Mechanical Systems, Classical Models
MATHEMATICAL AND ANALYTICAL TECHNIQUES WITH APPLICATIONS TO ENGINEERING Series E...
104 downloads
1959 Views
7MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Mechanical Systems, Classical Models
MATHEMATICAL AND ANALYTICAL TECHNIQUES WITH APPLICATIONS TO ENGINEERING Series Editor
Alan Jeffrey
The importance of mathematics in the study of problems arising from the real world, and the increasing success with which it has been used to model situations ranging from the purely deterministic to the stochastic, in all areas of today's Physical Sciences and Engineering, is well established. The progress in applicable mathematics has been brought about by the extension and development of many important analytical approaches and techniques, in areas both old and new, frequently aided by the use of computers without which the solution of realistic problems in modern Physical Sciences and Engineering would otherwise have been impossible. The purpose of the series is to make available authoritative, up to date, and self-contained accounts of some of the most important and useful of these analytical approaches and techniques. Each volume in the series will provide a detailed introduction to a specific subject area of current importance, and then will go beyond this by reviewing recent contributions, thereby serving as a valuable reference source.
For further volumes: http://www.springer.com/series/7311
Mechanical Systems, Classical Models Volume III: Analytical Mechanics
by
Petre P. Teodorescu Faculty of Mathematics, University of Bucharest, Romania
123
Prof. Dr. Petre P. Teodorescu Str. Popa Soare 38 023984 Bucuresti 20 Romania
Translated into English, revised and extended by Petre P. Teodorescu All rights reserved © EDITURA TEHNICĂ, 2002 This translation of “Mechanical Systems, Classical Models” (original title: Sisteme mecanice.Modele clasice, Published by: Ed. Tehnicá, Bucuresti, Bucharest, Romania, 1984-2002), First Edition, is published by arrangement with EDITURA TEHNICĂ, Bucharest, ROMANIA
ISSN 1559-7458 e-ISSN 1559-7466 ISBN 978-90-481-2763-4 e-ISBN 978-90-481-2764-1 DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-2764-1 Springer Dordrecht Heidelberg London New York Library of Congress Control Number: 2007943834 c Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2009 No part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, microfilming, recording or otherwise, without written permission from the Publisher, with the exception of any material supplied specifically for the purpose of being entered and executed on a computer system, for exclusive use by the purchaser of the work. Printed on acid-free paper Springer is part of Springer Science+Business Media (www.springer.com)
Contents
Preface
ix
18.
Lagrangian Mechanics 1. Preliminary Results 1.1 Introductory Notions 1.2 Differential Principles of Mechanics 2. Lagrange’s Equations 2.1 Space of Configurations 2.2 Lagrange’s Equations of Second Kind 2.3 Transformations. First Integrals 3. Other Problems Concerning Lagrange’s Equations 3.1 New Forms of Lagrange’s Equations 3.2 Applications
1 2 2 20 45 46 57 65 83 83 98
19.
Hamiltonian Mechanics 1. Hamilton’s Equations 1.1 General Results 1.2 Lagrange’s Brackets. Poisson’s Brackets 1.3 Applications 2. The Hamilton–Jacobi Method 2.1 General Results 2.2 Systems of Equations with Separate Variables 2.3 Applications
115 115 115 138 151 160 160 172 191
20.
Variational Principles. Canonical Transformations 1. Variational Principles 1.1 Mathematical Preliminaries 1.2 The General Integral Principle 1.3 Hamilton’s Principle 1.4 Maupertuis’s Principle. Other Variational Principles 1.5 Continuous Mechanical Systems 2. Canonical Transformations 2.1 General Considerations. Conditions of Canonicity 2.2 Structure of Canonical Transformations. Properties 3. Symmetry Transformations. Noether’s Theorem. Conservation Laws 3.1 Symmetry Transformations. Noether’s Theorem
213 213 214 225 231 242 254 265 265 289 300 301 v
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
vi 3.2 3.3 21.
22.
Lie Groups Space-Time Symmetries. Conservation Laws
Other Considerations on Analytical Methods in Dynamics of Discrete Mechanical Systems 1. Integral Invariants. Ergodic Theorems 1.1 Integral Invariants of Order 2s 1.2 Invariants of First Order 1.3 Ergodic Theorems 2. Periodic Motions. Action-Angle Variables 2.1 Periodic Motions. Quasi-Periodic Motions 2.2 Action-Angle Variables 2.3 Adiabatic Invariance 3. Methods of Exterior Differential Calculus. Elements of Invariantive Mechanics 3.1 Methods of Exterior Differential Calculus 3.2 Elements of Invariantive Mechanics 3.3 Applications 4. Formalisms in the Dynamics of Mechanical Systems 4.1 Formalisms in Spaces with s + 1 Dimensions 4.2 Formalism in Spaces with 2s + 1 or with 2s + 2 Dimensions 4.3 Notions on the Inverse Problem of Mechanics and the Birkhoffian Formalism 5. Control Systems 5.1 Control Systems 5.2 Optimal Trajectories Dynamics of Non-holonomic Mechanical Systems 1. Kinematics of Non-holonomic Mechanical Systems 1.1 General Considerations 1.2 Conditions of Holonomy. Quasi-co-ordinates. Non-holonomic Spaces 2. Lagrange’s Equations. Other Equations of Motion 2.1 Motion of a Rigid Solid on a Fixed Surface 2.2 Lagrange’s Equations 2.3 Applications 2.4 Other Equations of Motion 3. Gibbs–Appell Equations 3.1 Gibbs–Appell Equations of Motion 3.2 Applications 4. Other Problems on the Dynamics of Non-holonomic Mechanical Systems 4.1 Collisions 4.2 First Integrals of the Equations of Motion
311 319 335 335 335 341 354 356 356 361 365 368 368 373 385 390 390 394 397 402 402 407 411 411 411 421 430 430 436 443 467 478 478 482 491 491 498
Contents
23.
24.
Stability and Vibrations 1. Stability of Mechanical Systems 1.1 Stability of Equilibrium 1.2 Stability of Motion 1.3 Applications 2. Vibrations of Mechanical Systems 2.1 Small Free Oscillations About a Stable Position of Equilibrium 2.2 Small Forced Oscillations 2.3 Non-linear Vibrations 2.4 Applications Dynamical Systems. Catastrophes and Chaos 1. Continuous and Discrete Dynamical Systems 1.1 Continuous Linear Dynamical Systems 1.2 Non-linear Differential Equations and Systems of Non-linear Differential Equations 1.3 Discrete Linear Dynamical Systems 2. Elements of the Theory of Catastrophes 2.1 Ramifications 2.2 Elementary Catastrophes 3. Periodic Solutions. Global Bifurcations 3.1 Periodic Solutions 3.2 Global Bifurcations 4. Fractals. Chaotic Motions 4.1 Fractals 4.2 Chaotic Motions
vii 505 505 505 537 554 566 566 597 606 612 629 630 630 648 675 682 683 689 697 698 707 712 712 723
Bibliography
739
Subject Index
759
Name Index
765
“This page left intentionally blank.”
Preface
All phenomena in nature are characterized by motion. Mechanics deals with the objective laws of mechanical motion of bodies, the simplest form of motion. In the study of a science of nature, mathematics plays an important rôle. Mechanics is the first science of nature which has been expressed in terms of mathematics, by considering various mathematical models, associated to phenomena of the surrounding nature. Thus, its development was influenced by the use of a strong mathematical tool. As it was already seen in the first two volumes of the present book, its guideline is precisely the mathematical model of mechanics. The classical models which we refer to are in fact models based on the Newtonian model of mechanics, that is on its five principles, i.e.: the inertia, the forces action, the action and reaction, the independence of the forces action and the initial conditions principle, respectively. Other models, e.g., the model of attraction forces between the particles of a discrete mechanical system, are part of the considered Newtonian model. Kepler’s laws brilliantly verify this model in case of velocities much smaller then the light velocity in vacuum. Mechanics has as object of study mechanical systems. The first two volumes of this book dealt with particle dynamics and with discrete and continuous mechanical systems, respectively. The present one deals with analytical mechanics. We put in evidence the Lagrangian and the Hamiltonian mechanics, where the study of first integrals plays a very important rôle. The Hamilton–Jacobi method is widely considered, as well as the study of systems with separate variables. We mention also a thorough study of variational principles and canonical transformations. The symmetry transformations, including Noether’s theorem, lead to conservation laws. Integral invariants and exterior differential calculus are also included. A particular attention has been given to non-holonomic mechanical systems. Problems of stability and vibrations have been also considered in the frame of Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics. The study of dynamical systems leads to catastrophes, bifurcations and chaos. One presents some applications connected to important phenomena of the nature and one gives also the possibility to solve problems presenting interest from technical, engineering point of view. In this form, the book becomes – we dare say – a unique outline of the literature in the field; the author wishes to present the most important aspects related with the study of mechanical systems, mechanics being regarded as a science of nature, as well as its links to other sciences of nature. Implications in technical sciences are not neglected. Concerning the mathematical tool, the five appendices in the first volume give the book an autonomy with respect to other works, special previous mathematical knowledge being not necessary. The numeration of the chapters follows that of the first ix
x
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
two volumes, to which one makes reference for various results (theorems, formulae etc.). I am grateful to Mărgărit Baubec, Ph.D., for his valuable help in the presentation of this book. The excellent cooperation with the team of Springer, Dordrecht, is gratefully acknowledged. The book covers a wide number of problems (classical or new ones) as one can see from its contents. It uses the known literature, as well as the original results of the author and his more than 50 years experience as Professor of Mechanics at the University of Bucharest. It is devoted to a large circle of readers: mathematicians (especially those involved in applied mathematics), physicists (particularly those interested in mechanics and its connections), chemists, biologists, astronomers, engineers of various specialities (civil, mechanical engineers etc., who are scientific researchers or designers), students in various domains etc. Bucharest, Romania 7 January 2009
P.P. Teodorescu
Chapter 18 Lagrangian Mechanics The analytical methods of calculation have been introduced to can study in a systematic and unitary form the discrete mechanical systems (with a finite number of particles or with a finite number of degrees of freedom); thus, appears the denomination of “analytical mechanics”, besides that of “theoretical mechanics” (in the English, German and Russian literature) and that of “rational mechanics” (in the French or Italian literature). In “physical mechanics” stress is put on the experimental aspect, while in “technical mechanics” on the possibility to apply in technics the results obtained. In all these cases, the object of study is the same: mechanics, as a science of nature. In this order of ideas, we consider a discrete mechanical system S , formed by n particles Pi (or a finite number of rigid solids), of position vectors ri , subjected to the action of given forces Fi , i = 1, 2, ..., n (the resultants of all external and internal given forces which act upon the particle Pi ) and to certain links Lk , k = 1, 2, ..., nL . The basic problem which is put consists in the determination of the motion (position and velocity) of the mechanical system S in the time interval [t0 , t1 ] (eventually, [t0 , ∞ ) ) if Fi = Fi ( rj , rj ; t ) , Lk = Lk ( rj , rj ; t ) , ri (t0 ) = ri0
and
vi (t0 ) = vi0 , i = 1, 2, ..., n , k = 1, 2, ..., nL are given. A distinction between external and internal forces is not necessary; in exchange, the classification of the constraints and their representation in a finite or differential form, as well as their elimination from the calculation (when it is possible) have a particular importance. The elimination of the constraints and of the constraint forces from the calculation allows to obtain equations of motion which contain only the position vectors and their derivatives with respect to time. In general, one admits only frictionless constraints, which – obviously – restrains much the sphere of the problems which can by treated. Euler, in 1736, and Maclaurin, in 1742, have written the first treatises of mechanics in which they pass from purely geometric methods to methods based on differential calculus (Euler, L., 1736). The brothers Jacob I Bernoulli and Jean I Bernoulli, Daniel Bernoulli, the son of the latter one, Alexis-Claude Clairaut, Jacob Herman and PierreLouis-Moreau de Maupertuis have made important steps, considering many problems and enouncing various “principles”, which allowed to put in equation the problems of mechanics and to give their solution in a unitary form. “A special ability was always necessary to put in evidence the forces which have to be taken into consideration, so P.P. Teodorescu, Mechanical Systems, Classical Models, © Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2009
1
2
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
that each problem become piquant, exciting the emulation; ... the treatise on dynamics of Jean le Rond d’Alembert, appeared in 1743, has put an end to this kind of competition, offering a direct and general method to solve or – at least – to put in equation all the problems of dynamics which one could imagine”. These affirmations have been made by Joseph-Louis Lagrange in his famous treatise “Mécanique analytique”, which appeared in Paris, in 1788, in which mechanics is presented as an abstract science, as a chapter of mathematical analysis, which can be studied without using any figure (Lagrange,J.L., 1788). Thus, the theory of systems of ordinary differential equations, the variational calculus, the theory of punctual and canonical transformations, the theory of Pfaff forms, the theory of integral invariants etc. have been developed, the impulse given by Lagrange to the study of mechanical systems having a particular importance for the development of analysis, as well as of other chapters of mathematics. We consider, in the frame of this chapter, a discrete mechanical system S , formed – in general – by a finite number of particles and by a finite number of rigid solids (as it has been considered in Sect. 17.1.1.1); hence, the system has a finite number of degrees of freedom. For the sake of simplicity, we assume – so as it is made in any classical study, without loss of generality – that the system S is formed by a finite number of a particles; when it is necessary or when intervene particular data we refer to rigid solids too. Thus, after some preliminary results, we will do a detailed study of Lagrange’s equations of motion, which will be then applied to some important problems (Appell, P., 1941–1953; Goldstein, H., 1956; Lamb, H., 1929; Landau, L.D. and Lifchitz, E., 1960; La Valée-Poussin, Ch.J. de, 1925; Lurie, A.I., 2002; Mercier, A., 1955).
18.1 Preliminary Results First of all, we will present some introductory motions, which allow to pass from the representation of the discrete mechanical system S in the space E 3 to its representation by means of a representative point P in the representative space E 3 n . Passing in review the differential principles of mechanics, we can study the motion of the mechanical system S in the new considered space.
18.1.1 Introductory Notions In what follows we use the notions of displacement for a mathematical representation of the nL constraints Lk , k = 1, 2,..., nL ; this allows to introduce the notion of representative space E 3 n . A particular attention is given to the natural systems and to the particle subjected to non-holonomic constraints. 18.1.1.1 Displacements. Constraints One of the most important notions in the frame of the analytical methods is that of displacement; this notion has been introduced and considered at large in Sect. 3.2.1.1, putting in evidence the real displacements dri , the possible displacements Δri and the
Lagrangian Mechanics
3
virtual displacements δri of the particle Pi , of position vector ri , i = 1, 2,..., n . Starting from the displacements, one can define the real velocities vi = dri / dt , the possible velocities vi = Δri / Δt and the virtual velocities vi∗ = δri / Δt . In case of a particle subjected to stay on a fixed curve C or on a fixed surface S (steady case), the virtual displacement is directed along the tangent to the curve or is contained in the plane tangent to the surface at the point P , respectively; in both cases, the real displacement belongs to the (finite or infinite) set of virtual displacements. If the rigid S , e.g., is movable, then the virtual displacements take place in the tangent plane to this surface at the moment t (we consider the surface to be frozen at this moment), while the real displacement links the particle P situated at the point P of this surface at this moment t to the particle P situated at the point P of the surface at the moment t + dt ; hence, in a non-steady case, the real displacement does no more belong to the set of virtual displacements of the considered particle. This statement can be made in the case of a deformable surface S too. The constraints to which is subjected the discrete mechanical system S can be external or internal; in the following, this distinction is not useful. As well, we make distinction between unilateral (expressed by inequalities) and bilateral (represented in the form of equalities) constraints; in analytical mechanics, we will consider all the constraints to be – in general – bilateral. Another distinction is made between constraints of contact and constraints at distance; both these types of constraints can be expressed by equalities. A large study of the constraints is made in Chap. 3, Sect. 2.2. Another classification of the constraints, after Hertz, puts in evidence the holonomic (finite, of geometric nature) and the non-holonomic constraints (infinitesimal or differential, of kinematic nature). After Lothar Bolzmann, the constraints which do not depend explicitly on time are called scleronomic (stationary) constraints, those which vary in time being rheonomous (non-stationary) constraints. As a matter of fact, taking into account these classifications, one obtains a mathematical representation of the constraints. We mention also the distinction between ideal (perfect, smooth) constraints and constraints with friction (real). Analytical mechanics has been developed for discrete mechanical systems; some results can be adapted to the case with friction too. In the absence of the constraints Lk , k = 1, 2, ..., nL , the discrete mechanical system
S is a free mechanical system. The axiom of liberation from constraints states that there exists always a system of forces Ri , which is applied upon the mechanical system S subjected to constraints, so that each particle Pi can be treated as a free particle subjected to the action of the force Fi + Ri , i = 1, 2,..., n ; consequently, the mechanical system S can be studied as a free one. The forces Fi are given (known) forces, while the forces Ri are constraint (unknown) forces. The real elementary work dW of the given forces Fi is given by the relation (3.2.3) and the corresponding virtual work δW by the relation (3.2.3'); as well, the real elementary work dWR of the constraints forces Ri is given by (3.2.7), the corresponding virtual work δWR being of the form (3.2.7').
4
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
The p holonomic constraints are expressed in the form (3.2.8) if they are rheonomous and in the form (3.2.33') if they are scleronomic, the number s = 3n − p representing the number of degrees of geometric freedom of the discrete mechanical system S ; the motion takes place only if p < 3n (hence, s > 0 ) . We notice that a free rigid solid, component of a discrete mechanical system S , introduces 6 degrees of freedom. The m non-holonomic constraints are represented – in general – by means of the Pfaff differential forms in the form (3.2.13) (as well in the form (3.2.13')), with the aid of the real displacements, or in the form (3.2.15) (analogously, in the form (3.2.15')), by means of the virtual displacements. In case of scleronomic constraints, the relations (3.2.32) must also take place; otherwise, the constraints are rheonomous. The number r = 3n − m represents the number of kinematic degrees of freedom of the discrete mechanical system S . In case of holonomic constraints, we have r = s . The total number of constraints is, in general, nL = p + m , while the number of degrees of freedom (obviously, kinematic degrees of freedom, because the holonomic constraints involve the same number of geometric and kinematic degrees of freedom) is 3n − nL . The non-holonomic constraints of the form (3.2.12), considered above, have been called non-holonomic constraints of the first kind by G. Hamel; he introduces also non-holonomic constraints of the second kind, where appear the accelerations of the particles too, in the form f (drj , d2 rj ; dt ) = 0 ,
(18.1.1)
the dimensional homogeneity being ensured. A constraint relation of the form (3.2.13) corresponds to a holonomic constraint if it is an integrable differential Pfaff form; otherwise it corresponds to a non-holonomic constraint. The Theorem 3.2.2 of Frobenius gives the necessary and sufficient conditions, so that such a differential form of first degree be complete integrable (does correspond to an exact differential or does admit an integrable factor). We notice that the two classifications of the constraints (holonomic or non-holonomic and scleronomic or rheonomous) are independent; we can have, e.g., non-holonomic and rheonomous constraints (the most general case) or holonomic and scleronomic constraints (the most particular case). A mechanical system subjected to holonomic or non-holonomic constraints is called a holonomic or non-holonomic mechanical system, respectively; as well, a mechanical system subjected to scleronomic or rheonomous constraints is called scleronomic or rheonomous mechanical system, respectively. In case of scleronomic constraints, the real displacements belong to the set of virtual displacements. As a matter of fact, to have this property it is sufficient that the conditions αk 0 = 0, k = 1,2,..., m , be fulfilled in the relations (3.2.13) (it is not necessary that the constraints by scleronomic); such constraints are called catastatic. As examples of mechanical systems subjected to holonomic and scleronomic constraints we mention the particle compelled to stay on a fixed curve or on a fixed surface, as well as the rigid solid (or a non-deformable discrete mechanical system). If the curve or the surface are movable (rigid and movable with respect to a fixed frame of
Lagrangian Mechanics
5
reference or even deformable), then the constraint is holonomic and rheonomous. We notice that a rigid solid behaves – in a certain sense – as a particle which has not three but six degrees of freedom. Non-holonomic constraints are, e.g., those corresponding to the motion of a heavy homogenous sphere (see Sect. 17.1.2.8) or of a heavy circular disc (see Sect. 17.1.2.9) on a horizontal plane; we mention the motion of a rigid skate on the ice field too, case considered in Sect. 3.2.2.6. An important class of constraints, in the frame of which analytical mechanics has been developed, is the class of ideal constraints. We call ideal constraints those ones for which the virtual work of the constraint forces vanishes δWR =
n
∑ Ri
i =1
⋅ δri = 0
(18.1.2)
for any system of virtual displacements of the considered mechanical system S . If the virtual displacements δri are arbitrary (we have not constraints), then the relation (18.1.2) is fulfilled if and only if Ri = 0, i = 1, 2, ..., n . But if p holonomic constraints of the form (3.2.8) and m non-holonomic constraints of the form (3.2.13) take place, then we can use the method of Lagrange’s multipliers, the constraint forces being of the form (3.2.37). In this case, the real elementary work of the constraint forces is given by (3.2.37'); this work vanishes if fl = 0, l = 1, 2, ..., p , and αk 0 = 0, k = 1, 2, ..., m (conditions in which the real displacements belong to the set of virtual displacements, case of catastatic constraints), in particular in case of scleronomic constraints. Among the mechanical systems subjected to ideal constraints we mention the particle subjected to constraints of contact, frictionless (compelled to stay on a fixed or movable curve or surface), or the discrete mechanical system for which the distance between two particles is function only on time (constraints at distance). The classical ideal constraints of the rigid solid are: the simple support, the hinge and the built-in mounting. Ideal constraints are also the constraints of the rigid solid which can slide without friction along an axis (or, in general, along a superposable curve), the constraints of a rigid solid which can slide frictionless on a plane (or on a given surface), as well as the constraints of the rigid solid which is rolling or pivoting without sliding on a plane (or on a arbitrary surface); in the first cases, the virtual displacement is normal to the constraint force and in the last cases the virtual displacement is zero. We mention also the systems of two rigid solids considered in Sect. 3.2.2.9. As well, a mechanism (a discrete mechanical system formed of two rigid solids linked rigidly or by hinges or by perfectly smooth or rough surfaces) can be considered as a mechanical system subjected to ideal constraints. We mention also the constraints by threads, which are not always bilateral. Among the constraints with friction, we consider that one which corresponds to the sliding friction, for which the analytical methods of mechanics could be adapted. We assume that the virtual displacement δr takes place in an interval of time δt (which can be the interval of time Δt in which take place the possible displacements, the difference of which is the virtual displacement). In this case, the virtual displacement of a point of a free rigid solid with respect to the inertial frame of reference R ′ will be given by
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
6
δr ′ = vO′∗ δt + ( ω∗ δt ) × r ,
(18.1.3)
where vΟ′∗ δt (t ) and ω∗ δt (t ) are two arbitrary vectors, which define the virtual rototranslation at the moment t , r being the position vector with respect to the non-inertial frame R ; the position of this solid depends thus on six scalar parameters. We can express the virtual displacement δr ′ in the form δr ′ = δrO′ + δχ × r
(18.1.3')
too, where δχ represents a virtual rotation of the frame of reference R with respect to the frame R (of components δψ , δθ and δϕ , corresponding to Euler’s angles). In the case in which the rigid solid has a fixed point (e.g., the point O ), we have vO′∗ = 0 , its position depending only on three scalar parameters. As well, if the point O of the rigid solid has a motion given by rO′ = rO′ (t ) , then the real displacement will be given by dr ′ = vO′ dt + ( ωdt ) × r , with vO′ = drO′ / dt ; in exchange, for a virtual displacement (compatible with the constraints at the moment t ) the point O must have the position fixed at the moment t , while δr ′ = ( ω∗ δt ) × r , the rigid solid having three degrees of freedom too. The virtual work of the forces of inertia is expressed in the form δW i = − ∫∫∫ μ ( r ) a ′( r ; t ) ⋅ δr ′dV , V
(18.1.4)
where the virtual displacement δr ′ is given by (18.1.3), vO′∗ and ω∗ being arbitrary functions on time. Noting that a ′( r ; t ) represents the accelerations field in the real motion of the rigid solid, we can write, with respect to the frame of reference R ′ (we have r = r ′ − rO′ ), δW i = − { [ ( vO′∗ − ω∗ × rO′ ) δt ] ⋅ A ′ + ( ω∗ δt ) ⋅ DO′ ′ } ,
(18.1.4')
where A ′ is the dynamic resultant of the rigid solid, given by (14.1.27), while DO′ ′ is the dynamic moment with respect to the pole O ′ , given by (14.1.28). Analogously, in the case of the rigid solid, the virtual work of the constraints forces of torsor { R , MO } , will be expressed in the form
δWR = − [ ( vO′∗ − ω∗ × rO′ ) δt ] ⋅ R + ( ω∗ δt ) ⋅ MO ' = 0.
(18.1.4'')
18.1.1.2 The Representative Space E 3 n A basic aspect of the analytical methods of calculation consists in replacing the study of the motion of a discrete mechanical system S of geometric support Ω in the space E 3 by the study of the motion of a single geometric point, called representative point,
Lagrangian Mechanics
7
in another space, conveniently built up, called representative space. E.g., in Sects. 3.2.2.2 and 11.1.1.5 has been introduced the representative space E 3 n , by passing from the mechanical system S of n particles Pi , i = 1, 2, ..., n , to a representative point P , of generalized co-ordinates X k , k = 1, 2, ..., 3n , with the aid of the relations Xk = x j , k = 3(i − 1) + j , i = 1, 2,..., n , j = 1, 2, 3 , (i )
(18.1.5)
of the form (3.2.9), where x (j i ) is the component along the Ox j -axis of the position vector ri ; the real generalized displacements of this point are dXk , the possible generalized displacements are ΔXk and the virtual generalized displacements are δXk , k = 1, 2, ..., 3n , the respective properties corresponding to those in the space E 3 . In these conditions, the constraints of the mechanical system S become constraints of the representative point P . We use also the notations (i ) bj 0 = α j 0 , bjk = α , k = 3(i − 1) + l , jl
i = 1, 2,..., n , l = 1,2, 3 ,
(18.1.5')
of the form (3.2.9), where α(jli ) are the components along the Oxl -axis of the given vectors α ji , which specify the constraints relations (3.2.13); these relations take the form ωj ≡
corresponding
to
the
3n
∑ bjk dXk
k =1
+ bj 0 dt , j = 1, 2,..., m ,
relations (3.2.13''), where
(18.1.6)
bjk = bjk ( X1, X 2 ,..., X 3 n ; t ),
k = 0,1,..., 3n , or the form 3n
∑ bjkVk
k =1
+ bj 0 = 0, j = 1, 2,..., m ,
(18.1.6')
corresponding to the relations (3.2.13'''), where Vk = X k = dXk / dt , k = 1, 2,..., 3n , are the components of the generalized velocity of the point P in the representative space E 3n . Obviously, we assume that the constraints are linearly independent, hence that the matrices [bjk ] are of rank m . If a Pfaff differential form ω j is not completely integrable, then the respective constraint is non-holonomic; taking into account the form (18.1.6') of these relations, then the constraint is called kinematic too. We assume that, in general, the mechanical system S has m non-holonomic constraints (the representative point P is on a non-holonomic manifold with 3n − m dimensions, at
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
8
the intersection of m non-holonomic hypersurfaces in the space E 3n ). We can express these constraint relations also in the form 3n
∑ bjk δXk
k =1
= 0, j = 1, 2,..., m ,
(18.1.7)
corresponding to the relations (3.2.15''), by means of the virtual displacements, or in the form 3n
∑ bjkVk*
k =1
= 0, j = 1, 2,..., m ,
(18.1.7')
corresponding to the relations (3.2.15'''), where Vk* = δX k / Δt are the virtual generalized velocities ( Δt is the interval of time in which takes place a possible displacement). If bj 0 = 0, j = 1, 2,..., m , then the mechanical system is called catastatic. In this case, the set of virtual generalized displacements coincides with the set of possible generalized displacements and the constraints are called catastatic; as well, the set of virtual generalized velocities (which coincides with the set of possible generalized velocities) contains also the case in which these velocities vanish, hence the case of rest with respect to an inertial frame of reference (the denomination used above being thus justified). A mechanical system which is not catastatic is called non-catastatic; in this case bj 0 ≠ 0 . If the conditions bj 0 = 0, bjk =
∂bjk ∂t
= 0, j = 1, 2,..., m , k = 1, 2,..., 3n ,
(18.1.8)
are verified, then the constraints do not depend explicitly on time and are called scleronomic; otherwise, the constraints are rheonomous. We notice that a scleronomic mechanical system is catastatic too, but a catastatic one may be rheonomous too; a noncatastatic mechanical system is always rheonomous. If a Pfaff differential form is completely integrable (for a system of the form (18.1.6) we can use the Theorem 3.2.2 of Frobenius), then the corresponding constraint is holonomic, being of the form fl ( Xk ; t ) ≡ fl ( X1 , X 2 ,..., X 3 n ; t ) = 0, l = 1, 2,..., p ,
(18.1.9)
hence of the form (3.2.8''); such a constraint is also called geometric. In general, we assume that the mechanical system S has p holonomic constraints (the representative point P is on a manifold with 3n − p dimensions, at the intersection of p hypersurfaces in the space E 3 n ). These finite relations can be written also in the differential form 3n
∂f
∑ ∂Xlk
k =1
dXk + fl dt = 0, l = 1, 2,..., p ,
(18.1.10)
Lagrangian Mechanics
9
or in the form ∂f
3n
∑ ∂Xlk Vk
k =1
+ fl = 0, l = 1, 2,..., p ,
(18.1.10')
so that ∂fl = blk , l = 1, 2,..., p , k = 1, 2,...3n . ∂Xk
Analogously, using the virtual generalized displacements, we can write 3n
∂f
∑ ∂Xlk
k =1
δXk = 0, l = 1, 2,..., p ,
(18.1.11)
or 3n
∂f
∑ ∂Xlk Vk*
k =1
= 0, l = 1, 2,..., p .
(18.1.11')
We assume that also these constraints are linearly independent, the matrices [ ∂fl / ∂Xk ] being of rank p . If fl = 0, l = 1,2,..., p , the mechanical system S is catastatic; at the same time we have ∂f ∂ ⎛⎜ l ⎞⎟ ∂ ∂f ⎝ Xk ⎠ = l =0 ∂t ∂Xk
too, so that the respective system is also scleronomic. We notice that these two properties of the constraints coincide in case of the holonomic systems, for which fl ( Xk ) ≡ fl ( X1, X2, ..., X 3 n ) = 0 .
(18.1.12)
Let be two neighbouring, possible, simultaneous (at the moment t ) positions P ( Xk ) and P '( Xk + δXk ) , of the same representative point of the holonomic discrete mechanical system S . The constraint relations will be of the form fl ( Xk ) = 0 , fl ( Xk + δXk ) = 0 , l = 1, 2,..., p . Expanding into a Taylor series, we can write fl ( Xk ) +
3n
∂f
∑ ∂Xlk
k =1
δXk + ... = 0 .
Neglecting the terms of higher order and taking into account the constraint relations,
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
10
we find the conditions (18.1.11). One observes thus that δXk represent those differential generalized displacements which must be effected by the representative point to pass from a position to another one, at the same moment t , being thus virtual displacements (corresponding to their definition, as difference of possible displacements). If Fi = Fj( i ) i j represents the resultant of the given forces which act upon the particle Pi , i = 1, 2,..., n , in the space E 3 , then we can introduce, in the space E 3n , the given
generalized forces (shortly, the generalized forces) Qk , k = 1, 2,..., 3n , which act upon the representative point P , in the form Qk = Fj , k = 3(i − 1) + j , i = 1,2,..., n , j = 1,2, 3, k = 1,2,..., 3n . (i )
(18.1.13)
As well, by using the axiom of liberation from constraints, one introduces the constraint forces Ri = Rj( i ) i j , j = 1, 2,..., n , which act upon the particle Pi in the space E 3 ; we are thus led to constraint generalized forces Rk , k = 1, 2,....3n , which act in the space E 3n upon the representative point P in the form Rk = Rj , k = 3(i − 1) + j , i = 1,2,..., n , j = 1, 2, 3 . (i )
(18.1.13')
In what concerns the mass mi of the particle Pi , it is convenient to denote mi = mi
(1)
= mi
(2 )
= mi
(3)
, i = 1,2,..., n ,
so that M k = m j , k = 3(i − 1) + j , i = 1, 2,..., n , j = 1, 2, 3, k = 1,2,..., 3n , (i )
(18.1.14)
can be considered as 3 n generalized masses of the representative point P in the space E 3n . The real elementary work of the given generalized forces is given by dW =
n
3
∑ ∑ Fj( i ) dx (j i )
i =1 j =1
=
3n
∑ Qk dXk ,
(18.1.15)
k =1
while the real elementary work of the constraint generalized forces is expressed in the form
dWk = Analogously,
n
3
∑ ∑ R(j i ) dx (j i )
i =1 j =1
=
3n
∑ Rk dXk
k =1
.
(18.1.15')
Lagrangian Mechanics
11 n
3
∑ ∑ Fj( i ) δX (j i )
δW =
i =1 j =1
=
3n
∑ Qk δXk
(18.1.16)
k =1
is the virtual work of the given generalized forces, while δWR =
n
3
∑ ∑ R(j i ) δX (j i )
i = 1 j =1
=
3n
∑ Rk δXk
(18.1.16')
k =1
represents the virtual work of the constraint generalized forces.
18.1.1.3 Natural Systems We have seen in Sects. 1.1.1.12 and in 6.1.1.2 that a system of forces (corresponding, e.g., to a field of forces), which admits a simple potential (or quasi-potential) or a generalized potential (or quasi-potential) is called a natural system. A system of forces Fi = ∇ iU = Fj( i ) i j , ∇ i = i j
∂ ∂x (j i )
, i = 1,2,..., n ,
the components of which (i )
Fj
=
∂U ∂x (j i )
, i = 1, 2,..., n , j = 1, 2, 3 ,
(18.1.17)
derive from a simple potential, forms a system of conservative forces; to a simple quasi-potential of the form U = U ( r1 , r2 ,..., rn ; t ) corresponds a system of quasiconservative forces. Analogously, if Fj( i ) =
∂U ∂x (j i )
−
d ∂U , i = 1, 2,..., n , j = 1, 2, 3 , dt ∂x ( i ) j
(18.1.17')
where U = U ( r1 , r2 ,..., rn , r1 , r2 ,..., rn )
is a generalized potential, then the system of forces is conservative; in case of the generalized quasi-potential U = U ( r1 , r2 ,..., rn , r1 , r2 ,..., rn ; t )
the system of forces is quasi-conservative. In the representative space E 3n , the system of generalized forces is of components Qk =
∂U , k = 1, 2,..., 3 n , ∂Xk
(18.1.18)
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
12
in case of a simple potential (system of conservative generalized forces) U = U ( X1 , X 2 ,..., Xn )
or of a simple quasi-potential (system of quasi-conservative generalized forces) U = U ( X1 , X 2 ,..., X n ; t )
or of components Qk = [U ]k ≡
∂U d ∂U − , k = 1, 2,..., 3n , ∂Xk dt ∂Xk
(18.1.18')
in case of a generalized potential (system of conservative generalized forces) U = U ( X1 , X 2 ,..., X n , X 1 , X 2 ,..., X n )
or in case of a generalized quasi-potential (system of quasi-conservative generalized forces) U = U ( X1 , X 2 ,..., Xn , X 1 , X 2 ,..., X n ; t ) ;
we have used the Euler-Lagrange derivative corresponding to the index k , given by [
]k
=
∂ d ∂ − , k = 1, 2,..., 3n . ∂Xk dt ∂Xk
(18.1.19)
Noting that the generalized forces do not depend explicitly on the generalized accelerations d2 Xk Xk = , k = 1, 2,..., 3n , dt 2
it results that the generalized potential (quasi-potential) is of the form U =
3n
∑U j X j j =1
+ U0 ,
where
U j = U j ( X1 , X 2 ,..., Xn ) is a vector potential, while U 0 = U 0 ( X1 , X 2 ,..., Xn )
(18.1.20)
Lagrangian Mechanics
13
is a scalar potential, or where
U j = U j ( X1 , X 2 ,..., Xn ; t ) is a vector quasi-potential, while U 0 = U 0 ( X1 , X 2 ,..., Xn ; t )
is a scalar quasi-potential in the space E 3 n . Replacing in (18.1.18'), we obtain Qk =
3n
⎛ ∂U j
∑ ⎜⎝ ∂Xk j =1
−
∂U k ∂X j
∂U 0 ⎞ ⎟X j − U k + ∂X , k = 1, 2,..., 3n , k ⎠
(18.1.21)
in case of the quasi-conservative generalized forces; if the forces are conservative, then we have U k = 0 . Replacing the vector potential U j by the vector potential Uj = Uj +
∂ϕ , ϕ = ϕ ( X1 , X 2 ,..., Xn ; t ) , ∂X j
and taking into account that one can invert the order of application of the operators
∂ d d ∂ = ∂Xk dt dt ∂Xk for a function of class C 2 , we get the same generalized function Qk ; hence, the vector quasi-potential is determined leaving aside a field of gradients in the space E 3n . If to this transformation of vector quasi-potential U j → U j we associate the transformation of scalar quasi-potential U 0 → U 0 = U 0 + ϕ , hence if we effect the gauge transformation (of scale) U →U =U +
dϕ , dt
then the form (18.1.21) of the quasi-conservative generalized force remains invariant. A field of conservative generalized forces is stationary, while a field of quasi-conservative generalized forces is non-stationary. The elementary work of the conservative generalized forces which derive from a simple potential is an exact differential dW = dU ,
(18.1.22)
the work depending only on the extreme positions of the representative point P Wq = U ( X11 , X 21 ,..., X 31n 0 1 P P
) − U ( X10 , X20 ,..., X 30n ) .
(18.1.22')
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
14
If the trajectory of the point P is a closed hypercurve C in E 3 n , then the corresponding work vanishes (WC = 0 ). If these generalized forces result from a generalized potential, then the elementary work is a total differential dW = dU 0
(18.1.22'')
too, the scalar potential U 0 playing the rôle of the simple potential in the frame of the generalized potential (18.1.20), while the vector potential has no contribution concerning this elementary work; all the considerations made in case of the simple potential remain thus valid. In case of quasi-conservative generalized forces, which derive from a simple quasi-potential, the elementary work is no more a total differential, being of the form dW = dU − Udt ,
(18.1.23)
where we put in evidence the partial derivatives with respect to time. If the generalized forces result from a generalized quasi-potential, then we get dW = dU 0 − U 0 dt − ⎛ 3n ⎞ = dU 0 − ⎜ ∑ U kVk + U 0 ⎟ dt = ⎝ k =1 ⎠
3n
∑Uk dXk
k =1 3n
∂U
∑ ⎛⎜⎝ ∂Xk0
k =1
⎞ − U k ⎟ dXk . ⎠
(18.1.23')
We see, easily, that the transformations mentioned above for the generalized potential have no influence on this elementary work. We notice that a system of conservative generalized forces derives always from a generalized potential or from a simple potential as it depends or not explicitly on the generalized velocities of the representative point P in E 3 n . Introducing the potential energy V = −U , in case of a simple potential, or the potential energy V = −U 0 , in case of a generalized potential, we can write Wq = V0 − V1 = − ΔV , V = − Wq + V0 , 0 1 0 1 P P
P P
(18.1.24)
where ΔV is the variation of the potential energy. Consequently, the potential energy of a discrete mechanical system, acted upon by conservative generalized forces (natural mechanical system), is equal to the work with changed sign, effected by the generalized forces, beginning with the initial moment (excepting an arbitrary constant V0 , which represents the potential energy at the initial moment; often, one chooses V0 so that the minimum of the potential energy be equal to zero). The generalized forces which do not derive from a simple quasi-potential can be expressed in the from
Qk =
∂U + Qk , U = U ( X1 , X2 ,..., Xn ; t ) , ∂Xk
the elementary work being given by
(18.1.25)
Lagrangian Mechanics
15 ⎛ 3n ⎞ dW = dU + ⎜ ∑ QkVk − U ⎟ dt . ⎝ k =1 ⎠
(18.1.25')
In the case in which U = 0 (U = U ( X1 , X 2 ,..., Xn ) is a potential), the quantity 3n
∑ QkVk ,
k =1
of the nature of a power, represents the power of the non-potential generalized forces. The non-potential generalized forces Qk of a vanishing power 3n
∑ QkVk
k =1
=0
are called gyroscopic generalized forces, depending – obviously – on the distribution of the generalized velocities. The generalized forces Qk are, in this case, conservative; if the power of the non-potential generalized forces is non-zero, then these forces are non-conservative. The non-conservative generalized forces of negative power 3n
∑ QkVk
k =1
<0
are called dissipative generalized forces, because – in this case – the energy diminishes (we take into account (18.1.25') and notice that U = −V ). The forces (18.1.21) which admit a generalized quasi-potential are, as well, of the form (18.1.25), where we take U = U 0 and where Qk =
3n
⎛ ∂U j
∑ ⎜⎝ ∂Xk j =1
−
∂U k ⎞ X − U k , k = 1, 2,..., 3 n . ∂X j ⎟⎠ j
(18.1.26)
If neither the vector potential does not depend explicitly on time (Uk = 0 ), then it results 3n
∑ Qk X k
k =1
= 0,
the non-potential generalized forces being thus gyroscopic. Hence, any generalized force which admits a generalized potential is the sum of a generalized force which admits a simple potential and a gyroscopic force. If upon a mechanical system S act only gyroscopic generalized forces, then we have n
∑ Fi
i =1
⋅ vi =
3n
∑ QkVk
k =1
=0
and reciprocally. As well, the condition of dissipation becomes
(18.1.27)
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
16 n
∑ Fi
i =1
⋅ vi =
3n
∑ QkVk
k =1
<0 .
(18.1.27')
18.1.1.4 Case of a Single Particle In case of a single particle P we have n = 1 , the representative space being just the space E 3 , of co-ordinates x1 , x 2 , x 3 . Using the notations in Sect. 18.1.1.2, we can write the constraint relations, in general, in the form ωα ≡ bα j dx j + bα 0 dt = 0, α = 1, 2 ,
(18.1.28)
ωα , α = 1, 2 , being differential forms of first degree; we consider, in general, that
bα j = bα j (x1 , x 2 , x 3 ; t ), j = 0,1, 2, 3 . We may write bα j v j + bα 0 = 0, α = 1, 2 ,
(18.1.28')
too. If these forms are integrable (see Sect. 3.2.2.6 too), then the constraints are holonomic, so that fk (x1 , x 2 , x 3 ; t ) = 0, k = 1, 2 ,
(18.1.29)
relations which can be written also in the form fk , j dx j + fk dt = 0, k = 1, 2 ,
(18.1.29')
fk , j v j + fk = 0, k = 1, 2 .
(18.1.29'')
or in the form
If bα 0 = 0, α = 1, 2 , then the constraints are catastatic, while if bα j = 0 , α = 1,2 ,
j = 1, 2, 3 , too, then the constraints are scleronomic; otherwise, they are rheonomous. In case of a holonomic constraint, the conditions to be a scleronomic one too are reduced to fk = 0, k = 1, 2 . As in the general case, the constraint relations can be expressed also by means of the virtual displacements in the form bα j δx j = 0, α = 1, 2 ,
(18.1.30)
bα j v ∗j = 0, α = 1, 2 .
