TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION
4
SECTION 1: PSYCHOLOGY
17
Chapter 1: The Two Systems of Thinking
18
Chapter 2: Va...
513 downloads
4128 Views
5MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION
4
SECTION 1: PSYCHOLOGY
17
Chapter 1: The Two Systems of Thinking
18
Chapter 2: Variable Reinforcement
25
Chapter 3: Kantian Fairness Tendency
32
Chapter 4: Contrast Mis-reaction Tendency
41
Chapter 5: Deprival Super Reaction Syndrome
50
Chapter 6: Do Something Bias
58
Chapter 7: Pavlovian Conditioning
66
Chapter 8: Framing Effect
73
Chapter 9: Status Quo Bias
80
Chapter 10: Twaddle Tendency
89
Chapter 11: Reciprocation Tendency
96
Chapter 12: Gambler’s Fallacy
104
Chapter 13: Mental Accounting
111
Chapter 14: Social Proof
119
Chapter 15: Reason Respecting Tendency
127
Chapter 16: Bystander Effect
134
Chapter 17: Liking Bias
142
Chapter 18: Winner’s Curse
150
SECTION 2: STATISTICS
158
Chapter 19: Mean Reversion
159
Chapter 20: Law of Small Numbers
166
Chapter 21: The Power Law
175
SECTION 3: SOCIAL SCIENCES
182
Chapter 22: Tragedy of Commons
183
Chapter 23: Externalities
192
www.safalniveshak.com
1
TABLE OF CONTENTS | Mental Models, Investing, And You Chapter 24: Complex Adaptive Systems
198
Chapter 25: Moral Hazard
205
SECTION 4: ECONOMICS
213
Chapter 26: Matthew Effect
214
Chapter 27: Game Theory
222
Chapter 28: Gresham’s Law
229
Chapter 29: Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility
236
Chapter 30: Pari-mutuel System
244
SECTION 5: PHYSICS
253
Chapter 31: Thermodynamics
254
Chapter 32: Feedback Loops
262
SECTION 6: DECISION MAKING
271
Chapter 33: Occam’s Razor
272
Chapter 34: Checklist
279
Chapter 35: Loser’s Game
288
SECTION 7: BUSINESS
294
Chapter 36: Switching Costs
295
Chapter 37: Network Effects
303
Chapter 38: Float
311
Chapter 39: Arbitrage
322
Chapter 40: Surfing
330
SECTION 8: ENGINEERING
339
Chapter 41: Redundancy
340
Chapter 42: Critical Mass
347
Chapter 43: Theory of Constraints
355
www.safalniveshak.com
2
TABLE OF CONTENTS | Mental Models, Investing, And You
SECTION 9: MATHEMATICS
363
Chapter 44: Inversion
364
Chapter 45: Permutations and Combinations
372
Chapter 46: Bayes Theorem
379
Chapter 47: Alternative Histories
390
SECTION 10: LITERATURE
399
Chapter 48: Journaling
400
Chapter 49: Active Reading
409
Chapter 50: Storytelling
416
EPILOGUE
423
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
427
BIBLIOGRAPHY
428
ABOUT THE AUTHORS
432
www.safalniveshak.com
3
Introduction The world around us is changing pretty fast and the modern computers are becoming cheaper, faster and more intelligent than ever which means they are ready to replace a large part of human workforce. The day is not far where our work and skills will be threatened by an artificial intelligence. To stay relevant, we need to make sure that we remain valuable to the society in a way which can’t be substituted by a robot. So it’s time that we recognize not just the importance but the urgency of the need to become a learning machine.
Charlie Munger
Image Source: Poor Charlie’s Almanack Charlie Munger, the inimitable partner of Warren Buffett, has been saying the same thing for years – I constantly see people rise in life who are not the smartest, sometimes not even the most diligent, but they are learning
www.safalniveshak.com
4
Introduction | Mental Models, Investing, And You machines. They go to bed every night a little wiser than they were when they got up and boy does that help, particularly when you have a long run ahead of you. The question is where do we begin? We often go through each day without questioning our perception of the world. We seldom stop to wonder whether the world we perceive matches the real world outside. Most of the time, that’s fine…because our perceptions serve us quite well. In fact, our perception is good enough to guide us through a very complex world with few problems. But because it serves us so well, it’s easy to forget how limited perception really is. And one reason for inadequacy of human perception is that it has to deal with an enormously complex real world. We live in a world that is not only complex but vastly older and bigger than we are. To think we can fit it all into our heads is a logical absurdity. At same time, our world and life is full of opportunities, disguised as problems and challenges, which need to be either pursued or avoided. You don’t want to spend a disproportionate amount of time analysing a single problem. Instead the strategy should be to race through numerous problems and quickly identify the solvable ones. How do you do that? By learning the mental models.
Mental Models What’s a mental model? A mental model is a representation, inside your head, of an external reality. Mental models are the basic units which construct a person’s world view. It is the representation that a person has in his mind about the object he is interacting with. It is the way the person thinks about what it is they are doing or dealing with. Mental
www.safalniveshak.com
5
Introduction | Mental Models, Investing, And You models shape our actions as to how we act or behave in a particular situation. They define what people will pay attention to and how they approach and solve problems. Mental models are tools for the mind. The more models you have from outside your discipline and the more you iterate through them when faced with a challenge in a checklist sort of fashion, the better you’ll be able to solve problems. While thinking about a problem, mental models provide you a map with which you can quickly course correct your line of inquiry. These models are additive. Like LEGO. The more you have the more things you can build, the more connections you can make between them and the more likely you are to be able to determine the relevant variables that govern the situation. And when you learn these models you need to ask yourself under what conditions will this tool fail? That way you’re not only looking for situations where the tool is useful but also situations where something interesting is happening that might warrant further attention. It won’t be an overstatement if we call these list of mental models as a cheat sheet which allows us to better understand when to follow and when to reject the conventional wisdom. So it’s very important to have the right models in your head. And how do you build these models? You don’t have to build them all on your own. According to Munger, the most efficient way to learn is vicarious learning. He says – I believe in the discipline of mastering the best that other people have ever figured out. I don’t believe in just sitting down and trying to dream it all up yourself. Nobody’s that smart.
Vicarious Learning Vicarious learning is a very intelligent form of learning. Even the great scientist Isaac Newton once acknowledged, “If I have seen further than others, it is by standing upon
www.safalniveshak.com
6
Introduction | Mental Models, Investing, And You the shoulders of giants.” Newton wasn’t just being humble, he actually left a very important clue about how he learned things and became one of the greatest thinkers and scientists the world has ever seen. A wide array of mental models already exists in form of big and important ideas in every discipline. These big ideas have been developed over past hundreds of years by influential thinkers who have done the hard work of thinking and framing the knowledge in form of these models. By learning the big ideas from multiple disciplines we are allowing ourselves to stand on the shoulders of giants. People who have come before us and developed useful ideas in different subjects have already done the groundwork required for improved thinking. What remains to be done on our part is to learn these ideas, master them and begin using them in our decision making process. Learning mental models is vicarious learning i.e., learning from other people’s mistakes. Vicarious learning becomes supremely important when it comes to figuring out what not to do. “After all you don’t have to pee on an electric fence,” quips Munger, “to know that it’s dangerous.” You must have heard the following saying – “More the sweat in training, less the blood in war.” So training here is akin to learning the mental models and getting adept in their usage. This training will make sure that you get hurt less in making real life decisions. That’s the beauty of vicarious learning.
Man with Hammer It’s completely fine to use one model to understand the idea, and another to work out the details. But life becomes difficult when we think there’s only one way to approach it.
www.safalniveshak.com
7
Introduction | Mental Models, Investing, And You Munger prescribes You must know the big ideas in the big disciplines, and use them routinely — all of them, not just a few. Most people are trained in one model — economics, for example — and try to solve all problems in one way. You know the old saying: to the man with a hammer, the world looks like a nail. This is a dumb way of handling problems. What Munger is suggesting is that one shouldn’t try to solve problems with the only tool he or she possess. When you’re trying to make sense of the world around you, don’t try to explain things by thinking of one reason and then latching on to it. Big outcomes are rarely caused because of one reason. Ask “what else can cause this outcome.” Get more tools. Learn various mental models. Worldly wisdom requires the use of multiple mental models to understand the real life experiences. It’s said that there is nothing more dangerous than a man with an idea especially if it’s the only idea he has. So instead of swinging your single hammer in every direction, you should learn to rely on your toolbox containing multiple instruments i.e., metal models).
Jumping Jurisdictional Boundaries Having diverse mental models in your head is the true multidisciplinary way of learning. To think in a multidisciplinary way, you have to stop sweating the small ideas in your own discipline and reach out for big ideas in other disciplines. Stepping into different disciplines expands your mind’s ability to experience radically different thoughts, perceptions, and ideas. Paul Graham, founder of YCombinator and a very successful venture capitalist, says-
www.safalniveshak.com
8
Introduction | Mental Models, Investing, And You Studying things from unrelated subjects (multidisciplinary learning) is a lot like yoga for brain. You don’t actually get anywhere when you do yoga. You stand in one place and bend yourself in various shapes. But it makes you more flexible, so when you go out and do walk around, you can walk better. That’s why learning the fundamental ideas from major disciplines like physics, biology, math, psychology, history and economics and then remembering them in form of mental models will give you the highest return on investment (of your time and effort). You don’t really have to become an expert in every field. You merely have to learn the fundamental principles – what Munger calls the big ideas – and learn them so well that they are always with you. When you develop a knack for jumping over jurisdictional boundaries of multiple disciplines, you will be richer – both financially and intellectually.
Mental Models Are Contradictory As you start learning these mental models, you’ll find that some of these ideas are contradictory. But isn’t that the nature of truth? It not only feels contradictory but sometimes it looks outright paradoxical. An elephant is a great metaphor for the complex problems we encounter in the real world. It’s like six blind men trying to describe an elephant by grabbing on to different parts of elephant’s body. And we don’t want to be like those blind men who are looking at the problem from a single dimension.
www.safalniveshak.com
9
Introduction | Mental Models, Investing, And You
Image Source: From the book Graphic Presentation by Willard C. Brinton (1939)
Just like a carpenter’s toolbox contains tools to break things and also instruments to join them back, a multidisciplinary thinker’s mental toolbox contains tool of thinking which may sometimes point in different directions. The key to learn is how and when to use a particular tool, which can only come by practicing and implementing the mental models. In that sense multidisciplinary thinking is also an art which becomes more and more useful as you start using it. One goal to learn different mental models from multiple disciplines is to learn how problems can be transformed. Remember that painting of the old lady and young woman? Look at it again –
www.safalniveshak.com
10
Introduction | Mental Models, Investing, And You
Image Source: Perceptual Ambiguity Do you see both? Once you can see both of them it’s easy to switch between them. That’s the beauty of multidisciplinary thinking. The more models you have available, the bigger and clearer is your windshield through which you can observe the problems. We hope these mental models help you cut through the optical illusion around you and you start seeing many young and old ladies – metaphorically.
Independent Thinking Today our world is multidimensional and our problems are complicated. The superfluity of communication and information is drowning us in massive noise. Which means better decisions aren’t necessarily the result of having all the information. Most of the things that we read, listen or watch is dimly understood unless we have the right tools to detangle the balderdash from the core ideas. So in today’s world of information equality, what separates you from the crowd is your ability to generate unique insights using the same information that everyone has. Multidisciplinary education enables you to look at the problem from a variety of perspectives and increase the odds to arrive at a better solution and superior insights.
www.safalniveshak.com
11
Introduction | Mental Models, Investing, And You Becoming a sensible investor is a byproduct of learning to make better decisions. You can’t make better decision by thinking the same thoughts that everybody is thinking and doing the things which everybody is doing. And that’s why independent thinking is so important.
The Latticework In his 1994 speech to business school students, titled Lesson on Elementary, Worldly Wisdom As It Relates To Investment Management & Business, Charlie Munger said What is elementary, worldly wisdom? Well, the first rule is that you can’t really know anything if you just remember isolated facts and try and bang ‘em back. If the facts don’t hang together on a latticework of theory, you don’t have them in a usable form. You’ve got to have models in your head. And you’ve got to array your experience — both vicarious and direct — on this latticework of models. Learning the mental models is just the first step. The second and more important step is to have these models available in a usable form. How do we do that? We have to learn to integrate it into our existing knowledge. That’s what ‘hanging the facts’ means. You use this Latticework — a scaffolding — to hang your experiences and facts. Herb Simon, Nobel Laureate and author of the brilliant book Models of My Life, writes– The better decision maker has at his/her disposal repertoires of possible actions; checklists of things to think about before he acts; and he has mechanisms in his mind
www.safalniveshak.com
12
Introduction | Mental Models, Investing, And You to evoke these, and bring these to his conscious attention when the situations for decision arise. This ‘mechanism of mind’ is what the metaphor of Latticework all about. To be able to use those mental models effectively, one has to work on building his or her own latticework based on knowledge and experience. You may have noticed students who just try to remember and pound back what is remembered, writes Charlie, “Well, they fail in school and in life. You’ve got to hang experience on a latticework of models in your head.” Having the big ideas in usable form is how you begin to achieve worldly wisdom. This way of interacting with the world is supremely efficient. It makes you a better thinker, decision maker and gives you a tremendous edge in navigating the world around you. Even people with ordinary intelligence can outthink the smartest people if they develop certain thinking habits. Building a latticework of mental models is an ongoing process of, first, acquiring the significant concepts – the models – from many areas of knowledge and then, second, learning to recognize patterns of similarity among them. The first is a matter of educating yourself; the second is a matter of learning to think and see differently. Creating this latticework is about the ability of seeing patterns – how ideas and things relate and hang together. Knowledge that can be used in a variety of situations. Building a latticework of mental models will require you to embrace differences, ambiguity, conflict, and tension. Consider them signposts to better solutions and better problems.
Sharpening the Axe We think what Abraham Lincoln said is a great metaphor for lifelong learning. He said-
www.safalniveshak.com
13
Introduction | Mental Models, Investing, And You
Give me six hours to chop down a tree and I will spend the first four sharpening the axe. Spending a lot of time on a single problem is akin to struggling with a single tree with a blunt axe. Learning multi-disciplinary ideas and building a latticework of mental models is akin to sharpening your axe. Axe sharpening doesn’t necessarily mean that you have to build a super smart brain or develop an IQ of 180. You just have to devote some time in learning the ideas that matter – the true wisdom. Wisdom that can help you cut through the crap and directly see the core. And Latticework of Mental Models is that sharp axe. So the idea is to spend more time constructing, overhauling, fine tuning and maintaining your Latticework. Building your own Latticework of mental models is a tremendously useful way to evaluate and upgrade the fabric of your worldview.
To Learn Better, Teach Aristotle saidFor the things we have to learn before we can do them, we learn by doing them. This means we need to practice what we have learnt in various situations. These mental models and multidisciplinary ideas do no good sitting inside your head like artifacts in a museum for they need to be taken out and played with. Once you learn a model, the question that you should ask yourself is – where can I find a practical implication of this?
www.safalniveshak.com
14
Introduction | Mental Models, Investing, And You Another way to crystallize your learning is to teach it. As they say, “Tell me and I forget, teach me and I may remember, involve me and I learn.” Teaching is one of the most effective (and largely ignored) hack for learning. So start implementing what you learn and the first step to implementing any kind of knowledge is to teach it to someone else. When you read something interesting, don’t just forward the link to others, make efforts to explain the idea in your words, in your own unique way. When you are teaching to somebody else, it reveals the gaps in your own understanding. You will be surprised with the kind of insights that pop up in your head while you’re explaining new ideas to other people. So don’t just read, get involved. Don’t just learn, go out and teach. We urge you to find few friends and partners with whom you can share these ideas. And if nobody wants to listen to you, sit in front of the mirror and assume you’re talking to your sibling and share your knowledge. When we write about mental models, we imagine ourselves sitting in front of you and having this conversation face to face. That creates a fear in our minds that we might not be able to answer your doubts and questions. This subconscious fear makes us think hard before writing. Can you guess who benefits the most from this process? We. According to Charlie Munger, the best thing a human being can do is help another human being know more. And as they say charity begins at home, so we are constantly trying to help ourselves know more. So let us say this again - it might look like we are trying to spread the knowledge here but honestly our ulterior motive here is to solidify our own learning. And as a spillover effect, if just one more person benefits from our efforts, we would consider that we paid off a small percentage of the debt that we owe to Charlie Munger. And all we ask from you is to Pass it on.
www.safalniveshak.com
15
Introduction | Mental Models, Investing, And You
Before We Start According to one statistics, only 10 percent of the people read past the first two pages of a book they start. So if you’ve read this far, we can say you’re already ahead in the game. Not the game of “who knows more” but the game where knowing few essential ideas go a long way in reducing errors and increasing the quality of life. According to Mr. Munger, there are about 100 or so models across the disciplines of microeconomics, physiology, psychology, elementary mathematics, hard science and engineering that carry about 90% of the freight in making you a worldly-wise person. And, of course, it’s not possible to learn all of them in day or a week or even in a single year. It’s a long term proposition and will require serious efforts. But when you’ve committed yourself to a lifelong journey for seeking worldly wisdom, it’s a small price to pay. Are you ready to pay that price? Did you just say “Yes”? We think we heard that. In this book, we have compiled a list of 50 mental models arranged by fields of study, which can serve as a good starting point for you to create your own “latticework of mental models”. The book is a collection of essays that were published in past one year as part of Safal Niveshak’s Latticework series. Use these ideas as a springboard for further useful discovery. One last warning - Anything that you read “rewires” a part of your brain. The brain you have now; you don’t get that brain back after learning the mental models. We are sincerely hoping that the trade-off is worth it. With respect, Anshul & Vishal Note: In many of the places in the book we have used “I”. Although we haven’t specifically mentioned who that “I” refers to. It was intentional to keep the reader’s flow uninterrupted. If you have questions on specific chapters, you can always email us at vishal[at]safalniveshak[dot]com or anshul[at]safalniveshak[dot]com.
www.safalniveshak.com
16
SECTION 1: PSYCHOLOGY One of the most important node in Charlie Munger’s Latticework is this idea of behavioural economics. It’s the intersection of economics and psychology. In his book Thinking Fast and Slow, Daniel Kahneman, a Nobel Laureate who is also considered the father of behavioural finance, writes – A remarkable aspect of your mental life is that you are rarely stumped … The normal state of your mind is that you have
intuitive
feelings
and
opinions
about
almost
everything that comes your way. You like or dislike people long before you know much about them; you trust or distrust strangers without knowing why; you feel that an enterprise is bound to succeed without analyzing it. This overconfidence in our intuitive abilities for making crucial decisions in work and life can do us in. The fact is you’re probably not as effective at making decisions as you could be. Nobody is. But we can get better by learning about human behavioural quirks that can bring down the quality of our decisions. Behavioural finance, the place where psychology meets money, is increasingly becoming a very important subject for everybody. It’s no more a thing of academic interest for scientists. It’s mainstream now. The day isn’t far when awareness about human behavioural biases would become as essential as driving a car or using a computer. Awareness about behavioural biases doesn’t necessarily make us immune to them, however what we can attempt to do is to minimize their effect and increasingly make better choices. I would recommend that you start this section by reading Chapter 1 first because it will set the stage for subsequent ideas that are discussed in Psychology section. Rest of the sections and chapters can be read in any order.
www.safalniveshak.com
17
Chapter 1 The Two Systems of Thinking “What’s 2 + 2?” You can’t help but think of the answer instantly. Your mind throws the number “4” on your thought screen. It’s actually impossible to not think of the answer here, unless you haven’t learnt to count to ten. The answer is almost like a reflex. It was an instance of fast thinking. In fact, you don’t even need to consciously think about it. It just happens to you. This is the result of what scientists call reflexive brain. Now if I ask you, “What’s 38 multiplied by 27?” For most of you, except if you’re a math wizard, your brain goes blank. It doesn’t give you any instant answer. You’ll have to take a pause and calculate the answer with some efforts, and if you’re like me you won’t be able to do it without pen and paper. Here you have to involve a part of your brain which is known as the reflective brain. You experience a slow mode of thinking as you proceed through a sequence of steps to solve this multiplication problem. Reflexive brain is quick and it tends to jump to conclusion. Reflective brain is much slower, requires effort, it’s logical and, as we’ll see later, less prone to error. Daniel Kahneman, a Nobel laureate who is also known as the founding father of modern behavioural economics, in his book Thinking Fast and Slow, has termed these two modes of thinking as System 1(reflexive) and System 2 (reflective).
www.safalniveshak.com
18
Chapter 1 - The Two Systems of Thinking | Mental Models, Investing, And You System 1 operates automatically and quickly, with little or no effort and no sense of voluntary control. System 2 allocates attention to the effortful mental activities that demand it, including complex computations. The operations of System 2 are often associated with the subjective experience of agency, choice, and concentration. In other words, System 1 and System 2 modes of thinking can be imagined as intuitive and deliberate thought respectively. So these two don’t really exist physically inside your skull. They are mere representation of the way to understand how human brain carries out the task of thinking. Consider these two systems as agents within the mind, with their individual personalities, abilities, and limitations. “Systems 1 and 2 are both active whenever we are awake”, says Kahneman, “System 1 runs automatically and System 2 is normally in a comfortable low-effort mode.”
So for most of our routine tasks like walking, talking, reading, driving, etc., System 1 is engaged in helping us make quick and efficient decisions. System 1 is the first layer of thinking that any problem is delegated to by our brains. System 2 comes into picture
www.safalniveshak.com
19
Chapter 1 - The Two Systems of Thinking | Mental Models, Investing, And You only when a question arises for which System 1 does not offer an answer, as probably happened to you when you encountered the multiplication problem 38 × 27. The arrangement works well most of the time because System 1 is generally very good at what it does. But things aren’t as perfect as they seem. Our hero, i.e. System 1 is an overconfident guy. And under many specific conditions, which should ideally be delegated to System 2, our System 1 insists on making a decision and ends up creating systematic errors. These systematic errors from System 1 are called psychological biases. Here’s a simple example. Look at the image below. There are three sentences inside the triangles. Read them out loudly.
Did you notice the mistake? Don’t feel bad if you didn’t because most people fail to notice the error. In the first sentence, word “the” appears twice before the word “spring”. Same with the third sentence. And similarly in the second sentence the word “a” repeats. So what really happened?
Impatient System 1 Reading is pretty much an effortless activity (as far as understanding the literal meaning of the sentence is concerned) which is done by System 1. So in a hurry to make sense of the things, System 1 does these optimizations on its own level and hence
www.safalniveshak.com
20
Chapter 1 - The Two Systems of Thinking | Mental Models, Investing, And You these small inconsistencies remain invisible to us because of shortcuts taken by System 1. You may say that it was a case of an optical illusion, so here’s another example which doesn’t involve any images. This is a very simple math problem. Instead of trying to solve it, just observe the first intuitive answer that comes to your mind because that will give you a clue to workings of System 1. •
The total cost of Bat and a Ball is 110 rupees.
•
The cost of Bat is 100 rupees more than the Ball.
•
How much does the Ball cost?
If you’re in a hurry you would quickly conclude that “the ball costs 10 rupees” which is a wrong answer. If you do the math little slowly (using System 2), you’ll realize that the right answer is – ball costs 5 rupees and the bat costs 105 rupees. In all such situations you must pay attention, and you will perform less well, or not at all, if you are not ready or if your attention is directed inappropriately. Use of System 2 requires attention and its operation is disrupted when the attention is taken away. The sloppiness of System 1 is what creates cognitive biases. And that makes System 1 a very interesting subject of study. The whole field of behavioural economics stems out from the need to understand the peculiar characteristics of System 1. So let’s see how did this dude called System 1 come to be.
Origins of System 1 The System 1 thinking or the reflexive brain is a gift from evolution. Our ancestors were hunter gatherers and lived in jungles where there was a constant threat of being eaten by a wild beast. So when they sensed a movement in the bushes it was probably
www.safalniveshak.com
21
Chapter 1 - The Two Systems of Thinking | Mental Models, Investing, And You a predator about to jump on them. The only way our ancestors could survive was to run at any such signs. These reflexes or instincts, to run away from a potential danger, created a strong evolutionary advantage for homo sapiens and resulted in the development of reflexive brain. Imagine if I was in the same situation and upon sensing the movement in the bushes, instead of running, I pulled out my smart phone and started googling – “what does noise from bushes mean?” – by the time google gives me an answer I would be a dead meat. Now the process of evolution is slow. So those instincts, which our ancestors developed during the human evolution history of 2.5 million years, are still present in us. Our bodies and minds haven’t changed much in last few thousand years but the environment in which we live in has changed dramatically. The threat of being attacked by a wild beast isn’t there anymore, unless of course you decide to jump inside the cage of a lion in a zoo. Many of these instincts aren’t very useful in present day. But they do influence of our decision making. In the modern world these biases cause us to make big mistakes particularly in the financial markets.
