Magnetic Resonance Angiography
wwwwwwwwwwww
James C. Carr, MD Timothy J. Carroll, PhD Editors
Magnetic Resonance Angiography Principles and Applications
Editors: James C. Carr, MD Director of Cardiovascular Imaging Associate Professor of Radiology and Medicine Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine Chicago, IL USA
[email protected]
Timothy J. Carroll, PhD Associate Professor of Biomedical Engineering Director of MRI Research Department of Radiology Northwestern University Chicago, IL USA
[email protected]
ISBN 978-1-4419-1685-3 e-ISBN 978-1-4419-1686-0 DOI 10.1007/978-1-4419-1686-0 Springer New York Dordrecht Heidelberg London Library of Congress Control Number: 2011940427 © Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2012 All rights reserved. This work may not be translated or copied in whole or in part without the written permission of the publisher (Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, 233 Spring Street, New York, NY 10013, USA), except for brief excerpts in connection with reviews or scholarly analysis. Use in connection with any form of information storage and retrieval, electronic adaptation, computer software, or by similar or dissimilar methodology now known or hereafter developed is forbidden. The use in this publication of trade names, trademarks, service marks, and similar terms, even if they are not identified as such, is not to be taken as an expression of opinion as to whether or not they are subject to proprietary rights. While the advice and information in this book are believed to be true and accurate at the date of going to press, neither the authors nor the editors nor the publisher can accept any legal responsibility for any errors or omissions that may be made. The publisher makes no warranty, express or implied, with respect to the material contained herein. Printed on acid-free paper Springer is part of Springer Science+Business Media (www.springer.com)
“I would like to dedicate this to my wife, Jean and my son, Nate, who taught me to love books.” Timothy J. Carroll “I would like to dedicate this book to my wife, Maria, and children, Cristian and Sebastian, without whose constant support, dedication and inspiration, this work would not be possible.” James C. Carr
wwwwwwwwwwww
Preface
It is with tremendous enthusiasm and excitement that we introduce the book Magnetic Resonance Angiography: Principles and Applications to those who are interested in and involved with the ever-expanding field of magnetic resonance angiography (MRA). Vascular disease remains to this day the central cause for many serious clinical conditions, such as stroke, myocardial infarction, and peripheral arterial disease, each of which can precipitate further downstream complications, which can ultimately lead to serious morbidity and death in many individuals. While huge progress has been made to develop novel therapies for vascular pathologies, such as minimally invasive endovascular stents and stem cell therapies, much of these approaches still depend on an accurate depiction of the appearance and extent of abnormalities within the blood vessels. The original gold standard for diagnosing vascular disease was catheter-based digital subtraction angiography, which of course is invasive for the patient and can result in significant complications, albeit rare with current technology. The concept of inserting a needle directly into an artery so that iodinated contrast can be injected rapidly to opacify blood vessels under X-ray visualization will seem barbaric to readers of this textbook. In fact, it was not long ago that the accepted standard for diagnosing peripheral vascular disease was translumbar aortography, where the abdominal aorta was directly accessed percutaneously for diagnostic angiographic purposes. While such diagnostic techniques seem prehistoric and dated in the modern era, it is also a testament to how much progress has been made in the area of noninvasive vascular diagnosis that we have this attitude. Given the invasive alternatives, much effort has been spent on developing alternative noninvasive diagnostic techniques for assessing vascular disease. One of these tools, Doppler ultrasound, is used in routine clinical practice today to assess conditions, such as carotid artery stenosis and peripheral vascular disease. Ultrasound has the advantage of being noninvasive, cheap, and easily portable; however, it is most useful for superficial vessels, not having the penetration to image deeper structures, such as the intracranial vasculature or pulmonary circulation. Computed tomography (CT) is one of the most common diagnostic tools used today in medicine and can also be employed to image the vasculature. CT has achieved particular success with the recent development of multidetector scanners that allow rapid acquisition speeds at spatial resolutions that approximate digital subtraction angiography. While CT is quick and easy to operate, two major drawbacks include exposure to ionizing radiation and the requirement of injected potentially nephrotoxic-iodinated contrast for vessel opacification. Finally, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), which is also used in all areas of medicine today, is ideally suited for imaging the vasculature. It is a noninvasive imaging tool too; however, in contrast to CT and catheter-based angiography, it does not use ionizing radiation and gadolinium, which is used as the contrast agent, is relatively nontoxic compared to iodinated agents. While MRI also has some disadvantages, such as not being able to scan patients with devices, such as pacemakers, it is the only modality that can combine anatomic depiction with functional assessment in the same study.
vii
viii
MRI emerged as a vascular imaging tool about 30 years ago with the discovery of time-offlight (TOF) imaging, where it became apparent that, as blood flowed through an external magnetic field, it emitted a signal that could be used for imaging purposes. TOF was the original noncontrast MRA technique; however, scan times were long and images were plagued by flow artifacts that could result in misdiagnosis. The technique has benefited from acceleration strategies developed over the years and is still used routinely in the intracranial circulation. The field of MRA really took off in the 1990s with the development of contrast-enhanced MRA. Contrast-enhanced MRA relied on an intravenous injection of a gadolinium-based extracellular contrast agent which, when imaged with a T1-weighted gradient echo pulse sequence, produced bright images of the blood vessels with suppression of the background tissues. The principal impact of contrast-enhanced MRA was that it produced images that were similar to conventional angiograms in very short periods of time. Much of the development in the field of MRA over the following decade focused on improving acquisition speed and spatial resolution for contrast-enhanced MRA. More recently, a condition known as nephrogenic systemic fibrosis (NSF) was described and its cause was linked to patients with renal dysfunction who were exposed to high doses of gadolinium. A lot more is known about NSF now and the condition has nearly been eliminated with better screening of patients and using lower doses of gadolinium. One less talked about consequence was that the field of MRA diverted its attention away from contrast-enhanced MRA to the development of noncontrast MRA techniques. The result was the development of a myriad of new techniques over the last few years that has become confusing to practicing clinicians and scientists in the field. Magnetic Resonance Angiography: Principles and Applications is designed to bring together into a single textbook all of the different MRA techniques, both contrast-enhanced and noncontrast, current contrast agents and implications for NSF, and strategies for applying these techniques in different clinical situations. The book is targeted to physicists, physicians (particularly those specializing in imaging), MRI technologists, residents, fellows, and students, both doctoral and postdoctoral. The book does not claim to have all of the answers and reflects a snapshot of current thinking in the field. Already there are new developments on the horizon. However, we hope to be able to provide a concrete basis for comprehending current MRA techniques and the clinical protocols in which they are applied so that new techniques can be more easily understood. With this objective in mind, we have divided the textbook into two parts. Part I (Chaps. 1–16) is focused on MRA techniques and part II (Chaps. 17–29) is focused on clinical applications. Part I begins with a review of MRI physics as it pertains to MRA. There are chapters devoted to all of the main MRA techniques, including contrast-enhanced MRA, time-of-flight, and phase contrast. There are several chapters devoted to newer noncontrast MRA techniques. A couple of specific areas, such as time-resolved angiography and coronary MRA are addressed independently. We have also attempted to describe in more detail-specific topics, such as highfield MRA, susceptibility-weighted imaging, acceleration strategies, such as parallel imaging, vessel wall imaging, targeted contrast agents, and low-dose contrast-enhanced MRA. Part II encompasses all of the clinical applications for MRA. Each chapter is divided into an initial “techniques” part, which describes the MRA techniques and protocols for that disease and vascular territory, and an “applications” part, which describes the pathology and imaging findings relevant to the disease state being discussed. There may be some repetition of techniques previously described in part I, although not with the same degree of detail. It is hoped that the techniques and protocols discussed will provide a foundation for the reader to develop his/her own protocols. We have deliberately avoided providing “canned” protocols, which may be somewhat restrictive given the numerous MRA techniques currently available. The “applications” part is designed to provide a comprehensive description of different pathologies together with MRA imaging findings. This should be particularly useful to physicians in practice, residents, and fellows in training. We have devoted specific chapters to NSF and its implications for contrast-enhanced MRA, MRI contrast agents, and newer topics, such as interventional MRI.
Preface
Preface
ix
Finally, we would like to thank all of the contributors to this book, without whom this text would not be possible. Each author is a highly respected expert in the field of MRA and this book would not have been feasible without their contribution and dedication. We would like to thank all our colleagues in the MRI community whose inspiration, support, and friendship have been invaluable. We would specifically like to thank our respective mentors, Dr. Paul Finn, MD, and Dr. Charles Mistretta, PhD, whose past and ongoing support has provided guidance and encouragement for many years. We would like to thank Springer for bringing this book to fruition, specifically Jennifer Donnelly and Frances Louie, whose patience and effort have been immeasurable. Chicago, IL Chicago, IL
James C. Carr, MD Timothy J. Carroll, PhD
wwwwwwwwwwww
Contents
Part I MRA Techniques 1
Basic Principles of MRI and MR Angiography .................................................. Frank R. Korosec
3
2
Time-of-Flight Angiography ................................................................................. Seong-Eun Kim and Dennis L. Parker
39
3
Phase-Contrast MRI and Flow Quantification ................................................... Bernd Jung and Michael Markl
51
4
Technical Aspect of Contrast-Enhanced MRA ................................................... Honglei Zhang, Wei Zhang, and Martin R. Prince
65
5
Time-Resolved, Contrast-Enhanced MR Angiography Using Cartesian Methods ...................................................................................... Stephen J. Riederer, Clifton R. Haider, Casey P. Johnson, and Petrice M. Mostardi
75
6
Flow-Dependent Noncontrast MR Angiography ................................................ Mitsue Miyazaki, Satoshi Sugiura, Yoshimori Kassai, Hitoshi Kanazawa, Robert Edelman, and Ioannis Koktzoglu
89
7
Low-Dose Contrast-Enhanced MR Angiography ............................................... Kambiz Nael, Roya Saleh, Gerhard Laub, and J. Paul Finn
107
8
Vessel Wall Imaging Techniques ........................................................................... Rui Li, Niranjan Balu, and Chun Yuan
113
9
Noncontrast Coronary Artery Imaging ............................................................... Allison Hays, Robert G. Weiss, and Matthias Stuber
129
10
Contrast-Enhanced MR Angiography of the Coronary Arteries ...................... Qi Yang and Debiao Li
141
11
MR Angiography and High Field Strength: 3.0 T and Higher.......................... Harald H. Quick and Mark E. Ladd
149
12
Susceptibility Weighted Imaging and MR Angiography.................................... Samuel Barnes and E. Mark Haacke
157
13
Non-Cartesian MR Angiography ......................................................................... Walter Block and Oliver Wieben
169
xi
xii
Contents
14
Parallel Imaging in Angiography ......................................................................... Nicole Seiberlich and Mark Griswold
185
15
Targeted Agents for Wall Imaging ....................................................................... Emily A. Waters and Thomas J. Meade
199
Part II
Clinical Applications
16
Intracranial Arterial and Venous Disease ........................................................... Dariusch R. Hadizadeh, Horst Urbach, and Winfried A. Willinek
213
17
Carotid and Vertebral Circulation: Clinical Applications ................................. Sugoto Mukherjee and Max Wintermark
225
18
Thoracic Aorta ....................................................................................................... Emily Ward and James C. Carr
239
19
Pulmonary MRA .................................................................................................... James F.M. Meaney and Peter Beddy
253
20
Abdominal Aorta and Mesenteric Vessels ........................................................... Klaus D. Hagspiel and Patrick T. Norton
269
21
Renal Vascular Diseases ........................................................................................ Tim Leiner and Henrik Michaely
283
22
MRA: Upper Extremity and Hand Vessels .......................................................... Ruth P. Lim and Vivian S. Lee
297
23
Lower Extremity Peripheral Arterial Disease..................................................... Jeremy D. Collins and Timothy Scanlon
319
24
Noninvasive Imaging for Coronary Artery Disease ............................................ Reza Nezafat, Susie N. Hong, Peng Hu, Mehdi Hedjazi Moghari, and Warren J. Manning
337
25
Venous Imaging: Techniques, Protocols, and Clinical Applications ...................................................................................... Amir H. Davarpanah, Philip Hodnett, Jeremy D. Collins, James C. Carr, and Tim Scanlon
351
26
Pediatric MR Angiography: Principles and Applications .................................. Bharathi D. Jagadeesan and David N. Loy
365
27
Contrast Agents for MR Angiography................................................................. Christoph U. Herborn
381
28
CE-MRA in the Age of Nephrogenic Systemic Fibrosis ..................................... Aditya Bharatha, Sean P. Symons, and Walter Kucharczyk
387
29
Emerging Interventional MR Applications ......................................................... Clifford R. Weiss, Aravindan Kolandaivelu, Jeff Bulte, and Aravind Arepally
395
Index ................................................................................................................................
403
Contributors
Aravind Arepally, MD, FSIR Division of Radiology, Piedmont Healthcare, Atlanta, GA, USA Niranjan Balu, PhD Department of Radiology, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA Samuel Barnes, MS Research Assistant, Department of Radiology, Loma Linda University Medical Center, Loma Linda, CA, USA Peter Beddy Consultant Radiologist, St. James’s Hospital, Dublin, Ireland Aditya Bharatha, MD, FRCP(C) Neuroradiology Fellow, Department of Medical Imaging, University Health Network, Toronto, ON, Canada Walter Block, PhD Associate Professor, Departments of Biomedical Engineering, Medical Physics, and Radiology, Wisconsin Institute for Medical Research, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, WI, USA Jeff Bulte, PhD Professor and Director, Russell H. Morgan Department of Radiology and Radiological Science, The Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD, USA Jeremy D. Collins, MD Assistant Professor of Radiology, Department of Radiology, Northwestern Memorial Hospital and Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, IL, USA Amir H. Davarpanah, MD Department of Radiology, Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, Connecticut Robert R. Edelman, William B. Graham Chairman, Northshore University Health System, Evanston IL, USA J. Paul Finn, MD Professor of Radiology, Medicine and Biomedical Physics, Department of Radiology, Ronald Reagan UCLA Medical Center, Los Angeles, CA, USA Mark Griswold, PhD Associate Professor, Department of Radiology, University Hospitals of Cleveland/Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, OH, USA E. Mark Haacke, PhD Director, MR Research Facility, Department of Radiology, Harper Hospital/Wayne State University, Detroit, MI, USA Dariusch R. Hadizadeh, MD Department of Neuroradiology, University of Bonn, Bonn, Germany
xiii
xiv
Klaus D. Hagspiel, MD Professor of Radiology, Cardiology and Pediatrics, Director, Division of Noninvasive Cardiovascular Imaging, Department of Radiology, University of Virginia Health System, Charlottesville, VA, USA Clifton R. Haider, PhD Department of Radiology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN, USA Allison Hays, MD Assistant Professor of Medicine, Division of Cardiology, Department of Medicine, Johns Hopkins Hospital, Baltimore, MD, USA Christoph U. Herborn, MD, MBA Associate Professor of Radiology, University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf, Hamburg, Germany Philip Hodnett, MD Department of Cardiovascular Imaging, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, IL, USA Department of Radiology, New York University, NY Susie N. Hong, MD Advanced Cardiac Imaging Fellow, Cardiovascular Division, Department of Medicine, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA Peng Hu, PhD Assistant Professor, Department of Radiology, Ronald Reagan Medical Center, Los Angeles, CA, USA Nobuyashu Ichinose, MS Senior Specialist, MRI Systems Development Department, Toshiba Medical Systems Corporation, Otawara, Japan Bharathi D. Jagadeesan, MD Endovascular Surgical Neuroradiology Fellow, Washington University School of Medicine, Barnes-Jewish Hospital, Mallinckrodt Institute of Radiology, Saint Louis, MO, USA Casey P. Johnson Department of Radiology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN, USA Bernd Jung, PhD Department of Radiology, Medical Physics, University Hospital Freiburg, Freiburg, Germany Hitoshi Kanazawa, MS Senior Manager, MR Engineering, MRI Systems Development Department, Toshiba Medical Systems Corporation, Otawara, Japan Yoshimori Kassai, MS Group Manager, MRI Systems Development Department, Toshiba Medical Systems Corporation, Otawara, Japan Seong-Eun Kim, PhD Research Associate, Department of Radiology, Utah Center for Advanced Imaging Research, Salt Lake City, UT, USA Ioannis Koktzoglou, PhD Assistant Professor of Radiology, The University of Chicago, Northshore University Health System, Evanston IL, USA Aravindan Kolandaivelu, MD, BS Assistant Professor of Medicine, Division of Cardiology, Cardiac Arrythmia Service, Johns Hopkins Hospital, Baltimore, MD, USA Frank R. Korosec, PhD Professor of Radiology and Medical Physics, Department of Radiology, University of Wisconsin Hospital and Clinics, Madison, WI, USA Walter Kucharczyk, MD, FRCP(C), FIASTUM Professor, Departments of Medical Imaging and Surgery; Director, MRI and Spectroscopy, Joint Department of Medical Imaging, Senior Scientist; Hans Fischer Senior Fellow, Institute of Advanced Studies, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada Toronto General Research Institute, Toronto, ON, Canada Technical University of Munich, Munich, Germany Department of Medical Imaging, University Health Network, Toronto, ON, Canada
Contributors
Contributors
xv
Mark E. Ladd, PhD Director, Erhan L. Hahn Institute for MRI, University Duisburg-Essen, Essen, Germany Gerhard Laub, PhD Director, MR R&D West, MR Division, Siemens Healthcare USA, Pleasanton, CA, USA Vivian S. Lee, MD, PhD, MBA Vice Dean of Science, Professor of Radiology, Physiology and Neurosciences, Department of Radiology, New York University Langone Medical Center, New York, NY, USA Tim Leiner, MD, PhD Associate Professor of Radiology, Department of Radiology, Utrecht University Medical Center, Utrecht, The Netherlands Debiao Li, PhD Director, Cedars-Sinai Medical Center, Biomedical Imaging Research Institute, Los Angeles, CA, USA Rui Li, PhD Senior Fellow, Radiology Department, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA Ruth P. Lim, MBBS, MMed, FRANZCR Assistant Professor, Department of Radiology, New York University Langone Medical Center, New York, NY, USA David N. Loy, MD, PhD Instructor, Washington University School of Medicine, Barnes-Jewish Hospital, Mallinckrodt Institute of Radiology, Saint Louis, MO, USA Warren J. Manning, MD Cardiovascular Division, Department of Medicine, Department of Radiology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA Michael Markl, PhD Department of Radiology, Medical Physics, University Hospital Freiburg, Freiburg, Germany Director of Cardiovascular MR Research, Associate Professor of Radiology and Biomedical Engineering, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, IL, USA Thomas J. Meade, PhD Eileen M. Foell Professor of Chemistry, Biochemistry and Molecular and Cell Biology, Neurobiology and Physiology, and Radiology, Department of Chemistry, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL, USA James F.M. Meaney, MB, FRCR, FFR Professor, Department of Radiology, Trinity College Dublin, St. James’s Hospital, Dublin, Ireland Henrik Michaely, MD Associate Professor of Radiology, Section Chief of Vascular and Abdominal Imaging, Institute of Clinical Radiology and Nuclear Medicine, University Medical Center Mannheim, Mannheim, Germany Mitsue Miyazaki, PhD Senior Fellow, MRI Department, Toshiba Medical Research Institute, Vernon Hills, IL, USA Mehdi Hedjazi Moghari, PhD Research Fellow, Department of Medicine, Cardiovascular Division, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA Petrice M. Mostardi Department of Radiology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN, USA Sugoto Mukherjee, MD Assistant Professor, Section of Neuroradiology, Department of Radiology, University of Virginia Health System, Charlottesville, VA, USA Kambiz Nael, MD Radiology Resident, Department of Radiological Sciences, Ronald Reagan UCLA Medical Center, Los Angeles, CA, USA
xvi
Reza Nezafat, PhD Assistant Professor of Medicine, Director of Translational Cardiovascular Imaging Program, Department of Medicine, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA Patrick T. Norton, MD Assistant Professor of Radiology, Cardiology and Pediatrics, Division of Noninvasive Cardiovascular Imaging, Department of Radiology, University of Virginia Health System, Charlottesville, VA, USA Dennis L. Parker, PhD Director, Department of Radiology, Utah Center for Advanced Imaging Research, Salt Lake City, UT, USA Martin R. Prince, MD, PhD Professor of Radiology, Department of Radiology, Weill Medical College of Cornell University, New York, NY, USA Harald H. Quick, PhD Director of MR Imaging, Institute of Medical Physics, University Erlangen-Nürnberg, Erlangen, Germany Stephen J. Riederer, PhD Professor, Department of Radiology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN, USA Roya Saleh, MD Researcher, Department of Radiology, David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA, Los Angeles, CA, USA Timothy Scanlon, MD, MRCPI, FFR RCSI Department of Cardiovascular Imaging, Radiology, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, IL, USA Consultant Radiologist, Limerick Regional Hospital, Ireland Nicole Seiberlich, PhD Research Associate, Department of Radiology, University Hospitals of Cleveland/Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, OH, USA Matthias Stuber, PhD Professor and Director, Department of Radiology, Center for Biomedical Research, University Hospital Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland Satoshi Sugiura Chief Specialist, MRI Systems Development Department, Toshiba Medical Systems Corporation, Otawara, Japan Sean P. Symons, MD, MPH, FRCP(C) Neuroradiologist, Department of Medical Imaging, Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre, Toronto, ON, Canada Horst Urbach, MD Professor, Department of Radiology/Neuroradiology, University of Bonn, Bonn, Germany Emily Ward, MB, BCh, BAO Department of Radiology, Northwestern Memorial Hospital, Chicago, IL, USA Emily A. Waters, PhD Department of Chemistry, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL, USA Clifford R. Weiss, MD Assistant Professor of Radiology and Surgery, Division of Vascular and Interventional Radiology, Department of Radiology, Johns Hopkins Hospital, Baltimore, MD, USA Robert G. Weiss, MD Professor of Medicine and Radiology, Department of Medicine, Johns Hopkins Hospital, Baltimore, MD, USA Oliver Wieben, PhD Assistant Professor, Departments of Medical Physics and Radiology, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Wisconsin Institute for Medical Research, Madison, WI, USA Winfried A. Willinek, MD Associate Professor, Department of Radiology, University of Bonn, Bonn, Germany
Contributors
Contributors xvii
xvii
Max Wintermark, MD, MAS Associate Professor of Radiology, Neurology, Neurological Surgery and Biomedical Engineering, Department of Radiology, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, VA, USA Qi Yang, MD, PhD Attending Radiologist, Department of Radiology, Xuanwu Hospital, Capital Medical University, Beijing, China Chun Yuan, PhD Professor, Department of Radiology, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA Honglei Zhang, MD Assistant Professor, Department of Radiology, Weill Medical College of Cornell University, New York, NY, USA Wei Zhang, MD Research Fellow, Department of Radiology, Weill Medical College of Cornell University, New York, NY, USA
wwwwwwwwwwww
Part I MRA Techniques
wwwwwwwwwwww
1
Basic Principles of MRI and MR Angiography Frank R. Korosec
Introduction Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is a very versatile and useful imaging modality. It is capable of providing a wealth of diagnostic information, including information regarding blood flow. Magnetic resonance methods that provide images of the arteries are referred to as magnetic resonance angiography (MRA) methods. A variety of MRA methods exist. These methods can be categorized as noncontrast-enhanced and contrast-enhanced methods. The noncontrast-enhanced methods rely on the motion of blood (phase-contrast MRA, TOF MRA) or the magnetic properties of blood (steady-state free precession MRA) to differentiate signals from blood and stationary tissues, whereas contrast-enhanced methods require the intravenous injection of a contrast material to differentiate signals from blood and stationary tissues. In addition to providing information regarding the morphology of the blood vessels, some MRA methods can provide information regarding blood velocity or volume flow rates. If the MRA acquisitions are cardiac-gated, they can provide information regarding changes in blood velocity or volume flow rate throughout the cardiac cycle. Most MRA methods permit large volumes to be imaged, and the image sets may be retrospectively processed to provide observation of vessels from any perspective. Because MRI provides high-contrast images of soft tissues, MRI exams may be performed together with MRA exams to yield information regarding blood flow and target organ status in the same exam. In addition to providing information regarding vascular and tissue anatomy and blood flow, MRI can be used to obtain information regarding diffusion and perfusion (and a host of other qualities), making it a very
F.R. Korosec, PhD () Department of Radiology, University of Wisconsin Hospital and Clinics, E3/311, 600 Highland Avenue, Madison, WI 53792-3252, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
effective modality for obtaining a comprehensive assessment of vascular disease. There are a great number of MRA methods, and each derives vascular signal by employing features and imaging parameters that take advantage of differences in physical properties between blood and stationary tissues. In order to most effectively utilize the MRA sequences and reap their greatest benefits, it is essential to have a good understanding of the principles of MRI; knowledge of the strengths, limitations, and capabilities of the different MRA methods; and comprehension of how the imaging parameters, and features of each of the MRA methods influence image quality. The physical principles of MRI and MRA will be briefly described in this chapter. Details of the MRA methods are described in more detail in later chapters.
MRI Overview MRI offers a number of benefits over some of the other diagnostic imaging modalities. First, MRI derives signals using a magnetic field and radiofrequency energy, not ionizing radiation or radioactive materials. Second, MRI is able to demonstrate, with striking contrast, differences in signal intensities among different soft tissues. A host of MR imaging parameters can be modified to exploit a variety of tissue-specific properties to manipulate image contrast. Third, MRI is capable of providing tomographic images of any plane without requiring movement of the patient or any of the equipment. The images may be acquired as a series of two-dimensional (2D) slices, or as a true three-dimensional (3D) volume. MRI may be used to image nuclei of atoms containing an odd number of protons and/or neutrons. The nucleus of the hydrogen atom, 1H, on the water molecule satisfies this criterion as it is composed of a single proton. Because of its abundance in the body, the hydrogen nucleus on the water molecule is routinely imaged in MRI. The protons on the fat molecule (as well as the protons on some other molecules) also appear in MR images.
J.C. Carr and T.J. Carroll (eds.), Magnetic Resonance Angiography: Principles and Applications, DOI 10.1007/978-1-4419-1686-0_1, © Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2012
3
4
MRI systems use a strong magnetic field, B0, which is uniform throughout the imaging volume in the bore of the system, and is stable over time. The magnetic field strength is measured in tesla (T) or gauss (G), where 1 T = 104 G. The most commonly used clinical MRI scanners are whole-body imaging systems, with bore diameters of 60 cm or 70 cm,
F.R. Korosec
Fig. 1.1 A state-of-the-art 3 T MRI scanner
and magnetic field strengths of 1.5 T or 3 T. A state-of-the-art 3 T MRI system with a bore diameter of 60 cm is shown in Fig. 1.1. These systems use superconducting magnets, and require a reservoir surrounding the magnet to be filled with liquid helium periodically. The direction of the magnetic field is along the long axis (z-axis) of the bore. Resistive and permanent magnets also are used in MRI systems, but the field strengths of these systems are lower. The magnetic fields of some of these systems are aligned vertically. The hydrogen nucleus possesses a magnetic dipole moment and, from a classical physics perspective, will interact with a magnetic field as if it were a tiny bar magnet. The nuclear magnetic dipole moment of a hydrogen nucleus can either align or antialign with the strong magnetic field of the MRI scanner. In an ensemble of hydrogen nuclei, the majority of the nuclei will align with the magnetic field because it requires less energy to align than to antialign. The net sum of the nuclear magnetic dipole moments from an ensemble of nuclei will yield a bulk magnetization that is aligned with the applied magnetic field. This concept is demonstrated in Fig. 1.2. It is this bulk magnetization that is considered in discussions regarding MRI. In MRI, signal is generated when the bulk magnetization, M, is “tipped” out of alignment with the applied magnetic
Fig. 1.2 (a) Shown on a single xyz coordinate system for comparison with one another are vector representations of magnetic dipole moments aligned with (on the surface of the upward facing cone), and antialigned with (on the surface of the downward facing cone) the main magnetic field, B0. (b) Each vector has a longitudinal component, Mz, and a transverse component, Mxy. (c) Summing the transverse components yields a net sum of zero magnetization (since the orientation in the transverse plane is random, if enough dipole moments are considered, for each one
pointing in a given direction, statistically, there is likely one pointing in the opposite direction, resulting in total cancelation). (d) Summing the longitudinal components yields a net excess of magnetization aligned with the main magnetic field (since it requires less energy for the magnetic dipole moments to align with the magnetic field). (e) The result of summing the contributions from an ensemble of dipole moments is a net, or bulk, magnetization that aligns with the orientation of the main magnetic field, B0
1
Basic Principles of MRI and MR Angiography
5
Fig. 1.3 The bulk magnetization, M, rotates, or precesses, when it is in the transverse plane. The receiver coil detects an oscillating signal from the component of magnetization that points toward it (My in this case). The rate of precession and, therefore, the frequency of the detected signal, are proportional to the strength of the magnetic field, B0. In this diagram, the magnetic field is aligned along the z-axis
field, B0. The mechanism for tipping the magnetization is described below. The maximum signal is generated when the aligned (longitudinal) magnetization is tipped 90° so that it is perpendicular (transverse) to the direction of the applied magnetic field. The longitudinal magnetization is referred to as Mz, and the transverse magnetization is referred to as Mxy. The transverse component of magnetization rotates, or precesses, around the main magnetic field as shown in Fig. 1.3. The precessing transverse component of the magnetization can be detected using a receiver coil oriented perpendicular to the direction of the main magnetic field. The precessing magnetization induces a current in the receiver coil, proportional to the rate of change of the transverse component of the magnetization. Thus, it is the precessing transverse component of the magnetization that produces the MR signal. Because the bulk magnetization spins around the main magnetic field, and because the bulk magnetization is composed of nuclear magnetic dipole moments, the nuclear magnetic dipole moments are often referred to as “spins” in the context of describing the nuclear magnetic resonance phenomenon. The precessional rate of the bulk magnetization is proportional to the strength of the applied magnetic field, B0, and is given by the Larmor equation: ω 0 = g B0 ,
(1.1)
where ω0 is the precessional frequency, g is a constant referred to as the gyromagnetic ratio (its value depends on the nucleus under consideration, 42.58 MHz/T for hydrogen), and B0 is the strength of the main magnetic field. At a field
Fig. 1.4 When a magnetic field, B1, is applied along the x¢-axis in a frame of reference that rotates at the Larmor frequency, the bulk magnetization, M, will precess around B1 in the y¢z¢ plane. This method is used to tip the magnetization away from the longitudinal axis so that a component, Mxy, appears in the transverse plane
strength of 1.5 T, the precessional frequency of the bulk magnetization associated with the hydrogen atom is 63.87 million revolutions per second (63.87 MHz). The precessional frequency is commonly referred to as the Larmor frequency. When dealing with precessing magnetization, discussions are often made easier by introducing the rotating frame of reference. The rotating frame of reference is a frame of reference, such as a coordinate system, that rotates with the object that is being investigated. In this case, the object that is being investigated is the precessing bulk magnetization. Thus, if the xyz reference frame is made to rotate about the z-axis such that the x- and y-axes rotate at the precessional rate of the magnetization, it will appear as if the magnetization is not moving with respect to the rotating x- and y-axes, because the bulk magnetization will always stay in the same position relative to the x- and y-axes. Therefore, in the rotating frame, the precessional frequency of the bulk magnetization is zero. In the rotating frame, it is as if the main magnetic field, B0, is having no effect on the magnetization, so it can be ignored. With the introduction of the rotating frame, and the absence of B0 in this frame, it can be understood that the bulk magnetization can be tipped away from the longitudinal axis simply by applying a magnetic field perpendicular to the longitudinal axis. When this is done, the bulk magnetization will precess around this field. So, for example, if a magnetic field is applied along the x-axis in the rotating frame, the magnetization will precess in the yz plane as shown in Fig. 1.4. The magnetic field that is applied perpendicular to the bulk magnetization to tip it away from the longitudinal axis is referred to as the B1 magnetic field. Note that, in order to
6
Fig. 1.5 As viewed from the stationary frame of reference, the magnetization, M, precesses around the z-axis (at the Larmor frequency) as it is tipped away from this axis, tracing out a trajectory similar to the one shown here. The magnetic field, B1, is applied at the Larmor frequency so that it remains perpendicular to the precessing magnetization, M (ensuring that it is continuously acting to tip the magnetization away from the z-axis)
tip the magnetization away from the longitudinal axis, the B1 field must rotate at the Larmor frequency. If B1 does not precess at the Larmor frequency, the B0 field can no longer be ignored, and the magnetization will precess about some effective field determined by the combination of the B0 and B1 fields. Because the B1 magnetization precesses at 63.87 MHz, and this is in the radiofrequency range of the electromagnetic spectrum, the B1 pulse is often referred to as a radiofrequency (RF) pulse. The process of tipping the magnetization is often referred to as RF excitation. The strength of the RF excitation pulse is on the order of 50 mT, and the duration is typically on the order of just a few milliseconds. If the magnetization were observed from a stationary frame of reference as it were being tipped away from the longitudinal axis, it would be seen to precess about the longitudinal axis as it was being tipped, as shown in Fig. 1.5. The bulk magnetization can be brought from the z-axis into the transverse plane by applying a B1 pulse of the appropriate strength and duration. A B1 pulse that has such an effect is referred to as a 90° RF pulse, since this is the angle traversed by the tipping magnetization. As will be described later, it often is advantageous to tip the magnetization less than 90°. In this case, only a component of the magnetization will be brought into the transverse plane, and the signal will be proportional to sin(q), where q is the tip angle. MRI systems with higher field strengths produce more magnetization (more dipole moments align with a magnetic field of higher strength), which leads to generation of higher signals. Scanners with magnetic field strengths of 3 T are becoming more prevalent, and MRA methods performed on these systems yield excellent results [1–5].
F.R. Korosec
A host of RF coils are available for MRI and MRA applications at various magnetic field strengths. Coils that are cylindrical in shape may be used for transmission of the B1 pulse, and reception of the MR signal. These coils are typically referred to as transmit/receive RF coils. Coils that are not cylindrical in shape generally do not provide a uniform tip angle spatially, so these coils are used only for reception of the MR signal. These coils are referred to as receive only coils. When these coils are used, a cylindrical body coil that is built into the bore of the MRI system is usually used to transmit a spatially uniform B1 pulse. Some coils are composed of multiple smaller coils, or elements, each of which sends its signal to a separate receiver (amplifier, analogue-to-digital converter, etc.). Smaller elements are sensitive to noise from smaller regions of anatomy, and the noise detected by each element is uncorrelated. When the signals and noise from all elements are combined, the result is an image with improved signal-to-noise ratio relative to an image acquired with a single coil that is sensitive to noise in the entire volume covered by the multiple coil elements. These coils are referred to as phased array coils. Vendors currently are providing MRI systems with 32 or more receivers (channels) so phased array coils with 32 elements may be used. For some phased array coils, the number of elements exceeds the number of receivers in the MRI system. With these coils, signals from multiple elements may be combined and sent to a single receiver. Alternatively, the operator may specify that only certain elements be activated during a scan. For example, in a head/neck/spine coil, the operator may chose to activate only the elements required to image the head. In a subsequent scan, the operator may chose to activate only the elements required to image the neck. Some RF coils available for MR imaging are shown in Fig. 1.6.
MRI Contrast Mechanisms In MRI, varying degrees of contrast between different tissues can be achieved by modifying the MR imaging parameters. In this section, three magnetic properties of tissues, namely T2 relaxation, T1 relaxation, and proton density, are described. Later in this chapter, the imaging parameters that are modified to manipulate contrast based on these properties are discussed.
T2 (or Spin–Spin) Relaxation Time It already was shown that the bulk magnetization from a sample can be tipped into the transverse plane using a radiofrequency pulse. It also was shown that the transverse magnetization precesses, and as it does, it induces a signal in the
1
Basic Principles of MRI and MR Angiography
7
Fig. 1.6 Shown here are some of the coils used for MRI and MRA applications, including (a) an 8-channel head coil, (b), an 8-channel head and neck coil, (c) a 4-channel phased array peripheral vascular coil, and (d), an 8-channel phased array torso coil
receiver coil. What was not mentioned is that this transverse magnetization diminishes very rapidly. The rate at which the bulk transverse magnetization decreases is characterized by a constant referred as the T2 decay constant or the T2 relaxation time. Because it refers to relaxation of the transverse magnetization, it is often referred to as the transverse relaxation time. Also, because the effect is caused by spins interacting with neighboring spins, the decay constant is often referred to as the spin–spin relaxation time. The mechanism responsible for this diminution of transverse magnetization is described below. Recall that spins precess at a rate determined by the magnetic field that they experience (the Larmor equation). Recall also that, at 1.5 T, the spins from hydrogen precess at a rate of 63.87 MHz. In tissues, the magnetic field that each nucleus experiences is not exactly equal to the external magnetic field. This is because the magnetic field experienced by a spin is affected by the magnetic fields of the spins in its microscopic neighborhood. The microscopic neighborhood around a spin can cause the spin to experience a field slightly larger, or slightly smaller, than the applied external magnetic field. In tissues, the spins are constantly in motion, so the microscopic neighborhoods of spins are continually changing. The net result is that spins that are tipped into the transverse plane precess at slightly different frequencies (even if they are subjected to a uniform applied external magnetic field), and the precessional frequencies of the spins change over time. This is true even if the spins are in a macroscopically
homogeneous tissue, because of the presence of microscopic inhomogeneities. Due to the differences in the precessional frequencies of spins in different microscopic neighborhoods, the spins throughout the tissue eventually get out of synchronization with one another. That is, the spins that precess faster get ahead of those that precess slower. It is this dispersion, or dephasing, of spins that causes the net transverse magnetization to diminish over time. The behavior of the magnetic dipole moments during T2 relaxation is shown in Fig. 1.7. This figure shows that, in the rotating frame, spins that precess faster than 63.87 MHz, appear to precess clockwise (as viewed from the +z-axis), and spins that precess slower than 63.87 MHz appear to precess counterclockwise. As the spins get more out of phase with one another, components along the −x-axis cancel components along the +x-axis, and eventually components along the −y-axis cancel components along the +y-axis. The time it takes for the transverse magnetization to decrease to 37% of the initial magnetization is referred to as the T2 relaxation time. The T2 relaxation time is determined by the mobility of the spins in the tissue. Thus, different tissues with different spin mobility have different T2 relaxation times. The longer the T2 of a tissue, the longer its transverse magnetization persists. Differences in T2 times of different tissues can be exploited in MR imaging to achieve contrast among different tissues. Spin dephasing is exacerbated by inhomogeneities in the main magnetic field, B0. This is because the precessional rate
8
F.R. Korosec
Fig. 1.7 The rate of precession of spins is affected by neighboring nuclei. In the rotating frame of reference, spins that precess faster than 63.87 MHz appear to precess clockwise (as viewed from the +z-axis) relative to the reference frame, and spins that precess slower than 63.87 MHz appear to precess counterclockwise relative to the reference frame. This dephasing of the spins causes the magnitude of the transverse magnetization, Mxy, to decrease over time. The plot shows the
magnitude of the transverse magnetization as a function of time for two tissues. The time that it takes for the transverse magnetization to diminish to 37% of its initial magnitude is characterized by the T2 time constant. Different tissues have different compositions of nuclear neighbors, and therefore have different T2 time constants. This characteristic is exploited in MRI to obtain different signals from tissues with different T2 time constants
is dictated by the field strength (the Larmor equation). If the field varies spatially, then spins in different locations will have different precessional rates. This will lead to spin dephasing and loss of transverse magnetization in a manner similar to that responsible for T2 decay. Other factors contribute to spin dephasing as well (susceptibility differences, velocity distributions, acceleration distributions, etc.) The decay constant that characterizes how long it takes for the transverse magnetization to diminish to 37% of its initial strength when spin–spin interactions (T2) and all other effects are considered is referred to as T2* (T2 star). The formula for calculating T2* is
Recall that the net longitudinal magnetization is zero after the application of a 90° radiofrequency pulse. This is because after the application of the 90° RF pulse, the number of spins antialigned with the magnetic field is equal to the number of spins aligned with the magnetic field. In other words, the energy imparted to the spin system by the RF pulse causes half of spins to line up in a direction opposite to the magnetic field. After the application of the 90° RF pulse, antialigned spins give up energy to the lattice of the tissue, causing them to once again align with the B0 field. As spins continue to give up energy, aligned spins increasingly out number antialigned spins. The time constant that characterizes how long it takes for the longitudinal magnetization to return to 63% of its initial thermal equilibrium value (the value that it had before it was subjected to the RF pulse) is referred to as the T1 relaxation time. Because this process results from interactions of the spins with the structure of the tissue, or the tissue lattice, the T1 time constant is often referred to as the spin–lattice relaxation time; and because it characterizes the time it takes for the longitudinal magnetization to regrow, it often is referred to as the longitudinal relaxation time. The behavior of the magnetic dipole moments during T1 relaxation is shown in Fig. 1.8. As is the case with T2 relaxation, the T1 relaxation time is determined by the mobility of the spins in the tissue. Different tissues have different T1 relaxation times. The longer the T1 of a tissue, the longer it takes for its longitudinal magnetization to regrow. Differences in T1 times of different tissues can be exploited in MR imaging to achieve varying degrees of contrast among different tissues.
1 1 1 = + , * T2 T2 T2¢
(1.2)
where T2¢ is a time constant that characterizes the loss of transverse magnetization from all factors other than tissue specific, spin–spin interactions. Whereas dephasing due to T2 is advantageous because it permits tissues to be differentiated from one another, dephasing caused by other effects tends to unnecessarily diminish the transverse magnetization. Thus, it is desirable to minimize effects of signal loss from sources other than spin–spin interactions.
T1 (or Spin–Lattice) Relaxation Time At the same time that the transverse magnetization is diminishing, the longitudinal magnetization is increasing.
1
Basic Principles of MRI and MR Angiography
9
Fig. 1.8 After the magnetization is tipped into the transverse plane by the B1 pulse, the spins begin to collide with macromolecules that compose the lattice of the tissue, they give up energy, and they flip from the antialigned state to the aligned state. As more spins flip to the aligned state, the longitudinal magnetization, Mz, grows back to its initial thermal equilibrium value, M0. The plot shows the magnitude of the
longitudinal magnetization as a function of time for two tissues. The time that it takes for the longitudinal magnetization to regrow to 63% of its initial magnitude is characterized by the T1 time constant. Different tissues have different T1 time constants. This characteristic is exploited in MRI to obtain different signals from tissues with different T1 time constants
Table 1.1 Typical T1- and T2-relaxation times for selected tissues in a 1.0 T magnetic field
Table 1.2 Relative T1- and T2-relaxation times of different states of matter
White Matter Gray Matter Fat CSF
T1 (ms)
T2 (ms)
400 500 180 2,000
90 100 90 300
Solid Semisolid Liquid
T1
T2
Long Intermediate Long
Short Intermediate Long
CSF cerebrospinal fluid
Facts Regarding T1 and T2 Relaxation Rates As mentioned above, different tissues have different T1 and T2 values. This permits different tissues to be displayed with different signal intensities in MR images. The signal intensities of different tissues can be altered by manipulating the imaging parameters. Typical relaxation times for selected tissues (in a 1.0 T magnetic field) are listed in Table 1.1. It was stated above that both T2 and T1 relaxation times are dependent on the mobility of spins. The spins in liquids are fairly mobile. Therefore, liquids have long T2 values (see T2 of CSF in Table 1.1). At 1.5 T, the T2 of arterial (oxygenated) blood is about 250 ms, and the T2 of venous blood is about 220 ms. The spins in solids are relatively immobile, so, solids have short T2 values. In fact, the T2 values of solids are so short, that signals from solids do not appear in MRI images; the signals disappear before they can be detected. The T2 values of tissues are intermediate between the T2 values of liquids and solids.