(18.1.30')
or in the form
The relations (18.1.30) and (18.1.30') coincide with the relations (18.1.28) and (18.1.28'), respectively, in case of catastatic constraints (the set of virtual displacements
Lagrangian Mechanics
17
coincides with the set of possible constraints, while the real displacements belong to these sets). A simple example of particle subjected to a non-holonomic constraint is represented by a particle P2 which has a curvilinear and uniform motion of velocity v2 , collinear JJJJG with the vector P2 P1 , tangent to the trajectory, the point P1 having a rectilinear and uniform motion of velocity v1 (the problem of meeting; see Sect. 10.2.1.2). Starting from the relations x1′ = x1 , x 2′ = v1t + x 2 , which allow to pass from a movable frame of reference to a fixed one, and from the relation x1 = (v1 + x2 )
x1 , x2
one can write the constraint relation
( x 2′ − v1t ) dx1′ − x1′dx 2′ = 0 ,
(18.1.31)
which is non-holonomic. In case of scleronomic constraints bα j dx j = 0, bα j = bα j (x1 , x 2 , x 3 ; t ), α = 1, 2, j = 1, 2, 3 ,
(18.1.32)
the conditions of integrability are of the form (3.2.30'). The integrant factors λα = λα (x1 , x 2 , x 3 ), α = 1, 2 , must exist, so that λ1 b1 and λ2 b2 , bα = b α j i j ,
α = 1,2 , be gradients, hence curl (λα bα ) = λα curl bα + grad λα × bα = 0 ; a scalar product by bα leads to the conditions of integrability bα ⋅ curl bα =∈ijk bαi bαk , j = 0, α = 1, 2 .
(18.1.32')
If, in particular, curl bα = 0, α = 1, 2 , the conditions of integrability are fulfilled and we can take λα = const. Pfaff showed that, by a convenient transformation of coordinates, the non-integrable constraint relation (18.1.32) can be expressed in the form x 3 d x 1 − dx 2 = 0 .
(18.1.33)
We can see, easily, that the relation (18.1.32') does not hold. If bα = λα gradfα , α = 1, 2 , where λα is a scalar field of class C 1 , if fα is a scalar field of class C 2 and if λα and fα are functional independent, then the vector field bα is called biscalar; in particular, if λα and fα are functional dependent, then bα is a potential field. The necessary and sufficient condition that the vector field bα be locally biscalar is (18.1.32'); in this case, the scleronomic relations (18.1.32) are completely integrable (are locally exact or admit a locally integrant factor). J. Bertrand considered also the field lines
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
18
ϕα ( x1 , x 2 , x 3 ) = cα′ , ψα (x1 , x 2 , x 3 ) = cα′′ , cα′ , cα′′ = const, α = 1, 2 ,
of the curl bα (vortex lines), expressed by means of the first integrals ϕα and ψα ; we notice that grad ϕα ⋅ curl bα = 0 , grad ψα ⋅ curl bα = 0 , α = 1,2 . Associating the relations (18.1.32') too, one sees that the vectors bα , grad ϕα , grad ψα are coplanar, so that bα = λα gradϕα + μα gradψα , λα2 + μα2 ≠ 0, α = 1, 2 .
In this case, bα ⋅ dr = bα j dx j = λα gradϕα ⋅ dr + μα gradψα ⋅ dr = λα dϕα + μα dψα , α = 1, 2 ,
and one can show that the ratio λα , μα ≠ 0 , μα
depends only on the first integral ϕα and ψα . Let be a particle P subjected to a holonomic and scleronomic constraint f (x1 , x 2 , x 3 ) = const ; in this case, starting from a given point (let be from the origin, to fix the ideas), one can reach only the points on a two-dimensional manifold (the points of the surface f (x1 , x 2 , x 3 ) = f (0, 0, 0) ). If the constraint is non-holonomic and scleronomic (e.g., of the form (18.1.33)), then we can find a path which leads from the origin to an arbitrary point (x1 , x 2 , x 3 ) . Let be thus the path x 2 = f (x1 ) , x 3 = f ′(x1 ) , f (x ) ∈ C 3 ;
the constraint relation (18.1.33) is satisfied and we must choose the function f (x1 ) with the properties: f (0) = 0 , f ′(0) = 0 , f (x1 ) = x 2 , f ′(x1 ) = x 3 .
One sees easily, geometrically, that it exists an infinity of such functions, e.g., the functions of the family x x 2 f ( x1 )= ⎢⎡ 3x 2 − x 3 x1 − ( 2x 2 − x 3 x1 ) 1 ⎥⎤ ⎛⎜ 1 ⎞⎟ x 1 ⎦ ⎝ x1 ⎠ ⎣ πx + C 1 x12 ( x1 − x1 )2 + C 2 sin ⎛⎜ 1 ⎞⎟ , ⎝ x1 ⎠
(18.1.34)
Lagrangian Mechanics
19
where C 1 and C 2 are arbitrary constants. Hence, starting from a given point, a particle P with 3 − 2 = 1 degrees of freedom can reach only the points of a surface (a twodimensional manifold), in case of a holonomic constraint, while, in case of a non-holonomic constraint, one can reach any point in E 3 (a three-dimensional
manifold). These considerations remain valid also in case of rheonomous constraints. In case of a particle P subjected to two constraints (hence, which has 3 − 2 = 1 degrees of freedom) one can make analogous considerations. If both constraints are holonomic. then one can reach – starting from a given position – only the points of a curve (a unidimensional manifold), while, if only one of the constraints is holonomic, one can reach the points of a surface (a two-dimensional manifold); if both constraints are non-holonomic, then one can reach any point E 3 (a three-dimensional manifold). The results obtained above put in evidence that a non-holonomic constraint leads to a greater possibility of motion (it is less strict) that a holonomic constraint. If the resultant F of the forces which act upon the particle P derive from a simple quasi-potential U = U (x1 , x 2 , x 3 ; t ) , then we can write F = grad U , curl F = 0 ,
(18.1.35)
while if the force F derives from a generalized quasi-potential U = U ⋅ v + U 0 , U = U (x1 , x 2 , x 3 ; t ) , U 0 = U 0 (x1 , x 2 , x 3 ; t ) ,
then one has F = gradU 0 + v × curl U − U .
(18.1.35')
In general, a force F = gradU + F , U = U ( x1 , x 2 , x 3 ; t ) , is non-conservative; if U = U (x1 , x 2 , x 3 ; t ) and F ⋅ v = 0 , then the force F is gyroscopic. E.g., a force of the
form
F = v × curl U , U = U ( x1 , x 2 , x 3 ; t ) (corresponding to the vector potential in
(18.1.35')), is a gyroscopic force. As an example of force which derives from a generalized quasi-potential we mention the force F exerted upon a particle P in an electromagnetic field { E, B } , where E is the intensity of the electric field, while B is the magnetic induction. If q is the electric charge of the particle P , then we can write F = q (E + v × B) ,
(18.1.36)
where q E is the force exerted in the electric field, while q v × B is the force exerted in the magnetic field (Lorentz’s force); the force F is called the generalized force of Lorentz. The magnetic induction is of the form B = curl A ,
(18.1.36')
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
20
where A = A (x1 , x 2 , x 3 ; t ) is the magnetic vector quasi-potential, while the intensity of the electric field is of the form
(
)
+ grad A0 , E= − A
(18.1.36'')
where A0 = A0 (x1 , x 2 , x 3 ; t ) is a scalar quasi-potential. Replacing in (18.1.36), it results
(
)
F = −q gradA0 + q v × curl A − A ,
(18.1.37)
the force deriving from the quasi-potential U = q ( A ⋅ v − A0 ) .
(18.1.37')
We notice that Lorentz's force q v × B is a gyroscopic one.
18.1.2 Differential Principles of Mechanics In what follows, let us present some important differential principles of mechanics (Newton’s, d’Alembert’s, Gauss’s and Hertz’s principles), from which derive the equations of motion of the considered discrete mechanical system S in E 3 and of the representative point P in the representative space E 3 n , respectively; a special attention is given to the principle of virtual work. The results thus obtained will be illustrated by some applications.
18.1.2.1 Newton’s and d’Alembert’s Principles. General Theorems. Conservation Theorems As we have seen in Sect. 11.1.2.10, the equations of motion of a free discrete mechanical system S , free or subjected to constraints, are written in the form (11.1.8) or in the form (11.1.52), respectively, corresponding to the second principle of Newton, considered as the first differential principle of mechanics. Passing to the representative space E 3 n , the equation of motion of the representative point P will be of the form M k Xk = Qk , k = 1, 2,..., 3n ,
(18.1.38)
in case of a free point P , or of the form M k Xk = Qk + Rk , k = 1, 2,..., 3n ,
(18.1.38')
in case of a point P subjected to constraints, respectively. This differential principle can be expressed also in the form
Lagrangian Mechanics
21
d ( M k X k dt
) = Qk
+ Rk , k = 1, 2,..., 3 n ,
(18.1.38'')
corresponding to the form given to this principle by Newton. The Cauchy–Lipschitz theorem, stated in Sect. 11.1.1.5 (where we have used adequate notations for the generalized force) ensures the existence and the uniqueness of the solution. Introducing the generalized forces of inertia Qki = − M k Xk , k = 1, 2,..., 3n ,
(18.1.39)
the law of motion becomes Qk + Qki + Rk = 0, k = 1, 2,..., 3 n ,
(18.1.40)
and we can state. Theorem 18.1.1 (d’Alembert). The motion of the representative point P subjected to constraints in the space E 3 n takes place so that, at any moment, the point is in dynamic equilibrium under the action of the given and constraint generalized force and of the generalized force of inertia. We introduce the lost generalized force of d’Alembert
Φk = Qk + Qki = Qk − M k Xk , k = 1, 2,..., 3n .
(18.1.41)
In this case, the equations (18.1.40) become
Φk + Rk = 0, k = 1, 2,..., 3n ,
(18.1.42)
and we can state Theorem 18.1.1' (d’Alembert). The motion of the representative point P subjected to constraints in the space E 3 n takes place so that, at any moment, the constraint generalized forces are equilibrated by the lost generalized forces of d’Alembert. We notice that each of the Theorems 18.1.1 and 18.1.1' can be at the basis of the Newtonian model, representing thus a differential principle of mechanics. Formally, the equations (18.1.42), which represent the necessary and sufficient conditions of dynamic equilibrium (characterizing, entirely, the motion of the representative point P subjected to constraints, hence of the dynamic discrete mechanical system S subjected to constraints), are not different from the relations Qk + Rk = 0, k = 1, 2,..., 3n ,
(18.1.42')
which represent the necessary and sufficient conditions of static equilibrium of the very same representative point P (hence, of the same mechanical system S ). Hence, all the considerations which can be made in case of problems of statics can be transposed to similar problems with a dynamic character, replacing the given generalized force Qk
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
22
by the lost generalized force of d’Alembert Φk ; as well, one observers that the results concerning the problems of statics can be obtained by particularization, starting from the general dynamic case. If the momentum of the representative point P is defined in the form
H =
3n
∑ M k X k ,
k =1
(18.1.43)
then we can state a theorem of momentum
H =
3n
∑ (Qk
k =1
+ Rk ) .
(18.1.43')
As well, if the moment of momentum, with respect to the origin O , of the representative point P , is given by
KO =
n
3
∑ ∑
i = 1 j ,k ,l = 1
∈jkl M 3( i −1) +l X 3( i −1) +l X 3( i −1) +l ,
(18.1.44)
where we have introduced Ricci's symbol, then the theorem of moment of momentum is written in the form
KO =
n
3
∑ ∑
i = 1 j ,k ,l = 1
∈jkl X 3( i −1) +l ⎡⎣Q3( i −1) +l + R3( i −1) +l ⎤⎦ .
(18.1.44')
Starting from these two theorems, we obtain – easily – the corresponding conservative theorems too, hence two first integrals of the considered system of differential equations. Taking into account the above observations, the equations 3n
∑ (Qk
k =1
n
+ Rk ) = 0, ∑
3
∑
i =1 j ,k ,l = 1
∈jkl X 3( i −1) +l ⎡⎣Q3( i −1) +l + R3( i −1) +l ⎤⎦ = 0
(18.1.45)
represent the necessary and sufficient conditions of rest of the representative point P with respect to a given frame of reference, in the case in which the discrete mechanical systems S is non-deformable. The kinetic energy of the representative point P is defined in the form T =
1 3n M k Xk 2 k∑ =1
(18.1.46)
and we can write dT = dW + dWR ,
where the elementary work is given by (18.1.15) and (18.1.15'); we state thus
(18.1.47)
Lagrangian Mechanics
23
Theorem 18.1.2 (theorem of kinetic energy). The motion of the representative point P , subjected to constraints in the space E 3 n , takes place so that, at any moment, the differential of the kinetic energy of thus point is equal to the elementary work of the given and constraint generalized forces which act upon this point. If we introduces also the powers of the given and constraint generalized forces in the form P=
dWR dW , PR = , dt dt
(18.1.46')
then the relation (18.2.47) becomes T = P + PR .
(18.1.47')
We can state Theorem 18.1.2' (theorem of kinetic energy; second form). The motion of the representative point P , subjected to constraints in the space E 3 n , takes place so that, at any moment, the derivative of the kinetic energy with respect to time of this point is equal to the power of the given and constraint generalized forces. In case of catastatic ideal constraints, the elementary work of the constraint generalized forces vanishes ( dWR = 0 ; it will be shown in next section); hence d T = dW .
(18.1.48)
If the given generalized forces derive from a simple or a generalized potential, then dW = − dV , where V = −U in case of the simple potential and V = −U 0 in case of the generalized potential. Introducing the mechanical energy E , it results a mechanical energy of the form E = h , E = T + V , h = const .
(18.1.49)
We can state Theorem 18.1.3 (conservation theorem of mechanical energy). The mechanical energy of the representative point P , subjected to catastatic ideal constraints in the space E 3 n , is constant in time only and only if the given generalized forces derive from a simple or generalized potential. We notice that, in the manifold whit 3n dimensions, V = h represents the level of energy of the motion; because T > 0 , it results that the representative point P moves in the domain V < h . If we represent the arbitrary generalized forces in the form (18.1.25), then it results d (T + V ) =
3n
∑ Qk
k =1
⎛ 3n ⎞ dXk − Udt = ⎜ ∑ QkVk − U ⎟ dt , ⎝ k =1 ⎠
(18.1.50)
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
24
where V = −U corresponds to a simple quasi-potential; if U = U ( X1 , X 2 ,..., Xn ) is a simple potential, then we can write 3n d (T + V ) = ∑ QkVk . dt k =1
(18.1.50')
In the case of gyroscopic generalized forces we can write further a conservation theorem of mechanical energy (of the form (18.1.49)), while if the forces are dissipative, then the mechanical energy decreases.
18.1.2.2 Principle of Virtual Work. Lagrange’s Equations of the First Kind We have seen that a discrete mechanical system S subjected to ideal constraints verifies the relation (18.1.2); hence, a representative point P in the space E 3 n is subjected to ideal constraints if the relation (considered by P. Appell as relation of definition) δWR =
3n
∑ Rk δXk
k =1
=0
(18.1.51)
is verified. Starting from d’Alembert’s principle (18.1.42), effecting a scalar product by the virtual generalized displacements δXk , summing for all indices and taking into account the relation of definition (18.1.51) of the ideal constraints, we get the relation 3n
∑ Φk δXk =
k =1
3n
∑ (Qk
k =1
− M k Xk ) δXk = 0 ,
(18.1.52)
which represents a necessary condition to describe the motion of the representative point P . Assuming now that the condition (18.1.52) is fulfilled and that p holonomic constraints of the form (18.1.11) and m non-holonomic constraints of the form (18.1.7) take place, we will use the method of Lagrange’s multipliers; we can thus write ⎛ ∑ ⎜ Φk + k =1 ⎝ 3n
p
∑ λI
I =1
∂fI + ∂Xk
m
⎞
j =1
⎠
∑ μj bjk ⎟ δXk
= 0,
where λl , l = 1, 2,..., p , μj , j = 1, 2,..., m , are non-determinate scalars (Lagrange’s multipliers) and where we took into account that one can invert the order of summation, in a finite double sum. The p + m constraints are linear and distinct, the matrix of the coefficients ∂fl / ∂Xk and bjk being of rank p + m ; we express thus the virtual generalized displacements δX1 , δX 2 ,..., δX p + m (we can always choose them so that the determinant Δp + m of the respective coefficients in the constraints relations be non-zero) by means of the other 3n − ( p + m ) virtual generalized displacements, where the latter ones can be considered as independent. We put the conditions that the
Lagrangian Mechanics
25
expressions in the brackets which multiply the first p + m virtual generalized displacements do vanish, determining thus, univocally, p + m multipliers λl and μj (these multipliers are given by a system of p + m linear equations with p + m unknowns, of determinant Δp + m ≠ 0 ). The independent (and arbitrary) virtual generalized displacements δX p + m + 1 , δX p + m + 2 , ..., δX 3 n can be all taken equal to zero, expecting only one, let be δXk ; this
non-zero virtual generalized displacement being arbitrary, it results that the bracket by which it is multiplied must vanish too. Making, successively, k = p + m + 1 , k = p + m + 2 , ..., 3n , and taking into account the preceding considerations, it results that all the brackets which multiply the virtual generalized displacements must vanish. Finally, we can write
Φk +
p
∑ λI
I =1
∂fI + ∂X k
m
∑ μj bjk j =1
= 0, k = 1, 2,..., 3 n .
(18.1.53)
These equations are equivalent with the equations (18.1.42); in case of ideal constraints, we can express the constraint generalized forces in the form Rk =
p
∑ λI
I =1
∂fI + ∂Xk
m
∑ μj bjk , k j =1
= 1, 2,..., 3n ,
(18.1.54)
equivalent to (3.2.37). We can state (the relation (18.1.52) becomes a sufficient condition too) Theorem 18.1.4 (theorem of virtual work; d’Alembert-Lagrange). The motion of the representative point P , subjected to ideal constraints in the space E 3 n , takes place so that the virtual work of the lost generalized forces of d’Alembert, which act upon this point, vanishes for all the systems of virtual generalized displacements of the respective point. Taking into account the equivalence between the relation (18.1.52), which represents the form taken by Newton's equations, it results that the theorem of virtual work can be considered as being a principle (the principle of virtual work or the principle of virtual generalized displacements), because – starting from it – one can solve the fundamental problems of dynamics in case of ideal constraints. The equation (18.1.52) is called also the basic equation (the first form), while the equations (18.1.53) are known as Lagrange’s equations of the first kind. Introducing the virtual generalized velocities Vk∗ , we can write the conditions (18.1.52) in the form 3n
∑ ΦkVk∗
k =1
=0
(18.1.52')
too, the considered principle being thus called also the principle of virtual generalized velocities.
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
26
If some elements of the discrete mechanical system S are rigid solids, then one uses the formula (14.1.59) for the corresponding part of the virtual work. In the static case, the principle of virtual work becomes 3n
∑ Qk δXk
k =1
= 0,
(18.1.52'')
being stated for the first time in 1717 by Jean I Bernoulli. Let be a mechanical system S of n particles Pi , of weight mi g , i = 1, 2,..., n ; choosing a co-ordinate axis Ox along the descendent vertical, we can write the virtual work of these given forces in the form δW =
n
∑ mi
i =1
⎛ n ⎞ g δx i = δ ⎜ g ∑ mi x i ⎟ = δ ( M gξ ) = M gδξ = 0, ⎝ i =1 ⎠
where ξ is the applicate of the mass centre of the system S . We can thus state Theorem 18.1.5 (E. Torricelli). A mechanical system subjected to ideal constraints and to the action of its own weight is in equilibrium only and only for an extremum of the applicate of its centre of mass. Also this theorem can be considered to be a principle (Torricelli’s principle), which may be applied for a certain sphere of problems (in case of a uniform gravitational field). As we have seen in Sect. 4.1.1.7 (in case of a single particle), the position of equilibrium is stable, labile or indifferent as the applicate of the mass centre has a minimum, a maximum or is constant, respectively. Using the expression (18.1.54) of the constraint generalized forces and the constraint relations (18.1.6), (18.1.10), we can write the real elementary work (18.1.15') of the constraint generalized forces, in case of ideal constraints, in the form ⎛ p dWR = − ⎜ ∑ λl fl + ⎝ l =1
m
⎞
j =1
⎠
∑ μ j b j 0 ⎟ dt .
(18.1.55)
In case of catastatic constraints (we have fl = 0 , l = 1, 2,..., p , and bj 0 = 0 , l = 1, 2,..., m ), the real elementary work of the constraint generalized forces vanishes; indeed, in this case the real generalized displacements belong to the set of virtual generalized displacements, the relation (18.1.51) implying dWR = 0 . The conditions in which take place the relations (18.1.48) and (18.1.49) are thus entirely justified. Starting from the relations (18.1.6), we can write the constraint relations with the aid of the possible generalized displacements ΔX k , k = 1, 2,..., 3n , in the form 3n
∑ bjk ΔXk
k =1
+ bj 0 = 0, j = 1, 2,..., m .
Introducing the possible generalized velocities Vk =
ΔX k , k = 1, 2,..., 3 n , Δt
(18.1.56)
Lagrangian Mechanics
27
we can write 3n
∑ bjkVk
k =1
+ bj 0 = 0, j = 1, 2,..., m ,
(18.1.56')
too. Let be also other possible generalized velocities Vk + ΔVk , for the same position of the representative point P , at the same moment t , so that 3n
∑ bjk (Vk
k =1
+ ΔVk
) + bj 0
= 0, j = 1, 2,..., m .
Subtracting the last two relations one from the other, it results 3n
∑ bjk ΔVk
k =1
= 0, j = 1, 2,..., m .
(18.1.56'')
= 0, l = 1, 2,..., p .
(18.1.56''')
Analogously, we can write 3n
∂f
∑ ∂Xlk ΔVk
k =1
Hence, these finite variations of the possible generalized velocities verify the relations (18.1.7), (18.1.11) for virtual generalized velocities. One can thus write the basic equation (18.1.52) in the second form 3n
∑ Φk ΔVk
k =1
=
3n
∑ (Qk
k =1
− M k Xk ) ΔVk = 0 ,
(18.1.57)
for a given position of the representative point P , at a fixed moment t ; this form of the equation plays an important rôle in case of the phenomenon of collision. If ΔVk are differential quantities, then these variations are virtual generalized velocities (differences of possible generalized velocities) and we find again the form (18.1.52') of the basic equation, as it has been shown by P. E. B. Jourdain, in 1908. The corresponding principle is know also as Jourdain’s principle, being expressed in the form 3n
∑ Φk δX k
k =1
=
3n
∑ (Qk
k =1
− M k Xk ) ΔX k = 0 .
(18.1.57')
By a total differentiation of the constraint relation (18.1.56') with respect to time, we obtain the relations which must be verified by the possible generalized accelerations A = V , k = 1,2,..., 3n , in the form k
k
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
28 3n
⎡
∑ ⎢⎣bjk Ak
k =1
+
dbjk ⎤ dbjk Vk ⎥ + = 0, j = 1, 2,...m , dt dt ⎦
(18.1.58)
where d = dt
∂
3n
∑Vk ∂Xk
k =1
+
∂ . ∂t
(18.1.59)
We consider also the possible generalized accelerations Ak + ΔAk for the same position and the same velocity of the representative point P , at the same moment t ; as above, we obtain the relations 3n
∑ bjk ΔAk
k =1
= 0, j = 1, 2,...m .
(18.1.58')
Analogously, it results 3n
∂f
∑ ∂Xlk ΔAk
k =1
= 0, l = 1, 2,..., p .
(18.1.58'')
We see that the finite variations of the possible generalized accelerations verify the relations (18.1.7), (18.1.11), corresponding to the virtual generalized displacements. We are thus led to the third form of the basic equation 3n
∑ Φk ΔAk
k =1
=
3n
∑ (Qk
k =1
− M k Xk ) ΔAk = 0 ,
(18.1.60)
for a given position and generalized velocity of the representative point P , at a fixed moment t . If ΔAk are differential quantities, as Gauss and Gibbs have considered, we can write this equation in the form 3n
∑ Φk δXk
k =1
=
3n
∑ (Qk
k =1
− M k Xk ) δXk = 0 ,
(18.1.60')
where these variations are virtual generalized accelerations (differences of possible generalized accelerations) .
18.1.2.3 Gauss’s Principle. Hertz’s Principle Let us suppose that a particle Pi , of mass mi , of the mechanical system S subjected to constraints is, at the moment t , at the position Pi of position vector ri , velocity vi and acceleration ai , i = 1, 2,..., n . If no force would act upon the particle Pi , then this one would effect the real displacement (Fig. 18.1)
Lagrangian Mechanics
29 JJJJJG Pi Pi ′ = vi Δt ,
(18.1.61)
during the time t , while if upon this one would act upon only the given force Fi , then JJJJJG the particle would effect the real displacement Pi Pi ′′ , so that the derivation of the particle Pi in this motion would be given by the formula (5.1.21) in the form JJJJJG 1 F i ( Δt )2 . Pi Pi ′′ = 2 mi
(18.1.62)
Fig. 18.1 Gauss’s principle. Deviations
Finally, if the particle Pi is acted upon both by the given and the constraint forces, JJJJJG then it effects the real displacement Pi Pi ′′′ , in the time interval Δt ; the corresponding deviation of the particle is JJJJJG 1 Pi Pi ′′′ = ai ( Δt )2 , 2
(18.1.62')
JJJJG collinear with the acceleration ai . Let be also a possible displacement PQ i i , different JJJJJG from Pi Pi ′′′ , effected in the same interval of time Δt . JJJJJJG JJJJJG We notice that Pi ′′ Pi ′′′ and Pi ′′Qi represent the deviation of the particle Pi from the
free motion, in the time interval Δt to its real motion (the particle subjected to JJJJJG JJJJJJG JJJJJG constraints). Starting from the relation Pi ′′Qi = Pi ′′ Pi ′′′ + Pi ′′′Qi , we can write n
∑ mi Pi ′′Qi
i =1
2
=
n
n
i =1
i =1
∑ mi Pi ′′ Pi ′′′ 2 + ∑ mi Pi ′′′Qi
2
n JJJJJJG JJJJJJG + 2 ∑ mi Pi ′′ Pi ′′′ ⋅ Pi ′′′ Qi . i =1
JJJJJG JJJJJG JJJJJJG We may also write Pi ′′′Qi = Pi Qi − Pi Pi ′′′ , hence as a difference between a JJJJJG possible and a real displacement (which is a possible displacement too); hence, Pi'''Qi
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
30
JJJJJJG JJJJJJG JJJJJJG is a virtual displacement δri . On the other hand, Pi ′′ Pi ′′′ = Pi ′ Pi ′′′ − Pi ′ Pi ′′ ; taking into
account (18.1.62), (18.1.62') and introducing the lost forces of d’Alembert of the form (18.1.59), it results n JJJJJJG JJJJJG 2 ∑ mi Pi ′′ Pi ′′′ ⋅ Pi ′′′Qi = − ( Δt )2 i =1
n
∑ ( Fi
− mi ai ) ⋅ δri = − ( Δt )2
i =1
n
∑ Φi
i =1
⋅ δri .
Using the theorem of virtual work (in case of bilateral constraints) in the form (11.1.63), we notice that this sum vanishes; if the constraints are unilateral, then the relation (11.1.63'') takes place, the above sum being positive. As a conclusion, this sum is non-negative in case of ideal constraints, so that n
JJJJJG
∑ mi Pi ′′Qi
i =1
2
≥
JJJJJJG
n
∑ mi Pi ′′ Pi ′′′ 2
,
i =1
the equality taking place only if Qi ≡ Pi ′′′ . Gauss takes as measure of the deviation of the particle Pi from its free motion, in the real or in a possible motion, the constraint Z i = 2mi
Pi ′′ Pi ′′′ 2 ( Δt ) 4
,
or the constraint Z i = 2mi
Pi ′′′Qi
2
( Δt )4
,
respectively; in this case Z ≤ Z, Z =
n
n
i =1
i =1
∑ Zi , Z = ∑ Zi .
(18.1.63)
Hence, among all the possible motions of the discrete mechanical system S , the real motion is that for which the constraint Z is minimal (any other possible constraint Z is greater); but we notice that for all possible displacement must correspond the same positions and the same velocities at the moment t , the accelerations being different. JJJJJJG Taking into account the expression of the displacement Pi ′′ Pi ′′′ , we can express the constraint Z in the form Z =
1 n 1 1 n 1 Φ ι2 = ∑ ( F − mi ai )2 , ∑ 2 i =1 mi 2 i =1 mi i
(18.1.64)
Lagrangian Mechanics
31
while for the representative point P we can write 1 3n 1 1 3n 1 Φ κ2 = ∑ ( Qk − Mk Xk ∑ 2 k =1 M k 2 k =1 M k
Z =
)2 .
(18.1.65)
From the condition of minimum of the constraint in the real motion it results δZ = 0 ; because only the accelerations vary, we get δZ =
3n
1
∑ M k Φk δΦk
k =1
3n
3n
k =1
k =1
= − ∑ Φk δXk = − ∑ ( Qk − M k Xk
) δXk
= 0,
(18.1.66)
equation which can be identified with the equation (18.1.60'). Starting from this equation and from the relations (18.1.58'), (18.1.58''), written in the form 3n
∑ bjk δXk
k =1 3n
∂f
= 0, j = 1, 2,..., m ,
∑ ∂Xlk δXk
k =1
= 0, l = 1, 2,..., p ,
(18.1.67) (18.1.67')
respectively, and introducing Lagrange’s multipliers – on the same way as in the previous subsection – we find the equations (18.1.42). We can thus state Theorem 18.1.6 (theorem of the least constraint; C. F. Gauss). The motion of the representative point P , subjected to ideal constraints in the space E 3 n , takes place so that the constraint Z of this point has a minimum for virtual variations of the generalized accelerations (the generalized co-ordinates and the generalized velocities are considered constant). We can also say that, in the same conditions concerning the position, the generalized velocities and the generalized accelerations, the first variation of the constraint Z of the representative point must vanish (the constraint Z is stationary along the trajectory of the representative point P ). We have seen that the demonstration of this theorem implies the theorem of virtual work, being thus equivalent to Newton’s principle. Also the theorem of the least constraint, stated by Gauss in 1829, can be considered as a principle (the principle of the least constraint), because – starting from it – one can find again Newton’s equations in case of ideal constraints. H. Hertz considers that the given generalized forces, which act upon the mechanical system S , can be replaced by given constraints between this system and neighbouring systems which act upon it; thus, he studies only mechanical systems which are not acted upon by given generalized forces ( Qk = 0 ). As well, to obtain a geometric interpretation, he assumes that the generalized masses M k are equal to unity (hence, M 1 = M 2 = ... = M 3 n ). Thus, it results 2
Z =
1 3 n 2 1 3 n ⎛ d2 Xk ⎞ Xk = ∑ ⎜ . ∑ 2 k =1 2 k =1 ⎝ dt 2 ⎟⎠
(18.1.68)
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
32
In case of a single particle, of co-ordinates x1 , x 2 , x 3 , we have (we can assume, in this case, that the mass m is not equal to unity) Z =
m 2 ( x + x22 + x32 2 1
)=
m 2 a , 2
(18.1.69)
where a is the acceleration in the considered motion; we obtain thus δZ = a δa . Using Frenet’s frame of reference, we can write a2 =
v4 + v 2 ; ρ2
this sum of squares is minimal if v = 0 (which takes place because the given force is equal to zero and one assumes that the constraints are catastatic, so that dWR = 0 , while the constraint force has no component along the tangent to the trajectory), hence if the motion is uniform and if the curvature 1/ ρ is minimal. Hence, the trajectory of the point must be of minimal curvature (as near as possible to a straight line). In case of a discrete mechanical system S , of representative point P , we can express the kinetic energy in the form (with the above considerations)
( )
2
T =
1 3n 2 1 3 n dX k ⎞ 1 ds Xk = ∑ ⎛⎜ ⎟ = ∑ 2 k =1 2 k = 1 ⎝ dt ⎠ 2 dt
2
=
1 2 s , 2
where ds 2 = dX12 + dX 22 + ... + dX 32n is the square of the arc element in the space E 3 n . Because there are not generalized forces and assuming that to constraints are catastatic ( dWR = 0 ), it results that T = const. As we can notice, 2 3 n dX 3 n dX d2 X dX k k ⎞ k k = 0, X k = s, ∑ ⎛⎜ ⎟ = 1, ∑ ds ds 2 k = 1 ⎝ ds ⎠ k = 1 ds
so that d2 Xk 2 dXk Xk = s + s ; ds ds 2
in the mentioned conditions, we have s = v = 0 , hence the motion of the representative point on its trajectory is uniform. We can thus replace the quantity Z by the quantity K2 =
d2 Xk = 2 k = 1 ds 3n
∑
n
∑
i =1
( ddrs ) i
2
=
n
∑ Ki2 ,
(18.1.70)
i =1
where we define by K the curvature of the path travelled through by the system (in a certain sense, a measure of the curvatures of the paths of all the particles Pi which form
Lagrangian Mechanics
33
the system S ); the minimum of the curvature K corresponds, obviously, to the minimum of the constraint Z . We can thus state Theorem 18.1.7 (theorem of the least curvature; theorem of the most straight path; H. Hetz). The motion of the discrete mechanical system S , subjected to ideal catastatic constraints, in the absence of the given generalized forces (in spontaneous motion) and assuming a mass of equal generalized components, takes place, starting from a given initial uniform motion, so that the curvature K of the path travelled through by the system be minimal, with respect to any other possible path (the path travelled trough be the most straight possible one). As in the preceding cases, we can consider this theorem as a principle (the principle of least curvature or the principle of the most straight path). We mention that, because of the conditions which are imposed, this principle is not so easy to apply; but the connections to Lagrangian mechanics and to relativistic mechanics are interesting. Starting from a constraint relation of the form ϕ j ( X1 , X 2 ,..., Xn , X 1 , X 2 ,..., X n ; t ) = 0, j = 1, 2,..., m ,
which is not necessarily linear in the generalized velocities, and effecting a total derivative with respect to time, we obtain 3n
⎛ ∂ϕj
∑ ⎜⎝ ∂Xk X k
k =1
+
∂ϕ j ⎞ Xk ⎟ + ϕ j = 0, j = 1, 2,..., m . ∂X k ⎠
Varying only the accelerations, we find the relations 3n
∂ϕ j
∑ ∂X
k =1
δXk = 0, j = 1, 2,..., m ,
(18.1.71)
k
which are of the same form as the relations (18.1.67) ( bjk = ∂ϕ j ∂X k ). We can thus state that Gauss’s principle can be applied even if the kinetic constraint relations are not linear in the generalized velocities, having thus a larger sphere of applicability than the principle of virtual work (for which the mentioned relations must be linear in the generalized velocities). We remark that Jourdain’s principle has a position somewhat intermediary between the d’Alembert-Lagrange principle and Gauss's principle.
18.1.2.4 Applications Let be a particle P subjected to move on a deformable surface of equation f (x1 , x 2 , x 3 ; t ) = 0 (we use the notations in the space E 3 ); the constraint relation can be written in the form f, j δx j = 0 . If we use the principle of virtual work in the form
Φj δx j = 0 and if we eliminate, e.g., the virtual displacement δx 3 , then we get
(18.1.72)
34
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
f,1 f,2 ⎛ ⎞ ⎛ ⎞ ⎜ Φ1 − f Φ3 ⎟ δx1 + ⎜ Φ2 − f Φ3 ⎟ δx 2 = 0 . ,3 ,3 ⎝ ⎠ ⎝ ⎠
To satisfy this relation for any virtual displacement δx1 and δx 2 , the two brackets must vanish, hence f,1 f,2 f,3 = = . Φ1 Φ2 Φ3
(18.1.73)
This result corresponds to that obtained in Sect. 6.2.2.2 by the method of Lagrange’s multipliers.
Fig. 18.2 Motion of a particle on a fixed or movable or deformable sphere
In particular, let be a particle P in motion on a sphere S , fixed or movable and deformable ( r ′ − rO′ )2 = l 2 , of centre rO′ = rO′ (t ) and radius l = l (t ) (Fig. 18.2). Noting that grad[( r ′ − rO′ )2 − l 2 ] = 2( r ′ − rO′ ) , Lagrange’s equation of the first kind is of the form r ′ = λ ( r ′ − rO′ ) , λ indeterminate scalar (we assume that the given force is equal to zero); shifting the origin to the centre of the sphere, we can write the equation of motion in the form r = λr − rO′ , r = r ′ − rO′ , too, with the constraint r 2 = l 2 , putting thus in evidence the complementary force of transportation −rO′ of the movable frame of reference (in general, non-inertial). By a vector product by r and by a scalar product by r , respectively, we get d d 2 d ( r × r ) = rO′ × r , r = λ r2 − 2 rO′ ⋅ r . dt dt dt
If rO′ = 0 (hence, if the movable frame is inertial, the centre of the sphere having a JJJJJG rectilinear and uniform motion), then we have r × r = C , C = const , wherefrom C ⋅ r = 0 and dr 2 dt = 2λ ll ; hence, the trajectory is a great circle of the deformable sphere (the intersection of the plane C ⋅ r = 0 with the sphere). In particular, if the radius l of the sphere is constant, then the trajectory is a geodesic of it. Let now be a particle P which moves on a deformable curve of equations fk (x1 , x 2 , x 3 ; t ) = 0 , k = 1, 2 (in the space E 3 ); the constraint relations can be written
Lagrangian Mechanics
35
in the form fk , j δx j = 0 , k = 1,2 . Associating the condition (18.1.72) and eliminating the virtual displacements, we obtain Φ1
Φ3
Φ3
f1,1
f1,2
f1,3 = 0 ,
f2,1
f2,2
f2,3
(18.1.74)
relation which – together with the constraint relations – allows to determine the motion of the particle (see Sect. 6.2.2.1 too, where Lagrange’s multipliers are used).
Fig. 18.3 Motion of a particle on a movable circle of variable radius
Let us study, in particular, the motion of a particle P on a circle C , movable and of variable radius, represented by the intersection of the above considered sphere S with the plane α ⋅ ( r ′ − rO′ ) = 0 , α = α (t ) , which passes through rO′ and is normal to α (Fig. 18.3). As in the preceding case, in the absence of the given force, we can write the equation of motion in the form r = λ1 r + λ2 α − rO′ , λ1 , λ2 indeterminate scalars, r = r ′ − rO′ , with the constraint relations r 2 = l 2 , α ⋅ r = 0 . By a vector product by r and successive scalar products by r and α , respectively, we get
d ( r × r ) = λ2 r × α + rO′ , dt d 2 d r = λ1 r 2 − 2 rO′ ⋅ r + 2λ2 α ⋅ r , dt dt α ⋅ r = λ2 α2 − α ⋅ rO' . JJJJJG If α = const (hence, if the circle C is in a plane of fixed direction), then we have α ⋅ r = 0 , α ⋅ r = 0 too (according to the constraint relations). Thus, it results
λ2 = α ⋅
rO′ , α2
hence the component λ2 α normal to the plane α ⋅ r = 0 , of the constraint force (the component contained in the plane is λ1 r ). If rO′ = 0 (the movable frame of reference
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
36
is inertial), then the constraint force is contained in the plane of the circle, which has a fixed orientation. Let be two particles P1 and P2 of masses m1 and m2 and position vectors r1 and r2 , upon which act the given forces F1 and F2 , respectively; we assume a constraint relation at distance of the form ( r1 − r2 )2 = l 2 , l = l (t ) , which can be written as ( r1 − r2 ) ⋅ δr1 − ( r1 − r2 ) ⋅ δr2 = 0 . The principle of virtual work is written in the form Φ1 ⋅ δr1 + Φ2 ⋅ δr2 = 0 , being thus led to Lagrange’s equations of the first kind Φ1 + λ ( r1 − r2 ) = 0, Φ2 − λ ( r1 − r2 ) = 0 .
(18.1.75)
We obtain thus Φ1 + Φ2 = 0 . Assuming that F1 = m1 g + F12 , F2 = m2 g + F21 , g = g (t ) , where F12 and F21 are internal forces ( F12 + F21 = 0 ), it results m1 r1 + m2 r2 = (m1 + m2 )g , wherefrom t
τ
0
0
m1 r1 + m2 r2 = ( m1 + m2 ) ∫ dτ ∫ g ( τ )dτ + C1t + C2 , JJJJJG with C1 , C2 = const ; hence, the centre of mass C has a motion of acceleration g (t ) , being situated on the segment of a line P1P2 , so that
CP1 =
m2 l m1l , CP2 = , l = P1P2 . m1 + m2 m1 + m2
The particles P1 and P2 will be at any moment on two concentric spheres of radii CP1 and CP2 , respectively (hence, remains to be studied the problem of motion of a particle on a given sphere). In the particular case of two heavy particles, the mass centre C will describe a parabola situated in a vertical plane and having a vertical axis; the particles will be in a plane of fixed orientation, their motion with respect to the centre C taking place after the law of areas. The analytic methods of computation have been developed, especially, in case of discrete mechanical systems; however, they can be applied successfully also to problems concerning continuous mechanical systems. We consider thus a perfectly flexible, inextensible and non-torsionable thread, of given length l , fixed at the points P 0 and P 1 , acted upon by forces p (s ) on unit length. The principle of virtual work is written in the form ( Φ ⋅ δr ) ds ∫Pq P 1
2
= 0, Φ = p − μ a ,
(18.1.76)
where μ (s ) is the linear density, while a(s ) is the acceleration of an arbitrary point P . The relation ds 2 = (dr )2 leads to ds 2 δ(ds ) = dr2 ⋅ δ(dr ) ; because the thread is inextensible, we have δ(ds ) = 0 , so that the constraint relation (which takes place for all the elements of arc) is written in the form
Lagrangian Mechanics
37 dr ⋅ δ ( dr ) = 0 . ds
Starting from the points P of the curve C and considering a given system of virtual displacements (at any point P corresponds a virtual displacement δr at the moment t ), we obtain the points P , which form the curve C . If P ( r ) and P ′( r + dr ) are two neighbouring points on the curve C and P ( r + δr ) is a corresponding point on the JJJG JJJJG curve C , one can reach the point P ′ on the path PP + PP ′ or on the path JJJJG JJJJG PP ′ + P ′P ′ (Fig. 18.4); hence, the point P ′ can be specified by r + δr + d( r + δr ) = r + dr + δ( r + dr ) ,
wherefrom d( δr ) = δ(dr ) , so that the two operators are linked by the relation dδ = δd .
(18.1.77)
Obviously, the considerations made above involve, at the most, holonomic constraints; the relation of permutation (18.1.77) takes place just in such a case.
Fig. 18.4 Displacements of a particle laying on a curve
The constraint relation becomes dr ⋅ d ( δr ) = 0 , ds
so that Lagrange’s equation of the first kind will be ⎡
dr
⎤
Φ ⋅ δrds + λ ⋅ d ( δr ) = 0 . ∫Pq ⎥⎦ P ⎢ ds ⎣ 0
Integrating by parts
1
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
38 dr
dr
⋅ d ( δr ) = λ λ ∫Pq P ds ds 0
1
⋅ δr
P1 P0
−
δr ⋅ d ( ∫Pq P 0
1
λ dr ds
)
and noting that δr vanishes at the fixed points P 0 and P 1 , it results Φd s + d ( ∫Pq P ⎢ ⎣
⎡
0
1
)
λ dr ⎤ ⋅ δr = 0 . ds ⎥⎦
Because this relation must take place for any virtual displacement δr , we obtain Φd s − λ
dr = 0; ds
introducing the tension in the thread T =T
dr ,T = − λ , ds
we can write Φ+
dT = 0, ds
(18.1.78)
finding thus again the equation (12.2.10) of motion of the thread. We present now some simple applications too, eventually with a practical character.