In Investing When it comes to money and investing, presence of System 1 makes our brains illequipped to handle the situations. Investing is an area which presents many situations where reliance on System 1 gets us fooled into making very serious errors of judgment. Many psychological biases (we are going to see some of them in later chapters) are brainchild of System 1. Some of them are – Anchoring Effect, Overconfidence Bias, Confirmation Bias, Scarcity Bias, Authority Bias, Social Proof (Chapter 14), Base Rate Neglect, Liking Bias etc.
www.safalniveshak.com
22
Chapter 1 - The Two Systems of Thinking | Mental Models, Investing, And You Anchoring effect happens when people get hung up on the stock prices instead of the quality of the underlying business. System 1 thinking compares the current price to the recent high-low prices (anchor) and jumps to faulty conclusions. Confirmation bias is that property of System 1 which makes it prone to remain consistent with its earlier decisions or commitments. System 1 selectively seeks only that information which is consistent to its beliefs and discards any disconfirming evidence. When we see someone dressed as doctor on the TV, we assume that he knows what he’s talking about. Similarly, when a stock market expert (suit-tie wearing talking heads who like to show off their financial jargon vocabulary) forecasts the market movements and the macroeconomic shifts, System 1 falls for the Authority Bias and believes him. Liking bias (Chapter 17) makes us prone to favour those whom we like. It’s very common for people to get duped into buying useless financial products because the so called financial advisor (a salesman) comes across as a likeable person because of his or her pleasant personality and extraordinary communication skills. Base rate neglect is another such erroneous thinking where System 1 ignores the underlying base rate of success. If someone claims that his grandfather was a chain smoker and lived up to a ripe age of 95, he’s ignoring the statistics. Base rate says that statistically a chain smoker is unlikely to live a long life. Grandfather was an exception, an outlier and you can’t make your decisions based on such anecdotal evidences. But Systems 1 tends to fall for such misleading stats. Everyone knows some friend of a friend who made lot of money in an IPO. But don’t forget that the base rate of making money in IPOs is very poor. All these biases of System 1 can wreak havoc and cause serious damage to our financial wellbeing. So how do you fight with System 1?
www.safalniveshak.com
23
Chapter 1 - The Two Systems of Thinking | Mental Models, Investing, And You Turns out that it’s not that easy. It’s quite stubborn. System 1 operates automatically and cannot be turned off at will, errors of intuitive thought are often difficult to prevent, writes Kahneman, “Biases cannot always be avoided, because System 2 may have no clue to the error.” But let’s say you learn to reject the first intuitive response in every situation and call upon System 2 to find the more calculated and rational answer. Would that help? According to Kahneman, it would be an overkill. He writes – As a way to live your life, however, continuous vigilance is not necessarily good, and it is certainly impractical. Constantly questioning our own thinking would be impossibly tedious, and System 2 is much too slow and inefficient to serve as a substitute for System 1 in making routine decisions. The best we can do is a compromise: learn to recognize situations in which mistakes are likely and try harder to avoid significant mistakes when the stakes are high. Notice the point – when the stakes are high. So when you’re making an investment, it’s a high stake situation. But if you’re buying a toothpaste, you can give System 2 some rest and go with System 1.
Conclusion System 1 Vs System 2 is a brilliant mental model to explain the machinery of thought. And when it comes to the subject of thinking, Daniel Kahneman’s book is a bible. You can’t call yourself a serious student of behavioural economics if you haven’t read Daniel Kahneman’s book.
www.safalniveshak.com
24
Chapter 2 Variable Reinforcement It’s not often that you would find me exercising my thumb muscles with a TV remote but it so happened that on a Saturday afternoon while killing time in front of the idiot box, an unsettling thought caught me off guard. I realized that I had been surfing through the TV channels for the past hour without really spending more than a minute on any single channel. This habit is not uncommon but the unusual thing was, once I had looped through all the channels a couple of times and found that there was nothing interesting on TV, I still kept changing the channels without getting bored. So what was keeping me hooked? As a flash of insight the answer that my mind threw at me was an uncomfortable one. It wasn’t the content in the TV which was keeping me engaged. It was the excitement of unknown that existed for those short moments between channel switches. The moment I decided to flick the channel, for a millisecond my mind wouldn’t know what was going to appear next on the TV screen. My above hypothesis wasn’t entirely correct but I knew I was on to something. For few minutes, I even day dreamed about winning the next Nobel prize for a path breaking discovery in human behaviour! Please don’t laugh as that dream was soon shattered by Mr. Google. A little googling revealed an important mental model from the field of psychology. It’s called Variable Reinforcement.
What’s Variable Reinforcement? A response or action is called reinforced response if it generates a reward i.e., a person will be motivated to repeat a response if he or she gets a reward for the same. That’s
www.safalniveshak.com
25
Chapter 2 - Variable Reinforcement | Mental Models, Investing, And You the well-known theory of motivation. However, when a response is reinforced after an unpredictable number of tries, it generates a high and steady rate of response. Which means, when you receive the reward with irregular or unpredictable frequency, your behavior is reinforced even more strongly. Take a moment and think about the following questions. What’s your first instinct when you hear your phone ring? What’s the first thought when you see an incoming phone call from an unknown number? Is it easy to ignore and forget about a WhatsApp buzz or an unread message icon in your mailbox? Personally, my first instinct is to immediately answer the unknown call or read that unopened message. And my rationalizing mind justifies this urge with questions like – What if it’s an emergency? What if there’s a surprise for me? The situation described above is nothing but variable reinforcement in disguise. Psychologists have done elaborate experiments to prove that the effect of variable enforcement is pretty strong on human behaviour. Let’s take a look at one such empirical study.
Skinner’s Experiments In 1950s, a scientist called B.F. Skinner validated the reinforcement theory by conducting experiments on mice. He observed that mice responded most voraciously to random rewards. In one of his experiments, he selected two mice and fed them little differently. The first mouse was treated with same amount of food every time it pressed a lever. However, to the second mouse, the supply of food was irregular and uneven. When this second mouse would press a lever, it would sometimes get a small reward, other times a large one, and sometimes nothing at all.
www.safalniveshak.com
26
Chapter 2 - Variable Reinforcement | Mental Models, Investing, And You What Skinner observed that the second mouse pressed the lever compulsively when the food was given at irregular intervals. That established the theory of variable reinforcement. Nir Eyal, author of the book Hooked: How to Build Habit-Forming Products, writesHumans,
like
the
mice
in
Skinner’s
box,
crave
predictability and struggle to find patterns, even when none exist. Variability is the brain’s cognitive nemesis and our minds make deduction of cause and effect a priority over other functions like self-control and moderation. Variable rewards hook up our brains and keep it occupied. They sometimes create a trance like state for our minds. Variable reinforcement is used by a lot of sales and marketing people to keep you and me engaged with their products. This mental model appears at variety of places in the real world.
In Gambling Have you ever wondered why is gambling an addiction? Especially in casinos you will find people glued to slot machines pulling the lever compulsively. It’s been predicted by studies that even if some of those people end up winning the jackpot, they would prefer spending all that money back into slot machine. Interesting, isn’t it? Slot machine players have no way of knowing how many times they have to play before they will win. All they know is that eventually a player will win. This is why slot machines are so effective and players are often reluctant to quit. There is always the possibility that the next coin they put in will be the winning one. Like the skinner’s rat, they keep pulling the slot machine lever. A horrific finding claims that many slot machine addicts wear adult diapers because they don’t want to get up even to answer the nature’s call.
www.safalniveshak.com
27
Chapter 2 - Variable Reinforcement | Mental Models, Investing, And You It would be naive to think that those slot machines offer a fair play. These machines are designed to exploit the variable reinforcement inherent in human behaviour. The machine doles out rewards in a very unpredictable (which might seem totally random to untrained eyes but it’s not) fashion. Now that we are talking about slot machines, it’s worth mentioning an intelligent aspect of slot machine design called “calibrated near misses”, which exploits another behavioural quirk called Deprival Super Reaction Syndrome. We’ll discuss that in Chapter 5.
In Daily Life It’s common for most people to give in to the urge to take a phone call from an unknown caller or to check your email/mobile phone every few minutes. What we don’t realize that we have limited supply of willpower and attention in a day. When we spend our mental resources (cognitive fuel) attending to these small insignificant attention grabbing events, we are foregoing a chance to engage in deep thinking or doing any other important tasks (like reading a book). Another personal observation – with smartphones and digital devices powered with fast Internet, any song or music in the world is just a few seconds away from you. Then why do people still listen to radio? It’s because radio offers the element of unexpected and novel experience with irregular interval (those annoying radio ads can go on for a long time before the next song is played on air). And you can’t know beforehand which music is going to be played while you’re driving back home. Similarly, many companies use this trick to motivate people. Call centers often offer random bonuses to employees. Workers never know how many calls they need to make in order to receive the bonus, but they know that they increase their chances the more calls or sales they make.
www.safalniveshak.com
28
Chapter 2 - Variable Reinforcement | Mental Models, Investing, And You Video games is another such example which engages people and can lead to addiction. In case you don’t know – the video gaming industry is bigger than movies and music industry combined (worldwide). Surprising, right? Remember Farmville and Angry Bird games? The Twitters and Facebooks of the world are creating new habits by running users through a series of addictive products fueled by variable rewards.
In Investing There are ample evidences to show that a buy and hold strategy triumphs over frequent trading for majority of investors. Then why do people still get into frequent trading, hoping to make sustainable profits? Prof. Sanjay Bakshi compares these short-term speculators to butterflies jumping from one flower to the next. In a recent article, he wrote …reason why people resemble butterflies is because of the presence of a pleasure chemical called dopamine in our brains. The more the dopamine the more the pleasure. And novel experiences (imagine bungee jumping or a one-night stand) deliver enormous amounts of dopamine to the brain.
The
other
thing
that
delivers
dopamine
is
unexpected, pleasant surprises. And day traders get a lot of small, but pleasant surprises just like kids who are hooked to gaming. It gets addictive, this dopamine business. The more you get the more you crave for. If you put a day trader who just had a winning bet in a fMRI machine and compare him with a cocaine addict, the doctors can’t tell the difference. Their brains look just the same. Behaving like a butterfly increases the probability of
www.safalniveshak.com
29
Chapter 2 - Variable Reinforcement | Mental Models, Investing, And You novel experiences. It increases the probability of small, unexpected surprises [variable reinforcements]. Warren Buffett has written that for many “investor-dreamers, any blind date is preferable to one with the girl next door, no matter how desirable she may be.” He is clearly on to something. Similarly, checking your portfolio constantly is a type of addiction. Because of the inherent volatility of stock prices, there will be times when your portfolio will show profits (and sometimes it will be in red too). Every time you see a paper profit it releases a small quantity of dopamine, the feel good hormone, in your brain and your action (checking the portfolio) is reinforced. The notional increase in your portfolio value is a source of variable reinforcement. Now you know why we aren’t very different from rats when it comes to variable reinforcement.
Antifragility Meets Variability I am an admirer of Nassim Taleb’s ideas. Antifragility is one of his ideas that I found very insightful. It basically says that we should arrange our affairs in such a manner that the uncertainties of life should benefit us instead of causing a harm. So let me speculate a bit about reinforcement in the context of antifragility. Knowing that variable rewards induce addiction, can we design an environment for ourselves where variations (the stimuli which create everyday experience) increase the quality of our life? The idea is to bring in the element of pleasant uncertainty. How about doing something wacky which has the potential of creating a totally unexpected and new experience? Like wearing different coloured sock on each leg? Or parting your hair the other way? Hey! I am just suggesting. By the way I tried the hair
www.safalniveshak.com
30
Chapter 2 - Variable Reinforcement | Mental Models, Investing, And You trick and it freaked my wife big time. But guess what? It became a memorable day and she now calls me Mr. Wacky. Vishal, on his trip to Varanasi, roamed the city’s streets wearing the traditional Indian dhoti-kurta and found passersby amused at his attire. But as he tells me, it was one of his most memorable days in life and he would like to return to Varanasi soon and roam the streets wearing that dress again. A wise man said – “Life is not number of days you live but number of days you remember.” Perhaps this explains the behaviour of those crazy adventure junkies. They are addicted to creating unique moments even if it means frequently putting their life at risk. So a word of caution - taking this idea to extreme may backfire too. Please use common sense and please don’t break the law! Too much wackiness on a consistent basis can end up creating unmanageable mess.
Conclusion Variable reinforcement is a powerful force that focuses attention, provides pleasure, and infatuates the mind. Next time when you see people getting addicted in an environment or to some product, pull out the variable reinforcement mental model from your latticework toolbox. It may give you some useful insights.
www.safalniveshak.com
31
Chapter 3 Kantian Fairness Tendency I was almost at the end of a beautiful evening drive. Refreshing cold breeze gently blowing on my face through the car windows. The relatively less traffic on the road was like heaven on earth. Sporting an ear-to-ear smile I felt confident that nothing in the world had the power to take away my inner peace at that moment. But, as usual, my faithful and ever reliable nemesis, the chaos-monkey, had different plans for me that evening. Just when I was about to take a smooth turn on a closing traffic signal, a taxi cut me off while overtaking my car. The surprising rash maneuver from the taxi called for sudden brakes and by that time signal had turned red. As a result, I missed my turn because of the insensitive driving by the taxi driver. In the next few seconds, my Buddha smile turned into an angry frown and I was thrown out of my “appreciating the good things in life” mode. Why did I feel so agitated? Well, for one, I was ahead of the taxi and it was me who was supposed to cross the signal first. I felt as if the taxi guy had brutally robbed off my well-deserved right to take the turn before him. You might find it amusing but the incident costed me a whopping two minutes of extra wait for the traffic signal to turn green again and of course my inner peace. May be I am exaggerating and unnecessarily using strong words to describe a petty incident. But how could I take it easy? It was absolutely unfair! Do unto others as you would have done unto you. Sounds familiar? Well I would never have done the same thing (it’s pretty close to encroachment in my dictionary) to anybody else.
www.safalniveshak.com
32
Chapter 3 - Kantian Fairness Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You Probably the taxi driver didn’t really think it was unfair. Perhaps he’d been at the receiving end of the same treatment many times in the past that he now considered it fair to pass the buck. Or maybe he was just too busy marveling at his own driving skills. Who knows what he was thinking! Well, before you lose interest and stop reading, let me put an end to my rant about traffic etiquettes and being a victim of unfair treatment. Let me ask you this. Have you ever experienced this feeling of being treated unfairly? May be in some small way like when one of your utterly undeserving colleague got promoted before you. Ouch, I’ve been there!
Kantian Fairness Tendency Why is the human psyche so obsessed with the idea of fairness? Actually, it’s not just humans. Even monkey business (literally) isn’t immune to this tendency. Watch this video, which proves that the tendency to seek fairness in all transactions is not an invention of modern man, but the behaviour has been tattooed at a much deeper level by evolutionary process.
Image Source: YouTube.
www.safalniveshak.com
33
Chapter 3 - Kantian Fairness Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You The theory about human rationality takes the view that people would accept any offer made to them as long as they were better off. But we know that humans are anything but rational and many studies have shown that people will reject offers they view as unfair. Our ape just validated this hypothesis in the video. This is the matter of discussion in this chapter. Exploring the idea of what Charlie Munger calls Kantian Fairness Tendency. Although we’ve put this mental model under Psychology, it’s one of the big ideas from Philosophy. Let’s define fairness first. The basic idea is that we have devised certain rules that, when followed by everyone, result in a pretty smooth life for all involved. The key is that everyone needs to follow along. This unsaid understanding about ‘following along’ few ‘socially acceptable guidelines for conduct’ is what constructs the framework for fairness. When a behaviour doesn’t fall (or doesn’t seem to fall) in this framework, we label it as unfair. From Charlie’s talk, it’s not entirely clear why he has used the word Kantian but let me still take a stab at it. The word refers to the philosophical framework created by eighteenth century German philosopher Immanuel Kant. Kant’s ethics are founded on his view of rationality as the ultimate
good
and
his
belief
that
all
people
are
fundamentally rational beings. (Source: Wikipedia) According to Kant, an individual’s rights and duties are the foundation for defining morality and fairness. Passing a judgment on ‘what is fair’ seems pretty simple when you are the subject matter i.e., when you are evaluating the fairness in matters involving you. What about the case when you have to take a decision about ‘what is fair’ for a third person?
www.safalniveshak.com
34
Chapter 3 - Kantian Fairness Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You
Image Source: Imgur. I have borrowed a lot of ideas in this chapter from Prof. Sanjay Bakshi’s blog post on this topic. His discussion about ‘the law of higher good’ is another mental model that you need to be aware of.
Fairness and Envy If you look at the monkey’s behaviour in the above video, it’s clear that the reward for performing a task was acceptable to the monkey until he saw that his other monkey friend (I am just making a guess about their friendship; they could have been professional rivals too) is getting a better reward for the same task. Of course, at this point, the first monkey goes berserk. He just can’t believe it. He is boiling with anger. A complete pandemonium follows in his cage. My guess is that this extreme reaction against lack of fairness is because of envy, another mental model which we will discuss in detail some other time. However,
www.safalniveshak.com
35
Chapter 3 - Kantian Fairness Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You Kantian Fairness Tendency limits the behaviour to accepting or rejecting the offered deal, whereas envy takes it to the next level (i.e., the emotional outburst) which could, and definitely would, get you into trouble. You could say that a distorted worldview about fairness becomes the precursor to envious behaviour. That explains where the roots of envy lie.
Seeking Fairness In the TV news when you see a guy robbing a lady, the obvious first thought is to seek punishment for the culprit. But soon the news reporter reveals that the thief’s mother was ill and he needed money for her treatment. Does this justify robber’s act as fair? May be yes. But then, is it fair to the society as a whole that anybody who needs money for a genuine cause is allowed to rob strangers? As usual, Charlie Munger has some insights to deal with such situations. He has spoken about man’s over love of fairness in his UCSB talk. He said – It is not always recognized that, to function best, morality should sometimes appear unfair, like most worldly outcomes. The craving for perfect fairness causes a lot of terrible problems in system function. Some systems should be made deliberately unfair to individuals because they’ll be fairer on average for all of us. I frequently cite the example of having your career over, in the Navy, if your ship goes aground, even if it wasn’t your fault. I say the lack of justice for the one guy that wasn’t at fault is way more than made up by a greater justice for everybody when every captain of a ship always sweats blood to make sure the ship doesn’t go aground. Tolerating a little unfairness to some to get a greater fairness for all is a model I recommend to all of you. But again, I wouldn’t put it in your assigned
www.safalniveshak.com
36
Chapter 3 - Kantian Fairness Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You college work if you want to be graded well, particularly in a modern law school wherein there is usually an over-love of fairness-seeking process. Looking at the idea of fairness in isolation is akin to saying that a surgeon should refuse to operate on a patient because it will cause pain to him. Of course, an operation will cause pain (after the anesthesia wears out) and few days of inconvenience, but eventually it will prove to be a beneficial act for the patient. So, may be, seeking fairness isn’t always wrong. What you have to know is – at what level are you seeking fairness? At an individual level, or at a group level, or at some other level altogether. Answering that question would bring some clarity on what is fair and what isn’t. I suggest you watch this lecture from Michael Sandel who is a professor in Harvard University. Some of the thought experiments that he discusses in his lecture are so unsettling that it seriously challenged my long held notions about morality and fairness. The following story is from an article I read in Wall Street Journal – During the middle ages in Europe when the court couldn’t determine if a defendant was guilty they would offer him an option. The option was to either accept the punishment for their crime or put their hand in boiling water. The idea was that God, who knew the truth, would miraculously save any suspect who had been wrongly accused. The trick however was that a guilty person and an innocent one often respond differently to the same incentive. Typically, a guilty would choose to accept the punishment instead of sacrificing his hand. An innocent who believed in God would daringly agree for boiling water test.
www.safalniveshak.com
37
Chapter 3 - Kantian Fairness Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You In the ideal scenario, nobody really goes through the boiling water test, because the defendants are proven guilty/innocent based on their intentions only. But if nobody was ever made to go through the boiling water test in front of the crowd, the trick will lose its effectiveness. People need to at least see some defendants suffering the boiling water torture to believe in the authenticity of the test. Which means some innocent people will have to go through the torture and it would be unfair to them. In order to keep the sanity and order in society few innocents will end up being victim of unfair play. In other words, to make an omelet you need to break some eggs.
In Investing One of the ways this bias comes into play in investing is when people expect that they should make the money in the same way they lost it, i.e., they focus on individual stocks to make money for them. Of course, that’s what the idea is when you choose the stock to begin with. But expecting fairness in returns from the stock is a fallacy. Instead, you should make sure that you don’t lose money overall on your portfolio of stocks. No matter how much margin of safety and rigorous analysis you employ, you are bound to find (time to time) few losers in your portfolio. A natural reaction is to say, “It’s not fair. I have put in so much effort, analysis and money in this stock. It shouldn’t lose money.” Being aware of Kantian Fairness Tendency can save you some unwanted heartache. Now consider, for instance, a company that has historically paid good dividends to shareholders. As time goes on, if the company continues to grow and perform well, shareholders may rightly expect that their dividend should grow, too. But what if it doesn’t? What if something changes, maybe a slowdown in growth, or pressure on cash
www.safalniveshak.com
38
Chapter 3 - Kantian Fairness Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You flows? And what if the company decides to cut back on dividends to preserve cash for future expansion? See what happened when Hawkins Cookers cut its dividend from Rs. 60 per share in FY14 to Rs. 45 in FY15 due to slowdown in growth and pressure on cash flows. “It’s unfair! We paid 60X for this.” People who invested in this stock cried. And, when a lot of investors start singing the unfair song, this is what happens to the stock –
On the surface, this may seem fair on the part of the management, who wants to protect precious cash that would help them tide over the immediate slowdown in business. And given the management of Hawkins, it surely seems to be thinking long term. But to most people who bought the stock with unfair expectations, it’s the management and the business that now looks unfair to them!
Conclusion Life isn’t fair, but many can’t accept this. Tolerating a little unfairness should be okay if it means a greater fairness for all. But ‘what is truly fair for all’ isn’t an easy question to answer.
www.safalniveshak.com
39
Chapter 3 - Kantian Fairness Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You
Some of my thoughts in this chapter have been a result of my speculation about the utility of Kantian Fairness Tendency. There is a non-zero possibility that my arguments and conclusions are flawed, so instead of taking them at face value, please consider them as starting points to stimulate your own independent thought process.
www.safalniveshak.com
40
Chapter 4 Contrast-Misreaction Tendency Let me introduce you to my friend, Mr. Irrational. He is a figment of my imagination, inspired by Benjamin Graham’s Mr. Market. One fine day, it so happened that Mr. Irrational was trying on suits in front of a shop’s three-sided mirror. The men’s tailor shop was owned by Sid and Harry. The younger brother, Harry, being less experienced, was sitting at the back of the room with all the design catalogues and price list. Sid, elder brother and the chief tailor, who seemed to have hearing problems, was helping Mr. Irrational make a choice. “How does this one look?” asked Mr. Irrational. He liked the dark grey colour but wasn’t sure about the woolen texture of the suit. “Pardon me Sir. Can you please speak up little louder?” This was the third time that Sid had requested his patron to speak louder. “I am asking how does this suit look on me?” Mr. Irrational raised his voice. The extra decibels came with a hint of irritation. After all my friend is a soft spoken guy and shouting is considered rude in his family. “Aha! You’re looking fabulous in this one sir! Nothing less than a business tycoon.” Sid’s artificial smile bundled with a fake compliment proved that he was a skillful salesman. “How much does this one cost?” Mr. Irrational asked loudly. He didn’t want to repeat his sentence.
www.safalniveshak.com
41
Chapter 4 - Contrast-Misreaction Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You “This one sir? Let me check.” said Sid. He turned towards Harry and shouted at the top of his voice, “Harry, how much for this suit?” Looking up from his work – Harry called back, “For that beautiful all-wool suit, nine thousand rupees.” At this point, Sid turned to Mr. Irrational and reported, “He says five thousand rupees.” Curbing his instincts to correct Sid, Mr. Irrational realized that Sid’s hearing problem had just thrown up an opportunity to grab a nine thousand suit for five thousand. Without even giving a second thought, he hurriedly paid five thousand to Sid and scrambled out of the shop with his “expensive means good” bargain before poor Sid could discover the “mistake”. My question to you is this – do you think Mr. Irrational exploited Sid’s disability? What if I told you that there is a twist in the tale? What if Sid didn’t really have a hearing problem? As it turned out that it was an elaborate scam and Mr. Irrational was manipulated. Sid and Harry knew something important about human behaviour: humans rarely choose things in absolute terms. We don’t have an internal value meter that tells us how much things are worth. Rather, we focus on the relative advantage of one thing over another, and estimate value accordingly. This human behavioural bias is called Contrast-Misreaction Tendency.
Contrast-Misreaction Tendency (CMT) I’ll take Charlie Munger’s help in defining this behavioural anomaly. He writes -
www.safalniveshak.com
42
Chapter 4 - Contrast-Misreaction Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You .. human nervous system can’t naturally measure in absolute scientific units; it must instead rely on something simpler. The eyes have a solution that limits their programming needs: the contrast in what is seen is registered. And as in sight, so does it go, largely, in the other sense. Moreover, as perception goes, so goes cognition. The result is man’s Contrast-Misreaction Tendency. In the image here, the two inner rectangles are exactly the same shade of grey, but the right one appears to be a lighter grey than the left one due to the background provided by the outer rectangles. It’s the result of contrast effect.
