M a t he mati c a I Physics Proceedings of the 12th Regional Conference
This page intentionally left blank
Ma t he mati c a I Phys ic s Proceedings of the 12th Regional Conference Islamabad, Pakistan
27 March - 1 April 2006
M. Jamil Aslam COMSATS Institute of Information Technology, Pakistan National Centre for Physics, Pakistan
Faheem Hussain COMSATS Institute of Information Technology, Pakistan National Centre for Physics, Pakistan
Asghar Qadir National University of Science & Technology, Pakistan
Riazuddin National Centre for Physics, Pakistan
Hamid Saleem Pakistan Institute of Nuclear Science & Technology, Pakistan
N E W JERSEY
*
LONDON
World Scientific K SINGAPORE
*
BElJlNG
*
SHANGHAI
*
HONG KONG
*
TAIPEI
*
CHENNAI
Published by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd.
5 Toh Tuck Link, Singapore 596224 USA office: 27 Warren Street, Suite 401-402, Hackensack, NJ 07601 UK office: 57 Shelton Street, Covent Garden, London WC2H 9HE
British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
MATHEMATICAL PHYSICS Proceedings of the 12th Regional Conference Copyright 02007 by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd
All rights reserved. This book, or parts thereof; may not be reproduced in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or any information storage and retrieval system now known or to be invented, without written permissionfrom the Publisher.
For photocopying of material in this volume, please pay a copying fee through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA. In this case permission to photocopy is not required from the publisher.
ISBN-I 3 978-98 1-270-591-4 ISBN-10 98 1-270-591-0
Printed in Singapore by World Scientific Printers (S)Pte Ltd
INTERNATIONAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE
Farhad Ardalan, IPM, Tehran Hessameddin Arfaei, IPM, Tehran Alexander Belavin, ITP, Moscow Ugur Camci, Cannakale Ali Chamseddine, CAMS, Beirut John Ellis, CERN, Geneva George Jorjadze, RMI, Tbilisi Elias Kiritsis, Polytechnique, Paris Werner Nahm, IAS, Dublin Neda Sadooghi, IPM, Tehran Spenta Wadia, TIFR, Mumbai
LOCAL ORGANIZING COMMITTEE Kamaluddin Ahmed, CIIT, Islamabad M. Jamil Aslam, NCP, Islamabad Fazal-e- Aleem, CHEP, Lahore Faheem Hussain, CIIT/NCP, Islamabad Jameel-un-Nabi, GIKI, Topi Ghulam Murtaza, GCU, Lahore Asghar Qadir, CAMP-NUST, Rawalpindi Riazuddin, NCP, Islamabad Hamid Saleem, PINSTECH Muhammad Sharif, PU, Lahore Azad A. Siddiqui, CAMP-NUST, Rawalpindi Kashif Sabih, QAU, Islamabad
V
LIST OF SPEAKERS
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31.
B. Acharya* M. Ahmed* Z. Ahmed' M. Alishahiha F. Ardalan M. J . Aslam A. P. Balachandran U. Camci N. K. Dadhich 0. F. Dayi A. Dhar M. Duff I. H. Duru* Z. Ehsan* A. Fayyazudduin D. Ghoshal G. Hall M. Haseeb* P. A. Hoodbhoy T. Z. Hussain V. Hussain Jameel Un Nabi T. Jayaraman* A. Kadeer T. Kaladze A. R. Kashif M. Koca J. G. Korner A. Kumar D. A. Leites S. M. Mahajan
32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43. 44. 45. 46. 47. 48. 49. 50. 51. 52. 53. 54. 55. 56. 57. 58. 59. 60. 61. 62.
A. M. Mirza G. Murtaza* A. Naqvi J . V. Narlikar Maqsood-ul-Hassan Nasim* S. Panda J . Pasupathy' A. Qadir M. A. Rashid Riazuddin K. Saifullah H. Saleem M. Salimullah* S. Sazhenkov A. Sen* G. Shabbir H. A. Shah* M. Sharif S. S. Jabbari A. A. Siddiqui F . Tahir* I. Tarhan* G. Thompson* Hooft, G. 't N. Tsintsadze' G. Unal N. ijnal M. Varadarajan S. Wadia Y . Yan* A. F . Zakharov
*Their lectures could not be included in the proceedings.
vi
PREFACE These are the proceedings of the 12th Regional Conference on Mathematical Physics organized by the National Centre for Physics (NCP) in Islamabad, Pakistan, from 27 March to 1 April, 2006. This series of conferences was initiated by Iranian, Pakistani and Turkish physicists after the meeting at the International Centre for Theoretical Physics (ICTP) in 1986. Strangely, the first conference organized by this group of friends was called the 2nd Regional Conference which was held in Adana, Turkey in September 1987. The “region” referred to originally comprised Iran, Turkey and Pakistan. Over the years the region has expanded to encompass the broad West Asian region including Armenia, Georgia and other Central Asian former Soviet republics. In the east, the region was expanded to include India and Bangladesh. Over the years the regional conference has covered a broad range of topics in Mathematical Physics. In the 12th Regional Conference the topics treated were Particle Physics and String Theory; Relativity, Astrophysics and Cosmology; Plasma Physics; Formal Aspects. There were 23 plenary talks of 45 minutes each which took place in the mornings, which were for all participants. The afternoons were devoted to 38 specialized halfhour talks spread over two parallel sessions: one for Superstring Theory, High Energy Physics and Formal Aspects; the other for Relativity, Astrophysics, Cosmology and Plasma Physics. There were 163 participants from 15 countries, of whom 60 were speakers and 40 were from abroad. It was particularly heartening to see the enthusiastic participation of many young Pakistani students. There was also one evening lecture on “Abdus Salam at Imperial College” by Michael Duff, Abdus Salam Chair of Theoretical Physics at the Imperial College of Science, Technology and Medicine, in London, England. Apart from Michael Duff, participants included leading physicists from around the world, in particular Gerard ’t Hooft, the winner of the Nobel Prize for Physics in 1999. The organizers were particularly pleased
vii
viii
about the enthusiastic participation of a large contingent of colleagues from India. Our arrangement of the material is simple. We present all papers on Formal Aspects in Part I, Particle Physics and String Theory in Part 11, Plasma Physics in Part I11 and Relativity, Astrophysics and Cosmology in Part IV. Articles in each section are arranged in alphabetic order (by author’s name). Plenary talks are indicated by an asterisk. In our opinion the conference was a great success. To make this possible, financial and institutional support was necessary. The NCP provided the primary institutional support. We are most grateful to Prof. Qasim Jan, Vice-Chancellor of Quaid-i-Azam University, for also providing institutional support including use of the Geophysics and Physics Auditorium. The conference was co-sponsored by (as it is now known) the Abdus Salam ICTP, Trieste, Italy, the Higher Education Commission (HEC), Islamabad and the National University of Sciences and Technology (NUST), Rawalpindi. We are particularly grateful for the generous financial support provided by the Abdus Salam ICTP and the HEC. We are also indebted to the Pakistan Atomic Energy Commission (PAEC) for financial support. We would also like to thank the members of the International Advisory Committee and the Local Organising Committee for valuable advice. It is worth mentioning that two other Proceedings, of the 3rd and the 11th conferences that were held in 1988 and 2004 respectively, were also published by World Scientific in 1989 and 2005. Without the help of the staff of the NCP the conference would not have been a success. Our special thanks go to Ubaidullah Khalid, Gulzaman Khan, Kashif Sarfraz Khan, Mansoor Sheikh, Ashfaq Ahmad and the staff of the computer section. Special thanks go also to all the students of the NCP (far too many t o name here) who voluntarily did all the tough legwork to make the running of the conference a great success. We would also like to thank Alimjan Kadeer who came from afar t o help with organizing the conference.
M. Jamil Aslam Faheem Hussain Asghar Qadir Riazuddin Hamid Saleem Islamabad, Pakistan November 2006
This page intentionally left blank
TABLE OF CONTENTS Formal Aspects
1
Noncommutative Geometry: Fuzzy Spaces, the Groenwald-Moyal Plane A.P. Balachandran* and B.A. Qureshi
3
S-Dualities in Noncommutative and Non-anticommutative Field Theories O.F. Dayi, L. T. Kelleyane, K. Ulker and B. Yapigkan
12
New Casimir Energy Calculations H. Ahmedov and I.H. Durn
21
Quaternionic and Octonionic Structures of the Exceptional Lie Algebras M. Koca
25
On Critical Dimensions of String Theories D. Leites and C. Sachse
31
Transition Amplitudes for Time-dependent Linear Harmonic Oscillator with Linear Time-dependent Terms Added to the Hamiltonian M. A. Rashid
39
Entropy Solutions to a Genuinely Nonlinear Ultraparabolic Kolmogorov-type Equation S. A. Sazhenkov
47
Fokker-Planck-Kolmogorov Equation for fBm: Derivation and Analytical Solutions
G. Unar
53
*Plenary speaker
xi
xii
Particle Physics and String Theory
61
Holography and de Sitter Space M. Ahhahiha*
63
Brane Cosmology with String Antisymmetric Field F. Ardalan
73
Bosonization of a Finite Number of Non-relativistic Fermions and Application A. DhaV
79
Recent Applications of the Weyl Anomaly M. J. D u f
90
Higher Dimensional Perspective on N = 2 Black Holes A. Fayyazuddin*
102
pstrings vs Strings D. Ghoshal
109
Detecting Two-photon Exchange Effects in Hard Scattering from Nucleon Targets P. Hood bhoy*
117
BPS M-brane Geometries T.Z. Husain
130
Ward Identities and Radiative Rare Leptonic B-decays M.J. Aslam, A.H.S. Gilani, M.S. Khan and Riazuddin
136
Calculation of NLO QCD Corrections to Polarization Effects in Top Quark Decays A . Kadeer
147
Selected Topics in Top Quark Physics J . G. Korner*
155
Moduli Stabilization using Open String Fluxes A. Kumar
169
Topological Strings and Special Holonomy Manifolds J . de Boer, A . Naqvi and A. Shomer
177
xiii
Vacua in N = 4 Gauged Supersymmetry S. Panda
190
Neutrino Physics Riazuddin*
199
What String Theory has Taught Us about the Quantum Structure of Space-time M. M. Sheikh- Jabbari*
210
Gauge Theory Description of the Fate of the Small Schwarzschild Blackhole S.R. Wadia*
220
Plasma Physics
235
Zonal Flow Generation by Magnetized Rossby Waves in Ionospheric E-layer T.D. Kaladze, D. J. Wu, O.A. Pokhotelov, R.Z. Sagdeev, L. StenfEo and P.K. Shukla
237
Quiescent and Catastrophic Events in Stellar Atmospheres S.M. Mahajan* and N.L. Shatashvili
252
Zero-dimensional MHD Modelling of Two Gas-puff Staged Pinch Plasma with Finite-P Effect A.M. Mirza, F. Deeba, K. Ahmed and M.Q. Haseeb
283
Does Quasi-neutrality Remain Valid in Pair-ion Plasmas? H. Saleem*
290
Relativity, Astrophysics and Cosmology
299
Invariance under Complex Transformations, and its Relevance to the Cosmological Constant Problem G. 't H o o p and S. Nobbenhuis
301
Ricci Collineations in Bianchi I1 Spacetime U. Camci
320
On the Gauss-Bonnet Gravity N. DadhicW
331
xiv
Geometry and Symmetry in General Relativity G. HalP
341
Gravitational Collapse in Quantum Gravity V. Husain*
354
Can 55C0 Give us the Desired Prompt Explosion of Massive Stars? Jamil-un-Nabi
362
Symmetry Classification and Invariant Characterization of Two-dimensional Geodesic Equations A . R . KashiA F.M. Mahomed and A . Qadar
369
Gravitational Collapse with Negative Energy Fields J. V. Narlika?
375
Quantum Non-locality, Black Holes and Quantum Gravity A . Qadi?
382
Homothetic and Conformal Motions K . Saifullah
393
Proper Projective Symrnetrics in Space-times G. Shabbir
400
Matter Symmetries of Non-static Plane Symmetric Spacetimes M. Sharif and T. Ismaeel
407
Spacetime Foliation A .A . Saddiqui
416
Spinning Particle: Electromagnetic and Gravitational Interactions N . Unal
424
Quantum Gravity and Hawking Radiation M. Varadarajan
430
Measuring Parameters of Supermassive Black Holes with Space Missions A .F. Zakharov'
436
Participants
445
Formal Aspects
This page intentionally left blank
NONCOMMUTATIVE GEOMETRY: FUZZY SPACES, THE GROENWALD-MOYAL PLANE* A. P. BALACHANDRAN and B. A. QURESHI Department of Physics, Syracuse University Syracuse, NY 13210, USA balQphy.syr. edu In this talk, we review the basics concepts of fuzzy physics and quantum field theory on the Groenwald-Moyal Plane as examples of noncommutative spaces in physics. We introduce the basic ideas, and discuss some important results in these fields. In the end we outline some recent developments in the field. Keywords: Noncommutative Geometry; Quantum Algebra; Quantum Field Theory. SU-4252-832
1. Introduction Noncommutative Geometry is a branch of mathematics due to Connes, Gel’fand, Naimark, Rieffel and many others’. Physicists in a very short time vulgarized it and nowadays use this phrase whenever the spacetime algebra is noncommutative. There are two such particularly active fields in physics at present. (i) Fuzzy Physics, (ii) Quantum Field Theory (QFT) on the Groenwald-Moyal Plane. Item (i) is evolving into a tool to regulate QFT’s, and for numerical work. It is an alternative to lattice methods. Item (ii) is more a probe of Planck-scale Physics. This introductory talk will discuss both items (i) and (ii).
*Plenary talk given by A. P. B. at the 12th Regional Conference on Mathematical Physics, Islamabad (27 March-1 April, 2006).
3
4
2. History
The Groenwald-Moyal plane is an example where spacetime coordinates do not commute. The idea that spatial coordinates may not commute first occurs in a letter from Heisenberg to Peierls2. Heisenberg suggested that an uncertainty principle such as
can provide a short distance cut-off and regulate quantum field theories (qft’s). In this letter, he apparantly complains about his lack of mathematical skills to study this possibility. Peierls communicated this idea to Pauli, Pauli to Oppenheimer and finally Oppenheimer to Snyder. Snyder wrote the first paper on the subject3. This was followed by a paper of Yang4. In the mid-go’s, Doplicher, F’redenhagen and Roberts5 systematically constructed unitary quantum field theories on the Groenwald-Moyal Plane, even with time-space noncommutativity. Later string physics encountered these structures. 3. What is Noncommutative Geometry
According to Connes’, noncommutative geometry is a spectral triple,
where
A = a C*-algebra, possibly noncommutative, D = a Dirac operator, 7-1 = a Hilbert space on which they are represented. If A is a commutative C*-algebra, we can recover a Hausdorff topological space on which A are functions, using theorems of Gel’fand and Naimark. But that is not possible if A is not commutative. But it is still possible to formulate qft’s using the spectral triple. A class of examples of noncommutative geometry with A noncommutative is due to Connes and Landi‘. If some of the strict axioms are not enforced then the examples include SU(2),, fuzzy spaces, Groenwald-Moyal plane, and many more. The introduction of noncommutative geometry has produced a conceptual revolution. Manifolds are being replaced by their “duals”, algebras, and these duals are being ”quantized”, much as in quantum mechanics.
5
4. Fuzzy Physics In what follows, we sketch the contents of ”fuzzy physics”. Reference [7] contains a detailed survey.
4.1. W h at is f u zzy p h y s i ~ s ? ~ We explain the basic idea of fuzzy physics by a two-dimensional example: S; . Consider the two-sphere S2.We quantize it to regularize by introducing a short distance cut-off. For example in classical mechanics, the number of states in a phase space volume
AV
d3pd3q
=
is infinite. But we know since Planck and Bose that on quantization, it becomes
AV h3
- = finite.
This is the idea behind fuzzy regularization. In detail, this regularization works as follows on S 2 . We have
s2= [&R3
:
2 . 2 = T”.
(2)
Now consider angular momentum Li: 4 2
[ L i , L j ] = iEijkLk; L
= 1(1+ 1).
(3)
Set
Li
xi
=
=+
(4)
TJqmJ
+
+
-
where Bi E Matzl+l 3 space of (21 1) x (21 1) matrices. As 1 00, they become commutative. They give the fuzzy sphere S$ of radius r and dimensions 21 1.
+
4.2. W h y is this space fuzzy
As 2i-i ,?j (i # j ) do not commute, we can not sharply localize &. Roughly in a volume 47rr2 there are (21 1) states.
+
6 4.3.
Field theory on fuzzy sphere
A scalar field on fuzzy sphere is defined as a polynomial in 2i. i.e., A scalar field @ = A polynomial in 2i = A (21
+ 1)
-
dimensional matrix.
Differentiation is given by infinitesimal rotation: &@
=
[ L i ,@I.
A simple rotational invariant scalar field action is given by S ( @ )= p T r [ L i , Q I t [ L i ,@]
+
m
j-Tr(Qt@)
+ XTr(@+@)'.
(6)
Simulations have been performeds on the partition function 2 = d@ePs(@) of this model and the major findings include the following: Continum limit exists. 0
If clrn fim,
@ =
fim= spherical tensor,
then there are three phases:
(c
(a) Disordered : lclmI2) = 0. (b) Uniform ordered: ( \cool2) # 0 , ( Iclrnl') = 0 for 1 # 0. (c) Non-uniform ordered: ( IclmI2) # 0, ( 1 ~ ; ~=) 0 for 1 # 1. The last one is the analogue of Gupser-Sondhi phaseg.
4.3.1. Dirac operator
S$ has Dirac operator with no fermion doubling including instantons7. Also 5'; can nicely describe topological features. Hence it seems better suited for preserving symmetries than lattice approximations.
4.3.2. Supersymmetry Replacing S U ( 2 ) by OSp(2,1), the fuzzy sphere becomes the N = 1 supersymmetric fuzzy sphere and can be used for simulating supersymmetry. Simulations in this regard are already starting.
4.3.3. Strings'' If N D-branes are close together, the transverse coordinates N x N matrices with the action given by
s
=
x Tr [@z , @ j ] tpi, @j]
+ i fijk @i@j@k
@i
become
(7)
7
where f i j k are totally antisymmetric. The equations of motion
give solutions when f i j k are structure constants of a simple compact Lie group. Thus we can have Qi = cLi
f i j k = CEijk
, c = constant
If Li is irreducible, then we have 4
4
L . L = Z(Z+l),
(2Z+1) = N ,
and we have one fuzzy sphere. Or we can have a direct sum
Then we have many fuzzy spheres. Stability analysis of these solutions including numerical studies has been done by many groups. 5. The Groenwald-Moyal Plane 5.1. Quantum gravity and spacetime noncommutativity: heuristics
The following arguments were described by Doplicher, Redenhagen and Robert in their work in support of the necessity of noncommutative spacetime at Planck scale. 5.1.1. Space-space noncommutativity
In order to probe physics at the Planck scale L, the Compton wavelength of the probe must fulfill
ti ti - < L or M 2 - > Planckmass. Mc -
Lc -
(9)
Such a high mass in the small volume L3 will strongly effect gravity and can cause black holes to form. This suggests a fundamental length limiting spatial localization.
8
5.1.2. Time-space noncommutativity Similar arguments can be made about time localization. Observation of very short time scales requires very high energies. They can produce black holes and black hole horizons will then limit spatial resolution suggesting
At AlT'l 2 L2 ,
L = a fundamental length.
(10) The Groenwald-Moyal plane models the above spacetime uncertainties. 5.2. What is the Groenwald-Moyal plane?
The Groenwald-Moyal plane ds(Rd+') consists of functions a ,p, . . . on Rd+' with the *-product
a
+ .
p
= ae-+
+
a.eUUd,
P.
* xp
=
(11)
For spacetime coordinates, this implies,
lxp,
x y ~ *=
xp
* x,
-
x,
-iepv
(12)
The Groenwald-Moyal plane also emerges in string physics and quantum Hall effect. 5.3. How the G-M plane emerges from quantum Hall eflect and strings
5.3.1. Quantum Hall effect (the Landau problem)
+ Consider an electron in 1-2 plane and an external magnetic field B = (0, 0 , B ) perpendicular to the plane. Then the Lagrangian for the system is 1 2 L = -mx, 2
+ ex:A,
(13)
where
B ,bX a,b = 1,2, (14) 2 is the electromagnetic potential and xa are the coordinates of the electron. Now if eB -+ 00, then eB L -(X,X2 - i:2X1) (15) 2 This means that on quantization we will have i [?a , ? b ] = -Cab (16) eB which defines a Groenwald-Moyal plane.
A,
= --€
N
9
5.3.2. Strings Consider open strings ending on DpBranes. If there is a background two-form Neveu-Schwarz field given by the constants Bij = -Bji, then the action is given by Sc =
As a'
-
1
I 47ra
[gij aaxi d a x j - 27ra' Bij aaxi &xj eab (17)
+spinor termslda dt. 00,
+
e [Bij2j , 2.'"]= i&. or (20) i [ 2 j , ?.'"I = - ( B - ' ) j k (21) e which is just a Groenwald-Moyal plane. Figure [l]below indicates the different sources from where fuzzy physics and the Groenwald-Moyal plane emerge. The question mark is to indicate that the Groenwald-Moyal plane may not regularize qft's.
Fuzzy Physics
QFT Regularisation
l-kdl Effect
+>-
Groenwald-
Quantum Gravity Fig. 1. The Tangled Web: Emergence of Noncommutative spaces from different fields.
10
5.4. Prehistory (before 2004/2005)
Until 2004/2005 much work had been done on 0
0
QFT’s on Groenwald-Moyal plane and renormalization theory, uncovering the phenomenon of UV/IR mixing. Phenomenology, studying the effects on Lorentz violation ( from O,, in [z, , z,], = zO,,), C, C P and C P T
5.5. Modern e r a
In 2004/2005, Chaichian et. a1.l’ and Aschieri et. a1.12 popularized the Drinfeld twist13 which restores full diffeomorphism invariance (with a twist in the “coproduct”) despite the presence of constants Oh, in [Z, , Zv] = iOh,. This twist also twists statistics14. Much of this was known to Majid15, Oeckle16, Fiore17 and Watts?. So we have that the Drinfeld twist twists both (i) action of diffeomorphisms, and (ii) exchange statistics. This brings into question much of prehistory-analysis. Examples include: (i) Lorentz invariance need not be violated even if 0,” # 0. (ii) There need be no ultraviolet-infrared (UV-IR) mixing in absence of gauge fieldslg. There is also a striking, clean separation of matter from gauge fields due to the Drinfeld twist20, (in the sense that they have to be treated differently) reminiscent of separation of particles and waves in the classical theory. 6. Acknowledgments
The work was supported by DOE under grant number DE-FG0285ER40231.
References 1. Alain Comes, Noncommutative Geometry. (Academic Press, San Diego, CA, 1994); Joseph C. Varilly, Hector Figueroa and Jose M. Gracia-Bondia, EZ-
ements of Noncomutative Geometry. (Birkhauser, Boston,2000); G. Landi, Introduction to Noncommutative Spaces and their Geometries.(Springer Verlag, New York, 1997).
11
2. R. Jackiw, NucLPhys. Proc.Supp1. 108, 30 (2002), arXiv:hep-th/0110057; Letter of Heisenberg to Peierl (1 930), Wolfgang Pauli, Scientific Correspondence, Vol. 11, p.15, 3. H. Snyder, Phys. Rev. 7 1 , 38 (1947). 4. C. N. Yang, Phys. Rev. 7 2 (1947). 5. S . Doplicher, K. Fredenhagen and J. Roberts, Phys. Lett. B 331, 39 (1994); S. Doplicher, K. Fkedenhagen and J. Roberts, Comm. Math. Phys. 172, 187 (1995), arXiv:hep-th/0303037. 6. A. Connes and G. Landi, Commun. Math. Phys. 221, 141-159, 2001, arXiv:math.qa/O011194. 7. A. P. Balachandran, S. Kurkcuoglu and S. Vaidya, Lectures on Fuzzy and Fuzzy Susy Physics, arXiv:hep-th/O511114. 8. X. Martin, JHEP 0404 (2004) 077, arXiv:hep-th/0402230; F. G. Flores, D. O’Connor and X. Martin,PoS Lat 2005 (2005) 262. 9. S. S. Gubser and S. L. Sondhi, Nucl. Phys. B 605 (2001) 395-424, arXiv:hepth/0006119; J. Ambjorn and S. Catterall, Phys. Lett. B 549 (2002) 253259, arXiv:hep-lat/0209106; J. Medina, W. Bietenholz, F Hofheinz and D. O’Connor, PoS LAT 2005 263 (2005), arXiv:hep-lat/0509162. 10. R. J. Szabo, arXiv:hep-th/0512054. 11. M. Chaichian, P. P. Kulish, K. Nishijima and A. Tureanu, Phys. Lett. B 604, 98 (2004), arXiv:hep-th/0408069; M. Chaichian, P. Presnajder and A. Tureanu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 94, 151602 (2005), arXiv:hep-th/0409096. 12. M. Dimitrijevic and J. Wess, arXiv:hep-th/0411224; P. Aschieri, C. Blohmann, M. Dimitrijevic, F. Meyer, P. Schupp and J. Wess, Class. Quant. Grav. 22 (2005) 3511-3532, arXiv:hep-th/0504183. 13. V. G. Drin’feld, Leningrad Math. J . 1 (1990) 1419-1457. 14. A. P. Balachandran, G. Mangano, A. Pinzul and S. Vaidya, arXive:hepth/0508002; B. A. Qureshi, arXiv:hep-th/0602040. 15. S. Majid, Foundations of quantum group theory, Cambridge University Press, 1995. 16. R. Oeckl, Nucl. Phys. B 581 (2000) 559, arXiv:hep-th/0003018. 17. G. Fiore and P. Schupp, published in Quantum Groups and Quantum Spaces, Banach Centre Publications vol. 40, Inst. of Mathematics, Polish Academy of Sciences, Warszawa (1997) 369-377; G. Fiore, J. Math. Phys. 39 (1998) 3437, arXiv:q-alg/9610005; G. Fiore and P. Schupp, Nucl. Phys. B 470 (1996) 211, arXiv: hep-th/9508047. 18. P. Watts, Phys. Lett. B 4 7 4 (2000) 295-302, arXiv:hep-th/9911026; P. Watts, arXiv: hep-th/0003234. 19. A. P . Balachandran, A. Pinzul and B. Qureshi, Phys. Lett. B 634 (2006) 434-436, arXiv: hep-t h/0508151. 20. A. P. Balachandran, A. Pinzul, B. A. Qureshi and S. Vaidya, work in preparation.
S-DUALITIES IN NONCOMMUTATIVE AND NON-ANTICOMMUTATIVE FIELD THEORIES * OMER F. DAYI Physics Department, Faculty of Science and Letters, Istanbul Technical University, TR-34469 Maslak-Istanbul, Turkey, and Feza Gursey Institute, P. 0.Box 6, TR-34684 Cengelkoy-Istanbul, Turkey LARA T. KELLEYANE Physics Department, Faculty of Science and Letters, Istanbul Technical University, TR-34469 Maslak-Istanbul, Turkey KAYHANULKER Feza Gursey Institute, P. 0.Box 6, TR-34684 Cengelkoy-Istanbul, Turkey BARIS YAPISKAN Physics Department, Faculty of Science and Letters, Istanbul Technical University TR-34469 Maslak-Istanbul, Turkey Parent actions to formulate (S-) duals of noncommutative and nonanticommutative N = 1/2 supersymmetric U(1) gauge theories are presented. The equivalence of partition functions of the N = 1/2 supersymmetric U(l) theory and its dual is demonstrated within the Hamiltonian approach. The results which we obtain are valid at the first order in the noncommutativity parameter 0,” or in the non-anticommutativity parameter Cao.
1. Introduction
(S-) Duality transformations map strong coupling domains to weak coupling domains of gauge theories. A method of studying duality invariance of pure U(1) gauge theory is the parent action formalism’. This approach allows the introduction of a dual formulation of the noncommutative U(1) gauge theory2, which was studied in terms of Hamiltonian methods3. Dual *Talk given by 0 . F. Dayi at the 12thRegional Conference on Mathematical Physics, Islamabad (27 March-1 April, 2006)
12
13
actions for supersymmetric U ( l ) gauge theories were derived utilizing a parent action when only bosonic coordinates are noncomrn~ting~. Actually, duality is helpful for inverting computations performed in weak coupling domains to strong coupling domains, when partition functions of the “original” and dual theories are equivalent, i.e. when there exists a duality symmetry. For noncommutative U (1) gauge theory without supersymmetry, this equivalence was established within the Hamiltonian formalism5. Moreover, for non-anticommutative N = 1/2 supersymmetric U(l) theory dual action has been obtained and the equivalence of their partition functions was shown6. In the next section we give the parent actions which produce the “original” and dual theory actions. In Section 3, we demonstrate the equivalence of partition functions of N = 1/2 supersymmetric U(l) theory and its dual. 2. Parent actions In terms of the dual gauge field AD one can introduce the parent action for an Abelian gauge theory (9”” = diag(-l,l,l, 1)):
S, =
J
1 d4x(--F
d92
”u
F””
+ -21~ ~ , , ~ ~ d ~ A l f , F ~ ~ ) .
One treats F as an independent variable without requiring any relation with the gauge field A. Performing the path integral over AD, which is equivalent to solving the equations of motion for AD in terms of F and replacing it in the action, leads to the Abelian gauge theory action
‘J
So = -d4~FPuF””, 4g2 with now F = d A . Performing the path integral over F , which is equivalent to solving the equations of motion for F in terms of AD and replacing it in the action, leads to the dual action
where FD = d A D . The duality transformation is 1 g+-. 9 Let us deal with the noncommutative space defined by the constants
6”” :
[x”,x”] = P ” .