Fig. 18.5 Motion of a coach on a railway in a curved line
Let use consider a railway which, on a certain length, follows a curve of curvature radius ρ . D’Alembert’s principle, written for the mass centre C of a coach, in the normal plane to the curve (Fig. 18.5), leads to G + N + Ft = 0 , where G is the weight of the coach, N is the normal reaction of the ground, while Ft is the transportation force of a non-inertial frame of reference (the centrifugal force), of magnitude
Lagrangian Mechanics
39 mv 2 . ρ
Ft =
To can verify the equation of dynamic equilibrium, one must give to the ground an inclination of angle α , so that N sin α − Ft = 0 , N cos α − G = 0 , whence tan α =
Ft v2 = ; G ρg
the exterior rail must be superelevate to a height h = l sin α ≅ l tan α ( l is the clearance of the railway), so that h ≅
v 2l , gρ
(18.1.79)
at an arbitrary point of the curve.
Fig. 18.6 Belidor’s crane bridge
Let be now a rigid bar OA of weight G , which is rotating in a vertical plane, about a fixed point O . A perfectly flexible, inextensible and non-torsionable thread, which passes over a fixed pulley B , situated on the vertical line of O , connects the point A to a point P , where is suspended a weight Q . One must find the locus of the point P (a curve Γ ), so that the bar AO be in indifferent equilibrium (Fig. 18.6). The bar AO models Belidor’s crane bridge. We denote n = θ , OBP n =ϕ ; OA = 2l , AB = a , BP = r , OB = h , h > 0, BOA
we choose OB as Ox 2 -axis, the Ox1 -axis being horizontal, so that x C2 = l cos θ ,
x 2P = h − r cos ϕ . The constraint relations are a + r = L , r = r (ϕ ) , where L is the length of the thread. The mechanical system has only one degree of freedom and its
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
40
position can be specified by the angle ϕ . The principle of virtual work is written in the form −G δx C2 − Q δx 2P = 0 . We have δa + δr = 0 , δr = r ′(ϕ ) δϕ , a 2 = 4l 2 + h 2 − 4lh cos θ ,
hence a δa = 2lh sin θ δθ ; in this case δx C2 = −l sin θ δθ = −
a a a δa = δr = r ′(ϕ )δϕ . 2h 2h 2h
On the other hand,
δx 2P = − cos ϕ δr + r sin ϕ δϕ = [ r (ϕ ) sin ϕ − r ′(ϕ ) cos ϕ ] δϕ . We obtain thus the condition of equilibrium −
Ga r ′(ϕ ) + Q [ r ′(ϕ ) cos ϕ − r (ϕ ) sin ϕ ] = 0 , 2h
which determines the corresponding angles ϕ . We get thus the differential equation
{
}
G [ L − r (ϕ )] − Q cos ϕ r ′(ϕ ) + Qr (ϕ ) sin ϕ = 0 . 2h
Fig. 18.7 Equilibrium of three particles acted upon by three forces in a particular case
By integration, we obtain G 2 PL r (ϕ ) − r (ϕ ) + Qr (ϕ ) cos ϕ = const. 4h 2h
Hence, the equation of the curve r is of the form
Lagrangian Mechanics
41
r2 − ( α + β cos ϕ )r + γ = 0, α =
2 Pl 4Qh , γ = arbitrary, ,β = − G G
(18.1.80)
representing – in general – ovals of Descartes; for γ = 0 it results a Pascal’s limaçon. C. Neumann considered three particles P1 , P2 , P3 , linked so that the area of the triangle P1P2 P3 be constant, and upon which act the given forces F1 , F2 , F3 , respectively (Fig. 18.7). If r1 , r2 , r3 are position vectors of the particles P1 , P2 and P3 , respectively, and if we denote JJJJJG rjk = Pj Pk = rk − rj , j , k = 1, 2, 3, r12 × r13 = C u ,
where u = u(t ) is a vector normal to the plane P1P2 P3 , while C = const , then the constraint relation is of the form ( r12 × r13 )2 = C 2 = const . Taking into account the properties of the mixed product of these vectors, we notice that the constraint relation can be written in the form
[ ( r12 × r13 ) × r23 ] ⋅ δr1 + [ ( r12 × r13 ) × r31 ] ⋅ δr2 + [ ( r12 × r13 ) × r12 ] ⋅ δr3 = 0 ; associating the principle of virtual work, given by F1 ⋅ δr1 + F2 ⋅ δr2 + F3 ⋅ δr3 = 0 ,
and introducing Lagrange’s multiplier λ , we can write the equations of equilibrium (corresponding to Lagrange’s equations of the first kind) in the form F1 = − λC u × r23 , F2 = − λC u × r31 , F3 = − λC u × r12 ,
(18.1.81)
where we have used the notation introduced above too. It results that, for the equilibrium, the forces F1 , F2 and F3 must be in a plane normal to the unit vector u , hence in the plane of the triangle P1P2 P3 ; they must be normal to the sides opposite to the vertices at which they act (hence, their supports must pierce at the orthocentre H of the triangle, while their magnitudes must be in direct proportion to these sides). As a simple application of Gauss's principle, let us consider Atwood’s machine (see Sect. 11.1.2.2 and Fig 11.1), where the weights G1 and G 2 are modeled as particles and where we neglect the influence of the wheel of weight G . The constraint will be Z =
1⎡ 1 1 ( m1g − m1a )2 + ( m2 g − m2a )2 ⎤⎥ , ⎢ 2 ⎣ m1 m2 ⎦
where we assume that m1 > m2 ; in this case δZ = [ − m1 (g − a ) + m2 (g + a ) ] δa = 0 ,
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
42 being thus led to a =
m1 − m2 g, m1 + m2
(18.1.82)
a formula which corresponds to (11.1.21).
18.1.2.5 General Theorems. Conservation Theorems Let be discrete a mechanical system S of n particles Pi , acted upon by the given forces Fi , i = 1, 2,..., n ; assuming that the constraints allow an arbitrary virtual rigid displacement (with respect to an inertial frame of reference) δri′ = vO′∗ δt + ( ω∗ δt ) × ri , ri = ri′ − rO′ , i = 1, 2,..., n ,
(18.1.83)
where O is the pole of a non-inertial frame, rigidly linked to the mechanical system S in its rigid displacement (corresponding to the formula (18.1.3)). The principle of virtual work is thus written in the form n
∑ Φi
i =1
⋅ [ vO′∗ δt + ( ω∗ δt ) × ri ] = 0 .
Because the vectors vO′∗ and ω∗ are arbitrary, it results n
∑ Φi
i =1
n
= 0, ∑ ri′ × Φi = 0 , i =1
(18.1.84)
where we took into account the second relation (18.1.83). We can also write τO ′ { Φi } = 0 ,
(18.1.84')
the torsor of d’Alembert’s lost forces, with respect to the pole of an inertial frame of reference, vanishing. Starting from this result, we find again the general theorems of mechanics (the theorem of momentum and the theorem of moment of momentum). Comparing with the relation (11.1.61), written with respect to the same pole O ′ , where the lost forces of d’Alembert equilibrate the constraint forces, we see that in this new form of the theorem of torsor do not appear the constraint forces; this happens because the relation (11.1.61) can be written for any mechanical system, while the relation (18.1.84') takes place only for the mechanical systems which admit an arbitrary rigid displacement. In case a free rigid solid which, obviously, admits an arbitrary rigid displacement, the theorem of torsor becomes (V is the volume of the rigid solid, μ is the density, while F is a volumic force, which – eventually – can be reduced to a superficial one)
Lagrangian Mechanics
43
{
τO ' Φ dV
} = 0, Φ =
F − μ r ,
(18.1.85)
wherefrom
∫V ( F − μ r ) dV
= 0,
∫V r × ( F − μ r ) dV
= 0,
(18.1.85')
resulting the theorem of momentum and the theorem of moment of momentum, respectively. If the solid would have a fixed point, we could admit that this one is just the point O , so that rO′ = 0 and vO′∗ = 0 ; we obtain
∫V Φ ⋅ ⎡⎣ ( ω
∗
)
δt × r ⎤⎦ dV =
∫V ( r × Φ ) ⋅ ( ω δt ) dV ∗
= 0.
The virtual angular velocity ω∗ being arbitrary, it results
∫V r × Φ dV
= 0,
(18.1.86)
which leads to the theorem of moment of momentum. In the case in which the rigid solid has two fixed points, hence a fixed axis, we can take this axis as the O ′x 3′ -axis, O ′ ≡ O , after the vector ω∗ ; in projection on the axis O ′x 3′ ≡ Ox 3 , we can write
∫V ( x1 Φ2
− x 2 Φ1 ) ( ω ∗ δt ) dV = 0 ,
∫V ( x1 Φ2
− x 2 Φ1 ) dV = 0 ,
wherefrom (18.1.87)
being thus led to the projection of the theorem of moment of momentum on a fixed axis. If, for a discrete mechanical system S , the constraints admit as virtual displacement a translation of constant direction, specified by the constant unit vector u and of arbitrary magnitude δr ′ = k u δt , vO′∗ = k u , and if ω∗ = 0 , then we get
∫V Φ ⋅ u dV
= 0,
(18.1.88)
hence the theorem of momentum projected on the direction of unit vector u ; this allows to write a scalar first integral, component of a conservation theorem of momentum (corresponding to the theorem expressed by the first formula (18.1.84)). As well, if the mechanical system S has constraints which allow a rotation about an axis of fixed direction, specified by the unit vector u , then we can write δr ′ = ( ω∗ uδt ) × r , vO′ = 0 ; we obtain thus (if we take the point O on the fixed axis, then we have rO′ = 0 , O ≡ O ′ , hence r ′ = r )
44
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
∫V ( r ′ × Φ ) ⋅ udV
= 0,
(18.1.89)
that is the theorem of moment of momentum with respect to the pole O ′ , projected on the fixed axis of unit vector u . We obtain thus a scalar first integral too, component of a first integral of moment of momentum (corresponding to the theorem expressed by the second formula (18.1.84)). As in case of the theorem (18.1.84), in these results intervene only given forces; in exchange, they take place only for the mentioned particular motions of the rigid solid. One can make analogous considerations concerning the theorem of kinetic energy for the conservation of the mechanical energy, assuming that the constraints of the mechanical system S are catastatic.
18.1.2.6 Influence of the Forces of Friction Let us consider a particle P subjected to the action of a given force F and to holonomic constraints, which lead to a constraint force R . In case of a single holonomic an rheonomous constraint ϕ (x1 , x 2 , x 3 ; t ) = 0 , we can write R = N + T , where N is the normal constraint force and T is the tangential constraint force. If the constraint would be scleronomic, hence the force T would correspond to the sliding friction on the fixed rigid surface S (of equation ϕ ( x1 , x 2 , x 3 ) = 0 ). We can consider, e.g., a hydrodynamic friction, of the form T = − k v , k = k ( r , r ; t ) > 0 , which leads to the replacement of the given force F = F ( r , r ; t ) by a new force F = F − k v , the problem remaining the same from a mathematical point of view. In case of a Coulombian friction, of the form T = fN v / v , f = f ( r , r ; t ) , the problem is put in a different from, due to the unknown factor N , corresponding to the normal constraint force; we remain now to this second case. We assume a constraint ϕ ( r ; t ) = 0 , which may correspond to a family of rigid
surfaces St in motion, depending on the parameter t . The velocity of the particle is
v = vt + vr , where vt is the velocity of transportation and vr is the sliding velocity on the surface St (on the nature of a relative velocity); in this case, in the expression of the constraint force T , the velocity v is replaced by the velocity vr . The constraints are no more ideal, so that the condition of ideal constraint takes no more place; this condition is replaced by an analogous condition of the form R × W = 0,
(18.1.90)
where the vector W plays the rôle of the virtual displacement δr . The principle of virtual work is thus replaced by Φ⋅W = 0.
(18.1.91)
Noting that R = ± N n − fN τ = N ( ± n − f τ ) , where τ and n are unit vectors in the frame of Darboux, we can write the condition (18.1.90) also in the form
Lagrangian Mechanics
45 (n ± fτ) ⋅ W = 0 ,
(18.1.90')
neglecting the scalar N ≠ 0 . To express the unit vectors τ and n as functions of the data of the problem, we use the curvilinear co-ordinates u and v on the surface St so that v = ru′u + rv′v + r ; putting in evidence the partial derivatives with respect to these co-ordinates, it results vr = ru′u + rv′v and then τ = vers vr . As well, n = vers gradϕ = vers ( ru′ × rv′ )
(see Sect. 4.1.1.4 too). Eliminating W between the relation (18.1.90'), (18.1.91), which do not contain the unknown scalar N , by means of Lagrange’s multiplier λ , we obtain Φ + λ(n ± fτ) = 0.
(18.1.92)
If we associate also the scalar constraint relation ϕ = 0 to this vector equation, then we can determine the unknowns r = r (t ) and λ = λ (t ) . In case of two holonomic constraints ϕk ( r ; t ) = 0 , k = 1, 2 , which can correspond to a family of rigid curves C t in motion, depending on the parameter t , we proceed as above and obtain the equations Φ ⋅ W = 0, ( nk ± f τ ) ⋅ W = 0, k = 1, 2 .
(18.1.93)
We are thus led to Lagrange’s equation of the first kind Φ + λ1 ( n1 ± f τ ) + λ2 ( n2 ± f τ ) = 0 .
(18.1.94)
In the scleronomic case, this equation – to which we associate the constraint relations – is sufficient to solve the problem. In the rheonomous case, we use a representation in curvilinear co-ordinates r = r (q ; t ) (see Sect. 4.1.1.3 too) and representations r = r (q , qk ; t ) , k = 1, 2 , of the surface, so that the position of an arbitrary point of these ones be specified by the same values of the parameters q and qk , no matter its position in space. We have nk = vers ( rq′ × rq′k ) and τ = vers vr = q vers rq′ , this being the unit vector of the tangent to the curve C t ; in this case too, the problem is entirely determined.
18.2 Lagrange’s Equations A decisive step ahead has been made by Lagrange, by eliminating the holonomic constraints from the computation and by introducing independent generalized co-ordinates, in case of mechanical systems subjected only to such constraints; thus one passes from the representative space E 3n to a new representative space Λs , called the
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
46
space of configurations. The equations of motion of the representative point are thus Lagrange’s equations of second kind, which will be studied in this paragraph.
18.2.1 Space of Configurations By introducing the Lagrangian generalized co-ordinates, in a minimal parameterization, one passes from the space E 3 (or from the representative space E 3n ) to the space of configurations Λs . In what follows, we put in evidence the form taken by various mechanical quantities (displacement, velocity, acceleration, kinetic energy, work etc.), obtaining a new formulation of the fundamental problem of mechanics in the new representative space. 18.2.1.1 Generalized Co-ordinates. Representative Space Λs Let us consider a discrete mechanical system S of n a particles Pi , i = 1, 2,..., n , subjected to p holonomic constraints of the form (3.2.8), the corresponding representative point P in the space E 3n being subjected to p constraints of the form (18.1.9). In this case, the system S has 3n − p = s degrees of geometric freedom, its position being thus specified, at a moment t , by means of s independent parameters. To have motion, it is necessary that s ≥ 1 ; if s = 1 , then we say that the mechanical system is with complete constraints. Let be q1 , q2 ,..., qs a set of such parameters, which will be called Lagrangian generalized co-ordinates (shortly, generalized co-ordinates). The position of the mechanical system S will be thus given by relations of the form ri = ri (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ) ≡ ri (q j ; t ), i = 1, 2,..., n ;
(18.2.1)
correspondingly, the position of the representative point P in the space E 3n is specified by Xk ≡ Xk (q j ; t ), k = 1,2,..., 3n .
(18.2.2)
Obviously, the relations (18.2.1) verify identically the constraint relations (3.2.8), while the relations (18.2.2) verify identically the constraint relations (18.1.9). If the constraints are scleronomic, hence of the form (3.2.33'), then the relations (18.2.1) take the form ri = ri (q1 , q1 ,..., qs ), i = 1, 2,..., n .
(18.2.1')
As well, for constraints of the form (18.1.12), the relations (18.2.2) become Xk ≡ X k (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ), k = 1, 2,..., 3n .
(18.2.2')
Indeed, if for the relations (18.1.12), e.g., we assume that det ⎡⎣ ∂fl ∂Xk ⎤⎦ ≠ 0 , l , k = 1, 2,..., p (the matrix ⎡⎣ ∂fl ∂Xk ⎤⎦ is of rank p ), then it results, from the theorem of implicit functions, that Xk ≡ Xk ( X p + 1 , X p + 2 ,..., X 3 n ), k = 1, 2,..., p . We take
Lagrangian Mechanics
47
X p + 1 = q1 , X p + 2 = q2 ,..., X 3 n = qs , s = 3n − p ; one obtains thus relations of the
form (18.2.2'). Obviously, in case of relations of the form (18.2.1') or of the form (18.2.2') one can have only holonomic and scleronomic constraints. In particular, if no one holonomic constraint takes place (the mechanical system S is free) or if we ignore these constraints, we can take Xk = qk , k = 1, 2,..., 3n , corresponding to the representative space E 3n . But if we take into account all p holonomic constraints, the mechanical system S having only s = 3n − p degrees of freedom, then the parameterization qk , k = 1,2,..., s considered above is minimal. Otherwise, if we do not take into account all the holonomic constraints or if, during the motion, appear supplementary holonomic constraints of the form fl (qk ; t ) ≡ fl (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ) = 0, l = 1,2,..., h ,
(18.2.3)
then the mechanical system S remains with s − h degrees of freedom. Obviously, these constraints are independent too, so that the matrix ⎡⎣ ∂fl ∂q j ⎤⎦ is of rank h ; as well, we suppose that no one of these constraints is a consequence of the equations of motion (it is not a first integral of these equations). The constraints of the form (18.2.3) are rheonomous; we can consider, in particular, also scleronomic constraints of the form fl (q j ) ≡ fl (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ), l = 1,2,..., p .
(18.2.3')
We mention that one can have also unilateral constraints, expressed by means of inequalities; but, in what follows, we will consider only bilateral constraints. The space of generalized co-ordinates q1 , q2 ,..., qs is, as well, a representative space with s dimensions, called the space of configurations (figurative space or Lagrange’s space), which will be denoted by Λs (in the honour of Lagrange). A point P (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ) is a representative point, its position in the space Λs specifying univocally the position of the representative point P in the space E 3 n , as well as the position of the discrete mechanical system S in the space E 3 ; obviously, we must assume that the matrix ⎡⎣ ∂Xk ∂q j ⎤⎦ is of rank s , so that – on the basis of the theorem of implicit functions – to a given discrete mechanical system S corresponds only one representative point P (we notice that one can have several non-zero determinants of order s , so that we can express the minimal parameterization q j in various modes, depending on the generalized co-ordinates Xk ; if one takes into account the constraint relations (18.1.9) too, one sees that the respective expression are equivalent). The succession of value taken by the generalized co-ordinates during time leads to the functions qk = qk (t ), t ∈ [t0 , t1 ], k = 1,2,..., s , which represent the parametric equations of the trajectory of the representative point P , characterizing – at the same time – the motion of the mechanical system S .
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
48
In case of a particle constrained to stay on a curve one uses only one generalized co-ordinates q ( x i = x i (q , t ), i = 1,2, 3 ; see Sect. 6.2.2.1) in the space Λ1 ; e.g., in case of the simple pendulum this co-ordinate is the angle at the centre θ (see Sect. 7.1.3.1). In case of a particle constrained to stay on a surface we use two generalized co-ordinates ( r = r (q1 , q2 ; t ) ; see Sect. 6.2.2.2) in the space Λ2 ; e.g., in case of the spherical pendulum these co-ordinates are the applicate z and the angle at the centre θ (see Sect. 7.1.3.7). We notice that the particles of the mechanical system S can be replaced by rigid solids. E.g., in case of a physical pendulum we use also a generalized co-ordinate (the angle θ ; see Sect. 14.2.1.2), in the space Λ1 , while in case of a double pendulum one introduces two generalized co-ordinates (the angles θ1 and θ2 ; see Sect. 17.1.1.2), in the space Λ2 . As it can be seen, the generalized co-ordinates are not necessarily lengths; they can be angles too. Moreover, in the frame of the same Lagrangian space, some co-ordinates can be lengths, the other ones can be angles or even other quantities; it is not necessary that all generalized co-ordinates have all the same physical dimension. Practically, one chooses as generalized co-ordinates the parameters which can specify the configuration (position) of the discrete mechanical system S at any moment t . 18.2.1.2 Generalized Displacements. Generalized Velocities. Constraints. Generalized Accelerations Starting from the relation (18.2.1), we can express the real displacements in the form (we denote ri = ∂ri ∂t ) dri =
∂ri dq j + ri dt , i = 1, 2,..., n , ∂q j
(18.2.4)
putting thus in evidence the real generalized displacements dq j . Here and in what follows we use the convention of summation of dummy indices (from 1 to s ) in the space Λs ; analogously, we express the possible displacements in the form Δri =
∂ri Δq j + ri Δt , i = 1, 2,..., n , ∂q j
(18.2.5)
the virtual displacements being given by δri =
∂ri δq , i = 1, 2,..., n . ∂q j j
(18.2.6)
One introduces thus the possible generalized displacements Δq j and the virtual generalized displacements δq j , which have the same properties as those corresponding to the spaces E 3 and E 3 n . E.g., the virtual generalized displacements are differences of possible generalized displacements (as one sees from (18.2.5), (18.2.6)); as well, the
Lagrangian Mechanics
49
real generalized displacements belong to the set of possible generalized displacements, which – in general – does not coincide with the set of virtual generalized displacements. Let be two virtual displacements δ1 ri and δ2 ri of the same particle Pi , written in the form δ1 ri =
∂ri ∂r δ1q j , δ2 ri = i δ2q j , ∂q j ∂q j
where δ1q j and δ2q j are corresponding virtual generalized displacements; we may write δ1 ri + δ2 ri =
∂ri ( δ q + δ2q j ∂q j 1 j
)
too. Hence, by composition of two virtual displacements one obtains a new virtual displacement (the same property for the virtual generalized displacements). Let be the virtual generalized displacements δq j ; if −δq j is, as well, a virtual generalized displacement of the representative point P at a given moment t , then the displacement δq j is a reversible virtual generalized displacements. From the relations (18.2.6), it results that to reversible virtual displacements correspond reversible virtual generalized displacements. The velocities of the particles of the mechanical system S will be given by (we denote q j = dq j dt ) vi =
∂ri q + ri , i = 1, 2,..., n , ∂q j j
(18.2.4')
putting in evidence the real generalized velocities q j (shortly, the generalized velocities). As well, we express the possible velocities in the form (we denote q j = Δq j Δt ) vi =
∂ri q + ri , i = 1, 2,..., n , ∂q j j
(18.2.5')
the virtual displacements being given by (we denote q∗j = δq j Δt ) vi∗ =
∂ri ∗ q , i = 1, 2,..., n . ∂q j j
(18.2.6')
We introduce thus the possible generalized velocities q j and the virtual generalized velocities q∗j . We mention that also these quantities can have different dimensions (can be linear velocities, angular velocities etc.).
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
50
Using the generalized displacements introduced above, we can express the constraint relation (18.2.3) in one of the forms ∂fl dq j + fl dt = 0, l = 1, 2,..., p , ∂q j
(18.2.7)
∂fl δq = 0, l = 1, 2,..., p . ∂q j j
(18.2.8)
(
If fl = 0 , then it results ∂ ∂fl ∂q j
)
∂t = ∂fl ∂q j = 0, j = 1, 2,..., s , too, so that the
constraints are scleronomous; in this case, the set of virtual generalized displacements coincides with the set of possible generalized displacements, while the real generalized displacements belong to both sets (in case of holonomic constraints). Obviously, we can express the relations (18.2.7), (18.2.8) in one of the forms ∂fl q + fl = 0, l = 1, 2,..., p , ∂q j j
(18.2.7')
∂fl ∗ q = 0, l = 1, 2,..., p , ∂q j j
(18.2.8')
where we have introduced the generalized velocities and the virtual generalized velocities, respectively. If we replace in (3.2.13) the real displacements by the relations (18.2.4) or (18.2.4'), then we can express – in general – the constraint relations in one of the forms akj dq j + ak 0 dt = 0, k = 1, 2,..., m ,
(18.2.9)
akj q j + ak 0 = 0, k = 1, 2,..., m ,
(18.2.9')
where akj = ak 0 =
n
∑ αkl
i =1
n
⋅
∂ri 0 , j = 1, 2,..., s , ∂q j
∑ αkl ⋅ ri + αk 0 , k = 1,2,..., m .
(18.2.9'')
i =1
We notice, from (18.2.4') – (18.2.6'), that a necessary condition to have catastatic constraints is ri = 0, i = 1, 2,..., n ; indeed, in this case, to q j = 0 corresponds vi = 0 (hence, rest with respect to an inertial frame of reference), the inverse implication taking, as well, place (the matrix ⎡⎣ ∂Xk ∂q j ⎤⎦ is of rank s ). In case of holonomic constraints, the respective condition in sufficient too (as a mater of fact, in this case the constraints are scleronomic). In case of non-holonomic constraints one must have also αk 0 = 0 ; hence, from (18.2.9'') it results that these constraints are catastatic if and only if ak 0 = 0, k = 1,2,..., m . We notice that
Lagrangian Mechanics
51 akj =
n
∑ α ki
i =1
⋅
∂ri + ∂q j
n
∑ αki
i =1
⋅
∂ri . ∂q j
Because ri = 0 , while the matrix ⎡⎣ ∂Xk ∂q j ⎤⎦ is of rank s , it results that akj = 0 , j = 1,2,..., s , ⇔ α ki = 0, i = 1, 2,..., n , k = 1, 2,..., m . Hence, if the conditions akj = 0 are fulfilled, then the constraints (18.2.9'') are scleronomic.
We can express the non-holonomic constraint relations with the aid of the virtual generalized displacements too in one of the forms akj δq j = 0, k = 1,2,..., m ,
(18.2.10)
akj q ∗j
(18.2.10')
= 0, k = 1,2,..., m .
By means of the possible generalized displacements, it results akj Δq j = 0, k = 1, 2,..., m ,
(18.2.11)
akj q j∗ = 0, k = 1, 2,..., m ,
(18.2.11')
too. We can thus that, in case of catastatic constraints (holonomic or non-holonomic), the set of virtual generalized displacements coincides with the set of possible generalized displacements and the real generalized displacements belong to these sets. We notice, from (18.2.10), that – in case of bilateral constraints – the virtual generalized displacements are reversible; in case of non-strict unilateral constraints, only some virtual generalized displacements are reversible (these which are equated to zero in the constraint relations). In case of a scalar function ϕ (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ) or of a vector function W (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ) , the operator of total differentiation with respect to time is of the form d ∂ ∂ . = q j + dt ∂q j ∂t
(18.2.12)
This operator contains the operator of space differentiation q j ∂ ∂q j and the operator of time differentiation ∂ ∂t . Noting that ∂ d ∂2 ∂2 d ∂ ∂2 ∂2 = q j + , = q j + ∂qk dt ∂qk ∂q j ∂qk ∂t dt ∂qk ∂q j ∂qk ∂t ∂qk
and assuming that the considered functions are of class C 2 with respect to the corresponding variables (in this case, according to Schwartz’s theorem, the mixed derivatives are independent on the order of differentiation), we have the operator relation
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
52
∂ d d ∂ . = ∂qk dt dt ∂qk
(18.2.13)
Starting from (18.2.4') and taking into account (18.2.12), (18.2.13), we can calculate the acceleration of the particle Pi in the form ai =
dvi d ⎛ ∂ri = dt dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j
∂ri ∂ri dri ∂ ⎞ ⎟ q j + ∂q qj + dt = ∂q ( vi + ri ) q j + ∂q qj + ri , j j j ⎠
wherefrom
ai =
∂ri ∂2 ri ∂r qj + q j qk + 2 i q j + ri , i = 1, 2,..., n . ∂q j ∂q j ∂qk ∂q j
(18.2.14)
We have thus put in evidence the generalized accelerations qj = d2q j dt 2 , j = 1,2,..., s .
18.2.1.3 Kinetic Energy. Work. Natural Systems Starting from the expression (18.2.14') of the velocity of the particle Pi , we can calculate the kinetic energy of the discrete mechanical system S in the form T =
1 n 1 n ⎛ ∂r ⎞ ⎛ ∂r ⎞ mi vi2 = ∑ mi ⎜ i q j + ri ⎟ ⋅ ⎜ i q j + ri ⎟ . ∑ q ∂ 2 i =1 2 i =1 ⎝ ∂q j j ⎠ ⎝ ⎠
It results T = T2 + T1 + T0 ,
(18.2.15)
where T2 =
1 g q q , g = gkj = 2 jk j k jk
∂r
n
∑ mi ∂qij
i =1
⋅
∂ri , j , k = 1, 2,...s , ∂qk
(18.2.15')
is a quadratic form in the generalized velocities, T1 = g j q j , g j =
n
∂r
∑ mi ∂qij
i =1
⋅ ri , j = 1, 2,...s ,
(18.2.15'')
is a linear form in the generalized velocities, while
T0 = g 0 , g 0 =
1 n mi ri , 2 i∑ =1
is a constant with respect to these velocities.
(18.2.15''')
Lagrangian Mechanics
53
We notice that T0 ≥ 0 , being thus a non-negative quantity; the equality to zero takes place in case of catastatic constraints (if the constraints are holonomic, then they are scleronomic too). The linear form T1 can have any sign; also this form vanishes in case of catastatic constraints. Hence, in case of such constraints we have T = T2 =
1 n mi 2 i∑ =1
2
⎛ ∂ri ⎞ ⎜ ∂q q j ⎟ ⎝ j ⎠
≥ 0.
(18.2.16)
This quadratic form vanishes only if each bracket vanishes, hence for ∂ri q = 0, i = 1, 2,...n . ∂q j j
We notice that the matrix [ ∂Xk ∂q j ] of the coefficients of this system of linear equations is of rank s ; it results q j = 0, j = 1,2,..., s , the quadratic form T2 being positive definite. We remark, as well, that – in case of catastatic constraints – we have T2 = 0 too, the kinetic energy non-depending explicitly on time. One can state that g ≠ 0, g = det ⎡⎣ g jk ⎦⎤ .
(18.2.17)
Indeed, otherwise, the system of linear equations g jk qk = 0, j = 1,2,..., s , would have non-trivial solutions; thus, a linear combination of these equations could lead to 2T2 = g jk q j qk = 0 , without having all generalized velocities equal to zero. But the quadratic form T2 is positive definite, obtaining thus a contradiction. We mention also that T2 is a non-singular quadratic form (eventually, excepting the points (isolated) in which the correspondence (18.2.1) (or (18.2.2)) is not one-to-one). In general, the s (s + 1) 2 coefficients of the quadratic form T2 are of the form
g jk = g jk (q1 , q 2 ,..., qs ; t ),
j , k = 1, 2,..., s ;
as
well,
g j = g j (q1 , q 2 ,..., qs ; t ),
j = 1, 2,..., s . In case of catastatic constraints we have g jk = g jk (q1 , q 2 ,..., qs ),
j , k = 1, 2,..., s , g j = g j (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ), j = 1,2,..., s . The real elementary work of the given forces (external and internal) is given by dW =
n
∑ Fi
i =1
⋅ dri =
n
∑ Fi
i =1
⋅
∂ri dq j , ∂q j
where we have taken into account (18.2.4); we can also write d W = Q j dq j , Q j =
n
∑ Fi
i =1
⋅
∂ri , j = 1,2,..., s . ∂q j
(18.2.18)
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
54
By analogy, Q j are called generalized forces (by convention, we can assume that they act upon the representative point P ). The virtual work of these forces is expressed in the form δW = Q j δq j .
(18.2.19)
For the practical computation of the components (co-ordinates) of the generalized force, we can fix all co-ordinates excepting one of them (let be qk , to which corresponds the virtual displacement δqk ); calculating δW in E 3 , one can obtain Qk , making then – successively – k = 1, 2,..., s . We notice that a component Q j of the generalized force has the dimension of a force only if the corresponding generalized co-ordinate q j has the dimension of a length. Supposing that the given forces Fi , i = 1, 2,..., n , derive from a simple quasi-potential U ( ri ; t ) = U ( r1 , r2 ,..., rn ; t ) , then we can write U [ ri (q j ; t ); t ] = U (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ) ,
obtaining thus a simple quasi-potential in generalized co-ordinates; indeed we can write Qj =
n
∑ Fi ⋅
i =1
∂ri = ∂q j
n
∑ ∇iU ⋅
i =1
∂ri = ∂q j
(i ) ∂U ∂x k ∑ ∑ ( i ) ∂q j , i = 1 k = 1 ∂x n
3
k
wherefrom Qj =
∂U , j = 1, 2,..., s , ∂q j
(18.2.20)
the generalized forces being thus quasi-conservative. If U = U (q1 , q1 ,..., qs ) is a simple potential, then the corresponding generalized forces are conservative. But we must notice that the existence of a quasi-potential for the given generalized forces does not imply the existence of a quasi-potential for the given corresponding forces in the space E 3 . If Q j = [U ]j =
∂U d ∂U − , j = 1,2,..., s , dt ∂q j ∂q j
(18.2.21)
then we say that the generalized forces are quasi-conservative, deriving from a generalized quasi-potential U = U (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ) . We notice that the generalized forces cannot depend on the generalized accelerations (because the given forces cannot depend on the accelerations), so that the quasi-potential is of the form U = U k qk + U 0 ,
where U j = U j (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ), j = 0,1, 2,..., s . Hence,
(18.2.22)
Lagrangian Mechanics
55
∂U j ⎞ ∂U 0 ⎛ ∂U k Qj = ⎜ − ⎟ qk − U j + ∂q , j = 1,2,..., s , q q ∂ ∂ j k ⎠ ⎝ j
(18.2.21')
in case of quasi-conservative generalized forces; if the generalized forces are conservative, corresponding to a generalized potential, where U j = U j (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ) , j = 0,1,2,..., s , then we have U j = 0 . By following gauge transformation U k → U k = U k + ∂ϕ ∂qk , k = 1, 2,..., s , U 0 → U 0 = U 0 + ϕ , where
have
ϕ = ϕ (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ) is a function of class C 2 (to ( ∂ ∂qk )(d dt ) = (d dt )( ∂ ∂qk ) ), hence by a transformation of the form
U → U = U + dϕ dt , we obtain the same generalized forces Q j . Hence, the genera-
lized quasi-potential from which derives a quasi-conservative generalized force is determined excepting the total derivative with respect to time of a function ϕ of class C 2 . A field of quasi-conservative generalized forces is non-stationary, while a field of conservative generalized forces is stationary. The elementary work of conservative generalized forces is a total differential, being of the form (18.1.22), in case of a simple potential, or of the form (18.1.22''), in case of a generalized potential. If the generalized forces are quasi-conservative, deriving from a simple quasi-potential, then the elementary work is of the form (18.1.23); if these generalized forces derive from a generalized quasi-potential, then we get ⎛ ∂U 0 ⎞ − U j ⎟ dq j . dW = dU 0 − U 0 dt − U j dq j = dU 0 − (U j q j + U 0 ) dt = ⎜ ∂ q ⎝ j ⎠
(18.2.23)
We notice that the gauge transformation mentioned above for the generalized potential does not affect this elementary work. The mechanical systems which admit a simple or generalized potential (quasipotential) are called natural systems. The generalized forces which do not derive from a simple quasi-potential can be always expressed in the form Qj =
∂U + Q j , U = U (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ) , ∂q j
(18.2.24)
the elementary work being given by dW = dU + ( Q j q j − U ) dt .
(18.2.24')
If U = U (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ) is a potential, hence if U = 0 , then the quantity P = Q j q j represents the power of the non-potential generalized forces. By analogy with the definitions given in E 3 and E 3 n , the non-potential generalized forces Q j of zero power ( P = 0 ) are called gyroscopic generalized forces and depend, obviously, on the
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
56
distribution of the generalized velocities; in this case, the generalized forces Q j are conservative. If the power of the non-potential generalized forces does not vanish, then these forces are non-conservative. If P < 0 , then the corresponding generalized forces are dissipative. The quasi-conservative forces (18.2.21') which derive from a generalized quasi-potential are of the form (18.2.24), so that (we take U = U 0 ) ∂U j ⎛ ∂U k − Qj = ⎜ ∂qk ⎝ ∂q j
⎞ ⎟ qk − U j , j = 1, 2,..., s . ⎠
(18.2.24'')
If U j = 0, j = 1,2,..., s then it results Q j q j = 0 , the non-potential generalized forces being thus gyroscopic. Hence, any generalized force which admits a generalized potential is the sum of a generalized force which admits a simple potential and a gyroscopic generalized force. Let be, in general, a non-potential generalized force of the form Q j = − αij qi , j = 1, 2,..., s .
(18.2.25)
By a decomposition in symmetric and skew-symmetric parts of the tensor quantity αij , we observe that the non-potential generalized forces Q j = − α( ij )qi , j = 1, 2,..., s ,
(18.2.25')
where the quadratic form R =
1 α q q , 2 ( ij ) i j
(18.2.26)
called the Rayleigh dissipative function, is positive, are dissipative; indeed, we have Q j q j = − α( ij )qi q j ≤ 0 .
We notice that Qj = −
∂R , j = 1, 2,..., s . ∂q j
(18.2.26')
Analogously, the non-potential generalized forces Q j = − α[ ij ]qi = α[ ji ]qi , j = 1, 2,..., s ,
(18.2.25'')
are gyroscopic, because Q j q j = α[ ji ]qi q j = 0 . We observe that the notion of power of the non-potential generalized forces has a signification larger than the classical one, coinciding with the latter one in case of a potential (U = 0 ).
Lagrangian Mechanics
57
18.2.2 Lagrange’s Equations of Second Kind The basic problem of motion of a discrete mechanical system S in the space E 3 is reduced to the problem of motion of the corresponding representative point P , subjected to the action of the generalized forces Q j , j = 1, 2,..., s , and to m non-holonomic constraints (18.2.9) (or (18.2.9')) in the space Λs (the representative point P is on a non-holonomic manifold with s − m dimensions, at the intersection of m non-holonomic hypersurfaces). In what follows, we deduce Lagrange’s equations of second kind in case of holonomic or non-holonomic constraints; a special attention will be given to the case of quasi-conservative forces, by introducing Lagrange’s kinetic potential.
18.2.2.1 Lagrange’s Equations in Case of Holonomic Constraints Let be a discrete mechanical system S subjected to holonomic ideal constraints; the motion of this mechanical system, hence the motion of the representative point P in the space Λs will be governed by the theorem of virtual work, written in the form n
∑ mi
i =1
d2 ri ⋅ δri = δW = dt 2
n
∑ Fi
i =1
⋅ δri ,
(18.2.27)
corresponding to the formulae (11.1.59), (11.1.63) and to the formula (18.1.52), respectively. We calculate n
∑ mi
i =1
=
n
d2 ri ⋅ δri = dt 2
⎡ d ⎛ dr
∑ mi ⎢⎣ dt ⎝⎜ dti
i =1
⋅
n
∑ mi
i =1
d2 ri ∂ri ⋅ δq j dt 2 ∂q j
∂ri ⎞ dri d ⎛ ∂ri ⎞ ⎤ − ⋅ δq . ∂q j ⎠⎟ dt dt ⎝⎜ ∂q j ⎠⎟ ⎦⎥ j
The formula (18.2.4') allows to write ∂vi ∂r = i , i = 1, 2,..., n , j = 1, 2,..., s . ∂q j ∂q j
(18.2.28)
Using the operator relation (18.2.13) too, it results n
∑ mi
i =1
=
1 ⎡d ∂ ( mi vi2 ⎢ 2 i∑ = 1 ⎣ dt ∂q j n
∂vi ⎞ ∂v ⎤ − vi ⋅ i ⎥ δq j ⎟ ∂q j ⎠ ∂q j ⎦ i =1 ∂ ⎤ ⎡ d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ ∂T ⎤ − ( mi vi2 ) ⎥ δq j = ⎢ dt ⎜ ∂q ⎟ − ∂q ⎥ δq j , ∂q j j ⎦ ⎦ ⎣ ⎝ j ⎠
d2 ri ⋅ δri = dt 2
)
n
⎡d⎛
∑ mi ⎢⎣ dt ⎝⎜ vi
⋅
where we have introduced the kinetic energy T . Taking into account also the formula (18.2.19), we can write the equation (18.2.27) in the form ⎡ d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ ∂T ⎤ ⎢ dt ⎜ ∂q ⎟ − ∂q − Q j ⎥ δq j = 0 . j ⎣ ⎝ j ⎠ ⎦
(18.2.27')
58
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
As a matter of fact, this represents the fourth form of the basic equation. Because the constraints are holonomic, it results that the virtual generalized displacements δq j are independent; hence, we may write d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ ∂T − = Q j , j = 1,2,..., s , dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j ⎟⎠ ∂q j
(18.2.29)
getting thus the equation of motion of the representative point P , that is Lagrange’s equations of second kind (shortly, Lagrange’s equations), obtained be Lagrange in 1760. This system of differential equations of second order (the kinetic energy depends on the generalized co-ordinates, the generalized velocities and time) allows to determine the unknown functions, q j = q j (t ), j = 1, 2,..., s , t ∈ [ t0 , t1 ] . The fundamental problem of mechanics remains, further, deterministic; starting from the initial conditions (11.1.9), written for a discrete mechanical system, and taking into account the relations (18.2.1) or (18.2.1') and (18.2.4'), we associate the initial conditions of Cauchy type
q j (t0 ) = q j0 , q j (t0 ) = q j0 .
(18.2.30)
These conditions are univocally determinate (as we have seen in Sects. 18.2.1.1 and 18.2.1.2, in the general case). If q j0 = 0, q j0 = 0, j = 1,2,..., s , then we say that we have to do with homogeneous initial conditions. Thus, the problem is entirely formulated; the functions q j (t ) must be of class C 2 .
18.2.2.2 Case of Non-holonomic Constraints. Natural Systems. Kinetic Potential. Conditions of Equilibrium Let us suppose that the discrete mechanical system S , hence also the representative point P in the space Λs , is subjected to m < s non-holonomic constraints, which are expressed in the form (18.2.10), by means of the generalized displacements. In this case the problem is reduced to the determination of the functions q j = q j (t ), j = 1,2,..., s , so that, besides Lagrange’s equations (18.2.29), the relations (18.2.27') be also satisfied, for any virtual generalized displacements δq j , which verify the constraint relations (18.2.10); applying the method of Lagrange’s multipliers, used several times till now, we can write m ⎡ d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ ∂T ⎤ λk akj ⎥ δq j = 0 . − − Q − j ∑ ⎜ ⎟ ⎢ dt ∂q ⎣ ⎝ j ⎠ ∂q j ⎦ k =1
(18.2.31)
Assuming that the non-holonomic constraints are distinct, the matrix [akj ] is of rank m ; we can denote the generalized co-ordinates so that det[akj ] ≠ 0, j , k = 1,2,..., m ,
which allows to determine univocally the multipliers λk , by annulling the first m
Lagrangian Mechanics
59
square brackets. From the constraint relations we obtain the virtual generalized displacements δql , l = 1, 2,..., m , as functions of the virtual generalized displacements δqm + 1 , δqm + 2 ,..., δqs , which can be considered to be independent; following the usual reasoning, it follows that all square brackets vanish, so that we obtain Lagrange’s equations in case of non-holonomic constraints (Lagrange’s equations with multipliers) in the form
d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ ∂T − = Q j + Rj , j = 1, 2,..., s , dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j ⎟⎠ ∂q j
(18.2.32)
where Rj =
m
∑ λk akj , j
k =1
= 1, 2,..., s ,
(18.2.33)
are the components of the constraint generalized force. To determine the s + m unknowns (the functions q j = q j (t ), j = 1,2,..., s , and the parameters λk , k = 1,2,..., m ) we have thus at our disposal s equations of Lagrange with multipliers and m constraint relations. If the mechanical system S has h holonomic constraints (18.2.3), which have not been eliminated, then the constraint forces are Rj =
m
h
k =1
l =1
∂f
∑ λk akj + ∑ μl ∂qlj
,
(18.2.33')
where μl , l = 1, 2,..., h , are also Lagrange’s multipliers which must be determined, taking into account supplementary constraint relations too. In case of a natural system, the generalized forces derive from a simple or generalized quasi-potential, being of the form (18.2.20) or of the form (18.2.21). Introducing Lagrange’s kinetic potential (the Lagrangian, quantity of the nature of the energy)
L = T +U ,
(18.2.34)
we can write the equations (18.2.32) in the form d ⎛ ∂L ⎞ ∂L − = Rj , j = 1, 2,..., s . dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j ⎟⎠ ∂q j
(18.2.35)
If we express the generalized forces in the form (18.2.24), the kinetic potential being, further, given by (18.2.34), then the considered Lagrange equations become
d ⎛ ∂L ⎞ ∂L − = Q j + Rj , j = 1, 2,..., s , dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j ⎟⎠ ∂q j
(18.2.36)
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
60
putting in evidence the non-potential generalized forces. If the constraints of the discrete mechanical system equations become
S are holonomic, then these
d ⎛ ∂L ⎞ ∂L − = Q j , j = 1,2,..., s , dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j ⎟⎠ ∂q j
(18.2.37)
while in case of a natural system it results
d ⎛ ∂L ⎞ ∂L − = 0, j = 1, 2,..., s . dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j ⎟⎠ ∂q j
(18.2.38)
Using the Euler–Lagrange operator, we can formally write [T ]j + Q j + Rj = 0, j = 1, 2,..., s ,
(18.2.32')
[T ]j + Q j = 0, j = 1, 2,..., s ,
(18.2.29')
[ L ]j + Rj = 0, j = 1, 2,..., s ,
(18.2.35')
[ L ]j + Q j + Rj = 0, j = 1,2,..., s ,
(18.2.36')
[ L ]j + Q j = 0, j = 1,2,..., s ,
(18.2.37')
[ L ]j = 0, j = 1, 2,..., s .
