STUDIES IN APPLIED MECHANICS 43
Materials Processing Defects
STUDIES IN APPLIED MECHANICS Methods of Functional Analysis for Application in Solid Mechanics (Mason) 10. Boundary Integral Equation Methods in Eigenvalue Problems of Elastodynamics and Thin Plates (Kitahara) 11. Mechanics of Material Interfaces (Selvadurai and Voyiadjis, Editors) 12. Local Effects in the Analysis of Structures (Ladeveze, Editor) 13. Ordinary Differential Equations (Kurzweil) 14. Random Vibration- Status and Recent Developments. The Stephen Harry Crandall Festschrift (Elishakoff and Lyon, Editors) 15. Computational Methods for Predicting Material Processing Defects (Predeleanu, Editor) 16. Developments in Engineering Mechanics (Selvadurai, Editor) 17. The Mechanics of Vibrations of Cylindrical Shells (MarkuP) 18. Theory of Plasticity and Limit Design of Plates (Sobotka) 19. Buckling of Structures-Theory and Experiment. The Josef Singer Anniversary Volume (Elishakoff, Babcock, Arbocz and Libai, Editors) 20. Micromechanics of Granular Materials (Satake and Jenkins, Editors) 21. Plasticity. Theory and Engineering Applications (Kaliszky) 22. Stability in the Dynamics of Metal Cutting (Chiriacescu) 23. Stress Analysis by Boundary Element Methods (Bala~, SIcSdekand Sladek) 24. Advances in the Theory of Plates and Shells (Voyiadjis and Karamanlidis, Editors) 25. Convex Models of Uncertainty in Applied Mechanics (Ben-Haim and Elishakoff) 26. Strength of Structural Elements (Zyczkowski, Editor) 27. Mechanics (Skalmierski) 28. Foundations of Mechanics (Zorski, Editor) 29. Mechanics of Composite Materials- A Unified Micromechanical Approach (Aboudi) 30. Vibrations and Waves (Kaliski) 31. Advances in Micromechanics of Granular Materials (Shen, Satake, Mehrabadi, Chang and Campbell, Editors) 32. New Advances in Computational Structural Mechanics (Ladeveze and Zienkiewicz, Editors) 33. Numerical Methods for Problems in Infinite Domains (Givoli) 34. Damage in Composite Materials (Voyiadjis, Editor) 35. Mechanics of Materials and Structures (Voyiadjis, Bank and Jacobs, Editors) 36. Advanced Theories of Hypoid Gears (Wang and Ghosh) 37A. Constitutive Equations for Engineering Materials Volume 1: Elasticity and Modeling (Chen and Saleeb) 37B. Constitutive Equations for Engineering Materials Volume 2: Plasticity and Modeling (Chen) 38. Problems of Technological Plasticity (Druyanov and Nepershin) 39. Probabilistic and Convex Modelling of Acoustically Excited Structures (Elishakoff, Lin and Zhu) 40. Stability of Structures by Finite Element Methods (Waszczyszyn, Cicho~ and Radwahska) 41. Inelasticity and Micromechanics of Metal Matrix Composites (Voyiadjis and Ju, Editors) 42. Mechanics of Geomaterial Interfaces (Selvadurai and Boulon, Editors) 43. Materials Processing Defects (Ghosh and Predeleanu, Editors) .
General Advisory Editor to this Series: Professor Isaac Elishakoff, Center for Applied Stochastics Research, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Florida Atlantic University, Boca Raton, FL, U.S.A.
STUDIES IN APPLIED MECHANICS 43
Materials Defects
Processing
Edited by
S.K. Ghosh GKN International College of Engineering Lohmar, Germany
M. Predeleanu LMT University of Paris V/ Cachan, France
L~~
l
1995 ELSEVIER Amsterdam- Lausanne- New York- Oxford- Shannon-Tokyo
ELSEVIER SCIENCE B.V. Sara Burgerhartstraat 25 P.O. Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands
pages 17-58 reprinted from Journal of Materials Processing Technology, Vol. 32, nos. 1-2 (1992) ISBN 0-444-81706-9 91995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. No part ofthis publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher, Elsevier Science B.V., Copyright & Permissions Department, P.O. Box 521, 1000 AM Amsterdam, The Netherlands. Special regulations for readers in the U.S.A. - This publication has been registered with the Copyright Clearance Center Inc. (CCC), Salem, Massachusetts. Information can be obtained from the CCC about conditions under which photocopies of parts of this publication may be made in the U.S.A. All other copyright questions, including photocopying outside of the U.S.A., should be referred to the copyright owner, Elsevier Science BV, unless otherwise specified. No responsibility is assumed bythe publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. pp. 373-386: Copyright not transferred. This book is printed on acid-free paper. Printed in The Netherlands
Preface The Second International Conference on Materials Processing Defects (Proceedings of which was published as a special issue of the Journal of Materials Processing Technology, Vol. 32, nos. 1-2, 1992, 530 pages) was held GKN Automotive AG during 1 -3 July 1992. We believe that this technological field of defects, and more appropriately, avoidance of them, is very current in perhaps all sectors of the manufacturing industry. This is particularly important to reduce/minimize waste everywhere to address lean production procedures. The recent advances in finite plasticity and visioplasticity, damage modelling, instability theories, fracture modelling, computer numerical techniques and process simulation etc. offer new approaches and tools for defect prediction, analyses and guidelines for designing components to be manufactured by traditional and emerging process technologies. The present volume includes contributions from well known researchers and experts in this field, most of whom were also involved with the aforementioned Conference. The main aim of the contributions has been to extend and generalize somewhat their past contribution in the form a self-contained chapter on individual title topics such that a volume would be possible. We do hope that it matches to a large extent with the stated objectives considering the vast field of research into defects in all kinds of materials processing and associated topics: - Micro- and Macro-scale observation of defects Localization and instability analysis Damage modelling and fracture criteria - F ormability characterization - Defect prediction methods - Design considerations to avoid defects - Practical process/material considerations. -
-
We are very indebted to the authors and referees of this volume for their generous and very kind support. We would also thank Mrs. Heike Erlenkamp for all her help towards this volume. Finally, the team at Elsevier, Amsterdam: Mrs. Mary McAdam, Ms. Wilma van Wezenbeek, Dr. Bas van der Hoek and Dr. van der Hoop deserve special thanks for their patience and care for professional preparation and presentation of the book.
S K Ghosh Lohmar, Germany
M Predeleanu Paris, France 3 November 1994
vii
Dedicated to
Professor Frank W Travis DSc Professor Vellore C Venkatesh DSc
on the occasion of their 60th birthdays
The proceedings of the Conference, based on which this present volume has been initiated, was dedicated in 1992 to p r o f e s s o r William J o h n s o n F R S F E n g - T h i s book on M a t e r i a l s processing D e f e c t s is dedicated to my earlier teachers, p r o f e s s o r s Travis and Venkatesh. I do this with great pleasure on behalf of all their students, research assistants, research fellows, post doctoral researchers, colleagues and all others who have had contact with them throughout their professional careers. I t is very fitting indeed that this dedication appears in a volume published by Elsevier since both of them have been contributing through this publisher to the scientific community of materials processing worldwide for many years. M y dedication to p r o f e s s o r s Travis and Venkatesh will be incomplete without reference to their wives, M r s . J e a n T r a v i s and M r s . Gita Venkatesh concerning their generous support, help and kind hospitality always and everywhere, and especially, that extended to those, so-called 'foreign students/researchers abroad'. I t gives me great pleasure on all your behalf in wishing them continued good health and happiness.
I~rofeee)or Swaclhin K u m a r Ghoe)h Dirsc~0r GKN I n ~ c ~ r n a t i o n a l College of: Engineering Lohmar, G e r m a n y
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CONTENTS
Preface oo VII
Dedication Some Comments on the Structure of Technology of Plasticity in R&D and Production K. Lange James Nasmyth (1808-1890): The Steam Hammer and the Mechanics of Vee-anvil Forging W. Johnson
17
Modeling Dynamic Strain ~ i z a t i o n M. Predeleanu
59
in Inelastic Solids
Void Growth under Triaxial Stress State and its Influence on Sheet Metal Forming Limits R. C. Chaturvedi
75
The Prediction of Necking and Wrinkles in Deep Drawing Processes Using the FEM E. Doege, T. El-Dsoki and D. Seibert
91
Constitutive Models for Microvoid Nucleation, Growth and Coalescence in Elastoplasticity, Finite Element Reference Modelling J. Oudin, B. Bennani and P. Picart
107
Theoretical and Numerical Modelling of Isotropic or Anisotropic Ductile Damage in Metal Forming Processes J. C. Gelin
123
Research on Forging Processes for Production a + /3 Titanium Alloy TCll Disks Sencan Chen, Yu Xinlu, Zongshi Hu and Shaolin Wang
141
Modelling of Fracture Initiation in Metalforming Processes Y.Y. Zhu, S. Cescotto and A.M. Habraken
155
Formability Determination for Production Control J.A. Schey
171
Design of Experiments, a Statistical Method to Analyse Sheet Metal Forming Defects Effectively D. Bauer and R. Leidolf
187
Formability, Damage and Corrosion Resistance of Coated Steel Sheets J.Z. Gronostajski and Z.J. Gronostajski
203
Model of Metal Fracture in Cold Deformation and Ductivity Restoration by Annealing V.L. Kolmogorov
219
Prediction of Necking in 3-D Sheet Metal Forming Processes with Finite Element Simulation M. Brunet
235
Deformability versus Fracture Limit Diagrams A. G. Atkins
251
Prediction of Geometrical Defects in Sheet Metal Forming Processes by Semi-Implicit FEM A. Makinouchi and M. Kawka
265
Evolution of Structural Anisotropy in Metal Forming Processes J. Tirosh
283
Computer Aided Design of Optimised Forgings S. Tichkiewitch
297
Defects in Thermal Sprayed and Vapour Deposited Thick and Thin Hard-wearing Coatings M.S.J. Hashmi
311
A Study of Workability Criteria in Bulk Forming Processes A.S. Wifi, N. El-Abbasi and A. Abdel-Hamid
333
Degradation of Metal Matrix Composite under Plastic Straining N. Kanetake and T. Choh
359
Crack Prevention and Increase of Workability of Brittle Materials by Cold Extrusion H. W. Wagener and J. Haats
373
A Database for some Physical Defects in Metal Forming Processes M.M. Al-Mousawi, A.M. Daragheh and S.K. Ghosh
387
Split Ends and Central Burst Defects in Rolling S. Turczyn and Z. Malinowski
401
Form-Filling in Forging and Section-Rolling P.F. Thomson, C.-J. Chong and T. Ramakrishnan
417
Materials Processing Defects S.K. Ghosh and M. Predeleanu (Editors) 9 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Some Comments on the Structure of Technology of Plasticity in R&D and Production
o. Prof. em. Dr.-Ing. Dr.h.c. Kurt Lange Institut fQr Umformtechnik, Universit~t Stuttgart, Stuttgart, Germany
The complexity of the increasingly expanding field of production techniques and technologies led to various attempts to develop structures for the systematic treatment of problems. This is also true for the technology of plasticity. In 1956 O. Kienzle, University of Hannover, formulated seven points which must be or should be considered for the solution of metal forming problems. Only a few years later, around 1965, W. Backofen, MIT Cambridge/Boston, developed a system comprising four zones for his systematic approach to metal forming with emphasis on the behaviour of materials during deformation processes, including especially damage. The four zones were:
.
2. 3. 4.
Deformation zone with plastic material behaviour Friction and lubrication between work material and tool Material properties before deformation Material properties after deformation
The tool itself was not of so much concern for him being a materials scientist. Kienzle, however, had already included in his seven points the machine tool and the factory besides the tool as a key to successful production of formed parts. Based on the list of seven points by Kienzle (fig. 1, items 1-5,7,8) and Backofen (Fig.l, items 1-4) a general system for the investigation and development of metal forming processes was designed by the author taking the original scetch-flatrolling by Backofen as the first process example, but demonstrating also, that the same numbering is also valid for other processes (Fig.l). The idea was to demonstrate the close interconnnection of items 1-5, the sub-system workpiece-tool, and to push it into production by machine tool and factory, symbolized by the two surrouunding rings. Also introduced into the system was item 6, taking into account possible exchange between workpiece and surrounding atmosphere, following suggestions by Gebhardt, Stuttgart and Schey, Chicago, which might cause e.g. surface contamination.
For better understanding some short and incomplete descriptions of the meaning of the eight points-or areas-and their interaction are given in the following:
9A r e a 1, the plastic zone, concerns the determination of the material behaviour in the plastic state. Using plasticity theory and initially assuming an idealized, isotropic material, the stresses, strains, and material flow may be determined. Based on these, the temperature distributions may be found at different locations and for different points in time. Metallurgy allows a description of the behaviour of the material on a microscopic scale (anisotropy, textures etc.). 9 A r e a 2 deals with the characteristics of the workpiece before deformation.
These affect more or less the behaviour of the material in the deformation zone and the characteristics of the resulting workpiece. Besides the chemical composition, mechanical properties play an important role here as well as the crystal structure, texture and microstructure (such as grain size, amount and type of second-phase particles). Apart from the chemical composition, all of the properties mentioned can be changed to a greater or lesser degree by heat treatment.
Further, the
surface properties and the surface treatment prior to the forming process are also of significance. 9A r e a 3 concerns the woz'l,'piece characteristics. These are primarily the mechanical properties, surface properties, and workpiece accuracy after deformation. The workpiece characteristics after the forming process largely determine how the component will behave in service (e.g. work hardening in fastener production). 9A r e a 4 considers the boundary area between the partly elastic (rigid), partly plastic workpiece and the ela.~tic tool (= gap) and concerns all the questions
connected with friction, lubrication, and wear. The interaction of the workpiece and the tool materials plays an important role here. Further, in this area considerable changes in the original workpiece surface may sometimes occur.
9A metal-forming operation cannot be regarded in isolation from the forming tool. For this reason, area 5 deals with the many-sided problems connected with tool layout and tool materials. Appropriate design (e.g. to achieve the required stiffness of the machine and for guiding moving tool parts with respect to each other) and manufacture directly influences workpiece accuracy (area 31. 9In area 6, which is outside the zone of tool - workpiece interaction, surface reactions can take place between the workpiece and the surrounding atmosphere,
such as formation of oxides during hot forming or gas absorption when forming exotic metals. On the one hand, these operations may considerably affect the resulting surface properties, and on the other hand they may also influence the workpiece characteristics in the same area, for example, with exotic metals through the absorption of small amounts of gases. 9The t o o l - workpiece system (problem areas i to 6) is always incorporated in a machine tool (e.g. forging hammer, mechanical or hydraulic press, or rolling
mill). The machine tool is symbolized by the inner circle, area 7. It must provide the necessary energy and forces for the different operations at each stage of the process and assure sufficiently accurate guiding of the different parts of the tool with respect to each other. This calls for appropriate dimensioning of the tooling and, where necessary, of the workpiece-handling equipment for the application concerned (e.g. bulk forming or sheet forming). Finally, important factors affecting productivity are the stroke rate, setup time, and so on. 9Beyond this, area 8 is concerned with the integration of the metal-forming process itself into the production system as a whole. It covers all auxiliary equipment and functions (e.g. heat treating, cleaning, handling, and automation) on the shop floor as well as factory organisation (e.g. work preparation, production control, and cost estimation).
The systematic approach to the solution of problems in metal forming processes has proved to be realistic as a base for R&D especially also in connection with the systematic grouping of forming processes in the German DIN-standards 8582 to 8587[2-7]. This is based mainly on the important differences in effective stresses. However, simple descriptions of stress states are not possible since, depending on the kind of operation, different stress states may occur simultaneously or they may change during the course of a forming operation. Therefore the predominant stress states were chosen as classification criteria, resulting in five groups of metal forming processes:
1. C o m p r e s s i v e f o r m i n g (forming under compressive stresses). German standard DIN 8583 covers the deformation of a solid body in which the plastic state is achieved mainly by uni- or multiaxial compressive loading. 2. C o m b i n e d tensile and c o m p r e s s i v e f o r m i n g (forming under combined tensile and compressive stresses). DIN 8584 covers the deformation of a solid body in which the plastic state is achieved mainly by combined uni- or multiaxial tensile and compressive loading. 3. Tensile f o r m i n g (forming under tensile stresses). DIN 8585 covers the deformation of a solid body in which the plastic state is achieved mainly through unior m ultiaxial tensile stresses. 4. F o r m i n g b y b e n d i n g (forming by means of bending stresses). DIN 8586 covers the deformation of a solid body in which the plastic state is achieved mainly by means of a bending load. 5. F o r m i n g b y s h e a r i n g (forming under shearing stresses). DIN 8587 covers the deformation of a solid body in which the plastic state is achieved mainly by means of a shearing load. The examples in Figs.2 to 9 represent some of the more than 200 processes defined in the standards. They contain the same basic interaction between tool and workpiece, i.e. the relevant geometw features and the basic kinematic. It is obvious that the points or areas 1 to 8 as given above (see Fig.l) can be easily defined, so that in consequence the process scetches in DIN 8582 to 8587 will fit in our general system for the investigation of metal forming processes. Together they might also serve vew well as a basic introduction of students to forming technologies (see also [8]).
Development of Technology of Plasticity after 1965 For the time being, one should not forget, however, that the above presented systematic approach with eight areas was designed between 1960 and 1969 approximately. Since then, the scientific technical fundaments of the technology of plasticity have been and still are widened and deepened considerably with accelerating velocity. This development is driven by the need for more economic use of energy and materials on the one hand and by the intention to keep the prices of products for a rapidly growing number of consumers as low as possible. Especially metal forming processes have the potential to meet these challenges including the development of near-net or net-shape processes, e.g. in hot, warm and cold forging. The aim is to replace machining for metal removal by forming with material saving and high-dimensional accuracy as well as high surface quality as far as possible. During the last 20 to 25 years, the rapidly increasing introduction of permanently more powerful computers with appropriate software has not only contributed significantly to the above mentioned development but has also pushed it ahead. Process analysis and simulation with FEM-programs are improving the understanding of forming processes considerably and hence are offering the key to unforeseen possibilities of process optimization. Modern metrology technology supported by computer data processing has also contributed to this development which comprises also triboIogy phenomena, but there will be still very much to be clone to develop and improve theories and to produce data - both for the application in sound process layout. Finally, the influence of the computer on the functions and control of the modern forming machine tools should be not forgotten as well as its impetus on flexible process automation including material handling and tool exchange. Last not least the very important modern development of the die and tool technology - design increasingly by CAD and aided by FEM -, materials, surface coating and treatment must be mentioned here, as the functioning, reliable and economic tool is the key to economic production by forming.
It should be mentioned here that all of these developments and changes have been backed up by rapidly growing stimulating exchange between scientists and technologists, e.g. by books and other publications, by conferences and by cooperative work
in organisations.
To sum it up: Metal forming seems to be on the move to new
standards and capabilities in order to be permanently prepared for new challenges in modern industrial production.
New Systematic Structure of Metal Forming Processes The changes and partly rapid developments since approximately 1965 were reason enough to reflect on the systematic approach of 1968. It was the special concern of the author to demonstrate more clearly the interdependence of influencing factors on the process, and, hence, the product. All the more, the strong influence of the modern computer technologies and of the tools on the process should be made more transparent. This goal was finally reached by defining a "process core" or heart just by geometry and kinematic as shown in Fig.2 to 9, and to place it in the system centre, surrounded by the influencing areas = process components as satellites. The process core is interconnected with the six satellites Material, Tribology, Tool (design, manufacture) Machine-Tool + Automation, Production and Theory of Plasticity + C A - Techniques which is the usual starting area for a process development or investigation. All six areas are interacting with the process core and with one another. These interconnections between the satellites and/or the process core may be partly described mathematically or by data flow structures. Only the process core plus the six satellites or components together will represent a process completely. This is integrated into the general technical and economical conditions and will be influenced by the location and the market - the latter being determined more and more by global aspects. Consequently further process development
must be directed towards increased product quality, improved flexibility,
productivity and economy.
For fundamental scientific studies the interconnection of the process core with only one or a few of the six satellites, e.g. material, theory of plasticity may be sufficient - many publications just deal with the analysis or simulation of a "process" by combining geometry and kinematic with assumed material and friction laws. Frequently also the interconnection theory-process core-tool is being used effectively for the FEM-assisted design of tool geometries optimized for e.g. material flow with limited strain gradients. But for a real production process, the whole system must be considered.
This may be underlined by some closer looks to the contents and structure of the system components=satellites.
There is no doubt or at least there should not be about the
extraordinary significance of materials for metal forming.
Material and optimized forming process together will lead to a product meeting the customers needs in a very global meaning. It is expected that after the end of the long-lasting cold war the free exchange of products, ideas and research results will create a new era of materials characterized by the relationship between materials and manufacturing solutions to follow the new challenges for economy, low weight/high strength, environmental friendliness, recycability and minimum energy consumption for material generation. From the materials engineers point of view the satellite "Material" might be represented in more detail as shown in Fig. 1 1 [1 1]. Important is the interconnection: Materials design, all materials system, manufacturing- the latter including forming - which corresponds perfectly to the system in Fig. 10. Consequently the all material system could be easily redesigned and could serve as level 2, if the presentation in Fig. 10 is considered to be level 1. In another level 3, information on specific material properties e.g. flow stress vs. strain (Fig. 1 2) or vs. strain rate (Fig. 13) might be contained in various manners, while in more other levels relation describing equations, data storages etc. could be presented. Figure 13 emphasizes the interaction between "Material" and "Process core", the kinematic of which determines - besides the machine t o o l - the strain rate.
These ideas will have to be worked out in more detail, but t w o other systems- for tribology and tools- seem to confirm the general applicability of the forming system proposed in Figure 10. The tribological system acc. to Figure 14 as a generally accepted standard might be used as a first step into tribology on level 2. It demonstrates already on this level t w o important interactions; with "Materials" (i.e. workpiece) and with "Tool". From the point of view of the satellite "Tool", as shown under the aspect of tool life in Figure 15, various interactions are obvious, thus demonstrating the feasibility of the system in Figure 10 again: Double link with "Material" - workpiece and tool material -, interactions with "Tribology" (lubrication, coating), "Theory" (tool design, tool geometry) and the "Process core" (geometry) [13].
It might have been shown already by these few examples that the expansion of the new system for metal forming processes to a broad and deep, multilevel information system will be possible and of great advantage. Compared with the system in Figure 1 the process structure core, components as satellites - allows easy improved approach to the individual items and their interconnections and interactions. In modern R&D as well as in production the improved understanding and data backed-up knowledge of these interactions will be more then up to now the sound base for development of reliable processes and economic manufacture of highquality formed parts.
Literature
1. Lange, K." The Investigation of Metal Forming Processes as Part of a Technical System. Proc. 10th International M.T.D.R. Conference, Manchester, September 1969. Pergamon Press: Oxford and New York- 1970. 2. DIN 8582: Fertigungsverfahren Umformen (Manufacturing Process" Forming)" 1st ed. Berlin, KSIn" Beuth 1971. 3. DIN 8583" Fertigungsverfahren Druckumformen (Manufacturing Process: Compressive Forming)" parts 1 and 6, 2 to 5 1st. ed. Berlin, KSIn" Beuth 1969, 1970. 4. DIN 8584" Fertigungsverfahren Zugdruckumformen (Manufacturing Process: Combined Tensile and Compressive Forming)" 1st. ed. Berlin, KSIn: Beuth 1970. 5. DIN 8585" Fertigungsverfahren Zugumformen (Manufacturing Process: Tensile Forming)" 1st. ed. Berlin, K61n: Beuth 1970. 6. DIN 8586: Fertigungsverfahren Biegeumformen (Manufacturing Process: Forming by Bending)" 1st ed. Berlin, K61n" Beuth 1970. 7. DIN 8587" Fertigungsverfahren Schubumformen (Manufacturing Process" Forming by Shearing)" 1st. ed. Berlin, K61n" Beuth 1969. 8. Lange, K. (editor)" Handbook of Metal Forming. New York etc." McGraw-Hill 1985. ISBN 007-036285-8. 2nd printing Dearborn: SME 1994. ISBN 0-87263-457-4. 9. Lange, K." Dohmen, H.G. (editors)" Pr~izisionsumformtechnik
(Precision Metal Forming
Technology). Results of the program "Precision metal forming technology" of the German Research Foundation (DFG). Berlin etc.: Springer 1990. ISBN 3-540-51943-2. 10. Lange, K. (editor)" Umformtechnik-Handbuch f~r Industrie und Wissenschaft (Metal Forming Technology-Handbook for industry and science) Vol.4. Berlin etc." Springer 1993. ISBN 3-54055939-6. 11. Bridenbaugh, P.R." Commercial Transportation" The next, best engine for advanced materials systems. ASM News (April 1993) 4 + 5. 12. DIN 50320 Verschleil3. Begriffe, Systemanalyse von Verschleil~vorg~ngen, Gliederung des Verschleil~gebietes (Wear Terms, Systems analysis of wear problems, Breakdown of wear region). 13. Lange, K." Cs~r, L." Geiger, M." Kals, J.A.G." Tool life and tool quality in bulk metal forming. Annals of the CIRP Vo1.41/2/1992, 667-675.
2
1 plastic zone 2 materia! properti es before Tormlng
4
3 material properties after Torming
9
4 contact zone 5 tool
6 work~iece and surrounoing atmosphere 7 forming maschine 8 factory
~ 2
a.
4
I
/
4
6
6
5
/,
2
1~-3
b.
Figure 1. A general system for the investigation of metal forming processes. (a) System structure. (b) Examples for various metal forming processes.
Threaded roll
Roll
Final shape
Initial shape
~' ~ , ~ Pressure Master . ~ , \ ~ - roller (a)
.or,,.e
e
(b)
(c)
Figure 2. Compressive forming. Examples of lateral rolling. (a) Thread rolling by the run-through method. (b) Lateral rolling of spheres. (c) Flow turning. (After [3].)
10
@
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
Figure 3. Compressive forming. Examples of die-forming processes. (a) Fullering. (b) Heading in a die. (c) Closed die forging without flash. (d) Closed impression die forging (with flash). (e) Upsetting in a die. (After [3].)
Drawing die
Drawing die
i ~~~~ . nrclning die
(plug)
~>"' ~ ~\~~I
(a)
~Roll
~
~ ~~_~kpiece
u
Roll , Workpiece be)
Floating mandrel (b) Figure 4. Combined tensile and compressive forming. Basic drawing processes. (a) Drawing through a die (rod drawing, drawing over a fixed mandrel, ironing). (b) Drawing through rolls (wire drawing, drawing over a floating mandrel). (After [4].)
1!
f
(b)
(a)
(c)
Figure 5. Combined tensile and compressive forming. Basic deep-drawing processes with rigid tools. (a) First draw with blankholder. (b) Redraw without blankholder. (c) Reverse drawing. (After [4].)
"
-
~
Spinning mandrel Tailstock
~.~/.. :.-.~,~~ ~>,~ .....
Die
Workpiece
~~-~"~~'~'~
Workpiece
Pressure roll
(b)
(a)
__~ G/_ ( ~ ~ . ~ (c)
Pressure roll ---Workpiece Mandrel
L~w
Pressure roll
orkpiece
(d)
Figure 6. Combined tensile and compressive forming. Spinning processes. (a) Spinning of hollow bodies starting from a blank. (b) Expanding by spinning. (c) Necking by spinning. (d) Thread forming by spinning. (After [4].)
12
!
Punch ~~~-Wor
k
~=~ p
i
Die
e
c
~
~-----!--
[
~9
Coil 9
(a)
Compressedair
..~ Workpiece
Workpiece
~~- Lower die
~.'./,~i ""'.../""',~{--.~- IDie
(b)
(c)
Figure 7. Tensile forming. Shallow and deep recessing processes. (a) Recessing with a rigid tool (e.g., stretch drawing, embossing). (b) Recessing by means of a pressure medium (static action). (c) Recessing by means of energy activation (e.g., electromagnetic field). (After [5].)
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
-'--'3
(e)
(f)
(g)
Figure 8. Forming by bending. Examples of formation by bending with linear tool motion. (a) Free or air bending. (b) Free round bending. (c) Die bending. (d) Die round bending. (e) Draw bending. (f) Edge rolling. (g) Bending by buckling. (After [6].)
13
Initial shape Upper die _~ . ~ / ) i n a l shape
__.-~
__o _.L.
Welding boss (a)
(b)
(c)
Figure 9. Forming by shearing. Shearing deformation processes. (a) Lateral displacement. (b) Embossing. (c) Twisting. (After [7].)
,/
//
/ Mater,al )
/ Ir,Do,ogy )
~'\\
,,
i
Market Technological Progress Location-costs (Labor costs Energy costs)
Product Properties
'i
/
/
/
Figure 10. New structure model of metal forming processes. (After [9,10].)
Productivity Flexibility Economy
14
Materials Systems for Manufacturing Solutions f
Paradigmfor Materials Competitiveness
/
Materials
,..~ Social, Legall ~~ M //Test,/ Environmental anufacturing/ /Evaluation and / Acceptance //CCharacterization ......... ~/, Figure 1 1. Materials systems for manufacturing solutions. (After [1 1].)
Z "%E ' 1000 =
1450 I
800
~,
1!60
b"- 6O0
E
870
~
"~
580
40o
200
~ N~
2901
0
0
l
"
I
i
04
~
~--~ . . . .
(A~S'1015) ,
OR Stroln
1000 o,,I
E E
8O0
-
Z
~- 600 -
-~
29
16
h~
1450
._ u~ ,=.
6
87O
.~ 40o - ~
580
u~
i
1160
I//
'
P Soft-onneolea !
o
'7
200 -
.._o L~.
,
~
290
o
"
i ,
04
~A 'S 10 35) 08 StroJn
"^
16
,~
Figure 12. Flow curves of t w o c o m m o n steels with influence of kind of heat treatment. (After [8].)
15
oa
E E
z
;. 2 0 0
b ~ 4-
.~ 3 _o
72.5
500-
100 50
-
= 29.0
-
~
14.5
-
,7
7.25
\
i
........ I -------
0 0.1
0
r
T= 1000oc(1832~
t
....
-~- -- ~L
', 1
_ ,.-
i
_ ~- ~ ]
-i~-+---~_.~--
J
"1
~--I T : 1200~ (2139~ 1 T = 1100~ (2012~ / 1
I
10 1O0 Averagestrain rate ~m, sl
J
1000
Figure 13. Flow stress versus strain rate for C15 at various temperatures, strain ~p = 0.5. (After [8].)
Collective load system 1
i.~ Structure of the Tribological System
2 t
1 ~'~'~'~~'~~~~ ~. 9 .
.~
,/
Sureface changes (Wear types) ~1
/-4 i i .
",,, i
1Basicbody(Tool) 2 COunterbOdy(wOrkpiece) 3 Intermediatelayer 4 Surroundingmedium
] Material loss I (Wear measure)
Wear characteristics Ii
Figure 14. Tribological system. (After DIN 50320112].)
16
Tool Manufacturing
Tool/Workpiece-lnterface Lubrication Tool-Material
Workpiece
9Wear 9Hardness 9Resistance 9Fracture Toughness
9Tolerances 9Surface Roughness Ra
TOOL-LIFE
~-d
Heat Treatment
Workpiece Material
Wear/Fracture
k,? "
Tool Design
I Tool Geometry
9Active Elements 9Prestressing
i 9Die Angles I 9Fillets, Corners
~'~"l'i~
I 9Deformation 9Surface Quality
tllll
9Coating
t
Figure 15. Different aspects of workpiece and forming process determining tool life by affecting wear and/or fracture. (After[13].)
Materials Processing Defects S.K. Ghosh and M. Predeleanu (Editors) 1995 Elsevier Science B.V.
JA)~
17
I~ASI~/TH ( 1 8 0 8 - 1 8 9 0 ) "
T I l E S]'EAM ~ 1 ~
AID THE ~CHMIIC;~3 OF VEE--~VIL FORGING - byu
Johnsont
Summary An outline
biography
oi the 6:cotsman,
credit with the invention
James Nasmyth,
whom the British
ol the Steam Hammer and which the French deny,
is
~iven first oi all
C3
~
The enterprising in
hammer
Responding
and
production
that
to challenge,
iarge
diameter
paddle
also
to
introduced
anticipate
have that
talented he
Nasmyth
was
he overcame
ship
it would
able
the
successiui
to
late
retire
in
his
40s.
'gaggin 8' in !ilt hammers when iorging
crank--shaits
with
Vee-anvii,
promote
was so commercially
internal
his
his
s~eam hammer'
intuition
soundness
he seems
leading
in iorging
him
which
to the
flat anvil certainly did no~. At length we consider
the plasticity mechanics of these anvils and see
in w~at manner Nae,myth's expectation
was corroborated.
As well we consider some of the associated defects which arise.
Nasmyth's Steam-hammer .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
*Emeritus Pro~essor of Mechanics, Visiting Professor in Mechanical
University ol Cambridge and Engineering
Science and Technology in U.M, I.S.T.
and in the History of
18 INTRODUCTION
Yasmyth
is a well known British
whose name is widely many
innovations
or
new
too.
portrait
and landscape
Nasmyl.h the
famous while
very at
Professor
young
ase
Stephenson
a
19,
in
1827
what
reputation
objective
was
(see
of
the
works.
2)
However,
to show to Maudslay
that he was taken on as Mr. apprenticeship
Maudslay's
business
in
up
up
~inancial pros
be
in
the
such
done'.
Maudslay
Arts
He
a
that Nas]myth was a
Note <-
l)and
' an to
project to
2.
- a road
because in
20,
for
see Fig.
George
process
aware
05
it became Nasmyth's
of the
chief
for its ~k~chine - making tools
His
father place
was
him
unable
to
he
instruments, models
made
the
manufactured
built
and
age
and
well
instrument
be
required that proved
know
-) in 1826,
caused
Coming
factory.
1821-1826
to
came to naught a
so renowned
from
came
see
of London,
Maudslay's
in
partner,
1831
as
an
his capability,
private
Nasmyth
told
to
pay
apprentice and
t.he at
mechanical
the result
assistant,
of
in a
it
interred
being
the need for any
Dale
happened
carried too n~ny tools and material
Woolwich
(London)
for a Mr.
that
he
intended
to
He was offered an apprentice
at
from the father
Suffice that
the
cost
el
because
annually,
to say that Nasmyth's iirst
iioor
premium
to him when
Manchester ZSO
begin
of a young man who
It was helpful
Piccadilly, a
Joshua
person'.
employer
Street,
property,
in
took to working
and this he took.
at a rate of 3%.
However
his
in his workshop,
business
backin~
was
- he was now 26.
in engineering offer
and
'a most systematic
Nasmyth
for 12 months
had ambitions
- and
on
loss t.o all.
1831
for himself
of ~50, set
died
a great
Late
in
being disregarded.
Maudsiay churchyard,
of
expansomet.er
dea.igned
to
Note
School
This ultimately
of Henry
organisation
Maudslay's
Field,
of
to visit this company,
!ar,~e premium
took
This demonstrates
(!Z66-1832,
working
waitin~
enterprisin~
family'.
and solid substances'
he
(I?@l-1848)was
'showing
drawings
type
8.
was
He produced
his father being predominantly
mathematics.
Leslie
new
see Pig.
national
he
i.
Edinburgh and
in bulk all metals
Steam-carriage,
the
the
subjects
and
engineer,
but talented to the extent that he desisned
see Fig.
attended
usual
Edinburgh
measuring
and
painter,
bridges',
designs
was Scottish,
of an 'artistic and mechanical
studied
7hen
engineering
His ancestry
'bow-and-string
century mechanical
linked to the origin el the steam hammer.
business
member
mid-19th
of
his
and
he got
business workshops
so that when a machine accidentally
19
Figure 1
Figure 2
20
v
I
9
The Road Steam-Carriage. By James NasmyLh. Figure 3
Bridgewater Foundry, PaLricrofl. From a Painting by Alexander Nasmyth. Figure 4
21 crashed
through
business
below he was asked to find new premises.
Rapidly,
the
floor
Nasmyth
side oi Manchester) §
transport
located
per
were
premises 1836,
The
see
design,
said
per the and
twenty
engine
and
S.S.
New
what
would
Nas~]th tools except
much
should
anywhere, dilemma,
the not
so
be
The problem Nasmyth , were
by
diameter o~
the
Francis
just
the
expected di splay. )
was
wrought
trunk
iron
been
found
to
'compass,
No
taken
up
'Nasmyth's O.W.R's
between Bristol
determined S.S.
was
paddle
shaft
build
Britain.
about
was such that by
O.%;.R.
Humphries, 'call'
diameter.
for
to approval
approached
he might
the
those
done
iorging.
ol 30 in.
to
Orear
especially
All
most
steamship
in
a
for cast
]he existing
of range and fall as well as want of power of versions though
a blow of adequate
was
by
to
company
the
that contemporary
enlarged
%o
fulfilled
engineer,
and
il he thought
a shaft
Nasmyth's
ladle.
The
the
their
engines.
undertake
was to forge
world,
intermediate
and asked
on
directors
yard
forged.
August.
invitation and
history oi travel
Humphries, ship
his. new
in
that they won a ZIO0 premium
ol
a
tilt hammers, 'smith's
'tilted' intensity
by
the
work
hand
see Figs.5(a) hammer'
and
and thus
to its full height was still - and indeed
of a forgin 8 was the more it became Sa@6~ed; hammer
time
accepted
led
in the
e~llent~ ,
He called
its
history'
company
west
bal~ed and the entire
Company's
was
connection
the
vertical
observed
to supply
He was called on
production
of
Railway
engines
Steamship
even the largest, forge hammer, unable
ahead
personal
that
before
hammers had not the (b)
This
wrote to Nasmyth
blow'.
Western
(his)
equip
large
the huge
could
much
81azier's
bed of brick clay
ground'.
started
proved so successful
largest
consulted
had
it
Western had a successful
so
was
that
ol the
a
7he . .site. had 'A fine
it was du~ out,
out
travelling
...
which
like
iron.
in
be the
constructing the
the Great
large
Oreat
York,
(,anal.
rental .
and
oi
at Patricro~t
and water).
ieature,
tender.
event
site
roo~
C]~allen~ and_l{espons~
The locomotives
important
the
and use in his foundry of a Salety Foundry
In the mid-]gsos Nasmyth.
risen
Foundry
A novel
The_bS_Z~m Hammer:
(rail
to have
Fi~.4.
for
a six acre
of the ground'
Bridgewater
introduction
tender
through
~.-~~,,~ jvard as
facilities
!ay below the surface buildings
thence
at the edge of the Bridgewater
~DaY 1 ~/4~ pence
close,
and
itself.
that many European museums o~ technology
the
larger
the
space for clear fall
(It may conlidently
be
will have tilt hammers on
22
This copy of the well-known painting by Joseph Wright of Derby, dated 1772, portrays in a very vivid m a n n e r the inside of an iron forge, showing a water-powered helve- or tilt-hammer at work. beating a large lump of white-hot iron. held by pincers on the anvil. Repeated heating (in 'finery' and 'chafery' hearths) and hammering were necessary to reduce the carbon content of pig iron and convert it into wrought (or malleable or bar) iron. until the 'puddling and rolling' process was developed in the later eighteenth century. The h a m m e r was lifted, as shown, by knobs or blocks of wood fitted into a circular wooden drum. fLxed on the axle of the water-wheel and thereby rotated: the weight of the hammer-fall was increased by the springy timber board fLxed above the hammer. Water-powered h a m m e r s of this type were introduced in the late fifteenth century, relieving the smith of the most laborious part of his work. See (b) for the 'oliver', an earlier treadle-operated tilt-hammer, [29]. Figure 5(a)
23
For heavy work in forge or smithy, manual labour was partly replaced by mechanical power in the form of the 'oliver', a treadle-operated tilt-hammer. The hammer, with its shaft attached to an axle, was operated by depressing the treadle; when the smith removed his foot the h a m m e r was raised automatically by the springy action of the bent pole turning the axle. This device was in use from the late Middle Ages onwards. Cf the pole-operated lathe, [29]. Figure 5(b)
24
First D r a w i n g of S t e a m H a m m e r , 24th Nov. 1839. Figure 6
25 Nasmyth telis us that he was able rapidly to sketch out a Steam Hammer with all
its. executant
details
in about
bali
an hour,
in his
Scheme
Book.
His primary aim was to lift a heavy iron mass above the ~orging and to then let
it
tall
hammer
was
~ig.6.
vertically entered
Note
sits,
the
its
hammer hammers, that,
to which
Steam
block
through
see
'Every
arrangement certainly
such
the
Scheme
as
hammer
the
head
beneath
forging. Book,
massive and
was attached
admitted
a human attendant
upon
personal
elements,
a piston
hammer-head.
guided,
his
blow-strikinz
containing block:
in
but
24
anvii
a piston
the
[2]. ) Nasmyth,
writing
nearly
detail
drawing
retains
which
i gave
to
one of the most
it,
43
iamous
years
the
steam
see
whoie
cylinder it and the
raise
the
hammer
the rise and fall oi the
<~or details
the
on which
could
drop-
1839,
rod between
piston
valve.
o~
steam
November,
T.he inverted
would be able to control
a slide
This
o!
hall
a
to
the
century
this
ago'.
'steam side'
His
later,
day
the
drawing,
in the hist.ory oI mechanical
of
wrote
form Fig.
and
6,
is
engineering
technology. 7he proposed
design was communicated
~rom his engineering
superiors-
to put the job of construction
which
to Humphries
included Chief
out to tender.
and he ~ot approval Engineer
However,
I. Brunel
-
the paddle shaft was
never forged and our story at this point proceeds in a different direction. .~ontroversies
I/ns!ish-Co~tinent.a.1 Priority
in discovery
in the minds o~ men, astonishing
example
distinguished
or invention
otherwise
mathematician,
to him and
day,
but even the time o~ day
in
research
he
for
many
with
are three which
quarrel: work.
years Oi
claim first
such
have
experiences
one
that
some
learned something
much
later
inlringed
these
nation
lamiiiarity.
claims
7here
and iluents, the
Royal
was
the
to
priorities
claiming
disputes,
visited
a great.
.just. as to %he a
assume
a priority
it is all a matter ol national
using the terms 11uxions
Leibniz
or
oi
of
international
discovered
memoir oi a
mattered
not
and
Perhaps most of us who have been
some
country
biographical
questions
[$3,
course,
An extreme
of discovery
...',
such distinctive
] can
argue
strong passions
modesty.
in r,he
'Priority
to
in the beliei
Newlon
in the i660s, his
read,
known
dimensions,
one of its 'sons' ihere
was
somewhere.
international
oi great
! recently encountered
deal
priority
raises exceedingly
seemingly
for
honour.
oI some magnitude the
Newton-Leibniz
dif~erentiai
calculus
but he did not pub!isn Society
in
London
and
ol it, either in conversation or he saw a copied paper oi
26 Newton's
work.
On
work and published ethics
of
this
resounded A.R.
returning
to continental
it - first!,
matter
is
of
long into the lgth.
Hall's
see [4]. no
further
century.
PhiJosophers
book,
st
Europe
he completed
his
own
]he quarrel about the details and concern
but
its
reverberations
This is examined in great detail
War~
Belonging
to
this
period
in
too,
there was the continuous assertion by Hooke that Newton had stolen the idea of gravitation
from him,
A personal the
[4 and 5 (p. lg)], .
experience
Ballistic
Pendulum.
Englishman,
Benjamin
!orty
or so earlier
years
of claim to priority All
Robins,
1750,
yet
another
experiments Robins
that
and
cannon balls.
Robins
century
such
be!ore
clearly with
Magnus
respect
it was
though
to
the some
not with the
Magnus
Eifect
conducted
simple
table-top
artificial to the
circumstances
shooting
of
it
if
we
attached
Truesdell
seems
was
state
about the
what
framed
as
what
large,
heavy
and certainly claims might
have well
examples
made
called
of it
Of promises.
later
o~
in
all.
Of
research
writing
it behoves us to course,
suggests
o~
names
prior
Boyle's
known
about
length
is proportional
Hooke's
law,
are
claims.
in Young's
for a
Maxwell!,
Tresca
Cardano
criterion
of
line,
The
he
first
remind
o~
outright
(1501-1570)
of solution
pursued
ol one !orm o~
- under pledge of s e c r e c y -
theft
or
saw
Nicolo
at
it
We might
and that best
Tartag!ia
cubic equation
<1904)
that English
who first reported or perceived it), cases
that
- nothin$
Huber's
adiabatic
analysts
the
ior some about
modulus.)
properly
as
namely
we may recall
[8].
since
(This will
'his'
seems
With wry amusement Clerk
are
definition
yield
Law
to load
(1944),
there
Gira!mo
to him his method discovered
well
change
in the 18@Os.
course
at
To to-day's gathering we need go no further
[7].
the Mises
Zener and Holloman,
names
though
not Hencky's!
be
use
when done
law,
is already
been
is deplorable
this
elastic
that
effects
[6].
exemplify
stress and strain. reflect
to
genuinely,
unsatisfactoriness
well
to important
simple ignorance of previous work;
intend
to
Towneiey-Power-Boyle than
of names
and through
right
sometimes
by
The mid to-late 19th century saw the name of Magnus attached
The attaching get
it
the
to this phenomenon - about the time when it interested Lord Rayleigh carelessly
of
used
In the same vein,
identiiied
in
inventor
attribute
by Robins.
clearly
the
a pendulum
and others,
as it was
lapsed
described
writers
fact,
Cassini
had
demonstrated
had already
in
by J.D.
same intention or effectiveness is. incontestable
English
but
surrounds
heat
line
described it is not [9]. of
broken
to reveal
which
he had
only later to lind it published
in
27 Cardano's
volume,
Algebra),
in 1548.
citing
Artis
oi Cardan's
only
of Hooke's
masnae
Ever since
The
third in
major
We shall
complete
this
can indeed
joint
o~
and
occasions of
section,
noting
of
much
is
in
... The
zhe U.K.
continent
knows
the same
item
both men!
probable
this
, we
confrontations
this
the
Nasmyth
that
Hurope
its
It
Of
similarly,
on the
Art
solution!
misappropriation,
the
story.
design
But
oi
before
unpleasantness
hope
arise.
a
good I
in
steam
doing
so we
in these
matters
of
some
is reminded
manner
how
of
these
comments
birth
understanding
concerning
the
example made
more
One
were treated
mechanisms,
hope
for
ol
about
how
the
the study ol the rational,
matters
-
or
his
1992 is the year that sees the olflcial
for priority
and
Great
I
well-
should
trust
be
helpful
-
[ i0].
It many,
which
men.
with.
elsewhere,
James
Since
claims
evolution
intentioned dealt
that
by
describe
economic
on
Darwin-Wallace fact
by
somewhat
whilst
is
presently
section
political
the
case
be avoided.
....
but in fact it ante-dates
recollection,
hammer.
Alsebra
name reminds me that,
is known as Cardan's joint, confusion
. ..
it has been known as Cardan's
may
finally
above,
varied
be
remarked
- and several
and important
that
the
not touched
as to warrant
issues
touched
upon
in
upon yet closely r e l a t e d a systematic
treatment
this
are so
in a longer
paper or book. The Visit by le~. Nasmyth Schneider
owner
Patricroft They
were
that
Mon.
details that
Schneider
whilst ol
plant shown
with
foreign
his
'took
see
his hosts
over
p.236,
extraordinary
Creuzot
later
and
the
French works -
single
smoothness
elsewhere,
in
France,
manager, of
the
Mon. his:
Bourdon.
to Nasmyth
constructive
Nasmyth
in his A u t o b i o g r a p h y
'a copy
of the
plan
had visit
Mon.
it was related
sketches
[ ], held
and details
ol my
6.
