, complete descriptions of the transformations require modeling the dynamics of solution pH and chemical speciation of the solution. Grant and Heaney (1997) modeled the P leaching process for one-dimensional flow in small soil columns with the advection-dispersion equation using a ligand exchange model to represent adsorption or desorption reactions and a comprehensive solution speciation model for determining precipitation or dissolution reactions. Advantages of this approach are that all model inputs are determined independently of the model and model parameters are not soil dependent. However, the model required extensive information on soil chemical composition and supercomputer facilities to iteratively solve numerically intensive algorithms at fine spatial and temporal scales (ranging from 2.5 to 10 mm depth with time steps of 2 to 60 min). Because of these drawbacks, the authors concluded that this approach was not feasible for routine use. The processes of adsorption or desorption and precipitation or dissolution are difficult to separate in macroscale observations and are often collectively described by relating solid-phase (sorbed) P to dissolved P with a variety of nonlinear equations (McGechan 2002b; McGechan and Lewis 2002). Two of the more common equations are the Freundlich and Langmuir equations. The general form of the Freundlich equation is Q = kF Cb
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
(4.5)
Basic Approaches to Modeling Phosphorus Leaching
91
Sorbed P (mg kg-1)
250 200 150 100 Data Langmuir Freundlich
50 0 0.0
5.0
10.0
15.0
-1
Solution P (mg L ) FIGURE 4.2 Freundlich and Langmuir equations fit to P adsorption data for a Norfolk sandy loam A horizon (Fine-loamy, kaolinitic, thermic typic kandiudults). Coefficients for Equations 4.5 and 4.6 are as follows: kF = 104, b = 0.309, Qmax = 194, and kL = 1.45. (N.O. Nelson, 2001, unpublished data.)
where Q is the quantity of P sorbed in mg kg−1, C is the concentration of P in solution in mg L−1, and kF (mg1−b Lb kg−1) and b (unitless) are fitting coefficients. The Freundlich equation produces very good fits to experimental data (Figure 4.2), but the fitting parameters do not correspond with the theoretical models of surface adsorption. An alternate approach is the Langmuir equation: Q = Qmax [kLC/(1 + kLC)]
(4.6)
where Qmax is the maximum amount of P adsorbed to the soil (mg kg−1) assuming monolayer coverage, kL is a constant related to the binding energy of P (L mg−1), and other parameters are as previously defined. The Langmuir equation has the advantage of describing a theoretical adsorption maximum, which can be useful in regulatory arenas, but it does not always provide a good fit to experimental data (Figure 4.2). Freundlich and Langmuir equations have been incorporated into several field-scale models that describe P leaching. For example, Enfield et al. (1981) developed a sitespecific field-scale P leaching model that used the Langmuir equation with a simplified precipitation model. The Agricultural Nutrient Model (ANIMO), a field-scale model developed in the Netherlands, also uses a Langmuir equation to determine solution P concentrations (Groenendijk and Kroes 1999). HSPF has the option of using either a linear kinetic relationship or a Freundlich equation to determine solution P concentration (Table 4.2) but includes a retardation factor to correct for consistent overpredictions of P leaching (Bicknell et al. 2001). However, there are several drawbacks to using the
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
92
TABLE 4.2 Basic Approaches to Modeling Subsurface P Transport and Transformation in Selected Field- and Watershed-Scale Models
Model GWLFa,b
HSPFc
Method of Determining Soil Water P Concentration
Model Parameters and Associated Soil Properties Affecting Soil Water P Concentration
User input User input
Vertical Interflow Base flow
NI User defined User defined
NI User-defined concentration User-defined concentration
Vertical
Dissolved inorganic
Inorganic P is partitioned between solid and solution phases with either a linear or Freundlich equation depending on user settings. A retardation factor reduces solution P mobility.
