A Series of ~ o ~ o g r a p h s Editor: JACK CAZES Cherry Hill, New Jersey
1. Dynamics of Chromatography, J. Calvin Giddings 2. Gas Chromatographic Analysis of Drugs and Pesticides, enj jam in J. Gudzinowicz 3. Principles of Adsorption Chromatography: The Separation of on ionic Organic Compounds, Lloyd R. Snyder 4. MulticomponentChromatography:Theory of lnte~erence,Friedrich He/fferich and Gerhard K/ein 5. ~uantitative Analysis by Gas Chromatography,Josef ~ o v a k 6. High-speed Liquid Chromatography, Peter M. Ra~csanyiand €/isabeth ndamentals of Integrated GC-MS (in threeparts), en jam in J. Gudzinowicz, Mic~ae/J. ~udzinowicz,and Horace F. arti in 8. Liquid Chromatography of Polymers and Related Materials,Jack Cazes 9. GLC and HPLC Determination of Therapeutic Agents (in three parts), Part 1 edited by Kiyoshi Tsuji and Walter Morozowich, Parts 2 and 3 e d i t e ~ by ~ i y o s hTsuji i 10. Biological/Biomedical Applications of Liquid Chromatography, edifed by Gerald L. Hawk 11. Chromatography in Petroleum Analysis, edi~edby Klaus H. A/tgelt and T. H. Gouw 12. Biological/BiomedicalApplications of Liquid Chromatography I I , edifed by Gerald L. Hawk 13. Liquid Chromatography of Polymers and RelatedMaterials I I , edited by Jack Cazes and ~ a v i eDelamare r 14. Introduction to AnalyticalGasChromatography:History,Principles, and Practice, John A. Perry 15. Applications of Glass Capillary Gas Chromatography, edited by Walter G. Jennings 16. Steroid Analysis by HPLC: Recent Appli~tions,edited by 17. Thin-Layer Chro~atography:Techniques and Applica and Joseph Sherma 18. ~iological/~iomedical Applications of Liquid Chromatography I l l , edifed by Gerald L. Hawk 19. Liquid Chromatography of Polymers and Related ~ a t e r i a ~Ill, s edifed by Jack Cazes iological/~iomedical A~plicationsof Liquid Chromatography, edited by Gerald L. Hawk atographicSeparation and E~ractionwithFoamed Plastics and rs, G. J. Moody and J. D. R. Thomas cal Pyrolysis: AComprehensjve Guide, Wi/liam J. in Chromatography Detectors,edi~edby ~ h o m a sM. Vick~ey 24. High-Pe~ormanceLiquid Chromatography in Forensic Chemistry, edited d John D. Wi~wer,Jr. quid ~hromatographyof Polymers, edi~edby ~ o s e~f ~ f f c ~ 26. HPLC Analysis of Biological Compounds: A Laboratory Guide, Hancock and James T. Sparrow
27. 28.
33.
36. 37. 38. 40 41
49. 50.
51.
52. 53.
56
*
60. Modern Chromatographic Analysis of Vitamins: Second Edition, edifed by Andre P. De Leeffheer,Wi//yE. lam be^, and Hans J. Ne/is 61, Preparative and Production Scale Chromatography,edifed by G. Ganefsos and P. E. Barker 62. Diode Array Detection in HPLC, edifed by Ludwig Huber and Stephan A. George 63. Handbook of Affinity Chromatography, edifed by Toni K/ine 64. Capillary ElectrophoresisTechnology, edited by N o r b e ~ o A. Guzman 65. Lipid Chromatographic Analysis,edifed by ~akayukjShibamoto 66. Thin-Layer Chromatography: Techniques and Applications, Third Edition, Revised and Expanded, Bernard Fried andJoseph Sherma 67. Liquid Chromatography for the Analyst, Raymond P. -W.Scoff 68. Centrifugal Partition Chromatography, edifed by A/ain P. Foucau/t 69. Handbook of Size Exclusion Chromatography,edited by Chi-San Wu 70. Techniques and Practice of Chromatography, Raymond P. W. Scoff 71.Handbook of Thin-LayerChromatography: Second Edition,Revisedand Expanded, edited by Joseph Sherma and BernardFried 72. Liquid Chromatography of Oligomers, Consfanfin V. Ug/ea 73.ChromatographicDetectors:Design,Function, and Operation, Raymond P. W. scoff 74.ChromatographicAnalysisofPharmaceuticals: Second Edition,Revised and Expanded, edjted by JohnA. Adamovics 75. Supercritical Fluid Chromatography with Packed Columns:Techniques and Applications,edifed by Klaus Anfon andC/aire Berger 76. Introduction to Analytical Gas Chromatography: Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, Raymond P. W. Scoff 77. Chromatographic Analysis of Environmentaland Food Toxicants, edifed by Takayuki Shibamoto 78. Handbook of HPLC, edifed by Hena Katz, Roy Eksfeen, Peter Schoenmakers, and Nei/~ j / / e r 79. Liquid Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry: Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, W. ~.A. Niessen 80. Capillary Electrophoresis of Proteins, Tim Wehr, Roberto ~Odrjguez-Djaz, and ~ i n g d eZhu 81. Thin-Layer Chromatography: Fourth Edition, Revised and Expanded, ~ e r n a r dFried and Joseph Sherma 82. Counfercurrent Chromafography, edited by Jean-Michel Menet and Didier Thiebaut 83. Micellar Liquid Chromatography, A/ain B e ~ h o dand Celia ~arcja-A/varezCoque
Modern Chromatographic Analysis of Vitamins,Third Edition, Revised and Expanded, edited by Andre P. De Leenheer, ~ i / /E.ylam be^, and Jan F. Van Bocxlaer
M A R C E L
MARCEL DEKKER, INC. D E K K E R
NEWYORK BASEL
This book is printed on acid-free paper.
Marcel Dekker, Inc. 270 Madison Avenue, New York, NY10016 tel: 2 12~696-9000;fax: 2 12-685-4540 Marcel Dekker AC Hutgasse 4, Postfach 8 12, CH-4001 Basel, Switzerland tel: 4 1-61-26I -8482; fax: 4 1-61-26 1-8896 llttp://www.dekker.conl The publisher offers discountson this book when ordered in bulk quantities. For more information, write to Special Sales/Professional Marketing atthe headqLlarters address above,
Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, micro~lming,and recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the pLlblisher. Current printing (last digit): 1 0 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
The ~ I software~was written ~ exclusive^ R for this~ volume by~ Jose' R a n ~ ~Torresn L a p a ~ i~~J, ~ i v e r sofi ~~ a ~ p l o nSpain. a,
When studying micelle-catalyzedpeptide and oligonucleotide formation in late 1974 and 1975, I had no idea that this research would eventually lead to a newbranch of separation science. In the course of these synthetic studies, we hadto separate a variety of products producedin the merization reactions. We subjected the solution containing our products to traditional liquid chromatography on columns up to two meters in length. We noticedthat the elution behavior of the standards we used was completely different when wechromatographed the standards alone as compared to the spiked reaction solution. It soon becameclear that the micellar "catalyst" in the reaction solution was altering the separation. Soon afterwards we found that we could actually use some forms of chromatography to measure the binding constants of various molecules to micelles. In retrospect, my decision to try using micellar solutions as mobile phases in LCwas a logical progression of this work, but at that time, the deliberate use of micelles in analytical chemistry was unheard of and was met with a good deal of skepticism. The first paper on the deliberate use of micelles as a mobile phase for LC was published in 1977. This was quickly followed by successful applications in TLC and HPLC and a theoretical treatment based on the micellar pseudophase. Micellar liquid chromatography (MLC) was about to become a novel part of the great HPLC boom that occurred from the late 1970s through the 1980s. In early July 1980, a session devotedto the analyticalapplications of micelles was given as part of the International Symposium on Solution Behavior of S u r f ~ c t ~ (in n t ~Potsdam, NY). It was a huge success, o V
with standing-room-only crowds. The 1981 Gordon Conference on Catalysis in Micellar and Macromolecular Systems (Wol%oro, NH) also devoted a session to micelles in chemical analysis. The co-organizer of that session was Willie L. inze, who first demonstrated the use of micelles in enhancing spectroscopic analysis. Also, by that time we were using cyclodextrins as beneficial pseudo-phases in separations. At about this same time, the useof separation-based techniques to measure association constants to micelles, cyclodextrins, etc.was also popularized. A largenumber o scientists began investigation^ involving micelles in separations. y the mid-1980~~ the journal ~ ~ a Z ~ t i c a 1 a separate review category for micellar liquid C ~ e ~ i ~had t restablished y chromatography. It is interesting to note that our work on MLC led directly to the use of cyclodextrins in chromatography (and the "chiral separatio~srevolution") as well as to their use in capillary electrop~oresis, The authors of this book are among the leading European scientists in the area of micellar separations research. 0thhavemade significant contributions to the field. Early onI was fortunate to meet AlainBerthod because of his work in MLC. As a result, wehave successfully collaborated on many projects for over one and a half decades. Looking back, two things are most g r a t i ~ i n gabout our development of micelle-based separations. The first is that micellar methods are widely used and have solved many problems for scientists and technicians. Second, I have hadthe opportunity to meet andinteract with many wonderful people all over the world as a result of our joint interest in micellar or pseudo-phase~basedseparations. This is a particularly opportune time for this book. The field is sufficient~ymature that one is able to examine it with a proper perspective and to see how it gave rise and spread into other areas of separation science and analytical chemistry. ~ i c e l l a r ~ i q u i d C ~ r ois~a a t o ~ r a ~ thorough scholarly and practical presentation of all areas of this special separation technique. It is likely that it will be the de~nitivereference volume in this area of research and technology for years to come. Daniel W. Armstrong Curator Profissor Head of the ~nalyticalDivision Department of chemist^ University of ~ i s s o u r ~ - R o ~ l a
Our main concern in starting this almost three-year work was to fill a gap: there was no dedicated book exploring thoroughly the theme of Micellar Liquid Chro~atography(MLC). Several reviews appeare~in different journals. Chapters dealt with MLC in different analytical c h e ~ i s t r ybooks. ever, it was necessary to have a handbook exclusively dedicat the MLC technique. This is the goal of this book. We tried to collect as much infor~ationas poss adding the chemical knowledge needed to develop it. exhaustively the literature for MLC articles up to early to cite every reference with its full title so that the reader has a good idea of the covered topic. We wrote for the specialist, but wetried to explain the d i f ~ c u ~ t points starting from the basics. We shared the work equally. One of us, being interested in the physicochemistry of the micellar media, the role ofthe stationary phase and the efficiency problem, prepared the chapters on these topics. The other, being anexpert in micellar partitioning and modeling and optimization of retention, wrote the corresponding chapters. We corrected each other’s work to obtain some h o m o ~ e n e i ~ . We think that the text will be usefulfor people wanting to start MLC analyses and also for people working in related fields such as the separation methods using micelles and capillary electro~horesis or electrochro~atography.Students specializing in analytical chemist^ will find useful information as well.
From left to right, Alain Berthod, Celia Garcia Alvarez-Coque and Daniel W. Armstrong at HPLC’99 in Granada (Spain), June 1999.
We would like to thank first Jack Cazes and Russell Dekker, who invited us to prepare this book and published it after waiting patiently throughout the writing process. During the progress of the book, we realized that the exposed algorithms, neededto optimize new appIications, were difficult to use. We then asked Professor Jose Rarncin Torres-Lapasici to develop software to facilitate the mathematical treatment. This gave birthto MICHROM, a software program included on a CD-ROM with this book. We cannot thank him enough for this great enhancement of our work. We thank Christelle Garon-Boucher and Laurent Veyre for scanning the literature for crnc and micellar partition coefficient values that allowed usto prepare the important lists of such data included as Appendices. We thank also Joe P.Foley for reviewing our chapter on modeling. We conclude this preface thanking the inventor of the MLC technique, Daniel W. Armstrong, for his continuous support for more than twelve years. Lyon (France) and Valencia (Spain), October 1999 Alain ~ e r ~ and ~ oCelia d GarciaA~varez-Co~ue
Foreword Preface S y ~ b oand l ~ Abbrevia~ions
1.
Presentation of the Book
How theAuthorsBecameInvolvedinMicellarLiquid Chromatography 11. The Technique 111. The Book References
V
vii xiii
1
I.
2.
PhysicochemicalProperties of MicellarMedia 1. 11.
Introduction Surfactant Molecules 111. Surfactant Solutions IV. SolubilizationinMicellarPhasesandMicroemulsions V. Conclusions References
3.
HistoricalDevelopment of MicellarLiquid chromatography I. Ion Pair Chromatography 11. 111.
The Birth of MicellarLiquidChromatography ModernMicellarLiquidChromatography References
9
57
I. Introduction 11. S t a t i o n a ~Phase Characterization 111, Surfactant ~dsorption IV.StationaryPhasesandSelectivity V.Equilibrationand Care oftheColumn References
5.
115 I. Introd~lction 11. The Three-phase Model 111. HybridMicellarMobilePhases IV.EvaluationofPartitionCoefficients V. The SolubilityLimitTheory VI.EffectofpHonRetention VII. Effect of Ionic Strength on Retention VIII. Thermodyna~icProperties Based on the Three-phase Model References
I. Introduct~on 11. ChromatographicProcessandEfficiency 111. ChromatographicProcessandMicellarPhases TV. RemediationofReducedEfficiency V. Conclusion References
173
03 1. Introduction 11. Elution Order Reversals 111. The Choice of Surfactant as a Means to Control Selectivity IV.SolubilityLimitTheoryandSelectivity V.EffectofOrganicModifiersontheElutionStrengthandSelectivity VI.RelationshipBetweenElutionStrengthandSelectivity VII.InfluenceofTemperatureonSelectivity References
24 1 I. Introduction 11. RetentionBehaviorinPureMicellarEluents 111. RetentionBehavior in HybridMicellarEluents at ConstantpH IV.PhysicochemicalMeaning of theEmpiricalModels V.SimultaneousEffect of pH,MicelleandOrganicModifier VI. Neural Networks VII. Factors Affecting the Prediction Capability of the Models VIII. Optimization of the Resolution IX. Easy Modeling and Optimization in MLC with the MIC References
Y
293
9. ~uantitationof I. Introduction 11. RetentionBehaviorofHomologousSeries 111. Quantitative Stru~ture-retentionRelationships IV. Quantitative Retentiol1"activity Relationships References
10. Anal~icalUse of Micellar Liquid Chromatography
343
I. Introduction 11. MicellarChromatography of ProteinsandEnzymeActivity 111. Controlof Pha~aceuticalPreparations IV. Miscellaneous Applications References
apid Analysis of Untreated Physiological Fluids I. Introduction 11. The DirectInjectionApproach 111. Use of MicellarMobilePhases IV. ~ackgroundSignaloftheMatrixFluid Application V. Development VI.Screeningof Illegal Drugs in Sport VII.PreviousSeparationoftheDrugs References
429
12. Enhanced Detection in Micellar Medium I. Introduction 11. Enhanced Fluorescence Detection 111. Sensitized Terbium Fluorescence IV.Micelle-stabilizedRo0m"temperaturePhosphorescence V. Inductively-coupled Plasma-mass Spectrometry VI. Amperometric Detection References
463
13. E x ~ a n d i nthe ~ Micellar Liquid Chro~atographyField I. Introduction 11. UseofOriginalMobilePhases 111. UseofOriginalStationaryPhases IV.MicellarPhasesandIons V.MicellarSeparationsWithout aClassic Column Conclusion VI. References
Appendix I:
M I C H ~ O MSoftware
Appendix 11:
Critical Micelle Concen~ationsof Selected S
501 ~
a 503c
~
~
xij
Appendix 111: Surfactant Association Coefficients
527
Appendix IV: How to Prepare a Ternary Phase Diagram
593
~
597
n
~
~
x
first constant of the Knox equation (flow anisotropy) concentration of free solute in bulk water concentration of solute associated to the micelle second constant of the Knoxequation (longitudinal diffusion) asymmetry factor measured at WO.1 H third constant of the Knox equation (mass transfer) concentration of an added salt to a micellar solution longitudinal diffusion contribution to plate height eddy diffusion contribution to plate height correlation factor for PAH calculated as [(number of secondary double bonds) + (numberofprimaryand carbon atoms) - 0.5 for a nonaromatic ring] mass transfer contribution to plate height alkyl chain lengthof a linear alcohol alkyl chain length ofthe tail of a surfactant molecule stationary phase masstransfer Contribution to plate height stagnant mobile phase mass transfer contribution to plate height solute diffusion coefficient in the mobile phase solute diffusion coefficient in the stationary phase stationary phase particle diameter Fisher coefficient
ICCSO k
AM AS
ieS
MD
Kws
L
fraction of mobile phase inaccessible to the solute fraction of stationary phase unavailable to the solute free energy of cavity formation Cibbs free energy of reaction height at the peak maximum standard enthalpy of transfer from mobile phase to stationary phase 50% inhibitory growth concentration of phenols in the culture of ~ ~ t r a hp y y~ r~ ~ ao ~ ~ ~ ~ retention factor (previously called capacity factor and noted k') retention factor at zero micelle concelltration relative variation in the concentration of solute in bulk water upon addition of a modifier solute-micelle equilibrium constant partition constant between stationary phase and water multiplied by the phase ratio CPC constant solute size depending calculated or predicted retention factor experimental retention factor constant of the ion-exchange equilibriu~at the micellesolution interface constant of the ion-exchange equilibrium at the stationary phase-solution interface relative variation in the concentration of solute in micelle upon addition of a modifier autoprotolyse constant of water (= 10-14at 20°C) relative variation in the concentration of solute in the stationary phase upon addition of a modifier retention factor with a mobile phase of 100% water micellar partition coefficient or solute-micelle distribution constant solute-stationary phase equilibrium constant average distance of a molecule from the wall of a FFF channel
ratio of the ma~imali~ed ien~h-to-breadth ofthe rectan enclosing the molecu~es protonation constant methionine o surfactantformingmicelles(totalconcentration surfactant minus cmc) r molecules perAOT surfactant l ~ o ~ e c u l e micelle a~gregation number(number of surfactant molecules in one micelle) number of carbon atoms in an homologue compound 1-octano~-waterpartit~ollcoefficient coefficient betweens t a t i o n a phase ~ and micelles partition coefficient betweenwaterandmicellesper surfactant molecule pa~itioncoefficient between water ands t a t i o n a ~phase -log of the acid dissociation constantK, amount of adsorbed surfactant quantitation of hydrophobici~index constant of perfect gases resolution factor collcentration of a solute in a micellar medium (=[ [AMI) elution strength parameter in hydro-organic mobile phases elution strength parameter in hybrid micellar systems entropy variation standard entropy of transfer from mobile phase to stationary phase solvent-related properties of solutes absolute temperature delay time (time before the gradient reachesthe top ofthe column) retention timeof a neutral solute moving withthe electroosmotic flow in CE gradient retention time
retention time of amicelle in MEKC dead time time at the peak maximum mobile phase linear velocity total volume of eluent needed to elute a given solute from the column pore volume in GPC stationary phase column dead volume solute retention volume (= V,) volume of the active surface of the stationary phase width of a FFF channel tryptophan width of the peak at 10% of peak height tyrosine
chromatographic selectivity (k2/kl,2 is the most retained solute) methylene selectivity selectivity of a carbonyl group binding selectivity to micelles separation factor or selectivitybetween solute i and solute it- 1 stationary-phase pa~itioningselectivity complexation co"nstant of a metallic ionwith a H2L cornplexing agent complexation constant of a metallic ionwith a HI, complexing agent obstruction factor in stagnant mobile phase obstruction factor in porous or granular material degree of counterion binding to micelles mole percentage of solute in the micelles conce~tratio~ of modifier
organicvolumepercentage in a micellarsolutionor microemulsion phase ratio (=Vs/Vo) thickness of the stationary phase useful layer total concentration of surfactant partial specific volumeof the monomers of surfactant in the micelle P for the R, substituent log , standard deviation linkedto peak width chromatographic variance reduced mobile phase velocity(= ud, /D,) stagnant mobile phase fraction S
ACN AES AOT AY BET BSA CE cmc CMX CTM CTAB C1,TAB CTAC DDTC DF DMA
acetonitrile atomic emission spectrometry sodium diethyl hexyl sulfosuccinate (also called Aerosol OT@) alanyl-tyrosine Brunauer, Emmett and Teller method (using gas adsorption to measure the surface area of a porous material) bovine serum albumin capillary electrophoresis critical micelle concentration (mol/L) cefmenoxime hemihydrochloride cefotiam dihydroch~oride c e ~ ~ ~ i m e t h y ~ a m morohexadecyl~~ethylammonium niu~ bromide tetradecyltri~ethylammoniumbromide hexadecyltrimethylammonium chloride diet~yldithiocarbamate aspa~l-phenylalanine dimethylarsenic acid
ii
NED
dodecyltrimethylammonium bromide dithiocarba~ate ethyl a~lthraqLlinone e~ectrochromatography ~vaporativelight scattering detector ~ a ionization ~ e detector phenyla1any~-phenylalanine field flow fractionation glycyl-leucyl-~rosine gel permationchro~atography(also called sizee ~ c ~ u s i o n chromatography) hydrogen bond acceptor h y d ~ o ~ ebond n donor height equivalent to a theoretical plate high-perfo~anceliquid chro~atography S,8-dideaza-isopt~royl-~-glutamyl-~-glutamic acid inductively coupled plasma massspectromet~ Internationa~Olympic Committee internal surface r~versed-phase limit of detection linear solvation energy relations~ip leucy~-~rosine leucyl-t~ptophan methionylaspa~l-hu~an growth hormone micellar elec~rokinetic chromato~rap~y maleic acid icellar liquid c~romatography ~onomethylarsonicacid micelle-stabilized room t e ~ p e r a t u r e p h o s p h o r i ~ e t ~ N-ace~~-~-cysteine N-( 1-naphtllyl)et~yienediaminedihydroch~oride nuclear magnetic resonance octadecyl-bonded silica 0-ptha~aldehyde
O/W PAH
RPLC SDS
SFC THPA TLC W/O
oil in wateremulsion or microemulsion (aqueous continuous phase) polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon qua~titative retention-activi~ relationship quantitative structure-activi~ relatio~ship quantitative structure-retention relationship Reversed-Phase Liquid Chromatography sodium dodecyl sulfate (sodium lauryl sulfate) supercritical fluid chromatography tetrahep~lammoniumbromide thin layer chromatography water in oil emulsion or microemulsion (organic continuous phase)
erthod investigated the p micell~rsolution microemulsio~sbyusing electroch~ liquid c ~ o m ~ t o g r ~ p h y strong on micellar liquid chro erthod decided to study the ~ o d i ~ c a t i o no sf the station chromatogr~phiccolu
odmetmost
o f theresearchersinvolvedin
Upon returning to Europe, Berthod began work on the reduced efficiency problem in MLC[121. Garcia-Alvarez-Coque began workalso, on theinprovement ofderivatization reactions of organic compounds by the useofmicellarmedia 1131. In the early nineties, Dr. Laserna, another inefor~er'sgroup, involved both Berthed and Garcia-NvarezCoque in the analysis of drugs used illegally in sport [14, 151. At this tine, on Garcia-Alvarez-Coque also began to work onMLC. She wrote a review the solute-micelle and solute-stationary phase interactions [161. Afterwards, ~arcia-Alvarez-Coquebecame very interested in modeling the retention behavior ofsolutes 117, 181. Togetherwith Dr. Torres Lapasio, they prepared the software program~~C~~~~ for the development of MLC applications, that is included withthis book.
Micellar liquidchromato~raphyis an alternative to conventional reversedphase liquid chromatography ( P L C ) with aqueous-organic mobile phases. It joins the advmtages of rnicellar mediawith the separation capability of LC. Themobilephases are aqueoussolutionsofa surfactant at a concentration above the critical micellar concentration (cmc), that is, in a medium where micelles exist. The variety of possible interactions between solutes,micellesand stationary phasegivesa large versatility to this t e c ~ q u eand makes it appropriate for a wide range of solute analyses. ~ i ~ rofehydrop~lic s and hydrophobic compounds c m be separated in one run. This adap~bilityis perhaps the most important characteristic of MLC. Another advantage of the use of micellar solutions as mobile phases is the solubilization of nonpolar molecules. The necessary low amount of organic solvent used in micellar phases is very positive. It reduces the toxicity, ~ ~ a b i l i t y , e n ~ i r o impact ~ e n t aand l cost ofthese phases. Micellarmobilephases have posed,however,someserious problems, that have slowed the development and widespread useof in MLC than that First, the chromatographic efficiency is often much lower
1-
observed with similar colurnns in conventional RPLC. Secondly, the eluent strength of micellarsolutionscanbeextremelyweak. Fortunately, the addition of an organic modifier, such as an alcohol, can greatly remediate both of these problems. The position (retention) and shape (efficiency) of the chromatographic peaks depends on the nature and concentration of the surfactant and modifier, but it can also depend on the mobile phase pH, temperature and ionic strength. All these parameters can be modeled and optimized to provide an adequate separation of a mixture of solutes. The main use of the technique is in the analysis of physiological fluids. Micellar mobile phases are able to maintain proteins in solution. They allowthe direct injectionof biological samples inMLC systems. The protocol of the analysis is dramatically simplified.
. The pioneering workof Armstrong andthe early research performed in focused mainly on the study of the retention mechanisms and principles. ~lthoughsomeinteresting applications were also reportedfrom the beginning, most of the applied work has been done in recent years. The technique has reachedmaturity,andneedsareference organi~ingthe information given by the more than three hundredpapers, publishe~ date. to
It can be thoughtthat working on MLC just is mixing the su~actant with water, and flushmgthe solution throughthe column. As with any other technique,workingwithoutaminimumknowledgewillonly produce sapp pointing or misleading results. The use of micellar solutions, without special care, can easily damage the colurnn and even the chromatographic system. One of the purposes of this book is to expose the procedure to be followed andthe reasons for the problems that can develop. The knowledge of the physicochemical properties of the micellar phases is required in order to use them properly. This is outlined in the following chapter. The use of surfactants in chromatography was first implemented in ion-pair chromatography. This lead to the e m p l o ~ e nof t
in layer c ~ o ~ a t o g r development is reviewed in
to a property ofsurfactants is their ability at stationa~ phasesisdiscussedin several related topics. el e ~ p l a ~ i the n g beh~vi solutes inside the r this model was slightly modi~edand micelle-re~elle~ solutes [ZO] and hybri
re related to efficienc to remedy these problemsare descri~edin ~ h a p t e 6. r True ~icellarphases ( s u ~ a c t+~water) t can be consi~eredmobile phas~swithlowelution str forganic ~ o d i ~ e rmainly s, alco~olsare
to run the s o ~ w ~ r e . c o e ~ c i escale ~ t may not the bebest tool
chapters. ~~ectrophotometric detection has been utilized in most of the also interesting in ons, but other detection modes are Chapter13providesotheruses for organizedmedia, such as ~icroemulsionsor supercriticalfluids,inchromatographic separation. icellar electrokinetic c~omatographyhas attracted more a~entionthan other separatio iques using micellar phases. The connectionof this S also discussed. t e c ~ i ~ with ue odium dodecyl sulfate is the most commonly used s u r f a c t ~ in t ever, there are several thousand varieties of surfactants and can be used as well. ~ppendixI1 tabulates the physicochemical properties selected collection micellar of of partitioning coef~cientsgathered LC literature are also given in ppendix es 111. Fin of diagrams ofphase systems few re1 way to make one that cannot be found inthe literature.
3. 4.
reant, Micellar ~ ~ e cont s rotribu~lamine~mulsionand on ionic Surfactant Solution, Anal. Chem., 53: 1579 (1981). ges, ~ b t e n t i o nd'une ~mulsionde Fine et Mesure de la ~ a i l l ede ses Particules, J: Chim. Phys., 79: 373 (1982). Nome, partition in^ ~ e h a ~ i of o r~olutes bile Phasesin LC, Anal. Chem., 53: 1662 , strong, Application ofPseudophase L i ~ u i d Chromato~raphy:~ i ~ hSelective l y ~ o b i l e ases for present and ~ u t u r e Separa~ons,Am.Lab., 13: 14 (1
5.
6. 7. 8.
9. 10.
11.
12. 13.
14. 15.
A. Berthod, I. Girard and C. Gonnet, MLC. Adsorption Isotherms of two Ionic Surfactants on Jive Stationa~Phases, Anal. Chem., 58: 1356 (1986). A, Berthod, I. Girard and C. Gonnet, Additive Effects on Su~actant Adsorption and Ionic Solute Retentionin MLC, Anal. Chem.,58: 1362 (1986). D.W. Armstrong, T.Ward and A. Berthod, Micellar Effects on Molecular Diffusion: Theore~cal and Chromatographic Considerations,Anal. Chem., 58: 579 (1986). A. Berthod, I. Girard and C. Gonnet, S t a t i o n a ~Phase in U C : Surfactant Adsorp~onand Interaction with Ionic Solutes, ACS Symp.§er. ,342: 130 (1987), in Ordered Media in ~hemical Separations, edited byW.L. Hinze andD.W. Armstrong, American Chemical Society, Washington,D. C. A. Berthod, K.P.Li, T. Yuand J.D. Winefordner, A Simple, Versatile, Low Volume Fluorescence Detectorfor HPLC, Anal. Chem.,59: 1484 (1987). G.Ramis Ramos, M C . Garcia Alvarez-Coque, A.M.O'Reilly, I.M. Khasawneh and J.D. Winefordner, Paper-Substrate RoomTemperaturePhosphorimetry of Po~aromatic ~ydrocarbons Enhanced by Surface-ActiveAgents, Anal. Chem., 60: 4 16 ( l 988). G. Itarms Iiamos, M.C. Garcia Alvarez-Coque, A. Berthod andJ.D. Winefordner, ~luorescencein Microemulsions andReversed micelle^. A Review and New Results, Anal. Chim. Acta, 208: l (1988). A. Berthod and A. Roussel, The Role of the §tationar~Phase in MLC, J: Chromatogr., 449: 349 (1988). J.S. Esteve Romero, E.F. Sirno Alfonso, M.C. Garcia AlvarezCoqueand G. Ramis Rmos, Micellar enhance^ Spectrophotometric Determination of Organic Species, Trends Anal. Chem., 14: 29 (1995). erthod, J.M. Asensio andJ.J.Lasema, MLC for ~ a p i ~ Screening ofIllega1Drugs in Sport, J: Liq. Chromatogr~,12: 262 1 (1989). J. Sabater ~ o n t e s ~ oM. s , C. Garcia Alvarez-Coque, G. Ramis Ramos and J.J. Lasema,On the UseofMLC for Detection ofDrug Misuse in Sport, Quim. Anal. ,11: 163 (1992).