14
Noncommuting variables should be treated as operators. However, one can retain them commuting under the usual product and introduce noncommutativity in terms of the star product
Now, the coordinates x@ satisfy the Moyal bracket xp
*
* xp
-
= epv.
(5)
Moreover, one can perform the Seiberg-Witten map to noncommutative gauge theory fields, to deal with the ordinary gauge transformations7. The related parent action is2
S,
=1 /d4x(FpvFpv
+ 28pvFvpFP"F,p - -Op"FvpFpoFuP) 1
4g2
2 d4x A
D
~
c
~
~
~
~
~
~
F
P
~
,
where F and AD are taken as independent field variables. Similar t o the previous case, one can solve equations of motion for AD or for F and plug them in (6) to obtain the actions which are dual to each other. By this method duality is generalized to noncommutative gauge theory as g+
1
-. 9
and epv
-+ @v
= g2Cpvp~epo.
yielding noncommutativity of space-time coordinates of the dual theory even if the original noncommutativity was between space-space coordinates. It is shown that3 noncommutativity of space-time coordinates resulting from duality does not require any change in the Hamiltonian formalism. Thus we derived Hamiltonian formulation of noncommutative D3-branes and studied some of its aspects. For the supersymmetric U(1) theory, a parent action was available in terms of restricted superfieldsg. We introduced a version in component fields4. Moreover, the Seiberg-Witten map between ordinary and noncommutative gauge fields is generalized to supersymmetric gauge theories. However, it is possible to give some different parent actions; thus some different dual actions for noncommuting supersymmetric U (1)theory were obtained. The formalism of superstring theory with pure spinors" in a graviphoton background" gives rise to a non-anticommutative s ~ p e r s p a c e ' ~ ~ ~ ~
15
which was introduced also in other contexts 14915. It can equivalently be introduced as a deformation of 4 dimensional N = 1 superspace by making the chiral fermionic coordinates 8,, (Y = 1 , 2 , non-anticommuting
{ea,e p } = cap, where C a p (0‘” = C@ep&’ 7) are constant deformation parameters. gh are intact. This breaks half of the supersymmetry. Moyal antibrackets (star products) are used. Thus, instead of operators, one deals with the usual superspace variables. In euclidean R4 chiral and antichiral fermions are not related by complex conjugation. Seiberg used the vector superfield of this deformed superspace to derive, after a change of variables like the Seiberg-Witten map, the N = supersymmetric Yang-Mills theory action12. Gauge transformations possess the usual form. Although we deal with euclidean R4,we use Minkowski space notation. We proposed the parent action as6
where
I. =
g2
/d4x(
-
i --CpuF,,(ix 4
i ~ 4 F p Y F p-y-X@x 2
1
- !$@$I 2
1
1
+ -D: 4 + ;D;
+ $4) ,
1 1 I1 = /d4x{ + p u X n F p v a ~ A ~~, X @ X D -XD@X - &@AD 2 2 1-
-
--AD@$ 2
+
+ ~i D D ( D-I D2)
+
1
.
Here Fpy are independent field variables. Solving the equations of motion with respect to the “dual” fields and plugging into the parent action (7), the non-anticommuting N = supersymmetric U (1) gauge theory action follows: -
Here we have FPv = a,A, - &A,.
- iX@X
1 + -D2
2
16
On the other hand, if one solves the equations of motion with respect to the “original” fields and substitutes them in the parent action (7), the dual theory action will follow:
where FD,, = a,AoV - dvADp. Observe that the original theory action and its dual possess the same form and the duality transformation is
9 4
1 -1
9
3. Equivalence of partition functions Partition functions for the parent actions are expected to produce partition functions of their daughter actions. Indeed, it was shown that partition functions for noncommutative U(1) theory and its dual are equivalent5. Here we will deal with the N = 1/2 supersymmetric theory (10) and its dual (11). In the parent action (7) there are some terms cubic in fields. Thus, it would be apposite to discuss its partition function in phase space, where integrations would be simplified due to Hamiltonian constraints. Let
be the canonical momenta corresponding to
17
Each of the canonical momenta resulting from the parent action (7) gives rise to a primary constraint, which we collectively denote as ( 0 " ) :
+? = poi x 0 , xy = l-Iy M 0 , X2& E fi2& @I
= PI Pg
$Dl
xg
E
11%
-
12
-$&@O&c'
@D
x M
x 0,
+ki = pij 2 -
XI&
-
+&;A,";
@2 3
8D2
0,
pi
P2 x 0 , $ijkFjk
-
+ $A"(T:&
0,
x D & E no&
M
- +JD&@O&"
&$&~O"U
0,
M
7
= fi1&- &A"C&
x, = II;
0 0, 0,
M
0, x 0,
PD x 0.
The canonical Hamiltonian associated with the parent action is
1- +ZADp$
-
i -DD(DI2 D2).
The extended Hamiltonian is obtained by adding the primary constraints 0" with the help of Lagrange multipliers ,Z to the canonical Hamiltonian: 'FIE = 'FIp
+ La@".
Consistency of the primary constraints with the equations of motion:
6" = {'FIE, 0 " ) M 0 gives rise to the secondary constraints 1 i {'FIp,P1}= --D1- 0 x~0 , 2g2 2 1 i A2 E {'FIp,P2}= - 7 0 2 ZDD M 0 , 29 i AD = {XP, P o } I= -(Dl - 0 2 ) M 0 , A1 E
+
2
1
.(
(Po = {'FIp,P$}= -EaJkdkFijX 0 2
, ig2
{'FIp, Poi} = Poi - g2fijkdjADk+ -coi(xx+ M0 . 2 In path integrals first and second class constraints are treated on different grounds. Thus, let us first identify the first class constraints: 401 is Cpyi E
4$)
18
obviously first class. Moreover, we observe that the linear combination
is also a first class constraint. There are no other first class constraints. However, the constraints q5b2 contain second class constraints which we should separate out. This is due to the fact that a vector can be completely described by giving its divergence and rotation (up to a boundary condition). We used divergence of so that there are still two linearly independent second class constraints following from the curl of pD2:
@A,,,
454
Kr@A2 = ICnicijkdj&,
M
0,
where n = 1,2. ICY are some constants whose explicit forms are not needed for the purposes of this work. Although all of them are second class, we would like to separate cpyi in a similar manner:
where Cnj are some constants. The reason of preferring this set of constraints will be clear when we perform the path integrals, though explicit forms of Cl play no role in our calculations. In phase space, the partition function can be written as
where Yi and Pyi embrace all of the fields and their momenta. Sz denotes all second class constraints: S, = (41, 4z , @ I , Qz, 404,Q D ,cpz , cp3, Ai , A2 , (PO, A D ,X I , 21,xz,Rz, X D , RD). We adopted the gauge fixing (auxiliary) conditions
for the first class constraints 4~~ and 4 ~N ~is a .normalization constant. M is the matrix of the generalized Poisson brackets of the second class constraints: M = { S z ,SZ!}.
19
When we integrate over the fields which do not carry the label "D"
2=
/
V A DV~ ~ VD P DV~D D V P D(det g2)(deta:)(detj3)2
~ ( D D ) S ( P Da) ( a . P D ) w . exp{ i
/
d3x
_-g42 FDi j FDa3
' '
AD)
[piA D i + P D D D - T291P D i P L - i c g P D i x D x D
- '2g 2 C g F D i j x D X D - i g 2 X D @ x D
+
will result. In the exponent we distinguish the first order lagrangian of the dual theory, where IIg and f i ~ bare integrated. On the other hand integration of the other fields leads to
z=J
V A D~ P ~ v x v xV D V P
(det g 2 ) (det @)(det p ) 2 S ( D ) B ( P ) S ( B . P ) 6 ( d .A)
In the exponent we recognize the first order lagrangian of the original theory after integrations over II?, f i 1 & , IIg and n 2 & are performed in its path integral. Let us adopt the normalization to write the partition function of nonanticommutative N = supersymmetric U(1) gauge theory as
20
Therefore, by applying the duality transformation (12)-( 13), partition function of its dual can be obtained as
ZNAD
J
VAi V P i DA V O X V D V P 6 ( D ) d ( P ) b ( dP)S(a. . A)
Here, we omitted the label “D”of the dual fields. Comparing the results one concludes that the partition functions of non-anticommutative N = supersymmetric U(1) gauge theory Z N A and its dual Z N A Dare equivalent:
3
Z N A= Z N A D . Therefore, under the strong-weak duality non-anticommutative N = supersymmetric U ( l ) gauge theory is invariant.
4
Acknowledgments:
O.F.D. thanks the organizers Professors Riazuddin and F. Hussain for invitation and support. References 1. T.H. Buscher, Phys. Lett. B 194,59 (1987); Phys. Lett. B 201,466 (1988). 2. O.J. Ganor, G. Rajesh and S. Sethi, Phys. Rev. D 62,125008 (2000). 3. O.F. Dayi and B. Yapiakan, JHEP 10,022 (2002). 4. O.F. Dayi, K. Ulker, and B. Yapqkan, JHEP 10,010 (2003) . 5. O F . Dayi and B. Yapigkan, JHEP 11,064 (2004) . 6. O.F. Dayi, L.T. Kelleyane and K. Ulker, JHEP 10,035 (2005). 7. N. Seiberg and E. Witten, JHEP 09,032 (1999). 8. J. Wess and J. Bagger, Supersymmetry and supergravity (Princeton University Press, 1992). 9. N. Seiberg and E. Witten, Nucl. Phys. B 426,19 (1994) . 10. N. Berkovits, JHEP 04,018 (2000) . 11. H. Ooguri and C. Vafa, Adv.Theor.Math.Phys. 7,53 (2003). 12. N. Seiberg, JHEP 06, 010 (2003). 13. J. de Boer, P.A. Grassi , P. van Nieuwenhuizen, Phys. Lett. B 574,98 (2003). 14. J. W. Moffat, Phys. Lett. B 506, 193 (2001) . 15. D. Klemm, S. Penati, L. Tamassia, Class.Quant.Grav. 20,2905 (2003) .
NEW CASIMIR ENERGY CALCULATIONS H. AHMEDOV Feza Gursey Institute, 81220, Istanbul, Turkey. E-mail:
[email protected]. tr
I. H. DURU Izmir Institute of Technology, 35430, Izmir, Turkey. E-mail:
[email protected] New Casimir energy results for massless scalar field in some 3 -dimensional cavities are presented. We attempted to discuss the correlation between the sign and the magnitude of the energy and the shape of the cavities.
1. Introduction
The sign of the Casimir energy is known to be dependent on the dimension, topology and geometry. In this note we present some new exact results for massless scalar fields in three dimensional cavities with the trivial topology. We then compare the known Casimir energy values for several three dimensional cavities. The conclusion we arrived a t is that the existence of corners lowers the vacuum energy. 2. New Casimir Energy Results in Some 3-dimensional
Cavities In this section we present Casimir Energies for a massless scalar field in some 3-dimensional cavities. These cavities are rather special regions, for all of them are fundamental domains for some crystallographic group generated by reflections with respect to the boundary walls. This property enables us to' obtain the wave functions satisfying the Dirichlet boundary conditions and then the correct energy spectrum. (i) A Pyramidal Cavity The region is defined by the planes
21
22
This is the fundamental domain of the group of order 48 generated by the reflection with respect to the above planes'. The Casimir energy for a massless scalar field in this cavity is ( in h = c = 1 units )
0.069 7 > 0.
EpYT
(ii) A Conical Cavity The conical cavity we consider is the one with height h = a and with a very special opening angle ,B = arcsin; '. The crystallographic group which admits this cavity as the fundamental domain is the Tetrahedral group. The Casimir energy due to the fluctuation of the massless scalar field is'.
Em,
0.080 => 0. a
(3)
(iii) Triangular Cylinders Three kinds of triangles are the fundamentals domains of some crystallographic groups in the plane. These are equilateral, right-angled isosceles and the right-angled triangle which is the half of the equilateral one3. Here we give the results for a cylindrical cavity of height b and with equilateral triangular cross-section of edges a. Three possibilities are distinguished: a) For b > a
EtTi N b) For a
0.053 a
--
+ -(0.029)' . a2 '
> b > 5 N 0.7a 0.013
L ( - h
EtTi N 2 c) For b <
+
(0.011) a b2
+--0.093 a
(0.048) b a2
5 0.039 (0.014) a EtTi N -b2 ' b +
The energy for height a is
0.022 EtTi N -. a 3. Some Known Casirn,; Energy Results for 3-dimens~nal
Cavities (i) Casimir energy for the spherical cavity of radius a is4
23
(ii) Cylinders with square cross-section of edges a and of height b5 have
0.013 a
E r e c t 2 --
+
(0.011) b for a2
,a
(9)
and
0.013 b
Erect N --
+
(0.011)a for b2
For the cube of edge a we have
EcUbN
0.002
--
which is very small.
4. Discussion To obtain a meaningful comparison of the results we consider cavities of equal volumes. Such an approach may help us to understand the shape dependence of the energy. The positive energies for the pyramidal, conical and triangular cylinder cavities can be expressed in terms of energy of spherical cavity of the same volume as:
The energy for the cube ( which is negative but very close t o zero ) of the same volume is
It seems that corners of the cavity reduce the energy. If we think in terms of the path integral picture we can say that the paths hitting the corners cannot bounce back, but disappear. Thus we can think that corners in the cavities reduce the phase space volume, and then reduce the vacuum energy.
Acknowledgements The authors H. Ahmedov and I. H. Duru thank the Turkish Academy of Sciences (TUBA) for its support.
24
References 1. H. Ahmedov and I.H. Duru, J. Math. Phys. 46,022303 (2005). 2. H. Ahmedov and I.H. Duru, J. Math. Phys. 46,022304 (2005). 3. H. Ahmedov and I.H. Duru, in preparation. See also H. Ahmedov and I.H. Duru, J. Math. Phys. 45,965 (2004). 4. T. H. Boyer, Phys. Rev. 174,1764 (1968); B. Davies, J . Math. Phys. 13,1324 (1972); R.Balian and B. Duplantier, Ann. Phys. 104,300 (1978); J Schwinger, L.L. De Raad and K . A. Milton, Ann. Phys. 115,1 (1978); ibid. 115,388 (1978). 5 . See for example V.M. Mostapanenko and N.N. Trunov , The Casimir Effect and i t s Applications. (Oxford Univ. Press, New York, 1997) and references therein..
QUATERNIONIC AND OCTONIONIC STRUCTURES OF THE EXCEPTIONAL LIE ALGEBRAS MEHMET KOCA Sultan Qaboos University College of Science, Physics Department P.O. Box 36, Al-Khoud, 123 Muscat Sultanate of Oman E-mail: [email protected] The Cayley-Dickson procedure has been used to construct the root systems of S 0 ( 8 ) , SO(9) and the exceptional Lie algebra F4 in terms of quaternions. The Aut(F4) has a simple presentation of the form ( 0 , O ) @ (O,O)* where 0 represents the binary octahedral group. Two sets of quaternionic root system of F4, symbolically written [F4,F4] = F4 e7F4, describe the octonionic root system of Es where the root system of the exceptional Lie algebra E7 are represented by the imaginary octonions. The automorphism group of the octonionic root system of E7 preserving the octonion algebra is the Chevalley group G2(2) where the maximal subgroups of G z ( 2 ) are the automorphism groups of the octonionic root systems of the maximal Lie algebras E6, S U ( 2 ) x SO(12) and S U ( 8 ) of E7. Another pairing of the quaternionic roots of the form [F4,F4] = F4 aF4, constitutes the root system of E8 in terms of icosians where half of the roots describe the roots of the noncrystallographic Coxeter group H4. The relevance of H4 to Es and the maximal subgroups of H4 have been discussed. Polyhedral structures obtained from the quaternionic root systems of H4 are described as the orbits of H3.
+
+
Keywords: Polyhedra,Quaternions and Octonions
1. Introduction
Integer elements of the quaternions and octonions play important roles in the description of the root systems of the Lie algebras of rank-4, S0(8),SO(9) and the exceptional Lie algebra F4 The imaginary integer elements of quaternions correspond to the root system of the Lie algebra SP(3)while those of octonions describe the root system of the exceptional Lie algebra E7 '. The Weyl groups of the rank-4 Lie algebras have presentations as the finite subgroups of O(4) M S U ( 2 ) x S U ( 2 ) where each S U ( 2 ) can be represented in terms of quaternionic polyhedral groups. We introduce the Cayley-Dixon doubling procedure to construct the root systems
'.
25
26
of those celebrated algebras. Denote by a, b, c,d the elements of a division algebra other than the octonions. The pairs satisfying the product rule (Cayley-Dickson doubling rule)
( a ,b)(c,d) = (UC - db,cb + ad)
(1)
define the elements of a higher rank division algebra. For a , b real numbers ( a ,b) is a complex number; if a, b are complex numbers the pair is a quaternion. Similarly a pair of quaternion defines an octonion under the rule of (1).To construct the root systems of higher rank Lie algebras we start with the roots and the fundamental weights of SU(2) : 0, f l ;fi and obtain first the roots of SO(4) and then SO(5) in the manner;
SO(4) : ( f ,0)
= f l ;(0, f l ) = fi,
1 1 1 f-)= -(*I f i). 2 2 2 Two sets of roots of SO(5) constitute the roots of SO(8) :
SO(5) : ( f , O ) = f l ;(0, f l ) = fi; (f-,
T
= Vo @
V+ CB V-,
(2)
(3)
i
where VO= { f l ,f e l , f e z , fes}, V+ = { f l f el f e2 f e3) (even number of (+) sign), V- = { f l f el f ez f e3) (odd number of (+) sign). Here imaginary quaternions satisfy the relations eiej = -6ij Eijkek, i , j , k = 1,2,3. The set of quaternions T represents also the binary tedrahedral group as well as the 4-dimensional polytope {3,4,3). The weights of three 8dimensional representations of SO(8) are given by the quaternions:
i
+
The roots of SO(9) are the quaternions T @ V1. We define T’ = V1@VZ @ V3. Then the set of quaternions T@T’represent the roots of the exceptional Lie algebra F4. Imaginary quaternions of the roots of F4 constitute the roots of the Lie algebra SP(3). We also note that the binary octahedral group of order 48 is given by 0 = T d T ’ . We define the O(4) transformations by the quaternions: [a,b] : q -+ q‘ = aqb , [c,d]* : q q“ = cqd where q is the quaternion conjugation. Using this notation we can write the AutF4 and the Weyl group of F4 as follows 3:
+
--f
AutF4
=
[O,O]@ [O,O]*,
W ( F 4 ) = [T,T]@ [T,T]* @ [T’,T’]@ [T’,T’]*. Many subgroups of the AutF4 have been studied in reference ’.
(5)
27 2. Octonionic Roots of Es
Following the Cayley-Dickson doubling procedure we construct the octonionic root system of Eg as follows:
( T ,0) = T , (0, T ) = e7T, (K , K ) = VI e 7 K , (E,V3) = V2
+
+ e7V3, (V3,V2) = V3 + e7v2
(6)
where ea = -1 and e7e1 = e4, e7e2 = e5,e7e3 = e 6 1 , 4 .The imaginary octonions of (6) constitute the roots of the Lie algebra E7. The octonion multiplication table is given by e a. ej .-- -6..a j + $a.j.k e k, with
i,j,k=1,2,...,7,
(7)
completely anti-symmetric and $123 = $246 = 4435 = $367 = $651 = $572 = $714 = 1The automophism group of the octonionic root system of E7 is a finite subgroup of the exceptional Lie group G2 called adjoint Chevalley group G2(2) of order 12096215. It has four maximal subgroups of orders 432,336,192 corresponding to the automorphism groups of the octonionic root systems of the Lie algebras E6,SU(8) and SO(12) respectively. The fourth maximal subgroup of order 192 preserves the structure ( H ,H ) = H e7H where H stand for the quaternions6. A quaternionic representation of the root system of Eg is also possible with the following pairing7: $ijk
+
E8
=
( T ,0) @ (0, T )@ (Vl,V2)@ (v2, v3) @ ( 6 K ,)
+
a
(8)
where (A, B) = A aB , a= 2 ’ 7 = 2 . The quaternionic Eg roots in (7) can also be written as E8 = I aI where I represents the quaternions of the binary icosahedral group. It is known that the quaternions of I represent the roots of non-crystallographic Coxeter group H4 . It has been shown that the symmetry group of the root system of H4 can be written as8
+
of order 14,400. The maximal subgroups of the Coxeter group W ( H 4 ) have been studied in [9] and found to be Aut(SU(5)) M W(SU(5)) : 2 2 , W ( H 3 ) X 2 2 , W ( s U ( 3 ) ) X W(sU(3)) : 2 4 , W ( H 2 ) X W ( H 2 ) : 2 s , W ( S O ( 8 ) ): Z3 of respective orders 240, 240, 144, 400, 576. Two of these maximal subgroups W ( H 3 ) x 2 2 and W(H2) x W ( H 2 ) : Z4 are the non-crystallographic subgroups of W ( H 4 ) . The others are the crystallographic groups. The non-crystallographic Coxeter group W ( H 4 ) is a
28
maximal subgroup of the crystallographic group W(E8) .The eigenvalues of the Coxeter element of W(E8)can be determined from the characteristic equation8
+ A' - x5 x4 - x3 + x2 + 1 = p(X)q(X) = 0, 21r p ( X ) = X4 + 7X3 + 7 X 2 + TX + 1 = 0 -+ exp(im-), m = 7,13,17,23, 30 21r q ( x ) = x4 + ax3 + (rx2 + (TX + 1 = o -+ exp(im-), 30 1x1 - MI = AS
-
m = 1,11,19,29(Coxeter exponents of The half of the Coxeter exponents of
E8
W(H4)).
are the Coxeter exponents of H4 .
3. Quaternions and Polyhedra
We have already noted that the root system of SO(8) represents the vertices of the 4-dimensional polytope {3,4,3} . Actually the weights of any one of these 8-dimensional representations of SO(8) constitute the vertices of an hyperoctahedra {3,3,4} known also as 16-cell. Then the 16 weights of the remaining two 8-dimensional representation of S 0 ( 8 ) , in other words, the weights of the spinor representation of SO(9) represent the vertices of a hypercube or the polytope {4,3,3}, dual of the polytope {3,3,4}1°. One can determine the vertices of the polyhedra in 3-dimension by projecting any representation of these Lie algabras S0(8), SO(9) and F4. The useful Weyl groups in these projections are the W(SP(3)) and WjSO(7)). We shall give an example of this projection when we determine the orbits of W ( H 3 ) in the polytopes {3,3,5} = I and {5,3,3}. The vertices of {3,3,5} and {5,3,3}, in other words, the elements of the binary icosahedral group 1 and its dual can be obtained as follows" 5
{3,3,5} =
5
5
C @p3T= j=1 C @T?, {5,3,3} = j,k=1 C @p3T'pk
(11)
j=1
+ +
el oe3) and T is given in (3) and the elements of T' are where p = ;(T given in (4). Two subgroups of W ( H 4 ) , namely, W ( H 3 ) and W(SU(5)) each can be embedded in W ( H 4 ) in 120 different ways. The polytope {3,3,5} is made of tedrahedra in 3-dimensions and the symmetry of the tedrahedron is isomorphic to the Weyl group W(SU(4)) x S4 of order 24, a subgroup of the group W(SU(5)). It is implicit that the group W(SU(4)) M 5'4 can be embedded 120 x 5 = 600 different ways. This proves that the polytope {3,3,5} is made of 600 tedrahedra and so it is called 600-cell. From the
a
h
d
e
c
Fig. 1. Polyhedra Projected from the Polytope (5,3,3} as orbits of W ( H 3 ) .
fact that the Coxeter group W ( H 3 ) is isomorphic to the icosahedral group with inversion and can be embedded in the Coxeter group W(H4 ) in 120 different ways it can be argued that the polytope {5,3,3} is made of 120 dodecahedra and hence we have the name 120-cell.It is difficult to visualize these polytopes in 4-dimensions. Therefore it is advisable to project them into 3-dimensions by determining the orbits of W ( H 3 ) in the polytopes {3,3,5} and {5,3,3}. One representation of the group W(Iy3)in W(W4) can be written as W W 3 ) = blF1 G3 I v l P I * ; P l P E 1.
(la)
The orbits of W ( H 3 ) in {3,3,5} are just the conjugacy classes of 6. They consist of four icosahedrons, two dodecahedrons and one icosidodecahedron. Including the poles f 1 they complete the vertices of {3,3,5} : 4 x 12 + 2 x 20 $- 30 2 = 120 . The orbits of W(H3) in the polytope {5,3,3} can be determined by acting W ( H 3 ) in (12) on the quaternions in (11)l2.One cuts the $sphere S3 with the hyperplane f(@ Eq) = d where c is a fixed quaternion. In our example it is the quaternion B which is left invariant under the transformations of (12). Therefore the scalar d represents the scalar product of 1 with the quaternions in a given orbit. Calcu~ation$show that we have 15 orbits with the values of d equal
+
+
30
*+,
to 0, 'f4 f&, 2 2 f "2,J z 4 1 3 ,k224 ,f224 .These orbits represent convex solids some of which are regular polyhedra, some are Archimedean solids and the rest are the convex solids with two edge lengths having pentagonal, triangular, square and non regular hexagonal faces. We illustrate some of them in the figures. The orbit with d = 0 is a convex solid with 60 vertices (with two edge lengths), 12 pentagonal , 20 triangular and 30 rectangular faces. The widths of the rectangles are the edges of the pentagons and the lengths of the rectangles are the sides of the triangular faces. The = 7'. It is depicted in Fig. length to the width ratio of the rectangle is l a . The orbit with d = 'f is a icosidodecahedron with 30 vertices, 32 4. faces( 12 pentagonal and 20 triangular) and 90 edges which is shown in Fig. l b . The convex solid of d = f L has 60 vertices with 12 pentagonal and 2Jz 20 semi-regular hexagonal faces and is shown in Fig. lc. This could be used as a model for CSO as it has two different edge lengths corresponding to two different bondings. The orbit with d = is similar to the one in Fig. l c but long and short edges are interchanged. The orbit with d = ZIZ& is a semi-regular polyhedron, which has also 60 vertices, 90 edges, 62 faces(l2 pentagonal, 20 triangular, 30 square). Fig. I d shows this Small Rhombicosidodecahedron. The three remaining orbits are the dodecahedra with different circumscribed radii, one of which is depicted in Fig. le. I would like to thank Dr. Ramazan Koc for illuminating discussions.
*&
References 1. M. Koca and N. Ozdes, J. M. Phys. A 22, 1469 (1989); M. Koca, R. Koq, M. Al-Barwani, J. M. Phys. 44, 03123 (2003). 2. F. Karsch and M. Koca, J. Phys. A 23, 4739 (1990); M. Koca and R. Koq J . Phys. A 27,2429 (1994). 3. M. Koca, R. Koq, M. Al-Barwani, J. M. Phys 47, 043507-1 (2006). 4. H. S. M. Coxeter, Duke Math. J . 13,561 (1946). 5. C. Chevalley, Tohoku. Math. J. 7,14 ( 1955); Am. J . Math. 77,778 ( 1955). 6. M. Koca, R. Koq, N. 0. Koca, hep-th /0509189. 7. M. Koca, J. Phys. A 22, 1949 (1989); J . Phys. A 22, 4125 (1989). 8. M. Koca, R. Koq, M. Al-Barwani, J. Phys. A 34, 11201 (2001). 9. M. Koca, R. Koq, M. Al-Barwani, S. Al-Farsi, Linear Algeb. Appl. 412, 441 (2006). 10. H. S. M. Coxeter, Regular Complex Polytopes, (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1973). 11. P. du Val, Homographies, Quaternions and Rotations, (Oxford University Press,1964.) 12. M. Koca, R. Koq, M. Al-Ajmi, ' I Quaternionic Representation of the Coxeter Group W ( H 4 ) and the Polyhedra", Submitted for publication.
ON CRITICAL DIMENSIONS OF STRING THEORIES DIMITRY LEITES’ and CHRISTOPH SACHSEt Max-Planck-Institut fur Mathematik in den Naturwissenschaften (MPIMIS), Inselstr. 88, DE-04103 Leiptig, Germany; *E-mail:
[email protected] t E-mail:
[email protected] Exactly 10 of all simple Lie superalgebras of vector fields on 1IN-dimensional supercircles (superstrings) preserving a structure (either nothing, or a volume element, or a contact form) have nontrivial central extensions. The values of the central charges in (projective) spinor-oscillator representations of these stringy superalgebras associated with the adjoint module can be interpreted as critical dimensions of respective superstrings. Apart from the well-known values 26, 10, 2 and 0 corresponding to N = 0, 1, 2 and > 2, respectively, for the contact type stringy superalgebras (Neveu-Schwarz and Ramond types alike), there arc two more non-zero values of critical dimension: for the general and divergencefree algebras for N = 2. These dimensions, found here, are -1 and -2, respectively. We also mention related problems. Keywords: stringy Lie superalgebras, critical dimensions
1. Introduction We start by quoting from Ref. 1: “In various papers and books on string theories, a degenerate (in Dirac’s sense) Lagrangian is considered. The Fourier harmonics of the constraints of this Lagrangian can be endowed with a Lie algebra structure; this Lie algebra is isomorphic to the Lie algebra of the group of diffeomorphisms of the circle. The complexification of this Lie algebra is a versiona of the Witt algebra mitt: Either aer (@[x-l,x]) or its completion. The following types of mitt-modules (or their completions) are mainly studied: (1) FA,^ = @[x-’,x]x”(dx)’ (the answer to the question which of these modules are irreducible follows from Ref. 2, where the polynomial case is aEvery Lie algebra of vector fields on a manifold has several “incarnations”: The coefficients of the fields can be smooth functions, or polynomials, or power series, or Laurent polynomials, or (for completion) Laurent series, etc. depending on the problem.
