MAGIC HOUR SUSAN ISAACS
To my best friend, Susan Zises
Contents Chapter One Seymour Ira Spencer of Manhattan and So...
39 downloads
670 Views
1018KB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
MAGIC HOUR SUSAN ISAACS
To my best friend, Susan Zises
Contents Chapter One Seymour Ira Spencer of Manhattan and Southampton was a class…
1
Chapter Two Come on,” I urged the kid, hoping for an argument.
25
Chapter Three Bonnie Spencer’s dog barked with joy: Hiya, hiya, wonderful to…
51
Chapter Four The Homicide team meeting turned out to be six cops…
80
Chapter Five By the time I finished with Germy, it was after…
97
Chapter Six Jesus, what a day! Trying to dope out what was… 118 Chapter Seven If I wanted to be on time, I had two…
139
Chapter Eight Nice Bonnie Spencer.
156
Chapter Nine
175
What was so terrible? Sex, even with someone as fabulous… Chapter Ten I’d gotten Bonnie out of the tub. She was wearing…
190
Chapter Eleven We got to Bonnie’s house before eight the next morning.
209
Chapter Twelve What the hell was wrong with Robby? Jesus, if I’d…
226
Chapter Thirteen I left the diner, my lunch untouched. The afternoon had…
243
Chapter Fourteen I got back to Headquarters a little before four o’clock.
258
Chapter Fifteen When you and Sy split, was there a lot of…
277
Chapter Sixteen Easton had taken to his bed and hadn’t gotten out…
315
Chapter Seventeen This is why I knew I wouldn’t be able to…
334
Chapter Eighteen Bonnie had wanted to call Gideon to reassure him that…
360
Chapter Nineteen Bonnie was all juiced up, talking too fast, bopping in…
381
Chapter Twenty The tennis court of the East Hampton waterfront 396 mansion that… Chapter Twenty-One Growing up in the house of what had once been…
411
Chapter Twenty-Two In the end, I called Ray Carbone at home and… 438 Acknowledgments About the Author Other Books by Susan Isaacs Cover Copyright About the Publisher
CHAPTER ONE
Seymour Ira Spencer of Manhattan and Southampton was a class act. Hey, the last thing you’d think was “movie producer.” No herringbone gold chain rested on a bed of chest hair; there was no fat mouth, definitely no cigar. If you could have seen him, in his plain white terry-cloth bathrobe (which he was too well-bred to have monogrammed), standing on the tile deck of the pool of his beachfront estate, Sandy Court, sipping a glass of iced black-currant tea, talking softly into his portable phone, you’d have thought: This is what they mean when they say good taste. I’ll tell you how tasteful Sy Spencer was. He actually might have hung up, strolled inside and picked out a Marcel Proust book to reread. Except just then he got blasted by two bullets, one in his medulla, one in his left ventricle. He was dead before he hit the deck. Too bad. It was a gorgeous August day. I remember. The sky was a blue so pure and powerful you almost couldn’t look at it. Who could take that much beauty? Down at the beach, where Sy was, silver-
1
2 / SUSAN ISAACS
white gulls soared, then dive-bombed into the ocean. The sand gleamed pale gold. Farther north, out beyond my backyard, potato fields gave off a rich, dark-green light. It was the kind of perfect Long Island day that makes the summer people say: “Darrr-ling [or Machère or Kiddo], this is such a glorious time out here. And do you know what’s so pathetic? All the little social climbers are so busy being upwardly mobile that they never get to appreciate”—taking a deep, sensitive sniff of fresh air through their dilated nostrils—“such breathtaking loveliness.” Jesus, were they full of shit! But they were right. That day, the sun bathed the entire South Fork of Long Island in glorious light. It was like a divine payoff. For the last five years, one of the secretaries in Homicide had been bestowing the same benediction on me: “Have a nice day, Detective Brady!” Well, God had finally come through. This was it. For Sy Spencer, of course, this was not it. And to be perfectly honest, the day, wonderful as it was, wasn’t so nice for me either. Nothing as dramatic as Sy’s day. Definitely not so fatal. But the events of that sunny summer afternoon changed the ending of my story almost as much as they did Sy’s. I was home in the northwest corner of Bridgehampton, six miles east and five miles north of Sandy Court, in considerably less impressive circumstances. My house was a former migrant worker’s shack. It had been renovated by a hysterically ambitious, pathetically untalented, ponytailed Brooklyn Heights architect, who comprehended, too late, that the place would never be considered a Find. He had been forced to sell it cheap to one of the locals (me) because even the most gullible smoothie from New York would not buy a lowceilinged, Thermopaned, whitewashed hovel with a sixburner restaurant stove
MAGIC HOUR / 3
and aggressively cute fruits and flowers stenciled along the walls and floors, situated on a rutted, geographically undesirable road between a potato field and a stagnant pond. Anyway, somewhere around the time the bullet blasted through the base of Sy’s skull, my life also blew up. Our two lives—ka-boom!—were joined. Of course, I didn’t know it. Unlike movies, life has no sound track; there was no ominous roll of drums. For me, it was still a nice day. A fantastic day. There I was, with my fiancée, Lynne Conway, lying on a blanket on the grass in my backyard, having moved outside from the bedroom for a little postcoital sun, conversation and iced tea. (I’d even thrown a couple of lemon circles into our glasses, to show that, okay, Lynne might have gone to Manhattanville College and known about fish forks, but I could still be a gracious host.) Of course, if I had been truly gracious, we would have been stretched out on lounge chairs, but in the last few years I hadn’t had time for amenities like towels without holes, much less outdoor furniture. So what? I knew all that would change in three months, when we got married. We’d have lounge chairs on a brick patio. A barbecue with a domed cover. Tuberous begonias. I would stop referring to the bacon-cheddar cheeseburgers I ate in the greasiest diners in Suffolk County as dinner; I would come home to poached salmon with parsleyed potatoes, fresh asparagus. I would, at age forty, be a newlywed. I turned over onto my side. Lynne was so pretty. Dark-red hair, that Irish setter color. Peachy young skin. A perfect nose, slightly upturned, with two tiny indentations on the tip, as though God had made a fast realignment in the final seconds before her birth. She wore khaki shorts that revealed her fabulous long
4 / SUSAN ISAACS
legs. It wasn’t just her looks, though. Lynne was a lady. She came from a good family…well, compared to mine. Her father was a retired navy cipher expert. His retirement seemed to consist of sitting in a club chair, his white-socked feet on an ottoman, reading right-wing magazines and getting enraged at Democrats. Lynne’s mother, Saint Babs of Annapolis, went to Mass every morning, where she probably prayed that the Lamb of God would strike me dead before I could marry her daughter. Babs Conway needlepointed all afternoon while she watched The Young and the Restless and Geraldo; she was eight years into her masterwork, a gigantic “The Marys at the Sepulchre” throw pillow. So there was Lynne: a nice Catholic girl. And a good woman. A beauty. Believe me. I knew precisely how lucky I was to have her. My life had not been what you’d call a charmed existence. Happiness was a blessing I’d doubted I deserved and never believed I would receive. “For the honeymoon,” she said softly, adjusting the shoulder seam of my T-shirt, “what would you think—this is just another option—if instead of Saint John we spent a week in London?” “You want to snorkel in the Thames in late November?” Lynne smiled, and the smile made her look even lovelier. She offered no wisecracks. No: Do you think I want to spend my honeymoon with some schmuck in flippers? What she said, without a trace of sarcasm, was: “I think I get the point. Saint John.” I gazed into Lynne’s fine brown eyes. And then I stopped having a nice day. Because there I was with a wonderful, kind-
MAGIC HOUR / 5
hearted, titian-haired, honey-skinned woman, and all I was having was a nice day. I wasn’t having fun. This is nuts, I said to myself. I had to understand that Lynne was young. She didn’t quite get me yet. To her, I was a man of the world. It was kind of sweet. Okay, I wished she’d loosen up just a little. I admitted it. I even admitted I was a little tense. I should have wanted a drink. But listen, I told myself, I don’t want a drink. I’m doing fine. Still, that was why, when Headquarters called fifteen minutes later and said, There’s been a homicide reported in your neck of the woods, ha-ha, on Dune Road in Southampton—that’s the high-rent district, right?—a movie producer, Somebody Spencer, was shot… Jesus H. Christ, I said. Sy Spencer. You know him? I know about him. My brother’s doing some work for him on the movie he’s making out here. Hey, is it true he won an Oscar a couple of years ago? Yeah. I bet I saw him! On TV, you know, one of those guys saying: I wanna thank my agent and my parents and my late cat, Fluff. Listen, it’s your day off, but you’re the only one who lives way the hell out in the Hamptons, and we just got called in on a mess in Sachem where some computer nerd got into a fight with his old man and strangled him and tried to hide him under the compost heap, so could you get over and establish a presence? Keep the village police eager beavers from playing cops, sticking everything not nailed down into Baggies. You know how they can fuck up a crime scene. Thanks, pal. …Well, I felt a certain gratitude toward Sy Spencer. I walked Lynne out to her car and kissed her good-
6 / SUSAN ISAACS
bye. “Sorry, but this one sounds like it’s going to totally screw up our weekend.” She squeezed my hand and said, “Come on. I’m an old pro by now. I just feel awful about your brother’s boss. What a shock!” Then she added, “I love you, Steve.” I thought: This woman is going to be a wonderful wife. A terrific mother. So I said, “I love you too.” A homicide would be a snap compared to this. Which shows you how much I knew. The night was as beautiful as the day had been. But neither the moon that rose four hours later nor the floodlights from the Emergency Services truck shining on the crime scene could make cheerful what was, in fact, gruesome: a corpse. Although a corpse in a spectacular setting. Sy Spencer’s lifeless body sprawled facedown on his tile deck. These were no ordinary exorbitantly priced tiles; about one out of every five of the deep-blue squares was hand-painted with a different fish, all of them too fashionably thin and richly colored to truly exist in Long Island coastal waters. But as some New York exterior decorator probably explained to Sy, they combined an oceanic motif with tongue-in-cheek chic. The pool itself was long, luminous aqua. In the cool night air, a mist, like a rectangular cloud, hovered over the water. Sy’s graceful, sprawling gray-shingled house, built in the early twenties, in that lost era of huge families and happy servants, rose up three stories high behind the pool. If you turned the other way, you saw soft sand and the Atlantic. “How’s your beautiful bride-to-be?” Sergeant Ray Carbone asked me. We were standing right near Sy’s head. Carbone wore a blue serge suit and Clark Kent glasses. With his small frame, potbelly and hunched-
MAGIC HOUR / 7
over back, he looked more like an overtaxed accountant than a disguised Superman. “Still beautiful,” I said. “She’s a lot more than beautiful. Rita and I were talking about you two the other day. Lynne gives you just what you need. Stability. Stability’s the name of the game.” “For me, it has to be.” “Don’t think I was talking about the drinking.” “It’s okay. You can talk about it.” “As far as I’m concerned, that’s history. Look, I know there’s no such thing as a recovered alcoholic. You’re always recovering—for the rest of your life. But, Steve, you were classic emotionally labile.” Carbone, who had a master’s in forensic science, was going for a second one, in psychology. “You’d be Mr. Nice Guy, and then you’d become so withdrawn—like no one was home inside—and then you’d start with the belligerence. But the past few years: what a difference! You’re as solid as they come. Trust me. You don’t have to worry.” “No. I always have to worry.” “Wrong. But you know what? Your not being complacent is a sign of wellness.” That’s what happens to a guy after twenty-four credits at the State University at Stony Brook. “Actually,” he went on, “what I meant by stability was a fire in the hearth. Good company. A nice bowl of soup. We need something normal, healthy to come home to after what we have to look at.” Twenty-four credits couldn’t entirely knock out Carbone’s basic common sense. A technician from ID elbowed his way past us, knelt down beside Sy, and slipped bags over the lifeless hands. (Paper bags. In movies, they use plastic. Scary when the camera moves in close, those lifeless hands wrapped like last week’s Oscar Mayer pimento loaf. Very visual. But very phony: we never use them.
8 / SUSAN ISAACS
Plastic traps moisture and screws up any chance of doing an FDR test, to see if the victim fired a weapon.) “What did you find inside?” I asked Ray. “Nothing. No signs of robbery, no violence. Sy had packed a carry-on bag to go to L.A. for some meetings. There was an unmade bed in the guest room. He could have taken a nap.” The button on Carbone’s too-snug suit jacket popped open. Not counting his midsection, he was thin. But his clothes were always a size too small for his basketball of a belly. “The cook was downstairs the whole time,” he continued. “Nice lady. She gave me a bowl of clam chowder, the red kind. She’s making something now for all the guys. All she heard were the shots. Nothing before that.” “Nothing after?” “No. She looked out the window, saw Sy, ran out to him, saw he was dead. The way his head was turned, she could see that one eye, open.” We both glanced down. The hood of Sy’s bathrobe was pulled back far enough that you could see his quarter profile and a bit of his hair: short, tight gray curls, cut middle-aged-gladiator style. The one eye that was visible was wide open. Because of the position of his head, the eye stared downward, as though it had found a hideous flaw in one of the fancy fish tiles. “She called the village police.” “From the portable phone?” “No. She said she knows not to touch anything near a murder victim. She went into the kitchen.” Okay, I thought, what kind of homicide do we have here? Not a heat-of-the-moment crime of passion, a murder arising out of jealousy or a family quarrel. And so far there was nothing to indicate a felony murder, a killing that occurs during the commission of another crime, like a burglary.
MAGIC HOUR / 9
I knew I should hang on for forensic results—the autopsy report with photographs and videos, the toxicology and serology reports—but there I was, itching to figure out what kind of a guy/gal (I’m an equal-opportunity detective) the perpetrator was. Well, it was easy to figure out that this killer wasn’t some impulsive jerk who, in a moment of madness, grabbed a stake from the flower garden and turned Sy into a human shish kebab. No, this killer was extremely well organized, bright enough to plan the murder, bring his own weapon and take it away with him. His getaway had been slick too: completely uneventful. From the lack of any physical evidence so far, he hadn’t gotten rattled. Another thing that struck me—from the first minute I saw Sy—was that although the killer had a brain, he had no heart. I always notice how the perpetrator treats the victim; it tells so much. This one didn’t seem like any psychopath. I knew I’d have to wait for the autopsy, but it didn’t seem like there would be mutilation—no sicko ritualistic marks, no deranged slashing. So he was heartless but no sadist; there was no need to terrify, no gun shoved in the victim’s mouth or gut or genitals. Sy had been shot from a distance, from behind, impersonally. But just as there were no indications of cruelty, there were no signs of decency either: no concern, no remorse. The killer had not covered Sy’s face, or closed that awful, staring eye, or picked a flower and tossed it toward the body. Of course, it could be a stranger murder, a nut case unknown to Sy. “You hear about anybody else getting taken out this way?” I asked Carbone. I did my homework if I was in the mood; he always did his. If there was a serial killer operating within fifty thousand miles of Suffolk County, he’d have read about it.
10 / SUSAN ISAACS
“Rich people? Movie people? People shot from a distance?” “I’ll check with the FBI, but I don’t think so. Unless this is number one.” “We’ve got a cool cookie here,” I observed. “An organized fucker.” We’d wait for the post-offense behavior, to see if it was a Son of Sam-type wacko who’d want to declare his genius to the police. “Good shot too. Got to give him credit.” “So what do you think the weapon was?” “Low-gauge rifle?” I asked the ballistics guy, who was standing a couple of yards away, opening his case. He nodded. “Looks like a .22.” Carbone muttered: “Damn. That’s not going to make our life easy.” He was right. Here on the South Fork, .22s were a dime a dozen. Everybody had one; locals used them for target practice, small-varmint shooting. Or anything. If a farmer wanted to kill a pig, he’d get out his .22; my father had owned one. “What background were you able to get on this Sy guy?” Carbone asked me. “Fifty-three years old. Dartmouth College graduate. From a rich family—kosher provisions business. The ones with that commercial where they all sit around the kitchen table in crowns: ‘Bologna for the Royal Family!’ But it sounds like he wasn’t all that turned on by lunch meats. He wanted culture. He started a big poetry magazine, Shower of Light, about twelve years ago. Put a pile of money into it. But then he seemed to have decided that poetry wouldn’t get him what he wanted.” “What was that?” “Who the hell knows? What do most guys want? Excitement. Fame. Fortune. Superior ass. I mean, who would you rather hit on, a receptionist in a pas-
MAGIC HOUR / 11
trami factory or a poet? Or a movie star?” Carbone the Thoughtful looked like he was actually beginning to contemplate the alternatives. “Ray, the answer is: Movie star with giant boobs.” “I don’t like those big, big ones,” he said, thoughtfully. “What do you like? A girl who looks like she’s got two Hershey’s Kisses glued on her chest?” “No, but you see a young girl with giant ones, you figure that when she’s thirty-five…” He shook his head in sadness. “When she’s thirty-five,” the ballistics guy interrupted, “you trade her in for two seventeen-and-a-half-year-olds.” He chuckled at his own wit, then added: “Move back a little, out of my way.” “Anyway,” I continued, as we moved back, “all along, Sy Spencer was pretty much a man-about-town, one of those people who pop up now and then in the gossip columns. No dirt: just some guy with major bucks who gave money to the right causes, went to all those jet-setty charity benefits. That seems to be where he met the movie types who have houses out here. And he got it into his head that he wanted to be a movie producer. Apparently, so do half the people in his world. But he got what he wanted.” “You know, I’ve heard his name. Good movies, right?” “No doubt about it. The guy had class.” “So, Steve. Gut reaction.” “It’s going to be a media circus. Plus a major pain because we’re dealing with hotshots who expect heavy-duty ass-kissing: ‘No, thanks, sir, I don’t drink while I’m on duty,’ when they offer us the cheap-shit Seagram’s they’ve been keeping from before they became famous. And—unless we get lucky in the next seventy-two hours and find someone in Sy’s life strok-
12 / SUSAN ISAACS
ing a warm .22—it’s going to be an absolute bitch to crack. Sy was the ultimate fast-track guy; he probably had fourteen Rolodexes, and those were just for personal friends.” “Where would you start?” “The movie he was producing, I guess. It’s called Starry Night. They’re shooting it over in East Hampton now.” “No kidding! Now?” Having spent my whole life being local color in what people called the Fashionable Hamptons, I was used to rubbing shoulders with celebrities. Well, not exactly rubbing. But from the time I was a kid, besides the regular rich and semi-rich summer people, there’d be famous models squeezing tomatoes at a farm stand, or TV anchormen picking out a toilet plunger in the hardware store in town—right next to you. We knew to pretend they were just plain people, but we also knew it was okay to ogle as they paid the cashier. Neither they nor we wanted them so plain as to be overlooked. But Carbone came from the plain plain world, suburban Suffolk County, a world peopled by ex-third-generation Brooklynites—shoe salesmen and IRS auditors and junior high school social studies teachers—a world that, if plopped down outside downtown Indianapolis or Des Moines, would not seem an unnatural part of the landscape. “East Hampton’s only—what?—ten, twelve miles away,” he was saying. His eyes were lit by a starry sparkle. “We may have to go over there to question some people on the movie set.” Carbone was normally so levelheaded, so thoughtful, you’d think he’d have been glitz-proof, but at the thought of Lights! Camera! Action! he was loosening his tie, unbuttoning the top button of his shirt. If there’d been a straw hat and cane, he’d have grabbed them and high-stepped over to East Hamp-
MAGIC HOUR / 13
ton, belting out “Hooray for Hollywood.” “Who’s starring?” he asked, much too casually. “Lindsay Keefe and Nicholas Monteleone.” “No kidding!” Then, fast, he switched back to his I’m-aregular-guy mode. “I always liked him,” he said. “Reminds me of a young Gary Cooper. Good without being a goodygoody. And she’s a good actress.” Carbone shook his head in sadness. “But too left-wing for my taste.” “With her body, do you care what her position on disarmament is?” Suddenly it hit Carbone. “Is Lindsay Keefe here?” he asked, his voice a little hushed with awe. “In the house?” “Upstairs, with her agent. You didn’t hear her? He’s trying to calm her down.” “Can you believe it? I was in there, interviewing the cook. I didn’t even know she was here, in the same house.” “The agent brought her back from the set. Heavy-duty hysterics.” Carbone’s eyebrows began drawing together in sympathy, so I added: “Let’s not forget she’s an actress. Anyway, according to the agent, for the last six months Lindsay’s been living with Sy. Here, and he has a duplex on Fifth Avenue. They’re madly in love. Perfect relationship. Never a harsh word between them. Blah, blah, blah. The usual. Oh, and they were going to get married the minute the movie was finished.” “You believe the agent?” “He’s not a slimeball. He’s an older guy named Eddie Pomerantz. Late sixties, early seventies. You can’t miss him. A color-coordinated hippo: pink polo shirt and forty-eightwaist pink madras slacks. He was the one Sy was on the phone with when he was killed. Claims they were discussing some minor problem about photo approval. A movie star gets to approve
14 / SUSAN ISAACS
any picture before it’s handed out to the press, and Pomerantz said someone on this movie slipped a shot of Lindsay drinking coffee with her hair up in curlers to USA Today and she started crying when it got published because it’s detrimental to her career to be seen in hair curlers.” I shook my head. “For this the guy gets ten percent. Anyway, Pomerantz said he heard two shots over the phone.” “You buy his story?” Carbone asked. “I buy that he heard two shots. He sounded pretty definite on that. But he kept eating nuts like a fucking maniac. There was a giant bowl of nuts on the table in the library or den or whatever it’s called, and he must have glommed two pounds of pistachios in five minutes. I was going to tell him not to eat potential evidence, but he was such a nervous wreck I didn’t have the heart. He was upset about Sy, and very worried about his client.” “Could it be normal professional concern?” “Could be.” “Listen, in this situation, concern would be an appropriate response. You know and I know and this Pomerantz must know that murder may mean publicity, but in the long run, being the mistress of a homicide victim isn’t going to help anyone’s career.” I nodded in agreement. “What’s the matter? Do you think he’s afraid of something specific?” “Couldn’t tell. But we’ve got to consider if this business is in any way related to Lindsay Keefe. A jealous ex-boyfriend. Or some jealous ex-girlfriend of Sy’s who got pissed off that Lindsay came into the picture.” “And we have to find out if things were really that hunkydory between Sy and Lindsay,” Carbone said. “Yeah. Maybe Sy did something so terrible she felt she bad to kill him.” “Like what?”
MAGIC HOUR / 15
“How should I know, Ray? Maybe he left dental floss with last night’s corn on the cob on the sink. Who the hell knows what sets people off, makes them kill? Do you?” “No.” “Me neither. Maybe it was just something boring, like Sy was getting it on with the script girl.” “You can’t wait to start with the hypotheses, can you, Brady?” “No. Now listen: someone on this movie besides Lindsay might have had a grudge. Or from some other movie. Or it could have been a cold-blooded hit. We’ve got to find out what kind of life Sy had—beyond his movie life. Did he gamble? Was he cooking the books? Into weird sex? Doing drugs?” A video tech stepped in front of us and, walking around Sy’s body, aimed his camera on the white robe. Then he zoomed in on the two small splotches: the one on the hood, where a bullet entered just above Sy’s brain stem, and another by his left shoulder blade. “You’d never think of a man like Sy as a victim of anything,” Carbone mused. “He seems like the ultimate winner.” “I know. Look at all this,” I said, glancing around the pool area. White wood tubs overflowed with trailing ivy and deeppurple flowers that gave off a light, spicy scent: nothing too perfumy, nothing too obvious. The chaises lay back, deep, welcoming. Small stone tables were carved like diving fish. You’d put your drink on the tail. White umbrellas on bamboo poles stood tall, like giant parasols. Almost-invisible quadraphonic speakers peeked up from the velvet grass. “Ray, I bet your wildest fantasy isn’t as good as what Sy actually had. What was missing that any reasonable man could want?”