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
M. J.Medina Hemhdez and M C . Garcia Alvarez-Coque, Solute~ o b i l Phase e and Solute-Stationary Phase ~nterac~ons in Mz;C, Analyst, 117: 831 (1992). J.R. Torres Lapasio, R.M. Villanueva Camailas, J. M.C. GarciaAlv Mallols, M.J.Medina Hemimdez and Modeling of the Retention Behavior of Solutes in ~C with Organic Modl~ers,J ~hromatogr. ,639: 87 (1993). J.R.Torres Lapasio, R.M. Villanueva Camaiias, J. Mallols, M. J.Medina Hemhdez and M.C,Garcia AV Interpretive Strategyfor ~ptimization of Surfactant and Alcohol on cent ration in MLC,J. Chromato~r.A, 677: 239 (1994). M.F. Borgerding, F.H. Quina, W.L. Hinze, J. B o w e ~ a s t e rand H.M. McNair, Investigation of the Retention ~ e c h a n i s min on ionic MLC using an A l ~ l ~ e n ~ e n e ~ o m o Series, l o g o uAnal. s Chem., 60: 2520 (1988). P.Jandera and J. Fischer, Chromatographic Behavior in RPLC with Micellar and SubmicellarMobile Phases, JChromat~gr.A , 728: 279 (1996). M C Garcia Alvarez-Coque, J.R. Torres Lapasio and J.J. Baeza, Description of the Partitioning Behavior of Solutes and Data ~reatmentin Mz;C withModi~ers,Anal. Chim. Acta, 324: I63 (1996).
en the surfactant concentration is above a s p ~ c i value: ~ c the c~itical e l k concentratzo~(cmc), the surfactant solution ~ecomesa ~ i c e l l a r chromato~~aphy ( mic~lles, as mobile phases. systems is, thus, required t capabilities of this chromato~raphict e c ~ i q u e . e basic and s ~ p l i ~ e d b a c ~ ~ r o s y s t e ~ sisprovided. The rameters aEectin the cmc
was deli be rat^^ chosen to refer to review articles or books rather than to the manyori~inal ist of micellar
r~actant is a contractionof su y of this class of surfa~eor interfacial t~nsion. ents and a ~ ~ h i ~ h ifrom l e sthe
"philo," whch meanrespectively,bothandloving. molecules love bothpolar and nonpolarmedia. 11.I. ~
e
The amp~phile
~~ e sr c ~r ~ ~ i ~ ~
The ~ p h i p h i l i ccharacter of s u r f a c t ~molecules t is due to the association of twoparts with very differing polarities inside the same molecule[2]. One part is highly nonpolar, hydrophobic or lipophdic, usually an alkyl chain. Another part of the s u ~ a cmolecule ~ t is polar or hydrophilic. It canbe a nonionic chainwith polar groups, such as ether, alcohol or amine groups, or an ionic(anionic or cationic) group. Figure 2.1 shows the schematic representation of a s u r f a c t ~ tmolecule.Some s u r f a c ~ t shave two nonpolar tails or two polar heads,as illustrate^ in the figure. The natureof the sur~actantpolar head is used to classify the molecules.
Schematic representation of ionic surfactants (left) and nonionic surfactants (right). A-c~assicalsurfactants (e.g., SDS,CTAJ3, Brij); B-two-tailed surfacta~ts(e.g., AOT); C-two polar head surfactants (e.g., betaine, Pluronics, Tween 80).
According to the electrical charge of their polar head, the three main classes of surfactants are: anionic surfactants, cationic surfactants, and nonionic andor multisurfactants. A fourth class isaddedfortheamphoteric firnctional surfactants [33. a) Anionic ~ ~ r f u c t a n t s
Inaqueoussolution, the anionic surfactant dissociatesgiving an anion carrying themphiphilic properties and an inactive cation (e.g., Na" or h i o n i c surfactants are the mostcommonlyused active principlesin industrial and household detergent preparations. Soaps, sulfonated compounds, alkylsulfates and alkylphosphates are the four main anionic sufiactant fmilies. Table 2.1 Correspondence Between theHistorical and Normalized Names of Fatty Acids Whose Salts Make theSoaps
number
Nstorical name
IUPAC name
6 8 10
caproic acid caprylic acid capric acid
hexanoic acid octanoic acid decanoic acid
12 14 16 16:1
lauric acid myristic acid palmitic (cetic) acid palmltolelc acid
dodecanoic acid tetradecanoic acid hexadecanoic acid 9-hexadecenoic acid
18 18:1 18:2 18:3
stearic acid oleic acid linoleic acid linolenic acid
20 20:4 22 22: 1 24
arachidic acid arachidonic acid behepc acid qrucrc acid llgnocerlc acid
octadecanoic .acid. 9-octadecenoic acid, 9,12-octadecadienoic acid 9,12,15-octadecatrienoic acid elcosanoic acid 5,8,11,14~e~cqsatetranoic acid docosanoic ap;ld 13 -docosenolcacid tetracosanolc acid
saponification of natural oils and fats produces glycerol an fresh ashes is, probably, the is the reason whyfatty acids a ient n ~ e s dfrom i ~ e r ~ ~ rical names along with the whose sodi~mor potassium salts are the constituents of soaps. oaps are most oftena mi~tureof several s d u r n onified natural oil. roduces a soap whose compositionis oleate, 17% sodiumlinoleate, 6%
y connected to a carbon atom of the
,and the metal cation, The al~ylsulfonates r than 200 m. The ~ Z ~ Z ~ e ~ z e ~ e
d
cleans^^ a~ents.
LL s ~ ~ o s ~ c c have i ~ atwo ~ ehy~ophobic ~ chains, and
are salts of
~ a ~ l s u l f o s u c c i n aesters t e with the formula:
e ~ OT~(sodium ~ o~ ~2y ~~ esulfosuccinate) x y l is a sur [4]. form readily reverse micelles, in organic nonpolar solvents ~ulfosuccinatesabsorb slig~tly light at short w a v e l e n ~ s . the ester group is sensitive to h ~ ~ o l y s iso s ,they can only be used near in neutral solutions.
~
A Z ~ Z s ~ ~ The ~ ~salts e s . of sulhric acid ester form the alkyl sulfate surfactant family. They are produced by sulfation with sulfur trioxide of linear alcohols:
The al~lsulfuricacid formed is a strong acid, easilyneutralized by s o d i ~ or potassium hydroxide. The alkylsulfate aqueous solutionsare neutral and sis occurs in veryacidic solutions. O,Na is the most c o ~ o member n S physicochemical properties have been e~tensively investigated [3,4].
AZ
~
~
~ hisfamily ~ includes s ~
alkylesters of phosp
d
The alkylphosphates are low in aqueous solutions, even at extreme
~ the ~salts ~of thee mono ~i-
.
1
~
TH
t Anionic ~ ~ u ~ ar c t a n t sThe . hydrophilic part of many industrial
surfactant molecules associates an anionic group with a nonionic one [3]. These surfactants have the general behavior of anionic surfactants. Two examples ofsuch composite surfactants are the alkylethers~~ates:
and the carbo~methyletho~ylates~
h aqueous solutions, cationicsudactants are ionized ina cation canyng the amphip~licproperties,and an inactive anion, such as Cl- or Br-. The cationic group is most often a quaternary a ~ o ~ group u m [5]. The general formula is:
R’, Ry’and R,”groups can be identical e hydrophobic chain. The . The cetyl or hexadecyl trimethyl onium bromide C ~ ~ H 3 ~ - N ( c HBr3)~, is the cationicsurfactant most studied. Alkyl t r i ~ e t h y l a m ~salts o ~ iand ~~ d i a l ~ l d i m e t h y l a m m o salts n i ~ ~are non UV-absorbing sudactants, very stable in aqueous solutions.
A variety of cationic sudactants are derived from pyridine and imidazole, such as the a l ~ l ~ y r i d i n salts i ~ mandthe a l ~ l i~lda~olidi~ salts. These salts are very stable in aqueous solutions, but absorb whichmakesthem difficult to beusedin MLC. Also, surfactants associating a nonionic polyosyethylene chain with a cationic terminal group have been designed [5].
Nonionic surfactants are not salts, obviously, they do notgiveions in solution [6]. The hydrophilic part of their molecule containspolar groups
such as ether, alcohol, carbonyl or amino groups. Nonionic surfa~tants are stable in aqueous solution andare a little sensitive to the ionic stre are c o ~ e r c i a l l y water hardness. A variety ofnonionicsuxfactants available: 90% or more of these surfactants are obtained by polycondensation of ethyleneoxide. The alkyl ethuxylates:
can be referredto asC,E,, with m,the carbon number of the alkyl chain and n, the ethylene oxide number of the hydrophilic polyoxye~ylenechain. ese s u ~ a c ~are t snon absorbing molecules, usefir1 in MLC. e ethylene oxide pol~erizationstep in their synthesis?the alkyletho are mixtures of molecules with the same hydrophobic alkyl chain and a hydrop~licchain, having a different number of ethylene oxide units [6]. For example, the polyethylene 20 stearylether, marketed as rij@78, was found to contain only 30% of C18E20. It also contains 25% of Cl8E,1, 25% of C18E1g7 10% of a mixture of C18E22 and longer hydrophilicchains and 10% of a mixture of molecules with lessthan 19 ethylene oxideunits. It is possible to adjust both the hydrophobic chain length and the ethylene oxide condensation in the nonionic surfactant S properties of the final molecule can be tuned well to the needs. a lineofnonionic chemicalcompanieshavedeveloped suxfactants. A s an example, Table 2.2 lists the characteristics s u x f a c ~ t sfrom the IC1ChemicalCompany [6]. The physicochemical properties of solubili~ation, emulsification, wetting, cleansing and detergency, foamingor antifoaming, are very different amongthe members of the Brij farnily. The hydro~~lic-lipophilic balance value (HL as the ratio of the molecular weight the of hy~ophilicgroup to the molecular weight of the nonionic surfactant time 20, is used to sort the suxfactants in a 0-20 scale, from the more hydrophobic (low HLB value) to the more h y d r o ~ ~ l i Two c . surfactants with similar HLB values may have differing behavior, due to the very differing molecular weights. Furthermore, some batch to batch variation of the homologue distribution may occur for the same suxfactant. It must be pointedout that the formula given in Table 2.2 correspond to the average homologue molecule. The actual dist~butionin
ethylene oxideunits around the indicated value mayvary widely. It canbe noted that the CAS (ChemicalAbstract Service) number givento the CmE, chemicals is often relatedto the alkyl chain lengthonly.
Alkyl EthoxylateNonionic Surfactants of the BrijO Seriesa
30 35 52
C12E4 C12E23
10.2 17.2 5.6
52744-68-0 9002-92-0 9004-95-9
56 58 72
C16E10
13.2 16.0 5 .2
9004-95-9 9004-95-9 9005-00-9
12.7 15.5 5.2
9005-00-9 9005-00-9 9004-98-2
12.7 15.5
9004-98-2 9004-98-2
18.9 15.7
9005-00-9 9005-00-9
76 78 92
c1sE2
c16E20 C18E2 c18E10
c1sE20
C18:IE2
97 99 700 72 1
C18E100
C18E21
C,E, is the alkylethoxylate surfac~ntwith m ethylene oxideunits and n carbonatoms in the alkyl chain. c18 and cl,;,correspond tothe stearyl and oleyl hydrophobic groups, respectively.
a
The c o ~ o Z y ~are e r another ~ family of nonabsorbing nonionic sufiactants, in which the hydrophilic chain an is ethylene oxide polymer, and the hydrophobi~chain is a propylene oxide polymer.The two polymers can be connected in one or several points. For example, the PluronicO series dotte Chemicals Corporation are block copolymers withthe general formula:
Structure and Commercial Denomination of the Block Copolymer Nonionic Surfactants ofthe PluronicOSeries'
10%
20%
40% 30%
50% 80% 70% L35
L3 1
I900
1100
L42
L43
L44
L6 1
L62
L63
L64
2000
2200
l500
1700 2500
4800
2000
F6
8700
2900
L72
4100
2800
P85
L8 1
4500
2500
F77 6800
F87
7500
L101
4 700
3600
L121 4500
122
P123
P104 5400
0 14000
4600
103
F3
F108
105
16200
6500
F127
13300
b is the number of oxypropylene units (hydrophobic) the in surfactant molecule. The room temperature appearance ofthe surfactant is:L = liquid, P = paste, F = flakes. The numbers in italics under the codes are the surfactant average molecular weights.
a
y changing the oxyethylene (a) and oxypropylene (b) unit numbers, it is possible to build luronic homologues with a wide variety of properties. Table 2.3 lists the~olecularweights of the various embers of the Pl~ronic series. The m~ufacturercode includesa letter: L for liquid (low molecular weight), P for paste and F for flakes (solid with high molecular weight), and a two or three-digit number. The first or the first two digits correspondto approximately one fifth of the oxypropylene units in the molecule, and the last digit indicates the oxyethylene percentage in the molecule. For example, Pluronic F68 is a solid whose meanb value is about 6 .5= 30, and whose mole~ulecontains 80% of polyoxyethylene. The approximate mass of the lipophile pol~oxypropylenecentral block is1740. This corresponds to 20%
of the molecular weight ofF68, which is estimatedto be 1740/0.20= 8700, with 7000 (80%) as the mass ofthe two hydrophilic polyoxyethyleneblocks. The a value is close to 80. ther nonionic surfactant molecules includethe et~oxyzatedaZ@Z p~enoZs,which strongly absorb W light, and the e t ~ o ~ ~ afatty t e dacids, fatty esters andal~ano~amides, which are slightly absorbing nonionic su~actants[6]. The amine oxides, such as the alkyl dimethyl amineoxides:
are no~onic su~actants in basic and neutral solutions. They are protonated in acidic solutions and, thus, represent the transition to cationic su~actants.
Amphoteric su~actantsare ionic sudactants containing positive and negative charges on the same molecule [7]. They can be true amphoteric ions, such as the betaines:
with n r 1, that have a cationic nature in strongly acidic media and an amphoteric structure in neutral and basic solutions. These su~actantshave a mo~ileproton with a pKA valuearound 4. In s~~obetaines, the carboxylic a sulfonic group, -SO3- (pKA
-
The aminocarboxyZi~acids:
are ampholytes: they are cationic surfactants in strongly aci&c media, and anionic s u d a c t ~ t sin basic media, and possess an isoelectric point at an inte~ediatepH value, with an inner salt amphoteric structure. Natural
L-amino-acids are the building blocksof proteins and made a science theme by themselves. Other amphoteric surfactants include the betaines derived from imidazolines,which absorb W light and the lecithins or phosphati&cholines, whch are naturally occurring phospholipid§[7]. surfactants associating a nonionic moiety with a charged one are considered ionic surfactants.
~urfactantmolecules are water soluble and produce solutions with unique properties, due to the amphiphilic nature of the solubilized molecules. The two mainproperties of surfactant solutions are the a ~ s o ~ ~ t at i oany n interface andthe micelleformation. These are a consequence of polar and nonpolar interactions withthe sufiactant molecules.
a)
~ o ~ e c u1nteractlons ~ar
The interactions between moleculescan be sorted following an increasing polarity order as: (i) van der Waals forces, (ii) hydrogenbonding interactions, and (iii)electrostatic forces,
van der Waals Forces. These forces cover a variety of short distance range interactions, whose intensity decreases with the sixth power of the distance between two molecules. They include the London or dispersion forces between nonpolar molecules, the Debye forces between the p e ~ a n e n t dipole of a molecule and the induced dipole of another molecule, and the Keesom forces or dipole-dipole interactions between two polar molecules. The order of magnitude of van der Waals forces is 2 kJ/mol for polar and moderately polar molecules, and less than 1 kJ/mol for nonpolar molecules
[SI
*
e notion o f ~ y ~ ~ oint~~action ~ ~ o ~ was i c we1 r solute is dissolved in solute tends to locally restrict the motion of water molecules. water molecu~esis associate^ with the is entropy increase is responsible for the surface aq~eoussolution [g]. a c t i v i ~and micelle f o ~ a t i o of n s~rfactantmolecules.
ilic character of surfactant molecules e~plains interface. Two phases of different pol larity difference attracts the surfactant molecules because this can ze the entropychangeby putt in^ their polar r phase and their nonpolar part in the less polar phase. surfactant molecule arrangementat the liqui~-liqui The adso~tionof surfacta~tmolecules inter~acialtension. The decrease ofthe water-ai prope~y.The addition of a sur ers emulsion ~ o ~ a t i possible on liquid i~terfacialtension. etting and detergency are two imp0
properties of s u ~ a csolutions ~ t dueto surEactant adsorption at S e decrease of surface tension bysu~actantadsorp In ~ a t ~ r - ainterface ir depends on the s u r f a c ~ nconcentration. t s u ~ a c tadsorbs ~t on the s ~ t i phase o ~ c h~ a n ~ i nits~ nature and p o l a ~ ~ .
re Surfactant adsorption at interfaces. Left, liquid-liquid interface, the hydrophobic tails points towardthe less polar liquidphase. Right, air-water interface.
The second most important property of sudactant solutions is the micelle fo~ation.
Figure 2.3 shows that the physicochemical properties of a surfactant solution, such as the surface tension, undergo an abrupt change over a narrow concentration range. This concentration is called the critical micelle c o n c e n t ~ ~ t ~(cmc) o n of the surfactant. Above this concentration, micelles are present. Figure 2.4 shows a typical micelle for an ionic su~actant[101. The su~actantmolecules orientate in such a way that their polar heads face the water phase and their nonpolar tails aggregate in the waterless micelle core.
P5
Figure 2.3 Physicochemical changes related to micelle formation at the critical micelle concentration(cmc).Density andrefractive indexare two parametersalso affected by micellization (not shown).
~"--"-"""""
"
-I_""."
"
e
-"
X to 40 n
Figure 2.4 Representation ofan ionicmicelleaccordingto Hartley [lo]. The GouyChapman layer corresponds to the diffuse layer under the electric fielddue to the micelle. The Stern layer co~espondsto the ionic groups.
b) A Very S
~~
~o
~~
~e
e~
Using a closed association model, micelle formationcan be representedby:
in which N is the uggregution number or number of s u ~ a c tmolecules, ~t S, in the micelle aggregate. The equilibrium constant corresponding to Eq. 2.1 is:
G
~ t r o d u c the ~ gsurfactant concentration, C, and the percentage ofs u r f a c ~ t molecule forming micelles,"Prn,the following is obtained: K =
Figure 2.5 shows the valueof for bfferent sodium concentrations. At a critical c entration, the cmc, sharply. The cmc can be calculated as:
C . -
Micelle andmonomerproportionrelated to thesurfactant (SDS) concentration. Left ordinate: Amountof surfactant molecules in micelles (Q in Eq. 2.3).Right ordinate: monomer surfactant concentration.
micelle, andthe cmc is 8.2 the theoretical value molecule§ addedab
mc value). The micelle concentration was then only a tenfold increasein the overallsu~actantconcentration
verysimple, the closed association modelgives surfactant micellization.
an approximation to
The free energy of micellef o ~ a t i o n , C", is expressed by:
is the gas constant and T is the absolute temperature. Using the chemical potential, yo,the law of mass action is:
which in the subscripts stand for s u r f a c t ~ tmonomer an surfac~ntin micelles, respectively. From Eq. 2.4, it can be derived:
qs, I!.5 and 2.7 and notingthat the agg~egationnumber, most cases higher than 20 gives:
Finally, the entropy change,
O,
due to the micelle formation is:
S" = d A ~ / d T= R In cmc +
(2.9)
Increases in the cmc with temperature are often observed experimentally, which means that the AS" term is most oftenpositive. icellar solutions are sometimes called ordered media [121. The chemical order in a micellar solution seemsto be greater than in a classical solution. Equation 2.9 shows that the micellization ofsurfactant molecules obeys the second principle oft h e r m o d y n ~ c s .It seems that the surfactant h y d r o ~ b o nc h s have a much higher freedom of motion inside the micelle core than in the water bulk [131. The micelle structure minimizes the molecule energy. The large entropy increase of water molecules associated with the removal of nonpolar surfactant tails from the aqueous solution (hydrophobic eEect) is the main micelle driving force. Electrostatic forces tend to separate the polar heads that bear the same charge. The whole micelle is an e~uili~rium between these forces. This equilibrium is very sensitive to any chemical additive orparameter that can act on any of the forces, such as: salts, polar or nonpolar solutes,temperature and/or pressure.
The micellestructure is dynamic. The whole micelle aggregate has a finite mean lifetime.Fu~hermore,a given micelle existingat a given time, rapidly exchanges some surfactant monomers with the neighboring solution [141, The dynamic character of micellesis characterized by two relaxation times, as illustrated by Figure 2.6 [l51. The firstrelaxation time, r ~ g i n fiom g lO-* S to lom4 S , corresponds to a rapid monomer exchange between the micellar aggregate and the bulls solution. It can be considered as the mean lifetime of an individual surfactant moleculein the micelle [l S]. The second relaxation time, in the range of l 0-3S to -1 S, measures the lifetime of the aggregate itself. A decreasein sizeisfirst observed,followedby the vanishing of the aggregate, while other s u ~ a cmolecules ~ t are aggregating to form a new micelle (Figure 2.6).
FS
Figure 2.6 Dynamic exchange inmicelles. Slow process (msto S): micelle formation from monomers tomicelle through intermediateaggregates. Rapid exchange (in the ps range): exit and entrance of individualsurfactant molecules.
The micelle core is nonpolar. It contains somewater molecules [161, but its overall polarity is much lowerthan thatof water. The micelle core can be, thus, compared to a nonaqueous phase. However,due to the dynamic micelle ~ u c ~ a t i o nits ,is not exactly a phase. The micellar phase is often o - ~ it~ isunot ~ possible e , to separate it fiom the called a ~ ~ e ~ ~ because aqueous phase. When the aqueous phase is removedbydrying or evaporation, the crystalline form of the surfactant is obtained. This form is not identical to the micellar pseudo-phase, which is a hydrated form of sudactant molecules.
In a micellar solution,it is convenient to view the volume occupied by the surfactant molecules associated inmicelles as a phase. From a
practical point of view, the volume percentage ofthe micellar phase,qm,is Vm
-
= (C cmc) V
(2.10)
where v is the sur~actant~oZar v o Z ~ in ~ L/mol, e or volume occupied by one mole of s u r f a c ~in t the a ueous solution. For example, in a 0.1 ,v = 0.246 L/mol), 2.26% ofthe volu solution(cmc = 8.2 qm= 0.0226 (Eq. 2.10). The aque micellarpseudo-pce occupies the remaining 97.74% of the liquid volume, correspo qm.The q p ,value is usedto obtain the aqueous and micellar pseudo-p~ase volumes, 'va and Vm,respectively:
and
is the actual volume ofthe cellar solution. evaluate the solute and Vmvolumes are us ses, the solute micellar p m coe~cient, also call micellar ~ i ~ ~co~stant, ~ i and ~ ~ the ~ solute o local n concentr micellar or aqueous phase.
e micelle size depends onthe aggregation number. cture of micelles should be kept in mind. There is size due to the endless micelle creationldest size distribution curve for the surfactant solution is illustrated in Figure 2.7. ~ZceZZesare, in fact, an a~imateddist true single monomers;4 . 5 ~0-3 1 M (56%) are ihmers, trimers nts of higher aggregates (Fi~ure2.7). The average micelle aggregation number at 20°C and 0.1 surfactant concentration is
ED1
62, although there is, a c ~ a l l ya, Gaussian distribution centered onthe value
F i ~ ~2.7 re The distribution curve of theaggregatescontained ina 0.1 M SDS solution at 20°C. The SDS micelle aggregationnumber varies from 50 to 80 with an average value of 62.
The micelle shape dependson thesurfactant concentration. Spherical micelles(Figure 2.4) are found at a sudactant concentration near the cmc. The average diameter of SDS micelles is about 2 nm or -2OA in concentrations near the cmc. As the sudactant concentration increases, the micelle size andshape can change. Oblong, rod-lke or cylindrical micelles may be formed. The length and breadth of the rods or cylinders are in the low nm range (few tens of A). At high surfactant concentration, a viscous middle phase, a hexagonal structure andor a neat phase with a liquid crystal structure are observed with some surfactants [171. Figure 2.8 shows the molecular a~angementin some possiblestructures thatmay be found[181.
THOD an
It is notpossible to useviscoussolutions as mobile phases in liquid . Only relatively diluted micellar solutions with spherical chromato~raphy micelles will beuseful.
Possible physicochemical structures observed whenthesurfactant concentration in water increases. The lamellar and hexagonal structures have liquid crystal properties (from[1S]).
As s h o w in Figure 2.3, the particular concentration at which numerous properties of the surfactant solution change, is the cmc of the s u d a ~ ~ t . This value is very importantto h o w . The micelle is formedby an equilibrium betweenthe hydrophobic eRect, due to the lipophilic part of the sudactant molecule, and the polar forces of the polar part of the molecule.
This equilibrium is sensitive to numerous parameters, and any change in the surfactant or e ~ p e ~ m e n tconditions, al willaEect the cmcvalue as described below.
a) Su~actantS~uctureand the cmc The first parameter acting on the cmc value is the s u ~ a c t a n t s t ~ c t A u~e. longer hy~ophobicchain. will renderthe surfactant more hydrophobic and promote micelle f o ~ a t i o n .For the homologous surfactant series, the cmc can be relatedto the alkyl chain lengthby: lncmc=a-bn,
(2.13)
in whch a and b are constants, and is the number of carbon atoms in the alkyl chain. Table 2.4 lists the regression parameters for Eq. 2.13, fitted with the crnc data obtained from members of the three main classes of s u r f a c ~ t s .Table 2.5 gives the cmcs of the three homologous series. The polar head nature affects the cmc. The nonionic surfactants have much lower cmc valuesthan ionic surfactants with similarlipophilictail. The cmc value also decreasesrapidlywith the numberof carbon atoms in the nonpolar alkylchain. It can be seenthat the cmc of the two ionic s u r ~ a c ~ t homologues decreasesto a half when the nonpolar alkyl chain increases by one m ~ y l e n unit. e With one more methyleneunit, the cmc of the n o n i o ~ c surfactant homologues is decreased bya factor hgher than 3.Therefore, the cmc ofa non-ionic surfactant is two or three orders of maptude lower than the cmc ofthe ionic surfactant with a similar alkyltail. Regression Parameters of the In (cmc) vs. n, Curvesa
Homologous series
a
aa
ba
r2a
3. lb 4.3 4.8
0.65b 0.70 1.21
0.996 0.998 0.999
a = intercept, b = slope, r = regression coefficient. 4OoC,other values are for 25".
LV Experimentai Values of cmc(n")for Homologous Series of Surfactants
18
atomsCarbon
C,SO,
Na+
r-
8 16
10 14
12
140
33
8.6 0.23 0.582.2
300
69
16
3.7
0.9
0.3
C, corresponds to an alkyl chain withn carbon atoms; CnEmis the alkylethoxylate surfactant of the anionic alkyl with m ethylene oxide units andn carbon atoms in the alkyl chain. The cmc sulfate surfactants are given at 40°C [19]. Thecmcof the cationic [20] and nonionic surfac~nts[21] are given at 25°C. a Values estimated using the regression parameters of Eq. 13 given in Table 2.4 due topoor water solubility.
Values of cmc( m w for Different n-Dodecyl Surfactants at 25°C [22]
20
crnc
8.2 1.3"
crne
15
4 3 0Polar
10
12b
-E3
head
crnc
0.058
0.080
At 54°C Potassium tridecanoate or C,,-COOK c Dodecylsultaine Dodecylbetaine.
a
l .2
1.5
Table 2.6 compares the cmc values of a n u ~ b e r surfactants. It shows that the number of charges on the polar he p a r ~ e t emore r import than the electrical sign (positiveor counterion is e~ually~ p oby ~ its n~mber t o~charges. especially, nonionic su~actants have lower cmc v c o r r e s p o n ~ gcharged su~actants. b) ~ ~ eofc~ te ~ ~ e r a t u r e
e forces involved with the polar heads of ionic surfa ar or hydrogenbonding fo forces very diEerent from rature acts very di~erently with n o n i o ~ csurfactants. types of forces, therefore, the effect of temperature on s h o u l ~be studied separately from the effect on nonionic
Igure 2.9 shows the variation in. solubility with t
~ o zwas ~ t described by
ionic solided
surfactant i
later found that
,the micelle structureis an e~uilibriu lar heads andthe a~ractionforces b
chains. The tempera~remay affect differently thesetwo comp~ing forces. "h effect of temperature on the cmc values is often complex. At tempera~reshigher than the KraB point, the cmcof most ionicsudactants increases slightly.
0
Temperature dependanceof the SDS solubility. The lSraflEt point of SDS
is close to 15°C. The Kraffl boundary plateauis around 18°C.
u cmc mvalue can esist. This is the case of S cmc is at 29°C and increasesat hgher temperatures, as illustrat~~ by Figure 2.10. A 20% increase in the cmcof SDS is noted between 30°C and 60°C. The cmc of d o d e c y l ~ chloride, o ~ ~ a at 25°C (Table 2.6)and 1.7 X10m3 examples givean idea of the magnitudeof the effect of temperature on the cmc of ionic s u ~ a c t a n ~ .
A~
~~
.7 %am Point ("C) of Some Surfactants 1131.
JSraffk point
8
15
30
45
Surfactant
Sodium dodecanoate
Sodium tetradecanoate
Potassium tetradecanoate
Calcium tetradecanoate
36
53
8
>loo"
"."."....*.....~..."."*"~~."*~."..~."..~"*..~".*.*..~.~*."..~~~.*"*.~~.....".".."..~~"~~......."..~
IG-affk noint
The high Kram point of calcium surfactant salts is responsible for the precipitation of calcium soaps in hard waters .
35
~
O
n
1
T~mp~ratu (oC) r~ 2.10 Temperature dependance of some surfactant cmcs. Thick line and left ordinate: SDS. Thin lines and right ordinate: polyoxyethylene octylphenol with two ethylene oside units (E2), five units (ES)and nine units @g).
~ ~ ~ - ~z~ ~r ~f z~ c c These ~ ~ surfactants ~ ~ s . donot present the
wever, a nonionic micellar solution becomes turb ases when the temperature israise , Ths is the c Z o ~ ~ i n ~ polyoxyethylene chain,the polar art of most on-ionic s u r f a c ~ t s is , progressively dehydrated as the temperature raises. Losing water molecules, the polyoxyethylene chain becomes less polar and, at a particular temperature, a turbidity, the clouding, appears. n t nonionic surfactant solution. is called the c Z o ~ ~ ~ oofithe S e nonionic rnicellar solution onionic surfacta~t,and an containing the major part of the su~actant.
T
Cloud Point in "C
of SornePluronic@Nonionic
Surfactants."
?h ~ u r f a c ~Code nt
L3 l L6 1
6
Ethylene oxide unitsb
Solution Solution
4
37 24 20 1 1
29
5.4 8
12 77 2
22 40 46 50 74
82 5
1
?h
17 16 11 10 0 2 6 6 90
Surfactants are described in Table 2.3. In Phonic@ copolymers, the number of ethylene oxide units is referred as 2a, e.g. L31 contains 8 ethylene oxide units.
