E. Fliigel Microfacies of Carbonate Rocks
Erik Fliigel
Microfacies of Carbonate Rocks Analysis, Interpretation and Application With 330 Figures and 151 Plates, some in color
a- Springer
PROFESSOR DR.ERIKFLUGEL Institute of Paleontology Loewenichstrasse 28 D-91054 Erlangen Germany E-mail:
[email protected]
ISBN 3-540-22016-X Springer Berlin Heidelberg New York Library of Congress Control Number: 2004104816 This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or art of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, repro!uction on microfilm or in any other way, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted on1 under the rovisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9, 1965,in its current version, and permission for use must always ze obtained from Springer-Verlag. Violat~onsare liable to prosecution under the German Copyright Law. Springer is a part of Springer Science+Business Media springeronline.com O Sprmger-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2004 Printed In Germany The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not im ly, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and $ere fore free for general use. Camera-ready by Erentraud Fliigel-Kahler, Erlangen Cover design: E. Kirchner, Heidelberg Production: Almas Schimmel Printed on acid-free paper 32131411as 5 4 3 2 1 0
Preface
The objective of this book is to provide a synthesis of the methods used in microfacies studies of carbonate rocks and to show how the application of microfacies studies has contributed to new developments in carbonate geology. In contrast with other textbooks on carbonate sedimentology this book focuses on those compositional and textural constituents of carbonates that reflect the depositional and diagenetic history and determine the practical usefulness of carbonate rocks. The chapters are written in such a way, that each one can be used as text in upper level undergraduate and graduate courses. The topics of the book also apply to research workers and exploration geologists, looking for current information on developments in the use of microfacies analysis. Since microfacies studies are based on thin sections, instructive plates showing thin-section photographs accompanied by thorough and detailed explanations form a central part of this book. All plates in the book contain a short summary of the topic. An -> sign leads the reader to the figures on the plate. The description of the microphotographs are printed in a smaller type. Care has been taken to add arrows and/or letters (usually the initials of the subject) so that the maximum information can be extracted from the figures. Rather than being a revised version of 'Microfacies Analysis of Limestones' (Fliigel 1982) 'Microfacies of Carbonate Rocks' is a new book, based on a new concept and offering practical advice on the description and interpretation ofmicrofacies data as well as the application of these data to basin analysis. Microfacies analysis has the advantages over traditional sedimentological approaches of being interdisciplinary, and integrating sedimentological, paleontological and geochemical aspects. 'Microfacies of Carbonate Rocks': analyses both the depositional and the diagenetic history of carbonate rocks, describes carbonate sedimentation in various marine and non-marine environments, and considers both tropical warm-water carbonates and non-tropical cool-water carbonates,
presents diagnostic features and highlights the significance of microfacies criteria, stresses the biological controls of carbonate sedimentation and provides an overview on the most common fossils found in thin sections of limestones, discusses the relationships between diagenetic processes, porosity and dolomitization, demonstrates the importance of microfacies for establishing and evaluating sequence stratigraphic frameworks and depositional models, underlines the potential of microfacies in differentiating paleoclimate changes and tracing platform-basin relationships, and demonstrates the value of microfacies analysis in evaluating reservoir rocks and limestone resources, as well as its usefulness in archaeological provenance studies.
Structure of the Book Microfacies of Carbonate Rocks starts with and introductory chaper (Chap. 1) and an overview of modem carbonate deposition (Chap. 2) followed by 17 chapters that have been grouped into 3 major parts. Microfacies Analysis (Chap. 3 to Chap. 10) summarizes the methods used in microfacies studies followed by discussions on descriptive modes and the implications of qualitative and quantitative thin-section criteria. Microfacies Interpretation (Chap. 11 to Chap. 16) demonstrates the significance of microfacies studies in evaluating paleoenvironment and depositional systems and, finally, Practical Use of Microfacies (Chap. 17 to Chap. 19) demonstrates the importance of applied microfacies studies in geological exploration for hydrocarbons and ores, provides examples of the relationships between carbonate rock resources and their facies and physical properties, and also illustrates the value of microfacies studies to archaeologists. Important references are listed at the end of chapters or sections under the heading 'Basics'. The code
numbers K... are keywords leading to references on specific fields of interest (see CD), e.g. KO21 (coldwater carbonates), KO78 (micrite), or K200 (hydrocarbon reservoir rocks). The book is also accompanied by a CD containing an alphabetical list of about 14,000 references on carbonate rocks (see Appendix) as word document, and visual comparison charts for percentage estimation.
Synopsis of the Book's Contents Chapter 1: New Perspectives in Microfacies. Microfacies studies, which were originally restricted to the scale of thin sections, provide an invaluable source of information on the depositional constraints and environmental controls of carbonates, as well as on the properties of carbonate rocks. Microfacies studies assist in understanding sequence stratigraphic patterns and are of economic importance both in reservoir studies and in the evaluation of limestone resources. Chapter 2: Modern Depositional Environments. Knowledge of modem carbonates is a prerequisite for understanding ancient carbonate rocks. Modem carbonates are fortned both on land and in the sea, in shallow- and in deep marine settings, and in tropical and non-tropical regions, but the present is only part a key to the Past.
Microjbcies Analysis Chapter 3: Methodology. Which methods can be used in the field? Which sampling strategy should be applied and how many samples are required? Which laboratory techniques are useful in rnicrofacies analysis? Which other techniques should be combined with microfacies studies? Chapter 4: Microfacies Data: Matrix and Grains. This chapter offers practical advice on how to handle microfacies data, and deals with how to describe and interpret thin-section characteristics. Matrix types and grain categories are discussed with regard to their diagnostic criteria, origin and significance. Chapter 5: Microfacies Data: Fabrics. Typical depositional and diagenetic fabrics in limestones reflect the history of the rock. Microfacies criteria indicating breaks and changes in sedimentation (discontinuity surfaces) are of specific interest in refining sequence stratigraphic boundaries. Variously sized fissures, microcracks and breccias can be used in deciphering synand post-depositional destructive processes.
Chapter 6: Quantitative Microfacies Analysis. Whilst previous chapters focused on qualitative criteria this chapter deals with quantitative data including grain size analysis, frequency analysis and multivariate studies. Constituent analysis and the distribution patterns of specific grain types are valuable tools in the reconstruction of paleoenvironmental controls and depositional settings. Chapter 7: Diagenesis, Porosity and Dolomitization. Understanding diagenetic processes and their products is of high economic importance. The diagenetic microfacies of a rock reflects changes in the course of its lithification history. The main topics discussed in this chapter are porosity types, carbonate cements, diagenetic textures including compaction and pressure solution, and dolomitization/dedolomitizationand dolomite textures. The last part of the chapter deals with thinsection criteria for metamorphic carbonates and marbles. Chapter 8: Classification - chosing a name for your sample. Aclassification is simply a tool for organizing information, and should not be the only source of conclusions. Whilst a name based on texture and composition can not replace a well-defined microfacies type, rock names are essential for the categorization of samples. Textural classifications proposed by Dunham and by Folk have proven to be the most practical. Specific concepts must be adhered to in the naming of reef limestones, non-marine carbonates, recrystallized carbonates rocks and mixed siliciclastic-carbonate rocks. Chapter 9: Limestones are Biological Sediments. In contrast to siliciclastic rocks, both the formation and the destruction of most limestones is directly or indirectly influenced and controlled by biological processes. This chapter stresses the biological controls on carbonate sedimentation. Microbes, encrusting organisms, and macro- and microborers can yield useful information on paleoenvironment, depositional constraints and carbonate production. Chapter 10: Fossils in Thin Sections. It Is Not That Difficult. The recognition of fossils in thin sections is not so difficult once the diagnostic criteria for the main groups have been understood, particularly for algae and foraminifera, sessile invertebrates, and organisms with shells. This chapter provides an overview of the most common fossils found in thin sections of limestones. The text concentrates on identification criteria, environmental and temporal distribution, and on the significance of the fossils. Numerous instructive plates are included to aid in the recognition and differentiation skeletal grains in thin sections.
VII
Microfacies Interpretation Chapter 11:Summarizing Microfacies Criteria:Microfacies Types. How can microfacies data be combined in sensitive and practicable microfacies types? Which criteria should be used, which grain types are of particular importance and, how many microfacies types are reliable? The creation of microfacies types is illustrated by means of examples. Chapter 12: Recognizing Paleoenvironmental Conditions. Carbonate sediments are particularly sensitive to environmental changes. Microfacies and organisms are excellent paleoenvironmental proxies as they reflect hydrodynamic conditions, the impact of storms, substrate conditions, light, oxygenation, seawater temperature and salinity. Significant differences between the compositions of skeletal grain associations for warm-water and cold-water carbonates provide a useful tool for estimating paleoclimatic changes. How deep was the sea? Microfacies studies provide an answer. Chapter 13: Integrated Facies Analysis. Understanding the formation and diagenesis of carbonate rocks requires the combination of microfacies with mineralogical and geochemical data. The chapter deals with acid-insoluble residues and authigenic minerals in carbonate rocks, discusses the value of minor elements and stable isotopes in tracing the depositional and diagenetic history of limestones, and deals with the potential of organic matter in carbonate rocks for facies analysis. Chapter 14: Depositional Models, Facies Zones and Standard Microfacies. Microfacies are essential for defining depositional models and recognizing facies zones. Facies models assist in understanding depositional history. Changes in sedimentological and biological criteria across shelf-slope-basin transects form the basis of generalized models for carbonate platforms, ramps and shelves. Facies belts are reflected by their biotic zonation patterns and the distribution of Standard Microfacies Types (SMF Types). The latter are virtual categories that summarize rnicrofacies with identical criteria. Which criteria are used in differentiating the SMF Types of platform and ramp carbonates? What are the problems involved in the SMF concept? Revised and refined SMF types are a meaningful tool in tracing facies belts, but must be used with care. Common microfacies of carbonate ramps (Ramp Microfacies Types) show only partial correspondence to the SMF Types of rimmed platforms. Chapter 15: Basin Analysis: Recognizing Depositional Settings. Which diagnostic criteria characterize lime-
stones of different carbonate systems? Case studies for non-marine and marine carbonate rocks demonstrate how to translate microfacies into ancient depositional settings. Non-marine settings can be successfully reconstructed for pedogenic carbonates, paleokarst deposits and ancient speleothems, travertine deposits, and lacustrine carbonates, these can be characterized by specific microfacies types. Marine settings can be differentiated into peritidal carbonates, platforms and ramps, platform-slope-basin transects, and pelagic deep-marine carbonates. Grain Composition Logs are particularly effective in tracing platform-basin relations. Chapter 16: Recognizing Depositional Constraintsand Processes. Selected case studies are used to demonstrate the value of microfacies data in interpreting depositional controls. How can microfacies be used in sequence stratigraphy? Cyclic depositional patterns and sequence stratigraphic constraints are documented by microfacies data that assist in recognizing sequence boundaries, parasequences, high-frequency sea-level changes, and systems tracts. Which criteria characterize reef limestones? Major reef types differ in biota, matrix, sediment, and cements. Which methods should be employed in reconstructing former platforms and reefs that are only recorded by eroded relicts deposited on slopes and in basins? Clast analysis can solve this puzzle. Which criteria define ancient cold-water carbonates? Ancient cool-water shelf and reef carbonates are typified by specific biotic, compositional and diagenetic features. Which facies criteria are diagnostic of ancient ventand seep carbonates? Case studies provide answers. How to handle mixed carbonate-siliciclastic sediments and interpret limestone-marl successions? * Constraints on carbonate deposition exhibit secular variations, which are discussed in the last section.
Practical Use of Microfacies Chapter 17: Reservoir Rocks and Host Rocks. Carbonates are the most important reservoir rocks for hydrocarbons as well as forming important host rocks for ores. Limestones and dolomites contain more than 50% of the world's oil and gas reserves. Reservoir potential differs for carbonates formed in different depositional settings and depends on the interplay of depositional processes and diagenetic history. The microfacies of cores and cuttings - assist in the translation of lithological data into petrophysical information. Facies-based outcrop-analogue studies indicate the scale of porosity and
VIII
permeability variations within carbonate bodies. Microfacies analysis also assists in the genetic interpretation of carbonate-hosted base metal deposits controlled by specific facies patterns. Chapter 18: Carbonate Resources, Facies Control and Rock Properties. Carbonate rocks are important raw materials for chemical and construction industries and are high on the list of extracted mineral resources, both in terms of quantity and of value. Both exploration and exploitation can be enhanced by taking into account the relationships between depositional and diagenetic facies that control technologically relevant chemical and physical parameters, as well as the weathering and decay properties of carbonate rocks. Conservation and preservation of works of art and building stones should start with thin-section studies of the textural and diagenetic criteria that describe the porosity and permeability of the material. Chapter 19:Archaeometry. Microfacies analysis, combined with geochemical data has considerable potential in provenance analysis of archaeological materials. Thin sections reveal the source of building stones and of material used for mosaics and works of arts. The microfacies of temper grains in ancient pottery helps in understanding the source and production areas for ceramics. Last but not least, microfacies studies can throw new light at the love affair between Antony and Cleopatra. ...
Acknowledgments Thanks are due to many people who have provided photographs, information and advice: Gernot Arp (Gottingen), Martina Bachmann (Bremen), Benoit Beauchamp (Calgary), Thilo Bechstadt (Heidelberg), Michaela Bemecker (Erlangen), Joachim Blau (Giessen), Florian Bohm (Kiel), Thomas Brachert (Mainz), Ioan Bucur (Cluj-Napoca), Werner Buggisch (Erlangen),Thomas Clausing (Halle), Wolf-Christian Dullo (Kiel), Paul Enos (Lawrence, Kansas), Gerd Flajs (Aachen), Christof Fliigel (Miinchen), Helmut Fliigel (Graz), Beate Fohrer (Erlangen), Holger Forke (Berlin), AndrC Freiwald (Erlangen), Robert van Geldern
(Erlangen), Markus Geiger (Bremen), Gisela Gerdes (Oldenburg), Eberhard Gischler (Frankfurt), Dirk von Gosen (Erlangen), Jiirgen Grotsch (Damascus). HansGeorg Herbig (Koln), Richard Hofling (Erlangen), Bemhard Hubmann (Graz), Andi Imran (Makassar), Michael Joachimski (Erlangen), Josef Kazmierczak (Warszawa), Martin Keller (Erlangen), Stephan Kempe (Darmstadt), Helmut Keupp (Berlin), Wolfgang Kiessling (Berlin), Roman Koch (Erlangen), Karl Krainer (Imsbruck), Jochen Kuss (Bremen), Michael Link (Erlangen), Heinz Lorenz (Erlangen), Ulrich Michel (Nurnberg), Axel Mumecke (Erlangen), Fritz Neuweiler (Gottingen), Alexander Nutzel (Erlangen), Joachim Reitner (Gottingen), Jurgen Remane (Neuchatel), Elias Samankassou (Fribourg), Diethard Sanders (Imsbruck), Chris Schulbert (Erlangen), Baba Senowbari-Daryan (Erlangen), Robert J. Stanton (Thousand Oaks, California), Torsten Steiger (Bad Blankenburg), Thomas Steuber (Bochum), Harald Tragelehn (Koln), Jorg Trappe (Bonn), Dragica Tumsek (Ljubljana), Andreas Wetzel (Tubingen). I am indebted to Birgit Leipner-Mata and Marieluise Neufert (Institute of Paleontology Erlangen) for laboratory work and photography. Chris Schulbert (Institute of Paleontology) was a valuable help with all computer problems. I am sincerely grateful to my friend Johann Georg Haditsch (Graz) for critical reading the text of the book. Special thanks go to Karen Christenson (NiimbergKraftshof) who took care of linguistic problems and pitfalls. Editing, layout, drawings and the preparation of plates and figures have been camed out by my wife Erentraud Fliigel-Kahler. I am most grateful for her encouragement and constant help. Finally, I am obliged to all institutions who gave permission to use published material and to the staff of Springer Verlag, especially to Dr. Wolfgang Engel for his constant encouragement and to Dr. J. Witschel for assistance with the book.
Contents New Perspectives in Microfacies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Microfacies Concept . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . New Perspectives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Carbonate Depositional Environments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Carbonates are Bom not Made . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The 'Sorby Principle': Limestones are Predominantly Biogenic Sediments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Modem Carbonates: Obligatory Reading . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Carbonate Sediments Originate on Land and in the Sea . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Classification of Marine Environments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . BoundaryLevels . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Vertical and Horizontal Zonations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VerticalZonations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Horizontal Zonations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Review of Modem Carbonate Depositional Environments . . . . . . . . . . . . . Non-Marine Carbonate Environments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pedogenic Carbonates. Paleosols. and Caliche/Calcretes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Palustrine Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Cave Carbonates. Speleothems and Karst . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Glacialcarbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Travertine. Calcareous Tufa and Calcareous Sinter . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Lacustrine Carbonates: Lakes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Fluvialcarbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Transitional Marginal-Marine Environments: Shorelines and Peritidal Sediments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Beach (Foreshore). Barriers and Coastal Lagoons . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Peritidal Environments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Shallow-Marine Sedimentary Environments: 'Shallow' and 'Deep' . . . . . . Pericontinental vs Epicontinental Shallow Seas . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Carbonate Shelves. Ramps and Platforms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ShelfMargins . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Reefs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Tropical and Non-Tropical Carbonates: Different in Composition. Controls and Significance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Latitudinal Zonation and Diagnostic Criteria of Tropical and Non-Tropical Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Tropical and Subtropical Shallow-Marine Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Non-Tropical Shelf and Reef Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Deep-Marine Environments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Settings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sedimentation Processes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pelagic Sedimentation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Resedimentation (' Allochthonous Carbonates') . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Contents
Carbonate Plankton and Carbonate Oozes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Preservation Potential and Dissolution Levels . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Carbonate Slopes. Periplatform Carbonates and Caronate Aprons . . . . . . . Seepandventcarbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microfacies Analysis Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Field Work and Sampling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Field Observations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Lithology. Texture and Rock Colors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Bedding and Stratification. Sedimentary Structures and DiageneticFeatures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Fossils and Biogenic Structures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Field Logs and Compositional Logs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sampling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Search Sampling and Statistical Sampling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . How Many Samples? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Practical Advice for Microfacies Sampling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Laboratory Work: Techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Slices. Peels and Thin Sections . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Casts. Etching and Staining . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microscopy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Petrographic Microscopy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . StereoscanMicroscopy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Fluorescence. Cathodoluminescence and Fluid Inclusion Microscopy . . . . Mineralogy and Geochemistry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Trace Elements and Stable Isotope Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microfacies Data: Matrix and Grains . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Fine-Grained Carbonate Matrix: Micrite. Microspar. Calcisiltite . . . . . . . . Micrite . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Modes of Formation of Micrite and Other Fine-Grained Matrix Types . . . Microspar . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Calcisiltite . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Practical Aids in Describing and Interpreting Fine-Grained Limestones . . Significance of Fine-Grained Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Carbonate Grains . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Bioclasts (Skeletal Grains) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Peloids: Just a Term of Ignorance? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Cortoids - Carbonate Grains Characterized by Micrite Envelope . . . . . . . . Oncoids and Rhodoids . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Oncoids . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Rhodoids and Macroids . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ooids . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pisoids and Vadoids - Simply 'Larger Ooids' or Carbonate Grains on their Own? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Aggregate Grains: Grapestones. Lumps and Other Composite Grains . . . . Resediments: Intra.. Extra- and Lithoclasts - Insiders and Foreigners . . . . Intraclasts: Origin and Facies-Diagnostic Types . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Extraclasts: Strange Foreigners . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Morphometry of Carbonate Grains . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Intentions and Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Significance of Morphometric Data for Carbonate Grains . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Contents
Microfacies Data: Fabrics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Depositional and Diagenetic Fabrics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Geopetal Fabrics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Biofabrics and Grain Orientation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Bedding and Lamination Fabrics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Burrowing and Bioturbation Fabrics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Birdseyes. Fenestral Fabrics and Stromatactis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Birdseyes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Fenestral Fabrics ............................................. Stromatactis ................................................. Significance of Birdseyes. Fenestral Fabrics and Stromatactis . . . . . . . . . . Nodular Fabrics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Discontinuity Surfaces: From Microfacies to Sequence Stratigraphy . . . . . Classification of Discontinuities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Major Criteria of Discontinuities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microfacies Criteria and Significance of Exposure Surfaces . . . . . . . . . . . . Microfacies Criteria and Significance of Condensation Surfaces and Hardgrounds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Hardgrounds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Condensation Surfaces and Condensed Sections . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Discontinuities and Sequence Stratigraphy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Syn- and Postdepositional Features: Fissures. Veins. Breccias . . . . . . . . . . Sediment-Filled Fissures: Neptunian Dikes and Fissure Fills . . . . . . . . . . . Origin. Development and Filling of Sedimentary Fissures . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microfacies Analysis of Neptunian Dikes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Case Studies of Neptunian Dikes in Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Significance of Sediment-Filled Fissures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microfractures and Veins (Calcite Veins) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Origin and Classification of Calcite Veins . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Descriptive Criteria of Calcite-Filled Microfractures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Significance of Microfractures in Carbonate Rocks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Carbonate Breccias and Conglomerates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Teminology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . How to Describe Carbonate Breccias? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Carbonate Breccia Types: Origin. Classification. Criteria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Carbonate Conglomerates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Significance of Carbonate Breccias and Conglomerates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Quantitative Microfacies Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Grain-Size Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Grain-Size Analysis: Methods and Aims . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Measuring Grain Sizes and Describing Size Distributions . . . . . . . . . . . . . Approaches to the Environmental Interpretation of Grain-Size Data . . . . . Grain-Size Analysis in Thin Sections . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Grain-Size Studies of Modem and Ancient Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Grain-Size Studies of Modem Carbonate Sediments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Application of Grain-Size Analyses to Carbonate Rocks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Significance of Grain-Size Studies of Carbonate Rocks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Frequency Analysis of Microfacies Data . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Methods of Frequency Analyses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Counting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Estimating . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Image Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Contents
Constituent Ranking. Diversity and Maturity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Integrated Frequency Studies of Reef Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . PracticalAdvice . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Multivariate Microfacies Studies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Methods: Variations between Constituents and between Samples . . . . . . . . Significance of Multivariate Studies: Constituent Analysis as a Clue to Environmental Conditions and Depositional Settings . . . . . . . . . . .
Diagenesis. Porosity. and Dolomitization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Carbonate Mineralogy and Diagenetic Processes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Modem Carbonate Sediments and Ancient Carbonate Rocks . . . . . . . . . . . Common Carbonate Minerals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Diagenetic Processes and Controls . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . From Soft Sediments to Hard Rocks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Oscillating Trends in Phanerozoic Carbonate Mineralogy . . . . . . . . . . . . . Secularvariations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . How to Recognize Former Aragonite and Mg-Calcite Mineralogy in Ancient Low-Calcite Limestones? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Major Diagenetic Environments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Meteoric. Marine and Burial Diagenesis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Meteoric (Freshwater) Diagenesis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mixing Zone and Marine Vadose Environment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . MarineDiagenesis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Burial Diagenesis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Early and Late Diagenesis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Porosity of Carbonate Rocks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Porosity Categories. Pore Geometry and Permeability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Basic Definitions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pore Geometry and Permeability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Porosity Measurements and Pore Types in Thin Sections . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Porosity Terminology and Classification . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Porosity in Limestones and Dolomites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pore-Filling Processes: Cementation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Controls on Carbonate Cementation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Morphology and Fabrics of Cement Types . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CementTypes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Cen~entFabrics. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Cement Types and Diagenetic Environments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Facies-Controlled Diagenesis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Carbonate Platforms and Ramps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Reefs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Cold-Water vs . Warm-Water Diagenesis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Diagenetic Pathways and Patterns . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Diagenetic Textures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mechanical Processes: Compaction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Chemical Processes: Pressure Solution and Stylolitization . . . . . . . . . . . . . Significance of Compaction and Pressure Solution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Neomorphic Processes: Alteration and Recrystallization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Recrystallized Carbonate Rocks: What to do? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . How to DescribeRecrystallized Carbonate Rocks? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sparite: Recrystallization Product or Carbonate Cement? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dolomitization and Dedolomitization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Descriptive Criteria and Terminology of Dolomite Fabrics . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Contents
Thin-Section Description and Terminology of Dolomite Rocks . . . . . . . . . Dolomite Cement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Value of Dolomite Textures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Some Dolomitization Models . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dolomites Associated with Evaporites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mixing-Water and Seawater Models . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Subsurface Burial Dolomites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dedolomitization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Textural Criteria for Recognizing Dedolomitization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Origin of Dedolomite . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Significance of Dedolomitization. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Metamorphic Carbonate and Marbles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Classification . A Name for Your Sample . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Basicconcepts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Reef Limestones and Microbial Carbonates (Autochthonous Carbonates) . Classifications Based on Depositional Texture . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Prerequisites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Original and Expanded Dunham Classification . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Concepts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Original and Expanded Folk Classification . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Concepts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Specific Classifications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Diagenetic Changes in Depositional Textures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Some Nonmarine Carbonates Need very Specific Names . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Classification of Mixed Siliciclastic-CarbonateRocks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A Name for Your Samples: Some Practical Advice . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Limestones are Biological Sediments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microbial Carbonates and Stromatolites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Bacterial Contribution to Carbonate Precipitation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . How to Recognize Microbial Carbonates? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Describing and Classifying Benthic Microbial Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . Terminology and Descriptive Criteria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Classification of Benthic Microbial Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Stromatolites are Laminated Microbialites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Occurrence and Significance of Microbialites and Stromatolites . . . . . . . . Development through Time . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Paleoenvironmental Significance of Microbial Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . Economic Importance of Stromatolites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Biogenic Encrustations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Criteria and Constraints of Encrusters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Phanerozoic Encrusters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Significance of Encrustation Patterns in Recognizing Depositional Settings and Environmental Controls . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Bioerosion. Boring and Grazing Organisms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Recent and Fossil Microborers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Recent and Fossil Macroborers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Micro- and Macroboring through Time . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Qualitative Changes in Micro- and Macroborer Groups . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Quantitative Changes in the Intensity of Macroboring in Coral Reefs . . . .
Contents
XIV
Microborer Associations are Proxies for Paleo-Water Depths . . . . . . . . . . . Practical Advice: How to Describe Microbialites and Stromatolites. Biogenic Encrustations and Borings? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Fossils in Thin Section: It is Not That Difficult . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Specifics of Thin-Section Fossils . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . How to Determine Fossils in Thin Sections? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Which Fossils in which Time Interval? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Practical Advice . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Diagnostic Criteria of Fossils in Thin Sections . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Cyanobacteria and Calcareous Algae . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Cyanobacteria and Calcimicrobes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Corallinacean and Peyssoneliacean Red Algae . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Solenoporacean Red Algae . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ancestral Red Algae and Problematic Red Algae . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Udoteacean Green Algae and Gymnocodiacean Algae . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Phylloid Algae . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dasyclad Green Algae . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Charophyta: Fresh-Water and Brackish-Water Algae . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 'Calcispheres' and Algal Cysts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Foraminifera and other Protozoa . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Foraminifera . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Radiolaria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Calpionellids . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Benthic Sessile Organisms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sponges . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Hydrozoans . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Corals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Bryozoans . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Shells . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Brachiopods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Bivalves . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Gastropods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Cephalopods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Tentaculitids and Other Conical Shells (Cricoconarida; Hyolithida) . . . . . . Serpulids and Other Worm Tubes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CrustaceanArthropods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Trilobites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Echinoderms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Rare Thin-Section Fossils . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microproblematica . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Inventory of Microproblematica . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Discussion of Selected Microproblematica . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Biozonation of Platforms with Thin-Section Fossils . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Where to Look for Thin-Section Pictures of Fossils and Microfacies Types . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Microfacies Interpretation Summarizing Microfacies Criteria: Microfacies Types . . . . . . . . . . . . . MFTConcepts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . How to Differentiate Meaningful Microfacies Types . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Making Microfacies Types . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Contents
Recognizing Paleoenvironmental Conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Reconstructing Environmental Constraints . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Hydrodynamic Controls . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Hydrodynamic Energy Levels . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Classifying Low-Energy and High-Energy Environments . . . . . . . . . . . . . Paleocurrent Data . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Storms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Storm Deposits (Tempestites) on Shelves. Ramps and Platforms . . . . . . . . Impact of Tropical Storms on Reefs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Significance of Carbonate Storm Deposits . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Marine Carbonate Substrates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Carbonate Substrate Types and Organism-Sediment Interactions . . . . . . . . Recognizing Substrate Types . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Light . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Zonation and Light Conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Recognition of Photic and Aphotic Conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Oxygen . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Terminology and Classification . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Recognizing Paleo-Oxygenation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Case Study: Black Shale Development on a Carbonate Platform . . . . . . . . Seawater Temperature . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Seawater Temperature: Biotic Proxies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Geochemical Proxies of Seawater Temperatures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Salinity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Biotic and Microfacies Proxies of Paleosalinity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Geochemical Proxies of Paleosalinity ............................. Microfacies Proxies for Hypersaline and Evaporitic Conditions . . . . . . . . . Productivity and Nutrients . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Nutrients . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Estimating Paleonutrient Levels . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Effects of Nutrient Excess on Reef and Platform Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . Estimating Paleoclimatic Conditions: Grain Association Analysis . . . . . . . Concepts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Practical Advice. Examples and State of Current Information . . . . . . . . . . Distinguishing Grain Association Types . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Examples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . State of the Art . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Assessing Water Depths . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Hints to Paleowater Depths . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Case Study: Assessing the Water Depth of a Carbonate Ramp . . . . . . . . . . Integrated Facies Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Non-Carbonate Constituents . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Insoluble Residues (IR): Clay Minerals and Detrital Quartz . . . . . . . . . . . . Authigenic Minerals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Silicification of Carbonates. Authigenic Feldspar and Glauconite . . . . . . . Sulfides: Pyrite . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sulfates: Evaporite Minerals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Phosphates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Geochemical Proxies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . TraceElements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Strontium and Manganese .Favorite Tools for Facies Studies . . . . . . . . . .
Contents
Significance of Trace Elements in Facies Studies of Carbonate Rocks . . . . Stable Isotopes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Organic Matter in Carbonate Rocks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Depositional Models. Facies Zones and Standard Microfacies . . . . . . . Depositional Facies Models ..................................... Conceptual. Dynamic and Computer Models . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ConceptualModels . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . DynamicModels . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Numerical Models . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Basic Elements of Carbonate Facies Models . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Common Facies Belts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Common Depositional Patterns . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Different Depositional Settings Require Different Facies Models . . . . . . . Facies Zones of Rimmed Carbonate Platforms: The Wilson Model . . . . . . Standard Facies Zones and the Modified Wilson Model ............... Discussion and Use of Standard Facies Zones . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CarbonateRampModel . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Non-rimmed Shelves and Platforms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Isolated Platforms and Atolls . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . EpeiricPlatfomModel . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . EpeiricRampModel . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Biotic Zonation Patterns . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ConceptsandMethods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Case Study: Foraminifera1 Distribution in Late Triassic Reefs and Platforms Standard Microfacies Types (SMF) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Revised Standard Microfacies Types . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Discussion of Standard Microfacies Types . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Stratigraphic Microfacies Types . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Common Microfacies Types of Carbonate Ramps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microfacies Criteria of Carbonate Ramps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microfacies Types of Carbonate Ramps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Tracing Facies Zones with Microfacies Types . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Determining Standard Microfacies Types: A Practical Guide . . . . . . . . . . . Dynamic Microfacies Types and Environmental Changes . . . . . . . . . . . . . Basin Analysis: Recognizing Depositional Settings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pedogeniccarbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microfacies Criteria of Paleocaliche . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Significance of Paleocaliche and Paleosols . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Paleokarst and Ancient Speleothems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Diagnostic Criteria of Paleokarst and Paleospeleothem Structures . . . . . . . Significance of Paleokarst and Cave Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Travertine. Calcareous Tufa and Calcareous Sinter . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Lacustrine and Palustrine Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microfacies of Lacustrine Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microfacies Criteria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microfacies Types of Lacustrine Limestones . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Distribution of Lacustrine Microfacies Types . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Palustrine Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Peritidal Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Criteria of Peritidal Limestones . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Definitions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Contents
XVII
Major Facies Criteria of Peritidal Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Synopsis of Diagnostic Criteria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Case Study: Middle Devonian Peritidal Carbonates from Poland . . . . . . . . Carbonate Platforms and Ramps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ecological Controls on Platforms and Ramps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Response of Carbonate Platforms to Drowning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microfacies Signals of Drowning History . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Case Study: Platfonn Drowning Reflected by Microfacies . . . . . . . . . . . . . Case Studies: Platform and Ramp Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A Late Jurassic Bahamian-Type Carbonate Platform from the Northern Calcareous Alps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A Middle Devonian Ramp from Graz. Southern Austria ............... A Late Jurassic/Early Cretaceous Ramp from the Subsurface of Southern Bavaria. Germany . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Platform-Slope-Basin Transects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Types and Composition of Carbonate Slopes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Allochthonous Slope and Basin Deposits: Diagnostic Criteria . . . . . . . . . . Submarine Rockfalls . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Breccias and Megabreccias . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Debris-Flow Deposits . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Grain-Flow Deposits . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Turbidites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sliding and Slumping . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microfacies of Slope Carbonates: Case Studies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Permian of Sicily: Megablocks and Base-of-Slope Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . Triassic of the Southern Alps: Allochthonous Slope Sediments . . . . . . . . . Jurassic of Morocco: Platform-Slope-Basin Transect . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jurassic of the Northern Calcareous Alps: Detailed Information from Limestone Turbidites on Source and Deposition Patterns . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Slope Stability Reflected by Texture and Microfacies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Tracing Platform-Basin Transitions Using Grain Composition Logs . . . . . ConceptandMethods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Case Study: Late Triassic of the Gosaukamm Region. Austria . . . . . . . . . . Pelagic Deep-Marine Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Setting. Controls and Biota of Pelagic Limestones . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Examples and Case Studies of Pelagic Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microfacies of Paleozoic Basinal Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microfacies of Mesozoic Basinal Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Contourites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Realizing Depositional Constraints and Processes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Cyclic Carbonates. Microfacies and Sequence Stratigraphy . . . . . . . . . . . . Cyclic Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Cyclic Carbonates: Some Basics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microfacies and Cyclic Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Case Studies: The Lofer Cycle and the Latemar Cycle (Triassic of the Alps) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Carbonate Sequence Stratigraphy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sequence Analysis: Some Basics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microfacies Data Applied to Sequence Stratigraphy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Case Studies: Sea-Level Fluctuations and Systems Tracts Documented by Microfacies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Understanding Reef Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Contents
WhatisaReef'? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Reef Types . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Reef Fossils . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Reef Biota: Compositional Changes during Time . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Reef Guilds: Ecologic Units . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . How to Classify Reef Carbonates? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microfacies Approach to Reef Studies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Basic Constituents of Reef and Mound Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Describing Reef Carbonates: A Practical Guide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Case Studies of Some Ancient Reefs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mud Mounds: The Early Devonian 'Kess Kess' Mounds in the Anti.Atlas, Southern Morocco . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Waulsortian Mud Mounds: Early Carboniferous (Lower Mississippian) Muleshoe Mound. Sacramento Mountains. New Mexico. U.S.A. . . . . . . . . Reefs: The Capitan Reef. Permian Reef Complex. Guadalupe Mountains. Texas and New Mexico. U.S.A. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Fingerprinting Lost Platforms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Casestudies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Case Study: Platform Facies Patterns Derived from the Microfacies of Early Carboniferous Conglomerates (Southern Spain) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Case Study: Reconstruction of Paleo-Escarpments from Microfacies Data Recognizing Ancient Cool-Water Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microfacies Criteria of Non-Tropical Cold-Water Shelf and Reef Limestones . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Case Study: Early Tertiary Cool-Water Coral Reef . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Testing for Ancient Vent and Seep Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Diagnostic Criteria of Ancient Seep and Vent Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Casestudies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Late Eocene 'Whiskey Creek' Seep Carbonates of Washington State. U.S.A. Early Cretaceous Seep Carbonates in the Canadian Arctic . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mixed Carbonate-Siliciclastic Settings and Limestonehlarl Sequences . . . Carbonate-Siliciclastic Environments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Modern Carbonate-Siliciclastic Environments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ancient Mixed Carbonate-Siliciciastic Environments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Describing Carbonate-Siliciclastic Sediments: Practical Advice . . . . . . . . . Limestone-Marl Sequences: Primary orland Diagenetic Origin? . . . . . . . . Secular Variations in Carbonate Depositional Patterns and Temporal Changes in Microfacies Criteria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Changes of Major Carbonate Depositional Environments During Time . . . Phanerozoic Carbonate Platforms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Phanerozoic Reef Patterns . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pelagic Carbonates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Differences in Phanerozoic Benthic Carbonate Factories . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Temporal Changes in Non-Skeletal and Skeletal Mineralogy . . . . . . . . . . . Temporal Changes in the Abundance and Significance of Microfacies Criteria
Practical Use of Microfacies Reservoir Rocks and Host Rocks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Carbonate Hydrocarbon Reservoirs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Distribution of Carbonate Reservoirs during Time . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Depositional Setting and Environmental Controls of Carbonate Reservoirs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
830 830 831 831 831 833 833 834 836 836 838 842 843 847 847 848 848 849 852 852 856 857 857 858 859 860 862 862 862 864 864 866 868 868 869 870 872 873 874 874
877 877 878 878
Contents
XIX
Depositional Setting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Environmental Controls . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Diagenetic Controls on Carbonate Reservoirs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Reservoir Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Diagenetic Controls on Reservoir Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Seismic Interpretation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . LogResponse . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Cores and Cuttings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Reservoir-Related Outcrop Analog Studies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microfacies. Lithofacies and Reservoir Rock Types . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Reservoir Heterogeneity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Relevant Microfacies Data . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Reservoir Rock Types and Facies Criteria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Carbonate-Hosted Mineral Deposits . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ore Deposits and Carbonate Settings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microfacies and Ore Deposits . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Carbonate Rock Resources. Facies. Weathering. Preservation . . . . . . . Industrial Use of Carbonate Rocks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Exploration and Exploitation of Carbonate Rocks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Facies and Physical-Chemical Properties of Carbonate Rocks . . . . . . . . . . Weathering. Decay and Preservation of Carbonate Rocks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Weathering of Carbonate Rocks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Preservation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Microfacies and Archaeology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Questions and Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Buildingstones . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Building Stones: Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Building Stones: Examples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mosaic Material . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mosaic Material: Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mosaic Material: Examples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . WorksofArt . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Works of Art: Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Works of Art: Example . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ceramics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ceramics: Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ceramics: Example . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Marble Studies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Antony and Cleopatra: Tracing a Famous Love Affair . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Appendix Answers to Exercises . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Looking at the Attached CD . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Comparisoncharts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Using the List of References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Permissions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Index
1 New Perspectives in Microfacies
A rapid evolution in our understanding of carbonate rocks was triggered in the mid- to late 50's by the discovery of carbonate reservoirs in various parts of the world, followed by intensive research of recent carbonates. Modem and ancient carbonate environments, diagenetic processes and facies models were studied between about 1955 and 1965. During the late 60's and the 70's microfacies became an essential part of facies analysis and paleoenvironrnentalinterpretation of limestones. The increasing importance of limestones and dolomites as reservoir rocks and the use of thin-section fossils in subdividing carbonate platforms gave substantial impetus to the progress of microfacies research. The 1980's were characterized by an increased application of geochemical techniques with the object of developing predictive models for carbonate diagenesis and porosity. The subsequent period of time has seen the rapid development of sequence stratigraphy which now plays a major role in the characterization of the geometry and reservoir potential of carbonate rocks.
1.I The Microfacies Concept As originally defined by Brown (1943) and again independently by Cuvillier (1952) the term 'microfacies' referred only to petrographic and paleontological criteria studied in thin-sections. Today, however, microfacies is regarded as the total of all sedimentological and paleontological data which can be described and classified from thin sections, peels, polished slabs or rock samples. Field geology, including mapping and profiling, is a prerequisite for successful microfacies analysis. The importance of combined field work and thin-section studies was already emphasized in the earliest thin-section based investigations of carbonate rocks directed towards genetic interpretations of limestones (Peters 1863; Giimbel 1873; Sorby 1879; Hantken 1884). The practical application of thin-section criteria of limestones was demonstrated by Udden and Waite as early
as 1927 by the use of microscopic features of limestones for oil exploration in Texas. Hovelaque and Kilian (1900) published the first illustrated volume of thin-section photographs of carbonates. This approach was continued by the 'Intemational Sedimentary Petrographical Series' initiated by Cuvillier at the Third International World Petroleum Conference in Paris in 1951. The volumes published within this series as well as other comprehensive monographs containing numerous plates with thin-section photographs (see Sect. 10.4) contributed substantially to the rapid adoption of the microfacies approach. During the past decades microfacies has become an established part of the study of carbonate rocks. However, many authors use microfacies criteria in describing and classifying limestones but fail to explore the significance of these criteria for the interpretation of depositional and diagenetic histories of carbonate rocks. Part 2 and 3 of this book demonstrate the great potential of microfacies studies in basin analysis and applied carbonate geology.
1.2 New Perspectives New perspectives in the study and application of microfacies have resulted from the application of new techniques, from the availability of new comparative data on modem and ancient carbonates, from new data concerning the origin and distribution patterns of carbonate grains and the dominant biological control on carbonate sedimentation, from new concepts on defining facies models, and from new ideas concerning the course of carbonate sedimentation through geological time.
New techniques. Whilst microscopy is essential in the study of carbonate rocks there are many additional techniques which should also be utilized to maximize the information offered by microfacies analysis (Tucker 1988). Cathodoluminescence microscopy, fluid inclusion microscopy, scanning electron microscopy as well
A First Glance at a Thin Section
bonates and to recognize 'warm-mode' and 'cold-mode' paleolatitudes are improving rapidly.
Carbonate grains. Increasingly new more information is available concerning the biological and non-biological controls on the origin of carbonate grains, the site of deposition of carbonate grains, and on the distribution and dominance of grain types during the Phanerozoic. Characteristic grain type associations and the specific composition of grain types (e.g. ooids, oncoids, pisoids) provide hints on paleolatitudes and environmental controls for both marine and non-marine carbonate deposition (Sect. 4.2; Sect. 12.2).
Bioerosion. The biological destruction of carbonate substrates by borers, raspers and crushers is currently being intensively studied. Important objectives of these studies, which are also significant in microfacies analysis, are the application of boring morphology and boring patterns for paleobathymetric reconstructions and the estimation of the quantitative contribution of bioeroders for the marine carbonate budget (Sect. 9.3). Microbial carbonates:Carbonate deposits produced or localized by microbial communities are known from marine, marginal-marine, freshwater and terrestrial environments. The role of bacteria and cyanobacteria
Plate 1 A First Glance at a Thin Section The plate exhibits a thin section of a Mesozoic limestone from the Austrian Alps. Although the first appearance may be puzzling, a thorough investigation of the microfacies criteria reveals an amazing history for this rock. 1 The thin section shows fossils and dark-colored areas. The fossils correspond to organisms once living in a reef and contributing to the formation of a reef limestone. The dark-colored areas represent various types of fine-grained sediment. The reef limestone contains calcareous sponges, serpulid worms (SW), tube-like microproblematica (Microtubus, M), and bivalves. Sponges and encrusting Microtubus and serpulids formed an organic framework. The sediment within the framework (S 1) consists of tiny, densely packed microcrystalline particles (peloids) and some ostracods and foraminifera. Both elements can only be seen under greater magnification. The sponges are represented by non-chambered inozoans (IS), chambered sphinctozoans (SS) and chaetetid sponges (CS). Microtubus occurs encrusted on and within sponges, and is concentrated near the periphery of the framework, but the outermost part is a microbial crust (MC) formed by bacterially induced carbonate precipitation. The surface of the microbial crust outlines a distinct relief. The eye-catching large bivalve shell (BI) was heavily attacked by boring organisms including boring bivalves (BB) and microborers drilling tiny holes (MB). The bivalves are infilled with dark calcareous sediment (S2) different in composition from the sediment within the organic reef framework. The conspicuous circular section might represent a pelagic fossil (H, Heterastridium). The reddish fine-grained sediment (S3) yields densely packed skeletal grains including sponge spicules and pelagic shell debris as well as some radiolarians and pelagic ostracods. This sediment and the reef limestones are covered by a thin Fe/Mn crust (arrows) forming small microbial microstromatolites. The overlying sediment S4 contains (white) skeletal elements of crinoids, mostly parts of arms associated with pelagic shell debris. Radiolarians, small ammonites and pelagic algal cysts are too small to be visible on the plate. Interpretation: Microtubus indicates a Late Triassic (Norian to Rhaetian) age for the reef limestone. The composition of the reef-building assemblage characterizes reefs formed in protected low-energy settings. Environmental change is indicated by the peripheral microbial crust covering the reef fabric. The reef limestone and the microbial crust were transected by a fissure that remained open for some time as indicated by the calcite tapestry. Later on the fissure was infilled by the open-marine pelagic sediment S3. The Fe/Mn crust covering both the surface of the microbial crust and the fissure fill marks a discontinuity surface corresponding to a hardground and indicating a gap in the sedimentary record. The microfacies of sediment S4 reflects the renewed onset of pelagic sedimentation. The sediments S3 and S4 are Liassic in age. The time hidden in the pelagic sedimentary record, however, can not be determined from the thin-section data. Solution took place within the reef limestone as shown by solution voids (V) within the originally aragonitic sponges. In contrast primary calcitic fossils, e.g. Microtubus, are well preserved. These voids and the cement type of the calcite tapestry within the fissure point to freshwater diagenesis, an interpretation that also is supported by stable isotope data. The small-scale microfacies data of the thin section reflect the large-scale developments in sedimentation at the TriassicJurassic boundary in the Northern Calcareous Alps: Platform and reef development - platform destruction related to subaerial exposure and drowning - transition to open-marine pelagic sedimentation. The sample comes from the Tropfbruch quarry in Adnet near Salzburg, Austria, where Rhaetian reef limestones (Fig. 8.2) are overlain by Early Jurassic carbonates.
The story behind this thin section is rather difficult, but the following chapters will answer to all of your questions and give the information needed.
in the precipitation of fine-grained carbonate and in the formation of microbialites is becoming increasingly well understood. Laboratory experiments simulating bacterially-controlled carbonate precipitation, the recognition of bacterially constructed carbonate crystals and grains and the study of modem biofilms combine to indicate the importance of microbes in the formation of many items included within the list of microfacies criteria (e.g. micrite, peloids, ooids, oncoids, micrite envelopes, stromatactis, carbonate crusts; Sect. 9.1). Combined studies of microfacies and geobiochemical data are necessary in order to understand constructive microbial contr& (e.g. biogenic crusts and mud mounds), destructive processes (e.g. boring microbes) and carbonate cementation.
Carbonate sequences and cycles. The recognition and interpretation of cyclic patterns is a major objective of modern carbonate sedimentology. Because cyclicity is reflected by systematic changes in biota, grain composition, texture and early diagenetic criteria, microfacies studies are able to contribute to a better understanding of short-term depositional variations (Sect. 16.1.1). The three major prerequisites for sequence stratigraphy - a sound paleoenvironmental interpretation, an estimate of synchronicity, and the differentiation between regional and local effects - may be vigorously supported by microfacies studies which also improve the interpretation of sequence boundaries with regard to origin, timing and location (Sect. 16.1.2). New concepts in defining facies models. The value of 'models' in facies analysis depends largely on the significance attributed to a sedimentary model by the author. The majority of models suggested for the different modes of carbonate sedimentation are based on comparative studies between modem and ancient carbonates. These 'conceptual models' remain important tools because they facilitate the attribution of characteristic sedimentological or paleontological data to specific facies belts (Chap. 14). However, a too rigorous use of conceptual models for one's own facies studies may result in significant errors if the more descriptive, static character of the model is not critically considered. 'Dynamic models', concentrating on processes and controls and computer simulations dealing with the major controlling factors of carbonate buildups, provide a promising platform for the discussion of potential steps in the development of sedimentary bodies (e.g. carbonate platforms), organic structures (e.g. reefs) or individual sequences (e.g. cycles). The evaluation of computer-generated facies models should be strongly de-
pendent on microfacies and paleontological criteria because only these criteria deliver the paleoenvironmental information that can verify, refine or disprove theoretical concepts.
Secular changes during the Phanerozoic. There is considerable evidence for temporal and secular fluctuations in major facies types, the dominant types of carbonate cements, the mineralogy of skeletal grains and probably also in diagenesis and carbonate geochemistry. Some of these fluctuations can be explained by global changes in biological factors (e.g. role of carbonate plankton, nutrients), others by global changes in climate and oceanography. Microfacies criteria for carbonate rocks provide evidence for changes through time as shown by distinct differences in the composition of Phanerozoic bioclastic sands, types of calcareous ooids, composition and size of oncoids, open-space structures etc. (Sect. 16.7). The recognition of these changes has a major impact on depositional and diagenetic models for ancient carbonates. Applied microfacies. Carbonate rocks contain more than 50% of the world's oil and gas reserves, are important hosts to ore deposits and form very important raw materials. Depositional facies and diagenetic patterns determine the physical and chemical properties of these limestones and dolomites which control their reservoir potential (Chap. 17) and their technological attributes (Chap. 18). Microfacies studies assist in understanding the origin and history of these characteristics. Basics: New perspectives in microfacies Brown, J.S. (1943): Suggested use of the word microfacies. - Economic Geology, 38, p. 325 Carozzi, A.V. (1989): Carbonate rock depositional models. A microfacies approach. - 604 pp., Englewood Cliffs (Prentice Hall) Cuvillier, J. (1952): Le notion de 'microfacies' et ses applications. - VIII Congreso Nazionale di Metano e Petroleo, sect. I, 1-7 Cuvillier, J. (1962): ~ t u d eet utilisation rationelle de microfacies. - Revue de Micropal6ontologie, 4, 3-6 Fliigel, E. (1982): Microfacies analysis of limestones. 633 pp., Berlin (Springer) Spence, G.H., Tucker, M. (1999): Modelling carbonate microfacies in the context of high-frequencydynamic relative sea-level and environmental changes. - Journal of Sedimentary Research, 69, 947-961 Udden, J.A., Waite, V.V. (1927): Some microscopic characteristics of the Bend and Ellenburger limestones. - Texas University Bulletin, 27, 8 pp. Wilson, J.L. (1975): Carbonate facies in geologic history. 471 pp., Berlin (Springer) Further reading: KO02
2 Carbonate Depositional Environments
Knowing where modem carbonates occur, what they are composed of, and what their controls are is essential for evaluating microfacies data. The objectives of this chapter are to summarize the settings and environments in which carbonate sediments are formed and to document which classifications are used for differentiating these environments. Emphasis is placed on the definitions of terms. The potential of microfacies analysis in recognizing and interpreting the environments discussed in this chapter will be demonstrated later. If you want to know how to describe paleoenvironmental criteria, and which microfacies criteria can be used in deciphering the biological and depositional constraints on ancient limestones, have a look at Chap. 12 and 15.
Shallow-marine carbonate depositional systems differ fundamentally from siliciclastic depositional systems in their intrinsic controls, i.e. the growth potential including the 'aggregation potential' (the ability to grow vertically and to track sea level) and the 'production potential' (the ability to produce and export sediment). The aggradation potential is critical for the history of carbonate platforms and reefs, the production potential for the progradation and retreat of platforms. These differences are of central importance in the application of sequence stratigraphy to carbonates (Schlager 1992).
2.1.2 The 'Sorby Principle': Limestones are Predominantly Biogenic Sediments
Well over 90% or more of the carbonates found in modem marine environments are biological in origin, i.e. 2.1 Introduction the sediments are biotically induced (by an organic trigger, e.g. microbial micrites) or biotically controlled Microfacies analysis of carbonate rocks requires a (skeletal autotrophic and heterotrophic organisms deknowledge of modern carbonates and an understandtermine the composition, location and timing of caring of biological and geological changes during earth bonate production). Some of the 'abiotic' carbonate prehistory. R.N. Ginsburg's eloquent statement 'carbon- cipitation (represented by marine cements) is also trigate buildups are like Shakespeare; the plays go on - gered by organics or the activity of organisms. The only the actors change' emphasizes the remarkable simi- dominant role of organisms in the formation of limelarities and analogues in the criteria of modem and an- stones was recognized as early as 1879 by Henry Clifton cient carbonates. The aphorism, however, ignores the Sorby. Studying Paleozoic, Mesozoic and Tertiary carguiding role of the stage-managers who often decide bonate rocks in thin sections, he recognized the overthe basic mode of the play, similar to the changing geo- whelming abundance of fossils and their importance in logical and biological earth system parameters which the composition of carbonate sands and muds. The disshape the appearance of carbonate buildups. tribution and frequency of carbonate-producing organisms depend strongly on environmental factors, such as light, water temperature and sedimentary influx. 2.1.1 Carbonates are Born not Made These controls as well as the paleoenvironmental settings are reflected by microfacies criteria and paleonThis simple phrase by Noel James (1979) highlights tological data. the main theme of carbonate sedimentation and the differences between carbonate and siliciclastic sediments. Carbonates are 'born'. They originate as skeletal grains 2.1.3 Modern Carbonates: Obligatory or precipitates within the depositional environment. By Reading contrast, terrigenous clastic sediments are formed primarily by the disintegration of parent rocks and are There is a wealth of well-written reviews and concise transported to the depositional environment. updated syntheses of modem carbonate sediments (see
Marine Environments
8
CONTINENTAL, NON-MARINE
TRANSITIONAL MARGINAL-MARINE
MARINE Deep marine
Terrestrial, subaerially exposed Paleosols, caliche Caves and karst Coastal Eolian dunes lagoons, Glacial deposits Tidal flats Aquatic Freshwater tufa, travertine Freshwater and salt lakes Rivers
and reefs Ridge //// Basin ////////
Fig. 2.1. Settings of carbonate depositional environments.
list at the end of this section). The strength of these papers is that they outline the main criteria of recent marine and non-marine carbonates and their major controls in the context of interpreting ancient carbonate rocks. The information included in these fundamental texts is crucial for microfacies analyses. The 'Microfacies of Carbonate Rocks' does not intend to duplicate this information, but focuses on those data which are specifically relevant for microfacies studies.
2.2 Carbonate Sediments Originate on Land and in the Sea Carbonate sediments originate on land and in the sea. They are formed in three major settings: On the continents, within the transitional area between land and sea, and in the shallow and deep sea. Today only around 10 L;:, of marine carbonate production takes place in shallow seas. 90% of the modem carbonate production is related to the deposition of calcitic plankton in the deep sea. These proportions were very different during most parts of the Phanerozoic. Major depositional environments are shown in Fig. 2.1. Terrestrial and aquatic non-marine carbonates are receiving increasingly more attention from geologists because of their economic importance and their significance in paleoenvironmental analyses. These carbonates are discussed in Sect. 15.1 to 15.4. Owing to their very shallow-water setting, marginal-marine carbonates have been studied in great detail and offer a wealth of information on coastal sedimentation processes and diagenesis. About 70% of microfacies studies dealing with marine carbonates concerns shallow-marine carbonates formed on the shelf and near the shelf break. Future research should be focused on the huge deep-marine carbonate depositional regions on the continental slopes.
2.3 Classification of Marine Environments Marine environments are classified into the benthic, for the sea bottom, and the pelagic, pertaining to the water mass. There is no universally accepted scheme of subdivision of marine environments which is equally acknowledged by biologists, oceanographers and geologists. Fig. 2.2 summarizes categories that are frequently used. The categories are predominantly based on schemes proposed by Hedgpeth (1957) and Edwards (1979), who discuss marine terminology.
2.3.1 Boundary Levels Several levels at the sea bottom and within the water column are commonly used in a vertical subdivision of marginal-marine and marine environments (Box 2.1). Microfacies analysis provides the basic data for recognizing these levels in ancient carbonate rocks (see Chap. 12). Essential critical interfaces that control sedimentary patterns and the distribution of organisms are: (1) The lower and the upper boundaries of the tides (control the distribution of organisms), (2) the base of the photic zone (controls the distribution of light-dependent phototrophic organisms), (3) the base of the zone of wave abrasion (above which bottom currents and wave action may lead to erosion and cementation), (4) the base of the action of storms on the sea bottom, (5) the 0, minimum zone (strongly limiting life on and in the sea bottom), (6) the thermocline (the layer of water that is too cold for most carbonate-producing organisms), and (7) the pycnocline (the layer of water where salinity is too high for most organisms). High and low tide, wave base and storm wave base are used as basic boundaries in the classificationof the major shallow-marine environments.
Marine Zonations
Fig. 2.2. Marine depositional environments. Modified from Kennett (1982).
P E L A G W T E R A L ZONES
PELAGIC DEPTH ZONES
I
'Abyssopelagic \
Hadalpelagic
2.3.2 Vertical and Horizontal Zonations Subdivisions of marine environments are both vertical and horizontal:
2.3.2.1 Vertical Zonations Benthic depth zones: The depth of the sea bottom and critical levels controlling the sedimentation subdivide the benthic environments into six zones: (1) coastal sublittoral zone (above high tide, corresponding to the supratidal zone), (2) littoral (between high and low tide, identical with the intertidal zone), (3) sublittoral (below low tide, corresponding to the major part of the
continental shelf), (4) bathyal (approximately equal to the continental slope), ( 5 ) abyssal (corresponding to the abyssal plains), and (6) the hadal zone (deep-sea trenches). Modem carbonate sedimentation takes place within the range of zone 1 to parts of zone 5.
-> Geologists are in favor of the terms supratidal, intertidal and subtidal instead of the ecologically defined terms supralittoral, littoral and sublittoral. Pelagic depth zones: Five zones are defined by the vertical distribution of floating and swimming life. These are, in descending order, the epipelagic zone (the upper region of the oceans, extending to a depth of about 200 m), the mesopelagic, bathypelagic, abyssopelagic
Box 2.1. Glossary of terms used in the subdivision of marine environments. Fair-weather wave base (FWWB): Intersection of the wave base with submarine topography. The water depth below which surface wave action no longer stirs and moves the sediment. The depth of the wave base varies widely, depending on wave amplitude and fetch, bottom topography, activity of storms, orientation of shelves and ramps, latitudes etc. High tide: High water. The maximum height reached by each rising tide. Low tide: Low water. The minimum height reached by each falling tide. Mean sea level: The average height of the surface of the sea for all stages of the tide for a defined period. Storm wave base: See storm wave weather base. Storm wave weather base (SWWB): The water depth down to which storm-generated waves and resulting bottom currents rework bottom sediments and produce specific texture types (tempestites). The depth of the storm wave base varies strongly and depends on shelf and shelf edge topography, storm intensity and climate zone. Surf: a) The wave activity in the area between the shoreline and the outermost limit of breakers. b) A collective term for breakers. Tidal range: The difference in height between consecutive high and low waters. Tide: The periodic rise and fall of the sea resulting from the gravitational attraction of the moon and the sun acting upon the rotating earth and causing flood and ebb currents. Wave base: See fair-weather wave base.
10
(corresponding to oceanic environments below about 4 000 m), and hadopelagic zone. -> Note that the boundaries of the benthic and pelagic depth zones are not fixed accurately.These boundaries reflect the situation in modem oceans that are not necessarily equivalent to depth zones visualized for ancient oceans.
2.3.2.2 Horizontal Zonations The lateral distribution of pelagic organisms with respect to their distance from the coast characterizes two major zones of the ocean: The neritic zone is the water that overlies the continental shelf, today generally with water depth less than 200 m and covering about 8% of the ocean floor. The term oceanic zone refers to the water column beyond the shelf break, overlying the slope and the deep-sea bottoms, generally with water depths greater than 200 m and down to more than 10 000 m.
Depositional Environments Rao, C.P. (1996): Modem carbonates. Tropical, temperate, polar. - 206 pp., Howrah (Carbonates) Reading, H.E. (1996): Sedimentary environments, processes, stratigraphy.Thiid edition. - 688 pp., Oxford (Blackwell) Scholle, P.A., Bebout, D.G., Moore, C.H. (eds., 1983): Carbonate depositional environments. - Amer. Ass. Petrol. Geol. Mem., 33,708 pp. Scoffi, T.P. (1987): An introduction to carbonate sediments and rocks. - 274 pp., Glasgow (Blackie) Tucker, M.E., Wright, V.P. (1990): Carbonate sedimentology. - 482 pp., Oxford (Blackwell) Varney, M. (1996): The marine carbonate system. - In: Summerhayes, C.P., Thorpe, S.A. (eds.): Oceanography. An illustrated guide. - 182-194, New York (Wiley) Walker, R.G., James N.P. (eds., 1992): Facies models. Response to sea level change. - 409 pp., Ottawa (Geol. Ass. Canada) Wilson, J.L. (1975): Carbonate facies in geologic history. 471 pp., Berlin (Springer)
2.4 Review of Modern Carbonate Depositional Environments
-> Again, keep in mind that these water depths are not compatible with the situation in many ancient oceans. Note that the term 'neritic' is often used to describe sea bottom environments below the neritic water colun~n,or shallow-marine environments characterized by significant terrigenous influx.
The following review is focused on the definitions, main criteria and subdivisions of carbonate settings. The criteria that help recognize these settings and the evaluation of paleoenvironments in ancient carbonate rocks are discussed in Chap. 12 and 15.
Basics: Classification of carbonate environments and obligatory reading
2.4.1 Non-Marine Carbonate Environments
Classificatloiz Edwards, A.R. (1979): Classificationof marine paleoenvironments. - Geol. Soc. New Zealand Newsletter, 48, p. 48 Hedgpeth, J. (1957): Classification of marine environments. - In: Hedgpeth, J.E. (ed.): The treatise on marine ecology and paleoecology. Vol.1, Ecology. - Geol. Soc. America Mem., 67, 17-28 Kennett, J. (1982): Marine geology. - 813 pp., Englewood Cliffs (Prentice Hall) Nybakken, J.W. (1993): Marine biology. An ecological approach. Third edition. - 462 pp., New York (Harper Collins) Summerhayes. C.P., Thorpe, S.A. (eds., 1996): Oceanography. An illustrated guide. - 352 pp., New York (Wiley) Obligatory reading Bathurst, R.G.C. (1994): Carbonate sediments and their diagenesis. 2nd enlarged edition - Developments in Sedimentology, 12,660 pp., Amsterdam (Elsevier) Bosellini, A. (1991): Introduzione a110 studio delle rocce carbonatiche. - 317 pp., Ferrara (Italo Bovolenta) James, N.P., Kendall, A.C. (1992): Introduction to carbonate and evaporite facies models. - In: Walker, R.G., James N.P. (eds.): Facies models. Response to sea level change. - 265-275, Ottawa (Geol. Ass. Canada) Milliman J.D. (1974): Marine carbonates. - 375 pp., Berlin (Springer)
Non-marine carbonates originate in terrestrial and aquatic environments without marine influence. These carbonates, formed by abiotic and/or biotic processes differ in many aspects from marine carbonates, which are much better known to geologists. These carbonates are formed in terrestrial subaerially exposed settings and in submerged aquatic settings (Fig. 2.3). The major non-marine carbonate environments are listed in Box 2.2. Non-marine carbonatesformed in terrestrial subnerially exposed settings comprise pedogenic carbonates, palustrine carbonates, cave carbonates, eolian carbonates and glacial carbonates.
2.4.1 .I Pedogenic Carbonates, Paleosols, and CalichelCalcretes Terminology: The term pedogenic refers to soil genesis. Most pedogenic carbonates are formed withn soils rich in calcium carbonate. The termpaleosol describes 'a buried soil horizon of the geologic past' but is often
Non-Marine Environments
11
Non-marine continental environments Karst
Freshwater
Calcareous tufa
; Marginal marine I I I
environments
Peritidal zones
Fig. 2.3. Non-marine carbonate depositional environments.
used in a broader sense, embracing various descriptive terms associated with horizons of subaerial exposure (e.g. caliche). Important processes are chemical and physical weathering of host carbonate rock, soil development and accumulation of calcium carbonate within the soil by evaporation of saturated porewaters driven to the surface by capillary forces. These processes may result in a physicochemically and microbially controlled formation of hard crusts on the surface or in the upper horizon of soils (duricrusts). Depending on climatic conditions and the host substrate, the duricrusts consist of carbonate (forming calcretes or dolocretes) or other mineral phases (e.g. silica forming silcretes, gypsum -> gypscretes, hematite and goethite -> ferricretes). The following discussion is limited to near-surface accumulations of calcium carbonate (Low-Mg calcite) in terrestrial, alternating wet settings, generally called calcrete or caliche. These distinctive carbonates result
from multiple processes induced by life, climate and exchange between mineral phases: 'Calcrete' was proposed for calcareous-cemented deposits in Africa, the roots of the word caliche are Latin, meaning lime and limestones (Reeves 1976). Calcrete and caliche are used synonymously or separately (calcrete in order to describe highly indurated parts of caliche profiles). Other names are calcareous duricrust, cornstone, kalkar (Agarwal et al. 1992) or 'Krustenkalk'. These calcium-rich .soil accumulations cover an estimated 20 million km2 or about 13% of the total land surface (Yaalon 1988). They are widespread in temperate (e.g. Mediterranean),semiarid and arid climates, particularly in tropical and subtropical latitudes (e.g. Caribbean) with sparse rainfall and a mean annual temperature of about 18 "C. 'Calcicretes (syn. calcretes)' and 'dolocretes' can be differentiated.
Box 2.2. Carbonates originating in non-marine environments. Non-marine carbonates formed in terrestrial subaerially exposed settings Pedogenic carbonates, paleosols, calicheicalcrete: Formed by the accumulation of calcium carbonate within unconsolidated carbonate-rich soils. Palustrine carbonates: Carbonates formed in lacustrine and transitional non-marinelmarine environments originating by short-term oscillations of the water levels and characterized by a mixture of subaerial and freshwater facies criteria. Cave carbonates, karst: Formed by the precipitation of calcium carbonate within caves resulting in 'speleothems' (e.g. flowstones, dripstones). Eolian carbonates: Sedimentation of fine-grained, wind-born sand-sized carbonate material (-> eolianites). Glacial carbonates: Dissolution and recrystallization of glacially transported carbonate debris, occurs in glacial-marine deposits. Non-marine carbonates formed in terrestrial aquatic settings Freshwater carbonates: Travertine, calcareous tufa, calcareous sinter: Formation of carbonate deposits at warm, hot ore cold spring orifices in subaquatious settings (e.g. pools), by combined biotic and abiotic processes. Lacustrine carbonates: Deposition and precipitation of calcium carbonate in lakes of different salinity (freshwater lakes, salt lakes, playa lakes) and different settings. Fluvial carbonates: Carbonate deposits formed in rivers, creeks and waterfalls, originating from the combined activity of biotic and abiotic processes.
12
Important studies of pedogenic carbonates deal with late Pleistocene and Holocene calcretes on the Bahamas, Florida Keys, Yucatan, Barbados, Persian Gulf, Western Australia, and the Mediterranean (see Basics and references with Code K030). Calcareous paleosols typically contain a higher proportion of mineral insoluble residue than the enclosing limestone units. Two models have been developed for explaining the mechanisms that lead to the concentration of insoluble residue: (1) Selective dissolution and removal of calcium carbonate from carbonate host rock, and (2) accretion of wind-driven dust at the limestone exposure surface without major dissolution of the limestones (Multer and Hoffmeister 1968). Most authors favor the first explanation. Calcretes are defined as 'secondary accumulations of calcium carbonate (Low- and High-Mg calcite) in nearsurface settings, which result from the cementation and/or replacement of host material by the precipitation of calcium carbonate from soil water or ground water' (Wright 1990). In addition to the calcium carbonate derived from the host rock, eolian input is still an important factor (Goudie 1973). Currently, two basically different models are being discussed with respect to the formation of calcretes. The commonly held model, that calcretes are pedogene structures resulting from leaching of carbonate from the surface horizon, is questioned by the second model, claiming that calcretes are complex sedimentary formations that have undergone phases of deposition, pedogenesis, and transformation of sediments during early diagenesis heavily related to microbially influenced processes. According to the first model, calcrete is formed in the interior of a soil; according to the second model calcretes are accumulations that build up by aggradation from bottom to top (Verrecchia 1996). Classificafion: Calcretes are classified according (a) to their micromorphology and hydrological setting or (b) dolomite content (Netterberg 1978). Using micromorphological criteria, massive 'alpha calcretes' (exhibiting a dense pseudonodular microfabric with complex microcracks, microsparite and coarse-crystalline calcite, floating sediment grains (Pl. 128/6),and calcretes exhibiting microfabrics of biogenic (particularly fungal) origin, called 'beta calcretes', can be distinguished (Wright 1990).The latter group is characterized by microbial coatings, calcified tubules, Microcodium, alveolar septa1 fabrics, and needle fibre calcite (Pl. 128). Two calcrete types are differentiated according to their hydrologic setting: (1) Pedogenic calcretes derived from vertically percolating soil water and typically occumng in the form
Caliche
of well-horizonted soil profiles. Characteristic features are distinct profiles made up of a succession of different horizons and specific microfacies attesting to the presence of a vegetated soil cover. 'Rhizogenic calcretes' produced by calcification associated with plant roots occur in the fluvial sequences of floodplains (Wright et al. 1995), palustrine and lake margin areas with relatively high water-tables, on subaerially exposed marine carbonates (Wright 1994), in carbonate dunes (Hay and Reeder 1978) or in beachrock deposits. (2) Non-pedogenic calcretes, derived from laterally migrating groundwater and composed of well-indurated, variably extensive sheets of mottled carbonate (Goudie 1983). In contrast to the rather thin pedogenic calcretes (a few meters), these calcretes may have a thickness of more than 10 meters as shown by Australian examples. Compared with pedogenic calcretes, non-pedogenic calcretes are characterized by the absence of rhizoconcretions, black pebbles and peloids, and by more silica than carbonate.
Criticalfactors in theformation of caliche are (1) climate (a significant net annual moisture deficit in the soil; control on dust accretion caused by dust storms), (2) topography, (3) vegetation, (4) presence of carbonate and oxalic phases, (5) carbonate content, texture, porosity and permeability of the hosting substrate (ThCriault and Desrochers 1993), (6) action of microorganisms (Loisy et al. 1999) as well as (7) exposure time (which may range between a few tens of thousands, as shown by Holocene calcretes, and millions of years as suggested by Carboniferous calcretes). Vegetation is the main factor in rhizogenic calcretes (Klappa 1979; Wright et al. 1995) exhibiting textures which can be interpreted as calcification in, on or around roots: Intracellular calcification creates Microcodiumtype microstructures. Extracellular calcification around roots produces laminur rhizolites (Wright et al. 1988) consisting of vertical rhizoconcretions or as calcareous cementation around root mats (Pl. 2016). Incomplete calcification of root mats may be responsible for the formation of rhizogenic calcretes characterized by peloidal and coated grain fabrics (Calvet and Julia 1983). Exposure time, substrate composition and vegetation control the maturiq levels of calcrete profiles. Relatively mature levels can be recognized from the sequence of horizons forming the calcrete profiles and by the number of calcrete microfabrics (which increase with increasing maturity). A number of models for pedogenic calcrete profiles has been developed, focused on the progressive increase in the volume of secondary calcium carbonate within
Cave Carbonates
the host material (soil, sediment or rock) via a combination of cementation, replacement and displacement (Gile et al. 1966; Arakel 1982; Machette 1985; West et al. 1988; Rabenhorst et al. 1990). Diagnostic criteria of caliche andpaleocaliche: see Chap. 13 and P1. 1416, P1. 128, and P1 14119-10.
2.4.1.2 Palustrine Carbonates Palustrine limestones are deposits of shallow freshwater environments exhibiting extensive evidence of pedogenic modification (Pl. 48). These carbonates are common in many ancient continental and marginalmarine sequences. The term (derived from 'paludal', meaning marshy or swampy) was first proposed while describing late Cretaceous-Early Tertiary limestones in southern France (Freytet 1973,1984; Freytet and Plaziat 1982). Palustrine carbonates were originally considered as near-shore deposits of extremely shallow lakes with oscillating lake levels and densely vegetated shorelines. Because of a very low relief on the lake bottom, fluctuation in the water table should result in an interbedding of lacustrine facies (characterized by the occurrence of specific fossils), and pedogenic facies (characterized by textures which indicate a pedogenic overprint of dried-out parts of shores). This interpretation presents problems since many palustrine limestones are not associated with lake deposits. A suitable modern analogue for a palustrine environment may be the freshwater carbonate marshes of the interior Everglades in Florida (seasonal wetland model: Platt and Wright 1992). Seasonal variations in water depth and minor topographic variations across the area could explain the association of soil and calCrete criteria with dissolution features (pseudomicrokarst), and the presence of sublittoral carbonates which were formed in perennial shallow lakes within the wetland.
2.4.1.3 Cave Carbonates, Speleothems and Karst
Speleothems (carbonates formed in caves) are important paleoclimatic recorders documenting short- and long-term climatic fluctuations. Terminology: The term karst refers to physical structures formed by dissolution from meteoric waters. It includes 'all of the diagenetic features - macroscopic and microscopic, surface and subterranean - that are produced during the chemical dissolution and associated modification of a carbonate sequence' (Choquette
13
and James 1988). Karst develops (a) at the air-limestone or soil-limestone interface ('surface karst') and (b) within carbonate bodies ('subsurface karst'). Diagnostic features: Surface karst or exokarst is characterized by surface solution or corrosion features comprising small-scale and large-scale criteria (microkarst, residual paleosols, karren, solution pans or kamenitzas, and dolines or sinkholes). Large-scale geomorphological features (e.g. karst valley and karst towers) are responsible for characteristic landforms. Subsugace karst (see P1. 129) is represented by caves and vugs formed above, at and below the water table. Caves contain (a) secondary mineral deposits (porous calcareous tufa: moonmilk, and hard crystalline sinter or speleothems) precipitated by vadose and shallow phreatic waters and (b) internal cave sediments and karst breccia caused by the collapse of caves. Karst breccias exhibit a wide variety of internal composition depending on the site and the mode of origin (Sect. 5.3.3.3 and Sect. 15.2). Speleothems are precipitated from thin water films flowing over the rock and forming flowstones and dripstones, or in pools of water, forming 'cave pearls' (globoids, pisoids; vadoids: Chafetz and Butler 1980; Peryt 1983. See P1. 1418). Dripstones include stalagmites and stalactites as well as finely curved twiglike structures (helictites). Carbonate sinters are made up of calcite with various amounts of Mg, and/or aragonite,dolomite and rarer minerals (Gonzalez and Lohmann 1988; Tietz 1988). The mineralogical composition is often seasonally controlled; it depends on the MgICa ratio of the percolating pore-fluids, pC02, and evaporative conditions within the cave. Speleothems exhibit diagnostic cave cements (Folk and Assereto 1976; Kendall and Broughton 1978; Assereto and Folk 1980) which can be used in order to recognize ancient cave carbonates (Sect. 15.2.1).Common cement types in speleothems are length-slow and length-fast calcites and dendritic calcite crystals. Changes in mineralogical composition and cement types of vadose-zone speleothems may reflect short and long-ranging cyclic oscillations of climatic factors (Railsback et al. 1994; Shopov et al. 1994). There is increasing evidence for microbial contributions to the growth and fabric of speleothems (Danielli and Edington 1983; Jones and MacDonald 1989). Controls: Prerequisites for the formation of extant karst and cave systems are fluids that are undersaturated with respect to the country rock, and fluid flow transporting dissolution products (Lohmann 1988; Dreybrodt 1990). The most important intrinsic factors influencing karst development are the general lithol-
Travertine
14
ogy (including mineralogy, bulk purity, fabric and texture), stratal permeability, bedding planes, fractures as well as the existence of confined or unconfined aquifers and structural conduits. Limestones are several orders of magnitude more soluble than dolomites in meteoric waters. Major extrinsic factors are climate (rainfall and evaporation, temperature), base level (elevation and relief, sea level or local water bodies), vegetation and the duration of time involved in karstification. Different climatic conditions produce different karst types (James and Choquette 1988). Karst formed in areas of warm temperatures and high rainfall is characterized by the development of soils and terra rossa, abundant sinkholes, and dissolution-collapse breccia. In semiarid and temperate climates both karst and calcrete may occur together, depending on alternating wet and dry conditions (Esteban and Klappa 1983). The potential of microfacies studies for the recognition of ancient speleothems and karst and the significance of paleokarst in basin analyses is discussed in Sect. 15.2.
2.4.1.4 Eolian Carbonates
Terminology: The term eolianite has been coined for bioclastic wind-borne deposits that make up more than 9070 of the Pleistocene deposits of Bermuda (Sayles 1931). The term is now used for eolian sands that have been cemented by calcium carbonate in a subaerial environment. The coalescence of dunes results in linear ridges with large cross-bed sets which may stand a few tens of meters above the source beach. Glacial, interglacial and Holocene eolian carbonate dune deposits are known from Bermuda, the Bahamas, northeast Yucatan, California, the Trucial Coast, the Meditenranean (Mallorca, Tunisia, Israel) and western Australia. Generally modem eolianites are associated with coastal marine deposits and pedogenic carbonates. Wind can transport carbonate particles (ooids, microfossils) over wide distances (e.g. from Africa to the Caribbean). Recognizing carbonate eolianites: Summaries of features common among carbonate eolianites were given by McKee and Ward (1983) and Abegg et al. (2001). Important criteria are: (1) Grain texture - good overall sorting, fine- to medium-grained, fenestrae, sorting differences between laminae or beds. (2) Carbonate cements - vadose and phreatic Low-Mg calcite cements (PI. 212 and PI. 3 1/5,6) meniscus, pendant, needle-fiber, blocky, drusy). (3) Biota - plant structures (rhizoconcretions, calcified root systems of dune plants),
Microcodium, ichnofossils: crustacean and insect burrows, bioturbation; terrestrial gastropods. (4) Stratification - high- to low-angle beds, see Fig. 15.1. (5) Associated facies - upward-shallowing succession, shelf/ reef - beach grainstone - eolian grainstone. Grains are ooids or bioclasts, sometimes accumulations of particular foraminifera1 tests (forming the 'miliolite' of the Trucial Coast, a grainstone composed predominantly of miliolid foraminifera). Significance: The differentiation of wind-borne calcarenites from grainstones formed in marine environments is important because calcareous eolianites indicate carbonate shorelines, sea-level fluctuations (aragonite cements in eolianites indicate a later marine transgression; White 1995, San Salvador Island, Bahamas), paleoclimatic conditions and paleowind directions. 2.4.1.5 Glacial Carbonates The dissolution and recrystallization of glacially transported carbonate debris may result in the formation of micritic and sparitic carbonates, leading to a chemically distinctive carbonate matrix in meltout tills or subglacial crusts within glacial-marine deposits (Hallet 1976; Aharon 1988; Fairchild and Spiro 1990; Fairchild et al. 1993), which are also recorded in Precambrian and Phanerozoic glacial deposits. Enigmatic calcite pseudomorphs, known as glendonites and interpreted as pseudomorphs after ikaite, a metastable hexahydrate of calcium carbonate, were reported from some modem as well as ancient glaciomarine environments. Ikaite occurs in morgenstem-like and stellate aggregates, several centimeters in size, and indicates sub-zero temperatures at the seafloor. Glendonites are typically found in cold-water deposits dating from the Precambrian to the Pleistocene (Suess et al. 1982; Shearman and Smith 1985; Kemper 1987).
Non-marine carbonates formed in aquatic settings comprise freshwater carbonates, lacustrine carbonates and fluvial carbonates.
2.4.1.6 Travertine, Calcareous Tufa and Calcareous Sinter Origin: Travertine and tufa are freshwater carbonates formed as a result of physical and/or biochemical CO, degassing around carbonate- and C02-rich springs, along streams and in pools, and often precipitated together with and on cyanobacteria, bacteria, algae (Pl.
Travertine
2/6), mosses, and higher plants (Pl. 2/7) as well as on various organic and inorganic substrate. Cyanobacteria, bacteria and algae are able to trigger the precipitation of calcite and aragonite forming microbial travertines (Chafetz and Folk 1984; Folk et al. 1985). Millimeter- to centimeter-sized laminae (Pl. 2/1,2), and arborescent shrub-like calcite precipitates (Pl. 2/1), consisting of associations of micrite aggregates and rhombic spar crystals aggregates appear to be microbially controlled (Guo and Riding 1994). Stromatolitic travertine~exhibit alternating sparry and micritic laminae which are interpreted in terms of seasonality (Chafetz et al. 1991), climatic changes as well as changes in microbial and algal growth and sedimentation (Monty 1976). Travertines and tufa are often associated with higher plants (Pentecost 1990), but the ability of macrophytes to induce the precipitation of carbonate during photosynthesis is regarded as controversial. Consumption of CO, leads to carbonate precipitation in the immediate vicinity of photosynthesizing vegetation. Both field and laboratory studies show that the intensity of photosynthesis varies from least effective in springs and waterfalls to highly effective in lakes and rivers (Merz 1992).
inorganic precipitation
A organic precipitation
Fig. 2.4. Practical classificationof travertines, tufa and sinter (after Koban and Schweigert 1993).
2,3,5), tufa (Pl. 2/6,7) or sinter (PI. 214) (Schweigert 1996). Travertine often is used in a rather loose manner to designate hard and compact carbonate deposits; tufa for porous deposits. Many authors use travertine in a rather broad sense, covering all kinds of non-marine carbonates of springs, creeks, streams, pools and lakes, as well as caves (e.g. Julia 1983; Pentecost and Whitton 2000). More precise definitions were offered by Riding (1991): The term travertine is restricted to non-marine, Morphological differentiation: Travertine deposits ex- layered autochthonous carbonates deposited at thermal hibit distinctive morphologies (Chafetz and Folk 1984): springs and commonly exhibiting a bushy fabric (Pl. 21 1). Tufa refers to often conspicuously porous carbonWaterfall deposits, formed at sites of break-in slope ates, whose formation in non-marine cold-waters is of streams by the growth of plants and contempo- strongly controlled by aquatic plants. Calcareous sinraneous calcification, resulting in a massive, irregu- ters are characterized by well-developed lamination and lar contorted tangle of cement crusts and plant lack of visible porosity. Currently there is a tendency molds. to restrict the term travertine to thermal deposits (Ford Lake-fill accumulations, characterized by thick, and Pedley 1996; Fouke et al. 2000) formed at hot and horizontally stratified and laterally extensive trav- warm, often mineralized springs, and calcareous tufa ertine~.These are composed of thin summer layers to settings where calcium-rich waters bubble up from of (bacterial) shrubs intercalated with finely lami- springs to the earth, cool down and precipitate calcium nated winter mud layers and thicker, crudely lami- carbonate, supported by photosynthesizing plants. nated muds. Contorted zones composed of calcite rays, intraclasts and pisoids, represent spring oriHow to classify freshwater carbonates? Koban and fices on the lake bottom. Schweigert (1993) proposed a classification which reSloping mounds, fans and cones, characterized by flects the genetic factors responsible for the fabric of structures paralleling a slope at the time of deposi- non-marine freshwater carbonates (Fig. 2.4): The trition. angle underlines the inferred origin, setting and visible Terraced mounds, exhibiting a step-like morphol- porosity (see P1.2 for examples). ogy. Warm spring waters, flowing down both sides of Thermal travertines: Comparative studies of modfissure ridges. em thermal spring systems (Cady and Farmer 1996; Fouke et al. 2000) provide a basis for constructing faWhich names are appropriate? The terminology of cies frameworks which can assist in the interpretation freshwater-carbonates is controversial because of the of ancient travertines. The spectacular carbonate-premixed use of descriptive and genetic terms. This is par- cipitating thermal springs of the Mammoth Hot Springs ticularly true for carbonates called travertine (Pl. 211, in Yellowstone National Park, Wyoming, demonstrate
16
Travertine,Tufa, Sinter
Plate 2 Terrestrial Freshwater Carbonates: Travertine, Calcareous Tufa and Sinter Travertines, tufa and calcareous sinter are excellent paleoclimatic archives (Andrews et al. 2000). These carbonates and their corresponding water bodies can serve as analogues of Precambrian and Phanerozoic microbialites and their oceans (Arp et al. 2001). Travertines of hot springs are of interest for recognizing potential microbial signatures on Mars (Kempe and Kazmierczak 1997). Travertines are very important building stones that have been used since antique times (Winkler 1994). Many travertines and tufa originated during interglacial phases of the Pleistocene, but in places are still growing today. Terrestrial carbonates produced by precipitation in freshwater occur as travertines (->1-3,5), calcareous tufa (-> 6,7), and calcareous sinter (-> 4). Travertine is a layered deposit of calcium carbonate with moderate to high primary porosity, and often with a dendritic fabric. Calcareous tufa is an originally porous, laminated or massive deposit which commonly originates at cold subaerial springs, but also forms at subaquatic springs in soda lakes and highly alkaline salt lakes ('tufa pinnacles': Kempe et al. 1991; Benson 1994; Arp et al. 1998). Calcareous sinter is characterized by well-developed lamination and the lack of visible porosity. These carbonates orignate from degassing of CO, and HC03-caused by changes in temperature, pressure and photosynthesis. Travertine is often found on warm or mineralized hydrothermal waters, tufa on temperate waters. Tufa precipitation takes place on organic substrates (higher plants, algae, mosses) in freshwater. In both types carbonate chemistry and the temperature of the spring waters, the overall morphology of the accumulation and biologically induced processes are major controls. Characteristic textural criteria of freshwater limestones are (1) macroscopically visible voids (often corresponding to moulds and leaves of higher plants); (2) void-filling radiating calcite (-> 3); (3) small spar-filled cellular structures; (4) wavy and laminar layers (-> 1, 2); (3) concentric structures consisting of smooth and wavy laminae of micrite and sparite (-> 1); (5) alternating dark and light laminae with vertical thin 'filaments' (> 4); (6) layers with bubble structures (-> 1); (7) shrub-like structures (-> 1); (8) ovoid to subangular peloids with diameters from 50 to 300 pm, occurring in clumps or aggregates (-> 5); (9) travertine fragments occurring as intraclasts, and detrital grains derived from underlying or adjacent rocks; (10) pisoids (see P1. 1411). 1 Travertine. The name travertine is derived from the Latin lapis tiburtinus,meaning 'the stone of Tiburnium' (now Tivoli), a locality near Rome where these carbonate rocks have been quarried for more than two thousand years. At the 'type locality', the precipitation of carbonate occurs from spring waters. The importance of inorganic or organic (bacteriallyinduced) modes of precipitation is primarily controlled by water temperature and water chemistry (Chafetz and Folk 1984). In the Bagni di Tivoli locality, travertine occurs as stratified lake-fill deposits formed in shallow ponds.The travertine is composed of laterally continuous and vertical repetitions of layers with micritic shrubs (S; interpreted as result of bacterially induced precipitation) intercalated with laminated muds (-> 3). The shrubs nucleate on a substrate and grow and branch upward, indicating a phototrophic control. The bubbles (B) at the bottom may represent lithified gas-filled vesicles surrounded by bacterially precipitated walls or relics of chironomid insect larvae. The samples (-> 1 and 2) are classified as travertine according to the vadose setting, microbial-induced precipitation, and medium porosity (Fig. 2.4). 2 Travertine. 'Bacterial stromatolite'. Thin laminae aggregate into packets with large lenticular intermat cavities bulged up by large gas bubbles (B). Note the abundant micritic clumps within the mats (arrows) interpreted as bacterial aggregates embedded or surrounded by calcite crystals. Bagni di Tivoli near Rome. 3 Travertine. Laminated micrite layers bordering voids which are partly filled with bladed prismatic ('dogtooth', DC) calcite cement. Same locality as -> 2. 4 Calcareous sinter. The layers consist of fibrous cements arranged in bundles. The low-calcite sinter originated from carbonic acid-rich and calcium-rich mineral waters. The travertine was formed during warm interglacial periods in the Pleistocene. The sample is classified as calcareous sinter owing to inferred inorganic precipitation, low porosity and the vadose setting. Bad Cannstatt-Stuttgart, Germany. 5 Travertine. Peloids and bacterial mud reworked into intraclasts. Same locality as -> 2. 6 Recent freshwater tufa. The fabric is characterized by incrustations of oscillatoriacean cyanobacteria. The threads have a diameter of about 10 pm. Fossil Oscillatoriaceae are indicative of freshwater and brackish water environments. Schleierfalle, Ammer, southern Germany. 7 Modem freshwater tufa. Tufa deposition is controlled by a number of intervening factors including carbonate equilibrium, crystal nucleation, crystal morphology, and diagenesis (Ford and Pedley 1996; Merz-PreiR and Riding 1999: Jamsen et al. 1999). Note the porous texture and the plant stem (P) surrounded by euhedral calcite crystals some of which exhibit dark 'centers' (arrow) commonly interpreted as an indication of bacterial contributions to carbonate precipitation. The sample still fits into the triangle classification (Fig. 2.4) because of its high porosity, considerable organic contributions (-> 6) and origin in a phreatic setting. Same locality as -> 6.