(18.2.38')
as well as
Thus, Lagrange’s equations take a simpler form, which is easier to handle in case of natural systems; moreover, one obtains – in this case – interesting results concerning the integration of the respective system of equations. We notice that
L = L2 + L1 + L0 ,
(18.2.34')
where we take into account (18.2.15), so that
L2 = T2 , L1 = T1 + U − U 0 , L0 = T0 + U 0 ,
(18.2.34'')
in case of a generalized quasi-potential; if the quasi-potential is a simple one, then U = U 0 . The mechanical systems which admit a kinetic potential are called mechanical systems of first kind. In general, we can consider a mechanical system the motion of which is specified by a Lagrangian L = L (q1 , q1 ,..., qs , q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ) , even in the case in which the system is non-natural, with the condition that the Hessian of this function with respect to the generalized velocities be non-zero
Lagrangian Mechanics
61 ⎡ ∂2 L ⎤ det ⎢ ⎥ ≠ 0. ⎣ ∂q j ∂qk ⎦
(18.2.34''')
As a matter of fact, if the system is natural, then we have ∂2 L ∂2T = = g jk , ∂q j ∂qk ∂q j ∂qk
so that the considered Hessian is given by det[ g jk ] = g ≠ 0 , as it has been shown in Sect. 18.2.1.3. To the state of rest of the discrete mechanical system S with respect to an inertial frame of reference corresponds a position of rest of the representative point P in the space Λs . From (18.2.32) it results that (we make q j = 0, qj = 0, j = 1,2,..., s ) Q j + Rj = 0, j = 1, 2,..., s .
(18.2.39)
Obviously, these relations must be verified also by the initial conditions, where q j0 = 0, j = 1, 2,..., s . More precisely, the conditions (18.2.39) should be written in the form Q j (q10 , q20 ,..., qs0 , 0, 0,..., 0; t ) + Rj (q10 , q20 ,..., qs0 , 0, 0,..., 0; t ) = 0, t ∈ [t0 , t1 ],
(18.2.39')
where we have put in evidence also the position of equilibrium (corresponding to the initial conditions). If the discrete mechanical system S is subjected only to holonomic constraints, then the conditions of equilibrium are written in the form Q j = 0, j = 1, 2,..., s .
(18.2.40)
If the generalized forces derive from a simple quasi-potential, we obtain ∂U = 0, j = 1, 2,..., s , ∂q j
(18.2.40')
hence a necessary condition for the quasi-potential U to admit an isolated extremum. Concerning the state of rest, one puts important problems of stability, which will be considered afterwards.
18.2.2.3 Normal Form of Lagrange’s Equations Taking into account the expression (18.2.15), (18.2.15'), (18.2.15''), and (18.2.15''') of the kinetic energy, we can find an explicit form of Lagrange’s equations (18.2.32). We calculate thus ∂T ∂q j = g jk qk + g j and then
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
62
∂g jk d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ ⎛ ∂g j ⎞ = g jk qk + q q + + g jk ⎟ qk + g j , ⎜ ⎟ ∂ql k l ⎜⎝ ∂qk dt ⎝ ∂q j ⎠ ⎠ ∂gk ∂q 0 ∂T 1 ∂gkl = q q + q + ; ∂q j 2 ∂q j k l ∂q j k ∂q j
noting that the product qk ql is symmetric in the indices k and l , it results ∂g jk ∂ql
qk ql =
∂g jl ⎞ 1 ⎛ ∂g jk q q , + ∂qk ⎟⎠ k l 2 ⎜⎝ ∂ql
so that we write the equations (18.2.32) in the form g jk qk + [ kl , j ]qk ql + (2 γ jk + g jk )qk −
∂g 0 + g j = Q j + Rj , j = 1, 2,..., s , ∂q j
(18.2.41)
where we have introduces Christoffel’s symbols of the first kind [ kl , j ] =
∂g jl ∂g 1 ⎛ ∂g jk + − kl ⎜ 2 ⎝ ∂ql ∂qk ∂q j
⎞ ⎟ , j , k , l = 1, 2,..., s , ⎠
(18.2.42)
⎞ ⎟ , j , k = 1, 2,..., s . ⎠
(18.2.43)
as well as the skew-symmetric quantities γ jk = − γkj =
∂g 1 ⎛ ∂g j − k ⎜ 2 ⎝ ∂qk ∂q j
We have thus obtained a system of linear equations in the generalized accelerations qk , k = 1, 2,..., s . Let g jk = g kj be the algebraic complement of the element g jk in the determinant g , which is definite by (18.2.17); the normalized algebraic complement will be g jk = g kj = g jk g . We notice that the relations det[ g jk ] =
1 , g g mj = δkm , g jk
(18.2.44)
where δkm is Kronecker’s symbol (equal to unity for k = m and equal to zero for k ≠ m ), take place. Multiplying the system of equations (18.2.41) by g mj and summing with respect to j , it results (we replace then the free index m by j ) ⎧⎪ j qj + ⎨ ⎩⎪ k
⎫⎪ ∗ ∗ ⎬ q q + α jk qk + β j = Q j + Rj , j = 1, 2,..., s , l ⎭⎪ k l
(18.2.45)
Lagrangian Mechanics
63
where we have introduced Christoffel’s symbols of second kind, defined by (the relations of definitions for Christoffel’s symbols correspond to the relations of definition (A.1.44) and (A.1.45) from E 3 ) ⎧⎪ j ⎨ ⎩⎪ k
⎫⎪ mj ⎬ = [ kl , m ]g , j , k , l = 1, 2,..., s , l ⎭⎪
(18.2.42')
as well as the notations (as everywhere in this work, we make not considerations on covariance or on contravariance, the position of the indices – up or down – having no one signification) ⎛ ∂g ⎞ αmk = (2 γ jk + g jk )g mj , βm = ⎜ − 0 + q j ⎟ g mj , ∂ q j ⎝ ⎠ mj mj ∗ ∗ Qm = Q j g , Rm = Rj g , m = 1, 2,..., s .
(18.2.46)
The system of equations (18.2.45) represents thus the normal form of Lagrange’s equations, in which the generalized accelerations are expressed as functions of the generalized velocities and of the generalized co-ordinates; this form of the equations can be always obtained, because g ≠ 0 . In the case of catastatic constraints we have T = T2 , and the equations (18.2.45) take the form ⎧⎪ j qj + ⎨ ⎩⎪ k
⎫⎪ ∗ ∗ ⎬ q q = Q j + Rj , j = 1, 2,..., s . l ⎭⎪ k l
(18.2.47)
If the constraints are holonomic, then the equations (18.2.45) become ⎧⎪ j qj + ⎨ ⎪⎩ k
⎫⎪ ∗ ⎬ q q + α jk qk + β j = Q j , j = 1, 2,..., s , l ⎪⎭ k l
(18.2.45')
while the equations (18.2.47) read (in this case, the constraints are scleronomic too) ⎧⎪ j qj + ⎨ ⎪⎩ k
⎫⎪ ∗ ⎬ q q = Q j , j = 1, 2,..., s . l ⎪⎭ k l
(18.2.47')
In case of a single particle, the equations (18.2.47') become (6.1.24''').
18.2.2.4 Theorems of Existence and Uniqueness We can replace the system of s differential equations of second order (18.2.45') by a system of 2s differential equations of first order in the normal form ⎪⎧ j q j = u j , u j = ϕ j , ϕ j = Q j∗ − ⎨ ⎪⎩ k
⎪⎫ ⎬ u u − α jk uk − β j , j = 1,2,..., s , l ⎪⎭ k l
(18.2.48)
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
64
where u j = u j (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ), ϕ j = ϕ j (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , u1 , u2 ,..., us ; t ) . This system is autonomous; if the time does not intervene explicitly in u j and ϕ j , then the system is autonomous (or dynamical). We associate to this system the initial conditions (18.2.30) in the form q j (t0 ) = q j0 , u j (t0 ) = q j0 , j = 1, 2,..., s ,
(18.2.48')
the problem at the limit (18.2.48), (18.2.48') being thus a problem of Cauchy type. The problem (18.2.45'), (18.2.30) is equivalent to the problem (18.2.48), (18.2.48'); for the latter one we can state Theorem 18.2.1 (of existence and uniqueness; Cauchy–Lipschitz). If the functions u j and ϕ j , j = 1,2,..., s , are continuous on the interval (2s + 1) -dimensional D , specified
q j0 − Q j0 ≤ q j ≤ q j0 + Q j0 , q j0 − U j0 ≤ u j ≤ q j0 + U j0 ,
by
t0 − T0 ≤ t ≤ t0 + T0 , Q j0 , U j0 , T0 = const, j = 1, 2,..., s , and definite on the space
Cartesian product of the phase space (of canonical co-ordinates q1 , q2 ,..., qs , u1 , u2 ,..., us ) by the time space (of co-ordinate t ) and if Lipschitz’s conditions u j (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ) − u j (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ) ≤
1 λ q − qk , μj T k k
ϕ j (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , u1 , u2 ,..., us ; t ) − ϕ j (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , u1 , u2 ,..., us ; t ) ≤
1 1 λ ⎡ q − qk + uk − uk ⎤ ν j T k ⎢⎣ τ k ⎦⎥
are satisfied for j = 1,2,..., s , where T > 0 is a time constant independent on q j , u j and t , τ is a time constant equal to unity, while λk , μj , ν j are constants equal to unity (dimensionless if the corresponding generalized co-ordinate is a length and having the dimension of a length if the corresponding generalized co-ordinate is nondimensional), then there exists a unique solution q j = q j (t ), u j = u j (t ) of the system (18.2.48), which satisfies the initial conditions (18.2.48') and is definite on the interval t0 − T ≤ t ≤ t0 + T , where Q j0 U j0 ⎡ ( ! ) , τμj ( ! ), T T ≤ min ⎢T0 , λj V V ⎣
⎤ ⎥ , V = max μj u j ( ! ) , τν j ϕ j ( ! ) in D , ⎦
(
)
the sign (!) indicating “without summation”. The continuity of the functions u j and ϕ j on the interval D ensures the existence of the solution, according to Peano’s theorem. The condition of Lipschitz must be fulfilled too for the uniqueness of the solution; these latter conditions may be replaced by other ones less restrictive, in accordance with which the partial derivatives of the first order of the functions u j and ϕ j , j = 1,2,..., s , must exist and be bounded in absolute value
Lagrangian Mechanics
65
on the interval D . Besides, the conditions in the Theorem 18.2.1 are sufficient conditions of existence and uniqueness, which are not necessary too. The existence and the uniqueness of the solution have been put in evidence only on the interval [t0 − T , t0 + T ] , in the neighbourhood of the initial moment t0 (as a matter of fact, the moment t0 must not be the initial moment, but can be a moment arbitrarily chosen); taking, e.g., the moment t0 + T as initial moment, it is possible – repeating the above reasoning – to extend the solution on a interval of length 2T1 if, naturally, the sufficient conditions of existence and uniqueness of the theorem are verified in the neighbourhood of the new initial moment. Thus, we can prolong the solution for t ∈ [t1 , t2 ] , corresponding to a certain interval of time in which the considered mechanical phenomenon takes place, or even for t ∈ [t1 , ∞ ) or t ∈ ( −∞, t1 ] or t ∈ ( −∞, ∞ ) . We can state also theorems on the continuous or analytical dependence of the solution on a parameter, analogous to the Theorems 6.1.3 and 6.1.4; as well, we can state Theorem 18.2.2 (on the differentiability of the solutions). If, in the neighbourhood of a point P (q1 ,q2 ,..., qs , u1 , u2 ,..., us ; t ) ∈ D , the functions u j (q1 ,q2 ,..., qs ; t ) and ϕ j (q1 ,q2 ,..., qs , u1 , u2 ,..., us ; t ), j = 1,2,..., s , are of the class C k , then the solutions
q j (t ) and u j (t ) of the system (18.2.48), which satisfy the initial conditions (18.2.48'), are of class C k + 1 in a neighbourhood of the point P . In particular, if q j0 = 0 and Q j (t0 ) = 0 , which leads also to ϕ j (t0 ) = 0 ,
j = 1,2,..., s , the constraints being scleronomic, then we obtain q j (t ) = q j0 , j = 1,2,..., s , the solution being unique, according to the Theorem 18.2.1; hence, the representative point is at rest with respect to a given fixed frame of reference.
18.2.3 Transformations. First Integrals In the study of Lagrange’s equations an important rôle is played by the transformations of co-ordinates and by the gauge transformations which will be considered in what follows. As well, to integrate this system of equations, the problem is put to find first integrals; in this order of ideas, we will put in evidence – especially – the first integral of energy.
18.2.3.1 Point Transformations We call point transformation a transformation of generalized co-ordinates of the form q j = q j (q1 ,q2 ,..., qs ; t ), j = 1, 2,..., s ,
(18.2.49)
where q j are functions of class C 2 with respect to the new generalized co-ordinates; we assume that
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
66
⎡ ∂q j ⎤ det ⎢ ⎥ ≠ 0, ⎣ ∂qk ⎦
(18.2.49')
the correspondence between the two systems of co-ordinates being one-to-one. In this section, we will denote dq j dt = q j and will have q j =
∂q j ∂q j qk + , j = 1, 2,..., s , ∂qk ∂t
(18.2.49'')
hence, q j = q j (q1 ,q2 ,..., qs , q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ) , so that ∂q j ∂q j = , j , k = 1,2,..., s . ∂qk ∂qk
(18.2.50)
One the other hand
∂q j ∂ 2q j ∂ 2q j ∂ ⎛ ∂q j ⎞ ∂ ⎛ ∂q j ⎞ d ⎛ ∂q j ⎞ , = = = ql + q + ∂qk ∂qk ∂ql ∂qk ∂t ∂ql ⎜⎝ ∂qk ⎟⎠ l ∂t ⎜⎝ ∂qk ⎟⎠ dt ⎜⎝ ∂qk ⎟⎠ wherefrom it result the relation between operators
( ) = ddt ⎛⎜⎝ ∂∂q
∂ d ∂qk dt
k
⎞ ⎟ , k = 1, 2,..., l . ⎠
(18.2.51)
By the transformation (18.2.49), (18.2.49'), and (18.2.49'') we obtain T (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ) = T (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ) , where T is a new function which represents the kinetic energy in the generalized co-ordinates. We can write ∂T ∂T ∂q j ∂T ∂q j ∂T ∂q j ∂T d ⎛ ∂q j = + = + ∂qk ∂q j ∂qk ∂q j ∂qk ∂q j ∂qk ∂q j dt ⎜⎝ ∂qk ∂T ∂T ∂q j ∂T ∂q j d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ ∂T d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ ∂q j = = = + , ∂q j ∂qk ∂q j ∂qk dt ⎜⎝ ∂qk ⎟⎠ dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j ⎟⎠ ∂qk ∂q j ∂qk
⎞ ⎟, ⎠
d ⎛ ∂q j ⎞ , dt ⎜⎝ ∂qk ⎟⎠
where we took into account (18.2.50), (18.2.51); analogously, the generalized forces read Qk =
n
∑ Fi
i =1
⋅
∂ri = ∂qk
n
∑ Fi
i =1
⋅
∂ri ∂q j , ∂q j ∂qk
wherefrom Qk = Q j
∂q j , k = 1, 2,..., s , ∂qk
(18.2.52)
Lagrangian Mechanics
67
Thus, it results
d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ ∂T ⎡ d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ ∂T ⎤ ∂q j − − Qk = ⎢ ⎜ − − Qj ⎥ . ⎜ ⎟ ⎟ dt ⎝ ∂qk ⎠ ∂qk ⎣ dt ⎝ ∂q j ⎠ ∂q j ⎦ ∂qk
(18.2.53)
Hence, if the equations (18.2.29) take place, then we will have d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ ∂T − = Qk , k = 1, 2,..., s , dt ⎜⎝ ∂qk ⎟⎠ ∂qk
(18.2.54)
too. On the other hand, taking into account the condition (18.2.49'), the relations (18.2.54) entail the equations (18.2.29). We can thus state Theorem 18.2.3 Lagrange’s equations are invariant to a point transformation of the form (18.2.49), (18.2.49') in case of a holonomic discrete mechanical system.
18.2.3.2 Gauge Transformations We have seen in Sect. 18.2.2.2 that the motion of a natural mechanical system is governed be Lagrange’s equations (18.2.38), for which it is necessary to determine Lagrange’s kinetic potential L . We notice that the Lagrangian K L , K = const , leads to the same equations. One puts the problem to find a kinetic potential L ′ = L + L , if this one exists, to obtain the same equations (18.2.38); in this case, one must have
d ⎛ ∂L ⎞ ∂L − ≡ 0, dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j ⎟⎠ ∂q j
(18.2.55)
for any q j = q j (t ), j = 1, 2,..., s . For this, it is necessary that
L = a j q j + a 0 , a j = a j (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ), j = 1, 2,.., s , a 0 = a 0 (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ), otherwise the coefficients of the generalized accelerations qj cannot vanish, Replacing in (18.2.25), it results (the point corresponds to a partial derivative with respect to time) ∂ak ⎛ ∂a j ⎜ ∂q − ∂q j ⎝ k
∂a 0 ⎞ ⎟ qk + a j − ∂q ≡ 0, j = 1,2,..., s , j ⎠
so that we obtain the conditions ∂a j ∂a ∂a − k = 0, a j − 0 = 0, j , k = 1,2,..., s . ∂qk ∂q j ∂q j
Hence, it exists a function ϕ = ϕ (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ) , so that
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
68 aj =
∂ϕ , j = 1, 2,..., s , a 0 = ϕ . ∂q j
We find thus
L =
∂ϕ dϕ . q + ϕ = ∂q j j dt
(18.2.56)
We can state Theorem 18.2.4 In case of a discrete mechanical system which admits a kinetic potential L , this one is determined excepting the total derivative with respect to time of an arbitrary function of class C 2 , of generalized co-ordinates and time. In particular, the Lagrangian can be of the form (18.2.34). This gauge transformation corresponds to the analogous transformation put in evidence in Sect. 18.2.1.3 for a generalized quasi-potential.
18.2.3.3 First Integrals of Lagrange’s Equations A function f (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ) which is reduced to a constant along the integral curves of Lagrange’s system of equations (18.2.29) is a first interval of this system. If we determine l ≤ 2s first integrals fk (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ) = ck , ck = const, k = 1, 2,..., l ,
(18.2.57)
the matrix ∂ ( f1 , f2 ,..., fl ) ⎡ ⎤ M = ⎢ ⎥⎦ ( q , q ,..., q , q , q ,..., q ) ∂ s s ⎣ 1 2 1 2
being of rank l , then all these integrals are functionally independent (independent first integrals) and we can express l unknown functions of the system (18.2.29) by means of the other ones; replacing in this system of equations, the problem is reduced to the integration of a system of equations with 2s − l unknowns (hence, a smaller number of unknowns). If l = 2s , then all the first integrals are independent, so that the system (18.2.57) of first integrals determines all the unknown functions. We notice that the first integrals (18.2.57) are no more independent for l > 2s ; hence we can set up at the most 2s independent first integrals. Solving the system (18.2.57) for l = 2s , we obtain (the matrix M is a square matrix of order 2s , for which det M ≠ 0 ) q j = q j (t ; c1 , c2 ,..., c2 s ), q j = q j (t ; c1 , c2 ,..., c2 s ), j = 1, 2,..., s ,
(18.2.58)
hence the general integral of the system of equations (18.2.29). Thus, one puts in evidence 2s scalar constants of integration. Imposing the initial conditions (18.2.30), we get
Lagrangian Mechanics
69
q j (t0 ; c1 , c2 ,..., c2 s ) = q j0 , q j (t0 ; c1 , c2 ,..., c2 s ) = q j0 , j = 1, 2,..., s ;
the conditions (18.2.30) being independent, we can write ⎡ ∂ (q10 , q20 ,..., qs0 , q10 , q20 ,..., qs0 ) ⎤ det ⎢ ⎥ ≠ 0 ∂ (c1 , c2 ,..., c2 s ) ⎣ ⎦
and – on the basis of the theorem of implicit functions – we deduce
ck = ck (t0 ; q10 , q20 ,..., qs0 , q10 , q20 ,..., qs0 ), k = 1, 2,..., 2s . Thus, it results, finally, q j = q j (t ; t0 , q10 , q20 ,..., qs0 , q10 , q20 ,..., qs0 ) ,
q j = q j (t ; t0 , q10 , q20 ,..., qs0 , q10 , q20 ,..., qs0 ) .
(18.2.59)
Hence, in the frame of the conditions of the theorem of existence and uniqueness, the principle of virtual work and the principle of initial conditions determine, univocally, the motion of the discrete mechanical system S , subjected to ideal and holonomic constraints, in a finite interval of time; by prolongation, the statement can become valid for any t . Thus, the deterministic aspect of mechanics is put in evidence in its Lagrangian presentation too. If f1 = c1 and f2 = c2 are two distinct first integrals, then f ( f1 , f2 ) = c will be also a first integral. Any other first integral is expressed, in general, as a function of the 2s distinct first integrals of Lagrange’s equations. From (18.2.57) it results dfk dt = 0 ; hence dfk df q j + k qj + f = 0, k = 1,2,.., l , dq j dq j
(18.2.57')
relations which must be identically satisfied if one takes into account the equations of motion (or the general integral of these equations, for any constants of integration).
18.2.3.4 First Integrals of Painlevé and Jacobi. First Integral of Mechanical Energy We can find a first integral particularly important and useful of the system of equations (18.2.29), multiplying these equations by the generalized velocities q j , j = 1, 2,..., s , and summing for all indices j ; we obtain
d ⎛ ∂T dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j We notice that
∂T ⎞ ⎟ q j − ∂q q j = Q j q j . j ⎠
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
70
d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ ∂T q = q − q . dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j ⎟⎠ j dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j j ⎟⎠ ∂q j j
Because T = T (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ) , we have, as well, ∂T ∂T dT = q j + q + T , dt ∂q j ∂q j j
so that
d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ q − T ⎟ = Q j q j − T . dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j j ⎠
(18.2.60)
Taking into account (18.2.15) and noting that ∂T2 ∂T q = 2T2 , 1 q j = T1 , ∂q j j ∂q j
according to Euler’s theorem concerning the homogeneous functions, we can also write d ( T − T0 ) = Q j q j − T . dt 2
(18.2.60')
If it exists a function W = W (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ) , so that Q j q j − T = dW dt (the function W cannot depend on the generalized velocities too, because dW dt would introduce also generalized accelerations), then we state Painlevé’s first integral T2 − T0 − W = h , h = const .
(18.2.61)
We notice that one must have −T0 = W , because they are terms which do not depend on the generalized velocities q j ; as well, if the given forces Fi , i = 1, 2,..., n , do not depend on the velocities, hence if the generalized forces Q j , j = 1, 2,..., s , do not depend on the generalized velocities, then cannot appear quadratic terms in the generalized velocities, resulting T2 = 0 . In these conditions, we state that Painlevé’s first integral does not contain explicitly the time. If the generalized forces admit a simple quasi-potential of the form (18.2.20), then we can introduce the kinetic potential (18.2.34), so that the relation (18.2.60) reads d ⎛ ∂L ⎞ q − L ⎟ + L = 0 ; dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j j ⎠
(18.2.62)
assuming that the kinetic potential L does not depend explicitly on time (L = 0) , we get Jacobi’s first integral (Jacobi,C.G.J., 1882)
Lagrangian Mechanics
71 ∂L q − L = h , h = const , ∂q j j
(18.2.63)
which can be expressed also in the form (hence, a particular case of Painlevé’s first integral) T2 − T0 − U = h , h = const .
(18.2.63')
In particular, if the mechanical system is catastatic, hence scleronomic (being holonomic), then we have T = 0 , so that L = 0 if U = 0 , hence if the forces are conservative, deriving from a simple potential; we obtain the first integral of mechanical energy E = T − U = h , T = T2 , h = const .
(18.2.64)
The relation (18.2.62) with L = 0 can be written in the form
⎡ d ⎛ ∂L ⎞ ∂L ⎤ ⎢ dt ⎜ ∂q ⎟ − ∂q ⎥ q j = 0 j ⎦ ⎣ ⎝ j ⎠
(18.2.62')
too. Starting from this result, some authors try to obtain Lagrange’s equations, which is not possible because the generalized velocities q j cannot by arbitrarily chosen (they correspond to the motion in the actual state). If the generalized forces admit a generalized quasi-potential of the form (18.2.21), with (18.2.22), then we can express them by the relations (18.2.3); we obtain ∂U j ⎞ ∂U 0 ⎛ ∂U k − Q j q j = ⎜ ⎟ q j qk − U j q j + ∂q q j ∂ ∂ q q j j k ⎝ ⎠ ∂U 0 dU 0 dU 0 = − U 0 − U j q j = − U . q − U j q j = ∂q j j dt dt
The relation (18.2.60') becomes d (T − T0 − U 0 ) + L = 0 . dt 2
(18.2.65)
Supposing that the kinetic potential L = T + U does not depend explicitly on time (L = 0) , it results a first integral of Jacobi type (particular case of the first integral of Painlevé) T2 − T0 − U 0 = h , h = const .
(18.2.66)
As well, in case of scleronomic constraints we have T0 = 0 (and T0 = 0 too), being thus sufficient that U 0 = 0 , hence that the forces be conservative, deriving from a generalized potential, to have a first integral of mechanical energy in the form
72
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
E = T − U 0 = h , T = T2 , h = const .
(18.2.67)
The mechanical systems which admit a first integral of Jacobi or a first integral of Jacobi type are called generalized conservative systems; we have seen that these systems are natural systems for which the kinetic potential L does not depend explicitly on time (L = 0) . The quasi-potential U or the scalar potential U 0 are quantities of energetical nature; hence, the potential energy is V = −U , in case of a simple quasi-potential, or V = −U 0 , in case of a generalized quasi-potential. We introduce thus the generalized mechanical energy
E = T2 − T0 + V ,
(18.2.68)
which is constant in case of Jacobi’s first integral or of a first integral of Jacobi type. In particular, if the forces are conservative (we have V = 0 ) and the constraints are scleronomic (we have T0 = 0 and T = T2 ), then the generalized mechanical energy is equal to the mechanical energy, obtaining thus the first integral of mechanical energy. In case of generalized forces of the form (18.2.24), the relation (18.2.60) reads d ⎛ ∂L ⎞ q j − L ⎟ + L = Q j q j . ⎜ dt ⎝ ∂q j ⎠
(18.2.69)
If the kinetic potential does not depend explicitly on time ( L = 0 ), then it results
dE d ⎛ ∂L ⎞ = q − L ⎟ = Q j q j . dt dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j j ⎠
(18.2.69')
We can thus state that the mechanical system S admits a Jacobi’s first integral (written in the form (18.2.63) or in the form (18.2.63')) for generalized non-potential forces too. The relation (18.2.69') allows also to notice that, in case of dissipative nonpotential forces, the energy of the mechanical system diminishes. We observe that in none of the above considered first integrals does not intervene the component T1 of the kinetic energy; this is explained because the kinetic energy is determined excepting the total derivative with respect to time of a function ϕ (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ) of class C 2 , hence excepting dϕ dt = ( ∂ϕ ∂q j )q j + ϕ . In case of non-holonomic constraints, Lagrange’s equations have the form (18.2.32), so that the relation (18.2.60) becomes d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ q − T ⎟ = ( Q j + R ) q j − T . dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j j ⎠
Taking into account (18.2.29') and (18.2.33), we can also write
Lagrangian Mechanics
73
m d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ q j − T ⎟ = Q j q j − T − ∑ λk ak 0 . ⎜ dt ⎝ ∂q j ⎠ k =1
(18.2.70)
If the constraints are catastatic (we have ak 0 = 0, k = 1, 2,..., m ), then the relation (18.2.60) becomes (we have T = 0 too)
d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ q − T ⎟ = Q j q j , dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j j ⎠
(18.2.71)
so that the influence of these constraints is not seen; written in the form (18.2.60'), this relation becomes (we have also T0 = T1 = 0 ) dT2 = Q j q j . dt
Expressing the generalized ( E = T2 + V , V = −U )
forces
in
(18.2.71') the
form
dE = Q j q j − U , dt
(18.2.25),
we
can
write
(18.2.72)
so that, in the case in which the potential part does not depend explicitly on time (U = 0 ), while the non-potential forces are gyroscopic, we get a first integral. Hence, in general, a natural and catastatic, non-holonomic mechanical system, for which the generalized forces derive from a simple or generalized potential, has a first integral of energy of the form E = T + V = h , h = const .
(18.2.73)
Such a mechanical system is called a conservative system. If these generalized forces have only the non-potential part (U = 0 ), which is gyroscopic, even the kinetic energy T is conserved during the motion. We notice that this first integral of energy differs from that obtained for a discrete mechanical system S in E 3 because the holonomic constraint forces do not intervene any more. As a matter of fact, in case of catastatic constraints no essential difference appear, the real elementary work of the corresponding constraints forces vanishing. We notice also that, if we take into account (18.2.25'), (18.2.26) in case of a potential (U = 0 ), then the relation (18.2.72) leads to dE = −2 R , dt
(18.2.74)
where R is Rayleigh’s dissipative function, which characterizes the decrease of the mechanical energy E .
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
74
18.2.3.5 Reduction of Lagrange’s System of Equations by Means of Jacobi’s First Integral One can state Theorem 18.2.5. Jacobi’s first integral allows the reduction of Lagrange’s system of equations (18.2.38), corresponding to a holonomic and natural mechanical system with s degrees of freedom, to a system of equations corresponding to a mechanical system with s − 1 degrees of freedom (Jacobi,C.G.J., 1882). In particular, in case of a mechanical system with a single degree of freedom (a mechanical system with complete constraints), the first integral ∂L q − L = h , h = const , ∂q
(18.2.75)
reduces the problem to a quadrature; indeed, from (18.2.75) we can get q = f (q ) , wherefrom
t − t0 =
q
∫q
0
dq . f (q )
(18.2.75')
In case of a mechanical system with s degrees of freedom, we make the change of generalized velocities q1 → q1 , q2 → q1q2′ ,..., qs → q1qs′ , with qk′ = dqk dq1 = qk q1 ,
k = 1,2,..., s , so that L (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , q1 , q2 ,..., qs ) = Λ(q1 , q2 ,..., qs , q1 , q2′ ,..., qs′ ) . Differentiating, we can write too ∂L ∂Λ ∂L ∂Λ ∂qk′ 1 ∂Λ = = = , j = 1, 2,..., s , ( ! ) , k = 2, 3,..., s , ∂q j ∂q j ∂qk ∂qk′ ∂qk q1 ∂qk′ ∂Λ ∂L = + ∂q1 ∂q1
∂L ∂qk ∂L = + ∂ ∂q1 q 1 k =2 s
∑ ∂qk
s
∂L
∑ ∂qk
k =2
qk′ =
∂L + ∂q1
∂L qk . q1 k =2 s
∑ ∂qk
By the above mentioned change of variables in the first integral (18.2.63) and by taking into account the preceding results, we can write
q1
∂Λ −Λ = h, ∂q1
(18.2.76)
wherefrom q1 = q1 (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , q2′ , q 3′ ,..., qs′ ) . We denote L ′ = ∂Λ ∂q1 , so that
L ′ = L ′(q1 , q2 ,..., qs , q2′ , q 3′ ,..., qs′ ) . Using the notations thus introduced and taking into account the form (18.2.15) of the kinetic energy, we can write T (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , q1 , q2 ,..., qs ) = T (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , q1 , q2′ ,..., qs′ ) ,
Lagrangian Mechanics
75
so that T = q12T , where T = T (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , q2′ , q 3′ ,..., qs′ ) ; on the other hand, assuming the existence of a simple quasi-potential, we have T = U + h , h = const , while L ′ = ∂T ∂q1 = 2q1T , whence L ′ = 2 T (U + h ) . We can calculate ∂L ′ ∂2 Λ ∂ 2 Λ ∂q = + 2 1 , j = 1, 2,..., s , ∂q j ∂q j ∂q1 ∂q1 ∂q j ∂L ′ ∂2 Λ ∂2 Λ ∂q = + 2 1 , k = 2, 3,..., s ; ∂qk′ ∂qk′ ∂q1 ∂q1 ∂qk′
as well, by a partial differentiation of the relation (18.2.76) with respect to the generalized co-ordinates and the new generalized velocities, we obtain q1
∂ 2 Λ ∂q1 ∂2 Λ ∂Λ + q1 = , j = 1, 2,..., s , 2 ∂q ∂ ∂ ∂ q q qj ∂q1 j j 1
q1
∂2 Λ ∂q1 ∂2 Λ ∂Λ + q1 = , k = 2, 3,..., s . 2 ∂q ′ ∂qk′ ∂q1 ∂qk′ ∂q1 k
Comparing with the previous results, we may write ∂L ′ 1 ∂Λ ∂L ′ 1 ∂Λ = , j = 1, 2,..., s , = , k = 2, 3,..., s , ∂q j ∂qk′ q1 ∂q j q1 ∂qk′
wherefrom, using the above obtained relations, we get ∂L ′ 1 ∂L ∂L ′ ∂L = , j = 1, 2,..., s , = , k = 2, 3,..., s . ∂q j ∂qk′ ∂qk q1 ∂q j
Lagrange’s equations (18.2.38) lead to d ⎛ ∂L ′ ⎞ ∂L ′ − q1 = 0, k = 2, 3,..., s , ⎜ ⎟ ′ dt ⎝ ∂qk ⎠ ∂qk
or to d ⎛ ∂L ′ ⎞ ∂L ′ − = 0, k = 2, 3,..., s , dq1 ⎜⎝ ∂qk′ ⎟⎠ ∂qk
(18.2.77)
so that the functions qk (q1 ), k = 2, 3,..., s are determined by a system of s − 1 equations of second order of Lagrange type (the equations of Jacobi, who has put in evidence this method of calculation) in a (s − 1) -dimensional space. Thus, the number of degrees of freedom of the initial mechanical system has been reduced by a unity.
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
76
From the expression of the function L ′ of Lagrangian type, one observes that – in general – the new independent variable q1 intervenes explicitly, so that it is no more possible to obtain a first integral of the type of Jacobi’s first integral. By means of the notations thus introduced, we notice that q1 = t − t0 =
q1
∫q
0 1
T dq1 , U +h
(U + h ) T , so that
(18.2.77')
completing thus the information given by the equations (18.2.77) about the dependence with respect to time.
18.2.3.6 Hidden Co-ordinates. Ignorable Co-ordinates We call, after Helmholtz, hidden co-ordinate qk that co-ordinate which does not intervene explicitly in the expression of the kinetic energy T , hence for which ∂T ∂qk = 0 ; because we can have h ≤ s hidden co-ordinates, it is convenient to denote them q1 , q2 ,..., qh . If the co-ordinate qk does not intervene explicitly in the expression of the kinetic potential L = T + U , corresponding to a natural system which admits a simple or generalized quasi-potential, hence if ∂L ∂qk = 0 , then this co-ordinate is called an ignorable co-ordinate (after W. Thomson) or a kinostenic coordinate (after J. J. Thomson); this denomination is used also in the case of a nonnatural mechanical system which admits a Lagrangian, with the condition (18.2.34'''). We can have r ≤ s ignorable co-ordinates q1 , q2 ,..., qr . Sometimes only the denomination of hidden co-ordinates is used; but we will use both the denominations of hidden and ignorable co-ordinates, to can make distinction in various situations. The mechanical systems in which appear ignorable co-ordinates are called – by some authors – gyroscopic systems (because such situations appear often in case of the gyroscope). If ∂U ∂qk = 0 , where U is a simple or generalized quasi-potential, then an eventually corresponding ignorable co-ordinate is also a hidden one. We notice that we can have ∂ (T + U ) ∂qk = 0 , without having necessarily ∂T ∂qk = 0 (Pars, L., 1965). In the case of h hidden co-ordinates q1 , q2 ,..., qh , the first h equations of Lagrange for holonomic constraints (18.2.29) read d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ = Qk , k = 1, 2,..., h . dt ⎜⎝ ∂qk ⎟⎠
(18.2.78)
If we have Qk = 0 too, then there result h first integrals ∂T = ck , k = 1, 2,..., h , ∂qk
(18.2.78')
Lagrangian Mechanics
77
each first integral corresponding to a hidden co-ordinate. Assuming the existence of r ignorable co-ordinates q1 , q2 ,..., qr , Lagrange’s equations (18.2.38) take the form d ⎛ ∂L ⎞ = 0, k = 1, 2,..., r , dt ⎜⎝ ∂qk ⎟⎠
(18.2.79)
wherefrom the first integrals ∂L = C k , k = 1, 2,..., r . ∂qk
(18.2.79')
By convention, we denote pj =
∂L , j = 1, 2,..., s . ∂q j
(18.2.80)
In the case of a simple quasi-potential (or in the absence of a quasi-potential), it results pj =
∂T , j = 1, 2,..., s . ∂q j
(18.2.80')
If, in particular, the mechanical system is free or none holonomic constraint has been eliminated, the space of Lagrange being just the space E 3n , then – starting from the kinetic energy corresponding to the n particles – we can write ∂T ∂ ⎛1 n ⎞ = mi vi2 ⎟ = m j v j . ∂v j ∂v j ⎜⎝ 2 i∑ ⎠ =1
We notice that this represents just the magnitude of the momentum of the particle corresponding to the velocity v j . Starting from this observation, we will call the magnitudes p j , j = 1, 2,..., s , components of the generalized momentum; the first integrals (18.2.78') will be written in the form pk = ck , k = 1, 2,..., h ,
(18.2.78'')
while the first integrals (18.2.79') read pk = C k , k = 1, 2,..., r .
(18.2.79'')
If U is a generalized quasi-potential of the form (18.2.22), then it results ∂T = p j − U j , j = 1, 2,..., s , ∂q j
(18.2.81)
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
78
and in case of hidden co-ordinates we obtain d ( p − U k ) = Qk . dt k
If we have Qk = 0 too, then we can write the first integrals pk − U k = ck , k = 1, 2,..., h .
(18.2.81')
We notice also that the notion of generalized momentum has a larger sense than the classical one, corresponding to the case in which the generalized co-ordinate is a length. Let us consider, e.g., a particle for which the kinetic energy is expressed in cylindrical coordinates ( T = (m 2)(r 2 + r 2 θ2 + z 2 ) ); in this case, pθ = ∂L ∂θ = ∂T ∂θ = mr 2 θ = m ( r × r )z . Hence, to a generalized co-ordinate which is an angle corresponds a
generalized momentum which is a component of a moment of momentum. If the relation (18.2.80') takes place, then the relation (18.2.78) reads pk =
dpk = Qk , k = 1, 2,..., h . dt
(18.2.82)
Hence, in case of a hidden co-ordinate and in the absence of a quasi-potential, we can write an universal theorem of mechanics. If the generalized co-ordinate is a length, then the generalized force is of the nature of a force (so that the product Qk δqk be a work), obtaining thus a theorem of momentum corresponding to the respective linear coordinate; but if the generalized co-ordinate is an angle, then the generalized force – from the same reasons – is of the nature of a moment, resulting a theorem of moment of momentum corresponding to the respective angular co-ordinate. As a matter of fact, we can state Theorem 18.2.6 (theorem of generalized momentum). In case of several hidden coordinates and in the absence of a quasi-potential, in the free motion of the representative point in the space of configurations, a theorem of generalized momentum of the form (18.2.82) is verified. In the case in which Qk = 0, k = 1, 2,..., h , we can write a conservation theorem of generalized momentum, which is – in fact – a first integral of the form (18.2.78''). As well, in case of generalized forces of the form (18.2.24) and of several ignorable co-ordinates, Lagrange’s equations lead to the relations pk =
dpk = Qk , k = 1, 2,..., r , dt
(18.2.82')
where Qk are non-potential generalized forces; hence, we can state
Theorem 18.2.6' (theorem of generalized momentum; second form). In case of several ignorable co-ordinates, in the free motion of the representative point in the space of configurations, a theorem of generalized momentum of the form (18.2.82') is verified.
Lagrangian Mechanics
79
If Qk = 0, k = 1, 2,..., r , then we get a conservation theorem of generalized momentum, hence a first integral of the form (18.2.79'').
18.2.3.7 The Routh–Helmholtz Theorem We can state Theorem 18.2.7 (Routh–Helmholtz). If a discrete mechanical system S , with s degrees of freedom, has r ignorable co-ordinates, then the determination of the free motion of the representative point in the space of configurations is reduced to the integration of a system of differential equations of Lagrange type, corresponding to a mechanical system with s − r degrees of freedom and to the calculation of r quadratures. Indeed, let us perform the transformation of Routh, E.J. 1892, 1898]
R =
r
∂L
∑ ∂qk
qk − L .
k =1
(18.2.83)
The first integrals (18.2.79'), where L is of the form (18.2.34'), can be seen as a system of r linear equations in the generalized velocities qk , k = 1, 2,..., r ; the condition (18.2.34''') being fulfilled, we determine the functions qk = qk (qr + 1 , qr + 2 ,..., qs , qr + 1 , qr + 2 ,..., qs ;C 1 ,C 2 ,...,C r ; t ), k = 1, 2,..., r ,
where the generalized co-ordinates qr + 1 , qr + 2 ,..., qs are called palpable co-ordinates (unlike the ignorable co-ordinates). Replacing in (18.2.83), we get
R = R (qr +1 , qr + 2 ,..., qs , qr +1 , qr + 2 ,..., qs ;C 1 ,C 2 ,...,C r ; t ) . In this case, applying a variation δ to the function R of Routh, we obtain δR =
∂R δq j + j = r + 1 ∂q j s
∑
∂R δq j + j = r + 1 ∂q j s
∑
∂R
r
∑ ∂C k
k =1
δC k .