The cloudpoint temperature dependson the concentrati~nof surfactant. Itincreases si~ificantlywith the polyoxyethylene chain length, but scarcely depends on the polar chain length. As an example, the cloud points of some nonionic Pluronic surfactants (see Table 2.3) are listedin Table 2.8. The nonionic micelle size and aggregation number increases dramatically with temperature. It can be stated that the aggrega~onnumber becomes idlnite at the cloudxng temperature. As illustrated by Figure 2.10 (polyoxyethyleneoctylphenol surfactants with 2 (E2), 5 (E5) and 9 (E9) oxyethylene units), the cmc of a minimumvalue for a specific nonionic su~actantsmaypresent tempera~re. Often the increaseof temperature produces a continuous increase of cmc (E2 on Figure 2.10). h all cases, the cmc variations with temperature are on the order of 1% per "Cor less.
c) E ~ e cotf Added E ~ e c t r o ~ t e s The cmc of ionic surfactants is always depressed bythe presence o f a d ~ ~ d electrolytes. Shinoda [24] proposed the semi-em~iricalequation: / kT -A6/z In (cmc +
(2.14)
in which is the carbon number of the surfactant alkyl chain, free energy difference per methylene group between the monome~cand micellar state, 6 is the degree of counterion bindingto the micelle, z is the valency of the counterion, C,, is the added electrolyteconcentration, and A and B are constants. This equation was proposed in a similar form by other authors [25, 261, q.2.14 shows that the cmcofionic surfactants decreases e~ponentiallywith the concentration of any added electrolyte. It has been shown that the nature of the ion with the same charge as the ionic surfactant is not critical, i.e., sodium chloride, sodium sulfate or sodium phosphate similarly decrease the crnc of sodium dodecyl sul potassium or cesium chloride would change the counteri which wouldproduce a different slo e in the In (cmc) versus
NaI, and to 2.1 X lo-, M (a 75% decrease at 40°C), when 0.03 M CsClis added [22]. The cmc of nonionic surfactants is also decreased by added salts
[l l]. The effectiveness ofsalts in alteringthe cmc of nonionic s u r f a c ~ t s follows, approximately, the lyotropic series [111, whch is for anions:
and for cations:
The magni~deof the effect is, however, much lowerfor nonionic than for ionic s u r f a c ~ t s .For example,the cmc of C,4>E,,is 1.l X lom4 M at 25°C. The addition of 0.03 M NaCl decreases the cmc by5%, that is,only to 1'05 . It startsto s i g ~ f i c ~ t ldecrease y when the added salt on cent ration is above 0.1 M. Thus, to obtain a 55% decrease in the crnc, it is necessa to add as much as 0.86 M NaCl[22] (cmc = 5.5 XlO-' M). 0, or NaSCN, or 0.43 M Na2S04 or CaNO, are added, becomes 5.5 M, 8.5 XlO-, M, 2.3XlO-'Mand '7.6 The depression ofthe cmc by added salts is the result of a decrease in the repulsive forces between the ionic headgroups of the surfactant molecules. The micellization becomeseasier, since the hydrophobic effect on the non-polar chains is little modified or slightly enhanced (salting out effect) by the added electrolytes[28]. Also, the aggregation number of ionic micellesenlarges dramatically whichmaychange the micellarphase viscosity. The effect of salts on the cmc of a surfactant should be kept in mind when usingMLC. It is often necessaryto buffer the micellar phases using electrolytes.
d) ~
~of S eo ~ ~ c e n~~ s
~n~~ress~re
The addition ofan organic modifier is common in MLC, however, this can change the cmcvalue ofthe s u r f a c t ~used. t It is also important to consider the effect of pressure on the micellar state of surfactants, since pressure is a driving parameter in liquidc~omatography.
S OF M I C E L MEDIA ~~
Table 2.9 Effect of Short Chain Alcohols and of Pressure on the cmc of SDS and Decyl Trimethyl A~moniumBromide (C,,TAB) at 25°C [43]"
cmc
Alcohol V h
M
~~~
Mole fraction
%
Me~anol
0.45 0.57 0.14 3.6 0.88 7.7 1.9 4.013.2 0.122 20.0 5.9
0.9
%
(M)
0.0025 16.2 23.9
0.008
0 079
0.063 0.059 0.068
Ethanol 7.0 13.4
l .2 2.3 3.1 0.010.101 4.6 22.4
1
18 27
14.8
0.045 0.064
0.006
0.056 0.055 0.060
n-Propanol 3.2
14.3
0.43 7.0 0 -94 1.5 17.2 2.3
l
5.7 0.03 11.2 0.0013 0.030 9.2
0.018 0.039 0.0038 0.0006
Pressure
l 0.019
cmc ( ~ )
kg/cm2
p.s.i.
SDS
500 l000
7000 14000
0.0090 0.0094
ClOT 0.067 0,067
"The crnc of SDS and C,,TAl3 in pure water are0.0082 M and 0.068 M,respectively, at25°C and atmospheric pressure.
~uzvents.Short chain alcohols decreasethe cmc of ionicsurfactants at low concentration, but a cmc increase is also oRen observed for methanol and ethanol at larger concentrations (Table 2.9). Longer alcohols decrease the cmc, as illustrated by Figure 2.11. It has been observedthat the longer the alkyl chainof the linearalcohol, the higher the eEect on the cmc of potassium dodecanoate 129,431. Dioxane, the solventwith the lowest polarity and still fully miscible with water, decreases the solution average dielectric constant. It was generally foundto increase somewhat the cmc of surfactants. For example, the cmc of S 50%) in a 10% w/w and 25% w/w dioxane solution, respectively, at 2 122). Urea is a compound known for m o ~ ~ i the ng liquid water structure and for increasing the solution dielectricconstant [l l]. slightlyincreases th c ofionic surfac~nts. S is unaffectedby 2 rea andbecomes 9.0 urea solution at 25°C 1221. The cmc of dodec romide is 1.5X 10-2M in pure water, it becomes 2. (+200%), in 2 M and 4 M urea solutions, respectively [22]. ~ r e s s ~ rTable e . 2.9 also lists the eEect of pressure on the cmc of . Extreme pressures (2000 kg/cm2 or 28,500 p.s.i.) produce only small changes ( 4 0 % ) in the cmcs. It can be considered that the pressure used inclassical liquid chromatography,in the 40-200 kgjcm2range, will not change the cmc ofthe surfactant used. e) ~eterm~natlon of cmc V ~ ~ u e ~ Figure 2.3 shows a variety of physicochemical changes of the surfactant solution occurring when micelles form. The measurement of any one of these properties can be usedto determine accurately the cmc ofa s u r f a c ~ t . ~ ~ ens ion ~ ~ e ~ s ~ cr e ~The ee nmost t , commonly used cmc determination method is the surface tension measurement [22]. Figure 2.2 shows that the surfactant molecules orientate at the solution air-water i n t e ~ a ~ e . This surfactantadso~tiondecreases the surfacetension. The magnitude of the tension decrease depends onthe free monomer surfactant concentration. As shownby Figure 2.5,the free surfactant monomer concentration reaches a plateau for surfactant concentrations above the cmc. As the surfactant concentrationisincreased in the aqueous solution, the surface tension
1 EEect of normal alcohols on the CMC of potassium dodecanoate (25OC). Micelles does not form in concentrated alcohol solution(3M propanol 23% v/v; 3M butanol = 27.5% v/v). Milky emulsion formation occurs with very low amounts of long chain alcohols (from [29]). =I
(0.0727~Nlrn), the surface te to few dyneslcm (l0” Nlm) when the crnc is e~trapolationof the decreasingpart of the surface tension log ( s u r f a c t ~concentration) t plot (below the c (~bovethe crnc) gives the crnc v
conductivity can be used for cmc dete~ination[22]. Conductivity measurement is an accurate way to determine ionic surfactant cmcs in aqueous (e.g. 50% vlv methanol solutions. It should be used in organic rich solutions solution) to check if micellization does occur with ionicsurfactants.
~ ~ e c t ~ o ~ h o The t o ~absorption e t ~ . spectrum of numerous dyes changes when they solubilize in the micelle core. Other dyes are essentially waterinsoluble, they dissolve significantly in the presence of few micelles.The absorption spectrum of dye-containing surfactant solutions is recorded for increasing surfactant concentrations. M e n micellization occurs, an abrupt spectrum change is easily detectable. Sometimes a color change can be determinedvisually.uinaldineblue(pinacyanolchloride), fluorescein, rhodamine 6 6 and bromophenol blueare examples of dyes whose spectrum changes upon micelle solubilization. OrangeOT (1-~-tolylazo-2-naphthol), scarlet red (Sudan IV) or methyl yellow 2 ~ - d i m e t h y l ~ n o a z o b e n ~ eare ne) water-insoluble dyes usedfor cmc determination 1221.
Other ~ e t h o ~ Turbidimetry, ~. light scattering and refractive index measurements are spectrophotometric methods used to obtain surfactant cmcs. Viscosity, difhsion coefficient measurements, flow injection analysis and electrochemical methods (pote~tiometryand polarography and even capillary electrophoresis) canalso be used. The accuracy of the quoted methods is variable. However, all of them can rapidlygive an essentialinformation: a breakinthe studied f ~ ~ a t i o An continuous . change property is a reasonable proof for micelles of the studied property should bea warning signal: is there any micelle in this medium?
. A big interest in micellar solutions that is these mediaare able to solubilize, at the same time,polar, ionic solutes and nonpolarsolutes. The location of the solubilized compounds in the micelle or surroundings depends on the polarity of the solutes. On the other hand, when the amount of nonpolar solventincorporatedinamicellar phase becomeshigh,emulsionand
microemulsion structures can be formed. Classical emulsions cannot be used as mobile phases in liquid c~omatography,but microemulsions can. The microemulsion physicoche~calstructure and properties are exposed briefly below.
IK 1. SoZ~~iZz~ation in Mi~eZZa~ Me~za Small mounts of nonpolar compounds can dissolve in the nonpolar core of the micelle, ionic compounds are located in bulk water, and polar compounds can partition between the polar layer (Stern layer in ionic micelles,Figure 2.4) of the micelle and bulkwater. The polar layer of the micelles f o ~ e d by nonionic surfactants is larger than the Stern layer of theionic micelles (Figure 2.12). In nonpolar solvents, water andpolar solutes are located in the core of reverse micelles, and nonpolar solutes are dlssolved in the nonpolar solvent (Figure 2.8).
i
ic
.l2 Localization of solutes in the micelles. The apolar solutes are located in the micelle core. The polar solutes are locatedin the ionic palisade(Stern) layer. Alcohols may form mixed micelles.
ften, the solubilized CO ,the cmc can be in~reased e ~ o ~of nonpolar t s solutes can produce swo les that is the first step towards emulsion fo r alcohols tend to solubilize in micellesas illu oup of the alcohol is located in ated in the nonpolar micelle decrease the electrical repulsionbetween the first step t o ~ a r d microemulsion s fo~ation. h s term means that the of medium or long chainalcohol. There is no clear limit. S that there is 1 “alcohol molecule every a mixed micelle, micelles, it is not possible to speak of mixed micelles. the number of alcohol molecules should be comparab lecules. A mixedmicelleshould contain several alcohol molecules per micelle.
en a solute is addedto a micellar solution, distributes it i t s e ~ b e ~ ethe en aqueous solventand the micelles. To quantitate this &strib r ~ a r t i ~ o n c ~ e ~orc ~i ei nc te ~distrib~tion ~ar constant, as the ratio of the solute concentration in the micelles to the solute concentration in the nomicellar phase. It is expressed by [30]:
(2.15)
is the aggregation number, [ ]the solute ~o~centration in the cellar ~ e d i u mp, is the mole percentage ofthe solute in the micelles, (1 p)is the solute fraction located in the aqueous pseudo-phase, and qrnthe volume percentageofthe micellar pseudo-phase(Eq. 2.10). The aggregation number is not always known, therefore, the solute partition c o e ~ c i e nper t lecule, Pm ,is often used in
(2.16)
The solute pa~itioncoefficient and its location are linked. 2.13 sl~owsthe plotof p values vs. sudactant concentration i ~ c r e a s i nfrom ~ 100 to 200,000are ules of a solute 100-fold moresoluble in the micelles than in water (Kw = 100) are located inthe micellar phase of eason is that the micellar phase volume is only 2.7% of thetotal volume. Otherwise, 42% and morethan 99% of the rnoleand 200,000, respectively, are cules of a solute with ICw values of 2 located in the micellar phase of the 0.1 SDS solution. Ths shows that a solute with a ICw 200,000 can be considered fully locate = I :
Localization of solutes in the micellar phase as a function of thesolute partition coefficient. The indicated valueis the solute partition coefficient, Km. It should be divided by 62 (SDS aggregation number) toobtain the distribution constant per SDS molecule, pm*
LV
S micellar phase. Solutes with Km values between 1000 and 207000 are located in both phases. Solutes with lower located mainly in the aqueous pseudo-phase ofthe 0.12 S concentrationis commonly used in the mi . If the analyzed solute interacts with the 1000, number of SDS that its Km constant is higher than is about 62 molecules per micelle for 0.12 that a value Km = 1000 corresponds to molecule of only]Pw= 16.
c) S o l u ~ i l i ~ a toifoSalts ~ a~~~~ Salts and ionic compounds have a hgh affinity for the aqueous pseudophase. Their distribution constant is, thus, close to zero. This means that they are completely excluded from the micelles. The consequence that is the concentration of salts in aqueous solvent may be hgher than the bulk concentration. For example, for1 M SDS (288 gL), the volume percentage of the micellar pseudo-phase isqm = 0.246 (Eq. 2.10).Therefore, one liter olution contains246 mL of micelles and754 m L of water. If salt, say sobumnitrate, is bssolved in this micellar solution, the ed in the aqueous pseudo-phase7where its concentration can higher. The actual ion concentration willbe actually be 0 .O133 3% overall concent~ation. l/( l cp,)higher th
-
Ion location is even more i m p o ~ when t considering the p micellar solution. The proton concentration in the aqueous pseudo-phase will be: (2.17)
as:
the concentration ofprotons introduced inthe micellar media. ation can be writtenfor the hydroxide ions. The autoprotolysis or ionic product of water in the micellar m d u r n can be written (2.18)
The pK;, valueof a micellar solution will be expressed by [3 11:
(2.19) at 20°C. The J value was ~troduced totake into account ion-exchange phenomena or electrical interactions with the organic interphasethat may act on the ion location[3l]. To illustrate the use of Eqs. 2.17-2.19, let's suppose that 0.0 l HGl is added into one liter of the 1 M SDS solution previously mentio It should be pointed out that a l M SDS solution is a highly conce micellar solution.The aqueous pseudo-phase pH is 1.87 andnot 2.0, of a classical solution; the pK, value in 1 M SDS is 14.25, slightly higher than the value inpure water (14.00). The pH shift is only 0.13 unit (6.5%) 9 value of 24.6%. The pH shift is smaller than 0.05 in micellar with a , values P,lowerthan lo%, such as those usedas mobile phases media with ( in MLC. This pH change can, consequently, be ignored. However, when concentrated emulsionsor microemulsions are used, the pH shifts must be taken into account.
Micellar solutionsare two component mixtures: water and surfactant . ~~n a small amountof a third component is added, itcan be solubilized inthe a third nonpolar component, called rnicellar media. M e n a large amount of "oil," is added to a micellar solution, the solubility limit is exceeded and another system, biphasic innature, foms an emulsion,
The emulsion s t ~ c t u r is e obtained by adding energy to the mixture of water, surfactant and oil. The energy is necessary to increase the interface area. ~emulsions ~ are ) fomed Droplets tend to form. il in water ( oil droplets are dispers in a water continuous phase. Water in 01 emulsions have a continuous oil phase with water droplets insid 2.14). The droplet diameter range from0.02 pm for very fine emulsionto 50 pm and more forcoarse emulsions. The emulsion structure is notstable. reaming or sedime~tation ith time, the droplets fuse by coalescence.
oc~ursand, even^ ly, the oil phaseseparates from the aqueous phase 1321. ins and t~rbidityof such systems proscribe their use as mobile es
il in water
Physicochemical structures of the organized liquid systems. Micellar solutions, emulsions and microemulsions. Open areas: aqueous phase; dashed areas: apolar phase, redrawn from Ref.[3 l].
A microemulsion is an emulsion with droplets so small (c40 se visible light (Fi~ure2.14). A ~croemulsionlooks
be so low that the interfacial area tends to increase spontaneously E34.1. ome microemulsionsare thermo
longer (months to years) compared to the a classical emulsion [33,34].
e 131'
S
y ~ i ~o~three ~ r eco~ponents, A, e~uilateraltriangle volume, mass or mole, is selected. The relative ~ o u n t of s ressed in erc cent age of the selected parameter,such as:
% + C % = 100% rcentages are independent, the third one c gure 2.1S shows how a given mixturecan the crossing of the res
of the triangle. solvent, andthe top
(2.20)
The ternary phase diagramrepresentation. Point M represents the liquid mass, composition with59% ofA, 9% of €3and 32% of C (total 100%). The percentage can be volume or mole percentages.
ost ~ c r ~ m u l s i oare n s made withfour components. In this case, be used, unless a pseudo-component is defined, such as a given ratio of surfactant toalcoholic cosudactant. This active mixture is considered as the third component andis placed at the G apex. Figure 2.16 shows the phase diagram of the ternary system w a t e r ~ e p t a n e / s o dbis i ~ (2e~ylhexyl)sulfosuccinate (Aerosol OT or AOT) [35]. AOT is an anionic surfa~tantableto form ~/~ microemulsionswithout the need of a ~osurfactant.Figure 2.17 shows the phase &agram of the pseudo-ternary + n-butanol) [3l]. C syste~ water~eptane/(GTA~ s u d a ~ that t needs to be associated with a cosurfactant toform microemulsions. The ratio C T A ~ ~ u t a nwas o l constant (1/1 w/w) for all compositions represented inthe phase diagram. The hatched areas corres-
pond to emulsions or polyphasic mixtures. The open areas show the microemulsion domains and the dotted areas correspond to liquid crystal domains.
Mass phase diagramofthe ternaryliquidsystemmade of sodium diethylhexyl sulfosuccinate (AOT), heptane and water (25°C). This system presents a vast L2 (see Figure2.14) area. The L1area is lenticular.The dotted areais a viscous, birefringent and milky area, probably a suspensionof liquid crystalin L2 phase, redrawn from[36].
,111 Mass phase diagram of the quaternary liquid system made of CTAl3huhol (U1 in mass) as thesurface active mixture(surfactant f cosurfactant), heptane and water (NaC1O.lM). This system presents acontinuous change from the L1 structure to the L2 structure (see Figure 2.14). Thedotted areacorresponds toviscous milky compositions, redrawn from [3l].
~ i c r o ~ ~ u l sdomain. ion
onpolar solutes are locate
4.21
*
Evolution of the microemulsion realm of existence according to oil variation (from left to right: dodecane, benzene or toluene) and alcohol cosurfactant variation (from top to bottom: hexanol, pentanol, butanol, to the same 2/13 SDS/alcohol molar ratio) redrawn from [37].
L
solution ofsurfactant molecules inwater makes the micellar e media are easy to prepare, but their p~ysico-che~cal rties should be known in order to be able to use them correctly in . The two important points to remember are: (i) surfactants adsorb at e, and (ii) sur~actantassociations are dynamic; they f o m and or less rapidly. The first point partly explains the u n c o ~ o n solute retention and selectivity obtained in MLC due to modifications ofthe s ~ t i o n phase a ~ by s u ~ a c tadso~tion. ~t The second point may explain the slow mass transfer often observed in LC and may be responsible for the reduced c ~ o m a t o ~ r a p h i c e ~ ~ i e n c y .
1. 2. 3.
chick and F.M. Fowkes (series eds),
,Marcel Dekker, NewYork.
Surfactant Science
.
Gelbart, A.Ben-Sauland D. Roux (eds), Micelles) runes, ~icroemulsions,and ~onolayers,Springer Verlag,
rfactants, in ~ l l m a n'nS~ncyclope~ia of ~ n ~ u s t r i a ~
chemist^, VCH, W e i ~ e i m ,Germany, Vol. A25, pp 747-817 4.
5. 6. 7.
8. 9. 10.
11. 12. 13. 14.
15.
(1994). . Linfield (ed.), Anionic Surfactants, S u ~ a c Science ~ t Series, Marcel Dekker, New York, Vol. 7 (1976). E. J u n g e (ed.), ~ ~ Cationic Surfactants, S u ~ a c Science ~ t Series, Marcel Dekker, New York, Vol. 4 (1970). M.J. Schick (ed.), on ionic Sur~acta~ts: Physical Chemistry, ~ ~ ~ Science a cSeries, ~ Marcel t Dekker,NewYork, Vol. 23 7). . Lornax (ed.), Amphoteric Su~actants,S u ~ a c Science ~ t enes, Marcel Dekker, New York,Vol. 59 (1996). .A t h s and J.A. Beran, General chemist^, 2nd ed., ~ c i e n t i ~ c erican Books, New York( l 992). C.T d o r d , The ~ydrophobicEflect, 2nd ed., Wiley, New York (1980). G.S. Hartley, Ion Aggregation in Solut~onsof Salts with Long ~ a r a Chains, ~ n ~ o l l o i dZur., 88: 22 (1 939). G. C.Kresheck, in Water, a Comprehen~iveTreatise, F. Franks Plenum Press, New York, Vol. 4,pp. 95-167 (1975). Hinze and D.W. strong, Ordered Media in C h e ~ i c a l s i ACS, ~ W a s ~ ~ DC, o nVol. tions, ACS S ~ ~ oSeries, . Shaw, ~ntroduction to Colloid and Surface Chemistry, uttenvorths, London (1980). ,~ i n a rand~ulticomponent y So~utio~ ofAm~hi~hilic Co~pounds)Solubilization andthe or mat ion) S t ~ c t u r eand of Liquid Crystalline Solutions) Chem. ~ h e o r e ~ cSignl~cance al Rev., 68: 1 (1968). o and W. ~ ~ J. Lang, C.Tondre, R. Zana, R. Bauer, H. H Ubricht, Chemical ~ e l ~ a t i Studies on o f ~ i c e l l a r ~ ~ u i ~ iJ b:r i u m ) Phys. Chem., 79:276 (1975).
16. 17. 18. 19. 20
*
21. 22. 23.
24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30.
L. Laaksonen and J.B. Rosenholm, Molecular ~ynamics Simulations of the ~ater/OctanoateInte~acein the ?resence of Micelle, Chern. ?hys. Letters 216:429 (1993). J.F. goo^ and T. Walker, Micellization in Aqueous Solutions, in Colloid Science, D.H. Everett(ed.), The C h e ~ c a lSociety, London, ‘Vol. 3, Ch. 5, pp. 230-252 (1979). and P. M ~ e r ~ eine Mice~lization, , Solubilization and K.L. Micr ions, K.L. Mittal(ed.),Plenum Press, NewYork, ‘Vol. 1 (1979). Zana, Ionization of CationicMicelles: Effect of the ete er gent ucture, J Colloid Interface Sci., 18:330 (1980). .J. Rosen, Sur~actantsand Interfaci~l ~henomena, New York( l 978). D. Atwood and A T . Florence, Su~actantSystems, hap pm Hall, London (1983). P. Muke~eeand K.J. Mysels, cal Micelle Concentrations of AqueousSu~actantSystems,N S-NBS 3 6 , W a s ~ n ~ o n ( 1 9 ~ 0 ) . F. KraB and H.Wiglow, Ueber des Verhalten der fettsauren Alkalien und des Selfen in Gegenwart von Wasser, III Die ~ e ~ e n als ~ ~ s t a l l o i d e , W D Seven i e als Colloide, Chem. 3erichte, 28: 2566 (1895). K. Shinoda, in Colloidal S~rfactants,K. Shinoda, B. T ~ ~ u s h i and T. Isemura (eds.), AcademicPress, New York ( l 963). N. Funasaki, ~~ermodynamics of Micel~izationof Su~actantsin ?resence or Absence of Salts, J Colloid ~nterfaceSci., 61: 384 (1978). N. Nishiludo, inMixed SurfactantsSystems, (eds.), Sudactant Science Series, Vol. 46, York, p. 23 (1993). M.L. Corrin and W.D. Harkins, The Effectsof Salts on the cmcof Colloida~Electrolytes, J Am. Chem. Soc., 69: 683 (1947). Becher, Non Ionic Surface Active Compounds. Y: ~ ~ e ofc t ectrolytes, J :Col~oidScience, I 7: 325 (1962). K.~ ~ i n o dand a T. Nakagawa, in Colloidal Surfactan S ~ o d a B. , Tamamushi and T. Isemura (eds.), Academic New York (1963). D.W. Armstrong, T.J. Ward and A. Berthod, M i c e l l ~ r E ~ eonc t ~ o l e c u l a r ~ ~ ~ ~ s i heo ore n :tical and C~romato~raphic Considerations,Anal. Chem., 58: 579 (1986).
31. 32. 33
*
34. 35. 36.
Com~entson the ~ e ~ n i t i oofnMicroemulsions, Surfaces, 4: 201 (1982). an (eds.), Micel~arSolutions and lag, New York(1990). . Laughlin, The Aqueous Phase ~ehaviorof Surf~ctants, ~cademicPress, London (1994 . orthault, L2 Microemulsions as a t o ~ r a ~ hAnal. y , hem., 62: 1402
317.
38. 39.
. Tadros,
Su~factant~ in A~rochemicals,
40.
41. 42.
43.
Colloid ~nterfaceSci., 57: 1 (1995).
S:
A Review, A h .
process~g,surfactant ~ctionsby m a ~ n d . soap was done by heating fresh ashes mixed w odd to c o ~ p a rdoing e l a ~ with ~ chromato~r d ~
LC can be considered and others develo
y co~lombicforces o f a cation o~lombicforces, the two ions as§ociat f the solvent is low and/or because th ro~hobiceffect and the electrostatic interaction both r f o ~ a t i o n .The ion-pairing agent or counter-ion 7
58
ERTHOD and ~ A R ~ ~ A -
is most often a strong electrolyte with an alkyl chain of various length. uatemary onium alkyl halides are used as pairing agents for anions. Sodium alkyl sulfates or sulfonatesare anionic salts used as pairing agents for cations. The polarity of the ion-pair is much lower than the polarity of eachindividual ion. Ion-pairing is used to transfer ionsfroma polar aqueous phase to a nonpolar organic one [2]. In its simplest form, the partition equilibriumcan be represented by
where C’ and A- are any organic cation and anion, respectively. The ionpair (C’A‘) behaveslike a polarorganicmolecule and willtherefore preferentiallydissolveinapolarorganicphase such as an alcohol, a chlorinated solventor solvent-mixtures suchas ether and alcoholor ketone and alkane.
In 1973, ion-pair formation associated with phase transfer was used by Eksborg and Schill [3] to develop normal-phase ion-pair chromatography. A polar bare silica stationary phase was impregnated withan aqueous ionic solution. The eluent, a mixture of hexane, chloroform and pentanol, could [4] and h o x separate various benzoic and salicylic acid derivatives. Karger [S] used the normal phase mode with impregnated stationary phases to separate catecholamines by ion-pairing. Soon, h o x thought to use the hydrophobic eRect to f o m ion-pairs in aqueous phases. He developed the first use of reversed-phase ion-pair chro~atographyin 1976 [6]. He termed it “soap chromatography.” He added ionic surfactants to the polar hydro-organic mobile phase. They adsorb on the alkyl-bonded stationary phase. They also associate with the hydrophobic and ionic analytes. Two mechanisms can explain the analyte retention: (i)A classical ion-exchange mechanism, the ionic solute interacts with the counter-ion covered stationary phase. (ii) An ion-pairing mechanism, the hydrophobic ion-pairpartitionswiththealkyl-bonded stationary phase. The true
mechanism may depend on the nature of the ions. It is accepted that a mechanism intermediate between ion-exchange and hydrophobic p~~oning is likely. The dynamic ion-exchange involves differential adsorption of both the analyte ion and the surfactant counter-ion as described by Melander and Horvath [7].
The nature and concentration of the pairing ion of and the organic modifier, the ionic strength,the pH and the character of thestationary phase are the main factors acting on the retention behavior ofthe solute-ion. these factors are interdependent.
a) Ion- air A ~ s o r ~ ~on i othe n S t ~ t ~ o n se a~ The pairing ion adsorbs on the stationary phase. With~ydro-organicmobile [S]. Figure 3.1 phases, Freundlich-t~eadsorption isotherms were obtained shows the adsorption isotherms of sodium octyl sulfonate, CH3(CH2)~~ Na' (top) and sodium dodecyl sulfonate,C H 3 ( C H 2 )Na' ~ ~(bo~om) ~ ~ ~ on Lichrosorb W8 sorbent with different acetonitrile (ACN)-water mobile phases. The adsorbed amount of pairing ion increases exponentially the with carbon number in its alkyl-chain. It decreases rapidly with the organic modifier content (Figure3.2). The ionic solute retentionfactors are directly proportional to the amount of pairing-ion adsorbed the on stationary phase. The ion-pair adsorption phenomenon renders the equilibration of the s~tionaryphase critical. Workmg with none~uilibratedstationary phases will produce nonreproducible results. The time needed to eq~ilibratea column can be surprisingly long. For example, let's estimate the mobile needed to equilibrate a 25 cm column containing 2 g of 8 (3 05m2/g) witha water/ACN 80120 v/v solution containing 0.005 M sodium dodecylsulfonate. Figure3. l (bottom) shows that the ionpair adsorption amount is 0.8 pmol/m2. In the 25-cm column, the surface area is 700 m2,then 560 pmoles of sodium dodecylsulfonateare needed to equilibrate the column. This amount is contained in 112 mL, of mobile at phase. If the working flowrate is 1mL/min, the 25-cm column will need least l 12 minor approximately two hours to be correctly e~uilibrated.
Adsorption isotherms on a C8 bonded silicastationaryphase. Column 25 cm x 4.6 mm id. Lichrosorb RP8, 350 m2/g, 10 pm particle diameter. Top: sodium oc~lsulfonatein acetonitrile (ACN)-water mobilephases. Bottom: sodium dodecylsulfonate in ACN-water mobile phases, 20°C, data from Ref. [8].
e ion-pair adso~tionon the s t a t i o n a ~ phase precludes the use of organic modi~ergradients that would completely modify the s ~ t i o n a ~ phase adsorbed layer (Fig~re3.2).
F i ~ 3.2 ~ r ~ Rapid surfactant desorption with the increase of mobile phase organic modifier content, same experimental conditions as Figure 3.1.
b) S ~ ~ uStructure te
In ion-pair chro~atography,Tomlinson and &ley[g] have estimatedthe ion retention factors using hnctional group values, T, related to the constants. This shows that the hydrophobic part of the ionic solutes is res onsible for the retention as well as its ionic part. The later part may be d ionic strength dependent.
The acidity constant, pKA, is used to measure the ionization degree of a ,is 99% or more in the A’ solute at a given pH value. An acidic solute, ionic formfor pH values such as pH ~ P K $A- 2
(3‘2)
Similarly, a basic solute, B7is 99% or more in the protonated ionic form, BH’, for the pH values: PH
(3-3)
If both conditions are not fulfilled, the ionizable solute is retained partly in its molecular form andpartly through the dynamic ion-exchange process. The retention factor of ionizable c o m p o ~ d sshows a sigmoidal dependance on the mobile phase pH. The lower retention of the sigmoid corresponds to the molecular formpartitio~ng.The lugher retention values correspond to the dynamic ion-exchangeof the ionized form of the solute. A11 variations are possible. For example,the retention ofthe solute ~-c~orobenzoic acid is not sensitive to a pH change on the practical 1-8 range with a q u a t e m a ~onium pairing ion andACN/water 50150 v/v mobile phases [g]. Its PI(, value is 2.9 in pure water. The retention factor of the solute 4-aminobenzoic acid plotted versus the mobile phase p H is a sigmoidal curve with a maximum retention variation in the p a p p r o ~ ~ a t epH l y 4 [g]. The PICA value of 4-aminobenzoicacid is 4.9 in pure water, but it can be closeto 4 in A~N/water50/50 v/v solutions.