31
32
considered) ; (2) highest (or lowest) weight modules (irreducible ones are completely described in Ref. 3) which are all realized as quotients of the spinor Spin(V) or oscillator Osc(V) representations constructed from modules V = FA+. Since the representations of type (2) are projective, they give rise to a nontrivial central extension of mitt, the Virasoro algebra bit, and actually are representations of oir, rather than of mitt. Realization of the elements of mitt by quadratic polynomials in creation and annihilation operators acting in the spaces of spinor and oscillator representations is interpreted in physics as quantization. The “critical dimension” CD that appears in physics papers is the (only) dimension of the Minkowski space (in which the string under study lives) for which quantization is free of anomalies4. There are several, perhaps inequivalent in super setting, ways to compute the critical dimensions. The first ones are related to a study of various action functionals, see, e.g., Ref. 4, 5.” Feigin interpreted the CD as the value of the central charge of bir in the spinor representation corresponding to the adjoint mitt-module. Feigin used this CD in the computation of the semi-infinite cohomology which he introd~ced~~~-~. For the list of super analogues of mitt, simple Lie superalgebras that appear in string theories, see Ref. 10. Among them, there are precisely ten distinguished ones, which have a nontrivial central extension. Superization of Polyakov’s action and Nambu’s action leads to interesting supersymmetric integrable systems (see, e.g., Ref. 11, 12, 13, 14, and references therein) , super versions of minimal surfaces and constant curvature surfaces, but we can not describe critical dimensions in these terms. Our result: We apply Feigin’s picture to consider two, hopefully new, examples. (The isomorphism, up to parity, Spin(V) Y Osc(V), as spaces is referred to as the “Fermi-Bose correspondence” in physics papers. The values of CDs in these spaces differ by a sign, and this gives us hope to be able to interpret negative CDs as reasonable dimensions.) 2. Stringy superalgebras and modules over them 2.1. Vectorial Lie superalgebras with polynomial or formal coefficients. Let F := C[[y]] be the supercommutative superalgebra of formal power series in y = (y1, . . . ,ynfm) = ( ~ 1 , .. . , z,
cm)
33
by the yi. Define the topology on 3 in which the ideals (y)", where T = 0, 1, 2, . . . , are neighborhoods of zero. We see that .F is complete with respect to this topology. Let oect(n1m) be the Lie superalgebra of formal vector fields, i.e., of derivations of C[[y]]continuous with respect to the above topology. In general questions we denote oect(n)m) and its infinite dimensional subalgebras by L. In L , define a descending filtration L = L-I 3 LO 3 C1 3 . . . , setting
L, = {D E oect(n1m) 1 D ( 3 )
c (y)'")
(1)
Denote by L = @Lr, where L, = L r / L r + l r the associated graded Lie superalgebra. Let us identify Lo with g[(nlm)setting Eij H yjdi.
Remark. For some simple Lie superalgebras, the spaces of the highest and lowest weight vectors is multidimensional, cf. Ref. 15; there are also various gradings listed in Ref. 16. 2.2. Tensor fields.
Let us consider a given representation p of LO = Lo/L1 in V as a representation of LO.Since Hom(C[d],C) F,we may set T(V) := H o m U ( . c o ) ( ~ (V). ~), Each vector field D = Didi acts in T(V) by means of the Lie derivative Lo:For any f E . F , v E V and Dij = (-l)P(Yi)P(Dj)diDj, we set
+ (-i)~(~)p(f)fC D~~~(E~~)(v).
L ~ ( ~=vD) ( ~ ) v
-
Having fixed coordinates, we define the divergence as the map
D=
d XfiG + x g j dw i
j
divD =
Set soect(n1m) = {D E oect(n1m) divD
c + x(-l)p(gj)-. 2
i
j
dgi 89,
= 0).
2.3. Modules over stringy superalgebras.
Simple stringy superalgebras and their nontrivial central extensions are listed in Ref. 10. These extensions only exist for contact algebras (and the corresponding CDs are known), and also for oectL(l12) = OerC[~-',h, Ez][[z]land
mectf(112) = {D E oect'(ll2)
I div(zXD)= 0).
Denote by I ( V ) the oect(1ln)-module that differs from T(V) by allowing Laurent polynomials as coefficients of its elements instead of polynomials.
34
Clearly, I ( V ) is a bect’(lln)-module. Set ?;L(V):= ‘T(V)xP.Some of such modules are described in Ref. 17 as an easy corollary of Ref. 18. None of these modules has a highest or lowest weight vector. The “simplest” such modules over the Lie superalgebras oect’( 1In) and soectf:(1In) are, clearly, the rank 1 modules over 3,the algebra of functions. They are constructed as follows: Let VoZP be the space of tensor fields corresponding to the “pth power” of the g I-module corresponding to the superdeterminant or Berezinian (infinitesimally, XvoZ = pstr(X)voZ). For p = 0, this is just the space of functions, 3. Over tL(N)c oect’(lIN), the contact superalgebra which preserves the Pfaff equation with the form
it is more natural to consider the modules defined in terms of
CYN:
Observe that VoZ’ = FA(^-^) and that the Lie superalgebras of series tL do not distinguish between and a-’: their transformation rules are identical. Over t’(ll2) (and similarly over tM(113)), there are also modules 3 ~ := , 3~ ~ ; , [;d J~ 1 ] ”where , [dell = d& mod C Y N . Let c# = C Y N - ~ xed0 be the “Mobius” version of the contact form Q N and let t M ( N )c oect’(1IN) be the Lie superalgebra that preserves the Pfaff equation a f ( X ) = 0 for X E oect’(1IN). We set (clearly, Kf E tL(N))
&
+
K f = (2 - E ) ( f ) a where E =
c@i& and Hf i
af
ax + (-l)P(f)Hf+ -E, ax = C %&is the hamiltonian field with j I N
Hamiltonian f that preserves daN and (clearly, Kf” E t M ( N ) )
Kf”= (2 - E)(f)’D+ D ( f ) E + (-l)P(f)HfM, where
35
3. The spinor and oscillator representations in super setting 3.1. The Lie superalgebra bei(2nlrn). Define the Heisenberg Lie superalgebra fjei(2nlm) as follows. Consider a (272 1(m)-dimensionalsuperspace W = V @@I, where p( 1)= 0, and let (., .) be an even nondegenerate skew-symmetric bilinear form on V . Let W be the superspace of fjei(2nlm)with the bracket
+
[w,w] = (w,w)n, for w,w
E
V ; [n, fjei] = 0.
3.1.1. The big and small Weyl superalgebras. Being primarily interested in irreducible representations of fjei, or, equivalently, of its enveloping algebra, we consider not the whole U(fjei(2nlm) (the “big” Weyl superalgebra) but its quotient (the “small” Weyl superalgebra)
Uh(fjei(2nlm)= U(fjei(2nlm))/(n- h) for h E C. The quotient Ufi(bei(2nlm),called the superalgebra of observables, is, by definition, an associative superalgebra isomorphic, for k = [ and m even, to the associative superalgebra of differential operators on the supermanifold PIkwith polynomial coefficients diff(n1k) = “Mat”(C[q,(1) whereas, for k = and m odd, it is isomorphic to (for the definition of the queer analog QMat of the general matrix superalgebra, see, e.g., Ref. 19, 20)
F]
[F]
+
(For example, take 7r = Crn &.) For n = 0, the algebras diff and qdiff with super structure ignored are known under the name of Clifford algebras.
..
3.2. Spinor (Clifford-Weil-wedge-. ) and oscillator representations. Let po(2nlm) be the Poisson Lie superalgebra realized on polynomials. As is easy to see, po(2nlm)oE 05p(m12n),the superspace of elements of degree 0 in the &graded Lie superalgebra or, which is the same, the superspace of quadratic elements in the representation by generating functions. The complete description of deformations of po(2nlm) was recently given in Ref. 21: There is only one (class of) deformations: quantization Q and
36
we denote Spin(V) the module given by the through mapb
We will denote this representation Spin(V) and set Osc(V) := Spin(II(V)), where V is the standard representation of osp(m12n) = 05p(v), and IT is the change of parity. For n = 0, it is called the spinor representation; for m = 0 the oscillator representation. Now, suppose that V is a g-module without any bilinear form. Then, consider the module W = V @ V' (in the infinite dimensional case, V* is the restricted dual whose elements are sums of finitely many terms, not series) endowed with the form (for any w1, w1 E V, w2, w2 E V') B((Wl,W2),
(w1, w2)) = WZ(W1) f (-1)p("')*(w2)w2(w1).
This form is symmetric for the plus sign and skew-symmetric otherwise. In the following tables we give the results of calculations of the highest weights - the labels ( c ,h;HI, . . . , H k ) with respect to the central elements z ; Kt and Kclql, . . . , Kckllhof the spinor representations Spin(.FA,,) of the contact superalgebras. For the oscillator representation 0 s c ( . F ~ , ~=) Spin(II(.FA,,)) the values of the highest weight are (-c, h;H I , . . . , I l k ) . Problem. For which projective representations of tL(1IN) and tM(1IN), where N = 3,4, the values of c are nonzero? (So far there is only a partial answer22.)
3.3. The values c and h of the highest weight of the tL(lIN)-and tM(1IN)-module Spin(Fx;p). The labels of the highest weight other than c, h are all 0 , except for tL(112) and tM(113): the highest weight of Spin(.FA,v;,) is ( c ,h; v). N 0
h for tL
C
12x2 - 12x
+2
1
3 3 - 12X)
2
2
(fi
+ 2 X ) ( p + 1) p+2x
2 p + 2x
+v
h for tM 2p
+ 3x - f
2p
+ 2x - ;
bThe subscript L makes an associative superalgebra a Lie one, replacing the dot product by the supercommutator.
37
Remark. For the contact superalgebras g, our choice of g-modules V = FA;+ from which we constructed Spin(V @ V " )is natural provided we are interested in semi-infinite cohomology of g. Besides, for n small, all modules of tensor fields are of this form, anyway. For the superalgebras g of series Dect and m e c t , the situation is the opposite one: the adjoint representation V = g is of the form V = I ( i d * ) . 3.4. The choice of the cocycle. Now, let us fix the cocycle that determines the nontrivial central extensions of the distinguished stringy superalgebras. One choice comes from.the study of semi-infinite cohomology; it is very interesting and reasonable for Dir. Another choice is to directly calculate the bracket [ei,e-i] in the spinor or oscillator representation. We get
[ei,e-i]
=
(4)
Nowadays such infinite sums seem meaningless (or equal to 00) to most, but less than a century ago every student who took Calculus knew a way to compute (4): evaluate the Riemann <-function ((s) = at s = -1. n>l
For other distinguished stringy superalgebras g, physicists traditionally consider the cocycles whose restriction to the subalgebra mitt c g coincides with the fixed cocycle that determines Dir. The trouble is that there is no canonical embedding mitt c g for g 9 tL(1) or tM(1).
Problems. Which cocycle to choose? I n the following Theorem, can one consider Osc(g) (so CDs are positive) instead of Spin(g) ? 3.5. Theorem. For ~ e c t ~ ( 1 1 2CD ) , is equal to -1; for each saecti(ll2), CD is equal to -2.
Acknowledgements. We are thankful to MPIMiS and (Ch.S.) to the International Max Planck Research School affiliated to it, and the Tschira Foundation for financial support and most creative environment. D.L. is most thankful to A. D. R. Choudary and A. Qadir for hospitality. References 1. B. Feigin, D. Leites, in Group-theoretical methods in physics, eds. M.Markov, et. al. v. 1, Nauka, Moscow, 1983, 269-273, (English translation: Harwood Academic Publ., Chur, 1985, Vol. bf 1-3, 623-629). 2. A.N. Rudakov, Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR Ser. Mat. 38, 835 (1974).
38 3. B. Feigin, D. Fuchs, in Representation of Lie groups and related topics, eds. A. Vershik, D. Zhelobenko, Adv. Stud. Contemp. Math. 7,Gordon and Breach, New York, 1990, 465-554. 4. M. Green, J. Schwarz, E. Witten Superstring theory, (Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, 1987) 5. M.S. Marinov, Soviet Physics Uspekhi, 20,no. 3, 179 (1977); translated from Uspehi Fiz. Nauk, 121 no. 3, 377 (1977). 6. B. Feigin, Usp. Mat. Nauk 39,no. 2 (236), 195 (1984) (English translation: Russian Math. Surveys, 39,155-156). 7. B. Feigin, in Proceedings of the International Congress of Mathematicians, Vol. I, I1 (Kyoto, 1990), 71-85, (Math. SOC.Japan, Tokyo, 1991). 8. B. Feigin, E. Frenkel, Commun. Math. Phys 137,617 (1991); ibid.; erratum: Comm. Math. Phys. 137 , no. 3, 617 (1991); MR 92h:17028. Comm. Math. Phys. 147,no. 3, 647 (1992) 9. I. Frenkel, H. Garland, G. Zuckerman, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 83,8442 (1986). 10. P. Grozman, D. Leites, I. Shchepochkina, Lie superalgebras of string theories. Acta Math. Vietnam. 26 , no. 1, 27 (2001); hep-th/9702120 11. E. Ivanov, S. Krivonos, F. Toppan, Phys. Lett. B 405, 85 (1997). 12. S. Krivonos, A. Sorin, in Supersymmetries and quantum symmetries eds. J. Wess, E. Ivanov, (Dubna, 1997), 261-269, Lecture Notes in Phys. 524, (Springer, Berlin, 1999) 13. D. Leites, in: Operator Methods in Ordinary and Partial Differential Equations, S. Kovalevski Symposium, Univ. of Stockholm, June 2000, eds. S . Albeverio, N. Elander, W. N. Everitt and P. Kurasov (Birkhauser, BaselBoston-Berlin, 2002) (Operator Methods: Advances and Applications 132, 267 (2002)). 14. D. Leites, J . Nonlinear Math. Phys. 7,263 (2000); hep-th/0007256 15. P. Grozman, D. Leites, J . Nonlinear Math. Phys. 8, 220 (2001); math.QA/0104287 16. D. Leites, I. Shchepochkina, Classification of simple vectorial Lie superalgebras, preprint MPIM-Bonn-2003-28 (www.mpim-bonn.mpg.de) 17. V. Kac, A. Rudakov, Modules of Laurent differential forms on a superline (http://www.math.ntnu.no/-rudakov/preprint .html) 18. J. Bernstein, D. Leites, Selecta Math. Sou. 1, 143 (1981). 19. A. Kleshchev, Linear and projective representations of symmetric groups, Cambridge Tracts in Mathematics 163 (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2005). 20. M. Gorelik, Shapovalov determinants of Q-type Lie superalgebras, math.RT/0511623. 21. D. Leites, I. Shchepochkina, Theor. and Math. Physics 126, 339 (2001); preprint ESI-875 (www.esi.ac.at); math-ph/0510048. 22. E. Poletaeva, J . Math. Phys. 42,526 (2001) 23. A. Dzhumadildaev, C. R . Acad. Sci. Paris, Ser. Mathem. 324,497 (1997). 24. Seminar on Supennanifolds, Reports of Stockholm University, 1987-1 992, ed. D. Leites vv. 1-33 (1997).
TRANSITION AMPLITUDES FOR TIME-DEPENDENT LINEAR HARMONIC OSCILLATOR WITH LINEAR TIME-DEPENDENT TERMS ADDED TO THE HAMILTONIAN M. A. FlASHID Centre for Advanced Mathematics and Physics (CAMP), National University of Sciences €4 Technology, EME Campus, Peshawar Road, Rawalpindi, Pakistan E-mail address:
[email protected] Techniques developed earlier t o obtain the transition amplitudes for a general timedependent linear harmonic oscillator using standard operator techniques, are used to calculate transition amplitudes incorporating a linear timedependent term in the Hamiltonian. This allows for odd t o even and even to odd transitions which were not allowed when these linear terms were absent.
1. Introduction Time-dependent harmonic oscillators have been considered by many authors [1- 41. From the point of view of a physical application, Parker [5] applied the alpha and beta coefficients of the problem to the cosmological creation of particles in an expanding universe. Earlier, Kanai [a] had considered a simple form of the time-dependent linear oscillator. Though this model was criticized by Brittin [6] and Senitzky [7] for various reasons, Landovitz et al, ignoring the criticism, proceeded to calculate the Green’s function [8] for the general form of Kanai’s model and used it to calculate the corresponding transition amplitudes [9]. Their calculations are very difficult to comprehend. Recently we used standard operators to calculate the transition amplitudes for the general time-dependent linear harmonic oscillator in a transparent manner [lo]. This approach is expected to be relevant to other physical problems including Senitzky’s [7] complex model for the dissipative quantum mechanical oscillator. Here these manifest operator techniques are used to obtain the transition amplitudes after adding linear time-dependent
39
40
terms to the Hamiltonian which allow for transitions from odd to even and even to odd states. These transitions were not allowed under the even-parity Hamiltonian which did not include the linear terms. This paper is organised as follows. In Section 2, we introduce the modified Hamiltonian and obtain the transformed operator x i ( t ) , p + ( t ) in terms of the non-transformed time-dependent operators x and p and the coeficients in the"transition matrix". In Section 3, we calculate the corresponding transformed creation and annihilation operators. In Section 4, we derive the recursion relations satisfied by these transition amplitudes. These recursion relations are used in Section 5 to calculate a generating function which gives the transition amplitudes in term of the initial one. This initial one is then evaluated using its relationship with a known identity to complete the calculation. 2.
The Transformed Operators z-J-, p*
The Hamiltonian for a time-dependent linear harmonic oscillator with linear time-dependent terms added is given by
In the above, the functions f ( t ) , g ( t ) , u(t) and v ( t ) are all real continuous functions to make the Hamiltonian hermitian. Also f ( t ) = g ( t ) = 1, u ( t )= w ( t ) = 0 gives the usual time-independent linear harmonic oscillator Hamiltonian whereas putting u ( t ) = w ( t ) = 0 reduces to our earlier work [lo]. The wave-functions at an arbitrary time t are related to the ones at time t = 0 through a time-dependent unitary transformation U ( t ) by
Q ( x ,t ) = U ( t ) Q ( X O), ,
(2)
where U ( t ) satisfies the Schrodinger equation, i h & U ( t ) = H ( t ) U ( t ) . We define the operators O+(t)corresponding to any operator O ( t ) (which may have a manifest time-dependence) by
O*(t) = U t ( t ) O ( t ) U ( t ) , O _ ( t )= U ( t ) O ( t ) U t ( t ) .
(3)
These operators satisfy
d 1 -O-(t) = - [H(t),O-(t)] dt ah
+
(5)
41 The operators a+@), p + ( t ) are related to z and p by
+
+
z+(t)= u+(t)zu(t) = a ( t ) z b ( t ) p y1(t), p + ( t ) = u+(t)Pu(t) = c ( t ) z+ d ( t ) P + y2(t), where
a ( 0 ) = d(0) = 1, b(0) = c(0) = 0 , a ( t ) d ( t )- b(t)c(t)= 1 Using 1 dz+ [ z + ( t ) , H + ( t )=] f ( t )P+, ( 4 + u(t) at = ih and the expressions for z+(t),p + ( t ) in equation (6) we arrive at
Similarly from
we obtain
Yz(t) = - g ( t ) m w 2 y l ( t ) - v ( t ) . Equations (8) and (11)yield second order differential equations
Z ( t )- f ' O ( t ) + f (t)g ( t )w"(t) f (t) for the functions a ( t ) , b ( t ) and for c ( t ) ,d ( t ) we get .'
g'(t)
'
Z ( t ) - ---Z(t) 9 (4
=0
+ f ( t )g ( t )W 2Z ( t)= 0.
Equations ( 8 , l l ) have unique solutions, given the initial conditions, a ( 0 ) = d ( 0 ) = 1,b(0) = c(0) = 0. For the time independent case (f ( t )= g ( t )= 1), these are 1 a ( t )= d ( t )= cos w t , b ( t )= -sin w t , c ( t )= - mw sinwt. (15) mw
42
For completeness, we note that y1 ( t ),y2 ( t ) satisfy the non-homogeneous second order differential equations
3. Calculation of the transformed creation and annihilation
operators The non-Hermitian creation and annihilation operators A+ and A are related to the Hermitian operators z and p through
At
=
(p
J5aG
-i + i m w z ) , A = d%zz
( p- imws)
(18)
In terms of the energy eigenstates of the Hamiltonian H = H ( 0 ) given by
the operators A and At have matrix elements
< m IA In >= &S,,-1,
< m IAt In >= &&,+I.
(20)
Next we compute the transformed operatores A+ ( t )and A 1 ( t )in terms of the functions u ( t ) , b ( t ) , c ( t ) ,d(t),yl(t), y 2 ( t ) appearing in the transformed operators z+ ( t )and p+ ( t )in eq. (6). Indeed using equations (4,18b, 6) we have
A+ ( t ) = U t ( t ) A U ( t )=
i ~
d5aG
~t ( t )( p - i m w z ) u ( t )
where
i a ( t )= -( c ( t )- i m w (u ( t ) d ( t ) )- m2w2b( t ) ) 2mw
+
(22a)
43 i
p ( t )= (c ( t )- imw ( a ( t )- d ( t ) )+ m2w2b( t ) ) 2mw
(22b)
Similarly,
A; ( t )= U+ ( t )A+ ( t )U ( t )= p* ( t )A
+ a* ( t )A’ + y*.
(23)
Note that using the earlier initial conditions we get y1 (0) = y2 (0) = 0, a (0) = 1,p (0) = y (0) = 0.
(24)
For completness, we give below the expression for A- ( t )and A+ ( t )
A- ( t ) = a* ( t ) A - P ( t ) A ++ y ’ ( t ) , A t ( t )= -p* ( t ) A + a ( t ) A + + y ’ *( t ) (25) where
As in eq. (24), y’(0) = 0 4. Recursion relation for the transition amplitudes amn ( t ) = ( mIU (t)l n) Following the methods of our earlier paper
[lo] and using eqs. (21,25)
1
a m n ( t ) = (mlU(t)ln) = -(mlU(t)A+In-l)
fi
=-[fi 1
-ff
(4 P* ( t )J n - i ( m
( t )fib
+ff
-
Transposing the term
=
1
-(ATIU(t)ln-l)
fi
IU (t)ln - 2) - IPI2fib IU (t)I4 1IU (t)l n - 1) + (-P* ( t )Y ( t )+ 7’’ ( t ) )( mIU (41n - 1)
1
(26) (m IU (t)ln) and noting that unitarity yields
IaI2 - IpI2 = 1 and using equations (32,33) , we arrive a t
(27)
44
A similar procedure results in another recursion relation
5. Calculation of the transition amplitude We define coefficient Bmn(t)by means of the equation
In terms of Bmn(t)the recursion relation in eq. (28) becomes
n Bmn(t) = Bm-zn(t)
1 + -Bm-ln-l(t) + A(t)Bm-ln(t), IPI
where we have used
(31) The recursion relations in eq. (30) are sufficient to determine all Bmn(t) and hence the transition amplitudes up to a (in general) complex constant. To determine Bmn(t),we define a generating function M
m,n=O
where we shall assume that any Bmn(t)with any index taking negative integral value is zero. Then the recursion relation in eqn. (30) gives
which can be easily solved to give
45
Thus,
From equation (32) Bmn(t)is the coefficient of xm, yn in the above expansion and fix k and 1 as
k=
m-p-q 2
,1=
n-p-r 2
,
(37)
This results in
(38) where the summations over p , q , r are restricted by the argument of any factorial present in equation (38) to be a non-negative integer. For example, if m is an even integer, then p+q have to be even and m - p - q 2 0. We note, in particular, that when m = n = 0 , p = q = r = 0 and Boo(t) = aoo(t), which is consistent equation (35). From eqs. (29) and (38), we have
which gives amn(t) upto the function aoo(t). To determine this function, we use the standard normalization
But from the eq. (39)
x(-l)T(') 1 n--r- P
ao,(t)
= aoo(t)Jnr
From the above equations,
B*(t)". (y)!r!
(41)
46
where the expression in the bracket is obviously non-negative. Also the summation over n though infinite is convergent as
We can choose the phase such that aoo(t) = This reduces to the case of linear harmonic oscillator when f ( t ) = g ( t ) = 1, u ( t )= v ( t ) = 0.
References 1. P. Camiz, A. Garaldi, C. Marchioro, E. Presulti and E. Scacciatelli, J . Math. Physics 12,2040 (1971). 2. E.Kanai, Prog. Theor. Phys. Kyoto 3, 440 (1948). 3. E.H. Kerner, Can. J . Phys 36, 3719 (1958). 4. W.K.H. Stevens, Proc. Phys. SOC.Lond. 72, 1027 (1958). 5. L. Parker, Phys. Rev. 183,1057 (1969), (see in particular equation (13)). 6. E. Brittin, Phys. Rev. 77, 396 (1950). 7. I.R. Senitzky, Phys. Rev. 119,670 (1960). 8. L.F. Londonvitz L. F, A.M. Levine and W.M. Schreiber, Phys. Rev. A 20, 1162 (1979). 9. L.F. Londonvitz, A.M. Levine and W.M. Schreiber, 1980 J. Math. Phys 21, 2159 (1980). 10. M.A. Rashid and A. Mahmood J . Phys. A : Math. Gen 34, 8185 (2001).
ENTROPY SOLUTIONS TO A GENUINELY NONLINEAR ULTRAPARABOLIC KOLMOGOROV-TYPE EQUATION S. A. SAZHENKOV' Center for Advanced Mathematics and Physics, National University of Sciences and Technology, Peshawar Road, Rawalpindi, Pakistan E-mail:
[email protected] We consider a non-isotropic convection-diffusion-reaction equation of a very general form, in which the diffusion matrix is nonnegative and may change its rank depending on temporal and spatial variables, and convection and reaction terms may be discontinuous. This equation arises in astrophysics and plasma physics, in fluid dynamics, mathematical biology and financial mathematics. We assume that the equation a priori admits the maximum principle and is genuinely nonlinear, and we prove that there exists at least one entropy solution and that the genuinely nonlinear structure of the equation rules out fine oscillatory regimes in entropy solutions. The proofs rely on the method of kinetic equation and on theory of H-measures. Keywords: Ultra-parabolic equation; Vlasov-Fokker-Planck equation; Entropy solution; Genuine nonlinearity; Non-isotropic diffusion.
1. Introduction
In a space-time layer II := IW: x (O,T),T = const > 0, we consider the Cauchy problem for the quasilinear equation with partial diffusion and discontinuous convection and reaction terms
ut+&ai(x,t,u) - a 3 c , ( a i j ( ~ , t ) d , j b ( u+ ) )r ( x , t , u )= 0, (la) endowed with periodic initial data belonging to Lw(IWd) and periodicity conditions ult=o = uo(x), x E
u(x
IWd ,
+ ei,t ) = u(x,t ) , (x,t ) E II.
(1b) (1c)
*Permanent affiliation and address is : Lavrentiev Institute of Hydrodynamics, Prospekt Lavrentieva 15, Novosibirsk 630090, Russia.
47
48
In (1)ei (i = 1,...,d ) are standard basis vectors in Rd, u ( x ,t ) is an unknown function; the flux vector a := ( a i ) , the diffusion matrix A := ( a i j ) , the diffusion function b, and the reaction function r are given and satisfy the conditions
ai,Dx,ai,r E ~ ~ o ~ ( I R C ~ o c ( Raij u ) ) , C;oc(n), b E C,2,,-(R), (2) ai, aij, r are 1-periodic in x , A is symmetric, (3) aij(x,t)
In particular, the derivatives a,, and Dxi are connected via identity
&,g(x,t , u)= Dz&,
t ,).
+ a U g ( x , t ,.)az%u.
It is supposed that the rank of the diffusion matrix A may be less than the dimension of the space R : and may vary depending on x and t. Therefore Eq. (la) is an ultraparabolic equation. Equations of the form (la) arise in particle physics, fluid dynamics, combustion theory, mathematical biology, and financial mathematics. They are called Kolmogorov-type equations in line with the works of A. N. Kolmogorov relating to problems on stochastic diffusive processes modeling Brownian motion (see in survey Ref. 2). Particular forms of Eq. (la) have also other names: in problems about nonlinear convection-diffusion-reactionin anisotropic continuous media they are called Graetz-Nusselt equations and in studies of the transport of cosmic-rays they are named Fokker-Planck equations. They describe, in particular, non-stationary transport of energy or matter in cases, when effects of diffusion in some spatial directions are negligible as compared to convection and reaction. Considerably recently Kolmogorov-type equations have been applied to astrophysical problems: in solar physics with the investigation of acceleration of fast electrons in the solar corona and in space physics with ion acceleration at the solar termination shock and with particle acceleration at astrophysical shocks, including the possibility of second-order Fermi a~celeration.~
49
2. Notion of entropy solutions
We are interested in developing the existence and qualitative theory for the Cauchy problem (1) under conditions (2)-(4) and under the assumption that the maximum principle is a priori guaranteed. From the physical point of view, the most appropriate concept of solution to problem (1) is the notion of entropy solutions, since it is consistent with the fundamental fact that in diffusive processes entropy does not d e ~ r e a s e . ~ ? ~ In order to define an entropy solution of problem (l),let us introduce some notation. By Q we denote i2 x (O,T),where R stands for the unit cube [0, l)d. By LP c Lroc(Rd)and HS9p c H&dZ(Rd) we denote the Banach spaces, which consist of 1-periodic functions and are supplemented with the norms llull~p= I I U I I ~ - , ~ ( ~ and I I U I I H ~ , ~ = I I U I I H ~ , ~ ( ~ . For 1 L 0, let C‘ be the closed subspace of u E C’(Rd) such that u is 1-periodic with respect to xi, 1 5 i 5 d. Note that since Eq. (la) is degenerate, then the gradient V,u of a possible solution u E L”(II) may be understood merely in the distributions sense. However, also note that since the matrix A is symmetric and nonnegative, then there is a unique square root A1/2 = { a i j } ,which is a symmetric and nonnegative matrix, as well. This and the standard energy estimate’ yield that a possible solution u of problem (1) should a priori satisfy the bound IIA1/2V,p(u)llL2(Q)5 c, where the constant c does not depend on u and p(u) := m d s . This means that, although a particular derivative d Z i u may not be measurable on II, the differential expressions of the form cxijd,,p(u) involving these derivatives are measurable in II and integrable with the square in Q, i.e., they belong to L&,(II). Therefore the demand of partial integrability of V,u should be introduced into a notion of entropy solution. Now we are in a position to define an entropy solution of problem (1).
s”
Definition 2.1. Function u = u ( x ,t ) is an entropy solution of problem (l), if it satisfies the regularity and periodicity conditions u E LM(O,T ;L’) and cxijdZjp(u)E L2(0,T ;L 2 ) ,1 5 i 5 d; the entropy inequality
dtcp(u) + dzaqi(X, 4 u)- DZ,Qi(X,t ,).