Noting that δL =
∂L δq j + j = r + 1 ∂q j s
∑
∂L qk = k = 1 ∂qk r
δ∑
r
∂L
∑ ∂qk
k =1
s
∂L
∑ ∂q j j =1
δqk +
δq j ,
r
∑ qk δC k
k =1
and taking into account the relation of definition (18.2.83), we get, as well, δR = −
∂L δq j − j = r + 1 ∂q j s
∑
∂L δq j + j = r + 1 ∂q j s
∑
r
∑ qk δC k .
k =1
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
80
The variation δ being arbitrary, by comparison of the two relations, it results −
∂L ∂R ∂L ∂R = = ,− , j = r + 1, r + 2,..., s , ∂q j ∂q j ∂q j ∂q j qk =
∂R , k = 1, 2,..., r , ∂C k
so that, replacing in Lagrange’s equations (18.2.38), we get the equations
d ⎛ ∂R ⎞ ∂R − = 0, j = r + 1, r + 2,..., s , dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j ⎟⎠ ∂q j
(18.2.84)
which are of Lagrange type, corresponding to a mechanical system with s − r degrees of freedom; these s − r equations determine the generalized co-ordinates q j = q j (t ) ,
j = r + 1, r + 2,..., s . Replacing these co-ordinates in Routh’s function, it results
R = R (C 1 ,C 2 ,...,C r ; t ) and one can obtain the other generalized co-ordinates in the form qk − qk0 =
t
∫t
0
∂R d t = 0, k = 1, 2,..., r , ∂C k
(18.2.85)
the theorem being thus justified. Starting from (18.2.83), Hertz introduced a generalized kinetic energy of the form
T = T − ⎛⎜ V + ⎝
r
⎞
∑ C k qk ⎟⎠ ,
k =1
the sum being considered as being a potential of forces resulting from a unknown cyclic motion; as a matter of fact, Hertz tried to define the potential energy of a mechanical system by the cyclic motion of several “ignorable masses”, which are added to the palpable (visible) masses of the mechanical system S , which justifies the denomination given to the corresponding generalized co-ordinates. Let be the classical model of atom, called “rotator”, which has a motion of rotation about a fixed axis in the space. Because the kinetic energy T = (m / 2) (r 2 + r 2 θ2 + z 2 ) is thus that ∂T / ∂θ = 0 , the theorem of areas is = ∂L / ∂θ mr 2 θ = const ; taking into account r = const , it results θ = ω0t + θ0 , ω0 , θ0 = const . We notice that the function R of Routh plays the rôle of a kinetic potential for the new problem which remains to be solved. But we mention that in this catastatic mechanical system appear always terms linear in the generalized velocities too (even in case of the catastatic mechanical systems for which the kinetic energy is a positive definite quadratic form and which is acted upon by generalized forces which admit a simple quasi-potential).
Lagrangian Mechanics
81
18.2.3.8 Passing to an Equivalent System of Differential Equation of First Order In the absence of holonomic constraints, the space of configurations can be even the representative space E 3n . Indeed, the relation (18.2.1), written for a fixed t , leads to a metrics of the form ds 2 = g jk dq j dqk ,
(18.2.86)
where the coefficients of the Riemannian space R3n n
g jk =
∂r
∑ ∂qij
i =1
⋅
∂ri , j , k = 1, 2,..., s , ∂qk
(18.2.86')
can be obtained from the coefficients (18.2.15') taking masses equal to unity and maintaining the property det[ g jk ] ≠ 0 ; if the mechanical system is a free one, then s = 3n , hence an Euclidean space E 3 n , so that – by a linear transformation – we can obtain the normal form with constant coefficients
ds 2 =
∑ ⎡⎣⎢ ( dx1( i ) ) n
i =1
2
(
+ dx 2( i )
) + ( dx 3(i ) ) 2
2
⎤, ⎦⎥
(18.2.86'')
the square of the element of arc being expressed in the form of a sum of squares. If the time t is not fixed, ds 2 is an arbitrary polynomial of second degree in dq j (corresponding to the analogous form of the kinetic energy); but the character of the kinetic energy for a mechanical motion leads, by a convenient transformation, to an element of arc of the form (18.2.86'') too. But if there exist certain constraints, the space R3 n becomes a Riemannian space (of positive curvature), because – reducing the number of the configurative dimensions – the Euclidean character of the space is destroyed. In general, the state of a discrete mechanical system S is determined by its position and its motion in the neighbourhood of this position, hence by the set q j = q j (t ) , u j = q j = u j (t ), j = 1,2,..., s . We can thus conceive a representative space with 2s
dimensions, in which the representative point of co-ordinates q j , u j , j = 1, 2,..., s , does represent, at any moment, “the state” of the mechanical system S ; this space is called the state space or the phase space. In the case in which s = 3n , this space is 6n -dimensional and has not the character of a metric manifold; it is only an affine space and one cannot choose a common unity of measure for both types of co-ordinates, but it has a particular importance in the analytical representation of the motion. We have seen in Sect. 18.2.2.4 that one can replace Lagrange’s system of s equations of second order (18.2.45') by a system of 2s differential equations of first order (18.2.48), written in the normal form, the unknown functions being q j = q j (t ) and u j = u j (t ), j = 1, 2,..., s . This system of equations can be written also in the form
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
82
d q1 dq du1 du2 dqs dus dt = 2 = ... = = = = ... = = . 1 u1 u2 us ϕ1 ϕ2 ϕs
(18.2.87)
If we succeed to find 2s first integrals of the form fl (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , u1 , u2 ,..., us ; t ) = C l , l = 1,2,..., 2s , where C l are arbitrary constants, then we can determine the
unknown functions q j = q j (t ;C 1 ,C 2 ,...,C 2 s ) , u j = u j (t ;C 1 ,C 2 ,...,C 2 s ) , obviously, the relations dq j dt = u j , j = 1, 2,..., s , taking place too. The problem of motion of the mechanical system S is thus entirely solved. Let us suppose that the mechanical system S is catastatic, so that the time t does not appear explicitly in the expression of the kinetic energy; in this case,, the equations of motion take the form (18.2.47') (we assume to have only holonomic constraints, which – in this case – are scleronomic), where Christoffel’s symbols of second kind do not depend explicitly on time. As well, we suppose that neither the generalized forces Q j∗ do not depend explicitly on time ( ∂Q j∗ ∂t = 0, j − 1,2,.., s ). In this case, nor in the system of equations (18.2.87) the time does not intervene explicitly in the first 2s ratios; neglecting the ratio dt 1 , we will try to integrate the system of equations
dq1 dq du1 du2 dqs dus = 2 = ... = = = = ... = . u1 u2 us ϕ1 ϕ2 ϕs
(18.2.88)
If we succeed now to find the first integrals fl (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , u1 , u2 ,..., us ) = C l ,
l = 1,2,..., 2s − 1 , then we can determinate 2s − 1 unknown functions with respect to one the co-ordinates, e.g. q1 , in the form qk = qk (q1 ;C 1 ,C 2 ,...,C 2 s −1 ), k = 2, 3,..., s , u j = u j (q1 ;C 1 ,C 2 ,...,C 2 s −1 ), j = 1, 2,..., s .
Associating the equation dq1 u1 = dt 1 , we obtain t +τ =
dq
∫ u1 (q1 ;C1 ,C 2 ,...,Cs −1 ) ,
(18.2.88')
completing thus the integration constants by τ , the integration of the system of 2s linear equations (18.2.88) is thus reduced to the integration of a system of 2s − 1 linear equations and to a quadrature. Assuming that one can write a Jacobi first integral of the form (18.2.63) too, we can express then one of the generalized velocities, for instance q1 , in the form q1 = u1 (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , u2 , u3 ,..., us ; h ) , so that – instead of the system (18.2.88) – we
have to integrate a system of 2s − 2 linear differential equations
Lagrangian Mechanics
83
d q1 dq du2 du 3 d qs dus = 2 = ... = = = = ... = , u1 u2 us ϕ2 ϕ3 ϕs
(18.2.89)
with ϕk = ϕk (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , u1 , u2 ,..., us ), k = 2, 3,..., s . Thus, the complete system of integrals of the equations of motion (18.2.88) is formed by 2(s − 1) integrals of the system (18.2.89), by Jacobi’s first integral (18.2.63) and by the integral (18.2.88'). We put thus in evidence the trajectory of the representative point in the state space. Such a study has been made by Hamilton in the phase space and we will present it systematically in the next chapter.
18.3 Other Problems Concerning Lagrange’s Equations There are also other problems concerning Lagrange’s equations which present a particular interest, as the forms taken by these equations in some special cases or different systems of equations of motion equivalent to them. Besides these results, we will deal with some significant applications of the analytical methods introduced by Lagrange.
18.3.1 New Forms of Lagrange’s Equations In the following, we consider some new forms of Lagrange’s equations, as the central equation of Lagrange, the equations of Nielsen, the equations of Tsenov and the Mangeron–Deleanu equations. As well, we will put in evidence the form taken by these equations in case of continuous mechanical system, in case of a non-inertial frame of reference and in case of the phenomenon of collision. 18.3.1.1 Lagrange’s Central Equation Let be a particle Pi of position vector ri and of mass mi , which belongs to a discrete mechanical system S . We can write the obvious relation
(
d dri ⋅ δri dt dt
)
=
( ) ⎥⎤⎦ + ddrt ⋅ ⎡⎢⎣ ddt ( δr ) − δ ( ddrt ) ⎤⎥⎦ .
d2 ri ⎡ 1 dri ⋅ δri + δ ⎢ 2 dt ⎣ 2 dt
2
i
i
i
Taking into account the relations (18.2.1), we have T (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ) =
( ),
dri 1 n mi 2 i∑ dt =1
2
wherefrom, using the relations (18.2.28) too, we obtain ∂T δq = ∂q j j
n
∑ mi
i =1
( )
dri ∂ dri ⋅ δq j = dt ∂q j dt
n
∑ mi
i =1
dri ∂ri ⋅ δq = dt ∂q j j
n
∑ mi
i =1
The principle of virtual work, written in the form (18.2.27), leads to
dri ⋅ δri . dt
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
84 n
∑ mi
i =1
d2 ri ⋅ δri = Q j δq j . dt 2
In this case, multiplying the above identity by mi and summing for all the indices i , it results d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ δq = Q j δq j + δΤ + dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j j ⎟⎠
( )
dri ⎡ d dri ⎤ ⋅ ( δri ) − δ . dt ⎢⎣ dt dt ⎥⎦
n
∑ mi
i =1
Observing that δΤ =
∂T ∂T δq j + δq , ∂q j ∂q j j
we can write this relation in the form ∂T ⎡ d ⎡ d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ ∂T ⎤ ⎤ ⎢ dt ⎜ ∂q ⎟ − ∂q − Q ⎥ δq j = ∂q ⎢⎣ δq j − dt ( δq j ) ⎥⎦ j j ⎣ ⎝ j ⎠ ⎦ n dr dri d − ∑ mi i ⋅ ⎡ δ − ( δri ) ⎤ . ⎢ ⎥⎦ dt ⎣ dt dt i =1
( )
(18.3.1)
We get thus, after Hamel, Lagrange’s central equation (Hamel, G., 1927). In case of holonomic constraints, the operator relations (18.1.77) take place for the position vectors in E 3 ; as well, the operator relations (18.2.13) take always place for the generalized co-ordinates in Λs . In these conditions, the equation (18.3.1) leads to the fourth form of the fundamental equation (the equation (18.2.27')). 18.3.1.2 Mechanical Systems with Separable Variables. Systems of Liouville Type There are many problems, e.g. in celestial mechanical or in atomic physics, which lead to a Lagrangian for which the kinetic energy and the simple potential of the generalized forces are of the form T =
1 s Vj (q j )q2j , U = 2∑ j =1
s
∑U j (q j ) , j =1
(18.3.2)
where U j ,Vj , j = 1, 2,..., s , are functions of only one variable of class C 1 . In this case, Lagrange’s equations (18.2.29) read Vj (q j )qj +
dU j 1 dV j 2 q = , j = 1, 2,..., s . 2 dq j j dq j
Multiplying by q j and integrating with respect to time, we get
(18.3.3)
Lagrangian Mechanics
85
1 V (q )q 2 − U j (q j ) = C j , j = 1,2,..., s , 2 j j j
(18.3.3')
where C j , j = 1, 2,..., s , are integration constants. Summing with respect to the index j . one obtain the first integral of mechanical energy; but we have thus first integrals corresponding to s particular mechanical energies (eventually, to the mechanical energies of s particles). By s quadratures of the form t + τj =
Vj (q j ) 1 dq j , j = 1, 2,..., s , 2 ∫ U j (q j ) + C j
(18.3.4)
we introduce the integration constants τ j , j = 1, 2,..., s , too. Thus, one obtains the relations which link the time to each generalized co-ordinate, the problem being thus entirely solved. The respective mechanical systems are mechanical systems with separable variables. A problem similar is that of the discrete mechanical systems, called systems of Liouville type, for which we have s
T =
s 1 s uk (qk ) ∑Vj (q j ) q 2j , U = ∑ 2 k =1 k =1
∑U j (q j ) j =1 s
∑ uk (qk )
(18.3.5)
k =1
and where U j ,Vj and uk , j , k = 1, 2,..., s , are functions of only one variable. Obviously, the case considered above is a particular case of a system of Liouville type for which uk = 1 s = const . By the substitution Vj (q j ) =
dWj (q j ) W j = , j = 1, 2,..., s , q j dq j
we can write T =
u s 2 1 s Wj , U = ∑U j (Wj ), u = ∑ 2 k =1 u j =1
s
∑ uk (Wk ) .
k =1
(18.3.6)
Lagrange’s equations relative to the new generalized co-ordinate Wj take the form d ( uW k dt
1 ∂u
s
) − 2 ∂W ∑W j2
=
k j =1
∂U , k = 1, 2,..., s . ∂Wk
Multiplying by 2uW k , we get d 2 2 ∂u ( u Wk ) − uW k ∂W dt k
s
∑W j2 j =1
= 2uW k
∂U . ∂Wk
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
86
On the other hand, the first integral of mechanical energy is u s 2 Wj − U = h , h = const . 2∑ j =1
We are thus led to d 2 2 ( u Wk dt = 2W k
∂u ∂U + 2uW k ∂Wk ∂Wk
) = 2(h + U )Wk
∂ d [ ( h + U ) u ] = 2 [ huk (qk ) + U k (qk ) ] , k = 1, 2,..., s , ∂Wk dt
wherefrom one obtains the system of differential equations dW1 dW2 = = ... hu1 (q1 ) + U 1 (q1 ) + α1 hu2 (q2 ) + U 2 (q2 ) + α2 dWs dt = = 2 . u hus (qs ) + U s (qs ) + αs
(18.3.7)
Noting that u 2W k2 = 2(huk + U k ) + 2 αk , k = 1,2,..., s , summing with respect to all indices and taking into account the integral of mechanical energy, we find the condition s
∑ αk
k =1
= 0,
(18.3.7')
which must be verified by the constants αk , k = 1, 2,..., s , thus introduced. The equations (18.3.7) are with separate variables, the problem being reduced to quadratures. 18.3.1.3 Case of Continuous Mechanical Systems Let be a continuous mechanical system with a finite number of degrees of freedom, which occupies a domain V in E 3 and is acted upon by a volumic force F ( r ) (hence, by the force F dV on the element of volume); the torsor of these forces (resultant force and resultant moment) at the pole O is given by R =
∫V F (r )dV , MO
=
∫V r × F dV .
(18.3.8)
The kinetic energy is expressed in the form
T =
( ) dV ,
1 dr μ( r ) 2 ∫V dt
2
(18.3.9)
where μ ( r ) is the density, so that in the formulae (18.2.15), (18.2.15'), (18.2.15''), and (18.2.15''') we will have
Lagrangian Mechanics
87 g jk =
gj =
∂r
∫V μ(r ) ∂q j
∂r
∫V μ(r ) ∂q j
⋅
∂r dV , ∂qk
⋅ r dV , j , k = 1, 2,..., s , g 0 =
1 μ( r )r 2 dV . 2 ∫V
(18.3.9')
Analogously, the virtual work of the volumic forces will be given by δW =
∫V F ⋅ δr dV
= δq j
∂r
∫V F ⋅ ∂q j dV
= Q j δq j ,
so that the generalized forces will be Qj =
∂r
∫V F ⋅ ∂q j dV .
(18.3.10)
The principle of virtual work is expressed in the form ∂r ⎡ ⎤ ⎢ ∫V μ ( r )r ⋅ ∂q − Q j ⎥ δq j = 0 . j ⎣ ⎦
(18.3.11)
By a demonstration analogous to that in Sect. 18.2.2.1, where the sign plus is replaced by the sign integral, we find again the fourth form of the fundamental equation (18.2.27'). The results obtained are thus justified for rigid solids too.
18.3.1.4 Electromechanical Analogy We have seen in Sect. 8.2.2.10 that one can establish an interesting analogy between an R.L.C. circuit (an ohmic resistance R , a loading inductance L and a condenser of capacity C , connected in series with a generator having an electromotive force E (t ) ) and a particle P (of mass m → L , of damping coefficient k ′ → R and of coefficient of elasticity k → 1/C , acted upon by a given force F (t ) → E (t ) , where we have put in evidence the correspondence between various quantities), in a vibrating motion. Thus, we can introduce quantities analogue to those of mechanical nature in the form (we use well known notations)
1 ∂ ⎛ Rq 2 ⎞ 1 2 T = Wq 2 , Q = − ⎜ q , = − Rq , U = − 2 ∂q ⎝ 2 ⎟⎠ 2C
(18.3.12)
where (1/ 2)Rq 2 corresponds to Rayleigh’s function, q = q (t ) is the charge, while i = i (t ) = q (t ) is the intensity of the current. Lagrange’s equation d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ ∂T ∂U = +Q + F ⎜ ⎟− ∂q dt ⎝ ∂q ⎠ ∂q
leads to the equation (8.2.58).
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
88
The above considerations can be applied to complex R.L.C. circuits, corresponding to discrete mechanical systems with a finite number of degrees of freedom; using the mentioned electromechanical energy one obtains a system of differential equations which allows the determination of the electric charges q (t ) in each circuit.
18.3.1.5 Nielsen’s Equations We have established Lagrange’s equations by means of the d’Alembert–Lagrange principle (the principle of virtual work); analogously, Jourdain’s principle (18.1.57'), written in the form n
∑ mi ai
i =1
n
⋅ δvi = ∑ Fi ⋅ δvi ,
(18.3.13)
i =1
leads to an equivalent system of equations of motion. Starting from the relation (18.2.14) and taking into account (18.2.4'), we may write
∂ai ∂ 2 ri ∂r ∂v =2 qk + 2 i = 2 i , i = 1, 2,..., n , j = 1, 2,..., s , ∂q j ∂q j ∂qk ∂q j ∂q j
(18.3.14)
On the other hand, we notice that Jourdain’s principle can be written for a given position of the mechanical system, at a fixed moment, varying the velocities; thus, it results δvi =
∂vi ∂r δq j = i δq j , ∂q j ∂q j
(18.3.15)
where we took into account (18.2.28). In this case, Jourdain’s principle takes the form ⎡
n
∑ ⎢⎣ −mi ai i =1
⋅
∂vi ∂r ⎤ + Fi ⋅ i ⎥ δq j = 0 . ∂q j ∂q j ⎦
(18.3.13')
Using the expression of the kinetic energy, we get n
dT = dt
∑ mi vi
i =1
⋅ ai ,
∂T = ∂q j
n
∑ mi vi
i =1
⋅
∂vi , ∂q j
so that
( ) = ∑m v
∂ dT ∂q j dt
n
i =1
i i
⋅
∂ai + ∂q j
n
∑ mi ai
i =1
⋅
n ∂vi ∂v = 2 ∑ mi vi ⋅ i + qj ∂q j ∂ i =1
n
∑ mi ai
i =1
⋅
∂vi , ∂q j
where we have used the relation (18.3.14). Taking into account the expression (18.2.18) of the generalized forces, the form (18.3.13') of Jourdain’s principle leads to
( )
∂ dT ⎡ ∂T ⎤ ⎢ 2 ∂q − ∂q dt + Q j ⎥ δq j = 0 . j j ⎣ ⎦
(18.3.16)
Lagrangian Mechanics
89
Noting that the variations δq j of the generalized velocities are independent and arbitrary, in case of holonomic constraints, we can write the equations obtained in 1935 by J. Nielsen in the form (Dolapčev, Bl., 1966)
( )
∂ dT ∂T −2 = Q j , j = 1,2,..., s . ∂q j dt ∂q j
(18.3.17)
These equations are governing the motion of the representative point P in the space Λs . In case of the non-holonomic constraints (18.2.10), one must use the method of Lagrange’s multipliers. Taking into account the relation (we use the operator relation (18.2.13))
d ⎛ ∂vi ⎞ d ⎛ ∂ri ⎞ ∂vi , i = 1, 2,..., n , j = 1,2,..., s , = = ⎜ ⎟ dt ⎝ ∂q j ⎠ dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j ⎟⎠ ∂q j
(18.3.18)
we can write the derivative ∂v d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ d n mi vi ⋅ i = = ⎜ ⎟ q j ∂ dt ⎝ ∂q j ⎠ dt i∑ =1
n
∑ mi ai
i =1
⋅
∂vi + ∂q j
n
∑ mi vi
i =1
⋅
d ⎛ ∂vi ⎞ dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j ⎟⎠
in the form
( )
d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ ∂ dT ∂T , j = 1, 2,..., s . = − dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j ⎟⎠ ∂q j dt ∂q j
We see thus that Nielsen’s equations are equivalent to Lagrange’s equations. We mention also that, in some cases, Nielsen’s equations allow a more simple calculation that Lagrange’s ones. We consider also Gauss’s principle (the principle of the least action) (18.1.60') or (18.1.66), written in the form n
∑ mi ai
i =1
⋅ δai =
n
∑ Fi
i =1
⋅ δai
(18.3.19)
for a given position and velocity of the mechanical system. at a fixed moment, varying only the accelerations; in this case, the relation (18.2.14) allows to write ∂ai ∂r = i , ∂qj ∂q j
(18.3.20)
∂ai ∂r δq = i δqj . ∂qj j ∂q j
(18.3.15')
so that δai =
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
90 The relation (18.3.19) takes the form n
⎡
∑ ⎢⎣ Fi
i =1
⋅
∂ri ∂r ⎤ − mi ai ⋅ i ⎥ δqj = 0 ∂q j ∂q j ⎦
(18.3.19')
and, taking into account the above results and (18.2.28), we obtain
( )
∂ dT ⎡ ∂T ⎤ ⎢ 2 ∂q − ∂q dt + Q j ⎥ δqj = 0 . j j ⎣ ⎦
(18.3.16')
Noting that, in case of holonomic constraints, the variations δqj of the generalized accelerations are independent and arbitrary, we find again the equations (18.2.17) of Nielsen. The principle of Gauss in finite form (18.2.60) can be written also in the form n
∑ mi ai
i =1
⋅ Δai − Q Δqj = 0 ,
(18.3.19'')
where we have put in evidence the finite variations of the accelerations ai and of the generalized accelerations qj ; this is the fifth form of the fundamental equation.
18.3.1.6 Tsenov’s Equations Starting from Gauss’s principle, written in the form (18.3.19) or in the form (18.3.19'), we can establish also other equations, equivalent to Lagrange’s equations. To do this, starting from the expression of the derivative dT / dt , let us calculate d2T = dt 2
n
n
i =1
i =1
∑ mi ai2 + ∑ mi vi
⋅ a(2) , i (2)
where we have introduced the accelerations of second order ai too). Using the equations (18.2.14), it results ) a(2 = i
(see Sect. 18.1.2.5
∂ri ∂2 ri ∂r d ⎛ ∂ri ⎞ + 2 qj + q qj qk + 2 i qj + ... j ⎜ ⎟ ∂q j ∂q j ∂qk ∂q j dt ⎝ ∂q j ⎠ 2 ∂r ∂r ⎞ ⎛ ∂ ri = i qj + 3 ⎜ qk + i ⎟ qj + ..., ∂q j ∂q j ⎠ ⎝ ∂q j ∂qk
wherefrom ) a(2 = i
∂ri ∂v qj + 3 i qj + ... , ∂q j ∂q j
(18.3.21)
Lagrangian Mechanics
91
so that ) ∂a(2 ∂r i = i , ∂qj ∂q j
(18.3.20')
) ∂a(2 ∂v i =3 i . ∂qj ∂q j
(18.3.14')
as well as
Taking into account these results, we obtain n ∂a ∂ ⎛ d2T ⎞ = 2 mi ai ⋅ i + ∑ ⎜ ⎟ ∂qj ⎝ dt 2 ⎠ ∂ qj i =1
n
∑ mi vi
n n ∂ai ∂r ∂v = 2 ∑ mi ai ⋅ i + 3 ∑ mi vi ⋅ i , ∂qj ∂ ∂ q qj j i =1 i =1 (2)
⋅
i =1
so that the relation (18.2.19') leads to
⎧ 1 ⎡ ∂T
n
∑ ⎨⎩ 2 ⎢⎣ 3 ∂q j
i =1
−
∂ ⎛ d2T ⎞ ⎤ ⎫ + Q j ⎬ δqj = 0 . ∂qj ⎜⎝ dt 2 ⎟⎠ ⎥⎦ ⎭
(18.3.22)
Because, in case of holonomic constraints, the variations δqj of the generalized accelerations are independent, we can write the equations of I. Tsenov in the form ∂ ⎛ d2T ⎞ ∂T −3 = 2Q j , j = 1, 2,..., s . ⎜ ⎟ 2 ∂qj ⎝ dt ⎠ ∂q j
(18.3.23)
Taking into account the previous relations, we find easily that
( )
1 ⎡ ∂ ⎛ d2T ⎞ ∂T ⎤ ∂ dT ∂T −3 = −2 , j = 1,2,..., s . 2 ⎢⎣ ∂qj ⎜⎝ dt 2 ⎟⎠ ∂q j ⎥⎦ ∂q j dt ∂q j
(18.3.24)
Hence, the equations obtained in 1962 by Tsenov are equivalent to Nielsen’s equations (hence, to Lagrange’s equations too), in the case of ideal holonomic constraints (Dolapčev, Bl., 1966).
18.3.1.7 The Mangeron–Deleanu Equations Starting from the expression of the derivative d2T / dt 2 , we observe that n d3T ) 3 mi ai ⋅ a(2 = + ∑ i dt 3 i =1 n d4T ( 3) = 4 ∑ mi ai ⋅ ai + 4 dt i =1
n
∑ mi vi
i =1
n
∑ mi vi
i =1
⋅ a(i 3 ) ,
⋅ ai
(4)
+ ...,
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
92
where, in the last expression, we have mentioned only terms which contain generalized accelerations till qj (and not generalized accelerations of higher order); by complete induction, one can show that n dmT ( m − 1) + m = m ∑ mi ai ⋅ ai dt i =1
n
∑ mi vi
i =1
⋅ a(i m ) + ... ,
(18.3.25)
where the terms which contain the generalized accelerations q (j m ) have been put in evidence. On the other hand, starting from (18.3.21) and using the operator relation (18.2.13), we obtain (3)
ai
=
∂ri ∂v q j + 4 i qj + ... ∂q j ∂q j
and, in general, by complete induction, =
(m )
ai
∂ri ( m + 1) ∂v ( m ) + (m + 1) i q j + ..., i = 1, 2,..., n , q ∂q j j ∂q j
(18.3.26)
wherefrom ∂a(i m ) ( m + 1)
∂q j
=
(m ) ∂ri ∂ai ∂v , ( m ) = (m + 1) i , i = 1, 2,..., n , j = 1, 2,..., s . ∂q j ∂q ∂q j j
(18.3.26')
We can thus calculate ∂ ∂q j
(m )
( m − 1) m n ⎛ d T ⎞ = m m a ⋅ ∂ai ⎜ m ⎟ ∑ i i ∂q ( m ) + ⎝ dt ⎠ i =1 j
n
= m ∑ mi ai ⋅ i =1
n
∑ mi vi
i =1
⋅
∂a(i m ) ∂q j
(m )
+ ...
n ∂ri ∂v + (m + 1) ∑ mi vi ⋅ i + ..., j = 1, 2,..., s . ∂q j ∂ qj i =1
(18.3.25')
The relation 1 ⎡ ∂ ⎛ dmT ⎞ ∂T ⎢ ⎜ ⎟ − (m + 1) m ⎢ ∂q ( m ) ⎝ dt m ⎠ ∂q j ⎣ j
( )
⎤ ∂ dT ∂T ⎥ = . −2 q d t qj ∂ ∂ j ⎥⎦
(18.3.24')
which generalizes the relation (18.3.24) is thus easily stated. Thus, we find the D. I. Mangeron–D. Deleanu equations (Lagrange’s generalized equations), obtained in 1962 in the form ∂ ∂q (j m )
m ⎛ d T ⎞ − (m + 1) ∂T = mQ , j = 1, 2,..., s , m ∈ ` . ⎜ m ⎟ j ∂q j ⎝ dt ⎠
(18.3.27)
Lagrangian Mechanics
93
These equations are equivalent to Lagrange’s equations, to Nielsen’s equations and to Tsenov’s equations, which result as particular cases for m = 1 and m = 2 , respectively. Let us consider a differential principle of the form n
∑ mi ai
( m − 1)
⋅ δai
i =1
=
n
∑ Fi
i =1
( m − 1)
⋅ δai
,m ∈`,
(18.3.28)
where we have put in evidence accelerations of higher order; assuming that this principle takes place for a given positions, a given velocity and given accelerations till the (m − 2) -th order inclusive, at a fixed moment, varying only the accelerations of the (m − 1) -th order, we can write δa(i m ) =
∂a(i m −1) (m ) ∂q j
δq (j m ) =
∂ri δq ( m ) , i = 1, 2,..., n , m ∈ ` . ∂q j j
(18.3.26'')
The differential principle (18.3.28) can be written in the form n
⎛
∑ ⎜⎝ Fi
i =1
⋅
∂ri ∂r ⎞ − mi ai ⋅ i ⎟ δqi( m ) = 0, m ∈ ` . ∂q j ∂q j ⎠
(18.3.28')
Starting from this principle we can obtain the Mangeron–Deleanu equations. Obviously, in this case, the ideal constraints are defined by the relation n
∑ Ri
i =1
⋅ δqi( m −1) = 0, m ∈ ` .
(18.3.29)
All the equations thus established can be used for holonomic mechanical systems, immaterial from the type of ideal constraints which are considered, which represents an interesting generalization from the mechanical point of view. In case of non-holonomic constraints, these equations are completed with constraint generalized forces, after Lagrange’s method; one uses the equations which correspond to different types of ideal constraints.
18.3.1.8 Case of a Non-inertial Frame of Reference If we report the discrete mechanical system S to a non-inertial frame of reference R (movable with respect to an inertial frame R ′ , considered fixed), then the
generalized co-ordinates q j , j = 1, 2,..., s , will specify its position with respect to this frame; as a matter of fact, the position of the system S is thus specified even with respect to the frame R ′ , because the motion of the frame R with respect to the frame R ′ is known. One uses Lagrange’s equations (18.2.29) in the form
d ⎛ ∂T ′ ⎞ ∂T ′ − = Q j , j = 1,2,..., s , dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j ⎟⎠ ∂q j
(18.3.30)
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
94
where the kinetic energy with respect to the frame R ′ is given by T′ =
1 n mi ( vO′ + vi + ω × ri )2 , 2 i∑ =1
vi being the velocities relative to the frame
(18.3.30')
R , while Q j = Q j (ql , ql ; t ) are the
generalized forces; because ri = ri (ql ; t ) , one obtains T ′ = T ′(ql , ql ; t ) , the problem being then reduced to that corresponding to an inertial frame. Another method of calculation is based on the theory of relative motion (see Sect. 10.2.1); one introduces thus the generalized forces Q (j t ) = Q (j t ) (ql , ql ; t ) and (C )
Qj
= Qj
(C )
(ql , ql ; t ), j = 1, 2,..., s , corresponding to the transportation generalized
forces and to the Coriolis generalized forces, respectively. Lagrange’s equations become
d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ ∂T (t ) (C ) − = Q j′ , Q j′ = Q j + Q j + Q j , j = 1, 2,..., s , dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j ⎟⎠ ∂q j
(18.3.31)
where T = T (ql , ql ; t ) is the kinetic energy given by (calculated in the frame R )
T =
1 n mi vi2 . 2 i∑ =1
(18.3.31')
Gilbert elaborated in 1883 a mixed method, which is based – partially – on the theory of relative motion; one introduces thus a frame R with the origin at the pole O and with the axes parallel to the axes of the frame R ′ (which is not rotating about this frame). Hence, Lagrange’s equations read
d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ ∂T ∂U , j = 1,2,..., s , − = Qj + dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j ⎟⎠ ∂q j ∂q j
(18.3.32)
where U = U (ql , ql ; t ) is a potential given by
U =
n
∑ mi ri
i =1
⋅ aO′ = − M ρ ⋅ aO′ ,
(18.3.32')
corresponding to the centrifugal force. The kinetic energy T = T (ql , ql ; t ) with respect to the frame R is given by (see Sect. 11.2.2.2) T =
1 n 1 mi ( vi + ω × ri )2 = T + I Δ ω 2 + ω ⋅ KO , 2 i∑ 2 =1
(18.3.32'')
Lagrangian Mechanics
95
where KO and T are the moment of momentum with respect to the pole O and the kinetic energy, respectively, in the frame R , while I Δ is the moment of inertia of the mechanical system S with respect to the instantaneous axis of rotation Δ ; thus, the kinetic energy T with respect to the generalized co-ordinates and the generalized velocities is easily obtained. Using this method, Gilbert studies the influence of the rotation of the Earth on the motion of a heavy rigid solid of revolution, fixed at a fixed point O (different from C ), the principal axis of inertia Ox 3 being in rotation in a vertical plane linked to the Earth; the apparatus by which Gilbert verified experimentally the results theoretically obtained is called barogyroscope.
18.3.1.9 The Phenomenon of Collision In case of a phenomenon of collision, we start from the theorem of momentum, written in the form (13.1.8) for a particle Pi of the discrete mechanical system S subjected to constraints; a scalar product by ∂ri / ∂q j leads to mi vi′′ ⋅
∂ri ∂r ∂r ∂r − mi vi′ ⋅ i = Pi ⋅ i + PRi ⋅ i , ∂q j ∂q j ∂q j ∂q j
the position of the system S remaining the same before and after collision (we denoted by “second” the corresponding quantities after collision). Taking into account the relations (18.2.28) and summing for all the particles of the system S , we get the jump relations ⎛ ∂T ⎞ ⎛ ∂T Δ⎜ ≡⎜ ⎟ ⎝ ∂q j ⎠0 ⎝ ∂q j
⎞′′ ⎛ ∂T ⎟ − ⎜ ∂q ⎠ ⎝ j
⎞′ ⎟ = ⎠
Pj + PRj , j = 1, 2,..., s ,
(18.3.33)
where we have introduced the given generalized percussions and the constraint generalized percussions, respectively, in the form
Pj =
n
∑ Pi
i =1
⋅
∂ri ,P = ∂q j Rj
n
∑ PRi
i =1
⋅
∂ri , j = 1, 2,.., s , ∂q j
(18.3.33')
the index zero corresponding to an arbitrary moment of discontinuity t0 ∈ [ t ′, t ′′ ] , | t ′′ − t ′ |< ε, ε > 0 arbitrary.
Starting from the equations (18.2.32), integrating on the interval [t ′, t ′′ ] and passing to the limit in the sense of the theory of distributions, we can write
lim
∫
t ′′
t ′′ − t ′ → 0 + 0 t ′
t ′′ ∂T ⎛ ∂T ⎞ d⎜ dt = ⎟ − t ′′ −tlim ∫ ′ ∂q t ′ → + 0 0 ∂ q j ⎝ j ⎠
lim
∫
t ′′
t ′′ − t ′ → 0 + 0 t ′
(Q j + Rj )dt ;
noting that ∂T / ∂q j is a finite quantity and neglecting the given and constraint nonpercussive forces with respect to the corresponding percussive ones, we find again the jump relations (18.3.33), with
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
96 t ′′
Q j dt t ′′ − t ′ → 0 + 0 ∫t ′ lim
=
n
∂r
∑ ∂qij
i =1
⋅
=
t ′′
Fi t ′′ − t ′ → 0 + 0 ∫t ′
t ′′
lim
n
Fi dt = ∑ Pi t ′′ −t ′ → 0 + 0 ∫t ′ i =1
lim
⋅
⋅
∂ri dt ∂q j
∂ri = ∂q j
Pj ,
and similar relations for the constraint generalized percussions. Introducing the generalized momenta (18.2.80), considering Lagrange’s equations in the form (18.2.36) and observing that ∂U / ∂q j is a finite quantity, one can write the jump relations (18.3.33) in the form
( Δp j )0
= p j′′ − p j′ = Pj + PRj , j = 1, 2,..., s ,
(18.3.33'')
We state thus Theorem 18.3.1 (theorem of generalized momentum). The jump of the generalized momentum of a discrete mechanical system subjected to constraints, corresponding to a generalized co-ordinate at a moment of discontinuity, is equal to the sum of the given and constraint generalized percussions, which correspond to the same generalized co-ordinate and which act upon the same system at that moment. This theorem corresponds to the Theorem 13.1.2 stated in the space E 3 . Let us consider, in general, the case of a mechanical system S subjected to holonomic constraints, the position of which at the moment t ′ is definite by the generalized co-ordinates q1′ , q2′ ,..., qs′ (after eliminating the holonomic constraints); at the moment t0 ∈ [ t ′, t ′′ ] , h new holonomic constraints are suddenly introduced, so that the motion of the system S is suddenly perturbed. while at the moment t ′′ the generalized velocities have finite variations, passing from q j′ to q j′′, j = 1, 2,..., s , the position of the considered system remaining practically the same. The preceding constraints of the system S are permanent, while the new introduced constraints can become permanent or can disappear after the interval of percussion. The new introduced constraints are expressed by relations of the form ϕl (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ) = 0, l = 1, 2,..., h . Making a change of variable by which one replaces the co-ordinates ql by the co-ordinates rl = ϕl , the new constraints imposed to the system S will be expressed in the form rl = 0, l = s − h + 1, s − h + 2,..., s ; we assume to choose the generalized co-ordinates just in this form, having qs − h + 1 = 0, qs − h + 2 = 0,..., qs = 0 . If the new constraints introduced are temporary, then these co-ordinates will no more be equal to zero after the moment t ′′ ; otherwise, they remain equal to zero. The arbitrary virtual generalized displacements δq1 , δq2 ,..., δqs − h take place, while the virtual generalized displacements δqs − h + 1 , δqs − h + 2 ,..., δqs must vanish. We remain with Lagrange’s equations
d ⎛ ∂T ⎞ ∂T − = Q j , j = 1, 2,..., s − h , dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j ⎟⎠ ∂q j
(18.3.34)
Lagrangian Mechanics
97
for the interval of percussion, the constraints generalized forces new introduced disappearing from the calculation, because the corresponding virtual work vanishes Rs − h + 1 δqs − h + 1 + Rs − h + 2 δqs − h + 2 + ... + Rs δqs = 0 .
(18.3.34')
Noting that the variations of the generalized velocities are due only to the constraint generalized forces, the intensity of which has increased very much but which have disappeared from the calculation in the considered system of generalized co-ordinates, it results that ∂T / ∂q j and Q j are finite quantities; by integration on the interval of percussion and by passing to the limit, we find the jump relations ⎛ ∂T ⎞ ⎛ ∂T Δ⎜ ≡⎜ ⎟ ⎝ ∂q j ⎠0 ⎝ ∂q j
⎞′′ ⎛ ∂T ⎟ − ⎜ ∂q ⎠ ⎝ j
⎞′ ⎟ = 0, j = 1, 2,..., s − h , ⎠
(18.3.34'')
which are linear and homogenous with respect to the differences q j′′ − q j′ , j = 1, 2,..., s . One can thus state that the generalized momenta corresponding to the generalized co-ordinates, which do not vanish at the moment of collision, have the same values before and after this phenomenon (have not a jump). The generalized co-ordinates q1 , q2 ,..., qs have such values, in the equations (18.3.34''), that qs − h + 1 , qs − h + 2 ,..., qs do vanish at the moment of collision. In exchange, the generalized velocities qs − h + 1 , qs − h + 2 ,..., qs must not necessarily vanish, neither before, nor after collision; they equate to zero after collision if the new introduced constraints are permanent. In this last case, the relations (18.2.34'') determine entirely the generalized velocities q1′′, q2′′,..., qs′′− h , hence the state of generalized velocities after collision. Beside this particular case, we have at our disposal only s − h equations for s unknown generalized velocities, so that we must make supplementary hypotheses for the mathematical modelling of the mechanical phenomenon.
Fig. 18.8 A circular disc rolling without sliding on an axis in a vertical plane
As Beghin and Rousseau have shown in 1903, in case of a non-holonomic mechanical system, the constraint generalized forces are finite, so that they disappear from calculation, as well as the given generalized forces; hence, in this case, the jump relations (18.3.34'') can be applied too. Let be, e.g., a homogenous circular disc, of mass M and radius R , which moves in the vertical plane Ox1x 2 ; the disc strikes the Ox1 -axis at the moment t0 and continues to roll
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
98
without sliding on this axis. Before the collision, the position of the disc depends on three parameters: the co-ordinates ρ1 and ρ2 of the centre C of the disc and the angle of rotation θ , taken counterclockwise (Fig. 18.8). As an effect of the collision, two new constraints are introduced: the contact with the Ox1 -axis (hence ρ2 = R ) and the rolling of the disc on this axis ( ρ1 = Rθ ). Choosing conveniently the origin O , one introduces the generalized co-ordinates q1 = ρ1 , q2 = ρ2 − R , q 3 = ρ1 − Rθ , so that the constraint relations are expressed in the form q2 = 0, q 3 = 0 . Denoting by IO = MiO2 the moment of inertia of the disc with respect to the pole O , where iO is the corresponding radius of gyration, we can write the kinetic energy in the form T =
1 M ( iO2 θ2 + ρ12 + ρ22 2
1
( ) ( q
⎡ iO ⎣ R
) = 2M ⎢
2
1
⎤ − q3 )2 + q12 + q22 ⎥ . ⎦
We have at our disposal only a relation of the form (18.3.34''), corresponding to the generalized co-ordinate q1 , which does not vanish at the collision moment, that is
( ) [q ′′ − q ′ − ( q ′′ − q ′ ) ] + q ′′ − q ′ = 0 . iO R
2
1
1
3
3
1
But q 3 = 0 after collision, hence we have q3′′ = 0 too. Returning to the old variables, we can write
( iR ) ( ρ ′′ − Rθ′ ) + ρ ′′ − ρ ′ = 0 , O
2
1
1
1
the velocity of the centre of the disc in a rolling motion on the Ox1 -axis being given by ρ1′′ =
R ( Rρ1′ + iO2 θ ′ ) R2 + iO2
.
(18.3.35)
If Rρ1′ + iO2 θ ′ = 0 , then the disc stops.
18.3.2 Applications In what follows we present several applications, interesting by themselves, to illustrate the results previously obtained: the motion of a particle in various cases of loading, the problem of two particles and the problem of two centres; as well, we consider some cases of motion of the rigid solid: the plane motion of a bar, the double pendulum, the sympathetic pendulums etc.