1842 when he was requested
the
engine
[i].
at
and
notes
had taken
on a visit
engineering
book
carelul
with the remark
marine
works
mechanical
that is, Fig.
with
foundry
iron
Scheme
visitors
Only in April, connection
iron
great
of the hammer',
his
to
the
and Bourdon from his
Nasmyth's
Bourdon
steam hammer',
also
away
Royal at
Dockyards
Creuzot
'the crank
and truth
did
large
eye
. . . had ...
to make a visit to France
and he ... been
thus learn,
had
the
after
', and in response
in
opportunity
complimenting
of a large wrought and
drifted
with
to the question,
28
A Portrait of J a m e s Nasmyth. Figure 7(a)
Steam Hammer in Full Work. From a Painting by J a m e s Nasmyth. Figure 7(b)
29
In 1839 J a m e s N a s m y t h invented his famous s t e a m h a m m e r (patented 1842), which soon displaced the old helve- or t i l t - h a m m e r s in forges. This h a m m e r was simply an inverted s t e a m - e n g i n e cylinder, fLxed on top of a massive iron frame, with a heavy iron head fitted on the end of the piston-rod. Much larger forgings could now be made, firstly b e c a u s e there was a bigger gap between the raised h a m m e r a n d the anvil, a n d secondly b e c a u s e blows of far greater force could be given, since the direct action of s t e a m w a s a d d e d to the weight of the h a m m e r - h e a d . In this early photograph, t a k e n in 1855, we see N a s m y t h himself working one of his h a m m e r s at his Bridgewater Foundry, Patricroft, n e a r Manchester, [29]. Figure 7(c)
30 'How
(wasll that crank
hammer'.
Further
.+.he result
it
urged
would
France,
revealed
of the piston
that. their
foundry.
steam hammer
'like
cartilage
packing
between
for instance
with the hammer
under the piston
bones'.
was
He saw and inspected
rod at its junction
Bourdon to put elastic
act
'It was forged by your steam
was told,
said,
He learned that they had had a few mishaps,
breaking
Nasmyth
he
of their visit to the Bridgewater
the steam hammer. frequent
... forged?',
enquiry,
On
rod,
returning
block. so that
home
from
1~asmyth lost no time in taking out a patent on his steam hamme.r and
indeed it was secured in less than two months. 'To constructed fall'.
demonstrate
one
with
a
Hand-working
piston
to
the
of
later
pieces.
performing
this
inventions between
(See
patent
for
of
armour
I
4 ft.
range
Of
applied
speed as
novel
at
the
above
the
impact
were
development
of a
3?
method
useful,
of Nasmyth
incidentally,
that
of
the
of
successfully
unpatented
Mechanical
are listed and given away
the
development
of the
pile-
admission
out
cast
iron
experiment
in May
1863
exterior
description
in June
- earned
to
contributions enjoyed
before
the
was just beaten as regards
chilled
was
shot
able
by Major
ballistics
for
to
of Nasmyth's
priority shell
for
be conducted,
Pa!liser
field.
and whose
But
technical
we
a
Palliser shall
not
accomplishments
many and various.
He was married retirement,
use
in
with
which remained
Nasmyth
the
taken
known
here
on which plate'
it was
is well
continue
for
steam
hammer,
in [ i].
to add,
advocacy
penetrating
o~n
Some
with
my
stamping for welding together- hot
Nasmyth's
Contrivances
a clear
hammer
as well
of
was intimately connected with that of the steam hammer.
the
shell
for
and
and
the
operation
operation. )
Another- matter was
controls
and the process of 3
capabilities
block
increase
improved
and Technical
We ought
and
hammer
steam
Note
pp. 38'7-431,
driver
powers
cwt.
and
die and stamp system, iron
30
accelerate
refinements
the
travel
lunar
abroad,
recreation,
a great
painting, to
1840 and retired
see
deal Yig.
science,
after
of money. F(a),
being
to
engaged
1853,
7(b)
(which
is very
- by his
He devoted
himself,
astronomy,
makin S
in
some
living to the good age oI 82.
see 5ig.
having
~ine
after several
archeology
Nasmyth
in colour),
and
he
painted
well
whilst
Fig.
F(c~ shows him 'on the job' . It
is
very
notable
-
and
very
elected to the Royal Society of London.
surprising
- that
Nasmyth
was
He was never a member of the
not.
31 Institution
of Mechanical
Engineers
knew one of its founders,
(founded in 1847,
George Stephenson,
of Civil
Engineers,
national
recognition or Royal honours.
founded
in 181F.
though
he obviously
well) or the older Institution
~urthermore
he did not receive
any
Charles Babbage wrote in his books
that these sorts of failure to recognise talent and the enterprise on which national prosperity rested, 19th century, Much edited
were far too common in the England of the mid-
[Ii, 12].
of the material
(though
but
related
lightly)
Nasmyth's biography,
by
above
Samuel
is from Nasmyth's
Smiles.
Smiles
AutsbioHraphy ,
relused
to
write
but for what reason is not known.
_fibre about the whole Story it is well known that several
scientists and engineers had long been
interested in achieving what l~asmyth proposed
in developing,
marketing and
selling his steam hammer and particularly that James Watt had envisaged for the same
purpose,
the attachment
the piston or piston rod of years before Nasmyth.
of a 'hammer or stamper
(an) engine';
... directly
to
this he made known in IF84,
55
A patent of 1806 described Nasmyth's design of 1842
remarkably closely having been taken out by W. Deverell. added
that
probably be.
Robert
The
critical
'steam hammer, efficiently
1864
on,
the by
paper was, was,
between
for
the was
reported
said
to
and
his
slide
consumption
points
Steam
Hammer,
intended
be
to
to a paper to the set
in many magazines.
Patricroft, it turned
the
was
out to
addition
of
the steam valves'
adapted
[13]
him
to
use
as
precisely
Cantreil notes on this point, the
hammer between
only
of
time
magnitude
of
the
found
of
which
was
using
at
valves of
etc.,
sLeam
read
for
as
in
in December
Patricro~t record
renewed
and them;
but
of
contact
interest
iis
Mechanics
right.
This
Wilson's original
system
workpi ece nature
pressure when
of
delicately
ali ected of heat the
between
considering
and
as
of
occasion
how the length oi time of contact
this transler the
a
to be
again adapted to place the hammer under the carelul control
transferred not
History
manager
the success
for enabling
admission
Cantreli
Wilson,
hammer-man
demanded.
sales
apparatus
continuous
further,
later,
for
later
the hammer
- effectively,
locomotives.
Institute
the
addition
self-acting the
Nasmyth's
for making
operated
facilitating railway
Wilson,
responsible
It remains to be
interfacing
them. the
el.me~.t~ ~ tubes in the middle o~ this century.
the
amount
is of course This
eificiency
of
suriaces
and
is a subject oi
heat
a •
nuclear
the that iuel
32
Figure 8
Figure 10
Figure 1 1
33 F O U ~ D A T ! OHS FOR HAKP[EI~S, [ 14 ] We length
intend
the
to
by these anvils
foundations
shock
and
possibly
designed
being
cam.
very
being da
helve-
with
hammers
height work
thick
were
billets
which
at
considerable
comparing
is
ground
relatively
conducive
t.o pres
but
and in
delivered
their to
metal
materia i
is in part transmitted
and
structures,
distant
an
locations
what
was
soon became
(or handle~
needed
accuracy, problems
a
they
in
could that
an earthoutside
oi
these
of
at
the
as 1440
shows
six
cam.
These
old
by
forging
by
that
for accurate bounce"
hammer,
impact,
the
di~ficuit
saying
As weii
types
thors
and
which in
for free
iorce
against,
became
described
the
hand-
As early
achieve
'gagged'
ordinary
hammer
[15],
it soon
to allow
For
the
water-driven
well
because
iorge
to fail.
p.!'70
and
to
raising
or allowed
is observed it
in effect,
anvil
for
drawing,
'feed'
in
it
were,
kinds,
a
them.
to
having
released gave
limited
no
hammers
different
iorgings
the helve
not
~-~=med
to
automatic:
lift
ham3~ers for large forging,
large
of
Vinci
were
their
of
blow
earliest
tripped,
A.TD., ieonardo helve
The
certainly
somewhat
to surrounding
the
though
ha~ers
dept.h and
during the forging process
conducted
that
hammers,
then
in
Vee-anvii,
itself.
it is held
latter
the
thence
being
the forging plant
a
below
and
character~~s~ics. *
Drocessin~ supported
to discuss
>'fat anvil
to the
die
also they foundations
was
re!ativeiy
iow. !~ig. 8, lb.'
is a sketch
of a drop hammer
two men were required
to an up-position'
the
height
in the plate seen conspicuously A steam Fi~.. 9.
hammer
was
]'he heavy anvil
on a concrete
~oundation
The patents
Nasmyth's
!0
hammers
s,~u~.ture. . . . . .
at the Iront and
sits, on timber
claimed of
made
i843.
be
Note
a
sketch
the
Woo]wic. h Arsenal
oI wood, concern the
ld,30, see
themselves
res.tin S
or shoulder.
themselves
they were meant of
in
with
the
to allay.
!irs+. order
for
of the anvil
and super-
Nasmyth'<_
one
cnmpanv_.. supplied
o~ to
a hammer with a tup weighing 20 tons.
We may remark hote, out. ane specify
Gave
cast pedestal
independence
. Just . . a{ter . . . his . . retir-~m~r:~, .
by using the ratchets
by Francois
did not
or the problems to
,50
the hammer
of the hammer.
baulks
with an inte[raily
o~ %'att and Deveril!
is
wi~h a ~up of weight
o! fall was controlled
patented
laying of hammer foundations Fig.
oi i550
at *..he end of the rope for bringing
foundation
that
it was apparently
details
Nasmyth's
for each forgin 5 machine
practice
to draw
design as a
34
Figure 12
Figure 14
Figure 13
35 whole.
He always
had the anvil
and hammer
on independent
foundations
and
he liked t.o ieei that everythin.$ was; 'firm'. The will
subject,
find
great
is now
left
interest
anvils and their
in
at this
point
inspecting
foundations
ol,
hammer bounce and to minimise
but
it is thought
~'igs. Ii to
14
'
or with damping materials,
the communication
the reader
note
how
heavy
aim to prevent
of forging blows to distant
i ocat ions.
The FrenchnEn~lish Controversy about th~ Invention of the ~ t e a j _ ~ r The
patent
for
taken out in 1843.
Nasmyth's
steam
hammer
expired
in
1856
Nearly 500 had by then been manufactured
i/4 million pounds-worth
sold,
customers being distributed
having
been
and more than
world-wide.
A strong dispute broke out between the French and English as to which first
invented
Cantrell
conversation writes
the
[13], at
Creuzot
Cantre!l.
about, which
The
Bourdon
impractical' A sketch
steam
hammer.
Bourdon'~ in
subject
was. a
at
and very different 1839
is
Nasmyth's
treated
alleted
Patricroft,
that
on the
from what the Creuzot Nasmyth hammer
in
depth
recollection
gross; distortion
engineers
notes
of the November
of
1842,
Creuzot
made
The
record
the
ol
the
machine
in
the
facts:,
Nasmyth
visit
by
of
device
1839,
'was.
later became_.
is seen top right
in Fig.
6,
and the bottom left sketch is said to be close to the 1842 patent..
Some of
the
LooKing
opinions
at the
i859
and
does
it
later,
now expressed device,
are different
we are
indeed
said to see
neglect
the
only
solution
~or example that the hammer block
oottom.
from those
of Cantrell.
a sketch
of
certain
of his general
idea
ieatures
came
which
is guided by slides at its top and
Could it have then been known to require ~uidance the whole length
of the
block?
small.
The
impact, load inserting
The piston
rigid
fitting
is; a
weakness
somethin~
rod,
one senses,
together
of
- though
elastic,
(on
the
there the
has a cross-sectional block
to the rod under
is a note
left).
area
on the
Nasmyth
a iar~e
diagram
implied
too
about
that
he
recogni~. =4_~.~ this: need ~or elastic cushioning and thus -'-oo~"~sted- packing when he visited ~,o surround
Creuzot the
in 1842.
guides
We believe
beneath
the
downwards again as much to protect its upward bounce. .just below Cantreil
the
writes?
(or see that)
steam
cylinder
15
the
accelerate
sprinz~ the
iup
i% as absorb any shock it might give on
]here is indeed a note too o~,
cylinder.
to
he intended
hammer
block
This is not clear to the writer.
'? spring' speciiied
on the right, at
3
We see the anvil
tons
as
block
36 surrounded nothing
by cork
to
'work
is
standard
ground
appears
vibration
steam
engine
'
...
observations
foundation suggest
and
parlance.
for use as a seal. that
- which
is a good point
in the later sketch.
exhaustively/expansively?'
probably about
to reduce
in this respect
'cut-off
There
And at the
There
at
2/3
is mention
foot
stroke'
too
of
of the right
from
(the?)
Block'.
there
is more
useful
- which
'leather'
column,
These comment
but
is a reference -
a note
few
incomplete
to the
top Figure
than the bottom~ It is not
clear
that
a chain
was
here
intended
to exist
between
a
piston rod and the piston to raise and lower them. There answers
need
are
a
to
be
~asmyth's half hour
number
of
technical
available
to
questions
assess
the
outstandin S
degree
of
for
which
originality
of
'brain-storm'.
DIES KWD KNKLYSIS:
S L I P L i l l e FIELD THEORY ( s . 1. f . t . ) :
PLANE STRAIN INDENTATIO~ AND FORGING
It hammers Russia
is pertinent
and
perhaps
to
vee-dies
similar
or comparable
helpful
historical
for
it
hitherto
ones,
This
scientific
1.
Sliu
work
to
be
is
paid
a an
evaluation
line
of p l a n e
with
that
described,
to the writer
been
field
s h o w i n g how t o
terms
Germany,
invention
central
for science/engineering
to
done thus
and
development
Europe,
the
of
U.S.A.
and
If there are claims from
pioneers who
in Britain
have performed
and France,
contributing
to
it would
a more
accurate
strain,
in various the
which
books [16,
load to cause
o f a mass o f i s o t r o p i c , Results
~or
shear
an orthogonal
to a given die geometry, and velocity
matter
of has
scientific
vee-dies only
as
been
attention
against
flat
susceptible
of
theory
o~ k, the yield
establishing
insufficient
introduction
in the last generation.
calculate
s.l.f.t..
%hat quite
the
important
Lengthy expositions
using
the
record.
It appears has
in
about
in the second quarter of the 19th century.
within these countries be
inquire
pressures
stress net
of
have l o n g been a v a i l a b l e
indentation
under
conditions
rigid-perfectly-plastic and
loads
of the material. lines
with sufficient,
(metal movement)
the
17]
of yield
are
S.l.f.t.
shear
materials
usually stress
given
in
consists
in
appropriate
(though perhaps implicit),
boundary conditions.
stress
37 for metals originated with Prandtl
S,l,f,i:..
later
with
Nadai,
in
Germany,
though
the
in the 1920s and slightly
notion
of
slip
planes
in
soil
plasticity long ante-dated that,
even back to the time of Coulomb [18].
full
of plasticity
interrogation
of
the
kind
situation
raised
below
becomes possible following 1950, after Hill had published his book,
2.
Indentin~
with
a flat
(i) A flat rigid conditions restin 8
of
on
plane
a
deformation
rigid
die, strain,
refers
to
only
[16].
die
width 2a,
is set to indent normally
a block
frictionless
The
of
material
foundation,
see
two-dimensional
of
Fig.
uniform
depth
15(a).
plastic
and under h
flow,
the
,
strain
flow
being
independent of the third dimension.) The Fig.
15(a)
indicates
an orthogonal
net
of slip lines stretching
between the indenting die, AB , and the foundation shear stress lines 45 ~ .
Using
point
left in
and
the
written
as,
between
two
pair
s.l.f,
of Hencky
die
of
can
amount
frictionless
on
the
BE,
p,
drawn
of
technical able
to
the
are
~
the yield
foundation at
used
h/a
hydrostatic
is the change
at
line
the
in connection
be
,~
and
of the plastically
the
can
stress as
the pressure
pressure
die p
upwards
to
or displacement deforming
its sides
as
+o cause this is given by
this
on Fig.
18
leads
Fig.
16
Fig.
15(a) when
h/a ~
us to conclude 8.7.
that
sideways so found
ol individual
material"
this
particles
is represented
see Fig.
15(b).
(ii) Indentation with a flat die can cause the expulsion ol material the
a
The principles of the method make it
in a velocity diagram commonly known as a hodograph,
below
in
After
integration, cause
be
change
points.)
will
to the foundation; ratio.
is
numerical which
at each
equations
in hydrostatic
respective
calculated
pressure
Hencky
and
two
manipulation
to ascertain the velocity
at all points
which
(The two
slip
parallel
is speciiic to the given possible
and
same
is
expulsion
equations
be calculated.
tangents
pressure
at
see [!6 and 17] and knowing that there is no force of AE
Z~p + 2 k , ~ p = O'
inclination certain
right
points
;
- the slip lines - meet the friction!ess
the
with specific s.l.f.i., to the
CD
indicated p/2k = that
in Fig.
1 +
the mode
~
16(a). 2.57.
o~
The
from die
Entering
indentation
here proposed prevails over that implicit
<see in
bJ O0
..j
Q
~I
(D
0
,,,,
-~
-ol
I
i~~~~3~~ i
A~
o \
o
\
\
'
\
-i
I- 0 m
]>
E-u
< II
<
~
39
Fig.
!7(a)
isosceles Plastic the
is
triangle
adaptation
of
been
triangle
off
the
indented strip was examined,
and
work-piece
itself
evidence
indented
of
the
where
smooth foundation;
it
had
at
the
a small
the side strips as they move
in the
placed
15(a),
causes
see
clear
Fig.
having
indentation
material
an
tip
of
foundation.
the
right-angled s.l.f,
outwards
If the
bottom of
h/a is in the appropriate range,
been
material
previously
seeming in
at. E.
to r~ise
to
contact
be
the
we would folded
with
the
it would seem to be a fairly clear concentrated
or
flat, defect
in the lower strip surlace. The hodograph for the s.l.f, the
large
slightly above
range
of
smaller
h/a,
die
and hence
this
pressure
plotted
of
Fig.
17(a) is seen in Fig.
particular or
on Fig.
load 18,
mode
than
would
of
does
deformation the
constitute
mode
of
17(b).
In
requires Fig.
a
15(a)
yet a third mode
of
deformation. This last mode was propounded by ~. Hill,
There
work piece,
is yet
a fourth
mode
prompted by the results
but later examined using a s.i.f, large values about
which
of
h/a
.
see [p. 14Y,
involves
ol
the
indented
oi a crude upper bound due to Dugdale,
by Dewhurst,
We shall
bending
19].
not
[19];
include
it just prevails for
here any further
discussion
t,his fourth mode.
5. For~ing betwee~ flat~_e~ded e q u _ a l _ ~ t h
~i9_~
Consider the indentation cutting or ~orging ol a thick slab as in Fig. !9. line,
Because it
the top and
follows
section 2 ( i )
that
situation
19
a s.l.f,
give the necessary
formally
slab,
stretching Evidently
shown in Fig. 20 applied
by
the
diecussed immediately before,
that
of
M K
and
M u
to move outwards,
from one die to the other - which Fig.
I~.
is able to be used to
[~QI
be
with
is to have the dies approach
6. For~in~ w i t h f l a t - - e n d e d d i e s o~ ~t~equal w i d t h : to
the centre
that
h/a.
The s.i.i,
about
identical
for any given value ol
required
p/2k
symmetrical
15.
deform this
suggests.
are
is
and for the two portions
we need to construct is what Fig.
the
above or u s i n g Fig.
To plastically each other,
bottom halves
will provide an upper bound to the load dies
to eflect
the non-identical
lorging. s.l.1's
From
the
cases
from AB
and
C.i~,
40
/
,oo,~
:
' ~'-3-7
I A PAIR OF INTERSECTING VELOCITY DISCONTINUITIES
0 2
I
Outwardly Displaced RigidBlock
T
\
Slip-line Field
CI O21D
Hill's slip-line field for indenting with two dies.
Figure 20
Figure 19
(a) f
(b)
9
)
\
]
(a) Reproduction of Nasmyth's sketch of a flat-anvil forging. (b) Reproduction of Nasmyth's sketch of a V-anvil forging. Figure 22
Cutting with opposed wedge-shaped indenters. Figure 21
41 meeting at
K
would seem to be able to provide a solution.
certainly
to be met are,
pressures
o~ course different)
right
of
BKD
calculations tY]~ . 2k
AKC
of forces
and
should
hydrostatic
be
the s.l.f,
against
pressure
from
zero.
hodosraph
Then is
above or below
K .
a
at /a
and
CD
completing
the
(normal
the
numerical
same
and i approached
whether
The ratio of die pressure
to
ratios is given in [20]
equations for angles
can be draw-n,
AB
~orces to the le~t and
provides specific angles ~or ~ K
H/al~or various
Once having solved
on
(ii) the total
for these two conditions,
The
through
and
(i) equality
The conditions
and
,
an accompanying
It is given in form for a stationary
and a top die moving down,wards in [20]'
simple
upper
bottom die
bounds for this same
situation are also given in [20]. Cutting ~rire with pliers, Fig. approaching
21
[21]
shows
one
the
another
and
conlirms
that
section
wire is substituted.
those
which
causes the
thus
the mechanisms can
prevail
compression
latter
s.l.f,
of course
a
cutting
for
the
the
cutting
reduces
case
sides
of of
pair
wide,
The situations
in
whilst
for
of
thick
the compressive
plate.
dies,
Experiment
are much the same
i~ circular
are evidently very similar to
forging. the
wedge-shaped
Approach
wedge
cause
of
the
lateral
~orce necessary
dies
tension;
to effect
the
cutting action and at the same time the tension tends to cause fracture. More realistically, this is addressed
8.
in [21,
The T e n d e n c y t o
When forging split
or crack
centre
line
closed when a certain the
small
triangle
form
of
hodograph. void
top
is
half
can
as they
open
of move
19, the effect relatively
it up,
as
is reached.
the
opposed
such
is zero.
appropriate which
that
Fig.
of a short
initial
magnitude>
on the
to
takes
and
maintaining specific
the
17(a)
s.l.f,
of the two interfaces apart,
small
If this latter
be re-constructed
on the crack,
When separation
is formed
to
h/a ratio
s.l.f,
standing
the
as in Fig.
than a certain
slab
and
cracks
or reducing
the
dies as pliers are flat-ended
22 and 23].
ovenine-uD
(of more
of
is exceeded
the wedge-shaped
stress
ratio in the
shows then the its
accompanying
at the crack
place
it
occurs
a
after
the
dies
have
all
the
solutions
approached each other by some small amount. It concerning
has
not
been
emphasised
the s.l.fs above,
in
connection
with
that every case is one which is only
II~IPROVEMENTS
IN
FORGING
AND
IN
WELDING
IRON.
tO
MR. N^S.~YTH described to the British Association, at Edinburgh, an improvement of his, which tends to increase the certainty of the production of perfectly sound and solid cylindrical forgings, especially those of large size, such as shafts, axles, and the like. In the common method, by which the metal is placed upon a fiat anvil, the effect of the hammer is to spread the mctal out in one direction, and this must be corrected by t u r n i n g it round, so that each successive blow may correct ~he spreading caused by the prcvious one. T h i s causes a
AN:.N:~..:L.
THE
SCIENTIFIC DISCOVERY:
fretting or mincing of the centre part of the metal of the shaft or other forging, resulting in a separation of the metal t h r o u g h o u t the entire
0 R,
90
ANNL'AI,
()1." , ~ ' I I . : N ' i ' I I . ' I C
I)IYCOVI.lilY.
centre, fr('qu('utlv t~, .,-uch :m ('xh.t~t as to l)eraLit tim i)assagc of air or w:tWr from c,,I t,, (',,d. 'l'l,is (,vii Mr. N. (',a'ru('ts by using a wedgesh:,l)mi, ,)r V :ulxll, lwtw~ t.n lit,. j:tw.s of wl~it'h tile u'~rk to be hamm('red is I)lace,l. In tl,is ('as(', i,~sw:ul ()t" a ten,h.ncy to spread, so as to render the c(,ntr:tl i,,)rti(,zl ,)f tl~(' metal le.,-s compact ami solid, we havc exactly the (q)l)().stl,: cli;:ct, I)esi,h.s wl~icl, tim arti(.le is m,)r(; easily kept under the hammer, and the scales or impurities which fall from the hot iron fall (low, into the apex of the V out of the way, tlauu renmvin~ th(; bh.mi..,IL :~n,I r(,u,.zlm,'ss xvl~i(.h is caused l)y the scah's collecting on the line of t}~(; :mE II and b(.iug bea1,,n into the surface of the met:t]. "]'lie (.,:Jlll~r(..,,mnl..r (.P.i.('t of ll,t: I~}oxvs, i,m, is so mu(.h enhauc('d that ;ts mu('ll can l,(' Ii:,,n;nt'r(',[ ,)lit at ,me " h(;:tt " I)y the new anvil as in tl,r(.e '" hr " hv th,. (',~,,,m,,,, ,m,'. "l'lw angle ,,f sO ~ is me,st ~em.rally sui,:~l~l, , for ilz~' iu('lin:,li,m ,,f 11,(' s~,l,,s of 111(; V" 1he edges should be well rou,,(Is,1 ,)ff and the .~urth('u ,~f tlw V sides curved in the direction of tile. a,rts ,,f the work, to the extent of one eighth of an inch in twelve incht's, s() ::s to !,~, " l)r()ud " in the centre, and ~hus facilitate the cx~ensi,m (axis-ways) of the work. One anvil will accommodate forffings of :ill ,li:~,m.u'rs, which :,re not so ]ar~'e as to rest on the UlTcr c~,rm,v.~, m,r s,, s,nall as to touch the apex. T h e s e anvils have be(;~, v('rv ~'x~,',~...iw'lv i,,~r,Hl~,'('d. Mr. N:;s~J,)')l, ul..-,, ,l,.~.,,I,,.,I ::~, i,,,i,r~,vm,w+,t i,~ wc.lding, l i e commenced by showiu,_: t!vtt Ill{' l'r~'~i,~('!~ld~.li'('t it~ w<'l,lin,M :tri,~es from the interposing (,t'.~cur[:.,: ,,r " ('in,h.r "' b:'~twuuu tht' wehlcd surfaces, which i)revent tile two ...urliv.,.s I'mm I,,.i,~u I)r[,,t,.,l~t in contact at all points. he " slabs " prodtLc'u~l uu~d~.r lh,' :wti,)a ut" a tbr~u-hammer and anvil usually have some l),,vti,us el' flu.it surlitc('s sli~:htly concave, and the concavity is (,rditmvily such tl~:Lt ll~e i~nrts w h w h come inh) contact first are the e x t e r i . r cd,~.w.~. Tim Idows (,f the hanm~er weld the parts in natural coutacl, :m(l in a tin'arty or less degree expel the seoriab which will esc;,lW as i,)ug as th,.rc is :~ 1)assagc (rot, but if, as has been said is generally the ca..s,:, ll;c t, xterior l)ortiou of the surf:aces of the slabs is the first wchled, th[. scoria; nmst remain, and no amount of h a m m e r i n g can remove th('m, :,.t,I thus ~ c have :m unsound welding. T h e remedy fi)r this great evil is a very simple one. It i~ only ncccssary so to form the surfaces to be wch]e(I that a fi'ce exit may be prescrved to thc last fi~r the scori~., and l!,is is (hme by m a k i n g one of the surfaces sligl~lly convex, s,) tits, the ~v,,hling l)e,,.,ins at the centre a n d proceeds outwards, thus fi,r('in~ out :ill tl~(' s('m'ia', and a l l o w i n g com1)h,le c o n t a c t . - (Sril ]':/~g~, r ,m,I Ar, h m , t ' s Jour~zal, ~%1,l.
YEAR-B00K OF FACTS IN SCIENCE AND AR '~'
MOST
IMPORTANT
DISCOVERIES
MECHANICS, USEFUL A R ' [ I $ , NATURAL Plill r CHEMISTRY, TOGETHER
Wlf
s
A CLA$SII~J~ IN
LIST
OF
V.MT OF
SCIENTIFIC
AND IMPROVEMENTS
ASTRONOMY, METEOROLOGY, ZOtJlX)GY BOTANY,
MZN ;
RECItNT
8CIS[NTIFIC
P A T E N T $ ; OBITtTARIES
s
SCIENTIFIC
INDEX
OF
JOURNALS~
PUJL/Cs
OF
IMPORTANT REPORTSj
IMINENT
Ps
ETC.
U D I T I t D BY
DAVID OF T H B
LAWRBNCE
A. W E L L S , SCIENTIFIC
A. M.,
8CHOOL~
AND
GEORGE
BLISS,
JR.
BOSTON: GOULD
AND 59 WASHINGTON
1851. Figure
23
LINCOLN, STREET.
IN
MINERALOGY, GEOLOGY, GEOGRAPHY, ANTIQUITIES,
CAMBRIDOE!
$
43 momentarily geometry
applicable.
After
any
small
is changed and a new s.l.f,
degree
should,
of
deformation,
field
be developed
which
strictly,
accords with the new geometry. NASNYTH AND TH~ V--AJVVIL
Nasmyth,
[i, p.420],
introduced the V-anvil
in 1845.
He gave as his
reason the fact that this form of block avoided "unsoundness" at the centre of the forging. list
of
Before quoting the remarks taken from his chronological
Inventions
recall
Hill's
dies;
this we have
cleaving
and
solution
action
Contrivances to the
problem
shown in Fig.
at
the
centre
19
ol
A
how
are
they
and
A'
is
worth
of forging block
oppositely moving zones
separated M&
and
with
and
after M L
relevant
a single
where
the
to
pair
slip-lines
intersect will be noted.
in the inset to Fig.
rapidly
while
of
and in particular the shearing and
the
tangential velocity discontinuities) particles
it
19 indicate
crossing
the
(or
Two adjacent
diagrammatically slip-lines
into
.
Nasmyth wrote: "In connection with my Steam Hammer,
great cylindrical shafts,
when employed in forging
I introduced what 1 termed my V-anvil.
Its employment has most importantly contributed to secure perfect soundness in such class of forgings. forging cylindrical shafts, anvil.
In the old system of
the bar was placed upon a flat-faced
The effect of each blow of the hammer upon the work was
to knock the shaft into an oval form, as in Fig. 22(a), and the inevitable result of a succession of such blows was destruction of the soundness of the centre or axis of the shaft.. to remedy this ~rave defect, flat-faced anvil,
In order
arising from the employment of a
I introduced my V-anvil face, the effect of
which was that the dispersive action of the blow of the hammer was changed into a converging action,
which ensured the perfect
soundness of the work", see Fig. 22(b). (Report
of Nasmy%h's
instanced in Fig. 23.)
idea abou%the
V-anvil
in popular
terms as of 1851
is
44
Radially Outward Moving R~gid Block
C_entr.a!$tationarl ~. Rllld Blockwhich ~ is notD~storted
i ]
[ /
Shp.|ineField
DieMovesInwards withUmtSpeed
~ (a)
FinalSpeedof. Outwardly DisplacedBlock
\
Unit Speed
(runch or Die)
Hodograph corresponding to the slipline field for the portion above DOD in (a); hodograph for other two portions is of similar shape.
(b) Figure 24
45 However,
given
this
observation
corresponding to that of Fig. 22(b) author to be as in Fi 5. 24(a), having
an
appropriate
how
must appear.
[24],
for three
a/r.
slip-line
field
This was proposed by the indenting or forging dies,
stress field has a 3-fold symmetry as has the velocity field of Fig.
24
peripheral
The
the
whole
the
of
ask
the
Specifically,
ratio
we
regions
predicted
over
occurs leave a central rigid core of material dictated
principally
actually
has an angle
drawn in Fig, 24(a) only
a trivial
agreement
by the geometry in the
lower
adaptation
some
which,
of
of the
p/2k
~iven
s.l.f,
versus
it is emphasised,
to
r/2a
are
bring
requires
about
admirable
but for ~our dies were used are
given
at length,
in
Fig.
8
of
[25].
by Yang [25] using the
it is not necessary to use it to obtain results.
the writer's opinion the traditional the mathematical
deformation
judgment and intuition.)
24(a)
This case has been investigated recently, matrix method though
plastic
of the diagram not
with Nasmyth's practical knowledge, results
of
to treat of this latter angle
S.l.fs similar to those in Fig. and
which
of the situation. 'third'
, but of 80~
form
In
approach is sufficiently satisfactory:
demands made on engineering students to attain familiarity
with the matrix technique are made much too high. The set of results given in the Fig. what we described earlier above, of
h/a
8, o~ Yang,
show,
interestingly,
namely that for sufficiently large values
, tensile stresses that aid cracking,
can be developed
in what
is
predominantly a compressive process. A large volume on Industrial l;or~in~ (in French), is
that
by
Codron
English-speaking of
machines
[26] ;
it
countries.
and
test
is
behaviour
engineer of the 1920s.
V-dies
the
and
manner
However,
that
seems
in
which
any
modern
in
terms
Particularly, they
act
so
recognisable
(2nd edition i923),
virtually
It contains many results
piece
professional compression.
one
unknown
in
and much discussion appropriate
to
the
some mention is made of as
to
promote
central
plastic analysis oi this
situaion is not found there. A simple
elementary
analysis
I have not seen carried
could be made to calculate the pressure along dies in Fig, il
it
25(a). were
a
AB
out but which
etc.,
is suggested
We treat sector I of the diagram of the physical set-up as case
of
extruding
through
a
60 ~ wedge-shaped
die.
The
elements supposed uniformly stressed through their whole thickness between
46
Figure 25
47 one pair oi neighbouring a Irictional
stress
dies,
~p
on the
equilibrium
equation
p
and ~ ,
with a necessary
is
easy
find
to
This approach Fig.
circumstance CC'
as
a
and
between
parallel
line;
there
centre
line. )
curvilinear
in
hill'
the
that
If.
the
that ~
pressure
ol
material
is
there
course
be
note
that
zones,
no
triangular
internally
sound core of the iorging.
'unminced'
move
the a
of
that
in the
withotlt
on the cenlre hill
triangular
just considered
marked
in
compression
iriction
straight-sided the
dies.
or to be,
outwards
case
in
(see
the
it
approach breaks down a~
real
cusp
by
note
have to appear
ol the two cases
a central
We
o3 course
the
up an
between
along AB',
straight
cannot (In
and
As indicated
Figure.
unacceptable.
of
/~
as either
the
= 0 applied
is
p
By setting
a yield criterion
oi this elementary
We
triangular
condition
ior
dies the gap would
can
the element.
the element
sector
because gap
ol
the better the smaller
for the utilisation
C'C"
or
creating
'Iriction
apply a normal pressure
introducing
boundary
we may consider
circular
ends
for an element,
will apply
25(a)
part,
a
AB and A'B',
portion
in
on or
the the
constiZute 9ig.
23),
or
Other geometr ies_
26,
the
and less so in
latter
workpiece contact
ior cases
case
a dead
interface; there
is
Fig.
when
the r/2a
ratio
is small,
27, drawn ior i/6 o5 the whole si[uation,
metal
zone extends
across
the whole
where there is, relatively,
movement
oi a block
of
the
metal
an even greater
outwards
in
oi the hammer-
relative
to
length o! the
~-c.,,~.~
die. The whole
six
and
discontinuities what
Nasmyth
discontinuities out
to
radius
which away
content of
in
not
the
tending did
to
not
destroy
single
six
meeting
cavities
as
between simple parallel
its
iorsing
on
is
for
oi
their
zone
has
the
What
has
zone
oi
intersection> been
should
dies!
in
Fig.
daylight
integral
shiited
six to
or
veiociT.y
happened
an~
centrai
be regions
perhaps
be interested
to the British Association which
remain
disintegrating
soundness.
The reader
reviewed
through
of
'mincing',
points
'mincing'
Irom the centre.
region
by
comment
(and the the
central
penetrated
of l~asmyth's report
Science
'minced'
parts
are
bali
to note
a the
for the Advancement
23.
It
contains
could
be
seen
in
relerence iorgings
to made
48
"Dead" Zone Attached ~, A
"..
" ,o~o,,or,~:~T ,: Lre Face~ /
Sco,,o,
A slip-line field (one-sixth of field, there being a six-fold symmetry), for a very rough indenter, w h e n r is m u c h less t h a n 2a, a n d the d e a d m e t a l zone e x t e n d s only over part of the die face.
o. f ~ , e. r , al
~~vf
Figure 26
r r =-
A slip-line field of the s a m e kind as t h a t in Figure 6, b u t r not m u c h less t h a n 2a.
Figure 27
49 (ii) the
In Fig.
three
faces
periphery
of
solution the
28
there are of
the
of
forging.
block.
applying
zone
the
The
because
enforced
six separate There
plastic
(iii)
Fig.
29
down
through
V-block
suggests
(sector
half-right
the
delormation
II
of
Fig.
and half-left.
The mechanics
forging
the
around
standard
the
Prandtl
not
penetrate
through
the
core elastic.
the
and
is
two to each ol
is so large that when forging,
in which
between
25(a)),
local
does
internal
a circumstance opening
regions,
presented ratio
r/2a
whole of the block but leaves the
metal
is just
solution
the
s.l.f,
two
only
there lower
is no
expulsion
inclined
upwards
and
ol
dies of the
outwards
to
the
o~ ~low in this case remains to be
explored. SINPLE This subject be a method much
is dealt with at some length in [17].
easily
comprehended
(though nearly all s.l.f, Alternative simple
little
as
s.l.fs,
bounds
in excess
The
standard
an
energy
In
Fig.
used
than
can
of those
method,
and
easily
provided
foundation}
method
It can be said to
for plane strain which is is
the
theory
of
s. 1. fs,
only upper bounds.)
one can make calculations
which
in theoretical
(i)
and
solutions are themselves
to using
upper
i0%
requirement using
BOUNDS
of treating plastic metal deformation
more
using
UPPER
give
results
(after
for die loads accurate
to
much
greater
effort
upper
bound
consists
as and
by s.l.f.t.
for
finding
one
form
a 2d
of
it
is
exemplified
in
immediately
below. enforced 1/6
of
by the the
consists material BDA'',
by
cross
tup
approprimate
or die
section,
sector
solid
block
arrow
(south-eastwards);
or shears
quantities
an
the
crosses
performed
show
one
CBD,
being
AB
pattern
of
plastic
on the workpiece.
Ill,
we
suppose
compelled it
by
slides
For just
that CB
along
flow
the
flow
to
move
as
CD.
As
the
BD , it is sheared to move as a portion of exiting
in the direction
slides
we
frictionless
whole
in
indicated
25(a)
on
of
~.
CD and
block
Work is done in shearing as the metal (ii) on crossing
to provide an over-estimate
The calculation
of the tup load on
P.u = k(CD.v c~.) +
are easily measured ofl,
BD.
DB 'v Df~ );
CB,
from the diagrams Figs.
(i) to be
P , is
25(a)
nd
(b).
50
l
1
l S(otionary
' ",:.
,'X
X
~.~
4"....~x-,'..
<.~
9
" , 4 "4-
........~..
". 2.~ : : 22".. .[4.%~. "
9
v
'..:',:~.:<"
(b) (a) Showing i n s t a n t a n e o u s slip-line field for forging with a smooth die, consisting of circular sectors a n d 45 deg. isosceles triangles. (b) H o d o g r a p h corresponding to rationalised field, a straight line "3" being s u b s t i t u t e d for the arc. Figure 28
Unit
Speed
1
IlPll 2
J~l
(b)
3
(~
(a) Slip-line field showing one indenter a n d two perfectly smooth supports. Dotted lines define the blocks of the rationalised stress field. (b) Hodograph of the rationalised field for one-sixth of the whole situation. Figure 29
51 We
~ind ~or the example shown, P
Point
D
makes
=
that if
can be chosen to be any on
p
CD = 3 units then
k(3.3~6 + 2. 4.7)/2 5 =
a minimum;
D
here
8'ik,
C~
or p/2k = i-6.
but that one is best chosen which
is not
necessarily
the
best
point
in the
example. The hexagonal the unruptured,
internal mass of which triangle
un-minced cohesive central
In some of the Figures,
OCD
is 1/6, represents
body.
dotted straight
lines could be used to provide
an upper bound in place of the curved s. ls.
An
upper
equilibrium flow
bound
force
field;
result
can
also
be
simply
obtained
by
diagram for each and every chosen polygon
these
latter
fields
should
accompany
an
drawing
an
in the plastic
acceptable
velocity
field. Fig.
25(c)
is the
equilibrium
forgi~ 8 block for the same circumstance yield shear load the
starting
is
line
BD
for
Calorimetric remaining
10'7, is retained
there
s.l.f,
is
boundary)~ but continuity heat in
dull
across
have
i/6
o2
the
whole
The normal N, and
jump
has
to
be
observed
that
of the freely emerging metal.
LI]IES
shown
that
metal
the
there
in
about
90%
reappears
slip
lines
strain.
iorgin~s.
is usually
shear
of
as
in the
mass
there
kind of slip
as bright lines
These
heat
one
set
strain~(frequently
Assuming
away from the first hot
it
the
energy
heat.
in the deformed met.aliurgica! structure. )
in ~orgin Z especially) red
which
HEAT
deforming
solutions
a finite
in deformation
transfer
end faces
studies
plastically
In most which
for
(i) above.
to the centre-line ADIABATIC
in
as in
iie!d
S , on each oi the three lines o2 triangle CBD are clear'
point
there is no force parallel
dissipated
iorce
lines
of
the
at
lines
across
the
plastic
field
there
little
time
for
they can show up
(on
is also
line,
of
is.
exist
unseen
in the
body
of
deforming hot metal. Conspicuous "9*I the
late Dr.
heat R,A.C.
lines Sister
- designated - can
'Limes oY Theri~l Discontinuity'
be seen
in [27],
the temperature
being evident because the imposed shear strain is rapid and finite.
jump
The
52
9
~
_____
The last 250 ton white hot ingot to be forged into a naval gun being s h u n t e d over Ashton Old Road in 1927 from Sir W.G. Armstrong Whitworth's North Street steel works to the Whitworth Bessemer Works forge. Sketched by F r a n k Wightman when an apprentice at Saxon's engineering works opposite. Note the traffic men (Whitworth's), the two locomotives and the heat shields. (courtesy F. Wightman) [28]. Figure 30
Figure 31
53 history
ol this topic up to the late 1960s was described
Association an
easy
of ~ngineers
matter
incidentally, These
to
Sister
estimate
were first
many
years
heat
It is
maximum
have,
these
reported
having
been
seem
only
they
mathematicians
lines
have
and scientists
the hard phase,
and dangerous
metal
become
being
infinite 25(a); were
see [27].
transfer
in the short
working
the
object
martensite)
in steel
oI report
research ol
~or
engineers
attention
by
[93.
<especially can they leave
thus constituting
a source
ol unwanted
imperlection. forged
temperatures
magnitude. there
shown
heat
in the last two decades,
Where there is sliding of metal block
using a pyrometer,
to
Heat lines can cause phase changes behind
jumps, which
in the 1860s the subject
known
to
temperature
(if we neglect
by Tresca well
to the Manchester
in a paper of the latter name.
been verilied approximately
adiabatic
term) though
by
Such
six such
lines
(of ~inite amount)
be extremely
situations
are of course
to be likely
can
over metal arise
large
along
- theoretically
typical
in the Figure.
of defect
by the
inside a
line
These
CD
latter
late Prolessor
o~
in Fig. lines
Tomlenov
oi
Moscow in the late 1950s. Strain enormously bands
and
of
horizontal
rates
as implied
can
approach
white
lines
o~
in the various infinity
near
martensite
s.l.ls
to
die
inclined
at
above,
or
tup
corners.
a
few
degrees
vary The
to
the
can often be found near to die corners.
These two issues of heat lines of nominally and
suggested
regions
discussions
of
infinite
of s.l.f.t.,
strain
rate
have
because
there
infinite temperature
never
are no
been
properly
accompanying
level
faced
in
thermodynamics
of s.l.fs. DEFECTS
i.
We
have
first
discontinuities
in
using the V-anvil
seen
flat-lorging
some
the
avoidance
was
in
of
Nasmyth's
intersecting mind
when
in order to avoid their disrupting ellects.
the latter secures central is relocated
that
distance
soundness,
he
velocity turned
to
Whilst doing
it is our belief that the unsoundness
from a block
centre
such as
and that there could be in this case as many as six sites.
D
in Fig.
24(a)
54 2. We have pointed to the possibility being
able
across slag
pull
voids.
small
apart
the
(non-cohesive)
inclusions
causing o~
to
the
which
of developing
interiaces
~aces
have
o5
o~
otherwise
'stringers'
been
extended
of
inclinations
and
-
in
It should not be too difficult
cracks
tension
closed
unwanted
the other
cracks
(or
metallurgical
course
to examine
locations
in iorging and
of
roilin~
-
the consequences
than
the
symmetrical
and horizontal. 3.
We
have
indicated
that
metallurgical
inside forgings as a consequence
de~ects
may
occur
oI heat lines. CONCLUSIONS
We have infancy
to
Ultimately Fig. it
a
the
'li~e
massive
and
unit
death' ~or
the steam hammer was superseded 31
show because how
followed
becoming shows
a remarkable
it indicates
became
of the forging
steam very
hammer
heavy
•
its
workpieces.
by other kinds ol press.
drawing
made by an apprentice
which
how massive 1orgings had become after W.W.I.
necessary
in
some
circumstances
to
separate
we and
casting
and
forging shops. We have seen some s.l.f.t, predict die
of the results
and its adaptations fairly
~orging
investigation techniques, plasticity.
accurately
- loads,
like) as
a
simplilicaions
pressures,
processes.
and elaboration, Plasticene
which modern plasticity
or engineering
There
theoretical model
~low patterns is
scope
and de~ects ~or
and experimental,
material
<using
mechanics
-
- can begin to
grids>
much
in
more
using etchin~ and
photo-
55
NOTES
I. (Sir)John LESLIE (i~66-1832) Leslie was a Scottish mathematician and natural Andrews
and
s 1804
He
Enquiry into and
was
published and
Edinburgh. made
various
arithmetic
a
which
notice
in
medallist
1809,
led
to
in
!806.
18i3 and
his
181g
James Hall
The expansometer,
Among
of ~%.
for
other
on geometry,
appointment
Philosophy at ~dinburgh University in 1819. Playiair,
philosopher
particularly
his
the Nature and Properties off Heat published
Rumford
books
received
to
the
things
in he
trigonometry
Chair
in
Natural
He was a colleague of John(?~
Alexander Nasmyth and David Brewster.
see Fig. 2, was made for display at Lesiie's lectures.
James Nasmyth,
p,109,
[i], acknowledged with pleasure Leslie's private
explanations to him ol matters in Dynamics and Mechanics.
2. The PremiumApprentice: or
than
trade',
a century
connnenced
his
pro~essional time
later
However,
and
journeymen.
sought
provoked
o! the ~actory', by
an
than
engineer
still
-
'a fee
was 1840s work
for
known
in the
engineering at
paid
a still
days
practice
who
had
instruction phenomenon when
and
entered
in
even
the
writer
many
older
industry
by
Maudslay had ceased to take on such apprentices by to
join him as many
ill
feeling
with
irregularly
of them had caused the
regular
him much
apprentices
and came wearing "gloves"'
and their
... they were very disturbing elements in the work
p. 121, [i]. army
the
with
were
'They attended
attendance was irregular
(premium S.O.E.D.)
association
Nasmyth
annoyance
1765,
engineers
virtue of it. the
Way_we were
premium apprentice
The profession more
The
colonel
working
at
an
ordnance
~actory
in the
middle of W.W. II ~or not presenting himself carrying gloves and a cane~
He
was a newly commnissioned Electrical and Mechanical Engineer.) The reader interested in socially useless conduct will find a lot of interesting 'classic'
discussion
and
absorbing
about book,
such
practices
in
the
Theory af the Leisure
now
forgotten,
Class;
once
An Ecanomic
Study aY Institutions by the American academic renegade Thorstein Veblen, !irst printed in 1899 but available in Mentor Books,
1953.