16 / SUSAN ISAACS
Carbone started mulling it over, probably thinking something like a cohesive family unit or Self-knowledge. What I was thinking was: If Sy had stuck with kosher salamis and not had all his dreams come true, would he now be alive, dressing for dinner, buttoning a three-hundred-dollar sports shirt, or sticking his pinkie into the salad dressing to check whether his cook was using enough basil or chives or whatever this month’s most fabulous herb was? Why, on this splendid summer night, was Seymour Ira Spencer, the Man Who Had Everything, playing host to a bunch of cops who were swabbing between his toes, tweezing fluff off his bathrobe and cracking Lindsay Keefe tit jokes over his dead body? Look at a map. Long Island resembles a smiley but slightly demented whale. Its head—Brooklyn—butts against Manhattan, as if trying to get into some hot party from which it was deliberately excluded. But unlike bubble-brained Brooklyn, the whale’s body wants no part of the high life. Queens, Nassau and suburban Suffolk County just swim, eternally, in the bracing waters between the Atlantic and Long Island Sound, yearning to reach mainland America. See how the whale’s hump arches up in longing? All it wants is to be part of the U.S. of A., where life resembles a Coke commercial. Okay, now check out the rest of Suffolk County, the whale’s forked tail. The tail isn’t swishing a salute to either Manhattan or Middle America. No, it’s raised high to greet Connecticut and Rhode Island. The East End of Long Island is, really, the seventh New England state. See? On the North Fork of the tail, there are Yankee-style farms, fishing fleets and a few intensely quaint colonial villages that lack only a hand-carved
MAGIC HOUR / 17
“I am unspoiled” sign. And now look at the South Fork, my home. Our accents closer to Boston than the Bronx. Solid Anglo stock, augmented (most would say improved) by Indians, blacks, Germans, Irish, Poles and Others. More farms again. More cute towns. But unspoiled like the North Fork? No, spoiled beyond comprehension. For over a hundred years, artists and clods, geniuses and jerks, have been coming out here with their ways—and their money. To the Hamptons. “We summer in the Homp-tons,” they say. Do they ever: in oh-so-social Southampton, don’tsay-rich-say-comfortable Water Mill, bookish Bridgehampton, belligerently down-to-earth Sag Harbor, show-bizzy East Hampton, home-of-the-boring Amagansett (I think the last truly interesting person to live in Amagansett died in 1683) and I-am-one-with-the-sea Montauk. This summer paradise isn’t my South Fork, though; it belongs to men like Sy and to the legions of lesser New Yorkers who yearn to walk in his footprints in the sand. It is the Eden of the urbane: beach clubs, tennis clubs, yacht clubs, golf clubs; power breakfasts in the designated-chic local coffee shop, power softball games, power clambakes, power naps. But along this narrow strip of trendy whale’s tail, there are also hamlets called Tuckahoe and North Sea and Noyack and Deerfield. And there are people who neither know nor care that the copper beech is the Tree of Choice and the Japanese maple is Almost Out, or that duck is a passé poultry. There are people who are here not to vacation but to live lives: farmers, supermarket cashiers, dentists, welfare recipients, librarians, truckdrivers, short-order cooks, lawyers, housewives, carpenters, lobstermen, hospital orderlies. Oh, yes—and cops.
18 / SUSAN ISAACS
My name is Stephen Edward Brady. I was born in Southampton Hospital. A few days later, I went home with my mother to Brady Farm in Bridgehampton. It’s still there. Not the farm, of course. My father sold everything but the farmhouse and two acres in 1955, a little more than a decade before the big land boom that would have made them rich, the only thing my mother had ever wanted to be. I was born on May 17, 1949, to Kevin Francis Brady, farmer and (in the great South Fork tradition) drunk, and to Charlotte Easton (of the Sag Harbor Eastons) Brady, housewife and social climber. In 1951, my brother Easton was born. I went to Sagaponack Elementary School, a one-room schoolhouse. (The summer people say: “I love it! It’s so real.” So okay, A for ambience. C–for education. B for freezing dampness that makes your fingers throb in the winter. And A+ for smells from decomposing rodents under the foundation in late spring.) Then I went to Bridgehampton High. And then the State University of New York at Albany. It wasn’t that I’d been such a saint in high school, but at least I’d known who I was and that I’d belonged. Sure, I was a bad boy in Bridgehampton—a little driving while intoxicated, a little breaking and entering. In my heart I knew it was a phase, that someday I would become a solid citizen, buy back my father’s farm, sit on the school board. But I picked the wrong generation, and the wrong genes. Up at Albany, I became just another whacked-out asshole with sideburns. I embraced my generation’s holy trinity: sex, drugs, and rock and roll. I was a true believer. I screwed and drank and drugged along with Jim Morrison and Jimi Hendrix and Janis Joplin. I didn’t die, though. I flunked out. So I enlisted in the United States Army. Why? To this day, I have no idea. I can’t re-create the boy I
MAGIC HOUR / 19
was, the boy who could do something that dumb and selfdestructive. On my first day of basic, they clipped my hair with a machine that left it less than a quarter inch long. I remember standing at attention and having a five-foot-three Filipino drill sergeant reach up and grab those hairs between his thumb and index finger, pull at them, and scream up into my face, “Fucking hippie!” All I wanted to do was go home. I knew I wasn’t man enough to take it. Except I had to take it. In those eight weeks, the army’s goal is to break you down, then build you up again into a machine that obeys all commands without thought or argument. Well, they broke me down. I cried myself to sleep every night. There I was, a big guy, a soldier, boo-hooing into my pillow so that no one, especially all the other crybabies, could hear me. But I went off to war an infantryman, a master of the M79 grenade launcher. I fought for God and America and the honor of the Brady bunch. No. Actually, I just fought to stay alive. I fought even harder not to feel alive. Feeling dead was a major asset in Vietnam. I moved on from hash and pot to smoking opium joints. And after about a month, skag. Skag is heroin. Five or ten percent pure on the streets in the States. Ninety-six percent pure in Vietnam. No needles: cigarettes. You just had to inhale, so you weren’t a junkie. We were all very clear on that. We were just a bunch of grunts sitting around smoking at night after a hard day’s work in the jungle: a little patrolling, a little shooting, and then stacking up stinking dink corpses so we could get our body count and move on for more. Skag was cheap: three bucks a hit. Skag was good for us grown-up G.I. Joes, better than pot, because pot makes time go very, very slow. Heroin lifts you out of your body, takes you out of time. It got me
20 / SUSAN ISAACS
through those three hundred and sixty-five days in hell. No, I wasn’t caught. If you had brains and a little foresight, you could get a buddy to pee for you and were home free. (Ha.) I was discharged, honorably. I hadn’t been doing skag every day. Just almost every day. I said to myself: You’re not addicted. But when I landed back in the States after the eighteen-hour flight, I was sick—leg pains when we refueled in Guam, stomach cramps, the sweats in Hawaii. Terrible diarrhea the whole time, banging on the door of the airplane bathroom, doubled over, screaming at the top of my lungs: Please, oh God, let me in! In San Francisco I had to buy heroin on the street. Three days, five hundred bucks. I couldn’t handle a needle. The dealer had me wait in the basement of a burned-out grocery store; after the high started to wear off, I’d stand there shivering in the dark, my head twitching. I could smell the wet, charred wood and the decay, hear the deranged scurrying of rats. When there was a lull in his action, the dealer would clomp downstairs, hold a flashlight in his mouth and shoot me up. He had hunched shoulders and a thrust-forward turtle head, like Nixon. His damp, hot finger-tips probed for a vein; there were crescents of green-black dirt under his nails. He told me: Don’t expect me to keep doing this. This is a special introductory service. It was that night I lucked out. I came up for air about two A.M. and ran right into a San Francisco P.D. street sweep. A big, mean-looking black cop grabbed me. He was about to pat me down when he took a second look and said, Army? I said, Yeah, and he said, You dumb piece of white shit, but instead of taking me in, he dropped me at one of those free clinics in Haight-Ashbury. The clinic was run by a woman doctor. It took almost a week to get detoxed. Then I spent another
MAGIC HOUR / 21
two weeks in bed—with the woman doctor. Her name was Sharon. “Positive reinforcement,” she called it. Sharon panted a lot; I kept feeling her hot, moist spearmint Certs breath. She always gazed deep into my eyes the second it was over. Aren’t I marvelous? her eyes demanded. Marvelous? Somehow I was getting it up and, apparently, getting it off. But my dick could have been Novocained; I swear to God I felt nothing. By the end of the second week, Sharon was after me to go back to college—in San Francisco. Hey! I could move in with her! What a fabulous idea! Together we could bang our brains out! Detox the toxed! Refinish her floors! I did not leave my heart—or any other part of me—in San Francisco. I was back home for Christmas. Two days of my mother and brother, and I moved out. I needed a job. One of my buddies from high school had joined the Southampton Town P.D. No degree necessary. Decent pay. I applied, but there was a waiting list, so instead I joined the Suffolk County P.D. I became Guardian of the Suburbs, Keeper of the Peace for the lawn-tenders and splitlevel dwellers. I soon began showing my true Brady (as opposed to Easton) colors, popping a few beers a day. Then a six-pack. I was an alcoholic—not that I knew it—and an armed officer of the law. But hey, I was a terrific, ambitious cop. My job meant everything to me. In the beginning, I was even snowed by the dumb stuff: the uniform, the shield, the gun, the siren. Finally, I was part of something good. Law and order. With a little effort, I felt that my life, like Suffolk County, could be brought under control. Mainly I worked. I spent my days off in Bridgehampton, picking up women and getting laid or watching the Yankees. (In an ideal world, it would
22 / SUSAN ISAACS
have been both.) In eighteen years, I don’t think I had a relationship that lasted longer than a month. I worked my way up to drinking two six-packs and half a fifth of booze a day. Scotch in winter, vodka in summer. Like every other drunk, I was absolutely positive I wasn’t a drunk. My mind was so sharp; I could give you every single stat from Thurman Munson’s entire career. And at work, when I was on a hard case, I could lay off booze completely. Hey, I had no problem. By 1984 I was a detective sergeant in Homicide. I was working eighteen, twenty hours a day. I’d go on the wagon and stay on for a couple of months; then I’d slide off. But I was good at hiding my drinking. Finally, not good enough. Fourteen years after I’d been an alcoholic, someone in the department noticed that what even my friends had been calling my short fuse might be a bad drinking problem when I got into a fight with some guy from Missing Persons in the parking lot at headquarters in Yaphank. I pulled my gun, aimed and shot out his side mirror. I have absolutely no memory of it. They told me I started up because this guy had parked over the line, too close to my car, an indigo ’63 Jaguar, E-type. It could go from zero to fifty in 4.8 seconds. I loved my car. My commanding officer, Captain Shea, suggested a vacation at South Oaks, the department’s favored drying-out spot. Vacation: They took away my suitcase and searched it; they strip-searched me; they took away my razor. I was so scared. No one else there was. This was the place to see and be seen. Anybody who’s anybody is drying out, all the hip guys and gals in sweatpants and slippers seemed to be saying. They all loved group; they loved to talk about their sodden
MAGIC HOUR / 23
daddies, their stinko moms. They couldn’t wait to tell about waking up caked in their own vomit. They cried. They laughed. They hugged each other. They all seemed to think they were auditioning for the lead in their own TV bio-movie: Debbie [or Marvin]: Portrait of a Long Island Alcoholic. I remember always being cold at South Oaks, and talking as little as I could get away with. But I thought all the time. I thought: My life is shit. All I have is work—death—my dick and TV. Listen, when you’re sitting in a therapy session at a funny farm with seven substance abusers and a psychiatric social worker and you look back and realize that the highlight of the last decade of your life was getting cable so you could watch Sports Channel, you begin to realize you might be a little deficient in the humanity department. I dried out at South Oaks. After I left, I stayed with AA. The department told me they wouldn’t can me, but I would have to go back into uniform. That was terrible. No, humiliating was what it was. Forget that I’d once been thrilled to be the boy in blue. Now I was a man. So what was I doing all dressed up like Mr. Policeman for Halloween? Was I doomed to endless, mind-numbing cruising in a patrol car for the rest of my life? I fought like hell for half a year to get back into Homicide. Besides the Yankees, my work—putting together the puzzle—was the only thing I really cared about in the world, the only thing that made me feel alive. I finally made it back in, mainly because Shea and Ray Carbone knew they needed me and went to bat for me. But I lost my rank of sergeant. I was clearly not a leader of men. Shea said, “Bottom line, Brady. I don’t give a rat’s twat that alcoholism’s a disease. That’s your problem. If I hear you even walk
24 / SUSAN ISAACS
within a mile of a bottle of anything, I’ll bust your ass for good. Hear me?” Yeah, I said. Fair enough. In January 1989, on my way home from an AA meeting, I met Lynne, age twenty-three, originally of Annapolis, Maryland, a teacher of learning-disabled kids at Holy Spirit Academy in Southampton, when I stopped to help her with a flat tire. Lynne was intelligent. Serious. Classy. Pretty. And competent: she really didn’t need me to help her change the flat. And yes indeed, she was stable. On July 4, we got engaged. There it is. My Life, by Stephen Edward Brady. Not precisely a sterling character. In fact, something of a not-so-good guy. Maybe even a bad guy. But a man who, like all men, holds within him the possibility of redemption. Right? Anyway, my autobiography until that not-nice day when Sy Spencer was murdered and when I realized that—till death do us part—I would find peace and quiet and even happiness with Lynne. But I might never have fun.
CHAPTER TWO
Come on,” I urged the kid, hoping for an argument. “Sy and Lindsay were the perfect couple.” Jesus, I wanted life. Believe me, I’d worked on enough homicides to know that the first interviews set the tone for the whole investigation. You had to charge up your sources; any passion—rage at the killer, outrage, grief, hostility to the police—was better than slack jaws and lead asses. I paced back and forth. “Sy Spencer and Lindsay Keefe. A brilliant show-business couple: successful, in love, making a great movie.” “No,” Gregory J. Canfield whispered. He had actually uttered a word. That meant he was metabolizing. But it was hard to tell; he was about as animated as the average homicide victim. Gregory was Sy’s personal production assistant, hired through some work-study deal with NYU film school. Poor guy: not only was his personality bordering on inert, but he was a born creep. He was the world’s skinniest human being, and his tight maroon T-shirt, which clung to his rib cage, and his wide-legged shorts with pleats didn’t help. Also, he had those spooky blue-white,
25
26 / SUSAN ISAACS
almost colorless eyes, eyes that belonged to some slime-bellied animal that crawled along the sticky, grape-sodasplattered floors of dark movie theaters. “Uh, Mr. Spencer and Ms. Keefe—they weren’t any Irving Thalberg and Norma Shearer.” I could hardly hear him. In comparison, my voice sounded overly strong—like an announcer on a toilet-bowl-cleaner commercial. “What are you saying? They weren’t happy?” “Maybe Lindsay Keefe told you something else, sir,” Gregory J. Canfield mumbled. That seemed as close to authoritative as he could get. “But I think, you know, maybe they were headed for disaster.” “What do you mean? Personal disaster?” “Well, um, more with the film. Maybe the personal stuff would follow.” He bent down and ran his finger under a tootight strap on his leg. He was wearing sandals, handmade things with leather thongs that crisscrossed up his stick legs. “What was wrong with the movie?” I asked. But I’d lost him; his attention was riveted on Sy and the crime-scene crew. His eyes panned the activity and then bugged out for a close-up of a couple of ID apprentices who were unreeling a tape measure from the corner of the pool deck to the back of Sy’s skull. Gregory’s skin got a little green; he swayed: a potential fainter. “Let’s move,” I said, grabbing his shoulder and steering him away from the action, down toward the stillness of the dune heath. “Talk to me. That’s it. Concentrate. Now, what makes you think Starry Night was in trouble?” “Uh, the dailies. What they used to call the rushes. They weren’t…good.” “Not good, or lousy?” “Um, more than lousy. Actually, more than horrendous.” His head had swiveled back to watch an M.E. tech
MAGIC HOUR / 27
swabbing Sy’s nose with a giant Q-tip. I turned him around so he was facing the ocean and held my hands up on the sides of his face for a second, like blinders. “Stop looking at all the cop crap, Gregory. You’re a movie guy, not a Homicide guy. You’ll just make yourself sick. Now tell me about Starry Night.” “Lindsay was killing the film. You should have seen Sy’s face after dailies: it went from disappointed to…traumatized.” “What did he say?” I asked. “Uh, well, you see, nothing. He was very—how can I put it?—reticent.” “What do you mean? Reserved? Cold? Nasty?” Gregory swallowed to clear his throat; his Adam’s apple bobbled. “No. He just didn’t…didn’t respond. It wasn’t one of those comfortable Gregory Peck silences, you know? More brooding De Niro—if De Niro was playing an Ivy League type. Something was going on underneath, but you weren’t sure what. Anyway, Sy’s secretary was staying in his New York office, so my job was to always be there for him: place phone calls, keep lists of whatever he wanted people to do, run errands back and forth to the set that his personal assistant—the assistant producer—was too important to do. I was in the house a lot, sometimes in the same room. But he never said anything to me unless it was some specific request. Like get a glass of Evian; he liked it plain, no lemon. Or find out what kind of flowers the costume designer likes, because Lindsay had gotten pretty nasty over a red lace teddy; Sy wanted to smooth things over.” “He never talked to you personally?” “No. Just hello in the morning and goodbye when I left—if he wasn’t on the phone.” “Did you ever see him angry?” Gregory shook his head. “Did you ever see him show any emotion at all?”
28 / SUSAN ISAACS
“Well, he’d laugh at someone’s joke on the phone, that sort of thing. One time, when he was talking to someone who I guess was very important, he was doing William Powell. You know, roguish charm. But nothing else. Not while I was around, sir.” “Sounds like he must have been rough to work for.” “He was kind of like a combo William Hurt-Jack Nicholson. Classy-scary-cold. I think if you had some value to him he could be very nice. But I had absolutely no idea if he liked me or hated me.” “But still, even though he didn’t show emotion, you say you sensed he wasn’t thrilled with the dailies?” “Yes. The last couple of nights, he was white as a sheet after the lights came back on. He had to have known that Lindsay was running the film into the ground.” “But do you know that for a fact?” “No. I could just…intuit it.” “Had Lindsay and Sy been fighting?” “No direct confrontation. Not that I ever saw. But most of this week, the air was charged. I’m sure, with you being in Homicide, sir, you know better than most people that anger isn’t always expressed verbally.” “Yeah, I know that. But if you’re trying to sell me a charged-air theory, you’ve got to give me some substantiation. Come on now. How angry was Sy? How angry was Lindsay? Angry enough to have pumped two bullets into him?” Down near the beach, there was just enough light from Emergency Services for me to see Gregory’s white skeleton arms start popping goose bumps. “Please, Detective Brady, Ms. Keefe may have been wrong for this particular role, but I have the greatest respect for her not only as a performer but as a hu-
MAGIC HOUR / 29
man being. I’m sure someone of her intellectual stature and—” “Can it, Gregory! This isn’t some NYU film school fucking seminar. Now, you’d been shooting the movie for three weeks. Isn’t that early to know a picture’s in trouble?” “No. Everyone sensed it. You know how there’s a feeling of intense community? Did you ever see Day for Night?” “No. And don’t tell me about movies or actors. Tell me about life.” “On the set, the cast and crew were just going through the motions, talking about all the other movies they’d worked on. Not about this one.” “But what about Lindsay Keefe? How could she stink? She’s supposed to be one of the best actresses around, right?” “She is a good actress. But her role calls for vulnerability under a brittle exterior. The only thing that came through in dailies was brittleness. And not sophisticated, Sigourney Weaver brittleness. Just hardness, shallowness. Very TV miniseries.” “You personally saw these dailies?” “Yes.” “Well? Was she bad?” “Yes, sir.” “Did Sy ever express displeasure over her, either to her or to you or to anyone else?” “Not…really. But he was so circumspect, you never had any idea what he was thinking unless he specifically told you.” Gregory hesitated. I couldn’t tell if he was trying to come up with something—anything—to please me or whether he was honestly trying to remember something. But just then, Robby Kurz came sauntering down the lawn.
30 / SUSAN ISAACS
Detective Robert Kurz. Rain, shine, sleet, hail. Gunshot, strangling, knifing, poison. Man, woman, child. No matter what the conditions of a homicide were, Detective Robby lit up every crime scene with his big Howdy Doody smile, his endearing, snub-nosed face and the bright white light of his enthusiasm. “Yo, Steve!” “Hi.” To get away from his relentless exuberance, I walked toward the beach, pretending I wanted to think. Naturally, Robby hurried after me. Lucky for me, Robby was thirty. That provided some distance. I’d had almost ten years more on the force than he did. While he was still sitting in his patrol car, waiting for some commuter in Dix Hills to run a stop sign, I’d been the rising star of Homicide. In rank, having been busted, I was his equal. In fact, being lead detective, I was his superior. He tried not to acknowledge it. Robby—despite the shiny bald spot he tried to hide by combing his hair sideways and spraying it into paralysis, despite his desperately-eager-tocheat wife (Mrs. Howdy Doody, with a silver heart dangling in her freckled cleavage) and, more important, despite his arrest record, which was, embarrassingly and unfortunately, almost triple his conviction record—had determined that he was the perfect cop. This notion filled him with pleasure; it was impossible to pass him in the john, on the stairs, at the coffee machine without getting a rapturous grin. Every morning he handed out bagels and crullers and Danish to the squad like the Pope bestowing blessings. Robby stood beside me near the dune, one foot higher than the other, his body on an awkward slant. He was definitely not an outdoor guy; the security of Suffolk County-issue linoleum was vastly preferable to sand.