Lagrangian Mechanics
99
18.3.2.1 Motion of a Particle Using the expression T = (m / 2)( x12 + x22 + x 32 ) of the kinetic energy, in case of a single particle P , Lagrange’s equations (18.2.29) take the form ( q j = x j , j = 1, 2, 3 ) d ( mx j dt
∂r
) = F ⋅ ∂x
j
+F⋅
∂x k ik = F ⋅ ik δkj = F ⋅ i j = Fj = Q j , k = 1, 2, 3 , ∂x j
so that we find again the equations of motion (6.1.22'). In the case of cylindrical co-ordinates q1 = r , q2 = θ , q 3 = z , the kinetic energy (see the formula (5.1.13'')) has the form T = (m / 2)(r 2 + r 2 θ2 + z 2 ) , resulting Lagrange’s equations ( r = r cos θi1 + r cos θi2 + z i 3 ) d ∂r ( mr ) − mr θ2 = F ⋅ = F ⋅ (cos θi1 + sin θi2 ) = F ⋅ ir = Fr = Qr , dt ∂r d ∂r ( mr 2 θ ) = F ⋅ ∂θ = F ⋅ [ r ( − sin θi1 + cos θi2 ) ] = F ⋅ ( r iθ ) = rFθ = Qθ , dt d ∂r ( mz ) = F ⋅ = F ⋅ i 3 = Fz = Qz , dt ∂z
being thus led to the equations of motion (6.1.26), (6.1.26'). In particular, we obtain the plane motion in polar co-ordinates. As well, in the case of spherical co-ordinates q1 = r , q2 = θ , q 3 = ϕ (see the formula (5.1.12'')), we can write T = (m / 2)(r 2 + r 2 θ2 + r 2 sin2 θϕ 2 ) , while Lagrange’s equations read ( r = r sin θ cos ϕi1 + r sin θ sin ϕi2 + r cos θi 3 ) d ∂r ( mr ) − mr ( θ2 + sin2 θϕ 2 ) = F ⋅ dt ∂r = F ⋅ (sin θ cos ϕi1 + sin θ sin ϕi2 + cos θi 3 ) = F ⋅ ir = Fr = Qr , d ∂r mr 2 θ ) − mr 2 sin θ cos θϕ 2 = F ⋅ ( dt ∂θ = F ⋅ [ r ( cos θ cos ϕi1 + cos θ sin ϕi2 − sin θ i 3 ) ] = F ⋅ ( r i θ ) = rFθ = Qθ , d ∂r ( mr 2 sin2 θϕ ) = F ⋅ ∂ϕ dt = F ⋅ [ r ( sin θ sin ϕi1 + sin θ cos ϕi2 ) ] = F ⋅ ( r iϕ ) = rFϕ = Qϕ ,
wherefrom we get the equations of motion (6.1.25), (6.1.25'). If the support of the force F pierces the Ox 3 -axis, then Qϕ = 0 , so that we can write the first integral
mr 2 sin2 θϕ = const ,
(18.3.36)
according to which the projection of the particle P on the plane Ox1x 2 moves after the law of areas.
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
100
Analogously, we find again the equations (6.1.24''') in arbitrary curvilinear coordinates. Let be, e.g., the quadric Γ x12 x 22 x 32 + + −1 = 0 α1 α2 α3
(18.3.37)
and the quadrics homofocal to this one x12 x 22 x 32 + + −1 = 0. α1 − λ α2 − λ α3 − λ
(18.3.37')
If, to fix the ideas, α1 > α2 > α3 , then the equation (18.3.37') represents an ellipsoid for λ < α3 , an one-sheet hyperboloid if α3 < λ < α2 or a two-sheet hyperboloid if α2 < λ < α1 . Through each point P (x1 , x 2 , x 3 ) pass three homofocal quadrics Γ i , i = 1, 2, 3 . Supposing that the co-ordinates x1 , x 2 , x 3 are given, the equation (18.3.37') of third degree in λ has three real roots q 3 < α3 < q2 < α2 < q1 < α1 , as one can easily verify; the root q1 leads to a two-sheet hyperboloid, the root q2 leads to an one-sheet hyperboloid, while the root q 3 correspond to an ellipsoid. These three quadrics are orthogonal two by two. We obtain thus the elliptical co-ordinates (introduced by Jacobi) q1 , q2 , q 3 of the point P . Obviously, we have x12 x 22 x 32 ( λ − q1 ) ( λ − q2 ) ( λ − q 3 ) + + −1 = , − − − f (λ ) α1 λ α2 λ α3 λ f (λ ) = ( α1 − λ ) ( α2 − λ ) ( α2 − λ ) ;
multiplying by αi = λ and making then λ = αi , i = 1, 2, 3 , we can express the Cartesian co-ordinates as functions of the elliptic co-ordinates in the form x i2 =
( αi − q1 ) ( αi − q2 ) ( αi − q 3 ) , i ≠ j ≠ k ≠ i , i , j , k = 1, 2, 3 . ( αj − αi ) ( αk − αi )
(18.3.38)
Calculating the logarithmic derivatives, we obtain the element of arc ds 2 =
1 ( A dq 2 + A2 dq22 + A3 dq 32 ) , 4 1 1
(18.3.39)
where Ai = =
( qi
x12
( qi − a1 )
2
+
x 22
( qi − a 2 )
2
+
x 32
( q 3 − a1 )2
− q j ) ( qi − qk ) ( ! ) , i ≠ j ≠ k ≠ i , i , j , k = 1, 2, 3. f (qi )
(18.3.39')
Lagrangian Mechanics
101
If the intersections of the surfaces q j = const and qk = const taken two by two are the curves C i , i ≠ j ≠ ≠ k ≠ i , i , j , k = 1, 2, 3 (Fig. 18.9), then the element of arc on these curves is given by dsi =
1 Ai dqi ( ! ) , i = 1, 2, 3 , 2
(18.3.40)
so that ds 2 = dsi dsi .
(18.3.39'')
Fig. 18.9 Elliptic co-ordinates in E 3
The kinetic energy is calculated in the form T =
( )
m ds 2 dt
2
=
m ( A q2 + A2q22 + A3q32 ) , 8 1 1
(18.3.41)
allowing thus to obtain Lagrange’s equations. We decompose the given force F along the tangents to the curves C 1 ,C 2 ,C 3 , hence let be F = F1 + F2 + F3 ; the corresponding virtual work will be F ⋅ δr = Qi δqi = Fi δsi . Taking into account (18.3.40), it results Qi =
1 F 2 i
Ai ( ! ) , i = 1, 2, 3 .
(18.3.42)
In case of a plane motion, we can use elliptic co-ordinates in the plane Ox1x 2 , the corresponding formulae being obtained by particularization (we make x 3 = 0, q 3 = 0 ) from the above ones. The homofocal conics will be an ellipse and a hyperbola (Fig. 18.10). If the given forces are conservative or quasi-conservative, then we can use the results in Sect. 18.1.1.3 concerning natural systems. Lagrange’s equations can be written also in the vector form
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
102
d ⎛ ∂T ′ ⎞ ∂T ′ = F, ⎜ ⎟− ∂r dt ⎝ ∂v ⎠
(18.3.43)
with respect to a non-inertial frame of reference R (the generalized co-ordinates are taken with respect to this frame); in this case, the kinetic energy is given by T ′ = (m / 2)( vO′ + v + ω + r )2 . We notice that vO′2 is a known function of time and can be expressed as the total derivative with respect to time of another function; hence, this term can be omitted from calculation (Lagrange’s function – inclusive the kinetic energy – is determined excepting the total derivative with respect to time of an arbitrary function). On the other hand, we notice that m vO′ ⋅ ( v + ω × r ) = m vO′ ⋅
dr ⎡ d ( vO′ ⋅ r ) ⎤ = m⎢ − aO′ ⋅ r ⎥ ; t dt d ⎣ ⎦
Fig. 18.10 Elliptic co-ordinates in E 2
the total derivative with respect to time can be, as well, neglected. Thus, we can use the conventional kinetic energy 1 1 T = m v2 + m v ⋅ ( ω × r ) − m aO′ ⋅ r . 2 2
(18.3.44)
We can calculate dT = m ( v + ω × r ) ⋅ dv − m [ aO′ + ω × v + ω × ( ω × r ) ] ⋅ dr ,
wherefrom ∂T ∂T = m ( v + ω × r ), = − m [ aO′ + ω × v + ω × ( ω × r ) ] . ∂v ∂r
(18.3.44')
The equation (18.3.43) leads thus to the equation of motion m
dv = F − m [ aO′ + ω × r + ω × ( ω × r ) ] − 2m ω × v , dt
(18.3.45)
Lagrangian Mechanics
103
written with respect to the non-inertial frame of reference R ; the transportation force and the Coriolis force are thus put in evidence (see Sect. 10.2.1.1 too)
18.3.2.2 Case of a Particular Conservative Force We consider the motion of a particle P acted upon by a conservative force which derives from the simple potential
U ( r , θ , ϕ ) = f (r ) +
g (θ ) h (ϕ ) + 2 , r2 r sin2 θ
(18.3.46)
expressed in spherical co-ordinates. Noting that Qr = ∂U / ∂r , Qθ = ∂U / ∂θ and Qϕ = ∂U / ∂ϕ , we obtain Lagrange’s equations in the form h (ϕ ) ⎤ ⎡ ⎢⎣ g ( θ ) + r 2 sin2 θ ⎥⎦ , d 2 ⎡ sin 2 θ ⎤ , 2 ( r 2 θ ) − r 2 sin 2 θϕ 2 = g ′( θ ) − h (ϕ ) 2 dt mr 2 ⎣⎢ r sin 4 θ ⎦⎥ h ′(ϕ ) d 2 ( r sin2 θϕ ) = 2 2 , dt mr sin θ
r − r ( θ2 + sin2 θϕ 2
1
) = m f ′(r ) −
2 mr 3
(18.3.47)
where we have denoted by “prime” the derivative of the functions f , g and h with respect to the corresponding variables. The third equation (18.3.47) can be written also in the form mr 2 sin2 θϕ ( r 2 sin2 θϕ ) =
m d ( r 4 sin 4 θϕ 2 2
) = h ′(ϕ )ϕ dt
= h ′(ϕ )dϕ = dh (ϕ ),
so that we obtain the first integral r 4 sin 4 θϕ 2 =
2 [ h (ϕ ) + C 1 ] , m
(18.3.48)
where C 1 is an integration constant; as well, the second equation (18.3.47) reads 2C 1 sin 2 θ d 1 sin 2 θ ⎡ 4 2 2 ⎡ ( r 2 θ ) − g ′( θ ) ⎤ = 2 r sin 4 θϕ 2 − h (ϕ ) ⎤ = , m ⎦⎥ mr 2 sin 4 θ ⎣⎢ dt ⎦⎥ r sin 4 θ ⎣⎢ mr 2
where we took into account the first integral previously found. Multiplying by r 2 θ , one obtains 2r 2 θ d ( r 2 θ ) = d ( r 4 θ2 =
) = m ⎡⎢⎣ g ′( θ )θ dt + 2C 1 2
(
)
2 ⎡ 1 ⎤, g (θ ) − C1 d m ⎢⎣ sin2 θ ⎦⎥
sin θ cos θ ⎤ θ dt ⎥⎦ sin 4 θ
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
104 resulting the first integral r 4 θ2 =
2 m
⎡ g (θ ) + C1 + C 2 ⎢⎣ sin2 θ
⎤, ⎥⎦
(18.3.48')
where C 2 is a new integration constant. Eliminating the terms r θ2 and r sin2 θϕ 2 between the first equation (18.3.47) and the first integrals (18.3.48), (18.3.48'), we obtain r − 2
C2 1 = f ′(r ) . 3 m mr
Multiplying by rdt and integrating, we get the third first integral r 2 + 2
C2 1 = [ 2 f (r ) + C 3 ] , m mr 2
(18.3.48'')
where C 3 is a new integration constant. As a matter of fact, one can obtain this result starting from the first integral of the mechanical energy and taking into account the first integrals previously obtained. The first integral (18.3.48'') contains only one space variable, so that C dr 1 ⎡ 2 f (r ) − 2 22 + C 3 ⎤ , = ± f1 (r ), f1 (r ) = dt m ⎣⎢ ⎦⎥ r
(18.3.49)
wherefrom, by a quadrature, one gets t as a functions of r and then r = r (t ) , introducing the fourth integral constant C 4 . Analogously, the first integral (18.3.48') leads to
r
2
dr dθ 2 = ± , g1 ( θ ) = m f1 (r ) g1 ( θ )
⎡ g (θ ) − C1 + C ⎤ . 2 ⎥ ⎢⎣ ⎦ sin2 θ
(18.3.49')
By two quadratures, we obtain θ = θ (r ) and then θ = θ (t ) , a new integration constant C 5 being introduced. Finally, the first integral (18.3.48) allows to write dϕ dθ 2 = ± 2 , h1 (ϕ ) = [ h (ϕ ) + C 1 ] , m h1 (ϕ ) sin θ g1 ( θ )
(18.3.49'')
where we have used the previous result; hence, one obtains ϕ = ϕ ( θ ) and then one gets ϕ = ϕ (t ) , appearing the integration constant C 6 . The integration constants C k , k = 1, 2,..., 6 , are then determined by means of the initial conditions. The case of loading of a particle P , considered above, is useful in many particular cases of great interest.
Lagrangian Mechanics
105
18.3.2.3 Problem of Two Particles Let be two particles P1 and P2 of masses m1 and m2 , m1 ≥ m2 , respectively; the mass centre O is on the segment of a line P1P2 , so that m1r1 = m2 r2 , r1 = OP 1 , r2 = OP 2 , r1 ≤ r2 (Fig. 18.11). In spherical co-ordinates, we have P1 (r1 , θ , ϕ ) , P2 (r2 , π − θ , π + ϕ ) , and the kinetic energy can be expressed in the form
Fig. 18.11 Problem of two particles
T =
m1 2 m r1 + r12 θ2 + r12 sin2 θϕ 2 ) + 2 ( r22 + r22 θ2 + r22 sin2 θϕ 2 ) . ( 2 2
We introduce the notations m1r12 + m2 r22 = mr 2 , m1r12 + m2 r22 = mr 2 , with
r1 + r2 = r ,
(18.3.50)
where r = P1P2 ; we get r1 =
m2 m1 r , r2 = r, m1 + m2 m1 + m2
so that m1r12 + m2 r22 =
m1m2 2 m1m2 2 r , m1r12 + m2 r22 = r . m1 + m2 m1 + m2
Comparing with the notations which have been introduced, we must have 1 1 1 = + . m m1 m2
(18.3.50')
Thus, the motion of relation about the mass centre O is specified by the generalized coordinates q1 = r , q2 = θ , q 3 = ϕ , corresponding to three degrees of freedom. The kinetic energy will be thus given by
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
106 T =
1 m ( r 2 + r 2 θ2 + r 2 sin2 θϕ 2 ) . 2
(18.3.51)
Assuming that the two particles are acted upon only by forces of Newtonian attraction, the potential function being U = f
m1m2 , r
(18.3.51')
we obtain the case considered in the preceding section, with f (r ) = fm1m2 / r and g ( θ ) = h (ϕ ) = 0 ; the problem is thus reduced to quadratures.
18.3.2.4 Problem of Two Centres Let be a particle subjected to the attraction of two fixed centres C 1 and C 2 , in an inverse proportion to the squares of the distances rk = PC k , k = 1, 2 , to these centres; the potential of the corresponding forces is U =
k1 k2 + , r1 r2
(18.3.52)
where k1 , k2 > 0 are positive constants. We can study this problem in spherical coordinates too, by means of the results obtained in Sect. 18.3.2.2. But we can study the problem also with the aid of the elliptical co-ordinates introduced in Sect. 18.3.2.1. If, in this order of ideas, we denote q1 = λ =
1 1 ( r1 + r2 ) , q2 = μ = ( r1 − r2 ) , 2 2
(18.3.53)
then the curves λ = const represent ellipses, the semi-major axes of which are equal to λ , and the curves μ = const are hyperbolae the semi-major axes of which are equal to μ ; these curves are homofocal (they have common foci C 1 and C 2 ) and orthogonal one to the other. Observing that min(r1 + r2 ) = 2c , max r1 − r2 = 2c , 2c = C 1C 2 , it results the relation of condition λ ≥ c ≥ μ ; in this case, the equations of the families of ellipses and hyperbolae will be
x12 x2 x2 x2 + 2 2 2 = 1, 12 + 2 2 2 = 1 . 2 λ λ −c μ c −μ
(18.3.54)
By logarithmic differentiation, we can calculate the kinetic energy in the form
T =
m 2 ( x + x22 2 1
)=
μ 2 m 2 ⎛ λ 2 λ − μ2 ) ⎜ 2 + ( 2 2 c 2 − μ2 ⎝λ −c
Taking into account (18.3.53), we obtain the potential
⎞ ⎟. ⎠
(18.3.55)
Lagrangian Mechanics
U =
107
1 [ ( k1 + k2 ) λ − ( k1 − k2 ) μ ] , λ 2 − μ2
(18.3.55')
observing thus that we have a system of Liouville type (see Sect. 18.3.1.2). Because u1 (q1 ) = λ2 , u2 (q2 ) = − μ2 , U 1 (q1 ) = (k1 + k2 )λ , U 2 (q2 ) = (k1 − k2 ) μ, m m , V2 (q2 ) = − 2 , 2 λ −c μ − c2 dμ dλ dW1 = m , dW2 = m , 2 2 2 c − μ2 λ −c u = λ2 − μ2 , α1 = α, α2 = − α, V1 (q1 ) =
2
the system of equations (18.3.7) leads to
∫
dμ = ψ(μ)
2 β , m 1
dλ − μ2 ϕ (λ ) ∫
dμ = ψ(μ )
2 (t + β2 ), m
dλ − ϕ (λ )
∫ ∫λ
2
(18.3.56)
with the notations ϕ (λ ) = (λ 2 − c 2 )[ hλ 2 + (k1 + k2 )λ + α ], ψ ( μ ) = ( μ2 − c 2 )[ h μ2 + (k1 − k2 )μ + α ],
(18.3.56')
where h is the constant of mechanical energy, while α, β1 and β2 are three other integration constants. We denote by λ1 , λ2 and μ1 , μ2 pairs of two simple roots, differing from ±c , of the equations ϕ (λ ) = 0 and ψ ( μ ) = 0 , respectively, and let be the integrals ω11 =
λ2
∫λ
1
ω21 =
λ2
∫λ
1
λ
2
dλ , ω12 = ϕ (λ ) dλ , ω22 = ϕ (λ )
dμ , ψ(μ) μ2 2 dμ ∫μ1 μ ψ ( μ ) . μ2
∫μ
1
(18.3.57)
We introduce also the quantities ν1 and ν2 by relation ω11 ν1 + ω12 ν2 = πβ1 , ω21ν1 + ω22 ν2 = π (t + β2 ) .
(18.3.58)
The relations (18.3.56) define thus λ and μ as double periodical (elliptic) functions of β1 and t + β2 or (with the relations (18.3.58)) of ν1 and ν2 . If a relation of the form
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
108
n1 ω11 + n2 ω12 = 0, n1 , n2 ∈ ` , takes place, hence if ω11 and ω12
are commensurable
quantities, then the motion is strictly periodic with the period 2T = 2(n1 ω21 + n2 ω22 ) . If the roots λ1 , λ2 and μ1 , μ2 , respectively, are double, then we have so called motions of libration (called periodical conditioned motions too), important in the classical quantum theory.
18.3.2.5 Motion of an Electrized Particle in an Electromagnetic Field Let be an electrized particle P of electric charge q (eventually, an electron), which is in motion with the velocity v in an electromagnetic field { E, B } , where E is the intensity of the electric field and B is the magnetic induction (see Sect. 18.1.1.4). Lorentz’s generalized force (18.1.36) derives from the generalized quasi-potential (18.2.37'). We obtain thus Lagrange’s kinetic potential 1 2
L = m v2 + q ( A ⋅ v − A0 ) ,
(18.3.59)
where A = A ( x1 , x 2 , x 3 ; t ) is the vector magnetic quasi-potential, while the scalar one is A0 = A0 (x1 , x 2 , x 3 ; t ) . If one observes that dL / dvi = mvi + qAi , i = 1, 2, 3 , then Lagrange’s equations (18.3.38) read d ( mvi + qAi ) = q ( v j Aj ,i − A0,i dt
) = 0, i
= 1, 2, 3 .
We assume that the velocities do not depend on the point but only on the time. Calculating the total derivative dAi / dt = ( ∂Ai / ∂x j )v j + Ai , Lagrange’s equations become m
dvi = q ⎡⎣ ( Aj ,i − Ai , j ) v j − Ai − A0,i ⎤⎦ , i = 1, 2, 3 . dt
(18.3.60)
The relations (18.1.36') and (18.1.36'') can be scalarly written in the form Bi =∈ijk Ak , j , Ei = −( Ai + A0,i ), i = 1, 2, 3 .
It is seen that the equations (18.3.60) represent, in fact, the projections on the three axes of co-ordinates of Newton’s equation of motion m
dv = q(E + v × B) , dt
(18.3.60')
where we have Lorentz’s generalized force (18.1.36); for this, one takes into account the above relations and the relation ( v × B )i =∈ijk v j Bk =∈ijk v j ∈klm Am ,l
= ( δil δjm − δim δjl ) v j Am ,l = ( Aj ,i − Ai , j ) v j .
Lagrangian Mechanics
109
To take into account the relativistic aspect of the problem, one must introduce the mass m = m0 1 − (v / c )2 , where m0 is the mass at rest, while c is the velocity of propagation of light in vacuum.
18.3.2.6 Motion of the Rigid Solid A free rigid solid S has six degrees of freedom and we can use, e.g., the ′ , i = 1, 2, 3 , q 4 = ψ , q 5 = θ , q 6 = ϕ , where xOi ′ generalized co-ordinates qi = xOi are the co-ordinates of a point O of it with respect to an inertial frame of reference R ′ , while ψ , θ and ϕ are Euler’s angles, which specify the rotation about the point O . If a certain point P0 of the solid is compelled to slide (without friction) on a given surface, then it will have only two degrees of freedom, appearing thus a holonomic constraint relation; analogously, if the point P0 is compelled to stay on a given curve, then there result two holonomic constraint relations. Especially, if to the point P0 is imposed a given motion, then the rigid solid is subjected to three holonomic constraints; in particular, the point P0 (taken – in this case – as a pole O of a non-inertial frame R ) can be fixed. In each of these cases, one searches convenient generalized coordinates, by eliminating the respective constraints; thus, in case of a rigid solid with a fixed point, we can choose as generalized co-ordinates Euler’s angles, the kinetic energy being of the form (15.1.13), where I 1 , I 2 , I 3 are the principal moments of inertia with respect to the fixed point. We notice that ψ is a hidden co-ordinate, so that d ⎛ ∂T ′ ⎞ = Qψ . dt ⎜⎝ ∂ψ ⎟⎠
(18.3.61)
For instance, in case of the motion of a heavy homogenous rigid solid of revolution of mass M , which slides frictionless on a fixed horizontal plane (see Sect. 17.1.2.4), the kinetic energy reads T′ =
1 {M ( ρ1′2 + ρ 2′2 ) + [ Mf ′2 ( θ ) + J ] θ2 + J ψ 2 sin2 θ + I 3 (ϕ + ψ cos θ )}, 2 (18.3.62)
where ρ1′ , ρ2′ and ρ3′ = f ( θ ) are the co-ordinates of the mass centre C with respect to the inertial frame of reference R ′ and where J = I 1 = I 2 ; the potential of its weight is U = − Mgf ( θ ) .
(18.3.62')
We can use thus the generalized co-ordinates q1 = ρ1′ , q2 = ρ2′ , q 3 = ϕ, q 4 = ψ, q 5 = θ . The first four equations of Lagrange are written in the form ( ρ1′ , ρ2′ , ψ and ϕ are hidden and ignorable co-ordinates) d ⎛ ∂T ′ ⎞ d ⎛ ∂T ′ ⎞ d ∂T ′ ⎞ d ⎛ ∂T ′ ⎞ = 0, = 0, ⎜⎛ = 0, ⎜ = 0, ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ dt ⎝ ∂ρ1′ ⎠ dt ⎝ ∂ρ 2′ ⎠ dt ⎝ ∂ϕ ⎠ dt ⎝ ∂ψ ⎟⎠
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
110 being thus led to the first integrals
ρ1′ = νC′01 , ρ 2′ = νC′02 , ϕ + ψ cos θ = ω30 ,
J ψ sin2 θ + I 3 (ϕ + ψ cos θ ) cos θ = KC′ 3 ,
(18.3.63)
where we have used the notations in Sect. 17.1.2.4. Instead of the fifth equation of Lagrange, we can use the first integral of mechanical energy, the problem being thus entirely formulated. An important case is that of the rigid solid for which three non-collinear points have a given motion in a fixed (or mobile) plane; the problem is thus reduced to the motion of a mechanical system in a plane (or of a plane solid rigid), which has only three degrees of freedom, corresponding to the translation of a point (two degrees of freedom) and to the rotation about this point (one degrees of freedom). In the case of a system of rigid solids, one must keep in mind the connections between them. E.g., a hinge between two rigid solids involves the introduction of three holonomic constraints (we can imagine a free rigid solid, the second one having a point with a given motion).
18.3.2.7 Plane Motion of a Rigid Straight Bar Let be a rigid straight bar AB which moves frictionless in the plane O ′x1′x 2′ , being acted upon by forces in direct proportion to the mass and to the distance to the O ′x1′ -axis (we have chosen a system of particular forces, to fix the ideas). The position of the bar is specified by the co-ordinates ρ1′ and ρ2′ of the mass centre C and by the angle θ made with the fixed axis O ′x1′ (Fig. 18.12); we can thus choose the generalized co-ordinates q1 = ρ1′ , q2 = ρ2′ , q 3 = θ .
Fig. 18.12 Plane motion of a straight rigid bar
Using Koenig’s theorem, we can write the kinetic energy in the form T′ =
1 ⎡ M ( ρ1′2 + ρ 2′2 ) + I θ2 ⎦⎤ , 2⎣
(18.3.64)
where M is the mass of the bar and I is its moment of inertia with respect to the centre of mass C . Let us consider a bar element dx along the Cx -axis, which is attracted by the O ′x1′ -axis by the force − k μ ( ρ2′ + x sin θ )dx , k = const , where μ is the linear
Lagrangian Mechanics
111
density of the bar; this force −(k μ / 2)( ρ2′ + sin θ )2 dx . Noting that B
∫ A μ dx
= M,
B
∫A μx dx
derives
= 0,
B
∫A μx
2
from
the
simple
potential
dx = I ,
we get U = −
2 k B k ′ + ( sin ) ρ x θ μ dx = − ( M ρ2′2 + I sin2 θ ) . 2 2 ∫A 2
(18.3.64')
One obtains, easily, k Q1 = 0, Q2 = − kM ρ2′ , Q3 = − I sin 2 θ . 2
(18.3.64'')
We are thus led to Lagrange’s equations
ρ1′ = 0, ρ2′ = − k ρ2′ , 2 θ = − k sin 2 θ .
(18.3.65)
The mass centre C describes a sinusoid along the O ′x1′ -axis, its projection on this axis having a uniform motion; the bar oscillates about the O ′x1′ -axis with a frequency equal (in case of small oscillations with sin θ ≅ θ , hence sin 2 θ ≅ 2 θ ) to the frequency of the oscillations of the projection of the centre C on the O ′x 2′ -axis.
18.3.2.8 Double Pendulum We return to the double pendulum, considered in Sect. 17.1.1.2. This mechanical system has two degrees of freedom and we can choose as generalized co-ordinates the angles made by O1C 1 and O2C 2 , respectively, with the descendent vertical ( q1 = θ1 , q2 = θ2 ); we have denoted by O1 the suspension pole of the solid S1 with the mass centre C 1 and by O2 the hinge between this solid and the solid S2 , with the mass centre C 2 (see Fig. 17.1, a too). The kinetic energy of the mechanical system S ≡ {S1 , S2 } is given by T′ =
{
}
2 2 1 2 1 1 I θ + M ⎡ ρ ′(2 ) ⎤ + ⎡⎣ ρ2′(2 ) ⎤⎦ + I 2 θ22 , 2 1 1 2 2 ⎣ 1 ⎦ 2
(18.3.66)
where I 1 is the moment of inertia of the rigid solid S1 with respect to the O ′x1′ -axis, while I 2 is the moment of inertia of the rigid solid S2 , of mass M 2 , with respect to (2 ) (2 ) the axis which passes through the centre C 2 of co-ordinates ρ1′ , ρ2′ and is parallel
to the axis O1′x 3′ . We notice that ρ1′
(2 )
we obtain thus
= l cos θ1 + l2 cos θ2 , ρ2′
(2 )
= l sin θ1 + l2 sin θ2 ;
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
112 T′ =
1 1 ( I + M 2l 2 ) θ12 + 2 ( I 2 + M 2l22 ) θ22 + M 2ll2 θ1θ2 cos( θ2 − θ1 ) . 2 1
(18.3.66')
As well, the potential of the weight forces is U = M1gl1 cos θ1 + M 2 g ( l cos θ1 + l2 cos θ2 ) .
(18.3.67)
Lagrange’s equations read
( I1
+ M 2l 2 ) θ1 + M 2ll2 ⎡⎣ cos ( θ2 − θ1 ) θ2 − sin ( θ2 − θ1 ) θ22 ⎤⎦ = − ( M 1l1 + M 2l ) g sin θ1 ,
( I2
+ M 2l22 ) θ2 + M 2ll2 ⎡⎣ cos ( θ2 − θ1 ) θ1 + sin ( θ2 − θ1 ) θ12 ⎤⎦
(18.3.68)
= − M 2l2 g sin θ2 .
We find thus again (17.1.4), which have been studied and integrated by Bradistilov and by Anca Zlătescu. The small oscillations of the double pendulum have been considered in Sect. 17.1.1.2.
18.3.2.9 Sympathetic Pendulums The sympathetic pendulum has been considered directly with the aid of Newton’s equations in Sect. 17.1.1.3. We take again the problem in case of the two physical pendulums of masses M 1 and M 2 , the gravity forces being applied at the mass centres C 1 and C 2 , respectively; we denote O1C 1 = l1 , O2C 2 = l2 , where O1 and O2 are the
poles through which pass the axes of suspension. The two pendulums are connected by an elastic spring Q1Q2 , so that the point Q1 is on the straight line O1C 1 , while the point Q2 is on the straight line O2C 2 , with O1Q1 = O2Q2 = a (Fig. 18.13). The spring Q1Q2 is characterized by the elastic constant k , so that the magnitude of the force
which arises in the spring is given by k | O1O2 − Q1Q2 | , where k = const (unlike the case considered in Sect. 17.1.1.3, where the elastic constant depends on the mass of the physical pendulum upon which acts the spring, the position of the points Q1 and Q2 playing no one rôle). The position of this mechanical system is specified by the generalized co-ordinates q1 = θ1 and q2 = θ2 , these ones being the angles made by O1C 1 and O2C 2 , respectively, with the vertical line. The kinetic energy is given by T =
1 ( I θ2 + I 2 θ22 ) , 2 1 1
(18.3.69)
where I 1 and I 2 are the moments of inertia of each pendulum with respect to the corresponding axis of suspension. The potential U is expressed in the form U = g (M 1l1 cos θ1 + M 2l2 cos θ2 ) −
k (O O − Q1Q2 2 1 2
)2 .
Lagrangian Mechanics
113
But Q1Q22 = [O1O2 + a ( sin θ2 − sin θ1 ) ] + a 2 (cos θ2 − cos θ1 )2 2
= O1O22 + 2aO1O2 ( sin θ2 − sin θ1 ) + 2a 2 [ 1 − cos ( θ2 − θ1 ) ] .
In the case of small oscillations, we have sin θ1 ≅ θ1 , sin θ2 ≅ θ2 , cos θ1 ≅ 1 − θ12 / 2 , cos θ2 ≅ 1 − θ22 / 2 , so that
Q1Q22 + 2aO1O2 ( θ2 − θ1 ) + a 2 ( θ2 − θ1 )2 = [O1O2 + a ( θ2 − θ1 ) ] . 2
Hence, in case of small oscillations, it results U = g ( M1l1 + M 2l2 ) − −
1 ( M1gl1 + ka 2 ) θ12 2
1 ( M 2 gl2 + ka 2 ) θ22 + ka 2 θ1θ2 . 2
(18.3.69')
Fig. 18.13 Sympathetic pendulums
Lagrange’s equations read ( L = T + U ) k ∂ ( O O − Q1Q2 )2 = 0, 2 ∂θ1 1 2 k ∂ 2 I 2 θ2 + M 2 gl2 sin θ2 + O1O2 − Q1Q2 ) = 0 . ( 2 ∂θ2 I 1 θ1 + M 1gl1 sin θ1 +
(18.3.70)
In case of small oscillations, we get I 1 θ1 + M 1gl1 θ1 + ka 2 ( θ1 − θ2 ) = 0, I 2 θ2 + M 2 gl2 θ2 + ka 2 ( θ1 − θ2 ) = 0 .
(18.3.70')
In the particular case of two identical physical pendulums ( M 1 = M 2 = M , l1 = l2 = l , I 1 = I 2 = I ), we may write
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
114
∂2 ∂2 2 θ θ ω θ θ 0, + + + = ( ) ( ) ( θ1 − θ2 ) + ω 2 ( θ1 − θ2 ) = 0 , 0 1 2 1 2 ∂t 2 ∂t 2
where we have introduced the pulsations ( l ′ is the length of the synchronous mechanical pendulum) ω02 =
Mgl g 1 = , ω 2 = ( Mgl + 2ka 2 I l′ 2
) = ω02
+
2ka 2 . I
(18.3.71)
Hence, we obtain 1 [ ( θ 0 + θ20 ) cos ω0t + ( θ10 − θ20 ) cos ωt ] 2 1 1 1 0 1 θ1 + θ20 ) sin ω0t + ( θ10 − θ20 ) sin ωt ⎤⎥ . + ⎡⎢ ( 2 ⎣ ω0 ω ⎦ 1 θ2 (t ) = [ ( θ10 + θ20 ) cos ω0t − ( θ10 − θ20 ) cos ωt ] 2 1 1 0 1 − ⎡⎢ ( θ + θ20 ) sin ω0t − ω ( θ10 − θ20 ) sin ωt ⎤⎥ , 2 ⎣ ω0 1 ⎦ θ1 (t ) =
(18.3.72)
where θk0 = θk (0) , θk0 = θk (0), k = 1, 2 , corresponding to the initial moment t = 0 . If θ10 = θ0 , θ20 = 0, θ10 = θ20 = 0 , then we get θ0 (ω ( cos ω0t + cos ωt ) = θ0 cos 0 2 θ (ω θ2 (t ) = 0 ( cos ω0t − cos ωt ) = θ0 sin 0 2
θ1 (t ) =
− ω )t (ω cos 0 2 − ω )t (ω sin 0 2
+ ω )t , 2 + ω )t , 2
(18.3.72')
These results correspond to those in Sect. 17.1.1.3, excepting to the different definition of the elastic constant k .
Chapter 19 Hamiltonian Mechanics The motion of the representative point P ∈ Λs is governed by a system of s differential equations of second order (Lagrange’s equations) in Lagrangian mechanics. In 1834, W. R. Hamilton had the idea to use a representative space with 2s dimensions, the motion of a representative point in this space being specified by a system of 2s linear differential equations (Hamilton’s equations); The new formulation (in the frame of Hamiltonian mechanics) is equivalent to the Lagrangian formulation for discrete mechanical systems with holonomic, ideal constraints, being put a restrictive condition: these systems must be natural (as a matter of fact, the considered systems must admit a Lagrangian). These equations have remarkable analytical properties, leading to a rigorous and elegant mathematical formulation of the quantic model of mechanics. Especially, the Hamilton– Jacobi partial differential equation allows to pass from the matric quantum mechanics to the undulatory mechanics. In this order of ideas, after a study of Hamilton’s equations, we will consider in detail the Hamilton–Jacobi method (Arnold, V.I., 1976; Dobronravov, V.V., 1976; Goldstein, H., 1956; Lurie, A.I., 2002; Routh, E.J., 1892, 1898; Ter Haar, D., 1964).
19.1 Hamilton’s Equations After establishing some results with a general character, including Hamilton’s equations, we make a study of several expressions which play a special rôle: Lagrange’s brackets and Poisson’s brackets; these results will be illustrated by some applications to particular mechanical systems.
19.1.1 General Results To pass from the space of configurations to the phase space, one introduces the canonical co-ordinates and one obtains Hamilton’s canonical equations; after putting in evidence some properties of the latter ones, one considers Routh’s equations, as well as other equivalent equations. 19.1.1.1 Canonical Co-ordinates. Phase Space. Associate Expressions To study a natural discrete mechanical system S of n particles, subjected to holonomic ideal constraints, we consider Lagrange’s equations (18.2.38) (where we have introduced the kinetic potential L = T + U ), which describe the motion of the representative point P (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ) in the space of considerations Λs . To pass from this P.P. Teodorescu, Mechanical Systems, Classical Models, © Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2009
115
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
116
system of equations of second order to a system of equations of first order, one has an infinity of possibilities to proceed (e.g., as in Sect. 18.2.3.8). Thus, in Sect. 18.2.3.6 there have been introduced the generalized momenta by means of relations (18.2.80). Taking into account (18.2.81) and (18.2.15), (18.2.15'), and (18.2.15''), we can write p j = g jk qk + g j + U j , j = 1, 2,..., s .
(19.1.1)
Introducing the normalized algebraic complement g jk of the element g jk of the determinant g = det[ g jk ] ≠ 0 , which verify the relations (18.2.44), we obtain, easily, q j = g jk pk − g jk (gk + U k ), j = 1, 2,..., s .
(19.1.1')
Let Λ2′s be the space of the points P (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , q1 , q2 ,..., qs ) ; let us introduce also the representative space Γ 2s of the representative points P (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., ps ) . We notice that the formulae (19.1.1), (19.1.1') establish a one-to-one correspondence between the two spaces. A state of the considered discrete system S is represented, as we have shown in the preceding chapter, by a representative point in the space Λs , hence by a point ′ , and this one is represented, in a one-to-one mode, by a representative in the space Λ2s point in the space Γ 2s . The representative space Γ 2s is called the phase space (or the Gibbs’s space). The co-ordinates q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., ps of the corresponding representative point P (the set of generalized co-ordinates and the set of generalized momenta) are called canonical co-ordinates (Hamiltonian co-ordinates); the generalized momenta p j are coordinates conjugate to the generalized co-ordinates q j . We replace thus the study of the motion of the mechanical system S in E 3 by the study of the motion of the representative point P in the space Γ 2s . Having to do only with holonomic constraints, which are eliminated by passing to generalized co-ordinates, the representative point P ∈ Γ 2s is a free point. To study the motion of the point P , we will express the quantities of energetical nature used in the space Λs by means of the canonical co-ordinates in the space Γ 2s ; by passing to canonical co-ordinates, a function F (q j , q j ; t ) becomes a new function F (q j , p j ; t ) , called the associate expression of the function F , so that F (q j , q j ; t ) = F (q j , p j ; t ) . The quantities (18.2.15'), (18.2.15'') read 1 1 1 g jk q j qk = g jk p j pk − g jk (g j + U j ) pk + g jk (g j + U j )(gk + U k ), 2 2 2 g j q j = g jk g j pk − g jk g j ( gk + U k ),
where we took into account the relations (18.2.44). The kinetic energy will take the form
Hamiltonian Mechanics
117 T = T2 + T1 + T0 ,
(19.1.2)
where we have put in evidence a quadratic form, a linear form and a constant with respect to the generalized momenta, given by (we notice that Tk ≠ Tk , k = 0,1, 2 ) T2 =
1 jk 1 g p j pk , T1 = − g jkU j pk , T0 = − g jk (g j gk − U jU k ) + g 0 . 2 2
(19.1.2')
We get thus the associate expression of the kinetic energy by means of the canonical coordinates. If the generalized forces derive from a simple quasi-potential, then we have U j = 0, j = 1, 2,..., s , so that T1 = 0 ; as well, if the mechanical system is scleronomic, then it results g j = 0, j = 1,2,..., s , and g 0 = 0 , so that T0 = (1/ 2)g jkU jU k . If both conditions are fulfilled (the mechanical system is scleronomic and the generalized forces derive from a simple quasi-potential), then we obtain T1 = T0 = 0 , so that T = T2 . In this case, the relations (19.1.1) read p j = g jk qk ,
(19.1.1'')
the generalized momenta vanishing together with the generalized velocities. This property does no more take place if the mentioned conditions are not fulfilled. After a partial differentiation of (18.2.15) with respect to q j , we multiply by q j and sum for all the values of the index j ; it results q j
∂T2 ∂T1 ∂T0 ∂T = q j + q j + q j = 2T2 + T1 , ∂q j ∂q j ∂q j ∂q j
where we used Euler’s theorem concerning the homogeneous functions. Adding T1 + 2T0 to both members of this relation and using the relation (18.2.81) and the notations (18.2.15''), (18.2.15'''), we may write T =
1 1 q p + (g − U j )q j + g 0 , 2 j j 2 j
(19.1.3)
obtaining thus a new remarkable expression for the kinetic energy. By an analogous calculation, the associate expression of the generalized quasipotential (18.2.22) will be of the form
U = U 1 + U 0 , U 1 = g jk pk , U 0 = − g jkU j (gk + U k ) + U 0 ,
(19.1.4)
hence a sum of a linear form and a constant with respect to the generalized momenta. In case of a simple quasi-potential (U j = 0 ), we have U = U 0 = U 0 . Observing that T1 + U 1 = 0 , the associate expression of the kinetic potential (18.2.34) is given by
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
118
1 L = L2 + L0 , L2 = T2 , L0 = − g jk (g j + U j )(gk + U k ) + g 0 + U 0 , 2
(19.1.5)
hence it will be a sum a quadratic form and a constant with respect to the generalized momenta. In case of a scleronomic mechanical system and of forces which derive from a simple quasi-potential we have L0 = U 0 , while L2 is a positive definite form in the generalized momenta. We notice that one can make the transformation (18.2.80) in case of a non-natural mechanical system too, if the condition (18.2.34''') is fulfilled. Indeed, in this case the Jacobian of the functions ∂L ∂q j is the Hessian of the kinetic potential; thus, the theorem of implicit functions allows to calculate q j = q j (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., ps ; t ) ,
j = 1,2,..., s . Obviously, these relations are linear with respect to the generalized momenta, so that the most important results previously obtained remain valid. 19.1.1.2 Donkin’s Theorem. Legendre’s Transformation Let be a function X = X (x1 , x 2 ,..., xs ) of class C 2 , for which the Hessian is non-zero
⎡ ∂2 X ⎤ det ⎢ ⎥ ≠ 0. ⎣ ∂x j ∂x k ⎦
(19.1.6)
Let us consider a transformation of variables generated by the function X in the form yj =
∂X , j = 1, 2,..., s . ∂x j
(19.1.7)
We can state Theorem 19.1.1 (Donkin). A transformation (19.1.7) for which the condition (19.1.6) is fulfilled being given, there exists a transformation, inverse to this one, generated by a function Y = Y (y1 , y2 ,..., ys ) of class C 1 , by means of the relations xj =
∂Y , j = 1, 2,..., s . ∂y j
(19.1.7')
The two functions are linked by the relation (we assume that the variables x i are expressed with the aid of the variables y j ; as well, the function Y too) X + Y = x jyj .
