LAZAR DRAGON
MATHEMATICAL
METHODS IN
AERODYNAMICS
ll KLUWER ACADEMIC PUBLISHERS
EDITURA ACADEMIEI ROMANE
MATHEMATICAL METHODS IN AERODYNAMICS
Mathematical Methods in Aerodynamics by
LAZAR DRAGO$, Roqsonime Academy.
H charm Romania
L7 KLUWER ACADEMIC PUBLISHERS
EDITURA ACADEMIEI ROMANE
DORDRECHT/BOSTON FLONDON
BUCURE$11
A C.I.P. Catalogue record for this book is available from the Library al' Congress.
ISBN 1-4020-1663-8 ISBN 973-27-0986-3
Published by Kluwer Academic Publishers and Editura Academrei Romans. Kluwer Academic Publishers. P.O. Box 17. 3300 AA Dordrecht. The Netherlands. Editura Academici Romans. P.O. Box 5-42.050711 Ducure ti. Romania. Sold and distributed in North. Central and South America by Kluwer Academic Publishers, 101 Philip Drive. Nor well. MA 02061. U.S.A.
In all other countries. except for Romania and the Republic of Moldavia, sold and distributed by Kluwer Academic Publishers, P.O. Box 322. 3300 AH Dordrecht. The Netherlands.
In Romania and Republic of Moldavia sold and distributed by Editura Academici Rom5nc. P.O. Box 5-42.050711 tiucuresti. Rominia.
1'rintrrl an "id -free paper
All Rights Reserved 0 2003 Kluwer Academic Publishers and Editura Academiei Rorn inc
No part of this work may be reproduced. stored in a retrieval system. or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying. microfilming. recording or otherwise, without written permission from the Publisher, with the exception of any material supplied specifically for the purpose of being entered and executed an a computer system. for exclusive use by the purchaser of the work. Printed in Romania
Table of Contents xiii
Preface
I The Equations of Ideal Fluids
..
. ...................... .... ................. .
The Equations of Motion 1.1.1 Elements of Kinematics 1.1.2 The Equations of Motion ... 1.2 The 1.2.1 Helmholtz's equation. Bernoulli's integral 1.1
.
.
... .... .........
Potential Flow .............................
1.2.2 1.2.3
The Linear Theory .........................
I 1
3 5
5
6 8
... .......... .. ..... The Shock Waves Theory ............ ............. 1.3.1
The Jump Equations ........................
11 11
ilugoniot's Equation
13 15 16 17 19
1.2.4
1.3
............
The Equation of the Potential ...................
1
1.3.2 1.3.3 1.3.4 1.3.5 1.3.6
The Acceleration Potential
. ..
. . .
. .
. ..
.
. . . . . .
.
. .
.
.
.
The Solution of the .lump Equations ..............
.
Prandtl's Formula ....................... .. The Shock Polar .......................... The Compression Shock past a Concave Bend
..........
9
2 The Equations of Linear Aerodynamics and its Fundamental Solutions 21 2.1
2.2
21 21
2.1.2 2.1.3 2.1.4 2.1.5 2.1.6
22 24
26 28 29 30
The Steady Solutions ....................... 30
.... ... ................. 34 ............ ... The Fundamental Solutions for the Fluid at Rest ........ On the Interpretation of the Fundamental Solution ....... The Fundamental Solutions of the Steady System ............ 2.2.2 2.2.3 2.2.4 2.2.5 2.2.6 2.2.7
2.4
. ......... The Equation of the Potential ..... ... ........... .. ............ . The Linear System ...... The Uniform Motion in the Fluid at Rest ..... ... ... . The Equations of Motion ........ ... The Equations of Linear Aerodynamics .............
The Fundamental Solutions of the Equation of the Potential ...... 2.2.1
2.3
................. . .........
The Equations of Linear Aerodynamics 2.1.1 The Fundamental Problem of Aerodynamics
Oscillatory Solutions ...... ...........
Oscillatory Solutions for Al = 1 The Unsteady Solutions . . . . . The Unsteady Solutions for At = I .
.
. .
. .
. .
.
32
. .
.
. . .
.
.
41
42 43
2.3.1
The Significance of the Fundamental Solution
2.3.2 2.3.3 2.3.4 2.3.5 2.3.6
The General Form of the Fundeunental Solution .........
2.4.2 2.4.3
.
. .
.
. . .
. .
.
. ........... ...........
44 44
..... ....
45 46 47 48 48 50
The Determination of the Velocity Field .............
51
Other Fortes of the Components V and W
53
The Subsonic Plane Solution .... .... The Three-Dimensional Subsonic Solution The TwoDimensional Supersonic Solution
.
.
. . .
. .
. .
.
.
The Three-Dimensional Supersonic Solution ...........
The Fundamental Solutions of the Oscillatory System 2.4.1
36
The Determination of Pressure ... ... ............ 50
..
.
... ....
vi
2.4.4 2.4.5
2.5
The Fundamental Solutions in the Case Af = I ......... Fundamental Solutions of the Unsteady System I .......... ..
55 57 57 58
.. Cauchy's Problem ........ ............ . .. .. The Perturbation Produced by a Mobile Source ... . ..... Fundamental Solutions of the Unsteady System If .. ... ..... 2.5.1
2.5.2 2.3.3 2.3.4 2.6
The Incompressible Fluid ..................... 55 Fundamental Solutions . Fundamental Matrices .
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
. .. .
. . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
.
61
62 64 64 66
.
2.6.1
2.6.2
The Fundamental Matrices .. ............. ..... The Method of the Minimal Polynomial .... .... ... ..
3 The Infinite Span Airfoil In Subsonic Flow 3.1
3.1.2 3.1.3 3.1.4 3.1.5 3.1.6 3.1.7 3.1.8 3.1.9
3.2
3.3
69
. ...... . .... ... ... .. ... .... .... .. A Classical Method ........................ The Fundamental Solutions Method . ....... ... .. ..
The Airfoil in the Unlimited Fluid 3.1.1 The Statement of the Problem
.
.
69 69 70
.
.
The Function f (z). The Complex Velocity in the Fluid The Calculation of the Aerodynamic Action . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
72 75 76
.
. .
.. .................... .
77 Examples ........ . The General Case ......................... 80 Numerical Integrations ... ...... .............. 81 .
The Integration of the Thin Airfoil Equation with the Aid of Gauss-type Quadrature Formulas . ...
. ....... .....
81
The Airfoil in Ground Effects ....................... 82 3.2.1 The Integral Equation .. ..... ....... .... ..... 82 3.2.2 A Numerical Method .................. . ... .. 85 3.2.3 The Flat Plate ........................... 85 3.2.4 The Symmetric Airfoil .. ..................... 86 The Airfoil in Tunnel Effects .. ... . .... ... . ......... 88 . . .. . 88 3.3.1 The Integral Equation . .. 90 3.3.2 The Integration of the Equation (3.3.9) .
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
91
. .
.. .... ... . ......
The Numerical Integration .............. ......
92 92 95
The Integral Equation ................. ......
97
.
.
.
.
.
.
. . .
.
.
.
. . .
Numerical Results . . . . . . . . . . 3.4 Airfoils Parallel to the Undisturbed Stream 3.4.1 The Integral Equations . . 3.3.3
.. ..
.
.
.
.
.
. ... .
. .
. .
.
.
.
.
. .
. .
.
.
.............................. 97
3.4.2 3.5 Grids of Profiles 3.5.1 3.5.2 The Numerical Integration 3.6 Airfoils in Tandem . . . . . . .
... .. .................. 100 . . .... . ................
.
3.6.1 3.6.2 3.6.3
3.6.4
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
The Integral Equations The Determination of the Functions f, and ff
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
101
.
101
.. .... .. 103
. ....... ..... 104 ................. .........
The Lift and Moment Coefficients Numerical Values
.
.
.
105
4 The Application of the Boundary Element Method to the Theory of the Infinite Span Airfoil In Subsonic Flow 4.1
109
... . .... ... .............. 109 .. ... ... . .......... ....... 109 .. . ............ .. 110
The Equations of Motion 4.1.1 Introduction 4.1.2 The Statement of the Problem .
4.1.3
.
.
The Fundamental Solutions .. ..
. ............... 112
vii 4.2
Indirect Methods for the t idimited Fluid Case ............. 113 4.2.1
The integral equation for the Distribution of Sources ...... 113
4.2.2
The Integral Equation for the Distribution of Vortices
4.2.3 4.2.4 4.2.5 4.2.6 4.3
4.4
The Determination of the Unknowns .............. . The Circular Obstacle
. .
.
.
.
.
. . .
.
. . .
. . .
.
. . .
.
.
.
115 115 117 120
The Elliptical Obstacle ...................... 121
4.3.1 4.3.2 4.3.3 4.3.4 4.3.5
The representation of the solution ............... .
122
. .................... ....
125
4.3.6 4.3.7 4.3.8
Appendix ...... ................... ... .. 129
The Integral Equation ............. ... .. .... 123 .
The Circulation ..
The Discretization of the Equations ............... 126
The Lifting Profile ......................... 126 The Local Pressure Coefficient .................. 128
Numerical Determinations ................. ..
. .................... .. The Representation of the Solution . ............. .. 131 131 131
.
.
The Airfoil in Ground Effects 4.4.2 4.4.3 4.4.4 1.4.5
The Integral Equation .................. .. .. 134 The Computer Implementation ... .......... ..... 135 . 136 .. The Treatment of the Method . .. .
.
.
.
. . .
.
.
. .
.
.
.
The Circular Obstacle in a Compressible Fluid ......... 137
.. .... . ... ................ . .. 138
.1.4.6
Appendix
4.5.1
The Representation of the Solution ............. ..
.
The Airfoil in Tunnel Effects .... ................ ... 140 4.5.2 4.5.3 4.5.4 4.5.5
4.6
.. ....................... .... .
The Direct Method for the Unlimited Fluid Case ............ 122
4.4.1
4.5
.
The Boundary Elements Method ................ .
The Integral Equation ................ ....... 144
The Verification of the Method ...... ... ......... 146
Appendix ...... ................... ..... 149
Other Methods. The Intrinsic Integral Equation .......... . 4.6.1
140
.
Green Functions ...... ......... ........... 142 150
.
The Method of Regularization .................. 150
5 The Theory of Finite Span Airfoil in Subsonic Flow. The Lifting Surface Theory 5.1
The Lifting Surface Equation 5.1.1
5.1.2 5.1.3 5.1.4
155
.
... ... ............. .. 155 .
The Statement of the Problem .................. 155 Bibliographical Comments ..................... 158
The General Solution ................ ... .. .. 159 The Boundary Values of the Pressure ... ........... 161 .. 163 .The U.S Boundary Values of the Component w . . .
.
.
. ... .. .. .
. . .
.
.
.
x.1.6
The Integral Equation
=..1.7 .5.1.8
The Plane Problem ....... ..... .. ... ... ...
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
. .
164
Other Forms of the Integral Equation .............. 166
5.1.9 The Aerodynamic Action in the First Approximation
. .
.
.
. .
.
168 169
5.1.10 A More Accurate Calculation ................... 171 5.2
5.1.11 Another Deduction of the Representation of the General Solution 173 Methods for the Numerical Integration of the Lifting Surface Equation 175 5.2.1 5.2.2
The General Theory ........................ 175 Multhopp's Method ............. ........... 178
Viii
5.3
5.4
.. 179 180 The Third Method ......................... 181
5.2.3
The Quadratum Formulas Method
5.2.4 5.2.5
The Aerodynamic Action ... .. .
. . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.............. 184 . ...................... 184
Ground Effects in the Lifting Surface Theory 5.3.1
The General Solution
5.3.2
The Integral Equation
5.3.3
The Two-Dimensional Problem .... .... ....... ... 188
.
.
The Wing of Low Aspect Ratio
.
. .
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
.
.
. ..
.
..
.
.
. .
.
189
. .
193
.
5.4.2
The Integral Equation ......... ........ ... .. 189 The Case h = h(x) .......... . .. ... .... ... 192
5.4.3
The General Case
5.4.1
.
.
. .
.
.
. .
.
. ..
.
.
. . . .
. .
.
.
.
.
.
6 The Lifting Line Theory 6.1
186
19T
Prandtl's Theory .............................. 197 6.1.1 The Lifting Line Hypotheses. The Velocity Field . ...... 197 6.1.2 Prandtl's Equation . .. ..... .............. 200 6.1.3 The Aerodynamic Action ...... ........ . ...... 202 .
.
.
.
...................... 203
6.1.4 The Elliptical Flat Plate 6.2 The Theory of Integration of Prandtl's Equation. The Reduction to
Fredholm-Type Integral Equations ....... ..... ........ 205
6.2.2
The Equation of Trefftz and Schmidt ............... 205 Existence and Uniqueness Theorems ............... 209
6.2.3
Foundation of Glauert's Method
6.2.4 6.2.5
The Minimal Drag Airfoil
6.2.1
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
210
Glauert's Approximation ..................... 212
..... .. .............. 212
6.3 The Symmetrical Wing. Vekuas Equation. A Larger Class of Exact Solutions
... ....... .... . ... .. . ............. 214 The Integral Equation ....... .. . ... .......... 215
6.3.1
Symmetry Properties ........................ 214
6.3.2 6.3.3
Vekua's Equation
......................... .
217
The Elliptical Wing ........................ 220 6.3.5 The Rectangular Wing . . . 221 6.3.6 Extensions .................. . ...... ... 222 Numerical Methods . .. . 223 6.4.1 Multhopp's Method ........................ 223 6.4.2 The Quadrature Formulas Method .. ... .. .. ...... 228 6.3.4
.
.
.
. .
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
. . .
.
.
6.4
.
. . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.. ... ................. 231 Various Extensions of the Lifting Line Theory .............. 234 6.5.1 The Equation of Weissinger and Reissner .. .......... 234 6.5.2 Weissinger's Equation. The Rectangular Wing ......... 236 The Lifting Line Theory in Ground Effects .. ... .. 2.18 .
6.5
6.6
6.4.3
The Collocation Method
6.6.1
The Integral Equation .......... ...... ....... 238 The Elliptical Flat Plate ...................... 240
6.6.2 6.6.3 6.7
Numerical Solutions in the General Case
............. 241
The Curved Lifting Line ................ 6.7.1
6.7.2 6.7.3
The Pressure and Velocity Fields The Integral Equation . . . .
.... ...... 242
................. 242 . ..
.. . .. 246 The Numerical Method .... . ................. 247 . . . .
. . . .
.
. .
ix
7 The Application of the Boundary Integral Equations Method to the 251 Theory of the Three-Dimensional Airfoil In Subsonic Flow 7.1 The First Indirect Method (Sources Distributions) ........... 251 7.1.1 7.1.2 7.1.3 7.1.4 7.1.5
7.1.6 7.1.7 7.1.8 7.2
The Integral Equation The Integral Equation
. ................. . ... . . .... .............. 253 253
.
.
.
.
The Discretixation of the Integral Equation ........... 255 The Singular Integrals
. ... ................. .. 258
The Velocity Field. The Validation of the Method ....... 258
The Incompressible Fluid. An Exact Solution .......... 259
..
. . . . . . . . . 263 The Expression of the Potential . . The Second Indirect Method (Doublet Distributions). The Incompress.
.
.
.
.
ible Fluid .................................. 265 7.2.1 7.2.2 7.2.3 7.2.4
7.3
The General Equations ... . .................. 251
The Integral Equation ..... ... ............. .. 265 The Flow past the Sphere. The Exact Solution ......... 267
The Velocity Field ......................... 268 The Velocity Field on the Body. N. Marcov's Formula ..... 268
The Direct Method. The Incompressible Fluid ............. 271 7.3.1 The Integral Representation Formula ........ .. ..... 271 7.3.2 7.3.3 7.3.4 7.3.5
..... . ................ .. ..................... ... 275
The Integral Equation Kutta's Condition
274
The Lifting Flow .......................... 276
The Discretization of the Integral Equation ........... 279
8 The Supersonic Steady Flow 8.1
8.1.1
8.1.2 8.1.3 8.1.4 8.1.5 8.1.6 8.2
283
The Thin Airfoil of Infinite Span .. ................ ... 283
The Analytical Solution ...................... 283
The Fundamental Solutions Method ....... .... .... 286 The Aerodynamic. Action
287
.
. .
.
.
. . .
.
.
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
The Graphical Method ....................... 289 The Theory of Polygonal Profiles ................. 290 .. 294 Validity Conditions . Ground and Tunnel Effects .. .. .................. .. 295 8.2.1 The General Solution ............... .... .... 295 298 8.2.2 The Aerodynamic Coefficients ................. . The Three-Dimensional Wing .............. ... ... .. 300 .
.
.
.
.
8.3
.
8.3.1
Subsonic and Supersonic Edges ..... ............ .
8.3.2 8.3.3 8.3.4 8.3.5 8.3.6 8.3.7 8.3.8 8.3.9
The Representation of the General Solution ........... 302 The Influence Zones. The Domain Di ....... .. ..... 304 The Boundary Values of the Pressure ........... . .. 305 The First Form of the Integral Equation .
. .
.
. .
.
.
. .
. .
.
300
306
The Equation D in Coordinates on Characteristics .... .. 308
The Plane Problem ......................... 310 The Equation of Heaslet and Lomax (the 11L Equation)
.
.
.
311
The Deduction of HL Equation from D Equation ...... 313 8.3.10 The Equation of Homentcovschi (II Equation) . .... .... 318 8.4
... .... .... 320 Abel's Equation .......................... 320
The Theory of Integration of the H Equation .. 8.4.1
8.4.2
.
The Solution of the H Equation in the Domain of Influence
of the Supersonic Trailing Edge ...... ........ ... .
321
X
8.4.3
The Solution in the Domains of Influence of the Subsonic Lead-
ing Edge .......................... .. ... 323
The Wing with Dependent Subsonic Leading Edges and Independent Subsonic Trailing Edges . . . . . . . . . 324 8.4.5 The Wing with Dependent Subsonic Trailing Edges . .. ... 326 8.4.6 The Solution in the Zone of Influence of the Subsonic Edges under the Hypothesis that the Subsonic Leading Edges are letdependent . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 327 8.4.7 The Wing with Dependent Subsonic Trailing Edges . . . . . . 337 8.4.4
.
.
8.5
.
.
.
.
.
The Theory of Conical Nloticaas ...... ...... .......... Introduction ............... .. ... .. ... . 8.5.1
339
8.5.2 8.5.3
340
.
8.5.4 8.6
.
The Wing with Supersonic Leading Edges ..... ....... The Wing With a Supersonic Leading FAlge and with Another
Subsonic Leading or Trailing Edge .. .... . ...... ... The Wing with Subsonic Leading Edges .... .........
Flat Wings ... .
... .. .. .... .... ... ...... .. ...
The Trapezoidal Wing with Subsonic Lateral Edges ...... 352 The Trapezoidal Wing with Lateral Supersonic Edges ..... 355
The Triangular Wing. The Calculation of the Aerodynamic Action . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 349 .
.
.
.
The Equations of the Transonic Flow .......... .... ... ..
359 :3.59
.. . .... .. .. 359
9.1.1
The Presence of the Transonic Flow ....
9.1.2
The Equation of the Potential .. ... .... .... . ..... 361 The System of 'transonic Flow . ... . ....... . ... .. 364 The Shock Equations
.
.
.
..
.
.
.. ......... ... .. 368
The Plane Flow ..... ............... . .......... 369 .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.. .369
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
..
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
9.2.2
The Fundamental Solution The General Solution . .
9.2.3 9.2.4 9.2.5
The Lift Coefficient The Symmetric Wing The Solution in Real .
9.2.6
The Symmetric Wing
9.:3.1
The Fundamental Solution .......... . .. .... ... .M1 The Study of the Singular Integrals ........ ....... 386
9.2.1
.
.
.
.
.
. ..
371
376 376 377
. .. .. ......... ......... .. .. 380 The Thre"Dimensional Flow ... ..... . ......... ..... 383 9.3.2 9.3.3 9.3.4
9.4
347
8.6.3 8.6.4
9.1.3 9.1.4
9.3
:343
The Angular Wing with Supersonic Leading Edges .... ... 347
9 The Steady Transonic Flow
9.2
342
8.6.1 8.6.2
.
9.1
:339
.
.
.
... ... ... . ....... ..... 387 .......... :389 The Lifting Line Theory .. ... ........ .. .......... 392 The General Solution
.
Flows with Shock Waves .. ...... .. .. .
9.4.1
9.4.2
The Velocity Field ......................... :392 The Integral Equations ......... . .. .. 394 . .
.
.
. .
.
.
10 The Unsteady Flow
397
... ... . .... . .. 397 10.1.1 The Statement of the Problem ..... . .. .... .... .. 397 10.1.2 The Fundamental Solution ..... . ............ .. 397
10.1 The Oscillatory Profile in a Subsonic Stream
10.1.3 The Integral Equation
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
. .
. .
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.ie.19
10.1.4 Considerations on the Kernel ..... ....... .. ..... 402
xi
...... 404
10.2 The Oscillatory Surface in a Subsonic Strewn .....
10.2.1 The General Solution ............ ......... . 404 10.2.2 The Integral Equation ....................... 405 .
10.2.3 Other Expressions of the Kernel Function ......... .
.
10.2.4 The Structure of the Kernel .
.
10.2.5 The Sonic Flow ........
. .
. .
.
. . .
.
.
409 412
. .................. 413 .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
10.2.6 The Plane Flow ........ . .................. 414
10.3 The Theory of the Oscillatory Profile in a Supersonic Stream ..... 415 10.3.1 The General Solution 10.3.2
.
. .
.
.
.
.
. ..... .
.
.
.
. . .
.
. .
The Integral Equation and its Solution ....... .......
10.3,3 Formulas for the Lift and Moment Coefficients
10.3.4 The Flat Plate .............. .
. . . .
. ..
. .......... .
.
415 418 421
423 424
.. .......... 10.4 The Theory of the Oscillatory Wing in a Supersonic Stream ...... 426 .
10.3.5 The Oscillatory Profile in the Sonic Flow
10.4.1 The General Solution ............ .... ... . ... 426
10.4.2 The Boundary Values of the Pressure .............. 428 10.4.3 The Boundary Values of the Velocity, The Integral Equation
.
430
10.4.4 Other Expressions of the Kernel ................. 433
. ....... ............ . ....... 435
10.4.5 A New Form 10.4.6 The Plane Problem . . . . . . 10.5 The Oscillatory Profile in a Sonic Stream
.. .. .... .
.
.
. .
.
.
. .
436
.. .......... .... 438 .
.
10.5.1 The General Solution. The Integral Equation .. ........ 438 10.5.2 Some Formulas for the Lift and Moment Coefficients
.
.
.
.
. .
441
10.6 The Three-Dimensional Sonic Flow .................... 442
.. .. .. 442 .. .................. 443 10.6.3 The Plane Problem ......................... 446 10.6.4 Other Forms of the Kernel . .. . ... . 447 10.6.1 The General Solution
. .
.
. .
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
.
.
11 The Theory of Slender Bodies 11.1 The Linear Equations and Their Fundamental Solutions ..... ..
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
10.6.2 The Integral Equation ...
.
. . .
. .
11.1.1 The Boundary Condition. The Linear Equations ... 11.1.2 Fundamental Solutions .
.
449 449
. .... 449
... .... ........ . .... .
11.2 The Slender Body in a Subsonic Stream ... ............. .
452 454
. ... . ...... ........ 454
11.2.1 The Solution of the Problem
11.2.2 The Calculus of Lift and Moment Coefficients .....
..... 456
11.3 The Thin Body in a Supersonic Stream ................. 458
11.3.1 The General Solution ..... .................. 458 11.3.2 The Pressure on the Body. The Lift and Moment
. ............... 461 . ... .. ........ . ........... .. 463
Coefficients .............
11.3.3 The wing at zero angle of attack .... ............. 463 11.3.4 Applications
A Fourier Transform and Notions of the Theory of Distributions
465
.. ............... .. 465
A,1 The Fourier Transform of Functions
A.2 The Spaces V and S .. ................... .... .. 466 A.3 Distributions
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
467
A.4 The Convolution. Fundamental Solutions ................ 470
A.5 The Fourier Transform of the Functions from S ............ 472 A.6 The Fourier Transform of the Temperate Distributions ......... 473
xii
............ 475 .............. 478
A.7 The Calculus of Some Inverse Fourier Transforms A.8 The Fourier Transform in Bounded Domains
B Cauchy-type Integrals. Dirichlet's Problem for the Half-Plane. The Calculus of Some Integrals 481
Cauchy-type Integrals ........................... 481 .................. 482 B.3 Plemelj's Formulas ............................. 483 B.l B.2 The Principal Value in Cauchy's Sense
................ 483 ........ 485
B.4 The Dirichlet's Problem for the Half-Plane B.5 The Calculus of Certain Integrals in the Complex Plane B.6 Glauert's Integral. Its Generalization and Some
Applications ................................. 489
B.7 Other Integrals
............................... 491
C Singular Integral Equations C. i
493
The Thin Profile Equation ......................... 493
C.2 The Generalized Equation of Thin Profiles
................ 496
C.3 The Third Equation ............................ 498 C.4 The Forth Equation ............................ 502 C.5 The Fifth Equation ............................. 504 D The Finite Part
509
D.1 Introductory Notions ............................ 509
............................. 509 ................ 510
D.2 The First Integral D.3 Integrals with Singularities in an interval
D.4 Hadamard-Type Integrals ......................... 513
D.5 Generalization ............................... 515 E Singular Multiple Integrals
517
F Gauss-Type Quadrature Formulas
521 ............................. 521 F.2 Formulas of Interest in Aerodynamics .................. 525 F.3 The Modified Monegato's Formula .................... 529 FA A Useful Formula .............................. 530 F.1 General Theorems
Bibliography
533
Index
571
Preface
The researchers in Aerodynamics know that there is not a unitary method
of investigation in this field. The first mathematical model of the airplane wing, the model meaning the integral equation governing the phenomenon, was proposed by L. Prandtl in 1918. The integral equation deduced by Prandtl, on the basis of some assumptions which will be specified in the sequel, furnishes the circulation C(y) (see Chapter 6). Using the circulation, one calculates the lift and moment coefficients, which are very important in Aerodynamics. The first hypothesis made by Prandtl consists in replacing the wing by a distribution of vortices on the plan-form D of the wing (i.e. the projection of the wing on the plane determined by the direction of the uniform stream at infinity and the direction of the span of the wing). Since such a distribution leads to a potential flow in the exterior of D and the experiences show that downstream the flow has not this character, Prandtl introduces as a supplementary hypothesis another vortices distribution on the trace of the domain D in the uniform stream. The first kind of vortices are called tied vortices and the second kind of vortices are called free vortices. On the basis of this model one developed later the main theories of Aerodynamics namely the lifting surface theory (after 1936, more precisely in 1950, when Multhopp gave the equation of this theory), the lifting surface theory for the supersonic flow (after 1946) and the lifting theory for oscillatory wings and surfaces for the subsonic, sonic and supersonic flow (after 1950). In the framework of the last theory the wing is replaced by doublets distributions. From a physical point of view, there is no reason for replacing the wing with vortices or doublets distributions. It is true that the vortices are detaching from the wing, but these are effects , not causes of the presence of the wing. The fact that these replacements lead to correct results shows how subtle was Prandtl's in-
tuition. We specify that the distributions on D and its trace do not result from the equations of motion (they have been introduced outside the mathematical model). Taking into account this inconvenient, we have shown in (5.7) how it can be removed. We have to consider that the wing and the fluid constitute an interacting material system. If we want to study the fluid flow, then according to Cauchy's stress principle
xiv
(the principle of the internal forces; see for example [1.11), p.35), we have to assume that there exists it forces distribution on the boundary, which has against the fluid the same action like the wing itself. We shall replace therefore the wing with it forces distribution instead of a vortices, sources or doublets distribution and we shall find out the density of this distribution such that it should have the same action against the fluid like the wing itself. We shall proceed by imposing to the fluid flow determined by the forces distribution to satisfy the slipping condition on the wing, condition which is also satisfied by the flow determined by the wing. In this way it follows an integral equation for determining the forces density. This equation constitutes the mathematical model for the wing we have in view. This method is an unitary one and it is based only on the classical principles of mechanics (in fact. Cauchy's stress principle). It may be applied to all configurations: see [5.7) for the wing in a subsonic stream, [8.4] for the wing in a supersonic stream, [10.15], [10.16], [10.17) for the oscillatory wings in subsonic, sonic or supersonic stream etc. All these results are given in this book (see chapters 5, 8, 10, 11). We called this method (in[5.7)): the fundamental solutions method. It may be utilized to all cases in which one can calculate the fundamental solutions of the equations of motion. We have to notice that in the framework of this method, the existence of the vortices downstream the wing follows from the model (i.e. from the equations of motion) and it must not be introduced artificially. In the sequel we shall present some of the models of aerodynamics. For two-dimensional configurations, in a subsonic stream, the models are one-dimensional singular integral equations considered in the sense of Cauchy's principal value. One may integrate analytically only the equation of thin profiles in a free stream. For other geometries one determines numerical solutions with the aid of Gauss-type quadrature formulas (see Chapter 3). For three-dimensional wings in a subsonic stream, the models are two-dimensional integral equations with strong singularities, which are defined in the sense of Finite Part (see Chapter 5). For other geometry (for example the wing in ground effects) the models are generalized equations. All these models are solved only numerically. For the wing in it free stream, Multhopp's method is available. In this book we introdace a more general method - the quadrature formulas method. In the last part of Chapter 5 one presents the theory of low aspect wings which was extended by the author to the general case of asymmetrical wings. The lifting line theory may be deduced from the lifting surface theory with the aid of Prandtl's assumptions (6). This theory is developed
xv
by presenting analytical and numerical methods for solving Prandtl's equation; one considers also extensions of this theory, all the methods representing one-dimensional integral-differential equations. The author shows how these equations may be reduced to integral equations with strong singularities and for this type of singularities he gives a Gausstype quadrature formula, which allows the equation to be reduced to a linear algebraic system which is solved numerically. This method, which is very general. allows to obtain numerical solutions both in the case of the lifting line (Chapter 6) and the case of the lifting surface (Chapter 5). In the case of supersonic flow, the integral equations are solved analytically. For the three-dimensional wing (the lifting surface) we present in Chapter 8 a nice solution given by D. Homentcovschi in 18.16]. The integral equations describing the flow past oscillatory wings and profiles (chapter 10) have the same nature like the equations utilized in the case of steady flow but the kernels are more complicated. However for the sonic and supersonic flows these equations may be solved exactly by means of the Laplace transform, as it is shown in [10.17]. Chapter 9, devoted to the transonic motions. begins with a new asymptotic deduction of the equations of motion. The two and three-dimensional integral equations are obtained following the papers of the author and D. Homentcovschi. The theory of subsonic and supersonic flow past slender bodies (in Chapter 11) relies also on the fundamental solutions theory. In Chapter 2 one deduces the equations of the linear aerodynamics, on the basis of an asymptotic analysis. assuming that the small parameter depends on the thickness of the profile. In the classical aerodynamics this deduction is performed under the assumption that the unknowns and their derivatives have the same order of magnitude, but this fact cannot he a priori assumed. Then one calculates the fundamental solutions for the equation of the potential (paper [2.11]) and the fundamental solutions for the systems of equations of aerodynamics : the steady system[2.8], the oscillatory system [10.17], the unsteady system [2.6], (2.7]. On these solutions will rely the theories from the forthcoming chapters. The models we have already presented are the so called classical or linear
models. They are suitable for the thin wings and thin profiles because they rely on the following assumptions: 1) one uses a linear boundary condition, 2) the boundary condition is imposed on the support of the wing (the segment (-1.1] for the profile, the plan-form D for the three-dimensional wing), :3) the equations of motion are linearized. The development of the scientific computing allows us to develop more exact methods. Indeed we can give up to the first two assumptions using
xvi
the boundary integral equations method (BIEM). also called the boundary element method (BEN), which was employed for the first time by Hess and Smith [7.9], [7.10]. The integral equations on the boundary are obtained imposing the exact boundary condition on the boundary of the wing. The integral equation is discretize d using, for example, the collocation method. One obtains an algebraic system which is solved numerically. The linearization of the equations of motion is necessary only in the case of compressible fluids. The theory that we have developed is thus valid for every body in an incompressible fluid and for at thin body in a compressible fluid. Two chapters from this book, Chapter 4 for the 2d airfoil and Chapter 7 for the 3d airfoil are baLsed on our papers (L. Drago.1 and A. Dinu). The comparison between the known analytical results and the numerical results shows a very good agreement. In the Appendices we give some results concerning The Distributions Theory, The Singular Integral Equations Theory, The Principal value and The Finite Part, Gauss-type Quadrature Formulas, etc. In every work one finds, in a certain measure, both the achievements
of the predecessors and of the researchers contemporaneous with the author. Among the people which have directly collaborated with tae, I have to mention at first my professors Victor Va lcovici and Caius lacob, who introduced me in the field of aerodynamics. I also mention my younger colleagues Nicolae Marcov, Liviu Dint, Dorel Homentcovschi, Adrian Carabineanu, Victor Tigoiu, Vladimir Cardoi, Gabriela Marinoschi, Stelian Ion and Adrian Dinu. They were my students at the University of Bucharest, but I learned a lot from their papers. Some of them were my fellow - workers in the aerodynamics research, many of them stimulated me with their youth and their way of thinking in our seminars from the Faculty of Mathematics of the University of Bucharest. I am very grateful to all of them. My special gratitude goes to Adrian Carabineanu for his work in performing the English translation of the book, to Adrian Carabineanu and Stelian Ion for typesetting the monograph in Latex and to Victor 'igoiu for his activity in finalizing the 195D Grant with the World Bank. I acknowledge that the hook was sponsored by MEC-CNCSIS Contract 49113/2000, Grant 195D with World Bank. LAZAR DRACOS
Chapter 1 The Equations of Ideal Fluids
1.1 1.1.1
The Equations of Motion Elements of Kinematics
In this Chapter we present the equations governing the flow of ideal fluids. On the basis of these equations we shall develop the theory in the forthcoming chapters of the book. It is well known (see, for exannple, [1.11J), that the fluid flow is defined by the di eomorphism
x = X(t, X),
(1.1.1)
where X is the vector of position of a particle P in the reference configuration (for fluids this is the initial configuration), and x is the vector of position of the same particle at the moment t. For a fixed X and a variable t , the equation (1.1.1) furnishes the motion law for the particle having the vector of position X. Hence the velocity and the acceleration of the particle will be given by the formulas
v (t, X =
It X (t, X ),
a (t, X =
cit.
v (t, X).
(1.1.2)
The fluid is a continuum medium. It means that the support of the initial configuration is it domain Do. The image of this domain by the diffeomorphism (1.1.1) will be denoted by D and one demonstrates [1.11J that it is a domain. The functions X;(t, Xi, X2i X3) appearing in (1.1.1) belong to the class C2(D0) and the Jacobian is 0(X1, X2, Xa)
V(XI, X2, X3)
# (}
(1.1.3)
The velocity field defined in (1.1.2) may be discontinuous in isolated points, on abstract. curves or across abstract surfaces. This kind of surfaces will be named shock waves.
THE EQUATIONS OF IDEAL FLUIDS
2
The fluid flow may be described by functions defined on Do, i.e. functions having the form 46(t, X) , or by functions defined on D, i.e. functions having the form F(t, x). The first presentation is called the material description, because it utilizes quantities attached to the material particles, the second is called the spatial description, because it furnishes information about the particles which are located at the
moment t in the points of a domain D. The material derivative of the quantity 0 attached to the fixed and it is given by the formula particle X, is denoted by 46(t, X).
(1.1.4)
In order to obtain the derivative of F when X is fixed, we have to take into account that F depends on the coordinates X, through the functions Y{. Using the derivation rule for the composite functions, we obtain for the material derivative OF OF d X; OF OF OF +(v V)F. (1.1.5) F(t' x) dt + as d t +V'r7x; t For studying the motion of fluids we employ the spatial description. The main quantities are: the density (or specific mass) p(t, x ), the pres-
,
T.
sure p(t. x ), the velocity field v (t, x ), the temperature T(t, x ), the entropy s(t, x) etc. The acceleration which is the material derivative of the velocity is obtained by means of the formula:
a = at + (v 0)v .
(1.1.6)
Utilizing the derivation rule for the determinants, from (1.1.3) one obtains Eider's theorem
J = J div v
(1.1.7)
and then (see for example [1.11]) Reynolds's formulas for continuous inotions (i. e. motions characterized by fields belonging to the class) C1((to,tII X DWff
dtJDF(t,x)dv= r
-
1
ID
(F'+Fdivv)dv= r
(
1.1.8)
BtF dv+ / DFv nda
fD [OF + div(Fv)J dv =
JD and Reynolds's formula for motions with shock waves
dtI
F(t,x)dv= J_a_dv.f-J
E++E_
F v neda-J fFlld da, s
( 1.1.9)
3
THE EQUATIONS OF MOTION
- F_, and d is the displacement velocity of the surface of discontinuity S (see formula (2.5.1) and figure 2.5.1 from where OFJ = F.,. (1.110.
The Equations of Motion
1.1.2
The principle of conservation of mass is d
dt,Dpdv=O (V)DCD.
(1.1.10)
For continuous motions one utilizes the formula (1.1.8) and one obtains the equation of continuity
p+pdivv =0.
(1.1.11)
The general expression for the principle of variation of the momenturn is t L"= dPwdv
-jDpnda+ JDpf dv (V)DCD,
(1.1.12)
f representing the force per unity of mass. For continuous motions, from (1.1.11) and (1.1.6), one obtains Euler's equation p[
+ (v V) v] =pf -grade-
(1.1.13)
The balance equation of the energy (the first principle of the thermodynamics) is
j
( aD JOD
+ /Dpf - vda- /D q nda (V)DCD,
(1.1.14)
e representing the specific internal energy, and q, the flux of heat vector. For continuous motions, taking into account (1.1.11) and (1.1.13), we deduce
Pe = -pdiv v - div q . (1.1.15) In ideal fluids the processes are reversible. Eliminating div v by the aid of equation (2.1.11) and employing the second principle of thermodynamics (1.11], p.54, one obtains the fundamental equation of thermodynamics
de=Tds - pdv,
(1.1.16)
THE EQUATIONS OF IDEAL FLUIDS
4
where s is the specific entropy and v is a notation for 1/p. Eliminating div v from (1.1.15) and taking into account (1.1.16), we deduce the following remarkable form of the equation of energy
pTs= - divq.
(1.1.17)
This shows that if it is possible to neglect the change of heat (it is the case of aerodynamics where the velocities are great), then
s = 0.
(1.1.18)
The equation (1.1.18) indicates that s is constant on trajectories, the constant varying from one trajectory to the other. One calls such a motion isentropic motion.. If there exists a configuration where the entropy constant is the same everywhere, then in every configuration arising from the first one, the constant will be the same everywhere. Such a motion is called homentropic or isentinpic everywhere. The perfect gas is characterized by the following equations of state
p=pRT,
(1.1.19)
The first one (which is obtained from the laws of Boyle-Mariotte and Gay-Lussac) is the thcrmic equation (or Clapeyron's equation) and the second is the caloric equation. It is easy to prove (see for example [1.11) p. 57-58) that for this gas we have
p }+Co, e= P7 //J
1
-+C1.
-Y-1p
(1.1.20)
c, being the so called specific heat at constant volume and y = cp jc where cP is the specific heat at constant pressure. For the air 7 = 1.405. From the expression of a it follows for the homentropic motion:
p = kp'',
(1.1.21)
k representing a constant. The quantity c, defined by the formula
=
(dp/
'
(1.1.22)
has the dimension of a velocity. One shows (see for example [1.10)) that it gives just the speed of propagation of the surfaces of discontinuity of the pressure (sound waves). For the ideal gas in homentropic motion it follows c2
= 7plp.
(1.1.23)
5
THE POTENTIAL FLOW
The Potential Flow
1.2 1.2.1
Helmholtz's equation. Bernoulli's Integral
If the tnassic forces possess a potential f = grad II (in aerodynamics these ford (representing the weight of the air) are neglected) and if the fluid is characterized by a thermodynamic law having the form p = p(p), where p is a derivable function, defined for p > 0 such that ;7(p) > 0, then we deduce
f- Igrad p= grad
II -1 pp)
Utilizing the identity (v V) v = curl v x v + grad (v 2/2), Euler's equation (1.1.13) becomes
/ f +curlvxv=grad(n-1 dp-2v2). jt P \\
(1.2.1)
This is Hetnahoftss equation.
The flow of a fluid is irrotational in a domain D if everywhere in D. we have curl v = 0. This equation constitutes the necessary and sufficient condition for the existence of a differentiable function jp(x, x), such that
v=grad 44.
(1.2.2)
Such a flow is called potential. Applying the operator curl in (1.2.1), we eliminate the term in the right hand side of the equation. The resulting equation is integrated [1.11] as follows 0
P
(.VX) =
X(t,X),
(1.2.3)
WO and m) representing the vortex (2w =- curly) and respectively the density in a reference configuration. The formula (1.2.3) shows that if the motion is potential in a configuration, it remains potential in every theorem). configuration arising from the first one
We can therefore put curl v = 0 in (1.2.1). It results Bernoulli's integral
Ot+2vz+ J LP -n=C(t) 4t=8W Ot.
(1.2.4)
One may give to the spatial constant C(t) the value zero ([1.11], p.90). Neglecting the messic forces, Bernoulli's integral is
tt+2vz+
J
Pp=0.
(1.2.5)
6
THE EQUATIONS OF IDEAL FLUIDS
The motion of a fluid is stationary or steady if the velocity field does not depend explicitly on t. Nowr (1.2.4) becomes
2v2+ J ap-n=C.
(1.2.6)
P
In this case the constant cannot be zero.
For the perfect gas in homentropic motion we have the formula (1.1.21). With a convenient notation of the constant, from (1.2.6) we deduce v- + 'Y P = 7 PO = _ , (1.2.7) 2
T::_1 -P
7-lpo 7-1
pa, pn and co representing the pressure, the density and the square of the sound velocity for the fluid at rest. From (1.2.7) one deduces that in the compressible fluid there is a superior limit v of the velocity which is obtained for p = 0 and a critical value v, which is obtained for v = c. These values are VCr = Co
Vmax = Co
V7 +2
_
(1.2.8)
For v < v ., the flow is subsonic and for vrr < v < vmm, the flow is supersonic.
1.2.2
The Equation of the Potential
The equation of the potential is obtained from the equation of continuity (1.1.11), Bernoulli's integral (1.2.5) and the equation (1.1.21), assuming that v has the form (1.2.2). Calculating the material derivative of (1.2.5), we obtain: dt(5t+2tr2)+P=0.
(1.2.9)
Taking into account that p depends on t through the agency of p and utilizing the notation (1.1.22), we deduce
_± d dpP P
(Oe
+ 2v2)
(1.2.10)
Replacing in the equation of continuity, we obtain the equation of the potential
c2A -(v .V)(v -V)o -2(v V).6e-#u=0,
(1.2.11)
*r11F: POTENTIAL FLOW
where c' depends on 40. We find this dependence in the case of the perfect gas in homentropic flow. Taking into account (1.1.21), Bernoulli's integral (1.2.5) becomes v2
4+
+
)-i
{n7-t -1710-t}
= o,
(1.2.12)
representing the density in a reference state. From (1.1.21) and (1.1.22) it follows cc = kyp0-1, and from (1.2.12) we deduce:
po
1
(+v2)]7_1
=p
11 P=poll-7 1 (fit+2v2)Jy-1
(1.2.13)
,
(1.2.14)
CS
+2v2),
(1.2.15)
representing the pressure and the sound velocity in the CO reference state of density po. For the steady flow one obtains the equation
Po and
c2A4'-(v .V)(v cI)4'=0
(1.2.16)
and the formulas //
1
P=po1--y21
}
Jy-1
y P=poll-y 21V1\-V-1
,
(1.2.17)
c2 = c9
-
y-1 v2 2
(1.2.18)
where po, po and co are quantities corresponding to the fluid at rest (v = 0). One demonstrates [1.10], p. 207, that the equation (1.2.11) is hyperbolic and the equation (1.2.16) is elliptic for the subsonic flow (v2 < c'-) and hyperbolic for the supersonic flow (c2 < v2). The equality v2 = c2 occurs only on curves in the two-dimensional flow or surfaces in the case
of three-dimensional flow. These varieties are separating the domains where the flow is subsonic from the domains where the flow is supersonic. This kind of motion is called transonic. We denoted tit = I v 12.
8
THE EQUATIONS OF IDEAL FLUIDS
1.2.3
The Linear Theory
When the equations (1.2.11) and (1.2.16) are utilized in order to determine the perturbation produced by a thin body in a fluid having a known flow, they may be linearized Let us consider for example, that the uniform flow of a fluid having the velocity U,,, i, the pressure p,, and the density p,,,, is slightly perturbed by the presence of a body. We shall denote by
v = UU i + v'
(1.2.19)
the velocity field for the perturbed flow ( v' is the perturbation of the velocity field). We assume that all the coordinates of v' have the same order of magnitude a (e representing a small parameter which characterizes the body). Hence we assume that. (1.2.20)
where I- VI is bounded and e << 1. According to Lagrant o-Cauchy's theorem, the perturbed flow is potential, since it arises from a potential
flow. Hence, (3)¢, such that v = grad O and from (1.2.19), it follows
v' = grad p and -0 =U,,,r+V.
(1.2.21)
The condition (1.2.20) is equivalent to Sit) =
(Yr .
;Py, s5z) .
(1.2.22)
Replacing in the formulas above and neglecting the terms O(E2), we deduce v = (U,o + E ;5;r, E v, 63z), 2J2 = U200 + 21J. pa + 0022)
(1.2.23)
and then (1.2.24) U p7= - 2U.v*1 - pc1 = 0, (1.2.25) (1 - Af`)Vls +Wv + Vz_ = 0, where Af(= U,,,/c,,,) is Mach's number in the perturbed flow. One easily find that the equation (1.2.24) is hyperbolic, and the equation (1.2.25) is elliptic if Al < 1 and hyperbolic if Al > 1. The motions characterized by Al < I are named subsonic, and the motions with
Af > 1 arc named supersonic. The pressure is deduced from Bernoulli's integral, (1.2.5), which may be written as follows 1
2
actual
v2) 0o
+
p
f
clp
-;p
= 0.