56 $. A_~_Improved Method of Y e l d i ~
Iron
Such is the title of a two-page entry, 1845
in his List
ol
Inventions
and
pp. 418-20,
Contrivances.
He
[i],
by Nasmyth in
finds
it necessary
first of all to carefully instruct his reader about the meaning ol the term clearly a new term for many.
weldin~-
in Fig.
81 he then
illustrates
the
With the aid o~ the ~our diagrams
wrong
final and perfect completion of welding'. malleable
iron possessing
hollow part, white
hot
firmly will
contain
effect
the right
way to secure
'a
(a) and
(b), first shuts up in the
scoriae or molten oxide of iron that clings tenaciously to the
metal
dislodge.
c o n c a v e form,
and
Hammering together two pieces oi
of
iron
the
surlaces'
impurity,
If now the uniting
two
from
which
pieces the
continued further
hanLmering
prepared
convex
outwards
and
are
centre
expulsion of any surface impurities,
hammering
see
(c)and
would
proceed
would
in form,
with
it
the
fail
to to
hammering sideways
(d).
This procedure Nasmyth gave to the Lords of the Admiralty when serving on a Co~smittee investigating the causes of failure in the deiecive welding of Anchors and Chain cables.
ACK]fOWLEDGJtENT The
author
wishes
to
thank
several drafts of this manuscript.
Heather
Johnson
for
typing
the
usual
57 REFEI~ENCES 1
S. Smiles
.fames Nasmyth, Engineer, an Autobiography, John Murray, London, 1885.
2
G.F. Charnock
Mechanical Technol ogy, Constable, 1916.
(Editor)
Biographical Memoirs of Fellows of the Royal Society, 1990, p. 9, Vol. 36, The Royal Society, London. 4
D. Ojertson
The Newton Handbook, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London,
5
S. Timoshenko
History of the Strength of Materials, McGraw Hill Publishing Co., 1953.
W. J ohnson
The Magnus Effect: Early Investigation and a Question of Pri ori ty, I.J,M.S., Ill, pp. 859-8?2, 1986.
C. Truesdell
Essays in the History of Mechanics, Springer, N.Y., 1968.
7.
1986.
8. W. Johnson
Some Neglected Researchers in the Field of Metal Forki oK, CAD/CAM and Y.E.M. in Metal Forming: Keynote Address: pp. 1-24, April 1987, Pergamon Press.
9. W. Johnson
Henri Tresca as the Originator of Adiabatic Heat Lines, I.J.M.S., 29, pp. 301-310, 1987.
i0. W. Johnson
Benjamin Robins: 18th Century Founder of Scientific Ballistics: Some European Dimensions, lot. European Solid Mechanics Conference, Munich, Sept., 1991, Plenary Lecture. 1 . J . I m p a c t Eng. ( I n Press)
ii. C. Babbage
Reflections on the Decline of Science and Some Causes (in England), 1830.
12. A. Hyman
Charl es Babbage, Princeton University Press,
13. J.A. Cantrell
James Nasmyth and the Steam Hammer, The Newcomen Society, pp. 133-138, Vol. 5F, 1985/6.
1982.
]4. W.C. Andrews Large Hammers and their Foundation, and J.H.A. Crockett The Structural Engineer, Oct. 1945, pp. 453-492. 15. L. Reti
(Ed.)
The Unknown Leonardo. Hutchinson, London, 1974.
16. R. Hill
Mathematical Theory of Plasticity, O.U.P., 1950, pp. 355.
17. W. Johnson and P.B. Mellor
Engi neeri ng Pl ast i cit 7, Ellis Horwood and Co., pp. 646, 1973.
58 18. J. Heyman
Coulomb's Memoir on Statics, C.U.P. , 1972.
19. W. Johnson, R. Sowerby and R.D. Venter
Bibliography o f Plane Sg.rain Slip Line Fields for Metal Deformation Processes, A Source Book and Bibliography, Pergamon Press, pp. 364.
20. W. Johnson
Overestimates of Load for some 2-d Forging Operations, Proc. 3rd. U.S. Cong. of Applied Mechanics, pp,571-579, 1958.
2!, W. Johnson
The Cutting of Round ~ire with Knife-edge and F1 a t-face Tool s, App. Sci. Rec. Series A, pp. 65-87, 1957.
22. W. Johnson and H. Kudo
Cutting of Metal Strips Between Partly RoughKnife Tools, I.J.M.S., ~, pp. 224-230, 1961.
23. W. Johnson and F.U. Mahtab
Mechanics of Cutting Strip with Knife and Flatface Die~ l. JoMachine Tool Des. & Res., ~, pp. 335-356, 1962.
24. V. Johnson
Indentation and Forging and iVasmyth's Hammer, The Engineer, 205, pp. 348-350, 1958.
25. S. Yang
Research into the GFM forgin 8 process, Jnl. Matls. Proc. Tech., 28, 1991, pp. 307-319.
26. C. Codron
Procedes Forgeage dams L 'Industri e, Michel, Paris, 1923, pp. 566, 2nd, edit.
27. G.L. Baraya, R.A.C. Slater and %4. Johnson
On Heat Lines or Lines ol Thermal Discontinuity, I.J.M.S., ~t, pp. 409-414, i964.
28. E. France
A History of Oorton and Openshaw Logoprint, Manchester, 1989.
29. H. Chaloner and A.E. Musson
industry and Technology, Vista Books, 1963.
(Manchester),
1982,
Materials Processing Defects S.K. Ghosh and M. Predeleanu (Editors) 9 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
59
Modeling dynamic strain localization in inelastic solids M. Predeleanu
Laboratoire de M6canique et Technologie, ENS de C a c h a n / C N R S / U n i v e r s i t 6 Paris 6, 61 avenue du Pr6sident Wilson, 94230 Cachan, France
Abstract
The paper reviews the main results and underlines certain fundamental aspects of dynamic strain localization modeling for inelastic solids, including the thermo-mechanical coupling. Some important points requiring further study are mentioned.
1 INTRODUCTION
Modeling localization p h e n o m e n a represents a challenge not only for mechanics of deformable media but more recently for other branches of physics concerned with the propagation of waves which could be trapped by the presence of a disorder. Indeed, Anderson's experience in 1958 on the dynamics of quantic electrons [1] has given way to experimental and theoretical investigations in optics, acoustics and electromagnetics. Firstly, this phenomenon has been observed in manufacturing operations. Under severe loading conditions the deformation of a solid localizes in certain zones, often in the form of narrow bands, where the thermal energy also accumulates increasing the temperature eventually to the point of phase change in the material. Henry Tresca [2] reported in 1878 the apparition of heat lines in the form of a white cross during hot forging in a platinum bar and later in 1922 and independently by Massey [3] (see for additional references Johnson's paper [4]). Zener and Hollomon [5] observed such white bands during punching operations in a steel plate and proposed a simplified analysis. Commonly, these strain localization bands are termed shear bands, although whithin them not only shearing but a more complex deformation regime is present. When it is assumed that the material is non-conductor, then the shear
60 b a n d s are called adiabatic shear bands (see review paper by Rogers [6]). Generally, the shear bands are planar and their width can only reach a few microns. This intensive concentration of deformation and heat induces high gradients of certain kinematical and dynamical fields. That has led to model the shear bands as singular surfaces across which these fields suffer jump discontinuities. The localization zones can also have a spherical aspect as reported by Pr6mmer [7] for the explosive compaction operation of tungsten powder. It has been observed that the converging shock waves concentrate the deformation in a very small point wise region (0,12 mm diameter) where the temperature reaches the melting point of the material (-- 3000 ~ C). The localization phenomena can occur inside the body but also at the boundary, which in general induces more complex effects. Considering the loading conditions, we can distinguish: i) Quasi-static localization which appears during slow processes for which inertia effects may be neglected. In certain cases, the strain-induced thermal effects may also be ignored and consequently the material behaviour is defined in isothermal regime. ii) Dynamic localization occurs during high-energy rate processes such as explosive forming operations, high-speed machining, punching, ballistic impact and power laser. In this case, phase-changes can appear in material structure whithin the localization zones called transformed zones or transformed bands. Otherwise, it is a mere deformation band. In both cases, within the localization zone, the material suffers important micro-structural modifications generally leading to failure. Consequently two deformation regimes take up within the body, one within the localized zone and the other outside it. This fact requires the eventual use of two different constitutive models for material behaviour, which obviously induce an additional difficulty in analysis. The experimental studies indicate that the nucleation and evolution of the localized zones present a great variety of patterns, depending on the loading conditions, material behaviour and body geometry. So, the localized zones once initiated can develop without traversing the material (non-propagating or stationary bands) or they propagate inside the solid (propagating or PortevinLe Chatelier's type bands). Geometrical and kinematical characteristics of the shear bands such as width, spating and propagating speed can be measured. Modeling localization phenomena to predict all the aspects mentioned above represents a formidable if not impossible task at this point in time. Most studies published up to now introduce simplifying assumptions such as : quasi-static approximation by ignoring inertia effects, adiabacity hypothesis for heat transfer, one-dimensional analysis and simplified constitutive models for material behaviour. Two kinds of approaches have been followed in localization modeling: One, which aims to characterize the material sensitivity to the formation of localization zones, by using field equations inside the body but ignoring boundary conditions (material type analysis). The purpose of such analysis is to find the necessary a n d / o r sufficient conditions (criteria) for the existence of shear bands.
61
The second approach aims to capture the localized zones by solving a mixed initial-boundary value problem. The parametric studies of the analytical solutions (when these can be obtained !) or numerical simulations also permit to discuss the constitutive sensitivity to localization effects. The present paper reviews the main results and discusses certain fondamental aspects of dynamic strain localization modeling for inelastic solids, including the thermo-mechanical coupling. The governing equations are presented in Section 1 for inelastic materials with internal state variables, by using a Lagrangian formulation. The well-posedness conditions for a mixed initial-boundary value problem are defined in Section 2 and some pathological cases are cited such as : non-existence of a global solution, blow-up of a local solution, hyperbolicity loss of the governing equations. Section 4 is concerned with the use of singular surfaces in modeling localized bands, either as stationary discontinuity solutions introduced and developed by Hadamard [8], Hill [9], Mandel [10], or as possible bifurcated solutions in respect to the homogeneous ones, as proposed by Rice [11]. This approach has been extensively employed for the last decade, for the case of quasi-static strain localization in hyperelasticity and time-independent plasticity. Necessary and sufficient conditions have been formulated for strain localization inside the body [12] and at the boundary [13]. Mesh-dependence of the numerical solutions in the presence of a strain localization in such materials has multiplied the studies in this field. New specific regularization procedures have been proposed to avoid these difficulties by i n t r o d u c i n g non-local constittttive models [14], [15], second gradient deformation theory [16] - [18] or viscoplastic models [19], [20]. The study of localization problems by examining the stability of the solutions in Liapunov's sense is presented in Section 5. Currently, the linear perturbation method is used for the sake of simplicity in the case of applications. That way, the linear or infinitesimal stability is established, which obviously does not imply general Liapunov's stability. Other limitations and critical aspects of the method are also mentioned. In Section 6 some numerical results are reviewed : they are intended to capture the dynamical strain localization including thermal effects. However, a lot of work remains to be done in this field to establish the most convenient numerical strategies and elucidate the sort of mesh dependence in terms of constitutive models, material characteristic length and stress level.
2 - GOVERNING
EQUATIONS
Let us consider a deformable body B, in which a material point M occupies the position X in a reference configuration (30 in the three-dimensional Euclidian
62 space E and the position x in the configuration Ct at time t. po and p respectively denote the mass densities of the body in the configuration Go and Ct. The motion of the body with respect to Go is described by a mapping X, defined by x = % (X, t) on Go (B) x I, where I is a time interval. The deformation gradient relative to X is noted by F = 3 X / 3 X with det F ~ 0 and the particle velocity is noted by v = )~- x where a superposed dot denotes the material derivative with respect to the current time holding X fixed. The thermo-mechanical behaviour of the body can be generally defined, in terms of F, temperature field 8, temperature gradient g = 38/3X and a n u m b e r of internal state variables ot, by means of the constitutive relations w
= ~ (F, O, g, or) m
n = n (F, 0, g, ~) P = P (F, 0, g, 0t)
(1)
q =q (F, 0, g, o0 ot = ot (F, 0, g, or) where ~ is the specific free energy, q the entropy, P first Piola-Kirchhoff's stress tensor and q the heat flux. From Clausius-Duhem's inequality 9
1
-~,-n 6 + - - p / : - ~
1
PO Po 0 we can deduce [21] that
gq>0
(2)
~ = ~ (F, 0,~) q = -3V ~ (F, 0, ~)
P = Po ~
(3)
(F, 0, cz)
i.e. the material behaviour is defined by k n o w i n g the free energy ~ , the constitutive relation for heat flux q and the evolution equations for the internal state variables or. The internal variables, which can be scalar, vector or tensorial functions are introduced to describe the inelastic properties of the solid (plasticity, viscoplasticity, hardening, softening, etc...) and eventually thermal properties. The balance equations in the Lagrangian formulation are
63
p det F = go (mass balance equation) div P + Po b = Po 4, ( m o m e n t u m balance equation)
(4)
Po ~ + Po (f~ T1 + 0 rl) - P f: + div q = Po r (energy equation) w h e r e b denotes the body forces per unit mass and r the heat sources per unit mass. The E u l e r i a n f o r m u l a t i o n of the d y n a m i c c o u p l e d t h e r m o - m e c h a n i c a l p r o b l e m can be obtained from the equations (1) - (4), by using the mechanical and thermal fields defined on the current configuration as for instance the rate strain tensor D = sym (1h F -1) and Cauchy's stress tensor ~ = 1 / d e t F PF T. To the equations (1) - (4) one must add the initial conditions at t = to and the b o u n d a r y conditions on the boundary of the body. Two kinds of problems can be posed : i) Initial value problems (or Cauchy's problem) for which the solution is required at t e I w h e n initial data at to < t are known, for X e E and regularity conditions at oo are imposed. ii) Mixed i n i t i a l - b o u n d a r y value p r o b l e m , for w h i c h the solution verifies : a) initial conditions at t = to and b) b o u n d a r y conditions on the b o u n d a r y 3B e x p r e s s e d in terms of the d i s p l a c e m e n t s or velocities on one part 3Bu of the b o u n d a r y and in terms of the tractions on 3 B o : the t e m p e r a t u r e on 3B 0 and the heat flux on 3Bq with 3BuU3B o = 3B and 0BoU3Bc~ = 0B. It is w o r t h n o t i n g that for certain c o n s t i t u t i v e relations, the s y s t e m of e q u a t i o n s (1) - (4) is a first order quasilinear s y s t e m of partial differential equations, written in the matrix form A1 (W, X, t) Wt + A2 (W, X, t) Wx + A3 (W, X, t) = 0
(5)
where W (X,t) is a column vector grouping all u n k n o w n variables of the problem and Wt and Wx are respectively the temporal and spatial derivatives of W.
3 - WELL-POSEDNESS
OF THE PROBLEM
A mixed initial b o u n d a r y value problem is well-posed in H a d a m a r d ' s sense [22], if the data of the problem are such t h a t : i) A solution exists and is unique and ii) The solution continuously depends on the data. Othervise the problem is said to be improperly-posed. At this time, the question of the existence and unicity of the solution of the d y n a m i c coupled thermo-mechanical problem in three-dimensional cases is still
64 open, even for particular classes of inelastic material models. For the first order quasilinear system in one space dimension it has been proved that Cauchy's problem has a unique solt~tion if the system is hyperbolic and regularity conditions of Lipschitz's type are verified by the matrix coefficients of the system and the initial data [23], [24]. Ne\'ertheless, these conditions do not ensure a global solution. The following pathological cases will be cited : a) Recent studies [25], [26] have s h o w n that for r a t e - d e p e n d e n t materials exhibiting thermal softening, the solution of the dynamic shearing problem can be local and in this case it considered in [25] and
blor~,s-llp
in finite time. c~ = g (0, 7) ~' has been
b = G ~ + h (0, ~)
(6)
in [26], where c~ is the shear stress, 7 the shear strain, ;[ shear rate strain, G , elastic shear modulus, H and h material functions. b) The change of type of go\'erning partial differential equations can lead to a i m p r o p e r l y - p o s e d problem and that is associated with the occurrence of a localized m o d e of the soltttion. Thus,in [27], [28], considering the onedimensional constituti\'e relation (s = F (7), the solution is analysed when the tangent m o d u l u s F' (7) goes to zero. In this case the speed of propagation of a disturbance vanishes, and that is associated with a trat~pi~ly, of the wave, which accumulates deformation in localized zones. For elastic-plastic solids with nonassociative flow rules it has been sho~vn [29] that a loss of hyperbolicity of the governing equations system could occur. Also for isothermal regime, in [30] it is shown that for rate-dependent solids characterized by g = al (E, S) IZ + a2 (E,S) where S = F-ip is the second Piola-Kirchhoft's stress tensor, E = 1/2 (FTF-1) is the L a g r a n g i a n strain tensor, and al, a2 are material fonctions, the g o v e r n i n g equation system may loss hyperbolicity for large strains and stresses. Exemples can also be given for quasi-static problems when the governing system may lose ellipticity and the problem becomes improperly-posed.
4 - SINGULAR
SURFACES
9W A V E S
AND
STATIONARY
DISCONTINUITIES
The solution of an initial-boundary' value problem for a solid subjected to dynamic loading or rapid structural modifications (apparition and growth of cavities and cracks) may present singular surfaces S, across which certain field variables a n d / o r their derivatives ha\,e jump discontinuities. Let f (X, t) = 0 be the Lagrangian representation of the regular surface S and U = - i : / I g r a d f I denotes the speed of propagation of ~.
65 A singular surface which traverses the material is n a m e d wave. A nonpropagating singular surface, always consisting of the same particles is called a material surface or a stationary discontinuity. For a material singular surface, represented by f (X) = 0, the speed of propagation is zero. The existence of stationary discontinuity was associated which the m e c h a n i s m of the strain localization phenomena. A singular surface S is of the first order with respect to the motion Z (X, t),if Z is continuous across S but at least one of their first derivatives F and v and the t e m p e r a t u r e 0 suffer jump discontinuities across S. The propagating singular surfaces of the first order are shock waves, across which the normal velocity is d i s c o n t i n u o u s and vortex sheets, across which the tangential velocity is discontinuous. Across a material surface of the first order, the velocity v is continuous, but at least one c o m p o n e n t of the d e f o r m a t i o n g r a d i e n t F is discontinuous. A singular surface S is of the second order with respect to the motion Z (X, t), if v, F, 0, o~ are c o n t i n u o u s while their first d e r i v a t i v e s m a y exibit j u m p discontinuities across S. The propagating singular surfaces of the second order are called acceleration waves. On a material singular surface of the second order, the acceleration Z and the velocity gradient are continuous, but grad F is discontinuous. When f} and grad 0 are continuous the acceleration wave is called homothernlal [31], [32]. The existence and nature of the singular surfaces for a particular problem are d e d u c e d by using the geometric and kinematic compatibility conditions [31] [x]=-Ua, [ F ] = a | [x]=U2a, [1~ ] = - U a | 1 7 4 1 7 4
(7)
[0] = - U b, [grad 0] = bn where [~] denotes the jump of ~ across S, a and b are respectively the mechanical and thermal amplitudes of the wave, U is the speed of propagation and n the unit normal vector to S. Similar relations are added for internal parameters. The dynamic compatibility relations are deduced from the balance equations (4) using the relations (7). Using compatibility relations we deduce that the amplitude and the speed of propagation of the acceleration waves are completely determined by solving a homogeneous linear system of algebric equations of the form A8=O (8) where A is a linear map and 5 is a N - d i m e n s i o n a l vector g r o u p i n g the mechanical, thermal and eventually internal variable a m p l i t u d e s of the discontinuities. The necessary propagation condition is given by the following equation det A = G (U) = 0. (9)
66 It is to be noted that the map A depends on the propagation speed U as well as on the material properties and direction of propagation. The corresponding conditions for the existence of a material singular surface (stationary discontinuity) are obtained from (9) by putting U = 0, that is G ( U = 0 ) =0 (10) From a physical point of view only waves with real amplitude and real speed of propagation are significant. The acceleration waves in elastic-plastic materials for isothermal regimes have been studied in [33] - [39], [9], [11]. In this case the linear map A is expressed by A = Q - U 2 pl (11) where the second-order tensor Q is called the elasto-plastic acoustic tensor. For the rate-independent plastic material defined by 6 = H grad v, where H is the elasto-plastic m o d u l u s tensor we have Q = n H n . The analysis of the wave propagation is reduced in this case to a spectral problem : to determine the proper values and proper vectors of Q. The major symmetric conditions for H ensure that the cubic equation (9) has three real roots [9]. More generally the strong ellipticity condition for Q, i.e Q k,, )~k ~m > 0 for arbitrary non-vanishing vectors ~, and n, provides, for any given propagation direction n, positive squared speeds c o r r e s p o n d i n g to each real acoustical direction. The ellipticity condition is equivalent to the condition according to which the symmetric part of the acoustic tensor is positive-definite for every propagation direction [32]. The condition for possible material surfaces (stationary discontinuities) is obtained from (11) putting U = 0, i.e detQ=0 (12) It is w o r t h noticing that the above condition formally coincides with that for quasi-static strain localization, where the inertia terms are dropped. However, in this case, it is an acceleration wave (in quasi-static regim) for which the speed of propagation may not vanish. The study of the acceleration waves in inelastic solids with internal variables, under thermo-mechanical loadings has been considered in [40] -[47]. The results obtained show that the wave pattern is strongly influenced by the mechanical model considered but also depends strongly on the assumptions concerning the heat conduction. The simplest constitutive law for the thermal flux (Fourier's law) leads to infinite speed of propagation of the thermal disturbances. The analysis of the possible coupled acceleration waves shows that [f~] = [grad O] = 0. An alternative constitutive law for the heat conduction has been proposed in order to obtain a finite speed of propagation by Maxwell [48] and Cataneo [49], [50] in the form ~Cl +]3q =-k grad O (13) Generalized heat conduction relations in differential or integral forms have been considered in [51] - [54]. Also in [45], [55], thermal internal variables have been used to describe the heat conduction properties. In general, for the inelastic solids defined by constitutive relations of the form (1) an algebraic equation of the eighth degree has been obtained [45], [55] for the
67 p r o p a g a t i o n condition. It leads to non-symmetric acceleration waves mainly caused by thermal effects. In [45] it is shown that, for the solids characterized by (1) under the following hypothesis, all acceleration waves are real: m
m
1. The fonctions ~ and 0~ verify an inequality of elliptic type in Bowen's sense [56] in the neighbourhood of a strong equilibrium state [57] 2. The acceleration waves are symmetric 3. ~3g 1 (F, 0, g, o~) = 0
(14)
4.0t (F, 0, g, 0t) = bl (F, 0, 0t) g + b2 (F, 0, v.) (15) where bl et b2 are material functions. Additional conditions on the material characteristics are indicated to obtain four positive squared speeds of propagation. Necessary and sufficient conditions are given in [47] for the existence of real propagation speeds of acceleration waves in viscoplastic materials for Cataneo's heat conduction law. In quasi-static cases, conditions for the existence of a singular surface of the second order across which the velocity gradient exhibits j u m p discontinuities have been given for r a t e - i n d e p e n d e n t materials and Fourier's conduction law in [58] for finite strains. Such conditions were deduced also in [79] for more complex constitutives law for elasto-plastic materials, including kinematic hardening effects and the softening effect generated by d a m a g e process. Possible localization phenomena at the b o u n d a r y of the body and the thermo-mechanical coupling effects are discussed in [59] for small strains. It is worth noting that an alternative approach of the singular surfaces of the second order may be adopted by using the characteristic manifold theory [60]. It is known that the acceleration waves is a subset of the characteristics family.
5- INSTABILITY AND LOCALIZATION
The instability p h e n o m e n o n which can occur at different length scales of the material structure during a deformation process are considered to be the principal factor for the onset of strain localization. Among various definitions of stability, Liapunov's concept seems to be the most adapted to localization problems. It permits to appreciate the b o u n d n e s s in time of a p e r t u r b e d or bifurcation solution, or to estimate the tendency an imperfection has to localize the deformation and the heat energy. Let W (X, t) be all field variables which define an evolution of the body over time interval I and W* (X,t) a perturbed solution. It is said that the solution W is stable in Liapunov's sense [61] if, for each positive number e, there exists a positive number 8 such that
d o [W (x, t0)- W*(X, to)] < 8 for any W*, implies
(16)
68
d [W (X, t) - W* (X, t)] < E, (17) where d,, denotes a measure of the distnricr between initial disturbances and d a measure which defines the departure o f W' from W over the entire time interval I. The use of two metrics d,, and d has been introduced by Movchan [62] but currently in applications d,, is considered equal to d . An evolution which is not stable is called instable. If the time interval I is semi-infinite, then W is asymptotically stable if there exists 6 > 0 such that d [W (X, t) - W* ( X , t)] -+ 0 as t 4 00 for each W' which satisfies d,, [W (X, to) - W*(X, t,,)] < 6. I t is worth noticing that to characterize an evolution W as stable, it is necessary to verify the relations (16) - (17) for n n y departure W'. On the contrary , to characterize an evolution as instable it is sufficient to show that there exists l i t /cost oiic disturbance which does not verify the stability criterion. Secondly, the diagnosis of dynamic stability or instability depends o n the choise of the measures d,, and d. Schield and Green [63] and Koiter [64] have given various exemples of evolutions which are stable with respect to certain measures but instable with respect to others. The application of the above stability criterion to non-linear problems is not easy.Instead, the linear perturbation method is used, by linearizing the governing equations for small perturbations about a basic solution (which may be for instance, a space homogeneous solution). I t is obvious that the linear or infinitesimal stability as defined do not imply the general stability concerning the non-linear evolutions. The studies devoted to localizatiotl phenomena by using a linear stability approach are concerned with : a ) The analysis of the sensitivity o f certain inelastic materials, defined by their constitutive relations and balance equations in exhibiting stability or intability phenomena. The boundness of small perturbations of the progressive plane wave type W' = W,, exy [i 5 x.11 + ct], W,, = const, W,, n = 0 (18) is examined determining the necessary conditions on the material characteristics for the onset of shear bands. The boundary conditions are ignored. In 1651 viscoplastic materials are considered exhibiting strain and strain-rate hardening, pressure hardening and thermal softening. The analysis is concerned with two and three-dimensional flows, taking thermo-mechanical couplings into account. b) The analysis of linear stability of the solutions and the localized modes for the mixed initial-boundary value problems. Most studies are concerned with one and bidimensional analysis, i n p a r t i c u l a r ivith the simple shearing problem for materials governed by the cnnstitiiti\,e relation : 0 = p (0) ym 'y" [66] - [721 (see also for reference the review paper b y 8ai [73]).I t has been deduced, by using a linear perturbation method, that instability does not always imply localization. The relative linear perturbation analysis used in [69], permits to establish more edifying relations concerning both phenomena.
69 A complete analysis of the dynamic shearing problem for elasto-viscoplastic solids, defined by (6) and including thermo-mechanical coupling is given in [26]. The existence, uniqueness and continuous d e p e n d e n c e of the solution are proved. The stability analysis is performed by studying the behaviour of the perturbed disturbances represented by Fourier series. In order to point out the mechanism of strain and thermal localization, the following stability parameter is introduced
P(t) = c~~ H0 (O~ c~~ + [H (O~(t), c~~ "c~ Hc~ (O~ c~~ - 4H0/O~ c;~ (O~ c~~ where H(O, c~) is the plastic component of the shear rate, c~~, O~ the homogeneous solution Ho, Hc~ are the deri\'ati\'e of tlne fttnction H in respect to O and c~. The comparison of P(t) with a qt~antit\' d, depending of material constants, the thickness of the layer and the \'elocit)' of the upper edge of the layer, permits to deduce the following conclusions regarding the beha\'iour of the perturbation" 1. If P(t) ___d for all t ~ [T1, T2], the n o n - h o m o g e n e o u s p e r t u r b a t i o n of the h o m o g e n e o u s solution will not increase on [TI, T2] and strain localiztion does not occur during the time inter\'al [TI, T2]. 2. If there exists n >_ 1 such that n2d < P(t) < (n + 1)2d for all t e [T1, T2] then we can expect that the strain xx'ill be localized in the points where ]cos krrx[ takes its maximum value, that is, at the point Xi.k = i/ k \vith 0 < i _< k and 1 < k <_ n. If n is small then we can expect that the strain will be localized in some special zones. For instance for n = 1 the strain can be localized at the boundary and for n = 2 at the b o u n d a r y or in the middle. If n is large then there exists no special zones where the strain will be localized and the localization of the strain will depend on the shape of the perturbation at t = T1. The above analysis performed on the time interval [T1, T2] is significant for the behaviour of the solution on [0, T] if the [T1, T2] is sufficiently large. Numerical simulations are in agreement with qualitative results obtained by linear stability analysis.
6- NUMERICAL STUDIES Many basic aspects concerning the apparition and evolution of localization p h e n o m e n a eventually till failure are expected from c o m p u t e r numerical simulations. These will permit to abandon the simplifications as adopted in most approaches, such as 9one-dimensional analysis, adiabacity hypothesis, quasi-static a p p r o x i m a t i o n , simplified constitutive models, simplified failure criteria u n c o u p l e d with constitutive relations via damage theory. Obviously, more complete numerical studies require theoretical developments concerning the existence, unicity and stability of the solution but also computational strategies well a d a p t e d for capturing narrow localized zones which eliminate mesh dependence effects.
70 There are very few numerical solutions to the fully coupled two or threedimensional thermo-mechanical problems including inertia forces. Recently Batra and Liu [74], [75] have studied the dynamic plane deformation problem for a block subjected to shearing or compressive loadings on the top and bottom faces. The material behaviour is described by a thermally softening viscoplastic model defined by c~ = - p (p) t + 21.1D, 2, = ~]3i; (1- v0)(1 + r
(19)
1 ID =~ tr D '2, p(p)= K(p--- 1)
where o 0 is the yield in simple tension or compression, v is the coefficient of thermal softening, r and m are the strain rate sensitivity parameters, ~c represents the volumetric behaviour modulus, D' is the deviator of rate strain deformation tensor D, 6 Cauchy's tensor. Fourier's law of heat conduction is used but the solution is obtained only for adiabatic regime. The finite element solution is obtained by using the updated Lagrangian formulation, which permits to solve the severe distorsion of the mesh within the strain localization zone more easily. The material inhomogeneity is modeled by introducing a p e r t u r b a t i o n of temperature at the center of the block or assuming a weak material characterized by a reduced flow stress. The numerical simulations show that a shear band initiates from the region of the defect and propagates in the direction of maximum shearing stress. In [76] the same problem is considered for a bimetallic body containing an elliptical void. The sites where the shear bands initiate are described along with their propagation directions. Though the inertia effects are ignored, the papers by Lemonds and Needelman [77] and Anand et al [78] present interesting results concerning the influence of various features of the material behaviour on the initiation and growth of the strain localization zones. There also appears in [77] that heat conduction delays the apparition of shear band localization and influences the shear band thickness, in terms of isotropic and kinematic hardening characteristics. To avoid the pathological aspects in numerical t r e a t e m e n t w h e n rateindependent elastic-plastic solids are considered (ill-posedness of initial- value problems, mesh-sensitivity), Loret et Prevost [20], have proposed a visco-plasticity regularisation procedure for one-dimensional problems, by introducing a new parameter (relaxation time) into constitutive model. In [79], these procedure is extended to three-dimensional problems and the authors can capture the shear bands during the dynamic deformation of a elastic-plastic regular parallelipiped.
7 - CONCLUDING REMARKS The present paper has underlined some features in the phenomenological m o d e l i n g of the thermo-mechanical localization u n d e r high-rate loading
71 conditions. The review of the main results in this field shows that important advances have been brought in by the use of the discontinuity surface theory, linear stability analysis or numerical simulations. However, most studies are based on simplifying assumptions for the sake of simplicity that lead to partial or non clarifying conclusions. Secondly, many questions remain open, either from a mathematical point of view, or concerning the physical background used in modeling localization phenomena. Here are some of them : a. Generally, strain localization is associated with a softening of the material, in particular thermal softening, which, included in the constitutive model, can lead to a improperly posed problem. In this case, examples have indicated a possible non-existence of a global solution, a blow-up of a local solution and a bifurcation of solutions in localized modes which can be instable. In non-linear d y n a m i c elasticity and in r a t e - i n d e p e n d e n t plasticity, general equivalence theoremes establish connections for isothermal regimes between the existence of real waves, the uniqueness and the stability of the solutions. Such m a t h e m a t i c a l results do not exist for general t h e r m o - m e c h a n i c a l problems defined in section 2. b. As it has been shown, the use of second order singular surfaces has permitted to characterize the sensitivity of the material model to localization and also to mathematically characterize the governing equation system. The first order singular surface theory has been less used until now. But it could bring new advances concerning the jump discontinuities of velocity and thermal fields (for the case of generalized conduction heat models). c. In localization problem analysis, the stability has been approached essentially by using the linear perturbation method. But linear or infinitesimal stability does not i m p l y the general (non-linear) stability. The latter d e m a n d s more complicated computational methods in applying general criteria of stability based either on a kinematic concept (of Liapunov's type) or on an energetic one. d. Previous analytical solutions and a few the influence of the various aspects of the and d e v e l o p m e n t of localization zones hardening, thermal softening, smoothness sensitivity. On the other hand, there remain to point c o n d u c t i o n models, tensile stress states, loadings.
numerical simulations have stressed material behaviour on the occurence such as : isotropic and kinematic of the yield surface and rate strain out the role of inertial forces, heat hydrostatic stress and multi-axial
e. A more complete analysis of tile late stage of the localization process requires the following i n g r e d i e n t s i) A constitutive characterization of tile material, differing wether it refers to the inside or the outside of tile localization region.
72
ii) A modeling of the e\ entiial phase transition in the material. iii) A failure criterion, defined, for Instance, via coupled d a m a g e modeling.
8 - REFERENCES
1 P.W. Anderson,Phys. Re\,., 109 (1958)1492. 2 H. Tresca, Proc. Inst. Mech. Engrs 30 (1878) 301. 3 H.F. Massey, Proc. Manchester Assoc. Engrs (1921) 21. 4 W. Johnson, Int. J. Mech. Sci. 29 (1987) no 5 301. 5 C. Zener arid J.H.Hollonwn, J. Applied Physics 15 (1944)22. 6 H.C. Rogers,Ann. Rc\.. X1atc.r. Scl. 9 (1979) 283. 7 R. Priinimer, In. Esplosi\.r IVtJlding, Forming a n d Compaction, T.Z. Blazynski (ed), Applied Science I'iiblishers, London, (1983) 369. 8 J. Hadamard, Leqons sur Li propagaticm des ondes et les equations d e I ' h y d r o d yn a m iq i ie , Pa L'i 5, 1O(13. 9 R. Hill, J. Mech. Phys. Solids, 10 [1%2)1. 10 J. Mandel, I n Rheology a n d Soil h4echanics, J . Kravtchenko a n d P.M. Sirieys(eds), Springer (1966) 58 11 J.R. Rice, In Theoretical a n d Applied Mechanics, W.T. Koiter (ed) NorthHolland, Amsterdam, (1976) 207. 12 G. Borre a n d G. Maier, hleccanica 24 (1989) 36. 13 A. Benallal, R.Rillardon et G. Gt~!,nionat,C.R. Acad. Sci. Paris 310 (1990), serie I1 679. 14 Z.P. Ehzant, T.R. F;elyt~chkaa n d T.P. Chang, J . E I I ~ I I h4e~h. ~. ASCE 110 (1984) 1666. 15 G. Pijattdier-Cabot and Z.1'. I h a n t , J. Engng. Mech. ASCE 113 ( 1987)15 12. 16 H.L. Schreyer a n d Z . Chen, I n ConntitLiti\,e Equations: Macro a n d Computational Aspects, K.J. I\Jilliam (ed) ASME, New-York, (1984) 193. 17 N. Triantafyllidis and E.C. Aifantis, J. Elasticity 16 (1986) 225. 18 D. Lasry and T. Belytschko, Int. J . Solids Structures 24 (1988) 581. 19 A. Needleman, Comp. hleth. Appl. Mrch. Eng. 67 (1988) 69. 20 B. Loret a n d J.H. Prevost, Comp. Meth. Appl. Eng. 83 (1990) 247. 21 B.D. Coleman a n d M.E. Gurtin, J. Chem.Phys. 47 (1967) 597. 22 J. Hadamard, Lectures on Cauchy's problem in linear partial differential equations, IVover, New-York 1952. 23 P.D. Lax, Corn. Pure Appl. k t h . 6 (1953) 231. 24 A. Jeffrey, @uasilinear hy~wrL7oIicsystems a n d waves, Pitman Publishing, London 1976. 25 A.E. Tzavaras, Arch. Rational Mech. a n d Anal. 99 (1987) 349. 26 I.R. Ionescu and M. Predeleanii, Quart. J. Mech. Appl. Math. 46 (1993), 437 27 D.C. Erlich, D.R. Curran a n d L.. Seaman, Further development of a Cornpiitationall Shear Rand hlodel SRI R e p . AMMRC TR 80-3 (1980). 28 F.H. W u a n d L.B. Freuncl, J. blech. Phys. Solids 32 (1984) 119.
73
29 B. Loret, J.H. Prevost and 0.Harireche, Eur. J . Mech. A/Solids 9 (1990) 225. 30 I. Suliciu, Meccanica 19 (1984) 38. 31 C. Truesdell and R.E. Toupin, The classical field theories Handbuch der Physit III/l, Springer Verlag, Berlin, 1960. 32 C. Truesdell and W. Noll, The nonlinear field theories of mechanics, Handbuch der Physik 111/3, Springer Verlag, Berlin, 1965. 33 T.Y. Thomas, J. Rat. Mech. Anal. 7 (1958) 893. 34 J.W. Craggs, In Progress in Solid Mechanics vol. 1I.N. Sneddon and R. Hill (eds), North-Holland Publ. Comp.,Amsterdam, (1961) 143. 35 J. Mandel, J. Mecanique, 1 (1962)3. 36 T. Tokuoka, Mem. Fac. Engng, Kyoto Univ. 33 (1971) 193. 37 T. Tokuoka, Int. J. Non-Linear Mech. 13(1978) 199. 38 M.M. Balaban, A.E. Green and P.M. Naghdi, Int. J. Engng Sci. 8 (1970) 315. 39 J. Mandel, In Mechanical Waves in Solids, J. Mandel, L. Brim (eds) Springer-Verlag, Berlin (1976) 40 W. Kosinski and P.Perzyna, Arch. Mech. 24 (1972)629 41 Y. Tokouka, J. Engng. Math. 8 (1974) 9. 42 M. Piau, J. MPcanique 14 (1975)l. 43 I. Suliciu, Arch. Mech. 27 (1975)841. 44 W. Kosinski, Arch. Mech. 27 (1975) 733. 45 M. Mihailescu and I. Suliciu, Int. J. Solids Structures 12 (1976)559. 46 V. Kukudzanov, Arch. Mech. 29 (1977) 325. 47 K. Woloszynska, Arch. Mech. 33 (1981) 261, 451. 48 J.C. Max\vell, Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. London 157 (1867) 49. 49 C. Cattaneo, Atti. del Sem. Mntem. Fisico, Univ. di Modena 3 (1948) 83. 50 C. Cattaneo, C. R. Acad. Sc. Paris, 247 (1958) 431. 51 M.E. Gurtin and A.C. Pipkin, Arch. Rat. Mech. Anal. 31 (1968) 113. 52 N. Fox, Int. J. Engng Sci. 7 (1969) 437. 53 D.B. Bogy and P.M. Naghdi, J. Math. Phys. 11 (1970) 917 54 I. Muller, Arch. Rat. Mech. Anal. 40 (1971) 55 W. Kosinski, Field Singularities and Wave Analysis in Continuum Mechanics, PWN, Warszawa (1986). 56 R.M. Bowen, J. Chem. Phys. 49 (1968) 1625. 57 C. Truesdel, Rational Thermod~~iiarnics Mc Graw-Hill, New-York, 1969. 58 M.K. Duszek and P. Perzyna, Int. J. Solids Structures 27 (1991) 1419. 59 A. Benallal, C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris, 312 (1991) 117. 60 R. Courant and D. Hilbert, Methods of Mathematical Physics, Interscience Publishers, New-York, 1966. 61 A.M. Liap~inov,ProblPine g6116ral de la stabilite d u mouvement, Memoires de 1'Acad. Imp. Sci. St Petersburg VIII, ser. 22, n"5. 62 A.A. Movchan, Appl. Math. Mech. 24(1960) 988. 63 R.T. Shield and A.E. Green, Arch. Rat. Mech. Anal. 12 (1963) 354. 64 W.T. Koiter, Over de stabilitrit \'an het elastish evenivicht. Thesis, Delft, 1945. 65 L. Anand, K.H. Kim a n d T.G. Sha\vki, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 35 (1987)407.
74
66 R.J. Clifton, Report to the NRC Committee on Material Responses to Ultrasonic Loading Rates, 1978. 67 Y.L. Bai, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 30 (1982) 195. 68 T.J. Burns and T.G. Trucano, Mech. Mat. 1 (1982) 195. 69 C. Fressengeas and A. Molinari, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 35 (1987) 185. 70 T.W. Wright and J.M. Walter, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 35 (1987) 701. 71 C. Fressengeas, J. Physique 49 (1988) C3-278. 72 H.TZ. Chen, A.S. Douglas and R. Malek-Madani, Quart. App1. Math. XLVII (1989) 247. 73 Y. Bai, Res. Mechanica 31 (1990) 133. 74 R.C. Batra and De-Shin Liu, J. Appl. Mech. 56 (1989) 527. 75 R.C. Batra and De-Shin Liu, Int. J. Plasticity 6 (1990) 231. 76 R.C. Batra and De-Shin Liu, Int. J. Solids Structures 27 (1991) 1829. 77 J. Lemonds and A. Needleman, Mech. Mat. 5 (1986) 339, 363. 78 L. Anand,A.M. Lush and K.H. Kim, In Thermal Aspects in Manufacturing, M.H. Attia, L. Knops (eds), PED- vol. 30, A.S.M.E., NewYork, 1988. 79 M.K. Duszek, P. Perzyna and E. Stein, Int. J. of Plasticity 8 (1992), 361. 80 O. Harireche and B. Loret, Eur. J. Mech., A./Solids 11 (1992), 733.
Materials Processing Defects S.K. Ghosh and M. Predeleanu (Editors) 9 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
75
VOID GROWTH UNDER TRIAXIAL STRESS STATE AND ITS INFLUENCE ON SHEET METAL FORMING LIMITS R.
C.
CHATURVEDI
DEPARTMENT OF M E C H A N I C A L E N G I N E E R I N G INDIAN INSTITUTE OF T E C H N O L O G Y , P O k l A I ,
BOMBAY
-
4.00076,
INDIA
ABSTRACT The presence of voids in sheet meta 1 has been e x p e r i m e n t a l ly c o n f i r m e d [2]. Increase in s i z e of t h e s e v o i d s with plastic strains has been e x p e r i m e n t a l ly confirmed by Parmar and Me[ for [2] and modeled by R i c e and Tracey [12]. Bridgman [14] h a s s h o w n t h a t the s t r e s s s t a t e in the n e c k of a b i a x i a l ly s t r e t c h e d sheet becomes triaxial and analyzed the stress state. R a o [17] u s e d the I i n e a r i s e d v e r s i o n of R i c e a n d Tracey's void growth equation to develop void growth and coalescence model and incorporated the triaxial stress state for p r e d i c t i n g its i n f l u e n c e on f o r m i n g limits. Padwal et al. [22,23] further extended the analysis to cover both the I inearised and non-linearised versions and gave an analysis for
plastic
instability
as
wel I
as
the
prediction
of
forming
I imits. It is observed that the use of non-I inearised model predicts a much sharper growth of void fraction especially when the magnitude of relative hydrostatic stress component is large. The forming limits predicted at t h e e q u i b i a x i a l strain end are appreciably lower compared to t h o s e f r o m M.K. models. It is a l s o o b s e r v e d t h a t an i n c r e a s e in v o i d f r a c t i o n , as well as i n c r e a s e in v o i d s i z e at c o n s t a n t void fraction reduces the forming I imits. This model also predicts a dependence of the forming I i m i t s on s h e e t thickness and this is m o r e p r o n o u n c e d compared to t h a t f r o m the m o d e l of R a o a n d C h a t u r v e d i [10].
1. NOTATION a
C
- Half - Stress
1
-
D1 C
vo
,
C
v
the
sheet
concentration
Volume g r o w t h
-
thickness
Initial
and
at
the
center
of
the
factor.
rate.
current
volume
fraction
of
voids.
neck.
76
-
f
Equivalent Harciniak inhomogeneity index.
- Marciniak inhomogeneity index due to voids.
f V
- Characteristic width
‘0
(initial) of inhomogeneity.
m
-
Strain rate sensitivity.
n
-
Strain hardening exponent.
R
-
Radius of curvature at the neck.
r3
- Thickness dimension of the void.
Ri
- Radial velocity
to* t
-
Initial and current thickness of the sheet.
vo v
-
Initial and current volume of the voids.
2
- Distance of the element from the center of the neck.
a
-
Stress ratio ( a / u
-
Relative increase of a void volume.
I
of void surface in the i direction.
2
1
).
-
Principal strains.
_E.E
-
Equivalent strain and strain rate.
E.
-
Strain rate field far from the void. - Pre-strain.
E
0
c1
-
Constant
P
-
Strain ratio ( % / e l ) .
ul,u2,u3
-
Principal stresses.
0 , am
-
Equivalent and mean stress.
U
-
Superimposed hydrostatic stress.
-
h
-
U
T
0
(9 ) (v)
in the expression for Dl.
Variable tensile stress across the neck.
-
Yield stress in shear.
-
Subscript denoting values in the necking band.
- Superscript denoting values related to voids.