+ cp’(u)D,iai(x, t ,u)
in the distributions sense for all functions cp, qi and w such that cp E C~oc(R), cp”(u) 2 0 , duqi(x, t ,u)= cp’(u)duai(x,t ,u ) , and w’(u)= cp’(u)b’(u);and
50
the initial data (lb) in the weak sense, i.e., in the sense of the limiting relation u ( - , 7 )4 uo(.)weakly* in L”, as T \ 0. Note that taking p(u) = f u in (5) we see that entropy solution satisfies Eq. ( l a ) in the sense of distributions. 3. Formulation of the main results Besides conditions (2)-(4), the following genuine nonlinearity condition is imposed on the functions ai, a i j , and h. Condition 3.1. For a.e. ( x , t )E Il the following demand is fulfilled: for all ( 6 , ~ E ) Rd+’ such that I6I2 72 = 1 the intersection of the sets {A E R I h’(A)aij(x,t)Ci& = 0 ) and {A E R I T (dAai(x,t,X) (l/2)h’(A)dz, a i j ( x , t ) ) [ i = 0 ) has zero Lebesgue measure.
+
+
+
The following new existence theorem is the first main result of the paper. Theorem 3.1. Assume that Eq. (la) is genuinely nonlinear, satisfies conditions (2)-(4) and a priori admits the maximum principle. Then problem (1) has at least one entropy solution for any given data uo E Loo. Also we establish a qualitative property of genuine nonlinearity to rule out fine oscillations developing from initial data, which is the second main result of the paper. Theorem 3.2. Assume that Eq. (la) is genuinely nonlinear, satisfies conditions (2)-(4), a priori admits the maximum principle, and is provided with highly oscillatory initial data uk E L““, k = 1 , 2 , .. . such that uk 4 uo weakly* in L” as k 703. Then there exists a subsequence of entropy solutions u k , corresponding ; ) as k /” 03 to an to initial data uk, which tends strongly in L 2 ( 0 , T L2 entropy solution u, corresponding to initial data U O . 4. Method of justification of Theorems 3.1 and 3.2
Proofs of Theorems 3.1 and 3.2 rely upon the method of kinetic e q ~ a t i o n which allows to reduce quasilinear equations and systems to linear scalar equations on “distribution” functions involving additional “kinetic” variables. Alongside this method, the theory of H - m e a s u r e ~is~implemented. ~~ In this final section we give a brief explanation of the methodology of the proofs of Theorems 3.1 and 3.2.
51
First, the kinetic formulation of problem (1) is introduced in the form proposed in Ref. 6. It is linear with respect to the desired function, which is the distribution function f (x,t , A) = f z , t ( X ) of the parametrized Dirac measure on concentrated at the point X = u(x, t ) , where u(x,t ) is the entropy solution of problem (1).Notion of entropy solution and the kinetic formulation are equivalent to each other. Linearity of the kinetic formulation becomes possible due to appearance of an additional kinetic variable A. Second, the proof of Theorem 3.2 is fulfilled by virtue of the toolbox of the theory of H-measures. The construction of H-measures associated with a weakly convergent subsequence of the distribution functions fk(x,t , A), Ic = 1 , 2 , . . . is introduced in the form which was proposed in Ref. 8 for studying scalar conservation laws. By their nature, H-measures are microlocal defect measures that allow to track evolution of fine oscillatory regimes in the space of time t , positions x and frequencies E . More precisely, for any fixed X E R they indicate where in the physical space of time and positions, and at which frequencies in the Fourier space, weakly convergent in Lfo, sequences fail to converge strongly. One of the main properties of H-measures is that they are zero measures if and only if their generating subsequence is strongly convergent. Using the technics of Ref. 10, it is possible to establish a localization principle for the H-measures, i.e., to define a set in the (x,t,<)-spacesuch that the H-measures vanish in its complement. This principle combined with the genuine nonlinearity condition immediately imply that the H-measures are equal to zero measure everywhere for almost all X E R.Hence their generating subsequence is compact, which finishes the proof of Theorem 3.2. Finally, in order to prove Theorem 3.1, we introduce the well-posed approximation of problem (1), which incorporates a regularizing ‘‘small viscosity” coefficient. Availability of such approximation is guaranteed by the well-known theory of parabolic equations.’ After this, it is sufficient to remark that the approximate problem admits the kinetic formulation of exactly the same form as problem (1). Thus the rest of the proof of Theorem 3.1 is merely the byproduct of the proof of Theorem 3.2.
Acknowledgment The work was partially supported by the grant of Higher Education Commission of Pakistan under National Research Program for Universities (project title: Modern Mathematical Analysis for Phenomenon of Anisotropic Diffusion and Acoustic Wave Propagation in Porous Media).
52
References 1. 0. A. Ladyzhenskaya, V. A. Solonnikov, N. N. Uraltseva, Linear and Quasilinear Equations of Parabolic Type (Amer. Math. SOC.,Providence, RI, 1968). 2. E. Lanconelli, A. Pascucci, S. Polidoro, in Nonlinear Problems in Mathematical Physics and Related Topics 11, I n Honor of Professor O.A. Ladyzhenskaya, International Mathematical Series (Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht, 2002). 3. A. Marcowith, J.G. Kirk, Astron. Astrophys. 347,391 (1999). 4. L. D. Landau, E. M. Lifshitz, Statistical Physics, Part I, vol. 5 of Course of Theoretical Physics (Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford, 1999). 5. L. D. Landau, E. M. Lifshitz, Fluid Mechanics, vol. 6 of Course of Theoretical Physics (Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1959). 6. G.-Q. Chen, B. Perthame, Ann. Inst. H. Poincare' Anal. Non Line'aire 2 0 , 645 (2003). 7. P. I. Plotnikov, S. A. Sazhenkov, J. Math. Anal. Appl. 304,703 (2005). 8. E. Yu. Panov, Sbornik Math. 81,211 (1995). 9. L. Tartar, Proc. R. SOC.Edinb. 115A,193 (1990). 10. S. A. Sazhenkov, Siberian Math. J. 47,355 (2006).
FOKKER-PLANCK-KOLMOGOROV EQUATION FOR fBm: DERIVATION AND ANALYTICAL SOLUTIONS. GAZANFERUNAL Faculty of Sciences, Istanbul Technical University, Maslak 34469. Turkey E-mail: gunalOitu.edu. tr The Fokker-Planck-Kolmogorov (FPK) equation for It6 systems with fractional Brownian motion (fE3m) has been derived. The generalized Liouville theorem has been proved. Analytic solutions to the FPK have been obtained via conserved quantities of the deterministic part.
1. Introduction
F'ractional Brownian motion (fBm) was introduced by Kolmogorov to study turbulence in an incompressible fluid flow'. Long range dependence and selfsimilarity properties of fBm announced itself in the Nile river level studies of Hurst2. The parameter H E ( 0 , l ) which scales fBm BF (t 2 0) is called the Hurst parameter. Mandelbrot and van Ness studied properties of the fBm3. Standard Brownian motion becomes a special case of the fBm with the Hurst parameter H = 1/2. In contrast with the standard Brownian motion, increments of BF (t 2 0) are no longer statistically independent for nonoverlapping intervals of t. The correlation function becomes negative for H E (0,1/2) and it is known as antipersistent behaviour3. This is also known as intermittency in the study of turbulent fluid flows'.The correlation between the increments of BY (t 2 0) for non-overlapping intervals become positive for H E (1/2,1). It shows long-range dependence i.e. it becomes persistent. We now witness the foot prints of the fBm BF (t 2 0) for H E (1/2,1) ranging from the characteristics of solar activity to weather derivatives in mathematical finance4. An fl3m BF (t 2 0) is neither a semi-martingale6 nor a Markov process7. Therefore, a new stochastic calculus is needed for its treatment. It6 calculus for H E (0,1/2) has been given in reference [5] and for H E (1/2,1) in references [6] and [7]. Recently, Bender' has developed
53
54
a new calculus which is valid for H E ( 0 , l ) (see also reference [9] for an alternative approach). Here we rely on Bender's It6 formula in this paper. Here we consider It6 stochastic ordinary differential equation (SODE) of the form
+
dxi = fi(x,t)dt gia(x,t ) d B f , 1 I iI n;1 I aI T,
(1)
where f i ( x ,t ) is a drift vector and gi,(x, t ) is a diffusion matrix and, dB," is increment of fBm (summation convention applies to repeated indices and drops for indices in paranthesis hereafter). Based on an It6 lemmas~g which is valid for H E ( 0 , l ) we derive the FPK equation. Furthermore the Liouville theorem has been extended to It6 SODE given in equation (1). Finally we have obtained analytic solutions to the FPK equation via conserved quantities of the deterministic. This result leads to the fluctuationdissipation theorem
'.
1.1. Derivation of the FPK equation for f B m It6's formula for fBm for a scalar function h ( x ) reads as
The expectation value of Eq. (2) is
H t Z H - ' g j , gd2h k , ~ ] dt+E [gja%dBf1 dh
Therefore, we have
We now recall
This leads to
55
Let us treat each term on the right hand side separately.
where circumflex d i j denotes the omission of the variable. Integration by parts of the integral yields
The first term on the right hand side must vanish since p = 0 a t x j = f m . Hence,
Similarly we now treat the second integral in equation (7) to obtain
where
aij = g j a g k a .
Rendering back Eq. (10) and (11) into Eq. (7) yields
from which we deduce that
This is the celebrated FPK equation for It6 systems driven by fBm. Notice that when H = 1/2 Eq.(13) reduces to the celebrated Fokker-Planck equation for It6 system driven by Brownian motion. 2. Generalized Liouville theorem The Liouville theorem has been extended to the Langevin equations with standard Brownian motion by ChandrasekharlO. Here we extend it to It6 SODEs with tBm. We first define the following vector fields
H=hj-
d
dXj
and
d G,=gj,---, dXj
56
where
We now calculate i)
a
% ( p ( x , t ) R ) ; i i ) ~ H ( p ( xt , ) ~ ) iii) ; ~ 2 , ( p ( xt ), R ) ;
(15)
where p ( x , t ) is a smooth function, R = d x l A . . . A d x , is a volume form, C,is a Lie derivative with respect to the vector field given in the subscript and
~ 2 =, cG,cG,. Straightforward calculations for i) and ii) in Equation (15) lead to i)
zd( p ( x , t ) R ) = ( azP) R ,
ii) &(PO) =
In order to calculate the term iii) in Equation (15), we first evaluate CG, (Po):
We then calculate the Lie derivative of Equation (17) with respect to the vector field G, and sum over Q to obtain
Equations (16-18) are combined to give
where
Notice that 0 is an expansion of the term
57
We now rewrite Equation (19) as
Suppose that the function p ( x , t ) satisfies the FPK equation (13). Then the RHS of Equation (20) vanishes. If the LHS of Equation (20) vanishes, the function p ( x , t ) should satisfy the FPK equation given in (13). Hence, we have proven the following theorem.
Theorem 2.1. A sufficiently smooth function p ( x ,t ) satisfies
(g+LH--L 2 G2 , p R = O iff it satisfies the FPK equation given by Equation (13). Remark 2.1. Theorem 2.1 reduces to
for a deterministic dynamical system with the vector field
F=
fj-.
a
dXj
This is, indeed, the celebrated Liouville’s theorem which can be found in references [ll]and [12]. Therefore, Theorem 2.1 can be considered as an extension of Liouville’s theorem to stochastic systems. 3. Analytical solutions to the modified FPK equation
In this section we will make use of the generalized Liouville theorem to obtain the exact solutions to the modified FPK equation.
Proposition 3.1. Let the It6 S O D E with fBm be given as
dI dxi = f i ( x , t ) d t - d ( i ) ( x l , ...,&, ...,z,,t)-dt+g(i)(x1, dXi
..., &, . . . , X n , t ) d B y ,
(22) where caret denotes omission, I ( x , t ) = c r = l ckIrc(x,t ) , f j , j = Cons and C k s are constants, and
58
Then p ( x , t ) = Ae-(b'Sf3Jt), A and b are constants
is a solution to modified FPK equation (13) provided that di(x1, . . . , ~ i , . . . ,~ , , t )= bHt 2H-1 gi(xl,...,~i-i,...,x,,t) 2 .
(24) (25)
Proof. Let us define the following vector fields
Notice that div C =Cons , diw G,=O and
gkagia,k = 0. (26) This leads to H = F . We now appeal to the Liouville theorem which was proved earlier. To achieve this goal we calculate
i) zd( p ( x ,t ) R ) = ( azP) R , ii) , C F ( P ~ = ) ( L C P ) ~p(divC)R+ ( L D P ) R
+
()::
+p(divD)R, iii) L&(pR)= g i 7
R.
Rendering them back into (21) yields
The terms in the paranthesis must be zero for this relation to hold. Let p = 7r(I)e-(di"c)t where m
k=l
Here I k ( x ,t ) satisfy the condition given in (23). This leads to
Let us now use the condition given in (25). We now have
d7T
dl = -bI.
Solution to this equation leads to (24) thereby proving the proposition.
Remark 3.1. Constant A will be determined from the normalization condition i.e..
59
77 .. .
A
-w
e-('CEI Ck'k(X,t)f(divC)t)dlC1. . . d s ,
1.
:
-w
Therefore the constants ck must be chosen such that the function p(x,t ) is normalizable, so that it can represent a probability density function.
Corollary 3.1. Let the It6 SODE with fBm be given as
+ g ( i ) ( q , P l , ...,ljil
...IP,, t)dB?
(27)
where ' H ( p , q ) is the Hamiltonian and (i = l...n). The associated modified FPK equation (13) has a stationay solution of the form p ( p , q) = Ae-bx7 A and b are constants
(28)
provided that di(q,~l,...,lji,...,~,lt) = bHt
2H-1
2
gi(q,pl,...,lji,...,~,,t) *
(29)
Proof: Notice that the diffusion matrix enjoys the property (26). Letting
c =--ax a a ~ aqj j
-
ax a
--
aqj
a~j
in the proof of the proposition leads to the required result.
Remark 3.2. Notice that when the Hurst parameter H = 1/2 and, g i and di are constants in (29) leads to the celebrated fluctuation-dissipation relation
Acknowledgments Financial support provided by the conference organizers is gratefully acknowledged.
References 1. A. N. Kolmogorov, c. R. (Doklady) Acad. Sci. URSS (N.S.). 26, 115 (1940). 2. H.E. Hurst et al, Constable, London (1965). 3. B. B. Mandelbrot and J.W. Van Ness, S I A M Review 10, 422 (1968).
60
4. A. Shiryaev, in Workshop on Mathematical Finance, eds. A Shiryaev and A Sulem ( INRIA, Paris, 1998). 5. E. Al'os, 0. Mazet and D. Nualart, Stochastic Processes and their Applications 86,121 (2000). T. E. Duncan, Nonlinear Analysis 47, 4775 (2001). E. Al'os and D. Nualart, Stochastics and Stochastics Reports 75, 129 (2003). C. Bender, Stochastic Processes and their Applications 104,81 (2003). F. Biagini, B. Oksendal, B., A. Sulem and N. Wallner, Proc. R. SOC.Lond. A 460, 347 (2004). 10. S. Chandrasekhar, Rev. Mod. Phys. 15,2 (1943). 11. W.H. Steeb, Foundations of Physics 10,485 (1985). 12. G. Unal, Phys. Lett. A 233, 193 (1997). 6. 7. 8. 9.
Particle Physics and String Theory
This page intentionally left blank
HOLOGRAPHY AND DE SITTER SPACE MOHSEN ALISHAHIHA
Institute for Studies in Theoretical Physics and Mathematics (IPM), P . 0 . Box 19395-5531, Tehran, Iran E-mail: alishahOtheory.ipm.ac.ir In this talk I will review the simplest derivation of the holomorphic principle and the role of AdS/CFT correspondence in understanding it. I will then generalize it for de Sitter space where I present a holographic dual of gravity on de Sitter space in the static patch.
1. Holographic principle and AdS/CFT correspondence Let us start with one of our favorite equations which has been at the center of attention in theoretical physics for decades, namely the BekensteinHawking area-entropy law formula
s = 4G -A
'
This means that the entropy of a black hole, with area of the horizon A , is given by quarter of the area in natural units. One interesting feature of this formula is its universality and in fact it applies to all kinds of black holes. It is universal in the sense that it is independent of the specific characteristics and composition of the matter system. More interestingly it even applies for cosmological horizons like de Sitter space. We note, however, that its validity is not truly universal, namely it applies only when there is weakly coupled gravity. In particular if we consider higher order corrections to the Einstein-Hilbert action we will get a deviation from the area law. In this case one needs to use the Wald formula for the entropy l. Now the question we would like to ask is whether this equation could put a bound on the entropy of a system with gravitational interaction. To do this we closely follow the notation of papers by 't Hooft2 and Susskind3. To proceed we consider a spherically symmetric weakly coupled gravitational system. We will also assume that the space time is asymptotically flat.
63
64
Now with these assumptions consider an isolated matter system with mass M and entropy S,. Let us denote by A the area of the smallest sphere that fits around the system. To get a stable system M must be less than the mass of a black hole of the same area. Now consider a shell with mass m such that adding it to the system converts it to a black hole. Therefore the initial entropy of the system is initial Stotal -
sm + Sshi
(2)
s&
where is the entropy of the shell. Since the system is a black hole after adding the shell, the final entropy of the system is given by final Stotai = SBH =
A
-. 4G
(3)
On the other hand we note that the initial entropy must not exceed the final entropy so that S, s& I Taking into account that s s h > 0 leads one to the “spherical entropy bound” as follows
+
&.
s
A 4G
<-.
-
(4)
From a thermodynamical point of view entropy has a statistical interpretation. To be precise es is the number of independent quantum states on the volume surrounded by A. Therefore the entropy bound will put a bound on the number of degrees of freedom. In fact it seems that degrees of freedom are sufficient to fully describe any stable region enclosed by a sphere of area A. As a conclusion we are led to the holographic principle which states: A region with boundary of area A is f i l l y described by n o more than degrees of freedom or about 1 bit of information per Planclc area. Most of our intuitions about the holographic principle have come from AdS/CFT correspondence. Roughly speaking one may summarize the statement of AdS/CFT correspondence as follows. A d 1 dimensional theory which includes gravity is “dual” to a d dimensional theory without gravity. The prototype example of this correspondence comes from type IIB string theory on an A d s 5 background. More precisely the conjecture says: Type IIB string theory on A d s 5 x S5 with N units of five-form flux on S5 is dual to = 4 SYM theory an four dimensions with gauge group
6
+
U(N). Let us explain different points which are involved in this conjecture (1) Ads5 is a maximally symmetric solution of the Einstein action with
65
negative cosmological constant whose metric is given by
- + -dU2 R2
U2 ds2 = - d X 2 r2
u2
in Poincar6 coordinates and
ds2 = R2(cosh2pdt2
+ dp2 + sinh2 pdR;)
in global coordinates.
(2) The dual gauge theory lives on the boundary of the AdS5. Therefore if we take the Poincar6 coordinates the dual gauge theory is defined on R4 while in the global coordinate it is defined on R1 x S3. (3) There is one to one correspondence between objects of gauge theory and those of gravity which we summarize in table 1.
Table 1. Correspondence between objects of gauge theory and gravity ~
String theory side
Gauge theory side
String coupling Curvature S0(2,4) x SO(6) fields, strings, ... Partition functions
N 't Hooft coupling SC-group x R-symmetry Gauge inv. operators Generating functions
To see how the correspondence works consider for example a scalar field q5 with mass m such that dlboundary = $0. According to this correspondence one has
and the conformal dimension of the corresponding operator 0 , A, is given in terms of d and m: A = $ ( d d -).
+
2. Holography for de Sitter space In this section we would like t o see how one can find a holographic dual for gravity on de Sitter space. In this section we will present two different holographic descriptions for gravity on de Sitter space in two different coordinates. So let us first review a few facts about de Sitter space.
66
2.1.
What is de Sitter space?
de Sitter space is the maximally symmetric solution of the Einstein equations with positive cosmological constant. In fact the d-dimensional de Sitter space (dsd) can be realized as a hypersurface described by the following algebraic equation in flat d 1 dimensional Minkowski space
+
The dS metric is the induced metric from the flat space
Comparing the corresponding metric with the Einstein equations which are written in terms of the cosmological constant one finds a relation between the cosmological constant and the radius of the dS space as follows
A=
(d - l ) ( d- 2 ) 212
+
Therefore the dSd in the flat d 1 dimensional Minkowski space is a hyperboloid. The constraint ( 5 ) can be solved in different ways leading to different coordinate systems for dS space. Different coordinate systems are good for different purpose. The dS metric in global coordinates is given by
d S 2 = -dr2
+ l 2 cosh2 71 d R i - ,
As we see in these coordinates dsd space looks like a d - 1 sphere which starts out infinitely large at r = -00 then shrinks to its minimum finite size that r = 0 and then grows again to infinite size at r = 00. 2 . 2 . W h y de Sitter space? Having had enough information about dS space it is natural to ask why we are interested in dS space? Actually the recent astronomical observations indicate that the cosmological constant in our universe is not zero. In fact not only it is not zero but also its contribution is quite important and in fact it is responsible for almost 73% of the energy of the universe ( dark energy). If this interpretation of the observational data is correct, it means our universe might currently be in the de Sitter phase. Therefore it is worthwhile to study (quantum) gravity in de Sitter space.
67
Another interesting feature of dS space is that it has a cosmological horizon in which one can associate a temperature and an entropy which behaves very similar to the black hole area law
s = 4G -A ’
(7)
where A is the area of the cosmological horizon. This is the same as for a black hole and we would like to understand the origin of this entropy for dS as well.
2.3. d S / C F T correspondence From what we have learned in AdS/CFT correspondence one may hope that some kind of holography can also be applied here and could help us to understand quantum gravity on dS. In fact there is a naive observation. Namely consider an Ads space with radius R. Under R -+ iR one gets
A Ads SO(2,d)
+
-
+
-A dS SO(l,d+l)
Therefore one may conclude that gravity on dS is dual to a Euclidean CFT. Although this is just a naive observation and indeed it does not mean that we can study dS space by just an analytic continuationa, one can still think about it as an insight and try to make this statement as precise as we can. In fact this is the content of what is known as dS/CFT correspondence5. To make this correspondence precise let us consider the Brown-York stress tensor6, TP”,for a space time which is asymptotically dS7. One may ask the following questions: ( 1 ) What would be the boundary conditions for the metric if we want the stress tensor to be finite? ( 2 ) What is the most general diffeomorphism which preserves these boundary conditions?
The first question can be answered by perturbing dS space and computing T”” and then one may answer the second question. The answer to the second question is that the most general diffeomorphism is the conformal group of the ( d - 1)-dimensional Euclidean space. aIn particular we note that under this transformation there is no one to one correspondence between representations of SO(2,d ) and SO(1, d 1).
+
68
This is one of the main hints of the dS/CFT correspondence which says5:Quantum gravity o n dSd is dual t o a ( d - 1)-dimensional Euclidean conformal field theory residing o n the past boundary I- of dsd. We note that this CFT may be non-unitary! We note also that in studying this correspondence one uses the dS in the planar metric. So it is natural to ask: How would the holography work if we picked another coordinate system? In the next subsection we are going t o answer this question by studying gravity on dS space in the static coordinates. 2.4. d S / d S correspondence
In this subsection we would like to give a new holographic picture for gravity on dS in the static coordinate^'^^. The static patch in d dimensional de Sitter space of radius R can be foliated by dSd-1 slices:
ds2
= sin2
(i)
ds2sd-l
+ dW2.
The resulting metric (8) has a warp factor which is maximal with finite value at a central slice w = 1rR/2,dropping monotonically on each side until it reaches zero at the horizon w = 0, nR (see Fig. 1).The region near dS, static patch (spatial)
Localized graviton
E=O
1 R
E= -
E=O
Fig. 1. dSd-1 slicing of dsd.
the horizon, which corresponds to low energies in the static coordinates, is
69
isomorphic to that of d dimensional Ads space foliated by dsd-1 slices (for which the warp factor is sinh2(w/R) rather than sin2(w/R)) and hence constitutes a CFT on dsd-1 at low energies. Correspondingly, D-brane probes of this region exhibit the same rich dynamics as a strongly coupled CFT on its approximate Coulomb branch. Meanwhile, probes constructed from bulk gravitons range from energy 0 up to energy 1 / R at the central slice, and upon dimensional reduction their spectrum exhibits the mass gap expected of d - 1 dimensional conformal field theory on de Sitter space. Dimensionally reducing to the d - 1 dimensional effective field theory also yields a finite d - 1 dimensional Planck mass, so the lower dimensional theory itself includes dynamical gravity. Altogether, the geometry and energy scales are as summarized in Fig. 1. This leads to the following statement of de Sitter holography: The dsd static patch is dual to two conformal field theories on dSd-1 (hence thermal with temperature T = l/R), cut off at an energy scale 1 / R and coupled to each other as well as to (d - 1)-dimensional gravity. As it stands, restricting ourselves to times short compared to the decay time, and codimension one, this type of duality is analogous to the holographically dual description of the Randall-Sundrum or warped compactification geometries or, more precisely, the multi-throated versions. That is, the d-dimensional gravity theory is dual to a d - 1 dimensional cut off quantum field theory coupled to gravity. Both sides of the correspondence involve gravity (in different dimensions); nonetheless the holographic relation is useful because the bulk of the entropy is carried by the field theoretic degrees of freedom. This analogous RS case is reviewed in Fig. 2. At higher
"~
Localized graviton
Fig. 2.
&,
RS picture of dS/dS correspondence
energies E + Ads and dS differ. In AdSd-1, the warp factor diverges towards the UV region of the geometry (far away from the horizon) and d - 1 dimensional gravity decouples. In our case, as in Randall-Sundrum, the warp factor is bounded in the solution and one finds a dynamical d - 1 dimensional graviton. In the Randall-Sundrum construction, one truncates
70
the warp factor at a finite value of the radial coordinate by including a brane source (or a compactification manifold) with extra degrees of freedom. In the dS case, the additional brane source is unnecessary; a smooth UV brane at which the warp factor turns around is built in to the geometry. As reviewed above, the d - 1dimensional holographic dual of dSd is only a pair of CFTs up to the energy scale 1/R. On the d dimensional gravity side of the correspondence, one has a local effective field theory description good up to the d-dimensional Planck scale Md >> 1/R (or perhaps the bulk string scale in a stringy construction). At scales above Md quantum gravity effects become important in the bulk and one has to appropriately UV complete the system, for example by embedding it as a metastable dS into string theory following one of the constructions Most of our analysis now will be concerned with using the gravity side of the correspondence to determine the behavior of the d - 1 theory in the range of energies 1 / R < E < hfd. In the d-1 description, the Planck mass is dominated by an induced contribution of order MtIf N S/Rd-3, where S N (MdR)d-2 N ( M ~ - I R ) is the Gibbons-Hawking entropy of dSd and the effective species number (central charge) of our dual low energy CFTs. These scales of interest are summarized in Fig.3. One can use AdS/CFT correspondence to study some
'.
t
BRANE .,.
.. ....................,..,,.
,, ,,,,,,,, ,,
Quantum Gravity
_ _ _ _ _ _ - _ - _ - - - -_- _ - - - - - - - - BULK Classical Gravity in dSd
Md-1
Md
?
_ _ _ _ _ - - - - _ _ _l/L -Gravity + 2 CFTs in dS d-l
Fig. 3.
The correspondence in different energy scales
properties of this duality. In dS slicing the metric of dSd reads
71
while Ad& can be written as
Therefore the two can be related by a simple conformal transformation. 1 d S i d S d = tanh2(z)d 4 S d We can use this to map the physics in dS to dynamics in Ads, albeit with unusual actions. Namely the conformal map yields scalars with position dependent masses and gravity with a position dependent Newton constant. By applying the AdS/CFT dictionary to the resulting system, this allows us to make a direct comparison of the UV behavior of the d - 1 dual of dsd to the UV behavior of a strongly 't Hooft coupled CFT. The results are as follows. Scalar field: We get a conformally coupled scalar in Ads, independent of what values of the parameters M and E we started with in dS! The corresponding UV dimension of the dual operator is d
This ensures that the < 00 > two point function for the second choice behavior of a scalar field in d dimensions. reduces to the usual Gravity: We see that the dS/dS graviton corresponds to a varying Newton's constant in Ads, Md(z) = f (2)Md. As we approach the boundary the gravitational coupling increases. This allows for the localized graviton. Close to the boundary the graviton looks like a flat space graviton! In particular, the possible boundary behaviors are zo and z' , as opposed to zo and z4 for ordinary Ads gravity. This seems to yield two possibilities of the dimension of the dual operator, d - 1 and d - 2. Of course we expect the graviton to couple to the energy-momentum tensor with dimension d - 1. Conformal anomaly: One may also study the conformal anomaly for both dS slicing of Ads and dS slicing of dS. In the first case we get conformal anomaly for dS2, dS4 and dS6, while for the latter case the conformal anomaly is zero. One possible interpretation is that lower dimensional gravity screens the central charge to be zero, just as is well known from 2d gravity on string theory world sheets. In this scenario one does not even need a conformal field theory beyond scales 1 / R since the gravitational dressing will also make any FT a CFT. In the same spirit the universal UV dimension of the scalar fields can be understood as gravitational dressing.