Image Source: Wikipedia. Mr. Irrational, who was uninformed about suit business, had no clue about the value of the suit until he heard from Harry, who shouted “nine thousand rupees”. In that moment Harry had deliberately planted a price anchor in his customer’s mind. The very next moment, when Sid said “five thousand rupees”, Mr. Irrational found the suit cheap in contrast to price anchor.
www.safalniveshak.com
43
Chapter 4 - Contrast-Misreaction Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You Sid and Harry made their money even as the customer thought he got a ‘great’ deal! Unfortunately, almost every one of us, knowingly or unknowingly, has fallen for such scams in our lives. Peter Bevelin describes the idea eloquently in his book Seeking Wisdom – We judge stimuli by differences and changes and not absolute magnitudes. For example, we evaluate stimuli like temperature, loudness, brightness, health, status, or prices based on their contrast or difference from a reference point (the prior or concurrent stimuli or what we have become used to). This reference point changes with new experiences and context…. This means that how we value things depend on what we compare them with. If Mr. Irrational looked like a sitting duck, then let me warn you that Sid and Harry aren’t the only ones who understand the importance of CMT.
Exploiters of CMT Is it possible to influence customer’s decisions by manipulating the available options? The answer is a resounding yes. Consider this experiment where a group of people was asked to choose between $6 cash and an elegant pen. Most choose the cash. Another group of people was asked to choose between $6 cash, the elegant pen, or an inferior pen. Most choose the elegant pen. Why? By adding an inferior option, a decoy, which nobody chooses, people are subtly nudged towards the option (the elegant pen in this case) which can be compared to the inferior choice.
www.safalniveshak.com
44
Chapter 4 - Contrast-Misreaction Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You
Bevelin quotes the example of real estate where this bias is a standard tool of persuasion – Mary is looking at houses. The real estate broker knows that the house he is trying to sell Mary is in poor shape and a bad area. He starts by showing Mary bad properties in an ugly neighbourhood. Afterwards, he takes her to the house he wanted to sell all along. Suddenly this house and the area seem great in comparison to the other house she saw. The story isn’t much different when we end up buying that overpriced ₹25,000 leather accessory merely because the price is so low compared to our concurrent purchase of a ₹5 lacs car. Even when people know that this sort of customer manipulation is being attempted, it will often work to trigger buying, which demonstrates that being aware of psychological ploys is not a perfect defense. In fact the ‘predictability about our irrational behaviour’ was the premise on which Dan Ariely wrote his entertaining book, Predictably Irrational. In the following talk, Dan shows you some optical illusions to bring home the point that awareness about human biases doesn’t necessarily make you immune to them. On a lighter note, Rolf Dobelli suggests that if you are seeking a partner, never go out in the company of your supermodel friends. People will find you less attractive than you really are. Go alone or, better yet, take two ugly friends. I haven’t validated this trick, so goes without saying – “try it at your own risk!” There is another aspect of CMT which makes it very interesting. If we fail to perceive the change, due to small contrast, the mis-reaction may not trigger at all. For example, our kids grow up right in front of our eyes but we notice the change only when we look at old pictures.
www.safalniveshak.com
45
Chapter 4 - Contrast-Misreaction Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You
Contrast, the Invisible Killer Contrasts makes us blind to slow change until it’s too late. The reality around us seems pretty much constant, although it’s continuously changing. The change in a stimulus has to cross a certain threshold before our awareness can register it. It’s worth mentioning here a tremendously useful mental model called boiling frog syndrome, described by Prof Bakshi in this wonderful blog post. He explains – Small incremental changes tend to go unnoticed…If you put a frog in hot boiling water, he will instantly leap out of the pan and be never seen again. But, if you put a frog in a pan with room temperature water and slowly turn up the heat, he wouldn’t be able to tell the tiny incremental changes. He will boil and die. Charlie Munger once said that many businesses die just like the boiling frog. Cognition, misled by tiny changes involving low contrast, will often miss a trend that is destiny. He further warnsWhen a man’s steps are consecutively taken toward disaster with each step being very small, the brain’s Contrast-Misreaction Tendency will often let the man go too far toward disaster to be able to avoid it. This happens because each step presents so small a contrast from his present position. Warren Buffett says – One of the problems in society is that the most important issues are often these incremental type things…But, if you
www.safalniveshak.com
46
Chapter 4 - Contrast-Misreaction Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You keep doing it over time, the incremental problems are hard to attack because that one extra piece of pie doesn’t really seem to make a difference…but the cumulative effects of them will make a huge difference over time, just like overeating will make a huge difference over time. The time to attack those problems is early. Sometimes it is the small, gradual, invisible changes that harm us the most.
In Investing The whole idea behind systematic investment plan (SIP) is that a small outgo (as compared to the whole salary) every month from our paycheque doesn’t pinch. As we have seen contrast is a two sided sword, and its ill effects show up in investing also. Have you heard of “Big Bath” accounting? For the uninitiated it’s an accounting jugglery to “manage” a company’s earnings. Sometimes, to fool the shareholders, a particular year’s poor income statement is made to look even worse by increasing expenses and selling assets. As a result, the subsequent years, especially the very next, appear much better in contrast. Satyam’s case is another example which shows how big accounting scams are created. Here is what Ramalinga Raju’s aides at Satyam must have told him before the scam came to light – “If we slowly and gradually over time manipulate the numbers, the auditors won’t notice it.” You see, contrasts may blind us to change until it’s too late. For example, we often don’t notice the bad behaviour of others (like we ignore “small” accounting manipulations at companies) if it goes sour gradually over time. Often we see reality as constant, although it gradually changes.
www.safalniveshak.com
47
Chapter 4 - Contrast-Misreaction Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You
Similarly, we fail to notice how our money disappears. It constantly loses its value, but we do not notice because inflation happens over time. If it were imposed on us in the form of a brutal tax (and basically that’s what it is), we would be outraged. Another area where CMT can harm is our fixation on the stock price. When you are analysing a business, it becomes extremely hard to overcome the temptation to ignore the past stock price trends. If a stock has risen recently, our subconscious screams that the stock has become expensive. A recent fall in price triggers the CMT which convinces us that the stock has become cheaper. My advice? Don’t look at the stock price until you have analysed the business and worked out some valuation. For that matter, if you can’t avoid price based screeners, use them carefully.
Conclusion Understand that CMT is everywhere, and that we view our world through its lens – rose coloured or otherwise. Few psychological tendencies do more damage to rational thinking than CMT. Warren Buffett was probably referring to contrast bias when he said – Chains of habit are too light to be felt until they are too heavy to be broken. It’s interesting that most bad habits are formed because of this tendency but fortunately this bias, if used intelligently, can help us form good habits too. John Wooden, one of the most successful coaches in the history of basketball, observed – When you improve a little each day, eventually big things occur … Don’t look for big, quick improvement. Seek the
www.safalniveshak.com
48
Chapter 4 - Contrast-Misreaction Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You small improvement one day at a time. That’s the only way it happens and when it happens, it lasts. I wanted to tell my friend, Mr. Irrational, that he was taken for a ride by his tailors but then I thought to myself, “Let me keep the poor kid happy.” After all he still believes that he stole a great bargain. But you don’t forget to include CMT in your mental model checklist. And at the same time don’t forget to make use of it for creating good habits. PS: The tailor shop example was taken from Robert Cialdini’s book . Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion
www.safalniveshak.com
49
Chapter 5 Deprival Super Reaction Tendency In Chapter 2 when we discussed the Variable Reinforcement mental model, there was a brief mention about casino slot machines. Let me pull out that text for you – Now that we are talking about slot machines, it’s worth mentioning another extremely intelligent aspect of slot machine
design
called calibrated
near
misses, which
exploits another behavioural quirk called Deprival Super Reaction Tendency. Those calibrated near misses is going to be subject of investigation in this chapter. If you buy a ticket for the lottery that has the number 49 on it and the number 48 is drawn, you think, “I was so close…” BUT were you really? No you weren’t. If you have read the basics of statistics, you would know that the numbers in lottery are supposed to be random and the probability of each number is ideally same. So you weren’t anymore closer (or farther) from winning as you would have been if the number you got was 1. However, that’s not how the gambling systems are designed. In casinos, some slot machines receive better results (for the casino owner, not the gambler) than other machines based on the same payouts, same locations, same design, etc. How come? The difference between the two slot machines is this – even though the overall probability of winning or losing is the same in both, one machine has a lot more “near
www.safalniveshak.com
50
Chapter 5 - Deprival Super Reaction Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You misses” than the other one. This keeps gamblers hooked because it makes them think, “Oh! I was so close to winning. How could I miss it. Let me try again.” The gambler tends to play more, which translates into more collections for the casino from the “doctored” machine. Psychology of the near miss is particularly well known in the casino industry. The “near miss” potential is very reinforcing and makes people want to try again. In fact, gaming commissions, the regulatory bodies which control the casinos, are aware about this irregularity and they even allow slot machines to have unusually large number of “near misses” calibrated in the design. Here’s another interesting video where a slot machine designer explains how intelligent design and human psychology is used to make the activity an addiction. Now, why am I talking about gambling and slot machines? Because I want to tell you about …
Deprival Super Reaction Tendency This irrational response to “near miss” or “almost there” is what Charlie Munger has dubbed as “Deprival Super Reaction Tendency”. It’s another super critical mental model from the field of psychology. Let’s use the acronym DSRT because it saves screen space, computer memory, internet congestion, and my keyboard strokes. Another reason for using acronym is that it creates an impression in reader’s mind that the author is smart. You can call DSRT a flavour of loss aversion bias, which states that the quantity of man’s pleasure from a ten-rupee gain is significantly lower than the quantity of his displeasure from a ten-rupee loss. However, the irrational reaction to loss in this scenario (taking away the almost possessed reward) is little more intense.
www.safalniveshak.com
51
Chapter 5 - Deprival Super Reaction Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You
Image Source: Dilbert.com Peter Kaufman writes in Poor Charlie’s Almanack – If a man almost gets something he greatly wants and has it jerked away from him at the last moment, he will react much as if he had long owned the reward and had it jerked away. I include the natural human reactions to both kinds of loss experience – the loss of the possessed reward and the loss of the almost-possessed reward – under one description, Deprival Super Reaction Tendency. It’s no wonder that this tendency isn’t just limited to humans. Evolution has ingrained this anomaly in animals also. Kaufman adds – The Mungers once owned a tame and good-natured dog…There was only one way to get bitten by this dog. And that was to try and take some food away from him after he already had it in his mouth. If you did that, this friendly dog would automatically bite. He couldn’t help it. Nothing could be more stupid than for the dog to bite his master. But the dog couldn’t help being foolish…He had an automatic Deprival-Superreaction tendency in his nature. You should read about Prof. Sanjay Bakshi’s tryst with DSRT, in his own words.
www.safalniveshak.com
52
Chapter 5 - Deprival Super Reaction Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You
DSRT in Real World It’s not just money that triggers the DSRT. Taking away people’s freedom, status, love, friendship, opportunity, dominated territory or anything they value will results in DSRT. Charlie Munger explains – Deprival-Superreaction
Tendency
often
protects
ideological or religious views by triggering dislike and hatred directed toward vocal non-believers…because the ideas of nonbelievers, if they spread, will diminish the influence of views that are now supported by a comfortable environment
including
a
strong
belief-maintenance
system…University liberal arts departments, law schools, and business organizations all display plenty of such ideology-based
groupthink
that
rejects
almost
all
conflicting inputs. Centuries ago, DSRT was so strong that it wasn’t uncommon to subject the heretics to extreme torture and brutal death. Coca Cola, one of the most celebrated and profitable brands in the world, was almost brought down to its knees by DSRT. In 1985, they launched a ‘New Coke’ which had different taste from the original Coke. The response was something they didn’t expect at all. Coke was a birthright that everyone, from farmers to presidents enjoyed, together, and had for generations. Consumers felt that something had been taken away from them and replaced with something they didn’t ask for and didn’t like. The ‘New Coke’ was a colossal failure. Coca Cola had to recall the new product and immediately bring back the original Coke.
www.safalniveshak.com
53
Chapter 5 - Deprival Super Reaction Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You Don’t underestimate the power of DSRT!
DSRT and Lollapalooza One of the places where DSRT has ghastly effects is open-outcry auctions. Social psychology experiments show that bidders in auctions often get carried away and end up bidding far more than underlying value of the objects being auctioned. Such outcomes are almost always caused by a combination of multiple forces working in the same direction. In auctions, these include greed, envy, bias from commitment (every bid is a public endorsement of the bidder’s belief that value exceeds his bid), social proof (last price from another bidder was reasonable), low contrast (every successive bid is only a tiny increment over the previous one), and DSRT. So the best antidote to saving yourself from auctions is Warren Buffett’s advice – “Don’t go.” And Charlie Munger says in his Psychology of Human Misjudgment lecture – …the open-outcry auction is just made to turn the brain into mush: you’ve got social proof, the other guy is bidding, you get reciprocation tendency, you get deprival superreaction syndrome, the thing is going away… I mean it just absolutely is designed to manipulate people into idiotic behavior. Another area where DSRT, along with other behavioural biases, creates lollapalooza is the field of negotiations. In labour negotiations, the last thing negotiators want is the proposal to reduce wages. That’s because such decisions receive a disproportionately intense reaction from the unions due to DSRT triggered by the threat to take away something (wages, benefits etc.).
www.safalniveshak.com
54
Chapter 5 - Deprival Super Reaction Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You Many corporate salary structures include sign-on bonus (or retention bonus) which is given upfront with the condition that it will be recovered in case the employee leaves the organisation early. That’s a neat trick to exploit DSRT to keep the employees from quitting early. In fact, persuasion experts (salespeople and marketing professionals) know it very well that the easiest way to convince people is to take their focus on what they will lose rather than what they might gain if they don’t use the promoted product/service.
In Investing Peter Bevelin writes in his book Seeking Wisdom – We hate to admit we’ve lost money…we hate to sell losing stocks. It is the same as admitting to others and ourselves that we’ve made a mistake. We therefore hold on to our losers too long and sell our winners too soon. A realized loss feels worse than suffering the same loss on paper. In fact, the paper loss sometime drives people to such levels of irrationality that without questioning the quality of the business they buy more and try to average down their cost. Loss-aversion combined with ego, writes Peter Bernstein in his book Against The Gods, “leads investors to gamble by clinging to their mistakes in the fond hope that someday the market will vindicate their judgment and make them whole.” Sadly, the market doesn’t know that you’re holding on to a loser and neither does the losing stock.
www.safalniveshak.com
55
Chapter 5 - Deprival Super Reaction Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You
Antidote to DSRT We’ve already seen the most effective antidote against DSRT, under specific situation of auctions, is to avoid going to such places. How do you save yourselves from the vicious design of slot machines? I suggest – “Don’t go to the casino!” But if you must, set aside a small amount of money marked as “sin money” and use that. What to do when it comes to saving ourselves from DSRT arising out of conventional thinking? How do you deal with it at personal level and at organizational level in general? Answer is – invite a “Devil’s Advocate”. Deliberately bring in able and articulate disbelievers of your ideas, people who hold contrary views. Make them your “adversarial collaborators”, a term introduced by Daniel Kahneman in his book Thinking, Fast and Slow. To avoid falling for DSRT while investing in stocks, don’t focus on your purchase price. Ask: Suppose I hadn’t made the investment; would I make this investment today at current price? Don’t throw good money after the bad money. Charlie Munger advises – People go broke that way – because they can’t stop, rethink and say, “I can afford to write this one off and live to fight again. I don’t have to pursue this thing as an obsession – in a way that will break me.” Part of what you must learn is how to handle mistakes and new facts that change the odds. Life, in part, is like a poker game, wherein you have to learn to quit sometimes when holding a much-loved hand.
www.safalniveshak.com
56
Chapter 5 - Deprival Super Reaction Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You Now you know what to do when you hear the relationship manager from your bank tells you, “You will miss a 3X return if you don’t invest in our new scheme.” Don’t panic. Remind yourself that it’s the DSRT play. Knowing that our loss aversion makes us more sensitive to information that has negative implications for us, can we make use of DSRT to create positive results for us? Here is an idea – Extending the persuasion argument about DSRT, we can motivate ourselves to adopt good habits by focusing on the information emphasizing the possible negative consequences (loss of good health, longevity) of not performing certain activities.
Conclusion From coke to dogs, from stock market to open auctions, DSRT rules our lives. It should be pretty obvious by now that DSRT plays an important role in understanding the human behaviour.
www.safalniveshak.com
57
Chapter 6 Do Something Bias Let me introduce you to another of my imaginary friend, Dr. Placebo. He runs a thriving medical practice. In his clinic you’ll find a very interesting quote, uttered by famous scientist Blaise Pascal, displayed in the patient waiting area – All of humanity’s problems stem from man’s inability to sit quietly in a room alone. He hopes that his waiting patients learn something from this deep thought. Little does he realize that, more than his patients, he is the one who needs to meditate over Pascal’s quote. Before you lose your patience allow me to hold your attention for few more seconds. All that I have said above is quite related to our mental model – Do Something Bias. In case it sounds too simple a name for a mental model, there is another term which I learnt from Nassim Taleb and it’s called ‘Naive Intervention’. If that sounds too jargon-ish then how about ADHD?
ADHD I am sure many of you know few friends who are so restless that they find it impossible to sit at one place quietly. They have very short attention span and can’t stay with one activity for long. In medical science this abnormality is known as ADHD (Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder). What medical science doesn’t tell you explicitly that evolution (yeah, the same process which transformed monkeys into humans) has installed the seeds of ADHD in every human brain.
www.safalniveshak.com
58
Chapter 6 - Do Something Bias | Mental Models, Investing, And You
A survey in US revealed that the average holding period of a stock is 22 seconds. Pretty close to the attention span of a 5-year-old. Now in some cases this tendency is more pronounced and for few, with very severe symptoms of ADHD, may actually need medical treatment but for the rest of us this disorder manifests very subtly in our day to day decision making. In an attempt to be efficient and productive we force ourselves to always stay busy with some task or other. Not being occupied gives the impression that we are incompetent and wasteful. But sometimes, quite often actually, too much activity becomes counterproductive. In psychology this flavour of ADHD is known as Do Something Bias (DSB). 19th Century American writer Henry David Thoreau said – It is not enough to be busy; so are the ants. The question is: What are we busy about?’ Don’t confuse activity with results. There is no reason to do a good job with something you shouldn’t do in the first place. DSB is not only wasteful but can harm you in the long term. Ironically, even medical profession isn’t immune to the ill effects of DSB. In medical terms this is called Iatrogenic, which means causing unintentional harm while trying
www.safalniveshak.com
59
Chapter 6 - Do Something Bias | Mental Models, Investing, And You to help. Nassim Taleb has extensively discussed this topic in his book Antifragile. Here is an excerpt from the book – Consider this need to do-something through an illustrative example. In the 1930s, 389 children were presented to New York City doctors; 174 of them were recommended tonsillectomies [surgically removing the tonsil, a small bell shaped piece of organ hanging inside your throat]. The remaining 215 children were again presented to doctors, and 99 were said to need the surgery. When the remaining 116 children were shown to yet a third set of doctors, 52 were recommended the surgery…note that a death occurs in about every 15000 such operations … every child who undergoes an unnecessary operation has a shortening of her life expectancy… When you medicate a child for an imagined or invented psychiatric disease, say, ADHD or depression, instead of letting him out of the cage, the long-term harm is largely unaccounted for. You can routinely find Dr. Placebo prescribing heavy doses of antibiotics for a minor seasonal cold. Most of these strong antibiotic drugs are hepatotoxic i.e. causing damage to liver. In short they expedite the recovery from flu but the liver damage isn’t visible immediately. Why doesn’t he just send his patients back home with only an instruction to take rest and allow the body’s natural healing system to cure the minor cold? Taleb explains – …the doctor who refrains from operating on a back (a very expensive surgery), instead giving it a chance to heal itself, will not be rewarded and judged as favourably as the doctor who makes the surgery look indispensable, then brings
www.safalniveshak.com
60
Chapter 6 - Do Something Bias | Mental Models, Investing, And You relief to the patient while exposing him to operating risks, while accruing great financial rewards to himself. Obviously it’s not just the medical profession which is plagued with DSB. James Montier, in his book The Little Book Of Behavioral Investing, explains the prevalence of this psychological bias in the field of soccer. During penalty kicks, 94% or the times the goal keepers either dive towards their left or towards their right. However, if they stay at the center their success rate is far higher. Explanation offered by these goalkeepers was that at least they feel they are making an effort when they dive left or right, whereas standing in the center and watching a goal scored to the left or the right of you would feel much worse. The idea of DSB originates from the human urge to say “Look what I did for you” than “Look what I avoided for you”. This is closely related to the concept of silent evidence that we discussed in the first issue of Value Investing Almanack (the first issue is freely downloadable). My fears came true when I prodded Dr. Placebo little more about this – Anshul: Doctor, don’t you know that most of these flu cases don’t need medical intervention? And these strong doses of antibiotics that you prescribe have long term harmful effects. Dr. Placebo: Yes, Anshul. You’re right. But if I don’t prescribe any medicine to my patients they feel I haven’t done anything to help them. Why would they pay a hefty fee for doing nothing? Moreover, prescribing these medicines have psychological effect also. Just because they are popping a pill makes them believe that they are getting better. Placebo effect you know! (smiling sheepishly)
www.safalniveshak.com
61
Chapter 6 - Do Something Bias | Mental Models, Investing, And You
Anshul: In that case you could actually prescribe them placebos. You don’t need to stuff them with toxic drugs. Dr. Placebo: People are smart these days. Even before buying the drug they pull out their smart phones and google about the drug. If they find that I am prescribing them simple placebos they might stop coming to me or worse they might even file a malpractice lawsuit against me. Can you see my predicament? Even though this is an imagined conversation, Dr. Placebo has a point here. Just like the Soccer situation, this is a classic lollapalooza created by incentive caused bias and DSB. In case you haven’t heard of the term lollapalooza, you must read Poor Charlie’s Almanack. One of the culprits for triggering DSB in human mind is the overload of information. Has it ever happened that you opened the front page of the leading financial newspaper and it said “Nothing significant happened today”. For that matter majority of news (financial or non-financial) is toxic. You don’t believe me? Check out Rolf Dobelli’s article on why you shouldn’t read news.
In Business and Investing Let’s turn to the field of finance and see how this behavioural model explains certain peculiarities present in the markets. The market ups and downs are natural economic cycles (very similar to a living organism whose pulse is not a straight line) and it’s the natural way of maintaining a dynamic equilibrium (supply and demand). Any human intervention (faulty government policies to bail out failing banks or printing excess money) to iron out
www.safalniveshak.com
62
Chapter 6 - Do Something Bias | Mental Models, Investing, And You these natural cycles only seems to help in the short run. In the long run these actions actually build up a bigger bubble and results in severe devastating markets crashes. Any small fluctuation in the markets/economies creates an urge in policy maker’s mind to do something about it. This itch to DSB (instead of giving market some time to self-correct) creates unintended consequences by blowing up the severity of original boom and bust cycles. Short term fluctuations in the stock prices is a noise that you are supposed to ignore. If you start reacting to every small portfolio fluctuations and churn your portfolio frequently, in the long run your performance will be poor. Another interesting property of DSB is that the urge to act tends to intensify after a loss (a period of poor portfolio performance). So if your portfolio hasn’t performed well for some time (short term), it’s very difficult to sit and do nothing about it. This is when you need to be alert and be aware of your vulnerability. Similarly, if you have cash but no opportunity available (a common problem for value investors during bull market), you need to practice patience and remind yourself of ill effects of DSB. Warren Buffett says – Holding cash is uncomfortable, but not as uncomfortable as doing something stupid. This video aptly captures the idea. Making too many decisions also introduces something called decision fatigue. The more decisions you have to make lower the quality of each decision. Too many decisions and over activity increase the odds of failure especially in stock market investing.
www.safalniveshak.com
63
Chapter 6 - Do Something Bias | Mental Models, Investing, And You
How to Overcome DSB So how do you deal with this bias? The cure for this irrational behaviour is patience. Let’s look at a role model in the field of professional sports (after all we are aiming to become multidisciplinary thinkers) who has successfully overcome this behavioural bias. Even if you aren’t a big cricket fan you must be familiar with Rahul Dravid and his batting style. He is known to be the most patient batsman. Instead of swinging his bat at every ball he would patiently wait for the right one, a ball which is well inside his circle of competence (remember those perfectly executed cover drives). That’s what made him one of the most consistent batsman in cricket history. Scoring 5 double centuries in test cricket isn’t a joke. So what does it mean for you when it comes to stock market investing? Does it mean that you should close your eyes and stop looking for ideas? Not really. It definitely doesn’t mean that you should stop reading annual reports. It means that instead of trying to score a six on every ball, if you can patiently wait for the right stock to appear at the right price, you too can become “the wall” in stock market investing. I know sitting on the sidetracks and waiting is boring but I hope you understand that investing is a serious game and its purpose is not entertainment. As legendary investor Seth Klarman puts it: In a world in which most investors appear interested in figuring out how to make money every second and chase the idea du jour, there’s also something validating about the message that it’s okay to do nothing and wait for opportunities to present themselves or to pay off. That’s
www.safalniveshak.com
64
Chapter 6 - Do Something Bias | Mental Models, Investing, And You lonely and contrary a lot of the time, but reminding yourself that that’s what it takes is quite helpful. What it means is that while making any decision or taking any action, you should question yourself whether your decision is backed by sound reasons and analysis or it is just an excuse to satisfy the itch to do something. S. Pulavarti, who manages the $ 1.5 billion UCLA endowment fund says – It’s like you are in jungle with a gun which has only 5 bullets. If you are told that there is tiger in the jungle, you will be very careful about when to pull the trigger. It’s the same with investments.