T1 relaxation also is dependent on spin mobility, but in a fairly complicated manner. At 1.5 T, the T1 of arterial and venous blood is about 1,200 ms. The relative T1 and T2 times of solids, semisolids, and liquids are summarized in Table 1.2. These characteristics are schematically plotted in Fig. 1.9. For blood and most tissues, the T1 values increase with field strength (e.g., the T1 of arterial and venous blood is about 1,600 ms at 3 T), whereas the T2 values decrease slightly. The T1 and T2 values of blood and tissues may be decreased by intravenously injecting a gadolinium-based contrast material. Although T2 and T1 relaxation are described separately, they occur simultaneously. That is, as the spins are dephasing in the transverse plane, spins are also going from being antialigned with the B0 field to being aligned with it. Spin flips influence T1 and T2 (as spins flip, they lose coherence in the transverse plane). T2 is additionally influenced by spin– spin interactions. Thus, for most tissues imaged using MRI, T2 < T1. This means that the net magnetization in the transverse plane disappears before the longitudinal magnetization fully regrows. It is only for liquids that T2 may approach T1.
10
F.R. Korosec
Fig. 1.9 Schematic representation of (a) relative T1 relaxation times and (b) relative T2 relaxation times, of various states of matter
Bloch Equation The behavior of the net magnetization of protons due to excitation and relaxation can be summarized by the Bloch equation: M x i + M y j ( M z - M o )k dM , = M´g Bdt T2 T1
(1.3)
where M is the net magnetization, B represents the applied magnetic fields (including B0, B1, and gradient fields) and i, j, and k are unit vectors in the x, y, and z directions, respectively. Note that the behavior depends on both T1 and T2, which results in contrast between tissues with different T1 and T2 values. Solving this governing equation for M, with time-varying magnetic field gradients, yields the signal equations for different imaging sequences. In addition to being influenced by T2, T1, and proton density, the signal in MRI is influenced by diffusion, perfusion, magnetic susceptibility, chemical shift, temperature, magnetic field strength, motion (including that from flowing blood), presence of a contrast material, and many other factors. MRA techniques achieve contrast by harnessing the effects of motion (phase-contrast and TOF MRA), or the effects of injecting a gadolinium-based T1-shortening contrast material (contrast-enhanced MRA), or the inherently long T2 of blood (steady-state free precession MRA). The physical principles of the more common MRA techniques are introduced below.
Imaging Parameters and Their Effects on Image Contrast Signal intensity in MR depends on a number of factors, and there are a host of parameters in MR imaging sequences that can be modified to accentuate the influence of these factors. The signal intensity is proportional to the magnitude of the transverse magnetization at the time that the receiver is turned on. The rate at which transverse magnetization diminishes is characterized by the time constant T2. Different tissues have different T2 values. Tissues with short T2 values lose transverse magnetization quickly, whereas tissues with long T2 values lose it more slowly. Thus, allowing time to
elapse between tipping the magnetization transverse and sampling it allows achievement of signal differences from tissues with different T2 values. The time from when the magnetization is tipped transverse until the signal is detected is controlled by the MR imaging parameter TE (echo time). Because imaging sequences with longer echo times achieve signal differences based on variations in T2 decay times, they are referred to as T2-weighted imaging sequences, and the images produced with these sequences are referred to as T2-weighed images. The magnitude of the transverse magnetization is influenced by the magnitude of the longitudinal magnetization, since a component of longitudinal magnetization becomes transverse after the application of the RF pulse. After the longitudinal magnetization is tipped transverse, the longitudinal component begins to regrow. The rate of regrowth is characterized by the time constant called T1. Different tissues have different T1 regrowth times. In MR imaging, the longitudinal magnetization must be tipped many times in order to encode enough information to map the signals to the proper locations in the image (as described below). If only a short time elapses between applying the RF excitation pulses, the longitudinal magnetization will not fully regrow. The longitudinal magnetization from short T1 tissues will regrow more than the longitudinal magnetization from long T1 tissues. Thus, allowing only a short amount of time to elapse between applying RF excitation pulses will lead to different amounts of longitudinal magnetization being tipped transverse, which will result in different signal intensities from different tissues based on variations in T1 regrowth times. The time between applying RF excitation pulses is controlled by the MR imaging parameter TR (repetition time). Because imaging sequences with shorter repetition times achieve signal differences based on variations in T1 regrowth times, they are referred to as T1-weighed imaging sequences, and the images produced with these sequences are referred to as T1-weighed images. In order to minimize T2-weighting in these scans, the shortest possible echo time is used. In order to minimize T1-weighting in T2-weighted scans, a longer TR is used. When a long TR and a short TE are used, the signal intensities in the images are not dependent on T1 or T2 differences. In this case, the signal intensities depend on the density of hydrogen nuclei (on the water molecule) in each tissue. Since the hydrogen nucleus consists of a single proton, these imaging sequences are referred to as proton-density-weighted (also r-weighted) imaging sequences, and the images produced with these sequences are referred to as proton-densityweighted images. When is it desirable to achieve signal intensities in images that are strictly dependent on T1 values, T2 values, or proton densities of various tissues, a class of imaging sequences called spin-echo sequences is used. Typical TR and TE values used to achieve T1-, T2-, and
1
Basic Principles of MRI and MR Angiography
11
Table 1.3 TR and TE imaging parameters used to achieve different weighting in magnetic resonance images of the brain using a spin-echo imaging sequence at 1.5 T T1-weighting T2-weighting r-weighting
TR Short (400 ms) Long (3,000 ms) Short (3,000 ms)
TE Short (20 ms) Long (100 ms) Long (20 ms)
density-weighed images of the brain using a spin-echo imaging sequence are shown in Table 1.3. Spin-echo imaging sequences typically have scan times and properties that make them inappropriate for many MRA applications. Most MRA methods employ sequences called gradient-echo imaging sequences. In gradient-echo sequences, short TR and short TE values are used. This results in the signal for each tissue being dependent on combined effects of the T1, T2, and proton density of the tissue. There are several gradient-echo sequences used for MRA. Each yields signals that have different dependencies on the physical properties of the blood and tissues being imaged. For these sequences, additional imaging features may be employed to enhance signal differences between blood and stationary tissues. Also, imaging parameters, including tip angle, may be adjusted to enhance signal differences.
MR Image Formation To produce images in MRI, it is necessary to determine the origins of the signals so that they can be mapped to the appropriate positions in the image. This mapping of signal to position is accomplished by applying magnetic field gradients of predetermined amplitude and duration. To say that a magnetic field has a gradient means that it has a different strength at different locations in space. In MR imaging, the gradients are applied so that the magnetic field strength changes linearly with position. Magnetic field gradients can be applied along each of the three axes in the MR scanner. A magnetic field gradient has units of G/cm (or mT/m), and is represented as Gx, Gy, or Gz, depending on the axis along which it is applied. The gradient magnetic field adds to, or subtracts from, the main magnetic field B0. Thus, if a magnetic field gradient is applied along the x-axis, the total magnetic field at any position along the x-axis is given by B0 + Gx x, where x is the position along the x-axis. The value of x is 0 at the center of the magnet (isocenter of the gradient), and has greater positive values with increasing distance from the center in one direction, and greater negative values with increasing distance from the center in the other direction. If a 1 gauss/cm magnetic field gradient is applied in a 1.5 T scanner, the total magnetic field 10 cm from the isocenter of the gradient in one direction is 15,010 G
Fig. 1.10 The net magnetic field produced by applying a linear magnetic field gradient in the x direction. The lengths of the vectors represent the strength of the magnetic field. The gradient strength is denoted as Gx, and it is superimposed on the main magnetic field, B0. Note that when a gradient is applied along the x direction, the field varies linearly in the x direction, but is constant along the y and z directions
(15,000 G + 1 G/cm × 10 cm) and the total magnetic field 10 cm from the isocenter of the gradient in the other direction is 14,990 G (15,000 G – 1 G/cm × 10 cm), where the minus sign in the latter case is due to the negative direction with respect to the isocenter of the gradient. The vector representation of the magnetic field strength as a function of position resulting from the application of a linear magnetic field gradient is shown in Fig. 1.10. As was described previously, in the rotating frame of reference, the main magnetic field, B0, can be ignored. So, with this formalism, the total magnetic field that must be considered in the rotating frame becomes Gx × x for a magnetic field gradient applied along the x-axis, Gy × y for a magnetic field gradient applied along the y-axis, and Gz × z for a magnetic field gradient applied along the z-axis. For the remainder of this chapter, all discussions will pertain to the rotating frame of reference. Vector diagrams representing application of magnetic field gradients along the x-, y-, and z-axes in the rotating frame of reference are shown in Fig. 1.11. The strength of the magnetic field gradient can be plotted as a function of time. Such a plot is referred to as a pulse sequence timing diagram. Figure 1.12 demonstrates the characteristics of a pulse sequence timing diagram. In pulse sequence timing diagrams, the horizontal dimension represents time, and the vertical dimension represents the strength of the gradient at each point in time. The timing diagram shown in the top row of Fig. 1.12 represents a gradient that is applied along the x-axis (Gx) at a strength of 0.75 G/cm, for 4.0 ms. The gradient is turned on 1.0 ms after the clock starts, and it is turned off 5.0 ms after the clock starts. If the gradient were applied at a strength of 0.5 G/cm, and the timing parameters remained the same, the pulse sequence
12
Fig. 1.11 Vector representations of magnetic field gradients applied along the x-, y-, and z-axes. These representations ignore the contribution from B0. The length of the vector at each position represents the strength of the magnetic field at that position (less the contribution from B0). Note that all of the vectors point in the direction of the main magnetic field, meaning that they all add to, or subtract from, the main field, B0. In MRI, no magnetic fields are applied perpendicular to the main magnetic field (except the B1 pulses). In these diagrams, some of the vectors have
Fig. 1.12 (Top left) A timing diagram showing the strength of a magnetic field gradient (vertical axis) as a function of time (horizontal axis). Shown on the top right is a vector representation of the magnetic field gradient. The length of the vectors at each position (along the x dimension in this case) represents the strength of the magnetic field at that position. The bottom row shows a timing diagram and vector representation for a magnetic field gradient having a lower strength than the one shown in the top row
timing diagram would look like the one shown in the bottom row of Fig. 1.12. Typically, pulse sequence timing diagrams are used to give a rough indication of gradient strength and timing, and
F.R. Korosec
been intentionally omitted to reduce clutter. To complete Gx, the vectors at each x position should be reproduced along the y dimension (as shown in Fig. 1.10) and then each of those should also be reproduced along the z dimension. To complete Gy, the vectors at each y position should be reproduced along the x dimension, and then each of these should be reproduced along the z dimension. For Gz, the vectors at each z position are reproduced along the x dimension, but to complete the diagram, each of these vectors should be reproduced along the y dimension
so they do not include markings indicating actual times or gradient strengths. The remaining pulse sequence timing diagrams shown in this chapter will not include such markings. Also, the timing diagrams shown in Fig. 1.12 are drawn as if the gradients can be turned on and off instantaneously, which is not realistic. In reality, it takes time to ramp up the gradients to full strength, and an equivalent amount of time to ramp them down to zero strength. Magnetic field gradients are characterized by their maximum strength, and the time it takes to ramp them up to maximum strength. On state-of-the-art MRI scanners with high-performance gradients, the maximum gradient strength is about 5 G/cm (50 mT/m), and the amount of time it takes to ramp up the gradients on these systems is about 0.25 ms. Often times the gradient strength is divided by the ramp time to characterize the performance of the gradients in a single number, referred to as the gradient slew rate. For the numbers above, the gradient slew rate would be 200 mT/m/ ms. Stronger and faster gradients facilitate shorter TR and TE times, which is beneficial for MRA methods (as described later in this chapter). For the remaining pulse sequence timing diagrams shown in this chapter, the gradient ramp times will be represented by a sloped line before and after each gradient application. The remainder of this section describes how magnetic field gradients are used to select the magnetization that is going to be tipped into the transverse plane and then encode the signal from this magnetization so that it can be mapped to the proper position in the image.
1
Basic Principles of MRI and MR Angiography
13
Slice-Selection
Fig. 1.14 A spatially selective B1 pulse (right side of figure) is constructed by combining B1 fields that have different frequencies (left side of figure). The range of frequencies used to construct the B1 pulse is referred to as the bandwidth of the B1 pulse. The bandwidth of this pulse is −w3 to +w3, or ±w3. The spatially selective pulse shown here can be used in conjunction with a magnetic field gradient to generate transverse magnetization from spins having Larmor frequencies in the range −w3 to +w3
In order to form an image of a single slice, signal must be generated from only spins that are within that slice. This is accomplished by tipping only the magnetization within the slice of interest into the transverse plane so that it may be detected by the receiver coil. This can be achieved by applying a magnetic field gradient, and at the same time applying a specially tailored RF pulse. With the application of a magnetic field gradient along the z-axis, the Larmor equation (in the rotating frame) becomes w = g Gzz, where g is the gyromagntic ratio for protons, Gz is the strength of the magnetic field gradient, and z is the position along the z-axis. This means that, when the magnetic field gradient is being applied, spins at different positions along the z-axis have different Larmor frequencies. This is demonstrated in Fig. 1.13. By viewing Fig. 1.13, and by recalling that spins are only affected by an RF pulse that is transmitted at a frequency equal to the Larmor frequency of the spins, it can be realized that spins in a particular slice can be selectively tipped into the transverse plane by applying a magnetic field gradient, and at the same time applying an RF pulse that is made up of B1 fields that precess at the same frequencies as the spins that are within the slice that is to be imaged. An RF pulse made up of B1 fields having a range of frequencies will affect only spins that have a Larmor frequency that is within this range. Spins that have a Larmor frequency outside this range will be unaffected by the RF pulse. An RF pulse that is made up of B1 fields precessing within a range of frequencies is shown in Fig. 1.14. The range of
frequencies of the B1 fields making up the RF pulse is referred to as the bandwidth of the RF pulse. The RF pulse will affect only magnetization that has Larmor frequencies that are within the bandwidth of the RF pulse. Such a pulse is often referred to as a spatially selective, or slice-selective, RF pulse. The gradient that is applied to create a distribution in the Larmor frequencies of the spins so that magnetization from the spins within a specific slice can be selectively tipped is referred to as the slice-selection gradient. Changing the strength of the slice-selection gradient causes a change in the thickness of the slice that is selected (if the bandwidth of the RF pulse remains unchanged). Increasing the gradient strength causes spins in a thinner slice to be affected by the RF pulse, and decreasing the gradient strength causes spins in a thicker slice to be affected by the RF pulse. This is because increasing the gradient strength causes magnetization with Larmor frequencies that are within the bandwidth of the RF pulse to span a smaller distance, and decreasing the gradient strength causes magnetization with Larmor frequencies that are within the bandwidth of the RF pulse to span a larger distance. This phenomenon is demonstrated in Fig. 1.15. In Fig. 1.15, the bandwidth of the RF pulse includes frequencies from −625 Hz to +625 Hz (written as ±625 Hz), so it affects only spins that have Larmor frequencies within this range. If only a single slice is to be imaged, it is desirable to place that slice at the isocenter of the gradient. This is because the isocenter of the gradient is also the center of the magnet
Fig. 1.13 When a magnetic field gradient is applied along the z-axis, spins at different locations in the z dimension have different Larmor frequencies. The frequency as a function of position can be determined using the Larmor equation, w = g Gzz, where Gz denotes the strength of the magnetic field gradient, and z denotes the location along the z-axis
14
Fig. 1.15 The amplitude of the slice-selection gradient determines the thickness of the slice that is imaged. (a) A strong gradient causes the magnetic field strength to change rapidly with position, so when a strong gradient is applied, spins with Larmor frequencies in the range affected by the B1 pulse are clustered close together. (b) A weak gradient causes the magnetic field strength to change slowly with position, so when a weak gradient is applied, spins with Larmor frequencies in the range affected by the B1 pulse are spread out over a large distance
and the main magnetic field is most uniform at this point. So, if a single slice is to be imaged, the patient table is moved so that the anatomy that is to be imaged moves to the isocenter of the magnet. All of the discussion above pertained to imaging a slice at isocenter. If two slices are to be imaged, they cannot both be placed at the isocenter of the gradient so there is a mechanism to image slices off of isocenter. Imaging slices off of isocenter is accomplished by changing the frequencies of all of the B1 fields that make up the RF pulse. The bandwidth remains the same, but the frequencies of all the B1 fields that make up the RF pulse are offset to correspond to the position of the slice. A pulse sequence timing diagram demonstrating a sliceselective RF pulse and a slice-selection gradient is shown in Fig. 1.16. Here it is demonstrated that the gradient and RF pulse are applied simultaneously. The duration of the RF pulse is a function of its bandwidth. The duration of the gradient is equal to the duration of the RF pulse; the gradient must be on during the entire application of the RF pulse in order to maintain the distribution of spin frequencies. No other gradients may be on during application of the sliceselection gradient. The strength of the gradient is a function of the slice thickness, as explained above, and the strength of the RF pulse is a function of the tip angle. The greater the amplitude of the RF pulse, the farther the spins tip in the time that the RF pulse is applied. The negative lobe of the slice-selection gradient is used to refocus the spins. The spins along the slice-selection direction get out of phase with each other because the application of the slice-selection gradient causes the spins along this direction to precess at different frequencies while they are being tipped into the
F.R. Korosec
Fig. 1.16 A pulse sequence timing diagram showing a slice-selective RF (or B1) pulse, a slice-selection gradient, a phase-encoding gradient, a frequency-encoding (or readout) gradient, and the signal detected during activation of the receiver
transverse plane. Reversing the gradient for the appropriate amount of time causes the spins to come back into phase with each other.
Frequency-Encoding Now that a slice has been selected by tipping only the spins within that slice into the transverse plane, the signals from these spins must be encoded so that when they are detected, it can be determined from where they came, so that they can be mapped to the appropriate positions in the image. Differentiating the signal along one dimension of an object can be accomplished by applying a magnetic field gradient along that direction. Just as a slice-selection gradient applied along the z dimension causes spins at different locations along the z dimension to have different Larmor frequencies, a spatial-encoding gradient applied along the x dimension causes spins at different locations along the x dimension to have different Larmor frequencies. Thus, when the signals from the spins in the image slice are detected during the application of a magnetic field gradient, the frequencies of the signals can be used to map them to the proper location along this one dimension in the image. Because this gradient encodes position by giving spins at different positions different frequencies, it is referred to as the frequency-encoding gradient. It also often is referred to as the readout gradient because it is applied at the same time that the receiver coil is “reading out” the signal. An example of the effect that a frequency-encoding gradient has on the spins in an image slice is shown in Fig. 1.17. To understand more clearly how the frequency-encoding gradient allows the position of the spins to be determined,
1
Basic Principles of MRI and MR Angiography
consider the case of an object placed in the MR scanner as shown in Fig. 1.18. While the frequency-encoding gradient is being applied, the spins in the object precess at frequencies
15
Fig. 1.17 Application of a frequency-encoding gradient along the x dimension causes spins at different locations in the x dimension to have different Larmor frequencies. The signals can be mapped to the proper position in the image based on their precessional frequencies
that are dictated by where the spins are located along the magnetic field gradient. If the receiver coil is turned on while the frequency-encoding gradient is being applied, the detected signal will be a composite of all of the signals at all of the precessional frequencies of the spins in the object. When the signal is sufficiently sampled, the frequencyencoding gradient and the receiver coil are turned off and the signal is amplified, digitized, and sent to the signal processor. The signal processor performs a fast Fourier transform (FFT) on the sampled signal to determine the frequencies of all the signals composing the detected composite signal, and the relative number of spins precessing at each of the frequencies (signal intensity at each frequency). The output of the fast Fourier transform can be mapped to the columns of pixels (picture elements) in an image as shown in Fig. 1.18. So, the frequency-encoding gradient allows the relative amount of signal in each column of the image to be determined. To form an image, the spatial distribution of the signals in each column needs to be determined. This is the topic of the next section. Before this is addressed, a few aspects of frequency-encoding are discussed. The strength of the frequency-encoding gradient is chosen such that spins at one edge of the field-of-view (FOV) precess at a predetermined maximum frequency (added to the 63.87 MHz resulting from B0), and spins at the opposite edge of the FOV precess at the same predetermined maximum frequency but in the opposite direction (subtracted
Fig. 1.18 (Upper left) The sample, denoted by black squares in this example, extends over three of the six columns of the image. (Lower left) The detected signal contains contributions from all of the spins in the object, all precessing at frequencies determined by their location along the applied gradient. In this example, because the object extends over three of the six columns, the detected signal is composed of
signals having three different precessional frequencies, −w1, w1, and w2. (Lower right) Applying a fast Fourier transform to the detected signal reveals the frequencies that are contained in the signal, and the relative number of spins at each frequency. (Upper right) This information is used to map the signals from the spins to the appropriate column in the image
16
from the 63.87 MHz resulting from B0). The receiver is set by the operator to accept only frequencies within this predetermined range. This range of frequencies is referred to as the receiver bandwidth. A typical receiver bandwidth is ±16 kHz, which means that spins at one edge of the FOV precess at +16 kHz (faster than 63.87 MHz), and spins at the opposite edge of the FOV precess at −16 kHz (slower than 63.87 MHz). By keeping the receiver bandwidth the same and changing the strength of the gradient, the FOV in the frequencyencoding direction can be changed. Increasing the gradient strength decreases the FOV by causing spins that have precessional frequencies within the receiver bandwidth to be contained in a smaller region, and decreasing the gradient strength increases the FOV by causing spins that have precessional frequencies within the receiver bandwidth to extend over a larger region. The field of view is not restricted to the center of the magnet. Off-center FOVs are achieved by changing the frequencies that are accepted by the receiver. The receiver bandwidth is kept the same, but each of the frequencies that is accepted is changed by some amount depending on how far off of isocenter the FOV is shifted. A pulse sequence timing diagram, showing the timing of the frequency-encoding gradient and receiver activation relative to the timing of the slice-selection process is shown in Fig. 1.16. No other gradients may be applied during application of the frequencyencoding gradient.
Phase-Encoding The slice-selection gradient applied simultaneously with a tailored RF pulse allows the spins in a particular slice to be tipped into the transverse plane to generate signals, and the application of the frequency-encoding gradient permits determination of where the signals originate from along one dimension. To form an image, all that remains to be determined is from where along the second dimension in the image plane the signals originate. Encoding along the second image dimension is achieved by applying another gradient, this time along the y-axis. This gradient, because it gives signals at different positions and different phases, is referred to as the phase-encoding gradient. The phase of the magnetization is simply a measure of how far it precesses in the transverse plane during a given period of time. Phase is an angle and it is typically measured in degrees. If the magnetization in the transverse plane precesses one full revolution, it is said to have accumulated a phase of 360°. The phase-encoding gradient is applied after the magnetization is tipped into the transverse plane, and before it is read out; that is, it is applied after the slice-selection gradient is
F.R. Korosec
Fig. 1.19 (a) After the slice-selection process, the spins in the selected slice lie in the transverse plane, and are all oriented in the same direction (in this case, they all lie along the x-axis). (b) When a gradient, Gy, is applied along the y dimension, it causes spins at different locations along this dimension to precess at different frequencies. By the time the gradient is turned off, spins at different locations along the y dimension have accumulated different amounts of phase. This phase-encoding process is used to encode signals along this dimension with a unique phase so that when they are detected, they can be mapped to the proper position in the phase-encoding dimension in the image
applied and before the frequency-encoding gradient is applied. While the phase-encoding gradient is being applied, the spins at different locations along the y-axis precess at different rates. Thus, by the time the phase-encoding gradient is turned off, the spins at different locations along the y-axis will have precessed different amounts and thus will have accumulated different amounts of phase. This is shown schematically in Fig. 1.19. After the phase-encoding gradient has been turned off, the frequency-encoding gradient is turned on, and the signal from the selected slice is detected. In order to resolve all points along the y dimension, additional information is needed. The way this information is obtained is by applying additional phase-encoding gradients. After the application of each phase-encoding gradient, a frequency-encoding gradient is applied, and the signal is sampled again with the new phase-encoding value. The application of each phase-encoding gradient requires a separate TR. In each TR, a phase-encoding gradient of slightly greater amplitude is applied. This causes the spins to accumulate a slightly larger phase in each TR. The amplitude of the phaseencoding gradient is increased with each TR because, for any single application of the phase-encoding gradient, components of the magnetization from spins at different locations point in opposite directions causing the signals from some spins to partially cancel the signals from other spins. In order to appropriately determine the signal in each pixel along the phase-encoding dimension, the total number of phaseencoding gradients that must be applied is equal to the total number of rows of pixels that are to be resolved in the phaseencoding dimension (it is also true that the frequencyencoded signal needs to be sampled one time for each column
1
Basic Principles of MRI and MR Angiography
17
of pixels that is to be resolved in the frequency-encoding direction). An important difference between phase- and frequency-encoding is that increasing the number of rows of pixels in the phase-encoding direction results in an increase in scan time, whereas increasing the number of columns of pixels in the frequency-encoding direction does not affect the scan time (except in fast gradient-echo acquisitions, where increasing the number of frequency-encoding values necessitates an increase in the TR of the imaging sequence). It should be noted that for consistency of terminology in this chapter, frequency-encoding is being associated with rows of pixels in the image and phase-encoding is being associated with columns of pixels in the image, but the phaseand frequency-encoding dimensions can easily be swapped in practice. If it is desirable to have greater resolution along a particular dimension, the scanner operator would align the frequency-encoding along this dimension since aligning the phase-encoding along this dimension would necessitate a longer scan time. Just as the FOV in the frequency-encoding dimension can be adjusted by modifying the strength of the frequencyencoding gradient, the field of view in the phase-encoding dimension can be adjusted by modifying the strength of the phase-encoding gradients. Also, the center of the field of view can be offset in the phase-encoding dimension, just as it can be offset in the frequency-encoding dimension. Figure 1.16 shows the timing of the phase-encoding gradient with respect to the slice-selection gradient, the frequency-encoding gradient, the RF pulse, and the activation of the receiver. The phase-encoding gradient is shown with many amplitudes, representing the need to apply one phaseencoding amplitude for each row of pixels that is to be resolved in the phase-encoding dimension. It should be remembered that each phase-encoding value is applied in a separate TR. All other waveforms remain the same for all TR intervals. The scan time necessary to acquire the data to produce an image of a single slice in MRI is given by the following equation: Scan Time = TR ´ N y ´ Ave,
(1.4)
where TR is the repetition time of the imaging sequence, Ny is the number of phase-encoding values applied (one per TR), and Ave is the number of times each phase-encoding value is sampled for purposes of averaging the data. For certain imaging sequences used in MRI, the TR is chosen to achieve the desired image contrast (e.g., T1-weighting, T2-weighting, density-weighting). If the TR is much longer than the time necessary to acquire a single phase-encoded line of data from a given slice, then the data acquisition can be interleaved so that data from multiple slices may be obtained in a TR interval (i.e., excite slice 1, sample phase-encoding 1; excite
slice 2, sample phase-encoding 1; excite slice 3, sample phase-encoding 1; – continue until the TR interval has elapsed, then – excite slice 1, sample phase-encoding 2; excite slice 2, sample phase-encoding 2; excite slice 3, sample phaseencoding 2; – and repeat until all phase-encoding values have been sampled.) For this interleaved mode of acquisition, the scan time for imaging multiple slices is the same as that required for imaging a single slice, as long as the data for a given phase-encoding value for all slices can be acquired before the TR time elapses. If data are acquired from individual slices sequentially, such that all data for a given slice are acquired prior to collecting data for the next slice, then the scan time is increased by a factor equal to the number of slices imaged. This is true for the types of sequences most commonly used for MR angiography (i.e. fast gradient-echo sequences). The above methods, where individual slices are excited one at a time (in an interleaved fashion, or individually), and magnetization from only one slice is in the transverse plane at any given time, are referred to as 2D multislice imaging methods. If data are collected from contiguous slices, data are collected from a 3D volume, but the acquisition methods are still referred to as two-dimensional, multislice imaging methods. MR imaging may be performed using three-dimensional acquisition methods. With 3D acquisition methods, a component of the magnetization from a volume, or slab, containing all the slices to be imaged is tipped into the transverse plane in every TR, and the information is mapped to individual slices using a phase-encoding method. For 3D acquisitions, the pulse sequence timing diagram shown in Fig. 1.16 would be modified to include a phase-encoding gradient on the z-axis (sometimes referred to as slice-encoding, or slabencoding gradient). The phase-encoding gradient on the z-axis can be applied anytime after the application of the slice-selection gradient and before the application of the frequency-encoding gradient. With 3D acquisitions, data for every slice are sampled in every TR throughout the acquisition, so interleaved acquisition is not possible. For 3D acquisition methods, the scan time equation above must be multiplied by the number of slices imaged.
MR Data (k-Space) A representation of the matrix of data points acquired in an MRI scan is shown in Fig. 1.20. In MRI, analog data are sampled and converted to digital numbers. Each number (sampled point) is represented as a dot in this figure. Each dot along a row represents a different frequency-encoded sample (the number of columns of dots is equal to the number of columns of pixels that may be represented in the frequency-encoding dimension of the image). Each dot along a
18
column represents a different phase-encoded sample (the number of rows of dots is equal to the number of rows of pixels that may be represented in the phase-encoding dimension of the image). More frequency-encoding values (or more phase-encoding values) corresponds to more rows (or columns) of pixels across a FOV, leading to improved spatial resolution in an image. Actual data acquired during an MRI scan are shown in Fig. 1.21. In this figure, the dots have been replaced with a representation of the actual digital samples (the numeric values). Large numbers are represented with high-intensity signals, and small numbers are represented with low-intensity signals. In MRI, these numbers that are sampled correspond to Fourier weighting coefficients. A full discussion on Fourier
Fig. 1.20 In MRI, data are acquired at discrete points in what is referred to as k-space. The dots in this figure represent the locations of the acquired data points. The resolution in MR images is determined by how far from the origin data are sampled ( ± k x ,max, ± k y ,max ). The size of the unaliased field-of-view (FOV) in MR images is determined by the spacing between sampled points ( Dk x , Dk y )
Fig. 1.21 (a) MRI data. The signal intensity represents the magnitude of the Fourier weighting coefficients. The characteristics of the frequencyencoding gradient (in combination with the receiver bandwidth) determine which points are sampled along each row, and the characteristics of the phase-encoding gradient determine which points are sampled along each column. (b) An axial image of a human brain obtained after applying a two-dimensional fast Fourier transform (2D FFT) to the acquired data
F.R. Korosec
theory is beyond the scope of this chapter. However, a few concepts are introduced. According to Fourier theory, images can be formed by appropriately weighting and combing line-pair patterns (more specifically, cosine and sine function patterns). Fourier coefficients are the weighting values that must be applied to the line-pair patterns to produce the desired image. For twodimensional images, the Fourier coefficients can be arranged in a 2D matrix, and this matrix of coefficients may be displayed in what is referred to as k-space. The location of each point in k-space is associated with a line-pair pattern in image space. Locations along the kx-axis correspond to vertical line-pair patterns, locations along the ky-axis correspond to horizontal line-pair patterns, and locations along the diagonal axes correspond to diagonal line-pair patters. Locations near the center of k-space correspond to few line-pairs per image, whereas locations farther from the center of k-space correspond to more line-pairs per image. To fully represent an object in an image, an infinite number of line-pair patterns (and associated weighting coefficients) would be required. In MRI, only a subset of the Fourier coefficients are sampled, due to scan time considerations. The limited number of Fourier coefficients is confined between –kx,max and + kx,max in the frequency-encoding dimension, and –ky,max and +ky,max in the phase-encoding dimension. These Fourier coefficients, therefore, define the maximum spatial resolution in the image (highest density line-pair patterns in the x and y dimensions). The Fourier coefficients beyond these values are not sampled. The spacing between sampled Fourier coefficients defines the size of the FOV in MRI. The larger the spacing between the sampled k-space points, the smaller the FOV. This is demonstrated in Fig. 1.22. Another thing to note about k-space is that, in MRI, the imaging gradients are used to determine which k-space
1
Basic Principles of MRI and MR Angiography
19
Fig. 1.22 As the distance between k-space samples increases (in this case by acquiring fewer phase-encoded lines of data), the size of the field-of-view (FOV) decreases. When there is anatomy outside of the FOV, it “wraps around” and overlaps onto the anatomy within the FOV. This mismapping of the signal that originates from outside the FOV is referred to as spatial aliasing
points are sampled. The area (amplitude × duration) of the frequency-encoding gradient determines which point along the kx direction is sampled during data acquisition, and the area of the phase-encoding gradient determines which point along the ky direction is sampled. Negative gradient areas move through k-space along the negative kx and ky axes, and positive gradient areas move through k-space along the positive kx and ky axes. Once the FOV in the phase-encoding dimension is selected, Dky is determined, and the changes in the area of the phase-encoding gradient from one TR to the next can be calculated. Likewise, once the FOV in the frequency-encoding dimension is selected, Dk x is determined, and the changes in the area of the frequency-encoding gradient from one sample to the next can be calculated (in conjunction with the sampling interval of the receiver, which is dictated by the receiver bandwidth). Once the number of phase-encoding values ( N y ) and frequency-encoding values ( N x ) is determined, the number of k-space points can be determined, the kmax points can be determined Ny ö Nx æ çè ± k x ,max = ± 2 ´ D k x and ± ky ,max = ± 2 ´ Dky ÷ , and the ø duration of the frequency-encoding gradient, and maximum area of the phase-encoding gradient can be determined. By strategically applying combinations of magnetic field gradients, k-space may be sampled using a variety of trajectories. Instead of traversing k-space on a rectilinear grid [6] (typically referred to as Cartesian sampling), k-space can be sampled along 2D radial lines [7], where each radial line passes through the center of the k-space, and the radial lines are arranged with equal angles between them (like spokes on a wheel). Alternatively, k-space may be sampled along spiral trajectories [8], starting from the center and spiraling
outward. Other sampling trajectories exist as well, such as 3D radial [9], stack of spirals [10], 3D cones [11], as well as numerous others. The density of phase-encoding lines and readout samples required are determined by the Nyquist sampling criterion and can be described by the following equations, Dt £
2π , g Gx FOVx
(1.5)
2π , g TPE FOVy
(1.6)
DGy £
where Dt is the readout sampling interval (determined by the receiver bandwidth), Gx is the frequency-encoding gradient amplitude, FOVx and FOVy are field of view sizes in the x and y dimensions, DGy is the phase-encoding gradient amplitude step size, TPE is the duration of each phase-encoding gradient, and it is assumed that the imaging gradients can be turned on and off instantaneously (i.e., ramp time equals zero). If the requirements defined by these equations are not met, the reconstructed images will have aliasing artifacts, where copies of images will be superimposed as shown in Fig. 1.22. Finally, it has been described that points near the center of k-space represent low spatial frequency information (few line-pairs per image), and points at the periphery of k-space represent high spatial frequency information (many linepairs per image). This characteristic is often generalized by saying that the center of k-space contains the contrast information for the image, and the periphery of k-space contains the detail information for the image (information regarding
20
F.R. Korosec
Fig. 1.23 The images in the bottom row were produced by performing a fast Fourier transform (FFT) on the k-space data shown in the top row. Each image is shown directly below the k-space data used to produce it. These images demonstrate that the data at the center of k-space is responsible for representing the contrast in the image, whereas the data at the periphery of k-space is responsible for representing the detail in the image
the edges of objects). This concept is demonstrated in Fig. 1.23, which shows the image content derived from the center of k-space in one image, and the content derived from the periphery of k-space in a separate image.
Signal-to-Noise Ratio One parameter commonly used to characterize image quality is the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). This is the ratio of the amplitude of the signal (desired information) to the amplitude of the noise (undesired information), and is expressed as Signal/Noise. Generally speaking, a higher SNR indicates better the image quality. In MRI, the SNR depends on a large number of factors, including the field strength of the MRI scanner, the imaging coil used, the temperature of the object being imaged, the imaging sequence selected (i.e., spin-echo, gradient-echo, fast spin-echo, etc.), the imaging parameters that are used to manipulate image contrast (i.e., TR, TE, TI, tip angle, etc.), and a host of other parameters. Once the exam is setup, and the imaging parameters are selected to produce the appropriate contrast in the image, there are still a number of parameters that may be changed for a variety of reasons (modify anatomic coverage, resolution, scan time, etc.). These parameters affect the SNR according to the following equation [12]: SNR μ voxel volume ´ acquisition time.
(1.7)
The variable acquisition time is the time that the receiver is turned on and data are being acquired, and a voxel (volume element) is the volume of the object represented by a pixel in the image. The proportionality symbol appears because the SNR is dependent on the scan setup, as well as the scan parameters responsible for image contrast as described above. The SNR is dependent on the voxel volume since larger voxel volumes result in more spins contributing to the signal from each voxel. The SNR also is dependent on the time spent acquiring data. When more data are acquired, the signal increases coherently, whereas the noise (because it is random) increases incoherently (sometimes adding constructively and sometimes destructively). The result is that the ratio of the signal and noise increase as the square root of the amount of data acquired. The voxel volume can be calculated as FOVx / N x ´ FOVy / N y ´ sl thick, where FOVx and FOVy are the fields of view in the frequency-encoding and phase-encoding directions, respectively, N x and N y are the number of frequencyencoding and phase-encoding values, respectively, and sl thick is the slice thickness. The amount of time spent acquiring data is equal to the time spent acquiring each frequency-encoding value (Dtx), multiplied by the number of frequency-encoding points sampled Nx (Dtx × Nx = duration of readout), multiplied by the number of phase-encoding values Ny (since the each frequency-encoding value is sampled at each phase-encoding value), multiplied by the number of times every data point is resampled for purposes of averaging,
1
Basic Principles of MRI and MR Angiography
21
Ave. The time spent acquiring each frequency-encoding point is equal to the inverse of the sampling rate (sampling rate = receiver bandwidth = RBW, so Dtx = 1/RBW). So, the total time spent acquiring data is equal to ((Nx × Ny × Ave)/ RBW). The equation for SNR becomes: SNR 2D μ
N x ´ N y ´ Ave (1.8) FOVx FOVy ´ ´ sl thick ´ , Nx Ny RBW
where, FOVx and FOVy are the fields of view in the frequency-encoding and phase-encoding directions, respectively, N x and N y are the number of frequency-encoding and phase-encoding values, respectively, slthick is the slice thickness, Ave is the number of signal averages, and RBW is the receiver bandwidth. For 3D acquisitions, data for every slice are sampled in every TR throughout the acquisition. This increases the SNR of every slice by the square root of the number of slices imaged. So, for 3D acquisitions, the SNR equation is as follows:
allow for high scan time reduction factors. Parallel imaging can be used to obtain higher spatial resolution or coverage in the same scan time, or to obtain the same resolution and coverage in less scan time, or various combinations of the above. Reducing the scan time is particularly useful when scans must be completed during a breath-hold interval or when temporal resolution is desired.
Magnetic Resonance Angiography The most widely used MRA techniques can be categorized as contrast-enhanced, TOF, phase-contrast, or steady-state MRA techniques. In the remainder of this chapter, a brief overview of the physical principles of these techniques is provided, examples of clinical applications are shown, and the benefits and limitations of each of the specific methods are briefly discussed.
Contrast-Enhanced MRA SNR 3D = SNR 2D ´ N z ,
(1.9)
where N z is the number of phase-encoding values in the slab thickness direction (the number of slices encoded).
Parallel Imaging When multielement receiver coils are used, scan times may be reduced using a class of methods referred to as parallel imaging methods. SMASH [13] (simultaneous acquisition of spatial harmonics), SENSE [14, 15] (sensitivity encoding), and GRAPPA [16] (generalized autocalibrating partially parallel acquisitions) are examples of parallel imaging methods. These methods rely on the sensitivity of the different coil elements to determine information about the spatial location of the detected signals, thereby reducing the number of phaseencoding values necessary for image formation. With these methods, the scan time reduction factor, R, is dependent on the number of elements contained in a coil. Coils with more elements permit greater R values. If coil elements are distributed in more than one dimension, then the amount of data in both phase-encoding dimensions in 3D acquisitions can be reduced. Reducing the amount of data acquired results in a reduced SNR [see (1.8)]. Parallel imaging methods suffer from an additional reduction in SNR-based on coil geometry. This additional reduction in SNR is characterized by what is called a g-factor. With current coil configurations and SNR limitations, the scan time reduction factors afforded by parallel imaging methods are on the order of 4–6. Parallel imaging methods are particularly effective when used with 3D CE-MRA where the SNR is sufficiently high to
Contrast-enhanced MRA (CE-MRA) methods have gained widespread acceptance due to their ease of use, and their ability to quickly, reliably, and robustly produce high-quality diagnostic images of large vascular territories. In many clinical practices, CE-MRA has replaced X-ray DSA as the method of choice for imaging certain vasculature, including the carotid and vertebral arteries, the aorta and renal arteries, and the vessels of the lower extremities. Contrast-enhanced MRA techniques [17] achieve signal differences between blood and stationary tissues by manipulating the magnitude of the magnetization, such that the magnitude of the magnetization from moving blood is larger than the magnitude of the magnetization from stationary tissues. Manipulating the magnetization to produce signal differences in CE-MRA techniques is achieved not only by employing the appropriate imaging sequence parameters, but also by injecting a contrast material intravenously to selectively shorten the T1 of the blood. By implementing a T1weighted imaging method, appropriately synchronized to acquire data during the first pass of the contrast material through the arteries of interest, images can be acquired that show arteries with striking contrast relative to surrounding stationary tissues and veins. A 3D CE-MRA image of the arteries in the lower extremities is shown in Fig. 1.24.
Contrast Material Currently, the contrast materials most widely used for CE-MRA are gadolinium-based. The gadolinium atom is highly paramagnetic. It has seven unpaired electrons in its
22
F.R. Korosec
Fig. 1.24 A coronal MIP image of the vessels of the thighs of a healthy volunteer acquired using a coronal 3D contrast-enhanced MRA acquisition method applied after intravenous injection of a gadolinium-based contrast material
outer shell that interact with the hydrogen nuclei on the water molecules. This interaction results in an increased regrowth rate of longitudinal magnetization from these hydrogen nuclei (reduced T1), so they appear bright in images acquired with T1-weighted MR acquisition methods. The T1-shortening induced by the gadolinium-based contrast material is described by the following equation: 1 1 = + R1 ´ [Gd], T1 T10
(1.10)
where T1 is the shortened longitudinal relaxation time of blood in the presence of gadolinium, T10 is the longitudinal relaxation time of blood in the absence of gadolinium, R1 is the relaxivity of the gadolinium-based contrast material, and [Gd] is the concentration of the gadolinium-based contrast material. Since gadolinium atoms are highly toxic, they must be chelated before they can be injected into the blood vessels. Currently there are several different chelates widely used in CE-MRA, which include gadobenate dimeglumine (Multihance), gadopentetate dimeglumine (Magnevist), gadodiamide (Omniscan), gadoversetamide (OptiMARK), and gadoteridol (ProHance). These materials are permeable through the blood vessel walls, resulting in enhancement of signals from tissues over time, as the contrast material makes its way through the arteries, into the veins, and eventually into the stationary tissues. These chelates are referred to as extracellular contrast materials. Contrast materials that are not permeable through vessel walls, and remain in the blood pool for more than an hour without leaking into the surrounding stationary tissues, have been developed (e.g., gadofosveset trisodium: Ablavar) [18, 19]. These so-called intravascular, or blood pool, contrast materials
can be used to increase the imaging time in order to achieve greater coverage and higher spatial resolution. The drawback of increased acquisition time is that it results in venous enhancement, which leads to difficulty in evaluating the arteries. Methods are being developed to separate arterial signal from venous signal, but are not yet available clinically. An additional benefit of some of the intravascular contrast materials is that they have a higher relaxivity. In other words, they provide greater vascular signal during the first pass of the contrast material by causing a more dramatic decrease in the T1 of blood (per unit volume of contrast material) compared to the currently available extravascular contrast materials. Exposure to gadolinium-based contrast materials has been associated with the development of nephrogenic systemic fibrosis (NSF) [20] in patients with compromised renal function who also have other confounding health issues. NSF is an irreversible, often fatal, disease. Screening measures are now in place to identify patients at risk of contracting this disease. Since awareness has been heightened, and screening measures have been implemented to identify high-risk patients, the incidence of this disease has been nearly eliminated. The gadolinium-based contrast material is typically injected intravenously through an 18–22-gauge angiocatheter. The angiocather is typically inserted into a large, easily accessible vein, such as one of the veins in the antecubital fossa. However, other injections sites may be selected as well, including the forearm, wrist, or the back of the hand. Injection into the right arm provides the most direct route to the heart, increasing the likelihood of distributing a tight, highly concentrated bolus of contrast material to the vessels of interest. The size of the angiocatheter is dependent on the size of the vessel and the desired injection rate. Injection rates typically range from 0.5 to 4.0 ml/s for CE-MRA. Injection volumes range from 0.1 to 0.3 mmol of contrast material per kg of patient body weight (mmol/kg), with typical values in the range of 20–40 ml of contrast material. Higher volumes usually provide images with higher SNR in which the small vessel detail is better delineated. The intent is to reduce the T1 of blood to as low as 50 ms during the first pass of the contrast material. The injection of the contrast material is immediately followed by a flush of normal saline. The injection may be performed manually, or using an MR-compatible, computer-controlled injector as shown in Fig. 1.25. With a computer-controlled injector, the volume and injection rate are precisely programmed to ensure reproducible results. With manual injection, the clinician controls the injection and can better monitor the status of the patient.