Adsorption and desorption constants (user input) Freundlich coefficient and exponent (user input) Permanently fixed P (user input) Retardation factor (user input)
Interflow
Dissolved inorganic
Retardation factor (user input)
Base flow
Same as for interflow
Solution P concentration is determined from soil profile. P reactions are not simulated. A retardation factor reduces P mobility. Same as for interflow
Vertical
Dissolved inorganic (only from top 1 cm)
kd (user input) PSP (user input)
Tile drainage Preferential flow Interflow Base flow
NI NI NI Dissolved inorganic
Labile P is partitioned between solid and solution phase with a linear relationship (Equation 4.8) NI NI NI User-defined P concentration
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
NI
Same as for interflow
NI NI NI User input
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
SWATd,e,i
Pathway
P Forms Subject to Transport
Vertical
Dissolved inorganic
Labile P is partitioned between solid and solution phase with a linear relationship (Equation 4.8)
Tile drainage (GLEAMS)
Dissolved inorganic and particulate inorganic with PARTLEh
Labile P is partitioned between solid and solution phase with a linear relationship (Equation 4.8). Surface labile P concentration determines P concentration for particulate P transport
kd (function of % clay) PSP (function of % CaCO3, % clay, base saturation, and pH depending on soil weathering) kd (function of % clay) PSP (function of % CaCO3, % clay, base saturation, and pH depending on soil weathering) Sediment concentration in drain tiles (user input)
Notes: AnnAGNPS, ANSWERS-2000, and RZWQM were not included because the current model versions do not consider P leaching or subsurface P transport. Only pathways included in the model are listed; see Table 4.1 for additional details on pathways. NI = not included; PARTLE = particulate. a
D.A. Haith and L.L. Shoemaker, 1987, Water Resour. Bull. 23, 471–478. K.Y. Lee, T.R. Fisher, and E. Rochell-Newall, 2001, Biogeochem. 56, 311–348. c B.R. Bicknell, J.C. Imhoff, J.L. Kittle, Jr., T.H. Jobes, and A.S. Donigian, Jr., 2001, Hydrological Simulation Program-FORTRAN (HSPF): user’s manual for release 12, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency National Exposure Research Laboratory, Athens, GA, in cooperation with U.S. Geological Survey, Water Resources Division, Reston, VA. d S.L. Neitsch, J.G. Arnold, J.R. Kiniry, J.R. Williams, and K.W. King, 2002a, Soil and Water Assessment Tool theoretical documentation: version 2000, GSWRL Report 02-01, BRC Report 02-05, TWRI Report TR-191, College Station, TX. e S.L. Neitsch, J.G. Arnold, J.R. Kiniry, J.R. Williams, and K.W. King, 2002b, Soil and Water Assessment Tool user’s manual version 2000, GSWRL Report 02- 02, BRC Report 02-06, TWRI Report TR-192, College Station, TX. f W.G. Knisel, 1993, GLEAMS Groundwater Loading Effects of Agricultural Management Systems, version 2.10, Department Publication 5, Biological and Agricultural Engineering Department, University of Georgia Coastal Plain Experiment Station, Tifton. g Jimmy Williams, personal communication, December 22, 2005. h A. Shirmohammadi, B. Ulen, L.F. Bergstrom, and W.G. Knisel, 1998, Trans. ASAE 41, 353–360. i SWAT P subroutines are currently undergoing revision. The revised model will include P leaching throughout the entire soil profile (similar to EPIC) and will include dissolved P transport in tile drainage and interflow. Colleen Green, personal communication, December 21, 2005. b
Basic Approaches to Modeling Phosphorus Leaching
GLEAMSf/ EPICg
93
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
94
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
Freundlich and Langmuir equations in field- and watershed-scale models. First, determination of parameters for Equation 4.5 and 4.6 requires time- and labor-intensive laboratory procedures. Second, because soil chemical and physical properties affect P adsorption, model parameters are soil specific. Since the previously mentioned slow, near irreversible adsorption process occurs simultaneously with the fast adsorption process, the subsequent desorption is incomplete, and desorption curves rarely follow the adsorption curve (McGechan and Lewis 2002); therefore, model parameters for desorption are different than for adsorption. As a result of the aforementioned challenges, field- and watershed-scale models commonly use the simplified P cycle model developed by Jones et al. (1984) and Sharpley et al. (1984b) as the basis for describing P transformations (see Chapter 3). For example, various forms of this simplified model are used by Erosion Productivity Impact Calculator (EPIC) (Williams 1995), GLEAMS (Knisel 1993, Table 2), SWAT (Neitsch et al. 2002b, Table 4.2), Annualized Agricultural Nonpoint Source (AnnAGNPS) (Bingner and Theurer 2005), and Areal Nonpoint Source Watershed Environment Response Simulation 2000 (ANSWERS-2000) (Bouraoui 1994). In this model, soil P is represented in two organic P pools — fresh organic P and stable organic P — and three inorganic P pools — labile P, active P, and stable P. Labile P is the plant-available portion, analogous to anion-exchange extractable P, and it is in fast equilibrium with active P, which is in turn in a slow equilibrium with stable P. This is designed to represent two phase-P adsorption: fast, reversible P adsorption (labile P to active P), and slow, near irreversible adsorption (active P to stable P). At equilibrium, the stable P pool is four times the size of the active P pool (regardless of soil properties), and the size of the labile P pool is proportional to the active P pool according to the following equation: Plabile = Pactive (PAI/(1 – PAI))
(4.7)
where PAI is the phosphorus availability index. The PAI is conceptually defined as the fraction of applied fertilizer that remains labile after a six-month incubation with multiple wetting and drying cycles (Jones et al. 1984). The PAI is a function of soil properties and can be estimated with a series of soil-dependent empirical relationships. Although PAI was originally a function of several soil properties, including the size of the labile P pool (Sharpley et al. 1984b), it is often represented as a constant rather than changing with increasing P additions (Knisel 1993; Neitsch et al. 2002b; Williams 1995). Although the original model proposed by Sharpley et al. (1984b) did not estimate solution phase P, labile P is commonly partitioned between solid phase and solution phase according to kd = Qlabile /C
(4.8)
where Qlabile is the concentration of labile P on the solid phase (mg kg−1), C is the concentration of P in the solution phase (mg L−1), and kd is a partitioning coefficient (L kg−1) that either is a user-defined constant or is estimated as a function of clay content (Knisel 1993; Neitsch et al. 2002b; Williams 1995).
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Basic Approaches to Modeling Phosphorus Leaching
95
Sorbed P (mg kg-1)
400
Data
300
200
Langmuir Isotherm GLEAMS - 15 d GLEAMS - 50 d
100
GLEAMS - equilibrium 0 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
-1
Solution P (mg L )
FIGURE 4.3 Relationship between solution and sorbed P concentrations for a Norfolk sandy loam A horizon as predicted with GLEAMS P subroutines at 15 and 50 days following P application and the predicted equilibrium P concentration compared to Langmuir adsorption isotherm and adsorption data from Figure 4.2.