MAGIC HOUR / 31
“What’ve you got?” I asked. I ran my hand over the spikes of some tall beach grass. “Footprints on the grass near the house!” he enthused. “From rubber thongs. The regular, cheap kind. Mitch from the lab says they’re a man’s size ten or eleven, although obviously”—Robby paused, probably so I could prepare myself for a blast of deductive brilliance—“those kind of shoes can be worn by anyone. But if we can track them down—” “Where exactly were the footprints?” He pointed past the pool and the lawn, to the corner of the big porch that ran the entire length of the back of the house. I stretched my neck and squinted. A guy from the lab was straddling an area of grass right up against the house. He was just finishing photographing the footprints, getting ready to apply the dental stone we use for making molds of them. At that particular corner, the crawl space, neatly covered in lattice, rose about five or six feet high, with the porch above it. From up on the dunes, not far from where we were standing, a hundred feet away, it would have been easy to spot a man with a rifle. But not from the house. Unless you were deliberately leaning over the porch rail, looking right down at the spot where lawn met lattice, someone with a .22 could probably crouch in the shadowy safety of the grand old house and you’d never see him. “This could be major important!” Robby announced, nodding his head in agreement with himself. His sprayed hair didn’t move. But despite his excitement, I wasn’t ready to have an orgasm over the footprints; good investigators shouldn’t come too fast. I wanted to rule out all other possible explanations for the footprints before I wasted two days on a major thong hunt. “See if you can get someone to check out the gar-
32 / SUSAN ISAACS
deners,” I said to Robby. “Find out if any of them wore thongs. Also, take a look in Sy’s closet. I didn’t notice any in there when I did my walk-through, and I don’t think he’d do anything like wear them, but this could have been the summer that guys like him decided K Mart was très amusing or some shit, and he’d have bought fifty pairs.” I thought for a second. “Except maybe not a size ten or eleven. He was a little guy: little hands, little feet, probably little—” I stopped before I even started. It was no fun being immature and dirty around Robby. His idea of humor was Polack knock-knock jokes. His concept of sex talk was to confide that he and Freckled Cleavage had gone on a marriage encounter weekend. “Anything else?” I asked him. Robby grinned (boyishly) and fiddled with a cuff of his sports jacket, a shiny blue thing that had a half-belt stitched around the waist in back. He dressed as though he made an annual haberdashery pilgrimage to suburban Peoria. “There were hairs. In one of the guest bedrooms, although there weren’t any guests.” “Were they all from Sy?” “There was one pubic hair, probably his. Four head, someone leaning back against one of those wicker headboards. The hairs got caught.” “Any with roots?” With the new DNA typing, you can get a genetic make on someone from any cell with a nucleus. But to test hair, you need the follicle cells that cling to the root, and although you can sometimes make do with one, it helps if you have a clump of ten or twelve hairs. “Complete roots on two of the head hairs from the headboard. They were not Sy Spencer’s hairs, because they were black or very dark brown, and longish. He had short gray—” “Yeah, I saw.” I’d also gotten a fast look at Lindsay Keefe when
MAGIC HOUR / 33
her agent had half escorted, half hauled her out of the car, and she’d been what I’d remembered from movies. Blond. In fact, the blondest. “That’s all you found?” I asked him. “Come on,” he said. He was so goddamn chipper. “You know how long it takes to get anything resembling an opinion from ID.” “So while you were inside with Carbone you didn’t happen to ask if there were any live-in people who might have had a quickie in the bedroom? Maids, valets—that kind of thing?” “Relax. Where are you going? To a fire? I was just about to ask about servants, but I thought I’d fill you in first.” Robby paused. It had been three minutes since he’d displayed any disarming boyishness, so I got a lopsided smile. “Look, we both know this is a major case, Steve. I want the brownie points on this one—and so should you. If we can close this neat and fast, it could mean big things.” When you work with a bunch of cops, or any group of people, there are always some who are going to irritate you. Either with lousy character traits, like laziness, dishonesty, sloppiness, or just with irritating personal habits like teeth sucking, cuticle nibbling or superfluous grinning. But Robby wasn’t awful. He wasn’t hateful. Sometimes, like when he was talking sports, especially hockey, he could actually be interesting; nobody knew as much about the Islanders’ offensive strategy as he did. And so what if behind all the smiles he was a self-righteous dick? I just steered clear of him. But what I couldn’t steer clear of was the fact that I thought he was a bad cop. And he thought he was Suffolk County’s anointed Good Guy. Days, even weeks, before the assistant D.A.s felt they had a case,
34 / SUSAN ISAACS
Robby would be pushing to arrest, because he knew who the bad guy was. And he was going to get him. The smiles and the crullers he handed out to cops disappeared for suspects; most of his interrogations turned into finger-jabbing accusations. Sure, he could intimidate some kid into spilling his guts. But he’d alienate suspects other detectives had softened up, and instead of agreeing to a videotaped confession, they’d be screaming for a lawyer. One time, my best friend on the squad, Marty McCormack, and I had a young guy whose new wife had disappeared. I knew—Christ, everybody knew—that he’d killed her and dumped the body. But how could we find out where? We played it as if this guy was the anguished husband; Marty kept him looking for his wife, thinking of possibilities where she could be. I kept him talking. One night, we stepped out for a bowl of chili and asked Robby just to come into the interrogation room and baby-sit. In the half hour we were gone, he came on tough. Hostile. Aggressive. He knew this was a bad guy. Who didn’t? But he almost ruined it. And I’d lost it when I found out, banging walls, calling him a stupid piece of shit in the squad room. “You almost fucking blew it!” I yelled. He’d said, “Just cut it out, Steve,” and even managed a boyish shake of the head that said: Jeez, that Brady and his darn ole temper. It wasn’t that I hated him. We were just oil/water, fish/fowl, day/night. And so without making a big deal over it, we’d pretty much arranged our lives—and our desks—so we stayed apart. Until Sy. “Steve Brady!” Marian Robertson, Sy’s cook, exclaimed. Then she made a twirling motion with her index finger. Spin around, boy, it said. And, obedi-
MAGIC HOUR / 35
ently, I turned around so she could get the three-hundredsixty-degree picture. “I can’t say you don’t look a day older than you did in high school,” she went on, “though you are that same boy—but with a man’s face. I said to myself the minute you walked in: ‘That’s the boy who was shortstop on Mark’s team,’ although I went blank on your name. I do see your brother. Easton Brady’s your brother, right?” I nodded. “Such a handsome boy. Could be a movie star himself.” Mrs. Robertson babbled away with the absolute self-confidence that came with the conviction that she was the South Fork’s Most Unforgettable Character. In fact, I’d totally forgotten her until I walked into Sy’s kitchen. And what a kitchen—especially if you were a big eighteenth century fan. Strings of garlic, wreaths of herbs, copper pots and straw baskets hung from the walls and the beams. An iron kettle hung in a six-foot-high brick fireplace; it was so gargantuan Sy could have played hide-and-seek in it. Mrs. Robertson turned away from me to finish cutting the crusts off the sandwiches she was making for the crime-scene crew and began arranging them in a perfect, intricate pile: some creamy-colored cheese on the bottom, pale-pink pâté next, and then dark smoked ham, so the platter looked like a spiffy architectural model of a ten-million-dollar beach house. “Isn’t this something?” she inquired. “One of my specialties. Anyway, Steve, the minute you showed me your badge, of course I remembered hearing you had become a policeman, although as you may imagine, between you and I and a lamppost, you were pretty near the last boy at Bridgehampton High I’d expect to see in uniform, so to speak.” She gave me a nose crinkle that (I think) meant: You may have a gun and a badge, but to me you’re still a teeno with Clearasil
36 / SUSAN ISAACS
dots. “I see being a detective you can wear regular clothes. Rank does have its privileges, and that’s nice, because you are looking fit.” Marian Robertson looked the same as when she sat in the first row of the stands at every high school baseball game: dark-brown skin, short, with rounded features and a cute, pudgy body, as if, through interracial marriage, she was half sister to the Pillsbury Doughboy. The only change I could see was her hair; it looked like she’d slapped a gray wig on her head as a seventh-inning joke to give the Bridgies a laugh. Back in high school, she’d acted Unforgettable too, bringing cookies for “you young fellows,” handing each of us a chocolate-chip or a pecan sandy as we trotted off the field, calling out, There’s more where that came from! “Mrs. Robertson, I know you gave your statement to Sergeant Carbone, but I have a couple more questions. What does the maid look like?” “The maid? She’s very plain.” Mrs. Robertson opened one of the glass doors of the giant restaurant-style refrigerator, eyed the melons and took out an enormous beige ball that was probably a twenty-five-dollar, genetically engineered cantaloupe. I glanced at my pad. “There’s only the maid, Rosa?” “That’s right.” “Is she black, white, Hispan—” “Portuguese.” Marian Robertson cut me off. “Short, but taller than me. Maybe five foot two. You know, there used to be a song.” She cleared her throat: “‘Five foot two / Eyes of blue / But oh what those five two can do…’ Oh, Lord! Steve, that I’m singing! I apologize. How it must look! But I’ve been working for Mr. Spencer for fourteen summers, and it’s so…Murdered!”
MAGIC HOUR / 37
“Listen, you’re upset. You have every right to be.” I paused. “Were you very fond of him?” “Well…fond enough. I mean, he was so polite. That’s what everyone said: ‘Sy is so divinely polite. So courtly.’ You know how those Yorkers talk.” I nodded; all of us who were born here shared the knowledge that we were more decent and more down-to-earth than the slickers from New York City. When you really came down to it, we knew we were better human beings. “Let me tell you, you can double the phoniness in spades for movie types. But Mr. Sy Spencer himself seemed to be genuine silk stocking—not at all flashy or fresh.” “But did you like him?” “Well…now that I think about it, I’m not sure. He was one cool cucumber.” “Was he cold? Withdrawn?” “No. Very toned down, but decent enough. Smiled a lot. Didn’t laugh. Never treated me any different the first summer or the fourteenth. But it was like he had a script of how to act with a cook, and that was that. Teasing, like about how he was going to have to mortgage the house to pay for my chickens; I make a very rich chicken stock. But the same joke for fourteen years. “And let’s see. He was indeed polite: a compliment after every dinner party, and if he didn’t like something, which was hardly ever, he wasn’t rude. He’d just say, ‘I am not entranced by chocolate-dipped fruit.’” She opened a plastic container and handed me a cookie. “Viennese almond wafer.” “Thank you. Getting back to the maid, Mrs. Robertson. What does she look like?” “Short, like I told you. Yellowish skin, but with pockmarks, poor baby.” The cookie was good. I smiled. “What color is her hair?”
38 / SUSAN ISAACS
“My, are you handsome when you smile! You should smile more often. It lights up your face like a Christmas tree.” “Rosa’s hair, Mrs. Robertson?” “Originally, only the good Lord and her mother know, although my guess is your basic brown. For all the time she’s worked here”—she shook her head sadly—“fire-engine red.” “And you and Rosa were the only people who work here? I expected valets or chauffeurs or butlers.” “No. He hired waiters and bartenders for dinners and parties. He had a driver in the city, but he took a helicopter out here and drove himself around in that Italian sports car of his.” I held out my hand for another cookie. As she gave it to me, I asked: “Who was in the guest bedroom today with Sy Spencer?” “What?” She looked startled. “Someone used the guest bedroom.” “Besides Mr. Spencer?” “Yes.” “Really? I have no idea, Steve. You know, he and Lindsay Keefe were living together. But they’re in the master suite. What makes you think someone was in the guest bedroom?” I took another bite of the cookie. “Just some indications,” I answered. “Did you hear anyone upstairs?” “Only Mr. Spencer. He was here all afternoon, packing to go to Los Angeles, on the phone. He had been supposed to leave this morning, but then he had to go over to the movie set, so I guess he was changing a few plans.” “No one with him?” “No.” She thought for an instant and then added: “I mean, I won’t cross my heart and hope to die,
MAGIC HOUR / 39
because to tell you the truth, you can count the times on one hand that I’ve been on the second floor of this house. But as far as I know, he was alone.” “Where was Rosa?” “She cleans and does a laundry every morning, then goes home for the afternoon…she has a little girl. Takes whatever ironing. She comes back about six, to tidy up from my cooking—scours pots, damp mops the floor, takes out trash, that sort of thing. Then she stays through dinner and does the dishes and sets the table for breakfast.” “Mrs. Robertson, I don’t want to embarrass you, but in a police investigation we have to ask some pretty direct questions.” “Go ahead.” “Was there any indication that Mr. Spencer had sexual relations in any other room beside the master bedroom?” “I go home after dinner. So for all I know, he could be making hay in the sauna or in the screening room or in the wine cellar. All I can vouch for is not in my kitchen, because I would know in two seconds flat. Nobody, not the boss, not God himself, is allowed to mess with my kitchen. Got that, Steve?” “Got it.” “Good.” Local cops—in this case the Southampton Village P.D.—secure the perimeter of a crime scene. One of them, a gangly kid my grandmother would have called a long drink of water, came into the tent on the far side of the pool where we were inhaling Marian Robertson’s sandwiches. He called out: “Is there a Steve Brady on duty tonight?” I put down my mug of coffee. “A guy’s out front. Real shook up about the murder. Says he’s your brother.” So I went over to Ray Carbone to tell him about
40 / SUSAN ISAACS
Easton’s connection to Sy, even though I had to interrupt Carbone while he was lifting up a triangle of sandwich and eyeing it suspiciously, clearly having deduced that it was, in fact, pâté. “Can we talk outside for a minute?” I asked. He slid the sandwich back on the platter. The green-and-white-striped tent we’d been in was a threesided thing. I guess it was either for changing, if you were an exhibitionist, or for just lying out of the sun and wind. It was about ten feet away from the shallow end of the pool, a perfect distance for a police snack—far enough from the crime scene so that you wouldn’t have to pretend Sy’s body was a scatter rug while you were woofing down his food. “Listen, Ray, my brother—his name is Easton—he’s out front. He wants to see me.” “Let him come back, take a look,” said Carbone. In the shadow of Sy Spencer’s house, he’d suddenly become Long Island’s most gracious host. He even did a be-my-guest sweep with his arm. Then he added: “Easton?” “Yeah.” “What kind of a name is Easton?” “My mother’s from this Yank family up in Sag Harbor. It was her maiden name. They do things like that.” “I thought you were Irish.” “My father was Irish. About my brother—” “What does he do?” “A little bit of everything. Classy stuff.” “Like what?” “He sold Jaguars. I bought mine from him. Then he sold expensive real estate. Worked in a bunch of hot-shit boutiques around here.” “Sounds as if he never settled into a defined role. How come?” “I’m a borderline personality myself. How the hell
MAGIC HOUR / 41
should I know what’s wrong with anybody else?” Over in the tent, the men were still swarming around the table laden with Sy’s food. “Ray, put a lid on the psychoanalysis for now. I want to get this over with. It has to do with the case.” “The case? Your brother?” “Yeah. I mentioned the connection when Headquarters called, but I forgot to tell you. Easton was working for Sy. Listen, about three, four months ago he was out of a job: not exactly news. Anyway, he heard about how Sy was going to be making a big part of Starry Night in East Hampton, so he wangled an invitation to some jazzy charity party. To make a long story short, he got introduced to Sy and made a big pitch about how he’d been born and raised here and knew everybody and could be helpful. Sy liked him and hired him to be a kind of liaison with the locals—I guess to spread a little money around and keep things happy and get things ready for filming. He did so well that Sy kept him on for the movie.” “Any problems?” “No. It was really working out. That’s the shitty thing; my brother finally seemed to have found something he was enthusiastic about, plus something he was actually good at. Sy had even made him one of the assistant producers, with his name right up there. Not at the beginning, but at the end when you see all those names. Anyway, sooner or later someone will be taking his statement. I’m just letting you know about him because the department’s so big on all that ethics crap.” “Well, maybe let Robby take it.” I guess he saw my face. “Steve, Robby’s not a bad kid. Okay, too brighteyed and bushy-tailed for your taste.” “He has no balance.” “He has enough, and if not, you’ll make up for it. Robby is with you on this one. You’ll see, it’ll work
42 / SUSAN ISAACS
out. He’s really gung-ho. Anyway, it looks better if someone who isn’t your closest friend takes care of your brother. But listen, I have no objection if you want to sit in the background. Quietly.” He paused. “Is your brother, you know, a stable guy?” “No. He’s a demented twit who took a .22 and blew Sy Spencer away because Sy had become his mentor-father figure and Easton has such a low sense of worth that anyone who respected him and helped him self-actualize was ipso facto worthless and had to die.” I’m not bad. Easton is handsome. Although we resemble each other, I look like an Irish cop and he looks like an Episcopalian lawyer. In other words, my brother is a WASPier, more refined version of me: his eyes a truer blue, his jaw more squared-off, his hair shinier, plus he actually is six feet. I’m just a shade under, which has always annoyed me because girls—women—always ask “How tall are you?” and if I say six feet I feel like a fraud, but if I were to say five eleven and five-eighths, I’d feel like a buffoon. Easton was standing in the gravel driveway, not far from the stairs that led to the front door. He wasn’t in one of his typical getups: a bright-colored blazer, or a pale-pastel sweater, looking more the leisured Southampton aristocrat than the real ones ever did. He was wearing a dark-gray suit with an impeccable paisley tie. His cordovan shoes, illuminated by the unobtrusive low beams that lit the circular driveway and entrance, were brighter than his face. Upset? Even in the dim light I could see he was very upset. Skin waxy. Eyes red not so much from crying but, as I saw as I came up to him, from rubbing them, as if in disbelief. “Hey, East,” I said. He jumped. “You okay?” “Sorry. Do you know what’s so odd? Here I am,
MAGIC HOUR / 43
actually waiting for you, hoping you were here, but my mind was going in ten different directions at once, and just now, when I heard your voice, my first thought was: What the hell is Steve doing at Sy’s house?” “When did you hear about what happened?” “When I got back from New York. I drove there today, to do some odds and ends for Sy, and when I got home, there was a call on my machine. From this perfectly awful film school type who’s his P.A. Production assistant. Something like: ‘Um, uh, you might wish to know that Mr. Spencer was, like, murdered at his home.’” All of a sudden Easton stopped talking. He got the shakes. “Damn. It’s nippy,” he managed to say. Like my mother, Easton used words like ‘nippy’ instead of ‘cold’ or ‘cool’ or ‘chilly,’ words to distinguish him from the proles. “Oh, good God.” He rubbed his arms, but it didn’t help. Then his teeth started to chatter, fast, like those stupid wind-up teeth in novelty stores. “Did you speak to Sy today, East?” “Last night.” “Any indication of trouble?” “No.” “Had any threats been made against him that you know of?” He shook his head in answer—and in disbelief. “Do you have any reason to think he was afraid of anything, or anyone?” “No.” “Any change at all in his behavior?” He couldn’t stop shaking. “He was fine, I’m telling you.” For my brother, trembling was the absolutely perfect, tasteful way to fall apart: so proper. It didn’t make any noise, and unlike sweating or barfing, you could have your breakdown and then go right on to a cocktail party without messing up your clothes and having to change.
44 / SUSAN ISAACS
“They can get your statement tomorrow. Why don’t you go home? You look pretty shitty.” “I don’t even know why I’m here.” He glanced up at the house. “Actually, I suppose I thought I should show up. In the back of my mind I was thinking: With all the chaos—police, God knows what else—maybe I can give Sy a hand. It’s an insane reaction, but Steve, I have to tell you, this is such a shock. I mean, to get that message.” “It must have been a real kick in the nuts.” “It knocked the wind out of my sails. I can’t believe it. Who in God’s name would murder Sy?” “Who do you think?” “No one would want to kill him,” Easton announced. He was positive. He stuck his hands in the pockets of his New York City fancy pants. “The facts seem to indicate otherwise, don’t they?” “Probably a burglar.” “No.” “How do you know for sure?” “What are you talking about? It’s my job to know.” “And you’re never wrong, are you?” As usual, after more than sixty seconds in each other’s company, we were into our regular sibling routine—being irritated by each other. I decided this was one time I should be unirritated. More than that. He was my brother. He was genuinely upset; I should be gentle. “There doesn’t seem to be any evidence of a burglary attempt,” I said, as softly as I could. “How was he killed?” “Shot. From some distance. Most likely with something like a .22. It doesn’t look like an impulsive act.” We had a long moment of silence. “Listen, one of the other guys will interview you, probably tomorrow. Go on home.”
MAGIC HOUR / 45
He shivered again. “He was really good to me.” “Yeah. Listen, I’m sorry. Oh, East, one more thing. Forget fights, threats. Did Sy give any indication that he was having problems with anybody?” To give him credit, my brother really seemed to think about it. “I’ve only been working with him for three and a half months. I can’t set myself up as an expert. But from what I’ve seen, when you’re producing a movie, you have problems with everybody. You’re dealing with a cast and crew of a hundred prima donnas—and their agents, and their unions. And then you have the moneymen, who always make life a living hell. A producer has to be tough-minded—and tough. And Sy was. He never backed off from a confrontation. He just kept going.” A small, affectionate smile passed over Easton’s face for a second. “Sy was like a steamroller. He wouldn’t stop. You either moved or got crushed. At some point, just about everyone involved probably told him, or wanted to tell him: Drop dead.” “Son of a bitch!” Carbone blew up in front of me and Robby Kurz. He was yelling about Eddie Pomerantz, Lindsay’s agent, now safely on his way home, who, two minutes earlier, had informed him that Lindsay had taken a couple of Valium and was out like a light, but who then admitted, when Carbone started screaming at him, that she’d had four or five. Possibly six, although he wanted it clearly understood that his client was seriously not into drugs. Carbone explained to us: “I had that doctor from the M.E.’s office—the one with the Dumbo ears—go up to her room. He says she could be genuinely knocked out for more than eight hours. Passive-aggressive bitch.” We sat in Sy’s office, a room on the second floor that had probably been a kid’s bedroom. You knew it was an office because there was a phone with so
46 / SUSAN ISAACS
many buttons that it looked like it could launch a satellite, and a small computer. But that was it for modern stuff. The rest of the room looked like some fish-crazy English gentleman’s study: there was a stuffed marlin on the wall, some washed-out paintings of salmon leaping out of the rapids, a bunch of gleaming, never-used rods, perfectly, casually arranged in a corner. Carbone scanned his notepad. “Now listen, no matter when we get out of here tonight or tomorrow morning, I want both of you back at ten to interview Lindsay Keefe. I’ll probably be stuck in a meeting with Shea on how to handle this thing. This thing’s bigger than Newsday. It’s national. International. Now, Robby,” Carbone went on, “before ten, get what you can from Steve’s brother, Easton. Then meet Steve here, for Lindsay. After you’re through with her, you work on Sy’s business associates. First from this movie. Then start working back. “Steve, you concentrate on all the nonbusiness-type movie people. Oh, and his women. Look into if he was currently involved with anyone besides Lindsay. And check his exwives. He had two of them. One lives in Bridgehampton, so maybe you can get to her before ten.” He glanced down to his pad. “Bonnie Spencer.” I shook my head. It sounded vaguely familiar, but I was sure it wasn’t anyone I’d actually met. “A movie writer.” He handed me a piece of paper with an address. “You know where it is?” “About two minutes from where I grew up.” “The other ex lives somewhere in the city. She was the first, and we’ll have a name and address on her by tomorrow. All right? We’ll use Southampton Village’s squad room as a command post for the next day or two. I’ll meet up with the two of you as soon as I can get out here tomorrow.” He stopped, looked right at
MAGIC HOUR / 47
me, and sighed. “I think this is going to be it. The case where I find out that I’m too old for this kind of work.” I stood in Sy’s gym, talking to Lynne from his wall phone. All the not-fun stuff I’d been bugging myself about since the afternoon now seemed stupid. Engaged-guy nerves, a lastditch defense of bachelorhood. Because, objectively, Lynne was so terrific. One of the things that had always knocked me out about her was that she acted as though I had a normal, not-terriblyexciting job. I could be a manager of an Aamco transmission franchise. She deliberately did not focus on what I actually did. I understood why; homicide is the ultimate breakdown of law and order, and Lynne’s whole life, as a teacher and as a person, was dedicated to being constructive. She was there to give someone a chance, not take it away. Murder wasn’t exciting. It was sinful, and it was also outrageously unfair. In the deepest sense, killing wasn’t nice. Another thing: despite her career and her really astonishing competence, she was enough of a traditional female not to want to hear the details of a fatal beating, or how the scalp is peeled back from the skull during an autopsy. So she concentrated not on the subject of my work—the dead and how they got that way—but on the living. So we were not chitchatting about the murder, other than the briefest summary of what had happened and where I was. Instead, we were talking people. We’d done thirty seconds on how Carbone managed to be an intrusive pain in the butt and a terrific guy at the same time, a minute and a half on why I couldn’t stand Robby, and now we were on to my brother. “Did you say anything like: ‘Gee, Easton, I’m sorry
48 / SUSAN ISAACS
about Mr. Spencer. I know how much you liked him and how important he was in your life’?” “Don’t bust my chops, Lynne.” Except for the floor, the entire gym was mirrored. I was the only thing in the room that didn’t gleam. Besides a stationary bike, a treadmill and one of those stair-climbing things—all with glowing red or green digital displays—there was a bunch of Nautilus equipment. I stood up straighter; either Sy had a lot of vanity to work out in front of all those mirrors, or he needed tremendous incentive. “Steve,” she said patiently, “did you say anything at all to comfort your brother?” “Yeah. I said I was sorry.” “That’s all?” Just when I thought I looked okay in one mirror, I’d see my reflection in another. I pulled my shoulders back. I knew I didn’t have a gut, but in the ceiling mirror I seemed to, so I sucked it in. “Don’t get on me about Easton now. I just called to say good night and I love you.” “Well, good night and I love you too. It’s just that I know how much you want a decent relationship with him. Wouldn’t this be the perfect time to reach out?” I told her I guessed it was, and then we did the good night and I love you business again because I’d been on with her for almost five minutes and wanted to get back. After we hung up, I lay down on the gray-carpeted floor and closed my eyes for about ten seconds, probably my total rest for the next forty-eight hours. I know it was sentimental—and probably inaccurate—to say Lynne had saved me, but I really felt she had. Sure, I’d been staying sober with AA. And since getting back into Homicide I was working better than I ever had before. But by the time I met her, I was feeling scared. I
MAGIC HOUR / 49
was standing all alone, no crutches. No booze. No drugs at all. Two months after I got out of South Oaks, I got the flu. I sweated out a hundred-and-four-degree fever rather than risk becoming a Tylenol junkie. Hardly any women either: I had lost almost all desire. In the old days, almost anything that produced estrogen could get me going if I was in the mood to get going, but most of the time now I couldn’t seem to find anybody who made me want to unbuckle my belt. And yeah, there was football—the Giants, who I liked a lot. But no Yankees: it was January. I was running at least five miles a day to stay in shape and get that chemical going in the brain; I forget the name of it, but at South Oaks they told us it was the body’s natural narcotic and was okay. Running ten, twelve, sometimes fifteen miles on my days off, to get that high—and to exhaust myself because I was nervous about what I’d do with too much time and energy. See, at the funny farm the shrink talked to me about what deep down I always knew—or, if I didn’t know, sensed. That the drinking and the drugs and the womanizing were all pretty much the same thing, part of what he called my selfdestructive pattern. Sure, I had been going for the high, but (a big but) the high hadn’t been my real goal. What I’d really been searching for all that time was to feel nothing. Oblivion. So there I was, finally, trying to turn my back on oblivion, to face the world, to take one day at a time. But all that summer and fall, after those first heady years of sobriety, I started having nightmares: I was drinking again. I’d wake up from a dream about taking a bottle of icy, syrupy vodka out of the freezer, pouring it—almost against my will—and taking a deep, desperate sip. I’d feel panicked, sick to my stomach with despair. Because I knew how fragile my stability was. And I also knew I wasn’t a resilient
50 / SUSAN ISAACS
kid anymore. If I lost my grip again, I could fall into a bottomless pit, and I wouldn’t have the strength or the courage to try and climb back out. I would be lost for good. I would die. Talk about oblivion. And suddenly there was Lynne, standing by the trunk of her car, assembling the jack. She was cautious as I pulled over, but she looked me right in the eye and said, “Thanks. I can handle it.” I showed her my shield and told her that was fine with me; I’d hang around and watch. I liked watching women change tires. She handed me the jack, and when I finished I took her out for a hamburger. All of a sudden, I found I was having a genuine, normal conversation. Not just talking to a woman to prove I wasn’t only out to screw her. Real discussion. About the emotional problems kids with dyslexia can get. About whether a person’s body language can make them more or less likely to be the victim of a crime. About public schools versus Catholic schools. And about how I was an alcoholic. And two weeks later, we went to bed. I lay there afterwards and thought: Oh my God! I’m having a relationship.