Imaging Sequence CE-MRA typically is performed using a three-dimensional, RF-spoiled, fast gradient-echo imaging sequence [21]. The
1
Basic Principles of MRI and MR Angiography
23
Fig. 1.25 Typical patient setup for a 3D CE-MRA acquisition of the renal arteries. An MRI-compatible computer-controlled injector is used to administer the gadolinium-based contrast material into a vein in the antecubital fossa. One syringe is used to inject the contrast material, and the second syringe is used to inject a saline flush. The anterior and posterior sections of an 8-channel torso coil (square items with Velcro straps) are placed on top of and underneath, respectively, the patient to image the region of interest
pulse sequence timing diagram looks like the one shown in Fig. 1.16, with the addition of a phase-encoding gradient on the slice-selection axis. Also RF spoiling is used to eliminate, or spoil, the transverse magnetization so it does not contribute to signal in subsequent TR intervals. With RF spoiling, the RF pulse is applied such that the longitudinal magnetization is tipped into a different location in the transverse plane (relative to the y-axis) for each TR. Eliminating the coherence of the transverse magnetization so it does not persist from one TR to the next makes RF-spoiled sequences less T2*-weighted, and therefore more strictly T1-weighted (as long as TE Ⰶ T2*). Imaging occurs after the longitudinal magnetization has reached its steady-state equilibrium value (a state where the signal remains constant from one TR to the next since the amount of longitudinal magnetization tipped away from the longitudinal axis by the RF pulse equals the amount of magnetization that regrows during each TR interval). RF spoiled gradient-echo imaging sequences are given different names by different MR vendors, including SPGR (spoiled gradient recalled echo), FLASH (fast low angle shot), and T1 FFE (T1 fast field echo). The steady-state equilibrium magnetization for an RF-spoiled gradient-echo sequence (normalized for protondensity and assuming negligible T2* decay and perfect spoiling) is given by the following equation [22]: M xy (q ,TE ) =
M 0 sin (q )(1 - E1 ) - TE/T2* e , 1 - E1 cos (q )
(1.11)
Fig. 1.26 Calculated steady-state signal as a function of tip angle for tissues with various T1 values using a spoiled gradient-echo imaging sequence with a TR of 5 ms. Note that the signal initially increases with increasing tip angle, but then decreases. See text for details. Note also that the signal increases with decreasing T1 value. For a given tip angle, the relative signal difference (contrast) between tissues can be determined. For 3D CE-MRA, it is desirable to maximize the signal different between blood and stationary tissues
where E1 is defined to be exp( - TR/T1 ) , M 0 is the thermal equilibrium magnetization value, q is the tip angle of the imaging sequence, TR is the repetition time of the imaging sequence, TE is the echo time of the imaging sequence, T2* is the time constant characterizing the decay rate of the transverse magnetization of the tissue under consideration, and T1 is the time constant characterizing the regrowth rate of the longitudinal magnetization of the tissue under consideration. The signal as a function of tip angle and T1 for an RF-spoiled gradient-echo sequence with a TR of 5 ms and TE T2* is plotted in Fig. 1.26. It can be seen that the signal increases as the T1 value decreases. In CE-MRA, the injection of a gadolinium-based contrast material shortens the T1 of blood such that it gives rise to a large signal. All other tissues with longer T1 values give rise to lower signals. The graph also shows that the signal initially increases with tip angle as more magnetization is tipped into the transverse plane. However, as the tip angle is further increased, a point is reached where the tip angle is sufficiently large that it depletes the steady-state longitudinal magnetization that remains after tipping (and it is the longitudinal magnetization that contributes to the transverse magnetization in subsequent TR intervals), so the resulting signal gets smaller with increasing tip angles. The tip angle at which the largest signal is obtained is referred to at the Ernst angle. Rather than striving to achieve the largest signal from blood in CE-MRA, it is more desirable to maximize the image contrast (greatest signal difference between blood and other tissues).
24
Thus, tip angles greater than the Ernst angle are typically used when prescribing CE-MRA sequences. Prescribing an RF-spoiled gradient-echo sequence with a short TR and a large tip angle will yield signal differences based on differences in T1 relaxation times. As long as the scan is synchronized so that data are acquired when the contrast material is in the arteries of interest, the resulting T1weighted images will show the short-T1 arterial blood with a high signal, and the long-T1 veins and stationary tissues with diminished signal. In order to acquire the majority of the data for the contrast-enhanced angiogram during the first pass of the contrast material (when the concentration of the contrast material in the arteries is high, and the concentration in the veins and stationary tissues is low) it is necessary to use a short scan time. When imaging vessels in the abdomen, where it is necessary to acquire all the data during a breath-hold interval, it also is necessary to use a short scan time. To achieve short scan times in CE-MRA, a short TR is used, and a reduced data set is sampled. The TR may be reduced by using a specialized fast gradient-echo sequence, a high receiver bandwidth, the minimum echo time, a fractional-echo readout, a reduced number of frequency-encoding samples, and highperformance magnetic field gradients. A reduction in the data set may be achieved by employing a fractional FOV, a reduced number of phase-encoding values, and a reduced number of slices. Reducing the number of frequency-encoding values, phase-encoding values, or slices, for a specified volume of coverage, results in reduced spatial resolution in the MRA images. Designing CE-MRA imaging protocols requires compromises, and the best protocols are those that achieve the appropriate balance between scan time, anatomic coverage, and spatial resolution. The apparent spatial resolution may be increased by using zero filling [23, 24] to increase the number of pixels and/or slices in the reconstructed data set.
Scan Synchronization As has been described, in order to ensure the best possible image quality with CE-MRA, it is essential to properly synchronize data acquisition with the arrival and passage of the contrast material. If acquisition is completed before the arrival of the contrast material, the blood will not generate enough signal to appear in the angiogram. If the contrast material arrives during the scan – after data acquisition has begun, but before it is completed – the SNR of the arteries may be low, or artifacts may be present in the images [25]. The artifacts may manifest as a less intense area in the center of the vessels, ringing or replication of the vessel edges, or demonstration of only the edges of the vessels. The appearance of the artifacts depends on the size of the vessels
F.R. Korosec
affected, at what time during the acquisition the contrast material arrives in the vessels being imaged, the order in which the data are acquired, and the rate at which the concentration of the contrast material changes during the scan. If the data are acquired too late, the arterial signal will be diminished, and the veins and stationary tissues will be enhanced. Several methods have been developed to ensure proper timing of the acquisition relative to the passage of the contrast material. In one method, a timing scan is performed prior to acquiring the MR angiogram. For this timing scan, a small bolus of contrast material (1–2 ml) is injected, and then two-dimensional images are rapidly and repeatedly acquired [26]. From these images the arrival time of the contrast material can be determined and used to calculate when to start the acquisition of the three-dimensional angiogram after injecting the full bolus. In other methods, the signal in a volume [27] or an image [28] is monitored and acquisition of the angiogram begins when it has been determined that the contrast material has arrived in the vessels of interest. Finally, time-resolved methods have been developed that repeatedly acquire two-dimensional [29, 30] or three-dimensional [31–34] angiograms continuously during the passage of the contrast material, obviating the need to prospectively determine when the contrast has arrived. In addition to demonstrating the peak arterial frame, time-resolved methods provide information regarding the temporal characteristics of the passage of the bolus of contrast material. Images acquired using a commercially available time-resolved, CE-MRA technique known as TRICKs (Time-Resolved Imaging of Contrast Kinetics) are shown in Fig. 1.27.
Data Acquisition Order A current challenge of CE-MRA is obtaining high spatial resolution in the short amount of time available between arterial and venous enhancement. To address this issue, a method has been developed in which the data acquisition order is modified to acquire the low spatial frequency data early, during enhancement of the arteries, and the high spatial frequency data later, after enhancement of the veins and stationary tissues. This data acquisition order is referred to as elliptical centric phase-encoding order [35, 36]. It allows the acquisition time to be extended to increase the spatial resolution of the images without incurring substantial interference from enhancing veins and stationary tissues. In images, low spatial frequencies demonstrate the bulk of the contrast information, whereas high spatial frequencies demonstrate the detail information (see Fig. 1.23). Acquiring the low spatial frequency information (the contrast information) early in the scan, when only the arterial blood is enhanced, minimizes the amount of signal from veins and stationary tissues in the angiogram.
1
Basic Principles of MRI and MR Angiography
25
Fig. 1.27 Coronal MIP images of 8 of 13 time frames showing the vessels in the lower extremities of a patient acquired using the timeresolved 3D CE-MRA method called TRICKs. Note that the vessels in the
patient’s right leg fill much sooner and much more rapidly than the vessels in the patient’s left leg. The anatomical (nonvascular) MR images showed that this patient had a torn Achilles tendon in their right leg
Fig. 1.28 With 3D CE-MRA, it is common to subtract a “mask” image set, acquired prior to the injection of the contrast material, from an image set acquired during injection of the contrast material. This is an effective means of eliminating signals from stationary tissues that are common to both data sets, allowing the vessels to be much better
visualized. In this data set, the signal from the patient’s bladder is bright due to a prior injection of contrast material used to image vessels in a different anatomic location. Subtraction effectively eliminates this signal as well. Subtraction was performed on the source images. Shown here are the MIP images
If the contrast material reaches the veins and stationary tissues late in the scan, when the high spatial frequencies (the detail information) are being acquired, only the edges of these structures will appear in the images. This edge information from the veins and stationary tissues usually does not significantly interfere with observation of the arteries.
angiogram as shown in Fig. 1.28. The subtraction must be performed on the source slices prior to creation of the MIP images in order to fully retain the content of the three-dimensional data set. Mask subtraction in CE-MRA is analogous to subtraction in X-ray DSA in that the signals from stationary tissues (which remain constant between acquisitions) are eliminated by the subtraction, whereas the signals from vessels (which increased after the injection of the contrast material) persist after the subtraction. Disadvantages of subtraction are that it reduces the signal-to-noise ratio of the angiogram by a factor of 2 (because noise from two images, but signal from only one image, contribute to the angiogram), and it renders the angiograms susceptible to misregistration artifacts that result from patient motion.
Mask Subtraction The signal difference between vessels and stationary tissues can be increased in contrast-enhanced MRA methods by acquiring a precontrast mask image set and subtracting it from the postcontrast image set to produce a subtraction
26
F.R. Korosec
Multistation Exams Imaging more than one vascular territory, or station, during a single exam session presents challenges for CE-MRA. Two approaches are currently in use for performing multistation CE-MRA. In one approach, a separate injection of contrast material is administered just prior to scanning each territory [37]. There are benefits in this multi-injection approach, but the image quality can be adversely affected in two ways. First, the volume of contrast material available for each injection is only a fraction of the maximum allowed, because the volume must be split into multiple injections. The reduced volume leads to lower SNR in the angiograms. Second, residual contrast material remaining from the early injections enhances arteries in the mask acquisitions for the later injections. Because the arteries are slightly enhanced in the mask images, subtraction of the mask images leads to a signal reduction in the arteries in the subtracted angiogram. If the mask images from all stations are acquired before the first injection, they cannot be used to eliminate venous enhancement in the later images caused by residual contrast material remaining from the earlier injections. One benefit of a multi-injection method over a single-injection method (described below) is that more time can be spent imaging each station to achieve higher spatial resolution and extended coverage. This is possible because the scan times do not need to be limited in order to chase the bolus of contrast material. In a second approach utilized for multistation CE-MRA, multiple territories are imaged after administration of a single injection of contrast material [38–40]. After the administration of the contrast material is initiated in this single-injection approach, an image set is rapidly acquired from the first station, then the table is moved to bring the second station into the sensitive region of the MR scanner, and a scan is performed to image the second station. This table movement and data acquisition cycle is continued until all of the stations are imaged. With this method, it is necessary to scan quickly in order to image all the stations when the arterial signal is enhanced, and before the veins and stationary tissues enhance. Scanning quickly limits the spatial resolution and coverage that can be achieved at each station. Often the bolus of contrast material advances very quickly, and enhancement of veins and stationary tissues is inevitable in the later-acquired stations. When single-injection, multistation exams are performed, the mask images for all stations are acquired prior to administration of the contrast material, to prevent the contrast material from enhancing the vessels in any of the mask images. Finally, the rate of the injection must be reduced in
order to extend the duration of the contrast material administration to ensure that contrast material is present during imaging of all the stations.
Time-of-Flight MRA Just like CE-MRA techniques, TOF techniques [41, 42] derive contrast between flowing blood and stationary tissues by manipulating the magnitude of the magnetization, such that the magnetization is large for moving blood and small for stationary tissues. However, unlike CE-MRA techniques, TOF MRA techniques do not require the injection of a contrast material. Instead, TOF MRA techniques rely on the fact that blood is in motion, and stationary tissues are not. By appropriately adjusting the imaging parameters and scan prescription in TOF MRA techniques, a large signal may be obtained from moving blood, while a diminished signal is obtained from stationary tissues.
Imaging Sequence TOF methods can be implemented using two-dimensional or three-dimensional acquisition. For both acquisition methods, a spoiled, fast gradient-echo sequence is used. For twodimensional acquisition, thin slices are imaged, and the pulse sequence timing diagram is similar to the one shown in Fig. 1.16. For three-dimensional acquisition, thin slabs are imaged and the slabs are encoded into slices using a phase-encoding method. The pulse sequence timing diagram for three-dimensional TOF MRA is similar to the one shown in Fig. 1.16, with the addition of a phase-encoding gradient on the slice-selection axis. TOF sequences often employ additional gradients on the slice-selection and frequency-encoding axes to refocus unwanted phase accumulations accrued by spins that are in motion during the application of these imaging gradients. These additional gradients typically are referred to as flow-compensation gradients, velocity-compensation gradients, or first-momentnulling gradients [43, 44], and are discussed further in later chapters. They serve to reduce signal loss caused by intravoxel dephasing of spins traveling at different velocities. When a spoiled, fast gradient-echo sequence is used, the signal from tissues decreases with exposure to an increasing number of RF pulses. The longitudinal magnetization as a function of the number of RF pulses, n, is given by the following equation [45]:
(1 - (cosq E ) )+ M (cosq E ) M (n,q ) = M (1 - E ) n
z
1
0
1
1 - cos q E1
0
1
n
n ³ 1,
(1.12)
1
Basic Principles of MRI and MR Angiography
Fig. 1.29 Calculated signal for a spoiled gradient-echo imaging sequence with a flip angle of 30° and a TR of 5 ms shown as a function of the number of RF pulses experienced for tissues with various T1 values. Note that the signal decreases with increasing number of RF pulses experienced. Note also that the equilibrium signal is larger for tissues with shorter T1 values
where M z- (n,q ) is the longitudinal magnetization just prior to the nth RF pulse, E1def exp( -TR /T1 ) , M 0 is the thermal equilibrium magnetization, and q is the tip angle. given by (1.11). The steady-state equilibrium signal is often referred to as the saturation (or saturated) signal. The signal achieved using a spoiled gradient-echo sequence with a tip angle of 30°, a TR of 5 ms, and TE T2* is plotted in the graph shown in Fig. 1.29. The signal is shown as a function of number of RF pulses experienced, and the signals are plotted for several T1 values. The graph shows that, independent of the T1 of the tissue, the signals decrease with exposure to an increasing number of RF pulses, until a steady-state equilibrium value is reached. In TOF MRA, the goal is to subject the flowing blood to a very few RF pulses, and to subject stationary tissues to a large number of RF pulses, thereby achieving a signal difference between blood and stationary tissues. The graph also shows that tissues with short T1 values have high steady-state equilibrium signal levels. Thus, tissues with short T1 values, like fat, show up bright in TOF MRA methods. Ensuring that flowing blood experiences only a few RF pulses can be accomplished by imaging slices, or thin slabs, oriented perpendicular to the primary direction of flow. When this is done, the moving blood enters the slice fully magnetized, experiences only a few excitation pulses, and then flows out of the slice before it becomes saturated. This ensures that the signal from blood will be relatively large. This phenomenon is referred to as inflow enhancement, or flow-related enhancement. The stationary tissues, however, remain in the slice, or slab, throughout image acquisition, and so they give rise to a diminished signal because the
27
magnetization from them is saturated due to the constant exposure to the excitation pulses. Data collection typically does not begin until the signals from stationary tissues are brought to their steady-state equilibrium level. The number of excitation pulses experienced by moving blood as it traverses the imaging slice (or slab) depends on a number of factors including the thickness of the slice (or slab), the velocity of the blood, the orientation of the vessel relative to the image slice, and the TR of the imaging sequence. In general, thinner slices (or slabs), faster-flowing blood, vessels oriented perpendicular to the slice (or slab), and longer TRs lead to increased vascular signal. A longer TR, however, also leads to increased signal from stationary tissues (less saturation). Therefore, an intermediate TR typically is selected with TOF MRA methods. Increasing the tip angle leads to diminished signal from stationary tissues, but can also lead to increased saturation of blood that experiences multiple excitation pulses. As a result, an intermediate tip angle typically is selected with TOF MRA methods. These factors and others must be carefully considered when prescribing a TOF MRA sequence.
Two-Dimensional TOF MRA For two-dimensional acquisition, data are acquired from multiple slices stacked contiguously along the long axes of the vessels of interest. Because the image quality is best if the slices remain perpendicular to the direction of flow, 2D TOF MRA methods are best suited for imaging vessels that are straight, such as the carotid arteries, or the vessels in the lower extremities. The data from the slices can be retrospectively reprojected or reformatted to demonstrate long segments of the vessels. With 2D TOF MRA, the spoiled, fast gradient-echo method is prescribed so that thin slices (1–3 mm), oriented perpendicular to the long axis of the vessels of interest are imaged. Prescribing the slices in this manner increases the likelihood that the blood will experience only a very few radiofrequency excitation pulses as it flows through the image slice. When thin slices are imaged, a moderately large tip angle (60°) can be used to suppress the signal from the stationary tissues without substantially suppressing the signal from blood that quickly moves through the image plane. Even when thin slices are imaged, the moderately large tip angle can cause saturation of the signal from slowly moving blood, such as that in the carotid bulb. The degree of saturation can be reduced by decreasing the tip angle and/or increasing the TR of the imaging sequence; however, it must be realized that this also will increase the amount of signal from stationary tissues. Increasing the TR also will lead to a longer scan time. When imaging vessels that contain pulsatile blood flow, it is necessary to synchronize the acquisition of data to the cardiac cycle. Cardiac leads are placed on the patient, and the
28
F.R. Korosec
Fig. 1.30 (a) To produce these cardiac-gated 2D TOF MRA coronal images of the lower legs, (b) a stack of contiguous axial slices was imaged. The data set was acquired in 4 scans (different shaded slices in (b)); the table was moved between scans so that the imaged slices were always in the most uniform magnetic field to yield the highest image quality. The images comprise a three-dimensional data set from which maximum intensity projections (MIPs) at any obliquity can be produced retrospectively
ECG signal is fed to the MRI scanner. Data are then acquired only during systole in order to take advantage of the maximum inflow of fresh, fully magnetized blood, thereby reducing the likelihood of saturating the blood. Acquiring segments of data always at the same point in each cardiac cycle also reduces ghosting artifacts that otherwise would occur due to the changing velocity of blood throughout the cardiac cycle. Images of the arteries in the lower extremities acquired using an ECG-gated, 2D TOF MRA method is shown in Fig. 1.30. With 2D TOF MRA, a spatial saturation pulse [46–48] can be applied parallel to the image slice at the beginning of each TR to reduce or eliminate unwanted signal from blood flowing into the image slice from a particular direction. For example, when imaging the vessels in the neck, applying a saturation pulse superior to an axial image slice is an effective means of eliminating signal from blood in the jugular veins, as shown in Fig. 1.31a. The signal from the blood in the jugular veins is diminished or eliminated as the blood flows through the region affected by the saturation pulse. The venous blood, therefore, has little signal to give when it flows into the image slice. If a saturation pulse was not used, and the blood in the jugular veins was left unsaturated, these vessels would interfere with observation of the carotid arteries as shown in Fig. 1.31b. When imaging the neck, if the saturation pulse is prescribed inferior to the image slice, the signal from the carotid arteries can be eliminated to produce an image of the jugular veins as shown in Fig. 1.31c. In general, inferior saturation pulses are used to suppress the signal from arteries above the heart and veins below the heart, whereas superior saturation pulses are used to suppress the signal from veins above the heart, and arteries below the heart.
Three-Dimensional TOF MRA For three-dimensional TOF acquisition [49, 50], a slab, oriented perpendicular to the long axis of the vessels of interest, is imaged and the slab is encoded into thin slices using a phase-encoding method. Because a slab is imaged, a small tip angle (30°) must be used so the signal from blood that remains in the slab does not become too saturated. The small tip angle necessary to preserve signal from blood also leads to an undesirable preservation of signal from stationary tissues. Therefore, when 3D TOF MRA methods are applied, other mechanisms must be implemented in order to improve contrast between blood and stationary tissues. Some of these mechanisms include magnetization transfer [51–53], fat-andwater out-of-phase imaging, and/or ramped tip angle [54] excitation. These methods are described in later chapters. Three-dimensional TOF MRA methods offer smaller voxels, shorter echo times, and inherently higher signal-tonoise ratios than 2D TOF MRA methods. These are features common to all three-dimensional acquisition methods as described previously. The use of phase-encoding, rather than slice-selection, leads to the ability to image thinner slices (better resolution in reformatted images, smaller voxels), and to use a shorter TE. The combination of the small voxels and the short echo time leads to a reduction in the amount of signal loss caused by intravoxel dephasing. Threedimensional TOF MRA images of the cerebral vessels are shown in Fig. 1.32. Even when using magnetization transfer, fat-and-water out-of-phase imaging, and ramped excitation pulses, contrast between blood and stationary tissues can be small in
1
Basic Principles of MRI and MR Angiography
29
Fig. 1.31 (a) In 2D TOF MRA of the neck, a spatial saturation pulse applied superior to, and very near, each axial imaging slice will eliminate signal from blood in the veins to yield an arteriogram. (b) When no spatial saturation pulse is applied, both arteries and veins appear in the image, making interpretation difficult. (c) Applying a spatial saturation pulse inferior to, and very near, each axial imaging slice will eliminate signal from blood in the carotid arteries to yield a venogram
Fig. 1.32 (a) Axial, (b) coronal, and (c) sagittal MIP images produced from axial images of the intracranial vessels of a healthy adult acquired using a 3D TOF MRA technique
3D TOF MRA when thick slabs are used to achieve extended coverage. To achieve greater coverage with reduced saturation effects, 3D TOF MRA data can be acquired from multiple thin slabs arranged perpendicular to the vessels of interest using a method referred to as multiple overlapping thin slab angiography (MOTSA) [42, 55]. The multislab method combines the thin-slice benefits of two-dimensional acquisition (reduced saturation of blood) with the benefits of three-dimensional acquisition (including an inherently high signal-to-noise ratio, small voxels, and a short echo time) in an effort to provide high quality images as shown in Fig. 1.33. With 3D TOF MRA, a spatial saturation pulse can be applied just outside the slab at the beginning of each TR to eliminate signal from blood that will flow into the imaging slab as described previously for 2D TOF MRA. However, with 3D TOF MRA, the saturation pulse is not as effective.
This is because, as the blood that was initially saturated traverses the slab, the longitudinal magnetization from this blood begins to regrow, and the once-saturated blood eventually gives rise to signal. In general, the farther the oncesaturated blood penetrates into the slab, the less effective the saturation of the signal due to the increasing amount of time that elapses between saturation and signal detection.
Phase-Contrast MRA Phase-contrast (PC) MRA [56, 57] methods differ from CE-MRA and TOF MRA methods in that PC MRA methods provide a direct quantitative measure of the velocity of the flowing blood. Like TOF MRA methods, PC MRA methods can be acquired using 2D or 3D acquisitions. The 2D acquisitions, since they are rapid, can be cardiac-gated to provide
30
F.R. Korosec
Fig. 1.33 (a) Coronal MIP of axial images of the carotid arteries acquired using a multiple overlapping thin slab angiography (MOTSA) technique with a ramped tip angle, and a TE such that fat and water are out of phase with each other. (b) Magnified and cropped oblique MIP of the left carotid bifurcation
Fig. 1.35 A timing diagram for a 2D phase-contrast MRA pulse sequence. The timing diagram is similar to the one shown in Fig. 1.16 with the addition of a bipolar flow-encoding gradient on the frequencyencoding axis (shown as a dotted grey line to distinguish it from the other magnetic field gradients) Fig. 1.34 The transverse magnetization, Mxy, precesses when a magnetic field is applied. The amount that the magnetization rotates is denoted by the phase angle, f
dynamic information regarding blood flow throughout the cardiac cycle. Phase-contrast MRA techniques derive contrast between flowing blood and stationary tissues by manipulating the phase of the magnetization, such that the phase of the magnetization is zero for stationary tissues and non-zero for moving tissues. Phase is a measure of how far the magnetization precesses, or rotates, from the time it is tipped into the transverse plane until the time it is detected. The phase of the precessing transverse magnetization is shown in Fig. 1.34.
Imaging Sequence The pulse sequence used for phase-contrast acquisitions is a modified, spoiled, fast gradient-echo sequence. The most
significant modification to the gradient-echo pulse sequence timing diagram is the addition of a bipolar flow-encoding gradient as shown for 2D acquisition in Fig. 1.35. For 3D acquisition, a phase-encoding gradient would be added to the slice-selection axis. As described below, in order to encode flow in all directions, a data set must be acquired with the bipolar flow-encoding gradient applied on each of the three gradient axes, and to determine and eliminate unwanted phase accumulations from sources other than the bipolar flowencoding gradient, a reference data set also must be acquired. The effect of applying the bipolar flow-encoding gradient in PC MRA is that spins will accumulate a phase in proportion to their velocity. For example, stationary spins will accumulate no net phase shift. This is because the first lobe of the gradient (positive polarity) will impart a positive phase to the stationary spins, and the second lobe of the gradient (negative polarity) will impart an equivalent negative phase to the stationary spins, resulting in no net phase accumulation for stationary spins at the end of the application of the flowencoding gradient. So the signal associated with voxels containing stationary spins will be zero.
1
Basic Principles of MRI and MR Angiography
31
Fig. 1.36 (a) Axial, (b) coronal, and (c) sagittal MIP images of the intracranial vessels of a patient acquired using an experimental 3D PC MRA technique that employs an very rapid undersampled 3D radial
acquisition method (Images courtesy of Kevin Johnson, University of Wisconsin-Madison)
Moving spins, on the other hand, will be left with a net phase accumulation at the end of the application of the bipolar flow-encoding gradient. Since the spins are in motion, they will experience different field strengths during application of the positive and negative lobes of the bipolar flowencoding gradient, and therefore the phase imparted by the positive lobe will not equal the phase imparted by the negative lobe. The resulting phase is proportional to the velocity of the spins since faster moving spins travel farther between (and during) application of the positive and negative lobes of the bipolar flow-encoding gradient. This leads to a bigger difference in the gradient strength experienced by the spins during application of the positive and negative lobes of the gradient, which translates to a greater difference in the phase imparted to the spins by the positive and negative lobes of the bipolar flow-encoding gradient. Note that phase will only be imparted to spins that move along the axis containing the bipolar flow-encoding gradient. The phase imparted to spins by the application of a bipolar flow-encoding gradient on the frequency-encoding axis is given by the following equation:
data set is subtracted from each of the three flow-encoded data sets to eliminate phase accumulations resulting from sources other than the bipolar flow-encoding gradient (magnetic susceptibility, eddy currents, measurement imperfections, etc.). Alternatively, the bipolar flow-encoding gradients may be strategically applied on more than one axis simultaneously, to improve the signal-to-noise ratio of the subtracted images [58, 59]. These alternative methods still require the acquisition of four scans to acquire velocity information in all three Cartesian directions. The scan time for encoding flow in all three Cartesian directions using two-dimensional acquisitions is 4 × TR × Ny × Ave, where TR is the repetition time of the imaging sequence, Ny is the number of phase-encoding values acquired, and “Ave” is the number of signal averages. If flow is encoded in only a single direction, the factor of four is reduced to a factor of two. With two-dimensional acquisitions, a single thick slab is typically imaged. If multiple slabs are imaged, the scan time is determined by multiplying the above equation by the number of slabs imaged. Phase-contrast methods may also be implemented using three-dimensional acquisition [60, 61] as shown in Fig. 1.36. Benefits of three-dimensional acquisition include an inherently high signal-to-noise ratio (due to the effective averaging of signal that is acquired throughout the entire scan) and small voxels (due to the thin slices made possible by the encoding method employed). Also, three-dimensional image sets can be retrospectively reprojected or reformatted to permit observation of the vessels from any orientation. When phase-difference processing is used, images reformatted perpendicular to a vessel can be used to determine volume flow rate through that vessel. Three-dimensional acquisition is more time consuming than two-dimensional acquisition and thus is used less frequently. Due to the long scan times associated with three-dimensional acquisitions, they are not commonly cardiac-gated.
f v = ±g Gbp vFEt 2 ,
(1.13)
where g is the gyromagnetic ratio of the spins, Gbp is the amplitude of the bipolar flow-encoding gradient, vFE is the velocity of the spins along the frequency-encoding axis, t is the duration of each lobe of the bipolar flow-encoding gradient, and the ± indicates that the sign of the phase depends on the sign of the velocity, and whether the first lobe of the bipolar flow-encoding gradient is positive or negative. This equation ignores the ramp times of the bipolar flow-encoding gradient. In order to encode flow in all directions, the bipolar flowencoding gradient must be applied on each of the three gradient axes in separate TR intervals. In addition, a fourth nonflowencoded acquisition must be acquired. The nonflow-encoded
32
F.R. Korosec
Fig. 1.37 Vector diagrams showing the values that are measured for each pixel when implementing (a) phase-difference, (b) complexdifference, and (c) magnitude processing of phase-contrast data. In phase-difference processing, the phase angle, f, through which the magnetization rotates during each of the two acquisitions is
measured. In complex-difference processing, the distance between the ends of the magnetization vectors from the two acquisitions is measured. In magnitude processing, the magnitude of the magnetization vectors from the two acquisitions is measured, and the average is calculated
The scan time required for encoding flow in all directions using three-dimensional acquisitions is 4 × TR × Ave × Ny × Nz, where Nz is the number of slice-encoding values acquired and all other abbreviations are as described previously. If flow is encoded in only a single direction, the factor of four is reduced to a factor of two. With phase-contrast acquisition methods, the subtraction provides high contrast between vessels and stationary tissues, permitting large fields-of-view to be imaged with minimal detrimental effects from saturation, as long as a relatively small tip angle (20°–30°) is used.
by each pixel. Additionally, spins moving in one direction are assigned a bright (white) signal, whereas spins moving in the opposite direction are assigned a dark (black) signal as shown in Fig. 1.38. So, a cursor or region of interest (ROI) can be placed on the phase-difference images, and a direct measure of the velocity (mm/s) of the blood can be determined. In addition, if the cross-section of a vessel is demonstrated in the image, information regarding the volume flow rate of the blood (ml/min) in that vessel can be derived [62]. Furthermore, if the acquisition is cardiac-gated [63, 64], and a series of images is produced demonstrating the cross-section of a vessel throughout the cardiac cycle, then the acquired series of images can be evaluated to determine volume flow rate in that vessel throughout the cardiac cycle. The physiologic effect of vascular pathology can be evaluated by comparing the volume flow rate on the contralateral side with that on the ipsilateral side, or by comparing the volume flow rate before and after a physical or drug-induced challenge. The accuracy of volume flow rate measurements obtained using phase-contrast MRA is dependent on imaging parameters and placement of the ROI [62]. Because phase-difference images show direction of flow in the form of black or white signal, these images may be used to effectively differentiate arteries from veins when they are aligned antiparallel to each other. More importantly, phase-difference images can be used to detect retrograde flow in cases such as in subclavian steal syndrome, where a stenosis or occlusion of the subclavian artery proximal to the vertebral artery causes reversed flow in the latter. In complex-difference processing, vector subtraction is performed to determine the signal in each pixel as shown in Fig. 1.37b. Complex-difference images are shown in Fig. 1.38. With complex-difference processing, the signal in the images is dependent on the motion of the blood (as it is in phase-difference images), but the dependence is not linear (as it is in phase-difference images). Furthermore, the direction of blood flow is not represented in complex-difference
Processing Methods The data acquired with phase-contrast techniques can be processed in three different ways to produce phase-difference, complex-difference, and magnitude images. In phase-difference processing, phase subtraction is performed to determine the signal in each pixel as shown in Fig. 1.37a. For phase-difference processing, the phase of the magnetization is measured at the point in time when the receiver is activated. Since the phase of the magnetization is influenced by factors in addition to the bipolar flow-encoding gradient, typically two measurements are made, with only the bipolar flow-encoding gradient changed between the measurements, so the phase imparted by other factors remains the same for the two measurements. When the data for the two measurements are subtracted, the phase accumulation imparted by the other factors is eliminated since it is the same for the two measurements. The phase imparted by the bipolar flow-encoding gradients is opposite in the two measurements, so subtraction yields an enhancement of the phase caused by application of the bipolar flow-encoding gradient. In phase-difference images, the signal value of each pixel is linearly proportional to the velocity of the spins represented
1
Basic Principles of MRI and MR Angiography
33
Fig. 1.38 Sagittal images of the midline intracranial vessels demonstrating that data acquired using phase-contrast MRA can be reconstructed to produce phase-difference images showing flow in the (a) right/left, (b) anterior/posterior, and (c) superior/inferior directions. In these images, the intensity of the signal is proportional to the velocity of the blood. The intensity in these images can be squared, summed, and the square root can be calculated to produce a “speed” image as
shown in (g). Data acquired using phase-contrast MRA can also be reconstructed to produce complex-difference images showing flow in the (d) right/left, (e) anterior/posterior, and (f) superior/inferior directions. The intensity in these images can be squared, summed, and the square root can be calculated to produce a “speed” image as shown in (h). Finally, the phase-contrast data can be reconstructed to produce a magnitude image as shown in (i)
images, so flow in opposite directions is not represented as black and white as it is in phase-difference images. Therefore, complex-difference images are not used to determine quantitative information regarding blood velocity or volume flow rate, but are used instead for demonstrating the morphology of the vessels. In magnitude processing, the length of the transverse magnetization vector is measured to determine the signal in each pixel as shown in Fig. 1.37c. This is the processing method traditionally used to produce images in MRI. With phase-contrast methods, the phase of the magnetization is manipulated, but the strength of the magnetization, or its magnitude, is unaltered. Thus, displaying the magnitude of the magnetization permits simultaneous demonstration of vessels and stationary tissues as shown in Fig. 1.38.
methods, only velocities within a certain range will be accurately represented in the images. The range of velocities that will be accurately represented is determined by the velocityencoding (Venc) parameter selected when the imaging sequence is prescribed. Blood traveling at velocities higher than the Venc value will be misrepresented in the image, so this value must be chosen carefully. This misrepresentation of velocities outside of the Venc value is referred to as velocity aliasing and appears differently in phase-difference and complex-difference images. In phase-difference images, aliased signal is easy to identify by an abrupt change from very dark to very bright signal as seen in the image shown in Fig. 1.40, or vice versa (see transitions in Fig. 1.39 for phase-difference processing). In complex-difference images, velocity aliasing manifests as a decreasing signal for blood traveling at velocities beyond the Venc value (see Fig. 1.39 for complex-difference processing), and blood traveling at some velocities above the Venc value gives rise to no signal at all. Thus, with complex-difference processing, selecting a Venc that is too low can yield very misleading results that are not easy to identify. With both phasedifference and complex-difference processing, choosing a Venc value that is too low should be avoided in order to
Velocity Encoding and Velocity Aliasing In phase-contrast images, the signals are proportional to the velocities of the imaged spins, as shown in the graphs in Fig. 1.39. The proportionalities are different for phase-difference and complex-difference processing. For both processing
34
Fig. 1.39 Graphs demonstrating the signal as a function of velocity for (top) phase-difference (PD) and (bottom) complex-difference (CD) processing. For phase-difference processing, the signal is linearly proportional to the velocity of the spins – for spins with velocities within the range defined by the velocity-encoding (Venc) value specified by
F.R. Korosec
operator. For complex-difference processing, the signal is sinusoidally proportional to the speed (the signal is the same for positive and negative velocities) of the spins – for spins with velocities within the range defined by the velocity-encoding (Venc) value specified by the operator
veins in an arteriovenous malformation (AVM) can be displayed in separate images that are sensitive to different velocity ranges as shown in Fig. 1.41.
Balanced Steady-State Free Precession MRA
Fig. 1.40 With phase-contrast MRA methods, a velocity-encoding, Venc, value must be selected. Velocities above this value will be misrepresented, or aliased. In phase-difference-processed images, such as the one shown here, velocity aliasing is easy to identify (arrows) as an abrupt change from very dark to very bright signal, or from very bright to very dark signal (not shown)
prevent velocity aliasing. Choosing a Venc value that is too high also should be avoided as it leads to magnetization from all blood accumulating only small phase shifts, which results in low SNR, and a small signal range. To avoid velocity aliasing, some a priori information regarding the anticipated pathology may be helpful in determining the appropriate velocity-encoding value. Alternatively, different velocity-encoding values may be used in different scans to highlight different vessels. For example, arteries and
MRA also can be performed using balanced steady-state free precession (bSSFP) imaging sequences [65]. In bSSFP imaging, both the longitudinal and transverse components of magnetization are maintained in a steady-state condition. In order to ensure that the transverse component of magnetization is not spoiled, all of the imaging gradients must be completely balanced so that the net phase accumulation imparted to the spins from one TR to the next is zero. A pulse sequence timing diagram for a bSSFP sequence is shown in Fig. 1.42. Note that, between RF pulses, the area under the positive gradient waveforms equals the area under the negative gradient waveforms, ensuring that the net phase imparted to any spin by the imaging gradients during this interval is zero. Depending on MRI vendor, this imaging sequence is called FIESTA (fast imaging employing stead-state acquisition), trueFISP (true fast imaging with steady-state precession), or bFFE (balanced fast field echo). Since the transverse magnetization is maintained from one TR to the next, those tissues with long T2 values give rise to large signals in bSSFP methods. Tissues with short T1 values also give rise to large signals. The signal intensity is proportional to T2/T1. The signal intensity achieved with signal
1
Basic Principles of MRI and MR Angiography
35
Fig. 1.41 Phase-contrast MRA images can be acquired with different velocity sensitivities (using different Venc values) to highlight vessels containing blood flowing in different velocity ranges. These sagittal complex-difference-processed phase-contrast images of an arteriovenous malformation (AVM) were acquired with velocity-encoding
Fig. 1.42 A timing diagram for a balanced steady-state free precession (bSSFP) gradient-echo pulse sequence. Note that the gradient waveforms on all three axes are balanced so that the positive area equals the negative area to ensure that no net phase is imparted to any spins during the TR interval. This allows the transverse magnetization to achieve a steady-state value
steady-state free precession methods (when steady-state has been achieved) is given by the following equation [66]: M xy+ = M 0 ´
(1 - E1 ) ´ sin(q ) , 1 - ( E1 - E2 ) ´ cos(q ) - E1 E2
(1.14)
where M xy+ is the transverse magnetization immediately following the RF pulse, E1,2 def exp( -TR /T1,2 ) , M 0 is the thermal equilibrium magnetization, and q is the tip angle. If TE = TR/2, then the transverse magnetization that is detected is given by the following equation [67]: M xy = M xy+ ´ E2 .
(1.15)
A cardiac image acquired with a bSSFP method is shown in Fig. 1.43. Owing to its relatively long T2, blood appears
values of (a) 20 cm/s and (b) 80 cm/s. Note that the slower flow in the nidus of the AVM is better demonstrated in the image shown in (a), whereas the faster flow in the feeding arteries is better demonstrated in the image shown in (b)
Fig. 1.43 One of 16 images of a patient’s heart acquired during a single breath-hold interval using a cardiac-gated, balanced steady-state free precession (bSSFP) method. With these methods, multiple images of the same anatomic slice are typically acquired. Each image shows the heart in a different phase of the cardiac cycle. When all of the images are displayed in rapid succession (as a movie loop), the cardiac dynamics are revealed
bright in this image, providing high contrast between it and the surrounding myocardium. Other tissues with large T2/T1 ratios also appear bright in images acquired with bSSFP methods, limiting the application of these methods for MRA applications. Fat and venous blood have large T2/T1 ratios. Fat suppression may be achieved to varying degrees of success by using water-selective excitation pulse, or repeated spectral fat-saturation pulses. Similarly, venous suppression may be achieved to varying degrees of success by using spatial saturation or inversion pulses. Balanced SSFP methods suffer from signal loss in regions of magnetic field nonuniformities, since, under these circumstances, the requirement for zero net phase accumulation
36
between TRs is not satisfied. Thus, shimming the magnetic field is very important when using bSSFP methods. In order to reduce phase accumulations caused by remaining magnetic field nonuniformities, short TRs are employed with bSSFP methods. Balanced SSFP methods have proven useful for cardiac imaging applications [68], but owing to the remaining challenges faced by these methods, they currently are not widely used for MRA applications.