By simplifying the P cycle and by using empirical relationships, inorganic P transformations can be modeled with inputs based on readily available soil characteristics (i.e., total P, soil test P, soil texture, and organic matter content). However, these simplifications contain noteworthy drawbacks. The relationship between C and Qlabile is linear with slope of 1/kd (Equation 4.8). Furthermore, the relationship between labile P and active P is linear (Equation 4.7), as is the relationship between the active and stable P pools. The end result of this combination of equations is a linear relationship between adsorbed P and solution P concentration, as opposed to the nonlinear relationship typical of P adsorption isotherms (Figure 4.3). Although this relationship may be suitable at low soil P concentrations, it can potentially underpredict the solution P concentrations at higher soil P concentrations, thereby underpredicting P leaching. Because of this drawback, Knisel (1993) cautioned against using the GLEAMS model for simulations involving excess P applications. Furthermore, Stone et al. (2001) observed inaccurate predictions of soil P accumulation arising from these simplifications. This is an extremely important point to consider because this modeling approach will produce the greatest errors in scenarios where accurate prediction of P losses is of greatest interest and concern — that is, long-term applications of animal waste or biosolids. Further simplifying the prediction of subsurface P transport, models based on export coefficients determine P concentration in tile drainage, lateral flow, or base flow as a function of land-use characteristics (Table 4.2). Although this approach is simple, the results are highly dependent on the accuracy of the input data and tend not to extrapolate well to other sites. Some process-based models use this method
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
96
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
to simulate P loading to streams from base flow or tile flow (Neitsch et al. 2002a); however, this may lack continuity with modeling routines depicting P leaching in the soil profile. Recent interest in determining P leaching losses may lead to alternative methods for modeling P leaching. Simplified forms of the adsorption relationships have been made with relationships between quantity and intensity (Q/I), which relate a quantity of adsorbed P (e.g, soil test P concentration) to its intensity (e.g, concentration in solution) (Beauchemin et al. 1996; Koopmans et al. 2002). Several studies have found good linear correlations for Q/I relationships for different soil types (Andraski and Bundy 2003; Pautler and Sims 2000; Sharpley 1995). However, other authors have found split-line graphs more appropriate, which describe the Q/I relationship with two straight lines with significantly different slopes meeting at a change point (Heckrath et al. 1995; Hesketh and Brookes 2000; Koopmans et al. 2002). Q/I relationships based on soil test P can vary significantly between soils as a result of different sorption properties (Andraski and Bundy 2003). To correct for soil differences, Q/I relationships can be normalized based on soil properties that affect adsorption, such as extractable Fe and Al (Maguire and Sims 2002; Nair et al. 2004; Nelson et al. 2005). Q/I relationships utilize more easily accessible soil properties as compared to the standard adsorption isotherm equations, which may make them more adaptable to large-scale models employing limited data. For example, a Q/I relationship is used in the North Carolina Phosphorus Loss Assessment Tool to determine P concentrations in tile drain flow (Osmond et al. 2003). Other studies have found methods of estimating Langmuir adsorption parameters from simple soil extractions (Koopmans et al. 2002; van der Zee et al. 1988), which may allow for increased use of the Langmuir equation in field- and watershed-scale models. 4.3.2.2 Dissolved Organic P Leaching Although dissolved organic P can represent up to 88% of the total P in leachate (Chardon et al. 1997; Toor et al. 2003), relatively few field- and watershed-scale models consider organic P leaching. The ANIMO model allows dissolved organic P from animal waste applications to leach based on a linear adsorption function (Groenendijk and Kroes 1999), but no account is taken for dissolved organic P from other sources. More complex models have been developed but have not been incorporated into commonly available field- and watershed-scale models (Qualls 2000). 4.3.2.3 Preferential and Subsurface Particulate P Transport Preferential flow can transport dissolved or particulate P from the soil surface vertically through macropores, thereby greatly reducing P interaction with the soil matrix. Preferential P transport through macropores has been identified as a primary transport mechanism in well-structured soils (Akhtar et al. 2003; Kleinman et al. 2005). Preferential P transport has also been used to explain correlations between P spikes in drain water and manure applications (van Es et al. 2004) and correlations between surface soil P concentrations and P concentrations in underlying tile drain water (Heckrath et al. 1995). Vertical movement of particulate and colloidal P
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Basic Approaches to Modeling Phosphorus Leaching
97
through preferential flow pathways can result in significant contributions to P leaching. For example, particulate P transport in macropore water and tile drain water can represent from 20 to over 70% of total P transported (Heathwaite and Dils 2000; Turner and Haygarth 2000). Modeling these processes requires separation of macropore flow from matrix flow, determination of particle detachment, and determination of particle filtering (Jarvis et al. 1999). Furthermore, soil properties of the macropore walls may be very different from the bulk soil matrix due to clay and organic matter coatings. Therefore, accurately coupling the already complex dual-porosity solute transport models poses a very large challenge (Simunek et al. 2003). Due to these complexities, preferential and vertical particulate P transport is generally not included in field- and watershedscale models; however, some attempts have been made. Shirmohammadi et al. (1998) developed a simplified model that determined particulate P leaching with average annual drain-tile sediment concentrations (user input) and simulated drainage and soil P concentrations from GLEAMS. The MACRO model (Jarvis 1994; Larsson and Jarvis 1999) has been used on a few occasions to model preferential P transport (McGechan 2002a, 2003). McGechan et al. (2002) also found reasonable agreement between measured and modeled particulate P losses using the MACRO model.