72
3. Conclusions Let us conclude the talk by a few remarks.
(1) Holography might lead to a fundamental theory which includes quantum gravity.
(2) String theory has provided us an explicit example of holography: AdS/CFT correspondence. (3) This not only might help us t o understand quantum gravity and black holes but also it might provide a framework to study non-perturbative gauge theory (QCD). (4) One may also study quantum gravity on dS using holography. ( 5 ) So far there are two proposed holographies for dS space: dS/CFT and dS/dS.
References 1. R. M. Wald, “Black hole entropy in the Noether charge,” Phys. Rev. D 48, 3427 (1993) [arXiv:gr-qc/9307038]. 2. G. ’t Hooft, “Dimensional reduction in quantum gravity,” gr-qc/9310026. 3. L. Susskind, “The world as a hologram,” hep-th/9409089 4. S. Kachru, R. Kallosh, A. Linde and S. P. Trivedi, Phys. Rev. D 68, 046005 (2003) [arXiv:hep-th/0301240]. 5. A. Strominger, JHEP 0110,034 (2001) [arXiv:hep-th/0106113]. 6. J. D. Brown and J. W. York, Phys. Rev. D 47, 1407 (1993). 7. V. Balasubramanian,J. de Boer and D. Minic, Phys. Rev. D 6 5 , 123508 (2002) [arxiv:hep-t h/0110108]. 8. M. Alishahiha, A. Karch and E. Silverstein, JHEP 0506, 028 (2005) [arXiv:hep-th/0504056]. 9. M. Alishahiha, A. Karch, E. Silverstein and D. Tong, AIP Conf. Proc. 743, 393 (2005) [arXiv:hep-th/0407125].
BRANE COSMOLOGY WITH STRING ANTISYMMETRIC FIELD F. ARDALAN Physics Department, Sharif University of Technology, Tehran, Iran School of Physics, I w t . for Studies in Theoretical Phys. and Math. (IPM), Tehran, P.O. Box 19395-5531,Iran E-mail:
[email protected] physics.ipm.ac.ir The equations of a string inspired noncommutative gravity model on a brane are shown to admit a first integral, generalizing the five dimensional Friedman equation for the FRW Hubble parameter. Keywords: Gravity, Cosmology and Noncommutativity
In spite of extensive work on noncommutative gravity in the past few years, there is very little known about the noncommutative gravity theory induced on a brane, from string theory in the low energy, in the presence of a nonzero antisymmetric B field.” The one result in this area is Ref. [2] whose action is studied here. To present the result a short review of the string-induced gravity of Ref. [2] is in order: Closed strings generically have a massless spectrum consisting of the states
aThere are references to earlier work in Ref. 111 where the failure of the latest proposed noncommutative gravity theory to agree with string low energy is confirmed.
73
74
which give, the g,,
Graviton, symmetric,
the I?,,
Kalb-Ramond, antisymmetric,
and cp
Dilaton.
On the other hand open strings with Neumann boundary conditions give gauge fields in low energy and with Dirichlet boundary conditions lead to D-branes. Existence of branes provides for a simple description of our world, the brane world, where gauge fields live on 3-branes, and gravitons, cp, and B,, live in the bulk. It is known that, generally, in the low energy theory of string theory there are
1- Yang-Mills fields, with the action
C = FpyFPu , F,,
= a,A, - &A,
+ [A,, A,]
and 2- Gravity metric g,,
field with Einstein-Hilbert Lagrangian
R = R,V~pgpAgVP
C = &R,
In the presence of a constant nonzero B,, become noncommutative .
.
[d,53]
-
coordinates on the brain
B
and the low energy theory is modified as:
1’- Noncommutative Yang-Mills
LCg = F,,
* F’”,
F,,
= a,A,
-
&A,
+ [A, * A,
-
A,
* A,]
75
the product appearing in the scattering of gauge bosons; and 2’- An as yet unknown modification of Einstein gravity theory. In Ref. [2] by considering graviton scattering, it was found that the gravity model induced on a p-brane in the presence of a nonzero covariantly constant B field (Bab;c= 0), has the following form
/CB
= /dd’d-Rabcd(-)ac(-)bd,
1 g+B
1 g+B
a,b,c,d=O,l,..., p.
(1) It is to be noted that the form of the action in [2] is slightly different from equation (1);in particular B is taken to be constant there, which is in conflict with general covariance. The point of this work is to try to do cosmology with CB.There are a number of points in this regard: 1- B a b # 0 on 3-branes has been studied, independent of the action L B in eq. (l),in some detail, and has produced bounds on B, and naturally incorporates anisotropy in R4 cosmology. 2- B a b # 0 in the bulk may stabilize brane moduli, a point to be addressed in a separate work.
Here a simple situation on a 5-brane is considered where in the 5 and 6 directions.
Bab #
0 only
76
The FRW ansatz in 6 dimensions is
ds2 = -n2(t,y)dt2
+ a 2 ( t ,y)d2Ci + gABdyAdyB;
(3)
is the maximally symmetric homogeneous where A , B = 5,6, and isotropic 3 dimensional manifold with k = 0, ~1 The covariant constancy of B,
BAB;C= 0, leads to
BAB = Bod-
EAB
(4)
with Bo a constant; the two dimensional metric g ( 2 ) is taken as
The Einstein tensors of this action with the above metric are rather tedius and will be reported elsewhere. Here only a simple 5-dimensional limit is presented:
a2 6 ci iz GiB = ~ i { - [ - ( -+ 2-) n b2 a a
-
1 6 7i --(f2b n
ci
1 2a'l a
+ 2-)a + -(f2
n" + -)] n
77
where
b - bl
,
a,
E
=y5
,
a*
E
y
a -a av
, etc.
a
, etc.
and f2 =
+ Bg.
1
In the case of B = 0, a remarkable solution, Ref.[3], was obtained by noting that the Einstein tensor can be written as
with
F
ah
E (-)
b
aa - (-)2
n
- ka2;
and Einstein eqs. with
where the discontinuity across the brane has been used,
h ab
[-]
n2
= --p
3
b.
(13)
78
When B # 0 it is easy to verify that a generalization of the above construction exists. Then it can be shown that the relevant Einstein tensors may be written in terms of two functions F and F B ,
F = a2Fo,
a’
FB = a2f2Fo, Fo = (,)2
a - (--)2
-
Ic,
(19)
as
Then the Friedman eq. becomes
where now
&
from the dark This is a matter content modified by the factor of energy relation Ps = - p of eq. (16). Note also that a constant of integration C, as in equation (17), is not allowed, i.e. ”dark radiation” is not permitted when B # 0 Thus turning on a B field in two extra dimensions modifies the 4 dimensional evolutions in a simple controllable manner.
References 1. L. Alvarez-Gaume, F. Meyer and A. Vazquez-Mozo, Comments on noncom-
mutative gravity, [arXiv: hep-th/0605113]. 2. F. Ardalan, H. Arfaei, M.R. Garousi, and A. Ghodsi, Int. J . Mod. Phys. A18, 1051 (2003), [arXiv: hep-th/020411]. 3. P. Binetruy, C. Deffayet, U. Ellwanger and D. Langlois, Phys. Lett. B 477, 285 (2000), [arXiv: hep-th/9910219].
BOSONIZATION OF A FINITE NUMBER OF NON-RELATIVISTIC FERMIONS AND APPLICATION AVINASH DHAR Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Homi Bhabha Road, Mumbai 400 005, India
[email protected]?.res. in In this talk, I review our recent work on exact bosonization of a finite number of non-relativistic fermions moving in an arbitrary potential in one space dimension. I then discuss applications to problems in string theory and field theory, including to Tomonaga’s half-century old problem of bosonization of free fermions on a circle. The main results outlined here can be found in the papers hepth/0509164, hepth/0512312 and hepth/0603154.
Keywords: Bosonization; String Theory; Quantum Field Theory
1. Introduction The idea of bosonization, namely finding a bosonic system equivalent to a given fermionic system, is almost as old as quantum mechanics itself. The earliest observation for the existence of quantized collective bose excitations - sound waves - in a gas of fermions in 3-dimensions is due to Bloch’. Bohm and Pines* discussed charge density waves - plasma oscillations - in a gas of electrons. The first important technical breakthrough in treating a large system of interacting fermions is due to Tomonaga3 who showed, in a rigorously defined simple 1-dimensional model, that interactions between fermions can mediate new collective bosonic degrees of freedom. Historically, the Tomonaga problem has played an important role in the development of tools for treating a system of large number of fermionst interacting with long-range forces like Coulomb force, which is a recurrent problem one encounters in condensed matter systems. In his toy model *See Ref. 2 and references therein. tSee, for example, Ref. 4 for an account of this and for many of the original works cited below.
79
80
of a l-dimensional system of non-relativistic fermions on a circle, Tomonaga made essential use of the observation that a long-range (in real space) force like Coulomb interaction becomes short range in momentum space, so particle-hole pairs in a low-energy band around the Fermi surface do not get “scattered out” of the band. As a result, the interacting ground state, as well as excited states with low excitation energy compared to the Fermi energy, involve only particle-hole pairs in a small band around the Fermi surface. When the number of fermions is large, there is a finite band around the Fermi surface in which the excited states satisfy this requirement. For excitations in this band, the quadratic dispersion relation of non-relativistic particles approximately linearizes and becomes relativistic. Taking a cue fom this, Luttinger later used a strictly linear dispersion relation. Other works on the Luttinger problem, notably by Mattis and Lieb, Luther and Peschel and Haldane, which gave the exact solution in this case, have led to the class of systems now known as Tomonaga-Luttinger liquids, which provide an important paradigm4 in condensed matter physics. In the field theory context, bosonization of relativistic fermions was achieved by Mandelstam and by Coleman5. Besides condensed matter systems, non-relativistic fermions appear in many interesting situations in string theory and quantum field theory, like non-critical strings in (1 1)-dimensions, half-BPS sector of N = 4 super Yang-Mills theory in Cdimensions (which is dual to string theory on Ads5 x S5background), pure Yang-Mills theory on a cylinder in 2-dimensions , etc. In all the examples cited above, fermions arise from an underlying matrix quantum mechanics problem whose dynamics is controlled by the action
+
s=
s: dt
[ l W -V(M)].
(1)
Here A4 is an N x N hermitian matrix. In the U(N)-invariant sector, this matrix model can be shown to be equivalent to a system of N nonrelativistic fermions in l-dimension6. Jevicki and Sakita7 exploited this equivalence and used the method of collective variables to provide an alternative approach to approximate bosonization of non-relativistic fermions. Like Tomonaga’s approach, this method also works only in the low-energy approximation for a large number of fermions. Motivated by its application to non-perturbative formulation of (1 1)-dimensional string theory, an exact bosonization of a finite number of non-relativistic fermions, moving in an arbitrary potential in one space dimension, was developed in Ref. 8; see also Ref. 9. The basic object, in terms of which the bosonization is carried out, is the Wigner phase space
+
81
density u ( p ,q , t ) =
/
c N
dx e-ipz
+;(q
-
x/2, t ) + i ( q
+ x/2, t ) .
(2)
i= 1
Here + i ( q , t ) , i = 1,2,. f . , N are the single-particle states occupied by the fermions. The phase space density satisfies two constraints, viz.
/
F u ( p , q , t )= N, u * u = u.
(3)
The first of these is obvious. The second constraint, which equates to u the Moyal star product of u with itself, has a simple semiclassical limit. In this limit it reads u2 = u , which has the solutions u = 0 , l corresponding respectively to an unoccupied phase space cell or a cell occupied by a fermion. This constraint shows that a description of the bosoized system in terms of u is highly redundant. In fact, in the semiclassical limit, the only dynamical variables are the boundaries of the occupied regions of phase space. Although a semiclassical treatment of these constraints is relatively easy, an exact solution in terms of independent bosonic degrees of freedom has never been obtained. Because of this reason, applications of this bosonization formalism to non-perturbative situations have not been possible. This motivated us to look for and discoverlo an alternative exact bosonization scheme in terms of independent degrees of freedom, which is described below. 2. Exact Operator Bosonization Consider a system of N fermions each of which can occupy a state in an infinite-dimensional Hilbert space 'Flf. Suppose there is a countable basis of 7-lf : { Im),m = 0 , 1 , . . . , 00). For example, this could be the eigenbasis of a single-particle hamiltonian, hlm) = E(m)lm),but other choices of basis would do equally well, as long as it is a countable basis. In the second quantized notation we introduce creation (annihilation) operators +k (+m) which create (destroy) particles in the state Im). These satisfy the anticommutation relations {+my
+A>
= 6mn
(4)
The N-fermion states are given by (linear combinations of) Ifl,'"
,f N ) =
""$~,lo)F
(5)
where f m are arbitrary integers satisfying 0 5 f l < f 2 < . . . < f N , and 10)~ is the usual Fock vacuum annihilated by qm,m = 0 , 1 , . . . , 00.
82
It is clear that one can span the entire space of N-fermion states, starting from a given state I f i , . . . , f N ) , by repeated applications of the fermion bilinear operators Qmn = $k qn. However, the problem with Qmn’s is that they are not independent; this is reflected in the W, algebra that they satisfy, [Qmn,Qm/nl]= bm/nQmn/- ~ m n ~ Q m ~ n .
(6)
This is the operator version of the noncommutative constraint u * u = u satisfied by the Wigner density u. A new set of unconstrained bosonic operators was introduced in Ref. 10, N of them for N fermions. In effect, this set of bosonic operators provides the independent degrees of freedom in terms of which the above constraint is solved. Let us denote these operators by U k , k = 1 , 2 , . . . , N and their conjugates by, u:, Ic = 1 , 2 , .. . , N . The action of on a given N-fermion state I f 1 , . . . , f N ) is stated simply. It just takes each of the fermions in the top lc occupied levels up by one step. One starts from the fermion in the topmost occupied level, f N , and moves it up by one step to ( f N I), then the one below it up by one step, etc. proceeding in this order, all the way down to the kth fermion from top, which is occupying the level f N - k + l and is taken to the level ( f N - k + l 1). For the conjugate operation, U k , one takes fermions in the top occupied Ic levels down by one step, reversing the order of the moves. Thus, one starts by moving the fermion at the level f N - k + l to the next level below at ( f N - k + l - I), and so on. Clearly, in this case the answer is nonzero only if the (k 1)th fermion from the top is not occupying the level immediately below the kth fermion , i.e. only if ( f N - k + l - f N - k - 1) > 0. If k = N this condition must be replaced by f l > 0. These operations are necessary and sufficient to move to any desired fermion state starting from a given state. This can be argued as follows. First, consider the operator U k - 1 utk .Acting on a generic fermion state this
UL
+
+
+
operator moves only the lcth fermion from top up by one level. In other by words, U k - 1 U: = $ : N - k + l + l $ f N - k + l - Q f N - k + l f l , f N - k + l ’ In this composing together different f l k operations we can move individual fermions around. Clearly, all the N g k operations are necessary in order to move each of the N fermions indvidually. It is easy to see that by applying sufficient number of such fermion bilinears one can move to any desired fermion state starting from a given state. By definition, u:, fsk operators satisfy the following relations: c k 0:
= 1, g kt U k = e ( T k
-
[(Tl1a:] = 0,
1 # k,
(7)
83
where ( f N - k + l - f N - k - 1) = T k and O(m) = 1 if m 2 0, otherwise it vanishes. Moreover, all the (Tk'S annihilate the Fermi vacuum. Consider now a system of bosons each of which can occupy a state in an N-dimensional Hilbert space ' H N . Suppose we choose a basis {I k) , k = 1,. . . , N} of 7 - t ~In . the second quantized notation we introduce creation (annihilation) operators ul ( a h ) which create (destroy) particles in the state Ik). These satisfy the commutation relations [ ~ k , a != ] 6kl,
(8)
k,l = I , . . . ,N.
A state of this bosonic system is given by (a linear combination of)
It can be easily verified that equations (7) are satisfied if we make the following identifications (Tk =
1 1 tJGUk' JG' t
O k - ak
(10)
together with the map Tk
= f N - k + l - f N - k - 1, k = 1, 2, * .
'
N - 1;
TN
=fl.
(11)
This identification is consistent with the Fermi vacuum being the ground state of the bosonic system. The first of these arises from the identification (10) of (Tk'S in terms of the oscillator modes, while the second follows from the fact that (TN annihilates any state in which f 1 vanishes. Using the above bosonization formulae, any fermion bilinear operator can be expressed in terms of the bosons. For example, the hamiltonian can be rewritten as follows. Let E ( r n ) , m = 0 , 1 , 2 , . . . be the exact single-particle spectrum of the non-interacting part H of the fermion hamiltonian. That is, H = CzToE(m) +k Qm. Its eigenvalues are E = ~ f =E ('f= k ) . ,Using f k = X L N - k f l ri k - 1, which is easily derived from (ll),these can be rewritten in terms of the bosonic occupation numbers, N = c k = l E ( z L N - k + l r i + k - 1).These are the eigenvalues of the bosonic hamiltonian I
+
N H = X E ( A k ) , k=l
N
fi.lc
3
xaiai
f N-k.
(12)
i=k
This bosonic hamiltonian is, of course, completely equivalent to the fermionic hamiltonian we started with.
84
It should be clear from the above discussion that our bosonization technique does not depend on any specific choice of fermionic hamiltonian. Moreover, an interaction term, for example a four-fermi interaction, can also be bosonized following similar methods. A generic four-fermi interaction term will involve a generic polynomial interaction in the bosonic variables, the degree of the polynomial depending on the range of interaction. 3. Applications
Our bosonization techniques can be usefully applied to various problems of interest in many areas of physics, like non-critical strings, half-BPS sector of N = 4 super Yang-Mills theory, the Tomonaga problem, Yang-Mills theory on a cylinder, etc. In the following we briefly discuss some of these applications.
3.1. Half-BPSsector of h/ = 4 SYM and LLM geometries It is widely believed today that Einstein's gravity action, small quantum fluctuations around a classical solution to it described by gravitons, and even space-time itself are low-energy emergent properties of an underlying microscopic dynamics. Since string theory is a consistent theory of quantum gravity, we should be able to test these ideas within this framework. The AdS/CFT correspondence" provides a precise setting in which to explore these ideas. The classic example is N = 4 SYM and its dual string theory on Ads5 x S5. The duality states that weakly coupled low-energy type IIB gravity on Ads5 x S5and strongly coupled N = 4 SYM theory in the largeN limit have exactly the same physical content. The amazing thing is that there is no hint of either a 10-d space-time or gravitons in the SYM theory! In the boundary SYM theory, half-BPS states are described by a holomorphic sector of quantum mechanics of an N x N complex matrix Z in a harmonic potential12. This sector can be shown to be equivalent to the quantum mechanics of an N x N hermitian matrix in a harmonic potential. Gauge invariance implies that physical operators in the boundary theory are U(N)-invariant traces: trZk, k = 1 , 2 , . . . ,N . By the operator-state correspondence, then, the physical states in this sector are in one-to-one correspondence with the operators (trZkl)ll(trZkz)l2. . . . The total number of 2's is a conserved RR charge Q = Ci kili, with E = Q because of the tSee the last of Ref. 12.
85
BPS condition. At large N there is a semiclassical picture of the states of this system in terms of droplets of Fermi fluid in phase space. The ground state is a filled disc of radius centered at the origin in phase space. Small fluctuations of the boundary of the disc give low-energy excitations, while an arbitrary distribution of filled droplets corresponds to a generic state. By explicitly solving equations of type IIB gravity, Lin, Lunin and Maldacena13 (LLM) showed that there is a similar structure in the classical geometries in the half-BPS sector! In the LLM solutions, two of the space coordinates are identified with the phase space of a single fermion, leading to noncommutativity in two space directions in the semiclassical de~cription’~. Small fluctuations around AdS space, i.e low-energy graviton excitation^'^ are equivalent to low-energy fluctuations of the Fermi vacuumlG. Since the free fermi system on the boundary can be quantized exactly, one might hope to learn about aspects of quantum gravity by using the duality. At finite N , only the low-energy excitations on the boundary can be identified with low-energy (<< N ) gravitons in the bulk. These excitation on the boundary are created from the Fermi vacuum by fermion bilinears, which can be related to our bosonic stated7, using the bosonization rules. We have
One can compute exactly the correlation functions < p:,/?$, . . . >. The result of a computation of the 3-point function can be summarized as follows: (i) At low energies, perturbation theory is good and reproduces supergravity answers18. The low-energy interactions are described by an effective cubic hamiltonian. (ii) Perturbation theory breaks down for P’s with energy of order In the dual gravity description this is reflected in the fact that gravitons with energies larger than fl have a size smaller than 10-dim planck scale. Furthermore, this breakdown of perturbative calcualtions coincides with the existence, in the bulk gravity theory, of nonlocal solitonic excitations, giant gravitons 19, whose size is larger than 10-dim Planck scale precisely for energies larger than (iii) At energies of order N , the p interactions grow exponentially with N . At such energies, therefore, 0’s cease to provide a meaningful semiclassical description. On the boundary, single-particle states dual to bulk giant graviton states map to specific linear combinations of states dual to multi-graviton states
a.
n.
86
in the bulk12. These states are linear combinations of multi-/3 states and hence are related to our bosonic states. In fact, one can show17 that the boundary states corresponding to single-particle bulk giant graviton states are just the single-particle bosonic states! lgiant graviton of energy Ic) = aklO) t
(14) The bosonized hamiltonian for fermions in the harmonic potential is given by N
n
k=l
Thus, our bosonic states, which we have seen are dual to the giant graviton states in the bulk, exactly diagonalize the hamiltonian in the half-BPS sector. They provide a microscopic description of gravity in this sector, which is valid at all energies! 3.2. Free fermions on a circle
This is the classic Tomonaga problem. Note that interactions between fermions can be taken into account once the bosonization of the free part has been dealt with properly. The hamiltonian for free fermions on a circle is
s.
where Fourier modes are used in the second equality and w E Let us set x + = ~ +Zn and x - ~= +Zn-1. Then, the fermionic hamiltonian becomes H
=
wRC;==,
(
+;gn,
where e ( n ) = 1 if n is odd and
)2
vanishes otherwise. The corresponding bosonized hamiltonian2' is N
fik
+ e(%)
N i= k
k= 1
In the large-N, low-energy limit, H can be rewritten as a sum of O ( N ) and 0(1)pieces, H = H F HO H I , where H F is the fermi energy and
Ho
+ + k alak + C ) ,
(5
=TwN
2
k=l
N
C = c ( e ( f i k )- e ( N - 14)).
(18)
k= 1
The operator i. measures the number of excess fermions in negative momentum states over and above the number in fermi vacuum. Since it commutes
87
with the number operator aiak for all Ic, eigenstates of HO can be labeled by eigenvalues of 6 . Also, H1 evaluates to O(1) on excited states whose energy is low compared to N . The eigenstates of Ho have a simple interpretation; for large N , these represents a massless compact scalar in (1 1)-dimensions! It is the second term in (18) that effects this transmutation from a bunch of oscillators to a massless scalar, as can be seen from a computation of the partition function for Ho. In the limit N -i 00, the partition function turns out to be
+
The sum over v is the sum over eigenvalues of the momentum zero-mode of the compact scalar, but the sum over winding modes is missing because of the restriction to a fixed number of fermions, N . The O(1) piece in the hamiltonian, H I , leads to cubic interactions of the massless scalar. A systematic large-N expansion can be carried out to obtain the effective low-energy cubic theory. Our bosonization, of course, is exact and goes beyond the large-N limit. We should, therefore, be able to discuss even non-perturbative effects in this formalism. The following example illustrates precisely such an application.
3.3. 2 0 Yang-Mills on a cylinder
Non-relativistic fermions appear in 2D YM on a cylinder with U(N) gauge group21. They also appear, via this connection with 2D YM, in the physics of certain black Because of this, our bosonization has applications to these problems as well. Below we will briefly elaborate on the connection with black holes and baby universes. Type IIA string theory compactified on a Calabi-Yau manifold supports supersymmetric configurations of D4, D2 and DO branes. The back-reacted geometry is a black hole in the remaining four non-compact directions, labeled by the D-brane charges. The counting of the number of bound states of the branes maps to the partition function of pure two-dimensional YangMills theory on a cylinder22, and hence to the partition function for the Tomonaga problem. Also, as pointed out in Ref. 24, the partition function with a given asymptotic charge must necessarily include multi-centered black holes, corresponding to configurations with multiple filled bands of fermion energy levels. The existence of such multiple configrations gives rise
88
to nonperturbative corrections to the OSV relation23; schematically zBH
=
1$12
+ O(e-N).
(20)
The uncorrected equation is valid for a single black hole, and corresponds in the fermion theory to two decoupled Fermi surfaces (at the top and at the bottom) which is the correct description in the N -+ 00 limit. In case of the fermion theory, the 0 ( e c N )corrections signify the fact that a t finite N , the approximation of the Fermi sea as having two infintely separated Fermi surfaces is not valid and includes in the partition function many more states than actually exist in the system; the corrections subtract those states iteratively. In our bosonized theory, the structure of equation (20) can be recognized in the finite N partition function20 for Ho:
We see that there are two types of O ( e - N ) corrections compared to (19); one arises from the truncated sum, for finite N , over v and the other from the truncated product factors. Thus, the hamiltonian HO provides a simple example of the two types of nonperturbative corrections discussed in Ref. 24.
References 1. 2. 3. 4.
5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11.
F. Bloch, Z. Phys. 81,363 (1933) ; Helv. Phys. Acta 7,385 (1934). D. Bohm and D. Pines, Phys. Rev. 92,609 (1953). S. Tomonaga, Progr. Theor. Phys. 5 , 304 (1950). M. Stone, Editor, reprint volume entitled Bosonization (World Scientific, Singapore, 1994). S. Mandelstam, Phys. Rev. D 11,3026 (1975);S.Coleman, Phys. Rev. D 11, 2088 (1975). E. Brezin, C. Itzykson, G. parisi and J. B. Zuber, Comm. Math. Phys. 59, 35 (1978). A. Jevicki and B. Sakita, Nucl. Phys. B 165,511 (1980). A. Dhar, G. Mandal and S. Wadia, Mod. Phys. Lett. A 7,3129 (1992), hepth/9207011. B. Sakita, Phys. Lett. B 387,118 (1996), hep-th/9607047. A. Dhar, G. Mandal and N. Suryanarayana, J . High Energy Phys. 0601,118 (2006), hep-th/0509164 0. Aharony, S. Gubser, J. Maldacena, H. Ooguri and Y. Oz, Phys. Rept. 323, 183 (2000), hep-th/9905111.
89 12. V. Balasubramanian, M. Berkooz, A. Naqvi and M. Strassler, Giant Gravitons in Conformal Field Theory, hep-th/0107119; S. Corley, A. Jevicki and S. Ramgoolam, Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 5,809 (2002), hep-th/0111222; D. Berenstein, J . High Energy Phys. 0407,018 (2004), hep-th/0403110; Y . Takayarna and A. Tsuchiya, J. High Energy Phys. 0510,004 (2005), hepth/0507070. 13. H. Lin, 0. Lunin and J. Maldacena, J . High Energy Phys. 0410,025 (2004), hep-t h/0409174. 14. G. Mandal, J . High Energy Phys. 0508, 052 (2005), hep-th/0502104. 15. L. Grant, L. Mmz, J. Marsano, K. Papadodimas and V. Rychkov, J . High Energy Phys. 0508,025 (2005) , hep-th/0505079; L. Maoz and V. Rychkov, J. High Energy Phys. 0508,096 (2005) , hep-th/0508059. 16. A. Dhar, J. High Energy Phys. 0507,064 (2005), hep-th/0505084. 17. A. Dhar, G. Mandal and M. Srnedbkk, J. High Energy Phys. 0603, 031 (2006), hepth/0512312. 18. S. Lee, S. Minwalla, M. Rangarnani and N. Seiberg, Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 2,697 (1998), hep-th/9806074. 19. J. McGreevy, L. Susskind and N. Tournbas, J. High Energy Phys. 0006, 008 (2000), hepth/0003075; M. Grisaru, R. Myers and 0. Tafjord, J . High Energy Phys. 0008,040 (2000), hep-th/0008015; A. Hashimoto, S. Hirano and N. Itzhaki, J . High Energy Phys. 0008,051 (2000), hep-th/0008016. 20. A. Dhar and G. Mandal, Bosonization of non-relativistic fermions on a circle: Tomonaga’s problem revisited, hep-th/0603154. 21. J. A. Minahan and A. P. Polychronakos, Phys. Lett. B 312, 155 (1993), hep-th/9303153. 22. C. Vafa, Two dimensional Yang-Mills, black holes and topological strings, hep-th/0406058 23. H. Ooguri, A. Strominger and C. Vafa, Phys. Rev. D 70, 106007 (2004), hep-t h/0405146 24. R. Dijkgraaf, R. Gopakumar, H. Ooguri and C. Vafa, Baby universes in string theory, hep-th/0504221
RECENT APPLICATIONS OF THE WEYL ANOMALY M.J. DUFF
Blackett LabOTatOTy, Imperial College London, Prince Consort Road, London SW7 ZAZ , U.K. E-mail: m.duffOimperia1. ac.uk We review some recent applications of the Weyl anomaly: (1)The holographic Weyl anomaly, (2) The Weyl anomaly and corrections to Newton’s law in the Randall-Sundrum braneworld, (3) The revival of the original (Starobinsky) model of inflation driven by the Weyl anomaly, (4)The Weyl anomaly and the mass of the graviton in the Karch-Randall braneworld.