Conclusion I will close this discussion with a quote from Warren Buffett – I could improve your ultimate financial welfare by giving you a ticket with only twenty slots in it so that you had twenty punches – representing all the investments that you got to make in a lifetime. And once you’d punched through the card, you couldn’t make any more investments at all. Under those rules, you’d really think carefully about what you did, and you’d be forced to load up on what you’d really thought about. So you’d do so much better.
www.safalniveshak.com
65
Chapter 7 Pavlovian Conditioning Last month I decided to pay a visit to my friend Dr. Placebo in his clinic. It was a Friday and for some strange reason people are too happy to fall sick on a Friday. So it was a relatively less busy day for my doctor friend. I wasn’t sick as such but I like to catch up with Dr. Placebo once in a while. He has helped me in thinking about important mental models including Do Something Bias (Chapter 6) and Mean Reversion (Chapter 19). So I was hoping that a chit chat with him will again nudge me to some fresh insights. I wasn’t wrong. “So doc! Tell me something ironical about your profession?”, I asked him thinking that a question like that could take the conversation to an interesting direction. “The biggest irony of being a physician is that many people don’t really need doctor’s help. Many a times, my prescription is effective because people believe in them. Their belief in my treatment is what cures them.” He continued, “Sometimes just the fact that a doctor or nurse is paying attention to us and reassuring us not only makes us feel better but also triggers our internal healing processes. In many cases they would benefit just by popping a sugar pill. And it’s a proven fact also known as Placebo Effect.” “I see. That kind of explains your strange name.”, I winked thinking that he wouldn’t mind a friendly tease. “Don’t get me started on the origins of my name. But you should read about Pavlovian Conditioning. Now if you please excuse me, I have to leave now. It’s Friday and I have plans.”, saying this he got up from his chair and started leaving.
www.safalniveshak.com
66
Chapter 7 - Pavlovian Conditioning | Mental Models, Investing, And You I think I had offended him by joking about his name. Moreover, he had already given me more time than what he usually gives to his fee paying patients. But the visit had good payoff for me because it led to me to discover an important mental model – Pavlovian Conditioning - which is sometimes referred to as classical conditioning. Based on my readings about Charlie Munger, I can say that one of his favorite mental model from psychology is Pavlovian Conditioning. It’s one of those topics which has appeared multiple times in many of Charlie’s speeches. So what is Pavlovian Conditioning? It’s a behavioural trait which was first discovered by a Russian scientist named Ian Pavlov. In Seeking Wisdom, Peter Bevelin describes Pavlov’s experiment – The Russian scientist Ivan Pavlov studied the digestive system of dogs when he observed that a stimulus unrelated to food made the dogs salivate. In one experiment he rang a bell just before giving food to the dog. He repeated this several times until the dog salivated at the sound of the bell alone. No sight or smell of food was present. The sound of the bell produced the same response as the food. The dog learned to associate the bell with food. I realize that I’m not much different from Pavlov’s dog. Every time I order a pizza, I start drooling when the doorbell rings. I wonder if it’s Pavlov standing on the other side of the door holding a notebook instead of a hot pizza. The conditioning also works to trigger negative emotions like fear. Bevelin adds – Experiments have shown that we can learn to fear a harmless stimulus if it is paired with an unpleasant one. If
www.safalniveshak.com
67
Chapter 7 - Pavlovian Conditioning | Mental Models, Investing, And You for example rats consistently receive mild electrical shock after hearing a tone, the rats learn to develop a fear of the tone alone.
A Manipulation Tool In his seminal work, Influence – Psychology of Persuasion, Robert Cialdini talks about his friend who was having trouble selling a certain kind of turquoise jewelry. In spite of trying all sales tricks and marketing gimmicks she couldn’t move the sales. One fine day her staff, by mistake, changed the price tags for those turquoise pieces to double the original price. To their surprise, because of this increased price, the stock was sold out in a day. How do you explain this strange behaviour from her customers? Well, Pavlov just told us. The customers, with little knowledge of turquoise, were conditioned to associate high price with high value. These were the people who had been brought up on the rule “You get what you pay for”. Their conditioning led them to mistake the high price (bell) for quality (food) and they swooped down(salivated). There is one place in the world where Pavlov is secretly revered like a god. Can you guess? It’s Las Vegas and for that matter any casino in the world. Casino operators probably use almost every kind of behavioural trick to keep the gamblers longer inside the casino because they know that the longer the game continues, the larger the bets. Large rooms, noisy and flashy machines, sounds of spilling coins, hubbubs of crowds, and entertaining music, along with the smells of free food, drinks and perfume, provide the essential Pavlovian vibes to encourage gamblers to stay with their games for as long as possible.
www.safalniveshak.com
68
Chapter 7 - Pavlovian Conditioning | Mental Models, Investing, And You The slot machines in the casinos exploit yet another behavioural bias called Variable Reinforcement (Chapter 2), which is another form of conditioning, also known as Operant Conditioning(OC). In Pavlovian conditioning the response(salivation) is involuntary whereas in OC it’s a conscious decision on the part of subject. Like a rat falsely associating a lever press with supply of food and keeps pressing the lever endlessly.
In Business In 1996 Charlie Munger delivered a talk titled Practical Thought on Practical Thought. In this talk he used the example of Coca-Cola’s business model and explained how Pavlovian association lies at the heart of coke’s strategy. Charlie explains – The neural system of Pavlov’s dog causes it to salivate at the bell it can’t eat. And the brain of man yearns for the type of beverage held by the pretty woman he can’t have. …we must use every sort of decent, honorable Pavlovian conditioning we can think of. For as long as we are in business, our beverage and its promotion must be associated in consumer minds with all other things consumers like or admire. For decades, Coke’s strategy has been to create a strong association between its drink and ‘happiness’ in the consumer’s mind. And it’s not just Coke but a large part of modern advertising industry has relied on Pavlovian Conditioning. There is another interesting manifestation of this bias in the world of business, also known as “Persian Messenger Syndrome”. Here is an excerpt from Charlie’s talk on The Psychology Of Human Misjudgment –
www.safalniveshak.com
69
Chapter 7 - Pavlovian Conditioning | Mental Models, Investing, And You Some of the most important miscalculations come from what is accidentally associated with one’s past success, or one’s liking and loving, or one’s disliking and hating, which includes a natural hatred for bad news…Ancient Persians actually killed some messengers whose sole fault was that the brought home truthful bad news, say, of a battle lost… [this tendency] is alive and well in modern life, albeit in less lethal versions. It is actually dangerous in many careers to be a carrier of unwelcome news. Charlie uses the example of CBS (as warning) and explains how this problem is tackled in Berkshire – Chairman Paley (at CBS) was hostile to people who brought him bad news. The result was that Paley lived in a cocoon of unreality, from which he made one bad deal after another, even exchanging a large share of CBS for a company that had to be liquidated shortly thereafter…. At Berkshire, there is a common injunction: Always tell the bad news promptly. It is only the good news that can wait. It also helps to be so wise and informed that people fear not telling you bad news because you are so likely to get it elsewhere. Charlie Munger has his own nomenclature for most of these biases including Pavlovian Conditioning which he calls Influence by Mere Association.
In Investing One of the ways Pavlovian Conditioning shows its effect in investing is when investors start associating indexes to be the true and accurate representation of the whole
www.safalniveshak.com
70
Chapter 7 - Pavlovian Conditioning | Mental Models, Investing, And You economy. Remember the indexes don’t necessarily reflect the whole world of stocks. It’s just a collection of few companies based on their market capitalization. When the Sensex falls (akin to Pavlov ringing the bell), it triggers a conditioned response (panic or fear akin to salivation) in investors and without even investigating the business fundamentals of the stocks in their portfolio they start selling. Another interesting implication of classical conditioning is a tendency to classify businesses as stereotypes. In his lecture in Google campus, Professor Sanjay Bakshi explained how hostile stereotyping by Mr. Market can have wonderful consequences for the value investor.
Exploiting Pavlovian Conditioning So far our discussion has hovered around unintended and mostly undesired outcomes of pavlovian conditioning. In the spirit of inversion let’s see if we can exploit this behavioural quirk for our benefit. Awareness about classical conditioning can be very useful for creating good habits or breaking bad habits. Once you can identify the cue which triggers the associated conditioned response you can easily break the routine and replace the bad habit with a good one. Charles Duhigg, author of Power of Habits, explains this idea brilliantly in this video.
Conclusion I suspect that towards the end of his research, Mr. Pavlov was probably getting manipulated by his dogs. My suspicion was later confirmed by this image which I found on the internet.
www.safalniveshak.com
71
Chapter 7 - Pavlovian Conditioning | Mental Models, Investing, And You
Image Source: Google. Just kidding!
www.safalniveshak.com
72
Chapter 8 Framing Effect “Is it okay to smoke a cigarette while praying to God?” a young man asked his father. “Of course it’s bad. It’s a great sin and very disrespectful act,” the father replied. Being a religious man, he seemed deeply disturbed with his son’s atrocious question. “But last time you told me that to get rid of my addiction I should start praying while smoking. Didn’t you say that?” It seemed to him that his father was contradicting himself. “No my son! Don’t confuse smoking-while-praying with praying-while-smoking,” the father explained. “But what’s the difference?” the son was perplexed. “There is a difference. A huge difference. I don’t know what but my brain tells me that there is.” Now before we get started on a debate about the validity of father’s argument, let me clarify that the reason I brought up this anecdote was to highlight an important mental bias which plays out in our affairs very subtly. In fact someone made a TV commercial on the same line of thought and I found it very amusing. The way you frame the options is very important. How a message is communicated affects the way it is received. Framing has strong implications on our behaviour. Even
www.safalniveshak.com
73
Chapter 8 - Framing Effect | Mental Models, Investing, And You small and seemingly inconsequential changes in the wordings of a problem can result in large changes of preferences. In his book, The Art of Thinking Clearly, Rolf Dobelli writes – Glossing is a popular type of framing. Under its rules, a tumbling share price becomes ‘correction’. An overpaid acquisition
price
is
branded
‘goodwill’.
In
every
management course, a problem magically transforms into an ‘opportunity’ or a ‘challenge’. A person who is fired is ‘reassessing his career’. A fallen soldier – regardless of how much bad luck or stupidity led to his death – turns into a ‘war hero’. Genocide translates to ‘ethnic cleansing’. Now, it may just seem an intelligent play of words. And one might be tempted to explain this human behaviour by a simple logic – different words arouse different level of emotional response. But if you stop there, you’re going to miss a very critical idea here. There is more juice than meets the eye. It turns out that Framing is a cognitive bias and hence a very important mental model from psychology. It says people react differently to a particular choice depending on whether, and especially when, it is presented as a loss or as a gain. We find “99% fat free” food products enticing but if the same message says “contains 1% fat”, it would trigger a different response from us. Just by rearranging the available set of options, people can be nudged to opt for a specific choice. It’s not only a clever marketing trick to sell products but it can effectively be used by policy makers to increase compliance and even for improving our relationships. In case you want to dig deeper on this, Richard Thaler has written a book called Nudge, which primarily deals with the subject of choice architectures.
www.safalniveshak.com
74
Chapter 8 - Framing Effect | Mental Models, Investing, And You What scientists and psychologists have found is that people tend to avoid risk when a positive frame is presented but seek risks when a negative frame is presented. Gain and loss are defined in the scenario as descriptions of outcomes (e.g. lives lost or saved, disease patients treated and not treated, lives saved and lost during accidents, etc.).
Framing and Loss Aversion Framing is an outcome of our aversion to losses. Evolution has programmed our brain to seek loss minimization instead of gain maximizing. As a result, our brains, subconsciously, are always choosing the path of least pain. Let’s assume that there is a way to quantify or measure the human emotions of pain or pleasure and let’s say the units for that measure is ‘Aha’. So, ideally, loss of say Rs 100 should give you a pain of 10 Ahas and gain of Rs 100 will fetch you a pleasure of 10 Ahas. Right? Not really! The fact of the matter is that the pain of losing Rs 100 is little more, something like 15 Ahas. Daniel Kahneman, in his book Thinking, Fast and Slow, describes an experiment – We introduced our discussion of framing by an example that has become known as the “Asian disease problem”: Imagine that the United States is preparing for the outbreak of an unusual Asian disease, which is expected to kill 600 people. Two alternative programs to combat the disease have been proposed. Assume that the exact scientific estimates of the consequences of the programs are as follows:
www.safalniveshak.com
75
Chapter 8 - Framing Effect | Mental Models, Investing, And You 1. If program A is adopted, 200 people will be saved. 2. If program B is adopted, there is a one-third probability that 600 people will be saved and a two-thirds probability that no people will be saved. A substantial majority of respondents choose program A: they prefer the certain option over the gamble. The outcomes of the programs are framed differently in a second version: 1. If program X is adopted, 400 people will die. 2. If program Y is adopted, there is a one-third probability that nobody will die and a two-thirds probability that 600 people will die Look
closely
and
compare
the
two
versions:
the
consequences of programs A and X are identical; so are the consequences of programs B and Y. In the second frame, however, a large majority of people choose the gamble. So we see that the way in which an uncertain possibility is presented may have a substantial effect on how people respond to it. And many a times this has serious implications. For example, when asked whether they would choose surgery in a hypothetical medical emergency, many more people said that they would when the chance of survival was given as 80 percent than when the chance of death was given as 20 percent. As you can see, it’s not the trivial matter about to-eat-or-not-to-eat that 99% fat free ice cream. It’s the matter of life and death and still people, under the spell of Framing, falter in thinking rationally.
www.safalniveshak.com
76
Chapter 8 - Framing Effect | Mental Models, Investing, And You
In Investing The problem of Framing surfaces in investor behaviour in numerous ways. Let’s look at some of them. One of the common mistakes made by early investors in stock market is to sell their winning stocks and hold on to their losers. It’s called Disposition Effect which is an instance of narrow framing. So narrow framing, a flavour of framing effect, is our inability to zoom out on the situation. This creates a faulty perspective. Instead of looking at the overall portfolio performance we look to gain from every stock. To explain this with the help of an example. Let’s say we toss a coin and offer you the following bet – 1.
On heads, you win Rs 60.
2.
On tails, you lose Rs 40.
Should you accept or reject the bet? Most people would reject it. What if you had an option to accept a series of such bets, say 100 coins tosses each with the same offer? Now it becomes an attractive proposal, because over a series of multiples tosses, the probability of head and tail is 50-50. So even if you lose money on some of the bets, your net gains are going to be much closer to the expected value of this bet i.e., Rs 10 per bet. That’s roughly the idea behind broad framing. Kahneman writes –
www.safalniveshak.com
77
Chapter 8 - Framing Effect | Mental Models, Investing, And You The combination of loss aversion and narrow framing is a costly curse. Individual investors can avoid that curse, achieving the emotional benefits of broad framing while also saving time and agony, by reducing the frequency with which they check how well their investments are doing. Closely following daily fluctuations is a losing proposition, because the pain of the frequent small losses exceeds the pleasure of the equally frequent small gains. Once a quarter is enough, and many be more than enough for individual
investors.
In
addition
to
improving
the
emotional quality of life, the deliberate avoidance of exposure to short-term outcomes improves the quality of both decisions and outcomes. So now you have another reason to get rid of your portfolio tracker.
Breaking the Frame So how do you overcome Framing? Peter Bevelin, author of the must read book, Seeking Wisdom, suggests – The answers we get depend on the questions we ask. The British philosopher Herbert Spencer said: “How often misused words generate misleading thoughts.” Consider how a statement, problem, consequence, or question is presented. How is it worded? What is its context? Are we considering certain features and ignoring others? Emotional, selective and appealing frames influence us. The second strategy is to invert the problem statement. That’s called principle of inversion (Chapter 44). By doing so, some of the things which usually remain hidden from your view, because of your intuitive brain, resurface and you get a fresh view.
www.safalniveshak.com
78
Chapter 8 - Framing Effect | Mental Models, Investing, And You Scientists have also discovered that using a foreign language reduces decision-making biases. Some experiments show that framing effect disappears when choices are presented in a foreign tongue. That probably happens because when you’re using your native language, your thinking is more intuitive. The moment you’re asked to reframe the problem in a different language, your brain comes out of the auto-pilot mode and it has to employ a deliberate mode of thinking. Kahneman calls it your system 2 – the rational, deliberate and slower mode of thinking. Other remedies include looking at the problem from different vantage points and also making provision for probabilistic thinking.
Conclusion It’s important to realize the power of framing. Even school kids are learning this trick to manipulate their unsuspecting elders. The kid knows – “It’s not what you say, it’s how you say it.”
One clear advantage of learning about framing is that you can save yourself from getting manipulated from your kids.
www.safalniveshak.com
79
Chapter 9 Status Quo Bias Do you own a smartphone? Chances are that you’re reading this on a smartphone or a tablet. One of the most interesting thing about these smartphones is that they allow you to customize everything – data usage, app synchronization, phone encryption, even how loud you want the camera shutter to sound. How many of these customization settings have you used? In my case – almost none! What has phone customization got to do with mental models? Let me explain. In Chapter 6 we discussed about Do Something Bias. It’s a cognitive bias where people get an urge to take action or make unnecessary decisions when ‘not doing anything’ is required. Now let’s turn the table, and talk about a bias which is exactly opposite of Do Something Bias. It’s called Status Quo Bias. The tendency of people where they don’t do anything and continue to maintain the current state of affairs including their smart phone’s default settings. If we could boil down this cognitive bias to a more fundamental body of knowledge, it would be Physics. I am sure you must have heard of Newton’s laws of motion. The third law of motion states – An object either remains at rest or continues to move at a constant velocity, unless acted upon by an external force.
www.safalniveshak.com
80
Chapter 9 - Status Quo Bias | Mental Models, Investing, And You This characteristic, called inertia, is exhibited by all physical bodies. And when it comes to human behaviour, this tendency manifests in the form of Status Quo Bias. Here is a very intriguing case study which Dan Ariely, author of wildly popular book Predictably Irrational, mentions in his first – This graph shows the percentage of people, across different European countries, who are willing to donate their organs after they pass away. When people see this plot and try to speculate about the cause for the differences between the countries that donate a lot (in blue) and the countries that donate little (in orange) they usually come up with “big” reasons such as religion, culture, etc.
But you will notice that pairs of similar countries have very different levels of organ donations. For example, take the following pairs of countries: Denmark and Sweden; the Netherlands and Belgium; Austria and Germany (and depending on your individual perspective France and the UK). These are countries that we usually think of as rather similar in terms of culture, religion, etc., yet their levels of organ donations are very different.
www.safalniveshak.com
81
Chapter 9 - Status Quo Bias | Mental Models, Investing, And You
So, what could explain these differences? It turns out that it is the design of the form at the DMV. In countries where the form is set as “opt-in” (check this box if you want to participate in the organ donation program) people do not check the box and as a consequence they do not become a part of the program. In countries where the form is set as “opt-out” (check this box if you don’t want to participate in the organ donation program) people also do not check the box and are automatically enrolled in the program. In both cases large proportions of people simply adopt the default option. This default effect caused by Status Quo Bias on human behaviour is so strong that a whole discipline of ‘choice architectures’ has evolved around this idea of creating intelligent default options in different policy frameworks and various human interfacing systems. If you really want to learn more about choice architecture, Nudge by Richard Thaler is an excellent book to read. Thaler writes … People have a more general tendency to stick with their current
situation…
[It]
has
been
demonstrated
in
numerous situations. Most teachers know that students tend to sit in the same seats in class, even without a seating chart. But status quo bias can occur even when the stakes are much larger, and it can get us into a lot of trouble. …Those who are in charge of circulation [magazine subscriptions business] know that when renewal is automatic, and when people have to make a phone call to cancel, the likelihood of renewal is much higher than it is
www.safalniveshak.com
82
Chapter 9 - Status Quo Bias | Mental Models, Investing, And You when people have to indicate that they actually want to continue to receive the magazine. So next time when you apply for a new credit card and later figure out that you have been enrolled for couple of unnecessary “premium services” (which you of course don’t remember opting for), then don’t be surprised because the credit card application form probably had those options selected by default and you were actually required to specifically opt out of them. That’s an intelligent albeit a manipulative practice. These very dubious tactics makes me feel that the credit card industry is largely evil. In his awesome book Seeking Wisdom, Peter Bevelin writes… We prefer to keep things the way they are. We resist change and prefer effort minimization. We favour routine behaviour over innovative behaviour. The more emotional a decision is or the more choices we have, the more we prefer the status quo. This is why we stick with our old jobs, brand of car, etc. Even in cases where the costs of switching are very low. …We are more bothered by harm that comes from action than harm that comes from inaction. We feel worse when we fail as a result of taking action than when we fail from doing nothing. We prefer the default option, i.e., the alternative that is selected automatically unless we change it.
www.safalniveshak.com
83
Chapter 9 - Status Quo Bias | Mental Models, Investing, And You Of course people don’t blindly go with the current status. It’s only when they are either confused about the options or there is an uncertainty with a decision, that they choose to stick with the current state of affairs. Shane Parrish, in his wonderful blog Farnam Street, writes What happens when people are presented with difficult choices and no obvious right answer? We tend to prefer making not decision at all-that is, we choose the norm. In high-stakes decisions many options are better than the status-quo and we must make trade-offs. Yet, when faced with decisions that involve life-and-death trade-offs, people frequently remark “I’d rather not think about it.” In other words, when faced with a complex decision, people tend to accept the status quo, as reflected in the old adage, “When in doubt, do nothing.”
Image Source: www.dilbert.com What’s the reason behind this cognitive bias? Behavioural scientists believe that Loss Aversion Bias could be the culprit here. Any kind of change in the status quo brings the possibility of disruption in your comfort zone.
www.safalniveshak.com
84
Chapter 9 - Status Quo Bias | Mental Models, Investing, And You “The present may stink, but I still don’t want to lose it,” This is how we comfort ourselves when we face a need to change.
In Investing Several investors fall in love with their stocks in the garb of “buy and hold”. So they tend to protect the status quo by inventing new reasons to hold onto a dud investment. They will remain stuck in a status quo mode because they hate to admit they’ve lost money. Talking about status quo bias in the context of making the most efficient use of capital, Warren Buffett write We are free of historical biases created by lifelong association with a given industry and are not subject to pressures from colleagues having a vested interest in maintaining status quo. That’s important: If horses had controlled investment decisions, there would be no auto industry.
Benefits of Status Quo I might have created a very negative picture about Status Quo Bias. It isn’t that bad either. It’s something which mother nature and evolution has ingrained in our psyche so it must have some purpose after all. There are some upsides to this bias too. Daniel Kahneman, in his book Thinking Fast and Slow, writes Loss aversion is a powerful conservative force that favours minimal changes from the status quo in the lives of both institutions and individuals. This conservatism helps keep
www.safalniveshak.com
85
Chapter 9 - Status Quo Bias | Mental Models, Investing, And You us stable in our neighborhood, our marriage, and our job; it is the gravitational force that holds our life together near the reference point. Nassim Taleb, in his book Antifragile, argues that Status Quo bias has been made to look unnecessarily bad and it can coexist with Do Something Bias. He writes Few understand that procrastination [possibly caused by Status
Quo
Bias]
is
our
natural
defense…I
use
procrastination as a message from my inner self and my deep evolutionary past to resist interventionism [do something bias] in my writing. Yet some psychologists and behavioural economists seem to think that procrastination is a disease to be remedied and cured. Psychologists document the opposite of interventionism, calling it the status quo bias. But it seems that the two can co-exist, interventionism and procrastination, in one’s profession (where one is supposed to do something) and in one’s personal life (the opposite). It depends on domain. It is a sociological and economic problem, one linked to norms and incentives rather than mental property. One of the ways in which Status Quo can be exploited for your benefit is to start an investment SIP. The reason SIP works is because once it’s setup people aren’t willing to take the pain of changing or stopping the SIP.