4.4 MODEL EVALUATION As previously stated, the characteristics of an adequate model for P leaching are dependent on the characteristics of the agroecosystem being modeled and the modeling objectives. A detailed description of vertical P leaching, including the nonlinear P adsorption isotherm, is important for long-term simulations when P applications exceed crop removal — as with many animal-waste applications. Special attention should be paid to model descriptions of P leaching in soils with low P sorption capacities, such as sandy soils with low iron-oxide concentrations. Accurate representation of vertical P leaching in these scenarios will help avoid unrealistic predictions of P accumulation in the surface horizon, which would lead to equally unrealistic predictions of excessive P transport in surface runoff and with sediment. Continuity between vertical and horizontal P transport is particularly important when modeling systems with high soil P concentrations and artificial drainage systems. Furthermore, it would be particularly important to use a model describing preferential P leaching when simulating P transport in well-structured soils with artificial drainage systems, regardless of the soils’ P sorption capacities. Accurate representation of vertical and horizontal P transport in these situations will improve predictions of subsurface P losses and P export from these potentially high-risk watersheds. Continuity between vertical P leaching and P transport in interflow and base flow will only be important in specific situations where soil, agronomic, and hydrologic evaluations indicate that these will be relatively significant P loss pathways. Underestimation of P leaching will most likely not be a problem where P leaching is not expected, such as typical agricultural systems where P applications do not exceed agronomic recommendations. Furthermore, overall effects of P leaching will generally have a negligible impact on soil P distribution for short-term
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
98
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
simulations (< 3 to 5 years, depending on soil and management characteristics), regardless of P applications. Model evaluation with respect to P leaching begins by identifying the P transport pathways simulated and the corresponding modeling techniques (Table 4.1). The forms of P — dissolved and particulate, inorganic and organic — transported within each pathway must also be identified. The following characteristics should be identified for each P form and transport pathway: • • •
Method used for determining P concentrations Necessary model parameters affecting soil solution P concentration Method of determining model parameters
This initial evaluation process was completed for selected models as shown in Table 4.1 and Table 4.2. Further site-specific model evaluation must include fieldscale validation. The degree of validation required must be determined by the model user with due attention to site characteristics and modeling objectives. At a minimum, the predicted soil P distribution should be verified by comparison with measured soil P concentrations in similarly managed soils, especially when simulating long-term waste applications. More detailed model validation should be performed when simulating P losses from artificially drained agricultural systems, such as comparison of predicted and observed P concentrations in subsurface drainage water. More extensive model validation would include comparison of predicted and observed P fractions in soils and water, such as sediment-bound P, particulate and organic P, and dissolved P.
4.5 CONCLUSIONS Model evaluation with respect to phosphorus leaching should consider the hydrologic pathways simulated by the model and the P transformations simulated within each of the identified pathways, as illustrated in Table 4.1 and Table 4.2, for selected fieldand watershed-scale models. The majority of these models use a simplified fieldcapacity water-balance approach for simulating vertical water flux and various other approaches for tile-drainage, interflow, and base-flow simulation. Only four of the evaluated models simulated P leaching processes, none of which contained complete continuity and conservation of mass in describing P transformations and transport from the soil surface to surface water via tile drainage, interflow, and base flow. This further emphasizes the importance of model evaluation with respect to P leaching, especially for long-term simulations involving excess P applications. Land-management decisions, particularly those in watersheds with sandy soils or artificially drained soils, that are based on predictions from models with inaccurate representations of P leaching could result in future problems of unremediable long-term P leaching. A review of the literature on vadose zone modeling reveals a disconnect between the sophisticated laboratory-scale models reported in the literature and the simplified model techniques present in the widely available watershed-scale models. This disconnect arises from a few factors. First, there is great difficulty in scaling up the column or detailed soil profile models to watershed scales. Second,
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Basic Approaches to Modeling Phosphorus Leaching
99
many watershed-scale models are a conglomeration of previously developed field- and profile-scale models. Although great progress has been made in improving computer interfaces, data input, and watershed characterization used in these models, very little effort as of yet has been focused on updating the nutrient models to correspond with advances in scientific understanding and data availability, changes in typical agricultural management practices, and greater demands of modeling objectives. Therefore, it is the model user’s responsibility to determine model suitability with respect to their modeling objectives and the characteristics of the agroecosystem of interest.