77
2. INTRODUCTION A major contribution to the understanding of the onset of instability and prediction of FLD was made by Marciniak and (M-K) Cll. They introduced the concept of Kuczynski inhomogeneity factor and proposed a theory for predicting sheet This theory has been most widely metal forming I imits. accepted theory for predicting sheet metal forming limits. The inhomogeneity factor in M-K theory was taken to be in the form of a localized thickness reduction. However, inhomogeneity in actual material is very much different from the assumed thickness inhomogeneity. It is well known that the sheet in unstrained condition already contains some randomly located voids. The amount of voids or the so called void fraction (ratio of void voll~me to total volume under consideration) can be measured by scanning Parmar and Mellor 121 provided electron microscope ( S E M ) . experimental proof of void growth during plastic straining by measuring the relative changes in density of a sheet specimen subjected to plastic strain. They also provide an analysis of the phenomenon of coalescence of neighbouring voids in the shape of parallel long cylindrical holes under biaxial stretching. According to M-K analysis, when the material deforms, the localization of strain and formation of neck starts at the particular band, which has the lowest effective thickness due to the largest Concentration of voids. Since the void growth depends on strain, the rates of growth of void fraction inside and outside the band become different due to different strain states in these two regions. Due to this differential void growth, the effective inhomogeneity gets enhanced and gets superimposed o n the thickness inhomogeneity caused by the necking process. The localization of strain in the neck results in the continued growth of voids leading to their coalescence and finally to fracture. A number of attempts C3-101 have been made to express the assumed thickness inhomogeneity in M - K model in terms of Al 1 inhomogeneity caused by variation in void concentration. these studies showed that the overestimation of I imit strains near the equibiaxial tension state, using M - K analysis C l l , is significantly reduced in analyses considering the void growth. The growth of a void under biaxial stresses has been modeled previously by McClintock C111, and Rice and Tracey 1123. McClintock studied the growth of a cylindrical hole in a hardening plastic matrix, while, Rice and Tracey studied the growth of a spherical void in a non-hardening plastic matrix. Since voids inside a material are more likely to have a shape nearer the spherical than the cylindrical, the Rice and Tracey model is nearer the correct state than the McClintock model. Schmitt and Jalinier 1 1 3 1 proposed linearization of the Rice and Tracey model and obtained a simple analytical expres6ion for the change in volume fraction due to the growth of a void under biaxial stress as,
C
V
= C
vo
exp (1.92 ( 1 + p)
el)
(1)
Rao and Chaturvedi 1 1 0 1 used this void growth equation and proposed the simple statistical analysis of voId distribution to define the M-K material inhomogeneity as, fV
-
= 1
3
11’2
(2)
~ t ( 1 - c ~ ~ ) ~
[ r3 cvo
with the initial void fraction distribut.ion of voids as,
in
the
neck
due
to
random
Once the process of straining starts, the volume fraction of voids, both inside and outside the necking band, increases A t this stage the according to Eqns ( 1 ) and (3) respectively. inhomogeneity is contributed both by physical thickness inhomogeneity due to necking process as we1 I as thickness inhomogeneity due to the differential void fraction levels inside and outside the necking band, and is as given below, f =
g/t C(1
- CVB 1
/
(1
-
Cv)1
(4)
Schmitt and Jalfnier 1131 had assumed a biaxial stress state in the neck while proposing Eqn ( 1 ) f o r the change i n volume fraction due to the growth of a void. However, the stress state in the neck which is the critical region for C l 4 1 and that is an important instability is triaxial Bridgman C141 Shortcoming of the analyses so far discussed. has analyzed the triaxial stress state in the neck of a sheet undergoing plastic deformation in plane strain and shown that the stresses vary across the neck (Fig. t . ) following the equation : ox =
v1
[
1
+
log C 1 + (a/2R).( 1 - 2’
/
a2 f
1
]
(5)
This implies the presence of stresses along the thickness direction, and the stress state bacomes triaxial. This triaxial stress state in the neck can be determined b y swperimposing a hydrostatic tension component on the applied G i a k i a l stress field. Tt,is component. varies over the thickness of the neck, i t is ze113at the surface of the sheet ( 2 . a ) and attains its highest v a l ~ ~of, e Ch = C
1
log
c 1
t
a
/
2R
I
( 6 )
at. the center of the neck ( Z = O ) . The growth r a t e of voids wil I be influenced by the presence o f this hydrostatic stress component which -varies a c r n s 5 t h e thickness o t sheet. A s explained e a r i ier, the hydrostatic tensile stress, E q n ( 5 ) , varies a c r o s s the n e c k (Fig. 11. The average value of this tensile stress can b e calculated by Cl41,
79
I' Figure 1. Cross section of the inhomogeneity in the sheet.
a
av
= l/a S
a
dz
x
0
(7)
which gives, U
x av
= el Cf
where C
is a correction factor, given by.
f
C f = ( 1 + 2 R / a )'I2
log Cl+a/R + ( 2 a / R
(lta/2R )ll2]-
1
(8)
and o,is the major principal stress i n the neck, calculated disregarding the presence of three dimensional stress state. Thus during the necking process stress in the neck gets enhanced by this correction factor, due to the presence of three dimensional stress state. Based on the experimental observation of Bridgman 1141 and Hecker 1151, Ran and Chaturvedi C161 proposed the following simple relation for calculating the function a/R in Eq. ( 8 1 , a/R = K
-
1
(
tB/t
They also proposed that the factor K could constant and calculated using the relation,
K = 2
(
t
0
/
lo
1
2
(9)
be
considered
a
(101
This implies that K depends on the thickness t o of the sheet and width of inhomogeneity 1, ( F i g . 1). The value l o can be
80 considered a characteristic of the material dependent method of production but independent of the thickness. Thus i t is clear from the above discussion that the of voids in the neck considering the effect of triaxial state will b e different than that assuming plane condition in the neck.
on
the
growth stress stress
3. MODELING OF THE VOID GROWTH The change in volume and shape of the cavity initial radius R o e is given b y Rice and Tracey 1133 :
Ri
/
Ro =
E.
C1
+
D1
with
-
an
(11)
E
C 4 E i ia a deviatoric term ass?ciated w i t h the change in shape D,E is a spherical term associated with no volumetric growth.
D,
with the isotropic volume expansion. fol lowing expression C 1 2 1 :
D l = 0 . 5 5 8 sh
+
0.008 y ch
is
given
by
the
[$*]
o = ( a + o + o )/3 m 1 2 3
where, and
=
y
-35/(E1-E3)’
with
the
rule
f
1
> = E 21= € 3
Considering the presence of hydrostatic tensile stress ( o h ) superimposed on a biaxial stress state the new values of principal stresses become.
and a; =
(13)
0
h
Hence, a
m
= a /3C1+at3(ffh/0)l 1 1
Using Von
-
-
(14)
Mises yield function we get,
1/2 a = o [ 1 - a + a 2 1 1
(15)
81 and 7
2
0
112
(16)
= a C ( l - a + a ) / 3 1 1
Substituting a,,,and becomes, D 1 = 0.558 sh Cpl
t
in equation
T~
r
0,008
( 1 2 ) the expression
f o r D1
(17)
ch Cpl
where,
5
P =
c 1 - a + a2 Ill2
substituting
a = ' e w e 2 +P
get,
and -3p
(18)
for - 0 . 5 < = p < = 1
y = 2+p
In the expression for D, i f the second part which is negligible is not considered then we get,
Dl = 0.558 sh Cp1
(19)
Schmitt and Jalinier 1131 have linearieed the expression f o r Dq and arrived at the following relationship, D1 = 0 . 6 4 Cpl
(20)
In this paper both the linearised and
non-linearised forms of
D 1 are used. The radial deformation o f the void is given by, E"
-
(211
= C1 E. + D1 E
Substituting the value of €"
=
c1
€. t 1
0.64 C 1
t
p
and using
( 7 ) and ( 9 ) we get,
+ ( 2 t p ) (ah 1 0 1 1
The relative increase of void volume is, a
v
=
"ro=
exp (eV t 1
Using ( 1 1 ) we get,
5
t
1
E
1
122)
82 a
= exp
[ 1.92
I1
t
p +
( 2 t p ) (uh /
CY
1
11
E
(23)
1 1
When o ~ / # I = 0, the above expression reduces to the equation derived by Schmitt and Jalinier 1131 for the growth of a void in a plastic matrix under biaxial stress. Rao 1171 used the linearised form of D,, Eqn (20) and derived Eqn (23). For non-linsarised form of D,, Eqn (23) becomes,
a
= exp
[ 1.674
sh C ( 1 + p , ( 2 + p ) ( ~ ~ / # l ) ) /* A A1
where, A = C ( l + p t p2 )/311/2* 2 The above expression indicates growth is strain path dependent.
that
*
the
(24)
el]
rate
of
void
4. PLASTIC INSTABILITY The growth of a void in the neck of a sheet under superimposed hydrostatic tension, Eqn (241, is used to study its influence on the sheet metal forming limits using the M - K analysis incorporating the correction for triaxial stress state in the neck, Eq. ( 8 1 , and void growth equivalent of Marciniak inhomogeneity index, Eq. (4). I f the number of voids are considered to be constant i.e. the nucleation of new voids is ignored, the growth of a void fraction, as derived b y Schmitt and Jalinier C131, using non-linear form of Rice and Tracey C121 equation is, C v = C v o exp C1.674 sh C(l+p)/Al
*
A
*
ell
(251
where, A = C(l+pp2)/311/2 * 2 The growth of voids outside the groove will follow this rule. However, because of the superimposed hydrostatic tension due to triaxial stress state in the neck, the void growth in the neck will follow,
as derived earlier, Eqn (24). The equivalent flarciniak inhomogeneity index, given by Eqn (41, has been incorporated in the M-K model C11, instead of conventional physical thickness inhomogeneity and the equation describing the process of groove formation is derived as,
where, B = 314 Cp2/C1+ptpzll assuming isotropic material. The solution 118.191 of Eqn ( 2 7 ) enables determination of the limiting strain, when the function d G d z B a p p r o a c h e s zero.
83
5. RESULTS AND DISCUSSIot(( The changes in relative void volume with strains are given in Figs 2 and 3 for the equibiaxial and uniaxial tension path respectively, as a function of the relative hydrostatic stress, for both linearised ( Eqn 23) and complete (Eqn 2 4 ) forms of Rice and Tracey's equation. The curve for a value of u h / u , = O also represents the Schmi t t and Jal inier I131 void growth it can be seen from these figures that the equation (Eqn I). relative void volume and their growth rate increases with higher values of superimposed relative hydrostatic tension. The differences are more pronounced in equibiaxial tension than in uniaxial tension. The linearised model predicts a slower growth and growth rate, compared to the actual model and the difference is more for larger magnitudes of superimposed relative hydrostatic tension. The void growth is faster in equibiaxial tension compared to uniaxial tension. The effect of hydrostatic tension in the neck at constant inhomogeneity factor is to enhance its load carrying capacity. The growth of voids reduces the magnitude of the factor and has limits. The analysis an opposite effect on the forming presented above is therefore essential to get even a qualitative comprehension of the influence of the triaxial s t r e s s state. Fig. 4 shows t h e predictions o f this analysis i n curve C. It can be observed that the predictions are higher in plane strain region and lower in equibiaxial region than those by the M-K analysis (curve BI. The M - K analysis (without the consideration of void growth), using the influence of triaxial stress state only (curve A ) C l l , predicts values which are higher than usual M-K model throughout the range. The contribution of the analysis, based on triaxial stress state alone (curve A ) , is to predict a variation of forming limits with sheet thickness as observed experimentally by Haberfield and Boyles C201 but not predicted by conventional M - K analysis. However, as the values predicted are higher than those predicted b y M-K analysis, throughout the range, it does fl-K analysis, vir. not remove the other limitations of predicting higher forming limits i n the equibiaxial region C18,211. The analysis, considering void growth under triaxial stress state, corrects for this trend too. The effect of initial void fraction on l i m i t strains is Lower levels of initial void fraction shown in Fig. 5 . increase the l i m i t strains significantly. The effect of initial void size, at constant void fraction, on forming limits is shown in Fig. 6. This shows that the forming limits are higher when void size is smaller. Fig. 7 shows the e f f e c t o f increase in sheet thickness on l i m i t strains for various strain ratios. I t can be seen that the l i m i t strains increase significantly, with increase in the I t can also be observed that the thickness of the sheet. predictions based on the present analysis show relatively faster increase i n forming limits, with higher sheet thickness, as compared to the void growth model of Rao and Chaturvedi
84
8.0
&
i,i d
0 b,
i
,
,, r
tm
6.0
C~ O ~rhlo"I
I~I > 4.0
0.00 0.25 o 0.50 Linearized model Non-linearized model 9
9
I,i n,"
N
IZ
2.0
0.o
_ I . . . .
0.2
o.o
i
i
0.4
I
0.6
I
o~8
MAJOR TRUE STRAIN
Figure 2. Influence of superimposed hydrostatic tension on the change in volume of a void ( ~ =1.0).
8.0
a'h/~
W
9
9 [3
d
0
b,
6.0
o >
0.00 0.25 0.50 Lineerized model Non-lineorized model
,1:3
Ld > 4.0 I--
laJ r
.,.,.,J..13
2.0
. ~ ~ ~ : ~ 0.0 0.0
O.2
-~~''-~'4~-~'~
0.4
,
0.6
0.8
MAJOR TRUE STRAIN Fiqure 3. Influence of superimposed i n v o l u m e of a void ((~ = - 0 . 5 ) .
hydrostatic tension on the change
85 1.0
Z os o9
0.8 /
Ld 0.6 OC F-Qf O 0.4
/
n=0.22 R=I.0 ~o=0.006 /
/
0.2
/
/ O0
0.0
I,
0.4
MINOR TRUE STRAIN
Figure 4. Comparison of different models. A. M-K model c o n s i d e r i n g B.
C.
(f=0.99,
M-K
M-K
model
toll o = 0 . 8 ) .
0.8
forming
Iimits
triaxial
stresses
predicted
using
[ 16]
(f=O. 99).
model considering void growth under s t r e s s e s (Cvo=O. O l , r 3 / t = O . O 0 1 2 5 , t o / l c = 0 . 8 ) .
triaxial
[lO]. This rate of increase in f o r m i n g limits, with thickness, p r e d i c t e d by the p r e s e n t a n a l y s i s appears to b e t t e r a g r e e m e n t w i t h the e x p e r i m e n t a l observation (Fig. H a b e r f i e l d and B o y l e s [20].
sheet be in 8) of
6. CONCLUSI ONS The consideration of void growth with the presence of triaxial s t r e s s s t a t e p r o v i d e s a t h e o r y w h i c h can e x p l a i n the i n c r e a s e in f o r m i n g l i m i t s w i t h i n c r e a s e d s h e e t t h i c k n e s s w h i c h is not d o n e by the c o n v e n t i o n a l M-K a n a l y s i s . The void model also provides a phenomenological basis for the inhomogeneity factor
in
M-K
analysis,
The
I inearised
version
of
Rice
and
Tracey's equation, though accurate in the absence of hydrostatic stress component, is not a d e q u a t e in its p r e s e n c e at a p p r e c i a b l e levels. T h e a n a l y s i s a l s o p r o v i d e s a good b a s i s for p r e d i c t i n g forming I imits e v e n t h o u g h in the c u r r e n t form it i s o n l y for an i s o t r o p i c m a t e r i a l .
86
o.5 | Cvo-O.O02 z n.,i-u)
0.4
/ o=0.01
0.3 I--
o
,/
/
/ ,/
0.2 /t
0.1
Cvo=O.05
/
/
OOooF1
I
I
0.4 0.2 0.3 MINOR TRUE STRAIN
0.1
0.5
igure 5. Effect of initial void fraction on forming limits. n=O.22,R= 1 ,f= 1 , C o = 0 . 0 0 6 , r 3 = 0 . 0 0 1 , t o / I o = 0 . 6 )
o.~ / Z
J
r3=0.0002 0.4
/
t-U')
ILl 0 . 3
/ 0- - ) 0.2
005
./ ,/ o.1
I-
o.o ~ - / 0.0
[
/ 0.1
0.2
!
0.3
I
MINOR TRUE STRAIN
0.4
igure 6. Effect of void size on forming limits. n - O . 2 2 , R = 1 ,f= 1 ,Co=O.O06,Cvo=O.O 1 , t o / I o = 0 . 6 )
0.5
8?
__Z < 1.2
PRESENT MODEL VOC MODEL (10) 1.0
I'-" (/) o3 o3 LIJ
z
....-.,,o'-"
.....
.
1.0
o3
0.5
0.4
0.5 0.0
o T l-ILl :3 ~: I--.-
0.31
0.0 0.0
F ;
i--T
0.4
;~176 1.2
0.8
to/Io
Figure 7. Effect of sheet thickness on limit strain for various strain ratios (n=O.22,R= 1 ,f= 1,Co=0.006,r3=0.001 ,Cvo=O.O02).
Z
1.2
1.0
I-.o3
(/) o3 ILl Z Y (O T" I--LLI Z3 eI--
0.61 0.47 03
0.28 0.4
0.0
0.0
0.4
1
o18
SHEET THICKNESS
I
~.2 (ram)
Figure 8. Effect of sheet thickness on limit strain for various strain ratios (Experimental data for EDD stabilized steel (20)).
88
REFERENCES 1.
Marciniak, Z., Kuczynski, K. and Pokora, T. : 'Influence limit of plastic properties of a material on the forming diagram for sheet metal in tension', Int. J . of Mechanical Sciences, Vol. 1 5 , pp. 7 8 9 - 8 0 5 , ( 1 9 7 3 ) .
2.
Parmar, A. and Mellor, P. B. : 'Growth of voids in biaxial Int. J. Mech. Sci. V o l . 2 2 , pp. 1 3 3 - 1 5 0 , stress fields', (1980).
3.
Needleman, A. and Triantafyllidia, N. : 'Void growth and local necking in biaxially stretched sheets', Trans. ASME. J. of Eng. Materials and Technology, Vol. 100, pp. 164- 169,
(
1978).
4.
Chu, C.C.and Needlewan, A. : 'Void nucleation effects i n of Eng. Trans. ASME. J . biaxially stretched sheets', Materials and Technology, Vol. 1 0 2 , pp. 2 4 9 , ( 1 9 8 0 ) .
5.
Gurson, A.L. : *Continuum theory of ductile rupture by void nucleation and growth - Part I - Yield criteria and flow rules for porous ductile materials', Trans. ASME J. of Eng. Materials and Technology, Vo1.99, p p . 2 - 1 5 , ( 1 9 7 7 ) .
6.
Jalinier, J.H. and Schmitt, J.H. : forming-11-Plastic instability", Vol. 30, pp. 1 7 9 9 - 1 8 0 9 . 1982).
7.
Kim, K.H. and Kim, D.W. : 'The effect of void growth on Int. J. of Mechanical the l i m i t strains of steel sheets', Sciences, Vol. 25, pp. 2 9 3 , ( 1 9 8 3 ) .
8.
Barata Da Rocha, A., Barlat. F. and Jalinier, J . M . : "Predictions of the forming l i m i t diagrams of anisotropic National Sci. sheets i n linear and non-linear loading', Eng., France, ( 1 9 8 4 ) .
9.
Tai, W.H. : 'Prediction of l i m i t strains in sheet metal Int. J . of Mechanical using a plastic damage model', Sciences, Vol. 30, No. 2 , pp. 1 1 9 - 1 2 6 , ( 1 9 8 8 ) .
10.
Rao, U . S . and Chaturvedi, R.C. : 'Sheet metal forming limits under complex strain paths using void growth and coalescence model', Trans. ASME, J. Eng. Materials Tech., V o l . 108, pp. 2 4 0 - 2 4 4 , ( 1 9 8 6 ) .
11.
McClintock, F.A. : 'A criterion for ductile ASME. J. the growth of holes', Trans. Mechan ics, pp. 3 6 3 - 3 7 1 , ( 1968 )
.
12.
damage i n sheet metal Acta Metallurgica,
fracture by of Applied
Rice, J . R . and Tracey, D.M. : 'On the ductile enlargement J. of Mechanics and of voids in triaxial stress fields', Physics of Solids, Vol. 1 7 , pp. 2 0 1 - 2 1 7 , ( 1 9 6 9 ) .
89
13.
Jalinier, J.H. and Schmitt. J.H. : 'Damage in sheet metal forming - I - Physical behauiour', Acta Metal lurgica, V O I .30, pp. 1789- 1798, ( 1982I .
14.
Bridgman, P.U. : Studies in large fracture, McGraw Hill. pp. 32, (19521.
15.
Hecker, S. S. : 'Experimental studies of sheet stretch-ability', Formability analysis - Modeling and experimentation, Proceedings of Symposium held in Chicago, Illinois, pp. 150, (19771.
16.
Rao, U . S . and Chaturvedi, R.C. : 'A new model for predicting forming limits for strain rate sensitive materials', Manufacturing Simulation and Processes, ASME, pp, 119-127, (19861.
17.
Rao, U.S. : 'Sheet metal forming limits under simple and complex strain paths", Ph.D. Thesis, 1. I.T., Bombay, ( 1985 I .
18.
Padwal, S.B. and Chaturvedi, R.C. : 'Prediction of sheet metal forming limits", Proceedings The 2nd International Conference on Automation Technology, Taipei, Taiwan, July 1992.
19.
Padwal, S.B. and Chaturvedi, R.C. : .Computer aided International determination of forming l i m i t diagram., Conference on CADICAM, Robotics, & Autonomous Factories, 1. I.T. New Delhi, India, pp. 527-538, (19931.
20.
Haberf ield, A.B. and Boyles, M.U. : 'Laboratory determined forming I imi t diagrams', Sheet Metal Industries, v o l . 50, pp. 400, (19731.
21.
Padwal, S.B. and Chaturvedi, R.C. : .Prediction of forming limits using Hosford's modified yield criterion', International Journal of Mechanical Sciences, V o l . 34, No. 7, pp. 541-547, (1992).
22.
Padwal, S.B., Chaturvedi, R.C., and Rao, U . S . : .Influence of superimposed hydrostatic tension on void growth in the neck of a metal sheet in biaxial stress fields. Part - I Modelling', Journal of Materials processing Technology, Val. 32, N O S . 1-2, pp. 91-98, (19921.
23.
Padwal, S.B., Chaturvedi, R.C., and Ran, U.S. : 'Influence of superimposed hydrostatic tension on void growth in the neck of a metal sheet in biaxial stress fields. Part - 1 1 - Plastic Instability", Journal of Materials processing Technology, Vol. 32, Nos. 1-2, pp. 99-107, (1992).
plastic
flow
and
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Materials Processing Dcfects S.K. Ghosh and M. Predeleanu (Editors) 9 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
91
The Prediction of Necking and Wrinkles in Deep Drawing Processes Using the FEM DOEGE, E.; EL-DSOKI, T. and
SEIBERT,
D.
Institute for Metal Forming and Metal Forming Machine Tools, University of Hannover, Welfengarten 1A, D-30167 Hannover, Germany Abstract
Starting out from elementary analytical approaches, the authors discuss the main factors affecting failure by necking and wrinkles. To discuss necking, a large number of macroscopic criteria is evaluated in the light of recent results obtained with the Finite Element Method (FEM). The section on the prediction of necking closes with an evaluation of damage mechanics as a means to analyze failure. Parameters that influence wrinkling such as the blank holder force are discussed. Wrinkling in sheetmetal forming operation are considered either by an implicit FE-Code or an explicit FE-Code.
Introduction One of the main reasons for the FEM increasingly to attract the interest of the sheet metal working industry is that this numerical tool can indeed help to reduce the number of try-outs needed for die design. However, this requires criteria when analyzing FE-plots which allow to predict whether a deep drawing operation is feasible or not, necking and wrinkling representing the most important failure types.
2 2.1
Failure by Necking Analytical Approach
Generally spoken, failure by necking is said to take place when 9 the deep drawing ratio, i.e. ratio of blank diameter to punch diameter, is too large 9 the radii of the die are too small *The authors wish to express their appreciation to the "Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG)" for their financial support of the projects Do/75-2 and SFB 300/B5. Greatfully acknowledged are further the provision of the FE program ABAQUS from Hibbitt, Karlsson and Sorensen, Inc. and the successfull cooperation with the German agency ABACOM as well as the "Regionale Rechenzentrum fiir Niedersachsen (RRZN)"
92 9 the blankholder force is too high 9 lubrication is insufficient 9 the deep drawing gap, i.e. the gap between die and punch, is too small A simple equation first proposed by SIEBEL and PANKNIN [1] may help to understand this: Consider an axisymmetric cup, with the bottom already formed. The punch force Ft, which is in equilibrium with all forces acting on the cup, must be transmitted through its wall. If the punch force is larger than the transmittable force, then rupture will take place. Refection will show that for equilibrium conditions, the punch force is given by Ft -- Fid "~- Fbend"~- tPfric,die "~" Ffric,bh
,
(1)
Fid representing the ideal forming force, Fb~nd the bending force, Ffric,die the accumulated friction force between die radius and blank and Ffric,bh the friction force between blankholder and sheet. From the geometry and the yield behaviour of the cup one can deduce the load carrying capacity of its wall Fbt, the force at which bottom tearing will occur, and one can readily see that F, < Fbt
(2)
must hold as to avoid rupture. The research activities on the prediction of rupture following the analytical approach aim at improving the description of the terms in equation 1, extending them to general geometries and implementing them in fast PC runnable programs [2]. The main advantage of the analytical technique is its quickness in delivering results, while its main drawback is the lack of accuracy and the poor local resolution- for general part geometries, the method is not able to give stress and strain distributions in a sheet.
2.2
General R e m a r k s on the P r e d i c t i o n of N e c k i n g U s i n g the FEM
At the present stage, advantages and disadvantages of the FEM can be judged as opposite to the analytical approach: It is a slow method, yet though both hardware and software ~re becoming increasingly efficient, but it offers a good local resolution, giving realistic strain and stress distributions in the sheet. The accuracy of the FEM relies heavily on the knowledge of the boundary conditions one ha~-to prescribe. In particular, this involves the description of friction and yield behaviour which are both difficult to measure. Friction is a highly local phenomenon, depending on the lubrication conditions [3], the evolution of surface asperities during the forming operation and correct contact search, which in turn requires a shell element formulation which is able to incorporate the thickness in the contact algorithm. The yield behaviour is both history and stress state dependant - measuring the flowcurve for example by hydraulic bulging corresponding to a biaxial stress state will result in values 1 5 - 20% higher than those obtained by a uniaxial test [4]. Strictly spoken, one would
93 have to measure the full yield surface taking path dependancy into account - a very timeconsuming task. For the experimental determination of the boundary conditions, the approach chosen in this work is to measure the yield stress in a hydraulic bulging test and to perform simulations of the bulging test, where no friction develops. The friction is determined as the unknown quantity when simulating for example an Erichsen test and is adapted such as to give optimum agreement of punch force and strain distribution in both experiment and simulation. The friction parameter found thus is then also used for other geometries, when experimental data is not available. 2.3
Macroscopic
Fracture
Criteria
The term "macroscopic fracture criteria" was proposed by GROCHE [4, 5, 6] and implies criteria consisting of products, integrals and sums of macroscopic stresses and strains. To determine the value of this criteria at the onset of failure, both experiments and FE-simulations of hydraulic deep drawing processes, simple stretch and deep drawing operations were conducted. In the simulations, standard LEvY-MISES-plasticity was used, anisotropy effects taken into account through a quasi-isotropic flowcurve after SEYDEL
[7]. After determining characteristic values of the different criteria, their accuracy in predicting the critical punch stroke at which rupture would take place was investigated. It was found that the main factor affecting the accuracy is the mode in which failure takes place, whether under deep drawing or under stretching conditions. The deep drawing condition is characterized by a halt of the flange draw-in in spite of an increasing punch stroke, while deep drawing condition can be recognized by the monotonic flange draw-in punch stroke curve. The results are summarized in figures 1 and 2, indicating the deviation of the predicted punchstroke from the value determined experimentally. These results are confined to deep drawing cracks, which reveals a severe drawback of these criteria: One must know beforehand what type of crack will take place, i.e. whether failure will occur under deep drawing or stretch drawing conditions, [4, 6]. The equivalent MISES stress was judged best for the prediction of both deep drawing and stretch drawing cracks. It turned out, however, that the locus of maximum equivalent MISES stress does not necessarily coincide with the locus of failure in the sheet [4, 6]. At this stage, some remarks on implicit and explicit FE integration schemes seem appropriate. The results above mentioned were obtained using the implicit Finite Element Method. In industrial applications involving large models however, the explicit integration scheme is becoming increasingly important [8], as long as elastic springback prediction is not involved. In the explicit integration scheme, dynamic effects may superpose the solution and will be very noticeable especially in the stress distribution plots. Thus, the thickness strain and the sheet thickness distribution are currently the most widely spread variables used when evaluating a FE-simulation of a sheet metal forming process. In spite of its popularity, however, this kinematic criterion also has several shortcomings: There is no material-dependant critical sheet thickness reduction, since this parameter is operation-dependant. As an example, the reader may refer to the results of -
94
Figure 1" Errors in the prediction of the critical punch stroke using diverse instantaneous macromechanical fracture criteria, after GROCItE [5]
Figure 2: Errors in the prediction of the critical punch stroke using diverse integral macromechanical fracture criteria, after GROCIIE [5]
95 the INPRO group [9], where major strains of over 180% were obtained in the actual multi stage forming and simulation of an oil pan out of mild steel. Moreover, the thickness distribution may also indicate the wrong locus of failure, [6]. For two processes A and B, figures 3 and 4 show the equivalent plastic strain and thickness distribution, respectively. Both processes lead to fracture, process A under deep drawing conditions, process B under stretching conditions. From the diagrams 3 and 4, however, one would presume that only operation B is not feasible, whereas operation A is, which is not confirmed by the experimental findings. Moreover, knowing that process A leads to failure, one would erroneously deduce failure to take place at about 40ram from the center, which is near the die radius instead of the punch edge radius. Therefore, sheet thickness distribution and equivalent plastic strain must also be interpreted with great care and experience when attempting to predict failure.
EP
1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4
\
0.2
process A 0
20
40
60 blank diameter [mm]
Figure 3: Distribution of the equivalent plastic strain in an axisymmetric cup, [6]
2.4
Microscopic
Fracture
Criteria
The drawbacks of the macroscopic fracture criteria gave rise to the idea of applying the concepts of damage mechanics to sheet metal forming. Describing the evolution of an initially flawless material to a microcrack, damage mechanics bridges the fields of continuum mechanics dedicated to the study of perfectly homogeneous deformable bodies, and fracture mechanics, the focus of which is crack propagation [10]. This is done by describing the microscopic processes that precede ductile failure, which is generally attributed to the growth and coalescence of voids nucleating at rigid second phase particles [11]. Some micrographs taken with a light optical and scanning electron microscope can be seen in the figures 5 and 6. They show void formation in the necking area close to the rupture surface. As one can see, outside the necking area hardly any voids can be found. For a more detailed discussion, the reader may refer to [13]. One plasticity model to account for interior damage is the GURSON model [12], which was derived in an attempt to model a plastic material containing randomly dispersed
96 0.9 sheet thickness [mm] 0.6 0.4
f
process A =..-~
"\
process B
0.2
20
40
r / [mml
60
Figure 4: Sheet thickness at initial failure, [6]
Figure 5: Micrograph of a ruptured X5 Cr Ni 18 10 sheet (light optical microscope)
97
Figure 6: Micrographs of a ruptured X5 Cr Ni 18 10 sheet (scanning electron microscope) voids. Studying a unit cell large enough to be statistically representative and applying admissible velocity fields, the yield surface was derived as
q)~ + 2qlf cosh(F = (-~I
) - (1 + q3f 2)
(3)
In equation 3, q is the root of the second stress deviator, p is the hydrostatic pressure, k/ is the yield stress and f is the void volume fraction. When interpreting f geometrically as a fraction of void volume to matrix volume, one can say that for sheet metal forming, the damage variable f is small [13]. When f is equal to zero, the GURSON model abridges to standard LEVY-MISES plasticity. A suggestion how to extend the Gurson model to anisotropic matrix behaviour so that it is suitable for simulating sheet metal forming is sketched in [14]. To implement this constitutive model in a commercial FE package, an integration algorithm due to ARAVAS [15] was utilized. Documentation of uniaxial and hydrostatic tests performed on an eight-node brick element is presented in [14]. When applying the algorithm to shell elements that use the plane stress assumption, modifications of the method are needed since the out-of-plane component is not defined kinematically. These modifications are briefly outlined in [15]. Further modifications are needed when applying the algorithm to explicit FE schemes. When the elastic predictor is very large, i.e. 3q2p/(2kt) > 30, difficulties may arise with calculating the cosh term. As a modification, the authors chose a subincrementation following OWEN and HINTON [16] in order to avoid premature abortion of the iteration process of the Backward Euler algorithm. Figures 7 and 8 shows contour plots of the MISES equivalent stress and the damage variable of a large rectangular cup. Though the calculations were performed at a very high punch speed, the damage variable distribution is still very reasonable, the maximum indicating well the locus of necking, while the MIsEs equivalent stress distribution leaves ample room for speculation. Ergo, the damage variable works successfully as a pointer to the endangered area. Whether the damage variable will also work as a failure criterion, has to be analyzed in future work.
98
Figure 7: MISESequivalent stress distribution in a rectangular cup. For symmetry reasons, only one quarter of the cup was modelled
Figure 8: Damage variable distribution in a rectangular cup
99
3
Failure
by
Wrinkling
Apart from cracks, wrinkling represents another important kind of failure in the area of sheet metal forming. Two different types of wrinkles are known: 9 wrinkles of first order in the flange (figure 9) 9 wrinkles of second order in the free forming zone between the punch radius and the die radius While wrinkles in the flange can be suppressed by the blank holder force, this is not possible for the secondary wrinkles.
Drawing Conditions: 'drawing ratio' Blankholder Force Punch Geometry Punch Stroke
= 1.77 = 81 kN = 220 mm * 110 mm = 70 mm
Figure 9: Undeformed and deformed mesh for a rectangular box
3.1
General R e m a r k s on the A p p e a r i n g of Wrinkles
When using thin sheets for drawing a cup, the flange may start to wrinkle. This tendency can be explained by considering an axisymmetrical cup. Concentric circles move inward and attain smaller radii. This movement results in a pressure stress in circumferencial direction and a tension stress in radial direction. The sheet starts to wrinkle for a critical ratio of both stresses. Pressure due to the blank-holder can help suppress the wrinkles somewhat, but if the force increases too much, wrinkles may be replaced by necking.
3.2
T h e Blank-Holder-Force
As above mentioned the primary wrinkles can be suppressed by using a blank-holder during the deep-drawing process. SIEBEL [20, 21] was the first one who analyzed the connection between the occuring of wrinkles and the blank-holder-force on a theoretical
100 base.
Nearly the same investigation was made by GELEJI [22] in a more simple way. More complex mathematical relations were done by SENIOR [23], Yu and JOHNSON [24] as well as M E I E R a n d R E I S S N E R [25]. For the calculation of the blank-holder-force SIEBEL [20] suggested for rotational parts: 0.5Do] (~o - 1)2 + 100so
Pbh,Siebel "= (2...3) 10-3R~
P~ ~0 Do so
(4)
tensile strength forming limit ratio blank diameter initial blank thickness
While GELEJI [22] gave the relation Pbh,Geleji -" 0.02Rv0.2
/~.2 dp u Do
dp + 2u ] Do + dp + 2u
(5)
yield strength punch diameter gap between punch and die blank diameter
Both equations give nearly the same results. However practical investigations with a rigid blank-holder have shown, that wrinkles appear even if the upper limit of the force, calculated with one of the equations mentioned above, acts during the deep drawing process. The experience shows, that the force for suppressing wrinkles can be calculated by Pbh,exp -~ 1.5pbh,Geleji
(6)
For rectangular parts, SOMMER [26] suggests to calculate the needed force by Pbh,rec. -- k
k m
Ao/Ast
m
(ao) Ast-
1
Rm
(7)
parameter considering the thickness distribution in the flange parameter taking into account the workpiece geometry blank area/projected punch area
To which extent the blank-holder-force influences the success of the deep-drawing operation is illustrated in figure 10. The abscissa stands for the reduction ratio and the ordinate for the blank-holder-force. In the diagram there are three regions
101 9 region where wrinkling is expected 9 region where a successful draw is expected 9 region where necking is expected For a given reduction ratio there are two critical points. The first one is when wrinkling is eliminated and a successfull draw is expected. The second one is when necking is expected [27, 28]. The second region increases if either the friction between blank and die decreases or the friction between punch and blank increases. For a reduction ratio greater than the maximum ratio wrinkling and/or necking always occurs.
Figure 10: The domains of wrinkling and necking
3.3
Aspects
of
Stability
The wrinkling represents a so-called stability problem. The specimen under force deforms so that the new geometry is from the mathematical point of view a stable state of equilibrium [17]. This is characteristical for this kind of problems. By continous increase of the force the state of equilibrium is formally maintained, but at a certain time it becomes instable. At this critical point, even the smallest disturbance such as a non-centered point of application of force, inaccuracy due to manufacturing etc., will lead to instability. This holds for buckling of a bar as well as for wrinkling of sheet metals. The state of equilibrium is stable. The engineer's duty is to avoid a switching over to the stable equilibrium, since a drawing piece with such a geometry can not fulfill the requirements of the design nor its original function. 3.4
EULER's Formula
The wrinkling during sheet metal forming processes is similar to the mechanism of the buckling of a bar, as it was described by EULER when deriving his formula. This comparison is similar to the one of SIEBEL.
102 This process was simulated using the FE-package ABAQUS/Standard and ABAQUS/Explicit (figure 11). In order to reduce the needed CP-time, a plain strain condition was assumed. Another advantage of this assumption is that the discretisation of the model would not influence the results in a wrong way. The model in figure 11 was
Figure 11: Undeformed and deformed mesh for the buckling problem discretised using 8"100 linear elements. After a displacement of u = 21ram every code gives a different result: 9 for the implicit code the process will resemble an upsetting of the specimen, as it is well known from the forging process. 9 the explicit code shows the buckling of the model. For the engineer's point of view it suffices to know that wrinkling or buckling appears. The question of the quantity and the quality of the wrinkles is of a theoretical and academical nature. However it is possible to explain both results by the mathematical formulation of the used integration scheme [19, 29, 30]. For this reason it is also possible to gain the same results using an implicit code. Therefore imperfections have to be considered in the model: 9 geometrical imperfections, i.e. nonuniform sheet thickness 9 physical imperfections, i.e. nonuniform u
4
modulus, nonuniform yield stress
Summary
Failure by necking and wrinkling are two important types of failure in deep drawing which can be predicted using the Finite Element Method. After a brief survey on analytical methods, a large number of macroscopic failure criteria are reviewed in the section devoted to the study of necking. In the framework of continuum mechanics, the highest accuracy in predicting the critical punch stroke is attained with the equivalent MISES stress, which
103 however falls short of indicating the locus of necking. The section on necking closes with an evaluation of damage mechanics. Focussing particularly on the GURSON model, the void volume fraction is prooved to work successfully as a pointer to the endangered area, regardless of geometry and type of operation. Wrinkles in the flange can be suppressed by an adequately chosen blank holder force. The friction behaviour at punch/sheet and die/sheet as well as the sheet thickness influence the succeeding of the deep-drawing operation. In order to produce very thin cups, a subsequent and separate ironing operation usually follows. Wrinkles can be simulated by either an implicit FF_,-Code or an explicit FE-Code.
References [1] SIEBEL, E. and PANKNIN, W.: Ziehverfahren der Blechbearbeitung. Metallkunde 47 (1956) 4, pp. 207-212
[2]
DOEGE, E. and SCHULTE,E.: Design of Deep Drawn Components with Elementary Calculation Methods. In: PIETRZYK, M. and KUSIAK, M. (Eds.): Proc. of the 4th Int. Conf. on Metal Forming, Krak6w, Poland, Sept. 20-24, 1992. Journal of Materials Processing Technology, Vol. 34, pp. 439-448 (1992)
[3]
BOCHMANN, E. and DOEGE, E.: Friction as a Critical Phenomenon in the Simulation of Sheet Metal Forming. In: CHENOT, J.-L.; WOOD, R.D. and ZIENKIEWlCZ, O.C. (Eds.): Proc. 4th Int. Conf. on Numerical Methods in Industrial Forming Processes- NUMIFORM '92, pp. 415-420, A.A. Balkema/Rotterdam/Brookfield (1992)
[4] GROCHE, P.: Bruchkriterien fSr die Blechumformung. Dissertation, University of Hanover, Fortschritt-Berichte VDI, Reihe 2: Fertigungstechnik, Nr. 229, VDI Verlag Dfisseldorf (1991)
[5]
EL-DSOKI, T.; DOEGE, E. and GROCHE, P.: Prediction of Cracks in Sheet Metal Forming with FEM Simulations. Proc. of the Int. Conf. FE-Simulation of 3-D Sheet Metal Forming Processes in Automotive Industry, Zfirich. VDI-Berichte 894, VDIVerlag, Dfisseldorf ( 1991)
[6]
DOEGE, E. and EL-DSOKI, T.: Deep-Drawing Cracks - Stretching Cracks: Two Different Types of Cracks in Deep-Drawing Processes. In: GHOSH, S.K. and PREDELEANU, M. (Eds.): Proc. of the 2nd Int. Conf. on Material Processing Defects, Siegburg, Germany, July 1 - 3, 1992, special issue of Journal of Materials Processing Technology, Vol. 32, Nos. 1-2 (1992)
[7] SEYDEL,
M.: Numerische Simulation der Blechumformung unter besonderer Berficksichtigung der Anisotropie. Fortschritt-Berichte VDI, Reihe 2: Fertigungstechnik, Nr. 182, VDI Verlag Dfisseldorf (1989)
IS] TAYLOR, L.; CAO, J.; KARAFILLIS,A.P.
and BOYCE, M." Numerical Investigations of Sheet Metal Forming Processes. In: MAKINOUCHI, E.; NAKAMACHI,E.;
104
OI~ATE, E. and WAGONER,R.H. (Eds.): Proc. of the 2nd Int. Conf. NUMISHEET '93, Tokyo, Japan, pp. 161-172 (1993) [9] VON SItONING, K.-V.; SiJNKEL, R.; HILLMANN, M.; BLiJMEL, K.W. and WOLFING, A.: Mathematical Modelling Bridges the Gap between Material and Tooling. Proc. NUMISHEET '93, ibid, pp. 321 ft. (1993) [10] CHABOCIIE, J.L. and LEMAITRE, J.: Mechanics of Solid Materials. Cambridge University Press (1990) [11] TItOMASON, P.F.: Ductile Fracture of Metals. Pergamon Press (1990) [12] GURSON, A.L.: Plastic Flow and Fracture Behaviour of Ductile Metals Incorporating Void Nucleation, Growth and Interaction. Dissertation, Brown University (1975) [13] DOEGE, E. and Seibert, D.: On a Failure Criterion for Sheet Metal Forming in the Framework of Continuum Damage Mechanics. Int. J. of Damage Mechanics, in preparation [14] DOEGE, E.; EL-DSOKI, T. and SEIBERT, D.: Prediction of Necking and Wrinkles in Sheet Metal Forming. NUMISHEET '93, ibid, pp. 187-197 (1993) [15] ARAVAS, N.: On the Integration of a Certain Class of Pressure Dependant Plasticity Models. Int. J. of Numerical Methods in Engineering, Vol. 24, pp. 1395-1416 (1987) [16] OWEN, D.R.J and HINTON, E.: Finite Elements in Plasticity, Theory and Practice. Pinderidge Press Ltd., Swansea, UK, 2nd reprint, p. 253 (1986) [17] MOTZ, H.-D.: Ingenieur-Mechanik. VDI-Verlag Dfisseldorf (1991)
[18] SIMON,H.: RechnerunterstStzte Ziehteilauslegung mit elementaren Berechnungsmethoden. Fortschritt- Berichte VDI, Reihe 2: Fertigungstechnik, Nr. 188, VDI Verlag, Dfisseldorf (1990)
[19] NAGTEGAAL, J. C. and TAYLOR, L. M.: Comparision of implicit and explicit finite element methods for analysis of sheet metal forming problems. Proc. of the Int. Conf. FE-Simulation of 3-D Sheet Metal Forming Processes in Automotive Industry, Zfirich, ibid (1991)
[20] SIEBEL, E.: Der Niederhalterdruck beim Tiefziehen. Stahl und Eisen 74, pp. 155-158 (1954) [21] SIEBEL, E. and BEISSWANGER, H.: Tiefziehen. Carl Hanser Verlag, Mfinchen (1955) [22] GELEJI, A.: Bildsame Formung der Metalle in Rechnung und Versuch. Berlin: Akademie (1960) [23] SENIOR, B. W.: Flange Wrinkling in Deep-Drawing-Operations. J. Mechanics and Physics of Solids 4, pp. 235-246, (1956)
105
[24]
Yu, T. X. and JOHNSON, W.: The Buckling of Annular Plates in Relation to the Deep Drawing Process. Int. J. Mech. Sci. 3, pp. 175-188 (1982)
[251
MEIER, M. and REISSNER, J.: Instability of the Annular Ring as Deep-Drawn Flange under Real Conditions. Annals of the CIRP, Vol. 32/1, pp. 187-190 (1983)
[26] SOMMER,N.:
Niederhalterdruck und Gestaltung des Niederhalters beim Tiefziehen yon Feinblechen. Fortschritt- Berichte VDI, Reihe 2: Fertigungstechnik, Nr. 115, VDI Verlag, Dfisseldorf (1986)
[27] SCHEY,J.
A.: Tribology in Metalworking, Friction, Lubrication and Wear. In: American Society for Metals (1983)
[28] AVITZUR, B.: Handbook of Metal-Forming Processes. A Wiley-Interscience Publication (1983) [29] TEODOSIU, C. et.al.: Implicit versus Explicit Methods in the Simulation of Sheet Metal Forming. Proc. of the Int. Conf. FF_,-Simulation of 3-D Sheet Metal Forming Processes in Automotive Industry, Zfirich, ibid (1991) [30] MATTIASSON, K. et. al.: On the Use of Explicit Time Integration in Finite Element Simulation of Industrial Sheet Forming Processes. Proc. of the Int. Conf. FESimulation of 3-D Sheet Metal Forming Processes in Automotive Industry, Zfirich, ibid (1991)
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Materials Processing Defects S.K. Ghosh and M. Predeleanu (Editors) 9 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
107
C o n s t i t u t i v e m o d e l s for m i c r o v o i d n u c l e a t i o n , g r o w t h a n d c o a l e s c e n c e in elastoplasticity, finite e l e m e n t reference m o d e l l i n g J. Oudin, B. Bennani and P. Picart Laboratoire de GEnie Mrcanique, Unite de Recherche AssociEe au CNRS, Universit6 de Valenciennes et du Hainaut CambrEsis, B.P. 311, 59304 Valenciennes Cedex, France. 1. I N T R O D U C T I O N To enhance design, development and optimization of secure and efficient new modern metal forming processes, know-how, empirical rules and expensive experiments are not suited to industrial requirements. The main interest of numerical methods using accurate mechanical models, either in elastic, elasto-plastic or visco-plastic problems in a finite element framework, is to make easier the reliable design of new modern mechanical parts and structures. For those imperative reasons, more and more problems require to take into account material microstructure variables such as microvoid volume fractions in the different material matrixes involved. The basic aim is now to get the most efficient solution scheme for such problems in relation with non linear large strain finite element framework. Typically, from the most recent microscopic observations, damage occurrence involves four phases more or less linked. The first one is an accommodation phase of the material matrix in which high stress and strain gradients appear around second phase particles, inclusions and precipitates. The second one is a new microvoid nucleation phase, either due to rupture of second phase particles, inclusions or matrix or to decohesion of inclusion-matrix interface. In an obvious way, this nucleation phase depends on particles and inclusions shapes, stresses and their hydrostatic part [ 1]. The increase of microvoid volume fraction during nucleation has been related to effective plastic strain rate in the matrix, effective yield stress and macroscopic hydrostatic stress [2,3]. The third phase begins with the growth of previous nucleated microvoids, the corresponding variation of microvoid volume fraction can be observed by density, modulus of elasticity or microhardeness measurements. The modifications of the mechanical properties have been described in using state variable damage parameter for isotropic material and damage tensor for anisotropic one. The increase of microvoids and the corresponding loss of load capacity is clearly linked to triaxiality of the stress field [4]. The triaxiality rate and microvoid volume fraction are introduced into a specific yield function for porous material [5,6]. The fourth and ultimate phase is obviously the most critical phase, occurring coalescence of nucleated-extended microvoids and finally ductile fracture of material. This phase has been predicted either from critical dimension of microvoids {7], critical dilatency, critical energy [8] or intrinsic limit function [9]. The present paper describes a solution schema well fitted for finite element framework in large strain elasto-plastic problems with porous material. The constitutive model is based on an isotropic elasto-plastic potential with three material parameters [ 10,11 ] and the main phases of damage evolution, microvoid nucleation, growth and coalescence, are taken into account. Microvoid nucleation is related to effective plastic strain rate, microvoid growth to material strain rate and associated elasto-plastic potential and microvoid coalescence to effective plastic strain rate. As reference, this model has been implemented in ASTRID non linear farge strain finite element code. The related algorithms and useful program are described in detail to permit
108 implementation in any finite element framework and three levels of computations are achieved forward: patchwork test of three node elements, collar test and pipe bulging to check its good implementation and to enhance its interest. 2. MODEL AND COMPUTING ASPECTS 2.1. C o n s t i t u t i v e model The constitutive model is based on an isotropic elasto-plastic potential with three material parameters. According to the irreversible character of ductile plastic damage, the isotropic elasto-plastic potential D.ep is defined as follows Oef + 2 ql f cosh f~ep = o'--5-
q 2. O m. OM
.kIIl+q3f2) .