I'latt. 2 T r a \ ' t . r r ~ n e ,T u t a , Sinter
17
Lakes
18
the distinctive control of travertine microfacies types and dominating organisms (eucaryonts, photosynthetic and chemosynthetic bacteria) by water temperatures and pH values (Farmer 2000). Pamukale near Denizli (southeastern Turkey) is another famous locality where thermal spring waters at a hill built, and still build, large rimstone pools of travertine while flowing down in cascades about 100 m of height difference. Because of the large surface of the very thin layer of water, the water looses deep-source carbon dioxide, resulting in carbonate precipitation. The resulting white travertines have been used since Roman times as building stones. The Turkish name Pamrnukale means 'cotton castle' and refers to the strikingly white color of the large steps.
fabric-selective porosity patterns. Changes in porosity, permeability, specific surface, and water sorption due to the dissolution and precipitation of calcite within pores lead to a decrease in porosity and increase in rock hardness with time (Koch et al. 1999). The rapid precipitation of carbonate favors the preservation of fossil faunas and floras, and of archeological artifacts. Chronological dating of Pleistocene travertine~aids greatly in the age determination of prehistoric archeological material (Kahlke 1984).
2.4.1.7
Lacustrine Carbonates: Lakes
Lacustrine environments differ from marine environments in the properties, kinetics, chemistry and productivity of lake waters as well as in the sedimentation Phytoherms: Plant-dominated freshwater calcareous patterns originating in hydrologically open and hydrotufa, formed in river systems, are called 'phytoherms' logically closed lakes. Lakes are dynamic systems. (Cipriani et al. 1977; Pedley 1987, 1992) underlining Short-term and long-term changes in climate, water the dominant role of macrophytes and procaryotechemistry and bathymetry of lakes result in significant microphyte biofilms in the construction of carbonate variations of litho- and biofacies, and their lateral and buildups (Collinson 1988). Phytoherms of river sysvertical distribution patterns. tems, capable of damming the water courses to produce chains of lakes (e.g. Plitvica region, Croatia: Emeis Our review focuses on the carbonates formed in et al. 1987), are characterized by rapid growth in cool, lakes. Carbonates are only a part of lacustrine sediments, agitated waters. Continuous water circulation is neceswhich in addition, often include claystones, mark and sary for bringing in nutrients and providing replenishalso sandstones. The review neglects the siliciclastic ment of CaCO, for the extensive precipitation of Lowsediments as well as some chemical deposits (cherts, Mg-calcite cements within organic frameworks. The phosphorites). primary frameworks are provided by the in-situ growth Lacustrine carbonates are a specific type of terresof erect and trailing hydrophytes and semi-aquatic mactrial carbonate deposited within a lake or at the shorerophytes. Secondary frameworks are formed by oscillalines of a lake. Fluctuating shorelines may result in a toriacean cyanobacteria, diatoms and insect larvae colopedogenic overprint of lacustrine sediments leading to nizing exposed surfaces. The shelly fauna associated the formation of 'palustrine carbonates' (Sect. 2.4.1.2), with the phytoherms contains ostracods, gastropods, which were defined as 'near-shore deposits of extremely rare bivalves and crustaceans. shallow lakes with oscillating lake levels and densely The stability of these bioconstructions and also their vegetated shorelines' (Freytet and Plaziat 1982). Frepreservation in the fossil record is provided by a conquently, lake deposits are associated with paleosols as comitant development of thick Low-Mg calcite calcite well as with fluvial sediments. cements (micrite fringes and bladed calcite spar fringes) Because wind-driven currents and waves often do and by an intra-frame sediment infill. Both micritic not affect the lake bottom, lake waters tend to become fringe cements and the abundant small-scaled peloids permanently or seasonally stratified:Warmer and lighter are interpreted as the product of biological mediation waters (epilimnion) overlie colder and denser waters associated with a procaryote-microphyte biofilm and of the bottom zone (hypolimnion). These zones are the presence of organic detritus. separated by a zone characterized by a rapid rate of Significance: Travertines are important building and change of temperature with depth (mesolimnion). Perdecoration stones, used since antique times. High qual- manent stratification is characteristic of tropical ity travertine possesses a great mechanical strength and oligomictic lakes with temperature stratification and of remarkable resistance to weathering as compared with merornictic lakes in which the bottom water has a higher other building stones. Technological qualities of trav- salinity than the surface water. In both cases, the botertine~are strongly controlled by depositional facies tom water can become completely stagnant and be deand early diagenesis. Differences in technological prop- pleted of nutrients and oxygen, resulting in the accuerties of travertines and tufas are primarily caused by mulation of laminated muds rich in organic matter.
Lakes
Seasonal stratification is common in temperate climates. During the summer, surface waters are warmer and less dense than deeper waters. Cooling of the surface waters during the winter or an underflow by cool waters caused by rivers crossing the lake will produce surface waters of the same or higher density than that of the bottom waters. Consequently, the lake water body is turned over once or twice yearly and mixed (monomictic or dimictic lakes; tropical and polar lakes). Both near-surface waters and bottom waters are well-oxygenated, enabling a seasonal biogenic production (e.g. algae), which may be recorded by annual varves consisting of fine-grained siliciclastics, biogenic silica and carbonate formed in the deeper parts of the lakes. Fine-scale lamination, caused by the seasonal precipitation of carbonates or periodic influxes of sediment into lakes, is a common feature of both freshwater and saltwater lakes. Biologically induced precipitation of light carbonate laminae alternating with dark organic-rich laminae and/or detrital laminae form varved sediments in the deeper parts of many lakes.
Profundal zone: Aphotic zone. Often, but not always corresponds to the zone below the thermocline. Pelagial zone: Open-water, planktic zone.
Carbonates infreshwater lakes result from: Removal of C 0 2 by photosynthesis of plants (microbes, algae, floating phytoplankton, macrophytes), less commonly by changes in temperature, evaporation or mixing of water masses, resulting in the precipitation of Low-Mg calcite. Basin-wide carbonate blankets are produced in larger and deeper stratified lakes resulting from a seasonal change of algal blooms and sedimentationof organic matter, diatoms and detrital components, producing couplets of light carbonate-rich laminae and dark organic-rich laminae. Deposition of 'algal sediments', algally-coated grains (e.g. oncoids; P1. 1215, P1. 13115) and of characean oogonia (Pl. 65) in nearshore shallow parts of the littoral zone and accumulation of carbonate shells (e.g. gastropods, bivalves, or ostracods; P1. 130/2,3) in deeper parts of the littoral zone, resultOpen and closed lakes: Freshwater and salt lakes ing in biogenic sedimentation. Differences in the composition of the algal carbonates may reflect the Lakes are classified according to their salinity. Freshgenerally well-defined zonal distribution of vegetawater lakes usually contain
5 g/ Growth of stromatolitic bioherms (Pl. 13111) or 'al1. The setting of lakes in hydrologically open or hydrogal reefs' (Pl. 13011). logically closed basins as well as the chemistry of lake Input of allochthonous carbonate particles derived waters is used in separating major types of lacustrine from the drainage basin and deposited by debris environments (Allen and Collinson 1986): flows and turbidity currents in deeper part of the lake. (1) Hydrologically open lakes (freshwater lakes) Early diagenetic precipitation of carbonates (nonhave an outlet, relatively stable shorelines and are filled marine carbonate cements; Chafetz et al. 1985). with meteoric lake waters. They are characterized by the input of siliciclastic sediments in nearshore and offCase studies: Europe: Lake Constance, Germany: shore zones as well as by inorganic/biochemica1 and (Miiller 1971; Schafer and Stapf 1978; Dominik 1981); biogenic deposition of calcareous sediments in the shal- Eifel, Maar Lakes, Germany (Negendank et al. 1990); lower littoral zone and the deeper profundal zone. Most Lake Zurich and Lake Biel, Switzerland (Kelts and Hsu freshwater lakes are fed by rainfall; the salinity, there- 1978; Wright et al. 1980); Austria: Behbehani et al. fore, is low. Sedimentation patterns vary in response to (1986); North America: Green Lake, New York State changes in depositional regimes and source areas (Calvo (Eggleston and Dean 1976); Minnesota Lakes (Megard et al. 1989). Hydrologically open freshwater lakes are 1967; Murphy and Wilkinson 1980). The Green Lake normally perennial and occur mainly in temperate hu- exhibits wave-resistant stromatolite bioherms, formed mid climates. The subdivision of lake environments is by cyanobacteria and mosses trapping carbonate sedibased on biological criteria and embraces the follow- ment, and subsequent cementation by precipitated caling zones (Wright 1990): cium carbonate. Lake Michigan is an impressive exLittoral zone: Below the wave base, characterized ample of facies differentiation in a typical northern temby rooted macrophytes. The eulittoral zone is the perate hard-water lake. area between the highest and lowest sea levels, the supralittoral zone corresponds to the landward zone, (2) Hydrologically closed lakes (salt lakes) lack an which is rarely submerged. outlet. They are common in regions with semi-arid Sublittoral zone: Still within the photic zone, colo- warm and hot climates. If evaporation of the lake wanized by algae and cyanobacteria. ter is about equal to inflow, a permanent water body is
Lakes
maintained (perennial lake). If the evaporation exceeds inflow for a long time, salinity and the MgjCa ratio of the water will increase, as Ca is depleted by early-stage precipitates. Finally salts will be precipitated in these shallow 'salt lakes' and 'soda lakes' which normally fall dry, with the exception of a central pond containing highly concentrated brines (ephemeral lakes, playa lakes: Last 1993). High and extreme salinities can originate from a separation of former parts of the sea (e.g. separation of the Caspian Sea from the Mediterranean Sea), prolonged evaporation of lake waters, or increased input of dissolved salts. Case studies: Mono Lake, Death Valley, California; Great Salt Lake, Utah (Eardly 1966; Halley 1976); seamarginal ponds of the eastern Mediterranean e.g. Solar Lake, Israel (Krumbein and Cohen 1974; Friedman 1978); sea-marginal flats in the Red Sea, Gulf of Elat and Aqaba (Sneh and Friedman 1985); Australia: (De Deckker 1988); Lake Clifton (Burne and Moore 1983); Lake Thetis (Grey et al. 1990); Coorong Lagoon (Rosen et al. 1988). One of the most intersting saline lakes is the Dead Sea whose bottom sediments consists of precipitated aragonite, gypsum and halite, and detrital grains (Garber et al. 1987). Many hydrologically closed lakes are characterized by fringes of supralittoral mudflats (commonly termed 'playa' or 'inland sabkha'), sandflats in the nearshore zone, and depositions of mixed siliciclastic-evaporitic sediments as well as organic-rich sediments ('oil shales') within the lakes. Saline minerals are precipitated in perennial brines, as efflorescent crusts and salt pans and as cements within the sediments of the mudflats. Climatic changes may turn freshwater lakes into saline water bodies, as exemplified by the history of the modern Great Salt Lake, Utah, or the great lakes in the East African rift system.
waters on the playa surfaces cause supersaturation with respect to calcite, resulting in the formation of pisoids and carbonate encrustations (Risacher and Eugster 1979), ~ ~ d i o t h e r mfluids a l emerging from the lake bottom may produce sinter crusts consisting of aragonite and magnesium calcite (Lake Tanganyika, East-Central Africa: Cohen and Thouin 1987, Stoffers and Botz 1994).
Compositional characteristics of lake carbonates Similar to marine carbonates, lacustrine carbonates are composed of allochthonous and autochthonous constituents, the former represented by skeletal and nonskeletal grains and fine-grained calcite mud caused by seasonal phytoplankton blooms ('Seekreide': Schafer 1973), the latter by predominantly biogenic structures (stromatolites,bioherms and 'reefs') formed or induced by cyanobacteria and algae. All major grain categories known from marine carbonates also occur in lacustrine settings.
Biota: Differences exist in the inventory of the biota. Common organisms are (a) calcareous algae (charophycean algae, see Sect. 10.2.1.8 and PI. 65; planktonic and benthic green algae, see Pl.l3O/l) and cyanobacteria, siliceous algae (diatoms), (b) gastropods and bivalves, cf. P1. 13012, 3, (c) ostracods (see PI. 130/2), and (d) arthropods that are responsible for the production of abundant peloids. Otherwise marine organisms, e.g. foraminifera, also may occur in salt lakes. These ~narinebiota are transported by wind and may thrive in lakes if environmental conditions are favorable (Lee and Anderson 1991). Bioturbation and bioerosion are very important processes modifying the depositional texture of lacustrine sediments (Schneider 1977, Schroder et al. 1983). Cat-horzates in saltwater lakes are characterized by: Peloids and reworked and redeposited sedimentary Precipitation of High-Mg calcite and aragonite (e.g. fragments (intraclasts,lithoclasts) are common constituDead Sea) or Low-Mg calcite and High-Mg calcite ents. Small ooids and large oncoids (PI. 1311.5) are of (e.g. Lake Balaton, Hungary) because of the increase specific interest in microfacies studies of ancient lacustrine limestones because these grains may aid in the in the MgICa ratio, differentiation of non-marine and marine settings. Formation of carbonate laminites, consisting of CaOoids occur in marine as well in non-marine setMg carbonates, detrital quartz, silicates and organic tings (PI. 13/1), they are known from low- and highlayers, Ooid sands are formed in shallow, near-shore areas saline environments. Ooids are not common in recent of' current- or wave-swept lakes, sometimes ( e g freshwater lakes. Ooids originating in salt lakes have been described from the Great Salt Lake, Utah (Eardley Great Salt Lake, Utah) associated with Algal bioherms, composed of mm-scale laminated 1966; Kahle 1974; Sandberg 1975; Halley 1977; PI. 1312) and the Pyramid Lake, Nevada (Popp and Wilkinmicritic aragonite or of porous carbonate, Loss of COzby degassing or photosynthesis of spring son 1983).Ooids formed in a temperate 'marl' lake were
Fluvial Carbonates
reported from Michigan (Wilkinson et al. 1980). Saltwater and freshwater ooids exhibit differences in the morphology, microfabrics and mineralogy of the cortical layers, and in size ranges. The same is true for oolitic carbonate particles formed in situ in hypersaline algal mats (Friedman et al. 1973). These differences offer the possibility of tracing the development of ancient freshwater- and saltwater lakes (Sect. 4.2.5). Lacustrine oncoids have been described by various names (algal nodules, water biscuits, lake balls, lacustrine pisoliths) for many years (Pia 1926,1933, Schafer and Stapf 1978, Jones and Wilkinson 1978; P1. 1215). The origin of these grains is related to the activity of algae and microbes (Sect. 4.2.4.1). Cyanobacteria are known or assumed to be essential in the formation of these oncoids. Modem oncoids are not restricted to freshwater environments but also occur in brackish and hypersaline waters. Today, oncoids are rare in tidal and shallow subtidal marine environments. Recent marine oncoids are non-lithified, as opposed to modem hard freshwater oncoids that are closely similar to Paleozoic and early Mesozoic marine oncoids. This may be related to the replacement of porostromate oncoids by spongiostromate oncoids in marine settings during the Jurassic. Stromatolites occur both in freshwater and salt lakes. The stromatolites are usually domes, passively paving the relief of the substrate and reacting to environmental controls like currents. Stromatolites of less saline lakes are composed of calcium carbonate whose precipitation is induced by algalbacterial activity. Trapping of clastic particles, widely known from modern stromatolites, appears to be only of secondary importance. Stromatolites of saline lakes are well-known from hypersaline lakes in Utah, Nevada and California as well as from the San Salvador Island, Bahamas (Mann and Nelson 1989). The stromatolites have complicated microstructures consisting of micrite, pellets, filament molds and casts as well as sparry calcite. Lacustrine stromatolites contribute to the growth of 'algal mounds' as demonstrated by the 'reefs' described from the Great Salt Lake in Utah, which exhibit a nonskeletal framework of algally induced aragonite precipitates, internal sediments and carbonate cements, and cover about 100 square kilometers of the nearshore areas. The mounds extend from the shoreline down to a depth of 4 m; they are surrounded by rippled ooid sand. Coccoid bluegreen algae on the present-day living surface are different from the filamentous algae recognizable in the indurated stromatolites. The change in the algal flora may be due to an increase in salinity.A similar pattern is known from the famous intertidal stromato-
21
lites of Shark Bay in western Australia. Spectacular meter-sized strornatolites consisting of hydromagnesite were described from the highly alkaline Salda Golu Lake in Southern Turkey (Braithwaite and Zedef 1996). The composite stromatolites originate from microbially induced precipitation of hydromagnesite, which is possible because of the dissolution of magnesium and calcium during the passage of water through ultramafic rocks.
2.4.1.8 Fluvial Carbonates Carbonate deposits originate in fluvial waters in various settings including small creeks, large rivers or waterfalls where tufa is formed. Stromatolites,oncoids and ooids in present-day creeks and streams are usually formed by the complex activity of algae, mosses and microbes (Nickel 1985; Galli and Sarti 1989). Fluvial oncoids and ooids differ in morphological and compositional criteria as well as in transport patterns (Verrecchia et al. 1997) from marine grains and are, therefore. valuable environmental indicators. Basics: Non-marine carbonates Esteban, M., Klappa, C.F. (1983): Subaerial exposure environment. -In: Scholle, P.A., Bebout, D.G., Moore, C.H. (ed.): Carbonate depositional environments. - Mem. Am. Ass. Petrol. Geol., 33, 1-54 Etheridge, F.G., Flores, R.M. (eds., 1981): Recent and ancient nonmarine depositional environments: models for exploration. - Soc. Econ. Paleont. Min. Spec. Publ., 31, 349 pp. James, N.P., Choquette, P.W. (1990): Limestone - The meteoric diagenetic environment. - In: McIlreath, LA., Morrow, D.W. (eds.): Diagenesis. - Geoscience Canada, Reprint Series, 4,35-73 Pia, J. (1926): Pflanzen als Gesteinsbildner. - 355 pp., Berlin (Borntraeger) Pia, J. (1933): Die rezenten Kalksteine. - MineralogischPetrographische Mitteilungen, Neue Folge, Erganzungsband, 420 pp., Leipzig Further reading: KO28
Pedogenic carbonates, caliche, paleosols Esteban, M.C. (1975): Vadose pisolites and caliche. - Amer. Ass. Petrol. Geol. Bull., 60, 1048-1057 Klappa, C.E (1983): A process-response model for the formation of pedogenic calcretes. - In: Wilson, R.C.C. (ed.): Residualdeposits.-Geol. Soc. London Spec. Publ., 11,211220 Reeves, C.C. (1976): Caliche. Origin, classification, morphology and uses. - 233 pp., Lubbock, Texas (Estacado Books) Reinhardt, J., Sigleo, W.R. (1988): Paleosols and weathering through geologic time: principles and application. - Geol. Soc. America Spec. Paper, 216, 181 pp. Retallak, G.J. (2001): Soils of the past. Second edition. 416 pp., Oxford (Blackwell)
Basics: Non-Marine Carbonates
Wright, V.P. (ed., 1986): Paleosols. Their recognition and interpretation. - 3 15 pp., Oxford (Blackwell) Wright, V.P., Tucker, M.E. (1991): Calcretes. - Reprint Series Int. Ass. Sed., 2,352 p., Oxford (Blackwell) Further reading: KO30 Cave carbonates, speleothems and karst Borsato, A., Frisia S., Jones B., Van der Borg, K. (2000): Calcite moonmilk: crystal morphology and environment of formation in caves in the Italian Alps. - J. Sed. Research, A70, 1171-1182 Chafetz, H.S., Butler, J.C. (1980): Petrology of recent caliche, pisolites, spherulites and speleothem deposits from central Texas. - Sedimentology, 27,497-518 Drybrodt, W. (1988): Processes in karst systems - physics, chemistry, geology. - Springer Series in Physical Environments, 4, 288 pp., New York (Springer) Folk, R.L., Assereto, R. (1976): Comparative fabric of lengthslow and length-fast calcite and calcitized aragonite in a Holocene speleothem, Carlsbad Cavem, New Mexico. J. Sed. Petrol., 46,486-496 Frisia, S., Borsato, A., Fairchild, I.J., McDermott, F. (2000): Calcite fabrics, growth mechanisms, and environments of formations in speleothems from the Italian Alps and southwestern Ireland. - J. Sed. Research, A70, 1183-1196 Choquette, P.W., James, N.P. (eds., 1988): Paleokarst. 4 16 pp., New York (Springer) Fritz, R.D., Wilson, J.L., Yurewicz, D.A. (eds., 1993): Paleokarst related hydrocarbon reservoirs. - Soc. Econ. Paleont. Min. Core Workshop, 275 pp. Klinchouk, A.B., Ford, D.C., Palmer, A.N., Dreybrodt, W. (eds., 2000): Speleogenesis: evolution of karst aquifers. 527 pp., Huntsville (National Speleological Society) Mylroie, J.E., Carew, J.L., Vacher, H.L. (1995): Karst development in the Bahamas and Bermuda. -In: Curran, H.A., White, B. (eds.): Terrestrial and marine geology of Bahamas and Bermuda. - Geol. Soc. America Spec. Paper, 300, 2.5 1-267 Purdy, E.G. Waltham, I). (1999): Reservoir implication of modem karst topography.-Amer. Ass. Petrol. Geol. Bull., 83, 1774-1794 Thrailkill, J. (1976): Speleothems. - In: Walter, M.E. (ed.): Stromatolites. - 73-86, Amsterdam (Elsevier) Tietz, G.F. (1988): Zur Genese rezenter Karbonatbildungen in Dolomithiihlen Frankens. -Karst und Hohle, 1988, 7-79 Further reading: KO3 1
Eoliun carhonutcs Abegg, F.E.R., Harris, P.M., Loope, D.B. (eds., 2001): Modem and ancient carbonate eolianites: sedimentology, sequence stratigraphy and diagenesis. - SEPM Spec. Publ., 71,214 pp. Bigarella. J.J. (1972): Eolian environments: their characteristics, recognition, and importance. - Soc. Econ. Paleont. Min. Spec. Publ., 16, 12-61 Brookfield, M.E. (1992): Eolian systems. - In: Walker, R.G., James, N.P. (eds.): Facies models. Response to sea level change. - 143-156, Ottawa (Geol. Ass. Canada) Caputo, M.V. (1995): Sedimentary architecture of Pleistocene eolian calcarenites, San Salvador Island, Bahamas. - Geol. Soc. America Spec. Paper, 300,63-76 McKee, E., Ward, C.W. (1983): Eolian environment. - In: Scholle, P.A., Bebout, D.G., Moore, C.H. (eds.): Carbon-
ate depositional environments. - Amer. Ass. Petrol. Geol. Mem., 33, 131-170 Pye, K. (1994): Aeolian sediments: ancient and modem. Spec. Publ. Int. Ass. Sedimentologists., 16, 192 pp. Sayles, R.W. (1931): Bermuda during the Ice Age. - American Academy of Arts and Sciences, 66,381-468 Further reading: K 032 Glacial carbonates Edwards, M.(1986): Glacial environments. - In: Reading, H.G. (ed.): Sedimentary environment and facies. - 445470, Oxford (Blackwell) Eyles, N., Eyles, C.H. (1992): Glacial depositional systems. -In: Walker, R.G., James, N.P. (eds.): Facies models. Response to sea level change. - 73-100, Ottawa (Geol. Ass. Canada) Fairchild, I.J., Bradby, L., Spiro, B. (1993): Carbonate diagenesis in ice. - Geology, 21,90 1-904 Fairchild, I.J., Spiro, B. (1990): Carbonate minerals in glacial sediments: Geochemical clues to paleoenvironment. -In: Scource, J.D., Dowdeswell, J.A. (eds.): Glacimarine environments and processes. - Geol. Soc. London Spec. Publ., 53,241-256 Suess, E., Balzer, W., Hesse, K-F., Miiller, P.J., Ungerer, C.A., Wefer, G. (1982): Calcium carbonate hexahydrate from organic rich sediments of the Antarctic shelf: precursors of glendolites. - Science, 216, 1128-1131, Washington Shearman, D.J., Smith, A.J. (1985): Ikaite, the parent mineral of jarrowite-type pseudomorphs. - Proc. Geol. Ass. London, 96,305-314, London Further reading: K210 Calcareous tufa and travertine Andrews, J.E., Pedley, M., Dennis, P.F. (2000): Paleoenvironrnental records in Holocene Spanish tufas: a stable isotope approach in search of reliable climatic archives. Sedimentology, 47,961-97 1 Arp, G., Wedemeyer, N., Reitner, J. (2001): Fluvial tufa formation in a hard-water creek (DeinschwangerBach, Franconian Alb, Germany). - Facies, 44, 1-22 Chafetz, H.S., Folk, R.L. (1984): Travertines: depositional morphology and the bacterially constructed constituents. - J. Sed. Petrol., 54, 289-316 Folk,, R.L., Chafetz, H.S. (1983): Pisoliths (pisoids) in Quaternary travertines of Tivoli, Italy. - In: Peryt, T.M. (ed.): Coated grains. - 47 1-487, Berlin (Springer) Ford, T.D., Pedley, H.M. (1996): Areview of tufa and travertine deposits of the world. - Earth-Science Reviews, 41, 117-175 Irion, G., Miiller, G. (1968): Mineralogy, petrology and chemical composition of calcareous tufa from the Schwabische Alb, Germany. - In: Miiller, G., Friedman, G.M. (eds.): Recent developments in carbonate sedimentology in central Europe. - 157-17 1, Berlin (Springer) Julia, R. (1983): Travertines. -In: Scholle, P.A., Bebout, D.G., Moore, C.H. (eds.): Carbonate depositional environments. - American Association of Petroleum Geologists Mem., 33,64-72 Koban, C.G. (1993): Faziesanalyse und Genese der quartken Sauerwasserkalke von Stuttgart, Baden-Wiirttemberg. Profil, 5,47-118 Koban, C.G., Schweigert, G . (1993): Microbial origin of travertine fabrics. Two examples from southern Germany
Basics: Non-Marine Carbonates (Pleistocene Stuttgart travertines and Miocene Ried- Picard, M.D., High, L.R. (1981): Physical stratigraphy of ancient lacustrine deposits. - In: Ethridge, F.G., Flores, R.M. ijschingen travertine). - Facies, 29,251-264 (eds.): Recent and ancient nonrnarine depositional enviPedley, H.M. (1990): Classificationand environmental modronments: models for exploration. - Soc. Econ. Paleont. els of cool freshwater tufas. - Sed. Geol., 68, 143-154 Pedley, M. (1992): Freshwater (phytoherm) reefs: the role of Min. Spec. Publ., 31,233-259 biofilms and their bearing on marine reef cementation. - Platt, N.H., Wright, V.P. (1991): Lacustrine carbonates: fac i e ~models, facies distribution and hydrocarbon aspects. Sed. Geol., 79,255-274 - In: Anadon, P., Carrera, L., Kelts, K. (eds.,): Lacustrine Pedley, M. (2000): Ambient temperature freshwater microbial tufas. - In: Riding, R.E., Awramik, S.M. (eds.): Mifacies analysis. -Spec. Publ. Intem. Ass. Sedimentologists, crobial sediments. - 177-186, Berlin (Springer) 13,55-74, Oxford Pentecost, A., Whitton, B.A. (2000): Limestones. - In: Renault, R.W., Last, W.M. (eds., 1994): Sedimentology and Whitton, B.A., Potts, M. (4s.): The ecology of cyanobacgeochemistry of modem and ancient saline lakes. - Soc. Econ. Paleont. Min. Spec. Publ., 50,334 pp. teria. - 257-279, Dordrecht (Kluver) Renault, R.W., Jones, B. (2000): Microbial precipitates around Sermya, C., Pollingher, U. (1983): Lakes of the warm belt. 569 pp., New York (Cambridge Univ. Press) continental hot springs and geysers. - In: Riding, R.E., Awramik, S.E. (eds.): Microbial sediments.- 187-195, Ber- Talbot, M.R., Kelts, K. (eds., 1989): The Phanerozoic record lin (Springer) of lacustrine basins and their environmental signals. Palaeogeogr., Palaeoclimat., Palaeoecol., Special Issue, 70, Riding, R. (199 1): Classification of microbial carbonates. In: Riding, R. (ed.): Calcareous algae and stromatolites.304 pp., Amsterdam Torgersen, T. De Deckker, P., Chivas, A.R., Bowler, J.M. 2 1-51, Berlin (Springer) (1986): Salt lakes: a discussion of processes influencing Schweigert, G. (1996): Vergleichende Faziesanalyse, Palaopaleoenvironmental interpretations and recommendation okologie und,palaogeographisches Umfeld tertiiirer SiiBfor future studies. - Palaeogeogr., Palaeoclimat., Palaeowasserkarbonate auf der westlichen SchwabischenAlb und im Hegau (Baden-Wiirttemberg). - Profil, 9, 1-100 ecol., 54,7-19 Wright, V. P. (1990): Lacustrine carbonates. -In: Tucker, M., Further reading: KO29 Wright, V.P. (eds.): Carbonate sedimentology. - 164-189, Lacustrine carbonates Oxford (Blackwell) Allen, P.A., Collinson, J.D. (1986): Lakes. -In: Reading, H.G. Further reading: K025, K026, KO27 (ed.): Sedimentary environments and facies. Second edition. - 63-94, Oxford (Blackwell) Anadon, P., Carrera, L., Kelts, K. (eds., 1991): Lacustrine Fluvial carbonates facies analysis. -Spec. Publ. Intem. Ass. Sed., 13,318 pp. Galli, G., Sarti, C. (1989): Morphology and microstructures of Holocene freshwater-stream cyanobacterial stromatoAnderson, R.Y., Dean, W.E. (1988): Lacustrine varve formalites (Villa Ghigi, Bologna, Italy). - Rev. Paleobiol., 8, 39tion through time. - Palaeogeogr., Palaeoclimat., Palaeo49 ecol., 62,2 15-235,Amsterdam Dean, W.E., Fouch, T.D. (1983): Lacustrine environment. - McGamon, D.E. (1975): Primary fluvial oolites. - J. Sed. Petrol., 45,7 19-727 In: Scholle, P.A., Bebout, D.G., Moore, C.H. (eds.): CarNickel, E. (1985): Carbonates in alluvial fan systems. An apbonate depositional environments. - Amer. Ass. Petrol. proach to physiography, sedimentology and diagenesis. Geol. Mem., 33,97-130 Sed. Geol., 42,83-104 Forester, R.M. (ed., 1987): Paleo-lacustrine theme issue. Ordonez, S., Garcia Del Cura, M.A. (1983): Recent and TerPalaios, 2,412-522 tiary fluvial carbonates in Central Spain. - In: Collinson, Eugster, H.P., Hardie, L.A. (1978): Saline lakes. -In: Lerman, J.D., Lewing, J. (eds.): Modem and ancient fluvial sysA. (ed.): Lakes. Chemistry, geology, physics. - 237-293, Int. Ass. Sedimentologists Spec. Publ., 6,485-497 tems. Berlin (Springer) J. (1999): Fluvial sedimentology VI. Smith, N., Rogers, Friedman, G.M., Krumbein, W. (1984): Hypersaline exoInt. Ass. Sedimentologists Spec.Publ., 28,488 pp., Oxford systems. -Ecological Studies, Analysis and Synthesis, 35, Verrecchia, E.P., Freytet, P., Julien, J., Baltzer, F. (1997): The 500 pp., Berlin (Springer) unusual hydrodynamical behaviour of freshwater oncolites. Hakanson, L., Jansson, M. (1983): Principles of lake sedi- Sed. Geol., 113,225-243 mentation. - 3 16 pp., Berlin (Springer) Katz, B.J. (ed., 1990):Lacustrine basin exploration. Case studies and modem analogs. - Mem. Amer. Ass. Petrol. Geol., Palustrine carbonates 50,340 pp. Freytet, P., Plaziat, J.-C. (1982): Continental carbonate sedimentation and pedogenesis - Late Cretaceous and Early Kelts, K., Talbot, M. (1990): Lacustrine carbonates as geochemical archives of environmentalchange and biotic/abiTertiary of southern France. - Contributions to Sedimenotic interactions. - In: Tilzer, M.M., Sermya, C. (eds.): tology, 12,213 pp., Stuttgart Large lakes: ecological structure and function. - 288-3 14, Monty, C.V., Hardie, L.A. (1976): The geological significance Berlin (Springer) of freshwater bluegreen algal marsh. - In: Walter, M.R. Matter, A., Tucker, M.E. (eds., 1978): Modem and ancient (ed.): Stromatolites. -Developments in Sedimentology, 20, lake sediments. - Int. Ass. Sedimentologists Spec. Publ., 447-477, Amsterdam (Elsevier) 2,290 pp., Oxford Platt, N.H. (1992): Fresh-water carbonates from the Lower Freshwater Molasse (Oligocene, western Switzerland). Picard, M.D., High, L.R. (1972): Criteria for recognizing lacustrine rocks. - In: Rigby, J.K., Hamblin, W.K. (eds.): sedimentology and stable isotopes. - Sed. Geol., 78,8 1-99 Recognition of ancient sedimentary environments. - Soc. Platt, N.H., Wright, V.P. (1992): Palustrine carbonates and the Florida Everglades: towards an exposure index for the Econ. Paleont. Min. Spec. Publ., 16, 108-145
24
Transitional Marginal-Marine Sediments
freshwater environment. - J. Sed. Petrol., 52, 1058-1071 Modem carbonate coastal and offshore environments Wright, V.P., Platt, N.H. (1995): Seasonal wetland carbonate can be described by two models, the beach-banier issequences and dynamic catenas: a re-appraisal of palusland-lagoon model and the beach-strandplain model trine limestones. - Sed. Geol., 99,65-71 (Reinson 1984, Tucker 1990). The first model develFurther reading: K 030 ops inregions with moderate to high wave energy, relatively high tidal range and high carbonate sand production resulting in barriers and sand shoals and ridges. 2.4.2 Transitional Marginal-Marine The beach-strandplain model is also characterized by Environments: Shorelines and Peritidal high wave energy and high sand production rate, but Sediments low tidal range. Most modem carbonate shoreface-foreMarginal-marine environments (deltas, beaches and shore-backshore environments are dominated by skelbarrier-islands, estuaries, coastal lagoons and tidal flats) etal grainstones composed of skeletons of organisms occur in a narrow nearshore zone along the boundary living in these environments and in small coastal patch between continental and marine depositional realms. reefs; ooid grainstones are common in some regions. Coastal lagoons differ in sediment production and The shoreline is marked by great environmental instabiota. Protected lagoons with varying salinities behind bility resulting from intensive interaction between highenergy forces related to waves, tides, wind, and cur- beach bamers (islands or off-shor sand bars) are sites rents and constantly changing sea levels. Water energy, for the deposition of fine-grained sediments forming sediment transport and resulting sediment structures packstone through to mudstones; the biota are low-dichange across the shoreline from offshore to shoreface versity. Open lagoons connected to the open sea via and foreshore environments. Carbonate deposition takes tidal inlets and with a normal salinity contain a diverse place in the coastal shoreline zone at the beach, in fauna and a variety of sediment types. Freshwater coastal lagoons behind bamers, and within the periti- marshes, tidal flats, brackish water and salt ponds or dal zone. Sediments formed in arid and humid shore- sabkhas may occur adjacent to the lagoons. line environments differ in depositional patterns, composition and biota (Sect. 15.5). Key areas for the understanding of modem carbon- 2.4.2.2 Peritidal Environments ate shoreline sedimentation are the Yucatan Peninsula, Florida Bay, the Bahamas, Belize shelf, the Arabian Peritidal carbonates are sediments formed 'around the tides' (Folk 1973, Wright 1984) and include deposits Gulf, and western Australia. Excellent reviews of the environments, depositional formed in supratidal, intertidal and shallow subtidal arpatterns and facies sequences in these areas are given eas (Box 2.3). The term describes sedimentation on lowby Inden and Moore (1983) and Tucker (1990). Par- energy tidal zones, especially on tidal flats accreting ticularly handy overviews of modem peritidal carbon- from the shorelines of land areas or around islands, and ates were presented by Shinn (1983), Hardie and Shinn on shelves, platforms and ramps. Hardie and Shinn (1986) defined ten basic features characterizing tidal(1986), and Pratt et al. (1992). flat deposition:
2.4.2.1 Beach (Foreshore), Barriers and Coastal Lagoons The beach is strongly wave-dominated and constantly changing. Sediments are produced by the influx from rivers, erosion of cliffs and headlands,erosion of the sea floor, accumulation of shells and the depostion of nconsoliated sediment by tides. A common feature of low-ltitude warm-water beaches is the presence of beachrock (Scoffin and Stoddard 1983). Beachrock originates from the rapid cementation of sand grains and gravels by aragonite and Mg-calcite crystals growing in intergranular pores. Beachrocks are formed both in tropical (see PI. 3/7,8; P1.3313, PI. 35/1,2) and temperate environments (Pl. 3 1/3,4, P1. 9212).
(1) Carbonate tidal flats occur in settings which are protected from open ocean waves. Protection from the open ocean can be caused by wide shelf lagoons, dampening the incoming waves (e.g. Andros tidal flats on the Great Bahama Banks), a position behind barrier islands that separates back reef lagoons from the open ocean (e.g. Abu Dhabi, Persian Gulf), or within restricted embayments (e.g. Shark Bay, Australia). (2) The basic physiography of the tidal-flat system is determined by the scale of the tidal ranges. (3) Tidal flats are subdivided into three depositionalecological zones by the daily oscillations of the tides (Box 2.3). (4) Tidal flats are partly sea and partly land. They are affected by steep gradients of environmental con-
25
Peritidal Encironrnents
I
Box 2.3. Criteria of peritidal and subtidal zones. Supratidal zone (supralittoral): Shore zone above normal high tide, flooded only during storms and semi-monthly high spring tides. The zone includes marshes, mangrove forests and diverse coastal ponds of different salinity. May become evaporitic in arid or semiarid climates. Evaporitic supratidal flats are called sabkhas. The width of this zone depends on the relief and dip of the coasts. Intertidal zone (littoral, eulittoral): Near-coast zone between normal high- and low-tide levels which is alternatively flooded and exposed on a diurnal or semi-diurnal basis. Transitional area from marine to terrestrial conditions, dotted with brackish and saline ponds and dissected by subtidal creeks. This zone exhibits a variety of biological, sedimentary and diagenetic criteria. Because many of these criteria are preserved in the geological record, ancient intertidal carbonates are of major importance as key markers in facies studies. Subtidal zone (sublittoral, circalittoral): Marine zone below low-tide level, seaward of the tidal flats, extending down to the edge of the continental shelf and underlying the neritic zone. Water depths between a few decades of meters and 100 to 200 m. Includes low- and high-energy environments. The shallowest parts can be influenced by tidal currents and may be briefly exposed by serni-monthly neap tides. The zone is illuminated and includes shallow and deep subtidal subenvironments. Subdivisions are predominantly based on the distribution and composition of benthic biota.
ditions resulting in an extreme rich variety of sedimen- Basics: Modern transitional environments tary, early diagenetic and paleontological featurs re- Ginsburg, R.N. (ed., 1975): Tidal deposits, a case book of Recent examples and fossil counterparts. - 428 pp., Bercorded in carbonate rocks. lin (Springer) (5) Owing to the large number of combinations of Hardie, L.A. (ed. 1977): Sedimentation on the modem tidal circulation, salinity, tides and climate, care must be flats of Northwest Andros Island. - John opkins University Studies in Geology, 22,202 pp. taken, to use just a sngle 'model' in describing ancient Hardie, L.A., Shim, E.A. (1986): Carbonate depositional entidal deposits. vironments, modem and ancient. Part 3. Tidal flats. - Colo(6) Tidal flats are wave-protected and, therefore prefrado School of Mines Quarterly, 81, 1-74 erential sites for the accumulation of mud. Offshore Inden, R.F., Moore, C.H. (1983): Beach environment. - In: mud is transported shoreward onto tidal flat currents Scholle, P.A., Bebout, D.G., Moore, C.H. (eds.): Carbonate depositional environments. - American Asociation of and storms, and mud can also be produced on supratidal Petroleum Geolists Memoirs, 33, 21 1-265 flats. Pratt, B.R., James, N.P., Cowan, C.A. (1992): Peritidal car(7) Carbonate tidal flats nucleate on a continental bonates. -In: Walker, R.G., James, N.P. (eds.):Facies modmainland (Persian Gulf), isolated islands with a lagoon els. Response to sea level change. - 303-322, Ottawa (Geo(Florida Bay), and platform-margin islands (Great Balogical Association Canada) Shinn, E.A. (1983): Tidal flat environments. - In: Scholle, hama Banks). P.A., Bebout, D.G., Moore, C.H. (eds.): Carbonate depo(8) Warm and clear waters of shallow tropical envisitional environments. - American Association of Petroronments are conducive to the profilific growth of alleum Geolists Memoir, 33, 171-210 gal and microbial mats which influence carbonate depo- Shinn, E.A. (1986): Modem carbonate tidal flats: their disition by binding, trapping and precipitation in supraagnostic features. -Colorado School of Mines Quart. 81,735 and intertidal zones. Neumeier, U. (1999): Experimental modelling of beachrock (9) Early cementation is crucial in the preservation cementation under microbial influence. - Sedimentary Geolof primary structures and textures. ogy, 126,35-46 (10) Carbonate tidal-flat facies typically occur as Wright, V.P. (1984): Peritidal carbonate facies models: a restacked cycles, each ideally composed internally of an view. - Geological Journal, 19,309-325 upward succession of subtidal to intertidal to supratidal Wright, V.P.: (1990): Peritidal carbonates.-In: Tucker, M.E., Wright, V.P.: Carbonate sedimentology. - 137-164, Oxunits. Peritidal environments exhibit a high degree of variability in relation tothe tidal range, mean sea level, topographic position and meteorological factors acting within each zone. To overcome these problems, Ginsburg et al. (1977) have proposed the use of an 'exposure index' defined as the percentage of the time that a specific area is exposed. This approach also can be applied to ancient tidal carbonates (Sect. 15.5).
ford (Blackwell) Further reading: K019, KO20
2.4.3 Shallow-Marine Sedimentary Environments: 'Shallow' and 'Deep' Geologists reconstructing ancient depositional environments like to distinguish between marine 'shallow-water' and 'deep-water' carbonates, but have a lot of
Shelfs, Ramps, Platforms
26
RIMMED PLATFORM
UNRIMMED PLATFORM
Wave
'Deep sea' as used in marine biology to mean that part of the marine environment that lies below the level of effective light penetration for phytoplankton synthesis in the open ocean (photic zone), and deeper than the depth of continental shelves (corresponding approximately to > 200 m). The upper part of the deep sea retains some light (disphotic zone). The permanently dark region below sunlit waters is the aphotic zone which starts in temperate waters at rather shallow depths (about 100 m), and in tropical waters at deeper depths (about 600 m).
2.4.3.1 Pericontinental vs Epicontinental Shallow Seas
Fig. 2.5. Rimmed and non-rimmed carbonate shelves (platjbrms) and ramps (slightly modified after James and Kendall 1992). Note the different position of the 'carbonate factories' at the seafloor. Carbonatefactories (James 1979) are subtidal areas characterized by high carbonate production by predominantly benthic organisms. The optimum autochthonous carbonate production on rimmed platforms occurs near the platform margin and behind the margin. On ramps optimum areas of carbonate production are distributed over the entire extension of the ramp. Rimmed and unrimmed platforms are common in tropical and subtropical sunlit waters, today approximately 30" N and S of the equator, where the carbonate factory is primarily controlled by high water temperatures favoring phototroph carbonate-secreting organisms. Ramps are common in cool-water zones, extending polward from the limit of the tropical factory to polar latitudes, and characterized by the dominance of heterotroph organisms (Sect. 16.4). Schlager (2000) differentiated a third carbonate factory (mud mounds), characterized by the in-situ production of biotically induced and abiotic carbonate mud.
trouble doing so. Microfacies analysis assists in overcoming these difficulties (see Sect. 12.3). Common criteria used by marine geologists and biologists in distinguishing 'shallow-marine' from 'deepmarine' environments in modem oceans are the shelf break and the lower boundary of the well-illuminated zone. Another important boundary level is the storm wave weather base (see Box 2.1). Shallow seas occur above the continental shelf and include marginal-marine and marine environments, both in pericontinental and epicontinental settings. Deep-marine sea bottom environments are located on the slope, at the toe-ofslope and within basins.
Most modem shallow seas cover shelves around the margins of the continents. These pericontinental seas differ strongly from the epicontinental (epeiric) setting of many ancient shallow seas. Epeiric seas occupied extensive areas of the continental interior or the continental shelf. They differ from pericontinental seas with regard to wave and current regimes, sediment input and sea level controls. Modem examples of epeiric shelf seas are rare in contrast to the geological record, where epeiri carbonate platforms and ramps were common. 2.4.3.2 Carbonate Shelves, Ramps and Platforms Carbonate depositional models developed in the 1960s and early 1970s were strongly based on modem analogues from the Bahamas, Florida, the Yucatan and the Persian Gulf (Wilson 1975). These models describe sedimentation patterns onshelves characterize by the deposition of shallow-water sediments on flat platform tops, and by significant rims marked by reefs or shoals near the shelf break. Ahr (1973) noted that the 'rimmed shelf' model does not fit many ancient carbonate successions, and that a different model was necessary, especially for the epeiric shallow-water carbonates (Irwin 1965). The term carbonate ramp was adopted to describe a gently sloping depositional surface which passes gradually without slope break from a shallow, high-energy environment to a deeper, low-energy environment. A ramp is attached to a shoreline at one end and to correlative basinal beds at the other end. Fig. 2.5 exhibits the basic differences between immed and unrimmed shelves (platforms) and ramps with respect to the position of the optimum carbonate production (carbonate factory) and sediment transport.
27
Shelves, Ramps, Platforms
Carbonate Platforms: Broad Categories Rimmed carbonate shelves
Rimmed carbonate shelves (Ginsburg and James 1974): Shallow pericontinental flat-toppedplatforms.Outer wave-agitated edge characterizedby morphological rims (barrier reefs, shoals, islands) that absorb wave action and a pronounced break of slope into deeper waters. Rimmed shelf margins comprise accretionary, bypass and erosional margins. High-energy facies occurs predominantly at the outer shelf margin. Widths typically a few to about 100 km. Modern examples: Queensland Shelf off eastern Australia with the Great Barrier Reef, South Florida Shelf, Belize Shelf, Gulf of Suez.
Non-rimmed carbonate shelves
Non-rimmed carbonate shelves: Shallow platforms without a pronounced marginalbarrier. Characterized by open water circulation. The term includes 'open carbonate platforms' as well as carbonate ramps. Widths a few to more than 100 km. Modern examples: western Florida, Yucatan, Brazil. Atlantic, common in cool-water settings.
.............................
. :.'I:.:::.::. :.: .......... .................... ...... :.....:.. :
z..:.:.
Homoclinal ramps
Homoclinal ramps (Read 1982): Shallow epeiric and pericontinentalplatforms charac::.:;..:: ...,:.::,....;.'...:.:::..:,:;i:.:i.>;..;:::.::' . . . . ..:. terized by gentle uniform depositional slopes, .................. . ..........:.:.Y..~-:.:..+:..... .... passing downwards from a shallow nearshore high-energy facies offshore into a more muddy deeper-water facies without a marked break in slope. The angle of slope is commonly less than 1"(of the order of a few meters per kilometer), but steeper dips may occur. Width between 10 and > 100 km. Modern examples: Trucial Coast of the Arabian Gulf, Shark Bay of Western Australia.
--------------*-----------------M---
Distally steepened ramps
Distally steepened ramps (Read 1982): Similar to homoclinal ramps, but with a distinct increase in gradient in the outer, deep ramp region. Width between 10 and 100 km. Modern examples: Northeastern Yucatan, western Florida.
-1 ........ ...... .. ...:-.:. ....... ..
Epeiric platforms
Epeiric platforms (Shaw 1964): Very extensive, flat, cratonic areas covered by shallow . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ;. . .................... . . . . . " . .;:.. .. : seas. Dmlinated by shalbw subtidal-intertidal low-energy facies and tidal flat cycles. The oceanward margin can be gentle (ramp-like) or steep (shelf-like), and can be rimmed. Width between 100 and 10 000 km. No good modern examples of epeiric platforms exist.
...................................... <.::......................................... . . . .:. . . . :...:.:.. .::. ..........:....:... '
Isolated platforms
Oceanic atolls ,-------------------------------------------
Drowned platforms
...........................................
Fig. 2.6. Carbonate platforms: Broad categories.
Isolatedcarbonate platforms: Isolatedor detached shallow-water platforms, offshore from continental shelves surrounded by deep water. Platform margins partly with reefs and sand shoals, platform interior with low-energy facies and tidal flats. Most isolated platforms have steep margins and slopes into deep and very deep water. Widths between 10 and 100 km. Modern examples: Bahama Bank, Glovers reef1Belize. Oceanic atolls: Formed on extinct, subsiding volcanoes that rise several hundreds to thousands of meters from the deep ocean floor. Characterized by raised reefal rims, steep outer slopes and low coral islets encircling shallow and deep lagoons with pinnacle reefs. The circular or elliptical structures are surrounded by- deep . water of the open sea. Atolls range in diameter between less than 1 km to more than 130 km. ~ o d e r examples: n Maldive Islands, Indian Ocean. Common in the western and central Pacific Ocean. Drownedcarbonate platforms (Schlager 1981): Rapid sea-level rises, strong subsidence, or drastic reduction in carbonate productivity as result of environmental stress can cause complete or incipientdrowning of rimmed shelves, ramps and isolated platform. Pelagic platforms are drowned fragments of an ancestor shallow-marineplatform. Modern examples: Atolls in the Pacific and Indian Ocean, Blake Plateau north of the Bahamas.
28
Shelves and Ramps
Box 2.4. Lateral classification of carbonate shelves (Wilson and Jordan 1983) and carbonate ramps (Burchette and Wright 1992). Carbonate shelves Inner shelf: Near-coast tide-dominated zone including peritidal and shallow subtidal environments varying and restricted salinity; sluggish circulation; biota low-diverse. Mid-shelf: Extended shallow subtidal zone between the near-shore area and the shelf break, below fair-weather wavebase, but above storm-wave base; mud-dominated but with grainy storm sediments; water depths between a few tens of meters and 100 to 200 m; normal marine, but different conditions in local restricted areas; biota high-diverse. Outer shelf: Rimmed shelves: A nmow zone near the shelf break, with shoals and reefs. Non-rimmed shelves: A wide zone below normal storm-wave base which may be affected by intruding ocean currents. Carbonate ramps Inner ramp: Between upper shoreface (beach or lagoonal shoreline) and fair-weather wave base; seafloor more or less constantly affected by wave agitation; includes shoreline deposits, sand-shoals, and back-barrier peritidal sediments. Mid-ramp: Between fair-weather wave base and storm-wave base. The bottom is frequently reworked by storm waves and swells. Sediment composition and textures reflect proximal-distal trends. Outer ramp: Below normal storm-wave base, down to the basin plain. Mud-dominated, but with few storm beds. In deeper zones, restricted bottom conditions may develop.
Today the terms shelf, ramp and platform are used in describing the setting and depositional geometry of shallow-marine carbonates, but some confusion still exists with reard to the definition of these terms: Originally, the term platform described shallow-marine carbonate bodies with flt tops and steep flanks, formed by the accumulation of sediment on the shelf or in the ocean. Today the trm often is used rather loosely for thick, often lat-topped sequences of shallow-marine carbonates. Steep-sided flanks are not necessarily definition criteria. Many authors regard carbonate platform as a very general term that includes ramps, shelves and various types of flat-topped platforms or they use the term if they cannot yet make an assignment to any of these categories. 'Carbonate shelf' characterizes a carbonate depositional system which develops a constructional relief above the sea floor and is bordered on the shoreward side by marginal-marine or continental sediments, and offshore by slope and basinal sediments. The transition from shallow water to basin occurs over a relatively short distance and is marked by a distinct break in the slope. In this definition the term means the same as 'attached platform' a term, sometimes used for platform settings starting at the coast and continuing offshore. One of the major tools of microfacies studies is the understanding of ancient facies belts and depositional areas related to particular marine settings (Chap. 14). This aim requires the differentiation of well-defined categories. Fig. 2.6 exhibits sketches and definitions of broad categories of shallow-marine depositional settings. The figure illustrates definitions used by Ahr (1973, 1998), Ginsburg and James (1974), Schlager
(1981), Enos 1983), Wilson and Jordan (1983), Read (1982, 1985), Harris et al. (1985), Wright and Burchette (1998), and relies on the excellent reviews by Tucker (1985), Tucker and Wright (1990), Jones and Desrochers (1992), and Burchette and Wright (1992).
Lateral subdivision of shelves and ramps Carbonate shelves and homoclinal carbonate ramps are laterally subdivided into at least three parts (Box 2.4). Recognizing the various parts of ramps (Fig. 2.7) is important for using the 'standard microfacies' approach (Sect. 14.3). The differentiation of inner and mid ramp environments can be strongly improved if the deree of storm, wave, or tidal influence is considered. The identification of sediments, deposited in a 'basin' adjacent to the outer ramp of homoclinal or distally steepened ramps is difficult. The lack of coarse tempestites and the absence of turbidites can be used as diagnostic criteria. Sediments in shallow basins, but also in restricted basins and outer ramp settings may be strongly bioturbated (and, therefore, be mistaken for lagoonal facies). In distally steepened ramps the slope break is commonly located around the mid- or outer ramp. The corresponding 'outer slope' would form an appropriate additional subdivision of ramps (Burchette and Wright 1992).
2.4.3.3 Shelf Margins The boundary between the shelf and the continental slope is marked by the 'shelf break', a point at the shelf edge where a significant change in gradient occurs in the outermost edge of the continental shelf (Stanley and
29
Reefs
COAST
I
INNER RAMP
Peritidal
MID-RAMP
I
OUTER RAMP
I
-
BASIN
I
Mean sea level
Fair-weather wave base Storm wave base
mentation
Coarse-grained, storm layers intercalated in finegrained sediments
Depositional water energy
Low and high
Low
High
Low
Sedimentary structures
Lamination Irregular bedding, bioturbatm
Prevailing carbonate texture in limestones
Mudstones, WackeGrainWackebindstones, stones, stones, stones grainstones mudstones packstones
Cross-bedding
Pycno-/Thermocline
Fine-grained, resedimented, graded storm layers, intercalated in fine-grained sediments
Low and high
Hummocky. cross-stratifcation
Low
Bioturbation, lamination
Wackestones and resedimentedgrainlpackstones, mudstones
Fine-grained sediments Low
Lamination
Mudstones, bindstones, grainstones
Fig. 2.7. Generalized subdivision of carbonate ramps. Compare with Box 2.4.
Moore 1983). Carbonate shelf-slope breaks are stationary, offlap or onlap. Many carbonate shelf and ramp margins are characterized by reefs or by sand banks (Wilson 1974; Halley et al. 1983; James and Mountjoy 1983) which are the line source provenance of most deep-water resedimented carbonates (Schlager and Chermak 1979). Platform margins are subdivided into depositional margins, by-pass margins and rimmed margins. Depending on the geometry of the shelf margin and the declivity of the slopes, depositional and by-pass margins and slopes can be differentiated. Depositional margins exhibit a low relief from platform to slope and basins; by-pass margins are characterized by a steeper relief triggering the deposition of most platform-derived sediment on lower slopes, toe-ofslopes and in adjacent basin plains. The recognition of margin types with microfacies: See Sect. 15.7.
2.4.3.4 Reefs
Reefs are singled out from the broad spectrum of marine environments because of the dominating role of benthic organiss in the formation of these structures. Modem reefs originate predominantly in shallow-marine environments,but are also formed in deeper positions on the slope and even in basins. Contradictory long-held opinions that reefs are more or less confined to tropical and subtropical, low-latitude warm-water zones and the new knowledge that modem and ancient reefs can also be formed in mid- and high-latitude tem-
perate and cold waters has been increasing (see Sect. 16.4). Reefal carbonate production is generally considered as an essential factor in the formation of carbonate platforms (Bosscher and Schlager 1993; Kleypas 1997), but this opinion has recently been questioned (Kiessling et al. 2000). Reefs and their eminent role in the development of carbonate depositional systems are discussed in Chap. 14. Box 2.5 contains a glossary of some of the (too) many terms used in the context of reef studies. Basics: Modern shallow-marine carbonate environments Ahr, W.M. (1973): The carbonate ramp: an alternative to the shelf model. -Transact. Gulf Coast Ass. Geol. Soc., 23.22 1-225 A h , W.M. (1998): Carbonate ramps, 1973-1996: a historical review. - In: Wright, V.P., Burchette, T.P. (eds.): Carbonate ramps. - Geol. Soc. London Spec. Publ., 149, 7-14 Burchette, T.P., Wright, V.P. (1992): Carbonate ramp depositional systems. - Sed. Geol., 79, 3-57 Crevello, P.D., Wilson, J.L., Sarg, J.F., Read, J.F. (eds., 1989): Controls on carbonate platform and basin development. Soc. Econ. Paleont. Min. Spec. Publ., 44,405 pp. Enos, P. (1983): Shelf environment. - In: Scholle, P.A., Bebout, D.G., Moore, C.H. (eds.): Carbonate depositional environments. - Amer. Ass. Petrol. Geol. Mem., 33, 267296 Halley, R.B., Harris, P.M., Hines, A.C. (1983): Bank margin environment. - In: Scholle, P.A., Bebout, D.G., Moore, C.H. (eds.): Carbonate depositional environments.-Amer. Ass. Petrol. Geol. Mem., 33,463-506 Harris, P.M., Moore, C.H., Wilson, J.L. (1985): Carbonate depositional environments. Modem and ancient. Part 2: Carbonate platforms. -Colorado School of Mines Quart., 80, 1-60
30
Tropical and Non-Tropical Carbonates
Box 2.5. Glossary of terms used in distinguishing major reef types. Bioherm: Mound or lens-shaped reefal buildup. Biostrome: Tabular rock body, usually a single bed of similar composition. Laterally extended, dense growth of skeletal organisms. No depositional relief. A rigid framework may or may not be present. Buildup: A carbonate rock mass that is thicker than laterally equivalent strata, and probably stood above the sea floor during some or all of its depositional history. The term is often very loosely used for reefs, banks or thick massive limestone structures. Ecologic reef: An ancient reef interpreted as having been built by organisms into a rigid, wave resistant, topographic high on the sea floor (Dunham 1970). Framework reef: Built by organisms forming a rigid calcareous frame. Microbial mound: Biogenic mounds, formed by the action of microbes which initiate carbonate precipitation, and bind and trap sediment (James and Bourque 1992). Mound: A rounded hill-like structure. In the context of reef studies used for counterparts of framework reefs. See microbial mounds, skeletal mounds and mud mounds. Mud mound: Mud-dominated carbonate buildups (Wilson 1975). Organisms are minor constituents. Syndepositional relief. Reef: Laterally confined biogenic structures, developing due to the growth or activity of sessile benthic organisms and exhibiting topographic relief. This broad definition covers framework reefs, reef mounds, mud mounds as well as biostromes (Fliigel and Kiessling 2002). Reef mound: Lenticular carbonate bodies consisting of bioclastic mud with minor accounts of organic binding (James 1980). Skeletal organisms are common, but there is no evidence for a prominent in situ skeletal framework. Lime mud/carbonate cement and skeletal organisms are about equally important. Syndepositional relief. Skeletal mound: Biogenic mounds made of small delicate skeletal or encrusting organisms that are thought to baffle, trap, bind and stabilize lime mud (James and Bourque 1992). Skeletal reef: Corresponds to framework reefs with organisms, forming a rigid calcareous framework. Stratigraphic reef: A thick, laterally restricted mass of carbonate rock, without genetic connotations (Dunham 1970).
Hottinger,L. (1989): Conditions for generating carbonate platforms. - Mem. Soc. Geol. Ital., 40,265-271 Iru in, M.L. (1965): General theory of epeiric clear water sedimentation. - Amer. Ass. Petrol. Geol. Bull., 49,445-459 James, N.P., Bourque, P.-A. (1992): Reefs and mounds. - In: Walker, R.G., James, N.P. (eds.): Facies models. Response to sea level change. - 323-348, Ottawa (Geol. Ass. Canada) Jdmes, N.P., Kendall, A.C. (1992): Introduction to carbonate and evaporite facles models. - In: Walker, R.G., James, N.P. (eds.): Facies Models. Response to sea level change. - 265-275, Ottawa (Geol. Ass. Canada) James, N.P., Mountjoy, E.W. (1983): Shelf slope break in fossil carbonate platforms: An overview. - Soc. Econ. Paleont. Min. Spec. Publ., 33, 189-206 Jones, B., Desrochers, A. (1992): Shallow platform carbonates. - In: Walker, R.G., James, N.P. (eds.): Facies models. Response to sea level change. - 277-301, Ottawa (Geol. Ass. Canada) Read, J.F. (1982): Carbonate platforms of passive (extens~onal)continental margin-types, characteristics and evolution. - Tectonophysics, 81, 195-212 Read, J.F. (1985): Carbonate platform facies models. -Amer. Ass. Petrol. Geol. Bull., 69, 1-21 Schlager, W. (198 1): The paradox of drowned reefs and carbonate platforms. - Geol. Soc. Amer. Bull., 92, 197-211 Schlager, W. (1989): Drowning unconfomuties on carbonate platforms. - Soc. Econ. Paleont. Min. Spec. Publ., 44, 1525 Schlager, W. (1992): Sedimentology and sequence stratigraphy of reefs and carbonate platforms. - Continuing Education Course Notes, 34, 7 1 pp. Schlager, W. (2000): Sedimentation rates and growth potential of tropical, cool-water and mud-mound carbonate systems. - In: Insalaco, E., Skelton, P.W., Palmer, T.J. (eds.): Carbonate platform systems: components and interactions.
- Geol. Soc. London Spec. Publ., 178,217-227 Scholle, P.A., Bebout, D.G., Moore, C.H. (eds., 1983): Carbonate depositional environments. - Amer. Ass. Petrol. Geol. Mem., 33, 708 pp. Sellwood, B.W. (1996): Shallow-marine carbonate environments. - In: Reading, H.G. (ed.): Sedimentary environments and facies. - 283-356, Oxford (Blackwell) Tucker, M.E. (1985): Shallow-marine carbonate facies and facies models. -In: Brenchley, P., Williams, B.P.J. (eds.): Sedimentology, recent developments and applied aspects. - 147-169, Oxford (Blackwell) Tucker, M.E., Wilson, J.L., Crevello, P.D., Sarg, J.R., Read, J.F. (eds., 1990): Carbonate platforms. Facies, sequences and evolution. -Intern. Ass. SedimentologistsSpec. Publ., 9,328 pp., Oxford Wilson, J.L. (1975): Carbonate facies in geologic history. 41 1 pp., New York (Springer) Wright, V.P., Burchette, T.P. (1996): Shallow-water carbonate environment. - In: Reading, H.G. (ed.): Sedimentary environments: processes, facies, stratigraphy. - 325-394, Oxford (Blackwell) Wright, V.P., Burchette, T.P. (eds., 1999): Carbonate ramps: an introduction. - Geol. Soc. London Spec. Publ., 149, 1-5 Further reading: K018, K019, K020, K190
2.4.4 Tropical and Non-Tropical Carbonates: Different in Composition, Controls and Significance For a long time modem shelf carbonates have been considered to be restricted predominantly to warm-water tropical environments. However, extensive shelf car-
Tropical and Non-Tropical Carbonates
31
Cold Temperate
Fig. 2.8. Map exhibiting the occurrence of selected tropical and non-tropical shelfcarbonates. There are, of course, much more records (see maps provided by Wilson 1975, Rao 1996, and James 1997). The sites shown in the figure were selected with regard to their importance in comparative facies analyses. For numbers see Tab. 2.1. Base map after Nybakken (1993).
bonates are forming in all latitudes and at warm, cool and cold water temperatures. Modem non-tropical carbonates occur in tidal flats, on shelves and platforms as well as in the deep sea, similar to tropical shelf carbonates. Tropical carbonates are relatively well understood and are, therefore, discussed rather briefly in this chapter. The following text concentrates chiefly on nontropical shelf and reef carbonates, because microfacies analysis will have a high potential in the future for recognizing and evaluating ancient temperate and coolwater limestones. 2.4.4.1 Latitudinal Zonation and Diagnostic Criteria of Tropical and Non-Tropical Carbonates On the basis of mean surface ocean temperatures and overall organism distribution, three major biogeographlcal zones can be established whose boundaries are roughly parallel to latitudes: Tropical, temperate and polar (Fig. 2.8). Surface waters in the tropical zone are warm throughout the year, but in the temperate zone warm only in the summer. The thermocline (a zone of rapid temperature change between warm surface waters and cooler deeper waters) is a permanent feature of the tropical zone, occurs seasonally in temperate waters and is absent in polar zones since the ocean surface is covered with ice in winter and solar radiation is low in summer.
Subzones are differentiated according to surface water temperatures (and bottom water temperatures in the polar zone) as well as the latitudinal range (Fig. 2.9). The boundaries between the zones and subzones are transitional rather than absolute. Some trouble exists in the precisely defining of subzones and the use of the terms warm, temperate, cool and cold, particularly in the context of facies studies. Warm-temperate and cool-temperate subzones are rather well-defined (Briggs 1974) in contrast to the subtropical zone. Some authors consider this zone to be an equivalent of the warm-temperate zone; others define the subtropical one as a zone which borders the tropics. Here the climate is intermediate in character between tropical and temperate, though more like the former than the latter. Modem shelf carbonates and reefs are not limited to low-latitude tropical and subtropical warm-water environments, but also occur in temperate cool-water, and even polar cold-water 'non-tropical' settings of midto high-latitudes. Non-tropical settings can be loosely defined as lying poleward of the present limits of hermatypic corals reefs, or beyond the mean annual surface-water isotherm of about 20 "C, today typically near the 30"latitude. Carbonate production also takes place along a transitional spectrum of environments between tropical and non-tropical settings depending on ocean circulation and upwelling patterns. The northern, central and southem parts of the Gulf of California, Mexico, offers a unique possibility for studying carbonate proText continued on p. 34
32
Occurrence of Modern Shelf Carbonates
Table 2.1. Modern shelfcarbonates (except coral reefs) in non-tropical (ct - cold-temperate, p - polar, wt - warm-temperate) and tropical (tr) settings. The table lists sites that are particularly relevant for the understanding of ancient shelf carbonates and the interpretation of microfacies data. Numbers refer to the numbers in the map (Fig. 2.8).
ct
1
Sites
Reference
Remarks
Alexander Archipelago
Hoskin 1969
Skeletal sands, inner shelf
Barnhardt and Kelly 1995
Carbonate-rich sediments, spongebryozoan mounds Submarine seamount; nearly year-round sea ice cover; sponge-bryozoan mounds Largest open-shelf cold-water carbonate platform in the Arctic region; balaniddominated carbonates; bioclastic carbonates under glaciomarine conditions Open-shelf carbonates; discussion of bioerosion and preservation potential of bioclastic cold-water deposits; siliceous sponge mounds, Maerl, intertidal and subtidal communities; open shelves; deep shelves
!xla&2)
ct
2
p
3
p
4
Eastern Canadian shelf? Newfoundland, Nova Scotia Vesterisbanken, central Greenland Sea Spitsbergen Bank (Barents Sea) Southwestem Svalbard shell
ct 5
Western Canadian shelf? Vancouver Island, Hecate Strait
ct 6
Northwestern Europe: Scottish shelves: Rockall Bank, Orkney Islands; Ireland, Porcupine Bank; English Channel; Southern England; Northern Brittany Peninsula, France Northern Norway: off Trom
ct
7
wt 8
Mediter-rurzeuw Sea: Southern French coast; Balearic Islands, Spain; Malta Island; Gulf of Naple: southem Italy, Tyrrhenian Sea, off Southern Sicily
wt 9 wt 10
Adriatic Seu, l t a l y . ~ u l of f Trieste; Apulian shelf OffAlgeria and Tunisia
wt I I
S o ~ i t h ~ ~Gulfof - t z California
--
(Mexico) Bernzudu Island
-
tr 12 -
wt 13 tr 14
Off northwest Africa Belize-Yucatan, central America
tr 15
Bahamas: Florida
Henrich et al. 1992; Henrich et al. 1995 Bjorlykke et al. 1978; Freiwald 1995; Andruleit et al. 1996; Henrich et al. 1997 Nelson and Bomhold 1983; Young and Nelson 1988; Carey et al. 1995; Krautter et al. 2001 Bosence 1980; Scoffin et al. 1980; Farrow and Fyfe 1988; Scoffin 1988; Freiwald 1993; Henrich and Freiwald 1995; Schafer et al. 1996; Light and Wilson 1998; Wehrmann 1998; Bader 2001 Freiwald 1995, 1998; Henrich and Freiwald 1995
Near-shore coastal platforms and fjords; coralline algal reefs; deep shelf; bioclastic sands produced by carbonatesecreting organisms in kelp forests 'Coralligene' , maeri; ramp Walther 1910; Note: On this map Bosence 1985; the Mediterranean is indicated Laborel 1987; as cold-temperate. Many authors Bellan-Santini et al. 1994; consider the Mediterranean a Canals and Ballesteros 1997; Fornos and Ahr 1997; Basso 1998 predominantly warm-temperate region (Briggs 1974) Mixed siliciclastic-carbonate facies; relict Zuschin and Piller 1994; Toscano and Sorgente 2002 sediments and modem shelf carbonates Relict and modem calcareous sands and Caulet 1972: Burollet 1981 bioclastic carbonate mud -Halfar et al. 2000 Detailed microfacies analysis !
Ginsburg and Schroeder 1973; Kuhn 1984; Curran and White 199 Rad et al. 1982 Logan et al. 1969; James and Ginsburg 1979; Viniegra-Osario 1981; Gischler and Lomando 1999 Purdy 1963; Ginsburg 1956; Multer 1977; Schlager and Ginsburg 1981; Ginsburg 1991; Jones and Desrochers 1992; Curran and White 1995; Reid et al. 1995; Carew and Mylroie 1995
Semitropical conditions adjacent to the temperate realm due to the Gulf Stream Rimmed shelf Tropical ramp (campeche Bank); protected shelf lagoon (Belize); open shelf (Yucatan) Isolated platformlbank (Great Bahama Bank); unrimmed and rimmed shelves (western and southern Florida), subtropical setting
Occurrence of Modern Shelf Carbonates
Table 2.1. continued: Modern shelfcarbonates tr 16
ct 17 tr 18 tr 19
tr 20
tr 21
tr 22 te 23
Caribbean Sea: Caicos (British West Indies), Grand Cayman, Jamaica, Nicaragua Rise, St.Croix (U.S. Virgin Islands), Barbados Northeastern Brazilian shelf Gulf of Suez; Gulf of AqabalElat RedSea: Bay of Safaga (Egypt); Sudanian coast; Saudi Arabian coast Persian Gulfand Trucial Coast
Multer and Gerhard 1974; Hubbard et al. 1981; Liddell et al. 1984; Wanless and Dravis 1989; Tongpenyai and Jones 1991; Glaser and Droxler 1991; Geister 1992; Triffleman et al. 1992; Vecsei 2001 Jindrich 1983; Carannante et al. 1988 Friedman 1985; Reiss and Hottinger 1984; Sellwood and Netherwood 1984 Montaggioni et al. 1986; Piller and c an so& 1990; Brachert and Dullo 1990; Piller 1994; Schuhmacher et al. 1995; Dullo et al. 1996 Purser 1973; Loreau 1982; Friedman 1995
Western Indian Ocean: Mayotte (Comoro Islands), La RCunion, Seychelles Maldives Islands (Indian Ocean) South China Sea
Masse et al. 1989; Lewis 1969; Dullo et al. 1996; Camoin and Davies 1998; Purdy and Winterer 2001 Purdy and Bertram 1993; Ciarapica an Paseri 1993: Aubert and Droxler 1996 Li Desheng 1984; Guozhong 1998 Boichard 1985 Arp et al. 1996; Kempe et al. 1996 Emery et al. 1954; Davies et al. 1991; Camoin and Davies 1998; Vecsei 2001 Logan 1974; Playford 1990 Maxwell 1968; Scoffin and Tudhope 1985; Davies et al. 1989; Orpin et al. 1999 Agegian and Mackenzie 1989
Kalimatan (Borneo) Satonda Crater Lake, N' Sumbawa, Indonesia Western Pacific: Coral Sea, Queensland Plateau Shark Bay (W.Australia) Great Barrier Reef (Australia)
tr 24 tr 25 -
tr 26
tr 27 tr 28
Eastern Pacific: Hawaian Archipelago Southeastern Brazil
tr 30 wt 3 1
Summerhayes et al. 1976; Alexandersson and Milliman 1981
--
wt 32
Offsouthwestern Australia: Collins 1988
ct 33
Offsouthern and south-
ct 34
eastern Australian margin: Great Australian Bight: Lacepede shelf, Otway Tasmania
ct 35
New Zealand
p 36
Ross Sea (Antarctica). McMurdo
p 37
King George V coast (Antarctica)
Spencer Gulf Collins 1988, James et al. 1992; Boreen et al. 1993; Bone and James 1993; James et al. 1994 Rao and Adabi 1992; Rao and Nelson1992; Rao 1994; Rao and Amini 1995 Carter 1975; Nelson et a1.1988; Rao and Nelson 1992 Taviani et al. 2001
Domack 1983
Isolated platforms, shallow lagoons, reefs, carbonate banks
Cool-water shelf carbonates in tropical regions ! Near-coastal sediments, reefs Rimmed shelf, sedimentation adjacent to coral reefs
Arid subtropical, homoclinal ramp (Trucial Coast, Arabian Gulf), reefs, atoll lagoons; open shelf (Persian Gulf) Ramps, platforms, atoll lagoons, reefs
Oceanic atolls, banks Some cold-water carbonates because cold currents reduce sea-water temperatures Platforrri 'Marine' lake with increased alkalinity Banks, platforms, reefs
Shallow embayment, living stromatolites Largest modem reef province in the world, rimmed and unrimmed shelf, protected shelf lagoon, coral reefs, Halimeda banks, subtropical setting Mid-depth carbonate banks
, Extended carbonate ramps, effect of upwelling and low terrigenous input on carbonate production Rimmed shelf One of the world's largest modem accumulations of ramp-type coastal and shelf carbonates, high-energy o en shelf Shelf carbonates Platform and shelf carbonates
IProduction and accumulation of skeletal lgrains on continental shelves and offshore banks at depths < 350 m Sponge-bryozoan mound
Occurrence of Polar, Temperate and Tropical Carbonates
duction in cool-temperate, warm-temperate and tropical/subtropical environments (Halfar et al. 2001). The distribution of modem tropical warm-water belt and the northern and southern cold-water belts is controlled by the global circulation patterns of surface currents and the intensity and availability of nutrient recycling between surface and deep waters (Henrich and Freiwald 1995). The rocky coasts of open shelf coldwater belts are characterized by kelp-forests. Kelps are giant seaweeds (brown algae). The thalli provide habitats for numerous carbonate-secreting organisms (cirripeds, bryozoans, serpulids, crustose coralline algae, sponges). These epibionts contribute considerably to carbonate production not only on coastal platforms, but also in intrashelf troughs and coastal lagoons due to the drift of algal blades or the transport of pebbles attached to the algae (kelp-drafting). Modem tropical and non-tropical carbonate sediments exhibit many biological and sedimentological criteria (Table 2.2) which are used in discriminating warm- and cool-water carbonates in the context of facies analyses of ancient limestones (see Sect. 16.4). One of the most significant features concerns the biotic carbonate production in near-coastal shelves:
POLAR CARBONATES
Cold water c5 -10 "C (mean) -1.5 to16 "C (range)
>50° N and S
I 30" - 50" (SO0) N and S
Subtropical and tropical coasts are fringed by coral reefs. Non-tropical temperate rocky coasts of the Northem Seas are characterized by huge kelp forests which provide habitats for sediment-producing epibionts (predominantly barnacles, bivalves, echinoids, and bryozoans).
2.4.4.2 Tropical and Subtropical ShallowMarine Carbonates Shelf carbonates The major settings of subtropical carbonate-producing shelves fall into two categories: (1) Rimmed shelves (= protected shelf lagoons), and (2) open shelves (Fig. 2.10). These categories can be subdivided into those shelves which are influenced by temgenous input, and those which are not (Sellwood 1986). This classification fits many ancient carbonate shelves. Nevertheless, some caution is necessary in using recent shelf carbonates as analogues for ancient shelf and platform carbonates: Modem shelves have been strongly influenced by the Quaternary sea-level fluctuations, particularly by the erosional unconformity formed during the last
polar
>GO0 N and S (to >70° N)
>5 "C
subpolar
>50° to <60° N and S
5 - 10 "C
-
I
I
I
Beyond the Arctic Circle: Central Greenland Sea, Barents Sea, Ross Sea, Antarctica Arctic eastern Canada,Northern Norway, Western Canadian Shelf I Northwestern Europe
Cool water -1 0 -18 "C (mean)
cooltemperate
3O0to5Oo N and S
> I 0 to 25 "C (range)
warm temperate
25" to > 30" N 10 - 18 "C 25" to 30" S
Warm water
subtropical
18 - 22 "C
Bahama, Florida, Bermuda, Persian Gulf, Shark Bay
tropical
>22 "C
Great Barrier Reef, Indian Ocean, Pacific
5-10°C
18 to >22 "C (mean)
18 to 30 "C (range)
-
Southern Australia, Tasmania, New Zealand Mediterranean Sea, Off North Africa, Southwestern Australia
Fig. 2.9. Latitudinal distribution and critical sea-water temperatures of modem tropical carbonates and temperate and polar carbonate settings. Note that cool-water carbonates can also form i n tropical regions, where cold currents reduce sea-water temperatures (e.g. off the east coast of SouthAmerica, o f f the west coast of Africa and off the coasts of southern Asia).
Comparing Tropical and Non-Tropical Carbonates
35
Table 2.2. Main features of modern (warm-water)and non-tropical (cool- and cold-water)carbonates (based on Leonard et al. 1981, Nelson 1988, Rao 1997). Bold-type criteria are of specific value in microfacies studies of ancient non-tropical limestones.
Latitude Environment Tectonics Terrigenous input Geometry of buildups Mean water temperaturs Salinity Carbonate saturation Water circulation Accumulation rates Reefs Algal mats Biodegradation Carbonate content Texture Carbonate mud Origin of allochthonous mud Ooids Aggregate Grains Peloids Intra/Lithoclasts Calcareous red algae Rhodoids Calcareous green algae Stromatolites Seaweed (brown algae) Seagrass Zooxanthellate corals Azooxanthellate corals Coral growth forms Benthic foraminifera Bryozoans Bivalves Vermetid gastropods Serpulid worms Barnacles Echinoderms Siliceous sponges Skeletal grain associations Biotic diversity Equatability Association with non-carbonates Glauconite Phosphorite Biogenic silica Low-Mg calcite High-Mg-calcite Aragonite Dolomite Early sea-bed lithification Diagenetic trends
'hpical carbonates
Non-tropical carbonates
30" N - 30" S Platform; shelf Stable Low Attached and isolated platforms with marginal rims > 23 "C Normal to hypersaline Supersaturated to saturated Restricted to open 50 to >I000 cm/1000 a Common to abundant Common Common to abundant
beyond 30" N and 30"s Open shelf; ramp Stable to unstable Low to high Homoclinal and distally steepened ramps 4 0 "C Normal (to reduced) Saturated to undersaturated Open >1 to >10 cm/1000 a Rare to absent Absent Abundant, strong 50-100% Sands, gravels, muds Rare to abundant Physical and chemical degradation of skeletons Absent Absent Rare or absent Rare to common Abundant Abundant Very rare Rare Abundant Less common Rare Common to abundant Solitary and fasciculate Abundant, low-diversity Abundant Abundant and diverse Common Common Common to abundant Abundant Common to abundant Diverse Moderate to high High Rare to abundant Common Common Rare to common Common to abundant Abundant to common Rare Rare Less common Destructive
290% Muds, sands, gravels Common to abundant Disintegration of algae, microbial Common Common Common Common Common to abundant Common Abundant Common to abundant Rare Abundant Abundant Rare Diverse Common, high-diversity Rare to common Common and diverse Rare Rare to common Rare Common Rare to common Few High Low Rare Rare Rare Rare Rare to common Abundant Aimndant Common Common to abundant Constructive
Subtropical Shelf Carbonates
1~ x a m ~ l ewith s important references
Main features
Great Bahama Bank Anselmetti et al. 2000; Ball 1967; Curran and White 1995; Eberli and Ginsburg 1989; Ginsburg et al. 1991; Hardie 1977; Harris 1979; Hine 1977; Milliman et al. 1993; Newellet al. 1959; Neumann and Land 1975; Purdy l963a; l963b; Schlager and Ginsburg 1981; Shinn et al. 1969; Wanless and Dravis 1989; Ginsburg 2001
>
5
E
Shallow sea floor (-100 m average depth); topographical fringing barriers (reefs, shoals, islands) at the seaward margin; low-energy environments and mud deposition within the shelf lagoon, high-energy environments predominantly at the outer margins
.El
South Florida Shelf Bosence 1989; Enos and Perkins 1977; Ginsburg 1956; Halley et al. 1983; Messing et al. 1990; Multer 1969; Shinn 1963; Shinn 1983; Shinn et al. 1989; Stockman et al. 1967; Turmel and Swanson I976
L
a,
V)
m o
Cuba Bandy 1964; Daetwyler and Kidwell 1959; Bathurst 1975
%
c2
CLI a, 3 L G= Cn
-: .