Don’t Let Status Quo Kill Your dreams Status quo bias holds a lot of relevance in how we live our lives. Most of us born in a middle-class family, and with protective parents, must have heard and experienced
www.safalniveshak.com
86
Chapter 9 - Status Quo Bias | Mental Models, Investing, And You endless stories of the dangers of being curious, standing up, standing out or breaking the tradition. Believe it or not, this bias manifests in minor things like taking the same driving route, shopping from the same old store, using the same old brands coffee, soap, toothpastes and washing powder. Deliberately building habits and consciously creating routines is a nice hack to simplify life and focus on important things but please understand that following a set pattern unconsciously could ruin the possibility of a promising future. Settling for the status quo is living for something less than God desires for us. It’s not the way you make your dreams come true. The defender of the status quo appeals to the known against the unknown, to the bird in the hand against the bird in the bush, to present possessions against future dreams, to established precedent and well-tried methods against all kinds of dangerous innovations. Dreamers have no respect for the status quo, says Steve Jobs in the famous Apple ad. May be it’s the time to question your assumptions about career, work, money and relationships. I hope you’re not running your life on autopilot mode. “Only one thing would be worse than the status quo. And that would be for the status quo to become the norm.” – Elizabeth Dole, 1999 campaign speech
Conclusion Remember that deciding to do nothing is also a decision. And the cost of doing nothing could be greater than the cost of taking an action. So how do you overcome Status Quo Bias?
www.safalniveshak.com
87
Chapter 9 - Status Quo Bias | Mental Models, Investing, And You One trick is to periodically revisit your processes and ask whether they are serving their purpose. I’ll close this with a quote from Thomas Henry Huxley, a 19th Century British biologist. He said Perhaps the most valuable result of all education is the ability to make yourself do the thing you have to do when it ought to be done whether you like it or not. It is the first lesson that ought to be learned and however early a person’s training begins, it is probably the last lesson a person learns thoroughly.
www.safalniveshak.com
88
Chapter 10 Twaddle Tendency Open any financial news channel and often you can find a so called expert being interviewed on his opinion about the direction of the stock market and health of the economy. On being asked such macro questions, the answer usually goes something like this –
Maybe the gentleman above has a point. But I just don’t see it. Do you? All I see is that his verbal diarrhea was completely useless. In most cases, the right (and honest) answer is – I don’t know.
www.safalniveshak.com
89
Chapter 10 - Twaddle Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You But how can experts not know? They are interviewed because they’re supposed to know about everything. And even if they don’t know, what is Google for? All the facts and figures are few key strokes away, so it’s a sin to not have an opinion about everything, especially if you’re considered an expert and probably being compensated by pay per word. So does it mean you are entitled to have an opinion on a subject just because you know a lot of facts and figures about it? Absolutely not! The more books I read, bigger is the realization that “I don’t know” is usually the most honest answer and also the toughest one, more so if the questions are about complex world around us. Then why is it that we find it so hard to acknowledge our ignorance? I don’t know the answer to that but my guess is that saying “I don’t know” puts the human ego at risk, and to avoid looking like fools, people end up talking something which usually is crap. That reminds me of this quote from Plato – Wise men speak because they have something to say; Fools because they have to say something. This ‘need to say something’ when one doesn’t have anything useful to say is what Charlie Munger dubs as Twaddle Tendency. The word ‘twaddle’ means a speech or writing that is silly, trivial, pretentious and not true. In other words – nonsense.
www.safalniveshak.com
90
Chapter 10 - Twaddle Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You Twaddle tendency is the smoke screen created by shallow thinkers to hide their ignorance. The unnecessary jargons and pompous language is used to disguise the intellectual laziness and half-baked ideas. Sometimes this trick works, but only for a short while. And many a times this twaddle tendency is so obvious that it’s embarrassing. Checkout this video to see how this girl made a big fool of herself. It wasn’t her ignorance about the subject but her unwillingness to say, “I don’t know” that put her into real trouble. She felt she had to say something smart so she just twaddled. Like other behavioural biases, this tendency is also tattooed deep into human behaviour and probably evolution is the culprit behind this. Often, if the person is not prepared to answer he or she will simply make something up instead of saying nothing at all. Recently I met an accomplished value investor and asked his feedback about how to make Safal Niveshak more valuable for its readers. Instead of falling for the Twaddle Tendency and make up something, he did the most honest thing. He said, “I can’t give you an answer off the cuff. Let me think about it.” It’s rare to find people like that. According to Munger, people waste a lot of time talking about meaningless stuff which then leads to equally meaningless activities. In Poor Charlie’s Almanack, Charlie Munger describes an interesting experiment … A trouble from the honeybee version of twaddle was once demonstrated in an interesting experiment. A honeybee
www.safalniveshak.com
91
Chapter 10 - Twaddle Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You normally goes out and finds nectar and then comes back and does a dance that communicates to the other bees where the nectar is. The other bees then go out and get it. Well some scientist, clever like B. F. Skinner [perhaps Charlie’s favorite scientist], decided to see how well a honeybee would do with a handicap. He put the nectar straight up. Way up. Well, in a natural setting, there is no nectar a long way straight up, and the poor honeybee doesn’t have a generic program that is adequate to handle what she now has to communicate. You might guess that this honeybee would come back to the hive and slink into a corner, but she doesn’t. She comes into the hive and does an incoherent dance. Well, all my life I’ve been dealing with the human equivalent of that honeybee. And it’s a very important part of wise administration to keep prattling people, pouring our twaddle, far away from the serious work. In 1998 Wesco meeting, Charlie added … I try to get rid of people who always confidently answer questions about which they don’t have any real knowledge. To me they are like the bee dancing its incoherent dance. They are just screwing up the hive. Twaddle is perhaps harmless for the twaddler (if there is such word) except that he loses respect in the eyes of wise people. But if you’re at the receiving end and your bullshit filter isn’t strong enough to separate the twaddle from real talk, then you run a risk of not only wasting your time hearing the trash talk but may also end up losing your money and resources. In fact, most of the talking heads on financial TV (even the non-financial ones) are dishing out twaddle.
www.safalniveshak.com
92
Chapter 10 - Twaddle Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You
Charlie Munger is quite fond of the word and has used it at multiple occasions. It’s obvious that if a company generates high returns on capital and reinvests at high returns, it will do well. But this wouldn’t sell books, so there’s a lot of twaddle and fuzzy concepts that have been introduced that don’t add much. (WESCO annual meeting, 2000) I think the notion that liquidity of tradable common stock is a great contributor to capitalism is mostly twaddle. The liquidity gives us these crazy booms, so it has as many problems as virtues. (BRK Annual Meeting, 2004) At Farnam Street, Shane Parrish writes… While we all hold an opinion on almost everything, how many of us do the work required to have an opinion? The work is the hard part. You have to do the reading. You have to talk to anyone you can find and listen to their arguments. You have to think about the key variables that govern the interests. You have to think about your biases and incentives. You have to think not emotionally but rationally. And you need to become your most intelligent critic. Part of doing that means you need to have the intellectual honesty to kill some of your best loved ideas.
www.safalniveshak.com
93
Chapter 10 - Twaddle Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You
Only then, when you can argue better against yourself than others can you hold an opinion. After you’ve done that, after you’ve done the work, that is the time you can say “Hey, I can hold this view, because I can’t find anyone else who can argue better against my view.” Simply regurgitating facts and anecdotes doesn’t add any value to an argument. Unless somebody has struggled with an idea and spent some mental energy thinking about it, his or her knowledge is pretty superficial, second hand and precursor to a twaddle. Munger says, “I never allow myself to have an opinion on anything that I don’t know the other side’s argument better than they do.” Unless one qualifies Munger’s test to have an opinion, whatever he or she speaks on a subject, especially with overconfidence, is possibly just twaddle. In his book The Art of Thinking Clearly, Rolf Dobelli summarizes the idea very well … Verbal expression is the mirror of the mind. Clear thoughts become clear statements, whereas ambiguous ideas transform into vacant ramblings. The trouble is that, in many cases, we lack very lucid thoughts. The world is complicated, and it takes a great deal of mental effort to understand even one facet of the whole. Until you experience such epiphany, it’s better to heed Mark Twain: ‘If you have nothing to say, say nothing.’ Simplicity is the zenith of a long, arduous journey, not the starting point. So how do you identify a twaddle?
www.safalniveshak.com
94
Chapter 10 - Twaddle Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You
Whenever you hear a talk or read a statement with signs of overconfidence, coloured with hindsight bias, suggesting anecdotal evidences, predictions about unknowable, and high sounding complicated jargons, you can be pretty sure that the person is either lying or mad and possibly both.
Conclusion I don’t know who said this but there is some degree of truth to this statement – Unsolicited advices are like armpits. Everyone has one and they stink. Based on my personal experience I know something needs to be ignored when someone pulls me aside and gives a free and especially an unsolicited advice. Here’s how Elon Musk cuts through the twaddle when he is recruiting people … When you struggle with a problem that’s when you understand it…when I interview people, I ask them to tell me about the problems that they worked on and how they solved them. And if someone is really the person who has solved it then he would be able to answer it at multiple levels…if they aren’t then you can say ...oh! this isn’t the person who really solved the problem. Because anyone who struggles hard with a problem, never forgets it. It’s amazing how quickly you can find somebody’s edge of knowledge. Just ask why a couple of times and you can see how deeply that person has thought through the problem or issue. That’s what Musk means by ‘multiple levels’.
www.safalniveshak.com
95
Chapter 10 - Twaddle Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You And do you know the most dangerous form of twaddle? It’s the one which you tell yourself. Because the easiest person to fool is always yourself, says Richard Feynman.
www.safalniveshak.com
96
Chapter 11 Reciprocation Tendency Few months back I was watching a Bollywood action crime drama movie ‘Badlapur’. The movie portrays the human emotion of ‘revenge’ and how far someone can go to seek it. The protagonist in the movie patiently waits 15 years to avenge his wife’s and son’s murder. The urge to take revenge can manifest in smallest of things. Someone cuts you off in the traffic and the first thought that comes to mind is to get back at him and settle the account. In fact, people getting shot dead in road rage incidents isn’t uncommon these days. So what could be the reason for this strong force, a need to reciprocate the wrongdoing, in human behaviour? Is it just the anger? Or is it the resentment for receiving an unfair treatment? Let’s use the inversion mental model (Chapter 44) and turn the question around. If humans can have such a strong need to reciprocate to an injustice, can they also have a similar need to reciprocate a favour? To answer that question in a truly multidisciplinary way, let’s explore the field of Psychology. Robert Cialdini, a professor of Psychology and author of wildly popular book Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion, has done extensive research on human behaviour. One of the human biases that he talks about in his book is Reciprocity Bias. According to Cialdini – the rule for reciprocation is one of the most potent weapons of influence around us.
www.safalniveshak.com
97
Chapter 11 - Reciprocation Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You The rule says that we should try to repay, in kind, what another person has provided us. We are obligated (not by some external force but an internal urge) to the future repayment of favors, gifts, invitations, and the like. This rule is deeply implanted in us by the process of socialization that homo sapiens has undergone over thousands of years. Each one of us has been taught to live up to the rule, says Cialdini “and each of us knows about the social sanctions and derision applied to anyone who violates it.” So there is a strong social stigma attached to the act of not returning a favour. Not just that, the force of reciprocity is not only extremely strong but very subtle too. Cialdini compares the psychological force of reciprocity to a martial arts form called jujitsu. In jujitsu the key is to use the force and energy of the opponent against him. It exploits and manipulates the naturally present principles of gravity, leverage, momentum, and inertia. A skilled jujitsu artist can defeat an opponent without exerting much personal force. Surprisingly, to the onlookers (including the opponent), the manipulation is almost invisible. Cialdini writes … One of the reasons reciprocation can be used so effectively as a device for gaining another’s compliance is its power. The rule possesses awesome strength, often producing a “yes” response to a request that, except for an existing feeling of indebtedness, would have surely been refused. By the way, here is another reason why you shouldn’t miss this book – Charlie Munger was so impressed with Cialdini’s work that he gifted a Class A share of BRK (which was worth more than USD 100,000 at the time) to him.
www.safalniveshak.com
98
Chapter 11 - Reciprocation Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You It wouldn’t be an overstatement if I say that your Latticework of Mental Models is incomplete without this book. So do yourself a favour (no pun intended) and buy the book. The rule of reciprocation is so strong that it simply overwhelms the influence of other normal factors that affect the decision making. This makes it a powerful weapon of influence. People who we usually dislike, including pushy salesmen, can make us acquiesce to their requests if they provide us a small (even unwanted) favour beforehand. Remember those free samples in the supermarket cookie shop? Or those welcome beverages offered to you and your wife in a jewelry store? Well I am not debating your prowess for judging the quality of precious jewels but your jeweler knows something more. He knows how to play a mental jujitsu and subconsciously trigger the rule of reciprocation. It’s fascinating how the rule of reciprocation can be deployed by some clever salespeople in an indirect way without actually doing any favour. I remember meeting a financial expert, a salesman in disguise, who first offered me a premium credit card with loads of features including elite club memberships and access to 5 star lounges at the international airports (ironically to a guy who had never been on an airplane till then). I had to refuse but not without feeling guilty for having wasted his time on me. Then he took out another colourful brochure and showed me the benefits of lifetime free credit cards. Did I take that? Of course! It didn’t matter that I had no need for credit card. He had done me a favour by offering concession on his product. I had to comply under the excruciatingly heavy weight of reciprocation.
www.safalniveshak.com
99
Chapter 11 - Reciprocation Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You Cialdini dubs this flavour of reciprocity as rejection-then-retreat (RTR) technique. The idea is to first make a larger request, one that will most likely be rejected followed by retreating to a smaller request which you were really interested in all along.
Image Source: Influence – Psychology of Persuasion
In Business and Investing Because of the subconscious effect of reciprocity, the corporate code of conduct laid out by big organizations often prohibit its employees from taking any favours from their vendors/suppliers or customers. They understand that under the subconscious influence of reciprocity, people can unknowingly end up giving unfair advantage to people who they are dealing with. Here’s an excerpt from Poor Charlie’s Almanack – Wise employers, therefore, try to oppose reciprocate-favor tendencies of employees engaged in purchasing. The simplest antidote works best: Don’t let them accept any
www.safalniveshak.com
100
Chapter 11 - Reciprocation Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You favors from vendors. Sam Walton [founder of Wal-Mart] agreed with this idea of absolute prohibition. He wouldn’t let purchasing agents accept so much as a hot dog from a vendor. Given the subconscious level at which much Reciprocation Tendency operates, this policy of Walton’s was profoundly correct. Reciprocity, especially RTR, is an important negotiation tool. Labor negotiations often begin with extreme demands (to a reasonable limit) that they don’t actually expect to win but from which they can retreat in a series of seeming concessions designed to draw real concessions from the opposing side. Perhaps that gives an edge to the first mover in negotiations.
Image Source: Dilbert.com So next time when you see a positive analyst report for a seemingly dud business, it’s likely that the analyst was treated well with good food and expensive drinks in the company’s investor presentation meeting.
www.safalniveshak.com
101
Chapter 11 - Reciprocation Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You And when you attend the next AGM, think twice before accepting any freebies or free lunch from the management. Whoever said – there are no free lunches – was probably thinking about rule of reciprocation.
How to Fight Reciprocity The first problem in countering the reciprocity bias is that you can’t know beforehand whether the offer is an honest or whether it is the initial step in an exploitation attempt. You might end up rejecting the legitimate favours coming from individuals who had no ulterior motives. Cialdini suggests – As long as we perceive and define his [person offering a favor] action as a compliance device instead of a favor, he no longer has the reciprocation rule as an ally. If you find yourself in a possible reciprocity-situation with the realization that the primary motive is to sell you something, all you need is a mental act of redefinition. Look at the favour not as gift but as a sales device. So the trick is to be alert and cultivate a habit of catching yourself in such situation. Being aware of it can diminish the force exerted by the rule of reciprocation. Here’s Charlie Munger’s suggestion to save yourself from this bias – The standard antidote to one’s overactive hostility is to train oneself to defer reaction. As my smart friend Tom
www.safalniveshak.com
102
Chapter 11 - Reciprocation Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You Murphy so frequently says, “You can always tell the man off tomorrow if it is such a good idea.”
The Positive Side of Reciprocity In his book, The Education of A Value Investor, Guy Spier writes … I decided that I would write three letters per working day, or 15 per week. I began to thank people for giving a great speech, for sending me their investor letter, for providing a great meal in their restaurant, for inviting me to their conference…At first, my letter-writing experiment was quite calculated, since I did it with an explicit desire to improve my business…But it started to feel really good… This small action of writing hundreds of letters a year was transformational for me…this habit of writing letters is an incredibly effective way of compounding goodwill and relationships instead of merely compounding money… My letter-writing crusade had begun as a way of marketing my fund, but it ended up giving me a richness of life that I could hardly have imagined. Rather than becoming a good salesperson, I found myself starting to care about the people I was writing to and to think about how I could help them. The paradox is that, as I became more authentic and discarded my agenda, people became more interested in investing in the fund. As a corollary to the rule of reciprocation, let me dispense a free but not-be-taken-asa-favour advice here.
www.safalniveshak.com
103
Chapter 11 - Reciprocation Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You
In life and in business, focus on seeking those who you can help instead of who can help you. And then let reciprocity weave its magic.
Conclusion We started this chapter with an intention to explore the psychology of revenge. Revenge, as it turns out, is the ugly side of reciprocity. Revenge breeds counterrevenge and you soon find yourself in a full-scale war. Confucius said, “Before you embark on a journey of revenge, dig two graves.” Mahatma Gandhi seemed to agree with him when he said, “An eye for eye only ends up making the whole world blind.” So if you do want to get even with people, do so with those who have helped you. At the same time be careful while accepting any favours, for the subconscious force of positive reciprocity can make you take decisions which aren’t always in your best interest. Perhaps Bollywood star Salman Khan says it best. (Rough translation: Do me a favour, that don’t do me any favours!) To that, I have nothing to add.
www.safalniveshak.com
104
Chapter 12 Gambler’s Fallacy Let’s start with a small riddle. A man, who is a statistician by profession, believes that his next child will be a girl since his wife has already borne him three sons. Do you find his argument convincing? The argument intuitively doesn’t feel right. But why? We’ll circle back to this puzzle but before that let me indulge you in another interesting thought experiment. Imagine yourself as a spectator in a coin flipping tournament. You notice that in one of the plays, the coin has landed on heads for 5 consecutive flips. If you were given an opportunity to bet on the next flip, would you bet on heads or tails? I know you’re a value investor and don’t believe in speculating or gambling away your hard earned money on frivolous coin flipping tournaments, but this being a thought experiment I would request you to play along. So what’s your answer? The basic concepts of probability tell us that for random events like outcomes of coin flipping, both the head or tail are equal likely. In other words, the probability of a head and a tail are both 1/2 (0.5).
www.safalniveshak.com
105
Chapter 12 - Gambler’s Fallacy | Mental Models, Investing, And You So using my elementary knowledge of probability, I would reason that the universe will try to balance out the too many heads. When I use this argument to put my bet on tails, I am falling for a bias called Gambler’s Fallacy. The Gambler’s Fallacy is the mistaken belief that, if something happens more frequently than normal during some period, it will happen less frequently in the future, or that, if something happens less frequently than normal during some period, it will happen more frequently in the future (presumably as a means of balancing nature). (source: Wikipedia) That explains why our statistician friend’s argument is flawed. The gender of the fourth child is causally unrelated to any preceding chance events or series of such events. His chances of having a daughter are no better than 1 in 2 i.e., 50-50. With independent events (the gender of kids, result of toss using a fair coin, etc.) there is no harmonising force at work. The coin doesn’t know that it had landed heads in the last 5 tosses. The most famous example of the gambler’s fallacy occurred in a game of roulette at the Monte Carlo Casino in 1913 when the ball fell in black 26 times in a row. This was an extremely uncommon occurrence, although no more or less common than any of the other 67,108,863 sequences of 26 red or black. Gamblers lost millions of francs betting against black, reasoning incorrectly that the streak was causing an “imbalance” in the randomness of the wheel, and that it had to be followed by a long streak of red. (source: Wikipedia) So why is it called a gambler’s fallacy? Because it’s rampant among gamblers and speculators.
www.safalniveshak.com
106
Chapter 12 - Gambler’s Fallacy | Mental Models, Investing, And You There was a guy who claimed that he had a scientific way of playing the lottery. He diligently maintained a spreadsheet of winning numbers and would bet on those numbers which had appeared the least. Alas! another victim of Gambler’s fallacy. Now if a coin (a fair one) has equal probability (50:50) of turning heads or tails then why is it fallacious to expect a tail after 5 consecutive heads? That’s a fair question to ask. To answer that, let me take help from Daniel Kahneman. In his book, Thinking Fast and Slow, Danny writes … People expect that a sequence of events generated by a random process [coin toss] will represent the essential characteristics [equal probability of head and tail] of that process even when the sequence is short [few tosses]. In considering tosses of a coin for heads or tails, for example, people regard the sequence H-T-H- T-T-H to be more likely than the sequence H-H-H-T-T-T, which does not appear random, and also more likely than the sequence H-H-H-HT-H, which does not represent the fairness of the coin. Thus, people expect that the essential characteristics of the process will be represented, not only globally in the entire sequence, but also locally in each of its parts. A locally representative sequence [the sequence of 5 heads which you observed], however, deviates systematically from chance expectation: it contains too many alternations and too few runs. Another
consequence
of
the
belief
in
local
representativeness is the well-known gambler’s fallacy. After observing a long run of red on the roulette wheel, for example, most people erroneously believe that black is now
www.safalniveshak.com
107
Chapter 12 - Gambler’s Fallacy | Mental Models, Investing, And You due, presumably because the occurrence of black will result in a more representative sequence than the occurrence of an additional red. Chance is commonly viewed as a self-correcting process in which a deviation in one direction induces a deviation in the opposite direction to restore the equilibrium. In fact, deviations are not “corrected” as a chance process unfolds, they are merely diluted. Kahneman’s insights are remarkable. So if you didn’t understand the above two paragraphs, please read them slowly and then re-read them. Now if you were given an opportunity to bet on many such tosses, say 100 tosses, what would be your strategy for betting? Again the assumption being that it’s a fair coin (with no specific bias for either head or tail) and with the knowledge that probabilities are still 50:50. Kahneman explains this using an anecdote about famous economist Paul Samuelson. He writesThe great Paul Samuelson—a giant among the economists of the twentieth century—famously asked a friend whether he would accept a gamble on the toss of a coin in which he could lose $100 or win $200. His friend responded, “I won’t bet because I would feel the $100 loss more than the $200 gain. But I’ll take you on if you promise to let me make 100 such bets.” Unless you are a decision theorist, you probably share the intuition of Samuelson’s friend, that playing a very favorable but risky gamble multiple times reduces the subjective risk. Samuelson’s friend was pretty smart. He understood that Gambler’s fallacy arises out of a belief in a law of small numbers, or the erroneous belief that small samples must
www.safalniveshak.com
108
Chapter 12 - Gambler’s Fallacy | Mental Models, Investing, And You be representative of the larger population. Hence he was willing to bet on the aggregate outcome of bigger sample size than a single outcome. You probably noticed that I have been mentioning the use of a fair coin for our tosses. A fair coin ensures the pre-condition for a gambler’s fallacy to hold true, i.e. independent events.
Gambler’s Fallacy – Reversed! If I told you that in the same coin tossing tournament, there is play where the coin has turned heads for 50 consecutive tosses. What would you bet on for the 51st coin toss? The probability of that happening, using a fair coin, is 1 in a 1100 trillion but there’s also a chance that the coin is biased. A biased coin or an imperfect roulette wheel can also lead to outcomes like 5 consecutive heads but for totally different reasons. In these cases, the gambler’s fallacy might superficially seem to apply, when it actually does not. If you suspect that you’re dealing with a biased coin or a loaded dice, it’s reasonable to expect that long streak of skewed outcomes are not due to randomness. But sometimes human brain takes it too far in the other direction when a belief in the idea of hot hand takes root. This is the reverse of gambler’s fallacy, also known as hot hand fallacy. It originates from basketball where players who scored several times in a row are believed to have a hot hand, i.e. are more likely to score at their next attempt. In cricket, players are often declared to be “in-form” and are expected to consistently perform above average until the form lasts. Perhaps a hot-bat fallacy!
www.safalniveshak.com
109
Chapter 12 - Gambler’s Fallacy | Mental Models, Investing, And You At first the idea of gambler’s fallacy might look paradoxical to the mental model of mean reversion (Chapter 19) but it’s not. In his book, The Art of Thinking Clearly, Rolf Dobelli explains the subtle difference between the two. …if you are experiencing record cold where you live, it is likely that the temperature will return to normal values over the next few days, If the weather functioned like a casino, there would be 50% chance that the temperature would rise and a 50% chance that it would drop. But the weather is not like a casino. Complex feedback (Chapter 32) mechanisms in the atmosphere ensures that extremes balance themselves out. So,
take
a
closer
look
at
the
independent
and
interdependent events around you. Purely independent events really only exist at the casino, in the lottery and in theory. In real life, in the financial markets and in business, with the weather and your health, events are often interrelated. Which means a domain prone to truly random and independent events, like a casino, is more prone to gambler’s fallacy. However, in systems which behave like complex adaptive systems (Chapter 24) i.e. prone to self-correction, both mean reversion (negative feedback loops) and extreme outcomes (positive feedback loops) are a possibility.