(19.1.8)
If X = X ( x1 , x 2 ,..., xs ; α1 , α2 ,..., αm ) , where αk , k = 1, 2,..., m , are given parameters, then we have Y = Y (y1 , y2 ,..., ys ; α1 , α2 ,..., αm ) too, so that
Hamiltonian Mechanics
119 ∂Y ∂X =− , k = 1,2,..., m . ∂αk ∂αk
(19.1.9)
Indeed, the Hessian of the function X coincides with the Jacobian of the functions in the second member of the relations (19.1.7); on the basis of the condition (19.1.6), the theorem of implicit functions shows that, using the mentioned relations, we can obtain x j = x j (y1 , y2 ,..., ys ), j = 1, 2,..., s . Calculating the function Y from the relation (19.1.8) and expressing it by means of the variables y j , j = 1, 2,..., s , we obtain ∂x ∂Y ∂ ∂X ∂x k . = ( x y − X ) = k yk + x j − ∂y j ∂y j k k ∂y j ∂x k ∂y j
Taking into account the relations (19.1.7), we get the relations (19.2.7'), which are thus justified. If in the function X intervene also the parameters αj , j = 1, 2,..., m , then these ones intervene in the direct transformation (19.1.7) too; hence, we have to do with x j = x j (y1 , y2 ,..., ys ; α1 , α2 ,..., αm ) , j = 1, 2,..., s , as well as with Y = Y (y1 , y2 ,..., ys ; α1 , α2 ,..., αm ) . We can calculate ∂x ∂Y ∂ ∂X ∂x k ∂X ∂X , = − = − ( x y − X ) = k yk − ∂α j ∂α j k k ∂α j ∂x k ∂α j ∂α j ∂α j
where we took into account (19.1.7). The theorem stated by Donkin in 1854 is thus completely proved. The passing from the variables x j to the variables y j , considered above, is known as Legendre’s transformation. For instance, in the mathematical modelling of thermodynamics, where X = H is the enthalpy, −Y = G is Gibbs’s function of state, s = 1 , x1 = S is the entropy, while y1 = T is the absolute temperature, takes place the relation H − G = ST ,
(19.1.10)
the product ST being the bound energy; the relations ∂H ∂G = T, = −S ∂S ∂T
(19.1.10')
take place. 19.1.1.3 Canonical Equations We will use Donkin’s theorem and Legendre’s transformation to establish the equations of motion of the representative point P ∈ Γ 2s . We take thus X = L , x j = q j , y j = p j , α j = q j , j = 1, 2,..., s , as well as αm = t , m = s + 1 ; because of
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
120
the condition (18.2.34'''), the condition (19.1.6) is fulfilled. We introduce the function Y = H , called Hamilton’s function (Hamiltonian), in the form
H = p j q j − L .
(19.1.11)
If H = p j q j − L , then it results H = H (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., ps ; t ) . We may write pj =
∂L ∂H , , q = ∂q j j ∂p j
∂L ∂H ∂L ∂H , =− , = ∂q j ∂q j ∂t ∂t
(19.1.12) (19.1.12')
for j = 1,2,..., s . If in Lagrange’s equations (18.2.38) we take into account the first relations (19.1.12), then we can replace these relations by the equivalent system pj =
∂L ∂L . , p j = − ∂q j ∂q j
(19.1.13)
Using the first relations (19.1.12') and associating the last relations (19.1.12), there result the equations of motion (given by Hamilton in 1834) of the representative point P in the space Γ 2s in the normal form q j =
∂H ∂H , p = − , j = 1, 2,..., s . ∂p j j ∂q j
(19.1.14)
These equations are the canonical equations of Hamiltonian mechanics (Hamilton’s equations) (Hamilton, W.R., 1890). Using the relation of definition (19.1.11), we get ∂H ∂L ⎞ ∂qk ⎛ ∂L ⎞ ⎛ = − p j + ⎜ pk − ⎟ ∂q + ⎜ p j − ∂q ⎟ , ∂p j ∂ q ⎝ j j ⎠ k ⎠ ⎝ ∂ q ∂H ∂ L ⎛ ⎞ k . = q j + ⎜ pk − ∂p j ∂qk ⎟⎠ ∂p j ⎝
If the system (19.1.13) is verified, then one obtains Hamilton’s equations. On the other hand, if the canonical equations are verified, then the second relations obtained above lead to the first equations (19.1.13); indeed, one obtains a homogeneous system of linear algebraic equations for which the determinant of the coefficients det[ ∂qk / ∂p j ] is the inverse of the determinant det[ ∂p j / ∂qk ] , which is thus the Hessian (18,2,34'''), hence being non-zero (if L = T + U , then this determinant is equal to 1/ g ). Then, the first above relations lead to the last equations (19.1.13). We can thus state that Hamilton’s equations are equivalent to the equations (19.1.13), which – at their turn – are equivalent to Lagrange’s equations.
Hamiltonian Mechanics
121
We can calculate the first variation of the Lagrangian in the form δL =
∂L ∂L δq + δq = p j δq j + p j δq j , ∂q j j ∂q j j
(19.1.15)
which represents the sixth form of the basic equation; taking into account the operator relation (18.1.77), this relation takes the remarkable form δL =
d ( p δq ) , dt j j
(19.1.15')
in case of holonomic constraints. We can also write δ ( p j q j − L
) = q j δp j
− p j δq j .
For Hamilton’s function, we obtain, analogically, δΗ =
∂H ∂H δq + δp . ∂q j j ∂p j j
Using the relation of definition of Hamilton’s function and comparing these results, we find again the canonical equations (19.1.14). Hamilton’s equations form a system of 2s differential equations of first order in the unknown functions q j = q j (t ), p j = p j (t ), j = 1, 2,..., s . Taking into account the one-to-one link between the generalized velocities and the generalized momenta, we can put the initial conditions in the form
q j (t0 ) = q j0 , p j (t0 ) = p j0 .
(19.1.14')
Hence, we must know the position P0 of the representative point P at the initial moment. The number of the unknowns and of the equations became double, but their order diminished by a unity, which represents a great advantage from the point of view of computation; we remark also some properties of symmetry of the system of equations (19.1.14). We can write Hamilton’s equations in the matric form R = ZHR
(19.1.14'')
too, where R = [ q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., ps ]T , ∂H ∂H ∂H ∂H ∂H ∂H ⎤ T , ,..., , , ,..., HR = ⎡⎢ ∂qs ∂p1 ∂p2 ∂ps ⎥⎦ ⎣ ∂q1 ∂q 2
are column matrices, respectively, and Z is the matrix
(19.1.14''')
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
122
⎡ 0 I⎤ Z = ⎢ ⎥. ⎣ −I 0 ⎦
(19.1.14IV)
The matrices 0 and I are the null and the unit matrices, respectively, with s rows and s columns. If, in Donkin’s theorem, we take X = T , x j = q j , y j = p j , j = 1,2,..., s , so that the generalized momenta are given by p j = ∂T / ∂q j , j = 1,2,..., s , while the function Y = Φ is specified by Φ = p j q j − T ,
(19.1.16)
then we obtain Hamilton’s equations in the form q j =
∂Φ ∂Φ , p = − + Q j + Rj , j = 1,2,..., s , ∂p j j ∂q j
(19.1.16')
corresponding to a non-natural and non-holonomic mechanical system, hence to Lagrange’s equations (18.2.32). If Q j , j = 1, 2,..., s , is the non-conservative part of the generalized force, then Hamilton’s equations read q j =
∂H ∂H , p j = − + Q j + Rj , j = 1,2,..., s . ∂p j ∂q j
(19.1.16'')
In case of holonomic constraints ( Rj , j = 1,2,..., s ) and of quasi-conservative forces which derive from a simple potential ( Q j = 0, j = 1, 2,..., s ) we find again the canonical equations; in case of a generalized potential appears a supplementary term due to the modality in which the generalized momenta have bean introduced. The advantage to introduce these quantities by the relations (18.2.80) is thus put in evidence; as a matter of fact, we can thus consider the case of an arbitrary Lagrangian too. 19.1.1.4 General Theorems. First Integrals For the initial value problem (19.1.14), (19.1.14') one can state Theorem 19.1.2 (of existence and uniqueness; Cauchy–Lipschitz). If Hamilton’s function H is of class C 1 with respect to the space variables and of class C 0 with respect to time on the ( 2s + 1 )-dimensional interval D , specified by q j0 − Q j0 ≤ q j ≤ q j0 + Q j0 , p j0 − Pj0 ≤ p j ≤ p j0 + Pj0 , t0 − T0 ≤ t ≤ t0 + T0 , Q j0 , Pj0 ,T0 = const, j = 1,2,..., s ,
and defined in the space Cartesian product of the phase space (of canonical co-ordinates q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., ps ) by the time space (of co-ordinate t ), and if Lipschitz’s conditions
Hamiltonian Mechanics
123
∂ ∂ H (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., ps ; t ) − H (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., ps ; t ) ∂q j ∂q j μj s ⎡ μ 1 ⎤ ≤ ⎢⎣ τ λk qk − qk + λk pk − pk ⎥⎦ , T k∑ =1 ∂ ∂ H (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., ps ; t ) − H (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., ps ; t ) ∂p j ∂p j ≤
1 νjT
∑ ⎡⎢⎣ λk s
k =1
qk − qk +
τ ⎤ p − pk ⎥ , μλk k ⎦
hold for j = 1,2,..., s , where T > 0 is a time constant independent on q j , p j and t , the time constant τ and the constant μ of the nature of a mass are equal to unity, while λk , μj , ν j are constants equal to unity (dimensionless if the corresponding generalized co-ordinate is a length and having the dimension of a length if the corresponding generalized co-ordinate is non-dimensional), then there exists a unique solution q j = q j (t ), p j = p j (t ) of the system (19.1.14), which satisfies the initial conditions (19.1.14') and is definite an the interval t0 − T ≤ t ≤ t0 + T , where q j0 τ p j0 ⎡ T ≤ min ⎢T0 , λ j , ,T V μλj V ⎣
⎤ ∂H ⎡ τ ∂H ⎤ ⎥ , V = max ⎢ μλ ∂q , λj ∂p in D ⎥ , j j ⎣ j ⎦ ⎦
without summation with respect to the index j . The continuity of the derivatives of first order of the function H with respect to the canonical co-ordinates on the interval D ensures the existence of the solution, according to Peano’s theorem. Lipschitz’s conditions must be also fulfilled for the uniqueness of the solution; but the latter conditions can be replaced (as in the case of other theorems of uniqueness) by other ones less restrictive, according to which the partial derivative of second order of the function H with respect to the canonical coordinates must exist and must be bounded in absolute value on the interval D . As a matter of fact, the conditions in the Theorem 19.1.2 are sufficient conditions of existence and uniqueness, which are not necessary too. As in the case of other analogous theorems (e.g., the Theorem 18.2.1) one can obtain a prolongation of the solution for t ∈ [t1 , t2 ] , corresponding to a certain interval of time in which the considered phenomena takes place, or even for t ∈ [t0 , ∞ ) or t ∈ ( ∞, t1 ] or t ∈ ( −∞, ∞ ) .
We can state also theorems on the continuous or analytical dependence of the solution on a parameter, analogue to the Theorems 6.1.3 and 6.1.4; as well, we state Theorem 19.1.3 (on the differentiability of the solution). If, in the neighbourhood of a point P (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., ps ; t ) ∈ D , the functions ∂H / ∂q j , ∂H / ∂p j , j = 1,2,..., s , H = H (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., ps ; t ) , are of class C k , then the solution
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
124
q j (t ) and p j (t ) of the system (19.1.14) which satisfy the initial conditions (19.1.14')
are of class C k +1 in a neighbourhood of the point P . We call first integral of the system of canonical equations (19.1.14) a function f = f (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., ps ; t ) of class C 1 , which is reduced to a constant along the integral curves (trajectories in the phase space) q j = q j (t ; c1 , c2 ,..., c2 s ), p j = p j (t ; c1 , c2 ,..., c2 s ), j = 1, 2,..., s ,
(19.1.17)
of this system ( ck , k = 1, 2,..., 2s , are, obviously, integration constant); hence df =
∂f ∂f dq j + dp j + f dt = 0 ∂q j ∂p j
(19.1.18)
or df ∂f ∂f q + p + f = 0 = dt ∂q j j ∂p j j
(19.1.18')
along the integral curves. The canonical equations (19.1.14) can be written in the form d q1 dq dp1 dp2 dqs dps dt = 2 = ... = = = = ... = = ∂H ∂H ∂H ∂H ∂H ∂H 1 − − − ∂p1 ∂p2 ∂ps ∂q1 ∂q2 ∂qs
(19.1.19)
too, for integration being necessary 2s independent first integrals. If we determine l ≤ 2s first integrals fk (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., ps ; t ) = ck , ck = const, k = 1, 2,..., l ,
(19.1.20)
the matrix ∂ ( f1 , f2 ,..., fl ) ⎡ ⎤ M = ⎢ ⎣ ∂ (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., ps ) ⎥⎦
being of rank l , then all these integrals are functionally independent (independent first integrals) and we can express l unknown functions of the system (19.1.19) with respect to the other ones; replacing in this system of equations, the problem is reduced to the integration of a system of equations with 2s − l unknowns (hence, with a smaller number of unknowns). If l = 2s , then all the first integrals are independent, so that the system (19.1.20) determines all the unknown functions. We notice that, if l > 2s , then the first integrals (19.1.20) are no more independent; hence, one can set up at the most 2s independent first integrals.
Hamiltonian Mechanics
125
Solving the system (19.1.20) for l = 2s , we obtain (the matrix M is a square one of order 2s , for which det M ≠ 0 ) the solution (19.1.17), hence a general integral of the system of equations (19.1.14). One puts thus in evidence 2s integration constants. Imposing the initial conditions (19.1.14'), it results q j (t0 ; c1 , c2 ,..., c2 s ) = q j0 , p j (t0 ; c1 , c2 ,..., c2 s ) = p j0 , j = 1,2,..., s ; the conditions (19.1.14') being independent,
we may write ⎡ ∂ (q10 , q20 ,..., qs0 , p10 , p20 ,..., ps0 ) ⎤ det ⎢ ⎥ ≠0 ∂ (c1 , c2 ,..., c2 s ) ⎣ ⎦
and we get ck = ck (t0 ;q10 , q 20 ,..., qs0 , p10 , p20 ,..., ps0 ) , k = 1, 2,..., 2s , using the theorem of implicit functions. Thus, it results, finally (for j = 1,2,..., s ), q j = q j (t ; t0 , q10 , q20 ,..., qs0 , p10 , p20 ,..., ps0 ), p j = p j (t ; t0 , q10 , q20 ,..., qs0 , p10 , p20 ,..., ps0 ).
(19.1.21)
Hence, in the frame of the conditions of the theorem of existence and uniqueness, the canonical equations and the corresponding initial conditions determine, univocally, the motion of the discrete mechanical system S , subjected to holonomic ideal constraints, in a finite interval of time; by prolongation, the statement can be valid for any t . The deterministic aspect of mechanics is thus put in evidence in the Hamiltonian presentation too. If f1 = c1 and f2 = c2 are two distinct first integrals, then f ( f1 , f2 ) = 0 is a first integral too; any other first integral is expressed, in general, as a function of the 2s distinct first integrals of Hamilton’s equations. 19.1.1.5 Hamilton’s Function Starting from the relation of definition (19.1.11), passing to canonical co-ordinates, taking into account (18.2.80), (18.2.34') and using Euler’s theorem concerning homogeneous functions, we can write Hamilton’s function in the form
∂L H = p j q j − L = q − L = 2L2 + L1 − L = L2 − L0 . ∂q j j If we take into account also the relations (18.2.34''), it results H =
E , E = T2 − T0 + V ,
(19.1.22)
where E is the generalized mechanical energy, given by (18.2.68) and expressed in canonical co-ordinates (V = −U in case of a simple quasi-potential or V = −U 0 in case of a generalized quasi-potential). In case of a scleronomic mechanical system
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
126
( T2 = 0, T0 = 0 ) we have E = T2 + V = T + V = E , obtaining the mechanical energy of the considered mechanical system. Observing, on the basis of the formulae (18.2.15') and (19.1.1'), that 2T2 − g jk g jl [ pl − (gl + U l )]g km [ pm − (gm + U m )] = g jk [ p j − ( g j + U j )][ pk − ( gk + U k )],
we can represent Hamilton’s functions in the form H = H 2 + H1 + H 0 ,
(19.1.23)
where H 2 = T2 = H0 =
1 jk g p j pk , H 1 = − g jk (g j + U j ) pk , 2
1 jk g (g j + U j )( gk + U k ) − g 0 + V , 2
(19.1.23')
hence a sum of a quadratic form, of a linear form and of a constant with respect to the generalized momenta. In case of scleronomic constraints we have g 0 = 0 , g j = 0, j = 1,2,..., s , so that H 1 = − g jkU j pk , H 0 =
1 jk g U jU k + V , 2
(19.1.23'')
and in case of generalized forces which derive from a simple potential it result U j = 0 , j = 1,2,..., s , so that H 1 = − g jk g j pk , H 0 =
1 jk g g j gk − g 0 + V ; 2
(19.1.23''')
if both conditions are fulfilled, then H 1 = 0, H 0 = V . If g jk = δ jk , then we have g jk = δ jk , where δ jk is Kronecker’s tensor; we can write T2 =
1 1 1 1 δ jk q j qk = q j q j , H 2 = T2 = δ jk p j pk = p j p j , 2 2 2 2
(19.1.24)
hence in the form of a sum of squares. In this case, the generalized co-ordinates are orthogonal (they are called normal co-ordinates), the generalized momenta having the same property. We can calculate ∂H ∂H dH = q j + p + H . dt ∂q j ∂p j j
Hamiltonian Mechanics
127
Taking into account the equations (19.1.14), we can state that the relation ∂H dH = = H dt ∂t
(19.1.25)
takes place along the integral curves of Hamilton’s system of equations. If Hamilton’s function does not depend explicitly on time ( H = 0 , hence E = 0 ), then the generalized mechanical energy H (q1 , q 2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., ps ) =
E (q1 , q 2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., ps ) = h , h = const, (19.1.26)
is a first integral of the canonical system (19.1.14). This first integral corresponds to Jacobi’s first integral or to a first integral of Jacobi type of Lagrange’s system of equations, which can be written if L = 0 (see Sect. 18.2.3.4); as a matter of fact, H = 0 leads to L = 0 and reciprocally, on the basis of the last relation (19.1.12'). The mechanical system is, in this case, a generalized conservative system (as in the case in which L = 0 ). If the mechanical system is scleronomic, then we find again the first integral of the mechanical energy expressed in canonical co-ordinates ( H = T + V = E = h ), as a particular case; we have to do with a simple or generalized potential (U = 0 ) in this case, so that ∂ (T2 − T0 )/ ∂t + ∂V / ∂t = 0 . We notice that to have H = 0 it is not necessary that the mechanical system be scleronomic. Indeed, from (19.1.23') we see that it is necessary and sufficient to have g jk = 0, g j + U j = 0, g0 = V ;
(19.1.27)
the first relations above lead also to g jk = 0 for j , k = 1, 2,..., s , Taking into account (18.2.15'), (18.2.15''), we can state that these relations can take place only and only if the derivative ∂ri / ∂q j , i , j = 1, 2,..., s , do not depend explicitly on time, i.e. if ri = ri′ + ri′′ , ri′ = ri′ (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ) , ri′′ = ri′′(t ), i = 1, 2,..., s . This statement remains
valid for Jacobi’s first integral or for the first integrals of Jacobi type too; in particular, for ri′′ = 0, i = 1, 2,..., s , when the mechanical system is scleronomic, then one obtains the integral of mechanical energy. 19.1.1.6 Reduction of the Number of First Integrals As we have seen above, the function H is a first integral of the canonical system of equations if H = 0 ; hence, it is necessary to determine other 2s − 1 first integrals. If we write Hamilton’s equations in the form (19.1.19), then we notice that – in this case – we can neglect the last ratio in this system; indeed, to integrate the remaining system of equations, there are sufficient 2s − 1 first integrals, which do not depend explicitly on time. Thus we can determine 2s − 1 canonical co-ordinates as functions of one of them. To fix the ideas, we assume that ∂H / ∂p1 ≠ 0 ; we find thus the generalized co-
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
128
ordinates q j = q j (q1 ; c1 , c2 ,..., c2 s −1 ), j = 2, 3,..., s , and the generalized momenta pi = pi (q1 ; c1 , c2 ,..., c2 s −1 ), i = 1, 2,..., s . In this case, it results the function of
Hamilton H = H (q1 ; c1 , c2 ,..., c2 s −1 ) , where we have put in evidence the integration constants. From the first and the last ratio (19.1.19) we get −1
⎛ ∂H ⎞ t = ∫⎜ ⎟ dq1 + c2 s = F (q1 ; c1 , c2 ,..., c2 s ) , ⎝ ∂p1 ⎠
(19.1.28)
the function F containing he last integration constant c2 s too. Observing that the derivative ∂F / ∂q1 = ( ∂H / ∂p1 )−1 ≠ 0 , the theorem of implicit functions allows to calculate q1 = q1 (t ; c1 , c2 ,..., c2 s ) . Introducing then in the above results, we obtain the general integrals (19.1.17). The system of equations (19.1.19) is of the form (15.1.24), so that one can use the theory of Jacobi’s multiplier (see Sect. 15.1.1.4), as well as the theory of the last multiplier (see Sect. 15.1.1.5). In this case, x j = q j , xs + j = p j , X j = ∂H / ∂p j , Xs + j = −∂H / ∂q j , j = 1, 2,..., s , and x 2 s + 1 = 1 , n = 2s + 1 . We notice that the
divergence of the vector which has as components the denominators in (19.1.19) vanishes ∂ ∂q1
∂ ⎛ ∂H ⎞ ∂ ⎛ ∂H ⎞ ⎛ ∂H ⎞ ⎜ ∂p ⎟ + ∂q ⎜ ∂p ⎟ + ... + ∂q ⎜ ∂p ⎟ s ⎝ s ⎠ ⎝ 1⎠ 2 ⎝ 2 ⎠ ∂ ⎛ ∂H ⎞ ∂ ⎛ ∂H ⎞ ∂ ⎛ ∂H ⎞ ∂ + − + − + ... + ⎜− ⎟ + ( I ) = 0, ∂p1 ⎜⎝ ∂q1 ⎟⎠ ∂p2 ⎜⎝ ∂q2 ⎟⎠ ∂ps ⎝ ∂qs ⎠ ∂t
hence the condition (15.1.30) is fulfilled; a constant is thus a multiplier of the sequence of equations (19.1.19), while – according to the Theorem 15.1.4'' – any non-constant multiplier is a first integral of this system of differential equations. Hence, there are sufficient 2s − 1 first integrals to determine the general solution of the respective system. If H = 0 , then there remain sufficient 2s − 2 first integrals for a complete study of the canonical equations. For instance, in case of the problem of two particles – at a first view – there are necessary 2 ⋅ 6 = 12 first integrals; according to what has been shown above, in case of scleronomic mechanical systems and of conservative forces there are sufficient 2 ⋅ (6 − 1) = 10 first integrals. If the two particles are subjected to no one constraint, being acted upon only by forces of Newtonian attraction, we are just in the mentioned case; the conservation theorem of momentum leads to six first integrals, the conservation theorem of the moment of momentum allows to write three first integrals and the conservation theorem of mechanical energy given also a first integral, so that the integration of the corresponding system of canonical equations is reduced to quadratures. Let be a scleronomic conservative Hamiltonian system with two degrees of freedom. It is possible, in this case, to write the integral of the mechanical energy, i.e. H = (q1 , q2 , p1 , p2 ) = h , h = const ; one obtains the differential system
Hamiltonian Mechanics
129 d q1 dq 2 dp1 dp2 dt = = = = . ∂H ∂H ∂H ∂H 1 − − ∂p1 ∂p2 ∂q1 ∂q2
Let us suppose that another first integral f (q1 , q2 ; p1 , p2 ) = c , c = const , which does not contain explicitly the time, is known. The two first integrals being independent, we can calculate p j = p j (q1 , q2 ; h , c ), j = 1, 2 ; replacing in Hamilton’s equations, this system is reduced to dq1 dq = 2 = dt , ∂H ∂H ∂p1 ∂p2
with the unknown functions qk = qk (t ), k = 1, 2 , for which the last multiplier M = det[ ∂ ( p1 , p2 )/ ∂ (h , c )] satisfies the equation (see Sect. 15.1.1.5 too)
∂M ⎞ ⎛ ∂M ⎞ ∂ ⎛⎜ M ⎟ ∂ ⎜ M ∂p ⎟ ∂ p ⎝ ⎝ 1 ⎠ 2 ⎠ + = 0. ∂q1 ∂q2
Hence, ⎛ ∂H
∂H
⎞
∫ M ⎜⎝ ∂p2 dq1 − ∂p1 dq2 ⎟⎠ = const is a first integral of the last differential system. We notice that H and f depend on h and c by means of the generalized momenta p1 and p2 . Because dH / dh = 1 and dH / dc = 0 , it results
∂H ∂p1 ∂H ∂p2 ∂H ∂p1 ∂H ∂p2 + = 1, + = 0. ∂p1 ∂h ∂p2 ∂h ∂p1 ∂c ∂p2 ∂c One obtains analogous results from df / dh = 0 , df / dc = 1 . The determinant M being non-zero, we can write ∂p ∂H = 2,M ∂p1 ∂c ∂p ∂f = 2,M M ∂p1 ∂h
M
∂p ∂H = − 1, ∂p2 ∂c ∂p ∂f = − 1. ∂p2 ∂h
The last first integral becomes ∂χ = const, χ(q1 , q2 ; h , c ) = ∫ ( p1 dq1 + p2 dq2 ) . ∂c
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
130
Then, taking into account M det[ ∂ (H , f )/ ∂ ( p1 , p2 )] = 1 , the reduced system of differential equations allows to write ∂f ∂f dt = M ⎛⎜ dq 2 − dq1 ⎞⎟ , p p ∂ ∂ ⎝ 1 ⎠ 2
wherefrom t =
∂χ + const . ∂h
The integration of the differential system is thus reduced to a quadrature, which determines the function χ . 19.1.1.7 Routh’s Equations It is convenient, in some cases, to use as parameters which describe the motion of the mechanical system S a part of the Hamiltonian co-ordinates and a part of the Lagrangian ones; one obtains thus a “mixed method” to approach the problem. We assume that the motion is specified by Hamilton’s variables (denoted by Greek indices) q α , pα , α = 1, 2,..., r and Lagrange’s variables (denoted by Roman indices) q j , q j , j = r + 1, r + 2,..., s , the set of which form Routh’s variables. We effect a partial Legendre transformation of the form pα =
∂L , α = 1, 2,..., r , ∂qα
(19.1.29)
which allows to determine qα = qα (q β , pβ , q j , q j ; t ) = qα (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., pr , qr + 1 , qr + 2 ,..., qs ; t ), α = 1, 2,..., r .
Applying a variation δ to Lagrange’s function L = L (q α , qα , q j , q j ; t ) , we obtain δL =
r
∂L
∑ ⎝⎛⎜ ∂qα δqα
α =1
+
∂L δqα ⎞⎟ + ∂qα ⎠
∂L ⎛ ∂L ⎜ ∂q δq j + ∂q δq j j j j =r +1 ⎝ s
∑
⎞ ⎟. ⎠
Taking into account (19.1.29), we notice that r
δ ∑ pα qα = α =1
r
∂L
∑ ∂qα δqα
α =1
+
r
∑ qα δpα .
α =1
wherefrom r ∂L ⎛ r ⎞ δ ⎜ ∑ pα qα − L ⎟ = − ∑ ⎛⎜ δq α − qα δpα ⎞⎟ − ∂ q α ⎝ ⎠ ⎝ α =1 ⎠ α =1
∂L ⎛ ∂L ⎞ ⎜ ∂q δq j + ∂q δq j ⎟ . j j ⎠ j =r +1 ⎝ s
∑
Hamiltonian Mechanics
131
We introduce Routh’s function
R =
∑ pαqα − L r
,
(19.1.30)
α =1
where “the cap” indicates the expression of the generalized velocities qα , α = 1, 2,...,r , by means of Routh’s variables, so that R = R (q α , pα , q j , q j ; t ) ; it results δR =
r
∂R
∑ ⎛⎜⎝ ∂qα
α =1
δq α +
∂R δpα ⎞⎟ + ∂pα ⎠
∂R ⎛ ∂R ⎞ ⎜ ∂q δq j + ∂q δq j ⎟ . j j ⎠ j =r +1 ⎝ s
∑
Identifying the above relations, where we take into account the notation (19.1.30), we can write ∂L ∂R ∂R , qα = , α = 1, 2,..., r , = ∂q α ∂q α ∂pα ∂L ∂R ∂L ∂R ,− , j = r + 1, r + 2,..., s . − = = ∂q j ∂q j ∂q j ∂q j −
Lagrange’s equations (18.2.38) led thus Routh, in 1876, to the equations qα =
∂R ∂R , p α = − , α = 1, 2,..., r , ∂pα ∂q α
d ⎛ ∂R ⎞ ∂R − = 0, j = r + 1, r + 2,..., s , dt ⎜⎝ ∂q j ⎟⎠ ∂q j
(19.1.31) (19.1.31')
called Routh’s equations (see Sect. 18.2.3.7 too); we remark that a part of these equations are of Hamilton type (Routh’s function plays the rôle of Hamilton’s function) and another part of Lagrange type (Routh’s function plays the rôle of Lagrange’s kinetic potential), which justifies the name of “mixed method” given above. In the case in which the generalized co-ordinates q α , α = 1,2,..., r , are ignorable we find again the Routh–Helmholtz theorem (see Sect. 18.2.3.7 too). If the holonomic constraints to which is subjected the mechanical system S are also scleronomic, then the kinetic energy is expressed in the form T =
1 s s ∑ g jk (qr +1 , qr + 2 ,..., qs )qj qk . 2∑ j = 1 k =1
(19.1.31'')
We also assume that the generalized forces are quasi-conservative, deriving from a simple quasi-potential U = U (q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; t ) . In this case, pα =
∂Τ = ∂qα
r
∑ gαβ qβ
β =1
+
s
∑
j =r +1
g α j q j , α = 1, 2,..., r .
(19.1.32)
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
132
Because [ g αβ ] is a square matrix of rank r and det[ g αβ ] ≠ 0 , corresponding to the condition (18.2.34'''), we get r
∑ g αβ pβ
qα =
β =1
−
s
∑
j =r +1
hα j q j , α = 1, 2,..., r ,
(19.1.32')
where g αβ is the normalized algebraic complement of the element g αβ in det[ g αβ ] , while r
∑ g αβ g β j ,
hα j =
β =1
α = 1, 2,..., r , j = r + 1, r + 2,..., s .
(19.1.32'')
Obviously, the coefficients g αβ and hα j are functions only on the palpable coordinates q j , j = r + 1, r + 2,..., s . Observing that g jk =
r ∂2T ∂ ⎛ ∂T ∂T ∂qα = + ∑ ⎜ ∂q j ∂qk ∂q j ⎝ ∂qk α =1 ∂qα ∂qk ∂ ⎛ ∂T ⎞ ∂ r = qα − hαk pα , ⎜ ⎟ ∂q j ⎝ ∂qk ⎠ ∂q j α∑ =1
⎞ ⎟ qα ⎠
there results r
∑ gα j hαk
g jk = g jk −
α =1
= g jk −
r
r
∑ ∑ g αβ gα j g βk , j , k
α =1 β =1
= r + 1, r + 2,..., s . (19.1.33)
Analogically, ∂2T ∂ = = ∂pα ∂pβ ∂pα
g αβ
=
r
∑ g γβ δγα
γ =1
g jα ∂ = ∂q j
r
∑ g βα pβ
β =1
∂T ∂qγ ∂ = ∂ p ∂ p α β γ =1 r
∑ ∂qγ
r
∑ g γβ pγ
γ =1
= g αβ , α, β = 1,2,..., r ,
∂2T ∂ = = ∂q j ∂pα ∂q j
r
∂T ∂qβ ∂pα
∑ ∂qβ
β =1
= 0, α = 1, 2,..., r , j = r + 1, r + 2,..., s ,
so that we can write s 1 r r 1 s T = ∑ ∑ g αβ pα pβ + g q q . ∑ ∑ 2 α =1 β =1 2 j = r + 1 k = r + 1 jk j k
We denote
(19.1.34)
Hamiltonian Mechanics
133 T∗ =
s 1 s g q q . ∑ ∑ 2 j = r + 1 k = r + 1 jk j k
(19.1.35)
Let us introduce Routh’s potential U∗ = U −
1 r r αβ ∑ g pα p β 2 α∑ =1 β =1
(19.1.36)
and the generalized potential Π = U∗ +
s
r
∑ ∑ hα j pαqj .
j =r + 1 α =1
(19.1.36')
Taking into account the relation of definition (19.1.30) and the generalized velocities (19.1.32'), we obtain Routh’s function in the form
R = −(T ∗ + Π ) .
(19.1.37)
From (19.1.34), (19.1.35), and (19.1.36), it results T −U = T∗ −U∗.
(19.1.38)
Lagrange’s equations (19.1.31') can be thus considered as being the equations of motion of a reduced system, which admits −R (given by (19.2.37)) as kinetic potential and which has the same mechanical energy as the initial system. If, in particular, the kinetic energy of the initial mechanical system does not contain products of the generalized velocities qα of the ignorable co-ordinates, hence if g α j = 0, α = 1, 2,..., r , j = r + 1, r + 2,..., s , then the kinetic energy T is obtained as a sum of two quadratic forms: a form in the generalized velocities qα and a form in the generalized velocities q j ; such a mechanical system is a gyroscopic uncoupled one. In this case, hα j = 0, α = 1,2,..., r , j = r + 1, r + 2,..., s , while Π = U ∗ , as well, T∗ =
s 1 s g q q . ∑ ∑ 2 j = r + 1 k = r + 1 jk j k
(19.1.35')
As it can be easily seen, if the initial system is conservative (U = 0 ), then the reduced system has the same property (U ∗ = 0 ). If one has ∂U / ∂q α = 0 too, then it results ∂L / ∂q α = 0, α = 1, 2,..., r , so that the ignorable co-ordinates are hidden ones too. The motions in which vary only the hidden co-ordinates are called hidden motions; such type of motion occurs, e.g., in case of mechanical systems which contain gyroscopes. H. Hertz dealt in 1894 with these problems, considering the potential energy of a conservative system as being the kinetic energy of some hidden motions.
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
134 19.1.1.8 Cyclic Co-ordinates
A generalized co-ordinate q α which does not intervene explicitly in Hamilton’s function ( ∂H / ∂q α = 0 ) is called, after Helmholtz, cyclic co-ordinate; let us admit thus that the first r co-ordinates are cyclic ( α = 1,2,...,r ). Taking into account the first relation (19.1.12'), we can state that an ignorable co-ordinate (for which ∂L / ∂q α = 0 ) is a cyclic one too. We are thus led to r first integrals pα = bα , bα = const , α = 1,2,...,r ; taking into account the results in the preceding subsection, we can state that the cyclic co-ordinates do not intervene explicitly neither in Routh’s function, so that the equations (19.1.31) lead to the same results as the Routh–Helmholtz theorem (see Sect. 18.2.3.7). The Lagrange type equations (19.1.31) remain to be integrated. If we deal with the system of canonical equations, after the determination of the mentioned r first integrals, we remain with the system of equations (19.1.14) for j = r + 1, r + 2,..., s (a system of 2(s − r ) partial differential equations of first order with 2(s − r ) unknown functions). Hamilton’s function will be of the form H = H (q j , p j , bα ; t ) ≡ H (qr + 1 , qr + 2 ,..., qs , pr + 1 , pr + 2 ,..., ps , b1 , b2 ,..., br ; t ) ;
thus, by integration of the reduced canonical system, we get q j = q j (t ; ak , bk , bα ) ≡ q j (t ; ar + 1 , ar + 2 ,..., as , b1 , b2 ,..., bs ) , p j = p j (t ; ak , bk , bα ) ≡ p j (t ; ar + 1 , ar + 2 ,..., as , b1 , b2 ,..., bs ), ak , bk = const, j , k = r + 1, r + 2,..., s .
Replacing in Hamilton’s function, we obtain H = H (t ; ak , a j , bk , bα ) ≡ H (t ; ar + 1 , ar + 2 ,..., as , b1 , b2 ,..., bs ) .
Introducing in the first r equations of the first group of equation (19.1.14), we find also the cyclic co-ordinates qα =
∂H
∫ ∂bα
dt + aα , α = 1, 2,..., r .
(19.1.39)
Hence, q α = q α (t ; aα , bα , bj ) ≡ qα (t ; a1 , a2 ,..., as , b1 , b2 ,..., bs ) , only the cyclic coordinates depending on all the integration constant. If, in particular, all the generalized co-ordinates are cyclic ( r = s ), then all the generalized momenta are constant, while H = H (t ;b1 , b2 ,..., bs ) ; the cyclic co-ordinates are obtained by s quadratures, intervening the other s integration constants. If the mechanical system is also scleronomic, then it results ∂H / ∂bj = ω j , ω j = const , j = 1, 2,..., s , the generalized co-ordinates being of the form q j = ω j t + a j , j = 1, 2,..., s ,
(19.1.39')
Hamiltonian Mechanics
135
which justifies the denomination of cyclic co-ordinates. The problem of integration of Hamilton’s equations (19.1.14) is thus reduced to the determination of a transformation of generalized co-ordinates to maintain the form of the canonical equations, the new generalized co-ordinates being cyclic. As we will see, the intervention of the one or more cyclic co-ordinates may lead to a simplification of many methods of calculation. 19.1.1.9 The Pfaff Form of Hamilton. The Bilinear Covariant. Whittaker’s Equations Let be the differential form ω =
n
∑ Xi (x1 , x 2 ,..., xn )dxi ,
(19.1.40)
i =1
where the functions Xi , i = 1, 2,..., n , of class C 1 are definite on a certain domain in \n ; we assume that ω is not a total differential. An expression of this form is called Pfaffian (a Pfaff form). Let us suppose that x j = x j (u1 , u2 ), j = 1, 2,..., n , depending on two parameters. Let be the differential quantities dx j =
∂x j ∂x j du1 , δx j = du . ∂u1 ∂u2 2
Noting that d ( δx j
)=
∂2 x j d u d u , δ ( dx j ∂u1 ∂u2 2 1
)=
∂2 x j du d u ∂u2 ∂u1 1 2
and assuming that x j are functions of class C 2 in the two parameters, we have d( δx j ) = δ(dx j ) , according to Schwartz’s theorem. If we denote
ωd =
n
n
i =1
i =1
∑ Xi dxi , ωδ = ∑ Xi δxi
(19.1.41)
and take into account the permutation relation of the differential operators, then we can write ω ′ = ω ( d, δ ) = δωd − dωδ =
n
∑ ω j δx j , j =1
⎛ ∂Xi ∂X j ⎞ dx , j = 1, 2,..., n , ωj = ∑ ⎜ − ∂x i ⎟⎠ i i = 1 ⎝ ∂x j n
(19.1.41')
obtaining thus the bilinear covariant of the form ω . Let us make the change of variables
x j = x j (y1 , y2 ,..., yn ), x j ∈ C 1 , j = 1, 2,..., n ,
(19.1.42)
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
136
so that det[ ∂x j / ∂yk ] ≠ 0 on a domain in \n . Denoting ∂x
n
∑ Xi ∂yki , k
Yk =
i =1
= 1, 2,..., n ,
(19.1.42')
we obtain
ω = ω′ =
n
∑ ωk δyk , ωk
=
k =1
n
∑Yk dyk ,
k =1
∂Y
∑ ⎛⎜⎝ ∂ykl n
l =1
−
(19.1.43)
∂Yk ⎞ dy , k = 1, 2,..., n . ∂yl ⎟⎠ l
(19.1.43')
The Pfaff form ω and its bilinear covariant ω ′ maintain their form. The necessary and sufficient conditions to have ω ′ ≡ 0 for any δx j , considered arbitrary, are ω j = 0, j = 1, 2,..., n , being thus led to the differential system associate to the Pfaff form n
⎛ ∂X
∑ ⎜⎝ ∂x ji
i =1
−
∂X j ⎞ dx = 0, j = 1, 2,..., n . ∂x i ⎟⎠ i
(19.1.44)
The transform of this system, by the change of variables (19.1.42), will – obviously – be ∂Y
∑ ⎛⎜⎝ ∂ykl n
l =1
−
∂Yk ⎞ dy = 0, k = 1, 2,..., n . ∂yl ⎟⎠ l
(19.1.44')
As it can be easily seen, if ω is a total differential, then ω ′ = 0 ; consequently, we can state that the Pfaff forms ω and
c ω + dF = c ω +
n
∂F
∑ ∂xi
i =1
dx i ,
where c = const , and F = F ( x1 , x 2 ,..., x n ) is a function of class C 2 , have the same bilinear covariant. By definition, the Pfaff form of Hamilton is ω = p j dq j − H dt ,
(19.1.45)
where we have introduced the canonical variables q j , p j and the time t (hence, n = 2s + 1 ); the bilinear covariant of the form is
ω ′ = δωd − dωδ = δp j dq j − δHdt − ( dp j δq j − dH δt )
(
)
∂H ∂H ∂H ⎛ ⎞ ⎛ ⎞ dt ⎟ δq j + ⎜ dq j − dt ⎟ δp j + dH − dt δt . = − ⎜ dp j + ∂ ∂ ∂t q p j j ⎝ ⎠ ⎝ ⎠
Hamiltonian Mechanics
137
The differential system of Hamilton associated to the Pfaff form is formed by the canonical equations (19.1.14) and the differential outcome (19.1.25) of them. By introducing the notion of exterior differential in the sense of Elie Cartan, the Pfaff form of Hamilton can lead to a new differential principle of mechanics; choosing conveniently the Hamiltonian, one can build up new mathematical models (e.g., the invariantive model of O. Onicescu). In case of a generalized conservative system ( H = 0 ) one obtains the first integral (19.1.26) of the generalized mechanical energy. Assuming that ∂H / ∂p1 ≠ 0 (at least one the components of the generalized momentum must be non-zero, otherwise the motion of the mechanical system could not take place), the theorem of implicit functions leads to p1 = − K (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., ps ; h ) . The corresponding Pfaff form will be ω =
s
∑ p j dq j
j =2
− Kdql − hdt ,
(19.1.46)
where K plays the rôle of Hamilton’s function and q1 the rôle of time; indeed, according to a previous notice, the form ω and the form ω + hdt ( hdt is an exact differential) have the same bilinear covariant. In this case, the associate differential system will be q j′ =
∂K ∂K dK ∂K , , p′ = − , j = 1, 2,..., s , = ∂p j j ∂q j d q1 ∂q1
(19.1.47)
where q j′ = dq j / dq1 , p j′ = dp j / dq1 , j = 1,2, 3,..., s ; these 2(s − 1) equations of Hamilton type are known as Whittaker’s equations. One can thus determine the canonical co-ordinates q j = q j (q1 ; a2 , a 3 ,..., as , b2 , b3 ,..., bs , h ), p j = p j (q1 ; a2 , a 3 ,..., as , b2 , b3 ,..., bs , h ), j = 1, 2,..., s ;
(19.1.47')
replacing then in the function K , we obtain K = K (q1 ; a2 , a 3 ,..., as , b2 , b3 ,..., bs , h ) , hence the generalized momentum p1 too. Finally, Hamilton’s equation q1 = ∂H / ∂p1 allows to put in evidence the dependence on time of the canonical co-ordinates, introducing the last integration constant too. Besides, these considerations can be put in connection to those made in Sect. 19.1.1.6. Denoting
L =
s
∑ p j q j′
j =2
−K,
(19.1.48)
where L ′ = L ′(q1 , q2 ,..., qs , q2′ , q 3′ ,..., qs′ ) , and effecting a Legendre transformation, we can replace Whittaker’s equations (of Hamilton type) by Jacobi’s equations (of Lagrange type) (see Sect. 18.2.3.5).