Summary Under appropriate conditions, and when properly implemented, all MR angiographic methods can yield high-quality diagnostic images. Three-dimensional MRA methods offer small voxels, short echo times, inherently high signal-tonoise ratios, and the ability to retrospectively reformat image volumes to show tortuous vessels from any viewing angle. Three-dimensional CE-MRA methods can provide high quality vascular images with less sensitivity to artifacts (caused by intravoxel dephasing, signal saturation, cardiac pulsatility, and patient motion) and shorter scan times than noncontrast-enhanced MRA methods. Intravenous injection of a T1-shortening contrast material provides high SNR angiograms with high contrast between vessels and stationary tissues. Relatively high spatial resolution and large volume coverage may be achieved in reasonable scan times. In 3D CE-MRA images, vascular pathologies are well delineated. Owing to its many attributes, 3D CE-MRA is widely used for imaging vessels throughout the body, and in some situations is replacing X-ray DSA as the imaging method-of-choice. Three-dimensional TOF MRA methods are often used for imaging the intracranial arteries, as well as the extracranial carotid and vertebral arteries. Two-dimensional TOF methods are sensitive to signal loss from intravoxel dephasing and often are used as a highly sensitive and specific method for screening for stenoses of the carotid or lower extremity arteries. Two-dimensional TOF also may be used with an inferior spatial saturation pulse to image the intracranial veins. Twodimensional TOF MRA may be cardiac-gated to provide images in regions affected by cardiac pulsatility. Phase-contrast methods offer qualitative and quantitative information regarding blood velocity or volume flow rate. Two-dimensional phase-contrast methods offer short scan times, and often are used to provide multiple images, each sensitive to a different range of velocities, or are cardiacgated to provide velocity or flow information throughout the cardiac cycle. Three-dimensional phase-contrast images require long scan times, but the volume of information may be retrospectively analyzed to yield average velocity or flow information through any vessel, no matter what its orientation. The use of a bipolar flow-encoding gradient makes
F.R. Korosec
these sequences particularly susceptible to signal loss caused by intravoxel dephasing. bSSFP methods are widely used for cardiac applications, but owing to several remaining challenges, are not yet routinely used for MRA applications.
References 1. Bernstein MA, Huston J 3rd, Lin C, Gibbs GF, Felmlee JP. Highresolution intracranial and cervical MRA at 3.0T: technical considerations and initial experience. Magn Reson Med. 2001;46:955–962. 2. Thomas SD, Al-Kwifi O, Emery DJ, Wilman AH. Application of magnetization transfer at 3.0 T in three-dimensional time-of-flight magnetic resonance angiography of the intracranial arteries. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2002;15:479–483. 3. Willinek WA, Born M, Simon B, Tschampa HJ, Krautmacher C, Gieseke J, Urbach H, Textor HJ, Schild HH. Time-of-flight MR angiography: comparison of 3.0-T imaging and 1.5-T imaging-initial experience. Radiology. 2003;229:913–920. 4. Leiner T, de Vries M, Hoogeveen R, Vasbinder GB, Lemaire E, van Engelshoven JM. Contrast-enhanced peripheral MR angiography at 3.0 Tesla: initial experience with a whole-body scanner in healthy volunteers. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2003;17:609–614. 5. Gibbs GF, Huston J 3rd, Bernstein MA, Riederer SJ, Brown RD Jr. Improved image quality of intracranial aneurysms: 3.0-T versus 1.5-T time-of-flight MR angiography. Am J Neuroradiol. 2004;25:84–87. 6. Edelstein WA, Hutchison JM, Johnson G, Redpath T. Spin warp NMR imaging and applications to human whole-body imaging. Phys Med Biol. 1980;25:751–756. 7. Glover GH, Pauly JM. Projection reconstruction techniques for reduction of motion effects in MRI. Magn Reson Med. 1992;28: 275–289. 8. Meyer CH, Hu BS, Nishimura DG, Macovski A. Fast spiral coronary artery imaging. Magn Reson Med. 1992;28:202–213. 9. Barger AV, Block WF, Toropov Y, Grist TM, Mistretta CA.Timeresolved contrast-enhanced imaging with isotropic resolution and broad coverage using an undersampled 3D projection trajectory. Magn Reson Med. 2002;48:297–305. 10. Thedens DR, Irarrazaval P, Sachs TS, Meyer CH, Nishimura DG. Fast magnetic resonance coronary angiography with a three-dimensional stack of spirals trajectory. Magn Reson Med. 1999;41:1170–1179. 11. Gurney PT, Hargreaves BA, Nishimura DG. Design and analysis of a practical 3D cones trajectory. Magn Reson Med. 2006;55: 575–582. 12. Macovski A. Noise in MRI. Magn Reson Med. 1996;36:494–497. 13. Sodickson DK, Manning WJ. Simultaneous acquisition of spatial harmonics (SMASH): fast imaging with radiofrequency coil arrays. Magn Reson Med. 1997;38:591–603. 14. Pruessmann KP, Weiger M, Scheidegger MB, Boesiger P. SENSE: sensitivity encoding for fast MRI. Magn Reson Med. 1999;42:952–962. 15. Weiger M, Pruessmann KP, Kassner A, Roditi G, Lawton T, Reid A, Boesiger P. Contrast-enhanced 3D MRA using SENSE. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2000;12:671–77. 16. Griswold MA, Jakob PM, Heidemann RM, Nittka M, Jellus V, Wang J, Kiefer B, Haase A. Generalized autocalibrating partially parallel acquisitions (GRAPPA). Magn Reson Med. 2002;47:1202–1210. 17. Prince MR, Yucel EK, Kaufman JA, et al.: Dynamic gadoliniumenhanced three-dimensional abdominal MR arteriography. J Magn Reson Imaging. 1993;3:877–881. 18. Kroft LJ, de Roos A. Blood pool contrast agents for cardiovascular MR imaging. J Magn Reson Imaging. 1999;10:395–403. 19. Perreault P, Edelman MA, Baum RA, Yucel EK, Weisskoff RM, Shamsi K, Mohler ER 3rd. MR angiography with gadofosveset
1
20.
21. 22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31. 32.
33.
34.
35.
36.
37.
Basic Principles of MRI and MR Angiography trisodium for peripheral vascular disease: phase II trial. Radiology. 2003;229:811–820. Thomsen HS, Morcos SK, Dawson P. Is there a causal relation between the administration of gadolinium based contrast media and the development of nephrogenic systemic fibrosis (NSF)? Clin Radiol. 2006;61:905–906. Zur Y, Wood ML, Neuringer LJ. Spoiling of transverse magnetization in steady-state sequences. Magn Reson Med. 1991;21:251–263. Haacke E, Brown R, Thompson M, Venkatesan R. Magnetic Resonance Imaging: Physical Principles and Sequence Design. New York: John Wiley and Sons, Inc.; 1999:455. Du YP. Parker DL. Davis WL, Cao G. Reduction of partial-volume artifacts with zero-filled interpolation in three-dimensional MR angiography. J Magn Reson Imaging. 1994;4:733–741. Bernstein MA, Fain SB, Riederer SJ. Effect of windowing and zero-filled reconstruction of MRI data on spatial resolution and acquisition strategy. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2001;14:270–280. Maki J, Prince M, Londy F, Chenevert T. The effects of time varying intravascular signal intensity and k-space acquisition order on three-dimensional MR angiography image quality. J Magn Reson Imaging. 1996;6:642–651. Earls J, Rofsky N, DeCorato D, et al. Breath-hold single-dose gadolinium-enhanced three-dimensional MR aortography: usefulness of a timing examination and MR power injector. Radiology. 1996;201:705–710. Foo T, Saranathan M, Prince M, Chenevert T. Automated detection of bolus arrival and initiation of data acquisition in fast, threedimensional, gadolinium enhanced MR angiography. Radiology. 1997;203:275–280. Huston J, Fain S, Riederer S, et al. Carotid arteries: Maximizing arterial to venous contrast in fluoroscopically triggered contrastenhanced MR angiography with elliptical centric view ordering. Radiology. 1999;211:265–273. Wang Y, Johnston D, Breen J, et al. Dynamic MR digital subtraction angiography using contrast enhancement, fast data acquisition, and complex subtraction. Magn Reson Med. 1996;36:551–556. Hennig J, Scheffler K, Laubenberger J, Strecker R. Time-resolved projection angiography after bolus injection of contrast agent. Magn Reson Med. 1997;37:341–345. Korosec F, Frayne R, Grist T, Mistretta C. Time-resolved contrastenhanced 3D MR angiography. Magn Reson Med. 1996;36:345–351. Willig DS, Turski PA, Frayne R, et al. Contrast-enhanced 3D MR DSA of the carotid artery bifurcation: Preliminary study of comparison with unenhanced 2D and 3D time-of-flight MR angiography. Radiology. 1998;208:447–451. van Vaals JJ, Brummer ME, Dixon WT, Tuithof HH, Engels H, Nelson RC, Gerety BM, Chezmar JL, den Boer JA. “Keyhole” method for accelerating imaging of contrast agent uptake. J Magn Reson Imaging. 1993;3:671–675. Willinek WA, Hadizadeh DR, von Falkenhausen M, Urbach H, Hoogeveen R, Schild HH, Gieseke J. 4D time-resolved MR angiography with keyhole (4D-TRAK): more than 60 times accelerated MRA using a combination of CENTRA, keyhole, and SENSE at 3.0T. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2008;27:1455–1460. Wilman A, Riederer S, Huston J, et al. Arterial phase carotid and vertebral artery imaging in 3D contrast-enhanced MR angiography by combining fluoroscopic triggering with an elliptical centric acquisition order. Magn Reson Med. 1998;40:24–35. Huston J, Fain SB, Wald JT, Luetmer PH, et al. Carotid artery: elliptic centric contrast-enhanced MR angiography compared with conventional angiography. Radiology. 2001;218:138–143. Earls JP, Patel NH, Smith PA, DeSena S, Meissner MH. Gadoliniumenhanced three-dimensional MR angiography of the aorta and peripheral arteries: evaluation of a multistation examination using two gadopentetate dimeglumine infusions. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1998;171:599–604.
37 38. Ho KY, Leiner T, de Haan MW, Kessels AG, Kitslaar PJ, van Engelshoven JM. Peripheral vascular tree stenoses: evaluation with moving-bed infusion-tracking MR angiography. Radiology. 1998; 206:683–692. 39. Earls JP, DeSena S, Bluemke DA. Gadolinium-enhanced threedimensional MR angiography of the entire aorta and iliac arteries with dynamic manual table translation. Radiology. 1998;209: 844–849. 40. Meaney JF, Ridgway JP, Chakraverty S, et al. Stepping-table gadolinium-enhanced digital subtraction MR angiography of the aorta and lower extremity arteries: preliminary experience. Radiology. 1999;211:59–67. 41. Keller PJ, Drayer BP, Fram EK, et al. MR angiography with twodimensional acquisition and three-dimensional display: work in progress. Radiology. 1989;173:527–532. 42. Parker DL, Yuan C, Blatter DD. MR angiography by multiple thin slab 3D acquisition. Magn Reson Med. 1991;17:434–451. 43. Pattany PM, Phillips JJ, Chiu LC, Lipcamon JD, et al. Motion artifact suppression technique (MAST) for MR imaging. J Comput Assist Tomogr. 1987;11:369–377. 44. Haacke E, Lenz G. Improving MR image quality in the presence of motion by using rephasing gradients. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1987;148:1251–1258. 45. Haacke E, Brown R, Thompson M, Venkatesan R. Magnetic Resonance Imaging: Physical Principles and Sequence Design. New York: John Wiley and Sons, Inc.; 1999:461. 46. Felmlee JP, Ehman RL. Spatial presaturation: a method for suppressing flow artifacts and improving depiction of vascular anatomy in MR imaging. Radiology. 1987;164:559–564. 47. Edelman RR, Atkinson DJ, Silver MS, et al. FRODO pulse sequences: a new means of eliminating motion flow, and wraparound artifacts. Radiology. 1988;166:231–236. 48. Ehman RL, Felmlee JP. Flow artifact reduction in MRI: a review of the roles of gradient moment nulling and spatial presaturation. Magn Reson Med. 1990;14:293–307. 49. Ruggieri PM, Laub GA, Marsaryk TJ, et al. Intracranial circulation: pulse-sequence considerations in three-dimensional (volume) MR angiography. Radiology. 1989;171:785–791. 50. Schmalbrock P, Yuan C, Chakeres DW, et al. Volume MR angiography: methods to achieve very short echo times. Radiology. 1990;175:861–865. 51. Wolff SD and Balaban RS. Magnetization transfer contrast (MTC) and tissue water proton relaxation in vivo. Magn Reson Med. 1989;10:135–144. 52. Pike GB, Hu BS, Glover GH, Enzmann DR. Magnetization transfer time-of-flight magnetic resonance angiography. Magn Reson Med. 1992;25:372–379. 53. Edelman RR, Ahn SS, Chien D, et al. Improved time-of-flight MR angiography of the brain with magnetization transfer contrast. Radiology. 1992;184:395–399. 54. Nagele T, Klose U, Grodd W, Petersen D, et al. The effects of linearly increasing flip angles on 3D inflow MR angiography. Magn Reson Med. 1994;31:561–566. 55. Blatter DD, Parker DL, Robinson R. Cerebral MR angiography with multiple overlapping thin slab acquisition. Radiology. 1991; 179:805–811. 56. Moran PR. A flow zeugmatographic interlace for NMR imaging in humans. Magn Reson Imaging. 1982;1:197–203. 57. Dumoulin CL and Hart HR. Magnetic resonance angiography. Radiology. 1986;161:717–720. 58. Pelc NJ, Bernstein MA, Shimakawa A, Glover GH. Encoding strategies for three-direction phase-contrast MR imaging of flow. Magn Reson Imaging. 1991;1:405–413. 59. Hausman R, Lewin JS, Laub G. Phase-contrast MR angiography with reduced acquisition time: new concepts in sequence design. J Magn Reson. 1991;1:415–422.
38 60. Dumoulin C, Souza S, Walker M, Wagle W. Three-dimensional phase contrast angiography. Magn Reson Med. 1989;9:139–149. 61. Pernicone JR, Siebert JE, Potchen EJ, et al. Three-dimensional phase-contrast MR angiography in the head and neck: preliminary report. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1990;155:167–176. 62. Korosec F and Turski P. Velocity and volume flow rate measurements using phase contrast magnetic resonance imaging (review article). Int J Neuroradiology. 1997;3:293–318. 63. Nayler GL, Firmin DN, Longmore DB. Blood flow imaging by cine magnetic resonance. J Comput Assist Tomogr. 1986;10:715–722. 64. Pelc NJ, Herfkens RJ, Shimakawa A, Enzmann DR. Phase contrast cine magnetic resonance imaging. Magn Reson Q. 1991;7:229–254.
F.R. Korosec 65. Scheffler K, Lehnhardt S. Principles and applications of balanced SSFP techniques (review article). Eur Radiol. 2003;13: 2409–2418. 66. Haacke E, Brown R, Thompson M, Venkatesan R. Magnetic Resonance Imaging: Physical Principles and Sequence Design. New York: John Wiley and Sons, Inc.; 1999:480. 67. Scheffler K, Hennig J. Is true FISP a gradient-echo or a spin-echo sequence? Magn Reson Med. 2003;49:395–397. 68. Carr JC, Simonetti O, Bundy J, Li D, Pereles S, and Finn JP. Cine MR angiography of the heart with segmented true fast imaging with steady-state precession. Radiology. 2001;219: 828–834.
2
Time-of-Flight Angiography Seong-Eun Kim and Dennis L. Parker
Introduction Time-of-flight (TOF) angiography is a widely used means of producing angiographic images without the need for the injection of contrast agent. In this chapter, we discuss the MR imaging (MRI) physics which governs the creation of TOF angiograms. We also describe the MRI pulse sequence used for TOF imaging, sources of artifact, and compensatory mechanisms to reduce the deleterious effect of these artifacts.
MR Signal in Time of Flight The flow sensitivity of MRI methods is based on TOF effects, where the amplitude of the signal from flowing blood changes as it moves into the imaged volume, and phase effects, where motion of the blood during applied gradients results in a phase change due to motion. Both flow phenomena can be used to differentiate flowing spins from stationary spins by evaluating either the magnitude or the phase in the acquired MRI data. TOF effects influence the signal intensities of moving blood in MR image in nonangiographic applications. For example, flow voids resulting from the motion through a slice- and flow-related enhancement (FRE) have commonly been seen in both spin echo and gradient echo imaging, respectively. TOF image contrast is based on establishing a difference in the longitudinal magnetization of moving spins relative to stationary spins. The TOF effect was first reported in a nonimaging application by Suryan [1] and in the imaging of blood vessels by Hinshaw et al. [2]. The magnetization of a bolus of flowing blood is typically modified at one location and detected a short time later at another location. Since time elapses between the modification and detection S.-E. Kim, PhD () • D.L. Parker, PhD Department of Radiology, Utah Center for Advanced Imaging Research, Salt Lake City, UT, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
of the flowing magnetization, this effect is referred to as the “TOF” effect. TOF techniques in MRA can be divided into those which yield a high signal from flowing spins and low signal from the background tissue (white blood) and those which yield strong signal from the background tissue and little signal from the flowing spins (black blood). White blood (sometimes called bright blood) techniques are the most commonly used for angiography and are the focus of the remainder of this chapter. In white blood TOF, static tissue is suppressed by using a spoiled gradient echo (SPGRE) sequence with relatively short TR. The spoiling suppresses (i.e., saturates) the signal from static tissue, and the TR is adjusted to be long enough so that a sufficient amount of blood can flow into the imaging plane creating contrast between flowing and static tissue. TOF images can be acquired as two-dimensional (2D) or three-dimensional (3D) images. The acquisition of a 3D volume receives signal simultaneously from the entire volume of interest while a 2D acquisition receives signal sequentially from a series of image slices, one slice at a time. In both cases, images are stored as a 3D image dataset. For physician review, a projection angiogram from the 3D dataset is created by projecting the reconstructed image values through the 3D image volume, most commonly using the maximum intensity projection (MIP) [3]. 3D techniques in general have the advantage of higher signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and higher spatial resolution than 2D techniques at the expense of lower blood vessel signal because the blood remains in the slab for a significant fraction of the imaging time. 2D TOF images generally have higher contrast between blood and background tissue than 3D techniques but have lower spatial resolution due to slice thickness larger than 2 mm. To reduce blood signal saturation while maintaining the SNR of 3D acquisition, Parker et al. [4] developed the multiple overlapping thin 3D slab acquisition (MOTSA) technique. MOTSA acquisitions have the high SNR typical of 3D acquisition with improved vessel contrast common to 2D acquisitions.
J.C. Carr and T.J. Carroll (eds.), Magnetic Resonance Angiography: Principles and Applications, DOI 10.1007/978-1-4419-1686-0_2, © Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2012
39
40
The goal of TOF MRA is to provide an accurate depiction of the blood within the vascular lumen (artery or vein) noninvasively and various TOF techniques have been successful in meeting this challenge. The best results are achieved when appropriate pulse sequence parameters are matched to each clinical application. In some cases, alterations to the standard SPGR pulse sequence, such as the use of magnetization transfer (MT) saturation, flow compensation, MOTSA [5], or TONE [6], can improve diagnostic accuracy. In general, TOF MRA techniques are clinically useful in the evaluation of small aneurysms, atherosclerosis, vasospasm, and inflammatory vasculitis.
S.-E. Kim and D.L. Parker
blood with plug flow, uniform velocity throughout the radius of the vessel, with speed v in a blood vessel with flow perpendicular to a slice to be imaged, as shown in Fig. 2.1. During the time, TR, between RF pulses, the fluid moves a distance, dz. Thus, in the time, TR, a length, dz, of nonexcited blood moves into the imaged slice. If dz is greater than slice thickness, z, the entire vessel segment within the slice is replaced by fresh inflowing blood shown as region I in Fig. 2.1a. If dz is less than z, then there will be sections of thickness dz that see one, then two, and three RF pulses as shown as region I, II, and II, respectively, in Fig. 2.1b. If the velocity of blood is exactly z/TR, the full slice thickness, z = vTR, will be completely replaced with fresh inflowing blood. The critical speed (2.1) is defined as:
Quantification of the Time-of-Flight Effect Vc ≡
z . TR
(2.1)
The TOF effect has been reviewed by Axel et al. [7], Gullberg et al. [8], and Nishimura [9] who modeled the signal on the basis of the Bloch equations for a variety of pulse sequence schemes for both plug and laminar flow. If the spins in stationary tissue experience a large number of RF pulses, the longitudinal magnetization of the stationary spins approaches a steady-state equilibrium value that is independent of position within the slice. However, when flowing spins, such as in blood, are flowing into and out of the slice, they may be subjected to fewer RF pulses resulting in a different steadystate magnetization. In general, the TOF effect leads to a diminished blood signal in spin echo imaging. However, in gradient echo images with short TR, the TOF effect results in inflow signal enhancement, which increases the signal from flowing blood relative to static tissue. As a simplistic example, consider
When the speed of blood is faster than Vc, the blood in the vessel that lies in the selected slice is completely refreshed by blood containing unsaturated spins. The fresh blood results in a higher signal relative to the stationary tissue signal since stationary tissue experiences many more RF pulses and is much more saturated. This effect is called wash-in, inflow enhancement or FRE. If v < Vc, partial saturation of the blood will begin to take place for distances into the slice greater than vTR. Fresh (fully magnetized) blood flowing into the imaging slice restores some of the signal intensity lost to partial saturation. In the simple example given above, the flow direction was perpendicular to the slice plane. Inflow enhancement of flow signal decreases for blood flow that transverses the blood vessel obliquely, and increases as
Fig. 2.1 TOF effects in the presence of plug flow with speed v in direction z. (a) When the velocity is higher than the critical velocity as given in (2.1), spins in the blood region I experience only one RF pulse and then exit the imaging slice before the next RF application. Spins in region II are not affected by the first excitation but by the next RF pulse.
(b) When the blood is moving slower than the critical velocity, the saturation effect can be understood by dividing the slice into multiple segments. Blood located in each segment experiences a different number of RF pulses, RF(n), resulting in different saturation effects depending on n
2
Time-of-Flight Angiography
41
the blood’s speed increases above Vc. Inflow enhancement also increases as slice thickness is reduced since Vc is proportional to the slice thickness, z. If the perpendicular component of velocity exceeds the critical velocity, there is complete inflow replacement in the imaging slice during each TR. A further increase in velocity results in no further increase in blood signal enhancement and might even begin to decrease the signal due to intravoxel phase dispersion. To extend this mathematical model to 3D TOF and MOTSA sequences, the slice thickness (z) can be replaced by the slab thickness, Nzdz. If the blood vessel is straight and perpendicular to the imaging slab, the critical velocity (2.2) is given by Vc =
N z dz TR
(2.2)
and for velocities greater than the critical velocity, the blood inside the slab is completely replaced by fresh blood flowing from the outside of the slab. For standard SPGR sequences, the TOF effect can be explained as the difference in signal saturation between flowing and static spins. Spins flowing into a slice may be less saturated than static spins resulting in angiographic contrast differences. The longitudinal magnetization of a stationary spin (i.e., after a series of RF pulses) with equilibrium magnetization, Mo, and longitudinal relaxation time, T1, subjected to the SPGR pulse sequence is given by [10]: M z ss =
M 0 (1 − e − TR/T1 ) , 1 − e − TR/T1 cos q
(2.3)
where q is the flip angle and TR is the repetition time of the sequence, T1 is the longitudinal relaxation time of blood which is almost same as T1 of tissue, and M0 is the equilibrium longitudinal magnetization. Before reaching the steady state, the longitudinal pulse (2.4) is given by: M z (n − ) = M z ss + (e − TR / T1 cos q )n −1 ( M 0 − M z ss ) n ≥ 1. (2.4) The transverse magnetization after the nth RF pulse (2.5) is given by M + (n) = M z (n − )sin qe − TE/T2 .
(2.5)
In cases when TR is much shorter than T1, as the number of RF pulses, n, increases, the contribution of the second term in (2.4) gets very small. Under these approximations, the transverse magnetization after the nth RF pulse (2.6) can be simplified as: M+ =
M 0 (1 − e − TR/T1 ) sin q e − TE/T2 . 1 − e − TR/T1 cosq
(2.6)
As the TR/T1 ratio decreases, the transverse magnetization given in (2.6) monotonically decreases. In other words, saturation of the MRI signal increases. The maximum signal occurs when the flip angle is the Ernst angle (qE = arcos(exp(−TR/T1)), which implies that saturation is dominant over the creation of transverse magnetization for q > qE. Inflowing fresh or fully magnetized blood entering into the imaging slice restores some of the signal intensity lost to partial saturation. Inflow enhancement increases with the blood velocity and as the imaging slice becomes perpendicular to the velocity direction. It also increases as slice thickness is reduced. As mentioned previously, if the perpendicular component of velocity exceeds the critical velocity, there is complete inflow replacement in the imaging slice during each TR. A further increase in velocity yields no further increase in the signal enhancement in blood and might even begin to decrease the signal due to intravoxel dephasing effects which are discussed in the next section. When the blood experiences a single RF excitation pulse in an SPRE sequence, the amount of inflow enhancement in the spoiled gradient sequence is given by the difference (2.7): M + (n) − M + = M0 sin q (e − TR/T1 cosq )n −1 ⎛ (1 − e − TR/T1 ) ⎞ − TE/T2* 1 − . ⎜⎝ (1 − e − TR/T1 cosq ) ⎟⎠ e
(2.7)
By using (2.7), the inflow enhancement effect can be simulated and quantified. Figure 2.2 shows computer simulations based on (2.7). In these simulations, we studied how the normalized signal of the flow enhancement effect (FRE) changes as the flip angle (q) increases for two cases: (a) TR/T1 = 0.02 and (b) when TR/T1 = 0.1. The normalized signal was obtained by dividing (2.6) by M0e−TE/T2*. The simulation demonstrates that FRE increases as n decreases when the TR and slice thickness are fixed. For a fixed TR and slice thickness, increasing n means faster flow velocity. This trend continues until v = Vmax, at which point the flow experiences only one RF pulse and the flow enhancement effect reaches a maximum. If n = 1, the maximum transverse magnetization (2.8) is given by: *
M + (n = 1) = M0 sin q e − TE/T2 .
(2.8)
Figure 2.2 shows that if there is no partial saturation (n = 1), the higher RF flip angle (90°) results in a maximum FRE. Comparing the curves, we see that the ratio of TR/T1 decreases and the flow enhancement intensity increases. When velocity v is smaller than the critical velocity, the flow enhancement effect can be modeled by subdivision of imaging slices into multiple compartments and summation of the geometric series shown in Fig. 2.1.
42
S.-E. Kim and D.L. Parker
Fig. 2.2 Plots of the flow enhancement effect (FRE) simulated from (2.8). The label n is the number of excitation RF pulses experienced by spins located in the imaging slices
In general, arterial velocity is an interesting function of the branching nature of the vascular bed. From the aorta to the capillaries, as the vascular branches, the vessel crosssection becomes progressively smaller. However, the number of branches increases in such a manner that the total cross-section increases as the branching increases. Thus, from geometry alone, arterial velocity decreases with distance from the heart. In general, the velocity remains sufficiently high for successful inflow enhancement until diameters smaller than 0.2 mm are reached. For vessels that can be seen with TOF MRA, the velocities become relatively constant (less pulsatile) for the more distal segments.
Phase Dispersion and Flow Compensation Signal intensity in MRI TOF imaging depends upon the imaging pulse sequence and the geometry and nature (velocity profile, pulsatility, etc.) of flow. Because of viscosity, flowing blood experiences frictional forces from the surrounding blood and vessel wall in addition to the force due to the pressure drop along the vessel. These forces generally result in a form of laminar flow. Laminar flow is characterized by a parabolic velocity profile, where the velocities in the center of the vessel are greater than those at the vessel wall. The magnetic field gradients used for spatial signal encoding in MRI impart a velocity-dependent phase at the time of signal acquisition. Because the velocity of blood varies considerably over dimensions that are much smaller than an image voxel, laminar flow can result in a range of phases for the signal generating spins within a voxel. If not properly compensated, this phase dispersion results in a loss in signal from flowing spins. High-velocity fluid motion through static vessels and arterial branches, such as the carotid bifurcation, produces complex flow patterns, including flow vortices (recirculation) and unsteady, nonrepetitive pulsatile, or turbulent flow.
Flow vortices and unsteady, turbulent flow increase phase dispersion of spin coherence due to the multiple directions of motion, acceleration, and higher order motions. Even simple pulsatile flow can result in magnitude and phase signal variations that are a complex function of time. These temporal changes can cause spatial misregistration of pulsatile flow in images. Venous flow is much less pulsatile than arterial flow. Flow velocities in the human body under normal conditions range from a few mm/s up to 180 cm/s. The phase dispersion among spins having the same constant velocities can be recovered with addition of the gradient waveform lobes known as “flow compensation” or “first-order gradient moment nulling.” If the spins are flowing through a gradient m(G), the time-dependent phase of flowing spins (f) at the location r (2.9) is given by f (t ) = ∫ g G (t ) × r (t )dt a f (t ) = r0 × ∫ g G (t )dt + v × ∫ g G (t )tdt + ∫ g G (t )t 2 dt + 2 a f (t ) = r0 × g × m 0 + v × g × m1 + × g × m2 + (2.9) 2
where the expansion is obtained from a Taylor series expansion of r(t), r0 is the initial location of the spins, v is the velocity, a is an acceleration of the flow, and mj is the jth moment of the gradient. Equation (2.9) demonstrates that the behavior of the phase accumulated by the moving spins depends on the initial position, velocity, and gradient strength. If the velocity of each flowing spin is not constant, the phase accumulated after gradient application is not the same for each spin and varies with the velocity. This phase dispersion, if uncorrected, results in signal loss. To illustrate the effects of velocity on signal phase, an example of RF and gradient waveforms for a conventional SPGR sequence is shown in Fig. 2.3a. Slice selection (SS) is performed by the RF pulse in conjunction with the slice
2
Time-of-Flight Angiography
43
Fig. 2.3 3D SPGR pulse sequence for TOF acquisition without flow compensation (a) and with flow compensation in the slice selection and readout direction indicated by black arrows (b). The abbreviations
correspond to data acquisition (ADC), RF pulse (RF), readout (RO) gradient, phase-encoding (PE) gradient, and slice selection (SS) gradient
selection z gradient. The amplitude of the slice selection gradient is determined by the desired slice or slab thickness and the bandwidth of the RF pulse. A refocusing lobe is placed after the end of the RF pulse to compensate for the phase dispersion that occurs after the effective tipping of the magnetization into the transverse plane. The readout (RO) gradient, Gx, that is applied immediately after the RF pulse includes a dephasing lobe prior to signal acquisition so that the received signal is completely in phase at the time, TE, from the RF excitation. The amplitude of the readout gradient is determined by the desired resolution and the readout sampling bandwidth. Finally, a small gradient pulse is applied to the y gradient to create a variation in phase in the y direction during signal readout. This pulse sequence is repeated and the y gradient is stepped through values from a negative maximum to positive maximum. The SPGR works well for stationary tissues. The zeroth moment, m0, of both the slice selection and readout gradients is zero at the echo time, TE. The maximum signal occurs for the pulse sequence step, where the y phase-encoding gradient passes through the value, 0. At the time, TE, for this signal measurement, defined as the center of k-space, the stationary spins are completely in phase across the imaging volume. For the signal acquired when the y phase-encoding gradient has zero amplitude, all moments of the y gradient are zero. However, m1 and the higher gradient moments for the slice selection and readout gradients are not zero at time, TE. Thus, moving spins experience an additional phase shift due to motion during these gradients. Velocity dispersion due to laminar flow results in phase dispersion within a voxel and a net signal loss from flowing spins. Velocity-dependent phase dispersion can be corrected by a process known as velocity compensation or first-order gradient moment nulling (Fig. 2.3b). This is accomplished by adding additional area, positive and negative, to the gradient pulses used for to the slice selection and readout.
The magnitude of the lobes can then be adjusted to ensure that the moments of the waveform, when integrated over time, do not contribute to the velocity-dependent phase dispersion. In other words, flow compensation gradients “null” or zero the effects of phase dispersion. The amplitudes of the two compensation gradient lobes for each gradient are adjusted to null m0 and m1 at the times t = 0 and t = TE, respectively. In this manner, the phase of stationary and uniformly flowing spins is the same, independent of the velocity of flow velocity. An additional artifact can occur because of the difference in timing between the phase-encoding and readout gradients. If the time of the phase-encoding gradient is TP, there will be a position shift of v*(TE − TP) between the time the “y” coordinate is encoded and the “x” coordinate. Because the image is assumed to be recorded at time, TE, the blood may appear shifted from its actual position at that moment. When the flow is in the readout or phase-encoding direction, the shifted fluid appears to remain within the blood vessel. However, when the flow is diagonal within the readout and phase-encoding plane, the element of fluid appears to shift away from the vessel center with a distance of shift that is proportional to the flow velocity. If the flow is pulsatile, this shift will appear to change in size during the pulse sequence, resulting in blurring and ghosting artifacts. Such artifacts are often seen in the phase-encoding direction originating from the diagonal vessels in the circle of Willis. This last artifact can be eliminated by recognizing that the shift is due to a nonzero, velocity-dependent first moment of the phaseencoding gradient. By adding another lobe to the phaseencoding gradient, it is possible to step m0 through the values needed for imaging while at the same time nulling m1 at the time, TE. In 3D TOF, the rephrasing z gradient is usually used as a slice selection phase-encoding gradient. If first-order phase-encoding flow compensation is desired, both extra lobes on the z gradient can be stepped to achieve the desired m0 while maintaining a zero m1 at the time, TE.
44
Due to the additional lobes on the gradient waveforms, the minimum TE is increased. Spins experiencing higher orders of motion, such as constant acceleration, are not compensated by this technique. Acceleration terms, corresponding to the m2 moment, occur when flow is pulsatile or changes direction and in this case, some artifacts or signal loss can occur. Usually, this acceleration-caused signal loss is generally quite small and higher order flow compensation is usually not performed. However, it is possible to compensate for phase dispersion induced by constant acceleration by adding an additional lobe to the flow-compensating gradients. This is called second-order gradient motion rephasing or second-order gradient moment nulling, which compensates for constant acceleration. Changes in the rate of acceleration are described as jerk. Jerk can be compensated by third-order gradient moment nulling or third-order gradient motion rephasing with the addition of yet another lobe to the flow-compensating gradients. Signal loss due to these higher order terms is usually much smaller than the loss that would occur from the longer TE required to implement them such that most flow compensation techniques currently in use only compensate for first-order effects from constant velocity flow. If the TE of the pulse sequence can be made very short, all gradient moments will be small and there is no need for flow compensation. Thus, the phase dispersion in an ultrashort echo time sequence, such as a 3D radial acquisition technique, which requires no slice selection gradients and no readout prephasing, is minimal and there is no need for additional flow compensation [11].
S.-E. Kim and D.L. Parker
Flow-related enhancement can be reduced by the saturation of signal from the flowing spins, which depends on the number of pulses experienced by the blood, repetition rate, and blood T1 recovery time, and by intarvoxel phase dispersion.
Saturation effects are important in the setting of slow or in-plane flow, and can be minimized by using thinner slices and relatively long TR. Thus, 2D TOF [12] has the advantage in the setting of slow flow and is often the technique of choice for venous imaging. 2D TOF is also used in evaluation of cervical carotid stenosis to detect slow flow distal to a high-grade stenosis [13]. In 2D TOF imaging, a gradient echo sequence, usually 2D SPGR, is used to sequentially acquire a set of adjacent thin slices, generally 1–3-mm thick. TR, in a range of 20–30 ms, is used with a flip angle of 50–70°. If the velocity of flow is close to the critical velocity of 3–15 cm/s, as given in (2.1), the fluid in each slice experiences only a few RF pulses. The simulation shown in Fig. 2.2 demonstrates that the flow enhancement effect is maximized for flip angle in a range of 50–70°. The short TR and higher flip angle result in enhancement of the contrast between blood and background tissue, as there is insufficient time for longitudinal (T1) recovery of the static tissue magnetization and blood flowing into the slice is exposed to only one or two RF pulses for typical arterial velocities of 10–100 cm/s. The imaging plane is generally selected to be perpendicular to the flow direction, such as the axial plane for the carotid arteries. If arterial flow is principally along one axis and venous returns in the opposite direction (such as in the neck, with flow to the brain via the carotid arteries and return via the jugular veins), slice-selective saturation pulses can be used to eliminate the signal from flow in one direction. For example, to eliminate the signal from the jugular veins, a saturation RF pulse is applied superior to the axial slice (Fig. 2.4). To maintain saturation during the acquisition of all slices, this saturation pulse moves together with the axial slice as each subsequent slice is acquired. Blood flowing in the craniocaudal direction in the jugular vein is, thus, saturated before it flows into the imaging slice and produces no signal. Because the saturation pulse distinguishes arteries from veins only by the direction of blood flow, retrograde flow can result in the unwanted saturation of the desired vessel.
Fig. 2.4 Coronal MIP images of a 2D TOF acquisition of a healthy volunteer using the same acquisition parameters as Fig. 2.3. Coronal MIP image with no spatial saturation pulse (a) and with saturation pulse
superior to the imaging slices to suppress the venous signal (b) (images courtesy of Dr. Tae-Sub Chung, Gangnam Severance Hospital, Seoul, Korea)
2D TOF
2
Time-of-Flight Angiography
45
Fig. 2.5 2D TOF acquisition of a patient volunteer with atherosclerosis with TR = 28 ms, TE = 6.7 ms, flip angle = 50° , FOV = 16 cm, matrix = 256 × 256, slice thickness = 3 mm with 20% gap between slices.
(a) Coronal MIP; (b) axial source images; (c) 2D black blood T1w images
Transverse (axial) images acquired using 2D TOF in a patient with several severe stenoses just distal to the left and right bifurcation are shown in Fig. 2.5. Black blood 2D T1weighted images (Fig. 2.5c) confirm that atherosclerotic plaque caused the stenosis seen in 2D TOF. Figure 2.5a is obtained as the MIP through the “stack” of acquired image (Fig. 2.5b). Note that MIP images are not true angiograms but rather a projection produced from the source images. Any tissue with a short T1 relaxation time such as fat, depending on the exact scan technique used, may be hyperintense in the source images and thus on MIP images they may be potentially confused for flow. Further, the MIP image can be artifactual because only the brightest point along a projection line appears in the MIP image. It is possible that pathology or other important image details are masked behind brighter structures in the MIP image. Thus, when interpreting scans, it is important to review both the MIP and source images. The latter provide a means of assessing surrounding tissues and anatomy and often make identification of artifacts due to motion, signal loss, and the presence of fat easier. Pulsation and vessel motion induced by pulsation can cause artifacts in 2D TOF imaging. Flow compensation in the slice selection and frequency direction is helpful to reduce the inconsistent phase generated by pulsation [14]. Cardiac triggering can further reduce the artifact induced by pulsation. Fractional echo readout and a tailored excitation RF pulse are used to reduce the TE, since a shorter TE reduces the artifact induced by pulsation. Another drawback of 2D TOF is that complex flow, such as that seen distal to a stenosis, can have high-order motions (acceleration, jerk, etc.) and is not easily compensated for and can result in signal loss. Complex flow patterns specifically lead to signal loss in the region of a stenotic lesion and, thus, overestimation of the degree of stenosis. Although the slice thickness of
2D TOF sequences is usually less than 2 mm, 3D acquisitions can be used to produce images with thinner slices, which, together with the use of shorter TE, reduce the artifactual signal loss [15].
3D TOF Having intrinsically higher resolution and shorter echo times than 2D TOF, 3D TOF sequences suffer less from intravoxel phase dispersion. In 3D TOF imaging, a single slab of 3D slices is acquired. Like 2D TOF imaging, the slab is oriented to be perpendicular to the direction of flowing blood to ensure good inflow enhancement. SNR and the contrast between in-flowing blood and tissue in 3D TOF depend on the slab thickness and number of slices per slab. The transverse plane is often selected for a carotid or an intracranial 3D TOF acquisition to maximize the inflow enhancement effect; however, an oblique slab orientation is sometimes used, depending on the vessel geometry, to allow the desired imaging volume to be covered with fewer slices, which results in a shorter scan time. In 3D TOF acquisition, the blood inside the imaging slab generally experiences multiple RF pulses, so a smaller flip angle compared to that in 2D TOF is used to maximize the inflow enhancement effect. Further, spatial saturation is not usually applied in 3D TOF. Although spatial saturation could be applied in 3D TOF acquisition, it would increase the minimum TR and the venous signal in 3D TOF is already suppressed, except on a few entry slices, by the slow venous flow and thicker slab. Short TRs (~20 ms) in 3D TOF also result in reduced contrast between flowing and stationary tissue, including muscle and fat, which generally have a short T1 relaxation time compared with blood. Magnetization
46
S.-E. Kim and D.L. Parker
Fig. 2.6 (a) Schematic representation of TONE pulse. The flip angle of the TONE pulse increases as a function of distance in order to equalize the signal from flowing blood (indicated by arrow). (b) Coronal and sagittal MIP of 3D TOF acquisition of a volunteer at
1.5 T with and without TONE technique. The MIP image constructed with TONE shows the uniform vessel signal around edge (images courtesy of Dr. Tae-Sub Chung, Gangnam Severance Hospital, Seoul, Korea)
transfer is often used in 3D TOF to suppress the signal from the stationary tissue and to increase further the contrast between the flow and tissue. To minimize artifacts induced by turbulent or pulsatile flow, the echo time in 3D TOF is made as short as possible. Fractional echo readout and a short duration or asymmetric RF excitation pulse are used to achieve the shortest possible echo time. For situations where the signal from lipid can be a problem, an echo time can be selected, where the signal from lipid and water is out of phase, yielding better contrast between the two at the expense of a slight increase in problems due to the longer echo time. This out-of-phase echo time varies with the magnet field strength. When imaging with a thick 3D slab, the number of pulses experienced by the blood increases with distance into the slab. RF excitation that is uniform across the 3D slab results in greater inflow enhancement where the blood enters the slab, whereas distal slices in which blood has experienced
more RF pulses experience less flow enhancement signal. To compensate for the resulting variation in signal saturation, it has been found useful to make the RF excitation tip angle be a function of distance into the slab. For example, ramped RF excitation, where the tip angle is small at the slab entrance and increases with distance into the slab, is commonly used for 3D TOF to make the flowing blood signal across the imaging slab as uniform as possible [6, 16]. Ramped RF pulses, with spatially varying flip angle profiles parallel to the direction of flow, are often called tilted optimized nonsaturating excitation (TONE) pulses (Fig. 2.6). A variety of different flow compensation strategies are used in 3D TOF. Generally, flow compensation on the readout and slab selection gradient is used. In this case, the individual phase-encoding steps in the slice and phase-encoding gradient are not compensated. As described above, phaseencoding flow compensation can be used to compensate each step of both phase-encoding gradient waveforms. Although,
2
Time-of-Flight Angiography
47
Fig. 2.8 Axial MIP of 3D TOF acquisition of a healthy volunteer at 3.0 T (a) with linear view order and (b) with centric view order. Notice that the ghost artifact caused by pulsatile flow that propagates in the primary phase-encoding direction is reduced when centric view order is used
Fig. 2.7 Images obtained from four types of acquisition, from top to bottom. a–b, linear view ordering with (a) slice selection/frequencyencoding flow compensation and (b) three-directional flow compensation (3DFC). c–d, centric view ordering with (c) slice selection/ frequency-encoding flow compensation and (d) 3DFC. The cross-hatch artifacts arising from blood flow pulsations in the source images and other vessels near the circle of Willis are clearly evident in the two images in the top row. The artifacts are reduced by both 3DFC (second row of axial images) and centric view ordering acquisition order (third row), and the greatest reduction is observed when 3DFC is combined with centric view ordering acquisition (bottom row). More importantly, from the MIP images (right column), we note the change in apparent lumen diameter of the M1 segment (arrow) when using 3DFC. Without 3DFC, the obliquely oriented vessels have bright rims that are consistent with distortion or signal “pileup” (from Parker et al. [17], with permission)
compensation [20–22]. Ultrashort TE pulse sequences are also useful for scanning the brain in the presence of a metal clip or stent. In a 3D TOF acquisition, the order of k-space acquisition can be rearranged to reduce the prominence of artifacts induced by pulsatile flow (Fig. 2.8). A linear view order acquisition generally causes ghosts that are dominant along the phase-encoding direction [23]. An elliptical centric view order acquisition, which acquires the centric k-space first, spreads the ghosts evenly in the phase- and slice-encoding directions.
such phase-encoding flow compensation generally results in an increased echo time, it has the advantage of eliminating the misregistration artifact if blood is flowing obliquely to the frequency-encoding and one or both of the phase-encoding gradients (Fig. 2.7) [17]. To reduce the echo time in highresolution 3D TOF acquisition with three-direction flow compensation, a variable TE technique has been introduced [18, 19]. A variable TE technique in 3D TOF with threedirection flow compensation can minimize the TE at the center of k space. In this technique, k space of the 3D TOF is divided into several segments with different TE. Flowcompensation gradient lobes are calculated for each segment and the echo time at each segment is minimized. This results in a shorter echo time at the center of k space and a reduced flow-related signal void due to long echo times.