0 withOm>0 (la)
and 2 Oef
f2eP = ~ I + 2 ql f - "(1 + q3 f21~ = 0 with O m <- 0
(lb)
in which f is the state variable available for microvoided material, called microvoid volume fraction and defined by f = VA - VM VA
(2)
with VA elementary apparent volume of material and V M the corresponding matrix one. In relations (la, lb), oef={3/2 s:s} 1/2 is the effective stress, s is the deviatoric Cauchy stress tensor, O M is the effective matrix yield stress of the matrix material, ql, q2, q3 are the material parameters and O m is the hydrostatic stress related to macroscopic Cauchy stress tensor a. The constitutive model takes into account the three main phases of damage evolution, so, microvoid volume fraction rate is given by
/. = i~n + i~g + ~
(3)
where fn, i~g and fc are respectively the microvoid volume fraction rates due to nucleation, growth and coalescence.
109 Considering a random distribution of second phase particles, microvoid volume fraction rate due to nucleation is expressed by
fn = fN S N ~
exp
(4)
2SNZ
where fN is the nucleated microvoid volume fraction consistent in regard to inclusions volume fraction, Ss is the Gaussian standard deviation, EM is the effective plastic strain and eN is the mean effective plastic strain at incipient nucleation. For ferritic steel matrix containing Fe-Fe3 and Cu-SiO2 inclusions, the usual values are fN=0.04, SN--O.1 and EN=0.2. Microvoid volume fraction rate due to growth is expressed by the apparent volume change, ?g = VM ~/A = (1 -- f) tr D p VA
(5)
where tr DP is the first invariant of macroscopic plastic strain rate tensor. Finally, microvoid volume fraction rate due to coalescence depends on effective plastic strain rate and is expressed by t'c = f u - for kM = fE kM AI~r
with f > for
(6a)
and fc = 0
(6b)
with f < for-
In these last relations, fu is the ultimate microvoid volume fraction at ductile rupture, fer is the critical fraction at incipient coalescence, Aer is the additional strain increment leading to ductile rupture and f is the current microvoid volume fraction. Solution of the microvoided material problem is achieved as follows: at each load increment, the consistency condition ~ bf~ /gf~ b f ~ i" = 0 f~ep + ~o :(~ + Oo M (~m + Of
= ~ep = 0 leads to solve (7a)
110 Then, the plastic multiplier is expressed by f~q, 8~ep O: ,, 8fin, 80 3f2eP (1- f) i9o :I + (A N + fE)(1 _ f)OM ~f
o: 8f2q, ~"~ep :C e . 3~"~eP C)~C'~ePh 00 ~0" ~0" ~O M (1 -- f)o M
(7b) where C e is the material elastic constitutive tensor, OM is the effective matrix yield stress of the material, h is the strain derivative of matrix stress-plastic strain function g(EM), f is the current microvoid volume fraction and I is the second order identity tensor. The effective plastic strain rate is then calculated from dissipated power expressions in the matrix and the material, given by
EM --
o:D p (1- f) O M
(8)
with the plastic strain rate tensor defined by (9)
D p = ~, ~ n e P .
80 Finally, the material elasto-plastic constitutive tensor is e 8f2ep)T.c ~ 3 ~ c
ceP = C e _ 8f~p :C ~ 8f~p 9 8o 8o
~'p
-7oo c ~p
: ~~ 8t2q, c: ~o 9 _..___.Sleep(1- f) 8f2n ' :I +(A N + fE h ( 1 f )o M Of 3 0 ) ( i ' f )o M 8OM (10)
2.2. P r e d i c t o r / c o r r e c t o r
algorithm
The previous formulations are introduced into a large strain finite element framework whose flowchart, related to the authors code ASTRID, is shown in Figure 1. The specific elastoplastic algorithm, corresponding to an elastic prediction of Cauchy stress tensor and a correction of this tensor on the yield surface is described in detail in Figure 2.
111
Initial data
1
!
~"-if L~176 I
Compute the tangent stiffness matrix K T
...c oa'n,c- I
,l-.c ~
KT~Uin+l) =
B T C e B dV
f
KT~Uin+l
BT ~
dV
i 1 Solve the linear system to compute the nodal displacement increment Aun+ K T(Un+I) i i = AUn+l
g T ~n+l dV v
N T Fn + AFn+ 1 dS
!
Update the new nodal displacement vector i+l i i Un+1 = Un+1 + Aun+ 1 Update the loading force Wn+1 = Wn +/~Zn+ 1 -
!
Compute the strain increment A i A i ~+1 = B Un+1 !
Predictor/corrector algorithm I
Compute the material elasto-plastic constitutive tensor ( e~lf~p~T e~.ep
ODep Ce O~qep / ) % o : ~ --~--. " ~ -~V~- h(l_f) OM-
~[)ep a'-'~ (l-f) --j-d- "I + (AN + fe)(l_f) oM
I
Compute the residual n.ofil,_a.l force vector
,C ui.l"V
No
Figure 1. Finite element code ASTRID flowchart.
":S(3
112
Predictor/cormctoralgorithm ..... ,,,
I
Compute the Cauchy stress tensor after elastic stress predicu.'on O + 1 = O n + Ce: A~+I No, elastic loadin8 increment s, plastic loading increment
Compute plastic multiplier A~k+l
f2ep k ~ep
o b~p b f ~ C ~ igf~p ig~p hk : ;90 9 " " --k O0 ~0 ~o M (1-fk) OM ~.
ok t)flep
,bf~p 1-
:I+(A~fe)
fk)~
I Compute effective plastic strain and effective matrix yield stress
k+l k k k A~k+l eMn+ 1 = eMn+ 1 + Ae M = eMn+ 1 +
..k+l
"M = g ( ~ § !
o
k ~f2~p
/)a
k (1-f k) o M
l)
Compute the new microvoid volume fraction n+l = AN AEM + ( 1+fk)
I + fe AEM
3o ! Compute the Cauchy stress tensor k+ 1 k e ~,k +1 t)~')ep On+ 1 = On+ 1 - C A c}O"
No
Figure 2. Flowchart of the predictor/corrector algorithm.
:-~-o (i--'~')7M
113 3. S O M E
REFERENCE
RESULTS
The proposed predictor/corrector algorithm performances are enhanced through a validation example, a reference one and a typical one. Patch test, collar test and pipe bulging according to material and matrix properties are performed as defined in Table 1. _ ,
Table 1. Material and matrix properties. Continuous matrix Microvoided material Nucl~tion Growth Coalescence Modulus of elasticity E ql Poisson's ratio v fN q2 fu effective matrix yield stress CM SN q3 fcr I~N fi At;r 200,000 N.mm -2 15 0.3 0.04 1 1/ql 500(1 +eM) N.mm -2 0.1 2.25 0.2 0.2 0.1 0.25 200,000 N.mm -2 1.5 0.3 0.04 1 l/q1 500(1 +eM) N.mm -2 0.1 2.25 0.2 0.2 0.05 0.25 200,000 N.mm -2 1.5 0.3 0.04 1 l/q1 650(1 +CM~ N.mm -2 0.1 2.25 0.2 0.2 10 -4 0.25 ,,
.
Patch test _
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
,,
Collar test
,,,
Pipe bulging
3.1. P a t c h
,,,
test
Besides basic tests on each library element, it is interesting to look after patch of elements, such as the one shown on Figure 3.
Prescribed disolacements : Node 1 : Ur=13z--0 Node 2 : U z - - 0 Node 3 : U z = l mm Node 4 : Ur--0 and Uz=l mm
Figure 3. Patch test of three node elements - dimensions and boundary conditions. Three computations are achieved until 1 mm prescribed displacement, the first one only takes into account microvoid growth, the second one nucleation and growth, the third one nucleation growth and coalescence. Computed microvoid volume fractions are given on Figure 4 : monotonous variation of microvoid volume fraction versus effective plastic strain is, as expected, obtained from 0.1 to 0.198 (see curve (1)); the incidence of nucleation appears when the matrix strain reaches 0.2 mean nucleation strain and the microvoid volume fraction gradient increases from 0.195 to 0.262, the fraction obtained at 0.6 effective strain being now equal to 0.225 (see curve (2)).
114 When coalescence is considered, the previous nucleation-growth results are strongly modified when the fraction reaches 0.2 critical value, and consequently the fraction gradient becomes 1.49, the fraction at 0.6 effective plastic strain being equal to 0.349 (see curve (3)). An other attractive and engineering representation of this patch test is given on Figure 5, in term of axial load capacity : the basic modifications of the load-prescribed displacement curves are as visible as above, the axial load capacity decrease being well related to microvoid nucleation, growth, coalescence (see curves (1),(2),(3)); looking now to the results when considering a cavity free material, the loss of load capacity is exactly computed (see curve (4)).
Figure 4. Microvoid volume fraction versus effective plastic strain, ASTRID code computations: (1) growth, (2) nucleation and growth, (3) nucleation, growth and coalescence.
Figure 5. Axial loading versus prescribed axial displacement, ASTRID code computations: (1) growth, (2) nucleation and growth, (3) nucleation, growth and coalescence, (4) cavity free. 3.2. Collar test Collar test of material is one of the required experiments for the determination of intrinsic ductility curves. The numerical modelling of this problem is very useful especially if taking into account voided materials. The dimensions of the required specimen are often : for the cylinder height 21 mm and diameter 14 mm, for the collar thickness 3 mm and diameter 21 mm, for the cylinder-collar connecting surface radius of curvature 0.8 mm. The corresponding finite element mesh is built for a quarter of the specimen (Figure 6a) : 58 Q4 elements with 2x2 Gauss integration points for the main domain and 4 T2 elements with a single Gauss integration point, located at the upper right corner vicinity of the domain. The computation is achieved with 280 increments for a prescribed displacement of 8.4 mm which leads to a final
115 specimen height of 4.2 mm (Figure 6b). As expected, the maximum increases of microvoid volume fraction are predicted in the collar zone (Figure 7a) and a maximum of 0.289 located on the collar upper surface; this is related to path and positive values of the hydrostatic stress component and in the last increment, hydrostatic reaches in the maximum microvoid volume fraction zone 137 N.mm -2 compared to -1040 N.mm -2 in the close cylinder zone (Figure 7b).
B
Prescribed displacements upper face Ur---0 and Uz=8.4 mm
(a)
Figure 6. Collar test specimen, one fourth of the meridian plane" (a) initial mesh, (b) deformed mesh. The evolution of the microvoid volume fraction in the centre zone shows that microvoid nucleation and growth is not yet effective in element 1, microvoid nucleation and growth appears in element 2 located at the connecting zone at 40% height reduction (Figure 8). The coalescence is observed in element 3 located at the external part of the collar at 75% height reduction. A minimum
0 maximum
f
,A
------ A-
A B C N/ram 2 D E
- 1040 -483 -30 137 283
0 A
503 -2965
o
A B
(b)
? i CD ii,+D
0.066 0.117 0.193 0.236 0.263 0.278 0.289 0.050
BcD E
(a)
-----A
A B C D E F
r
m
_2 mm
Figure 7. Collar test, 80% height reduction, ASTRID code computations: (a) microvoid volume fraction, (b) hydrostatic stress.
116
Figure 8. Collar test, ASTRID code computations: (a) zoom of the centre zone, (b) microvoid volume fraction in 1, 2 and 3 elements. To complete the above analysis, it is useful to look after the collar dimensions all along the test: the thickness is going from 3 mm to 3.547 mm (+18%), the diameter from 21 mm to 32.8 mm (+56%). 12
]
Wi -
0.6
J
0.54'7/~
. ,..,q
~ ~ 6 0 ............................................................--/ 0
11.8]
I..... ! ~ 0 . 3 0~' - ................................................................................... --
4.0 8.0 8.4 0 (a) Uz prescribed axial displacement (mm)
4.0 (b)
8.0 8.4
Figure 9. Collar test, ASTRID code computations: (a) diameter increase of the collar versus prescribed axial displacement, (b) thickness increase of the collar versus prescribed axial displacement.
3.3. Pipe bulging Pipe bulging is one of the typical cold forging processes in which the material ductility limits are rather easily reached and therefore the development of new such cold forged parts has a strong handicap. The dimensions of the non-bulged pipe in the example are: length 470 mm, internal diameter 170 mm, external diameter 340 mm. The finite element mesh used here is made of 280 Q4 elements with 2x2 Gauss integration points (Figure 10a). The computations are performed on the above basis with a prescribed displacement of 70.5 mm on the upper and lower faces (Figure 10b), the pipe-punches contact being a sticking one, the pipe-shape die contact being a free-sliding one. The microvoid volume fraction reaches rather quickly 137x10.4 maximum value in the equatorial outer zone of the pipe (Figure 11a) coming from 10.4; the microvoid volume fraction r-gradient is also expressive, 4.3x10 -4 per mm. Hydrostatic stress map at the last step shows strong r and zgradients, the heterogeneity being increased by microvoid nucleation and growth whilst in the
117 main part of the pipe, the hydrostatic stress remains negative; the z-gradient is equal to 14-12 N.mm -1 in the upper and lower zones; the r-gradient in the centre zone is lower, from 6 N.mm: to 2.8 N.mm -1, going from the middle to the outer surface. On Figure 12, it is shown that microvoid volume fraction strongly increases in the centre zone as far as hydrostatic stress grows upper than zero and again increases when the effective plastic strain becomes greater than 0.2 the mean nucleation value.
Figure 10. Pipe bulging: (a) initial mesh, (b) 30% height reduction deformed mesh.
N.mm -2 A B C
A
0.0012 0.0046 0.0092
--
0.0137 0.0001
,
V.
0j
~-~0
t~ D"C -190 ''0 70 r 0 A,
.
(a)
A
.
(b)
-1180
-1507 137
minimum 50 mm
Figure 11. Pipe bulging, 30% height reduction, ASTRID code computations" (a) microvoid volume fraction, (b) hydrostatic stress.
118
Figure 12. Pipe bulging, centre zone outer surface vicinity, ASTRID code computations: (1) hydrostatic stress, (2) microvoid volume fraction versus effective plastic strain. CONCLUSIONS The proposed damage model is based on a kinematic model in which microvoid volume fraction evolution in the constitutive matrix is described. The main damage phases are well enhanced, microvoid nucleation is related to effective plastic strain rate, microvoid growth to material strain rate and associated elasto-plastic potential available for porous material, microvoid coalescence to effective plastic strain rate. This model has been implemented into a finite element framework, of which the related algorithms and computer programs are described. Throughout three levels of finite element computations, element patch test, collar test as reference problem for the determination of material properties, pipe bulging as tactical important problem for which microvoid volume fraction determination is essential, it is shown that (i) formulation of elasto-plastic potential leads to coherent results, (ii) strain-controlled approach for nucleation and coalescence seems to be available in cold forging and similar engineering applications, (iii) effective strain path, hydrostatic stress path principally are to be analysed for each problem. NOMENCLATURE f
fi fu fN f~
current microvoid volume fraction critical fraction at incipient coalescence initial microvoid volume fraction ultimate microvoid volume fraction at ductile rupture nucleated microvoid volume fraction consistent with inclusion volume fraction coalescence parameter microvoid volume fraction rate
fc
microvoid volume fraction coalescence rate
fg
microvoid volume fraction growth rate
119
g(eM) h i
k n
ql,qE,q3 s tr DP u
AN B
C~ Cep DP E F I
J1 J2
KT N R
S SN V
VA VM E
EM
eM EN Au AF Ae Aer v t~ O'ef (~m O"M ~"~ep ~'~ep--O
microvoid volume fraction nucleation rate stress-plastic strain function of the matrix material strain derivative of g(e M) iteration loop index local iteration loop index loading increment loop index material parameters deviatoric Cauchy stress tensor first invariant of macroscopic plastic strain rate tensor nodal displacement vector nucleation parameter strain displacement operator material elastic constitutive tensor material elasto-plastic constitutive tensor macroscopic plastic strain rate tensor modulus of elasticity loading force second order identity tensor first Cauchy stress invariant Jl=30rn second Cauchy stress invariant J2=1/2 s:s tangent stiffness operator interpolation function residual force vector limiting surface on which surfacics traction are prescribed Gaussian standard deviation plastic deformed volume of the material elementary apparent volume of material elementary volume of matrix material macroscopic Green strain tensor effective plastic strain effective plastic strain rate mean effective plastic strain at incipient nucleation nodal displacement increment loading force increment strain increment additional strain increment leading to ductile rupture elastoplastic multiplier Poisson's ratio macroscopic Cauchy stress tensor effective stress hydrostatic stress effective matrix yield stress of the matrix material microvoided material potential consistency condition
120 REFERENCES A. Needleman, J. of Applied Mechanics, N~ (1987) 525. E. Onate and E. Kleber, Proc. of NUMIFORM 86, (1986) 339. J.R. Rice and D.M. Tracey, J. Mech. Phys. Solids, N~ (1969) 201 C. Lamy, P. H~caj, J. O'udin, J.C. Gelin and Y. Ravalard, Int. J./Vlech. Sci., 33, 5 (1991) 339. A.L. Gurson, Proc. Int. Conf. Fract., D.M.R. TAPLIN Ed., N~ (1977) 357. A.L. Gurson, Proc. J. Eng. Matl. Tech., N~ (1977) 2. H. Sekigushi and K. Osakada, Bull. of J.S.M.E., N~ (1981) 534. M. Oyane, S. Shima and T. Tabata, J. Mech. Working Tech., N~ (1978) 325. J.C. Gelin, J. Oudin, Y. Ravalard and A. Moisan, Annals of the CIRP, N~ (1985) 151. B. Bennani, P. Picart and J. Oudin, Proc. 3rd Int. Conf. on Computational Plasticity, (1992) 1443. B. Bennani, P. Picart and J. Oudin, Int. J. of Damage Mech., 2, 2 (1993) 118.
10 11
APPENDIX FORTRAN COMPUTER PROGRAM FOR THE PREDICTOR/CORRECTOR ALGORITHM SUBROUTINE PRED CORR (EPST, FRVO, KGAUS, LPROP, NMATS, PROP, SIGM,SIGMA, STRAIN) C C Inout variables: C - E P S T 9array of effective plastic strains C - F R V O 9array o f microvoid volume fraction C - K G A U S 9Gauss integration point number C - L P R O P 9material element number C - N M A T S 9matrix material number C - PROP 9array o f matrix material C - SIGM 9array of Cauchy stress tensor C - S I G M A 9elasticaly predicted Cauchy stress tensor _
C - S T R A I N 9array of plastic strain increment A~ C IMPLICIT REAL*8 (A-FLO-Z) C O M M O N / N U C L E A T I O N / E P S N U , FN, SN C O M M O N / G R O W T H / E T O L , Q1, Q2, Q3 C O M M O N / C O A L E S C E N C E / D E , FCR C C C o m m o n variables 9
C c C C C C C
Calle~ subroutines" INVAM, S I G M A E Q G L O - I N V A M - calculation subroutine of deviatoric Cauchy stress tensor s (DEVIA) and two Cauchy stress invariants J1, J2 (VARJ1, V A R J 2 ) - S I G M A E Q G L O - calculation subroutine o f stress-
C plastic strain function o f matrix material o M C ( S I G M A M ) and its strain derivative h (SLOPE) C C Internal variables 9 C - AN 9 nucleation parameter, A N C - A V E C T 9normal vector at yield surface C - B E L A S 9bulk modulus of elasticity E/{ 3(1-2"v) } C - FEPS 9coalescence parameter, fe C - D E P S E F 9effective plastic strain increment,/Xe M C - D E V I A 9deviatoric C a u c h y stress tensor, sij C - D F " increment of microvoid volume fraction, Af C - D F C O A L E S C E N C E 9increment of microvoid
C - DE " additional strain increment leading to ductile C rupture, AEr
C volume fraction coalescence, Af c
C - E T O L " residual potential convergence tolerance C - FCR 9critical microvoid volume fraction, fcr
C fraction growth, Afg
C - F N " nucleated microvoid volume fraction, fN C - E P S N U 9mean effective plastic strain at incipient C nucleation, EN C - Q1, Q2, Q3 9material parameters q l , q2' q3 C - S N " Gaussian standard deviation, S N C D I M E N S I O N EPST(*),FRVO(*), SIGM(4,*) D I M E N S I O N PROP(NMATS,*), STRAIN(*) D I M E N S I O N AVEC'T(4), DEVIA(4), DSIGMA(4), D I M E N S I O N SIGMA(d),STRES(4)
C - D F G R O W T H 9increment of microvoid volume C - D F N U C L E A T I O N 9increment of microvoid C volume fraction nucleation, Af n C - D L A M B 9increment of plastic multiplier, AX C - D S I G M A 9increment o f Cauchy stress tensor AO C - EPSEF 9effective plastic strain, EM C - FU 9ultimate microvoid volume fraction at C ductile rupture., fu C - F 9microvoid volume fraction, f C - GELAS 9shear modulus, G=E/{2*(I+v)} C - lITER 9index of local iteration loop, k
121
C - SLOPE : g(EM) strain derivative, h C - POISSON : poisson's ratio, v C - POTEN : microvoided material potential, f2ep C - SIGMA : Cauchy stress tensor, oij C - SIGMAEF : effective plastic stress, Oef C C C C
- SIGMAM : effective yield stress, o M - STRES : elastic stress increment - VARJ1, VARJ2 : 1st and 2 nd Cauchy stress tensor invariants, J1 and J2
C - VELAS : V=E/{ 1-2*v} C - YOUNG : modulus of elasticity, E C IER=O PI=3.141592653589793 YOUNG=PROP(LPROP,1) POISSON=PROP(LPROP,2) GELAS=YOUNG/(2.D0*(1.DO+POISSON)) VELAS=YOUNG/(1.D0-2.D0*POISSON) BELAS=YOUNG/(3*(1.DO-2.D0*POISSON)) C C Initial values of state variables at previous C convergent loading increment C EPSEF=EPST(KGAUS) F=FRVO(KGAUS) CALL I N ' A M (DEVIA, LPROP, NMATS, PROP, SIGMA, VARJ2, VARJ1) C A L L S I G M A E Q G L O (EPSEF, LPROP, N M A T S , PROP, S I G M A M , SLOPE) C C Compute the elastic stress increment C TRAN=DEFA(1)+DEFA(2)+DEFA(4) D 11=STRAIN(1)-TRAN/3.D0 D22=STRAIN(2)-TRAN/3.D0 D12=STRAIN(3) D33=STRAIN(4)-TRAN/3.D0 STRES ( 1)=2.D0*G ELAS *D 11+B ELAS *TR AN STRES (2)=2.D0*G ELAS *D 11+BELAS *TR AN STRES(3)=2.D0*GELAS*D12 STRES (4)=2 .DO*G ELA S *D33 +B ELAS *TR AN C C Update the Cauchy stress tensor C DO I=1,4 SIGMA(I)=SIGM A(I)+STRES(I) ENDDO C C Check the loading type C C 1=Q2* V ARJ 1/(2.D0* S IG MAM) PHI=I.D0+Q3*F*F-2.D0*QI*F*DCOSH(C1) YIELD=(3.D0* VARJ2/(SIGMAM* S IGM AM)-PHI C C YIELD <=0 elastic loading C YIELD >0 plastic loading C IF(YIELD.LE.O) GOTO 20
C C Return to the yield surface, radial-return algorithm C ffI'ER=I 10 CONTINtYE C C Compute the nucleation parameter, A N C AI=EPSEF-EPSNU A2=SN* DSQRT(2.D0*PI) A3=FN*DEXP(0.SD0*AI*A1/(SN*SN)) AN=A3/A2 IF (EPSEF.LT.EPSNU) AN=0.DO C C Compute the coalescence parameter C FEPS=0 FU=I.D0/Q1 IF (F.GE.FCR) FEPS=(FU-FCR)/DE C C Compute the plastic multiplier increment A~. C C Tension state case C CI=Q2*VARJI/(2.D0*SIGMAM) C C Compression state case C IF (VARJ1.LT.0.DO) CI=0.D0 C C Square root radical sign test which validates C potential factorization C TEST=I.DO+Q3*F*F-2.DO*QI*F*DCOSH(C1) SIGN=I .DO IF (TEST.LT.0.D0) SIGN= -1.D0 C PHI=DSQRT(SIGN~ ALPHA=SIGN*QI*Q2*F*DSINH(C1)/2-DO SIGMAEF=DSQRT(3.DO*VARJ2) DL11=ALPHA/PHI DLI=3.DO*GELAS+3.DO*VELAS*DL11 9 *DL11 C C
/3 t'/cp
DL1 =
5o
Co
"
i3 D., p
9
5o
C
C
C C
DL2.I=PHI+((ALPHA* VARJ1 )/(PHI*SIGMAM)) DL22=DL21*DL21 DL2=S LOPE*DL22/(1 .D0-F) ~ i'2q, Of~q, o 9 DL2= ~ h i9o i9o a ( 1-f) o M DPHIFV=SIGMAM*SIGN*(QI*DCOSH(C1)9 Q3*F)/PHI DLNUCLEATION=AN*(DL21/(1-DO-F)) DLGROWTH=(1.DO-F)*3.DO*ALPHA~HI DLCOALESCENCE=FEPS*DL21/(1-DO-F)
122
C DO ISTRI=I,4 SIGMA(ISTR 1)--SIGMAflSTR 1)DLAMB*DSIGMA(ISTR 1) ENIXX)
DL3=DPHIFV*(DLNUCIXATION+ 9 DLGROWTH+DI.L-OALESCENCE) C /gt~ C C
DL2 =
n, Oc~M
h
~(I ( 1-f) c M
DLAMB=(SIGMAEF-SIGMAM*PHI) /(DL1 +DL2+DL3) C C Compute the effective plastic strain increment, kE M C DEPSEF=DLAMB*(SIGMAM*PHI*PHI+ 9 ALPHA*VARJ1)/((1.D0-F)*SIGMAM*PHI) C C Compute the microvoid volume fraction C increment due to nucleation Afn C DFNUCLEATION=AN*DEPS EF C C Compute the microvoid volume fraction C increment due to growth Afg C DFGROWTH=DLAMB*(1 .DO-F) *3 .DO*ALPHA/PHI C C Compute the microvoid volume fraction C increment due to coalescence Afc C DIR2OALESCENCE=FEPS*DEPSEF IF (DFNUCLEATION.LT.0.DO. OR.VARJ1.LT.0.DO) DFNUCLEATION=0.DO IF (DFGROWTH.LT.0.DO) DFGROWTH=0.DO IF (DFCOALESCENCE.LT.0) DFCOALESCENCE=O.D0 DF=DFNUCLEATION+DFGROWTH+ DFCX)ALESCENCE C C Update the effective plastic strain and microvoid C volume fraction C EPSEF=EPSEF+DEPSEF F=F+DF C C Compute the Cauchy stress tensor C SQJ2=DSQRT(VARJ2) AVEC~(1)=DSQRT(3)*DEVIA(1)/SQJ2 AVECT(2)=DSQRT(3)*DEVIA(2)/SQJ2 AVECI'(3)=DSQRT(3)*DEVIA(3)/SQJ2 AVECI'(4)=DSQRT(3)*DEVIA(4)/SQJ2 TRAVEL'q'=VELAS*(ALPHA/PHI) DSIGMA(1)=GELAS*AVECT(1)+TRAVECT DSIGMA(2)=GELAS*AVECT(2)+TRAVECI" DSIGMA(3)=2.DO*GELAS*AVECT(3) DSIGMA(4)=(3ELAS*AVF.L-q'(4)+TRAVEC~
C C Compute the new effective matrix yield stress and C 1st and 2nd Cauchy stress tensor invariants C CALL INVAM (DEVIA, LPROP, NMATS, PROP, SIGMA, VARJ2, VARJ1) CALL SIGMAEQGLO (EPSEF, LPROP, NMATS, PROP, SIGMAM, SLOPE) C C Compute the new microvoided plastic potential C C Tension state case C C 1=Q2* VARJ 1/(2. DO*S IGMAM) C C Compression state case C IF (VARJ1.LT.0.DO) CI=O.DO TEST= 1+Q3* F* F-2*Q 1*F* DCOS H(C 1) SIGN=I IF (TEST.LE.0.DO) SIGN=-I.D0 ALPHA=SIGN*QI*Q2*F*DSINH(C1) PHI=DSQRT(SIGN*TEST) SIGMAEF=DSQRT(3.D0*VARJ2) C POgEN=SIGMAEF-SIGMAM*PHI C IF (DAB S(POTEN).GT.ETOL.AND. IITER.LE. 100) THEN C C New local iteration C I1TER=I1TER+I GOTO 10 ENDIF C 20 CONTINUE C C State variables keeping C EPST(KGAUS)=EPSEF FRVO(KGAUS)=F DO ISTRI=I,4 SIGM(ISTR 1,KGAUS)=SIGMA(ISTR 1) ENDO9 C REFth~ END
Materials Processing Defects S.K. Ghosh and M. Predeleanu (Editors) 9 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
123
Theoretical and numerical modelling of isotropic and anisotropic ductile damage in metal forming processes J.C. Gelin Laboratoire de M6canique Appliqu6e, URA CNRS 004, Universit~ de Franche-Comt~ 25030 BESANCON C~dex- France Abstract
The modelling of defects occurrence in metal forming is a real challenge for the engineer concerned with processing of new materials or new geometries. From an economical point of view it is important to be able to predict before setting the process if it leads or not to defects. As fracture in metal forming is mainly due to the development of ductile damage or plastic instabilities, a review of some models and methods is presented, applicable both in quasi-static as well as in transient dynamic situations, for cold or hot forming conditions. Numerical modelling of damage development in some industrial forming processes illustrates the possibilities of the proposed approach.
1. INTRODUCTION During metal forming, the main causes of fracture result either from plastic instabilities associated with localisation phenomena (necking in sheet metal forming, surface fracture observed in bulk metal forming .... ), or from the development of damage due to large straining of the material (central bursting in extrusion, internal fracturing in cold forging .... ). The plastic instabilities result from mechanical conditions associated with the loss of stability of the equilibrium problem and can be treated as a local problem with classical methods in that field as the singular perturbation technique [1 ], the linear stability analysis [2] or the Hill's stability theory [3]. The development of damage results from the apparition of microvoids or microcracks that growth under large straining conditions and lead to macroscopic discontinuities in the workpiece. From observations at the microscopic level, the main cause of internal damage in metal forming is the ductile fracture or intergranular fracture occurring in cristallographic materials [4]. Ductile fracture results from the decohesion of the matrix material around inclusions or second phase particles, then the microcavities or microvoids growth due to large straining and they tend to form macroscopic cavities or cracks leading to macroscopic fracture [4]. Such a mechanism mainly arrives in cold forming conditions. In hot forming conditions, i.e. when the deformation temperature is greater than about half of the melting temperature, the main cause of damage development is associated with intergranular damage that corresponds to the nucleation of cavities at grain boundaries, this phenomenon being mainly controlled by the viscoplastic strain rate. Although both mechanisms of internal damage in metal forming are different from the metallurgical point of view, we will show that they can be treated with approximately the same mechanical approaches.
124 On the other hand, forming processes are mainly controlled by boundary conditions (lubrication and friction), by the displacement and the average speed of the tools, and by the temperature deformation during the process. In modem metal forming industry, as example in rolling or wire drawing of steels or aluminium alloys, the average speed of the processes is such that the classical time independent plasticity is no longer applicable, so the need for better understanding the effects of high speed forming is necessary. Numerical modelling of metal forming has now gained the industrial stage, and it became possible to simulate metal deformation and to calculate stress and strain states for complex processes, see as example the increasing interest in the Numiform Conference in terms of papers and number of processes simulated [5]. Numerical modelling is mainly based on finite element models for bulk and sheet metal processes that are developed for steady or unsteady state conditions. The material behaviour considered is rigid-(visco)plastic, elasto-plastic or elastoviscoplastic [6]. In some cases the transient dynamic conditions are taken into account, sometimes for computational purposes, or in other cases to describe particular effects associated to dynamic loading [7][8]. The finite element simulation of defects occurrence in metal forming is a real challenge and there are two principal ways to achieve such an analysis. One way consists to carried out a conventional finite element simulation and, by postprocessing the finite element results, in using a ductile fracture failure criterion, to detect the zones where risks of fracture can occur. It is the approach employed in [9][ 10]. A somewhat modified form consists to take into account of damage accumulation in the flow stress curve of the material and to carried out a simulation with a flow stress that increases with hardening and decreases with damage, such a possibility have been applied to simulate localized necking in sheet metal forming. One of the major limitation of such an approach is that fracture criterion used have to be fitted with experimental results obtained with tensile, torsion or compression tests. In the case of complex metal forming processes, the process conditions influence significantly strain and stress paths and the material parameters obtained from simple tests and are no longer applicable. Another way consists to directly incorporate damage evolution in constitutive equations and to carried out the FEM simulation with such equations. First attempts have been carried out for extrusion where the Gurson model [ 11] have been employed. The results show that the finite element method can be successfully used to predict the formation of central bursts in extrusion [12][13]. In [14][15] an extension is given to treat the elastic-viscoplastic case and results obtained show that inclusion of viscoplastic effects generally tend to decrease the risk to obtain fracture as it is remarked in most forming processes. In that paper an isotropic model recently developed by the author and coworkers [ 16][ 17] that takes into account both degradation of elastic properties and modification of plastic flow when plastic straining increases is presented. Using elasto-(visco)plastic or rigid-(visco)viscoplastic finite element formulation, the model has proved to give satisfactory results in agreement with experimental ones. Then some basic ideas to do an extension of the model to take into account anisotropic damage are given[ 18]. As in many industrial cases the real conditions are a combination of dynamic loading and elasto-viscoplastic behaviour, with temperature and softening effects associated to adiabatic conditions, the present investigation describes the combined effects of dynamic loading, visco-
125 plasticity and temperature on the development of ductile fracture in metal forming processes. In section 2 of the paper we intend to underline some important points in the development of damage models. In section 3 and in the case of finite strain elasto-plasticity or elasto-viscoplasticity, an isotropic damage model is presented. The damage evolution is described in the framework of internal state variables. Of course the anisotropic damage presents some particular difficulties to define a damage tensor with significant constitutive properties and due to the fact that we work in finite strains. Some attempts in this case are mentioned. In section 4 of the paper some aspects of the numerical implementation of the proposed models are described and some difficulties inherent to finite element computations with damage constitutive equations are related. The last part of the paper concerns simulations of practical metal forming processes that have been carried out with the finite element method developed. The damage and ductile fracture development are analysed in extrusion for a very slow punch velocity and for a high punch velocity. Results obtained concerning the damaged zones in the extrudate clearly show that the damaged zones move from the centre of the extrudate to the external part when the punch velocity increases. The second example treated is a high speed upsetting of a cylinder along two generative lines. 2. MECHANICAL DESCRIPTION OF DUCTILE DAMAGE As previously mentioned the notion of macroscopic damage in forming operations is generally acknowledged by the observation of cracks were not present in the virgin material before loading/unloading process. Due to the microscopic origin of ductile damage it results that the classical theories such as elasticity or elasto-plasticity are not able to properly describe the behaviour of metals that exhibit ductile damage. It results that refined theories have been developed or are in progress to try to describe properly the behaviour of damaged materials, for a review see [ 19]. In order to model changes associated to damage some approaches were developed. Between these we can distinguish two major classes 91) the phenomenological approach starting with the Kachanov's model [20] initially used for describing damage in creep and generalized later for the ductile damage in small strains and to isotropic or anisotropic cases in finite strains; ii) a microscale-macroscale approach that intends to construct models at a macroscale using some considerations from the microscale and some additional assumptions. The basic ideas of the last approach goes back to the work of Hill [21 ] and were used substantially by Gurson [ 11] and are now an active domain of research. In his original one dimensional model, Kachanov [20] suggests that damage should be defined as the density of microvoids in any cross section of the material. The relative area of the voids in a cross section being represented with a scalar variable d(x) with 0 < d(x) < 1, where x stands for the current position. The damage variable d(x) used in [33][34][35] and in other author works is often interpreted as the effective area reduction caused by the distributed microscopic cracks and cavities due to material damage. It is clear that d(x) is well adapted to represent damage in one dimensional case, but the generalization to 3-dimensional cases suffer from serious limitations and numerous alternatives are proposed. It seems that an obvious choice for defining a damage variable representing nucleation, growth and coalescence of voids and microcavities is their volume density denoted by f(x) where x means for current position. For practical measurements, the
126 void volume fraction fix) is directly related to the density of the material through relation: (1)
p(x) = (l-f(x))Po(X)
where p(x) is the current density of the material, P0(X) is the initial one if we consider that the void volume fraction in the initial state is zero (f0(x) in other cases). Clearly the variable fix) is applicable in 3-dimensional cases but the remaining question here is how to take into account both the area of the cracks and their orientation. When damage is isotropic, it is tempting to try to relate d(x) to fix) introduced for the same purpose. As it is demonstrated in [22] it is not possible through purely mathematical arguments, the relation is an inequality relation expressed as: [1-(1-f(x))
2/3] < d ( x ) < [ f ( x ) 2/3]
(2)
The extension of the damage variables previously introduced in the anisotropic cases where the orientation of the cavities have to be taken into account can be formulated with the following arguments. Using remarks from Rabier [22], let d(n) the scalar function defined on the unit sphere centered at x position and that describes damage in direction n. Since the damage is anisotropic and since the function d(n) is even it follows that it can be developed in a generalized Fourier series by means of the spherical function. Thus the function d(n) can be expressed as : d (x, n) = D O(x) + gij (n) Dli j (x) + .......
(3)
where gij = (ni nj - ~5ij/3). Thus (D1)ij is a traceless and symmetric second order tensor. The six scalar variables D O and (D1)ij describe entirely that anisotropic damage state. Another arguments are given in [34] that consider two configurations of the same solid, a damaged one (B) and one corresponding to the undamaged fictitious configurations (Bud). If G denotes the fictitious deformation gradient from B to Bud it results from the Piola transformation that : n*dS* = jG-TndS
with
J = detG
(4)
where ndS is the area vector in B, whereas n dS is the area vector in Bud.The argument developed in [34] implies that the damage state of B can be described by the linear transformation JG T , and similary to the one directional case it is possible to introduce a damage tensor as:
1-D
= JG -T
(5)
It results that equation (4) can be written as follows: n*dS* = ( 1 - D ) n d S that generalizes to anisotropic cases the concept of net load carrying section.
(6)
127
3. D U C T I L E D A M A G E MODELS
3.1 The isotropie ease We consider in this paper a material containing microscopic voids or cracks. From the physical point of view it is possible in a first approximation to consider that the void volume fraction f represents a measure of the damage, figure 1.
Figure 1 - Schematic representation of a porous material containing micro-voids Taking into account that the deformation can be decomposed in an elastic part, in a pure dilatant part and in a plastic one that preserves the volume, the classical multiplicative decomposition can be extended as [ 16][ 17]: F = FeFdF p
(7)
where F e is the elastic deformation gradient, pO is the deformation gradient associated to the dilatation due to the growth of voids and FP is the plastic deformation gradient with detFP = 1. Finite strain decomposition (7) leads to express the relative change in volume during the deformation as a function of the determinant of the deformation gradient F and we have: detF = detFedetFddetFP =
p0 p
=
1 fo 1-f
(8)
with detF e = 0 e ; detF d = 0 a ; detF p = 1
(9)
where p0 is the initial density of the material, P the current density of the material, 0 e the volume change associated with elasticity and 0 d is the volume change associated with damage evolution (the plastic flow is assumed to be an isochoric one). The scalar measures 0 d or f can be indifferently used to characterize damage evolution, in our model we prefer to use 0 d because of its geometric signification. An important point to be remarked is that these scalar measures consider only volume change due to the growth of voids, but not their shape and orientation, clearly 0 d or f are isotropic damage variables. Let
Be
the Cauchy Green tensor associated to the elastic deformation gradient :
128
B e = FeF eT
(10)
and let ~e the Cauchy Green tensor associated to the isochoric elastic deformation as B e = (0e)
2/3B-e
(11)
with F e = (0 e) l/3~e
and
~e = ~e~e T
(12)
Let ~ the free energy defined on the current configuration. We suppose that elasticity, plasticity and damage are uncoupled, V is written in the following form: = ~,e (0e, ~e ) + ~p (0~) + ~1/d(Od)
(13)
For simplification we consider that the elasticity coefficients K and G (bulk modulus and shear modulus) are sufficient to describe the isotropic elastic behaviour and the term ~e is de fined as: v e ( ~ e , 0 e)
(14)
= 41 ( G t r ( ~ e ) + K U ( 0 e ) )
The Cauchy stress tensor c corresponding to V is given by the following relation: c = 2oB e ~ V _ 2pdev g *~V---~ + p ~ l ~)Be ~)ge 30 e
(15)
If we suppose that U (0 e ) = Ln (0 e ) 2 relation (15) can be written as: = 2K(Ln(0 e))l+Gdev(~e)
(16)
that coincides with the classical elasticity relation in the small strains limit. In order to establish the damage model let consider a plastic potential defined on the following form: ~)(G, 0d, o0(s p ) )
= ~/21devol + o 0 ( ~ p ) B ( 0 d ) g ( t r o ) - - ( I 0 ( I ~ P
)
(17)
where g(tro) is an unknown function of the first invariant of the stress tensor, o 0 is the flow strength of the undamaged material, devo is the deviatoric part of o and Idevol is the euclidian norm of devo. From the conservation of mass law and admitting that 0 e = 1 it results that: _ {~d
+ 0dtrD p
_.
0
(18)
Relation (18) is sufficient to define the form of the function g(tro) introduced as an unknown one in relation (17):
129 trc~ g (trc) - [3exp ( ~ )
(19)
where ~ is a constant that depends on the shape of voids (generally ]3=3/2) and c 0 is the flow strength of the undamaged material. Function u(0 d) can be chosen as u(0 d) = In 0 d accordingly with results associated to the growth of a spherical void in a spherical cell of material with a yon Mises flow rule [ 11]. It results that the plastic potential of the material containing voids is entirely defined as: r
0d, Oo ) = ~
d e v o ] - o o I 1 - 1 3 L n ( 0 d ) e x p ( ~trc~ ) 1
(20)
The plastic strain rate tensor is given by the normality relation as: devc I- Ln0d 2 13exp (2-~o) trcr 1 1 D p = ~ I~-32Idevc]
(21)
The plastic potential defined in relation (20) is very closed from the form obtained in [11] and used in [ 12][ 13] to predict defects occurrence in the axisymmetric extrusion process. A representation of the plastic potential defined in relation (20) is given in figure 2 in the space [Idevcl/c 0, tr(ff/2ff0)], the void volume fraction being considered as a parameter, we see that 0d =1 or f=0 corresponds to the well known von Mises case whereas f=l corresponds to the complete degradation of the material. In the physical reality f=l is never reach and the load carrying capacity of the material decreases considerably for small values of the void volume fraction (from f=0.05 to f---0.2). Relation (20) describes the plastic potential that can be used in cold forming considering the material as an elastic-plastic one. In hot forging cases we can consider that the elastic strains are small compared to the viscoplastic strains and then it becomes possible to use a rigidviscoplastic approach.
0
1
2 MEAN S T R E S S tr c~,'3.,\
3
Figure 2 - Effective reduced stress versus mean reduced stress as a function of void volume fraction
130 Let consider relation (20) as a viscoplastic potential [14], it results immediately that the viscoplastic strain rate is given by: d e v ~ + Ln0d 2 13exp ( 2t -r ~~ D p = ]?I~-32 IdevoJ
1
(22)
where ~" is in that case a time dependent parameter or a strain rate sensitivity parameter. To relate the spherical part of D p to the rate of void volume fraction the conservation of mass law is use, thus: tro = ( 1 - f) trD p = ( 1 - f) ~ 13Ln0dexp (~-~0)
(23)
The effective or the equivalent viscoplastic strain rate for the damaged material (sound material + voids) is given by: = q?
(24)
It is interesting to remark that for an undamaged material the effective viscoplastic strain rate is equal to q?. The factor q?can be expressed in assuming that the plastic power dissipated in the aggregate (sound material+voids) is equal to the plastic power dissipated in the sound material" O. D p = ( 1 - f) Oog5o
(25)
where o o and g~o are respectively the flow strength and the effective strain rate acting on the matrix (sound material). From relation (25) it results that ~, depends on devo, tro, f and. Generally the flow stress of the matrix (sound material) is expressed as a function of the temperature, effective viscoplastic strain rate and effective viscoplastic strain. Among the models that have been proposed, the most current is based on the observations by Sellars and Tegart [23] that steady state conditions for both creep and hot working are similar: o'* = 1 A r g s h I Z l t / n X
(26)
where: o* is the plateau or saturation stress, - or, A, n are temperature-independent constants for a specific microstructure, - Z, the Zener-Hollomon parameter defined as: -
z , xpE 1 with 9 -~ viscoplastic strain rate, - T absolute deformation temperature, Q activation energy. On the other hand, the work hardening regime (at small strains) is best represented by the fol-
-
131 lowing laws: (~0 = ~n ~m e XP I ~ T ]
(28)
or [24]: b c o o = (a+~+~-~)
in -m ~
(29)
Finally, to consider both the work hardening and the dynamic recovery, Voce's equation is usually used: o o - o* - (~* - oi) exp ( - N E p)
(30)
where 6 i is the flow stress of the matrix at a given cumulated plastic strain and temperature T. Although empirical, the above equations usually represent quite well the experimental data. More recently, the introduction of structural variables such as dislocation density and subgrain size for calculating the flow stress as a function of strain, strain rate and temperature leads to more physically based relationships [25][26]. Under adiabatic conditions the balance of energy gives: ~)T PCv-0--~ = k(~:D p
(31)
where p is the density in the deformed shape, C v is the heat capacity and k specifies the fraction of plastic energy transformed into heat, a typical value for metals is 0.9. To complete material description, the elastic behaviour has to include thermal sensitivity as: 6 = 2K (T) Ln (0 e) 1 + G (T) dev ( ~ e )
(32)
The model described does not consider a yield to define the plastic the viscoplastic flow. 3.2 The anisotropic case
We describe here a recent approach developed to take into account anisotropic ductile damage [18]. The damage variable introduced, following the arguments developed in [22] is a second order symmetric tensor denoted A. The macroscopic Cauchy stress tensor is decomposed into a part normal to A and a part parallel to A as follows: o = c
A
o:A + ~A
(33)
(above A 9B = Aij Bij and oA:A = 0). Then o A is the analog of the deviatoric part of o (denoted devo) while (o:A) / (A:A) is the analog of trff. Starting from this analogy it is postulated a yield condition in the form: A
f (~, A) = or" cr + CoO "~
A
2 Cl
A" A
(34)
132 where c o and Cl are material constants allowing to introduce qualitative constitutive aspects. It is easy to see that (34) can be written in the equivalent form: f(o,A)
= (1 + c 0 ) d e v o : d e v o + c 0 ( t r o ) 2rl(A) -Co 3
dev~:devA A:A
2
c1 A'A
(35)
(trA) 2 where 1"1(A) = 1 - 3A---7~ A and thus 11 = 0 if and only if A = a l . At this point at least two consequences are clear : firstly, the damage evolution changes qualitatively the yield condition, introducing plastic anisotropy. Secondly the form (35) which generalizes the von Mises yield condition can be also written for a yield function that includes the first invariant of the stress (its analog being (c:A) / (A:A)). It is shown in [18] that the yield function (35) has interesting properties concerning damage evolution. The damage tensor under loading conditions tends to become normal to the stress tensor. Other models based on the extension of the Kachanov model using a fourth order damage tensor are discussed in [27] and [28]. But the constitutive laws associated to damage variables have to be determined, the thermodynamical restrictions being not sufficient to formulate completely the model. 4. EQUILIBRIUM EQUATIONS AND VARIATIONAL F O R M IN THE DYNAMIC RANGE
4.1 Variational formulation and discretization The dynamic equilibrium problem consists to solve the following field equilibrium equations for all the points of the domain under consideration: ~)V
in
divo'+ f = p~-~ o.n=t u=fi
on on
f~ Ft
(36)
Fu
In equation (36) p is the material density, f is the body forces vector and t are the prescribed tractions imposed on a part of the boundary. The variational form associated to the equilibrium equations can be written in term of the total energy G(u) as:
G(u)
= fV( Fe,tx,0 d ) d V - f t u d S - f f u d S + J d ( u )
(37)
where g is the free energy per volume unit and Jd(u) is the energy associated to inertial loading. Solution u of the problem minimizes the total potential energy G(u). The minimum of quantity G(u) is obtained when the linearized derivative of equation (37) is equal to zero. The first variation of (37) relatively to the displacement field leads to: ~ F T : VSrldV - f t r l d s - f f r l d S + f p a . rldV DuG(U )1"1 = f~--F Ft
~
(38)
133 where 1"1is the homogeneous field associated to u and a is the acceleration field. Equation (38) is a non-linear one with respect to the displacement field u and the acceleration field a. To solve such an equation an iterative technique based on the Newton method is used: [DuG (u, 1"1) ]iAui + ~ + [G (u, rl ) ]i = 0
(39)
where u = [u, a] T, [.]i stands for quantity [.] at the ith iteration, and where DuG ( u ) 1"1 corresponds to the linearized derivative of G(u) in the 11 direction. A Newmark scheme for integration in time is used. Equation (39) is discretized at the element level in using a mixed formulation where the variational unknowns are the displacement field u(x, t), the acceleration field a(x,t), the dilatancy field 0(x,t) and the pressure field p(x,t) [29][30].