CHAPTER THREE
Bonnie Spencer’s dog barked with joy: Hiya, hiya, wonderful to see ya! Its tail made giant circles of jubilation: Whoopee! We got company! It was a huge, happy thing, like a fat, black English sheepdog. “Steve Brady,” I called out, and flipped open my ID. Her dog interrupted its woofing only long enough to lick my hand and my shield: Hiya! Love ya! But Bonnie Spencer stood silent and motionless in her front doorway—and gaped. It was seven forty-five, the morning after her ex-husband had been murdered. She obviously hadn’t been expecting condolence calls; she was wearing turquoise second-skin biking shorts, a huge, shapeless faded pink cotton T-shirt and sweat socks. A pair of sneakers dangled from her hand, as if she’d been about to put them on for a run. “I’m a detective with Suffolk County Homicide,” I added. Her lips rounded as if she was going to say Oh!, but she didn’t. She didn’t do anything, not even glance at my ID. She simply gawked. “Bonnie Spencer?” The
51
52 / SUSAN ISAACS
dog poked her leg with its snout, as if to say: Come on, talk to the guy. But she didn’t. I put my ID away, stuck my hands into my pockets. Even though it was a warm, end-of-summer morning, the moist, leafy smell of fall was in the air. Bonnie Spencer didn’t seem to want to look at me; instead, she seemed mesmerized by my car in her driveway. Listen, the ’63 XKE is a truly great car, but when there’s a detective from Homicide on your doorstep first thing in the morning, that should be the attention-grabber. “Are you Bonnie Spencer?” I repeated. She blinked, shaking off her daze. Her eyes brightened. “Am I Bonnie Spencer?” She laughed. But then she did an awkward box step of embarrassment, probably sensing her manner wouldn’t win any awards for Most Seemly Display of Wistful Sadness in a Situation in Which an Ex-Spouse Has Been Offed. She switched to subdued. “Of course I’m Bonnie.” Then she added: “Gee.” Gee. Bonnie Spencer. Okay, picture the ex-wife of a celebrated movie producer. What comes to mind? A cold, elegant bitch with tobaccocolored arms who wears jewelry to the beach. A stunner with pointy, polished nails that tap all the time, sending out the coded message: Fuck you; I’m dissatisfied. But Bonnie Spencer didn’t seem dissatisfied. And she definitely didn’t come across as elegant, especially with that goof of a dog slobbering with happiness at her side. Looks? No glamour girl, not by a long shot. More like one of those girl-buddy types, tall—five eight or nine—broad-shouldered and clean, probably from some clean town where all the girls said “Gee.” Nothing to write home about. Not much to look at. But the weird thing was, I couldn’t keep my eyes off her. Her best feature was her hair, glossy and dark,
MAGIC HOUR / 53
pulled back into a ponytail. Other than that…well, okay features. Deep laugh lines around her eyes. She had the high, healthy color men have more often than women: that rosy brownness that comes to the naturally fair-skinned who spend a lot of time out of doors. In other words, Bonnie Spencer, sneakers in hand, looked like someone you never really got to know in high school: the big, strapping girl jock who gets over mourning the end of field hockey season by spending the winter stroking her lacrosse stick. Except she was no girl—not anymore. The strong body and the shiny hair were deceptive. At first glance I had put her in her early thirties. But her neck was a little too lined, her lips a little too pale. She was in her late thirties, maybe even forty. In relation to Sy she made absolutely no sense. To have seen the compact, richly robed, perfectly groomed Mr. Spencer and his exquisite world of hand-painted pool tiles, and then to look at big, all-American Bonnie standing on the planked wood floor of a pretty but definitely not showstopping old salt-box house…The question was not why Sy had dumped her, but how such a man had come to marry such a woman in the first place. She was staring at me again. Her eyes were dark gray-blue, a deep, mysterious color for such a straightforward girl, the color of the ocean. I looked into them; that howcome-you’re-here expression had returned. “Ms. Spencer?” “Please,” she said, almost shyly. “Bonnie.” And then, once more, ka-boom, her mood changed. Suddenly she became friendly, easy. She gave me a smile. A great, generous smile. Perfect white teeth, except for a slightly crooked one in front, as though her parents had run out of money a month before the orthodontist had finished. Listen, it
54 / SUSAN ISAACS
can make you so happy to get a warm, uncomplicated smile like that. But why the hell was she smiling? Why the hell was her face lit up like that? What did she think I was going to do? Ask her to the senior prom? “You’ve heard about your former husband, Seymour Spencer?” “Oh, God,” she breathed. The smile vanished. Her eyebrows, the kind that slant up, like a bird’s wings, drew together; they were eyebrows meant for a more delicate woman. “It was on the ten o’clock news last night. One of those god-awful stories about famous people you don’t know. Except it was about Sy.” For a minute, her expression reflected the normal disorientation of the average citizen confronted with murder: a flash of horror, then a fast flare-up of incomprehension. “You probably hear this all the time, but I can’t believe it.” Her voice was filled with fervent emotion. “I’m so sorry.” Too much emotion. Too goddamn fervent. Look, I’d been in Homicide a long time. Every working day of my life was spent with the distraught, the agitated, the grieving, the indifferent. And so I knew that something wasn’t right about Bonnie Spencer. First of all, her “I’m so sorry” was overly personal; it’s hard to explain, but even the world’s most extroverted person doesn’t respond to a cop with that kind of familiarity. And another thing: just standing there in the doorway, she kept changing her mood. Not in the usual way, like a dazed person trying to come to grips with a too-terrible reality, but as though she were searching for the perfect, appropriate emotion to show off to me. How did I know all this? Any decent detective knows when to turn off his mind and tune in his gut.
MAGIC HOUR / 55
And my gut was saying: Something’s going on with this woman. So all of a sudden, instead of a routine interview with a dead hotshot’s ex-wife to see if I could come up with any leads, I was on the alert. “Would you like to come in?” she was asking. “Thanks.” It was a good-size, solid house, built for a farm family. I followed her—and the dog—into a roomy kitchen and, naturally, said “Yeah, great” when she offered to make me coffee. (Saying yes to coffee during an investigation makes people feel you’ve accepted them; it makes them relax, open up. Unfortunately, half the time you wind up drinking stuff that tastes like lukewarm liquid shit, but in the long run it’s probably worth it.) She cleared the morning’s papers—the Times, Newsday, the Daily News—all with their stories about Sy’s murder, off the table. She must have gone out for them when the coffee shop opened, at six; they’d all been read. I tipped the chair back and sat quietly, the way I usually do. I wanted to see what Bonnie Spencer would reveal. But she turned away to put the water up to boil and measure out coffee, so for a few seconds the only thing she revealed was nice thighs—a little overdeveloped, but muscular, tight. Meanwhile, the dog put its head on my lap and gazed up into my eyes—the soulful look a dumb girl who wants to be taken seriously would give in a bar. Bonnie turned around. “Moose,” she ordered, “go to place!” She pointed toward one of those small, oval braided rugs. The dog ignored her. Bonnie shrugged, half to herself, half in apology: “The dog has the IQ of a cockroach.” Then she opened a cabinet and took out a little white pitcher shaped like a cow. She was waiting for me to begin questioning her. I didn’t. She asked: “Did Sy…” She stopped
56 / SUSAN ISAACS
and started over. “The TV said he was shot.” I nodded. She held open the refrigerator with her hip while she poured milk into the pitcher. I glanced inside: no chilling white wine or goat cheese in there. God knows over the years I’d made it with enough summer women to recognize that, at least in the food department, Bonnie was not a typical New York woman. She was either on a budget, on a diet, or had given up all hope of visitors; she had a pint container of milk, whole wheat bread and a big, Saran-wrapped glass bowl that looked like she’d gotten overenthusiastic about broccoli. “Was his death instantaneous?” Her voice was high, hopeful. “We’ll know more after the autopsy.” Just then, Moose gave a deep, lovelorn sigh and lay down at my feet. On my feet, actually. “Everything I can think of to say is a cliché—but I hope he didn’t suffer.” “I hope not.” “Well,” she said, “I guess you weren’t just cruising the neighborhood and felt like a cup of coffee.” “I guess not.” All of a sudden I realized I had seen her before. Probably at the post office, getting her mail. “I guess you have some questions,” she said. “Yes.” But I didn’t ask any. I got busy pretending to formulate a question while studying her cow pitcher. What I was actually doing was checking out if Bonnie had a body worth writing home about under that big T-shirt. Naturally, when I caught myself doing it, I got pissed because I’d always made it a point never to think about sex during work hours (which is generally a snap, homicide not being generally conducive to hard-ons), and also because wanting to know what was under her T-shirt made me feel ridiculous. If she were in a movie, she’d be the heroine’s good-natured
MAGIC HOUR / 57
girlfriend, a tomboy with a heart of gold. But for someone who wasn’t attractive, she was so attractive. Here I was, half hoping she’d need something on a high shelf. She’d have to stretch up her arms; her shirt would rise and I would get to see her ass. It made me feel like a louse. Since AA and especially since Lynne, I’d stopped my bad-boy crap, my automatic concentration on anything female, my reflexive coming on to almost every woman I met. “Tell me about you and Sy Spencer,” I said quickly. “How long were you married to him?” “Three years—1979 to 1982.” She poured the boiling water through the coffee filter. “You don’t take notes?” “I think I can manage to remember 1979 to ’82.” I’d forgotten to take out my pad. Suddenly it felt like a block of lead in my jacket pocket. “Amicable divorce?” “Even if it hadn’t been, do you think I’d shoot him seven years later?” “I’m open to all possibilities.” “Well, I didn’t shoot him.” Her manner was solemn, sincere, proper; if Bonnie Spencer’s mouth was from the city, the rest of her had grown up in that nice non-New York hometown, wherever it was. “Good. Now, do you want to answer my question? How was the divorce?” “Amicable.” “Fair settlement?” “I got this house.” “Just the house?” “Yup.” “Was there any litigation?” “No. Both of us were just overflowing with amicability. ‘Bonnie, please take the alimony.’ ‘No, Sy, but thanks so much for thinking of me.’” “Why no alimony? He was rich.”
58 / SUSAN ISAACS
“I know. But back then, I didn’t care about money. Oh, and I was in my wronged-woman phase: ‘Do you honestly think a monthly check will make up for the loss of a husband, Sy?’” She shook her head. “God, was I morally superior. You can imagine Sy—and his matrimonial lawyer. They must have been shouting ‘Hallelujah!’ and jumping up and down and hugging each other.” I didn’t like this. At the same time I was being vigilant, trying to figure out just what was wrong with Bonnie Spencer—because I knew there was something wrong—I was finding there was something about her I really liked. Maybe I was just intoxicated by the homey atmosphere—being at that bright-polished wood table in the fresh-smelling country kitchen, watching a woman open a cupboard and think for a second before choosing from a bunch of mugs. Maybe it was that big hairy black mop, Moose, warming my feet. I could just feel myself letting go, my brain turning to mush. Bonnie put the cow pitcher and a sugar bowl down on the table and handed me a mug of coffee. The mug said “I love”—the “love” was one of those hearts—“Seattle!” and had a cartoon of a smiley animal with funny-looking flippers. “I know it’s tacky,” she said. “It was a choice between tacky and chipped.” “You didn’t get any alimony at all?” I tipped the pitcher. The milk came out of the cow’s mouth. It was so dumb. “I never dreamed I’d need it. See, when I met Sy, I was a hot screenwriter. My movie—Cowgirl—had just opened. It got great reviews, did decent business. And during the time we were married, I wrote five more screenplays. Three of them were in development.” She sat down across from me at the table.
MAGIC HOUR / 59
“When you’re a big success right off the bat, you assume it’s going to go on forever.” “It didn’t?” She shook her head. “No. Cowgirl was my first and only movie. Nothing ever happened with any of the others. Anyhow, Sy offered to pay me alimony at least three times. But I wanted to show him I could be independent. And you know what? In the long run, it really was better this way.” “Why did the marriage break up?” She was clearly not a New Yorker, because instead of giving me a socio-psychofeminist analysis of the relationship, she clammed up. “Come on,” I urged. “I know this may seem like an invasion of your privacy, but someone’s been murdered. I need a picture of this man’s life—a complete picture.” It took her a while, but finally she opened up. “When we met, in L.A., Sy was trying to produce his first movie. I guess I was the important one—the toast of both coasts. Okay, the semi-toast. He loved coming along for the ride. He met a lot of people. You know, contacts. “I don’t want to make it sound as if he was using me. I think he truly thought I was…well, wonderful. And he was so smart and worldly that when he proposed I thought: Gee, if this man is in love with me, maybe I am wonderful. Anyway, pretty soon he made his first movie, and then his second. And let me tell you, Sy earned his success. He wasn’t just another rich guy who wanted to get into the movie business to date actresses or impress his friends in Cleveland. He was a born producer.” “What makes a born producer?” Bonnie didn’t have to think for much more than a second; she’d done her legwork on Sy a long time ago. “He has to have a good story sense; Sy had a great one. And the ability to get people excited over
60 / SUSAN ISAACS
his vision. And be a trendsetter. If everyone else was making heartwarming movies about farm families with lovable old grandpaws and alfalfa blights, Sy would make something stylized and science-fictiony because he loved the script and believed it would make a great movie.” “So he became a big producer. What happened to you?” “Nothing much. I stopped needing an unlisted number.” “You’re not saying he dropped you when you stopped being a hot screenwriter?” “Yup.” Yup? “Where are you from?” I asked. “Ogden, Utah. Is Moose bothering you?” “He’s okay.” “She. Can’t you tell? She loves men. She drops me in two seconds flat for anything in pants. She’s the town slut.” Real fast, Bonnie’s doting dog-lover smile faded. She glanced away, up at the wall clock, but she wasn’t interested in the time. I made a mental note to check on her reputation. “How did Sy drop you?” “How? Not too hard, considering how much he wanted out. He told me—very gently—he had been having an affair with someone. Some society lady, like his first wife, except this one didn’t look like she ate oats and neighed. Anyway, he told me he was in love with her and it was causing him enormous pain to be hurting me, but that he would appreciate a divorce so he could marry her.” “But he didn’t marry her.” “No, of course not. He just wanted out. He was having the affair anyway, so he used it. I guess he thought it would be easier for me if there was another woman; he knew I could accept love a lot better than him saying, ‘Hey, Bonnie, I hate taking
MAGIC HOUR / 61
you places because you’re taller than me and a has-been.” “And you weren’t angry at this kind of treatment.” “Of course I was angry! If you go back seven years, I bet you’d find twenty witnesses who heard me yelling: ‘I hope you die, you louse.’ But time passes. And the fact of the matter is, we wound up being friends.” “When was the last time you saw him?” “I’m not sure.” But she was! Damn it, I could feel it. She lifted her chin, examined a pot holder on a hook and pretended to think. “A few days ago, I think. I dropped in on the set.” “And before that?” “Let’s see…Oh, about a week before. He asked me to come over, to see his house.” “Did you stay long?” “No. He just gave me the fifty-cent tour.” “How good friends were you?” “Pretty good friends.” “Did you spend a lot of time with him?” “Not all that much.” “Did he visit you here?” “He dropped by once or twice. But we were mainly phone friends. He was my colleague, my collaborator. See, I hadn’t written any screenplays for a few years, but last winter, when I gave it another shot, I sent it right off to Sy. I mean, I hadn’t seen him since the divorce, but I knew he’d give me a fair reading. And he really liked it!” She massaged her forehead. “Oh, God almighty, I can’t believe he’s dead.” “What about the script?” “What? Oh, we were developing it together. It was a kind of female-buddy spy movie.” “What exactly does ‘developing’ mean?” “It means working on a project—the script, the
62 / SUSAN ISAACS
financing, trying to get a good director or a star involved. But Sy never moved on a project until he was satisfied with the script. And mine—it’s called A Sea Change—wasn’t quite in shape to be sent out. But he had a lot of great suggestions. I was rewriting based on his suggestions.” “And then he’d produce it?” “Yup.” “Was he paying you a lot?” “Well…he wasn’t actually paying me yet. But if I’d asked, he would have given me option money.” “Why didn’t you ask?” “I guess the same reason I didn’t want alimony. I didn’t want to seem greedy. I know, that sounds stupid. No, it is stupid. But Sy always worried that people—women—were out for what they could get from him. I didn’t want him to think that of me, either time. Anyway, I knew he’d be fair once we got rolling.” “How do you support yourself? Family money?” She laughed and looked around the kitchen. “Does this look like family money?” “You live in Bridgehampton all year round?” I was really surprised. “Sure. Oh, I see; you thought this was my sincere little summer cottage where I go to get away from my forty-room Sutton Place triplex. No, this is it. I support myself by writing. I do the ‘Happy News’ column for the South Fork Sun. I’m sure it’s the high point of your week: weddings, babies, anniversaries. ‘Penny and Randy Rollins of Amagansett’s famed Wee Tippee Inne celebrated their nineteenth anniversary with a gala extravaganza—featuring Penny’s worldfamous fish chowder!’ And I write copy for mail-order catalogs. Stuff like ‘White swirls of rayon chiffon set aglow by luminescent faux-pearl buttons.’” “You didn’t resent Sy, that you had to give up
MAGIC HOUR / 63
screenwriting, give up all that high living for something…less exciting?” “Resent? A woman tends to resent a man who says, ‘I don’t desire you anymore.’” She looked away, embarrassed. Then she went on: “But that’s on a personal level. Professionally, how could I resent him just because other people weren’t hiring me as a screenwriter? That wasn’t Sy’s fault. Eight studios and fifty thousand independent producers rejected my scripts. They said they were sweet. Sweet is movie speak for insignificant. But in all those years I never doubted that Sy wished me well.” “Did you ever talk about anything beyond this new project?” “Sure. Look, I know his friends, his family.” “Any brothers or sisters?” “No. Just Sy. Both his parents died since the divorce. But he had aunts, uncles, lots of cousins. I knew them all; we went way back. When I met him, he was still publishing his poetry magazine and trying to get his first movie produced, and his office was still in the Spiegel Crown Kosher Provisions building.” “Spiegel?” “Spiegel was his name originally: Seymour Spiegel.” She shook her head. “He changed it the summer before he went to Dartmouth. I never understood why. I mean, what did he think he would say at graduation? ‘These are my parents, Helen and Morton Spiegel. Their name used to be Spencer, but they Judaicized it.’ Or if he was going to change his name, why not go the whole route and call himself Bucky? I mean, Sy is not a quantum leap from Seymour.” Just then, Bonnie got stopped by some memory of Sy. Her eyes opened too wide, the expression people use when they’re trying not to cry. She stood up and got busy sponging off what looked like a clean stove.
64 / SUSAN ISAACS
And then it happened again: the imposition of self-control, followed by the conscious shifting of the gears of her personality. When she turned around, she was composed—but with just the appropriate degree of concern. “Do you have any ideas about who killed him?” she asked. Sincere. Saddened. Full of sympathy. Full of crap. “Do you?” “No,” she said. For a woman her age, she looked like she had a great body. I tried to figure out where I’d seen her before. Maybe running. She had the slim, muscular legs of a runner. “Think back over the last few weeks. Was Sy angry at anybody?” She leaned against the kitchen counter and smiled. “Everybody. When he was making a movie, anyone who gave him a hard time was an enemy. It was funny, because for all his charm he was aloof, and always in control. When we were married, we’d have fights where I’d yell, kick the refrigerator, and Sy would watch, like he was watching an actress doing an improvisation: Wife Losing Her Temper. “But when he was producing—God, that was another story! Goodbye charm. And forget aloof. His money and his reputation were on the line. He never yelled—that wasn’t his way—but he’d lace into people in this icy voice. It could really get scary—all that fury expressed in this absolutely cold manner. Let me tell you: he got his way.” “Was he angry at anyone the last time you talked?” “Lindsay, I guess.” “But they were living together. They were supposed to be in love.” “Well, I’ve got to tell you: the love part is debatable. But even if they had been, this is the movie business. An executive producer doesn’t love an actress who’s jeopardizing a twentymillion-dollar proj-
MAGIC HOUR / 65
ect. Sy told me the dailies were awful, which really surprised me because her success isn’t just based on blatant beauty; she’s a talented actress.” “But you think Sy got disillusioned with her?” “Sy had a gift for falling in and out of love pretty easily.” “Let’s put love aside. Was he annoyed with her? Angry?” “Furious. He said she was just coasting—not putting any thought or energy into the role because it wasn’t an ‘important film.’ That really ticked Sy off, because it was an article of faith with him that any movie that’s true, that moves audiences—even a screwball comedy—is an important film. He believed in Starry Night. And Lindsay didn’t. What made the problem even worse was that she has such a monumental ego she couldn’t see how flawed her performance was. And naturally, she wouldn’t try to fix what she’d decided wasn’t broken. Let me tell you, if he hadn’t gotten killed, he would have made her life a living hell.” “So he was ready to steamroll Lindsay?” “Yup. And the director too.” “What’s his name?” “Victor Santana.” “Why was he mad at him?” “Because Santana had gone gaga over Lindsay and couldn’t or wouldn’t get her to change.” “Anyone else?” “Oh, his usual hate list. The director of photography they’d hired—a French boy genius—was shooting too pastelly. The line producer was bellying up to NABET—the film technicians’ union—too much. Sy was angry at everyone.” “Okay, then who of the movie people was seriously angry at Sy?”
66 / SUSAN ISAACS
“I don’t know. I’m not part of the Starry Night company.” “How about Lindsay Keefe?” “My guess is if you tell a critically acclaimed actress—a movie star—that her performance is putrid and then, no matter how many little adjustments she makes, that the dailies are still awful…well, you figure it out. But even I wouldn’t believe she’d shoot him because he criticized her work.” “Who else?” “I don’t know.” I looked her straight in the eye. “He was your ex-husband. He could talk to you.” “We didn’t talk all that much.” “You talked enough. What else was on his mind?” “He never really said anything specific.” “Tell me anyway.” “Well, I just want you to know this is my interpretation of what he didn’t say.” “Go ahead.” “This is a very expensive movie for an independent production. I think maybe he was a little concerned that his backers were upset. The people who invested might have heard about trouble on the set, and they might have gotten anxious.” “Who were they?” “Specifically? Beats me. I think a couple of them may have been from his days in the kosher meat business.” She paused. “You know there are some rough people in that industry.” “Yeah, there’s mob money in it.” “From the little Sy said, though, these guys didn’t sound like out-and-out goons. More like businessmen in suits and ties, except with five-pound gold ID bracelets.” “Was that all? No one else with a grudge?”