3D TOF with magnetization transfer has been employed for intracranial MRA to suppress the signal intensity of background brain tissue [24]. An MT pulse is a spectrally selective RF pulse that reduces the signal from tissue that has higher amounts of large molecules. Water molecules that are in contact with macromolecules generally move slowly and have a broad NMR resonance. Off-resonant excitation can saturate the magnetization on these water molecules. When these water molecules exchange with free water, the net magnetization in the tissue is reduced. Because blood has a lower concentration of macromolecules, off-resonance MT pulses can be used to selectively saturate the magnetization in station tissues with minimal effect on blood magnetization. In 3D TOF, MT is used to suppress the signal intensity of the brain parenchyma while leaving the signal from blood unaffected, thus improving smaller vessel visibility. Figure 2.9 shows a comparison of intracranial 3D TOF images acquired without and with the inclusion of MT pulses. An MT RF pulse generally requires a long pulse duration and higher RF power. Thus, MT pulse application causes increased TR and further increases the already long scan time of high-resolution 3D TOF acquisition. To increase the time
k-Space Sampling Strategies 3D MRA acquired using ultrashort TE sequences, such as projection or spiral acquisition, gives a minimal artifact from phase dispersion of flow across a voxel, even without flow
Magnetization Transfer
48
S.-E. Kim and D.L. Parker
Fig. 2.9 Axial MIP of 3D TOF acquisition of a volunteer at 1.5 T (a) without MT saturation and (b) with MT saturation. Notice that MIP with MT saturation demonstrates more small, distal, middle cerebral arteries’ detections (images courtesy of Dr. Tae-Sub Chung, Gangnam Severance Hospital, Seoul, Korea)
efficiency in 3D TOF, the majority of the MT effect is obtained by applying the MT pulses only around the center of k-space [25]. The use of MT saturation at high field strength becomes problematic because the SAR increases with the square of the RF transmission frequency, which is proportional to the main magnetic field strength. For this reason, MT saturation in TOF has been utilized only at 1.5 or 3.0 T. Because of the chemical shift between the fat and water, there is a small (3 ppm) difference in Larmor frequency between fat and water resonances, and a TE-dependent phase shift in their signal contributions to a given voxel. Choosing a TE at which fat and water are outphase can provide some fat suppression. However, the TE, where water and fat are out of phase, is greater than the minimum TE achieved by the pulse sequence and further increases the signal loss induced by intravoxel phase dispersion. As a general rule, the TE should be minimized at the cost of other considerations because of the rapid increase in intravoxel diphase dispersion that accompanies increased TE.
Multiple Overlapping Thin 3D Slab Acquisition 3D TOF MRA is susceptible to signal loss due to saturation of the moving spins in thick slabs. To reduce flow signal saturation while retaining the high spatial resolution, short echo times, and some of the SNR advantages of 3D techniques, a sequential acquisition of multiple 3D slabs has been developed. MOTSA has all the advantages of the single-volume 3D TOF techniques, and the use of overlapping thin slabs generally overcomes the problem of spin saturation. MOTSA is currently one of the most popular clinical 3D TOF applications [4]. This popularity is due in part to stronger in-flow enhancement and better vessel contrast-tonoise ratio properties of MOTSA compared to other techniques. Multiple thin slab acquisition reduces the signal saturation of slowly flowing blood compared to one thick single-slab acquisition, and overlapping slab acquisition
Fig. 2.10 Schematic representation of a MOTSA acquisition with three slabs and eight slices per slab. There are three overlap slices at each boundary between slabs
eliminates the signal void from each slab boundary region – often called the venetian blind artifact. The slices located in the overlapped region can be acquired twice with an entry slice from the first slab and an exit slice from the next slab [26]. This technique moderates the variation of the final MIP image intensity after taking the maximum of two images using a pixel-by-pixel comparison. Increasing the amount of slab overlap can obviously reduce the slab boundary artifact. Using a slab overlap of 50% can almost completely eliminate the artifact (Fig. 2.10). However, increasing overlap also increases the scan time per unit coverage in the slice direction. A sliding interleaved ky (SLINKY) sequence was proposed as an alternative technique to reduce the slab boundary artifact in multiple slab acquisition [27]. In a typical MOSTA data acquisition, the slab excitation is shifted
2
Time-of-Flight Angiography
after acquisition of all of ky and kz phase encodings. In SLINKY acquisition, the slab excitation is sliding every few views by one slab location. A designated partial set of the ky phase-encoding steps are collected and the acquisition of the partial set of the ky space is interleaved during continuous sliding of a slab along the slice selection direction [28]. SLINKY equalizes the flow enhancement effect across the entire slab dimension and eliminates the slab boundary artifacts while retaining good acquisition time efficiency compared with conventional MOTSA.
49
the extended scan time needed for phase encoding of the larger matrix is not clinically feasible. Parallel imaging (PI) techniques can accelerate scans at the cost of SNR and, thus, can achieve very-high-resolution MRA studies within a reasonable scan time [31]. For example, optimized coils coupled with PI techniques at 3.0 T can yield scan times similar to or shorter than those at 1.5 T. On this basis, intracranial TOF image quality improvements have previously been described in the transition from 1.5 to 3 T and 3 to even 7 T [32].
Summary TOF at High Magnetic Fields 3D TOF MRA is considered to be a safe, fully noninvasive imaging procedure with submillimeter spatial resolution. As such, it is routinely used to screen for cerebrovascular diseases, such as aneurysms and arteriovenous malformations. However, more subtle microvascular disease usually cannot be seen with the resolution capabilities of standard field strength MRA. Increased vessel contrast and spatial resolution are highly desirable for more sensitive detection of small aneurysms and vasculitis and for improved morphological characterization of larger aneurysms. The recent development of ultrahigh-field MRI scanners enables assessment of the cerebral arteries with a spatial resolution previously not achieved with standard MRI scanners. MRA at 7.0 T has shown superior contrast between blood and background tissue mainly because of the increased T1 recovery time of tissues and better suppression of the background signal relative to that of the blood vessels [29]. The increased SNR also yields improved visualization of the microvasculature of the human brain at high spatial resolution [30] (Fig. 2.11). However, at very high field strengths, the frequencyencoding dimension is limited by the TE-dependent artifacts of susceptibility-induced dephasing and pulsatile flow, and
In this discussion, we have presented a general overview of the basics of TOF MRA and provided discussion of the various trade-offs in image acquisition. Many of the concepts of TOF MRA were developed in the late 1980s and early 1990s, and hence are very mature. However, improvements in MRI techniques and technology have also led to progress in TOF MRA. These improvements include improved gradient capabilities, higher magnetic field strength, increased number and quality of RF channels and components, and new pulse sequences and acquisition techniques. In the past 20 years, gradient performance has increased from 1 mT/m and 20 T/m/s to over 40 mT/m and 200 T/m/s. Field strength in clinically used MRI scanners has now reached 3 T, and work is being performed at 7 T. The number of receiver channels has increased from 1 to as many as 128 on commercially available scanners, allowing the design of receiver coil arrays with more elements to allow parallel imaging to reduce image acquisition time and thereby reduce motion artifacts. Finally, new pulse sequences, including 3D radial acquisition, PROPELLER, and many others, have increased the flexibility available for novel TOF MRA techniques. Thus, as it is with many fields of MRI, TOF MRA continues to evolve in capability and ultimate utility.
Fig. 2.11 TOF MRA acquired at 7 T with a custom-built transmit/ receive head coil with eight stripline elements. TR/TE 21/3.4 ms; flip angle 40°; bandwidth 303 Hz/pixel; resolution 0.6 × 0.5 × 0.6 mm3 (noninterpolated); acquisition time 5 min 58 s; parallel imaging with
GRAPPA, reduction factor 2, 40 reference lines. The high spatial resolution enables nice depiction of fine, peripheral vessels (images courtesy of Mark Ladd of the Erwin L. Hahn Institute for MRI, Essen, Germany)
50
References 1. Suryan G. A time-of-flight method. Proc Indian Acad Sci Sect. 1959;A33:107. 2. Hinshaw WS, Bottomley PA, Holland GN. Radiographic thin section image of the human wrist by nuclear magnetic resonance. Nature. 1977;270:272–273. 3. Laub G. Displays for MR angiography. Magn Reson Med. 1990;14:222–229. 4. Parker DL, Yuan C, Blatter DD. MR angiography by multiple thin slab 3D acquisition. Magn Reson Med. 1991;17:434–451. 5. Davis WL, Warnock SH, Harnsberger HR, Parker DL, Chen CX. Intracranial MRA: single volume vs. multiple thin slab 3D time-offlight acquisition. J Comput Assist Tomogr. 1993;17:15–21. 6. Atkinson D, Brant-Zawadzki M, Gillan G, Purdy D, Laub G. Improved MR angiography: magnetization transfer suppression with variable flip angle excitation and increased resolution. Radiology. 1994;190:890–894. 7. Axel L, Shimakawa A, MacFall J. A time-of-flight method of measuring flow velocity by magnetic resonance imaging. Magn Reson Imaging. 1986;4:199–205. 8. Gullberg GT, Wehrli FW, Shimakawa A, Simons MA. MR vascular imaging with a fast gradient refocusing pulse sequence and reformatted images from transaxial sections. Radiology. 1987;165: 241–246. 9. Nishimura DG. Time-of-flight MR angiography. Magn Reson Med. 1990;14:194–201. 10. Vlaardingerbroek, MT, den Boer JA. Magnetic Resonance Imaging: Theory and Practice. Springer Verlag Telos; 1996:191–204. 11. Nielsen HT, Gold GE, Olcott EW, Pauly JM, Nishimura DG. Ultrashort echo-time 2D time-of-flight MR angiography using a halfpulse excitation. Magn Reson Med. 1999;41:591–599. 12. Keller PJ, Drayer BP, Fram EK, Williams KD, Dumoulin CL, Souza SP. MR angiography with two-dimensional acquisition and threedimensional display. Work in progress. Radiology. 1989;173: 527–532. 13. Heiserman JE, Drayer BP, Fram EK, et al. Carotid artery stenosis: clinical efficacy of two-dimensional time-of-flight MR angiography. Radiology. 1992;182:761–768. 14. Urchuk SN, Plewes DB. Mechanisms of flow-induced signal loss in MR angiography. J Magn Reson Imaging. 1992;2:453–462. 15. Keller PJ. Magnetic resonance angiography of the neck. Technical issues. Neuroimaging Clin N Am. 1996; 6:853–861. 16. Priatna A, Paschal CB. Variable-angle uniform signal excitation (VUSE) for three-dimensional time-of-flight MR angiography. J Magn Reson Imaging. 1995;5:421–427. 17. Parker DL, Goodrick KC, Roberts JA, et al. The need for phaseencoding flow compensation in high-resolution intracranial magnetic resonance angiography. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2003;18: 121–127.
S.-E. Kim and D.L. Parker 18. Song HK, Wehrli FW. Variable TE gradient and spin echo sequences for in vivo MR microscopy of short T2 species. Magn Reson Med. 1998;39:251–258. 19. Jeong EK, Parker DL, Tsuruda JS, Won JY. Reduction of flowrelated signal loss in flow-compensated 3D TOF MR angiography, using variable echo time (3D TOF-VTE). Magn Reson Med. 2002;48:667–676. 20. Schmalbrock P, Yuan C, Chakeres DW, Kohli J, Pelc NJ. Volume MR angiography: methods to achieve very short echo times. Radiology. 1990;175:861–865. 21. Glover GH, Lee AT. Motion artifacts in fMRI: comparison of 2DFT with PR and spiral scan methods. Magn Reson Med. 1995;33: 624–635. 22. Glover GH, Pauly MJ. Projection reconstruction techniques for reduction of motion effects in MRI. Magn Reson Med. 1992; 28:275–289. 23. Wilman AH, Riederer SJ, King BF, et al. Fluoroscopically triggered contrast-enhanced three-dimensional MR angiography with elliptical centric view order: application to the renal arteries. Radiology. 1997;205:137–146. 24. Dagirmanjian A, Ross JS, Obuchowski N, et al. High resolution, magnetization transfer saturation, variable flip angle, time-of-flight MRA in the detection of intracranial vascular stenoses. J Comput Assist Tomogr. 1995;19:700–706. 25. Parker DL, Buswell HR, Goodrich KC, Alexander AL, Keck N, Tsuruda JS. The application of magnetization transfer to MR angiography with reduced total power. Magn Reson Med. 1995;34: 283–286. 26. Blatter DD, Bahr AL, Parker DL, et al. Cervical carotid MR angiography with multiple overlapping thin-slab acquisition: comparison with conventional angiography. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1993;161:1269–1277. 27. Liu K, Rutt BK. Sliding interleaved kY (SLINKY) acquisition: a novel 3D MRA technique with suppressed slab boundary artifact. J Magn Reson Imaging. 1998;8:903–911. 28. Liu K, Lee DH, Rutt BK. Systematic assessment and evaluation of sliding interleaved kY (SLINKY) acquisition for 3D MRA. J Magn Reson Imaging. 1998;8:912–923. 29. Kang CK, Park CW, Han JY, et al. Imaging and analysis of lenticulostriate arteries using 7.0-Tesla magnetic resonance angiography. Magn Reson Med. 2009;61:136–144. 30. Kang CK, Hong SM, Han JY, et al. Evaluation of MR angiography at 7.0 Tesla MRI using birdcage radio frequency coils with end caps. Magn Reson Med. 2008;60:330–338. 31. von Morze C, Purcell DD, Banerjee S, et al. High-resolution intracranial MRA at 7T using autocalibrating parallel imaging: initial experience in vascular disease patients. Magn Reson Imaging. 2008;26:1329–1333. 32. von Morze C, Xu D, Purcell DD, et al. Intracranial time-of-flight MR angiography at 7T with comparison to 3T. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2007;26:900–904.
3
Phase-Contrast MRI and Flow Quantification Bernd Jung and Michael Markl
Introduction Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) techniques provide noninvasive methods for the accurate depiction of the vascular morphology and anatomy. In addition, the intrinsic motion sensitivity of MRI can be used to image vessels as in phasecontrast (PC) MR-angiography or to directly acquire and quantify blood flow [1–5]. Such techniques offer the unique possibility to acquire spatially registered functional information simultaneously with the morphological data within a single examination. Visualization and quantification of blood flow and tissue motion using PC MRI has been widely used in a number of applications. Characterization of the dynamic components of blood flow and cardiovascular function provide insight into normal and pathological cardiovascular physiology and are part of imaging protocols in daily clinical routine. In addition, the same underlying principles can be exploited to evaluate other dynamic processes in the human body such as CSF flow [6] or the cyclic wall motion of the heart [7].
ECG-triggered blood flow measurements as presented in 1986 by Nayler et al. [1]. The basic principle of PC MRI relies on the fact that the MR signal is inherently a vector quantity as illustrated in Fig. 3.1. The MR signal can thus be characterized not only by its magnitude but also by its phase f. As a consequence, a phase image can be reconstructed from any acquired MR data set in addition to the typical magnitude image reflecting the underlying anatomy. The MR-signal phase is affected by motion, which can be used to image vessels as in PC MR-angiography but also to quantify blood flow and motion of tissue. In the presence of a magnetic field gradient, the MR signal originating from a moving object presents with an additional signal phase, which is directly proportional to the velocity of the moving object. The measurement of MR signal phase, therefore, allows for motion quantification of the moving spins. The time-evolution of the MR-signal phase of the transversal magnetization of an object at the location r(t) can be derived from the spatial dependent Larmor frequency (3.1). w L (r , t ) = g ( B0 + Δ B0 (r ) + r (t )G(t )).
(3.1)
Basic Principle of Phase-Contrast MRI The development of PC MRI initiated in the pre-MR imaging area with the first observation of coherent motion on the MR signal phase reported in 1954 by Carr and Purcell [8]. The basic concept was further developed for by Hahn who proposed to exploit the sensitivity of the MR signal phase to flow or motion for the measurement of sea water motion [9]. With the advent of MR imaging in the 1980s, the theory of phase velocity imaging was first described in 1982 [10] followed by first the presentation of MR velocity map images [11, 12] and clinical applications based on time-resolved B. Jung, PhD () • M. Markl, PhD Department of Radiology, Medical Physics, University Hospital Freiburg, Freiburg, Germany e-mail:
[email protected]
In this equation, B0 denotes the static main magnetic field, DB0 reflects contributions by local field inhomogeneities, and G(t) is the time-dependent magnetic field gradient. The resulting signal phase f acquired at echo time TE can be derived by integrating the Larmor equation resulting in the following (3.2): TE f (r ,TE) = f0 (r ) + g ∫ G(t )r (t )dt. t0
(3.2)
In this equation, the initial signal phase and the effects of field inhomogeneities are combined in the spatially dependent and typically unknown background phase f0(r). To evaluate the effect of flow or motion on the signal phase, the spatial location of a moving object or flowing spins can be approximated in first order as r (t ) = r0 + v (t ) with constant
J.C. Carr and T.J. Carroll (eds.), Magnetic Resonance Angiography: Principles and Applications, DOI 10.1007/978-1-4419-1686-0_3, © Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2012
51
52
B. Jung and M. Markl
Fig. 3.1 During an experiment, rf-excitation generates a precessing transverse magnetization vector, which induces the MR signal in a receiver coil surrounding the object under investigation. Following image acquisition anatomical (top right) and phase images (lower right) can be reconstructed from the raw data which reflect the local magnitude and phase of the transverse magnetization
velocity v, i.e., it is implied that tissue motion or blood flow does not change fast with respect to the temporal footprint (TE) of the data acquisition. Equation (3.2) then simplifies to the following (3.3): TE TE f (r ,TE) = f 0(r ) + g r0 ∫ G(t )dt + g v ∫ G(t )tdt t0 t0 = f 0(r ) + g r0 M 0 + g vM1.
(3.3)
In addition to the background phase f0(r) the signal phase measured at TE is determined by the 0th and 1st order gradient moments M0 and M1. For PC-MRI, a bipolar gradient is typically used in order to quantify velocities, i.e., two gradients with identical amplitude G and duration Dt but with opposite polarity of the amplitude (see Fig. 3.2). The symmetry of this gradient scheme results in a vanishing 0th gradient moment M0 = 0. As a result, stationary spins no longer contribute to the signal phase and (3.3) reduces to the following (3.4): f (r ,TE) = f0 (r ) + g vM1 .
(3.4)
The remaining non-zero first gradient moment M1 determines the velocity induced signal phase and moving spins experience an additional contribution in the signal phase which is proportional to the velocity of the moving spins as illustrated in Fig. 3.2. However, the measured signal phase f(r, TE) is still offset by the spatially dependent and unknown background phase f0(r). By subtracting the phase fref(r, TE) of an additionally performed reference scan the background phase can be eliminated. The resulting phase difference Df = f − fref finally yields the velocities of the moving spins (3.5):
Fig. 3.2 Bipolar velocity encoding gradient and temporal evolution of the MR signal phase for stationary spins and an object moving with constant velocity v
Δf . v= g ΔM1
(3.5)
The calculated phase difference Df reflects changes in the MR signal phase associated with the motion component along the direction of the velocity encoding gradient. By adding a bipolar gradient to the MR pulse sequence along the read, phase, or slice direction and by subtracting a reference measurement without encoding gradient, flow or motion along these directions can be directly quantified. Such PC-MRI pulse sequences with single-direction velocity encoding are typically available on all commercial MR systems and permit the reconstruction of the following images (Fig. 3.3): • Magnitude image: the signal intensity represents the MR signal amplitude averaged over the two scans used for one-dimensional velocity encoding. • Complex difference image (flow encoded magnitude image): the signal intensity represents the absolute value of the phase shift and therefore contains no information about the flow direction (e.g., phase shifts of −170° and +170° shows the same pixel intensity). • Phase difference image: the signal intensity represents the phase angle DF between the reference and the motion encoded scan, i.e., the local velocities along the encoding direction. As is evident from (3.5), appropriate control of the first gradient moment (gradient strengths and duration) can be used to control flow or motion encoding. Owing to the 2p periodicity of the MR-signal phase, there exists an upper limit of the velocities that can be encoded using the PC principle. The velocity sensitivity “venc” refers to the maximum
3
Phase-Contrast MRI and Flow Quantification
53
Fig. 3.3 Images that are typically reconstructed from a 2D phase contrast acquisition with through-plane velocity encoding (bipolar encoding gradient along the slice direction). Note that the gray scale intensity for the phase difference image characterizes the motion
direction: the ascending aorta appears white due to the positive blood flow direction (flow foot to head) whereas the descending aorta appears black encoding to (negative) flow in the opposite direction (head to foot)
velocity that can be encoded by the bipolar gradient and is given by the following (3.6): venc =
±π . γΔM1
(3.6)
Thus, the acquisition of moving objects requires the approximate knowledge of the blood flow or tissue velocities. If the first moment of the bipolar encoding gradient is too large, the signal phase can exceed values above ±p. Velocities positively exceeding the preselected venc of the PC-MRI acquisition result in velocity aliasing in the negative velocity range and vice versa. For example, a velocity of 120 cm/s measured with a venc of 100 cm/s will yield a velocity of −80 cm/s in the phase difference image. Figure 3.4 schematically illustrates the velocity aliasing effect for a parabolic flow profile. Figure 3.5 demonstrates the effect of different choices of venc with respect to the highest occurring velocities vmax in an in-vivo situation. No aliasing and a clear positive/negative blood flow velocities in the ascending/descending aorta can be observed with an optimal venc slightly exceeding the highest occurring velocities during peak systole (top left image). Aliasing in a few pixels can be seen in the ascending aorta if venc is chosen slightly smaller than vmax (lower left image). Aliasing in a considerably larger area of both ascending and descending aorta is evident if venc is far below the highest velocities (lower right image). Note also that if venc is chosen much higher than the systolic peak velocities in the aorta, no aliasing occurs but the velocity noise is substantially increased as indicated by the gray color within both ascending and descending aorta (top right image). It can be shown that the velocity noise s linearly increases with an increasing velocity sensitivity venc and is inversely related to the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) in the corresponding magnitude images as follows (3.7) [13].
Fig. 3.4 Velocity aliasing for a parabolic flow profile. If the velocity sensitivity venc is smaller compared to the highest occurring flow velocities aliasing towards inverted velocity values occurs
Fig. 3.5 PC-MRI with through-plane velocity encoding in the ascending and descending aorta. The individual phase difference images show the encoded blood flow velocities during peak systole in the same subject for four different velocity sensitivities (venc)
54
B. Jung and M. Markl
Fig. 3.6 PC gradient echo pulse sequences for one-directional velocity encoding along the slice direction. The gray shaded bipolar velocity encoding gradient is added to a standard gradient echo sequence with
s=
2 venc . p SNR
(3.7)
To avoid velocity aliasing while maintaining a low velocity noise, it is thus important to select the velocity sensitivity higher than the expected vmax but as small as possible to achieve optimal velocity-to-noise performance for velocity quantification.
Phase-Contrast Pulse Sequences Typical applications of PC-MRI for measurement of blood flow in the aorta or cranial vessels are limited in scan time and therefore based on fast gradient echo pulse sequences. PC pulse sequences are formed by adding the bipolar velocity encoding gradient lobes to a gradient echo sequence as illustrated in Fig. 3.6 for velocity encoding along the slice (through-plane) direction. The addition of bipolar gradients for motion encoding prolongs the echo time TE which may cause flow artifacts, especially in the presence of pulsatile flow with rapid changes in velocity across a voxel. Therefore, a flow compensated acquisition (M1 = 0) is often used as the reference scan, i.e., an additional gradient is applied that refocus the MR-signal phase at TE independent from the velocity of moving spins (Fig. 3.6, left). For PC measurements a short echo time TE is desirable to minimize the signal loss due to T2* decay and reduce susceptibility and flow artifacts. However, the addition of bipolar gradients and use of flow compensated gradient waveforms results in relatively long echo times (in the order of 4–10 ms)
flow compensation along the slice direction. For improved performance, the bipolar gradient can be combined with the imaging gradient resulting in more time efficient gradient waveforms and reduced echo time TE
compared to a conventional gradient sequence as used for example used in contrast-enhanced measurements (1–3 ms). Therefore, several methods to reduce TE in PC-MRI have been introduced [14, 15]. One method that is implemented on most modern clinical MR systems utilizes the combination of the gradient waveforms of the reference scan with the bipolar gradients used for motion encoding, i.e., the flow encoding gradients are added onto the imaging gradients as depicted in Fig. 3.6 (right) resulting gradient waveforms with improved time efficiency. A further reduction of TE can be achieved by the implementation of two-sided flow encoding [14]. The difference between the two-sided flow encoding and conventional flow encoding with reference scan and flow encoded scan (also called one-sided flow encoding) is illustrated in Fig. 3.7. For one-sided flow encoding, the reference scan must be acquired with the same TE as the flow encoded scan to allow for a consistent subtraction of the background phase. For twosided flow encoding the moment DM1 of the flow encoding gradient is split in equal parts for both scans. The first scan (“up-case”) encodes the moment DM1/2, the second scan (“down-case”) −DM1/2 such that the difference yields the total encoding moment DM1. The corresponding gradients to encode DM1/2 require considerably a shorter duration and thus permit a noticeable reduction in echo time TE. Note that according to (3.5), the PC principle only permits the encoding and measurement of the motion component along the direction of the bipolar encoding gradient as shown in the pulse sequences described above for velocity encoding along the through-plane direction. To encode velocities along all three spatial dimensions at least four scans have to be acquired: one reference scan and three velocity encoded scans with different bipolar motion
3
Phase-Contrast MRI and Flow Quantification
55
Fig. 3.7 Different encoding strategies for one-directional velocity encoding along the slice direction
encoding gradients along read, phase, and slice direction but otherwise identical acquisition parameters [15]. This property results in relatively long scan times of PC-MRI which is one of the major drawbacks of PC measurements.
Implementation and Clinical Protocols To synchronize flow or motion sensitive measurements with periodic tissue motion or pulsatile flow, data acquisition is synchronized with the cardiac cycle and a k-space segmented pulse sequence scheme is used as illustrated in Fig. 3.8 [16]. The ECG signal is used to gate the MR measurement to consistently capture a series of time frame in the cardiac cycle for each heartbeat. Since the MR acquisition is not sufficiently fast to measure all required data during a single heartbeat, the periodic movements or flow are assessed by
Fig. 3.8 Time-resolved ECG synchronized CINE PC-MRI data acquisitions. One-directional through-plane velocity encoding requires the execution of two differently velocity encoded scan for each raw data line
56
reconstructing images from data acquired over several cardiac cycles. For each heartbeat and time frame, only a subset (NSeg) of all required (Ny) phase encoding steps are measured (k-space segmentation). The procedure is repeated for a different subset until the full raw data set is acquired for all time frames. As a result, time resolved (CINE) images can be derived depicting the dynamics of periodic physiological processes during the cardiac cycle. PC acquisitions can be combined with the CINE principle by successively acquiring the different velocity encoded scans for each raw data line (interleaved velocity encoding) [1, 3–5]. For an n-directionally encoded PC-MRI measurement n + 1 raw data lines have to be acquired for each phase encoding step. For a given repetition time TR and cardiac period of TECG, different imaging protocols can be constructed based on a trade-off between temporal resolution (Dt), spatial resolution (Ny phase encoding lines per slice) and total acquisition time Tacq. The selection of the number of phase encoding lines NSeg then determines the temporal resolution Dt = n TR NSeg and a total scan time Tacq = Ny/NSeg TECG of the PC CINE acquisition. From different PC protocols, 2D CINE PC with throughplane velocity encoding is mostly applied in the clinical routine. For a typical TR on the order of 5–10 ms measurements can be performed with temporal resolutions of up to 10–20 ms. Such PC-MRI protocols can be employed for volume flow measurements through a vessel. It should be noted that the CINE acquisition scheme is based on a periodic cardiac cycle. The regularity of the heart rate is important to ensure that data are consistently acquired for all time frames and heartbeats. An irregular heart rate would result in different entries in the data matrix acquired at different period of the heart cycle and thus induce artifacts. To avoid such inaccuracies, arrhythmia rejection algorithms have been introduced in clinical CINE PC-MRI protocols. Thoracic applications of PC-MRI are affected by breathing motions and should be performed at a constant breathing position to avoid respiration artifacts and errors in velocity encoding. For fast acquisitions, this can be realized by breath holding for the time of the acquisition [17]. However, the duration of the total acquisition is then limited by the breathhold capacity of the subject therewith limiting the spatial and/or temporal resolution of the acquisition. Breath hold is often not feasible for longer acquisitions such as high resolution or multidirectional PC-MRI. One possible remedy is to monitor the breathing pattern by a fast one dimensional MR scan without phase encoding (navigator) positioned at the interface between the liver and lung [18–20]. The large contrast between the liver tissue and air is easily tracked and can be used to detect the breathing position and to gate the data acquisition to the respiration cycle.
B. Jung and M. Markl
Applications of 2D CINE PC-MRI Most MR systems offer imaging protocols permitting both in-plane and through-plane velocity encoding. In-plane velocity mapping can be performed in one or two directions and is mainly used for visualizing flow patterns within the imaging plane such as jets through stenosed vessels or valves. The velocity encoding direction should be parallel to the direction of the flow in the vessel of interest. An in-plane acquisition of a high-velocity jet can be helpful for planning a subsequent through-plane scan on the jet location with maximum velocities, especially for the assessment of mitral or tricuspid valve regurgitation. The most common applications for CINE PC MRI focus on valvular, congenital, and other heart diseases. Flow quantification with through-plane velocity encoding can be used to estimate the fraction of regurgitant flow in case of valve defects or to quantify global cardiac function such a stroke volume and cardiac output [5, 21]. In the presence of pulmonary–systemic shunts, the pulmonary/systemic flow ratio can be determined and used to assess the severity of the disease [22–24]. For the quantification of left or right ventricular stroke volumes, cardiac output and regurgitant fractions throughplane velocity encoding is used and the temporal resolution is chosen such that cardiac cycle is covered by approximately 15–20 time frames. In combination with a spatial resolution of about 1–2 mm, these scans are typically performed during breath-hold. Typical velocity sensitivities are venc = 150 cm/s for aortic flow measurements and venc = 100 cm/s for flow in the pulmonary artery. However, it should be noted that in the case of a valve or vessel stenosis blood flow velocities can reach values of up to 800 cm/s. To avoid velocity aliasing the PC-MRI scan should be repeated using a higher velocity sensitivity venc until the phase aliasing has disappeared to allow for an appropriate flow analysis. Following successful data acquisition, the PC-MR data can be used for flow quantification as illustrated in Fig. 3.9 showing the systolic magnitude and phase difference image in the ascending and descending aorta. Vessel lumen segmentation of the ascending aorta for all time-frames throughout the cardiac cycle can be used to obtain the flow-time curve. In patients with aortic valve insufficiency, a slight backflow due to a mild aortic valve insufficiency can be observed that is not present for normal volunteers. The mild increase of flow after the closing of the aortic valve is caused by a contraction of the aortic wall, called the “Windkessel”-effect. Figure 3.10 shows systolic magnitude and the phase difference images in the ascending aorta at the level of the aortic valve for a patient with an aortic valve stenosis. At peak systole and maximum valve opening, blood flow is confined to a small area compared to the full diameter of the ascending
3
Phase-Contrast MRI and Flow Quantification
Fig. 3.9 Blood flow quantification in the aorta using 2D PC-MRI and through-plane velocity encoding. Left: Following data acquisition, the vessel contours of the ascending aorta (AAo) are identified by lumen segmentation to quantify time-resolved blood flow.
57
Right: Flow-time curves in the ascending aorta above the aortic valve in normal controls and two patients. In patients, the different extent of early diastolic regurgitant flow (arrows) indicates mild aortic valve insufficiency
Fig. 3.10 2D PC-MRI and through-plane velocity encoding in a patient with aortic valve stenosis and a dilated ascending aorta (Ao)
aorta as indicated by the dark color in the phase difference image (arrow). A further clinical application provided by CINE PC-MRI is provided by the evaluation of shunts reflecting defects in the septum of the heart that allow transfer of blood from the arterial to the venous system or vice versa (from the system with the higher to the lower pressure) [23]. To quantify the shunt volume two CINE flow measurements are performed. PC-MRI in the ascending aorta and in the pulmonary artery is used to quantify the left and right ventricular stroke volumes QS and QP, respectively. The ratio QP /QS represents the direction of shunt and the shunt volume. For QP /QS = 1 no shunt is present, if QP /QS > 1 a shunt from the aortic circulation to the pulmonary circulation is present and vice versa for QP /QS < 1.
Phase-Contrast Angiography While most clinical angiographic applications rely on the application of Gd contrast agent, 3D PC MR angiography (PC-MRA) based on velocity encoded 3D MRI with three-
directional encoding has proven to be a useful alternative. PC-MRA can provide detailed information on vascular geometry and may offer additional information on flow direction [25–28]. Several strategies exist for calculating a PC-MR angiogram from the data. A possible combination of velocity and magnitude data is shown in Fig. 3.11. The three-directional encoded PC-MRI data is used to calculate absolute velocities |v| for each image voxel which are additionally weighted by the magnitude images for suppression of background signal. Alternatively, complex difference images can be calculated directly from the raw data – as described above – for each individual velocity encoding direction and combined in a sum of squares sense [25, 26]. It is important to note that the depiction of the vessels is determined by the choice of the velocity sensitivity venc. The maximum intensity projections (MIP) of the cranial vessels in Fig. 3.12 demonstrate the effect of the velocity sensitivity on PC-MRA data. Small vessels with slow flow are more clearly visible using a smaller venc-factor (Fig. 3.12c, d). Larger vessels with higher blood flow velocities demonstrate a decreased signal due to (multiple)
58
B. Jung and M. Markl
Fig. 3.11 Derivation of 3D PC-MRA from PC-MRI data with three-directional velocity encoding and maximum intensity projects of PC-MRA data in the head and thorax
Flow-Sensitive 4D MRI
Fig. 3.12 Influence of the velocity sensitivity (venv) of PC MRA. PC MRA Maximum Intensity Projection (MIP) images acquired with venc’s of 80 (a), 40 (b), 20 (c), and 10 (d) cm/s. High venc images highlight the arterial system. As the venc is decreased the visualization of the high velocity arterial system is compromised, while, the visualization of the veins is improved. This is especially true for the slowflowing veins such as the internal cerebral vein (arrows) (Images courtesy of Kevin Johnson and Oliver Wieben, Departments of Medical Physics and Radiology, University of Wisconsin Madison, USA)
aliasing of the signal phase. For increased venc-factors, the visualization of larger arterial vessels is improved and venous signal is suppressed. The quality of the depicted vessels is best if the chosen flow sensitivity represents the physiological situation of the vessel segment of interest. Most PC-MRA implementations used nongated data acquisition which can result in artifacts for pulsatile blood flow. Further drawbacks of the PC-MRA method are long scan times and lack of respiration control, which limited most applications of 3D PC-MRA to static regions with low pulsatile flow such as the cranial vessels. In this context, new implementations based on time-resolved accelerated acquisitions or radial imaging strategies are promising and provide a considerable improved performance regarding flow artifacts, total scan time, and spatial resolution without the need for contrast agent administration [29, 30].
Traditionally, MRI imaging of flow is accomplished using methods that resolve two spatial dimensions (2D) in individual slices. Alternatively, 3D spatial encoding offers the possibility of isotropic high spatial resolution and thus the ability to measure and visualize the temporal evolution of complex flow and motion patterns in a 3D-volume. In this context, ECG synchronized flow-sensitive 3D MRI using three-directional velocity encoding (also termed “flow-sensitive 4D MRI” or “time-resolved 3D velocity mapping”) can be employed to detect and visualize global and local blood flow characteristics in entire targeted vascular regions (aorta, cranial arteries, carotid arteries, etc.) [31, 32]. For thoracic or abdominal applications, the data acquisition needs to be synchronized with the subject’s respiration. Owing to the acquisition of at least four data sets for three-directional velocity encoding, PC MRI inherits a trade-off between spatial/temporal resolution and total scan time. Nevertheless, a number of studies have reported methodological improvements (parallel imaging, adaptive navigator gating with increased efficiency, time-optimized velocity encoding gradients, etc.) permitting the acquisition of flow-sensitive 4D MRI data within the entire aorta or other arterial systems within reasonable scan times of the order of 10–15 min. For the subsequent analysis and visualization of complex, three-directional blood flow within a 3D volume, various visualization tools including 2D vector-fields, 3D streamlines, and time-resolved 3D particle traces have been proposed [33]. A representative data acquisition and data analysis strategy for the 3D visualization of blood flow characteristics in the thoracic aorta is illustrated in Fig. 3.13. Several groups have reported advances in the application of flow-sensitive 4D MRI including the analysis of blood flow through artificial valves [34], ventricular and atrial flow patterns [35, 36], blood flow characteristics in
3
Phase-Contrast MRI and Flow Quantification
59
Fig. 3.13 (a) Data acquisition and visualization of vascular geometry and 3D hemodynamics for flow-sensitive 4D MRI in the aorta using navigator gating and prospective ECG gating. (b) The resulting raw data comprises information along all 3 spatial dimensions, 3 velocity
directions, and time in the cardiac cycle. (c) 3D blood flow visualization permits the depiction of time-resolved 3D vascular hemodynamics within the entire thoracic aorta
the thoracic aorta [37–39], peripheral vessels [38], carotid arteries [40], large intracranial arteries [41], as well as flow in the pulmonary and venous systems [42]. Figure 3.14 illustrates the potential of the methods to assess, visualize and quantify flow characteristics in different vascular regions in the body. Recent studies indicate the potential of flow-sensitive 4D-MRI for the detailed visualization of complex flow patterns associated with vascular pathologies. The complete coverage of the vascular region of interest permits the assessment of spatial and temporal characteristics of 3D blood flow as shown in Fig. 3.15 for a patient with aortic valve stenosis and a dilatation of the ascending aorta. The disturbed complex flow patterns in the aorta illustrate the effect of the pathological valve function on aortic hemodynamics and may help to improve the understanding of the link between valve dysfunction and aortic dilatation often sees in such patients. Since flow-sensitive 4D MRI data reflects the true underlying time-resolved blood flow velocity vector field, it is possible to quantify the directly measured (e.g., flow rates) or derived parameters such as pressure difference maps [43],
wall sheer stress [44], pulse wave velocity [45], and others. Findings in recently reported studies combining the complete spatiotemporal coverage of flow-sensitive 4D MRI and advanced quantification strategies are promising and may help to define new clinical markers for the improved characterization of cardiovascular disease. Examples include relative pressure mapping within the heart and aorta [46] or renal arteries [27], wall shear stress analysis in the thoracic aorta [47], or assessment of onset and dynamics of regional turbulent kinetic energy in the aorta [48]. A disadvantage of PC MRI is related to the need for multiple acquisitions for encoding a single velocity direction, resulting in long scan times. New methods based on the combination of PC MRI and fast sampling strategies, e.g., radial imaging with 3D PC-VIPR as shown in Fig. 3.16, have been reported and are promising for further reduction in total scan time and/or increased spatial or temporal resolution [29, 49]. In this context, a number of studies have already demonstrated the potential of radial imaging techniques for the assessment of vascular function with increased efficiency compared to conventional methods [27, 50, 51].
60
B. Jung and M. Markl
In addition, the total acquisition time or temporal and spatial resolution associated with a specific MR technique may be further improved by using new spatiotemporal imaging acceleration [52, 53].
Sources of Errors Over the past three decades numerous studies have systematically validated the quantitative and qualitative analysis of blood flow using in-vitro and in-vivo experiments. It has to be noted, however, that there are a number of sources of inaccuracies in PC-MRI, which can results in errors in the measured velocities. The major sources of errors include eddy current effects [54], Maxwell terms [55], and gradient field distortions [56]. Appropriate correction strategies should, thus, be applied to ensure accurate flow quantification using PC-MRI data.
Maxwell Terms
Fig. 3.14 Flow-sensitive 4D MRI in different vascular territories. (a) 3D flow visualization in the large intracranial arteries in the circle of Willis using systolic streamlines. The tortuous routes of the different vascular segments and changes in regional velocities can clearly be appreciated (CCA/ICA/ECA: common/internal/external carotid artery). (b) Time-resolved 3D particle traces during peak flow in the carotid bifurcation. Note the typical helical flow pattern in the ICA bulb. (c) Blow flow characteristics in the distal abdominal aorta (Ao) and peripheral arteries in the left and right leg (IA iliac artery). Quantitative flowtime curves demonstrating typical triphasic pulsatile flow can be derived from the same data as shown for the distal abdominal aorta
It can be shown that, as a consequence of the Maxwell equations, a magnetic field gradient cannot be switched on, without generating additional unwanted nonlinear magnetic fields. These concomitant gradient terms or Maxwell’s terms arise whenever a gradient is activated. They are described by Maxwell’s equations and result in magnetic fields with nonlinear spatial dependences. Concomitant gradient crossterms arise when the longitudinal gradient Gz is activated with a transverse gradient (Gx or Gy). They result in phase errors and hence are affecting the velocity measurements using PC MRI. It is possible to reduce or correct these effects
Fig. 3.15 Flow-sensitive 3D MRI and visualization using systolic 3D streamlines in a patient with aortic stenosis and a dilated ascending aorta (AAo). Note the flow acceleration through the stenotic aor-
tic valve which results in a flow jet directed towards the outer wall of the AAo and considerable vortex formation in a large segment of the AAo
3
Phase-Contrast MRI and Flow Quantification
61
during postprocessing by fitting a polynomial onto the data as described by Bernstein et al. [55]. Corrections can be performed during image reconstruction, based on the knowledge of the gradient waveforms that can be used to derive the correction factors needed for Maxwell term compensation.
reflected in the strength or direction in the first order gradient moments and thus the velocity encoding. Therefore, gradient field distortions can lead to considerable deviations between the designed and the actual encoding in PC-MRI. The true gradient field demonstrates not only deviations from the nominal gradient strength but also from the intended gradient direction and thus affects not only the magnitude of encoded velocities but also velocity encoding direction. Dependent upon the spatial location of the velocity measurements, errors in velocity magnitude can be as high as 60%, while errors in the velocity encoding direction can be up to 45°. The true magnitude and direction of the underlying velocities can be recovered from the phase difference images by a generalized PC velocity reconstruction which requires the measurement of full three-directional velocity information. A generalized reconstruction of velocities can then applied using a matrix formalism that includes relative gradient field deviations derived from a theoretical model of local gradient field nonuniformity. In addition, approximate solutions for the correction of one-directional velocity encoding are available [56]. The gradient field model needed for the corrections is vendor specific and depends on the design on the gradient systems. Significant improvement in velocity quantification can be achieved by using the known field distortions to correct the measured phase shifts. Results of a phantom experiment with one-directional velocity encoding illustrating the effect of gradient field distortions are shown in Fig. 3.17. The relative velocity encoding errors predicted by the gradient field model are illustrated by the surface plot which demonstrates the relative deviations from nominal z-gradient strength a coronal plane transecting the flow phantom in longitudinal direction. Since steady flow was used for all experiments, the true mean through-plane velocities are expected to be constant as a function of spatial location (z) along the tube. The deviation of the measured velocities demonstrates the effect of gradient field nonuniformity and corresponded well to the predicted errors predicted by the gradient field model. Although errors associated with gradient field distortions have been known for some time, corrections for these inaccuracies are to date often not part of the standard image reconstruction process and mostly absent from commercial systems.