(1.2.26)
THE POTENTIAL FLOW
9
if we neglect the massic forces. It obviously results
de+2 (v2-U2)+f dr=0,
(1.2.27)
Let us assume that the relation
p=Poo+0(e).
(1.2.28)
is also valid. Then we deduce p(p) = poo +
J
r dp
rx 1
=
I
loo (p
`poo)
dr + 1 --
J
pW JJ j 0
I
P
0(e2) = p + P c2px
pay
+ O( r2)
0(6
c?C p
2) .
poll
(1.2.29)
Replacing (1.2.21), (1.2.23) and (1.2.29) in (1.2.27), we find in the linear approximation the formula for the determination of the pressure
P - P,x = -f).G%e + U,otp,.),
(1.2.30)
Since the previous formulas will be deduced in a different manner in Chapter 2, in dimensionless variables, we are going to introduce here
these variable (x', y'. z', t'), by means of the formulas (x, y, z) = Lo(r`, y', z'),
t = (Lo/UU)t',
y: = Uaip'p - P = PoUp',
(1.2.31)
Lo representing a reference length which is not specified yet. So, the equation (1.2.22) becomes j112Vt.e. = 0.
(1.2.32)
and the formula (1.2.30). l), = - (vi. + co=.) .
1.2.4
(1.2.33)
The Acceleration Potential
Another function, often utilized in aerodynamics, is the acceleration potential ;', introduced by Prandtl. Its existence is ensured for the unlimited fluid characterized by the lawn p = p(p), by the equation
a = -brad / .11
dam'
P
(1.2.34)
TILE EQUATIONS OF IDEAI. FLUIDS
10
resulting from (1.1.6). (1.1.13) and (1.2.1). Denoting
a= grad !, ,
(1.2.35)
we get
v" = -
J
clp'
+ C(t) .
(1.2.36)
where C(t) is an arbitrary function depending on t, which can be determined Lw imposing the value of 0 for a certain state. For example, if the fluid is incompressible and one consider, that t/' vanishes at
infinity (where p = p,), it follows C = p,/p, whence (1.2.37)
V, = (P. - P)//).
Since t' represents the perturbation of the pressure, it is usually called the prrssum function. The relation between 4) and 0 may be deduced from the equations (1.2.5) and (1.2.26). We have
r
= grad
grad (wt + (1/2)v2) _ -grad J
(1.2.38)
If the flow is uniform at infinity, with the velocity U., it results tl =Vet + (1/2){tom - U )
(1.2.39)
In the framework of the linearized theory this relation becomes
V'= P +U.oP.-
(1.2.40)
Taking into account the permutahility of the operator a/Ot + U,,(9/0x with the operators appearing in (1.2.24), it follows that '0 satisfies the sane equations (1.2.24) or (1.2.25). From (1.2.29) and (1.2.39), it results that ,, has the same expression (1.2.37) in the case of the linear approximation for compressible fluids. In order to write the boundary conditions, we have to indicate the relation between 0 and the coordinates of the velocity. For steady motions, we obtain from (1.2.40), (taking into account that rv must vanish at infinity) : Uc
= jW4)dx,
Ucw
as-dX.
(1.2.41)
For unsteady flow, deriving (1.2.40), we get .2.42) (1.2.42)
THE SHOCK WAVES THEORY
11
Performing the change of variables t, x --+ r, £ :
r=t,
t;=x-U".t
(1.2.43)
and denoting
w(t, x, y, -) = w (T, 0(t, x, y) z) _ V"'(r,
U,
,
y, z) ,
(1.2.44)
we deduce ay//Or = N//&r, whence, integrating
Ta
(1.2.45)
00
Returning to the variables t and x, we get w(t, x, y, z)
=
f
+U.r',y,z)dr' _ (1.2.46)
fe
1.3 The Shock Waves Theory 1.3.1
The Jump Equations
The principles of motion for the continuous media are expressed in terms of balance equations. The general form of a balance equation is dt,npQdv -
Jen
R nda+JnpSdv,
(1.3.1)
where D is a material domain, Q and S are tensors having the same order and R is a tensor having the order greater with a unity. For the ideal fluid, the principle of conservation of mass (1.1.10) has the form (1.3.1), with
Q=I, R=0,S=0.
(1.3.2)
The principle of variation of the momentum (1.1.12) is obtained for
Q=v, R=-pI, S= f,
(1.3.3)
I representing the unity tensor, and the balance equation for the energy (1.1.14) for
Q=a+(1/2)v2,R=-pv-q,S= f v.
(1.3.4)
THE EQUATIONS OF IDEAL. FLUIDS
12
Let us see now the balance equation (1.3.1) in case that D is crossed by a surface of discontinuity with the displacement velocity d ([1.11), p.28). Applying the derivation formula (1.1.9), the equation (1.3.1) gives
.I [
UL 51
pQ)-AS1 l dv + i;:++E.. pQ(v
n)-Rnda-
llpQQdda=O.
We pass to the limit superposing F,+ and F_ on S (fig. 1.3.1). In this case, n+ becomes n, and n_ becomes -n.
Fig. 1.3.1.
If we assume that the integrand from the first integral is bounded, the first term tends to zero, because vol D± ---. 0. Hence one obtains:
jDPQ(v.n_d)_Rnoda=07
(1.3.5)
where we denoted (1.3.6)
The limit values encountered here are continuous on S (they are not continuous across S), and S is arbitrary, because the balance equations are formulated for every D. By virtue of the fundamental lemma ([1.11) p.31), from (1.3.5), we deduce
OpQ(v n - d) - Rn = 0.
(1.3.7)
13
THE SHOCK WAVES THEORY
This is the equation which leads to the balance equation. It establishes the connection between the limit values from the two parts of the shock waves. If across a surface the fields have discontinuities, this surface is a shock wave. Utilizing (1.3.7) for (1.3.2), one obtains;
=0,
(1.3.8)
for (1.3.3)
Opv(v n - d) +pn, = 0,
(1.3.9)
and for (1.3.4), (1.3.10)
The conduction laws utilized in practice (particularly Fourier's law) make impossible the discontinuity for q. Hence we shall utilize the equation (1.3.10) as follows 1 p(e+2v2
=0.
(1.3.11)
To the previous equations we shall add the inequation: Ops(v . n
- d)Q > 0,
(1.3.12)
coming from the Second Principle of Thermodynamics ([1.111, p.50). For the ideal fluid we have an equality.
1.3.2
Hugoniot's Equation
The jump Equation (1.3.11) is quite complicated. It can be replaced by a simple equation (Hugoniot's equation), which establishes a connection only between the thermodynamic quantities from the two sides of the shock wave. In order to deduce these equations, for the sake of
simplicity we introduce the propagation speed P = d - v n. In this way, the jump equations become
r
OPPI =0,
(1.3.13)
OpPv-png =0,
(1.3.14)
=0,
(1.3.15)
THE F.QUATIOSS OF IDEAL FLUIDS
14
[pPsO <0.
(1.3.16)
From these equations we have to find the unknowns behind the shod; wave and its propagation speed if we know the state of the fluid in front of the shock wave. For the salve of simplicity too, we mark by the index 1 the limit values (on S) in front of the shock wave and by the index 2
the limit values behind the shock wave. The normal to S is positively orientated from the region 2 toward region 1. We exclude the situation Pi = P-2 = 0, because in this case the surface of discontinuity does not cross the fluid (it is a material surface moving together with the fluid). For deducing Hogoniot's equation, we notice that from (1.3.13) it follows that the quantity p P is continuous across the shock wave. N e denote by
rn=pjP1=P2P2
(1.3.17)
this quantity. Since in the jump equations we employ only the velocity on the shock wave in a current point of the wave, we write
v=v,,n+vet.
(1.3.18)
v'2 =
vn representing the normal component and vi the tangential component
(situated in the plane determined by n and v). We denoted by t the versos of the tangent.
Projecting (1.3.14) on the tangent and on the normal to the shock wave and taking into account that by hypothesis, in T 0, we deduce
UVt =0,
rnOv,, 11
- H =0.
(1.3.19)
The first equation shows that the tangential component of the velocity
remains constant across the shock wave. From the definition of the propagation speed P and from the conservation relation (1.3.17), we deduce
Vn =d-P=d-nzT, r- 1/p,
(1.3.20)
the second equation from (1.3.19) becoming rn2OTO +
0.
(1.3.21)
From (1.3.15) taking into account the equations (1.3.19), (1.3.20) and (1.3.21), we notice that:
pPvt 9 =III
vie) = 0,
OpP'el1 = -21n2dOrl + rn3[r20 = 2dOpE
- Innllpll (rl + r'2)
THE SHOCK WAVES THEORY
15
From these equations and from (1.3.15), we get: 2Ohl = OpO(T1 +r2),
(1.3.22)
where h = e + pr is the enthalpy ([1.11], p.55). This is the first form of Hugoniot's equation. Performing the calculations in (1.3.22), we get also the form (1.3.23) 2Oej + rlJ(PI + P2) = 0, and. for the perfect gas, when e is given by (1.1.20), one finds the third expression: P2 P1
=
b+ 1)p2 - (7 - 1)PI
(1.3.24)
(7 + 1)pt - Of - 1)P2
which is useful in applications.
The inequality (1.3.2) shows that if m > 0 (the shock wave surpasses the fluid), then 81 < 82; if in < 0 (the fluid surpasses the shock wave), then 82 < s1. In all cases behind the shock wave the entropy is not decoeasing. It increases or remains constant. 1.3.3
The Solution of the Jump Equations
In the sequel we are going to demonstrate, for the perfect gas, that giving the state of the medium in front of the shock wave and the propagation speed Pt, one may determine completely the state behind the shock wave. To this aim, we introduce the numbers:
M1 = Pt/cl ,
M2 = P2/c2,
(1.3.25)
where c1 and c2 represent the sound velocity in front of the shock wave respectively behind the shock wave (CI = 7Pi/Pl, 4 = 7P2/p2). By hypothesis, M1 is known and M2 is unknown. From (1.3.21), we deduce:
P2 - P1 = in2(rl _,r2) = p1P1 (1 - r2/rl) = 7P1Mi (1 - 72/r1) .
The function (pa/pl) -1 may also be obtained from (1.3.24). Comparing the expressions we get:\
T2-1= 71
2 (M1-11,E-1= 27 7+1 / Pt 7+
(M2 -1).
(1.3.26)
From the relation P1r2 = P2r1i it follows:
f
-1)I(1-Jt't2)=11th-1
(1.3.27)
THE EQUATIONS OF IDEAL FLUIDS
16
From the perfect gas law p = pRT and from (1.1.20), we obtain: - 81
82
C11
fi-C )(p1)'
= in
J
(i) r
111
r2/rl and p2/pt being replaced from (1.3.26).
Prandtl's Formula
1.3.4
For the stationary wave (d = 0), we have v = -rnr, such that the equation (1.3.11), for the perfect gas, becomes Q1v2+
ry
PO
y-1P
2
=0.
(1.3.29)
The expression written here intervenes in Bernoulli's integral (1.2.7).
Taking into account the meaning given there to
v,,,,,x
, we have the
relation
P1=1 2 2+ iv max=l 2vt.7-1pt 1
P1=12v2msx 2
11
(1.3.30)
which shows that vmax is invariant across the shock wave. Taking into account that 0, from (1.3.30) we deduce: 1
y
P1
PI
2 t[ 2 0 _ 'r' - l pj
P11}2
1l
(1.3.31)
/
We eliminate p2/pt by the aid of equation (1.3.24) and pre/pl, by the aid of relation PIV1.. = P2v2n which results from (1.3.17). Employing once again (1.3.30), we deduce: ('y + 1)v1nv2n - (/ - 1)v? = 2yP1/Pl
1)(v 1
- vl ).
Writing vu = v2i = vi, we obtain Prandtl's fonnula v1nt'2n=
-llvmax-Vi y+1
ry+1
)=t2.r(1.3.32)
the significance of vt. being that of (1.2.8). In the expressions vma and va. utilized here, cp is the sound velocity for the fluid in front of the shock wave (at rest). The relation (1.3.32) gives c2,, when the state of the fluid in front of the shock wave is known. For the normal shock According to this relation, if (:;( = 0), the relation becomes vttt2 = vt is supersonic, then v2 is subsonic.
THE SHOCK WAVES THEORY
17
The Shock Polar
1.3.5
Buselnann (Vortrage arcs dem Gebiete des Aerod amik, Aachen, 1929), gave a graphic method for constructing v2 if the angle with v1 is known. To this aim, we consider in the current point Al from the shock wave (fig. 1.3.2) the AIX axis, pointing in the direction and sense of v1 and the AIY axis in the plane determined by v1 and the normal n to the shock wave.
Fig. 1.3.2.
We use the normal pointing towards the state (2); the change of the sense of the normal does not affect the jump relations (excepting the relation (1.3.16), whose signification is known), because in these relations the normal intervenes linearly. Because of the continuity of the tangential component of the velocity, v, lies also in the plane
determined by v1 and n and it will have on the tangent versor t the same projection AIQ like vl. We denoted by PI and P2 the extremities of the vectors v 1 and v2 and by 0, the angle between v2 and v1. Our aim is to find the geometric locus of the point P2 when 0 is varying. We shall use, obviously, Prandtl's formula (1.3.32). Denoting by (X, Y) the coordinates of the vector v2, from the figure, it results X = v2 cos 0, Y = 1v2 sin 0, vl = v1 sin o, vt = v1 cos B , v2., = v-± sin(v - 0) = X sin Or - Y cos a .
(1.3.33)
So, Prandtl's formula becomes:
Xsin2a-YsinorCosa= vi
- 7+1 VICOS2a
(1.3.34)
THE EQUATIONS OF IDEAL FLUIDS
18
From the triangle P1P2R, where the angle P1P2R = a, it follows tana = (vi - X)JY, such that (1.3.34) becomes (1.3.35) Y2(b- X) = (vl X)2(X - a),
-
%%'here we denoted 2
a=
Vt
,
b=v`,+ vl
2
y+1
vi.
(1.3.36)
From the assumption that vt is supersonic, it follows that a < vi, we deduce vj < b < v.. and from vi < The curve representing eq. (1.3.35) is symmetric with respect to MX, it intersects the MX axis in the points A(a) and Pt (v1) (which are inverse with respect to the sonic circle x2 + y'' = v,2,,), the last point
being double and has a vertical asymptote in B(b). The curve is real for a < X < b and it is represented in figure 1.3.3. It is called foliurn of Descartes. It is the shock polar.
Fig. 1.3.3_
Let us show now how we construct v2 when we know the angle
0 made with vl. First of all one constructs the shock polar. This is determined only by the state (1). The same state determines the angle ©p made by the tangent MT with the MX axis. If 0 < Bo, there exist three intersection points 1,1_,13, of the radius vector with
the polar, but only one is P2. The points on AT are eliminated because they correspond to instable shocks. One eliminates the points
THE SItOCI' WAVES THEORY
19
1:1 because. generally, the shocks are compressive. (v2 < vt ). P2 will coincide therefore with 12. If C is the intersection of the polar with the sonic circle and 9° is the corresponding polar angle, then v2 will be supersonic if 0 < B, and subsonic, if 0 > O. Once 11 determined, it results the direction of the versor t (the orthogwua from M on P1P2) and then the angle a. The density, the
pressure. the temperature and the entropy behind the shock wave is obtaincNi front (1.3.26) and (1.3.28), setting M1 = -vln/et = -MI sin or, where .111 = v1/c1 is Mach's number in front of the shock wave.
1.3.6
The Compression Shock past a Concave Bend
We consider a supersonic flow having the velocity v1 i, the density p) and the pressure P1 in the presence of a concave bend having the opening b (fig. 1.3.4a)). The wall ME produces a compressive shock, the discontinuity line MM' being characterized by the unknown angle a. Behind the shock, the velocity which has to be tangent to ME, will make the angle 6 with MX . If 6 < Bo, the position of P2 will be given by 11 from the polar corresponding to this motion. It follows like above, a and the flow behind the shock. If 6 > B(), one cannot satisfy for v2 the condition to be parallel to AI E. As the experience confirms, the assumption of a rectilinear shock wave Al Al' cannot be taken into consideration. In this case one admits the existence of a detached curvilinear shock wave which is formed in front. of Al (fig. 1.3.4b)). The experience confirms this assumption. Flence the detached shock waves are formed in front of the dihedron (S > A() (fig. 1.3.5a)), or in front of the bodies with rounded leading edge (fig. 1.3.5b)). As an information we give the following values : (10 = 10° for M1 = 1.42 and Bo = 22.55°, for M1 = 2. Depending on
Fig. 1.3.4.
the shape of the body, i.e. on the values of 0, behind the shock wave,
THE EQUATIONS OF IDEAL FLUIDS
20 C
0<00
Pig. t.3.5.
we meet regions where V2 is subsonic (11M2 < 1), if 9 > 9, and regions
where u2 is supersonic, if 9 < O. When 9 is big, the compression is big. When 9 is passing to small values, it appears a detente and the velocity becomes again supersonic. On the direction MV the shock is normal (vi v2 = v,2 and v2 is subsonic. The subsonic regions are separated from the supersonic ones through sonic lines CD and C'D'. Behind the shock wave, the flow is transonic. The shock waves theory will be present in the transonic flow and the hypersonic flow.
Chapter 2 The Equations of Linear Aerodynamics and its Fundamental Solutions
2.1 2.1.1
The Equations of Linear Aerodynamics The Fundamental Problem of Aerodynamics
The fundamental problem of aeroclynamica consists in determining the perturbation produced in a given state of a fluid by a certain motion of a body. The given state of the fluid is called basic state or unperturbed
state. The unperturbed state of the fluid may be the rest state, the uniform flow state, or more generally, the state given by the flow with an imposed non-uniform velocity field. In this book the unperturbed state will be either the rest or the uniform flow. In his turn, the body may he fixed, moving uniformly or may have a general imposed motion. Obviously, a fixed body in at rest state of a fluid does not produce any perturbation. The most common are the case when the unperturbed fluid moves uniformly and the body is fixed and the case when the fluid is at rest and the body has a given uniform motion. As we shall see in 2.1.6, these cases are equivalent, from the mathematical point of view. In both cases, the resulting perturbation will he stationary. If the perturbing ixxly has a non-uniform motion, the perturbation will be non-stationary, whatever should be the state of the fluid. In the sequel we shall consider only the cases when the unperturbed fluid is at rest or has an uniform flow. The problem of determining the perturbation may be practically solved only in the case of small perturbations, when we can neglect their products (we keel) only the principal parts of the equations). In these cases, the linear systems of equations obtained for the perturbations may be investigated either with the methods of the classical analysis or with the methods of the theory of distributions. The systems will be linear
22
LASEAR AERODYNAMICS. FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS
with constant coefficients in case that the basic state is uniform and they will be linear with variable coefficients in case that the basic flow is not uniform. Since, as we have already mentioned, the last case will not be treated in this book we give here some references, [2.4], [2.14], [2.15], [2.20], (2.22), for the reader interested in this subject.
The order of magnitude of the perturbation is determined by the basic flow and by the shape of the body. For some basic flows, a slender body with it small incidence changes slightly the flow, i.e. produces small
perturbations (governed by linear systems of equations). We cannot establish in advance the conditions of validity of the linear theory. This will be done after determining the solution of the linearized equations, imposing not to obtain results which cannot be accepted from a physical point of view. In this way, from Chapters 3 and 8, it will follow that in the case of steady flow, the linear theory is not valid when the basic flow
has approximately the sonic velocity (M = 1), or has an hypersonic velocity (M > 3) even if the body is slender with a small incidence. In these cases one has to employ the non-linear equations for determining the perturbation. A special feature has the unsteady flow because the system of equations of motion is hyperbolic and it is well known (see, for example, [1.6]), that for this sort of problems, Cauchy's problem is correct, i.e. the solution depends continuously on the initial data. If these data are small, the perturbations will remain small at every instant.
2.1.2 The Equations of Motion First of all we assume that the basic motion (the unperturbed motion) (the Ox axis is of a fluid is an uniform motion with the velocity taken to be on the direction and in the sense of the unperturbed stream
and we denote by i the versor of this axis), the pressure po,, and the density p,,. We denote by xi, yi, zi the generic spatial coordinates, by t i the time and we introduce the dimensionless coordinates x, y, z, t by mean., of the relations (2.1.1) (xi, yi, zi) = Lo(x, y, z), Uwtl = Lot. where LO is a characteristic length which has to be specified in every problem we have in view. We assume that the uniform motion defined above is perturbed by the presence of a body which has a prescribed motion. Let
F(ti, xi, yi, zt) = 0.
(2.1.2)
23
TILE EQUATIONS OF LINEAR AERODYNAMICS
be the equation of the surface of the moving body. Denoting by V 1, p1 and pt the velocity, the pressure and the density for the perturbed flow, we shall write:
V 1 = UU(i + v), Pt = P.- + P"Uoop, pi = Poa(1 + P),
(2.1.3)
the first terms defining the basic motion, and the last ones, the perturbation. Obviously we have: lien (v, p, p) = 0. _-.-OD
(2.1.4)
We neglect the heat changes (in aerodynamics this assumption is plausible, because the variation of the phenomena are very rapid and there is not enough time for the heat change) and we assume that the fluid obeys to the perfect gas law. In these conditions, the perturbed flow will be determined by the following equations:
01+p1divlV1 =0, sl =0, P1V1+grad, pi =0,
(2.1.5)
s1 representing the specific entropy and "the point", a notation for the material derivative: (2.1.6)
s 1 = c,.1n(Pl /Pi) + C, f = of /0t1 + (V 1 V 1)f .
The index 1 attached to the differential operators indicates that the derivatives are calculated with respect to x1, yl, zl Taking into account the expression of the entropy, from the equation (2.1.6), we get: P1p1 = 'YPt11,
(2.1.7)
so that we can eliminate pl from the first equation (2.1.5). Hence, we have to take into consideration the system (2.1.8)
01 + ypldiv3 V1 = 0, p1Vl +grad, p1 = 0 which, taking into consideration (2.1.1) and (2.1.3) becomes: A!2[pt+(1+u)p=+VVlpy+wp;]+(1+-tM2p)(u?+vy+w=)
+p)[ut+(1+u)U=,+ ruy+wu,]+ps=0, +p)[Vt++u)vs+vuy+wvZ]+Py=0, (1+p)[wt+(1+u)w2+trwy+wWz]+p: = 0,
= 0, (2.1.9) (2.1.10) (2.1.11)
(2.1.12)
24
LINEAR AERODYNAMICS. F'UNDA'MENTAL SOLUTIONS
where (u, v, w) = v, pt = dp/at, Ps = Op/tax,... and M = U00/c., coo =
'YPoo/Poo ,
(2.1.13)
Al representing Mach's number in the basic motion and 'y, the ratio of the specific heats The condition for the perturbation surface (2.1.2) to be a material surface is F = 0 (the Euler-Lagrange criterion)and it may be written as follows
Ft +(l+u)F,+vFy+wF =0.
(2.1.14)
This condition must be satisfied for F(t, x, y, z) = 0. The system of equations (2.1.9) - (2.1.12), together with the boundary condition (2.1.14), will determine the perturbation (p,v).
A. The Linearization around the Uniform Motion 2.1.3
The Equations of Linear Aerodynamics
We assume now that the equation of the perturbing surface is z = h(t, x, y) = ei (t, x, y),
(2.1.15)
where e is a small parameter and h(t, x, y) is a known function with continuous first order derivatives (fig. 2.1.1a)). If the perturbation surface is cylindrical with generators parallel to Oz (fig. 2.1.1b)), then
the equation of the profile determined in the xOy plane is assumed to have the form y = h(t, x) = J (t, x) . (2.1.16) In this case, the perturbation will be plane. For the surface (2.1.15), we write F = eh(t, x, y) - z in (2.1.14). One obtains Eht + E(1 + u)h= + evhy = w (2.1.17) which has to be satisfied for z = Eh(t, x, y). The principal part from the left. hand side of the equality (2.1.17) has the order of e. We deduce that the right hand part must have the same order of magnitude. Hence it follows
w(t,z) y,eh) = e'w(t)x,y,eh). We consider that this relation is valid all over the fluid, whence w(t, x, y, z) = e1 F(t, x, y, Z).
(2.1.19)
25
TIIE EQUATIONS OF LINEAR AERODYNAMICS
--s 0
a)
Fig. 2.1.1.
Taking into account (2.1.18). the principal part of the boundary condition (2.1.17) is h, (t, x, y) + h..(t, x, y) = w(t, x, y, 0) .
(2.1.20)
Taking into account (2.1.19), we deduce that the principal part of the product from (2.1.12) has the order e. It follows therefore that p has the same order. Hence, p(t, x, y, -) = Ep(t. X, r, =)
,
(2.1.21)
the residual equation from (2.1.12) being
Dw+p: =0,
(2.1.22)
where D is the material derivative operator for the unperturbed motion:
D = a/at + 9/ax .
(2.1.23)
Taking into account (2.1.21), from (2.1.10) and (2.1.11), we deduce u(t, x, y, z) = F-u(t, x, y, z) , v(t, x, y, :) = e'u(t, x, y, z)
(2.1.24)
and the residual equations
Du+p,,=0, Dv+py=0.
(2.1.25)
Now, the equation (2.1.9) becomes
?J2Dp+ dive = 0.
(2.1.26)
This equation together with the equations (2.1.22) and (2.1.25) which have the vectorial form Dv + grad p = 0,
(2.1.27)
LINEAR AERODYNAMICS. FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS
26
constitute the fundamental system of the linear aerodynamics. Obviously, this system has to be integrated with the boundary condition (2.1.20) and the condition at infinity upstream
lim (p, v) = 0.
(2.1.28)
If the perturbation is plane, the condition (2.1.20) will be replaced by
ht(t, x) + h=(t, x) = v(t, x, 0)
.
(2.1.29)
If the perturbation surface is fixed (i.e. h does not depend explicitly on t), the perturbation will be stationary, determined by the system 1v12p= + div v = 0 ,
vx + grad p = 0
limo(p, v) = 0
2 30) . (.1
and by the boundary conditions w(x, y, 0) = hr (x, y) ,
(2.1.31)
v(x, 0) = hr (x) .
(2.1.32)
Obviously, the equations (2.1.26), (2.1.27) and (2.1.29) could be easily obtained from (2.1.9)-(2.1.12) and (2.1.14), supposing that all the perturbations have the same order of magnitude. But this thing has to be demonstrated. In the case of transonic flow, for example, the perturbations have different orders of magnitude (see Chapter 9).
2.1.4
The Equation of the Potential
Applying the operator curl in (2.1.27), we obtain:
Dcurlv = 0.
(2.1.33)
Taking into account the significance of the operator D, we deduce that curl v is constant on the parallels to the Ox axis, the constant generally varying from one parallel to the other. Since at infinity upstream (x =
= -oo) the constant vanishes on every parallel to Ox, it follows that curl v = 0 on every trajectory coming from --cc. This property is not true for trajectories detaching downstream from the body. This fact will be better put into evidence by the fundamental solutions. In the irrotational zone we have v = grad cp(t, x) .
(2.1.34)
THE EQUATIONS OF LINEAR AERODYNAMICS
27
Taking into account this representation of the field v, from (2.1.27) we deduce
p = -D
(2.1.35)
The function f (t) which should be added in the right hand side of the equation may be considered equal to zero, since W is determined with the approximation of an arbitrary additive function of t. From (2.1.26) and (2.1.35) it follows Dip = M2D2co or, explicitly (1 - M2)fpxs + Wy, +'pz:. - 2M2WfZ - M2Vu = 0.
(2.1.36)
This is the equation of the potential. In case of the stationary flow, from (2.1.33) it results curly = f(y,z),
f representing an arbitrary field which must be considered zero because
for x -- -oo we have curl v = 0. Again it is true the observation that curl v is not zero on the parallels at the Ox axis detaching downstream from the body. In the irrotational zone we have therefore v = grad W(x) .
(2.1.37)
From the first equation (2.1.25), taking into account (2.1.28), it follows
p(x) = -u(x) .
(2.1.38)
Replacing (2.1.37) and (2.1.38) in the first equation (2.1.30), it follows
(1 - M2)9u + ,pyy + ,P:: = 0.
(2.1.39)
This equation may be obviously deduced from (2.1.36). For the incompressible fluid (M = 0) these equations become Al P = 0.
(2.1.40)
Applying the operator grad in (2.1.39), we get: (1 - M2)v22 + vyy + USX = 0.
(2.1.41)
Hence, the coordinates of the velocity (and the pressure) satisfy the same equation (2.1.39). The equations (2.1.36) and (2.1.39) have been obtained in another
way in Chapter 1. There we utilized the Lagrange-Cauchy theorem in order to prove that the perturbed flow is potential. Here, without
28
LINEAR AERODYNAMICS. FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS
utilizing this theorem, we demonstrated that in the first approximation the perturbation is potential. In addition, we see here that downstream the perturbing body, the perturbation does not possess this property any longer.
B. The Linearization around the Rest State 2.1.5
The Linear System
Let us assume now that the basic state of the fluid is the rest state, which is perturbed, as above, by a prescribed arbitrary motion of a body. We denote by po and po the pressure and the density of the fluid at rest. We denote also by ca = -ypo/po the square of the sound velocity for the same state. Since, in this case, there is no characteristic velocity, it is not recommended to use the variables (2.1.1) and (2.1.3). It is natural to use dimensional coordinates and to put V1 = V, P1 = PO + POP, Pt = Po(1 + p),
(2.1.42)
litn (p, v, p) = 0. (x}-00
(2.1.43)
The system of equations of motion has the shape
p+(1+p)divv=0, (1+p)P=(c2 +7p)p, (1+p)v+grad p=0.
(2.1.44)
If the equations of the perturbing surface have the form (2.1.15), we shall have the boundary condition Eli, + EU) X + Evii, = w
(2.1.45)
which has to be satisfied for z = Eh(t, x, y). We deduce w(t, x, y, d) = eii (t, x, y, ch)
(2.1.46)
and the boundary condition w(t, x, y, 0) = ht (t, x, y) .
(2.1.47)
Assuming like in (2.1.3), that (2.1.46) is valid all over the fluid, w(t, x, y, z) = ew(t, x, y, z),
29
THE EQUATIONS OF LINEAR AERODYNAMICS
from the projection of the second equation from (2.1.44) onto the Oz axis, we deduce
P(t,x,v,z) = C PO, z, v, z)
and the residual equation
wt+pz=0. Acting in the sequel like in subsection (2.1.3), we obtain at last
p t +divv = 0 , p t = c2pt , vt + grad p = 0
(2.1.48)
We deduce the system
pt+c2divv=0, vt+gradp=0 lim (p, v) = 0 III--=
(2.1.49)
and the solution p = c2p. The system (2.1.49) has to be integrated with the boundary condition (2.1.47). From (2.1.49) one obtains the fundamental equation of acoustics
pa - cRAp = 0. 2.1.6
(2.1.50)
The Uniform Motion in the Fluid at Rest
Let us consider the particular case of the uniform motion of the per-
turbing body in the fluid at rest. We assume that the motion is performed with the velocity U0 in the negative sense of the Ox axis. Putting
V, = Uov, pi = poll + A, Pt = po + poop
(2.1.51)
and utilizing the variables (2.1.1), we get the system:
Mop+(1+yAf,p)divv=0, (1+p)Mop=(1+yM p)P, (1+p)v+gradp=0,
(2.1.52)
where MQ is Mach's number for the fluid at rest. As above, one deduces the boundary condition (2.1.47) and the system (2.1.52) reduces to the residual form
Af2pt+divv=0, vt+gradp=0 and M p = p.
(2.1.53)
30
LINEAR AERODYNAMICS. FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS
In a frame of reference R' = Cx'y'z' (fig. 2.1.2) solidary with the body, having the axes parallel and having the same sense with the axes
of the frame R = Oxyz (the frame R' is inertial), the system (2.1.53) has the form of the steady system (2.1.30). Indeed, we pass from the frame R to the frame R' by means of the Galilean transformation
t'=t,
=x+t, Y ,=Y, z'=z.
(2.1.54)
With this transformation, the system (2.1.53) gains the form of the system (2.1.26). (2.1.27) and the condition (2.1.47), the form (2.1.20).
But, since we deal with a translation of the body, h in (2.1.47) has the form h(x + t, y) which is transformed in h(x', y'). The boundary condition in the variables x', y', z' will have therefore the form (2.1.31), so that it will determine a steady motion. The system of equations of motion in z', y', z' will have the form (2.1.30). Hence we have demonstrated that the problem of determining the perturbation produced by a body moving uniformly with the velocity -Uoi, in a fluid at rest, is equivalent to the problem of determining the
perturbation produced by the same fixed body in an uniform stream with the velocity Uoi.
2.2
The Fundamental Solutions of the Equation of the Potential
2.2.1
The Steady Solutions
This subsection is written on the basis of the paper [2.111. The fundamental solutions of the equation (2.1.39) are the solutions of the equation
(1 -
e ,+
(2.2.1)
a representing Dirac's distribution. These solutions are, obviously, dis-; tributions. Utilizing the Fourier transform method, we shall obtain ternperate solutions. Taking into account (A.5.1), valid also for temperate solutions, we obtain using the notation a2 = IaI2, (a2
- M202).? = -1,
(2.2.2)
whence
E_
1
a2-M2ni
--V-'
1
[(1
-A12)a +a2+a
(2-2.3)
FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS OF THE EQUATION OF THE POTENTIAL 31
In the subsonic case M < 1, we shall denote
fl= 1-M2,
(2.2.4)
and in the supersonic case (M > 1),
k= M2-1.
(2.2.5)
In the subsonic case one utilizes the formulas (A.7.10) and (A.7.11). One obtains the following fundamental solutions:
x+
4w
E
1
2Aft
In
1(y
+z)
,
n = 3,
x f2 +y2, n = 2,
(2.2.6)
(2.2.7)
For the two-dimensional case we have not written the additive constamt C - in j3 appearing in (A.7.11), because the fundamental solution is determined with the approximation of a solution of the homogeneous equation. In the supersonic case, one utilizes the formulas (A.7.14) and (A.7.15). One obtains the following fundamental solutions:
1 H(x - ky2+z2)} 27r
.6 = -
x-k(y+z)
n=3,
H(x - klyl), n = 2.
(2.2.8)
(2.2.9)
H repn-senting, as we have considered in Appendix A, Heaviside's func.
tion. From the definition of this function (A.3.13), it follows that the three-dimensional solution is different from zero only for
x > kk/,/2 +z2.
(2.2.10)
This inequality implies x > 0, xs > k2(y2 + zs).
The set of points from the space verifying these inequalities constitutes
the interior of the cone with the vertex in the origin of the system of coordinates (the perturbation point) and the symmetry axis along the Ox axis (fig. 2.2.1a)). This cone is called Mach's cone. In fact, it is the characteristic cone associated to the partial differential equation (2.1.39)
LINEAR AERODYNAMICS. FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS
32
Y
b)
a)
Fig. 2.2.1.
in the hyperbolic case. The radius of the cone is x/k, and the angle p (the semi-opening) is determined by the formula tan y =
xxk
=k
= Ml -11
(sin µ = M J
.
(2.2.11)
In the two-dimensional case, the solution is different from zero only
inside the dihedrou made by the plane; x = ±ky where x > 0 (fig. 2.2.1b)). This is Mach's dihedrun. 2.2.2
Oscillatory Solutions
The fundamental oscillatory solutions are defined by the equation
(1 - M2)En + Cm + e - 2M26 - M2Ea = 6(x)exp(iwt) , (2.2.12) associated to the equation (2.1.38). They will have, obviously, the shape
E = E(x)exp(iwt),
(2.2.13)
where
(1- M2)E;= + E,,,, + E.: - 2iwAf2E= + w2M2E = 6(x).
(2.2.14)
Performing the change of functions E - e: E = exp(Ax)e
(2.2.15)
and nullifying the coefficient of the derivative e=, one obtains the equar tion: (1 - M2)e", + eyy + e1t + ae = exp(-Ax)6(x),
(2.2.16)
FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS OF THE EQUATION OF THE POTENTIAL 33
where A
ikM,
w2M2
a= 1-M2
(2.2.17)
In the subsonic case (M < 1) one performs the change of variable (x, y, 0 (X, Y, Z):
X =x, Y = fly, Z=Az
(2.2.18)
and one takes into account (A.3.11). One obtains the equations:
cxx + cyy + e z + k2e = exp(-AX)8(X ), n = 3, e x x + eyy + k2e = ftuexp(-)LX)b(X), n = 2,
(2.2.19)
where k = WA1/02 = wM. In (2.2.19) we have Helmholtz's non-homogeneous equations. It is well known (see, for example, [A.12], §9), that Helmholtz's equation has two fundamental solutions in the three-dimensional case and the same number of solutions in the two-dimensional case, the choice of the solution depending on the type of oscillation defined by the equation. Taking into account that we obtained Helmholtz's equation looking for oscillations having the form (2.2.13), it follows (see, for example, [1.41) Chapter 7, §2) that the following solutions have a physical meaning: ea
=
exp(-ikIXI) 4i(XI
1 fr(2)
e2 = 4
(kIXI) ,
63 representing the solution for the three-dimensional case and 'e2 the solution for the two-dimensional case. Hoe) is Hankel's function. Performing the convolutions of these solutions with the right hand member from (2.2.19) (A.4.6 formula), we get the following fundamental solutions e2 = 4'-Ho2)(kjXI),
e3 =
so that, taking into account the changes already made, we find: E3
ik(Mx - R) , (2.2.20)
E2 = -'blIt HQ(kR)exp (kMx) ,
with the notations
R= a +f2(y2+z2), 17 = Vx2 ++Q2y2.
34
LINEAR AERODYNAMICS. FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS
In the supersonic case ; (Al > 1) one performs the change of variable
X =x, Y=ky, Z=kz.
(2.2.21)
The equation (2.2.16) becomes
exx - eyy - ezz + v2e = -exp(-AX) 6(X),
(2.2.22)
where v = wM/k2. In (2.2.22) we have the non-homogeneous KleinCordon-Fock equation. The fundamental solutions of this equation are also known (JA.8J [A.111). Performing the convolutions of these equations with the right hand member of (2.2.22), we get: Y Y
X27tH (
e3
C2
y- -2+-Z Z2) cos X
X.
Z.
V
Z2
--y2) 2kH(X - IYI)Jo (vvX2
such that finally it follows
-
E E3
1
H `x - k Vy2 +zs)
cosv
x -k y +z)
x_k (
kf.M2
.i.i)exp,
1-M=x) (2.2.23)
(v 2L,
H(x - IyI)Jo
x2 - k2y2) exp (12X)
Due to the presence of Heaviside's function in (2.2.23), it is obvious
that these solutions will be different from zero only in the interior of Mach's cone with the vertex in the origin for x > 0, respectively in the interior of Mach's dihedron (with the edge on Oz) for x > 0.
2.2.3
Oscillatory Solutions for M = 1
If M = 1, the equation (2.2.14) becomes
Ev + E..s - 2iwE= + w2E = 6(--).
(2.2.24)
Introducing the Fourier transform 2 with respect to the variables y and z one obtains A
2iwE=-(w2-az-a3)E_-6(x).
FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS OF THE EQUATION OF THE POTENTIAL 35
The solution of this equation (see (A.21)) has the shape E = H(x)E, where
2iwE. - (w2 - az It follows
0,3 ) E(o) E = O , = -1/2iw.
E - - H(x)
w2
2iwP
- a3 - a3.
[
(2.2.25)
2iw
For obtaining E we take into account that
L
0
exp (-au2)d u =
(2.2.26)
we notice that +00
exp (-iAa - Ba2)da =
FOG
exp -B (a + 2B
l)a
-
da
///
42
I.
One obtains:
E
4irx) p
(- i'd r2) ,
(2.2.27)
with the notation r2 = z2 + y2 + z2. In the two-dimensional case we have:
[__(x x 2+y2)], 11
(2.2.28)
where 2o- 2Riw = 1.
The solutions (2.2.27) and (2.2.28) may also be obtained as limits of the subsonic solutions (2.2.20) for M - 1. For obtaining (2.2.27), we notice that M2
2
jj(Mx - R) _ - lim M+ R = -U , limy
(2.2.29)
x being positive, as it follows from the supersonic solution (2.2.23). For obtaining (2.2.28) one takes into account the asymptotic behaviour of Ho2) for great values of the argument ((1.42)). HO(2(k1)
t/2
(-h)
exp (-ik R +
i)
(2.2.30)
and one performs a calculcalculus similar to (2.2.29). In the two-dimensional
case, the limit of the supersonic solution for M --+ 1 is obtained in (10.171.
36
LINEAR AERODYNAMICS. FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS
The Unsteady Solutions
2.2.4
In the sequel we are going to determine the fundamental solutions of the equation (2.2.14), i.e. the solutions of the equation
(I - M2)e11 + £yy + E, - 2Af2£u - Af 2£tt = 6(t, x)
.
(2.2.31)
This equation determines the perturbation produced in the uniform stream, defined in 2.1, by a source of potential acting at the moment t = 0 in the origin. The problem is plane (two-dimensional) if the source is uniformly distributed on the Oz axis. Applying the Fourier transform, we deduce M2d2£/d t2
- 2M2ial d E/d t + (a2 - A12c )£
(2.2.32)
We know from Appendix A that the solution of this equation has the form £ = H(t)E, where H(t) is Heairiside's function and k, is a solution of the problem
MV P/dt2 - 2M2ia1 dE/d t + (a2 - Al2a2 )E = 0, k(0) = 0 (dE/d t)(0) = -AI--2.
(2.2.33)
We get:
A'IE =
_sin J a jf- ti t
e t°'t
.
(2 . 2 .34)
Utilizing the formulas (A.7.14) and (A.7.15), we deduce
£(t , x) = -- Irt 6(t-MR) , 1
2r where
R=
H(t - MR)
n=3 , n = 2,
(2.2.35)
(2 . 2 . 36)
t2 - M2R`
(x-t)2+1,2+z2, R= (x-t)2+12.
We shall not write any longer the factor H(t) from the right hand member, because obviously this member is different from zero only for
t>0. Further we shall perform a detailed investigation of the solutions (2.2.35), (2.2.36). We denote
h(t)=t-AIR.
;'.2.37)
FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS OF THE EQUATION OF THE POTENTIAL 37
We are interested to find the zeros t; of this function, as we are going to utilize the formula: (2.2.38)
from [A.10], page 20. We have also to know the sign of the function h, because the two-dimensional solution differs from zero only for h > 0. One notices in (2.2.37) that the zeros t; are positive. Obviously.
h(0) < 0 and h(oo) = (1 - M2)oo. For the graphic representation of the function h : (0, oo) - R, we have to separate the cases M < I and M > 1. The zeros of the function h(t) are tt-
M2x+M x +(1(2.2.39) 1
112
In the subsonic case (Al < 1), h(t) has a single positive root namely h(t)
t,
t
Fig. 2.2.2.
t+. The graphic of the function h is represented in figure 2.2.2. Utilizing the formula (2.2.38) and taking into account that
t+=Ai (x-t+)2+y2+z2, we deduce
--
1 t+
4r t
x
b(t - t+) + (y` + x )
(2.2.40)
,
in the three-dimensional case and
H(t - t°.)
1
27r
t -A
(2 ,
.
2 41) .
38
LINEAR AERODYNAMICS. FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS
in the two-dimensional case. Here we denoted to = t f(z = 0). The solution (2.2.40) was given for the first tine' in [2.11], and the solution (2.2.41) is given in [1.2]. A given point P (fig. 2.2.3) perceives in different manners the perturbation produced at the moment t = 0 in the origin of the system of coordinates in the three-dimensional case and the perturbation produced at the moment t = 0 uniformly on the O: axis, in the two-dimensional case. In the three-dimensional case the perturbation is perceived at the moment t+ and only at this moment (see the solution (2.2.40)). In the two-dimensional case, the perturbation is perceived by P continuously, beginning from the moment t° (see the solution (2.2.41)). The explanation of this difference is that in the case of the plane problem, one admits that, at the moment t = 0, the entire Oz axis emits perturbations, to representing the moment when the perturbation emitted by the origin reaches the point B(x, y, 0) and t > to , the period when the perturbations emitted at the moment t = 0
by the other points of the Oz axis reach P. In figure 2.2.3, Q is the position of the source (moving with the stream) at the moment to, the distance QP being given by the formula J(x - t.)2 + y2 = M'lt+
Fig. 2.2.3.
In the supersonic case, we have to determine the zeros of the function
h'(t). They are given by the equation
(x-te)2+y2+z2 = M(to-x).
(2.2.42)
Noticing that x < to, it follows that there exists a single zero, namely
to = x +
y2 -+z2/k.
(2.2.43)
A simple calculation gives h(to) = x - k
y2 -+z 2 .
(2.2.44)
FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS OF TILE EQUATION OF THE POTENTIAL 39
We shall distinguish three cases (fig. 2.2.4):
h(to) = 0,
h(to) > 0,
h(to) < 0.
(2.2.45)
Ni)
t,
2 x>k(y+x)
b)
a)
c) Fig. 2.2.4.
In the first case the fundamental solution is £3
1 t+b(t - t+) + t_8(t - t_)
t x- ky+
41r
0, E2
_
_
1
2;r
1
t -M (-x
t)
t
(2.2.46)
,
(2.2.47)
Ea was given for the first time in (2.11]. One interprets this solution as follows: given a point P(x, y, z) in the interior of Mach's cone, there exist two and only two moments t+ and t_ when the perturbation produced in the origin at the moment t = 0 affects this point (fig. 2.2.5). The moments t+ and t_ are calculated as functions of the coordinates of P by means of the formula (2.2.39). In the two-dimensional case, P(x, y, 0) is affected during the interval It, to_) the explanation being similar to that given in the subsonic case. In this interval, the expression under the square root is positive.
40
LINEAR AERODYNAMICS. FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS
In the three-dimensional case, figure 2.2.5 presents the intersection of the z = 0 plane with Mach's cone and with the spheres having the centers Q1 and Q2. In the two-dimensional case the figure indicates the intersection of the same plane with Mach's dihedron and with the cylinders having the radii M- t9+ and Mtoi . Since from the relation sing = Q,P;/OQ; we deduce sinp = M-1 it follows that p is Mach's angle, i.e. the two spheres (cylinders) are inscribed into Mach's cone (dihedron).