In Investing In stock markets how many times have we heard, ‘whatever goes up must come down’ or ‘how much more can it drop?’.
www.safalniveshak.com
110
Chapter 12 - Gambler’s Fallacy | Mental Models, Investing, And You These beliefs are a manifestation of gambler’s fallacy in investor’s behaviour. Vishal is fond of quoting the example – A stock that falls 95%, first fell 90% and from that level fell another 50%. When Warren Buffett said, “turnarounds seldom turn” he probably had gambler’s fallacy in mind. Expecting that the future events will smoothen out the stock prices, just because it has been falling for ‘n’ continuous trading days, is an irrational way of thinking. Sometimes investors abruptly change their belief from gambler’s fallacy to hot-hand fallacy. When their patience runs out, having lost money by betting on outcomes which are supposedly “long overdue”, they tend to go overboard in assuming that a stock has come to its “form” and will continue its trend. They bet heavily on the new “trend” and right then the tide turns and the roaring market makes a mincemeat out of those unsuspecting hot-hand believers.
Conclusion Typically, humans intuitively find it hard to deal with randomness as a result we tend to put a tremendous amount of weight on previous events, believing that they’ll somehow influence future outcomes. Gambler’s fallacy dictates that the idea of “balancing force of the universe” is a baloney. Gambler’s fallacy requires you to understand the basics of probability. If you aren’t acquainted with the basic probability concepts, you need to learn it else you might end up like the proverbial (as described by Charlie Munger) single legged man in an asskicking contest.
www.safalniveshak.com
111
Chapter 13 Mental Accounting Imagine yourself with your friend in the Sin City, i.e. The Las Vegas. While walking on the Las Vegas Boulevard you find a $10 bill sticking out from the side of the pavement, as if it’s telling you “Please Pick me!”. You pick it up and feel ecstatic about your moderately good fortune. “Wait a minute! Is that a sign from the universe?”, a strange but perfectly reasonable thought appears in your mental screen. Perhaps Lady Fortuna is nudging you to try out your luck using this $10 totem. After all it’s the Las Vegas. The Gambler’s Paradise. Your friend however is tired and heads back to the hotel. But you just can’t ignore the sign from above. Taking this as an omen, you enter the first Casino and head straight to the roulette table. You want to bet on your lucky number 7. Sure enough, the roulette ball hits 7 and 35-1 bet wins you $350. You let your winnings ride and the ball lands on 7 again, paying you $12,250. And so it goes. Within an hour you are a multimillionaire with $50 million in your kitty. Feeling like Daniel Ocean from Ocean’s Eleven, you intend to bring the house down with your raging streak of luck. Being just one step away from becoming a billionaire you bet all your money on number 7 one last time – only to lose it all this time. Broke, dejected and little flabbergasted you walk down several miles to join your friend in the hotel room. “Where were you man?” asks your friend as you enter the room. “Playing roulette.” You’re still feeling a little shaken. “How did you do?”
www.safalniveshak.com
112
Chapter 13 - Mental Accounting | Mental Models, Investing, And You
You cut the story short and tell him, “Not bad. I lost ten dollars.” My question to you is – “Did you really just lose $10?” If your answer is yes, then perhaps you are unaware of the behavioural bias called Mental Accounting. This concept, first proposed by University of Chicago’s Richard Thaler, states that human beings have the tendency to categorize and handle money differently depending on where it came from, where it is kept, or how it is spent. Are you confused a bit? Here is another thought experiment to get a better handle on curious effects of mental accounting. Try to answer the questions honestly.
The Case of Lost IPL Ticket Imagine you have bought a ticket to an IPL cricket match where your favourite team is playing. When you reach the venue you realize you’ve lost the ticket, which cost you 2000 rupees. Are you going to spend another 2000 bucks and buy a new ticket at the venue (assuming it’s available at the ticket counter) to see the match? Your answer would probably be no. That was my answer too when I heard this for the first time. Now let’s re-construct the same scenario little differently. Instead of buying the ticket beforehand you’re standing in the line to buy the ticket in the stadium. At the ticket counter you realize that you’ve lost 2000 rupees cash somewhere on your way to the stadium. Still, you have more than enough in your wallet to buy the ticket. What would you do in this case? Buy a ticket?
www.safalniveshak.com
113
Chapter 13 - Mental Accounting | Mental Models, Investing, And You Intuitively, like most people, you’d probably answer yes. Like I did when I was asked the same question. Irrespective of the fact, whether you buy the ticket again or not, aren’t both the cases setting you back by 2000 rupees? Then why is your behaviour different in above two cases? You might say that the loss of the ticket and the loss of 2000 rupees aren’t the same. It’s possible that I might find either the ticket or the 2000 rupees later (that it’s misplaced instead of lost). However, the ticket will have become useless to me whereas the 2000 rupees will not have. But not everybody is so rational (and so hopeful about lost money) while standing at the ticket counter. This inclination of human mind to mentally separate the two losses in different categories is a classic case of mental accounting. We shift perspectives on money as the surrounding circumstances change. We tend to mentally put money into different ‘accounts’ and that determines how we think about using it. The economic theory says that money is fungible, and there should be no difference in the way we spend the bonus money and the salary income. Think about it for a moment, won’t it sound ridiculous if your local grocery store guy tells you, “Sir! Since you’re paying using the money from your salary, I am going to give you 20% discount. However, if you want to pay using the money from your Diwali bonus, then I’ll charge you 20% extra.”? But a similar logic seemed perfectly reasonable at the IPL ticket counter.
Earned Money Vs Found Money Have you ever been guilty of spending your stock dividends (or the interest on fixed deposits) as if it was free money? Before you answer that let me admit that I have been
www.safalniveshak.com
114
Chapter 13 - Mental Accounting | Mental Models, Investing, And You guilty of this mistake multiple times in the past. I used to mentally compartmentalize the dividend money as excess money. The outcome is that my salary (earned money) gets spent on my needs first however the year-end bonus (found money) gets spent on discretionary items, like vacations, first. Do you know somebody who pays 18% interest on revolving loans on credit card in spite of having money invested in bond funds earning 7% returns? It’s pretty obvious that his mental wall separating the two accounts is not going to come down for a long time. For that matter plastic money (credit cards) is the scariest exhibit of mental accounting for messing up your personal finances.
Lollapalooza of Mental Accounting The funny thing about mental biases is that they usually don’t come alone. In most cases there are multiple biases acting together creating a lollapalooza effect. So even in this case there is a subtle interplay of mental accounting and contrast effect. Let me share my personal experience. Every time I go for my monthly grocery shopping, I am always surprised at number of unplanned small items I end up picking. A 10 rupees cookie pack, a 15 rupees coffee sachet (even though I am a tea drinker) and a glittery ball pen displayed near the billing counter. We justify these small items purchases in contrast to a usually larger grocery bill. This is what contrast bias does to you. I would never have bought those items if my final bill amount was going to be small. A brilliant insight found in the book Why Smart People Make Big Money Mistakes –
www.safalniveshak.com
115
Chapter 13 - Mental Accounting | Mental Models, Investing, And You Mental accounting helps explain the one of the greatest puzzles of personal finance – why people who don’t see themselves as reckless spenders can’t seem to save enough…Although people are cost conscious when making large financial decisions – such as buying a house, car, or appliances – mental accounting makes them relax their discipline when making small purchases. The cost of such purchases gets lost among larger expenses, such as the week’s grocery bill…The problem, of course, is that while you might purchase a car or refrigerator every few years, you buy groceries every week or every day. Being costconscious when making little purchases is where you can often rack up big savings. By the way, a side note – Psychologists suggest that you should never go for grocery shopping when you are feeling hungry. You would end up buying stuff that you don’t need unnecessarily bloating up your bill. Sales people understand these quirks in human behaviour. They don’t shy away from exploiting these biases for their benefit. Now you can guess why consumer electronic stores promote the extended warranties so much at the time of purchase. Or why insurance agents push those exotic policy riders.
Side Effects of Mental Accounting In some cases, mental accounting can actually come back and bite you harder. Let me use my favourite thinking tool -hypothetical situations - to explain the point – Let’s say you plan to spend 20,000 rupees for buying a smartphone. On the day of the purchase, you suddenly find a 10% discount deal and end up saving 2000 rupees on your phone. Research has shown that most people in this scenario start accounting
www.safalniveshak.com
116
Chapter 13 - Mental Accounting | Mental Models, Investing, And You those 2000 rupees as ‘found money’ and end up spending not just those 2000 bucks but some more to use up the free money. So you see how the ‘bonus money’ can sometimes do more harm than good. It’s another mental accounting mind bender.
Overcoming Mental Accounting If your grandmother gifted you 1000 rupees on your birthday, are you going to use that money for paying your electricity bill? Sounds insensitive right? You aren’t going to splurge the same money on gambling either. That’s the basic idea for countering the harmful effects of mental accounting. Convert every inflow mentally into “earned income” and then evaluate what do you want to do with it. So imagine that all kinds of income are earned income including dividends from stocks, interest on fixed deposits, money found on the road, the Diwali bonus from your employer, income tax refunds and for that matter even the money gifted from your grandmother. Second trick is to delay spending any ‘bonus’ money. Just keep it in a fixed deposit for a month. Sleep over it before splurging it on anything. You would be surprised how quickly your brain re-categorizes your ‘bonus’ money to ‘earned’ money. Another common sense approach is to limit the use (rather abuse) of plastic money. I have gotten into the habit of using my credit card only for online purchases (that too I prefer net banking or even cash on delivery option). Of course that increases my trips to the ATM but that’s the whole point. Spending money shouldn’t become so convenient that you end up spending all.
www.safalniveshak.com
117
Chapter 13 - Mental Accounting | Mental Models, Investing, And You
Exploiting Mental Accounting I am a big fan of Nassim Taleb’s books. I like experimenting with his mental models wherever I can find some useful application. Antifragility is one such concept, which says that you arrange your affairs in such a manner that harmful effects generated by uncertainties (mental accounting) of life make you stronger and better. So let’s see how we can actually not just shield ourselves from ill effects of mental accounting but use it for our benefit. This starts with the understanding that all human biases have a reason behind them. Let’s assume that you are a perfectly rational human being. Before spending any money, you would always check the opportunity cost i.e. before buying nice t-shirt for yourself, you would ask what other things you are foregoing in order to have the new shirt. Obviously this process is too rigorous and nobody has the time and mental capacity to go through this exercise every time we spend money. So we fall back to the behavioural short cut of mental accounting by pre-assigning money for each cause. Explained that way mental accounting doesn’t look all that evil. It gives us an easy and simple way to carry out our day to day financial transactions without too much of cognitive overload. When you associate your money to a specific emotional goal, you channelize the will power to save money for that goal. Saving money for years to buy that dream house of yours or to buy that long cherished dream vacation in Europe. In fact, the first advice given by any reasonably good personal financial advisor is to create a do-not-touch emergency fund for yourself. The idea is to stash away some part of your saving in an ultra-safe asset and not to touch it unless there is an emergency. Here is an example of how famous Hollywood actor Dustin Hoffman used mental accounting when he was struggling to make a career in Hollywood.
www.safalniveshak.com
118
Chapter 13 - Mental Accounting | Mental Models, Investing, And You
Conclusion So the central idea here is that money is not truly fungible in a human mind, and this oddity produces an irrational behaviour while dealing with certain situations involving money. Although mental accounting can distort your thinking process and lead you to make erroneous decisions, with proper awareness it can also be used for our benefit. If I were to summarize mental accounting in one sentence, it would be – Reimbursements send people on trips to the bank, and bonuses send people on trips to Goa.
www.safalniveshak.com
119
Chapter 14 Social Proof Imagine it’s Friday evening, the beginning of a long weekend, and you decide to watch the latest action flick in your nearest multiplex. Since you don’t want to miss the beginning of the movie, you decide to take the elevator as soon as you reach the mall. Although the health freak inside you is mad because you promised him to always take the stairs in a mall. The moment you enter the elevator you notice that there are half a dozen other people inside but strangely everybody is facing towards the back of the elevator. Isn’t that odd? So what would you do in this situation? Can you guess what most people do in such situation? Watch this video of a social experiment which tried to capture people’s reaction in the similar situation. Most people fall for this and blindly copy the actions of others without resisting or questioning. They assume that if everybody is doing it, there must be some reason for it. They fear looking like an odd man out. This tendency is called Social Proof. As per Wikipedia, social proof is: A psychological phenomenon where people assume the actions of others in an attempt to reflect correct behavior for a given situation. This effect is prominent in ambiguous social situations where people are unable to determine the appropriate mode of behavior, and is driven by the assumption
that
surrounding
people
possess
more
knowledge about the situation.
www.safalniveshak.com
120
Chapter 14 - Social Proof | Mental Models, Investing, And You In short, monkey see, monkey do. That’s how you can explain the social proof tendency to your kids. Can you guess what’s shown in the picture below?
Image Source: bashny.net If you can’t make out, that’s a top view of a flock of sheep leaving the stall. All the sheep are stampeding to pass through the narrow gate. And there is no fence, only the gate! Social proof, also known as herding, is a terribly useful mental model from psychology. So let’s dig deeper.
www.safalniveshak.com
121
Chapter 14 - Social Proof | Mental Models, Investing, And You Humans are social animals. We want what others want and we tend to avoid what others avoid. When we’re uncertain, in an unfamiliar environment, we try to resolve the ambiguity by following others. But why is it so? Why do we follow the herd? To answer that you’ll have to cross the boundaries of psychology and step into the discipline of biology. Darwin’s Theory of Evolution give us some clues. In the hunter gatherer environment if you saw a group of panic struck homo sapiens running past you, the obvious conclusion was that they were being chased by a ferocious, and perhaps hungry, beast. It gave you a tremendous evolutionary advantage if you started following the herd behaviour under such circumstances. So that’s how the social proof tendency has been wired in human behaviour. Although we don’t live in the hunter gatherer environment anymore it still makes our lives seemingly easier if we just stay in the herd. Being part of the majority acts as a protection from criticism. If we’re wrong and everybody else is wrong too, we get blamed less.
Benefits of Social Proof It would be unfair to say that every social proof situation is bad. As we have seen that social proof tendency, like many other behavioural biases, came into human behaviour because of evolutionary reasons so it must have utility in carrying out routine activities. We see this helping us in our daily lives. From our selection of books at Amazon to relying on other people’s experience with a particular seller on eBay, we rely on other people’s decisions to make our own.
www.safalniveshak.com
122
Chapter 14 - Social Proof | Mental Models, Investing, And You Most of the times, these decisions are good and extremely helpful. In his wonderful work, The Wisdom of Crowds, James Surowiecki argues convincingly that the quality of decisions taken by a group is usually better than the one that a single member of group will make. In fact, e-commerce and social networking websites spend a lot of efforts in developing strong recommendation engines which are primarily based on the idea of “social proof” i.e. figuring out the most popular products (or online content). These social proof based recommendations help us discover the right products. Herding becomes particularly useful in ambiguous situations because it simplifies the decision making process. So there is nothing wrong in making small decisions based on social proof. It actually makes our lives easier and saves a lot of time and energy. Social proof can be a wonderful tool for nudging people to adopt good behaviour and follow best practices. In the book, Yes! 50 Scientifically Proven Ways to Be Persuasive, authors describe an interesting experiment which was conducted in a hotel to promote recycling of used towels by the hotel guests. The researchers placed a message card indicating that the majority of guests already chose to reuse their towels. Guests whose cards subtly employed the principle of social proof were 26% more likely to recycle their towels than those who saw only the basic environmental protection message. That’s a big improvement at no additional cost to the hotel. When it comes to making crucial decisions, you have to take a step back and think for yourself. And when you fail to do that you not only miss tremendous opportunities but can often get into serious troubles. This is the dark side of social proof.
www.safalniveshak.com
123
Chapter 14 - Social Proof | Mental Models, Investing, And You
The Dark Side of Social Proof Routinely it’s pretty much safe, even efficient, to follow others. However, it can have dangerous consequences when the stakes are high. It won’t be an overstatement if I say that social proof has the potential to cost you your life. The story of lemmings jumping off the cliff in large groups may be apocryphal but it’s scary when the herd behaviour drives even humans to commit dangerously foolish acts. In 1978, under a strong spell of social proof bias, more than nine hundred followers of the cult leader Jim Jones and his organization committed mass suicide. As far as human behaviour is concerned, German-Swiss philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche was accurate in his observation when he said: Madness is rare thing in individuals – but in groups, parties, peoples, and ages it is the rule. Skilled marketing people are experts in persuasion techniques and adept at exploiting such behavioural biases to shove their products down the customer’s throat. Social proof is what is at work in canned laughter – what you hear in comedy shows. The reason such laughter exists is because it causes the audience to laugh longer and more often when humorous material is presented and to rate the material as funnier. In fact, you will hear the laughter even when there’s nothing to laugh about. I propose they add such laughter to business channels as well.
In Investing It’s sad but most of the financial industry is plagued by ill effects of social proof. Warren Buffett’s writes -
www.safalniveshak.com
124
Chapter 14 - Social Proof | Mental Models, Investing, And You Most managers have very little incentive to make the “intelligent but with some chance of looking like an idiot” decision. Their personal gain/loss ratio is too obvious: if an unconventional decision works out well, they get a pat on the back and, if it works out poorly, they get a pink slip. (Failing conventionally is the route to go; as a group, lemmings may have a rotten image, but no individual lemming has ever received bad press.) If you start analysing the portfolios of majority of the mutual fund managers, you will discover that they’re very similar or differ only minutely and very rarely we observe any manager taking a very big and ‘against the consensus’ call. It’s no surprise that their returns are also not much different. John Maynard Keynes, one of the most influential economist of 20th century, captured this tendency with a sarcastic comment: Worldly wisdom teaches that it is better for reputation to fail conventionally than to succeed unconventionally. A lot of investors also exhibit social proof in their investment decisions. They hold a particular stock because most of the people in their ‘investing groups’ are positive on a stock. This act of mindless copying also leads to mindless selling in tough times because it’s difficult to buy with ‘conviction’ in tough times (and low prices) when there is no knowledge base to get that ‘conviction’ at the very first place.
Overcoming Social Proof One of the best ways to brace yourself from being a victim of social proof is to choose your role models carefully. Your heroes can serve as reference points for making a decision about our own behaviour.
www.safalniveshak.com
125
Chapter 14 - Social Proof | Mental Models, Investing, And You Guy Spier, author of the book The Education of a Value Investor, shares a wonderful strategy in his book: “here is a wisdom here that goes far beyond the narrow world of investing. What I’m about to tell you may be the single most important secret I have discovered in all my decades of studying and stumbling…What I stumbled upon was this. Desperate to figure out how to lead a life that was more like his [Warren Buffett], I began constantly to ask myself one simple question: “What would Warren Buffett do if he were in my shoes?” …The minute I started mirroring Buffett, my life changed. It was as if I had tuned in to a different frequency.” So find out your heroes and populate your thoughts with them. For the second strategy to counter the force of social proof, let’s take Mark Twain’s help who said: Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it is time to pause and reflect. Taking a contrarian position isn’t an iron rule. Don’t take pride in being contrarian just for the sake of it. Mr. Twain is essentially asking us to become an independent and rational thinker. Warren Buffett simplifies it furtherWe derive no comfort because important people, vocal people, or great numbers of people agree with us. Nor do we derive comfort if they don’t.
www.safalniveshak.com
126
Chapter 14 - Social Proof | Mental Models, Investing, And You Would you sell your brand new car if some of your neighbours came to you and started offering 30 percent less than your purchase price? Of course not. You know the real worth of your car and selling it at a price quoted by Mr. Neighbour (a close cousin of Mr. Market) isn’t a wise decision. So why would you do that with your stocks? Benjamin Graham, the highest authority on security analysis, reminds usYou’re neither right nor wrong because the crowd disagrees with you. You are right because your data and reasoning are right. Checklist is another great tool to save yourself from social proof tendency. The catch is that you have to create the checklist beforehand. When the whole world (crowd) is stampeding in one direction, checklist can bring some sanity in your decision making process. And last but not the least, tune out the unnecessary noise i.e. the newspapers and news channels. More than any real information they just resound the “market sentiments” which is nothing but herding. Just because somebody is on the TV, who is articulate and wears a business suit, doesn’t mean he is a superior thinker and has valuable insights.
Conclusion Conformity often results from uncertainty. In situations where we aren’t sure what to do, we conform to popular choice. But when the stakes are high, you don’t want to be in a situation where you’re unsure because that would trigger the force of herding. Becoming an independent thinker may not earn you any popularity but it surely will make you wealthy over long term.
www.safalniveshak.com
127
Chapter 15 Reason Respecting Tendency Next time when you approach an ATM machine and find a queue in front of it, try this hack – tell the person in front of the queue “Excuse Me. May I go before you because I have to withdraw money?” I am sure you haven’t tried this before, neither have I. Sounds like a poor idea. Doesn’t it? Why would anyone let you go ahead unless you have a genuine reason. Isn’t withdrawing money a redundant excuse? Isn’t it obvious that everybody in the queue is there to withdraw money? But there might be some merit to above idea because in 1970s Harvard psychologist Ellen Langer conducted a similar experiment. She went into a library, where there was a long waiting queue in front of the photocopier, and approached the first person in the queue and asked, “Excuse me. I have five pages. May I use the Xerox machine?” That would probably infuriate a lot of people because everybody was there to make copies. Naturally most people refused to oblige to Langer’s request. In the second part of the experiment she gave a reason while making a request. “Excuse me. I have five pages. May I use the Xerox machine, because I’m in a rush?” This time most people gave in to her request and allowed her to go ahead. This is reasonable because if people are in a hurry, you would often let them cut into the front of the queue. But then came the interesting twist in the experiment. In the final part of the experiment she tried another approach, this time saying, “Excuse me. I have five pages. May I go before you, because I have to make some copies?” Now that’s a lame excuse. Everybody in the queue has to make copies, but
www.safalniveshak.com
128
Chapter 15 - Reason Respecting Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You surprisingly the result in this approach was amazing. She was allowed to pass to the front of the queue in almost all cases. It turns out when people justify their behaviour they face less resistance. Our need for making sense makes us even believe in nonsense. So for most people it seems to matter very little if the excuse is good or not. They aren’t really looking for a reason but just an answer, no matter how unreasonable the answer is.
Image Source: eBay Lewis Carroll (British mathematician and writer, 1832-1898, from Through the Looking Glass) In Art of Thinking Clearly, Rolf Dobelli writes – It seems people are addicted to the word ‘because’ – so much so that we use it even when it’s not necessary. If
www.safalniveshak.com
129
Chapter 15 - Reason Respecting Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You you’re a leader, undoubtedly you have witnessed this. If you
provide
no
rallying
call,
employee
motivation
dwindles. It simply doesn’t make the grade to say that the purpose of your shoe company is to manufacture footwear. No: today, higher purposes and the story behind the story is all-important; for example: ‘We want our shoes to revolutionalize the market’ (whatever that means) Charlie Munger has termed this bias as Reason Respecting Tendency (RRT). In his famous lecture ‘Psychology of Human Misjudgment’, Charlie explains the origin of this bias – There is in man, particularly one in an advanced culture, a natural love of accurate cognition and a joy in its exercise. This accounts for the widespread popularity of crossword puzzles, other puzzles, and bridge and chess columns, as well as all games requiring mental skill. This tendency has an obvious implication. It makes man especially prone to learn well when a would-be teacher gives correct reasons for what is taught, instead of simply laying out the desired belief ex cathedra with no reasons given. Few practices, therefore, are wiser than not only thinking through reasons before giving orders but also communicating these reasons to the recipient of the order. In general, learning is most easily assimilated and used when, lifelong, people consistently hang their experience, actual and vicarious, on a latticework of theory answering the question: Why?
www.safalniveshak.com
130
Chapter 15 - Reason Respecting Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You Unfortunately, Reason Respecting Tendency is so strong that even a person’s giving of meaningless or incorrect reasons will increase compliance with his orders and requests…This sort of unfortunate byproduct of ReasonRespecting Tendency is a conditioned reflex, based on a widespread appreciation of the importance of reasons. And, naturally, the practice of laying out various claptrap reasons is much used by commercial and cult “compliance practitioners” to help them get what they don’t deserve.
Reason for RRT There is a reason for reason respecting tendency. Peter Bevelin, in his book Seeking Wisdom, writes – When people ask us for a favor we are more likely to comply if they give us a reason even if we don’t understand the reason or it is wrong. Often it isn’t the reason itself that is important, but the way the reason is phrased. Sometimes the word “because,” without a sensible reason, is all that matters. We want explanations and the word “because” imply an explanation. Charlie Munger tells the story of Carl Braun, the creator of CF Braun Engineering Company – His rule for all the Braun Company’s communications was called the five W’s – you had to tell who was going to do what, where, when and why. And if you wrote a letter or directive in the Braun Company telling somebody to do something, and you didn’t tell him why, you could get fired. In fact, you would get fired if you did it twice.
www.safalniveshak.com
131
Chapter 15 - Reason Respecting Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You
You might ask why that is so important? Well, again that’s a rule of psychology. Just as you think better if you array knowledge on a bunch of models that are basically answers to the question, why, why, why, if you always tell people why, they’ll understand it better, they’ll consider it more important, and they’ll be more likely to comply. Even if they don’t understand your reason, they’ll be more likely to comply. So there’s an iron rule that just as you want to start getting worldly
wisdom
by
asking
why,
why,
why
in
communicating with other people about everything, you want to include why, why, why.