4.2 Integration of constitutive equations The numerical solution of elasto-plastic problems by the finite element method in displacement formulation leads to a sequence of displacements Un+l such that: Un + 1 = Un + Au n +
1
(40)
Displacement Un+1 corresponds to the (n+l)th loading increment, whereas displacement u n corresponds to the nth loading increment. In order to calculate the displacements, stresses and internal parameters corresponding to Un+ 1, it is necessary to define a procedure that can be explicit or implicit. The procedure that we have retain is an implicit one and is based on the following relation: Fn+l = ( l + V n U n + l ) F n
(41)
The approximation of the elastic gradient for the (n+ 1)th increment can be written as: e(o)1 = Fn + 1FnP-1Fnd-1 Fn+
(42)
Such an approximation supposes that the internal variables ot and 0 d are constant during the elastic prediction phase. From equation (42) it results that: Be(o) e(o) e(0) T n+l = Fn+l Fn+l
(43)
From the expression of the free energy potential, it results that the stress tensor is expressed as: ~e(O ) en(O) c)~ n+l = P ~ +l ~BeCo) n+l
(44)
The plastic multiplier and 0 d are calculated in using the expression of the constitutive functions and yield function. The algorithm used is an extension of the algorithm proposed by Simo and Ortiz [31 ], developed by Gelin [30] in the case of elasto-viscoplastic behaviour, and applied by Aravas [32] in the case of elastic-plastic behaviour with ductile damage.
134 5. N U M E R I C A L RESULTS 5.1 Extrusion of a cylindrical bar First example concerns the extrusion of a cylindrical bar (at low or high speed) represented in figure 3, extruded with a semi-cone die angle equal 5.7 ~ (respectively 15~ The initial dimensions of the bar are given in figure 3. The material properties used correspond to a mid-carbon steel with E = 210000 Mpa, v = 0.3 and o 0 = 500 ( 1 + 0 , 4 ~ '4) MPa, the operation is carried out under isothermal conditions. Figure 4a and figure 4b show the deformed mesh corresponding to a punch displacement L0 = 40mm with a punch velocity v0/L0 = 103 s -1.
Figure 3 - Geometry of the extrusion of a cylindrical bar through conical dies
zl
I
m
a
I I
zt I
mi m I
B i m i m m m m m n m m u m m n
im-,,u,m-,"' m m u m u m u m m
n n u m m m m n
~'"--""--"
m m m m m m m l
nmm,m n n m m n
.m.m.m.m.m.m.m., m
mmlmmmmmm
ram,
mmmmmmmm mmmmmmmmp-m
mmmm'amm m a m a m m Immmm,mami
_mmmm.,mm|m!m
m a m m m a m m
maw
l'-iiii~;
m~mmammmm
mlm
mm'mmmmmaml mmmmmmmmm
Immmmmmmm Rmmmmmmam
1 i
(a)
-- '--
mlumm,,,
i i
i
! i !
(b)
Figure 4 - Deformed mesh corresponding to (a) L0 = 40 mm, o~ = 5.7 ~ and v~ (b) L0 = 40 mm, cx = 15 ~ and v0/L0 = 103 s -1
- 103 s 1
Another computations have been carried out with a punch velocity equal 0.1 s -1. The contours of effective plastic strain are not sensibly influenced by the inertial terms. Figure 5a and 5b show the contours of void volume fraction for a punch displacement corresponding to 40mm
135
with v0FL0 = 103 s -1 whereas figure 6 shows the contours of void volume fraction for a punch displacement corresponding to 40mm with v0/L 0 = 10 -1 sl.It is clear that the inertial terms have an influence on the increasing of void volume fraction near the external surface of the extrudate. In that study the effects of inertial terms is to move the damaged zones from the central part of the extrudate to the external surface of the extrudate.
I'A iBC 4.08E-2 4.33E-2 4.59E-2 4.84E-2 5.09E-2 5.35E-2 i! 5.60E-2 5.86E-2 6.1 IE-2 6.36E-2
~
4.08E-2 4.90E-2 5.72E-2 6.54E-2 E 7.36E-2 8.18E-2 G 9.00E-2 H 9.8 IE-2 I 1.06E-1 J 1.15E-I
a Figure 5 - Contours of void volume fraction (a) L0 = 40 mm, o~ = 5,7 ~ and v0/L 0 = 103 s -1 (b) L0 = 40 mm, o~ = 15 ~ and v0FL 0 = 103 s "1
\ 5
/ ~
A B C D E F G H I
+2.053E-02 +2. 665E-02 +3. 276E-02 +3. 888E-02 +4.499E-02 +5.111E-02 +5. 722E-02 +6.334E-02 +6. 945E-02
Figure 6 - Contours of void volume fraction L0 = 40 ram, o~ = 15 ~ and v0/L0 = 10 -1 s -1 5.2 High speed upsetting test Computer simulations have been carried out that consider a simple upsetting of a steel cylindrical cylinder with an initial diameter DO= 20 mm, as it is represented in figure 7. The upsetting corresponds to a frictionless one and the die are supposed to be rigid. Two loading cases
136 have been simulated, one corresponding to a quasi-static case with v0/H 0 = 0.1 s -1 and the other corresponding to a dynamic loading case with v0/D0 =103s -1. The material properties used correspond to a steel with E = 210000Mpa, v = 0.3 and the flow strength is given by 0,4 c o = 500 ( 1 + (~:P) ) MPa. Isothermal conditions were assumed for the simulations. A previous study has revealed that in the initial deformation stage [7] the deformed mesh is strongly influenced by the inertial effects. Figure 8 shows the upsetting load and reveals that the load is influenced by the inertial terms. But the major result concerns the contours of void volume fraction plotted in figure 9 that shows an important void volume fraction increase at the free surface of the compressed cylinder, associated to an important increase of the axial stress. Our results are in agreement with results found in [36] using a viscoplastic finite element program to simulate upsetting tests.
llllt
___. l~I
L
m
IllI] 1 ,,, irr-~
Figure 7 - Initial and deformed mesh corresponding to the upsetting of a cylinder along generative lines a reduction in height equal 44% (D O = 20 mm, v0/H0=103s-]). 8O00 w
~
D
~ 9
uasi-static case
_ l - ~ .J
a
!
o
;
2 ; ; Punch Displacement (mm)
s
Figure 8 - Curves of force on the die versus die displacement corresponding to the quasi-static (v0/H 0 = 0.1 s -1) and dynamic loading case (v0/H 0 =103s -1)
137
rt A B C D E F G H
1.05E-5 8.46E-3 1.69E- 2 2.54E- 2 3.38E-2 4.23E-2 5.07E-2 5.92E-2
A B C D E F G H
1.11E-5 1.15E-2 2.31E-2 3.46E-2 4.62E-2 5.77E-2 6.92E-2 8.08E-2
A B C D E F GH
1.13E-5 1.43E-2 2.85E-2 4.28E-2 5.70E-2 7.12E-2 8.55E-2 9.97E-2
v
(b)Contours ot void volume tracUon (AD/D0=34%).
i<
(b)Contours of void volume fraction (AD/D0=40%)
u
Figure 9 - Contours of void volume fraction corresponding to the upsetting of a cylinder (DO= 20 mm, v0/H0=103s-l, AD/D0=44%) 6. CONCLUSIONS Material models to deal with the plastic flow of damaged metals that contain micro-voids or micro-cracks have been developed and used in situations of quasi-static and dynamic loading with strain rate and temperature effects. The constitutive models describe ductile damage in terms of a scalar or tensorial variable related to volume change. The strain rate effects, adiabatic heating and inertial terms are considered. The inertial effects are included in the equilibrium equations and a variational formulation have ben proposed that includes an accurate
138 treatment of the quasi-incompressibility conditions associated with the elasto-viscoplastic flow. The following results have been obtained for a stationary process: i) when loading velocity increases the inertial terms delay the central defects in the extrudate, ii) when inertial effects are taken into account the apparition of defects is moved in the peripheral part of the extrudate. In non-steady state process as the upsetting of a cylinder the inertial terms are important and lead to a concentration of damage on the external free surface of the cylinder. From our analyses, it is shown that in some cases of industrial relevance, it is necessary to take into account of inertial effects to be in agreement with experimental observations. REFERENCES
[ 1] J.R. RICE, The localization of plastic deformation, in Theoretical and Applied Mechanics, Ed. W.T. Koiter, North-Holland (1976). [2] D. DUDZINSKI, A. MOLINARI, Mod61isation et prrvision des instabilitrs plastiques en emboutissage, In Physique et m6canique de la mise en forme des m6taux, Presses du CNRS (1990) 444-460. [3] R. HILL, On discontinuous plastic states with special reference s to localized necking, J. Mech. Phys. Solids, 1 (1952) 19-36. [4] D. FRANCOIS, A. PINEAU, A. ZAOUI, Comportement Mrcanique des Matrriaux, Tome 2, Herm/~s, Pads (1993). [5] J.L. CHENOT, R.D. WOOD, O.C. ZIENKIEWICZ Eds., Numerical methods in industrial forming processes, A.A. Balkema, Rotterdam (1992). [6] J.C.GELIN, D. LOCHEHGNIES, Simulations num6riques en grandes deformations plastiques, In Physique et mrcanique de la mise en forme des mrtaux, Presses du CNRS (1990) 553-562. [7] J.C. GELIN, A finite element analysis of high speed metal forming processes, Annals of the CIRP, 40-1 (1991) 277-280. [8] J. TIROSH, Kinetic and dynamic effects on the upper bound in metal forming processes, J. ofAppl. Mech,43 (1976) 214-218. [9] L. CHEVALIER, P. LE NEVEZ, Calculs 61asto-plastiques en grandes drformations avec pr6vision d'endommagement ductile. Application ~ l'extrusion - Physique et Mrcanique de la Mise en Forme des Mrtaux. Presses du CNRS, Paris (1990) 553-560. [10] A. EL MENNI, M. DUBOIS, J.C. GELIN, Contribution ~ la simulation numErique du d6coupage des m6taux, Congr~,s STRUCOME 93, APCAS (1993) 567-579. [11] A.L. GURSON, Continuum theory of ductile fracture by void nucleation and growth: Part I- Yield criteria and flow rules for porous ductile media, J. Eng. Mat. Tech., 99 (1977) 225. [12] J.C. GELIN, J. OUDIN,Y. RAVALARD, An improved finite element method for the analysis of damage and ductile fracture in cold forming processes, Annals of the CIRP, 34-1 (1985) 209-213.
139 [13] N. ARAVAS, The analysis of void growth that leads to central bursts during extrusion, J. Mech. Phys. Solids, 34-1 (1986) 55-79. [14] J.C. GELIN, A viscoplastic model for void containing materials incorporating temperature effects, Proc. of the 2nd Int. Conf. on Computational Plasticity, Ed. by D.R.J. OWEN,E.HINTON and E. ONATE, Pineridge Press (1989) 515-526. [15] J.C. GELIN, Application of a thermo-viscoplastic model to the analysis of defects in warm forming conditions, Annals of the CIRP, 35/1 (1986) 157-160. [ 16] J.C. GELIN, M. PREDELEANU, On a finite strain elastic-plastic ductile damage model Model and computational aspects, 17th Int. Cong. Theoretical and Applied Mechanics, Grenoble, France (1988). -
[17] J.C. GELIN, M. PREDELEANU, Finite strain elasto-plasticity including damage Applications to metal forming problems, Proc. of NUMIFORM 89 Conf., Ed. by E.G. THOMPSON et al., A.A. Balkema (1989) 151-157. [18] J.C. GELIN, A. DANESCU, Constitutive model and computational strategies for finitestrain elasto-plasticity with isotropic or anisotropic ductile damage, In Proc. of 3rd Ht. Conf. Computational Plasticity, Ed by D.R.J. Owen et al, Pineridge Press (1992) 1413-1424. [19] M. PREDELEANU, Finite strain analysis of damage effects in metal forming processes, in Computational Methods for Predicting Materials Defects, Ed by M. PREDELEANU, Elsevier (1987) 295-308. [20] L.M. KACHANOV, Time of the rupture process under creep conditions, Isv. Akad. Nauk. SSR, 8 (1958) 26-31. [21] R. HILL, The essential structure of constitutive laws for metal composites and polycristals, J. Mech. Phys. Solids, 15 (1967) 79. [22] P. RABIER, Some remarks on damage theory, Int. J. Engrg. Sci., 27(1) (1989) 29-54. [23] C.M. SELLARS, W.J. Mc TEGART, La relation entre la rrsistance et la structure dans la d6formation ~ chaud, Mere. Sci. Rev. Met., 63 (1966) 731. [24] M. MOTUMURA et al., On relating the resistance to deformation of commercial pure aluminium and aluminium alloys to strain, strain rate and temperature, J. of Jap. Inst. of Light Metals, 9 (1976) 432. [25] O. RICHMOND, Microstructure-based modelling of deformation processes, J. of Metals,4 (1986) 16. [26] L.A. LALLI, A.J. DE ARDO, Experimental assessment of structure and property predictions during hot working, Met. Trans. A., 21 (1989) 301. [27] T.J. LU, C.L. CHOW, On constitutive equations of inelastic solids with anisotropic damage, Theoretical and Appl. Fract. Mech.,14 (1990) 187-218. [28] J. JU, On energy based elasto-plastic damage theories : constitutive modelling and computational aspects, Int. J. Solids Struct., 25 (1989) 803-833. [29] J.C. SIMO, On a fully three-dimensional finite strain viscoelastic damage model: Formulation and computational aspects- Comp. Meth. Appl. Mech Engrg, 60 (1987) 153-173.
140 [30] J. C. GELIN - Application of an implicit method for the analysis of damage with temperature effects in large strain plasticity problems, In Numerical Methods for Nonlinear problems, Ed. by C. Taylor et al., Pineridge Press (1986) 494-508. [31] J.C. SIMO, M. ORTIZ, A unified approach to finite deformation elasto-plastic analysis based on the use of hyperelastic constitutive equations, Comp. Meths. Appl. Mech. Eng. 49 (1985) 221-245. [32] N. ARAVAS, On the numerical integration of a class of pressure- dependent plasticity models - Int J. for Numer. Meth. in Engrg., Vol.24 (1987) 1395-1416. [33] J. LEMAITRE,J.L. CHABOCHE, Aspects ph6nom6nologiques de la rupture par endommagement, J. Mech. Appl., 2(3) (1978) 317-365. [34] S. MURAKAMI, Mechanical modelling of material damage, Trans. ASME, J. Appl. Mech., 55 (1988) 280-286. [35] D. KRAJCINOVIC, Constitutive equations for damaging materials, Trans. ASME, J. Appl. Mech, 50 (1984) 355-360. [36] N.L. DUNG, Prediction of the fracture initiation using a finite element method and various damage models, Proceedings of Plasticity 91 (1991) 607-611.
~
~
~
"
0~
~"0
oO ~
~
=
OO
~
~
~
~o
~
~
0
~
o
o
,..,.
0
in,.
,-... 9
~
~., ~-,
0
,._
o~=
0
~" ~ '
~~o
0
=
~
0
I~
9
9
~
~,
o ~ 0~ ~
~
. . . .
oC~
~ o
~
~
~
~ ~
~ 0~
~ ~~-
~
~ ~
~
-
~
-0~
~ ,.,.
~
- ~
~.~
~ ~D
~
~ ~ ~
~
~
~...~".
~
~~
~.~
,.
,-~ ~
~ 8
~
~D
~,-"
o~ ~~-
~.
~
0
~ .
~
o~.
~. 0
~
~ ~ ~
~ o o o ~
<
~ ~
~
"
~
~"
~ . ~ o ~ . g
-~--~
~ ~ ~ .
~" ~
~~o
o ~ ~ ~o
~.~y =
~.=~-
~
~" .
~ ~ ~-
~
8
~
~
....
~.
o
~ ~ 0~ ~
~~
~ ~ ~ ~~o ~ :~ ~ ~ ' ~
o =
o
~"
o~
9
.
~
--.
o.
0~
1.-,~
<
~
~
~.
~
~" ~
~
n~
~
~-'
~
o
0
0
-"
o
~--,.
~
o
,-"
:~
0
b~
'
O0
imJo
.~
"I
~,
":
~.~
;:r
~'o v
"
142 is worse, the conductance of most of which is about 1/15 that of aluminium alloy. The severe control condition is required during titanium alloy forging process because it is easy to produce overheated phenomenon and makes its structure and properties worse. The nominal composition of titanium alloy T C l l , which belongs to two phase titanium alloy,is Ti-6A1-3.5Mo-2Zr-0. 3Si. It has two kinds of microstructure under normal temperature,one is the acicular Weisz structure with good elevated temperature creep property obtained by heat treatment heating above the phase transition temperature (990~ another is the equiaxed ~-[-[3 structure with good elevated temperature fatigue property obtained by large deformation and heat treatment under phase transition temperature. The acicular t3 structure can be translated into the stable equiaxed a+[3 structure with the alloy's being heated and deformed under the phasetransus temperature. The property and extent of this transus is depend on heating temperature and strain. According to this, it is practicable to control the final structure and distribution by controlling blocking shape and forging parameters. In order to implement the computer-aided design and manufacturing ( C A D / C A M ) approach,detailed mathematical models of the workpiece material, the forming process, and the workpiece-tool interface conditions are required. However, these models did not exist in a sufficiently complete form. Nowadays, the finite element analysis of upsetting processes are subjected to uniform temperature field or added heat conduction which is not in conformity with practical produce. In fact,the initial state is a non-uniform temperature field,conversely,the heat produced during deformation effects the distribution of temperature field. However, there are no data for these models which could be referred. The objective of this paper is to establish and prove the model required and combines them to form a computer program of interactive mode used in forging design. The test of the deformation resistance in high temperature for this material is carried out as well. 2. THE M A T E R I A L M O D E L IN FORGING CONDITION
To establish a workpiece' s plastic flow equation or a constitutive equation the uniform compression tests under various temperature and strain rate are carried out.
143 2 . 1 Test process
1)Test samples
O 1_1
t
~6.4
f
__1
....
~8. o Figure. 1
I
--1
Size of sample
The initial structure which conforms with that of forging stock is 13 structure. The size of the sample is shown in Fig. 1. Lubricating pits have been caved on both ends. 2 ) T e s t temperature distribution The test temperature chosen should cover the entire heating range (T =800~-1050'C, ~= 1 0 - 3 ~ 2 . 5 s - ~ ) . In view of the active area of the dynamic-recrystallization and phase transition ( T = 9 0 0 ~ 1 0 0 0 ' C ) t h e points of test temperature are added fitly. Hence eight test temperatures are chosen: 8 0 0 C , 8 5 0 C , 900'C, 9 3 0 C , 960'C ,980"(2,1010"C,1050:C. The deformation of each strain rate point is above 50 percent reduction of basic height. All tests were conducted on a Gleeble-1500 material heat modeling test machine. The test temperatures and strain rates are keeped at constant . All test data are recorded automatically by computer system. 2.2 Experimental results and analysis The s t r e s s - s t r a i n curves by the amendment of data and temperatures are shown in Fig. 2. It can be seen that:
144
400
~,,,
250
(a)T=850C
~(b)T=
900C
2oo
300
[..,
200 U~
15o 100
m~
[-.,
[..., 100
5O |
0.2
200
0'.4
i
0.6
0.'8
TRUE STRAIN
0
(c)T=930 C
150
~
_
9
A
i
0.2 0.4 0.6 TRUE STRAIN
018
.(d)T=960 C
~'150
r~ 100
r~
[..., 100
&--10-,S-,
r.l.1 [-,
~---10-zS-i
50
~=10-3S-1 0.2
0.4 TRUE
0.6
t0.8
~-----lO-~S-I 0
0.2
STRAIN Figure2
0.4 TRUE
0.6
0.8
STRAIN
The stress strain curves
1) There is an extensive and obvious softening phenomenon in the alloy T C l l of forging condition. 2) Alloy T C l l is a kind of material sensitive to the strain rate. The more the strain rate, the more deformation resistance. 3) T C l l is also sensitive to temperature under phase transition point (990'(2). The temperature leads a large deformation resistance. 4) Alloy T C l l has a "stress peak" at the initial deformation, the strain at the peak stress point is nearly equal to the critical strain at the
145
beginning of dynamic-recrystallization r 1 6 2 is not c o n s t a n t , b u t changes as deformation temperature and strain rate vary. The constitutive equation for T C l l could be obtained by multivariate regression way for test data. Being sensitive to temperature, low conductivity and extensive deformation softening phenomenon,alloy T C l l gets non-uniform deformation during forging processes,which easily produces overheat structure,leads the workpiece properties worse and defects. 3. THE SIMULATION OF THERMO-VISCOPLASTIC FEM FOR TC11 WORKPIECE FORGING DEFORMATION
Some deformation field information which can not be obtained by physical experiment could be studied by computer simulation , such as deformation shape at any t i m e , s t r a i n , s t r a i n rate,temperature and so on at any points. According to the deformation field we could identify whether forging defect exists in an area, or according to the value of strain and strain rate, the structure change trend in an area could be identified. If the preforming shape and forging parameters could be changed, rational process parameters could be chosen conveniently and quickly on the computer and the necessary test could be reduced to the minimum. Because alloy T C l l is sensitive to strain rate, neglecting elastic deformation and using the rigid-viscoplastic models are more practicable. 3.1 The contitutive equation of deformation Processes The contitutive eqution of deformation processes is: 2(5.
~t
iJ ~
- - E: ij --3 - g.,
where o'~i is deviatoric stress t e n s o r ; 8 , ~ , i s reffers to equivalent stress and equivalent strain rate respectively. In general, the equivalent stress is the function of total strain,strain rate and temperature ,which will be given by: o=o(~,~,T) then for the incompressible rigid-viscoplastic material its energy funtional is taken as r~-- fvE(~j)dv-- I Sp F~,ds + I v k ~,j~,jdv
146 Here,plastic work E(e~i)can be shown as E(e~i)= [ ode 1 Where: ), express Lagrange's multiplier, and X = -~ o~, &i is Claisen tensor. The second item in the equation expresses external force work. General, forging is carried out under elevated temperature, the mechanics properties of forging workpiece,in especial titanium alloys, change obviously as the temperature is varified. During forging processes accompanied by deformation heat, if the die temperature is lower,relative large temperature gradient between the workpiece will be formed due to the heat loss created by heat conduction and radiation between the workpiece.the dies and the environment. Hence, the effect of temperature on forging processes must be considered. During elevated temperature deformation processes the plastic deformation work could lead local temperature high, phase transformation, and structure bad, conversely, which produces the change of deformation-resistance and mechanics properties and affect the plastic process itself again. According to this ,the calculation of deformation and temperature should be carried out by coupled way. Heat conduction energy balanced equation can be given as: KT,ii-qt-Jr--lo c "i"-- 0 Where:K T,ii refers to heat conductance;J r heat generation rate;p cT internal energy change rate. In general, the heat generation rate in the forgings mainly comes from plastic deformation work ~r --- ~Oij~ij
is usually O. 90,after the boundary condition is taken,the variational form of which can be found IvNT.iIT.,dv-~- I P C T I T d v - - I v vaii~ii~jTdv-
Is
q.iTdSq=0
Where:q, refers to boundary heat flow sagitta. The temperature of which is written into nodal temperature interpolating function,its matrix form is: C T+KT=Q Where.C refers to the matrix of heat capacity;K the matrix of heat conduction,Q the sagitta of heat flow. The following several factors are considered in the sagitta of heat flow:
--"
~
=
o
~
"
~-=
~
o~
""
~4 ~
~
~
--~
.
"
o =
~
,-,.
~.
~ o -~. . ~
~.
g
9
~,
~
~
. ~o ~
~
~'8 ~
9
~
~..
~
~D
~ ' ~
~
~"
~
~
~-~
-"
o
r~
~
F
~I
~
"~
~
,
.
~
~
~
ff
~
o
~
O~
~
~
~
~
9
~..~
-
:~--, 0~
~B.~
~
~
....
~
~ ~"
=~
~'
~m'~
~
~
~-~
~
.
~ ~
=
~
.
~~~
~*--, ~ . .
~.~.=
o
~
o
~
-.
;
~
0
..
T
I~
...
O0
0
p..,~
r
Cb
0
db
Oo
0
+
-].
0
-co
g
~"
"C~
"
o
~
~
II
o
r
.
-
o
o
=~.
~
~
r
~"
~
0
~
=
:=r
0
~
~
~
=
~
cr~
~
~"
e
'-" o~
~
O~
~o~
9
~ ] ~ ~
9
db
,.~
0
o
~
~
~
~)
|I~
~
9
~
"-" 0
O~
r
"~
0~-~
o'q
.
0
=-.o
>~
~
""
9 ~.
. ~ ~
148
die
1.14 ~~'~'~9"~0"79/ ~__~____~0Q97
X \ O.60\
1~.,:--2:1.32,1.14v \ ~" \ ~ 1
51 ~"
-
\i
i
(a)lsogram of effectivestrain (die)
494~486~ ~'--~--511--:518~-'~'~ \ ~1~16!'1173-~1185~~_..._.~197~ ~ 1220 ~1
]21 I ]209 i--~..:._.,!233 l'''''-'--'-'~-20/
~/~ 12~~
(b) The temperature of workpieceand die Figure. 3 Size of workpiece ,{~250X 300mm,the initial temperature of workpiece T--1203K.
I
die
|
.
475
9
~1.6Gz!-46,~._2~\ \ .. -
\
{a) Isogram of effective strain
___1[...._12~38~242~1244 ~
4
6
J \\\ \ \ X ~~X~ ~
(b)The temperatures of workpiece and die Figure. 4 Size of workpiece ~250 X 300mm,the initial temperature of workpieee T=1233K
149
_f\ (a)Isogram of effective strain die 472 171
'
1245
(rA
240
(b) The temperature of workpiece and die Figure. 5
Size of workpiece Zf290 • 150mm,the initial
temperature of workpiece T = 1233K. 3)According to the distribution of temperature,the temperature rises led by deformations are of frequent occurence. On the parts of the stock near the dies, the temperature distribution is mainly controlled by the boundary's heat exchange. While in the center and diagonal areas, the thermal conductivity for titanium alloy is relatively bad and the deformatoin rate is fast, the rising of temperatures created by deformation is not easy to release, so the temperature distribution is mainly controlled by the local deformation quantities.which belongs to the lifting temperature area,its form of distribution is basically similar to distribution of deformation. 4) While titanium alloy T C l l is deformed,there will be some isolated "island"on the temperature distribution. The"island" only appears when the initial forging temperature is relatively low (Figure 3 ) , a n d it will disappear as the initial temperature is risen (Figure 4). This indicates that there exists an extremely nonuniform deformation when forging under low temperature. On the shear zone near the "dead area", the
150
drastic shearing deformation will create a quick lift of temperature higher than the areas around,and form an isolated island distribution . This kind of distribution will deepen and augment as the deformation is enlarged. 5)During the entire deformation process ,at the part near the dies, the temperature of the workpiece continuously goes down , and by the friction’ s effect, the deformation is very small, the forged structure and initial structure should have no obvious difference; but at the center area ,especially a t the center shear zone, as the deformation increases, the temperature of workpiece will increase continuously. At some local area such as the “island”, the temperature will probably surpass the phase transition point ( 990.C 1. This will create a phase transition, greatly affect the forged structure ,grain size and the performance of the forgings ,and this is undesired. 4. PROVING THE “ ISLAND TEMPERATURE FIELD
(a)At the island area Figure. 6
”
PHENOMENON
ON
THE
(b) At the center
T h e sample microstructure
In theoretic analysis for the temperature field ,is it inevitable or a fault that the ” island” appears during calculation? To prove this, the following experiment was arranged :Use titanium alloy T C l l stocks 120 X 12Omm, the initial microstructure is a p. Given 70 percentage deformations to the stocks under two kinds of temperature: 1233K (9SO’C) and 1133K (860.C). T h e workpieces were forged into disks. Divided the disk in the center and observe the microstructure on the longitudinal direction. In the ” dead area” the microstructure is the
+
151
initial uniform c~ if- 13 . According to the elevated temperature microstructure observed, it is proved that near the island the temperature rose(shown in Fig. 6-a)and the microstructure at the center of the tested sample(Fig. 6-b) was equiaxial under the condition of low temperature (1133K). The experiment indicates undoubtedly that the heat area " island" exists, especially when the stock' s temperature is low. this will be a guide in theoretic analysising and process planning. 5. M O D E L I N G OF DEFORMATION
DYNAMIC
MATERIAL
BEHAVIOR
IN
HOT
A new method of modeling material behavior which accounts for the dynamic metallurgical processes occurring during hot deformation is presented. The approach in this method is to consider the workpiece as a dissipator of energy in the total processing system and to evaluate the dissipated energy co-content J =
jia.ao from the constitutive equation
relating the strain rate ( ~ ) to the flow stress ( a ) . The optimum processing conditions of temperature and strain rate are those corresponding to the maximum or peak in J. It is shown that J is related to the strain-rate sensitivity index ( m ) of the material and reaches a maximum value (Jma~)when m = 1. A typical constitutive relation for a simple dissipator is schematically represented in Figure 7 (a) in the form of the variation of flow stress with strain rate (flow)at constant temperature and strain. At any given strain r a t e , t h e power P (per unit volume) absorbed by the workpiece during plastic flow is given by
or
P=~247
J=Ii d~
In figure 7(a) total energe of dissipation is given by the rectangle,the area below the curve is G , t h e dissipator content,and the area above the curve is J, the dissipator co-content. The G term represents the energy dissipated by plastic work, most of which is converted into heat; the remaining small part is stored in the lattice defects. The dissipator cocontent J is related to the metallurgical mechanisms of occurred dynamic
152 heat dissipation.
J = COiCONTENT
FLOW STRESS
G+CONTENTI1 9, '
I
~-
1g
_
STPAIN RATE (a)
,-,~,~,~ , . ~ , ~ ,,,\x,, a~, \'\\5,
9
" '
'~':)~,~ " "
I
FLOw ~ ) ~ ~ f Y v m = 1II ST RESS Xk'~k~,~ ,,~z I I
STRAIN RATE (b) Figure 7 (a) Schematic representation of G content and J co-content
for workpiece having a constitutive
equation represented by curve a - - f ( e ) . ( b ) S c h e m a t i c representation showing Jm,x which occurs when strainrate sensitivity ( m ) of material is equal to one. ( F r o m
E4-1). The rate of the power dissipation ( J / J m a x ) through whole metallurgical processes is shown to be an index of the dynamic behavior of the material and is useful in obtaining a unique combination of processing temperature and strain rate and also in delineating the regions of internal fracture. Metallurgical processes such as dynamic recovery, dynamic recrystallization,internal fracture (void formation or wedge c r a c k i n g ) , separation or growth of particles or phases under
153 dynamic conditions,dynamic spheroidization of acicular s t r u c t u r e s , a n d deformation-induced phase transformation or precipitation under dynamic conditions contribute to the changes in the dissipated cocontent J. Let the rate of power dissipation be r/ J _ 2m 1 For processing of materials the most favorable conditions are those which provide the highest J dissipated in the most efficient fashion (highest r/) and lie within the "safe" regions.
Figure. 8
T C l l ( W ) stable working region ( E = 0 . 6)
The energy co-content J serves as the most useful index for characterizing dynamic material behavior in processing for the following reasons 9 1. It defines unique conbinations of T and ~ for processing (peak values of J and r/) and also distinguishes the regions which produce internal fracture. 2. It is a continuous parameter and can be integrated with the finiteelement analysis. From it ,an algorithm can be developed which can be incorporated into process defects control. T C l l is a a-b-t3 titanium alloy whose hot-working characteristics are
154 element analysis. From it ,an algorithm can be developed which can be incorporated into process defects control. TC11 is a a q-t3 titanium alloy whose hot-working characteristics are very sensitive to the initial microstructure and processing parameters. Fig 8 is an isograph of r/for T C l l (W) at 0. 6 strain. It shows TC11 (W) stable working region. 6. CONCLUSION Defects occurred in forging process of titanium alloy TC11 referred to complex energy field change and dynamics metallurgics behavior. 1. Coupled thermo-viscoplastic FEM simulation is the base for titanium alloy forging defects analysis. 2. Due to the deformation heat and the poor thermal conductivity for titanium alloy,the so--called isolated "island"exists in temperature field after forging process ,and it may induce local defect. 3. The dynamic metallurgy analysis offers useful referential judgement for optinum forging parameters choice and avoidance of defects. REFERENCES 1. G. D. Lahoti, T. Altan, Research to Develop Process Models for Producing a Dual Property Titanium Alloy Compressor Disk, AD/ Al12271 ,Interim Technical Report ,AFWAL-TR-81-4130,1"--7,19~21,52~'65,267~-324,Oct. 1981. 2. S. I. Oh, J. J. Park, S. Kobayashi, T. Altan, Application of FEM Modeling to Simulate Metal Flow in Forging a Titanium Alloy Engine Disk, Transactions of the ASME, November 198:], Vol. 105,251-258. 3. Chen Sencan, Hu Zongshi, Wang Shaolin, et al, Research on Forging Processes for Producing Two Phase Titanium Alloy T C l l Disks, Journal of Tsinghua University Vol. 32. No. $2 1992. 4. Y. V. R. K. Prasad, H. L. Gegel, et al, Modeling of Dynamic Material Behavior in Hot Deformation. Forging of Ti-6242, Metallurgical Transaction, Volume 15A, October 1984.
Materials Processing Defects S.K. Ghosh and M. Predeleanu (Editors) 9 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
155
M o d e l l i n g of F r a c t u r e I n i t i a t i o n in M e t a l f o r m i n g P r o c e s s e s Y.Y. Zhu, S. Cescotto and A.M. Habraken M.S.M. Department, University of Liege, 6 (BELGIUM)
Quai Banning, B-4000
LIEGE
Abstract
In this paper, two kinds of approaches for modelling the fracture initiation in metalforming processes are reviewed. One is an uncoupled approach based on various published fracture criteria; another one is a coupled approach based on the continuous damage mechanics. Recent development of energy-based isotropic damage model with two damage variables is described in some details. A viscous regularization of the Duvaut-Lions type is also proposed to take into account effects of strain rate and mesh sensitivity. Both fracture criteria and damage model have been implemented in finite element code and compared with experimental work. It leads to the conclusion that the described damage model is a powerful tool for predicting material processing defects.
1. I N T R O D U C T I O N Ductile fracture of metals implies the appearance of damage processes which grow gradually. Many investigations [1] have shown that ductile fracture involves four successive damage processes which are the nucleation of void from inclusions, void growth, void coalescence (onset of a crack) and cracking propagation. From the viewpoint of application in metalforming processes, it is very important to define the fracture event, because the ultimate stage of the workpieces is preceded by or corresponds to crack initiation and propagation. When a material is formed by processes as forging, rolling, drawing, etc. it experiences large unrecoverable deformations. These deformations load to the development of zones of high strain concentration and, consequently, the onset of internal or surface cracks. The strain localization is the cause of many defects. For example, free-surface cracks occur in such processes as upsetting, bending and rolling; internal cracks in extrusion and drawing and in some forging processes. Although the appearance of a crack during the deformation process is, in most of the cases, undesirable, in some particular situations of deep drawing for example, the initiation and propagation of a crack is sometimes expected in order to soften the behaviour of the sheet in a zone that will be cut off at the end of
156 drawing operation. Furthermore, during metal cutting, the removal of chips is only possible because cracks have been created in the machined part of the cutting tool. Thus cracking is an inherent part of such processes. For occurrence of surface cracks, the fracture criterion may be constructed experimentally. However, for predicting internal fracturing, formulations of fracture criteria under general deformation are required. Since damage processes still remain difficult to define and proper mechanical models are not yet fully developed, recently, many methods have been investigated. [2-4]. There are two kinds of approaches, including uncoupled and coupled ones. In the uncoupled approach, the damage is computed from the stress and strain fields but does not modify these fields. The onset of fracture is determined according to the fracture criteria using the classical constitutive laws. By using the finite element method in conjunction with the fracture criteria, numerical predictions of the fracture event and its initiation sites are obtained. Maps of each cumulative fracture criterion value are computed and a crack occurs where one criterium reaches or exceeds its threshold value experimentally measured. This approach is well adapted to the cases where the redistribution of the stresses due to damage can be neglected, and is thus generally sufficient for most initiation fracture analyses. For example, Oh et al [5] employed a rigid plastic finite element technique to examine the use of the Cockroft and Latham's criterion [6] and a modified version of the McClintock's criterion [7] to predict fracture in axisymmetric extrusion and drawing. Sowerby et al [8, 9], Dung [1013] used a rigid plastic finite element model to examine the capability of Mc Clintock's void growth model, Crockcroi~ and Latham's criterion and Oyane's formulation [14] to predict damage accumulation in the upsetting of steel specimens. Their numerical results showed that the McClintock's model is appropriate to assess the forgeability of some steels. Clii~ et al [15-17], Pillinger et al [18] and Hartley et al [19] presented an investigation on the ability of elastic-plastic finite element simulations to predict the initiation of ductile fracture in bodies undergoing large plastic deformation. They found that the criterion based on generalized plastic work (Freudenthal's model [20]) was the most successful. In the coupled approach, the damage processes are incorporated into the constitutive relations. In this case, the redistribution of stresses or strains due to the damage accumulation is taken into account. Prior to achieving the critical amount of damage, the stress distribution based on the coupled approach is similar to that obtained with the uncoupled one. However, the coupled method gives a more accurate numerical simulation because the damage development and stress drop continue aider the onset of void coalescence. Therefore, after local fracture initiation, further damage can cause stress redistributions that will automatically induce fracture propagation as long as the coalescence criterion is exceeded and the large crack extensions can be simulated continuously. This approach implemented in a finite element code allows the prediction of defect occurrence. For examples : Aravas [21] studied the behaviour of microvoids nucleated at second phase particles during direct axisymmetric extrusion, using large deformation finite element analysis together with Gurson's constitutive
157 model. Onate [22, 23] found a formal analogy between the equation of pure plastic and viscoplastic flow for void-containing metals (Gurson's model [24]) and those of standard nonlinear elasticity. According to this approach, the effect of nucleation, growth and coalescence of voids could be treated by classical nonlinear elasticity, that is, to allow standard finite element formulations developed for elastic problems to be used for the analysis of complex metalforming processes including the effects of voids. Predeleanu et al [25], Gelin [26] proposed a finite strain elastoplastic model incorporating ductile damage mechanisms of Lemaitre's theory [27]. Their model included the strain softening of the material when ductile fracture occurs. Tirosh [28] suggested a computational procedure to couple the porosity of the material and the impact loading for solving explosive forming processes with materials which obey Gurson's yield criterion. A more detailed review of the applications of second approach to metalforming processes can be found in [2-4]. A satisfactory coupled constitutive relation should not only describe the initiation and propagation of fracture but also check the efficiency of the fracture criterion. Therefore, it is still necessary to implement several fracture criteria into the coupled constitutive law, on the one hand to define the new damage variables, on the other hand to determine the critical values when the material points fracture [29].
2. F R A C T U R E CRITERIA There are a lot of fracture criteria. It is obviously advantageous to keep the number of experimentally determined parameters to a minimum [3]. In this paper, only six previously published fracture criteria are chosen. In the following formulae, Cl, c6 are the critical material dependent values, at fracture they are denoted by the subscript f; A, K are material constants to be determined from experiments; ~1, c2, ~3 are the principal stresses; ~m is the hydrostatic stress; ~, e are the equivalent stress and strain. 2.1. F r e u d e n t h a r s m o d e l Freudenthal [20] proposed that the absorbed energy per unit volume is the critical parameter at fracture, that is 9
~o etude =Cl
(1)
This criterion does not consider the influence of hydrostatic stress and high tensile stress explicitely. 2.2. C o c k c r o f t - L a t h a m ' s m o d e l Cockroft and Latham [6] proposed that it is the principal tensile stress, rather than the equivalent stress, which is important in fracture initiation. They postulated that fracture occurs when the integral of the largest tensile principal stress component over the plastic strain path to fracture equals a critical value for the material, namely : m
= c:
<2)
158 This criterion does not take into account the influence of hydrostatic stress explicitely on fracture. 2.3. Brozzo's m o d e l Brozzo et al [30] proposed an empirical modification of Cockrot~ and Latham's model to consider the effect of hydrostatic stress explicitely. The modified equation is presented in the following form" .~o e
2~ 1
3(Ol-Om)
(3)
de =c3
2.4. G h o s h ' s m o d e l Ghosh [31] proposed a fracture criterion for plane strain state based on the statistical process of shear joining of voids in sheet metalforming. Here, we extend it to three dimensional state, that is 9 (~1 + ~2 + ~3)(~1 - c~3) = c4 (4) 2.5. O y a n e ' s m o d e l
Oyane et al [14] considered a void growth model and postulated that" (5) 2.6. M c C l i n t o c k ' s
model
McClintock et al [7] analyzed the expansion of long cylindrical cavities under a triaxial system of fixed orientation. They derived a closed form expression for the damage accumulation 9 I
~/3(1- n) sh
2
~
=
(6)
where n is the work hardening exponent of the material which obeys the following power hardening law 9 o=Ke n (7) There are two other equations for the coalescence of voids with their axes parallel to the other principal tensile stresses. m
3. A FULLY C O U P L E D I S O T R O P I C E L A S T O P L A S T I C DAMAGE M O D E L There exist many coupled constitutive models for local approach of ductile fracture, such as Gurson's models [24, 32], Perzyna's model [33], Lemaitre's model [27], Rousselie's model [1], Ladev~ze's model [34], Simo-Ju's model [35]. In the nonlinear finite element code LAGAMINE (developed in MSM Department, University of Liege), elastoplastic Gurson's law, damage Ladev~ze's law have been introduced. More recently, new fully coupled elasto-(visco)-plastic damage models for isotropic and anisotropic materials have been implemented [29]. Hereai~er, the isotropic damage model will be reviewed briefly.
159 3.1. D a m a g e v a r i a b l e s The damage variables, based on various equivalence hypothesis, represent the average material degradation which reflects the various types of damage at the microscale like nucleation and growth of void, microcracks and other microscopic defects. Ladev~ze [34] suggested a damage model with two scalar parameters d (deviatoric component) and 8 (volumetric component) by which not only the elastic modulus but also Poisson's ratio can vary with the damage growth. In this paper, these two damage variables are used. The true stress tensor g_can be transformed into the effective stress tensor G with the help of the damage variables d, 5, viz G' Gm G' = - -1-d'
Gm =
(8)
1-5
with G' the deviatoric stress tensor, Gin the hydrostatic stress. The coefficients (l-d) and (1-8) in (1) are reduction factors associated with the amount of damage in thematerial. 3.2. Equivalence
Hypotheses
For continuum damage models, various equivalence hypotheses have been proposed in order to transform the damage state into virgin state, such as strain equivalence [27], stress equivalence [35], elastic energy equivalence (Cordebois and Sidoroff [36]). From the viewpoint of energy conservation, the energy equivalence may be of more physical significance. In this paper, we propose an extension of this hypothesis, in the case of the two damage variables d, 8 model. Finally we can obtain the following relations between damaged material and virgin material.
e_. =e_ (1-d),em=em(1-8),ePq=ePq(1-d)
(9)
Here, e' is the deviatoric strain tensor, am the average strain, eePq the equivalent plastic strain. 3.3. P l a s t i c yield s u r f a c e The yield function Fp used in this paper is made of the energy-based Von Mises yield criterion with both isotropic and kinematic hardening, in the form : Fp
V
4--G~l:dfi- - R ~
R(a)
(10)
in which 2: is the deviatoric component of the shii~ stress tensor 2, Ro denotes initial plastic hardening threshold; R is plastic hardening threshold; a is accumulated plastic energy variable. Fig. 1 shows the corresponding yield surface for different values of the damage variables. We can see that with the growth of damage, the elastic region is reduced.
160 .o2/ay
!o o. l,,i
2.
O.
d=O-
~
.
"
.5
.o.s
i
.2
.2
/ -x'.5
d,-O.
9
~
allay q.
9
1./-(!
.///. -
l.s
z
Fig. 1 Plastic yield surface 3.4.
Damage
evolution
surface
In order to describe the growth of damage, several damage evolution criteria can be defined, such as, strain-based criterion [27, 37], stress-based criterion [38, 39], energy-based criterion (Ladev~ze [34]). In the present model, a modified energy-based damage evolution criterion is proposed: Fd = - Y d - < x > YS-Bo-B(I 3) G"G' < 1;>G2 (11) = 9 +__m _ Bo_B(~) 2G(I- d)3 9((I-8)3 With the definition, < ~ > = 8/d forGm >0; (12) 0 forGm_< 0 the difference of mechanical effects observed under tension and compression states can be described. Here B o denotes initialdamage strengthening; B is the damage strengthening threshold, [3is overall damage. The physical meaning of (11) is that the negative hydrostatic component does not contribute to damage evolution. Fig. 2 displays the evolution of the initial damage surface in stress space.
=o
~ _ _ ~ = 0 .