It is established in ion-pair c~omatographythat saltsalways reduce the ionpair retention factors by shielding ion-ion interactions. The plot of the retention factor, k, of a ionic solute versus the inverse of the mobile phase ionic strength7I-’, is linear with a positive slope [g], Often, an increase in ionic strength decreases the retention factor and reducesthe efficiency ofthe system. From a practical point of view,the mobile phase salt concentration (ion-pairing agent, solute and buffer) should be maintained belowthe 0.02 M limit [101.
e) ~ ~ g a n i c
~ o d ~ iand e r on~cent a t ration u~e
~ e t h a n o lacetonitrile , or isopropanol are the organic modifiers commonly usedinmixtures with water. Higher organic modifier concentrations produce drastic reduction of ionicsolute retention factors. “his is dueto the increased elution strength of organic rich mobile phase and also to the decrease ofthe pairing ion adsorption on the stationary phase (Figure 3.2). As illustrated by Figure 3.1, the ion-pair adsorbed amount depends onthe nature and concentration of the organic modifier and on the alkyl chain length ofthe ion-pairing agentitself.
fl ~ a t u r eo ~ tI~o ne- ~ aAgent ~r Changing the ion-pair agent is the most readily available way for molfying the ionic solute retention factors. This is achieved by selectinga ion-pair of the same class but with a different alkyl chain length. If the alkyl chain length increases, the ion-pairing agent adsorbed amount increases (Figure 3.1) and the ionic solute retention factors increase. Also the hydrophobic character of the ion-pair increases. Practically, alkyl chain length ranging from 6 methylene units (hexyl) to 16 units (hexadecyl) are available in chemical catalogues.
An increase in temperature is almost always associated with a decrease of the retention factor f lo]. This is again a result of the ion-pairing agent adsorption whose isotherm changes with temperature. This is a problem in the dailyuse of ion-pairing chromatography. Variations ofambient temperature result in a poor reproducibility ofthe retention factor values. Table 3.1 summarizes the parameters acting on the solute retention in ion-pairing chromatography. The big interest of the technique is its ability to analyze and to separate ionic solutes together with molecular solutes using LC columnandhydro-organicmobile phases with low ~ o u n t of s the ion-pairing agent. A satisfying long term reproducibili~of the results may be difficultto obtain, however.
Parameters Acting on the Ionic Solute Retention in Ion-pairing Chromatography
aramete~
Effect on retention
ty alkyl bonded bonded
ion-pairing alkyl chain length ion-p~ringconcentration organic modifier concentration organic modifier nature PH solute on ionic strengthI temperature
exponential increase linear increase exponential decrease change selectivity depends pKA decrease withI-' decrease
An increase of the listed parameter produces the indicated effect on the ionic solute retention factor.
The con~ntrationof surfactant in the solutions usedas mobile phases in ionpair c~omatographyshould notpass the cmc value. It was h o r n that the solute retention was different when micellespresent were in the mobile phase [S-lo]. Figure 3.3 illustrates the dramatic retention change observed when the surfactant cmc is passed [l l]. The retention factor ofbenzyl t r i m e t h ~ l ~ o n i ubromide m (BTAB),a cationic solute, is plotted versus the mount of §D§adsorbed on the stationary phase (a cyanopropyl bonded TAB retention factor is directly proportional to the §
adsorbed mount. concentration rea retention factor d
that first developed . chemical separatio~s
tant solutions above invented people by studying
the cmc for the use
physicochemical properties.
Retention factor of the cationic solute benzyltrimethylammoniumbromide
(BTAB)versus the adsorbed amount of SDS on a CN bonded phase. Column 10 cm x 4.6 mm i.d., CPS Hypersil 5 pm. Inset shows log k vs. the SDS concentration in the aqueous mobile phase. Reprinted from Ref. 11 with permission of the American Chemical Society.
a) A Pioneering
or^
In the early sixties Herries and Richards [123 studied the differences in reactivity of proteinmoleculesbeforeand after dena~ration. They consideredmicelles as possiblemodelssince surfactants werewellestablished denaturating agents. Their studies led them to be involved in kinetic studies of reactions where the reactants partition differently between an aqueous and micellar phase. For their calculationstheyneeded the partition coefficient of the various reactant molecules between the aqueous and micellar phase. The gel permeation chromatography (GPC) technique was used for this purpose. Their idea was: GPC separates the big molecules from the small ones. A. micelle is a molecular association big enoughto be excluded from the GPC stationary phase gel. The monomersurfactant molecules are small and retained insidethegelpores.Thereactantmolecules that partition between the micellarandaqueousphasewillhave a retention volume i n t e ~ e ~ abetween te the micelle retention volume (close to the exclusion volume) and the permeation volume. Then, the reactant retention Volume can be related to its micellar partition coefficient.
*
In an article exposing their results[121, they werethe first to use the arti in and Synge theoretical derivation to establish the equation relating the solute retentionto its micellar partition coefficient. Although their Sephadex G-25 column presented a strong adsorption for some solutes, they were able parameter versus the SDS to obtain straight lines plotting the Vi/(V~-V*) surfactant concentration, thesubscripts i, e ando refer to the internal (pore) and the external volume of the GPC gel,thesoluteelutionvolume of the lines (exclusion)volume,respectively.Theslopeandintercept allowed themto determine accuratelythe micellar partition coefficient of the seven compounds studied [121. They were not interested in the separation go firther in this direction. ability of the technique and did not
7
b) The ~ e ~ i b e r aUse t e of ~ i c e ~Phases ~ a r for Se~arat~on In the late seventies, aniel Wayne Armstrong was working as a graduate student in the Janos Fendler’s group at Texas A&M University (College Station, Texas). His workwasrelated to synthesisandchemicaland biochemical reactions in micellar media.To measure the micellar partition coefkient of transfer ribonucleic acids (tRNA), he usedthe GPC method [121. He got thepartition describedbyHenries,Bishopand&chards coefficients ofthe tRNA solutes he was lookingfor. He readily noticedthe separation capability of the method and immediately announced this fact in his veryfirst article on the topic:The relativelow cost, the ease of operation and shor~essof timefor a completerun merit, we believe, the development of this technique to i t s ~ lpotential l [131.
The first MLC chromatogram.Mobile phase:0.2 M SDS,column: 30 cm
x 4 mm i.d. MicropackMCH-10,lO pm C18 particles, flow rate varying between 2 mL/min
and 3 mL/min as indicated by the dashed line. Solutes: a varietyof phenols, PAHs and other aromatic compounds. Reprinted from Ref. 16.
Armstrontook an
separations with another more affordable technique: thin layer chromatography (TLC). He successfblly used micellar normal and reversed phases with TLC plates to separat investigated anionic micellarsoluti reversed micelles with sodium dioctylsul reversed micelles in cyclohexane [141. broadening of the initial spots on the micellar devel thought to use cyclodextrins the same way as micelles a s e Chr ” to designate all the term: ~ ~ P s ~ u d o - ~ hLiquid chromatographic techniques, GPC, that C, use a secondary chemical e~ullibrium,withmicelles or cyclodextrins, in the separation process [151.
1980, ~rmstrongmoved to eorgetown Univer apply hs ideas onthe capabilities of mic C article presented the separation of ph LC c h r o m a t o ~ ris~ shownin #7)was only 80 efficiency of the 0-cresol peak (Peak column (h.e.t.p = 375 pm or 38 particle hameters). This low efficiencywas probably not pointedout because a flow gradient was used [161. ith Famk Nome, an ex-memberendler group that was s p e n d ~ gsome time as a post-doc with A co~erstonearticle establish~gthe theory o proposed the three-phase model (see Chapter 5) and established it with experiments and asupport~gtheory based onthe following equation:
where 4 is the phase ratio, +=V,N,, the ratio of V,, the stationary p volume and Vm,the mobile phase volume insidethe c retention factor; v is the surfactant molar volume; concentration in the mic form ([M] =total surfactant concentration cmc), and the P, and constants are the dimensionless solute pa S and water coefficients between the ,respectively. s~tionaryphase and wate determine the solute micellar partition coefficient affinity [1'71, b) The ~
'
a S ~r r e o ~af ~ the MLC ~ e c h ~ i ~ u e
Interested by the use of micellar mobile phases, several research teams started to workin the LC field. LindaCline-Love, at Seton es range, NJ)was studying the spectroscopic ~ r o p e ~ i of strong proposed to use theseproperties to the detection of fluorescent and phosphorescent compounds [lS]. Love further developed such use of the micellar phases [191. group verified confirmed Armstrong's theory [201. John University of Florida (~ainesville,FL), was the first to i nze7 eE1ciency problem in another Fendler former studentthat took an aca Salem, NC), showed eory (Eq. 3.4) and could be used as well as ionic surfactants E221 'rkbrigh~, at the Universi~of M ~ c h e s t e r ( ~ n g l ~used d)7 separate salts of dithiocarbamates with cationic s u ~ a c t ~[23], ts
. III.1.
1982-1986, a GrowingInterest
er 1982, more and more research groups located worldwide started to now a professor investigate the capabilities of MLC. In the US, Armstron~y at Texas Tech University (Lubbock, TX), was still active in the field [24251. Armstron~[26-271 and the otherAmerican scientists E281 wrote reviews to increase the di&sion of the technique. Researchersin I d y [29], China [30-311, Spain [32], France [ l 1, 331 or Japan [34-351 increasedthe knowledgeof the foundationsofMLCand its application range. The Liquid Chromato~raphywas progressively deno~nation:~~eudo-phase replaced by: Micellar Liquid C h r o ~ a t o ~ r a [ ~1h1y2 1 331.
b) ~~e 1
~ New 8 York ~ A~S~eeting
strong andHinzeproposed
to the AmericanChemicalSociety to organize a symposiumon the useof Ordered Media in Chemical ~eparation~ at its 19lStMeeting held in New York inApril 1986. A high percentage ofthe people working in the MLC field attendedor were invited, With the texts of the conferences, the two symposium organizers edited a book contain~ga great partof the MLC knowledge at this time [36). It is ~ p o to point ~ t out that Armstrong hmself gave a talk on cyclodextrin formation. He was happy that people used and developed C techque he invented,but he thoughtthat the technique had oms. The use ofCDs for chemical separations was already his main researchinterest. He was so successhl applying theCD chemistry to the difficult task of chiral separations that so far7he never went backto LC limitations were clearly seen during this s y m p o s i when ~ the capa~ilitiesof the micellar phasesassociated with the then newcapillary e1ectrophoresis techque were exposed. Electropherogr~sshowing efficiencies in the 100,000 platesh range were displayed [37].
III.2.
198 7 - ~ r e s e ~Mt ,~ t ~MLC re
After the 1986 symposibecame clear that LC wouldnot supplant any separation methodser, the interest of the scientific c o ~ u n i ~ was still signific~tas LC publications appearing S seen as an interesting t e c ~ i ~ u that e per year (Figure 3.5 deserved studies intwo main directions: (i) the ~ n d ~ e n tway: a l eluent strength, selectivityand e~lciencyan (ii) the applied way: hydrophobici~studies and original separations.
40
Figure 3. Number of articlesentirelydedicated to IdLC sorted by publicationyear from 1977 to 1998.
?
~ ~~ t r e~n ~ te~ , ~ ~ e ~ etc t i v i ~ a nThe ~ ~very ~ i clow i eefficiency ncy. obtained with purely aqueous micellar phase was greatly improved by the 3% vlv propanol addition r e c o ~ e n d e dby weak eluent strength of the aqueous micellar a ~ ~ i t i oofnalcohols. These studies were initiated by rsey’s student [38-391. Hinze showed that the retenti C models(logkproportional compoundsdidnotobeytheestablished to homologuenumber)[40]. He propadirect transfer ~ e c h ~ i s m between the micelles and the stationary phase [4 l]. C were thoroughlyinvesti~atedby Love [44] and others [45]. e reasons for the low efficiency observed in were investi~atedby and ~ ~ t i ~ i z a t i o n ~undamental . studies increased the ~ o w l e d ~ofethe micellar retention mechanisms It was then possible to propose theoretical models that allowed chromatographers to predict and C separations [48-501.
~ i ~ ~~ eo~ a~r ~i t ci o ~ S~early s~. as 1985, Cline-Loveshowed that the surfactant molecules contained in the micellar mobile phase were able to bind to proteins and to reduce greatly their a ~ s o ~ t i on o nthe silica based stationary phases. The directi of biologicalsamplessuch as s e w ithoutproteinpreciitationinsidethe or urinesamples can bedone i colu~ [511. This property initiated a great interest for number of works in thisarea [32, 52-5 51. b i c i ~an^ Qu~ntitative~ ~ u c t ~ r e ~ e t e ~ partition coe~lcientof a sol~tecan be are l data for the nshi [56-591. research field was investigated by numerous groups ~ e ~ a r a t i o n s o ~ r o n s a n ~ r ~ o r ~ aThe n i caqueous ~ ~ e cphase i e s . of the micellar mobile phase c m dissolve polar solutes
3. of
4. 5.
Organic Co~pounds, J:Chro~atogr., 83: 99
.L.Karger, High Perfor~anceIon Pair Partition The Separationof Biogenic Amines and their matogr. Sci. 12: 52 1 (1974). and, ~eparationof Tricyclic Psychosedative eed Ion Pair Partition and ~ i ~ u i d - S o l i d
6. 7.
Pair Chro~ato-
9.
10. 11.
graphy, Adsorption is other^^ of Two Ionic Surfuctants on Five
12.
13.
~olutesbetween Mic Gel ~iltrationand Eflect on the ~ineticsof Some ~ i ~ o l e c u l a r ~eactions,JPhys. Chem. 68: 1842 (1964). . Fender, ~ ~ e r e n t ipartition al in^ of t ~ A between s Micellar and AqueousPhases: a ~ o n v e n i ~Gel nt ~ i l t r a t i oMethod ~ for Separation of t ~ A sBiochi~. , Bio~hys. Acta, 478: 75(1977). .Terrill, Thin Layer Chromato~ra~hic and ~ucleosides Separation of Pesticides, ~ecachlorobi~henyl with Micellar Solutions, Anal. Chem., 51:2160 (1979).
15. 16.
17. 18.
19.
20. 21. 22
I)
23. 24. 25.
26. 27. 28.
D .W. A ~ s t r o n g , Pseudophase Liquid Chromatography: Applications to TLC, J: Liq. Chromatogr., 3: 895 (1980). D.W. h s t r o n g and S.J.Henry, Use of an Aqueous Mobile P ~ s e for Separation of Phenolsand P M s via HPLC, J: Liq. Chro~atogr.,3: 457 (1980). o Solutes r D.W. A ~ s t r o n gand F, Norne, Partitioning ~ e h ~ i of luted with ~ i c e l l a r ~ o Phases b i l e in Liquid Chromatography, Anal. Chem., 53: 1462 (1981). D.W. A ~ s t r o n gW.L. , Hinze, K.H. Bui andH.N. Sin& ~ n ~ a n c e d Fluorescence and Room ~emperaturePhosphorescence ~etection in Pseudophase Liquid Chromatography,Anal. Letters, 14: 1459 (1981). . Weinberger, P. Yamchuk and L.J. Cline-Love, ~ i q u i d ChromatographicPhosphorescence ~ e t e c ~ owith n ~icellar Chromatography and Post-column ~ e t e c t i o n ~ o d eAnal. s , Chem., 54: 1552 (1982). P. Yamchuck, R. Weinberger, R.F. Hirsch and L.J. Cline-Love, Selectivity in Liquid Chromatographywith ~ i c ~ l l a r ~ o b i l e Phases, Anal. Chern.,54: 2233 (1982). J.G. eEtchegaray and J.S. Landy, ~ ~ c i e n c y Enha cellar Liquid Chromatogra~hy,Anal. Chem., 55: 924 (1983). M.F. Borgerding andW.L.Hime, Characteri~ationa n d ~ v a l ~ a ~ o n of the Useof on ionic ~olyoxyethylene(23) dodecanol @rij 35) Micellar~obilePhases in RPLC, Anal. Chem., 51: 2183 (1985). G.F. Kirkbrightand F.G.P. Mullins, Separation of ~ i t h i o carbamates by HPLC using a ~ i c e l l a r ~ o bPhase, i l e Analyst,
G.Y. Stine, Selectivi~ in Pseudophase Liquid 1. Chem., SS: 2317 (1983). G.Y. Stine, Selectivi~in valuation and ce~le-Solute~nteructlons,J: Am. Chem. SOC.,
, A~plications of Pseudophase Liquid C~romatography:Highly Selective~obilePhasesfor Present and Future Separa~ons,American Lab., 13: 14 (1981). D.W. Armstrong, ~ i c e l ~ eins Separations: A Practical and heo ore tical Review, Sep. Pur$ Methods, 14: 2 13 (1985). L.J. Cline-Love, J.G. Dorsey and J.G. Habarta, The ~ z c e l l e Analytical Chemistry ~nterface,Anal. Chem., 56: 1132A (1984).
29.
.Pelizzetti,The Useof a in the HPLC ~ e ~ a ~ a toifoHn y ~ ~ o x y b e n ~ e n e ~ e r i v a ~ v ~ s , A
30. 31. 32.
33. 34.
i, Cation-~xchan~e C ~ ~ o ~ a t o ~ofr aC ~a th~yc h o l a ~ i n ~ s cella^ ~ o b i l Phases, e JPhar~acobio-~yn., 7: 5 ( l 984). ads, ~ i c e l l e ~ x c l u s i o n C h r o ~ a t o ~ r aof~ h~yn o r ~ a n i c
36. 37.
39. 40.
41.
he^., 62: 130 (1990).
43. 44.
~Role ers C : ~ e l e c t i vin i ~~ Chem., 64: 1894 (1992 F.P,Tomasella anclL.J. based onthe ~ h r e e - ~ h a s e
~~~
45. 46. 47. 48 49. 50.
51. 52. 53
*
54.
56.
~ o l v e n t ~ t r e nand ~th and~icelles, Anal. dynamic ~ r o ~ e r t iin es ~ ~ u i l i b r iAnal. u ~ Chem., ~odel,
arina, ~etermination ~ o l u t Association e Constants of ~ o B ~ ne e and ~ a ~ h t h a l e n e
7
57. 58.
59.
60. 61. 62. 63.
IA-ALV
Correlation with the Octanol- Water System, Anal. Chim. Acta, 212: 171 (1988). di andE.D. Breyer, ~uantitationofHydrophobici~with al. Chem., 61: 1040 (1989). , Sanchez and F. lez, MA. R o d r i ~ e z - ~ e l ~ a d o.J. ~arcia-Nontelon~o,Solute-Micelle Association Constants and t s H y d r ~ p h o b i cfor i ~ PAHs by Correlation of Pot, ~ o e ~ c i e nwith MLC, Chromatographia,34: 627 (1992). I. Ueda andH. Fujiwara, Micelle Water N ~ ~ u rK.a Hayash, , rtition Properties of~henolsete ermined b y ~ CProposal . for a Versatile Measureof Hydrophobyci~,Chem. Pharm.Bull.,43:
.P.Nullins, HPLC of Organic and~norganicAnions: Use of cellar ~ o b i l Phases, e ACS Symp. Ser., 342: 115 (1987). terpretation of ~etentionBehaviors of rans sit ions in MLC using an Ion-exchange ~ o d e l Anal. , Chem., 64: 589 (1992). iura, MLC Separation of ~anadiump )Chelate with 2-(2~hia~o~la~o)-S-dimethylaminophenol, Fresenius J Anal. Chem., 344: 294 (1922). S. Terabe and Z.Deyl (eds.), Micelles as Separation ~ e d i in a Chromatography and~lectrophoresis,J Chromatogr.A, 780: 1 361 (1997).
-
The two main properties ofsurfactant molecules are micelle formation. and adsorption at interfaces. In Micellar Liquid Chro~atography( micelle formation property is linkedto the mobile phase. Micelles play the role of the organic modifierRPLC. in Nonpolar solutespartition themselves between the micelle apolar core and the apolar bonded stationary phase. 5. The surfactant adsorption This partitioning willbe the subject of Chapter property is linked to the stationary phase. A significant numberof s u r f a c ~ t moleculesmay adsorb on the stationary phase surface changing its properties. The study of such adsorption andits associated problems is the main subject ofthis chapter.
Although new materials are rapidly emergingfor c~omatographicstationary phases, silica is still the principal medium used as the material for liquid chromatography (LC)pachng [1-31.
II.l.
P ~ y s i c o c ~ e ~ iPro~erties cal of Silica
The three physicochemical parametersfor silica relevantto chromatography are the particle size, thesurface area and the porosity. The other important parameters are the particle shape,the carbon percentage, the ligand density and bonding structure and the surface silanol concentration [l]. 7
0
0000 - 0 O F
W"
mmm+
vi"
2 vivi-0 G 0 t7
o\W M M
000
0
00000
o!o\.o! ? Y Y Y Y
000 M M M M"
22s v i n vin W"
TH
E
f”i
00
U
0000 vivlvivi
“mm
000
M “
lrivivi
f”if”if”i
600 W“lri” vi”
v??
mm-
-m*
00
e?=? 000
0
a) Particle Size ilica packings are always obtained withparticle a distribution, i. e., a stated -pm particle diameter isan average diameter. The polydispersity of a silica powder is related to the width of the particle size distribution. It can be given. by the ratio d90/dl0,particle diameters of which 90% and 10% o f t particle are smaller than or equal to, respectively. The ratio dgO/dlo shou be as close to unity as possible (monodispersesilica). Particle size is always associated to particle shape which can be spherical or irregular. Table 4-1 lists the particle size and shape of some commonly usedc o ~ e r c i asilical based LC packings. b) Surfcrce Area
The a m o ~ h o u ssilica used for LC packings is highly porous. The specific surface area of a silica sample is equal to the sum of its internal (pores) and external areas 141. The specific surface area, A, of a porous silica sample is expressed in m2/g. iiis due to internal area at more than 99% [l]. It is easily measured by the BET method that uses gas a d s o ~ t i o n . i s o t h e ~ s . Surface area and porosity are linked. c) Pore Size andPore Volume
Pores are holes, cavities and/or channels communicating with the silica surface. Pores can be regarded as cylinders with a diameter, Pd, usually Their total volume is the pore measured in m, s o m e t ~ e isn A (=O.1 m). volume, Vp,measuredincm3/g or mL/g of material. The pore size distribution is measured by the mercury intrusion method [1, 41. A, good chromatographic silica packing should havenarrow a pore size distribution. In such case, pore volume, pore diameter and specific surface area can be linked by the a p p r o ~ ~ a t i relation: ve
t?- = 4
0 0 0 ~ ~ ~ ~
with the units m2/g, cm3/gand nrn for t?-, Vp and Pd, respectively. Eq. 4.1 can be used to estimate the pore volume of a given silica packing when the surface area andpore diameter are given. The typical pore size of classical LC packing ranges between8 and 20 m (80-200 B\)(Table 4.1). wide pore packings with30 to 100 nrn (300-1000 /S)pore size are mar~eted
Apolar surfaces are obtained with alkyl groups. A variety of can be bonded on silica surfaces producing chromatographic p a c h g s with a widerange of polarity and properties.
A bond^ silica packing is characterized by its carbon load, %C, its surface coverage in ~ ~ o l / m and 2 , the bonding type, monomeric or p o l ~ e r i c end-capped , or not [l, 3, 41. It was shown that the maxi mu^ bonding coverage density was 4.5 pmol/m2 for monomeric dimethyl-alkylsilyl groups. A lower coverage density means that some silanol groups remain a~ainable to the solutes. They are called “residual silanols.” They are responsible for the tailing observed onthe peaks of basic compounds and sensitivity of the packing. Table 4.1 lists the physicochemical properties of a selection ofcomercially available HPLC packings.
. classical 4.6 m i.d. LC column contains about l g of packing material per l 0 cm of column length. The packingsufiace area is much higher, inthe hundredth ofm2range, than the tubing surface area (a few cm2). ~urfactant adsorption on the porous packing should be consideredsince it may change the s t a t i o n a ~phase surface properties.
Several methods can be used to estimate the amount of surfactant molecules adsorbed on the s t a t i o n a ~phase surface in aLC column. The titration, the brea~hroughand the stripping methods will bedescribed because they can produce reliable results with common chromatographic equipment. The results obtained with agivenmethodcanbeused to checkand to corroborate the results of another method. Accuracy ofthe method dep~nds on the exact knowledge of the column dead volume which should be the first p a r ~ e t eto r establish.
a) Dead ~ o ~ u ~ e
~ e a s u r ~ ~ e ~ t s
The ~ e t e ~ i n a t i oofn the void or dead volume of a column is too often neglected by chromatographers. The dead volume,Vo, is the mobile phase volume inside the column. It corresponds to the inter-particle volume, Vi,
plus the porous or intra particle volume, V,. It is also the mobile phase volume needed to elute a nonretained solute. Vo=toF
(4.3)
where 1;, is the retention time of a nonretained solute and is the F flow rate. A n on retained sol LC with polar mobilephases can be pure acetone or methanol or asorbingioniccompound such as sodium nitrate or uracil [7]. The dead volume obtained should be compared to the column internal volume,VC: VC dc2= n;/4
L
(4.4)
where dcis the column i n t e ~ a l d i ~ eand t e rL, the column l e n ~ h .For the popular 4.6 mm i d . tubing, the column internal volume is 0.166 mL per column cm (-1.7 mL for 10 cm). The ratio V ~ is cthe total porosity of the column. It is a dimensionless number that should be somewhere between0.7 and 1. If the V ~ ratio c is found to be higher than unity, it means the dead volume is c is found to over~stimated:the solute used was retained. If the V ~ ratio belowerthan 0.7, thedeadvolumeis too small. The test solute was probably excluded from the internal pore volume ofstationa~ the phase. A practical rule of thumb for the 4.6 mm isd.column only is E71: V. (rnL) =: 0.1 L (cm)
(4.5)
A l0 cm 4.6 m i.d. column should have a dead volume closeto 1 mL. For adsorption isotherm determination, theaccurate knowledge of the dead volume is required. In mostcases, the dead volumetracer method produces appropriate results. When a cross-check the of dead volume value is necessa~,the ~ e ~~ se it can ~~ beo used. ~ First, the columnis carefilly flushed and filled with methanol which has a density of 0.79 14 g/cm3 at 120°C. It is disco~ectedfiom thepump and its two sides are closed to avoid evaporation. The column is weighted. Itsmass is WveOH.Next, the column is similarly flushed and filled with chloroform, d=l.483 g/cm3at 2O"C, and weighted. The second mass, WcHc13, higher than the first one, allows to obtain the dead volume with a high accuracy using:
HAS
7
The 1.446factor is only valid for methanol and chloroform at 20°C. Any pair of solvents with a significant density difference and compatibili~with the stationary phase can be used instead of methanol and chloroform. The 1.446 factor is trivially the reverse ofthe solvent density difference.
It is often necessary to determine the surfactant concentration in a given solution.Ionic surfactants canbedeterminedby the two-phaseliquid method. Ionic dyesare soluble in aqueousphases. They form ion-pairs with surfactant molecules bearing an opposite charge. The ion-pairs are apolar and canbe extracted intoan apolar organic phase. Chloroform is commonly used. The typical protocol for titration of a cationic surfactant, e.g., c e t y l t r i m e t h y l ~ o nbromide i~ (CTAB), is as follows. A known volume of the cationic surfactant solution to be titrated is introduced ina test-tube. It is diluted withwater. A l0 mL volume of chloroform is added along with few drops of a cationic indicator dye and a few drops of an anionic dye. Sunset yellow, mordant red 72, disulfine blue W 150 or alizarins are examples of anionic dyes. Cationic dyescan be dimidium bromide, methyl red, neutral red or chrornoxan green. The color of many indicators is pH dependent, and it may be necessary to add a buffer (or an acid) in the aqueous phase. Few cationic surfactant moleculesand the anionicdye associate forming ion-pairs that are extracted into the chloroform phase coloring it. A known SDS solution, say, exactly 0. drop. The tube isshaken. An emulsion forms eeds a minute to separate because it is stabilized by the cationic surfactant. andthecationic surfactant formion-pairs that chloroform phase. As the titration progresses, the emulsionseparates faster and faster because there is less and less cationic surfactant to stabilize it. When the endpoint is reached, the SDS molecules anionic dye-cationicsurfactant ion-pair and forman pair extracted by the organic phase. This produces the phases. The equivalent volume ofthe S S solution allows to calculate the cationicsurfactant concentration in the titrated volume. The protocol for
an anionic surfactant is similar. A CTA standard solution is used for the titrating agent. Nonionic surfactant cannot be titrated by this method. They are oRencompoundswithverylowvolatility. Their concentration can be d e t e ~ i n e dby weighting the r e m a ~ n gsolid matter aRer complete solvent evaporation. c) The ~
~ e u ~ t eth h ~hodo u ~ ~
The accuracy of the b r e ~ ~ o u method gh depends on the ability to detect the surfactant inthemobilephase. A refractive index ( )detector is most oftenrequiredsinceusable surfactants shouldnot absorb An evaporative light ring (ELS) detector can also be used su st surfac~antsare solids at room temperature.
A t h e ~ o s t a t e dchromatographicsystemshouldbe used. The ,packed with the studied s t a t i ~ ~ a phase, ry is first e~uilibratedby pass in^ the aq~eousphase, pure water or buffer or water and organic modifier, without anysurfactant molecule. The eluent is then switchedto a mixture made ofthe same mobile phasecon~ininga h o r n concentration, C, of surfactant. A surfactant concentration front thus moves down the c o l u ~ . If the surfactant is orbed by the packing material, the ,will exceed the dead or void volume, b r e ~ h r o u g hvolume of the front ~ ~ This ) ~ ~ o u n oft surfactant adsorbed will then be ( ~ B - [8]. shouldbeexpressedpreferablyinpmol/m2 for convenient compa~isonbetween phases. It should be pointedout that the brea~hroughvolume may notbe easy to determine. Figure 4.1 shows the idealb r e ~ h r o u g hshape and some curves that maybeobtaineddependingon thecolumn efficiency. A progressive surfactant adsorption may be due to pore size polydispersity of the stationa~phase: the larger pores are filled before the smaller pores. Also, successive surfactant layers may form. These c i r c u m s ~ c e smay in the detector response. In case of produce slow baseline changes or steps corrected. Theadsorbed ~ o u n of t steps, the VB volumeshouldbe s u ~ a ccorresponds ~ t to the area shown in Figure4.1. the signal is propo~ionalto the surfactant concentration.The recorder trace can be usedto correct the VBvolume. The responseof most ELS detectors
is not propo~ionalto the surfactant concentration. A calibration must be p e r f o ~ e d€or each case or the titration control shouldbe use.