1. Thirty three years of the Weyl anomaly In 1973 Derek Capper and the author (two Salam prot6g6s on our first postdocs in Trieste) discovered that the conformal invariance under Weyl rescalings of the metric tensor gpu(x) 4 f12(x)gpu(z) displayed by classical massless field systems in interaction with gravity no longer survives in the quantum theory’. As a consequence, the energy-momentum tensor develops a non-vanishing trace A233: 1 A = gpu(TpV) = -(cF (4r)2 where F is the square of the Weyl tensor:
F
-
aG + dV2R),
1 + -R2, 3
= CpuPuCpVPuR P V W Rpupu- 2RPU Rpu
(2)
G is proportional to the Euler density: G = RpvpuRpuPu - 4RPV RpuiR2,
(3)
and a , c and d are constants. Since then these Weyl anomalies have found a variety of applications in quantum gravity, black hole physics, cosmology, string theory and statistical mechanics. On the occasion of the Salamfest in l’rieste in 1993, the author gave a review entitled T w e n t y years of the
90
91
Weyl unomuly4. Since this conference is, in some sense, another Salamfest, I wish to review some of what has happened since. Weyl anomalies appear in their most pristine form when conformal field theories are coupled to an external gravitational field. They also have a role to play when gravity is coupled to non-conformally invariant theories and when gravity is itself quantized but their significance is less clear cut. Fortunately, all of the recent applications I shall focus on in the present paper fall into the first category. In this case the constants u , c and d are given in terms of the field content of the CFT by3
where N, are the number of fields of spin s. The coefficients a and c are independent of the renormalization scheme but d is not. We have quoted the result given by dimensional regularization; the result given by zeta-function regularization or point-splitting has -18 instead of +12 as the coefficient of N1 5 . In fact, d can be adjusted to any desired value by adding the finite counter term2
SCt /d4q/ijR2.
(5)
N
A particularly important example of a CFT is provided by Yang-Mills with gauge group U(N), for which
(NilN1/2, No) = (N2’4N2,6N2).
N
= 4 super
(6)
Then
and hence
The first application of the Weyl anomaly, discussed in section 2, is the holographic Weyl a n 0 m a l y ~ 3that ~ appears in the AdS/CFT correspondence’-’’. The next three sections are devoted to the Weyl anomaly and braneworld: the corrections to Newton’s law” in the RandallSundrum model12 in section 3, the recent revival l3>l4of the original Starobinsky model15 of inflation driven by the Weyl anomaly in section 4,and the mass of the graviton16 in the Karch-Randall rnodell7 in section 5.
92
2. The holographic Weyl anomaly, 1998 Here we follow the work of Henningson and Skenderis‘ who recall that a theory containing gravity and defined on an open (d+ 1)-manifold X can, in some cases, be equivalent to a d-dimensional conformal field theory defined on the boundary M of X8-l0. The partition function is then a functional of the boundary data: zgrav[4(0)1=
S,
~exP(-s[+l>,
(0)
where the subscript on the integration sign indicates that the functional integral is over field configurations 4 that satisfy the boundary condition given by 4(0). There is a one-to-one correspondence between the fields 4 on X and the primary operators 0 on M . The set of correlation functions of the latter are conveniently summarized by a generating functional:
where q+o) is now regarded as a formal expansion parameter. The partition function of the gravity theory on X and the generating functional on M are then equal, regarded as functionals of +(o): z g r a v [ + ( ~ )= l ZCFT[+(O)].
A field of particular importance in a theory containing gravity is of course the metric G M N The . corresponding operator in the boundary conformal field theory is the stress-energy tensor T,”. The boundary data for the metric G,, is not a boundary metric g(o),v, but only a conformal structure [g(o)].(This is defined as an equivalence class of boundary metrics when two metrics that differ by a local rescaling are considered equivalent , i.e. g(o) exp 2 c ~ ( z ) g ( Ofor ) an arbitrary positive function ~ ( z ) . ) Henningson and Skenderis‘ consider the effective action N
s [ g ( O ) ]= - 1% ZCFT[g(O)I
(9)
of the theory on M . A priori, this is a functional of the metric g(0) on M , but by conformal invariance, it should actually only depend on the conformal equivalence class [g(o)].However, this invariance is sometimes broken by the Weyl anomaly. This means that S [ g ( o ) ]is not invariant under a conformal rescaling bg(o) = 2 b c ~ g ( of ~ )the metric, but transforms as
93
where A is the anomaly. On general grounds, the gravitational part of the Weyl anomaly vanishes when the dimension d of M is odd but when d is even there can be an anomaly. In d = 4, for example, it is of the form (1). For pure gravity the theory in the bulk is described by the EinsteinHilbert action plus a cosmological constant term:
A choice of conformal structure [g(o)]on the boundary M determines a unique metric G M Nin the bulk of X that solves the equations of motion 1 RMN- -RGMN = R G M N . (11) 2 (This is of course true only up to diffeomorphisms). However, the bulk action diverges when evaluated for such a field configuration because of the second order pole in G,, on the boundary. Furthermore, the boundary terms in the action are ill-defined, since G M Ndoes not induce a finite metric ljp, on M . To regulate the theory in a manner consistent with general covariance, we pick a specific representative g(o) of the boundary conformal structure [g(o)].This determines a distinguished coordinate system ( p , d’), in which the metric on X takes the formlg Ld+lL
GMNdxMdxN = 4 p-’dpdp
+ p-’gp,dx,dx”.
(12)
Here the tensor g has the limit g(0) as one approaches the boundary represented by p = 0. The length scale Ld+l is related to the cosmological constant A. Einstein’s equations for G,, can then be solved order by order in p with the result that g is of the form = g(0)
+ Pg(2) + . . + pd/’g(d) + pdl2 logph(d) + O(pd/2+1). *
(13)
The regularization procedure now amounts to restricting the bulk integral in the action to the domain p > E for some cutoff E > 0 and evaluating the boundary integrals at p = E . The regulated action evaluated for this field configuration is then of the form
The coefficients a ( o ) ,a(’), . . . , a ( d ) are all given by covariant expressions in g(o) and its curvature tensor R P v p V . The divergences as E goes to zero can thus be canceled by adding local counterterms to the action, so that
94
we are left with a finite effective action Wfin[g(0)]. To find the variation of S f i n [ g ( o ) ]under a conformal rescaling of the boundary metric g(o), we note that the regulated action W[g(o)] is invariant under the combined transformation Sg(0) = 2 6 a g ( o ) and 6~ = 2 6 a ~for a constant parameter 6u. The terms proportional to negative powers of E are separately invariant, so the variation of Wfin[g(0)]must therefore equal minus the variation of the logarithmically divergent term. The latter is given by 1
since log 6 transforms with a shift whereas a ( d ) itself is invariant. Although this formula was derived under the assumption that 60 is a constant, it follows from the general form of the conformal anomaly that it can be applied also for a non-constant 60. If we now evaluate the anomaly explicitly for the case d = 4, we get6
A = “ (L 3 64~G5
RP”R,,
1
-
?Rz> .
Inserting for example the values of L5 and G5 appropriate for the ads5 x S5 geometry of N coincident D3-branes in type IIB string theory,
we get the same anomaly as that of an N = 4 U(N) supermultiplet as given in (8). The agreement between the strong coupling calculation and this weak coupling result indicates that there is a non-renormalization theorem for the Weyl anomaly. 3. The Weyl anomaly and corrections to Newton’s law, 2000
In his 1972 PhD thesis under Abdus Salam, the author showed that, when one-loop quantum corrections to the graviton propagator are taken into account, the inverse square r - 2 behavior of Newton’s gravity force law receives an r-4 correction whose coefficient depends on the number and spins of the elementary particles20)21.Specifically, the potential looks like
where G4 is the four-dimensional Newton’s constant, h = c = 1 and (Y is a purely numerical coefficient proportional to the c coefficient in the Weyl
95
anomaly
a=
8 37r
-C.
(19)
From (7), (18) and (19) we see that the contribution of a single N = 4 U ( N )Yang-Mills CFT is
Now fast-forward to 1999 when Randall and Sundrum proposed that our four-dimensional world is a 3-brane embedded in an infinite five-dimensional universe. Gravity reaches out into the five-dimensional bulk but the other forces are confined to the four-dimensional brane. Contrary to expectation, they showed that a n inverse square T - ~law for gravity is still possible but with an rP4correction coming from the massive Kaluza-Klein modes whose coefficient depends on the bulk cosmological constant. Their potential looks like T
where L5 is the radius of AdS5. Since (20) was the result of a four-dimensional quantum calculation and (21) the result of a five-dimensional classical calculation, they seem superficially completely unrelated. However, if we now invoke the miracle of the AdS/CFT correspondence of Maldacena we can demonstrate that the two are in fact completely equivalent ways of describing the same physics". If we use the AdS/CFT relation (17) and the one-sided brane-world relation 2G5 G* = -, L5
where G5 is the five-dimensional Newton's constant, then (20) reproduces exactly the Randall-Sundrum result (21). Experimental tests of deviations from Newton's inverse square law are currently under way. 4. Weyl anomaly driven inflation, 2000
In a recent paper, Hawking, Hertog and Reall14 considered a model in which inflation is driven by the Weyl anomaly of a large number N of matter fields. In the large N approximation, they perform the path integral
96
over the matter fields in a given background to obtain an effective action that is a functional of the background metric: exp(-W[gl) = J441 exp(-S[4; gl).
(23)
They neglect graviton loops, and look for a stationary point of the combined gravitational action and the effective action for the matter fields. This is equivalent to solving the Einstein equations with the source being the expectation value of the matter energy momentum tensor:
where
Matter fields might be expected to become effectively conformally invariant if their masses are negligible compared to the spacetime curvature. The Weyl anomaly,
# 0,
gpLy(TpY)
(26)
is entirely geometrical in origin and therefore independent of the quantum state. In a maximally symmetric spacetime, the symmetry of the vacuum implies that the expectation value of the energy momentum tensor can be expressed in terms of its trace
Thus the trace anomaly acts just like a cosmological constant for these spacetimes. Hence a positive trace anomaly permits a de Sitter solution to the Einstein equations22. This is very interesting from the point of view of cosmology, as pointed out by Starobinsky15. Starobinsky showed that the de Sitter solution is unstable, but could be long-lived, and decays into a matter dominated Friedman-Robertson-Walker (FRW) universe. The purpose of Starobinsky’s work was to demonstrate that quantum effects of matter fields might resolve the Big Bang singularity. From a modern perspective, it is more interesting that the conformal anomaly might have been the source of a finite but significant period of inflation in the early universe. This inflation would be followed by particle production and (p)reheating during the subsequent matter dominated phase. Starobinsky’s work is reviewed and extended by Vilenkin in [23].
97
In order to test the Starobinsky model, it is necessary to compare its predictions for the fluctuations in the cosmic microwave background (CMB) with observation. This was partly addressed by Vilenkin23.Vilenkin showed that the amplitude of long wavelength gravitational waves could be brought within observational limits at the expense of some fine-tuning of the coefficients parameterizing the Weyl anomaly. The analysis of Starobinsky and Vilenkin was complicated by the fact that tensor perturbations destroy the conformal flatness of a FRW background, making the effective action for matter fields hard to calculate. However, we now have a way of calculating the effective action for a particular theory, namely N = 4 U ( N ) super Yang-Mills theory, using the AdS/CFT correspondence'. In their paper Hawking, Hertog and Reall14 calculate the effective action for this theory in a perturbed de Sitter background. This enables them to calculate the correlation function for metric perturbations around the de Sitter background. They can then compare their results with observations. The fact that they are using the N = 4 Yang-Mills theory is probably not significant, and we expect their results to be valid for any theory that is approximately massless during the de Sitter phase. They include in their action higher derivative counterterms, which arise naturally in the renormalization of the Yang-Mills theory. There are three independent terms that are quadratic in the curvature tensors: the Euler density, the square of the Ricci scalar and the square of the Weyl tensor. The former just contributes a multiple of the Euler number to the action. Metric perturbations do not change the Euler number, so this term has no effect. The square of the Ricci scalar has the important effect of adjusting the coefficient of the V 2 Rterm in the trace anomaly, as shown in eq. (5). It is precisely this term that is responsible for the Starobinsky instability, so by varying the coefficient of the R2 counter term we can adjust the duration of inflation. The Weyl-squared counterterm does not affect the trace anomaly but it can contribute to suppression of tensor perturbations. The effects of this term were neglected by Starobinsky and Vilenkin. They also neglected the effects of the non-local part of the matter effective action. Hawking et. al. take full account of all these effects. Vilenkin showed that the initial de Sitter phase is followed by a phase of slow-roll inflation before inflation ends and the matter-dominated phase begins. Since the horizon size grows significantly during this slow-roll phase, it is important to investigate whether modes we observe today left the horizon during the de Sitter phase or during the slow-roll phase. If the present horizon size left during the de Sitter phase, Hawking et. al. find that
98
the amplitude of metric fluctuations can be brought within observational bounds if N , the number of colours, is of order lo5. Such a large value for N is rather worrying, which leads us to the second possibility, that the present horizon size left during the slow-roll phase. Their results then suggest that the coefficient of the R2 term must be at most of order lo’, and maybe much lower, but N is unconstrained (except by the requirement that the large N approximation is valid so that AdS/CFT can be used). They also find that the tensor perturbations can be suppressed independently of the scalar perturbations by adjusting the coefficient of the Weyl-squared counterterm in the action.
5. The Weyl anomaly and the graviton mass, 2002 An old question is whether the graviton could have a small but non-zero rest mass. If so, it is unlikely to be described by the explicit breaking of general covariance that results from the addition of a Pauli-Fierz mass term to the Einstein Lagrangian. This gives rise to the well-known Van DamV e l t m a n - Z a k h a r ~ vdiscontinuity ~~?~~ problems in the massless limit, that come about by jumping from five degrees of freedom to two. Moreover, recent a t t e m p t ~ to ~ ~circumvent l~~ the discontinuity in the presence of a non-zero cosmological constant work only at tree level and the discontinuity re-surfaces at one loop2’. (A similar quantum discontinuity arises in the “partially massless” limit as a result of jumping from five degrees of freedom to four2’ and also for spin 3 / 2 where the jump is from four degrees of freedom to two30). On the other hand, in analogy with spontaneously broken gauge theories, one might therefore prefer a dynamical breaking of general covariance, which would be expected to yield a smooth limit. However, a conventional Higgs mechanism, in which a scalar field acquires a non-zero expectation value, does not yield a mass for the graviton. The remaining possibility is that the graviton acquires a mass dynamically and that the would-be Goldstone boson is a spin one bound state. Just such a possibility was suggested in 197531. Interestingly enough, the idea of a massive graviton arising from a spin one bound state Goldstone boson has recently been revived by P ~ r r a t in i~~ the context of the Karch-Randall brane-world17 whereby our universe is an AdS4 brane embedded in an Ads5 bulk. This model predicts a small but finite four-dimensional graviton mass
99
in the limit L4 3 00, where L4 and L5 are the 'radii' of Ads4 and AdS5, respectively. From the Karch-Randall point of view, the massive graviton bound to the brane arises from solving the classical D = 5 linearized gravity equations in the brane background17. The Randall-Sundrum complementarity of the previous section can be generalized to the Karch-Randall AdS braneworld picture. From an AdS/CFT point of view, one may equally well foliate a Poincar6 patch of AdSs in AdS4 slices. The Karch-Randall brane is then such a slice that cuts off the Ad& bulk. However, unlike for the Minkowski braneworld, this cutoff is not complete, and part of the original AdSs boundary remains. Starting with a maximally supersymmetric gauged N = 8 supergravity in the five dimensional bulk, the result is a gauged N = 4 supergravity on the brane coupled to a n/ = 4 super-Yang-Mills CFT with gauge group U(N), however with unusual boundary conditions on the CFT fields As was demonstrated in ref. [32], the CFT on Ads4 provides a natural origin for the bound state Goldstone boson which turns out to correspond to a massive representation of S0(3,2). However, while [32] considers the case of coupling to a single conformal scalar, in ref. [16]we provided a crucial test of the complementarity by computing the dynamically generated graviton mass induced by a complete N = 4 super-Yang-Mills CFT on the brane and showing that this quantum computation correctly reproduces the KarchRandall result, eq. (28). The result again depends on the c coefficient of the Weyl anomaly:
This expression is our main result, and generalizes that obtained in [32]. For the Karch-Randall braneworld17, where the CFT fields are that of N = 4 U(N) super-Yang-Mills we use (7) and find simply
which reproduces exactly the Karch-Randall result (28) on using (17) and (22). Although we focused on t h e N = 4 SCFT, the result is universal, being independent of which particular CFT appears 'in the AdS/CFT correspondence. This suggests that c plays a universal r61e in both the Minkowski and AdS braneworlds, as indicated in (30) and (18), and that our result is robust at strong coupling. This presumably explains why our one-loop computation gives the exact Karch-Randall result. However, we do not know for certain whether this persists beyond one loop.
100
6. Conclusions Thirty-three years on, t h e Weyl anonaly continues t o find new a n d interesting applications. Some others that space did not allow include t h e Weyl anomaly as an infrared diagnostic33 a n d t h e Weyl anomaly and the volume of Sasaki-Einstein manifolds34 that arise in string compactifications.
7. Acknowledgements My thanks t o Faheem Hussain and Riazuddin for their kind invitation t o Islamabad.
References 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
7.
8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20.
D. M. Capper and M. J. Duff, Nuovo Cim. A 23, 173 (1974). S. Deser, M. J. Duff and C. J. Isham, Nucl. Phys. B 111,45 (1976). M. J. Duff, Nucl. Phys. B 125,334 (1977). M. J. Duff, Class. Quant. Grav. 11,1387 (1994), [arXiv:hep-th/9308075]. N.D. Birrell and P.C.W. Davies, Quantum fields in curved space, (Cambridge University Press, 1982). M. Henningson and K. Skenderis, JHEP 9807, 023 (1998), [arXiv:hept h/9806087]. M. Henningson and K. Skenderis, Fortsch. Phys. 48,125 (2000), [arXiv:hepth/9812032]. J. M. Maldacena, Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 2, 231 (1998) [Int. J. Theor. Phys. 38,1113 (1999)], [arXiv:hep-th/9711200]. S. S. Gubser, I. R. Klebanov and A. M. Polyakov, Phys. Lett. B 428, 105 (1998), [arXiv:hep-th/9802109]. E. Witten, Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 2,253 (1998), [arXiv:hep-th/9802150]. M. J. Duff and J. T. Liu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 2052 (2000) [Class. Quant. Grav. 18,3207 (2001)], [arXiv:hep-th/0003237]. L. Randall and R. Sundrum, Phys. Rev. Lett. 83,4690 (1999), [arXiv:hepth/9906064]. S. W. Hawking, T. Hertog and H. S. Reall, Phys. Rev. D 62,043501 (2000), [arXiv:hep-th/0003052]. S. W. Hawking, T. Hertog and H. S. Reall, Phys. Rev. D 63,083504 (2001), [arXiv:hep-th/0010232]. A. A. Starobinsky, Phys. Lett. B 91,99 (1980). M. J. Duff, J. T. Liu and H. Sati, Phys. Rev. D 69,085012 (2004), [arXiv:hepth/0207003]. A. Karch and L. Randall, JHEP 0105,008 (2001), [arXiv:hep-th/0011156]. C.R. Graham and J.M. Lee, Adv. Math. 87,186 (1991). C. Fefferman and C.R. Graham, in Elie Cartan et les Mathematiques d’aujourd’hui (Asterisque, 1985) p. 95. M. J. Duff, Problems in the classical and quantum theories of gravitation, Ph. D. thesis, Imperial College, London (1972).
101 21. 22. 23. 24. 25.
M. J. Duff, Phys. Rev. D 9, 1837 (1974). J. S. Dowker and R. Critchley, Phys. Rev. D 13, 3224 (1976). A. Vilenkin, Phys. Rev. D 32, 2511 (1985). H. van Dam and M. J. G. Veltman, Nucl. Phys. B 22, 397 (1970). V. I. Zakharov, JETP Lett. 12, 312 (1970) [Pisma Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 12,
447 (1970)]. 26. M. Porrati, Phys. Lett. B 498, 92 (2001), [arXiv:hep-th/0011152]. 27. I. I. Kogan, S. Mouslopoulos and A. Papazoglou, Phys. Lett. B 503, 173 (2001), [arXiv:hep-th/0011138]. 28. F. A. Dilkes, M. J. Duff, J. T. Liu and H. Sati, Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 041301 (2001), [arXiv:hep-th/0102093]. 29. M. J. Duff, J. T. Liu and H. Sati, Phys. Lett. B 516, 156 (2001), [arXiv:hepth/0105008]. 30. M. J. Duff, J. T. Liu and H. Sati, Nucl. Phys. B 680, 117 (2004), [arXiv:hepth/0211183]. 31. M. J. Duff, Phys. Rev. D12, 3969 (1975). 32. M. Porrati, JHEP 0204, 058 (2002), [arXiv:hep-th/Oll2166]. 33. K. Intriligator, Nucl. Phys. B 730, 239 (2005), [arXiv:hep-th/0509085]. 34. D. Martelli, J. Sparks and S. T. Yau, “Sasaki-Einstein manifolds and volume minimisation,” arXiv:hep-th/0603021.
HIGHER DIMENSIONAL PERSPECTIVE ON N=2 BLACK HOLES ANSAR FAYYAZUDDIN Department of Natural Sciences, Baruch College, CUNY, New York, NY 10010, USA E-mail:
[email protected]. edu We present 11 and 10 dimensional supergravity descriptions of N=2 4 dimensional black holes. The problem is formulated in the context of type IIA string theory compactified on R(3!1)~CY3.The black holes are bound states of D4-branes wrapped on 4-cycles and DO-branes. We reduce the problem to a set of differential equations which describe black hole solutions in the lowest derivative supergravity theory. We argue that the full space-time is inherently 10 (or 11) dimensional. We then proceed to solve these equations in the nearhorizon regime, which we define using ideas of ”geometrical transitions” - where localized branes are replxed by smooth flux. Keywords: black holes, supergravity
1. Introduction In these proceedings I summarize some results obtained in [l].The problem, generally speaking, is to find ways of treating string theory black holes in a manifestly 10 (or 11) dimensional setting. In this paper we will work in the low-energy approximation of string theory known as supergravity. Much is known about supersymmetry preserving black holes that arise as solutions in 4- and 5-dimensional supergravity. These solutions have provided us with the setting for a number of interesting results, including the crowning achievement of the Strominger-Vafa microscopic counting of black hole entropy’. In this short article we will be concerned with a class of black holes that arise in the context of Calabi-Yau compactifications of type IIA string theory down to 4-dimensions. The approximation that one usually employs is one where the energy scales for the theory are restricted such that the internal Calabi-Yau manifold cannot be resolved geometrically. In other words, the Calabi-Yau is treated geometrically as a point. The low-energy
102
103
fluctuations of the Calabi-Yau provide us with fields in the d=4 theory. For instance, there are low-energy fluctuations of the Calabi-Yau metric which preserve the complex structure. These excitations appear as massless fields in the d=4 effective theory, known as the Kahler moduli fields. In the d=4 type IIA supergravity theory there are a number of U(l) gauge fields. These gauge fields can be understood as follows. In ten dimensions there are charged 2- and 4-branes, they couple to anti-symmetric tensor fields and are magnetic duals of each other. In the 4-d theory there are point particles which arise from D2-branes wrapping 2-cycles and D4branes wrapping 4-cycles. These point particles are also charged, but now with respect to 1-forms. The number of independent 1-forms is simply given by the number of 2-cycles or 4-cycles, i.e. the Betti numbers bz(= b 4 ) . There is an additional U(l) gauge field, known as the "graviphoton". The graviphoton is a U(l) gauge field in d=10 which couples electrically to DObranes and magnetically to D6-branes. In the d=4 theory this U(l) field continues to couple electrically to the DO-branes and magnetically to D6branes wrapping the entire Calabi-Yau. Thus there are bz 1 = h(l?') 1 gauge fields. Given these gauge fields one can try to construct Reissner-Nordstrom black holes. It is known that a large class of these black holes preserve supersymmetry - these are extremal black holes where the charge and mass are equal. These black holes have some very interesting properties. The geometry interpolates between two regimes: R(3,1)at infinity and Ad& x S2 close to the horizon. A general feature of these black holes is that there is a so-called "attractor mechanism" at play. The attractor mechanism ensures that the near-horizon geometry depends only on the charges of the black holes; it is independent of the values of any fields at infinity. In addition to these general results, it is also known that black holes made up of wrapped Dbbranes and DO-branes can have a non-zero horizon area in the classical lowest derivative supergravity theory. In the usual conventions, these black holes are magnetically charged with respect to the b2 U(l) fields and electrically charged with respect to the graviphoton. The area of the horizon is given by the magnetic charges pz,i = 1,...,b2, electric charge 40 with respect to the graviphoton of the black hole as well as the triple intersection number of the underlying Calabi-Yau, cijk, which appears as a coupling in the effective d=4, N=2 supergravity action. The area of the horizon at leading order is given by 4-6:
+
+
104
2. 11-dimensional solutions for 4-d black holes In this section we outline some results on how to treat a class of N=2 black holes in d=4 from an 11-dimensional point of view. The class of black holes we are interested in are the ones mentioned at the end of the previous section. They are magnetically charged with respect to the b2 U( 1) fields and electrically charged with respect to the graviphoton. These black holes have a well understood origin in 10-d, as mentioned above. They descend from D4-branes wrapping 4-cycles and DO-branes. It is also well understood how to lift this configuration to l l - d i m e n ~ i o n s Under ~ ~ ~ ~ this ~. lift the background geometry lifts to the Calabi-Yau geometry times a circle, CY3xS'. The D4-branes lift to M5-branes wrapping both a 4-cycle in the Calabi-Yau and the S1. The DO-branes lift to momentum along the S1. We would now like to find the supergravity solution for this configuration directly in d = l l . In [l]we took the supergravity solution for M5-branes wrapping a holomorphic 4-cycle as found in [8] (see also [9]) and added momentum along the circle. The final metric is given by:
+ f ( d y + (f-' l ) d t ) 2 ) + H2/3(dr2+ r2dR;) + 2H-1/3gm,dzmdz",
ds2 = H-1/3(-f-1dt2
-
(2)
where g is a Kahler metric dR; is the metric on a unit 2-sphere, and H is a function. H is related to the determinant of the metric g through det(g) = aH21hI2,where h is holomorphic in z m (allowing for holomorphic changes of coordinates') and a is a constant. The 4-form field strength of 11-d supergravity is given by: 928,
F
i i --r2dTgmfidzm A dz" A dvoZ(S2) -r2dmHdzm A dr A dvoZ(S2) 2 2 i - --r2dmHdzmA dr A dvoZ(S2). (3) 2
+
=
In the above expression, dvoZ(S2)is the volume form on the unit two sphere. The functions f and H , and the metric g satisfy the differential equations: 1 H-l--dT(r2dTf) 2g""dmdfif = 0, r2 1 -dT(r2dTgmii) 2dmdfiH = 0. (4) r2 Once we solve these two differential equations we can completely specify the metric and 4-form. In general the differential equations (4) are difficult to solve. In fact, the differential equation for g is non-linear because of the presence of H .
+ +
105
Nevertheless, there are some important lessons we can learn even at this stage. First, it should be clear that in general the metric does not have a product form. This is because H , f and g depend on T , zm, z m , and, except for the extremes of the black hole space time, as we shall see, the metric is irreducibly 11-dimensional. Second, the metric g, which approaches a Calabi-Yau metric as one moves far away from the black hole, is not Calabi-Yau or even conformal to Calabi-Yau throughout the remainder of the spacetime. Thus the “compactifying” manifold in the interpolation between the asymptotic and near-horizon regimes does not have a simple description except as a Kahler manifold. If we compute the “6-d” Ricci tensor of the Kahler metric g, it can be expressed as derivatives of H with respect to zms and does not vanish generically. 3. The near-horizon regime and geometrical transitions
Black holes are often thought of as space-times interpolating between the asymptotically far and the near-horizon regions a. These two regimes are useful for studying different aspects of black holes. The far regime is where one defines the ADM mass, but it is the near-horizon geometry that determines its Bekenstein-Hawking entropy. In the case at hand we know that at infinity we should approach R3t1xCY3 - the ”vacuum” manifold. In this limit, g approaches the metric on the Calabi-Yau and H , f + 1. We would like to say something about the near-horizon behavior of the geometry and other supergravity fields. Generally speaking the near-horizon geometry can be thought of as a truncation of the full space-time geometry to the desired region. Since we don’t know the entire geometry of the black hole, we might wonder if there are simplifications that occur in the near-horizon region which allow one to determine it even while the full geometry remains unknown. We will argue that there is a sense in which one might hope to isolate the near-horizon region without attempting to find the entire space-time of the black hole. The central idea was presented inlo where it was argued that as one hones in on the region of space-time close to the branes composing the black hole, the localized branes dissolve and we are left with a smooth region with flux. This flux computes the charge of the dissolved branes. aIt sometimes makes sense to continue the space-time beyond the horizon a s well. This will not be relevant to anything we are interested in here.
106
This transition is called a "geometric transition" in [lo].We will use this idea to develop an ansatz for the supergravity solution in the near-horizon region and solve the differential equations that we wrote down earlier. To develop the ansatz it is easier to think about the system in type IIA string theory. In this theory our black holes are bound states of D4 and DObranes. The DCbranes couple magnetically to the tensor field whose field strength is given in (3). To compute the charge of DCbranes we should compute the flux produced by F through an appropriate cycle. The DObranes, on the other hand, couple to a R-R field C1 = (f-' - 1)dt. The DO brane charge is computed by calculating the flux of the 8-form Gg = *dC1. We take as an ansatz':
F
t
F' = ~2 A dvoZ(S2),
Gg + GL = WG A
dvol(S2).