REFERENCES Akhtar, M.S., B.K. Richards, P.A. Medrano, M. deGroot, and T.S. Steenhuis. 2003. Dissolved phosphorus from undisturbed soil cores: related to adsorption strength, flow rate, or soil structure? Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 67:458–470. Andraski, T.W. and L.G. Bundy. 2003. Relationships between phosphorus levels in soil and in runoff from corn production systems. J. Environ. Qual. 32:310–316. ANSWERS user’s manual. Available with software download at http://dillaha. bse.vt.edu/answers/. Beauchemin, S., R.R. Simard, and D. Cluis. 1996. Phosphorus sorption–desorption kinetics of soil under contrasting land uses. J. Environ. Qual. 25:1317–1325. Bicknell, B.R., J.C. Imhoff, J.L. Kittle, Jr., T.H. Jobes, and A.S. Donigian, Jr. 2001. Hydrological Simulation Program-FORTRAN (HSPF): user’s manual for release 12. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency National Exposure Research Laboratory, Athens, GA, in cooperation with U.S. Geological Survey, Water Resources Division, Reston, VA. Bingner, R.L. and F.D. Theurer. 2005. AnnAGNPS technical processes: documentation version 3.2. Available at http://www.ars.usda.gov/Research/docs.htm?docid=5199. Borah, D.K. and M. Bera. 2003. Watershed-scale hydrologic and nonpoint-source pollution models: review of mathematical bases. Trans. ASAE 46:1553–1566. Bouraoui, F. 1994. Development of a continuous, physically-based, distributed parameter, nonpoint source model. Ph.D. dissertation Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, VA. Available with software download at http://dillaha.bse.vt.edu/ answers/. Breeuwsma, A. and S. Silva. 1992. Phosphorus fertilization and environmental effects in the Netherlands and the Po region (Italy). Report 57, Dienst Landbouwkundig Onderzoek. The Winard Staring Centre, Wageningen, the Netherlands. Chardon, W.J., O. Oenema, P. D. Castilho, R. Vriesema, J. Japenga, and D. Blaauw. 1997. Organic phosphorus in solutions and leachates from soils treated with animal slurries. J. Environ. Qual. 26:372–378. Culley, J.L.B. and E.F. Bolton. 1983. Suspended solids and phosphorus loads from a clay soil. II: watershed studies. J. Environ. Qual. 12:498–503. de Jong, R. and A. Bootsma. 1996. Review of recent developments in soil water simulation models. Can. J. Soil Sci. 76:263–273. Deal, S.C., J.W. Gilliam, R.W. Skaggs, and K.D. Konyha. 1986. Prediction of nitrogen and phosphorus losses as related to agricultural drainage system design. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 18:37–51. Diekkruger, B., D. Sondgerath, K.C. Dersebaum, and C.W. McVoy. 1995. Validity of agroecosystem models: a comparison of results of different models applied to the same data set. Ecol. Model. 81:3–29.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
100
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
Eitzinger, J., M. Trnka, J. Hosch, Z. Zalud, and M. Dbrovsky. 2004. Comparison of CERES, WOFOST, and SWAP models in simulating soil water content during growing season under different soil conditions. Ecol. Model. 171:223–246. Enfield, C.G., T. Phan, and D.M. Walters. 1981. Kinetic model for phosphate transport and transformation in calcareous soils. II: laboratory and field transport. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 45:1064–1070. Gerke, H.H. and J.M. Kohne. 2004. Dual-permeability modeling of preferential bromide leaching from a tile-drained glacial till agricultural field. J. Hydrol. 289:239–257. Gerke, H.H. and M.T. van Genuchten. 1993. A dual-porosity model for simulating the preferential movement of water and solutes in structured porous media. Wat. Resour. Res. 29:305–319. Grant, R.F. and D.J. Heaney. 1997. Inorganic phosphorus transformation and transport in soils: mathematical modeling in ecosystems. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 61:752–764. Groenendijk, P. and J.G. Kroes. 1999. Modelling the nitrogen and phosphorus leaching to groundwater and surface water with ANIMO 3.5. Report 144, Winand Staring Centre, Wageningen, the Netherlands. Available at http://www.alterra.wur.nl/NL/Producten/ Modellen/. Haith, D.A. and L.L. Shoemaker. 1987. Generalized watershed loading functions for stream flow nutrients. Water Resour. Bull. 23:471–478. Hansen, N.C., T.C. Daniel, A.N. Sharpley, and J.L. Lemunyon. 2002. The fate and transport of phosphorus in agricultural systems. J. Soil Water Conserv. 57:408–417. Haygarth, P.M. and A.N. Sharpley. 2000. Terminology for phosphorus transfer. J. Environ. Qual. 29:10–15. Heathwaite, A.L. and R.M. Dils. 2000. Characterizing phosphorus loss in surface and subsurface hydrological pathways. Sci. Total Environ. 251–252:523–538. Heckrath, G., P.C. Brookes, P.R. Poulton, and K.W.T. Goulding. 1995. Phosphorus leaching from soils containing different phosphorus concentrations in the Broadbalk experiment. J. Environ. Qual. 24:904–910. Hendricks, J.M.H. and M. Flury. 2001. Uniform and preferential flow, mechanisms in the vadose Zone. Pp. 149–187 in Conceptual Models of Flow and Transport in the Fractured Vadose Zone, National Research Council (Ed.). Washington, D.C.: National Academy Press. Hesketh, N. and P.C. Brookes. 2000. Development of an indicator for risk of phosphorus leaching. J. Environ. Qual. 29:105–110. Hillel, D. 1982. Introduction to Soil Physics. San Diego, CA: Academic Press. Jacques, D., J. Simunek, A. Timmerman, and J. Feyen. 