Possible detector signal obtained during breakthrough experiments. An efficient column gives a sharp of rise the detector signal. A less efficient column gives a smooth detector rise. The shaded area shows the detector changes obtained in a real study [lo] and corr~spondsto the adsorbed surfactantamount.
or accurate results, it is advisa~letocontrol
the sur~actant a d s o ~ t i o n p e r € o ~ i nag titration. The effluentleaving the c o l u ~is correspond in^ to the collected untilthe detector response reaches plateau a absorbance value of the initial surfactant solution. concentration inthe collected effluentis d e t e ~ i n e dby titrati su~actantmass is adsorbed onthe stationa~phase in the column. The mass obtainedby titr~tionshould corroborate the one obtained using the brea~hroughvolume.
RTHO
Anotherway to determinetheamountof surfactant adsorbedonthe stationary phase of a column is to strip it off with a strong eluent and to titrate the collected emuent. This methodassumes that there is no irreversible surfactant adsorption. m s is not always the case. Irreversible adsorptions were mentioned by h o x for anionic surfactants [9] and by inze [101 for a nonionic surfactant. However, in most cases, adsorbed surfactant can be fully strippedoff the stationary phase by pure methanol, a mixtureof methanol and propanol orpure propanol. The protocol iss t r ~ ~ M~e r complete o ~ ~c o l~m . ~ ~ i l i b r a t i o n two with thesurfactant solution at concentration G, the column is flushed by or three void volumes of aqueous phase without surfactant. This effluent is not collected.This step washesout the water solublesurfactant contained in the void volume without desorbing the surfactant of the stationary phase. Next, the column is rinsed with at least 10 column void volumes of pure methanol (or propanol). The effluent, containing the desorbed sudactant, is collected. ethanol is evaporated and the dry surfactant is re-dissolved in a measured volumeof water. The amount ofsurfactant is determined by titration.
III.2. A ~ s o r ~ tIisoo~t ~ e rwith ~ s Aqueous ~ ~ a s e s a) Anionic ~urfactant ~ e ~ h studied o d the adsorption ofSDS on five different HypersilB stationary phases [l 11. Five 10 cm x 4.6 m i d . LC columns were specially selected for the study. All experiments were done in,a thermostatic bath at 30°C. The amount of SDS adsorbed on the phases was determined by crosschecking the resultsobtainedwith(i) the brea~hrough method,(ii) controlling the concentrationof the effluentsolution,and(iii)by the within an 8% stripping method. The 3 resultswereinagreement experimental error. Figure 4.2 presents the S S adsorption on bare , bonded phase,SAS Hyp ~ ~ e r s i l CPS B , ~ ~ e r s i l aBcyanopropyl a methyl bonded phase,MOS HypersilB, an octyl bonded phase and ersilo, anoctadecyl bondedphase. The physicochemical prope~iesof these phasesare listed inTable 4. l. A very differing behavior was obtained
HA
with nomicellar mobile phases and micellar mobiles phases. Figure 4.2 can be compared with the adsorption isotherms obtained in ion-pair chromato~raphy(Figure 3.1 and Chapter 3) 191.
0
0.002
0.004
0.0043
0.008
0.0
SDS ~ n c ~ n t r ~ t (mol/L) ion
SDS adsorption isotherms at 30°C on five different Hypersil@ A) nonmicellar mobile phases; B) micellar mobile phases, data from [1l].
phases.
S
the low concentration a1 point of view, the bile phase can be very large. The l.9 ~ m o ~ m 2
S
indicated byan arrow. Thethree nonpol ersil@,show a Lang~uir-likeadsorpti a concave shape or L type in the Giles’ classi~cation[121. phase shows a convex shapeor S type cooperative adsorpti increases in the order: bare silica < exactly the decreasing order of the
ypersil@passes the one on mainly responsiblefor
e [121:the amount of adsorbed suda
linear for a ionary and mobile phase, respectively, should be isotherm. Figure 4.3 shows the Freundlich plots of the five a d s o ~ t i o nisotherms. For the 4 bonded phases, there are clearly tvvo
di~erentslopes sepa by the micellization area (logcmc = -2. l). increase of adsorbed ismuchlowerwithmicellar solutions than pre-~icellarsolution. There is still a S adsorption increase. S phase. These results were possible to speak of saturationonlywith 'S workon an Alt hase [131. A diEerent result o noted a sharp adsorption m a ~ ~ for u man just before the micellization conc 153. The substrate was a mono-c~stallinesilicon wafer that was by nitric acid to produce an optically flat silica plate that was d end-capped. The bondingdensity was 2.8 chlorodimethyloctadecy pmol/m2, similar to the ersil8 (2.9 pmol/m2).This flat substrate is diE1cult to compare withporous silica used for LC pachngs. '
l
.3 S t a ~ o n phase a ~ versus mobile phase SDS concentr~tionsin log-log coordinate showing a clear break for the cmc value (cmc= 0.0082 M,log cmc = -2.1).
6) Cationic S~rfactant
The adso~tionof CTAB was similarly studied on the five H ~ e r s i l ~ s t a t i o n a ~phases listed in Table 4.1 [111, The results are presented in xres 4.4 and 4.5
GTAB concentration (mol/L)
o
0.b2 ab4
0 . h 0.08 o:r 0.i2 0.i4 CTAB concentration (mot&)
o.is
0 . i ~ 012
Figur CTAE3 adsorption isotherms at 30°C on five different Hypemil@phases. A) nonmicellar mobile phases; B) micellar mobile phases.
~ o n - M i c ~Mobile ~ l a ~ Phases. Figure 4.4A shows the CTAB adsorption for sub-micellar solutions. The conclusions are exactly similar to those obtained for SDS adsorption. The b r e ~ h r o u g hvolumes were much higher. The 2.1 ~mol/m2 CTAB adsorption withthe 0.0003 M solution corresponds to 0.00022 moles of CTAB. This amount was contained in 2.2 liters of mobile phase. The experiment duration was two days at l mL/min. The three apolar phases show L-type concave adsorption isotherms. The two polar phases show S-type convex isotherms [121. The notable dif3erence is the CTAB adsorption on bare silica. This adsorption is a proof that ~y~rophobic interaction is not the onlydriving force for CTA adsorptionon the poroussilica surface. S i l ~ o l - q u a t e ~armno a~ interactions are likely. They induce a cooperative adsorption of more C molecules by hydrophobic interaction.
log Cm ([CTAB] in mol/L)
.5 Stationaryphase versus mobilephase C T A B concentrationsinlog-log coordinate showing a clear breakfor the cmcvalue (cmc = 0,0009 M, log cmc = -3.05).
.5
~ i c e l l a~r o ~ iPhases. l e Figure 4.4 shows the 30°C adsorption i s o ~ e ~ s concentration range [1l]. The five i s o t h e ~ are lateau for concen~ationhigher than the cmc [121. Figure 4.5 shows the corresponding logC, versus log C, ~reundlichplots The curves are clearly made by two lines. The slo e chan e at the cmc concent~ation(log cmc= -3 -05)is apparent an a d s o ~ t i o nsaturation is observed for C cmc. For the three other phases, a adsorbed ~ o u nist noted (Figure 4. what was observed with the S S surfactant (Figur
c) ~ o n ~ o n i c
~urfact~~~
inze studied the adsorption of nonionic s u r f a c ~ ton s a Cl (Resolve G 18, Table 4. l) [161. H-type isotherms similar to the ones obtained with ionic surfactants (Figures 4.2 and 4.4) were e s ~ b ~ i s h efor d two polyosyethylene dodecyl ether surfa~tants (BrijB22 and adsorption increased beyond the surfactantcmc.The 22 ~ o u nincreased t from l .4 pm0 )to 2 pmo~m2at 1700 cmc (0.16 unt was almost increase of the BrijB 35 adsorb cont~uous.It was about 0.3 p and 0.9 pmo~m2 at 850cmc (0. G, versus log C, Freundlich plot ofthe BrijB 22 bilinear curve s i ~ i l ato r the plots found in Figure m Freundlich plot of the BrijB 35 break at the cmcconcentration. ater soluble surfactant, itmay have a low affinity for the apolar bmded solve C l 8 s t a t i o n aphase ~ [16].
a) ~hysicoche~ical ~tructure of the Ionic ~urfactantLayer The s t ~ c ~ofr e
ed on porous silica 5 pm, 6 m pore re studied first [171 so stu~ied[181. with high power proton
FT
es used to study the sur orbed molecules. linked to polarity di~erencesfound with s u r f a c t ~covered t phases.
~urfactantadsorption on monomeric C 18 bonded silica phases.A) the ionic B) the cationic sulfate groups protrude outside the bonded layer making it negatively charged; 8 layer; C) Sil~ophilicinteractions are another way ammonium groups are buried insideC 1the of adsorption; D) the cyano to explain the lower ionic charge observed in case CTAl3 strongly bindto thecharged surfactant head either positive or negative. A, B and D from studies [17, 181. C from chromatographic studies [19].
n a~yl-bondedphases, the W results seem to indicate that the surfactant is located insidethe trimethyl onium polar head of the CTAB thickness ofthe bonded layer (Figure 4.6~4)when the sulfate polar group of de as illustrated by Figure 4.613 [1’71. This would covered alkyl-phases are more polar with a negative charge than the TAB covered phases. These results are coherent with o d that theSDS adsorption could occur Berthod’s work[191. ~ e ~ thought ophobic adsorption as seenby (Figure 4.6). However, ways to describe the adsorptio B: (i) h y ~ o p h o ~and ic (ii) silanop~lic adsorp~on (Figure 4.6C) [191. The silanophilic adsorption is the interaction between the Lewis acid silanol groups and the basic cationic onium groups.It is the onlyway to explain the CTAB adsorption on the bare silica (Figure 4.4). The studies showed that there was a strong interaction the surfactantcharged heads andthe cyano groups bonded on the rb phase. The charged heads ofthe adsorbed surfactant molecules are ‘‘tied up” by the cyano ~ n c t i o n a l of i ~the bonded phase (Figure 4.6 [181. The negative SDS charge is almost canceled and so is the positive charge. The stationary phase has just a slightly higherpolarity after surfactant adsorption. The surfactant-c~anogroups’ strong inte~actionwas difficult to disrupt: part of CTAB or SDS was irreversibly adsorbed on ~ i c r o s o r b[1S]. Such irreversible adsorption was not observed with the ypersilB phases [l 1, 191.
b)
ha^^^ of the
Silica Surface
It was shown that the adsorption of s u r f a c t ~molecules t onthe silica surface changes its polarity. ~bviously,it also changes its s t ~ c t u r esufiace , area, pore volume and pore size. It was shown that, with S S and BrijB 35, the surface arealost beyond the cmc was closeto 0.6m2p adsorbed surfactant ole [161. For example, 0.5 pmol/m2 of BrijB 35 were olve C 18 whenthe aqueous phase concentration was 0.02 this phase was 180m2/g The total amount ofadsorbed is 90 pmoles. The surface area decline is close to face area of the stationary phasecovered bythe is only 126 m2/g, a 30% loss. The surface area loss was only 0.3 m2 per adsorbed pmole of BrijB 22.
The surface area decrease may be to distortion due of the pore shape or to pore filling with surfactant. The pore structure of the phase was studied by nitrogen porosimetry [161. It was found that, for 2 and SrijO 35and for anionic SDS, the generalporeshape no of 18 phase was retained. The pore volume was decreased by surfactant adsorption. These observations suggested that the s u ~ a c ~ t molecules were coating the interior walls of the pores without completely filling them[161. The thick surfactant film formed onthe top of the organic bonded layer is responsible for apart of the loss of efficiencyobserved in L C with purely aqueousphases. 111.4. Eflect o ~ ~ o b i ~ eA~~itives P ~ on ~ Ss e~ ~ a c At ~~ s~o t~ ~ ~ i o n a,)Buffers and Salts
Ionic compounds are frequently added to micellar mobile phasesfor p 2 described the significant changesthat ionic strength adjustments. Chapter anysalt additionproducesonthephysicochemical s t r u c ~ r eofionic surfactant micelles (mainly: decrease of cmc and increase the aggregation of number). The slope changes in the log C, versus log C, Freundlich plotfor adsorption data obtained with CTAB and SDS mobile phases with 0.1 NaCl added salts corresponded to the surfactant cmcs in such solutions (0.0002 M and 0.0014 M, respectively, comparedto 0.0008 M and 0.0082 M in pure water) [20]. The amount of adsorbed surfactant was found to depend on the stationary phase [1 1,16, 191. A “salting-out” effect was observed with the apolar alkyl phases. Inmost cases, it increased the amount of adsorbedsurfactant by loweringthe electrostatic repulsions and enhancing the hydrophobic interactions [rZO]. Table 4.2 lists the effect of NaCl addition on the adsorption of various surfactants on different L C phases. The addition of NaCl increases the surfactant adsorption by 15 to 40%. The exception,5pmol/m2of SDS on HypersilO SAS C1 phase dropping to 4.4 ~mol/m2 when 0.1 M NaCl is added (Table 4.2), was that are enhanced by NaC1 on explained by silanol ion-exchange phenomena hase [rZO]. The Si-0- ionized groups have no affinity for the anionic *
~ u ~ a c t+a ~ t NaCl
~dsor~ed tat. Phase ~191 POI 1191
5.2
-id-
4.6
Davisil C18 -id-id-id-
3.2 .8
.o
5.0
~191 POI 1191 c201 1.5
7
33
P11
3.4 -id-
[21] 3.6
150
-id-id-
3.1
1’70
-id-id-id-
P11 C211 c211 [H]
1.8 2.6 [21] 130
[21] c211
Table 4.2 presents the results obtainedwith W absorbing pyridinium chloridesurfactants [2 l]. The authors studied the “salting out” S stationary phase. ef5ect that increased the adsorbed ~ o u n on t an They also studied the desorption rate of the four ethoxy pyridinium chloride surfactants by passing pure NaCl solutions onthe surfactant-coveredphase. exponential decrease ofthe surfactant loadmg was obtained. The half time, tl,2,to desorb 50% of the surfactant, was between 1.5 hours and 170 hours (a week) [2l], NaCl dramatically decreasedthe sudactant desorption rate. This is a logical consequence of the “salting out” effect.
The first studies of surfactant adsorption isotherms were donewith hydroses in ion-pairing chromatography.The CTA rsil8 was found to be 1.2 pmol/m2 with 5 thanol-water mobile phase containing 0.0 1 is valueis 30% lower than the value obtain water (1.7 pmol/m2, Figure 4.4). h o x obtained even lower values on a HypersilB SAS phase (0.2 pmol/m2 with a 30-70% v-v prop~ol-water e was the first to establish phase containing 0.055 surfactant adsorption isotherms 191. The adsorbed amou S was as high as 8 pmol/m2 with a 20-80% watermobile phase containing 0.07 sodium salts and 0.0 Saturation of the stationary phase by AB was observed o C 18phase when 60-40% v-v methanol-water (with0. l a CTAB concentr It was established that organic modifiers decreasedthe ~ o u noft adsorbed surfactant by competingfor adsorption sites and/or bydecreasi~g the hydrophobic interactions [24]. For ionic surfactants, the ability of an organic modifier for s u r f a c ~desorption t was related to its hydrophobici~. Figure 4.7 shows that the amount ofadsorbed surfactant decreases linearly with the organic modifier concentration. The slope of the lines is related to the surfactant desorption s t r e n ~ h . Pentanol strongly desorbs ionic surfactants, methanol is less efficient [24]. hysicoche~calmethods such as contact meas~rementsand ourier t r a n s f o ~ e dinfrared (FT
le, surface tension spectroscopy were
f ~ a of~additive ~ n
ole fraction of additive
Effect of organic additives on the plateau of concentration of adsorbed surfactant. Stationary phase: Hypersil ODs; mobile phase concentration,SDS =0.2 M,CTAB = 0.1 M, data from 1241,
used to investigate the structure of the alcohol-silica bonded layer [25]. It was found that the alkylchains of propanol and longern-alcohols inte~enetratethe C18 bonded alkyl chains to form a single monolayer similar to the one formed by the alkyl chains of the surfactant molecules (Figure 4.6). The hydroxyl group is oriented toward the aqueous phase. Competitionbetweenalcohol and surfactant molecules for a d s o ~ t i o n explains the decreasedamount of adsorbed surfactant with increasing concentration of alcohol inthe mobile phase (Figure 4.7). The organic additives of the micellarmobile phase affect the su~actant-adsorbedlayer. This changes the chromatographicselectivity and efficiency obtainedfor a set ofanalytes with the same column. and efficiency are studied in otherparts of this book.
It was shown that surfactants adsorb at any interface, especially the stationary phase surface. The question is: once a column is well ~uilibrated with a micellar phase, are we working with a given bonded stationary phase or with a surfactant stationary phase? In other words, does the surfactant coating of the stationary phases render themall similar?
To answer to the introduction question, astudy of the retention behaviorof a set of solutes of various polarities was done with different stationary phases and identical micellarmobile phases [26]. SDS and C phases were used withfivedifferent i18 phases. The retention of the strong's three phase polar, apolar as well as ionicsolutesobeyed model(eq. 3.4, Chapter 3). Table 4.3 lists the solute-micelle partition coefficient and the PWs solute-stationary phase affinity coe~lcientfor different solutes on four bonded phases. values are similar within experimental errors (see Chapter 5).Th alues are similar for the and C 18 bondedphases. hese two phases do behave similarly in classical LC. The more polar 1 and CN bonded phases do show signific~tly ower a&ty coefficient The surfactant layer is there: cationic solutes are retainedby the four bondedphasesandhyd anic mobile phases. eirhighaffinity for the stationary phaseswithobile phases isdue
a~itionCoef~cients, hase ~~~, Pws,for Four
Solute
SAS C1
tationary phase ODs C18
MOS C8
38 37 40 ctylbenzen~sulfonate 160 e n z y l t r i ~ e t ~ y l a ~1700 on.
300 2000
0 35 1900 Cetylpyridi~umchloride 3000
360 23 3200 4700
35 1400
~tylbenzenesulfon~te 9.4 e n ~ y l t r i ~ e t ~ y l420 ~on.
190 190 Ca~eine 3.6 1.8 enzoic acid 870 550 760 Cetylpy~di~um chloride 850 610 1000
Average value
38 220 1900
36 l10 500
200 1500
390 2800 2900
190 34 2000 4300
300 33 2500 3700
33 1500
10 51
. .
2.3
2.0 90
63
m
.=
910
Data from Ref.28. Toluene = apolar solute, cafEeine= polar solute, sodium octylben~enesulfonate and benzoic acid= anionic solutes,b e n ~ l t r i m e ~ y l a m m o n i ~ = cationic solutes. H~ersil stationa~ bro~ideand cetylp~ridi~ium c~loride phase data are listed in Table 4. l.
enol) ere more retained on
the
b) ~ ~ t e ~ f aTension ci~l
was s h o that ~ the surfactant adsorption decreasedthe interfacial tension between the stationary and mobile phases. In the absence of micelles (ionpair chromatography), the nonionic solute retentionfactor was agected by t h s interfacial tension change accordingto eq. 4.7 [321:
where k,is the retention factor in the absence ofsur~actant,C is the mobile phase surfactant concentration (Kcmc), is the Gibbs free energyof adsorption of the surfactant at idkite dilution and4; is a constant relatedto the change in interfacial tension caused by the added surfactant. A. negative 4; value produces a decrease of the solute retention factor with an increase of surfactant concentration [33].
c) ~ a ~~ i cde l ~ Gradient ar Capabili~es The surfactant adsorption isotherms showan almost horizontalplateau for sur~actantconcentration above the cmc (Figures 4.3 and 4.5). This property was used to perform rapid analyses with a micelle concentration gradient a micellar solution a change in total surfactant concentration serves hange the concentration ofthe micelles. If the surfact~t-a~orbed layer depends only on the free s u r f a c ~concentration, t thenthe stationa~ phase is not altered bychangesintheconcentrationof the micelles. erefore it is possible with micellar concentration gradientsto speed the ion of strongly retained solutes without affecting the stationary phase t [34]. This allows a step gra~ientback to the initial conditions ~ t h o u ree~uili~ration time [l31. This rapid gradient capability is not universal in horizontal plateau in thesurfactant isotherm adsorption ficant increases of s u r f a c t ~ adsorption t above the cmc were observed especially with nonionic surfactant [l61 and/or with polar statio^^ phases [.191. In such cases, some time (=several column volumes) will be necessary to re-equilibrate the column after a micellar gradient analysis.
7 *
It is always recommended to use the same column with the same type of surfactant. A column should be dedxated to the anionic su~actants,a second oneto the cationic sudactants, etc. The reproducibility of the results in MLC dependsonthecolumnequilibration. The adsorbed layer of surfactant should be donecorrectly. It was shownthat the time to reach the equilibrium between the stationary phase and the mobile phase could be very long in ion-pair chromatography with sub-micellar mobile phases. Two days at 1 mLlmin were necessaryto equilibrate a 15 cm x 4.6 mm i.d. column of HypersilB ODs with a mobile phase containing 0.0003 These low surfactant concentration solutions do notconta they are not used inMLC. With a micellar phase,the equilibration time is reduced. It is possible to use the rapid gradient capability just mentioned above. Typically,a mobile phase containinga hgh surfactant concentration (10 to 100 cmc)can be usedto quicklysaturate the column withsurfactant. Then 5 to 10 column volumesare used to rinse the column withthe mobile phase containingthe desired amount ofsurfactant.
The recommendationto use the same column withthe same surfactant was done because, in some instances, it may be impossible to fillyremove the su~actant-adsorbedlayer. It was not possible to eliminate a small part of SDS adsorbed on a 1980 HypersilB ODs phase even when using a pure methanol mobile phase [S]. However, a complete SDS desorption from a 1988Hypersil8 ODs phase was possible with pure a methanol mobile phase [24]. Part of the nonionic Brij 35 surfactant could not be removed from a Resolve C 18 phase after a 24-hour elution of water-acetonitrile 70-30% v-v [161. Conversely, thereare many examples where thesurfactant layer can be completely stripped off the stationary phase [1 1, 19, 2 1,241. It was suggested that partial irreversible surfactant adsorption was dueto a tight insertion of the s u r f a c ~ alkyl t chains in thealkyl moieties of the bonded A column could be used with ~erent layer of densely grafted phases [35].
S (anionic and catio c) afker a complete methanol [M].
"
ost s u r f a c ~ t are s very soluble In pure m phase is r e c o ~ e n d e dfor s u r f a c ~ t methanol-propanol75-25%v-v may be n e c e s s a ~in rare occasions. 20 to 50 column volumes is the minimum ~uantityof methanol to elute and to remove the adsorbed surfactant. h experime ensure a complete su~actantdesorption. The a decreases the solute mass~transferbetween th mobilephase. This producesband-broadeni erved [l6, 24, 353. The e x p e r ~ e n t atest ~ can be test m i ~ u r e is prepared to measure the ef~ciencyo LC newcolumnwith a classical hydro-organic mobile p e~ample,a 50 pmol/L benzophenone + biphenyl solution was stationary phase and a~ethanol-water75-2 ntion p a r ~ e t e r sof the test solutes (retenti es) are measured with the hydro-organic mobile phase and the any surfactant exposition. These p a r ~ e t e r sare simil~rly column has been exposedto s u r f a c ~ t srinsed , with pure quilibrated with the reference hydro-or~anicmobile phase [24]. If the retention factors and the peak ef~cienciesof the test solutes re cove^ ofthe initial s~tionary similar to their original values, a complete phase surface can be assumed. small decrease of the col^ e ~ c i e n c y be due to column aging.
rsolutionsused C containmore than 90% vlv water. e aqueous solutions are to dissolveminute ~ o u n t sof silica ecially at elevated temperature~30'~) andlor values hi~herthan 6. 1ca dissolution is deadly for thecolumn. It uldbereduced to a S problem is solved by saturating the aqueous mobile phase is done, without causing any band broadening, bylaci in^ a s a ~ r a t i n g p r e c o l just u ~ after the pump and b re the injection valve. This precolumn can be a short (5 cm x 4.6 m i. column packed with a
are silica phase to reduce the pressure buil precolumn also acts as a filter, it should be checkedregularly.
A micellar solution should stay not in contact with the bon based s~tionary-phaseswhen the chromatogra~hicsystem is not first reason is that the c~omatographi dware does not like S such as ionic surfactant solutions. osionmay occur in systems conta~ingionic surfactant solutions. that are weighted to prepare the micellar soluti an produce crystals’ forma~onaround the pump rystals may obstruct the system producing c may also scratch the p u p piston. The sec rich micellar solution may produce silica Si-C bond ruptures that can ruin the column. A very essential rule of care is: a m i ~ e l ~ phase ar s h o u never ~ ~ stay motionless in a c h r o ~ a t o ~ r a p h l ~ system. cleaning procedure will beindicated. It may be every evening andto re-equilibrate it everymo that a micellar phase does not harma c ~ o m a t o g r a p ~syc is not static. This means that it is possible to keep a micellar phase overnig if the pump is not turned off. If the operator knows he willgo on WO with the same micellar phase and he wants to leave, hec m value (often 0.1 mL/min) to reduce the pressure he shouldplace the detector outletTe the mobile phase r e s e ~ o i rto recycle the micellar phase. ensures that the system will not run dry (unless a leak occu also guarantees the good equilibrium of the adsorbe column. Last, itsaves the stationary phase since the recycled mobile phase is saturated in dissolve silica and will not dissolve moreof it. LC system will not be used for the weekend or d according to the following three step pro First, the micellar phase is replaced by 100% pure water. pump is flushed rapidly and the system, valve, column, detector tubing, is rinsed with 10to 20 column volumes of pure water. higher flow rate can be used if the pressu does not increase too much. The pure water viscosity is only 1
Next, a 100% methanolmobilephase is used to remove the adsorbed surfactant in the chromtographic system. A IowJEow rate (0.5 mLlmin or less) should be used at the beginning because the methanol-water mixture has a hgh viscosity whichis signi~cantly increased by the desorbed surfactant. Once the pressure decreases, the flow rate may be resumed. At least 10 column volumes pure of methanol should be passed throughthe column. Then, the hydro-organic mobile phase used to test the column efficiency can be loaded in the system (5- 10 column volumes). The test itself will be done when the system willrestarted. be The power can be turned off. The column contains a classical hydro-organic phase without ionsthat will not damageit. The complete procedure takes about half an hour. It should not be n e g s t d . The 100% water step should not be bypassed. A brutal change fiom a buEerd micellar mobile phaseto a 100% methanol phasem y produce salt c r y ~ l i ~ ~ The o n column . and even thep ~ p system ~ g could be damaged. The last step, with a hydro-organic mobile phase, can be bypassed. But it is good practiceto check for column performances once every week. the micellar phase during the If thetwo rules, a low flow rate with night and the30 min cleaning procedurefor the weekend,are respected, the life~imeof the columns used inMLC are comparable and evensuperior to LC.These rules were followed witha chromatographic performances were system using a 15-cm ODS column. The CO ma~tainedfor morethantwoyearsofintensive use.
2.
3.
erthod, Silica: Backbone ater rial of Liquid Chromatography Column Packing, J Chromatogr., 549: 1 (199 1). Unger, F.E. and Regnier R.E. matography Packings,J Chromatogr., 544: 1 (1991). A. Berthod, ~ o r m a l and Reversed Phases in Liquid Chromatography, Encyclopedia of Analytical Science, Academic ress, New York,pp. 2567 (1995).
4.
K.K. Unger, Porous Silica, J. Chromatogr. Library, Elsevier, ~ s t e r dVol. ~ ,16 (1979).
5.
J.C. Giddings, Dynamics of Chromatography,Marcel York (1965).
6.
Fhenomenex, ~ P L C ~ a t e r iSorbent al Characte~stics, Commercial Catalogue (1996).
7.
L.R. Snyder, J.J. Kirklandand J.L. Glajch, Prac~calHPLC eth hod ~evelopment,2nd Ed. VViley Interscience,NewYork (1997)).
8.
J.H. . b o x and G.R. Laird, Soap Chromatography)a New HPLC Techniq~e for Separation of Ionizable ~aterials) J Chromato~r. , 122: 17 (1976).
9.
Knox and R.A. Hartwick, Mechanism of Ion-pair Liquid omatography ofAmines, Neutrals, Zwitterions andAcids using Anionic ~etaerons,J Chromatogr., 204: 3 (198 1).
10.
and Evaluation erding andW.L. Hinze, ~haracte~zation ofNonionic~~cellar~obile Phases in .RP-HPLC, Anal. Chem., 57: 2183 (1985).
11.
A.Berthod, I. Girard and C. Gonnet, MLC: Adsorption Isotherms of Two Ionic Surfactants on Five Sta~onary Phases, Anal. Chem.,
58: 1356 (1986). 12.
C .H. Giles, Anionic Surfactants, E.H. Lucassen-Re~ders (Ed.), Surfactant ScienceSeries, Marcel Dekker, New York, Vol. 1 1, 4 (1981).
13.
orsey, M.G. Khaledi, J.S. Landyand J.L. Lin, Gradient E l u t i o n ~ CJ, Chromatogr., 316: 183 (1984).
14.
M.E. Montgomeryand M.J. VVirth, Eflect of SDS onthe c in a C18 ~rientational B e h ~ i o rof a ~ y ~ r o p h o b iProbe Monolayer Bonded to Silica, Anal. Chem., 64: 2566 (1992).
15.
.A.Fiaseckiand M.J. Wirth, Spectroscopic Probing of the Interfacial ~oughnessof SDSAdsorbed to a Hydrocarbon Surface, Langmuir, 10: 19 13(1994).
17.
Interface Sei., 165: 497 (199~). 18.
ooper, Solid-State onCyanopropyl o n ~ e d ~ h a sIrnplieations es: for MLC, JI Colloid Interf~ceSei., 179: 341 (1996).
19.
,A d ~ i ~ v e on ~ ~urfaetant ~ects
20. 1362 (1986). 21.
surf act ant^ on ODS ~ilica:Role of ~l~ctrostatics, J. C o l l o i ~ Interface Sei., 155: 124 (1993). 22.
.A. Wall, ~ y d r o p h o b i c C h ~ o ~ a t o ~ rwith aphy , S1 Dyna~icallyCoated Sta~onaryPhases, J.~ h r u ~ a t o g r1.74: (1979).
23.
i e r s e ~ a ,~ e v e r s e d ~ h a s e ~ ~ with L CC ~ t r i ~ i Containing de ~ l u e nJ.~Lig. , C ~ r o ~ a t o g4:~ . , 1961 (1981).
24.
ussel, he R o ~ eof the Station~ry~ h a s ein C. A ~ s o r ~ t i oand n ~ ~ c i e n cJ y., Chrornatogr.,449: 349 &h, Spectroseopic Study of the aC18 Surface by L o n ~ - ~ h na~n ~lcohols, Anal. Chern., 66: 680 (1994).
27.
29.
30.
1.
32.
kda, ~ i ~ u l t a n e o u s ~ e ~ a r a tofi o Ionic n and on ionic C o ~ ~ o u n dussin^ ~eversed-~hase ~ieell~r Chro~ato~ra~~y Anal. ~ e i ~ n ~9:e59 s , (2993).
eming, T h e r ~ o d y n a ~ i c Ion- air LC, Anal. Chem., 54: 225 1 e~ersed-~hase
,Interfacial Tension
33.