Fig. 2.2.5.
If P belongs to Mach's cone, there exists only one moment t+ = = t_ = to = xM2/k-2, when the point P is affected by the perturbation. At that moment, the source is located in the intersection of the Ox axis with the normal at the cone in the point R.
If P is in the exterior of the cone, it is not affected by the perturbation. Hence, for the unsteady flow, the perturbed zone is also in the interior
of Mach's cone (respectively Mach's dihedron), but unlike the case of steady or oscillatory flow (when an arbitrary point P from the zone was affected all the time) in the unsteady motion it is affected only at two moments t+ and t_ (in the interval between these moments in the two-dimensional flow) or in a single moment if P is on the cone (dihedron). This happens because in the first two cases the fundamental solutions correspond to sources acting all the time in the origin (on the Oz axis), while in the last case the solutions correspond to sources acting only in the moment t = 0.
FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS OF THE EQUATION OF THE POTENTIAL 41
2.2.5
The Unsteady Solutions for M = 1
If M = 1, the solutions of the equation (2.2.31) will be (2.2.35) and
(2.2.36) with M = 1. The function h(t) = t - R has an unique zero (it' > 0) namely the moment tj = r2/2x. It follows that the fundamental solutions E3
-_
5 ( t8;rt x2
) 2x
)
4rrx a (t
- 2x (2.2.48)
1 H(2xt-x2-y2) 2n
2zt. _ x2 _ y2
vanish only for x > 0. Every point P from the half-space (half'-plane) x > 0 is affected by the perturbation. In the three-dimensional case, the perturbation emitted by the origin at the moment t = 0 is received in the point P(x > 0, y, z) at the moment ti, and only at this moment. If the perturbation is emitted by the Oz axis (the two-dimensional flow), an arbitrary point P(x > 0. y, 0) receives this perturbation continuously, beginning with the moment tj = (x2 + y2)/2x.
Fig. 2.2.6.
The moment of the first reception tj is given by the equation (x - ti), + y2 + z2 = ti.
(2.2.49)
The graphic of this equation is a sphere (a cylinder in the two-dimensional
case) with the center on the Ox axis in the point tj and the radius
42
LINEAR AERODYNAMICS. FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS
t1 (figure 2.2.6). The point t1 is obtained graphically, taking the intersection of the Ox axis with the mediator plane of the segment OP (the mediator line of OP in the two-dimensional case).
2.2.6
The Fundamental Solutions for the Fluid at Rest
As we have seen in subsection (2.1.5) , the propagation of a small perturbation in the fluid at rest, is described by the equation (2.1.50). The fundamental solutions of this equation will be defined by
Eu-c2(E +Eyy+t )=6(t,z).
(2.2.50)
They will give the pressure produced by an unitary perturbation in the origin of the system of coordinates at the moment t = 0. Applying the Fourier transform in (2.2.50), we get: d2 ?/d t2 + c2a2E = d(t) .
(2.2.51)
Utilizing (A.3.17), we deduce that the solution of the equation (2.2.51)
is E = H(t)E, where d2E/d t2 + c2a2E = 0, E(0) = 0, k(0) = 1.
(2.2.52)
Solving this problem, we find: sinclcxIt
cla By virtue of formulas (A.7.14) and (A.7.15), we obtain:
6(ct - r) C3
=
£2 =
- 6(ct - r)
4zrc2t 1
2rc
H(ct - r)
41rrr (2.2.53)
c t- -r
E1 representing the solution in the three-dimensional care and t2 the solution in the two-dimensional case. The solution E shows that the perturbation produced in the origin at the moment t = 0 is concentrated, for t > 0, on a spherical surface having the radius ct and the center in origin. The perturbation propagates as a spherical wave having the velocity c. On the sphere of radius r the perturbation is only at the moment t = r/c. We notice the validity of Huygens' principle. The
FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS OF THE EQUATION OF THE POTENTIAL 43
solution E2 shows that the perturbation emitted on the Oz axis at the moment t = 0 lies at a moment t > 0 in the interior of the cylinder of radius ct. There is a foregoing front of the wave propagating with the velocity c, but there is no posterior front. Unlike the three-dimensional case, behind the foregoing front, the perturbation differs from zero at every moment t. In this case Huygens' principle is not valid any longer. We know from 2.2.4 the explanation of this fact.
2.2.7 On the Interpretation of the Fundamental Solution The equation
p+pdivv = pgb(x)
(2.2.54)
may be interpreted as the equation of continuity when there is a source with the intensity pq in the origin. Indeed, integrating on every domain D containing the origin and taking into account (A.7.3), we get:
(p+pdivv)dv=pq.
(2.2.55)
ID The integral gives the variation of the mass from D in the unity of time. This is given by the intensity of the source. In every domain D which does not contain the origin, the mass is preserved. The presence of the term b(x) in (2.2.54) represents the cause of the motion. Since the term has a spherical symmetry, it follows that the flow will have this property too. Hence v = F(r)x/r and v = grad V with YP = f F(r)dr. An uniform flow, with the velocity U,,i is also potential, hence the flow resulting by overlapping the uniform flow over the flow due to a source is also potential. According to the calculus from subsection 1.2.2, it follows c20O -
(V - V)(V V)¢ = 95(x) Setting q = eq, the equation may be linearized and for q = 1 one obtains (2.2.1). The solution of the equation (2.2.1) could therefore represent the perturbation produced into the uniform stream defined by M, by a mass source of intensity p, placed in the origin of the system of coordinates. In the same way, the equation (2.2.31) could be obtained from the equation A+ pdiv v = pgb(t, x), (2.2.56) which would represent the equation of continuity in case that a source
of intensity pq is acting in the origin at the moment t = 0.
44
LINEAR AERODYNAMICS. FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS
2.3 The Fundamental Solutions of the Steady System 2.3.1
The Significance of the Fundamental Solution
In order to put into evidence the physical significance of the fundamental solutions of the steady linear system, we consider the equations: Af 2px + div v = 0,
vx + grad p = F, (2.3.1)
lim (p, v) = 0.
As it is already known, these equations determine, in the first approximation. the perturbation produced into the uniform stream defined in 2.1 by a force density F. For being able to utilize these equations in the case of a force of intensity f = (fl, f2, f3), applied in a point C, we have to define a density F whose action against the fluid must have the same torsor (resultant and resultant moment) like the force f. We state that this density is
F = f b(x - t),
(2.3.2)
where 6 is Dirac's distribution. Indeed, taking into account (A.7.3), we deduce that the torsor of this density is
f fb(x - lr)dx = f, f x x fb(x - F)dx = E x f ,
(2.3.3)
i.e. just the torsor of the force f. Hence the system
M2p,, + div v = 0, v= + grad p = f b(x) lim (p, v) = 0,
(2.3.4)
x--.-oo
determines the perturbation produced in the uniform stream, defined in 2.1, by the force of intensity f = E 7f, applied in the origin of the system of coordinates. By definition, this system determines the fundamental solutions of the steady linearized system of aerodynamics. One obtains the plane solutions if one considers that the force having
the constant intensity f is uniformly distributed along the Oz axis, being parallel to the xOy plane, i.e. f = (fl, f2i 0). In this case we have the same conditions for every z; and the perturbation is plane.
THE FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS OF THE STEADY SYSTEM
45
The General Form of the Fundamental Solution
2.3.2
We are interested in those solutions of the system (2.3.4) which can be obtained by means of Fourier transform. They are, obviously, distributions. Utilizing the formulas (A.6.4), from (2.3.4) we deduce:
A12alp+et v=0, ialy+iap=-f.
(2.3.5)
From (2.3.5) we deduce: P" =
is f
(2.3.6)
a2 - M2a'I
Then, from the second equation (2.3.5) it follows
f ink
(-ia)(-ia f)
(2.3.7)
iai(02-M2a1)
Utilizing (A.6.9) and (2.2.3) from (2.3.6) we deduce:
P(x, y, z) = -(f . V)F_i [a2 - A12ai = (f V)E. I
(2.3.8)
Taking into account (A.7.7), and (2.3.7) we obtain:
v = fH(x)5(y,z) - V(f 0)S-' [ini(cr2 1 Af2c 2)J
(2.3.9)
But
X
[iaia
a2 - A1201] =
_ AI2a2)J
E,
(2.3.10)
whence, integrating with respect to x, by virtue of Lebesgue's theorem [A.9}, it follows J.--`1
ial(a"-
' .1(2 "
1fI
=
f Ed x.
(2.3.11)
The integration limits have been appropriately imposed in order to satisfy the last condition from (2.3.4). It results therefore v(x, y, z) = f H(x)6(y, z) + VV, where
r
f o0
Ed x.
(2.3.12)
(2.3.13)
46
LINEAR AERODYNAMICS. FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS
The formula (2.3.12), which is valid both in the subsonic and supersonic
cases, shows that the perturbation is potential, excepting the Ox axis for x > 0 (in the two-dimensional case, one excepts the xOz plane for x > 0), where the first term does not vanish. Hence the perturbation is not potential downstream the point (or the fine) where the perturbing force is acting. From (2.3.8) and (2.3.12) it also results:
u(x, y, z) = ft H(x)ft, z) - p(x, y, z) .
(2.3.14)
With the exception mentioned above one obtains (2.1.38). In the sequel we shall utilize also some expressions of the components of the velocity which do not result from (2.3.12). In the two-dimensional
case, performing the change az = a2 - M2a1 - (1 - M2)ai in the component v resulting from (2.3.7), we deduce:
V=-
a
ia2f
+ (1 - M2)
iaif2 a2-1b12a
(2.3.15)
whence (2.3.16) v(x, y) _ - ftEy + (1 - M2)f2El . Analogously, in the three-dimensional case, replacing a3 = Maa1 - (1 - M2)a1 a2, in the component w resulting from (2.3.7),
-
we obtain: w
_
ioaf1
-a2-M2
1
ia1f3 +(1-M2 )a2-M2a1 (2.3.17)
1a2f3 ia2a3f2 crl(a2 M2a1) a1(a2 - M2at) '
-
whence ,,2
w(x, y, z) = -f1Es + (1- M2)f3e2 - f2 ys
Ed x + f382yy f Ed x ,
'f-C00
00
(2.3.18)
with the notations
= 82/8y8z, .. .
2.3.3 The Subsonic Plane Solution If the perturbation is plane and the free flow is subsonic, E has the expression (2.2.7). From (2.3.8) one obtains
P(x, y) -
1 xf1 + 132yf2 27x/3 x2 + /32y2
(2.3.19)
47
THE FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS OF THE STEADY SYSTEM
and from (2.3.16), 0x
(2.3.20)
- yf +g2y 2 If the force f is distributed on a straight line parallel to the Oz q), then the axis intersecting the xOy plane in the point 2nx2
v(x, y) =
.
perturbation will be determined by the system
12px+divv=0, v=+gradp= f6(x-t,y-q), (2.3.21)
litn (p, v) = 0.
After performing the change of variables (x, y) -, (xo, yo):
xo=x-e,yo=y-17 ,
(2.3.22)
the system (2.3.21) is transformed into the system (2.3.4). Hence, for (2.3.21) one obtains I
P(x, y) = 2T'8
xofl + X02
02yof2
+ p2ya
,
v(x, J) =
Q x0f2 - yofl 27r XT o
2y02
-
(2.3.23)
These solutions have been obtained in [2.10].
2.3.4
The Three-Dimensional Subsonic Solution
In this case, E is determined by (2.2.6). From (2.3.8) one obtains
4ap(x, y, z) = --(fia: + flay + f30z)(1/R) ,
(2.3.24)
where
R=
x2+f2(y2+z2).
(2.3.25)
Taking into account that
_
dx
J (x2 + a2)3/2
x a2(x2 + a2)1/2
(2.3.26)
we deduce
j'a()dX=_22 (2.3.27) 1
R dx
-y+z2
48
LINEAR AERODYNAMICS. EUNDAMEN"TAL SOLUTIONS
Employing these results, we deduce from (2.3.13) the expression of the potential cP(x'y,z)
1
fi _
= 4zr R
(1+j)12-22 (1+)f3]
y
y2+z
(2.3.28)
which gives the possibility to calculate the components of the velocity. From (2.3.18) we also obtain:
/
4-1r8,(I?)-4 fsa=[
w(x,y,z)=
(2.3.29)
- -,(f2a: - f3ay)y2 + z2
Cl
+R
.
Considering A = 1, we find the solutions for the incompressible fluid. These results have been obtained in [2.8).
2.3.5
The Two-Dimensional Supersonic Solution
In this case, E is given by (2.2.9). Taking into account (A.7.17), from (2.3.8) we deduce
2kp(x, y) _ (-f, + k f2sign y)a(x - klyl)
(2.3.30)
,
and from (2.3.16),
2v(x, y) = (-f1sign y + kf2)6(x - klyl).
(2.3.31)
Obviously, the perturbation differs from zero only in Mach's dihedron. The solution was given and utilized in [2.10].
2.3.6
The Three-Dimensional Supersonic Solution
In this case, E is given by (2.2.8) and (2.3.32)
P(x, y, z) = (flame + fear + fsa.)E .
Denoting s = k y2 + z2 and taking into account (A.3.9) and (A.3.14), we deduce
ay T Ed x = a H(x - s) o
H(x - 8)(9y
J
rl
dx
Js I X7 9
2 z2E - = 11+
x 7X=F== R
(2.3.33) f
49
THE FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS OF THE STEADY SYSTEM
such that,
By means of formula (2.3.12) we determine the velocity field. The similarity between this potential and the subsonic potential is striking (2.3.28).
Let us show now that both p given by (2.3.32) and the velocity field resulting from the potential (2.3.33), are different from zero only in the interior of Mach's cone. The assertion follows immediately if we use the formula d [H(x) dx xa )j
= x(x .A) = -aH(+i
,
A # 0,1,2,...
(2.3.35)
demonstrated in the theory of distributions (see, for example, [A.5], §2.2). Indeed, we can write:
1 H(x - s)
1
(2.3.36)
27.- (x - s)1/2 (x + s)1/2
such that the derivatives of £ will have the factor H(x - s). From (2.3.18), it follows for w : (2.3.37)
w(x, y, z) _ -(fl(9t + k2f3a=)£ + (f2as - f3ay)./2 +/z'£
In the sequel, we shall utilize also another expression of the component w. This follows writing W
ia3f1
a2 - M2c,
_
ia2a3f2 al (a2 - J%f 2a1)
k2iai - ia2 oil (a2 - Af 2ai)
f3
instead of (2.3.17). Utilizing (2.3.11), one obtains: Fx
w(x, y, z) =
f2t.1
£dx - f3(k28L - 01y) J
z
£d x. (2.3.38)
50
LINEAR AERODYNAMICS. FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS
The Fundamental Solutions of the Oscillatory System
2.4 2.4.1
The Determination of Pressure
The fundamental oscillatory solutions are defused by the system: M2(pt + p=) + div v = 0
vt + yr + grad p = f d(x)exp (i wt)
(2.4.1)
lim (p, v) = 0.
z-+-oo
They will be complex. Since the system is linear, the real part of the solutions will correspond to the case when exp (i wt) will be replaced by coswt, and the imaginary part will correspond to the case when exp (i wt) will be replaced by sin wt. The solutions of the system (2.4.1) determine the perturbations produced in the uniform stream defined in
2.1, by a force having the periodic intensity f exp (i wt), applied into origin in the three-dimensional case and uniformly on the Oz axis in the two-dimensional case. Obviously, the solution of the system (2.4.1) has the form
p = P(x)exp (iwt), v = V(x)exp(iwt) ,
(2.4.2)
P and V satisfying the system AI2{iwP-}-Ps)+divV =0 iwV + V,, + grad P = f 8(x)
(2.4.3)
Urn (P, V) = 0.
s-+-oo
Applying the Fourier transform in (2.4.3), we get
A12(w-as)P=a'V, (w--al)V-aP=-if, whence
P
_
ia- f M2(as - w)2 - a2'
V
_
if
a
ia- f
as - w + as - w M2(as - w)2 -- a2 (2.4.4)
Applying the Fourier transform, from equation (2.2.14) we deduce:
E = -F-s [a2 - M2(as - w)2j
,
P = (f V)E.
(2.4.5)
THE FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS OF THE OSCILLATORY SYSTEM
51
The pressure P will be expressed by means of the solutions (2.2.9) and (2.2.23). In the two-dimensional subsonic case, we shall have:
P= -0(f V)[Ho2)(k1)exp(ikdlx)] ,
(2.4.6)
and in the throe-dimensional subsonic case, P
Q)
{expJux - R)]
(2.4.7)
4r(f k being given in (2.2.19) and R, R in (2.2.20). In the two-diinensional supersonic case, we have:
P = -(f' V) [H(x - klyl)Jo (v x2 - k2y2)exp (-ivMx)] ,
(2.4.8)
and in the three-dimensional supersonic case, 1
P
(f 0)[H(x-Z: 21r
y2 +z2)
1 cosy x--k2( +z7) exp(-ivMx)]
\/X- 2 - k (y +:)
(2.4.9)
v being given in (2.2.22). Taking into account the formula (2.3), we deduce that the solution (2.4.9) differs from zero only in the interior of Mach's cone.
The Determination of the Velocity Field
2.4.2
Since the velocity field V vanishes at -oo, we deduce like in (2.3.12):
f
_ i
_
iai(a2-M'-a? +2alw+w2) - f 1
"
Gdx,
where
G = -f- 1a2
1
- M2a1 + 2alw + w2 Using the change ai - ca -+ aI, we get:
(
]
r Gdx. -i a 1 w NIz a lW)2 - a2] = -ie'""d 00
(2.4.10)
(2.4.11)
If we replace al by al - w in (A.7.9) we find
ai
- w ] = e-"`H(x)b(y, z) i
(2.4.12)
52
LINEAR AERODYNAMICS. FUNDAMENTAL. SOLUTIONS
Utilizing (A.6.9), on the basis of formulas (2.4.11) and (2.4.12), from (2.4.4) we deduce:
V = fe-k"H(x)b(y,z) + Vcp,
(2.4.13)
where
_ -(f
0)e-k'1X
/
G dx.
(2.4.14)
f oc
We notice that the perturbation is potential, excepting the Ox axis for x > 0, i.e. excepting the trace of the source in the uniform stream. Let us determine now the distribution G. We notice, applying the Fourier transform, that it is the solution of the equation
(1 - M2)Gu +
G - 2iwGx - w2G = 6(x).
(2.4.15)
The solution of this equation may be obtained like in 2.2. So, in the two-dimensional subsonic case we find
G = _ ZI-0 Hoe) (k1) exp (iox) ,
(2.4.16)
and in the three-dimensional case G
41rR
exp
[ik(_R)]
(2.4.17)
.
In the two-dimensional supersonic case one obtains-
G = -- 2k H(x - klyl)Jo (ui/2 - k2y2) exp (lJx) = H(x - kEyl)g,
not (2.4.18)
and in the three-dimensional case
G = - 2 H (x - k
y2 + --2)
x= - k (y' + z-)
cos v X-
r
- k-(y- + -)
exp (izux)
-
not
H(x-k. Vy2 -+z2) g, (2.4.19)
w being defined in (2.2.19). Taking into account the behaviour of Ho2) for great values of the argument (2.2.30), we deduce that in all cases we have:
lim (G, G=) = 0.
s----oo
(2.4.20)
THE FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS OF THE OSCILLATORY SYSTEM
53
2.4.3 Other Forms of the Components V and 14 In the two-dimensional case from the component V given by (2.4.4) one eliminates a2 by means of the identity
a2=a2-M112(al -w)2+M2(a1-w)1-ai. Thus one obtains
if, ai -W
ft, a2 h12(a1-W)2-a2
+ if2 (M2 -1)a, - 2M2wa1- M2w2 a, -w M2(a1 - w)2 - a2
whence, utilizing the inversion formulas (A.6.9) and (2.4.11), V (X, y)
{f,
,
+ f2 [(M2 -1)O + 2M2iwt7, - M2 W2] }
(e-iWX
X
J
Gdx = -f,e';v,x Gy - iw 00
J
m
-fee-i4" llI2iwG - (I - M2)Gx + w2 J X G d xl
.
J
oo
(2.4.21)
We also obtain this form using the expression of V given in (2.4.13) and (2.4.14),
V=
`H(x)6(y, z) - f14 f/
X
x
a-wx
J
\
G d x)
-
00
Gyy, dx,
;aid eliminating Gy, with the aid of the equation (2.4.15). Indeed, in the two-dimensional case, utilizing (2.4.20), we deduce
G., d x = H(x)d(y) - (1- it f2)Gx + 2iwG + w2 J
Gdx .
From the last taro formulas we find again (2.4.21).
For the supersonic solution, taking into account (2.4.33), with the definition of g given in (2.4.18) we have s r
-
8y
Gdx=H(x-kIyI)
r
gdx,
f Ivl
r r (x Gdx=H(x-kjyj)OOJ x gdx,
J oo
lyi
(2.4.22)
54
LINEAR AERODYNAMICS. FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS
such that V given by (2.4.21) is zero outside Mach's dihedron. In a similar manner, in the three-dimensional case we deduce for the component W
W (x, y, z) = - f ie " (G c - iw rx
G$ d x)
J oo
- f2e'11x foo G,, d xx
-he-i- 2"-(1-M2)Gx+(w2-822y)
x
Gdx, 00
(2.4.23)
We notice that using the notation:
s=k y 2 ++z2
(2.4.24)
we may write in the supersonic case W (x, y, z) = H(x - s)w(x, y, z) ,
(jX)
(2.4.25)
where taking into account the definition of g from (2.4.19),
w = -fie
ir'"
k.ix
(.
- f3e-u.,x [2iwg+k2g+(,2_ay)jXgdxj whence we deduce that W is different from zero only in the interior of Mach's cone with the vertex in the origin. Indeed, utilizing the formulas (A.3.9), (2.3.35) and noticing that s8/8y = k2y8/8s, we may write :
82yy /x Gdx=822
[H(x-s)
JT gdxJ =
00
= [H(z
- s)8(k2y/s)8,j gd= H(x - s)8J g d x
and from
GdxJ =H(x-S) {g=-iw f g2dx)
8s\\`G-iwJ 00
it follows the formula (2.4.25).
.J.
55
THE FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS OF THE OSCILLATORY SYSTEM
2.4.4
The Incompressible Fluid
The (oscillatory) solutions for the incompressible fluid may be obtained considering Al = 0 in (2.4.4), or directly in the subsonic solution. So, in the two-dimensional case we deduce from (2.4.5): P(x, Y) =
I xf! + 02
(2 . 4 . 26 )
2
The general form of the equation (2.4.15) for M = 0 is G = g exp (iwx),
(2.4.27)
where Og = 0. One obtains therefore: G(x, y) =
exr (i x)
ln(x2 + y2) .
(2.4.28)
For the three-dimensional problem we have:
(f V) T ,
P(x, y, z)
with the notation r = 2.4.5
G(x, y, z)
ex (iwx)
(2.4.29)
x2 + y2 +-2.
The Fundamental Solutions In the Case M = 1
If Al = 1, E is the solution of the equation (2.4.23), and G, the solution of the equation
Gyy + C_. - 2iwG,. - w2G = 8(z) .
(2.4.30)
C is determined like E. They have the form:
E = H(x)e, G = H(a)g.
(2.4.31)
In the two-dimensional case. e and g have the expressions:
e=-
a
.exp
(x+ T
\ g=-
2
exp
)J , l2 (x- (2.4.32)
with the notation utilized in (2.4.26) for a. The solution given by (2.4.5) and (2.4.21) is P(x, Y) = H(x)(fies + f2eg) (2.4.33)
V (x, y) = H(x)v(x, y),
56
LINEAR AERODYNAMICS. FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS
where
v(x, y) = - f le-iwx [gy - iw J xgy (r, y) d r]
-
Q
(2.4.34)
[2ig + w2
f2C-
g(r, y) d TJ
Ix
J0
In the three-dimensional case, utilizing (2.2.6) we deduce:
p-(
1
C = - ----- ex 4irx
iw
2x
t2
_
1
J
,
-1
4'rr
2 2 x- y+Z
iw
exp
x
2
(2.4.35)
Taking into account (2.4.5) and (2.4.23), it follows
P(x, y, z) = H(x)(fie. + f2e,, + f3e=) (2.4.36)
W(x, y, z) = H(x)w(x, y, z), where -fie-Lox
w(x, y, z) =
rgz - iw
jx1
''j
x { - fee
gy d x-
//
- f3e-twx [2iwg + (w2 - ayy)
x
g dx
.
J
Q
The integrals from (2.4.37) have a strong singularity in the origin, but they are convergent, as it results from the following calculus indicated by V.Iftiinic:
!
/Oz
gd r
fJf
47r
bin ,
4T
hm e\O
r -exp
!02
r
I i (br `
fT r exp { i (6T F
lL
r= exp (ibr) - 1 exp
2l) l d r -2\1Jff
T!
f
J
dT 1
(-i- I d r + EimQ fJ T exp f\-- i
idt.
The first limit exists because exp (-ice /r) is a bounded function. In the second integral we perform the change of variable r = 1/t and we integrate by parts. We obtain:
inn J T
ce/z
(_!)dr=j
exp (-iC'-t)
jt =
57
FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS OF THE UNSTEADY SYSTEM 1
x
iC2
= 2 exp (x )
f
0c
2
dt
exp (-ic t) t2 .
~ ir2 The last integral is obviously convergent. The solution (2.4.33) was given in {10.20) and the solution (2.4.36), in [10.17]. They can be also obtained as limits of the subsonic solutions.
Indeed, for P given by (2.4.6) and (2.4.7) one utilizes (2.4.27) and (2.4.28). A similar calculus may be performed for G given by (2.4.16) and (2.4.17). Passing to the limit for M \ 1, we get g given by (2.4.32) respectively g given by (2.4.35). This section was written entirely on the basis of the papers [10.17]-[10.20].
Fundamental Solutions of the Unsteady System I
2.5 2.5.1
Fundamental Solutions
In this section we determine the fundamental solution of the system (2.1.51), i.e. the solution of the system
pt+c2divv=0, vt+gradp= f6(t.x) (2.5.1)
liim(p,v)=0. 00
We already know that this system determines the perturbation produced in the fluid at rest, having the density po and the pressure po, by a force having the intensity f, applied instantaneously (at the moment t = 0) in the origin of the system of coordinates (on the Oz axis in the case of the two-dimensional problem). Utilizing Duhamel's principle, we deduce that the solution of the system (2.5.1) has the form:
(p, v) = H(t)(P, V) ,
(2.5.2)
where H(t) is Heaviside's function and (P, V) is a solution of the system
Pt+c2divV =0, P(0, x) = 0,
lim(P, V) 00
Vt+gradP=0 V (0, a) = f 6(x)
(2.5.3)
0.
Applying the Fourier transform, we deduce the system (2.5.4)
58
LINEAR AERODYNAMICS. FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS
which has to be integrated with the conditions
P(0) = 0, V (O) = f .
(2.5.5)
The solution of this system is f)(1-coscla(tl
P=cia. f5inlcall It, V = f+ia(ia
J
2
,
such that, by inversion, we have:
P(t,x) _ -c(f . V).F-i
Csinclaltl
.
)
1C O
(2.5.6)
(1- Cos cla It 1
V (t' x) = fo(x) + V (f V ).F`'
C,,2
.
Utilizing the formulas (A.7.14) and (A.7.22), with the notation r = lxl, we deduce the following fundamental solution for the three-dimensional problem: P(t,x)=-(f.V)d(ct-r)
41rt (2.5.7)
V(t,x) = f6(x) + V(f V)
H(ct - r) 47rr
and for the two-dimensional problem,
P(t, x) = -
c
H(ct - r)
(f V) ct2-r' 21r (2.5.8)
r) Inct+ VCr t -r
V(t,x)=f6(x)+V(f
These are the solutions of the system (2.5.3).
2.5.2
Fundamental Matrices
The solution of the system (2.5.1) has been determined for the first time by means of matrices in (2.6]. As we shall see, in some applications it is preferable to use fundamental matrices. We introduce therefore the matrices:
0c200
00c20
000c2
0000 1000 ] 0000 Q= 0000 ,R- 1000 ,S= 0000 1000 0000 0000
,
(2.5.9)
FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS OF THE UNSTEADY SYSTEM 1
VT
= fir,
U, V, W1, FT
59
= (0. f1, f2, f3J,
u, v, w representing the components of the vector v and fl, f2, f3, the components of the vector f. The system (2.5.1) is written as follows:
Vt+QV=+RV,+SVL =F6(t,x) (2.5.10)
V(t, oo) = 0.
Introducing the matrix L. such that
V .- LF,
(2.5.11)
we deduce:
Le + QL,, + RLy + SL,. = E6(t, x) (2.5.12)
L(t, oo) = 0,
E representing the unit matrix with 4 x 4 elements. Utilizing Duhamel's principle, we deduce that the solution of the equation (2.5.12) has the form
L = H(t) K(t, x), where
(2.5.13)
Kt+QKx+RKy+SKs=0 (2.5.14)
K(0, x) = EJ(x)
,
K(t, oo) = 0 .
Applying the Fourier transform to the problem (2.5.14), we deduce:
k,=.U, k(0,a) = E,
(2.5.15)
where 0
A=icr1Q+i02R+ia3S=i
C2a1 C202 C2a3 01 0 0 0 a2 0 0 0 0 a3 0 0
The solution of the problem (2.5.15) has the form:
K = Eexp(At).
(2.5.16)
It is well known that for determining the function exp (At) one may employ two classical methods: the method of matrix functions and the
LINEAR AERODYNAMICS. FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS
60
method of the minimal polynomial. We shall utilize herein the method of the minimal polynomial described in 2.6.2. The eigenvalues of the matrix A are Al = 0, \2,3 = ±i laic, the first one being multiple of order two. One deduces that the minimal polynomial has the form
a(A - a2)(-\ - a3) = a(a2 + a2c'2) . Comparing this form with (2.6.13), we obtain
(?p=a2=0,
ai =-a2c2
Hence, the equations (2.6.18), (2.6.1.9) and (2.6.17) become
-
9oft
2c2921
go = 0,
92(0) = 9'2(0) = 0, !f2(0)
go (0) = 1,
9i = -c12c292 + 90,
91(0) = 0 .
K has the form Ego + Agl + A-2g2. We get:
k = E+ Asmclalt + A21 - COSCktIt C202 Clal
Using the inverse Fourier transform we obtain:
K(t,x)=E6(x)+AY-1 I
sinclalt+A2.._t
1 -c:asclaltclal
c2a2
J
where, for the three-dimensional case, 0 A
C2ar Clay c2as
ox ay
0 0
0 0
0 0
a_
0
0
0
Utilizing the formulas (A.7.14) and (A.7.22), we deduce that the matrix K has the form: H(ct - r) (2.5.17)
K(t,x) = Eb(x) + 4tAb(ct - r) + 4ac2A2
71
In the two-dimensional case we have:
K(t, x) = Eb(x) + +
1
27rc2
1
21rc
A
H(ct - r) +
c t - r' VC-It-
A2 H(ct-r)Inct+ r
-r
(2.5.18)
FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS OF THE UNSTEADY SYSTEM 1
A=-
61
0 CZC7z c28y 0 0 ax a, 0 0
The formulas (2.5.13), (2.5.17) and (2.5.18) give the fundamental matrices.
2.5.3
Cauchy's Problem
We shall prove in the sequel that the solution of the problem Vt + QVz + RVt, + SV. = F(t, x)
V(0, x) = 0,
(2.5.19)
V(t, oo) = 0
(2.5.20)
is c
V(t,x)=1 K*Fdt,
(2.5.21)
0
where
K*F= f 3K(t-r,x-4)F(r,4)d4=f K(r,4)F(t-r,x-4)d4 is a convolution. Indeed, taking into account (2.5.14), we have:
Vt=K*FLt +
t
f K,*Fdr, 0
t
QVz+RVv+SVs=J (QKx+RKv+SK=)*Fdt, 0
V +QVs+RVy+SVz
F(t,x). fR3
The conditions (2.5.20) are obviously verified, because K(t, oo) = 0. Taking into account (2.5.17) and (2.5.18), with the notation p = _ fit', it follows for the solution of the problem (2.5.19), in the three-
62
LINEAR AERODYNAMICS. FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS
dimensional case,
V(t,x)
.fu F(-r,x)d-r +
4c A
r
c
Jr3 F(t-
-r, x - t)6(cr - p) d t +
, A2 I d r fa F (t-
irC"
-r,x - ls)
3
H(cr-P)d P
(2.5.22)
and in the two-dimensional case, r1
V (t, x)
= foF(r,x)dr+2xc AI
u
-T,x~4)
H(crr _
I dTI2F(te
p) d4+2 VR-T P2
A2
p2dt.
-r,x-E)H(cr-P)III Cr+ P
(2.5.23)
2.5.4
The Perturbation Produced by a Mobile Source
We shall apply the above formulas for determining the perturbation produced in the fluid at rest (having the density po and the pressure po) by a force of intensity f . whose application point moves uniformly, with the velocity v, in the direction of the Ox axis and in the negative sense. This problem, also considered in [2.6), is important in aerodynamics because it models the leading edge of an uniformly moving airplane in the air at rest. The solution is obtained from (2.5.22) replacing
F(t, x) = Fo6(x + vt)6(y, x),
(2.5.24)
63
FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS OF THE UNSTEADY SYSTEM 1
where Fo' = (0, fl, f2, f3). One finds V(t,x)=FDH(x,+vt)o(y,a)+4I
R,)
AFD.I D
t
l A2Fo f +zirc-
H(
dr+
b(cr
_ RT) d
(2.5.25)
where
R, _
x + vt - vr)2 + y2 + z2 .
(2.5.26)
For calculating these integrals we have to study the behaviour of the function h(r) = c-r - R,r , (2.5.27) on the interval (0, oo). We shall proceed like in 2.2.4. Because h(O) < 0
and h(oo) = (c2 - v2)oo. we have to separate the subsonic flow case (v < c) from the supersonic flow case (v > c). The zeros of the function h(r) are given by the formula (c2
where
- v2)r+ = -v(x + vt) ± R,
R = [(x + vt)2c2 + (c2 - v2)(y2 + z2), 1/2
(2.5.28)
.
(2.5.29)
In the subsonic case, only r+ is positive. If the velocity of the source
is supersonic (v > c), the function h(r) has two zeros (r+ < 'r-) if /to > 0 and no zero if !to < 0. We denoted ho = h(ro), ro representing the zero of the derivative of the function h,
vro=x+vt+
cr0
Vv-
(2.5.30)
It results,
vho = c(x + vt) -
(v2 - c2)(y2 + z2).
(2.5.31)
Utilizing the relation crfh'(r ) = ±R which may be verified directly, and the formula (2.2.38), we deduce
f
' 6(cr - R') T
0
dr =
cR-1 H(t -,r+),
if v < c,
cR-1JH(t-r+)+H(t-r_)J, if v>candho>0, 10,
if v > c and ho < 0.
(2.5.32)
64
LINEAR AERODYNAMICS. FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS
In the same time, taking into account the definition of Heaviside's, function we have:
JtH(CRr) dRr v
- v In c(x +
vt)
c(x + vt) + R R,
if(v
c,ho>0,t c, ho > 0, t >T-,
-;-
if v>c,ho<0.
0,
(2.5.33)
Now the solution (2.5.25) is explicit. The solution of this problem may be also obtained directly (without using the formula (2.5.22)) [1.10].
The interpretation of the solution is similar to the interpretation from (2.2.4).
Fundamental Solutions of the Unsteady System II
2.6 2.6.1
The Fundamental Matrices
In this section we determine, using the papers [2.71 and [2.9], the fundamental solutions of the system (2.1.26), (2.5.27), i.e. the solutions of the system
M2(pt+p=)+divv=0 vi + v;r + grad p = f a(t, x)
(2.6.1)
limp, v) = 0. 00
Introducing the matrices
Q=
1
1
0 0
0 0
00 10 ' 01
000M-2
00x1'20
1 M'200 R=
00
0
10
0
00 0
0 0 0
_ ' S
000 0 000 0 100 0
and the matrices V and F defined in (2.5.9), the system (2.6.1) may be written like in (2.5.10). We shall proceed like in the previous section. Considering
V = H(t)K(t, x)F,
(2.6.2)
65
FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS OF THE UNSTEADY SYSTEM II
one obtains the following equation for k : Kt = AK, where
K(0, a) = E,
(2.6.3)
al a1M-2 02M -2 a3M-2 al
A=i
a2 CM
1
0
0
0 0
1
0
0
1
The roots of the characteristic polynomial are:
Al = ial,
A2,3 = i (al ± lalM-1),
(2.6.4)
the first root being double. One verifies that the minimal polynomial has the form
(A-A1)(A-A2)(A-,13) = (A-ial)3+a21tf-2(a-ia1). Comparing with (2.6.13) it results: a2 = 3i a1, al = 3a2 - 02M-2, ao = i a1(a2M-2 -
a2).
(2.6.5)
k has the form K = Ego(t) + Ag1(t) + A2g2(t) ,
(2.6.6)
the functions 90, 91, 92 being determined by the equations gg2 - a292 - a19o2 - aog2 = 0, 92(0) = g2(0) = 0, 92(0) = 1, (2.6.7)
goo = ao92, 90(0) = 1,
901 = a1.92 + go, 91(0) = 0.
Determining these functions, .%v find:
go = I 1 -
ioM
lal t la) sin M
M2 - a?a2
/ I
1 - o0c1
lalt`1
M JJ
/ m sin lal t - 2ia?M2 a2 1 -cos lal t J
91
=
9'2
(al 1 exp(ialt). = a/ - aft
_
M
M
exp(i alt),
exP(i a1 t),
1112
1
(2.6.8)
LINEAR AERODYNAMICS. FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS
66
In the three-dimensional case one utilizes the formulas (A.7.15) and (A.7.23). From (2.6.6) it follows the fundamental matrix:
K(t, x) = Eb(2- t)b(y, z) + 4 +
(E
t
R)+
(EOY +
+2A8,.+A')11(tA1R
-R} (2.6.9)
where R = V(2--- t)2 + YT-A- z2 and
A = -
AI'28y M 2(9:
8r A1'2O 0. a2 0
8=
0
0
0
0
Sr
0
ay
In the two-dimensional case one utilizes the formulas (A.7.15) and (A.7.23). From (2.6.6) one obtains the following fundamental matrix: A12
K(t, x) = Eb(x - t, y) + -(EO + A) 2"
+
where R=
(
A122
2-r
H(t -- AM) jt72
+
A12R2
(O_ + 2A87 + A2}H(t - AIR) In t i
+_
t2 - A12
nip
(2.6.10)
- t)- y2 and 8? A
AI'28,. M-28y
8=
0.1
0
8y
0
8t
lit [1.10] and [2.7] one gives some applications which are important for aerodynamics. We mention the mobile source on the direction of the unperturbed stream and the mobile source on the direction perpendicular to the same stream.
2.6.2
The Method of the Minimal Polynomial
In the sequel we present the method utilized for determining the function exp (At). Let A be a matrix with n x n elements and let At, ... , Ak(k < n) be its eigenvalues, i.e. the roots of the characteristic polynomial
A(A) = det (AE - A)
.
FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS OF TIIE UNSTEADY SYSTEM II
67
Obviously,
0(a) = (A - A1)m1
... ()1 - A )mk ,
(2.6.11)
where ml + ... + ink = n. The minimal polynomial associated to the matrix A is by definition the polynomial with the smallest degree which has the property
P(A) = 0.
(2.6.12)
Let
-... - a1,\ - ao P(A) = am be this polynomial. Obviously, m < n, because .(A) = 0. am-la,n-I
(2.6.13)
From (2.6.12) and (2.6.13) it results m-1
Am=
EajA''
j=0
and step by step m-1
Am+p
= E aln) A3 ,
p = 0, 1, 2, .. .
jO Taking into account that the exponential is a power series, we deduce
that there exist the functions go(t), ... , g.-1(t) .
such that
exp(At) = goE+g1A+...+gm_1A"-1
(2.6.14)
We have:
A exp (At) = goA +... + +9,n-1(ao E + al A + ... + a,,,-1 Am-1 ) , gm_2A'n-1+
( 2. 6 .15)
On the other hand,
A exp(At) = (d/(It) exp(At) = g(E+g'A+...+g',,,-lAm-1. (2.6.16) Since P(A) is unique, from (2.6.15) and (2.6.16) we obtain:
90=ao9m-1791 =a19+n-1+go,...,9in_1 =a+n-19m-1+9m-2 (2.6.17)
68
LINEAR AERODYNAMICS. FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTIONS
We deduce that 9m_1 is the solution of the differential equation 1rn?1
= am-1g(n1 1' -#- ... + olgVn- 1 + (109,n-1 ,
(2.6.18)
with the following initial conditions: g,,
1(0) = girl -1(0) = ... = girl1(0) _ 0, g
(in-1) 1' (0) = 1 .
(2.6.19)
The functions go, ... , gin-2 are determined from (2.6.17) with the cu conditions 90(0) = 1,91(0) = 0,---,9,,.-2(0) = 0-
(2.6.20)
imposed by (2.6.14). In fact, for determining the minimal polynomial, one takes into ac-
count that it is a divisor of the characteristic polynomial, hence it has the form:
P(A) = (A - A0," (A - A2)u'2 ... (A - Ak)' = = A"-on,-1Arn-1 -...-ao,
(2.6.21)
nj < mj and n1 + n2 + ... + nk = in. To conclude, we try with divisors having the form (2.6.21), beginning with the simplest where
(ill = n2 = ... = nk = 1) in order to satisfy the equation P(A) = 0. from the University of Bucharest We mention that dr. *t. has communicated us this method.
Chapter 3 The Infinite Span Airfoil in Subsonic Flow
The Airfoil in the Unlimited Fluid
3.1 3.1.1
The Statement of the Problem
In this subsection we determine the perturbation produced by a thin infinite cylindrical body in a subsonic uniform stream having the velocity UQ,i, the pressure pQ, and the density p,,. We assume that
the generators of the cylinder are perpendicular on the velocity of the unperturbed stream which is parallel to the xOy reference plane. The cylindrical bodies are bodies with constant cross-section and the infinite cylinders are cylinders which are long enough, such that the effects of the end conditions over the flow in the rOy plane may be neglected. Under these assumptions ( the conditions which determine the perturbation are not varying in time and they are the same in every plane parallel to xOy), the perturbed flows of the fluid will be stationary and plane. Ua
Y
Fig. 3.1.1.
% Te utilize the variables r , y, z introduced in (2.1.1) and the per-
turbations p and v defined by (2.1.3). In figure 3.1.1 one presents the profile determined by the intersection of the cylindric body with the xOy plane. We denote by
y = la(x) ± hl(x)
(3.1.1)
the equations of the curves C+ (the upper surface) and C_ (the
70
THE INFINITE SPAN AIRFOIL IN SUBSONIC FLOW
lower surface). The curve having the equation y = h(z) gives the so called skeleton of the profile. For imposing the boundary conditions we use the projection of the profile onto the Ox axis (the direction of the unperturbed stream). Defining Lo from (2.1.1) as the half length of this projection and taking the origin of the axes of coordinates in the middle
of the projection, it follows that the functions h(x) and h1(x) have to be defined on the segment [-1,+1]. We assume that these functions have continuous first order derivatives and that the derivative h(x) satisfies Holder's condition (see Appendix B). The cylinder is thin if h(x) = Fh(x),h1(x) = Eh1(x)
e representing a small parameter. We notice that whatever would be the equations of the curves C+ and C_, they may be written like in (3.1.1). Indeed, if the equations would be y = h±(x) = ehf(x), they might take the form (3.1.1) putting
h+(x) + h_ (x) = 2h(x), h+(x) - h- (x) = 2h1(x). Taking into account the equations (3.1.1) the following conditions have to be satisfied v(x, ±0) = h(x) ± 14 (x), Ix I < 1
(3.1.2)
as it follows from (2.1.32).
3.1.2 A Classical Method The classical methods for solving this problem rely on the assumption that the perturbation is potential. We have therefore v = grad Sp(x, y).
(3.1.3)
The potential p which is defined in the exterior of the segment [-1, +11 from the xOy plane, is the solution of the equation (3.1.4)
P"P:: +'p1,s, = 0
with the boundary conditions jpi,(x, f0) = h'(x) ± h4 (x) ,
JxJ< 1
(3.1.5)
and the condition at infinity z
lim00(P_, spy) = 0
(3.1.6)
71
THE AIRFOIL IN THE UNLIMITED FLUID
which follows from (2.1.28).
Using Clauert's transformation x, y -, X, Y:
X=x,
Y=fiy,
(3.1.7)
one obtains from (3.1.3) and (3.1.4)
u=six -- U,
v =A(PY=QV
sOxx +'PYY = 0
(3.1.8)
(3.1.9)
in the exterior of the segment [-1,+11 from the XOY plane. The boundary conditions (3.1.5) and the conditions at infinity (3.1.6) become
V (X, fO) = h'(X) f hi (X),
1X 1 < 1
lira (U,V)=0. X -»- cc
(3.1.10)
The problem was solved by many authors (see for example Birnbaum [3.51, [3.61, Sohngen [A.34), Sedov [1.38], p.47, Iacob [1.21), p.661), by means of one of the following two methods: reduction of the problem to an ntegral equation which is then solved or the reduction of the problem
to a boundary value problem in the complex plane. We also mention the methods relying on the expansion of the solution in a Fburier series. (Glauert [3.211 and Atei. inger (3.491).
In the sequel we give one of the most natural methods for reducing the problem to an integral equation. We represent the holomorphic function W = U - iV in the Z = X + iY plane with the cut [-1, +1] on the real xis, by means of the Cauchy integral
W(Z)=-L
r -f(t)+I t(t)dt,
(3.1.11)
where f(t) and fl(t) are unknown real Holder functions. It is easy to understand the significance of this representation. W(Z) Is the sum of the complex velocity determined by a continuous superposition of squrm having the intensity fm on the segment [-1, +1) and the complex velocity determined by a continuous superposition of vortices having the circulation f, on the same segment. In fact, the integral containing f may also be regarded as a continuous superposition of doublets on the segment [-1, +1] from the (Z) plane. Obviously; W(Z) is a holomorphic function in the exterior of the
segment [-1, +11 and it vanishes for Z -+ oo. Hence, U and V
THE INFINITE SPAN AIRFOIL IN SUBSONIC FLOW
72
satisfy the equation (3.1.9) and the condition (3.1.10). In order to prove this we pass to the limit considering Z - X ;k i 0, where X E (-1, + 1). Using Pleme(j's formulas (B.3.1) and separating the real part from the imaginary one we obtain:
2f(X)+2- /
U(X,±0)= V(X,±0) =
2ft(X) -
t
2zr,
it()dt
(3.1.12)
tfit) dt.