Great Barrier Reef Drew 1983; Gagan et al. 1990; Larcombe and Woolfe 1999; Maiklem 1968; Maxwell 1968; Maxwell and Swinchatt 1970; Scoffin and Tudhope 1985; Tudhope 1989
,3 2 $$
Northwestern Yucatan Folk 1967; Folk and Robles 1964; Gischler and Lomando 1999; Hoskin 1963; Logan et al. 1969; Viniegra-Osario 1981; Wilson 1970; Ward and Brady 1973
.s E O "
Sea floor gently inclined towards the shelf break; sedimentation controlled by wave action, and tidal and oceanic currents; calcareous sands in shallow settings; mud in deeper settings; wide irregular facies belts; lack of resedimentation by mass flow mechanism
Belize Gischler and Lomando 1999; Gischler et al. 2000; James and Ginsburg 1979; Purdy 1974; Purdy et al. 1975; Scholle and Kling 1972
D
f
2>
O
5 m
1
g
0 a,
, 5% 91 r 3
+
.E
5
Eastern Gulf of Mexico Folk et al. 1962; Gardulski et al. 1986; Rezak et al. 1985; Siringan and Anderson 1994 Persian Gulf Houbolt 1957; Patterson and Kinsman 1981; Purser 1973; Scholle and Kinsman 1974
Fig. 2.10. Major settings of modem subtropical shelf carbonates (based on Sellwood 1986).
glacial stage. Facies distribution and setting of modem reefs and shoals, therefore, are strongly controlled by the Pleistocene topography (Purdy 1974). Excellent reviews and detailed descriptions of modem tropical and subtropical shelf carbonates from different settings can be found in Sellwood (1986), Tucker and Wright (1990), Jones and Desrochers (1992), and Wright and Burchette (1996). In the context of interpreting of microfacies data, these references must be thoroughly consulted.
definitions and significance of these constituents are discussed in Sect. 4.2. Plate 3 offers a first look at the diversity of the grain types.
Reefs Modem tropical and subtropical reefs are situated at shelf and platform margins, and on shelves, platforms and ramps. The distributional pattern of recent coral reefs suggests that reefs are arranged nearly symmetrically in both hemispheres, do not occur at latitudes greater than 34", are concentrated at the western marConzposition of tropical and subtropical shallow-mu- gins of the oceans, are absent in the vicinity of large rine carbonates: Similar to ancient limestones, mod- river mouths, and exhibit two reef realms (Caribbean em warm-water shelf carbonates consist of polygen- and Indo-Pacific realm). etic carbonate mud and different categories of grains. Furthergoing explanation of the distributional patGrains include biogenic material (detrital bioclasts or tern suggests that reefs prefer shallow waters and tropiin situ calcareous organisms), sand-sized grains of mud- cal to subtropical climates, and can grow in land-locked grade carbonate (peloids), various coated grains (oo- settings and in open oceanic settings, and that reefs ids, oncoids, rhodoids), sand-sized aggregates of ag- avoid settings with high clastic input and areas affected glutinated particles (grapestones), and lithified and re- by cool eastern boundary currents and coastal upworked sediment clasts (lithoclasts, intraclasts). The welling. In summary, sea-water temperature, sunlight
Modern and Pleistocene Carbonates
and water depths, and nutrients and siliciclastic input are the major controls on the distribution of modem zooxanthellate coral reefs. Cool-water reefs are discussed in Sect. 16.4.1.
2.4.4.3 Non-Tropical Shelf and Reef Carbonates Shallow-marine temperate carbonate sediments constitute about one third of modem global shelf sediments (Nelson 1988). Modem temperate cool-water carbonates differ from tropical carbonates in the type of skeletal grains, mineralogy and diagenesis, oxygen and carbon isotopes and in the range of trace elements. Nontropical and tropical shallow-marine carbonates differ significantly in their prevailing geometries: The scar-
37
city of rapidly growing calcareous frame-building organisms and the absence of aragonite (which would favor early lithification)hinder the development of platforms with wave-resistent margins and steep flanks. Non-tropical shelf sediments are primarily controlled by bottom currents which distribute the bioclastic sediment over extended areas. The results are homoclinal ramps, developing in low-water energy, and distally steepened ramps in high-energy environments. Non-tropical carbonates are found almost continuously from mid to high latitudes in shelf areas with low or missing clastic input. Similar settings which occur along a latitudinal transect from warm to cold water conditions, may be developed along downslope profiles at any latitude (including tropical carbonate platforms, Brazil shelf).
Plate 3 Modern and Pleistocene Carbonates: Shallow-Marine and Windblown Sands; Beachrocks The samples shown on this plate document the common composition of calcareous sands deposited in shallowmarine (-> 1-3) and subaerially exposed environments (-> 4,5,7,8). Both the Bahamas and the Bermudas offer excellent possibilities for studying the controls on the deposition of calcareous sediments and the processes involved in their transformation into carbonate rocks. The Bahamas are a large isolated platform, 700 x 300 krn in size. The subtidal sediments exhibit specific distributional patterns (see map on next page). Lithofacies characterized by skeletal grains (coralalgal), ooids and reefs (see P1.5 117) occur at the platform margins, whereas sediments rich in aggregate grains (grapestone) or carbonate mud (pellet mud) are platform-interior facies. Modern shallow-marine carbonate sands formed in tropical and subtropical warm-water environments consist predominantly of skeletal grains (foraminifera, -> 6; calcareous algae, -> 5; mollusk shells, -> 2, and other biota), associated with non-skeletal grains including peloids (-> 2), ooids (-> 1,3) and composite grains represented by aggregate grains (-> 1; P1. 1511-3), and reworked and redeposited sediment (intraclasts, -> 1). Grains are usually aragonite or High-Mg calcite. The average size ranges between < 0.5 and about 2.0 mm. Sand accumulations are common on or near the seawards edge of banks, platforms or shelves (Halley et al. 1983). Sand production and the development of modem bank-margin sand bodies are strongly controlled by antecedent topography, physical processes (wind, waves, tides, and storms), and sea-level changes. Various encrusting organisms contribute to the stabilization of the sediment binding of grains and to the formation of beachrocks (-> 8). Submarine cementation within inter- and intragranular pores as well as early diagenetic cementation of subaerially exposed sediments lead to an incipient lithification (-> 4). The microstructure of many grains becomes highly altered due to the activity of microborers (-> 2; 'micritization') and diagenetic alterations. These grains are formed in specific high- and low-energy environments (see map). Eolianites, consisting of windblown marine carbonate grains, are known from modem and ancient tropical and subtropical coastal environments (see Fig. 15.1). Eolianites are commonly associated with coastal marine deposits and paleosols. Because the sediment consists of grains, originally formed in shallow-marineenvironments, eolian grainstones may be confused with marine calcarenites. Important diagnostic criteria of eolianites are lamination and stratification with high- to low-angle beds (see Fig. 15.1), fine- to medium-sized grains, good overall sorting (-> 4), sorting differences between laminae or beds, inverse grading, rounded tabular grains, and meteoric vadose meniscus and microstalactitic calcite cements (-> 4). Other cement types are fibrous cements consisting of long calcite crystals, and rnicrite rim cement that superficially resemble micrite envelopes. Calcified plant root systems in calcarenites associated with paleosols and carbonate crusts (see P1. 128) suggest a pause in sedimentation under subaerial conditions.
38
Plate 3: Description of Figures
Plate 3 Text Continued: Modern and Pleistocene Carbonates: Shallow-Marine and Windblown Sands; Beachrocks 1 Constituents of recent marine calcareous sands: Ooids (0), aggregate grains (grapestones, G; see P1. 1511-3), intraclasts and peneroplid foraminifera(P). Ooid nuclei are large peloids and skeletal grains. Holocene: Exuma Kays, Great Bahama Bank. 2 Skeletal grains (forminifera, algal debris, Halimeda HA) and micritized grains. Note the crossed-lamellar microstructure of the large aragonite gastropod shell. Parts of the shell were destroyed by microborers (arrows; see P1. 5211-4). The sediment in the shell interior was cemented prior to deposition. Subtidal unstable sand of the coralgal facies. Holocene: Bimini Island, Great Bahama Bank. 3 Ooids. Tangentially structured 'normal ooids' (TO) exhibiting a cortex of several aragonite lamellae and 'superficial ooids' (SO), characterized by only a few laminae (see P1. 13). Nuclei are large peloids. Note the small dark micrite-filled spots within some ooids (bottom left) representing microborings. The Bahamian ooid shoals occur along the platform margin. The Joulters ooid shoal north of Andros Island consists of ooid grainstone (formed on current-swept, rippled sea bottoms), ooid packstone (formed on stabilized burrowed bottoms), fine-peloid packstone (formed on stabilized and burrowed bottoms), pellet wackestone and lithoclast packstone (formed in active tidal channels) as well as skeletal grainstone (Hams 1983). Holocene: Joulters Cays, Great Baharna Bank. 4 Constituents of a poorly cemented wind-blown ooid sand (ooid grainstone) forming eolian dunes. Tangentially structured ooids. Cementation has taken place in the meteoric vadose zone. Note rims of Low-Mg calcite cements (arrows) connecting the grains. These 'meniscus cements' and phreatic granular calcite cements indicate freshwater diagenesis (see PI. 32156). Cementation affects densely packed grains more strongly than loosely packed grains. Most pores between the grains are open (but were filled with epoxy during the preparation of the thin section).The grains were formed within a marine environment, but an eolian deposition is indicated by the good overall sorting and vadose cements (Caputo 1995).Late Pleistocene (Grotto Beach Formation; age about 125 000 a): San Salvador Island, Bahamas. 5 Skeletal grains, predominantly fragments of the green alga Halimeda (see P1.57/1,2), few foraminifers and gastropods. The disintegration of Halimeda and other green algae is a major process in the production of carbonate mud (see P1.71 1,2). Late Pleistocene (French Bay Member, Grotto Beach Formation): San Salvador Island, Bahamas. 6 Lithified calcareous sand (calcarenite), deposited in a nearcoastal marine environment during an interglacial phase. Consisting predominantly of skeletal grains (peneroplid foraminifera),peloids, and grains that have been intensively attacked by microborers and transformed into microcrystalline calcite (dark). Late Pleistocene (Belmont Formation): Devonshire Bay, southern Bermuda. 7 Fossil beachrock composed of large micritized aggregate grains (AG) and some skeletal grains (bored shells: arrow points to borehole; foraminifera, F). In contrast to -> 8, all the intergranular pores are filled with cement. Beachrock is formed in the intertidal zone of subtropical or tropical coasts. Late Pleistocene (Grotto Beach Formation): Same locality as -> 5. Juvenile beachrock consisting of well-preserved fragments Andros Island E of Halimeda (HA), composite grains and peloids. Note the still open voids (V). The grains are encrusted by foraminifera (arrows). Beachrock originates from the growth of aragonite and Mg-calcite cements in intergranular pores. Cementation can take place within a few years. Late Pleistocene (Grotto Florida Beach Formation): Same locality as -> 5.
Map and cross-section of Andros Island. Modified from Friedman and Sanders (1978) and Blatt et al. (1972).
Figs. 1-3: Loose grains are embedded in resin which appears white in transmitted light.
Plate 3: Modern and Pleistocene Carbonates
39
1 mm
lmm
-100 urn
-
1rnm
- 1 rnrn
1mm
-
Imm
-
lmm
Temperate and Polar Carbonates
Studies of mid- and high-latitudinal non-tropical carbonates started rather late in the 1970s, but 'temperate' and 'cold-water ' carbonates are becoming continuously better documented (Nelson 1988; Henrich and Freiwald 1995; Rao 1996; James and Clarke 1997) and have become one of the most exciting tools in carbonate research. The importance of non-tropical coral reefs was underlined by Teichert (1958). Chave (1967) pointed out that shelf carbonates could form at all latitudes, regardless of water temperature. Based on a thorough analysis of modem shelf sediments, Lees and Buller (1972) recognized the fundamental differences between tropical and temperate carbonates, and the importance of water temperature and salinity as major controls on the composition of shelf carbonates. The authors emphasized the significance of 'grain association patterns' for distinguishing between tropical and non-tropical carbonates. This concept provides a high potential for evaluating the climatic and oceanographic controls on ancient carbonates using microfacies data (Sect. 12.2). The last twenty years have produced a wealth of papers dealing with non-tropical coastal and shelf carbonates in the Northern and Southern Hemisphere and comprising a latitudinal range of 30 to 80" N and 30 to 70" S. Temperate and cold-water shelf carbonates were studied in the northern Atlantic (northwestern France, England, Ireland, Scotland, Norway), in the Greenland and Barents Sea, on the Canadian Scott Shelf, from various parts of the Mediterranean Sea (Tunisia, Sicily, Adriatic Sea, Eastern Mediterranean)as well as from Pacific regions (Western Canada, India). In the Southem Hemisphere extensive temperate carbonates are forming today off Australia, Tasmania and New Zealand on tidal flats, gulfs, shelves, platforms and ramps. The largest modem temperate-water carbonate shelf production occurs on the outer shelf, shelf edge and upper slope of the southern and southeastern margin of Australia (Boreen and James 1993). The eastern Tasmanian shelf is an excellent example for the deposition and diagenesis of cool-water carbonates. These carbonates have been extensively studied with regard to compositional, mineralogical and geochemical criteria and are, therefore, a reference standard for recognizing and interpreting ancient non-tropical carbonates. Informative reviews and collections of case studies are available (Nelson 1988; Henrich and Freiwald 1995; James and Clarke 1997). Rao (1997) gives an excellent overview on the present state of knowledge and includes a comprehensive bibliography. Controls on temperate carbonates: Major controls on the origin and composition of temperate carbonates are (a) the rate of dilution from ter-
rigenous sources, (b) appropriate sea-water temperatures (which may be relatively 'warm' - the Mediterranean type of parts of southern Australia, or 'cool temperate' - e.g. Otway shelf, southeastern Australia; Tasmania), (c) the relative abundance of calcareous biota, (d) the availability of nutrients, (e) sufficient levels of saturation of CaCO, in seawater (allowing cementation and reducing dissolution), (f) high water energy for accumulating calcareous sands, and (g) the rate of accumulation (approximately an order of magnitude lower in temperate shelves than in tropical shelves). Many non-tropical carbonates form at low CO, levels hregions of upwelling waters, which maintain CaC03saturation and provide nutrients for luxuriant growth of fauna. Lowering of sea level results in wave-base erosion and redistribution of sediments from shallow to deeper water and below the wave base. Temperate and polar carbonates: Bioclastic carbonates of shelfpla$orms: These sediments are represented by moderately to well-sorted accumulations of coarse and fine bioclastic sands (e.g. bryozoan-, mollusc-bryozoan or coralline algal sands; P1. 412, 3, 5) with minor amounts of fines and gravels (e.g. molluscan gravel). The sands consist mainly of bioclasts, some micritic peloids and angular, rounded and bored intraclasts (reworked submarine hardgrounds or semilithified carbonate). Ooids are absent. Sedimentary particles are permanently reworked and swept basinward along the slopes, where the grains mix with autochthonous or older particles. Many sediments are a mixture of modem calcareous sands and Pleistocene relict carbonates. Australian case studies demonstrate the occurrence of two major facies zones: Above the zone of winnowing the sediment consists of coarse skeletal harsh and some relict particles. Below, the deposits are muds, rich in planktonic material and some benthics (Nelson et al. 1988, James and von der Borch 1991). Carbonate mud sedimentation occurs on the temperate shelf of southeastern Australia (Blom and Alsop 1988). The calcitic muds are produced by the accumulation and disintegration of nannoplankton, as well as from the biodegradation of skeletal grains accumulating on the sea floor. Many high-latitude carbonate muds are bioerosional and result from maceration of shells (Farrow and Fyfe 1988). Bioerosion down to about 25 m is intensive in the photic zone. Shelly substrate is affected by e.g. clionid sponges, endolithic algae, bivalves, regular echinoids, crabs, fish. Bioerosional products are angular silt- and gravel-sized chips, or mud-sized disintegration products of fecal pellets.
,,
Cool-Water Reefs
41
Case studies in the northern Atlantic underline the great importance of subtidal kelp forests, which harbor a great number of carbonate-secreting and sediientproducing organisms. These forests occur along the wave-exposed flanks of rocky coastal platforms. In contrast, pure coralline red algal gravel deposits ('maerl') develop in more protected parts of the platforms. 'Maerl' is a Breton term, and refers to unattached crust-forming branched or nodular coralline algae and algal gravel, including their widely distributed deposits (Pl. 412). Maerl is one of the most abundant shallow-water carbonates of cool-temperate environments. Modem maerl beds are found throughout the Mediterranean Sea, and are common on temgenous-free Atlantic coasts in depths < 20-30 m, from Norway and Denmark in the north to Portugal in the south, extending to Morocco and Mauretania on the African coast. Maerl deposits have been studied in detail in Brittany, northwestern France (Henrich and Freiwald 1995, Bader 2001), British Islands (Farnham and Jephson 1977), western Ireland (Bosence 1985) and in the Mediterranean Sea. The French term 'corallig2ne' refers to recent coralline algal buildups of the Mediterranean (Bosence 1985). These carbonates occur in intertidal and sublittoral rocky coasts in water depths between about 20 and 160 m; they are represented by reefs formed by corallinacean frameworks. The coralligkne can be considered to be a good recent analog for some Miocene coralline limestones of the Tethyan region that exhibit a very similar generic composition and similar growth forms of red algae.
Skeletal grains: Common bioclasts are bryozoans (Pi. 4/5),foraminifera, molluscs, echinoids and calcareous red, algae. Other organisms include barnacles, serpulids, brachiopods, ahermatypic corals and sponges. The main groups occur in various proportions, depending on the water temperature, salinity, nutrients and grain size of the sediment. Compositional differences allow 'skeletal grain assemblages' characterized by the dominance of particular grain types to be defined (e.g. bryozoans and mollusks = bryomol association occurring on deep shelf banks of the northern Atlantic; P1.4/4), which are indicative of special environmental conditions and particular parts of the shelf (Sect. 12.2.2.1). Non-skeletal grains (peloids, intraclasts) are rare, ooids are absent. Cool-water reefs: Diverse in composition and distribution: Lower slope deep-water reefs ('lithoherms'): Neumann et al. (1977) described elongate coral bioherms in water depths of several hundred meters, that are axially aligned with the flow field of the Florida current. The upcurrent end of the mounds consists of dense thickets of branching ahermatypic corals; the middle and downcurrent sections are rocky, and strongly bioeroded with attached sponges, alcyonarians, gorgonians, and crinoids. Sediments from this zone are a mixture of planktonic foraminifers and pteropods, with skeletal grains from lithoherm organisms. Large amounts of aragonite mud are trapped in the coral thicket at the upcurrent ends of the mounds or in sponge-boring cavities within the lithoherms. The description of these
Table 2.3. Generalized comparison of modem warm-water shallow-marine reefs and cold/cool-water deeper-marine coral reefs.
Sea water temperature range Bathymetrical range Light Zonation patterns Nutrional regime Trophic modes Diversity of coral framework builders Diversity of associated fauna Diversity of associated flora Biological framework stabilization Bioerosional impact Diagenetic impact Interskeletal cementation Intraskeletal cementation Internal sediment Automicrite
Warm and shallow water reefs
Cold and deeper water reefs
20 - 28 "C -50 m Photic zone Windward-leeward Light zonation Oligotrophic Photo- and heterotrophy High High High Coralline Algae High High Very common Very common Very common Common
4 - 12°C 250 m to >1 000 m Aphotic to dysphotic zones Current zonation Taphonomic zonation Eutrophic Heterotrophy Low High Non existent Encrusting sponges High Low Rare Low to common Very common Very common
4 ?.
structures started a fascinating hunt for Holocene and ancient 'deep-water and cold-water reefs' which is still going on. Non-tropical reefs differ significantly from reefs thriving in shallow warm waters (Table 2.3). High-latitudinal reefs are stressed ecosystems whose biota should be able to tolerate low water temperatures as well as sharp seasonal temperature fluctuations, salinity fluctuations and low light influx. Common reef-building organisms are corals, calcareous red algae, bryozoans, bivalves (e.g. oysters), serpulids and tube-constructing sabellarid polychaetes, vermetids, encrusting forarninifera and sponges. Non-tropical reefs comprise coral reefs, coralline algal reefs, sponge-bryozoan reefs, and mollusk reefs. Examples of coralline algal reefs and maerl pavements have been studied on the northern coast of Brittany (France), and the coast of the Troms District in northern Norway (Freiwald et al. 1991; Freiwald and Henrich 1994). Oyster reefs, vermetid reefs and serpulid reefs occur in different parts of the Atlantic Ocean (Milliman 1974). Corals contribute significantly to the formation of large and extended reef-structures in deeper cold-water settings (Lophelia reefs), but also in relatively shallow warm-temperate environments (Cladocora banks of the eastern Mediterranean: Kiihlmann 1996; Taviani et al. 2001). Lophclia reefs: Huge framework reefs built by the azooxanthellate coral Lophelia cover huge areas of the deep and cold eastern Atlantic shelf bottoms (Scottish shelf: Scoffin et al. 1980; Norwegian shelf: Henrich and Freiwald 1995; Freiwald and Wilson 1998; Faroe Island: Frederiksen et al. 1992, see P1.412). The corals are preserved as frameworks or coarse coral rubble. Hovland and Thomsen (1997) discuss possible causal relations between deep-water coral reefs and hydrocarbon seeps.
Cool-Water Carbonates
tions in light regime, seasonal sea ice cover, ice shelves, currents and circulation patterns. The largest open-shelf cold-water carbonate platform in the Arctic is Spitsbergen Bank in the northwestern Barents Sea (Henrich et al. 1996; Pi. 416). The bank corresponds to a >80 000 km2 wide shallow shelf platform bordered by > 400 m deep troughs. Water depths range from less than 25 m to deeper than 120 m. The bank is completely covered by sea ice for 6 months. Melting sea ice causes strong seasonal variations in surface water salinity. The maximum summer temperature is 2 "C on the bank and 4-6 "C in the marginal zone. Another bioclastic carbonate production area is the southwestern Svalbard shelfwhere skeletal carbonate deposition resting on tillites takes place under glaciomarine conditions in depths between 50 and 80 m (Andruleit et al. 1996). Carbonates are produced by (a) barnacles living on kelp forests and forming mobile sands which are transported over the shallow platform, and (b) benthic communities (infaunal bivalves, balanids, hydrozoans, soft corals, sponges, bryozoans) forming buildups on the deep flanks of the platform. The seamount is covered by extensive sponge-bryozoan bioconstructions exhibiting three distinct facies belts depending on variations in down-slope food transfer. Different communities occurring in these belts are biogenic mats with sponge spicules and bryozoan fragments, sponge bryozoan-serpulid buildups, bryozoan thickets, and sponge-crinoid mounds (Henrich et al. 1992). Basic patterns of sediment distribution are coarse, high-energy bioclastic sands consisting of balanids, bivalves and benthic foraminifera on top of the bank and arctic mollusk coquinat glaciomarine gravel lag deposits over the flanks. These carbonates differ from other high-latitude shelf carbonates with or without glaciomarine controls. Postglacial or interglacial carbonate sediments capping older glaciogenic units and not influenced by glaciomarine settings are known from the Scottish shelf, the Norwegian shelf, off Nova Scotia and Newfoundland, and western Canada. Carbonate deposition associated with glaciomarine environments occurs on Antarctic shelves (Domack 1988; Taviani et al. 1993).
Polar carbonates and arctic sponge-bryozoan mounds: Parameters other than the rather stable water temperature control polar carbonates influenced by glacio~narineconditions (Domack 1988;Henrich et al. 1997): the seasonality of light levels (polar night, polar sum- Signijicance of cool-water carbonates: mer), winter sea ice coverage versus summer open po- 1 Quantitative and qualitative data of high-latitude cool-water carbonates are strongly needed in all lar conditions, seasonality in plankton production, and speculations on regional and global carbonate budseasonality in terrigenous sediment discharge by glaciers, meltwater plumes, rivers and release of sea ice gets. sediment (Henrich et al. 1992,1997). The richness and 2 Because the kind of skeletal and non-skeletal grains, facies, carbonate mineralogy and diagenesis vary diversity of benthic organisms are controlled by relawith sea-water temperatures and other factors, the tively constant (low but stable) temperatures, low flucdifferentiation of tropical and non-tropical carbontuations in salinity, low terrestrial input and fluctua-
Basics: Modern Non-Tropical and Polar Carbonates ates is an important tool in reconstructing paleoclimate and paleolatitudes. Classical concepts, based on grain associations e.g. foramol, Sect. 12.2) must be refined, taking into account not only temperature and salinity as major controls on carbonate composition, but also the negative influence of temgenous input as well as the importance of food supply, biogenic interactions e.g. food transfer from seasonal plankton blooms to benthic communities (benthopelagic coupling) and variable oceanic configurations (Betzler 1995). In addition, differentiation between cold-water and tropical carbonates is complicated by the fact that the occurrence and distribution of cold-water carbonates are controlled not only by lateral latitudes but also by the change in warm to cold conditions along downslope profiles (Carannante et al. 1988). These bathymetrically controlled changes may occur at any latitude and need further study. In contrast to modem tropical carbonates, composed predominantly of aragonite and Mg-calcite, many Phanerozoic limestones are formed from calcitedominated carbonates. Modem cold-water carbonates, therefore, may be good analogues for ancient shelf limestones, e.g. from the Paleozoic or Jurassic (James and Bone 1989, 1991; James and von der Borch, 1991; James et al. 1992). Diagenesis and reservoir potential: It is generally assumed that sea-floor and meteoric cementation are very limited in cool-water carbonates as compared with tropical warm-water carbonates. Carbonate minerals are predominantly High-Mg calcite (and minor aragonite) in shallow warm temperate carbonates and High-Mg to Low-Mg calcites in cool temperate carbonates. The mineralogical composition is controlled by water temperatures and water depths. Carbonate saturation of sea water in non-tropical settings is less pronounced or even undersaturated (Opdyke and Wilkinson 1990). Diagenesis, therefore, is predominantly destructive (Alexandersson 1978). Compared to tropical shallow-marine carbonates the diagenetic potential is low and sediments may remain essentially unlithified for a long period of time. Nevertheless, intraskeletal and intergranular carbonate cementation can be common in some temperate and cold-water carbonates (Rao 1996; James et al. 1992, 1994; Henrich and Freiwald 1995). Basics: Modern non-tropical temperate and polar carbonates Andruleit, H., Freiwald, A., Schafer, P. (1996): Bioclastic carbonate sediments on the southwestern Svalbard shelf. Marine Geology, 134, 163-182 Bader, B. (2001): Modem Bryomol-sediments in a cool-wa-
ter, high-energy setting: the inner shelf off Northern Brittany. - Facies, 44,81-104 Bone, Y., James, N.P. (1993): Bryozoans as carbonate sediment producers on the cool-water Lacepede Shelf, southern Australia. - Sed. Geol., 86,247-271 Boreen, T.D., James, N.P. (1993): Holocene sediment dynamics on a cool-water shelf: Otway, southeastern Australia. - J. Sed. Petrol., 63,574-588 Bosence, D.W. (1985): The Coralligene of the Mediterranean - a Recent analog for Tertiary coralline algal limestones.In: Toomey, D.F., Nitecki, M.H. (eds.): Paleoalgology. 215-225, Berlin (Springer) Briggs, J.C. (1974): Marine zoogeography. - 475 pp., New York (McGrawHill) Cairns, S.D., Stanley, G.D. (1981):Ahermatypic coral banks: living and fossil counterparts. - Proc. 4th Int. Coral Reef Symp. Manila, 1,611-618 Colantoni, P., Cremona, G., Ligi, M., Borsetti ,A.M. , Cate, F. (1985):The Adventure Bank (off Southwestern Sicily): a present day example of carbonate shelf sedimentation. Giorn. Geol. Ser. 3,47, 165-180 Domack, E.W. (1988): Biogenic facies in the Antarctic glacimarine environment: basis for a polar glacimarine summary. - Palaeogeogr., Palaeoclimat., Palaeoecol., 63,357372 Farrow, G.E., Fyfe, J.A. (1988): Bioerosion and carbonate mud production on high-latitude shelves. - In: Nelson, C.S. (ed.): Non-tropical shelf carbonates - modem and ancient. - Sed. Geol., 60,281-297 Fomos, J.J., Forteza, V., Jaume, C., Martinez-Tabemer, A. (1992):Present-day Halimeda carbonate sediments in temperate Mediterranean embayments: Fornells, Balearic Islands. - Sed. Geol., 75,283-293 Freiwald, A. (1993): Coralline algal maerl frameworks - islands within the phaeophytic kelp belt. - Facies, 29, 133148 Freiwald, A. (1998a): Geobiology of Lopheliapertusa in the North Atlantic. - Habilitation Thesis University Bremen, 194 pp. Freiwald, A. (1998b): Modem nearshore cold-temperate calcareous sediments in the Troms District, Northern Norway. - J. Sed. Research, A68,763-776 Freiwald,A., H e ~ c hR., (1994):Reefal coralline algal buildups within the Arctic Circle: morphology and sedimentary dynamics under extreme environmental seasonality. - Sedimentology, 41,963-984 Freiwald, A., Henrich, R., Patzold, J. (1997): Anatomy of a deep-water coral reef mound from the Stjemsund, West Finnmark, Northern Norway. - In: James, N.P., Clarke, J.A.D. (eds.):Cool-water carbonates. - Soc. Econ. Paleont. Min., Spec. Publ., 56, 141-162 Freiwald,A., Henrich, R., Schafer, P., Willkomm, H. (1991): The significance of high-boreal to subarctic maerl deposits in Northern Norway to reconstruct Holocene climatic changes and sea level oscillations. - Facies, 25,315-340 Freiwald, A., Wilson, J.B. (1998): Taphonomy of modem deep, cold-temperate water coral reefs. - Historical Biology, 13, 37-52 Gillespie,J.L., Nelson, C.S. (1997): Mixed siliciclastic-skeleta1 carbonate facies on Wanganui Shelf, New Zealand: a contributionto the temperate carbonate model. -In: James, N.P., Clarke, J.A.D. (eds.): Cool-water carbonates. - Soc. Econ. Paleont. Min., Spec. Publ., 56, 127-140 Halfar, J., Godinez-Orta, L., Ingle, J.C. (2000): Microfacies
44
Modern Non-Tropical Cool-Water Carbonates
Plate 4 Modern Non-Tropical Cool-Water Carbonates: High-Latitudinal Temperate and Polar Shelf and Reef Carbonates from the Northern Atlantic Marine carbonate production is by no means restricted to tropical warm-water environments. Abundant and widespread biogenic carbonate production occurs in non-tropical, mid- and high-latitudinal temperate and coolwater settings with low or missing clastic input, and even in cold water beyond the Arctic Circle. Examples are known from the southern and northern hemispheres. Cool-water carbonates record climatic and paleoceanographic information in their sedimentary deposits and architectures. Microfacies and sedimentary architecture of ancient cool-water carbonates provide basic data for the evaluation of paleoclimate and paleolatitudes. Modem coolwater carbonates are good analogues for limestones formed in calcite-dominated Phanerozoic seas. Widely extended carbonate deposits and even reefal frameworks occur in Subarctic and Arctic seas. Most sediments are bioclastic sands and gravels, formed by balanids, mollusks, foraminifera and coralline red algae. Many of these organisms are epibionts, living on benthic macroalgae which form extended kelp forests in nearshore environments. Kelp and coralline algae are adapted to seasonal climatic perturbations. On the Spitsbergen Bank, the largest open-shelf cold-water carbonate platfonn of the Arctic region, the carbonate production is centered around two main factories: (a) barnacle sands, produced within kelp forests growing on the shallowest part of the platform and transported over the platform, and (b) high biogenic production by infaunal bivalves (-> 6) as well as balanid-hydrozoan-soft coral-sponge-bryozoan buildups on the flanks of the platform (Henrich et al. 1997). Marked differences in the composition of bioclastic grain associations reflect specific environmental conditions on the shelf bottoms; these 'grain association patterns' are powerful indications of the climatic, oceanographic and latitudinal controls of ancient cool-water limestones (see Sect. 12.2). Recognizing reefs in deep, aphotic zones is highly important for interpreting ancient analogues. Different reef types are formed by corals, coralline red algae (-> I), siliceous sponges, bryozoans, and mollusks. These organisms, living in stressed ecosystems, are able to tolerate low watef temperatures, and seasonal fluctuations of light intensity, nutrient availability and salinity. Spectacular reef mounds built by the azooxanthellate coral Lophelia (-> 3) originate at present in eastern Atlantic Ocean of northwestern Europe, at the west Florida and the Bahama Bank slopes, the southeastern Brazilian continental slopes and on eastern Pacific seamounts. Azooxanthellate deep-water corals have the potential to construct large, biologically zoned framework-supported reef mounds below the storm wave base in the aphotic zone (Freiwald 1997). The coral reefs of the Nordic Seas in water depths between 200 and 1200 m can be followed tens of kilometers at lengths and widths of several hundreds of meters. 1 Coralline red algal reef: The reefal framework covers about 125 000 square meters and grows in water depths of 6 to 16 m. Litlzothamnion cf. glaciale is one of the most common framework builders. Note the high density of branching common in turbulent waters. The branches are a prominent source for the producrion of algal gravels and rhodoliths deposited onshore and offshore and producing rhodolith pavements. Troms District, Northern Norway. 2 Near-coast coralline algal gravel ('maerl') facies. Multiple fragmentation of branched rhodoliths caused by storms result in the formation of algal fragment accumulations. The maerl, a mixture of carbonate (skeletal) sand and seaweed is used as agricultural fertilizer. It characterizes cool-water temperate sediments, composed of unattached crusted-forming branched or nodular algae and algal gravel. In turbid, high-energy waters of the cool-temperate northwestern European Atlantic, maerl occurs mostly in the photic zone of wave-protected coasts at depths of 1-10 m (Freiwald et al. 1991). In the warmtemperate Mediterranean Sea, maerl is common in depths down to 40 m. Water depth 5 m. Troms District, Norway. 3 Azooxanthellate reef-forming deep-water coral (Lophelia pertusa). Azooxanthellate corals harbour no photosynthetic symbionts. The corals feed on suspended particles which are seasonally generated in the high-productivity euphotic zone. The corallites of Lophelia exhibit strong variations in the branching pattern, the shape and thickness of corallites, the diameter and the intratentacular budding patterns. These variations support the framebuilding potential of the anastomosing coral. Faroe Island Shelf. Water depth 252 m. 4 Open-shelf skeletal carbonate sediment composed of mollusks, bryozoans and serpulids. Malangsgrumen Bank, off Troms, northern Norway. Water depth 95 m. 5 Selected bioclasts (1-2 mm fraction) of the open-shelf skeletal carbonate shown in Fig. 4. Most bioclasts are bryozoans. The facies corresponds to the 'bryomol grain association' (see PI. 106/2,3) which is common on modem cool-temperate shelves. Water depth 90 m. Malangsgrumen Bank, off Tromso, northern Norway. 6 Arctic-benthic carbonate deposits of the seasonally sea ice-covered Spitsbergenbank (73'30' N and 9'10' W), western Barents Sea. Coquina-gravel lag deposit colonized by abundant bivalves (Mya truncata, - M , note the cylindrical siphones, arrow; Chlamys islandica - C), echinoids (E), hydrozoans, soft corals, balanids, sponges, bryozoans - B) attributed to the initiation of small-scale mounds. The high density of in situ organisms is due to a permanent high productivity zone at the boundary of Atlantic and Arctic surface waters over the flanks of the Spitsbergenbank. Water depth 79 m. -> 1-5: Courtesy of A. Freiwald (Erlangen), 6: Freiwald et al. 1991
Plate 4: Modern Cool-Water Carbonates
45
Deep-Marine Environments analysis of recent carbonate environments in the Southem Gulf of California, Mexico - a model for warrn-temperature to subtropical carbonate formation. - Palaios, 15, 323-342 Henrich, R., Freiwald, A., Schkfer, P. (1997): Evolution of an Arctic open-shelf carbonate platform, Spitsbergen Bank (Barents Sea). - In: James, N.P., Clarke, J.A.D. (eds.): Cool-water carbonates. - Soc. Econ. Paleont. Min., Spec. Publ., 56, 163-181 Henrich, R., Freiwald, A., Wehrmann, A., Schafer, P., Samtleben, C., Zankl, H. (1996): Nordic cold-water carbonates: Occurrences and controls. - GottingerArb. Geol. Palaont., Sonderband, 2, 35-52 Henrich, R., Hartrnann, M., Reitner, J., Schafer, P., Freiwald, A., Steinmetz, S., Dietrich, P., Thiede, J. (1992): Facies belts and communities of the arctic Vestrisbanken Seamount (Central Greenland Sea). - Facies, 27,71-104 James, N.P. (1997): The cool-water carbonate depositional realm. - In: James, N.P., Clarke, J.A.D. (eds.): Cool-water carbonates. - Soc. Econ. Paleont. Min., Spec. Publ., 56, 1-20 James, N.P., Bone, Y. (1989): Petrogenesis of Cenozoic, temperate water calcarenites, South Australia: a model for meteoric/shallow burial diagenesis of shallow water calcite sediments. - J. Sed. Petrol., 59, 191-204 James, N.P., Clarke, A.D. (eds., 1997): Cool-water carbonates. - Soc. Econ. Paleont. Min., Spec. Publ., 56,440 pp. James, N., Collins, L.B., Bone, Y., Hallock, P. (1999): Subtropical carbonates in a temperate realm: modem sediments on the southwest Australian shelf. - J. Sed. Petrol., 69,1297-1321 Lees, A. (1975): Possible influences of salinity and temperature on modem shelf carbonate sedimentation. - Marine Geol., 19, 159-198 Lees, A., Buller, A.T. (1972): Modem temperate-water and warm-water shelf carbonate sediments contrasted. - Marine Geol., 13, M67-M73 Macintyre, I.G. (1988): Modem coral reefs of western Atlantic: new geological perspective. -Amer. Ass. Petrol. Geol. Bull., 72, 1360-1369 Messing, C.G., Neumann, A.C., Lang, J.C. (1990): Biozonation of deep-water lithoherms and associated hardgrounds in the northeastern Straits of Florida. - Palaios, 5, 15-33 Mullins, H.T. (198 1): Modem deep-water coral mounds north of Little Baharna Bank: criteria for recognition of deepwater coral biohems in the rock record. - J. Sed. Petrol., 51,999-1013 Nelson, C.S. (1988): An introductory perspective on nontropical shelf carbonates. - Sed. Geol., 60, 3-12 Nelson, C.S., Bornhold, B.D. (1983):Temperate skeletal carbonate sediments on Scott Shelf, northwestern Vancouver Island, Canada. - Marine Geol., 52,24 1-266 Nelson, C.S., Keane, S.L., Head, P.S. (1988): Non-tropical carbonate deposits on the modem New Zealand shelf. In: Nelson, C.S. (ed.):Non-tropical shelf carbonates - modem and ancient. - Sed. Geol., 60,7 1-94, Neumann, A.C., Kofoed, J.W. , Keller, G.H. (1977): Lithotherms in the Straits of Florida. -Geology, 5,4-10 Rao, C.P. (1996): Modem carbonates, tropical, temperate, polar. Introduction to sedimentology and geochemistry. 206 pp., Howrah (Univ. Tasmania) Rao, C.P. (1997): A colour illustrated guide to sedimentary textures, cold, cool, warm, hot; An introduction to the interpretation of depositional, diagenetic and hydrothermal
temperatures. - 128 pp., Howrah, Tasmania (Rao, C.P.) Rao, C.P. (1999): Cold water polar aragoniticbivalve elemental composition,east Antarctica.-Carbonates and Evaporites, 14,56-63 Schafer, P., Henrich, R., Zankl, H., Bader, B. (1996): Carbonate production and depositional patterns of Bryomolcarbonates on deep shelf banks in mid and high northem latitudes. - Gijttinger Arb. Geol. Palaont., Sonderband, 2, 101-110 Scoffin, T.P., Bowes, G.E. (1988): The facies distribution of carbonate sediments on Porcupine Bank, northeast Atlantic. -In: Nelson, C.S. (ed.): Non-tropical shelf carbonates - modem and ancient. - Sed. Geol., 60, 125-134 Smith, A.M. (1988): Preliminary steps toward formation of a generalized budget for cold-water carbonates. -In: Nelson, C.S. (ed.): Non-tropical shelf carbonates - modem and ancient. - Sed. Geol., 60,323-33 1 Smith, A.M., Nelson, C.S., Spencer, H.G. (1998): Skeletal carbonate mineralogy of New Zealand bryozoans. - Marine Geol., 151,27-46 Teichert,C. (1958): Cold- and deep-water coral banks. -Bull. Amer. Ass. Petrol. Geol., 42, 1064-1082 Walther, J. (1910): Die Sedimente der Taubenbank im Golf von Neapel. - Preuss. Akad. Wiss., phys.-math. Kl., Anhang Abh. 3,1910,49 pp. Further reading: K021, K210 (glacial carbonates)
2.4.5 Deep-Marine Environments 2.4.5.1 Settings Oceanic deep-marine settings beyond the shelf break bordering pericontinental shelves include the slope, the base-of-slope and continental rise, the abyssal plains, mid-oceanic ridges, oceanic rises and volcanic seamounts, as well as deep-sea trenches. Deep-marine environments, however, also comprise parts of the deeper areas of peri- and epicontinental open shelves and of outer ramps, lying below the storm wave water base, and below the lower boundary of the well-lit zone. The bottom of the modem oceans comprises three bathymetrically defined zones (Fig. 2.2;Box 2.6). The bathyal zone lies to the seaward of the shallower subtidal shelf zone and landward of the deeper abyssal zone. The upper limit is marked by the edge of the continental shelf. The abyssal zone seaward of the bathyal zone covers approximately 75% of the total ocean floor. It pertains the nearly flat deep-sea plains. Abyssal plains are usually covered by thin deposits of pelagic ooze or distal turbidites. The lower limit of the zone is bathymetrically only loosely defined. The deepest area of the sea bottom, the hadal zone, lies specifically within the deep-sea trenches below the general level of the abyssal zone, in depths between >6 000 and more than 10 000 m. These marginal trenches are narrow, steepsided troughs running parallel to continental margins at seaward base of a continental platform.
Sedimentation Processes
NNNNNNNUNHNUNNNNNNNNNNNNN
CaC03
0ce
Reropods Foraminifera Coccolidhophores
an Radiolaria
Si02
--
Diatoms
7
Calcite compensation depth
*
In contrast to modem oceanic basins, many basins found in the geological record occur in cratonic positions and represent intra-platform or intra-shelf basins (e.g. pelagic epeiric basins). Note that the term basin as used by carbonate sedimentologists does not necessarily imply that carbonate basins are analogous to deep oceanic basins. Carbonate basins generally lie well above abyssal depth, commonly less than a few hundred meters below sea level. 2.4.5.2
Fig. 2.11. Sources and pathways of modern deep-sea sediments, deposited in tropical, temperate and boreal (polar) zones. Note that only the radiolarian oozes have a fossil record starting in the Paleozoic. Coccoliths (planktonic algae) and planktonic globigerinid foraminifera have become essential constituents of deep-sea sediments since the Cretaceous. The fossil record of deep-sea carbonates formed by pteropods (gastropods adapted to pelagic life) is scanty and limited to the Tertiary and Pleistocene (Buccheri et al. 1980). The earliest records of diatoms (siliceous algae) date from the Middle Cretaceous, but the group did not become important as sediment builders before the Tertiary. Modified from Hay (1974).
Sedimentation Processes
ooze, sediments derived from shallow-marine sources and deposited on slopes and basins, deep-sea clays and volcanic material, and glacial-marine sediments produced by ice-rafting (Fig. 2.1 1). The basic classification of deep-marine sediments considers grain size and composition. Currently used compositional classifications were developed by scientists participating in the DSDP and ODP programs (Berger 1974; Kennett 1982).
2.4.5.3
Pelagic Sedimentation
Biogenic deep-sea sediments are formed by the remains of pelagic organisms contributing to the formation of carbonate or siliceous oozes and muds. The term 'pelagic' means 'of the open sea' and refers to marine nektonic or planktonic organisms whose environment commonly is the open ocean. Large terrigenous sediment input and submarine volcanism cause mixtures of biogenic material and temgenous clays resulting in the formation of fine-grained muddy, 'hemipelagic sediments'. The character of the biogenic sediment depends on the supply of the biogenic material, the dissolution at and near the sea-bottom and in the water column, the dilution of the sediment by non-biogenic components, and alterations during diagenesis: The supply depends on the fertility of the pelagic organisms, which in turn Modem deep-sea deposits comprise biogenic sedi- is related to the availability of nutrients. Both nutrients ments including pelagic siliceous oozes and carbonate and sunlight control the primary production. The dis-
Sedimentation in the deep sea is controlled by four major processes (Cook and Mullins 1983; Cook et al. 1983; Enos and Moore 1983; Pickering et al. 1986; Stow 1985, 1986): (1) settling of marine pelagic and windblown material from the water column, (2) bottom transport by gravity flows including turbidity currents, debris flows, grain flows, and slumping, (3) redeposition of the sediment by geostrophic bottom currents including contour currents, and (4) chemical and biochemical precipitation on the sea floor. The first process is responsible for the deposition of pelagic sediments, the second one for the formation of a broad spectrum of resediments.
48
Glossary for Deep-Water Carbonates
Box 2.6. Glossary of terms used to describe deep-water carbonates Abyssal plains: Area of deep sea bottom below 2000 m and between 4000 and 6000 m, including the nearly flat deepsea plains covered by sediment. Accretionary slope: Adepositional slope, less steep than by-pass slopes. Characterized by net accumulation of sediments. Aragonite compensation depth (ACD): Level in the oceans where aragonite is dissolved. The bathymetrical position of the ACD and the CCD depends on the fertility of the surface waters and the degree of undersaturation of deep waters. Aseismic volcanic ridges: Volcanic seamounts, ridges and plateau, rising several kilometers above the deep ocean floor. Base-of-slope: The lower or lowermost part of slopes, continental rise. Bathyal: Sea bottom between about 200 (continental shelf edge, shelf break) and 2000 (4000) m, encompassing the continental slope and continental rise, down to the deep sea.. Bypass slope: Slopes on which sediment is transported from shallow to deeper water without significant deposition on the slope. Calcite compensation depth (CCD): The level in the deep oceans where the rate of dissolution of calcium carbonate (calcite) balances the rate of deposition and below which carbonate-free sediments accumulate. The level is characterized by a transition from carbonate ooze ro deep-marine clay or siliceous ooze. Today, the CCD has a mean depth of about 4.5 km, but varies between ocean basins. Note that large shifts of up to several thousand of meters of the CCD have occurred during the Meso- and Cenozoic. Chalk: Fine-grained porous carbonate rock, predominantly composed of pelagic nanno- and microfossils, and deposited on deeper shelves and basins. Continental rise: Setting at the foot of the continental slope between the slope and the deep ocean basin, characterized by a gently sloping surface created by coalescing submarine fans. Sedimentation takes place by downward sediment transport and deposition at the slope base. The continental rise may be subdivided by submarine canyons and deepsea channels. Contourite: Sediment deposited on the continental rise by contour-following bottom currents. Debris flow: A sediment gravity flow. Sediment transport by a cohesive matrix. Corresponds to mudflow. Erosional slope: A steep slope. Net sediment loss. Erosion due to rockfalls, sediment gravity flows and the effect of contour currents. Grain flow: A sediment gravity flow. Grains are supported during the sediment transport by dispersive pressure arising from grain collisions. Gravity flows: Downslope flow of sediment. Comprises turbidites, grains flows, and debris flows. Guyot: A type of seamount with a platform top. Hadal: Deepest area of sea bottom, lying specifically within the deep-sea trenches below the general level of the abyssal zone, between 6000 and > 10,000 m. Hemipelagic sediments: Fine-grained muddy sediment consisting of a mixture of calcareous biogenic material and tenigenous clay. More than 25% of the fraction coarser than 5 pm is of temgenous or volcanic origln. The sediment has undergone lateral transport. Deposited near continental margins, on slopes, abyssal plains, and ridges. Lysocline: The level or ocean depth at which the rate of dissolution of calcium carbonate just exceeds its combined rate of deposition and precipitation. The lysocline is characterized by a noticeable decrease in the percentage of deepmarine carbonate sediments and by an interval separating well-preserved from poorly preserved microfossil assemblages. The calcite lysocline is defined by planktonic foraminifera and calcareous nannofossils, the aragonite lysocline by pteropods. Oceanic basin: Comprises various deep-sea settings including abyssal plains, volcanic hills, mid-oceanic ridges and deep-sea trenches. Oceanic plateau: Topographically high area of the ocean floor that rises to within 2-3 km of the sea floor surface above the abyssal floor. Many Pacific plateaus are covered by carbonate ooze overlying volcanic rocks. Pelagic carbonates: Fine-grained calcareous sediments of the open sea, composed chiefly of the skeletal debris of calcareous planktonic organisms, and deposited in a range of deep-water settings (slopes, ocean floor, seamounts, mid-oceanic ridges). Periplatform sediments: Intermixed platform-derived sediments and pelagic carbonate muds (Schlager and James 1978). 1 Resedimented carbonates: Carbonate rocks characterized by redeposition of shallow-water carbonate sediment into deep water. Submarine mass transport and redeposition is related to a variety of processes, including rockfalls, slides, slumps, and gravity flows. Resedimented carbonates may be additionally reworked by deep-marine bottom currents. Rockfalls: Single blocks or many clasts derived from steep slopes of the shelf margins and deposited in talus piles at the base of slopes or as blocks on the slopes. Abundant along fault-bounded platform margins and along fore-reef slopes. Seamount: Elevation of the sea floor, 1000 m or higher, flat-topped (Guyot) or peaked. Slope: Surface which connects the shelf or the shelf break with the continental rise or the deep-sea floor. Turbidite: A sediment laid down by a turbidity current. Characterized by graded bedding, moderate sorting and a vertical sequence of distinct sedimentary structures. Turbidity currents are initiated by the disturbance of the sediment near the shelf margin or on the slope; deposit originally shallow-water sediments on the slope, at the foot of the slope and on abyssal plains. Limestone turbidites are called 'calciturbidites' or 'allodapic limestones'.
I
1
l
Resedimentation
tribution of pelagic sediments on the sea bottoms is controlled by the different dissolution of biogenic grains, produced in the surface waters of the oceans. Most dissolution of siliceous tests (radiolaria, diatoms) occurs in highly silica-undersaturated shallow surface waters. In contrast, most dissolution of carbonate tests takes place on the sea floor as bottom waters become more undersaturated in calcium carbonate. Therefore, siliceous biogenic sediments reflect the biological fertility of the surface waters, whereas carbonate biogenic deep-sea sediments chiefly reflect the preservation potential of carbonate at various depths. The proportions of siliceous and carbonate-rich oozes depend on bottom-water circulation which controls both dissolution pattems, and, through upwelling, fertility pattems (Berger 1970,1974,1976).Differences in the composition of pelagic calcareous plankton reflect differences in oligotrophic, mesotrophic and eutrophic nutrient environments (Henrich et al. 2001).
2.4.5.4 Resedimentation ('Allochthonous Carbonates')
2.4.5.5 Carbonate Plankton and Carbonate Oozes Carbonate oozes cover about 50% of the modem ocean floor. They are deposited on deep-sea plains, submarine rises, ridges and plateaus. Modem carbonate oozes consisting of the shells of minute drifting planktonic organisms comprise foraminifera1 ooze, namofossil ooze and pteropod ooze: Foraminifera1 oozes are dominated by tests of sand-sized planktonic foraminifera (Pl. 73/10) occurring within carbonate mud consisting of calcareous namofossils. Nannofossil oozes or coccolith oozes are very fine-grained muds composed predominantly of remains of planktonic algae (Chrysophyta: Coccolithophorida; P1. 713-5). Pteropod oozes are restricted o shallow tropical areas in depths < 3 000 m. They consist of aragonitic shells of planktonic gastropods (pteropods and heteropods). The carbonate production is greatest in surface waters with high biological productivity caused by upwelling. Production and growh rates of pelagic foraminifera and coccolithophorids are differnt.
Plankton contributes to the sedimentary record by (1) settling of individual tests, (2) fecal pelletization, Downslope gravity transport along deep-marine slopes and (3) the deposition of various biogenic materials (inoccurs by various processes including rockfall, slump- cluding 'marine snow', aggregates, flocks and particuing, sliding, and sediment gravity flows. late organic matter, POM). Individual settling may play Subaqueous rockfalls occur in areas with very steep a role in the deposition of larger microfossils (e.g. foratopography producing talus and scree deposits at the minifera, radiolarians), but fecal pelletization and seabase of slopes. sonally varying sinks of detrital aggregates (e.g. phyA slump is a downslope translocation of a sediment todetritus displaying an important food resource in the parcel along discrete shear planes. In slides, large blocks deep sea, Thiel et al. 1988) play the greatest role in the move on only a few slippage planes. Both slumping transportation of smaller tests (e.g. coccolithophorids; and sliding are controlled and triggered by high rates Honjo 1976). of sedimentation creating oversteep slopes and differential compaction, structural changes (e.g. effect of salt -> A cautionary note: Comparable calcareous plankdomes) as well as by earthquakes. In sediment gravity ton is not known from pre-Mesozoic records and comflows, the sediment is transported downwards under parisons with modem analogues work for pelagic Methe influence of gravity. sozoic-Tertiary carbonates, but not for Paleozoic slope The sediments are transported by different mecha- and basin carbonates (see Sect.15.8). nisms: In 'grain flows', the sediment is supported during transport by direct grain to grain interactions. In 'debris flows' larger grains are supported by a matrix 2.4.5.6 Preservation Potential and Dissolution consisting of a mixture of fine sediment and interstitial Levels fluid. In 'turbidity currents', the sediment is supported In modem oeans carbonate sediments are largely mainly by the upward component of fluid turbulence. absent below depth of about 4500 m. High hydrostatic The resulting deposits differ in grain size, sorting, tex- pressure, low water temperature and high partial presture and sedimentary structures. Because turbidity cur- sure of C02 lead to dissolution and significant diferrents are episodic, the resulting turbidites are interbed- ences in the carbonate preservation potential of deepded with finer pelagic sediments representing the back- sa sediments. These differences have been used to disground sedimentation. tinguish two levels:
50
(1 ) The lysocline, defined as the depth that separates well-preserved from poorly preserved planktonic assemblages and where a noticeable decrease in the percentage of carbonate occurs. Because calcareous microfossils dissolve at different rates, three types of lysoclines are used: the pteropod or aragonite lysocline (ALy), defining significant dissolution of aragonite material occurring in relatively shallow depths; and the foraminifera1lysocline and the coccolith lysocline (calcite lysocline, CLy), defining the significant dissolution of calcite material in greater water depths. (2) The calcite compensation depth (CCD) is defined as the depths at which calcite microfossils and carbonate arelargely absent. The depth of the CCD in modem oceans varies between about 4 200 and 5 400 m, with a mean depth of about 4500 m. At that level, the rate of dissolution balances the rate of accumulation. -> A cautionary note: The depth position of the CCD in Phanerozoic oceans has varied during geological time owing to fluctuations in the amount of carbonate being brought into the oceans from the land, variations in hydrothermal activity, or increased carbonate production on the shelves. Because the calcareous tests of planktonic organisms differ in dissolution susceptibilities, dissolution types can be used to record steps in the formation of diagenetic patterns. Present-day foraminifera species exhibit a dissolution ranking that is strongly controlled by the thickness, size and shape of the tests. Most coccoliths are more resistant than foraminifera with regard to dissolution. First evidence of coccolith dissolution occurs in depths above 3000 m, but changes in the composition of the assemblages become evident in depths between 3000 and about 5000 m.
2.4.5.7 Carbonate Slopes, Periplatform Carbonates and Carbonate Aprons Gravity flows, particularly turidites and debris flow deposits, are common on carbonate slopes, and also occur in basins (Cook et al. 1983; McIlreaii992). These sediments are derived from shallow-water platform and platform-edge settings, sometimes also from the upper slope, and transported to upper, mid and lower slope settings. Carbonate slopes were categorized as: (1) 'by-pass slopes' on which sediment is transported from shallower to deeper water without significant deposition on the slope: gravity flows bypass the slopes nd accumulate in adjacent basins. (2) less steep 'depositional or accretionary slopes' where gravity flow sediments are predominantly deposited in lower slope settings, as dem-
Basics: Deep-Marine Carbonates
onstrated by excellent examples from the Holocene Bahamian slopes. The resulting fine-grained 'periplatform carbonates' (Schlager and James 1978; Boardman and Neumann 1984; Boardman et al. 1986; Pilskaln et al. 1989) form a sequence of resedimented shallow-marine carbonates intercalated within pelagic carbonates. The Bahamian carbonate slopes (Straits of Florida, Little Bahama Bank) offer the possibility of studying the interplay between allochthonous and pelagic sedimentation, and submarine cementation, resulting in the formation of hardgrounds. The periplatform ooze of the upper slope consists of a mixture of bankderived material and pelagic debris. Lower slope and base-of-slope seiments are turbidites and mud- or grain-suported debris flow deposits, interbedded with periplatform ooze, and forming large carbonate aprons. Cyclic variations in the prevailing mineralogy (aragonitic and Mg-calcitic platform-derived grains vs calcitic pelagic grains) of periplatform carbonates and differences in the abundance of platform-derived and pelagic carbonates signalize climate changes, sea-level fluctuations and changes in the rate of carbonate production on the platforms which are reflected by microfacies analysis (Sect. 16.1). Another promising approach of microfacies studies is the evaluation of the controls on the different declivities of carbonate slopes which depends greatly on the primary depositional texture. Basics: Deep-marine carbonates Berger, W.H. (1991): Produktivitat des Ozeans aus geologischer Sicht: Denkmodelle und Beispiele. - Zeitschrift der deutschen geologischen Gesellschaft, 142, 149-178 Cook, E., Enos, P. (eds., 1977): Deep water carbonate environments. - Soc. Econ. Palwnt. MUI.Spec. Publ., 25,336 pp. Cook, H.E., Hine, A.C., Mullins, H.T. (1983): Platform margin and deep water carbonates. - Soc. Econ. Paleont. Min. Short Course, 12,563 pp. Cook, H.E., Mullins, H.T. (1983): Basin margin environment. -In: Scholle, P.A., Bebout, D.G., Moore, C.H.(eds.): Carbonate depositional environments. - Amer. Ass. Petrol. Geol. Mem., 33,539-617 Coniglio, M., Dix, G.R. (1992): Carbonates slopes. - In: Walker, R.G., James, N.P. (eds.): Facies models. Response to sea level change. - 349-373, Ottawa (Geol. Ass. Canada) Crevello, P.D., Harris, P.M. (1985): Deep water carbonates: buildups, turbidites, debris flows and chalks. -Soc. Econ. Paleont. Min. Core Workshop, 6,527 pp. Doyle, L.J., Pilkey, O.H. (eds., 1979): Geology of continental slopes. - Soc. Econ. Paleont. Min. Spec. hbl., 27,374 pp. Enos, P., Moore, C.H. (1983): Fore-reef slope environment. -In: Scholle, P.A., Bebout, D.G., Moore,C.H. (eds.): Carbonate depositional environments. - Amer. Ass. Petrol. Geol. Mem., 33,507-537 Hsii, K.J., Jenkyns, H.C. (eds., 1974): Pelagic sediments: on land and under the sea. -Spec. Publ. Int. Ass. Sedimentol., 1,447 pp.
Seep and Vent Carbonates Leggett, J.K. (1985): Deep-sea pelagic sediments and palaeooceanography: a review of recent progress. -In: Brenchley, P., Williams, B.P.J. (eds.): Sedimentology, recent developments and applied aspects. -95-118, Oxford (Blackwell) Little C.T.S., Campbell, K.A., Herrington, R.J. (2002): Why did ancient chemosynthetic seep and vent assemblages occur in shallower water than they do today? Comment. Int. J. Earth Sciences, 91, 149-153 Macilreath, LA., James, N.P. (1979): Facies models. Carbonate slopes. - Geosci. Canada Reprint Ser., 5, 189-199 Milliman, J.D., Droxler, A.W. (1996): Neritic and pelagic carbonate sedimentation in the marine environment: ignorance is not bliss. - Geol. Rundschau, 85,496-504 Mullins, H.T. (1986): Periplatform carbonates. - Colorado School Mines Quart., 81,63 pp. Mullins, H.T., Cook, H.E. (1986): Carbonate apron models: alternatives to the submarine fan model for paleoenvironmental analysis and hydrocarbonexploration. - Sed. Geol., 48,37-79 Oxburgh, R., Broecker, W.S. (1993): Pacific carbonate dissolution revisited. - Palaeogeogr., Palaeoclimat., Palaeoecol., 103,31-39 Schlager, W., Chermak, A. (1979): Sediment facies of platform-basin transition, Tongue of the Ocean, Bahamas. Soc. Econ. Paleont. Min. Spec. Publ., 27, 193-208 Schlager, W., Camber, 0.(1986): Submarine slope angles, drowning unconformities, an self-erosion of limestone escarpments. - Geology, 14,762-765 Schlanger, S.O., Douglas, R.G. (1974): Pelagic ooze-chalklimestone transition and its implicationsfor marine stratigraphy. -Spec. Publ. Int. Ass. Sedimentol., 1, 117-148 Shanrnugarn, G. (2000): 50 years of the turbidite paradigm (1950s - 1990s): deep-water processes and facies models a critical perspective. - Marine Petroleum Geol., 17, 285342 Stow, D.A.V., FaugCres, J.C. (eds., 1998): Contourites, turbidites and process interaction. - Sed. Geol., 115, 1-386 Westphal, H., Reijmer, J.J.G., Head, M.J. (1999): Sedimentary input and diagenesis on a carbonate slope (Bahamas): response to morphologic evolution of the carbonate platform and sea-level fluctuations.- In: Harris, P.M., Saller, A.H., Simo, J.A.T. (eds.): Advances in carbonate sequence stratigraphy: application to reservoirs, outcrops, and models.- Soc. Econ. Paleont. Min. Spec. Publ., 63,247-274 Further reading: K022, K023, KO24
Kemish 1993). The very first vent site with sea-bed dwelling large benthic organisms was discovered 1977 on the Galapagos rift in the eastern Pacific, where hydrothermal vent organisms are associated with sulfide mineralizations and surround black and white smokers within an area of a few hundreds of square meters. Today, examples of seep and vent communities are known from the Pacific (Fig. 2.12), the Monterey Bay of Califomia, the Gulf of Mexico, the continental slope off Louisiana, the North Sea and the Black Sea (Nybakken 1993). Modem cold-seep communities are nearly always found in oligotroph waters of the aphotic zone, and occur from shallow to deep water down to about 3000 m (Callender and Powell 1999, Little et al. 2002). The success of the low-diversity vent communities (consisting of bivalves, vestimentiferan tube-worms, arthropods) depends on specialized anaerobic bacteria, which build carbon molecules using reduced inorganic compounds (particularly sulfides) that are contained in the heated water gushing from the vents. The low-diversity vent communities depend on these endosymbiontic bacteria. Bivalves (giant vesicomyid clams, infaunal lucinids) are able to exploit directly gas seepage by hosting chemoautotrophic bacteria in symbiosis in the gills. The symbionts produce organic matter via chemosynthesis using methane or sulfur from vented fluids or available in the environment. Hydrothermal vent communities and cold seep communities are phylogenetically related and show similarities in the physiology and anatomy of their dominant organisms.
2.4.6 Seep and Vent Carbonates
Cold-seep communities contribute to the formation of a specific carbonate rock type. Characteristics of these limestones are (1) carbonate beds embedded in shales or mounds exhibiting irregular textures, and occurring within a strongly differing facies, (2) low-diversity but abundant mollusks, and (3) abundant authigenic carbonate cements. Ancient vent and seep carbonates are becoming increasingly more frequently reported from the Phanerozoic rock record (see Sect. 16.5).
One of the most exciting discoveries in the last twenty years is the recognition of authigenic and biogenic carbonates formed in deep-water settings by fluid and gas expulsions near cold seeps and hydrothermal vents (Beauchamp and von Bitter 1992). Biomass concentrations of organisms with calcareous shells occur near hot hydrothermal vents on midocean ridges and cluster around cold seeps of natural gas, brines, hydrocarbon and methane in varying depths of the oceans, particularly within faulted continental margin environments (Tunnicliffe 1992; Lutz and
Basics: Seep and vent carbonates Aharon, P. (2000): Microbial processes and products fueled by hydrocarbons at submarine seeps. - In: Riding, R.E., Awramik, S.M. (eds.): Microbial sediments. - 270-282, Berlin (Springer) Beauchamp, B., von Bitter, P. (eds., 1992): Chemosynthesis: geological processes and products. - Palaios, 7, 337-484 (with papers on modem and ancient chemosynthetic carbonates) Callender, W.R., Powell, E.N. (1997): Autochthonous death assemblages from chemosynthetic communities at petroleum seeps: biomass, energy flow and implications for the fossil record. - Hist. Biology, 12, 165-198
This book consists of three major parts. This first part 'Microfacies Analysis', deals with the methods of microfacies studies (Chap. 3), qualitative and quantitative microfacies data (Chap. 4, 5 and 6), diagenetic criteria (Chap. 7), limestone classification (Chap. 8) and biological controls on the formation of carbonate rocks (Chap. 9 and 10).
3 Methods
This chapter summarizes field work studies, sampling strategies and laboratoy methods relevant to microfacies analysis. A precise field record of geological and paleontological data as well as sampling strategies that consider the vertical and lateral variations in these data are vital for the success of microfacies studies. Laboratory methods study microscopic features and mineralogical and geochemical data.
A highly recommended description of field methods is given by Tucker (1982). The methods used in the study of litho- and biofacies of sedimentary rocks are the subject of several textbooks (Leeder 1982; Lewis 1984; Pettijohn et al. 1987; Miall 1990; Chamley 1990; Blatt 1992,Friedman et al. 1992, Lewis and McConchie 1993; Boggs 1995; Reading 1996; Leeder 1999; Miali 2000; Einsele 2000).
3.1 Field Work and Sampling
3.1.1.1 Lithology, Texture and Rock Colors
Many criteria that are important in facies interpretation can not be recognized sufficiently in small-scale microfacies. Paleoenvironmental interpretations derived from microfacies should be controlled by lithological criteria and sedimentary structures evaluated by the high information potential provided by fossils and biogenic structures. Microfacies sampling requires an understanding of the meaning of bedding and the depositional characters reflected by sedimentary structures.
Lithology: Sedimentary rocks are classified into siliciclastic rocks (claystone/mudstone, siltstone and sandstone), conglomerates and breccias, carbonate rocks (limestone, dolomite), mixed siliciclastic-carbonates (marl, argillaceous and sandy limestones), evaporites (gypsum, anhydrite, salt), siliceous sedimentary rocks (cherts), phosphorites and organic-rich rocks. Carbonate rocks make up 20 to 25 percent of all sedimentary rocks in the geological record and are classified into limestones and dolomites (dolostones); see Fig. 3.1. Limestones consist of more than 50% CaC03. They comprise limestones and dolomitic limestones. Dolomites are composed of more than 50% CaMg(C03), and are subdivided into calcitic dolomites (50-90% dolomite) and dolomites. Although detailed differentiation of carbonate rocks is best performed in the laboratory, field distinctions can also be made, using dilute 10% hydrochloric acid (limestone will fizz strongly, dolomite will show little or no reaction). Alizarin-red-
3.1.1 Field Observations
Field work forms the basis for studying sedimentary deposits. Criteria that can be studied in outcrops and cores in facies analyses are: lithology, texture, rock color, bedding, sedimentary structures and diagenetic features, and fossils and biogenic structures.
Rock Color Carbonate lithologies Dolomite 0
10
Limestone
90
50
Dolomitic limestone
Calcareous
100%
Dolomite
dolomite
Mixed siliciclastic-carbonatel i l o g i e s
Marl
Argillaceous l~mestone
Bituminous argtllaceous hmestone
Sandy
limestone
Fig. 3.1. Common lithologies of carbonate rocks and mixed
carbonate-siliciclasticrocks. The symbols used are those from the standard Shell Legend.
S in weak HC1 stains limestone pink to mauve but leaves dolomite unstained. Mixed siliciclastic-carbonate lithologies include marls (a sediment consisting of 65-35% carbonate and 35-65% clay), argillaceous limestones (a limestone containing an appreciable amount of clay, less than 50%) and sandy limestones (a limestone containing an appreciable amount of quartz sand).
Texture: Attention should be focused on the depositional variability of limestone beds, on depositional processes recorded by characteristic sedimentary patterns, and on the control of microfacies-based paleoenvironmental interpretations using larger-scaled criteria. The texture of major limestone types can be characterized in the field using the classification proposed by Dunham (1962); see Sect. 8.3.2. Much information is provided by the size, shape and sorting of grains, the ratio of matrix to grains, and the fabric. Details are described in Chap. 4. The textural composition of beds and laminae may be characterized by distinct vertical gradations in grain size (graded bedding). 'Normal grading' (coarser grains at the base, finer grains at the top) and 'reverse or inverse grading' (coarser particles at the top grading downwards to finer particles) are important in the interpretation of depositional processes (PI. 1711, PI. 10212, PI. 11512, PI. 1161 1, PI. 12612). Rock color: Many limestones are a shade of gray, but limestones can also display distinctive rock colors which need a more precisive terminology (Folk 1969). Dolomites are often creamy yellow or brown in color. Rock colors can be characterized by simple verbal descriptions (e.g. medium to dark gray) or by comparing fresh rock fracture surfaces with standard color schemes
(e.g. U.S. National Research Council Rock-Color Chart based on the Munsell Color System: Goddard et al. 1948). The use of the Rock Color Chart requires (a) determination of the gradation of color (hue), followed by (b) estimation of light to dark values, and (c) estimation of the degree of saturation (chroma). Colors are indicated by a code (e.g. 5 R 416) or by a descriptive name (e.g. moderate red). Color names used in the Rock Color Chart do not always correspond to the subjective color impression of geologists, which may be adequate for general surveys but not, for example for the characterization of carbonate rocks used in the arts or as building stones. Colorimetric analysis is another approach but relatively rarely used for limestones (Engelbrecht 1992), except when determining technological criteria. Colors of carbonate rocks are strongly controlled by depositional conditions, diagenesis and recent weathering. The amount and composition of the non-carbonate fraction is crucial for the color aspect because the adsorption of iron and manganese on the surface of finely dispersed clay minerals is often responsible for distinct colors. Fe and Mn content, rock color and depositional facies may exhibit distinct correlations, specifically in hemipelagic and pelagic sediments. Of particular significance is the oxidation-reduction balance: Yellow colors, for example, can be caused by the oxidation of FeS as demonstrated by the famous Jurassic Solnhofen Limestone of Southern Germany which appears in fresh samples bluish gray. Comparisons of photometric color measurements with geochemical data of limestones indicate correlations of bluish and yellowish colors with pyrite and goethite contents and dark or light rock color values with clay and silt contents. Green and drab gray colors may be caused by organically derived carbon and Fe2+ compounds such as sulfides in reduced sediments. Various shades of red, yellow and brown colors are due to Fe3+ compounds such as hematite and limonite in oxidized sediments. Yellowish shades of marbles can be caused by small quantities of siderite. Dark colors are also induced by aromatic hydrocarbons (pure solvent-soluble organic matter composed of carbon and hydrogen only). The amount of organic matter and the degree of light reflection are related (Patnode 1941). Black colors can also be caused by thermal heating. Sedimentary limestones may undergo considerable color change during metamorphism (Winkler 1994).
Why is this limestone red? Vivid rock colors generally provoke questions which are difficult to answer.
Bedding
Very generally, the coloration of sediments is regarded as synsedimentary (caused by the input of detrital coloring material or by contributions of ferric bacteria; Mamet et al. 1997) or postsedimentary (caused by diagenetic changes within the sediment or coloration by overlying beds). Red limestones may serve as an example for the problems involved: The red color of marine carbonates is primarily caused by small amounts of ~ e (about ~ + 2%: Franke and Paul 1980). Volcanic emanations provide a direct source of iron in seawater. But the weathering of land masses associated with an input of iron to the sea (as colloids or absorbed on clay minerals) and organic matter provide the major source. Low sedimentation rates, near-bottom waters rich in oxygen, the absence of sulfate-reducing bacteria as well as the local Eh/pH potential within the sediment and at the sedimentlwater interface favor the development of red colors (e.g. by dehydration of goethite to hematite: Rech-Frollo 1971).The intensity of the red coloration may depend on the amount of detrital material and iron (Hallam 1967; Fliigel and Tietz 1971). Because iron is transported from land to sea via several solution/precipitation-phases, the importance of climatic controls for the formation of red limestones must also be considered. The following diagenetic factors promote rock coloration: (a) Compaction facilitates the flow of oxydized pore water through the sediment. (b) Pressure solution and freeing of iron from clay minerals may be responsible for red-colored stylolite seams, often occumng together with burial dolomites (Mattes and Mountjoy 1980). (c) During dedolomitization, Fe originally incorporated in dolomite can be precipitated as FeO(0H) and oxidized to Fe,03, producing reddish rock colors. cm
/
Shell Standard Legend 1995 Meter bedded
1
Colored paleosols (e.g. terra rossa, a residual soil, over limestone bedrock, typically in karst areas) can impact on rock colors. Reddening of paleosol horizons is caused by (a) in situ alterations of iron-rich clays, (b) reddened detritus brought from the exposed surface downward through the soil by percolating waters, (c) dehydration of goethite to limonite and hematite during subaerial exposure in a well-drained environment (Retallack 1981), or (d) concentration of reddish matrix by eluviation within the paleosol profile during alternating wet and dry climate periods (Goldhammer and Elmore 1984). Terra rossa, brought to the sea will not directly cause red colors (Hinze and Meischner 1968). Near-surface cavities in karstified reef limestones may contain red internal sediments, derived from an overlying soil zone, with deeper cavities being filled with green and gray internal sediments (Satterley et al. 1994). Changes of rock colors with depth below the surface indicate changes in the oxidation state within the vadose and phreatic zones (Esteban 1991).
3.1.1.2 Bedding and Stratification, Sedimentary Structures and Diagenetic Features Many of the structures described in this subchapter can also be recognized at a microfacies scale, particularly sedimentary fabrics and diagenetic textures (Fig. 3.4). Bedding and stratzfication: Carbonate rocks are stratified or non-stratified. Non-strat@cation is a result of (a) primary lack of bedding (e.g. in reefs), (b) bed-destructing processes (e.g. intensive burrowing), or (c) diagenetic processes (e.g. dolomitization or strong recrystallization of limestones).
Boggs 1995
Demicco and Hardie 1994
Very thickly bedded
100
Thickly bedded 30
I
Layers greater than 100 mm, thick to very thick beds
Decimeter bedded Medium bedded Thinly bedded
3
Centimeter bedded Very thinly bedded
-1-
Layers 5 mm to 100 mm, Laminae >5 mm Thin beds 4 0 0 mm
Thickly laminated 0.3
Millimeter bedded
Layers <5 mm, fine laminae Thinly laminated
Fig. 3.2. Commonfield classifications of stratified sediments. The Shell classificationis based on scales. Many textbooks on sedimentology, e.g. Boggs (1995), recommend a classification based on thickness ranges. Demicco and Hardie use only three thickness categories, whose limits were determined by the experience of the authors studying predominantly Upper Proterozoic and Lower Paleozoic carbonates. In choosing 5 mm as the upper boundary of the thinnest category, the importance of thin microbial mats in tidal flats has been considered. Bed thicknesses between 0.5 and 10 cm and between 10 and 30 cm are common in shelf carbonates.
Thickness of Beds
bounded above and below by distinct surfaces are called bedsets (Collinson and Thompson 1982). Limestones consisting of thin, strictly parallel or non-parallel laminae are named laminites (Sect. 5.1.3). The descriptive term 'Plattenkalk' refers to sequences composed of fine-grained, laminated limestones, which are bedded in flat centimeter-decimeter thick, parallelsided units (Swinburne and Hemleben 1994).
Fig. 3.3. Geometries of carbonate rock layers. Thii sections. Left - Planar fine-laminated limestone characterized by alternating millimeter-scale lamina couplets consisting of mudstone (dark gray) and packstone (light streaks).The black line in the center and the black spots near the top are bitumina. Note the extremely fine lamination within the lamina couplets, the parallel orientation of fine shells and the concave-up position of the ostracod shell near the top of the sample. These criteria indicate suspension settle-out of mud (calcisiltite) within a quiet-water environment, alternating with sporadic influx of peloids, clay and terrigenous quartz grains transported by gentle traction currents. The sample represents an organic-rich facies formed in small isolated, tectonically induced basins within an intertidal to subtidal carbonate platform. The bitumen-rich limestones were deposited from a stratified water body with anaerobic and dysaerobic conditions (Czurda 1973; Hopf et al. 2001). Large-scale cyclicity was controlled by sea-level change, small-scale cyclicity was controlled by climatic and seasonal fluctuations. These limestones are regarded as potential carbonatic source rocks. Right - Wavy-crinkled$ne laminated dolomite characterized by irregularly undulated stromatolitic layers. Black laminae are interpreted as the result of microbial activity (binding of sediment, accumulation of organic material). The sample represents the intertidal part of the Hauptdolomit platform. Both samples are from the Late Triassic Hauptdolomit of the Wiestal quarry,Gaissau, SalzburgiAustria.Scale is 5 mm.
Stratificatio : A bed is a tabular or lenticular layer that is sufficiently distinct from under- and overlaying strata with respect to lithology, composition and texture and separated from these strata by recognizable boundary planes. Genetically, a bed may represent a depositional episode during which physical conditions did not change significantly ('sedimentation unit': Otto 1938). Following the proposal of McKee and Weir (1953) the term bed should be limited to strata thicker than 1 cm. Very thin strata (thickness <1 cm) are called laminae (Campbell 1967). Laminae are the result of changing depositional conditions causing variations in the grain size, texture, mineral composition, and content of clay and organic material. Groups of laminae forming a distinct sedimentary structure are called laminasets. Groups of similar beds or cross-beds,
Field studies of bedding and stratification must consider (1) boundary planes and bedding surfaces, (2) bed thickness, (3) composition and internal structure of beds, and (4) vertical bed sequences. (1) Boundary planes and bedding s u ~ a c e s Upper : and lower surfaces of beds are called bedding planes, most of which are caused by abrupt changes in depositional conditions, non-deposition or erosion. However, bedding planes also result from diagenetic processes or weathering. Pressure solution and stylolite seams parallel to depositional bedding may produce 'pseudo-bedding' simulating true depositional bedding, and leading to sampling problems, because bed-lo-bed sampling usually relies on the assumption of sedimentary boundary planes. Bedding surfaces are abrupt planar, abrupt irregular or gradational, with even (flat), wavy or curved surfaces that are parallel or non-parallel to each other. Differences in bedding surfaces provide information related to the time span of non-deposition (e.g. scalloped or irregular potholed surfaces, sometimes with paleosols, indicate a paleokarst stage; irregularly shaped hardgrounds may point to deep-marine solution). Sedimentary structures on top and bottom surfaces of bedding planes provide information about depositional energy and substrate features. Some of the more common structures on the top surfaces of limestones are modifications of surface topography, bed forms (ripples, dunes, hummocks), shrinkage cracks and primary current lineations, and various trace fossils. Structures seen on bottom surfaces include flute marks, groove marks, tool marks, scour structures as well as load marks.
(2) Bed thickness: Terminologies for the bed and laminae thickness have been proposed by various authors (McKee and Weir 1953; Ingram 1954; Reineck and Singh 1980), but none has been generally accepted. Ingram's scale (used by many authors) and the Shell approach (distinguishing only 'ranges') are to be recommended (Fig. 3.2). Demicco and Hardie (1994) distinguish three layer categories based on layer thickness, layer boundary geometry, and textural layer composition. This classification is a practical key to the identi-
Field Criteria
Peritidal
Stratification Planar lamination Wav lamination. ~ r l n h e dlamwat~on Planar thin bedding Wa thin beddin ~ r i z e thin d d n g Planar thick begin Wavy-cnnkled thck%edding Hummoc cross-bedd~ng Large-sca e cross-bedding Wave-r! ple cross-beddlng ~eterollrhlccross-bedding Small-scale cross-bedding Graded bedding Cracks - .- -..Mud cracks Prism cracks Sheet cracks Fenestrae Breccias Conglomerates Storm-la lithoclast gravels channel$ gravels Ed ewlse gravels lmhcate gravels Limestone breccias Submarine hardgrounds Ne tunian dykes ~erormationstructures Nodular structures Biogenic structures Microbial laminites Stromatolites Thrombolites Bioturbation Dia enetic structures ~agiche Tepee Solution pores Evaporite minerals Chicken-wlre sulfates Deformed sulfate layers
",
-
Fig. 3.4. Commonfield criteria of carbonate rocks include stratification types as well as sedimentary and diagenetic structures. The processes causing many of these structures are highlighted by microfacies data (black dots). The figure considers the scheme developed by Demicco and Hardie (1994) for shallow-marine carbonates.
fication and interpretation of layering without crossstratification, and can be applied both to field and thinsection observations (see Fig. 3.3 and P1. 18). Bed thickness analysis of limestones can be used in recognizing breaks in sedimentation, cyclic sedimentation patterns and gradual environmental changes. These investigations are based on the hypothesis that the thicknesses of stratigraphic units follows a lognormal distribution (Lumsden 1979). (3) Composition and internal structure: Beds appearing internally homogeneous (massive, structureless) in the field, may exhibit textural and structural inhomogenities when studied using staining and etching methods, ultra-thin sections, X-ray or tomography (Larsen and Theide 1971; Kenter 1989).
Many beds are internally differentiated into laminae and a number of informal units. Laminae result from short changes in the depositional conditions causing variations in grain size, composition and texture, fossil content as well as the content of non-carbonate and organic material. Small-scale laminations of fine-grained limestones assist in recognizing of yearly varves, distal turbidites or tidal rhythmites (Brown et al. 1990; Archer and Feldman 1994). Fine-scale biogenic lamination is particularly common in lagoonal and lacustrine sediments; stratification types of lake sediments were classified by Cole and Picard (1975) and Bullwinkel and Riegel(2001). Internal layers and laminae that are essentially parallel to the bedding planes constitute a planar stratification or planar lamination (Fig. 3.3). A practical key
Fossils and Biogenic Structures
for identifying and interpreting layering in carbonates without internal cross-stratification was provided by Demicco and Hardie (1994). The classification is based on layer thickness (Fig. 3.2, layer geometry (planar: P1. 2017; wavy: P1. 18/2,4, P1. 12311; and crinkled: P1. 251.5, P1.12313) and layer composition (using Dunharn's limestone classification). The authors present a very useful discussion of the possible origins of laminated and bedded carbonates. Layer geometry and layer composition can be evaluated by microfacies data. Layers or laminae deposited at an angle to the bounding surfaces are responsible for the formation of crosslamination. All types of cross-stratification as well as flaser and lenticular bedding known from siliciclastic rocks also occur in carbonate sediments: Small- and large-scale cross-stratification, wave-ripple cross-stratification, hummocky cross-stratification (Imbrie and Buchanan 1965; Duke 1985). Planar lamination and cross-lamination are common in shallow-marine carbonates, but cross-lamination is often obliterated. Parallel laminae form in a variety of environments (lacustrine; peritidal to deep sea) but are often destroyed by burrowing organisms and therefore better preserved in reducing or anaerobic environments. Heterolithic stratification is characterized by irregular alternations of mud and sand layers (Pl. 1812) which result in flaser, wavy or lenticular bedding structures. (4) Vertical bed sequences can be recognized from the differences in texture, fossil content or be thickness. Thinninglfining-upward and coarseninglthickening-upward sequences related to rates of environmental change and depositional energy are the significant patterns recording changes in sea level and accomodation.
Sedimentary structures and diageneticfeatures: These structures exhibit a wide variety of pre-, syn- and postdepositional features which allow the processes and the interpretation of paleoenvironments to be dismissed (Fig. 3.5). A highly recommended introduction to sedimentary structures and early diagenetic features of shallow-marine carbonates is the well-illustrated SEPM Atlas prepared by Demicco and Hardie (1994). Many sedimentary structures are identical with those of siliciclastic rocks (e.g. cross-bedding, ripple marks) but, because of the strong impact of biogenic and diagenetic factors on carbonate sedimentation, structures also exist which are more common in or limited to limestones (e.g. fenestral and growth cavities, tepees). Excellent overviews of sedimentary structures of non-carbonate and carbonate rocks were provided by Potter and Pettijohn (1963), Collinson and Thompson (1988), Reineck and Singh (1986), and Ricchi Lucchi
(1995). Allen (1984) discussed the processes controlling specific sedimentary structures. Various classificationsof sedimentary and diagenetic structures differ in their more genetic and process-oriented or descriptive approaches. Demicco and Hardie (1994) differentiatephysical structures,biogenic structures, and chemical features. Physical structures include stratification, breccias and conglomerates, mudcracks and other disruption structures, soft deformation structures, mechanical compaction structures and miscellaneous physical structures. Erosional structures, slump structures,diagenetic deformational structuresand dikes are larger scale structures, commonly involving several beds. Slumping and sliding structures need specific studies. Instructive field and sample illustrations of sedimentary and diagenetic structures can be found in Pettijohn and Potter (1964) and Demicco and Hardie
-
STRATIFICATION Lamination and bedding -
-
-'--,--
planar
WaVY
crinkled
0hummocky
/
CROSS-BEDDING GRADED BEDDING
. .. ....