1.C h e ~,55: . 425 (1
radient Ca~abilities inze, Investi~ationof the C, J: c h r o ~ a t o ~ r556: . , 263
35. (1991).
. icellar Liquid Chromatography(MLC), the mobile phase consists of an ~queoussolution of surfactant at a concentrationabove the critical mi concentration (cmc), in contact an with alkyl-bonded stationary phase. versed-PhaseLiquidChromatography LC) mode, with micelle S a mobile phase modifier. It is also o necessary to add a small concentration of an organic solvent to improve the efficiency and br control the elution strength and selectivity of the mobile phase. technique has also been named as pseudo-phase liquid chromatography. This term was coined to describe separations where s i ~ f i c a n t p a ~ i t i o n i n g of a solute occurs to discrete aggregates dissolved in.the mobile phase, rather than to bulk solvent. of anionic, cationic, nonionic and icellar mobile phases zwitterionic surfactants are usedinconjunction with stationary phases(including CS, C18 and cyano). su~actant(usually
solute-statio~a~ phase hydr ar ith an anionic surfactant: (a) n o n ~ o ~ soiut
icellar systems share the basic components of an at is, a nonpolar stati phaseand a polar aqueousmobile phase. owever, con~entional with a ~ u e o u s - o r g ~mobile c phases homogeneous, whereas micellar solutionsare microscopicallyheterogeneous, being co~posedof two distinct media: the ~ p h i p h i l i cmicellar aggregates e surrounding bulk aqueous or aqueoussurfactant monomers in a concentration approximately equal to the cmc. Inmicellar solutions, the solutes are preferential~ysolubiliz~ into or onto the micellar assembly, a process which is d ~ ~Thecsolutes . localized in micelles experiencemicroenviro~ent a that is d r ~ a t i c a l l ydifferent from that of bulk solvent interns of polarity d fluidity. This is reflected by micelle-inducedp e ~ ~ r b a t i o nofsphysicochemical prope~iesof the solutes, i~cludingchanges in solubility, acidity, photo~hysical prope~ies and reaction rates. L C is muchgreater than that of conventional
solvents, because of the number of possible ~teractionswith both mobile and stationary phases (Fig. 5.1). The solutes in the mobile phase can interact electrostaticallywith the charged outer-layer of ionic micelles, and hydrophobically with their lipophilic interior. steric factor can also be i m p o ~ ~The t . modificationof the stationary phase by a d s o ~ t i o nof surfactant mono~ers,which creates a"micelle-li surface, gives riseto similar ~teractionswith the solutes. The co~bination of these interactions cannot be duplicated by anytraditional pure or mixed ile micellar solutions will never totally replace traditional aqueous-organic eluents, they offer several interesting alternatives to separation work. The basic mechanism ofseparation in L C is fairly well understood and there is a reasonable theoretical foundation on whichto build. a fascinating example of the use of a secondary chemical equili liquid chro~atography.The primary equilibrium is the pa~itioningof the solute between bulk mobile phase and stationary phase, and the secondary equilibrium is the pa~itioning tomicelles. This secondary equilibrium is affected bya great variety of p a r ~ e t e r s :type and concentrations of surfactant and additives such as salts or org c modifiers (for instance, . The current knowledgeon C interactions isexposed
1
in this chapter. The 0 plications of such interactions on the elution strength and selectivi~of micellar eluentsare considered in
mstrong and Nome [l]proposed a three-phase (stationary phase, bulk aqueoussolvent and micellarpseudo-phase)model, to explain the chromatographic behavior in an W L C system of a solute eluted with a mobile phase containing a surfactant above the cmc. Such a treatment has allowed a theoretical description of MLC, and greater understanding and utilization of this chromatographic technique. ~ccordingto the three-phase model, the retention of a solute is controlled bythree competing reversibleequilibria, namely partitioning (or b ~ d i n g )from bulk aqueous solvent to micelles, p a ~ i t i o ~ nfrom g bulk aqueous solvent to the alkyl-bonded stationary phase, and direct transfer from micelles to the stationary phase. The first equilibrium takes place inside the mobile phase, and the latter equilibrium can be neglected in most si~ations,but it is significant for highly nonpolar (water-insoluble) solutes, which have a great affinity for both stationary phase and micelles. The partition in^ equilibria are described by three coef5cients: Pm (between water and micelles), Pws (between water and stationary phase), and,,P (between micelles andstationary phase). It is the first partition c Pw ,that imparts uniqueness to MLC. The coefficients Pwsand opposing effects on the retention of solutes: as Pwsincreases the retention due to increased increases, whereasas P,, increases the retention is reduced partition in^ into micelles. The retentionbehavior of solutes willdependon the type of interactions with the micelles and with the surfactant-modified stationary phase. Nonpolar solutes should only be affected by hydrophobic interactions (Fig. 5. la). For these solutes, different proportions of nonpolar, dipoledipoleand proton donor-acceptor interactions between solutes and
surfactants are expected. But for solutes that are charged, two distinct situations can be considered:
(i) the sign ofthe charges on the solute and surfactant arethe same (Fig. 5.lb), or (ii) the sign ofthe charges onthe solute and su~actantare opposite (Fig. 5. IC).
The first situation is encountered when an anionic solute is eluted with an anionic surfactant, or a cationic solute is eluted with a cationic surfactant [e.g.,dissociated phenol with the anionic surfactant sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), and protonated benzylaminewith the cationic ),on a C 18 column] surfactantdodecyl t r i m e t h y l ~ o n i u mbromide (D [2]. Electrostatic repulsionfrom the micelleshoul affect the retention as the solute will still reside in the bulk solvent phase, and therefore, will move downthe column. In contrast, repulsion fromthe su~actant-modified the solute may elute stationaryphase shouldcause a decreased retention, and in the dead volume. However, it may be retained by hydrophobic ~teraction with the stationary phase, although this effectwill be reducedby the electrostatic repulsion. Because due to different hydrophobic interactions, dissociated phenol and 2-naphtholare well separated with S The second situation appears when a solute is c~omatographedwith an oppositelycharged surfactant? where electrostatic attraction occurs between both species. ~lectrostaticattraction between solute and micelle will complement any hydrophobic interaction?and thus, it can be expected that the solute will remain inthe mobile phase for a longer period of time, decreasing the retention. However, electrostatic and hy~ophobic intera~ions with the stationary phase are often sufficiently large to offset micellar attraction and thus thee retention will increase. That is why ~ssociated phenol and 2-naphtholare retained to a greater extent with SDS on a Cl8 column [2].
on ionizable solutes should only e~perience hydrophobic interactions. It has been shown, however,that any molecule with moment can profoundly be affected byelectrostatic effects [3].
nction of the micellarpseudo-phasein has beencompared to that of the organic modifierin traditional S for most solutes an increase in the concentration of surfactant in the mobilephase results in a decreased retention. This is in contrast to reversed-phase ion-interaction chromatography, where the surfactant concentration is belowthe cmc (i.e., no micelles exist), and the addition of an ionic surfactant will retention of compounds that interact electros~ticallywith it. ,the elution strength increaseswith micelle concentration only ifthe solute interacts with micelles.
strong and Stine [4] proposed a classification of compounds into three groups, according to their elution behavior with a micellar mobile phase: (i) compounds bindingto micelles (ii) nonbinding cornpounds (iii) antibinding compounds
c om pounds that associate or bind to micellesshowdecreased retention when the concentration of micelles inthe mobile phase is increased. or compounds that do not associate with micelles, the retention may remain unalteredby the micellecontents (nonb~ding), may increase with c creasing micelle concentration (antibinding). Fig. .2 shows plots of the n factor (lk)vs. micelle con~ntration([ nding, nonbindingand antibinding compo lines of positive, zero and negative slope, respectively. The behavior most freque~tlyobserved is binding to micelles, while the antibinding behavior is quite ~ n c o ~ o n .
Typical plotsof MLC retention vs. mobile phase micelle concentrationfor a: (a)
bind in^ solute, (b)non bind in^ solute, (c) anti bind in^ solute.
ith anionic micelles are n e ~ a t i ~ e l y
lsion is an i m ~ o factor ~ ~ in t so ~ositi~ely charged corn ~~~
The a n t i b ~ d behavior ~g cannot be observed with stationary phases that adsorb an appreciable mount of surfactant (i.e.,C8 or C 18 bonded phases). For these phases, when the column acquires the same charge as the micelles, and no hydrophobicinteraction occurs, similarly charged solutes tend to elute in the dead volume of the column. In contrast, when using stationary phases which do not adsorb large quantities of surfactant (i.e.,C 1 or preferably cyano-bonded phases), one can observe increased retention when eluting with higher a concentration of micellesthe in mobile phase. Antibinding results from a compound being strongly excluded or repelled from the micelle. In fact, the solute is not only excluded from the micelle, but also from the double-layer aroundthe micelle. Thesolute is thus forced onto the stationary phase. A. negativewater-to-micelle pa~ition 0) has been assigned to these compounds, whichhas in principle no physical meaning. However, as compounds that bind to micelles each have a characteristic coefficient, compounds that are excluded from micelles may have characteristic a negative parameter. This parameter may be usefbl, sinceinsome cases it canbe correlated to the degreeof electrostatic repulsion between solute and micelles. There are a variety of methodsto measure partition coefficients of solutes to micelles. Much less attention is givento solutes that do not seem to interact with micelles or, at least, do not follow models that require a specific type or amount of interaction. The repulsion of a solute from a micelle is sometimes implied (for instance, in the micellar idibition of a reaction), but rarely treated in a rigorous quantitative manner. Part of the reason for this is the lack of experimental techniquesthat can measurezero or negative interactions. In addition, experimental phenomena that can be explained bythe binding ofsolutes to micelles are often thought to be more relevant and interesting. Using MLC one can detect and measure positive (i.e. binding), negative (i.e., antibinding) or zero (i.e. nonbinding) interactions between solutes and micelles. ~ u ~ h e ~ oone r ecan , monitor a solute's change in behavior (from binding to nonbinding to antibinding or vice versa),when a small change the in e n v i r o ~ e nand/or t micelles occurs.
3
11.3. ~ e s c r ~ t i o ofnthe ~etentlonBehavior In MLC, the retention factor is relatedto the concentration of monomers of surfactant in the form of micelles (i.e.,total concentration of surfactant minus cmc), through very simpleequations. Three theoretical approaches, basedon the three-phasemodel,havebeenproposed to formulate the retention of binding solutesfor liquid chromatographic systemsat various micellar concentrations:the p a ~ i t i o model ~ g of Armstrong and Nome [l], and the equilibrium approaches of ~ n y a n and a ~Cline-Love [5], and Foley [6]. Jandera andFischer 171 extended the mathematical treatment to antibinding solutes. The equationsderived are similar and allow the evaluation of the strength of solute-micelle and solute-stationa~phase interactions. Also, another pseudo-phasecan be substituted for the micelle ~ (such as a cyclodextrin or crown ether), without appreciably c ~ a n g i nthe theoretical equations.
a) ~ q ~ a t i of nArmstrong andNome Armstrong and Nome [l]extended to micellar media the classic model of ~ a ~and i Synge, n andHerries et al. [S]. The model describes the s i ~ a t i o n that a solute experiences inan ideal system formedof a numberof identical plates, where pa~itioningequilibria take place. The transitions that can occur in the three e n v i r o ~ e n t sthat exist in a micellar chromatographic system (i.e . ,the aqueous phase,the micelles andthe stationary phase) were considered (Fig. 5.1). The mass fraction of solute ineach e n v i r o ~ e nand t ,,P and ,,P . The PM,coeficient each theoreticalplate was obtained firom was not included in the model, since can it be obtained by combination of the two former (PM, = P,, /P,,). Based onthe expression givingthe maximally occupiedtheoretical plate, the following equation was obtained:
to the
-Love [5] rewrote the pseudo-phase retentio~ e~uation y used retentionfactors and bin ing constants, rather gelutionvolumes and rtition coefficients. a1 e~uilibriawere consi
ssociation of the solute i hase ind ding sites,
ssociation or binding of the solute in bulkwater with o~omerof surfactant in the rnicelle:
(iii) direct transfer of the solute from the micelle to the s t a t i o ~ phase: a~ S
+
cted inthis approach. in the expression givi
is quantity can be included in the pa~ition is referredto the asso~iationof the solute with a surfactant monomer in the micelle, and should be multiplied bythe aggregation numberto find the constant referredto the whole ~ c e l l e .
e as§umptions made in the equilibrium model proposed by not veryhfferent from thoseof the previous authors [1,5]. The associ~tion between the solute in bulk water and the micelles (eq. 5.4) is considered a secondary equilibrium, which affects the retention of the solute in the absence of micelles, given byk,.
This equationis again similar tothe equation prop (eq. 5.l). The retention factor of fiee so in eq. 5.1 and K , [S] in eq. 5.6, whereas corresponds to the same constant in eq.5.6, and to the product U in eq, 5.1 when the volume of aqueous phase is taken as total volume of mobile phase. Also, the basic pseudo-phase equation of retention (eq. 5. l) can be al~ebraicallyrearranged in at least 12 different related forms [g]. Although obtaining one form fr another is mathematically trivial, there are certain stati§tical and other antages in using di~erentvariations.
d) ~ a r ~ ~~o oe ~n c i e n t ~
The three models given by eqs. 5.1, 5.6 and 5.7 lead to similar linear equations lk vs. [ 1,a d can be rewritten as:
or
a .3 Solute-micelle, Km, and solute-stationaryphase, KM,binding constants in micellar mobilephases.
Figure 5.3 illustrates the three-phase model with indication ofthe partition constants Km and KAs. The values of Km and K A S give i n f o ~ a t i o nabout the solute affinityto micelles andto the stationary phase, respectively. One consequenceof the partitioning treatmentis that the measured values of K ICMsforacompoundusing the samemicellarmobile phase, but stationa~phases, will result different in values of KAs and KMs ,but identical values of K,,. By the same token,the measured values of a compound on a single stationary phase,but with two micellar mobile phases, will result in differentvalues of K, and identical valuesof ICAs . The constant C I s should indicatethe difEerent degreeof of surfactant. This was not however observed in a study p e r € o ~ e dwith severalsolutesand CTAB as surfactant [lo]. The highvalues of ICAs obtained with cyano-silica, and the unexpectedly low values G 18-silicaY with clearly showedthat the adsorption ofsurfactant was not the only factor to take into account. The subjacent stationary phase (the bonded moiety) probably still plays a role in the interaction of the solute between bulk water and stationary phase. In spite ofthe sufiactant coverage, the polar nature of the bondedstationary phase is maintained.
e) Jandera and Fischer Approach Equations 5.8 and 5.9 describe the retentionofsolutes that can form associates, or inclusioncomplexes,bothwithmicelles and s u r f a c ~ t adsorbed on the stationary phase. Tks is the case for neutral compounds and compounds with an opposite charge to the sufiactant. However, as indicated above, compounds having the same charge as the sufiactant will be excluded from the micelles and repelled the by modified stationa~phase, unless other interactions exist that neutralize the electrostatic repulsion. For solutesrepelled from themicelles, the retention increaseswith the concentration ofsurfactant, which supposesan apparent negative valuefor K, . Since this constant is the ratio of the eq~ilibriumconcentrations of solute between bulk water and micelles, it should be positive.
era and Fischer1’71pointed out to the severe inconsistency of the retention stated above, to describe the behavior of tib bind in^ pos~latedthat asthe repulsion forces hinder the molecules of a solute to come into close contact with the molecules of s u ~ a c ~a tpart , of thes~tionaryphase with adsorbeds u ~ a c tbecomes ~t inaccessible. This a~ m e ~that s only a action of the real volume ofs ~ t i o n pha the phase ratio in the column. The relative re~uctionin acc the amount of adsorbed s u ~ a c t ~ t
(5.10)
imilarly, a fraction of the volume of mobile phase could notp a ~ i c i ~ ain. te the interacti~nswith the solute: (5.l l) mo
where fs and fmare the fractions of stationary and mobilephases inaccessible to the solute, respectively, which depend on both solute and s u ~ a c t ~ t . ~ c c o r ~ton this ~ model, four equations were f o ~ u l a t e d correspond in^ to diflerent si~ations.The first coincides witheq. 5.8, which is valid for solutes that are not excluded from both s ~ t i o n phase a ~ and or solutes repelled by the adsorbed monomers of s u r f a c t ~ on t the s~tionaryphase, but associated with the micelles:
(5.12)
whereas for solutes repelled by both the stationary phase and micelles:
similar equation can e obtained for solutesnonexc d by the micelles = 0 in eq. to antibin~ngsolutes. It is not likely, however, the stationary phase bythe adsorbe ciated withthe surfactant in the mobile phase, or vice versa,owing to the mherently similarnature of the interaction forces between the molecules inthe two phases.
us
inally, all the equations describing the retention in f o ~ u l a t e das:
where the coefficients c. and cl will have a different S n according to the nature of the interactions in the stationary phase and micelles.
~uations5.1 5.6 and ,7 predict decreased retention concentration, if the solute pa~itionsto the micelle. ount of surfac~nt7 over a wide range ofs u r f a c t ~ concentration, t l show that below the cmc th will be little change in retentions unless re are ion interaction effects. the other hand7at very h concentration, the solute can elute near the dead increases in concentration will not lower the retention. taken near this region might deviate from theory and should *
for a he e~uationsof retention have been verified experimentally er of solutes (nonpolar7polar, neutral an
1
(anionic, cationic, nonionic and zwitterionic), and column materials (CS, C 18 and cyano). They are also valid for mobile phases containing constant a amountof organic modifier.However, it should be noted that certain assumptions have been made to formulate the equations, regarding the micellar and chromatographic system. It was assumed that:
(i) the cmc and aggregation number of micelles are not affected by the small mounts of solute being chro~atographed, (ii) binding of the surfactant to the stationary phase does not appreciably affect the retention timeof the solute or, if the retention is affected, this binding reaches a level of saturation at or before the cmc of the surfactant is reached, (iii) an increasing concentrationof micelles does not alter their aggregation numberor geometry, (iv) the stoichiometry of the solute-micelle 'lcomplex" is 1:l.
In cases where these assumptions are not valid, deviations from the expected behavior can be found. In fact, the three latter assumptions are only reasonable at a limited range of low surfactant concentration. For instance, adsorption of SDS does not occur on naked silica until 0. l M concentration is reached. Therefore,the model shouldf d with silica as the stationary phase. In fact, it was observed that the change on the silica sudace due to SDS adsorption caused a variation in the KASvalues of several nonionicand ionic solutes, so that the plots of lk vs. SDS micellar [IO]. concentration were no longer linear At high concentration, some surfactants such as CTAB, undergo "sphere to rod" transitions. Also, upward curving plots will occur with 12 stoichiometry or greater. Apparently, owing to these reasons, nonlinearity was observed in the lk vs. total SDS concentration plots for some amino acids and peptides (Fig. 5.4) [l l]. Two different lines were obtained for
IT1
YST
1
these com ounds, depending onthe examined range (0.02-0.08
0.
0.2
.SDS concentration alanyl-tyrosine (AY), han (W), eluted at pH sing two different ranges of surfactant concentration: Solid lines, 0.02-0.08 M SDS; dashed lines, 0.1-0.2 M SDS.Reprinted from Ref. 11 with permission of Elsevier.
Finally, deviations fromthe model are observed for highly and low retained solutes. In the former case, irreversible adsorption of the solute on the stationary phase may occur, whereas in the latter, the elution of the solute willalways take place in the dead volume. The high errors obtained for hydrophobic compounds mayarise, at least partially, from using large
concentrations of surfactantwhch are needed to elute these CO ase column, in a reasonabletime.
.
a) ~ n ~ ~ n c eof~ ti e nti ton ~
t ~ e n ~ t ~
ne of the most serious problems of pure micellar eluents is their we elution s t r e n ~ h often , lower than the elution stre of methanol-water obile phases. Shorter retention times can be achieved by using higher s~rfactantconcentrations andshorter chain-len~hbonded stationa~phases. The elution strength can also be increased by the a ~ ~ i t i oofnan o solvent. The term hybrid was proposedfor t e ~ eluents a ~ of water-o solvent-micelles, and will be used here[121. of l - p r o p ~ oto l mi cell^ mobile addition of small per ey et al. [U],to enhance the first r e c o ~ e n ~ e d chromatographic ef~ciencyand decrease the a s ~ eof t ~ e then, several organic solvents have been stu
micellar medium,it increases to ca. study was made onthe effect of different organic additives (i.e., diols, alkanes, alkylnitriles, and di~olara rotic s o ~ v e ~ t s such as dimethyl sulfoxide and dioxane) upon the elution st
hexadecyltrimeth~la~onium chloride ( phases, for two neutral test solutes, benzene and 2-eth~lanthra~u~oney retained on aC 18 stationary phase [171. The test solutes were chosen due to the fact thatbenzene is relatively water soluble and 2-ethylanthra~u~one is virtually waterinsoluble. Thus, they represent two extremesin hydrophobicity. The results indicated that the presence of alcohols, diols, alkylnitriles?and dipolar aprotic solvents, in the micellar mobile phases, resulted ina diminution ofthe retention factors for the two test solutes. contrasty the presenceof the alkane additives (i.e.,pentane, hexane, cyclohexane) did notgreatly alter the retention. 0.25
0.20
I/ k 0.15
0.10
0.05 0.07
0.08
0.09
0.10
Ef5ect of the hydrophobici~of alcohols obilephases containing 3% l-propanol
1.
0.11
0.12
0.13
the retention of arniloride, eluted
an
LV
The use of alcohols as additives in MLC can result in dramatic reductions in the elution times of solutes, compared to those observed with pure aqueous micellar mobilephases. The retention factors decrease as the carbon number (hydrophobicity) ofthe alcohol is increased(Fig. 5.5),and the reduction is more pronounced for micellar solutions containinggreater mounts of the additive (Fig. 5.6). The organic modifier effects uponthe retention howeverare attenuated as the surfactant concentration is increased. n the other hand, the eEects are greater for more hydrophobic solutes. Thus, thereductioninretention factors observeduponthe addition of organic modifiers to micellar mobile phases depends, not only upon the identityandconcentrationof the organicmodifier, but also uponthe concentrationof surfactant andthe hydropho~icity of the test solute. mounts oforganicmodifier can greatly affect solute LC. This is particularly importantwhenattempting to separate very hydrophobic components. 0.3
EfXect ofthe concentration ofalcohol on the retention of: (a)naphthalene, and (b) 2,3-benzofluorene, inSDS mobile phases modified with l-butanol. Reprinted from Ref. 20 with permission of Elsevier.
MlC
"le elution strength of the alcohol is usually greater than that of the surfactant. However, for positively charged solutes such as catecholamines in acidic medium, anionicsu~actantscan originatean important reduction in the retention due to the hgh aE1nity of the solutestowards the negatively charged micelles [2 l ~. b) ~ i s ~ ~ ~ cof~ art r niteionn in^ ~~ ~ u i ~ i b r i ~
The relative effectiveness of an organic modifier,in. LC appears to be directly relatedto its own ability to partition and bind to the micellar pseudophase. That is, the bettertheorganicmodifier binds to the micellar assembly, the greater its ability to alter the retention ofsolutes. Eq. 5.9 is also valid for hybrid micellar eluents (Fig. 5.5). For these eluents, solute binding c o n s t ~ t to s micelles and the partitioning intothe stationary phase both decreaseas a result of the addition of the modifier, especially hghly for hydrophobic solutes. However, the Km/KMratio increases and, therefore, the elution power of the mobile phase isgreater. The addition of alcohols to micellar mobile phasescauses changes in certain micellar properties, suchas the aggregation number andthe cmc are of thes u r f a c ~.tThe observed reductions in retention in hybrid systems however too large to berationalized in termsof these changes. The reductions should be explained by the modification micro-enviro~ent of the of the micelles and the stationary phase.
MLC retention may be due to the The organic additive effects upon. modification of the micelle produced by the introduction of molecules of modifier in its palissade, and to the change in thenature of the surfactantmodified stationary phase. The addition of organic modifieralso increases the aE1nity of the solute forthe bulk aqueous solvent in the mobile phase, which becomes more nonpolar. This significantly alters the equilibrium of the solute away from the micelle and stationary phase towards the bulk aqueous phase which becomes more nonpolar.
The concentration of organic solvent added to the micellar mobile phase should not be very high, since this might reduce the role of micelles and
bring the system closer to an ~ueous-organicsystem. Large concentrations of modifier can totally disrupt the micelle structure, as the h~drophobic effect, the maindriving force for micelle formation, is reduced. The maximum allowable concentration depends on the type of modifier and surfactant, and is usually not known. As a rule of thumb, the voluie percentage of organic solventshouldbe kept below15-20%. separations reported in the literature were carried out with hybrid mobile phases containing too large amounts of modifier, the role and integrity of micelles were thus not entirely clear 122-241. en hybrid micellar eluents were first used, they were severely criticized. It has been argued that when organic mo fiers are used, this type of chromatography loses some of its appeal 1251. owever, most reported procedures in MLC, since 1985, utilized these eluents. The experience acquired in our laboratories on the development ofanalytical procedures for the deter~nationof different drugs (e.g., P-blockers, diuretics, narcotics, steroids, stimulants and sulfonamides)has shown that, in most instances, the retention ofsolutes with pure micellar eluents is excessive, which forces one to add a modifierto achieve adequate retention times. It may seem logicalto assume that the separation mechanism with aqueous surfactant-organic solvent mobile phase is similar to that with conventional aqueous-organic solvent, rather to pure aqueous surfactant mobile phase, since the effect of adding an organic solvent is to sacrifice the role and effectiveness of micelles. However, as long as the integrity of micelles ismaintained, addition of modi~er a to a micellar mobile phase will not create an aqueous-organic system, even though in hybrid systems the interactions between solutes and micelles are reduced, and the s t a t i o n a ~ phase is more similar to that of a conventional aqueous-org~icsystem. In effect, organic solvents modifythe structure and CO ase, as they solvate the hydrocar~onaceousbonded phase. [26] studied the adsorption isothermsof different organic phases and showedthat over 90% of the C 18 phase was covered with l -propanol at a concentration of 3% (w/v). "herefore, with a micellar mobilephase that includes a small concentrationof organic solvent, the s t a t i o n a ~phase resembles a solvated phase in an aqueous-organic system, rather than in a pure aqueous micellar mobilephase.
The c~omatographic ehavior of alkyl homologousseries is useful for the investigation of retention. h aqueous-organic systems, th of a homologous series is related to the number of carbon atoms, for each solute inthe series, through the following relations hi^ [L271:
(5.15)
where n, is the number of carbon atoms in the homolog., a nonspeci~cselectivity of a me~ylenegroup, and p is the contri retention from the hnctional group c o ~ o to n the series. increase in retention due to the addition of a methylene group as a measure of hydrophobic interaction ina given In contrast to this behavior, severalauthors have notedthat a linear relationship between k and n, seems to exist in LC, when either a pure aqueous micellar or a phase used is [28, 291. hasobserved rij@ been 35 as micelle-for 8 s t a t i o n a ~phases, and n-alkylben surfactants with 2-al~ylant~aquinones and ~-alkylphenones ashomologous series. been suggestedthat a different retention mechanismex series inan aqueous surfactant-organic solvent mobile an aqueous-organicsolventsystem,and that ure hybrid micellar mobile phasesare similar. d from the linear k vs. n, relationship, i of solutes of the homologous series will be e isocratic mode, com~aredto that of conventiona . This behavioris hrther c o ~ e n t ine ~
Fritz [30] studied t e t r ~ h e p t y l a ~ o ~bromide um
effect of some surfactants [i.e.., S, ~octylsulfosuccinate,
rij@ 30), polyoxyethylene(~0)sorbitan ethylene-polyox~ropylenecopolymer 1,2-decanedioll, d inconventional nitrile-water and methanol-water mobile phases with C18 columns. er the workingconditions,the f o ~ a t i o nofmicelleswasunlikely. S even in pure water because it has a wever, the presenceof su~actants as additives in aqueous-organic mixtures greatly improved the separation of several groups of compounds: alkylben~enes, polycyclic aromatic alkylphenols, and some otheraromatic compounds. ns obtained without thes u r f a c ~ t sshorter , retention times and sharper peaks were obtained. The retention times of late-eluting S were reduced by a larger percentage than the retention of earlier S effect is similar to that obtained with gradient elution but in h s case isocratic elutionwith an aqueous-organiceluent,containing an rfactant, was used. raphy can be considered a bridge between C, because surfactants were used at concentrations above their cmc in aqueous solution, but without micelle e observed additive effect couldarise in two ways. First, the surfactant molecules might be adsorbed on the s u ~ a c eof the stationary e, with the long alkyl orpolyox~ro~ylene chains interacting withthe chains and the hydrophilic head groups sticking out. This would give more hydrophilic surface and thus reduce the retention times of solutes. econd, hydro~hobicinteractions might be established betweenthe solute molecules and the longalkylorpolyoxypylenechainsof the discrete surfactant molecules,in the mobile phase. drogenbonding rolewhenbothsoluteand surfactant containpotentialhyd @ 30 o ation centers,as in al~ylphenolseparations with Brij Inthe exper~entalconditionsofthese separations, no adsorption of molecules could occur on the surface of thestationary phase, the second mechanism wasthus probably correct. Increasingconcentrationsof s u ~ a c in ~ the t aqueous-organic solvent eluents resulted in progressively lower retention factors. stingly, eq. 5.9 was followed for these mobilephases, however, instead concentration of micelles, the concentration oftotal sur
used. The treatment assumeda 1:1 association between solute ands u ~ a c ~ t , and consequently, the linear range was limited to rather low concentrations of surfactant. On the other hand, a linear relationship was found between log k of alkylbenzenes and a~ylphenols,and the carbon number of the series,for all surfactants studied. Ths relationship suggests that the retention mechanism ofthe systems agreed withthat found in conventional aqueous-organicLC,rather than in MLC.
JK 1. A ~ v a n t a o~fethe ~ MLC Approach There is a significant amount of experimental support for the three-phase model in MLC. First, plots of retentiondata fit the theoretical e~pressions (see Section 11.3), for a variety of solutes whch bind to micelles. ~econd, the experimental values ofKm and KAsare independent of the s ~ t i o n a ~ phaseandmicellarsystem,respectively. F u ~ e ~ o rmicellar e, binding constants evaluated byMLC are in good agreement with those obtained by otherindependentmethods (e.g., spectroscopic, potentiometric, kinetics, solubility, etc.) [S ,11,3l]. As an example, Table 5.1 shows the c~culated ,,P and PM, and related binding constants, for several partition coefEicients phenols, quinols and catechols, obtained from chromatographc elution with SDS, compared to previous data. The agreementis satisfacto~for phenols where spectrophotometric methods were used. Slight differences, however, are observed between the chromatographic and kinetic data for quinols and cons~ts catechols. Appenbx I11 lists the partition coefficients and binding that we found preparingthis book. According to eq. 5.9, a linearized plot of I l k vs. [M] yields a slope
KAhn/KAs (units M” or L/g) and a dimensionless intercept1KM. Thus, the
binding constantKm (M-’ or L/g) can be calculatedas the ratio of the slope to the intercept, and KA, coincides with the reciprocal of the intercept. eme em be ring that Km = U ( Pm 1 ), thecalculation of the
-
Partition CoefXicients (Pwsand Pw) and Binding Constants (Km) for Several Compounds Eluted with Sodium Dodecyl Sulfate Mobile Phases on a C 18 Column [31] compared to non-chromatographic methods.