MAGIC HOUR / 67
“I’m pretty sure,” I waited while she thought. “Nope,” she said at last. “No one else. Definitely.” I stood and faced her. She lowered her head so I was looking down at her dark, shiny hair. Her breathing became quick, shallow. I knew I was getting to her. Not just the cop: the man. “Bonnie, you’re smart, observant. Sweet too, and I mean that as a compliment.” She tried to look me in the eye—casual. But her face had flushed bright pink. “You’re not being straight. I get the feeling you’re holding back, and that concerns me.” “I’m not holding back anything.” Just for an instant her voice caught in her throat. I moved in closer. “You could help me solve a murder, Bonnie.” “I can’t. Honestly. I’ve told you everything I know.” “Listen, if things were going lousy with Sy Spencer’s movie, with Lindsay, who would he confide in? Who knows the business? Who knows him? You.” “Please. I’ve told you everything he told me.” “I’ve got to tell you: something about you doesn’t feel right. What are you hiding?” She turned her head away from me. “Come on, do you want me to start thinking maybe you were involved?” “Why would you think that?” She wasn’t exactly scared, but she wasn’t at ease either. “Open up, Bonnie.” I stepped toward her. She inched backward, until she was pressed against the sink. I moved in until we were almost touching. “Tell me what you’re not talking about. Be smart. Because if I start to think you were involved, I’ll go after you—and I won’t stop.” I had a few minutes after Bonnie, so I drove down to the beach. I hadn’t liked the way the interview had ended. A little official charm is one thing. That final
68 / SUSAN ISAACS
minute, that simultaneous coming on to her and threatening her, was another. And I hadn’t come on to her just for leverage; I’d really wanted to be close to her. I needed to clear my head. Down at the beach, a stiff wind was whipping up the sand, blowing sharp, scratchy grains against my face and neck. Summer people were scuttling around, on the verge of hysteria. Nature was behaving badly. They closed their insideout umbrellas, folded their chairs, picked up their coolers and rushed past me, back to their cars. There could be no grain of sand under gold spandex bikinis, or in eyes that had to be wide open for the next hostile takeover. I took off my shoes, squatted down by the dunes near a patch of jointweed, pretty much out of the worst of the wind, and watched until all the New York bodies had run away. Back in the late fifties, when I was a kid, people still slept on the beach, right where I was, on hot summer nights. Grownups would pitch tents, but the rest of us would lug out the blanket rolls we’d learned to make in Boy Scouts. Sometimes we’d tell scary stories about the Cropsey Maniac or whisper dirty jokes, but by eleven, we’d fall silent and just lie on our backs, staring up at the night sky. The stars were so beautiful they shut us up. I must have been about ten when I started sneaking out of the house one or two nights a week to sleep on the beach after the summer was over. I did it all year round, except for the winter months. Once the house was dark, I’d tiptoe down the steep back staircase and out the door, grab the blanket roll I kept in the toolshed behind the house, take my bike and race like hell for three quarters of a mile over the pitchblack road. I don’t know why I had to get out. Okay, even back
MAGIC HOUR / 69
then, my brother and I didn’t exactly revel in each other’s company; but our relationship was more mutual annoyance than animosity. At his worst, Easton was just a pain-in-theass prig who ironed his T-shirts. My mother? A lady. She didn’t hit me or scream at me. She just didn’t like me, and probably didn’t love me. I was the mirror image of the drunk farmer who’d fucked her over and then taken off. Just being myself—dangling my legs over the arm of the couch while I read, whistling a tuneless few notes when I was doing something mindless like washing windows—pissed her off. She’d pass by, and there’d be just a sharp expulsion of air through her nose, an irate snort. When I was younger I’d ask, “Hey, Ma, what’s wrong?” Her answer would be “nothing” in the form of a high-society chuckle—a throaty heh-heh of denial. Then she’d say, “Steve, sweetheart, please. Anything but ‘Ma.’ Did I raise a hillbilly?” My mother always made me feel like total shit. I know. She didn’t have it easy. The farm was gone, and so was my old man. There was no way near enough money to feed me and Easton, and keep us in jeans and sneakers, much less for her to lead the gracious-lady life she aspired to. So she got a job—at Saks Fifth Avenue in Southampton, selling expensive dresses to expensive women. And when she wasn’t involving herself in rich lives by zipping up their dresses or stroking their embossed names on their charge cards, she was busting her chops doing scutz work for their charity groups. My mother would do anything—set up three hundred bridge chairs in the midday sun, lick one thousand envelope flaps until past midnight—to be allowed into their swan-necked, high-cheekboned society. I don’t know where my mother got her obsession with the upper crust. Sure, her family was an old one in Sag Harbor, and to hear her you could practically
70 / SUSAN ISAACS
see portraits of bearded Eastons in the brass-buttoned uniforms of whaling boat captains. But there were no portraits; I’d biked up to the Sag Harbor Library in eighth grade and learned there was absolutely no basis for ancestor worship. Early Eastons might have gone to sea, but they’d obviously been ordinary sailors: guys with bowlegs and black stumps for teeth. Her old man, who died before I was born, had sold tickets for a ferry company that had the Sag Harbor and New London, Connecticut, route. Still, my mother was convinced, despite all hard evidence to the contrary, that she was a gentlewoman. She didn’t give a damn about the local South Fork female elite, the wives of lawyers, doctors, successful farmers, or even the moneyed Yanks—maybe because they all knew who she was, or wasn’t. No, she lived for Memorial Day, when her “friends” opened up their summer houses out here. Even when we were kids, she’d sit at the supper table and talk about her New York “friends.” Quality People. Her friends, of course, were not her friends but her customers, summer women who came to the grand old houses, “cottages” in Southampton—like the one Sy bought—for the summer. She’d go on and on about Mrs. Oliver Sackett’s hand-embroidered-in-England slips (“Divine, teeny stitches!”), or the thirty-one (“Norell! Mainbocher! Chanel!”) dresses Mrs. Quentin Dahlmaier had ordered from the main branch in New York, one for every night of the month of July. Bottom line? My mother felt fucked every single day of her life because she didn’t have a driver (“Never say ‘chauffeur’!” she warned Easton; “it’s nouveau riche”) and a maid and a sable coat. She didn’t even have a roof that didn’t leak. And I think that’s why I got out from under her roof as often as I could. Sitting over a plate of her
MAGIC HOUR / 71
spécialité de la maison, macaroni and undiluted Campbell’s Cheddar Cheese Soup (which, of course, she knew was not Quality, but which she announced was Great Fun), listening to her go on to Easton in her throaty voice—she was a heavy smoker and wound up sounding like Queen Elizabeth with laryngitis—Jesus. She’d talk about how Mrs. Gabriel Walker (“one of the Bundy sisters, from Philadelphia”) was mad for nubby linen, absolutely mad…. Her conversation was directed to Easton, never to me. But then she knew and I knew that would be a waste of time. I did not belong in that house. Like my old man, I was not Quality. “Had Mr. Spencer to the best of your knowledge received any threatening messages or phone calls?” Robby Kurz was asking Lindsay Keefe. You could tell Robby had gotten up extra early to get spiffy. He’d arranged a yellow handkerchief in the breast pocket of his brown plaid jacket into points. The smell of his double dose of hairspray overpowered the scent arising from a huge bowl of white roses on the table in front of the couch he and I were sitting on. “Of course there were no threats.” Lindsay exhaled, a sharp, pissed-off breath between pursed lips. She was trying very hard to be patient. “What do you expect? That his killer went up to him and announced: ‘You’re a dead man’? And there were no heavy-breather phone calls either.” For a woman in shock, Lindsay sounded clearheaded. In fact, completely self-possessed, not a hint of hysteria. The batshit, Valiumed, sensitive artiste her agent had described could have been some other person. Even though I’d caught a glimpse of her the night before, in the back of my mind I must have been
72 / SUSAN ISAACS
expecting a fifteen-foot-tall Goddess of Film, a gargantuan babe with enormous, glistening lips and colossal legs that could crush any man caught between them. But Lindsay, standing by the window, fingering the sheer white curtain, was of ordinary height, although so small-boned and petite (except for her world-famous tits) that she looked as if she’d been created solely to make men feel big, important. In her daintiness, she must have been a perfect match for Sy. Two exquisite pocket-size people: a separate species. But Sy had been an ordinary-looking man. Lindsay Keefe’s looks were extraordinary. No wonder she’d gone from doing Greek tragedies in little theaters in little midwestern cities to making avant-garde films in Europe to being an American movie star. Her features were beautiful. Okay, they didn’t add up to perfection, but they came damn close. (Movie stars usually have one annoying flaw—a wen, a strawberry mark that you can’t ignore, one defect that makes you wonder why they couldn’t pop a few thou for a plastic surgeon. Lindsay had a black mole on her neck, at the spot where a guy’s Adams apple is. It was a thing you’d never think about on a regular person, but I couldn’t keep my eyes off it.) Her skin was the palest possible, the kind where you can almost picture the whole blood vessel network underneath. Her hair was some miraculous white-blond, but with half silver, half gold overtones. And the eyes: pure black. She’d gotten herself up all in white. A long, filmy skirt and a plain, schoolgirl blouse. The living room was all white also, like a stage set designed solely to flatter blondes. There were a lot of what I’m sure were antiques, but solid stuff: fat couches and chairs covered in different materials—but all whites too, various shades of it, so it became a kind of color. “If you want to know the truth,” Lindsay went on,
MAGIC HOUR / 73
“nothing could scare Sy. He was a man in control, at the peak of his powers. Intellectually, emotionally, financially…” She stopped for a second. When she continued, it was with disgust, as though she’d caught us sniggering over the notion of Sy’s “powers.” She seemed exasperated with what she’d decided were our infantile, dirty cop minds. “All right, I’ll fill in the blank for you: at the peak of his powers sexually.” Forget that her words were unfair, to say nothing of blunt, brusque and bordering on the stunningly snotty; it hardly mattered. Robby and I sat motionless as she spoke. Her voice had a deep, sensual undercurrent, a hypnotic hum. You wanted to hear whatever she had to say. She could be talking about Sy’s death, or reciting erotic poetry, or reading the ingredients off a Kaopectate label. You couldn’t resist being Lindsay Keefe’s audience. You wanted to applaud everything. Because besides the Face and the Voice, there was the Body. She had positioned herself perfectly in front of the window. With the curtains open, the late-morning light behind her was so strong you could practically see what she had for breakfast. Everything was lit up: her legs, the line of her bikini underpants stretched over her flat stomach, her hand-span waist—and most of all, the fact that she wasn’t wearing a bra. Incredible: her boobs were flawless, the awesome ones that defy gravity and point north. And naturally, she stood slightly sideways, making sure the sunshine lit her up so you couldn’t avoid seeing the pokes her nipples made as they pushed against the gauzy fabric of the tightly tucked-in blouse. “Sy was a great success artistically and financially. You must know that this is not an industry where people wish each other well. But would someone
74 / SUSAN ISAACS
murder him because his last film won the Gold Palm at Cannes and grossed ninety-two million? Please.” Robby was nodding at everything Lindsay said, but it was nodding run amok. His head kept bobbing up and down, nonstop, like one of those jerky dolls with springs for necks you used to see in the backs of cars. I wasn’t nodding at all. Because, number one, although I might have been spellbound by the Voice, I still had enough brains to realize all we were getting from Lindsay were words. She was giving a brief (but wonderfully well lit) personal appearance that would satisfy two uncouth cops—without revealing anything. And, number two, my nodding reflexes weren’t working so well because I was genuinely stunned at Lindsay Keefe’s absolute indifference to us. Hey, we hadn’t dropped in to discuss delinquent parking tickets. You’d think, being an actress, she’d offer a few chest-heaving sobs, or at least sniffle. All she was doing, though, was going through the motions of an interview so she wouldn’t get marked down as uncooperative—and keeping us titillated while she was at it, only because it would have been against her nature to be in the same room with a human dick and not titillate. But she totally didn’t give a shit about what we thought about her. I’d never come across that before. Homicide is not a common circumstance in most lives and, therefore, neither are homicide detectives. I’d always gotten some reaction: respect, hostility, obsequiousness, guardedness, guile, cooperation. Forget personal qualities: to anyone remotely connected to a murder, Robby and I were figures of authority, symbols of the Law. But not to Lindsay. To her, we were clowns in cheap sports jackets. She lifted her hair out from under her collar, letting
MAGIC HOUR / 75
it fall over her shoulders. “Is there anything else you want from me?” Lindsay demanded. Robby tried to be cool. He didn’t get anywhere. He started giving off a sour wet-wool smell; he was in a sweat of nerves and desire. “Did Mr. Spencer ever mention anyone from his past who might not wish him well?” he asked. Lindsay took a slow, deep breath, presumably to show us how she was trying to retain her composure so she could continue the ordeal of questioning. “Miss Keefe?” To be fair, Robby’s voice didn’t quite squeak, but it wouldn’t have won any prizes for resonance. She left her position near the window and came and sat on a chair opposite us, her legs curled under her, her hands clasped in ladylike fashion in her lap. “Look, I’ve given you all the help I can,” Lindsay said. “I don’t know anything more.” That voice! It was one of those voices you read about in old detective stories, which girls with names like Velma have: rich, luscious, like warm cream. Except the funny thing was, for all her cream and translucent skin and superior tits and blond hair and black mystery eyes, Lindsay Keefe wasn’t knocking my socks off. Sure, if your taste ran to devastating blondes she wasn’t bad. But on or off the job, I was never the kind of guy who gets off on contempt. Okay (to be fair), maybe this was Lindsay’s tough act, to hide some vulnerability—or some real or imagined indiscretion she was afraid was incriminating. Or (not to be fair) maybe Lindsay was just an insolent, contemptuous, cold, emotionally defective twat. “Well?” she asked. “Any more questions?” Robby wasn’t completely star-struck, but he seemed to have forgotten, momentarily, that he was the killer interrogator of the Suffolk County P.D. Homicide Squad and the beloved husband of Freck-
76 / SUSAN ISAACS
led Cleavage. He gulped. “I think that about covers it for now,” he said. “Fine,” she said, and stood. Robby stood too, although not without banging his shin on the white marble coffee table. I stayed on the couch. “Did Mr. Spencer ever mention seeing any of his colleagues from his days in the kosher meat business?” Lindsay eyed me a little curiously. I hadn’t said anything beyond a “Hello” and an “I’m sorry”; until now, I’d been letting Robby do the questioning. “Why don’t you sit down just for one more minute, Ms. Keefe.” She sat, and then Robby did too. “The meat business,” I prompted. “No,” she answered. “I’m almost positive he didn’t see any of them. For him, that was another life. But let me say this, Detective…I forgot your name.” “Steve Brady. Did any people he knew from the meat business invest in this movie, Ms. Keefe?” “Yes. One or two.” “Do you know their names?” “Just one. Mikey. Michael, I suppose.” “Any last name?” “I don’t know it.” “Did you ever hear of Mr. Spencer meeting with this Mikey?” She shook her head. “Having a phone conversation with him?” “Sy made most of his calls from his study.” “Right, but did you ever happen to be passing by and hear any call to this Mikey?” “Actually, once. And I was passing by—not eaves-dropping. Don’t condescend to me.” “Okay. What did you happen to hear, passing by?” “Sy was reassuring this man that everything was going well.” “Was Mikey worried that it wasn’t going well?” “No, of course not. It was one of those soothing,
MAGIC HOUR / 77
stroking, you’re-so-important phone calls. Sy was a master of those.” “No problems with Starry Night?” I asked. She shook her head, allowing a curl of her long platinum hair to fall in front of her shoulder. She started twirling it around her index finger; I assume my eyes were supposed to follow the little circles until I was mesmerized. But I couldn’t stop watching the mole on her neck; it was so black it looked like an undeveloped third eye. “Mr. Spencer was pleased with how it was going?” I asked. “Yes.” “No problems with the director? Any of the actors?” “Nothing that wasn’t routine.” “He was happy with your performance?” “Of course.” Emphatic. Clipped. “Why do you ask?” “Just trying to get the lay of the land,” I said. “Let’s be straight with each other, Detective Brady. I don’t know what you’ve heard, but there’s always on-set gossip about the star of a film. Sometimes it’s more than petty nastiness. I’m sure there are people saying terrible things, like that I’m a tough bitch. That’s because I’m serious—passionately serious—about my work. Or that my performance is somehow lacking. Or that my relationship with Sy was…well, one of mutual convenience. The truth is, yes, I am tough. But I also happen to be a vulnerable human being.” “I’m sure you are.” “And I loved Sy very, very much.” “I understand.” “I hope you also understand that Sy loved my work.” She bowed her head for an instant, a second of silence. Then she looked me right in the eye. “And he loved me.”
78 / SUSAN ISAACS
“I don’t doubt that for a minute,” I said, and thought about the long, dark hairs that had gotten caught on the headboard in the guest room. “We were going to be married.” I asked: “What do you know about his ex-wives?” “I haven’t met either of them.” “Did he ever talk about them?” “Not very much. The first was named Felice. He married her right after college. She was getting her Ph.D. at Columbia. Supposedly very brilliant. Came from a distinguished family. A great deal of money.” “What happened?” “Truthfully?” “Please.” “Bor-ing.” “Did he have any contact with her recently?” “No. I’m almost positive. They were divorced in the late sixties. She’s remarried.” “What about his second wife?” I asked. “Bonnie. From out West someplace.” “Do you know anything about that marriage?” Robby asked. “A mismatch.” Lindsay placed the fingers of one hand in the palm of the other; they needed a rest, or else she was examining her nails. “She’s a writer. Well, she had one movie produced, and that’s when Sy met her. I think he was enamored of what he thought was a lively, unpretentious intelligence. All zip, and hero-worshiping quotes from Joseph Mankiewicz’s screenplays. That appealed to him—for five minutes.” “And then?” I asked. “The truth? She had one movie in her. She was yesterday’s news by the time they were married.” “Do you know if he saw her at all?” Robby asked. “No. Of course not. But she lives around here. When they split, she got their old summer place. Ac-
MAGIC HOUR / 79
tually, though, Sy did hear from her a few months ago. She sent him some new script she’d written.” I asked: “Was he going to produce it?” “God, no.” I found myself swallowing hard. “He told her no?” “Of course. He told me he had to. Kindly, probably generously. But I’m sure very, very firmly. Oh, but wait a second. That’s right. I’d forgotten. She came onto the set in East Hampton, pursuing him. I didn’t see her, but she went and knocked on the door of his trailer. It was awful. But he said he told her in no uncertain terms: ‘Goodbye. Stay off the set of my film. And keep your screenplays to yourself.’ That may sound harsh, but he had no choice. This business is a magnet for all sorts of unstable people.” “He knew her, though,” I said. “She was his ex-wife. Did he think she was unstable?” “No. As far as I know, he just thought she was a loser. But if Sy had given her the least bit of encouragement, she’d have been all over him: Love my screenplay. Love me. Do for me. Make me rich, famous. Make me a star. People like her are desperate. Sy had to get rid of her.”
CHAPTER FOUR
The Homicide team meeting turned out to be six cops sitting around a blackboard shrugging shoulders. Robby hadn’t been able to interview Easton because he’d been tracking down the kosher-meat guy, Mikey, who turned out to be Fat Mikey LoTriglio—a real sweetheart. Like the SpiegelSpencers, Mikey’s family had owned a major meat-processing plant, but he also had ties to another family—the Gambinos. He had a dandy record of arrests for extortion and aggravated assault—our kind of guy—but he’d never been convicted of anything. Ray Carbone announced that all he’d been able to do, because he’d been busy calming down the higher-ups and helping write a press release, was find out that Sy’s first wife’s name was Felice Vanderventer and she lived on Park Avenue. Our man at the autopsy, Hugo Schultz, the Sour Kraut, reported that not counting his death, Sy had been in great shape. No diseases. No traces of alcohol or drugs. His last meal seemed to have been bread and salad. There was evidence of recent ejaculation, probably post-salad. Oh, he’d been killed by the first
80
MAGIC HOUR / 81
bullet, which had gone through his head; the one that had gone through his heart was unnecessary: Target practice, Hugo said. The other two guys listened and drank coffee. I briefed everyone on Bonnie’s story on her screenplay versus the opposing Lindsay version—and how there was something not right about Bonnie, something that bothered me. Oh, and that Lindsay’s claim of giving a stellar performance was countered by both Bonnie and Gregory J. and how I thought Starry Night, the twenty million dollars it was costing and, possibly, Lindsay’s reputation might be headed for the crapper. In other words, what I got from the meeting was not much. It was then that I thought about my movie man. Jeremy. Germy. Jeremy Cottman, the most famous movie critic on TV, was my one rich and famous friend. Okay, so it wasn’t exactly a big-ass buddy friendship. In fact, it had been over twenty years since I’d laid eyes on him. Jeremy had been a Bridgehampton summer kid, the son of rich but not famous parents. His father had been a stockbroker whose only customer seems to have been himself. Mr. Cottman played perpetual golf; his skin had the texture of a grilled cheese sandwich. Mrs. Cottman, who called everyone “cutie-pie,” had spent whole summers in a sunbonnet that tied under her chin, clutching a pair of clippers, pruning anything that didn’t run away. Their house, a rambling white wood Victorian, overlooked Mecox Bay. Rich kids like Jeremy played all summer: swimming in each other’s pools, going to parties at each other’s beach clubs, taking riding lessons in those puff-thigh pants. Kids like me worked. I started out scraping
82 / SUSAN ISAACS
duck shit and sorting potatoes for the farmer who had bought our land. When I was twelve, I graduated to cleaning swimming pools, and later to caddying at one of the local golf clubs. But in spite of work, summer had always been an enchanted time. It didn’t get dark until late, so we’d grab a bite of supper and rush down to the ball field. We were in the four thousandth inning of a baseball game that had been going on since the summer after third grade: shirts and skins, our shirts getting progressively scruffier as the fifties gave way to the sixties, our skins darkening from the white, stickout-ribbed chests of nine-year-olds to the broad, tanned, hairy torsos of high school seniors. It was a strictly Bridgehampton game. Every once in a while, a summer kid would ride past—on an English racing bike. After a few nights of bypasses, he’d brake, knock down his kickstand and get really busy inspecting a tire. Usually we’d ignore him, as in: This is one club you can’t join, fuckface. But if he looked like a terrific jock, we’d be a little less exclusive. Sure, the kid would have to have the balls to grunt the opening “hi.” But then, if he wasn’t too welldressed, we might ask him if he wanted to hit a few. Jeremy (I was the one who started calling him Germy) made our team. He was an incredible power hitter, a so-so outfielder, and a cruel and funny mimic. He’d pick some movie star or a baseball player and have them say terrible things about one of the kids, so it was like being dumped on by Marilyn Monroe or Carl Yastrzemski (the greatest human being Bridgehampton had ever produced, even though he’d played for Boston). I’d never met anyone like Germy Cottman. To be able to hit those line drives. To have discovered a way to say whatever was on his mind. God, how good
MAGIC HOUR / 83
that must feel! We became great summer friends, eventually trusting each other enough to share our most intimate sports fantasies. We were the best of buddies from about the time we were twelve until we went off to college. Germy went to Brown. I went to Albany State. I looked for him that summer after freshman year, but his mother, clipping roses that were doing something to annoy her, said, Sorry, cutie-pie, Jeremy is in Bologna, learning Italian. I saw him around once or twice after that, but we didn’t have much to say; by then, he was an intellectual, I was a druggie, and neither of us was playing ball anymore. But every now and then Germy’s name came up around town. I heard he was in graduate school in Chicago for something; he was working on a newspaper in Atlanta; he was working on a newspaper in Los Angeles; he was writing long movie reviews—film criticism, I suppose—for some high-minded magazine. And then one night on TV: the Germ! I remember lying on my couch, pretty drunk but not totally gone, slugging down a beer, thumbing the remote control. There he was, swiveling back and forth in a big leather chair, legs crossed, telling us folks at home—in his familiar, clothespin-on-thenose prep school nasality—why Out of Africa was such an overrated movie; then he did a brief, mean, but exceedingly accurate, imitation of Meryl Streep. Germy was on the map. A celeb. And over the next couple of years, his show actually got better. He wasn’t only negative. Sure, there were still his killer reviews and his snide imitations, but he stopped showing off his intellectual superiority and started displaying his real intelligence. He’d run a film clip in slow motion and explain exactly about how a certain shot was done, or describe precisely why So-and-so
84 / SUSAN ISAACS
was a good editor, or a bad production designer. He knew the players too; he’d report how some internal fight at a studio affected a particular movie. All America watched Germy: seven-thirty, Friday nights. And read about him too, in People, Time, Newsweek. I read he’d married the daughter of a famous 1940s director; that he had a house on a cliff overlooking the Pacific; that he’d moved back to New York; that he’d divorced his wife after fifteen years and married some very famous Broadway lighting designer—not that I’d ever heard of her. Around town there was talk that his father had had a heart attack on the eighteenth hole and had died before they could get him back to the clubhouse and that his mother had died too, and Germy had inherited the house. But although I kept up with what he was doing, I hadn’t spent any time with him since I’d played shortstop and he’d played outfield. I felt a little nervous about calling him, but then I thought: I’ve got to give it a shot. It being a glorious, sunny Saturday afternoon, Germy could actually be a couple of miles away. He might be spending the day practicing a cruel Clint Eastwood imitation or banging the lighting designer or (I smiled to myself as I pulled into his driveway) sitting cross-legged on his bed the way he used to, working neat’s-foot oil into his mitt. A minute later, there he was at his front door, his hands braced against the frame, as if he were defending his house from some intruder who might push him aside and ransack his living room, or demand to know what Chevy Chase was really like. “Yes?” Chilly, about to cross the border into absolute iciness. “You don’t recognize me, Germy?” Then he did the Oh-my-God! I-don’t-believe-it! bit, followed by our mutual finger-squishing handshake.