2002. Calibration of Richards and convection-dispersion equations to field-scale water flow and solute transport under rainfall conditions. J. Hydrol. 259:15–31. Jarvis, N.J. 1994. The MACRO model (version 3.1): technical description and sample simulations. Reports and Dissertations 19, Department of Soil Science, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Uppsala, Sweden, p. 51. Jarvis, N.J., K.G. Villholth, and B. Ulen. 1999. Modelling particle mobilization and leaching in macroporous soil. Eur. J. Soil Sci. 50:621–632. Johnsen, K.E., H.H. Liu, J.H. Dane, L.R. Ahuja, and S.R. Workman. 1995. Simulating fluctuating water tables and tile drainage with a modified root zone water quality model and a new model WAFLOWM. Trans. ASAE 38:75–83. Jones, C.A., C.V. Cole, A.N. Sharpley, and J.R. Williams. 1984. A simplified soil and plant phosphorus model. I: documentation. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 48:800–805. King, L.D., J.C. Burns, and P.W. Westerman. 1990. Long-term swine lagoon effluent applications on Coastal Bermuda grass. II: effect of nutrient accumulation in soil. J. Environ. Qual. 19:756–760.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Basic Approaches to Modeling Phosphorus Leaching
101
Kleinman, P.J.A., M.S. Srinivasan, A.N. Sharpley, and W.J. Gburek. 2005. Phosphorus leaching through intact soil columns before and after poultry manure application. Soil Sci. 170:153–166. Knisel, W.G. 1993. GLEAMS Groundwater Loading Effects of Agricultural Management Systems, version 2.10. Department Publication 5, Biological and Agricultural Engineering Department, University of Georgia Coastal Plain Experiment Station, Tifton. Knisel, W.G. and J.R. Williams. 1995. Hydrology components of CREAMS and GLEAMS models. Pp. 1069–1114 in Computer Models of Watershed Hydrology, V.J. Singh (Ed.). Highlands Ranch, CO: Water Resources Publications. Koopmans, G.F., R.W. McDowell, W.J. Chardon, O. Oenema, and J. Dolfing. 2002. Soil phosphorus quantity–intensity relationships to predict increased soil phosphorus loss to overland and subsurface flow. Chemosphere 48:679–687. Larsson, M.H. and N.J. Jarvis. 1999. Evaluation of a dual-porosity model to predict fieldscale solute transport in a macroporous soil. J. Hydrol. 215:153–171. Lee, K.Y., T.R. Fisher, and E. Rochell-Newall. 2001. Modeling the hydrochemistry of the Choptank River basin using GWLF and Arc/Info. 2: model validation and application. Biogeochem. 56:311–348. Leij, F.J. and M.Th. van Genuchten. 2002. Solute transport. Pp. 189–248 in Soil Physics Companion, A.W. Warrick (Ed.). Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press. Lemunyon, J.L. and T.C. Daniel. 2002 Quantifying phosphorus losses from the agricultural system. J. Soil Water Conserv. 57:399–401. Maguire, R.O. and J.T. Sims. 2002. Measuring agronomic and environmental soil phosphorus saturation and predicting phosphorus leaching with Mehlich 3. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 66:2033–2039. Maguire, R.O., J.T. Sims, and F.C. Coale. 2000. Phosphorus solubility in biosolids-amended farm soils in the mid-Atlantic region of the USA. J. Environ. Qual. 29:1225–1233. Malone, R.W., L. Ma, R.D. Wauchope, L.R. Ahuja, K.W. Rojas, Q. Ma, R. Warner, and M. Byers. 2004. Modeling hydrology, metribuzin degradation, and metribuzin transport in macroporous tilled and no-till silt loam soil using RZWQM. Pest Manage. Sci. 60:253–266. McGechan, M.B. 2002a. Effects of timing of slurry spreading on leaching of soluble and particulate inorganic phosphorus explored using the MACRO model. Biosyst. Eng. 83:237–252. McGechan, M.B. 2002b. Sorption of phosphorus by soil, part 2: measurement methods, results and model parameter values. Biosyst. Eng. 82:115–130. McGechan, M.B. 2003. Modelling phosphorus leaching to watercourses from extended autumn grazing by cattle. Grass Forage Sci. 58:151–159. McGechan, M.B. and D.R. Lewis. 2002. Sorption of phosphorus by soil, part 1: principles, equations and models. Biosyst. Eng. 82:1–24. McGechan, M.B., N.J. Jarvis, P.S. Hooda, and A.J.A. Vinten. 2002. Parameterization of the MACRO model to represent leaching of colloidally attached inorganic phosphorus following slurry spreading. Soil Use Manage. 18:61–67. Mozaffari, M. and J.T. Sims. 1994. Phosphorus availability and sorption in an Atlantic coastal plain watershed dominated by animal-based agriculture. Soil Sci. 157:97–107. Nair, V.D., K.M. Portier, D.A. Graetz, and M.L. Walker. 2004. An environmental threshold for degree of phosphorus saturation in sandy soils. J. Environ. Qual. 33:107–113. Neitsch, S.L., J.G. Arnold, J.R. Kiniry, R. Srinivasan, and J.R. Williams. 2002a. Soil and Water Assessment Tool user’s manual version 2000. GSWRL Report 02-02, BRC Report 02-06, TWRI Report TR-192, College Station, TX.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
102
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