(3.1.13)
The mark"' " indicates the principal value in Cauchy's sense (Appendix B). From (2.1.38), (3.1.8) and (3.1.12) it follows
p(x, +0) - p(x, -0) = U(X, -0) - U(X, +0) = f (x).
(3.1.14)
This relation puts into evidence the significance of the function f (x).
It will be fundamental for the determination of the lift and moment coefficients.
Imposing the conditions (3.1.10) in (3.1.13), adding and subtracting the relations just obtained, we find Q
T
/ tdt _
= -2h' ( X)
JX i < 1 ,
Oft(X) = -2h4(X) JXi < 1.
(3 . 1 . 15)
(3.1.16)
The relation (3.1.16) determines the function Of, and (3.1.15) represents an integral singular equation for the determination of the function Of. It is the well known equation of thin profiles which was put into evidence by Birnbaum in 1923 and solved by Sohngen in 1939. Its solution, given in Appendix C, will be written in (3.1.25).
We notice that the thickness of the profile is ensured by the distribution of sources (ht = 0 ft = 0) and the discontinuity of the pressure (hence the lift and moment coefficients) is ensured by the distribution of vortices.
3.1.3
The Fundamental Solutions Method
There is no physical justification for replacing the wing by a continuous distribution of sources and vortices. It is more natural to replace the wing by a continuous distribution of forces and to determine the
73
THE AIRFOIL IN THE UNLIMITED FLUID
intensity of these forces, in order to obtain the same action against the fluid like in the case of the wing. Indeed, the fluid and the wing are two interacting systems. If we want to determine the motion of the first subsystem, we have to replace the action of the second subsystem by a distribution of forces. This is the basic idea of the fundamental solutions method. We shall replace the wing by a continuous distribution of forces f = (fl, f) on the segment [+1, -1], having the intensity f a priori unknown (the intensity will depend on the point). In fact, for obtaining a plane perturbation, the forces have to be uniformly applied on parallels to the Oz axis, intersecting the xOy plane in the points of the segment [-1,+11. Taking into account the formulas (2.3.23), it will result the following perturbation in the fluid:
p(x,y) = (x, v) _
1 27r#I f
+1 xof1() X02
+ #2y2 (3.1.17)
/+t xof(t) -yfi(E)d 21r ./
1
xo + 82y2
In view of imposing the boundary conditions (3.1.2) we have to calculate
ylimo v(x, y) for jxj < 1. Denoting by v(x, ±0) these limits, we have
u(x, f0) =
Q
lim 2ir y--±o
f+1 xof W 1
(3.1.18)
xo + 02y2
The first integral represents the tangential derivative of a simple layer potential and the second the normal derivative of the same potential. Although the formulas which give the limits of these derivatives are known, we prefer to calculate them directly. If we pass to the limit in the first integral making y = 0, we cannot
simplify with x0 because for
= x it is zero. We shall divide this
integral in three parts. Since for a e small enough, we may approximate
f
on the segment (x - e, x + E) with f (x), we deduce performing the substitution - x = u,
:+C xoM) _
#2y2
+`
ud u
I-C U2 +Qty 2
74
THE INFINITE SPAN AIRFOIL IN SUBSONIC FLOW
the integrand being an odd function. It remains +1
lim
xof W
d+
r:- E f
d- -lim E-.0 l J (
V-±0 J1 xo2+ 1
zo
1
r1 f(_)
Ji x-4
f
d J
=
d
excepting
zero,
The second limit from (3.1.18) is
f1
Jx.c xo
the
(3.1.19) interval
(x - s, x + e) where the integrand is infinite for y = 0 and f = x. Approximating again f j (C) by f, (x), or applying the mean formula, since f i is integrable and multiplied by an integrable factor having a constant sign, we get: Yli
m
J
lm Y
114 +a
fi(x)vuy f,
+ uZ
v(x,
0)
°J
y
-Z0'
f
±f1(x) -
d
(_)
Imposing the boundary conditions (3.1.2), adding and subtracting, we get: Q
f
(4)
d _ -2h'(x),
(3.1.21)
(x).
(3.1.22)
fi(x) _
We also have
P(x, fU) =
fi(e
f2f(x) + 2WQ
(3.1.23)
such that f (x) has the same significance like in (3.1.14). The sntegral equations (3.1.15) and (3.1.21) coincide. In fact, the representation (3.1.11) may also be obtained from the fundamental solution. This representation is valid for the points which do not belong to the semi-axis Ox (x > 1). Indeed in these points we
have u = -p, such that
u- v=
1
1
2
i -f (S) + i P
J_i
-Z
.11(x)
df
'
(3.1.24)
75
THE AIRFOIL IN THE UNLIMITED FLUID
where Z = x + i fly. We see from (3.1.16) and (3.1.22) that instead of Of, from (3.1.11) we put here fl. The equivalence just established shows that the formula (3.1.11) is not valid on Ox (x > 1). On this half-line the flow is not irrotational. We mention finally that the proof of Plemelj's formulas (which are necessary for obtaining the integral equation (3.1.15)) is anyway more difficult than the proof of the formulas (3.1.19) and (3.1.20). 3.1.4 The Function f (x). The Complex Velocity in the Fluid The solution (bounded in the trailing edge) of the integral equations (3.1.15) and (3.1.21) are obtained from the formula (C.1.9). We have therefore: (x)=
Of
2 V -x' 44 /iTih'(t)d t. tt x l+xf
(3.1.25)
1
Obviously, for the symmetric profile (h = 0) it results f = 0. One obtains the complex velocity substituting (3.1.16) and (3.1.25) in (3.1.11). Since, taking into account the formulas (B.5.5) and (B.5.7), we deduce
_
dt 11-t 1+t (t-Z)(s-t)
+1
1
+1
1
t
1
a
1 Z+t(tZ+st)dt=
Z
1
s-Z Z+1'
it follows
W(Z)
h'
I
-- A J-11 t'(Zdt+ i
+zr(3
Z
1
Z+1
f,
+1
(3.1.26)
1+ t h` (t)
1-tt-Z d t
For the incompressible fluid (f3 = 1) one obtains the formula (t) u-iv=-1AJf 1 hit-z dt+ i
+
-
z_ i
+1 J
+l /rTih (t) 1
(3.1.27)
1-tt-zdt'
where z = x+iy. The formula (3.1.27) was given for the first time by Sedov [1.38], p.51 and deduced in a different manner by lacob [1.21), p.664,
76
THE INFINL'I'E SPAIN AIRFOIL IN SUBSONIC FLOW
which solved the problem (3.1.9), (3.1.10) reducing it to a boundary value problem in the complex plane. It is not simpler to solve the bound-
ary value problem than solving the singular integral equation (C.1.1). Moreover, the complex velocity field is not of much interest in aerodynamics. It is utilized only for determining the jump of the pressure on the profile (which is calculated directly in the framework of the method of the integral equations).
3.1.5
The Calculation of the Aerodynamic Action
In some papers the aerodynamic action is calculated by means of a curvilinear integral on the contour of the profile. This calculation is wrong for contours with angular points. A correct calculation is performed using a control contour (surface in the three-dimensional case) surrounding the profile (wing). We shall perform this calculation where it will be absolutely necessary. Here we shall give a simple calculation, observing that in the first approximation, the action of the fluid comes
from the jump of the pressure pl(xl, -0) - pi(xi, +0) = Dpi 1, which gives the lifting force, parallel to the Oy axis. Taking into account the formulas (2.1.1) and (2.1.3) on the unity of length of the cylinder, it follows the lifting force
L= I
(IPi I dxI = P.UULo
J
I i [!pO d x
(3.1.28)
and the following momentcalculated with respect to the point x°:
MI
=fJ to (xi - x°) x pt ?d xi ,
where j represents the versor of the Oy axis. We obtain MI = Mk, where
rfi
M = poU020Lo J
(r - x°)OpOdx.
(3.1.29)
We denoted
Bp0 = P(x, -0) - p(x, +0)
(3.1.30)
Instead of the dimensional quantities L and M, it is preferable to use the dimensionless quantities CL and chl, named the lift coefficient respectively the moment coefficient. These aerodynamic coefficients are defined by the formulas: L M CL,
= (l/2)PooU2 (2Lo) '
cA'
= (1/2)p.U,
(3.1.31)
77
ME AIRFOIL IN THE UNLIMITED FLUID
It is preferable to use the dimensionless aerodynamic coefficients because
the numerical calculations are performed for dimensionless quantities. From (3.1.14), (3.1.28)-(3.1.30), and (3.1.31) it results CL
=-
f
+1
f (x)d x, cAt = i
-12
J
'
(x - x°)f (x)d x .
(3.1.32)
i
Finally, utilizing the solution (3.1.25), (B.5.4) and (B.6.9) we get
cL-
h(3.1.33)
r+i JY
CAf=-i13 J-1 f V
±tth'(t)dt- 1
2x°cL.
1
(3.1.34)
In the case of the profiles which are symmetric with respect to the Ox
axis, (h = 0), cL and cM vanish. Obviously we cannot use the method for calculating the drag because
it has the order e2
3.1.6
Examples
The flat plate. For the flat plate having the angle of attack (fig. 3.1.2a)), the equation (3.1.1) is
E
y = -xtgE = -Ex. It follows
h(x) = -.ex whence CL=
27re
ire
CM= -(x° + 2)A 1
(3.1.35)
These formulas were given for the first time by Glauert (1928) and Prandtl (1930). For the incompressible fluid (M = 0) one obtains CL = 27rE,
1l
cAf = - z° + 2) Ire
(3.1.36)
We notice that CL is increasing (c,%f is decreasing) for M / 1 (fig. 3.1.3) (the lift is increasing because of the compressibility). In the vicin-
ity of M = 1 (starting approximately with Al = 0.8) the lift has very great values, in contradiction with the reality. We deduce that in the vicinity of M = 1 the linear theory is not valid any longer. Therefore, for the transonic flow (Chapter-9) we shall utilize other equations. From (3.1.25) one obtains the jump of the pressure
THE INFINITE SPAN AIRFOIL IN SUBSONIC FLOW
78
U.
b) r
c) Fig. 3.1.2.
CI
2ttE
M 0.8
1
Fig. 3.1.3.
/if = -2e
1
V +
x
(3.1.37)
The parabolic profile (fig. 3.1.2b)). This profile is obtained for h(x) = e (I - x2), h1 = 0. Utilizing (B.6.9) we find CL =
Ze 73
°f=-
7r
Cm
1 - xa
(3.1.38)
with the same interpretation for cG.
The S-profile (fig. 3.1.2c)). For h(x) = e(x - x3) and hl (x) = 0, we obtain CL
- x°)
A , CH = 4,6 (
j
,
f = V-x + Tx 1+x
--X 2 (3.1.39)
1
The profile with thickness, having the shape of an elliptic sector For a profile having the shape of a sector bounded by two arcs
THE AIRFOIL IN THE UNLIMITED FLUID
79
of ellipse having the small semi-axes e2 < ei (fig. 3.1.4), we have
h+(x) _ -62 VI -X
h_(x)
,
x7, (3.1.40)
2h(x) = -(i, + s2) 1 - x
2h1(x) = (El -- 62W1 -X*
,
.
uw
Fig. 3.1.4.
For f, and f ,
taking into account the representation (3.1.16) and
(3.1.25) we deduce
Aft = (F1 - E2)
lx x v-
3f =
,
-
dt
t
1-t 1-t t -x
X
e2
1
?r
+xI
f' 1-x t-x
where
1+t
£l
x
dt +
1
1-x
(3.1.41)
+1 dt 1
1-t
Per forming the change of variable 1 -- t = u and taking into account (D.2.3), we get 7* +l 1ddu 1
,/ 1- t = `r2
u = in 2.
(3.1.42)
Utilizing (B.5.8) we get 1(3f =
El i Ex
/ I
\
x . In 2 + x In l + x)
(3.1.43)
Ale also have £1 +F2
2-
dt
_ 61+12(2--1n2), (3.1.44)
CMS _ -
£12x°(2 - In 2). 2/3
The action of the fluid is equivalent to a lifting force passing through the origin.
80
THE INFINITE SPAN AIRFOIL IN SUBSONIC FLOW
3.1.7 The General Case It is well known that the Chebyshev polynomialsof first kind
T,,(t) = cos(n arccost)
(3.1.45)
constitute a basis on the interval (-1, +1). We shall consider the series
expansion of h(t) in this basis: h'(t) = E an cos(n arccos t).
(3.1.46)
t=ooso
(3.1.47)
Putting it follows
co
h'(cos a) _ E an cos no n-U
whence j" h'(cos8)d6,
ao
an = 2
0
7r
7T
jh1(cos0)cosn0d0, (3.1.48)
n= 1,2,...
Substituting (3.1.46) in (3.1.33) and (3.1.34) and performing the change of variable (3.1.47), one obtains 2n cf,
ao +
al 2
a2\ 7r V cdt = - a ao + al + 2 J.
(3.1.49)
Theses formulas were given by Homentcovschi in (A.201.
It is important to calculate the distribution of the jump of the pressure on the profile. Using the change of variable (3.1.47) and Glauert's formula (B.6.6) we deduce +l 1 + t h'(t) °Q (1 + cos a) cos no-
J
1-tt-xdt=EanJ n-o
coso-cos9
U
=
(3.1.50)
= 7r cot
8 °O
an sin n9,
x = coo 8.
-o
Replacing in (3.1.25) it follows:
pf(x)=2Eansinn8 00 n=0
It is Glauert who proposed this type of solution.
(3.1.51)
THE AIRFOIL IN THE UNLIMITED FLUID
3.1.8
81
Numerical Integrations
In the case of an arbitrary profile, for calculating the integrals (3.1.33)
and (3.1.34) one may employ quadrature formulas (F.2.24). Using the notations
_
tQ-cos
2a-1 a=1,...,n 2n + 1'
(3.1.52)
,
one obtains n
> (1 +
41r
13(2n + 1)
cL
(3.1.53)
CM
-
n
2n -T3
1
a
(1 + ta)tali (tQ) - 2 CL.
(2n -+I) a-
1
For calculating the integral from (3.1.25) one utilizes the formula (F.3.1). In the collocation points 2i7r
xj =
t = 1,...,n,
Cos Fn + 1 ,
(3.1.54)
it results
f(T,)
4
p(2n
+'
1)
X. E 1
+
t
Q=1 Q
- x1 h (tQ)
(3.1.55)
The results obtained with these formulas are much more accurate than the results obtained with other methods.
3.1.9
The Integration of the Thin Airfoil Equation with the Aid of Gauss-type Quadrature Formulas
We may use the quadrature formulas from Appendix F to create and extremely efficient method for determining the solution of the integral equation (3.1.15). There were made many such attempts in various papers but nowhere one can find the good solution because there is not
prescribed the behaviour of the solution in the points ±1. We know from Appendix C that the solution of the above mentioned equation depends on the behaviour imposed in ±1. The solution satisfying the Kutta-Joukovsky condition in the trailing edge is
/3f (t) _ -E
+ t F(t) 1
(3.1.56)
82
THE INFINITE SPAN AIRFOIL IN SUBSONIC FLOW
Using (F.2.19) and posing h = -Eh, we reduce the equation (3.1.15) to the algebraic system n
Ai,F, =hl, j = 1,...,n,
(3.1.57)
a=1
where Fa = F(ta),
h1
= h (xj), A,a =
t-
2n + I '
2n + 1 Qa-
z1 =
x,' (3.1.58)
+ 17r' In (3.1.57) we have a linear algebraic system with n equations for n unknowns Fl, ... , Fn. We can create a computer code for Cos
solving the system. The coefficients AJa, the weight points to and the collocation points xj are the same for every profile. For a given profiles we have to change only the column with the elements h1, ... , K. After determining the unknowns Fa, the lift and moment coefficients result from the formulas (3.1.32) and (F.2.18). CL = - +1 f(t)d t = F t F(t)d t =
j_1I
l+t
Q
(3.1.59) 1
cl=-Z J
+1 1
WE
tf(t)dt=-2ENA1,
where n
ta)F0,
NL a=1
(3.1.60)
a=I
For verifying the method we utilized the analytic solution for the flat plate (3.1.37). From (3.1.56), it follows that for hJ = 1 we must have F = 2. The results obtained with the numerical method described above, with n = 20 gave for F. values situated between 0.999 and 2.001 and for NL and NM the value 0.999. Hence the method is extremely efficient [3.12].
3.2 3.2.1
The Airfoil in Ground Effects The Integral Equation
When an airplane is landing or taking off we have to take into account the ground effects. Some of the first papers devoted to these effects belong to Tomotika and his fellow-workers (3.44], [3.45]. We have also to
83
THE AIRFOIL. IN GROUND EFFECTS
mention the papers of Pancenkov [1.33], [1.34], [3.36], and especially the papers of Plotkin and his fellow-workers [3.37]-(3.39}, where one gives the integral equation of thin profiles in ground effects and one proposes
approximate solutions. The is considered a small parameter. Widnall and Barows (5.37J and Tuck [3.46] used asymptotic methods for investigating the problem. In fact one encountered two small parameters: the arrow of the airfoil and the distance from the airfoil to the ground. The fluid was considered incompressible. In the sequel, following 13.131, we shall utilize the method of funda-
mental solutions, in order to obtain the integral equation for the compressible fluid and for the airfoil with thickness. The small parameter is the arrow of the airfoil. In case that the distance from the airfoil to the ground is also small, we have to elaborate a new theory. We use the notations from the previous subsection. We denote by a/2 the distance from the airfoil to the ground (fig. 3.2.1). The perturbation has to satisfy the following boundary conditions: v(x, f0) = h(x) ± hI (x),
v(x, -a/2) = 0
U.
Ix1 < I.
(3.2.1)
- oo < x < oo .
(3.2.2)
-I
+1
x
T a/2
an
-I
---
- -
+1
Fig. 3.2.L.
According to the method of fundamental solutions, we have to replace the airfoil by a continuous distribution of forces (ft, on the
segment [-1, +1] from the y = 0 axis. For satisfying the boundary condition (3.2.2) we shall consider a symmetric distribution of forces
(fl, -f
on the symmetric segment (-1, +11 of the y = -a axis
and we shall determine the intensity of the distributions from the condition (3.2.1). Taking into account that the perturbation produced within the uniform stream having the velocity U,i by the force (fl, f2) is (2.3.23), it follows that the two distributions will determine in the fluid
84
THE INFINITE SPAN AIRFOIL IN SUBSONIC FLOW
the perturbation
1 J-tf
+t
P(-T' y) =
+
v(x, y) =
1
xoft W + J32yf (t) x02 +,82y2
f
+t
xofi(Q - 132(y + a)f (C) + M(y + ;)-2
A f+t z0f(0 - bf1(0 d
xa +U
1
-
(3.2.3)
1 r+t xofW + (y + a)ft (_) 21r
x0#2(N+a)2
1
f and f j
having to be determined. One easily verifies that this representation satisfies the condition (3.2.2). We denoted xo = x - . Only the first integrals become singular. when passing to limit for y
±0, Using the formulas (3.1.19) and (3.1.20), we deduce
p(x, +0) - p(r., -0) = f (x) ,
f(o d t-
t
v(x, f0)
_
2ft(x)
+ 27r
(3.2.4)
,
(3.2.5)
+1
io+m
11-r
where in = fla. adding, we get:
Imposing the conditions (3.2.1), subtracting and
ft(x) _ -2hi(x) ar
FI fro)
2l
jxi < 1
t1 oo+ in
dt = H(x),
(3.2.6) (3.2.7)
where
H(x) = h'(x) -
A ,l
+t,,,2d 1
xo
(3.2.8)
The equation (3.2.7) is the integral equation In Appendix C it was called the generalized equation of the thin airfoil. For the incompressible fluid (/3 = 1) and for the airfoil without thickness (ht = 0) it coincides with the equation given by Pancenkov and Plotkin.
85
THE AIRFOIL IN GROUND EFFECTS
3.2.2
A Numerical Method
The equation (3.2.7) is obviously a singular integral equation. As we have shown in Appendix C, it may be reduced to a Fredholm equation, but the problem remains still unsolved because there are not available general methods for solving this type of equations (excepting the method of successive approximations). As we have already shown in 13.131, the equation (3.2.7) may be solved numerically utilizing the quadrature formulas from Appendix F. Looking for the solutions of (3.2.7) having the form (3.1.56), putting H = -e and using (F.2.18) and (F.2.19), one obtains the linear algebraic system n 7 1j
.
(3.2.9)
a=1
where FQ = F(t0),
T-1 j = H(xj),
B ra
1
(t° - 1)(xj - t0)
2n + I (xj - tu)2 + m2
(3.2.10)
Aj,,, t,, and xj being given in (3.1.58). From the system (3.2.9) we determine the unknowns F1,. .. , F,,. Now the lift and moment coefficients (3.1.32) (for x° = 0) will be obtained from the formulas CL
J_ !+1
CAI
2{3
I.
(3.2.11)
_
+
t tF(t)d t
2 Nit ,
where we have utilized the notations (3.1.60). One may write computer programs for solving the system (3.2.9). The coefficients Aja and Bj0 do not depend on the shape of the
airfoil, such that the program may be utilized for every airfoil. One changes only the matrix with one column Wj . 3.2.3
The Flat Plate
In the case of the flat plate with the angle of attack we have 77j = 1. We solve the system (3.2.9) and then we determine NL and
THE INFINITE SPAN AIRFOIL IN SUBSONIC FLOW
86
NM with the formulas (3.1.60). We write the aerodynamic coefficients (3.2.11) as follows CL = cL NL,
(3.2.12)
CAf =
where c' and cM are the coefficients for the free stream (a = oo). 5.
NL1 4
3
2.
1.0.6 Mp0
}
1.
0.0
4.0
2.0
6.0
8.0
0.0
4.0
2.0
6.0
8.0 a
a
a)
b)
Fig. 3.2.2.
The variation of NL and NAf versus a is shown in figures 3.2.2a) and 3.2.2b). The compressibility effects on the lift and moment are greater than it is shown in the above mentioned figures, because A also intervenes in c -L4 cy. Obviously, the ground effect is great when a is small and it quickly decreases when a increases. 3.2.4
The Symmetric Airfoil
As we have seen in (3.1.5), for the symmetric airfoil in a free stream with zero angle of attack, the lift and the moment vanish. The situation is different for the wing in ground effects. As we may observe from (3.2.7) and (3.2.8), i i the case of symmetric airfoil (h = 0, hl 0 0), H does not vanish, hence the solution of the equation. (3.2.7) is different from zero. For the Joukovsky symmetric profile considered in 11.28), [3.37], [3.13) y = +E(1 - X) VI - x2
(3.2.13)
THE AIRFOIL IN GROUND EFFECTS
87
we obtain using the notation hl = -(1 - x) 1- x' and the formulas (F.2.12) and (F.2.18):
H =-m
;r J-1 (xj - e)2 + m2 in
P
d_
1 - (-2,
'1
2m
to (1 - trt )
+1F-(,)2+fn2 - 2n+I
E(xj-tn)2)+m2'
(3.2.14)
In this case one presents NL and N11 versus a in figures 3.2.3a) and 3.2.3b) for n = p = 20. The lift coefficient is where
cos y7r
p+
negative i.e. the resultant is a force pointing towards the ground. Hence when the airplane is landing or taking off it becomes heavier. The pilot has to take into account this fact.
- al.bo
- - - Msean6
I
: _
F-
a'l 0.001 l
000
1.60
/
-=-
l
4.00
5.20
a30
410
OAO.
I
000
400
I
1
a 1.60
'20
4.90
640
900
b
a) Fig. 3.2.3.
The fact that both in the case of the flat plate and the case of the symmetric profile, the lift and the moment become very great when a is very small, is not true in reality. Hence, for small values of the parameter
a we have to elaborate a new theory based on two small parameters (see [5.37]).
88
3.3 3.3.1
THE INFINI'T'E SPAN AIRFOIL IN SUBSONIC FLOW
The Airfoil in Tunnel Effects The Integral Equation
The experiments for determining the aerodynamic parameters are performed in wind tunnels. We have therefore to take into account the influence of the walls of the tunnel an the aerodynamic characteristics, of the airfoil. Since many papers dedicated to this subject are secret, we cannot give the history of the research in this field. We have cited in the bibliography some authors, without consulting their papers. We shall present therefore, only the model that we gave in [3.14]. This model can be easily obtained with the method of fundamental solutions and it is in the spirit of the theory previously presented in this book. We formulate the problem as follows: an uniform stream, having the
velocity U ,i, the pressure pao and the density p,,, flowing between two infinite flat plates parallel to the O.T. axis, encounters a thin airfoil of infinite span with the generatrices parallel to the Oz axis. The fluid is compressible, and the velocity of the uniform stream is subsonic. One requires to determine the perturbation and the influence of the stream on the airfoil. We utilize the variables (2.1.1) and (2.1.3). Let (3.1.1) represent the equations and a the distance between the plates (walls) (fig. 3.2.1). For determining the perturbation, we have to impose the following boundary condition: v(x, ±0) = h'(x) ± hl(x),JxJ < 1
(3.3.1)
v(x, ±a/2) = 0, -oo < x < oo
(3.3.2)
Y
+11 w2
xx
I /2 Fig. 3.3.1.
In order to utilize the method of fundamental solutions, we shall f)(t) replace the airfoil by a continuous distribution of forces defined on the segment [-1, +1). For satisfying the boundary conditions (3.3.2), we have also to take into account symmetric distributions on the
images of the strip [-1,+1) in the planes y = ±a/2 and symmetric distributions on the images of the images in the planes y = ±3a/2 etc.
89
THE AIRFOIL IN TUNNEL EFFECTS
(the method of images). In this way one obtains the following general representation of the perturbation: +oo
P(x, Y) - 27rp
na)f(e) d xo + 02(y - na)2
+1
1
J-
,
(3.3.3) (
v x, y) =
p }OO f 27r
1
(-1)"Xof(t) - (y ro + (y - na)2
with xo = x - . We can easily verify that v given above satisfies (3.3.2). For imposing the conditions (3.3.1) we have to pass to the limit considering y -+ 10, -1 < x < 1. The only singular integrals
correspond to n = 0 and they are calculated using the formulas (3.1.19) and (3.1.20). Taking into account the equalities (1.161: 00
_
1
k2 + n2 n=1
zr cosh kn 2k sinh kir
1
2k2 '
A
2k sink ka
"-1 k2 + n2
2k2 '
we deduce: 1
p(x, f0) = f 2 f (x) +
v(x,±0) _
f xo
)d
+
(3.3.4)
+1
1
7rp
-L
J_1
2f1(x) + 2r ,
rLd+ (3.3.5)
+p
where m = ap Kl (xo) _
I fi
K(xo)f(t)dt`,
-o
K(xo) = m sink-' (m xo' -
,
coth \\(m xo//
,
\
XO
(3.3.6)
From (3.3.4) we deduce again the significance of the function f :
f (x) = p(x, +0) - p(x, -0),
(3.3.7)
90
THE INFINITE SPAN AIRFOIL IN SUBSONIC FLOW
and from (3.3.5) and (3.3.1),
fl(x) = -2hi(x),
(3.3.8)
+I
x
2, K(xo)f()d= h'(x)
.
(3.3.9)
1
The formula (3.3.8) determines fl and the equation (3.3.9), the function f. The integral equation of the problem is in fact the generalized equation of the thin profiles. The kernel K has no singularity for t = x. We notice that for a - oo (m -+ oo) the equations (3.3.4) and (3.3.9) are reduced to the equations corresponding to the airfoil in a free (unlimited) airfoil.
3.3.2
The Integration of the Equation (3.3.9)
We utilize the quadrature formulas from Appendix F for integrating
the equation (3.3.9). Putting h = -eh, we shall look for solutions f having the form (3.1.56). Utilizing (F.2.18) and (F.2.19), we reduce the equation (3.3.9) to the system n
j=1,...,n,
>2CfaFo =hj.
(3.3.10)
0=1
where F. = F(ta), hi = h(xj), C'° = m 2n
1
sinh-1 I -(xj
- to,)}
,
(3.3.11)
§i xj being given in (3.1.58). After determining the unknowns F1,.. . , F, from (3.3.10), the lift and moment coefficients may be obtained by means of the formulas: tQ
(3.3.12)
cA, _
CL =
NL and NA, having the expressions given in (3.1.60). The distribution of the pressure on the airfoil may be obtained from (3.3.4), taking into account (3.3.8). We get p(to,T0)=ff&
2J3
l+ta
1 rr/3
1 hl(x)dx1
tp - x
THE AIRFOIL rN TUNNEL EFFECT'S
91
The values of the pressure in the points to, may be determined in the wind tunnel by means of pressure plugs. We have thus the possibility to verify the theory presented herein. We may use a computer for solving the system (3.3.10). Since the coefficients C1,, do not depend on the shape of the airfoil, we have to change in the program only the column containing the elements 1 .
Numerical Results
3.3.3
= 1. In
For the flat plate having the angle of attack e we have
this case, the formulas (3.3.12) become cL = cL NL, cm = cMNM, cOLO
and cc representing the coefficients corresponding to the unlimited fluid. - M. b 0
»
1
MWI"06
za
-I
I
1.4
1.3
a
00
02
0.4
0.6
01
1.0
'10.1
00
01
0.4
06
02
1.0
to"
h)
a) Fig. 3.3.2.
The figures 3.3.2 present the variations of NL and Niv versus the width of the tunnel for M = 0 (incompressible fluid) and M = 0.6. We notice that the lift in the wind tunnel is greater then the lift in the unlimited fluid and it decreases when the width of the tunnel increases. For the same width, the lift is an increasing function of M. The theory presented herein allows us to determine these variations.
92
3.4 3.4.1
THE INFINITE SPAN AIRFOIL IN SUBSONIC FLOW
Airfoils Parallel to the Undisturbed Stream The Integral Equations
In the literature, the problem of the uniform flow past a configuration of airfoils has been solved for the incompressible fluid and for airfoils whose exterior may be mapped conforma.lly on the exterior of a circle. There were given especially solutions for the biplane [1.36], [3.38]. We shall consider in the three forthcoming subsections, following the paper [3.15], the general problem of the compressible fluid in subsonic flow and
airfoils with thickness of arbitrary shape. YA
UM
a/2
x
Fig. 3.4.1.
We shall consider in this subsection, two airfoils parallel to the undisturbed stream (fig. 3.4.1), not necessarily identical. The free stream has
the velocity U,,,i, the pressure p,, and the density pp,;,. One utilizes the variables (2.1.1) and (2.1.3) and one considers that the equations of the airfoils are: y = h(x) . h1(x), Y = 1(x) ± 11(x),
krl < 1
(3.4.1)
1 XI < 1
(3.4.2)
the first corresponding to the upper airfoil and the second to the lower airfoil. The dimensionless distance between the projections of the airfoils is denoted by a. Utilizing the method of fundamental solutions, we
shall replace the upper airfoil by a distribution of forces of intensity and the lower airfoil by a distribution (gl, g)(t), both of them (fl, defined on the segment [-1, +1]. Starting from the above mentioned perturbation produced by a force in the free stream (the fundamental solution (2.3.23)), we deduce that the perturbation produced by the two
AIRFOILS PARALLEL TO THE UNDISTURBED STREAM
93
distributions is: +t
1
Ax, U) - 2yrQ
xof 1(e) + QZ(y - a12)f (t)
1- 1
xa +,Bs(y - a/2) s
d t+
+t
X091 (t) + O2(y + a/2)9(t)
1
+ 27rp J-1
d
(y + a/2)2
xo +
(3.4.3)
x, y) = (
p T,,-- 1
+1 xof (e) - (y - a/2)ft(e) d t+ xp +,02(y - a/2)2 1
+ Q r+t xo9(t) - (y + a/2)gt () d t,
2tr f 1
xo + /32(y + a/2)2
where x0 = x - .. The distributions of forces will be determined from the boundary conditions
When y
v(x, (a/2) f 0) = h'(x) ± hi (x),
fix( < 1
(3.4.4)
v(x, -(a/2) f 0) = !'(x) ± li (x),
jxj< 1
(3.4.5)
(a/2) ± 0), the first integrals from the representation
(3.4.3) become singular and they have to be calculated with the formulas (3.1.19) and (3.1.20). One obtains
P(x, (a/2) f 0)
2 f (x) +
+1
1
+ 2aQ
' fl
,
270 T-1
-;To
(3.4.6)
xo.91 + 7n,89
xo + jn2
_1
1
v(x, (a/2) 10) _
1 ft (x) + 2a
T-1
d+
d
f (')d t+ xo
(3.4.7) 1
1 Qxog -
f
+ 2rr ,l
1
mgt
xo + m2 d
,
where rn = ap. From (3.4.6) it follows f(x) = P(x,(a/2) + 0) - p(x,(a/2) - 0),
(3.4.8)
and from (3.4.4) and (3.4.7)
fi(x) = -2h'1(x)
(3.4.9)
94
THE INFINITE SPAN AIRFOIL ICY SUBSONIC FLOW
J
t f x()) d
t
+ 2 , i t xo +(r roe d = H(x),
where
(3.4.10)
+I
H(x) = h'(x) +
2
d
.
(3.4.11)
In the same way, passing to the limit in (3.4.3) when y -i -(a/2)±O (in this case the second integrals become singular), from the boundary condition (3.4.5), we obtain
g(x) = p(x, -(a/2) + 0) - p(x, -(a/2) - 0),
'(mot 9(e)
1
gi(x) = -21c(x), +t f( )2dC +
I
0
I
X2 +,fn
(3.4.12) (3.4.13)
= L(x),
(3.4.14)
0
where
L(x) = l'(x)
-
,1
t
I x('2d.
(3.4.15)
The distributions of forces on the two chords are determined by solving the system of integral singular equations (3.4.10) and (3.4.14). From
(3.4.9) and (3.4.13) the functions H(z) and L(x) are known. The field of pressure on the profiles are given by the formula (3.4.6) and the corresponding formula for p(z, -(a/2) ± 0). Symmetric Airfoils. If the two airfoils are symmetric with respect
to the Ox axis, then
l(z) = -h(x), 1I (x) = hI (x) .
(3.4.16)
It follows L(x) = -H(x) whence
xz(+tn
r,
I
If
gdt;+ o
J
(3.4.17)
I
Since the solution of the generalized equation of thin profiles is unique, it results f = -g, and the 'system of equations (3.4.10) and (3.4.14) reduces to a single equation
2
Ifro) d 1
2
f
+I I
+(n) 'TO f s
d4= H(x)
(3.4.18)
o
which is just the equation (3.4.7) of the airfoil in ground effects. The result is natural. The lift and moment coefficients for the upper airfoil
95
AIRFOILS PARALLEL TO THE UNDISTURBED STREAM
are given by the formulas (3.2.11). For the lower airfoil they have the opposite sign. For the entire configuration we have cL = cAt = 0. Identical Airfoils. If the airfoils are identical, then 1(x) = h(x) - 2a,
it(x) = hj(x).
(3.4.19)
Moreover, if the airfoils have no thickness, then L = H. Subtracting the equations (3.4.10) and (3.4.14), it results g = f whence A
f
I_ z2 +(m)2d = h'(x). 1
1
27r
(3.4.20)
This equation has the form of the generalized equation of thin profiles and it can be integrated numerically like in (3.2.2) and (3.3.2).
3.4.2
The Numerical Integration
In order to solve numerically the system (3.4.10) and (3.4.14), we shall use the quadrature formulas from Appendix F. For thin airfoils,
the functions H(x) and L(x) have the form H(x) = -eH(x), L(x) _ = -iL(x), hence we shall look for the following type of solutions
Qf (t) = -E V 1
+t
F(t),
3g(t) = -E
1 + tG(t)
(3.4.21)
which satisfy the Kutta-Joukowsky condition on the trailing edge. Utilizing (F.2.18) and (F.2.19), the system (3.4.10) and (3.4.14) is reduced to n
E(Aj.F.-Bj.Go)=Hl, ,7=1,...,n, a=1
(3.4.22) n
>(A1oGo-BjoFa)=1i, a=1
A,,,, tQ and x, are given in (3.1.58) and Bj, in (3.2.10). Like always,
F. = F(t0), G. = G(t0), H, = 77(x,), LJ = L(x,). We have to find out the unknowns Fl,. .., Fn, Gl, ... , Gn from the system (3.4.22). The
coefficients Aj0 and B 0 are the same for all the airfoils; only H and L, are varying. The lift and moment coefficients for the entire configuration are given by the formulas
THE INFINITE SPAN AIRFOIL IN SUBSONIC FLOW
96
CL
=-1
1+1
+1
(f+9)dt=
/(F+G)dt--Ni 1+t (3.4.23)
+1 CAI
--2J-,
+1
t(f+9)dt=2Q11
where
t
l+t(F+ c)dt =
-ASE2Q1V2,
n
N, =
1
2n + 1
:(1 - ta)(F. +G(), Q=1 (3.4.24) n
N2
2n 1 1
1)(F.+G.). 0=1
We notice that N, and N2 contain only the unknowns Fa + Ga which may be determined from the system
Aja(Fa + Ga) - Bja(Fa + Ga) = Nj + Lj
(3.4.25)
a=l
of n equations (j = 1, ... , n) with n unknowns. The unknowns Fa and Ca are separating only when we calculate the pressure on the two airfoils. For example, the field of the pressure on the upper airfoil is obtained from (3.4.6) with the formula
p(t,., (a/2) f 0) = f
29E
f
1 -to F.
0 - 4)G(ti) f3(2n + 1)
(ta - t{)2 + m2
- x)li(x) h', (x) dctQx(ta-x)2+m2d x, iro f!" 1
t
cos
2iIr
2n+1'
(3.4.26)
to being given in (3.1.58). In the same way we may determine the field of the pressure on the lower airfoil. The numerical determinations have been performed for the biplane
having the angle of attack E(h' = 1' = -E) (fig. 3.4.2a)) and for the symmetric biplane (h' = -1' = -e) (fig. 3.4.2b)) taking n = 10. In
GRIDS OF PROFILES
97
a)
b) Fig. 3.4.2.
the first case HJ = L, = 1, and in the second 77J = -Tj = 1. The coefficients A, , Bin depend only on the parameter m = a#. In the second case we obtain N1 = N2 = 0 for all the values given to m (it is natural). In the first case, the values of N1Q'1 and N2Q-1
depend on a and M. They are given in tables 1 and 2. In the first line we may find the values of 13-1N1 and 0-1N2 for the monoplane. We notice that the lift coefficient for the biplane is much greater then the lift coefficient for the monoplane and it increases with a. The lift increases also with M. The same conclusions are true for the moment coefficient. Table 2
Table I
The values of N,$-1
a=0.5 a=1 a=5
3.5 3.5.1
M=0
M=0.6
1.00 1.461886
1.25 1.741425
1.70842 1.981013
2.034937 2.46087
The values of N2
a=0.5 a=1 a=5
1
M=O
M=0.6
1.00 1.624288
1.25 1.941250 2.209987 2.477736
1.827670 1.991025
Grids of Profiles The Integral Equation
The classical problem may be also solved in a simple manner by means of the method of fundamental solutions. One obtains again the generalized equation of thin profiles. Let us consider a grid of identical airfoils having the equations y = na + h(x) ± hl (x) ,
n=0,±1,±2,...,
(3.5.1)
98
THE INFINITE SPAN AIRFOIL IN SUBSONIC FLOW
which perturb the uniform subsonic stream defined in section 2.1.1. Since every airfoil produces the same perturbation, we shall replace every profile by the same distribution of ford (fl, f) (c). Since the perturbation produced by the force (fl, f2) in the uniform stream is (2.3.23), we deduce that the perturbation produced by the grid is
1 C`
P(x, U) =
+t xoft(s) + Q2(y 1-1 (3.5.2)
Q 21r
u(x, A =
+°° -00
f
+' xof W - (U - na)fl W d x0 + (32(y - na)2
L
where xo=x-t;. The profile corresponding to n = 0 will be called the reference Passing to limit, when y -, ±0 the integrals corresponding to n = 0 become singular and they are calculated with the formulas profile.
(3.1.19) and (3.1.20). Employing the notation k = xo/m. we get +00
n*o
-00
x° A0 + m2n2
- 2x°
-00
nx
n
-
1
2x°
1r
k2 - n2 - m2 \2k
m2
= +00
00
n
coth -xo m 7T
coth k7r -
1
2
1
K(xo),
r
TO
2n=0' (3.5.3)
whence: '6 P(x, ±0) = f 2 f (x) + j,-
f x°) d t+
f1
(3.5.4)
+z
1
+2- j h (xo)fi (4)d t, P(x, +0) - P(x, -0) = f W,
(3.5.5)
d+
1
u(x, f0) _ 2 Q
ft (x) + 2 J
t
o (3 .5.6)
+i
+2 fl
99
GRIDS OF PROFILES
Imposing the boundary condition v(x, f0) = h'(x) ± M, (x)
(3.5.7)
fi(x) = -2hi(x)
(3.5.8)
we deduce +1 2 j K(xo)f(t)dt
If (o) d t +
= h'(x)
(3.5.9)
1
This is the integral equation of the problem. It has the same form like the equations (3.2.7), (3.3.9) and (3.4.10), (3.4.14), excepting the non - singular kernel. Obviously, from (3.5.3) we deduce that the kernel K(xo) is not singular. After determining f by means of (3.5.9), the field of pressure on the reference profile will be obtained from (3.5.4), and (3.5.5) will be utilized for the calculation of lift and moment coefficients.
In order to obtain the pressure on the profile corresponding to n = I and to impose the boundary condition on this profile, we must pass to the limit in (3.5.2) y - a :E 0. In this case, the integrals corresponding to n = 1 become singular. With the change of variable y - a = Y we have for example
rx, +t
Ax, a t 0) =
lim
to J- xxo + #2Yf d +
27r,3 Y
+
+00
1
n#1
27 r3
2
-00
+1 xof1 +,82(1 - n)af d ,l-1 x0 +1112(1 -n)2
Putting I - n = nl in the last integral we deduce +00
n'At
-00
_ +ao
1
To' + m2(1 -
-a0
00
1-n
+00
"#1
n)2
n,00
X.2
+ m2(1 - n)2
1
m2n'
-0
such that, taking into account (3.5.3), we obtain for p(x, a t 0) the same expression like for p(x, ±0). In the same way, for v(a, a f 0) one obtains the same formula like for v(x, ±0). In this way, imposing the boundary condition
v(x,a±0) = h'(x) ±14(x),
(3.5.10)
100
THE INFINITE SPAN AIRFOIL IN SUBSONIC FLOW
one obtains the equations (3.5.8) and (3.5.9). We draw the conclusion
that if f1 and f are determined by (3.5.8) and (3.5.9), the boundary conditions arc satisfied on each profile and the field of pressure coincides with the field on the reference airfoil. The lift and moment coefficients are calculated on every profile by means of the formulas
cj =-J
1
1
2
1
3.5.2
r
f(t)dt, cal=---
+
tf(t)dt.
(3.5.11)
t
The Numerical Integration
If f haa, the form (3.1.56) and It has the form -sh, using the quadrature formulas (F.2.18) and (F.2.19), we obtain from the integral equation (3.5.9) the system n
Di,,Fa = Itj, j = 1, ....:a ,
(3.5.12)
a=1
where
T 1 - t Goth
in 2n + 1
71
in
(xj - ta) ,
(3.5.13)
to and xj being given in (3.1.58). Considering for CL and cAf the form (3.1.59), we obtain for NL and N,%j the expressions (3.1.60). For example, for a grid of flat plates having the angle of attack E(hj = 1), the variations of the coefficients Nf and N,tt versus a, are given in figures 3.5.1.
We notice that the coefficients cL and cAt are increasing functions
of a and Al. They tend asymptotically to I when a - cc, hence the lift and moment coefficients tend asymptotically to the taken in the case of a single profile. The pressure in the control points (nod(s) is obtained from the formula
P(tu>f0) =
213
1
7T,9
x-
tQda.-
(3.5.1 l)
/' ,ro
-1
AIRFOILS IN TANDEM
101
.o
N 12
1.02
a%
IN 09$
014
091
066
011
US
0n
00
a
000
020
010
0.60
030
040
1.00 X10-,
a)
000 am 040
060
0.*0
1.00 X10'
b) Fig. 3.5.1.
3.6 3.6.1
Airfoils in Tandem The Integral Equations
In the sequel we shall determine the perturbation produced in the uniform stream defined in 2.1 (under the assumption that it is subsonic (M < 1)), by a configuration of airfoils in tandem (fig. 3.6.1), having the equations
y=11(x)±h1(z), al <x
(3.6.1)
a2 < z < b2 .