Fig. 2 Damage evolution surface
161 3.5. V i s c o u s r e g u l a r i z a t i o n of i n v i s c i d d a m a g e m o d e l s The local approach of ductile fracture based on the coupled constitutive theory is a useful tool to predict initiation in ductile fracture condition and enables the analysis of the propagation of completely damaged zones. However, developments are still needed especially in the case of very localized zones to handle the possible instabilities and bifurcation of the solution corresponding to local strain softening or loss of positive definiteness of the global stiffness matrix [40]. In rate independent materials, the localization corresponds to a bifurcation of the local behaviour of the material and to the occurrence of strain rate jumps through singular surfaces [37]. In some cases capturing the shear band of localization have the problem associated to the mesh dependency. Viscous regularization seems to be one of powerful approach to solve localization problem associated to material softening [35, 41, 42]. In fact, in viscous models, there are no plastic and damage consistency conditions, thus no strain rate jumping phenomenon [40]. On the other hand rate dependence naturally introduces a length-scale into the dynamic initial boundary value problem. In the present isotropic model, there exists non-smooth corner regions between the plastic yield surface and the damage evolution surface. The softening phenomenon can be captured with this model. As an extension of the proposal of Simo et al [44] for non-smooth multi-surface viscoplasticity and the suggestion of Loret and Prevost [42, 43] for softening elastoplasticity, we construct the viscous regularization of the present rate independent damage model by Duvaut-Lions form [45] as : ~(0) + At / * -n+l n ~n+l -~ = l+At /[t n -Tn(0) + l + At n /ktT* -n+l -Tn+l = l+At /kt n
qn+l=
qn +At n /l.tqn - +1 l+At /~
(13)
n ,
in which, qn + 1 is the vector of state variables, (~(0) (0) are the solutions n+l and Tn+l , * of the elastic predictor step, ~ n + l , T n + l are the inviscid solutions of isotropic elastoplastic damage models, ~ is the viscosity coefficient. More details on this model can be found in [29]. 4. N U M E R I C A L EXAMPLES AND D I S C U S S I O N S 4.1. D y n a m i c forging and fracture c r i t e r i a As an attractive example, let us consider a dynamic contact modelling of steel forging at 1150~ with the uncoupled approach. High strain rates and large variations of the contact area are effective in this example. The material
162 properties of the workpiece are assumed to be represented by an elasto-viscoplastic constitutive equation [46] in which all the parameters are determined according to the given temperature 9Young's elastic modulus E = 1.2 x 105 MPa; Poisson's ratio = 0.4; strain rate exponent n = 9.259; strain rate coefficient B = 0.034; initial yield limit K o = 50 MPa; the mass density p = 7800 kg/m 3. For definition of contact elements, the penalty coefficient on the contact pressure Kp = K~ = 5 x 1013 N/m 3 and the Coulomb's friction coefficient ~ = 0.3 are chosen.
discretiz~
a crack appears here
i
plane O!symmetrY ,
i i
before forging
after forging
Fig. 3 Dynamic forging This simulation corresponds to a practical case of metalforming in which a fracture was observed during the forming process. Although the actual piece was three dimensional, the region in which the crack developed could be adequately modelled as axisymmetric (fig. 3). Furthermore, due to the existence of an horizontal plane of symmetry, only one half of the piece is discretized. Since the strains are very large, the choice of an appropriate initial finite element mesh becomes a very important aspect. In fact, it is necessary to make sure that the simulation results are practically mesh independent. Therefore, three different meshes are used (fig. 4) 9'2~IESHI" 6-node firfite elements with constant mesh density; '2VIESH2" 6-node finite elements with variable mesh density; '2VIESH3" 8-node finite elements with variable mesh density. Fig. 4 shows the initial meshes (solid line) together with corresponding deformed configurations (dashed line) at time t=0.5 ms obtained by implicit dynamic scheme. At this time, fracture initiation sites of workpiece near the comer of the die can be observed experimentally. On fig. 4, we can observe that the elements near the right corner of the die are severely distorted. This means that the finite element mesh should be refined in the region of the flash and that the solution presented on fig. 4 does not model the flash with precision. However, we are more interested in the region near the lef~ re-entrant comer of the die, where the mesh is not too distorted. All the numerical simulatin show that the accumulative values of the six fracture criteria present a very sharp maximum near this corner at time t = 0.5 ms. These values are given in table 1. The location of these maxima are indicated by a cross on fig. 5 (the results are those given by implicit dynamic simulation with MESH3). On the same figures, other crosses appear, in the flash region. This means that the accumulative values at these Gauss integration
163 points are equal or larger than at the point near the left comer. Hence, in the flash, there are some points at which the critical value is larger than at the point near the lef~ corner of the die. However the flash will be cut off at the end of the forging process. Furthermore, it was pointed out that the solution in the flash is not reliable because of the excessive mesh distortion.
(a) mesh 1
(b) mesh 2
j.
(c) mesh 3
Fig. 4 Initial and deformed meshes
i Criterion Mesh 1 Implicit Mesh 2 Implicit Explicit Mesh 3 Implicit
I
Table 1. V ~ u e of fracture criteria 1 2 3 4 8.84 2.03 1.23 4.02 6.85 1.12 0.70 20.1 7.05 1.22 0.76 20.2 9.17 0.91 0.66 16.0
5 0.45 0.29 0.32 0.27
6 3.16 2.51 2.63 3.31
,.
Table 1 shows the broad agreement of accumulative values of each criterion given by different meshes and different time integration schemes. The differences may be due to the discretizations. Fig. 5 indicates that the fracture initiation locations based on each criterion are almost the same, and the damage accumulations are very local near the lef~ corner of the die which is confirmed by the experimental results. This may be due to the existence of high stress concentrations and localization of strains near this corner.
164
~
kp
(a) c r l t e r i o n - i
(b) c r l t e r l o n - 2
(c) c r i t e r i o n - 3
(d) crlterlon-4
(e) c r l t e r l o n - 5
(f) crlterlon-6
Fig. 5 Fracture criteria for mesh 3
165 4.2. C o l l a r tests, c o m p a r i s o n s b e t w e e n e x p e r i m e n t s , f r a c t u r e c r i t e r i a
and damage theory The upsetting of a circular cylinder is often used to assess the cold forgeability, but with ductile materials, the test can result in excessively high loads before surface cracking occurs. To overcome this difficulty, some alternative upsetting procedures are described in literature and so-called collar tests are recommended when studying the upsetting of ductile materials [8-11]. The collar tests often result in lower fracture strains in comparison with the upsetting of the circular cylinder [8]. In the present collar tests, two kinds of specimens are used : specimen with one flange as shown in fig. 6.a; specimen with three flanges as seen in fig. 6.b. The ratio of the height to the diameter must be low enough to prevent buckling but large enough to give sufficient deformation to induce fracture. All the tests were terminated when a surface crack could be detected with the naked eye.
COMPLEX UPSE'IqqNG (COLLAR TESTING)
J
l
t ee~
l
,
I
I
20
2O , -
t----
t__.
30
~
--|
3O
(b) with three flanges
(a) with one flange
Fig. 6 Sizes of collar specimens (a) with one flange (b) with three flanges.
~(MPa)
B+Bo (MPa)
//
~}0.,
3~).
200.
20.
I00.
I0.
~.
~b.
p(~)
:~. ~. ~(s)
(a) effective stress - strain c u r v e
(b) damage evolution
Fig. 7 Material properties of aluminium
166 The isotropic damage constitutive law for aluminium is determined with a uniaxial tensile test [29]. The resulting p a r a m e t e r s are : E = 7.47 x 1010 Pa, v = 0.333, ~ = 3.5; ~ = 10 -5 s; the effective stress-strain curve for virgin material and the damage B-~ curve are shown in fig. 7. For contact, the Coulomb's friction coefficient ~ = 0.17 is used.
Fig. 8 Final deformation at fracture (a) specimen with one flange, (b) specimen with three flanges Fig. 8 shows the experimental results of final deformation at fracture for bush specimens respectively. The cracks appear to propagate inwards to a depth of 2 to 3 m m and cover the full height of the collar. It is also found t h a t these cracks are at approximately 45 ~. It means t h a t the flange at the equatorial free surface is fracturing with a "shear-type" failure mode. At high height reduction, some other smaller cracks n e a r the contacting sites between the free surface of body and the flanges can be observed for the collar test with three flanges. The theoretical distributions of Von Mises stress, of deviatoric and volumetric damage variables, and of the six fracture criteria are shown in fig. 9. As expected, the m a x i m u m values of volumetric damage variable 5 and fracture criteria 2 to 4 are located in the collar. In general, the hydrostatic stress o m becomes larger at the equatorial free surface. Cracks are usually formed there owing to high tensile state where the Von Mises stress may not be too high. The distribution of fracture criterion 1 and criterion 6 are similar but they do not give ideal prediction of fracture for the present collar tests.
167
Fig. 9 Distribution of stress, damage and fracture criteria at 50 % height reduction ((a) for specimen with one flange)
168
Fig. 9 Distribution of stress, damage and fracture criteria at 50 % height reduction ((b) for specimen with three flanges)
169 5. C O N C L U S I O N S AND REMARKS In this paper, two approaches for modelling of fracture initiation in metalforming processes have been presented. The uncoupled approach based on various fracture criteria which is very easily introduced in any structural analysis code. The corresponding postprocessing induces very low extra computation costs. This approach is generally justified if the redistribution of stresses and strains due to damage can be neglected and is thus generally suited for most predictions of fracture initiation. However, it should be pointed out that until now, none of the criteria mentioned in this paper could adequately describe the observed behaviour for all types of experiments [29]. In reality, the plastic damage, loading ultimately to failure, can be caused by many different mechanisms, such as internal and external necking, large shear deformation, nucleation, growth and coalescence of voids and so on. Any one or more mechanisms can cause final rupture. Therefore in order to predict fracture initiation, several criteria should be implemented together, each of them describing more accurately the different mechanisms. The fully coupled approach based on the continuum damage theory is of course the most attractive one. In this paper, an energy-based isotropic damage model has been proposed to characterize microcrack initiation and growth in ductile materials. Rate-dependent effects are accommodated and the numerical problem of mesh dependency is improved by means of viscoplastic regularization of Duvaut-Lions' type. Therefore the proposed damage model is a useful tool for modelling of fracture initiation and propagation in metalforming processes. Our further research will be focused on the extension of the present model to a new one with non local damage framework in order to completely avoid the meshdependency problem.
REFERENCES G. Rousselier, Nuclear Engineering, Design, 105 (1987) 97. 2. M. Predeleanu, Computational Methods for Predicting Material Processing Defects, Elsevier, (1987), 295. Y.Y. Zhu and S. Cescotto, Programme mobilisateur multimat~riaux de la r~gion wallonne, n ~ 1, Contrat n ~ 1758 (1991). J.C. G~lin and M. Predeleanu, NUMIFORM'92, (1992) 214. 5. S.L. Oh, C.C. Chen and S. Kobayashi, Trans. of ASME, 101 (1979) 36. 6. M.G. Cockroft and D.J. Latham, J. Inst. Metals, 96 (1968) 33. 7. F.A. McClintock, J. Appl. Mech. 35 (1968) 363. 8. R. Sowerby et al., J. Engng Maters. Tech., 106 (1984) 101. 9. R. Sowerby et al, VDI-Forschung im Ingenieurween 5 -(1985) 51. 10. N.L. Dung, Forsh. Ing. - Wes., 50 -1984) 55. 11. N.L. Dung, NUMIFORM'86 (1986) 261. 12. N.L. Dung, PLASTICITY~89 (1989) 53. 13. N.L. Dung, PLASTICITY'91 (1991) 607. 14. M. Oyane, Bulletin of JSME, 15 (1972) 1507. 15. S.E. Clift et al., 25th MTDR, Birmingham (1985) 413. 16. S.E. Clift et al, Int. J. Mech. Sci., 32 (1990) 1. o
o
,
170 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43. 44. 45. 46.
S.E. Clift, Numerical Modelling of Material Deformation Processes, Springer (1992) 406. I. Pillinger et al, Int. J. Num. Meth. Engng, 25 (1988) 87. P. Hartley et al, Res. Mech., 28 (1989) 269. A.M. Freudenthal, The inelastic behaviour of engineering materials and structures, Wiley, New-York (1950). N. Aravas, J. Mech. Phys. Solids, 34 (1986) 55. E. Onate and M. Kleiber, NUMIFORM'86, (1986) 339. E. Onate and M. Kleiber, Int. J. Num. Meth. Engng, 25 (1988) 27. A.L. Gurson, J. Engng Maters. Tech., 99 (1977) 2. M. Predeleanu et al, NUMIFORM'86, (1986) 277. J.C. G~lin, Ann. CIRP 35 (1986) 157. J. Lema~tre, J. Engng Maters. Tech., 107 (1985) 83. J. Tirosh and .D Iddan, J. Mater. Proc. Tech., 24 (1990) 203. Y.Y. Zhu, Doctoral Thesis, MSM, University of Liege, (1992). P. Brozzo et al, 7th Biennal Conf. (1972). A.K. Ghosh, Metal. Trans., 7A (1976) 523. V. Tvergrrad and A. Needleman, Acta Metall. 32 (1984) 157. P. Perzyna, Int. J. Solid Stru., 22 (1986) 797. P. Ladev~ze, Rapport interne n ~ 34, LMT, Cachan, 1984. J.C. Simo and J.W. Ju, Comp. Mech., 5 (1989) 375. J.P. Cordebois and F. Sidoroff, EUROMECH 115 (1979). A. Benallal et al, Cracking and Damage, Elsevier (1989) 295. C.L. Chow and J. Wang, Engng Frac. Mech., 30 (1988) 83. G.Z. Voyiadjis and P.I. Katton, Int. J. Engng. Sci. 28 (1990) 505. A. Benallal, R. Billardon and J. Lema~tre, Comp. Meth. Appl. Mech. Engng, 92 (1991), 141. O. Harireche, B. Loret, Eur. J. Mech. A/Vll (1992) 733. B. Loret and J.H. Prevost, Comp. Meth. Appl. Mech. Engng 83 (1990) 247. J.H. Prevost and B. Loret, Comp. Meth. Appl. Mech. Engng 83 (1990) 275. J.C. Simo et al, Int. J. Num. Meth. Engng, 26 (1988) 2161. G. Duvaut and J.L. Lions, Les in~quations en m~canique et en physique, Dunod, Paris (1977). S. Cescotto and R. Charlier, SMIRT'85 (1985).
Materials Processing Defects S.K. Ghosh and M. Predeleanu (Editors) 9 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
171
Formability determination for production control John A. Schey Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Waterloo Waterloo, Ontario, Canada N2L 3G1
ABSTRACT A critical feature of pressworking is that sheet contact with the die surface delays strain localization and subsequent failure. Therefore, basic tests such as the tension test and other inplane forming tests show relatively poor correlation with production performance. Only simulation tests--such as the limiting dome height (LDH), stretch-bend, and hole-expansion tests--that also involve tool/sheet contact have the potential for good correlation. This means, however, that variables relating to geometry, tribology, and other process parameters are introduced. If tests are to yield reproducible, meaningful information, the effect of these variables must be understood. Extensive round-robin tests will have to be conducted before any of the tests can be accepted as general standards.
1. I N T R O D U C T I O N Formability is a technological property and as such suffers from a vagueness of definition that results from the complexity of the reality to which it refers. Definitions can be deceptively simple: "Formability is the technical term used to describe the relative ease with which a metal can be shaped through plastic deformation" or "the ability of a material to undergo plastic deformation without fracture" [1]. Although some view formability as synonymous with workability, here we will limit the term to describe the ease of shaping in sheet metalworking, with workability more appropriately reserved for bulk deformation processes. Translation of the definition into practical terms is difficult, because formability is a system property. It may sometimes be strongly related to a material property, but more frequently it depends on unique combinations of several material properties and process variables. Complex forming processes usually combine several modes of forming, requiring different formability measures at various locations of the stamping and during different stages of the forming process. The main task is to find appropriate descriptors of formability and then develop tests that allow the determination of these properties. A simulative test for formability assessment must duplicate the critical strain state or forming mode found in the actual process. It should also be relatively be simple so that reproducible, unambiguous results can be obtained. Several valuable contributions to the subject have appeared in journals as well as books and conference volumes [2-10]; the present review surveys progress in the more recent time period, moving from applied to basic tests.
172 2. D R A W A B I L I T Y The drawing of deep cups, in which average sheet thickness remains essentially unchanged, represents a special case in that formability, now better termed drawability, is linked to the plastic anisotropy of the sheet, as expressed by the r value [11, 12]. The primary measure of drawability remains the limiting draw ratio (LDR) which can be readily and quite reproducibly determined in cupping tests [2, 13], provided that tooling configuration, blankholder pressure, press speed, and surface topography of the tooling are clearly specified. Friction is a powerful variable but can be neutralized by the use of oiled polyethylene sheet. Plastic anisotropy reflects the preferred orientation of crystals (texture) in the sheet. Texture also results in differences in elastic properties and hence in the speed of propagation of sound waves. This allows the ultrasonic determination of r values (see [ 14]). Commercial instruments are suitable for static measurements; recent efforts aim at techniques for measuring the r value on line, on sheet moving at 150 m/min, with a resolution of r to 0.05 or better [ 15].
3. F O R M I N G
LIMIT DIAGRAM
(FLD)
The most significant development of the last decades has been the introduction of the FLD (also known as the Keeler-Goodwin diagram) to describe forming limits under strain states ranging from balanced biaxial tension through plane strain to combined tension/compression. An entire volume [7] is devoted to the subject, and it will suffice here to look only at selected recent developments. Continuing progress is being made in the test technique itself. The use of strips of varying widths was introduced by Nakazima et al [16]. The technique now used was established by Hecker (see [17]): gridded specimens of varying widths are firmly clamped and stretched, under well-lubricated conditions, with a punch of 100 mm or 4 in (101.6 mm) diameter, until localized necking is observed or the maximum load is sensed. The strain ratio in the vicinity of the neck is obtained from the distorted circles of the grid, giving points on the forming limit curve (FLC). The standard technique was given in 1981 [ 18] together with the application of the grid technique to die development and troubleshooting. The tedium and uncertainties associated with manual measurement of circles are alleviated by computer-based image-analysis techniques [19, 20]. Surface strains have also been measured by taking two views of the surface [21, 22]. Yet faster results were obtained by the use of a camera to take photos of the grid during the deformation process itself, together with photos of a reference grid, so that strains could be immediately computed [23]. It remains difficult to decide what circle to take as the definitive one: the technique described by Bragard [24] uses parabolic interpolation but has, apparently, not been widely adopted. The shape and elevation of the FLC are a function of material properties, punch speed (strain rate), grid size, and even of the definition accepted for necking. Since substantial straining may be accommodated by diffuse necking, sheet thickness is a powerful factor by providing more material for deformation prior to the onset of local necking. For typical lowcarbon steels, Keeler and Brazier [25] found that the position of the plane-strain intercept (in percent) is defined by sheet thickness t (mm) and strain hardening exponent n: FLCo = a (23.3 + 14.1 t)
173 where a = n/0.21 (max. 1). Many recently introduced steels give a better fit if a = n/0.21 is used without limitation. It is then assumed that all steels have a FLC of the same, "standard" shape (Fig. I), hence it is sufficient for control purposes to determine only n for each coil. A safety zone of 10% can be added to account for process variability [ 18].
.
~\
80
STANDARD" FLC
"
111,,1
I--Or)ooC_)
<1~
\~ fl/-
-
x_10%,SAFETY
20-
ZONE
i
0
I , I I
-4O-20 MINOR
,
I
, I i I
0 2O 4O STRAIN , %
60
Fig. 1 Forming limit diagrams [18, 26]
The tacit assumption is that the limit strain is independent of strain-rate sensitivity (m value). However, it is clear--as discussed under Tension Test--that the m value has powerful influence on post-necking strain. Thus, it is reasonable to base the correlation on total (final) elongation in the tension test ef. Indeed, Raghavan et al [26] propose the relation FLCo = 2.78 + 3.24t + 0.892 ef where ef is the total elongation in percent of a transverse tensile specimen of 50.8 mm gage length. Furthermore, they use a "standard" shape that has gradual transition at plane strain (Fig. 1), similar to that found by Hecker [17]. The formula gives better agreement with experimental FLCo values than the one based on n, especially for the newer steels, including interstitial-free, bake-hardening, and coated steels. Whether two materials have the same formability is usually judged from a visual comparison of their FLCs. Buchar [27] argues that judgment should be based on statistical evaluation. It has long been recognized that the FLD is affected also by the strain path and that a production part formed along a non-linear path may fail either below or beyond the strain predicted by the standard FLC. Predictive work is difficult but beginnings have been made. Thus, Tse et al [28] developed a multilinear semi-empirical model to show the effect of a sequence of operations on the position of the FLC. They also performed three-dimensional grid analysis, evaluating strains from square arrays of grid points with a two-view system [21 ] and calculating the remaining ductility (taken as the residual n value) for each operation. The volume of metals does not change with plastic deformation. Thus, forming severity may be simply judged from thickness measured with a micrometer or ultrasonic gage [29]. Since the sum of natural (logarithmic) strains is zero, the maximum tensile strain can be calculated from
174 the thickness strain and minor strain. Minor strain is known to be zero at plane strain, hence here major strain equals through-thickness strain in absolute value. For the convenience of press-shop operators, a thickness strain diagram can be constructed which gives permissible thickness reductions, if desired, with a 10% safety zone. Away from plane strain the magnitude of minor strains must be detected by grid analysis; from this, permissible major strain is calculated for different parts of the pressing. Subsequent production control or die development efforts rely simply on measured thickness. Again, for the convenience of operators, diagrams or look-up tables can be constructed [30]. The FLC can be considered a property of the material, with the understanding that strain rates, strain paths, and in-plane vs. out-of-plane measurement can affect the result. The application of the FLC (or thickness strain analysis) is most powerful, however, as a tool for measuring the state and performance of the entire forming system. This can include the combined effects of the material, lubricant, stamping design (strain state and magnitude), tooling, stamping press, and even ambient conditions such as temperature and humidity [31]. Its application, however, is limited to existing processes; no information is available prior to designing and building the forming system. The results, while measuring the quality or state of the process, are nonspecific regarding appropriate measures for remedial steps or improvements to the process. Operator experience and, frequently, further testing are required to isolate a problem.
4. L I M I T I N G
DOME HEIGHT (LDH) TEST
The FLD provides a most powerful tool for production control but requires considerable effort. Furthermore, an FLC based of n or ef is often not sensitive enough to separate good coils from bad ones. There remains thus a need for tests that evaluate stretch formability with less effort. Such tests have been around for some eighty years. The Erichsen test has been widely used in Europe, the Olsen test in North America. Neither of them correlate with press performance for several reasons: some draw-in is always possible, the biaxiality of stress state is significant and difficult to control, and the small punch radius introduces a considerable bending component and makes results greatly dependent on sheet thickness [32, 33]. The Fukui test [2] gives a combined measure of stretchability and drawability. The newer dome tests are variants of the FLD determination method. Firmly clamped sheet specimens are deformed to fracture with a relatively large hemispherical punch, and the stress state is changed by varying the width of the specimen.
4.1.
Development of test method
In 1975 Ghosh [34] proposed that formability relevant to production conditions could be determined if gridded blanks of widths resulting in near-zero minor strain were tested. The critical minor strain measured next to the fracture site is plotted against specimen width. Similarly, the minor strain in the critical area of the press-formed part is determined. From the plot of minor strain vs. specimen width, the specimen width that reproduces the critical minor strain in the pressing can be chosen. The quality of sheets can then be routinely checked by performing dome tests at this width, with dome height as the critical value. A further simplification is introduced from the observation that some 85% of failures in stampings occur at or near plane strain [33]. One may dispense with the grid and plot dome
175 height vs. specimen width. The plot goes through a minimum, denoted as LDHo or simply LDH. Good correlation with press shop performance [33, 35] encouraged a significant cooperative development effort by the North American Deep Drawing Research Group (NADDRG), leading to a recommended referee practice [36]. Specimen widths are changed in 3-ram increments until two blank widths on each side of a minimum height value are obtained. The critical blank width is that which produces the minimum average dome height; five more tests are conducted at this width. The LDH value is then the average dome height of the eight blanks, reported to one decimal place in mm. It should be noted that there is a positive minor strain, as there would also be in a practical pressing. To find the intercept at plane strain, the specimen would have to be gridded or, at least, two parallel lines scribed at the expected fracture site [37]. At plane strain, however, discrimination is often reduced [37, 38]). Blank width, number of tests, and standard deviation of dome heights are reported. Test conditions appear to be well defined, and recent round-robin tests organized by the NADDRG [36] showed that reproducibility was acceptable within each participating laboratory, with standard deviations of 0.076 to 0.2 mm. However, the means ranged from 32.2 to 34.8 mm, a range wide enough to qualify the material as good or bad from a practical point of view. Evidently, test parameters were not adequately controlled. The LDH is a system property and, if reproducible results are to be obtained, it is essential that influencing factors be understood. In addition to laboratory investigations, substantial efforts were expended also in industrial applications [39 ].
4.2. Test geometry Test geometry is reasonably well fixed. The punch is a hemisphere (often a half ball-beating ball) of 100 mm or 101.6 mm (4 in) diameter. Smaller punches have been used, e.g., 75 mm [37], but this changes the ratio of sheet thickness to punch radius and increases the limit strain. Hence absolute values of LDH should not be compared for sheets of different thicknesses [35]. A small change in punch diameter from 100 to 101.6 mm, however, has no effect [40]. Greater variations exist in binder design. Cavity diameter and radius are well defined and small deviations from the specifications are of little significance. More important is lockbead configuration. The original design incorporated a triangular lock bead with a conforming female die. In the course of time the groove in the female die was changed to a square with little effect on the strain state or LDH. Yet later the binder surface was relieved by 0.075 mm from the bead inward [36]. This leads to more draw in, necessitating a slightly wider blank and increasing the LDH by some 0.5 mm [40]. Thus, results obtained with different binder designs are not comparable. Wear of tooling used in quality-control applications can also be sufficient to affect the results.
4.3. Binder (clamp) force. The test results critically depend on the absence of draw in, specified [36] as not more than 0.25 mm measured in the center of lock beads. Evidently, the clamp force required depends on bead design and friction on the binder surface. With the standard design and a smooth (ground) surface, Meuleman et al [41] found 200 kN sufficient for sheet of 0.84 mm thickness. Metals Handbook [2] indicates 250 kN. A systematic investigation confirmed that 250 kN is required to prevent draw in [42]. Below this, both mean dome height and scatter increase (Fig. 2); this is a potential problem with machines used in several quality-control laboratories [39].
176
131 m
34.0
130
E E
129 -iI-c3
E E
128 33.0
127 ~
I a
126
J
-125o
32.0
I I00
31.0 0
1 200 CLAMP
1 300
I 400
FORCE,
kN
i 500
Fig. 2 Effect of clamp force on LDH [42]
4.4. I n t e r f a c e conditions Friction determines, at a given blank width, the strain distribution in the course of stretching. It is imperative, therefore, that friction be controlled and made highly reproducible. Many factors, mutually interacting, determine friction, hence a strict procedure for surface preparation and lubrication must be followed. Sheets are usually supplied with mill oil of often unspecified or unknown composition on their surface. A logical step would be to remove this oil and test in the "dry" condition. Friction is high, forcing the fracture site away from the pole, and plane-strain conditions are readily attained. Dome height is low and sensitive to material properties such as the n value [32, 33, 35] but, in repeated testing of the same sheet, random variations are often observed [41 ]. 34.0
-J
_ 335 33.0
E "
32.5
O J
-
i
~ ~
~
~
~
o
z
t " ~" o', -
a,.
5
"-" ~ j e"i 5
w D
~
-~"'
u
~0~ ~ o
~
o
o_
~ o
w D
~
f
o_
-
~ w
32.0
-3
31.0
Fig. 3 Changes in LDH with surface preparation and lubrication [44]
177 The problem is common to all metalworking tests [43]. Polar cleaning fluids remove lubricant residues quite effectively but can form patchy EP films of their own, leading to higher LDH values (Fig. 3) [44]. Acetone, while popular, does not remove all oil [38, 44, 45]. If a dry surface is problematic, a slightly lubricated one may be acceptable. The simplest method is based on wiping the sheet surface, spreading out and removing excess mill oil. This has been adopted for quality control [39] but can give problems in comparisons of materials from different sources. Better reproducibility is obtained [44] by first removing mill oil residues with a non-polar solvent such as mineral spirits (paint thinner) and then applying a lowviscosity lubricant such as the so-called mineral seal oil of 4.6 cSt viscosity at 38 ~ (this is similar to the wash oil used by Meuleman et al [41 ]). Heavier oils increase dome height and, more importantly, the scatter of results (Fig. 3), no doubt because the strain ratio becomes more variable as fracture moves closer to the apex, as noted also by Ayres [38]. Reacted residues of mill oil can affect the results, as shown by much higher LDH found on sheets immersed in oleic acid or chlorinated paraffin for several weeks [44]. Reacted films can be removed by pickling, but surface topography could change with unknown consequences. LDH values stabilize only after the interface reaches equilibrium. An important part of the standard process is, therefore, conditioning of the tooling by drawing ten dummy blanks, the readings of which are ignored. Punch surface becomes even more important in the testing of coated (e.g., galvanized) sheet, since metal transfer (pick-up) would, if not removed, affect subsequent tests even on bare steel [37]. This can be particularly disturbing in industrial quality control where a large variety of sheet materials are tested in quick succession. It appears, however, that wiping the tooling with dry paper towel is adequate; any disturbing effects disappear after ten samples are tested [39].
4.5. Temperature Testing in a press shop environment introduces further variables such as temperature. Superimposed on changes in ambient temperature are localized changes, primarily from heating of the punch due to heating of the hydraulic oil used for operating most test equipment. Higher temperature lowers the viscosity of oil at the interface and reduces the LDH, signifying increased friction (Fig. 4). This leads to the conclusion--supported by observations of the deformed sheet surface--that the test operates in the mixed-film lubrication regime. Hence, increasing temperature should also reduce the LDH, and this has indeed been observed, with a decline of some 0.5 mm over a temperature range from 25 ~ to 45 ~ [45, 46]. The widely divergent results below 25 ~ indicate a further influencing factor. Tests conducted in the winter followed the trend expected from changes in lubricant viscosity. In contrast, those conducted in the summer showed a precipitous drop in LDH at 15 ~ where water condenses on the punch preventing the development of a continuous, effective oil film. These effects can be minimized by heating the tooling to 38 ~ [39].
4.6. Punch s p e e d Not all test facilities are capable of developing the recommended speed of 250 mm/min. The effect of speed is somewhat controversial [36, 47]. In tests with dry interfaces, Ayres [38] found with increasing speed a slight increase in LDH for aluminum-killed steel and a definite decrease for 2024-T4 aluminum. He attributed the difference, at least in part, to the positive and negative strain-rate sensitivities of the two materials, respectively.
178
[4s]
VISCOSITY, cSt
x
o 4.6
I o
33
[46]I
38~
x4.7ot
62
at
38~
38oc
~------~ 62 ot TEST TEMP.
32
_J 3O 29 10
I 15
I 20
1 25
l
1
30
1
35
,l 45
40
TEMPERATURE, ~
Fig. 4 Effect of tooling temperature on LDH [45, 46]
4.7. Interactions Uncertainties of interpretation are bound to remain if only a single variable is studied at a time. It is necessary to conduct tests with the main factors affecting film thickness--including viscosity, temperature, punch speed, and surface roughness--systematically varied within the ranges expected in testing practice [46]. A factor of known importance is roughness of punch and sheet. Specifications [36] simply state that punch roughness should be of 0.125 ~m (5 ~in) Ra maximum and are silent on roughness orientation. To reveal effects of temperature on formability, Fischer and Schey [46] conducted tests with punches of 0.033 and 0.144 ~m Ra circumferential or random finishes, at punch speeds (v) of 0.83 to 8.3 mm/s, temperatures of 25 and 50 ~ and with oils blended to give the same viscosity (q) at the two temperatures. Humidity was not controlled and changed according to the weather and heating season. 33.0 -
I
32.0
v
I
E E 31.0
-r a --.I
I
30.029.0 28.0
Z
ooooo Unknown Humidity ooooo Low Humidity ~0 03L~ High Humidity 0
~
~
i
I
i
25
t
i
i
~
i
50
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
75 100 "r/V ( m m 3 / s 2)
i
J
i
J
i
125
i
~
i
i
i
150
Fig. 5 Changes in LDH value with oil viscosity, punch velocity, and humidity [46]
179 LDH values were lowest at high (over 40%) relative humidity (RH)(Fig. 5) and increased with qv rising from 30 to 110, indicating decreasing friction, as expected for mixed-film lubrication. Dome heights obtained in a winter period characterized by very low (but not accurately known) RH were much higher and failed to give a clear trend. The rougher punch resulted in some 0.25 mm higher domes, suggesting that the deeper (but in absolute values still very fine) troughs helped lubricant retention and lowered friction. For a constant qv, increasing temperature decreased the LDH by 1 mm, indicating a true change in formability. This agrees with Ayres [48] and Stevenson [49] who found that m and thus total elongation dropped with increasing temperature in this low-temperature regime. In routine testing the punch is refinished in situ with an abrasive (not specified in the recommended practice, but usually crocus cloth, 600-grit SiC paper, or Scotchbrite). It is assumed but seldom checked that the finish is indeed random and unchanging, perhaps because earlier work showed the direction of finish to be unimportant [41 ]. Finishing the punch with 600-grit SiC paper until repeated refinishing caused no further change in roughness gave Ra - 0.04 pm. The LDH was now sensibly independent of humidity. It is not obvious why this should be so; humidity has unpredictable effects on lubricant performance (in [43], p. 54). Results indicate that the effect can vary with surface roughness, most likely through its effect on lubrication mechanism. Whatever the explanation may be, it is reassuring to know that a random finish is much less sensitive. Roughness must, nevertheless, be controlled, as shown by the some 1 mm higher LDH obtained with a rougher (Ra = 0.144 pm) random finish. Any factor that affects lubrication also affects friction. For this reason, otherwise identical sheets of different surface topographies give different LDH values. For example, production sheets of rougher finish gave lower LDH than laboratory-rolled sheets of finer finish, even at the same n values [50].
4.8. Test technique A very large source of potential error is the use of incorrect blank width. Determination of the critical width is tedious and there is a temptation to conduct tests on blanks of constant width (typically, 133 mm) for all materials. As seen in Fig. 6a, the dome height changes quite
@
(.9
/
,,4
2
o a 3 mm--~, ~_ I I I I I I I J BLANK WIDTH, mm
1
I_I
2rnm-,~ ~ I
I
I
I
~-~ I
BLANK WIDTH, mm
Fig. 6 Determination of LDH by two different methods
I
180 steeply away from the critical width, and replicate tests on blanks of incorrect width will simply yield an inaccurate LDH with greater precision. This would explain the tight dispersion yet wide range of LDH results obtained in round-robin tests. These problems can be avoided and the effort reduced if the test method is changed as follows: For a given material group, the approximate critical width is explored by testing blanks in 6-mm increments. Routine tests are then done on blanks cut at 2-mm increments, with the widths chosen to assure at least three points on each side of the critical width. Triplicate tests at, say, 7 to 9 widths again require 21 or 27 blanks, but this time they can all be cut at once. As shown by the typical plot in Fig. 6b, the curve of dome heights is well defined. It is then a matter of agreement whether to take as the LDH the minimum of the best-fit curve or the intercept of two best-fit straight lines. For all its proven benefits, the LDH test is time-consuming and subject to a relatively large scatter of results, attributable to a number of causes [reviewed in 51 ]. There are continuing efforts to improve the test technique. Kim and Park [52] retain the blankholder of the standard die set but replace the hemispherical punch with a cylindrical punch of 37.5 mm radius and 70 mm length, thereby ensuring fracture in plane strain. A standard specimen width of 126 mm was found suitable for a variety of steels. Height at fracture (limiting punch height, LPH) was very close to the LDH value but scatter, expressed as standard deviation, was greatly reduced. It appears that, by forcing fracture to take place in plane strain, sensitivity to variations in friction is also reduced, minimizing scatter and eliminating the need for finding an optimum blank width. Taking a different approach, Miles et al [5 l] replace the circular lock ring of the standard die set with straight lock beads and use a cylindrical punch with an elliptical profile to obtain fracture near plane strain. This "OSU Test" gave punch heights at fracture that correlated well with the LDH value, and the number of test specimens required was less than in the standard LDH test. The scatter of data was, however, no better than with a well-controlled LDH test. The value of any of these newer tests would have to be proven in strictly designed and controlled round-robin tests. Until such trials are made, a properly conducted LDH test still gives the most sensitive measure of formability in plane strain. Random variations, otten attributed to the poor reproducibility of the test, are then revealed as true changes in formability. For example, dayto-day variations in LDH on a coil-annealed material made no sense until it was realized that the variations were due to a true change in formability along the length of the coil [44]. The test lends itself to considerable automation. The load-displacement curve begins to drop when necking sets in; hence, with the advent of computer-based data acquisition and process control, it is easy to detect the maximum punch force and the corresponding dome height. The punch can be automatically stopped at, say, 1% drop in force. At this point, there is incipient fracture at the failure site. The LDH test is a technological test, in essence simulating a production part made with a hemispherical punch and a completely locked blank. As such, it is subject to all the variables that affect a pressing. This is a disadvantage in that other variables must be strictly controlled if a single variable, such as the formability of sheets, is to be evaluated. It is, however, also an advantage in that it highlights the importance of other variables in the system, alerting one to the sensitivity of the stretching process to a host of influences. In stamping plants where the test has been introduced, it has proven of great help in separating problems due to material quality from those due to process variables [39].
181
5. S T R E T C H - B E N D
TESTS
The LDH test and its variants fail to predict formability when bending strains dominate. Various stretch-bend tests have been proposed, although none of them have achieved the status of a standard. Demery [53] performed extensive testing with two configurations. The hemispherical stretch-bend test (HSBT) is similar to an LDH test but the radius of the hemispherical punch is reduced. The load reaches a maximum when the limiting height is attained. Narrower blanks stretched over larger-radius punches fracture outside the contact zone in a tensile mode. Lowest limit strains are obtained with wide (fully constrained) specimens, giving the most critical evaluation of formability. At a given radius, the limiting height increases with increasing sheet thickness because more material is available for distributing the necking strain. Similarly, for a constant thickness, limiting height increases with increasing punch radius because the larger punch distributes strain more uniformly prior to necking. For practical applications, presentation as a function of t/g (increasingly severe curvature) is most illuminating. The angular stretch-bend test (ASBT) is the plane-strain analog of the HSBT. Rectangular blanks are gripped on their ends and stretched by wedge-shaped punches of varying tip radii. The limiting height again increases with tip radius, but decreases with sheet thickness, presumably because of the dominance of thickness strain. A simplified model of the latter test [54] correctly accounts for several effects of friction. Lower friction, as produced by polyethylene sheet lubricated with oil, promotes sliding and thus thinning over the punch where fracture occurs. For a given friction, increasing t/R (tightening bend) promotes bending strain and thus fracture on the punch. Fracture strain can be regarded as a material constant. (It should be noted that the strain relevant to this situation is neither the uniform strain nor strain in the neck, rather some intermediate value which should correlate with elongation measured over a short gage length, in which localized strain in the neck receives greater weighting.) In the course of stretching, strain over the punch increases more rapidly under lubricated conditions, hence the fracture strain is reached at a lower height. Sliding over the punch makes more material available for the free-stretching ligaments, increasing limiting height when ligament fracture controls the event. Evidently, for the test to yield reproducible results, interface conditions have to be controlled as they are in the LDH test. For sharp radii (t/g < 0.85) friction effects are swamped by the dominance of through-thickness strain. However, fracture is then forced to occur over a very short distance, reducing sensitivity of the test to material variables that promote distribution of strain over a punch surface. Correlation studies with industrial press performance have not been published, but some companies do use the test routinely as an adjunct to the LDH test [55].
6. T E N S I O N T E S T There is a perhaps never-ending search for a measure of formability as an intrinsic material property. Some form of tensile testing would appear ideal to determine formability in the absence of the disturbing influences of friction, with well-controlled stress states free of the bending that is characteristic of all out-of-plane tests.
182
6.1
Standard tension test
The left-hand side of the FLD gives forming limits in a tensile/compressive strain state (i.e., at negative minor to major strain ratios). Ostensibly, the simplest measure is elongation in the standard tension test. Following the arguments and experiments of Ghosh [56] it is now well recognized that while uniform strain is more or less proportional to strain hardening (n), postnecking strain is largely governed by strain-rate sensitivity (m), thus, both contribute to elongation to fracture (final strain) ef. Finite-element analysis [57] shows that both n and m are important throughout the entire strain history. It is, therefore, reasonable that ef should correlate reasonably well with observed rankings of formability in press working, as recognized early in this century. Correlation is certainly much better than with n. The correlation is, however, far from perfect and greatly depends on the geometry of the tensile specimen on the one hand and on the stress state prevailing in production on the other. There is also a question of correlation with simulation tests. We have seen that for most steels, FLDo intercepts correlate better with ef than n. The same holds for LDH values [36]. Stevenson [49] found that among tensile properties only ef gave general correlation with LDH for a wide range of steels, aluminum alloys, and zinc. The equation LDH (mm) = 10.0 § 0.508 ef described the relationship with a standard error of 1.62 mm when ef was taken from ASTM specimens of 50.8-mm gage length. Since the error is larger than the 0.5 to 1.0 mm difference in LDH that separates a good lot from a bad one, Stevenson too suggested that ef can be regarded only as a gross indicator of formability. Story et al [50] found that, even for aluminum alloys which show very little post-necking strain, dome heights correlated best with an instantaneous strain hardening exponent combined with ef. A seldom recognized problem is the poor reproducibility of the tension test. This is surprising in view of the long history of this widely practiced test, yet the problem was evident in each round-robin test conducted by NADDRG [58].
6.2. Plane-strain tension Since most failures in pressworking occur near plane strain, it is reasonable to search for methods that eliminate transverse strain in a tensile specimen. For thick materials, transverse grooves can be machined so that gage length is reduced and the non-deforming shoulders restrain lateral contraction. With decreasing gage length to width ratio, the strain state moves closer to plane strain. For thinner sheet, Devenpeck and Richmond [59] achieved the same objective by sandwiching the sheet between end plates and defining the gage length by transverse electron-beam welds. In-plane strains were obtained from photos of grids, throughthickness deformation from holographic interferometry [60]. For the steel used, the limit strains were only slightly lower than those determined in a dome test. Other forms of planestrain testing have been proposed. For example, Graf and Hosford [61] achieve plane strain over a large portion of the width of simple rectangular specimens by wrapping the sheet around grips that allow free choice of the deforming length. With gridded sheets it should be possible to obtain the plane-strain intercept of an FLC. Ziaja [62] uses a gridded, side-notched tensile specimen and computes the left-hand side of the FLC from a modified McClintock [63] fracture criterion.
183 Sang and Nishikawa [64] completely eliminated lateral strain by attaching to the sheet specimen a spring-loaded clamp with four knife edges indenting the two sides of the sheet parallel to the loading direction. They defined the plane-strain limit strain as the point where the longitudinal thickness gradient reached 0.1; this coincided with the development of a visible neck. Fracture strain was calculated from thickness at fracture. No comparisons with FLDs were made, however, Timothy [65] found that, in stretching over an unlubricated punch of 50 mm diameter, necking strain was some 40% higher than in plane-strain tension. This effect was already noted by Ghosh and Hecker [66] who pointed out that friction over the punch and the gradual wrapping of sheet over the punch surface combine to postpone necking. Since the same effects operate in practical operations, the use of plane-strain tests is questionable, especially for materials showing negative strain-rate sensitivity and thus a tendency to flow localization. An apparently simpler test has been proposed by Richmond and Devenpeck [67] for assessing the material's ability to distribute strains and thus giving a measure of stretchability. A tapered specimen is produced by machining circular arcs in the width of the specimen. The extent of plastic zone is judged from grids or brittle lacquer coating. The test was successful in showing that a dual-phase steel has greater stretchability than a low-carbon DQSK steel, even though standard tensile test data (including n and ef) would indicate otherwise.
6.3. Biaxial tension In-plane biaxial tension can be generated by an ingenious method proposed by Marciniak and Kuczynski [68]. A circular specimen is clamped and stretched over a flat-face punch together with another specimen in which a central hole had been made. Several specimens are stretched to find the point at which necking begins. The technique is used also in conjunction with punch stretching to determine the FLC around plane strain (below + 10 % minor strain). Alternatively, the strain just before fracture is found by continuous observation of a grid [50]. No stress-strain information is, however, obtained since the load at necking and failure cannot be measured. Out-of-plane biaxial tension, such as produced by hydrostatic bulge testing, can provide stress/strain curves to large strains [69] but does not give a good measure of formability [70] since the crucial element of contact with the die is missing. Similarly, biaxial stretching over a punch has limited value since few pressings fail in this mode and correlation with plant performance is poor [70].
7. H O L E E X P A N S I O N A problem of different dimension is the edge cracking that sets a limit to the expansion of holes, whether expansion is into a straight flange (perpendicular to the plane of sheet) or offset (like the bottom of a cup formed by a flat-faced punch on a previously pierced sheet). An intrinsic edge formability can be determined by expanding holes of reamed (or otherwise burr-free) surfaces with a tapered, well-lubricated punch. Intrinsic edge formability is related not just to ductility as expressed, for example, by reduction of area in the tension test, but also to an absence of inclusions or, in general, of weak interfaces in a two-phase structure. Since a single stress raiser located at the edge can initiate fracture, limits of expansion are not directly predictable from tensile tests done in only one direction. Indeed, even plastic anisotropy (both
184 normal and planar) plays a role, since hole expansion requires in-plane deformation and is adversely affected by through-thickness deformation. Formability tests such as the LDH test are not relevant, because strain accommodation around an inclusion reduces harmful effects. For the same reason, flanging limit increases with increasing sheet thickness [71, 72]. Any stress raiser present will reduce flanging limits. Burrs resulting from punching are most harmful. Burrs of highly jagged configuration are more deleterious and are prone to form on materials of lower ductility. For a given material, degradation of expansion limits is usually a function of burr height to sheet thickness ratio [73]. Because burrs or other edge damage significantly reduce expanding limits, surface finish--and even residual stress distribution--in the wall of the hole must be strictly standardized, for example, by detailed specification of the preparation method.
8. C O N C L U S I O N In judging the value of formability tests for production purposes, it is worthwhile to reflect on the purpose of such tests. The primary goal is judgment of suitability for specific press forming applications in various contexts: matching the material to the demands of the process; modifying a process or design to suit material capabilities; troubleshooting and production control; and development of new materials. Ideally, one would measure some basic property and then, with the aid of appropriate process models, predict production performance. Despite enormous effort and undeniable progress, this goal has not yet been achieved. Until such time when total solutions become available, continuing efforts must be exerted to find simulation tests that take the full complexity of reality into account. Of fundamental importance is die contact which aids in delaying strain localization. This introduces interface friction as a complicating factor which, for testing purposes, needs to be neutralized. If, however, production conditions are to be strictly simulated, the effects of lubricants must be understood; this leads into the very large and complex area of tribology as it pertains to sheet metalworking. As the example of the LDH test shows, progress in these directions can be slow but measurable. Progress would be accelerated by conducting more round-robin tests, preferably in global cooperation. One can only agree with Levy [55] that no unique test is likely to exist and a battery of tests must be applied. For production control purposes the likely candidates are the LDH test or its variants, the angular stretch-bend test, and hole expansion. The tension test remains important as a quick check on overall quality. Truly relevant simulation tests, combined with statistical process control [74], would go a long way to put production on a firm footing.
Acknowledgments The author is grateful to the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada for support of research and to R.F. Fischer for helpful discussions. Special thanks are due to Dr. D. J. Meuleman who critically reviewed the manuscript and offered valuable suggestions.