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
138
19.1.2 Lagrange’s Brackets. Poisson’s Brackets In what follows one introduces Lagrange’s and Poisson’s brackets, in connection to the system of canonical equations; these brackets allow to determine first integrals of the mentioned equations and put in evidence interesting properties of the integration constant. 19.1.2.1 Lagrange’s Brackets. Lagrange’s Theorem Let be the function x i = x i ( ξ1 , ξ2 ,..., ξn , η1 , η2 ,..., ηn ), yi = yi ( ξ1 , ξ2 ,..., ξn , η1 , η2 ,..., ηn ), i = 1, 2,..., n ,
(19.1.49)
of class C 1 . We call Lagrange’s brackets (denoted by square brackets) the sums ⎡ ∂ (x , y ) ⎤
∂x ∂y ⎞ ⎛ ∂x ∂yi − i i ⎟, ∂ ∂ ξ ξk ∂ξ j ⎠ k ⎦ k ⎣ i =1 i =1 ⎝ n n ∂x ∂y ⎞ ⎡ ∂ (x , y ) ⎤ ⎛ ∂x ∂y [ η j , ηk ] = ∑ det ⎢ ∂ ( η i , ηi ) ⎥ = ∑ ⎜ ∂ηi ∂η i − ∂η i ∂ηi ⎟, j j j ⎠ k ⎦ k k ⎣ i =1 i =1 ⎝ n n ∂x i ∂yi ⎞ ⎛ ∂x i ∂yi ⎡ ∂ ( x i , yi ) ⎤ [ ξj , ηk ] = ∑ det ⎢ ∂ ( ξ , η ) ⎥ = ∑ ⎜ ∂ξ ∂η − ∂η ∂ξ ⎟, k k ⎦ k j ⎠ j j ⎣ i =1 ⎝ i =1 n
n
[ ξj , ξk ] = ∑ det ⎢ ∂ ( ξ i , ξi ) ⎥ = ∑ ⎜ ∂ξ i j j
(19.1.49')
for j , k = 1, 2,..., n ; the denomination of brackets is given because these quantities are sums of brackets. Lagrange’s brackets are, obviously, anticommutative (skewsymmetric with respect to the indices j and k )
[ ξj , ξk ] = − [ ξk , ξj ], [ η j , ηk ] = − [ ηk , η j ], [ ξj , ηk ] = − [ ηk , ξj ] .
(19.1.49'')
In quantum mechanics it is used to denote Lagrange’s brackets in the form { ξ j , ξk } ,
{ η j , ηk } , { ξj , ηk } . Let be q j = q j (t ; a , b ) , p j = p j (t ; a , b ), j = 1,2,..., s , the integrals of the canonical system (19.2.14), where we have put in evidence the integration constants a and b ; the corresponding Lagrange’s bracket is written in the form (the two constants play the rôle of parameters) ∂q j ∂a [ a ,b ] = ∂q j ∂b
Let us calculate
∂p j ∂q j ∂p j ∂q j ∂p j ∂a = − . ∂p j ∂a ∂b ∂b ∂a ∂b
(19.1.50)
Hamiltonian Mechanics
139
∂q j ∂p j ∂q j ∂p j ∂q j ∂p j ∂q j ∂p j d [ a ,b ] = + − − , dt ∂a ∂b ∂a ∂b ∂b ∂a ∂b ∂a
where we assume that the two parameters are independent on t , so that (d / dt )( ∂ / ∂c ) = ( ∂ / ∂c )(d / dt ) , where c can be a or b ; taking into account Hamilton’s equations, we may write ∂q j ∂2 H ∂qk ∂2 H ∂pk = + , ∂c ∂qk ∂p j ∂c ∂pk ∂p j ∂c ∂p j ∂2 H ∂qk ∂2 H ∂pk = − − , ∂c ∂qk ∂q j ∂c ∂pk ∂q j ∂c
where, analogously, we make – successively – c equal to a or b . We get ∂q ∂q j ⎞ ∂p ∂p j ⎞ ∂2 H ⎛ ∂qk ∂q j ∂2 H ⎛ ∂pk ∂p j d [ a ,b ] = − k + − k ⎜ ⎟ dt ∂qk ∂q j ⎝ ∂a ∂b ∂b ∂a ⎠ ∂pk ∂p j ⎜⎝ ∂a ∂b ∂b ∂a ⎟⎠ ∂q ∂p j ⎞ ∂q ∂q j ⎞ ∂2 H ⎛ ∂qk ∂p j ∂2 H ⎛ ∂pk ∂q j . + − k + − k ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ∂qk ∂p j ⎝ ∂a ∂b ∂b ∂a ⎠ ∂pk ∂q j ⎝ ∂a ∂b ∂b ∂a ⎟⎠
Observing that the mixed derivatives of Hamilton’s function do not depend on the order of differentiation (we assume that H ∈ C 2 ), it results that the first two sums vanish (the derivatives of the function H are symmetric with respect to the indices k and j , while the brackets are skew-symmetric with respect to the same indices); if in the last sums we replace the dummy indices k and j by j and k , respectively, then we remark that the last two sums vanish too. Hence, d[a , b ]/ dt = 0 , so that
[ a , b ] = const ;
(19.1.51)
we can state Theorem 19.1.4 (Lagrange). Lagrange’s bracket corresponding to two integration constants is constant along the trajectory of the representative point P in the phase space Γ 2s . 19.1.2.2 Poisson’s Bracket. Properties Let be the functions ξi = ξi (x1 , x 2 ,..., x n , y1 , y2 ,..., yn ), ηi = ηi (x1 , x 2 ,..., x n , y1 , y2 ,..., yn ), i = 1, 2,..., n ,
of class C 1 . We call Poisson’s brackets (denoted by usual brackets) the sums
(19.1.52)
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
140 ⎡ ∂( ξ , ξ ) ⎤
⎛ ∂ξ j ∂ξk ∂ξ j ∂ξk ⎞ , − ∂yi ∂yi ∂x i ⎟⎠ i i ⎦ ⎣ i =1 i =1 n n ⎡ ∂ ( η j , ηk ) ⎤ ⎛ ∂η j ∂ηk ∂η j ∂ηk ⎞ , = ∑ det ⎢ = ∑⎜ − ⎥ ∂yi ∂x i ⎟⎠ ⎣ ∂ ( x i , yi ) ⎦ i =1 ⎝ ∂x i ∂yi i =1 n n ⎡ ∂ ( ξ j , ηk ) ⎤ ⎛ ∂ξ j ∂ηk ∂ξ j ∂ηk ⎞ = ∑⎜ − , = ∑ det ⎢ ⎥ ∂yi ∂x i ⎟⎠ ⎣ ∂ (x i , yi ) ⎦ i =1 ⎝ ∂x i ∂yi i =1 n
( ξj , ξk ) = ∑ det ⎢ ∂ (xj , yk ) ⎥ ( η j , ηk ) ( ξj , ηk )
=
n
∑ ⎜⎝ ∂xi
(19.1.52')
for j , k = 1, 2,..., n ; these brackets are anticommutative too (skew-symmetric with respect to the indices j and k )
( ξj , ξk ) = − ( ξk , ξj ) , ( η j , ηk ) = − ( ηk , η j ) , ( ξ j , ηk ) = − ( ηk , ξj ) .
(19.1.52'')
In quantum mechanics, Poisson’s brackets are usually denoted in the form [ ξ j , ξk ] , [ η j , ηk ] , [ ξ j , ηk ] .
Let us put in evidence the connection between Lagrange’s and Poisson ’s brackets in a unitary form; we will consider 2n functions f j = f j (x1 , x 2 ,..., x n , y1 , y2 ,..., yn ) , j = 1, 2,..., 2n , for which ∂ ( f1 , f2 ,..., f2 n ) ⎡ ⎤ det ⎢ ≠ 0; ⎣ ∂ (x1 , x 2 ,..., x n , y1 , y2 ,..., yn ) ⎥⎦
so that, in this case, we can calculate x i = x i ( f1 , f2 ,..., f2 n ) , yi = yi ( f1 , f2 ,..., f2 n ) , i = 1, 2,..., n . Observing that 2n
2 n ∂f ∂y ∂f ∂x k k = δ jk , ∑ i = 0, ∂fi i = 1 ∂x j ∂fi
∑ ∂xij
i =1 2n
2 n ∂f ∂y ∂f ∂x k k = 0, ∑ i = δ jk , ∂fi ∂ y ∂ f j i i =1
∑ ∂yij
i =1
∂fp ∂xl ∂fp ∂yl ⎞ + = δpq , ∂fq ∂yl ∂fq ⎟⎠
∑ ⎛⎜⎝ ∂xl n
l =1
for j , k = 1, 2,..., n and p , q = 1, 2,..., 2n , we obtain, easily, 2n
∑ [ fi , fj ] ( fi , fk ) = δ jk , j , k
i =1
In detail, we can write
= 1, 2,..., 2n .
(19.1.53)
Hamiltonian Mechanics
141
2n
∑ {[ ξi , ξj ] ( ξi , ξk ) + [ ηi , ξj ] ( ηi , ξk )} = δ jk
,
∑ {[ ξi , ξj ] ( ξi , ηk ) + [ ηi , ξj ] ( ηi , ηk )} = δ jk
,
i =1 n
i =1 n
∑ {[ ξi , η j ] ( ξi , ξk ) + [ ηi , η j ] ( ηi , ξk )} = δ jk ,
.
(19.1.53')
i =1 2n
∑ {[ ξi , η j ] ( ξi , ηk ) + [ ηi , η j ] ( ηi , ηk )} = δ jk
,
i =1
for j , k = 1, 2,..., n . In case of a Hamiltonian system, let be the functions
ϕ = ϕ (q j , p j ; t ) ,
ψ = ψ (q j , p j ; t ) of class C ; the corresponding Poisson’s bracket is 1
[ ϕ, ψ ] =
∂ϕ ∂q j
∂ψ ∂q j
∂ϕ ∂p j
∂ψ ∂p j
=
∂ϕ ∂ψ ∂ϕ ∂ψ − . ∂q j ∂p j ∂p j ∂q j
(19.1.54)
We mention the obvious properties (ϕ , ϕ ) = 0, (ϕ ,C ) = 0, (C ϕ, ψ ) = C (ϕ , ψ ), C = const, (ϕ , ψ ) = −( ψ , ϕ ), ( − ϕ , ψ ) = −(ϕ , ψ ) ,
(19.1.55)
as well as the properties ( f ,q j ) = −
∂f ∂f , ( f , pj ) = − , j = 1, 2,..., s , ∂p j ∂q j
(q j , qk ) = 0, ( p j , pk ) = 0, (q j , pk ) = −( p j , qk ) = δ jk , j , k = 1, 2,..., s .
(19.1.55') (19.1.55'')
Starting from the relation of definition (19.1.54), it results, as well, (ϕ1 + ϕ2 , ψ ) = (ϕ1 , ψ ) + (ϕ2 , ψ ), (ϕ1ϕ2 , ψ ) = ϕ1 (ϕ2 , ψ ) + ϕ2 (ϕ1 , ψ ),
(19.1.55''')
where we have used the formulae of differentiation of the sum and of the product of two functions. The formula of differentiation of a function of function leads to (ϕ , ψ ) = (ϕ , ψ ) =
m
∂ϕ
∑ (Pj , ψ ) ∂Pj
,
∂ϕ ∂ψ ⎛ ∂ϕ ∂ψ − P Pk ∂Q j ∂ ∂ k j =1 k =1 m
m
∑ ∑ ⎜⎝ ∂Qj
(19.1.56)
j =1
⎞ ⎟(Q j , Pk ) , ⎠
(19.1.56')
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
142
where ϕ = ϕ (Q j , Pj ) , ψ = ψ (Q j , Pj ) , with Q j = Q j (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., ps ; t ), Pj = Pj (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., ps ; t ), j = 1, 2,..., m .
We can calculate ∂2 ϕ ∂ψ ∂ϕ ∂2 ψ ∂2 ϕ ∂ψ ∂ϕ ∂2 ψ ∂ ( ϕ, ψ ) = + − − ∂t ∂t ∂q j ∂p j ∂q j ∂t ∂p j ∂t ∂p j ∂q j ∂p j ∂t ∂q j ∂ϕ ∂ψ ∂ϕ ∂ψ ∂ϕ ∂ψ ∂ϕ ∂ψ = − + − , ∂q j ∂p j ∂p j ∂q j ∂q j ∂p j ∂p j ∂q j
where we assume the continuity of the derivatives of second order and where the point indicates the differentiation with respect to time; there results ∂ (ϕ , ψ ) = (ϕ , ψ ) + (ϕ, ψ ) . ∂t
(19.1.57)
Introducing the differential operator Dϕ =
∂ϕ ∂ ∂ϕ ∂ , − ∂q j ∂p j ∂p j ∂q j
(19.1.58)
where ϕ ∈ C 1 is a given function, we can express Poisson’s bracket in the form ( ϕ, ψ ) = Dϕ ψ .
(19.1.58')
Let be χ = χ (q j , p j ; t ) ; we assume that the functions ϕ , ψ and χ are of class C 2 . Taking into account the expression of Poisson’s brackets in the form (19.2.58'), we can write ( ϕ, ( ψ , χ ) ) − ( ψ , ( ϕ , χ ) ) = ( Dϕ Dψ − Dψ Dϕ ) χ = Dχ ∂ϕ ∂ψ ∂2 ∂ϕ ∂2 ϕ ∂ ∂ϕ ∂ψ ∂2 ⎡ ∂ϕ ∂2 ψ ∂ = ⎢ + − − ∂q j ∂qk ∂p j ∂pk ∂q j ∂p j ∂pk ∂qk ∂q j ∂pk ∂p j ∂qk ⎣ ∂q j ∂p j ∂qk ∂pk 2 2 2 ∂ϕ ∂ ψ ∂ ∂ϕ ∂ψ ∂ ∂ϕ ∂ ψ ∂ ∂ϕ ∂ψ ∂2 − − + + ∂p j ∂q j ∂qk ∂pk ∂p j ∂qk ∂q j ∂pk ∂p j ∂q j ∂pk ∂qk ∂p j ∂pk ∂q j ∂qk ∂ψ ∂ϕ ∂2 ∂ψ ∂2 ϕ ∂ ∂ψ ∂ ∂2 ⎛ ∂ψ ∂2 ϕ ∂ −⎜ + − − ∂q j ∂qk ∂p j ∂pk ∂q j ∂p j ∂pk ∂qk ∂q j ∂pk ∂p j ∂qk ⎝ ∂q j ∂p j ∂qk ∂pk ∂ψ ∂2 ϕ ∂ ∂ψ ∂ϕ ∂2 ∂ψ ∂2 ϕ ∂ ∂ψ ∂ϕ ∂2 ⎞ ⎤ − − + + χ. ∂p j ∂q j ∂qk ∂pk ∂p j ∂qk ∂q j ∂pk ∂p j ∂q j ∂pk ∂qk ∂p j ∂pk ∂q j ∂qk ⎟⎠ ⎦⎥
Hamiltonian Mechanics
143
Observing that the operators of second order are of the form
∂ψ ∂ϕ ⎞ ∂2 ⎛ ∂ϕ ∂ψ ⎜ ∂q ∂q − ∂q ∂q ⎟ ∂p ∂p = 0 j j k ⎠ k ⎝ j k or of the form
−
∂ϕ ∂ψ ∂2 ∂ψ ∂ϕ ∂2 + = 0, ∂q j ∂pk ∂p j ∂qk ∂p j ∂qk ∂q j ∂pk
the commutator D will be also an operator of first order; we remain with ∂χ ⎛ ∂ϕ ∂2 ψ ∂ϕ ∂2 ψ ∂ψ ∂2 ϕ ∂ψ ∂2 ϕ ⎞ + − − ⎜ ∂qk ⎝ ∂q j ∂q j ∂pk ∂q j ∂p j ∂pk ∂q j ∂p j ∂pk ∂p j ∂q j ∂pk ⎟⎠ ∂χ ⎛ ∂ϕ ∂2 ψ ∂ϕ ∂2 ψ ∂ψ ∂2 ϕ ∂ψ ∂2 ϕ ⎞ − + − − ∂pk ⎜⎝ ∂p j ∂q j ∂qk ∂q j ∂p j ∂qk ∂q j ∂p j ∂qk ∂p j ∂q j ∂qk ⎟⎠ = Dχ ( ψ, ϕ ) = − Dχ (ϕ , ψ ) = − ( χ,(ϕ , ψ ) ) .
Finally, we get the Poisson–Jacobi identity ( ϕ , ( ψ , χ ) ) + ( ψ , ( χ , ϕ ) ) + ( χ, ( ϕ , ψ ) ) = 0 .
(19.1.59)
As a matter of fact, in the left member of this identity one observes that each term will have as factor a derivative of second order of one of the functions ϕ , ψ or χ . But all the derivatives of second order of the function χ vanish, as it has been shown; the expression in the above identity is obtained by circular permutations of the first Poisson bracket, so that the derivatives of second order of the functions ϕ and ψ will be equal to zero too, the identity being thus proved. If we take ϕ = q j or ϕ = p j and ψ = H , we obtain (corresponding to the formulae (19.1.55'))
(qj ,H ) =
∂H , ( pj , H ∂p j
)=
−
∂H , j = 1, 2,..., s . ∂q j
(19.1.60)
Hamilton’s equations (19.1.14) take the form q j = ( q j , H ) , p j = ( p j , H
)j
used in the quantic modelling of mechanics.
= 1, 2,..., s ,
(19.1.60')
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
144
19.1.2.3 First Integrals of the Canonical System Let be f = f (q j , p j ; t ) a first integral of Hamilton’s canonical system, which is constant along the trajectory of the representative point P ∈ Γ 2s ; thus, we will have ∂f ∂f df = q + p + f = 0 . ∂q j j ∂p j j dt
Taking into account the equations (19.1.14), this necessary condition becomes
( f , H ) + f = 0 ,
(19.1.61)
where we use Poisson’s bracket. As well, starting from the partial differential equation of first order ∂f ∂H ∂f ∂H − + f = 0 , ∂q j ∂p j ∂p j ∂q j
we can write the associate characteristic system (the Lagrange–Charpit sequence) in the form (19.1.19), hence in the form of Hamilton’s equations. Hence, we can state Theorem 19.1.5 (Poisson). The function f = f (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., ps ; t ) ∈ C 1 is a first integral of the canonical system (19.1.14) only and only if the relation (19.1.61) (which is thus a necessary and sufficient condition) holds. If f = 0 , hence if the function f does not depend explicitly on time ( f = f (q j , p j ) ), then the condition (19.1.61) becomes (f ,H ) = 0 .
(19.1.61')
In the particular case f = H we find again the first integral of the generalized mechanical energy. Performing the partial differentiation of the relation (19.1.61) with respect to time and taking into account (19.1.57), we can write ( f , H ) + ( f , H ) + f = 0 ; if H = 0 , corresponding to a generalized conservative mechanical system; then we remain with the relation
( f , H ) +
∂f =0 ∂t
and we can state Theorem 19.1.6 (Poisson). If f = f (q j , p j ; t ) is a first integral for Hamilton’s equations of a generalized conservative mechanical system, then f , f,... are, as well, first integrals for this system. If we make χ = H in the Poisson–Jacobi identity, that one takes the form (ϕ ,( ψ, H )) + ( ψ,( H , ϕ )) + (H ,(ϕ , ψ )) = 0 ; assuming that
Hamiltonian Mechanics
145
(ϕ , H ) + ϕ = 0, ( ψ, H ) + ψ = 0
(19.1.62)
and taking into account the properties (19.1.55), (19.1.57), we can write ((ϕ , ψ ), H ) +
∂ (ϕ , ψ ) = 0 . ∂t
(19.1.62')
We state thus Theorem 19.1.7 (Jacobi–Poisson). If we suppose that the functions ϕ = ϕ (q j , p j ; t ), ψ = ψ (q j , p j ; t ) ∈ C 2 are first integrals of the canonical system (19.1.14), then Poisson’s bracket (ϕ , ψ ) is a first integral of the system. Starting from the first integrals H , ϕ , ψ , one can build up new first integrals of the form ϕ , ϕ,..., ψ , ψ,...,( H , ϕ ),( H , ψ ),(ϕ,(ϕ, ψ )),(ϕ ,( H , ψ )) etc., by means of the last two theorems. Thus, one can obtain, at a given moment, a constant or a first integral which is not independent on the previous first integrals; indeed, the canonical system admits at the most 2s distinct first integrals. If, by setting up a Poisson bracket of the first integrals ϕ and ψ , we get (ϕ , ψ ) = C , C = const
(19.1.63)
(ϕ , ψ ) = C (ϕ, ψ ), C = const ,
(19.1.63')
or
which is – practically – the same thing, then we say that the two first integrals are canonically conjugate. Moreover, if, in particular, (ϕ , ψ ) = 0 ,
then we say that the first integrals More general, let us consider α = 1, 2,...,r ; after S. Lie, the ( fα , fβ ) = fαβ ( f1 , f2 ,..., fr ), α, β
(19.1.64)
ϕ and ψ are in involution.
the functions fα = fα (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., ps ; t ) , set of these functions forms a functional group if = 1, 2,..., r , hence if Poisson’s bracket of two
functions of this set is a function of the functions which belong to the set. These notions have been used by S. Lie in the study of Hamilton’s system of equations. 19.1.2.4 Theorem of Lie. Theorem of Liouville Let us suppose that r first integrals f j = f j (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p1 , p2 ,..., ps ; t ) of the canonical system are known, so that
( f j , H ) + fj = 0, j = 1, 2,..., r . Assuming that these first integrals are in involution, we can write
(19.1.65)
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
146
( f j , fk ) ≡ 0, j , k = 1, 2,..., r .
(19.1.65')
Thus, the system of functions { f j , j = 1, 2,..., r } will be a system in involution. Let us introduce the conjugate variables p0 and q 0 = t , so that ∂H / ∂p0 = 0 , ∂f j / ∂p0 = 0, j = 1, 2,..., r . Let be, in general, the functions ϕ and ψ of variables q 0 , q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p0 , p1 , p2 ,..., ps . We can set up Poisson’s bracket ∂ϕ ∂ψ ∂ϕ ∂ψ − + (ϕ , ψ ) , ∂t ∂p0 ∂p0 ∂t
(ϕ , ψ )0 =
(19.1.66)
where we put the index zero so to specify the introduction of the variables q 0 and p0 ; if ∂ϕ / ∂p0 = ∂ψ / ∂p0 = 0 , then we have (ϕ , ψ )0 = (ϕ, ψ ) . Denoting f0 = H + p0 and observing that fj + ( f j , H ) = ( f j , f0 )0 = 0 , we can express the relations (19.1.65), (19.1.65') in the unitary form ( f j , fk )0 = 0, j , k = 1, 2,..., r .
(19.1.67)
We assume that the equations f j = c j , c j = const, j = 1, 2,..., r , and H + p0 = 0 lead to pk = ϕk (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , pr +1 , pr + 2 ,..., ps , c1 , c2 ,..., c2 s ; t ), p0 = H
= − H = ϕ0 (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , pr + 1 , pr + 2 ,..., ps , c1 , c2 ,..., c2 s ; t ) ,
pk = ϕk
(19.1.68)
for k = 1, 2,..., r . If u is one of the variables q 0 , q1 , q2 ,..., qs , p0 , pr +1 , pr + 2 ,..., ps , then we can write ∂f j + ∂u
r
∂f j ∂ϕα = 0, j = 1, 2,..., r , ∂u
∑ ∂pα
α =0
or ∂f j = ∂u
r
∂f j ∂ ( pα − ϕα ) , j = 1, 2,..., r . ∂u
∑ ∂pα
α =0
We notice that these equations become identities if u is one of the variable p0 , p1 , p2 ,..., pr . We can thus write ∂f j ∂fk = ∂qi ∂pi
r
r
∂f j ∂f ∂ ( pα − ϕα ) ∂ ( pβ − ϕβ ) , i = 0,1, 2,..., s . ∂qi ∂pi
∑ ∑ ∂pα ∂pkβ
α =0 β =0
Taking the double of the skew-symmetric part with respect to the indices j and k , it results
( fj , fk )0
=
r
r
∂f j ∂f
∑ ∑ ∂pα ∂pkβ ( pα
α =0 β =0
− ϕα , pβ − ϕβ )0 , j , k = 0,1, 2,..., m .
(19.1.69)
Hamiltonian Mechanics
147
The conditions (19.1.67) read r
∂f j
∑ ∂pα z α( k )
∂f
r
∑ ∂pkβ ( pα
= 0, z α( k ) =
α =0
β =0
− ϕα , pβ − ϕβ ) ,
α, j , k = 0,1, 2,..., r .
(19.1.67')
Fixing k , one obtains a system of r + 1 linear algebraic equations with det[ ∂f j / ∂pα ] ≠ 0 , by the previous hypothesis; we get z ( k ) = 0 , hence also a system of r + 1 linear algebraic equations with the same non-zero determinant of the coefficients. Finally, ( pα − ϕα , pβ − ϕβ ) = 0 or ( p j − ϕ j , pk − ϕk )0 = 0, j , k = 0,1, 2,..., r .
(19.1.70)
In an expanded form, we can write ∂ϕ j ∂ϕk ⎞ ⎛ ∂ϕ j ∂ϕk ⎜ ∂q ∂p − ∂p ∂p ⎟ σ σ σ σ ⎠ σ =r +1 ⎝ ∂ϕ j ∂ϕ = − k , j , k = 0,1, 2,..., r . ∂qk ∂q j
( ϕj , ϕk )sσ =r +1
=
s
∑
(19.1.70')
These conditions show that the functions f1 , f2 ,..., fr are first integrals of the canonical system, being two by two in involution. Replacing p j by ϕ j , j = 1, 2,..., r , −H by ϕ0 and dt by dq 0 in the Pfaff form of Hamilton (19.1.45), we obtain the form ω =
r
∑ ϕ j dq j
+
j =0
s
∑
pσ dq σ ,
(19.1.71)
σ =r +1
the bilinear covariant of which is given by ∂ϕ j ⎞ δq ρ ⎟ dq j ∂ p ρ j =0 ⎝ k =0 ρ =r +1 ⎠ s s r s s ∂ϕ j ∂ϕ j ⎛ ⎞ ∂pσ + ∑ ∑ δpρ dq σ − ∑ ⎜ ∑ dqk + ∑ dpρ ⎟ δq j ∂ ∂ ∂ p q p ρ ρ k j =0 ⎝ k =0 σ =r +1 ρ =r +1 ρ =r +1 ⎠ ω ′ = δωd − dωδ =
r
⎛
s
∂ϕ j
∑ ⎜ ∑ ∂qk
δqk +
s
∑
⎡ ⎛ r ∂ϕ j ∂ϕ ⎞ ∑ ⎢ ⎜ ∑ ∂qk − ∂q kj ⎟ dq j k =0 ⎣ ⎝ j =0 ⎠ s s s r ∂ϕ s ⎛ ∂ϕk ∂ϕk ∂pσ j ⎤ ⎞ dpρ ⎥ δqk + ∑ ⎜ ∑ dq j − ∑ dpρ ⎟ δq σ − ∑ dq ρ − ∑ ∂ ∂ ∂ p q p ∂ q ρ σ ρ ρ ⎦ ⎠ ρ =r +1 ρ =r +1 σ =r +1 ⎝ j = 0 ρ =r +1 −
∂pσ ∑ ∑ ∂pρ dpρ δqσ = σ =r +1 ρ =r +1 s
s
+
s
⎛
r
∂ϕ j
∑ ⎜ ∑ ∂pρ dq j
ρ =r +1 ⎝ j = 0
+
r
∂pσ ⎞ dq σ ⎟ δpρ . ∂ p ρ ⎠ σ =r +1 s
∑
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
148
The associate differential system, obtained by equating to zero the brackets which multiply the differential variations δq σ and δpσ , is written in the form r ∂ϕ ∂ϕ j j dq j , dpσ = − ∑ dq j , σ = r + 1, r + 2,..., s . ∂ ∂ p q σ σ j =0 j =0 r
dq σ = − ∑
(19.1.72)
The equations obtained by annulling the square brackets which multiply the differential variations δqk are identically verified if one takes into account the conditions (19.1.70') and the equations (19.1.72). The functions ϕ j , j = 0,1, 2,..., r , being thus determined, the system (19.1.72) becomes a system of 2(s − r ) equations with 2(s − r ) unknown functions. Corresponding to Morera’s method of integration, we introduce an arbitrary parameter λ , so that q j = q j (λ ), j = 0,1, 2,..., r . Denoting r
K (qr + 1 , qr + 2 ,..., qs , pr + 1 , pr + 2 ,..., ps , c1 , c2 ,..., c2 s ; λ ) = − ∑ ϕ j j =0
dq j , dλ
(19.1.73)
the system of equation (19.1.71) reads q σ′ =
dq σ ∂K dpσ ∂K = , pσ′ = = − , σ = r + 1, r + 2,..., s . dλ ∂pσ dλ ∂q σ
(19.1.72')
As a matter of fact, starting from the Pfaff form ω =
s
∑
σ =r +1
pσ dq σ − Kdλ ,
(19.1.71')
one obtains the same result. We can thus state Theorem 19.1.8 (S. Lie). If the system of 2s canonical equations (19.1.14) admits r , r ≤ s , first integrals in involution, resolvable with respect to r , of the generalized momenta, then the integration of this system is reduced to the integration of a system of 2(s − r ) canonical equations in s − r pairs of conjugate variables and to quadratures. The generalized co-ordinates q1 , q2 ,..., qr are then determined, using the relation ϕ k = −
∂H , k = 1, 2,..., r . ∂qk
(19.1.74)
In the particular case r = s , we notice that ∂ϕ j / ∂pk = 0, j , k = 0,1, 2,..., s , and from (19.1.70') it results ∂ϕ j ∂ϕk = , j , k = 0,1, 2,..., s . ∂qk ∂q j
(19.1.75)
Hamiltonian Mechanics
149
Thus, we can state that the existence (necessary and sufficient conditions) of a function S = S (q 0 , q1 , q2 ,..., qs ; a1 , a2 ,..., as ) is ensured, so that ∂S ∂S = ϕj , = S = ϕ0 = − H ∂q j ∂q 0
p j = ϕj
, j = 1, 2,..., s .
(19.1.75')
Hence, dS =
s
∂S
∑ ∂q j
j =0
dq j =
s
∑ ϕ j dq j ,
j =0
(19.1.75'')
and we can state Theorem 19.1.9 (Liouville). If the system of 2s canonical equations (19.1.14) admits s first integrals in involution, resolvable with respect to the generalized momenta, then the integration of this system is reduced to quadratures. We notice that the function S satisfies the partial differential equation of first order ∂S ∂S ∂S ⎞ , ,..., S + H ⎛⎜ q 0 , q1 ,..., qs , = 0, ∂q1 ∂q2 ∂qs ⎟⎠ ⎝
(19.1.76)
called the Hamilton–Jacobi equation, and the condition
⎡ ∂2S ⎤ ⎡ ∂ϕ j ⎤ det ⎢ = det ⎢ ⎥ ⎥ ≠ 0, ⎣ ∂ak ⎦ ⎣ ∂q j ∂ak ⎦ assuming that the function ϕ j
(19.1.76')
are resolvable with respect to the constant
ak , j , k = 1, 2,..., s ; in this case, S is the complete integral of the Hamilton–Jacobi
equation (see Sect. 19.2.1.1 too). If H = 0, fj = 0, j = 1,2,..., s , hence if the Hamiltonian and the first integrals do not contain explicitly the time, then the functions ϕ j have the same property, so that S (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , a1 , a2 ,..., as ; t ) = S (q1 , q2 ,..., qs , a1 , a2 ,..., as ) + T (t ; a1 , a2 ,..., as ) .
From (19.1.75'), it results T = ϕ0 ; but (19.1.75) shows that ϕ0 = − h , h = const , obtaining S = − ht + S . Let be a generalized conservative mechanical system ( H = 0 ), the canonical system (19.1.14) of which admits s − 1 independent first integrals f j , j = 1, 2,..., s − 1 , in involution, which do not contain explicitly the time ( fj = 0 ). The s th first integral is H and the other first integrals must verify the conditions ( f j , H ) = 0, j = 1, 2,..., s − 1 ; hence, H is also in involution with these first integrals and we can apply Liouville’s theorem.
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
150
If, in case of the motion of a heavy rigid solid about a fixed point, beside the first integral of the moment of momentum and the first integral of the kinetic energy we can set up a third integral, in involution with the first two ones, then the integration of the equations of motion is reduced to quadratures, according to Liouville’s theorem. 19.1.2.5 Other Formulations in the Spaces Λs and Γ 2s We have built up the Lagrangian formalism in the space Λs to study the motion of the representative point P , while in the space Γ 2s we have used the Hamiltonian formalism to determine the motion of the corresponding representative point; but these formalisms are not the only ones which can be used. For instance, starting from the relation (19.2.15'), we notice that one can write d δ ⎡ ( pj q j ⎣⎢ dt
)−L
⎤ = q δp + q δp j j j j ⎦⎥
too. Denoting ϕ =
d (p q dt j j
)−L
(19.1.77)
,
we obtain qj =
∂ϕ ∂ϕ , q = , j = 1, 2,..., s , ∂p j j ∂p j
(19.1.77')
hence, relations of the form (19.1.13); one obtain thus, easily, a system of differential equations of second order
d ⎛ ∂ϕ ⎞ ∂ϕ − = 0, j = 1,2,..., s , dt ⎜⎝ ∂p j ⎟⎠ ∂p j
(19.1.77'')
analogue to Lagrange’s equations (the place of the generalized co-ordinates is taken by the generalized momenta). But, to can set up the function ϕ , we must solve the system of equations (19.1.13) with respect to q j and q j , function of pk and pk , which is difficult – in general – this system being non-linear in the generalized co-ordinates. We can start also from the relation δ ( q j p j − L
) = q j δp j
− p j δq j .
We denote
ψ = q j p j − L
(19.1.78)
and obtain the system of equations qj =
∂ψj ∂ψj , pj = − . ∂p j ∂q j
(19.1.78')
Hamiltonian Mechanics
151
In this case too, the difficulty consists in expressing the generalized co-ordinates as functions of the derivatives with respect to time of the generalized momenta, using the second subsystem (19.1.13).
19.1.3 Applications We consider, firstly, the motion of a single particle; we pass then to a Hamiltonian treatment of a system of two or more particles, as well as to the case of a rigid solid or of a system of rigid solids. 19.1.3.1 Motion of a Particle In general, the generalized momentum is defined by the relation (18.2.80). In case of a generalized quasi-potential intervenes the vector part in the form (18.2.81); to simplify the presentation, we assume, in what follows, that the generalized forces derive from a simple quasi-potential, the generalized momenta being thus given by the relations (18.2.80'). We use the results obtained in Sect. 18.3.2.1. In case of a single particle P (x1 , x 2 , x 3 ) , the representative point in Γ 6 is expressed by P (q1 , q2 , q 3 , p1 , p2 , p3 ), q j = x j , j = 1, 2, 3 , so that the kinetic energy is given by
T = (m / 2)( x12 + x22 + x 32 ) , while the generalized momenta (equal to the usual components of the momentum) are p j = mx j , j = 1, 2, 3 .
(19.1.79)
Hamilton’s function becomes (we use the formula of definition (19.1.11) with (18.2.3.4)) 1 p p − U (x1 , x 2 , x 3 ; t ) , 2m j j
H =
(19.1.79')
while the canonical equations (19.1.14) read x j =
1 ∂U p , p = , j = 1, 2, 3 . m j j ∂x j
(19.1.79'')
In cylindrical co-ordinates ( q1 = r , q2 = θ , q 3 = z ), we obtain
pr = mr , pθ = mr 2 θ , pz = mz .
(19.1.80)
Hamilton’s function being H =
(
)
1 1 pr2 + 2 pθ2 + pz2 − U (r , θ , z ; t ) , 2m r
There result the canonical equations
(19.1.80')
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
152
1 1 1 pr , θ = pθ , z = pz , m m mr 2 ∂U ∂U 1 2 ∂U pr = p + , p θ = , p z = . 3 θ ∂ r ∂ θ ∂z mr r =
(19.1.80'')
If ∂U / ∂θ = ∂U / ∂z = 0 , then θ and z are cyclic co-ordinates. As well, in spherical co-ordinates ( q1 = r , q2 = θ , q 3 = ϕ ) we can write
pr = mr , pθ = mr 2 θ, pϕ = mr 2 sin2 θϕ ,
(19.1.81)
so that H =
(
)
1 1 1 pr2 + 2 pθ2 + 2 pϕ2 − U (r , θ , ϕ ; t ) . 2m r r sin2 θ
(19.1.81')
We get Hamilton’s equations 1 1 1 pr , θ = p , ϕ = pϕ , 2 θ 2 m mr mr sin2 θ ∂U 1 1 pr = pθ2 + pϕ2 + , ∂r mr 3 sin2 θ ∂U ∂U cot θ p θ = pϕ2 + , pϕ = . 2 2 ∂ϕ ∂ϕ mr sin θ
r =
(
)
(19.1.81'')
If ∂U / ∂ϕ = 0 , then ϕ is a cyclic co-ordinate. We notice that, in case of a simple potential of the form (18.3.46), we find a system of canonical equations equivalent to Lagrange’s equations (18.3.47). In case of a central force of Newtonian attraction we have U = k / r , k > 0 , so that ∂U / ∂r = − k / r 2 , ∂U / ∂θ = ∂U / ∂ϕ = 0 .
As a matter of fact, in case of a central force the trajectory is a plane curve; if the intensity of this force is function only on the distance to the fixed pole, Hamilton’s function will be given by (in polar co-ordinates, in the plane of the motion, the fixed pole being the origin of the co-ordinate axes) H =
(
)
m 2 1 1 ( r + r 2 θ2 ) − U (r ) = 2m pr2 + 2 pθ2 − U (r ) . 2 r
(19.1.82)
There result Hamilton’s equations in Γ 4 r =
1 1 1 2 ∂U pr , θ = p , pr = pθ + , p θ = 0 , 2 θ m ∂r mr mr 3
(19.1.82')
θ being a cyclic co-ordinate; we obtain pθ = mC , C = const , and then r 2 θ = c ,
hence the first integral of areas. Eliminating the generalized momentum pr and taking into account the first integral previously obtain, we can write
Hamiltonian Mechanics
153 r =
C2 1 ∂U + . 3 m ∂r r
(19.1.82'')
We find thus the equation of motion of the particle along the vector radius (see Sect. 8.1.1.1, formula (8.1.3)); the first integral H = h corresponds to the first integral (8.1.6'). In elliptical co-ordinates (see Sect. 18.3.2.1), the formula (18.3.41) leads to p1 =
m m m A q , p = A2q2 , p3 = A3q3 ; 4 1 1 2 4 4
Hamilton’s function will be given by H =
2 ⎛ p12 p22 p32 ⎞ + + −U , m ⎜⎝ A1 A2 A3 ⎟⎠
(19.1.83)
with U = U (q1 , q2 , q 3 ; t ) , allowing thus to write the canonical equations in the form q1 = p j =
4 p1 4 p2 4 p3 , q = , q = , m A1 2 m A2 3 m A3
p32 ∂A3 ⎞ 2 ⎛ p12 ∂A1 p22 ∂A2 + + ⎟ , j = 1, 2, 3 . m ⎜⎝ A12 ∂q j A22 ∂q j A32 ∂q j ⎠
(19.1.83')
The generalized momenta p j , given by (19.1.79), are the components of the momentum H = p ; the components of the moment of momentum KO = r × p will be KOi = ∈ijk x j pk = m ∈ijk x j xk , j = 1, 2, 3 .
(19.1.84)
We can thus form Poisson’s brackets ∂p j ∂pk ∂p j ∂pk , − ∂x i ∂pi ∂pi ∂x i ∂ (∈jlm xl pm ) ∂ (∈knr x n pr ) ∂ (∈jlm xl pr ) ∂ (∈knr x n pm ) (KOj , KOk ) = − ∂x i ∂pi ∂pi ∂x i ( p j , pk ) =
=∈jlm ∈kni x n pm − ∈jli ∈kir xl pr = ( ∈rji ∈kli + ∈jli ∈kri ) xl pr = ( δrk δ jl − δ jr δlk ) xl pr =∈ijk ∈ilr xl pr , ∂p j ∂ (∈klm xl pm ) ∂p j ∂ (∈klm xl pm ) − ∂x i ∂pi ∂pi ∂x i = −δij δil ∈klm pm = − ∈kjm pm ,
( p j , KOk ) =
MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, CLASSICAL MODELS
154 so that
( p j , pk ) = 0,(KOi , KOk ) =∈ijk KOi , ( p j , KOk ) =∈ijk pi , j , k = 1, 2, 3 .
(19.1.85)
If some of the above quantities are conserved (are first integrals), then also the other quantities have the same property (the Jacobi–Poisson theorem leads to new first integrals). For instance, if p1 , KO 2 and KO 3 are first integrals, then p2 , p3 and KO 1 are first integrals too; other first integrals cannot be obtained, the cycle being closed. If a particle P is acted upon by an elastic central force of intensity in direct proportion with the distance to the pole O , then the potential U is given by U = −(k / 2)(x12 + x 22 + x 32 ), k = const ; the second group of canonical equations (19.1.79'') reads p j = − kx j , j = 1, 2, 3 .
(19.1.79''')
As it can be easily verified, (19.1.84) are three first integrals of the canonical equations. The first equation of the first subsystem of equations (19.2.79'') and the first equation (19.1.79''') (for j = 1 ) give the first integral f1 = mx12 +
1 2 p . k 1
(19.1.86)
As well, Poisson’s bracket (KO 3 , f1 ) leads to the first integral f2 =
1 p p + mx1x 2 . k 1 2
(19.1.86')
One observes easily that one cannot obtain new first integrals starting from the first integrals (19.1.84), (19.1.86), and (19.1.86') and using the Jacobi–Poisson theorem; indeed, if one could obtain such a first integral, then the functions q j , p j , j = 1, 2, 3 , could be expressed by means of the six integration constants, the generalized momenta being thus constant (which is not possible, because the motion would be annulled). A first integral which (unlike the previous ones) contains explicitly the time is f3 = m ωx1 cos ωt − p1 sin ωt , ω =
k . m
A partial differentiation with respect to time leads to a new first integral f4 = f3 = − m ω 2 x1 sin ωt − p1 ω cos ωt ,
which is not distinct from the previous ones, because f 2 f32 + ⎛⎜ 4 ⎞⎟ = kf1 . ⎝ω⎠
(19.1.86'')
Hamiltonian Mechanics
155
As a matter of fact, the maximum number of first integrals in case of a free particle is six. 19.1.3.2 Problem of Two Particles Be means of the results in Sect. 18.3.2.3 and of the formulae (18.3.51), (18.3.51') for the kinetic energy T and for the simple potential U , respectively, we notice that we can use a formula of the form (19.1.81'); there results Hamilton’s function H =
(
)
fm1m2 1 1 1 pr2 + 2 pθ2 + 2 pϕ2 − . r 2m r r sin2 θ
(19.1.87)
Hence, the canonical equations read 1 1 1 pr , θ = pθ , ϕ = pϕ , m mr 2 mr 2 sin θ fm1m2 1 cot θ , p θ = pθ2 + pϕ2 − pϕ2 , pϕ = 0 . 2 r sin θ mr 2 sin θ r =
pr =
1 mr 3
(
)
(19.1.87')
We see that ϕ is a cyclic co-ordinate, so that pϕ = const is a first integral. We remain only with four canonical equations, determining thus the functions r = r (t ), θ = θ (t ), pr = pr (t ), pθ = pθ (t ) ; we obtain then the generalized angular velocity ϕ and, by a quadrature, we can calculate ϕ = ϕ (t ) too. 19.1.3.3 Motion of an Electrized Particle in an Electromagnetic Field Starting from the results obtained in Sect. 18.3.2.5, we find the generalized momenta pi = mvi + qAi , i = 1, 2, 3 ; the relation of definition (19.1.11) leads to H =
1 1 1 pi ( pi − qAi ) − ( pi − qAi ) ( pi − qAi ) − qAi ( pi − qAi ) + qA0 , 2m m m
where we took account (18.3.59). Finally, we can write Hamilton’s function in the form H =
1 1 ( p − qAi ) ( pi − qAi ) + qA0 = ( p p − 2qpi Ai + q 2 Ai Ai 2m i 2m i i
) + qA0