(3.6.2)
y =12(x) f h2(z),
For the incompressible fluid this problem was studied by Chaplygin and Sedov (1.38) who determined the complex velocity. If we reduce the problem to integral equations and we solve them like in 13.151, we can determine directly the quantities of interest in aerodynamics (the field and the jump of the pressure on the airfoils, the lift and moment coefficients). Moreover, the fluid may be compressible and we don't need to use elliptic integrals. In the sequel, we shall present the results from the last paper cited above. Replacing the airfoils by distributions of forces having the intensities (gl . fl) respectively (g2, f2) and taking into account the fundamental
THE INFINITE SPAN AIRFOIL IN SUBSONIC FLOW
102 Y
K
a,
b,
a3
b,
Fig. 3.6.1.
solution (2.3.23), we get the following representation of the perturbation:
jbX0g1(t)+#2yf1(C)
1
P( x, y) = 2aQ 1
x0 + /y2 r"' xo92(
+2Q 1
S
) + 02Yf2(t) d
xo + Q2 y2
,
(3.6.3)
v(x,y)=
xofiW --y91( )d xo + 132y2
2,r J a
Q rb'
+ 2a az
x0 +
dtt
y2
We kept the same notations like above. Passing to limit for al < x < b1 and taking into account (3.1.19) and (3.1.20), one obtains:
P(x,f0) = 2fi(x) + 27r#
xo
J a2
(3.6.4)
p(x, +0) - p(x, -0) = f 1(x)
(3.6.5)
f,a,
0
Q, f bi fi(t)
v(x, t0) =
bz
o1( )dC+
91(x) + 27r J
n,
xo
d+
fb aZ
xo d '
(3.6.6}
Imposing the boundary condition
v(x, ±0) =1 (x) ± hi (x) it follows 91(x) = -2hi(x)
Q
fl(O)
27r1 axo 1
d
2a Jxo
2xo L d=11(x) (3.6.8) Q
f
+
+
(3.6.7)
AIRFOILS IN TANDEM
103
In the same way, for a2 <x < b2 we deduce:
P(x,±0)=f2f2(x)+2a V(x, f0) = -T 192W + 2
27r
-
C
g 0{dt+2 )
., f )dt+ 2 Mo
22(i)dt(3.6.9) Y J., x0
f oQd(, z
whence, utilizing the boundary condition
v(x, f0) = !'(x) f h2(x) we obtain
p(x, +0) - p(x, -0) = MX),
(3.6.10)
92(x) _ -214(x),
(3.6.11)
2f
a,
i
t
'f
: _ (x).
f
( 3. 6 . 12)
Hence the functions fl(x) and f2(x) will be defined by the system (3.6.8) and (3.6.12). This is an interesting mathematical problem, since the first equation is defined for al < x < bl and the second is defined for a2 < z < .b2.
3.6.2
The Determination of the Functions f, and f2
For f, the equation (3.6.8) has the structure (C.1.5) which has the solution (C.1.9). Utilizing (B.6.11) and the last formula from (B.5.4) we deduce:
Of, (x) = Lt (x) + x
xt-
t
2(f)d
f
V
- bt
(3.6.13)
where
L1(z) = a
b-a t
n,
(3.6.14)
i
Substituting fl given by (3.6.13) in (3.6.12) and taking (B.6.11) and the last formula from (B.5.4) into account, one obtains the following integral equation for f2:
2 r.2 V/F - a'
f2(t)dt=L2(x), a2<x
(3.6.15)
THE INFINITE SPAN AIRFOIL IN SUBSONIC FLOW
104
La(x)
r
x-
,(x)
=
a1 b1
-!
- a,
h'
7r Ja,
Y
-- x
4b1 --
clt
.
(3.6.16)
The type of the equation (3.6.15) is (C.1.1) and its solution has the form (C.1.9). One obtains:
2 ((x - b1)(b2 - x)11/'r,ll (x - a t)( - aa)
/3f2(x) =
/t- a
l.
L2(t)dt
t-x
t
l
or, taking (3.6.16) and the first formula from (B.6.11) into account, 13f2(2) =
2
(x - bi)(b2 _ x)
7r
x - '1)(x - n2)
+
(
( -a l}(aa (b1 - .)(b2 -
t-n 1)(t-a- I.' )
(t-b1)(b2-t) t - .r
a
)
- x`l +
a2 < x < b2 .
dt
(3.6.17)
Once 13f2 determined, from (3.6.13) it results f3f1: (b1 - x)(ax -
fllx) ! 2
a) r
(x - al)(x -
J a2
2
V(()
- ) li(S} xd +
--a1}(a2
(t - a1)(t - a2) 12(E)
(t - b1)(ba - t) t - x
a1 < c < b1.
dt
(:3.6.18)
In this way we determined the solution of the system (3.6.8) and (3.6.12).
3.6.3 The Lift and Moment Coefficients From the formulas (3.6.5) and (3.6.10), we deduce for the lift and moment. coefficients: b;
1 f;(x)dx, cAr
cL = -
1
b,
xfi(a)dx
(3.6.19)
Utilizing the solutions (3.6.17) and (3.6.18), changing the order of integration and taking (13.6.5) into account, we find
c1
bi
-2j +
a, b=
102
E)1t(ti)dti
(b1 --
/(t - al)(t - a2)12(t)cit (t - b1)(b2
- t)
.
(3.6.20)
AIRFOILS IN TANDEM
105
Utilizing the same solutions, changing the order of integration and taking (B.G.6) into account, we get for the moment coefficient:
C.%/
( - al)(a2 - )
L
-13
(bi
b2 FLI- al)(t-a2)
bi)(t - t)
+,._ n
alt (od +
,
tt2(t)d t
+
al+as-b1 -b2 4
CL C. (3.6.21)
Obviously, the formulas (3.6.20) and (3.6.21) are generalizations of the formulas (3.1.33) and (3.1.34). Utilizing (B.5.14) we may prove by induction that in the case of n profiles in tandem we have:
r
cL
b
kt
/i_ak1(t)d k=1
1
(3.6.22)
"
n
cet=-1R fj11 k=1
3.6.4
k
t
t
Q
I n
bktlJ(t.)dt+(ak-bk) k=1
Numerical Values
In the case of two flat plates having the angle of attack fs
(fig.
3.6.2a) or 3.6.2b)), the integrals (3.6.20) may be expressed with the aid of elliptic functions. The first one has the form of the integral 252.21 from (1.4), page 105, and the second has the form of the integral 256.21 from the same book, page 122. For more complex configurations, these kinds of expressions are not available. However, in all cases, the integrals intervening in the expressions of c z, and ctit (for every n), may be calculated numerically by means of the quadrature formulas (F.2.24). For example, if n = 2, performing the change of variable C -+ t:
=
b1-al al+bl 2 + 2
-1
(3.6.23)
THE INFINITE SPAN AIRFOIL IN SUBSONIC FLOW
106
a)
b) Fig. 3.6.2.
and utilizing (F.2.24) we deduce:
_
(b - ) (b'i - ) d - 2n+ 1 or=l (1
Jo 1
I1
Jl =
n
bl - at
al)(a2 -
1
1
(a2f)) {d f t)(62
al + bl
2
(3.6.24)
-
-
it
a to b - to
+ ta)
(bi - al)2 n 1 + 2(2n E to(1 + to) + 1)
:to
0=1
a = 2a2 - (al + bl)
b ,
=
bl - al
252 - (al + bi) bl - al
where to are given by (3.1.52). Similarly we get: '2
1
2
1
J2
,
(t - al)(t - a2)
(t - bl)(b2 - t)
=a2 2 C=
-' 1 + t 2n+1 am1
(t - bl)(b2 - t)
7r
J2
(t-al)(t-a,) = b2-a2 n
to
(3.6.25)
c-tom
2(2n+1)
2al - (a2 + b2)
b2-a2
td t
c
d=
Vd-to'
0=1
251 - (a2 + b2)
b2-a2
Hence for two flat plates in tandem having the angle of attack -- we
107
AIRFOILS IN TANDEM
have 0ir2
CL =
£(11 +12),
cM = re`(Jt +J2)
(3.6.26)
13
where 11, 12, J1, J2 may be calculated numerically using a computer. For example, for at = 1, b1 = 2, a2 = 3 and b2 = 4 one obtains: 4 11 = 0.370671 and 12 = 0.629328. For a1 = 1, b1 = 2, and b2 = 5 one obtains: I1 = 0.415458 and 12 = 0.584541. For a1 = 1, b1 = 2, a2 = 6 and b2 = 7 one obtains: I1 = 0.449746 and 12 = 0.550253. In all the cases we have 11 + 12 = 0.999999, hence the lift has practically the value of the lift for a single plate and this is true even if the distance between plates increases. Since --11 + 12 takes the values 0.258657, 0.169083, 0.100507 it results that if the first plate
has the angle of attack -c and the second e, the lift decreases when the distance between plates increases. If the first plate has the angle of attack -s and the first has the angle of attack e, the lift becomes negative.
The previous formulas enable us to obtain numerical values for cL and cAl in the case of n airfoils with different shapes.
Chapter 4 The Application of the Boundary Element Method to the Theory of the Infinite Span Airfoil in Subsonic Flow
4.1 4.1.1
The Equations of Motion Introduction
The theory exposed in the previous chapter relies on the following three assumptions: 10 The linearization of the boundary condition. 2° The linearized condition is imposed on the chord of the profile, not
on the boundary (as it is natural to do). 3° The linearization of the equations of motion.
The assumptions are plausible for thin airfoils, otherwise they may be the cause of great errors. The application of the boundary integral equations method (BIEM), which is also called the boundary elements method (BEM), enable its to give up the first two assumptions. Hence we shall utilize the non-linear boundary condition which will be imposed on the contour (boundary) of the airfoil. For the incompressible fluid, we shall employ the exact equations (4.1.4) i.e. the equation of continuity and the equation of irrotationality, such that, in this case, the mathematical model (the equations of motion and the boundary conditions) will be valid for every airfoil (not only for the thin ones). In the case of the compressible fluid, we shall utilize the linearized equations, hence the results will be valid only for thin profiles, but even in this case the results are better then the results obtained by adopting the first two assumptions.
110
THE BOUNDARY PLEXENTSNIFTHOD
The first step in solving a problem with the boundary integral equations method (or the boundary elements method) consists in reducing the boundary value problem to a boundary integral equation (whence it follows the first name of the method); the second step consists in solving approximately the integral equation, replacing the boundary with a polygonal line (whence it follows the second name). In addition we have to mention that there exists a direct method and an indirect method. In, the direct method we utilize the equations of motion for deducing a representation of the solution in the domain occupied by the fluid with the aid of the solution on the boundary. Then we pass to the limit on the boundary. In the indirect method, we replace the wing with a distribution of fundamental solutions (sources, vortices, doublets) on the boundary and and we determine their intensity imposing the boundary conditions to be verified; in this way one obtains an integral equation for the intensity of the fundamental solutions; the method is therefore indirect. As we shall see in 4.2, it is easier to use the indirect method, but the results are less accurate. It is more difficult to utilize the direct method (4.3) but the results are more accurate. Therefore, in the forthcoming subsections we shall use mainly this method.
4.1.2
The Statement of the Problem
The problem was already formulated in the previous chapter. A subsonic stream having the velocity U,,.i (the Ox, axis has the direction of the unperturbed stream), the pressure p. and the density p is perturbed by the presence of a cylindric body with the generatrices perpendicular on the x1Oyu plane, having a given cross section (see fig. 4.1.1). One requires to determine the perturbation and the action of the fluid against the body. Denoting by X, Y the dimensionless coordinates introduced by means of the relation
(xi,yi) = L0(X,Y),
(4.1.1)
Lo being an unspecified reference length, and by U,,,,V and pc,.U"'2'P, the perturbation of the velocity and the perturbation of the pressure, we have:
V1 =UU(i+V), P1 =p +pWU,P.
(4.1.2)
The system which determines the perturbation is (2.1.30), written with capital letters. Projecting the second equation on OX and taking the damping condition at infinity into account, we deduce
P = -U.
(4.1.3)
111
THE F . UNrIONS OF MOTION
y
U., x Fig. 4.1.1.
In this way we deduce the equations which determine the perturbation:
/28U/ax + aV/aY = 0, 8V/ax - au/ay = 0,
(4.1.4)
U and V representing the coordinates of the vector V. and ,0 having the usual significance ([f = l - Af ). On the boundary C, of the airfoil we shall impose the condition
(l +U)N,y +VNy = 0,
(4.1.5)
N,V and Ny representing the coordinates of the inward normal to C1. Performing the change of variables
x=X. y=0Y (4.1.6)
u= f3U, v=V, the system (4.1.4) becomes au/ax + aV/ay = 0,
av/ax - au/8y.
(4.1.7)
In order to transform the condition (4.1.5), Ave notice that if the
boundary C1 has the parametric equations X = X (S), Y = Y(S) with S increasing when the curve C1 is traversed like in figure 4.1.1, then
N = (dY/dS, -dX/dS).
(4.1.8)
Performing the change of variable (4.1.6), we have x = x(X (S)), y = y(Y(S)) and
THE BOUNDARY ELEMENTS METHOD
112
Cl and the transformed curve C being traversed in the same sense (a increases with S). It follows NX
- # dS'
Ny
=n
a-S
(4.1.9)
,
such that (4.1.5) becomes
(,3 + u)nx + l2vny = 0 on C.
(4.1.10)
One also imposes the damping condition at infinity lim(u, v) = 0.
(4.1.11)
00
4.1.3 The Fundamental Solutions The first step in applying the BIEM consists in determining the fundamental solution of the system of equations (in our case, the system (4.1.7) ). We call source-type solution the solution of the system
au'/ax + 8v /ay
a(x - t, y - 11), (4.1.12)
&v'/Ox -au.la!l = 0. The fact that the perturbation represented by 5 intervenes in the equation of continuity justifies the name of the solution. We apply the Fourier transform and like in Chapter 2 we obtain: U0
1
x-t
27r(x-e)2+(y- n)2'
v*
_
I
y
q
21r(s-t)2+(y-17)2
(4 1.13)
We call vortex-type solution the solution of the system
au /Ox + W /ay = 0, (4.1.14)
Ov'/Ox Obviously one obtains:
W = -v*, v = u' .
(4.1.15)
113
INDIRECT METHODS FOR THE UNLIMITED FLUID CASE
Indirect Methods for the Unlimited Fluid Case
4.2
The integral equation for the Distribution of Sources
4.2.1
Taking (4.2.13) into account, we deduce that if we replace the airfoil
having the contour C (fig 4.1.1) with a distribution of sources of intensity f (x) apriori unknown, the perturbation of the velocity in the point Al(t) from the fluid will be given by the formulas:
v( ) _
2-4
-1
(4.2.1)
,Cf(x)Ix-4I2ds.
In order to determine the intensity f (x) we impose the boundary condition (4.1.10). To this aim, we have to calculate the boundary values in (4.2.1) when C -+ zo a current point Qo of the boundary C. We are going to prove that if f (x) satisfies the Holder condition on
C, i.e. there exist two positive constants A and p (p < 1) such that, for every two points Q(=j) and Q(x2) belonging to C, we have: If (z1) - f (w2)1 < Alaet - x21',
then
- 2 . PC f(x)
v(xo ) = lim
_ - 2 f (xo)n °
-2
- 2a Pf (m)
(4.2.2)
d8= (4 .2 .3)
X Isa
X0 d =012
it,
in every regular point Geo. We denoted PC
= li , Pi-C
(4.2.4)
where c is the arc cut out from C by the circle of radius E and center Qo (the arc QI Q2 from fig. 4.2.1). We denoted by no the inward normal at C in Qo. Indeed, taking the definition (4.2.4) into account, we notice that it suffices to evaluate the integral on c. We have limo
Eli
( _ 2 - f f (x)
\
=
Ii
n
{
L= liX0 PC
12-4
TV JC I-T-C
ds= f
[f (x) - f (xo)) I
d aJ - f Z
o)
44.2.5)
THE BOUNDARY ELEMENTS METHOD
114
Fig. 4.2.1.
Taking into account that f satisfies the condition (4.2.2), we deduce that the first integral from the right hand side of the equality (4.2.5) vanishes when E -- 0. For calculating L we shall replace the arc Q1Q2 with the segment on the tangent Q'Q'2 (fig. 4.2.1) and we shall put on this segment: x = xO + STO,
s E [-E, +EJ .
(4.2.6)
We assume, for the sake of simplicity, that M(C) tends to Qo(xo) on the direction of the normal n°. We have therefore
4 =xo--9n° cu q>0.
(4.2.7)
It follows
L= Um
17-0
r
+C E
o+ r1no s2 .
,2
q.e.d. Imposing the condition (4.1.10), we obtain from (4.2.1) and (4.2.3) the following integral equation: (flo2
+ N2n02) f (xo)+
+
(x - xo)n° +f2(y - bo)n° Uds=2pn2. cf(x) Ix-xo12
(4.2.8)
INDIRECT' METHODS FOR THE UNLIMITED FLUID CASE
115
From this integral equation we are going to determine the intensity of the sources. For the incompressible fluid (M = 0) it may be solved exactly for the circular obstacle (4.12).
4.2.2
The Integral Equation for the Distribution of Vortices
If we replace the airfoil with a distribution of vortices having the intensity (circulation) g(x) , defined on C, then, according to the formulas (4.1.15), we obtain the following expressions for the components
of the perturbation u and v in a point M(t) from the fluid: da,
u(0 =
2
where l; = (1:, rl), x = (x, Y) Taking the formula (4.2.6) into account, we obtain: Y-YO d s W012
U(X0) = 2g(xo)ny +
9(x) Ix
-
, (4.2.10)
f
2 g(xo)n:
v(xo)
- -1 P9(m) 1 -Z
X0 12
d
and from the boundary condition (4.1.10):
-M2g(xe)niny+ +1 ir
'(x)p2(x-xo)ny-(V -bb)nrd8=2f3n=, c
(4.2.11)
Ix - xol
where M is Mach's number in the unperturbed flow. For the incompressible fluid (A! = 0) we have a first kind integral equation.
4.2.3
The Boundary Elements Method
One utilizes the following collocation method in order to solve the equations (4.2.8) and (4.2.11): one approximates the boundary C by it polygonal line {!,,}(j = 1 T), with the end points on C (fig.
'TIME BOUNDARY ELEMENTS METHOD
116
Fig. 4.2.2.
4.2.2) and one approximates on every segment Li, the unknown f (respectively g) by the value fj (resp. gi) from the midpoint of the segment. Denoting by :xf the vector of position of the midpoint, we have fi = f (x°), (j = L N). We may also consider a linear variation of f on L. In this case we have to determine the two constants from the values of f in the end points of the segment L,. i.e. from the values
of f on C. Now the equation (4.2.8) may be written as follows:
( 02
+/32802) f(xo) + 1
+_7
r
(x - X0 710 + )`12(y - ?ko)tty
'Y
fi
L,
ds = 28nr .
Ix - xo1Imposing
the equation to be satisfied in every midpoint, i.e. putting successively xo = x9 . i = 1N, we get the system: N
ai fi +
Ai i f) = Ai,
i
(4.2.12)
where
tai = nr(xP) + '3ly1y(x)) (4.2.13)
AiJ
n'r(x:))Uii + /3lnv(x°)V i
+
Ai = fln (xn) ,
117
INDIRECT METHODS FOR THE UNLIMITED FLUID CASE
with the notations
Ucj = / u'(x,x°)da L (4.2.14)
Y1 = jv(zz?)ds1 f
u' and v' being given in (4.1.13). The linear algebraic system (4.2.12) consisting in N equations will determine the N unknowns f{. Now the perturbation of the velocity in the points Po(x°) follows from (4.2.3) N
1
vi
=-2f.n(x°)-EV1jfj J-1
(4.2.15)
V>, = (U+f,V ) In the same way, from the equation (4.2.11) we get the system N
hi9, + 1: Bij9j = A, , i = 1,(4.2.16) j:1
where
2b; _ -1tnz(x°)n,,(x°) , (4.2.17)
Bij = #'nr(x°)U,j - n(x°)Vij. From (4.2.10) we obtain the following velocity field N
1
w = 29jnr(x0)+Evj9j j..1
(4.2.18)
1
Vf
4.2.4
N t'4s(x'i')-Uijgj. -
The Determination of the Unknowns
The integrals (4.2.14) may be computed numerically using quadrature formulas. They may be also calculated exactly for every shape of
THE BOUNDARY ELEMENTS METHOD
118
the contour C. Since the integrals UUJ, V, are singular we shall calculate their Finite Parts. For avoiding the singular integrals, we may utilize the regularization method 4.8. For obtaining a parametrization of the segment L,, we shall denote by (x1, yl) and (x2,112) the coordinates of the end points PI, respectively P2, considered in the sense of traversing C (fig. 4.2.2). Then, the coordinates of the generic point on L., will be
y°+-2ylt, -1<-t<1,
x°-i-x22xlt,
(4.2.19)
where, obviously,
x°
X2 2 x1
yj=112
2 111
(4 . 2 .20)
.
Utilizing the formula
ds = 1(&-)2 -+ (dy)
,
we deduce
gds=l,dt, lJ =
(x2-x1)2+(112-111)2.
(4.2.21)
Denoting
4a = I,b= (x°-x°)(x2-xl)+(i4 -Y?)(112-Yi), c = (xjI - x? )2 + (yp - y1)2,
-
+1
k 1
tkdt
ate+bt+c'
k = 0,
(4.2.22)
1,
we get (x - x°)2 + (y - y°)2 = ate + bt + c
(4.2.23)
whence, U,,
=
Io 47f [ (xj_ x°)
+x2 2
x1J l]
, (4.2.24)
ii4i[(y°- y° ) Io+2 yi
V
119
INDIRECT METHODS FOR THE UNLIMITED FLUID CASE
Taking the running sense on C into account, we shall have in (4.2.13), (4.2.15), (4.2.17) and (4.2.18): n,,(x°) _
_-V1
r+y(x 0) = x1 !J X2 1
ii V2
(4.2.25)
1 11z`)
n,,(xo) _
n (x?) = x I
j.
where (xl'), yi')) and (X( 2" Y2()) are the coordinates of the end points of the segment Li and 1; is the length of this segment, i.e. xz')
- xi'1)2 + (yz;l - y1'))2]1/2
(4.2.26)
.
We have to notice that in (4.2.24) the integrals Ik may be calculated exactly. Indeed, since
<0,
A =- b=-4ac = we have
to =
V'--5
Il - I 2a
In
arctan.
(4.2.27)
dc-a'
a+b+c -
(4.2.28) b
a-b+c a/
arc t an vr---s
c-a
Taking (4.2.23) into account, we deduce a + b + c = (x2 - x°) + (y2 (4.2.29)
a-b+c= (xl -x°)2 +(yi -y°)2. For i = j we have b = c = 0, such that the integrals Ik become
singular. Utilizing the formulas (D.2.3) we obtain
Io = -2/a,
Il = 0.
(4.2.30)
So, the coefficients ai, At,, A{, b1 and B1j depend on the coordinates
of the end points of the segments L, on C. Hence, we may solve the systems (4.2.12) and (4.2.16) using a computer.
120
TllE BOUNDARY ELEMENTS METFIOD
4.2.5
The Circular Obstacle
For testing the two methods presented above and the direct method from the following subsection, we shall use the exact solution for the incompressible flow past a circular obstacle. This solution is already
known. If 0 is the origin (center) of the obstacle and R its radius, then the complex velocity in dimensionless variables is (see (5.2.4) from 11.111)
R UI -iVI =U01- Z2) \\
.
(4.2.31)
t
Taking R as reference length and putting z = exp(iO) it results u = - cos 2O ,
y _ -sin 2O
(4.2.32)
In figures 4.2.3 and 4.2.4 we compare the numerical values obtained for u by mens of (4.2.15) and (4.2.18) with the values obtained by
means of (4.2.32). We observe that the solution obtained by means of the distribution of vortices is better. It is also useful to compare the numerical values obtained on the three ways for a quantity of aerodynamic interest. This is the local pressure coefficient defined by the formula
A P.
Cy _ = (1/2)P..oUx ,
(4.2.33)
with the notations from (4.1.2). Taking into account that for the incompressible fluid, the system (4.1.7), for which we have determined the approximate solutions, is the exact system of the equations of motion, we shall calculate also Cn exactly. This may be obtained from Bernoulli's integral 1 V2 Pi 1 r r2 . Poo _ (4.2.34)
Poa
2
Poo
It follows
Cp=1-V2=1-(1+ u)2-t'2.
(4.2.35)
Using this formula, from (4.2.15) we get C,, in the case of the distribution of sources, from (4.2.18) we get. C,, in the case of the distribution of vortices and from (4.2.32) we get C,, exactly. We also calculate Cn with the direct method from the following subsection. The graphic rep-
resentations show that the direct method gives better results than the indirect methods and among these ones, the method based on the distributions of vortices is better.
INDIRECT METHODS FOR THE UNLIMITED FLUID CASE
121
t 1.
I
es
m
As
.03
.1s
.1s
a
.1
a
n 6e m IJI If Im )m >r )10 1L ))a us
a
W b b Ip Ip 110 7q 30 M RD 30 No
Fig. 4.2.3.
4.2.6
Fig. 4.2.4.
The Elliptical Obstacle
The profiles with smooth boundaries (for example the circle or the ellipse) are non-lifting profiles. The profiles with angular points determine a circulatory motion of the fluid and therefore it appears the lift. The circulation (and the lift) are determining from the Kutta-Joukovsky condition (see for example, (1.101 p. 179), hence these profiles are lifting profiles. In the first case we encounter d'Alembert's paradox. As we shall see in the following subsection, the indirect methods are utilized mainly for non-lifting bodies, while the direct formulation is suited for
writing the k - J condition. It is well known the exact solution for the elliptic obstacle in the incompressible fluid. The complex potential from the (Z1) plane is given by the formula (see for example, (1.101 p.178).
F(zi) =
2 {( zi + za'°+
zl
+ (zi '
at + bt e1°l
(4.2.36)
t
at - bj
where at and bl are the semiaxes, 4 = at - b1, and a is the angle of attack. Deriving (4.2.36) we deduce the complex velocity which has the same form in dimensionless variables z = Z, a, b, c . Hence it follows
1+u-iv=
]e`1°+
2[(1+
(4.2.37)
+(l `
z
a+bei°l a - b
122
THE BOUNDARY ELEMENTS METHOD
We determine the components u and v separating the real part from the imaginary one. The graphic representations for the exact solution and for the solution obtained with the first indirect method, are given in [4.7J. We notice that the results are almost identical.
4.3
The Direct Method for the Unlimited Fluid Case
4.3.1
The representation of the solution
As we have specified in 4.1, in the framework of the direct method we represent the velocity field in the fluid with the aid of its values on
the boundary of the body and then we pass to the limit. In order to obtain this representation, we shall consider a domain D exterior to the boundary C and limited by a circle CR having the radius big enough, such that C should be situated in the interior of CR. For f and g continuously differentiable function C', we have the identity
[f (aulax + avlay) + 9(8v/ax - 8u/8y)Jda = 0
(4.3.1)
which follows from (4.1.7). Noticing that
fau/ax = a(fu)/ax - ua f /ax, .. . and applying Gauss's formula, we obtain the identity J[u(Of/ax - 89/8y) + v(8f/ey + 09/8x)Jda = (4.3.2)
=
j[u(fn
- 9ny) + v(9nx + f ny)Jds .
the integral on 47R vanishing when R - oo, because of the behaviour
at infinity of f and g which will be identified with u' and v' and because of the condition (4.1.11).
For f = u' and g = -v' (4.1.13), taking (4.1.12) into account, we deduce:
u(f) =JC u(x) [u'(x, )n (x) (4.3.3)
+v(x) [u'(x, Ony(x) - v'(x, )n=(x)] }ds
,
THE DIRECT METHOD FOR THE UNLIMITED FLUID CASE
123
and for f = v' and g = u' 2L(x) [v`(x, S)ns(x) C
(4.3.4)
+v(x)[u'(z,4)n=(x) + v'(x,C)ny(x)]}d8.
This is the integral representation of the solution, valid for every point M(4) from the exterior of C.
4.3.2
The Integral Equation
For obtaining the boundary integral equation, we have to pass to the limit in (4.3.3) and (4.3.4), letting the point M(r;) to tend to the generic
point Qo(zo) belonging to C. To the limit, the integrals containing the fundamental solution (u', v') become singular. Hence we have to adopt the definition (4.2.4). We calculate the integrals on c, as follows: lim
Ju(z) [u*(x,F)n (x) + v*(x,C)nyr(x)]ds lim
J [u(x) - u(xo)] [u'(x,4)n=(x)+ (4.3.5)
+v (x, 4)nr(x)]ds + u(xo)Li L 1 = lim
t-M. 1c
[u' (x,
,
where
v`(x, 4)ny(x)]ds .
If c =
is replaced by the segment Q'1Q'2 (fig. 4.2.1), then we Z have the parametrizations (4.2.6) and (4.2.7) and n = no. Hence,
L=
27r re
s2
+
ds = 2
.
Passing to the limit, the first integral from the right hand side of the equality (4.3.5) vanishes when e -+ 0.
124
THE BOUNDARY ELEMENTS METHOD
Similarly we have: Eli
m
J
v(x)[u*(x,Lr)nv(x)
- v`(x,t)nt(x)]ds
_ slim J [v(x) - v(xo)] [u`(x, )ny(x)-v*(x, t)nz(x)]ds + v(xo)L2 , where
L2 = lim
=
(4.3.6)
J[u*(x)n(x) +v(x,)n(x)]ds = ny - -r,0, no.)
r
s2 it
+
ds = O. 172
Therefore, from (4.3.3) we deduce:
2u(xo) _
{u(x) [u*(x, xo)ns(x) + v*(x, xo)ny(x)]+ (4.3.7)
+v(x) [u* (x, xo)nv (x) - v* (x, xo)nz(x)] }ds
.
In the same way, from (4.3.4) we obtain: 2V(xo)
{u(x)[u*(z,xo)nz(x) - u*(x,xo)nv(x)]+ (4.3.8)
+v(x) [u* (x, xo)n=(x) + v*(x, xo)ny(x)] Ids. The formulas (4.3.7) and (4.3.8) constitute a system of two singular
integral equations on C for the unknowns u(xo) and v(xo). Now we introduce the function G = (13 + u)ni, - vnx .
(4.3.9)
We may utilize on C the condition (4.1.10). It follows
Q+u= n2n2G, v= -nz v
2
2C.
(4.3.10)
nv
Replacing these relations in (4.3.7) and (4.3.8) and taking into account the relations PC. (u* n,,
+ v*nv)ds = -1/2;
P(u*nv - v*nr)ds = 0,
(4.3.11)
THE DIRECT METHOD FOR THE UNLIMITED FLUID CASE
125
which will be demonstrated in (4.3.7), we get: u ( xo )
= ,3 + 2
P C
(v '
n,n V u ')Gd s - M2 n2 + #2n2 x
y
4.3.12) u (xo
)=2TS
and then G(xo) - 2
\
- u '-A12 n2+
2n2v ' Gds
x
y
)
I
PC
+ hf2
[u'nox + v'rty+ n22
nzny + g2nyh (v n o
'
- u ' ny° )JGd s = 2An y ,
(4.3.13)
with the notation no = n(xo). The equation (4.3.13) is the singular integral equation of the problem. Putting M = 0, one obtains the equation for the incompressible fluid.
4.3.3
The Circulation
In the case of the profiles with angular trailing edge, we have to utilize the circulation. Taking the sense defined on C1 into account and denoting by stl) and n(') the (dimensional) versors of the tangent and inward normal, we have 41),
sod = -11y1), 41) =
(4.3.14)
such that
rl =
V1 si'idwi'
(U1nyll
- Vinzll)ds(') =
= -U0LoP[(1 + U)Ny - VN,;Jds. With he changes of variables (4.1.6) and (4.1.9), we deduce
[' 1 = -
U
0 ° j[(0 + u)ny - vn=Jds.
(4.3.16)
Denoting r1 = U,,,Lor, r representing the dimensionless circulation and utilizing (4.3.9), it results the simple formula:
r = - PCds.
(4.3.17)
For the incompressible fluid one obt ins:
r=-
G ds.
(4.3.18)
These formulas also emphasize the significance of the function G.
THE BOUNDARY ELEMENTS METHOD
126
4.3.4
The Discretization of the Equations
Acting like in 4.2.3, we reduce the equation (4.3.13) to the algebraic system N
i = 1, 2, ... , N ,
(1/2)G{ + F A;jG,i = J3;,
(4.3.19)
j=1
where
Ci = C(x°), A = Onv(x°),
A,j = -nh(x°)Utj - n,(x°)V J--
(4.3.20)
nz(x°)n1r(x°)
n2(x') nr(x°)V, -- nv(x°)U,j]
_M2 n2(xj),
Uy and
being defined (4.2.14).
After determining the unknowns G1 from (4.3.19), we may determine the circulation from the formula: N
-/3I' = E 1jGj ,
(4.3.21)
j=1
representing the length of the segment Lj. We deduce the components of the velocity 1j
+ u; =
A2ny(x°)G=
n2(x°) + A2n2(x°)
ns (x°)Gi
n2(xe) +
n2(x°) '
(4.3.22)
from (4.3.10). Obviously, for n(x°) and n(x°) we shall utilize the expressions (4.2.25) and for U;j and [;j, (4.2.24).
4.3.5
The Lifting Profile
If the profile has an angular point (fig. 4.3.1), or a cusp, like the Joukovsky-type profiles, then we have to determine the circulation using the Kutta-Joukovsky rule. The circulation determines the lift. For determining the circulation,
we impose the equality of the pressure in the points P, (on the upper side of the angle) and P; (on the lower side of the angle) when
THE DIRECT METHOD FOR THE UNLIMITED FLUID CASE
127
Fig. 4.3.1.
these points (Pp and Pi) tend to the angular trailing edge P1. From Bernoulli's integral it follows that the equality of the pressures implies the equality of the tangential components of the velocity, (according to the slipping condition the normal components are null). Taking into account the orientation of the versor of the tangent s(1) on the upper and lower sides of the angle (fig. 4.3.1), we deduce the condition: Vi(P,).stt}+V1(Pi),alt}
=0.
(4.3.23)
With the notation (4.3.9), we have:
V1 slit =
U)sal + VsY)J = UM
+u J"'J 13
+vn=1ds
pJdS
d5
such that (4.3.23) implies G(Pi) = 0.
(4.3.24)
Consequently, for such a profile, we have to add the condition (4.3.24) to the system (4.3.19). In order to solve this problem we introduce [4.18J
the regularization variable A and we obtain the system:
A+(1/2)Gi+AijGj =;3i, i = 1,...,N, (4.3.25)
G(P,) + G(Pi) = 0, for the unknowns C1,. .. , Gtr , A. in this way the number of equations equals the number of unknowns. For big values of N we obtain a small A i.e. (A - 0).
THE BOUNDARY ELEMENTS METHOD
128
4.3.6 The Local Pressure Coefficient As we have seen in 4.2.5, the local pressure coefficient for the incompressible fluid (4.2.33) is (4.2.35). Let us deduce the expression of the local pressure coefficient for the compressible fluid. For the potential flow we have the formulas 11.101 page 206 which become, using the notations from this chapter:
Vi ;fir
Pi = Pu
2 Pl-potl-ry-1
l C?
: c2o
V12\i
(4.3.26)
J
2
_co2t1-72
For the uniform flow that we have in view, these formulas give
7-1UW 7-l 2
cam)
7-1 U2
Pco - Po
2
T
(4.3.27)
co
=cfltl-7-1 U"
cclo
2
czo
From the last relation we deduce k
,y-1
1
Uz
7-tlli2+
2
(4.3.28)
such that, denoting
r=72142,
(4.3.29)
it follows 1
k(7 - 1)
=1+1. z
(4.3.30)
Introducing the parameter k in the formulas (4.3.26) and (4.3.27), we
THE DIRECT METHOD FOR THE UNLIMITED FLUID CASE
129
get:
P1=PO I-
V"k 00
\
r
(4.3.31)
Poo=P0(1-721k}T
,
7-1
Poo = Po 1-2
k)
T
These formulas will be replaced in (4.2.27). Taking out the factor (7 - 1)k/2 and utilizing (4.3.30), it results _ 2 2 ( )]'-T-11. (4.3.32) Cp = j -- 1+ ry 2 1 M2 ( U2 .yM2
For the incompressible fluid (M = 0) one obtains the formula (4.2.29). For the compressible fluid, V12/U.2 from (4.3.32) will be replaced by (1 + u/#)2 + v2. We shall employ the local pressure coefficient in order to define the lift coefficient which gives a global measure of the action of the fluid against the profile CL =
'f Li
Cl,nylidat ,
(4.3.33)
where Ll is the length of the contour C1. It is also important to get the expression of the critical velocity v, because the subsonic character of the flow is maintained only if Vl < vi,, . This velocity is obtained from (4.3.26) putting vl = cl and utilizing the definition of k. We obtain: U02
4.3.7
11+721 (M2 -1)]
.
(4.3.34)
Appendix
In this subsection we shall prove the formulas (4.3.11). To this aim, we denote by C, the arc (semicircle) of the circle of radius e with the center in Q0, interior to the profile (fig. 4.3.2) and we notice that we have the parametrization
x-xo=Ecos9, y-yo=EsinO (4.3.35)
00<0<00+ir
THE BOUNDARY ELEMENTS METHOD
130
Fig. d.3.2.
which, for u', z}' (4.1.13) implies: U* (x, xa)
1 cos 0 2;r
v' (x, x)
E
1 sin y 27,,
(4.3.36)
E
We also consider the circle CR with the center in Qo, and the radius R big enough, such that the profile C is in the interior of the circle. On this circle we have the parametrization
x-x0=Rcos4
,
,-
such that
9l'
lcoscp
= in R
y-yp=RsincF, V*
(4.3.37)
1Sill
27r R In the domain D. exterior to the contour C - c + Cs and interior '
to the circle CR, we may integrate the equation: au'/ax + av'/(9y = a(.r - x0, y - yo)
(4.3.38)
Applying Green's formula we get:
(u'n., + v'ny)ds + Prr (0n, + v'ny)ds+ (4.3.39)
+
(u'n2 + Ti'ny)ds = 1.
THE AIRFOIL IN GROUND EFFECTS
131
or, PC
lu*(x, xo)ns(x) + v'(x, xo)ny(x)jds + 1
+ 2n
f"' o
2a
1
dO
+-
j dip = 1. ,
0
One obtains the first of the relations (4.3.11). Integrating on D the equation
8u'/8y - 8v-/8x = 0, one obtains the second of the relations (4.3.11).
4.3.8 Numerical Determinations In figure 4.3.3 we compare u calculated by means of the direct method with u calculated exactly. We observe that the values are almost the same. In figure 4.3.4 we give 4 graphic representations: u
exact, u direct, u sources, u vortices. We notice that u obtained by means of distributions of sources (4.2.15) does not give very good results and u obtained by means of distributions of vortices (4.2.18) gives better results. The values of u obtained with the direct method are constantly in the vicinity of exact values of u . Is
tS
as
a3
.1
Ti rr-FT lTF
43
TG
as a
a o IN laI10us 110
210 210 010 110
a
to
.a
10 Ib ISO to ]b M 7s Im in IM
Fig. 4.3.3.
4.4 4.4.1
Fig. 4.3.4.
The Airfoil in Ground Effects The Representation of the Solution
When the airplane is landing or taking off we have to take into account the influence of the ground. We shall consider this problem herein
'1'm; BOUNDARY ELEMENTS METHOD
132
Y;
x> Fig. 4.4.1.
replacing the ground with the x10:1 plane (fig. 4.4.1). We have the same problem like in the previous sections. Art uniform subsonic stream,
having the velocity U,,,, the pressure p and the density p", flowing in the yt > 0 half-space, is perturbed by the presence of an infinite cylindrical body, having the generatrices parallel to :r, IOzt, the Oxt axis having the direction of the stream. The x10y1 plane determines a cross section whose boundary C1 is assumed to be a thin profile. Using the smite notations like in 4.1 we have to integrate the system (4.1.7) in
the ha lf-plane y > 0, with the boundary condition (4.1.10) on C and the supplementary condition zr(x, 0) = 0,
(4.4.1)
(V)X.
In this case, instead of the fundamental solution (u', v') from 4.1.3 we shall utilize Green's distribution (U', V') determined by the system au; 119X l aVV/ay = 6(x -
y -11)
(4.4.2)
(9DU/ay = 0,
I) representing a point front the y > 0 half-plane, and the boundary condition
U'(a,0) = 0.
V+(r.0) = 0.
(V)x.
(4.4.3)
This distribution is obtained by means on the fundamental solution (4.1.13) using the method of images. Denoting 2r,
(x - )2 + (y - rj)2 (4.4.4)
vt (T, y, , tl) _
1
27r (x
y-rI
- )2 + (y - 1)2
133
THE AIRFOIL IN GROUND EFFECTS
we have
Uf = u*(x,11,Cq) f u*(x,y,C-q) (4.4.5)
Vf = v'(x,y, ,q) ±v'(x,y,C -q) Indeed, u' (x, y, t, q) and v'(x, y, t, q) verify the system (4.1.12) for ev-
ery t in the xOy plane. Obviously, u'(x, y, t, -q) and v' (x, y, t, -q) verify the system
8u'/8x+ 8v'/811= b(x - C y +q) (4.4.6)
8v'/8x-8u'/Oy=0. When t is in the superior half-plane (y > 0) this system becomes
8u'/8x + 8v'/ay = 0 (4.4.7)
8v'/8x + 8t,'/8y = 0. With these specifications one easily finds that (4.4.5) verifies (4.4.2). It is also very easy to verify the conditions (4.4.3). Let us return now to the representation of the solution. Denoting by D the domain from the superior half-plane y > 0 which is exterior to C and delimited by a half-circle CR with the center in the origin, the
diameter on Ox and the radius big enough in order to contain C in the interior (fig. 4.4.1), we deduce like in 4.3, for R - oo, the identity [u(8f 1,9x
- 8g/8y) + v(8f/8y + 8g/8x)] ds =
(4.4.8)
IL) =:
j [(u f + vg)n= + (v f - ug)ny] ds +
J
u(x, 0)9(x, O)dx. 0000
We took into account the fact that on the diameter of the half-circle we
have n = (0, -1) and that the integral on CR vanishes for R - oo when f and g are distributions having the form U., V. Putting now f = U+ and g = -V;, from (4.4.2) and (4.4.3), we deduce
u( ) = J (u(x) [U+(x, 4)n1(x) + V+(x, )ny(x)] +
c
+v(x) [U+(x, C)n,(x) - V+(x, 4)ns(x)] Ids.
(4.4.9)
THE BOUNDARY ELEMENTS METHOD
134
In the same way, for f = V. and g = U , from (4.4.9) we obtain
vW =
PC {u(x) [V -*(x, F)nr(x)
- V*
(4.4.10)
+v(x)[U-w (x, )ns(x) + V`(x,Ony(x)]}ds. Formally, the solution is identical to (4.3.3) and (4.3.4). It differs only by Ut, V}.
4.4.2
The Integral Equation
Acting like in 4.3, we deduce f
(1/2)u(xo) = PC {u(x)[U+(x,xo)n:(x) + V+ (m, xo)ny (x)] +
+v(x)[U..(z,xo)ny(x)
(1/2)v(xo)
_'
- V+(x,xo)ny(x)]}ds, (4.4.11)
{u(x) [V=` (x, xo)n: (x) - U* (x, xo)ny(x)] +
+v(x) [U' (x, xo)n=(x) + V! (m, xo)nv(x)} }ds.
Utilizing the identities PC (U}nt + V.ny)ds =
-2, P(U_ny - V'n=)ds = 0
(4.4.12)
which will be demonstrated at the end of this section, we obtain for G defined by (4.3.9), the following integral equation:
(1/2)G(xo) - PC {U (x, xo)n.(xo) + VV (x, xo)ny(xo)+
+1bllni(z)+
(ny,x) [V_(x,xo)n=(x)-
(4.4.13)
-U, .(x, xo)n.,(x)] }Gds = Qnv(xo), where the mark "prime" has the same significance like in (4.2.4).
The formulas (4.3.10) which determine u and v in function of C, remain valid.
135
THE AIRFOIL IN GROUND EFFECTS
4.4.3
The Computer Implementation
The equation (4.4.13) is discretized like in 4.3.4. One obtains the system N
(1/2)G; +
i1
A;}Gj= B;,
I = 1, ... , N ,
(4.4.14)
where
AU = -n,,(x°)U,j o
o
-M2ny(x')+Q2n2(xq)( (x)V
(4.4.15)
+
with the notations
U, =
J Lf
U; (Z' x0)ds , V j =
j
V(x, x9)ds,
(4.4.16)
s
B; remaining unchanged. The system (4.4.14) will determine the unknowns C1,.. . , GN. From (4.3.22) it follows u;, v;, (i = 1, ... , N). The circulation is obtained with the formula (4.3.21). For lifting airfoils, we also consider the Kutta-Joukovsky condition (4.3.24). We solve the problem introducing the regularization variable A and acting like in 4.3.5.
In order to obtain the expressions of the unknowns U, j and Vtj*, we use the notations (4.2.22) and the relations Y= (xs -
x°)(x2 - x1) + (y° + y°)(y2 - y1),
c1= (xi -x°)2+(y;+y°)2
Ik =!-i1
(4.4.17)
ate+bit+
'
In this way one obtains
(z-x°)2+(y+y?)2=ate+b't+c', 4[(xjo -x0)(Io
U,3
Vi'*
=
-Lj
41r
kla)+x22x1(Ilfli)f
12 yl (Il f li)J [Y-v?Iodv?+Y?I6+ (o
(4.4.18)
THE BOUNDARY ELEMENTS METHOD
136
n(x0) and n(xti) being defined in (4.2.25). For It) and It one obtains the expressions (4.2.28). Since A = b2 - 4ac'
(?1j + Y9)(x2
- XI) - (xj - xe))(?M -
x!1)]2
< 0,
it follows
4, =
a
2Qr arctan
,
C' -a
(4.4.19)
1t=2a III +b+c'-afwhere
,arctar.
-©
c' - a
,
a+b'+c' = (>'2-x°)2+(J2+J9)2 (4.4.20)
a -b<+cl = For i = j the integrals Io and It become singular and they have the values (4.2.30).
4.4.4
The Treatment of the Method
The problem presented in this subsection was studied in (4.10] and we present with small modifications the solution given in that paper. For testing the method we use the exact solution which is available for the circular obstacle in ground effects (fig. 4.4.2), (4.12]. If the center of the circle is in the point (0, b) and the radius is a (a < b), then, employing the usual notations, we have the exact solution:
u - iv= -2 E Z2 C" +
n>1
where the sequences
+4
E n>t
cn b» Z2
+ b2
(4.4.21)
and {cn} are defined by the following
{bn}
formulas: 2
2
b"+1=b-b+a
c,++1=(b+bC11
b,,,
n)2n--0, > (4.4.22)
b1=b,
c1=a2.