.... ... A
v
Fining upward (normal) Coarsening upward (inverse) CRACKS
, , , Mudcracks ,
FENESTRAE
-
,,
,
Prism cracks
Fenestral structures
BRECCIAS, CONGLOMERATES
o o
b
a
a
T
D
a
O
,a , a Conglomerate
0
Breccia
b
0
0
0
0
0
0
NEPTUNIAN DYKES DEFORMATION STRUCTURE S load casts
@
slumping convolute bedding
BlOGENlC STRUCTURES r n Stromatolites Bioturbation 7 Bored surface
--Q--VH
DlAGENETlC STRUCTURES A A
8 Tepee
A A A
A
A A
Gypsum
3
Solution pores
> > > > > 'Anhydrite > >
Fig. 3.5. Standard Shell Legend symbols o f abundant sedimentary, biogenic and diagenetic structures occurring in carbonate rocks. The symbols are useful for a uniform schematic representation.
Checklist for Field Description
59
Box 3.1. Checklist for field description of paleontological data in carbonate rocks. Bedded limestones Bedding and sedimentary structures Bedding types (lithology, thickness, bedding boundaries, texture; see Fig. 3.1, Fig. 3.2) 'Event beds' ? (beds caused by physical and biological events of short duration, e.g. storms, turbidity currents, earthquakes, sudden death of organisms resulting in mass acummulations; see Sect. 5.1.3) Cyclic patterns ? (see Sect. 16.1) Sedimentary structures and diagenetic features (see Fig. 3.4) Types and preservation of fossils Classification of fossils (group, taxa) Evaluation of fossil types with regard to ecological criteria Trace fossils and/or body fossils ? Burrowing and bioturbation (see Sect. 5.1.5) Taphonomic criteria (see Chap. 10) Abundance and distribution of fossils Fossil concentrations Abundance of fossils based on bulk samples or on counts using various grids (see Sect. 6.2.1) Distributional patterns of fossils on bedding planes (random, patchy, oriented) Lateral distribution of fossils within the beds Distribution and type of fossils within underlying and overlying beds
I
I
Massive limestones (e.g. reef limestones) Geometry of the carbonate body Mapping of the boundary and geometry of the buildup Mapping of major litho- and biofacies types Establishing time lines (tracing bedding surfaces in the flank facies), discontinuities and event marker beds, e.g. storm layers, synsedimentary breccias) Look for bottom-top structures (particulary at the flanks of buildups) Types and preservation of fossils Classification of fossils Taphonomic criteria Analysis of the principal fossils with regard to their inferred role in buildup formation (e.g. framebuilders, binding and encrusting organisms) Differentiation of growth forms of sessile organisms Abundance and distribution of fossils Vertical and horizontal cover (density) and size of reefbuilding organisms (using a gridded overlay, the quadrat method orthe line method, see Sect. 6.2.1) Recognition of significant vertical sequential changes in growth forms, taxonomic composition or abundance Relation between sediment, texture and fossils Description of the 'matrix' between and around autochthonous reefbuilders (see Sect. 16.2.5.2) Description of growth cavities, shelter structures, open-space structures and solution voids (see Sect. 5.1.5) with regard to geometry, dimension, distribution and filling (sediment, spar, crystal silt, still open) Description of fissures with regard to setting, size, orientation, filling and fossils Abundance of fine-grained sediment and carbonate cements in relation to benthic fossils Diageneticfeatures: see Sect. 7.4.4.2
3.1.1.3 Fossils and Biogenic Structures Fossils, fossiliferous sediments and biogenic sedimentary structures are key sources of information on paleoenvironments, sedimentation patterns and diagenesis. Strategies necessary for describing paleontological data in the field were summarized by Goldring (1991). Field strategies are different for bedded sediments and for dominantly autochthonous buildups. Box 3.1 is based on afield classification offossiliferous sediments proposed by Goldring (1991). Of special interest are 'fossil concentrations', bioclastic fabrics, and ichnofabrics.
Fossil concentrations are relatively dense accumulation of biologic hardparts (irrespective of taxonomic composition, state of preservation, or degree of postmortem modification). By taking into consideration the taxonomic composition, bioclastic fabric, geometry and internal structure of the deposit, skeletal concentrations can be grouped genetically according to the inferred relative importance of biogenic, sedimentologic and diagenetic processes (Kidwell et al. 1986; Fig. 3.6). This approach is useful for interpreting 'shell beds' composed of mollusks and brachiopods, and understanding the processes
Field Logs
Fig. 3.6. Field description of skeletal concentrations (Modified and completed after Kidwell et al. 1986). Accumulation of shells, echinoderm fragments and other fossils are produced by biogenic (area 1in the triangle), sedimentologic (area 2) and diagenetic processes (area 3). An example of biogenic concentrations are oysters, whose larvae preferentially colonize sites with abundant adults causing reef-like structures in subtidal shelf settings. Photo at top right: Placunopsis, Middle Sedimentolwic Diaoenetic Triassic, Germany. Sedimentobgical concentrations form through hydraulic reworking of hardparts, and/or through non-cleposition of sediment, or selective removal of the sedimentary matrix. These processes result in the formation of conspicuous shell beds (lumachelles, coquinas). An example is shown in the foto at bottom left: Accumulation of looseley packed, bimodal sorted bivalve shells within a storm layer originated in inner shelf position; the inversely graded carbonate mud was infilled sub- sequent to the deposition of the shells. Late Triassic, Northern Alps, Austria. Diagenetic concentrations originate from the increase of the spatial density of fossils by compaction and selective pressure solution. The photo at bottom right displays a crinoidal limestone, formed on a carbonate ramp and strongly affected by pressure solution. Early Carboniferous: Frank's Slide,Turtle Mountains,Albertafcanada.The triangle can be used to estimate the position of shell beds along an onshore-offshore transect: Tidal flats are characterized by a composition corresponding to the areas 1 and 2; lagoons by the dominance of the areas 1 and 4; shallow shoals by the dominance of the area 2; inner shelf shell beds by the areas 2 and 4; and subtidal outer shelf settings below storm wave base by the abundance of concentrations that correspond to area 1.
and environments responsible for their origination. Fossiliferous carbonates yielding fossils or fossil fragments larger than 2 mm can be readily categorized into macroscopic fabric types using semi-quantitative scales for close-packing and size-sorting of coarse bioclasts (Kidwell and Holland 1991; Fig. 3.7). The fabric types are useful to narrow the possible modes of origin, e.g. accumulations of mollusk shells or crinoidal fragments. Ichnofabrics and trace fossils have a high potential for interpretating of paleoenvironments and depositional processes (Donovan 1994;Bromley 1996).A semiquantitative field classification of bioturbation based on pattern recognition of the percentage of original sedimentary fabric disrupted by biogenic reworking facilitates the explanation of bioturbation structures seen in thin sections (Droser and Bottjer 1986; see Sect. 5.1.4). Distinctive distributional patterns of trace fossils in carbonate shelf environments are useful in delineating environments of deposition and determining sea-level positions.
3.1.1.4 Field Logs and Compositional Logs
Field information originating from stratigraphic sections and mapping is commonly recorded by written descriptions of observed features (field notes: Tucker 1982, Graham 1988). Graphic logs aid in documenting of rock composition and texture and consist generally of a main column showing the lithological sequence (drawn as column or imitating a weathering profile) and adjacent columns showing the occurrence and distribution of sedimentological and paleontological data. These columns may include only field data or a combination of field and laboratory data. Various standard forms for plotting graphic logs and standardized coding systems have been proposed to uniformly describe facies criteria, and to facilitate transforming field and laboratory data into digital data (e.g. Charollais and Davaud 1974; AmStrat-CanStrat system: Miall 1990). Reijers et al. (1993) recommend a hierarchically organized lithofacies coding system allowing macro-
Packing
Fig. 3.7. Classification of coarse bioclasticfabrics characterizedby closepacking of fossils (modified after Kidwell and Holland 1991). The classification can be used in the field as well as in thin section studies. Basic Bioclast supported, Most bioclastswithin Most bioclasts are more than parameters are packing, size sorting of bioclastlbioclast contacts one body length of each other, one body length common a few in dired contact awav from each other the bioclasts larger than 2 mm,and the biofabric which is bioclast-supported ('densely packed') or matrix-supported ('loosely packed and 'dispersed'). The fabrics are well-sorted exhibiting little variations in the size of bioclasts, bimodal sorted (with two discretes modes), or poorly sorted exhibiting great variations in bioclast sizes. The packing and sorting descriptors convey an immediate visual image of the fossiliferous limestone. The criteria have genetic implications. The categorization by close-packing and size-sorting limits the number of possible origins and leads to basic hypotheses that can be tested using taphonomic, palecologic, sedimentologic and stratigraphic features. The sample exhibits a fabric characterized by large gastropod shells and abundant smaller bioclasts consisting of small gastropods and bivalve valves. These bioclasts constitute an overall loosely packed fabric which would be classified as gastropod floatstone following Dunham's classification (see 6.2). The finer bioclasts, however, are densely packed and these parts of the thin section would be classified as fine-bioclastic mollusk packstone. Small gastropods often are regarded as 'dwarf' forms pointing to unfavorable environments. It should be taken in mind, however, that the majority of gastropods is characterized by mm-scale shells. Note the strong recrystallizationof the large gastropods. The originally aragonitic shell has been replaced by coarse-grained calcite crystals.The first whorls are completely obliterated; following whorls exhibit various cement generations or are infilled by micritic sediment. Late Cretaceous pebble in Quaternary deposits: GrazIStyria,Austria. scopic features of sedimentary rocks to be objectively described and the data stored in a computer database. The standard lithologic logging system proposed by Shell International Exploration and Production (Standard Legend 1995) offers a widely used possibility for describing featuresf recognized in .outcrops, cores and microfacies samples. Lithology, texture and composition, rock color, accessory minerals, fossils, stratification and sedimentary structures, postdepositional criteria and diagenetic features as well as physical criteria (e.g. porosity and permeability) are expressed by symbols, standard abbreviations and codes. Too many symbols and criteria will mask trends in the stratigraphic sequence. For the purpose of microfacies studies the most important data should be shown in logs: e.g. depositional textures, fossils, grain types, matrix and carbonate cement. Logs are presented in a variety of scales depending on the problems involved. Detailed microfacies logs may require a scale of 1 cm = 1 m or less. Authors studying depositional patterns of carbonate rocks use a scale of 1 cm =10 m.
3.1.2 Sampling The following comments refer to outcrops and cores. Sampling of cuttings requires specific methods discussed in Sect. 17.1A.2. Sampling depends on the nature of the project (Griffith 1967). The scope of the problem must be defined before collecting samples. Typical research objectives may be depositional texture of carbonate rocks as an aid to classifying rock types and assessing physical properties, type, texture and size of carbonate grains as an aid to determining depositional environment and paleocurrents, studies of grains, matrix, cement and pores for understanding diagenesis and physical/technological properties of carbonate rocks, paleontological criteria, for subdividing and correlating stratigraphical units or providing data which can help with paleoenvironrnental reconstructions.
How Many Samples?
3.1.2.1 Search Sampling and Statistical Sampling
plan, e.g. at equal distances or according to a random distribution. Common methods of sampling are: Simple random sampling: Samples are taken at unSize of samples evenly spaced intervals determined by random numMicrofacies sampling should provide (1) lithological bers, and the variability of the samples is checked samples exhibiting textures, structures and fossils on a by variance tests (Eltgen 1970). hand specimen scale, (2) samples for laboratory analySystematic sampling: Samples are taken at evenly sis (samples for geochemical investigations should conspaced intervals and checked by significance tests; sider induration and degree of weathering!), and (McCammon 1975). Sampling within a constant ver(3) samples for paleontological studies. Because the methods used in laboratory investigations may not yet tical distance facilitates the statistical treatment of be certain at the time of sampling, large-sized samples distributional data (Grotsch et al. 1994). are recommended allowing several medium to largeStratified sampling: At least two samples are taken from each bed; the number of samples should be scale thin sections to be prepared and specific quesproportional to bed thickness. tions to be studied. The sizes 5 x 4,5 x 5, and larger up Cluster sampling: Several adjacent samples are taken to 20 x 15 cm have proved useful as formats for thin in random distribution. This approach was successsections used in microfacies analyses. fully used for microfacies studies of reef limestones and shelf carbonates. Large and oriented samples (showing the position of the samples in spaces and marked in the field) are In practice, real possibilities of microfacies sampling necessary for and theoretical statistical requirements differ widely due determining top-and-bottom criteria, allowing the to the outcrop situation, accessibility and physical condepositional and structural top to be recognized, studying textural variations and fabrics (e.g. grain dition of the student carrying heavy sample bags. 'We orientation; bedding, discontinuity surfaces, biotur- collect what we can...' bation, breccia), Beware ofthe tfamily photo album effect' describing biotic characters (e.g. growth forms, sucIn a family photo album extraordinary events like cession pattems, guilds). Reef limestones require birthdays and holidays are commonly overrepresented large and very large samples because of the high as compared with photos of every day life. Similarly, compositional variations within centimeter and decimany microfacies samples are often selectively taken meter ranges. Only large samples allow synchronous because of a conspicuous abundance of fossils in some and non-synchronous associations to be differentibeds or exceptional textural types. The 'daily life' reated and sediment types and internal features (caviflected by more monotonous lithotypes (e.g. micritic ties, cryptic habitats) within bioherms or biostromes shelf limestones or hemipelagic limestones) is recorded to be discussed. Large samples, sometimes compristo a minor degree, because the vertical sampling dising a whole bed, are also necessary for calciturbidtance is larger and the spacing more irregular.The depoites (Herbig and Mamet 1994). sitional 'trends' (e.g. cycles) derived from samples representing extraordinary events rather than 'daily life' Equipment and first observations Microfacies sampling requires the use of a ham- may display an artificial pattern. mer, chisel and, sometimes specific equipment (angle grinder). Hand lenses as well as a pocket microscope for grain size measurements (Miiller 1967) and textural 3.1.2.2 How Many Samples? observations in the field are important prerequisites. Determine rock color, texture, composition and mean The variability, diversity, and richness of microfacies size of grains, induration and weathering in hand data are related to sample size effects. An increase in sample size may lead to an increase of richness and specimens. diversity. Various analytical techniques are known to estimate sample size in geological, biological, and arStatistical sampling Statistical sampling, based on random samples with cheological studies. Some methods are also valuable the objective of estimating the statistical probability of in microfacies analysis (curves of sample size against facies types and pattems, is a common approach in mod- diversity or richness, regression and simulation techem microfacies studies (Carozzi 1988). Statistics re- niques). There is, of course, no general rule for the numquire that the samples be taken according to a specific ber of microfacies samples that are 'truly representa-
Advices for Sampling
tive' of the limestone studied, but some empirical tendencies do exist:
Shallow-marine bedded carbonate sequences need a detailed sampling program, because they exhibit high microfacies variability due to changing subtidal and tidal depositional sites and the common occurrence of cyclic sedimentation pattems. A very close sampling of cyclic carbonates at an interval of 0.10 m and less is recommended if high-order short-term cycles are to be detected (Buggisch et al. 1994). Thin- to medium-bedded platform and ramp carbonates are commonly sampled at intervals between 0.20 and 0.50 m (corresponding to a bed-to-bed sampling) or at intervals of several meters. Bed-to-bed sampling is advised if the study aims to understand of short-term changes in environmental controls of biota and sedimentation. Novak and Carozzi (1972) studied a 5 m thick section of Late Carboniferous-Permian platform carbonates by using thin section samples taken at intervals of 20 cm and a continuous series of samples.Although continuous sampling provided more information and allowed a better separation of microfacies types, the general trend in the sequence of microfacies types was still recognizable for sampling intervals of 20 cm. Wider intervals are used for (1) search sampling (taking samples preferentially from conspicuous beds noticeable because of a particular composition, structure or cyclic pattern), and (2) obtain pilot studies aiming to a first overall picture of the section studied and recognize lithotypes which may be evaluated later by microfacies data. Cyclothems that are evident already from field observations are often described using only a few samples. This may provide false information because shallowing- or deepening trends of the cycles could be missed. In addition, cyclic sedimentationpattems may be obscured by the amalgamation of beds, thus calling for densely spaced samples (Gischler et al. 1994). Massive to coarse-beddedcarbonates (reefs,mounds) require the study of many samples in order to consider (1) the variability of sediment within and between frame-building and baffling organisms, (2) the various kinds of voids and open-space structures common in mounds and reefs, (3) lateral microfacies changes on a decimeter-scale, and (4) relations between mound fac i e ~and intermound facies. Microfacies analysis of bedded deepwater carbonates often is based on rather few samples because of the assumed 'monotonous' microfacies spectra of these limestones. The calculated sampling interval (profile thicknesslnumber of samples) of most case studies lies between 1.OO and 2.50 m. Wheras the overall qualitative composition of deep-water limestones may indeed be uniform, the quantitative investigation of microfa-
cies criteria and microfossil distribution, based on a 'onetentimeter style' sampling exhibits hidden aspects of environmental controls (No6 1993). Hardgrounds and condensed pelagic limestones should be studied in channel samples covering the total bed thickness and with particular consideration of the bed surfaces,because rnicrofacies types can change within a distance of a few millimeters and centimeters. Collectingsamplesforpaleoecological or biostratigraphical analysis must take into account the strong facies control of the frequency and distribution of fossils. Many microfacies studies aiming for biostratigraphical classifications are based on spot samples taken at regular intervals or over a regular number of event beds (e.g. calciturbidites). Channel samples continuous over the total thickness of limestone beds are necessary to understand fine-scale vertical variations in event beds. These variations describe the hydraulic changes during the formation of the calciturbidites.
3.1.2.3 Practical Advice for Microfacies Sampling 1 Become clear about the principal aim of the investigation and decide whether you will use random sampling or systematic sampling strategies. 2 Start with a test section to understand the scale of microfacies variations and choose the most appropriate vertical sampling distance. 3 Mark the orientation of the sample (sedimentary top and, if necessary dip and strike, which may be important for the interpretation of grain orientation as a current indicator) before removing the sample from the bed. 4 Take samples of an appropriate size allowing for the preparation of thin sections, the study of non-carbonates in acid residues and geochemical analyses. 5 Consider the negative effect of weathering and avoid taking samples for geochemical and diagenetic studies at or near bedding surfaces. 6 Follow a strict sampling strategy, but do not exclude sampling of beds showing rare but conspicuous criteria (e.g. extremely fossiliferous beds, beds exhibiting differences in colors). But be careful not to follow the 'family photo album effect' by samplingpredominantly 'extraordinary' lithotypes. 7 Locate microfacies sampling in those parts of beds which will deliver a maximum potential on information. 8 When working with bedded carbonate sequences, do not forget to sample also non-carbonate interlayers as well.
Practical Advices
Rock colors Wells, N.A. (2002): Quantitative evaluation of color measurements: I. Triaxial stereoscopic satter plats. - Sedirnentary Geology 151, 1-15 Folk, R.C. (1969): Toward greater precision in rock-color terminology. - Geol. Soc. America Bull., 80,725-728 Fliigel, E., Tietz, G.F. (1971): ~ b e die r Ursachen der Buntffiung in Oberrhat-RiKkalken(Adnet, Salzburg). -Neues Basics: Field work Jahrbuch fiir Geologie und Palaontologie, Abhandlungen, Field methods and graphic record 139,2942 Allen, J.R.L. (1982): Sedimentary structures. Their characGoddard, E.N., Trask, P.D., De Ford, R.K., Rove, O.N., ter and physical basis. - Development in Sedirnentology, Singewald, J.T., Overbeck, R.M. (1948): Rock-color chart. 30, 1258 pp., Amsterdam (Elsevier) - Geological Society of America Collinson, J.D., Thompson, D.B. (1988): Sedimentary struc- Patnode, H.W. (1941): Relation of organic matter to color of tures. - 2nd edition, 208 pp., London (Allen and Unwin) sedimentaryrocks. -Amer. Ass. Petrol. Geol. Bull., 25,1921Dietrich, R.V., Dutro, J.T., Foose, R.M. (1982): AGI data 1933 sheets for geology in the field, laboratory, and office. Wright, W.D. (1969): The measurement of color. - 340 pp., 2nd edition, Boulder (American Geological Institute) London (Hilger) Gagliardi, R., Kalin, O., Morreale, E., Pataca, E., Scandone, F., Sprugnole, R. (1980): Una banca dati geologici del Sampling progetto finalizzato geodiiamica. - Consiglio Nazionale Griffith, J.C. (1967): Scientific method in analysis of sedidelle Ricerche. Progetto Finalizzato Geodinamica, Pubments. - 508 pp., New York (McGraw-Hill) blicazione, 393, 1-90 Schindel,D.W. (1980): Microstratigraphicsampling and the Leeder, M.R. (1982): Sedimentology.Process and product. limits of paleontologic resolution. -Paleobiology, 6,408344 pp., Boston (Allen and Unwin) 426 Lewis, D.W., McConchie, D.M. (1994): Practical sedimenFurther reading: K003, K004, K014, K015, KO16 tology. 2nd ed. - 256 pp., New York (Chapman and Hall) Reijers, T.J.A., Mijnlieff, H.F., Pestman, P.J., Kouwe, W.F.P. (1993): Lithofacies and their interpretation: a guide to standardised description of sedimentary deposits. - 3.2 Laboratory Work: Techniques Mededelingen Rijks Geologische Dienst, 49,l-55 Shell International Exploration and Production B.V., The Hague (1995): Standard Legend 1995. - Document and Originally strongly focused on the study of thin sections, peels or slices with the aid of low to medium CD-ROM version Tucker, M.E. (1982): The field description of sedimentary power binocular and petrographical microscopy, the rocks. - Geological Society of London, Handbook Series, combined use of conventional thin-section data and 2, 112 pp., London (Open University Press) more sophisticated detailed microscopy (SEM, cathodoTucker, M.E. (ed., 1988): Techniques in sedimentology. luminescence and fluorescence microscopy) as well as 416 pp., Oxford (Blackwell)
9 Do not restrict sampling to microfacies alone, but also collect macrofossils and specific micropaleontological samples. 10Record the sampling locality and the beds sampled in field photographs and detailed sketches.
mineralogical and geochemical studies have proved to be of high potential in the application of microfacies Bedding, sedimentary and biogenic structures Bromley, R.G. (1996):Trace fossils: biology, taphonomy and analysis. Valuable summaries of techniques are found in Miiller (1967), and especially in Tucker (1981). The applications. - 2nd ed., Dordrecht (Kluwer) Cole, R.D., Picard, M.D. (1975): Primary and secondary sedi- latter book includes excellent overviews of diverse mimentary structures in oil shale and other fine-grainedrocks, croscopical methods, cathodoluminescence microsGreen River Formation (Eocene), Utah and Colorado. copy, scanning electron microscopy, X-ray powder difUtah Geology, 2,49-67 Campbell, C.V. (1967); Lamina, laminaset, bed and bedset. - fraction and chemical analysis of sedimentary rocks. Sedimentology, 8, 7-26 Texts covering the paleontological aspects of microDroser, M.L., Bottjer, D.J. (1986): A semiquantitative field facies studies are listed in Sect. 10.4. classification of ichnofabric. - J. Sed. Petrol., 56,558-599 Goldring, R. (1991): Fossils in the field. Information potential and analysis. - 218 pp., London (Longman) Kendall, C.G.St.C., Warren, J. (1987): Areview of the origin and setting of tepees and their associated fabrics. - Sedimentology, 34, 1007-1027 Kidwell, S.M., Holland, S.M. (1991): Field description of coarse bioclastoc fabrics. - Palaios, 6,426-454 Lewis, D.W., McConchie, D.M. (1993): Practical sedimentology. - 256 pp., London (Chapman and Hall) Lumsden, D.N. (1971): Facies and bed thickness distributions of limestones. - J. Sed. Petrol., 41,593-598 Plummer, P.S., Gostin, V.A. (1981): Shrinkage cracks: desiccation or synaeresis. - J. Sed. Petrol., 51, 1147-1156
3.2.1 Slices, Peels and Thin Sections The composition, fabric and texture of carbonate rocks are studied in slices, peels, or thin sections which may be etched or stained in various phases of preparation in order to emphasize specific criteria. Various techniques and methods are described by Adams et al. (1984) and Miller (1988). Slices: Oiling and gentle etching of cut and smoothened carbonate rock faces exhibit otherwise cryptic fab-
Laboratory Work
rics or show fabrics within apparently homogeneous limestones (Bromley 1981). Peels: The imprint of etched surfaces on transparent plastic films is the most rapid and simplest method for studying cut, polished, and etched samples. Acetate replicas can be made using a dry-peel technique (McCrone 1963; Germann 1965) or by making peel sheets by pouring solutions (ethyl cellulose in trichloroethylene, nitrocellulose) on to glass plates (Davies and Till 1968). The procedure of preparing peels includes (I) cutting, grinding (and polishing) the sample, (2) drying and etching the cut surface, (3) flooding the surface with a solvent and (4) pressing the film onto the surface; the film will settle down into irregularities in the etched surface and produce the replica. After pulling off, the peel should be pressed or mounted between glasses. Peels have many advantages: They offer a rapid and inexpensive method to obtain a first observation of the characteristics of the sample. Peels can be used not only for carbonates but also for cherts, siliceous clastics and sulfates rocks (Mandado and Tena 1986). Peels can be studied just like thin sections using a binocular microscope or a simple microfiche equipment and they can be placed in the negative carrier of a photographic enlarger, producing iarge negative prints by projecting the image directly to bromide paper. These prints may be used as working copies exhibiting locations of areas of particular interest. Replicas can be made of large surfaces, even up to several tenths and hundredths of square centimeters. Serial peels can be produced by regrinding surfaces after each peel, thus allowing the three-dimensional reconstruction of open-space structures or fossils only known from thin sections (Honjo 1963). Staining peels prior to the flooding of rock surfaces allows minerals and fabrics to be differentiated (Katz and Friedman 1965). Since earlier stains can be removed by repolishing, different stains indicating different minerals can be used with good success. Peels are suited for high-magnification studies and phase contrast microscopy (Frank 1965; Honjo and Fischer 1965) and for SEM studies (Brown 1986). Acetate peels have proved to be of value in studying carbonate cements and textural criteria (e.g. grainsize distribution: Gutteridge 1985). Disadvantages of peels are the susceptibility of acetate films to contamination and the danger that porous samples might be difficult to work with, because the film may bulge into the pores, causing blisters. Ac-
etate films are isotropic; the main disadvantage of peels, therefore, is that minerals can not be identified by optical properties, such as relief or birefrigence. Thin sections: The investigation of the composition and fabric of surface and subsurface samples requires standard thin sections with a thickness of approximately 30 pm. These thin sections are usually cut perpendicular to the bedding. Initially, the thin sections should not be covered, allowing later more detailed investigations (staining etc.). Very fine-grained micrites are studied in high-quality ultra-thin sections with a thickness between 0.5 and 5 pm (Lindholm and Dean 1973), allowing observations at magnifications of between x 150 and x 1000. Thin sections may be subject to etching and staining (Friedman 1959; Houghton 1980; Rassineux and Beaufort 1987). These procedures and other more detailed studies (e.g. cathodolurninescence microscopy: Mugridge and Young 1984) only can be applied to uncovered thin sections. Rapid covering can be done using a plastic spray (Moussa 1976). Microfacies thin sections are generally larger and thicker than regular petrographic slides. Commonly used sizes are from 5 x 5 up to 15 x 20 cm. Large thin sections are necessary for studying reef limestones, coarse-grained detrital limestones and carbonates deposited during events (e.g. turbidites, tempestites). Note: Samples are generally cut perpendicularly to bedding planes. Therefore, a thin section comprising a vertical interval of 5 cm records a set of 'microsequences' corresponding to shorter or longer time intervals within a scale of hundreds, thousands or more years.
3.2.2 Casts, Etching and Staining Casts: Impregnation of carbonate rocks and fossils with low viscosity epoxy resin under vacuum and under pressure has a high potential in recognizing micron- and submicron-scaled structures in porous but also moderately porous carbonates and evaporites. Impregnation of carbonate rocks with a mixture of fluorescent dye and epoxy resin enhance the ability to study micro- and macroporosity. SEM observations of artificial casts aid in the study of microporosity and pore geometries of limestones and chalks (Gardner 1980; Beckett and Sellwood 1991; see P1. 6), modem and ancient microborings (Golubic et al. 1975; see P1.5211-4). Etching and staining: Etching of slices or thin sections with hydrochloric acid (1-5% by volume) or acetic acid (about 20% by volume) causes partial dissolu-
Casts, Etching, Staining
66
tion that emphasizes textural criteria and allows subsequent staining, which is one of the most useful techniques in carbonate rock studies. Comparing staining techniques with other methods, e.g. X-ray diffraction, may exhibit discrepancies in estimates of dolomite in limestones (Gensmer and Weiss 1980). The success of etching and staining depends on (a) the strength and temperature of the reagents, (b) etching and staining times, (c) the pre-treatment of the sample, and d) the composition and fabric. An advantage of staining is the possibility using the method already used during field studies (Warne 1962). Staining assists in (1) identifying minerals common in carbonates (aragonite, Mg-calcite, calcite and dolomite, gypsum and anhydrite, feldspars), (2) studying dedolomitization (Evarny 1963), (3) recognizing microporosity (Yanguas and Dravis 1985)
3.2.3 Microscopy The microscopic study of thin sections of carbonate rocks provides the basic microfacies data. The combination of microfacies analysis with the criteria derived from fluorescence, photoluminescence, cathodoluminescene and fluid inclusion studies provide key information on sedimentary and diagenetic processes.
3.2.3.1 Petrographic Microscopy
3.2.3.2
Stereoscan Microscopy
Utilization of Steroscan Electron Microscopy (SEM) in the study of ancient and modem carbonate rocks has brought about major breakthroughs in our understanding of depositional and diagenetic products and processes (Welton 1984; Trewin 1988). The chief advantages of the SEM are the great depth of focus, producing excellent photographs of extremely small (micron- and submicron-sized)three-dimensional surfaces, the high power of resolution and the possibility of very high magnifications in the range between x 10 up to x 100 000. Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) of replicas, however,which has been used prior to SEM in the study of carbonate rocks (Fischer et ai. 1967), is still a valuable tool in carbonate investigation (e.g. biomineralization modes, microbial contribution to the formation of carbonates). Today, SEM studies are a part of integrated analyses which combine SEM with energy dispersive X-ray (EDX) data, back-scattered electron images and image analysis,cathodoluminescencemicroscopy and conventional studies of (stained or etched) peels and thin sections. Peels and thin sections can be used directly for SEM studies. EDX studies show element composition and element distribution. Element mapping is used to distinguish mineralogical phases and to elucidate Mg and Sr distributional patterns in cements and fossils. Carbonate SEM samples should be unaffected by weathering. Nonporous limestones and dolomites are studied using untreated fractures of rock chips or slices (size about 5 by 10 by 10 mm) which are polished and etched with dilute hydrochloric acid or formic acid, or Titriplex-111. Samples are mounted on stubs by doublesided sticky tape or various glues. Porous carbonates may need specific sample treatment (Trewin 1988).
Good polarizing microscopes and binocular microscopes are essential tools for microfacies studies. Microscopes should have photographic equipment low and high power magnification and should be equipped with mechanical or computer-interfaced stages for examining modal composition and fabrics (Kobluk and Vyas 1989). The major applications of SEM in investigating carThe speed, thoroughness and accuracy of thin-section analysis can be increased by using integrated com- bonate rocks include studies of the matrix of fine-grained limestones (micrite, chalk) puterized systems (Kobluk and Kim 1991).To provide an overview of the whole thin section, the use of digiand the composition of modem carbonate muds, composition and ultrastructure of fossils and nontal film scanners (De Keyser 1999) and microfiche inbiogenic carbonate grains, struments is strongly recommended. Microfacies obbreakdown of fossils, including the importance of servations should always start with low-power examiendolithic borings in the destruction of grains and nations and continue to high-power magnification. Prithe formation of micritic coatings, mary textural features in dolostones and recrystallized type, sedimentological and biostratigraphical role of limestones can be made visible by using a simple light diiuser (translucent plastic or plain white paper), placed micro- and namofossils, distribution and geometry of micropores, directly under the thin section (Delgado 1977). mineralogy, morphology and spatial relations of carThere are many excellent and colored texts on minbonate cements, eral identification in thin sections (e.g. Scholle 1979; Adam et al. 1984; Carozzi 1993). stages of dolomitization,
Microscopy
type and distribution of non-carbonate minerals, changes taking place during burial diagenesis and incipient metamorphosis.
3.2.3.3 Fluorescence, Cathodoluminescence and Fluid Inclusion Microscopy Fluorescence is a form of luminescence and represents the property of material to emit light when exited by visible or ultraviolet light (Rost 1992). Fluorescence microscopy is a standard technique in coal petrography, paleobotany, and the organic petrography of sediments of mainly organic origin or with a high organic content (e.g. petroleum source rocks). Fluorescence in limestones is probably caused by organic matter (Machel et al. 1991). Samples are studied as polished slices and thick thin sections (Clausing 1991). Epifluorescence in carbonates is used for recognizing hidden microfabrics (Dravis and Yurewicz 1985; Klotz 1989), studying organic constituents of fine-laminatedlimestones (e.g. cyanobacteria,algae, pollen and spores), differentiating automicrites and allomicrites (Neuweiler 1995), understanding biomineralization processes. Cathodolurninescence (CL) microscopy of carbonate rocks, starting with the work of Sippel and Glover (1965), is a significant tool in the petrography of marine and non-marine carbonates (Marshall 1988; Barker and Kopp 1991; Barbin et al. 1991) and in the investigation of primary or diagenetic microstructures of fossils (Amieux 1987; Elorza et al. 2001). CL microscopy stimulates of luminescence on polished thin sections (thickness < 30 pm) and polished rock surfaces by electron borbardment. Luminescence depends on the material characteristics of the excited solid. These characteristics comprise the chemistry, crystal structure, lattice defects and other factors (Hemming et al. 1989). The main activator elements of carbonates are ~ n and PW2.Activation of calcite and dolomite by Rare Earth elements is also a common feature of Phanerozoic marine limestones and sinter calcites (Habermann et al. 1996). The subjective determinationof CLcolors should be supplemented by spectrometricanalyses. CL studies are often combined with petrographic microscopy (Gregg and Karakus 1991) and rare element microanalyses, and have become a significant part of microfacies analyses. The major applications of CL microscopy for carbonate rocks (see P1.5) are for observing and interpreting of diagenetic phases (e.g. zonar structures within crystals reflecting changes in
67
the chemical environment and/or in the growth speed; early diagenetic and burial cements reflecting burial depths; mineral transformations, such as the alteration of calcite to dolomite (Richter 1984), evaluating pore water chemistry, reflected by sector zoning in calcite crystals (Bruckschen et al. 1992), and interpretation of the diagenetic history of reservoir rocks, reconstructing diagenetic events which identify stages of cementation and provide a 'cement stratigraphy' that are used to establish cement-based stratigraphic correlations (Meyers 1991; Sect. 7.7. l), recognizing fabrics (e.g. distinction of recrystallized structures, recognition of microcracks), studying the diagenesis of fossils.
Fluid inclusions in minerals have been studied during the last twenty years with respect to the genesis and migration of hydrocarbons, mineral deposits, diagenesis of sedimentary rocks and problems of structural geology and petrology (Roedder 1984, 1990; Lattanzi 1991). Fundamental for the interpretation of fluid inclusion data is the assumption, that the fluid inclusions still have the same composition and volume as at the time of formation in a closed system. Alterations may be caused by changes in geometry and volume or by a temporary or permanent opening of the inclusions. Carbonate crystals with fluid inclusions appear dark in thin sections and polished sections. Cloudy inclusions of aqueous liquid and vapor within carbonate crystals provide information on the diagenetic environment of cements (vadose zone, low-temperature phreatic zone, high-temperature burial zone) and their thermic history. The size of the inclusion ranges from < 10 pm to 30 pm. Fluid inclusions are caused by primary engulfment of fluids within growing crystals or by secondary entrapment of fluids in microfractures that are subsequently healed. Samples should not have been subjected ~ significant + to overheating beyond the temperature of entrapment or the temperature of homogenization (Barker and Goldstein 1990) and should have been reequilibrated during recrystallizationand deformation. Calcite crystals should display distinct growth zones. Genetic interpretationsand classifications are based on the composition, form, and position of the inclusions as well as their relationship to crystal structures (Roedder 1984; Goldstein 1993). Investigations require a petrographical microscope (with UV epifluorescence capabilities for differentiating aqueous and hydrocarbon inclusions) and a heating and freezing stage. Fluid inclusion studies are com-
Cathodoluminescence
68
Plate 5 Cathodoluminescence (CL): A Possibility to See More Cathodoluminescence microscopy of thin sections has become an important tool of microfacies analysis.It assists in observing diagenetic phases recorded by different cement types (-> 1, 2, 8) and establishing a 'cement stratigraphy'as well as recognizing zonation patterns of calcite crystals and the mode of porosity occlusion (-> 3). CL reveals the original structures of fossils and their growth modes (-> 4) and facilitates the recognition of diagenetic not or little altered shells which can be used for the determination of stable isotopes. Generally CL accentuates diagenetic and sedimentary textures (-> 6,7), thus allowing a more precise observation of microfacies criteria. The combined use of CL and petrographic microscopy is strongly recommended. 1 and 2 Primary interparticle pore in transmitted light (-> 1) and under CL (-> 2). Note the different appearance of
cement successions. The succession consists of a light-brown luminescent radialfibrous cement (A) circumcrusting a grain followed by non-luminescent dogtooth cement (B) and banded yellow to brown luminescent burial coarse mosaic calcspar cement which fills the remaining pore space. Early Jurassic: Carbonate platform of Jbel Bou Dahar, High Atlas, Morocco. Zoned crystal growth. The luminescence pattern exhibits the distinct zonation of a large crystals filling the pore space in a travertine. Quaternary: Tivoli near Rome, Italy. Ulltastructure and growth modes of fossils: Shell of the inoceramid species Antarcticerarnus rabotensis (Crame and Luther). Under cathodoluminescence a distinct yellow luminescent lamina is visible which interrupts the normal sized prisms constructing the shell. A recovery to normal crystal sizes is rather slow as seen by the smaller prisms (here) left of the yellow lamina. This interruption in shell growth is interpreted as the result of a cooling interval or even a freeze shock which influenced the growth of prisms in the shell. Growth direction of the shell is from right to the left in this picture. Late Cretaceous (Campanian): James Ross Island, Antarctica. Grade of diagenetic alterations of shells. Punctate brachiopod. The brachiopod shell appears dark (unaltered) with some luminescent parts (diagenetically altered). The punctae are filled by orange luminescent diagenetic calcite. Sediment in the lower part shows bright orange luminescence due to Mn2+incorporation ('activator' ion) during the diagenetic transformation of metastable aragonite and High-Mg calcite to the stable phase Low-Mg calcite and are therefore relatively stable to diagenetic alteration. Unaltered shells usually show no luminescence. The shell belongs to the genus Sclzizophoria. Devonian: Iowa, USA. Diagenetic stages: Relictic ooids. The ooid layers were dissolved mainly during late burial diagenesis; the preserved core consists of recrystallized shell fragments which show a weak red to orange luminescence. Open moldic porosity appears dark. The outline of the ooids is traced by orange to red luminescent early diagenetic micritic envelopes and fine crystalline cements. Interparticle porosity between ooids is filled by coarse crystalline sparite showing bright orange luminescence. This is interpreted as the result of late diagenetic neomorphism of an original early diagenetic marine-phreatic sparite. Late Cretaceous: Sinai Peninsula, Egypt. Dolomitization and compaction. Dolomite rhomboids. The rhomboids have a non-luminescent to weakly luminescent core surrounded by a bright orange luminescent zone. The weak luminescence of the cores indicates iron-rich diagenetic fluids and the incorporations of Fe2+in the dolomite lattice ('quench' ion) during crystal growth. By contrast, the final bright orange luminescent zone indicates changing pore fluid chemistry with more Mn2+ incorporation in the crystal lattice. Broken cores cemented by the outer luminescent zone indicate ongoing compaction during dolomitization. The rhomboids are interpreted as baroque dolomite typical of late burial diagenesis. Same locality as -> 6 Diagenetic filling of a fossil (brachiopod shell not visible in figure). Left part shows sediment (micrite) with red to orange luminescence due to diagenetic transformation to Low-Mg calcite and the incorporation of Mn2+in the calcite lattice. Remaining porosity was cemented by large calcite crystals (right) formed during late diagenesis. The distinct zoning of the crystals with weak and bright orange luminescent zones indicates slow crystal growth, changing pore water chemistry and/or changing redox conditions during crystal formation. The latest cements exhibits bright orange to yellow luminescence and document the final stage of the diagenetic cements. Middle Devonian: Anti-Atlas, Morocco.
-> 1, 2: Blomeier and Reijmer 1999; 3: Courtesy of R. Koch (Erlangen); 4: Elorza et al. 2001; 5-8: Courtesy of R. von Geldern (Erlangen)
Trace Elements and Stable Isotopes
The most important carbonate minerals are LowMg calcite (LMC), High-Mg calcite (HMC), aragonite and dolomite (Fig. 3.8). The dividing line between LowMg calcite and High-Mg calcite is commonly drawn at 4 mol % MgC03. These groupings can be subdivided into those containing a variable amount of MgCO, Fluid inclusions in carbonates are a powerful tool (4-12 mol 9%) and those containing a consistently high for the amount of MgCO, (12-28 mol %, e.g. corallinacean red history and timing of shallow and burial diagenetic algae, echinoderms). The latter group represents the and low-grade metamorphic processes ( Brockerhoff HMC sensu stricto (hHMC = high High-Mg calcite). The amount of Mg substitution for Ca in the calcite and Friedman 1987; Liedmann 1992), conditions of dolomitization (Goldstein et al. 1990; structure is determined by X-ray diffraction analysis. The composition of carbonate sediments is studied Montanaze and Read 1992), migration processes of paleofluids (Burruss et al. by petrographical microscopy and X-ray diffraction (XRD), which is particularly useful for analyzing fine1985; Ricken 1992; Muchez et al. 1994), uplift and subsidence history of sedimentary rocks grained carbonate rocks. The qualitative and quantita(McLimans 1987), tive methods of XRD whole rock analysis and clay minsubaerial exposure and karst phenonema (Goldstein eral analysis are described by Hardy and Tucker (1988). XRD data provide information on the chemical comet al. 1990), data on pore water chemism and temperature dur- position of carbonate minerals, allow carbonate minerals to be distinguished, and are used to determine the ing the formation of geodes, vugs and veins. ordering of dolomite crystals and the proportions of calcite and dolomite. The 'carbonate bomb' (Miiller and Gastner 1971) offers the possibility of rapidly deter3.2.4 Mineralogy and Geochemistry minating the contents of CaCO, and insoluble residues Carbonate minerals include minerals composed of in limestones. C0,2- and one or more cations. Approximately sixty minerals occur in nature with a C03group in common. Of these the trigonal CaC03 (calcite) and its orthor- 3.2.5 Trace Elements hombic polymorph (aragonite) are the most common and Stable Isotope Analysis in modem sediments. Calcite and dolomite are by far the most common carbonate minerals in ancient car- Section 13.3 summarizes the impact of geochemical bonate rocks. Several cations can substitute in varying studies of ancient limestones and the advantage of comamounts for the Ca2+in the crystal structure: ~ g ~ bined + , investigations of microfacies, stable isotopes and Fe2+and Mn 2+ are more readily accepted in the hex- trace elements. agonal calcite structure, and S$+ and ~ a by~the+aragonite structure. The minor element composition of cal- Trace elements: The elemental analysis of carbonate cite and aragonite is determined by biochemical and rocks provides important data on the sedimentary and diagenetic history. Atom Adsorption Spectrophotometry physical-chemical processes.
monly combined with petrographic and cathodoluminescence microscopy and isotope analysis (Sotak and Lintnerova 1994). Fundamental techniques have been described by Hollister and Crawford (198 I), and Goldstein (1993).
System
Mol % MgCO,
Stability
Calcite CaCO, Low-Mg calcite (LMC)
trigonal
<4
stable
Mg-calcite CaCO, High-Mg calcite (HMC) Aragonite CaCO,
trigonal
>4 to -30 Mg content correlated with water temperature
metastable
very low
metastable, alters readily in calcite under aqueous conditions
40 - 50
stable
Dolomite
I
orthorhombic
trigonal CaM~(CO,),
Fig. 3.8. Common carbonate minerals.
1
Mineralogy
Isotope signal Preservation potential HIGH Good chance of preservation of carbon and oxygen isotope signals
Mineralogy of components
-
Components Skeletal Non-skeletal
Pristine aragonite
Mollusks
Pristine Low-Mg calcite fossils, grains or cements
Brachiopods, belemnites, foraminifera, bivalves
Marine cements, Low-Mg calcite ooids
Pelagic sediments particularly coccolith oozes
Molluscs, foraminifera, corals, echinoderms, calcareous algae
Marine cements, ooids, peloids, intraclasts
Some micrites, some shallowwater carbonates some dolomites
-
Phosphatic fossils
Conodonts, fish teeth
MODERATE
Secondary calcites
Carbon isotope signals may be preserved, oxygen isotope signals are commonly altered
(stabilized in relatively closed systems with low waterlrock ratio)
LOW
Secondary calcites
Carbon and oxygen isotope signals very likely to have been altered
(
Bulk sediments
(stabilized or cemented in relatively open systems with high waterlrock ratio)
Marine cements
Limestones altered by near surface meteoric diagenesis of intensive cementation or recrystallizationduring burial; many dolomites
Fig. 3.9. Preservation potential of carbon and oxygen isotopes in ancient carbonate sediments and skeletal and non-skeletal constituents, and phosphatic fossils. Modified after Marshall (1992).
(AAS) is widely used in the analysis of limestones and dolomites because of elements hidden in minor amounts within the carbonate lattice. Inductively-coupled Plasma Atomic Emission Spectrometry Analysis (ICP-AES) and Neutron Activation Analysis (NAA) are used for determining the contents of trace elements and rare earth elements in carbonate rocks by whole-rock and selective analyses (Fairchild et al. (1988). Minor elements in carbonate rocks and in fossils are important paleoenvironmental indicators. The combined use of microfacies data, trace elements and isotope geochemistry in facies analyses continues to evolve in current studies (see Chap. 13).
sisting of Low-Mg calcite are rather resistant to diagenetic alteration, isotope analyses of brachiopods are enjoying increasing popularity. Stable isotope analyses of ancient carbonates provide proxies for paleoenvironmental constraints (e.g. temperature and salinity variations of the sea water, terrigenous input), unravel changes in carbon cycling of ancient ocean-atmosphere systems and document global fluctuationsin the climate. Isotope abundance measurements for geochemical research are determined on a mass spectrometer. Basics: Laboratory work
Techniques and microscopical methods Beckett, D., Sellwood, B.W. (1991): A simple method for Stable Isotopes: The isotope ratios of '80/160 and 13C/ producing high-quality porecasts of carbonate rocks. - Sed. 12Care very often used to trace processes involved in Geol., 71, 1-4 the production of carbonate grains and their subsequent Brown, R.J. (1986): SEM examination of carbonate microfacies using acetate peels. - J. Sed. Petrol., 56, p. 538 conversion into limestones. Isotope studies are perDelgado, F. (1977): Primary textures in dolostones and reformed as whole-rock bulk analyses or analyses of crystallized limestones: a technique for their microscopy single components (e.g. isolated fossils, carbonate cestudy. - J. Sed. Petrol., 47, 1339-1341 ments) or as microsamples of individual parts of fos- Folk, R.L. (1987): Detection of organic matter in thin-sections using a white card. - Sed. Geol., 54, 193-200 sils (e.g. shells) or cement crystals. The preservation Friedman, G.M. (1959): Identification of carbonate minerals potential of isotope signals depends on the preservaby staining methods. - J. Sed. Petrol., 29.87-97 tion of the primary mineralogy and the degree of di- Gardner, K.L. (1980): Impregnation technique used colored agenetic alterations (see Fig. 3.9). Diagenesis can obepoxy to define porosity in petrographic thin sections. scure the original composition of constituents of carCanadian Journal of Earth Sciences, 17, 1104-1107 bonate rocks, and if undetected, can lead to erroneous Germann, K. (1965): Die Technik des Folienabzuges und ihre Ergiinzung durch Anf&bemethoden. - Neues Jahrbuch fiir conclusions. All samples, therefore, must be tested prior Geologie und Palaontologie Abhandlungen, 121,293-306 to isotope analysis with respect to potential diagenetic Gies, R.M. (1987): An improved method for viewing microoverprinting, using petrographic and CL microscopy, pore systemsin rocks with the polarizing microscope.-Soc. SEM criteria and chemical data. Because shells conPetroleum Engmeers Formation Evaluation, 1987,209-214
72
Gutteridge, P. (1985): Grain-size measurement from acetate peels. - J. Sed. Petrol., 55,595-596 Katz, A., Friedman, G.M. (1965): The preparation of stained acetate peels for the study of carbonate rocks. - J. Sed. Petrol., 35, 248-249 Kobluk, D.R., Kim, K.H. (1991): A new microcomputer-assisted approach to the study of thin sections of carbonate rocks. - Bull.Canadian Petroleum Geology, 39,252-259 Mandado, J.A., Tena, J.M. (1986): A peel technique for sulfate (and carbonate) rocks. - J. Sed. Petrol., 56,548-549 Miller, J. (1989): Microscopic techniques. I. Slices, slides, stains and peels. -In: Tucker, M. (ed.): Techniques in sedimentology. - 86-107, Oxford (Blackwell) Moussa, M.T. (1976): Plastic spray thin-section cover. - J. Sed. Petrol., 46,252-253 Mugridge, S.J., Young, H.R. (1984): Rapid preparation of polished thin sections for cathodoluminescence study. Canadian Mineralogists, 22, 5 13-515 Miiller, G. (1964): Methoden der Sedimentuntersuchung. 303 pp., Stuttgart (Schweizerbart) Murphy, C.P. (1986): Thin section preparation of soils and sediments. - 149 pp., Berkhamsted (Academic Publ.) Ruzyla, K., Jezek, D.I. (1987): Staining method for recognition of pore space in thin and polished sections. - J. Sed. Petrol., 57, 777-778 Trewin, N. (1988): Use of the scanning electron microscopy in sedimentology. - In: Tucker, M. (ed.): Techniques in sedimentology. - 229-273, Oxford (Blackwell) Tucker, M. (ed., 1988): Techniques in sedirnentology. 394 pp., Oxford (Blackwell) Yanguas, J.E., Paxton, S.T. (1986):Anew technique for preparation of petrographic thin-sections using ultraviolet-curing adhesive. - J. Sed. Petrol., 56,539-540 Warne, J. (1962): A quick field or laboratory staining scheme for the differentiation of the major carbonate minerals. J. Sed. Petrol., 32, 29-38 Wolf, K.H., Easton, A.J., Warne, S. (1967): Techniques of examining and analyzing carbonate skeletons, minerals and rocks. -In: Chilingar, G.V., Bissell, H.J., Fairbridge, R.W. (eds.): Carbonate rocks: physical and chemical aspects. - Developments in Sedimentology, 9B, 253-341 Fluorescence and cathodoluminescence microscopy Amieux, P. (1982): La cathodoluminescence: mtthode d'ttude stdimentologique des carbonates. - Bull. Centre Rech. Exp1or.-Prof. Elf-Aquitaine, 6,437-483 Barbin, V. (1995): Cathodoluminescence of carbonates: new applications in geology and archaeology. - Scanning Microscope Supplement, 9, l 13-123 Barker, C.E., Kopp, A.C. (eds., 1991):Luminescence microscopy and spectroscopy. Quantitative and qualitative applications. - SEPM Short Course, 25, 195 pp. Fairchild, I.J. (1983): Chemical controls of cathodoluminescence of natural dolomites and calcites: new data and review. - Sedimentology, 30, 579-583 Gregg, J.M., Karakus, M. (1991): A technique for successive cathodoluminescence and reflected light petrography. J. Sed. Petrol., 61,613-614 Hemming, N.G., Meyers, W.J., Grams, J.C. (1989): Cathodoluminescence in diagenetic calcites: the roles of Fe and Mn as deduced from electron probe and spectrophotometric measurements. - J. Sed. Petrol., 59,401-411 Machel, H.G., Mason, R.A., Marino, A., Mucci, A. (1991):
References Laboratory Work Causes and emission of luminescence in calcite and dolomite. - In: Barker, C.E., Kopp, O.C. (eds.): Luminescence microscopy and spectroscopy: qualitative and quantitative applications. - SEPM Short Course, 25,9-25 Marshall, D.J. (1988): Cathodoluminescence of geological materials. - 146 pp., London (Unwin Hyman) Marshall, D.J. (1991): Combined cathodoluminescence and energy dispersive spectroscopy. - SEPM Short Course, 25,27-35 Meyers, W.J.(1991): Calcite cement stratigraphy: an overview. -In: Barker, C.E., Kopp, O.C. (eds.): Luminescence microscopy and spectroscopy: qualitative and quantitative applications. - SEPM Short Course, 25, 133-148 Miller, J. (1988): Cathodoluminescence microscopy. - In: Tucker, M. (ed.): Techniques in sedimentology. - 174-190, Oxford (Blackwell) Neuser, R.D., Bruhn, F., Gotze, J. Habermann, D., Richter, D.K. (1996): Kathodolumineszenz: Methodik und Anwendung. - Zentralblatt fiir Geologie und Palaontologie. Teil I, 1995,287-306 Pagel, M., Barbin, V., Blanc, P., Ohnenstetter, D. (2002): Cathodoluminescence in geosciences. - 514 pp., Berlin (Springer) Ramseyer, K., Fischer, J., Matter, A., Eberhardt, P., Geiss, J. (1989): A cathodoluminescence microscope for low intensity luminescence. - J. Sed. Petrol., 59,619-622 Richter, D.K., Zinkemagel, U. (1981): Zur Anwendung der Kathodolumineszenz in der Karbonatpetrographie. - Geologische Rundschau, 70, 1276-1302 Rost, F.W.D. (1992): Fluorescence microscopy. Volume I. 253 pp., New York (Cambridge University Press) Mineralogy, geochemistry and stable isotopes Arthur, M.A., Anderson, T.F., Kaplan, I.R., Veizer, J., Land, L.S. (1983): Stable isotopes in sedimentary geology. SEPM Short Course, 10,435 pp. Clauer, N., Chaudhuri, S. (eds., 1992): Isotopic signatures and sedimentary records. - Lecture Notes in Earth Science, 43,529 pp. Dickson, T. (1990): Carbonate mineralogy and chemistry. In: Tucker, M.E., Wright, V.P: Carbonate sedimentology. - 284-313, Oxford (Blackwell) Fairchild, I., Hendry, G., Quest, M., Tucker M. (1988): Chemical analysis of sedimentary rocks. - In: Tucker, M. (ed.): Techniques in sedirnentology. - 274-354, Oxford (Blackwell) Faure, G. (1986): Principles of isotope geology. - 589 pp., New York (Wiley) Hardy, R., Tucker, M. (1988): X-ray powder diffraction of sediments. - In: Tucker, M. (ed.): Techniques in sedimentology. - 191-228, Oxford (Blackwell) Hoefs, J. (1997): Stable isotope geochemistry, 4th edition. 201 pp., Berlin (Springer) Moore, C.H. (1989): Carbonate diagenesis and porosity. Developments in Sedimentology,46,338 pp., Amsterdam (Elsevier) Morse, J.W., Mackenzie, F.T. (1990): Geochemistry of sedimentary carbonates. - Developments in Sedimentology, 48,707 pp., Amsterdam (Elsevier) Veizer, J. (1983): Trace elements and isotopes in sedimentary carbonates.-In: Reeder, R.J. (4.): Carbonates: mineralogy and chemistry. - Reviews in Mineralogy, 11,265-299 Further reading: KO05 to KO12
4 Microfacies Data: Matrix and Grains
The purpose of this chapter is to outline and discuss the criteria used in the description of matrix and grains. Microfacies criteria reflected by fabrics and quantitative microfacies data are discussed in Chap. 5 and 6. Major constituents seen in thin sections of carbonate rocks are 'grains' and 'groundmass', the latter developed as fine-grained carbonate 'matrix' or as spany calcite representing pore-filling cements or recrystallized matrix. A spany calcite groundmass is conventionally called 'sparite' (calcite spar), and discussed in Chap. 7. Grains and matrix are separated at 62.5 pm in terrigenous sediments but at much lower values in carbonate rocks. Here the lower limit is defined differently as larger than 4 ym or >20 ym or >50 pm. SEM studies reveal the arbitrary character of particle size boundaries between grains and matrix, but a conventional definition is necessary for thin-section studies. The physical arrangement of particles, including their texture and structure, forms a fabric which reflects the depositional and diagenetic controls on the formation of carbonate rocks.
terial such as micrite, microspar and calcisiltite.A common generalization is that 'matrix' is synonymous with 'groundmass', but some authors use these terms to designate both fine-grained interstitial material (e.g. micrite) as well as coarse interstitial crystal fabrics (e.g. sparite formed by cementation or neomorphic processes, see Sect. 7.6). This contradicts the limitation of the term matrix to 'mechanically deposited material between particles - as distinct from precipitated cement' (Bathurst 1975). One should be cautious about regarding all fine-grained interstitial material as synsedimentary matrix: Intensive micritization, compaction and neomorphism of mixed carbonate/siliciclastic deposits as well as alterations of peloids may lead to the formation of a carbonate pseudomatrix (Dickinson 1970; Geslin 1994).
Techniques: Genetic interpretation and the understanding of the properties of fine-grained carbonates require the examination of polished and/or etched rock surfaces, thin sections, stereoscan microscope and transmission microscope studies, the investigation of geochemical and isotopical signatures as well as the use of 4.1 Fine-Grained Carbonate Matrix: biomarkers (Sect. 13.3).- Conventional thin sections used in microfacies studies are commonly too thick Micrite, Microspar, Calcisiltite (about 30 pm) to reveal distinct crystal boundaries. Peels Fine-grained matrix constitutes a significant part of the and ultra-thin sections offer better data (Honjo and carbonate record. Despite the importance of micro- Fischer 1965; Wolf et al. 1967; Lindholm and Dean crystalline limestones in basin analysis and as reser- 1973; Murphy 1986; Tucker 1988). voir rocks and limestone resources, classifying and geMicrite textures described only on the basis of light netically interpretating microcrystalline carbonates still microscopy may be inadequate. Epifluorescence miinvolve many problems. However, the advent of the croscopy assists in the discussion of organic material scanning electron microscope and the data provided by preserved in limestones (Dravis and Yurewicz 1985, geo- and biochemical analyses now allow us to take a Neuweiler and Reitner 1995). SEM studies of broken, closer look at modem carbonate muds and ancient fine- polished and etched surfaces provide an insight into grained limestones. the variability of micrites. Polished and etched SEM samples deliver better results than broken surfaces. The Definition: The term matrix denotes the interstitial main data which can be retrieved from SEM studies of material between larger grains. Most definitions refer fine-grained carbonates are summarized in Box 4.1. to the relatively small size of the crystals and/or particles bordering intergranular pores. Hence the matrix Major categories: Micro-grained limestones exhibit of micro-grained limestones includes fine-grained ma- mean sizes commonly between 2 ym to about 30 ym.
74
Micrite Terminology
Box 4.1. SEM criteria used in the distinction of fine-grained microcrystalline limestones of different origin and diagenetic history (based on Fischer et al. 1967; Fliigel 1968; Wise et al. 1970; Minoura 1974; Moshier 1989; Peszat 1991; Lasemi et al. 1993; Munnecke 1997).
Microfabric Grain size: Is measured by counting the longest diameter of 100 to 200 grains. Allows attribution to grain size-based classifications. 'Sorting' in micrites, as the result of competition between space and grain growth, can be used as measure of the textural maturity of fine-crystalline carbonates. Grain size ranges may reflect differences in the depositional environment (e-g. reef micrites and micrites in limestone/shale sequences). Differences in predominant crystal sizes provide indications of the potential aragonite-dominated or calcite-dominated precursors of calcite micrites. Grain contacts: Grain contacts seen under the SEM are straight, curvilinear or serrate. The percentage of specific grain contacts reflects the degree of diagenetic changes (e.g. recrystallization). Grain shape: Differentiation of anhedral, subhedral and euhedral micrite grains. Anhedral and subhedral grains forming a hypidiotopic fabric appear to be common in micritic rocks composed of grains > 4 pm. Irregular, interlocked grains form an 'amoeboid mosaic', in contrast to block-like grains forming a 'pavement mosaic' common in limestones affected by thermal stress. Most rnicrite grains are angular to subangular. Subrounded and rounded grains result from intergranular solution and crystal overgrowth. Inclusions in crystals: Liquid and gas inclusion pits are common in microspar crystals as well as in larger spar crystals. The composition of the inclusions indicates the conditions under which recrystallization took place. Microfenestrae: Some micrites contain round voids, 40 to 80 pm in size, which are filled with blocky calcite. The preservation of this microfenestral fabric is used as evidence against a strong mechanical compaction of the sediment prior to lithification. Boundary between calcite matrix and fossils: Diagenetic stages are distinguished by differences in the boundaries between matrix and fossils: (a) Sharp boundaries between matrix and Low-Mg calcite fossils (e.g. brachiopods, bryozoans, ostracods, trilobites) with well-preserved ultrastructures; (b) moderately sharp boundaries between matrix and fossils (recrystallized tabulate and rugose corals, stromatoporoids); and (c) boundaries between matrix and fossils (e.g. mollusks) which are difficult to recognize. Microporosity: SEM studies reveal numerous types of micropores (5- 10 pm wide) in micritic limestones, including both primary and solution-enhanced intercrystallinepores, as well as micromolds, microvugs and microchannels (PI. 716; see Chap. 5). Microporosity is developed in many subsurface micritic limestones, including significant petroleum reservoirs in Mesozoic and Tertiary deposits of the Middle East, North Africa, and the North American Gulf Coast.
Skeletal grains A main advantage of SEM studies of micrites is the possibility of recognizing the occurrence and abundance of planktonic nannofossils (Pl. 713-5, P1. 77/23) in mudstones and wackestones in both deep-water and shallow-water settings. SEM differentiation of silt-sized and smaller bioclastic grains derived from the breakdown of shells helps to define micrites formed by the accumulation of disintegrated invertebrate skeletons (group 7: Fig. 4.1).
Three categories can be distinguished according to differences in grain size and composition:
4.1.1 Micrite Terminology: The term 'micrite' is the abbrevation of
1 Micrite, characterized by a crypto- to microcrystalline crystal texture. The original definition by Folk (1959) sets a grain-size limit of <4 pm. 2 Microspar, characterized by a fine-grained calcite matrix consisting of crystals ranging from 5 to about 30 pm in diameter, most commonly about 5 to 7 pm, and often exhibiting a rather uniform size distribution. 3 Calcisiltite (calcite silt), characterized by a finegrained matrix composed of detrital silt-sized calcite particles. Silt comprises a size grade between 2 and 62 pm (Assally et al. 1998). The upper size limit is approximately the smallest size which can be differentiated with the unaided eye.
'microcystalline calcite'. Originally, 'micrite' was proposed as a genetic term referring to lithified mechanically deposited lime mud (Folk 1959). Most authors, however, now use the term in a non-genetic descriptive sense for a rock composed of fine-grained calcite crystals and particles formed in place or by the accumulation of fine-grained pre-existing carbonate material. This broad definition even includes 'microcrystalline cement' and 'micrite cement', precipitated as micron-sized Mg-calcite in reefs, beachrocks, hardgrounds and caliche, and occurring in primary mud-free, grainsupported sediments of carbonate slopes (Wilber and Neumann 1993). Friedman (1985) has strongly opposed the use of the term micrite for microcrystalline calcite
Classification of micrites
precipitated in marine and nonrnarine diagenetic environments (see Milliman et al. 1985 for discussion). In general, micrite is understood to be the finegrained matrix of carbonate rocks and the fine-grained constituent of carbonate grains. The crystal size of micrites ranges from cryptocrystalline (not resolvable with the petrographic microscope) to microcrystalline (individual crystals recognizable with a petrographic microscope but not visible with a binocular microscope and hand-lens). The original micrite definition relies strongly on crystal size limits which can only be recognized in petrographical thin sections (Pl. 6) or the use of SEM (Pl. 7). An example of a 'typical' micrite corresponding to Folk's definition are the famous Jurassic lithographic limestones of Solnhofen in southem Germany (Fig. 4.4; P1.4611). Terms often used more or less synonymously with micrite are lime mud, lime ooze as well as lime mudstone (Pl. 46/1), calcimudstone and calcilutite. The last three terms are useful field terms. Microfacies thin sections are approximately 30 pm thick, and are commonly thicker than petrographical thin sections. This may cause difficulty in measuring true crystal sizes. Therefore, upper crystal size limits for micrite have come into use: 10 pm (Elf-Aquitaine 1975), 20 pm (Dunham 1962), and 30 pm (Leighton and Pendexter 1962). Bosellini (1964) differentiated 'micrite I' (crystal size <4 pm) and 'micrite 11' (430 pm). The broadening of the definitions has resulted in being subsumed micrite and microspar into one category. A conspicuous micrite type is minimicrite (Folk 1974),consisting of Mg-calcite and calcite crystals with a size range mostly below 1 pm (Pl. 616). Minimicrite appears black in transmitted light and white in direct light. Minimicrite occurs in lime mudstones, wackestones, and microbialites, and constitutes the tests of porcelaneous foraminifera. It is found in calcimicrobes (Pl. 716) and in the skeletons of coralline red algae (Sect. 10.2.1.2). Bernier (1994) stressed the fact that lithographic limestones composed of very fine micrite (crystals frequently as small as 2 pm) and characterized by specific controls on their origin should be clearly separated from other micrites by the designation lithographic micrite.
(e.g. tidal channels, algal mats, lagoons, platforms), reefs, and deep-marine ocean floors. Main hypotheses starting with Sorby (1879) explain the origin of microcrystalline calcite in limestones as (1) in-place formation of fine-grained carbonate triggered by biochemical and physicochemical factors, (2)post mortem disintegration of calcareous algae, (3) physical or biological abrasion of skeletal material, (4) accumulation of pelagic calcareous plankton, and (5) a result of diagenetic processes including cementation and recrystallization (Fig. 4.1). Honjo (1969) differentiated micrites formed by the growth of carbonate in place or resulting from the destruction, accumulation and deposition of pre-existing carbonate particles characterized by subhedral polygonal calcite grains meeting at interfaces (orthomicrites),and micrites composed of calcareouspelagic biota (nannoagorite).These primary micrites are often contrasted with the secondary micrites and pseudomicrites resulting from diagenetic processes (Wolf 1965). Several genetically defined terms are in use to designate the major modes of micrite genesis: Automicrite (Wolf 1965) refers to 'autochthonous' micrite interpreted as the result of in-place formation of fine-grained calcite or aragonite on the sea floor or within the sediment as an authigenic product triggered by physicochemical, microbial, photosynthetic and biochemical processes (Pl. 6/3,5; P1.50/2,4). The term was revived in the context of studies of mud mounds and biocalcification (Reitner and Neuweiler 1995, Neuweiler 1995). Automicrite exhibits specific fabrics and has a uniform mineralogical and chemical composition. Automicrite is fundamentally different from allomicrite (Wolf 1965), meaning 'allochthonous' micrite and interpreted as the sedimentary microcrystalline matrix derived from the breakdown of various carbonate grains and deposition of fine-grained material (Pl. 6/1,6; P1. 7). Allomicrites may contain mineralogically and chemically different constituents. The term 'orthomicrite'(Honjo 1969) designates micrites made of subhedral polygonal clay-sized calcite grains meeting at interfaces.
Modern carbonate muds and ancient fine-grained carbonates: Modem carbonate muds originate in marine and non-marine sites, in warm water and cold waClassification of micrites: Few topics in carbonate ter environmentsand in shallow and deep settings. Mudsedimentology have been debated as controversially as producing processes which can be found in modem carthe origin and classification of fine-grained carbonate bonate environments and which were also operating in rocks. Today, fine-grained carbonate muds originate in the formation of ancient carbonates are: the effects of metabolic and other processes of bacnon-marine environments (e.g. pedogenic and lacusteria, cyanobacteria and algae on the precipitation trine settings; Sect. 2.4. I), and marine environments including shallow marine inter- and subtidal settings of carbonates, Text continued on p. 80
76
Micrite and Microspar
Plate 6 Micrite and Microspar: What do they Look Like in Thin Sections? The former carbonate mud in limestones occurs as fine-grained microcrystalline calcite matrix (micrite). The originally very strict definition (crystals < 4 pm) was broadened for practical reasons and because of the difficulties in genetically interpretating micrite. Micrite represents an accumulation of allochthonous sedimentary particles forming allomicrites (e.g. calcareous nannoplankton, foraminifera or parts of algal skeletons; -> 1,6 and P1.7) or a product formed in place on the sea floor (-> 5) or within the sediment (-> 3, 4) by physicochemical, microbial and biochemical processes (automicrite). Regardless of an autochthonous or allochthonous origin, the occurrence of micrite is commonly regarded as an indicator of low-energy depositionalenvironmentsin protected shallow areas or in deep water below the fair-weather wave base. Many problems are involved with this paradigma. The term microspar (microsparite) refers to a calcite matrix with rather uniform crystal size and equant crystal shape. The origin is explained by the recrystallizationof micrite-sized calcite crystals during recrystallization or as one-step process of cementation and calcitization of aragonite precursors (see Fig. 4.5). There exist six main criteria which should be considered in a thin-section analysis of fine-grained limestones and which are answered in the description of the figures of this plate: (A) - Sea-floor micrite or internal micrite? (B) - Overall fabric? (C) - Textural differences in the sample? (D) - Crystal size and crystal fabric (E) - Fossils and biogenic textures? (F) - Non-carbonate material? Micrite types: Note the textural difference between the rounded micrite clast, composed of homogeneous micrite, and the inhomogenous finely bioclastic 'allomicrite' matrix (questions B and C). Bioclasts are shell debris (question E). The sample represents an intraclast wackestone (see P1. 1613) formed by episodic storms on a carbonate ramp (question A). See P1. 102 for further criteria for storm deposits. The crystal sizes of the micrite clasts are about 10 pm and exceed the 4 pm limit (question D). Middle Triassic (Hauptmuschelkalk): Kiinzelsau, southwestern Germany. Microsparite: Equant fine-grained texture interpreted to have originated by recrystallization in the vadose zone of former micrite (see PI. 47/2). Late Jurassic carbonate ramp (see P1. 136): Subsurface, Kinsau, southern Germany. Automicrite: Cauliflower structure formed within cavities of a carbonate mud mound. The inhomogenous structure (question 2) represents a succession of 'peloidal container organomicrites' (black, crystal size about 10 pm, question D) and accretionary thrombolites (irregular peloidal fabric formed within relics of soft sponges; see questions A and E). Thrombolite structures are also shown on PI. 5015 and P1. 13115. Early Cretaceous (Albian): Soba reef area, Mazo Grande, northern Spain. Internal micrite (question A) within synsedimentary cavities in a micritic peloidal bindstone. Note gradation, geopetal filling and coarse sparite at the top. The cavities occur within dark micrite formed by sediment entrapment by tiny donezellid algae (arrows; see PI. 6011; Question E) which contribute to the framework of decameter-sized mud mounds. Micrite infillings of synsedimentary cavities often exhibit textures which are distinctly different from the enclosing matrix (Pl. 17/3, P1.20/1, P1.50/4). Significance of the sample: Evidence of the timing of sedimentary and diagenetic processes. The internally precipitated micrite alters the mudlgrain ratio of the pre-existing sedimentary deposits and questions the use of micrite content an indicator of low water energy. Late Carboniferous (San Emiliano Formation, Westfalian): Cantabrian Mountains, northern Spain. Sea-jloor automicrite (question A). Hemispheroids of dense micritic/fenestral microbialites (question B) contributing to the formation of decameter-sized platform-margin reefs (Neuweiler 1993). The finely laminated structures disappear with increasing sediment supply. Autochthonous formation of microbial micrite (originally Mg-calcite) by in-situ calcification is indicated by the purity of the micrite (no non-varvonate material; question F) and the protrusional outer margins (arrows). Slight changes in sediment input are shown by the alternation of black micrite and micrite rich in fine bioclastic debris (predominantly sponge spicula; question E). Note circular cross section of burrows pointing to a rapid alternation of soft and hard bottom conditions (question E). Early Cretaceous (mid-Albian): Soba reef area, Vasco-Cantabrian basin, northern Spain. Pelagic sea jloor allomicrite with abundant planktonic foraminifera (questions A and E). Note differences in size and packing of the calcitic foraminifera1 tests which may point to burrowing in the sediment. The sediment is dominated by foraminiferal tests most are sand-sized.The fine-grained micrite component often results from the deposition of nannofossils and only to a minor degree from the degradation of foraminifera1tests. SMF 3-FOR.Open-marine deep-water environment. Early Tertiary (Eocene): Apennines, Italy. -> 3: Reitner and Neuweiler 1995; 4: Hensen et al. 1995; 5: Neuweiler 1993
78
Micrite: S E M Studies
Plate 7 A Closer Look at Micrites: Genetic Interpretations Based on SEM Studies
SEM criteria (Box 4.1) are useful in classifying allomicrites according to crystal size, biotic composition and textural feature and assist greatly in interpretating the possible origin of fine-grained limestones. Many modem carbonate muds and ancient micrites are accumulations of disintegrated calcareous skeletal elements. Two models focus on different aspects of this: The 'Halimeda model' (Fig. 4.3) focuses on a bioclastic origin of the fine-grained matrix of carbonate rocks. Calcareous green algae (-> 1-2) are regarded as a major potential source of carbonate mud originating in tropical and subtropical shallow-marine warm-water environments (e.g. Bahamas, Florida). Muds are deposited in protected parts of platforms and are exported to periplatform areas. The skeleton of Halimeda (Pl. 57/1,2, P1. 149/ 4) and other lime-secreting green algae consist of minute aragonite needles which are set free on the death of the plants. These needles (-> 2) are similar in morphology, size and geochemical signatures to needles found in the aragonite muds. Phanerozoic halirnedacean green algae became abundant during the Mesozoic (Pl. 57/3,6) but were already common elements in Devonian platform carbonates (Pl. 57/4,5). The 'Solnhofen-Oberalm model' (Fig. 4.4) underlines the rock-building capacity of Low-Mg calcite skeletons of planktic algae (mostly Coccolithophorida, -> 3-5) living in the upper hundred meters of the water column of the open oceans, but also occurring in shallow lagoonal waters. The accumulation of these nannoorganisms resulted in the formation of deep-marine basinal carbonates since the Mesozoic. Micrites composed predominantly of the constituent shields of coccolithophorids and related groups appear in the Triassic, are common in the Jurassic and became very abundant during the Cretaceous (e.g. in chalks, -> 3) and the Tertiary. Many taxa are useful for biostratigraphic correlations of Late Cretaceous and Cenozoic open-marine pelagic carbonates. With some exceptions (e.g. Schizosphaerella, -> 7) these 'nannofossils' are generally too small to be recognized in regular thin sections and must be studied in SEM. Note that the samples of Figs. 4 and 5 on this plate would be easily classified as 'lime mudstone' or 'unfossiliferous micrite' if studied in thin sections only (Pl. 4411, P1. 4611). SEM images on the other hand define a characteristic packstone fabric. Extremely fine-grained 'mini-micrites' are common features of microbially induced automicrites and of micritic Mg-calcite skeletons of cyanobacteria (-> 6) and some foraminifera. 1 The udoteacean green alga Halimeda is one of the most effective carbonate producers in modem tropical and subtropical reefs and lagoons (mode 5 of Fig. 4.1); cf. Fig. 4.2. You are looking into the organic filament here. Recent: Bahamas. 2 Close-up of fused Halimeda aragonite needles. Algal needles occurs as blunt-ended laths which are larger than precipitated crystals. Recent: Bahamas. 3 Coccolith chalk (namomicrite; mode 9 of Fig. 4.1). Chalk is a pelagic sediment composed predominantly of calcitic fossils including coccoliths, with many planktonic foraminifera and calcispheres (Zijlstra 1995). Important macrofossils are ammonites, belemnites and crinoids. A significant benthic fauna (echinoids, bivalves, bryozoans, sponges, brachiopods) occurs in shelf-sea chalks. The depositional depth of chalks varied between a hundred meters to a few hundred meters for shelf-sea chalks, but to many hundred meters and perhaps thousands of meters for deep-sea chalk. The sediment consists of diagenetically altered coccolith plates, smaller micrite grains and large euhedral calcite crystals resulting from pressure solution overgrowth (this Fig.). Coccolith shields are deposited parallel to the bedding. Diagenesis is variable. Much of the chalk is only weakly lithified (soft chalk) and retains a high porosity in spite of deep burial. The low cementation potential of shelf chalks is due to the primary low calcite mineralogy of most skeletal grains, the lack of meteoric pore fluids and the absence of deep burial. Retarded diagenetic change in chalks, also caused by large amounts of clay minerals, is responsible for high reservoir qualities. Late Cretaceous: DSDP Site 463, core 44, western equatorial Pacific. 4 Coccosphere. The preservation of coccospheres is a proxy for bottom water energy conditions. Intact coccospheres are evidence of minimal post rnortem disturbance. Note overgrowth of small calcite crystals on the coccoliths. Close-up of
-> 5. 5 Coccolith limestone. Note the co-occurrence of well preserved coccospheres (bottom) and isolated and broken coccoliths (right). Cretaceous (Maastrichtian): Denmark. 6 Microbial micrite, characterized by extremely small equant calcite crystals. These minimicrites were formed within the peripheral mucus of cyanobacteria. The circular open structures correspond in size and distribution to structures interpreted in the Solnhofen limestone as coccoid cyanobacteria (Keupp 1978). Small crystal size as well as the absence of pitted surfaces and inclusions suggest a High-Mg calcite precursor mineralogy. Note the high intercrystalline microporosity. Late Jurassic (Tithonian): KapfelbergJKelheim, Bavaria, Germany. 7 Deep-water limestone consisting of Schizosphaerella (S). This calcidinophycean algal genus is a common rock-building constituent of Tethyan Jurassic hemipelagic basinal limestones. The tiny globular fossil is constructed of two hemispherical to cap-shaped valves. Early Jurassic (Sinemurian): Adnet near Salzburg, Austria.
80
Formation of Micrite
the influence of microbial mats on the formation of autochthonous fine-grained carbonates, the processes involved in the breakdown of the skeletons of calcareous algae and invertebrates into finegrained particles, the role of sessile organisms in the control of the deposition of fine-grained material (trapping, baffling, biding), the variations in urrowing activities creating specific carbonate mud microfabrics and the ways in which the deposition, dissolution and accumulation of calcareous plankton takes place.
ritized skeletal grains are potentially a major source of Mg-calcite mud (Reid et al. 1992). Unlithified deep-sea carbonates formed at the sea bottom were reported from the Mediterranean Sea and the Red Sea. Supersaturation with respect to calcium carbonate due to relatively high water temperatures and salinities promotes 'inorganic' precipitation of Mg-calcite carbonates (Milliman et al. 1969; Milliman and Muller 1977). Another hypersaline basin where inorganically precipitated carbonates have been reported is the Arabian Gulf. The large quantities of fine-grained aragonite in nearshore sediments off Saudi Arabia and the Trucial Coast are explained by inorganic precipitation, since aragonite-producing calcareous green algae do not grow in the Arabian Gulf (Kinsman 1964). However, no evidence for inorganic precipitation of deep-sea Mg-calcite carbonate muds was found by Ellis and Milliman (1985). These muds are formed by suspended carbonate grains of biogenic or detrital origin.
The overwhelming majority of modem shallow- and deep-marine carbonate muds is now regarded as biogenic or biologically induced in origin. Initially, microcrystalline carbonate matrix was considered as precipitated directly from seawater (Cloud 1962). Later, spurred by observations of Lowenstam (1955) and Lowenstam and Epstein (1957) and supported by the forward-looking suggestions of Sorby (1879), most workers began to accept shallow-marine lime muds as being primarily the product of a breakdown of skeletal 4.1.2 Modes of Formation of Micrite and biota, particularly calcareous algae. 'Whitings' (float- Other Fine-Grained Matrix Types ing patches of lime mud), as evidence of physicochemical precipitation, fell into disrepute and were consid- The discrimination of micrites generated by different ered to be caused by biologically induced carbonate pre- processes is of high-ranking importance for paleoenvicipitation (Robbins and Blackwelder 1992). ronmental interpretations, basin analysis and the underBut, more recently, evidence for the direct precipi- standing of the properties of fine-grained carbonate tation of aragonite lime muds emerged (Shinn et al. rocks. Fig. 4.1 summarizes twelve modes which can 1989; Milliman et al. 1993; Friedman 1994). The in- lead to the formation of micrites. crease in micrite carbonates during the Early Proterozoic is thought to be a result of blooms of cyanobacte- 'Inorganic' micrites: ria in phosphate-rich oceans. Strong photosynthesis (1) Physicochemicalprecipitation:Initially, the microcombined with high population densities could have crystalline matrix of limestones was considered a induced the precipitation of mud via whitings. The fine- 'chemical' rock, precipitated directly from seawater. grained sediment produced in whitings was fixed in This view was based on the interpretation of carbonate benthic cyanobacterial mats. In waters, highly oversatu- muds in hypersaline lagoons of the Bahamas as an exrated with respect to calcium carbonate, the mats deve- clusively physicochemical precipitation of Mg-calcite lope to stromatolites (Merz-Preiss 2000). Very recent and aragonite in conjunction with high salinity and exinvestigations suggest an intricate bio-physicochemi- treme temperature (Cloud 1962, De Groot 1965, Loreau cal coupling between microbial activity, water current 1982, Dix 2001), but was also contested by geochemical data (Husseini and Matthews 1972). circulations, and water chemistry (Thompson 2000). Calculations of sedimentation rates, carbonate mud The aragonitic mud on the Great Bahama Banks has budget and stable isotope data indicate that a considerlong been of great interest as a possible analogue for able amount of the aragonite and perhaps also Mg-calancient fine-grained carbonate rocks. As a result, the cite muds of the Great Bahama Bank, observed as term lime mud has become more or less synonymous 'whitings' could be chemically precipitated (Shinn et with aragonite needles in the minds of many geolo- al. 1989), but a biochemically induced precipitation triggists. It must be stressed, however, that many modem gered by planktonic cyanobacteria cannot be ruled out. carbonate muds consist of Mg-calcite (e.g. South Whitings believed to have been triggered by plankton Florida and Belie: Taft and Harbaugh 1964, Enos 1977) blooms are reported from marine shallow-water areas and need an alternative genetic interpretation. Mic- as well as from lakes. Inorganic precipitation of Mg-
/
Automicrites
Processes 1 Physicochernical precipitationtriggered by salinity and water temperature fluctuations
Abiogenic ('inorganic') Automicrite (autochthonous micrite) formed in place at the seabottom or within the sediment
2 Carbonate precipitation mediated by organic matrices (Ca-binding organic macromolecules), causing organornineralization and formation of organomicn'te
Biologically induced
3 Metabolic processes of heterotroph and chemolithotroph bacteria and other microbes causing microenvironmental changes which induce carbonate precipitation
Biologically controlled
4 Metabolic processes of phototrophic cyanobacteria and algae causing carbonate precipitation
1 Allomicrite (allochthonous micrite), deposition of disintegrated skeletal material and of fine erosional detritus
Disintegrationof predominantly benthic biota
6 Disintegration of epibionts living on seagrass and macro-algae
7 Disintegration of invertebrate skeletons 8 Bioerosion causing detrital abrasion and microborings
causing 'micritization' Disintegrationof pelagic biota Erosion and abrasion
Pseudomicrite Diagenetic 'micrite'
.
5 Disintegration of benthic calcareous algae into submicroscodc fraaments (Haheda model)
9 Accumulation of calcareous plankton (foraminifera; coccolithophorids and other nannofossils causing 'nannornicnYe.9) 10 Mechanical erosion of limestones, e.g. at coasts 11 Micro- and crv~tocrvstallinecarbonate cements
Diagenesis
12 Recrystallization and 'grain diminution' (replacement of former larger crystals by tiny crystals)
Fig. 4.1. Terminology and genetic modes of origin of carbonate muds and limestones composed of microcrystalline calcite (micrite). The numbers correspond to the numbers used in the text.
calcite muds has been suggested for carbonate muds along the Trucial Coast and in the Dead Sea. Interpretation of limestones: Various authors studying ancient carbonate rocks have assumed that carbonate mud is inorganically precipitated. This is mainly based on a facies association comparable to the Bahama Bank or related to the grain sizes of micritic limestones, similar to those of modem aragonite crystals.