Stock Market Fell Because ... Whenever there is a significant movement in stock prices, you’ll never find the talking heads on the financial news channels saying, “We don’t know what caused this rise/fall in the markets.” If they did, who would listen to them? They know the human need for attaching a reason to every wiggle in the stock market. And there is never a dearth of twaddle (Chapter 10) when it comes to explaining the market movements. Dobelli writes – If the stock market rises or falls by half a percent, you will never
hear
the
true
cause
from
stock
market
commentators – that it is white noise, the culmination of an infinite number of market movements. No: people want a palpable reason and the commentator is happy to select one. Whatever explanation he utters will be meaningless –
www.safalniveshak.com
132
Chapter 15 - Reason Respecting Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You with frequent blame applied to the pronouncements of Federal Reserve bank presidents. When I started investing in stock market, I first turned to the paid research reports. These reports had colorful fonts, impressive pie charts and graphs, detailed financials and numerous intelligent sounding reasons for buying the recommended stocks. I was convinced and started buying stocks based on their monthly recommendations. But soon a pattern emerged in their stock reports. It seemed that they had a standard template for their stock reports which they filled with their opinions (not reasons) and copied the data from annual reports. Needless to say that I lost money in almost all those stock recommendations. It took me few years to realize the importance of independent thinking in investing. Every research report is just an opinion unless you agree with it based on your own sound reasoning and rational thinking. The only way you can save yourself from RRT is by questioning the reasons provided by others. And not just others, develop the habit of questioning the reasons generated by your own mind because, as Richard Feynman says, the easiest person to fool is yourself.
Image Source: Dilbert.com
www.safalniveshak.com
133
Chapter 15 - Reason Respecting Tendency | Mental Models, Investing, And You
Conclusion Reason Respecting Tendency is where people want the answers to something but don’t care to know the background information or reasoning to gain a better understanding. So next time when you find yourself standing at the end of a long queue, you know what to do to save time. And if somebody tries this trick with you, you can counter it by giving another random excuse. Or you can tell him, “Do you think you’re the only one who reads Safal Niveshak?”
www.safalniveshak.com
134
Chapter 16 The Bystander Effect Just after 3 a.m., March 13, 1964 in New York City, Catherine Genovese, a 28-year old woman, was stabbed to death in a parking lot in front of her apartment complex. Catherine’s murder story could have drowned in the middle pages of most newspapers like many other crime stories, except that it didn’t. Catherine’s murder wasn’t a quick, muffled death. It had been a long, loud, tortured, public event. The killer had chased and attacked her in the street three times over a period of thirty-five minutes before his knife finally silenced her cries for help. Shockingly, thirty-eight people, all in the surrounding apartments, witnessed at least one of her killer’s three attacks from the safety of their apartment windows for 25 minutes without calling the police. The story has since been thoroughly debunked, a case of sensational reporting, but at the time it was written it led to intense interest in the phenomenon from psychologists. Even if there is a ten percent truth to above story, it’s a baffling account of a crime, not because it was a murder, but because “good people” failed to call the police. Why didn’t the neighbours help? Were they indifferent? Frightened? Why should they be afraid of calling the police from the safety of their own homes? Has the violence on TV and movies made people so insensitive? Was it the beginning of a new epidemic known as large scale social apathy? Interview with the witnesses revealed none of these explanations was the real reason behind people’s inaction.
www.safalniveshak.com
135
Chapter 16 - The Bystander Effect | Mental Models, Investing, And You I found Genovese’s story in Robert Cialdini’s masterpiece, Influence – The Psychology of Persuasion. Cialdini writes – A simple anonymous call to the police could have saved Catherine without threatening the witness’s future safety or free time. No, it wasn’t the observers’ fear or reluctance to complicate their lives that explained their lack of action; something
else
was
going
on
there…They[social
psychologists] examined the reports of the Genovese incident and, on the basis of their knowledge of social psychology, hit on what had seemed the most unlikely explanation of all – it was that thirty-eight witnesses were present…no one had helped precisely because there were so many observers. This is called The Bystander Effect, which basically states that as humans, we don’t only imitate good actions, but we also have a tendency to follow wrong actions and inactions of fellow humans. Friedrich Nietzsche was on to something when he proclaimed Madness is a rare thing in individuals – but in groups, parties, peoples, and ages it is the rule.
Diffusion of Responsibility When several people, potential helpers, around you are witnessing the same event, the personal responsibility of each individual reduces. It’s called diffusion of responsibility. Have you ever seen someone broken down on the side of the road and thought, “I could help them, but I’m sure someone will be come along.” Everyone thinks that. And no
www.safalniveshak.com
136
Chapter 16 - The Bystander Effect | Mental Models, Investing, And You one stops. Watch the following video of a social experiment which demonstrates the bystander effect. In a crowd, your inclination to rush to someone’s aid fades, as if diluted by the potential of the group. Everyone thinks someone is going to eventually do something, but with everyone waiting together, no one does. To be able to extend any help we must interpret an event as an emergency. When we are uncertain, we have a tendency to look at people around us to see how they react. If others don’t react, we interpret that as evidence that it is not an emergency, and we therefore don’t react. We don’t want to be the ones that stand out in a crowd and risk embarrassment for acting in a non-emergency situation. Fear of embarrassment plays a big role into group dynamics. Talking about fear of embarrassment, it should be obvious to see that bystander effect is founded on the principle of Social Proof. But here comes the problem. If each person reasons the same way, everyone draws the same conclusion. “Since nobody is concerned, nothing is wrong. It can’t be an emergency.” Sometimes it’s also termed as Pluralistic Ignorance – a psychological state characterized by the belief that one’s private thoughts are different from those of others. Simply put, it’s a situation where everyone is thinking the same thing but believes he or she is the only person who thinks it. When it comes to explaining behavioural biases humorously, there is no one who can do it better than Dan Ariely, author of wildly popular book Predictably Irrational. Dan, in this short video, not only explains but demonstrates (watch it till the end) the idea of pluralistic ignorance.
www.safalniveshak.com
137
Chapter 16 - The Bystander Effect | Mental Models, Investing, And You Social psychologists determined that when the potential helper doesn’t see anyone around, except the victim, he’s more likely to come forward for help. So the more people present when a person needs emergency help, the less likely it is any one of them will lend a hand. What aggravates pluralistic ignorance? Cialdini writes – It seems that the pluralistic ignorance effect is strongest among strangers: Because we like to look poised and sophisticated in public. I suspect if people were to witness the Genovese murder case in present time, instead of watching silently they would, probably and unfortunately, tweet about it.
Image Source: Eric Allie Cartoons.
www.safalniveshak.com
138
Chapter 16 - The Bystander Effect | Mental Models, Investing, And You
Breaking The Spell of Pluralistic Ignorance So the two primary factors that create bystander effect is uncertainty about the emergency and diffusion of responsibility. If we can address these two things, we can break the spell of pluralistic ignorance. Many studies have shown it takes only one person to help for others to join in. Whether it is to donate blood, assist someone in changing a tire, drop money into a performer’s coffers, or stop a fight—people rush to help once they see another person leading by example. In fact, it’s usually not the first person but the second one who tips the attention of the crowd. See this video where the first follower converts a lone nut’s dance into a movement. God forbid, if you ever find yourself in a situation where you’re the one who needs the help and people around you seemed to be under a strong spell of Bystander effect, what should you do? The key is to first realize that bystanders fail to help, not because they are unkind, but because they are unsure. They are still guessing whether an emergency actually exists and whether they are responsible for taking action. Should you cry for help? No, that doesn’t work as we have seen in the case of Catherine Genovese. Cialdini suggests – Based on the research findings we have seen, my advice would be to isolate one individual from the crowd: Stare, speak and point directly at that person and on one else: “You, sir, in the blue jacket, I need help. Call an ambulance.” With that one utterance you should dispel all the uncertainties that might prevent or delay help…In
www.safalniveshak.com
139
Chapter 16 - The Bystander Effect | Mental Models, Investing, And You general, then, you best strategy when in need of emergency help is to reduce the uncertainties of those around you concerning your condition…Be as precise as possible about your need for aid. Do not allow bystanders to come to their own conclusions because, especially in a crowd, the principle of social proof and the consequent pluralistic ignorance effect might well cause them to view your situation as nonemergency. When a person realizes that he’s the one responsible for taking an action, bystander effect disappears. There is no diffusion of responsibility. So the takeaway here is to remember you are not so smart when it comes to helping people. In a crowded room, or a public street, you can expect people to freeze up and look around at one another. I hope you remember the fairy tale about The Emperor’s New Clothes where everyone pretends the king is wearing clothes, until a child points out the emperor isn’t wearing any clothes. Whether it’s the naked emperor or a rag picker dying on street, the Bystander Effect gives both of them an equal treatment – a stare of ignorance.
In Investing Warren Buffett says – We derive no comfort because important people, vocal people, or great numbers of people agree with us. Nor do we derive comfort if they don’t. A stock price may or may not reflect the true value of the underlying business, however what it does reflect, at all times, is either the pluralistic ignorance or the wisdom of the crowd. How would you know?
www.safalniveshak.com
140
Chapter 16 - The Bystander Effect | Mental Models, Investing, And You Is the falling stock price really an emergency situation i.e. is the underlying business is deteriorating? Does it require your intervention, in terms of selling your holding or buying more? Why is nobody buying a particular stock which is languishing in spite of a great underlying business? May be it’s a victim of bystander effect. But how do you know? The only way you can know that is by becoming an independent thinker. By not letting the uncertainty and the diffusion of responsibility let you affect. Decide for yourself, do your own evaluation, think independently and then take action. As we have seen in the case of the lone dancer in the video, you could be the first follower, the first mover and then you will reap the benefits when the crowd follows you.
In Business Most of the so called “independent directors” on the boards of publicly listed companies are mere bystanders. Even if some of them feel that the CEO of the company is taking wrong decisions, they rarely raise a voice against it. And the reason is again the same – uncertainty and diffusion of responsibility. Most independent directors sit on the board to help the CEO comply to regulation for a minimum number of independent directors. And of course the easy money (director’s compensation) doesn’t hurt. When an independent director doesn’t understand the business of the company and/or doesn’t have the required experience to contribute to the decision making process for the company, it’s obvious that he/she will be uncertain about the quality of decisions that CEO takes. Moreover, these people don’t have their skin in the game, i.e. their interests aren’t aligned with the minority shareholder, so their attitude is mostly – It’s not my responsibility.
www.safalniveshak.com
141
Chapter 16 - The Bystander Effect | Mental Models, Investing, And You Charlie Munger, while talking about social proof, said – …the outside directors on a corporate board usually display the near ultimate form of inaction. They fail to object to anything much short of an axe murder until some public embarrassment of the board finally causes their intervention. A typical board-of-directors’ culture was once well described by my friend, Joe Rosenfield, as he said, “They asked me if I wanted to become a director of Northwest Bell, and it was the last thing they ever asked me. In life and in business, the importance of independent thinking can never be over emphasized. It’s this one skill that will separate you from the crowd. George Patton wisely summarized the idea in few words, “If everyone is thinking alike, then somebody isn’t thinking.”
Conclusion Learning about mental models will not only make you smarter but can also save your life. Having seen the potentially dire consequences of bystander effect, you now know how to rescue yourself, if you ever find yourself a victim of emergency situation in a public place.
www.safalniveshak.com
142
Chapter 17 Liking Bias It was March 2007 and I was desperately looking for a tax saving investment product. Until that year I had been sticking to the old fashioned conservative options like tax saving FDs and LIC policies. But the stock market frenzy of 2007 was rubbing off on me. So when I received a call from a stranger who called himself a “financial advisor” and showed a great concern for my financial wellbeing, I couldn’t say no to his request for a meeting. Although the young chap seemed to have just a few years of experience in the industry but his demeanor was nothing less than that of a CEO of a large company. He was well dressed, tidy, confident and articulate. When we met he took interest in my hobbies and complimented me about my reading habits. Needless to say I took an instant liking to him. He told me about a new financial product called ULIP (unit linked insurance plan). I had never heard of ULIP, so before committing any money to it I borrowed some time from him and did a quick research on google. The reviews on the internet weren’t very encouraging. Some even claimed of unethical selling by private banks and insurance companies as far as ULIP was concerned. But my financial advisor seemed to know what he was talking and I liked him. He even told me that one of his elder cousin was from my college. So I went ahead and invested my money.
www.safalniveshak.com
143
Chapter 17 - Liking Bias | Mental Models, Investing, And You It turned out that I wasn’t the only one who lost money in toxic financial products which were indiscriminately peddled by many suit-tie wearing sales people. So why did I succumb in spite of knowing that ULIP wasn’t the best option for me? I would like to put the blame on the so called “financial advisor”. But he was just doing his job i.e. selling stuff. Even today I can’t imagine him as a crook or unethical person. It was much later, after reading Robert Cialdini’s book Influence, when the realization set in that I had been a victim of something called Liking Bias or Liking Tendency. Because of liking tendency, we tend to like who are physically attractive, popular, cooperative, or people we have positive associations with. Also, those who are similar to us in background, opinion, lifestyle, interest, attitude, looks, values, and belief. We also like and trust anything familiar. Most people prefer to say yes to the requests of someone they know and like. It’s a natural tendency to ignore the faults of those we find likeable while doing just the opposite to the people we don’t like. According to Charlie Munger, Liking tendency acts as a conditioning device that makes the liker or lover tend: 1. To ignore the faults of, and comply with the wishes of, the object of his affection; 2. To favor people, products, and actions merely associated with the object of his affection (Influence from Mere Association Tendency); and 3. To distort other facts to facilitate love.
www.safalniveshak.com
144
Chapter 17 - Liking Bias | Mental Models, Investing, And You Just as liking and loving make humans agree with each other despite their vices, the tendency to hate or dislike does the absolute reverse and leads to ignoring or refuting the person we dislike or hate despite the virtues. Here is what Munger has to say on that: Disliking/hating tendency also acts as a conditioning device that makes the disliker/hater tend to: 1. Ignore virtues in the objects of dislike, 2. Dislike people, products and actions merely associated with the objects of his dislike, and 3. Distort other facts to facilitate hatred Liking bias, due to its persuasion power, is widely used by negotiation experts and salespeople to tip the scale in their favour. Since it is extremely profitable, there is a huge demand of people who can persuade other people to take desired actions and some people have a natural flair for it. There are numerous examples of war Marshalls, CEOs, sports managers etc. In fact, the first thing any salesman is taught is to Be Likeable. Which means their sales training programs not only teach them all the nuances of communications skills but also teach them to dress well and create an impeccable first impression. Their aim is to be likeable even before they open their mouth. People who exploit this bias know that first impression is not only the last impression but the lasting impression too. Joe Girard is considered the most successful car salesman in the world. His tip for success:
www.safalniveshak.com
145
Chapter 17 - Liking Bias | Mental Models, Investing, And You There is nothing more effective in selling than getting the customer to believe, really believe, that you like him and care about him.
What Creates Liking Bias According to Cialdini following factors cause one person to like another person – 1. Physical Attractiveness – Research has shown that we automatically assign to good-looking individuals such favorable traits as talent, kindness, honesty, and intelligence. Good looking people are likely to receive highly favorable treatment in many setups including elections, employment interviews and even in judicial process. Experiments show that attractive criminals are seen as less aggressive and get a milder punishment than ugly criminals. In another study the better looking men and women received aid more often, even from members of their own sex. In short, good-looking people enjoy an enormous social advantage in our culture. 2. Similarity – We like people who are similar to us. This similarity could be in the area of opinions, personality traits, background, or lifestyle. Salespeople can manipulate similarity to increase liking by claiming that they have backgrounds and interests similar to ours. They are trained to look for evidence of such things while interacting with the potential customer. There are techniques like mirroring and matching the customer’s body posture, mood and verbal style to subconsciously trigger the feeling of similarity. As a corollary we don’t like the ones we perceive as dissimilar to us. 3. Being Liked – We like people who like us. If we feel that a person likes us, we tend to like them back. Remember Joe Girard? Do you know his trick to get his customers to like him? Each month he sent every one of his thousands of former customers a holiday greeting card containing just one line – ‘I like you’. Being liked and accepted is basic emotional need for all human beings. British Prime
www.safalniveshak.com
146
Chapter 17 - Liking Bias | Mental Models, Investing, And You Minister and novelist Benjamin Disraeli said, “Talk to a man about himself and he will listen for hours.” We are phenomenal suckers for flattery. And we reciprocate the way others see us. If we perceive others dislike us, we tend to dislike them. 4. Cooperation – We like people who cooperate with us. How do we get people to cooperate? Create an external common threat or an opportunity for mutual gain. A typical example could be a salesman pretends to be on our side and “negotiates with his boss” to secure a good deal for us. Another example is the good cop/bad cop trick routinely employed by police to get a confession from a suspect. One police officer acts hostile and other, acting as a good cop, tries to calm down his angry partner and pretending a soft corner for the suspect. The suspect develops a subconscious liking for the good cop and cooperates. Here’s another interesting trick. Asking a favor of someone is likely to increase that person’s liking for us. Counterintuitive right? But it works because people want to be seen as consistent with their behavior. Benjamin Franklin tells us about an old maxim: “He that has once done you a kindness will be more ready to do you another, than he whom you yourself have obliged.”
In Business In his book, The Art of Thinking Clearly, Rolf Dobelli writes – Aid agencies employ the liking bias to a great effect. Their campaigns use beaming children or women almost exclusively. Never will you see a stone faced, wounded guerrilla fighter staring at you from billboards – even though
he
also
needs
your
support.
Conservation
organizations also carefully select who gets the starring
www.safalniveshak.com
147
Chapter 17 - Liking Bias | Mental Models, Investing, And You role in their advertisements. Have you ever seen a World Wildlife Fund brochure filled with spiders, worms, algae or bacteria? They are perhaps just as endangered as pandas, gorillas, koalas and seals – and even more important for the ecosystem. But we feel nothing for them. The more human a creature acts, the more similar it is to us, the more we like it. Companies already understand this. Employees at Disney theme parks and Hilton Hotels wear name tags emblazoned with their hometowns. So the visitors feel comfortable when they see people from their own place.
In Investing Almost all the financial news commentators on TV have great personalities and outstanding communication skills. You’ll never find them untidy or with unkempt hair. They’re articulate, confident, humourous and witty. There’s no way you can’t like these talking heads on TV unless you have lost significant money following their advices and forecasts. Some of them are so likeable that people don’t mind losing money and still continue to like them. That’s the power of psychological biases. You can’t counter its force even if you know about it. So the only way to save yourself from this is to stop watching financial news channels. Many successful investors don’t talk to the management because they understand the power of liking bias. A direct talk with a management, especially a charismatic CEO with likeable personality, can trigger liking bias and create a prejudice in our minds. The legendary investor Peter Lynch reminds us not to fall in love/get emotional with a stock. The stock doesn’t know that we own it, so falling in love with it only makes us susceptible to bad judgment.
www.safalniveshak.com
148
Chapter 17 - Liking Bias | Mental Models, Investing, And You Remaining detached enough from our investments to look at them objectively is a crucial skill to becoming a successful investor.
Overcoming Liking Bias The biggest problem with behavioural biases is that their force is so strong that it’s extremely difficult to counter them. And the best strategy is to avoid being in such situations. So this is what Guy Spier writes in his book, The Education of a Value Investor, about how he deals with such situations – …I soon began to see that I made lousy decisions when I bought things that salespeople were hawking to me. The problem is that my brain (and most likely your brain too) is awful at making rational decisions when confronted with
a
well-argued,
detailed
pitch
from
a
gifted
salesperson. So I adopted a simple rule that has proved extraordinarily beneficial. When people call to pitch me anything at all, I reply in as pleasant a manner as possible, “I’m sorry. But I have a rule that I don’t allow myself to buy anything that’s being sold to me.” I may miss out in the short term. But over a lifetime I have no doubt that I’ll benefit much more by detaching myself from people with a self-interest in getting me to buy stuff. So now whenever I get a call from these financial advisors, asking for a meeting, I just refuse to meet them.
www.safalniveshak.com
149
Chapter 17 - Liking Bias | Mental Models, Investing, And You Still you may find yourself in such situations where it’s unlikely that you could muster a timely protection against the unconscious effect of liking bias. First thing that needs to happen in that situation is to bring the awareness. Ask yourself, “Have I come to like this person more than I would have expected in such a short time?” If the answer is yes then it’s time for a quick counter maneuver, which doesn’t mean that you should look for reasons to dislike the person. That would be like fighting with natural force of behavioural bias which isn’t going to help much. What you need to do is to put a conscious effort to separate the person from the deal. Concentrate exclusively on the merits of the deal. Try to look at the facts and situation objectively. This may save you.
Conclusion We do things for people we like, because it’s a natural reciprocation to being liked. William James said, “The deepest principle in human nature is the craving to be appreciated.” So don’t forget that I like you!
www.safalniveshak.com
150
Chapter 18 Winner’s Curse Consider this thought experiment – A friend of yours is the Chairman of the Acme Oil Company. He occasionally calls with a problem and asks your advice. This time the problem is about bidding in an auction. It seems another oil company has gone into bankruptcy and is forced to sell off some of the land it has acquired for future oil exploration. There is one plot Acme is interested. Until recently, it was expected that only three firms would bid for the plot, and Acme intended to bid $10 million. Now they have learned that seven more firms are bidding, bringing the total to ten. The question is, should Acme increase or decrease its bid? What advice would you give? Do you advise bidding more or less? If you’re like me and seeing this case study for the first time you’d probably go with a higher bid. After all, there are additional bidders, and if you don’t bid more you won’t get this land. Isn’t it? Unfortunately, if you decide to increase the bid, you’d be falling in a trap called Winner’s Curse. The above example of oil auction comes from Richard Thaler’s book The Winner’s Curse. Thaler writes – Most people’s intuition in this problem is to bid more…However, there is another important consideration that is often ignored. Suppose that each participant in the auction is willing to bid just a little bit less than the amount he or she thinks the land is worth (leaving some room for the profits). Of course, no one knows exactly how much oil
www.safalniveshak.com
151
Chapter 18 - Winner’s Curse | Mental Models, Investing, And You is in the ground: some bidders will guess too high, other too low. Suppose, for the sake of argument, that the bidders have accurate estimate on average. Then, who will be the person who wins the auction? The winner will be the person who was the most optimistic about the amount of oil in the ground, and the person may well have bid more than the land is worth. This is the dreaded winner’s curse. In other words, the winner’s curse says that in a competitive auction, the highest bidder will typically overpay for the asset. Hence the bidder “wins” the auction but is “cursed” by the overpayment. “Winning is an informative event, telling us whose estimate was most optimistic,” writes Peter Bevelin, in his book Seeking Wisdom “When we place a bid on a house, company, project, or negotiate to buy something, we don’t realize what is implied by an acceptance of our offer. That we may have overestimated its value and therefore paid too much.” Following are the key characteristics of a winner’s curse situation – 1.
There are many bidders. That’s because auctions, by definition, are competitive. If there is only one bidder it is not an auction, it is a sale.
2.
No one is certain about the true value of the asset being auctioned.
3.
The winner is typically the one who is most optimistic about the value of the asset.
Winner’s curse becomes very important mental model in corporate mergers and acquisitions, because when companies bid against one another to buy a target corporation, the highest bidder frequently pays too much.
www.safalniveshak.com
152
Chapter 18 - Winner’s Curse | Mental Models, Investing, And You In his book, The Art of Thinking Clearly, Rolf Dobelli writes – The Winner’s curse suggests that the winner of an auction often turns out to be the loser. Industry analysts have noted that companies that regularly emerged as winning bidders from these oilfields auctions systematically paid too much, and years later went under. This is understandable…The highest bid at an auction is often much too high –unless these bidders have critical information other aren’t privy to. Today this phenomenon affects us all. From eBay to Groupon to Google AdWords, prices are consistently set by auction. Bidding wars for cell phone frequencies drive telecom companies to the brink of bankruptcy. Initial public offerings (IPO) are also examples of auctions. And, when companies buy other companies – the infamous mergers and acquisitions – the winner’s curse is present more often than not. Astoundingly, more than half of all acquisitions destroy value, according to a McKinsey study. So why do we fall victim to the winner’s curse? First, the real value of many things is uncertain. Additionally, the more interested parties, the greater the likelihood of an overly enthusiastic bid. Second, we want to outdo competitors. The buyer in an auction is no longer just purchasing a product, he or she is engaged in a test of will, trying to outdo other participants. Remember Warren Buffett’s words – It’s not greed that drives the world, but envy.
www.safalniveshak.com
153
Chapter 18 - Winner’s Curse | Mental Models, Investing, And You According to Charlie Munger, open-outcry auctions are a perfect setup for driving people to highly irrational behaviour. Auction is a place where multiple psychological biases act together, creating a lollapalooza effect, and results in a series of bad decisions. The list of cognitive biases that are at play in an auction is just mind boggling. Here’s a sample that I pulled out from Prof. Bakshi’s recent blog post– … an open-outcry auction situation is a very interesting social setting where multiple models from psychology like authority (where the auctioneer is a symbol of authority who not only certifies the authenticity of the object being auctioned, he also announces an initial big price which serves as an “anchor”, social proof (caused by observing other bidders bid up the price), the incentives of the auctioneer (the higher the price at which the object sold, the
more
the
money
reciprocation/retaliation
made
by
the
auctioneer),
(resulting
in
competitive
bidding), envy , low contrast effect (every new bid is a small increment over a previous bid), commitment bias (every bid and escalation of the bid is a public commitment), overconfidence, and deprival super reaction (caused by the countdown to end of auction) combine to turn this social setting into something like a death trap.