(5)
Here w2 and wg are 2- and 6-forms defined on the complex %fold over which the metric g is defined. We will assume that these forms do not explicitly depend on r , since they compute the number of branes which is independent of r . This ansatz implies, by a quick comparison to (3) and the definition of Gg, that 8,H = 0 and 8, f = 0, or H = H ( r ) ,f = f ( r ) . As explained in [ l ] this , ansatz leads one finally to the supergravity solution:
ds?,
=
r2 R2(--ddt2 R2
R2 r + -dr2) + R P 4 ( d y + (- - l ) d t ) 2 r2 a0
+ R2R2dOi+ 2k,fid~md~fi,
(6)
with
IC,~
=
-KPR-~(W~),~
(7)
the metric on the complex %fold. R and R are constant parameters which count the number of D4 and DO-branes. The metric Ic is Calabi-Yau (Ricci flat and Kahler). If we define Jk = ilCmAdzm A dz" to be the Kahler form on the complex 3-fold, then
F = ~2 A dvoZ(S2) = R R J k A dvoZ(S2), G2 = dC1 = d( f-' - 1 ) = R 3 R - l d t A dr.
(8)
This is a completely smooth solution. A particular solution of this kind (0 = 1 ) was also found in [ l l ]We . list the main features of the solution: 0
The metric is an AdS2xS2xCY3 space with a U ( l ) bundle over the Ads2 factor. The U ( l ) bundle is such that the space-time is in
107
0
0
0
fact Ads3 x S2 x CY3. The radius of curvature of the Ads3 space is f i R R and the radius of curvature of the S2 is OR. The field strengths F and G2 are non-singular. In the presence of localized branes these field strengths would blow up at the location of the branes. This is not the case here, the flux is completely smooth. The metric k is a Calabi-Yau metric. This Calabi-Yau space is not the same manifold as the one that appears in the asymptotic region. There are many ways to see this but perhaps the easiest way to see it is by noting that certain cycles of the Calabi-Yau in the near-horizon region have non-zero size due to the presence of flux, while the asymptotically far away Calabi-Yau does not have this property since there is no flux present as we move infinitely far away from the black hole (T -+00). More explicitly
The first of these integrals counts the number of D4-branes wrapping a 4-cycle dual to & while the second counts the number of DO-branes. We assume that both integrals are non-zero - i.e. that the number of D4 and DO branes are non-zero. On the right hand side the volumes of appropriate cycles appear. We have thus related the volume of cycles to the flux and therefore to the number of branes. There is no such relation in the T ---t 00 limit. From the previous point one can see that the near-horizon supergravity solution is determined in terms of the charges of the branes - the number of D4, DO branes and specifying the cycles through which the F-flux should be computed. This is the manifestation of the attractor mechanism in this higher dimensional setting.
4. Acknowledgments
I am grateful to the organizers, Faheem Hussain and Riazuddin, for the invitation to attend and for organizing a stimulating conference. I would also like to thank the participants at the workshop who came from diverse countries to attend for many interesting discussions. It was particularly inspiring to have a large number of physicists from India there.
108
References 1. A. Fayyazuddin, Class. Quantum Grav. 23,5279 (ZOOS), hep-th/0603141. 2. A. Strominger and C. Vafa, Phys. Lett. B379 , 99 (1996), hep-th/9601029. 3. S. Ferrara, R. Kallosh, and A. Strominger, N=2 eztremal black holes, hepth/9508072 A. Strominger, Macroscopic entropy of N=2 extremal black holes, hepth/9602111 S . Ferrara and R. Kallosh, Supersymmetry and attractors, hep-thl9602136. 4. K. Behrndt, G. Cardoso, B. de Witt, R. Kalosh, D. Lust, T. Mohaupt, Classical and quantum N=2 supersymmetric black holes, hep-th/9610105. 5. M. Shmakova, Calabi- Yau black holes, hep-th19612076. 6. J. Maldacena, A. Strominger, and E. Witten, Black Hole Entropy an M-theory, hep-th/9711053. 7. C. Vafa, Black holes and Calabi- Yau threefolds, hep-th/9711067. 8. H. Cho, M. Emam, D. Kastor and J. H. Traschen, Calibrations and Fayyazuddin-Smith Space-times hep-th/0009062 9. T. Z. Husain, That’s a wrap! hep-th/0302071. 10. C. Vafa, Superstrings and Topological Strings at Large N , hep-th/0008142. 11. A. Simons, A. Strominger, D. Thompson, X. Yin, Supersymmetric Branes in Ad& x S 2 x CY3, hep-th/0406121.
pSTRINGS vs. STRINGS DEBASHIS GHOSHAL Harish-Chandra Research Institute, Chhatnag Road, Allahabad 21 1019, India E-mail:
[email protected] The amplitudes for the tree-level scattering of the open string tachyons, generalised to the field of padic numbers, define padic string theory. We briefly review some properties of this pstring theory and take a fresh look at the p + 1 limit, where it is known to approximate the usual string theory. We argue that it should be thought of as a continuum limit.
In this talk, we will consider the relation between p-strings and strings. However, while the latter is well known, the former is perhaps not so. It may not be out of place, therefore, to review some aspects of p-string theory before we revisit the p -+ 1 limit, where p-strings are known (empirically) to approximate ordinary strings”. Recall that the tree-level scattering amplitude of N on-shell open-string tachyons of momenta Ici (i = 1,.. . ,N ) , Ic: = 2, C Ici = 0 is: N J
45i<j
i=4
The integrals are over the real line R and the integrand involves absolute values of real numbers. The 4-point amplitude can be computed exactly, but d N for N 2 5 cannot be evaluated analytically. Perhaps with a mathematical motivation, Ref. [l]considered the above problem over the local field of p-adic numbers, to which it admits a ready extension. In order to describe it, let us digress briefly. On the field of rational numbers Q, we are familiar with the absolute value norm. The field R of real numbers arise as its completion when we put in the limit points of Cauchy sequences, in which convergence is decided by the absolute value norm. However, it is possible to define other ~
would like to suggest that the p in the beginning of ‘p-string’ is silent, making it phonetically same as ‘string’.
109
110
norms on Q consistently. To this end, fix a prime number p and determine the highest powers n1 and 722 of p that divides the numerator z1 and denominator z2 respectively, in a rational number z1/z2, ( 2 1 , z2 coprime). The p-adic n o m of z1/z2, defined as: 121/221, = p"2-n1, satisfies all the required properties, indeed even a stronger version of the triangle inequality 1x yl, 5 max(lxlp, /yip). In fact, apart from the absolute value norm, the p-adic norms are the only possible ones (upto a natural notion of equivalence). If we require completion using the notion of the padic norm, we get the field Q p . Any padic number E E Q, has a representation as a Laurent-like series in p:
+
E = PN (Eo + t1P + E2P2 + . . . ) , where, N is an integer, En E {0,1, . , p - 1) and 60 # 0. A review of these properties may be found in Ref. [3]. Coming back to the Koba-Nielsen amplitudes (l),Freund et. al. proposed to modify these by replacing the absolute values in the integrand by the p-adic norms and the real integrals by integrals over the field Q,. These are, by definition, the amplitudes for the scattering of N open pstring tachyons. An amazing consequence is that all these integrals over Q, can be evaluated analytically. This means that the tree level effective action of the open p-string tachyon T is known exactly. It is best summarised as2l4 +
.
(3)
+
in terms of the rescaled and shifted field 'p = 1 g,T/p. The potential has a local minimum and two (respectively one) local maxima for odd (respectively even) integer p (see Fig. 1).We note parenthetically that the spacetime action can be extrapolated to all integers. Moreover, in this modification, the boundary of the the open p-string worldsheet is valued in p-adic numbers, but the target spacetime is the usual one.
Fig. 1. Exact tachyon potential in pstring theory for p = 2 , 3 .
111
Apart from the trivial constant solutions, 'p = 0'1, to the equation of motion from (3), there are soliton solutions. In fact, the equation separates in the space-time arguments and for any (spatial) direction, there is a localised gaussian lump, whose amplitude and spread are correlated2. More recently p-string theory has come in to focus through the realisation that the exact spacetime theory of its tachyon allows one to study nonperturbative aspects of string dynamics, such as the process of tachyon condensation. In Ref. [5], the solitons of the effective theory of the p-adic were identified with the D-branes and shown that the dynamics is according to the behaviour conjectured by Sen7. A rather unexpected relation emerges with the usual bosonic open string in the p 4 1 limit8 (see also the prescient comments in Ref. [9]). In this limit, the effective action (3) of the tachyon of p-string theory turns out to approximate that obtained from the boundary string field theorylO>" (BSFT) of usual strings. The formalism of the latter was useful in proving the Sen conjecture^^^^^^^^. This correspondence remains true even after a noncommutative deformation of the p-string effective a c t i ~ n ' ~In ? ~fact, ~. it can be used to find exact noncommutative solitons of the usual string theory for all values of the deformation parameter14. The relation to the usual strings is all the more surprising and counterintuitive from the point of view of the p-string 'worldsheet'. In fact, the 'worldsheet' description16 of the p-string itself is not in the least obvious. The interior of the worldsheet, analogous to the unit disc or the upper halfplane of the usual theory, is an infinite lattice with no closed loops, i.e., a tree B, in which p + 1edges meet at each vertex (see Fig. 2). This is known to mathematicians as the Bruhat-Tits tree and is familiar to physicists as the Bethe lattice. The boundary of the tree B,, defined as the union of all infinitely remote vertices, can be identified with the p-adic field Q,. One may use e.g., the representation (2) in which case, the integer N chooses a branch along the dotted path (in Fig. 2) and the infinite set of coefficients determine the path to the boundary. On the other hand, the tree 17, is the (discrete) homogeneous space PGL(2 ,Q,) /PGL( 2,Z,) : the coset obtained by modding PGL(2,Q,) by its maximal compact subgroup PGL(2,ZP). This construction parallels the case of the usual string theory, in which the UHP is the homogeneous coset PSL(2,R) modulo its maximal compact subgroup SO(2). The action of PGL(2,Q,) on Qp extends naturally to B,. The Polyakov action on the 'worldsheet' B, is the natural discrete lattice action for the free massless fields X p . Zabrodin16 showed that starting with a finite Bethe lattice and inserting the tachyon vertex operators on the
en
112
boundary, one recovers the prescription of Refs. [l,21 in the thermodynamic limit. If we set p = 1, we get a one dimensional lattice. However, the relation to the usual string is through the limit p -+ 1 and naively it is not apparent how to make sense of this. This is the problem we will address in the following. First, we claim that the p-string ‘worldsheet’, i.e., the Bethe lattice B,, gives a discretisation of the worldsheet of the usual string, the disc. But in B,, the number of sites upto some generation n from an origin C (say):
grows exponentially for large n. Therefore, the formal dimension of the Bethe lattice is infinite, if embedded in an Euclidean space. It is for this reason that these lattices are useful in the study of statistical and field theory models: being infinite dimensional, they give the results of mean field theory and coincide with the result in the upper critical dimension. For example, for a free scalar field theory with arbitrary interactions (that would come from, say, vertex operators) the upper critical dimension is two. One would expect to get the results of the two dimensional scalar field theory with arbitrary interactions from the computation on a Bethe lattice.
Fig. 2. A finite part of the ‘worldsheet’ of the 3-adic string: the tree B, for p = 3, 2 3 3 = Q3. A pat.h from the points 0 and 00 on the boundary is shown by a dotted line.
On the other hand, in a d dimensional hyperbolic space with the metric Ri sinh2 d f l i - , the volume of a ball of radius R (R >> Ro, the radius of curvature)
ds$ = dr2
+
(k)
vold(R)
N
exp
(x R) d-1
(5)
also grows exponentially for large R. This suggests a natural embedding of
113
Bethe lattices in hyperbolic spaces. If we parametrise a p=l+-(d-l),
Ro
and consider the limit a -+ 0 so that p 4 1, the formulas (4)and (5) agree with the identification n-m lim n a = R, from which we see that a is the lattice a-+O
spacing. Thus we see that a Bethe lattice Bp can be used to discretise a hyperbolic space of constant negative curvature. Moreover, it provides a natural continuum limit when p 4 1. In particular, this is true when the dimension d = 2, the case of our interest. In fact the embedding of B, in to the unit disc/UHP equipped with a metric of constant negative curvature (say, the Poincard metric) is isometric - it is related to the hyperbolic tessellation of the disc/UHP and often has rather interesting connections with the fundamental domains of the modular functions of SL(2,C) and its subgroups17. The standard way to obtain a continuum limit from a lattice regularisation is to go to ever finer lattices with smaller lattice spacings and eventually consider the limit in which the lattice spacing becomes vanishingly small. In Fig.3, the ‘black’ lattice with lattice spacing a = 3a’ gives a coarser approximation compared to that with spacing a‘. Suppose we start with the ‘black’ lattice, the boundary of which is isomorphic to Q3. In comparing this sublattice to the full lattice, we see that between two neighbouring ‘black’ nodes there are two (in general rn) new nodes, which in turn branch further so that the new lattice is similar to the old one. What, if any, is the relation of the new lattice to Q3? The answer to this question is interesting and takes us in to the second digression in arithmetic.
Fig. 3. A finer lattice with with lattice spacing a’ leads to a coarse grained lattice with lattice spacing a = ma’ ( m = 3 here), when the ‘grey’ branches are integrated out.
The field Q p (just like R) is not closed algebraically. That is, not all roots of polynomials with coefficients in the field belong to the field. In the
114
case of R, one can adjoin a root of x’ -t 1 = 0 and get the algebraically closed (and complete) field of complex numbers C. It is said to be an index two extension: this means that C is a two dimensional vector space over R. The story is more complex for Q p . One starts with an algebraic, say quadratic, extension; but this field is not closed. In fact, none of the finite algebraic extensions of Q, are closed, so one needs to consider the union of all such extensionsb. Now consider an extension -(m) Q p of index m. Actually there are several such extensions, but among those there are some which are called totally ramified with which one can associate a Bruhat-Tits treeC -(m)
B,
that can be obtained from the original one of Q p through the process described above. Namely, to get the tree for a totally ramified start with the ‘black’ tree for Qp and introduce (m- 1) new nodes between the exisiting ones. Connect (infinite) ‘grey’ branches to these so that the tree is uniform with coordination number p as before. In there is a special element 7r that plays the role that p does for Q p . Specifically, any element of the extended field can be expressed as a Laurent series in terms of 7r (just like (2)), and the norms of its elements -(m) are powers of 7 r . In particular, for the element p E Q p , we have
QLm),
qLm’,
P E Tm *
(7)
Parametrising both p and T as in (6), we see that the lattice spacing a’ of Ekm) is related to a of Bp as a mu’, a fact that is apparent from the construction. We see from (7) that when we consider larger and larger extensions 7~ N p l l m approaches the value 1 for any p . The corresponding lattices provide a finer discretisation and a passage to the continuum limit. This suggests a way to understand the limit p 4 1 through string theories based on the extensions of Q,. However, not everything is in place yet. If we compute the tachyon amplitudes given by (1) based on the field -(m) Q p , the answer we get is exactly the same as that for Q p ! This is because the coefficients in the Laurent expansansions of both are the same, the trees are similar, therefore, the measures that affect the integrals work out to be identical’. The resolution comes from the following. In taking a continuum limit, we are not really interested in the exact answer, but rather turns out that it is not complete. Thankfully, after completion, the resulting field is still closed. We will not worry about it at this point, although this may turn out to be the right setting for the closed p-strings. CThere are Bruhat-Tits trees for all algebraic extensions, and our argument can be repeated in those cases. The case we discuss is the most transparent.
115
in comparing the degrees of freedom of the coarse-grained lattice from the fine one from a (real space) renormalisation group perspective. In order to do this, we should integrate out only the degrees of freedom on the new nodes and new branches (‘grey’ in Fig. 3) so that we are left with those in the ‘black’ sublattice with some effective interaction between these residual degrees of freedom. A rescaling of the lattice so that the spacing a 4 ba = a’ completes the RG transformation. Let us see the effect of these on the Poisson kernel on the Bethe lattice. It is more transparent for the Dirichlet problem for which the Green’s function is16 V ( z , w )= where d ( z , w)is the number of steps in lattice units between the sites z , w. Since the spacing in t3, is m times that in -(m) B, , da = mdfic,, z md, after f i p - d ( Z l w ) ,
integrating out the intermediate sites we have V e = ~ & p - m d ( Z ~ W ) . When we rescale the lattice, the original form of the kernel is recovered with the substitution p -+ 7~ = p 1 I m . The Green’s functionN(z,w) for the Neumann problem is roughly the logarithm of D ( z , w ) ,so the same argument holds there. Thus we conclude that the RG procedure would make sense if its effect on the tachyon action (3) is to replace p -+ r = PI/”. The action for the usual bosonic string is obtained in the limit m -+ 00, which is a continuum limit in the sense of RG. Related results in the literature lend support to this argument. Ref. [18] finds an exact solution to the problem of a random walk on the Bethe lattice. In the limit p -+ 1 (continuum limit) this gives the solution of the Brownian motion on a hyperbolic space of constant negative curvature. This proves that the Green’s function for the diffusion equation on the disc/UHP with a metric of constant negative curvature can be obtained as a continuum limit from the Bethe lattice. Using the well known relation between the kernel of the diffusion equation and the Green’s function of a free scalar field theory, the latter kernel for the disc/UHP with a metric of constant negative can be obtained from the Bethe lattice in the p -+ 1 limit. We are interested in a diffeomorphism and Weyl invariant free scalar field theory coupled to the metric on the disc/UHP. There are also marked points corresponding to asymptotic states given by vertex operators on its boundary. Only hyperbolic metrics can be consistently defined on such a surface. Further with the freedom from diffeomorphism and Weyl invariance, the metric can be made one of constant negative curvature. In the worldsheet functional integral, therefore, the contribution is from such a surface and the sum over surfaces is equivalent to integrating over curvature. The continuum limit of a scalar field theory on a Bethe 1,atticewould seem to give a good approximation.
116
Acknowledgments
I a m grateful t o the organisers of this very interesting conference for the invitation. I cannot thank Faheem Hussain, Riazuddin a n d all t h e others enough for the trouble they took t o make everything, especially the visa procedure, so easy for us. T h e warmth of the hospitality of t h e people of Pakistan will always remain a cherished memory. Discussion with Chandan Dalawat, Peter F'reund a n d Stefan Theisen and hospitality at the Albert Einstein Institute during the process of writing are also acknowledged gratefully.
References 1. P. Freund and M. Olson, Phys. Lett. B 199,186 (1987);
P. Freund and E. Witten, Phys. Lett. B 199,191 (1987). 2. L. Brekke, P. Freund, M. Olson and E. Witten, Nucl. Phys. B 302, 365 (1988). 3. L. Brekke and P. Freund, Phys. Rept. 233,1 (1993). 4. P. Frampton and Y . Okada, Phys. Rev. D 37,3077 (1988). 5. D. Ghoshal and A. Sen, Nucl. Phys. B 584, 300 (2000), [arXiv:hepth/0003278]. 6. P. Frampton and H. Nishino, Phys. Lett. B 242,354 (1990). 7. A. Sen, Non-BPS states and branes in string theory, arXiv:hep-th/9904207. 8. A. Gerasimov and S. Shatashvili, JHEP 0010, 034 (2000), [arXiv:hepth/0009103]. 9. B. Spokoiny, Phys. Lett. B 207,401 (1988). 10. E. Witten, Phys. Rev. D 46, 5467 (1992), [arXiv:hep-th/9208027]. 11. S. Shatashvili, Phys. Lett. B 311,83 (1993), [arXiv:hep-th/9303143]; S. Shatashvili, Alg. Anal. 6 ,215 (1994), [arXiv:hep-th/9311177]. 12. D. Kutasov, M. Marino and G. Moore, JHEP 0010,045 (2000), [arXiv:hepth/0009148]. 13. D. Ghoshal and A. Sen, JHEP 0011,021 (2000), [arXiv:hep-th/0009191]; D. Ghoshal, in Proceedings of Strings 2001, eds. A. Dabholkar et. al., [arXiv:hep-th/0106231]. 14. D. Ghoshal, JHEP 0409,041 (2004), [arXiv:hep-th/0406259]. 15. D. Ghoshal and T. Kawano, Nucl. Phys. B 710, 577 (2005), [arXiv:hepth/0409311]. 16. A. Zabrodin, Commun. Math. Phys. 123,463 (1989); L. Chekhov, A. Mironov and A. Zabrodin, Commun. Math. Phys. 125,675 (1989). 17. S. Nechaev and 0. Vasilyev, J. Phys. A 37, 3783 (2004), [arXiv:condmat/0310079]. 18. C. Monthus and C. Texier, J. Phys. A 29, 2399 (1996), [arXiv:condmat/9509067].
DETECTING TWO-PHOTON EXCHANGE EFFECTS IN HARD SCATTERING FROM NUCLEON TARGETS PERVEZ HOODBHOY Department of Physics, Quaid-e-Azam University, Islamabad 45320, Pakistan. Following the discovery of a discrepancy between nucleon formfactors extracted from polarization transfer methods and the traditional (single photon) h s e n bluth formula, two-photon exchange processes have come under scrutiny. We consider here the production of a lepton-antilepton pair by real photons off a hadronic target. The interference of one and two photon exchange amplitudes leads to a charge asymmetry term that may be calculated explicitly in the large-t limit in terms of hadronic distribution amplitudes. A rather compact expression emerges for the leading order asymmetry at fixed angle in the centre-of-mass of the lepton pair. The magnitude appears sizeable and is approximately independent of the pair mass in the asymptotic limit.
Measurement of the nucleon's electric and magnetic form factors has traditionally been based upon the well-known Rosenbluth formula' which assumes that scattering occurs through the exchange of a single photon. A recent extraction of G$/GG in the Q2 range from 0.5 to 5.6 GeV2 has used the polarization-transfer technique exploited at Jefferson Laboratory2. This method, which does not use the Rosenbluth separation, revealed a large discrepancy with previously published form factors. Subsequently, a close scrutiny was made of two-photon exchange effects in elastic electron-proton scattering. In this process a virtual photon knocks the incident proton into an excited state, and a second one de-excites it back into the ground state. Both photons may be hard, and hence they probe nucleon structure. The effects were found to exist at a few percent level and are capable of resolving the observed discrepancy3. Model dependence is inevitable. Chen et al.4 have also calculated the two-photon exchange contribution and related it to the generalized parton distribution~~ that occur in various other hard processes as well. A clear exposition of experimental techniques and
117
118
two-photon physics may be found in a review by Wright and Jager6. In this note, I shall consider two-photon effects in the production of a lepton-antilepton pair from a hadronic target by real photons (see Fig. 1) at high centre of mass energy s.
2-
Fig. 1.
Exclusive photoproduction of a lepton pair off a proton target.
The process predominantly occurs through the exchange of one photon, with a two-photon admixture. Both amplitudes are for the same final state and so interfere with one another. These exchanges come from diagrams with opposite charge conjugation7. This fact enables one to isolate the interference term by counting the difference in the number of produced antileptons and leptons. In the limit of large momentum transfer t , they can be explicitly computed from the leading Fock-state in terms of lowest order hadronic distribution amplitudes. We find a rather compact expression for the leading order asymmetry at fixed angle in the centre-of-mass of the lepton pair. The inputs to this calculation, apart from the hadron distribution amplitudes, are experimentally determined hadronic form factors at sufficiently large t. We note that Berger, Diehl, and Pire had analyzed and estimated exclusive lepton pair photoproduction (at small t ) as a means of studying generalized parton distributions in the nucleon'. Exclusive electroproduction of J/psi mesons (which then decay into lepton pairs) has been studied at HERAS for fairly small Q 2 values. Before considering the more complex case of the proton, we shall first consider a pion target. It is convenient to work in the rest frame of the produced lepton-antilepton pair. The mass of the quarks, and of the hadronic target, have been ignored in this preliminary calculation, i.e. P 2 = PI2 = 0 where P p and P I P are the momenta of the initial and final hadron. The squared invariant mass of the produced leptons (also assumed massless) is
119
M 2 . This may be selected at will and should be chosen far away from a re+ onance. Simple expressions emerge only for s >> -t, M 2 >> A&D where t is defined, as usual, from t = ( P - P ' ) 2 .It is negative in the physical region. The incoming real photon (g2 = 0) is taken along the z-axis, and the x - z scattering plane is defined by the incoming vectors g p and Pi', + where P makes angle .1c, with the z-axis. The outgoing, elastically scattered, hadron is in the x - z plane. The sum of the lepton-antilepton momentum vectors is Kfi = Zp 1'". A convenient parametrization of the scattering kinematics is then provided by
+
where the incoming hadron energy E , incoming photon energy w , and angle .II, are
s+t 2M M 2-t w=2M c=-
cos$=l--.
S
2WE
The outgoing lepton and antilepton, also taken to be massless, have spinors u(Z)and v(Z'). The lepton and anti-lepton momentum vectors are
M
2 p = -(1,sin 8 cos 4, sin 8 sin 4, cos 8) , 2 t M Z p = -(l, - sin8 cos 4, - sin 8 sin 4, - cos 8 ) . 2
(8) (9) 4
The azimuthal angle 4 is measured relative to the plane formed by P and (which defines the z-axis and hence 8). In the centre-of-mass frame 4 used here P also lies in this plane. By angular momentum conservation, the two massless leptons have opposite helicities. Since we shall work a t the amplitude level, we need simple, covariant expressions for the matrix v(Z')E(Z) in the helicity basis. The method developed by Vega and Wudka" is especially convenient when used in the cm frame:
7
120
An overall phase has been set to zero in the above matrix since it will not enter the cross-sections. The auxiliary vector q$ is defined as, T&
= ( 0 , c o s ~ c o s $ f i s i n ~ , c o s ~ c o s $ ~ z c-sine). os$,
Here f refers to the lepton helicity.
QP
(12)
satisfies,
Consider now lepton pair production from a pion via the form factor diagram (Fig.2). This, together with its crossed counterpart, is easily calculated in the large s limit.
Fig. 2.
Form-factor contribution to lepton pair production at lowest order.
With the pion factor normalized such that F,(O) = 1, the amplitude for producing a positive helicity lepton from a positive helicity real photon is
Ail
= AI(B,$,yT1I t l rl)
For convenience we have defined the dimensionless momentum transfer,
t
p = --
M2.
By examining the y-matrix structure, the other helicity amplitudes are
121
For momentum transfers much higher than the invariant mass of the produced lepton pair
Note that the $ dependence entirely disappears in this limit. The singular behaviour for 0 4 0 comes from the lepton propagator in Fig. 2 and disappears upon including the lepton mass. However, for purposes of comparing with the other amplitudes to be computed below, where including the mass would make the formulae less transparent, this mass will be kept a t zero in this preliminary calculation. The squared amplitude from Fig. 2, summed over lepton polarizations, and averaged over photon polarizations, is:
The coefficients a, are a0 a1
,
= -(p2
+ +
4p 1) 2(p2 = 4&(p - 1) cot 8, -
+ 1) csc26 ,
(23) (24)
2p. (25) Under spatial inversion (i.e. 0 + B 7r and $ -+ $ ) the outgoing lepton and anti-lepton are exchanged. But , computed from Eq. 22 suffers no change. In other words the charge asymmetry a t leading order is zero. A fermion line attached to three vector vertices has the opposite charge conjugation properties relative to the same line with two vertices. We shall use this property in an essential way. So, now consider scattering into the same final state but through the exchange of two photons. The three photon vertices may be connected to the Z-l+ line in six different ways, two of which have been shown in Fig. 3. In general, the scattering from any hadronic state is extremely complicated and, in the language of Fock states, involves an infinite number of proton wavefunction components. However, in the large-t limit, all higher components beyond the minimal one are strongly suppressed in a purely exclusive process. The reason is straightforward: every quark and gluon present a2 =
+
122
Fig. 3.
Typical two-photon contributions to lepton photoproduction from a pion target.
in the initial state must be "turned around" and its momentum components redirected into the final state. This simple fact allows for calculation of hadronic f o r m - f a ~ t o r s ~ as~ ,well as generalized parton distributions1*, etc. In the calculation reported below we assume that large enough values of t can be selected for the minimal 2-quark component of the pion to dominate the scattering. Integrating over the transverse momentum of quarks, one may then approximately represent the pion state by
(26) where the integration measure is [ds] = ds1dz26(1 - z1 - 4.
(27)
Here a = 1 , 2 , 3 denotes colour. Asymptotically, as is well known, &(x) approaches fT&s(l- x). The calculation of diagrams in Fig. 3 is straightforward. Typically one has a denominator that, expanded out in the large s limit, looks like 1 s(xl - yl) [I
+ p + 2ficos4sinO + ( p - 1)
+ if'
This is singular at 51 = y1, and so has a principal part in addition to an imaginary (delta function) piece. The principal parts cancel when taking the sum of all six diagrams for the upper diagrams. The numerator is of 0(s2),and so the overall contribution is proportional to s.
123
After a tedious calculation, the amplitude for producing a positive helicity lepton from a positive helicity real photon via two-photon exchange reads,
In the above, 1:
= 1- X I and the integrand depends upon
8 and 4 :
The other amplitudes can be expressed in terms of A;' :
The negative signs in the above amplitudes will be responsible for the charge asymmetry in the crossection, as we shall see shortly. But first, let us remark on the apparent problem in the integral,
For 4 = 0 the integrand is real and has a singularity inside the integration range. However, reinstating the lepton mass removes the singularity by introducing a term of order m2/M2. This still leaves a very strong 4 dependence, thereby distinguishing the two-photon exchange term from that with a single photon. A proper calculation must, of course, include lepton masses. One might wonder about other diagrams, also of O(e3), such as those in Fig. 4. However, these can be shown to be of O(l/s). Now consider the interference term in IAl A2I2,
+
124
Fig. 4. A typical diagram for lepton pairproduction from a single quark in the target. The sum of all such diagrams is suppressed in the large - s limit for real photons.