Automicrites Automicrites (autochthonous micrites) are microcrystalline carbonates formed at the sea floor or within the sediment. As a primary product of in-place mineralization, automicrite is fundamentally different from allomicrites which are a microcrystalline sedimentary matrix formed by the deposition of disintegrated skeletal material and fine erosional detritus. Automicrites include biologically induced, biologically controlled as well as 'inorganic' carbonates as discussed above. The formation of autochthonous micrites is triggered by: Organic matrices (Ca-binding organic macromol-
ecules) mediating organomineralization (Reitner 1993, Reitner et al. 19951, and causing the formation of 'organomicrites'. Carbonate mineralization concepts based on the interaction with Acidic Organic Macromolecules (AOM) first used to explain the skeletal structures of organisms (Degens 1979; Addadi and Weiner 1989; Lowenstam and Weiner 1989; Simkiss and Wilbur 1989), and were further developed in the context of automicrite formation (Reitner et al. 2000). Metabolic processes of heterotroph and chemolithotroph bacteria and other microbes causing changes in the microenvironment surrounding the bacterium and inducing calcium carbonate precipitation. Bacterial controls on carbonate precipitation were at one time controversially discussed but have now been confirmed by experimental studies as well as direct field observations (Sect. 9.1). Metabolic processes of phototroph cyanobacteria and algae, that reduce C02to organic carbon compounds, and thus shift the solubility equilibrium toward the precipitation of carbonate. This mode of automicrite
82
.
Lizard Island Model
>>> Fig. 4.2. The Lizard Island model (Reitner 1993, Reitner et al. 1995).Lizard Island is located in the northern part of the Great Barrier Reef. The granitic island is fringed by coral reefs. The microbialites growing in cryptic habitats of dark reef caves offer a model for describing the biological controls on the formation of automicrites. The microbialites are products of matrix-mediated calcification via specific Ca-binding acid organic macromolecules and baffled detritus. The model shown in the figure underlines the interaction between biofilm activity, sponge development, and the development of microbialites. Microbes and sponges played a central role in the formation of ancient automicrites from the beginning of the Cambrian (PI. 817, PI. 82). The interaction between sponges and microbial biofilms is not restricted to cryptic niches in tropical reefs, but also occurs in cool-water and polar sponge mounds. A: The surface of the rnicrobialites is covered by microbial biofilms (1) which control the input of Dissolved Organic Matter and of Dissolved Organic Carbon. Biofilms are complex structures consisting of variably diverse microbial single- or multilayered sheets (see Fig. B). The biofilms control the distributionof sponges (2) and, via biochemical signals, the settlement of sponge larvae (3). The sponge profits from the supply of microbial nutrients and DOM from the water column (4) and DOC from the biofilm. Metabolic waste (5) is recycled. The products of symbiotic heterotrophic bacteria living within the sponges are important sources of nutrients; they also control metabolic processes and enhance calcification. Microbial biofilms are responsible for the degradation of organic matter into Ca-binding macromolecules, and therefore for the production of free calcifying mucilages. Calcified microbes and partly mineralized fungal hyphae have been observed in some biofilms (6). Fe/Mn bacteria contribute to the formation of Fe/Mn crusts (7) which are also common in many ancient automicrites. The sediment-trapping property of biofilms is important for the growth of microbialites consisting of thrombolitic crusts forming irregular pillar-like structures at the top of the microbialite (Pl. 811). These crusts, dome-shaped micritic and irregular peloidal textures are major constituents of ancient mud mounds (Pl. 812, 6). Calcium crystal growth requires increase in alkalinity.In the Lizard Island reef caves increase in alkalinity is triggered by the weathering of granitic silicates which form the island. Microbialites grow at the surface (8) or in erosional pockets (9) forming 'accretionary organomicrites'. 'Container organomicrites' are represented by the carbonates precipitated within the decaying sponge. The vertical sequence (10) starts with a coralgal facies followed by a coralline algal crust and the microbialite facies. This succession corresponds to the lightdependent horizontal succession seen in the caves. B: Biofilm model after Wilderer and Charaklis (1989) adapt to microbialite formation. The biofilms are about 100 pm thick. They act as a reactor to take up dissolved organic carbon and organic particles via EPS channel systems. The reactor filters and produces DOM and DOC, e.g. as waste products, and release the organic matter back to the seawater or into the open system of microcavities and irregular pocket structures of the upper microbialite. Some of the products are acidic macromolecules which enhance mineralization and the formation of automicrite. DOC - Dissolved Organic Carbon, DOM - Dissolved Organic Matter, EPS - Extracellular Polymeric Substances, IPS Intracellular Polymeric Substances. Modified from Reitner (1993). formation has been discussed for some time, especially in regard to micrites formed in peritidal 'algal mats'. The formation of organomicrites is controlled by organic macromolecules (Fig. 4.2). The organic matter is characterized by a surplus of specific compounds derived from microbes, free organic matter, and decaying organisms. Evidence of Ca-binding Acidic Organic Macromolecules (AOM) have been found in modem and ancient automicrites by chromatography and fluorescence microscopy (Neuweiler and Reitner 1995, Russo et al. 1997). Fluorescence microcopy is of particular value in the determination of residual organic matter (Dravies and Yurewicz 1985, Machel et al. 1991). Two sources of Acidic Organic Macromolecules can be distinguished: (1) Internal production of AOM by eucaryotic and procaryotic organisms via metabolic enzymatic and decaying processes, (2) External origin of AOM as a part of dissolved organic matter in the
open water column. The macromolecules become enriched within immature microbialites or at the interspace waterlmature sediments. They are produced and/ or fixed by organisms (e.g. in biofilms, Fig. 4.2B) or trapped in microcavities and pockets. Differences in the composition of these compounds may result in different carbonate fabrics: Enrichment in acidic amino acids (Asp + Glu) presumably is linked to the formation of stromatolite and thrombolite fabrics; proteinrich substances within confined spaces (e.g. microcavities) result in the formation of peloidal pockets, peloidal coatings and peloidal stromatolites; and the decay of soft sponge tissue, enriched in bacteria, leads to micropeloidal structures mirroring parts of the former sponge bodies. The characteristic criteria of automicrites are biolaminated structures, clotted peloidal microfabrics or extremely fine-grained cryptocrystalline textures. A common automicrite microfacies of automicrites formed in slope settings are boundstones composed of small peloids that are associated with cement layers
Lizard Island Model
'
Phytoplankton
Seawater Oligotrophic conditions
NOj
83
----cop
Cryptic habitat Adult coralline sponge
Nutrient flux
II. Microbialite formation by mineralizing organic macromolecules (indirect microbial control)
Increased alifal~nltcyand (Ca?) input of weathered cont~nentalcrust silicates
Lithification via Ca-binding proteins polysaccharids,glycoproteins , CaCO3 formation via ammonlf~cation(increase of alkalinity) Peloid formation, sponge tissue calcification (micro-peloids)
Rockv basement
B Liquid phase Cells Metabol~tesM
Seawater
Liquid phase Surface film Base film
Basement (microbialite)
(Keim and Schlager 1999). Modem automicritesas well as peloidal and microcrystalline carbonate cements consist of Mg-calcite and aragonite. The same mineralogies have been inferred for ancient automicrites but a Low-Mg calcite composition might be a possibility, too.
(2) Organomicrites (Reitner et al. 1995; P1. 8): The formation of modem Mg-calcite automicrites precipitated in isotopic equilibrium with the ambient seawater, and controlled by a specific composition of organic material was studied by Reitner (1993) in indurated microbialites occurring in reef caves off Lizard Island, Great Barrier Reef (Fig. 4.2; P1.811). The microbialites are formed under dark conditions. Phototrophic organisms are absent. The most important factor controlling the formation of organomicrite is the presence of large
I
amounts of specific organic macromolecules with the ability to fix and bind divalent cations, mainly Ca2+ and Mg2+.The increase in alkalinity required for calcium crystals is triggered by ammonification (microbial decay of organic matter, e.g. sponges), sulfate reduction (in anaerobic layers of stratified water masses) or via carbonate and silicate weathering (Kempe et al. 1989; Reitner and Neuweiler 1995). Neuweiler et al. (2000) discuss the controls of soluble humid substances on the in situ precipitation of microcrystalline calcium carbonates. Organomicrites are differentiated according to the modes and loci of their formation (Reitner 1993): Accretionary organomicrites (PI. 615, P1. 811, 2; Fig. 4.2) are vertically growing structures exhibiting thrombolitic, stromatolitic or massive hardground-type
Formation of Micrites
textures. Borings are proof of early lithification. The textures are a function of sediment supply. Very f i e grained automicrite (0.5-1 pm; minimicrite) is formed by calcifying microbial biofilms within thin calcifying mucus sheets below the biofilms, and in pockets of trapped organic mucus and sedimentary grains. These conspicuously dark, aphanitic micrites contain in-situ peloids and in-situ ooids and are characterized by stromatolitic orland massive fabrics. Container.organomicrites (Pl. 613, 4, P1. 5014) develop as fill-up structures of semi-closed microcavities within encapsulated decaying tissues of metazoans, mostly sponges, as well as in voids made by boring organisms. Many sponges represent 'bacterial containers' (Fig. 4.2) because the bacterial biomass within the sponge is higher than that of the sponge tissue itself. The decay of bacteria-rich tissue result in the formation of a clotted micropeloidal microfabric which can also be observed in ancient sponge reef carbonates.
(3) Microbial precipitation controlled by heterotroph and chemolithotroph organisms (bacteria, fungi): Bacterial decay of organic matter is probably the main source of energy in the early diagenesis of sediments (Pl. 50/1,2,3). Bacteria are important agents in the formation of femc hydroxide, iron sulfides, calcium phosphates as well as calcium carbonate. Starting more than ninety years ago (Drew 1911; Bavendamm 1932), an increasing number of authors have demonstrated and suggested that life processes of marine bacteria and the decomposition of organic matter by bacteria cause physicochemical changes in the microenvironment that result in calcium carbonate precipitation. This has been proved in laboratory experiments and observed in various modem carbonate-producing environments (soils, freshwater and marine realms, particularly in lagoons; see Buczynski and Chafetz 1993; Castanier et al. 1999, and Sect. 9.1). Interpretation of limestone (Box 4.2): A bacterial (not a cyanobacterial) origin of ancient micrites has been argued by many authors (Salomon 1914; Hadding 1958; Maurin and Noel 1977; Riding and Awramik 2000). Because most bacteria are indifferent to light, bacterially-controlled precipitation of automicrite is not restricted to shallow environments, but also is possible in subtidal settings, cryptic habitats as well as deep restricted basins. A microbial production of the micrite forming the bulk of 'mud mounds' is advocated by many authors (Sect. 9.1 S.2; PI. 816). The assumed position of the Paleozoic mounds in deep-water environments below the photic zone creates some problems for this interpretation (Bourque and Boulvain 1993) except the bacteria involved are regarded as chemo-
synthetic (Warnke and Meischner 1995). Microbial micrites were described from Tertiary reefs (Saint Martin et al. 1993).
(4) Precipitation controlled by phototroph organisms (cyanobacteria and algae): The removal of CO, by assimilating cyanobacteria and algae, linked to photosynthesis and augmented by bacterial activity, triggers the precipitation of Mg-calcite and aragonite. The production of lime mud by cyanobacteria is known in modem peritidal environments (Bahamas, Florida Bay, Persian Gulf, Red Sea sabkhas) and in highly saline lakes (e.g. Coorong, Australia; Lake Tanganyika, eastem Africa; Antarctic oasis lakes). The importance of filamentous cyanobacteria in the formation of micrite is documented by the calcification and preservation potential of benthic cyanobacteria (Golubic et al. 2000; Merz-Preiss 2000). The LowMg calcite crystals produced within the extracellular organic sheets of benthic cyanobacteria are set free after the death of the cyanobacteria and the degradation of the organic material; this may result in the formation of carbonate mud. This model is applied to ancient micritic rocks, e.g. to the Late Triassic Hauptdolomit of the Northern Alps which represents a huge platform connected with the hinterland and affected by runoffs of freshwater (Zankl and Merz 1994). Kazmierczak et al. (1996) and Kazmierczak and Iryu (1999) postulate that many Jurassic micritic and peloidal limestones are products of a variously intensive calcification of mats of benthic coccoid cyanobacteria, and that many microcrystalline cements described from ancient reefs may be products of in vivo calcified cyanobacteria. Cyanobacterial micrites are often developed as minimicrites with crystal sizes <2 pm (PI. 716). The in situ calcification of benthic coccoid cyanobacteria mats, observed, for example in the highly alkaline soda lake Lake Van, Turkey, may represent a model for cyanobacterial controlled formation of micrite and peloidal micrite (Kempe et al. 1991; Kazmierczak 1996). Coccoid cyanobacteria mats are permineralized with micritic aragonite precipitating in vivo on and within the mucilage sheets surrounding the cells. Variations in the intensity of the calcification of the mats controlled by the level of calcium carbonate saturation create homogeneous micrite and peloidlike bodies, producing a pelmicrite texture. Disintegration into individual peloids and reworking by currents result in a pelsparite texture. Micritic peloidal grains reminiscent of those of the hypersaline Lake Van are common in cyanobacterial mats formed in hypersaline perimarine environments (Baffin Bay, Texas: Dalrymple 1965; Laguna Mormona, California: Horodyski Text continued on p . 88
Microbial Carbonates
85
Box 4.2. Microbial Controls on Carbonates. Interest in the bacterial fossil record is expanding owing to the recognition of the fundamental microbial controls on sedimentation and Earth's biogeochemical evolution (Neuweiler et al. 1997, Ehrlich 1999). Bacterial sulfate reduction plays a paramount role in the formation and decomposition of minerals, and the control of early diagenetic processes in carbonates (Mache12001). Bacteria and other microbes are able to form carbonate rocks (limestones: Castanier et al. 1999; dolomite: Wright 1999) and minerals on all scales. The significant role of microbes in the formation and degradation of shallow- and deep-marine as well as non-marine carbonates becomes increasingly more evident (Riding and Awramik 2000). Microbes (cyanobacteria,photosynthetic and non-photosynthetic bacteria, green and red algae, fungi) and 'microbialites' (Burne and Moore 1987) play a crucial role in the genetic interpretation of micrite, carbonate cements and biomineralization processes. Microbialites are laminated or nonlaminated organosedimentary deposits formed under the control of benthic microbial biofilms, organic matter degrading microorganisms, benthic metazoan communities, free organic matter, and sediment trapping. The formation and construction of inter- and subtidal microbial mats, intertidal and subtidal stromatolites, mud mounds and reefs, and vent- and seep carbonates is highly controlled by microbes. Marine microbialites are common structures in cryptic niches of modem and ancient reefs (see Facies, vol. 29, 1993). Mud mounds are regarded as a specific carbonate factory that differs fundamentally from the tropical and from the cool-water carbonate factories (Schlager 2000). The geologic record of the microbial contribution to framebuilding in deep-water mud mounds is inferred from (1) problematic microfossils, (2) laminated structures, and (3) clotted and fenestral micrite (thromboids). Bacterial calcification occurs in pedogenic (e.g. caliche: Loisy et al. 1999), sabkha environments, cave carbonates and lacustrine carbonates, and in hot-water travertines and beachrocks. Microbial activity has a high impact on diagenesis (Sedimentary Geology, vol. 12611-4, 1999), controls lithification of tidal deposits and reefs and the formation of cements (Gonzales-Munoz et al. 2000), and contributes to the formation of manganese nodules, concretions (Coleman 1993) and iron sulfide and phosphorite deposits. Fe-encrusted bacteria and fungi produced the red color of Devonian mud mounds (Boulvain et al. 2001) and hematite staining of carbonate grains and microstromatolites in Jurassic carbonate ramps (Prkat et al. 2000). Most heterotrophic bacteria are able to induce calcium carbonate precipitation as a by-product of physiological activity in laboratory experiments (Buszynski and Chavetz 1993). Bacteria act as nucleation sites and may become embedded in growing carbonate particles (Castanier et al. 2000). The calcification in procaryotic cyanobacteria depends on water chemistry and photosynthetic bicarbonate uptake, and the existence of suitable sheets. Physicochemical precipitation at high levels of supersaturation leads to a dense encrustation of the filaments, forming solid micritic tubes (Pl. 5312). Photosynthetic bicarbonate take-up in less saturated waters can lead to micrite precipitation within the sheets (Merz-Preiss 2000). Globular grains and peloids occurring in modem microbial mats and ancient stromatolites (Pl. 1231 3) are formed by bacterially induced calcium carbonate precipitation around dead cyanobacterial threads as proved by laboratory experiments. Microbial mats are vertically laminated organosedimentary structures, which develop on solid surfaces and have steep gradients of oxygen and sulfur (Van Gemerden 1993). They are dominated by cyanobacteria, colorless and purple sulfur bacteria, and sulfate-reducingbacteria. The driving force of most microbial mats is photosynthesis by cyanobacteria and algae. Microbial signatures in thin sections are in-situ formed benthic peloids and ooids (Chavetz 1986, Gerdes et al. 1994) within mats, thrombolitic, clotted and fine-peloidal fabrics, laminated and stromatolitic fabrics, fossils interpreted as cyanobacteria (see P1. 53) and microborings (Pl. 5211-4,6). Thrombolites (Kennard and James 1986; PI. 6/3, PI. 5015, Pl. 131/5) characterized by clotted microtexture and the absence of lamination occur in a variety of settings ranging from freshwater environments to deep shelf, and were important in the formation of framework reefs from the Cambrian to the Cretaceous (Leinfelder and Schrnid 2000; P1. 50/'75). SEM observations may exhibit nannobacteria, and organic biomarker and isotope data assist greatly in the evaluation of microbial contributions to the formation of carbonate rocks. Namobacteria in the 0.03 to 0.2 pm range occur in modem and ancient carbonates. Folk and Chavetz (2000) stress the importance of these microbes for carbonate precipitation in non-marine and marine environments, but also say that 'one needs faith and optimism' to see these extremely tiny grains. Southam and Donald (1999) argue that these very small spherical or rod-shaped grains may represent solid, inorganic precipitates.The geological record of calcified bacterial mats and microbial carbonates starts in the Archaean. Microbial mats are the oldest structured ecosystems on earth, known already from 3.5 Ga old carbonates (Surnner 2000). The predominance of microbes in Precambrian ecosystems has no counterpart in the Phanerozoic.
86
Microbial Carbonates
Plate 8 Microbial Contribution to the Formation of Micrites: Some Examples Modem microbialite (accretionary organomicrite) forming cm-sized thrombolitic columns without distinct laminations. The structure consists of microcrystalline and peloidal Mg-calcite. Note the numerous inclusions of detrital grains (arrows). These automicrites exhibit specific soluble organic matrices which are regarded as responsible for the nucleation of calcite crystals. Bacteria within biofilms contribute to the degradation of organic matter (see Fig. 4.2). Reef cave, Lizard Island, Great Banier Reef. Bacterial contribution to the formation of mud mounds: Crudely laminated stromatolite interpreted as organic matrix mediated automicrite (organomicrite, see Figs. 4.1 and 4.2). Note the morphological similarity with -> 1. Settlement by sponges, foraminifera and polychaetes (not shown in the figure) and the criteria discussed on P1.615 indicate calcification at the surface. Mud mound. Cretaceous (Albian): La Sia, Vasco-Cantabrian basin, Spain. Bacterial contribution to the formation of non-marine oncoids: Cyanobacteria contribute significantly to the formation of oncoids in non-marine, transitional and marine environments (see P1. 12/1,5).The taxonomic composition of the oncoids reflects differences in environmental conditions (e.g. salinity). The figure displays details of the cortex of an oncoid formed in a freshwater environment (Leinfelder 1985).The vertical sequence of the cyanobacterial morphotypes tells us the environmental history of the oncoid: a - Bacinella? sterni Radoicic (alga?, intergrowth of alga and nubeculariid foraminifera?) interwoven with cyanobacteria; b - ScytonemalCalothrix;c - crust consisting of Phormidium; d - bush-like tufts Schizothrix; e - another Phormidium crust. The oncoid-forming organisms can be compared with morphotypes of modem calcifying cyanobacteria. Changes in the morphotypes reflect response to changing microenvironments. The ScytonemalCalothrixmorphotype points to an episodic toleration of subaerial exposure, the Phormidium morphotype indicates increased hardwater conditions of moderate to high energy levels, and the Schizothrix type represents fairly agitated freshwater conditions. The oncolite horizon occurs within terrestrial siliciclastica and is interpreted as deposits of an ephemeral hardwater lake with varying salinities. Late Jurassic: Albuquer, Portugal. Bacterial contribution to the formation of micritic deep-water limestones: Dendrolite microbialite. Erect or pendant micritic mm-sized calcitic shrubs occurring in cryptic habitats of aphotic environments (Frutexites Maslov; arrow), and interpreted as being bacterial or fungal in origin, are often present in ferromanganese crusts of ancient deep-water stromatolites (Myrow and Coniglio 1991; Bohm and Brachert 1993). Frutexites is an important element of deep-water and peritidal carbonates formed during intervals of low sedimentation. Shallow-waterexamples appear to represent coelobites, deep-water examples grew within the sediment or on the sea floor of dysaerobic basins. Note the penetration of the sediment and the downward growth (indicated by the internal infill) of the shrubs. Note the change in shape of the more globular fibrous Frutexites growing into the cavity as compared with the black opaque shrubs within the sediment. The arrow points to the erosional boundary of Frutexites on the cavity ceiling. Morphologically similar bacterial shrubs form in a variety of inhospitable marine and non-marine environments (Chavetz and Guidry 1999),including travertines. An inorganic origin of some of these structures, however, can not be ruled out. Early or Middle Jurassic (Obersee Breccia): Lunz, Austria. Bacterial contribution signalized by 'black/white' peloids: Tiny micritic peloids (arrows) surrounded by a clear rim of acicular calcite cement crystals are interpreted as bacterially induced or as microbial fossils (e.g. Baccanella, see P1.991 8). Similar peloids have been described from numerous shallow marine reefs, both modem and ancient (Macintyre 1985, Chavetz 1986). In-situ 'benthic' peloids occur as cavity-fill precipitates or as laminated crusts, both between and within skeletal material. Most peloids range from 10 to 60 pm in diameter, have cloudy centers, and clear exterior rims. In modem peloids, the rim consists of dentate High-Mg calcite crystals. The cores are interpreted as bacterially induced precipitates. The sample represents small cavities within boundstones forming a sponge/algal/carbonate cement reef. Middle Permian: Straza near Bled, northwestern Slovenia. Bacterial/algal contribution indicated by thrombolitic fabric: 'Peloidal micrite', exhibiting a distinct clotted fabric, is a common constituent of ancient deep-water mud mounds. Formation and accumulation of the sediment by binding effects is explained as a result of the binding effects of bacteria and/or algae. Similar textures originate from the bacterial decomposition of sponges (see Fig. 4.2). Note the fenestral clotted packstone fabric (F: fenestrae). A clotted microstructure is taken as having been influenced by organically mediated calcification, either forming clots of bacteria or cementing peloids together. Central part of an algal mound. Late Carboniferous (Westfalian):Cantabrian Mountains, Northern Spain. Cryptic microbialite containing small encrusting foraminifera (arrow). The composition of micro-encruster associations allows paleoecological conditions and sub-environments to be distinguished (Schmid 1996). Sessile foraminifera are often attached on macerated skeletons of sponges. Note faint relicts of a siliceous sponge (S) at the bottom. The decomposition of the tissue of siliceous sponges and subsequent microbial carbonate precipitation can result in the formation of peloidal and minipeloidal micritic fabrics (Warnke 1996). The association of sponges and microbes is a common feature of Phanerozoic mud mounds and reef mounds. Upper Jurassic reefs and massive buildups characterized by the abundance of siliceous sponges (Pl. 78) and calcified microbes are common on the European northern Tethyan shelf (Portugal; Spain; Southern Germany; Poland; Romania). Most mounds were formed within peri-/epicontinental seas on homoclinal mid and outer ramp settings. The mounds were composed of early lithified automicrites and of allomicrites. Late Jurassic (Oxfordian) sponge reef: Dobrogea, Romania. -> 1,2, 7: Keupp et al. 1993; 3: Leinfelder 1985; 4: Bohm and Brachert 1993; 5: Fliigel et al. 1984; 6: Hensen et al. 1995
I'l:ttz
8 . blicrohial Carbonates
87
Allomicrites
and Von der Haar 1975; Shark Bay, Australia: Monty 1976; Gulf of Aqaba: Friedman et al. 1973, Gerdes and Krumbein 1987). Interpretation of limestones: The disintegration of externally calcified cyanobacteria is regarded as an important source of micritic reef limestones, especially of Paleozoic age (e.g. Pratt 2001).
Allomicrites Allomicrites (allochthonous micrites) originate from the destruction of calcareous algae and invertebrate skeletons, bioerosion, accumulation of calcareous plankton as well as from the erosion and abrasion of lithified carbonates (Fig. 4.1). In shallow waters, tropical storms and ebb-tidal currents causing a mixing of bank and ocean waters can lead to a redistribution of genetically different carbonate muds. Carbonate muds produced on shallow-marine platforms are also a major source for periplatform sediments deposited on slopes or in basins (periplatform carbonates, see Sect. 2.4.5.7) (5) Disintegration of benthic calcareous algae: The Halimeda model. The disintegration of the skeletons of modem calcareous green algae causes the formation of sand- to clay-sized particles. Processes involved in the disintegration, deposition and redeposition of the algal particles are exemplified by the udoteacean alga Halimeda (Fig. 4.3; P1.711-2, P1.5711-2). The ultrastructural elements of the calcareous skeleton of this and other green algae are aragonite needles. These needles are set free after decomposition of the organic matter. Morphologically similar needles are abundant in carbonate muds of the Great Bahama Bank and Florida Bay as well as in Pacific lagoons (Lowenstam and Epstein 1957; Stockmanet al. 1967; Neumann and Land 1975; Nelsen and Ginsburg 1986). The algal origin of the needles was supported by (a) comparable stable isotope data of muds and algal needles, (b) SEM photomicrographs (Pl. 712) indicating morphological similarities between the aragonite produced by udoteacean algae and the aragonite needles occurring within the aragonite muds, and (c) excess productivity of udoteacean algae in the Bight of Abaco (Little Bahama Bank) where the algae produce more than twice the amount of fine-grained aragonite that has accumulated in the Bight (Neumann and Land 1975). Aragonite muds occumng in the deeper Northwest Providence Channel are, therefore, explained as the result of the extended offbank export of algal muds. These points, however, have to be discussed in the light of new data: (a) Isotope data could also indicate chemi-
cal precipitation of the aragonitic muds, (b) SEM studies show that the aragonite needles in the Great Bahama Bank muds are bladed and have poorly developed pointed ends, in contrast to algal needles with blunt-ended prisms (Loreau 1982; Macintyre and Reid 1992). Nonskeletal aragonite needles are apparently precipitated ubiquitously over the Bahama Bank; they accumulate within the low-energy bank leeward of Andros Island and are exported to the deeper leeward slope (down to -90 m), and even to deep settings, as indicated by the position of the aragonite lysocline in a depth of 1500 m (Droxler et al. 1988), (c) Present-day standing stocks of green algae and carbonate production appear too low to account for the volume of Holocene aragonitic mud on top of the Bahama Bank. Algal mud production is estimated to be greater than an order of magnitude less than the precipitation rate calculated for the mud on the bank. Of course, a significant algal contribution to the submicroscopic needles of the muds can not be ruled out and has to be re-evaluated. Measurements of growth rates of Halimeda and other calcified udoteaceans suggest that these algae renew their standing stocks within a few weeks (Wefer 1980; Multer 1988; Hillis 1991, 1999)and could, therefore, produce tremendous amounts of fine-grained carbonate sediment in shallow lagoonal and reef environments. Halimeda mounds and banks, formed in deeper and shallow slope settings in eastern Australia, Indonesia and the Caribbean, document the enormous sediment-producing potential of these algae (see publications in Coral Reefs, vol. 6, 1988).The disintegration of algae, not only udoteaceans, is an additional important source of fine-grained sediments in modern reefs. Breakage and subsequent diminution of exposed calcified filaments of endolithic (boring) green algae (e.g. Ostreobium) and of filamentous cyanobacteria result in the production of silt- and micrite-size material (Kobluk and Risk 1977). Interpretation of limestones: Green algae, closely comparable with modem Halimeda, have been known since the Late Permian (Poncet 1989), were more common in the Late Triassic (Fliigel 1988; P1. 57/3), and became rock-building constituents of warm-water platform carbonates during the Cretaceous and in the Tertiary (Hillis 2001). Halimediform algae exhibiting a highly identical internal structure, however, occur as early as in the Ordovician and are more common in the Devonian (Pl. 57/4,5).
(6) Disintegration of epibionts living on seagrass and macro-algae: Seagrass (Thalassia, Posidonia, Zostera and others) is abundant in shallow subtidal and inter-
Halimeda Model
F
Filament
G
Fig. 4.3. The Halimeda model. Halimeda, a common calcareous green alga in lagoonal and reef environments, is one of the most prominent producer of modem carbonate muds and sands. The erect plant is several centimeters high and attached with a holdfast of root-like filaments to the sediment (B). The alga is segmented and branching. The segments possess an internal structure composed of interwoven tubular filaments which are differently arranged in the central and peripheral parts of the segments (C and D; P1. 5711, 2). Calcification starts at the surface between the filaments (D to F)) and progresses inwards. The skeleton consists of minute needles of aragonite (5 pm long and 0.3 bm wide; G; Pi. 712) which, on the death of the plant and disintegration of the segments, disperse inthe sediment and provide a source for lime mud. The mud is often redeposited within the shallow-water area or in deeper environments on the slope. Isolated algal segments (Pl. 315) are a major component of calcareous back-reef sands and occur in the talus of many Cenozoic reefs. A: The first species of Halimeda was documented from the Mediterranean Sea in 1599 by the Italian naturalist Imperato. His figure illustrates superbly the characteristic segmentation, the branching pattern and the inconspicuous holdfast of Halimeda tuna. The holdfast of the pantropical species forms a mat that fixes the plant onto the rocks or corals. The width of the thallus is about 10 cm. B: The basic holdfasts of the sand-growing species act as anchors in times of storms. C: Internal structure of a segment. Note the different branching pattern and orientation of the filaments in the central part (medulla) and the peripheral part (cortex). D: Differentiation of cortical filaments. Calcification (gray pattern) takes place around and between the filaments. E: Calcification on and between medulla (left) and cortical filaments. F: Close-up of the cortex exhibiting remains of organic membranes; see also Fig. E. G:Aragonite needles. Sources: A, B and C - modified from Hillis-Colinvaux (1980); D - modified from Hillis (1959).
tidal settings. Seagrass can tolerate a wide range of salinities, it occurs most prolific in water depths between 2 and 15 m. The mud banks of Southern Florida, sometimes regarded as an analogue of ancient mud mounds (Bosence 1985), document four important controls of seagrass on carbonate mud production and energy baffling: (1) The long and dense root systems (rhizomes), extending a few tens of centimeters below the sea bed, stabilize and bind the sediment. (2) The long blades have a baffling effect, can trap passing suspension-trans-
ported particles and reduce current speeds (Ginsburg 1957; Scoffin 1970; Almasi et al. 1987). Depending on the density of the meadows, large amounts of muddy sediment (packstones and wackestones) will accumulate. (3) Seagrass stabilizes the substrate permitting colonization by stable-bottomsediment-producing and sediment-reworkingcommunities, and (4) very importantly, sea-grass blades provide a constantly renewable substrate onto which benthic organisms can attach and grow (Ginsburg and Lowenstam 1958).
90
Epibionts are integral members of seagrass communities. The disintegration of the epibionts is a major source of lime mud in Florida Bay (Turmel and Swanson 1976; Nelsen and Ginsburg 1986) and other areas (Land 1970; Patriquin 1972). Epibionts comprise a variety of encrusters such as coralline algae, foraminifera, bryozoans, bivalves, gastropods and serpulids (Brasier 1975; Ivany et al. 1990). Seagrass is not restricted to tropical environments but is also common in warm- and cool-temperate carbonate settings ( Gostin et al. 1984) where epibiontic bryozoans and foraminifera contribute sigmfkantly to the production of mud-, silt- and sand-sized particles (Collins 1988). Floating seaweeds (large brown macro-algae) provide another habitat for epibionts which contribute to the formation of fine-grained carbonates. The epibionts (mostly bryozoans, coralline algae) occurring on Sargassum and other kelps produce significant amounts of skeletal material, which add much to nearshore and offshore carbonate muds and sands (Pestana 1985; Wehrmann 1998). Interpretation of limestones: Seagrass is known as far back as the Late Cretaceous and floating macroalgae at least since the Jurassic, but perhaps from the Devonian. Fossil seagrasses are extremely rare in the rock record, but can be inferred by examining characteristic lithologies (carbonate lenses enclosed within shales: Petta and Gerhard 1977; fining upwards sequences: Wanless 198l), invertebrate assemblages and associated foraminifera (Eva 1980). A contribution of epibionts to the formation of fine-grained limestones of inner shelf settings, therefore, should not be ruled out.
Bioerosion
compounds on and within the skeletons, and the microstructure of the infested particle. (c) Degradation by microborers (see point 8). (d) Mechanical erosion and abrasion in high-energy environments (Folk and Robles 1964; Swinchatt 1965; Matthews 1966; Stieglitz 1972). Tidal currents and wave action in lagoons may be effective in grinding grains. Experiments (Chave 1964; Folk and Robles 1964) as well as studies of the mud and silt fraction of modem carbonates (Mathews 1966; Stieglitz 1972; Futterer 1979) prove that mechanical abrasion and biological processes work together in the production of muds, whereby bioerosion appears to be of greater importance in low-energy environments. Nearly all marine invertebrates are affected by this destruction process. Impressive examples were reported from benthic forarninifera, corals, bivalves and gastropods, echinoderms,barnacles as well as coralline red algae (Alexandersson 1979; Fitzgerald et al. 1979; Canfield and Raiswell 1991). Shells of modem benthic reefal foraminifera break down into micron-sized needles and rods through combined effects of corrosion, dissolution,abrasion and erosion (Kotler et al. 1992; Debenay et al. 1999). Interpretation of limestones: The formation of allomicrites by the disintegration of invertebrate skeletons appears to be a common mode both in shallow-marine and deep-marine settings (Pl. 11811). Fine-grained micritic sediments may still show the disintegrated basic skeletal elements as demonstrated by fine-grained Cretaceous limestones consisting of calcite prisms of shells of the bivalve Inoceramus (Pl. 8718). Bioclastic micrites originating from the disintegration of corals, stromato(7) Disintegration of invertebrate skeletons (bioclas- poroids, tabulates and crinoids were described from Sitic micrites): Sorby recognized as early as 1879 that lurian reefs (Watts 1981). invertebrate skeletons disintegrate after death by 'maceration' processes into microscopic elements forming (8) Bioerosion and microborings: Bioerosion by macalcareous muds and silt- to sand-sized particles. De- rine and non-marine boring and grazing organisms is a major process in the production of clay- and silt-sized structive processes include: (a) Destructive diagenesis (physicochemical disso- carbonate particles contributing greatly to the formalution due to carbonate undersaturation), common in tion of micrite and calcisiltite. Biological erosion decolder sea water at higher latitudes and characterized stroys organic skeletons, grains and carbonate subby dissolution and breakdown of solid carbonates on strates, and creates cavities. Processes involved in bioerosion are corrosion by endolithic organisms and loosthe sea floor and in contact with sea water. (b) Microbial degradation of skeletal-bindingorganic ening of hard substrates by dissolution. Organisms matter under aerobic conditions at the sedimentlwater which are able to disintegrate hard carbonate substrates interface or just below it (Henrich and Wefer 1986; Frei- and skeletons include microbes, algae, foraminifera, wald 1995). The susceptibility to dissolution of car- sponges, near-shore bryozoans, worms (sipunculids, bonate grains depends on the amount of skeletal bind- polychaetes), mollusks, arthropods (cirripedians) and ing organic matter, as well as on the size, shape and echinoderms (regular echinoids). Chemical-mechaniroughness of the crystallites (Walter 1985). The im- cal borings by clionid siliceous sponges in skeletons or pact of degrading bacteria on biogenic carbonates is rocks, produce large quantities of fine-grained carboncontrolled by the distribution and supply of organic ate sediment (up to 30% of the total sediment) in deeper
Accumulation of Plankton
intertidal and subtidal zones; most boring chips are siltsized (Futterer 1974, Moore and Shedd 1977). Clionids are common in tropical regions, but also occur at high latitudes. Boring bivalves (e.g. Lithophaga, PI. 521 8) and snails occur preferentially in shallow seas. Of particular importance are heterotroph bacteria, cyanobacteria, green and red algae as well as fungi (Pl. 5211-4) producing microborings and causing micritization (Pl. 1212, P1. 1316). Bacterial attacks of organic matter in shells lead to the disintegration of skeletal grains into ultrastructural units. Borings of bacteria and fungi have diameters <4 ym, often 1-2 pm. Microborers produce species-specific boring pattems are used as paleobathymetrical markers (see Sect. 9.3.4). Bioerosion is responsible for significant carbonate production in reefs (Peyrot-Clausade et al. 1995; Van Treek et al. 1996). Abrasion and bioerosion of totally micritized skeletal grains provide the dominant source of Mg-calcite lime mud in some modem lagoonal environments (Reid et al. 1992). Carbonate mud production triggered by bioerosion is equally effective in tropical and non-tropical environments (Farrow and Fyfe 1988; Gaillard et al. 1994). Grazing and rasping organisms (e.g. mollusks, echinoderms, fishes) produce large amounts of fine-grained carbonate sediment in intertidal and subtidal environments. A combination of bioerosion caused by microborers, predominantly cyanobacteria, and subsequent grazing by gastropods and sea-urchins on endolithic microflora within the inter- and supratidal zone is one of the main causes of the erosion of limestone coasts (Torunski 1979).
(9) Accumulation of calcareous plankton on the deep shelf and in basins: Modem pelagic carbonate muds deposited largely in water depths of several hundred to several thousand meters are dominated by (1) accumulations of calcitic planktonic foraminifera associated with tests of nannoplankton (foraminifera1 or Globigerinu mud), (2) accumulations of calcitic nannoplankton consisting predominantly of planktonic algae (coccolithophorids; see Winter and Siesser 1994for an overview; coccolith mud), and (3) deposition of pelagic gastropods (aragonitic pteropods and heteropods; pteropod mud). Planktonic foraminifera evolved at the beginning of the Mesozoic and diversified through the Cretaceous and Cenozoic. The earliest quantitatively important calcareous nannofossils appeared in Late Triassic Tethyan marginal seas. Pteropods have been known since the Tertiary (Eocene). A pelagic sediment consisting of calcareous plankton is chalk (PI. 713) deposited in Cretaceous deep shelf and basinal settings. The texture is similar to micrite,
but chalk is white in color, less dense, and less compact than micrite. The sediment consists of diagenetically altered coccolith plates, smaller micrite grains and large euhedral calcite crystals resulting from pressure solution overgrowth. The low cementation potential of shelf chalks due to the primary Lowcalcite mineralogy of most skeletal grains and the lack of meteoric pore fluids are responsible for the high reservoir qualities of the North Sea chalks (Scholle 1977; Zijlstra 1995). Planktonic foraminifera micrite (Pl. 616) Although only a small part of the original life planktonic assemblages become incorporated in the sediment, tests of planktonic foraminifera contribute significantly to the particle flux from shallow to deep waters and to the composition of pelagic carbonate muds (Berger 1971, 1975). The transition from death assemblage to sediment assemblage is strongly controlled by dissolution of calcite on the sea floor which in tum is a function of the fertility of the overlying waters and the aggressiveness of the bottom waters. Both factors depend on oceanic circulation pattems. Planktonic foraminifera are deposited with nanno-organismsand other calcareous plankton, e.g. calcidioflagellate cysts (Pl. 7312). Nannofossil micrite (nannomicrite, nannoagorite, ultramicrite; P1. 713-5,7) The contribution of calcitic nanno-organisms to the formation of very fine-grainedmicrites depends on primary productivity, depositional conditions and the course of diagenesis. Nannofossils include coccolithophorids as well as other nanno-organisms (cone-shaped nannoconids, schizospherids, spherical thoracosphaerids and others) belonging to systematically different planktonic algal groups. Modern coccolithophorids flourish in open-marine oceanic waters but also occur in lagoonal environments (Kling 1975) and reefs (Conley 1979). The cone-shaped nannoconids were abundant in Jurassic and Lower Cretaceous strata, but also occur in Late Cretaceous open-marine microcrystalline carbonates.They are commonly associated with radiolaria, calpionellids, and ammonites and may form almost pure namoconid limestones (PI. 77/23). Schizosphaerella (Pl. 717) is a common rock building fossil in Liassic pelagic carbonates (Kdin and Bernoulli 1984; Bombardiere 1993). Although there are a few reports of isolated coccolith-like fossils from Paleozoic sediments and the Middle Triassic as well (Vecsei and Duringer 1998), the earliest quantitatively important coccolithophorids appear in Late Triassic (Late Carnian) Tethyan marginal seas (Di Nocera and Scandone 1977; Bellanca et al. 1995).
92
The appearance of calcareous plankton microorganisms in the Mesozoic has markedly moved the location of major carbonate deposition towards an oceanic setting. Nannofossils were abundant in Late Jurassic-Early Cretaceous fine-grained carbonates formed in shallow epicontinental and shelf settings (e.g. Solnhofen limestone, Fliigel and Franz 1968; Keupp 1978; Noel et al. 1993), and also were deposited in deep-sea basins (Fig. 4.3). During the latest Jurassic the sink for carbonate deposition shifted from shallow seas to deep oceans. This is reflected by the common association of calpionellid limestones, ribbon cherts and pure namofossil carbonates, first recognized by Steinmann (1925). Nannofossil productivity was sufficiently high in the pelagic regime to depress the carbonate compensation depth in the Tethyan Ocean. Owing to the Late Cretaceous transgressions, the pelagic carbonate sedimentation (Chalk facies) spread to epicontinental seas occurred. Many Cretaceous and Early Tertiary chalks consist almost exclusively of coccolithophorids. Post-Tertiary oceanic sediments have a smaller percentage of coccoliths and larger percentage of pelagic foraminiferal remains. The evidence of namofossil contribution to micrite genesis requires detailed SEM studies of the 'nannofacies' (Noel 1969) as well as more sophisticated investigations of the orientation patterns of coccolith elements (Ratschbacher et al. 1994). Sedimentation and diagenesis of nannomicrites (Fig. 4.4) have been studied by many authors (e.g. Noel and Melguen 1978, Fliigel and Keupp (1979). The good correlation of the coccolithophorid assemblages within the water masses and those found in surface sediments provide a powerful tool for the reconstruction of paleo-oceanographic patterns. Preservation patterns of coccolithophorids are important proxies for paleo-bottom currents and differential solution at the sea floor and within the sediment (McIntyre and McIntyre 1971; Schneidermann 1973).
How do plankton skeletons become pelagic ooze? The sedimentation of calcareous plankton occurs by settling of individual tests, fecal pelletization, and inorganically formed flocs of biogenic material ('marine snow': Lampitt 1996). At the sea bottom plankton is affected by bottom currents and bioturbation. Although only a small part of the original life planktonic assemblages become incorporated in the sediment, tests of planktonic foraminifera contribute significantly to the particle flux from shallow to deep waters and to the composition of pelagic carbonate muds. The transition from death- to sediment-assemblage is strongly controlled by dissolution of calcite
Diagenetic Micrites
on the sea floor which in turn is a function of the fertility of the overlying waters and the aggressiveness of the bottom waters. Both factors depend on oceanic circulation patterns. The disintegration of plankton foraminifera1 skeletons is poorly understood (Palmer-Julson and Rack 1992). Some planktonic foraminifera disarticulate into individual chambers and the chamber walls may dissociate into crystallites (Lowenstam and Weiner 1989). But most constituents of foraminiferal carbonate muds range from silt- to sand-size. The microcrystalline component of the foraminiferal mud consists of accumulations of coccoliths. In limestones and modem coccolith ooze, coccoliths are commonly observed as disarticulated plates and are rarely intact. The plates themselves may disassociate into crystallites.
(10) Mechanical erosion of limestones: In high-energy environments limestone coasts are prone to mechanical erosion causing abrasion of clay- and silt-sized carbonate particles. Examples have been described from the Adriatic coast (Schneider 1977) and from the coasts of the Persian Gulf and Puerto Rico (Pilkey and Noble 1966; Kukal and Saadallah 1973). Abrasion is facilitated by coeval bioerosional loosening of rock surfaces. Rivers as well as wind transport the fines. Interpretation of limestones: Indications for micrites formed by abrasion are poor sorting and the association of fine-grained carbonate and non-carbonate particles (Lindholm 1969), a very small crystal size (<2.4 pm), as well as rounding and good sorting (Peszat 1991). Because of the lack of calcareous plankton in the Paleozoic, some authors have argued that Paleozoic micrites formed in deeper ramp, slope and basinal positions, may represent fine-grained carbonate eroded and winnowed from shallower platforms or carbonate coasts. The ten modes of possible origins of micrite described above correspond more or less to the original definition given by Folk (1959, 1962) which focuses on crystal size and inferred sedimentary origin. Both crystal size and the different clues to the origin of micrites are more successfully studied by means of scanning electron microscopy and geochemical data than solely by investigating thin sections alone.
Diagenetic micrites (pseudomicrites) The recognition of the diagenetic character of microcrystalline carbonate rocks is of crucial importance, particularly for interpreting ancient reefs and speculating on the energy level during the deposition of finegrained sediments on platforms and ramps.
Solnhofen-Oberalm Model
93
Lagoonal Limestone Solnhofen
Fig. 4.4. The Solnhofen-Oberalm model. Biotopes, depositional settings and diagenetic environments of coccoliths and other calcareous nanno-organisms.A: Most coccolithophoridsflourish in water depths down to about 100m. Concentrationmaxima occur in the tropical zone at depths of about 50 m, in temperate zones at 10-20 m. Major controls on the distribution of coccolithophorids are light, water temperature and salinity. Different assemblages occur in tropical, temperate and subarctic zones. B: Most coccoliths are transported to the sea bottom enclosed in fecal pellets produced by zooplankton and fish. Free and isolated coccoliths are dissolved at the hydrographic lysocline. C: Increasing dissolution at the waterlsea bottom interface occurs at depths below 3000 m. The diversity decreases strongly at the 'coccolith lysocline' (LY) near 4000 m. Selective dissolution patterns of coccolithophorids characterized by increasing corrosion and fragmentation are used as paleobathymetrical indicators. The zone of complete coccolith dissolution (coccolith calcite compensation depth) lies at depths of about 5300 m. Diagenetic processes involving dissolution of parts of the coccoliths and syntaxial overgrowth start at the sea bottom and are continuous within the sediment. D: Grain-to-grain pressure solution related to increasing burial causes further dissolution at burial depths > 300 m, and provides a source for the carbonate needed for the growth of porefilling calcite. Another source is the dissolution of aragonitic shells. The figure addresses the importance of nannofossils for the formation of allomicrites both in Late Jurassic deep-water and shallow-water settings. Coccoliths occur in the lagoonal Solnhofen Limestone of Bavaria with an abundance of up to 80% on bedding planes, and in the Oberalm Limestone in the Austrian Alps (abundance > 50% within the beds). The carbonate deposition in the Solnhofen lagoon was controlled by an alternation of hypersaline conditions favoring the growth of cyanobacteria mats and normal marine conditions with the sedimentation of ultraplankton and the input of allochthonous carbonates. The light-colored bedded Oberalm Limestone (PI. 7611) represents a common Late Jurassic to Early Cretaceous bathyal facies that is widely distributed in the Alpine-Mediterranean region. The limestone is also known as Apfychuslimestone, Majolica, or Biancone. The carbonate production was controlled by the deposition of coccoliths and nannoconids as well as by the input of fine-grained carbonate derived from nearby platforms into open-marine basins. Adapted from Fliigel and Keupp (1979).
(11) Micro- and cryptocrystalline calcite cements: Detailed studies reveal that many 'micrites' are in reality crypto- and microcrystalline calcite or aragonite cements precipitated in very different settings including reef cavities (Friedman 1985; Reid et al. 1990; Scoffin 1993), slope environments (Wilber and Neumann 1993), ocean floors, beachrock (Pl. 3113) or caliche crusts (Sect. 2.4.1.1). A growing number of authors calls these micro- and cryptocrystalline cements 'micrite' or 'micritic cements', not taking into consideration the continuing struggle for clearness in sedimentological terminology (Friedman 1985; Milliman et al. 1985).
Micro- and cryptocrystalline cements are formed in place and, therefore, correspond to 'automicrites' as described above; see (1) to (4). Differentiating these micritic autochthonous microfabrics from allochthonous micrites is essential for accurately interpreting of depositional environments. A 'micritic matrix' occurring in intergranular pores of carbonate slope packstones or in voids of reef carbonates should not be considered a priori as an indication of low energy conditions (Reid et al. 1990; Wilber and Neumann 1993). Bahamian slope carbonates demonstrate the formation of autochthonous 'muddy' carbonates by interstitial precipitation of fine-grained Mg-calcite at the
Microspar
thermocline-layer depths (200 to 800 m) and in areas of strong currents. This process can transform sedimentary grain-support fabrics into diagenetic mudsupport fabrics (see Chap. 6), and thus give the paleoenvironmental interpretation a wrong direction. A cyanobacterial origin of rnicrite cements has been described from Pleistocene carbonates (Kazmierczak and Iryu 1999).
(12) Recrystallization and grain diminution: Recrystallization of grains (e.g. peloids, see Sect. 4.2.2) and grain-diminution (Orme and Brown 1963) of skeletal grains are further possibilities for the formation of a 'micrite' fabric. Grain diminution (degrading neomorphism) takes place both during early diagenetic and burial diagenetic phases (Dixon and Wright 1983). It results in a replacement of former larger crystals by tiny crystals due to changes in crystal texture or changes in mineralogy. Examples are known from modem and ancient algal carbonates, where early diagenetic microcrystalline cements are formed within the algal frarnework (Alexandersson 1977). The dissolution of sparry cements in grain-supported limestones and the precipitation of microcrystalline cement (Wardlaw 1962; sparmicritization, Kahle 1977) can also cause the formation of diagenetic micrite. Alteration of skeletal grains due to a combination of micritization and recrystallization lead to the formation of modem lagoonal muds composed of rnicrite-sized clumps of equant anhedral Mgcalcite crystals about 0.5 pm in size (Reid et al. 1992). 4.1.3 Microspar
Microcrystalline carbonate rocks display a wide range of mean crystal sizes. For examples see P1. 612; P1.4712, PI. 9117). Folk (1959, 1965) distinguished between 'micrites' (<4 pm) and 'microspar' (4-30 prn).
Definition: The term refers to a fine-grained calcite matrix, characterized by rather uniformly sized and generally loaf-shaped, subhedral and euhedral calcite crystals ranging from 5 to more than 20 pm in diameter (Folk 1959). Other authors use different crystal size limits: 4-10 pm (Tucker 1981) or 5-50 pm (Bathurst 1975). Further criteria are a mosaic-like microtexture, equant grain shapes and boundaries, pits within the crystals (interpreted as a result of the dissolution of former aragonite needles enclosed in poikilotopic calcite crystals), impurities of clay or organic matter between the crystals, sometimes a patchy distribution within the micritc, and the association of microsparitic limestones with shaley interbeds. Microsparite is a limestone
@ namphere
abioclast (brachiopod) microfossil
.,,.,-/! -t
#-: : . : .
Q
aragonite needles
,"30 yrn,
pitted structure microspar
Fig. 4.5. Two models explaining the formation of microspar textures in fine-grained limestones. A: Aggrading neomorphism (slightly modified from Folk 1959, 1965). The microspar texture is formed by the conversion of smaller High-Mg calcite crystals (top) to larger calcite crystals (bottom) by gradual enlargement maintaing a uniform crystal size at all given times. B: Transformation of aragonite-dominated lime mud to microspar without a micrite stage (modified after Lasemi and Sandberg 1984). The sketch, based on the investigation of microcrystalline Silurian limestones, illustrates the processes leading to the formation of microspar (after Munnecke 1997). The precursor carbonate mud (top, A) consists of aragonite needles, Low-Mg calcitic and High-Mg calcitic and aragonitic bioclasts, and clay minerals. Cementation (B) in intergranular pores starts with the precipitation of microspar crystals that enclose smaller aragonite needles and bioclasts in the sediment close to the sea bottom. The boundaries of the microspar crystals are accentuated by clay seams. The dissolution of aragonite needles causes pit-like structures (C). Aggrading neomorphism (D and E) destroys larger bioclastic grains and produces the final microspar fabric. Note that the size and the shape of microspar crystals are determined in a one-step process by cementation (B), in contrast to the Folk model according to which the microspar fabric originates at the end of a long-lasting process.
Calcisiltite
whose fine-grained matrix is developed as microspar. Sometimes the term is used simultaneously with microspar. Folk (1959) described a gap in crystal sizes somewhere between 3 and 4 pm between micrite and microspar. The data of Lasemi and Sandberg (1993) suggest that the 'micrite curtain' (Folk 196.5) is an artifact of lumping two mineralogically different groups of micrites. Munnecke (1997), studying Silurian fine-grained carbonates, also found no gap. Origin: Several explanations for the formation of microsparitic limestones have been suggested (Fig. 4.5): (1) Recrystallization (aggrading neomorphism: Folk 1965) of micrite calcite subsequent to the removal of Mg2+ions which form a 'micrite curtain' and are responsible for the gap in crystal size somewhere between 3 and 4 pm between micrite and microsparite (Folk 1974). Breaking through the 'Mg-cage', which in turn initiates recrystallization, is triggered by freshwater input related to freshwater aquifers, the influence of rain water, and weathering near the surface (Longman 1977). Interbedded clay could attract magnesium ions from adjacent micrites to facilitate microspar formation through aggrading neomorphism. (2) One-step neomorphic process of cementation and replacement (calcitization) of aragonite-dominatedprecursors to microspar without a micrite stage, also connected with the infiltration of meteoric waters. Porosity reduction occurs without compaction. Examples: Holocene and Pleistocene (Steinen 1978, 1982; Lasemi and Sandberg 1984; 1993), Pennsylvanian (Wiggins 1989) and Silurian (Munnecke and Samtleben 1995; Munnecke 1997). (3) Neomorphic growth from deep surface fluids (Brand and Veizer 1981; Suchecki and Hubert 1984). Wiggins (1989) demonstrated that saturation with respect to calcite appears to be the only requirement for microspar formation. This situation can also be met independently of freshwater if organic acids react with aragonite in marine environments (Baker et al. 1982). (4) Recrystallization of silt-sized carbonate grains (Duringer and Vecsei 1998). Significance: Depending on the model used, the occurrence of microsparitic limestones has been regarded as evidence for meteoric diagenesis, for the influence of low-salinity fluids or for subaerial exposure. Honjo (1969) pointed to the frequency of microsparitic limestones in the Paleozoic and the abundance of micritic limestones in the Mesozoic. The author discusses the possibility of controls by changes in global sea-water chemistry. A more likely explanation is that the longer time involved in the diagenesis of Paleozoic
Dismtegration of carbonate grains and limestones -- 7. 10
C\
\\
Formation
A
II Disintegration
Erosion oitiba~mud Disintegrationof calcareous green algae and epibionts living on seagrass -- 5. 6
Tidal flats
Fig. 4.6. Polygenetic carbonate mudproductionin a shallowmarine platform environment. Lime mud budget for the Bight of Abaco, Little Bahama Bank. Numbers indicate possible modes of origin (see Fig. 4.1). The Bight of Abaco is a semi-closed, 7 m deep shallow carbonate lagoon. Temperature and salinity vary seasonally from 20 "C to 30 "C, and from 34 to 39%0, respectively. Skeletal aragonite and Mg-calcite muds and sands are the predominant sediments. The main source of fine-grained carbonates are sub-microscopical elements of calcareous green algae. Additional sources include fine-grained material produced by the bioerosion, abrasion and breakdown of carbonate grains, and by bacterially-induced and possible chemical precipitation of aragonite and Mg-calcite. An important source is the import of inter- and supratidal muds to the lagoon. Lagoonal pellets disaggregate and return to the fined fraction; the disintegration of cemented pellets formed near the bank edge provides a source for lagoonal muds. The export of lagoonal muds to tidal flats and onshore mud transport are triggered by storms. Some lagoonal carbonate is exported in solution. The Abaco example demonstrates that more carbonate mud is produced by algal disintegration and other sources than can be accommodated on the top, and that mud transport moves on to adjacent tidal flats and into deeper waters around the platform. Based on Neumann and Land (1975).
carbonate rocks has favored the formation of microspar fabrics. Global chemical abd biochemical controls have been suggested for the abundance of microspar in the enigmatic Proterozoic 'molar tooth structures' (Long 2003) 4.1.4 Calcisiltite Definition: The name was proposed by Kay (195 1) for limestones consisting predominantly of detrital calcite particles of silt size (2-63 pm). Calcisiltite embraces the coarser part of 'calcilutite' (Grabau 1904) which designates a fine-grained rock composed of clayand silt-sized carbonate particles. Later Lindholm
96
Check List for Micrites
Box 4.3. Check your sample!
A) Sea-floor micrite o r internal micrite? Check your sample to discover whether you are looking at a sea-floor micrite formed at the bottom/water interface (the more common case), or at an internal micrite formed within the cavities and intergranular voids of the sediment. This distinction is of major importance in the paleoenvironmental evaluation of micritic rocks, because internally precipitated micrite alters the mudlgrain ratio and may invalidate interpretations that relate the amount of micrite matrix to water energy levels (Reid et al. 1990). Internal micrites form (a) in the water column or on the sea floor, the skeletal or non-skeletal grains are transported into the cavities. Or, (b) the internal micrite forms within the cavities. The sediment consists of skeletal debris or unattached precipitates, or of attached non-skeletal precipitates. The last two cases correspond to the autochthonous 'container organomicrites' (Fig. 4.2) and are characterized by common peloidal fabrics (PI. 614). The rnicrite within cavities differs in color, microtexture, crystal size and included grains from the micrite of the host rock. Infilling of micrite may be totally or restricted to the bottom part of the cavity, resulting in a geopetal structure (e.g. in 'stromatactis', PI. 2011, 8). Alternation of micrite and grains may result in normal and reverse gradation structures. Internal micrite should not be confused with the diagenetically formed internal vadose silt (see Sect. 7.4.2.1). B) Describe the overall microfabric! Microfabrics give indications of the possible origin of the fine-grained matrix and assist in attributing your sample to one (or several) of the groups summarized in Fig. 4.1. Homogeneouslmassive matrix (Pl. 6/1; P1. 9011): Appears dense in thin sections, dark in transmitted light, commonly without any or with only a few grains, often without fossils, and with no or only vague lamination. May point to group 1 of Fig. 4.1, but also to a diagenetic pseudomicrite matrix (modes 11 and 12). Inhomogeneous matrix (Pl. 19/1,6; PI. 25/4): Characterized by irregularly distributed micrite areas differing in color (dark and light gray), microfabric (with or without peloids and bioclasts) and the degree of reworking, which is often caused by burrowing and bioturbation. Peloidal matrix (PI. 816): Fine-grained matrix with abundant very small peloids (no fecal peloids), commonly densely packed, sometimes exhibiting a clotted fabric, appearing in various shades of gray in transmitted light. Often associated with sponges. Common fabric of internal micrites and organomicrites. Points to modes 2 and 3. Fine-bioclastic matrix: (PI. 611, PI. 8718-9): Micrite containing abundant very small bioclasts, which appear white in transmitted light. Bioclasts originate from the disintegration of various invertebrates, and often cannot be identified in thin sections. Points to the modes 6 to 8. Laminated matrix: Fine, curved or plane laminae, consisting of homogeneous and/or peloidal micrite, sometimes alternating with spar- and grain-bearing zones. Are laminae boundaries sharp or gradual? Lamination may reflect (a) differences in automicrite production (autochthonous growth of microbialites; modes 2 , 3 and 4; P1. 1814; PI. 50/2,4, PI. 1231 3). (b) differences in sediment deposition (e.g. caused by tides or bottom currents; P1. 1812, P1. 20/8), or (c) pressure solution seams (see Sect. 7.5.2; P1. 3716). Siltitic matrix: Is the bulk of the matrix within the silt-sized range, and do small angular lithoclasts occur? This might point to the abrasion of former carbonate rocks (mode 10).
C) Are there conspicuous textural differences in your sample? Marked differences in texture, rock color and the type of common fossils (e.g. encrusting and boring biota) may indicate changes or breaks in sedimentation associated with hardgrounds (common in micrites of mode 9). D) Try to evaluate crystal size and crystal fabric! Petrographical thin sections allow the measurement of crystal sizes as well as the recognition of crystal shapes (an-, subor euhedral) and fabrics which may be equant (consisting of nearly equidimensional crystals) or non-equant (composed of different sized crystals). Grain size is the conventional measure in distinguishing micrite and microspar. Fabrics made of non-equant crystals may point to recrystallization (Pl. 3813; mode 12).
E) Take a look a t the fossils and biogenic textures occurring within the micrite matrix! Fossils should be differentiated according to their life habits (planktonic, benthic; soft or hard bottom dwellers), frequency and preservation. Borings and fragmentation of calcareous green and red algae may indicate mud production related to the disintegration of benthic algae living on the sea bottom or on seagrass and soft macro-algae (modes 5 and 6). Strong fragmentation and intensive borings of invertebrate skeletons points to the modes 7 and 8. An abundance of calcareous plankton suggests mud formation from the accumulation of pelagic organisms (mode 9).
F) Non-carbonate material Many microcrystalline limestones contain varying amounts of clay, quartz and other non-carbonate minerals. Care should be taken in differentiating the mineralogical composition and distribution (random, in zones) of these constituents. The percentage of clay in micritic limestones is a major control on recrystallization. Interbedded clay could attract magnesium ions from adjacent micrites and facilitate microspar formation through aggrading neomorphism (Sect. 7.6).
Genetic Interpretation of Micrites
97
Box 4.4. Microfacies criteria useful for the genetic interpretation of micritic limestones include texture, fabric, and the preservation and association of fossils. Differences in dominating rock colors are caused by variations in non-carbonate constituents (e.g. terrigenous input, organic matter, authigenic minerals), pH conditions, and the crystal size of the finegrained carbonate matrix. References to settings concern only the more common cases. The numbers refer to the modes of origin summarized in Fig. 4.1.1
1 Lime mudstones. Homogeneous very fine-grained ......................................................................................PI. 12511
2 Boundstones, mudstone, wackestones, packstones. Inhomogeneous matrix. Some dark, very fine-grained micrite. Peloidal, thrombolitic and stromatolitic fabrics. Close association of sponges and in situ microbial structures. Sponge structures replaced by micropeloidal fabrics. Differentiated microbial fabrics developed at the surface of the sediment (crusts and vertical pillars, encrusting organisms, bored hardgrounds) or within semi-closed cavities. In situ peloids and ooids. Gray and dark rock colors within laminae. Common in ramp, deep shelf, mud mound and reef P1. 615; P1. 1011; P1. 2811; P1. 5011, 2,4 settings. ............................................................................................................ 3 Bindstones, mudstones. Inhomogeneous matrix. Indistinct wavy lamination. Very small peloids exhibiting white calcite cement rims. Inferred bacterial structures within cavities and voids. Common in ramp, deep shelf and mud mound settings. Also in non-marine environments. .......................................................P1. 814-5; P1. 1811; P1. 12113
4 Bindstones. Very fine-grained matrix (minimicrite). Relicts of cyanobacteria, commonly filaments (Porostromata). Tidal and shallow subtidal settings. Also in non-marine environments. ........................................... P1. 716; P1. 12411
5 Wackestones. Inhomogenous matrix. Abundant fragmented udoteacean calcareous green algae or gymnocodiacean algae. Shallow-marine subtidal settings, reefs, upper slope. .......................................................................
P1. 5713, 6
6 Wackestones containing abundant transported epibionts (foraminifera,serpulids, small mollusks, red algae). Characteristic biotic associations. Spatially restricted lenses consisting of fine-grained carbonates and occurring within shaly limestones. Tidal and shallow subtidal settings. ..................................................................................P1. 6712 7 Fine-bioclastic wackestones and mudstones. Often dark, very fine-grained micrite. Skeletal debris derived from fragmented and disintegrated shells of invertebrates. Association of debris and large bioclasts and fossils. Dark and variegated rock colors. Shelf and deeper ramp settings, base-of-slope and basinal settings. Also in non-marine environments. ..................................................................................................... P1. 9112; PI. 11811; P1. 14418-9; P1. 14714
8 Wackestones, packstones. Abundant micritized grains. Microborings in skeletal and non-skeletal grains. Gray and dark rock colors. Deep subtidal shelves and ramps. .............................................................................. P1. 1013, 5 9 Wackestones, packstones, mudstones. Abundant pelagic microfossils (planktonic foraminifera, calpionellids, 'calcispheres') and nannofossils. Light and dark rock-colors. Common in open-marine environments. Deep shelf, slope and basinal settings. ......................................................... P1. 2915; P1. 73/2, 3, 10; P1. 7611, 7, 8; P1. 77/23; P1. 99/10 10 Wackestones, packstones. Inhomogeneous calcisiltitematrix. Mixing of silt-sized and larger angular and subrounded lithoclasts in association with poorly preserved bioclasts and non-carbonate clasts. Various rock colors. Shelf and ramps as well as slope settings. ..................................................................................................................... P1. 14112
11Common in boundstones. Fine-grained inter- and intragranular calcite cement, dark in transmitted light. Homogeneous fabric. Microspar texture. Formed during shallow and deep burial diagenetic environments. Affects marine and non-marine carbonates (e.g. caliche). .................................................................................................. P1. 4712 12 Patchy recrystallization of micrite to microspar and in places to pseudospar. The recrystallization affects both the fine-grained matrix and the grains. The crystals of bioclasts (coralline algae, mollusks) may exhibit diminution and homogenization of size. Formed during shallow and deep burial diagenetic environments.Affects marine and nonmarine carbonates. ....................................................................................................................................... P1. 3813, 6
(1969) described a Devonian limestone, using the term calcisiltite for fine-grained, poorly-sorted carbonates (grain sizes 5-15 pm) which probably resulted from the breakdown of skeletal material. This fabric originating from mechanical deposition should not be confused with microspar which describes a diagenetic fabric. Bioclastic calcisiltites, produced by abrasion and bioerosion processes, are common in modem shallow-ma-
rine lime mud environments (Folk and Robles 1964; Swinchatt 1965; Fiitterer 1978).Microbioclastic calcisiltites, however, also occur in deeper-water ramp, slope and basinal settings. Abiogenic or biogenic breakdown of a calcite substrate following the initial diagenesis (microsparitization: Pomar et al. 1975; sparmicritization: Kahle 1977) can produce a 'diagenetic sediment' consisting of silt-sized crystals. This crystal silt or vadose silt
98
(Dunham 1969; P1. 3417) should not be confused with mechanically deposited calcisiltite (see Sect. 7.4.2.1).
4.1.5 Practical Aids in Describing and Interpreting Fine-Grained Limestones
How do we describe fine-grained carbonate rocks? Box 4.3 and Box 4.4 summarize the main questions which should be answered in a thorough description of micritic limestones. The answers are necessary for tackling the difficult question: 'What do you think about the origin of these micrites?' (see Fig. 4.6). How do we interpret fine-grained carbonates? The genetic interpretation of micrites is difficult but can however, be facilitated by a combined use of microscopic, submicroscopic and geochemical criteria. Fig. 4.6 summarizes some key criteria, but it must be emphasized that, particularly in shallow-marine and also in non-marine environments, several genetic modes work together, as exemplified by the calcareous mud budget of the Bight of Abaco, Bahamas. This example as well as many others demonstrate the central importance of mud import and mud export from shallowwater settings to deep-water settings. Export from shallow platform areas to deep shelf settings was a common process during the Paleozoic and Mesozoic (e.g. Pittet et al. 2000).
4.1.6 Significance of Fine-Grained Carbonates
Micritic carbonates offer a wealth of information on the controls of the origin and physicochemical properties of fine-grained limestones. Box 4.5 lists some of these points. Further explanations are provided in the chapters indicated in the Box. Basics: Matrix and micrite Bemier, P. (1994): For a reinstatement of 'lithographic', a precise word to define a precise limestone. - Geobios, 16, 307-3 11 Borza, K., Harman, M. (1970):Lithologisches and elektronenmikroskopisches Studium von Kalksteinen des Oberjuras und der Unterkreide. - Geologicky Zbomik, Geologica Carpathica, 21, 139-151 Castanier, S., Le MCtayer-Levrel, G., Perthuisot, J.P. (2000): Bacterial role in the precipitation of carbonateminerals. In: Riding, R.E., Awramik, S.M. (eds.): Microbial sediments. - 32-39, Berlin (Springer) Charaklis, W.J., Marshall, K.C. (1990): Biofilms. - 316 pp., New York (Wiley) Fischer,A.G., Honjo, S., Garrison, R.E. (1967): Electron mi-
Significance of Fine-Grained Carbonates crographs of limestones and their nannofossils. - Monographs in Geology and Paleontology, 1, 1- 141 Fliigel, E. (1967): Eleldronenmikroskopische Untersuchungen an milairkchenKalken -Geologische Rundschau, 56,341-358 Fliigel, E., Franz, H.E., Ott, W.F. (1968): Review on electron microscope studies of limestones. -In: Miiller, G., Friedman, G.M. (eds.): Recent developments in carbonate sedimentology in central Europe. - 85-97, Berlin (Springer) Fliigel, E., Keupp, H. (1979): Coccolithen-Diagenese in Malm-Kalken (SolnhofenJFrankenalb, Oberalml Salzburg). - Geologische Rundschau, 68,876-893 Folk, R.L. (1959): Practical petrographical classification of limestones. - Amer. Ass. Petrol. Geol. Bull., 43, 1-38 Folk, R.L. (1962): Spectral subdivision of limestone types. In: Ham, W.E. (ed.): Classification of carbonate rocks. ~ m e rAss. . Petrol. Geol. Mem., 1,62-84 Folk, R.L. (1965): Some aspects of recrystallization in ancient limestones.-In: Pray, L.C., Murray, R.C. (eds.): Dolomitization and limestone diagenesis. A symposium. Soc. Econ. Paleont. Min. Spec. Publ., 13, 14-48 Honjo, S. (1969): Study of fine grained carbonate matrix: sedimentation and diagenesisof 'micrite'. - Paleontological Society of Japan Special Paper, 14,67-82 Kazmierczak, J., Coleman, M.L., Gruszczynski, M., Kempe, S. (1996): Cyanobacterial key to the genesis of micritic and peloidal limestones in ancient seas. - Acta Palaeontologica Polonica, 41,3 19-338 Kazmierczak, J., Iryu, Y. (1999): Cyanobacterial origin of microcrystalline cements from Pleistocenerhodoliths and coralline algal crusts of Okierabu-jima, Japan. - Acta Palaeontologica Polonica, 44, 117-130 Keim, L., Schlager, W. (1999): Automicrite facies on steep slopes (Triassic, Dolomites, Italy). - Facies, 41, 15-26 Lampitt, R.S. (1996): Snow fall in the open ocean. - In: Summerhayes, C.P., Thorpe, S.A. (eds.): Oceanography. An illustrated guide. - 96-112, New York (Wiley) Lasemi, Z., Sandberg, P. (1993): Microfabric and compositional clues to dominant mud mineralogy of micrite precursors. - In: Rezak, R., Lavoie, D.L. (eds.): Carbonate microfabrics. - 173-185, New York (Springer) Loreau, J.-P. (1972): PCtrographie de calcaires fins au microscope Clectronique a balayage: introduction B une classification des 'micrites'. - Comptes Rendhes, Acad. Sci. Paris, 274, 810-813 Munnecke, A. (1997): Bildung mikritischer Kalke im Silur von Gotland. - Courier Forschungsinstitut Senckenberg, 198, 1-131 Munnecke, A., Samtleben, C. (1996): The formation of micritic limestones and the development of limestone-marl alternations in the Silurian of Gotland, Sweden. - Facies, 34, 159-176 Neuweiler, F., Reitner, J., Monty, C. (eds., 1997): Biosedimentology of microbial buildups. IGCP Project No. 380, Proceedings of the 2nd Meeting Gottingen/Germany 1996. - Facies 36, 195-284 Pratt, B.R. (1995): The origin, biota and evolution of deepwater mud-mounds. - In: Monty, C.L., Bosence, D.W.J., Bridges, P.H., Pratt, B.R. (eds.): Carbonate mud-mounds. Their origin and evolution. - Int. Ass. Sedimentologists Spec. Publ., 23,49-123 Pratt, B.R. (2001): Calcificationof cyanobacterial filaments: Girvanella and the origin of lower Paleozoic lime mud. Geology, 29,763-766
99
Significance of Micrites
Box 4.5. Significance of micritic limestones - a first glance. Paleoenvironmental proxies Water energy levels: Microcrystalline carbonates are tradionally thought to represent mud accumulated in lowenergy quiet waters on the sea floor. However, fine-grained calcite also forms as an internal precipitate or sediment in cavities below the sedimenvwater interface, especially in reef carbonates. This internal micrite can invalidate interpretations relating the amount of rnicrite matrix to the degree of water energy. Another pitfall is that finegrained carbonates can be deposited and preserved in high-energy environments, if organisms (e.g. microbes) bind the sediment (Sect. 12.1.1). Changes in sediment input: The formation of accretionary organomicritesrequires low or moderate rates of sediment input. Bottom conditions: Differences in organisms living on and within the sediment, and favoring soft, solid and hard bottoms are indicators of substrate consistency Sect. 12.1.3). Depositional settings of fine-grained carbonates Lagoons: Limestones formed in lagoons can be differentiated from open-marine micritic carbonates by dominating microfacies types and specific associations of fossils (Sect. 10.3). Reefs: Fine-grained carbonates originate in reefs inside framework and solution cavities. Different parts and growth stages of framework reefs are characterizedby the specific microfabrics of these internal sediments, which correspond partially to allomicrites,but also include biologically induced automicrites. Mud mounds exhibit diagnostic microfacies types (Sect. 16.2.5.1). Periplagorms: The transitional character of fine-grained periplatform carbonates accumulating on slopes or in basins is reflected by specific microfacies types. Diagnostic criteria are platform-derived grains associated with pelagic biota as well as diagenetic fingerprints (Sect. 15.7.5). Slopes: Steep ancient and modem slopes were stabilized by biologically induced automicrites that exhibit specific microfacies patterns (Sect. 15.7.4). Pelagic micrites: Microfacies as well as diagenetic criteria and geochemical signals characterize depositional settings and assist in the understanding of the oozelchalk/limestone transition (Sect. 7.1.4 and 15.8). Global secular variations Temporal changes in the dominating mineralogy: The dominant mineralogy of the mud precursors of micrites has a strong influence on the resulting microfabric. A distinction between the aragonite-dominated-precursor (ADP) and calcite-dominated precursor (CDP) micrites can be made by recognizing aragonite relicts, differences in crystal surfaces and crystal size, differences in microfabrics, as well as on the basis of geochemical data. The study of the Phanerozoic record of micrites and other carbonate constituents points to the existence of secular variations in carbonate mineralogy and global changes in the chemistry of the oceans over time. Technological properties Reservoir rocks: The microporosity of micrites is one of the reasons that giant hydrocarbon fields are related to finegrained limestones, not only to genuine chalks in the North Sea but also to chalky micritic limestones, e.g. in the Middle East (Sect. 17.1.2). Limestone resources: Many micrite-dominated reefs, particularly mud and reef mounds, are characterized by the exceptional purity of the limestones, which makes the carbonates very suitable for industrial use. Micritic limestones with high intergranular porosity have a high aptitude for mechanical disintegration and grainy destruction, which are useful properties for the production of high-quality technical chalk. Many technological properties of finegrained carbonates are controlled by the sedimentary fabric ahd the course of diagenesis (see Chap. 18).
Reid, R.P., Macintyre, LG., James, N.P. (1990): Internal precipitation of microcrystalline carbonate: a fundamental problem for sedimentologists.- Sed. Geol., 68, 163-170 Reitner, J. (1993): Modem cryptic microbialite/Metazoan fac i e ~from Lizard Island (Great Barrier Reef, Australia): formation and concepts. - Facies, 29,3-39 Reitner, J., Gautret, P., Marin, F., Neuweiler, F. (1995): Autornicrites in a modem marine microbialite. Formation model via organic matrices (Lizard Island, Great Barrier Reef, Australia). - Bulletin de 1'Institut ocCanographique, Monaco, no. spCcial, 14, 237-263 Reitner, J., Neuweiler, F. (1995): Mud mounds:a polygenetic spectrum of fine-grained carbonate buildups. - Facies, 32,l70 Scoffin, T.P. (1993): Microfabrics of carbonate muds in reefs.
-In: Rezak, R., Lavoie, D.L. (eds.): Carbonate microfabrics. - 65-74, New York (Springer) Riding, R.E., Awramik, S.M. (eds., 2000): Microbial sediments. - 33 1 pp., Berlin (Springer) Sorby, H.C. (1879): The structure and origin of limestones. Proceedings of the Geological Society London, 35,59-95 Winter, A., Siesser, W.G. (1994): Coccolithophorids. 344 pp., Cambridge (Cambridge University Press) Wise, S.W., Stieglitz, R.D., Hay, W.W. (1970): Scanning electron microscopy study of fine grain size biogenic carbonate particles. - Transact. Gulf Coast Ass. Geol. Soc., 20, 287-302 Wolf, K.H. (1965): Gradational sedimentary products of calcareous algae. - Sedimentology, 5, 1-37 Further reading: K033, KO78
Carbonate Grains
100
4.2 Carbonate Grains Various names are in use for organic and non-organic particles of limestones that are larger than the groundmass: Grains, particles, constituents, and 'allochems'. The last term is a collective term for mechanically deposited grains that have undergone transportation in most cases (Folk 1962). Grosso mod0 skeletal grains and non-skeletal grains can be separated. Skeletal grains comprise complete or fragmented fossils. Common 'non-skeletal' grains are peloids, various coated grains (Peryt 1983), grain aggregates and clasts. The strict differentiationof 'skeletal' and 'non-skeletal' grains, however, has been discarded, because the formation of most coated grains and grain aggregates as well as some ooids and peloids is substantially controlled by biotic processes.
Terminology of carbonate grains: Fig. 4.7 summarizes the definitions between the major grain type categories commonly used to describe carbonate rocks. Excellent colored thin-section photographs of grain types can be found in Adams and MacKenzie (1998). Subtypes and the controls on the formation of grains are discussed in the following paragraphs of this chapter. The nomenclatoral differentiation of carbonate grains developed from the study of modem carbonate environments in the 1960s and was rapidly augmented by facies studies of ancient carbonate rocks. Today, more than thirty useful and less useful terms are known, having been proposed for specific grain types that differ in real or inferred origin, morphology, internal structures and size. Microfacies analysis needs well-defined grain categories, but it should be kept in mind that a careful description is more important than a desperate search for an instant label for a grain.
Small micritic grains, commonly without internal structure. Subrounded, spherical, ovoid or irregular in shape. Size between <0.02 and about 1 mm, commonly 0.10 to 0.50 mm. Rounded skleletal grains and other grains covered by a thin micrite envelope. Boundary between the central grain and the envelope indistinct. Size between 2 mm, up to >1 cm. GRAIN AGGREGATES
Compound grains consisting of two or more originally separated particles (e.g. ooids, skeletal grains) that have been bound and cemented together, formin! grape-like or rounded lumps. Intergrainspaces filled with micrite or spar. Outline irregular lobular or rounded. Size 0.5 to more than 2 mm. Synsedimentary or postsedimentary lime clasts, reworked partly consolidated carbonate sediment or already lithified material. Shape and size are highly variable: angular to rounded. Size ranges between <0.2 mm and several decameters. Very small clasts are hardly distinguishable from peloids. Fragmented or complete skeletons of organisms. Size from 0.05 mm to many centimeters.
Fig. 4.7. Descriptive terminology of the major categories of carbonate grains. Some of these grain types represent gradational stages: Cortoids may develop into oncoids; spherical isolated pisoids may resemble ooids structurally, and very small micritic clasts are often included within the peloid group.
Bioclasts (Skeletal Grains)
Signijkance of carbonate grains: Grain types are paleoenvironmental proxies both for non-marine and marine carbonates (e.g. water energy levels, sedimentation rates); characterize and differentiate specific depositional settings and sea-level fluctuations, and provide significant insights into global secular variations of carbonate mineralogy in Phanerozoic oceans. Grain association patterns are central to the reconstruction of paleoclimate and paleolatitudinalzones (Sect. 12.2.2.1). The 'compositional maturity' of limestones (the extent to which a sediment approaches the constituent endmembers: synsedimentary clasts, ooids, fossils, peloids, micrite, and temgenous minerals) augment the complexity of the processes that operate on carbonate sediments (Smosna 1987). Changing grain composition reflects cyclic sedimentation and assists in evaluating of sequence stratigraphic models (Sect. 16.1.2.2). Grain type, mineralogy and spatial variations in the distribution of grains are major controls on the porosity development of reservoir rocks, as exemplified by Fig. 4.8.
4.2.1 Bioclasts (Skeletal Grains)
10 1
high-resolution sequence stratigraphy and paleoenvironmental interpretation of shallow-marine and deepmarine carbonates (Courtinat 1989; Steffen and Gorin 1993; Tyson 1995; Pittet and Gorin 1997; Rameil et al. 2000). Reworking of whole or fragmented skeletal grains (e.g. foraminifera, mollusks) from unconsolidated or semiconsolidated sediments is common in shallowmarine environments. Read (1974) termed those grains lithoskels and described modem examples from Shark Bay, Australia, where banks of skeletl grainstone have been formed by accumulation of grains eroded from Pleistocene sediments. Ancient lithoskels are common in lag deposits (Pl. 9/7). Sizes of bioclasts The average size of skeletal grains seen in thin sections varies widely, and for larger fossils depends on the size of thin sections used. The sizes of skeletal grains and fossils in the thin sections vary within a range of <1 mm to a few millimeters to several centimeters. The ordinary size ranges of skeletal grains are reported in the context of the discussion of the fossil groups in Chap. 10. The size of skeletal grains reflects growth size (e.g. tests of planktonic foraminifera), and size patterns; these are caused by transport processes leading to the diminution of fossils or fragments of fossils, and depend on hydraulic modifications. The shape and bulk density of bioclastic carbonate grains as well as the skeletal structure are important factors affecting the composition and grain size distribution of carbonate rocks (Maiklem 1968). The effect of the hydraulic modification of the initial grain size varies with the shape of the grain, whether blocks (corals, coralline algae), rods (larger foraminifera, turreted gastropods), plates (Halimeda segments, pelecypod valves), or spheres (rounded foraminifera). In experiments, plate-shaped grains settle significantly more slowly than any of the other grain types. Spheres also settle slowly. Block-shaped grains finer than about 2 mm settle slowly, grains coarser than 2 mm exhibit higher and irregular settling velocities. Rods of all sizes tend to settle quickly and smoothly with their long axis horizontal, if the interior is not partly filled with sediment.
Terminology Originally, the term bioclast was used for fossils which were transported, broken and abraded and which became part of the organic debris (Grabau 1920). Today, the term has a rather vague meaning in the context of microfacies studies, and is commonly used for fossils, seen in thin sections, regardless of whether the fossils are fragmented (e.g. crinoid ossicles or broken shells) or still completely preserved (e.g. double-valved bivalves). The latter have been assigned to biomorpha. The term skeletal grain is synonymous with the term bioclast. Organoclasts are organic particles of various origin with or without structure. They includeplzytoclasts (Bostick 1971: clay- to fine sand-sized, land-derived plant remains), palynomorphs (HCI and HF resistant organic microfossils comprising cyanobacterial and algal remains, e.g. dinoflagellates and acritarchs; spores and pollen), degraded organic matter as well as zooclasts of organic microfossils (e.g. organic relicts of benthic foraminifera; scolecodonts: polychaete jaws). Phytoclasts and other organoclasts commonly are studied in palynofacies slides after extracting the fossils Constraints on the preservation of skeletal grains from sediments by chemical methods, but can rarely The record of carbonate bioclasts in limestones is also be recognized in thin sections. The analysis of strongly controlled by (1) the primary skeleton minerorganoclasts found in Mesozoic and Cenozoic carbon- alogy, (2) taphonomic and diagenetic processes and ate rocks is of increasing importance for understand- (3) methodological biases. ing the relations between carbonate and terrestrial en(1) Primary skeleton mineralogy and biomineralvironments and provide very useful information on ization: Skeletal grains consist of mineral phases and
Preservation of Skeletal Grains
Size Q
Peloids
2
.