In Business Many business acquisitions are justified using fancy jargons such as ‘synergistic benefits’ and ‘strategic advantage’. But what really happens in most acquisitions? The winning bid is largely a result of overestimation of future benefits and succumbing to the competitive pressures (with investment bankers adding fuel to the fire). One just
www.safalniveshak.com
154
Chapter 18 - Winner’s Curse | Mental Models, Investing, And You has to look at the projected ‘synergistic benefits’ at the time of benefits and the actual results a couple of years down the line. If you want see the proof, you don’t need to go very far. In his post, Prof. Bakshi quotes the example of Tata Steel’s disastrous acquisition of Corus in 2006 in a competitive open-outcry auction. Just before Tata Steel’s first bid on 20 October, 2006, the market cap of the company was about Rs 26,000 cr. On 31 January, 2007 Tata Steel won its bid for Corus after offering 608 pence per share for the target company, valuing it for about $11 billion. Eight years later, Tata Steel’s market cap stands at Rs 23,000 cr. What an amazing case of value destruction! And Hindalco’s acquisition of Novelis was not different. Knowing what happens to people who get into open-outcry, auction-like situations, psychologically astute people like Buffett and Munger have a no-fault rule when they get invited to auction situations. The rule is: Don’t Go. When you win an auction, what you win is the right to pay more (for the asset being auctioned) than everyone else thought it was worth. Explained in this way, it’s quite easy to see why Warren Buffett had this simple “Don’t Go!” advice for auctions. Winner’s curse presents itself not just in auctions and large M&A activities but even in smaller business decisions. Let’s say you are the business head who has limited resources to execute only one project among many. All your 10 reporting managers have presented their plans to you. Which one would you pick? Of course, the one that looks most attractive. Isn’t it?
www.safalniveshak.com
155
Chapter 18 - Winner’s Curse | Mental Models, Investing, And You But all managers have an incentive to make their own project the most attractive one. The risk is therefore that you end up choosing the project with the most optimistic forecast. Which means you selected the one which has higher chances of turning out to be more expensive and time consuming than it was initially projected to be.
In Investing The winner’s curse does not need a fancy auction. The same curse may be visited on an investor in a hurry to buy a stock on which someone has provided a hot tip. During bull markets, the rising prices and increasing demand for the stocks creates an auction like environment. As the price of equities climb, more and more people get enticed into making higher bids and driving the prices even higher. In effect, people who agree to buy stocks at inflated prices are being overly optimistic, just like an auction winner, about the future prospects of the businesses which those stocks represent. If you want to participate in the stock market auctions, you must ascertain the true value of what’s being offered. Peter Bevelin, in his book Seeking Wisdom, writes (emphasis mine)Research shows that the more bidders there are competing for a limited object, each having the same information, and the more uncertain its value is, the more likely we are to overpay. Instead, if our objective is to create value, the more bidders there are, the more conservative our bidding should be. This also implies that the less information we have compared to other bidders or the more uncertain we are about the underlying value, the lower we should bid. It’s the winner’s curse that Warren Buffett warns us against when he says, “Be fearful when others are greedy.”
www.safalniveshak.com
156
Chapter 18 - Winner’s Curse | Mental Models, Investing, And You So how do you save yourself from Winner’s curse? First, acquire as much information as you can. If you can determine what an item (or a stock) is worth, you will avoid overspending. And second, know your limits. If you do not have enough information, wait and get some more, and if you think long and hard to establish a top price, stick to it. Additionally, thinking about following questions can help you in making a rational decision. 1.
How would I reason if I think it through from the viewpoint of the other person?
2.
Why are they selling? Don’t forget that the seller might have an informational advantage. So why would I make a better decision than someone who has all the information?
3.
The other person is most likely to accept our offer when it’s least favourable to us, especially when he or she is anonymous (typical in stock market transactions). What are the chances that the other person’s decision is being made under pressure and is irrational?
In fact, a practitioner of value investing tries to find a situation which is reverse of an auction. Chetan Parikh, an accomplished value investor, writes in his blog In value investing you are buying a stock where in many cases sellers are bidding to sell you a company at lower levels (how else do you explain the fact that even 70 years after Benjamin Graham’s Security Analysis, one gets to buy companies at less than cash on the balance sheet). Also
www.safalniveshak.com
157
Chapter 18 - Winner’s Curse | Mental Models, Investing, And You most of the estimates are working in your favour if like all good value investors, you insist on a good margin of safety.
Conclusion To summarize, in an auction with many bidders, the winning bidder is often a loser. A key factor in avoiding the winner’s curse is bidding more conservatively when there are more bidders. While this may seem counterintuitive, it is the rational thing to do. Remember, when the applause of the auction is over, you want to make sure you are still happy with the deal.
www.safalniveshak.com
158
SECTION 2: STATISTICS
www.safalniveshak.com
159
Chapter 19 Mean Reversion There are certain days in everybody’s life which in spite of being ordinary remain etched in the memory for a long time. It was 15th of December. I distinctly remember it because I bought my car that day. The ownership of new car brought with it an excitement to take care of it. The first task in front of me was to be diligent about tracking the mileage. At an average of 13 km/liter it was a satisfactory performance. However, after few weeks I started noticing that the mileage numbers would go down occasionally and then come back again to the normal. There wasn’t any change in my driving style or driving routes. Except the source of fuel there was no other variable that could cause the variation in performance. So my hypothesis was that the quality of fuel was affecting my vehicle’s performance. To empirically validate my hypothesis, I decided to keep track of different fuel stations where I got the petrol from. The next time when I saw a dip in the mileage numbers I went to a different fuel station and the improvement in the numbers followed. This made me conclude that my earlier fuel station was the culprit. Having discovered this, yours truly (i.e. me) proudly announced his statistical prowess to everybody and asked them to avoid that particular fuel station. Not long after discovering the “dishonest fuel pump,” I started seeing those mileage fluctuations again. Obviously my earlier deduction was flawed. So what happened then?
www.safalniveshak.com
160
Chapter 19 - Mean Reversion | Mental Models, Investing, And You Daniel Kahneman recounts a similar experience in his book Thinking Fast and Slow. While teaching flight instructors he was told how the act of praising the pilots on a recent good performance usually resulted in a poorer performance subsequently and vice versa. This logic goes against the conventional motivation theory that encouragement leads to improved performance. According to Kahneman, the flaw in their reasoning was that they had attached a causal interpretation to the inevitable fluctuations of a random process. Let’s try to understand the concept in light of my mileage counting experiment. The reality was that my mileage numbers were experiencing fluctuations due to randomness and there didn’t exist any specific pattern. Even if I hadn’t changed my fuel station, I would have seen the mileage numbers improving anyway because the numbers were simply fluctuating around a mean. This phenomenon is called Mean Reversion. Mean reversion is a mental model from the field of statistics. It says that an event that is not average will be followed by an event that is closer to the average. I was suffering from the tendency to attribute meaning to a phenomenon governed only by chance. Here is an interesting insight from the book Innumeracy: Mathematical Illiteracy and Its Consequences – ...very intelligent people can be expected to have intelligent offspring, but in general the offspring will not be as intelligent as the parents. A similar tendency toward the average or mean holds for the children of very short parents, who are likely to be short, but not as short as their parents. If I throw twenty darts at a target and manage to hit the bull’s-eye eighteen times, the next time I throw twenty
darts,
I
probably
won’t
do
as
well.
This
phenomenon leads to nonsense when people attribute the
www.safalniveshak.com
161
Chapter 19 - Mean Reversion | Mental Models, Investing, And You regression to the mean to some particular scientific law, rather than to the natural behavior of any random quantity. Nassim Taleb in his book Fooled by Randomness observes – The ‘hot hand in basketball’ is another example of misperception of random sequences: It is very likely in a large sample of players for one of them to have an inordinately lengthy lucky streak. As a matter of fact it is very unlikely that an unspecified player somewhere doesn’t have an inordinately lengthy lucky streak. This is a manifestation of the mechanism called regression to the mean....in real life, the larger the deviation from the norm, the larger the probability of it coming from luck rather than skills...This can be easily verified in stories of very prominent people in trading rapidly reverting to obscurity, like the heroes I used to watch in trading rooms. Let’s see some of the areas where mean reversion raises some serious concerns about our decisions.
Your Doctor’s Secret Weapon Remember Mr. Irrational? It so happened that Mr. Irrational wasn’t keeping well due to common cold virus. Now for most people the immune system is strong enough to fight the virus and allow the body to heal on its own. Although this healing process usually takes few days. So after two days of discomfort, right when his body is on the verge of bouncing back to normal healthy state, Mr. Irrational decides to visit his doctor, Dr. Placebo. Remember Dr. Placebo? We discussed in Chapter 6 how Dr. Placebo himself suffers
www.safalniveshak.com
162
Chapter 19 - Mean Reversion | Mental Models, Investing, And You from a behavioural anomaly called “Do something Bias”. So Dr. Placebo prescribes a mild antibiotic drug, which is quite unnecessary in this case. Unsurprisingly, the very next day Mr. Irrational is back to normal, healthy as a horse. He concludes, irrationally of course, that Dr. Placebo has the ability to cure any disease in a single day. The inherent randomness present in the natural process of falling sick and healing back makes it an obvious candidate for mean reversion. Alas! Mr. Irrational hasn’t heard about mean reversion.
Scope of Mean Reversion It’s very important to understand that reversion to the mean is meaningful only in those activities or situations where there is some element of randomness involved. The intensity with which mean reversion affects an activity is directly proportional to the element of luck controlling the outcome in that activity. So if you are looking at something like professional swimming and recording the lap time for Michael Phelps, it won’t be a revelation that the outcome (lap timings) stays pretty much consistent with very little scope for reversion to the mean. Sports like swimming or chess are activities where luck plays relatively small role. They are dominated by skill resulting in very consistent and predictable outcomes. However, not all sports enjoy the same level of predictability. Games like Cricket, Basketball and especially many other team sports have quite a bit of luck dictating the end result. When it come to my car mileage there were myriad of factors like traffic conditions, road condition, the minor fluctuations in my driving style, the weather, wind speed etc. which affected the mileage. The randomness introduced by these environmental factors makes this activity prone to mean reversion.
www.safalniveshak.com
163
Chapter 19 - Mean Reversion | Mental Models, Investing, And You
In Investing You would agree with me that stock market investing is also one such activity where luck plays a significant role in investor’s performance. Consider this typical process that many investors follow. They look at the last few years performance of a fund manager and put their money in his fund. Soon they observe that the fund underperforms the benchmark for next few years. Frustrated and flabbergasted, they pull out the money and find another fund manager based on the same criteria i.e., last few years’ performance. The naive investor is clueless why the fund performance deteriorates immediately after he puts his money into it. Mean reversion buddy! In stock market periods of above average performance are usually followed by below average returns and periods of below average performance are typically followed by above average returns. When Warren Buffet said Be greedy when others are fearful and be fearful when others are greedy. He was perhaps hinting us to exploit the mean reversion. And that’s why it’s essential that you shouldn’t go just by the outcome (fund performance) of such activity. The trick is to look at the process that leads to the outcome. Choose the process which is sound and rational. The second trick for dampening the effect of mean reversion is to take a bigger sample size. Which means you shouldn’t rely on short term performance records. If you are looking at ten-year performance figures of a fund, then odds are high that the
www.safalniveshak.com
164
Chapter 19 - Mean Reversion | Mental Models, Investing, And You fluctuations introduced by randomness and luck have evened out over long term and what you see is a reasonable proxy for fund manager’s skill.
Illusion Created by Mean Reversion So we see that mean reversion creates two kinds of illusions. The first is the illusion of cause and effect. Out inherent tendency to look for what is causing a measurement to regress toward the mean, an exercise that is frequently fruitless. The second is the illusion of feedback, which makes it seem like favourable feedback leads to worse results and unfavourable feedback leads to better results. Michael Mauboussin, author of The Success Equation, writes in his book – Understanding and using the phenomenon of reversion to the mean is essential in making sound predictions [decisions]... Reversion to the mean is most pronounced at the extremes, so the first lesson is to recognize that when you see extremely good or bad results, they are unlikely to continue that way. This doesn’t mean that good results will necessarily be followed by bad results, or vice versa, but rather that the next thing that happens will probably be closer to the average of all things that happen. When I first understood the concept of mean reversion, it was one the eureka moments of life. Suddenly I had an answer for a lot of unexplained observations around me. Remember, the only reason mean reversion happens is because of randomness. Anytime you hear that mean reversion is happening because of competitive forces, declining moat, etc. wear your lens of mental models and then investigate further.
www.safalniveshak.com
165
Chapter 19 - Mean Reversion | Mental Models, Investing, And You
Conclusion In the current world of digital revolution and information explosion, it has become increasingly important for you to build a strong bullshit filter to separate the noise from real knowledge. Mean reversion is one such bullshit filter.
www.safalniveshak.com
166
Chapter 20 Law of Small Numbers Other than the closed glass chambers in the corporate world, there is one very unusual place where grand scheming about workplace strategies (office politics) happens regularly. Don’t worry, there is nothing hush-hush about this place and it’s not at all surrounded by thick soundproof walls. Wondering what I am talking about? Let me give you another hint. It’s the designated open area in every large company, where people go out in fresh air to fill their lungs with freshly brewed smoke. You guessed it right. I am talking about the smoking areas. Mind you, it’s not just a place trafficked by the smoke billowing nicotine guzzlers, but you’ll often find those hapless passive smokers too who don’t realize that their lungs are going to collapse sooner than their active smoker buddies. Before you dismiss my lame attempt at sarcasm, let me confess that I used to be one such ignorant passive smoker who would stand next to a friendly smoke machine and take pride in my ability to resist the temptation of those white sticks. Smokers! Please forgive me if I have offended you. But trust me, it was intentional! Anyways, my sole consolation on those suffocating trips were some of the delusional (and absolutely hilarious) arguments that I would get to hear by my nicotine addicted pals. You know what my favourite argument was? This one –
www.safalniveshak.com
167
Chapter 20 - Law of Small Numbers | Mental Models, Investing, And You My grandfather was a lifelong chain smoker and still lived up to a ripe age of 90 years. So don’t tell me that smoking kills.
Image Source: Fine Tobacco NYC There is just one problem with this logic – it is dead wrong! I can’t help but imagine how Charlie Munger would react to this line of thought. He would probably snort with laughter, as if he wanted to say – “Boy, you’re suffering from I-know-a-man syndrome.” A classic mistake of taking a specific instance and blindly generalizing it. Cognitive dissonance is one mental model that we had discussed in the April 2015 issue of Value Investing Almanack, which explains the self-deceptive behaviour of tobacco addicts. But an irrational behaviour is rarely the result of a single behavioural bias. We have something else at play here.
www.safalniveshak.com
168
Chapter 20 - Law of Small Numbers | Mental Models, Investing, And You What we’re going to explore today is a bias which was first identified by Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman. It’s called the Law of Small Numbers, also known as ‘insensitivity to sample size’. In fact, this ‘I-know-a-man-syndrome’ is an extreme case where people tend to generalize from small amounts of data. Most people, including many experts (involved in serious empirical research), don’t appreciate how research based upon small numbers or small populations can often generate extreme observations. As a result, people have a tendency to believe that a relatively small number of observations will closely reflect the general population. Consider my argument – “I know a man who jumped from 5th floor and survived the fall. Which implies that it’s safe for anyone to repeat the act.” “No it’s not!” Intuitively dismissing the argument, you might say, “It’s an aberration, an exception that can’t be relied on.” The point I am trying to make here is that sample size matters while trying to establish any patterns.
Fooled by Sample Size Next time when you watch a commercial on TV, pay attention and see if you find any of the following claims – “Seven out of ten housewives prefer this washing powder.” Or for that matter, “Four out of five dentists recommend this toothpaste.” Rings a bell? And there is no end to such compelling claims. It’s a common trick used by marketing people to win your trust. Truth be told, these claims don’t tell us anything unless we know how many dentists or housewives were surveyed. Maybe they surveyed just 10 housewives and dentists; an observation that can’t be extrapolated to include all dentists or housewives.
www.safalniveshak.com
169
Chapter 20 - Law of Small Numbers | Mental Models, Investing, And You Anytime you see such statistics thrown at you, please don’t forget to question the sample size. With small sample size, odds are pretty high that conclusions can’t be trusted. Peter Bevelin in his must-read book Seeking Wisdom, explains – A small sample size has no predictive value. The smaller the sample is, the more statistical fluctuations and the more likely it is that we find chance events. We need a representative comparison group, large enough sample size, and long enough periods of time. Small samples can cause us to believe a risk is lower or higher than reality. Why? A small sample increases the chance that we won’t find a particular relationship where it exists or find one where it doesn’t exist. Charlie Munger gives an example of the importance of getting representative data – even if it’s approximate – The water system of California was designed looking at a fairly short period of weather history. If they’d been willing to take less perfect records and look an extra hundred years back, they’d have seen that they weren’t designing it right to handle drought conditions which were entirely likely. Many a times people fall for the confirmation bias and try to back-fit the data to their theory or model. If something doesn’t fit their hypothesis, they discard it and cherry pick the smaller set of observations which conform to their assumptions. Munger adds –
www.safalniveshak.com
170
Chapter 20 - Law of Small Numbers | Mental Models, Investing, And You You see that again and again – that people have some information they can count well and they have other information much harder to count. So they make the decision based only on what they can count well. And they ignore much more important information because its quality in terms of numeracy is less – even though it’s very important in terms of reaching the right cognitive result. All I can tell you is that around Wesco and Berkshire, we try not to be like that. We have Lord Keynes’ attitude, which Warren quotes all the time: “We’d rather be roughly right than precisely wrong.” In other words, if something is terribly important, we’ll guess at it rather than just make our judgment based on what happens to be easily countable. In Thinking Fast and Slow, Daniel Kahneman writes – Extreme outcomes (both high and low) are more likely to be found in small than in large samples. So why do we fall for this bias? One reason is our love for stories. Instead of questioning the accuracy and uncertainty associated with the sample, we focus on the story those numbers are telling us. Kahneman further explains – The exaggerated faith in small samples is only one example of a more general illusion – we pay more attention to the content of messages than to information about their reliability, and as a result end up with a view of the world around us that is simpler and more coherent than the data
www.safalniveshak.com
171
Chapter 20 - Law of Small Numbers | Mental Models, Investing, And You justify. Jumping to conclusions is a safer sport in the world of our imagination than it is in reality.
Luck and Small Numbers It’s important to understand the context or circumstance where this fallacy becomes more pronounced. Let me use an example to explain my point. If you were observing Michael Phelps, the swimming legend, compete against few amateur swimmers, even few observations would be enough to make a generalization about future outcomes of such competitive events i.e., Michael Phelps will trounce each one of them every single time. Here you don’t need to worry about the law of small numbers. Why? The answer lies in understanding the role of skill and luck in any activity. The magnitude of the fallacy grows larger as the luck-to-skill ratio rises. Be it sports or investing, a lot in our life is governed by luck. Certain games (cricket or poker) have higher element of luck and some are completely devoid of luck (chess or swimming). So an amateur player can win a game of poker a few times just because of luck, but over a longer period of time i.e., over a large number of hands played, the luck evens out and skill prevails. A corollary to our law of small numbers would be – over short periods of time, luck is more important than skill. The more luck contributes to the outcome, the larger the sample you’ll need to distinguish between someone’s skill and pure chance. For that matter, how do you determine if an activity is ruled by luck or pure skill? There’s a simple and elegant test proposed by Michael Mauboussin in his book, The Success Equation, which is to ask whether you can lose on purpose. If you can’t lose
www.safalniveshak.com
172
Chapter 20 - Law of Small Numbers | Mental Models, Investing, And You on purpose, or if it’s really hard, luck likely dominates that activity. If it’s easy to lose on purpose, skill is more important. This has huge implications not only in sports but in investing too. David Einhorn, billionaire hedge fund manager and author of Fooling Some of the People All of the Time, explains – People ask me “Is poker luck?” and “Is investing luck?” The answer is, not at all. But sample sizes matter. On any given day a good investor or a good poker player can lose money. Any stock investment can turn out to be a loser no matter how large the edge appears. Same for a poker hand. One poker tournament isn’t very different from a coinflipping contest and neither is six months of investment results. On that basis luck plays a role. But over time – over thousands of hands against a variety of players and over hundreds
of
investments
in
a
variety
of
market
environments – skill wins out.
In Business and Investing Business and investing are fields where this fallacy is rampant and that’s because luck plays a significant role, especially in the short term. As a result, unscrupulous finance professionals (salesmen) mis-sell their useless financial products by decorating them with flawed performance statistics. Similarly, shrewd managements use the same tricks to hide their poor performance.
www.safalniveshak.com
173
Chapter 20 - Law of Small Numbers | Mental Models, Investing, And You If a mutual fund manager has had three above-average years in a row, many people will conclude that the fund manager is better than average, even though this conclusion does not follow from such a small amount of data. A prudent way to assess the real performance of a fund manager is to observe his returns and actions over a longer period of time. Recently, my relationship manager-cum-stockbroker offered me a new fund scheme. He claimed, “Our fund has generated a 60% CAGR in last one year.” It sounded not only misleading but outright hilarious. CAGR stands for compounded annual growth rate and the idea of compounding isn’t much useful if you’re talking about a period as short as one year. I am sure he would be peddling a different “one-year-60-percent-cagr” product to another gullible investor next year. Following the same line of inquiry, it’s obvious that while evaluating businesses, you should look at long-term performance numbers. Preferably past ten years. Doing this not only gives you an idea about resilience of the business during downturns, but also shrinks the possibility of extreme numbers (very poor performance in one quarter or extraordinary performance in another quarter) skewing your decision making process. I am guessing that this law is equally applicable in human relationships too. You can’t judge somebody’s character based on your interaction with him or her a couple of times. Character is revealed by observing a person’s behaviour under diverse set of situations and over extended periods of time.
Conclusion To summarize, relying on small set of observations, especially in activities where luck plays some role, can lead you to faulty conclusions. Many decision makers do not understand this fallacy and are often fooled by the high degree of randomness inherent in the small numbers.
www.safalniveshak.com
174
Chapter 20 - Law of Small Numbers | Mental Models, Investing, And You The solution is to develop a knack for placing an activity in the skill-luck continuum and maintain a healthy skepticism for the patterns observed in the small samples. I wish I could go back in time and tell my smoke buddy that his grandfather represented an extremely small sample size and perhaps the luck was heavily on his side. Who knows he could have survived past the age of 100 had he stopped smoking.
www.safalniveshak.com
175
Chapter 21 The Power Law Do you know how much property damage and loss of lives is caused by earthquakes every year? No idea? Consider this – An earthquake in Japan in 2011 caused an estimated property loss of US$ 235 billion. The deadliest earthquake in recorded history (in terms of loss of lives) occurred in Shaanxi (China) killing more than 800,000 people. According to one study, annual average losses from earthquakes range from US$ 1.3 to 5.7 billion. That’s loss per year because of all the earthquakes. This is quite huge, considering that it’s caused by an event which we have no control over. These statistics show that when mother nature’s fury is unleashed, even the modern society with all its technology and resources, finds itself helpless. Now another question. What do you think is the average loss caused by an earthquake, in terms of dollars per earthquake? Let’s do a quick back of the envelope calculation. So yearly loss of US$ 5.7 billion divided by number of earthquakes per year. How much would that be? Take a guess. Probably that number would be couple of million dollars per earthquake. Right? It’s actually little over US$ 10,000. That’s it! How come? That’s because the total number of earthquakes (excluding the ones that can’t be detected by instruments) occurring every year are more than 500,000. Yes you read it right.
www.safalniveshak.com
176
Chapter 21 - The Power Law | Mental Models, Investing, And You But the catch is that majority (more than 80 percent) of these tremors are so minor that they can’t even be felt by humans. Animals, they say, are more sensitive to such minute shocks. So next time when you see a dog with raised ears or a kitten with tilted head, they’re probably experiencing an earthquake. Of these 20 percent (100,000) earthquakes which are felt by humans. And about 1 percent actually cause any damage. So we see that more than 99 percent of the damage is caused by less than 1 percent of the earthquakes. That, my friend, is the Power Law, a very important mental model from Algebr