Gradient Field Nonlinearities
Eddy Currents
It is well known that nonuniformity in magnetic field gradients can cause significant image warping and require correction. In PC-MRI, these imperfections introduce errors in velocity measurements by affecting the first moments used to encode flow or motion [56, 57]. Any error in strength or direction of the local gradient from its ideal value is directly
Switching of imaging and encoding gradients in PC-MRI results in changes in magnetic flux, thereby inducing eddy currents in the conducting parts of the scanner system (coils) or in the patient. These eddy currents can cause alterations of the desired gradient strengths and duration and thus result in spatially varying phase errors in the MR images [58]. For
Fig. 3.16 PC VIPR is based on spoiled gradient echo sequence with bipolar flow encoding gradients (a) and a true 3D radial trajectory (b). Visualization of the flow conditions obtained with a PC VIPR scan of a 18 month-old male with pulmonary venolobar syndrome. Particle traces in various cardiac phases obtained from the PC VIPR scan from a posterior view (c). The vascular system is color coded in blue (veins) and red (arteries). (d) Atrial defect measured at 1.34 L/min. (e) Analomous Pulmonary Venous Return “Scimitar Vein” Flow – 0.42 L/min. (f) Abnormal Systemic Artery showing flow to the right lung (Images courtesy of Kevin Johnson and Oliver Wieben, Departments of Medical Physics and Radiology, University of Wisconsin Madison, USA)
62
Fig. 3.17 2D PC MRI with one-directional velocity encoding: Demonstration of the effect of gradient field inhomogeneities on velocity encoding. Left: PC-MRI velocity measurements in a tube phantom with constant laminar flow parallel to the direction of the main magnetic field (B0, z). Mid: Simulated and normalized z-gradient fields (left) depict the spatial variation of the relative deviation from the ideal
B. Jung and M. Markl
gradient strength in a coronal plane at the phantom locations. Right: Measured through plane velocities are compared to predicted measurement errors (thick black lines). Since the measured errors are in agreement with predictions, a correction can be performed based on the model of the encoding gradient fields
Fig. 3.19 Schematic illustration of a typical correction scheme for PC-MRI data. While Maxell and gradient field corrections can be automatically performed during image reconstruction, eddy current effects often require user interaction to identify regions for phase offset estimation (see also Fig. 3.18)
Fig. 3.18 Image-based eddy current correction of 2D PC-MRI data. The application of bipolar velocity encoding gradients can results in eddy current induced phase shifts as illustrated for a static phantom demonstrating which should ideally include constant and zero phase differences inside the entire object. The phase difference gradient is a result of spatially dependent eddy current induced phase offsets. For in-vivo PC-MRI (right) eddy current effects can be corrected by subtracting eddy current offsets estimated from regions of interest in static tissue
PC-MRI, the different gradient waveforms that are used for the subsequent velocity encodes lead to different eddy current induced phase changes in the phase images of each velocity encoded acquisition. As a result, subtraction of phase images does not eliminate errors related eddy currents and additional data processing is needed to restore the original velocity encoded signal phase. Several correction strategies have been proposed and are typically based on the subtraction of an estimation of the spatially varying eddy current induced phases changes. The spatial variation of the phase difference in regions containing static tissue is used to calculate the eddy current induced offset for the entire image. By fitting a plane or higher order polynomial to the phase difference data, the phase offset characteristics can be estimated and subsequently used to correct the entire image by subtraction (see Fig. 3.18) [54].
Compensation for Maxwell terms and for gradient field nonlinearities do typically not require user interaction. Maxwell corrections can be performed during image reconstruction, based on the knowledge of the gradient waveforms in the PC-MRI pulse sequence used for data acquisition. Similarly, gradient field models describing deviations between the designed and the actual velocity encoding gradients can be employed to automatically correct for gradient field nonlinearities during image reconstruction. For eddy current correction, automatic correction algorithms have been reported. However, for a reliable estimation of background offsets, user inter action may often be required to correctly identify static background signal (Fig. 3.19). It is of note that it is common to all sources of inaccuracies, that error in velocity encoding strength increase with increasing distance from the isocenter of the magnet. Velocity measurements with a single slice placed at or near the center of the magnet and with the vessel of interest close to the center of the FOV are therefore largely insensitive to encoding errors. The situation differs considerably, however, if multiple slices are acquired within a single acquisition or if blood flow is to be analyzed within a larger plane or a 3D imaging volume. For off-center flow quantification corrections for all of the above sources of inaccuracies should be performed to ensure reliable quantitative analysis of flow and derived parameters.
3
Phase-Contrast MRI and Flow Quantification
Acceleration Errors The MR signal phase is not only sensitive to the blood or tissue velocity, but it depends as well on the acceleration and higher-order terms. All those higher order terms are neglected when approximation blood flow or tissue motion in first order as (3.3). Although this assumption is reasonable in most situations, it may induce an error on the measured velocities. This effect may be reduced by optimizing the shape of the gradient waveforms or reducing TE (Oshinski et al. [59]). Although it is difficult to fully correct for this effect, it is possible to further reduce it at the cost of longer imaging times by integrating acceleration encoding [60] or Fourier encoding (Firmin et al. [61]).
References 1. Nayler GL, Firmin DN, Longmore DB. Blood flow imaging by cine magnetic resonance. J Comput Assist Tomogr. 1986;10:715–722. 2. Dumoulin CL, Souza SP, Darrow RD, Pelc NJ, Adams WJ, Ash SA. Simultaneous acquisition of phase-contrast angiograms and stationary-tissue images with Hadamard encoding of flow-induced phase shifts. J Magn Reson Imaging. 1991;1:399–404. 3. Pelc NJ, Herfkens RJ, Shimakawa A, Enzmann DR. Phase contrast cine magnetic resonance imaging. Magn Reson Q. 1991;7: 229–254. 4. Mohiaddin RH, Pennell DJ. MR blood flow measurement. Clinical application in the heart and circulation. Cardiol Clin. 1998;16: 161–187. 5. Chai P, Mohiaddin R. How we perform cardiovascular magnetic resonance flow assessment using phase-contrast velocity mapping. J Cardiovasc Magn Reson. 2005;7:705–716. 6. Naidich TP, Altman NR, Gonzalez-Arias SM. Phase contrast cine magnetic resonance imaging: normal cerebrospinal fluid oscillation and applications to hydrocephalus. Neurosurg Clin N Am. 1993; 4:677–705. 7. Drangova M, Zhu Y, Bowman B, Pelc NJ. In vitro verification of myocardial motion tracking from phase-contrast velocity data. Magn Reson Imaging. 1998;16:863–870. 8. Carr HY, Purcell EM. Effects of diffusion on free precession in nuclear magnetic Resonance Experiments. Phys Rev. 1954;94: 30–638. 9. Hahn EL. Detection of sea water motion by nuclear precession. J Geophys Res. 1960;65:776–777. 10. Moran PR. A flow velocity zeugmatographic interlace for NMR imaging in humans. Magn Reson Imaging. 1982;1:197–203. 11. Bryant DJ, Payne JA, Firmin DN, Longmore DB. Measurement of flow with NMR imaging using a gradient pulse and phase difference technique. J Comput Assist Tomogr. 1984;8:588–593. 12. Van Dijk P. Direct cardiac NMR imaging of heart wall and blood flow velocity. J Comput Assist Tomogr. 1984;171:429–436. 13. Andersen AH, Kirsch JE. Analysis of noise in phase contrast MR imaging. Med Phys. 1996;23:857–869. 14. Bernstein MA, Shimakawa A, Pelc NJ. Minimizing TE in momentnulled or flow-encoded two- and three-dimensional gradient-echo imaging. J Magn Reson Imaging. 1992;2:583–588. 15. Pelc NJ, Bernstein MA, Shimakawa A, Glover GH. Encoding strategies for three-direction phase-contrast MR imaging of flow. J Magn Reson Imaging. 1991;1:405–413.
63 16. Atkinson DJ, Edelman RR. Cineangiography of the heart in a single breath hold with a segmented turboFLASH sequence. Radiology. 1991;178:357–360. 17. Thomsen C, Cortsen M, Sondergaard L, Henriksen O, Stahlberg F. A segmented K-space velocity mapping protocol for quantification of renal artery blood flow during breath-holding. J Magn Reson Imaging. 1995;5:393–401. 18. Ehman RL, Felmlee JP. Adaptive technique for high-definition MR imaging of moving structures. Radiology. 1989;173:255–263. 19. Felmlee JP, Ehman RL, Riederer SJ, Korin HW. Adaptive motion compensation in MRI: accuracy of motion measurement. Magn Reson Med. 1991;18:207–213. 20. Taylor AM, Jhooti P, Wiesmann F, Keegan J, Firmin DN, Pennell DJ. MR navigator-echo monitoring of temporal changes in diaphragm position: implications for MR coronary angiography. J Magn Reson Imaging. 1997;7:629–636. 21. Didier D. Assessment of valve disease: qualitative and quantitative. Magn Reson Imaging Clin N Am.2003;11:115–134, vii. 22. Gatehouse PD, Keegan J, Crowe LA, Masood S, Mohiaddin RH, Kreitner KF, Firmin DN. Applications of phase-contrast flow and velocity imaging in cardiovascular MRI. Eur Radiol. 2005;15: 2172–2184. 23. Beerbaum P, Korperich H, Barth P, Esdorn H, Gieseke J, Meyer H. Noninvasive quantification of left-to-right shunt in pediatric patients: phase-contrast cine magnetic resonance imaging compared with invasive oximetry. Circulation. 2001;103: 2476–2482. 24. Underwood SR, Firmin DN, Rees RS, Longmore DB. Magnetic resonance velocity mapping. Clin Phys Physiol Meas. 1990;11 (Suppl A):37–43. 25. Bernstein MA, Grgic M, Brosnan TJ, Pelc NJ. Reconstructions of phase contrast, phased array multicoil data. Magn Reson Med. 1994;32:330–334. 26. Dumoulin CL, Souza SP, Walker MF, Wagle W. Three-dimensional phase contrast angiography. Magn Reson Med. 1989;9:139–149. 27. Lum DP, Johnson KM, Paul RK, Turk AS, Consigny DW, Grinde JR, Mistretta CA, Grist TM. Transstenotic pressure gradients: measurement in swine--retrospectively ECG-gated 3D phase-contrast MR angiography versus endovascular pressure-sensing guidewires. Radiology. 2007;245:751–760. 28. Dumoulin CL. Phase contrast MR angiography techniques. Magn Reson Imaging Clin N Am. 1995;3:399–411. 29. Johnson KM, Lum DP, Turski PA, Block WF, Mistretta CA, Wieben O. Improved 3D phase contrast MRI with off-resonance corrected dual echo VIPR. Magn Reson Med. 2008;60:1329–1336. 30. Bock J, Frydrychowicz A, Stalder AF, Bley TA, Burkhardt H, Hennig J, Markl M. 4D phase contrast MRI at 3 T: effect of standard and blood-pool contrast agents on SNR, PC-MRA, and blood flow visualization. Magn Reson Med. 2010;63:330–338. 31. Markl M, Harloff A, Bley TA, Zaitsev M, Jung B, Weigang E, Langer M, Hennig J, Frydrychowicz A. Time-resolved 3D MR velocity mapping at 3T: improved navigator-gated assessment of vascular anatomy and blood flow. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2007; 25:824–831. 32. Wigstrom L, Sjoqvist L, Wranne B. Temporally resolved 3D phasecontrast imaging. Magn Reson Med. 1996;36:800–803. 33. Buonocore MH. Visualizing blood flow patterns using streamlines, arrows, and particle paths. Magn Reson Med. 1998;40:210–226. 34. Kozerke S, Hasenkam JM, Pedersen EM, Boesiger P. Visualization of flow patterns distal to aortic valve prostheses in humans using a fast approach for cine 3D velocity mapping. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2001;13:690–698. 35. Fyrenius A, Wigstrom L, Ebbers T, Karlsson M, Engvall J, Bolger AF. Three dimensional flow in the human left atrium. Heart. 2001;86:448–455.
64 36. Kilner PJ, Yang GZ, Wilkes AJ, Mohiaddin RH, Firmin DN, Yacoub MH. Asymmetric redirection of flow through the heart. Nature. 2000;404:759–761. 37. Bogren HG, Buonocore MH. 4D magnetic resonance velocity mapping of blood flow patterns in the aorta in young vs. elderly normal subjects. J Magn Reson Imaging. 1999;10:861–869. 38. Frydrychowicz A, Harloff A, Jung B, Zaitsev M, Weigang E, Bley TA, Langer M, Hennig J, Markl M. Time-resolved, 3-dimensional magnetic resonance flow analysis at 3 T: visualization of normal and pathological aortic vascular hemodynamics. J Comput Assist Tomogr. 2007;31:9–15. 39. Kilner PJ, Yang GZ, Mohiaddin RH, Firmin DN, Longmore DB. Helical and retrograde secondary flow patterns in the aortic arch studied by three-directional magnetic resonance velocity mapping. Circulation. 1993;88(5 Pt 1):2235–2247. 40. Harloff A, Albrecht F, Spreer J, Stalder AF, Bock J, Frydrychowicz A, Schollhorn J, Hetzel A, Schumacher M, Hennig J, Markl M. 3D blood flow characteristics in the carotid artery bifurcation assessed by flow-sensitive 4D MRI at 3T. Magn Reson Med. 2009;61:65–74. 41. Wetzel S, Meckel S, Frydrychowicz A, Bonati L, Radue EW, Scheffler K, Hennig J, Markl M. In vivo assessment and visualization of intracranial arterial hemodynamics with flow-sensitized 4D MR imaging at 3T. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2007;28:433–438. 42. Reiter G, Reiter U, Kovacs G, Kainz B, Schmidt K, Maier R, Olschewski H, Rienmueller R. Magnetic resonance-derived 3-dimensional blood flow patterns in the main pulmonary artery as a marker of pulmonary hypertension and a measure of elevated mean pulmonary arterial pressure. Circ Cardiovasc Imaging. 2008;1:23–30. 43. Tyszka JM, Laidlaw DH, Asa JW, Silverman JM. Three-dimensional, time-resolved (4D) relative pressure mapping using magnetic resonance imaging. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2000;12:321–329. 44. Stalder AF, Russe MF, Frydrychowicz A, Bock J, Hennig J, Markl M. Quantitative 2D and 3D phase contrast MRI: optimized analysis of blood flow and vessel wall parameters. Magn Reson Med. 2008;60:1218–1231. 45. Vulliemoz S, Stergiopulos N, Meuli R. Estimation of local aortic elastic properties with MRI. Magn Reson Med. 2002;47:649–654. 46. Ebbers T, Wigstrom L, Bolger AF, Engvall J, Karlsson M. Estimation of relative cardiovascular pressures using time-resolved three-dimensional phase contrast MRI. Magn Reson Med. 2001;45:872–879. 47. Frydrychowicz A, Stalder AF, Russe MF, Bock J, Bauer S, Harloff A, Berger A, Langer M, Hennig J, Markl M. Three-dimensional analysis of segmental wall shear stress in the aorta by flow-sensitive four-dimensional-MRI. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2009;30:77–84. 48. Dyverfeldt P, Sigfridsson A, Kvitting JP, Ebbers T. Quantification of intravoxel velocity standard deviation and turbulence intensity by generalizing phase-contrast MRI. Magn Reson Med. 2006;56: 850–858.
B. Jung and M. Markl 49. Gu T, Korosec FR, Block WF, Fain SB, Turk Q, Lum D, Zhou Y, Grist TM, Haughton V, Mistretta CA. PC VIPR: a high-speed 3D phase-contrast method for flow quantification and high-resolution angiography. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2005;26:743–749. 50. Turk AS, Johnson KM, Lum D, Niemann D, Aagaard-Kienitz B, Consigny D, Grinde J, Turski P, Haughton V, Mistretta C. Physiologic and anatomic assessment of a canine carotid artery stenosis model utilizing phase contrast with vastly undersampled isotropic projection imaging. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2007;28: 111–115. 51. Moftakhar R, Aagaard-Kienitz B, Johnson K, Turski PA, Turk AS, Niemann DB, Consigny D, Grinde J, Wieben O, Mistretta CA. Noninvasive measurement of intra-aneurysmal pressure and flow pattern using phase contrast with vastly undersampled isotropic projection imaging. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2007;28:1710–1714. 52. Baltes C, Kozerke S, Hansen MS, Pruessmann KP, Tsao J, Boesiger P. Accelerating cine phase-contrast flow measurements using k-t BLAST and k-t SENSE. Magn Reson Med. 2005;54:1430–1438. 53. Jung B, Honal M, Ullmann P, Hennig J, Markl M. Highly k-t-spaceaccelerated phase-contrast MRI. Magn Reson Med. 2008;60: 1169–1177. 54. Walker PG, Cranney GB, Scheidegger MB, Waseleski G, Pohost GM, Yoganathan AP. Semiautomated method for noise reduction and background phase error correction in MR phase velocity data. J Magn Reson Imaging. 1993;3:521–530. 55. Bernstein MA, Zhou XJ, Polzin JA, King KF, Ganin A, Pelc NJ, Glover GH. Concomitant gradient terms in phase contrast MR: analysis and correction. Magn Reson Med. 1998;39:300–308. 56. Markl M, Bammer R, Alley MT, Elkins CJ, Draney MT, Barnett A, Moseley ME, Glover GH, Pelc NJ. Generalized reconstruction of phase contrast MRI: analysis and correction of the effect of gradient field distortions. Magn Reson Med. 2003;50:791–801. 57. Peeters JM, Bos C, Bakker CJ. Analysis and correction of gradient nonlinearity and B0 inhomogeneity related scaling errors in twodimensional phase contrast flow measurements. Magn Reson Med. 2005;53:126–133. 58. McCauley TR, Pena CS, Holland CK, Price TB, Gore JC. Validation of volume flow measurements with cine phase-contrast MR imaging for peripheral arterial waveforms. J Magn Reson Imaging. 1995;5:663–668. 59. Oshinski JN, Ku DN, Bohning DE, Pettigrew RI. Effects of acceleration on the accuracy of MR phase velocity measurements. J Magn Reson Imaging. 1992;2:665–670. 60. Forster J, Sieverding L, Breuer J, Lutz O, Schick F. Fast acceleration-encoded magnetic resonance imaging. Med Phys. 2001; 28:28–35. 61. Firmin DN, Nayler GL, Kilner PJ, Longmore DB. The application of phase shifts in NMR for flow measurement. Magn Reson Med. 1990;14:230–241.
4
Technical Aspect of Contrast-Enhanced MRA Honglei Zhang, Wei Zhang, and Martin R. Prince
Introduction Although MR angiography (MRA) has revolutionized imaging of vascular diseases, the complicated nature of blood/soft tissue contrast mechanisms and the unique artifacts associated with each of the many techniques have made it challenging for referring physicians to become comfortable interpreting noncontrast MRA studies. Fortunately, contrast-enhanced (CE) MRA provides the type of contrast arteriogram that clinicians and radiologists are comfortable interpreting while eliminating the risks of radiation, iodinated contrast, and arterial catheterization [1]. Just like DSA and CTA, CE-MRA provides reliable enhancement of the arterial lumen during the arterial phase of the Gd bolus injection. Although MR imaging is slower than DSA or CTA, advances in magnet technology, gradient performance, pulse sequence design, and MR contrast agents continue to improve CE-MRA image quality such that it rivals DSA in accuracy for diagnosing vascular anomalies and diseases. This chapter describes the basic principles underlying CE-MRA techniques, approaches to optimizing applications throughout the body, and methods of contrast agent bolus timing.
Theory Unlike conventional MRA techniques which rely on blood flow or intrinsic blood relaxation properties to distinguish vasculature from background tissue, CE-MRA uses a contrast agent (e.g., gadolinium) to shorten the T1 (spin lattice) relaxation time of blood so that the intraluminal signal is brighter than that of surrounding tissues [1, 2] on T1-weighted images. Blood can then be directly imaged using fast,
H. Zhang, MD () • W. Zhang, MD • M.R. Prince, MD, PhD Department of Radiology, Weill Medical College of Cornell University, New York, NY 10022, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
three-dimensional, spoiled gradient echo or steady-state free precession pulse sequences. The short echo time of these 3D gradient echo sequences minimizes blood motion, e.g., flow artifacts which are problematic on noncontrast techniques. Spoiled gradient echo is preferred over steady-state free precession especially for large, field of view (FOV) applications to eliminate banding and susceptibility artifacts of steadystate free precession. T1 shortening effect of paramagnetic contrast agents, e.g., gadolinium, is independent of blood flow or scan plane. With CE-MRA, in-plane imaging of vessels allows a small number of slices, required in the plane of those vessels, to quickly image an extensive length of vessel at high spatial resolutions. CE-MRA data can be acquired in coronal, sagittal, or oblique planes to encompass the vascular anatomy of interest with a minimal number of slices. Imaging in the plane of the arteries also takes advantage of the tendency for MR to image at higher resolution in plane compared to through plane. Thus, CE-MRA is intrinsically fast, allowing high-resolution, breath-hold MR angiograms. The high resolution and quality of CE-MRA have yielded sensitivity and specificity for evaluating different vascular territories in the high 90% range using conventional X-ray angiography as gold standard of reference [3–5]. CE-MRA captures central k-space data during the peak arterial phase of a contrast agent bolus [2]. More peripheral k-space data may be collected before and/or after the Gd peak to enhance MRA image resolution. More k-space details are described under “Fourier consideration.” This 3D data can be reformatted into any obliquity to unfold tortuous arteries and to view lesions in multiple organs. Compared to computed tomographic angiography (CTA), volume rendering is more straightforward because arteries are the brightest structures; there is no need to cut away bones since calcium has low signal on MR. As long as the echo time (TE) is sufficiently short, less than 3 ms, vascular calcifications do not interfere with depiction of the artery lumen. The short echo time used with 3D Fourier transform (FT) gradient echo sequences also minimizes artifact from metal clips, bowel gas, and other susceptibility sources.
J.C. Carr and T.J. Carroll (eds.), Magnetic Resonance Angiography: Principles and Applications, DOI 10.1007/978-1-4419-1686-0_4, © Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2012
65
66
Pulse Sequence CE-MRA primarily utilizes 3D spoiled gradient echo pulse sequences to take advantage of their high speed, short echo time, and T1 weighting with a single center of k-space for the entire volume of data [2]. CE-MRA can also be used with steady-state free precession with more signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) but also more artifacts, especially with larger FOV, where it is difficult to have good field homogeneity. PC MRA may also improve postinjection of paramagnetic contrast agent. Three-dimensional sequences have high spatial resolution with thin slices and intrinsically high SNR. This sequence is made fast by using short RF pulses or completely eliminating slice selection. Spoiling of the transverse magnetization is useful because it accentuates T1 contrast, thereby magnifying the effect of paramagnetic contrast agents (e.g., gadolinium). It also suppresses signal from background tissues to enhance image contrast and reduce visibility of background aliasing. Mask subtraction and fat suppression can also enhance image contrast, but can create artifacts. For example, motion between the mask and arterial phase creates misregistration artifacts. Poor field homogeneity can cause a fat saturation pulse to drift onto the water peak at the edge of the image or near-susceptibility sources giving the false appearance of occlusion. A recent advance is the acquisition of two echoes, in phase and out of phase with each TR and eliminating fat signal with the Dixon method. Repetition times (TR) used for CE-MRA are generally around 5 ms or less, and TE are typically 1–2 ms. Total scan times range from 10 to 30 s, although this can be lengthened further in regions not affected by respiratory motion for greater resolution, coverage, or SNR. It can also be shortened by sacrificing spatial resolution or coverage and repeated multiple times to provide time-resolved MRA showing the passage of contrast through the volume of interest. Using ultrashort TR, parallel imaging, partial Fourier, and/or sharing of peripheral k-space data, sliding window reconstruction with radial or spiral trajectories, time-resolved CE-MRA is possible at subsecond temporal resolution [1, 6–11]. Even faster temporal resolution can be acquired with Cartesian acquisition with projection reconstruction (CAPR), vastly undersampled isotropic projection reconstruction (VIPR), k–t broad-use linear acquisition speed-up technique (BLAST), or using 2D spoiled gradient echo sequences with complex mask subtraction [1, 12–15]. Gradient echo imaging without spoiling can also be useful when tissue perfusion is of interest.
Fourier (k-Space) Considerations MR imaging does not collect data voxel by voxel. Instead, MR scanners collect spatial frequency data, also known as Fourier or k-space data. With 3D MR imaging, the entire 3D
H. Zhang et al.
“Fourier” or “k-space” dataset is collected before reconstructing individual slices [2]. Because k-space maps spatial frequencies rather than spatial data, k-space data does not directly correspond to image space. Instead, different regions of k-space data determine different image features. For example, the center of k-space or “low” spatial frequencies dominates image contrast, whereas the periphery of k-space or “high” spatial frequencies contributes more to fine details, such as edges. Thus, the state of the contrast agent bolus and intravascular T1 in large vessels is captured at the moment corresponding to acquisition of central k-space [1, 2, 11]. If central k-space is collected when the arterial contrast agent concentration is peaking but has not yet reached capillaries and veins (arterial phase), only the arteries will be bright on MRA images. With optimal timing, contrast injection duration does not need to be as long as the acquisition time when the bolus peak in the artery of interest occurs during acquisition of central k-space data. Most protocols use contrast injection durations that are much shorter than the scan acquisition time. Shorter injection duration with the same total Gd dose results in a faster injection with higher blood Gd concentrations which increases SNR. On the other hand, shorter injections must be timed precisely to avoid artifacts which occur when the contrast bolus peak does not coincide perfectly with acquisition of the center of k-space. For a given Gd dose, the injection strategy is a trade-off between a fast injection for higher intravascular signal versus a slow injection for more uniform signal, easier bolus timing and fewer artifacts. As a general rule, injecting the total contrast dose over approximately half of the acquisition time is optimum if the Gd bolus is perfectly timed for the arterial phase to synchronize with the acquisition of central k-space data. Make sure to avoid a rapid increase or decrease in the concentration of the contrast agent during the acquisition of the central k-space as this causes edge-ringing artifacts (Fig. 4.1). Another factor that must be considered is phase-encoding order. Generally, phase encoding is performed “sequentially” such that central k-space is acquired at the midpoint of the scan. Alternatively, phase encoding can be performed in a “centric” fashion such that central k-space is acquired at the beginning of the scan. Although centric phase-encoding order has been shown to be more prone to artifacts [15], it greatly simplifies bolus timing and may be less susceptible to venous enhancement and artifacts from incomplete breath holding. Centric encoding is generally most effective when performed as an elliptical centric variant, as this concentrates the center of k-space into a shorter time at the beginning of the scan [16, 17]. Another choice is partial Fourier acquisition beginning near the k-space center which has some of the benefits of both centric and sequential ordering [18]. The best suppression of venous enhancement is with recessed elliptical centric encoding. Recessing the absolute center of k-space a few seconds from the beginning of the scan allows
4
Technical Aspect of Contrast-Enhanced MRA
Fig. 4.1 Time-resolved 2D MRA images show ringing artifact in the anterior tibial artery on early images, where there is enhancement of the periphery of k-space but not yet in the center of k-space. Ringing
67
disappears on the third image at 22 s indicating that the center of k-space is fully enhanced. Later images show enhancement of the veins and heel ulcer
Fig. 4.2 MR venogram of the legs with 9 mL gadofosvoset trisodium shows extensive acute deep venous thrombosis of the left upper soleus and gastrocnemius veins with surrounding inflammation
data acquisition to begin on the leading edge of the bolus while still synchronizing the center of k-space with the arterial Gd peak [19].
Contrast Agents At present, most CE-MRA examinations are conducted using gadolinium-based MR contrast agents. Gadolinium (Gd3+) is a paramagnetic metal ion that decreases both the spin–lattice (T1) and spin–spin (T2) relaxation times [3]. Because Gd3+ itself is biologically toxic, it is chelated with ligands, such as DTPA (gadopentetate dimeglumine), HP-DO3A (gadoteridol), gadoversetamide, or gadobenate dimeglumine to form low-molecular-weight contrast agents. These small, “extracellular” agents rapidly redistribute from the intravascular compartment into the interstitial space. Typically, 80% of gadolinium chelate leaks into the intravascular space within 5 min. Thus, imaging of arteries must be performed rapidly to exploit the “first pass” of the contrast agent. As compared with iodinated contrast agents, gadolinium chelates have a very low rate of adverse events and no nephrotoxicity, which is a significant advantage in patients with impaired renal
function. One exception is gadobenate dimeglumine which is ionic and has nearly as many reactions as iodinated contrast agents but very low risk of nephrogenic systemic fibrosis (NSF). Some new high-relaxivity contrast agents are large enough, e.g., USPIO, or bind to large, serum molecules, e.g., gadofosvoset trisodium, so that they stay within the intravascular compartment with minimal leaking out of the capillaries [20, 21]. These agents are referred to as blood pool or intravascular contrast agents. The high relaxivity of these blood pool agents makes them ideal for first pass, arterial phase imaging because a large, contrast effect is achieved with safe, low-injection rates. In addition, the longer intravascular half-life of these contrast agents may allow imaging longer for higher resolution or imaging additional vascular territories during the equilibrium, blood pool phase. Pulmonary and coronary 3D MRA may benefit from these new contrast agents. Other uses relate to venous imaging (Fig. 4.2) and “road map” imaging for monitoring vascular interventions. Blood pool agents may also be useful for identifying gastrointestinal (GI) bleeding using delays in a manner analogous to labeled red blood cells. Similarly, they can be used to detect slow or intermittent stent graft leaks [22].
68
Contrast Dose and Injection Rate In order to image bright blood with respect to background tissues during the arterial phase, sufficient contrast agent must be administered to transiently reduce the arterial blood T1 to substantially less than that of the brightest background tissue, fat, which has a T1 of approximately 270 ms [2]. During the “first-pass” arterial phase, blood T1 is more related to infusion rate and contrast agent relaxivity than total contrast dose, as arterial phase imaging occurs well before intravascular contrast equilibration. Total gadolinium dose and rate of delivery is a trade-off between maximizing intravascular signal (higher injection rate) and minimizing artifacts (longer injection duration). In the ideal situation, a large dose at a high rate would be optimal. This, however, must be weighed against safety, practicality, and cost. Gd chelates’ concentration in the arteries is estimated by the injection rate divided by the cardiac output. Higher injection rates give higher arterial Gd concentration and correspondingly higher SNR until the concentration is so high that T2* effects reduce signal. Diminishing return due to these T2* effects starts to occur for injection rates greater than 5 mL/s for standard, extracellular gadolinium chelates. It is also important to avoid Gd concentration changing too rapidly during acquisition of central k-space data as this creates ringing artifacts. But having a high injection rate for a long duration results in a large dose of Gd which can be expensive and may excessively exceed FDA limits. A good strategy for maximizing injection rate while minimizing the dose is to use a relatively rapid (2–3 mL/s) injection with a duration shorter than the scan duration. Typically, an injection duration that is half of the scan duration is optimum. For a 75 kg patient who received 15 mL of Gd (0.1 mmol/kg) at an injection rate of 3 mL/s for 5 s, the scan duration should be about 10-s long. Due to contrast agent dilution at the leading and trailing edges of the bolus, as well as varying transit times through different portions of the pulmonary circulation, the contrast bolus tends to lengthen as it travels from the antecubital vein (where it is typically injected), through the heart and lungs, to the arteries being imaged. This bolus dispersion depends on individual cardiovascular parameters which are difficult to predict, but at least 5–7 s of bolus prolongation occurs in most individuals [2]. Even greater bolus dispersion can be expected for peripheral arteries, whereas only minimal bolus dispersion can be expected for pulmonary arteries. For fast breath-held acquisitions of the systemic arterial system, the total dose of contrast should be administered at a rate that results in an injection time that is at least 5–7 s shorter than the data acquisition time. An injection duration which is about half the scan duration is recommended since it is not necessary to have peak Gd concentration while acquiring the periphery of k-space.
H. Zhang et al.
The optimal Gd dose also depends upon the vascular territory being imaged and the available software and hardware. Generally, the more contrast agent, the better the MRA image quality because larger contrast agent doses allow high injection rate for a longer time. However, the FDA-approved dose is only up to 0.3 mmol/kg body weight. Recently, concern over NSF has led to greater attention to the dose of Gd use for MR procedures because the risk scales with dose. It appears that for ionic and macrocyclic gadolinium chelates, there is negligible risk at 0.1 mmol/kg as the overwhelming majority of NSF cases have occurred at high doses (Fig. 4.3) [23]. For nonionic linear chelates which have the most cases of NSF, the risk of single dose appears to be less than 1 in 10,000 for patients with GFR <30 mL/min. For extremely fast MRA acquisitions, the contrast agent dose also has to be small because of the limit on how fast one can inject intravenously. Recently, ultralow-dose MRA has been developed by Kramer et al. using just a few mL of Gd for time-resolved imaging of the arch and carotid arteries [24]. These dose issues are entirely different with iron oxide agents which have no risk of NSF.
Patient Preparation The more relaxed and informed a patient is, the more easily they can remain still and perform a long breath hold. Reassurance and a brief description of the scan can help. In patients who are particularly anxious, premedication with sedatives, such as diazepam, may be useful. This helps the patient to relax and lie still. Relaxation also decreases cardiac output which yields a higher arterial contrast agent concentration for the same injection rate. Patients on beta blockers and older patients with reduced cardiac output tend to have the best-quality CE-MRA for this reason. Since most CE-MRA is performed in the coronal plane, arm position is important to allow for a smaller FOV without aliasing, particularly important when using parallel imaging (e.g., SENSE) which is less forgiving of wrap-around artifact [25]. For carotid, large, FOV, sagittal, oblique, aortic or peripheral studies, the arms can remain by the patient’s side, as aliasing is not a factor. For pulmonary, small FOV aortic, renal, and mesenteric studies, the arms must either be elevated out of the imaging plane using cushions, extended overhead, or enclosed in Faraday sleeves. Positions in which the arms are elevated have the added benefit of gravity-aided venous return from the IV injection site. This ensures rapid delivery of the entire Gd dose to the central circulation. Recently, a new pulse sequence know as rotated slice encoding (ROSE) allows for excitation of a limited slab in the sagittal plane with data reconstruction in the coronal plane which eliminates wrap around of the arms without requiring elevation overhead.
4
Technical Aspect of Contrast-Enhanced MRA
69
Fig. 4.3 Bolus chase MRA in a patient with GFR = 25 mL/min using thigh compression and only 11 mL gadobenate dimeglumine to reduce NSF risk
If CE-MRA will be performed with the arms by the patient’s side, placing the IV in the antecubital vein is adequate. If the arms are overhead or crossed over the chest, it may be preferable to place the IV above or below the antecubital fossa so it will not kink and obstruct when the patient’s elbow bends. A 20- or 22-gage catheter is optimal. For smalldiameter catheters (greater than 22 gage), warming the contrast to body temperature decreases the viscosity to allow for adequate injection rates. Use of a standardized IV tubing system is helpful to avoid uncertainty about priming volume and to simplify flushing.
Contrast Injection (Hand Versus Power Injection) Hand injection gives the operator more control over bolus administration and allows early detection of IV problems, such as blockage or extravasation. Hand injection is always preferred for pediatric patients (especially babies) when injecting central lines or when there is a tenuous IV line. Hand injections avoid tethering the IV to a mechanical pump, eliminating the problem of inadvertently pulling out the IV when the patient is advanced into the magnet. Problems of battery failure and accidental premature injection are also eliminated with hand injection. With hand injection, it is helpful to always use the same IV tubing system to avoid
uncertainty about flow resistance and how much contrast agent must be injected to fill the IV tubing. A power injector has the advantage of delivering precise infusion of contrast agent at a consistent and predictable injection rate, provided there are no obstructions [26]. It also allows a single operator to run the MRA exam from the control room without having to enter the scanner room. With power injection, it is important to carefully monitor the patient using a pulse oximeter or other monitoring device, as it is more difficult to detect a contrast reaction from the control room as compared to standing next to the patient for hand injections. Either way, the contrast injection must be immediately followed by adequate saline flush to complete delivery of the bolus and help flush the arm veins. Suggested flush volumes range from 15 to 50 mL, with most authors using 20 mL [2]. Improved filling of peripheral k-space has been suggested with a dilute Gd flush composed of 1 part Gd and 9 parts saline.
Bolus Timing Considerations Gd bolus timing relative to acquisition of central k-space is critical for CE-MRA. The contrast travel time, defined as the time required for contrast to travel from the injection site to the vascular territory of interest, is highly variable. It depends
70
on the degree to which the bolus “broadens” as it transits the cardiopulmonary vasculature. Mean transit time to the common femoral artery of 24 ± 6 s, with a range of 13–37 s, has been reported [27]. Older patients, patients with a history of congestive heart disease, patients on beta blockers, and patients with aortic aneurysms tend to have slower flow.
“Best Guess” Technique Several solutions to proper bolus timing have been developed. The simplest is to just make an educated “best guess.” Sequential phase encoding is preferred when using “best guess,” as this encoding strategy as well as longer scan duration are more tolerant of timing errors. The most difficult aspect of best guess technique is estimating the contrast agent travel time. If timing is not accurate, it is better to image slightly late (increased venous phase) than slightly early (ringing/banding artifact). With this in mind as a general guideline, the contrast agent travel time from an antecubital vein to the abdominal aorta would be approximately 15 s for a young healthy patient and a few seconds less for hypertensive or athletic patient. Contrast agent travel times would be approximately 20–25 s for a healthy elderly patient (>70 years old), 25–35 s in patients with cardiac disease or an aortic aneurysm, and up to 40–50 s when severe cardiac failure in conjunction with aortic aneurysm is present. Add 3 s if the IV is in the hand [1]. Best guess technique works well for scan time of at least 40 s or longer (with sequential k-space encoding) when the impact of 5 s of timing error is minimal.
H. Zhang et al.
background signals. Finally, the imaging bolus may not behave identical to the test bolus due to moment-to-moment patient variables, such as venous return and cardiac output, as well as the different total volume of injection. It is especially important to be aware that a test bolus with the arm at the patient’s side may not be accurate if the forearms are then repositioned above the patient’s head for the actual scan as overhead positioning the patient’s arms may stretch and pinch the subclavian veins.
Automatic Triggering Another approach to bolus timing uses a pulse sequence that can automatically detect contrast arrival in the aorta and synchronize 3D MRA data acquisition with the arterial phase of the contrast bolus. The operator selects a region of aorta to be sampled at 20-ms intervals. As contrast arrives in the aorta, the signal within the sampling region increases. A trigger threshold of typically 20% signal increase detects the leading edge of the contrast bolus. This gives the patient time to take in a deep breath and suspend respiration before the actual scan commences 5 s later. By beginning the scan near the center of k-space, i.e., centric or preferably recessed elliptical centric encoding, there is synchronization between the arterial phase of the bolus and elliptical centric acquisition of central k-space data. Commercial versions of this pulse sequence are available as “SmartPrep” (GE Medical Systems) or “Bolustrack” (Philips Medical Systems).
MR Fluoroscopy Test Bolus Technique A bolus-timing acquisition can be performed prior to acquisition of 3D MRA dataset using a small Gd contrast dose of ~2 mL followed by a 20-mL saline flush at the same rate as planned for the actual injection. Multiple, single-slice, fast gradient echo images in the vascular region of interest are acquired as rapidly as possible (every 1–2 s) for approximately 1 min. In order to minimize time-of-flight effects, the 2D test bolus images should either be oriented in the plane of imaged vessel (i.e., sagittal or coronal for the aorta) or alternatively be relatively thick (greater than 1 cm) with a superior saturation band or a blood-nulling inversion prepulse. The time of peak arterial enhancement (contrast travel time) is then determined visually or using ROI analysis. While quite effective, there are several drawbacks to the test bolus technique. Setting up, performing, and analyzing the test bolus lengthen the overall examination time. The test bolus rapidly redistributes into the interstitial space and is excreted by the kidneys into the ureters, thereby increasing
Perhaps, the most popular method of contrast bolus timing is to use extremely rapid MR fluoroscopy [1, 2, 16, 17]. With this technique, 2D gradient-refocused images are rapidly (less than 1 s/image) obtained through the vascular structure of interest, ideally using complex subtraction to improve contrast and decrease artifacts. Images are generated in near real time and updated at greater than once per second. The operator watches the contrast bolus arrive and then switches over to recessed elliptical centric 3D MRA when the desired enhancement is detected. This technique allows real-time, operator-dependent decision making. This may be particularly advantageous in cases with unusual or asymmetric flow patterns, such as unilateral stenoses and slow filling aneurysms. The ability to assess the vasculature “on the fly” under these circumstances is a great asset, as is the time and contrast savings associated with avoiding a test injection. It is useful to shift the MR fluoroscopic monitoring to a proximal region of vascular anatomy to get more advanced warning of contrast agent arrival. Using carotid MRA as an
4
Technical Aspect of Contrast-Enhanced MRA
71
example, MR fluoroscopic monitoring in the chest shows contrast agent arriving in the subclavian vein, then right heart, pulmonary arteries, left heart, arch, and finally proximal great vessels. Tracking the bolus over such a long period makes precise triggering easier. If the flow is very slow, the operator can compensate to allow for greater target vessel enhancement before triggering. Fluoroscopic triggering is improved by recessing the absolute center of k-space a few seconds from the beginning of the 3D acquisition, thus avoiding the previously described “leading-edge” artifact from early triggering.
More recent refinements traverse k-space using radial or spiral projections [1], which allow for sliding window reconstructions at very high temporal and spatial resolutions. VIPR and CAPR are particularly promising. VIPR can be combined with phase-contrast imaging as well. Another strategy that works particularly well with the sparse MRA datasets is to use training data acquired either pre or post contrast injection. Training data and post-Gd steady-state data help calculate high spatial resolution during high temporal resolution undersampling while contrast agent is injected, e.g., k–t BLAST or HYPR TRICKS.
Time-Resolved 3D Contrast MRA
Imaging Different Vascular Phases
Because proper bolus timing is difficult and a timing mistake can ruin the study, time-resolved techniques have been developed whereby multiple 3D datasets are acquired extremely rapidly (typically, 1–10 s per acquisition). Bolus timing is no longer a factor as multiple vascular phases are obtained without any predetermined timing (i.e., inject and begin scanning simultaneously). The operator simply selects the desired image set: pure arterial phase, maximum venous, etc. This is particularly useful in the carotid and pulmonary arteries, where the venous phase is extremely rapid, and in the calf, where variable rate filling may occur due to stenoses, occlusions, or rapid AV shunting due to soft tissue ulcers, cellulitis, and other inflammatory diseases [2]. The most straightforward way to accelerate acquisition time is using some combination of limiting the imaging volume, decreasing the resolution (e.g., fewer, thicker slices and fewer phase-encoding steps), decreasing TR, and partial Fourier parallel imaging. Recent developments in gradient systems allow TRs of <2 ms on many systems. Simultaneous high spatial resolution and high temporal resolution over a large FOV can be obtained using 3D TRICKS (time-resolved imaging of contrast kinetics) [28– 30] and its variants, including TREAT, HYPR-TRICKS, and PR TRICKS. TRICKS divides k-space into multiple blocks. Central k-space (which contributes most to overall image contrast) is collected more frequently (oversampled) than blocks of data corresponding to more peripheral k-space. Images are then “synthesized” at high temporal resolution by piecing together each unique block of central k-space data with an interpolation of the remaining k-space blocks acquired in closest temporal proximity. This technique allows greater temporal and spatial resolution/volume coverage than with a streamlined conventional sequence. k-space discontinuities, in conjunction with varying intravascular Gd concentration, may lead to ringing artifacts. These artifacts, however, can be minimized by making sure that the Gd bolus is not too compact.