Compound Phenol or Benzene- l-ol 4-~ethylbenzenel-ol 4"~thylbenzene-1-01 4-~-Propylbenzene-1-01 4 - ~ - ~ u ~ l b e n z e1-01 ne3,5-~i~ethylbenzen~-l-ol 2,4,5-Trimethylben~ene-l-ol
28.6 75.8 174.2 389.0 69.4 179.2
2,3,5,6-Tetr~ethylbenzene-l-01
(460) 6.3 17.6
Catechol or Benzene- 1,2-diol 4-~ethylbenzene-l,2-diol 4-~yanobenzene-l,2-diol 3-~-Propylbenzene-1,2-diol 4-~-Bu~lbenzene-l,2-diol Hydroquinone or Benzene-1,$-diol
2-~ethylbenzene-l,4-diol 2-Chlorobenzene-l,4-diol 2-Phenylbenzene-l ,&diol 2 - ~ - B ~ ~ l b e n z e1n,&diol e2,3,5-Trimethylbenzene- 1,4 -diol
a
9.7
5.6 75.2 156.2
1.7 3.0 4.7 32.4 50.2 9.4
40.2 95.0 245.0 450.0 995.0 229.6 513.6 (1 150) 27.4 72.4 28. l 225.0 43 1.0 14.5 21.1 34.0 202.0 244.4 53.8
10.2 24.4 63.5 116.7 258.4 59.5 133.3 (300) 6.9 18.6 7.1 58.3 111.8 3.5 5.2 8.6 52.2 63.3 13.7
8"
9.9" 24" 65" 140" 280" 64" 125" 200" 4b lob 5b 37b
75b 3b 6b
7b 85b 65b 12b
Spectrophoto~etricmethods; Kinetic methods, in parenthesis, extrapolated values.
ensionless water-micelle partitioncoe~lcientis trivial if the correct unit views have been published on the evaluation of these C [6, 321. ~ n f o ~ n a t e l the y , d i ~ e ~ s i oproblem n was
Km Binding Constants in Llrnol for Diverse Neutral Solutes in SDS and CTAB Micellar Systems.
Co~poun~ E21
PI
References
E101
E111 1291 E311
P 3 1 1341 E351 1361 E371
mobile phases 5325 Anthracene Benzene 25.8 18.9 23.520.319.217.1 cohol Benzyl 11.8 8.8 10.4 Na~hthalene 23 242 217 5 245 353 290 Nitrobenzene 22. l 23.2 23.1 9.4 Phenol 10.2 9.6 9.5 Pyrene 8065 Toluene 52.9 50.0 63.3 54.2 59.3 52.4 56.5
5440
Compound
25.9
10.5
76.1 44.8
References ~71
Benzene 47.2 40.2 27.2 ~enzonitrile 19.4 17.5 ohol Benzyl 12.8 104 Chlorobenzene 548 54.7 ~itrobenzene 36.9 27.0 38.5 Phenol 79.5 Toluene
[l01
35.9
l291 ~361 ~331
l381
23.7 17.3
13.5 157
71.4
83.3 204 142 129 142
Although bindingcon~ants(Krn) are usually reported,it should be noted that the figure depends on the units of the partial specific volume of monomers of surfactant in the micelle (Llmol or Llg). It may be more convenient, therefore,to indicate water-micelle partitioncoe~lcients(
A nonexhaustive literature compilation of these coefficients, as measured by LC, is given in AppendixIII. The binding constants are listed addressing e unit problem. In some cases, the partition coefficients were calculated in the referencedarticles. It can be observed from the binding constants given that chemically bonded reversed-phase columns were generally employed, with octadecylsilica and octylsilica stationary phases mostly used. Sometimes cyano, C l and silica columns werealso used. Binding constants SDS and C T D micellar systems. Nonionic have been calculated mainly for and zwitterionicsurfactants have also been studied, although only to a small extent. Most work was done using pure and unbuffered micellar mobile phases at room temperature. Whena modifier was introduced inthe mobile phase, it consisted of a short or medium chain alcohol, such as methanol, ethanol, propanol or butanol, or a salt such as sodium chloride at low concentration, When pH was fixed, a phosphate buffer wasusually used. ome solute-micelle binding constants for aromatic compounds with CTAB, obtained by differentauthors under identical experimental conditions, are included in Table 5.2. Only the chromatographic column could change (octadecylsilica and octylsilica). Good agreement exists when different Km values are available, especially in thecase of S even for veryhydrophobiccompoundsfor whch the error inthese dete~inationsis usually high. The evaluation of solute-micelle binding constants has important implications outside thefield ofchromatography, suchas micellar catalysis, tertiary oil recovery, and enzyme and membrane modeling. powerhi technique for thedete~inationof these constants, in comparison to classical methods. The use of MLC inthis field has several advantages:
(i)theevaluation can bemadefor allthe compounds experiencing a c~omatographicretention inthe system that varies when the concentration of surfactant in the mobile the compounds phase is changed. %S is quite common and do not need to experience a change in their spectroscopic characteristics in micellar media, as when spectroscopic methods are used,
(ii) simultaneous determination of the constants of several solutes is possible, as the retention timesof a mixture of the solutes can be measured from a single injection. (iii) solute concentrationneed not be know, and (iv) impurities, present ifsample, the in are chromatograp~callyseparated and will not interfere.
Moreover,bindingconstants can beobtainedfromindependent sources to predict retention factors. This is usehl to facilitate systematic optimization. h example of this type of prediction has been given for perylene which showeda high retention and the interceptof the Ilk vs. [ plot was essentially zero with aG 18 colum and SDS in the mobile phase [S]. The retention factor at a given micelle concentration and a reported value ofthe binding constant were taken to estimate the value of the intercept in eq. 5 -9, and tohrther predict the retention at varyingmicelle concentration. The agreement between experimental and predicted values was excellent.
It? 2. S o ~ ~onsi~erations e on
art it ion in^ ~ a ~ c ~ ~ a t i o n
a) Critical ~ i c e l l eConcen~ration For any aqueous surfactant solution, there is a relatively small range of concentrations below which virtually all surfactant is present as monomers, and above which virtually all additional surfactant is present in micellar form. This micelli~ationphenomenon causes significantchangesin the bulk physical propertiesofthe solution. The cmc an is important parameter which deserves careful attentioninorder to minimize uncertainties in measurement.
The cmc values for the most widely used surfactants in MLC are wellknow(e.g., 8,1~lO-~MforSDS, 1,3~lO-~MforGT~,and 1.0 rij@ 35) [39]. However, in a hybrid micellar mobile phase where an organic solvent is present, the cmcvalueschange and are often not
referenced. Therefore, they should be evaluatedprior to the calculation of binding constants.
ifferent modifiers show different behavior. A pro~ressivedecrease in the cmc has been observedin S~~ solutions, with respect to the absence of modifier, for all alcohols, methanol excepted [40]. The reduction in the cmc is larger when the length of the alcohol chain is increased, and occurs even for small amountsof alcohol. At moderateconcentrations of propanol, butanol and pentanol,the concentration of micelles almost coincides withthe total concentration of surfactant. Similarly to methanol, the cmc increases with the concentration of organic solvent for acetonitrile and t e t r ~ ~ d r o ~ r ~
l401.
I
7
-iD
-5.0
4.0 "3.0
Loll [w-351
-2.0
Log k vs. log
(0)aniliniumchloridein(a) only, and (Q) sodium benzoate in (b) only. Reprinted from Ref. 41 with permission of Elsevier.
e determination of cmc values is made by the measurement of some property of the solution, as a h c t i o n of surfactant concentration. the extrapolated segments o cmc is taken as the point of intersection of easured propertyat concentrations ofsurfactant below and above the cmc. ne of the properties that has been used to measure cmc values is the retention in a micellar mobile phase of a neutral solute strongly with micelles[4 l]. Figure 5.7 shows plots oflog k surfactant concentrationforacetophenone, a n i l i ~ u mchl nitrobenzene, phenol and sodium benzoate, and the three su and BrijB 35. Thesolutions also contained 3% l -propanol to e the efficiency of the chromatographicpeaks. The d r ~ a t i change c in retention as micellization occured is quite obvious.The values of cmc for the three surfactants were calculated from these plotsand the results were compared to conductimetric measurements. A relatively good agreementof the chro~atographicand literature values(chromatographicmethod: 4 . 7 lo3, ~ 3 . 6 10” ~ and 3.43 10-nductimetricmethod: 7.3 x l Om3, 1 . 3 ~ 1 0and - ~ L O X ~ OM, - ~for S and BrijB 35, respectively) was evidence that it is truly solubilization of the solutes by the micelles that causes elution, at relatively high concentration ofsurfactant. b) ~ o l u of ~ ~et a t i o ~ aPhase ry
or convenience, the partition coefficients ,,P and ,,P are U considering the entire volume of the silica support particles. in mind, however,that only the surface bonded layer isa the pa~itioningequilibria. The calculation of ,P from eq. 5.1 requires ,, which cannot be determined easily. Usually, the difference knowledge of V between the empty column volume and the packed column void volume is taken as Vs ,which gives an overestimation ofthis volume since it includes the entire volume occupied by the silica solidsupport particles, rather than just the true stationary phase. Although theuse of such a value will result in accurate values for ,,P ,the values obtained for,,P and expected to be significantlyin error, withunderestimated partition coefficients. An approach that completely excludes any volume associated with the base silica material should thus be used.
1
orgerdinget al. E291 developed an accurate procedure for d ~ e the c~~ o mg a t o g r a pphase ~ c ratio.In thw procedure, measurementof the total weight of the paclung material in the colurnn, and ofthe cumulative pore volumes of unbonded silica support and bonded C 18 packing materials, before andafter exposure to the m i c e l l e - f o ~ gsurfactant, is made. In this way, any volume associated with the base silica material is completely excluded, sincethe stationary phase volumeis assumed to be that portion of the silica pore volume filled upon bonding the odadecylsilane (or other alkyl ligand) chainsand, in the presence of micelles, by sorption of the surfactant to the C 18 chains.
c) ~ r r o r in s the Slopeand~nterceptof the ~ q ~ a t i of o n~ e t e n ~ o n The evaluation of and Km is usually made from linear regression of the experimental data of retention factors and micelle concentration, accordmg to eq. 5.9 (remember KAs= 4,Kws). It is evident that K,, will be affected by a larger error than KAs. Considering that: K,,, = NB
(5.16)
where A and B are the slope and interceptof the straight-line, the error will be givenby:
AKm = (B AA + A AB)/
(5.17)
being the errors in the slope and intercept, respectively. It should be noted that the error in K,, is not only affected by the errors in the slope and intercept, but also by their values. The intercept ofthe straight-line decreases(KM increases) withthe hy~rophobicityof the compound. High unce~aintiesin KM and even higher in K,, ,will result for compounds showing very low intercepts (close to zero).These are compoundswith an importanthydrophobic character,
IT1
experiencing a high retention in the MLC system (e.g.,anthracene pyrene). The high unce~intiesin the retention factors of hy compounds often yield negativeintercepts, that is, negative values for and K&. It has been shown that the application of weights to the linear fitting (eq. 5.9) of (l k , [M] )experimental data, or the use of nonlinear regression (eq. 5.8) improves greatly the accuracy of the binding cons [42]. With these data treatments, achievement of negative interce frequent. The statistical treatment of lk vs. [ plots indicates that the error a compound having either in the slope tends to increase when working very small or very large binding constants. There are, therefore, ce limits to the applicability of the procedure with a given stationary ph~se. Consider, for example, the retention of naphthalene with a C 1 phase column [l]. Because of naphthalene's great affinity for the s t a t i o n a ~ phase andlow affmity for water, an appreciable concentration of micelles in the mobile phase was needed to achieve elution in time. In fact, it was difficult to obtain a su~lcientamount enough surfactant concentration to calculate an accurate @usstatiomry phase. In constant for n a p h ~ e n eusing , did not interact as strongly with a cyano stationary sufficient data could be collected to calculate the bindi the slope of the lk vs. [ ] plot was large and the intercept close to zero, thus, small changes in the slope ofthe line resulted in relatively large changes in the intercept. n the other hand, the interaction of hydroquinone with a ionary phase was very low. This lack of interaction was even more pronounced with the cyano column [l]. Consequently, the retention times of hydroquinone with a cyano c o l m were not sufficiently di~erentor consistent inthe presence or absence of micellesin the mobilephase. particular case, it was difficult to collect adequate data for proper tre Limitations such as those described for naphthalene (with the column) and hydroqu~one(with the cyano column) would be moreserious if one were limited to a singlestationary phase. Fortunately, several ~fferent polarity bonded stationary phases are available. As a result, a very wide variety of compounds can be chromatographed using micellar mobile phases
and treated accordingly.It has been proposedthat a stationary phase should be changed for a more polar oneto decrease the errors in the evaluation of S for hydrophobiccompounds(the order of increasing polarityisthefollowing: C 18 C8 C 1cyano silica). This should decrease the partition coefficients betweenthe aqueous phase andstationary phase, and increase the intercept of the straight-line.It was however checked that the reduction in the errors was minor when a C8 column was used instead of aC 18 column[321. The advantage of usinga more polar colurnn the compounds out ofthe c o l u or ~ reducing is still the possibility of eluting their retentiontimes. If the solubility of a hydrophobic compoundthe inaqueous phaseis increased by the addition of an organic modifier, such as an alcohol, the dis~lac~ment of the equilibria towards the aqueous phase will enable the calculation of the binding constants. Ineffect, the additionofalcohol AS and KM ,and the associated errors. Figure 5.6 shows the increase in the intercept of the straight-line of Ilk:vs. [M] for hydrophobic solutes, when l-butanol at different concentrations is added to an aqueous micellar solution. The Km binding constants of several benzene derivatives andP eluted with hybrid §I)§ micellar mobile phases, are given in Table 5.3 for di~erentalcohols at varying concentration. The decrease in KbMdue to the addition, of alcohol to the mobile phase was higher for the most hydrophobic co~pounds.It was also more important with increasing length (decreasing polarity) of the alcohol chain, Finally, Km decreased withthe percentage of alcohol in the mobile phase. It is interesting to note that it was possible to calculate the constants for all compounds in the presenceof butanol. This is in contrast to the results obtained when no additive was utilized the in mobile phase. an alcohol usually decreasedKm ,regardless of the romatic compounds, this has been checkedfor §D§ wever, in the presence of cationicCTAB micelles, the binding constants were higher than in the presence of anionicSI)§. Th~s can be explained by the favorable electrostatic interactions between the positively charged CTAB head groups and the unlocated charge of the
aromatic ring of the solutes. In fact, the difference in Km values with ,relative to SDS, was greater for naphthalene derivatives.
. The approximately zero intercepts obtained for hydrophobic compounds, such as the bgher molecular weight homologues, merelyreflect their large aEmity for the micelles ands u r f a c ~ t ~ o a t stationary ed phase, c~mparedto bulk aqueous component in the mobile phase. Solubility data inhcate that these compounds are virtually insoluble inwater. This ~ n d i n gimplies that as the amount of such hydrophobic solutes in the aqueous phase is almost negligible, they can only be transported between the micelles in the mobile phase and the surfactant-modi~edstationary phase by a direct transfer process, and no partitioning will take place between aqueous phase and micelles, or between aqueousphase and stationary phase. Therefore, only a single equilibrium willexist, which is described by P,, (Fig. 5,8) [29]. Although mentioned in theories of pseudo-phase c~omato~raphy, the possibility of a direct transfer of an insoluble or a sparingly water-soluble solute, from the micellein the mobile phase to the su~actant-coated stationary phase, was largely ignored. For this situation, a m o d i ~ form e ~ of quation of Armstrong and Nome (eq. 5.l) was derived [29], which successfullyaccounts for the dependence between and k [M], observed inthe elution of such hydrophobic solutes:
The drawback of the solubility limit theory is the dif~cultyin defining an exact limit for this behavior. Also, if the intercept in eq. 5.9 is to zero, the binding constants Km and very small, although not equal PS, values can be be calculated, but the errors will be very high. Only evaluated for very hydrophobic solutes. It was checked that this pa~ition
coe~cient,determined at any given micellar mobile phase composition fiom for othermobilephase eq. 5.18, is useful to predictsoluteretention concentrations with little error, over the entire alkylbenzene homologous series range [29].
Representationofthe direct transfer process for distributionofa solute between the micellar pseudo-phase and the surfactant-modi~edC 18 stationary phase. Reprinted from Ref 29 with permission of the American Chemical Society.
It can be observed, inFig. 5.6, that at low alcohol concentrationthe retention m e c ~ s m is a directtransfer between the micelles andthe modi~ed stationa~phase, andat the highest alcoholconcentratior~s,perhaps owing to an e~ancementin the solubility, the dissolved portion of solutes in bulk solvent interacts with both micelles and stationa~phase.
. VL 1. ~ ~ a nin~Acid-Base e s ~ e ~ ~ viniM o ir c e ~ ~ ~ r M e d i ~ The retention of weak organicacids and bases is affectedby the pH of the micellar mobile phase. Solute-micelle binding constants of the dissociated or cationic micellesare and undissociated forms of a compound with anionic
different.Smallchangesinp can thus significant1 alter the chromatographic retention, particularlywhen the mobile phase is close to the value of the roto on at ion constant (log KH ). Therefore, fo c o m ~ o u n ~the s, must be specified retention data are values in micella a is c ~ c i a for l a o etention mechanisms des and in better understanding optimi~ationstrategies in The influenceof micelles on the acid-base properties of a n ~ ~can e s be significant andis reflected in changes in logI C H . A good example is the acid-base behavior of amino acids and peptides, which present the f o l l o w ~ g equilibria [44, 451:
espite large structural diEerences among amino acids and peptides, their log KH values in bulk aqueous solution are very similar. In micellar media, the eEect of chemical s t ~ c ~on r elog K, is much more ~ r o n o u n c e ~ of solute-mi (Table 5.4),which is indicative of the profound influence interactionsontheacid-base behavior of thesecompounds [44J apparent protonation constant in micellar media is expressed as:
are thebindingconstants where Km andKm undissociated species, respectively.
of the dissociatedand
As shown inTable 5.4, both carboxylateand amine groups of amino
acids andpeptides are weakeracidsin §D§micelles. The contributo~ factors to the positive log K, shiftin an SDS system are, first, the electrostatic repulsion between the carboxylate group and S
1 Tab! protonation Constants of Several Amino Acids and Peptides Measured Potentio~etrica~~y in Aqueous and Micellar Solutions[44].
omp pound
Ionization Step
Glycine Aspartic acid
Glycyl-~lyc~e Benzoic acid Lysine
Lysylphenylal~e
1 2 1 2 3 1 2 l 1 2 3 l 2 l 2 3 1 2 1 2
0.1 M
0.1 M
log Kma l o g k b Alog Kc log kbAlog Kc 9.74 9.72 -0.03 2.34 2.57 +0.23 9.80 9.76 -0.04 3.45 3.68 +0.23 2.04 2.39 t-0.35 8.08 8.22 +O.14 2.89 3.34 +0.45 4.15 4.76 +O .47 3.18 -0.97 10.56 10.55 -0.0 1 9.32 +0.46 9.78 +l S9 3.88 2.29 +o.02 8.71 -0.54 9.23 9.25 0.00 + l .86 2.21 2.21 4.07 10.45 10.26 -0.19 +0.68 8.03 7.35 +2.18 4 '94 2.76 -1 -03 8.18 +OS7 9.2 1 9.68 -0.21 2.11 +2.27 4.59 2.32 d d 8 -06 4.73
I&,,,,=Protonation constants in nonrnicellar solutioncontaining 0.1 M NaCI; &,= Protonation constants in micellar solution containing 0.1 M NaCl; c Shift of protonation constant, The solubility wastoo low tobe measured potent~ometrically.
a
second, the hydrophobicand electrostatic attraction of the alkyl and protonated amine groups to the SDS micelles; andthird, the localization of protonated weakacid, 'HA-, in an e n v i r o ~ e nwith t lowerdielectricconstant. In addition, the molecular size(andor aqueous solubility) of the compounds also seem to play a role in in~uencingbinding constants, and consequently, e log KH the mag~tudeof the log KH shift. As expected,the m a ~ ~ ofdthe shift is larger for compounds experiencing greater interactions with S micelles (2.e.,log KH = 1.6-2.3 for amino acids andpeptideswith hydrophobic and basic groups, as compared with log KH = 0.2-0.5 for the more polar compounds). In cationic CTAB solution,the shft sign of logKHis opposite of that in SDS solutions [44].The compounds are stronger acids in GT media than in aqueous solutions. This is probably due to the strong electrostatic attraction of the negative chargeon the conjugate bases, to the cationic head groups of CTAB micelles. Incontrast to SDS, the shift in log KH1 is larger than in log Km . The large log KHshift of benzoic acid in CTAB solution.ascompared to the shifts observed for amino acids, and to the same compoundin SDS solution, can be attributed to the strong electrostatic attraction and hydrophobicinteractionsof the conjugate base of benzoic acid, and perhaps more importantly, to the lack ofelectrostatic repulsion whch is evident for the other solutes. Apparent protonation constants were evaluatedfor several solutes in SDS micellar solutions, from MLC retention factors at varying concentration of micelles and 1 -propanol [46). It was observedthat themodifier decreased micelle the values of log ICKapp, whereas these wereincreasedwith concentration. The shifts inlog ICKapp upon variation ofmodifier concentration are causedbyboth the modification of the t h e ~ o d ~ a m i c constants in the aqueous-organic solvent, andthe displacement ofacid-base equilibria due to the modification of the interaction of the solute with the micelles, inthe presence of modifier.
major constraint of silica bonded phases is the limi range of between o yretainedstrong acids and bases, whose protonation constants are either outsideor close to the boundariesof this range. In suchcases, ~troductionof electrostatic to theeluent of a small amountof interactionsthroughtheaddition surfactant, with a charge opposite that of the solute, provides ade~uate retention. Thus, the use of micella DS mobile phases shifts the apparent protonation constants of solutes to milder p conditions, and benefits the observation of the maximal limiting retenti within the operable limits of silica-based columns. Also, the wider distribution of protonation constants of compoundsinmicellarmediagivesa greater selectivity to the chromatographic separations. .S and 7.5, This istroublesomeintheseparation
of the micellar mobile phase is usually buffered using the ric acid-base systems. Potassium ion cannot be used with ,as ~otassium dodecyl sulfate precipitates from aqueous solutions due to its high Kram point (see Chapter 2). columnshouldbeequilibrated themobilephaseuntilbeforeand after the c o l u is ~ onepeakisobservedi a t o g r ~ of s weakacidsand bases because prototropic equilibriaare much faster than the solute-micel~e or solut~-stationa~ phase d ~ a m i c s . *
Cyano-bondedand Cl8 columns interact verydifferentlywith surfactant monomers, resulting in a different elution behavior of organic acids and bases,as a function of micelle concentration and pH in the mobile yano paclungs do not appear to adsorb S S monomers and generally have the capability of retaining various species. ionic C 18 c o l u ~ s are modified by adsorption SDS of monomers, withthe negative headgroups in contact with the mobile phase, such that the surface is charged and will repulse anionic species. Some examples of retention behavior for weak organic acids and bases are shown below.
7
9 Change in chromatographic retention with pH lurnn, at various SDS molar concentrations: (0)0.02, 0.10. Reprinted from Ref. 47 with permission of the American Chemical Society.
a) Cyano C o ~ u ~ n s
For somesolutes, the pH of micellar solutions is ~ofn d ~ e n timpo~ance al in determining the sign of the slopes in the l/k vs. [M]plots (positive, negative or zero). Forbenzoic acid at pH 4.5, the retention factors decrease withincreasing SDS concentration, because ofhydrophobic interaction of the neutral acidic specieswith the SDS micelles, but at pH > 4.5, the retention factors increase owing to electrostatic repulsion between the negative charges of the basic species and micelles (Fig. 5.9) [47]. Hence, completely opposite behavioris observed depending onpH. In the intermediate range of pHvalues, there is an isoeluting point where k is completely independent ofSDS con cent ratio^. This is the p
whch the two species, acid and base in equilibrium witheach other, have the same retention. This is analogousto the isosbestic point in spectroscopy and would be expected to give the protonation constant in the micellar medium (for benzoic acid, log KHis 4.2 in water, and 4.7 in SDS micellar solution, as obtained from the isoeluting point). It has been c o ~ e n t e dbefore, in Section 11.2, that if solute retention is constant with increasing micelle that the solute-micelle binding concentration,h s does not necessarily mean constant is zero. Theisoelutingpoint (50% ionization point) clearly emo on st rates that thelack of change ink, with micelle concentration in the mobile phase, is the result of the balancing or opposing hydrophobic and electrostatic effects caused by the change inthe form of the species. n the other hand, inspection of the retention factors for weak bases using cyano columns andSDS eluents showsthat the largest k values occur in more basic solution, where the neutral free-base form is present, and the smallest in acidic solution where the protonated, positively charged form exists, which has favorable electrostatic attraction to the negatively charged micelles (Fig. 5.10) E471
10 Change in chromatographic r various SDS molar concentrations: Reprinted fromRef. 47 with permissionof the American Chemical Society
b) C18 C o l u ~ n s The effect of pH on the retention factors of solutes, eluted with an anionic surfactant, is very similar on C l 8 columns to that obtained using cyano columns, when hydrophobic interactions dominate. However, less hydroCl8 phobicandnegativelycharged solutes willeluteveryquicklyon columns, because of repulsion from both micelles and negatively charged modified stationary phase, Fig. 5.l 1 shows plots of k vs. pH with the typical
1s C"
6
3
4
=
3
4
5
0
a
Q
pw
7
d
n
7
Modification ofthe retentionwith pH in a C 18 column for: (V) benzocaine?(U) ) furosemide, (A) tyrosine, and (A) sulfanilamide?for 0.05M SDS-8% (v/v)l-propanol (a,b), and0.15M SDS without alcohol (c,d) mobile phases. Reprinted from Ref. 46 with permission of Elsevier.
.11
behavior found when weak acids are eluted fromC 18 columns. of the retention factors with pH is shown for mobile phases of conta~ing8% (v/v) l-propanol and without&us modfier. Inspection of the curves revealsthat the largest k values are achieved in acidic solutions, where the neutral or cationic forms of the solutesare present, and the smallest, in more basic solutionwheretheanionic or neutralforms dominate. The dependence ofk on pH at a constant~ n c e ~ t r a t i oofnsurfactant and modifier is si~moidal,which resemblesthat of conventional acid-base titration curves. The observed increase in retention at lower pH could beascribed to the fact that the interaction of solutes with the surface of the su~actant-modi~ed stationary phase is stronger than with micelles.
Change in chromatographicretention with pH for aniline in a C 18 column with 0.05 h4SDS mobile phases. Reprinted from Ref. 47 with permission o f the American Chemical Society
~ ~ o ~ tofi anionic o n surfactant monomers onthe surface of a s t a t i o n a ~phase also causes protonated organic bases to be retained a longer period of time than the neutral free-base forms, because of electrostatic onsequently, the elution behavior of protonated bases will mimic n C l 8 columns (Fig. 5.12), in contrast to the behavior observed on cyano columns. Figures 5.10 and 5.12 aremirror images of each other.
No isoeluting point exists with G 18 s ~ t i o n phases, a~ but it can be where the change in kper unit change in average log KHvalues obtained from ,with a C18 column, were in good agreement withthose obtained fromthe isoeluting point using a cyano column [471.
aC1, can also influence c~omatographicretention. ation predicts a decrease in activity coe~lcientswith ength, with a c o n c o m i ~ increase t in solute solubility (salting-in efliect). In this context, the terms "salting-in" and "salting-out" apply to the solute becoming more or less soluble in bulk aqueous phase, respectively, and do not refer to the behavior in the micelle. solubility ofionic organic species, as a ~ n c t i o nof salt concentration, depends onboth their ionic andcarbocyclic portion, it will bethe result of a co~binationof electrostatic and hydrophobic eEects. The behavior of antibinding and binding solutes should be consideredseparately.
If antibindingis mainlyan electros~ticphenomenon, one wouldexpect to see de~nite salt effects on this chromato~ra~hic behavior. In effect, m o ~ ~ c ~ t i o ~ of ionic strength might be su~lcient to change completely an antibinding to a bindingtype behavior (i. e. ,salting-out into the micelle).
salt, bromophenol blue isan antibinding compound, whereas the in presence of as little as 0.02 NaC1, it appears to be nonbinding. At slightly higher salt concentration, the compound binds strongly to SDS micelles [48]. In fact, binding of bromophenol blue to SDS micelles increases substantially more than might be expected from the linear increasethe inconcentration of NaCl. The chromatographic behavior of bromophenol blue plotted as k vs. pH,withandwithoutadded salt, is shownin Fig. 5.13 [47]. Large going differences ink occur at high pH, and the two curves tendto co~verge towards low pH values, indicating that salt effects (electrostatic effects) should be larger for anionic speciess dand l e r for neutral species. Also, the elution behavior vs. micelle concentration at high pH with salt reverses, compared to that without added salt. The bromophenol blue anion is less retained using 0.05 M SDS compared to 0.08 M S S, but has the opposite behavior whenNaC1 is added, indicating that the anionic species in the presence of salt behave more like the neutral species (i.e., the sign of the slope ofthe lk vs. [M] plot changes from negativeto positive). For most antibinding solutes,the slope of l k vs. [M] becomes less negative with increasing ionic strength, althoughallnot compounds showthis trend,indicating that more than simpleelectrostatic eEe considered. For example, the interaction of naphthol green micelles appears to be largely unaffected bythe addition ofsalt. Conversely, the slope oflk vs. [M] for thiocyanate ion becomes even more negative with increasing NaCl concentration [48], Therefore,itseems that for the transition from antibindingto nonbinding andfirther for binding to occur, the solute ion must have sufficient hydrophobic character to associate with the nonpolar portion of the micelle, once electrostatic repulsions have been mini~zed.
In lyophobiccolloidal systems, theadditionofsufficient salt between colloidal generally brings about flocculation. h analogy flocculation andthe nonbinding-binding transition has been drawn [48]. The counterion layer around the micelle is narrowed in a solution containing higher concentration of ions, which facilitates appro~imation the of the solute to the micellar assembly. Hydrophobic interactions between the solute and the nonpolar core of the micelle can then be established.
c
.l3
Salt effects on the retention factor of bromophenol bl various pH values. Micellar mobile phase: (0)0.05 M SDS, 0.05 M SDS-0.10 M NaCI, and (A) 0.08 M SDS-0.10 M NaCI. Reprinted from Ref. 47 with permission of the American Chemical Society.