0
Pelletal Tidal Flat
l
Type 21Type 3 ratio < 1 Ooid Shoal 3
0 u
Q
@ @
@
&
2
Pelletal Tidal Flat
0
Grainy Shoal Algal-laminated Shoal
@ @
Ooids 3
Ooid Shoal
Ooid Bar
Aggregate Grains
2
3
..-. ...
a
Grainy Shoal Algal-laminated Shoal Transgressive Deposits Grainy Shoal Algal-laminated Shoal
Intertidal
I
Fig. 4.8. Implication of carbonategrain studies.A statisticallybased microfacies analysis of core slabs of gas-producing carbonate reservoir rocks demonstrates the relationships between grain types, depositional subfacies, and porosity distribution. The subtypes can be recognized in cuttings as well. A: Presence and composition of grains are indicative of subfacies types that reflect specific environmental conditions and settings on a tidal to subtidal carbonate platform. Peloids and coated grains are the most reliable indicators of subtypes. Peloids are differentiated according to shape and size, ooids according to size, number of laminae and shape, and aggregate grains (including grapestones) according to internal structure and size. B: Intergranular and moldic porosity increases distinctly with increasing ooid size and abundance. The amount of algal content is negatively correlated with porosity. Late Permian (Zechstein Ca2 platform): Northwest Germany. Modified from Steinhoff and Strohrnenger (1996).
organic phases (Mann 2001; Cuif and Sorauf 2001). Both phases are involved in biomineralization and affected by destructive processes. Today more than 60 biominerals occurring in bacteria, plants, protists and metazoans are known. About 50% of the more common skeleton-building biomerals are represented by carbonate phases. Other more common skeleton-building minerals are phosphates and silica (Fig. 4.9). Biomineralization follows two basic lines, characterized by biologically controlled or biologically induced processes. Bio-controlled deposition of minerals takes place in isolated spaces and in close association with an organic matrix (Degens 1979, 1989; Lowenstam and Weiner 1989; Simkiss and Wilbur 1989; Addadi and Weiner 1992). According to this model, a matrix of acidic macromolecules rich in aspartic and glutamic aminoacids acts as a binding sur-
Shallow Subtidal
Skeletal Mineralogy
Aragonite Cyanobacteria Pyrrhophyta: Chrysophyta: Chlorophyta:
Rhodophyta: Radiolaria Foraminifera Ciliata: Sponges.
Scyphozoa: Hydrozoa Corals:
Bryozoa Brachiopoda: Molluscs:
.,,. Calciodinoflagellata Diatoms Coccolithophorida Dasycladaceae Udoteaceae Gymnocodiaceae Charophyceae Solenoporaceae Squamariaceae Corallinaceae
LOW-Mg Calcite
High-Mg Calcite
4ragonite + Calcite
CaPhosphates
Silica
0 0
a 0
n L#
Calpionellida Demospongea Calcarea Sphinctozoa Stromatoporoidea Chaetetida Archaeocyathida Hexactinellida Conulata Octocorallia Rugosa Heterocorallia Tabulata Scleractinia
a ,, I
V n
n
n
Articulata lnarticulata Monoplacophora Polyplacophora Scaphopoda Bivalvia Gastropoda Nautiloidea Ammonoidea Belernnoidea
Tentaculitida Annelida: Serpulida Arthropoda: Trilobita Ostracoda Cirripedia Decapoda Echinoderrnata Tunicata ---Vertebrata Conodonts
a
0 0 a a a m
__f_
___e__
-0Aptychus
a
a
rn
a o (otoliths)
Fig. 4.9. Primary skeletal mitzeralogy of organisms relevant for microfacies studies. The dominating mineralogy i s indicated by black circles, less common mineralogy by open circles. Note that bimineralic skeletons occur in several groups (e.g. bryozoans, arthropods). Adapted from Leadbeater and Riding (1986), Lowenstam and Weiner (1989), Mann et al. (1989), Carter (1990), and Van de Poel and Schlager (1994).
face for Ca2+,thus controlling the precipitation of CaCO,. The controlled, organic matrix-mediated mineralization is responsible for the bulk of the Phanerozoic fossil record. This biomineralization type appears in the Late Precambrian-Early Cambrian inkival. Bioinduced formation of minerals results from the activi-
ties of organisms on their external environment with no necessary specific interaction with organic matrices. Primary examples are the precipitation of calcium carbonate induced by metabolic processes of bacteria (Sect. 4.1.1), the formation of iron sulfides as products of sulfate-reducing bacteria, or the precipitation of ara-
Taphonomy
gonite crystals in spaces between cells due to the removal of carbon dioxide in the process of photosynthesis of algae. Bacterially-induced carbonate formation was already abundant early in the Proterozoic at least 2.4 billion years ago. There is a growing body of data on biomineralization processes that act in the formation of carbonate hardparts of invertebrates and algae. The current state of the art is documented in the books listed at the end of this subchapter. Conflicting interpretations of carbonate biominerais relate to the functional forms, the interactions between matrix and crystals and between macromolecules and crystals (Mann 201). Auseful glossary of skeletal biomineralization was made by Bandel et al. (1990).
Several morphological types of skeletons or tests can be distinguished on the basis of their resistance to fragmentation and the resulting skeleton grains (Wilson 1975):
1 Needles embedded in organic tissues yield fine scattered particles. Examples are sponges: (PI. 78/3), octocorals, holothurians, tunicates and green algae, e.g. Penicillus. 2 Segmented robust skeletons linked together by organic tissue will suffer intact transport of parts of the skeleton, but in the end yield sand-sized and larger particles (green algae, e.g. Halimeda: P1. 1491 3; articulated red algae, bryozoans, echinoderms:Fig. 10.55; trilobites: PI. 9411). 3 Branched skeletons composed of blade-like or cylindrical elements yield non-equant fragment sizes (2) Taphonomic and diagenetic biases: Becoming a (some corals, bryozoans: P1. 10613, red algae and fossil is a rather difficult task. The processes that lead phylloid algae) to fossil destruction and fossil preservation are summarized with the term 'taphonomy'. Process-oriented 4 Chambered hollow skeletons are relatively resistant to disintegration (coralline sponges: P1. 7915, gastaphonomic studies are a major tool of modem geotropods, serpulids: P1. 9212; brachiopods, some bibiological analyses. Microfacies interpretations should valves and crustaceans, foraminifera,dasyclad green rely strongly on the results of taphonomic studies. algae: P1. 6111). Some basic references are listed at the end of this sub5 Encrusted skeletons are ususally rather resistant to chapter. mechanical breakup (sessile foraminifera, stromatoIn marine environments, carbonate hardparts are deporoids, corals, byozoans, serpulids, red algae). graded through physical abrasion, fragmentation and comminuation, infestation of microendoliths, bioero- 6 Massive skeletons are most resistant to fragmentation mainly because of their large size and their sion by grazing and predation, micritization, synmoundlike shape (e.g. colonial corals: P1. 8411 strodepositional recrystallization related to the decompomatoporoids: PI. 8017). sition of organic tissue, and biologically andlor chemically-induced dissolution (Bathurst 1966; Freiwald Calcareous skeletal microstructures can be grouped 1995; Perry 1998; Cuif et al. 1999;Peterhiinsel and Pratt 2001). Breakdown is most rapid at the sediment-water into ten major categories (Box 4.6) whose criteria are interface and in the surficial sediments, where dissolu- better revealed by SEM magnification than by lighttion is fastest and microborers most abundant. Disso- optical studies. The definition of microstructure types lution and bioerosion rates decrease rapidly with depth differs considerably due to different techniques and in the sediment. Bioturbation may speed up or slow magnifications used to study the basic microstructural down the degradation of carbonate grains (Bradshaw elements. For instance, diagenetic alterations of primary structures frequently are overlooked in thin section. and Scoffin 2001 ). The breakdown of carbonate hardparts and skeletal Thin-section microphotographsof common microstrucgrains is controlled by primary mineralogy, ultra- tures can be found in Horrowitz and Potter (1971) and stucture, crystal size, shape and size, the porosity and Majewske (1974), SEM photographs of skeleton ultrapermeability of the skeletons, the resistance of organic structures in the biomineralization atlas of Carter coatings against decomposition as well as shell strength (1990). (Zuschin and Stanton 2001) and the morphology of the skeleton. The dissolution rate of biogenic grains is inTaphonomic loss resulting in a loss of information, versely related to grain diameter. These factors and the is caused by the transport of hardparts and skeletal rates and modes of burial influence the physical and grains and by time-averaging (Allison and Briggs 1991; chemical behavior of hardparts and control the record Kidwell and Behrensmeyer 1993; Martin 1999; of skeletal grains in shallow and deep marine environ- Behrensmeyer et al. 2000). During transport processes, ments (Force 1969; Walter and Morse 1984: Henrich skeletal grains can loose their original shape and beand Wefer 1986). come increasingly worn and rounded. Univalved shells
Microstructures of Invertebrate and Algal Skeletons
105
Box 4.6. Major microstructure categories occurring in invertebrate and algal skeletons (after Wendt 1990 and Majewske 1974). The organic matrix within the hardparts is an important control on the preservation of microstructures and the post-mortem destruction (Glover and Kidwell 1993; Cuif et al. 1999). Organic-rich microstructures (OR) of mollusks are in fact commonly preserved only as molds; organic-poor microstructures (OP) are often fairly well-preserved. 0-dimensional Microgranular: Irregularly interlocked anhedral grains without preferred orientations. Aragonite or calcite. Common in cyanobacteria (Pl. 716) and calcareous algae, foraminifera (Pl. 68), calpionellids, serpulids; uncommon in mollusks; rare in corals and coralline sponges (Pl. 79/1,6). 1-dimensional: Thin, elongate crystals with lengthlwidth ratios between 1 5 and 1:25. Irregularfibrous: Randomly oriented individual fibers. Aragonite or calcite. Foraminifera, coralline sponges, ostracods, trilobites (Pl. 94/3), mollusks. Orthogonal (fibro-normal): Crystals oriented parallel to each other and perpendicular to the surface of the skeletal elements. Aragonite or calcite. Calcareous algae, foraminifera, coralline sponges, rugose and tabulate corals, ostracods, trilobites, mollusks. Clinogonal (trabecular): Crystals diverging at low angles from a central axis or several aligned centers. Usually aragonite, rarely calcite. Coralline sponges, hydrozoans, and rugose, tabulate and scleractinian corals. Spherulitic: Spherical or hemispherical aggregates of crystals, centrically or excentrically arranged. Usually aragonite, very rarely calcite. Coralline sponges, hydrozoans, octocorallia; very rare in bivalves. 2-dimensional: Planar or curved blades which may be composed of subcrystals with the same optical orientation. Lamellar (foliated): Very thin lamellae regular or more or less parallel to surface of skeletal elements, or arranged in stacks of slightly different optical orientation. Mostly calcite, rarely aragonite. Hydrozoans, rugose and tabulate corals, serpulids (Pl. 9216, 8), brachiopod shells and spines (PI. 86/1,6), tentaculitids (Pl. 91/7), bryozoans (Pl. 85/4), gastropods, bivalves (OP). Nacreous: Thin, organic-rich tablets composed of subcrystals of the same optical orientation, oriented parallel to the surface of skeletal elements or growth lamellae. Aragonite. Found only in mollusks (inner layer of certain bivalve and gastropod shells; major parts of cephalopod shells; OR). Crossed lanwllar: Thin interfingeringor branching first order lamellae composed of parallel-arranged second order lamellae. The optical orientation of the first-order lamellae alternates. Commonly aragonite, rarely calcite. Found only in mollusks (OP; bivalves, gastropods: PI. 149/5; hyolithids). 3-dimensional: Large crystals (about 0.1 mm to several cm in size). N o ~ m dprisnzatic: Polygonal prisms arranged parallel to each other and perpendicular or oblique Lo the surface of skeletal elements. Each prism is an individual crystal with unit extinction. Usually calcite, rarely aragonite. Inner carbonate layer of most punctate and impunctate brachiopods, outer carbonate layer of bivalves (Pl. 87/2,5, 8; OR) and gastropods, rostra of belemnites (PI. 90/7), ostracods (Pl. 9312). Optical uniform: Morphologically well-defined skeletal elements or whole shells appear to be single calcite crystals in the light microscope. Calcite cleavage visible under ordinary light. Typical of echinoderms (Pl. 95/3) and spicules of some calcareous sponges. Extremely rare in foraminifera and bivalves.
(gastropods, cephalopods) and thin bivalved shells (brachiopods, bivalves, ostracods) are highly subject to intact transport of the skeleton, whereas multi-element, tightly sutured (echinoids, some crinoids) and loosely articulated skeletons (most crinoids, trilobites) are subject to disarticulation and fragmentation (Brett and Baird 1986). Out-of-habitat transport of fossils is commonly associated with settings affected by high-energy currents or steep depositional slopes. Time-averaging is the mixing of skeletal elements of non-contemporaneous organisms (Walker and Bambach 1971). Mollusks and benthic foraminifera from near-shore marine settings are time-averaged over decades to hundreds of years, and organisms living on carbonate platforms and in reefs over a time scale of
decades to ten thousands of years (Kidwell and Behrensmeyer 1993). A model showing the distribution of the relative abundance of the types of time-averaging in different marine environments was developed by Fiirsich and Aberhan (1990). However, despite all these constraints, death assemblages of resistant skeletal elements are excellent records of environmental distribution and community composition for many major groups (Kidwell and Flessa 1996). Many skeletal grain types have specific preservation potentials within a given depositional environment, depending on the susceptibility of grains to mechanical destruction, duration of deposition/exhumation/re-
Utility of Different Methods
distribution processes, and early dissolution of grains calcite (Pingitore 1976), and by biogenic micritization. preceding cementation. Brachert et al. (1996) refer to Aragonitic bioclasts were likely prone to sea floor disthis particular type of microfacies as microtaphofacies. solution, but preservation of Quaternary aragonitic These microfacies types reflects the taphonomic his- pteropods is reported from the deep continental slope. tory of bioclast rather than original distribution pattems. Generally, preservation of aragonitic fossils in carbonThe microtaphofacies concept provides important in- ate rocks requires very specific depositional and diagesights into the controls on microfacies of carbonate netic conditions (Fiichtbauer and Goldschmidt 1964; ramps and platforms by sealevel fluctuations (Sect. Scherer 1977). The selective diagenetic changes in invertebrate skel16.1.2.2). etal grains were investigated by experimental dissoluMajor preservation biases are caused by dissolution tion of recent skeletal carbonates, particularly of molprocesses involved in skeletal grain diagenesis (Chave lusks, bryozoans, echinoderms, corals and calcareous 1964): Skeletal diagenesis is a matter of multiple algae (Walter 1985). These studies and the study of the choices in space and time, as exemplified by the diage- microarchitecture of hardparts show the dominating role netic sequence pattems of corals (Schroeder 1984; see of the ultrastructure for the relative reactivity of skelP1. 35). Because skeletal durability relates strongly to etal carbonates during dissolution and preservation mineralogy and ultrastructure, relative diagenetic (Dullo 1987). The impact of the diagenetic loss of bioclasts on the preservational orders of skeletal structures are common, and can be used to estimate diagenetic changes. The composition of carbonate rocks has been thoroughly relative order of preservation in meteoric environments studied by comparison of modem and Pleistocene caris calcite > aragonite > High-Mg calcite. High-Mg cal- bonates affected by meteoric diagenesis (Land 1967), cite is unstable in freshwater and can easily transform and is exemplified by the 'diagenetic sieve' (Dullo 1984; to Low-Mg calcite by incongruent leaching or only little Fig. 4.10). Initial diagenetic alterations of the hardparts of machange in microstructures and microfabrics (Bathurst rine organisms may occur within a short time (Flessa 1971). The process of magnesium loss during stabilization and Brown 1983). The diagenetic thickening of skelof Mg-rich calcites and the effect of that loss on the etal elements of recent corals takes place within a time resulting calcite microfabric are not well understood range of twenty years, prior to the alteration of arago(Towe and Hemleben 1976; Dreifuss 1977; Oti and nite to calcite (Potthast 1992). Selective dissolution and Miiller 1985). Some of the altered HCM parts show replacement of aragonitic bioclasts continues in shaltextural alterations, others do not. The characteristically low-marine burial environments (Brachert and Dullo finer size distribution and the relic-free microfabrics 2000). In addition to all the processes described above, doresulting from HCM stabilization are distinctly different from the coarse, pitted, relic-bearing calcites which lomitization (Murray 1964),silicification, burial diagenreplace originally aragonitic constituents. The interpre- esis and compaction can contribute strongly to the oblittation of diagenetic alterations in fine-grained calcitic eration of skeletal grains and to their complete loss in skeletal grains (porcelaneous foraminifera: Budd and the geological record (see PI. 3611, 3, 4; P1. 3717, P1. Hiatt 1993; echinoderms: Richter 1979, 1984) is also 4714, P1. 10918). complicated by the level of observation since the resulting 'grain diminution' (Sect. 4.1.2) is difficult to (3)DifSerent methods can lead to different results: substantiate in thin sections. Thin sections of limestones do not document the total Aragonite skeletons (mollusks, corals, green algae) record of skeletal grains. Some very small skeletal are replaced by calcite (Bathurst 1964; Talbot 1972), grains may be missed. Agglutinated or silicified miand have a consistent alteration behavior (Sandberg crofossils may be underrepresented. Toomey (1983) 1984). The replacement crystals are one or more or- while studying a Late Paleozoic shelf limestone in thin ders of latitude larger than the crystals they replace. sections and acid residue samples, demonstrated that The original microstructures are commonly not pre- only about 80% of agglutinated foraminifera could be served. The transformation of aragonite skeletons into recorded in the acid residue samples. calcite bioclasts takes place in meteoric and phreatic Some organism groups are almost always underenvironments by cementation after dissolution of ara- represented or missing in thin sections when compared gonite via a mold stage (PI. 149/5), by in situ calcifica- with acid residues of limestones (e.g. agglutinated foration and micro- to macrorecrystallization connected minifera, ostracods, echinoderms, scolecodonts, conwith a solution film between aragonite and replacing odonts, fish remains). One example are holothurians
Influence of Diagenesis
107
Fig. 4.10. The 'diagenetic sieve' (after Dullo 1990). The Echmoderms Ostracods Aragonltlc Mollusks study of modem submergent reefs and Pleistocene emergent reefs allows the stages and timing of the diagenetic alterations of skeletal grains to be recognized (e.g. James 1974; Scherer 1975; Gvirtzman and Friedman 1977; Vollbrecht 1990). Comparison of the biotic composition of recent reefs off the Red Sea Coast with a strongly altered reef on the Pleistocene terraces, occurring in different levels of elevation above the present sea, exhibits progressive diagenetic alterPLEISTOCENE REEFS ations of bioclasts. These alterations result in the partial to complete leaching bf primary aragonitic biota, a gradual decrease in Mg-calcitic hardparts, concommitent processes of replacement and recrystallization, and the precipitation of carbonate cements. Aragonitic bioclasts (scleractinians, hydrozoans, aragonitic mollusks) and Mg-calcitic bioclasts (echinoderms, foraminifera, coralline calcareous algae) are drastically reduced in the geological record by meteoric diagenesis. The Pleistocene reef limestone yields a higher amount of unidentified bioclasts, peloids, carbonate cement and pores than modem reefs. The examples demonstrate the significant modification of biotic composition and the frequency of skeletal grains in limestones by selective fossil diagenesis. The degree of progressive diagenesis within the reef terraces is proportional to the age of the Pleistocene reefs, which varies between 86 000 and about 340 000 years. MODERN REEFS
Foram~n~fers and
B~oclasts,Non-skeletal Gra~ns,Matr~x,Cement,
which occur in high abundance in acid residues of basinal limestones, but are extremely rarely observed in thin sections. A combination of thin section studies and the investigation of acid residues is strongly recommended. These differences are important for the evaluation of 'fossil diversity in thin sections' (Sect. 6.2.1.4). The advantages and disadvantages of two-dimensional versus three-dimensional aspects of skeletal grains are illustrated in P1. 9/1-6. Significance of bioclasts Skeletal grains are the most valuable grain types in the context of determining the age of limestone samples. The type and composition of ;keletal grains is highly sensitive to the depositional environment and offer significant proxies for paleoenvironmental controls on carbonate depositionand paleoclimatic conditions. Under favorable conditions, the diagenesis of skeletal grains can document sealevel fluctuations as exemplified by the study of Pleistocene beach sediments in Bermuda Island (Vollbrecht and Meischner 1993). The diagenesis of sediments is reflected in the diagenesis of fossils. Because the original mineralogy of most calcareous fossils is known or can be inferred, fossil diagenesis is a perfect tool for reconstructing diagenetic pathways.
Basics: Preservation of skeletal grains (bioclasts) Adams, A.E., MacKenzie, W.S. (1998): Acolour atlas of carbonate sediments under the microscope. - 180 pp., London (Manson) Majewske, O.P. (1974): Recognition of invertebrate fossil fragments in rocks and thin sections. - International Sedimentary Petrographical Series, 13, 101 pp., Leiden (Brill) Peryt, T.M. (ed., 1983): Coated grains.- 655 pp., Berlin (Springer) Richter, D. (1983): Classification of coated grains: discussion. - In: Peryt, T. (ed.): Coated grains. - 7-8, Berlin (Springer) Steinhoff, I., Strohmenger, C. (1996): Zechstein 2 carbonate platform subfacies and grain-type distribution (Upper Permian, Northwest Germany). - Facies, 35, 105-132
Bionzineralization Carter, J.G. (ed., 1990): Skeletal biomineralization patterns, processes and evolutionary trends. Vol. I. - 832 pp., New York (Van Nostrand) Degens, E.T. (1979): Why do organisms calcify? - Chem. Geol., 25, 257-269 Degens, E.T. (1989): Perspectives in biogeochemistry. 423 pp., Berlin (Springer) Leadbeater, B X C , Riding, R. (eds., 1986): Biomineralization in lower plants and animals. - Syst. Ass. Spec. Vol., 30, 308 pp., Oxford (Clarendon Press) Kempe, S., Kazmierczak, J. (1994): The role of alkalinity in the evolution of ocean chemistry, organization of living systems and biocalcification prozesses. - In: Doumenge, F. (ed.): Past and present biomineralization processes. -
108
Skeletal Grains
Plate 9 Skeletal Grains (Bioclasts): 'Thin-Section Fossils' and Taphonomic Pitfalls Skeletal grains are the prime source of carbonate sands and muds deposited in marine environments. The value of bioclasts in facies analysis depends largely on the level of systematic assignment. Determination of 'thinsection fossils' at a genus or species level depends on the paleontological background of the student and her or his ability to reconstruct a three-dimensional picture from random cuts. Reconstruction and taxonomic attribution is facilitated by comparison of 'thin-section fossils' with 'acid-residue' fossils (-> 1-6). The joint use of thin-section and acid-residue techniques is strongly recommended - last but not least because thin-sections reflect only parts of the total fossil record of the limestone sample. The poor preservation of taxonomically important criteria caused by taphonomic and diagenetic processes (-> 7) is responsible for generalized taxonomic assignments (e.g. 'limestone with gastropods and foraminifera'). Two- and three-dimensional aspects offossils. Selective silicification of a Late Pennsylvanian shelf limestone (Carnic Alps, Austria) allows of thin-section and acid-residue data to be compared (Fohrer 1991). 1 Thin section: Median section of the microgranular calcareous foraminifera Deckerella Cushman and Waters (Palaeotextulariacea, Fusulinina). Genus criteria: Elongate test, short and wide chambers, biserially and later uniserially arranged. Microgranular wall dark in transmitted light; exterior part of the wall agglutinated. Aperture of later stages with parallel slitlike openings. The thin section provides all the information necessary for generic determination. The genus is restricted to the Carboniferous. 2 Acid residue of a specimen of Deckerella. The morphology of the test and the arrangement of chambers are shown more distinctly than in the thin section. 3 Thin section: Oblique axial section of the dasyclad green alga Anthracoporella Pia (compare P1. 5916). 'Stem cell' filled with sediment; the thick wall exhibits tangential, longitudinal and oblique sections of pores (branches). The arrow points to encrusting foraminifera. 4 Acid residue of Anthracoporella. Shape and arrangement of pores are more obvious than in the thin section. Quantitative species-diagnostic data (e.g. pore diameter) are different from thin-section data. 5 Thin section: Fenestrate bryozoan exhibiting the obverse side of the net-like colony, fenestrules (F) and cross sections of zooecia apertures (ZA); compare P1. 85/10. These criteria allow them to be designated only as 'fenestrate bryozoa'. 6 Acid residue.The taxonomically important arrangement, size and shape of the zooecia are more obvious than in thin sections and allow them to be assigned to the genus Fenestella. Measurements can be done more exactly than in thin sections. Taphonomic and diagenetic controls on the preservation of skeletal grains. Essential criteria for describing the 'microtaphofacies' of this sample are abrasion, fragmentation, bioerosion and encrustation. Microtaphofacies refers to the taphonomic biasing caused by displacement, redeposition and mixing of grains as well as selective dissolution which in turn is controlled by the primary skeletal mineralogy. 7 The limestone conglomerate (Early Tertiary, Eocene: Croatia) consists of fossils (gastropods - G, bivalves - P, foraminifera, dasyclad algae), micritic limestone pebbles (MLP), peloids and small reworked and rounded micrite clasts (MC). Gastropods and alveolinid foraminifera exhibit different preservation due to different primary mineralogy: The aragonitic gastropod shells are dissolved, but the shape of the test is still preserved. Molds are infilled with sediment and microfossils. In contrast, the porcellaneous calcitic tests of the miliolid foraminifers Alveolina (A) and Orbitolites (0)exhibit no dlagenetic changes. Low-Mg calcite is less susceptible to dissolution than aragonite or High-Mg calcite. The example exhibits a common relative order of bioclast preservation within an environment affected by oscillating marine, phreatic and vadose diagenetic processes: Low resistance of primary aragonitic skeletal grains (e.g. gastropods, scleractinian corals, dasyclad algae) to dissolution, and higher resistance of primary calcitic grains represented by miliolid foraminifera, coralline algae, and fibrous lamellar bivalve shells (Gindy 1987; Bathurst 1994). Taphonomic history of gastropods: Reworking and redeposition of the 'steinkerns' (lithoskels) took place subsequent to dissolution of aragonitic shells and mold formation together with the deposition of well-rounded micritic limestone pebbles (MLP). Interstices between larger skeletal grains and pebbles were filled with alveolinid and other foraminifera, dasyclads and small bioclast debris. Gastropod molds were encrusted by foraminifera (F) and spirorbid worms (W). Other organisms settling on hard substrates are barely recognizable barnacles (B), compare P1. 9316, 7. Borings of shells are evident. Meteoric dissolution is recorded by irregular solution voids (SV) filled with silt. Temporal sequence of events: Reworking of back-reef biota (indicated by Alveolina and Orbitolites) and deposition of molds of aragonitic shells, pebbles and micrite clasts in a high-energy environment -> encrustation and boring of larger fossils -> cementation and meteoric dissolution -> deposition of foraminifera1 sand. The mixed deposition of worn fossils, allochthonous lithoclasts and blackened peloids as well as strong encrustation and boring characterize a 'lag deposit', formed in an environment with slow accumulation of coarse material within a winnowing zone (Standard Microfacies Type 14).This is the case in coastal zones which are prone to rapid changes in sedimentation rates, destruction, dissolution and renewed marine deposition. -> 1-6: Fohrer 1991
Plate 9: Skeletal Grains
109
110
Bulletin Institute de OcCanographieMonocao, Special Issue, 13,61-117 Lowenstam, H.A., Weiner, S. (1989): On biomineralization. - 324 pp., New York (Oxford University Press) Mann,S. (2001): Biornineralization -principles and concepts in bioinorganic materials chemistry.- 210 pp., Oxford (Oxford University Press) Mann,S., Webb, J., Williams, R.J.P. (eds., 1989): Biomineralization. Chemical and biochemical perspectives. 54 1 pp., Weinheim (VCH Verlag) Sirnkiss, K., Wilbur, K.M. (1989): Biomineralization. Cell biology and mineral deposition.- 337 pp., San Diego (Academic Press) Towe, K.M. (1972): Invertebrate shell structure and the organic matrix concept. - Biomineralization Research Report~,4,2-14 Westbroek, P., de Jong, E.W. (eds., 1983): Biomineralization and biological metal accumulation. - 533 pp., Dordrecht (Reidel) Further reading: KO43 Taphonomy Allison, P.A., Briggs, D.E.G. (1991): Taphonomy: releasing the data locked in the fossil record. - 560 pp., New York (Plenum) Behrensmeyer, A.K., Kidwell, S.M., Gastaldo, R.A. (2000): Taphonomy and paleobiology. -In: Erwin, D.H., Wings, S.L. (eds.): Deep time. Paleobiology's perspective. Paleobiology Supplement, 26/4, 103-147 Brett, C.E., Baird, G.C. (1986): Comparative taphonomy: a key to paleoenvironmental interpretation based on fossil preservation. - Palaios, 1,207-227 Donavan, S.K. (ed., 1991): The process of fossilization. 303 pp., New York (Columbia University Press) Fiirsich, F.T., Aberhan, M. (1990): Significance of time-averaging for paleocommunity analysis. - Lethaia, 23, 143152 Kidwell, S.M., Beluensmeyer,A.K. (eds., 1993):Taphonomic approaches to time resolution in fossil assemblages. - Short Courses in Paleontology, 6, 302 pp., Knoxville (Paleontological Society) Kidwell, S.M., Flessa, K.W. (1996): The quality of the fossil record: populations, species and communities. - Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Sciences, 24,433-464 Maiklem, W.R. (1968): Some hydraulic properties of bioclastic carbonate grains. - Sedimentology, 10, 101-109 Martin, R.E. (1999): Taphonomy. A process approach. 524 pp., Cambridge (Cambridge University Press) Murray, R.C. (1964): Preservation of primary structures and fabrics in dolomite. - In: Imbrie, J., Newell, N.D. (eds.): Approaches to paleoecology.- 388-403,New York (Wiley) Perry, C.T. (1998): Grain susceptibility for the effects of microboring: implication for the preservation of skeletal carbonates. - Sedimentology, 45, 39-51 Further reading: KO80 Fossil diagenesis Bathurst, R.C.G. (1964): The replacement of aragonite by calcite in the molluscan shell wall. -In: Imbrie, J., Newell, N. D. (eds.):Approaches to paleoecology. - 357-387, New York (Wiley) Brachert, T.C., Dullo, W.-Chr. (2000): Shallow burial diagenesis of skeletal carbonates: selective loss of aragonite shell material (Miocene to Recent), Queensland Plateau and
References on Skeletal Grains
QueenslandTrough, NEAustralia) - implications for shallow cool-water carbonates. - Sedimentary Geology, 136, 169-187 Chave, K.E. (1964): Skeletal durability and preservation. In: Irnbrie, J., Newell, N.D. (eds.): Approaches to paleoecology. - 377-387, New York (Wiley) Chems, L., Wright, V.P. (2000): Missing mollusks as evidence of large-scale, early skeletal aragonite dissolution in a Silurian sea. - Geology, 28,79 1-794 Dullo, W.-Chr. (1983): Fossildiagenese irn miomen Leithakalk der Paratethys von Osterreich: Ein Beispiel fiir Faunenverschiebungen durch Diageneseunterschiede. Facies, 8, 1-112 Dullo, W.-Chr. (1990): Facies, fossil record, and age of Pleistocene reefs from the Red Sea (Saudi Arabia). - Facies, 22, 1-46 Flessa, K.W., Brown, T.J. (1983): Selective solution of macroinvertebrate calcareous hard parts: a laboratory study. - Lethaia, 16, 193-205 Glover, C.P., Kidwell, S.M. (1993): Influence of organic matrix on post-mortem destruction of molluscan shells. - J. Geol., 101,729-747 Gvirtzman, G., Friedman, G.M. (1977): Sequence of progressive diagenesis in coral reefs. - Studies in Geology, 4,357380 Henrich, R., Wefer, G. (1986): Dissolution of biogenic carbonates: effects of skeletal structure. - Marine Geology, 71, 341-362 Pingitore, N.E. (1976): Vadose and phreatic diagenesis: Progress products and their recognition in corals. - Journal of Sedimentary Petrology, 46,985-1006 Richter, D.K. (1979): Die Stufen der meteorisch-vadosen Umwandlung von Mg-Calcit in Calcit in rezenten bis pliozanen Biogenen Griechenlands. - Neues Jahrbuch fiir Geologie und Palaontologie,Abhandlungen, 158,277-333 Further reading: K042, KO44
4.2.2 Peloids: Just a Term of Ignorance? Many marine and non-marine limestones contain micron- and millimeter-sized, more or less structureless subrounded micritic grains, that are commonly called peloids or pellets (Pl. 1011-3). Although the term peloid is often used as a nongenetic term of ignorance, the genetic differentiation of these grains offers important informations on the depositional setting, paleoenvironrnental conditions and diagenetic features. Terminology Peloid (McKee and Gutschick 1969) is a comprehensive descriptive term for polygenetic grains composed of micro- and cryptocrystalline carbonate. Peloids are commonly devoid of internal structures but may contain fine-grained skeletal debris and other grains. The term was proposed in order to replace the widely used term 'pellet' which, for many authors had become a synonym for 'fecal pellet'
Modern Peloids
The name pellet should be restricted to grains of fecal origin; for all the other micrite grains the term 'peloid' is recommended. Many peloids are subrounded or rounded, but ovoid and rodlike shapes may also occur. The dimensions of the silt- to fine-sand-sized particles vary within a range of a few pm to a few mm, but most calcareous peloids are rarely larger than 500 pm, and commonly exhibit a diameter of < 200 pm, often 30 to 100 pm. Comparison with other grain types Peloids differ from ooids and oncoids by the absence of concentric or radial internal structures, and from small rounded intraclasts by their uniform shape, good sorting and small size (<200 pm). Peloids are generally smaller than ooids, pisoids and oncoids. Occurrence Peloids occur in rock-building abundance forming peloid limestones (Pl. 12111-3) or as only minor constituents of carbonate rocks together with other grain types (Pl. 12211). Peloids constitute grain- or mud-supported fabrics (contributing to wackestone, packstone, graingrainstone and bindstone textures), are found as isolated or amalgamated grains (PI. 50/2), and occur within layered (Pl. 50/2,5) and clotted textures (Pl. 1011).Peloids are common in shallow-marine tidal and subtidal shelf carbonates and in reef and mud mounds, but are also abundant in deep-water carbonates. By contrast to the abundance of peloids in tropical shallow-marine carbonate, peloids are rare or absent in non-tropical coolwater carbonates.
sites with abundant peloids are the Persian Gulf and the sea off Egypt (Stoffers et al. 1980). Peloids are also generated within algalJcyanobacteria1mats; examples are known from sea-marginal hypersaline pools along the shores of the Gulf of Aqaba, the Red Sea, and Canary Island (Friedman et al. 1972; Gerdes and Krumbein 1987). The 'peloidal question': What are the genetic subtypes of ancient peloids? The origin of ancient peloids is often in doubt and the attempt to distinguish them is limited to recognizing of peloids of fecal, detrital or in situ precipitated origin (MacIntyre 1985). There are, however, some clues for better genetic specification of peloids. Several terms have been suggested for characterizing genetic subcategories. Shape, size and sorting as well as the composition of the grain associations are diagnostic criteria for interpreting the origin of peloids. The following peloid subcategories are used in microfacies studies (Fig. 4.11).
Peloids of biotic origin: ( I ) Fecalpellets (Fig. 4.12; P1. 13618): Rounded, usually fine-grained particles caused by organisms that eat mud, digest organic matter from the mud and excrete the non-digested lime-mud. It should be kept in mind that many authors still use the term 'pellet' and not 'fecal pellets' for peloids produced by carbonate mud-ingesting organisms. Producers of fecal pellets in shelf environments are deposit- and detritus-feeders, herbivorous animals and plankton-feeders, including arthropods, mollusks (inModem peloids tertidal gastropods and polyplacophorid chitons), Marine peloids are conspicuous constituents of low- worms, echinoderms, and fishes. Deposit-feedingcrusenergy shallow tidal and subtidal platform carbonates taceans, gastropods, holothurians, and worms are quan(Pl. 311) but are also found in sheltered reef cavities, titatively important. Callianassa, a shallow-marine and slope and basinal settings. The Great Bahama Bank thalassinid decapod crab, deposits as much as 4.5 mm/ is a good example of the importance of peloids for the year of fecal pellet mud. The assignment of fossil fecal makeup of shallow-marine mud-rich carbonates (Imbrie pellets to specific pellet-producing animals is difficult and Purdy 1962; Purdy 1963; Neumann and Land 1975; because fecal pellets of most invertebrates lack speHarris 1979).The 'pellet-mud facies' and 'mud facies' cific morphological criteria. Exceptions are gastropod of the restricted interior platform, originating in very and crustacean fecal pellets, which are characterized shallow waters with increased and fluctuating salini- by specific dimensions and morphological criteria. Deties and covering an area of about 10 000 km2, com- capod fecal pellets are pierced by longitudinal canals prises abundant peloids forming up to 75% of the total whose number, size and outline in transverse sections sand fraction. Most pellets are lithified organic excre- are used for taxonomic classification (Favreina, P1.931 ments (fecal pellets) produced by carbonate ingesting 5, Sect.10.2.4.7). Fecal pellets accumulate not only in organisms, particularly by polychaete worms, gastro- modem tropical and temperate intertidal and subtidal pods and some crustaceans. Open interior parts of the settings, but also in deep-marine environments where platforms are floored by peloid and aggregate grain planktonic shells (e.g. coccolithophorids) are transsands. These peloids result from the micritization of ported to the sea bottom via fecal pellets of zooplankvarious carbonate grains ('bahamite peloids'). Other tonic and nektonic animals (see Fig. 4.4).
Peloids: Diagnostic Criteria
Origin
Types
Diagnostic criteria
Lithified organic excrements
1 Fecal pellets
Rounded elongated, rod-shaped or ovoid dark-colored micritic grains, rarely spherical. Commonly homogeneous or with silt-sized inclusions; rarely with defined internal structures. Sizes
Abrasional products of algae and calcimicrobes
2 Algal peloids
Irregularly shaped, rounded micritic grains, exhibiting gradations from grains with relicts of algal structures to homogeneous grains. Size c20 pm to -2 mm . . . . . . . . . . . PI. 13614
Grains resulting from hardpart-boring and rasping activity of organisms
3 Bioerosional peloids
Scoop-shaped subrounded and angular grains. Sizes from 20 l m to 100 pm
Synsedimentary and postsedimentary reworking of carbonate mud and micrite
4
Mud peloids (Lithic peloids)
Variously shaped micritic grains, commonly without internal structures. Wide size ranges, poor sorting. Frequent occurrence within distinct beds or laminae . . PI. 1012,PI. 12112
Internal micritic molds of bivalved shells
5 Mold peloids
Ovoid micritic grains, sometimes with relicts of still undissolved shells (ostracods, small bivalves). . . . . . . PI. 13218
Ooids and rounded skeletal 6 grains whose microstructures have been lost through micritization
Bahamite peloids
Round micritic grains, some of which with relicts of the primary microstructures. Association of peloids, aggregate grains and ooids. Transition of micritized bioclasts to peloids of the same size. Larger than algal peloids . . . . . PI. 1013,PI. 4311
Ooids and skeletal grains; microstructuresdestroyed by recrystallization
7
Pelletoids
Microcrystallinegrains, in places exhibiting vague residual internal structures. Diffuse outlines due to amalgamation and compaction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . PI. 3816
Biochemical precipitation triggered by microbes and organic substances
B
Microbial peloids
Rounded micritic grains associated with laminated and clotted fabrics. Sizes from <80 pm to >600 pm . . . . . . PI. 816,PI. 1011
Chemical precipitation of carbonate cements with or without organic controls
3
Precipitated peloids
- - - - - -
-
-
- -
-
- - - - -
-
Tiny peloids within carbonate cements; consisting of a cloudy micritic center sourrounded by clear exterior rims of crystals. Occurrence in cavity fill precipitates (e.g. in reefs) . . . . PI. 815
Fig. 4.11. Origin and diagnostic criteria of carbonate peloids. The term 'peloid' is only descriptive until thin-section studies reveal information providing a genetic co-motation. -
Criteria: Fecal pellets are commonly elongate, rodshaped or ovoid grains. Most fecal pellets are homogeneous, but some may contain silt-sized inclusions (quartz or skeletal debris). The dark color of the grains or the peripheral rim in transmitted light is caused by the high content of organic matter or iron sulfides. Fecal pellets occur in isolated nests and are common in burrowed limestones. Parautochthonous occurrences are often characterized by small, moderate to wellsorted pellets. The sorting of fecal pellets provides a first approximation of the hydrodynamic behavior of these grains (Wanless et al. 1981). Environment: Carbonate fecal pellets are produced in tropical marine and in non-marine environments, but are more commonly preserved in subtidal and lower intertidal zones of inner platform or ramp settings, with low water energy and reduced sedimentation rates. The fossilization of the originally soft particles requires bacterial decomposition of the organic mucus and intragranular cementation by Mg-calcite or aragonite. Lithi-
fication takes place preferentially in warm shallow waters that are supersaturated with respect to calcium carbonate, i.e. the interior part of the Bahama platform (Kornicker and Purdy 1957; Land and Moore 1980). Non-marine fecal pellets occur in salt lakes and freshwater lakes, and are known from pedogenic carbonates. Fecal pellets of filter-feeding zooplanktonic crustaceans (copepods), reported from ancient lacustrine limestones, are elongated grains with long diameters of 250 to 500 pm. Pedogenic and caliche peloids vary greatly in shape and sizes (10 pm to more than 1 mm). Ovoid grains are fecal pellets produced by worms, ants or gastropods (Klappa 1978; Jones and Squair 1988). Sometimes vegetal microstructures are preserved within the grains. Other caliche peloids originate from carbonate precipitation around roots and root hairs or in association with the decomposition of vegetal and fungal matter (types 8 and 9 in Fig. 4-11) or by micritization of skeletal grains (type 6 in Fig. 4.11; Calvet and Julia 1983).
Peloid Types
Fecal pellets
113
Mold peloids
Pelletoids
Fig. 4.12. Three of nine peloid types (see PI. 10 for other types!). Early Cretaceous lagoonal limestone with fecal pellets, characterized by rounded, elongated micrite grains of different size. Middle Devonian shelf limestones with mold peloids, representing steinkerns of ostracods whose valves have been dissolved. Strongly recrystallized Carboniferous limestone exhibiting round micritic pelletoids and spar-filled intergranular pores. Scale is 500 pm.
(2)Algal peloids (Pl. 13614) originate from the disinte- Peloids resulting from reworking of mud and grains: gration of calcified algae and calcified microbes. The term was introduced by Wolf (1965b).. The peloids are (4) Mud peloids (Pl. 1012, P1. 1711, P1. 12112): This the final product of the gradational abrasion of algal category includes variously shaped micritic grains elements. Limestones with algal peloids are character- caused by the reworking of lithified carbonate mud and ized by the association of structureless peloids, irregu- micrite clasts. These grains were called 'mud grains' larly shaped micritic grains with inherited algal struc- (Fabricius 1966), 'small intraclasts' (Wilson 1967), tures, and skeletal grains exhibiting preserved algal 'small mud aggregates' (Purdy 1963), 'pseudopellets' structures. Algal peloids can be derived from the me- (Fahraeus et al. 1974: reworked and current-transported chanical destruction of upward-growing ramose, and lithified carbonate mud) or 'lithic peloids'. The latter nodular and laminar growth forms of green and red al- term is widely used. In fact, many mud grain peloids gae as well as calcimicrobes. Another process leading are genetically intraclasts formed by erosion and redeto the formation of algal peloids is the destruction of position within the same basin. The nomenclatorial disexterior carbonate precipitates of filamentous algae tinction between small intra- and lithoclasts and pe(Schroeder 1972). The peloids are commonly round to loids is based on an arbitrary size limit (150 pm: Wilson 1967; 150 pm: Folk 1962; 500 pm: Coniglio and angular detrital particles. Environment: Algal pellets resulting from the com- James 1987). A size limit of 200 pm is recommended. Criteria: Mud peloids are characterized by the simiminution of algae and cyanobacteria ( e g Girvanella tubules) are particularly common in Early Paleozoic lar composition of the micrite forming the peloids and shelf carbonates (Wolf and Conolly 1965; Coniglio and the micritic matrix; irregular contact between areas with and without peloids (interpreted as bottom reworking); James 1985). the preferential occurrence of peloids in lenses, lami(3)Bioerosionalpeloids: Rock- and biogenic hardpart- nae or layers; the hydraulic equivalence of peloids and boring demosponges (mainly members of the family quartz grains found together; and evidence absence of Clionidae), occurring in tropical and temperate oceans, burrowing (i.e., no fecal pellets). In addition, poor sortpenetrate the substrate by means of cellular etching ing, a broad spectrum of peloid shapes and sizes as well (Hatch 1980). They release scoop-shaped chips which as repeated occurrence within a stratigraphic profile contribute significantly to the fine-grained mud and pe- provide evidence for interpreting the grains as lithic loid fraction in modem coral reefs and to carbonate peloids. coastal sediments (Fiitterer 1974; Torunski 1979;Acker The last-mentioned criterion indicates fluctuations and Risk 1985; Edinger and Risk 1996). Endolithic in water energy and erosion. This assists in recognizsponges already appeared as early as the Cambrian and ing cyclic shallowing patterns in shelf carbonates (Carss became more common during the Mesozoic (Perry and and Carozzi 1965) and allochthonous sedimentation on Bertling 2000). Rasping by gastropods and sea urchins deeper shelves and within basins (Wilson 1969). Mud results in the erosion of small limestone clasts corre- peloids form mm- to cm-thick grainstone or packstone layers within micritic limestone. sponding in size and subangular shape to peloids.
114
Peloids and Cortoids
Plate 10 Peloids and Cortoids Peloids are rounded micro- and cryptocrystallinecarbonate grains appearing dark in transmitted and white in direct light. Most peloids except some of fecal origin show no differentiated internal structures. The term 'pellet' should be reserved for peloids of fecal origin. Peloids are generally smaller than other carbonate grains. The term peloid includes genetically different grains (see Fig. 4.1 1)originating from biotic activities (fecal pellets, Fig. 4.12; algal peloids; bioerosional peloids), reworking of mud and grains (mud peloids or lithic peloids, -> 2; mold peloids, Fig. 4.12), early and late diagenetic alterations of grains (bahamite peloids, -> 3; pelletoids, Fig. 4.12), as well grains formed in situ by biochemical and/or chemical processes (microbial peloids, -> 1; precipitated peloids). Peloids are abundant in tropical and subtropical shallow-marine environments (platforms,ramps, reefs), but can be also faund on slopes and in basins, and contribute to the formation of non-marine carbonates in pedogenic, freshwater and lacustrine settings as well. Cortoids are carbonate grains (frequently bioclasts) exhibiting thin micrite envelopes. The micritic coatings are commonly thinner then those of oncoids which may develop from the overgrowth of cortoids. In the case of mineralogical differences between the coated bioclast and the micrite rim, cortoids can preserve shape and gross structure even of diageneticallyhighly altered grains (-> 4; P1. 13013).Destructive and constructive micritization are probably the most common modes of cortoid formation. Destructive micrite envelopes are formed by the interplay of repeated microboring and infilling of the tiny little voids by microcrystalline Mg-calcite or aragonite cements. Constructive micrite envelopes are formed by an intergrowth of externally calcified filamentous algae on the surface of carbonate grains. Both modes are connected with the activity of microbes, algae and fungi. The most intensive carbonate grain micritization takes place in warm shallow tropical seas, and is carried out almost exclusively by cyanobacteria. Micritization of carbonate grains caused by microbes, however, also occurs in the deep oceans. In non-tropical settings the formation of cortoids predominantly results from chemical dissolution and recrystallization of carbonate grains in cold, carbonate-undersaturated waters. Cortoids are common in shallowmarine shelf and platform carbonates, but also originate in non-marine environments. Considering the strong impact of light on the vertical distribution of microborers, many authors have used marine cortoids as paleobathymetrical indicators. More cortoids are shown in P1. 3318, PI. 3512, P1. 11813, P1. 12711, and P1. 13013. Microbialpeloids. The clotted structure of the peloids and the occurrence as constituents of bindstones point to a microbially induced origin of the grains formed in situ within mats ('benthic peloids': Gerdes et al. 1994; Kazmierczak et al. 1996). Bedded lagoonal limestone. Late Permian (Zechstein): Harz, Germany. Mud peloids. Small, subrounded and subangular micritic grains. Poor sorting and distinct differences in size and shape indicate that these grains originated from the reworking of weakly lithified carbonate mud. Genetically, these peloids are small intraclasts, but are conventionally assigned to the peloid group with an arbitary size limit of about 200 pm. SMF 16NON-LAMINATED. Early Carboniferous (VisCan): Notsch, southern Austria. Bahamite peloids. Peloids originating from the micritization of ooids ('pseudopeloids': Lakschewitz et al. 1991). The microstructure of small ooids is completely or highly altered by crystal diminution. Some ooid grains (arrows) still have preserved relicts of the original structure, but most grains exhibit the characteristic criteria of peloids (structureless round micrite grains). Pseudopeloids are the dominant grains within the grainstone texture (GT) as well within the packstone texture (PT) of synsedimentary clasts. The ooids and peloids were formed on submarine pelagic swells (as indicated by pelagic faunal elements such as protoglobigerinids as nuclei of the ooids) and redeposited subsequent to transport in deeper parts of the slopes. The pseudopeloid grainflows are overlain by micritic limestones with pelagic skeletal grains. The succession reflects sedimentation on a subsiding swell accompanied by syntectonically caused downslope sediment movements. Late Jurassic (Red Nodular Limestone): Chiemgau Alps, Bavaria, Germany. Cortoids. The micrite envelope of the outer part of the shell is caused by the attacks of microborers associated with micrite precipitation. The boundary between the micrite envelope and the shell exhibits the characteristic irregular outline. Note the distinct microborings on the surface (black arrows). The infestations have already destroyed the interior part of the shell fragment (white arrow). Early Carboniferous: Cracow area, Poland. Cortoids, rounded fossils and redeposited oncoids. Micrite envelopes (ME) caused by microbial microboring and infilling of the holes by micrite is evident in echinoderm fragments (E). Echinoderm fragments show a characteristic cleavage structure. The micrite envelopes of this sample are stained by hematite impregnations. This points to contributions of Febacteria (see Marnet and Boulvain 1990). Note the imbricate structure represented by the parallel and inclined arrangement of the bioclasts, and indicating current transport. Dasyclad algal fragments (DA), fusulinid tests (F) and oncoids (0)are conspicuously rounded. In total, these criteria reflect the following steps: (1) Reworking and rounding of the grains formed within a subtidal environment, (2) formation of microborings and bacterially-induced staining during a quietwater phase, followed by (3) final deposition within a current-influenced ramp environment. Early Permian: Carnia, Southern Alps.
Plate 10: Peloids and Cortoids
Peloids: In-situ Formation
116
Reworked and redeposited mud peloids are common micritized and recrystallized ooids or bioclasts. Reid in protected shallow-marineenvironments. Larger lime et al. (1991,1992) and Reid and MacIntyre (1998) emmud intraclasts and smaller mud peloids can originate phasize the widespread occurrence of micritizationlreif lime mud dries out and small chips become comrni- crystallization processes affecting foraminiferal and nuted and rounded, or if storms and currents disturb algal grains, and leading to the formation of micro- and cryptocrystalline grains. Peloids originating from the the bottom sediments. micritization of ooids have been called pseudopeloids A never ending story - A comment on the term (Lakschewitz et al. 1991; P1. 1013) aiming to distin'pseudo-ooid': The original definition of this term guish these peloids from peloids that represent micrit(Bornemann 1886) referred to transported and worn ized bioclasts. fragments of fine-grained limestone clasts observed in thin sections of the Triassic Muschelkallc. Later uses of (7)Pelletoids (Fig. 4.12; P1.3816): The term was introthe term connoted well-rounded, structureless carbon- duced by Blatt et al. (1972) for microcrystalline grains ate grains of very different origin (Fliigel and Kirch- that have been generated by the recrystallizationof varimayer 1962). But this connotation coincides with the ous carbonate particles, such as skeletal grains (e.g. foradefinition of pseudopellets as well as with that of small minifera) and ooids. Pelletoids are often amalgamated well-rounded intra- and lithoclasts. Some authors still and have diffuse outlines due to compaction and aguse pseudo-ooid to describe ooids with poorly preserved grading crystal growth. Some pelletoids may show structures or as a name for strongly micritized grains. vague residual internal structures of the original grain. However, the term pseudo-ooid should no longer be Distinguishingbetween pelletoids and bahamite peloids can be difficult. used now. -> Note that some authors use the term 'pelletoid' for (5) Peloids resulting from the internal molds of fos- textures exhibiting pellet-like grains which are believed sils (Fig. 4.12; P1.13218): Internal molds of thin-shelled to have been formed by incipient or incomplete recrysostracods, mollusks and foraminifera can be preserved tallization of micrite. Other authors use the adjective 'pelletoid' to describe limestones with (non-altered) peas small peloids when the shells are dissolved. loids. Peloids resulting from syn- or postdepositional alterations of grains: (6)Bahamite peloids: Micritized grains (Pl. 1013, P1. 4311, P1. 12114): This category comprises isolated and composite peloids whose formation is in some way comparable to that of morphologically similar grains in the modem Bahama Banks. Intensive micritization of bioclasts and of ooids, leading to the complete loss of the microstructure of the grains, can produce round micrite grains. These grains occur in association with aggregate grains, ooids and micritic intraclasts. The peloids are generally larger than algal peloids. Originally the name bahamite was proposed for ancient shallow-marine limestones with grains that closely resemble grain assemblages found in the interior of the Bahama Banks (Beales 1958), but also known from other modem shallow-marine environments (Kendall and Skipwith 1969; Logan 1974;Pusey 1975).The term refers to carbonates composed of accretionary and composite grains including aggregate grains and peloids. Gygi (1969), studying Jurassic platform carbonates, introduced the name bahamite grain for structureless microcrystalline peloids and aggregates of these peloids. Genetically these peloids are altered fecal pellets and
In-situ formation:
(8) Microbial peloids (Pl. 816, P1. 1011): There are increasingly more reports about the in-situ formation of carbonate particles in modem microbial mats, on ancient micrite crusts, and within the peloidal textures of mud mounds (Box 4.7; Friedman 1978; Javor and Castenholz 1981; Pickard 1992; see Facies, volume 29, 1993). These particles correspond morphologically to peloids, ooids, oncoids and aggregate grains. In-situ growth of modem oncoids has been reported from lakes, lake margins and sabkhas (Jones and Wilkinson 1978), and rivers or streams (Freytet and Plaziat 1965; Hartkopf-Frijder et al. 1989). Ancient in situ growth has been claimed for Tertiary lacustrine oncoids (Leinfelder and Hartkopf-Froder 1990). Algal and cyanobacterial pellets formed in situ (benthic peloids) occur in microbial mats of salinas, saline lakes and intertidal settings (Gerdes et al. 1994; Kazmierczak et al. 1996). The rounded micritic grains as well as autochthonous micrite (Sect. 4.1.2) are the result of biochemical precipitation triggered by microbial activity leading to the decomposition of organic
Fabrics of Peloidal Limestones
Diagenesis of peloids Modem marine peloids consist of High-Mg calcite and/or aragonite, freshwater peloids are composed of Low-Mg calcite (Brand and Veizer 1983; Rao et al. 1994). Peloid limestones appear to have suffered remarkably little compaction (Beales 1965). The preservation of carbonate peloids of fecal origin is only possible if lithification takes place rapidly. The precipitation of Mg-calcite peloid cement plays an important role in the submarine cementation of upper slope sediments. Gradations from amorphous microcrystalline calcite to clotted peloidal micrite and peloidal micrite, followed by the in-situ precipitation of polypeloidal aggregates have been observed on Bahamian slopes (Wilber and Neumann 1993).Selective (9)Precipitatedpeloids (Pl. 815): Inorganic and organi- dolomitization of peloids is common in fecal pellets as cally induced chemical in-situ precipitation has been well as algal peloids and mud grain peloids. proved for the origin of very small (20-60 pm, usually 40 ym) peloids within calcite cements and occurring within inter- and intraskeletal cavities of reefs as well Significance of peloids Ancient peloid limestones account for thousands of as in non-reef cavities (Macintyre 1985; Chafetz 1991; Reitner and Neuweiler 1995).These peloids are a com- cubic kilometers of lagoonal, shelf, bank, reef-core and mon characteristic of submarine Mg-calcite cements mud mound deposits, but they are relatively rarer than (Macintyre et al. 1968; Shinn 1969; Land and Goreau other limestone types. Paleoenvironmental proxies: Many shallow-marine 1970; Alexandersson 1972). The peloids consist of well-developed dentate rims peloidal grainstones have a scarcity of biotic constituof microcrystalline rhombic calcite forming small ro- ents or contain only specific biota (ostracods, benthic settes (5-10 pm in length) around a nondescript cloudy foraminifera, green algae) indicating conditions were inadequate for many animals with regard to salinity and anhedral nucleus. substrate. By contrast, peloidal packstones and wackeThis bimodal texture has been explained as the re- stones with abundant fecal pellets and burrows indisult of cate adequate nutrients and oxygen. (a) initial rapid precipitation of anhedral magnesDepositional proxies: Many ancient peloid limeium calcite, followed by a second stage of slower pre- stones appear to have formed in shallow warm-water cipitation of larger euhedral Mg-calcite, forming the environments (banks, shelf- and reef lagoons). Finedentate rims (Macintyre 1977, 1978; Lighty 1985); grained peloidal limestones are generally regarded as (b) intermediate stages of the development of ad- typical of shallow, low-energy, restricted marine envivancing crystal growth from microcrystalline Mg-cal- ronments. This generalization is supported by many cite crystals (Alexandersson 1972); case studies,but the examples should be critically evalu(c) crystal growth around a nucleus of suspended ated for the following reasons: silt-sized clastic particles that were flushed into cavi- 1 Accumulation of peloids may record specific presties by wave pumping (James et al. 1976); and ervation sites rather than specific depositional envi(d) growth of cement crystals induced by bacteria ronments. (Buczynski and Chafetz 1991; Sect. 4.1.2). Peloidal car- 2 Mass occurrences of fecal pellets can be allochthobonate cements occur as peloidal fill (e.g. in small reef nous or autochthonous, and the size and sorting of cavities), in the form of rim cement and coatings on these peloids, therefore, may not be a measure of grains, and as thin dense crusts on the surface of coral current energy. skeletons and reef rubble. 3 Peloids may be deposited near the place of their origin but can also be transported to shallower or deeper Common peloid microfabrics environments. Understanding of the hydrodynamic Carbonate peloids contribute to the formation of four behavior of carbonate fecal pellets is important for widely distributed microfabrics (Box 4.7) important in interpretating of the origin of peloidal carbonates the context of facies interpretations. (Wanless et al. 1981).
tissue (e.g. sponges) and organic substance. Smallscaled peloids occurring in microcavities off Lizard Island, Great Barrier Reef, grow in organic mucilages enriched by Ca-binding proteins (Reitner and Neuweiler 1995). Tuberoids are considered a special kind of peloid. The term was suggested for rounded and nodular, darkcolored and variously sized micritic particles (Fritz 1958) occurring in abundance in bedded limestones adjacent to sponge reefs. These grains are common in Jurassic and Cretaceous limestones with remains of siliceous sponges and micritic crusts (Pl. 11611;Kott 1989). The grains are interpreted as precipitates of carbonate induced by decaying organic matter.
Cortoids
4 Peloid pack- and grainstones are not restricted to hibits a circumgranular non-laminated micritic rim comshallow-marineenvironments but are also important monly called a 'micrite envelope'. Because of the sigconstituents of slope and basin sequences formed nificance of these grains as facies indicators, a separate grain type category called 'cortoid', was proposed by turbidites and debris flows. (from 'cortex', Latin for bark; Fliigel 1982).
4.2.3 Cortoids - Carbonate Grains Characterized by Micrite Envelope
Micritization and micrite envelope Micritization is a process whereby the margins of A specific category of carbonate grains are bioclasts, carbonate grains or the total volume of grains are reooids or lithoclasts and peloids, whose periphery ex- placed by crypto- or microcrystalline carbonate crys-
Box 4.7. Commonfabrics in peloidal limestones usually interpreted as products of microbially or biologically induced carbonate production. Micritic clotted fabric (Pl. 1011) Texture: Densely spaced, variably sized globular and irregular peloids forming amalgamated clots; commonly within a microspar, micrite or spar matrix. Origin: (a) Recrystallization of carbonate mud and peloidal micrite (Cayeux 1935; Bathurst 1970; Leeder 1982), (b) diagenetic alteration of soft-pellet grainstones to wackestones (Bathurst 1970) (c) diagenetic amalgamation of precipitated peloids (Reid 19871,(c) diagenetic alteration of soft-bodied organisms (Bourque 1984), (d) diagenetically modified algal debris (Coniglio and James 1985), (e) products of in situ calcified mats of benthic coccoid cyanobacteria (Kazmierczak et al. 1996), and (f) grazing and decay of algal mats (Pratt 1982). Occurrence: Common in tidal laminated carbonates, in mud mounds, and reefs (Sun and Wright 1983; Neuweiler 1993) as exemplified by Triassic reefs, where about 75% of the reef core framework can consist of precipitated peloids occurring in cavities, intraskeletal voids and organic crusts (Reid 1987). Sparry peloidal fabric (Pl. 8/5) Texture: Abundant, very small peloids formed in situ and consisting of a microcrystalline core surrounded by a dentate crystal rim (Type 9: Fig. 4/11). The peloids are part of submarine carbonate cements. Origin: Chemical or biochemical precipitation (type 9, Fig. 4/11). Occurrence: Common in intra- and interskeletal voids of reef rocks similar to clotted fabrics, associated with internal sediments and carbonate cements and within crusts associated with corals and sponges. Thrombolititic peloidal fabrics (Pl. 5015) Texture: Non-laminated structure. Abundant peloids of irregular shape and size, some retaining filamentous structures. Common calcite 'spherulites' (peloids) consisting of radially-oriented, non-ferroan calcite, typically 12-20 pm in diameter with a cloudy micrite core, 1-10 p n in diameter. Origin: (a) In-situ precipitation. The formation of in-situ spherulites within the sediment is controlled by supersaturation of CaC03 in solution and a site for nucleation. Supersaturation of CaC03 is caused by (a) the release of CO, and NH, on the decay of organic matter and (b) bacterial sulphate reduction. Bacteria can form spherulites in aerobic, anaerobic, agitated and non-agitated laboratory conditions, but experimental precipitation of spherulites without the presence of bacteria points to the possibility that spherulitic textures also can form as a by-product of decayed organic matter. Spherulites in stromatolites have been interpreted as calcified cyanobacteria. (b) Allochthonous grains. Deposition of small allochthonous fecal pellets and algal peloids within cavities (James et al. 1976) or formation of pellets by cryptic filter feeders (e.g. clionids: Land and Moore 1980). These interpretations are supported by the fact that peloids can settle at the base of cavities. Occurrence: Thrombolitic fabrics occur in lacustrine limestones (Pl. 13115) and beachrocks, and are common in laminated tidal and subtidal carbonates (stromatolites) as well as in subtidal shelf carbonates, mud mounds and non-skeletal microbialite reef frameworks (particularly in the Carboniferous and Permian, Jurassic and Cretaceous). Biocementstones (Tsien 1981) - Sect. 8.2 Texture:Fine-grained micritic limestones consisting of peloids, delicate small andlor poorly calcified organisms contained within abundant, localized carbonate cement. Origin: Fabric, formed by free-living microorganisms (cyanobacteria, algae, sulfur-reducing and sulfate-reducing bacteria) and small encrusting benthic invertebrates, which trap and build carbonate mud from bottom waters, resulting in the formation of small micritic 'protopeloids' (Tsien 1985). Amalgamation of the peloids leads to the formation of peloidal automicrite. A large part of the limestones is formed by biologically induced carbonate cements. Occurrence: Reef frameworks, specifically in the Permian and Triassic (Webb 1996).
Origin of Cortoids
tals. Incomplete micritization leads to the formation of cortoids, whereas complete micritization can bring about a gradual to total alteration of the original grain (Pl. 13417) and the formation of bahamite peloids (Fig. 4.11). The term micritization was worked out in the context of studies of modern lagoonal carbonates (Bathurst 1966). Later, the term was expanded to include all processes resulting in obliteration of original carbonate microstructures through gradual alteration to cryptocrystalline textures. Micritization processes are controlled by biological and chemical factors and take place in shallow- and deep-marine as well as in terrestrial and lacustrine environments. Micritization of aragonitic skeletal grains has been described from the Bahamas and the Persian Gulf, micritization of Mg-calcite skeletal grains from Florida and Belize (Reid et al. 1992). Micritization processes are fundamental in loosening the surface, abrading and rounding carbonate grains, completely destroying the original structures of skeletal and other grains. Persistent micritization results in the formation of carbonate muds (Sect. 4.1.1). The term micrite envelope was first used by Bathurst (1964) in the study of syngenetic and early diagenetic changes affecting modem skeletal grains. The term refers to a thin, non-laminated coating of very fine micrite around carbonate grains, particularly skeletal grains or ooids. Modem envelopes consist of aragonite or High-Mg calcite. In limestones, the calcitic envelopes of cortoids appear white in reflected light and dark in transmitted light. The thickness of the envelopes varies between a few pm and about 500 pm. Origin of cortoids Micrite envelopes originate from destructive and constructive processes that take place at or near the sediment-water surface. Both photosynthetic and non-photosynthetic organisms play a major role in the formation of cortoids. Common modes are: (1) Destructive micritization related to microboring organisms: The classical model is a three-step process (Bathurst 1966; Fig. 4.13: A1 and A2). (a) Microbolic products of microendoliths lead to biochemical dissolution of skeletons (Ehrlich 1999) leaving microborings (Golubic et al. 2000). Endolithic microborers attacking the surface of bioclasts and ooids, particularly in shallow-marine environments, produce tiny little voids (size < 1 pm to about 50 wm) which are colonized by filamentous cyanobacteria, green and red algae as well as fungi (Sect. 9.1). Boring organisms can colonize a grain within
Fig. 4.13. Origin of cortoids. A - Three-step destructive micritization related to microborings (adapted from Bathurst 1966).Al: Endolithic cyanobacteria, algae or fungi produce (1) tube-like microborings (black) on the surface of bioclasts. (2) Vacant tubes (white) originating after the death of the endoliths are (3) infilled with microcrystalline carbonate cement (stippled in A2). Multiple boring and filling result in the formation of micrite envelopes. B - Destructive micritization by concurrent cyanobacterial microboring and filling of boreholes (modified after Reid and Macintyre 2000). Microboring (black) just beneath the grain surface produces tunnels which are filled by radial-fibrous cement as the organism advances. C -Constructive micritization caused by precipitation of microcrystalline calcite around exposed filaments of endo- and epilithic algae and cyanobacteria (adapted from Kobluk and Risk 1977a). C1: Initial microborings; C2: Colonization of the grain surface by endo-epilithic filamentous algae; C3 and C4: Precipitation of calcite cement on the surface of filaments; C5: Resulting micrite envelope. Most micritic rims are thinner than 500 pm.
120
a matter of days and infest a grain in a few weeks; (b) Death of the microborers and vacation of tubes; (c) Emplacement of micritic aragonite or High-Mg calcite cements within vacant tubes. The formation of cements can be triggered by organic acids produced during the bacterial decomposition of organic compounds. Multiple repetition of boring and filling destroys the peripheral zone of the grains and finally results in the formation of a circumgranular micritic rim recognized in thin section. The surface of the rim exhibits shallow pits; the boundary between the envelope and the skeletal core is irregular and may preserve microtube structures penetrating into the skeletal grain (Pl. 1014). Destructive cortoids are abundant in shallow-marine environments (Lloyd 1971; Margolis and Rex 1971; Harris et al. 1979), but also occur in transitional and non-marine (e.g. caliche: James 1972; lacustrine environments: Schneider et al. 1983; P1.13013) and vadose settings (Pl. 3314; P1. 3512). A special mode of destructive micritization has been proposed by Reid and Macintyre (2000). This model focuses on concurrent microboring and filling of bore holes (Fig. 4.13B). In contrast to the Bathurst model, micritization occurs in microborings of cyanobacteria penetrating just beneath the grain surface and producing tunnels. The tunnels are filled by radial-fibrous aragonite cements that are precipitated as the organism advances. Extensive multiple repetition of the process results in the micritization of just the peripheries of the grains or the whole grain. As opposed to micritized by processes corresponding to the Bathurst model, the grain margins here are almost completely preserved.
Significance of Cortoids
laginous coating of the grains (Kendall and Skipwith 1969). Modified versions of these interpretations are gaining more and more acceptance. Constructive micrite envelopes are formed both in marine and in continental and lacustrine environments (e.g. karst: Jones and Kahle 1995; eolianites: Calvet 1982; lake carbonates: Schneider et al. 1983). Terrestrial vadose cortoids are caused by calcified filaments of fungi and actinomycetes that collapse and coalesce forming an intertwined organic meshwork that in turn triggers the precipitation of microcrystalline cements. Recognizing different modes of origin: Destructive and constructive micrite envelopes are difficult to distinguish in thin sections. Constructive cortoids may show irregularities on the outer surface of the grains and the micritic rim may be of variable thickness, whereas destructive cortoids exhibit irregularities towards the grain interior and often reveal relicts of microborings. Because primary mineralogy controls the susceptibility to the effects of microborings in carbonate grains (Perry 1998), aragonitic bioclasts often are more frequently bored than primary calcitic bioclasts. Micritization is selective, affecting some shells more than others. Shells with homogeneous prismatic microstructures exhibit micritic envelopes more often than shells with fibrous or foliated microstructures. (3) Partial dissolution and recrystallization: Partial dissolution of skeletal grains associated with recrystallization and crystal diminution are other processes known to lead to the formation of micrite envelopes. Mollusk shells composed both of aragonite and Mg-calcite are affected differently by submarine early diagenetic selective dissolution. This may result in a peripheral rim consisting of residual micrite (Winland 1968; Alexandersson 1972; P1. 5216). The micritic preservation of echinoderms in the chalk of Texas is an outcome of partial dissolution called 'inorganic micritization' (Neugebauer and Ruhrmann 1978). High-Mg calcite echinoderm fragments may lose Mg and convert to Low-Mg calcite without a dissolution stage. Inorganic micritization and 'shell-residue micrite' envelopes are widespread at the bottom of modem seas in temperate regions. Micritization also can be the result of decomposition of indigenous organic matter within shells, producing the simultaneous growth of microcrystallinecarbonate (Purdy 1968; Burgess 1979).
(2) Constructive micrite envelopes related to epilithic organisms (Kobluk and Risk 1977a, 1977b):These cortoids result from the precipitation of microcrystalline calcite around and between dense populations of exposed filaments of endo- and epilithic algae and cyanobacteria (Fig. 4.13C). The precipitation occurs predominantly upon dead filaments. The outer boundary of the micrite rim appears irregular. Contrary to mode 1, the micrite envelope is formed without destruction or alteration of the grain periphery. The process involves addition of carbonate to the exterior of the grain and requires grain stabilization for the duration of the envelope formation. This occurs in low-energy environments or shallow burial. Another possibility for the formation of constructive micrite envelopes is the growth of nannocrystals Significance of cortoids within biofilms coating carbonate grains (Loreau 1970) Preservation potential: The susceptibility of skelor the dissolution and reprecipitation within a muci- etal grains to micritization differs with regard to the
Oncoids and Rhodoids
fossil groups affected. This is demonstrated, for example, by fossils in Silurian shelf carbonates showing decreasing susceptibility to micritization from trilobites to ostracods, brachiopods, bryozoans, corals, and tentaculites (Mohamad and Tucker 1992). Micrite envelopes are relatively resistant to dissolution, protect the grains from being destroyed, and often contribute to the preservation of casts of primary aragonitic skeletal grains during freshwater diagenesis (Pl. 3314). The stability of a micrite envelope depends on its stable mineralogical composition and on a high content of organic matter within the micritic rim. The envelopes are prone to selective dolomitization; this may imply that the mineralogy of the envelopes was once High-Mg calcite (Buchbinder and Friedman 1970).
121
4.2.4 Oncoids and Rhodoids Nodular coated grains formed by microbes, algae and other encrusting organisms are common constituents of platform, reef and slope carbonates. These grains represent two major categories: 1) oncoids (formed predominantly by calcibionts and algae) and 2) rhodoids (formed by free-living calcareous red algae). Oncoids and rhodoids are excellent indicators of paleoenvironmental and climatic conditions, and sea-level fluctuations and depositional settings. As opposed to other carbonate grain types, the prevailing settings of oncoid formation changed over the Phanerozoic and rhodoids started to dominate from Late Mesozoic to Cenozoic.
Oncoids (onchos, Greek for nodule) are unattached, rounded, mm- to cm-sized, calcareous or non-calcareous nodules that commonly exhibit a micritic cortex consisting of more or less concentric and partially overlapping laminae around a bio- or lithoclastic nucleus. The term oncoid is not a genetic term and should be regarded as purely descriptive. The name is commonly used in Europe, but not in America where the term 'pisoid' (or pisolith) was and is still used both for coated grains, called oncoids here, but also for grains similar in internal structure but larger than ooids (Sect. 4.2.6). Other not very precise names applied to oncoids are 'algal balls' and 'algally-coated grains', 'mummies' or 'osagid grains'. Oncoids and rhodoids are common in limestones and marly sediments. The latter allow individual grains to be investigated with regard to their composition, size and shape. and grain assemblages. The combined study of thin sections and acid residues augments information on the organisms involved in the formation of oncoids. SEM observations and geochemical studies are necessary to evaluate the contribution of clay material and organic matter to carbonate and non-carbonate oncoids (e.g. Carbone and Civitelli 1974; Andrews 1986; Scudeler Bacelle and Marusso 1983; Palmer and Wilson 1990). Comparison with other grain types: Oncoids differ from cortoids by the greater thickness of the micritic Depositional setting: Bedded grainstones with a high coatings and the frequency of preserved cyanobactepercentage of cortoids and other coated grains, together rial, algal or foraminifera1structures. Ooids and pisoids with rounded bioclasts characteristically form in areas are commonly smaller und have regular concentric of constant water action, at or above wave base. These laminae. As a rule but with a few exceptions, many conditions occur in the 'winnowed platform edge sands' oncoids and rhodoids are considerably greater than all of carbonate platforms (standard microfacies type 11, other carbonate grains. see Sect. 14.3.1) as well as in current-washed sand shoals of inner ramp settings (Pl. 1811, PI. 3318). Grainy Terminology cortoid sediments are often associated with patch reefs Various names have been proposed for organically scattered across the shelves or occurring in a leeward coated rounded grains consisting of a core and a cortex position behind reef belts (Pl. 11813, P1. 12711). formed by encrusting by organisms.
Paleoenvironmental proxies: In accordance with the original explanation that micrite envelopes originate from light-dependent boring organisms (Bathurst 1966), coated grains are often regarded as indicators of 'shallow-marine warm-water' environments (e.g. Leonard et al. 1981). Having observed differences in the abundance of microboring frequency and intensity at different water depths (Vogel et al. 1995), some authors use cortoids and micritized grains as indicators of specific water depths, thus considering the abundance of bored grains to be reliable indicators of shallow waters down to a few tens of meters (Swinchatt 1969; BernardDumanois and Delance 1983). Although there are many modem and ancient examples supporting this interpretation, caution is necessary because a few records of micrite envelopes being formed via non-light dependent microborings and infillings of calcite cements are also known from deepsea settings (Friedman et al. 1971; Hook et al. 1984). In addition, strong boring and leaching is also a common feature of colder carbonate-undersaturated marine waters (Zeff and Perkins 1979; Campbell 1983). But because carbonate precipitation within the boreholes is rare or absent, typical cortoids are rarely preserved in these settings.
122
Oncoids and Macroids
Spongiostromate vs, porostromate oncoids: The name 'oncoid' was suggested by Heim (1916) for micritic grains found in Jurassic shelf limestones in Switzerland. The author discussed a bacterial origin. Apparently unaware of Heim's definition, Pia (1927) considered oncoids to be unattached stromatolites. Classifying blue-green algae (cyanobacteria) of unknown affinities he distinguished two informal groups, Spongiostromata and Porostromata. Spongiostromata are nodules or heads with defined growth forms but without (or very rarely with) visible organic microstructures. Concentric laminae originate from fine grains of sediment adhering to the mucilagineous surface of cyanobacteria and algae and also from the precipitation of calcium carbonate in response to the withdrawal of carbon dioxide during photosynthesis. Porostromata comprise forms exhibiting preserved tubular microstructures. To subdivide the Spongiostromata, Pia used the terms 'Stromatolithi' and 'Oncolithi'. The former include forms which grow attached to the substrate; the latter term refers to unattached free nodules. Today, the descriptive term spongiostromate oncoid (PI. 1113) is used for micrite oncoids possessing a laminated dense micritic or spongy fabric without visible filaments; porostromate oncoid (Pl. 1213) applies to grains exhibiting fine micritic-walled tubes, generally less than 100 pm in size (Monty 1981). Since these tubes are prone to obliteration by recrystallization, the apparent lack of tubular structures is not an unequivocal sign of spongiostromate oncoids. The co-existence of oncoids with well-preserved porostromate microstructures and laminated oncoids of the same size and shape, but without tubular microstructures may point to diagenetically altered porostromate oncoids ('paraporostromate oncoids': Catalov 1983).
Skeletal and non-skeletal - a basic subdivision: Because the Porostromata include fossils of different systematic position, Riding (1977) introduced the term skeletal stromatolites for "stromatolites in which the organisms responsible for their formation are commonly preserved as calcified fossils". The term non-skeletal is identical with 'spongiostromate oncoid'. Skeletal stromatolites and porostromate oncoids are typically constructed by calcified cyanobacteria, but green algae and microproblematica also take part in the formation of non-attached or attached structures. Recent counterparts of Girvanella, a common microfossil in porostromate oncoids, consist of Low-Mg calcite. The same mineralogy is inferred for ancient Girvanella oncoids, but ferroan calcite in some Girvanella skeletons indicates a High-Mg calcite mineralogy, too (Richter and Fiichtbauer 1978).
Oncoids and stromatolites:A particular type of modem and ancient oncoids is associated with intertidal and shallow subtidal algal mats and stromatolites. These oncoids are microbialites and sometimes formed in situ within algal mats (Dahanayake et al. 1985).Ageometrical classification of modem shallow-marine stromatolites and oncoids (including 'algal biscuits': Gebelein 1969) was proposed by Logan et al. (1964) and promptly adapted to ancient oncoids (e.g. Radwanski and Szulczewski 1966). However, the premise that recent marginal-marine oncoids are useful paleoenvironmental analogues of ancient lithified calcareous oncoids was questioned by Monty (1972)' who stated that modem freshwater algal nodules are the much better analogues for pre-Cenozoic marine oncoids.
Non-algal oncoids and macroids: The original definition of the term oncoid has been broadly expanded. It presently covers carbonate nodules formed as biogenic accretions not only by microbes, algae and micro-organisms, but also by bryozoans or serpulids for example. Bryozoan nodules, also called 'bryooncoids' or 'bryooids', are built by free-living bryozoan colonies associated with microbes (Hillmer et al. 1996, Scholz 2000). The laminar growth of bryozoan colonies circumcrust litho- or bioclastic nuclei. Modem cm-sized bryooncoids occur in temperate regions (Rider and EMCO1979).Ancient counterparts have been described from Neogene and Cretaceous sediments (Balson and Taylor 1982).
Rhodoids and cyanoids - more sensitive categories: Since it is desirable to separate coated nodular grains of different origin and formed in different environments, specific names have been coined, starting with the term 'rhodolite' for "nodules and detached branch growth with a nodular form composed principally of coralline algae" (Bosellini and Ginsburg 1971). Because rhodolite has priority for a variety of the mineral garnet, the name was later replaced by 'rhodolith'. Peryt (1983) suggested the name rhodoid for nodular grains formed mainly by coralline but also by other red algae. Finally, Riding (1979, 1983) proposed the name cyanolith or cyanoid for porostromate oncoids formed predominantly by calcified filamentous and coccoid cyanobacteria that are commonly preserved as tubes. Corresponding stromatolites were called 'skeletal stromatolites'. Oncoids with tiny tubular microfossils that can not be identified as being of cyanobacterial origin should simply be called 'porostromate oncoids'.
Classification of Oncoids, Rhodoids and Macroids
Compositional Types
Examples
Dominating Biota
Micrite oncoid
PI. 12/2
Microbes
Spongiostromate oncoids PI. 1113-4; PI. 12/73 (non-skeletal) PI. 8913; PI. 13115
Microbes and algae
Note: Micrite oncoids and spongiostromate oncoids also originate from micritization of porostromate oncoids
Porostromate oncoids (skeletal)
PI. 12/1,3,4; PI. 142/11; PI. 13614
Calcified cyanobacteria e.g. Cyanoids (formed by calcimicrobes); Girvaneh oncoids algae
Foraminiferaloncoids
PI. 11/56; PI. 5112 PI. 111118
Encrusting foraminifera e.g . Nubecu/atLa oncoids
Composite oncoids
PI. 5119; PI. 11913
Association of cyanobacteria, algae, foraminifera or other encrusting organisms
e.g. Giwane//aforaminiferal oncoids Giwane//a-Spirort,~~ oncoids; foraminiferal-algal oncoids
Rhodoids
PI. 5618
Calcareous red algae
e.g. Coralline algal rhodoids; Archaeo/iihophy//um rhodoids
Composite rhodoids
PI. 1216; PI. 14916
Associations of red algae and other encrusting organisms
e.g. Foraminifera-red algal rhodoids
Macroids
--
Foraminifera or bryozoans, or other encrusting organisms
e.g. Acervulinid foraminiferal macroids; bryozoan macroids (bryoids)
Fig. 4.14. Practical classification of oncoids, rhodoids and macroids.
The name macroid was suggested by Peryt (1983) for organically coated grains with sizes >10 mm (see Fig. 4.14). Presently the term is used for cm-sized coated grains formed predominantly by encrusting metazoans or protozoans, sometimes associated with algae (e.g. balanid macroids, serpulid macroids). Foraminiferal macroids constructed by Acervulina or Gypsina are common constituents of Cenozoic warm- and coolwater carbonates (Perrin 1992). Nodular growth forms produced by free-living corals were called coralliths (Gill and Coates 1977).
Conzposite growth types: Many oncoids and rhodoids consist of two or more encrusting organisms that occur in abundance and form repetitive or randomly distributed structures. Examples are oncoids formed by calcimicrobes and encrusting foraminifera, or oncoids built by foraminifera and coralline algae (Pl. 149/6). The latter have been called 'for-algaliths' (Prager and Ginsburg 1989), but a simple descriptive designation as foraminiferal-coralline algal oncoids of these composite oncoids is sufficient, too (Fig. 4.14). Highly diverse oncoid communities indicate rather stable conditions during the growth of the grains over time. Size catagories: Kutek and Radwanski (1965) and Peryt (1983) proposed names describing size grades of
oncoids: micro-oncoid or microids (<2 mm), piso-oncoid (2 to 10 mm), and macr-o-oncoidor macroids (>10 or >20 mm). Most modem and Tertiary macroids which are not formed predominantly by coralline algae (e.g. foraminiferal macroids) exhibit sizes ranging from about 10 to 100 mm. Since the abundance of very small and of exceptionally large oncoids may indicate specific hydrodynamic controls, the differentiation of micro-oncoids and macro-oncoids is meaningful. The term piso-oncoid should be replaced by meso-oncoid for oncoids with sizes from about 2 mm to about 10 mm, but usually only up to 5 mm, because the suffix piso- is too close to 'pisoid' which refers to a grain category distinctly different from oncoids.
Semantic problems: Oncoid designates the individual grain, oncolite a limestone consisting of more than 50 % oncoids. This definition parallels the strongly recommended use of ooid for the grain and oolite for a sedimentary rock composed of ooids (Teichert 1958). Analogously, the terms cyanoid and rhodoid should be used for the the individual grains, and cyanolite and rhodolite for the carbonate rocks. But many authors still prefer the suffix '-lith' and not '-oid' in order to name the individual grains (rhodoliths: Bosence 1983). The terms 'oncoid-bearing' or 'rhodoid-bearing' characterize limestones with less than 50% oncoids.
Modern Oncoids
124
Practical classification Fig. 4.14 outlines a practicable classification of common oncoid and rhodoid types, based on the dominating biota involved in the formation of the grains: ( A )Oncoids: The main types are differentiated by (a) the existence/absence of non-skeletal or skeletal mic.rostructures, the biotic composition and the occurrence of non-algallcyanobacterial (zoogenic) biota, and (b) the diversity of co-existing biota that contribute to the cortices.