Decomposing (4.4.21) in simple fractions, we get
at - iv = - E Gn [(z - bn)2 + n>1 i1
(1
(4.4.23)
+ ibn )2}
THE AIRFOIL IN GROUND EFFECTS
137
YA
U-
Fig. 4.4.2.
whence, separating the real part from the imaginary one, we deduce u
= - L'` n>1
x22-(y-b,,)2 + x2-(y+bn)2 f x2 + (y
- bn )212
[x2
+ (y + b.)212 (4.4.24)
v= -2xEG& rx y - b + (y - bn)212 + n>1
y +bn Jx2
+ (1/ + bn)?12
Putting
r=acos8, y=b+asinO, we find uIC and vJ,. Using the formula (4.2.35), we represent in figure 4.4.3 the exact solution by a continuous curve and the approximate solution (in the case
of the incompressible fluid, rt = 0) by small squares. We considered r = 0, a = 1 and b = 1.1. Since the two solutions practically coincide, we conclude that the method presented herein is very good. It may be applied for every shape of the airfoil.
4.4.5
The Circular Obstacle in a Compressible Fluid
In this case there is not available any exact solution, such that we have only the information provided by the BIEh1. We have to take care to use
THE BOUNDARY ELEMENTS METHOD
138 4
C,
0 -4
.8
1
-12J
ace METHOD EXACT
-16.J -20 J -24. r
0
90
180
I
270
360
Fig. 4.4.3.
for the radius of the circle values that are small with respect to the other characteristic lengths (for example, the distance to the ground) because only in these circumstances we can employ the linearized equations. In figure 4.4.4, we represent the coefficient CL defined by (4.3.33) for the circular obstacle with the radius a = 1, considering 60 nodes on the boundary, . Obviously, the compressibility determines the increase of the lift (as we have already seen in the case of the free fluid). We considered 7 = 1.405. Giving the distance to the ground, we may calculate (in the absence of the circulation) the values of M for which the flow remains subsonic (one utilizes vQ given by the formula (4.3.34).
4.4.6
Appendix
In order to prove the formulas (4.4.12) we take into account that in the entire plane, the solutions (U7, VV) satisfy the systems
aUU/ax+av}/ay=a(x-t,y-17)± 5(x-C y+ ii) (4.4.25)
aVV/ax - aUl/ay = 0, where 7> 0. Like in 4.3.7, we denote by Cf the arc of circle interior to the profile
C, having the center in Qo(zo) and the radius a and by CR the
THE AIRFOIL IN GROUND EFFECTS
139
000C,
-0.02 -0.01
-0.06
-0.08 -0.10
-012 -0.14
-016.
-02000
10
0.5
1.5
2.0
30
2.5
3.5
H
Fig. 4.4.4.
circle having the center in Qo and the radius R big enough, such that the profile C belong to the interior of the circle. The domain exterior to the curve C - c + CF and interior to the circle CR will be denoted by D. We shall integrate on this domain the first equation from (4.4.25) and and we shall apply Green's formula. One obtains: 2 = P[U+(x, xo)nr(x) + V. (x, xo)nv(x)Ids+ + find P (U+r1r + V. n.,,)ds + -00
f)(U*nr +V. nv)ds . 1z
(4.4.26)
With the parametrizatiou (4.3.37) we deduce on CR: :c - :r.0
COs
(r-xo)2+(y- ))2 - R x-x'0
_
(x - xo)2 + (y + yo)2
Cos
/
'
_
T. - xU R2 + 411o(y - yo) + 4Jo
I 1 +4sin R
z
R +42)
1
=
Cos
+O(R `)
whence,
u+ =
RV
-
+ O(Rr2), V+
si
+ O(R--)
140
THE BOUNDARY ELEMENTS METHOD
V. = O(R-2) . Utilizing the parametrization (4.3.35) on C1 we have for example
U! = O(R-2),
y-yo+2yo y+yo (x-xo)2(y+yo)2 (x-xo)2+(y-vo)2+4yo(y-1m)+4y 2 (,+,,sin 2yo j (1 + Esyoe +
2yo
2
bI
+ 0(c).
Hence, Uf
_
1
=tar
C0619+0(6),
s
_
V1
sine 1 e + 4Ayo
+0(6).
Taking into account that on C. we have d s = Ed 9 and on CR, d s = Rdw, we get: 6o+x
lim
(U+n= + V nv)d s = PC.
limo PC
tar ,
(U..n + V+ny)d s=
1
d9
2t
I f0 de = 2.
Replacing all these in (4.4.26) it follows the first relation (4.4.12).
4.5 4.5.1
The Airfoil in Tunnel Effects The Representation of the Solution
Assuming that the airfoil is situated between two planes parallel to the direction of the unperturbed stream (fig. 4.5.1), we have to integrate the system (4.1.7) in the domain exterior to the contour C and bounded by the two planes, with the boundary conditions (4.1.10) and the supplementary condition (4.5.1) v(x, 0) = 0, v(x, a) = 0 (V)x, Denoting by D the domain of motion delimited by the sides x = fd (fig. 4.5.2), we deduce for d - oo the identity ID [u(Of I8x - 89/8y) + v(8f/8y + 89/&)I da =
= JR/u + gv)n, + (f v - 9u)nv)ds+
+J
+00
00
q(x, 0)u(x, 0)dx 00
g(x, a)u(x, a)d x . +00
(4.5.2)
141
THE AIRFOIL IN TUNNEL EFFECTS
Fig. 4.5.2.
We took into account (4.5.1) and the fact that for x = td the integrals vanish when d --+ oo if f and g behave like the solution of (4.1.13) and it and v have the property (4.1.11). For f =1.t and g = -V+, where (17+, V+) verifies in the domain occupied by the fluid, the system (4.1.12) and the relations V+(x, 0) = 0,
V+(x, a) = 0,
(4.5.3)
we get from (4.5.2):
u(4) =
lc 1u(x)[U+(x,01=(x)
(4.5.4)
+v(x) [U+(x, 4)ny(x) -V+(=. F)n7(x)] )d s.
Analogously, for f = V_ and g = U_, where (U_,V_) verify the system (4.1.12) and have the supplementary property U_(x,0) = 0,
U_(x,a) = 0,
(4.5.5)
we get from (4.5.2):
v() _ (4.5.6)
+v(x) [U-(x, t)rns(x) - V-(x, Ony(x)] }d s.
142
THE BOUNDARY ELEMENTS METHOD
Hence we obtain for u(x) and v(4) the same representation like in (4.4.1), with the difference that (UU, V V ) become (U_+, V ).
4.5.2
Green Functions
The system (4.1.12) determines the fundamental solutions of the system (4.1.7). These are distributions. The fundamental solutions which are defined only in a portion of the plane and satisfy the boundary conditions are named Green functions, or, more properly, Green distributions.
The solutions (U+,V+) and (U_,V_) are therefore Green functions. For obtaining these solutions we employ the method of images. If M(t)
is a point of the strip -oo < z < +oo 0 < y < a (fig. 4.5.1), then the solution (without restrictions) of the system (4.1.12) is (4.1.13). As we already know, it represents the perturbation produced in the entire plane xOy by a source located in M. For satisfying the first condition of (4.5.3), we have to place a source having the same intensity (taken to
be equal to the unity) in the symmetric point M(t, -ri). For satisfying the second condition of (4.5.3), we have to place sources having the same intensity in the points which are the symmetric points of M and
M with respect to the y = a axis, i.e. in the points Mi (t, 2a - rl), Mi (t, 2a + q). These sources disturb the condition on y = 0, such that
we have to place sources in the symmetrical points of Mi and Mi with respect to the y = 0 axis, i.e. in the points M+1 (t, -2a + i) and -2a - ,) etc. The perturbations produced by these sources are
x-t
1
+
V(")+
27r (x-t)2+[(y-(2na±q)12 1
y-(2nat9)
(4.5.7)
27r (x - t)2 + [y - (2na ±, )12
and they satisfy the system OUP }/Ox + OV n)/Oy = a(x - t, y _ (2na ± ii)) (4.5.8)
OVA" i /Ox + OD'") /ay = 0.
In the strip -oo < x < +oo, 0 < y < a, all the perturbations satisfy the homogeneous system, excepting the perturbation (Uo , V+)
THE AIRFOIL IN TUNNEL EFFECTS
143
which satisfies the corresponding non-honwgeneous system.
lI+(x, ) = 2;r
(x'
+ [y - (2nn + 11)]'
+
(4.5.9)
r:
I 'V-4'
{ (r
=-00
y - (2nn + rl)
}
(x - )2 + [y - (2nn + n)]2
2,r n=-00
y - (2na - r1)
[y- (2na-17)]2
+{:r.
satisfies the system (4.1.12) and the boundary conditions (4.5.3). It is just the solution utilized in (4.5.4). In the same way we deduce that the solution
U-(x, ) = 2;r
{ (x - C)2 + [y - (2na + 11)12
-
x-t (4.5.10)
)-2,
L
I
n=-1
(2na
+ 11)
(a-ti)2+ [y-(2na+1))]2+
y-(2na-11) + (x - )2 + [y - (2na -11)]1
satisfies the system (4.1.12) and the boundary condition (4.5.5). This is just the solution utilized in (4.5.6). The series (4.5.9) and (4.5.10) are the Green functions of the problem. The sums intervening in (4.5.9) and (4.5.10) may be calculated using the formula = ircot az,
(4.5.11)
where z = x + iy. Separating the real part, from the imaginary one, we
144
THE BOUNDARY ELEMENTS METHOD
get from (4.5.11): +oo
y
y2 + (x - n)2
= 7r
sink 27ry cosh 2iry - cos 21rx (4.5.12)
+00
0
x-n
sin 2irx
n=-ao y2 + (x - n)2 = A cosh 2iry - cos 27rx
Using these relations we obtain the expressions of the Green functions:
sinhQ(x-
(x - ) - cos Q (y - q)
cosh Q
71
f=4n cosh 1
sinh -(x
- .)
a (x - ) - cos a (y + +)) (4.5.13) 7r
_
V f (x, ) =
sin -(y - q) n
1
sin
7;(y
cosh Q(x - e) -
4.5.3
+
A
`a
+,q) 7r(y + n)
The Integral Equation
In the sequel we shall proceed like in 4.3.2, i.e. we pass to the limit
-i xo E C in (4.5.4) and (4.5.6), we introduce the function G by means of the formula (4.3.9) and we utilize the relations
+(x, xo)n.(x) + V+ (x, xo)ny(x)]d s = - 2 (4.5.14)
lu-(x,xo)ny (x) - V-(x,xo)n.(x)1ds = 0,
145
THE AIRFOIL IN TUNNEL EFFECTS
which will be demonstrated in Appendix 4.5.5. One obtains the following integral equation:
(1/2)G(xo) - c {U_(x,xo)n(x)
V+(x, xo)nt,(x)+
+M2ni(X) + f(X) [V-(x, xo)nx(xo)-
(4.5.15)
-U+(x, xo)n,(xo)]}Gds = Onv(xo) , and discretizing, we deduce the system N
(1/2)Gi + E AijGj = Bi, j = 1, ... , N,
(4.3.16)
i.t
where Aij is A!. from (4.5.15) with the notatipns
U= f Dx, x°)ds, l= J V f(x, x°)d s
.
(4.5.17)
;
..
In order to determine these coefficients we consider on Lj the parametrization (4.2.19). Further we have two possibilities: the exact calculus like in 4.2.4, or the approximate calculus, with Gauss-type quadrature formulas (A.55], for the resulting integrals +l Ut(t)d
1-'
Uii =
2
t, Vj = 1_j t1 f V±(t)d t . 2
t
(4.5.18)
t
In case that i = j, these integrals become singular for t = 0, because of the terms sinh a [x(t) - x?d t
+1 t
cosh
a
sin
t ui
[x(t) - x°] - cos'-` [y(t) - A a
a
(y(t) - y°) d t
[x(t) - x°] - cos [y(t) - y°j
cosh
a
a
146
THE BOUNDARY ELEMENTS METHOD
but, taking into account that the integrands are odd functions, we deduce that they vanish. We have therefore 1.
+1
8a
i
Uf=± ` }-
`" -
sink - [x(t) - x9 'd t
a
cosh
[x(t) -;J - cos a [y(t) - y°] (4.5.19)
a
sin
+e
Co.),
a
[y(t) - y,)jd t
n 7r [x(t) - x,)[ - cos [y(t) - yp[ a a
These integrals may be also calculated numerically, using the Gauss-type quadrature formulas.
4.5.4 The Verification of the Method In order to perform this verification the shall use the solution given by the complex potential
f (z) = z + Ctanh
(4.5.20)
z
where C and a are real constants. Let us study the flow determined by this potential. Employing Euler's formulas we deduce the identities sinh iy = i sin y,
cosh iy = cos y
cosh 2 Ax cos2 Ay + sinh2 Ax sins Ay = 2 (cosh 2Ax + oos 2Ay),
cosh2 Ax cost Ay
- sinh2Ax sin Ay = 2 (1 + cosh 2Ax cos 2Ay), (4.5.21)
such that, separating the imaginary parts, we get from (4.5.20): C sin 2Ay
- y + cosh 2Ax + cos 2Ay '
(4.5.22)
We denoted A = 7r/a. Obviously the straight lines y = 0 and y = a are streamlines ('P = 0 and 'I' = a). Another streamline is the line y = a/2(41 = a/2) but not entirely because for x = 0 the fraction from (4.5.22) is not determined. Further we shall study the velocity field. From (4.5.20) it results
w(z) = u
iv = I +
AC cosh2 Az
,
(4.5.23)
THE AIRFOIL IN TUNNEL EFFECTS
147
whence, utilizing (4.5.21), u.
= 1 + 2AC
1 + ch2 Ax cos 2Ay (cosh 2Ax + cos 2Ay)2 (4.5.24)
V = 2AC
sinh2 Ax sin 2Ay (cosh 2Ax + cos 2Ay)2
Now we return to the streamline y = a/2. This line may be continued ('I' = a/2) on the set of points (x, y) where we have: a z
= -y+
C sin 2Ay cosh 2Ax + cos 2Ay
(4.5.25)
This curve is symmetric with respect to the Oy axis, because the equation is even in the x variable. It is also symmetric with respect to the y = a/2 axis, because the points having the ordinates y = a/2 + yo and y = a/2 - yo, where
_ yo
C sin 2Ayo
cosh 2Ax - cost Ayo
(4.5.26)
simultaneously belong to the curve. Hence the curve having the equations (4.5.25) is an oval which orthogonally intersects the axes y = a/2
and x = 0. In the point P(-a, a/2) we have therefore u = 0. From (4.5.24) it follows the equation
sinh2An = AC,
(4.5.27)
for the half-diameter a as a function of C. The semi-diameter 6 on the Oy axis may be determined from (4.5.26) as follows
_
C sin 2A,0
1-cos2Af3' whence it results a simpler equation
$tan AQ = C.
(4.5.28)
We draw the conclusion that the complex potential (4.5.20) characterizes the uniform flow with the velocity (1, 0), in the channel having the sides
y = 0 and y = a, in the presence of the oval having the diameters 2a and 2/3 with the center on the Oy axis (fig. 4.5.3). It is not difficult to see how this potential was obtained. One knows that the uniform flow at infinity, in the presence of a doublet, determines
THE BOUNDARY LLPMENTSMEITHOD
148
y=0
L. H=8110
x=0
Fig
the flow past a circular obstacle. Let us study now the circular flow in the presence of a doublet in a channel. For the sake of simplicity, we
consider the doublet situated in the origin and y = a/2, y = -a/2, the equations of the lines which are the walls of the channel. These right lines become streamlines for the flow determined by the doublet, if we add, according to the method of images. symmetric doublets. The potential f0(z) describing the flow produced by these doublets is
A(z)_...+
I z+ia
+1+
+...
1
=
_ro
_ let -cot Trz Ia IT
1
Ir
irz
u
a
-coth
Ave take
fo(z) = CcothA>. A = 7r/a,
C representing it real o constant. If the Ox axis coincides with the lower wall. as we have previously considered. then the potential becomes
fo(z) = Ceoth A
(:_ i a2)
= Ct.unh Az .
Adding the potential of the uniform flow having the velocity (1,0) we obtain (4.5.20). In the paper [4.9] that we utilized for writing this subsection, we made tests for the local pressure coefficient C,,, defined by (4.2.35). In figure 4.5.4 we present the values of Ci, calculated exactly (by means of (4.5.24) and the values calculated with the numerical method presented
above with H = a/10. The maximum relative error is 0.73% in the case of a discretiration with 80 nodes. For the circular obstacle, symmetrically placed in a tunnel, we present the compressibility effect in figure 4.5.5 where one indicates the variation of the maximum velocity
THE AIRFOIL IN TUNNEL EFFECTS
149
i-
I -o-
-
na i
\ 0 J Fig. 4.5.4.
_
Fig. 4.5.3.
against the distance to the walls for 'r = 1.405 in the cases M = 0 and M = 0.3 and in the absence of the circulation (F = 0). We considered 60 equidistant nodes on the circumference. In [4.9) one presents the graphic representations for C, in the case of the NACA-4412 profile at 0 angle of attack and Mach=0.5 in a free stream and in a tunnel. The example is instructive, because, in this case the trailing edge is angular, and we have to impose the equality of the pressures on the two sides of the edge in order to determine the circulation.
4.5.5 Appendix In order to prove the first formula (4.5.14) we shall notice that (U+, V+) (x, y, xo, yo) satisfy in the domain D, exterior to the contour C-c+C1,
and bounded by the walls y = 0 and y = a and by the segments x = ±d, the equation:
aU+/49x+aV+/Oy=6(x-xo,y-yo). Integrating this equation over D and applying Gauss's formula one obtains:
J (U+nx + V+n1)d s + ii;t a 1c,
+ d im
ra
J0
(U+n" +
s+
U+(d, y, xo, yo)d p + slim J t7+(-d, y, xo, yo)d p = 1, -oo J.a (4.5.29)
THE BOUNDARY ELEMENTS METHOD
150
the integrals on y = 0 and y = a vanishing by virtue of the relations (4.5.1). The integrals on C6 are calculated utilizing the parauiietrizntions (4.3.35) which imply
sin0+C,
cos0+0(e),
Uf=
I
I
where C_
1
2ryo
yn
1
1 + a2
n=0
(yo/a)2 - n2
To the limit, when a -i 0, this is 1/2. One calculate the last two integrals taking into account that d t Id
_
2
(a. - b)tan (t/2)
a -b
a+bcost
arctan
a -b'
To the limit, when d -- 0, every integral is 1/2. One obtains the first formula (4.5.14). Analogously, we obtain the second formula if we integrate the equation aTJ_/ay
- 8TH-/ax = 0
on the same domain D.
4.6 4.6.1
Other Methods. The Intrinsic Integral Equation The Method of Regularization
The methods that we have already utilized have been given by L. Drago§ [4.6] and by L. Drago§ and A. Dinu [4.7], [4.8], [4.9], [4.10]. Specific to these methods is the fact that one utilizes physical variables the velocity and pressure fields), such that from the solution one obtains directly the elements of interest in aerodynamics (the velocity and the pressure on the profile). Other methods (Biudolino a.o. [4.2], Morino and Luo [4.20]) utilize the real potential and others (Griello a.o. [4.15],
Carabineanu [4.4]), the stream function. All these methods may be utilized only for incompressible fluid. The theory that we are going to present in the sequel will be also applied to the incompressible fluid, but it has the advantage to utilize the physical fields. Moreover, the singular integrals are avoided and one utilizes the intrinsic elements of the flow (the tangential component of the velocity). Therefore it is suitable to call this method the method of regularization [4.11].
OTHER METHODS. THE INTRINSIC INTEGRAL EQUATION
151
Denoting
V = Un(i+v),
(4.6.1)
we shall determine the perturbation from the equations
dive=0, rotv=0
(4.6.2)
with the boundary condition (4.6.3)
and the condition at infinity limn v(x) = 0.
(4.6.4)
We may write the equations (4.6.2) as follows
div (v - c) = 0, rot (v - c) = 0,
(4.6.5)
c representing a constant vector. We put into evidence the normal and tangential components of the velocity:
v = (v n)n + (v s)s =
v,8.
(4.6.6)
By virtue of the condition (4.6.3) we may write
v = -n?n + v,s.
(4.6.7)
Rewriting the scalar formulas from 4.3 as a vectorial formula we deduce that for every two continuously differentiable functions or distri-
butions f and g , by virtue of the equations (4.6.5) (k - the versor of the Oz axis), we have:
ID if div (v - c) + (gk) rot(v - c)]da = 0,
(4.6.8)
D representing, like, in 4.3.1, the domain exterior to C and interior to the circle Cn having the radius R big enough. Utilizing the formulas
div f (v - c) = (v - c) grad f + f div (v - c) (4.6.9)
div [gk x (v - c)] = (v - c) rot (gk) - gk rot (v - c) and applying Gauss's theorem, we obtain the identity:
J(v -c) gradf-rot(gk))da=
f(v - c) (fn-nxgk)ds, }- CR
(4.6.10)
152
THE BOUNDARY ELEMENTS METHOD
n being the normal (pointing outwards the domain D (i.e. the inward pointing normal with respect to C and the outward pointing normal with respect to CR). We shall write the distribution (4.1.13) as follows
v,-
1
x - xn
2r,
Ix - xo12
(4.6.11)
and the system (4.1.12) that it satisfie :
divv'=b(x-x()), rote'=0,
(4.6.12)
the equations being valid for every point xn from D + C. For (f, g) (u', -v'), one obtains from (4.6.10) the projection of the identity
(v - c)divv'da = J
{[n (v - c)]v + [n x (v -- c)] x v}ds, +CR
JJJD
(4.6.13)
on the Or axis. For (f,g)
(v'.u') we obtain the projection of the same identity on the Oy axis. Hence the relation (4.6.13) is valid. By virtue of (4.6.12) we obtain from (4.6.13)
v(xa) - c = f
{[n (v - c)]v' 4. [ri x (t+ - c)] x v}tl s. (4.6.14) TCu
llere we shall put c = v(xo) - vo and we shall evaluate the integral on CJt. Utiliziug the parametrization (4.3.37), we shall deduce for the projection of this integral on the Ox axis
xli
{n - (v - vo)u' + (u - ua)(u'n7 + v'n,)2m
-riI[(ei - 110W + (v - vo)v']}d3 =
1
2=r j (u - t!o)dV = -110,
because for R , oo, u vanishes according to the condition (4.6.4). One deduces a similar formula for the projection on the Oy axis. Utilizing these results one obtains from (4.6.14) the following representation
V(x0) = PC {[n (v - vo)]v' + In x (v - vo)] x v' }d s.
(4.6.15)
The integral is not singular because the factor v - vo tends to zero when x xo E C. This is a regularized integral. The formula (4.6.15) is valid for both xo in the fluid and on the boundary C.
OTHER METHODS. THE INTRINSIC INTEGRAL EQUATION
153
We notice utilizing (4.6.7) that on C we have
nxv=v,k (4.6.16)
In - (v-vo)]v' = (-n=+ such that, after elementary calculations, from (4.6.15) one obtains
V(xo) _
P(v,k x v' + v;((v' . s°)n-(n v')s° - (n s°)v'] - nxv'-
(4.6.17)
-79x((n° v`)n - (n . v')n° - (n n°)v']}d s. For obtaining the unknown v, outside the integral, we shall perform the operation no x (4.6.17) and we shall take into account that we have no_ soy, n o_ y - -soy,
(4 6 18)
no x v' = (so v')k
(4.6.19)
:-
.
.
We deduce
no x s°
whence 11°= 4.6.20)
((s° . v')n' - (so v')ns]d s. This is the integral equation of the problem. It is a regularized (nonsingular) integral equation because when x - x°, the denominators and the numerators (n° v')v°) of the integrand simultaneously vanish (see (4.6.11)). The equation (4.6.20) was obtained in a different manner by V.Cardng (4.5]. It is, obviously an intrinsic equation. This equation may be also solved by means of the boundary elements method. One obtains, like above, a linear algebraic system of N equations with
N unknowns. In the case of lifting airfoils the following boundary condition is added (see also (4.3.23)).
-+Pf.
(4.6.21)
154
THE BOUNDARY ELEMENTS METHOD
Taking (4.6.1) and (4.6.18) into account, we apply this condition as follows:
v. (P.) + v.(A) = ny(P.) + ny(Pi) ,
(4.6.22)
P, and Pi being sufficiently close of Pf. From the equation (4.6.20) and the condition (4.6.22) we shall determine v, on C. 'Since we have more equations than unknowns, we shall treat the problem like in 4.3.5, introducing the auxiliary variable A. The reader may find examples in [4.11].
Chapter 5 The Theory of Finite Span Airfoil in Subsonic Flow. The Lifting Surface Theory
5.1 5.1.1
The Lifting Surface Equation The Statement of the Problem
We assume that an uniform flow, having the velocity (the Ox axis has the direction and the sense of the uniform flow), the pressure p,, , the density p,, and Af(= U,./c,.) < 1, is perturbed by the presence of a finite span wing, perpendicular on the flow direction. Any body which has a characteristic dimension much larger then the two other dimensions is considered to be a wing. We call the span of the wing, the length of the wing taken along the direction of the large characteristic dimension (figure 5.1.1).
Fig. 5.1.1.
One requires to determine the action of the fluid against the wing. In fact. as we have already seen when we studied the two-dimensional case, for determining the action, one has to calculate the perturbation
THE LIFTING SURFACE THEORY
156
fields p(x) and v(x). We employ the Cartesian variables x,y, z introduced in (2.1.1) and
the fields p and v introduced by (2.1.3). The Oy-axis has the span direction and the origin 0 is situated in the middle of the wing. The Oz-axis is taken perpendicular to the Ox and Oy-axes in order to detennine a Cartesian, positive oriented frame.
We assume that the projection of the wing onto the xOy-plane is a simple connected domain D, with a piecewise smooth boundary &D such that every straight line parallel to the Ox-axis (which has the direction of the unperturbed flow) should intersect the boundary in almost two points Q. and Q f. As we may see in figures 5.1.2 and 5.1.3, the lateral edges of the wing may be exceptions from this assumption if
they are parallel to the Ox -axis . The intersection of 8D with a lateral edge parallel to the Ox -axis consists of a point, two confounded points or a straight segment. Assuming that the two lateral edges consist
of a point (denoted respectively by B and B') we notice that they divide the boundary into two arcs
The front arc BB' which is attacked by the stream is called the leading edge and the rear arc is called the trailing edge. The equation
of the leading edge (consisting of the points Q,) is x = x_(y), and the equation of the trailing edge is x = x+(y). Hence Qa has the Cartesian coordinates (x- (y), y) and Qf (x+ (y), y). For wings with lateral edges consisting of simple or confounded points we obviously have:
x+(±b) = x-(±b),
(5.1.1)
where 2b is the span (in dimensionless variables). We shall call these ones I wings, and the wings whose lateral edges consist of straight segments will be called II wings. For the II wings the condition (5.1.1) will be replaced by the condition of the continuity of the pressure along the edge (the Kutta-Joukowski condition (see (5.1.30)). In figures 5.1.2 we indicated the domain D for some I wings having lateral edges consisting of simple points (the delta wing, figure a), the gothic wing, figure b), the trapezoidal wing, figure c), the rhombic wing, figure d), the swallow tail wing, figure e) or lateral edges consisting of double confounded points (the elliptical wing, figure f)). In figure 5.1.3 we present the domain D for the arrow shaped wing (with lateral edges consisting of straight segments). The domain D is named the plane form of the wing or the planar form of the wing.
157
THE LIF"TINC SURFACE EQUATION
b)
a)
d)
f)
e) Fig. 5.1.2.
We notice that the wing has two surfaces: the upper surface, denoted by S+ and the lower surface denoted by S_ . The equations of these
THE LIFTi G SURFACE THEORY
158
surfaces may be written (for the sake of simplicity) in the following form
z = h(x, y) f hj (x, y) ,
(x, y) E D .
(5.1.2)
Indeed, considering z = f (x, y) the equation for S+ and z = g(x, y) the equation for S_, then, setting 2h(x, y) = f (x, y) + g(x, y) (5.1.3) 2h1(x,y) = f(x,y) - g(x,y),
we obtain (5.1.2).
B.
Fig. 5.1.3.
The wing is thin if and only if h and h1 have the form h(x, y) = A-(x, y),
h1(x, y) = Fhl (x, y)
,
(5.1.4)
E(<<1) being a real parameter (max h, h1 in D), and !t $i hl bounded functions. We also assume that h(x,y) and hl (x, y) are defined on D and have the first order derivatives with respect to x, denoted by h,,, hi=.
The two surfaces S+ and S_ do not intersect each other if and only if h(x, y) + hl (x, y) > h(x, y) - hi (x, y).
5.1.2
(5.1.5)
Bibliographical Comments
The bibliography concerning this subject is extremely rids and it is not possible tp mention it entirely. In fact, this is not necessary
'ME LIFTING SURFACE EQUATION
159
because the fundamental solutions method, utilized herein is different from the previously utilized methods. As we have already mentioned in the introduction, the methods utilized so far rely on the equation of the potential (we assume that the perturbation is irrotational, the wing being assimilated to a distributions of bound vortices or doublets. Downstream, behind the wing, where the experience shows that the flow is not irrotational, one introduces in an artificial manner a free vortices
distribution. The perturbation of the velocity results from the velocity field induced by the two distributions. This is Prandtl's model [6.21) for the lifting line theory, which assumes that the wing may be replaced by the segment BB'. The lifting surface theory, which does not replace
the domain D with the segment BY, was developed after 1936 by Prandtl [5.26], (5.27), Weissinger [5.35], Reissner [5.29], Multhopp [5.24], Flax, Lawrence [5.12), Truckenbrodt (5.32), Mangler and Spencer (5.22),
etc. We also mention the unpublished paper [5.6] of P.Cociirlan. Some synthesis of the research in this domain may be found for example in [1.1), [1.2], (1.38) and [1.41]. D. Homentcovschi [5.16] presents, for the compressible fluid, a theory relying on the equations of motion written in distributions, without assuming that the flow is potential. Another theory is given in (5.7]. Here one introduces the fundamental solutions method. It is not necessary to assume that the flow is potential and a vortices sheet is formed behind the the wing. These properties result from equations.
5.1.3
The General Solution
As we have already mentioned in 3.1.3, there is no physical reason to replace the wing by a distribution of vortices. It is reasonable to replace the wing by a distribution of forces which should have against the fluid
the same action as the wing. Indeed, the fluid and the wing must be considered as an interacting material system. According to Cauchy's tension principle (see [1.11), p.35), there exists a ford distribution f on the wing (or on D) which has the same action against the fluid like the wing itself. The perturbation of the fluid flow will be determined by this distribution and by the slipping condition on the surface of the wing. We try to employ a forces distribution on D, having the form
f = (f1,0,f)(,t1) If we manage to satisfy the boundary conditions, on the basis of the uniqueness theorem, we deduce that we found the solution of the prob-
160
THE LIFTING SURFACE THEORY
Obviously, there exist various distributions which enable us to reach the solution. In chapter 7 we shall employ distributions on the boundary of the body. From (2.3.24) we deduce that the perturbation of the pressure due 1em.
to the force f applied in the point (t, q) is
ft(c rt)8 + f(c n)8 u-.) ,
(5.1.6)
xo=x-t,yo=y-v1, Ri= xo+(yo+z2),
(5.1.7)
P(x,IV,x)
J
where
A continuous superposition of such forces on D, will give
[fi(ii)- + f
P(x, y, z) = -1
n) ez
] JJD since the problem is linear. For the potential jp, from (2.3.28) we deduce ( X y, z) = T 7r-
JD
[f
(R1
) -- uo+
z z2
(_) d t d n ,
+ RI) f (t,
n)1 d
(5.1.8)
dn (5.1.9)
and for the velocity field from (2.3.12)
v(x, y, z) = 6(z) Jf f(, t7)H(xo)b(yo)d d r< + Oip
(5.1.10)
which can be written explicitly:
u(x, y, z) = 6(z) Jj h (, r1)H(xo)a(yo)d d r- p(x, y, z)
v(x,y,z) =
AD I fl
,
(f,n)' (i;)
-f(t,rl)Z [y
(i+9.)] }ddt 2 (5.1.11)
w(x, y, z) = 6(z)
IfD f (t, tt)H(xo)5(yo)df d n+
+4- fD f fi(t,n)g ()dd_ r1
-4Rffnf(F,n)az
[1l0
z2
THE LIFTING SURFACE EQUATION
161
For w, from (2.3.29) we get:
w(x,y,z)
4rr
lID
[fi(i); (RI}
-Q2f(E,rl)
CRI)
JdC dq+
+4 AD f(C17)Zy
(5.1.12)
(l+ Xg
Jo2+YO
Ri)J
z2
dtdn
From formula (5.1.10) we deduce that the perturbation is potential,
excepting the strip from the xOy - plane, -b < y < b, x > x_ (y), where the first term does not vanish. We notice that the existence of the vortices sheet behind the wing, which was a hypothesis in the classical theories (see Prandtl [6.21]), represents herein a consequence following from the equations of motion. As the experience confirms the existence of such a sheet, it means that the experience confirms the mathematical model based on the fundamental solutions method.
5.1.4
The Boundary Values of the Pressure
In view of calculating the boundary values of the pressure when z -' ±0 and (x, y) E D, we notice that the first term from (5.1.8) represents the tangential derivative of a simple layer potential and the second, the normal derivative of the same potential. From the potential theory one knows (see for example, [1.6), [1.39]) how to obtain the boundary values of these derivatives but we prefer to calculate them directly. After deriving we have to calculate
It
limo
f
i
(s, y) E D
(5.1.13) =-
lim
z-'.±O JD
(x, y) ED
dd
f(t,n)
.
1
We notice that setting z = ±0 and (x, y) E D, Rl vanishes when the generic integration point Q(t, n) coincides with M(x, y) E D. The integral Il becomes singular. Denoting by DE the disk with the radius
THE LIFTING SURFACE THEORY
162
E and the center h1, we shall write and we shall consider by definition ,
hm
(5.1.14)
U IJD 110 = JJ-D, +AD, if the limit exists. For calculating the integral on Dt, one makes the
change of variable
O7D,
q -+ r, 0: - x = Or c os 0, tj - y = r sin 0 (5.1.15)
0
0<0<21r
and one notices that if f is a continuous function, for a small enough, we may approximate f on the disk with f (x, y). We deduce:
AD, 1 and then, the formula
dtj=
fJ
r2 cos
f(xJ 1!) 12,,
0c (
f1
r2
+z 2)3/2
d9dr=0
=o1 f(e,r1)0dedt, R
(5.1.16)
D
where
R= Vxg+
(5.1.17)
As it is shown in (E.0.12), the last integral exists. As regarding 12, it vanishes outside a vicinity DD of M. We have therefore I2
Zo :
(x. y) E D
.f(C,t]) z dCdti
lID
74
2s
=f
li
n)
fo
z
Jo
(5.1.18)
rd 0d r = f2tr f (x, y) Jo (r2 + z2)3/2
(;, v) E D
Taking into account these results, from (5.1.8) we deduce:
p(x, y, f0) =
-
0
ID f i (4, r]) ? d d of 2f (x, y), (x, y) E D. (5.1.19)
This is the formula for the pressure on the upper and lower surfaces of the wing. We deduce the formula (5.1.20) p(x, y, +0) - p(2, y, -0) = f (x, y) , which gives us the significance of the function f (x, y). Like in the twodimensional case, f is the jump of the pressure on the wing. This is a fundamental result for the calculus of the aerodynamic action.
THE LIFTING SURFACE EQUATION
5.1.5
163
The Boundary Values of the Component w
If one utilizes (5.1.11), then taking the limit, when z -+ ±0, the first term disappears because 5(±0) = 0. It is more difficult to calculate the limit of the last term because it contains the derivative with respect to z. The calculation is performed in (5.221 and in 11.111, p.208, 209. We utilize here the expression (5.1.12) for w. In this expression, the limits of the first two terms are given by the formulas (5.1.17) and (5.1.18) and the derivative with respect to y from the last term commutes with the limit. We have therefore, lira
13
a8y yo + z
I1
a
z
(1 + La Rl )] dC drl =
(s, y) E D
(5.1.21)
8
_
j22K(xty,z7ii)dt,
y) ED +Cr,
with the notation x+(7)
K(x,y,z,r1)=1_
(5.1.22) 00
After setting z = 0 in the last expression of 13, we notice that we may not simplify with yo, because it vanishes for 77 = y. We shall divide the integral into three parts:
J-bb
_ 1b £+Jy+E+
JyyEa
The last integral vanishes because for F small enough we may consider K(x, y, z, v7) = K(x, y, z, y) whence
+E
TY-C
yoz
K(x,y,z,rl)dn=-K(x,v,z,y) f +E +z =0. E u 2du2
For the integrals on (-b, y - s) and (y + e, +b) we may pass to the limit, setting z ± 0 and we may then simplify by yo, because it does
THE LIFTING suitFACE THEORY
164
not vanish. It follows 13 =
a
Hen I I
`J b
3y
= line
+ r rb\ ! (r., rl, 0, 0 d rJ
Jy+il
1C(x,'y, 0, y - E)
l
f
+b\l
,,...s
+
t3
=
Yo
1i
(x, y.
L'
+ \J-b + Jv+c/ ay \ yo /
0,
y + `)
(5.1.23)
d tJ
Expanding into a Taylor series the first two terms and taking into account the definition of the "Principal Value" (D.3.1) and the definition of the "Finite Part" (D.3.6), we deduce 3'/`' b
1
+1 tb
h'(x,
II
_JJDf -7( o- `1+
Rddy+2
ayh(x,y,0,J1)di, _
JJ,
f(e,iJ)x (5.1.24)
Taking into account the expressions of 11,11 and 13 from (5.1.12) we obtain: u,(x, y, ±0)
5.1.6
= f fl (?', y) - 41, 1fn f (y, i) (l +
)
d d r1 . (5.1.25)
The Integral Equation
F om the boundary conditions (2.1.33) and the equatiolLS (5.1.2) we deduce: ua(x, y, f0) = Jr=(3:. y) t h' (x, y)
,
(:r, y) E D .
(5.1.26)
Replacing the last relation in (5.1.25), subtracting and adding the two relations, the first corresponding to the upper sign (the condition on the upper surface) and the second corresponding to the lower sign, we get (5.1.27)
4
_ ly JJ n
C1
yo
\
+
0) d diJ = hr(x,y), R
(x, y) E D.
(5.1.28)
THE LIFTING SURFACE EQUATION
165
The relation (5.1.27) determines directly f, (w, y) and the relation (5.1.28) constitutes an integral equation for determining the function f . This is the well known equation of the lifting surface. It is obviously a
singular integral equation with a strong singularity. The mark * is for the "Finite Part". For the incompressible fluid, The equation has been written for the first time by Multhopp in 1950 [5.24]. A rigorous demonstration is given by Mangler in the Appendix of the above mentioned article. The demonstration is quite complicated because the author utilizes the representation
w(x,y,z)=-47r
(5.1.29)
which follows from (5.1.11). Short deductions are presented in [1.1], [1.38].
For wings with lateral edges consisting from straight segments (figure 5.1.3) the equation (5.1.28) is integrated with the conditions
f (x, ±b) = 0
(5.1.30)
which, taking into account (5.1.20), means the continuity of the pressure (the Kutta-Joukowski condition). On the trailing edge
x = x+(y), -b < y < +b
(5.1.31)
one imposes the boundedness condition for the function f (x, y). An equation equivalent to (5.1.28) was given by Lawrence and Flax in 1951 [6.11]. Formally, it can be obtained from (5.1.28) using the identity
)= R
(I+0
yo
xo+R _ 8 rxo+Ro xpyo) 8y 1 \ xoyo 8
(5.1.32)
It follows: 4v
1
A
f(
AC 17)
(1+)ddtih'(xY)1
(x, y) E D.
(5.1.33)
Sometimes it is preferable to use this equation instead of (5.1.28), because it has weaker singularities (Cauchy-type singularities). A rigorous deduction of equation (5.1.33) from (5.1.28) must start from the definitions of the Finite Part and Principal Value . Using the function
C(y) = -
/
+(n)
s . (n)
f (t, t1)d e ,
(5.1.34)
TILE LIMNG SURFACE THEORY
166
whose significance will be given in 6.1, one demonstrates the identities
r f(art) d z; d q - -
= Iv
yJD dy
ff
X
f(C rl) d
(5.1.35)
d d(5.1.36)
ff
aUo
d
e
which lead to the equivalence in view (see also 6.1).
5.1.7 Other Forms of the Integral Equation 1. We are going to give another form for the expression (5.1.12) of the component w . In this expression the integrals are not singular, so we may employ Green-type formulas. We have
(1+.)]dd1l=
fin
_aly 1 70, +_ - i
yo
z2 {1
+
a)}
drl
d
(1+)]ddY! 1111 Lf YD_2 R1 + y02
+
JJ D
a yoZa YO (1 + RI ) d d l = r 1 Jo J
= PODf(4,r!)yo
a
.a
YO
1/o+z2
(5.1.37)
Using the identity:
(
ax `Ri)
1
l/ + 3 R z
8 (_ i xo
Of
oR
(5.1.38)
and Green's formula, we deduce
I
fDf(c,rl)8x
(_)ddT!= -POD M,17)
+132z2ffD x(oR1)dedn-JJ1
l
Lf
(5.1.39) YO T9Ridr dry.
167
THE LIFTING SURFACE EQUATION
Replacing (5.1.37) and (5.1.39) in (5.1.12) and passing to the limit, we obtain 1
1
w(x, y, ±O) = t 2 f 1(x, y) +47rJaL -
f (c n) ( yo
\l +
R moo) d e+
(5.1.40)
+4n JJD 5; yo \1 +
o} dt dn,
whence it follows the integral equation:
R
f (C n)
1
47rJoD
yo
(5.1.41)
of +4R JJD
yo
+
J de do ° h=(x,y)
This is the equation given by Homentcovschi equation herein, utilizing
Green's formulas before passing to the limit is preferable to that of Homentcovschi which utilizes Green's formulas for singular integrals. Formally, the equation (5.1.41) is deduced from (5.1.28) by means of the identity (5.1.32) as follows: ACT))
AD
(i+ xo
_
1r
8
(1+
R
1
R
(1+
l o)d /
`
dn(5.1.42)
2. In other papers (see for example, 11.21) we find the equation:
47r
AD 1 yo
I+ o) d
do - h=(x, y) .
(5.1.43)
It can be obtained from Homentcovschi's equation, imposing the condition f (x, y) = 0 on 8D. (5.1.44)
Usually this condition may be imposed either on the trailing edge or on the leading edge and on the lateral edges. Indeed, imposing the
168
THE LIFTING SURFACE THEORY
condition (5.1.44) both on the leading and trailing edges means that for the plane profile obtained through it section of the wing with a plane parallel to the xOz-plane, one has to determine the jump of the pressure which vanishes at the both edges. But it is well known that the jump of the pressure for the plane profile satisfies the equation (C.1.1) which
has a bounded solution at both edges only if the free term Satisfies the condition (C.1.13). Hence the condition (5.1.44) is valid only after imposing some restrictions for hx(x, y). However, for wings whose trailing (leading) edge is a straight line perpendicular on the Ox-axis, like, for example, the delta wing with the base representing the trailing (leading) edge perpendicular on Ox, or the trapezoidal wing with the big base representing the trailing (leading) edge perpendicular to Ox, the entire integral equation (5.1.41) reduces to the integral equation (5.1.43), because on the perpendicular trailing (leading) edge we have d = 0, and on the lateral edges we may impose the condition (5.1.41). For the rectangular wing the equation (5.1.43) is exact.
5.1.8
The Plane Problem
In order to obtain the solution of the plane problem from the threediniensional solution we assume that the intersection of the wing with each plan parallel to the xO.-; -plane is a profile having the same shape (figure 5.1.1). This means that the equations (5.1.2) have the form z = h(x) ± hl (x) ,
(V)y,
(5.1.45)
and the domain D is the rectangle (- I < x < 1, -b < y < b) with no (half of the chord of the wing wsas taken as the reference length La). From these hypotheses it follows the general representations of the solutions (5.1.8) and (5.1.12), b
fi = fi(b),
f = fW
Taking into account that
J
dy
y
(a2 + ff2y2)3/2
(12 f a'- + / y2
we deduce
lim r b-..oo_b
_ (!)(17)_$(229) R 2:co
169
THE LIFTING SURFACE EQUATION
lin)
b- -oo ./ b
Oy
1
y02
V+
(1 +
Z2 2
=- lim r+b0 (
1,
R
y°
)J cl vi = (5.1.47)
(i+)Jdi=o.
Jl[yo
So, the above mentioned representation becomes
I
+I
nQ
xofi(o)+42 #2Zf
dE
Q r+1 xofg) - zpIWd, w(C z) = 2a JI xO+/32z2
(5.1.48)
and v(x, z) = 0. Taking into account that here Oz has the position of the Oy -axis from the problem considered in 3.1,we find again the formula- (3.1.17).
The integral equation is obtained from (5.1.28). For calculating the integral
)r1 b
b yo
(1 +
Lo dtl, R
we use the definition of the Finite Part and the identity (5.1.32) valid on each of the intervals (-b, y - s), (y + E, b). Thus we obtain I+b 1 b
yo
(1 +°J d
lint f x0 + ,
e-'0 l xoyn
R
+x yRl+b c -
2
(1+
Uf
Ix011
/-bby ( l+
R)drl=-o.
whence
urn
(5.1.49)
The integral equation r educes to (3.1.21).
5.1.9
The Aerodynamic Action in the First Approximation
We indicated in [1.11], p. 79 the way to calculate the action of the fluids against the bodies by applying the transport equations of the momentum and the moment of momentum to the fluid filling the domain
THE LIFTING SURFACE THEORY
170
bounded by the body surface E and the control surface E0 surrounding E. This calculus is absolutely necessary when the body has corners, like in the case of thin bodies. However, in a first approximation the calculations may be done taking into account that the action of the fluid is given by the jump of the total pressure OPi 0 = Pt (x1, yl, -0) - PI (x, yi, +0)
which determines the lift L. On the unit of area the force is pljk (fig. 5.1.4), k representing the versor of the Ozl-axis, and on the entire area of the domain D1, L = Lk, where
L=
f 1 pl I
1dy1 =
f fD POdxdy .
(5.1.50)
Fig. 5.1.4.
For the resulting moment one obtains the formula
M
=
zl x Opt I kdxtdyl = PooUZLo fJ z x QpO kdxdy, (5.1.51)
where according to (5.1.20),
64 = P(x, y, -0) - p(x, y, +0) _ -f (x, b) .