With most 3D CE-MRA studies, extensive efforts are made to optimally image the arterial phase. Once the arterial phase dataset is collected, the sequence can (and should) be repeated to obtain venous and equilibrium phases. Later phases are useful in detecting and evaluating dissections, portal venous or other venous structures, parenchymal enhancement patterns, tumors, and perhaps even renal glomerular function. Because these “later”-phase examinations occur more in the equilibrium phase of gadolinium distribution, signal is reduced as compared to arterial phase. In order to maximize signal in these later phases, the flip angle should, if possible, be reduced. Whereas the optimum flip angle for the arterial phase may be 30–40° at a TR of 4–6 ms, the optimal flip angle decreases to 15–25° in later phases. To image highly concentrated Gd excreted into the collecting system and ureter, use a high flip angle (45–60°) with the widest bandwidth and shortest possible echo time.
Postproccessing and Display CE-MRA produces a 3D volume of image data. The default data presentation is a series of contiguous images (slices) in the plane of acquisition (typically, coronal plane). These are referred to as source images. This dataset is best viewed interactively using a computer workstation allowing for thin multiplaner reformatting (MPR). In this manner, thin (typically, 2.0 mm) slices reconstructed at 1-mm intervals with 50% overlap can be viewed in axial, sagittal, coronal, or oblique planes. This eliminates overlapping structures and unfolds tortuous vessels. Because these reformatted slices remain thin and are not projections, they not only provide the best achievable contrast, but also minimize the chance of diagnostic error. Because single-voxel-thick reformations show only short vascular segments, it is advantageous to utilize the maximum intensity projection (MIP) postprocessing technique for
72
combining information from multiple slices to see longer segments of vessels. Using this algorithm, the user specifies the subvolume thickness and obliquity. The algorithm then generates rays perpendicular to the subvolume and uses the maximum value of any voxel encountered along that ray for the corresponding pixel intensity in the output image. This technique is fast, and works extremely well with CE-MRA, since vascular signal is much greater than background signal. It provides projection images that are similar to conventional angiograms. This technique is helpful for displaying complex vascular anatomy, particularly when vessels are not oriented along a single plane. Despite its usefulness, the MIP algorithm is subject to artifacts. Perhaps, the most common artifact arises when stationary tissue has greater signal intensity than the vascular structures of interest, as can occur in the presence of other vessel segments, fat, hemorrhage, metallic susceptibility artifacts, or motion artifacts. This in turn leads to the mapping of nonvascular signal into the projection image and causes a discontinuity in vessel signal, potentially mimicking a stenosis or occlusion. This type of artifact is best overcome by minimizing the thickness of the MIP subvolume, thereby excluding as much extraneous data as possible. Other artifacts inherent to the MIP technique have been described. These mainly consist of underestimating vessel lumen, and are more of a problem with TOF or PC techniques. Zebrastripe artifact from slices too thick can be reduced using zero filling in the slice direction. Because of these potential pitfalls, most authors agree that the MIP images should be used as a roadmap, utilizing the source images for definitive diagnosis. Some authors suggest volume rendering may be more accurate than the MIP and similar to using the MPR, but should still not replace careful evaluation of the source images and MPR. Subtraction techniques are also useful in image evaluation, particularly in vascular regions not subject to significant respiratory motion. These areas include the extremity, pelvic, and carotid and intracerebral arteries. A “digital subtraction” MRA is easily produced by subtracting precontrast from postcontrast magnitude image data. Provided the patient maintains the same position on both studies, subtraction will reduce background signal and improve vessel conspicuity. Subtraction is particularly useful in the extremities because they are stationary and subsequently have less chance for misregistration between the precontrast mask and arterial phase images. An improvement on this technique, particularly with thicker slice or 2D projection MRA exams, involves complex subtraction of the pre- and postcontrast “complex” or “raw” (k-space) datasets. Complex, vector subtraction detects both the phase and magnitude effects of Gd to obtain a larger effect from the contrast agent.
H. Zhang et al.
Whole-Body MRA The systemic nature of vascular disease, particularly atherosclerosis, means that vascular pathology is likely to be present in multiple vascular territories. With faster gradient systems and specialized coils, whole-body MRA to cover from the carotid arteries to the calf can be achieved by adding proximal stations to a peripheral MRA exam. However, it is difficult to scan fast enough with MR to keep up with the rapid flow of contrast down the legs. Excessive venous enhancement may obscure calf arteries and limit diagnostic utility in the lower extremities. A possible solution of this technique is placement of blood pressure cuffs (e.g., SmartTourniquet, TopSpins Inc, Ann Arbor, MI) as high up as possible toward the groin around the thighs for venous compression [31]. By applying subsystolic thigh compression with blood pressure cuffs, the window of arterial enhancement in the calf (only 35 ± 14 s without compression) is lengthened considerably. Venous compression whole-body MRA is simple to implement and is likely to enhance the performance of all other multistation MRA strategies for assessment of the peripheral arterial tree.
References 1. Zhang HL, Zhang W, Juluru K, Prince MR. Body magnetic resonance angiography. Semin Roentgenol. 2009;44:84–98. 2. Prince MR, Grist TM, Debatin JF. 3D Contrast MR Angiography. New York: Springer, 2003. 3. Fain SB, King BF, Breen JF, Kruger DG, Riederer SJ. High-spatialresolution contrast-enhanced MR angiography of the renal arteries: a prospective comparison with digital subtraction angiography. Radiology. 2001;218:481–490. 4. Hathout GM, Duh MJ, El-Saden SM. Accuracy of contrastenhanced MR angiography in predicting angiographic stenosis of the internal carotid artery: linear regression analysis. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2003;24:1747–1756. 5. Schoenberg SO, Rieger J, Weber CH. High-spatial-resolution MR angiography of renal arteries with integrated parallel acquisitions: comparison with digital subtraction angiography and US. Radiology. 2005;235:687–698. 6. Chung T, Muthupillai Rh. Application of SENSE in clinical pediatric body MR imaging. Top Magn Reson Imaging. 2004;15: 187–196. 7. Fink C, Ley S, Kroeker R, Requardt M, Kauczor HU, Bock M. Time-resolved contrast-enhanced three-dimensional magnetic resonance angiography of the chest: combination of parallel imaging with view sharing (TREAT). Invest Radiol. 2005;40:40–48. 8. Tsuchiya K, Honya K, Fujikawa A, Tateishi H, Shiokawa Y. Postoperative assessment of extracranial-intracranial bypass by time-resolved 3D contrast-enhanced MR angiography using parallel imaging. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2005;26:2243–2247. 9. Xu Y, Haacke EM. Partial Fourier imaging in multi-dimensions: a means to save a full factor of two in time. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2001;14:628–635.
4
Technical Aspect of Contrast-Enhanced MRA
10. Hu HH, Madhuranthakam AJ, Kruger DG, Glockner JF, Riederer SJ. Combination of 2D sensitivity encoding and 2D partial fourier techniques for improved acceleration in 3D contrast-enhanced MR angiography. Magn Reson Med. 2006;55:16–22. 11. Zaitsev M ZK, Shah NJ. Shared k-space echo planar imaging with keyhole. Magn Reson Med. 2001;45:109–117. 12. Zhu H, Buck DG, Zhang Z, et al. High temporal and spatial resolution 4D MRA using spiral data sampling and sliding window reconstruction. Magn Reson Med. 2004;52:14–18. 13. Mistretta CA, Wieben O, Velikina J, et al. Highly constrained backprojection for time-resolved MRI. Magn Reson Med. 2006; 55:30–40. 14. Wang Y, Johnston DL, Breen JF, et al. Dynamic MR digital subtraction angiography using contrast enhancement, fast data acquisition, and complex subtraction. Magn Reson Med. 1996;36:551–556. 15. Wilman AH, Yep TC, Al-Kwifi O. Quantitative evaluation of nonrepetitive phase-encoding orders for first-pass, 3D contrastenhanced MR angiography. Magn Reson Med. 2001;46:541–547. 16. Riederer SJ, Fain SB, Kruger DG, Busse RF. Real-time imaging and triggering of 3D contrast-enhanced MR angiograms using MR fluoroscopy. Magma. 1999;8:196–206. 17. Wilman AH, Riederer SJ, King BF, Debbins JP, Rossman PJ, Ehman RL. Fluoroscopically triggered contrast-enhanced threedimensional MR angiography with elliptical centric view order: application to the renal arteries. Radiology. 1997;205:137–146. 18. Goldfarb JW, Prasad PV, Griswold MA, Edelman RR. Dynamic three-dimensional magnetic resonance abdominal angiography and perfusion: implementation and preliminary experience. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2000;11:201–207. 19. Watts R, Wang Y, Redd B, et al. Recessed elliptical-centric viewordering for contrast-enhanced 3D MR angiography of the carotid arteries. Magn Reson Med. 2002;48:419–424. 20. Robert P, Violas X, Santus R, Le Bihan D, Corot C. Optimization of a blood pool contrast agent injection protocol for MR angiography. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2005;21:611–619. 21. Li W, Tutton S, Vu AT, et al. First-pass contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance angiography in humans using ferumoxytol, a novel ultr-
73
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
asmall superparamagnetic iron oxide (USPIO)-based blood pool agent. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2005;21:46–52. Ersoy H, Jacobs P, Kent CK, Prince MR. Blood pool MR angiography of aortic stent-graft endoleak. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2004;182:1181–1186. Prince MR, Zhang H, Morris M, et al. Incidence of nephrogenic systemic fibrosis at two large medical centers. Radiology. 2008;248:807–816. Kramer U, Fenchel M, Laub G, et al. Low-dose, time-resolved, contrast-enhanced 3D MR angiography in the assessment of the abdominal aorta and its major branches at 3 Tesla. Acad Radiol. 2010;17:564–576. Born M, Willinek WA, Gieseke J, von Falkenhausen M, Schild H, Kuhl CK. Sensitivity encoding (SENSE) for contrast-enhanced 3D MR angiography of the abdominal arteries. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2005;22:559–565. Kopka L, Vosshenrich R, Rodenwaldt J, Grabbe E. Differences in injection rates on contrast-enhanced breath-hold three-dimensional MR angiography. AJR Am J Roentgenol.1998;170:345–348. Prince MR, Chabra SG, Watts R, et al. Contrast material travel times in patients undergoing peripheral MR angiography. Radiology. 2002;224:55–61. Turski PA, Korosec FR, Carroll TJ, Willig DS, Grist TM, Mistretta CA. Contrast-Enhanced magnetic resonance angiography of the carotid bifurcation using the time-resolved imaging of contrast kinetics (TRICKS) technique. Top Magn Reson Imaging. 2001;12:175–181. Naganawa S, Koshikawa T, Fukatsu H, et al. Contrast-enhanced MR angiography of the carotid artery using 3D time-resolved imaging of contrast kinetics: comparison with real-time fluoroscopic triggered 3D-elliptical centric view ordering. Radiat Med. 2001;19:185–192. Du J, Carroll TJ, Wagner HJ, et al. Time-resolved, undersampled projection reconstruction imaging for high-resolution CE-MRA of the distal runoff vessels. Magn Reson Med. 2002;48:516–522. Zhang HL, Ho BY, Chao M, et al. Decreased venous contamination on 3D gadolinium-enhanced bolus chase peripheral MR angiography using thigh compression. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2004;183: 1041–1047.
wwwwwwwwwwww
5
Time-Resolved, Contrast-Enhanced MR Angiography Using Cartesian Methods Stephen J. Riederer, Clifton R. Haider, Casey P. Johnson, and Petrice M. Mostardi
Introduction and Overview Ever since the introduction of contrast-enhanced MR angiography (CE-MRA) in the mid-1990s [1, 2], there has been steady improvement in the technique. Early investigations identified a number of performance targets, including the desirability for high-spatial-resolution 3D imaging, need to synchronize the acquisition to the arterial phase of the contrast bolus passage, and desirability for minimal enhancement of the venous system. To a great extent, these were addressed with the development of short repetition time (TR) gradient echo pulse sequences, nonreal-time [3] and realtime [4, 5] means for determination of accurate timing, and development of centric view orders which allowed extended acquisition times into the venous phase [6]. Early on, there also was interest in the development of time-resolved techniques to allow visualization of the temporal passage of the contrast bolus through a targeted vascular system. One way to do this was by simply repeating the application of a pulse sequence. For 3DFT acquisition, the total number of repetitions is equal to NY × NZ, where NY and NZ are the number of phase-encoding steps in the y and z directions, respectively. The acquisition time for one image, Tacq, is then given by Tacq = NY × NZ × TR. For repetition times of 10 ms, as available in the mid-1990s, this restricted the NY × NZ values to be in the range of 64 × 32 in order to limit the acquisition times to about 20 s. Times much longer than this would have limited value in portraying contrast bolus passage, particularly for the arterial phase. One way to allow shorter acquisition times was to convert from a 3DFT to a 2DFT pulse sequence, as studied with “MR DSA” [7]. This allowed the portrayal of contrast material passage with acquisition times of 2 s or less, but in a projection or thickS.J. Riederer, PhD () • C.R. Haider, PhD • C.P. Johnson • P.M. Mostardi Department of Radiology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN 55902, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
slice format; i.e., the z spatial resolution was sacrificed in exchange for improved time resolution. The above illustrates the fundamental trade-off between spatial and temporal resolution in MRI. During the time the contrast bolus passes through the vasculature, the MR data acquisition time can be spent in sampling as many low- and high-spatial-frequency k-space phase encodings as possible once each or it can be spent in sampling some subset of spatial frequencies multiple times each. The first of these provides a single, high-spatial-resolution image. The latter provides a time series of images having reduced spatial resolution. One way to modify this relationship is to use the method of “view sharing” [8] in which images are reconstructed at time intervals smaller than the intrinsic acquisition time Tacq. A variant of this is to sample the low spatial frequencies in 3D k-space at a higher rate than high spatial frequencies and to then reconstruct a full image at the sampling rate used for the low spatial frequencies. This is the basis of keyhole imaging [9] and the TRICKS technique [10]. Because the appearance of an MR image is dominated by the state of the magnetization during the measurement of the low spatial frequency or “central” views, the resultant images tend to at least superficially represent the contrast material distribution at the times of the central k-space samplings. However, depending on the manner and speed by which k-space is sampled, the resultant images are subject to artifact [11], as to be discussed briefly in this chapter. The above-described trade-off of spatial and temporal resolution was altered by the discovery of methods of “parallel acquisition,” first introduced in the late 1990s. Parallel acquisition is based on the principle that the redundancy of measurements of the magnetization made using multiple vs. a single receiver coil can allow a reduction in the total number of repetitions of the acquisition for some given spatial resolution. With one class of parallel acquisition techniques, the signal values at specific target k-space phase-encoding locations are estimated from samples at nearby measured points and from knowledge of the spatial response functions of the receiver coils. Such k-space-based methods include
J.C. Carr and T.J. Carroll (eds.), Magnetic Resonance Angiography: Principles and Applications, DOI 10.1007/978-1-4419-1686-0_5, © Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2012
75
76
“SMASH” [12] and “GRAPPA” [13]. With the second broad class of techniques called “SENSE” [14], aliased reconstructed images formed individually from multiple receiver coils are algebraically combined with the coil spatial response functions to provide the unaliased result. The above-cited works describe parallel acquisition performed along one phase-encoding direction, for which case the typical maximum practical acceleration R is about 4. However, these methods can be applied along the two phase-encoding directions of 3DFT acquisition [15] for which accelerations of R = 8 or more are routinely possible. The use of parallel acquisition has a price: compared to an unaccelerated acquisition, the use of a reduced number of measurements and the additional mathematics required to form the final image adds complexity and causes a reduction of the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). If severe, the SNR loss may render the accelerated images nondiagnostic. One of the only ways to address this is by the use of a receiver coil array which is designed to perform parallel acquisition effectively. Also, compared to applications in which the magnetization state does not change from one repetition to the next, CE-MRA is more immune to SNR loss. This is because the acceleration in effect causes more of the k-space data to be sampled during the highly enhanced phase of the contrast bolus passage [16]. For these reasons, effective coil design and 2D parallel acquisition are well-matched to the standard acquisition techniques used for CE-MRA. In the remainder of this chapter, a number of the above techniques and relationships are discussed in more detail. Examples are drawn from time-resolved CE-MRA of several vascular territories.
Methods
S.J. Riederer et al.
reconstructed, and ideally is chosen to be just larger than the size of the object along that direction. The total length along a k-space direction over which sampling is performed is proportional to the spatial resolution along that conjugate direction. For example, the further one samples along the kX direction, then the finer the spatial resolution is along x. Once k-space is adequately sampled, the final image is formed by inverse Fourier transform of the accumulated data set. With Cartesian methods, the sampled k-space points are along a rectilinear pattern, with the principal directions of the pattern along kX, kY, and kZ. For 3D acquisition, it is assumed that the kX direction corresponds to frequency encoding, and during one repetition of the acquisition all kX points for a specific combination of (kY, kZ) values are sampled. Because sampling along kX occurs quickly, within msec, it is convenient to characterize the specific manner that k-space is sampled in Cartesian 3D acquisition by simply focusing on the kY–kZ plane. Non-Cartesian methods can be described as those in which the k-space sampling deviates from that described above. The 3D rectilinear sampling pattern is disrupted along one or more of the three directions. Cartesian and non-Cartesian methods both have their relative advantages. Cartesian techniques are useful in general and valuable for 3D CE-MRA for several specific reasons. These include the following: (1) the rectilinear k-space sampling pattern lends itself to straightforward image reconstruction by fast Fourier transformation; (2) truncated FOVs can readily be created along two directions using the processes of slice selection (along z) and bandwidth limitations (along x); (3) the intrinsic rectilinear sampling pattern readily allows the regular undersampling desired for performing parallel acquisition; and (4) the ability to easily and preferentially sample the center of k-space is retained. Description of non-Cartesian methods is outside the scope of this chapter.
Cartesian Sampling Here, a brief review of Cartesian sampling is provided as background for the pulse sequences to be described in the remainder of the chapter. With virtually all MRI acquisition techniques, an image is formed by sampling its Fourier transform. If the spatial coordinates of the 3D image are (x, y, z), then the “conjugate variable” coordinates of its Fourier transform are (kX, kY, kZ). This latter, three-dimensional space is called “k-space.” For each repetition of the data acquisition, a different region of k-space is sampled, the specific region depending upon the gradient waveforms applied. The MR signal is sampled at discrete time points, causing the sampling of k-space to be performed at discrete points. The spacing between consecutive k-space points in a specific direction, e.g., kX, is equal to the reciprocal of the field of view (FOV) along the conjugate (here, x) direction in the resultant image. FOV is the distance over which the image is periodically
k-Space Sampling for Time-Resolved CE-MRA Figure 5.1 shows a progression of sampling patterns for Cartesian 3DFT acquisitions. In all cases, the kY–kZ phaseencoding plane is shown, and the dots indicate the specific possible locations at which samples can be measured. As discussed above, the rectilinear pattern of dots is due to the Cartesian nature of the sampling. Figure 5.1a also shows an orange central disk and black annular region, the black region extending out to radius kM. The disk defined by this radius specifies the region within which actual measurements are made at the discrete points. The radius kM is selected according to the desired spatial resolution: the larger the radius, the finer the spatial resolution. In this figure, sampling of the corners of kY–kZ space is not performed. This is done to make the spatial resolution approximately isotropic within the y–z
5
Time-Resolved, Contrast-Enhanced MR Angiography Using Cartesian Methods
77
Fig. 5.1 Plots of the kY–kZ phase-encoding plane for 3DFT acquisition and various CAPR sampling patterns and readouts. (a) Full sampling out to some maximum k radius, kM. (b) Schematic time ordering of the sampling pattern of (a). (c) Sampling pattern with undersampling allowed in the annular black region. (d) Time ordering used to sample (c). Note the reduced overall duration because of the annular undersampling. (e) Sampling pattern used for CAPR. The vanes of (b) are further apportioned into individual vane sets, each set designated with a different color. (f) Time ordering used for the CAPR acquisition. Sampling alternates between the central orange region and one of the vane sets. (g) Further undersampling applied to the CAPR pattern as allowed with parallel acquisition along both the kY and kZ directions. (h) Time ordering for accelerated CAPR
plane [17]. Also, not sampling the corners provides an approximate 25% (p/4) reduction of acquisition time vs. the case of sampling the full square array of points. It is possible to use different maximum k-space radii along the kY and kZ directions of Fig. 5.1a in case it is desired to have different spatial resolution along y vs. z. Similarly, different FOVs along y and z would cause the spacing between points to differ along the kY and kZ directions in accordance with the 1/ FOV dependence described earlier. Figure 5.1b illustrates a possible time order with which the desired phase-encoding “views” of Fig. 5.1a are sampled. The experimentalist has control of this and may select a specific view order depending on the application. For CE-MRA, the “elliptical centric” view order [6] is commonly used, in which each measured point is first ranked according to its radius from the kY–kZ origin, smallest to largest. The time order of sampling is done using this ranking. In this example of Fig. 5.1a, b, because the points within the orange disk are
closest to the k-space origin, they are sampled first in the sequence. Once these are completely sampled, the process continues to sampling of the points within the black annular region. This is represented schematically in the time ordering of the orange and black blocks of Fig. 5.1b. Similar centric-like samplings are also possible [18]. Figure 5.1c illustrates a variant of the sampling shown in (A) in which the circular sampling region has been decomposed into a central orange disk and a set of vanes. As before, only those points falling within one of these regions are actually sampled. Thus, in the outer annular region, points which lie in a gap between two vanes are not sampled. This reduction in the number of sampled points allows a proportionate reduction in the acquisition time vs. (A), a factor approaching 2.0 in the limit of the central orange region becoming increasingly small. During image reconstruction, the data in these gaps can be filled with zeroes or alternatively it can be estimated using partial Fourier–homodyne techniques [19, 20].
78
In practice, the radius of the central orange disk is typically 0.2–0.4 that of kM, leading to an acquisition time reduction or “acceleration” factor due to this homodyne processing of RHD = 1.6–1.8. Figure 5.1d shows the accompanying temporal playout of the samples of Fig. 5.1c assuming elliptical centric ordering. Note the reduction in acquisition duration depicted schematically vs. (B). Repeating the measurement process of Fig. 5.1d would provide a time-resolved 3D Cartesian sequence for which the frame time or the time between consecutive reconstruction time points would match the overall acquisition time for one image. However, as shown in (E), it is possible to convert the pattern of (C) into one which readily allows view sharing and a reduced frame time. In this case, the vanes comprising the outer annular region are subdivided into sets, each vane set shown in a different color, four in this example. The same points in kY–kZ space are sampled as in (C), but the temporal playout is now altered as shown in (F). This starts with a sampling of the central orange disk region, but is then followed with that of one of the vane sets, here black. The time ordering within all colored blocks is again done using the EC view order. This is followed by a second sampling of the orange disk, followed by sampling of a second vane set, here green. This process repeats until all four vane sets have been sampled, at which time the process repeats itself. Figure 5.2 shows how the measured data are sorted into the image series. Figure 5.2a repeats the playout of data acquisition shown in Fig. 5.1f. Once all four vane sets have been sampled, reconstruction for the first image can be performed. Due to the redundant sampling of the central disk, there is flexibility in how the sorting is done. One method is that shown in Fig. 5.2b. In this case, in addition to the four vane sets, the central orange k-space measurement made just before the last vane set is used in image reconstruction. In studies to be briefly described later in this chapter and described in detail in Mostardi et al. [11], this has been found to provide a good compromise between sharpness in portraying the bolus leading edge and spatial resolution. In Fig. 5.2b, the short vertical arrow indicates the specific time to which the first reconstructed image, “Image 1,” is ascribed. This time corresponds to sampling of the central-most view within the orange region. Again, in Mostardi et al. [11], assignment of this frame time to this point within the data acquisition has been shown to be accurate. Figure 5.2c shows sorting for the second image. In this case, the earliest measured vane set (black) of Image 1, along with central k-space, has been replaced with updated samples while measurements for the three other vane sets have been retained. This process of replacing central k-space and one vane set and sharing views from the others continue for subsequent images in the series as shown. The sampling pattern of Fig. 5.1e and data sorting of Fig. 5.2 are but one specific implementation of the CAPR pulse sequence. Variables include the relative radius of the central
S.J. Riederer et al.
Fig. 5.2 (a) Time ordering of data acquisition for CAPR. The colored blocks refer to the regions of k-space identified in Fig. 5.1e. (b) Selection of data from (a) used to form Image 1. Vertical arrow identifies the time ascribed to the image. (c) Selection of data from (a) used to form Image 2. (d) Time ordering of data acquisition for 2D-accelerated CAPR with colored blocks referenced to Fig. 5.1g. Because of the reduced number of points within each region, the durations of all colored blocks are smaller than in (d) vs. (a). (e, f) Selection of data from (d) used to form Images 1 and 2
orange disk, the number of vane sets, and whether or not 2D homodyne reconstruction is used. In the limit of only one vane set with 2D homodyne sampling disabled, the sequence reverts to a standard, single-phase 3D acquisition (Fig. 5.1a). Alternative patterns for sampling kY–kZ space using a rectilinear Cartesian sampling pattern and for data sorting have also been studied. These include the original TRICKS technique which also used temporal interpolation [10], TREAT [21, 22], TWIST [23, 24], keyhole methods [9, 25, 26], and others [27]. Details of these are available in the respective references.
Parallel Acquisition A method which has proven to be critical in favorably altering the balance between spatial and temporal resolution is
5
Time-Resolved, Contrast-Enhanced MR Angiography Using Cartesian Methods
parallel acquisition. As described earlier in this chapter, the method is based on simultaneously measuring the MRI signal with multiple receiver coils and using the redundant information to estimate unmeasured samples. Avoiding actual measurement of the estimated samples allows a reduction in acquisition time. Parallel acquisition was originally described for reducing the number of samples along the single phase-encoding direction of 2DFT Cartesian acquisition, and acceleration factors R in the range of 2–4 were reported [28, 29]. Accelerations larger than this often lead to unacceptably low SNR. However, it was subsequently recognized that the method can be applied to multiple phase-encoding directions, such as the two directions of 3DFT acquisition [15]. This generally allows a given acceleration at considerably less SNR loss than for 2DFT acquisition. An accelerated acquisition is performed by reducing the number of sampled points in k-space and accounting for this in the reconstruction. For purposes of discussion in this chapter, it is assumed that the “SENSE” parallel acquisition technique is performed, but many aspects of the implementation apply to other acceleration techniques as well. Starting with the original sampling pattern, the undersampling is generally done evenly across all of k-space. This is where the intrinsic, evenly spaced rectilinear pattern of Cartesian sampling readily lends itself to the further undersampling desirable for parallel acquisition. Suppose, for example, it is desirable to undersample by twofold along both kY and kZ, yielding a net acceleration R = RY × RZ = 2 × 2 = 4. The CAPR sequence presented previously (Fig. 5.1e) can be readily converted to this (Fig. 5.1g). Every other measured point of the original pattern has been eliminated along both the kY and kZ directions. The temporal playout of views with this SENSE-accelerated view-shared sequence is schematically shown in Fig. 5.1h. Because of the acceleration, the temporal width of each region is reduced, thus allowing a reduction in the frame rate as well as the overall acquisition time necessary for each image. Figure 5.2d–f shows the view playout and data sorting for the case of accelerated CAPR acquisition of Fig. 5.1g, h. Note that for the same extent of k-space coverage, i.e., the same spatial resolution, the frame time is markedly reduced compared to the unaccelerated case of Fig. 5.2a–c. One can question how far parallel acquisition can be taken to reduce acquisition time. The practical limit depends on the SNR of the resultant image. It has been shown that SNR is lost in parallel-accelerated images in inverse proportion to the product of R and g, where R is the acceleration factor and g is a measure of the noise amplification dependent on the similarity of spatial responses of the individual coil elements comprising the coil array [14]. This latter “g-factor” is a spatially varying function which takes on values at or larger than its ideal value of unity.
79
Temporal Footprint Analysis With view-shared sequences, there is correlation from one image to the next because of the commonality of at least some of the data. That is to say, the temporal resolution of such a sequence is not exactly as small as the time between consecutive images in the time series. Expressed another way, two acquisition techniques which may have the same frame time might not have the same temporal resolution in distinguishing two phenomena. To attempt to elucidate this, the parameter of “temporal footprint” has been proposed [30]. The temporal footprint is defined as the time interval over which the k-space data that contributes to the image is acquired. If views are not shared from one image to the next in a series, then the temporal footprint is simply equal to the acquisition time for each image. For the case of CAPR, the temporal footprint can be seen from the data sorting plot of Fig. 5.2. For Image 1 (Fig. 5.1b), this is the time span from the start of acquisition of the first vane set (black) to the end of the last vane set (red). Note that this is larger than the frame time, the time between consecutive images in the series. Figure 5.3 is a plot of the temporal footprint vs. the frame time for a 3D image of given spatial resolution. The outermost curve is for the case of no parallel acquisition (R = 1), and the rightmost point of the curve is for the case of no view sharing. For this case, the footprint matches the frame time, as expected. Suppose next that additional measurements of the phase-encoding views at and near central k-space are somehow inserted into this process, as shown previously in Fig. 5.1f. This specific case of the use of four vane sets is referred, here, as an “N4” acquisition, and this operating point is identified on the outermost curve. In general, decomposition of the sampling pattern of Fig. 5.1e can be done into N vane sets, leading to the corresponding operating point on the curve in Fig. 5.3 as shown. In general, as N increases, the level of view sharing increases in that the fraction of data maintained from one image to the next increases. Although this leads to a reduction in the frame time and a higher frame rate, it is accompanied by an increase in the temporal footprint. At some point, an extended temporal footprint can lead to an undesirable level of artifact. Consider next the effect of parallel acquisition. An acceleration of R allows the acquisition time to be reduced by R for fixed spatial resolution. In Fig. 5.3, this causes the temporal footprint vs. frame time curve to be shifted down and left toward the origin, as seen for the curves for R = 2, 4, and 8. High accelerations allow a radical shift of the original curve, allowing performance with markedly smaller frame time and smaller temporal footprint compared to that of the R = 1 reference. The innermost curve of Fig. 5.3 is for R = 8, an acceleration which has been shown to be feasible for time-resolved CE-MRA of the peripheral vasculature [31]. At the operating
80
S.J. Riederer et al.
Fig. 5.3 Diagram of temporal footprint vs. frame time. Each point along a given curve corresponds to a specific degree of view sharing. As this degree increases, the frame time is reduced, but the temporal footprint gets longer. Each curve corresponds to a different factor R of acceleration due to some version of parallel acquisition, such as with SENSE
point of N4, a frame time of 5 s is allowed using a temporal footprint of less than 20 s. Both of these times are markedly smaller than the acquisition time of 105 s required for a single-phase image with no parallel acquisition.
Receiver Coils for Parallel-Accelerated, Time-Resolved CE-MRA The typically coronal imaging orientation of CE-MRA readily lends itself to the design of effective coil arrays for parallel acquisition. In the coronal format, the frequency encoding or readout direction is typically chosen to be along the superior/inferior (S/I) direction. This means that the two phaseencoding directions are within the transverse plane, generally left/right (L/R) for phase encoding and anterior/posterior (A/P) for slice encoding. Coil elements can then be formed into an array such that the central axis of each element lies within the transverse plane. This is important because it is along this axis that the spatial sensitivity is greatly variable and can be controlled, thus allowing some control of the g-factor governing noise amplification. The design and optimization of coils for parallel acquisition of the calves are illustrated in Fig. 5.4. Figure 5.4a shows a maximum-intensity-projection (MIP) image of the calves of volunteer acquired with 2D SENSE-accelerated (R = 7.3) CAPR CE-MRA acquisition with a frame time of 5.0 s and temporal footprint of 17.7 s. Spatial resolution is 1-mm isotropic. An eight-element receiver coil array was used, placed circumferentially around the subject’s calves. Although the image quality is considered to be very good, there is still some falloff of signal at the superior and inferior extents of the 40-cm FOV (arrows), there is slight graininess in the result, and although not evident from the figure there was a considerable gap between the subject’s legs and the coil.
Fig. 5.4 Example of effective coil design for 2D-SENSE-accelerated CE-MRA. (a) MIP of calves made with original eight-element receiver coil. Arrows identify falloff at superior and inferior regions. (b) MIP of calves of a different volunteer acquired using modified coil. Note improved S/I coverage and improved SNR vs. (a). (c) Box plots of g-factors for original coil (blue) and modified coil (yellow) several different 2D accelerations (panels A and B reproduced from Haider et al. [31] with permission; panel C reproduced from Johnson et al. [32] with permission)
5
Time-Resolved, Contrast-Enhanced MR Angiography Using Cartesian Methods
81
This was addressed by redesigning the coil array. Specifically, the coil elements were increased from 21.4 to 27.1 cm in length and the two anterior and two posterior elements were all reduced in width from 14.4 to 10.5 cm. This reduced the net circumference to allow a tighter fit of the coil array to the anatomy and reduced the noise amplification due to acceleration in the A/P (z) direction. A result made using the modified coil with the same acquisition but a different subject is shown in Fig. 5.4b. Image quality is markedly improved. Figure 5.4c is a comparison of the range of g-factors occurring over the volume of the calves for four different 2D SENSE acceleration factors for the original coil array (blue plots) and the modified array (yellow). Note the desired reduction in g-values allowed with the new coil. Also note that even for R = 4 × 2 = 8 the 75th percentile g-factor value is still less than 1.4. Similar coil arrays can be developed to facilitate highly 2D-accelerated CE-MRA for other anatomic regions, such as brain, arms and hands, thorax, abdomen, thighs, and feet.
The Signal Enhancement Effect in Accelerated Contrast-Enhanced MRA As stated above, the application of parallel acquisition to MRI extracts a price in lost SNR. However, for the case of CE-MRA, the SNR loss is not as severe as might initially be expected. The above-stated relationship linking SNR loss to the acceleration R and the g-factor assumes that the magnetization level does not change during the acquisition. However, for CE-MRA, the signal of interest due to the contrast bolus is time dependent or transient, and this tempers the degree of SNR loss. This effect has been studied in detail in Riederer et al. [16], but the essence of the result is illustrated in Fig. 5.5. Figure 5.5a shows the hypothetical signal at a point in a blood vessel due to the time-dependent passage of the contrast-enhanced blood. The behavior is modeled here with a gamma variate function, but the exact mathematical dependence is not important other than that the signal rapidly comes to a peak and then wanes over time with a time constant on the order of several tens of seconds. Next, assume that data are acquired for a CE MR angiogram using a 3DFT acquisition with the elliptical centric view order. Furthermore, assume that the acquisition is triggered to start at peak contrast, corresponding to t = 0 in (A). This acquisition matches the time-dependent signal to kY–kZ space repetition by repetition. However, because the k-space values used are ordered according to their k-space radius, this matching can simply be reflected as a scaling of the bolus curve with kr, shown in Fig. 5.5b for the unaccelerated R = 1 case. Here, kr is defined as the distance from a point in the kY–kZ plane to the origin. Next, consider the case of accelerated acquisition with an assumed R = 4. As shown previously in comparing Fig. 5.1e–g,
Fig. 5.5 Graphic illustration of signal enhancement effect in 2D-accelerated CE-MRA. (a) Schematic plot of contrast bolus passage through a region within an artery. CE-MRA acquisition using centric phase-encoding order is assumed to start at t = 0. (b) Plots of the signal of (a) as mapped to kY–kZ space for the cases of no acceleration (R = 1) and assumed acceleration R = 4. For the latter, note that the area under the curve is larger and the shoulder is broader (reproduced from Riederer et al. [16] with permission)
accelerated acquisition causes increased gaps in k-space between the sampled points. In mapping the bolus curve of Fig. 5.5a to k-space for the accelerated case, the regions of peak signal are pushed out to larger kr values because of this increased sampling distance between points. The accelerated case is shown for R = 4 in Fig. 5.5b. The difference between the R = 1 and R = 4 curves in Fig. 5.5b is important in two ways. First, the area under each curve is proportional to the signal level in the final image. Clearly, that for the R = 4 case is larger, leading to an increased relative signal vs. the unaccelerated case. This effect compensates in part for the R- and g-factor-related SNR loss. A second important difference is in the shape of the curves in Fig. 5.5b. The wider shoulder of the R = 4 case leads to a narrower point spread function in y–z space, indicating sharper spatial resolution for an equal extent of k-space sampling. Another way to explain the signal enhancement effect in CE-MRA is that acceleration causes the high-contrast, arterial-phase signal to be assigned over a broader region of k-space. This then leads to an overall signal enhancement. In Riederer et al. [16], the signal enhancement effect is studied in more mathematical and experimental detail.
82
Specifically, the enhancement effect is demonstrated experimentally as being about 20% in R = 4 SENSE-accelerated images of the intracranial venous system for a CE-MRA study using intravenously administered contrast material.
Temporal Fidelity in Contrast-Enhanced MRA Although view sharing allows a reduction in the frame time and parallel acquisition allows a reduction in the overall acquisition time, neither of these methods has driven the absolute acquisition time of 3D CE-MRA down to the subsecond level. Thus, it is important to determine how accurately an image reconstructed for a specific time point using some kind of 3D CE-MRA method represents the actual signal in the contrast-enhanced vasculature at the time point. A number of methods have attempted to do this by simulation; e.g., 33. Starting with some assumed temporal enhancement pattern, such as the gamma variate of Fig. 5.5a, the signal in a blood vessel of some assumed size is simulated and then matched to k-space using the assumed CE-MRA acquisition technique. Fourier transformation of the simulated, sampled k-space gives the final image. In addition to simulation, it is possible to study such temporal fidelity effects experimentally, as in Mostardi et al. [11]. In this work, a phantom was constructed (Fig. 5.6a) in which rods filled with diluted contrast material were translated under computer control through the FOV of the MRI system. The abrupt leading edge of the phantom allows measurement of any temporal blurring or artifact which might precede the advancing edge in a CE-MRA image. Sample results from one experiment are shown in Fig. 5.6b–e. In all cases, the frequency-encoding direction is along the direction of motion, left to right in the results shown. Figure 5.6b is an enlargement of the leading edge of the phantom showing a small level of blur, defined as the width between the 25 and 75% levels of full signal. This was measured as 10 mm or about 10% of the 104-mm distance moved from one time frame to the next. The assumed acquisition was the CAPR method of Fig. 5.1e using no acceleration; i.e., R = 1. Figure 5.6c shows results using a random view ordering in the kY–kZ plane. This order has properties akin to projection reconstruction or radial acquisition in which central k-space is sampled throughout the frame time. All other aspects of the acquisition were identical to that used for (B). As shown, this causes the blur to be 60 mm, considerably larger than in (B). Figure 5.6d, e shows results for the CAPR and random-order acquisitions using 2D SENSE acceleration of R = 7.3. The resultant reduced frame time causes the frame-to-frame advance of the phantom to be reduced from 104 to 22 mm. The accelerated CAPR acquisition shows a reduction in blurring from 10 to 7 mm, still well focusing the leading edge of the phantom. For the random
S.J. Riederer et al.
ordering (E), the blurring is also reduced as expected, but the blur width is still more than half of the distance traveled per update. The above example demonstrates that for a given sampling pattern and view order, the sharpness in portraying the advancing contrast bolus improves as the temporal footprint is reduced using k-space undersampling acceleration techniques. The results also prove that the view order itself can have a major impact on controlling the sharpness of the image. Even with the reduced temporal footprint allowed by R = 7.3 acceleration, the random view ordering of (E) had inferior sharpness to the elliptical centric ordering pattern of (B) for the unaccelerated case.
Fig. 5.6 Experimental phantom studies for assessment of CAPR performance. (a) Schematic of computer-controlled phantom. (b–e) Comparisons of elliptical centric (EC) vs. random phase-encode ordering without (R = 1) and with (R = 7.3) acceleration. Enlargements of leading edge of moving phantom acquired with (b) EC, R = 1; (c) random, R = 1; (d) EC, R = 7.3; (e) random, R = 7.3. Note that EC provides sharper edge depiction than random, and acceleration provides sharper edge depiction than no acceleration (reproduced from Mostardi et al. [11] with permission)
5
Time-Resolved, Contrast-Enhanced MR Angiography Using Cartesian Methods
Results Accelerated, time-resolved, 3D Cartesian CE-MRA has been used in imaging many vascular regions. Here, we present representative results using the CAPR technique.
MRI Data Acquisition 3D CAPR examinations were performed on a number of subjects using a protocol approved by the Institutional Review Board of our institution. For all volunteers, written consent was provided. The examinations were performed using the CAPR sampling pattern discussed previously. A fast gradient echo pulse sequence was used, typically with the following parameters: repetition time (TR) 5.85 ms; echo time (TE) 2.7 ms; flip angle 30°; bandwidth ±62.5 kHz; and a full echo comprising 400 points. SENSE calibration was performed using a similar sequence, except with a flip angle of 10°; bandwidth of ±31.25 kHz; and a fourfold reduction in the Y × Z spatial resolution. Because of the time-resolved nature of the acquisition, no timing bolus is necessary. However, to obtain an accurate subtraction, a fully sampled CAPR image was acquired prior to injection of contrast material. The general contrast administration technique used was injection of 20 mL of gadobenate dimeglumine contrast agent (Multihance; Bracco Diagnostics, Princeton NJ) administered at a rate of 3 mL/s into the antecubital vein using a power injector (Spectris; Medrad; Indianola PA). This was followed by a saline flush of 20 mL administered at 3 mL/s. Automated reconstructions of all images were performed using a custom system interfaced to the MR imager. The time delay from end of acquisition to image display for a CAPR sequence comprising over 30 time frames was typically no longer than two minutes, thus allowing immediate clinical review.