MAGIC HOUR / 85
It was for real. We were both pretty touched at seeing each other, although not comfortable enough to follow our natural inclination, which was to give each other one of those acceptable, non-homo, World Series hugs. “Steve! Come in!” I followed him through the front hall, toward the living room. It was like stepping back into 1959: the blue-and-white umbrella stand filled with tennis rackets, the dark, scratchedup old mirror in a carved wood frame. “I can’t believe it,” I said. “It looks exactly the same. Any minute your little sister’s going to come running in and spit at me.” “That’s right!” Germy said in his slow honk. “I’d forgotten. She spent a whole summer spitting at you. She was madly in love.” The Cottman house still had the we’ve-been-rich-forever shabbiness it had when we were kids: faded flower print cushions, threadbare rugs with flowers that skidded across wood floors, old wicker chairs. Out on the back terrace, there were flowers blooming in his mother’s mossy clay pots, and the old, white-painted wrought-iron chairs, chipped in the same places. Like the house, Germy hadn’t changed much. He was tall, about my height, but he hadn’t outgrown his round-chinned baby face, with its button nose and wide-open eyes. Sure, his forehead was a little lined, his brown hair had a little gray, but in his horn-rimmed glasses and white tennis sweater, he looked more like a tall kid in a daddy costume than a full-fledged adult. He made a take-a-seat gesture. “Can I get you anything? A cup of coffee?” Then he remembered. “A beer?” I shook my head. “Steve! God! Tell me about yourself. Where are you living? What do you do?” Germy had much too much class to ask: What do you want? although it must have been in the back of
86 / SUSAN ISAACS
his mind that maybe I was there for a handout, or with some obnoxious request: Can you get me an autographed picture of Goldie Hawn? “I’m here, in Bridgehampton, north of Scuttle Hole—” “Married, single, div—” He interrupted both me and himself with his own enthusiasm. “I got married again last year!” He paused as if to give me time to prepare myself for something wonderful. “To Faith Armstead!” I nodded respectfully, as in: Oh, of course, I’m always dazzled by Faith Armstead’s lighting. “Congratulations.” “She’s stuck in a theater all day today. Can you believe it?” His second marriage was working; I could hear the pleasure as Germy pronounced his wife’s name. And he seemed proud, almost awed by her dedication; she could have been the first wife since the dawn of history to work on a Saturday. “Now, what about you?” he demanded. “I never got married. I was pretty screwed up when I got back from Vietnam.” “Vietnam,” Germy echoed. “And then I got used to being single, being free. But I finally met a great girl. We’re getting married Thanksgiving weekend.” “You were in Vietnam,” he said softly. The new quietlymoved reaction. After all those years of being Asian-baby butchers, we had somehow turned into national treasures. “Did you see action?” “No, you jerk-off. They needed a shortstop on the Saigon intermural team, so I spent the whole war on the ball field. Listen, I really want to catch up, but I’m actually here on business….” I saw his face fall a little, his round kid-cheeks flatten. “Eat it, Je-re-my. You think I’m going to give you a life insurance pitch?”
MAGIC HOUR / 87
“Well…” His embarrassment evaporated. “No.” He became his real self, his caustic TV self. “You look more like redwood decks, actually.” “I’m a detective with Suffolk County Homicide.” “You?” “Yeah. Never thought I’d wind up on this side of the law, did you?” “Homicide!” he said. “Steve, that’s exciting. Glamorous!” “Yeah, well, the violence is fantastic, and I’ve always been crazy about decomposition.” “Seriously, do you like what you do?” “It stimulates my intellectual processes.” “I said seriously.” “Yeah, I like it. A lot. Now, do you know why I’m here?” It took him less than a tenth of a second. “Sy Spencer.” “I need background, foreground, whatever you’ve got. Did you know him?” He turned his chair so he was facing me; his back was to the bay. “Slightly.” “You didn’t hang out with him?” “No. He ran on that middle-aged fast track: a little old money, a lot of new money, and writers, restaurant owners, fashion designers. All those emaciated, face-lifted women and their beefy men.” “Sy wasn’t beefy. Five six, a hundred thirty-two pounds.” “He was an exception.” Germy hesitated: “Oh. You know how much he weighed from…?” “Yeah. The autopsy. Listen, the guy was in fantastic shape. I should have his liver. If he hadn’t backed up into those bullets, he’d have lived till a hundred. The thing is, Germy, I know more than I want to about all his organs. But I want to know about him. So I need
88 / SUSAN ISAACS
you. Even if you weren’t his best friend, you must know about him, about what he was doing.” “Of course.” “Okay, what do you know about Starry Night?” “Gossip or substance?” “Both. Substance first; get it over with.” Germy took off his glasses and gave the earpiece a thoughtful chew. “All right. I actually read an early draft of the script. It’s an action-adventure-love story about a charming heel who marries a very rich woman for her money. Superficially she’s the frosty, sophisticated sort—a ‘Hamptons’ type, if you’ll forgive me. She’s overwhelmed by the heel’s magnetism and sexuality. Well, to make a convoluted story short, his past—dealing a little cocaine—catches up with him, and some Colombian types kidnap his wife for reasons the script does not adequately make clear. The heel doesn’t care at first. Then slowly he realizes he has fallen madly in love with the wife, and she…she’s tied up in a basement in…I’m a little foggy here, but I think in Bogotá. Maybe Brooklyn. In any case, it dawns on her that he’s more than a charming stud; he’s the first true love of her life. He goes after her, she escapes, there’s a gratuitous car chase, the bad guys seem about to win. But in the end they live happily ever after.” I sat still for a minute, staring out at the shimmering golden reflection of the sun in the bay. “Would a guy like me shell out six bucks to see it?” “Hard to say, Steve. It’s a film about breaking through your shell, discovering your humanity. The script has some of the best dialogue I’ve read in years. Genuinely witty. And some fine straight moments, before the kidnapping, when each starts to reveal himself to the other and then pulls back, as if they realize they’re violating some unwritten Law of Superficiality of jet-set marriages. But it certainly
MAGIC HOUR / 89
doesn’t cover any new ground. And as far as I can recall, the plot is pedestrian. But the characters are unusually well drawn for a postliterate script.” He slid his glasses back on. “In case you don’t know it, we are living in what is, essentially, a postliterate era.” “Oh, I do know it. It’s a tragedy I’ve got to live with every day of my life.” “I knew you’d feel that way.” We sat in comfortable silence for a minute. When you know someone since you’ve been kids, you have a kind of ESP. I could sense Germy, like me, relaxing, lifting up his face to feel the sun, and wanting—really, desperately wanting—to talk about all the amazing things that had happened to the Yankees since Steinbrenner. But I had a your-guess-is-as-good-as-mine homicide hanging over my head, so I made myself stick to the subject. “It sounds like maybe you have a qualm about the Starry Night script.” “Well, it could make an exciting, stylish film. But it’s all in the execution. Will the actors be credible? Will you believe in the possibility of a great love between Lindsay Keefe and Nicholas Monteleone? His appeal has always been more emotional than sexual. He’s essentially a man’s man; all his best movies have been about relationships between men—rodeo riders, Amazon explorers…” He grinned. “Homicide cops. But the question about whether the movie will work goes beyond the two principals: Will the Colombians be offensively stereotypical Latino greasers or genuinely terrifying? How good a job will the director do on the action sequences? Will the big chase scene come off? Also, the real problem—the reason Sy didn’t get studio financing—is that it was felt there is a limited audience for this type of vehicle: Cary Grant cum balls. It probably won’t play to the
90 / SUSAN ISAACS
under-twenty-fives. It’s not moving enough to be another The Way We Were. And it’s not a sizzler; even if Lindsay does bare her breasts once again, or decides it’s time for a change and moons the camera, it won’t help. First of all, audiences have seen her body too many times; there’s a strong inclination to say: ‘Please, madam, keep your shirt on.’ In the script, the compelling sex is verbal, lighthearted man-woman word play, not sex play.” He leaned back and clasped his hands behind his head. “Is that substantive enough?” “Yeah. Now what about money? I’ve heard twenty big ones. Where does that kind of dough come from?” “Private investors. Or banks who had faith in Sy’s track record.” “If you were a bank, what kind of faith would you have?” Germy unclasped his hands, then crossed his arms over his chest. “I’d invest—although not twenty million. That seems awfully high for a film that will be shot primarily out here and in Manhattan, even with all the lavish set decoration and costumes and an anxious director who’s known for a lot of retakes. But forgetting dollars and cents, Sy’s films were really good. Bankable. He believed in starting with a polished script. He’d go for the gifted actor over the big name. I always admired his movies.” “Just admired? You ever love any of them?” He took a minute to consider the question. “No. I can’t really explain it, but there was something a little smug about every picture he produced. Each one seemed to be saying: ‘Aren’t I sensitive? Provocative? Don’t I have superb production values?’ There was always intelligence and care, but never any real spirit. I suppose his films were like Sy himself.”
MAGIC HOUR / 91
“From the little you knew him, what did he seem like?” “Intelligent. Polished but not slick. And for the movie business, where hugging and kissing and screaming ‘Dahlink, you’re a very great genius’ is an institutional requirement, he was notable because he was so restrained. A gentleman.” Germy stopped short. “What are you thinking about? Even if it seems totally irrelevant.” “Well, Sy wasn’t definable. He struck me as something of a chameleon. Man-about-town with men-about-town. Lover boy with women. Tough negotiator with the unions—a real dirty street fighter. And full of Jewish show-biz warmth with a couple of the old-time reporters, dropping Yiddish all over the place. The few times he and I talked, he was very professorial—as if the only thing he lived for were discussions of Fritz Lang’s deterministic universe. It made me laugh because I knew he had to have gotten me confused with another critic: I never gave a flying fuck about Fritz Lang.” “Which one of his personalities came closest to being the real Sy Spencer?” “I haven’t the foggiest.” “What do you think drove him, Germy? Money? Sex? Power?” “Well, he certainly seemed to have enjoyed all of those. But he didn’t seem driven, even though he must have been. He could be pleasant—even charming. But some integral part of his circuitry—the part that reaches out and makes human connections—seemed…disconnected.” “What do you know about his ex-wife Bonnie Spencer?” Germy shook his head: never heard of her. “She wrote the screenplay for a movie called Cowgirl.”
92 / SUSAN ISAACS
“I remember that one. It was a nice movie.” “What was it about?” “A widow of a small-time rancher literally puts on her husband’s boots. It deals with her relationships with the ranch hands, the neighboring wives. Some moving dialogue about her passion for the land. Beautifully photographed.” “A major motion picture?” “No. But a really decent minor one.” He took off his glasses again and did some more gnawing. “Her name wasn’t Spencer when she wrote it. Something else.” “Sy married her after it came out. But then none of her other screenplays ever got made.” I had this vivid image of Bonnie in her bicycle shorts and too-big T-shirt leaning against the sink in her kitchen. It was not an image of a person who could in any way be in the movie business. “Ever hear anything about her?” “No,” he said. “It sounds like he cut her loose when he realized she wasn’t the hot property he thought she was.” “That sounds fairly typical. Of the industry and of Sy.” “What about Lindsay Keefe? I’ve been hearing her acting wasn’t very good this time around.” “Well, now we move on to gossip. I’ve heard the same thing, and I don’t doubt it. She’s a very cerebral actress. Her characters tend to be focused women, intelligent, passionately devoted to whatever they’re doing, sometimes capable of deep emotion: abused women who write poetry, missionaries who join obscure revolutionary movements. That sort of thing. The character in Starry Night, though…she’s different. Soft, endearing, the poor little rich girl. My guess is, Lindsay may be enough of an actress to project endearingness. But she’s mostly head, no heart. The role would be one hell of a stretch.”
MAGIC HOUR / 93
“Will they stop making the movie now that Sy’s dead?” “Are you joking? Making movies is a business. For an actor, a director, they’d have to stop for a few days until they could get a replacement. For an executive producer…they won’t even stop for a cup of coffee.” “Did you hear anything else about what was happening on the set?” “The usual malicious innuendos.” “Good. What are they?” “That Sy was dissatisfied, and he and Lindsay may have actually fought over her performance. Or, even if there was no confrontation, she sensed she was in trouble with him. In either case, she took a deep breath…and pointed her major artillery at the director, Victor Santana. Made him an ally.” “How did she get him on her side?” “Her side? Her side was the least of it.” “No shit! Lindsay was making it with Santana?” “Steve, when the executive producer leaves the set for the day and the director and the leading lady then proceed to hold a script conference in the director’s trailer for forty-five minutes with the blinds drawn and they don’t ask a production assistant for coffee and the trailer is observed rocking back and forth, what do you think?” “Fuck City.” The real question was, what did Sy think? What did he know? And what had he been planning to do about Lindsay Keefe? We sat in his kitchen eating ice cream out of pint containers, the way we used to. Halfway through, we switched; I got Germy’s cookies ’n’ cream and he got my coffee Heath bar crunch. Neither of those flavors had been invented when we were kids.
94 / SUSAN ISAACS
He told me how his mother’s cancer had metastasized and how excruciating her pain had been and how she’d finally ended it by OD’ing on the Seconal she’d accumulated over a month. I told him I always thought she’d go on forever with that funny old bonnet and the pruning shears and how truly sorry I was she wasn’t around anymore to call me cutiepie. He put down his spoon. “Steve, when we were kids, I never had the courage to ask you…Your father just walked? Your mother supported the family?” “Yeah. After he sold the farm, he had a few different jobs, but he’d always get canned for coming to work drunk. I’m not talking a little slurring; I’m talking pissed out of his mind. When you’re working over at Agway, it isn’t a plus to puke all over the biggest farmer in Bridgehampton. Anyway, he took a hike when I was eight.” “You never heard from him again?” “No. For all I know, he could still be alive somewhere, although I wouldn’t make book on it.” My father was a lazy, disgusting, dirty drunk. He was also, in rare, semi-sober moments, a sweet man, talking sports to me, buying a buck’s worth of bubble gum so I could have the baseball cards. And he’d sit beside Easton as he built his model ships and say “Good work,” although he couldn’t help, because his hands shook with perpetual D.T.s. And once in a while he’d come up to my mother and say, “‘Ah, love, let us be true to one another,’” or “‘Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day?’”—and for that second, you could see there had once been something between them. “You never let me come into your house,” Germy said quietly, as we walked back onto the terrace. “You always had an excuse. The painters. Your mother was expecting company.”
MAGIC HOUR / 95
“We didn’t have any money. I couldn’t have even offered you a soda. And the place was falling apart. You lived here, in all this richness, and this was just your summer house.” We fell silent for a minute because, although we had often discussed Roger Maris’s troubles, we had never spoken about our own; we had no idea where to take the conversation next. I got up, walked to the edge of the terrace and, for a minute, watched the brilliant red-and-white sail of a Windsurfer skim across Mecox Bay. I turned back to Germy. “Remember your Sunfish? You got it for your sixteenth birthday.” He nodded. “You let me sail it, and I took it out so far I was sure I was going to die or get in deep shit with the coast guard. I remember I was more afraid of the coast guard than of death.” “That was when you were starting to get pretty wild. I remember the next summer, before college. You were drinking too much, even for a rebellious kid. I started…not to feel comfortable with you.” “I know.” “You were bragging about breaking into houses over the winter, trashing them—for fun.” He looked straight at me. “Were you just bullshitting?” “No. And it wasn’t just a little vandalism. I’d gone bad, Germ. I was stealing. Color TVs, stereos. Sold most of the stuff to a fence over in Central Islip. I pissed the money away. Booze. Records. A leather jacket. Except one time I went to Yankee Stadium. Got a terrific seat, right near first. This was going to be my perfect day. But we lost. A shitty game.” “When was that?” “July of ’66.” “A shitty year,” Germy recalled. “We finished last.” “I remember. The first of many shitty years. For me. The Yankees got better. I didn’t. Not for a long time.” I separated my thumb and index finger by
96 / SUSAN ISAACS
maybe an eighth of an inch. “This much,” I explained. “I missed being dead or in the slammer by this much.” “That must be scary.” “Yeah, it was.” I thought for a second. “Still is.”
CHAPTER FIVE
By the time I finished with Germy, it was after three o’clock. And it was a Saturday afternoon and the set of Starry Night was closed down. So I had the movie people come to me in our temporary headquarters in the Southampton Village P.D. I’d gotten use of the Xerox/coffee machine room for interviews—with the understanding that I could be interrupted in the event of a catastrophic copying crisis. The room was no more or less ugly than any other small, windowless, fluorescent-lighted, metal-and-green-leatherettechaired government-bureaucracy utility room. Its stale air was perfumed with prehistoric coffee grounds and the fumes of copier fluid, its floor decorated with the pink and white and blue confetti of torn-off ends of Sweet ’n Lows, Equals and sugar packets, as well as with a dusting of white powder that was not a controlled substance but nondairy coffee lightener. It was no different from any other room where cops work: a place that was habitable yet degrading to the human spirit at the same time. Victor Santana, the short-haired, thickly mustached, spiffy dude of a director who sat across from
97
98 / SUSAN ISAACS
me, was willing himself to rise above his surroundings. He was doing a damn good job. He did not seem to belong in the room. In fact, he did not seem to belong anywhere except in a three-star restaurant, a four-star movie or a five-star hotel. The guy was one suave package: a white shirt with a dark red tie, pale-gray slacks and a charcoal sports jacket made of some priceless fabric so exclusive a guy like me would never have heard of it. Santana’s name was Hispanic, and he was a pretty intense beige, but his accent wasn’t Spanish. He sounded as if he was trying to have been educated at Oxford. It didn’t quite work; his diction, like his sideburns, was a little too clipped. My guess was he wouldn’t deny his heritage, but neither would he cry “Caramba!” to an offer to be grand marshal of the Puerto Rican Day parade. He came off as urbane, the sort of guy James Bond would banter with at a chemin de fer table, whatever the hell chemin de fer is. But despite his civil smiles and even his I’m-so-accommodating dark-eyed glints, I knew I was getting nowhere fast. He seemed to be spouting the same essential script as Lindsay: Starry Night was great; Lindsay was a great actress; Sy Spencer had been a great producer. “Making a film,” he was explaining, veddy Britishly, each consonant a pearl, “is a collaborative process. I cannot tell you what a joy it was—artistically and personally—to work with Sy and Lindsay.” So I said: “Mr. Santana, please cut the shit. We know for a fact that you and Lindsay Keefe were having an affair.” His torso twitched, as if I had, for an instant, electrified his chair. “That is absolutely untrue!” he declared. He pronounced the word “ab-so-lyutely.” “We have witnesses.” Of course, all we had was a secondhand report of a rocking trailer. But it was
MAGIC HOUR / 99
worth a shot. “Witnesses who can testify to you and Ms. Keefe—in your trailer.” Suddenly he appeared to be studying the veins in his hand. After a second, though, I realized he wasn’t into veins; he was communing with his wedding ring. Santana was in his mid-thirties and had had a couple of successes. Maybe he was calculating how much each lurch of the trailer would cost him if his marriage blew up. Had Lindsay been worth a hundred thou per hump? Or maybe he just felt guilty. “Why not tell me about it?” “All right,” he sighed. Total mush: here was this cosmopolitan guy who didn’t have the presence of mind to ask who the witnesses were and what they had witnessed. It was going to be a cinch, because Santana was dying to Tell All. He settled his perfectly tailored ass back in the chair but leaned the rest of himself forward. “We were having an affair,” he confided, real whispery, as if to say: Swear to God you won’t tell. “Please understand, this is no superficial run-of-the-play liaison. It is…well, it is a love affair. I wouldn’t want you to think…” “No problem, Mr. Santana. Listen, normally, what you do is your own business. Two people working together can fall for each other. Happens all the time. It’s just that in this case, the lady’s boyfriend, fiancé, whatever, was shot through the head and heart. So I have to ask a few questions.” “Maybe…Do you think I should speak to an attorney?” “You can speak to whoever you want. Hire a whole law firm. You’re a sophisticated man. You know what your rights are. But why? You’re not guilty of anything, are you?” “Of course not.” “So just answer a couple of questions. Now, to make my life easier. Or later, if you want, with your
100 / SUSAN ISAACS
lawyer.” I really wasn’t trying to trip him up. I just didn’t feel like hanging around until the middle of the following week when some dork in a dark-blue three-piece pinstripe could manage to get here from Manhattan, hook his thumbs onto his vest pockets and give me a harangue on prosecutorial discretion. “Did Sy know about you and Lindsay?” “No. Of course not.” “How do you know?” “I asked. I was a bit nervous, but she said she was certain.” “Everything seemed lovey-dovey between them?” “I’m quite certain he thought so.” “Which means what?” “Which means he didn’t know how Lindsay felt about me—and I about her.” You know those hearts-and-flowers stories you read where the hero’s eyes shine? Well, Victor Santana’s eyes started to shine. He glowed with the glory of love. You wouldn’t think a grown-up guy with such an expensive sports jacket could be such a sap, but he was. “Was Sy happy with her acting?” This clearly was not Santana’s favorite question. His glow dimmed. He sat up straight, tense. He tried to calm himself by stroking his tie; it had lots of little shield designs that I guess were supposed to be club insignias, or family crests. “Hey, Mr. Santana, I’ve been talking to a lot of people. I have an idea of what’s going on, so do us both a favor. Don’t get creative. Was Sy happy with what Lindsay was doing?” “He was not thrilled.” “Objectively, how was she?” “She was wonderful. I mean that sincerely.” He stopped whacking off his tie; he started rotating his wedding ring. “So Sy Spencer was wrong?” “Yes. Completely.”
MAGIC HOUR / 101
“Why would a smart producer like him think an actress—someone who he’s also supposed to be in love with—is crapping up his movie? Especially if she’s not?” “Sy wanted total control over every aspect of Lindsay’s life. When she started showing the smallest signs of independence, he began to undermine her—so she would be more dependent on him.” Santana’s script was a little different from Lindsay’s, but it was pretty clear from his mechanical delivery who had written his lines. “Sy was terrified of losing her. So he played on her vulnerability. Superficially, Lindsay seems strong. But she’s a very vulnerable woman.” “What did Sy say to you about her acting?” “He indicated that he felt Lindsay was cold.” Santana shook his head as if unable to comprehend such insensitivity—except the gesture was way overdone, like an actor in a silent film. “What did he want you to do?” “He told me to warm her up.” “Did you try to warm her up in the acting area?” “No. Truly, it wasn’t necessary. She was giving a smashing performance.” Come on, I wanted to say. Get real, Santana. Your old man was probably a building superintendent, and here you are saying “troooly” and “smahshing.” “The warmth was there,” he was explaining. “Not in words. But in a million tiny gestures. The camera really doesn’t lie, you know.” “You saw this warmth in the dailies they show?” “Definitely.” “Who else saw it? Besides you and Lindsay?” In his silence, I could feel Santana’s embarrassment. So I changed the subject before he could start resenting me. “What about your work? Was Sy happy with it?” Santana let go of his wedding ring and glanced up. “Other than our disagreement over Lindsay, I think
102 / SUSAN ISAACS
he was pleased. This was only our third week of shooting.” “Did he ever have it out with you over how you were directing Lindsay?” More silence. “Come on. Why should I hear a lot of fancy stories from third parties when I should hear the plain truth from you?” “He said…” He shook his head as if refusing to give words to the unspeakable. “What?” “He said if Lindsay didn’t start showing some real warmth…” “He’d do what?” “He’d replace me with someone who would be able to…” “Say it.” “He was…crude. What do they say about men like Sy? You can take the boy out of Brooklyn, but you can’t take the Brooklyn out of the boy. He said, and I quote: ‘Give her a kick in the clit and get her to act like a real woman.’” “End quote,” I said. “Oh, yes indeed,” he agreed. “End quote.” I wasn’t really sure why Nicholas Monteleone was such a famous actor. It’s not that he was bad-looking. Dark-brown hair, matching eyes. Big lips that critics probably called sensuous. And for a slim guy, lots of muscles, even in unnecessary places, like his forearms, as though he moonlighted as a blacksmith. If he’d worked in Homicide, he’d be second or third best-looking. But that someone was paying him a million bucks a movie because he was such a hunk? I’d seen a couple of his pictures, and he’d never looked like a leading man to me. He had no intriguing dark corners; despite his sleepy, heavy-lidded eyes, he was all sunshine and light. But he did look like his part in Starry Night: a
MAGIC HOUR / 103
playboy. His thick, almost shoulder-length hair was moussed back on the sides. He’d rolled up the cuffs of his pale-pink shirt just once, and miraculously, they stayed that way. But sitting in the Xerox/coffee room, Nick wasn’t playing it smooth. More: Forget I’m a world-famous star. I’m a regular guy. Come on, let’s be friends! Temporary friendship was fine with me. He seemed genuinely good-natured, and what the hell, it’s nice to have a movie star trying to grin his way into your heart. But for all his pleasantness, Nick Monteleone didn’t seem to know anything worth knowing. Had he seen Sy angry? Hmmm. No, didn’t think so. Had anyone been angry at Sy? Ummm, not that I know of. That type of thing for twenty minutes. “Uhhh,” he finally said, “I know this is a serious business, and I’m probably acting like a self-centered asshole, but I’ve gotta ask. By any chance did you happen to catch me in Firing Range? I played one of you guys.” “Yeah,” I told him. It wasn’t anything I’d go to the movies for; I’d caught it on cable, although I wasn’t about to tell him that. “You were very good.” In fact, he had gotten a lot of it right: the camaraderie of a homicide squad, the compulsive twenty-hour workdays and, especially, the fatigue. But he’d worn a shoulder holster—which hardly anyone I know wears—and he’d been physically slow, almost clumsy. By the time he’d have drawn his gun, he would have been dead about forty seconds; he hadn’t moved right. And now, watching him, I realized he couldn’t even sit right. He was doing the relaxed, manly, lean-back-on-the-two-rear-legs-ofthe-chair, when suddenly he lost his balance and almost crashed over backward. He saved himself, barely, but couldn’t admit defeat by bringing the chair down on all four legs, so for a minute his feet did a hysterical
104 / SUSAN ISAACS
cha-cha until he regained his balance. Forget his expensive muscles; I saw that Nick had the coordination of a Frankenstein windup toy. When he was a kid, the guys probably muttered, “Not Monteleone!” when they were picking teams. “Did you get what my character was about?” he asked. “I mean, did you buy him?” “Sure.” Actually, thinking about it, I remembered shaking my head, wondering how come this white Chicago homicide lieutenant (in movies, homicide-cop heroes are always lieutenants) had a combo black-New York-Rambo accent: Yo, mothafucka, put that .38 (which came out like “dirty-eight”) on the table and get those hands up high. Now, putz. “I mean, you probably think I’m just another narcissistic actor—and you’re probably right—but I am just honestly curious: Could I have been someone you work with?” What he wanted, I realized all of a sudden, was unconditional acceptance. Not just as my friend. As my colleague. I had to love him totally—and prove my love—or he wouldn’t open up to me. So I gushed. “You know, it was the goddamnedest thing! You really were one of us,” I told him. “No shit, you could have had the desk next to mine at Headquarters.” Nicholas’s entire body eased. He let up on his macho chair routine. He stretched out his legs, crossed his feet at his ankles. He was wearing some kind of step-in shoes made from lots of thin strips of leather; they probably had some foreign name my brother would know. “Tell me about dailies,” I asked him, now that we were practically best friends, to say nothing of partners. “What are they exactly? The whole day’s worth of film?” “The film has to be processed, so what you’re see-
MAGIC HOUR / 105
ing is the footage shot the day before. All the takes. The director and the editor sit in the back and talk—whisper, actually—about which take is good, which isn’t, what coverage they’ll use, what kind of light and color corrections they’ll want to order.” “Who else goes to see them?” “Actors. Sometimes. Personally, I’m superanalytical about my own work, and I like to see what everybody else is doing too. You know. Like how is my lighting? My costume? My makeup?” “Did Lindsay go to dailies?” Nicholas compressed his big lips. “No. She always rushed back to Sy’s house to work out. Swam laps in his pool. Had to keep those pecs toned.” “How come she didn’t want to see her acting? She’s supposed to be smart. Isn’t she analytical about her work the way you are?” “The real truth? Lindsay is an egomaniac.” This said by a guy who went every night to watch his makeup. “She’s totally convinced she can gauge her performance as she gives it, so why bother to see herself? Besides”—Nicholas shook his head wearily—“if she wants a reaction, all she has to do is look into Spanish Eyes after each take. You get what I’m saying? She can see her brilliance reflected.” “She really got to Santana?” “Got to him? She had him in a chain collar, on a leash. ‘Roll over, Victor. Good boy! Stay!’ A tragedy for the rest of the company. The first week, Victor was very strong, full of ideas, energy, really exciting to work with. And actually giving Lindsay a rough time because from day one—well, day three or four—he was under the gun. Sy was not happy with Miss Keefe’s work. Naturally, Lindsay being Lindsay, she immediately picked up that the balance of power had shifted—away from her. She needed a new ally.