(5.1.52)
171
THE LIFTING SURFACE EQUATION
Denoting by At the area of the domain DI (which is the domain D in dimensional coordinates) we have
Al =
dx1dy1 = LoJ1 dxrdy = LOA.
(5.1.53)
U
IL,
For the lifting coefficient et, one obtains the formula cl
def
L
(1/2)paoU.A1
= - A AD f(x,y)dxdy,
(5.1.54)
and for the moment coefficients (5.1.55)
2 Aao
dot
der
_11f
=
Z
Aao
l,layf(x, J)dxdy,
xf (x, y)dxdy,,
(5.1.56)
where al = a0Lo is the medium chord of the domain D1 on the direction of the unperturbed stream. As we shall see in the sequel, the drag (the projection of the resultant on the direction of the unperturbed stream ) and the gyration moment (the projection of the moment Ozlaxis) have the order of magnitude e2, for this reason they are not present in this calculation. M? is the rolling moment, and Afy, the pitching moment.
5.1.10 A More Accurate Calculation We obtain a more accurate calculation if we have in view that the resultant and the resultant moment are determined by the jump of the tension vector i.e. by the formulas
R = - Jf pt nOdxtdyl , M = - fJ x1i x OplnO&rtdyl ,
(5.1.57)
I
w here n is the outward normal on E. The presence of the normal enables us to take into account the shape of the wing. If the equation of the wing is h(x, y) - z = 0(h = FIT), the normal n is
+h k n=kri1+hr+hy =hri+hyj-k+
ta'' + h2 2
172
THE UFTINC SURFACE THEORY
Neglecting the terms of order O(E3) and taking into account that h is h(x, y) f h1(x, y), it follows
- p'nD = 2pco [h1=i + hlyj + (hxh1 + hyhlu)k] -POOU,2, IpI (h=i + by j - k) + pooU.2, < p > (hi1i + hlyj)
,
where we denoted
< p >= p(x, y, +0) + p(x, y, -0) .
(5.1.58)
Hence the lift is:
R. = -PpoUULo ff .f (y)dxdy + 2p.Lo ff
(h,,hl +
hyhiy)dxdy,
(5.1.59)
and the drag Rr = 2PooL2
IfD h1:dxdy + p UULo Jf f (x, y)h,,dxdy+ D
(5.1.60)
f < p > hudxdy.
+p,oUO2OL0 ifD
For the rolling moment one obtains the formula:
h!= = -P.UULo LID yf (x, y)ddy +2pLy(hh+ (5. 1.61)
for the pitching moment one obtains
= pULx f (x, y)dxdy - 2pLx(hhl,, + hhly)dxdy,
jj
(5.1.62)
and for the gyration moment, AI. = 2pooL03
Jj ( xhl- yhl)dxdy+
+PoU;,Lo JJ f(xhy - yhx)dxdy+ .l D
(5.1.63)
+PooUo,LO f f < p > (xhty - yh1m)dxdy, D
where
=--
xo
h1xR3dEdrl, D
(5.1.64)
THE LIFTING, SURFACE EQUATION
173
as it results from (5.1.19) and (5.1.27). If we keep only the terms of order O(E), it follows: R.- _ -Poo U.2 Lo2
Rr = 2pxL
JJ
JJ D f
(x, y)dxdy,
1i1=(x, y)dxdy, (5.1.65)
(A fr, Afy) = p
A-Y'X)f (x, y)dxdy, D
M, = 2pmLo Jf (xh- yhtr)dxdy. For the lifting surface (hl = 0) the formulas (5.1.55)-(5.1.59) become R.
fD f (x, y)dxdy,
R: = -PU Lo f f f(x,y)h.(x,y)dxdy, D
(5.1.66) (M1. A.fy)
=p
LG
ff(-y, x)f (x, y)dxdy,
A9, = 2pxLo ff (xhy - yhr)dxdy.. D
Rz, Air §i My being O(s), and Rr and Al;, O(E2). 5.1.11
Another Deduction of the Representation of the Gen-. eral Solution
In the sequel we shall deduce again the representation of the solution
(5.1.8), (5.1.12). We start from D. Homentcovschi's idea (exposed in (A.81) to utilize the Fourier transform for bounded domains (A.6]. The method synthesizes the problem of determination of the fundamental solution and the problem of replacing the wing with a forces distribution.
In addition it justifies the assimilation of the wing with a distribution of forces having the form (fl, 0. f ). Indeed, employing the formulas
THE LIFTING SURFACE THEORY
174
(A.8.2) to the system of linearized aerodynamics (2.1.30) and taking into account that D is a surface of discontinuity, we get
0=-ia1A (5.1.67)
0=-iali) - iap- Pk, with the notations [jpj)e,(QI x+a2Y)d x d
y,
(W' P) = JJ D ( where, taking into account (5.1.20), (5.1.25) and (5.1.27), awj = w(x, y, +0) - w(x, y, -0) = 2hi=(x, y) (5.1.68)
W = p(x, y, +0) - p(x, y, -0) = f (X., Y) From (5.1.67) one determines first p and then w. One obtains
ia3P - ia1W
a2-M201
(5.1.69)
ia3W W =ate
+,Q2 a
ia1P
ia2P
+ a ( 2 - M22)
Utilizing the expressions of P and W, we find: 1Q3
p-
J fp(t, r?) a2-A?2aj e(-t4+0tin)9 dv7is l
dd d11,
-2 [1D hit (e, t?) a2 - M2a2
whence, taking into account (A.6.9), P(x, y, z)
fJD'02
,-I
i(o,+ozq)
a2 -
2ai d dy+ (5.1.70)
rrrr +2JJD
hlt
,rl)
az
a2 - M2a2
Employing (A.7.2) we obtain
P(x,y,z) =-4a
+ 27r
f fD rr
JJD
(_)d+ (5.1.71)
hlt (, q) 8x (R1 d dr7
NUMERICAL I`TECRATION OF THE LIFI1NC SURFACE EQUATION
175
where R1 is that from (5.1.7). We obtained in this way the representation (5.1.8). Similarly, utilizing (2.3.11) and (2.3.27), we have:
F`1 fly
_
ial(a2 - M1ai)
(5.1.72) r
0 aJ-110
1)dr
47r
ya+z2 yo
(i+) jai
such that R, having the same expression, it follows:
w(x,y,z)
=-T7r
-
1,! n
Yj)
dFdij-
/32
+ 4T 11
(5.1.73)
(R1) di;d;+
0 [ ?100+Z2 yo
(1+)].d rl,
which is just the representation (5.1.12). We have to notice that from (5.1.70) one deduces the inversion formulas 1
[Y2
at(G2 - h12a21) 1
4z y2
y
1+
X
r.' +
(a" +z-) (5.1.74)
which could be utilized in 2.3.
5.2 5.2.1
Methods for the Numerical Integration of the Lifting Surface Equation The General Theory
There are not yet known exact solutions of the equation (5.1.28). The first numerical solution was given by Multhopp in 1950 15.24]. Previously the same author had given in 1937 the approximate solution (to which one assigned his name), for the lifting line equation (Prandtl's equation (6.1.16)). Multhopp's method relies on the Gauss-type quadrature formulas for non-singular integrals. At that time there were not available quadrature formulas for singular equations. For the singularity appearing in the lifting surface equation, Multhopp utilizes a series expansion
176
THE I..IFTINC SURFACE THEORY
with Chebyshev polynomials of first kind, which is truncated in order to obtain an algebraic system. The method is analogous to Glauert's method for Prandtl's equations, except that the sin functions are replaced by Chebyshev polynomials. In 1958, at a Meeting in Fort Worth, Hsu gave a quadrature formula for integrals with a strong singularity and employed this formula for the singularity from the equation (5.1.28). However, in Hsu's formula the unknowns are present even in the collocation points and this is a drawback. Starting from a formula given by Monegato [A.52), Drago§ gives [6.5] the formula (F.3.5) where there are present supplementary unknowns in the collocation points. One utilizes successfully this formula for solving Prandtl's equation in 6.5 and for solving the lifting surface equation in [5.10] and [5.11]. These solution will be presented in 5.2 and 5.3. In 5.2 we shall sketch the solution of the equation S via the collocation method. We have to solve the equation: I 4rr
N(xo, lyo)dt dr1= -hr(x, y),
i f( Q
(5.2.1)
o
where
N(xo,yo)=1+
To
V2'or+
Y4
(5.2.2)
with the following conditions:
f (t, ±b) = 0,
x-(fb) < < x+(±b)
(5.2.3)
-b < rl < +b. (5.2.4) The first two conditions mean the continuity of the pressure on the f (x+(rl), q) = 0,
lateral edges in case that they are straight segments (if the lateral edges are represented by points the conditions disappear by virtue of (5.1.1)). The condition (5.2.4) ensures the boundedness of the pressure along the trailing edge. One performs the following reasoning: each intersection
of the wing with a plane parallel to xOz determines a thin profile; as it is known from 3.1 for such a profile one imposes the boundedness condition on the trailing edge.
In order to utilize the quadrature formulas we shall perform the change of variables
(x, y) - (u, v)
TI) --4 (a.
defined by the equations x = a(y)u + c(y) Zr = a(ri)a + c(q) (5.2.5) y
by
rl = b13
177
NUMERICAL INTEGRATION OF THE LIFTING SURFACE EQUATION
with
a(y) =
x+(y)
- z-(y) 2
,
c(y) =
x+ (y) + x-(y) 2
(5.2.6)
Writing the equation (5.2.1) as follows:
r
1
T
UFO
+(n)
f
q)N(xo, yo)d
do = -4xhz(x, y)
and taking into account that e(t,g)
= a(F)b,
.9(a, /3)
we deduce
f
a(A)
1
(v - A)2
f (a, /3)N(u, v, a, Q)da] dfl = 9(u, v),
(5.2.7)
where denoting by a(v), c(v), f (a, /3) etc., the functions a(y), c(y), f((, q) in the new variables, we have
a(v)u + c(v) - a(/J)a - c(/3)
N(u, v, a, /3) = 1 +
1/2
{[a(v)u + c(v) - a(Q)a - c(f)J' + k2b2(v - /3)21
(5.2.8) (5.2.9)
g(u, v) = -4rrbhi(u, v),
with the notation k
The Kutta-Joukowski conditions
(5.2.3) become
-1 < a < +1) , f(1,/3)=0, -13<+1).
(5.2.10) (5.2.11)
The solution of the equation (5.2.7) depends on the behaviour that we impose at the extremities of the intervals (±1). For a fixed 0 , one obtains within the wing a thin profile. For such a profile we have imposed
in 3.1 the behavior given by
++ a . Along the span one imposes in
the behaviour 1 --02. Such a behaviour ensures that the conditions (5.2.10) are satisfied. We shall seek for solutions f (a/3) having the shape
f(a,A) = f -l
++aF(a,A),
(5.2.12)
178
THE LIMING SURFACE THEORY
with F bounded. For F one obtain the equation
JT (p1- v a(13) I- t '1 + a
F(Q, 3)N (ti: vj rx $)da1 d8 _
-1
=y(u.v),
(5.2.13)
Utilizing the quadrature formula (F.2. [8), this equation becomes ni
1 ^F
t
2. (1 - a)
2
r)
,
a(;T):"(u.. v,(xi,O)F(ai, 1)d 8 = (5.2.14)
= (tin + 1)g(u.v),
where
`=cos2m= (5.2.15) i= lm. a +1' From now on Nttlithopp's method and the quadrature: formulas method are separating.
Multhopp's Method
5.2.2
Using the formula (F.4.2) for (f3 m
v)-2
,
equation (5.2.14) becomes
p
--4irEE(1+k)(1i=1 k-i
J1
-or)Uk(u) JJJ
- 3 `u(f3)N(a. v,
!
= (2m + 1)g(u,v).
(5.2.16)
One calculates the integral from this equation utilizing (F.2.12). One Obtains
r -.1-r
it
E(l+I)(I
r=1 k-l,t=1 (5.2.17)
=(2m+ 1)(n.+ 1)9(u, V),
-1 < u,v <+1,
NUMERICAL INTEGRATION O THE LIFTING SURFACE EQUATION
with
cosn+l'
7
=r
.
179
(5.2.18)
Introducing the notation
H(ai,f3j) _ (1 - ai)(1 -QJ)a(#j)F(ai,f3j),
(5.2.19)
the system (5.2.17) becomes m rn
p
-4irrG.rL.r
(1
k)Uk(v)Uk(Yj) (u, v,ai,Qj)H(ai,QJ) _
i=1 j=1 k-i
(5.2.20)
=(2m+1)(n+1)g(u,v),
-1
There are m x n unknowns, H(ai, /3j ). In order to obtain the same number of equations in (5.2.20) we shall assign m values to u and n values to v, obviously, all of them in the interval (-1, +1). As we shall see later, the aerodynamic coefficients are functions of H(ai, /3j ). It is sufficient to find out these unknowns. We may write computer programs for solving the system (5.2.20).
5.2.3
The Quadrature Formulas Method
Utilizing in equation (5.2.14) the formula (F.3.5), we obtain the equation
m n
tar E F` [1i=1 j=1
(1 - ai)(1 ()3j - Ak)2 m
-7r(2m + 1)(n + 1)2 E(1 - ai)a(.3k)N(u, Qk, ai, Qk)F(ai, Qk) _ iml
= (2m + 1) (n + 1)g(u,13k) , (5.2.21)
where
Aj=ten+1, for k = T.
(5.2.22)
180
THE LIFTING SURFACE THEORY
In (5.2.21) we have a system of n linear algebraic equations with m x n unknowns F(a1, /3j ). Imposing the system to be verified in m points ul
-
oOS
Vir 2m+1
=al,
t=T,
(5.2.23)
the number of equations equals the number of unknowns. The system will be written as follows
m n
Bik, a=Tm k=I-n(5.2.24)
Aekij Ha 13 i=1
where we denoted Alki;
(2 [1- (-1)j+k]
=t
()3j -)3k)2
-(2m + 1)(n + 1)21
j
-A
}N(atflkoi/3i)
(5.2.25)
Btk = (2m + 1) (n + 1)9(a1,Pk)
5.2.4
The Aerodynamic Action
The lift and moment coefficients are calculated by the aid of formulas (5.1.54)-(5.1.56). Using (5.2.12), (F.2.18) and (F.2.12) we obtain: CL
A
ff
D
Af
+1
=Af
f
+L +1
f(t,
1- fl2a(Q) 1
41r2b
m
[f
1
l f(a,
d/3 =
+1 1
1+
aF(a, l)da] dQ =
(5.2.26)
"
A(2m+ 1)(n+ 1) FF H(a"Pj)' w1 j=1
where H(a;, (3j) are (5.2.19). Formula (5.2.26) is valid for both Multhopp's method and the quadrature formulas method.
NUMERICAL INTEGRATION OF THE LIFTING SURFACE EQUATION
181
In a similar way we obtain: 2
=
IL of 4R
Aao
+I
J_ I
ja(,3)f (a,13)da df3 =
n
in
2b2
f
+I
aoA(2m + 1)(n + 1) E E Qj H(ai,13j) i=1 j=1
,
(5.2.27) cy
Aao 2b - Aao
11
f
r')dCdr' =
+1
+I
J-1 4-Ir
2
ta(,B)a + c(R)I a(A)f (a, Q)da d/.3 =
b
aoA(2m+1)(n+1) ao
m
r( ( it
(5.2.28)
q
ti_1 j=1
representing the length of the medium chord and
di =
CD = - A !ID 41r2 b
A(2n+1)(n+1)
n
(5.2.29)
n
i=1 j=1
For the flat plate of incidence E, we have h(x, y) = -Ex then g(u, v) _ 47rb. For the rectangular flat plate we have x_ = -1, x+ = 1, a = 1,
c=0, u-a
N(uvapl=1+ , , , 5.2.5
(5.2.30)
The Third Method
Some numerical experiments show that it is not always indicated to
impose the behaviour along the direction a under the form We shall use in (5.2.7) the following quadrature formula +1
m f (a, Q)N(u, v, a, /3)da = > f(ai, i9)Ki (u, v, f3) ,
1
i=1
(5.2.31)
182
THE LIFTING SURFACE THEORY
2i
where a; = - m , i = 0, 1'.. . , m are equidistant nodes on the interm val (-1,+1), and K1 (u, v, /3) =
joi-I
N(u, v, a, fl)da =
2
m
1
a(Q) /[a(v)u + c(v) - a(A)a; -- c(/3)1+ k2b2(v
+
- p)2+
(a(v)u + c(v) - a(/3)a{-1 - c(,6)J2 + k2b2(v - /3)2.
(5.2.32)
The behaviour in the span direction remains the same (like in the previous methods), hence:
1--#2F(&,,6),
f (a, A) =
(5.2.33)
where F(a, 3) is finite for rQ = ±1. We shall use the same formula (F.3.5) with respect to p. So, the equation (5.2.7) furnishes the following discretized form of the equation (5.2.7) ,n
n
HtkiiF(a (3:) = bh=(ailk) ,
(5.2.34)
i=I j=1
where
Htk;j _ =
1
4(n + 1)
{i_(_i+k]
2 Ak)2a(13i)Hj(ac,,6k, Qj)
(Qj -
,
k (5.2.35)
and
n +l 1 H10919 =
a(/3k)Ha(at, Qk, /3k) .
(5.2.36)
The algebraic system (5.2.34) has m x n linear equations with m x n where #j =coo 17r unknowns
n+l*
NUMERICAL INTEGRATION OF THE LIFTING SURFACE EQUATION
183
The lift and moment coefficients are calculated by means of formulas CL
_ -
2b
+1
A
11
+1
1-,2a(fl)F(a,A)da dQ =
J_1
1
2bir
(n + 1)A
j
(1-1,)a(13j) J
F(a, $$)da
1
(5.2.37)
1
n
4bnr
(1 in
n+ 1 )rr1A Jul i=1 C,
22 2
1
1+1
#a(13)
J1
=
1- J32F(a, /3)da dfl _ (5.2.38)
nm
4b2ir
E I6ja(0j)(1 - AJ)F(ai, Qi) = (n + 1)mAao, Jul i=1 Aao
f
1111
a(#)[a(A)a + c(Q)]
1- 02fla,,O)da d/3 =
n cm
-4b,r In + 1)mAan Jul iml
EEa(AJ)(1-
_Q1)(2i-'m-1a(pi)+c(fii),F(ai,QP)(5.2.39)
In the paper 15.101, from which we presented this method, there are presented computer programs for the elliptical flat plate h(x, y)
= -cx, x2 + e < 1, b = 2
and for the wing whose projection on the Oxy - plane is an rectangle
-b
h(x,y) = e(1 - x2),
e <
(5.2.40)
THE LIFTING SURFACE THEORY
184
The fluid in considered incompressible. For the rectangular wing one obtains an analytic solutions in the framework of the theory dealing with the wings of low aspect ratio. In this way we have a test solution for the third method. One deduces that this method furnishes very good results.
5.3 5.3.1
Ground Effects in the Lifting Surface Theory The General Solution
The ground effects in the lifting surface theory were taken into consideration in (5.311 and [5.371 where one utilizes asymptotic methods. An approach of this subject in the framework of curvilinear lifting line theory may be found in [1.32], [1.331. The present subsection is elaborated following (5.8], where one gives the general theory. One utilizes the fundamental solutions method. The geometry of the problem is presented in figure 5.3.1. The origin of the reference frame is located in the middle of the span, the Ox-axis
has the direction of the unperturbed stream and the Oy-axis has the span direction. The ground is considered to be the plane 1I having the equation z = -d/2. The unperturbed flow is characterized by the velocity Ui , the pressure p(,,, and the density po and it is considered to be subsonic like in 5.1. The field of velocity v1, the pressure p1 and
Fig. 5.3.1.
the density p1 for the perturbed flow have the form (2.1.3). One utilizes
185
GROUND EFFECTS IN THE LIFTING SURFACE THEORY
dimensionless variables. The equation of the upper and lower surfaces are given by (5.1.2). It results the following boundary conditions w(x, y, ±0) = hr(x, y, ±hiz(x, y)
(5.3.1)
(x, y) E D
(5.3.2)
w(x, y, -d/2) = 0, (V )x, y.
For satisfying the last condition we shall utilize the images method. This means to replace the wing with a forces distribution f + = (fl, 0, f )
defined on D and with a symmetric distribution f - = (fl, 0, -f) defined on the domain D', which is the symmetric of D with respect to the plane II. In order to write the general form of the perturbation fields p and w we have at first to write the form determined by the
concentrated forces f+ in P+(4+) and f- in P_(4-). We have therefore to determine the solution of the equations
M28p/8x + divv = 0 (5.3.3)
8v/8x + grad p = f+b(x - 4+) + f -b(x - 4-) corresponding to the system (2.3.4). The system (5.3.3) is linear and its solution is the sum of the corresponding solutions from (2.3.4). Taking into account (2.3.24) and (2.3.29), and the form of the fields f + and f -, we deduce: p(x, y, z)
=-4
w(x* y, z)
=4
0T (f,
+fa ) `R+l
8z ( R+)
4 f8 x
47r
(fie -fe)
(i)'
R+) +
+47r 5; [(y_+)2+(z_z+)2 (i+xR+ )J+ 2
+4 Oz
f
R_)+4 f8x (R_)y - 17
4ir 8y (y - 17- )2 where
R+=
(x - t:1)2+
(z - C-)2
+
-- (1 +
x R-
2n*)2 +(z - (±)2).
l
)J
' (5.3.4)
(5.3.5)
186
THE LIFTING SURFACE THEORY
The points P+ and P- are symmetric if £+ _ {- = f, tl+ = n- = n, t+ _ C, C- _ C - d. When P+ are in D((= 0), the symmetric points
P-((- _ -d) are in V. Assimilating the wing with a continuous superposition of forces defined on on D, it results the following general solution:
p(x, y, z) _
- 47r JJv [fi,-+f,q)-}
()d_
d-9(5.3.6)
rr
f (e, n) 8 l ((Rid) dkc di J
w(xy, z)
4s
IL
+47r'ID
[f(t,
n)ex
JJDf(t,rl)
4r AD
A2f(t, n)
] (R,'
) de cI +
(L)d+ (i+)}d_ [yo-0
If,V,17)z +
1
+47r
-
02f (f, n)
8J
!0-
Lyo+
dC
(1+ -10-d/J dt
dn,
(5.3.7)
where xo=x-t, yo=y-Hand Rt =
xo+(32(yo+z2), Rld= 90 +p2[yo+(z+d)2J.
(5.3.8)
This is the general representation of the perturbation, the functions f, (t, r)) and f (t, t) being determined from the boundary conditions (5.3.1). The condition (5.3.2) is obviously satisfied.
5.3.2 .
The Integral Equation
Acting like in 5.1, we shall pass to limit considering z -- ±0, (x, y) C-
E D. To the limit, only the integrals related to R are singular. Using the formulas (5.1.16), (5.1.18) and (5.1.24), from (5.3.6) and (5.3.7) we
CROU\l) EFFECTS IN THE LIFTING SURFACE THEORY
187
get
P(x, y, ±0) = 4rID fi(f,t,)Rgdt dry ± 2f (x, y) +
+ 4a JJ f1(, q)
ddi 4j r
R3 dti,
,
(5.3.9)
P(x, y, +0) - P(-T, V, -0) = f (x, y),
and
w(x, y, f0) =
2 f1 (x, y)
47
if
-
47r ,IJD
R (i+)d_
f
ff f (t, t)N(xo,
(Z' Y)
-
d'l
41r
3Nn)dt dr1,
(5.3.10)
where
N
yo) _
(d2-#
) + (d + ;'F d
2
2
(1 + xd° )
I
(5.3.11)
with the notations
R=
xo + $2y$ , Rd =
xo + 02 (y02 + d2) .
(5.3.12)
Imposing the boundary conditions (5.3.1) we deduce
fi (x, y) = -2hi:(x, y)
(5.3.13)
and then
4Rv
f
(YOT
L1+'0 R)
dk drl + 4,r
AD
f (f, rl)N(xo, yo)dC dy =
(5.3.14)
The equation (5.3.14) may be called the generalized lifting surface equation. It was given in [5.8]. The sign "*" is for the Finite Part. Using
188
THE LIFTING SURFACE THEORY
the identity (5.1.32) we may write the equation as follows:
4n 8y
jf f (,'1)
1+
o)
= h' (x, y)
drl
-
4a
If f (t, r!)N(xo Uo)df do =
.JJD hlfR3
1) dt
dtl . (5.3.15)
The Two-Dimensional Problem
5.3.3
Like in 5.1.7, in order to obtain the representation of the solution and
the integral equation for the wing of infinite span we assume that the normal sections in the wing determine profiles having the same shape. It means that the equations (5.1.2) have the form z = h(x) ± hl(x)
(V)y
and the domain D is a rectangle (-1 < x < 1, -b < y < b) with oo. We notice that in the representation of the general solution
b
(5.3.6) and (5.3.7) ff and f have the form f,(£) and f(t). Relying on formulas like (5.1.46), from (5.3.6) we deduce
P(x, z) -
1
21rp 1
)324f (t) dt+ f,2 xoft Wxo ++ $2z2 r+1 xofl (t) +,32(z + d)1 (t)
0 +$2(x2+d)2 which are just (3.2.3)1. Using formulas like (5.1.47), from (5.3.7) it results: w(x,z) __
r11 x01(0+
z2(C)dc _2 J_li xOf +fl
(
+d)2( )41
2a
i.e. just (3.2.3)2.
For obtaining the integral equation we shall use (5.1.45). We also have oo do
J
ydq
2 ,
l
00
The integral
1=
+00
L -0o (y[+
d2 _ yo
xo dn
)2 R1
= 0.
(5.3.18)
189
THE WING OF LOW ASPECT RATIO
reduces to integrals having the shape
Jo
(u2 +
r
du d2) VU-T-+31
Je
du (u2 + d&)Z u +
which may be calculated using the change of variable u -+ v where
u
V
(5.3.17)
VU-27 71
One obtains
I=
2,0
d
1-
xo
xo
arctan
xo dQ
(5.3.18)
Using the same change of variable (5.3.17) one obtains also +O0
xo d
1 (plc
01?
11
9
1
+ ;01
o
xo
x
arctan d
(5.3.19)
such that we finally obtain oo
-l
(5.3.20)
xo + d2 02
Taking into account the previous results, the integral equation (5.4.12) becomes
,r+i 1 Jl
1
xo
_
dt
-
r+i xof ()
27r JJ
1
xo + d2#2
L" /+1
clk
= (5.3.21)
h'(1)
which is just (3.2.7).
In (5.111 one extends the method from 5.2.3 also to the equation (5.3.14).
5.4 The Wing of Low Aspect Ratio 5.4.1
The Integral Equation
In the sequel we shall pay attention to the ratio A = (2b)2/A,
(5.4.1)
190
THE LIFTING SURFACE THEORY
called the aspect ratio. We denoted by 2b the span and by A the area of the domain D. For wings characterized by a small A (wings of low aspect ratio) one develops herein a theory which leads to the integration of the lifting surface equation (5.1.33). For wings characterized by a big A we shall develop in the following chapter the lifting line theory. These
are the two asymptotic theories of the lifting surface equation. If the square of the span is small with respect to the area A, we deduce that on the greatest part of the wing we have yo << xo (see fig. 5.4.1) and we may write R
Ixoi
xo
xo l
L1 + O (
)J ,
(5.4.2)
o
where R is (5.1.17). On the contrary, when the square of the span is big with respect to A (see figure 6.1.1), on the greatest part of the wing we have xo << yo, so that we can make the hypothesis (see 6.1).
Fig. 5.4.1.
R = kayo)
(5.4.3)
Returning to the wings of low aspect ratio, we notice that under the hypothesis (5.4.2) the equation (5.1.33) may be approodmated by 4rr 8y J JD
f (n) (j+LX-01 df drl =1. (z, y)
(5.4.4)
Noticing that the integrand of this equation is different from zero only on t < x, we shall consider only wings whose trailing edge is a straight line perpendicular on Ox like in 5.4.1. Introducing the unknown function F(x, q)
JS-(n)
f(s, q)d,
(5.4.5)
THE WING OF LOW ASPECT RATIO
191
utilized for the first time by Jones 15.171, 15.18), the equation (5.4.4) becomes
8
1
v+(=)
{
dry = h=(x, y) ,
2w 8y Jy_ (x)
(5.4.6)
yo
where y = y+(x) represents the equation of the leading edge OB, and y = y- (r), the equation of the leading edge OA. From (5.4.5) and from the figure one notices that F(x, y- (x)) = F(x, y+ (x)) = 0.
(5.4.7)
In (5.4.6), utilizing the definition of the principal value, we derive taking into account (5.4.7) and then we integrate by parts. It follows a
F(x, n)
ay
_f dq -
e F'
1
yo! d
_ 'v+ SF do
- Jy-
an
'
(5.4.8)
where, from now on,
y- = y-(x), y+ = y+(x) In this way equation (5.4.6) becomes + OF dr)
1
Jv-
8q
- h. (x, y)
(5.4.9)
This equation can be also obtained starting from Homenteovsch's equation (5.1.41) which, in case that one imposes the condition (5.1.44) on the leading edge, becomes equation (5.1.43). Then we can see that from (5.4.5) it follows
8F_
8f
(5.4.10)
The equation (5.4.8) is a thin profiles-type equation (C.1.1) and it has one of the solutions (C.1.9), (C.1.10), (C.1.11) or (C.1.14). The solution of the equation (5.4.8) must satisfy the condition
J
+OFdq=0 y_ a!
(5.4.11)
arising from (5.4.7). The only solution satisfying this solution is (C.1.11)
with C = 0. Hence, 8F(x,TI)
-2
1
(t-y-)(y+-t)h=(x,t)dt. t-77 (5.4.12)
192
THE LIFTING SURFACE THEORY
Integrating this solution on the interval (y_, y) and taking into account (5.4.7) and (B.6.11), we get F(x, y)
_
'
dq
2ly
(n-y-)(y+-q)
-
+
(t - V -)(y+ -' t)
t
y-
(x, t)dt .
-q
(5.4.13)
As from (5.4.5) it results f (x, y) = F, (x, y), we deduce f (x, y) =
=2
8
8x
ydq
ru+
(t -
(qy-)(y+-q) y-
ly-
t)
t-q
(x, t)dt . (5.4.14)
Employing (B.6.11) ones easily check that this solution satisfies the vanishing condition on the leading edge
f(x,y-)=f(x,y+)=0. 5.4.2
(5.4.15)
The Case h = h(x)
In case that
h does not depend on the variable
y, taking into
account (B.5.6) and performing the change of variable q = y_ cos20 + y+ sin20, we get
: Jv-
0 < 0 < 7r/2,
(5.4.16)
' V+
dt7
At - Y-) (y+ - t)dt = t-q n - y-)(y+ - q) Iv_7r
Y+-Y- r 2
-a J
y+
v-
dq
On - y-)(y+ - r!) ydq=sV(y-y-)(y+- y)
Hence,
f(x, y) = 2
[h'/i_
y)]
.
(5.4.17)
193
THE WINO OF LOW ASPECT RATdO
Utilizing (5.1.54)-(5.1.56) and Green's formula we deduce: CL
- A If
19
[W(x)Vv - v-}(v+ - Y1
f (y-a (b-y)dy=-2Ah'(1)(b-a)2,
A
-S
= - A ,,D ybx
= - Ah'(1)1
cv
A
v=
Y
[h!(x)-,/(y -
v-)(v+ - v)] dxdy =
(v - a)(b - y)dy = -
bWrh'(l)(b
- a)z,
I/I; [zWv'?j- v-)(v+ - v)1 dx dy_ A
If h'(x) vir(v -y-)(Yu)dxdy = -
_ -CL -
1
0
[v+(z) - y_(x)12 h'(x)dx, (5.4.18)
the reference chord ao bung 1. For example, fnr the rectangular flat plate of incidence -e with the span 2b one obtains CL = wk,
c, = -
c= = 0,
!
,
(5.4.19)
and for the triangular flat plate of incidence -£, we have,
CL=xe(b - a), because y+ = bx,
c, = (b2 - a')
r
,
cy = - 3 xc(b - a),
(5.4.20)
y- sax.
5.4.3 The General Case We shall write (5.4.14) as follows
f(x, y) =
2b x8s
r_
(t - -y-)(y+ - t)h.(x, t)I(y, t)dt,
(5.4.21)
THE LIFTING SURFACE THEORY
194
where
Y
d-q
I(y,t) =
(5.4.22)
(r1-y-)(y+-rl) t - n with y- < y < y+, y- < t < y+. This integral may be calculated l
fv-
explicitly.
For y < t the integral is not singular.
For
t < y the
integral is singular but noticing that we have 1(y+, t) = 0 (it results from (B.5.8)) we get IY+ 1
I(y,t)
d'l
y+-rl) t-17
(5.4.23)
which also is not a singular integral. Since
A
(n-a)(b-n) t-11 (5.4.24)
(t-a)(b-rt)+ (b-t)(q -a)
1
in
(t - a(b-it)- -v(((r1-a)
(t - a)(b - t)
we deduce the fundamental formula
f(x,y) = =
2 8 f+h
(t-y-)(y+-y)+ (y+-t)(y-y-) dt.
(x,t)
a 8x v-
(5.4.25)
For determining the lift and moment coefficients we have to calculate the integral
(t
V+
G(a, t) =
- y-)(y+ - y) +
(y+ - t)(y - y-) dy.
J(t-y-)(y+-y)- V(-y+---4(y -y-)
(5.4.26)
Performing the changes of variables
t=y++y-+y+-y-moo, y=y++y-+y+-y-cos9, 2
2
2
2
(5.4.27)
we deduce
Gxt
- y+ 2 y- fo X in
sm2 sm
B+a 2
sin 8 d9,
(5.4.28)
195
THE WINC OF LOW ASPECT RATIO
the integral having an integrable singularity for 8 = a. The integrand from (5.4.28) is the kernel from the equation (6.2.15). Using for 0 91 a the expansion (6.2.17), we get: G(x, t) = w y+
y- sin o =
2
(y+
- t)(t - y-) .
(5.4.29)
It follows
(t - a(b-y)+ (b-t)(y-a)
fb
G(I, t)
=J
In
Ja
IWa)(b-y)-'(b-t)(y-a)
(5.4.30)
=x (b - t(t-a). Similarly one deduces b
(t - a) (b - y) +
JQ y
(b - t) (y - a)
dy=
IV'(t-a)(b-y)-i(b-t)(y-a)
(5.4.31)
=att+b2a) (b-t)(t-a). Utilizing Green's formula and the expression (5.4.25) for f (z, y) taking into account (5.4.30), (5.4.31), we get:
A
CL
-
-4
,
lb 41
h`(1, t)G(1, t)d t = rb
a
_
b
cs = - AJa t (b - t)(t - a)h=(1, t)d t + !-+-b ct, Cy = -CL -
r1
4
rA
Ju
4
r2
- -CL - A
dx
y+
y_
h.(x, t)G(x, t)d t =
ry+
dT o
f
(5.4.32)
hs(z, t)
(Y+ - Wt - y-)d t .
When h(x, t) does not depend on t we find again the formulas (5.4.18).
196
THE LIFTING SURFACE THEORY
This problem, for wings symmetric with respect to the Ox-axis, was studied in [5.171. It was also included in [1.1], [1.2]. The general problem for the arbitrary wing as it was presented herein, was solved in 15.91.
Chapter 6 The Lifting Line Theory
6.1 6.1.1
Prandtl's Theory The Lifting Line Hypotheses. The Velocity Field
Prandtl's theory is the first mathematical model for the three - dimensional wing (the finite span airfoil). It was elaborated in 1918 16.211 and it remained until the years '40 the only theory for this wing. The german
scientist, gifted with an extraordinary engineering intuition, guessed very well the simplifications which may be performed. Prandtl's method consists in replacing the wing with a distribution of vortices on its plane
- form (the domain D from 5.1). Since the experience indicates that downstream the wing the flow is not potential, Prandtl introduced a vortical distribution defined on S, the trace of the plane-form D in the uniform stream (figure 6.1.1), the velocity field in the fluid being determined by the two distributions. The vortices on D are called tied vortices and the vortices on S are called fee vortices. This idea continued to dominate the aerodynamics, the models concerning the subsonic, supersonic and transonic, steady or oscillatory flows, elaborated in the years '50, '60, being conceived on the basis of this method. In 1975 D. Homentcovschi, utilizing the theory of distributions proved that the hypothesis of the existence of free vortices is not necessary because it follows from equations. L. Dragon [5.71 obtained
the same result utilizing the method of the fundamental solutions. In this subsection, we deduce the lifting line theory from the lifting surface theory, as we proceeded in [5.7], utilizing the following three hypotheses (the hypotheses of Prandtl's theory): 10 One neglects the thickness of the wing, therefore in (5.1.2) one considers hl = 0. From (5.1.27) it results fl = 0, such that the representations (5.1.8), (5.1.11) and (5.1.12) give
P(x,y,z) = -4 7r-
IL f(CTT)1 (-) dcdi 19Z
(6.1.1)
THE LIFTING LINE THEORY
198
u(x,y,z) _ -p(x,y,z) v(x,y,z)
_-
+
jo
z2(1+Rl)]dfdi7
(6.1.3)
)Io
qJ
w(x, y, z)
(6.1.2)
fD f (C, 17)
8x 1)dt d t7+
JJD0Y
(6.1.4) -+ z2
(1 + 11 )]d t d n;
2° One considers that the unknown is the circulation C. along the contour c, resulting from the intersection of the wing with an arbitrary
plane n parallel to the xOz plane at the distance y(-b < y < b) (fig. 6.1.1). This will be, obviously, a function of y
Fig. 6.1.1.
Pudx,
C(y)=
because on this contour d y = 0 and wdz = O(E2) (it results from (2.1.17) and (2.1.21) ). Taking into account (6.1.2) and (5.1.20), we obtain
r C(y) =
Jx
u(x, y, -0)d x + / + u(x, y, +0)d x x
We have also
f X
f(x,
y)d x .
(u)
(6. 1 .5)
x+ (y)
C(n) = -
x_ (y)
f (f, n)d t.
(6.1.6)
PRANDTL'S THEORY
199
From (5.1.1) or (5.1.30) it results
C(±b) = 0;
(6.1.7)
30 The domain D, i.e. the projection of the wing on the xOy plane, is replaced by the segment [-b, +bJ (fig. 6.7.1); for this reason we call this theory the lifting line theory. when For studying the behaviour of the integrals (6.1.1)-(6.1.4) x_(n) -+ 0 .- x+(il), we notice that in the vicinity of this segment, for a given n , the function f (e, n) keeps a constant sign, such that we may apply the mean formula. For a function h(z, y, z, n), continuous in f, when x- (q) -+ 04-- x+(n), we have therefore f ( n)k(x, y, z,
limJ1
r+b
hm
ti)d d r! _
r+(n)
J-b [ Js_ty)
-lim
,
f (t, n)k(x, y, z, t, r1)d
d r! +b
-b
k(x, y, z, (', n)C(n)d n = - fb k(-T, y, z, 0, n)C(n)d n , (6.1.8)
where £ E (x_(rl), x+(n)). Applying this formula in (6.1.1)-(6.1.4) and taking into account (6.1.7), we obtain
2
P (x,
y, z) = -
4 rb C(n)
d n = -u(x, y, z) ,
f+b
v(x, y, z) = 4
.! b
_- a 4n
w(x,y,z) =-Q2 41r
ly2+z2
J b C('l)
f
1
)]dii
C(17)ay [ o + z2 (1 +
= rT
o
(6.1.9)
C'(n)yo+z2 ( 1 + C(n)
rb
-4 J b
Ro
}n, d
drl-
b
0,07) y02
YO
Z2
(1 + X
d
200
THE LIFTING LINE THEORY
where we denoted RD =
x2 +#(y2 + z2)
(6.1.10);
Fbr Q = 1 we obtain Prandtl's representation ((1.21], p. 708).
6.1.2 Prandtl's Equation In the sequel we shall deduce the equation for C(y). This will obviously result from the lifting surface equation by virtue of the above hypotheses. We shall employ the equation (5.1.33). Taking (6.1.6) and (D.3.6) into account it results
8
f( , n) d
8y JD y-n 1
fd n= dy -d- f' +b
C(q)
-b n-y
-
d
rJ
C(q) d n.
O
-b (n - y)2
Utilizing (D.3.7) and (6.1.7), we also deduce:
.
&
c(_)
= l1+b C'(n)
J
b
'n-yd
(6.1.12)
In the second term from (5.1.33) we take into account that when
x_(n) - 0 4- z+(n), on the greatest part of the domain D, we have so << 14, before E which intervenes in the definition of the principal value of the integral with respect to n becomes zero, i.e. before yo becomes zero. In the principal value we shall perform therefore the approximation R = fl I. An exact evaluation of this approximation is, made by D. Homentoovschi in [6.9) as follows
jjf(r)
ryxTo +
dd
XDYO
Taking into account that sign yo = 2H(yo) -1,
H'(yo) = 6(y - q),
H representing Heaviside's function and 6 Dirac's distribution we
201
PRANDTL'S THEORY
have: Z_
JJ
20
f (f, n) xovo +b
I J-b
JJ
d {d ~ Q f (txon) t
LJ
d C,
f (on) s yod fd n =
' f=+ (v) f (t'17) _ d
5(y - n)d n= 2Q
xo
(y)
(6.1.13)
Hence the equation (5.1.33) becomes: 1
+(v)
,rte C'(n) d n +
sr f b n - y
f (c Y) d
'r s_(v)
xo
= 2h' (a, y)
(6.1.14)
x]-1/2
(6.1.15)
Multiplying this equation by [x - x-(y)]11.2[x+(y)
-
and integrating it with respect to x on the interval obtain from the first formula (B.5.4): AC(y) =
(x-
a(2) 'f+b C'(n)dn+1(y),
J bn-y
(y), x+(y)), we
(6.1.16)
where we denoted
a(y) =
J(y) _ -2
W
x+ (y) - x- (y)
(6.1.17)
2
IT
x(6.1.18)
a(y) representing a half of the chord of the profile at the distance y. The equation (6.1.16) is the well known Prandtt's equation (the lifting line equation). This equation, together with the conditions (6.1.7), has to determine the unknown C(y). It is an integro-diferential singular equation, with a Cauchy-type singularity. Utilizing (6.1.12), the equation
for C(y) may be written QC(y) =
a 2y)
t +b
r
b
(n
+ (ny)2 d n
9(y) .
(6.1.19)
In this form, the equation is not integro-differential any longer, it is only integral, but with a stronger singularity. The mark "s" is for the Finite Part. As we have already shown in [6.5] [6.6), this form is more adequate for the numerical integrations (see also 6.4.2, 6.4.3).
202
THE LIFTING LINE THEORY
z
A
Fig. 6.1.2.
The significance of the function j (6.1.18) is given in [1.2J. In the case of the flat plates having the angle of attack c (fig. 6.1.2) we have
hx = -e whence (6.1.20)
j(y) = 2irea(y).
6.1.3
The Aerodynamic Action
Taking into account (6.1.6), from (5.1.54) and (5.1.56) we deduce 2 CL
2
+b
C(y)d y, c
+b
Aao 1-b
yC(b)d y, cv = 0.
(6.1.21)
The expression of c, is natural because for the wing reduced to the segment [-b, +b] the fluid cannot create a moment which should rotate this axis. By virtue of the first hypothesis (h1 = 0), in the framework of the lifting surface theory, the quantities Rs and M, which have the
order of magnitude 0(e2) are reduced to those given in (5.1.56) and (5.1.59). Utilizing (6.1.6) and (6.1.7), we obtain:
R. = -p.U.Lo
C(y)h=(0, y)d y, b
(6.1.22)
+b
M: = P,,. U,2,. L. f
yC(y)hi(0, y)d y b
But, from the boundary condition
w(x,y,0) = h,(x,y)
6.1.23)
and from (6.1.9) it results h=(0, y) = w(0, y, 0) _ -
1
lim (
41r c-.o \
f
V-s b
+
b y+c
)
C'M d Yo
rl ,
203
PRANDTL'S THEORY
because, with the change of variable n - y = u, we have y+E
Eiti y-E
C(rl)' 11o
+-Z 2 d r! _ -C'(y) lim E-0
f
+6
z = 0.
1 y+bCl(I1)d b
tl
y
rJ ,
( 6.1.24)
we deduce 2 CU
f
A J-b
C(y)w(y)d y, (6.1.25)
2
MS cZ
A
(1/2)Poo
`k
2 Alai
Aa_
Jb yC(y)w(y)d y,
representing the area of the domain D and ao, the length of
the dimensionless medium chord along the direction of the unperturbed stream. In fact, for w we may also utilize the expression
w(y) = QC(y) - ?(y)
(6.1.26)
2wa(y)
which results from (6.1.18) and (6.1.26).
6.1.4
The Elliptical Flat Plate
Until the appearance of the papers of Magnaradze [6.16] and Vekua [6.28] in the years 1942, 1945 it was available only one exact solution of Prandtl's equation corresponding to the elliptical flat plate wing. Usu-
ally this solution is obtained as an answer to the following minimum problem: "To determine among the wings having the same lift, the wing corresponding to the minimum drag" (see, for example, (1.201). Sometimes one utilizes Glauert's approximate method (see 6.2.4). In the sequel we shall present a simple method which does not need any special considerations on Prandtl's equation. Let us consider a flat plate with the angle of attack E, whose projection on the x10y1 plane is an ellipse having the semi-axes Lo and bLo (figure 6.1.3). In dimensionless coordinates, the equation of the ellipse is x2+ +y2/b2 = 1. For the edges and the chord it results y2
xf = f
1 -
2 52
,
a(y) =
1 -
2'
(6.1.27)
204
THE LIFTING LINE THEORY
YI
bLo
L=am
Fig. 6.1.3.