Neitsch, S.L., J.G. Arnold, J.R. Kiniry, J.R. Williams, and K.W. King. 2002b. Soil and Water Assessment Tool theoretical documentation: version 2000. GSWRL Report 02-01, BRC Report 02-05, TWRI Report TR-191, College Station, TX. Nelson, N.O. 2001. North Carolina State University, Raleigh. (unpublished data). Nelson, N.O., J.E. Parsons, and R.L. Mikkelsen. 2005. Field-scale evaluation of phosphorus leaching in acid sandy soils receiving long-term swine waste applications. J. Environ. Qual. 34:2024–2035. Notodarmojo, S., G.E. Ho, W.D. Scott, and G.B. Davis. 1991. Modelling phosphorus transport in soils and groundwater with two-consecutive reactions. Water Res. 25:1205–1216. Novak, J.M., P.G. Hunt, K.C. Stone, D.W. Watts, and M.H. Johnson. 2002. Riparian zone impact on phosphorus movement to a coastal plain black water stream. J. Soil Water Conserv. 57:127–133. Osborne, L.L. and D.A. Kovacic. 1993. Riparian vegetated buffer strips in water-quality restoration and stream management. Freshwater Biol. 29: 243–258. Osmond, D.L., D.A. Crouse, S.H. Hodges, A.M. Johnson, and K.J. May. 2003. NCANAT: North Carolina Agricultural Nutrient Assessment Tool, version 1.0. North Carolina State University, Raleigh. Parsons, J.E. 1999. Simulation models for drainage water quality. Pp. 501–535 in Agricultural Drainage, R.W. Skaggs and J. van Schilfgaard (Eds.). Madison, WI: ASA, CSSA, and SSSA. Pautler, M.C. and J.T. Sims. 2000. Relationships between soil test phosphorus, soluble phosphorus and phosphorus saturation in Delaware soils. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 64:765–773. Peterjohn, W.T. and D.L. Correll. 1984. Nutrient dynamics in an agricultural watershed: observations on the role of a riparian forest. Ecology 65:1466–1475. Porro, I., P.J. Wierenga, and R.G. Hills. 1993. Solute transport through large uniform and layered soil columns. Water Resour. Res. 29:2533–2541. Preedy, N., P. Haygarth, R. Matthews, and L. Heathwaite. 1999. Simplified classification of hydrological terminology for phosphorus transfer. Pp. 3–11 in Impact of LandUse Change on Nutrient Loads from Diffuse Sources, L. Heathwaite (Ed.). IAHS Press. 257. Qualls, R.G. 2000. Comparison of the behavior of soluble organic and inorganic nutrients in forest soils. Forest Ecol. Manage. 138:29–50. Reyes, M.R., R.L. Bengtson, and J.L. Fouss. 1994. GLEAMS-WT hydrology submodel modified to include subsurface drainage. Trans. ASAE 37:1115–1120. Romano, N. and A. Santini. 2002. Field. Pp. 721–738 in Methods of Soil Analysis Part 4— Physical Methods, J.H. Dane and G.C. Topp (Eds.). Madison, WI: SSSA Book Series 5. Schoumans, O.F. and P. Groenendijk. 2000. Modelling soil phosphorus levels and phosphorus leaching from agricultural soils in the Netherlands. J. Environ. Qual. 29:111–116. Sharpley, A.N. 1995. Dependence of runoff phosphorus on extractable soil phosphorus. J. Environ. Qual. 24:920–926. Sharpley, A.N., S.J. Smith, B.A. Stewart, and A.C. Mathers. 1984a. Forms of phosphorus in soil receiving cattle feedlot waste. J. Environ. Qual. 13:211–215. Sharpley, A.N., C.A. Jones, C. Gray, and C.V. Cole. 1984b. A simplified soil and plant phosphorus model. II: prediction of labile, organic, and sorbed phosphorus. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 48:805–809. Shirmohammadi, A., B. Ulen, L.F. Bergstrom, and W.G. Knisel. 1998. Simulation of nitrogen and phosphorus leaching in a structured soil using GLEAMS and a new submodel, “PARTLE.” Trans. ASAE 41:353–360. Sims, J.T., R.R. Simard, and B.C. Joern. 1998. Phosphorus loss in agricultural drainage: historical perspective and current research. J. Environ. Qual. 27:277–293.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Basic Approaches to Modeling Phosphorus Leaching
103
Simunek, J., N.J. Jarvis, M.Th. van Genuchten, and A. Gardenas. 2003. Review and comparison of models for describing non-equilibrium and preferential flow and transport in the vadose zone. J. Hydrol. 272:14–35. Skaggs, R.W. 1978. A water management model for shallow water table soils. Technical Report 134, Water Resource Research Institute, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill. Soil Science Society of America. 1997. Glossary of Soil Science Terms. Madison, WI: SSSA. Starks, P.J., G.C. Heathman, L.R. Ahuja, and L. Ma. 2003. Use of limited soil property data and modeling to estimate root zone soil water content. J. Hydrology 272:131–147. Stone, K.C., B.K. Gerwig, R.G. Williams, D.W. Watts, and J.M. Novak. 2001. Using GLEAMS and REMM to estimate nutrient movement from a spray field and through a riparian forest. Trans. ASAE 44:505–512. Toor, G.S., L.M. Condron, H.J. Di., K.C. Cameron, and B.J. Cade-Menun. 2003. Characterization of organic phosphorus in leachate from a grassland soil. Soil Bio. Biochem. 35:1317–1323. Turner, B.L. and P.M. Haygarth. 2000. Phosphorus forms and concentrations in leachate under four grassland soil types. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 64:1090–1099. van der Ploeg, R.R., R. Horton, and D. Kirkham. 1999. Steady flow to drains and wells. Pp. 213–263 in Agricultural Drainage, R.W. Skaggs and J. van Schilfgaarde (Eds.). Madison, WI: ASA, CSSA, and SSSA. van der Zee, S.E.A.T.M., M.M Nederlof, W.H. van Riemsdijk, and F.A.M. de Haan. 1988. Spatial variability of phosphate adsorption parameters. J. Environ. Qual. 17:682–688. van der Zee, S.E.A.T.M. and W.H. van Riemsdijk. 1988. Model for long-term phosphate reaction kinetics in soil. J. Environ. Qual. 17:35–41. van Es, H.M., R.R. Schindelbeck, and W.E. Jokela. 2004. Effect of manure application timing, crop, and soil type on phosphorus leaching. J. Environ. Qual. 33:1070–1080. Wegehenkel, M. 2000. Test of a modeling system for simulating water balances and plant growth using various different complex approaches. Ecol. Model. 129:39–64. Wierenga, P.J. 1995. Water and solute transport and storage. Pp. 41–60 in Handbook of Vadose Zone Characterization and Monitoring, L.G. Wilson, L.G. Everett, and S.J. Cullen (Eds.). Boca Raton, FL: Lewis Publications. Williams, J.R. 1995. The EPIC model. Pp. 909–1000 in Computer Models of Watershed Hydrology, V.J. Singh (Ed.). Highlands Ranch, CO: Water Resources Publications.