The behaviorof thiocyanate is difficult to explain in terms of electrostatic criteria. However,itmaybe possible to rationalize by considering the negligible hydrophobic character of this ion. added, the predominate factor may bethe ions increasedaffinity for the bulk solution (salting-inef-fect), resulting ina lesser association with micelles and
1
decreased retention with increasing salt concentration. In contrast, many organic ions tendto be salted-out to the micelle.
nly a few studies have been made on the effect of ionic strength on the ehavior of binding solutes [36, 43, 491. The main effect of NaCl is to decrease electrostatic interactions. The salting-out effect corresponds to a reduction ofelectrostatic repulsions byNaC1, but the addition of NaCl also decreases electrostatic a~ractions, In fact, no uniform behavior seems to exist with ionicsolutes. The presence ofsalt has ~ifferenteffects on solutebinding constants, depending on the nature of the c o ~ ~ o u nFor ~. benzene derivatives, in general, the binding constants increased in the presence of NaCl. In contrast, for naphthalene derivatives, these only increased forl-nap~thol, while for naphthaleneand 2-naphthol, they decreased 13(51.
.
The effectof temperature on the retentionofcompoundsprovides t h e r m o d ~ ~data i c thatdescribe the chromato al. [131 proposed the use ofhigh ~mperatures off e~uationto micellar mobilephases:
S" are the standard enthalpy and e solute from the mobile phaseto the s ~ t i o n phas a~
for transfer of solutes from bulk water to the stationary phase )anisole, (A) l-naphthalenemethanol, (0)toluene, and (B) naphthalene. Mobile phase: 0.10 M SDS. Reprinted from Ref. 50 with permission of the American Chemical Society.
ff plots for transfer of solutes from bulk water to micelles for: (+) isole, (0)toluene, (A) 1 naphthalenem met ha no^, and (B) naphthaiene. Mobile phase:0.10 M SDS.Reprinted from Ref 50 with permissionof the American Chemical Society.
consider, however,the multiple equilibria involved inMLC, as described by the three-phase model. Tomasella et al. [34,50] proposed a more rigorous approach that accounts for thetwomainequilibria,andprovides the t h e ~ o d ~ ~associated i c s with eachtransfer. The t r ~ s f e of r solutes from bulk aqueousphase to the stationary phase is described by:
(5.22)
If the standard enthalpy, A As ,andthe standard entropy, Aso~s ,are f temperature over the temperature range of interest, a plot of [M])] vs. 1/T willbelinear(Fig. 5.14). AHoAsdoes not change with increasing concentration ofsurfactant, since mice effect on this transfer. The general trend is a more negative sing hydrophobicity of the compounds, as observed for a group of (Table 5.5) [S l]. This means that the transfer fiom bulk aqueous phase to stationary phase becomes enthalpically favored for more hy~ophobiccompounds. The less negative valuesof AH",, found inMLC, with respectto conventional LC,indicate that the effectof temperature on k is less pronounced with micellar eluents. In addition, the change in enthalpy for the transfer of solutes from bulk aqueous phase to the micellar pseudo-phase can be calculated by the following e~uation: (5.23)
vs. 1Rgives astrai~ht-linewhose slope and intercept will d Asom(Fig. 5.15). Again, AHom becomesusually greater with increasing compound hydrophobicity. However, a change in
tempera~redisplays a minor change in Km ,when compared with the changes that arecaused by the ad&tion of a few percentof organic m o ~ i ~ e r to the mobile phase. Change in Enthalpy (Kcallmol) for Transferof Solutes from Bulk Aqueous Phase to the Stationary Phase and fromBulk Aqueous Phase toMicelles [S l].
~aphthalene
-2.65
-4.49 -6.20
Acenaphthylene Fluorene
-3.08
-4.84
Anthracene
-5.40
-8.19
P h e n ~ t ~ e n e -6.58
-8.76
9-~ethylanthracene -6.12 luoranthene
-9.05 -8.58
Pyrene
-6.88
-9.29
Chrysene
-10.5
-13.3
-9.68 ~enzor~lanthracene
-12.2 -13.9
en~o[~]~uorant~ene enzo[~]pyrene enzo[e]pyrene Perylene
1.8 -10.6
-1
-4.43
-7,05
-1 1.4
-14.9 -12.8 -14.1
-1 1.7
1. 2.
3.
4. 5.
trong andF.Norne, Partiti ar Mobile Phases inLC, Yarmchuk, R. Wein~erger~ Selectivi~in LC with Micellar Mo rial. Chem.,54: 2233 (1982). . Vera, Study of the arina, 0.Jimenez, on Selectivi~of a of Benzene and ~aphthalene ~erivativesin M C , Microchem. J: ,53: 2 15 (1996). .W.A ~ s t r o and n ~ G.Y. Stine, ~ e l e c t i vin i ~Pseudo-phase LC, Anal. em., 55: 2317 (1983). l l a r on LC ~ ~ n ~ a nand a rL.J. t Cline-Love, ~ o d e l f o r ~ i c eEfects ~etention Factors and for ~et~rminationof ~icelle-Solute ~ ~ u i l i b r Constants, i~m Anal. Chem,, 56: 1557 (1984). Foley, Critical Compilation of Solute-~icelleBinding Constants elated Parameters~om~C Measurements,Anal. Chim. Acta, 231: 237 (1990). Jandera and J.Fischer, Chromato~ra~hic Behavior in W L C with A, 279 cellar and Submicellar Mobile Phases, J Chromato~r. 728: ./
~
6.
7.
.G. Herries, W. Bishop and F. Solutes between Micellar and AqueousPhases: ~easurementby Gel ~iltrationand Efect on the Kineticsof some Bimolecular~eactlons, J: Phys. Chem., 68: 1842 (1964). 9. .Armstrong,~icellesin Separations:A Practical and ~ h e o r e ~ c a l Review, Sep. Pur$ eth hods 10. rthod, I.Cirard and C, ten~onStudy of Solutes of Various Polarities, Anal. Chem., 58: 1359 (1986). 11. .Strasters and M.C. Khaledi, Comparatlve Study of the ~eterminationof ~ o l u ~ e - ~ i c e linl edin^ Constants by MLC and ~ i c e l l aElectro~netic r CapillaryChromato~ra~hy, Anal. Chim.Acta, 246: 131 (1991). aledi, J.K. Strasters, A. ~imult~neous ~nhancement of ~eparati~n Selectivi~ and So~vent 8.
13. 14.
15.
16. 17. 18.
19. 20,
21.
22
I
23
Strength in W L C using Micelles in ~ydro-OrganicSolvents, Anal. Chem., 62: 130 (1990). .T.DeEchegarayand J.S . Landy, ~ ~ c i e n c y ~nhancementin MLC, Anal. Chem., 55: 924 (1983). Torres Cartas, M.C.arcia Alvarez-Coque and R. C a m ~ a s~etermination , of Anabolic Steroids in Pharmaceuticals by LC with a Microemulsion of Sodium DodecylSu~ateand Pentanol as Mobi~ePhase, Anal. Chim. Acta, 302: 163 (1995). .Garcia Alvarez-Coque, E.F. Simo Alfonso,G. Ramis steveRornero, ~igh-PerformanceMLC Determination of mides in Pharmaceuticals after Azodye Precol~mn Derivatization,J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal. 13: 237 (1995). ssel, The Roleof the Stationary Phasein ~ C , J. Chromatogr., 449:349 (1988). Jr., W.L. Hinze and F. romatogr., 12: 1367 ( offman and E. Bonvini, HPLC Separation of Ino~itol ersemploying a Reversed-Phase Column and Micellar ~ o b i l Phase, e J. Chromatogr., 529: 65 (1990). .N. Kayali, S. Rubio Barroso and L.Polo Diez, ~ e t e r m i ~ a of ~on PAHs in Particulate Air by I " , J. Liq. Chromatogr., 17: 3623 (1994). .L.Marina, A ~ o d e Describing l the tion of Alcohols to the Mobile Phasein MLC?J: Chromatogr. A, 719: 15 (1996). .Villanueva Camaiias,J. edina Hernandezand M.C.Garcia Alvarez-Coque, Modeling of ntion Behavior of Solutes in h.17;C with Organic M o d ~ ~ e r s ~ J. C~romatogr.,639: 87 (1993). irkbright and F.G.P. Mullins, ~eparationof ~ i t h i o c a r ~ HPLC usinga Micellar Mobile Phase, Analyst, 109: 493 ( .Wu and J.H.Aiken, ~ i c e l l a HPLC r ~eparation Bilirubin Species with Direct SampleInjection, J. Liq. Chro~atogr., 18: 1219 (1995).
24.
Separation and Phase-~olute Interaction by MLC, J Liq. Chromatogr., 18: 2397 (1995). 25. sch and L.J. Cline-Love, Eflects iency o f ~ CJ. ,Chromatogr., 283: 47 (1984). 26. cott and C.F. Sirnpson, Solute-So~ventInteractions on the Surface of ~eversedPhases.Interactive Characteristicsof some ShortChain Aliphatic Moderators h a v i n ~ rent ~unctionalGroups, raday Symp. Chem.Soc., 15: 69 (1980). 27. . Jandera, W L C of Homo~ogousSeries. A General Method for re diction of ~ e t e n t ~ oJ n ,Chro~atogr.,314: 13 (1984). d J. Ngeh-Ng~ain~i, ~etention ~ehavior of
29. ir, Inves~gationof the ~etention Mechanism in on ionic MLC an Al~lbenzeneHomologous Series, Anal. Chem., 60: 2520 30. 31.
32.
. Li
and S. Fritz, ~ o v eAdditives l for the Separation of Organic by HPLC, JC~romatogr.A, 728: 235 (1996). and E.Pelizzetti, The Useof a Micel~arMobile Phase in Separation of Hydroxyben~ene~erivatives,Anal. Chim.
istribution Coe~cients
33.
cel~e-~oluteAssociation Constants of some ~enzene and S by Micel~arHPLC, Chro~atographia, 28:
35.
~ctanol- at er Coe~cientswith Hydrophobici~for Po~cyclic Aromatic-~vdrocarbonsby MLC, Chromato~raphia, 34: 627 (1992).
LL
36.
.L. Marina, In~uenceofAlcoho1 OrganicMod~ers uponthe Association Constants andRetention Mechanism for Aromatic Compounds in MLC, J Liq. Chromato~r.& Rel. Technol.
.Khaledi, J. S. Landy andJ.L. Lin, ~radient-Elution kiZCqJ Chromatogr., 316: 183 (1984). an, Solute Retention in MLC,JI 38.
37.
39.
orsey, TheMicelle A ~ a ~ t i c a l
40.
41. 42.
43
*
44.
45.
46.
47.
HybridkiZC, Chromatographia,48: 655 (1998). J.S. Landy and J.G. Dorsey, Characterization o f ~ i c e l l a rMobile Phases for W L C , Anal. Chim. Acta, 178: 179 (1985). C. Garcia Alvarez-Coque, J.R. Torres Lapasio and J.J scription of thePartitioning ~ehaviorof Solut Treatment in kiZC with M o d ~ e r sAnal. , Chim. Acta, 324: 163 (1 996). .A. Garcia, S. Vera and M.L. Marina, ~eterminationof MicelleSolute Association Constants of someBenzeneand ~aphthalene ~erivativesby Micellar HPLC with ~ u t a n o land Sodium-Chloride Additives to Mobile Phase, Chromatographia,32: 148 (1991). ASH.Rodgers, Micellar-Mediated S h ~ t sof .G. Khalediand Ionization Constants of Amino Acids andPeptides, Anal. Chim. Acta, 239: 121 (1990). .G. Khaledi, In~uenceof pH on Retention and Consequences of Micellar-~nducedS ~ ~ oft s ‘zationConstants,Anal. Chem., 66: 327 (1994). .Torres Lapasio, J.J. Baeza Baeza and M.C. Garcia Alvarez-Coque, ~escriptionof the ~etentionBehavior in M C as a Function of pH, S~rfactantand Modl~erConcentration,J Chromatogr. A, 769: 155 (1 997). M. Arunyanart and L.J. Cline-Love, In~uence of Micelles on Partitioning Equilibria of Ionizable Species in LC: pH and Ionic Strength Effects, Anal. Chem., 57: 2837 (1985).
0– strong and .U.Stine, valuation and Perturbation of Micelle-So~uteInteractions, J: Am. C h ~ mSoc., . 105: 6220 (1983). erthod, I. Girard and C. Gonnet, Additlve Ejcfeects on Surfactant A~sorptionand Ionic Solute Retentionin MLC, Anal. Chem., 58: 1362 (1986). .P.Tornasella and L.J. Cline-Love, Thermodynamic Properties in MLC based on the Three-Phase ~ ~ u ~ l l bModel, r i u ~Anal. hem., 62: 13 15(1990). 51. Rodriguez Delgado, M.J. Shchez, Gonzalez and F.Garcia elongo, Role of Temperuture in the h ~ i o orf PAHs in MLC. ~hermodyna~ic Aspects, J: C h r o ~ a t o ~Science, r. 33: 647 (1 995).
. The first historical use of micellar phases in chromatography was with the Gel Permeation Chromatography technique (GPC) (see Chapter 3). The low efficiencyproblem was not notedin the early use of micellar phases because GPC is not a technique that produces sharp peaks. However, Arrnstrong observed very early that the TLC micellar spots were broader than nonmicellar ones[1].Broad peaks,i.e., poor efficiency, were obtained when micellar mobile phaseswere used insteadof classical hydro-organic mobile phases in cIassicalLC [2, 31. Dorsey attributed the reduced miceIIar efficiency to a poor wetting of the apolar stationary phase by the aqueous surfactant phase [ 3 ] . He proposed the addition of 3% l-propanolto remediate the problem [3,4]. Yarmchuck et al. thought that a slow mass transfer between the micelles and the stationary phase was responsible for reduced efficiency [5]. Armstrong [6], Berthod [7] and Hinze [8] concluded that poormass transfer within the stationary phase itself was mainly responsible for the observed low efficiency. Two main approaches were proposed to enhance the efficiency in MLC: (i)-the addition of low amounts (3% v h ) of l-propanol [3] to decrease the amount of adsorbed surfactant and to increase the stationary phase wetting, (ii)-to raise the temperature [4, 5) to reduce the liquid viscosity and to increase the chemical reaction rates. In this chapter, thepossible causes ofthe reduced efficiencyin MLC will be surveyed anda rernediation path will be proposed and discussed. The chromato~ra~hic process is rapidly exposed pointing out the thermodynamics (retention time) and the kinetics (peak efficiency). The differences between a classical hydro-organic reversed mobile phase and a micellar phase are recalled. The kinetics of the chrornato~raphicprocess can be modeled using the Knox equation that relates the reduced plate height to the 17
l
reduced mobile phase velocity. Knox plots with classical hydro-organic mobile phases and micellar mobile phases are compared and discussed. ~ u r f a ~ t a n t a d s o ~ont ithe o n s t a t i o n a ~phase and solute exchange between micelles and the bulk are the two main differences between classical and micellar phases. Thesetwo mechanisms are likely responsiblefor the major part of the efficiency loss. The effect of the adhtion of various organic solvents onthe micelle physicochemical structure and surfactant adsorption is exposed.The efficiency enhancementsobtainedwithtem~eraturechanges and/or organic modifier additionsare described.
. The t h e ~ o d ~ ~ofi the c sc~omatographicprocess is responsible for the solute r~tention.The retention volume,VR,is related to the solute affinity constant for the stationary phase, K, by
in whichV, and V, refer to the mobile and stationary phase volume inside the column. The retention factor, k, is expressed by
where Q, (=V, No), is the phase volume ratio. The peak retention volume and factor are due to chemical equilib~~a which are temperature dependent. The classical Gibbs free energy equati&n can be applied:
Combining eqs. 6.2 and 6.3 yields: Ln k = -AHo/RT + ASo/R + Ln 4
C64
The plots of Ln k versus UT,the Van't Hoff plots, will be linear if ASo are constant over the temperature range studied. The slope of the Van't Hoff plot gives the enthalpy change associated with the solute transfer from the mobile to the stationary phase. The intercept is related to the entropy change. Nonlinearity of these plots would indicatechanges in the chromato~aphicmechanism with temperature.
The kinetics of the chromatographic process is linked to efficiency. The number of theoretical plates, N,that measures column efficiencies, is best estimated using the Foley-Dorsey equation when a departure from the Gaussian symmetrical peak shape is noted [9]:
BM + 1.25 in which W,.1, is the peak width at 10% peak height, B/A is the peak asymmetry factor measured by the ratio of the back (B) to front (A)half portion of the W,.,, peak width referring to its t, retention time. This equation takes into account the peak asymmetry. In MLC, the efficiency decreases are always associated with peak tailings, i.e., asymmetry. All plate counts given were obtained using the Foley-Dorsey equation.
According to Snyder and Kirkland [IO], the con~ibutionsto band broadening in a column can be represented in H, the column plate height, by the equation:
in whichthe C values are constant plate height coefficients related to eddy diffusion (e), mobile phase mass transfer (m), longitudinal diffusion (d), sta~nantmobile phase mass transfer (sm) and s t a t i o n a ~phase mass transfer ( S ) , D, is the thickness of the stationary phase layer, D, the solute iff fusion coef~cientin the mobile phase, D, the solute diffusion coefficient in the stationary phase layer and U is the mobile phase velocity. TheKnox equation [111 is used in LC to d e t e ~ i n ethe contributions to the final solute band width. It can be expressed as:
where A', B' and C' are the constants of the Knox equation, h is the reduced plate height calculated as h=H/d,, where H is the column plate height (H=LIN, L beingthe column lengthand N the number of theoretical plates), d, is the stationary phase particle diameter, U is the reduced mobile phase velocity, i.e., U = ud,/Dm,with the average mobile phase velocity, U, The A', € 3 ' and C' terms are related to flow anisotropy, molecular lon~itu~inal diffusion andmass transfer processes, respectively. The theoretical support for the Knox equation was derived by Horvath [12). The A' term cannot be expressed simply. The theoretical treatment links A' to structural parameters of the column packing,porosity, pore volume, pore diameter and tortuosity [121. A' is related to the flow pattern and the general band spreading due to "eddy" diffusion [13). The B' term (longitu~ina~ molecular diffusion) was written as [131:
where ym and y, are obstruction factors for diffusion through granular and/or porous material. The C’ term of the Knox equation represents the mass transfer contributionto solute band ~roadening.It was written as [131
where the y terms are obstruction factors with the subscripts defined for eq. 6.6, 9 is the stagnant mobile phase fraction and q is a geometrical factor depending on porosity [12-141. and broadening and/or unusual retention are also known to occur when specific interactions take place between particular solutes and the stationary phase. The most common cause of such band broadening is a stationary phase overload. It can bealso an exclusion phenomenon due to the small size of the stationary phase pores and the large size of the solute. Acid-base interactions between the surface silanols and basic compounds, especially the amine compounds:,dramatically broaden the corres~onding peaks. Peak deformations, either frontings or tailings, are observed.
I13.~ x t e r ~n ~ ~~
roade n den in^
The plate number, i.e., the chromato~raphicefficiency, is a parameter difficult to estimate correctly [151. The use of methods assuming Gaussian peaks may produce grossly overestimated peals efficiency. The a s y ~ m e t ~ based method [g] (eq. 6.5) was designated as the manual method giving plate numbers closest to the exact plate numbers obtained with the moment method [15, 161. The second central reducedmoment of a peak too often overlooked, that corresponds to its variance [171. It is known, but is a combination of the column variance plus the overall peakvariance, a2:, all the other extra-column variances
(6.10)
17
where the subscripts refer to the column, connecting tubing, injector, detector and other variance contributions (e.g., electronic time constants, frits, unions).
.l Efficiencyexperimentalmeasurement. 1- observedefficiency for a 10,000 plate column, the extra-column bandbroadening is heavy in decreasing the column efficiency band broadening and efficiency for low k solutes. 2-observed efficiency with extra-column enhancement combined withk reduction, amaximum N value seems toexist, 3-true column efficiency when enhancements are used in MLC. Reprinted from [25] with permission of Elsevier.
It is possible and desirable to reduce all extra-column variances. However, external band broadening cannot be fully eliminated. The ~ e a s u r e d and a variance is always the sum of the actual column variance, 02c01,
constant term. If the column efficiency is constant.fora variety of solutes, increases linearly with time the square root of the column variance, acOl, or elution volume. The other variance contributions are rather constant with time. As the retention time increases, the external band broadening contribution to the global variance becomes less significant. The measured efficiencies of highly retained peaks appear higher than the efficiencies of lowk peaks. Figure 6.1 (curve 1) shows that a plateau of constant efficiency, the true column efficiency, is rapidly reached. for improvi~gthe efficiency in LC reduce the retention factor at the same time that they decrease the parameter. Then, the e x ~ e r i ~ e ~ t a ~ observed efficiency may show a maximum value [121 for a given ls value as illustrated by Figure 6.1 (curve 2). Itmeans that the ef~ciency enhancementcanbe annihilated by the extra-column effects. This is specially true when nonoptimized chromatographic systems are used.
c ~ ~ ~ ~ ,
.
The three phase model was exposed in the previous chapter. besides the solute exchange between the stationary and the mo the micelles introduce a secondary chemical equilibrium. Each equilibrium, micelle-aqueous phase, stationary phase-aqueous phase and stationary phase-micelles, has its thermodynamic constant, PWM, PSM,respectively, linked together and to the micellar concentrati the phase ratio, 4, and the surfactant molar volume, v, by the ~rmstrong equation [181.
(6.1 1)
The PSMconstant, not contained in eq. 6.l 1, is the ratio of the two other constants [181:
(6.12)
A.1~0,each e~uilibriumis not reached instantane~uslyan kinetic constant. All three kinetics constants intervene in the global observed efficiency and are studied individ~ally therea~er.
In the early studies, the micellar reduced efficiency was attri [S]. di~inishedrate constant for solute exit from the ~icellar a~gregates If the solute stays inside the micelles that move withthe mobile phase for a long t i m ~ it, interacts with less stationary phase. It “sees” a s h o ~ e r column. Assuming the solute entrance in the micelle is diffusion controlled and e~uivalentfor all solutes, the exit rate constant is inversely ~ r o p o ~ i o nto a lthe PWM constant. l’he solutes with the highest affinit~for the micellar phase shauld be the least r~tained.Actually, they are the most retained solutes which shows that the solute affinity for the micelles (Pm) are strongly correlated to the affinity for the surfactant covered stationary These combined effects with the h ~ ~ r o p h osolutes ~ i c show that they are the ones with the poorer efficiency [5]. The reduced solute exit rate from the micelle produces a decreased solute diffusion coeffi~iellt in the mobile phase, D,. It was shown that the m iff fusion ~oefficientwas ~ecreasedby ,,P constant [6]. l’he overall solute micelle iIlclusion related to the diffusion coefficient, D,, in a micellar solution depends on the micelle diffusion coefficient, DM,and the solute iff fusion coefficie~t i n the aqueous phase, D,,
D m = D, +”-----D , l+
l
1 -l”
(6.13)
is related to the solute a f ~ n i t yc,onstant, PwM,~ e a s u r ~ byd
The product [Mlv is the volume percent of micellar phase and l-[M]v is the volume percent of the aqueous phase 161.
/
Decreases of the benzene diffusion coefficient due to its inclusion in micelles of different surfactants (Data from [6]). Reprinted from 1251with permission of Elsevier.
Figure 6.2 illustrates the decrease of the benzene diffusion coefficient in various ~ i c e l l a rsolutions. Table 6. l lists the diffusio~ coefficients of various solutes in different micellar media. Depending on the solute affinity for the micellar phase, the D, diffusion coefficient can be decreased by a factor varying from 2 to 10 (Figure 6.2). Such a D, decrease may highly increase the B‘and C’ terms of the Knox equation as
shown by eqs. 6.8 and 6.9, respectively. The corresponding reduced velocity, U, is also increased by the D, decrease which should reduce the observed negative effect at low flow rates and magnifL it at high flow rates. An i m ~ o ~ a surfactant nt concentration does not seem to be favorable for ef~cie~c~. .l
DiffbsionCoefficients in VariousMicellar Phases at 24°C
Solute
P,
P
D, (x l o6 cm%)
Brij 22, 5% w/v; 0.08 M Benzyl alcohol Benzaldehyde Benzene Micelle
16.5 21.6 72.2
1600 2100 7000
5. l 4.7 2.9 0.87
400 640 1800
6.3 5.5 4.4 0.94
4800 15,000 43,000 120,000
6.8 3.4 1.7 0.94 0.57
-
Brij 35,5% w/v; 0.042 M Benzyl alcohol Benzaldehyde Benzene Micelle
10 16 45
-
~~~,1.4% w/v; 0.05 M Benzene Toluene ~thylbenzene Prop~lbenzene Micelle
77.4 242 694 1940 "
P is the partition coefficient referring to the micellar phase (=P,,,,xN,,,). Brij 22 = C12E10, mw = 610, v = 0.9542mL/g or 0.582L/mol, Naggr, = 97, cmc= 0.09 mM. Brij 35 = C12E23, mw = 1200, v= 1.064 Limo1 or 0.867 mL/g,NBRPr,= 40, cmc = 0.1 mM. SDS,mw = 288, v= 0.246 Umol or 0.854 mL/g, N8ar, = 62, cmc = 8.2 mM. Data from [7],
III 2. cellar Phase- ~ t a t i o ~Phase ar~ ~ x c h a ~ ~ e s Chapter 4 extensively described the surfactant adsorption occurring when micellar phases are used. This adsorption takes place with any surfactant,
LE
ionic (see Figures 4.2 and 4.4) as well as nonionic (Figure 4.1). surfactant adsorbed layer changes the solute-stationary phase and micellestationary phase interaction and kinetics. The amount of adsorbed material depends on the surfactant and the stationary phase used. It is about 4.5 pmol/m2(-1.3 mg/m2 or -140 mg/(g of C 18 phase) or 14%) for the SDS surfactant on a C18 phase. Similar measurements gave 4.3 pmol/m2 (-2 mg/m2or -.2 10 mg/(g of C 18 phase) or 2 1%) for the CTAB surfactant on the same C 18 phase (see Chapter 4). These amounts of adsorbed SDS or CTAB are close to two surfactant molecules per bonded moiety for the C 18 phases. Corresponding results were obtained for nonionic surfactants [8, 191. The adsorbed surfactant molecules fill up part of the silica pore volume and in doing so, reduce the stationary phase surface area [19,201. The surfactant adsorbed layer increases the thickness of the statio~ary phase organic layer, 0, Assuming a regular layer, the previously indicated adsorbed mass of SDS on the C 18 phasecorresponds to 1.06 mm3/m2or an average thickness of about 1.06 nm. The same calculation for the CTAB layer on the C 18 phase gives a thickness of about 1.6 nm. These estimated of the surfactantmolecule lengths. The breadths roughly correspond to --M @,parameterintervenes quadratically in the last term of eq. 6.6 that means the surfactant layer may dramatically reduce the chromato~raphic efficiency.
As shown by eqs. 6.7, 6.8 and 6.9, the A',B' and C' terms of the Knox equation are not directly related to the kinetic constants of the three equilibria occurring with micellar mobile phases. The slow exchange of the solute between the micellar and aqueous phases increases the three terns of the h o x equation. It increases the flow anisotropy (A'term). It reduces the molecular diffusion. increasing the B' term (eq. 6.8) and the C' term (eq. 6.9). The reduction of the stationary phase-micellar phase soluteexchanges due to the adsorbed layer acts mainly on the C' term.
Table 6.2 lists the A',B' and C' values experimentally obtained by several workers [19-22]. To be meaningful, the Knox plots should be obtained on the same column, with the same solute and different mobile
phases. In column #l, with the benzene solute, the efficiency loss is due to A'increases (+300%) and B' increases (+700%) compared to the values Parameters of the Knox Equation
Optimal Flow
Column Phase Mobile Solute
A'
k
mUmin
Benzene
25°C 45°C
MeOH-water 70/30 v/v SDS 0.05M (1.4% w/v) ACN-water 30/70 1.2 Brij 35 0.042M(5% w/v) 0.2 SDSO.O5M(l.4%w/v) SDS 0.05M(1.4%w/v) 0.7
~t~y~benzene MeOH-water 70130 v/v SDS 0.05M (1.4% w/v)
1 1
2 2,
1.1 3.1
CO.1
0.2 20 0.2, 16.4 0.026 6 0.03 5.6 0.16 11.4 0.05
1.1
3.2 0.65 1.0 3.4 2.7
15.6 17.3 26. l 17.8 16.3
0.2 0.3
1.1 3.1
3.8 23
3.5 45
0.1
5.4
0.26 5.8
0.2 0.3
3 3 1 1
Cu~~arin 0.01M SDS (0.3% w/v) 2 O.OlM+2%C30H SDS 0.018 8.5 4.0 0.2 2 SDS 0.01M+1% G50H 0.007 8.8 3.0 0.32
0.15 0.5
-
-
Column #l: 10 cm, 4.6 mm id., Radial-Pack ODs, 10 pm (Waters), datafrom [21], Column #2: 10 cm, 4.6 mm id., Apex ODs, 5 pm (Jones), data from [21]. Column #3: 10 cm, 4.6mm i.d., C14 bonded phase, 5pm, 3.5 pmol/m2,data from [22]. Room temperature, unless otherwise indicated.
obtained with the methanol-water mobile phase. The C' term is little ith the ethylbenzene solute, the A' and B' values are similar to the benzene values but the C'term isalso increased by 350%. In column #2, the efficiency reduction compared to the acetonitrile (ACN)-water phase is due to moderate increases of both the A' (+54%)and C'(+16%) terms; the decrease of the B' term is not significant considering the raw data set E2l]. In column #3, the hydro-organic reference values were not given. Assuming the column #l values can be used, the efficiency loss is ain due to the A'and B' term increases (+300% and +80%, respectively). hen the temperature was raised from 25°C to 45"C,this decreased the A' and C'terms by -21% and -70%, respectively. The effect of alcohols on
nox parameters is seen by a decrease of the A' terms by -26% and
-45% and a dramatic decrease of the C' parameters by -93% and -97%
is shown when only 2% v/v propanol and 1% v/v pentanol, respectively, were added [22]. The use of the b o x plots to study the causes of micellar reduced efficiencies leads to the following conclusions. The micellar phase flow anisotropy seems to be much higher than the flow anisotropy obtained with a hydro-organic phase of Comparable viscosity (increased A' term). This is only partly due to the micellar viscosity. The main reason of such differences in flow patterns is the partial clogging of the stationary pores by adsorbed surfactant molecules [19, 221. A temperature raise decreases the mobile phase viscosity and the amount of adsorbed surfactant [22]. Both effects decrease the flow anisotropy and the A' term. It will be exposed thereafter that alcohol additions to a micellar phase dramatically reduce the amount of adsorbed surfactant. ' term is linked to solute diffusion coefficient which is nclusion (eq. 6.8 and Figure 6.2). The increase of the ) , change andalso to thek increase (Table in micellar phases is due to the I 6.2). Considering the C' term equation (eq. 6.9), it should be expected that micellar phases decrease C' because k values are higher and coefficients are lower. This is not observed experimentally. It means t the surfactant adsorption causes dramatic decreases of the D, parameter. The solute diffusion coefficient in the surfactant covered stationary phase is very dif~cult[6,7,20-2 l]. It slows down the solute mass-transfer. This effect becomes dominant for lipophilic solutes that have a high affinity for the stationary phase (ethylbenzene, Table 6.2). The peaks correspo to