For a flat plate j(y) has the form (6.1.20) hence it is proportional to a(y). From Prandtl's equation it results that C(y) is also proportional to a(y). We shall look therefore for solutions having the form:
C(y) = k 1-
a Eb2
,
(6.1.28)
k being a constant which will be determined by imposing (6.1.23) to verify (6.1.27). Using the change of variables q = boos 0, y = b cos o, and Glauert's formulas (B.6.6), it results: di7
11-y such that
k
(2TE
A + 7r/2b)
_ir,
(6.1.29)
(6.1.30
Since the area of the ellipse is w b, from the formulas (6.1.23) and (6.1.27) we obtain s cL = k, CD = , cj = cs = 0. (6.1.31) 46
Obviously, cD = 0(0). For b - oo one obtains the infinite span flat plate. From (6.1.23) and (6.1.27) it results: CL =
21r8
(6.1.32)
205
THE INTEGRATION OF PRANDTL'S EQUATION
6.2 The Theory of Integration of Prandtl's Equation. The
Reduction to Fredholm-Type Integral Equations 6.2.1
The Equation of Trefftz and Schmidt
The general method of solving the integro-differential equations con-
sists in reducing them to Fredholm-type integral equations. As it is well known, for the last ones a general theory is available (existence and
uniqueness theorems, exact and approximate methods for solving the equation). The first investigation of Prandtl's equation was performed by Trefftz in 1921. He reduced the problem of solving Prandtl's equation to the problem of determination of a harmonic function in the superior half-plane with mixed conditions on the boundary. We shall prove in the sequel that such a problem may be reduced to a Fredholm-type equation. To this aim we shall consider the harmonic function U(y, z) in the superior half-plane z > 0 from the yOz plane, with mixed boundary conditions in the Z = y + iz complex plane (fig. 6.2.1). We shall also consider the complex function
F(Z) = U(y, z) + iV(y, z) =
1
2m
: ZdR. Jb+1 COO
(6.2.1)
z (Z)
-b
+b
y
Fig. 6.2.1.
Obviously this is an holomorphic function in the (Z) plane with the cut (-b, +b) and it vanishes to infinity. U(y, z) is therefore a harmonic function in the half-plane z > 0. It results obviously
U(y, +0) = 0, y E (-oo, -b) U (b, oo).
(6.2.2)
The limit values on the segment (-b, +b) are obtained by means of Plemelj's formulas. We deduce
2U(y, +0) = C(y), y E (-b, +b).
(6.2.3).
206
THE LIFTINC LINE THEORY
Taking the conditions (6.1.7) into account, we get d
-dn= f
C(t1)
ZJ
bbtj
b
=-f C(rl)'3;
rl
b
C(rl)aZ
Z)dr)_ Cn
1 Z) d+l -
f
b 71- Zdrl
Deriving we deduce from (6.2.1):
F'(Z) =
I-i
8 = 2m J-b W(Zd q
(6.2.4)
and with Plemelj's formulas ' +b
az (y, +0) = d (y, +0) = 2a f
d,
(6.2.5)
n representing the inward pointing normal of the superior half-plane on
the segment (-b, +b) of the real axis. Taking (6.2.3) and (6.2.5) into account, Prandtl's equation is transformed into the following condition on the segment (-b, +b): dU
21U(y, +o) A(y)
- J(y),
(6.2.6)
A(y) = ra(y), A(y)J(y) =1(y) ,
(6.2.7)
in
(y, +0) =
where, from now on, we denote
So, Prandtl's equation was replaced by the following mixed boundary value problem: "to determine the harmonic function U(y, z) in the z > 0 half-plane, vanishing at infinity and satisfying the boundary conditions (6.2.2) and (6.2.6)". Then, the function C(y) will result from (6.2.3). The mixed problem is reduced to a Fredholm-type integral equation. Proceeding like in [1.211, p. 713, we notice that because of the condition (6.2.2), the function F(Z) may be extended by symmetry in the lower half-plane z < 0. In this way, on the lower margin of the cut (-b, +b1 we shall have the condition dU
d n (y, -0) =
2QU(y, -0) + Ay), A(y)
(6.2.8)
So, we reduced the above mixed problem to the problem of determination of the harmonic function U(y, z), in the yOz plane, with the cut
THE INTEGRATION OF PRANDTL'S EQUATION
207
[-b, +b) and the conditions (6.2.6) and (6.2.8) on the two margins of
the cut. It is known (see for example, 11.111 [1.201 [1.31J) that the Joukovsky-
type conformal mapping Z - W: Z = I
(W + W
(6.2.9)
maps the exterior of the cut [-b, +b] from the (Z) plane onto the exterior of the circle of radius b and the center in origin from the (W) plane (fig. 6.2.2), the superior margin of the cut being mapped on the
superior half-circle from the superior half-plane. The points fb are double and singular. One obtains the correspondence of the boundaries
putting W = be''. We have
y=boost, a=0.
(6.2.10)
Fig. 6.2.2.
For 0 < a < r, (6.2.10) gives the correspondence between the halfcircle r+ and the superior margin of the cut, and for -W < a < 0, the correspondence between r- and the inferior margin (fig. 6.2.2). Since from the extension by symmetry it results U(y, +0) = -U(y, -0), we deduce that U(a) is an odd function on F. With the same application (6.2.10), the functions A(y) and j(y) become even functions. We denote them by A(a) , respectively j(o). Now we shall see how the boundary conditions (6.2.6) and (6.2.8) are transformed. To this aim we remind to the reader that, after performing a conformal mapping,
208
THE LIFTING LINE THEORY
the ratio of the lengths is given by the modulus of the derivative. More
precisely, let W = f (Z) be a conformal mapping and let M(Z) and N(Z+AZ) be two neighboring points and M1(W) and N1(W+AW) their images. Obviously we have AMN' lim I
1
= lim I1Z 1 = lim
I
AZ = If'(Z)1
Hence, returning to our problem and denoting by N the outward normal to 1', we shall have
dU_dU dN_dUIdW do
dN (a) do
TN- d
Taking (6.2.10) into account, the boundary conditions (6.2.6) and
(6.2.8) on the two half - circles r+ and r_ give dU (a) = 2/3I sin a)
dN
A(a)
U(a) - J(a) sin a
(6.2.12)
Denoting W = it + i v, the harmonic function U(y, z) in the yOz plane becomes the harmonic function U(u, v) in the exterior of the circle r. This one vanishes at infinity and has the normal derivative (6.2.12) known on 1'. It is a Neumann problem. Its solution is given by Dini's formula (see for example (1.20] p. 31). We obtain
U(u,v)=n J_" U(a)Inlbei°-Wlda+ko dN
(6.2.13)
being an unknown constant. Considering that W tends to a point be' ° from C, one obtains U(s) =
b
r+ir J JJJ
aN (o )1n I2 sin s
2 a I da + kO .
(6.2.14)
:
Since U(a) is an odd function it results dN (a)
dN
(-a) ,
and integrating only on the interval (0, 7r), we deduce U(s)
b f0" ddN (a)S(s, a)d a,
7r
(6.2.15)
THE IN'I'ECRATION OF PRANDTL'S EQUATION
209
where we denoted S(s, o) = In
(6.2.16) am
2
We have (see, for example, 11.16]): 00
S(s, o) _ -2 F sin ks sin ko km1
(6.2.17)
k
the series being absolutely and uniformly convergent (s 0 o). In (6.2.15) we did not encounter ke, because we have U(s) _
_ -U(-s) whence U(0) = 0. Taking into account the relation (6.2.12) in which 2U(o) is replaced by C(a) according to the condition (6.2.3), one obtains the following Fredholin-type integral equation C(S) = A J
C(°)
si) S(s, a)d or + Jo(a)
,
(6.2.18)
where A=
2bQ
z
Jo(s)
,
2b
x
J(o)S(s, o') sin o d o .
(6.2.19)
To
Hence we reduced Prandtl's integro-differential equation to the Fredhoimtype equation (6.2.18). The kernel of this equation has an integrable singularity. Equivalent integral equations have been given by Betz and Gebelein in 1936 and Trefftz in 1938.
6.2.2
Existence and Uniqueness Theorems
For proving the existence and uniqueness of the solution of Prandtl's equation , we shall use the first theorem of Fredholm. This may be enunciated as follows: the equation b i
P(s) = A
K(s,)p(o)ds + f(s),
(6.2.20)
fa has an unique solution for a given value of A and for every fee term f if and only if the corresponding homogeneous equation admits only the trivial solution V(s) = 0. Hence, we must show that the equation
210
THE LIFTING LINE THEORY
(6.2.18) which is homogeneous (Jo = 0) has only the trivial solution. But the homogeneous equation corresponds to the boundary problem (6.2.12) which is homogeneous (J = 0). Applying Green's formula
/ JD
U)2du dv = -JOD Ud S,
(6.2.21)
where D is an annulus, exterior to the circle r, bounded by an concentric circle of radius R > b and observing that for R -- oo the last term vanishes (see, for example, §6.1 from
1 fx A
we deduce
UdNda < 0.
Utilizing the homogeneous condition (6.2.12), we obtain: W IAsin
0.
(6.2.22)
This inequality implies U = 0, because, as it results from the definition (6.1.17), we have A > 0. Hence, Prandtl's equation has an unique solution. This result is very important, because, as we have already seen in 6.1.4 and as we shall see in the sequel, we manage, on various ways, to determine a solution of this equations. The above result ensures that if we find a solution, this is the unique solution of the equation.
6.2.3
Foundation of Glauert's Method
The integral equation (6.2.20) is a Fredholm-type equation of the second kind. This equation has a symmetric kernel if
K(s, a) = K(a, a).
(6.2.23)
The equation (6.2.18) has not a symmetric kernel, but it can be symmetrized. Indeed, multiplying the equation with
(on the inte-
A) gration interval the quantity under the radical is positive) and, taking the function as an unknown c(8) =
sins C(s) A(s)
(6.2.24)
211
THE INTEGRATION OF PRANDTL'S EQUATION
one obtains the following equation:
c(s) _ -2a
Ja
c(a)
VsTn,; i "in a A
00
sink sin ka
a ()k_i
d a + F;i(S) A(s) (6.2.25)
00
K=-2E k i1
sin s smo sin ressin rca k A(s) A(a)
is obviously symmetric. The kernel is even degenerate, but not of finite rank. As it is known (see, for example, [1.22], vol.3, p.193), the integral equations with degenerate kernel may be reduced to infinite algebraic systems and the equations with degenerate kernel of finite rank may be reduced to linear algebraic systems with a finite number of equations. We are not in this situation, and according to (6.2.25)we shall take only the property of symmetry of the kernel into account. According to the theory of Hilbert and Schmidt (see, for example, (1.22] v. 3, p. 243) the solution of the integral equation may be expanded, with respect to the eigenfunctions of the kernel, into absolutely and uniformly convergent series. Hence the solution of the equation (6.2.25) has the form: 00
C(a) =
A(a E At, sin ka. )k-1
Taking (6.2.24) into account, it results: 00
C(a) _ E Ak sin ka.
(6.2.26)
k=1
The (constant) coefficients Ak will be determined replacing (6.2.26) in the equation (6.2.18), or easier, performing this replacement in Prandtl' equation (6.1.18), which, with the change of variables y = b cos s,
(6.2.27)
1 ) = b cos a
and with the notation C(s) for the function C(y) composed with (6.2.27)1 etc., becomes 2b/3C(s + a(s)
C'(a)d a=
casa-cuss
2itbaOff( s s
)
(
6.2.28 )
Before discussing about how to determine the coefficients A, from (6.2.26) and (6.2.27), we must notice that the form (6.2.26) of the so-
lution C(a) may result directly from (6.2.18), without utilizing the
212
THE LIFTING LINE THEORY
theory of Hilbert and Schmidt. Indeed, taking (6.2.17) into account, the equation (6.2.18) becomes: _'inks
C(s) = -2a
fo"
k=1
A(( )) in k sin a d a+
V +4rb
sin ks
Air)
sin ko sin od a .
I0 The integrals are constants and the solution will have the form (6.2.26).
6.2.4
Glauert'e Approximation
We shall return now to the problem of determination of the coefficients Ai from (6.2.26). Replacing C from (6.2.26) in (6.2.28) and using Glauert's formula (B.6.6) (herein is the origin of this formula), we deduce: E Ak[2bfl sins + k7ra(s)) sin ks = 21rba(s) j (s) sins .
(6.2.29)
k=1
Glauert's approximation consists in keeping the first n terms from the expansion (6.2.26) and then imposing (6.2.29) to be satisfied for n distinct values of the variable s. The coefficients Ak are the solution of an linear algebraic system, but we cannot evaluate the error of the approximation. Many other approximations have been given in the literature (see Lotz in [1.24), Carafoli in [1.5)).
6.2.5
The Minimal Drag Airfoil
The foundation of Glauert's method,which consists in establishing the formula (6.2.26) gives the possibility to give an answer to the following problem of practical interest: to determine among the wings with the same lift, that one which has the minimum drag. In view of this determination we shall calculate, utilizing the formulas (6.1.21), (6.1.25) and (6.2.26), the lift and drag coefficients cL and CD. For determining the lift and the drag, we multiply these coefficients by the same factor 1 2 p00UUA1. Since
2! sin ka sin lad v = irdkl ,
k,1=1,2,...
213
THE INTEGRATION OF PRANDTL'S EQUATION
we deduce +b
f Jb
ct, = A
C(y)d y = A f C(a) sin ado, = JO
'At v.
(6.2.30)
Utilizing Glauert's formula (B.6.6), we obtain:
()
C'(s)s a
1
1
4ab To Cos a - oos or
such that: CD
/
2
C(V)w(y)d, y = -
b
A °°
1
2A
1 (ksmka) ksI
f
4b
sin ka kAi sin a
w(a)C(a) sin ad a =
o0
Alsinio do =
(6.2.31)
!:1
oc
kAj. k=t
The formulas (6.2.30) and (6.2.31) indicate that among all the wings with the same lift (with the same A1), the minimum drag corresponds
to the wings for which A2 = A3 = ... = 0. The solution of Prandtl's equation for these wings is
C(o) =A1sin or =C(y)=At V, where Al = C(O) may be determined obviously from the equation (6.1.26). We have _C(_)
A(N)
5
= 2w(y) + J(y) _ - 1 At + J(y).
(6.2.33)
In the case of the flat plate, j has the form (6.1.20). It results J = 2e whence we deduce that the member from the left hand side of (6.2.33) is constant. Hence,
a(y) = ao 1 -
,
(6.2.34)
the constant ao being determined by the relation
0
+
2b) Al = 2E,
(6.2.35)
214
THE LIFTING LINE THEORY
if one gives Al. The same relation determines Al if one gives ao.
For example, when Al = k like in (6.1.28), it results ao = 1, like in (6.1.27) and vice versa. The expression (6.2.33) shows that the wings which have the above property are the elliptical flat plates.
6.3
The Symmetrical Wing. Vekua's Equation. A Larger Class of Exact Solutions
6.3.1
Symmetry Properties
Very often in aerodynamics we encounter the case when the wing is symmetric with respect to the xOz plane. In this situation we have
x*(y) = xt (-y) ,
-b < y S +b
h(x, y) = h(x, -y) ,
(6.3.1)
From (6.1.19) and (6.1.20) it results
a(y) = a(-y),
j(y) = j(-y).
(6.3.2)
Let us prove that we also have
C(y) = C(-y) .
(6.3.3)
Indeed, changing in Prandtl's equation (6.1.18) y by -y and taking (6.3.2) into account, it results
AC(-y) =
a2 y)
1c (q) d q +.7(y) . Cc(q)
n
(6.3.4)
y
Putting in the integral n = -u and observing that
C(q)d17 = dC = C'(u)du, we deduce r -16 C'(rl)d
f b 1+31
_
'/'_b
C(u)du =,+b Cl(,i)d+l
J.fb -u+y
b
7I-y
(6.3.5)
Introducing this relation in (6.3.4) and comparing with (6.1.18), we get (6.3.3).
THE SYMMETIUC'AL WING. VEKt'A'S EQUATION
215
The Integral Equation
6.3.2
We shall present in the sequel the simplest method for obtaining the equation (6.2.18). The demonstration is inspired from [A.27), where, on his turn, it was taken from Magnaradze (6.16] and Vekua (6.28). With the notations (6.2.7) Prandtl's equation is I 'r+b
C"(n) d
27r ,!-b rl - y
n = 0C(y) - J(y) .
(6.3.6)
A(y)
For the existence of the principal value we have to assume that C'(y) satisfies Holder's condition on the segment (-b, +b). We shall invert this equation assuming that the right hand member is known. As it is known from (C.1.1) the solution C'(y) depends on the behaviour imposed in the points ±b. We know that we cannot obtain a bounded solution in the two points without imposing a restriction to the right hand member. In the same time, because of the symmetry of the wing,
we cannot consider C bounded only in an extremity. Hence C' is unbounded in the two extremities, i.e. the solution has the form (C'.1.11). Further, for inverting the equation (6.3.6), A(y) and J(y) have to satisfy Holder's condition on [-b, +b]. If A(y) and hs(x, y) (with respect to the y variable) have this property we deduce the same thing for J(y) . Moreover, a(y) must not vanish on (-b,+b). If all these conditions are satisfied, then, using the formula (C.1.11), we obtain
C'([/) _
-2
'r+b
1
b2y2
b
bz -
I' [#'(") - J(n)] d n+ n-y A(q) (6.3.7)
B representing a constant which has to be determined. It is zero because from (6.3.3) we have C'(y) = -C'(-y), whence C'(0) = 0. Imposing this in (6.3.7) and observing that the integrand is an odd function, it results the assertion. Utilizing now the identity
P) --r12 d dy
In
-y2- 62-n2 i(y-n)+ i(y-n)+ b2-y2+ P-
(6.3.8)
216
THE LIFTING LINE THEORY
and integrating (6.3.7) on the interval (-b, y), from (6.3.3) one obtains:
C(y) _
+b
2 W
1
110A(+l)
b
(6.3.9)
i(y-tl)+ &2y2i(y-q)+ b -y + /bbl-
-J(17)] In
because the modulus is equal to the unity for y = -b. Performing the change of variable y = b cos s ,
tI = b cos a
(6.3.10)
and taking into account that in
-y2-
(y-tl)+
(y-17)+ b2-y2+ b2-q2
is - e is = In l e-i s _ eio I
e
- S($ a)
we obtain obviously the equation (6.2.18).
Using the notation A(tr-a) we have A(bcoe(7r-a)) = A(-boos a) _ = A(-y). Hence, taking (6.3.2) and (6.3.3) into account, it results A(tr - a) = A(a),
J(tr - a) _ i(a),
C(tr - a) = C(a)
(6.3.11)
whence:
sin ad a =
I"/2 [#A(a) - J(a)J In
s+a --/z
pc(o') - J(a)J In
o
cos cos
2 s - a sin ad a . 2
But, .
sin In
sin
$-a 2 s+a 2
cos
s+a
2 s-a cos 2
= In
sins - sin or sin s+sin or
THE SYMMETRICAL WING. VEKUA'S EQUATION
217
In this way, the equation (6.2.18) for the symmetric wing becomes 26
C(s) _
J"/2 [(;) (6.3.12)
- sing -J(a) In sins sinada, sins + sin a J
with s in the interval (0, n/2).
Vekua's Equation
6.3.3
In 1945, I.N.Vekua [6.28] gave for the symmetric profile whose chord
has the form bz
a(y) =
2
-y
with p(y) = p(-y) > 0,
,
P(y)
(6.3.13)
(where p(y) is an analytic function on [-b, +b]), a Fredholm-type integral equation which has the great advantage that it may be integrated exactly for a large class of profiles. Vekua's method was extended immediately by Magnaradze [6.16] to wings for which the function p(y) is not necessarily analytic on the interval f-b,+b]. Since we had not the occasion to read this papers, we present herein a a synthesis due to Muschelisvili [A.27]. To this aim, we write the equation (6.3.7), where we considered 13 = 0, as follows 20
A(y) C'(y) +
+b
C(11 f-b ' '
1
(6.3.14)
= A(y)J1(y) -
tb
a(y) b2 - y2
R(y,n)C(rl)d>j b
where 2(3
R(y, rl) =
Ji (y) =
1
(i-r a(n)
7r 17 - y 2
-
_
a(R-7-ill
y)
(6.3.15)
Ifb +b
62 - y2
J(q)d i1.
(6.3.16)
Ji (y) _ -J1(-y) .
(6.3.17)
rl - y
Obviously we have:
R(y, ) _ -R(-y, -y)
THE LIFTING LINE THEORY
218
Further we shall assume the continuity of the first order derivative of the function
P(y) =
(6.3.18)
a(y)
In this case, R(y, i) will be a continuous function. Since according to (6.1.7) we have: C(q
ay i-bb
r1
11
=
dq =
o d y \Jb ` + Jy+a, v
11
tab
do _
J-b
17
-
dn,
from (6.3.14) it results
dy [A(y)C'(y)] +
2Q ' +b
J-b rl (y d q
B(y),
(6.3.19)
where
B(y) =
dy [A()Ji() -
lr+b
a(y)
J
R(y, n)C(r1)d n I
.
(6.3.20)
Obviously,
B(y) = B(-y)
(6.3.21)
Eliminating the integral from (6.3.19) by means of Prandtl's equation, we obtain the following differential equation: A(y)
b [A(y)C'(y)] + 4/32C(y) = A(y) [B(y) + 4i3J(y)I .
(6.3.22)
Assuming that the right hand member is known, we have in (6.3.22) a differential linear equation for C(y). The homogeneous equation has the linear independent solutions cos s(y), sin s(y), where 20
8(y) =
(6.3.23)
Jo a(rl)
Utilizing Lagrange's method of variation of constants, we deduce that the equation (6.3.22) has the following solution: C(y) = Co cos s(y) + Cl sin s(y)+
y sin [s(y) + 2Q f [B('l) + 4QJ(n)]
- s(n)]d n,
(6.3.24)
THE SYMMETRICAL WING. VEKUA'S EQUATION
219
Co and C, being constants. Obviously, Co = C(0). Calculating C(-y), taking into account that s(y) is an odd function (its derivative is an even function) and B(q) and J(n) are odd functions, and imposing (6.3.3), it results C1 = 0. Introducing B given by (6.3.20) in (6.3.24), performing an integration by parts and observing that the integrated term is zero because
JI(0) = 0,
1-b
it results the following integral equation: +1
C(y)
K(y, ii) =
a
f
+b
(6.3.25)
K(y, q)C(t7)d n= g(y) ,
R(qj, q)
cos [s(y) - s(rh)]d nl ,
(6.3.26)
To
+2 10yJ
g(y)=Cocoss
sins
s
d+ (6.3.27)
+ [iivi)ccs[a(v) - s(n)1 d q.
The equation (6.3.25) for J9 = 1 is the equation given by Vekua and Magnaradze. Unlike the equation of Trefftz (6.2.18), this is regular (the kernel has no singularity). Moreover, in case that the function p(y) given by (6.3.18) is a rational function, more precisely in case that a(y) has the form:
a(y)=a
0
-y21+ply2+...+pny2n
9
1+qly +...+gny2"
(6.3.28)
as we shall see in an example, the equation of Vekua and Magnaradze reduces to an algebraic finite system. This form for a(y) is suitable for approximating every wing of practical interest. We have to mention that, for the wings having the form (6.3.28), the case when qt = 92 =
... = q,, = 0, has been solved by H.Schmidt in 1937, 16.241, and the case when pi = pl = ... = pn = 0 belongs to a larger class, considered by the author of the present book in 1958, (6.41. For this class one obtains the exact solution.
Before passing to applications we notice that if constant, then, taking (B.5.6) into account, we deduce g(y) = Co cos s(y) + 2k1,
J(tl) = k is a (6.3.29)
220
THE LIFTING LINE THEORY
where
I (y) _
{sin[s() - s(rl)) -
cos[s(y) - s(n)J
q
dq. (6.3.30)
6.3.4 The Elliptical Wing
Denoting by a and b the semi-axes of the ellipse from the xOy plane, we deduce s
1-b V
a(y)=aa b2-y2, as=a/b.
Obviously, R = 0 whence K(y, r)) = 0. The equation (6.3.25) gives directly the solution C(y) = g(y), where g is calculated with the formula (6.3.29). In I one performs an integration by parts. Since from (6.3.23) it results 2fi s'(tl) = ira(y)
we deduce
+wao
I=
b2-y2-bcoos(y).
Since from (6.1.20) and (6.2.7) it results J = 2e, using the notation 4wea o
aao+2/9' we deduce
C(y) = Co cos s(y) + k
- kb cos s(y) .
(6.3.31)
For determining the constant Co we shall employ the condition C(b) = 0. Since from (6.3.23) it results
s(y) =
20 wao
arcsin b ,
we deduce Co = kb whence
C(y)=k b2 -y2. For ao = 1/b one obtains exactly the solution (6.1.30).
(6.3.32)
THE SYMMETRICAL WING. VEKUA'S EQUATION
221
The Rectangular Wing
6.3.5
We shall consider now that a(y) has the form a( E/)=ao
b2 -
y
21+
(6 . 3 . 33)
,
the real numbers p and q being chosen in order to ensure only positive values of the fraction one [-b, +b]. In the sequel we shall see that one
imposes pb2 > -1 whence qb2 > -1. From (6.3.15) and (6.3.33) we deduce
R(nt, n) =
c(q + Th)
(1+pip)(1+pni)'
20(g -
C
p)
(6.3.34)
irao
and from (6.3.26) K(y, r1) =
' wo(y) +'P1(y)
(6.3.35)
1+pr7
where acs{s(by} -_aq(m)) 1 +
MY) = c
1
1
d'ri
(6.3.36)
Taking into account that for pb2 > -1 we have d ,q
q 1 + pb2
1
I (1+p) b2-
1+
arct&n
from (6.3.23), for p # 0, we deduce s(y)
2Q f q arcein EI + _ 7rao Lp b
1 +'2 J
p- q p
arctan
y
1+ pb2 l
(6.3.37)
and for p = 0, (I +
s(y) _ L
c) aresin b - Zy
vfb2 --y2 l
.
(6.3.38)
Replacing K(y, q) given by (6.3.35) in the integral equation (6.3.25) and observing that the first term vanishes because the integrand is an odd function, we deduce:
C(y) + tPiny)
r-b
1
C +(p
dt = Cocoss(y) + 2k1(y).
(6.3.39)
THE LIFTING LINE THEORY
222
The integral is a constant Cl which may be determined by multiplying (6.3.39) with (1 + py2)-1 and integrating with respect to y on the
interval (-b,+b). We obtain
J
III[
b
1 + P?1
1 (6.3.40)
bbl+py2dy.
-Col bb +a( dy=2A;
Imposing (6.3.39) and the condition C(b) = 0, we deduce the relation Co cos s(b) - 91(b) CI = -2k1(b).
(6.3.41)
Determining the constants Co and Cl from the system (6.3.40) and (6.3.41), we find the exact solution of Prandtl's equation
C(y) = Cocoss(y) - !C1SOj(y) +2kI(y).
(6.3.42)
Using the inverse method, i.e. considering various values for the con-
stants p and q and calculating the form of the chord, we may find important wings for which the exact solution (6.3.42) is valid. So, in (A.271, considering q = 0 and pb2 = 0, 9, one obtains an almost rectangular wing (the variation of the chord versus the span is very small). Indeed, we have y/b
a/boo
0. 1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1.00
1.02
1.03
1.05
1.06
1.06
1,03
0.95
0.75
Importantresults ofthis meth method are givenin [1.331. 6.3.6
Extensions
Modifying Vekua's method, we managed in (6.4) to give the exact solution of Prandtl's equation for wings whose chord satisfies the relation ys
a(y) =
P(y)
,
(6.3.43)
where p(Z) is a holomorphic function in the Z = y + i z complex plane, excepting the vicinity of the point at infinity where one admits
223
NUMERICAL METHODS
the following series expansion: k>O
p(Z)
=n=-oo E PAZ"
(6.3.44)
.
The determination of the solution of Prandtl's equation is reduced to solving a Hilbert-type problem, whose exact solution is given. The polynomials belong to the class (6.3.44), whence the great importance of this solution. According to Weierstrass's theorem (see for example, [6.13], p.61), every continuous function on the interval [-b, +b] (i.e., every possible form of the wing) may be approximated by polynomials. Practically, for this one may employ an interpolation method (for example, Newton or Lagrange's method). Even if p(y) is a polynomial, in this method it is not necessary to be symmetric, like in the theory of Vekua and Niagnaradze.
Numerical Methods
6.4 6.4.1
Multhopp's Method
The idea of biulthopp's method consists in approximating the func-
tion C(a) by the trigonometric polynomial P"(c) obtained by the Lagrange interpolation in the basis (sinkc)kl,...,n. For determining P", we notice that after introducing the matrices
ST = (sin c,...,sin nc),
aT
= (al,...,an),
it may be written as follows
=
P.
n
(c)
ak sin ka = sTa.
(6.4.1)
kal
The points where one imposes for PP(o) to coincide with C(o) (the nodes) are given by the uniform grid aI
n+1 -o,
a2
2a
n+1
-2a,...,c"=
na
n
1 =nor,
(6.4.2)
whidi is usual in the theory of interpolation [6.13] p.20. These are equidistant on the half-circle with the diameter on the span (fig. 6.4.1). The points xJ = cos a1
(6.4.3)
THE LIFTING LINE THEORY
224
+z
x
-1
1
b
y
Fig. 6.4.1.
are the zeros of the Chebyshev polynomial of order two (F.2.8) on the interval (0,7r).
Denoting c; = C(a1) we have to determine the matrix a from the system Sa = c,
(6.4.4)
where
sin ai sin 2a1 ... sin nal S = sin a2 sin 202... sin nag
c=
(6.4.5)
sin a, sin 20,E ... sin na
One obtains [6.131, p.21
S-1 =
IS. n2
(6.4.6)
NUMERICAL METHODS
We shall present at the end of the section this calculus. Hence,
n+l
sin v1... sin na1
Cl
... sin na
c
(sin a...sin no) I sin on
1Ecinko l 2
n+
(6.4.7)
k=1
1(sin a... sin na)
ctsinka 2
+
sin koj s i n j=1
k=1
For C(a) we have the Wowing expansion:
C(a)
= n +2 1
n
n
ck
sin ka j sin jo.
(6.4.8)
We must notice that this expression could be also obtained from (6.2.26) approximating the Fourier coefficients according to the definition of the integral for an equidistant division a. Indeed, f om (6.2.26) we have:
C(Q) sin yoda
Aj TO
+1
k,i
C(ck) sin jai, .
Since jak = jka = kof, eraplaying Glauert's approximation Al sin jo,
C(Q) _
j-1 one obtains (6.4.8).
Utilizing Multhopp'e expansion (6.4.8), from Prandtl's equation (6.2.28)
226
THE LIFTING LINE THEORY
and from Glauert's formula, we deduce: sin s
4b,3
n+1
n
n
ck > sin jka sin js+ k=1
j=1 (6.4.9)
27r
s sins.
sin jka sin js = 2irba s j=1
k=1
Giving to s the successive values La(£ = 1, ... , n) and taking into account the formulas (6.4.17) and (6.4.19) from below, we deduce the
system (£ = I,-, n), BtkCk = Bt,
Oct +
(6.4.10)
k=1
where
2Bt = (n + 1)ira(£k)j(£a).
(6.4.11)
Fbr k $ t, Btk
-
lra(£a) 2bsin£a
I - (-1)n-t 8
_
I sine
(k + t)a 2
1
sine (k - £)o`
' (6.4.12)
2
and for k = e, Att =
7ra(£a)
n(n + 1)
2b sin la
4
(6.4.13)
Determining the unknowns c1, ... , c from the system (6.4.10), one obtains the solution of Prandtl's equation from (6.4.8). Since Atk vanishes when k - £ is an even number, the system (6.4.10) may be separated; more precisely, the unknowns with odd indices may be expressed by means of the unknowns with odd indices and vice versa. This fact was proved in [1.2]. As it is already mentioned in (1.2] and in (6.17] an iterative procedure for determining the unknowns is
also established. The author had not at his disposition this paper. The procedure simplifies in the case of the symmetric wing (C(y) = C(-y)), i.e. when ck = Cn+l _k (k = 1, 2, ... , [(n+ 1)/2]) or in the case of the antisymmetric wing (ck = -c,+1_k). In the first case the system reduces to [(n + 1)/2] equations, and in the second to ((n - 1)/2]. The square brackets indicate the integer part of the number from the interior.
227
NUMERICAL METHODS
In the sequel we shall calculate the sums that intervened in the above formulas. Let it be for the beginning n
r
j=1
i=1
11.Ecosrja, 12 - Esinrja.
(6.4.14)
Denoting z = e1r`r, for r 96 0, we obtain
_
z - zn+i
-
=
l- z
1
whence, separating the real part from the imaginary one,
I1 = -1 +
1 - (-I}r ,
2
12 =
1 - (-I)r 2
cot
ra . 2
(6.4.15)
One obtains the sum n
r
Ejcosrja-
1
j=1
4
I
era
sin 2
(6.4.16)
12 with respect to a. We deduce therefore, noticing that k - f and k + f are odd or even simultaneously,
deriving
n
n
2 E sin kja sin eja = E cos(k - e) jaj=1
j=1
(6.4.17) n
-Ecos(k+f)ja= (n+l)6kt. j=1
With these formulas, the relation (6.4.6) written as follows S-1S
n2
S2=1
may be immediately proved, since we have: n
Sz
n
_ E sine ja F sins ja sin 2ja ... sine ja sin nja j=1 ial j=1
(6.4.18)
THE LIFTING LINE THEORY
228
Utilizing now (6.4.16), for k q& a we deduce n
2 E j sin kja sin eja = j=1 (6.4.19)
4
sin2
and for k = e:
(k+2 e)a
sin2
e
(k 2
n
4 E j sine kja = n(n -}- 1).
(6.4.20)
j=1
Analogously it results: n
2 E sin jka sin ja = > cos j(ka - a) - > cos j(ka + a) _ j-1 j,1 j
-Re z-Zn+1
Z-Zn+1
_Re 1- f
I-Z
s,,01(ka+.)
(-1)k+1 sin(n + 1)a sin ak COs a - COS ak
(6.4.21)
If we utilize this identity, for the formula (6.4.8) which gives the solution of Prandtl's equation , we obtain the final form
C(a) __
1
n+l
n k=1
k+1
`
sin(n + 1)a sinker . coo a - cos ka
(6.4.22)
In [A.23], p. 98-111 one gives a mathematical justification of this method. More precisely, one demonstrates that under certain circumstances, the iterative procedure that one utilizes for solving the system (6.4.10) is convergent and the solution (6.4.22) converges uniformly to the solution of Prandtl's equation.
6.4.2
The Quadrature Formulas Method
In [6.5) we gave a numerical method for solving Prandtl's equation by means of Gauss-type quadrature formulas. It is well known that these
229
NUM ERICAG METHODS
formulas give the best approximation. The key of this method consists in writing Prandtl's equation in the form (6.1.21). With the change of variables
y = bs , q7 = bz
(6.4.23)
and, keeping the notations C(s), a(s) and j(s) for C(bs), a(bs) and respectively j(bs), the equation (6.1.21) becomes .
/3C(s)
2b)
1
J-1 (z
(s)s d x + j (s) ,
(6.4.24)
and the conditions (6.1.7),
C(±1) = 0.
(6.4.25)
The solution of the equation (6.4.24) has the form
C(s) =
1
-_3 2 c(s) .
(6.4.26)
Employing the quadrature formulas (F.3.5), the equation (6.4.24) reduces to the algebraic system n
EAkici =7k, k = 1nn,
(6.4.27)
i=1
where we denoted ak = a(zk), Ck = C(xk), era k
A
2b(n + 1)
(-1):+kl
1-
Akk=fV1 -xk+6
jk = j(zk)
(x1x2
-1
i#k,
zk)2
(6.4.28)
n41; zi=Cosn+1,t I'n'
the unknowns being c1,... , c,t. The system has to be studied theoretically and solved numerically using a computer. After determining the unknowns, the lift, drag and moment coefficients, defined in (6.1.21) and (6.1.25), CL
C=
2b
win the form
f
+1
1 - s2 c(s)d s, cD = - A
1
= mA J
1
`s
1 - s2 c(s)d s, c;
r1
ZA-
j
1 - s2 w(s)c(s) ds,
11
s
1 - s2 w(s)c(s) ds, (6.4.29)
230
THE LIFTING LINE THEORY
give with the formula (F.2.12) CL =
(n + 1)A E(1 i=1
- x?)c" CD = - (n + 1)A isl
" _ {n + 1)mA E(1- x; 2)xc:, 27rb2
i_I
x?)w,c{
>,
2nb2
2 c= (n + 1)mA E(1 - xd )x:wig i_1
(6.4.30)
where
w; =
13 VI - x, .
2aai
(6.4.31)
In (6.4.30) we used, like in (6.1.21), the notations A for the area of the domain D and m for dimensionless length of the mean chord (in the direction of the unperturbed stream). For verifying the method, we applied it in [6.5) to the elliptical Sat wing, for which the exact solution is known (6.1.28), (6.1.30). With the notation (6.4.26) it results c(s) = k. Putting in (6.4.27) Aki =
1- x4Ak;,
c; = k4,
it results that the system Ak.;ci
= Q+ it/(2b)
(6.4.32)
must have the solution dl = d2 = ... = c;, = I. For b = 10 one obtains numerically dl = 4 = ... 1000. We deduce therefore that the proposed method is very good. In the sequel we shall give the numeric solution for the rectangular wing (in this case there exists no exact solution). Taking the reference
length Lo in the definition of the dimensionless variables (2.1.1), to coincide with the half of the chord, we deduce xt = :L1. It results
a(y) = 1 and j(y) = 27rc. Putting c; = 27red', the system (6.4.27) becomes Akic!
= 1, k = I- n,
(6.4.33)
where Ak; are given by (6.4.28) where we put ak = 1. The quantities
NUMERICAL 1METHODS
231
of interest in (6.4.30) are
1
kl =_ 71+1
(1-xi)c',
k2=-.1 (1-x?)3,2(c,')2, (6.4.34)
V(1-x?)x,c;, k4=
n+1 i_i
A
n+1
E(1-x?)3/2x,(cI')2. i=1
One obtains CL = 7r2ek1 ,
CD = 7r2e2(kl - k2), (6.4.35)
2c= = 7r2bek3 , 2c; = 7r2bC2(k4 - k3)
.
For b = 10 we obtain the following values:
fi
1
0.8
kl
k2
k3
k4
0.2347 0.2544
0.0907 0.0856
0
0
0
0
The result c= = c. = 0 is natural because of the symmetry of the wing. The lift and the drag increase because of the compressibility. This result is also natural. The value 2.307c obtained here for cL in the case of the incompressible fluid is smaller than the values 7.29 e, 5.28 £, ... ,
obtained with Glauert's method [1.12], but the values obtained with Glauert's method come closer to the values given here if A(= 2b/m) increases, i.e. the span is great with respect to the chord. Just in this situation the lifting line theory is valid. We may think therefore that the method we have just exposed is at the same time very simple and very efficient.
6.4.3
The Collocation Method
The simplest numerical integration method is certainly the collocation method [6.6]. In case that Prandtl's equation has the form (6.1.19) and satisfies the conditions (6.1.7), the solution has the form
C(y) =
b2
- y2 c(y) .
(6.4.36)
According to the collocation method, the segment [-b, +b] is divided into iV elements L; and the function c(y) is approximated on each
232
THE LIFTING LINE THEORY
element with its value c; from the mid - point y° of the segment. So, the equation (6.1.19) gives
,
N
[
4
c(y) = a(y)
2,8
fd
ix1
(b - y)2 d rI + 2j(y),
(6.4.37)
where, as we have already stated, Cj = c(y?). Imposing this equality to
be satisfied in every point yk, k =I,-, N, one obtains N
2
Vr2b2
- yk2ck = ak E Aloe: + 2jk k = I ,
,
(6.4.38)
i=1
where ek = c(yk), ak = a(yko), ?k = ?(yk),
Ak, -
w+1 f J(y
(6.4.39)
b-q
-
y y;+1 representing the extremities of the segment L;(y1 = -b, yN+1 = = b). So, (6.4.35) represents an algebraic linear system consisting of N
equations with N unknowns cj. For calculating Ak{, we notice that for e V (a, ?'J we have
I
a
( 7 7-e )2
d
,
y-e
a -- e
+
nee In [ (ry-e)2 + ( b -e +
+aresin
a
b2_.72s)2 (a-e)
- ry b --a- 7 (6.4.40)
For e E (a, 7) we shall write
II = o
-
(71e)2 d q b2-772
s
=J
66
(n - e)2 v° 'I
d1 (6.4.41)
T
(77 -
e)2 d
b -V2 7
(rl - e)2
d ij.
We use the formula (6.4.37) for calculating the last two integrals. Since (D.3.9)
r-b (q - e)l
d n= -7r ,
(6.4.42)
233
NUMERICAL METHODS
it results that I1 is also determined. Utilizing these formulas, for k 96 i we obtain: Aki
V - y?
b2
y
- 77i+I
yk0
yi+1 - yk
yl
(yi+1
02is
b2
72 + (Vb2_YA.
b2-t/i+l
In
y`
(Vi-Yk)2+ yi
+arcsin
(\
b2-yk2
- yko
yi+1 - yk
y,2
+
+
R--i/i+l - -Eli F1
b2
y,2
P
(6.4.43)
and for k = is y2
b2
Aii =- -7r -
Ii yt I
-
Vbi
b2 - y<+1
y2
+
+ (y +1 I Vb2 - y2
+arcsin b2
1,2+
- yI
`2
Vb2-y°2+ b2-y, )
/
2]n
t? +
(VFb2
2b (6.4.44)
Vb2
y°2
+
tJ+i
where we denoted 2ti = yi+1 - yiFor testing the method one utilizes also the elliptic flat wing. For this wing the exact solution is (6.1.28) with k determined in(6.1.30). Comparing (6.4.33) with (6.1.28), it results c = k/b. For E = 0.1,,0 = 1
(the incompressible fluid) b = 10 and N = 50, the numerical values obtained for ci are situated between 0.050 and 0.053, and the value of k/b is 0.052. For E = 0.0872, A = 1, b = 20 and N = 50 the values obtained for ci are situated between 0.0243 and 0.0252 and the value of k/b is 0.0252. The results given by this method are more accurate when the angle of attack is small. The accuracy also increases when N increases.
THE LIFTING LINE THEORY
234
Since the method is simple and can be easily applied one can accept the error of order 10-3 that it contains.
6.5 Various Extensions of the Lifting Line Theory
The Equation of Weissinger and Reinner
6.5.1
In the sequel we shall study new integral equations in order to improve
Prandtl's model. In the past the researchers did not pay too much attention to these equations because the integrands contain both the unknown C and the derivative C'. Now we may use successfully these equations because some fundamental results concerning the Finite Part are known and, as we have mentioned in 16.5], after replacing the
Principal Value of an integral which contains C' and has a Cauchy type singular kernel by the Finite Part of an integral which contains C and has an hypersingular kernel, we may employ the numerical methods. First we shall study the equation of Weissinger [6.30] and Reissner [5.29]. For obtaining it, we return to the lifting surface equation (6.1.28). Taking (6.1.6), (6.1.11) and (6.1.12) into account, we deduce +b
rlydn. l Cdn-7dt J-e 9 ff bod JJ dq+2
(6.5.1)
Utilizing (5.1.35), from (5.1.28) it results the first form of the integral equation
r+b fi(n) d n +
1
ri - y
1'rj
(1 4w JJD lJo \
_ z o d td r1= rt, (x, y). R
(6.5.2)
Multiplying this equation by (6.1.15) and integrating it on the interval [x_(y), x+(y)] one obtains
j+b
a(y)C(rl)d71+
brl - Y +
1
+b
2a J-b
+(v) x+(n)
Tx-)
x-x-(y) Mm) (i_i) dx d d E rl f(v), x+(v)-x (6.5.3)
j(y) being (6.1.18).
235
VARIOUS EXTENSIONS OF THE LIFTING LINE THEORY
Further we shall perform an approximation which consists in replac-
ing f(f,9) by C(n) A(n)
f (f, rl)
x+(n) - f
(6.5.4)
This is just the solution of the two-dimensional problem when h' is constant. Indeed, according to the formula (C.1.9), for a given y , the equation of the two-dimensional problem
1+(v) f(f,y)
T
( 6 .5.5 )
= hx (x,y),
n ,-(,) f - x
becomes, in case that h' does not depend on x: f (x , y)
x+(y) - x
= -h(y) x - x_(y)
(6 5 6) .
.
Multiplying (6.5.5) by (6.1.15), integrating the result over (x_ (y), X+ (y)] and utilizing the formulas (B.5.4) one obtains: -+(v)
C(y) __
- J:-(v)
(6.5.7)
f (f, y)d f = ira(y)h'(y)
Eliminating h' from (6.5.6) and (6.5.7) one obtains (6.5.4). With this approximation, the equation (6.5.3) becomes:
a(y) J bbC n)di? +27r YO
T-b
(6.5.8) TO
where
N (y, n)
:+(v)
_+(»)
xo rIl R)
x+(ti) - F x- x-(y) - x-(+))
x+(y) -- x
dxd
f
.
(6.5.9)
Using the notation r)) No ( y, n) = N(y,
A(y)A(n) = 1
x(y)
f A(y)A(q) J=_(vl 1
(6.5.10)
_+(,) J=-(»)
x+(r1) - f
x -x_ (y)
f- x-(rI) V x+(y) - x
d xd
f,
THE LIFTING LINE THEORY
236
we may write the equation (6.5.8) as follows: CYO
- f eb
)dn+
2A
fC
o
N°(b,n)dn = J(y).
(6.5.11)
and J(y) being defined in (6.2.7). This equation has been deduced by Reissner [5.29). Other simplifications are performed in the papers [5.24] [6.30] in order to obtain an approximate solution. The A(y)
difficulty consists in the presence of both C(n) and C'(n) in the integrand (the equation is integro-differential). Employing, as we have already shown, the Finite Part, i.e. taking (6.1.12) into account, we may write the equation (6.5.11) as follows C(q)
2 _1
y! `Ni(y, n)d, = J(y) ,
(6.5.12)
where we denoted NI = No - 2. This is the equation we are going to use in applications. This is an integral equation.
6.5.2 Welssinger's Equation. The Rectangular Wing In the case of the wings for which the lifting surface equation cannot have the form (5.1.41) (this class is established in 5.1.7, and it contains the rectangular wing) one obtains an equation which may be easily utilized in applications. This equation was given by Weissinger [6.31), and received his name. Starting from the definition (6.1.6), we have:
-i',}(n)f (x+(n) n) + x'-(n)f (x-(n), vi)-
f - f=-(")
<