After simplication, this becomes,
(35) In the above, C = 1 - x = 1 - XI and e, = 2/3, ed = -1/3. We define the charge asymmetry as:
+
Obviously E(e,$) = -E(O 7r,+). This quantity is proportional to the difference in count rates between antileptons and leptons. As is apparent from the definition of A, the integral over x asymptotically goes to a constant, finite value as p -+ m. A leading order c a l ~ u l a t i o nfor~ ~ the ~~~ pion form factor gives (-t)F, = 12f,27rC~asat large t or, equivalently, pF, = 1 2 ( f , 2 / M 2 ) 7 r C ~ a sNote . that M , the lepton pair invariant mass, has disappeared from the final formula for E. In Fig. 5 , E is plotted as a function of p for fixed angles. Note that we have assumed collinear quarks and so the formula is valid only for M greater than the typical kT of quarks inside the pion.
125
0.4
0.3 0.2 0.1
Fig. 5 .
Lepton pair asymmetry from a pion target.
With the above case for the pion as a warm-up, we now proceed to lepton pair production from a %quark target. For calculational purposes, it is useful to introduce a 4-vector for the scattered hadronlO,
tP= (0, cos$, -i,
-
sin$),
P.E = 0,
(37)
(38)
in terms of which the proton spinor matrix can be expressed as,
The form-factor contribution to lepton photoproduction off a proton is identical to that from a pion in the limit where the spin-flip term (Pauli form factor) is set to zero. Indeed for massless quarks and no transverse momentum, this is strictly true. The minimal state of the proton is,
126
Fig. 6. Typical diagrams for lepton pair production from a 3-quark proton.
where [dz] = dz1dz2dz36(1- 2 1 - z 2 - z3).Asymptotically, @(XI, 22,z3) 120 ~ 1 2 2 x 3but more realistic wavefunctions have been constructed and can be found in refs. [11,121. The proton case requires more work but it follows the calculation detailed above for the pion. With some typical diagrams shown in Fig. 6, we imagine that 3 collinear quarks with charges el,e2,e3 enter from the left with momentum fractions z1,52,23 and emerge to the right with fractions y1,y2,y3. An extra gluon is required to transfer the hard momentum on to the remaining quark, and this brings an additional factor of g2 into the amplitude. The incoming proton is taken to be in a definite (positive) helicity state. In the absence of quark transverse momentum, as well as quark mass, the helicity of the final proton is that of the incoming one. Equivalently, in this approximation, the Pauli form factor is zero. Summing over the twelve different ways of connecting two photons to the 3 quark lines gives, after a tedious calculation: N
(41) In the above (as well as in the equation below), it is implicitly understood that the complex conjugate, and exchange of labels (1,3)% (3,l)
127
Fig. 7.
Lepton pair asymmetry from a proton target.
are to be added on. The charges ei are in units of the electron charge e (ae = e2/47r). Inserting this and the single-photon results into Eq. 34 yields,
J XI idyl el(e222y2 +
Y3)216(!/1- 21) [ Y l E f A1 E2
e323!/3)@(21,22,23)@(!/1, YZ, 212223YlY2Y3
(42)
As a check on the correctness of the calculations for scattering amplitudes
-
for both the meson and baryon cases, we have verified that the Ward iden-
tity is satisfied in all different ways. Perturbatively ( - t ) ’ G M ( t ) constant at large t , and so again one has approximate scale invariance. In Fig. 7 we have plotted the asymmetry off a proton target. In this exploratory calculation we have used the Chernyak-Zhitnitsky wavefunction in ref. [9]. In this paper we have calculated asymmetries, not cross-sections because the latter involve a 3-body phase space. Since J-Psi photoproduction has
128
been measured in exclusive reactionsg, lepton pair production should also be possible. Finally we remark that Sudakov effects, which arise from the bremstrahlung of widely separated quarks that undergo large changes in momentum, will lead to a weakening of the effective coupling. Thus, although the angular structure of the amplitude will probably be similar, one must investigate diagrams that are of one order higher in a,. For the proton case this will involve a very large number of diagrams that will require a machine computation. We have not attempted this calculation.
Acknowledgments The author thanks Stanley J. Brodsky and Xiangdong J i for valuable comments and encouragement.
References 1. M.N. Rosenbluth, Phys. Rev. 79, 615 1950. 2. M.K. Jones, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 1398 (2000); 0. Gayou, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, 092301 (2002); V. Punjabi, et al. Phys. Rev. C71,055202 (2005). 3. P.G. Blunden, W. Melnitchouk, J.A. Tjon, Phys. Rev. C72, 034612 (2005), nucLth/0506039. 4. Yu-Chun Chen, Andrei V. Afanasev, Stanley J. Brodsky, Carl E. Carlson, Marc Vanderhaeghen, Phys. Rev. D72, 013008 (2005), hep-ph/0502013. 5. X. Ji, Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 610 (1997); ibid., Phys. Rev. D 5 , 7114 (1997); A. V. Radyushkin, Phys. Lett. B380, 417 (1996); ibid., Phys. Lett. B 3 8 5 , 333 (1996); ibid., Phys. Rev. D 5 6 , 5524 (1997). 6. C.E.H Wright and K. Jager, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 54, 217 (2004). 7. S.J.Brodsky and J.R.Gillespie, Phys. Rev. D173, 1011 (1968). This paper discusses photoproduction of lepton pairs from a nuclear target and also uses interference with the Born amplitude to generate asymmetries. 8. E.R. Berger, M. Diehl, B. Pire, Eur. Phys. J. C23, 675 (2002), hepph/0110062. 9. ZEUS Collaboration, Nucl. Phys. B 6 9 5 , 3 (2004), hep-ex/0404008. 10. R. Vega and J. Wudka, Phys. Rev. D 5 3 , 5286 (1996), erratum: ibid. Phys. Rev. D 5 6 , 6037 (1997). 11. G.R. Farrar, H. Zhang, A.A. Ogloblin, and I.R. Zhitnitsky, Nucl. Phys. B311, 585 (1988). 12. V. Braun, R.J. Fries, N. Mahnke, E. Stein, Nucl. Phys. B 5 8 9 , 381 (2000), erratum: ibid. Nucl. Phys. B607, 433 (2001). 13. G.P. Lepage and S.J. Brodsky, Phys. Rev. D22, 2157 (1980).
129 14. P. Hoodbhoy, X. Ji, and F. Yuan, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 012003 (2004), hepph/0309085. 15. A.V.Efremov and A.V.Radyushkin, Phys. Lett. 94B,245 (1980).
BPS M-BRANE GEOMETRIES TASNEEM ZEHRA HUSAIN*
Jefferson Physical Laboratory, Harvard University, Cambridge, M A 02138, U . S . A *E-mail:
[email protected] In the search for a classification of BPS backgrounds with flux, we look at geometries that arise when M-branes wrap supersymmetric cycles in CalabiYau manifolds. We find constraints on the differential forms in the back-reacted manifolds and discover that the calibration corresponding to the (background generating) M-brane is a co-closed form.
Keywords: Supergravity, M-Branes, Flux Backgrounds.
1. Introduction Ever since it was found that compactifications of String/M-Theory on special holonomy manifolds preserve supersymmetry, such manifolds have been widely studied. If Euclidean they must also be Ricci-flat and according to Berger's classification their holonomy groups are then dictated by their dimension d ; we have S U ( n ) holonomy (Calabi-Yau manifolds) in d = 2 n dimensions, S p ( n ) holonomy (hyper-Kahler manifolds) if d = 4 n , Gz holonomy in d = 7 and S p i n ( 7 ) in d = 8. This neat categorization however, applies only in the absence of flux; as we will now see, supersymmetric backgrounds are no longer quite so simple once space-time contains flux! 2. D = l l Supergravity
We will study the geometry of BPS M-branes using 11-d supergravity'. While admittedly just an approximation to M-theory, supergravity is useful when considering BPS states since these are protected from quantum corrections by supersymmetry and hence guaranteed to survive the transition to strong coupling/M-Theory. The bosonic fields of d = l l supergravity are the metric G I J and a threeform gauge potential A (with associated field strength F = dA) which cou-
130
131
ples electrically to M2-branes and magnetically to M5-branes. The bosonic actiona of this theory
S
=
1
/ 2t9
d ” s a
1 2
1 6
R - - F A *F - -AA F A F
leads to the equation of motion 1
- -GIJF 1 KLMN FKLMN 12 144 together with the Bianchi Identity dF = 0 and equation of motion for the field strength d * F f F A F = 0. In BPS backgrounds the supersymmetric variations of all fields vanish when the variation parameter is a Killing Spinor. Since we are restricting ourselves to purely bosonic backgrounds, we have set the gravitino 9 to zero, hence the supersymmetric variation of the bosonic fields vanishes trivially. The variation of the gravitino however, is proportional to the bosonic fields and hence not zero a priori. In order t o guarantee supersymmetry, we impose
R I J = - F I K L M F JK L M
+
+
6 x 9 1 = [VI - -r J K L F I J K L -rI J K L M F J K L M ] X = 0. (3) 18 144 When F = 0, the Ricci tensor vanishes and supersymmetry is preserved only if the background admits covariantly constant spinors. From V I X= Ob it follows that [VI, v J ] x= 0 and the identitiy [VI, v J ] x= ~ R I can then be used to show that a Killing spinor in such a background must be a singlet of the Spzn(1,lO) subgroup 7-l generated by R I J K L r K L . In other words, ‘FI has to be a special holonomy group. This is the logic that lies behind the oft-quoted statement that String/M-Theory compactified on special holonomy manifolds is supersymmetric. Note however that this entire argument depends crucially on the fact that F = 0. As it turns out, flux is an intrinsic part of most realistic backgrounds, for instance those generated by BPS M-branes. Being charged gravitating objects, these branes modify any space into which they are placed, warping the geometry and giving rise to a field strength flux. The resulting ‘back-reacted’ manifold is no longer Ricci-flat nor does it admit covariantly constant spinors, but since the brane is BPS, the background remains supersymmetric. aThe field content of 11-dimensional supergravity also contains a fermion - the gravitino q.However, since we are considering purely bosonic solutions, we are not concerned with how the gravitino appears in the action or its equations of motion. bHere, VrX = [El1 $~Yrij]x.
+
132
The work reviewed here is part of a scheme to characterize the geometries of BPS M-branes and arrive at an exhaustive classification of these flux-filled, yet still supersymmetric, backgrounds.
3. The Geometry of BPS M-branes Before we discuss M-branes wrapping more complicated supersymmetric cycles, we look at a planar M5-branec in order to build an intuition for the general features exhibited by supergravity solutions. Consider an M5-brane placed in Minkowski space. Spacetime, after being curved by the brane, is described by the metric ds2 = H-1/3~ p u d X ” d X u H2/36,pdXQdXP and field strength F,p-,a = ;caprap 8,H. Poincare invariance on the worldvolume implies that H be independent of coordinates X” tangent to the brane. Rotational invariance in the transverse directions X a says that H can depend only on the radial coordinate T = and the metric is diagonal in this subspace. The conditions dF = 0 and d * F = 0 fix H to be a harmonic function in the space transverse to the brane, i.e, H = 1+ 5 . More complicated BPS configurations can be generated by wrapping M-branesd on supersymmetric cycles in a compactification manifold M . The very presence of the brane deforms space-time such that M no longer has special holonomy. Regardless of the particular cycle it wraps, there are some univeral features exhibited by the geometry of a BPS brane wrapped on a supersymmetric cycle C embedded in a manifold M . Space-time splits naturally into three subspaces; unwrapped directions X” transverse to M but tangent to the brane, M itself, spanned by dX’ and the X a directions transverse to both brane and manifold. The flat worldvolume directions exhibit Poincare invariance so nothing can depend on X”. Along directions X,, the brane appears point-like and the configuration is rotationally symmetric. This leads to a diagonal metric in this subspace and further dictates that the functional dependence of any physical quantity only involve the radial coordinate r. Fayyazuddin and Smith incorporated these isometriese
+
Jm’
=We are mentioning only M5-branes explicitly but of course a parallel analysis can - and in fact has been - carried out for M2-branes as well. dAn M2-brane along the 012 directions preserves the 16 supersymmetries which survive ro12x = x. The metric and field strength are specified by ds2 = H - 2 / 3 q p v d X p d X V H’/3b,gdXadXP and F012, = where H = 1 + p = 0,1,2 spans the worldvolume and T is the radial coordinate in the transverse space spanned by a = 3 , . . . l o . eThe metric in M is left completely general, since we have made no assumptions about either this manifold or the supersymmetric cycle yet.
+,
+
133
into the metric ansatz
+
ds2 = H ~ ~ p u d X c ” d XGIjdX’dXJ u
+ Hi6,pdX“dXp.
(4)
They then began their search for a supersymmetric supergravity solution by imposing d X Q = 0. This lead to a set of equations which can be solved by expressing the field strength and the metric in terms of a single function H. If, in addition dF = 0 and d * F = 0, we are guaranteed that Einstein’s equations are satisfied. While the former condition is trivially satisfied, the latter leads to a non-linear differential equationf for H. Strictly speaking, a supergravity solution is not found until this equation is solved; though possible in theory, this proves very difficult in practise. However, the process we have just described yields an unexpected boon. In addition t o relating the metric to the field strength, dxQ = 0 also imposes constraints on certain differential forms in M . It is well known that special holonomy manifolds can be defined through conditions on the differential forms they admit. Proceeding in analogy we can begin to characterize M using the constraints obtained by the above analysis. 4. How BPS M-branes deform Calabi-Yaw
In the following, we will restrict ourselves to M-branes wrapped on supersymmetric cycles in Calabi-Yau manifolds. A Calabi-Yau n-fold is, by definition, a Ricci-flat Kahler manifold, with SU(n) holonomy. Equivalently, a Calabi-Yau is defined through the conditions dJ = dR = 0 , where J is the Kahler form and R the unique (n, 0) form on the manifold. Even when explicit metrics are not known, as is the case for most Calabi-Yaus, these conditions on the differential forms provide a wealth of information about the geometry of the manifold. The supersymmetric cycles of a Calabi-Yau are even-dimensional holomorphic cycles, calibrated by the appropriate power of J , and a Special Lagrangian n-cycle calibrated by R. Branes wrapped on these cycles saturate the BPS bound so their charges are fixed by their masses and the calibrating forms are simply the respective volume forms3. Into spacetime of the form R ( 1 > 3CY2 ) ~ xR3, we introduce an M5brane with worldvolume R(’13)x Cz where C2 is a holomorphic 2-cycle and consequently, calibrated by J. This M5-brane deforms the four-manifold such that it is no longer Calabi-Yau4 but instead satisfies the constraint dm[H1I3x J ] = 0. ‘H can hence be thought of as the appropriate generalisation (for a wrapped brane case) of the harmonic function in the solution for a planar brane.)
134
If spacetime looked like R('l3)x C Y ~ X Rthe , presence of an M5-brane with worldvolume R(133)x CZ would modify the geometry and the sixmanifold would be subject to the constraint a M [ H - 1 / 3 * J ] = 0. An M5brane wrapping a holomorphic 4-cycle (calibrated by J A J ) can only be nontrivially embedded into a CY 3-fold. The brane deforms this six dimensional space in such a way that the Calabi-Yau condition dJ = 0 is replaced by i 3 ~ [ H l* /J~A J ] = 0. When membranes wrap holomorphic two-cycles in CY n-folds, their back-reactions distort the 2n-dimensional manifolds such that d ~ [ [ H ( " - ~*)Jl ]~= 0. Recall that Calabi-Yau manifolds also admit another kind of supersymmetric cycle, the Special Lagrangian (SpelL). A SpelL n-cycle C,calibrated by Reie is a n n-dimensional real submanifold of C" on which Jlr. = 0 and ReieIr. = Vol(C).Even though a phase can be incorporated in general, for simplicity, we will consider SpelL cycles calibrated by ReR [or I m R ] . Since a SpelL is a real manifold, there is no reason to assume that a brane wrapping it will deform space in such a way that a complex structure survives on the backreacted manifold M . In fact, the Fayyazuddin-Smith analysis of these geometries5 shows us that only an almost complex structure J survives. For a M5-brane wrapping the SpelL 3-cycleg calibrated by Re R, we find that the Calabi-Yau %fold is deformed into a manifold on which a M * [Re R ] = a M [ I m = 0. The requirement of supersymmetry i3Q = 0 leads to other constraints as well on R and J . Once again, all physical quantities can be expressed in terms of a single function H, which is subject to a non-linear differential equation.
a]
5 . Conclusions
In backgrounds without flux, bosonic supersymmetric solutions of supergravity are given simply by metrics with special holonomy. The question is, how do we generalise this classification when flux is non-vanishing? As a case in point, we studied the background generated by a M-brane wrapping a holomorphic cycle in a Calabi-Yau manifold. Even though we were able to specify the metric and field strength only modulo solution of a non-linear differential equation, we found certain defining equations for the manifold M , into which the Calabi-Yau was deformed. We then proceeded to study M-branes wrapping other supersymmetric cycles, aiming not to find explicit metrics for a handful of examples but intead to characterise gSince a SpelL 2-cycle in a CY 2-fold is merely a holomorphic 2-cycle in a redefined complex structure, we will mention only SpelL 3-cycles here
135
a back-reacted manifold through constraints on its differential forms. Our approach differs from the usual in that most of the work done in this field focuses on finding explicit supergravity solutions in some approximation; these solutions will at best tell us about the local geometry near the cycle. In contrast, the statements we make are global and can be used to classify the back-reacted manifold. For all M-branes wrapping supersymmetric cycles in Calabi-Yau manifoldsh we obtain a constraint on the dual of (the appropriately rescaled) calibration on M . Such constraints, we hope, will lead to a concise and exhaustive classification of supersymmetric flux backgrounds. Acknowledgments: I am grateful to the organizers for the stimulating atmosphere they created in Islamabad this April. Faheem Hussain, in particular, went out of his way to make the conference a success. I would also like to thank Ansar Fayyazuddin for several vary enjoyable collaborations on which this review is based. References 1. D.J.Smith, Class. Quant. Grav. 20, R233 (2003). 2. A.Fayyazuddin & D.J.Smith, JHEP 9904, 030 (1999); B.Brinne, A.Fayyazuddin, T.Z.Husain & D.J.Smith, JHEP 0103,052 (2001). 3. T.Z.Husain, If I Only Had A Brane (PhD thesis), hep-th/0304143; P.K.Townsend, Class. Quant. Grav. 17,1267 (2000). 4. T.Z.Husain, JHEP 0312,037 (2003); T.Z.Husain, JHEP 0304,053 (2003). 5. A.Fayyazuddin & T.Z.Husain, Phys. Rev. D73, 126004 (2006); A.Fayyazuddin, T.Z.Husain & I.Pappa, The Geometry of M-branes Wrapping Special Lagrangian Cycles hep-th/0505182. 6. T.Z.Husain, JHEP 0308,014 (2003).
hThe only exception is the M5-brane wrapping a holomorphic 4-cycle in a CY 4-fold 6. It has been known for a while that this configuration stands apart from the crowd in a number of ways, a key reason behind this apparent discord being that it is the only M-brane geometry encountered so far which does not satisfy F A F = 0
WARD IDENTITIES AND RADIATIVE RARE LEPTONIC B-DECAYS M. JAMIL ASLAM, AMJAD HUSSAIN SHAH GILANI, MARIAM SALEH KHAN AND RIAZUDDIN National Centre for Physics, Quaid-i-Azam University Campus Islamabad, Pakistan. Form factors parametrizing radiative leptonic decays of heavy mesons (Bf -+ $+q) for photon energy are computed in the language of dispersion relations. The contributing states to the absorptive part in the dispersion relation are the multiparticle continuum, estimated by the quark triangle graph, and resonances with quantum numbers 1- and 1+ which include B* and B;I and their radial excitations, which model the higher state contributions. Constraints provided by the asymptotic behavior of the structure dependent amplitude, Ward Identities and gauge invariance are used to provide useful inforare predicted mation for parameters needed. The couplings g B B * y and if we restrict to the first radial excitation; otherwise using these as an input the radiative decay coupling constants for radial excitations are predicted. The value of the branching ratio for the process B+ -+ yp+v, is found to be in the range 0.5 x lop6. A detailed comparison is given with other approaches.
1. Introduction The radiative leptonic decay B+ 4 l+viy has received a great deal of attention in the literature' as a means of probing aspects of the strong and weak interactions of a heavy quark system. The presence of the additional photon in the final state can compensate for the helicity suppression of the decay rate present in the purely leptonic mode. As a result, the branching ratio for the radiative leptonic mode can be as large as for the ,u+ case which is in accordance with the the upper limit provided by the CLEO collaboration for the branching ratio B ( B 4 I v y ) of 2.0 x at 90% confidence level'. This would open up the possibility for directly measuring the decay constant f~ as well as provide useful information about the CKM matrix element IvUbl3. In this paper, we will study the radiative leptonic B decays,
136
137
B+ + l + y y . Our main inputs are dispersion relations, asymptotic behavior and Ward Identities, all of which have strong theoretical basis and in these aspects it differs from other approaches to which we will compare our results at the end. Our approach is close to that followed in Ref. [4] for B -+ ~ 1 ~ 1 . 2. Decay kinematics and current matrix elements
The decay amplitude for radiative leptonic decay, B+ -i Z+uly, can be written in two parts, inner bremsstrahlung ( M I B )and structure dependent ( M s D ) ,as follows:
M ( B + + Z + ~ l y= ) MIB + MSD.
(1)
They are given by5
with
Here E; denotes the polarization vector of the photon; p , p l , p , ; k are the four momenta of B+, Z+, Y , and y, respectively; s1 is the polarization vector of the Z+; f B is the B meson decay constant and FA, FV are two Lorentz invariant amplitudes (form factors) defined by
where q is the momentum transfer.
138
3. Dispersion Relations
The structure dependent part, Hfi” is given by
We note that6
so that for the real photon we can write
where k p H p y = 0 and H p ’ is parametrized as in Eq.(6). The second term in (13) is absorbed in M I B . The absorptive part is
Abs [ i H p V = ] 1/ d 4 x e i k ’ x(0 I[j&(x), J,”(O)]IB ( p ) ) 2
The S-function in the first term implies p i = k2 = 0 and since there is no real particle with zero mass, the first term does not contribute. Thus contributing to the absorptive part are all possible intermediate states that couple to By and are annihilated by the weak vertex (0 IJ,”(O)ln). These include the multiparticle continuum as well as resonances with quantum numbers 1- and 1+.Thus
The dots stand for contributions from higher states with the same quantum numbers. The couplings gBB’y and fB;iBy are defined as
139
We assume that the contributions from the radial excitations of B* and B: dominate the higher state contributions. Thus we write
FA(t) =
RA 1- t / M i ; i
RA( 1- t / M $
1 4
1,
i-
M2
ImFACont !’Ids, (17) s -t
-
ZE
where M is a cut off near the first radial excitation of MB* or Mp.2 and SO= M B mT,and
+
and Rv, and R A are ~ the corresponding quantities for the radial excitations with masses MB: and M B ; ~In~ the . next section we develop the constraints on some of the parameters appearing in the above equations. If we model the continuum contribution by the quark triangular graph (similar calculations exist in the literature7), we obtain
together with the term
which appears in Eq. (13). As is well known (see for example Ref. [8]), the pole at q2 = M i in Eq. (19) arises due to the u (6) quark propagator which forms one side of the quark triangular graph, the other sides being part of the B meson wave function. 4. Asymptotic Behavior
To get constraints on the residues Ri, it is useful to study the asymptotic behavior of form factors FV and FA. It has been argued that the behavior of form factors for very large values of It1 can be estimated reliably in perturbative QCD processes [pQCD]4>9>10. For t << 0 and for It1 much larger than the physical mass of heavy resonances, pQCD should yield a very good approximation to the form factors. First we note that by vector meson dominance
140
where
fpl
having dimensions of mass, is defined as
Then using the methods employed in [lo], it is easy to calculate [only the diagram where the gluon is emitted by the light quark in (ba) bound state and absorbed by the heavy quark contributes and is by itself gauge invariant] FpQCD: PQCD = FPQCD FV A
Here
and is governed by the tail end of the B meson wave function characterized by E . Now using the asymptotic behavior of Eq. (17), namely
RiM:
+1 7T
/
1
M2
ImFCont(s)ds ,
so
we obtain
(24)
i
where a
=
+
or (- 1) and we have defined
In the heavy quark limit, c scales as f B M B Q U / A while RvM& scales as g B B * y M B f B , where in the quark model g B B * y N Thus the right hand side of Eq. (25) goes to zero in this limit. Hence we get the convergence condition N
R M ~+
2 %,
C R ~ M :+ c = 0.
(27)
i
The convergence relation, Eq. (27), is a model-independent result and constitutes a very binding constraint for model b ~ i l d i n g Here, .~ we will study the constrained dispersive model where only the first two radial excitations are kept because as the radial excitations of B* become heavier they are
141 Table 1. €3-mesons masses in GeV
MB MB*
5.71
1.12
1.24 1.22
less relevant to the form factors”. The spectrum of radial excitations is given in Table 1, where the subindices 1 and 2 correspond to the 2s and 3s excitation of the B*, etc. Thus the convergence condition (27) now reads
RM2 + RIM;
+ R2M; + c = 0.
(28)
This condition leaves two free parameters R1 and using Eq. (24), we obtain RM2 (Mi - M2)
RIM; (Mi - Mf)
+
F ( q 2 ) = (M2 - q2)(M: - q2)+(M; - $)(Mi - q 2 )
R2
in the model and
M; - M~ (Mi - q2)(M2- q2)” (29)
where in the heavy quark limit M B = M& = M and
5 . Ward Identities Constraints
It is useful to define
(y( k ,€) Izlia’”vq,bl B ( p ) ) = -iE’Va%;kapgFl(q2),
(7( k ,6 ) Iai~’~ysqAlB ( p ) )= [(q * k) €*’
- (E*
(31)
. q ) k’] F3(q2). (32)
Now we will make use of Ward Identities and gauge invariance principle to relate different form factors. The Ward Identities* used in our process for this purpose are:
(7( k ,6 ) Iaia’vqvbl Bb)) = - ( m b
+ mq) (Y (k, €1 ICy’bl
W p ) ) , (33)
(7( k ,6 ) I.lii0’”y~qvbI B b ) ) = ( m b - mq) (7 (k,€1IW’%bI B ( p ) ). (34)
Substituting these Ward Identities in Eqs. (31) and (32) and using Eqs.(9,10) we obtain [2,. k = q . k , E* . p = E* . q]
*See ref. [I41 for a detailed derivation of these Ward Identities.
142
The results given in Eq. (35) are model independent because these are derived by using Ward Identities. In order to make use of Ward Identities to relate different form factors, we define
(Y (k, €1 liuaapbl B b ) ) = - i E a p p o E * P ( t k ) [(P + kIUg++ qU9-I -iq -2
. €*(Ic)€,&&
+ k)Pq“h
[qaEpp0TE*’
(IC)(P k)aqT - a
[(P
k),
+
EppmE*’(k)
(P
+ k)O qT
p] hl -
a
H
p] h2. (36)
Since we have a real photon, gauge invariance requires that if we replace ~ p ( k by ) k p , the matrix element should vanish. This requires g+
+ g- + 2 ( q . k ) h = 0.
(37)
Thus, finally we obtain
n
Therefore, the normalization of FV and FA at q2 = 0 is determined by a universal form factor (g+ (0) - M z h z ) . Now the form factor hz does not get any contribution from the quark triangle graph nor from the pole and therefore we shall put it equal to zero. The contribution to g+ (4’) from the quark triangle graph14 is
We expect the Ward Identities to hold at low q2 below the resonance regime and as such we use the results obtained from them at q2 = 0. Thus from Eqs. (38 and 39), we obtain (mb
+ mq) FV (0) = 2g+ (0) = (mb- mq)FA (0)
*
(41)
Further, using & . = M B - mb in the above equation (41) and neglecting terms of the order of f r n , ) / M ~ ,we obtain another constraint using Eqs. (29, 30) at q2 = 0
(a
143
Restricting to one radial excitation (M2 = M I ) ,the results are summarized in Table 2. These are the final expressions for the form factors of our process B 4 y l y , if we restrict to the one radial excitation. We also observe the approximate equality F v ( q 2 )= FA(q2) of the form factors which also occur in some other model^^^$^^. For numerical work, we shall use B-meson masses given in Table 1 and f B = 0.180 GeV. Now we study the effect of second radial excitations and the results are:
where A is a parameter which in principle can be obtained when g B * B - , and f B ; B y become known. For numerical values we shall use A = 0 [i.e., M I = M2 (one radial excitation)] and A = 3 and A = 4.8. The second value of A (= 3) corresponds to the estimate of gB*B-, from vector meson dominance
where gB'Bp- = 11fi GeV-l is obtained in [15] and f p - / m p= 205 MeV. The third value of A (= 4.8) gives more or less the width for B* By --f
144 obtained from MI transition in the non relativistic quark model (NRQM). These values give decay widths for B* -+ B y transition as 23 keV, 5.5 keV and 0.8 keV respectively while MI transition in the NRQM predicts it to be 0.9 keV. These predictions will become testable when the above decay width is experimentally measured.
Fig. 1. Differential decay rate versus photon energy z is plotted and comparison is given with various approaches. The solid line (for A = 0 ) , dashed-tripledotted line (for A = 3.0) and dotted line (for A = 4.8) are our calculation, dash-dot-dot line”, dashed line12 and dash-dotted line13. The thin-solid line is the Sudakov resummation calculation result from Ref. [12].
In Fig. 1, differential decay width of the process is plotted against z which is the photon energy spectrum and we see that for our calculations the peak is shifted to lower value of z as compared to those for Eilam et al.,17, Korchemsky et a1.l’ and Chelkov et al.13. So, for the process B