Micrite oncoids consist of micrite, exhibit no distinct lamination, but are comparable in shape to other oncoid types. These oncoids result from trapping of fine-grained sediment on the surface of vanished microbiallalgal felts and/or microbially induced precipitation of carbonate. The oncoids correspond genetically to spongiostromate oncoids. Many micrite oncoids, however, are caused by obliteration of porostromate and other oncoids due to pervasive microboring and recrystallization. Spongiostromate oncoids are poorly or distinctly laminated grains, consisting of micritic layers around a bio- or lithoclastic nucleus. The laminae are the result of sediment trapping and the calcification of microbial or algal filaments. Owing to the rapid decomposition of organic filaments, commonly only the lamination but not the filaments are visible. Spongiostromate microfabrics are variable. They embrace micritic, spongy, fenestral, peloidal and other fabrics. These fabrics are produced by differences in environmental factors, biotic composition and diagenetic overprint. Comparable textures are known from recent as well as ancient stromatolites (Logan et al. 1974; Monty 1976, 1976). Organisms which can be incorporated within spongiostromate oncoids are foraminifera, bryozoans and various microproblematica (Kutek and Radwanski 1965; Elliott 1966; Dahanayake et al. 1976). Porostromate oncoids are layered or non-layered, usually micritic grains exhibiting remains of skeletal microbes and calcareous algae. Oncoids formed by recognizable cyanobacteria are called cyanoids. Porostromate microfabrics are defined by loose or tangled, variously oriented, straight or sinuous calcified filaments. Typical cyanoids are Girvanella oncoids, known from the Cambrian to the Jurassic. A characteristic feature of these oncoids is the alternation of dark Girvanellabearing and light barren laminae. Girvanella oncoids are more rapidly lithified than spongiostromate oncoids as evidenced by more abundant macroborings in porostromate oncoids. Foraminifera1 oncoids are formed by encrustations of calcareous or agglutinated tests, starting with settlement on a hard surface, e.g. a bioclast. Some foraminiferal oncoids are distinctly layered,
others are not. Composite oncoids consist of several taxa that form alternating layers. Common types are (I) grains built by various cyanobacterial and algal taxa; (2) cyanobacteria and/or algae associated with encrusting foraminifera (e.g. 'osagid grains': Henbest 1963; Toomey et al. 1989); and (3) cyanobacteria and algae, associated with taxonomically different encrusters (e.g. foraminifera, bryozoans, serpulids (Girvanella-spirorbid oncoids: Poncet and Lapparent 1975). Rare groups which contribute to the formation of oncoids, particularly in non-marine and marginal-marine environments, are spirorbid worms and vermetid gastropods (Poncet and de Lapparent 1975; Burchette and Riding 1977). (B) Rhodoids: They are easily recognized by the very fine micritic network of the microstructures (Pl. 54, P1. 56). Opposed to oncoids, the internal structure of rhodoids is strongly controlled by the internal growth pattern of the red algal thalli. Rhodoids, therefore, are not necessarily laminated. Nodular thalli of very finegrained calcareous red algae may be confused with micrite oncoids, e.g. Marinella Pfender, a common constituent of Late Jurassic and Cretaceous platform carbonates (Pl. 13613). Composite rhodoids originate from the growth of red algae associated with encrusting foraminifera and other sessile organisms. The diversity within the cortex may be low, moderate and high, and is a sensible measure for short-term changes of environmental conditions.
In-depth classifications:Oncoids have been subdivided according to biotic composition, internal structures (lamination), shape and growth form as well as size (Maslov 1960; Dragastan 1964; Zhuravleva 1964; Logan et al. 1964; Radwanski and Szulczewski 1966; Catalov 1970; Dahanayake 1977, 1978). Similar criteria have been used for categorizing rhodoids, but the types of internal structures, systematic composition of the red algae as well as the shapes of the oncoids are more relevant (Bosellini and Ginsburg 1971; Bosence 1983). Catalov (1983) differentiated 'phytogenic' oncoids (corresponding to porostromate oncoids), 'zoogenic' oncoids (foraminiferal oncoids), and 'zoophytogenic oncoids' (composite oncoids).
4.2.4.1 Oncoids Modem oncoids Present-day oncoids form in a wide variety of environments, ranging from freshwater lakes, streams and marshes to marine inter- and subtidal conditions. It is
Recent Oncoids
generally believed that many oncoids and concentric laminae are formed by adhesion of fine grains of sediment to the mucilaginous surface of algal mats (Pl. 111 1,2) and also by precipitation of calcium carbonate in response to the withdrawal of carbon dioxide by algae during photosynthesis. Nodule turning is facilitated by waves and tidal currents, a sloping surface, or bioturbation of the underlying surface by grazing herbivorous fish. The contribution of cyanobacteria and other bacteria to the formation of cyanoids and spongiostromate oncoids has generated a large number of publications in the last few decades that have clearly established the fundamental role played by cyanobacteria (Pentecost and Riding 1986; Gerdes et al. 1994). These observations were reinforced by experiments that succeeded in creating calcite and aragonite biocrystals under laboratory conditions approximatingnatural conditions (Chafetz and Buczynski 1992; Knorre and Krumbein 1992; Castanier et al. 1999). The eminent function of microbes for the formation of freshwater oncoids and ooids was exemplified by Davaud and Girardclos (2001) in Lake Geneva, Switzerland: In surficial sediments nucleation of Low-Mg calcite occurs in close association with organic films formed by the mucus of filamentous cyanobacteria and diatoms. In subsurface sediments the intercrystalline porosity is reduced and the micritic porous and organic-rich coatings are transformed into a dense mosaic with scattered molds of filaments, creating a microfabric similar to ancient oncoids.
Recent non-marine oncoids: Free-lying, rounded irregularly laminated oncoids occur in fluviatile and lacustrine habitats; they form in association with calcareous tufa, and as microbial coatings on tropical karst cavities ('terrestrial oncoids': Jones 1991). Lacustrine and fluviatile oncoids are similar with regard to their morphology and internal criteria. Oncoids from freshwater lakes have been studied in Europe and North America (e.g. Pia 1933; Jones and Wilkinson 1978; Schafer and Stapf 1978; Murphy and Wilkinson 1980; Schneider et al. 1983; Obenluneschloss 1991). The ellipsoidal or subspherical, centimeter to tens of centimeter-sized oncoids are produced by cyanobacteria in association with green and red algae as well as diatoms. The oncoids typically possess a laminated, porous microstructure, with layers or tufts of micrite tubes representing the encrusted sheets of cyanobacteria or green algal filaments. The taxonomically differentiated filaments form a fine intertwined network or a conspicuous radial microfabric. Common oncoid nuclei are mollusks, plant debris or rock pebbles. The basic types correspond to porostromate as well as spongiostromate
125
oncoids. Smaller and discoidal oncoids (e.g. Schnegglisteine in Lake Constance) exhibit a distinct lamination with alternating porous and dense carbonate layers reflecting seasonal growth (Pl. 1215). Freshwater lake oncoids are characteristically concentrated in shallow, near-shore zones with only slight wave- or current-agitation. Their distribution allows climatically controlled lake level fluctuations to be reconstructed (Magny 1992). As shown by oncoids in the Lake Constance, changing textural and diagenetic features of the oncoids are related to differences in the composition and growth pattern of the microbes and algae that participate in the formation of the nodules. Modem lacustrine oncoids demonstrate that the formation of spongiostromate and porostromate oncoids does not necessarily need strong or repetitive turning of the nodule and that in-situ growth is a common feature. An interesting aspect related to the nutrient controls of oncoid-forming algae are freshwater oncoids created by industrial pollution (Dean and Eggleston 1984). Fluvial oncoids, formed by often highly diverse algae and cyanobacteria, are extremely variable in shape (ellipsoidal, discoidal, spherical, subcylindrical,irregular), size and internal structures (Glazek 1965, Golubic and Fischer 1975). Many oncoids exhibit excentric growth forms due to the contacts of the grains. The layers are often asymmetrically arranged, interrupted or obscured. Oncoid sizes range from samller than 5 cm to larger than 30 cm; large oncoids are rather common. Many oncoids exhibit distinct concentric lamination and radial fibrous structures.
Recent marine oncoids: In marginal-marine settings cyanoids originate in intertidal to shallow subtidal environments with normal, low or high salinity (Golubic and Campbell 1981; Richter et al. 1979; Neuser et al. 1982; Richter and Sedat 1983). Some spongiostromate oncoids are formed by trapping and binding of sediment on the surface of finely filamentous mats that disintegrate and roll on the substrate (Gebelein 1976;Jones and Goodbody 1985). Modern open-marine oncoids formed in intertidal to subtidal environments (e.g. Bermuda, Bahamas, Netherlands Antilles) often do not display distinct laminations, because algal growth patterns are continuously destroyed. The nuclei of these oncoids are provided by algal chips and skeletal grains from adjacent organisms living on seagrass. Oncoids with concentrically stacked laminae (spheroidal structures, type-SS structures of Logan et al. 1964) originate in the low intertidal zone exposed to waves, and in the agitated shallow-water zone below the low-water mark. The prime prerequisite for the growth of these oncoids is believed to be the overturning of the laminated bod-
126
How to Describe Oncoids
Box 4.8. How to describe oncoids? Check your samples and use information from the field! Field criteria Depositional regime: Predominantly carbonate, mixed siliciclastic-carbonate or siliciclastic environments? Position of oncoid beds in the section: Occurrence in defined horizons (-> event beds, part of shallowing or deepening upward sequences)? Repetitive occurrence (-> cyclic patterns)? Occurrence in mud-dominated or grain-dominated limestones (-> different settings and environmental controls)? Abundance and distribution of oncoids: Either more or less than 50% of rock volume (-> oncolite or oncoid-bearing limestone). Densely packed (grain-to-grain contacts) or scattered oncoids (-> autochthonous and allochthonous oncoids)? Color of oncoids and matrix (-> may reflect differences in composition andlor weathering)? Sedimentary structures: Bedding, cross-bedding, bioturbation, grading, parallel orientation, imbrication, geopetal structures (-> clues to movement of oncoids and water energy)? Co-occurrence with stromatolites cryptalgal orfenestral structures, intergrowth of oncoids and stromatolites (-> intertidal and shallow subtidal environments)? Association with ooids andlor lithoclasts (-> reworking of oncoids)? Associated fossils (type, preservation, abundance; -> paleoenvironment)? Field and laboratory criteria Limestone texture: Wackestone/floatstone, packstone, grainstonelrudstone, bindstone? Matrix (homogeneous micrite, fine-bioclastic micrite, sparry calcite)? Oncoid types: Micrite oncoids, spongiostromate orland porostromate oncoids (cyanoids), foraminifera1 oncoids, composite oncoids? Single or multiple oncoids? Orientation of oncoids and other grains (-> current transport?) Size ranges, average, fi-equency distribution, sorting (-> occurrence and frequency of micro-, meso- or macro-oncoids)? Variations in shape, surface and growth forms (symmetrical, asymmetrical) of oncoids); ( -> water energy; in-situ growth)? Associated grains and fossils? Laboratory criteria Geopetalfabrics in oncoids (-> turning during growth, several growth phases)? Size. Ranges, average, dominating size fractions? Shape: Spherical, subspherical, ellipsoidal, discoidal, flattened (-> environmental and biological controls)? Contorted oncoids (-> soft oncoids, compacted oncoids )? Sur-ce: Smooth, grooved, pustular, lobate; conspicuously round or rounded; bored; encrusted; preserved or eroded growth pattems (-> reworking and redeposition)? Individual growth patterns of oncoids: Changes in basic microfabrics and biotic contribution, multi-stage patterns (-> reflecting changes in environmental factors)? Borings: Totally bored or partially bored oncoids (-> alternations of hard and soft stages; early lithification during the growth of oncoids)? Cracks in the oncoids: Type, frequency, infilling (-> syn- or post-depositional origin, desiccation)? Cortex: Basic mzcrofabric of the cortex: Lamination, meshwork (fine or coarse arrangement of sparry fenestrae, biotic contribution) or predominantly micritic? Layers and lamination: Layers and/or laminae; texture (distinct or vague, densely and loosely laminated; compound laminae and laminae sets, S-, I,- and R-type; see Fig. 4.15); configuration (concentric or non-concentric, continuous or non-discontinuous, tapering out of laminae); composition of the laminae composition (micritic, granular, biotic, sparry); surface of laminae (smooth, wavy, crenulated; disruption and micro-unconforrnities; impregnations, e.g. by glauconite, limonite); laminae thickness; inclusions of sediment between laminae; alternation of different laminae types (dark and light laminae, biotic and micritic laminae; organically-rich and organically-poor laminae; clay-rich and clay-poor laminae)? Biotic composition of the cortex: Taxonomic inventory, morphotypes (shape and size, abundance of different groups, diversity, successions), comparison with organisms outside the oncoids (-> biological controls, continuous/discontinuous growth, selective oncoid biota)? Nucleus: Present or absent, single or several nuclei, size, composition (bioclast, lithoclast, other grains), preservation, comparison of nuclei and non-oncoid grains with regard to grain types and biotic diversity (identical or different -> autochthonous/allochtonous oncoids)? The nucleus may be a complete or broken skeleton, an inorganic grain, or a soft particle which has subsequently decayed. Cortex and nucleus: Size and ratio; cortex larger or smaller than nucleus; different thickness of the cortex on the upper and lower side of the oncoid (-> in situ growth)? Is there a significant correlation between the size of the oncoids and the thickness of the cortex?
How to Describe Onocids
ies, generally accomplished by wave and current action; this allowing phototrophic growth to occur on all sides of the oncoids. Varying degrees of agitation and movement of the grains result in several geometric types (Fig. 4.15): SS-I structures (biconvex lenticular oncoids), SS-R oncoids (oncoids consisting of randomly arranged hemeispheroids that make up the structure), and SS-C structures (characterized by concentrically stacked spheroids). How to describe oncoids and oncolites? The analysis of oncoids requires field data and careful studies of thin sections. Box 4.12 summarizes the criteria which should be examined.
Dimensions and shape: Oncoid size is controlled both by environmental conditions and biological factors. The former include water energy and sedimentation rate, the latter metabolic processes of the biota involved in the oncoid formation, competition with grazing organisms and the size of the bioclastic or lithoclastic nuclei used. Marked variations in oncoid size within limestone horizons are important indicators of changes in deposition patterns, and are used to evaluate sequence boundaries as well as sea-level fluctuations. The size of modem freshwater oncoids ranges from smaller 2 mm to larger 100 mm. Ancient spongiostromate oncoids commonly vary from smaller 2 mm up to 50 mm. The average size of ancient porostromate oncoids is approximately 50 mm, but the range may extend up to more than 100 mm. Shape modifications both of oncoids and rhodoids can be best described by means of the Sneed and Folk sphericity-form diagram for particle shapes. The triangle diagram displays long, intermediate, and short axes and defines the basic form types (discoidal, spheroidal, and ellipsoidal). Many oncoids are elongate or subspherical in shape and may be flattened on one side. Laminated versus non-laminated micofabrics: Modem stromatolites and oncoids offer the possibility of understanding the controls of microstructural elements of oncoids. The basic lamination in ancient oncoids consists of couplets seen as dark, organic-rich micritic laminae, alternating with microspar or sparry as well as lighter colored laminae poor in organic matter, and often thicker than the dark laminae. The generation of individual laminae is intimately related to life activities of microbial assemblages. The generation of couplets with two distinct laminae members implies iterative changes in environmental variables that control the life activities of microbes, e.g. sedimentation rates, periodic deposition of sediment onto the growth surface -
127
induced by tides or storms, day to night variations or seasonal changes in water chemistry resulting in changes in saturation and nutrients. Seasonal long-term environmental changes may affect water temperature, salinity, water level and turbulence, nutrients and sediment influx. The thickness of the laminae depends on the phototactic response of photosynthesizing cyanobacteria, the makeup of the microbiota, seasonal changes which may affect lithification and carbonate precipitation, and the modifications of initial laminae thickness by diagenesis. The microrelief along a single lamina, e.g. small-scale crenulations, tufts or domeshaped structures, is produced by particular microbes, but may also reflect diagenetic modifications.
Descriptive subdivision of oncoids: Several attempts have been made to classify oncoids with laminated fabrics (e.g. Dahanayake 1977; Malchus and Kuss 1988; Kuss 1990). These classifications consider the composition of the laminae and the biota incorporated within the cortex. Because different lamina types reflect changes in water energy levels and water depths (e.g. Bowman 1983), a simple descriptive subdivision is proposed here (Fig. 4.15): The subdivision of the geometric types follows Logan et al. (1964), who classified oncoids, (called 'spheroidal stromatolites') according to the arrangement of the laminae, reflected in turn by the shape of the nodules. Type C is characterized by concentricallyarranged laminae, Type R by randomly arranged, non-continuous and overlapping laminae, and Type I by inverted laminae. In addition, a fourth Type L for randomly growing lobate forms with dome-shaped laminae is proposed here. The five compositionul laminae types may occur in isolation, but many oncoids show multi-stage sequences consisting of several laminae types. These sequences are used to estimate hydrodynamic changes during oncoid growth, e.g. from quiet-water conditions (reflected by types 1 and 2 in Fig. 4.15) to moderate to high-energy conditions (type 5). Note that a given oncoid type can be transformed to another type by diagenetic alteration. The micrite laminae of Type 1 are microbial in origin or were formed by trapping of fine-grained sedimentary material (Pl. 11/2).This type is the most common microfabric in spongiostromate oncoids and is regarded as indicative of an environment with constant low-energy conditions, e.g. protected shallow subtidal or basinal oncoids. Some of these oncoids may be completely recrystallized porostromate oncoids. Type 1 oncoids are commonly sphaeroidal or ellipsoidal. The spany spots of type 2 (corresponding to 'grumous' larni-
128
nae, Dahanayake 1978) most commonly represent molds of calcimicrobes or algae, but in some cases may be caused by diagenetic alteration of peloidal fabrics. Type 2 oncoids are common in low-energy environments. Type 3 is of particular interest because it reflects the response of microbiota to short-term environmental changes. Type 4 is often characterized by sessile foraminifera or porostromate calcimicrobes(e.g. Girvanella). Girvanella tubes are usually visible in the exterior parts of the oncoids, and rapidly loose their shape to the inner oncoid parts.The encrusting foraminifera depend on hard substrates, and therefore testify to
Oncoids
the existence of sporadic lithification during oncoid growth. The diversity of type 4 can be both low and also very high, thus reflecting the appropriate conditions for the growth of epiphytes and epizoans in shallow subtidal environments with low sedimentation rates. The fabric of Type 5 has been called fenestral. Both Type 4 and Type 5 may lack a well-defined lamination or the meshwork characterizingType 5 may form non-laminated oncoids. Non-laminated oncoids are rounded micritic grains commonly containing abundant relicts of calcified biota. Shapes are often irregular, lobate and not strictly
Plate 11 Oncoids: Calcareous Nodules Formed by Microbes, Algae and Other Encrusting Organisms Oncoids are mm- to cm-sized, rounded or irregularly formed grains consisting of a layered micritic cortex and a bio- or lithoclastic nucleus. The layers originate from crusts of sessile organisms (predominantly calcimicrobes and algae, but also foraminifera, bryozoans, serpulids and others). These organisms enhance and initiate the precipitation of calcium carbonate, act as encrusters and binders, trap fine-grained sediment or enhance synsedimentary lithification. Oncoids are common in marine and non-marine environments. Basic oncoid types are distinguished by the existence of skeletal or non-skeletal microfabrics (porostromate and spongiostromate oncoids) and by the prevailing biotic composition (e.g. microbial oncoids, foraminiferal oncoids). The shape, internal structures and biotic composition denote paleoenvironrnental factors (e.g. water energy, sedimentation rates) and specific settings (see Box 4.11). The main settings of Phanerozoic oncoids have changed over time: Paleozoic spongiostromate oncoids grew predominantly in lacustrine and transitional marine environments; Cambrian to Jurassic porostromate oncoids flourished in marine subtidal environments. Starting in the midJurassic, porostromate oncoids were increasingly substituted for by spongiostromate oncoids, which became the only type in marginal-marine and particularly in lacustrine settings. In normal marine settings oncoids were replaced by rhodoids starting with the Late Cretaceous. Oncoids are commonly larger than ooids and vadoids (pisoids). They exhibit more irregular and often overlapping layers which are considerably thicker than the coatings of cortoid grains. 1 Modern oncoid formed by snowball-like sediment-trapping on the slimy surface of microbial films. A poorly developed laminar fabric is indicated by micritic areas (arrows). The oncoids with a maximum size of about 5 cm occur in quartzbearing calcareous sands on the coast of the Red Sea. Ras Muhammed, Sinai, Egypt. 2 Detail of Fig. 1. The oncoid consists of strongly micritized foraminifera (F), cortoids, rounded intraclasts and small angular quartz grains (Q). Note the open interparticle porosity (P). 3 Spheroidal spongiostromatelporostronzate oncoids. The micritic layers of the cortex are accentuated by differences in color and the incorporation of spherical microfossils. Intergranular pores are occluded by sparitized calcitic rhombs indicating dedolomitization processes similar to those described from Middle Jurassic reservoir rocks in the Paris Basin (Purser 1985). The complex diagenetic history is characterized by partial dolomitization of oncoid floatstones associated with a replacment of matrix and peripheral parts of some grains, dissolution of dolomite crystals and filling of the rhombic molds by calcite. The limestones represent the upper part of a shallowing-upward cycle. Late Middle Jurassic: VrhnikaLogatec near Ljubljana, Slovenia. 4 Detail of -> 3. Vague remains of very thin, vertically arranged, branched filaments are recognizable within the gray layers (A). In contrast, horizontally growing Giwanella-like tubes occur in layer B. The dark-colored zone at the top of A point to cessations in the growth of the oncoid. 5 Foraminifera1 oncoids. Irregularly shaped and partly contorted oncoids built by the encrusting foraminifera Nubecularia reicheli Rat. Bioclastic oncoid grainstone. Bioclasts used as nuclei are identical to the bioclasts occurring outside the oncoids. Reworking of oncoids is indicated by variations in shape and size (< 2 to 5 mm). These oncoids formed on highenergetic shoals at the boundary of the restricted and open-marine parts of a carbonate platform. Middle Jurassic (Bajocian): Bourgogne, northwestern France. 6 Nubecularia oncoid. The core (an echinoderm fragment, E) is surrounded by layers of densely spaced foraminiferal tests. The chambers exhibit thick walls that touch each other (arrows). Same sample as -> 5.
Plate 1 1 : Oncoids
129
Ancient Oncoids
1 Micrite only
Micritic and sparitic laminae
Micrite with
2 sparitic patches
Micrite with encrusting organisms
5 Meshwork Fig. 4.15. Descriptive subdivision of laminated oncoids in regard to growth patterns and the composition of the laminae. A - Basic geometric types of oncoids found in recent shallow-marine settings and related to varying degrees of agitation and movement of the grains (modified from Logan et al. 1964): Type C (characterized by Concentrically stacked spheroid layers, SS-C); Type R (oncoids consisting of Randomly arranged hemispheroidal layers); and Type I (biconvex lenticular oncoids exhibiting Inverted hemispheres, SS-I). Irregular random growth also can produce Lobate growth forms (Type L). Type I describes a particular case characterized by the interruption of oncoid growth, partial destruction and renewed growth after reworking and transport. B - Five types of laminae are commonly composed of: 1 - Laminated fabric consisting predominantly of micritic laminae (Pl. 12/7), 2 - Micritic laminae exhibiting tiny sparry spots whose distribution accentuates the laminar structure of the oncoid (Pl. 11/3), 3 - Couplets of micritic and spany laminae (Pl. 12/3), 4 - Micritic laminae including or alternating with layers of recognizable encrusting microfossils (Pl. 119/3), 5 - Laminae exhibiting an open meshwork with spar-filled voids (e.g. PI. 1214, P1. 11813). Nucleus (black), micrite (stippled), sparry calcite (white).
spheroidal. The biota are represented by calcimicrobes, to the depositional environment from other areas or foraminifera and various skeletal metazoans with spe- whether the oncoids were formed within the deposicific growth forms and succession patterns. Organisms tional environment. Carozzi et al. (1983) uses the 'incontributing to Late Jurassic non-laminated oncoids in- dex of biotic diversity of benthics'; the IBDB relates clude foraminifera, serpulids, bryozoans, chaetetid cor- the number of groups or taxa forming the nuclei to the alline sponges, Bacinella, Marinella, and porostromate bioclasts occurring together with the oncoids. calcimicrobes. Oncoids devoid of a continuous lamination have been called pseudoncoids (Dahanayake et Ancient oncoids al. 1976). Most ancient oncoids consist of calcite, sometimes with minor admixtures of clay minerals, quartz and orBiotic composition of the cortex: The diversity of ganic matter. The composition of these admixtures usuthe microfossils in oncoids reflects small-scale envi- ally corresponds to that of the minerals occurring in ronmental conditions that assist in interpretating long- the vicinity of the oncoids. term environmental trends (Scherze 2001). Autochthonous 'forarniniferal-algal' oncoids composed of intiNon-carbonate oncoids include phosphatic, fermgimately associated calcimicrobes and encrusting tubu- nous and manganese nodules as well as, less commonly, lar foraminifera may indicate deeper-water settings oncoids consisting of pyrite (Schieber 1999) or chlo(Peryt and Peryt 1975). rite (Misik and Sucha 1997). The first three types are often associated with pelagic carbonates. The oncoids Nucleus: The shape of the nuclei often determines are found together with stromatolitic crusts on disconthe shape of the oncoid grain. A comparison of bio- tinuity surfaces, often corresponding to major straticlasts acting as nuclei with the skeletal grains of the graphic gaps and related to eustatic highstand phases. sample indicates whether the oncoids have been brought The formation of these oncoids appears to be strongly
Ancient Non-Marine Oncoids
controlled by microbes which induce mineralization and act in trapping and binding sediment (Monty 1973; Charnpetier and Joussemet 1979). Different sources contribute to mineralization. Manganese nodules result from enrichment of deep oceanic bottom waters in manganese from submarine volcanisms, basalts and riftzone hydrothermal fluids. Manganese and ferromanganese oncoids, crusts and pavements are widely known throughout the Mesozoic of the Tethyan region in condensed pelagic limestones (Jenkyns 1970). Nodular phosphorites containing phosphatic oncoids originate under conditions of marine upwelling, but input of phosphorus from river drainage must also be taken into account (see P1. 110). Common features of non-carbonate oncoids are variations in the contribution of encrusting organisms (particularly foraminifera: Greenslate 1974), the geometry and arrangement of oncoid laminae and the shape of the nodules. The size ranges from < l mm to 2-10 cm (manganese micro- and macronodules: Pattan 1993). Examples of ancient fermginous oncoids are limonitic Middle Jurassic nodules known as 'snuff-boxes' --3 rnrn 5 and believed to have been formed in an oxic environment with periodical current influence (Gatrall et al. b Boring 1972; Palmer and Wilson 1990). These oncoids are asc Clast removed from underlying rock sociated with episodes of reduced sedimentation. The g Glauconitic crust oncoids exhibit asymmetric cortices. hg Hardground The original ferric composition of the laminae was m Microbes probably under the control of non-photosynthetic mi( I Low sedrnenf supply croorganisms. Phosphatic oncoids exhibit dense lami4 High sed~rnentsupply nated and microstromatolitic fabrics (Krajewski 1983; Martin-Algarra and Vera 1994). A genetic interpretation of phosphatic oncoids and stromatolites formed at discontinuity surfaces of drowned carbonate platforms Fig. 4.16. Formation of phosphatic oncoids on a Mesozoic pelagic swell. The ellipsoidal and subspherical oncoids are is shown in Fig. 4.16.
Ancient non-marine oncoids: Oncoids formed in ancient lake systems have been known since the Precambrian (Buck 1980), but have been studied more thoroughly only from the Tertiary (Box 4.9). The oncoids provide information about lake depositional systems and provide insights into the regional climate and lake level fluctuations (Awrarnik et al. 2001). Lacustrine oncoids are commonly associated with high-energy, often mixed siliciclastic-carbonate near-shore environments. They can mark the initiation of climatically induced transgressive phases. Conditions favorable for oncoid formation are high carbonate input associated with the increase in precipitation and the contribution of supersaturated groundwaters. Reworked oncoids indicate falls in lake level. Oncoids formed in soda lakes are known from Tertiary lake deposits (Dixit 1984). Freshwater and saline oncoids can be separated by dif-
several centimeter in size. The microstromatolitic laminae were formed by microbes, phosphate minerals, trapped pelagic micrite, and encrusting foraminifera. The nuclei of the microstromatolitic oncoids are mud clasts as shown in Fig. A: 1 growth of microbes (m) on a hardground (hg); 2 deposition of pelagic sediment and burial of microbial mats; 3 formation of clasts by burrowing and/or currents; 4 encrustation of isolated clasts and and rolling under moderate currents; 5 disymmetric upwards development of microbial lamination; 6 renewed growth of microbes (m) on the oncoid.
Fig. B demonstrates the origin of endostromatolites in voids within the oncoids: 1 oncoid grown on a micritic clast with a glauconitic rim; 2 burrowing and boring (b) affecting the oncoid and the nucleus, growth of microbes in the cavity (m); 3 infilling by pelagic sediment (stippled). Modified from Martin-Algarra and Vera (1994).
Ancient Marine Oncoids
Box 4.9. Selected case studies of ancient lacustrine-fluvial spongiostromate and porostromate oncoids and oncolites. Pleistocene: Awramik et al. 2001; Brochier et al. 1986; Casanova 1985; Dixit 1984. Tertiary: Anadon and Zarnarreno 1981; Bertrand-Sarfati et al. 1994;Bignot 1981;Bradley 1929;Colom 1993; Crouzel et al. 1972; Dixit 1984; Freytet and Plaziat 1982;Herbig 1991,1994;K l i h 1926;Leinfelder and Hartkopf-Froder 1990;Link et al. 1978;Llombart and Krauss 1982;Macker 1997;Moik 1990,Nickel 1983; Obrhel1984; Ordonezet al. 1983;Rutte 1953; Speck 1949; Surdam and Stanley 1979; Truc 1978; Weiss 1969. Cretaceous: Carozzi 1989; Monty and Mas 1981. Jurassic: Leinfelder 1985. Triassic: Clernmensen 1978. Permian: Clausing 1990;Schiifer and Stapf 1978;Stapf 1989. Carboniferous: Bertrand-Sarfatiand Fabre 1972;Obrhel 1977. Devonian: Donovan 1975; Fannin 1969; Obrhel 1976.
ferent types of bioclastic nuclei (e.g. unionid bivalves, gastropods, decapod crabs). Mollusk shells are more commonly used as nuclei for lithoclasts or gravels. 'Hollow' central parts of non-marine and marine oncoids or nuclei consisting of silt or sandy material can be caused by the disintegration and subsequent infilling of plant stems acting as nuclei (Jones and Goodbody 1985); those oncoids might be indicators of the existence of former macrophyte meadows. A common feature, particularly of larger lacustrine oncoids, are fine radial structures (Pl. 1217) sometimes emphasized by vertically arranged micro-cracks. Some of these radial structures are inaugurated by vertical growth patterns of algae. The composition of non-marine or extremely marginal marine oncoids depends on the growth patterns of algae, cyanobacteria and sometimes also of foraminifera and other organisms. The abundance and shape of oncoids is only sometimes hydrodynamically controlled. Many lacustrine oncoids originate from in-situ growth. Lacustrine oncoids have ellipsoidal and spheroidal, sometimes cylindrical shapes. Common sizes vary between 15 and about 200 mm. Sphaeroidal oncoids are generally attributed to fluvial channels and bottom lags of ponds; more irregular forms occur preferrentially in shallow parts of lakes (e.g. Nickel 1983, Casanova 1985), but these relations should not be transferred to all ancient examples (Leinfelder and Hartkopf-Froder 1990).
As opposed to marine oncoids, lacustrine and fluvial oncoids often exhibit distinct sets composed of morphologically identical laminae, e.g. couplets of dark and light laminae. Alternating thin micritic laminae and thicker laminae with vertical structures reflect the different compositions of the original algal associations (Monty and Mas 1981; Freytet and Plaziat 1982; Moik 1990; see P1. 813). Laminae thickness and micromorphology depend on the interplay between carbonate precipitation and sediment binding on algal filaments and the decay of the benthic microbial communities (Golubic 1976; Burne and Moore 1987). Binding and inorganic carbonate precipitation appears to be quantitatively more effective than biologically induced precipitation (Pentecost 1978). As opposed to marine oncoids, studies of non-marine oncoids allow a higher resolution of the development and time involved in environmental changes. Growth types of freshwater and brackish oncoids and stromatoliticstructures are powerful aids in reconstructing the depositional history of lacustrine, fluvial and deltaic sediments (e.g. Leinfelder 1985).The form, size, and microstructures are used to distinguish depositional zones of fluvial systems, e.g. channel base, abandoned channels, or the mouthes of rivers (Anadon and Zamarreno 1981; Nickel 1983; Macker 1997). Distributional patterns of oncoids assist in differenting specific lacustrine and fluvial depositional settings in coastal playa lakes and hypersaline lakes (Herbig 1994). Common microfacies criteria of non-marine oncoid-bearing limestones are micrite, peloids, black intraclasts, small radial ooids, stromatolites, gastropod and other mollusk shells, and ostracods (Link and Awramik 1978). Diagnostic criteria for ancient freshwater oncoids are nuclei formed by freshwater mollusks, lamination patterns analogous to modern freshwater oncoids, well-preserved microstructures, occurrence together with terrestrial sediments, and often large sizes. Ancient marine oncoids: Phanerozoic marine oncoids were formed in at least eight different settings including (1) tidally influenced marginal-marine environments, (2) open-marine shelf lagoons, (3) the environs of platform patch reefs, (4) back-reef areas, (5) associated with platform margin reefs, (6) on the upper slope, (7) basins, and (8) on pelagic platforms. These settings were best studied for Late Jurassic carbonates, particularly in Switzerland and France. Some of these settings can be differentiated by the types and composition of the oncoids, and in the associated sedimentary facies. Fig. 4.17 is a simplified summary of the main criteria of Late Jurassic oncoites and oncoid-bearing limestones. Oncoids are frequent constituents of
133
Depositonal Environment o f Late Jurassic Oncoids
Location Depositional texture
Wackestone Packstone Bindstone
Nackestone Padstone floatstone
Wackestone Packstone Floatstone
Grainstone Rudstone Wackestone
'ackstone %&tone
Wackestone Floatstone
Associated grains
Peloids Cortoids Stromatolites Birdseyes
3ioclasts
Biilasts Peloids
Cortoids Bioclasts lntraclasts
3icdasts ithalasts
Bioclasts
Associated fossils
Foraminifera Algae
Mollusks
Foraminifera
Foraminifera Calcar. algae Mollusks
3eef biota
Simple Multiple
Simple
Simple
Simple
Concentric
kncentric Inverse
Type of oncoid
-
EE:ems
I
1
Ammonites
I
Peloids
1
Planktonic foraminifera
I
Simple
Simple
Elliptical
Concentric (Radial Inverse
Simple
2->10mm
Prevailing size
5 -60 mm
Growth type
Basic types of oncoids
~-
Simple Multiple
1
~ialasts
Concentric Lobate Radial M Por > Sp Comp
Lobate Concentric Por > Sp M Comp Foraminifera
Concentric Radial Lobate Por > Sp Camp
Por C ,o
1
jM
2
1
Concentric
I
~
Cortex: Laminated Non-laminatec
L
Lamination type .-
1,2,3
.
Biotic composition
Calcimicrobes Algae
Caldmicrobes Serpulids Foraminifera
Caldmicrobes Highly diverse metazoans
Calcimicrobes Low-diverse metazoans
Lithoclasts Algae
Bivalves Corals
Corals Sponges
Corals Mollusks Algae
Serpulids
~
Boring~
--
Nucleus
Echinoderms
-
p p ~
Remarks
Mixed types Eroded and broken oncoids
-
Corals Echinoderms Mollusks
Cephalopods Echinoderms
Cephalopods Peloids Lithoclasts
_Ni6"=" Glauconite
Fenuginous
Ferruginou!
Fig. 4.17. Depositional environments and characteristics of Late Jurassic (Ogordian-Kimmeridgian) oncoids. The criteria are ordered according to their frequency in about 15 case studies. Although there are many deviations from this scheme, differences between shallow- and deeper-water oncoids are evident. Associated fossils, shapes and growth types, the lamination patterns and the type of the bioclasts forming the nuclei are of particular interest. Oncoid sizes reflect changing environmental conditions rather than specific depositional sites. Information on oncoids is provided by studies of the Late Jurassic 'Hauptmumienbank', which can be followed in northern Switzerland and France for at least 100 km. These studies indicate paleowater depths of a few meters for lagoonal oncoids, about 50 m for oncoids formed on the upper slope, and > 100 m for basinal oncoids. Based mainly on Dahanayake (1983), Fezer (1988), Gasche (1956), Gasiewicz (1983), Gygi and Persoz (1987), Gygi (1992), Kutek and Radwanski (1965), Leinfelder and Schmid (2000), Massari (1983), Piimpin (1965), Scherze (200 1) and Schmid (1996). Comp = composite oncoid, M = micritic oncoid, Por = porostromate oncoid, Sp = Spongiostromate oncoid.
Precambrian and Phanerozoic Oncoids
Jurassic shelf carbonates. Most of these settings are also documented by non-Jurassic examples (see Box 4.9). Oncoids formed in upper slope and baiinal settings are not known prior to the Permian.
Reef oncoids: Concentrically structured porostro-
amples are known from the Liassic and Late Jurassic of the Tethyan region (originally described as 'pelagic oolites': Jenkyns 1972; Massari 1983). The oncoids are characterized by polyphase coatings consisting of micritic and granular laminae, the latter composed of finegrained skeletal debris. Encrusting organisms (e.g. Nubecularia) are common. Nuclei are bioclasts (e.g. fragments of ammonites, sponges) and lithoclasts. The sizes vary between <2mm and 100 mm. The oncoids occur in association with microstromatolitesand originated through sediment-bindingand/or mineral-precipitating activity of microbes in regions with low sediment input, probably at storm-wave depth. Box 4.10 lists important case studies of Cambrian to Cretaceous marine oncoids.
mate and micritic oncoids are common constituents of Paleozoic reef limestones (e.g. Devonian stromatoporoid-coral reefs in western Canada: Machielse 1972; late Permian coralline sponge-Archaeolithoporellareefs of the Tethys region: Sano et al. 1990). Oncoids are common constituents of Devonian back-reef sands and fore-reef sediments. Locally porostromate oncoids grow in place on the slope, sometimes together with stromatolites. Very good examples are the capped oncoids formed by Rothpletzella (Playford et al. 1976). Differences in the biotic composition of the oncoids give hints Precambrian and Phanerozoic oncoids Oncoids occur already in Archean carbonates, toof changes in sea level and water depths. Pelagic oncoids: These spongiostromate grains, gether with stromatolites and ooids (Hofmann et al. formed on the tops of seamounts and drowned plat- 1999; Grotzinger and James 2000). The grain type is a forms, became more frequent during the Jurassic. Ex- common constituent of Proterozoic platform carbon-
Box 4.10. Selected case studies of ancient marine spongiostromate and porostromate oncolites. In contrast to modem oncoids, these oncoids were common in Paleozoic and Mesozoic subtidal and intertidal environments as well as in slope and basinal settings. The last marine cyanoids are known from the Cretaceous. Cyanoids were replaced by coralline algal rhodoids during the Late Cretaceous and the Tertiary. Cretaceous: Carozzi 1989 (tidal setting; oncoid bars on shallow carbonate platform); Lewy 1972; Masse 1979; Weiss 1969. Jurassic: Bollinger and Burri 1970 (patch reefs); Colacicchi et al. 1975 (tidal setting); Dahanayake 1977, 1978, 1983 (lagoonal carbonates); Dangeard 1935; Dragastan 1969; Elliott 1966; Fezer 1988 (platform margins and openmarine lagoonal settings, lagoonal carbonates); Gasche 1956; Gasiewicz 1983 (peritidal); Gygi 1969, 1992 (openmarine lagoon, slope, basin); Heim 1916; Hug 1999; Jenkyns 1972 (pelagic platform); Kutek and Radwanski 1965 (peritidal and basinal settings); Kuss 1990; Leinfelder et al. 1993; Leinfelder and Schmid 2000; Massari 1983; Massari and Dieni 1983 (pelagic platform); Misik 1966; Piimpin 1965 (reef, back-reef sands); Purser 1975 (peritidal); Scherze 2001 (patch reef);. Schmid 1996 (lagoonal and reef settings) Triassic: Biddle 1983 (reef-derived material); Catalov 1970,1983 (platforms); Fischer 1964 (tidal setting); Goldhammer et al. 1990 (tidal setting); Hagemeister 1988; Jerz 1966 (siliciclastic-carbonate inner shelf); Kisten et al. 1990; Peryt 1977, 1980; Radwanski 1968; Schuler 1968; Tichy 1983. Permian: Fliigel 1979 (lagoonal and reef settings); Fiichtbauer 1968 (near-reef); Kerkmam 1966 (reefs, back-reef sands); Mazzullo and Cys 1983; Peryt 1981; Peryt and Wagner 1981 (basinal setting); Rothe 1969; Termier and Termier 1955 (reef), Toomey 1974, 1983, Toomey et al. 1988, 1989 (subtidal carbonate shelves, open-marine and restricted shelf lagoons). Carboniferous: Bowman 1983 (subtidal platform); Burchette and Riding 1977; Carozzi 1989 (tidal setting; shoals in inner ramp position); Gerhard 1985; Henbest 1963; Johnson 1946; Neal 1969; Obrhel 1977; Perret 197 1; Toomey 1975; Wright 1983 (peritidal setting) Devonian: Kaufmann 1964; Machielse 1972 (back-reef sands and forereef setting); Pia 1932; Playford and Cockbain 1966 (forereef setting at platform margin); Poncet and Lapparent 1975 (siliciclastic-carbonate inner shelf); Wolf 1965 (reef). Silurian: Ratcliffe 1988 (shelf lagoon); Stel and De Coo 1977 (patch reef); Toomey and LeMone 1977. Ordovician: Benedict and Walker 1978; Blackwell et al. 1984 (lagoonal setting); Carozzi 1989 (tidal setting); Maslov 1960; Wood 1948. Cambrian: Gandin and Debrenne 1984 (associated with archaeocyathid patch reefs); Halley 1975 (peritidal setting); Hose 1961; Youngs 1977; Zhuravleva 1964.
Significance of Oncoids
135
ates together with 'katagraphs' (non-laminated carbonate structures of different size, and a structure consisting of micritic particles and peloids: Zhuravleva 1964, 1979). Conspicuous criteria of many Precambrian oncoids are their large size (up to tens of centimeters) and radialfibrous microfabrics interpreted as bacterially induced structures. Until the Vendian-Cambrian transition, oncoids are represented by spongiostromate and micritic growth types. The first calcimicrobes forming porostromate oncoids appear in the Late Vendian. Peryt (1981) suggested a distinct change in the major oncoid types and their environments during the Phanerozoic. He assumes that Paleozoic spongiostromate oncoids were predominantly formed in lacustrine and transitional marine environments, whereas porostromate Girvanella oncoids flourished in marine subtidal environments from the Cambrian to the Jurassic. Starting in the mid-Jurassic, porostromate oncoids were replaced by spongiostromate oncoids, which became the only type in marine settings and continued to flourish in lacustrine settings. Monty (1979) made the point, that spongiostromate oncoids were substituted in marine settings by rhodoids starting in the Early Tertiary. This concept is supported by the predominance of cyanoids in Paleozoic shelf carbonates. However, porostromate and spongiostromate oncoids may occur in close association in the same beds, pointing to a much stronger biological control on oncoid formation than previously thought.
Significance of oncoids in microfacies analysis Oncoids provide important microfacies data. Box 4.11 summarizes some significant points. Two case studies Early Permian oncolites and rhodoliths of the Carnic Alps, Austria - different composition and different setting (Fig. 4.18A, P1. 1211): Oncolite beds consisting of porostromate meso-sized oncoids with ranges between 10 and >50 mm are intercalated in shallow-marine inner and outer platform carbonates. Four types can be recognized according to their biotic composition: ( I ) Giwanella-foraminifera1oncoids of near-coast settings with strong siliciclastic input (Fig. 4.18A); (2) large composite oncoids (size up to 70 mm) composed of Girvanella and Claracrusta of open-marine inner platforms with minor siliciclastic input; (3) large red algal-foraminifera1rhodoids made of Archaeolithophyllum and calcitornellid foraminifera, and associated with fusulinids, dasyclad algae and mollusks, occurring in open platform settings; and (4) centimeter-sized spherical Archaeolithoporella-oncoids, associated with
Fig. 4.18. Weathered surfaces of oncoid limestones. A: Oncolite (oncoid packstone) composed of spheroidal and ellipsoidal meso- and macro-sized oncoids embedded within argillaceous bioclastic micrite. Most oncoids are Girvanella oncoids (cyanoids) or composite oncoids made by cyanobacteria and encrusting foraminifera. Note the high amount of small broken oncoid debris between the larger well-preserved oncoids and aligned oncoids, indicating reworking by currents. Early Permian: Carnic Alps, Carinthia, Austria. B: Oncoid wackestone with variously sized and poorly sorted ellipsoidal oncoids. The argillaceous carbonate matrix contains fine-bioclastic debris. Note the large size of the nuclei and the thin micritic coatings. Late Triassic (Carnian): Obir, Karawanken Mountains, Carinthia, Austria.
cement-rich platform-margin reefs. Similar types occur in comparable settings in Late Carboniferous and Early Permian platform carbonates of the Tethys and in the United States (e.g. Toomey 1983; Toomey et al. 1988, 1989). Late Triassic oncoid-bearing beds of the Calcareous Alps, Austria - regional marker beds (Fig. 4.18B): The huge middle and upper Late Triassic carbonate platforms of the Alps are separated by Carnian siliciclastic-
136
Significance of Oncoids
Box 4.11. Significance of oncoids and oncoid limestones Paleoenvironmental proxies Biotic composition and lamination types reflect environmental factors that control microbial and algal growth as well as encrusting communities (light, salinity, water energy, sediment input). The availability of light is not necessarily a limiting factor because cyanobacteria and various green algae also grow in areas of low light intensities (e.g. on the undersides of oncoids). Salinity: Oncoids originate in freshwater, brackish waters and marine waters. Ancient freshwater and brackish-water oncoids are differentiated from marine oncoids by nuclei formed by fresh water mollusks, specific lamination patterns analogous to modem freshwater oncoids, better preserved microstructures and the association with terrestrial sediments. Water-energy levels: Oncoids are often used as indicators of high energy, low intertidal to shallow subtidal environments, because it is thought that oncoids require frequent overturning and rolling to form, and that the degree of turbulence determines oncoid shapes. These generalizations do not hold in many freshwater and subtidal environments, where spongiosuomate and porostromate oncoids originate without significant rolling but nonetheless exhibit concentric laminae. Stationary growth is shown by asymmetrical shapes and asymmetrical widths of laminations. Rolling appears to be indicated by subspherical shapes, well-laminated cortices, concentric symmetrical growth patterns, and abrasion of algal or cyanobacterial structures. Cessations in rolling are manifested by strongly encrusted laminae surfaces. Lack of rolling is revealed by branched and lobate oncoid shapes. Multistage oncoids exhibiting a change from laminar to lobate growth forms record a change from common rolling to less frequent rolling. Low-energy and highenergy oncoids are better differentiated by the combined approach of oncoid criteria and texture types: Low-energy, quiet-water conditions are indicated by large micritic single and multiple oncoids that exhibit discontinuous growth layers (oncoid type R, Fig. 4.15) and form floatstones and wackestones. Quiet-water conditions are also indicated unlaminated or only weakly laminated meshwork oncoids (type 5, Fig. 4.15). Higher-energy environments are reflected by small oncoids, that exhibit regular laminations and form packstones and grainstones. Redeposition of oncoids is indicated by smoothing and breaking, co-occumence of different oncoid types, and oncoids found in a matrix different than the micrite forming the oncoids. Paleo-water depths are reflected in biotic composition, nuclei and lamination types. Deeper-water oncoids are often un-laminated or have densely spaced micritic laminae (e.g. in the Permian Zechstein). This is a favorable setting for continuous oncoid growth. The slowly growing Girvanella oncoids are considered indicators of reduced sedimentation, preferrably in deeper settings at depths of some tens of meters. Spongiostromate oncoids develop over shorter periods in unstable ecological conditions. Oncolite beds, intercalated in platform sequences, can reflect breaks or hiatuses in sedimentation. Short-term alternations of stationary phases and oncoid-building phases are shown by changes in lamination and encrustation types, micro-unconformities of laminae surfaces, and the incorporation of sediment within the oncoid. Sea-level fluctuations Shallowing-upward sequences and cyclic depositionalpatterns: Shallowing is indicated by stromatolitic crusts overgrowing oncoids, marked changes in size, shape and composition of oncoids, and differences in depositional texture types. A good example was described by Ratcliffe (1988). Oncoids are characteristic constituents of shallow subtidal members of muddy and grainy platform cycles (e.g. Fischer 1964; Goldhammer et al. 1990; Purser 1975). Transgressive and regressive phases: Oncoids often occur at the base of transgressive sequences formed in shallow low-energy environments (e.g. Wright 1983) and mark maximum flooding surfaces. An oncolitic wackestone facies with whole fossils may indicate regressive conditions. Stratigraphic gaps and condensed sequences: Breaks in sedimentation are manifested by non-carbonate oncoids and by oncoids with ferruginous or glauconitic coatings, associated with microstromatolites, hardgrounds and lithoclastic beds. Regional correlations In ramp and platform settings, oncolite limestones can be excellent marker beds that can be followed laterally for tens and hundreds of kilometers. Examples are known from the Late Triassic (Fig. 4.18B) and the Jurassic. Depositional settings of marine oncolites Compositional and morphological features of oncoids, and their association with other grains and fossils are valuable criteria in recognizing depositional settings on platforms, slopes and basins (Fig. 4.17). Reservoir rocks Micritic oncolitic limestones are regarded as poor reservoir rocks, but exceptions are known, e.g. oncoid limestones associated with microbial reef carbonates (Late Jurassic Smackover Formation in the eastern Gulf Region: Becher and Moore 1979),and productive Cretaceous platform carbonates of Texas (Bebout et al. 1979) and offshore Brazil (Carozzi and Falkenhein 1983). The critical differentiation of oncoids and other coated grains is important; misleading environmental interpretations and exploration targets may result if oncolites are confused with subaerial fabrics (Gerhard 1985).
Rhodoids and Macroids
carbonate intervals (Raibl Formation). Oncolite beds appear in several cycles, but are concentrated at the base and near the top of the shaly-sandy sequence. These beds have a thickness of some centimeters to several meters and alternate with coquina limestones and lime mudstones. Lower and upper oncolite beds differ in the size and growth forms of the oncoids, the material used as nuclei, and the biotic associations (bivalves, foraminifera, echinoderms, ammonites). The size of the oncoids found near the base of the sequence increases from the base to the top. Most oncoids are cyanoids and composite oncoids built by Giwanella and encrusting foraminifera. The laminae correspond to the lamination Types 1 and 4; calcareous laminae alternate with clay laminae. The upper horizon is a marly finely bioclastic oncoid packstone (Fig. 4.18B) with average oncoid sizes of rarely > 10 mm. Most oncoids 2-3 mm thick, between 3 and 15 mm long. The growth forms of the ellipsoidal porostromate and composite oncoids correspond to Types C, R, and L; the lamination pattern to Types 1 , 2 and 4 (Fig. 4.15). Similar to the lower oncoid horizon, oncoid sizes increase towards the top. Oncoid growth was terminated by strong terrigenous
input. Both oncoid horizons can be laterally followed for more than 200 kilometers. The depositional environment is interpreted as deeper subtidal lagoons with reduced sedimentation: Quiet-water conditions are indicated by the association with marly sediments and the frequency of large lobate and asymmetrical oncoids. Adeeper setting is indicated by the common association with crinoids and echinoids (which also provide most nuclei). In some regions, the oncoid originated in well-lit areas behind local ooid shoals. Microfacies and stratigraphic sequence suggest a general deepening-upward trend for these sections, whereby the oncoid beds mark regional sequence boundaries related to global sea-level rises during the Middle and Late Carnian. 4.2.4.2 Rhodoids and Macroids Rhodoids are unattached nodules composed predominantly of free-living encrusting calcareous red algae. Cenozoic rhodoids are commonly composed of coralline algae with High-Mg calcite skeletons (Pl. 54/1),
Fig. 4.19. Composite red algal-foraminiferal rhodoid (A).The nucleus is a rhodoid clast exhibiting slightly columnar growth forms. The outer part of the nodule is characterized by alternating concentric layers of encrusting acervulinid foraminifera (light laminae; C, D) and laminar coralline algae (dark laminae; E). The thickness of the foraminifera1 laminae varies conspicuously. Macroborings (B) are restricted to the rhodoid clast, indicating lithification prior to the settlement of encrusting foraminifera. The borings are infilled with fie-grained and peloidal sediment. The lengths of these commonly ellipsoidal nodules range from 10 to 70 mm, and are frequently between 30 and 50 mm. The widths range from 5 to 30 mm (frequently 10-20 mm). Modem acervulinid foraminifera and acervulinid macroids preferentially occur in deeper waters of reef slopes down to about 70 m. Similar water depths are inferred for the rhodoid floatstones represented by the sample. These white- to cream-colored rhodoid limestones are widely used as decorative stones in the Mediterranean area. Tertiary: Northern Italy.
Rhodoids and Macroids
sea-level fluctuations is an important factor for the biotic composition and internal growth patterns of rhodoids. Water temperature controls the composition of algal communities and their biogeographic distribution. Hydrodynamic energy is regarded as another very important ecological factor for rhodoid distribution. It controls external and internal growth forms and the sucDistribution of modern rhodoids: Rhodoids are cess of taxonomic successions. Salinity control is of known from tropical and subtropical, temperate and minor importance, because most calcareous coralline polar seas. Living rhodoids occur in intertidal pools red algae are adapted to normal marine environments. (Wehrmann et al. 1995) to subtidal shelves below nor- The co-existence of corallines and cyanobacteria, howmal wave base, down to depths of more than 200 m. ever, indicates the possibility that brackish-water conDeeper-water settings are often dominated by macroids ditions can also be tolerated (Richter and Sedat 1983). Vertical accretion rates are high for tropical rhodoids (e.g. outer Florida shelf: Prager and Ginsburg 1989). In tropical warm-water settings rhodoids (30 OS to (about 1-2 mmlyear) and an order of magnitude lower 20 ON) occur in shallow-water environments (lagoons, for temperate and deeper-water rhodoids (Matsuda tidal channels, reef flats, back-reef areas; seagrass beds), 1989). Growth rates of thin and thick crusts depend at shelf margins as well as in deeper forereef environ- strongly on the effect of grazing herbivorous organments on terraces (Minoura and Nakamori 1982; isms (Steneck 1985). Scoffi et al. 1985; Gischler and Pisera 1999).The common lower limit in the tropics is about 80 m, but living How to describe rhodoids and macroids? The methods for analyzing of modem and Tertiary rhodoids also occur in depths between 160 and 180 m, too (pers. comm. W.-Chr. Dullo). Temperate rhodoids rhodoids and macroids are firmly established (Bosellini are known from the warm-temperate Mediterranean Sea and Ginsburg 1971; Bosence 1983a, 1983b, 1991).The in depths between about 35 and 150 m (e.g. Basso main criteria are external shape, internal growth pat1998), and from the transition between tropical and tem- terns, size, and the biotic composition of the cortices. perate waters off southern Queensland between 50 and In addition, nuclei types and associated fauna are of 110 m (Lund et al. 2000). These rhodoids contribute to importance. Box 4.12 summarizes the features which the widely distributed rhodalgal facies which inter- should be checked. fingers with the bryomol facies (Sect. 12.2). On rocky coastal slopes of the cool-temperate Atlantic, living External shapes and internal growth patterns: The rhodoids grow in depths between about 20 and 40 m, external shape depends on the internal growth patterns in higher latitudes between 5 to 25 m (TromsolNor- of the algae, and the frequency of turning (Braga and way: pers. cornm. A. Freiwald). A characteristic sedi- Martin 1988). Growth forms are apparently controlled ment consisting of coralline algal branches, rhodoids by the frequency of overturning. Increasing overturnand their detritus, is 'maerl' (Sect. 2.4.4.3). Wide and ing causes flattening of branches which join laterally. thick accumulations of rhodoids with only few detritus In tropical and subtropical climates branched rhodoids are called 'rhodolith pavements'. In polar regions liv- are formed in shallow and quiet waters; in sheltered ing corallinacean algae were reported from depths be- areas they are spherical; in higher energy areas flattween 60 m to about 100 m (Svalbard shelf: Andruleit tened ellipsoidal shapes dominate. Rhodoliths with conet al. 1996; northern Norwegian shelf). These rhodoids, sistent internal growth patterns indicate stable environhowever, exhibit only thin crusts. mental conditions and/or fast growth. Ellipsoidal, spheSome caution is necessary in a too rigorous use of roidal and laminar growth patterns are generally con'modem' rhodoids for paleobathymetrical interpreta- sidered to be indicative of higher water energy. Discoitions, as seen in originally Pleistocene 'relic rhodoids' dal and flat external forms, and branching and columwhich formed in shallow-marine settings and now are nar internal growth forms are common in low-energy found in deep-water settings (e.g. South African shelf: environments (Piller and Rasser 1996). Siesser 1972). Size: Modem rhodoids range in size from 10 to about Controls: The most important control on the growth 250 mm, more frequently from about 10 to 100 mm. of coralline algae and the formation of rhodoids is light. Ancient coralline rhodoids have about the same size. Light intensity is correlated with water depth and geo- The size of ancient rhodoids appears to be strongly congraphic latitude. A change in water depth combined with trolled by the composition of the algal communities
but peyssoneliacean red algae with aragonitic skeletons (Pl. 64/10) can be of importance, too (Basso 1990). Late Paleozoic rhodoids were formed by ancestral red algae (Pl. 56). Centimeter-sizedunattached nodules, predominantly consisting of encrusting organisms other than coralline algae (e.g. foraminifera), are called macroids.
Describing Rhodoids
139
Box 4.12. How to describe rhodoids? A combination of field and laboratory criteria is recommended. Arrows indicate palecological indications and clues for interpreting paleo-environmental and depositional settings. Field criteria Depositional regime: Predominantly carbonate, mixed siliciclastic-carbonate or siliciclastic? Position of rhodoid beds in the section: Occurrence within defined horizons (-> event beds, part of shallowing or deepening upward sequences). Repetitive occurrence (-> cyclic patterns)? Occurrence in mud-dominated or grain-dominated limestones. (-> different settings, water depths and environmental controls)? Abundance and distribution of rhodoids: Either more than or less than 50% of rock volume (-> rhodolite or rhodoidbearing limestone). Densely packed (grain-to-grain contacts) or scattered? Color of rhodoids and matrix (-> differences in composition and/or weathering)? Sedimentary structures: Bedding, cross-bedding, bioturbation, grading, parallel orientation, imbrication, geopetal structures (-> movement of rhodoids)? Field and laboratory criteria Limestone texture: Wackestone/floatstone, packstone, grainstone/rudstone, bindstone? Microfabrics: Single or multiple rhodoids Composite rhodoids (e.g. algal-foraminifera1 macroids)? Orientation of rhodoids and other grains (-> current transport?) Size ranges, average, frequency distribution, sorting (-> micro-, meso- or macroids)? Variations in shape, sphericity, surface and growth forms (symmetrical, asymmetrical) of rhodoids (-> hydrodynamic conditions)? Association with ooids andlor lithoclasts (-> reworking of rhodoids)? Associated fossils? Laboratory criteria Geopetal fabrics in rlzodoids (-> overturning during growth)? Shape, external growth forms and sphericity: Spheroidal, ellipsoidal, discoidal (Folk and Sneath triangle diagram (-> hydrodynamic energy; environmental and biological controls). Symmetric or asymmetric growth? Contorted rhodoids? Swface: Smooth, bumpy, grooved, lobate; conspicuously round or rounded; bored; encrusted; surface preserved or eroded (-> reworking and redeposition)? Internnl growth patterns: Laminar, branched, columnar, globular; densely or openly spaced branches (-> hydrodynamic energy). Mixed or multi-stage microfabrics? Layers and lamination: Configuration (concentric or non-concentric, continuous or discontinuous); thin or thick lamina crusts? Size: Dominating sizes, ranges and distribution; arithmetic mean diameter: (long + intermediate + short axis lengths):3. Biotic composition of coatings: Taxonomic inventory (-> paleo-water depths), mono- or multispecific morphotypes including shape and size, abundance of different groups, rhodoid diversity in relation to rhodoid size, type and frequency of encrusting organisms; comparison with organisms occurring outside the rhodoids (-> biological controls, continuous/discontinuous growth, selective biota) Ecologic successions and growth patterns of rhodoids: Changes in basic microfabrics and biotic contribution (-> changes in environmental factors) Borings: Totally or partially bored (-> hard and soft stages) Cracks within the oncoids: Type, frequency, infilling (-> desiccation, syn- or post-depositional origin) Nucleus: Present or absent; single or several nuclei; size; composition (bioclast, lithoclast, other grains; fragments of coralline algae); preservation of nuclei; comparison of nuclei and non-oncoid grains with regard to grain types and biotic diversity (identical, different -> autochthonous/allochthonous rhodoids) Cortex and nucleus: Size and ratio; different thickness of cortex on the top and bottom of the rhodoids (-> in-situ growth)? Associated fauna?
such as shown by different sizes of Late Paleozoic Archaeolithoporella and Archaeolithophyllum rhodoids. Biotic composition: Taxonomic successions may be the result of a change in rhodolith size: the larger the size, the higher the stability of communities over time.
But whether the succession of algal species represents changing environments or a change in rhodolith size is still an open question. Monospecific branching rhodoids occur both in temperate and arctic waters as well as in tropical environments.
140
Ancient rhodoids and macroids Most fossil rhodoids are known from Tertiary shelf carbonates and reefs (Box 4.13). Coralline algae appear in the Late Jurassic. Only a few rhodoids have been reported from the Cretaceous (e.g. Early Cenomanian solenoporacean-corallinaceanrhodoids, reef flat facies). Late Carboniferous and Permian rhodoids (PI. 5618) differ from Cenozoic rhodoids in their preference for near-coastal, very shallow settings.
Cyanoids and Rhodoids
Significance of rhodoids in microfacies analysis Rhodalgal limestones represented by shelf carbonates and reefs with large contributions of coralline algae are, volumetrically, the most important facies in the Miocene Mediterranean (Esteban 1996). The rhodalgal-type grain associations are indicative of platforms developing in temperate seas or in subtropical to tropic areas with anomalous (e.g. cooler, eutrophic, upwelling) conditions (Carannante and Simone 1996; Sect. 12.2).
Plate 12 Cyanoids and Rhodoids: Cyanobacterial and Red Algal Nodules Cyanoids (-> 1) are a specific type of porostromate oncoids, characterized by recognizable tubular microstructures which can be attributed to calcified cyanobacteria. Cyanoids are common constituents of Paleozoic shallow-marine limestones. Rhodoids (rhodoliths; -> 6) are nodules formed by encrusting (mainly rhodophycean) red algae. The freeliving encrusting calcareous algae exhibit characteristic finely meshwork structures (see P1. 54). Other organisms contributing to the formation of nodules are encrusting foraminifera that form centimeter-sized macroids. Living rhodoids occur in tropical, temperate and polar settings and are found from tidal zones down to more than 200 m. They contribute to the formation of platforms, ramps and reefs. Ancient rhodalgal-typegrain associations are often indicative of platforms formed in temperate seas or in subtropical to tropic areas, sometimes with anomalous (e.g. cool-water, upwelling and nutrient-rich) conditions. Diagnostic descriptive criteria are the external shape, internal growth patterns, size ranges, and the biotic composition of the cortices. In addition, nuclei types and the associated fauna are of importance. The growth form and shape are controlled by hydrodynamic factors, the biotic composition by light intensity and competition with herbivorous organisms. Cyanoids, a group of skeletal oncoids formed by calcified porostromate cyanobacteria (see P1.53). Cores are platy phylloid calcareous algae (see P1. 58). Note the irregular discoidal shape of the oncoids and breaks in growth of layers. The elliptical shape of the grains depends on the shape of the nuclei; the laminae form concentrically around the cores (Type C oncoid, Radwanski and Szulszewski 1966). Oncoid sizes in the oncolitic bed vary between about 5 mm and 1 cm and are within the range of piso- and macro-oncoids. Associated fossils are coated fusulinid foraminifera. SMF 13. Openmarine inner platform. Early Permian (Asselian): Carnic Alps, Austria/Italy. Micrite oncoids produced by micritization of microbial oncoids, aggregate grains and peloids. Oncoid nuclei are shells and foraminifera. Note solution void filled with silt (arrow). Open-marine platform. Early Jurassic (Pantokrator Limestone): Peleponnesus, Greece. Porostromate oncoids composed of Rothpletzella (see P1. 1213). These microfossils (attributed to green algae or to cyanobacteria) are common constitutents of Devonian open-marine and semi-restricted shelf limestones and reefs. They occur together with lamellar stromatoporoids and contribute to the formation of boundstones. Note the alternation of black (with tubular fossils) and white sparry laminae. Forereef slope. Late Devonian (Frasnian): Canning Basin, Australia. Two-stage oncoid. The nucleus, a chaetetid coralline sponge is surrounded by an unlaminated meshwork corresponding to Bacinella (imterpreted as microbial in origin). Lamination is only developed at the periphery of the spherical oncoid. The grain is interlinked with other Bacinella oncoids, forming a framework texture together with corals and coralline sponges. High-energy subtidal environment of a carbonate platform. Late Jurassic (Plassen Limestone, Tithonian): Krahstein, Styria, Austria. Modern soft lacustrine oncoid composed of cyanobacteria and green algae. The asymmetrical shape and the dome-like pattern of the laminae point to in-situ growth of the oncoid. The small micritic grains result from disintegration of the oncoids by waves and frosting during winter. The oncoids from Lake Constance are restricted to near-shore areas. There are two types, one smooth and hard, the other soft and exhibiting a spongy fabric. Soft oncoids occur embedded in a substrate of a sandy flat covered by 0.5 to 1.5 m water. Gnadensee, Lake Constance, southern Germany. Sphaeroidal, laminar rhodoid formed by alternating crusts of corallinacean red algae (black) and encrusting foraminifera (white chambers). Note serpulid worms (S). The nucleus of the rhodoid is a poritid coral. Shallow subtidal back-reef environment. Early Tertiary: Lower Austria. Brackish-water oncoids. The elliptical oncoids were formed by weakly calcified cyanobacteria and algae. Smaller particles are algal peloids and coated grains. Note discontinuous laminae and shrinkage structures within the oncoids (arrow). The recrystallized nucleus was initially coated by dense dark and light concentric laminae. The layers of the second growth stage follow the shape of the first growth stage. SMF 22.Coastal pond. Late Jurassic (Lusitanian): near Fatima, Portugal.
Plate 12: C y a n o i d s and Rhodoids
141
Ooids: Terminology
4.2.5 Ooids Box 4.13. Selected case studies of ancient rhodoid limestones. A comprehensive list of references dealing with
modem and ancient corallinacean red algae can be found in the Intemet (http//paleoweb.net/algae).
As an introduction first let us show you some especially beautiful examples from the Early Triassic of Germany. Diameter of ooids: 0.4 rnm.
Pleistocene: Hills and Jones 2000; Minoura and
Nakamori 1982; Richter and Sedat 1983. Tertiary:Adey 1979;Adey and Macintyre 1973; Bassi
1995; Borrouilh-Le Jan and Hottinger 1988;Bosence and Pedley 1982; Boulanger and Poignant 1975; Braga and Martin 1988; Buchbinder 1977; Burgess and Anderson 1983; Dabrio et al. 1981; Dullo 1983; Esteban 1996;Fravega et al. 1993,1998; Friebe 1988; Llombart 1982; Manker and Carter 1987; Martin et al. 1993; Maslov 1962; Moussavian and Hofling 1993; Nebelsick and Bassi 2000; Orszag-Sperber et al. 1977;Pedley 1996;Perrin 1992; Penin et al. 1995; Pisera and Studencki 1989; Plaziat and Pemn 1992; Rasser 1994;Sirnoneand Carannante 1985;Studencki 1988; Vanucci et al. 1993, 1994a, 1994b, 1996. Cretaceous: Reitner 1987. Carboniferous and Permian: Johnson 1946; Toomey
1975,1983, 1985. Ooids have long been recognized as the most inThe environmental interpretation of rhodoid-rich triguing constituents of carbonate rocks (Sorby 1879; limestones in the geological record must necessarily Kalkowsky 1908; Fig. 4.21). For a long time ooids were start with the appropriate choice of the present-day cli- regarded as chiefly 'inorganic' grains, but strong biomatic model. The composition, growth forms and zo- logical controls on the formation of ooids are evident nation of rhodoids and macroids are excellent facies (Fig. 4.24). Microfabrics, the mineralogy, abundance indicators, but the risks of a too simple use of rhodoid and size of ooids reflect physical and chemical condidata for paleoecological studies should be considered tions of depositional environments in marine and nonmarine settings. Ooids, therefore, are valuable paleoen(Reid and Macintyre 1988). Rhodoids have been successfully used for estimat- vironmental proxies for water energy, temperature, saing paleo-water depths (e.g. Pemn et al. 1995; Basso linity and water depths. The paleoenvironmental inter1998), and evaluating sea-level fluctuations (Adey pretation of ancient ooids, however, should be done with 1986; Bourrouilh-Le Jan and Hottinger 1988; Freiwald some caution because (a) present-day marine Bahaet al. 1991; Basso and Tomaselli 1994). In a geological mian-type ooids formed in turbulent environments are section, variations in shape, size, algal communities and not necessarily analogues of ancient ooids, and (b) the associated sedimentary features of rhodoids commonly transport of ooids from the areas in which they were reflect changes and temporal trends in depths and wa- produced to the depositional areas is often underestiter energy (Braga and Martin 1988). The biotic com- mated. Changes in mineralogy and abundance of ooids position of macroids reflect depth-controlled distribu- over time have been related to changes in atmospheric tional patterns (Hottinger 1983; Piller and Pervesler 1989; carbon dioxide or to the rate of sea-level change and Plaziat and Perrin 1992;Moussavian and Hofling 1993). used as indicators of global secular variations in Phanerozoic climates. Valuable reviews on modem and anEconomic importance: Limestones with abundant cient ooids were provided by Simone (1981) and Richrhodoids are popular decorative stones for exterior and ter (1983). Oolites (calcareous rocks composed of oointerior use because of their pleasing appearance and ids) formed on marine platforms and ramps comprise resistance to abrasion. Rhodoid floatstones, formed in more than 50% of the world's carbonate hydrocarbon lagoonal and reef environments, are common in Oli- reservoirs. gocene and Miocene platform carbonates containing hydrocarbon rocks, for example in Indonesia, the Phil- Terminology ippines and the South China Sea (e.g. Grotsch and Ooids are spherical and egg-shaped carbonate or Mercadier 1999). non-carbonate coated grains exhibiting a nucleus sur-
Ooids: Shape and Size
rounded by an external cortex, the outer part of which is concentrically smoothly laminated. Most ooids are smaller than 2 rnm in diameter; many ooids between 0.5 and about 1 mm in size. Modem calcareous ooids consist of aragonite and/or calcite. The bestknown noncarbonate ooids are iron ooids. The cortices of ooids exhibit a variety of microfabrics caused by different orientations of carbonate crystals in the laminae. Tangentially or randomly arranged crystals form tangential ooids (usually aragonite; P1.313, P1.12011, P1.1361 7), radially arranged crystals form radial-fibrous ooids (High-Mg calcite andlor aragonite; P1. 1312, P1. 12012, P1. 13013).Micrite ooids are spherical grains composed of a nucleus and a micritic cortex, in places exhibiting a vague concentric structure (Pl. 1315, 6; P1. 13417). Spheroids are small grains composed predominantly of radially arranged fibrous crystals. Comparison with other grains Oncoids exhibit a more irregular, often non-concentric lamination; many oncoids are considerably larger than ooids. Pisoids are characterized by concentric laminae, but differ from ooids in their larger size (usually several millimeters) and often very irregular shape. Criteria Descriptive criteria providing clues to the environmental conditions and the depositional setting of ooid formation are the microfabric of the cortex, nuclei types, the shape and size of the ooid, associated fossils and sedimentary textures.
Shape and size: Ooids occur as single or compound (complex) ooids (PI. 13617). The latter consist of two or more ooids bound together to form the nuclei for a new larger ooid (polyooid). 'Multiple ooids' result from the intergrowth of several ooids. Most ooids are spherical, but egg-shaped ooids are also common. The shape often results from the shape of the nuclei. Size and sorting provide clues to the hydrodynamic conditions. Ooid size is controlled by the supply of nuclei (Bathurst 1975), growth rate (Swett and Knoll 1989), mobilization and agitation (Carozzi 1989) and abrasion (Medwedeff and Wilkinson 1983). The maximum size of most ooids (about 1 mm) may reflect a balance between growth and abrasion. Experiments suggest that size differences between radial ooids and radial-concentric ooids may be explained by ooid transport processes (Davies et al. 1978). Heller et al. (1980) observed a critical size associated with a change in radial ooids to tangential ooids at 0.6 mm; this probably reflects a change in the mode of transport from suspension to bed load. Computer-based models demonstrate that a
low supply of new nuclei and high cortex growth rate both promote the growth of large ooids. High average water velocity and velocity gradients also enhance ooid growth (Sumner and Grotzinger 1993). Conspicuously large ooids appear to be more abundant in Precambrian open-marine carbonates than in Phanerozoic carbonates (Pl. 1618). Neoproterozoic giant ooids may have formed through a combination of lower nuclei supply (because of the lack of skeletal fragments during the Precambrian), higher growth rate, and higher average agitation level (which might be caused by a predominance of carbonate ramps over rimmed carbonate platforms during the Neoproterozoic; Sumner and Grotzinger 1993). A useful method for determinating the true grain size of ooids in thin sections was suggested by Fabricius (1967).
Nucleus and cortex: Nuclei include lithoclasts, peloids, skeletal grains and minerals, e.g. quartz grains. Fecal pellets are common nuclei, particularly of ooids formed in low-energy environments (Jones and Goodbody 1984). Carozzi (1960) drew attention to the frequent association of ooids and rounded elliptical or spherical micritic grains representing rounded bio- or lithoclasts (Fig. 4.25). These grains (called 'pseudooolites') also occur as nuclei of ooids and indicate a long abrasion phase prior to overgrowth by ooid laminae. The cortex/nucleus ratio is an important descriptive criterion of ooids. Superficial ooids (Carozzi 1957) are ooids, in which the thickness of the cortex is distinctly less than half of the diameter of the entire ooids (Pl. 311, P1.2916). 'Normal' ooids are characterized by a cortex whose thickness is equal or greater than half the diameter of the ooid. Superficial ooids often only reveal one or two laminae. Very thin oolitic films are a common feature of Bahamian ooids (Bathurst 1967). The average thickness of ooid laminae is 1-3 km. Cortex thickness is related to environmental controls, particularly hydrodynamic factors. Small nuclei tend to have thick coatings, that probably form quickly, because smaller grains are more easily put into motion. Larger grains which are seldom moved have only superficial coatings or no coating at all (Bahamian ooids, Harris 1979). Mineralogy and microfabric (Fig. 4.20): The cortex of modem ooids consists of aragonite, Mg-calcite or calcite. Aragonite and Mg-calcite can co-occur in alternating laminae within one and the same ooid (Land
Ooids: Structural Types
et al. 1979; Major et al. 1988). These mineralogies formed ooids in the Precambrian (Tucker 1984) and during much of the Phanerozoic. Cortical microfabrics: Most modem aragonitic ooids formed in high-energy marine environments exhibit a concentric or tangential microfabric, which is rarely well preserved in ancient concentric tangential ooids. Marine low-energy ooids are characterized by a radial-fibrous fabric which is also known from hypersaline environments and Low-Mg calcite ooids formed in freshwater environments. The original mineralogy of ancient ooids is inferred from preserved fabrics, owing to the fact that diagenetic calcification of aragonite typically results in obliteration of textural details, whereas ooids exhibiting radial arrangement of acicular crystals point to original calcite mineralogies (Kahle 1974).
Radial ooids (Pl. 13/2,4) are characterized by a cortical fabric consisting of radial-fibrous crystals. In most cortices this microfabric also exhibits concentric banding (radial-concentric, banded radial), but banding may be absent in small ooids with an average diameter of
Concentric
(tangential)
about 0.3 mm. The radial-fibrous structure of ancient calcitic ooids is considered to be primary because of the similarities to the microfabric of modem High-Mg calcite radial ooids from Baffin Bay, Texas (Land et al. 1979),the Amazon Shelf (Milliman and Barretto 1975), and from deep waters of the Great Barrier Reef (Marshall and Davies 1975). The significantly higher Mg content of radial calcite ooids as compared with tangential ooids may be suggestive of a High-Mg calcite precursor and a transformation of High-Mg calcite to Low-Mg calcite without destruction of microstructures. This primary radial microfabric must be distinguished from a secondary radial structure resulting from a diagenetic overprint on primary radial and concentric ooids (Marshall and Davies 1975). This structure transects the concentric laminae. The radially oriented large crystals may extend to the outer surface of the ooid or they may be limited to parts of the cortex. Traces of concentric layering can be preserved within the radially oriented crystals.
Micrite ooids often occur together with other ooid types. The micritic fabric may be restricted to certain
Microfabric of the cortex
Mineralogy, modern examples
Environment
Concentric laminae consisting of tangentially arranged crystals whose long axes are aligned to the surface of the laminae. High microporosity
Aragonite: Bahamas, Yucatan, Abu Dhabi, Persian Gulf
Very shallow, warm lowlatitudinal seas; common in
(Great Salt LakeIUtah) Low-Mg calcite: Caliche ooids*
Radial
(radial-fibrous) ooids
Laminae consisting of radially arranged crystals; long crystal axes perpendicular to the laminae surface
high-energy settings
Terrestrial
Shallow marine, common in Aragonite: Persian Gulf, Great Barrier Reef, (Yucatan low-energy sellings Shark Bay, Mediterranean) Gulf of Aqaba Great Salt LakelUtah
Sea-marginalhypersaline pool Lacustrine-hypersaline
Mg-calcite: (Baffin Bayflexas)
Micritic (random Laminae composed of randomly arranged microcrystalline crystal: ooids
Calcite and Low-Mg calcite: e.g. Cave pearls* Aragonite: Bahamas
Non-marine
or Laminae obliterated or absent, due to a pervasive micritization of the cortex
Fig. 4.20. Major structural ooid types. Concentric or tangential ooids originate commonly in high-energy settings; radial or radial-fibrous ooids are formed in moderate to low-energy environments. Well-preserved radial-fibrous fabrics of ancient ooids are generally regarded as primary features that have not been structurally changed over the course of transformation of High-Mg calcite to Low-Mg calcite. Micritic ooids can be generated by the random growth of crystals, or the micritic appearance of the ooids is caused by obliteration of original tangential or radial microfabrics by micritization and recrystallization of the cortex. Locality names put in brackets refer to places where ooids are rare; asterisks refer to terrestrial grains, which some authors call ooids, but which are treated as a separate grain category (pisoids, see Sect. 4.2.6) in this book.
Ooids: Structural Types
145
1 mrn
Fig. 4.21. The drawings, taken from the fundamental paper by Sorby (1879),demonstrate two basic microfabricsfound in ancient ooids and interpreted as being formed under different hydrodynamic conditions. A - Ferruginous tangential concentric ooids, which were repeatedly broken during formation. The nuclei are bioclasts (network structure: bryozoans) and fragments of ooids. The microfabric of the ooids is characterized by tangentially oriented crystals forming distinctly concentric laminae. The ooids occur together with small bioclasts and bivalve shells (top right) and angular terrigenous quartz grains. B - Single and compound radial-fibrous ooids formed around bioclasts, rounded clasts and peloids (black) as well as small oncoids (top left). The microfabric of the light-colored laminae is characterized by radially oriented fibrous crystals. Skeletal grains are echinoderms (top right) and mollusk shells. Note grain-support fabric and high open interparticleporosity. Middle Jurassic (A - Inferior Oolite, B - Great Oolite, Bathonian): Southern England. Primary sedimentary structures observed in the oolitic limestones of the Great Oolite Series suggest deposition in a tidal flat channel system (Klein 1965). The Great Oolite forms a hydrocarbon reservoir. The type of ooid fabric controls the distribution and amount of intragranular porosity (Sellwood and Beckett 1991).
laminae or it occurs everywhere in the cortex of originally calcitic or originally aragonitic ooids. Aragonite ooids can be transformed to micritic and microsparitic ooids by in-situ calcitization (Popp and Wilkinson 1983, Friedel 1995). In thin sections micrite ooids appear dark, featureless and microcrystalline. The micritic fabric results from the activity of microborers (PI. 1316) or from recrystallization, leading to a microgranularmosaic consisting of small calcite crystals (2-10 pm), and displaying neither concentric nor radial microfabrics. Fossils in ooids and oolitic limestones Oolitic limestones are either poor in fossils or they contain specific fossil assemblages. The composition of autochthonous fossil assemblages in grainstones is constrained primarily by sediment stability. A decrease in faunal diversity commonly correlates with increased sediment mobility (Feldman et al. 1993).The common absence or rarity of sessile or even mobile benthos in oolitic limestones suggests that periods of stabilization were not long enough for shelled organisms. Highly unstable and constantly shifting substrates are inhabited by only a few shelly benthos. Macrofossil assem-
blages can provide a powerful guide for estimating sediment stability when used in conjunction with the analysis of microfacies and sedimentary structures. Encrusting microfossils occurring upon ooids and enclosed within ooids indicate short-term stable conditions during the growth of the ooids (Fig. 4.22). Most common are encrustations by foraminifera (PI. 1313). Calcareous micro-algae in ooids are valuable environmental indicators (Dragastan and Richter 1999). Specific ooid types Fig. 4.23 summarizes a few ooid types characterized by specific morphology. Syndepositionally formed grains are cerebroid, eccentric, broken and regenerated as well as part of the distorted ooids. Some distorted ooids as well as half-moon and spiny ooids originate from diagenetic processes, the latter two by early diagenesis. Significantly deformed ooids are of tectonic origin. Modem ooids Modem ooids originate in marine and non-marine settings. Marine ooids occur in intertidal and shallow
146
Modern Ooids
Fig. 4.22. Microfossils within and on ooids. A - Ooids offering a hard substrate for encrusting organisms. In areas dominated by mobile calcareous sands, ooids and bioclasts often are the only substrates available for encrusting organisms, particularly foraminifera. Note the multi-stage structure of the ooid. Ooid growth started on a nucleus formed by an mid. The development of radial-fibrous laminae was disturbed by the encrustation of foraminifera, followed by a new set of laminae with radial-fibrous microfabric. The outer part of the mid exhibits a tangential-concentric microfabric reflecting the change to more agitated water energy. The strong overgrowth by nubeculariid foraminifera indicates the absence of grain transport. Late Triassic (Carnian): Central Carinthia, Austria. B - Fossils as ooid nuclei. Due to the high mobility of ooid grains, oolitic limestones are commonly poor in autochthonous fossils. Exceptions are microfossils occurring as ooid nuclei, e.g. benthic foraminifera which provide clues to the age of oolites and their depositional environment. The nucleus of the radial ooid is an endothyranid foraminifera.Early Carboniferous (Kirchbach limestone, VisCan): Carnic Alps, Austria. Scale is 1 mm.
subtidal marine environments. Non-marine ooids are known from lacustrine and terrestrial sediments. Some of these 'ooids' are pisoids (Sect. 4.2.6). Ooids form in wave-agitated regions of the seas (high-energy ooids), and in marginal-marine or non-marine low-energy settings ('quiet-water ooids'). Excellent examples of modem marine ooids (Box 4.14) include those from the Bahamas, the Persian Gulf, the Red Sea and the Great Banier Reef. Very important studies on ooids formed in a hypersaline setting have been carried out in the Great Salt Lake in Utah, in coastal pools of the Gulf of Suez, and the southern Red Sea. The Quaternary ooid sand shoals of the Bahama Bank originate and accumulate in different subenvironments, including mobile fringes, sand flats, tidal channels, platform shelfs, open margins, and platform interiors. The shoals consist of long and narrow or spillover bars and tidal channels that trend nearly perpendicular to the length of the shoal. Tidal flow and wavegenerated current cause the ooid sands to be in motion over the entire width of the shoal. On average ooids range in diameter from about 0.25 to 1.OO mm and very rarely exceed 2 mm. The variations in the depositional settings are produced by a decrease in grain agitation from the ocean-facing margin of the interior of the ooid shoals. Local variations relate to topography and the stabilization of the sea bottom by vegetation. The main environments differ in the composition, abundance and
association of carbonate grains, the distribution patterns of organisms, as well as the type and frequency of physical and biogenic sedimentary structures. Ooids occur together with peloids, aggregate grains and skeletal grains. The distribution of ooid sand shoals is restricted to high-energy zones along open bank margins. Highenergy deposits are tidal-current or wind-wave-generated (Wanless and Tedesco 1993). Tidal-current generated sands are characterized by ooid growth in water depths ranging from less than 1 m to as much as 10 m. Well-developed tangential ooids originate in marine sand belts, tidal bar belts, floodtidal belts and in areas stabilized by algae and seagrass. Tide-dominated ooid sand bodies have been studied in the Bahamas and in the Persian Gulf (summarized in Halley et al. 1983). Examples of ancient oolites formed in tidally influenced zones are known from the Mississippian (Smosna and Koehler 1993) and Jurassic oolites of southern England (Klein 1965, Wilson 1968). Wind-wave-generated oolitic sands (southeastern Bahamas, Caicos platform) contrast strongly with tidalgenerated oolitic sands, restricted to shoals near the platform margins (northern Bahamas). Wind-wave generated sands are characterized by thick and widespread sheet-like ooid grainstones. Regular spherical, tangential ooids form stratified deposits on wind-wave agitated shallow subtidal shoreface settings on the platform interior, and on ocean-wave-agitated shorefaces facing the platform margin. Irregularly shaped ooids
Ooid Formation
147
Box 4.14. Selected case studies of modern marine and non-marine ooids. Note that Mediterranean references also include studies of Early Holocene and reworked Pleistocene relict ooids. Marine environments: Bahamas - Ball 1967; Bathurst 1967,1968;Carney and Boardman 1993; Cros 1979; Fabricius 1977; Gektidis 1997;Harris 1979,1983; Illing 1954; Loreau 1982; Newel1 et al. 1960; Purdy 1963; Reitner et al. 1997; Strasser and Davaud 1986. Caribbean - Daetwyler and Kidwell 1959; Lloyd et al. 1987; Milliman 1969; Ward and Brady 1973; Zans 1958. Persian Gulf- Friedman 1995; Loreau 1982; Loreau and Purser 1973; Nazhat 1998. Gulf of Suez - Anwar et al. 1981, 1984; Sass et al. 1972; Sneh and Friedman 1984. Mediterranean Sea - Fabricius 1970; Richter 1976. Great Barrier Reef - Flood 1983; Marshall and Davies 1975. Shark Bay, Australia - Davies 1970.
which tend to deviate from their spherical shapes and are affected by biological degradation, cementation and encrustation, form banks and widespread subtidal sheets in areas of intermittent wind-wave-agitation across the platform interior. The ultrastructure of Bahamian ooids displays tangentially arranged, subhedral needle-like crystals or anhedral rod-like crystals. In contrast, ooids of the Great Salt Lake are characterized by crystals whose long axes are arranged perpendicularly to the ooid surface (PI. 1312).These radial-fibrous ultrastructures are common in marine and hypersaline ooids. Ancient records of radial-fibrous structures were initially regarded as diagenetic products of Bahamian-type aragonitic ooids (e.g. Shearman et al. 1970), but are now recognized as primary features. Modem depositional environments of marine aragonite ooids like the Bahamian ooids are said to be chemically not representative for ancient shallow-marine environments where calcite ooids have been formed (Sandberg 1975). Large and asymmetrical ooids, which are greatly different from Bahamian-type ooids, were described from the Laguna Madre in Mexico (Rusnak 1960). Laminae with radially and tangentially arranged crystals alternate in these ooids. The formation of these low-energy or quiet-water ooids (Freeman 1962) appears to be related to the low water turbulence and to periodic variations in salinity. Low-energy ooids formed in lagoons, coastal lakes and protected shallow environments with different salinity are common in the geological record. Low-energy and high-energy controls are not necessarily separated at a clear-cut level, as demonstrated by ooid sands occumng in lagoons along the Sinai beaches of the Gulf of Suez. The ooids occur in carbonate mud; they represent wind-blown material and
Hypersaline and freshwater environments: Saline lakes -Great Salt Lake, Utah: Eardley 1938;Halley 1977;Kahle 1974; Sandberg 1975; Reitner et al. 1997. Hypersaline lakes - Baffii Bay, Texas (marine-hypersaline): Land 1970. Laguna Madre, Texas: Freeman 1962; Rusnak 1960. Pyramid Lake, Nevada: Popp and Wilkinson 1983.Sea-marginalpools, Red Sea: Friedman 1978;Friedman et al. 1973;Friedman and Krumbein 1985. Dead Sea: Garber and Friedman 1983; Garber et al. 1981. Freshwater lakes -Davaud and Girardclos 2001; Wilkinson et al. 1980, 1984.
ooids formed under low and high energy conditions, differentiated by grain size and microfabric (Sass et al. 1972). Deep-water ooids: Modem and ancient ooids also are found in deep-marine settings. The bulk of these ooids represent allochthonous shallow-water material transported into slope and basinal settings as debris flows or turbidites. 'Pelagic ooids' (see Sect. 15.8) and 'seamount ooids' are found on the top of drowned platforms and seamounts (e.g. Hesse 1973).