185 REFERENCES
Metals Handbook, 9th ed., Vol. 14, Forging and Forming, ASM, Metals Park OH, 1988. B. Taylor, in [ 1], pp. 877-899. S.S. Hecker, A.K. Ghosh, and H.L. Gegel (eds.), Formability: Analysis, Modeling, and Experimentation, A/ME, New York, 1978. J.R. Newby and B.A. Niemeier (eds.), Formability of Metallic Materials -2000 A.D., ASTM STP 753, Philadelphia, PA, 1982. R.H. Wagoner (ed.), Novel Techniques in Metal Deformation Testing, TMS, Warrendale, PA, 1983. A.K. Sachdev and J.D. Embury (eds.), Formability and Metallurgical Structure, TMS, Warrendale, PA, 1987. R.H. Wagoner, K.S. Chan, and S.P. Keeler (eds.), Forming Limit Diagrams: Concepts, Methods, and Applications, TMS, Warrendale, PA, 1989. Autobody Stamping Technology Progress, SAE SP-865, 1991. 8 Autobody Stamping Applications and Analysis, SAE SP-897, 1992. 9 10 Sheet Metal and Stamping Symposium, SAE SP-944, 1993. 11 W.T. Lankford, S.C. Snyder, and J.A. Bauscher, Trans. ASM, 42 (1950) 1192-1235. 12 R.L. Whiteley, Trans. ASM, 52 (1960) 154-168. S.Y. Chung and H.W. Swim, Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng., 165 (1951) 199-223. 13 14 K. Sakata, D. Daniel, J.J. Jonas, and J.F. Bussiere, Met. Trans., 21A (1990) 697-706. 15 A.V. Clark, N. Izworski, M. Hirao, and Y. Cohen, in [8], pp. 1-13. 16 K. Nakazima, T. Kikuma, and K. Hasuka, Tech. Rep. 264, Yawata Iron & Steel Co., Sep. 1968, p. 141. 17 S.S. Hecker, in [3], pp. 150-182. 18 S. Dinda, K.F. James, S.P. Keeler, and P.A. Stine, How to Use Circle Grid Analysis for Die Tryout, ASM, Metals Park, OH, 1981. 19 R.A. Ayres, E.G. Brewer, and S.W. Holland, Trans. SAE, 88 (1979) 2630-2634. 20 D.N. Harvey, in Proc. 13th Bienn. Congr. IDDRG, Melbourne 1984, pp. 403-414. J.H. Vogel and D. Lee, J. Mater. Shaping Technol., 6 (1989) 205-216. 21 22 M.I. Kapij, J.J. Moleski, T. Ohwue, J.H. Vogel, and D. Lee, in [9], SAE Paper 920436. Y. Wang, A.E. Bayoumi, and H.M. Zbib, J. Mater. Shaping Technol., 9 (1991) 143-152. 23 24 A. Bragard, in [7], pp. 9-19. S.P. Keeler and W.G. Brazier, in Microalloying 75, New York, 1977, pp. 517-530. 25 26 K.S. Raghavan, R.C. van Kuren, and H. Darlington, in [9], SAE Paper 920437. 27 Z. Buchar, IDDRG Working Group Meeting, Linz, Austria, 1993. 28 W. Tse, T. Aboutour, J.S. Thomas, A. Assempoor, and M. Karima, in [9], SAE Paper 920437. 29 S.P. Keeler, SAE Paper 850278. 30 D.J. Hogarth, C.A. Gregoire, and S.L. Caswell, in [8], pp. 87-95. J.F. Siekirk, J. Appl. Metalwork, 4 (1986) 262-269. 31 S.S. Hecker, Met. Eng. Quarterly, 14 (1974 Nov.) 30-36. 32 R.A. Ayres, W.G. Brazier, and V.F. Sajewski, J. Appl. Metalwork., 1 (1979) 41-49. 33 A.K. Ghosh, Met. Eng. Quarterly, 15(3) (1975) 53-64. 34 J.M. Story, J. Appl. Metalwork., 2 (1982) 119-125. 35 36 R. Thompson and NADDRG, in [ 10], SAE Paper 930815.
186 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74
H. Vegter and C.M. Dane, IDDRG Working Group Meeting,, Amsterdam, 1985. R.A. Ayres, in [5], pp. 47-64. A.F. Graf and N. Izworski, in [ 10], SAE Paper 930816. R.F. Fischer, M.A.Sc. Thesis, University of Waterloo, 1992. D.J. Meuleman, J. Siles, and J.J. Zoldak, SAE Paper 850005. J.A. Schey and R.F. Fischer, J. Mater. Shaping Technol., 9 (1991) 85-86. J.A. Schey, Tribology in Metalworking: Friction, Lubrication and Wear, ASM, Metals Park, OH, 1983, pp. 233-235. J.A. Schey, J. Mater. Shaping Technol., 6 (1988) 103-111. N. Izworski and A. Graf, in [8], SAE Paper 910512. R.F. Fischer and J.A. Schey, in [9], SAE Paper 920434. J.M. Story, J. Appl. Metalwork, 3 (1984) 292-300. R.A. Ayres, Met. Trans., 16A (1985) 37-43. R. Stevenson, J. Appl. Metalwork, 3 (1984) 272-280. J.M. Story, D.J. Lege, and W.H. Hunt, Jr., in [5], pp. 113-129. M.P. Miles, J.L. Siles, R.H. Wagoner, and K. Narasimhan, Met. Trans., 24A (1993) 1143-1151. Y. Kim and K. Park, to be published in Met. Trans., Ser. A M.Y. Demeri, J. Appl. Metalwork., 2 (1981) 3-10. O.S. Narayanaswamy and M.Y. Demeri, in [5], pp. 99-112. B.S. Levy, in Proc. 13th Bienn. Congr. IDDRG, Melbourne, 1984, pp. 592-605. A.K. Ghosh, in [3], pp. 14-28. K. Chung and R.H. Wagoner, in [6], pp. 261-277. B.A. Niemeier, in [4], pp. 296-314. M.L. Devenpeck and O. Richmond, in [5], pp. 79-88. M.L. Devenpeck, in [5], pp. 219-233. A.F. Graf and W.F. Hosford, in [ 10], SAE Paper 930812. G. Ziaja, in microCAD-Systems 93, University of Miskolc, 1993. F.A. McClintock, J. Appl. Mech. 90 (1968) 363-371. H. Sang and Y. Nishikawa, in [5], pp. 3-13. S.P. Timothy, in [7], pp. 21-36. A.K. Ghosh and S.S. Hecker, Met. Trans., 5 (1974) 2161, 6A (1975) 1065-1074. O. Richmond and M.L. Devenpeck, in [5], pp. 89-98. Z. Marciniak and K. Kuczynski, Int. J. Mech. Sci., 9 (1967) 609-620. R.F. Young, J.E. Bird, and J.L. Duncan, J. Appl. Metalwork, 2 (1981) 11-18. J.R. Newby, in [4], pp. 60-83. M.Y. Demeri, in Proc. 15th Biennial Congress IDDRG, Dearborn, MI, ASM, 1988, pp. 231-236. L.D. Kenny and H. Sang, in [5], pp. 15-30. S.P. Keeler, Machinery, (1968 June) 98-104. S.P. Keeler, in [1], pp. 928-939.
Materials Processing Defects S.K. Ghosh and M. Predeleanu (Editors) 9 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
187
Design o f Experiments, a Statistical M e t h o d to analyse Sheet Metal Forming Defects effectively D. Bauer a and R. Leidolf b a,b Institute of Production Engineering, University Siegen, P.O. Box 101240, 57068 Siegen, Germany
1. INTRODUCTION Because of constantly increasing shortage of raw material it is necessary to optimize material utilization in sheet metal forming processes. In order to determine wether a particular sheet metal can be deep drawn without defects the so-called cup test has been developed [ 1]. The tools of this test consist of the punch, the die, the blank holder and auxiliary equipement to center the blank. By means of these an axissymmetric deep drawing process can be performed by the cup test. This is done by placing a circular blank over the die and pressing the blank into die with the punch. Additionally, a force is required to press the blank holder against the blank to prevent wrinkling. Before deep drawing takes place the blank is coated, too, by an appropriate lubricant in order to reduce friction and wear. The ratio of the initial blank diameter d to the punch diameter dst is the well-known drawing ratio 13= d/dst. Its maximum value is the so-called limited drawing ratio [3max. This is generally dependent on a large number of drawing parameters, e.g. lubricant, die radius, blankholder force, etc.. The best economic material utilization can be obtained with a parameter combination that provides the maximum limited drawing ratio. In the following it will be shown how this aim can be achieved by the statistical method called design of experiments.
2. LIMITED DRAWING RATIO AND MAXIMUM DRAWING FORCE One method to determine 13max is given by keeping the punch diameter dst constant and drawing blanks with progressively enlarged diameters d, for example in steps of l mm. The largest
blank
diameter
dmax that
can be
drawn
without
failure
delivers
finally
188 13max
= dmax/dSt.This method is commonly preferred. But it is a laborious and an expensive
one. A more effective one is the method according to Schmidt-Kapfenberg. Starting point of this method published by M. Schmidt [2] is the analysis of the drawing force required to produce a cup. This force F z is measured in dependence of the punch travel during the cup test. Fig. 1 shows three representative results of such measurements carried out with constant punch diameter dst = 110mm and different blank diameters d 1 = 150mm, d 2 = 200mmm, d 3 = 240mm and corresponding drawing ratios 131 - 1.36, 132 = 1.82, 133 = 2.18. In case of d 1 and d 2 a cup can be drawn without fallout. But in case of d 3 failure occurs before the cup is formed completely. Usually, the failure occurs in a narrow band of material in the cup wall just above the radius of the punch which has undergone no radial drawing or bending but is subjected essentially to tensile straining and thinning. Thus, in this critical region necking defects, followed by tearing defects, will destroy the cup as soon as the stress state induced by the drawing force is getting equal or exceeds the strength of the wall material. At this critical instant the corresponding drawing force curve is interrupted, Fig. 1. I
78,1
'
d 3 = 2#Omm N
U.. (D O 0 q.13) c" "13
,
52.6
~
i
i
~_-------i ! d2 =! 200mm
[
I
35.8
17.5
F 8
6
13
19
punch displacement h -
2:6
m
32
~,,.-
Figure 1. Drawing force versus punch displacement. Sheet metal AIMg0.4Sil.2, thickness so = lmm, d 1 - 150mm, d 2 = 200mm, d 3 = 240mm; 131 = 1.36, 132 = 1.82 133=2.18.
M. Schmidt observed that there exists generally a linear relationship between the maximum of the drawing force Fmax and the increase of the blank diameter d, resp. the drawing ratio 13, if
189 Fmax is lower than the failure load FBr. Because of this M. Schmidt suggested to determine 13max only by three different runs of the cup test: two with different blank diameters smaller than dmax in order to fix the straight line in the subcritical area Fmax _< FBr, and one with a blank diameter larger than dmax to obtain the failure load FBr, Fig. 2. The point of intersection than gives the value of dmax resp. 13max. The failure load FBr is only dependent on the strenght and the thickness of the sheet material. For a given test arrangement it is a constant and cannot be varied. But against that Fmax in the subcritical area is dependent on the complete set of parameters as listed in Fig. 4. Thus, by systematic variation of these parameters the maximum values of the drawing force in the subcritical area can be minimized. Fig. 3 demonstrates this for two different parameter combinations of the cup test. The failure load gives for both combinations the same value. But in the subcritical area combination II is delivering lower Fmaxl and Fmax2 values than combination I. By reason of this, the point of intersection is shifted to the fight and 13max increases. This means, the limited drawing ratio is not a material property of sheet metal. On the contrary, it is not only depending on the strenght and thickness of sheet material but on lubricant, tool geometry, blankholder force, sheet roughness and all of other forming parameters, too. Thus, by an optimal combination of the forming parameters the stress state in the cup wall induced by the maximum drawing force in the subcritical area can be minimized, i.e. the corresponding limited drawing ratio can be improved and maximized. F~lax
hypercritical
area
A F~r
4
FmaxZ
F~ax1
subcritical
area
i
i ....
v
i ~I
~2
~max
~Br
Figure 2. Determination of the limited drawing ratio according to SCHMIDTKAPFENBERG.
190
max
~r
combination combination
l
/ /
Fmax2I Fmax2II FmaxlI FmaxllI
I II
--/ / / J/
'
lj fll
f12 flmaxI flmaxlI
Figure 3. Increase of the limited drawing ratio by reducing the maximum drawing forces Fmaxl and Fmax2.
3.
TRADITIONAL AND MODERN METHODS FOR DESIGN OF EXPERIMENTS
The traditional method to design and analyse experiments is the so-called one-factor-at-atime-method. One influential factor is set on different levels and the effect of this factor on a target value can be examined, while the remaining parameters of the process are on a constant level. There are a lot of studies like that regarding to the effect of different metal forming parameters upon limited drawing ratio. So, for example, W. Ziegler analysed the influence of the die radius upon 13max [3], while R. Woska investigated the controllable variable "tool coating" [4]. But the traditional method has two considerable disadvantages: 1. It is not possible to make out interactions between factors. So, it would be likely that the increasing of the die radius also increases the amount of 13max, if a special tool coating is used, while the same increasing of the die radius doesn't change 13max by the use of another tool coating. 2.
It requires a lot of temporal and financial experimental power input. This disadvantage today gains in importance because of global competition. Because apart from a very high quality standard it is possible to get advantages compared with competitives, if someone has brief, but efficiently development times and low development costs.
191 These are the reasons for a lot of industrial branches to favour the methods of statistical design of experiments (DOE), today. The number of required tests is fewer. In addition to the low power input it is a great advantage to determine the single influence of a factor as influences between two or more factors
(interactions).
(effect)
as well
Because of the special way to
analyse the experimental results, it is possible to get high certainty regarding to the effects of treatment factors. This is very important, because today any producer has to minimize the risks as a result of poor product quality. If necessary, he has to prove by data, that his products have no safety reducing quality defects. Further, it is hardly or even not possible to create mathematical models and without a model it is not possible to optimize the investigated process. For optimization it is not necessary to have a model, which is in accordance to natural laws. Very often a statistical model is sufficient. The design of experiment allways provides a statistical model,-which allows to suggest main effects and interactions. Also a correlation between controllable variables
(factors)
and a target value can be set up. To determine linear
relationships it is enough to investigate two levels of the selected factors. For many years the methods of DOE are used successfully in agricultural sciences [6], chemical engineering [7] and plastic material manufacturing [8]. In this paper it will be shown how to apply DOE on a metal forming problem. The deep drawing conditions are analysed with regard to maximum material economy. The single effect of different metal forming parameters on the limited drawing ratio was studied in great detail [9,10], but interactions are neglected until now. So, in this work full factorial design will be used, because the other well-known DOE-method TAGUCHI's experimental design- is a simplified form of factorial design. So, the TAGUCI-I/plans only supply meaningful results, if a lot of informations about the process and especially about the interactions are given [ 11 ].
4.
CONTROLLABLE VARIABLES UPON MAXIMUM DRAWING FORCE At the beginning of statistical design of experiments it is necessary to analyse which
controllable variables are probably important for the target value. The drawing force of a deep drawing process consists of different components [9]: -
ideal plastic deformation load Fid, needed for the plastic, lost-free tension-compressiondeformation,
-
-
flexural load FBie to bend over the die and punch radius, friction force F R in the areas of contact between tool and cup.
192 This drawing force components could be influenced by changes of the deep drawing system, which consists of forming and tribological parts. The forming part contents the loads and stresses, caused by metal forming. So, there are radial tensile stresses and tangential compressive stresses in the flange. Finally the flange is bent over the die and punch radius. Changes of the drawing force by one of this forming system parts can be realized by tool geometry (punch, die) and by increasing or decreasing blankholder force. Also the tribological system can be used to change the drawing force. The tribological system consists of all contact surfaces between tool and cup. The friction force in the four different areas (1: cup - die / 2: cup - blankholder / 3: cup - die radius / 4: cup - punch radius) is influenced by kind and quantity of lubrication and by mating of materials between tool and test sheet. So these parameters are also controllable factors regarding to the drawing force, because friction force is part of drawing force. Figure 4 describes all factors regarding to maximum drawing force for the used experimental arrangement.
Control[able variables (rneta[ forming parameter) .pmc~
= diameter
dst
= punch radius = material. - diameter
d,r,
= die racrmJs = materiat = L-[earance
uz
9blankl~der: = b(ankhotder force FN = material.
9test sheet:
= diameter
d
= gauge so = surface microslT'ucture = material. 9Lubricant:
- kind = quantity L
Figure 4. Controllable variables
:,~
_ I
(factors) influencing the maximum drawing force.
193 Four of these factors are chosen for a full factorial 24-plan. These n=4 factors are: blankholder force
FN
lubrication quantity S die radius
rz
blank diameter
d
The blank diameter has of course a great effect on maximum drawing force (compare Fig. 1). So, this factor is chosen to study, if the other investigated factors are independent from d. In this case the straight line in subcritical area would be shifted parallel analogous to Fig. 3. But if there are interactions between d and one or more than one factor, the straight line would be moved and turned, too. The next step of this work is how to investigate the effect on the limited drawing ratio. Further, a 23-plan is made for
133 =
2.18 (d = 240mm; hypercritical area).
This two plans are basic for the mathematical models to calculate the straight lines in sub- and hypercritical area. At least a relation between the calculated maximum drawing forces and the limited drawing ratio will be determined. All other metal forming parameters shown in Fig. 4 are kept on a constant level (table 1). Table 1 Test conditions. die material
AMPCO 25
blankholder material
AMPCO 25
punch material
1.2379
punch diameter
110 mm
,,
punch radius
3 mm
drawing gap
1.2 mm
lubricant
OEST Platinol BZK4
sheet material
AIMg0.4Sil.2
sheet surface microstructure
Isomill fein
gauge
0.8 mm
5.
FULL FACTORIAL DESIGN A full factorial 2n-experiment has n factors each at two levels. The range between the low
and high level should be as large as possible to calculate effects and interactions almost
194 certainly, if existing. Further, the uncertainty for the calculated relationship between factors and target value caused by random variance of testing results can be minimized [12]. The factor levels then are combined in such a way, that all possible combinations of the factor levels can be realized in one run. The notation of factors and runs is strongly systematic. The factors are marked with capital letters, started with "A". The name of a run indicates, which factor levels are realized in this run, because the name consists of all corresponding small letters of the factors, which are on high level, with exception of the test, where all factors are at their low level. This test is called "(1)". Table 2 shows the normal 24-experimental design. The four factors: A
= blankholder Force F N
B
= lubricant quantity S
C
= die radius r z
D
= blank diameter d or drawing ratio 13
comes to 24 = 16 runs.
Table 2 Normal 24-experimental design.
1
8
(1)
2
15
a
3
9
b
4
11
ab
5
14
c
6
1
ac
7
2
bc
8
10
abc
9
16
d
10
5
ad
11
4
bd
12
6
13 14
+
-
_
+ J
+
+
+
+
-
-
+
+
-
+
abd
+
-
+
13
cd
-
+
+
3
acd
15
12
bcd
16
7
abcd
+
+
+
-
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
195 Besides of the normal notation the table shows all levels which shall be realized in a run by a sign. (-) means the low level, (+) the high level. The first column contents the serial number, column two the testing number. This number is created by random. The experiments shall be realized in this random order to eliminate uncontrollable, systematic disruptive factors. It is important to prevent, that the effect of a disruptive factor is added to a controllable factor. By selecting the low and high level of blankholder force the low one has to prevent wrinkling and the high one should not create stretch forming processes. For the used experimental arrangement the values are fixed at F N = 35kN and 50kN, which corresponds to an onset value ofblankholder pressure of 1.31N/mm 2 and 1.87N/mm 2, resp.. The lubricant quantity levels S = 3g/m 2 and 6g/m 2 are selected according to the quantities usually used in practice. The die radius is fixed at r z = 3mm and 6mm. At least the chosen blank diameters are d = 150mm and 200mm, so both diameters are in the subcritical area.
6.
EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS To minimize the influence of random variation, each of the 16 combinations (table 2) is
replicated three times. In addition, by means of these replicates an analysis of variance can be conducted. This analysis of variance indicates certainly, if changes of the target value are influenced by the effect of a factor or is caused by stochastic errors in measuring. Table 3 contents the results of the 48 runs (column 2-4), and in addition, the statistical average ~Fma x (column 5). The other columns are explained later.
7. ANALYSIS OF VARIANCE It is not meaningful to list the experimental results without supplementary analysis. But because of the specific combination of parameters used in full factorial design, it is possible to calculate effects and interactions caused by the factors, too. This quantities are explaining the changes of the target value, in this case maximum drawing force, under the influence of a controllable factor. Then the analysis of variance
(ANOVA) helps to prove, if target value
changes are really influenced by increasing the level of one factor or if these changes are caused by experimental variations and disruptive factors. This ANOVA-procedure is explained very well in statistical literature [6, 7, 13, 14]. So, it will not be repeated here.
196 Table 3 Experimental results and analysis of variance (ANOVA). iname Fmax. 1st run /
kN
(1) a
28.093
i
c ac ,bc abc
l
d
a
26.256 26.354 ~
28.386
~
28.464
,25.905 1
,
25.983 62.125
ad
61.851
bd
1
cd
n
acd
kN
28.269 28.054
i
26.353 ' ,25.944 28.054
l
28.483
i
29.265
i
28.210
9
28.568
i
9
~ J
26.198 62.203
I
i
26.081 61.812
60.484
i
i
I
62.242 62.085
i
l
m
-0.110
1.769
no
-1.796
472.646
yes
I
62.476 62.359
l
62.046
i
60.549
ABC
I
62.099 62.125
no
0.037
0.197
no
-0.020
0.061
no
i -0.0951
1.328
no
|
i
BD
60.627 !
0.668
AC
D
i
l
0.068,
c
,61.838 mAD
60.523 i
26.087
1% /
A
,i25.976 B C
I
/
88.559
,25.866
9
signif.
Total
i26.159
60.874
bcd
28.353 i
kN
/
28.184
60.484
61.929
value
l
i28.034
i60.640
l
average!
28.054
m
60.523 61.577
effect- test-value
I
26.217 26.276 B I ~ ' L26.276 L26.191 A B
,62.203
1
•Fma x [ effect kN
28.347
,61.460
abd i
Fmax 3rd run
kN
28.444
b ab
Fmax 2nd run
CD 9
|
,
0.015 a
0.051
,
no i
23.393
!
yes !
-0.071
0.735
0.090
1.196
|
no yes
!
q
i
|
0.2E+06 0.035
0.400 i
ABD i
-0.019 34.098
|
no no i
ACD
-0.009
0.012
no
0.053
0.410
no
-0.1281
2.392 i
no
60.835
60.952
~60.640
60.809
BCD
abcd j61.030
60.210
60.366
60.536
ABCD
F(1, 32, 1%) = 7.500 factor A
blankholder force
min. 35kN
max. 50kN
factor B
die radius
min." 3mm
max. 6mm
factor C
lubricant quantity
min. 3g/m 2
max. 6g/m 2
factor D
drawing ratio
min. 1.36
max. 1.82
Table 3 (column 6-9) contains the results of the analysis of variance. The effects, usually named with the same capital letter as the corresponding factors (in this case A, B, C and D), are indicating the medium changes of target value, if one factor is kept at its low or high level. Effect B shows for example, that the maximum drawing force decreases for 1.796kN on average, if the die radius changes from 3 to 6mm, while effect C means an increasing maximum drawing force for 0.037kN by using 6g/m 2 lubricant instead of 3g/m 2. Also important is the interaction BD between die radius and blank diameter. This quantity indicates, that the
197 influence regarding to Fmax decreases by increasing of blank diameter. This fact is explained in Fig. 5. The schematic graph demonstrates, that it is possible to get a larger limited drawing ratio by using a greater die radius. But the effect of the high level of rz regarding to Fmaxreducing is not so great for the high level of 13 as for the low 13-level, so this is negative for the limited drawing ratio 13max. Fz
J
/
FZ, B r u c h
.7 J
~l-effect
J J
J
J
I
200
mm
"i Y
~J
B for d z =
T J
J
J
3 mm
rz = 6 mm 7 L'---
J
J J
rz=
/
effect
B for d 1 =
150 m m
i
J
J
i
straight
line
B low
straight
line
B high
Figure 5. Interaction BD between die radius and drawing ratio.
Changes of maximum drawing force are not only influenced by controllable variations of the investigated factors, but also by uncontrollable disruptive factors. The analysis of variance [ 13 ] allows to decide, if the maximum drawing force is really influenced by one or a series of investigated factors. Such a factor, which can be used for optimization of the target value, is called
significant. Said in simplified terms, the effects and interactions are significant, if this
values are greater as the natural variance of the experiment. To prove significance, a so-called F-test is used to compare experimental variance and effects. The experimental results, in this case the 48 values of Fmax, are used to calculate a test statistic for each effect or interaction. This test statistics are compared with the critical value of a fixed significance level, mostly 1% or 5%. In column 10 of table 3 the results of this test are listed by "yes" and "no". This means, that an effect is either ("yes") or not ("no") significant at the l%-risk of erroneous rejection. Comparing the test values (table 3) with the critical value F(1, 32, 1%) = 7.50 gives
198 significance for effect B (die radius), interaction BD (between die radius and drawing ratio), and naturally for effect D (drawing ratio). The confidence intervall for this result is 99%. Fig. 5 presents the results of the analysis of variance. This bar chart allows to compare the size of some selected effects and interactions. The most important part in this graph is the significance area, marked by a straight line. All factors, which are greater than this area, can be used for changes of maximum drawing force and so, for limited drawing ratio, too. So, in this case only r z can be used to optimize 13max.
l
8,5
significance area
-8.8
-1.4
-2.8
A
B
~
C
AC
BC
~C
Figure 6. Effects and interactions in comparision with significance area 1%.
8. MATHEMATICAL MODEL Started out from the analysis of variance a mathematical model can be established. This model describes the relationship between the target value (maximum drawing force Fmax) and the significant factors (die radius r z and drawing ratio 13) by means of a linear regression procedure [ 12] Fmax = f(rz, 13) .
199 This summarizing equation is for the presented 24-experiment:
/ ]
Fmax - [ 4 4 . 2 8 - 0.898. ] ~ - 3
+17.049.
+0.2. ~ - 3
.
0.227
0.227
-6.99
kN
(1)
By means of this equation any desired value of Fmax can be determined in the range 3mm _
and
1.3636 < 13 --- 1.8182 .
This model allows to calculate the maximum drawing force for all combinations of r z and 13 within range of validy. Because there are only two significant factors it is possible to present equ. (1) as an area in three-dimensional space (Fig. 7). According to this graph a minimum value of Fma x is given by the parameter combination r z = 6mm and 13 = 1.3636, this is Fmax = 26.133kN. The factors A = blankholder force and C = lubricant quantity could be fixed on any level between 35kN up to 50kN and 3g/m 2 up to 6g/m 2, resp.. In practice a level would be chosen, which is easier to create and/or of lower cost.
71
kN 61
L
/
51 41 E"o) E . c_
31
1 1.9 1.7"
E-o 9
4
5.5 die
radius rz
Figure 7. Diagram of model equation.
6 mm
1.3"
~x~
/
200 Equ. (1) describes the straight line in subcritical area, according to Fig. 2. In order to calculate the limited drawing ratio 13max, one point in hypercritical area is needed to determine the failure load FBr. According to the method by Schmidt-Kapfenberg this failure load is independent from the used metal forming parameters. So, one or a few experiments (to eleminate natural variance of measured values by calculating the mean) are enough. But to bear out this thesis, a 23-experiment with three replicates is carried out with blank diameter d 3 = 240mm resp. drawing ratio 133 = 2.18 and controllable factors A = F N, B = r z and C = S. The analysis of variance indicates, that none of this factors is significant regarding to Fmax. So, the calculated statistical average of all observed values of the 24 runs (each with three replicates) in the hypercritical area can be used as failure load. This calculation is delivering, here: FBr = 67.435kN
9.
(2)
O P T I M I Z A T I O N OF L I M I T E D D R A W I N G RATIO The summarizing equ. (1) for the 24-experiment describes the straight line in subcritical
area. This relationship together with failure load FBr (equ. 2) can be used to calculate the limited drawing ratio for any value of the significant factor r z. Therefore, equ. (1) is equated with equ. (2) and solved to 13. The solution is a summarizing equation for 13max: 135.59 + 1.532. rz / mm 13max(rz) = 72.367 + 0.587. rz / mm
(3)
By means of this equation any value of the limited drawing ratio can be determined for a given die radius in a range between 3mm and 6mm. For example, for a given value r z = 4mm a limited drawing ratio 13max = 1.896 can be realized. Optimum is found at 13max = 1.908 with r z = 6mm.
10. C O N C L U D I N G R E M A R K The intention of this work was the optimization of deep drawing conditions by reducing the maximum drawing force that is needed for metal forming and to increase the limited drawing ratio by means of designed experiments. A statistical design of experiment is a test, or a series of tests, in which the controllable input factors or process variables are varied
201 according to a particular pattern. The effects, which these variations have on the output response or target value are observed and evaluated statistically by an analysis of variance. This statistical technique enables to determine which factors and probable interactions between the factors have a significant influence on the target value. Finally, by means of a linear regression model a mathematical relationship between these significant factors and interactions on the one hand and the target value on the other hand is established. In the paper presented the designed experiment is a 2n-factorial one with three replicates in the blank diameter, die radius, lubricant quantity and blankholder force. By means of this the target value drawing force on the one hand and target value failure load on the other hand are investigated. Both investigations are delivering, finally, that the die radius is the only significant influential factor on the limited drawing ratio regarding the four input factors mentioned above. But, of course, other input factors can be studied in future, too, by the presented method, e.g. tool coating, kind of lubricant, etc..
REFERENCES
1. G.E. Dieter, Mechanical Metallurgy, Mc-Graw-Hill, Inc., New York 1986. 2. M. Schmidt, Archiv fur das Eisenhnttenwesen 3(1929)3, 213. 3. W. Ziegler, Industrie-Anzeiger 91 (1969)30, 19. 4. R. Woska, Werkstatt und Betrieb 114(1981)5, 342. 5. C. Schulze, QZ 36(1991)6, 334. 6. R.A. Fisher, The design of experiments, Oliver and Boyd, London, 1966. 7. O.L. Davies, The Design and Analysis of Industrial Experiments, Longman Group Ltd., London, New York, 1980. 8. J. Rabe, Kunststoffe 83(1993)4, 291. 9. K. Lange, Umformtechnik Band3: Blechbearbeitung, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York, 1990. 10. E. Doege, et. al., VDI-Berichte 330(1978), 12. 11. H. Kuhn, VDI-Z 132(1990)12, 91. 12. B. Pegel, Empirische Modellbildung und Versuchsplanung, Akademie-Verlag, Berlin 1980. 13. K. D. C. Stoodley, Applied Statistical Techniques, Ellis Hoi'wood Ltd., England, 1980. 14. L. L. Lapin, Probabiltity and Statistics for modem engineering, 2nd. ed., PWS-Kent Publishing Company, Boston, 1990.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Materials Processing Defects S.K. Ghosh and M. Predeleanu (Editors) 9 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
203
Formability, damage and corrosion resistance of coated steel sheets J.Z.Gronostajski and Z.].Gronostajski Institute of Mechanical Engineering and Automation, Technical University of Wroctaw, ul. Lukasiewicza 3/5, 50-371 Wroctaw, Poland
1. EN'TRODUCTION In recent years the demand for good corrosion protection in wide variety of finished products has resulted in the increasing use of various kinds of coated steel sheets [1-4] manufactured according to three processes: electrogalvanized coating - hot dip galvanized coating roller coating. Usually, the coatings are made of the following materials: pure zinc, alloyed zinc and plastic. A surface of coatings is essential not only for the protection, but also for the decoration, of a very wide range of products. The use of coated steel in press metal forming is becoming a quite common practice. The application, for example, of HSLA steels in the motor car industry enables a reduction in material thickness, in the weight of the car and in fuel consumption, but places higher demands on corrosion protection. The forming processes of coated steel sheets are limited by the similar phenomena as arise during the deformation of uncoated steel sheets, namely plastic instability, fracture, wrinkling caused by inappropriate mechanical properties, and additionally by the other phenomena like as: formation of cracks within the coating, lack of adherence between the base steel and the coating, powdering and abrasion, caused by the roughness of the surface layers. These phenomena are caused by the combination of a soft surface film and a hard base material and by differences in surface characteristic of coated steel sheets from those of ordinary cold rolled steel sheets. Special attention has to be paid to the influence of the deformation conditions on the performance of the coating, as regards protection against corrosion. The adhesion of the coatings- either metallic or organic - must remain good, and the surface should not be damaged during forming. When the coating beans to crack, the main property of coated steel sheet, i.e., its corrosion resistance, starts to deteriorate due to the exposure of the base steel to the atmosphere. Generally the application of coated steel sheets in press forming raises three main questions: the formability of the coated steel sheets, the adherence of the coating during the forming operations, and the effect of the forming on the behaviour of the coating. The paper gives the answer to above questions. -
-
204 2. E X P E R I M E N T A L PROCEDURE
The presented results were obtained on the base of investigation of fifth types of coated steel sheets [5-7]: zinc electrogalvanized steel sheet (ZEGS), zinc hot-dip galvanized steel sheet (ZHDGS), polyethylene coated zinc hot-dip galvanized steel sheet (PCZHDGS), acryl coated zinc hot-dip galvanized steel sheet (ACZHDGS) and PVC coated zinc hot-dip galvanized steel sheet (PVCCZHDGS). While the organic coating of the zinc layer was on one side only, the zinc coating was on both sides of the sheets. The thickness of the coatings and of the sheets is presented in Table 1, the chemical composition of the steels are given in Table 2. TABLE 1 The thickness of the coatinss and the total thickness of the coated steel sheets Thickness of Material Sheet Zinc Organic Intermetallic layer coating layer (mm) (~m) (~tm) (~m) ZEGS 1.03 10 ZHDGS 0.90 28 3.1 PCZHDGS 0.95 26 60 3.5 ACZHDGS 1.05 23 400 3.1 PVCCZHDGS 0.93 20 200 3.0 TABLE 2 Chemical composition of the steels investisated Material C Mn Si P weight % ZEGS 0.08 0.27 0.03 0.025 ZHDGS 0.08 0.35 0.01 0.025 PCZHDGS 0.09 0.37 0.01 0.028 ACZHDGS 0.08 0.36 0.02 0.035 PVCCZHDGS 0.09 0.44 0.01 0.035
S
AI
Ni
Cu
0.05 0.05 0.03 0.02 0.02
0.006 0.007 0.008 0.004 0.006
0.07 0.08 0.05 0.10 0.10
0.07 0.08 0.05 0.10 0.10
The forming limit diagrams were made by using specimens of varying width, to secure all the types of strain paths occurring in practice during a pressing operations. The FLDs were determined for simple strain paths (SSPs) and complex strain paths (CSPs), the latter consisting of two different linear stages of deformation. In the first stage the specimens were tensioned uniaxially to approximately e 1 = -0.06, or deformed equibiaxially to about e 1 = e 2 = 0.06, whilst in the second stage the strain paths were changed from uniaxial to nearly equibiaxial deformation. During the first stage of deformation in-plane conditions existed and in the second stage of deformation a hemispherical punch, 110 mm diameter, was used. The methods used for strain analysis and plotting of the FLDs have been described elsewhere [5]. The organic coated sheet steels were investigated in three various conditions: first, with the organic coatings, next with a zinc layer after the removal of the organic coatings, and finally, after the organic and zinc coatings had been removed, so that the base steels were in contact with the punch. The friction coefficients between various surface layers and the steel
205 tool were measured by using equipment similar to that one described elsewhere [8]. The study was performed without additional lubricant, but the soft zinc coating and the organic layers can be assumed to act as solid lubricant. The cracking resistance of the zinc coating was evaluated using the specimens that were tested to establish the FLDs. Several samples were cut from each of the specimens and examined under a scanning electron microscope. Scanning of the zinc coating was started at the fracture or necking band and was continued in the direction of major strain towards the less strained area away from the crack, until an area was reached in which no zinc cracking was noticed, the strain measured in this area indicating the cracking limit. The strain at which cracking began for a given path was marked on the same coordinates system as the FLDs. The cracking limit curve was drawn by connecting the points for the different paths, the flaking limit curve being evaluated in the same manner. As it was difficult, sometimes, to distinquish between cracking and flaking of the zinc layer using the scanning electron microscope, adhesive tape was employed to evaluate the flaking. SEM was also used to investigate the damages in the steel sheets such as: the type and size of cracks, the nucleation and growth of voids, the size, shape, quantity and chemical composition of the inclusions. The corrosion resistance was measured by the resistance to red rust in a corrosion test carried out according to American Standard C44-75. The corrosion test utilizes a one hour cycle that includes a 10 minutes period in a water solution of 3.5% NaCl followed by a 50 minutes period out of solution, dunng which the specimens are allowed to dry. This one cycle is continued 24 h/day for a total of 30 days at a temperature of 27_+ l~ and a humidity of 45_+6%. A general pictures of correlation between the strain level and corrosion resistance were made by drawing in the coordinate system g l-g2 the progress of corrosion for defined strain paths and degrees of deformation. 3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Comparison of the FLDs of the zinc hot-dip galvanized steel sheet and of the zinc electrogalvanized steel sheet for linear and complex strain paths can be seen in Fig. 1. Formability of zinc electrogalvanized steel sheet for all strain paths used in the study is much better than formability of zinc hot-dip galvanized steel sheets. The differences are mainly caused by presence of a brittle iron-zinc alloy layer between the zinc coating and the steel. Thickness of the layer is round about 3.1 ~tm (Table 1). The effect of the organic coatings and zinc coating obtained by hot-dip method on the FLDs related to the FLDs of base steel sheets is presented in Fig.2-4 [6]. Curves were determined for each of the above mentioned three conditions. Generally, the presence of coatings improves the formability of the sheets, but the improvement depends on the type of coating material. Comparing these curves, it can be noted that the PVC layer exerts a more distinct effect on the position of FLC than do polyethylene coatings, whilst the smallest influence is exerted by acryl. The effect of organic coatings on the ratio of the increment of effective strain caused by the coatings to the effective strain at the point of instability of the bare steel, determined along different linear strain paths, is shown in Fig5. From the figure it can be seen that the relative increase of formability caused by each of the organic coatings under study, is not dependent on the linear strain ratio. For the complex strain paths the differences in the FLCs between coated steel and bare steel are more distinct when the final stage involves biaxial stretching than when it involves uniaxial tension: this is because the area
206 of contact between the punch and the deformed sheet, as well as the contact pressure, are greater during biaxial than uniaxial deformation. As a consequence, the effect of friction due to different surface conditions becomes more significant.
E1
O,Z,O~
,
- ' - P~ ---zinc
o2.o
!
015
C.I0
.... sfeel
-0, 5-0J0-0 35 o o.os o.lo
9
-0,05
I
-o, s-o, o-ops o Qos o,lo
o,2o
Figure 1. FLDs of zinc hot-dip galvanized Figure 2. FLDs of polyethylene coated zinc and zinc electrogalvanized steel sheets for hot-dip galvanized steel sheet for simple and simple and complex strain paths complex strain paths Compared to steel, the coatings are soft and, consequently, their shear strength is low. Hence, they can be assumed to act as solid lubricants in the forming processes, with a large thickness as compared to the surface roughness of the bare metal. The measured coefficients of friction, ~t, are presented in Table 3, from which it can be noted that the lowest value was obtained for the PVC coating and the highest value for the bare steel. The decrease of the friction coefficient due to the presence of the zinc coating is in accordance with the findings of Ranta-Eskola [9] and M~kimattila [10], but according to Flossdorf [3] the effect of the zinc coating on the coefficient of friction can be varied, dependently on the sliding velocity, tool material, surface roughness and lubricant.The results of friction tests, as well as those of the analysis of the FLDs, establish that the position of the FLCs increases when the friction between the punch and the formed sheet decreases, which is in agreement with the results reported by Weidemann [11], Blanchard [12] and Gerdeen [13]. Weidemann investigated the drawability of coil coated steels and found that some of the coated steels, e.g., coated with PVC, can be drawn to a greater drawing ratio than uncoated steels, due to the reduction of friction between the tool and the sheet surface. Blanchard [12] concluded that the reduction in sheet-tool friction caused by different types of zinc coating made a noticeable contribution to the increase in the performance of the metal
207
E1
0/+0
~\%. '~x.~
~" 9
,,
_.<--
'
...... .... 9
~. ....
0115 "aJ"
acry1,0,10 ~ zinc steel 0,0~
, , -q15-o9o-qos
T I
l i ,
I
-
o o.o5 o,lo E2 q2
Figure 3. FLDs of an acryl coated zinc hotdip galvanized steel sheet for simple and complex strain paths
-.-
~v
.0~0
---
zinc steel
t3,05
i
i
-0;15-0,10-0,05
0 0 , OSO;lOl~ z 0,20
Figure 4. FLDs of the PVC coated zinc hot-dip galvanized steel sheet for simple and complex strain paths
TABLE 3 The coefficients of friction between the sheet and the tool Coefficient of friction Material Plastic coating Zinc-tool Steel-tool -tool ZEGS 0.18 0.20 ZHDGS 0.16 0.20 PCZHDGS 0.11 0.16 0.19 ACZHDGS 0.13 0.17 0.20 PVCCZHDGS 0.09 0.15 0.19 in press forming. Veerman [14] also reported different FLCs for different lubricants, showing that the FLCs decreased with increasing friction. The opinion is advanced in some reports that modification of the friction conditions between the tool and the sheet metal changes only the strain paths, and has no direct effect on the FLCs. In such analysis one additional factor must be taken into account, which is that the modification of the friction conditions changes not only the strain path but also the strain gradient in the necking area. It can be concluded that the one of the reasons for variation of formability with the type of surface conditions between the tool and the formed sheet is associated with the change of the strain gradient. The effect of the complex strain paths of the coated steel sheets on the FLDs is illustrated in Figs 1-4. The FLDs for the uniaxially prestrained specimens are displaced in the direction of negative minor strain, whilst those for equibiaxially prestrained specimens are displaced in the direction of positive minor strain. As shown by the plots of Figs 1-4, the forming limit
208
..... ....
PCV polyethylene ncryt
0,3
i)
0,55
FLC /r-'---
FI~C
(:U
,:,., L,O
0,2 "="
==.
===-
.=,~
.-=-
,===.
m l , = = , = , , ~ = , = = .
===,
~
I .
025"
' ~ ~
,0,20 -0#
-02
0
Q2
0,4
Figure 5. The effect of different coating on the ratio of Aee/e e for different simple strain paths
o Qos
E2 o2o
Figure 6. CLC, FkLC and FLC of the ZEGS for simple and complex strain paths
curves can be raised significantly in the area of deformation close to plane strain by using the CSPs if the primary forming sequence is close to uniaxial straining. This is of great importance to the press-forming industry, as it allows the formability of the material to be increased by controlling the strain paths, particularly since final states of deformation close to plane strain are dominant in pressed auto body panels. Comparing the FLCs for linear strain paths with those for primary forming in equibiaxial stretching, it becomes obvious that the FLCs for a CSPs are lower than those for the SSPs. The effect of the CSPs on the FLCs of coated steel sheets is in agreement with the data reported in the literature [ 15,16] for uncoated steel sheets. The effective work-hardening rates of the steel sheet under biaxial loading are greater than those under uniaxial loading: the strain softening which occurs due to the change in strain path from biaxial to uniaxial, therefore produces a rapid loss in the ability of the biaxially prestrained steel to undergo uniform deformation. The effect of changing of the strain path from uniaxial to equibiaxial on the limit strain can be explained similarly. The cracking (CLCs) and flaking limit curves (FkLCs) in comparison with the FLCs for zinc electrogalvanized, zinc hot-dip galvanized and polyethylene coated zinc hot dip galvanized steel sheets are shown in Figs 6-8, and for other sheets are given in papers [17]. From the Figs 6-8 one can notices, that the highest value of cracking strains has the electrogalvanized zinc coating. The coating has a constant chemical composition over the thickness of the coating without intermetallic layer, nearly the constant thickness and small grain size, what is a reason, which in negative minor strain region makes coating follows deformation of the steel core without cracking. In the positive minor strain region the cracking
209
limit curves of electrogalvanized zinc coating lie below the FLCs but much higher than CLCs of zinc hot-dip galvanized steel sheets. From Figs 6-8 it is evident that the cracking of the zinc layer depends on the strain ratio. For both linear and complex strain paths, the higher is the value of s2/e 1 ratio the lower is the value of the major cracking strain of ZHDGS sheets and the larger are discrepancies between FLCs and CLCs of ZEGS sheets. The cracking limit curves of the specimens that were prestrained equibiaxially are lower than those of the specimens that were prestrained uniaxially. By comparing the cracking limit curves for linear- and complex-strain paths (Figs 6-8), it can be noted that the cracking limit curves for uniaxially prestrained specimens lie at a higher major strain than the cracking limit curves for linearly deformed specimens, whilst the latter in turn lie at a higher major strain than the cracking limit curves for equibiaxially prestrained specimens. This shows that biaxial stretching is an unfavorable forming mode for hot-dip galvanized and electrogalvanized steel sheets and that uniaxial tension seems to be recommendable. From Figs 7-8 it can be noted also that for hot-dip galvanized steel sheets in the range of thickness of zinc layer investigated, the greater is the thickness of the layer (Table 1) the higher is the position of the cracking limit curves at the same SSP. The highest position is for the ZHDGS sheet with a zinc layer of 28 p.tm thickness (Fig.7) and the lowest is for the PVCCZHDGS sheet with a zinc layer of 20 lam thickness [ 17].
El 9,~
I . I
1
,
~,& ! / 7 1 u , ~ u i ~ ~ , 7 " ,
-~--..-.,r% i " ' , 3 6 - i
- /z
1
,7-,1'I-
Ix'4
!
i
CLC , , 1_
o,lo
1
..o.o5 I 1
-0 15-0,10-~5 0 ~5 0,10 ~2 0,20 Figure 7. Cracking limit curves, flaking limit curves and forming limit curves of the zinc hot-dip galvanized steel sheet for simple and complex strain paths
iL
.....
I
iI
0,0~
-0,15-0,10-0135 0 0,O5 0,10 s
02O
Figure 8. Cracking limit curves, flaking limit curves and forming limit curves of polyethylene coated zinc hot-dip galvanized steel sheet for simple and complex strain paths
Cracking of the zinc coating and the growth of the cracks during deformation was analysed in terms of the formability of the coating. The area fraction of the cracks 0rc) as a function of
210 the thickness strain (e3) for linear-and complex-strain paths is shown in Figs 9 and 10 respectively. The lines in each of these figures have been plotted using a simple model suggested by Makimattila and Ranta-Eskola [18]. In the model it is assumed that if the coating is rigid (i.e., does not deform plastically) the area fraction of the cracks is determined by the area increase due to deformation (solid lines). The formability index of zinc layer (k) was defined by the equation below.
(I)
fc = 1 - exp [(! - k)c~]
A value of k = 0 means that the coating does not deform plastically, whilst for k = 1 the coating deforms in the same manner as does the base steel (i.e., without cracking). The values of k at simple and complex strain paths for zinc electrogalvanized steel sheet are much higher than those for all kinds of hot-dip galvanized steel sheets (Table 4). Schedin et al [19] for zinc hot-dip galvanized steel sheet obtained the similar results of k = 0,8 as an average value for uniaxial tension, plane strain and equibiaxial stretching. The k values for all the steel sheets used in the study, are greater for uniaxially deformed or predeformed specimens than that for equibiaxially deformed or predeformed specimens. This means that the formability of the zinc coating for equibiaxial deformation is lower than that for uniaxial deformation, which is in agreement with the conclusions drawn from the cracking limit curves presented in Figs 6-8.
k..I
---catcut~afed -.-unbx~ot tension .... ploq,e simjn ;------:
,4---
.<E 0::: C)
z
0 I--L_J
---eQUIDIQ~IQ[
0,20
<
L_U C~
0,05 0
/~,
v
sfretch~ng/ I ck--0
~---eq9. ibioxio[ § , uniaxio( /I
(_.1
q20"- strain
Y
0,15
< 0,10
0:5 !1
] cotcutcd'~
q2s .-.-uniQx~l-,-equi-, biaxio[ strdin,~ f,L
I.I0
k-0,62,
i ! I i
i I
z 0,15 0 I--
I
tk:0?6 i
I -o,I -02 -0,3 -0,4 -0S THICKNESS STRAIN, E3
Figure 9. Area fraction of the cracks of the zinc layer as a function of the thickness strain of the PCZHDGS for simple strain paths
O,10
,,t
'k-0 !/ -.'""
u_ I_1_! r~
095
//
<1:
0
I" -0,I
I-