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
5
Phosphorus Transport in Streams: Processes and Modeling Considerations Brian E. Haggard University of Arkansas, Fayetteville, AR
Andrew N. Sharpley U.S. Department of Agriculture-Agricultural Research Service, University Park, PA
CONTENTS 5.1 Introduction...................................................................................................105 5.2 Abiotic and Biotic Processes........................................................................106 5.3 Phosphorus Spiraling ....................................................................................109 5.3.1 Determining Phosphorus Spiraling...................................................109 5.3.2 Stream Properties and Phosphorus Spiraling ...................................113 5.4 Algal and Microbial Processes .....................................................................114 5.5 Stream Sediments and Phosphorus ..............................................................115 5.5.1 Sediment Source Effects...................................................................115 5.5.2 Sediment and Equilibrium Phosphorus Concentrations...................117 5.6 Impact of Stream Processes on Eutrophication ...........................................120 5.7 Modeling Phosphorus Transport in Stream Channels..................................122 5.8 Conclusions...................................................................................................124 References..............................................................................................................125
5.1 INTRODUCTION Modeling of phosphorus (P) transport from the landscape to aquatic systems represents a number of complex processes, including rainfall–runoff patterns, manure and fertilizer application, soil–water–P interactions, and crop and forage growth. Numerous processbased models are available to accomplish this task, and many of these models are discussed in other chapters of this book. These models integrate large amounts of 105
© 2007 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
106
Modeling Phosphorus in the Environment
information to simulate catchment-scale P transport from the landscape. They have been reasonably successful in predicting catchment-scale to edge-of-field losses of P and how nutrient and land management affects these losses. However, a major gap in predicting the response of receiving water bodies is the simulation of fluvial processes occurring during P transport from landscape (edge of field) to receiving waters. Although much research relates land management to edge-of-field P losses, little data are available on the fate and transport of this P once in fluvial systems, though this can affect the amount ultimately entering a water body (McDowell et al. 2004). Most importantly, tributaries can act as sinks and sources of P and can influence the effectiveness of watershed best management practices (BMPs) and the response time of impacted water bodies to land remediation (Meals 1992). The modeling of P transport through streams must account for variability in flow, P sources, and in-channel processes (Hanrahan et al. 2001); however, the complexity and spatial variability of these instream processes limit the ability of catchment-scale models to simulate P transport in streams (Sharpley et al. 2002). A complex array of physical, abiotic, and biotic processes occurs within the channel and hyporheic zone of streams, and these complex processes, as well as land-use impacts, influence both P concentrations and loads during downstream transport. Furthermore, these channel processes can greatly influence the shortand long-term impact of P inputs on the degree of eutrophic response of receiving waters. The proportion of P transported during storm and base-flow conditions varies with catchment P sources and the importance of stream-channel and riparian processes. Though long-term (e.g., annual) inputs and outputs of P to streams may be similar, short-term (e.g., daily and monthly) transport of P from effluent discharges, drainage fields, and other upstream sources may be heavily buffered by streamchannel processes. Streams that have been enriched with P will often act as shortterm transient storage zones, releasing dissolved P back into the water column when aqueous concentrations are low (Ekka et al. 2006; Haggard et al. 2005). The release of P from sediment to overlying waters can delay or even mask P loss reductions from catchment-based BMPs (Meals 1992; National Research Council 2000). Despite the importance of these in-stream processes,