Controls on ooid formation The exact nature of the formation of individual ooids is still uncertain. It is generally accepted that most ooid deposits form in shallow waters which are regularly agitated over a long period of time by waves and/ or currents. Other environmental prerequisites include minimal siliciclasticinput and generally warm temperatures, common in low-latitude settings. Carbonate ooids form in settings where at least five requirements must be met: presence of nuclei, bottom agitation to move grains, a source of supersaturated water, a process of water renewal, and minimal amount of grain degradational processes. Major controls on ultra- and microstructures of ooid laminae are water chemistry, salinity and turbulence (Lippmann 1973; Loreau 1973; Fabricius 1977). The growth of radial-fibrous ooids in low-energy environments is apparently controlled by high or fluctuating salinity. This assumption is supported by experiments (Davies et al. 1978). A major and perhaps the essential
148
Specific Ooid Types
Cerebroid ooids (Graf and Lamar 1960; Carozzi 1962) Criteria: Indented periphery. Mottled appearance of the cortex. Sectors made of tangentially arranged laminae and radial micritic sectors which often start at former depressions of the nucleus surface. Occurrence: Marine and non-marine. Often associated with stromatolites. Interpretation: The indented periphery of the ooids has been explained as a result of a peripheral replacement. The formation of the micritic sectors is ascribedto bacterial dissolution and precipitation (Kahlke 1974). Asymmetrical and eccentric ooids (Gasiewicz 1984) Criteria: Small spherical and ovoid composite grains consisting of superficial ooids acting as eccentric nuclei for successively formed ooids whose growth takes place preferrentiallyupward. Alternation of very thin oolitic laminae (white) and micrite envelopes (black). Ooid size commonly < 0.30 mm. Rare in wackestones and grainstones, common in packstones, associated with abundant peloids. Eccentric ooids should not be confused with oomolds with eccentric nuclei. Occurrence: Low-energy shallow-marine lagoonal and lacustrine environments, periodically without agitation. Interpretation: The ooid laminae are explained as resulting from short periods of water agitation, the micritic envelopes correspond to longer non-turbulentperiods. Eccentric growth is controlled by changes from suspension to saltation and traction processes at the sea floor. Top: A superficial ooid formed in suspension and deposited on the sea floor is the base of a micrite envelope and forms the eccentric nucleus of a subsequent new superficial ooid. Bottom: Ongoing ooid formation subsequent to rolling and turning. Broken and regenerated ooids (Carozzi 1961a) Criteria: Fragments of radial or tangential ooids that act as nuclei for new ooids are surrounded by ooid laminae. The ooids are characterized by alternating concentric ooid laminae and micritic laminae (white). Occurrence: Common in high- and low-energy settings, occurring together with partly cracked ooids and regular ooids. Interpretation: These ooids indicate multiple synsedimentary reworking and breaks in the formation of ooids, commonly associated with redeposition. Also known from ferruginous ooids ('hiatus ooids', Berg 1944). Distorted ooids (Carozzi 1961b; Conley 1977) Criteria: Characterized by notched and stretched, sometimes flattened ooid grains, or grains connected by narrow apophyses, or series of grains linked in zigzag chaines parallel to bedding. The distortion has commonly preceded cementation and strong compaction. These ooids co-occur with other distorted grains (e.g. micritized intraclasts) in irregular pockets or in zones parallel to the bedding. Occurrence: Restrictedto specific limestone horizons, affected by strong waves or currents. Com-
&@ @
&
mon Interpretation: also in non-carbonate The shapes oolitic of distorted deposits. ooids illustrate a complete gradation from initial rupture and plastic deformation of soft grains to the rupture of rigid bodies. Explanations include fracture and plastic alteration of soft ooids in a turbulent environment, sediment sliding, or compaction. Deformation occurs when uncemented or poorly cemented ooids are buried (PI. 1318, PI. 3615). The term also is used for pitted ooids and cracked ooids which result from mechanical distortion and pressure solution. These ooids exhibit displaced and sometimes broken laminae (Pl.15OI2).
Half moon and shrunken ooids (Wherry 1916; Mazzullo 1977) Criteria: Ooids in which the interior cores have dropped to the bottom of the concentric outer layers, forming a geopetal fabric. Cross sections commonly exhibit a 'half-moon' aspect characterized by an internal dividing line convex upward which separates an upper light part (frequently calcite-filled) and a lower dark part. Occurrence: Rare in carbonate-evaporite series, but also known from meteorically influenced carbonates. Interpretation: These ooids may be products of evaporite-carbonate or aragonite solution diagenetic processes (Carozzi 1963) and may indicate vanished evaporites in associated rocks (Folk and Pittman 1971; Folk and Siedlecka 1974). Geopetal ooids, however, can also result from the selective aggrading recrystallization of the ooid nuclei during a period of meteoric diagenesis (Mazzullo 1977).
i
Spiny ooids (Davaud et al. 1990) Criteria: Characterized by external cortices exhibiting spines. The external cortices are detached from the underlying cortices near the points of contact between ooid grains, suggesting a postdepositional origin for the spines. The external cortices (white) are not stretched or broken and fit perfectly into the underlying cortices (densely arranged laminae) in undeformed areas. Occurrence: Lagoonal beach sands cemented in a vadose environment. Interpretation: The ooids are explained by tangential compressive deformation due to crystal growth in the outer cortices during early subaerial deformation. Spiny ooids differ from distorted ooids formed during burial compaction; these ooids display convex forms pointing into the pore space.
@
-
Deformed ooids (Cloos 1947; Nissen 1964; Badoux 1970) Criteria: Originally spheroidal ooids are distinctly elongated, flattened and stretched. Microfabric structures recognizeable in traces only or completely destroyed. Occurrence: Described from folded carbonate series. Indicate tectonic style and timing of plastic deformations. Interpretation: Intensive tectonic stress results in elongations parallel to the schistosity planes.
Fig. 4.23. Common specific ooid types.
Description of Ooids
control on ooid growth is the distribution and composition of organic matter and the activity of microbes (Mitterer 1972; Suess and Futterer 1972; Reitner et al. 1997).
149
environments is replaced by calcite. Dissolution starts with the dissolution within ooid laminae and continues to the formation of solution pores following the course of the laminae (Budd 1988).
The loss of internal structures in many ancient ooids is attributed to a rapid solution of aragonite due to subaerial exposure, and facilitated by the decay of organic matter. Ooid cortices consisting of coarse blocky spar or small equant crystals are interpreted as a result of calcitization including the destruction of an origiDiagenesis and porosity of ooids and oolites Early diagenetic changes of ooids include alterations nally porous aragonitic fabric and the formation of a by microborings and abrasion and processes related to coarse-grained calcite fabric (Rich 1982;Tucker 1984, the decay of organic matter. Dissolution processes oc- 1985; Friedel 1995). Originally Mg-calcite radial-ficur during fabric-selective diagenesis which is con- brous ooids transform to Low-Mg calcite via intergranutrolled by the primary mineralogy. Aragonite within lar solution/precipitationfilms (Richter 1983; Heydari ooids deposited in shallow-marine shoal and shoreface et ai. 1993). How to describe ooids? Box 4.15 summarizes the essential criteria for microfacies analyses of oolites.
Box 4.15. How to describe ooids? Check your sample! Field criteria Depositional regime: Predominantly carbonate, mixed siliciclastic-carbonate or siliciclastic? Geometry of the oolite body: Mound-shaped or sheet-like? Restricted to well defined horizons or comprising a series of limestone beds? Limestone texture: Grainstone, packstone, wackestone? Or even bindstone? Sedimentary structures (lamination, bedding, cross-bedding, -> hydrodynamic conditions)? Association with lirhoclasts and fossils? Laboratory criteria Abundance (high, medium, low, -> high abundance may indicate autochthonous ooid deposits) and distribution of ooids in the samples ( concentrated and densely packed or scattered)? Single or polyphase ooids (-> redeposition)? Major structural ooid types (tangential,radial, micritic ooids; micritic ooids with microborings or signs of recrystallization? Radial ooids with fibrous crystals cross-cutting the laminae -> diagenetic alteration)? Specific ooid types (cerebroid; asymmetrical and eccentric -> changes in growth conditions; broken and regenerated -> synsedimentary reworking and temporal breaks in ooid formation, potential hiati in sedimentation; distorted -> disruption of normal ooid formation and/or diagenetic alterations; half-moon ooids -> clues to vanished evaporites; deformed ooids -> indication and measure of tectonic stress)? Don~inatingshape (spheroidal, ellipsoidal, other)? Size and sorting (ranges, average; uni- or bimodal; median, skewness -> differentiation of autochthonous and allochthonous ooids)? Nuclei (skeletal grain, lithoclast, peloids, mineral grain; single nucleus or several nuclei; preservation and rounding of nuclei; comparison of nuclei material with the non-ooid grains in the sample)? Nucleuslcortex ratio (-> clue to hydrodynamic conditions)? Cortex (homogeneous or inhomogeneous; thickness -> superficial or normal ooid)? Ooid laminae (thickness; alternation of light and dark laminae; signs of mechanical abrasion -> pointing to high-energy conditions; detached laminae -> compaction, burial diagenesis)? Inferred primary nzineralogy based on the preservation (aragonite, calcite, bimineralic)? Fossils (acting as nuclei of the ooids, or encrusted on ooid laminae and surfaces; skeletal grains associated with the ooids)? Preservation of the ooids (partly or completely recrystallized, calcitized, dolomitized, silicified ooids; different preservation of laminae -> originally bimineralic composition; conspicuously black colored laminae or completely black ooids -> may indicate incorporation of organic matter under reduced conditions)? Cracks or ruptures within the ooids (-> shrinkage structures or burial features)? Oomolds (partly or completely leached ooids: abundance, distribution, internal sediment and cements; connecting pores).
150
Ooids
Plate 13 Ooids: Key Criteria in Microfacies Studies Ooids are spherical particles with concentric laminae coating a nucleus. Modem marine ooids consist of aragonite or High-Mg calcite, or they are bi- or polymineralic. Calcareous ooids are classified according to (a) the primary microfabric (tangential, radial, micritic), (b) number of laminae (normal ooids with many laminae, -> 3; superficial ooids with few laminae, -> 7), and (c) shapes (-> 5, 8; compound ooids). Primary microfabrics are environmentally controlled: Tangential ooids originate predominantly in high-energy environments, radial 00ids preferentially as 'quiet-water ooids' in low-energetic marine and non-marine environments (e.g. salt lakes, -> 2). Micrite ooids are caused by different processes (e.g. total micritization, -> 6; precipitation within biofilms, -> 5). Transport processes and diagenesis can change shape and composition of ooids (-> 1,4 ,7,8). Ooids are common constituents of shallow-marine carbonates, but also originate in non-marine settings, e.g. in hypersaline lakes and lagoons, and freshwater lakes. Wind-transported ooids form conspicuous eolianites. Genetic hypotheses focus on combined microbial-mechanical processes, chemical precipitation and chemical-physical processes. Current research favors strong controls by organic compounds (Morse and Mackenzie 1990). Some authors believe that microbes actively participate in the construction of ooid fabrics. Others suggest that microbes have a mainly destructive role or that they are only passively involved in building ooid layers by trapping particles or by providing a favorable substrate for nucleation of crystals. Ooids are of key importance in microfacies analysis: (a) They record paleoenvironmental conditions (water energy, transport, salinity, depositional sites), if details of microfabrics, shape and sorting are considered (Fig. 4.26; P1. 12011-2); (b) Ooids indicate changes in carbonate mineralogy and oceanographic conditions through the Phanerozoic; and (c) Oolitic limestones are important reservoir rocks for hydrocarbons, owing to high fabric-selective inter- and intragranular porosities, and contribute to the formation of ore deposits. 1 Tangentially structured, primarily Mg-calcitic ooids. The picture shows spherical ooids and 'cerebroid' ooids (arrow) with cones. The origin of cerebroid Mg-calcite ooids has been related to dissolution and precipitation by bacteria (Richter 1983). Cerebroid ooids are common in evaporitic settings (e.g. saline lakes), but also occur in marine environments. The photograph shows an original thin-section of Kalkowsky (1908) from the Rogenstein. Early Triassic (Lower Bunter): Bad Harzburg, Germany. The environment was a playa lake with variable salinity. 0oid-bearing beds are intercalated within mainly siliciclastic successions and occur in close association with laminated stromatolites. This association and the almost complete absence of fossils is characteristic for restricted brackish or saline environments.. 2 Modem aragonitic radial and radial-concentric ooids. The small and partly distorted radial ooids have nuclei made of micritic clots. The cortex consists of radially arranged crystals. The larger radial-concentric ooids (top left) are subspherical in shape. Radial-fibrous crystals build the inner part of the ooid and occur within the concentrically arranged outer laminae. Nuclei are lithoclasts and fecal pellets of the brine shrimp. The onset of radial-concentric growth is sizet Lake, Utah. This lake i s regarded as a controlled and indicates changes of low and high energy conditions. ~ i e a Salt modem scenario for ancient salt lake microbialites and a place where bimodally sorted aragonitic radial ooids are being formed under hypersaline low-energy conditions. Ooid formation takes place close to the oxic/anoxic interface within the sediment, and appears strongly controlled by the composition of organic matter of biofilms attached to the ooids. 3 Radial-fibrous ooids periodically encrusted by sessile foraminifera. The biogenic encrustations took place during phases without movement of the ooids. Note the multi-stage development of the large ooid. Ongoing encrustation would result in the formation of an oncoid. Late Triassic (Carnian): Carinthia, Austria. 4 Radial-concentric quiet-water ooids and purely radial ooids (PRO). Note the radial-fibrous structure of the large ooids characteristic for formation in low-turbulence environments and the bimodal composition. Ooids exhibit moderate compaction (C) indicated by some interpenetrating grains. Breaks in ooid growth, regenerated broken ooids (left) and healed cracks (desiccation?), differences in shapes, and meniscus cements (arrows) indicate reworking in tidal zones (Simone 1974). SMF 15-R. Early Cretaceous (Neocomian): Monte Camposauro, southern Apennines, Italy. 5 Microbial ooids, formed in situ within a microbialite (see Fig. 4.24). Thin wavy peloid laminae alternate with ooids (arrows) and peloids. The small peloid nucleus is followed by a microspar rim and an outer micrite rim. The ill-defined laminated structure and shape of these ooids in combination with the occurrence of variously sized grains is a common feature of ooids formed in situ. Similar criteria are known from ooids of Late Jurassic sponge 'reefs'. Cretaceous (Albian): Cantabria, Spain. 6 Micritized tangential ooids. The tangential fabric is only recognizable in peripheral parts of a few ooids. Note the very weak compaction. The depositional style reflects the situation 1 of the Carozzi model (Fig. 4.25), characterizing ooid formation and deposition in high energy zones. SMF 15-C. Oolite shoal, inner ramp environment. Early Carboniferous: Tournai, Belgium. 7 Weakly compacted grainstone with partly dissolved superficial ooids ('oomolds'). Note the high intragranular porosity caused by dissolution of the originally aragonitic cortices and/or nuclei. Intergranular pores are filled with granular and drusy meteoric cements (see P1.29/3,4). Pennsylvanian (Missourian): Utah, U.S.A. 8 Selectively dolomitized ooids. Note the distinct compaction of the grains indicated by the deformation of the ooids. The arrow points to distorted ooids (see Fig. 4.23). Cambrian: Yoho Valley, Rocky Mountains, British Columbia, Canada. -> 5: Neuweiler 1993
I'latc i 3 : O o ~ d s K : c) Criteria
151
1 rnrn
1 rnm
-1 rnm
152
Compaction of Ooids
Fig. 4.24. Ooids originate in low- and high-energy environments (Fig. 4/19), but also grow in situ within microbial mats (benthic ooids), e.g. in hypersaline ponds (e.g. Friedman et al. 1985, Gerdes et al. 1994). The growth of the ooids is a result of cummulative processes by biofilm attachment and subsequent aragonite encrustation. A - Microbial ooid surrounded by sheats of filamentousmats. Dark laminae represent meshworks of degraded filamentbundles of the cyanobacteriaMicrocoleus. Light laminae are extracellularpolymeric substances produced by coccoid cyanobacteria and diatoms. B -Benthic ooid as a part of an aggregate grain. The ooid consists of microcrystalline aragonitic laminae with radially arranged crystals (light)and organically enriched laminae produced by biofilms (dark). Dark laminae are usually thinner than light laminae. In contrast to marine Bahamian ooids that are controlled by hydrodynamic conditions, the nuclei of benthic ooids are rarely allochthonous grains; they normally originate from the adjacent microbial community (e.g. cell colonies) or as metabolic products, including bubbles and liquid globules. Subrecent: Salina Janubio, Lanzarote, Canary Island, Spain. Scale is 100 pm. Courtesy of G. ~erdes,Wilhelmshaven.
Porosity: Aragonite ooids are susceptible to dissolution and formation of oomoldic porosity during freshwater diagenesis; moldic porosity is generally accompanied by low permeability. Primary calcite ooids are less susceptible to dissolution in meteoric waters, hence, preserved porosity is interparticle porosity, and permeability is generally higher. The understanding of the complex time and space relationships of different porosity types of oolitic limestones is critical for reconstructing the depositional and diagenetic history and for evaluating their importance as potential hydrocarbon reservoirs (Cussey and Friedman 1977; Carozzi 1981; Handford 1988; Sellwood and Beckett 1991). Primary porosity types of oolites include intra- and interparticle porosity. Secondary porosity is produced by early diagenetic intraparticle dissolution (oomoldic porosity) and late diagenetic fracturing. Oomolds (Friedman 1964): Dissolved aragonitic ooids are common in subaerially exposed Pleistocene limestones and are known from rocks as old as the Cambrian. Many oomolds exhibit an eccentric displacement of the non-aragonitic nuclei, often perpendicularly to the bottom of the mold, subsequent to the dissolution of the aragonitic laminae (PI. 1317, P1. 29/3,4, P1. 1SO/ 1). The majority of observations indicates that oomoldic porosity suggests the presence of former aragonite. High-Mg calcite ooids transform to Low-Mg calcite
ooids with retention of fine fabric details and no indication of wholesale dissolution and creation of distinct moldic porosity.
Compaction: Most oolitic limestones are somewhat compacted. The measurement of packing provides a tool for quantitatively estimating the degree of grain compaction before final cementation and lithification. Compaction measures derived from thin-section data of ooid grainstones include the packing density and the packing index (Coogan 1970). Both measurements consider the total number of grains and the number of grainto-grain contacts. Strong compaction of ooid carbonates is indicated by the frequency of interpenetrating grains, ooids with peripheral sialled-off laminae, flattened ooids (Pl. 3615) and abundant, very closely packed 'fitted' ooids. Experimental compaction of ooids under deep-burial temperatures and pressure and varying salinity conditions shows appreciable reduction of bulk volume and porosity and the development'of solution contacts. Plastically deformed ooids exhibit concav-convex and longitudinal contacts (Bhattacharyya and Friedman 1984). Dolomitization: Many limestones exhibit selective dolomitization of ooids starting with an initial precipitation along the periphery of the grains, followed by
Ancient Ooids
3
c
4
@
I
0
0
O . . .
@
. I
/:
3
e I
-
I
I
o
I
I
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
I
I
I
I
Increasing Grain Size
Fig. 4.25. Model of the possible relationships between water energy, maximum and average grain size and the thickness of ooid cortices (superficial versus normal ooids). The model was developed for Great Salt Lake ooids (Carozzi 1957) and improved during the study of Mississippian shallow-marine ooid shoals in the Illinois Basin (Lacey and Carozzi 1967, Rao and Carozzi 1971).The maximum size of ooids and non-coated micritic grains is taken as a measure of the water energy level necessary to transport grains by traction or suspension processes. The numbers 1 to 6 describe different situations with regard to the hydrodynamic intensity which could favor the formation of ooids. Situation 1 and 2: The local agitation is greater than the maximum current intensity which brought the grains. Ooid formation affects all the grains available until the size of the largest ooid and that of the largest movable grain are (nearly) equal. The corresponding deposit is an oolite with a constant maximum size of normal and superficial ooids independant from the size of the available nuclei. Situation 3: The local water energy equals the maximum size of the non-coated grains. All smaller grains will be coated until their diameter reaches that of the largest non-coated grains. The sediment consists of normal and superficial ooids associated with equal-sized, rounded non-coated grains. Situation 4: The local water energy is lower than tha that of the currents which carry the largest grains into the environment. Grains which can not be lifted by the local agitation settle as non-coated grains. Other grains are coated, resulting in a sediment consisting of variously sized noncoated grains and small, predominantly normal ooids. Situation 5: The local water energy can just move the smallest grain resulting in very small superficialooids, associated with non-coated rounded particles of different size. Situation 6: The local agitation equals or is less than the water energy needed to put the smallest grain in motion. The resulting deposit consists of rounded non-coated grains without ooids. Black circles: Non-coated carbonate grains (transported litho- and bioclasts, commonly rounded and micritic, brought into the area of ooid formation by currents); open circles: superficial ooids; circles with cross-hatched signature: normal ooids. After Carozzi (1960). dolomite precipitation along porous cortical laminae (Zempolich and Bakker 1993; PI. 4018). The coalescence of dolomite crystals results in the formation of mimetic dolomite laminae and a concentric dolomite fabric (Pl. 4016).Dolomite ooids without traces of concentric laminae may indicate dolomitization subsequent to a calcitization stage. Ancient ooids Non-carbonate ooids comprise iron ooids, phosphatic ooids (Swett and Growder 1982; P1. 11012, 4 , 6), siliceous ooids, and less frequent ooids consisting of silicate minerals (Meiburg and Kaever 1974; Ehrenberg 1993; Bloch et al. 2002), sulfates (Babel and Kaprzyk 1990) or sulfides (Schieber 1999). Ancient limestones with concentrically laminated iron ooids are of great economic importance. The iron minerals may be limonite, hematite, magnetite, siderite or chamosite. Iron oxides and chamosite are com-
mon in oolitic ironstones. Iron ooids in limestones are generally explained by the replacement of carbonate (aragonite?) ooids by iron and silica compounds, probably during very early diagenetic stages, perhaps preceding the inversion of aragonite to calcite. The onshore or offshore source of the iron (terrestrial weathering products, volcanic material, biochemical enrichment?) and the formation of oolitic ironstones is the subject of considerable debate (Gygi 198 1, Kimberley 1983, 1994, Sturesson et al. 1999). Major problems are the process and environment of ooid formation (accretionary or concretionary; shallow-marine or nonmarine), the nature of iron minerals (diagenetic or primary), and the mechanisms of iron enrichment. Examples of modem iron ooids are known from lacustrine and marine environments (e.g. Lake Chad: Lemoalle and Dupont 1973; Mahengetang Island, Indonesia: Heikopp et al. 1996). Oolitic ironstones are known from the Precambrian and the Phanerozoic; they are particularly
Ancient Ooids
154
Box 4.16. Selected case studies of ancient marine and non-marine (NM) ooids and ooid limestones. Pleistocene: Caputo 1993; Evans and Ginsburg 1987; Fabricius and Klingele 1970; Geno and Chafetz 1982 (NM); Hesse 1973; Jones and Goodbody 1984; Major et al. 1988; Richter and Neuser 1998; Wiedicke and Kudrass 1999 Tertiary: Roda 1965; Schoff 1937 (NM); Swirydczuk et al. 1979 (NM, low-salinity lake) Cretaceous: Gely and Loreau 1986; Nazhat 1998; Simone 1974, 1981; Strasser 1986; Tisljar 1983. Jurassic: Bausch 1961; Bersier 1937; Bosellini et al. 1981; Castellarin and Sartori 1973; Cussey and Friedman 1977; dYArgenioet al. 1975; Dickinson 1969; Dragastan and Richter 1999; Fabricius 1967; Heydari and Moore 1994; Koch et al. 1994; Kolckrnann 1992; Loreau 1969, 1979; Martinis and Fontana 1968; Massari and Dieni 1983; Schaller and Koch 1996; Schloz 1972; ScudelerBacelle 1976,1980,1983;Sellwoodet al. 1989; Strohmengeret al. 1987; Swirydcuk 1988; Wilson 1968; Zempolich and Erba 1999. Triassic: Aigner 1984; Carozzi 1964 (NM); Fabricius 1967; Frantzen 1887; Friedel 1995; Gidon 1952; Haage 1970; Homung 1998; Kalkowsky 1908; Labecki and Radwanski 1967; Milroy and Wright 2000 (nonmarine, freshwater lake); Paul 1982; 1985; Paul and Peryt 2000; Usdowski 1962, 1963; Young and Edmundson 1954; Zeng Yun-Fu 1983. Permian: Bausch and Wiontzek 1961; Clark 1980; Fiichtbauer 1968; Henmann 1956; Kerkmann 1966; Piatkowski 1977. Carboniferous: Burchette et al. 1990; Carozzi 1961; Choquette and Steinen 1985; Conley 1977; Dingle et al. 1993; Feldman et al. 1993; Henbest 1945; Hird and Tucker 1988; Hunter 1993; Keith and Zuppann 1993; Kettenbrinck and Manger 1971; Knewtson and Hubert 1967; Lacey and Carozzi 1967; Payton 1966; Wilkinson et al. 1984. Devonian: Poncet 1983; Reijers and Ten Haave 1983. Silurian: Richter 1983. Ordovician: Cantrell and Walker 1985; Carozzi and Textoris 1965; Davis 1966; Hyeong and Lee 1992; Schramm 1963; Stureson et al. 1999; Weaver 1992 Cambrian: Brown 1959; Carozzi 1963; Choquette 1955; Chow and James 1987; James and Klappa 1983; Mazzullo 1977; Poncet 1984; Sha and Jiang 1998; Swett 1965; Wherry 1916. Precambrian: Beukes 1983; Labecki and Radwanski 1967; Radwanski and Birkenmayer 1977; Simonson and Jarvis 1993; Singh 1987; Sumner and Grotzinger 1993; Swett and Knoll 1989; Tucker 1984, 1985; Zempolich et al. 1988.
abundant in two periods: from the Ordovician to the Devonian, and the Jurassic to the Early Tertiary (Young 1992). Iron oolites were formed in more than one mode. Microfacies studies of Devonian shallow-marine carbonates with iron ooids suggest that iron ooids originated in lagoonal or back-bar environments with temporarily phreatic conditions and fluctuating Eh-pH conditions. The iron was leached from pelitic sediments of the Old Red continent and was precipitated as concretionary iron hydroxide on bioclasts (Utescher 1992). The Middle and earliest Late Jurassic oolitic ironstones in central Europe originated in open, shallow to deeper marine environments (Gygi 1981). Iron was derived from the land by lateritic weathering. Iron ooids formed at the distal fringe of an argillaceous, terrigenous sediment below the normal wave base but within the reach of storm-generated waves.
Zempolich et al. 1988) exhibit distinct differences in size, shape and internal structures. This has been explained by fluctuation in the concentration of calcium carbonate in seawater during the Proterozoic (Grotzinger 1990). Estimate making according to the number of references (Box 4.16), oolitic carbonates were abundant in the Early Carboniferous and in the Middle and Late Jurassic, but seem to have been rare in Silurian and Tertiary deposits.
Secular variations There is much evidence for temporal fluctuations in the mineralogy of marine carbonate precipitates during the Phanerozoic (Sect. 16.7.3). Sandberg (1983) postulated a secular variation in the mineralogical composition of ooids with aragonite (and High-Mg calcite) occurring in the Late Precambrian-Cambrian, Mid-Carboniferous through Triassic, and Tertiary to Recent, and Low-Mg calcite ooids in the Mid-Paleozoic and JurasAncient calcareous ooids: Ooids are known as far sic-Cretaceous. The temporal variation was explained back as the early Precambrian (Beukes 1983; Simonson as a consequence of changes in the composition of ocean and Jarvis 1993: 2.5 billion years; ooids with radial- water and the major controls on the mineralogy (Pco, concentric structures). Ooids from the Early and the and Mg/Ca ratio). Several authors prefer this model by Late Precambrian (Radwanski and Birkenmajer 1977; Bates and Brand (1990). Many exceptions to the genSingh 1987; Swett and Knoll 1989; Tucker 1984,1985; eral pattern exist.
Ooids: Depositonal Sites Low- or High-Mg Calcite
~ i g h - Calcite ~g
I
Aragonite?
MINERALOGY ated
I
--
z
m
0
-
-> K
C
Restr~cted
SALINITY
Manne
Fig. 4.26. Depositiorzal sites and erzvironmenfalcontrols of ooids exemplified by a case study of shallow-water, near-coastal Purbeck facies (lowermost Cretaceous) carbonates of the Swiss and French Jura mountains (after Strasser 1986). Purbeck sediments comprise shallow subtidal, inter- and supratidal, normal marine, brackish, freshwater and hypersaline facies. Top: Inferred primary mineralogy, water energy, salinity, and depositional environment of ooid types characterized by different morphological features and cortical structures. All types show transitions. Type 1 and Type 4 may develop into superficial ooids, Type 2 to oncoids, and Type 3 to large asymmetric coated grains. 1 - spherical micritic ooids with thinly laminated tangential cortices forming well-sorted grainstones with up to 90 % ooids and only a few fossils (intertidal), 2 - irregular micritic ooids with thinly laminated cortices forming packstones (shallow marine to lagoonal), 3 - ooids with thinly laminated fine-radial cortices contributing to poorly sorted skeletal grainstones (deposition in quiet-water environments), 4 - ooids with a few fine-radial laminae occumng in well-sorted packstones and wackestones (brackish lagoonal environment), 5 - ooids with coarse-radial cortices contributing to well-sorted grain- and packstones (lagoons with varying water energy). Bottom: Environments where ooids may have been formed. Type 1 ooids formed in normal-marine shallow waters under high-energy conditions in small sand bars under the influence of tidal currents. Type 2 ooids originate in a quiet-water lagoonal environment populated by algae and cyanobacteria. The radial ooids of Type 3 indicate marine conditions differing in water chemistry from the environment of type 1 ooids, and frequent stirring-up of the sediment. Type 4 and type 5 ooids represent low-energy lagoons of varying salinity with charophycean algae and ostracods. Ooids were accumulated in sand bars by storms.
Wilkinson et al. (1985) found peak abundances of ooid formation during the Late Cambrian, Late Mississippian, Late Jurassic, and the Holocene. These penods coincide with periods of global transgressions and regressions. The reduction in ooid abundance in Middle Ordovician to Early Mississippian and Late Cretaceous to midTertiary might be explained by the absence of wave-
agitated environments during times of strong continental submergence or by a threshold formed by too high PCO2levels. Significance of ooids Two examples of the potential of ooid analysis in microfacies studies are shown in Fig. 4.25 and Fig. 4.26, and summarized in Box 4.17.
156
Significance of Ooids
Box 4.17. Significance of ooids and oolites. Paleoenvironmental proxies Microfabrics, size distributions of ooids and sedimentary structures (e.g. cross-bedding, laminar bedding, fine laminae) of oolitic limestones reflect environmental conditions dominating water energy, salinity and water depths. Water energy levels and transport processes: Differences in high- and low-energy settings control growth and prevailing microfabrics of ooids, and determine the number of autochthonous ooids (deposited more or less at the place of origin) and allochthonous ooids (deposited after greater transport). As many ooids form in current-swept areas, they can accumulate in conditions different from those in which they were generated. Ooids of intertidal and shallow subtidal areas are frequently transported to adjacent subenvironments, but also to areas at a greater distance (e.g. slope, basins). Autochthonous ooids are characterized by rare or missing abrasion, the association of single and broken ooids, and the occurrence of ooids with same maximum size. These ooids exhibit a relatively simple transport history. Changes from radial to tangential concentric microfabrics combined with the crossing of a critical threshold of grain size allow the paleocurrents to be estimated (Heller et al. 1980). A diameter of 0.6 mrn appears to mark the threshold for particles transported in suspension or as bed load (Miller et al. 1977). Allochthonous ooids are characterized by mixing of various-sized ooids (Pl. 4616) and abrasion of laminae. These ooids are distinguished from ooids deposited in situ by microfabric, size, thickness of the cortices, and associated grains (Chow and James 1987). Evidence of redeposition is (1) the size, sorting, and skewness of ooids and associated grains, (2) the ratio of ooid content/mean diameter, and (3) the cortex/nucleus ratio (Carozzi 1983; Fig. 4.25). Low-energy conditions are generally inferred from the dominance of radial-fibrous rnicrofabric, irregular and often asymmetrical shapes, and size parameters. Changes from low- to high-energy and from bed-load to suspension transport are reflected by microfabrics of ooids (Poncet 1984). Salinity: Freshwater ooids often differ from marine ooids in having exceedingly irregular surfaces and shapes, and commonly tangential or microsparitic laminae. Ooids formed in hypersaline settings appear to be characterized by the predominance of radial ooids as compared with other ooid types.Water depths: Some workers use the amount of ooids as measure of water depths (Fabricius 1967). Bahamian ooids are concentrated in very shallow waters. Their abundance in mobile ooid fringes and on sand flats (depth 95% (Harris 1979). Sea-level fluctuations Sea-level fluctuations influence circulation patterns and submarine morphology, which in turn control the local conditions for ooid growth. This may be indicated by distinct compositional changes from skeletal to ooid grainstones or vice versa. Drops in sea level can lead to exposure and rapid cementation, causing the death of the ooid factory (Bosellini et al. 1981). Regional correlations Oolitic beds which can be laterally followed for long distances are valuable stratigraphic markers. An example are stratigraphically distinct Devonian ironstone horizons consisting of ferruginous ooids and bioclasts that were transported by storms several tens of kilometers over the open shelf (Dreesen 1989). Depositional settings Marine ooids are deposited in shoreface settings of ramps, on inner platforms, near outer margins of platforms, and as allochthonous sediments on the slope and in proximal or distal parts of basins. Specific settings can be recognized from the abundance, texture, ooid type, and the number of autochthonous and allochthonous ooids. Resedimented ooids, deposited as calciturbidites on the slope and in coalescent deep-sea fans, are often bimodal, poorly sorted and occur with lithoclasts and shallow-marine, platform-derived skeletal grains (Bosellini et al. 1981; Kolckmann 1992; Zempolich and Erba 1999). Paleoclimate and paleoceanography Ooids are often used as proxies for warm-water environments or tropical settings (e.g. Opdyke and Wilkinson 1990, Kiessling et al. 2002). The main assumption is that carbonate ooids favor warm waters with high salinities (Lees 1975). Oolitic deposits appear to be good paleoclimatic indicators. During the Phanerozoic they were usually concentrated in the tropics and lower subtropics, but not at or very near to the equator. Differences in the diagenetic style of ancient oolites are attributed to the prevailing climate. The paucity of early meteoric cements is explained as a result of an arid climate, whereas abundant meteoric cements should reflect a more humid climate (Hird and Tucker 1988). Integrated paleoceanographic and paleoclimatic models have been developed based on the mineralogical and geochemical criteria of ooids (Heydari and Moore 1993). Economic importance of ooid carbonates Hydrocarbon reservoir rocks: Because aragonite and calcite ooids behave differently with regard to dissolution and cementation, the original mineralogy as well as the spatial distribution of ooid sand bodies (sheets or shoals), and the geometry of ooid-bearing sequences have a significant influence on reservoir qualities of carbonate rocks (Sw irydczuk 1988; Burchette et al. 1990; Hovorka et al. 1993). Oolites consisting of autochthonous and allochthonous ooids may represent different reservoir types due to significant differences of primary fabric-selective intra- and interparticle and secondary interparticle and fracture porosity (Carozzi 1983; Handford 1988). For important field case studies and a discussion of oolitic reservoirs see Keith and Zuppann (1993). Ore deposits: Carbonates with fermginous ooids form important iron ore deposits in Europe and North America.
Pisoids and Vadoids
157
-
4.2.6 Pisoids and Vadoids Simply 'Larger Ooids' or Carbonate Grains on their Own?
(e.g. cave pearls in high-energy splash pools, PI. 14/8), or pisoids originating in geyser waters). Low-energy 'quiet-water' pisoids show irregular layers at the peTerminology riphery and strong deviations from the spherical shape Grains which are structurally similar to ooids, but (e.g. pisoids formed in low-energy rimstone pools of have a diameter larger than 2 mm, are often called caves). The shape may be asymmetrical, and exhibit pisoids (from pisum, Latin for pea). Different names downward or upward thickening (Pl. 1416, PI. 12612) have been used for these grains, e.g. 'diagenetic oo- as well as lateral elongations whose laminae vanish ids', caliche ooids (Fig. 4.27), cave pearls, vadose oo- within the surrounding sediment or connect single ids etc. The size limit of 2 mm is highly artificial, but pisoids, indicating in-situ growth. Broken and recoated also considers, that most marine ooids do not grow to pisoids are common, indicating alternating periods of large sizes, because large grains can not be held in sus- fracturing, reworking and pisoid growth. A common pension long enough to be coated. Many pisoids are feature of vadoids is polygonal fitting resulting from several centimeters in size, but others are smaller than vadose compaction. the critical boundary allows. Nucleus and cortex: The nuclei are formed by fragThe term pisoid, has different meanings, depending ments of pisoids and cement crusts, lithoclasts, peloids, on the genetic concepts inferred. Some authors use the name in order to describe rounded carbonate grains built by algae; these 'algal pisolites' however should be addressed as oncoids or rhodoids (Sect. 4.2.4). Other authors favor the term pisoid, when they want to express a non-marine origin for a coated carbonate or non-carbonate grain. It may be characterizedby concentric layers made up of calcite or aragonite around a nucleus, commonly a lithoclast or pisoid fragments. The term vadoid introduced by Peryt (1983) underlines the substantiated or inferred formation of many (but not all) of these grains within a freshwater vadose or marine vadose environment, as indicated by specific cement types. Vadoid is a useful term if the vadose origin is sufficiently substantiated. A specific variety of pisoids, first recognized in back-reef strata of the Permian Reef Complex in New Mexico and West Texas, has been called walnutoid (Esteban and Pray 1983; PI. 3416, P1. 12611). The name is derived from the striking resemblance in size and shape to nuts of the Texas walnut tree. Comparison with other grains Pisoids are generally larger than most marine ooids, and characterized by dense or irregular laminations Fig. 4.27. Caliche pisoids. A - Holocene caiiche with pisoids around a non-skeletal nucleus. Oncoids differ in the (center) and micritic crusts. Note the indistinct lamination around organically coated nuclei. The matrix contains abuncommon presence of encrusting biota. Criteria Descriptive criteria of pisoids are the shape, nucleus, cortex, and structure of the cortex laminae as well as the size, sorting and texture of the grains. Shape: The shape of pisoids is environmentally controlled: Pisoids formed in continuously agitated water exhibit increasing roundness in the peripheral layers
dant terrigenous quartz grains. Fuerteventura, Canary Islands. B - Ancient caliche with finely laminated layers which have been transformed into pisoids with indistinct boundaries. In contrast to stromatolites formed by biogenic activity, the laminar structures fill in the depressions of the microrelief. Such fabrics, together with in situ brecciation, desiccation cracks and the sparseness or absence of fossils, are good indicators of subaerial exposure of marine sequences and periods of nondeposition during which paleosols were formed in a semiarid climate. Middle Triassic (Wetterstein Formation, Ladinian): Reisskofel, Carinthia, Austria. Scale is 5 rnm for A and B.
158
Pisoids and Vadoids
Plate 14 Pisoids and Vadoids Pisoids are carbonate or non-carbonate grains structurally resembling ooids but differing in origin, environment, internal structure and often a larger size (several millimeters to centimeters). Discrimination between pisoids, oncoids and marine ooids is essential for recognizing non-marine or marginal-marine intervals, breaks in marine sedimentation (see P1. 126) and the explanation of cyclic sequences (-> 1). Vadoids originate in a vadose freshwater (ranging in salinity from freshwater streams to hypersaline sabkhas) and in vadose-marine environments (e.g. supratidal areas, -> 4) . The grains are formed in various climate zones, in pedogene settings (caliche pisoids, -> 6; P1. 128), karst regions and caves (spelean pisoids, 'cave pearls', -> 8),and comprise fluvial pisoids as well as marine-vadose pisoids (-> 1; see P1. 126). Many carbonate vadoid grains are formed by chemical (e.g. cave pearls in speleothems), but also by microbially induced precipitation (e.g. caliche pisoids in humid subtropical and tropical areas). Phosphatic, fermgineous, or siliceous pisoids are the result of the replacement of primary carbonate pisoids or concretional in-situ formations (-> 7). 1 Vadose-marine pisoids ('walnutoids', Estaban and Pray 1983), formed by accretionary growth on a shelf crest within shoaling upwards sequences in a protected hypersaline environment. The grains are linked by outer laminae and meniscus cement. Successive laminae differ in thinner darker micritic and clearer, microspar lamellae. Nuclei are peloids or fragments of preexisting pisoids. White areas represent neomorphic carbonate. Compare P1. 12611. Note that the existence of pisoids, inverse graded bedding, polygonal fitting as well as radial-fibrous fans and mammillary crusts need not necessarily indicate subaerial exposure. These pisolitic deposits are part of the shelf interior facies separating evaporitic dolomites on the landward side (lagoonal setting) and fossiliferous marine grain-, pack-, and wackestones on the seaward side (open shelf). Interpretations of the depositional environment ranges from caliche formation in continental or coastal-spray-zone settings (Dunham 1969; Scholle and Kinsman 1974), products of marine inorganic precipitation in inter- and subtidal settings (Esteban and Pray 1983), and grains formed in marine seepage or groundwater springs (Handford et al. 1984). The seep-spring hypothesis is currently favored. SMF 26. Late Permian (Carlsbad Group, Guadalupian): Mouth of Walnut Canyon, back-reef facies of the Permian Reef Complex, New Mexico, U.S.A. 2 'Coniatoids'. The term has been suggested for carbonate crusts made up of uniformly thick coatings of aragonitic lamellae occumng in the supratidal zone of the Persian Gulf (Purser and Loreau 1973). Criteria: Very densely-spaced finely crystalline and fibrous laminae, sometimes forming discordant crusts on marine substrates. Note the irregular, non-spheroidal shape of the grains and the marine nuclei (aggregate grains). Supratidal environment. Early Carboniferous (VisCan): Czatkovice, Cracow area, southern Poland. Transgressive grainstone filling the relief of an underlying caliche horizon. 3 Bi-oken and i-eworkedpisoids indicating erosion and redepostion of vadoids in high energy environments. SMF 26. Early Cretaceous: Apennines, Italy, 4 Vadose pisoids. Note the meniscus cement (arrow) between the pisoids. Late Permian (Zechstein): Subsurface, northern Germany. 5 Coniatoids. As compared with marine ooids, these grains differ in their large non-skeletal nuclei (-> 2). Early Carboniferous (VisCan): Czatkovice, Cracow area, Poland. 6 Culichepisoids formed on top of lacustrine stromatolites. Note the significant upward growth. These pisoids were formed within soils where vadose and shallow phreatic groundwaters became saturated with respect to calcium carbonate. Early Permian (Rotliegendes): Oberweiler Tiefenbach, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany. 7 Siliceous pisoids. Bauxitic paleokarst surface. Note the shrinkage pores around the pisoids (arrows) and the morphological similarities with other vadoids (e.g. -> 1). Cretaceous: Subsurface Ras a1 Khaimah, United Arabian Emirates. 8 'Cuve pearl' (cave pisolite, spaeloid) of a modem speleothem. These non-attached calcite cave deposits originate by successive calcite precipitation from vadose-meteoric waters, forming strictly concentric lamellae around a nucleus; these vadoids are characterized by radial crystal structures. Note the slight deviations from spheroidal shape due to space competition with other grains. These grains grow in cupshaped depressions of caves. The grains are rotated by falling water drops (Homann 1969). Micritic pisoids with an irregular internal lamination have been interpreted as 'subterranean oncoids' because of calcite precipitation related to the metabolism of bacteria living within biofilms (Gradzinski 2001). Subrecent: Styria, Austria.
Plate 14: Pisoids and Vadoids
159
Environments of Pisoids
or mineral grains. Nuclei formed by skeletal grains are rare, but may occur in peritidal settings. Pisoids may have more than one nucleus. Cortex: Many pisoids exhibit a distinct concentric structure consisting of very densely spaced dark and light laminae (Pl. 1417, P1. 12611). The light laminae consist of microspar. Dark laminae are interpreted as microbially induced (Esteban and Pray 1983, Jones and MacDonald 1989). The number of laminae is variable and ranges from distinctly more than in ooids to only few. Caliche pisoids often have few laminae, freshwater and vadose pisoids many laminae (Esteban 1976), but many exceptions exist. Texture: Inverse grading is a common feature of autochthonous pisoids formed in situ. Common associations of pisoids are fenestral carbonates, tepees, diagenetic grainstones and vadose mammillary crusts, characterized by bent laminae at the bottom surface of pisoids. Diagenesis: Modem pisoids formed in hypersaline settings (e.g. Persian Gulf) consist of aragonite and/or High-Mg calcite. A brick-like microfabric of microsparitic laminae seen in many ancient pisoids is caused by meteoric-phreatic inversion of originally aragonitic laminae into granular calcitic laminae without a distinct dissolution phase (Assereto and Folk 1976). Experiments and studies of ancient peritidal carbonates suggest that intense fenestral alteration of original micritic sediments in the peritidal environment can lead to in situ formation of pisoids and diagenetic grainstones (Mazzullo and Birdwell 1989).
Box 4.18. Environments of pisoid formation.
Non-marine Pedogenic horizons (Burgess 1983; Chafetz and Butler 1980; Calvet and Julia 1983; caliche and soil pisoids see Sect. 2.4.1.1) Speleothems (Kirchmayer 1964; Donahue 1969; Jones and MacDonald 1989; Tietz 1988; cave pearls see Sect. 2.4.1.3) Cold- and hot-water springs and pools (travertine pisoids formed by inorganic precipitation and bacterially triggered carbonate deposition (Chavetz and Meredith 1983; Folk and Chavetz 1983) Spring-fed pools (Schreiber 1981) Freshwater and salt lakes (Jones and Wilkinson 1978; Handford et al. 1984; lacustrine pisoids see Sect. 2.4.1.7) Fluvial environments (Braithwaite 1979; Jones and Wilkinson 1978; see 2.4.1.8)
Transitional marine and shallow-marine Beach zones Coastal sabkhas and playa lakes (Jones and Renault 1994) Supra- and intertidal zones (Purser and Loreau 1973, see 2.4.2.2) Subtidal shelf crest
Several settings of pisoid formation are common in the geological record:
Cave pisoids or 'cave pearls' are grains formed by chemical precipitation on a preexisting nucleus in a pool of water within a cave. They originate in high-energy splash pools and low-energy rimstone pools. The pisoids from splash pools are commonly spherical to subspherical (Pl. 14/8), exhibit a polished surface and Modem pisoids: Environments and controls typically have an exotic nucleus surrounded by disRecent pisoids form under a wide range of environ- tinct laminae exhibiting a radial microfabric, and yieldments including non-marine, transitional marine and ing an extinction cross under crossed nicols. Pisoids shallow-marine settings (Box 4.18). from rimstone pools have an irregular shape with a rough surface, rarely have a nucleus, and commonly Pisoids originate from exhibit indistinct and irregular porous laminae. The 1 Chemical precipitation from carbonate-saturated crystal fabric of pisoids formed in speleothems is, at agitated water (e.g. cave pearls of speleothems; or least partly, controlled by organic compounds and bacthermal pisoids, e.g. Mammoth Hot Springs,Yellow- terial contribution (Jones and Renault 1994). stone). The concentric laminae originating from chemical precipitation are abraded by contacts with Vadose pisoids may originate in hypersaline transiother grains. tional environments or in meteoric environments. Char2 Chemical and biochemical precipitation in low-en- acteristics of these grains are in situ growth, e.g. indiergy environments (e.g. vadose pisoids, fluvial vidual grains that coalesce and build composite grains pisoids, pisoids formed in periodically desiccated and (Pl. 14/1), and asymmetrical growth extending upwards sometimes hypersaline tidal zones, and (Pl. 1416). Repeated desiccation of vadose pisoids can 3 concretionary growth in arid and semiarid pedogenic lead to fracture and grain breakage; reworked pisoid layers (caliche pisoids). fragments are abundant in supra- and intertidal depos-
Ancient Pisoids
its (PI. 14/4). Features characteristic of vadose and phreatic pisoids are a radial fibrous fabric, perched inclusions, grain-to-grain contacts, polygonal fit of grains (PI. 126/2), pisoids linked by cement crusts (PI. 126/ l), inverse grading (PI. 126/2), tepee structures, and irregular non-spherical pisoid shapes.
cur? Pisoids have been interpreted variously as marine, schizohaline, lacustrine, fluvial, spring-surface fed surface pool, speleothemic, phreatic and vadose. Phreatic and vadose as well as schizohaline and marine records of pisoids are common from the Permian, Triassic and Jurassic (Box 4.19).
Vadose pisoids have many characteristics in common with caliche pisoids. Joint features are, for example, the downward elongation of laminae, and the development of fibrous or blocky calcite cements between the grains. Both hypersaline and caliche pisoids are associated with fenestral fabrics (commonly grainsupported for vadose pisoids, mud-supported for caliche pisoids). Features which can be used to differentiate vadose pisoids are (1) the regional geological setting of pisoid accumulation; (2) presence of fossils; (3) spar crystals with a triangular cross section, indicating precipitation from fresh water; and (4) fabrics which point to the original mineralogy (e.g. brick-like textures or elongated rays with square termination interpreted as aragonite relicts formed in hypersaline settings (Assereto and Folk 1976; Esteban 1976; Esteban and Pray 1983; Chafetz and Butler 1980; Hay and Wiggins 1980).
Primary marine pisoids are known from Paleozoic and a few Triassic and Jurassic occurrences. In contrast to the rather scarce record from the Phanerozoic, marine pisoids appear widespread in Proterozoic carbonates, commonly associated with ooids, stromatolites and intraformational conglomerates (Swett and Knoll 1989). This disparity is related to changes in the degree of calcium carbonate supersaturation caused by the Late Precambrian and Early Cambrian radiation of calcified algae and animals.
Caliche pisoids originate in situ at the surface or within surface layers by evaporation. The sizes ranges from about 2 mm to several centimeters. Many caliche pisoids are characterized by weak or obscure lamination, accretion and centrifugal growth, laminae of variable thickness, alternation of light and dark laminae, composite nuclei (pisoid fragments or lithoclasts), or absence of an observable nucleus, circumcracking structures, association with micritic crusts, a clotted peloidal texture and a mud-supported fabric (Fig. 4.27; P1. 12816). Fluvial pisoids and lacustrine pisoids typically show variable irregular shapes and sizes, alternation of finegrained detritic laminae and laminae consisting of coarse cement; association with laminated crusts, organic detritus and crystal sand. Unusual settings in which pisoids are formed are oilfield waters (Kemp 1959), landfills (Maliva et al. 2000), power stations (Knatz 1966), and old mines (Hahne et al. 1968).
Ancient pisoids The interpretation of ancient pisoid limestones hinges on two questions: What processes caused pisoid formation and in what environment did formation oc-
The Permian Reef Complex case study: An instructive example of the varying interpretation of pisoid limestones in the ancient record are the pisoids occurring in bedded carbonates of the famous Permian Reef Complex (PI. 1411, PI. 3416, PI. 12611). Early workers considered the pisoids to have been formed by algae; they compared the grains with modem oncoids and assumed that the pisoids were formed and deposited in lagoons as free subaquatic sedimentary particles. Dunham (1969) and Thomas (1965) were the first to sugBox 4.19. Selected case studies of ancientpisoids. A comprehensive list of studies of modem and ancient pisoids and pisolites can be found in Peryt (1983). Pleistocene: Braithwaite 1983; Burgess 1983; James 1972. Tertiary: Gradzinski and Radomsi 1976; Misik 1980; Surdam and Stanley 1979; Swineford et al. 1958. Cretaceous: Enos 1974; Tisljar 1983. Jurassic: Melas and Friedman 1987; Goldberg and Friedman 1974. Triassic: Assereto and Folk 1976,1980; Bernoulli and Wagner 1971; Ciarapicca and Passeri 1983; Dozet 1991; Henrich 1984; Wagner 1987 Permian: Pisoids in the Permian Reef Complex, Texas - Dunham 1969; Esteban 1976; Esteban and Pray 1977, 1983; Loucks and Folk 1976; Kendall 1969; Mazzullo and Birdwell 1989 (discussion: Wright 1990); Pray and Esteban 1977; Peryt 1981, 1983, 1984; Clark 1980; Folk and Siedlecka 1974. Carboniferous: Gerhard 1985; Misik 1980; Wright 1981. Devonian: Wardlaw and Reinson 1971. Silurian: Kahle 1974; Frank et al. 1993. Precambrian: Cao Ruiji and Xu Yaosong 1983; Radwanski and Birkenrnayer 1977; Simonson and Jarvis 1993; Swett and Knoll 1989.
162
Significance of Pisoids
Box 4.20. Significance of pisoids and vadoids. Paleoenvironmental proxies Water energy levels: Differences in shape and lamination of vadoids (e.g. cave pearls) allow the evaluation of continuous or discontinuous and high- and low-energy environments. Transport processes: The analysis of the association of vadose pisoids with other coated grains allows transport processes within schizohaline peritidal zones to be recognized (Peryt and Piatkowski 1977). Salinity: Many pisoids found in peritidal carbonates were formed in waters of increased salinity. Other pisoids are indicative of non-marine salinity, e.g. freshwater or brackish waters. Sea-level fluctuations Pisolitic limestone beds intercalated within marine sequences may indicate breaks in sedimentation caused by drops in sea level, and associated with karstification phases. Pisoids are common constituents of the supratidal and intertidal members of shallowing-upward cycles. Depositional settings Caliche pisoids, cave pisoids, lacustrine pisoids and meteoric-vadose and marine-vadose pisoids can be used to recognize different subenvironments of terrestrial and marginal marine settings (Esteban and Pray 1983). Standard microfacies 25 underlines the importance of pisolitic carbonate rocks. Paleoclimate Micro- and ultrastructureof cave pisoids as well as caliche pisoids reflect seasonal changes and longer-term climatic changes. Economic importance Hydrocarbon reservoirs: Pisoid limestones are important reservoir rocks, e.g. in the Permian of West Texas and in the Mississippian of North Dakota (Gerhard 1985). The productive facies include pisolitic wackestones and grain- to packstones. Porosity is enhanced by subaerial and vadose dissolution related to pisoid formation.
gest a completely different interpretation of the pisoids. Pisoids were regarded as vadose concretions produced by subaerial vadose exposure and diagenesis in a caliche soil. The caliche hypothesis gained wide acceptance, but started being discussed again. Texas pisoids were compared with modem pisoids found in sabkha environments of the Persian Gulf (Scholle and Kinsman 1974). Assereto and Folk (1976) and Loucks and Folk (1976) concluded that the pisoids were produced by marginal marine supratidal environments. Intensive research by Lloyd Pray and his group led to a complete rejection of the caliche and the vadose origin hypotheses (Esteban and Pray 1976, 1983). The authors interpreted the pisoid depositional setting as a shelf crest of a carbonate marginal mound separating an evaporitic lagoon from a more open-marine area. Pisoids and pisolites formed from the intensive precipitation from very shallow hypersaline waters in a peritidal environment. Thick pisolite development commonly occurred as parts of shoaling upward sequences of inter-tepee depressions. As shown by the pisoids of the Permian Reef Complex, differences in shape, nuclei, lamination and texture of pisoids reflect differences in the depositional environment (Noe 1996). Mobile transported pisoids, formed on shallow subtidal environments, are characterized by spherical and ellipsoidal shapes, symmetrical cortices, nuclei of bioclasts and broken pisoids, and a normally graded texture. Pisoids formed in situ within
peritidal settings exhibit a polygonal fitted fabric, asymmetrical cortices, downward bent laminae, sediment inclusions in the peripheral laminae, and inverse grading. Similar criteria occur with pisoids formed in situ in the vadose zone (e.g. caliche pisoids), but these grains are distinguished by their association with meniscus and dripstone calcite cements and mammillary cement crusts. Non-carbonate pisoids Most modem pisoids consist of calcite or aragonite, but ferruginous, phosphatic and siliceous pisoids (PI. 12613) are also known (Carozzi 1960; Jenkyns 1970; Bhattacharyya and Kakimoto 1982; Burgess 1983; Soudry and Southgate 1989;Abreu 1990).Non-carbonate pisoids were formed in more than one mode (Sect. 4.2.5). The source of the iron of ferruginous pisoids has been related to volcanism, as well as to solution and weathering processes. Pisoids occurring within laterite and bauxite profiles are explained by dissolution and reprecipitation controlled by climatic variation, chemistry of the groundwater in terms of its pH and Eh, and differences in weathering of the parent rocks and in transport processes (Pl. 12614). Significance of pisoids Box 4.20 summarizes the significance of pisoids in microfacies analysis.
Aggregate Grains
4.2.7 Aggregate Grains: Grapestones, Lumps and Other Composite Grains Originally separated ooids, bioclasts and other grains can be bound together by organic films, encrusting organisms and aragonite or Mg-calcite carbonate cements, forming composite grains. The best known modem examples are the sand-sized 'grapestones' of the Bahama Banks which constitute up to eighty volume percent of the total number of particles in a very large transitional area from agitated ooid shoals to the protected mud and peloid mud environments. Strong micritization of the component particles often makes it difficult to distinguish between aggregate grains and resediments, which are reworked chunks of partly consolidated sediment. Most aggregate grains form in very shallow areas where currents and waves are sufficient to remove fine-grained sediment, but not sand. Recent Bahamian-type aggregate grains occur in subtidal and intertidal shallow-marine environments with restricted or changing circulation. Grapestones, consisting of peloids, ooids and oncoids, and cemented by aragonite or cryptocrystalline Mg-calcite are also known from sea-marginal hypersaline pools (e.g. Red Sea: Friedman 1978). In hypersaline coastal ponds of the Black Sea, cementation within grain aggregates occurs by means of bacterial degradation of calcium sulphate (Baltres 1975). Grapestones and other varieties of aggregate grains are characteristic constituents of many Precambrian and Phanerozoic platform carbonates and valuable paleoenvironmental proxies. Terminology Aggregate grains were first observed in the Bahama Banks (Illing 1954; Purdy 1963), then in the Persian
1 Binding stage
2 Grapestone stage
Gulf (Taylor and Illing 1969, Kendall and Skipwith 1969) and also in the Gulf of Batabano south of Cuba (Bathurst 1975). The grains are common in platform environments, but can also be associated with reefs (Milliman 1967). Different names characterize different shapes and the variable contribution of organisms and carbonate cements to the formation of these composite grains: Grapestones:Aggregates of spherical grains (often micritized ooids) whose external shape resembles microscopic clusters of grapes. Typical grapestones exhibit very little microcrystalline carbonate, but often interparticle carbonate cements (Pl. 1512). Micritization of these cements may transform a grapestone grain into a lump grain (Pl. 6211). Lumps: Aggregates with a smoother outline than grapestones; they commonly have hollow interiors and are often strongly micritized (Pl. 1513). Botryoidal or oolitic lumps: Grapestone or lumps with a thin oolitic coating. Microbiallalgal aggregate grains: Sedimentary particles are agglutinated by biofilms, cyanobacteria and algae (PI. 1515). The grains are common in lagoonal environments and often associated with microbial mats. Encrusted aggregate grains: These grains are characterized by strong biogenic encrustations with sessile foraminifera, calcareous algae, serpulids and other organisms (Pl. 1514).The grains are common in protected lagoonal environments. A typical feature of aggregate grains is the irregular shape and the typically lobate outline (Pl. 15/1,8). The size ranges between 0.5 and several millimeters, but lies commonly below 1 mm. Although many transitions exist between these varieties (Halley et al. 1983), the more common types are
3 Lump stage
4 Mature lump stage
Fig. 4.28. Multi-stage formation of aggregate grains (grapestones and lumps). Stage 1: Ooids and skeletal grains are bound together by microbial filaments, organic biofilms and encrusting organisms, e.g. foraminifera. Stage 2: Increasing calcification of microbiota contributes to the formation of a porous, cemented aggregate (grapestone) with a lobate outline. The grains are affected by microborers leading to micritization. Stage 3: Increased cementation (black) creates a smoother relief and reduces the intergranular porosity. Stage 4: Continuous micritization and cementation form a matrix-rich aggregate grain whose outline becomes successively more rounded. After Tucker (1990).
Aggregate Grains
meaningfully differentiated because different types correspond to specific stages in the formation of aggregate grains as well as different energy levels.
grains. Coatings of aggregate grains by microbes and encrusters may result in the formation of cortoids and even oncoids.
Comparisons Grapestone type aggregate grains are commonly easily recognizable by shape and composition. If the grains have been transported and eroded along their surfaces, differentiating between aggregate grains and rounded intraclasts becomes more difficult. Rounded intraclasts occurring together with angular intraclasts are often larger than typical aggregate grains and may exhibit inclusions of microfossils. Extraclasts consisting of pieces of grainstone or wackestone differ from aggregate grains by truncation of the composite particles at the extraclast boundary and often a strikingly different composition as compared with associated
Controls on the formation of modem aggregate grains The Bahamian grapestone facies forms within relatively low-energy and low-nutrient environments with low sedimentation rates. Extensive grapestone deposits made of skeletal and ooid grains occur in very shallow water of the Great Bahama Bank margin at the bankward edge of flood tidal deltas and along the beaches of the leeward side of islands and keys beyond the surf zone. Aggregate grains tend to form in areas with some water circulation, winnowing of fines and mobilization of sediment, followed by periods of stabilization and cementation (Wanless 1981). They are absent in areas of dense vegetation.
Plate 15 Aggregate Grains (Grapestones, Lumps): Common on Shallow-Marine Carbonate Platforms Aggregate grains, first studied in the Bahama Banks, are composite grains consisting of ooids, skeletal material and peloids, bound together by organic films and aragonite or Mg-calcite carbonate cements. In thin sections many aggregate grains exhibit a typically lobate outline (-> 1,4,8) and are encrusted by foraminifera, calcareous algae or serpulids. Varieties of aggregate grains include 'grapestones' (-> 2), 'lumps', -> 3), and microbial/ algal aggregate grains, common in lagoonal environments (-> 4, 8). Common prerequisites for the formation of aggregate grains are stabilization of the individual particles during reduced phases of deposition in environments with restricted circulation, cementation on the sea bottom and periodical reworking. Biofilms, microbially induced early cementation between the particles, and the absence of mud are important controls. -> Note that limestone classifications do include aggregate grains in the intraclast or lithoclast categories! 1 Modern aggregate grains ('grapestones') consisting of densely packed, micritized ooids, peloids and foraminifera (arrow). The grains are bound together by organic films and thin cement rims. White areas within the large lobate aggregate grain are open pores. Berry Islands, Great Bahama Bank. The grapestone belt on the Great Bahama Bank covers a very large shallow area, deeper than 3 m, with a maximum depth of 1&15 m. 2 Pleistocene aggregate grains forming weakly lithified calcareous sands. Note thin cements on the surface of some grains (arrows). Most intergranular pores of the sediment are still open. E: Echinoid fragment. San Salvador Island, Bahamas. 3 Plrlstotenc aggregate grains ('lumps' because of the large amount of micrite in the grains). The grains are somewhat rounded, but the characteristic lobate outline is still visible. Aggregates consist of ooids and skeletal grains (e.g. foraminifera,). The calcitic bivalve shell (P) exhibits a layered prismatic microstructure. Late Pleistocene: Grotto Beach, San Salvador Island, Bahamas. 4 Enc~.ustedaggregate grains typically showing very irregular outlines, distinctive invaginations and protuberances, and encrustations of miliolinid foraminifera (spar-filled chambers appearing as white bent elements, arrows). Intergranular pores are filled with submarine fibrous cement and vadose crystal silt. D: Dasyclad green alga. Carbonate Platform. SMF 17. Middle Permian: Velebit, Croatia. 5 Microbial lumps and small micritized dasyclad green algae (D). The net-like structures within the aggregate grains are cyanobacteria. Inner carbonate platform. SMF 17. Middle Triassic (Ladinian): Marmolada, Dolomite Mountains, Italy. 6 Aggregate grains occurring together with loose peloids. The lumps consist of peloids and a few skeletal grains. Outer carbonate platform. Early Jurassic: Djebel Assiz southwest of Tunis, northern Tunisia. 7 Aggregate-grain limestone. Carbonate platform. The sample was taken near a reef as shown by the abundance of reef biota within the aggregate grains. Note rounding and different size of many grains. Late Triassic (Bedded Dachstein Limestone, Norian): Gosaukamm, Austria. 8 Aggregate-grain grainstone. The grapestones consist of ooids and fossils. Some aggregate grains exhibit thin oolitic coatings (arrows,'botryoidal lumps'). SMF 17. Middle Triassic (Anisian): Lagoonal limestone. Olang Dolomites, Italy.
165
Plate 15: Aggregate Grains
1 mm
1 rnrn
-
1 mrn
1 rnm
1 rnrn
1 rnrn
166
Bahamian aggregate grains (PI. 1511, 3) demonstrate (a) a strong control of grapestone formation by microorganisms living in the interstices between the composite grains and in microborings (Fabricius 1977), and (b) continuous successions of increasing binding, agglutination and induration. Cyanobacteria, algae and fungi are effective in connecting and binding the constituent grains, trapping loose silt material (Cros 1979), destructively alterating the composite grains, and triggering cementation within intergranular voids. The formation of grapestones requires a sequence of depositional conditions, starting with the supply of the constituent grains (Fig. 4.28). After an environmental change, a subsequent set of depositional conditions must allow binding and cementation of grains. These changes correspond to periods of bottom mobility alternating with periods of bottom stability. Grapestone sites have been regarded as areas of nondeposition or at least reduced deposition. Marine cementation is strong because the process has millennia to operate on a limited amount of sedimentary material (Winland and Matthews 1974). Not all ancient limestones with abundant aggregate grains were formed by the processes outlined above: Constituents of the well-sorted grapestone sands of the Bahamas, may also correspond to sand and granulesized lithoclast fragments derived by erosion of firmground crusts (Demicco and Hardie 1994).Firmgrounds are sediments in the initial stages of hardground formation that can be easily broken up and transported as cohesive intraclasts (Jindrich 1969; Hardie and Garrett 1977; Dravis 1979). Carbonate aggregates, similar in morphology to 'grapestones' are common in lower slope fore-reef sediments, off Barbados. They were formed in situ by submarine lithification processes (Stentoft 1994). Ancient aggregate grains Carbonate grains which are similar to modem shallow-marine aggregate grains with respect to shape, size, composition and internal cements are already known from Precambrian limestones. Phanerozoic records of limestones with abundant and dominating aggregate grains are common in platform carbonates, but appears to be concentrated in specific time intervals including the Devonian, the Late Permian (Pl. 1514,PI. 34/7), the Middle and Late Triassic (PI. 1515, 7, 8), Jurassic (Pl. 1516, P1. 6211) and the Cretaceous (Pl. 2919, P1. 4311, PI. 12714). Limestones with abundant aggregate grains, peloids and only a few special skeletal grains are common members of platform carbonates formed in openmarine settings. Two common paleogeographic settings of larger grapestone depositional areas were the areas
Intra-, Extra-, and Lithoclasts
behind and adjacent to shelf-margin reefs (e.g. P1.12 11 4), and areas which are transitional on the seaward side to ooid shoals and green algal-foramjniferal sands on the landward side (Pl. 6111). Significance of aggregate grains Aggregate grains, which can be interpreted as analogs of Bahamian grapestones, indicate low to moderate and changing water energy levels, tropical and sub.tropical warm-water conditions, low-nutrient environments and low sedimentation rates. The depositional setting of bedded limestones composed predominantly of aggregate grains usually corresponds to attached or isolated platforms. Grainstones predominantly consisting of aggregate grains are characteristic parts of platforms formed during sea level highstand phases.
Economic potential: Carbonates with aggregate grains occurring in association with oolitic limestones are reservoir rocks (e.g. in the Cretaceous of the Near East). Because most grapestones originate in environments with no or very low terrigenous input, the noncarbonate residues of many limestones with abundant aggregate grains are conspicuously low. These limestones are important resources of chemically high-quality carbonate rocks (Fliigel and Haditsch 1977).
4.2.8 Resediments: lntra-, Extra- and Lithoclasts - Insiders and Foreigners The redeposition of material derived from preexisting carbonate sediments and rocks is a common process in marine and non-marine environments. Reworking and redeposition can take place early and contemporaneous with sedimentation, or late and post-depositional. Syn- and postsedimentary reworking and erosion produce carbonate clasts. These clasts reflect environmental conditions within the depositional basins as well as the input of material brought into the basins. Constituent clast analysis of extrabasinal material has become a major tool of microfacies studies providing an excellent basis for reconstructing 'lost carbonate platforms' which are recorded only by their relics preserved in small clasts in limestones or abundant clasts of brecc i a ~(Sect. 16.3.2.1). Terminology The two major types of millimeter- to centimetersized redeposited grains are intraclasts and extraclasts (Folk 1959). An intraclast is a carbonate fragment of lithified or partly lithified sediment, derived from the erosion of nearby penecontemporaneous sediment from
Intraclasts
within the basin and redeposited within the same area (Pl. 1617, 8). An extraclast is a fragment of carbonate rock derived from the erosion of an exposed ancient limestone on land outside the depositional basin in which it is found (Pl. 1612, 4). These definitions look succinct, but are in practice somewhat tricky because of the difficulties involved in the precise recognition of the two categories in thin sections. Many authors, therefore, use the term lithoclast (Folk 1962) to characterize both, erosional detritus brought into the depositional area from an outside source (= extraclasts) as well as pieces of semilithified sediment which have been reworked syndepositionally (= intraclasts). The term limeclast (Wolf and Conolly 1964) which designates 'limestone rock fragments and grains' has the same comprehensive meaning. The term was introduced to replace the genetic term 'intraclast'. Genetically, limeclasts embrace however, 'intraclasts' as well 'extraclasts'. It should be noted, that the term lithoclast referred in the original definition only to angular fragments of reworked non-contemporaneous particles of extrabasinal lithified carbonate sediment. Other terms that describe genetic subcategories of intraclasts are plasticlasts, algal intraclasts, pseudo-intraclasts, and protointraclasts. The last term as well as caliche intraclasts refer to diagenetic products. Plasticlasts (Folk 1959) result from the reworking of weakly consolidated lime mud at the sea or lake bottom by waves or currents; the grains correspond to small mud flakes and mud pebbles (Pl. 1617).These micritic particles are usually small (< 0.5 mm); they have the same composition as that of the micritic matrix. Algal intraclasts resulting from reworking of lime mud covered by microbial and algal mats are common constituents of inner ramp and platform carbonates. Pseudo-intraclasts (Wobber 1965)are produced by bioturbation. The breakup of the sediment by burrowing organisms causes variously sized, often angular micritic clasts, which are more or less still in place. Pl~otointraclasts(Bosellini 1964) or autoclasts (Sander 1936) can be formed by early diagenetic movement of sediment related to submarine or subaerial dehydration of the sediment, but also to seismic shocks. The common characteristic is that the boundaries of the separated clasts still fit like pieces of a jigsaw puzzle. Diagenetically formed intraclasts which are still in place also occur in calcareous paleosols. These caliche intraclasts (Siesser 1973) are subaerially broken pieces of caliche crusts (Esteban and Klappa 1983; Francis 1986; P1. 12816). Calclithite is a terrigenous or carbonate-cemented rock consisting of more than 50% carbonate extraclasts,
which are derived from the erosion of older lithified limestones (Folk 1959). The grain size of these rocks ranges from silt to gravel, but is commonly formed in the sand or conglomerate sizes. Many calclithites are typically stream or alluvial fan deposits. Calclithites record rapid erosion and signify a high-relief source area, as shown by the high content of carbonate extraclasts in the lithic sandstones of the Alpine Molasse basins.
4.2.8.1 Intraclasts: Origin and FaciesDiagnostic Types Intraclasts are commonly found in shallow-marine environments, but also are transported to deepwater. Shallow-marine environments in which intraclasts are formed are characterized by wave-dominated regimes and tides that continuously rework carbonate. 'Rip-up clasts' are common in inter- and supratidal settings but also occur in subtidal environments where scouring undermines lithified mud beds (Exuma Sound, Bahamas). Intraclast grainstones are often interpreted as deposits formed by storm wave erosion and reworking of various sediment types occurring in shallow-marine environments. The occurrence in cross-bedded channel fills supports this interpretation. Intraclasts can also originate by desiccation of carbonate muds in supratidal environments (Ainardi and Champetier 1976). Intraclasts formed by seismic events are discussed in Sect. 12.4. Box 4.21. Selected records of ancient and modern 'black pebbles'. 'Black pebbles' are known from ancient paleosols, karstic sinkholes and reworked speleothems,lacustrine ponds, beachrocks as well as from tidal and subtidal carbonates. A model for blackening and blackpebble sedimentation was described by Leinfelder (1987): See Fig. 4.29. Holocene: Barthel 1974; Houbolt 1957;MaiMem 1967; Shim 1973; Shim et al. 1969; Strasser 1984; Strasser and Davaud 1986; Sugden 1966; Van Straaten 1954; Wagner and van der Togt 1973; Ward et al. 1970. Pleistocene: Beach and Ginsburg 1980; Montenat 1981. Tertiary: Freytet 1982; Hafeli 1966; Platt 1992; Shinn and Lidz 1988. Cretaceous: Barthel1974; Cotillon 1960; Francis 1986; Lang and Tucci 1997; Rey 1972; Strasser and Davaud 1983. Jurassic: Enay 1980; Seyfried 1980; Leinfelder 1987. Triassic: Bechstadt 1975, 1979; Bechstadt and DoblerHirner 1983; Eppensteiner 1965; Henrich 1984; Piller 1976; Wignall and Twitchett 1999. Carboniferous: Wilson 1967. Ordovician: Sardeson 1914.
Black Pebbles
Microlithoclasts Limestones predominantly consisting of small angular to subangular micritic grains (sometimes described as 'peloids', Sect. 4.2.2) appoximately equal to or smaller than 0.1 mm are common in deeper-marine shelf, slope and basin settings (Pl. 11412, P1. 13711). These 'small intraclasts' (Wilson 1967) differ from peloids in their low sphericity and greater variation in size and shape. Reef clasts Destruction of lithified reef carbonate leads to the production of reef-derived detritus ranging from millimeter-sized debris to huge blocks up to several tens of meters in size. The smaller fraction consists of mostly angular and subangular lithoclasts, which are commonly deposited on fore-reef slopes or transported to lower slope and basinal settings (e.g. calciturbidites).Because the distribution of many reef organisms (framebuilders, foraminifera, algae) is limited to specific parts of the reefs, the biotic composition of the lithoclasts can be used to reconstruct the source area (Pl. 1616, P1.271 2, PI. 11413, P1. 11512).
Black pebbles The term refers to special types of carbonate clasts and grains predominantly characterized by the distinctive gray or black color of the particles. Although originally summarized as 'black pebbles' (cailloux noirs) two types should now be differentiated: (a) black grains in the sand-size range and (b) dark gray to black angular limestone pebbles (black lithoclasts) millimeters or centimeters in size. Both types occur together with nonblackened counterparts and may be found within the same limestone bed. Black pebbles and black grains are common in lithoclastic packstones (limestone breccias and conglomerates)and oncolitic limestones (forming nuclei of oncoids) but also occur in mud- and wackestones. Black grains: Modem and ancient black grains have been recorded from intertidal and subtidal environments. The grains are usually rounded (whole or broken fossils, peloids, ooids). Together with nonblackened grains they exhibit an often graded salt-and-pepper texture and are common above unconformities and diastems. Intertidal and subtidal blackening of carbonate caliche
reefalhiodastic limestones
high energy grainstones
fenestral limestones coastal conglomerates
,=' icoids with bli 8
1
-
/
Y
1
-
-y
high energy limestones
.
,'-,7,, (XI nuclei
-
/-//
m/
relic pebbles
/
/
(39
low-enelrgy mud-
Fig. 4.29. 'Black pebbles': Black-colored limestone clasts are a valuable tool for identifying partial or complete subaerial exposure of limestones (Strasser and Davaud 1983). The figure displays models for blackening (top) and black-pebble deposition (bottom), based on the study of the Upper Jurassic Ota limestone of the Lusitanian Basin, Portugal (Leinfelder 1987). Blackening is mostly due to plant material. Organic material infiltrates soft or slightly lithified sediments as well as solution cavity fillings within cemented limestones. Black pebbles are in part transported and found in alluvial fans, beach conglomerates and lagoonal settings represented by oncolitic limestones and lithoclastic packstones. Other black pebbles are parautochthonous relicts of brecciated black crusts that were reworked during a transgression.
Significance of Intraclasts
grains was reported from many Holocene carbonates of tropical and nontropical marginal marine environments (Florida, Bahamas, Persian Gulf, Great Barrier ReefIAustralia, Tunisia; North Sea) as well as from hypersaliie lakes (Ward et al. 1970). Both organic matter and/or iron or manganese sulfide as well as clay minerals have been quoted as the blackening agents (Lang and Tucci 1997; Maiklem 1967). Pilkey et al. (1969) proved the necessity of reducing conditions for blackening in an experiment. The salt-and-pepper texture may be caused by laterally migrating tidal channels that erode blackened grains and redeposit them together with nonblackened grains, or it may be the result of landward migrating mudbanks. Erosion and redeposition transport blackened grains and lithoclasts into various sedimentary environments and, therefore, they are found in near coastal areas and supratidal and inland ponds (Fig. 4.29, Box 4.21 and Box 4.22).
Black lithoclasts: Black lithoclasts originate in subaerial environments. Most black lithoclasts are angular
and show evidence of having been fractured. The clast occur at the top of pedogenic sequences and are not graded. The organic matter absorbed on and infiltrating into the grains is derived from rotted plants (high terrestrial plants, algae) and affects mainly unconsolidated carbonate sediments deposited in terrestrial, supratidal, intertidal and subtidal settings (Platt 1992). Black pebbles are associated with their original environment, such as soils (Bechstiidt and Diihler-Himer 1983; Francis 1986). They are also known from tempestites (Aigner 1982) and beac rocks (Pl. 3313). Blackening of lithoclasts derived from soilstone crusts in the Florida Keys has been explained as being caused by 'instantaneous' forest fire heating (Shinn and Lidz 1988). Heating experiments show that limestone pebbles can be blackened at temperatures between 400 "C and 500 "C. Cementation of subtidal sediments within the vadose zone, followed by brecciation and resedimentation can result in the formation of 'black pebbles' (Bechstadt 1975). Lithoclasts deposited in depressions
Box 4.22. Significance of intraclasts in microfacies analysis. Paleoenvironmental proxies Paleocurrent analysis: Intraclast orientation patterns are useful in evaluating wave action and tidal currents in shallow subtidal and peritidal environments (Pl. 1815). It seems likely that the long axes of intraclasts are aligned transversely to the flow (Lindholm 1980). Imbrication of flat pebbles indicates upcurrent orientation. Orientation patterns of mud clasts in turbidites allow bottom currents to be recognized. Seismic shocks: Intercalations of intraformational flat-pebble conglomerates and laterally continuous intraclastic carbonates in subtidal shelf carbonates were interpreted as indicators of possible tsunami effects related to seismic shocks (Kazmierczak and Goldring 1978; Ruffer 1996). Sedimentation patterns Discontinuous sedimentation: Repeatedly bored and encrusted lime clasts in micritic shelf carbonates can be used to reconstruct sea-bottom conditions (e.g. soft-, firm- or hardground) and lithification stages (Chudziekiewicz and Wieszorek 1985). Hardground intraclasts indicate repeated breaks in sedimentation and may mark discontinuity surfaces. Signijj'cance of 'blackpebbles': The occurrence of 'black grains' indicates submarine diastems and unconformities. 'Black lithoclasts' in multicolored breccias point to subaerial exposure and the existence of a vegetation cover. Black pebbles occurring within breccias associated with marls and marly dolomites of lagoonal sequences point to cyclic emersion and karstification producing residual sediments. In general, evidence of blackened carbonate material in limestones should stimulate one to think of breaks in marine sedimentation, partial to complete subaerial exposure, reworking of carbonate strata, changes in sea-level fluctuations, existence of terrestrial plant growth and possibly even forest paleo-fires, as well as the existence of nearby terrestrial environments. Reconstruction of lost platforms and sea-level fluctuations Clast analysis (see Sect. 16.3) is of particular value in evaluating platform- and reef-derived lithoclastic carbonates and breccias deposited on the slope or at the base-of-slope (PI. 1711). The analyses require field studies (abundance and compositional variations of clasts), microfacies differentiation, and biostratigraphical dating of clasts and enclosing matrix (Pohler and James 1989; Stock 1994; Belka et al. 1996). Clues to diagenetic processes Intraclasts are common in Proterozoic shelf and ramps. The influence of storm wave erosion and subsequent erosion is more probable in the formation of these intraclasts than fair-weather processes, because of the extensive sea-floor cementation caused by microbialites carbonates (Sami and James 1993). Reworked dolomite crusts in tidal carbonates may be indicative of early supratidal dolomitization (Germann 1965).
Resediments: Intra-, Extra-, Lithoclasts
170
can be dissolved by organic acids and blackening is induced by bitumen or pyrite. Hardground intraclasts A specific type of lithoclasts are hardground intraclasts (Pl. 2 114, P1. 139110) found in deep shelf or basinal settings, sometimes called 'subsolution clasts'. These grains are mm- to cm-sized irregularly-shaped, predominantly micritic clasts. The surface is impregnated with Fe-Mn oxides (Pl. 2318) and differs therefore in color from the matrix. Microborings as well as biogenic encrustations (foraminifera, serpulids) are common. The clasts reflect repeated phases of erosion, encrustation/impregnation and accretion. The clasts were originally interpreted as a result of submarine dissolution at the sea bottom during inter-
vals of nondeposition (subsolution clasts: Hollmann 1964), but a multistage origin a