In Vivo Results Figure 5.7 shows results in the calves from three normal subjects and illustrates the intrinsic spatial and temporal resolution of the method. Common temporal enhancement patterns are shown as follows: simultaneous bilateral filling of the arterial vasculature of both calves (A1–A4); early filling of one side (here, the right) vs. the other (B1–B4); and fast arterial transit with fast arterial-to-venous circulation (C1–C4). In B2 and B3, note that venous return is already starting in the proximal region (arrows), but owing to the short 5-s frame time and the high temporal fidelity, this can readily be distinguished from the arterial signal in the same region in (B1). In C1–C4, note the rapid transit of the contrast bolus
83
along nearly the full superior–inferior extent of the FOV in going from C1 to C2. Also, note the prominent venous signals in some structures only one frame (5 s) after initial filling (arrows, C3). The high precision in the temporal and spatial resolution of the CAPR acquisition is illustrated in the study shown in Fig. 5.8. The spatial resolution readily supports magnification and projection at arbitrary angles. The temporal resolution allows clear determination of the sources of the blood for the major vessels. Figure 5.9 shows results from another study of the calves, this from a subject who was first imaged using CT angiography because of suspicion of peripheral vascular disease. This study illustrates how CTA can be limited by calcification interfering with assessment of the vessel lumen. However, CE-MRA does not have this limitation. Figure 5.10 illustrates the application of CAPR to CE-MRA of the hands. In this case, the sequence was modified to provide a somewhat shorter update time (3 vs. 5 s) and temporal footprint (12 vs. 17 s) compared to those used for the calves. Figure 10.5 shows 3 full coronal MIP images calculated 30.0, 33.0, and 57.0 s, after the injection of contrast agent, respectively. Also shown are time-of-arrival (TOA) maps [34] of the left hand with the displayed values approximately limited to the arterial phase (D), and with all arrival times displayed (E–F) at several projection angles. CAPR has also been used to image the vasculature of the brain. In this case, the CAPR acquisition parameters are generally modified to allow for a somewhat faster frame time to account for the reduced arterial-to-venous transit time. The study of Fig. 5.11 was acquired using a 2.3-s frame time and shows the early arterial phase (A) formed 21.3 s post injection, and late arterial (B, 23.6 s), early venous (C, 25.9 s), and subsequent venous (D, 28.2 s) phases. A general, easily assessable measure of the temporal fidelity of a time-resolved MR angiographic sequence is its ability to generate an image of the intracranial arterial system devoid of venous enhancement. Figure 5.12a–c all clearly demonstrates this. Signals in the superior sagittal sinus are not apparent until the next frame 2.3 s later (arrows, D). Finally, Fig. 5.12 illustrates the recent application of accelerated CAPR acquisition to multistation CE-MRA of the lower extremity [35]. In this example, the acquisition was initiated at the level of the thighs, with image reconstruction performed in real time. That is, a coronal MIP of a 3D image was reconstructed and presented to the observer approximately 900 ms after completion of data acquisition for that image. The observer monitored arrival and transit of contrast material, and when it reached the distal extent of the thigh FOV he/she triggered table motion by mouse click. After an approximate 6-s delay to allow table motion, the CAPR acquisition was initiated at a calf station. Separate eightelement coil arrays were used at each station. Figure 5.12a
84
S.J. Riederer et al.
Fig. 5.7 CAPR results from volunteer studies for three common flow patterns. (a1–a4) Symmetric blood flow in left and right calves. (b1–b4) Asymmetric left vs. right filling and early venous return (arrows). (c1–c4) Rapid superior-toinferior contrast transit and rapid arterial-to-venous circulation (reproduced from Haider et al. [31] with permission)
shows an MIP of the full FOV while Fig. 5.12b–e shows an individual region of the distal station identified by the dashed box of (A) at consecutive 5.1-s time intervals.
Discussion In this chapter, we have attempted to describe some of the properties and applications of Cartesian-based, time-resolved 3D CE-MRA as implemented using contemporary techniques. Compared to the practice of 3D time-resolved MRA techniques introduced over 10 years ago, e.g., the TRICKS method [10], there are several notable advances. Perhaps, foremost among these is the reduction in acquisition time allowed using acceleration techniques, particularly 2D acceleration techniques allowed by the two phase-encoding directions of 3D acquisition. 2D sensitivity encoding (SENSE) [15] allows accelerations of 4× to 8× or more, and when coupled with the typical 1.8× acceleration
allowed by 2D homodyne the net acceleration factor is well over an order of magnitude. As shown in Fig. 5.3, this radically reduces the frame time and temporal footprint of timeresolved sequences. In effect, this allows time-resolved imaging at higher spatial resolution than what was possible previously with single-phase methods. A critical technical element contributing to the high quality of accelerated 3D CE-MRA is the receiver coil array. It is important to understand that simply making the element count higher does not in and of itself provide improved image quality. Rather, the element size should be matched to the size of the object, and the spatial orientation should be matched to the direction(s) of any parallel acquisition. For the case of 2D SENSE applied to the transverse plane, which is typically the case in CE-MRA, coil arrays which can be placed circumferentially around the subject provide low g-factors and retain SNR at high acceleration factors. The improvement in speed of acquisition means that image sequences having superior temporal and spatial
Fig. 5.8 Illustration of the high spatial and temporal resolution of CAPR. CAPR results of the calves in a subject with suspected peripheral arterial disease (PAD). (a–c) are coronal MIPs from consecutive frames acquired at 50, 55, and 60 s post injection, respectively. The left anterior tibial artery (ATA) is well-seen (arrow, a), but the other two major vessels in the left calf appear to be occluded. (d–g) MIP of the subvolume identified in the dashed box of (a) projected at 0, 30, 60, and
90° from the A/P direction and corresponding to 50, 55, 60, and 65 s post injection, respectively. These subvolumes clearly show how the left posterior tibial artery (e, arrow) is perfused by a spontaneously recruited geniculate artery (e, arrowhead). Also, the peroneal artery (f, arrow) is fed by an auxiliary artery (f, arrowhead) originating from the left ATA
Fig. 5.9 Comparison of 3D CE-MRA acquired with CAPR to CT angiography (CTA). (a) Subvolume of the circulation of the right calf taken from the CTA showing a stenosis at the origin of right anterior tibial artery (arrow). (b, c) Consecutive frames obtained 5 s apart of the same anatomic region as (a) imaged with the CAPR MRA. Both images clearly show the stenosis (arrow, b) and also portray the progression of
contrast material through the vasculature. (d) Targeted reconstruction of the left leg from the CTA, also portraying a stenosis at the origin of the anterior tibial artery (arrow). (e) Comparison MRA, showing the lesion at the origin (arrow) but in addition a distal region suspicious of narrowing (arrowhead) difficult to appreciate in the CTA exam because of overlying calcium (reproduced from Haider et al. [31] with permission)
86
S.J. Riederer et al.
Fig. 5.10 CAPR CE-MRA of the hands. (a–c) Coronal full field-of-view MIPs of the hands acquired 30.0, 33.0, and 57.0 s post injection. (d) Dorsal time-of-arrival (TOA) map of the left hand with TOA values restricted to the arterial phase. (e–g) Maps of all TOA values of the left hand at progressive oblique angles (reproduced from Riederer et al. [34] with permission)
stricter. For example, the image frame rate of some technique should not be equated with the temporal resolution. It has been shown that the time over which data are generated for image formation affects the portrayal of a time-varying phenomenon [30]. Similarly, if it is desirable to cause a reconstructed image to best freeze the status of the object at the time of the image reconstruction, then the central k-space information should be measured in only one, temporally compact time interval. Accurate portrayal of velocity of an object over a sequence of frames requires that the distribution of k-space sampling be consistently applied during the temporal footprint for each frame of the sequence. Finally, incorporation into an image of appreciable high spatial frequencies measured well after central k-space can lead to “anticipation” artifact in which the vasculature distal to the bolus leading edge position at the time of reconstruction can erroneously appear to be enhanced. Such signals can potentially be reduced with iterative methods, e.g., [36], but Cartesian acquisition with appropriate view ordering can still effectively limit the extent of such artifact. Fig. 5.11 CAPR CE-MRA of the neurovasculature. Full field-of-view MIPs formed at an oblique angle of the brain acquired (a) 21.3 s, (b) 23.6 s, (c) 25.9 s, and (d) 28.2 s post injection. Note that in spite of the relatively long (6.9 s) temporal footprint the signal from the superior sagittal sinus (arrows, d) is not seen in the early frames
resolution are now possible compared to their previous counterparts. However, for adequate assessment of performance, the criteria for evaluation of performance have now become
Conclusion Time-resolved 3D CE-MRA based on Cartesian k-space sampling can now be performed using acceleration techniques, view ordering, and receiver coil arrays which allow high-quality imaging in multiple vascular territories.
5
Time-Resolved, Contrast-Enhanced MR Angiography Using Cartesian Methods
87
Fig. 5.12 CAPR CE-MRA of the lower extremity using a time-resolved multistation technique. (a) Coronal MIP of the full longitudinal FOV, encompassing the thighs and calves. (b–e) Coronal MIPs of the subvolume identified in (a) formed 46.6 s (b), 51.7 s (c), 56.7 s (d), and 61.8 s (e) post injection (reproduced from Johnson et al. [35] with permission)
Acknowledgments The authors acknowledge the assistance of Eric Borisch, Kathy Brown, Norbert Campeau MD, James Glockner MD PhD, Roger Grimm, Thomas Hulshizer, John Huston MD, Thanila Macedo MD, Phillip Rossman, Diane Sauter, Terri Vrtiska MD, and Phillip Young MD.
References 1. Prince MR, Yucel EK, Kaufman JA, Harrison DC, Geller SC. Dynamic gadolinium-enhanced 3D abdominal MR arteriography. J Magn Reson Imaging. 1993;3:877–881. 2. Prince MR. Gadolinium-enhanced MR aortography. Radiology. 1994;191:155–164. 3. Earls JP, Rofsky NM, DeCorato DR, Krinsky GA, Weinreb JC. Hepatic arterial-phase dynamic gadolinium-enhanced MR imaging: optimization with a test examination and a power injector. Radiology. 1997;202:268–273. 4. Foo TKF, Saranathan M, Prince MR, Chenevert TL. Automated detection of bolus arrival and initiation of data acquisition in fast, three-dimensional, gadoliuium-enhanced MR angiography. Radiology. 1997;203:275–280. 5. Wilman AH, Riederer SJ, King BF, Debbins JP, Rossman PJ, Ehman RL. Fluoroscopically-triggered contrast-enhanced threedimensional MR angiography with elliptical centric view order: application to the renal arteries. Radiology. 1997;205:137–146. 6. Wilman AH, Riederer SJ. Improved centric phase encoding orders for three dimensional magnetization prepared MR angiography. Magn Reson Med. 1996;36:384–392. 7. Wang Y, Johnston DL, Breen JF, et al. Dynamic MR digital subtraction angiography using contrast enhancement, fast data acquisition, and complex subtraction. Magn Reson Med. 1996;36:551–556. 8. Riederer SJ, Tasciyan T, Farzaneh F, Lee JN, Wright RC, Herfkens RJ. MR fluoroscopy: technical feasibility. Magn Reson Med. 1988; 8:1–15. 9. van Vaals JJ, Brummer ME, Dixon WT, et al. “Keyhole” method for accelerating imaging of contrast agent uptake. J Magn Reson Imaging. 1993;3:671–675. 10. Korosec FR, Frayne R, Grist TM, Mistretta CA. Time-resolved contrast-enhanced 3D MR angiography. Magn Reson Med. 1996;36: 345–351.
11. Mostardi PM, Haider CR, Rossman PJ, Borisch EA, Riederer SJ. Controlled experimental study depicting moving objects in viewshared time-resolved MRA. Magn Reson Med. 2009;62:85–95. 12. Sodickson DK, Manning WJ. Simultaneous acquisition of spatial harmonics (SMASH): fast imaging with radiofrequency coil arrays. Magn Reson Med. 1997;38:591–603. 13. Griswold MA, Jakob PM, Heidemann RM, et al. Generalized autocalibrating partially parallel acquisitions (GRAPPA). Magn Reson Med. 2002;47:1202–1210. 14. Pruessmann KP, Weiger M, Scheidegger MB, Boesiger P. SENSE: sensitivity encoding for fast MRI. Magn Reson Med. 1999;42: 952–962. 15. Weiger M, Pruessmann KP, Boesiger P. 2D SENSE for faster 3D MRI. Magma. 2002;14:10–19. 16. Riederer SJ, Hu HH, Kruger DG, Haider CR, Campeau NG, Huston III J. Intrinsic signal amplification in the application of 2D SENSE parallel imaging to 3D contrast-enhanced elliptical centric MRA and MRV. Magn Reson Med. 2007; 58:855–864. 17. Bernstein MA, Fain SB, Riederer SJ. Effect of zero-filling and windowing of MRI data on spatial resolution and acquisition strategy. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2001;14:270–280. 18. Willinek WA, Gieseke J, Conrad R, et al. Randomly segmented central k-space ordering in high-spatial-resolution contrastenhanced MR angiography of the supraaortic arteries: initial experience. Radiology. 2002;225:583–588. 19. Noll DC, Nishimura DG, Macovski A. Homodyne detection in magnetic resonance imaging. IEEE Trans Med Imaging. 1991;10: 154–163. 20. Madhuranthakam AJ, Hu HH, Barger AV, et al. Undersampled elliptical centric view-order for improved spatial resolution in contrastenhanced MR angiography. Magn Reson Med. 2006;55:50–58. 21. Fink C, Ley S, Kroeker R, Requardt M, Kauczor H-U, Bock M. Time-resolved contrast-enhanced three-dimensional magnetic resonance angiography of the chest. Invest Radiol. 2005;40:40–48. 22. Cashen TA, Carr JC, Shin W, et al. Intracranial time-resolved contrast-enhanced MR angiography at 3T. Am J Neuroradiol. 2006; 27:822–829. 23. Lim RP, Shapiro M, Wang EY, et al. 3D time-resolved MR angiography (MRA) of the carotid arteries with time-resolved imaging with stochastic trajectories: comparison with 3D contrast-enhanced bolus-chase MRA and 3D time-of-flight MRA. Am J Neuroradiol. 2008;29:1847–1854.
88 24. Lim RP, Jacob JS, Hecht EM, et al. Time-resolved lower extremity MRA with temporal interpolation and stochastic spiral trajectories: preliminary clinical experience. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2010;31: 663–672. 25. Hadizadeh DR, Falkenhausen Mv, Gieseke J, et al. Cerebral arteriovenous malformation: Spetzler-Martin classification at subsecondtemporal-resolution four-dimensional MR angiography compared with that of DSA. Radiology. 2008;246:205–213. 26. Ruhl KM, Katoh M, Langer S, et al. Time-resolved 3D MR angiography of the foot at 3 T in patients with peripheral arterial disease. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2008;190:W360-W364. 27. Frydrychowicz A, Bley TA, Winterer JT, et al. Accelerated timeresolved 3D contrast-enhanced MR angiography at 3T: clinical experience in 31 patients. Magma. 2006;19:187–195. 28. Weiger M, Pruessmann KP, Kassner A, et al. Contrastenhanced 3D MRA using SENSE. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2000;12:671–677. 29. Sodickson DK, McKenzie CA, Li W, Wolff S, Manning WJ, Edelman RR. Contrast-enhanced 3D MR angiography with simultaneous acquisition of spatial harmonics: a pilot study. Radiology. 2000;217:284–289.
S.J. Riederer et al. 30. Haider CR, Hu HH, Campeau NG, Huston III J, Riederer SJ. 3D high temporal and spatial resolution contrast-enhanced MR angiography of the whole brain. Magn Reson Med. 2008;60:749–760. 31. Haider CR, Glockner JF, Stanson AW, Riederer SJ. Peripheral vasculature: high-temporal and high-spatial -resolution three-dimensional contrast-enhanced MR angiography. Radiology. 2009;253:831–843. 32. Johnson CP, Haider CR, Rossman PJ, Hulshizer TC, Borisch EA, Riederer SJ. Coil design for highly accelerated 2D SENSE MRA of the lower legs. In: 16th Meeting, ISMRM. Toronto, 2008;1079. 33. Cashen TA, Jeong H, Shah MK, et al. 4D radial contrast-enhanced MR angiography with sliding subtraction. Magn Reson Med. 2007;58:962–972. 34. Riederer SJ, Haider CR, Borisch EA. Time-of-arrival mapping at three-dimensional time-resolved contrast-enhanced MR angiography. Radiology. 2009;253:532–542. 35. Johnson CP, Haider CR, Borisch EA, Glockner JF, Riederer SJ. Time-resolved bolus-chase MR angiography with real-time triggering of table motion. Magn Reson Med. 2010;64:629–637. 36. Mistretta CA, Wieben O, Velikina J, Block W, Perry J, Wu Y. Highly constrained backprojection for time-resolved MRI. Magn Reson Med. 2006;55:30–40.
6
Flow-Dependent Noncontrast MR Angiography Mitsue Miyazaki, Satoshi Sugiura, Yoshimori Kassai, Hitoshi Kanazawa, Robert Edelman, and Ioannis Koktzoglou
Introduction Noncontrast MR angiography (NC-MRA) techniques such as time-of-flight (TOF) and phase contrast (PC) have been available since the early days of MRI development. However, long scan times and various artifacts have limited their use in the clinical setting over contrast-enhanced (CE) MRA techniques, introduced first around the mid-1990s. At the present time, three-dimensional (3D) TOF remains the main technique for intracranial MRA, while PC has been used as an angiogram technique as well as flow functional technique in various regions of the body. In other regions of the body like the chest, abdomen, and peripheral regions, CE MRA became the main MR technique in those areas. Rapid development of CE MRA was facilitated by various developments in system hardware, parallel imaging, sequence improvements, and the introduction of time-resolved MRA. Since the recent FDA black-box warning associated with the use of gadoliniumbase contrast agent in 2007 and the risk of developing nephrogenic systemic fibrosis (NSF), there is renewed interest in NC-MRA as an alternative to CE MRA. In this chapter, we focus on the following NC-MRA techniques, flow-dependent angiography techniques: TOF, PC, fresh blood imaging (FBI) using electrocardiographically (ECG) or peripheral pulse gating (PPG)-triggered half-Fourier fast spin-echo (FSE), and an arterial spin labeling (ASL) technique, time-spatial labeling inversion pulse (time-SLIP) combined using ECG- or PPG-triggered half-Fourier FSE and bright blood balanced steady-state free precession techniques. M. Miyazaki (*) MRI Department, Toshiba Medical Research Institute, Vernon Hills, IL, USA S. Sugiura • Y. Kassai • H. Kanazawa MRI Systems Development Department, Toshiba Medical Systems Corporation, Otawara, Tochigi, Japan R. Edelman • I. Koktzglou Northshore University Health System Evanston, IL, USA
Flow-dependent MRA techniques can be classified into (1) TOF, based on flow-related enhancement, (2) PC using the phase difference images, (3) triggered FBI using the intrinsic bright blood of FSE, and (4) an ASL, time-SLIP, and balanced steady-state free precession (bSSFP). A brief explanation of TOF and PC is provided, but we emphasize FBI and time-SLIP techniques with brief inclusion of the bSSFP approaches including various clinical applications.
Time-of-Flight Time-of-flight (TOF) utilizes flow-related enhancement which is an inflow effect whereby blood flowing in vessels perpendicularly the slice plane or slab appears bright. The technique relies upon the signal difference between the inflow blood and the stationary background signals to define the lumen of the blood vessels. The MRI signal arising from stationary tissue is saturated by the application of repeated RF excitation pulses and a relatively short repetition time (TR). Blood flowing into the imaging plane experience fewer RF excitations pulses, appear brighter that static tissue. For intracranial MRA, a 3D gradient echo (GE) or field echo (FE) pulse sequence is used for image acquisition and the data is processed into maximum intensity projections (MIPs). Figure 6.1 shows good contrast between the stationary background and the vessels in the intracranial MIP images obtained using 3D TOF at 3 T. As compared to 1.5 T, 3 T provides a higher signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), but also benefits from longer T1. The longer T1 results in more effective saturation of the signal from stationary background tissue. Originally developed at 1.5 T to enhance inflow effects, TOF technical advancements include tilted optimized nonsaturated excitation (TONE) [1], which progressively increase flip angles through the slab to lessen the effects of blood saturation within the slab and multiple overlapping thin slab acquisition (MOTSA) [2], where each thin slab benefits from the inflow of fresh unsaturated blood. Magnetization transfer (MT) pulses can be applied to improve
J.C. Carr and T.J. Carroll (eds.), Magnetic Resonance Angiography: Principles and Applications, DOI 10.1007/978-1-4419-1686-0_6, © Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2012
89
90
M. Miyazaki et al.
Fig. 6.2 (a) 3D time-of-flight (TOF) sequence diagram using a slice selective off-resonance since (SORS) magnetization transfer (MT) pulse. Note that the slice selective gradient (A) is applied along with the SORS MT pulse. (b) 3D TOF images acquired with two types of MT pulses performed on a healthy volunteer with a metal clip placed on the right side of his neck at 1.5 T. Note the loss of vessel signals on the right hemisphere using a nonselective MT pulse, whereas the application of the SORS MT pulse maintains blood signal in the right hemisphere
Fig. 6.1 Intracranial 3D time-of-flight performed on a healthy male volunteer at 3 T. Maximum intensity projection in the axial (left) and oblique sagittal directions (right) demonstrates excellent blood to background contrast and depiction of small peripheral intracranial vessels
suppress the brain and improves the blood to background contrast in intracranial MRA [3]. The MT pulse excites short T2 restricted water protons, which are bound to macromolecules, and through their chemical exchange, signals of the free unbound water protons are reduced. There is a notable amount of MT effects in blood as well. In order to additionally improve the contrast between the blood and the brain background signals, a slice selective off-resonance sinc (SORS) pulse was developed as an MT pulse [3]. Figure 6.2a shows a pulse sequence diagram of 3D TOF with a slice
selective gradient A as indicated as the SORS pulse. Figure 6.2b shows 3D MRA images with and without the slice selective MT pulse on a volunteer with a metal clip placed on the right side of his neck at 1.5 T. Note the loss of arteries in the right hemisphere in the 3D TOF MIP image observed using the nonselective MT pulse. With the application of the slice selective MT pulse, SORS, the right intracranial vessels are visualized and less affected by the metal clip. The nonselective MT pulse applied across the entire anatomy, including the blood vessels near the metal clip, results in loss of blood signals in the right hemisphere; whereas the SORS pulse located at the top of the brain has less affect on the blood traveling from the heart. The effect of the SORS pulse is schematically explained in Fig. 6.3. The SORS pulse placed on the top of the head provides a large MT effect to the brain parenchyma because it is closer to the center frequency. With the nonselective MT pulse, blood traveling from the heart experiences less MT effect as blood entering into the coil sensitivity has a long distance to travel into the center of the imaging slab. The farther the travel distance of blood to the center of the imaging slab, the smaller the MT effect in the blood. Results that show higher blood to background contrast can be obtained using the SORS pulse rather than applying a spatial nonselective pulse. In peripheral MRA, 2D TOF sequences using a presaturation pulse to saturate venous signals are utilized to depict arterial vessels. However, peripheral run-off imaging requires a large coverage, which leads to long acquisition times. In addition, the 2D TOF technique is limited in depicting the vessels that are perpendicular to the orientation of the vessels. Vessels that are oriented through the slice plane have less inflow effect and lose signal, making it difficult to image slow tortuous peripheral vessels. In order to improve the
6
Flow-Dependent Noncontrast MR Angiography
91
Fig. 6.3 (a) Schematic of 3D time-of-flight scan using an SORS MT pulse. The yellow box shows the slice selective MT (SORS) pulse and the red box shows the imaging plane. The distance between the SORS MT pulse and imaging slab can be translated to the frequency. (b) MT effect in frequency domain. The curve shows the MT effect on frequency that the closer to center frequency, F0, the greater the MT effect.
Since the SORS MT pulse is slice selective, and positioned at the top of the head, it gives a constant frequency offset, providing a strong MT effect to the background signals, whereas the blood traveling from the heart experiences various frequency offsets on its way to the center of the imaging slab, which give less MT effect to the blood signals in average (Modified from Miyazaki et al. [3], with permission)
depiction of slow flow peripheral vessels, especially in patients with peripheral arterial diseases (PAD), ECG or PPG is applied to trigger at the peak systolic period, which lengthens scan time.
to straightforward flowing vessels. Figure 6.4 shows a sagittal view of a brain MRA obtained using the 3D PC technique and the PC cine images of aortic outflow track and its color map display. The PC cine images allow calculations of flow velocity distribution, maximum velocity, and flow quantity.
Phase Contrast Phase contrast (PC) technique utilizes the phase information of moving objects by applying pairs of bipolar (flowcompensated and uncompensated) gradient pulses to generate flow sensitive images [4]. The phase data is used to reconstruct and generate MR angiographic images and velocity-encoded flow quantification images. To produce PC MRA images with flow sensitivity in the x, y, and z directions, four acquisitions are required, one flow uncompensated and three (x, y, and z) with different flow compensation directions. Despite the long acquisition time, the strength of this technique beyond imaging the flowing blood is the quantitative measurements of blood flow that can be obtained with the same data. To obtain flow quantification data, velocity-encoded images are created by subtracting the phase shifts that are generated by the flow-encoded and flow-compensated acquisitions. The signal intensity in the velocity-encoded images contain phase shift ranges from +180° to −180°, where the positive phase shifts provide bright signals and the negative phase shifts produce dark signals. Unlike the TOF method, PC MRA required a priori knowledge of the blood flow velocity. Velocity information is used to set the value of the velocity-encoding (VENC) gradient which controls contrast of the flowing blood. Lengthy scan times and potential occurrence of artifacts from incorrect VENC settings limit this technique
Fresh Blood Imaging: ECG-Gated 3D PartialFourier Fast Spin-Echo Background Originally described by Wedeen et al. in the 1980s, the ECGgated spin-echo technique demonstrated pulsatile flow and presented 2D projection images as noncontrast-enhanced MRA in lower extremities [5, 6]. Improvements in both hardware and software have made it possible to extend this technique to 3D acquisitions and further shorten scan time by using a single-shot partial-Fourier FSE pulse sequence. The shortening of the echo train spacing (ETS) in 3D partialFourier FSE has made this technique clinically feasible on commercially available MRI scanners. Below we describe the distinct features and intrinsic properties that allow partial-Fourier FSE pulse sequences to be optimized for angiography. In FSE acquisitions, T2-mediated decay of the MR signal that results in blurring effect in the phase-encode (PE) direction is unavoidable. This results since FSE-based sequences sample multiple echoes at different echo times, unlike spin-echo sequences collecting an echo per line [7, 8]. Table 6.1 shows the T2 burring effect of blood simulated using a point spread function (PSF). The shorter the T2 value, one pixel signal spreads to a couple pixels, as indicated by the increasing of full-width at
92
M. Miyazaki et al.
Fig. 6.4 (a) Intracranial sagittal maximum intensity projection view image on a healthy volunteer using the 3D phase contrast (PC) technique. (b) PC cine images of the aortic outflow track (top) and the color map image (bottom) on a healthy volunteer
Table 6.1 Signal intensity in arbitrary units and full-width at halfmaximum (FWHM) simulated using a point spread function (PSF) with several T2 values (Modified from Miyazaki et al. [8] with permission) T2 200 ms (artery) 100 ms (vein) 50 ms (muscle)
Signal intensity (arbitrary units) 42.1 12.0 1.8
FWHM (pixels) 2.2 4.1 8.1
half-maximum (FWHM). The FWHM can be improved by increasing the number of shots and the application of parallel imaging to reduce T2 blurring. Increasing the data collection to two shots allows the first shot and the second shot to be interleaved while filling k space for each partition, which results in sharper images by reducing the data sampling period. However, the scan time will be twice as long as a single-shot method. The application of parallel imaging permits shorter data sampling periods, which results in reduced T2 blurring; however, it does not affect the scan time because of a fixed repetition time (TR).
Principles The NC-MRA technique, FBI, relies on ECG-gated 3D partial-Fourier FSE sequences, triggered for systolic and/or diastolic acquisitions. In order to obtain successful bright blood MRA images, essential concepts are discussed [9, 10]. The T2 relaxation time of blood causes T2 blurring effects in the phase-encoding direction on fast spin-echo type sequences [7]. In order to reduce T2 blurring where the PE direction is perpendicular to the vessel orientation, applying parallel imaging helps reduce the data sampling period, thus reducing the T2. Also, shortening of the ETS in partialFourier FSE reduces the total data sampling duration, which
reduces T2 blurring, motion-related artifacts, and minimizes susceptibility artifacts. Acquiring from near the center of the k space with a rectilinear filling permits intrinsically less flow-dephasing in the PE direction compared to the readout (RO) direction [11]. Additional prepulses like a short-tau inversion recovery (STIR) can be used in conjunction with the 3D partial-Fourier FSE technique to achieve fat suppressed images. FSE-based sequences allow the selection of effective TE (TEeff) to control the contrast. With 3D partial-Fourier FSE acquisitions, appropriate ECG delay(s) for diastolic and/or systolic triggering need to be selected for various applications. Figure 6.5a shows the relationship between the flow velocities of the ascending aorta, the descending aorta, and the superior vena cava (SVC) and the various ECG-triggering phases or delays measured using the PC technique, and Fig. 6.5b shows the corresponding signals intensities during each ECG delay obtained using partial-Fourier FSE. A preparatory “ECGprep scan” that produces 2D single-shot images at incremental triggering times of arbitrary steps can be used to find the specific trigger delay (TD) for systole (Fig. 6.6a), when arteries are black blood (flow voids), and for diastole when arteries are bright, as shown in Fig. 6.6b [9]. Each singleshot 2D acquisition is acquired in two or three R–R intervals at incremental delays to produce different phase images. In a peripheral run-off study, a second 2D preparatory scan provides the amount of spoiler gradient that provides the best selective dephasing of the arteries of interest [10]. In the spoiler preparation, each single-shot projection image is repeated by varying spoiler gradients. Presetting the amount of spoiler gradient accordingly to the regions is preferred to reduce total scan time. In general, the slower the vessel, the stronger the spoiler gradient strength is to differentiate slow flow arteries.
6
Flow-Dependent Noncontrast MR Angiography
Fig. 6.5 (a) Flow velocity measurement of the ascending aorta, the descending aorta, and the superior vena cava obtained throughout the cardiac cycle using the PC technique. (b) The signal intensities of the corresponding vessels using partial-Fourier FSE at effective TE (TEeff) of 60 ms on a healthy volunteer (Modified from Wedeen et al. [5] with permission)
Before moving to the 3D acquisition methods, it is noteworthy to mention the by-product of the 2D ECG-prep scan; subtraction of the systolic- from diastolic-triggered images provides noncontrast perfusion images. Figure 6.7 shows lung perfusion images obtained using ECG-gated partialFourier FSE on a healthy volunteer and a patient with a pulmonary thromboembolism. The signal difference of pulmonary vessels between diastole and systole provides noncontrast pulmonary perfusion MRA (Fig. 6.7a), and the hypointensity defect is due to the pulmonary thromboembolism, which matches with DSA image (Fig. 6.7b). This signal difference of systole and diastole was intensively investigated in both human and canine imaging [13, 14].
Noncontrast MRA Applications in Abdomen The noncontrast-enhanced MRA technique relies on an ECG-gated 3D partial-Fourier FSE sequence which is triggered during diastole to obtain bright blood signals and during systole to produce a flow void or black blood signals [9]. In abdominal MRA, since venous enhancement may not be a serious detriment to image quality, a single diastolic-
93
triggering acquisition can be performed without a systolic subtraction. For the relatively fast flow of the thoracic aorta, the PE direction should be oriented to be parallel to the direction of flow (craniocaudal) with the application of presaturation bands superior and inferior to avoid wrap-around artifacts. Clinical evaluation of noncontrast FBI images was performed in a prospective study of 75 patients with arterial diseases referred for noncontrast FBI (34 dissection, 27 aneurysm, 4 arterial occlusion, and 10 surgical bypass); image quality of the noncontrast FBI images graded excellent in 45, satisfactory in 25, and poor in 5 patients; with all 34 dissection cases, the intimal flap was consistently visualized [15]. In addition, the noncontrast FBI technique provides clear depiction of the aorta in postoperative patients with metal wires, clips, or implants. FBI provides images with minimal artifacts that unambiguously delineate the anastomosis between the bypass graft and the native vessel. Figure 6.8 shows a typical noncontrast diastolic-triggered FBI images on a patient with a dissecting aortic arch using the ECG-gated 3D partial-Fourier FSE method compared to a contrast-enhanced (CE) MRA (Fig. 6.8b). The FBI source images clearly demonstrate the intimal flap and tear and some pleural and pericardial effusions by synchronizing the ECG triggering. The corresponding CE MRA source images acquired after the FBI scans reveal the patent lumen and the intimal flap and tear by the difference in the contrast arrival timing.
Peripheral MRA: Separation of Arteries from Veins As discussed previously, the orientation of the PE direction relative to the vessels of interest can be selected to optimize arterial signal for the thoracic cavity. For relatively slower moving protons in the peripheral arteries, the PE direction can be oriented perpendicular to the direction of flow and flow-spoiler gradient pulses applied in the readout (RO) or frequency direction to increase the flow-dephasing effect during systole. The percentage of the flow-spoiling gradient is defined as a percentage relative to one-half of the entire RO gradient area [10]. Flow-spoiling gradient pulses accentuate the differences in signal between systolic and diastolic phases, without affecting slower flowing venous blood and the stationary background signals. Therefore, in peripheral MRA, the signal between systole and diastole is emphasized by adding flow-spoiling or partial flow compensation for optimizing flow void in systolic acquisitions [10]. In peripheral MRA, systolic- and diastolic-triggering timing becomes crucial to have optimal signal difference. We use the ECG-prep scan using similar scan parameters as in the 3D acquisition, such as R–R interval, effective TE, orientation of the PE direction, application of a prepulse such as STIR for fat suppression, and a single-shot acquisition window duration. The ECG-prep acquisition is typically incremented by a 50 or 100 ms with repetition time (TR) of
94
M. Miyazaki et al.
Fig. 6.6 (a) Sequence diagram of an ECG-prep scan (single slice with multiple phases). (b) Corresponding images of the aortic vessels obtained using the ECG-prep scan. Note that the systolic-triggered image shows the aorta with dark blood (yellow arrow), whereas the
diastolic image shows the aorta with bright blood ( red arrow ) . The superior vena cava (SVC) (blue arrows) shows bright signal throughout the cardiac cycle (Modified from Wedeen et al. [5] with permission)
Fig. 6.7 (a) The signal difference of pulmonary vessels from the subtraction of the systolic- from diastolic-triggered 2D projection images on a healthy volunteer. (b) DSA image (top) shows the right pulmonary thromboembolism (red open arrow), whereas the diastole–systole subtraction 2D projection image shows the corresponding region with hyposignal intensities (red arrows) (Courtesy of Dr. K. Nakamura of Kyoritsu Hospital, Japan)
two or three R–R intervals to observe the single-shot 2D images across the entire cardiac cycle. The artery of interest with lowest signal will be selected as a systolic triggering delay and the subtraction of the systolic image from all the ECG-prep images will provide high signal intensity of the artery of interest, which will be the diastolic triggering delay. These manual calculations sometimes are cumbersome and difficult to determine the systolic and diastolic triggering delays, especially in small vessels in the 2D projection images. This cumbersome procedure of determining the triggering delays is even more difficult when the signal intensities of diastole are similar in images. The development of graphic display software, FBI-Navi, is utilized to provide a graph of signal intensity versus ECG phases [16], as shown in Fig. 6.9. The FBI-Navi manipulates all the phase images of the ECG-prep scan and automatically calculates the signals in the cardiac phases of the artery. Figure 6.9a shows a variation of the arterial signal intensity presented in a twodimensional graph to select the delays, the hypointensity for
6
Flow-Dependent Noncontrast MR Angiography
95
Fig. 6.8 (a) Contiguous source images of noncontrast FBI MRA and (b) contrast-enhanced (CE) MRA of the thoracic arch of a patient with an aortic dissection. The FBI source images clearly demonstrate the intimal flap and tear (arrow) and some pleural and pericardial effusions (arrowheads) due to synchronizing the ECG triggering. The CE MRA source images acquired after the FBI scan reveal the patent lumen and the intimal flap and tear by the difference in the contrast arrival timing (Modified from Urata et al. [15] with permission)
Fig. 6.9 (a) The result of the FBI-Navi plot shows signal intensity in arbitrary units and the ECG phases. The lowest signal area should be the systolic triggering delay (red circle) and the high signal plateau area is the diastolic triggering period (red circle). (b) The diastolic source image
shows both arteries and veins in bright blood, whereas the systolic source image shows black blood arteries and bright blood veins. The subtraction of the systolic source images from the diastolic images generates an arteriogram after the maximum intensity projection processing
systolic, and the hyperintensity for diastolic triggering delays. The determination of diastole should be the beginning to the middle of a plateau area, since the single-shot acquisition duration is about 150–350 ms for a 256 × 256 matrix, depending on the number of shots and parallel imaging factor. Figure 6.9b shows typical images of diastolic and
systolic MIP images and the subtraction of systolic from diastolic images that generate the arteriogram after the MIP procession. In order to reduce misregistration caused by two separate systolic and diastolic 3D acquisitions, a continuous acquisition is enabled to collect systolic and diastolic images
96
M. Miyazaki et al.
Fig. 6.10 (a) A schematic of continuous acquisitions of systole and diastole using ECG-gated 3D partial-Fourier FSE. Each slice is acquired in one single-shot acquisition using partial-Fourier FSE. One trigger delay (d1) is timed for systole for one 3D acquisition, while a second (d2) is timed for diastole. Acquisitions are performed every other or every
third R–R intervals. A short-tau inversion recovery (STIR) pulse is generally applied for fat suppression. To generate a bright blood angiogram, the systolic images (where arterial flow appears dark) are subtracted from diastolic images (Reproduced with permission from Ito et al. [25]). (b) Corresponding peripheral run-offs MRA on a healthy volunteer
without interrupting the scan. Figure 6.10a shows the schematics of continuous systolic scans with each slice encoding with the same delay from an R wave, followed by the diastolic scans. At each slice encoding, a single-shot partialFourier FSE is acquired with a STIR pulse for fat suppression. Operators can preset the system to subtract systolic from diastolic triggering scans, this subtraction of source images provides an arteriogram after the MIP processing. Typically, the RO flow compensation or spoiler gradient is present on patients and healthy volunteers. Generally, older patients with slower flow require a stronger RO spoiler pulse. Vessels in the hand and feet with slower flowing blood are also imaged with this approach using stronger flow-spoiling pulses to differentiate systolic signal from diastolic signal. Three separate groups clinically evaluated the ECG-gated partial-Fourier FSE MRA technique on patients with peripheral diseases. In the preliminary study in 2002, Urata et al. [17] reported that the ECG-gated FBI method was comparable to CE MRA in 24/44 regions, while 15 were inferior and 5 were superior, when tested in a total of 56 regions (18 iliac, 20 femoral, and 18 calf area) in 26 patients who were diagnosed or had suspected arterial occlusive disease. To avoid the overestimation of stenoses, the investigators in this study suggested that diastolic images, depicting both arteries and veins, always be evaluated in addition to the subtracted MIP images. Nakamura et al. used a similar strategy and compared noncontrast MRA with 16-detector CTA and found in their study of 13 patients with 56 diseased segments from the iliac to calf regions that the MR method resulted in a sensi-
tivity of 94%, a specificity of 94%, and an accuracy of 94% for the detection of ³50% stenosis [18]. In a separate study, Lim et al. compared the noncontrast MRA method in the distal station (calf and pedal arteries) with the conventional bolus chase imaging and 3D timeresolved contrast-enhanced imaging in 36 patients [19], where the reference standard was a combined consensus interpretation of all three sequences. When all subjects were studied, the noncontrast technique demonstrated accuracy of 79.4% (1,083/1,364), sensitivity 85.4% (437/512), and specificity 75.8% (646/852), with a high negative predictive value of 92.3% (646/700). Serious artifacts lead to poor diagnostic confidence in 17 patients (47.2%). Among the patients with satisfactory diagnostic confidence, accuracy, sensitivity, and negative predictive values were 92.2% (661/717), 92.4% (158/171), and 97.5 (503/516), respectively. One limitation of the study was that only the subtracted MIP images were evaluated. Further clinical studies using similar settings are required.
Noncontrast MR Venography In the area of noncontrast MR venography, there have been few reports outside the 2D TOF technique which can use saturation bands to suppress arterial flow. New modifications to the FBI technique were developed for faster flow in the iliac region using a swap phase-encode arterial double-subtraction elimination (SPADE) technique and flow-refocusing pulses (FR-FBI) in the RO direction [17] for slower flow in the femoral and calf regions. The FR-FBI technique uses a
Fig. 6.11 (a) A schematic of the swap phase-encode artery doublesubtraction elimination (SPADE) technique to visualize the iliac veins. The SPADE technique utilizes three acquisitions (two diastolictriggered acquisitions, one with the head–feet and the other with the right–left PE directions, and one systolic acquisition FR-FBI) to depict the iliac veins. (b) A 61-year-old female with an extensive deep vein thrombosis (DVT) 20 days after surgery for tibial fracture. The iliac region was acquired using the SPADE technique. The femoral and calf regions were acquired using the FR-FBI. (A) Conventional venography shows thrombi in the peroneal, popliteal, superficial, and common femoral veins (arrowheads). The proximal extent of throm-
bosis is not visualized (arrows). (B) maximum intensity projection (MIP) images of SPADE for pelvis, and FR-FBI for thigh and calf show the thrombi as hypointense signals in a wide range from the popliteal to common iliac venous lumen (arrowheads) and high signal intensity in the IVC (arrow). In the calf region, the presence of elevated signals due to edema obscures the appreciation of calf veins in the MIP images. (C) Source images of (B) reveal the presence of thrombus in peroneal vein as a hypointense signal defect within the venous lumen, as well as popliteal, superficial femoral, and iliac veins (arrows) (Reproduced with permission from Furudate and Miyazaki [16])
98
M. Miyazaki et al.
15% flow compensation pulse, the percentage of FR relative to one-half the entire RO gradient area, in the RO direction. The SPADE technique utilizes three acquisitions (two diastolic-triggered acquisitions, one with the head–feet and the other with the right–left PE directions, and one systolic acquisition FR-FBI) to depict the iliac region, as shown in Fig. 6.11a. Figure 6.11b shows an example of clinical cases presenting a comparison of DSA and noncontrast venography using SPADE for the iliac veins and FR-FBI for the femoral and calf veins [17]. The clinical evaluation was reported on 41 legs of 32 patients (25 of the 32 patients with nonmagnetizing metal implants) suspected of having deep vein thrombosis (DVT) examined using SPADE (iliac) and FR-FBI (femoral and calf), compared to conventional X-ray venography [18]. The results of the FR-FBI and SPADE for diagnosing thrombus study provided sensitivities of 100% (53 of 53) for two reviewers and the corresponding specificities of 100% (for one reviewer) and 99.6% (for the other reviewer). There were greater numbers of nondiagnostic scores in the conventional X-ray angiograms as compared to those in the noncontrast SPADE and FR-FBI exams.
Time-Spatial Labeling Inversion Pulse with 2D/3D Partial-Fourier FSE Background In an ASL technique, a time-spatial labeling inversion pulse (time-SLIP) can be applied in conjunction with 2D/3D partial-Fourier FSE or bSSFP. The FSE-based methods have the advantage of less sensitivity to susceptibility artifacts compared with gradient-type bSSFP method. However, bSSFP has the advantage of depicting fast flow and multidirectional flow over the FSE-type method. These merits and pitfalls of the FSE and bSSFP methods are discussed in detail, along with their applications to specific regions and purposes are introduced [22] Here, we discuss the three main approaches and applications of time-SLIP with 2D/3D partial-Fourier FSE methods. Depending upon the applications, the three types of techniques, flow-in, flow-out, and tag-on and tag–off alternative subtraction, were selected to visualize the vessels of interest and relationship to the surrounding background signals [23]. Principle of Techniques Figure 6.12a shows a sequence diagram of a time-SLIP with 3D partial-Fourier FSE. Sequence can be converted to a 2D acquisition by removing the slice encoding. There are three different approaches to studying the vessels of interest; flowout, flow-in, and an alternate tag-on and tag-off subtraction. The flow-out technique utilizes both nonselective (A) and the spatially selective pulse (B) to make the marked bright blood
Fig. 6.12 (a) A sequence diagram of time-spatial labeling inversion pulse (time-SLIP) with 3D partial-Fourier FSE. The A pulse is nonselective and the B pulse is spatially selective followed by the 3D partialFourier FSE. Note that the selective pulse allows rotating to any orientation to freely mark the area. The flow-out technique, the marked blood flow-out, utilizes both a nonselective (A) and the spatially selective pulses (B) to bring the magnetization of tagged area blood signals to flow out from the area during the inversion time (TI). The flow-in technique utili