106 / SUSAN ISAACS
So she sniffed out Victor’s weakness. That’s her greatest gift, finding a guy’s most sensitive area.” “What was Santana’s?” “Oh…being allowed to live in Movieland. I mean, Victor Santana was a damn good cinematographer and then moved to directing. He’s directed two really well-received films, right? But beneath his ‘I’m so sophisticated’ façade he’s still wide-eyed about being in the business. Deep down, he can’t even believe he made it out of East Harlem. And here’s Lindsay, with her classical-theater background and her Commie Chic reputation and her half-naked Vanity Fair. Supremo nympho. The only guys who get into her are major lefties—or very heavy hitters with a net worth of at least fifty mil. So Victor thinks: If the same woman who screws the world’s most interesting men—that Latvian novelist, Fidel Castro’s minister of defense, Sy Spencer—well, if she wants to screw me, I must be in their league.” “How did she get Sy? What was his weakness?” “Oh, easy. Sy was the ultissimo intellectual snob. And even though she manages to take off most of her clothes in every movie she makes, Lindsay is still considered a very serious actor; she’s convinced everybody she’s getting naked as an hommage to the First Amendment. She gets brilliant reviews in all the right little magazines—the ones with French names and cheapo paper—and the big ones too. And she was politically correct on Nicaragua before anyone else knew you were even supposed to think about a Nicaragua. Also, she’s a genuine beauty. No plastic surgery. And that for-real blond hair.” “No shit. The hair’s real?” “I’ve been told by highly placed sources that the bottom…it’s a match.” “Wow.” Then I said: “Okay, we’d better get back to the dailies business. Did Sy see them all the time?”
MAGIC HOUR / 107
“He had to. First of all, he genuinely cared. And also, they were the only way to monitor his investment.” “Did he ever say anything about being dissatisfied?” “No. I mean, it depends on the director, but usually it’s not just the inner circle at dailies. There’s the director of photography, the writer, cameramen, sound men, assistant directors, production assistants, hair and makeup, set designer. The whole cast and crew, if they feel like it. Usually about fifteen people show up, sit around, stuff their faces with trail mix and watch. So Sy—who prided himself on his classiness—wouldn’t sit and bitch about Lindsay in front of an audience.” The skin around Nicholas’s eyes glistened, almost raccoonlike, in the fluorescence. At first I’d thought it was some weird trick of the light. Then I realized it was face cream. “So how did you know he wasn’t happy with her?” “Well, one day about a week ago, we’d been shooting very late. Hardly anyone came to dailies. Most people, Santana included, were wiped; they got the hell out the second after the lights came on. I was kind of hanging around, wanting to get a minute with Sy to talk about something—” “What?” “I forget. I’m sure it was nothing important. In any case, Sy starts letting loose to a few of his people. Not loud, and not even angry, which shows you how under control he was, because when you looked at Lindsay up on that screen it was like looking at Big-Tit Barbie. I mean, not one single spark of life. Anyway, Sy was supercool, just kidding about the scene and what a fortune it was going to cost to have an effects man add lightning, and did we really need lightning. Everybody started talking about lightning. All of a sudden, Sy laughs and says how the best thing that
108 / SUSAN ISAACS
could happen to this movie would be if lightning struck Lindsay. Then he said, ‘Just kidding.’ But naturally, everybody knew what he meant.” “What did he mean?” “If anything really happened to her? It’s what the moneymen always say when one performer is crapping up a movie; if lightning struck, the completion guarantors—the insurers—would have to pay so they could begin production again with another actress. Sy was being lighthearted, but the subtext was: Forget the two-hearts-that-beat-as-one shit; he wished to hell he could be rid of her.” Nicholas paused. He was working up to something big. Inhale. Exhale. Inhale. Finally, he got it out: “Can I call you Steve?” I wasn’t any actor, but I flashed my most engaging copfriend smile. “Yeah, sure.” He smiled back. “And you call me Nick. Now, Steve, just between us. About Sy’s wanting to get rid of Lindsay. This last week, I think Sy might have been taking meetings off the set.” Nick had heavy eyebrows. He lifted them significantly. “Do you get my drift?” “He had someone else?” “I’m not sure. But you could see Lindsay trying too hard to please him, and him not interested in getting pleased. I mean, she’d put an arm around him, and he’d put his arm around her. The movements were right, but hell, I’m an actor. Why do I get the big bucks? Because I’m intuitive. I know body language, and his was saying, ‘I have a headache tonight, dear.’” “Maybe he was just upset about her performance.” “Maybe. But the first two weeks, he’d always be sniffing around her, hanging around the set most of the day. He knew then that she wasn’t doing her best work, but he was so goddamn hot for her he couldn’t be angry. I mean, you should have seen him: canned
MAGIC HOUR / 109
heat. But suddenly he’s looking at his watch. He’s leaving by eleven.” “Did you hear any talk—vague rumors, even—about this from anyone?” “No. It’s just my theory.” Nicholas the Graceful stood up, stretching his arms, and—whammo—slammed his hand against the wall. He sat down again and pretended his knuckles weren’t throbbing. “Listen, can I really trust you, Steve?” “You bet.” I leaned forward and gave him a light, malebonding arm punch. “You know you can.” “You know Katherine Pourelle?” “The actress? Yeah, sure.” “This is not for public consumption, but I used to have a thing with her, when we were both starting out. She was living with this guy from ICM. Her agent, in fact. Well, she was more than living with him. She was married to him. Anyhow, we had this big love, big breakup, big hate. But last winter we met in Vail. New husband—real estate developer. New agent. But you know what goes down. We stopped being silly and became…I guess you’d call it friends.” I assumed what he was trying to tell me was that he fucked Katherine Pourelle in Vail while her husband was out schussing. I gave him what I hoped was a knowing smile. “Well, I got a call from her Tuesday night. From L.A. She wanted to know what was with the production. At first I thought she’d heard about how lousy Lindsay was doing and just wanted to dish. Kat hates Lindsay and loves to dish. She did a play with her, years ago. Everybody who ever worked with Lindsay loathes her. Fine, I figured, so we talked about Lindsay and Santana, how he was her first non-Commie Hispanic. Oh, and about how Lindsay always closes her eyes when the director is talking, like she’s concentrating on the voice of God, and how you wish you could
110 / SUSAN ISAACS
smack her. Anyway, we had this long, really great talk, but there was something left unsaid. I could sense it. I mean, Steve, I earn my living by being open to feelings.” “Right,” I said encouragingly. “So I said to her: ‘Come on, Kat. Tell me what you heard.’ So she makes me swear not to tell a soul. She’d gotten a call from Sy that morning!” “And?” “He asked if she would give Starry Night an overnight read. Supersecret. Do you get what I’m saying?” “He wanted her to look at the part Lindsay was playing?” “You got it!” Nick said. “I think Sy knew that this was a potential twenty-million-dollar catastrophe. And I think he’d also found himself someone with blonder hair, or plus grande boobies. Lindsay had lost her hold on him. You know what, Steve? I think Sy was getting ready to pull the plug on Lindsay.” When Lynne took me on, she knew we had a lot going for us. I wanted what she wanted: love, companionship, a family, plus—since she seemed to average one marriage proposal every two weeks—a chance to stick it to her stick-up-the-ass family. But in taking me on, she knowingly, willingly and of her own free will bought the whole package: recovering alcoholic (to say nothing of a guy with a former fondness for pot, hash, barbiturates and heroin), recovered fuckerarounder, about-to-be-old fart, compulsive runner, workaholic. Her acceptance of me was absolute, unquestioning. Was she perfect? No. She was a pain in the ass about order, the type who in sixth grade would have won Neatest Three-Ring Binder. I was neat; she was nuts. She had to restrain herself from making the bed
MAGIC HOUR / 111
the minute I got up to go to the bathroom. She actually inspected her pencils every night to make sure they were all sharpened for the next day. Lynne’s idea of wild spontaneity was going out for a nude moonlight swim—after she finished her lesson plan but before the eleven o’clock news. Still, as much as I bitched about it, deep down, her order comforted me. I needed a structured life filled with perfect pencil points and lights out immediately after Johnny Carson’s monologue. Her imperfections turned out to be virtues. So why was I less than wild with happiness? Why couldn’t I accept Lynne without reservation, the way she’d accepted me? How come I couldn’t say: Sure, she’s a little serious, but who gives a shit with that hair, those legs? Why was I wasting time worrying that I wasn’t one hundred percent ecstatic? Wasn’t ninety-nine percent enough? What was wrong with me? She had five million sterling qualities. Why was I zeroing in on the one she lacked? Why the hell was I waiting for Fun? It wasn’t that Lynne didn’t have a sense of humor. She did. But it was a sense of other people’s humor. She’d smile whenever I’d say something even mildly clever. She’d laugh at Eddie Murphy and Woody Allen movies, at my friend Marty McCormack’s stupid minister-rabbi-priest jokes (where the priest, naturally, always got the punch line) and at any attempt at comedy by any member of grades K through 6 at Holy Spirit Academy, especially her kids, the ones with learning disabilities. What Lynne lacked was liveliness. I knew it wasn’t fair to hold it against her. It was like saying to a woman, I want you to be five foot two and built like a brick shithouse, when she is, in fact, tall and willowy. Still, I couldn’t shake the low feeling that had come over me on the blanket in my backyard the day be-
112 / SUSAN ISAACS
fore. More than disappointment, less than dread. I didn’t know what the hell it was. But there I was, taking a phone break, my feet up on the Xerox machine, making it worse—giving her an opening I knew she didn’t have the capacity to fill. “Okay, who do you think is sexier? Me or Nicholas Monteleone?” And as Lynne, predictably, was responding, “You,” I found myself ashamed of myself for wanting: “Are you kidding? Nicholas Monteleone!” She asked: “Is he a nice person?” “Yeah. Friendly; a good talker for someone who speaks other people’s lines for a living. When I finished questioning him, I felt: Too damn bad he has to leave; he’s great company. But he’s so terrific that you start wondering whether it’s him or it’s an act. Like, if he thought that running around the room and imitating an aardvark would put him in a better light with Homicide, would he forget the congeniality bit and start licking up ants?” “What do you think?” “Ants,” I said. I looked at my watch. It was after five. “Listen, honey, were you counting on lobster?” “No, but that’s what you told me you were counting on.” “Did you melt the butter?” “No, of course not. And you didn’t buy the lobsters. I know you. I know you so well that right now I know I’m going to have a Lean Cuisine and then about ten you’ll pop in—just to say hello.” “I’m a very friendly guy.” “Guess what? You won’t be able to be too friendly. My roommates are home tonight.” “Shit. All right, if I get finished by ten, ten-thirty, can I pick you up and take you over to my place?” Just as Lynne was saying, “Okay, but not too late a night, because I have a huge pile of test results for next year’s kids I have to go through,” a Southamp-
MAGIC HOUR / 113
ton Village cop appeared at the door with a surprise guest: Gregory J. Canfield. Gregory gaped at the room, slack-jawed, trying to register everything, as if the decor—including the brown-stained hot plate of the Mr. Coffee machine and me with my feet up—was going to be the subject of his final in Advance Set Design at NYU film school. Now that there was no corpse to upset his delicate balance, he was Mr. Movie Man. I said, “People. Speak to you later,” to Lynne and “Thanks” to the cop who’d shown Gregory in. Then I hung up, swung my feet off the Xerox machine and told Gregory to sit. But he barely got through the door when he stopped short. You could see his mind moving in for a close-up; he stood before the bulletin board, staring at a yellowing FBI Most Wanted list, at hand-printed signs offering Doberman-mix puppies, an ’81 Datsun 280 ZX and a model 12 Winchester pumpaction shotgun, probably wishing someone else from NYU was there to share this Moment of Authenticity. “Okay, now you know what lower middle class looks like, Gregory. Time to sit down.” He did. “You’re here to help me. Right?” He nodded. He looked slightly less repulsive than the day before, mainly because instead of baggy shorts, he was wearing baggy slacks. His skeletal white legs, with their bulbous kneecaps, were covered. “I remembered what I couldn’t remember last night.” “Great,” I replied. I waited. He was staring at my holster, which was clipped onto my belt. “You remembered something?” “You asked me if there were any threats made to Sy Spencer.” “And?” “I don’t know if you’d classify this as a threat. I
114 / SUSAN ISAACS
mean, a genuine threat.” Gregory hesitated. Now he was gazing at me with the same passionate intensity he’d directed at the bulletin board. He’d obviously decided I was the star of this movie. He flushed. He fidgeted. He beamed at me. I was his True Detective. “Listen, Gregory, anything you think is even remotely threatening—a dirty look—is something I want to hear about.” “Did you know Sy had an ex-wife who lives in Bridgehampton?” My heart gave a thump. I sat up, alert. Damn it, I’d been right. There was something about her. “Bonnie Spencer,” I said. His face fell. “Hey, if by this time I didn’t know Sy had an ex in the neighborhood, what the hell kind of detective would I be?” Gregory still looked like he was debating whether or not to be clinically depressed. “Now come on. You’re my key man in this investigation. Okay, I gave you a name: Bonnie Spencer. But now it’s your job to fill me in.” “Well, Sy married her right at the beginning of his career as producer. She’d written the scenario…That’s another term for screenplay. It’s more common in Britain. In any case, she’d written a movie called Cowgirl in the late seventies. Unpretentious film. Her credit was Bonnie Bernstein.” That big Utah jockette didn’t strike me as a Bernstein. “Had she ever been married before Sy?” I asked. “I don’t know.” “Okay, go on.” It’s funny; as he was talking, I realized that Bonnie had been on my mind since I’d left her that morning. I couldn’t shake the images I had of her. One was the real Bonnie as I’d seen her. The other one was even more vivid, and unconnected with reality; she was in some sort of sleeveless thing, a dress or a tank top, that bared part of her broad shoulders. I could see
MAGIC HOUR / 115
her arms and shoulders: strong, smooth, with the sheen of a deep tan. Incredibly silky skin. It was really, well, an exciting image—and a strange one, because the bare-shouldered Bonnie in my mind’s eye was so incredibly desirable, and really had nothing to do with the big girl in the big T-shirt I’d interviewed. “The marriage broke up,” Gregory reported, “and she went into total eclipse as a writer.” “How come?” “I don’t know.” Maybe, I thought, Bonnie Spencer reminded me of someone else, some large, bewitching girl out of my past. That made sense. But my house was no more than four miles from hers; I could have passed her one summer evening on one of my runs and focused in on her best few square inches. Or maybe I’d given her a half second of consideration in my bar-hopping days, before moving on to someone better. Who the hell knew? In all those years of drinking—especially toward the end—there were black holes in my memory. We could have met at a cocktail lounge and discussed Truth and Beauty all night, and it would be a total blank. “From what I’ve heard,” Gregory went on, “Bonnie is pretty much of a zero. Her only real significance is that she used to be married to Sy. But even then, I probably wouldn’t have heard about her if she hadn’t come to the set.” Right. Bonnie had mentioned she’d dropped in to see Sy. “What happened?” Gregory rubbed his palms together as though he was heating them up for a passionate prayer. “One of the other P.A.s came running over to me, saying Sy’s ex-wife was there and what should he do. But he couldn’t do anything, because she was right there behind him. She’d followed him. To see her, she’s
116 / SUSAN ISAACS
this very plain Jane type, but you could understand how she must have learned a thing or two from Sy, because before I could say a word or go get one of the assistant directors, she walked right past me and knocked on the trailer door. I said, ‘Excuse me, miss, but that trailer is private. I’ll have to ask you to please wait over by the craft services table.’ Well, that second Sy opened the trailer door. He took one look at her and…you would not believe his face!” “Tell me.” “Beet red, and I mean b-e-e-t. She said something like ‘Hiya, Sy!’ as if she expected him to give her this major warm welcome, which, of course, he didn’t.” Gregory drew in his sunken cheeks. He seemed to be waiting for applause. I didn’t clap. “Gregory, you came in to tell me about a threat.” “Oh. Right. Yes, well, Sy gave her this withering look and said, ‘This is not a Bonnie Bernstein production. You know you do not come onto a set unless you are invited.’ And believe me, the way he said it was not exactly sotto voce. I mean, Sy could be beard.” Shit. Even though I knew there was something wrong about Bonnie, I felt lousy for her. “How did she react?” I asked. “Jolted. Absolutely jolted. I mean, for whatever reason, she had been expecting a red carpet. She must have thought he’d welcome her with open arms and—” I cut him off. “The threat, Gregory.” “Right. Well, she stood there for a minute, paralyzed. I mean, you can imagine the humiliation. For a second, I thought she might cry. But she didn’t. No. Quietly, and I mean quietly, like probably I was the only one close enough to hear, do you know what
MAGIC HOUR / 117
she said to him? She said, ‘Sy, you’ve just been a rotten bastard for the last time!’ That’s what she said. Days before he was murdered. And then she just turned her back on him—and walked away!”
CHAPTER SIX
Jesus, what a day! Trying to dope out what was under Lindsay’s sheet of ice, behind Nicholas Monteleone’s cloud of congeniality. Feeling upset that my brother was so upset, wondering if he’d be able to find another job. Seeing Germy again, seeing my past. Lynne. And Bonnie Spencer. The hardest part of the whole day. Ever since the morning, I’d been fighting her off—the desirable, bare-armed fantasy Bonnie and the real Bonnie, big, plain. Okay, so with fantastic, gold-medal thighs. But I wanted her out of my mind, and she wasn’t cooperating. After Gregory had gone—although not before he’d announced, in front of about ten guys in the squad room, that I was a “fascinating combination” of Scott Glenn and Keith Carradine—I lifted the phone to call Marty McCormack, at home. I wanted to fill him in, ask him if he thought I should bring Bonnie in for questioning, scare her a little. Actually, I just wanted to talk to a friend. But all of a sudden, I’d started feeling…It’s hard to describe, but every drunk knows the sensa-
118
MAGIC HOUR / 119
tion: a slight tightening in the throat, a fluttering of the heart, and then weariness, edginess. It all happens in that microsecond before your brain says, Hey, I really would love a drink. I hung up the phone and drove over to Westhampton Beach. And at five o’clock, I was sitting on a brown metal folding chair in the basement of the Methodist church in the usual repulsive fog of cigarette smoke at an AA meeting. But I seemed to be doing everything I could to avoid making the old searching and fearless inventory of myself. Instead, I found myself easing into a real hot reverie—reliving my morning meeting with Bonnie, then improving on it. I was in her kitchen again, moving in on her. Her back was pressed against the sink, but now I was rubbing up against her. I kissed her, and she let out a cry of relief and desire and put her arms around me. Her arms felt so incredibly wonderful. I became aware that I was breathing a little too deeply, crossing, uncrossing my legs. I forced my attention straight ahead. The smoky basement haze softened the too-lip-sticked darkred mouth of the speaker. Her name was Jennifer. She had wide maroon makeup stripes on her cheeks and dark-brown eye shadow that went up to her eyebrows. But although she looked hard, she didn’t sound it; she had that high, silly, sweet voice of a girl who asks you to make a muscle and then squeals “Oooh!” She couldn’t have been much older than Lynne. “See, I used to empty out the saline solution for my contact lenses and put vodka in the bottles!” Jennifer explained. We all laughed, applauded; that was one we hadn’t heard. “Anyhow, I kept three bottles in a drawer at work. Two or three times a day I’d start blinking like crazy and rubbing my eye.” Usually I hated meetings in the summer. Somehow,
120 / SUSAN ISAACS
when I wasn’t looking (or was too drunk to notice), AA had become a nonalcoholic version of a singles bar. Dingy church basements were packed with yuppies exchanging degradation stories and slipping each other business cards. Despite all warnings, pickups were common. “Hi, babe. Need a sponsor?” AA had turned into the new Hamptons scene, and locals like me felt like…well, locals. Jennifer giggled. “I’d grab a bottle of saline solution, toddle down to the bathroom and chug the vodka! And after work, I’d sneak the bottles into my purse, take them home and refill them for the next day!” This meeting wasn’t all that bad; along with most of the others, I nodded with recognition at Jennifer’s desperation and—despite her lack of anything resembling intelligence—her enormous ingenuity. I thought: We’re all so cunning when we’re desperate to fuck ourselves over. I stretched out my legs and leaned back in the chair, forcing myself to relax, to listen, understand, learn. But just as I was thinking an enlightening thought—about how so many drunks have this almost religious belief in the superiority of vodka, its odorless innocence, its purity—Bonnie pushed her way into my head again. Beneath that straight-shooter veneer, behind the savvy, self-effacing humor, what the hell was she? A Fatal Attraction psychopath pursuing Sy, hounding him to produce some hunk of junk she thought was a screenplay—or to get him to love her again? Or was she simply a no-talent loser who had barreled onto the set after pumping up her courage with cocaine or booze or some dopey assertiveness training book? And what about the threat Gregory had overheard? Look, telling someone it’s the last time he’s going to be a rotten bastard is, to a homicide cop, somewhat less significant than a vague “I’m gonna get you” or a specific “I’m going to hack your balls off and make
MAGIC HOUR / 121
them into cuff links.” Still, when I’d interviewed her, Bonnie had tossed off her visit to the set in a couple of words, giving the impression that dear old Sy had asked her to drop by just to be friendly: a little cheek-to-cheek air kiss, a little “Oh, Bon, you must meet Johnny, our key grip,” a little chat about some dangling participle in her screenplay. And what about her story about being invited to Sy’s house, getting the fifty-cent tour? Why would a smart operator like Sy Spencer risk the Wrath of Lindsay by bringing home his tall-in-the-saddle ex-wife to have a look around the master bedroom suite with its king-size closets, its emperorsize bed? Why would he offer Bonnie a tour of a house that had to have pointed out to her: Sweetheart, did you get fucked over on alimony! Was he that insensitive? That much of a prick? Or had Bonnie pushed her way in there too? And why had she told me about it? Good old honesty? Or had anyone seen her, maybe making an unseemly fuss? rifling through drawers? taking something that didn’t belong to her? Had she been smart enough to know we’d be dusting everything—from the doorknobs to the blade of Marian Robertson’s Cuisinart—for prints and knew hers were there? Goddamn Bonnie. It ticked me off that all day long I hadn’t been able to get her out of my mind. When I thought about it, she was the one who’d ruined Lindsay Keefe for me. Here I’d been expecting at least a cheap thrill, and what happened? I’d actually gotten turned off because Lindsay, posturing in front of the window, had seemed so false after Bonnie’s “naturalness.” Big deal. She was in great shape and she’d…I don’t know. She’d amused me. But I knew, as I sat there, tuning out the AA meeting, that I was acting nuts, fixating on Bonnie. By any rational standard, I’d never had it so good. Lynne was great-looking, sweet,
122 / SUSAN ISAACS
young. But there I was, eyes closed, imagining running my hands over the flawless satin of Bonnie’s arms—even though, for all I knew, she could have clammy, fish-belly flesh or rough lizard skin, or her entire body could be dotted with dime-size brown freckles. I wasn’t sure what was going on. Had Bonnie Spencer gotten to me? Or had I gotten to me? Gregory, after all, had been right on target about her: a plain Jane. Barely nice eyes—okay, an interesting color. An ordinary nose. A forgettable mouth, most likely with chalky, premenopausal lips; I really hadn’t noticed. So what the hell was I doing wanting to…I can’t even say wanting to see her again. Just wanting her. Forget reality. I wanted my fantasy too much to open my eyes: I had dropped my jacket onto her kitchen floor. My tie was unknotted, my shirt was open, and I was tearing off Bonnie’s bra so I could hold her against me, skin to skin. Applause startled me. I looked up. Jennifer, smiling with lipsticked teeth, was stepping down. Engaged-guy nerves. That was my problem. Definitely. After more than half a lifetime of drinking—and womanizing—of being a master self-deceiver (“Only three beers tonight”) and a consummate liar (“Oh, sweetheart, oh, you’re so beautiful, oh, I love you”), it was so hard to keep it simple. Willie, the leader, a big local guy in a plaid shirt who was a motorcycle mechanic, stepped to the front. Years before, he’d gotten his teeth knocked out in a fight; his dentures looked as if they’d been molded for a giant; they made him lisp. “Thith hath been a great meeting!” he boomed. “Time to clothe now. Would all thothe who feel like it join me in the Therenity Prayer?” Was it only that I was having the normal alcoholic’s trouble of keeping it simple? Or was I in deeper shit,
MAGIC HOUR / 123
really looking to self-destruct? To throw over Lynne, which equaled throwing over happiness, stability, a chance to be a human being? Was I still drawn to oblivion? Forty-five of us stood and held hands. I squeezed tight. I felt warm I’m-with-you squeezes back, even from the yuppie jerk in tennis whites on my right. I thought: This is what I’m here for. Support. I can’t do it myself. I need these people. I need God. I need… I couldn’t fight Bonnie. Something is wrong about her, I thought. Plus, objectively, there is absolutely nothing about her to turn me on. And yet now I was imagining kissing her soft, warm skin. “God grant me the serenity…” My voice was embarrassingly loud. Maybe I could keep it simple: Just admit she was one of those women who, despite the most commonplace looks, had always been an erotic genius, even now, even as she was getting too old for anyone to want. A not-homely, not-pretty woman you’d overlook on the street but who, in close quarters, knows exactly how to get to you. Or maybe she wasn’t devious. Maybe she did it unconsciously: she gave off primitive, subliminal signals or secreted some subtle female animal smell. Whatever it was, I wasn’t going to let it affect me. “…To accept the things I cannot change,” I prayed. “Courage to change the things I can; / And wisdom to know the difference.” Amen. On the basis of its architecture, my mother’s house, an old place with weathered cedar siding and a deep front porch, should have been charming or quaint or inviting. But it wasn’t. There were too many trees too close: overpowering oaks, dark, drippy maples, grim
124 / SUSAN ISAACS
spruces; their humid shadows spooked the house. And inside…well, it was always dank, especially in the living room, with its never-quite-dry upholstery; sit there long enough and your pubic areas felt about to mildew. No wonder I’d gone off to Vietnam, come home for three days and then never gone back. But my brother had never moved out. Oh, right, you could say, hearing that: He still lives with Mommy. But it really wasn’t like that. Easton was no mama’s boy. Sure, with his navy-blue blazers and golden color, he might look like some hare-brained heir to a Southampton fortune. But in truth, he was very unindulged. My father had given him almost nothing, except an occasional unbankable belch, and in any case had cleared out soon after Easton’s sixth birthday. My mother, although she clearly preferred him to me, spent every cent she had on upping her own Quality Quotient, not his; she would never pass up buying a hundred-dollar ticket to a benefit for hyperkinetic Maori Anglicans held on some rich socialite’s lawn (with shrimp in sculptedice swan boats) in order to do something nice for her son. Still, Easton had inherited my mother’s grand dreams, although unlike her, he had never lost touch with the truth. He was not the typical Bridgehampton local who falls in with the summer crowd; he did not get dizzy drinking rich people’s champagne. No matter how much time he spent in their perfect houses, he knew he wasn’t one of them, that he was, essentially, poor and, in addition, not blessed with that mysterious personal magnetism that attracts money. So forget Easton buying his own place, or even renting an apartment. Both assumed a steady income, and my brother understood that long-term job retention—unlike cutting lemon peels into translucent twists—was not one of his fortes. I’m sure he never
MAGIC HOUR / 125
actually sat down with my mother and said: Listen, I can play golf, tennis and croquet, sail a boat. I know the correct dress shoes to wear from Memorial Day to Labor Day. But for some reason I keep getting canned after six or eight months. So if you don’t mind, I’d going to stay put here. Why go through the embarrassment of setting up housekeeping somewhere and then getting evicted? Right, Mom? Actually, Easton’s living at home suited them both. No rent for him, just whatever he could contribute, whenever. And living in the big house set far back from the road, he could pass himself off as a Bridgehampton blueblood. Who among his city slicker acquaintances would get out of their Porsches to inspect the house—and discover we did not own the adjoining farmland? Who, over the course of a lazy summer, would bother to check his credentials, to find out that his father had been not a gentleman farmer but a drunk given to pissing on the floor of the local tavern? (I call Easton’s friends acquaintances. Just like my mother, he lived for the summer people. From the time he got his driver’s license, he ignored the kids at high school and hung out with a semi-social Southampton crew: the Daddy-is-onWall-Street-and-by-gosh-so-am-I fraternity. It didn’t seem to matter who they were individually; they all had boats to invite him on, golf clubs to take him to, wives’ college roommates to fix him up with. They were interchangeable: extremely tan, mildly wealthy and slightly stupid.) Anyway, the domestic arrangement suited Easton. And I guess my mother liked having him around because he could do all the man jobs: mow the lawn, put up the storm windows, check the mousetraps in the cellar. She’d never been much of a farm wife, even when she’d had a farmer.
126 / SUSAN ISAACS
Living with Easton gave my mother an audience for her compulsive monologue no one else would be willing to listen to. She’d sit at the table, push her food around her plate, light up a cigarette and—puff, puff—talk about the French five-thousand-dollar dress Mrs. Preston Cortwright had tried to return the Monday after her big party; the rumor that Mr. Edward Dudley, husband of size-three Mrs. Edward—puff, puff—had taken up with their Experiment in International Living seventeen-year-old fatso fräulein from Munich. Or—my mother would tap off the ash—how she herself had made all the right diplomatic moves and had finally been named deputy associate chairlady of the Southampton-Peconic Museum of Art’s annual cocktail party. My mother’s pretentiousness, her coldness—her absolute nothingness—never got to my brother. Unlike me, he could listen to her expound on Quality without wishing she’d choke to death on one of her goddamn Protestant watercress sandwiches. Not that they spent a lot of time together. My mother used the big back bedroom on the first floor, and Easton took over the second floor. I don’t think either of them longed for more companionship. Okay, compared to me, Easton was my mother’s pride and joy, but compared to what she had expected of him—the presidency of a major brokerage firm, senior partner of a Wall Street law firm—he was a loser. But a well-dressed one. Robby Kurz did a major double take after we rang the doorbell. “Easton Brady,” my brother said to Robby, and shook his hand. Robby stared at Easton. Then he blinked a couple of times, as if expecting his vision to clear. He had probably been imagining me minus two years, and
MAGIC HOUR / 127
that was sort of true. But he was also face-to-face with a gent in gray flannel slacks, a pale-blue oxford shirt and a sapphireblue V-neck sweater, a rich-looking Waspy guy who was combing back his hair off his forehead with his fingers—hair that was just slightly too long. Not hippy or scruffy hair, but hair that seemed to be saying: Forgive the length, but I just got back from sailing home from Bermuda. Half an hour later, Robby was still sneaking fast, disbelieving glances from Easton to me. He sat at a folding card table across from Easton in my brother’s sitting room; it had once been my bedroom. As a kid, Easton had used the table to build his model ships; now it was covered with a huge, square fringed gold cloth, like one of those scarves you see on pianos in old movies. It almost hid the table’s skinny metal legs. I sat directly behind my brother, on a nice old cracked leather couch he must have picked up at some yard sale; the shrink at South Oaks had had one like it, the same dark brown. My deal with Ray Carbone was that I could be at Easton’s interview without being there. But every now and then my brother would turn his head and glance at me for reassurance as Robby questioned him about the cast and crew. What the hell: I’d nod, letting him know he was doing fine. Well, he was. “What exactly were you doing in New York yesterday?” Robby was asking. “I was meeting with our casting director. Going over deal memos and negotiating a price on some extra work we wanted done. Sy and Santana felt we had to cast the Colombian drug kingpin as threatening, but quietly threatening.” “You mean all the parts weren’t filled yet, even after they’d started making the movie?” Robby asked. “That’s right.” Easton sounded casual, like someone who’d been in the business for twenty years in-
128 / SUSAN ISAACS
stead of a few months. “It happens fairly often. We knew we could always sign an actor we’d already read, but we were hoping for someone special. The problem was where to look.” I rested my head on the back of the couch’s cool leather, crossed my arms over my chest and checked out my brother. I was impressed: no more of his sweaty, eager, fasttalking bullshit, like when he was selling houses or Jaguars or hand-knitted boat-neck sweaters. Easton had become a genuine movie guy. “We’d seen just about every over-fifty swarthy actor in New York and California. No luck, but we weren’t ready to give up. Well, not yet.” He really seemed to know what he was talking about. I was proud all of a sudden. He kept plucking at the neck of his sweater, probably to realign the V in front. “The casting director wanted to start looking at actors in Chicago, to farm the work out to her associate there. But the price she quoted us seemed out of line. Sy thought it would be better to negotiate with her in person than over the phone, but he couldn’t do it. He was busy on the set and getting ready to go to L.A., so he asked me to.” “How long did that meeting last?” “From before two until—I’m guessing now—three-thirty, four. I’m not sure. You could check with her.” “Did you speak to Sy on the phone at all during that time?” “No. I was going to drive over to his house after dinner, around nine, and tie up whatever loose ends there were.” “Was he expecting any company for dinner?” I interjected. “No,” Easton said. “Just Lindsay.” “Did you come straight back here after your meeting?” Robby asked. “No. I went to Sy’s shirtmaker to give him a swatch of Egyptian cotton Sy wanted to use and to pick up
MAGIC HOUR / 129
some other shirts that were ready.” I couldn’t see my brother’s face from the couch, but Easton must have smiled at Robby because, suddenly, Robby had on his supertoothy grin. “Assistant producer,” Easton continued, “and swatchcarrier. My whole job was to smooth things out for Sy. I went to meetings, made phone calls, wheeled and dealed in a minor way. And even played errand boy.” He fell silent for a minute, then added solemnly: “It was the best job I ever had.” Outside my old bedroom window, the leaves on the oak tree were almost black against the blue-gray twilight. It’s usually a down time for ex-drunks, but there I was, all of a sudden, feeling pretty up—about Easton. My brother, obviously, had always had some inner aberration that had screwed up his chances at a career. But outwardly he’d been Mr. Moderate. Balanced, temperate, neat, controlled. No fires burning in his soul. You couldn’t believe he wasn’t able to get a grip on his life, because he seemed so balanced. He did nothing to excess; when he drank, it was a watered-down Scotch or a couple of glasses of wine. When he drugged, it was one puff of a joint. Even the women he went out with were understated—to the point of invisibility: well-bred, well-dressed, with boobs barely bigger than their tiny noses. But strangely, the movie business, famous for its bullshit, had managed to make Easton more real. He was much less pompous. Okay, still not the kind of guy you’d ask over for Monday Night Football, but friendlier, looser. A decent man instead of Charlotte Easton Brady’s finely featured, immaculately groomed, elegantly dressed prig of a son. Maybe, I started thinking, after all these years, we could really be brothers. Lynne would say, Let’s have Easton to dinner, and I’d say, Great.
130 / SUSAN ISAACS
“Why was Mr. Spencer going to Los Angeles?” Robby asked. “He had four or five different projects he was interested in. He had a lot of meetings lined up.” I broke in. “Isn’t it a little unusual for a producer to leave town while his movie is being made?” Easton turned around, giving me the profile that demonstrated who’d gotten the best of the genes. “Not necessarily. Sy was executive producer. He had what’s called a line producer to supervise the whole production, take care of the day-to-day problems. And he had me to put out smaller fires. So he could afford to get away for a couple of days.” “Except things were pretty lousy here.” “What do you mean?” “The business with Lindsay.” “Lindsay.” Easton seemed a little ill at ease, as if by confirming trouble he’d be letting Sy down. “I see you’ve heard the rumors.” “We heard about the lousy dailies,” I told him. “Were they that bad?” He shrugged. “I can’t be a hundred percent sure, Steve. I haven’t been in the business long enough to really know. I mean, when Sy asked, I pretended to have an opinion and crossed my fingers and hoped I didn’t sound like a complete fool. But whatever reactions I have, they’re still pretty much the same as the man who buys a ticket and sits in a multiplex with a box of popcorn: either bored or enjoying himself. As far as I could see, Lindsay was doing all right. And she looked—there’s no other word—breathtaking.” Robby started his compulsive Lindsay nodding. “But I think I understood what Sy was talking about. Whenever Lindsay was on the screen, I wasn’t riveted—except by her beauty. I looked, but I didn’t really listen. My attention wandered. And to be honest, it
MAGIC HOUR / 131
probably would have wandered more if I hadn’t been involved in the movie.” “But she wasn’t a disaster?” I inquired. “Not her acting per se. But I think from Sy’s point of view the movie itself was a disaster-in-progress, because the audience had to love this woman. And even I could see you did not love. Lindsay in those dailies. Actually, you didn’t even like her all that much. You just didn’t care.” Robby took over. “Was Sy going to Los Angeles to speak to Katherine Pourelle about taking over Lindsay’s part?” Just before Easton whipped his head around to face Robby, I saw his reaction: absolutely stunned at how far we’d come so fast. “Jesus, who told you that?” Neither of us responded. Finally, Easton spoke. “Well, congratulations! Whoever your source was knew what he was talking about.” He turned back to me, really curious. “Who told you?” “I can’t, East.” “Oh, right,” he said. “Sorry. I didn’t mean to be pushy….” He smiled. “Well, not too pushy. In any case, Sy was going to see Katherine Pourelle. But as far as I was concerned, it was just a typical Sy maneuver. You see, he would let word leak out that he was speaking to Pourelle and her agent. That would put the fear of God into Lindsay, make her wake up and start—well, start acting. But I swear to you, Sy never would have fired her.” “He told you that?” Robby asked, then cleared his throat. He was getting hoarse. It had been a long day, and he looked like one exhausted Howdy Doody. Even the perky points of the yellow handkerchief in his breast pocket had gone limp. “No. But you see, I’d gotten to know Sy. He could be objective, tough, even callous about Lindsay the
132 / SUSAN ISAACS
actress. But he was completely vulnerable to Lindsay the woman. She had an enormous hold over him.” “Sex?” I asked. “Yes,” Easton responded. “Was it just a sex thing, or did love enter into it too?” Robby inquired. “It must have been both.” Easton lowered his head. His shoulders rose and fell with each of his sighs. And all of a sudden it hit me. Easton, like Sy, was being objective about Lindsay’s performance—but not about Lindsay herself. He couldn’t hide it. He’d actually fallen for her. “It’s not just that she’s beautiful, or talented or intelligent,” he was explaining, trying to sound detached, “although she’s all those things. She has a way of getting to a man.” Robby was bobbing his head again: Yes! Yes! Yes! “Sy…Sy needed Lindsay too much to fire her.” I heard Easton swallow. He seemed to have needed her too. He had one hell of a lump in his throat. “He needed her even if it cost him twenty million dollars?” Robby asked. “Yes.” But what about Nick Monteleone’s theory that Sy had chilled on the fair Lindsay and was, in fact, getting his toes curled elsewhere after he left the set every morning at eleven? I thought about those long, unblond hairs caught on the headboard in the guest room. “Were you there for that conversation about if lightning struck Lindsay?” I asked. Easton’s posture went ramrod straight. Once again, he seemed amazed that we actually had been doing what we were supposed to be doing: being detectives. Finally, he said: “God, you two are thorough! And…well, yes. I heard Sy say that. But that wish-
MAGIC HOUR / 133
ing Lindsay were out of the picture—literally—was just Sy’s way of blowing off steam.” “What do you mean?” “She was a big disappointment, but he wouldn’t have fired her. Trust me, Steve. There was no way he would have been able to cut her loose.” Easton’s tongue came out to moisten his lips. “He was helpless when it came to Lindsay.” Normally, I would have gone after him, half kidding, half zinging it to him, saying: Him helpless? What about you, sucker? I’d have given him a lot of shit about falling for a movie star. But I wasn’t going to embarrass my brother in front of Robby. Also, I realized that even if this was a hopeless crush, it was important; this was the first time in Easton’s life where he was showing some passion. It was not something to laugh about. “What about the other investors?” Robby asked. “It wasn’t just Sy’s money, was it? What about Mikey LoTriglio?” “Mikey!” Easton said. “Yes, of course. He’d slipped my mind. God, you should see him. What a tough act. Makes Marlon Brando in The Godfather look like a pussycat.” He stopped and considered what he’d been saying. “But maybe that’s not fair. He has a thick New York accent. And he looks like such a…hood. Maybe that makes him seem tougher than he is.” “Was Sy afraid of him in any way?” Silence. Easton must have been chewing his lip over that. I peered around. There was a script on the coffee table in front of the couch. I picked it up. My brother turned at the sound of paper. He saw what I was holding. His body sagged; his poise deserted him. He seemed to have forgotten about Robby. “See that script, Steve?” He sounded like a kid a few seconds from tears. “Sy gave it to me Thursday, the day
134 / SUSAN ISAACS
before…He handed it to me and said, ‘Our next movie, Easton. It just might make history.’” “I’m really sorry,” I said. “Things were going great with him, weren’t they?” “I finally—” He cut himself off, realizing Robby was there. “My life was tied to his,” he said quietly. He took a deep breath, and when he spoke again he was the old Easton, aggressively cheerful. “Well, I guess I’ll have to beat the bushes, find something else.” He shook his head. “I’d hate like hell to have to move to California, but I may have to. Be closer to the action, to people in the business.” Oh, shit, I thought. Easton had lucked out with Sy. He’d found a patron who liked his Southampton style and who had the rare and good instinct to trust Easton, to allow him to rise to all sorts of occasions, to prove himself. But Sy couldn’t give a reference. And what the hell kind of résumé could my brother hand out in Hollywood? Failed car salesman? For years Easton hadn’t even been able to sell madras Bermudas to congenital preppies. He lacked something—conviction, balls. What would he do in Los Angeles? How would he maneuver in a city of sharks? “Uh, where were we?” Robby wondered. He was massaging the bridge of his nose as if it were some newly discovered acupuncture point that would induce bright eyes and a clear mind. Except it didn’t work. Christ, he was wiped. I thought: Thirty years old is too young to get that tired that fast. Maybe that was why he was always trying to jump the gun, pushing for an arrest. The guy had no stamina. He couldn’t keep it up for a long investigation. “We were on Mikey,” I reminded him. “Right. Mikey.” “Sy did get…on edge when Mikey called,” Easton admitted to Robby. “But ‘on edge” for you or me might mean losing our temper, biting our nails. For
MAGIC HOUR / 135
Sy, it was just a slight tightness in his voice. You’d have to know him quite well to pick it up.” “Did he seem afraid?” Robby asked. “I don’t know. There was just that hint of tension. Although that in itself was a bit unusual. I mean, Sy never got anxiety. He gave it—to everybody. But every time Mikey would call, Sy would shake his head and mouth: ‘I’m out.’” While my brother talked, I opened the script. It said: “Night of the Matador” and “An original screenplay by Milton J. Mishkin.” I turned the page and read a little: LOW-ANGLE SHOT OF MATADOR,
huge, commanding,
menacing against black BG.
MATADOR I am Roderigo Diaz de Bivar—El Cid. And I am Francisco Romero, seven hundred years later, piercing the bull with my sword. SFX:
Thunderous animal breathing. Is it the matador? Or the bull? And I am Manolete, gored to death. And the young El Cordobes. CAMERA RISES.
BG brightens and WE SEE Matador in the center of the bullring, surrounded by PICADORS on horseback and BANDERILLEROS. He brandishes his red muleta. I am Spain. CAMERA MOVES IN to Matador’s HEAR flamenco music:
muleta for ECU and as WE
136 / SUSAN ISAACS
I am man. BEGIN OPENING CREDITS
against red.
I thought: They couldn’t pay me to read this shit, much less see it—which probably means it’s a true work of art. “Did Mikey LoTriglio call Sy a lot?” Robby was asking. “The last week or so, yes. About two or three times a day.” Robby began playing with the fringe on the scarf that covered the table, running his fingers through it. “What were Mikey’s calls about?” “I gather he’d been hearing rumors that the movie was having problems. Sy kept denying it, of course.” “Do you think this Mikey made any threats?” “I never heard his part of the conversation,” Easton said. “But whatever his message was, Sy found it…disturbing.” He paused. “Sy’s upper lip would get those little beads of sweat. You can’t imagine what that was like. Sy was not a man to sweat.” Inducing perspiration is not, in the State of New York, grounds for arrest, but you couldn’t tell that from Robby’s face. Suddenly he was awake, alert. Mikey was his guy. You could see the gleam of handcuffs shining in Robby’s eyes. “Hey, easy, Robby,” I said. “Steve, this is a good lead,” Robby responded, ignoring Easton, as if he were another cop—or a member of the family. “Mikey’s bad.” “Sure, but he’s no moron. Would he shoot Sy over a bad investment?” “Come on. He’s Mafia.” “Yeah,” I acknowledged, “but this doesn’t look like their kind of hit. They tend to be more personal,
MAGIC HOUR / 137
more close-up than a couple of long-distance bullets from a .22.” But Sy might have had other enemies, I thought: a pissedoff poet from his old magazine; an old show-biz connection with a grudge; some South Fork local he’d insulted—a gas station attendant, an electrician, a swimming pool contractor—some guy with a snootful of sauce and a pocketful of ammo. And what about Lindsay? Calculating, egotistical, arrogant, maybe ruthless, maybe about to be bounced in her dual role as star and concubine. Could she fire a rifle? And, damn it: Bonnie. How much research had she done for Cowgirl? “What about the ex-wife?” I asked Easton. “There’s some talk that Sy was developing her screenplay.” Easton shook his head. “No. Sy gave me her script fairly soon after I started working for him, before we were in production. Asked me to find some nice things to say about it. My guess is that when he told her no, he wanted to be able to say: ‘Oh, but the dialogue was so fresh, so honest.’” “How was the dialogue?” “I don’t know. Not horrible. But Sy said she was born forty-some-odd years too late, that she wrote 1942 women’s B movies.” “Did she ever call him?” Robby asked. “Yes. A couple of times a week, as a matter of fact. And she dropped in on him on the set, which did not amuse him. I know; I was in the trailer with him. You know how cool Sy always was? Well, I thought he was going to have a fit.” Easton stopped. He turned around in his chair to face me. “What are you thinking?” I asked my brother. “Woman Scorned?” “I don’t know,” Easton said thoughtfully. “I’m not
138 / SUSAN ISAACS
a cop. I don’t know how to weigh these things. But, Steve, I have to tell you: I didn’t like the look on Sy’s face when he saw her. I had a feeling something wrong was going on.”
CHAPTER SEVEN
If I wanted to be on time, I had two minutes to make the ten-minute drive to Lynne’s. So what did I do? I drove right to Bonnie Spencer’s, parked around the corner and then stood diagonally across the road